Advances in
BOTANICAL RESEARCH incorporating Advances in Plant Pathology
VOLUME 24
Advances in
BOTANICAL RESEARCH ...
40 downloads
1950 Views
28MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Advances in
BOTANICAL RESEARCH incorporating Advances in Plant Pathology
VOLUME 24
Advances in
BOTANICAL RESEARCH incorporating Advances in Plant Pathology Editor-in-Chief J. A. CALLOW
School of Biological Sciences, University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK
Editorial Board J. H. ANDREWS
H. G. DICKINSON M. KREIS R. M. LEECH R. A. LEIGH E. LORD D. J. READ I. C. TOMMERUP
University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, USA University of Oxford, Oxford, UK Universitb de Park-Sud, Orsay, France University of York, York, UK Rothamsted Experimental Station, Harpenden, U K University of California, Riverside, USA University of Shefield, Shefield, UK CSIRO, Perth, Australia
Advances in
BOTANICAL RESEARCH incorporating Advances in Plant Pathology edited by
J. H. Andrews
I. C. Tommerup
and
Department of Plant Pathology, The University of Wisconsin-Madison Madison, USA
CSIRO Forestry and Forest Products, CSIRO Centre for Mediterranean Agricultural Research, Perth, PO Wembley 6014, Australia
Series editor
J. A. CALLOW School of Biological Sciences, University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK
VOLUME 24
1997
ACADEMIC PRESS San Diego London Boston New York Sydney Tokyo Toronto
This book is printed on acid-free paper Copyright
0 1997 by ACADEMIC PRESS
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. Academic Press, Inc. 525 B Street, Suite 1900, San Diego, California 92101-4495, USA http://www. apnet .com Academic Press Limited 24-28 Oval Road, London NW1 7DX, UK http://www.hbuk.co.uk/ap/ A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library ISBN 0-12-005924-X Typeset by Keyset Composition, Colchester, Essex Printed in Great Britain by Hartnolls Limited, Bodmin, Cornwall 97 98 99 00 01 02 EB 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
CONTENTS
CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME 24 ..................................... CONTENTS OF VOLUMES 13-23
xv
....................... ,............ .... xvii
SERIES PREFACE ................................. .......................... ....... xxiii PREFACE .................................................................................
xxv
Contributions of Population Genetics to Plant Disease Epidemiology and Management M. G. MILGROOM and W. E. FRY I.
Introduction _........._................................_...................,...... ..... ..
1
11.
Population Genetics and Plant Pathology ..... ................... .............. A. What is (and what isn’t) Population Genetics? ........................ B. Brief history of Population Genetics in Plant Pathology ............
3 3 4
111. What can Population Genetics Contribute to Epidemiology and Plant Disease Management? ....... .................................. . . . ......... .......... A. The Concept of a Population ............................................... B. Genetic Variation in Populations .....................,............... ...,. C. The Use of Neutral Genetic Markers to Estimate Ecologically Important Variation ........................... ...................,........,.. .. D. The Interface between Population Genetics and Epidemiology ... E. Population Characteristics vary among Populations ....... ..,. ... . ...
10 13 18
IV. Examples of the Integration of Population Genetics and Epidemiology A. Fungicide Resistance in Pyrenophora teres ........................... ... B. Epidemiology and Population Genetics of Phytophthora infestans
19 21
... ....
24
V.
Future Contributions of Population Genetics to Plant Pathology
5 5 8
19
Acknowledgements ....................................................................
24
...............................................................................
25
References
vi
CONTENTS
A Molecular View Through the Looking Glass: the Pyrenopeziza brassicae-Brassica Interaction A . M . ASHBY I . Introduction I1. The A. B. C. D.
...........................................................................
P . brassicae-Brassica Interaction ......................................... The Fungus ..................................................................... Pathogenesis .................................................................... Sexual Morphogenesis ....................................................... Disease Epidemiology .......................................................
32 32 32 33 33 34
111. Molecular Techniques in the Analysis of the P. brassicae-Brassica Interaction .............................................................................
38 .
IV. Molecular Analysis of Pathogenesis ........................................... A . Surface Growth and Penetration: the Role of Cutinase ........... B . Subcuticular Growth: the Role of Protease ........................... C . Using Reporter Genes to Measure Fungal Biomass In Planta . . D . Proposed Role of Extracellular Protease in Pathogenicity ........ E . Implications for Disease Control .........................................
40 41 42 45 47 47
V. Analysis of the Hemibiotrophic Phase: the Role of Cytokinins ....... A . Biochemical Analysis of Cytokinin Production by P. brassicae . B . Molecular Analysis of P. brassicae Cytokinins ....................... C . The Role of Cytokinins in Pathogenicity .............................. D . Implications for Disease Control .........................................
47 49 49 51 51
VI . Analysis of Sexual Morphogenesis ............................................. A . Biochemical Analysis: Identification of a Post-Mating Factor ... B . Molecular Analysis ........................................................... C . Sexual Morphogenesis in P . brassicae: a Speculative Summary . D. Implications .....................................................................
51 52 53 58 60
VII . A Molecular View through the Looking Glass: the P. brassicaeBrassica Interaction ....................................................................
60
...............................................................
65
.................................................................
65
............................................................................
65
VIII . Concluding Remarks Acknowledgements References
vii
CONTENTS
The Balance and Interplay Between Asexual and Sexual Reproduction in Fungi M . CHAMBERLAIN and D . S. INGRAM
.............................................................................
I . Introduction
71
..............
72
I11. Comparisons of Genetic Variation. Physiological Costs and Fitness between Asexual and Sexual Systems ........................................... A . Does the Sexual System Generate more Variants? ................... B . Is the Sexual System Physiologically more Costly? ................... C . Are Sexual Progeny more “Fit”? .............................................
73 73 74 74
I1. Initiation of Asexual Sporulation and Sexual Reproduction
IV. Maintaining and Changing the Balance between Reproductive Processes .................................................................................... A . Species-determined Equilibria ............................................... B . Genotype-determined Equilibria ........................................... C. Seasonally Maintained Equilibria .......................................... D . Physical and Nutritional Factors ........................................... E . Density and Competition ..................................................... F. The Effect of Mycelial Extracts and Specific Morphogens .........
80
...............................................................................
81
....................................................................
82
Acknowledgements References
76 77 77 77 78
......................
V. Trade-off between Asexual and Sexual Reproduction VI . Conclusion
74 75
...............................................................................
82
The Role of Leucine-Rich Repeat Proteins in Plant Defences D . A . JONES and J . D . G . JONES I . Introduction
...........................................................................
I1. Resistance Genes Encoding Proteins with Extracytoplasmic LRRs .. A . Resistance Genes Encoding Membrane-anchored Proteins with Extracytoplasmic LRRs and no Kinase Domain .................... B . A Resistance Gene Encoding a Membrane-anchored Protein with Extracytoplasmic LRRs and a Cytoplasmic Kinase Domain ..... C . Avirulence Determinants that Interact with Resistance Proteins Containing Extracytoplasmic LRRs ..................................... D . Activation of Plant Defences by Resistance Genes Encoding Proteins Containing Extracytoplasmic LRRs ............................
90 91 91 95 97 99
I11. Resistance Genes Encoding Proteins with Cytoplasmic LRRs ......... 101 A . Resistance Genes Encoding Proteins with Cytoplasmic LRRs and 102 Potential Leucine Zippers ..................................................
...
CONTENTS
Vlll
B . Resistance Genes Encoding Proteins with Cytoplasmic LRRs and Homology to the Cytoplasmic Domains of Toll and the Interleukin-1 Receptor ........................................................... C . A Gene Encoding a Protein with Cytoplasmic LRRs that is Required for a Resistance Gene to Function ........................ D . Avirulence Determinants that Interact with Resistance Proteins Containing Cytoplasmic LRRs ............................................ E . Activation of Plant Defences by Resistance Proteins Containing Cytoplasmic LRRs ........................................................... IV . Defence-related Genes Encoding Proteins with Extracytoplasmic LRRs ................................................................................... A . Polygalacturonase-inhibiting Proteins ................................... B . LRR Extensins ................................................................ C . A Viroid-induced LRR Protein ..........................................
108 109 113 114 119 120 127 131
V. Genes Encoding Proteins of Unknown Function with Extra131 cytoplasmic LRRs ................................................................... 131 A . The AWJL Proteins of Wheat ............................................ 135 B . Receptor-like Protein Kinases ............................................ VI . A Gene Encoding a Protein of Unknown Function with Cytoplasmic 137 LRRs ...................................................................................
VII . The A. B. C.
Evolution of Plant LRR Proteins ........................................ The Evolution of LRR Proteins in the Eukaryotes ................ Evolutionary Clues Provided by Intron Arrangements ............ Evolution of Different Specificities in LRR Proteins ..............
138 138 141 143
VIII . The Structure and Molecular Specificity of Plant LRR Proteins ...... A . Inferences about the Structure of Plant LRRs by Comparison with the Known Structure of Porcine Ribonuclease Inhibitor ... B . Inferences about the Structure and Interactions of Extracellular Plant LRR Proteins Based on their Potential Patterns of Glycosylation .................................................................. C . Inferences about the Interactions between Plant LRR Proteins and their Ligands Based on Comparisons with the Interactions between Ribonuclease Inhibitors and Ribonucleases .............. XI . Concluding Remarks ...............................................................
144 144 147 150 153
.................................................................
156
References ............................................................................
156
Acknowledgements
ix
CONTENTS
Fungal Life-styles and Ecosystem Dynamics: Biological Aspects of Plant Pathogens. Plant Endophytes and Saprophytes R . J . RODRIGUEZ and R . S . REDMAN I . Introduction
...........................................................................
I1. Plant Pathogens
........
.......................................................
171
...................................................................
174
...........................................................................
176
...............................................................
179
..........................................
182
I11. Plant Endophytes IV. Saprophytes
V . Life-style Crossroads
VI . Life-styles and Ecosystem Dynamics
VII . Fungal Biology in Agricultural Versus Natural Ecosystems VIII . The Evolution of Agriculture IX . Conclusion
............
...................................................
............................................................................
.........................
183 184 186
....................................
187
............................................................................
187
Acknowledgements References
169
Cellular Interactions oetween Plants and Biotrophic Fungal Parasites M . C . HEATH and D . SKALAMERA I . Introduction
.............................................................................
I1 . Why do Fungal and Oomycetous Parasites form Intracellular Structures? A . General Characteristics of Plant-Haustorium Interfaces ............. B . Maintenance of a Differentiated Extrahaustorial Membrane ...... C . Solute Transport Across the Plant-Parasite Interface ................ D . Other Roles of the Haustorium ............................................ E . Concluding Remarks ........................................................... 111. Of what Significance are the Plant Cellular Rearrangements that Accompany Parasite Invasion? .................................................... A . Defensive Responses to Parasite Invasion ............................... B . Parasite-Induced Changes in the Plant’s Endomembrane System C . Associations of Intracellular Fungal Structures with the Plant Nucleus ............................................................................ D . Changes in the Plant Cytoskeleton ........................................ E . Concluding Remarks ........................ ..............................
196 198 198 199 202 204 205 206 206 207 209 210 210
CONTENTS
X
IV. Why do Biotroph-Invaded Cells Die in Resistant Plants? ................ A . Is Cell Death the “Default State” following Cell Penetration? ... B . Do Invaded Cells Die in Host and Non-host Plants for the Same Reason? ........................................................................... C. Arguments for Cell Death in Resistant Plants being a Form of Programmed Cell Death ...................................................... D . Arguments against Cell Death in Resistant Plants being a Form of Programmed Cell Death ...................................................... E . Cellular Mechanisms of Cell Death ....................................... F. Concluding Remarks ........................................................... V . Conclusions References
210 211 212 214 215 216 218
..............................................................................
219
...............................................................................
219
Symbiology of Mouse-Ear Cress (Arubidopsis thalhna) and Oomycetes E . B . HOLUB and J . L . BEYNON I . Introduction
............................................................................
I1. Defining a New Research Arena of Plant Biology ......................... A . The Dawn of Arabidopsis ................................................... B . Relevant Trends in Modern Biology ..................................... C . A Rebirth in Plant Pathology .............................................. D . A Copernican Perspective ...................................................
228 229 229 230 231 232
I11. Symbionts from the Wild .......................................................... A . The Phytobiont: Arabidopsis thaliana ................................... B . The Biotrophs: Peronospora parasitica and Albugo candida ...... C . Three Rs of Symbiosis ....................................................... D . The Phenotypes of Interactions: Consequences of Recognition ..
233 233 235 238 240
IV. Molecular Genetics of Natural Variation ...................................... A . Building Models: Predicting the Host Genotype ..................... B . Nonallelism: Juggling with Apples and Oranges ..................... C . Major Complexes of Recognition Genes: How Big is a Cluster? D . A Natural Anomaly of Susceptible Origin .............................
243 246 248 254 258
V . Mutations: Revealing Complexity from Black and White ................ 259 260 A . A Myriad of Columbia Mutants ........................................... 261 B . Surprising Extremes in Wassilewskija ................................... VI . Avenues of Future Research
......................................................
262
................................................................ ...................................................................
268 269
..............................................................................
269
VII . Concluding Remarks Acknowledgements References
xi
CONTENTS
Use of Monoclonal Antibodies to Detect. Quantify and Visualize Fungi in Soils F. M . DEWEY. C . R . THORNTON and C . A . GILLIGAN I . Introduction
...........................................................................
I1. Production of Species-specific and Genus-specific Monoclonal Antibodies ................................................................................... A . Selection and Preparation of Immunogens ............................ B . Selection of Hybridoma Cell Lines Secreting Specific Antibodies C . Choice of Antibody Subclass .............................................
276 278 278 279 279
I11. Assay Formats ....................................................................... 280 A . Enzyme-linked lmmunosorbent Assays (ELISAs) .................. 281 B . Membrane Assays ............................................................ 282 IV. Sample Preparation ................................................................. 283 A . Extraction of Antigens from Soil ........................................ 283 B. Elimination and Reduction of Interference from Soil Components .......................................................................... 286 V. Detection
..............................................................................
VI . Quantification ........................................................................ A . Estimation of Biomass ...................................................... B . Immunological Estimation of Colony-forming Units ............... C. Setting of Thresholds for Detection and Quanta1 Assay Systems D . False-negative Results ....................................................... VII . Visualization
..........................................................................
VIII . Concluding Remarks
289 289 293 296 298 300 302
.................................................................
304
............................................................................
304
Acknowledgements References
...............................................................
287
Function of Fungal Haustoria in Epiphytic and Endophytic Infections P. T. N . SPENCER-PHILLIPS I . Introduction
.............................................................................
I1. Strategies for Nutrition and Biotrophy: an Overview
309
.......................
311
I11. The Challenge of Biotrophic Nutrient Accumulation ....................... A . The Apoplastic Environment ................................................
313 314
xii
CONTENTS
IV. The Role of Haustoria and Intercellular Hyphae in Transfer Intercept A . Vascular Association: General Considerations ......................... B . Minor Vein Type. Mechanisms of Phloem Loading and Interception Strategy ................................................................. C . Evolutionary Aspects ..........................................................
316 317 318 324
..............................................
325
................................................
327
....................................................................
328
References ...............................................................................
328
V . Alternative Functions of Haustoria VI . Summary and Research Priorities Acknowledgements
Towards an Understanding of the Population Genetics of Plant-Colonizing Bacteria B . HAUBOLD and P. B . RAINEY I . Introduction
.............................................................................
335
I1. Quantifying Genetic Variation: the Indirect Approach ....................
337
I11. The Neutral Theory: Historical Background to the Study of Bacterial 338 Population Genetics .................................................................. IV. Population Structure .................................................................. A . Genetic Structure ........................................... B . Phylogenetic Structure ........................................................ C. Spatial and Temporal Structure ............................................
340 340 342 343
......................................................
345
VI . Conclusions ..............................................................................
347
V . The Metapopulation Concept
Acknowledgements
....................................................................
References ...............................................................................
347 347
Asexual Sporulation in the Oomycetes A . R . HARDHAM and G . J . HYDE I . Introduction
.............................................................................
I1. Sporangiogenesis ....................................................................... A . Induction .......................................................................... B . Morphological Development ..................................................
353 357 357 359
...
CONTENTS
Xlll
C. Synthesis of Zoospore-specific Components during Sporangio361 genesis ............................................................................. 111. Zoosporogenesis
....................................................................... 377 A . Induction .......................................................................... 377 B . The Process of Cleavage ...................................................... 378 C. Synthesis of Zoospore-specific Components during Zoosporo384 genesis ............................................................................. D . Polarization of Zoosporic Organelles ..................................... 386 E . Zoospore Discharge ............................................................ 386 F. Conclusions ....................................................................... 389
....................................................................
390
...............................................................................
390
Acknowledgements References
Horizontal Gene Transfer in the Rhizosphere: a Curiosity or a Driving Force in Evolution? J . WOSTEMEYER. A . WOSTEMEYER and K . VOIGT I . Horizontal or Lateral Gene Transfer: where does it Occur?
.............
399
I1. Bacteria as Recipients of Foreign DNA ........................................
401
I11. Fungi as Recipients of Foreign DNA ...........................................
410
IV . Plants as Recipients of Foreign DNA ........................................... A . Agrobacteriurn turnefaciens ................................................... B . Rhizobiurn Interactions with Legumes ...................................
416 416 418
.......................................................
420
V. VI .
Interkingdom Gene Transfer
.........................
422
...............................................................................
424
Refevance of Lateral Gene Transfer for Evolution References
The Origins of Phytophthora Species Attacking Legumes in Australia J . A . G . IRWIN. A . R . CRAWFORD and A . DRENTH I . Introduction
...........................................................................
432
I1. Legumes in Australia ..............................................................
432
111. Phytophthora Species Attacking Legumes in Australia
A . Taxonomy
.................. 433 ....................................................................... 433
xiv
CONTENTS
B . Asexual Life Cycle ........................................................... C . Sexual Life Cycle ............................................................. IV. Genetic Variation and Possible Origins of Phytophthora Species Attacking Legumes ................................................................. A . Phytophthora sojae .......................................................... B . Phytophthora medicaginis ................................................... C . Phytophthora vignae .......................................................... D . Phytophthora macrochlamydospora ......................................
436 437 437 438 439 439 440
V . Evolutionary Relationships between Phytophthora Species Attacking 440 Legumes ............................................................................... VI . Evolution of Species and Host Specificity in Phytophthora Species attacking Legumes .................................................................. A . Biological Species and Speciation ........................................ B . Evolution of Host Specificity in Phytophthora .......................
442 442 443
VII . Evolution of Cultivar Specificity in Phytophthora sojae ....................
448
..............................................................
450
.................................................................
451
VIII . Concluding Remarks Acknowledgements
............................................................................
451
INDEX ...............................................................................
457
References
CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME 24
A. M. ASHBY, Department of Plant Sciences, University of Cambridge, Downing Street, Cambridge CB2 3EA, UK J . L. BEYNON, Department of Biological Sciences, Wye College, University of London, Wye, Ashford, Kent TN25 5AH, UK M. CHAMBERLAIN, (previously known as M. Jurand) Royal Botanic Garden, 20A Inverleith Row, Edinburgh EH3 5LR, UK A. R. CRAWFORD, CRC for Tropical Plant Pathology, The University of Queensland, Brisbane 4072, Australia F. M. DEWEY, Department of Plant Sciences, University of Oxford, South Parks Road, Oxford OX1 3RB, U K A. DRENTH, CRC for Tropical Plant Pathology, The University of Queensland, Brisbane 4072, Australia W. E. FRY, Department of Plant Pathology, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY 14853, USA C. A. GILLIGAN, Department of Plant Sciences, University of Cambridge, Downing Street, Cambridge CB2 3EA, UK A. R. HARDHAM, Plant Cell Biology Group, The Research School of Biological Sciences, The Australian National University, P. 0. Box 475, Canberra 2601, Australia B. HAUBOLD, Department of Plant Sciences, University of Oxford, South Parks Road, Oxford OX1 3RB, UK M. C . HEATH, Department of Botany, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario M5S lA1, Canada E. B. HOLUB, Plant Pathology and Weed Science Department, Horticulture Research International- Wellesbou me, Warwickshire CV35 9EF, UK G. J . HYDE, School of Biological Science, University of New South Wales, Kensington, NSW 2033, Australia D. S . INGRAM, Royal Botanic Garden, 20A Inverleith Row, Edinburgh EH3 5LR, UK J . A. G. IRWIN, CRC for Tropical Plant Pathology, The University of Queensland, Brisbane 4072, Australia D. A. JONES, The Sainsbury Laboratory, John Innes Centre, Colney Lane, Norwich NR4 7UH, UK J . D. G. JONES, The Sainsbury Laboratory, John Innes Centre, Colney Lane, Norwich NR4 7UH, U K M. G. MILGROOM, Department of Plant Pathology, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY 14853, USA
xvi
CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME 24
P. B. RAINEY, Department of Plant Sciences, University of Oxford, South Parks Road, Oxford OX1 3RB, U K R. S . REDMAN, National Biological Service, NW Biological Science Center, Seattle, W A 98115, U S A R. J. RODRIGUEZ, National Biological Service, NW Biological Science Center, Seattle, W A 98115, U S A D. SKALAMERA, Department of Botany, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario M5S lA1, Canada P. T. N. SPENCER-PHILLIPS, Department of Biological Sciences, University of the West of England, Bristol BS16 l Q Y , UK C. R. THORNTON, Department of Plant Sciences, University of Cambridge, Downing Street, Cambridge CB2 3EA, U K K . VOIGT, Friedrich-Schiller-Universitat Jena, Lehrstuhl fur Allgemeine Mikrobiologie and Mikrobengenetik, Neugasse 24, 0-07743 Jena, Germany A. WOSTEMEYER, Friedrich-Schiller-Universitat Jena, Lehrstuhl fur Allgemeine Mikrobiologie und Mikrobengenetik, Neugasse 24, 0-07743 Jena, Germany J. WOSTEMEYER, Friedrich-Schiller-Universitat Jena, Lehrstuhl fur Allgemeine Mikrobiologie und Mikrobengenetik, Neugasse 24, 0-07743 Jena, Germany
xvii
CONTENTS TO VOLUMES 1 S 2 3
Contents of Volume 13 Interactions Between Photosystems N. R. BAKER and A. N. WEBBER
Cyanobacterial Water-Blooms C. S. REYNOLDS
Determinants of Yield of Secondary Products in Plant Tissue Cultures H. A. COLLIN
Contents to Volume 14 Protein Targeting R. J. ELLIS and C. ROBINSON
Control of Isoprenoid Biosynthesis in Higher Plants J. C. GRAY
Dunaliella: A Green Alga Adapter to Salt M. GINZBURG
Contents to Volume 15 Perception of Gravity by Plants T. BJORKMAN
Crassulacean Acid Metabolism: a Re-Appraisal of Physiological Plasticity in Form and Function H. GRIFFITHS
xviii
CONTENTS TO VOLUMES 13-23
Potassium Transport in Roots L. V. KOCHIAN and W. J. LUCAS
Sporogenesis in Conifers R. I. PENNELL
Contents of Volume 16 Lipid Metabolism in Algae J. L. HARWOOD and A . L. JONES
The Alteration of Generations P. R. BELL
The Formation and Interpretation of Plant Fossil Assemblages R. A . SPICER
Primary Productivity in the Shelf of North-West Europe P. M. HOLLIGAN
Contents of Volume 17 Plant Evolution and Ecology During the Early Cainozoic Diversification M. E. COLLINSON
Origin and Evolution of Angiosperm Flowers E. M. FRIIS and P. K . ENDRESS
Bacterial Leaf Nodule Symbiosis I. M. MILLER
Fracture Properties of Plants J. F. V. VINCENT
CONTENTS TO VOLUMES 13-23
xix
Contents of Volume 18 Photosynthesis and Stomatal Responses to Polluted Air, and the Use of Physiological and Bacterial Responses for Early Detection and Diagnostic Tools H. SAXE
Transport and Metabolism of Carbon and Nitrogen in Legume Nodu1es J. G. STREETER
Plants and Wind P. VAN GARDINGEN and J. GRACE
Fibre Optic Microprobes and Measurement of the Light Microenvironment within Plant Tissues T. C. VOGELMANN, G. MARTIN, G. CHEN and D. BUTI'RY
Contents of Volume 19 Oligosaccharins S. ALDINGTON and S. C. FRY
Are Plant Hormones Involved in Root to Shoot Communication? M. B. JACKSON
Second-Hand Chloroplasts: Evolution of Cryptomonad Algae G. I. McFADDEN
The Gametophytdporophyte Junction in Land Plants R. LIGRONE, J. G. DUCKETT and K. S. RENZAGLIA
Contents of Volume 20 Global Photosynthesis and Stomatal Conductance: Modelling the Controls by Soil and Climate F. I. WOODWARD and T. M. SMITH
In vivo NMR Studies of Higher Plants and Algae R. G. RATCLIFFE
xx
CONTENTS TO VOLUMES 13-23
Vegetative and Gametic Development in the Green Alga Chlamydomonas H. VAN DEN ENDE
Salicylic Acid and its Derivatives in Plants: Medianes, Metabolites and Messenger Molecules W. S. PIERPOINT
Contents of Volume 21 Defense Responses of Plants to Pathogens E. KOMBRINK and I. E. SOMSSICH
On the Nature and Genetic Basis for Resistance and Tolerance to Fungal Wilt Diseases of Plants C. H. BECKMAN and E. M. ROBERTS
Implication of Population Pressure on Agriculture and Ecosystems A. H. EHRLICH
Plant Virus infection: Another Point of View G. A. DE ZOETEN
The Pathogens and Pests of Chestnuts S. L. ANAGNOSTAKIS
Fungal Avirulence Genes and Plant Resistance Genes: Unraveling the Molecular Basis of Gene-for-Gene Interactions P. J. G. M. DE WIT
Phytoplasmas: Can Phylogeny Provide the Means to Understand Pathogenicity B. C. KIRKPATRICK and C. D. SMART
Use of Categorical Information and Correspondence Analysis in Plant Disease Epidemiology S. SAVARY, L. V. MADDEN, J. C. ZADOKS and H. W. KLEIN-GEBBINCK
CONTENTS TO VOLUMES 13-23
xxi
Contents of Volume 22 Mutualism and Parasitism: Diversity in Function and Structure in the “Arbuscular” (VA) Mycorrhizal Symbiosis F. A. SMITH and S. E. SMITH
Calcium Ions as Intracellular Second Messengers in Higher Plants A. A. R. WEBB, M. R. McAINSH, J. E. TAYLOR and I. M. HETHERINGTON
The Effects of Ultraviolet-B Radiation on Plants: A Molecular Perspective B. R. JORDAN
Rapid, Long-Distance Signal Transmission in Higher Plants M. MALONE
Keeping in Touch: Responses of the Whole Plant to Deficits in Water and Nitrogen Supply A. J. S. McDONALD and W. J. DAVIES
Contents of Volume 23 The Value of Indexing for Disease Control Strategies D. E. STEAD, D. L. EBBELS and A. W. PEMBERTON
Detecting Latent Bacterial Infections S. H. DE BOER, D. A. CUPPELS and R. GITAITIS
Sensitivity of Indexing Procedures for Viruses and Viroides H. HUTTINGA
Detecting Propagules of Plant Pathogenic Fungi S. A. MILLER
Assessing Plant-Nematode Infestations and Infections K. K. BARKER and E. L. DAVIS
xxii
CONTENTS TO VOLUMES 13-23
Potential of Pathogen Detection Technology for Management of Diseases in Glasshouse Ornamental Crops I. G. DINESEN and A. VAN ZAAYEN
Indexing Seeds for Pathogens J. LANGERAK, R. W. VAN DEN BULK and A. A. J. M. FRANKEN
A Role for Pathogen Indexing Procedures in Potato Certification S. H. DE BOER, S. A. SLACK, G. VAN DEN BOVENKAMP and I. MASTENBROEK
A Decision Modelling Approach for Quantifying Risk in Pathogen Indexing C. A. LBVESQUE and D. M. EAVES
Quality Control and Cost Effectiveness of Indexing Procedures C. SUTULAR
SERIES PREFACE
Advances in Botanical Research is one of Academic Press’ longest standing serials, and has established an excellent reputation over more than 30 years. Advances in Plant Pathology, although somewhat younger, has also succeeded in attracting a highly respected name for itself over a period of more than a decade. The decision has now been made to bring the two serials together under the title of Advances in Botanical Research incorporating Advances in Plant Pathology. The resulting synergy of the merging of these two serials is intended to greatly benefit the plant science community by providing a more comprehensive resource under one “roof”. John Andrews and Inez Tommerup, the previous editors of Advances in Plant Pathology, are now on the editorial board of the new series. Our joint aim is to continue to include the very best articles, thereby maintaining the status of a high impact factor review series.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
PREFACE
All plants, whether in the wild or cultivation, co-exist and interact with numerous phylogenetically and ecologically diverse microbes. Some are potential plant pathogens. Plant pathology is a complex field of study; the future is an exciting one with rapidly evolving scientific approaches to research, many of them at the cusp of development. Articles in this volume analyse developments in plant defence mechanisms, pathogen reproduction, growth, survival and population genetics and dynamics. The recognition of disease resistance in plants is ancient. Plant resistance genes were recognized a century ago, pathogen virulence and avirulence genes 50 years ago, the first pathogen avirulence genes were isolated in the last decade and the first plant resistance genes in the past 4 years. Jones and Jones focus on key resistance genes that encode proteins containing leucine-rich repeats or that require a protein with leucine-rich repeats to function. They discuss evolution, molecular specificity and the role in plant defence mechanisms of leucine-rich proteins, a protein class involved in specific protein-protein interactions. Precision and efficiency in analysing disease phenotype variation and bridging the conceptual gap between genetical and functional aspects of symbiosis is underpinned by basic principles and modern research tools. Holub and Beynon examine the concepts and approaches involved in associating host resistance specificity with a single locus, determining whether the phenotype is actually due to single o r multiple genes and unravelling the interacting network of genes involved in disease expression. Ashby shows how, by employing a multidisciplinary approach using biochemical, molecular biological and classical plant pathology to dissect a host-pathogen interaction into its component parts, new leads towards developing novel control strategies are emerging. Heath and Skalamera examine the hypotheses and supporting evidence about cellular interactions between plants and biotrophic fungal parasites. They question why fungal biotrophic parasites form intracellular structures, the significance of cellular rearrangements that accompany invasion and why invaded resistant cells die. Their synthesis throws new interpretative light on the complex associations of haustoria and cells in compatible and incompatible interactions. Spencer-Phillips has taken on the challenge of exploring the roles of intercellular hyphae and haustoria in intercepting and transferring organic and inorganic nutrients from host tissue in epiphytic and endophytic infections. To persist, pathogens must produce propagules. Chamberlain and Ingram consider asexual and sexual reproduction of fungal pathogens for their ability
xxvi
PREFACE
to generate genetic variation, the physiological and fitness costs of the processes, how the balance is maintained and what are the trade-offs between the two reproductive processes. Hardham and Hyde synthesize the current state of knowledge of sporangiogenesis and zoospore production in oomycetes. Adoption of function-oriented approaches and new techniques reveal similarities in the process of sporulation across the taxon where previously diversity was thought to be the case. The importance of capitalizing on recent technical advances to develop accurate and reliable methods for detecting pathogens in soil, a microbially , chemically and physically complex environment, is the theme of Dewey, Thornton and Gilligan’s chapter. They emphasize the need to couple this with new approaches to sampling techniques and methods of statistical analysis to quantify soil pathogens. Evolution of plants is influenced by their pathogens, and vice versa. Evolution of pathogens may also be influenced by other microbes. That plant rhizosphere and soil communities provide opportunities for horizontal gene transfer amongst microbes and plants is the thesis of Wostemeyer, Wostemeyer and Voigt. They highlight the significance of foreign DNA transfers for recipient organism evolution. Legumes, like most agricultural crop species, have been relocated amongst continents, in some cases with their pathogens. Irwin, Crawford and Drenth discuss approaches to unravelling the possible evolutionary origins and genetic variation of Phytophthoru species associated with the pasture legumes in Australia. That information is used in searches for sources of host resistance. Can a pathogen life-style be defined? Rodrigues and Redman point out deficiencies in current understanding of fungal biology related to cross-overs in behaviour by organisms amongst the categories plant pathogen, endophyte or saprophyte. Prominent pathogens move between categories and they may influence natural and agricultural ecosystem community structure and dynamics. Haubold and Rainey challenge microbial pathologists and phytopathologists to consider questions relating to the extent and significance of genetic variation within plant-colonizing bacterial pathogens. If effective biological control strategies are to be developed, then temporal and spatial variation must be understood. They also stress that understanding the mechanisms, rates and extent of recombination in natural populations are essential if genetically engineered bacteria are to be safely exploited in agriculture. Milgroom and Fry illustrate how the practical need to understand pathogen variation and evolution is the most significant application of population genetics to epidemiology and disease management. Sufficient knowledge exists for this critical step in integration to be taken in a few diseases, and they highlight the experimental structures needed for others to follow that route. John H Andrews Inez C Tommerup
Contributions of Population Genetics to Plant Disease Epidemiology and Management
M. G. MILGROOM and W. E. FRY
Department of Plant Pathology, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY 14853, USA
.............................................................................
1
11. Population Genetics and Plant Pathology .....,,..............,................ A. What is (and what isn’t) Population Genetics? ........................ B. Brief history of Population Genetics in Plant Pathology .............
3 3
I. Introduction
111. What can Population Genetics Contribute to Epidemiology and Plant Disease Management? ........................................................ A. The Concept of a Population ................................................ B. Genetic Variation in Populations ........................................... C. The Use of Neutral Genetic Markers to Estimate Ecologically Important Variation ................................................,............ D. The Interface between Population Genetics and Epidemiology . . . E. Population Characteristics vary among Populations ............... .... IV. Examples of the Integration of Population Genetics and Epidemiology ......................................................... ........ .... A. Fungicide Resistance in Pyrenophora teres .............................. B. Epidemiology and Population Genetics of Phytophthora infestans ............................................................................ V. Future Contributions of Population Genetics to Plant Pathology . ... ... Acknowledgements .................................................................... References ...............................................................................
4 5 5
8 10 13 18 19 19 21
24 24 25
I. INTRODUCTION Population genetics and genetic variation in plant pathogens are subjects that have generated much interest since the late 1980s. Almost every recent issue Advances in Botanical Research Vol. 24 incorporating Advances in Plant Pathology
ISBN 0-12-005924-X
Copyright 0 1997 Academic Press Limited All rights of reproduction in any form reserved
2
M. G . MILGROOM and W. E. FRY
of major plant pathological and mycological journals has at least one article on genetic variation of a plant pathogen species. The visibility of this area in plant pathology is also evident from the number of recent reviews of concepts and methods appropriate to population genetic studies with plant pathogens (Burdon, 1992; Leung et al., 1993; McDermott and McDonald, 1993; McDonald and McDermott, 1993; Anderson and Kohn, 1995; Brasier, 1995; Milgroom, 1995a, 1996), as well as recent reviews of population genetic studies of specific organisms (Fry et al., 1992; Wolfe and McDermott, 1994; Kohn, 1995; Leslie, 1995; McDonald et al., 1995; Milgroom, 1995b). Although there is an exciting potential for population genetics to contribute to plant pathology, it is difficult to predict whether it will become an indispensable part of plant pathology, or fade away as fashions change. The study of population genetics of plant pathogens is still in its infancy, with some of the requisite growing pains associated with development into a mature discipline within plant pathology. Its rapid emergence has been made possible, in part, by technological advances that have increased the ease with which one can find polymorphic genetic markers; further fueling this rise is the apparent fashion of using molecular biological techniques. As a result, researchers are undertaking numerous studies in which genetic variation is described and quantified on various scales. The future of this field, from the perspective of population genetics, will be to progress beyond the description of genetic variation, towards an emphasis on evolutionary processes. Its future with respect to epidemiology is an open question, and the subject of this chapter. Whether population genetics becomes an integral discipline within plant pathology depends, in part, on whether it can be integrated with epidemiology and disease management. Evolutionary biology and population genetics have the potential to deliver much basic information about plant pathogens. Two books in the 1980s (Wolfe and Caten, 1987; Leonard and Fry, 1989) initiated the integration, but much has happened in this field since they were published. Useful integration of these fields will require mutual understanding and better communication between geneticists and epidemiologists. The value of applying population genetics in plant pathology is not always obvious, and is sometimes impeded by biological and conceptual obstacles. We will try to highlight some of the ways population genetic studies relate to epidemiology and disease management, and identify the various obstacles. We begin with an overview of population genetics and a brief account of its history in plant pathology. This is followed by some of the general principles that unite population genetics and epidemiology. Finally, we finish by describing research on two pathosystems in which links between population genetics and epidemiology are relatively strong.
GENETICS AND PLANT DISEASE EPIDEMIOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT
3
11. POPULATION GENETICS IN PLANT PATHOLOGY A . WHAT IS (AND WHAT ISN’T) POPULATION GENETICS?
Population genetics is a field concerned with determining the extent and pattern of genetic variation in populations with the goal of understanding the evolutionary processes affecting the origin and maintenance of genetic variation. The conceptual framework is based on evolutionary biology and on the processes affecting the genetic composition of populations: selection, mutation, gene flow, genetic drift and mating systems. With an understanding of the relative importance of different evolutionary processes, predictions can be made about changes in the genetic composition of populations. Sometimes predictions can be made for responses of pathogen populations to selection by various management practices. The term “population genetics” has sometimes been interpreted broadly among plant pathologists to include any study on genetic variation. This interpretation is perhaps one reason why population genetics is not fully understood in plant pathology as a discipline distinct from systematics and diagnostics. Although knowledge of genetic variation is key to population genetic studies, it is but the raw material from which inferences are made. In population genetics, evolutionary inferences are made based on the dynamics of gene and genotype frequencies within and between populations. Systematics is fundamentally different: phylogenetic inferences are made at the species level (or higher) from morphological and genetic differences among taxa. Although there is overlap of concepts and techniques between population genetics and systematics, the scale is different, in both time and space. Systematics focuses on differences between species or higher taxa, which have evolved over relatively long time scales, and often in different locations. Most emphasis in population genetics is on microevolutionary events within populations of single species, and on time scales that are generally shorter than those required for speciation. However, this distinction is not always clear, especially when taxonomic complexity is revealed by closer inspection of genetic variation within species complexes (e.g. Vilgalys and Cubeta, 1994; Leslie, 1995). Furthermore, the distinction between microevolution and macroevolution is somewhat arbitrary because microevolutionary events may lead eventually to speciation (Brasier, 1995). Population genetics is sometimes confused with those studies of genetic variation in which the goal is to find diagnostic genetic markers among species or among different phenotypes within species. The search for diagnostic markers and studies of population genetics share the need for genetic variation as the basic empirical observation, but the objectives are very different. Genetic differences exploited for diagnostic purposes are more akin to systematics than to population genetics. Neither the population concept nor that of evolution, however, is considered rigorously in the search for
4
M. G. MILGROOM and W. E. FRY
diagnostic tools. Similarly, the use of molecular genetic markers in population genetics must be distinguished from molecular biology, where questions are addressed at a subcellular as opposed to a population level of organization. Clearly, a discipline is defined by the questions asked, not the tools used. B. BRIEF HISTORY OF POPULATION GENETICS IN PLANT PATHOLOGY
Plant pathologists began their studies of population genetics when they discovered variation in physiological races (now often referred to as “pathotypes”) within populations of plant pathogenic fungi. Pathotypes are defined solely by their abilities to cause disease on host plants with different resistance genes. From a management perspective, deployment of resistance genes in host plant populations has become a fundamental concept in plant pathology (Vanderplank, 1963). Successful deployment of resistance genes depends on knowledge of the genetic composition of pathogen populations, at least with respect to the relative frequencies of different pathotypes. Pathotype surveys have been conducted on numerous pathogens, and are still part of the strategies for managing diseases with host plant resistance (e.g. Kolmer, 1989). Population genetic concepts received greater attention in relation to variation in pathotypes when pathologists began asking questions such as “Why is there more pathotype variation in some populations than others?”, or “Will complex pathotypes (super-races) evolve in response to resistance gene deployment?” Questions like these grew out of the need to manage disease, but could be addressed adequately only within a population genetics framework; in other words, there was a natural integration of epidemiology and population genetics. These questions generated studies on fitness, host specialization, sexuality and recombination, population structure, etc., in relation to pathotype evolution (reviewed in Wolfe and Caten, 1987). As a consequence, an awareness was established of the link between evolutionary processes and disease management. In the late 1970s to mid-l980s, a different perspective emerged as attention was turned towards variation in genetic markers besides pathotypes. Some of the earlier work was done with enzyme polymorphisms, vegetative incompatibility and mating types (e.g. Leonard, 1978; Burdon et al., 1982; Puhalla, 1985; Stenlid, 1985; Tooley et. al., 1985; Leung and Williams, 1986). Plant pathologists were not only applying well-known laboratory techniques to plant pathogen populations, but also began asking questions about evolutionary processes beyond selection for pathotypes by host plant resistance. By the late 1980s and early 1990s studies of molecular variation in plant pathogens all but eclipsed those of pathogenic variation in plant pathology. These recent studies were made possible by technological innovations in molecular biology that made genetic markers (e.g. RFLPs and RAPDs) more accessible.
GENETICS AND PLANT DISEASE EPIDEMIOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT
5
The advances in technology also brought about a marked change in emphasis in population genetics of plant pathogens. The biology of pathogens at the population level and processes other than selection have been emphasized. For example, studies have been conducted on population structure to make inferences on gene flow, genetic drift and recombination (reviewed in Fry et al., 1992; Leung et al., 1993; McDermott and McDonald, 1993; McDonald and McDermott, 1993; Anderson and Kohn, 1995; Milgroom, 1995a, 1996). This field has been exciting, resulting in new knowledge about the biology of pathogens. However, with few exceptions, little effort has yet been made to apply this new knowledge to epidemiology and disease management.
111. WHAT CAN POPULATION GENETICS CONTRIBUTE
TO EPIDEMIOLOGY AND PLANT DISEASE MANAGEMENT? The answer to this question is not simple. At present, there are few generalities about the contributions that population genetics can make. The obstacles to applying population genetics to epidemiological questions are both historical and conceptual. For some plant pathologists, the concepts of population genetics and evolutionary biology are foreign ideas, and conversely, few population geneticists have an understanding of plant pathology. Population genetics derives from general biology, in which organisms are considered primarily in natural environments (or experimental cages in the laboratory). The separate developments of population genetics in biology and in plant pathology have inhibited effective communication among researchers and delayed the integration of these disciplines. There are several fundamental concepts from population genetics that can be applied profitably to epidemiology and disease management. In the following sections we identify some concepts that seem most likely to integrate these fields. We also discuss some of the obstacles that need to be recognized in order to apply population genetics appropriately to epidemiological problems. Each concept is illustrated with relevant plant pathological examples. A . THE CONCEPT OF A POPULATION
A population is not simply a haphazard collection of individuals, but has biological and practical significance that is important from a research perspective. A fundamental concept in any research is that the samples or experiments are so structured that the inferences made can be applied to more general phenomena beyond the objects being observed. The key question is to what populations will inferences be made? Although this is
6
M. G. MILGROOM and W. E. FRY
often done implicitly, a more careful examination of this question is crucial in studies of population genetics - and indeed, this may be one of the defining features of population biology. The challenge is to direct research efforts towards an appropriate target population. A precise definition of a population is somewhat elusive. A restrictive definition of a population that has sometimes been used by ecologists is: a collection of individuals that are actually or potentially interbreeding (Pianka, 1988). For most microorganisms, such as many plant pathogens, the dependence of this definition on “interbreeding” makes it irrelevant because of their largely asexual life histories. As an alternative, a population may be viewed as “a group of organisms of the same species occupying a particular space at a particular time” (Krebs, 1985, p. 157). Although the potential to interbreed is not required in this definition, and is therefore more appropriate for most plant pathogen species, it is somewhat unsatisfying from a genetic perspective. The missing concept in genetic and evolutionary terms is that a population is a pool of individuals from which the next generation will be drawn. In addition, the concept of a population has to be extended further to include genetic composition: the spatial and temporal limits of a population are defined by uniform allele frequencies. Populations may sometimes have underlying genetic structure in which subpopulations have differences in allele frequencies. In this case, a population comprises multiple subpopulations, some or all of which have differences in allele frequencies. Accurate population definition is essential so that sampling is done in a manner which will enable inferences to be made about the population of interest. There are two practical problems that commonly limit the inferences that can be made appropriately to the population level; neither is unique to plant pathology. The first problem is that of recognizing and sampling populations. The second problem is the study of laboratory strains that are not representative of individuals present in field populations. Unfortunately, it is frequently difficult to define the target population, and therefore appropriate sampling strategies are not always clear. Because of these practical difficulties, analyses are sometimes done on laboratory strains. Each of these problems will be discussed in more detail. From an operational perspective, recognition of population structure is very important when estimating population genetic parameters. Wolfe and Knott (1982) discussed this problem in relation to pathotype surveys, but many of the same caveats apply to any population sampling. The most important caveat is to avoid pooling individuals belonging to genetically distinct subpopulations. This problem can arise by sampling over diverse areas or at different times. Knowledge of the biology of an organism can be useful for rationally delimiting the scale of a population. A population may comprise individuals within a given geographic region on a continental scale, e.g. Puccinia graminis f. sp. tritici, which migrates hundreds of kilometres in North America (Roelfs, 1985), or as small as a soil core, e.g.
GENETICS AND PLANT DISEASE EPIDEMIOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT
7
Fusarium oxysporum, where populations 10 m apart in undisturbed soil may be genetically distinct (Gordon et al., 1992). The defining feature is the subdivision of the population into genetically distinct subpopulations. In addition, the size of genetic individuals (genets) also varies greatly (see Brasier, 1992; Anderson and Kohn, 1995), which, in turn, influences the sampling strategy to be adopted. Although studies on characterized laboratory strains can be valuable for revealing biological phenomena, inferences made from them to natural populations may be misleading or inappropriate. For example, an important question for the management of fungicide resistance is the fitness of resistant individuals (Milgroom et al., 1989). Some studies have shown that laboratoryselected mutants resistant to fungicides have reduced fitness compared to wild type strains (e.g. De Waard and Van Nistelrooy, 1990). To apply this finding to management in the field, however, one needs to ask whether it is appropriate to make inferences from laboratory strains. Surveys of field populations have sometimes shown quite different results from those in the laboratory. For example, there were only two variable amino acid sites in the p-tubulin gene that conferred benomyl resistance in Venturia inaequalis and other fungal plant pathogens collected from field populations; in contrast, seven additional variable amino acid sites were found among resistant laboratory mutants (Koenraadt et al., 1992). A possible explanation for this discrepancy is that most mutants are at such a selective disadvantage that they are not likely to be found anywhere but in a laboratory. Inferences made about fitness of laboratory strains in this case would be very misleading. The problem of defining a population on which to make inferences is perhaps best exemplified by studies in which genetic variation of culture collections is described. These studies may be valuable for systematics or biogeography, or finding diagnostic markers, but they are less useful for population genetics because the target “population” is artificial, being a collection of disparate individuals which would normally be separated both in time and space. One example of different inferences from different samples is found with the chestnut blight fungus, Cryphonectriaparasitica. The effects of vegetative incompatibility (vic) genes on transmission of fungal viruses (hypoviruses), which cause hypovirulence in C. parasitica, were studied independently in two laboratories. One approach was to start with laboratory strains from various populations, but with characterized vic genes (Huber and Fulbright, 1994). The other approach was to sample a large number of uncharacterized isolates randomly from a single natural population (Liu and Milgroom, 1996). Although both studies found similar results, the choice of strains made a fundamental difference to the inferences that could be made. The strength of the Huber and Fulbright (1994) study was the valuable insight into genetic control and cellular-level interactions affecting virus transmission. However,
8
M. G. MILGROOM and W. E. FRY
inferences to the population level were not possible because of lack of knowledge of vic allele frequencies in specific populations. In contrast, Liu and Milgroom (1996) estimated the average effects of vic genes in a natural population, but without an understanding of the effects of each individual gene. The inference from this study was the average transmission of hypoviruses and the potential success of biological control with hypovirulence in a specific population. The weakness was that inferences could not be made to other populations without assuming that vic allele frequencies were similar to those in the sampled population. The important lesson is that the population to which inferences can be made depends on the population that is sampled for study. For epidemiology and management, where it is essential to make inferences beyond laboratory strains, the best approach is to sample directly from the target population of interest. Wolfe and Knott (1982) and Milgroom (1995a) discussed some of the practical constraints on sampling populations for population genetic studies; this issue will not be discussed further here. B. GENETIC VARIATION IN POPULATIONS
Almost every population has some degree of genetic diversity; the few exceptions are usually where single clones have colonized new areas (e.g. Correll et al., 1992; Goodwin et al., 1994b). There are two basic types of genetic variation: ecologically important variation and selectively neutral variation. Ecologically important variation refers to traits that affect fitness and, therefore, may be under selection. Selectively neutral variation refers to variation in traits that do not (or are assumed not to) affect fitness and are not under selection. Changes in selectively neutral traits are affected by evolutionary forces such as mutation, genetic drift and gene flow (although they may be affected indirectly by selection on linked genes). The different inferences that can be made from each type of genetic variation will become evident below. The challenge is to understand how each type of genetic variation relates to epidemiology and disease management. In many situations, ecologically important variation is the type of variation that is more relevant for disease management. Variation in pathogen populations in response to a management practice may have implications for the durability of that practice, since individuals may be selected for or against. The best-known examples in which genetic variation, and therefore selection, has a direct effect on disease management are pathotypes and fungicide resistance. However, variation in other traits may also be relevant to management and may help to explain some failures of bialogical or cultural controls, although these latter areas have been studied little to date. Similarly, variation in response to environmental conditions has also been hypothesized to affect the genetic composition of fungal populations (e.g. Koller et al., 1995).
GENETICS AND PLANT DISEASE EPIDEMIOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT
9
An understanding of variation in ecologically important traits is relevant to epidemiology and management because it helps predict how a population will respond to selection. The strength of selection (or more formally, the rate of change of the mean fitness in a population) is proportional to the variance in fitness in the population; this is known as the fundamental theorem of natural selection (Fisher, 1930). For example, the variance in fitness in a fungal population when a fungicide is applied is roughly equivalent to the variance in fungicide resistance phenotypes (Milgroom et af., 1989). Therefore, surveys of pathogen populations may be used to estimate this variance and to predict the rate of selection. If a pathogen population is uniformly sensitive to a fungicide, i.e. it exhibits no variation in fungicide resistance, then resistance cannot be selected and the use of that fungicide may provide effective disease management. Conversely, once there is variation for response to fungicide, selection will favour the resistant individuals, whose fitness will be greater than sensitive individuals when fungicide is applied; the resistant individuals will then increase in frequency. Estimates of variance need to be made from adequate samples, from defined target populations (e.g. Smith et af., 1991; Peever and Milgroom, 1993) in order to make inferences to the population level that are relevant to management. A culture collection is unlikely to represent a target population accurately. Successful breeding and deployment of durable host-plant resistance depends on an understanding of variation in pathogen populations. Proper resistance screening requires first defining the pathogen populations against which resistance is being bred, and then sampling the target populations adequately. In some cases a target population has been well sampled. For example, a collection of the most common clones of Sclerotinia sclerotzorurn that occur across the canola-growing regions of Canada (Kohli et af., 1992) is available for screening for resistance in Canada (L. M. Kohn, personal communication). The goal in screening for resistance against large samples of the pathogen is not only to find the best resistance, but also to assess the range of variation in the pathogen population for virulence on particular breeding lines. In other words, successful deployment of resistance relies on both breeding and screening against appropriate target populations of pathogens. From an evolutionary perspective, there are two main outcomes of a comprehensive resistance screening programme. First, interactions between breeding lines and pathogen isolates can be identified, which indicate specialization of pathogen genotypes to resistant lines. The magnitude of the interaction and variation on individual hosts are important features in interpreting the significance of interactions, Second, the variance in virulence and fitness among isolates on particular host lines can also be estimated, allowing the rate at which a population will shift to higher levels of virulence to be predicted.
10
M. G. MILGROOM and W. E. FRY
As biological control is used increasingly against plant pathogens, failures are likely to occur because target organisms evolve resistance to the introduced agents. There are few examples of plant pathogens in which resistance to biological control agents has been documented. The potential for resistance to some hypoviruses in C. parasitica was recently demonstrated in the laboratory (Polashock el al., 1994). The evolutionary processes leading to failures of biological control are similar to those for the evolution of fungicide resistance or pathotypes, but are rarely considered when biocontrol agents are deployed. Surveys of existing vaiiation (as with fungicide resistance and virulence) would be logical steps in estimating the evolutionary potential for resistance in target populations. An equally challenging evolutionary problem in biological control is the potential for declining effectiveness of introduced agents because of selection against more effective individuals. An outstanding example is myxoma viruses released in Australia to control rabbits (reviewed in Fenner and Myers, 1978). The myxoma virus caused nearly 100% mortality in the rabbit population when it was first introduced. However, several years later, moderately virulent strains increased in frequency, and the most virulent viruses all but disappeared. Simultaneously, viruses placed such intense selection pressure on rabbit populations that the average level of virus resistance increased. Needless to say, the effectiveness of biological control decreased dramatically. Comparable phenomena have yet to be described in plant pathology, but the example of the myxoma virus should not be ignored. The primary lesson from these examples is that an understanding of ecologically important variation is needed in order to predict the durability of any particular management practice. The evolutionary process most pertinent to management is selection, and direct measurement of the phenotype of interest is usually the best approach for studying ecologically important variation. C. THE USE OF NEUTRAL GENETIC MARKERS TO ESTIMATE ECOLOGICALLY IMPORTANT VARIATION
As selectively neutral genetic markers have become more accessible, there have been numerous attempts to substitute them for direct assessment of ecologically important characters. The motivation is quite reasonable: it is generally simpler to determine an allozyme or RAPD profile of a pathogen isolate than it is to inoculate a series of differential cultivars to determine its pathotype. If neutral genetic markers are good predictors of pathotypes, then their use could save valuablettime and expense. However, this approach must be undertaken cautiously; there is no general rule that variation in one marker can predict variation in another. The success of this approach depends on the type of marker used, or knowledge of the population structure of the
GENETICS AND PLANT DISEASE EPIDEMIOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT
11
pathogen. This issue will be discussed at the level of both individuals and populations. 1. Predicting variation among individuals Genetic markers can sometimes identify an ecologically important trait. A direct assay is sometimes possible by detecting a particular gene responsible for the trait of interest. For example, benzimidazole resistance can be assayed directly by selective polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification of alleles of the P-tubulin gene that confer resistance (Koenraadt and Jones, 1992). Alternatively, when a gene of interest cannot be assayed directly, neutral genetic markers tightly linked to it may be used if the association between loci is strong. Finding linked markers is becoming increasingly possible given the efforts in numerous laboratories to develop genetic maps of various pathogens, or the use of techniques such as bulked segregant analysis (Michelmore et al., 1991). For example, RAPD markers tightly linked to avirulence loci in barley powdery mildew, Erysiphe graminis f. sp. hordei, have been found to have strong non-random associations (cited in Wolfe and McDermott, 1994), but the association is not perfect and estimation of avirulence allele frequencies from these markers would include a measurable amount of error. Exploiting non-random associations is an approach that has been used successfully to predict ecological traits with neutral markers in some organisms. There are a number of examples of plant pathogens for which there are almost perfect associations between neutral markers and pathotypes or vegetative compatibility groups (e.g. Burdon and Roelfs, 1985; Kistler et at., 1991; Kohn et al., 1991; Goodwin et al., 1992b; Anderson and Kohn, 1995). Non-random association among alleles at different loci is referred to as “gametic disequilibrium”, or “gametic phase disequilibrium”, and is caused primarily by two different factors. First, simultaneous selection for different traits can result in non-random associations; this is exemplified by selection for pathotypes with combinations of avirulence genes compatible to host-plant resistance with two or more corresponding specific resistance genes (Wolfe and Knott, 1982; Hovmoller and 0sterglrd, 1991). Second, and more relevant to the use of neutral markers, gametic disequilibrium often occurs between tightly linked loci. An extreme case of gametic disequilibrium is when organisms are asexual such that the entire genome is effectively linked; all the organisms cited above for strong non-random associations among different markers are asexual for much or all of their life cycles (the exception above is S. sclerotiorum, which is homothallic and, therefore, no recombination occurs [Kohn et al., 19911). Conversely, gametic disequilibrium is minimal in sexually reproducing organisms because of recombination (e.g. Milgroom et al., 1992a; McDonald et al., 1994; Liu et al., 1996; Milgroom, 1996). Therefore, population structure and reproductive biology should be known before attempting to use neutral markers to predict other traits.
12
M. G . MILGROOM and W. E. FRY
Prediction of ecologically important variation from neutral markers has several serious drawbacks. First, different mutation rates among loci can result in uncorrelated variation. For example, in the rice blast fungus, Magnaporthe grisea, a single clonal lineage, defined by a multilocus RFLP fingerprint, may comprise many diverse pathotypes because the mutation rate for avirulence genes is apparently greater than for the RFLP marker (Levy et al., 1993; Zeigler et al., 1995). Therefore, in M . grisea, even though the range of pathotypes within a lineage may be limited, a lineage does not necessarily identify pathotype. A similar situation occurs with Phytophthora infestans, in which there is much pathotype variation within some clonal lineages (Goodwin et al., 1995~).As a contrasting example, there was no significant variation in virulence among clones of S . sclerotiorum from canola in Canada that differed in RFLP genotypes and mycelial compatibility (L. M. Kohn, personal communication), The problem of differential mutation rates is further highlighted in pathogens such as F. oxysporum in which host specialization is only sometimes associated with vegetative compatibility groups (Correll, 1991; Appel and Gordon, 1994). These discrepancies can be explained simply by variations in mutation rates between different loci. The restrictions on using neutral genetic markers to predict ecologically important variation should be considered carefully before attempting such a project. First, a decision has to be made whether a genetic marker is simpler than a direct assay of the phenotype of interest. For example, it may be simpler in some organisms to assay a fungicide resistance phenotype than it is to probe for a particular gene: compare a simple cultural technique (Lalancette et al., 1984) to amplifying P-tubulin genes (Koenraadt and Jones, 1992) to assay for benomyl resistance. On the other hand, the determination of a pathotype may require considerably more effort compared to determining simple molecular markers. However, a random search for markers associated with pathotypes may be fruitless unless the target population is clonal and markers can be found with appropriate levels of variation. Alternatively, finding tightly linked markers with predictive value in sexual populations may require extraordinary effort unless a genetic map has already been constructed. In addition, it may be necessary to verify an association between markers for each population to be studied because different degrees of association may be found within different populations. For example, the simple relationship between pathotypes and clonal lineages found in US populations of M . grisea (Levy et al., 1991) was more complex in populations in Colombia and the Philippines (Levy et al., 1993; Zeigler et al., 1995) (see also section IIIE, p. 18). When all these factors are considered, it may be more accurate, and less effort, to survey variation in the ecologically important trait of interest than it is to find reliable diagnostic genetic markers.
GENETICS AND PLANT DISEASE EPIDEMIOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT
13
2. Predicting variation among populations An important misconception about the use of neutral genetic markers is that knowledge of their variation can be used to predict variation in ecologically important traits. This misconception may derive from generalization of the special cases described above (clonal populations, use of linked markers, similar mutation rates, etc.). Unfortunately, there are surprisingly few studies comparing diversity of both types of markers among different populations. Diversity in pathotypes and allozymes showed a rough correlation in the asexual barley scald fungus, Rhyncosporium secalis (Goodwin et al., 1993); however, the correlation was not strong, and sample sizes were sometimes small. In contrast, variations in RAPD markers were poor predictors of variation in avirulence alleles in E . gruminis f. sp. hordei (Wolfe and McDermott, 1994), and in fungicide resistance in Pyrenophora teres (Peever and Milgroom, 1994b; see also section IVA). Conceptually, any attempt to correlate diversity of different markers is fraught with problems. First, as mentioned above, differential mutation rates confound any correlation. Second, and more important, is the effect of selection on ecologically important variation but not on unlinked neutral markers. For example, a population that is highiy diverse for both pathotypes and neutral markers could lose much of its pathotype diversity if exposed to highly selective host-plant resistance such that few pathotypes survive. This same population could maintain its diversity for neutral markers if the population is not highly clonal. Claims that knowledge of variation of neutral markers can predict variation in pathotypes or fungicide resistance should, therefore, be interpreted with caution. D. THE INTERFACE BETWEEN POPULATION GENETICS AND EPIDEMIOLOGY
We will discuss two entirely different ways in which neutral genetic variation can be applied to epidemiological questions. First, selectively neutral markers can be exploited directly for addressing epidemiological questions in which specific strains are tracked in the environment. Second, concepts of population genetics allow inferences to be made about evolutionary processes, which in turn may affect interpretations of epidemiology. Examples of how evolutionary inferences can be made to plant pathogen populations have been reviewed recently (see section 1, p. 1 for references) and will not be repeated here. In the following sections, we give examples of how genetic variation and population genetic concepts can be integrated with epidemiology and disease management. 1 . Direct tracking o j genotypes One of the simplest applications of genetic variation and genetic markers in an epidemiological context is the direct tracking of specific genotypes. This
14
M. G . MILGROOM and W. E. FRY
may be useful for determining the source of inoculum or for identifying different genotypes in competition studies. The ability to discriminate among genotypes can facilitate competition experiments (Ennos and McConnell, 1995; Legard et al., 1995), and may be used even for organisms that have regular sexual cycles if tracking is done during the asexual phase (Sierotzki et al., 1994). An excellent example of tracking specific genotypes to address epidemiological questions is the work summarized by Webber et al. (1987) on the saprophytic phase of the Dutch elm disease fungus, Ophiostoma novo-ulmi. Using benomyl-resistant isolates, Webber and colleagues showed that there were two distinct sources of inoculum contributing to the colonization of elm bark: the fungus present in the xylem from the pathogenic phase and spores introduced by bark beetle vectors from the saprophytic phase in dead elm trees. In addition, after inoculating trees with benomyl-resistant isolates of known vegetative compatibility types, they found recombinant genotypes on the emerging beetles. This result demonstrated that at least some ascospores contributed to bark colonization and that recombination maintained genotype diversity in the population. In another example of determining the source of inoculum, Shah et al. (1995) tested the hypothesis that a major source of Stagonospora nodorum on wheat in New York state was infected seed. They used two complementary approaches, one using classical epidemiological methods, the other taking advantage of genetic variation in S. nodorum populations. They infected wheat seeds with S. nodorum isolates that had known RFLP genotypes and then mixed these with clean seed to create seed lots with varying proportions of infected seed, which were then planted in the field. The severity of the ensuing foliar epidemics correlated to the proportions of infected seeds planted. In addition, the majority of the isolates recovered from foliage and seed in the next generation were the same genotypes as those used to infect seeds, although these same genotypes were not found in the resident background population. Results from both approaches clearly demonstrated a significant role of seed-borne inoculum in this pathosystem. As a source of inoculum, long-distance dispersal, or gene flow, is usually quantitatively insignificant, although there are exceptions. For example, the Puccinia pathway in North America has been described in detail (Roelfs, 1985) in which Puccinia graminis f. sp. tritici overwinters in Texas and Mexico and migrates annually throughout the midwestern USA and into Canada; migration occurs in the reverse direction in autumn. Another pathogen that overwinters far from an agricultural host population in the USA is the tobacco blue mould pathogen, Peronospora tabacina. Each year inoculum must be reintroduced into tobacco-growing regions in the USA from overwintering areas. However, the exact locations of the inoculum sources are not known despite attempts to identify them by trajectory studies (Davis and Main, 1988). Tobacco blue mould is an example where direct tracking of genotypes
GENETICS AND PLANT DISEASE EPIDEMIOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT
15
could potentially be applied to answer a basic epidemiological problem. An essential requirement would be to develop a set of polymorphic genetic markers and to characterize genetic variation in all possible source populations. This approach has been used successfully for tracking the sources of immigrant genotypes of Phytophthora infestans in the USA and Canada (Goodwin et a f . , 1994a,b; see also section IVB). Although long-distance dispersal is generally not important quantitatively as a source of inoculum, it can sometimes have significant qualitative effects, especially the introduction of novel pathotypes. A good example of this is barley powdery mildew in Europe. Analyses of neutral genetic markers made it possible to demonstrate that some genotypes have dispersed on a continental scale, introducing pathotypes compatible with host resistance genes that otherwise were effective against the resident mildew population (Brown et af., 1991; Wolfe and McDermott, 1994). By surveying genetic variation throughout many possible source populations and matching genotypes, the origin of dispersing inoculum could be identified confidently. 2.
Evolutionary inferences f r o m population genetic studies
Gene pow. The analysis of selectively neutral genetic variation among subpopulations by gene-diversity analyses provides another approach to studying gene flow and sources of inoculum (for methods see Leung et al., 1993; McDermott and McDonald, 1993; Milgroom, 1995a). Populations that are genetically subdivided are likely to have restricted gene flow among subpopulations, and to some degree may be managed as separate entities (Leung et a f . , 1993; Milgroom, 1995a). In contrast, a population that is genetically uniform over a large area may be experiencing widespread dispersal among subpopulations such that, in theory, the whole population must be considered as a management unit. Disease management for subdivided pathogen populations with host-plant resistance has been recently summarized (Leung et al., 1993) and will not be discussed further here. Management of fungicide resistance in subdivided populations is discussed below (section IV). Population structure due to various levels of gene flow may be a factor that can be exploited to a greater extent in future disease-management efforts. Estimates of gene flow from analyses of gene diversity have some inherent weaknesses, especially in agricultural systems that are highly disturbed by episodic introductions of plant pathogens. When populations are subdivided, it is an indication that gene flow is restricted to some degree. However, lack of genetic differentiation among populations is more problematic because it can be explained in at least two ways: by high levels of current gene flow, and/or by gene flow that occurred in the past (Slatkin, 1987). It is possible that populations with little genetic subdivision because of past gene flow
16
M. G. MILGROOM and W. E. FRY
actually experience low levels of current gene flow among subpopulations (although gene-diversity analyses would not show this). An example of historical gene flow is when a pathogen is introduced into a new area along with an agricultural crop. If the introduction occurred relatively recently it is unlikely that populations would have reached an equilibrium between gene flow and drift. To estimate current gene flow from gene-diversity data, one must assume that populations are in equilibrium for gene flow and genetic drift (Slatkin, 1987). Therefore, estimates of gene flow are likely to be fairly reliable when populations are highly subdivided, but claims of high levels of gene flow may be overestimated when subdivision is weak, and need to be supported by more information about the biology of an organism, especially its ability to disperse or be transported long distances. This problem was discussed in detail in relation to population subdivision in C. parasitica in North America (Milgroom and Lipari, 1995). Recombination. There are numerous plant-pathogenic fungi that reproduce sexually. Sexual reproduction not only contributes to recombination and the potential to generate new genotypic diversity, but equally important from an epidemiological perspective, it often involves structures that differ in dormancy, survival or dispersal characteristics from asexual propagules (see also section IVB). As an example, primary inoculum of Mycosphaerellu graminicola on wheat could be either sexual or asexual. Asexual pycnidiospores produced on crop debris are generally dispersed over short distances. However, ascospores of M. gruminicola can disperse over longer distances (Shaw and Royle, 1989). Identification of sexual or asexual inoculum sources for M . graminicola has been investigated both with epidemiological techniques and population genetics. The importance of airborne inoculum of M . graminicola, most likely ascospores, as primary inoculum was demonstrated by Shaw and Royle (1989) by excluding other sources of inoculum. A complementary population genetic approach was used by Chen et al. (1994) in the same system. They showed that, although allele frequencies did not change over 3 years, there was no carryover of multilocus genotypes from year to year; this finding is consistent with frequent recombination and annual recolonization by ascospores. Both approaches led to similar conclusions about the role of ascospores: one observed the effects of airborne spores on disease progress, while the other made inferences from patterns of genetic variation. In contrast to the above example, where airborne inoculum could be assayed directly, studies of genetic variation are sometimes the only approach available for determining if sexually produced inoculum is present. For example, until recently only the A1 mating type of Phytophthora infestans was found outside of central Mexico (Goodwin et al., 1994b). The discovery of the A2 mating type in Europe in the 1980s (Hohl and Iselin, 1984; Fry et al., 1993) signalled an important potential for oospore formation. Oospores
GENETICS AND PLANT DISEASE EPIDEMIOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT
17
would allow P. infestuns to survive in the soil between potato crops, potentially altering the source of inoculum and epidemiology of late blight. The increase in genotypic diversity of P. infestuns populations in Europe in recent years has been attributed to immigration of new genotypes and the occurrence of sexual reproduction (Drenth et uf., 1994; Sujkowski et uf., 1994). Using genetic markers in an epidemiological context, Drenth et uf. (1995) confirmed that oospores survived in soil and that recombinant genotypes infected potato crops the following year. Recombination also has significant effects on the diversity of multilocus genotypes (reviewed in Milgroom, 1996), although recombination per se does not affect gene diversity, which is a function of the number and frequencies of different alleles. The importance of recombination to the diversity of pathotypes is well documented for Pucciniu gruminis f. sp. tritici in North America (Roelfs and Groth, 1980). Following the eradication of barberry, on which P. graminis reproduces sexually and produces overwintering teliospores, the diversity of pathotypes decreased significantly. Similarly, the diversity of pathotypes west of the Rocky Mountains in the USA, where the barberry was not eradicated, was significantly greater than in areas to the east where barberries were eradicated (Roelfs and Groth, 1980). The population structure of this pathogen was significantly altered such that it is now almost exclusively asexual with few clones (Burdon and Roelfs, 1985). Recombination and multilocus population structure are highly relevant to resistance gene deployment. For example, non-random associations among avirulence alleles in P. gruminis f. sp. tritici sparked a debate about the causes and significance of gametic disequilibrium. Vanderplank (1982) speculated that non-random associations were caused by selection against particular combinations of avirulence alleles. The implication of such selection is that certain combinations of resistance genes would be durable because compatible pathotypes would have reduced fitness. However, a simpler explanation for the observed gametic disequilibrium in populations of P. gruminis f. sp. tritici is clonal population structure (Knott, 1986). This explanation has fundamentally different implications for resistance gene deployment, since cultivars with particular resistance gene combinations would be vulnerable to compatible pathotypes if they occurred in the population, for example by immigration or mutation. The importance of gametic disequilibrium and gene deployment has been studied in much detail for barley powdery mildew, Erysiphe gruminis f. sp. hordei. Hovmcdller and 0stergbrd (1991) and Hovmdler et uf. (1993) demonstrated both positive and negative associations among avirulence alleles, depending on which resistance genes occurred together in common barley cultivars; their findings were similar to theoretical predictions for gametic disequilibrium (0stergird and Hovm~ller,1991). However, they also found that selection was not entirely predictable because of hitch-hiking selection, in which the frequency of avirulence alleles not under selection
18
M. G . MILGROOM and W. E. FRY
increased (or decreased) as a result of selection for other avirulence alleles in clonal populations. Brown (1995) modelled gametic disequilibrium among alleles at different avirulence loci in relation to the extent of recombination occurring and initial genotype distributions, and showed that hitch-hiking selection is difficult to predict in asexually reproducing populations. The dynamics of gametic disequilibria among avirulence alleles offers promise for understanding and improving resistance gene deployment in response to knowledge of pathotype distributions in populations. A unique example of disease management that required a thorough understanding of recombination was described by Crute (1989) for lettuce downy mildew, caused by Bremia Zacfucae. During the 1980s, resistance to the fungicide metalaxyl occurred in B. lucfucae in the UK. However, metalaxyl resistance initially arose only in a single clone, with the B2 mating type, which was avirulent on cultivars with the D m l l resistance gene. In order for metalaxyl resistance genes to be recombined into pathotypes virulent on Dmll cultivars, resistant and sensitive isolates had to occur on the same cultivar to mate successfully. Mating between resistant and sensitive isolates could only occur on cultivars that lacked D m l l (to allow metalaxylresistant isolates to colonize) and were not treated with metalaxyl (to allow metalaxyl-sensitive isolates to colonize). Therefore, to prevent recombination, growers were recommended to apply metalaxyl to cultivars lacking D m l l , even though control against the resistant isolates would be ineffective. Although this strategy was short lived due to the appearance of metalaxyl resistance in other pathotypes (Crute, 1992), it provides insight into the direct integration of population genetics and disease management.
E. POPULATION CHARACTERISTICS VARY AMONG POPULATIONS
It is important to recognize that different populations of the same species sometimes have completely different population structures. This concept is important because management strategies applicable to one population may not apply to other populations. Unfortunately, this means that studies need to be replicated in several different populations in order to understand the range of variation that occurs within a species. Populations may vary in allele frequencies, or their overall genetic structures may be completely different. Differences in allele frequencies may result from restricted gene flow and genetic drift (Goodwin et al., 1993; Peever and Milgroom, 1994b; Milgroom and Lipari, 1995), founder effects (Milgroom et uZ., 1992b) or selection (Kolmer, 1989; Wolfe and McDermott, 1994). The two case studies discussed below (section IV) demonstrate some of the management implications of different allele frequencies among populations. Populations may also differ in the extent to which recombination occurs,
GENETICS AND PLANT DISEASE EPIDEMIOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT
19
affecting the multilocus structure of populations. There are several striking examples of both clonal and sexual population structure in the same species: Puccinia graminis f. sp. tritici (Roelfs and Groth, 1980), Magnaporthe grisea (Kumar et al., 1995), Ophiostoma novo-ulmi (Brasier, 1988), Phytophthora infestans (Goodwin et al., 1992b; Drenth et al., 1994) and Cryphonectria parasitica (Liu et a f . , 1996). Other examples are likely to emerge as more investigations are done.
IV. EXAMPLES OF THE INTEGRATION OF POPULATION GENETICS AND EPIDEMIOLOGY A. FUNGICIDE RESISTANCE IN PYRENOPHORA TERES
Population genetics has made a significant contribution to managing resistance to sterol biosynthesis-inhibiting fungicides (SBIs) in Pyrenophora teres, which causes net blotch of barley (Peever and Milgroom, 1992, 1993, 1994a,b). The questions addressed in this system were familiar in fungicide resistance management: (1) is there cross-resistance among chemically related fungicides, and (2) are there fitness costs associated with fungicide resistance? Approaching these questions from the perspective of population and ecological genetics yielded some useful information about population structure and disease management. The approach used to address questions of cross-resistance and fitness costs was to sample discrete populations of P. teres. Samples of 22-35 isolates were taken from each of four populations in North America and one in Germany; SBIs had been used previously for disease control in only two of the five populations. The growth rate of each isolate was measured in vitro in the presence of five different SBIs. There was significant variation in SBI resistance within populations, indicating that SBI applications would potentially result in selection for higher frequencies of resistant phenotypes. Cross-resistance among different SBIs was analysed in terms of genetic correlations, to determine whether the same genes controlled resistance to different SBIs (Peever and Milgroom, 1993). Resistance to many pairs of SBIs was correlated in some populations, but not in others. In other words, there were different cross-resistance relationships in different populations. A similar approach to estimating genetic correlations was used to determine if genes that control SBI resistance also affect fitness (Peever and Milgroom, 1994a). Latent period and sporulation were estimated in isolates from two populations. However, there was no correlation between SBI resistance phenotype and fitness. These results must be interpreted somewhat cautiously, as it is difficult to make inferences from greenhouse studies to fitness in natural populations. In addition to studying SBI resistance and fitness, Peever and Milgroom
20
M. G. MILGROOM and W. E. FRY
(1994b) also analysed population structure using RAPD markers in the same samples. The diversity of RAPDs was not correlated with variation in SBI resistance between populations, i.e. variation in neutral genetic markers was not a good predictor of ecologically important variation for these populations. In addition, there was no discernible association between RAPDs and SBI resistance within populations. Analysis of the multilocus genetic structure revealed that four of five populations did not deviate from what was expected under random mating. Therefore, recombination may be sufficient to uncouple selection for SBI resistance from neutral genetic markers (contrast this with the Phytophthoru infestans example below; section IVB). The analysis of population structure among Pyrenophora teres populations using RAPDs showed moderately high genetic subdivision, with 33-46% of the variation attributable to differences among populations (Peever and Milgroom, 1994b). Genetic subdivision is most likely a result of restricted gene flow among populations; therefore, each population may have to be considered individually in terms of fungicide resistance management. Interestingly, when phenotypic variation in fungicide resistance was partitioned within and among populations, the result was similar to that found with RAPDs: 38% of the variation was due to differences among populations. The similar degree of genetic differentiation for both ecologically important and selectively neutral traits suggests that selection has not strongly affected population structure (Spitze, 1993), even though SBIs had been applied occasionally in two of the populations studied. A result that merits closer examination is the finding that different populations had different cross-resistance relationships (Peever and Milgroom, 1993). The cause of these differences is not understood entirely, but the simplest explanations are that there are different alleles conferring SBI resistance, or allele frequencies are different in each population. An alternate hypothesis is that fungicide resistance genes are non-randomly associated. However, the lack of gametic disequilibrium among RAPD loci suggests that populations may experience a significant amount of recombination. In addition, selection from fungicide use appears minimal since only two populations had experienced these fungicides prior to sampling, and, as shown above, differentiation among populations was similar for both RAPDs and resistance phenotypes. These studies have some clear lessons for SBI resistance management in P. teres. First, because of significant phenotypic variation in SBI resistance in each population, it can be predicted that resistance would evolve if fungicides were applied intensely; and, because there are no detectable fitness costs associated with SBI resistance in P. teres, the frequencies of resistant phenotypes would not necessarily decline if fungicide use were subsequently discontinued. Second, differences in cross-resistance among populations mean that SBI resistance has to be managed independently in each population; this conclusion is further supported by strong genetic differentia-
GENETICS AND PLANT DISEASE EPIDEMIOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT
21
tion among subpopulations. Third, by assaying for cross-resistance in different populations, we can predict which combinations of fungicides would be effective in each population. Fourth, differences in allele frequencies for SBI resistance may strongly affect genetic correlations for cross-resistance. Therefore, no single model of cross-resistance among SBIs is appropriate for P. teres. Whether similar conclusions apply to other populations of P. teres, or to different species, awaits further studies of this type. An important feature of this research is the sampling and, therefore, the populations to which inferences can be made. Inferences that can be made from the population approach are simple to understand and relevant for management. B.
EPIDEMIOLOGY AND POPULATIONS GENETICS OF PHYTOPHTHORA INFESTAN S
Recent studies of Phytophthora infestans have revealed unexpected population structure that in turn has led to hypotheses concerning migrations, and insights into management of late blight. The initial motivation for studying the population genetics of P. infestans came from disease management problems in Europe in the early 1980s. At that time, there were two factors that signalled some unexpected variation in the pathogen population: disease control failures caused by metalaxyl resistance (Davidse et al., 1981), and the detection of A2 mating types (Hohl and Iselin, 1984). In addition, there was a profound lack of knowledge concerning geographic distribution, population structure, and the evolutionary processes shaping populations of f. infestam. Population genetic studies in North America have provided the bases for short-term management strategies, and may eventually lead to long-term management strategies. 1. Population structure
Prior to the 1980s there were probably three geographically defined populations around the world. First, the source population in central'Mexico is unique among P. infestans populations. This population has characteristics of a randomly mating sexual population (Tooley ef al., 1985; Goodwin et al., 1992b): approximately equal frequencies of A1 and A2 mating types (Tooley et ul., 1985), allozyme genotypes in Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium (Goodwin et al., 1992b), and a huge diversity of multilocus genotypes in any small geographic area (e.g. a single field) (Matuszak et al., 1990). Second, populations in the USA and Canada were derived from the population in Mexico, and were asexual, but with several clonal lineages. Third, on other continents, populations were dominated by a single clonal lineage (termed US-l), with most genetic diversity caused by mutation or mitotic recombination within that lineage (Goodwin et al., 1994b). The hypothesized pathways of migrations of f. infestans were recently summarized (Fry et al., 1993).
22
M. G. MILGROOM and W. E. FRY
Recent immigration of P. infestans into the USA and Canada illustrates the importance of population genetics to epidemiology and management. A significant migration occurred into the USA and Canada, probably from northern Mexico beginning in the late 1970s, but became most noticeable in the early 1990s (Goodwin et al., 1994a, 1995b). As in Europe, these migrations were first signalled by metalaxyl resistance (Deahl et al., 1993) and then by detection of individuals with the A2 mating type (Deahl et al., 1995; Goodwin et al., 1995b). In the early 1990s, populations in the USA and Canada were dominated by four clonal lineages: the resident lineage (US-l), and three recent immigrant lineages (US-6, US-7 and US-8) (Goodwin et al., 1994a, 1995b). The recent immigrant lineages represented A1 (US-6) and A2 (US-7 and US-8) mating types; all were resistant to metalaxyl (Fry et al., 1993). In addition, in most locations, the individuals in a single field and often over a vast region were in the same lineage (Goodwin et al., 1994a, 1995b). Analysis of pathotypes has generally not been as useful as analysis of neutral markers in deciphering relationships among populations. Individuals sampled in Mexico generally represent complex pathotypes, which were virulent on cultivars with multiple specific resistance genes (Tooley et al., 1985; Rivera-Pena and Molina-Galan, 1989). In addition, clonal lineages found in the USA and Canada that were recently derived from Mexico had greater pathotype complexity than resident pathotypes (Goodwin et al., 199%). Selection for complex pathotypes may be important in some locations, e.g. Mexico, but in the USA and Canada most potato cultivars lack specific resistance. In the absence of selection, rare pathotypes (and virulence factors) are likely to be lost because of genetic drift: relatively small numbers of individuals survive over winter in asexual populations, i.e. there are annual bottlenecks (Goodwin et al., 1995~).Further confounding our understanding of pathotypes, it has also been shown that pathotype diversity can develop rapidly within a clonal lineage (Goodwin et al., 199%). 2. Late blight management The strong clonal population structure of P. infestans in the USA and Canada during the early 1990s has led to some interesting management options. Knowledge of the widespread occurrence of immigrant genotypes in 1994 stimulated plant pathologists to launch an intensive effort to educate growers and extension personnel concerning the attributes of immigrant genotypes. At the same time, plant pathologists began to petition for the use of fungicides that otherwise would not have been available. Convincing documentation that the significant late blight problems were caused by immigrant genotypes was instrumental in convincing growers and regulatory personnel that new measures were needed. These efforts helped avert major epidemics in 1995. Knowledge of genetic variation and population structure made it possible
GENETICS AND PLANT DISEASE EPIDEMIOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT
23
to develop rapid diagnostic tests to identify P. infestuns lineages. Because field populations usually consisted of a single clonal lineage, and because the four major lineages in the USA and Canada could be distinguished via allozymes (Gpi), a rapid assessment of the allozyme genotype (Goodwin et al., 1995a) enabled practitioners to learn (sometimes within hours) which lineage was causing the problem in a particular field. This was especially important in predicting the efficacy of metalaxyl. Metalaxyl was extremely effective against US-1, but was much less effective against the immigrant lineages US-6, US-7 and US-8. The observation that certain lineages appeared to be associated mainly with potatoes and that other lineages were associated with both potatoes and tomatoes motivated investigations of host specialization. It became clear that US-6 and US-7 were pathogenic on both tomatoes and potatoes, whereas US-8 was primarily a pathogen of potatoes (Legard et ul., 1995). Host specialization was polymorphic in US-1 (Legard et al., 1995). Because P. infestuns is aerially dispersed, tomato growers needed to know if late blight in nearby potato fields was caused by US-6 or US-7. If so, then the fungus in neighbouring fields posed a serious threat to tomatoes, and management efforts were needed. Variation in aggressiveness was another characteristic that has been important to late blight management. Because clonal lineages could be easily distinguished, it became possible to investigate whether the immigrant lineages posed a more significant threat than did the resident US-1. During 1994 and 1995, several investigators began testing the hypothesis that US-8 was more aggressive than US-1 on potatoes. If the immigrant lineages are more aggressive, an overall intensification of management efforts will be needed. In contrast to earlier populations where only A1 mating type individuals were present, the occurrence of both A1 and A2 individuals in a few fields signals the possibility of sexual reproduction. The presence of oospores could alter the life history of P. infestans in the USA and Canada, consequently altering the epidemiology of the disease. The potential for sexual reproduction has two significant implications for late blight management. First, oospores survive as dormant propagules in soil and may serve as a significant additional source of inoculum. Previously, the soil had not been a source of inoculum for this fungus; in its asexual phase P. infestuns is essentially an obligate parasite and cannot persist in the absence of living hosts. Second, recombinant progeny could result in greater genotypic diversity in the population of P. infestuns in the USA and Canada, destroying the simple clonal structure that exists. Recombination will eliminate the association between allozyme genotype and pathogenic traits, and destroy the potential for using neutral genetic markers to predict epidemiologically important traits. Knowledge that populations of P. infestuns in the USA and Canada are in flux signals the need for significant new investigations in epidemiology and
24
M. G. MILGROOM and W. E. FRY
management. Probably most urgent is the need to investigate the role of oospores in the epidemiology of potato and tomato late blight in the USA and Canada; whether oospores will contribute significantly to initial inoculum is now unknown. Quantification of the greater aggressiveness of recent immigrant genotypes should lead to appropriate intensifications of late blight management strategies. Some opportunities for adjustments in late blight management include development and use of more resistant plants and new chemistries of fungicides. Knowledge that a single clone can be broadly and rapidly dispersed emphasizes the need to determine factors affecting dispersal of P. infesruns and to determine if all genotypes are similarly capable of such dispersal.
V. FUTURE CONTRIBUTIONS OF POPULATION GENETICS TO PLANT PATHOLOGY Population genetics can enhance our understanding of pathogen biology and, therefore, has much to offer plant pathology. Although much of the recent research on population genetics of plant pathogens has involved the description of genetic variation at various scales, some research has progressed to asking questions about evolutionary processes. This is a critical step beyond the descriptive phase because it allows greater insight into pathogen evolution and biology. Like any basic science, the utility of population genetics in plant pathology may at first seem negligible. Rather than letting its fundamental nature deter us, we need to broaden our perspectives to examine how this information can be applied. The most significant applications of population genetics to epidemiology and disease management are likely to derive from practical needs to understand pathogen variation and evolution. Descriptive studies of variation without questions focused on evolutionary processes are not sufficient. Similarly, elegant evolutionary inferences made about pathogen populations for which there are few associated management problems contribute little to the integration of population genetics and disease management. To apply population genetics to epidemiology and disease management, the burden is on plant pathologists to increase their understanding of population genetics and evolution. This educational development is essential, and fortunately is well underway. Education on evolutionary concepts will enhance communication with geneticists and lead to a better integration of population genetics into plant pathology in the future.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We thank Jim Anderson, Clive Brasier, Tom Gordon and Bob Marra for making helpful suggestions on an earlier draft of this chapter.
GENETICS AND PLANT DISEASE EPIDEMIOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT
25
REFERENCES Anderson, J . B. and Kohn, L. M. (1995). Clonality in soilborne, plant pathogenic fungi. Annual Review of Phytopathology 33, 369-391. Appel, D. J. and Gordon, T. R. (1994). Local and regional variation of Fusarium oxysporum from agricultural field soils. Phytopathology 84, 786-791. Brasier, C. M. (1988). Rapid changes in genetic structure of epidemic populations of Ophiostoma ulmi. Nature 332, 538-541. Brasier, C. M. (1992). A champion thallus. Nature 356, 382-383. Brasier, C. M. (1995). Episodic selection as a force in fungal microevolution with special reference to clonal speciation and hybrid introgression. Canadian Journal of Botany 73(Suppl. l ) , S1213-S1221. Brown. J. K . M. (1995). Recombination and selection in populations of plant pathogens. Plant Pathology 44, 279-293. Brown, J. K. M., Jessop, A. C. and Rezanoor, H. N. (1991). Genetic uniformity in barley and its powdery mildew pathogen. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London, Series B Biological Sciences 246, 83-90. Burdon, J . J. (1992). Host population subdivision and the genetic structure of natural pathogen populations. Advances in Plant Pathology 8, 81-94. Burdon, J. J. and Roelfs, A. P. (1985). Isozyme and virulence variation in asexually reproducing populations of Puccinia graminis and P. recondita on wheat. Phytopathology 75, 907-913. Burdon, J. J . , Marshall, D. R., Luig, N. H. and Gow, D. J. S. (1982). Isozyme studies on the origin and evolution of Puccinia graminis f. sp. tritici in Australia. Australian Journal of Biological Science 35, 231-238. Chen, R.-S., Boeger, J. M. and McDonald, B. A. (1994). Genetic stability in a population of a plant pathogenic fungus over time. Molecular Ecology 3, 209-2 18. Correll, J. C. (1991). The relationship between forma speciales, races, and vegetative compatibility groups in Fusarium oxysporum. Phytopathology 81, 1061-1064. Correll, J. C., Gordon, T. R. and McCain, A. H. (1992). Genetic diversity in California and Florida of the pitch canker fungus Fusarium subglutinans f. sp. pini. Phytopathology 82, 415-420. Crute, I. R. (1989). Lettuce downy mildew: a case study in integrated control. In “Plant Disease Epidemiology”, Vol. 2 (K. J . Leonard and W. E. Fry, eds), pp. 30-53. McGraw-Hill, New York. Crute, I. R. (1992). The role of resistance breeding in the integrated control of downy mildew, Bremia luctucae, in protected lettuce. Euphytica 63, 95-102. Davidse, L. C., Looijen, D., Turkensteen, L. J. and Van der Wal, D. (1981). Occurrence of metalaxyl-resistant strains of Phytophthora infestans in Dutch potato fields. Netherlands Journal of Plant Pathology 87, 65-68. Davis, J . M. and Main, C . E. (1988). Applying atmospheric trajectory analysis to problems in epidemiology. Plant Disease 70, 49W97. Deahl, K. L . , DeMuth, S. P., Sinden, S. L. and Rivera-Pena, A. (1995). Identification of mating types and metalaxyl resistance in North America populations of Phytophthora infestans. American Potato Journal 72, 35-49. Deahl, K. L., Inglis, D. A. and DeMuth, S. P. (1993). Testing for resistance to metalaxyl in Phytophthora infestans isolates from northwestern Washington. American Potato Journal 70, 779-795. De Waard, M. A. and Van Nistelrooy, J. G. M. (1990). Stepwise development of laboratory resistance to DMI-fungicides in Penicilliurn italicurn. Netherlands Journal of Plant Pathology 96, 321-329.
26
M. G . MILGROOM and W. E. FRY
Drenth, A., Tas, I. C. Q . and Govers, F. (1994). DNA fingerprinting uncovers a new sexually reproducing population of Phytophthora infestans in the Netherlands. European Journal of Plant Pathology 100, 97-107. Drenth, A., Janssen, E. M. and Govers, F. (1995). Formation and survival of oospores of Phytophthora infestans under natural conditions. Plant Pathology 44, 86-94. Ennos, R. A. and McConnell, K. C. (1995). Using genetic markers to investigate natural selection in fungal populations. Canadian Journal of Botany 73(Suppl. l), S302-S310. Fenner, F. and Myers, K. (1978). Myxoma virus and myxomatosis in retrospect: the first quarter century of a new disease. I n “Viruses and Environment”, 3rd International Conference on Comparative Virology, Mont Gabriel, Quebec (E. Kurstak and K. Maramorosch, eds), pp. 539-570. Academic Press, New York. Fisher, R. A. (1930). “The Genetical Theory of Natural Selection.” Clarendon Press, Oxford. Fry, W. E., Goodwin, S. B., Matuszak, J. M., Spielman, L. J., Milgroom, M. G. and Drenth, A. (1992). Population genetics and intercontinental migrations of Phytophthora infestans. Annual Review of Phytopathology 30, 107-129. Fry, W. E., Goodwin, S. B., Dyer, A. T., Matuszak, J. M., Drenth, A., Tooley, P. W., Sujkowski, L. S . , Koh, Y. J., Cohen, B. A., Spielman, L. J., Deahl, K. L., Inglis, D. A. and Sandlan, K. P. (1993). Historical and recent migrations of Phytophthora infestans: chronoIogy, pathways, and implications. Plant Disease 17, 653-661. Goodwin, S. B., Allard, R. W., Hardy, S. A. and Webster, R. K. (1992a). Hierarchical structure of pathogenic variation among Rhynchosporium secalis populations in Idaho and Oregon. Canadian Journal of Botany 70, 810-817. Goodwin, S. B., Spielman, L. J., Matuszak, J. M., Bergeron, S. N. and Fry, W. E. (1992b). Clonal diversity and genetic differentiation of Phytophthora infesrans populations in northern and central Mexico. Phytopathology 82, 955-961. Goodwin, S. B., Saghai-Maroof, M. A., Allard, R. W. and Webster, R. K. (1993). Isozyme variation within and among populations of Rhynchosporium secalis in Europe, Australia and the United States. Mycological Research 97, 49-58. Goodwin, S. B., Cohen, B. A., Deahl, K. L. and Fry, W. E. (1994a). Migration from northern Mexico was the probable cause of recent genetic changes in populations of Phytophthora infestans in the United States and Canada. Phytopathology 84, 553-558. Goodwin, S. B., Cohen, B. A. and Fry, W. E. (1994b). Panglobal distribution of a single clonal lineage of the Irish potato famine fungus. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA 91, 11591-11595. Goodwin, S. B., Schneider, R. E. and Fry, W. W. (1995a). Cellulose-acetate electrophoresis provides rapid identification of allozyme genotypes of Phytophthora infestans. Plant Disease 79, 1181-1185. Goodwin, S. B., Sujkowski, L. S., Dyer, A. T., Fry, B. A. and Fry, W. E. (1995b). Direct detection of gene flow and probable sexual reproduction of Phytophthora infestans in northern North America. Phytopathology 85, 473-479. Goodwin, S. B., Sujkowski, L. S. and Fry, W. E. (1995~).Rapid evolution of pathogenicity within clonal lineages of the potato late blight disease fungus. Phytopathology 85, 669-676. Gordon, T. R., Okamoto, D. and Milgroom, M. G. (1992). The structure and interrelationship of fungal populations in native and cultivated soils. Molecular Ecology 1, 241-249.
GENETICS AND PLANT DISEASE EPIDEMIOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT
27
Hohl, H. R. and Iselin, K. (1984). Strains of Phytophthora infestans from Switzerland with A2 mating type behaviour. Transactions of the British Mycological Society 83, 529-530. Hovmdler, M. S. and 0sterglrd, H. (1991). Gametic disequilibria between virulence genes in barley powdery mildew populations in relation to selection and recombination. 11. Danish observations. Plant Pathology 40, 178-189. Hovmdler, M. S., Munk, L. and Bsterglrd, H. (1993). Observed and predicted changes in virulence gene frequencies at 11loci in a local barley powdery mildew population. Phytopathology 83, 253-260. Huber, D. H. and Fulbright, D. W. (1994). Preliminary investigations on the effect of individual vic genes upon the transmission of dsRNA in Cryphonectria parasitica. In “Proceeding of the International Chestnut Conference”, 1&14 July 1992 (M. L. Double and W. L. MacDonald, eds), pp. 15-19. West Virginia University Press, Morgantown, VA. Kistler, H. C., Momol, E. A. and Benny, U. (1991). Repetitive genomic sequences for determining relatedness among strains of Fusarium oxysporum. PhytopatholOgy 81, 331-336. Knott, D. R. (1986). The genetic structure of populations of Puccinia graminis f. sp. tritici. Phytopathology 76, 1149-1 151. Koenraadt, H. and Jones, A. L. (1992). The use of allele-specific oligonucleotide probes to characterize resistance to benomyl in field strains of Venturia inaequalis. Phytopathology 82, 1354-1358. Koenraadt, H., Somerville, S. C. and Jones, A . L. (1992). Characterization of mutations in the beta-tubulin gene of benomyl-resistant field strains of Venturia inaequalis and other plant pathogenic fungi. Phytopathology 82, 1348-1354. Kohli, Y., Moral], T. A. A., Anderson, J. B. and Kohn, L. M. (1992). Local and trans-Canadian clonal distribution of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum on canola. Phytopathology 82, 875-880. Kohn, L. M. (1995). The clonal dynamic in wild and agricultural plant pathogen populations. Canadian Journal of Botany 73(Suppl. l ) , S1231-S1240. Kohn, L. M., Stasovski, E., Carbone, I., Royer, J. and Anderson, J. B. (1991). Mycelial incompatibility and molecular markers identify genetic variability in field populations of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum. Phytopathology 81, 480485. Koller, W., Smith, F. D., Reynolds, K. L., Wilcox, W. F. and Burr, J. A. (1995). Seasonal changes of sensitivities to sterol demethylation inhibitors in Venturia inaequalis populations. Mycological Research 99, 689-692. Kolmer, J. A. (1989). Virulence and race dynamics of Puccinia recondita f. sp. tritici in Canada during 1956-1987. Phytopathology 79, 349-356. Krebs, C. J. (1985). “Ecology”, 3rd edn. Harper & Row, New York. Kumar, J., Nelson, R. J. and Zeigler, R. S. (1995). Population analysis of Magnaporthe grisea at a high diversity site in the Himalayas. Phytopathology 85, 1132 (abstract). Lalancette, N., Jr, Russo, J. M. and Hickey, K. D. (1984). A simple device for sampling spores to monitor fungicide resistance in the field. Phytopathology 74, 1423-1425. Legard, D. E., Lee, T. Y. and Fry, W. E. (1995). Pathogenic specialization in Phytophthora infestans: aggressiveness on tomato. Phytopathology 85, 13561361. Leonard, K. J . (1978). Polymorphisms for lesion type, fungicide tolerance, and mating capacity in Cochliobolus carbonum isolates pathogenic to corn. Canadian Journal of Botany 56, 1809-1815. Leonard, K. J. and Fry, W. E. (eds) (1989). “Plant Disease Epidemiology: Genetics,
28
M. G . MILGROOM and W. E. FRY
Resistance and Management”, Vol. 2. McGraw-Hill, New York. Leslie, J. F. (1995). Gibberella fujikuroi: available populations and variable traits. Canadian Journal of Botany 73(Suppl. l), S282-S291. Leung, H. and Williams, P. H. (1986). Enzyme polymorphism and genetic differentiation among geographic isolates of the rice blast fungus. Phytopathology 76, 778-783. Leung, H., Nelson, R. J . and Leach, J. E. (1993). Population structure of plant pathogenic fungi and bacteria. Advances in Plant Pathology 10, 157-205. Levy, M., Correa-Victoria, F. J., Zeigler, R. S., Xu, S. and Hamer, J. E. (1993). Genetic diversity of the rice blast fungus in a disease nursery in Colombia. Phytopathology 83, 1427-1433. Levy, M . , Romao, J . , Marchetti, M. A. and Hamer, J . E. (1991). DNA fingerprinting with dispersed repeated sequence resolves pathotype diversity in the rice blast fungus. Plant Cell 3, 95-102. Liu, Y.-C. and Milgroom, M. G . (1996). Correlation between hypovirus transmission and the number of vegetative incompatibility (vic) genes different among isolates from a natural population of Cryphonectria parasitica. Phytopathology 86, 79-86. Liu, Y.-C., Cortesi, P., Double, M. L., MacDonald, W. L. and Milgroom, M. G. (1996). Diversity and multilocus genetic structure in populations of Cryphonectria parasitica. Phytopathology (in press). Matuszak, J . M., Goodwin, S. B., Fry, W. E. andvillarreal-Gonzalez, M. J. (1990). Changes in the genetic diversity of Phytophthora infestans during an epidemic in central Mexico as determined by DNA fingerprints. Phytopathology 80, 965 (abstract). McDermott, J. M. and McDonald, B. A. (1993). Gene flow in plant pathosystems. Annual Review of Phytopathology 31, 353-373. McDonald, B. A. and McDermott, J. M. (1993). Population genetics of plant pathogenic fungi. BioScience 43, 311-319. McDonald, B. A., Miles, J . , Nelson, L. R. and Pettway, R. E. (1994). Genetic variability in nuclear DNA in field populations of Stagonospora nodorum. Phytopathology 84, 250-255. McDonald, B. A., Pettway, R. E., Chen, R. S., Boeger, J . M. and Martinez, J. P. (1995). The population genetics of Septoria tritici (teleomorph Mycosphaerella graminicola). Canadian Journal of Botany 73(Suppl. l), S292-S301. Michelmore, R. W., Paran, I. and Kesseli, R. V. (1991). Identification of markers linked to disease-resistance genes by bulked segregant analysis: a rapid method to detect markers in specific genomic regions by using segregating populations. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA 88, 9828-9832. Milgroom, M. G. (1995a). Analysis of population structure in fungal plant pathogens. In “Disease Analysis through Genetics and Molecular Biology: Interdisciplinary Bridges to Improved Sorghum and Millet Crops” (J. F. Leslie and R. A. Frederiksen, eds), pp. 213-229. Iowa State University Press, Ames, IA. Milgroom, M. G. (1995b). Population biology of the chestnut blight fungus, Cryphonectria parasitica. Canadian Journal of Botany 73(Suppl. l), S311S319. Milgroom, M. G. (1996). Recombination and the multilocus structure of fungal populations. Annual Review of Phytopathology 34, 457477. Milgroom, M. G. and Lipari, S. E. (1995). Population differentiation in the chestnut blight fungus, Cryphonectria parasitica, in eastern North America. PhytopatholOgy 85, 155-160. Milgroom, M. G., Levin, S. A. and Fry, W. E. (1989). Population genetics theory
GENETICS AND PLANT DISEASE EPIDEMIOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT
29
and fungicide resistance. In “Plant Disease Epidemiology”, Vol. 2 (K. J . Leonard and W. E. Fry, eds), pp. 340-367. McGraw-Hill, New York. Milgroom, M. G . , Lipari, S. E. and Powell, W. A. (1992a). DNA fingerprinting and analysis of population structure in the chestnut blight fungus, Cryphonectria parasitica. Genetics 131, 297-306. Milgroom, M. G., Lipari, S. E. and Wang, K. (1992b). Comparison of genetic diversity in the chestnut blight fungus, Cryphonectria (Endothia) parasitica from China and the US. Mycological Research 96, 1114-1120. Bsterglrd, H. and Hovmejller, M. S. (1991). Gametic disequilibria between virulence genes in barley powdery mildew populations in relation to selection and recombination. I. Models. Planr Pathology 40, 166-177. Peever, T. L. and Milgroom, M. G. (1992). Inheritance of triadimenol resistance in Pyrenophora teres. Phytopathology 82, 821-828. Peever, T. L. and Milgroom, M. G . (1993). Genetic correlations in resistance to sterol biosynthesis-inhibiting fungicides in Pyrenophora teres. Phytopathology 83, 1076-1082. Peever, T. L. and Milgroom, M. G. (1994a). Lack of correlation between fitness and resistance to sterol biosynthesis-inhibiting fungicides in Pyrenophora teres. Phytopathology 84, 5 15-5 19. Peever, T. L. and Milgroom, M. G. (1994b). Genetic structure of Pyrenophora teres populations determined with RAPD markers. Canadian Journal of Botany 72, 9 15-923. Pianka, E. R. (1988). “Evolutionary Ecology”, 4th edn. Harper & Row, New York. Polashock, J. J., Anagnostakis, S . L., Milgroom, M. G. and Hillman, B. I. (1994). Isolation and characterization of a virus-resistant mutant of the chestnut blight fungus. Current Genetics 26, 528-534. Puhalla, J . E. (1985). Classification of strains of Fusarium oxysporum on the basis of vegetative compatibility. Canadian Journal of Botany 63, 179-183. Rivera-Pena, A . and Molina-Galan, J. (1989). Wild tuber-bearing species of Solanum and incidence of Phytophthora infestans (Mont.) de Bary on the western slopes of the volcano Nevado de Toluca. 1. Solanum species. Potato Research 32, 181-195. Roelfs, A. P. (1985). Epidemiology in North America. In “The Cereal Rusts”, Vol. 2 (W. R. Bushnell and A. P. Roelfs, eds), pp. 403-434. Academic Press, New York. Roelfs, A. P. and Groth, J. V. (1980). A comparison of virulence phenotypes in wheat stem rust populations reproducing sexually and asexually. Phytopathology 70, 855-862. Shah, D., Bergstrom, G. B. and Ueng, P. P. (1995). Initiation of Septoria nodorum blotch epidemics in winter wheat by seedborne Stagnospora nodorum. Phytopathotogy 85, 452-457. Shaw, M. W. and Royle, D. J. (1989). Airborne inoculum as a major source of Septoria tritici (Mycosphaerella graminicola) infections in winter wheat crops in the UK. Plant Pathology 38, 35-41. Sierotzki, H., Eggenschwiler, M., Boillat, O., McDermott, J. M. and Gessler, C. (1994). Detection of variation in virulence toward susceptible apple cultivars in natural populations of Venturia inaequalis. Phytopathology 84, 1000-1009. Slatkin, M. (1987). Gene flow and the geographic structure of natural populations. Science 236, 787-792. Smith, F. D., Parker, D. M. and Koller, W. (1991). Sensitivity distribution of Venturia inaequalis to the sterol demethylation inhibitor flusilazole: baseline sensitivity ~~
~
30
M. G . MILGROOM and W. E. FRY
and implications for resistance monitoring. Phytopathology 81, 392-396. Spitze, K. (1993). Population structure in Daphnia obtusa: quantitative genetic and allozyme variation. Genetics 135, 367-374. Stenlid, J. (1985). Population structure of Heterobasidion annosum as determined by somatic incompatibility, sexual incompatibility, and isoenzyme patterns. Canadian Journal of Botany 63, 2268-2273. Sujkowski, L. S., Goodwin, S . B., Dyer, A. T. and Fry, W. E. (1994). Increased genotypic diversity via migration and possible occurrence of sexual reproduction of Phytophthora infestans in Poland. Phytopathology 84, 201-207. Tooley, P. W., Fry, W. E. and Villarreal Gonzalez, M. J. (1985). Isozyme characterization of sexual and asexual Phytophthora infestans populations. Journal of Heredity 76, 431-435. Vanderplank, J. E. (1963). “Plant Diseases: Epidemics and Control.” Academic Press, New York. Vanderplank, J. E. (1982). “Host-Pathogen Interactions in Plant Disease.” Academic Press, New York. Vilgalys, R. and Cubeta, M. A . (1994). Molecular systematics and population biology of Rhizoctonia. Annual Review of Phytopathology 32, 135-155. Webber, J. F., Brasier, C. M. and Mitchell, A. G. (1987). The role of the saprophytic phase in Dutch elm disease. In “Fungal Infection of Plants” (G. F. Pegg and P. G . Ayres, eds), pp. 298-313. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Wolfe, M. S. and Caten, C. E. (eds) (1987). “Populations of Plant Pathogens: Their Dynamics and Genetics.” Blackwell, Oxford. Wolfe, M. S. and Knott, D. R. (1982). Populations of plant pathogens: some constraints on analysis of variation in pathogenicity. Plant Pathology 31, 79-90. Wolfe, M. S. and McDermott, J. M. (1994). Population genetics of plant-pathogen interactions: the example of the Erysiphe graminis-Hordeum vulgare pathosystem. Annual Review of Phytopathology 32, 89-1 13. Zeigler, R. S . , Cuoc, L. X., Scott, R. P., Bernardo, M. A., Chen, D. H., Valent, B. and Nelson, R. J. (1995). The relationship between lineage and virulence in Pyricularia grisea in the Philippines. Phytopathofogy 85, 44-51.
A Molecular View Through the Looking Glass: the Pyrenopeziza brassicae-Brasska Interaction
A . M . ASHBY
Department of Plant Sciences. University of Cambridge. Downing Street. Cambridge CB2 3EA. UK
...........................................................................
32
I1 . The P. brassicae-Brassica Interaction ......................................... A . The Fungus ..................................................................... B . Pathogenesis .................................................................... C . Sexual Morphogenesis ....................................................... D . Disease Epidemiology .......................................................
32 32 33 33 34
111. Molecular Techniques in the Analysis of the P . brassicae-Brassica Interaction .............................................................................
38
I . Introduction
IV . Molecular Analysis of Pathogenesis ........................................... A . Surface Growth and Penetration: the Role of Cutinase .......... B . Subcuticular Growth: the Role of Protease ........................... C . Using Reporter Genes to Measure Fungal Biomass In Pfanra . . D . Proposed Role of Extracellular Protease in Pathogenicity ....... E . Implications for Disease Control .........................................
40
V. Analysis of the Hemibiotrophic Phase: the Role of Cytokinins ....... A . Biochemical Analysis of Cytokinin Production by P . brassicae . B . Molecular Analysis of P . brassicae Cytokinins ....................... C . The Role of Cytokinins in Pathogenicity .............................. D . Implications for Disease Control .........................................
47
VI . Analysis of Sexual Morphogenesis ............................................. A . Biochemical Analysis: Identification of a Post-Mating Factor ... B . Molecular Analysis ........................................................... C . Sexual Morphogenesis in P . brassicae: a Speculative Summary . D . Implications ....................................................................
51
Advances in Botanical Research Vol . 24 incorporating Advances in Plant Pathology ISBN &12-005924-X
41 42 45
47 47 49 49
51 51 52
53 58 60
Copyright @ 1997 Academic Press Limited All rights of reproduction in any form resewed
32
A. M. ASHBY
VII. A Molecular View through the Looking-glass: the P. brassicaeBrassica Interaction .................................................................
60
VIII. Concluding Remarks ............................................................... Acknowledgements ................................................................. References ............................................................................
65 65 65
I. INTRODUCTION Molecular biology has had a profound influence on all of the biological sciences. Over the last decade the use of molecular techniques in plant pathology has advanced to such a degree that we are now able to analyse complex plant-microbe interactions at the molecular level and to establish the role of certain genes and gene products in these interactions. This approach, encompassing biochemistry, molecular biology and conventional plant pathology, involves the dissection of an interaction into its component parts and investigates how the manipulation of these component parts may alter the interaction as “a whole”. This type of multidisciplinary approach will lead to great advances in our understanding of plant pathology in the decade to come. We are using such an approach to address three key questions concerning the Pyrenopeziza brassicae-Brassica interaction: 1. How does P. brassicae pathogenize Brassica species? 2. How does P. brassicae derive nutrients from host tissue during its biotrophic phase of growth? 3. What are the mechanisms controlling sexual morphogenesis in P. brassicae? By addressing and beginning to obtain answers to these questions through molecular analysis, a greater understanding of this fungus-host interaction will be realized, which will ultimately allow the development of novel strategies for controlling light leaf spot disease of brassicas. This review focuses initially on our understanding of the P. brassicae-Brassica interaction from a conventional plant pathological standpoint. Current progress on the use of molecular and biochemical techniques to analyse pathogenicity and sexual morphogenesis are then discussed and, finally, using the information gained from our molecular analyses together with a little speculation, a view of the interaction “through the molecular looking-glass’’ is proposed.
11. THE P. BRASSICAE-BRASSZCA INTERACTION A. THEFUNGUS
Pyrenopeziza brassicae Sutton and Rawlinson (anamorph Cylindrosporium concentricum) is a haploid, heterothallic discomycete and is the cause of light
PYR E N 0 PEZIZA BRASSICA E-B RASSICA INTERACTION
33
leaf spot disease of brassicas, which is considered one of the most damaging diseases of winter oilseed rape (Brassica napus L. subsp. ofeifera (Metzger) sink) in the UK (Lacey et al., 1987; Yarman and Giltrap, 1989; Hardwick et al., 1991). B . PATHOGENESIS
During pathogenesis the fungus displays a mode of nutrition characteristic of the hemibiotrophic plant pathogens within the Ascomycotina. After spore germination and initial infection (Fig. lA), a biotrophic phase of growth within the host is established. Here a relatively balanced physiological relationship exists between host and pathogen, and only limited visible signs of infection are evident (Courtice et a f . , 1988). These include thickening and stiffening of infected tissue and the formation of “green islands”, which result from the redirection of host nutrients to the site of infection leading to preferential retention of chlorophyll around the lesion as a consequence of growth substance imbalance (Maddock, 1979). During this early phase of development, the fungus obtains all its nutritional requirements from the plant, but little is known about how this is achieved. The first and most characteristic visible symptom of the disease is the formation of minute, snow-white spots erupting through the leaf surface. Each spot or conidiomata consists of numerous, unicellular, cylindrical spores, formed within the host in an acervulus beneath the cuticle (Fig. 1B,C). Sporulation ultimately results in rupture of the cuticle, with the lesion enlarging in a concentric fashion (Fig. 1D). The central chlorotic region becomes cracked and blistered, possibly as a result of toxin production by the fungus or simply as a result of separation of the cuticular layer from the upper epidermal membrane, rendering the lower surface susceptible to desiccation. In cases of severe infection the lesions will coalesce and infected areas may eventually wither and die. Asexual conidia are then dispersed to other susceptible hosts primarily by rain-splash, although atmospheric dispersal of conidia is possible (McCartney el al., 1986). C. SEXUAL MORPHOGENESIS
P. brussicae is heterothallic, having two mating types designated MAT 1-1 and MAT 1-2 (Mot et al., 1984). Reproduction occurs by two mutually exclusive pathways of development (Fig. 2). In the absence of a compatible mating type, spores germinate and differentiate by a process of enteroblastic conidiation to form asexual conidia (Fig. 1C). Conversely, in the presence of the opposite mating-type, an early interaction of opposite mating type hyphae results in suppression of asexual sporulation and initiation of a complex, co-ordinated, pathway of development culminating in the formation
34
A. M. ASHBY
of apothecia (Fig. 3A-F). The fungus is competent to undergo sexual development during the first 6 days of conidial growth. After this period commitment to asexual sporulation is irreversibly established. Early interaction between opposite mating types is therefore required for successful induction of the sexual cycle, after which hyphae are destined to reproduce asexually (Illot, 1984; Siddiq, 1989; Ashby, unpublished observations). The production of fertile ascocarps in vitro was first described by Maddock and Ingram (1981), and subsequently the sexual system has been used to analyse fungicide-resistant, auxotrophic and pathogenicity mutants (Illot et al., 1987; Courtice et al., 1988; Ball et al., 1991a,b). The clear delineation of this state is now an important marker for a molecular analysis of sexual morphogenesis and pathogenicity in the fungus (Ball et al., 1991b; Ashby and Johnstone, 1994). The teleomorph of the fungus has been shown to occur naturally on oilseed rape in the UK and Ireland (Staunton and Kavanagh, 1966; Lacey et al., 1987; McCartney and Lacey, 1990) and is commonly found on vegetable brassicas in New Zealand (Cheah and Hartill, 1985). A survey of isolates of P . brassicae from 27 winter oilseed rape crops in East Anglia in 1987 revealed that both mating types were represented amongst the isolates from 74% of the fields tested, suggesting that there is a possibility that the teleomorphic stage may appear regularly (Ball et al., 1990). D. DISEASE EPIDEMIOLOGY
Oilseed rape is now a well-established and important “break crop”, and the increased acreage under cultivation may potentiaIly act as a source of wind-borne inoculum of light leaf spot disease of other brassica crops (Gladders, 1984). Most damage occurs after severe infection of new oilseed rape crops by P. brassicae in the autumn, although visible symptoms often go unnoticed until the following spring (Jeffery et al., 1989). Recent work by Figueroa et al. (1995) using a number of isolates of P. brassicae and a range of double-low (low erucic acid and low glucosinolate) cultivars of Brassica napus, demonstrated that low-temperature regimes increased both the incubation period (the time from inoculation until 50% of the lesions were produced) and the latent period (the time until the first lesion with
Fig. 1. Scanning electron micrographs illustrating the pathogenesis of P. brassicae. (A) Hyphae of P.brassicae JH26 (MAT 1-2) germinatingon a leaf surface and growing subcuticularly within B. napus (L. ssp. oleifera cv. Shogun). (B) An acervular conidioma rupturing the epidermis. (C) Enteroblastic conidiation (scale bar represents 10prn). (D) Typical symptoms induced in planta and signifying the late stages of infection; concentric rings of erumpant conidiornata surrounding a central necrotic lesion (scale bar represents 12mm). S. Batish, K . Johnstone and A . Ashby, unpublished observations.
36
A. M.ASHBY
Fig. 2. Mutually exclusive pathways of development in P. brussicue and the proposed role of sex factor (SF) in controlling these pathways. Open and closed conidia depict different mating types of the fungus. The sex factor inhibits asexual sporulation, resulting in all available resources being diverted into fuelling sexual morphogenesis. From Ashby and Johnstone (1994).
acervuli appeared) of infection and also decreased the rate at which conidia were able to germinate. The low temperatures prevailing during the winter months may therefore account for the decrease in the rate of progression of epidemics of light leaf spot disease on oilseed rape. However, it is equally probable that the incidence and severity of the disease during the winter months of some years may be sufficiently low to go unnoticed (Figueroa et al., 1995). The significance of light leaf spot is such that substantial reductions in green leaf area and plant dry weight at flowering were observed when fungicide applications were delayed, resulting in a 46% loss of seed yield (Jeffery et al., 1994).
Fig. 3. Sexual morphogenesis in P. brussicue. (A) Scanning electron micrograph (SEM) showing the interaction between JH26 (MATl-2) and NHlO (MAT1-1) after 4 days (scale bar represents 100pm). T. Cole and A. Ashby, unpublished observations. (B) Mycelia of a MAT 1-1GUS isolate (NHlOpNOM102/18) interacting with wild type MAT 1-2 (JH26) mycelia after 4 days on CMM medium stained with X-Gluc (scale bar represents 1 mm). Reproduced from Ashby and Johnstone (1994). (C) SEM showing a mature fertile apothecium from a cross of JH26 and NHlO (scale bar represents 100pm). T. Cole and A. Ashby, unpublished observations. (D) Crushed apothecium from a cross of a GUS transformant of P. brassicae MAT 1-2 (JH26pNOM102/4) and a wild-type MAT 1-1 isolate (NH10). The apothecia were stained with X-Gluc to show the differential contribution made by each mating type to fruiting body formation (scale bar represents 25 pm). Reproduced from Ashby and Johnstone (1993). (E, F) SEMs showing magnification of the apothecium to reveal the ectal explicium (E), paraphyses (P) and asci (A) (scale bar represents 10 pm). T. Cole and A. Ashby, unpublished observations.
P YRENOPEZIZA BRASSICAE-BRASSICA INTERACTION
37
38
A. M. ASHBY
Annual crop losses in the UK have recently been estimated at over 25 million (Thomas and Walker, 1994). The disease has greatest impact in oilseed rape crops sown in consecutive years (Figueroa et al., 1994), which suggests that inoculum may be carried over from one season to the next on infected rape stubble as well as volunteer plants, probably as a result of overwintering by the teleomorphic stage (McCartney and Lacey, 1990). It has also been suggested that the release of ascospores from apothecia may provide an important inoculum source later in the season, reducing the efficacy of fungicide application (Figueroa et al., 1994). The occurrence of wind-borne ascospores sheds new light on disease dissemination, and, in particular, the fact that P. brassicae has, by this route, the potential to spread beyond the immediate vicinity of oilseed rape into other brassica crops, thus providing an effective mechanism for continuing infection from season to season. Occurrence of the sexual stage provides the opportunity for enhagced genetic variability which may affect both pathogenicity and the development of tolerance to fungicides. Such factors are likely to become more predominant as oilseed rape is exploited by more intensive agricultural practice (Maddock and Ingram, 1981). A survey carried out by Maddock et al. (1981) revealed considerable heterogeneity of resistance between a range of brassica varieties and subspecies. This was the case both between cultivars within these groups and between individuals of a single cultivar. Although differential interactions between cultivars and isolates were shown, they were not sufficiently defined to establish clear physiological races of the pathogen. It has been suggested that as agricultural exploitation of the host proceeds, as a result of breeding for resistance, P. brassicae may face more selection pressure than ever before and that by monitoring changes in the population of P. brassicae it may be possible to follow the evolution of a host-pathogen relationship from a state of relatively balanced coexistence (Maddock et al., 1981). To this end, Simons and Skidmore were able to demonstrate that a differential interaction between several host genotypes of Brassica oleracea and P. brassicae isolates can occur and that resistance to P. brassicae appears, in most cases, to be expressed as a dominant character (Simons and Skidmore, 1988). A survey of host-pathogen interactions is required, allowing a differential set of host cultivars to be defined for the identification of key virulence factors in P. brassicae.
111. MOLECULAR TECHNIQUES IN THE ANALYSIS OF THE P. BRASSICA E-BRASSICA INTERACTION Over the last decade a range of molecular techniques has been developed for analysing the P. brassicae interaction (Table I; Skidmore et al., 1984; Ashby and Johnstone, 1994). The extraction of high-molecular-weight DNA is an essential prerequisite for the cloning of fungal genes. Using the method of Raeder and Broda (1985) up to 1pg DNA per milligram of fungal tissue
TABLE I Molecular techniques developed to analyse the P. brassicae-Brassica interaction Molecular technique Generation of mutants DNA extraction Fungal transformation Co-transformation Reporter genes GUS Luciferase Genomic library complementation cDNA library construction Differential display PCR AFLP analysis
Status in P. brassicae research Auxotrophic Pathogenicity Developmental 1 p g per mg dry weight 2-200 transformants per pg DNA 70% co-transformation with pAN7-1 Mitotically stable GUS transformants
4 luciferase vectors for expression in fungi have been constructed Auxotrophic mutants Pathogenicity mutants Developmental mutants Sex factor induced in preparation Casein induced Technique currently being developed for P. brassicae Analysis of P. brassicae population substructure
Reference Courtice and Ingram (1987) Ball et al. (1991b) Siddiq et nl. (1992) Ball et al. (1991a) Ball et al. (1991a) Ashby and Johnstone (1993)
0
2
5 !2 ta
a
R
Ashby and Johnstone (1993) 7 M. Chadwick and A. Ashby (unpublished observations) Ball et al. (1991a) Ball et al. (1991b) Ashby and Johnstone (1994) M. Robb (unpublished observations) A. J. Clark (unpublished observations) ga A. J. Clark (unpublished observations) @
z R
3 2
Majer et a1 (1995)
E
40
A. M. ASHBY
with a molecular weight >50 kDa is obtained (Ball et al., 1991a). There are several vectors available for fungal transformation, but those most suitable for this system are the PAN series of vectors (Punt et al., 1987). Both PAN 7-1 and PAN 7-2 are shuttle vectors which encode ampicillin resistance for expression in Escherichia coli and carry the hygromycin B-phosphotransferase gene flanked by the gpd promoter and trp C terminator sequences from Aspergillus for expression in the fungus. Since P. brassicae is highly sensitive to hygromycin (growth is inhibited at concentrations above 5 pg ml-’) these vectors were useful in establishing a transformation system for this fungus. A third vector, pNOM102 (Roberts et al., 1989) based on the PAN vectors but containing a P-glucuronidase gene under the control of a constitutive promoter, has been used as a reporter gene in P. brassicae (Ashby and Johnstone, 1993). A second reporter gene vector has been constructed based on “click beetle” luciferases (Chadwick and Ashby, unpublished observations). There are four luciferases, each emitting light at a different wavelength (Wood et al., 1989). Each of the four click beetle cDNAs was cloned into pAN52-1 (Punt et al., 1987) and they are currently being evaluated as reporter genes in P. brassicae and other fungi. Using such reporter genes in combination will enable both spatial and temporal expression of a number of fungal genes to be analysed at any one time. Fungal protoplasts can be prepared by a method based on that of Yelton et al. (1984), and are transformed using a modified method of Vollmer and Yanofsky (1986), as described by Ball et al. (1991a). Transformation frequencies in the region of 50 transformants per microgram of transforming DNA are routinely achieved. A genomic library has been constructed in pAN7-2 and used successfully in transformation experiments to complement auxotrophic mutants to restored prototrophy (Ball et al., 1991a), a protease positive pathogenic phenotype to a protease negative non-pathogenic m:itant (Ball et al., 1991b; see section IVB) and a sex factor responsive fertile phenotype to a sexual development mutant (Ashby and Johnstone, 1994; see section VIB). cDNA libraries have also been constructed (M. Robb and A. Clark, unpublished observations; Table I). Recently, the technique of amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) analysis has been developed to study both P. brassicae population substructure and the evolution of a relationship between P. brassicae and B . napus (Majer et al., 1995).
IV. MOLECULAR ANALYSIS OF PATHOGENESIS With a view to understanding the complexities of plant-microbe interactions, the “molecular dialogue” between pathogens and their hosts has been intensively studied over the last decade. For biotrophic and hemibiotrophic plant pathogens, a number of criteria have to be met to establish successful pathogenesis. Pathogenicity factors must be expressed to enable penetration of host tissue by mechanical or enzymatic degradation and to allow the
PYRENOPEZIZA BRASSICAE-BRASSICA INTERACTION
41
ingressing pathogen to access nutrients from the host without initiating any visible disease symptoms. The successful biotrophic pathogen must also resist activating host defence mechanisms which may result in a hypersensitive reaction (HR), thereby culminating in localized cell death and the consequent localization of the pathogen. Since P. brassicae lacks a clear race structure and no differential interaction with the host is evident, the fungus does not appear to elicit an H R response. The fungus does, however, appear enzymatically to degrade the cuticle prior to ingress (Maddock, 1979), and recently, and in view of the controversy surrounding the role of cutinase in the pathogenicity of Fusarium solani f. sp. pisi on pea (Stahl and Schifer, 1992; Rogers et al., 1994), we have begun to analyse the role of an extracellular cutinase in penetration of B. napus by P. brassicae. The importance of cell-wall-degrading enzymes in pathogenesis is well documented (Cooper, 1984). An initial strategy to look for such determinants in the P. brassicae interaction involved screening UV mutants of P. brassicae for deficiencies in cell-wall-degrading enzyme production. Mutants that were deficient in endopolygalacturonase (EndoPG), pectin methyl esterase (PME) and protease production in vitro were also found to be non-pathogenic in detached cotyledon tests (Ball et al., 1991b). Our research has focused primarily on the role of the protease in pathogenicity (see sections IVB and IVD).
A . SURFACE GROWTH AND PENETRATION: THE ROLE OF CUTINASE
Suspensions of conidia of P. brassicae artificially inoculated onto a leaf surface tend to be deposited preferentially over the anticlinal walls of epidermal cells (Rawlinson et al. , 1978). Upon germination conidia become septate forming relatively short germ tubes, which may swell slightly at the apex prior to penetration. Appressoria are never formed and hyphae d o not enter through stomata but directly penetrate through the cuticle. From microscopical analysis showing sites of pathogen ingress it appears that enzymatic degradation of the cuticle may be important in facilitating penetration (Maddock, 1979). P. brassicae has been shown to produce methyl esterase activity (Ball, 1989) and quantification of enzyme production was obtained by hydrolysis of p-nitrophenylbutyrate. Degradation of tritiated cutin confirmed that this activity was consistent with that of a cutinase (K. Davies, unpublished observations). The cutinase was also inhibited by PMSF, and ebelactones A and B (A. Jones and K. Davies, unpublished observations). Identification of the cutinase gene(s) by heterologous probing and polymerase chain reaction (PCR) is currently ongoing within the laboratory and our long-term aim is to perform gene knockout experiments on the P. brassicaecutinase(s) to assess the role played by cutinase in fungal penetration of brassica species.
42
A . M. ASHBY B. SUBCUTICULAR GROWTH: THE ROLE OF PROTEASE
Upon penetration, the fungus forms a hypomycelium of long thin septate infection hyphae which extend through the subcuticular space between the cuticle and walls of the epidermal cells (Rawlinson et a f . , 1978; Maddock, 1979). The hyphae then branch and proliferate below the cuticle to form a mycelial plate, beneath which hyphae begin to penetrate into leaf tissue along anticlinal walls and between cells of the upper mesophyll, but never through into cell lumina (Rawlinson et al., 1978; Maddock, 1979). The mechanisms by which the fungus is able to occupy space beneath the cuticle and to derive nutrients from within the plant are still unknown, and are therefore of great scientific interest. A UV mutant, designated NHlO 247, was found to be deficient in its ability to produce an extracellular protease and was also found to be nonpathogenic in a cotyledon-based pathogenicity test (Ball et al., 1991b, 1992). When crossed with the opposite wild type mating type, both protease and pathogenicity phenotypes co-segregated, suggesting that protease is a determinant of pathogenicity or that both protease and pathogenicity genes are closely linked. The resulting protease minus pathogenicity minus progeny from the cross (NH10 247:JH26; Ball et al., 1991b) were functionally complemented by a single integration event from a bulk library transformation (Fig. 4) and cloned sequences resulting in the acquired phenotype were recovered by the technique of cosmid rescue (Perucho et al., 1980). Approximately 4.5 kb of genomic DNA which flanked the original cosmid insert in NHlO 247:JH26 T was rescued in pAN7-2 and designated pPROTl (Fig. 5A). PCR using a primer reverse translated from the N-terminal amino acid sequence and a primer flanking the 4.5 kb insert in pPROTl gave a unique product (Fig. 5B,C), suggesting that the N-terminus of protease was located on the 4.5 kb fragment from pPROT1. Sequencing identified the unique ClaI site; however, analysis of open-reading frames (ORFs) on either side revealed no ORF with significant sequence homology to proteases. When pPROTl was transformed into P. brassicae, 40% of the resulting transformants displayed a loss of protease and pathogenicity phenotypes. Fig. 4. Complementation of the protease minus pathogenicity minus mutant by bulk cosmid library transformation. (A) Proteolytic transformant recovered from transformation of P. brussicue NH10247:JH26 (MAT 1-2) with a bulk cosmid library. A cleared zone of enzyme activity is evident around the complemented transformant (arrowed) (scale bar represents 2 cm). (B) Southern blot of NH10247:JH26T (MAT 1-2). Genomic DNA restricted with ClaI (which does not cut within the vector pAN7-2, track 1) and restricted with EcoRV (which linearizes pAN7-2, track 2) was probed with radiolabelled pAN7-2. (C) Symptoms induced by the protease transformant NH10247:JH26T (MAT 1-2) in a detached cotyledon test. Small white conidiomata are visible on the cotyledon (scale bar represents 2 mm). Reproduced with permission from Ball et al. (1991b).
PYRENOPEZIZA BRASSICAE-BRASSICA INTERACTION
43
44
A.
M. ASHBY
Barn HI
Fig. 5. Molecular analysis of the functionally complemented transformant, NH10247:JH26T which displayed a restored protease and pathogenicity phenotype. (A) pAN7-2 with 4.5 kb of rescued flanking sequence extending to the first ClaI site on either side of the original insert in NH10247:JH26T and designated pPROTl. (B) The unique product derived from a PCR reaction using the N-terminal protease primer and a primer flanking the 4.5kb insert in pPROTl. A. Ashby, unpublished observations.
PYRENOPEZIZA BRASSICAE-BRASSICA INTERACTION
45
Similarly, all subcloned fragments were able to elicit some effect on protease production by the fungus. It is possible that the pPROTl fragments rescued from the transformant contain regulatory sequences, rather than encoding the protease structural gene. Fragments from either side of the ClaI site are currently being used to chromosome walk through the genomic library of P. brussicue and 10 putative positive genomic clones are currently being analysed (A. Hunter, A. Clark and A. Ashby, unpublished observations). The extracellular protease was purified by FPLC separation and a biochemical profile of the protease obtained as well as sequence from its N-terminus (Batish, 1992). Biochemical analysis of the purified protease showed a pH optimum of 8.0, temperature optimum of 40°C and 100% inhibition with HgC12 confirming the findings of Ball et ul. (1991b) using a crude preparation. However, further biochemical analysis and information from the N-terminal amino acid sequence suggests that the protease is likely to belong to the serine family of proteases rather than cysteine (S. Batish, A. Clark, A. Hunter, A. Ashby and K. Johnstone, unpublished observations). A parallel approach has involved the construction of a cDNA library to casein-induced mycelium. The primer derived from the N-terminus was used in a PCR reaction against messenger RNA from induced mycelium to generate a unique RT-PCR product as a probe for library screening. cDNA clones are currently being analysed (A. Clark and A. Hunter, unpublished observations). C . USING REPORTER GENES TO MEASURE FUNGAL BIOMASS IN PLANTA
Reporter genes such as P-galactosidase, P-glucuronidase (GUS) and luciferase are widely used in plant and bacterial systems, but are relatively new tools for use in fungi. The enzymes encoded by the reporter genes hydrolyse specific chromogenic and fluorogenic substrates, liberating a specific colour or fluorescence indicative of reporter gene activity. Co-transformation of P. brussicae isolates NHlO (MAT 1-1)and JH26 (MAT 1-2) with pAN7-1 (for hygromycin selection; Punt et ul., 1987) and the constitutively expressing GUS vector pNOM102 (Roberts et ul., 1989) resulted in a range of transformants of both mating types expressing GUS activity (Ashby and Johnstone, 1993). One transformant, designated JH26pNOM102/13, was also found to be non-pathogenic and deficient in its ability to produce extracellular protease in vitro. In pluntu studies using the GUS expressing, protease minus, pathogenicity minus mutant and a wild-type GUS expressing isolate revealed that, although penetration and growth of infection hyphae were achieved in both cases, the mutant was unable to build up sufficient biomass to elicit the formation of acervular conidiomata and, therefore, visual symptoms of disease progression (Fig. 6).
C
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
Days after inoarlaton
Fig. 6. Thin sections through detached cotyledons of B . napus L. ssp. oleifera cv. Shogun showing the extent of fungal biomass after 15 days. (A) A MAT1-1 GUS expressing wild-type P. brassicae (NH10 pNOM102/18) (scale bar represents 150 Wm). (B) The MAT 1-2 protease minus pathogenicity minus GUS expressing isolate (JH26 pNOM102/13) (scale bar represents 150 pm). (C) Quantification of fungal biomass from NHlO pNOM 102/18 (MAT 1-1) and JH26 pNOM102/13 (MAT 1-2) using GUS expression mutant JH26 pNOM102/13. S. Batish, K . Johnstone and as a direct measurement: (0)wild-type NHlO pNOM102/18; (.)protease A. Ashby, unpublished observations.
14
16
PYRENOPEZIZA BRASSICAE-BRASSICA INTERACTION
47
D. PROPOSED ROLE OF EXTRACELLULAR PROTEASE IN PATHOGENICITY
From our findings one might expect that a key role for protease is the degradation of matrix glycoproteins which decrease the association between cells of the epidermis, facilitating growth of fungal mycelium both subcuticularly and, eventually, between the cells of the mesophyll. In support of this hypothesis, we have recently identified a brassica glycoprotein that is preferentially degraded by the protease ( A . Clark, A. Hunter, A . Ashby and K. Johnstone, unpublished observations). Secondly, localized degradation may result in release of nutrients from the apoplast, thus allowing the fungus to establish sufficient biomass prior to sporulation. There are other possible roles for a protease, however, including degradation of host cell matrices during the necrotrophic and saprophytic phase of growth and the degradation of host pathogenesis-related proteins. E.
IMPLICATIONS FOR DISEASE CONTROL
Establishing that cutinase is required for penetration of the cuticle of brassicas may allow the formulation of a number of strategies to effect disease control. These may include the spraying of ebelactones or other cutinase inhibitors on brassica crops at the beginning of the growing season or the use of genetically manipulated brassicas which express a cutinase inhibitor constitutively throughout their developmental cycle. Equally, cultivars with thicker cuticles could be generated transgenically or by conventional plant-breeding methods. Subcuticular growth of the fungus may be limited by expression of protease inhibitors in plants. Equally, once the natural substrate of the protease is established, subtle modification may prevent proteolytic cleavage, thereby reducing the space available for fungal growth in pluntu. Both strategies might be easily implemented through brassica transformation.
V. ANALYSIS OF THE HEMIBIOTROPHIC PHASE: THE ROLE OF CYTOKININS One of the major gaps in our current knowledge of plant pathology is an understanding of the physiological mechanisms of biotrophy and hemibiotrophy in fungal plant pathogens (Brian, 1967). In particular, several key questions remain unanswered, namely: how this delicate state of co-existence is maintained, what differentiates it from the necrotrophic mode of nutrition and, in a broader context, how these interactions relate to host specificity and disease resistance. There is substantial evidence that plant-growth regulators play a role in bacterial and fungal diseases of plants, including abnormal plant growth as
48
A . M. ASHBY
a result of infection, for example in formation of galls, hypertrophies, stem elongation and premature senescence. In addition, it has been established that many plant pathogenic micro-organisms are able to synthesize plantgrowth regulators including auxins and cytokinins (Greene, 1980). Cytokinins are N-6 substituted derivatives of adenine and in healthy plants are synthesized in the roots and transported to other regions of the plant through the xylem. They are responsible for stimulating metabolism and transportation of nutrients concomitant with a general stimulation of metabolic activity and cell division. In pathogenic interactions where hormonal imbalance does not result in prolific cell division in the host, but where the host is metabolically responsive to changes in endogenous levels of growth regulators, fungal cytokinins could function as key determinants of pathogenicity by increasing host metabolism, diverting nutrients and retaining chlorophyll to establish localized “metabolic sinks”, thus reducing the expression of senescence symptoms (Elstner, 1983). Fungal cytokinins may by themselves, or through the activation of enzymes such as superoxide dismutase, catalase and peroxidase, defend against the deleterious effects of free radicals, scavenging these highly active oxygen species, and therefore limit the processes which collectively contribute to the HR (Elstner, 1983; Beckman, 1990). A classic symptom of biotrophic rust infections is the presence of “green islands” around the point of infection which have been attributed to an imbalance in plant-growth regulators, caused directly or indirectly by the pathogen. In addition, aqueous extracts have been taken from spores of several fungi and have been shown to induce “green island” effects, suggesting that cytokinin-like molecules can be produced by both host and pathogen (Sequeira, 1973; Moore, 1979; Skoog, 1980). In the P. brassicae-Brussica interaction, “green islands” are often observed during the early stages of infection, indicative of plant-growth regulator imbalance (Maddock, 1979). This effect may be a result of either overproduction of cytokinins by the host in response to pathogen ingress, or synthesis of fungal cytokinins. There are a number of disparate reports in the literature on the ability of plant pathogenic fungi and mycorrhiza to synthesize cytokinins in vitro (Laloue and Hall, 1973; Miura and Hall, 1973; Mills and Van Staden, 1978; Kraigher et al., 1991), but definitive evidence for a role for fungalderived cytokinins in these interactions is yet to be established. Since both plant and pathogen may be capable of synthesizing plant-growth regulators and can influence each other’s ability to produce plant-growth regulators, it is experimentally difficult to identify the contribution of each partner to this phenomenon. In the cases of Agrobacterium turnefuciens and Pseudomonas savastanoi there is direct molecular evidence that bacterial genes are required for the synthesis of plant-growth regulators, and mutation of these genes either causes loss of or a change in disease symptoms (Nester and Gordon, 1991; Surico and Iacobellis, 1992). In order for the role of pathogen-derived plant-growth regulators to be
PYRENOPEZIZA BRASSICAE-BRASSICA INTERACTION
49
definitively established in a plant-microbe interaction, it is essential to produce direct molecular evidence. This is best provided by insertional inactivation of gene(s) essential for biosynthesis of the pathogen-derived plant-growth regulators and comparing disease symptoms of mutants with near-isogenic counterparts. To date, no such molecular evidence has been produced for a fungal plant pathogen. One of the major difficulties associated with the analyses of most obligate biotrophs is their dependence on the host for growth and development. Conveniently, P. brussicue is a hemibiotroph and can be cultured in vitro on nutrient medium. We are therefore well placed to test the hypothesis that cytokinins of fungal origin are responsible for maintaining the physiological balance between host and pathogen during the biotrophic phase of growth. This hypothesis draws together the ideas of early workers (Brian, 1967; Lewis, 1973) who, frustrated by the complexity of the interactions displayed by obligate parasites, were unable to investigate this phenomenon further. This source of control over plant metabolism maintained by the pathogen, if a widespread phenomenon, may be a fundamental determinant of biotrophy in plant-pathogen interactions and may be a significant contributing factor towards host specificity and disease resistance. A.
BIOCHEMICAL ANALYSIS OF CYTOKININ PRODUCTION BY P. BRASSICAE
Initial studies have shown that cytokinins are synthesized and exuded by P. brussicae during the early stages of its development, and cytokinin presence can be qualitatively visualized using a detached barley cotyledon assay (Fig. 7). A high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) for cytokinins has been established (Huntley , 1995) and has been used both to analyse levels of cytokinins from aqueous spore washes of P. brassicae and to quantify the levels of cytokinins found in extracts of mycelium and culture filtrate from. P. brassicae grown under a range of different culture conditions. Cytokinins with cross-reactivity to zeatin riboside (ZR) antibodies were identified in spore washes from P. brussicae, and when grown under different culture conditions the fungus produced differing levels of predominantly ZR cross-reactive cytokinins, with most ZR being produced under conditions comparable to those experienced by the fungus in planta (Table 11; A. Murphy, K . Johnstone and A. Ashby, unpublished observations). B. MOLECULAR ANALYSIS OF P. BRASSICAE CYTOKININS
From comparison of deduced amino acid sequence homologies between the p t z gene from Pseudomonas savastanoi and the ipt and tzs genes from A .
50
A . M. ASHBY
Fig. 7. Detached barley leaf assay. “Green island” inducing activity from 5 PI of aqueous spore extracts from: (A) P. brassicae JH26 (MAT 1-2); (B) P. brassicae NHlO (MAT 1-1); (C) Venturin inaeqclalis (positive control); (D) Erysiphe graminis (positive control); (E, F) Water (control), spotted onto detached barley leaves. 5/11 of concentrated extract was equivalent to approximately lo5 spores (A. Murphy, K. Johnstone and A. Ashby, unpublished observations). (Scale bar represents 1 cm.)
TABLE 11 Cytokinin production (pmol gfwt-’) by P. brassicae isolate JH26 (MAT 1-2) Culture filtrate Medium Malt extract Murshige and Skoog
Mycelium
z type
IPA type
z type
IPA type
9.6 13.4
ND 19.4
1.8 118.0
Z, zeatin; IPA, isopentyl adenosine; ND, none detected.
tumefuciens (Powell and Morris, 1986), two degenerate oligonucleotide primers from regions of these sequences showing high homology and which flanked a central 400 bp region of these genes were generated. The two oligonucleotides were used as primers in PCR reactions using P. brussicue genomic DNA as template. In the control PCR reaction with pGV0201 (De Vos et ul., 1981; Engler
PYRENOPEZIZA BRASSICAE-BRASSICA INTERACTION
51
et ul., 1981) containing the tmr locus from the T-DNA of A . tumefuciens and harbouring the ipt gene, a PCR product of 400 bp was produced, as expected. PCR against fungal DNA revealed two unique PCR products. Both products were sequenced but failed to show significant sequence homology with the bacterial genes. However, they are currently being used to perform gene knockout experiments by transformation (A. Murphy, K. Johnstone and A. Ashby, unpublished observations). To analyse further the effects of cytokinin imbalance on pathogenicity, a fungal expression vector allowing constitutive expression of the ipt gene from A . tumefuciens in P. brussicue has been constructed and transformants overproducing cytokinins are being screened in pathogenicity tests (A. Murphy, K. Johnstone and A. Ashby, unpublished observations). C. THE ROLE OF CYTOKININS IN PATHOGENICITY
We have demonstrated that P. brussicue synthesizes both Z R and IPA cross-reactive cytokinins in vitro and research is underway to clone cytokinin biosynthetic genes. It is proposed that fungal cytokinin production enables re-direction of nutrients to sites of pathogen ingress, increasing the availability of nutrients for pathogen consumption. We are now able to test if cytokinins of fungal origin are produced in plunta and if gene knockout of fungal cytokinin biosynthetic genes affects the ability of P. brussicue to infect brassica species. The molecular dissection of cytokinin biosynthesis in fungal biotrophic and hemibiotrophic plant pathogens may highlight a possible global importance of fungal-derived cytokinins in facilitating obligate parasitic interactions and the mutualistic mycorrhizal associations. D. IMPLICATIONS FOR DISEASE CONTROL
At present this research is still in its infancy and a more detailed analysis of fungal cytokinin expression both in vitro and in plunta is required. However, should we discover in the future that fungal-derived cytokinins are regulated and synthesized via an alternative biosynthetic pathway or by different enzymes to those of plant-derived cytokinins, one could envisage the development of a targeted approach for disease control whereby biosynthesis of the fungal cytokinin was preferentially inhibited. This would prevent re-direction of nutrients to the site of pathogen ingress and therefore reduce the available nutrients for establishment of fungal biomass.
VI. ANALYSIS OF SEXUAL MORPHOGENESIS Understanding development is currently one of the major challenges throughout biology. Fungal development is relatively simple, with hyphal
52
A. M. ASHBY
Fig. 8. Parallel approaches adopted for the analysis of fungal sexual morphogenesis involving both biochemical and molecular analyses. (Reproduced from Ashby and Johnstone, 1994.)
tubes differentiating into asexual, sexual, resting or specialized structures, depending on the perceived environmental stimulus. Physiological studies have revealed that chemical sex factors have important regulatory roles in sexual development in fungi (Machlis, 1966), with evidence available that hormones are likely to trigger a switch between asexual and sexual reproduction (Ashby and Dyer, 1992; Dyer et al., 1992). Molecular studies have focused primarily on the cloning and characterization of mating type idiomorphs (Giasson et al., 1989; Kronstad and Leong, 1989; Glass et al., 1990; Mutasa et al., 1990; Staben and Yanofsky, 1990; Froelinger and Leong, 1991; Piccard et al., 1991; Bolker et al., 1992); however, cloning of mating type loci from plant pathogenic ascomycetes is still in its infancy, with Cochliobolus heterostrophus being the only example other than P. brassicae (Turgeon et al., 1993). We have adopted a two-pronged approach to the analysis of sexual morphogenesis in P. brassicae, involving a biochemical analysis of pre- and post-mating factors and a molecular approach involving the complementation of mutants, cloning and characterization of the mating-type loci, analysis of protein profile changes concurrent with sexual morphogenesis and the use of reporter genes to study the relative contributions made by each mating type to sexual morphogenesis (Fig. 8). A. BIOCHEMICAL ANALYSIS: IDENTIFICATION OF A POST-MATING FACTOR
The biochemical analysis of sexual morphogenesis in P. brassicae has focused on the identification, characterization and partial purification of a lipoidal sex factor termed SF (Illot et al., 1986; Siddiq et al., 1989, 1992). Preliminary analysis demonstrated that crude SF was lipophilic, with the active component having a molecular weight of less than 5000 kDa and was present as a minor proportion of the crude extract (Siddiq, 1989; Siddiq et al., 1989).
PYRENOPEZIZA BRASSICAE-BRASSICA INTERACTION
53
SF behaves as a sex morphogen and analysis of the physiological mechanisms involved with fruit-body formation has revealed that SF, which is extracted from mated cultures only, has the following effects on controlling development of P. brassicae (Fig. 9A,B; Siddiq, 1989; Siddiq et al., 1989, 1992): (i) when added to single mating-type isolates of the fungus, SF inhibits asexual development and stimulates immature ascocarp formation; and (ii) when added to mated cultures, SF stimulates an increase in the rate of formation and number of mature ascocarps. Methanolic extracts from single mating-type extractions had no effect on sexual morphogenesis. Partial purification of SF by HPLC (Fig. 9C) and thin layer chromatography (TLC) indicates that the active component is likely to be a modified hydroxy fatty acid (A. Ashby, S. Ertz and K. Johnstone, unpublished observations). SF therefore acts as a morphological trigger molecule, suppressing asexual sporulation and stimulating ascocarp development (see Fig. 2). SF functions over a defined time window of between 3 and 6 days post-incubation with spores of P. brassicae (Siddiq, 1989). Removal of cultures from the influence of SF before 3 days or addition of SF to 7-day-old mycelium results in normal levels of asexual sporulation with no stimulation of immature ascocarp development. Similarly, reciprocal spermatization experiments where mycelium of one mating type was inoculated with spores of the opposite mating type, and vice versa, revealed that P. brassicae was able to undergo sexual morphogenesis providing that both mating types were present and that germination of individual mating-type isolates had not been allowed to proceed further than approximately 7 days prior to mixing (A. Ashby, unpublished observations). Illot (1984) showed that an early interaction of opposite mating types was a prerequisite for sexual morphogenesis and that ascocarps did not result when mycelial blocks of opposite mating type were allowed to grow towards one another and interact in the centre of a petri dish. It appears from this information that P. brassicae is able to initiate sexual development only within a defined time window of between 3 and 7 days post-germination. Within this phase, the fungus appears to be highly perceptive to environmental stimuli such as the presence of its opposite mating type or the presence of sex factor. Such tight control over sexual morphogenesis may be of significance to the life cycle of the fungus in planta. SF (both partially purified and crude) has been used as a morphological trigger for the molecular analysis of sexual morphogenesis in P. brassicae (Ashby and Johnstone, 1994).
B. MOLECULAR ANALYSIS
I . Complementation of developmental mutants A range of sexuality mutants was generated by ultraviolet (UV) mutagenesis and partially characterized by Siddiq (Siddiq et al., 1989, 1992). One such
€ 4 0
5
!6i
%
P
g
30
-#g
t
Y
gm
20
2e
10
P
200 100
0
0 0 A
VI
300
0.0030.03 0.25 0.5 0.75
1
1.5
IS9 (WM)
2
0
2.5
0.003Q.03 0.25 0.5 0.75
1
1.5
2
2.5
tw ( w m b
B 100
-80
?
E
5
F
260 .E r-n m 0
920 0
L L U
r N o + w c t - m o Z m m
C
Fig. 9. Bioassay and purification of SF. (A) Numbers of conidia produced by single-mating-type isolate JH26 (MAT 1-2) of P. brassicue after 15 days’ incubation on 3% MA supplemented with different concentrations of SF. (B) Total numbers of mature apothecia (solid columns) and numbers of mature apothecia per cm2 (hatched columns) produced in mated cultures of P. brassicue (NHIO x JH26) after 30 days’ incubation on 3% MA supplemented with different concentrations of SF. Each column is based on nine replicate counts of three individual experiments. The bars represent standard errors of the means. (Reproduced with permission from Siddiq et ul. (1992).) (C) Results of a bioassay of sequential 1 -min fractions of crude SF separated by normal phase HPLC. (Reproduced from Ashby and Johnstone, 1994.)
P YRE N 0 PEZl ZA B RASSICAE- BRA SSICA INTER ACTION
55
Fig. 10. Complementation of the P. brassicae developmental mutant JH26 973 with a wild-type genomic library which resulted in transformant JH26 973(T) with restored fertility and responsiveness to SF. (A) Light micrograph of JH26 973 (MAT 1-2) crossed with wild-type NHlO (MAT 1-1) after 14 days on CMM medium in which development of asexual spores, but not apothecia, has occurred (scale bar represents 5 mm). (B) Light micrograph of JH26 973(T) crossed with wild-type NHlO after 14 days on CMM medium in which very little asexual sporulation and abundant fertile apothecia are evident (scale bar represents Smm). (C) Southern blot of sex transformant JH26 973(T). Genomic DNA restricted with ClaI (which does not cut within the vector pAN7-2, track 1) and restricted with Sac1 and NcoI (which linearize pAN7-2, tracks 2 and 3) was probed with radiolabelled pAN7-2. (Reproduced from Ashby and Johnstone, 1994.)
mutant, designated JH26 973, was unable to respond to SF and was infertile when crossed with a wild-type isolate of compatible mating type. This mutation was fully complemented by genomic library transformation and the resulting transformant designated JH26 973(T) (Fig. 10A,B).Southern hybridization of genomic DNA from the transformant revealed that functional complementation resulted from a single integration event (Fig. 1OC). Cosmid rescue is currently being performed in order to rescue flanking DNA of interest. One may propose that such flanking DNA will contain gene(s) involved in
56
A. M. ASHBY
“upstream” sexual development and may well encode for the SF receptor, an SF transport protein or even gene products at the MAT 1-2 locus itself.
2. Cloning of the mating-type loci Mating-type loci in lower eukaryotes appear to be “master regulatory switches” controlling pathways of cell specialization and sexual morphogenesis. Using heterologous probing we have identified the MAT 1-2 locus of P. brassicae which is the first identification of a MAT locus from a discomycete member of the Ascomycotina. A southern blot of Hind I11 digested genomic DNA from a MAT 1-2 isolate was probed at relatively high stringency with the MAT A probe from Neurospora crassa and a single hybridizing band at 3 kb was observed, with no cross-hybridization of the probe to MAT 1-1genomic DNA (Fig. 11; P. Venkatasurbramanian and A. Ashby, unpublished observations). The 3 kb fragment was subcloned into pBluescript and sequence analysis is currently ongoing. Flanking sequences surrounding the MAT 1-2 locus will be used to identify the MAT 1-1 locus. Once unique MAT sequences are available, it will be possible to generate primers for a PCR-based diagnostic kit, allowing plant pathologists to identify and assign mating type to P. brassicae isolates harvested from infected leaves very early in the disease cycle. It will therefore be possible to inform farmers of potential epidemics of light leaf spot well in advance, which will enable them to administer a suitable fungicide regime. This is currently difficult as there are no visible signs of infection in the early stages of the disease, and identification of the fungus involves a laborious culturing procedure that can take up to a month to complete. PCR offers the information within a single day and will therefore reduce the need to spray crops with fungicides as a precautionary measure. Unique primers specific for the P. brassicae mating types will also eliminate the difficulties often associated with distinguishing between ascospores of P. brassicae and the morphologically similar saprophytic fungus, Unguicularia cfr. raripila (Inman et al., 1992). Mating-type loci and pathogenicity. In the badisiomycete genus Ustilago, whose members cause smut disease of cereals, there appears to be an association between mating type and pathogenicity. In U. maydis, a pathogen of corn, the mating-type genes consist of two idiomorphs at the “a” locus and at least 25 alleles at an unlinked “b” locus. It is the “b” locus that determines both pathogenicity of the dikaryon and sexual morphogenesis in planta. In U. hordei, a pathogen of barley, the mating system is bipolar. Successful mating results in the formation of an infectious dikaryon which is able to complete its sexual cycle in planta. Therefore in this basidiomycete pathogen, a single locus controls both pathogenicity and sexual morphogenesis (Thomas, 1988). At present there are no reports showing an association between mating type and pathogenicity in ascomycete plant pathogens. Until recently, however, MAT loci had not been cloned from
PYRENOPEZIZA BRASSICAE-BRASSICA INTERACTION
57
Fig. 11. Southern blot of wild-type P. brussicae JH26 (MAT 1-2) showing hybridization with a 3 kb fragment of genomic DNA. Genomic DNA was restricted with Hind I11 and probed with a digoxygenin (DIG) labelled 5.5 kb NdeI/NsiI fragment from p2A4, containing the MAT A locus from Neurospora crassa (kindly provided by Dr B. Metzenberg). Track M, lambda Hind I11 markers (DIG labelled); track 1, restricted genomic DNA of MAT 1-2 (JH26); track 2, restricted genomic DNA of MAT 1-1 (NH10). Arrow highlights the 3 kb hybridizing band. (P. Venkatasurbramanian and A. Ashby, unpublished observations.)
plant pathogenic ascomycetes, and therefore there has been no realistic way of specifically mutating MAT genes so that this question could be addressed directly. Although the sexual cycle in P . brussicae is not a prerequisite for pathogenicity and no evidence for the involvement of the MAT genes in pathogenicity is available, we will now be able to test this directly. 3. Protein profile analysis of developmentally regulated genes As part of a programme of research focusing on the molecular analysis of sexual morphogenesis, SF has been used as a morphological trigger and resulting changes in protein profiles have been analysed. Protein profile analysis of single mating-type isolates of P. brussicae both alone and induced with SF, as well as profiles of mature fertile ascocarps from crosses revealed the presence of a major protein in SF-induced single mating-type isolate extracts and in extracts from mature ascocarps. This protein is designated sex factor-induced (SFI1) protein (Fig. 12A). The
58
A. M. ASHBY
protein has a molecular weight of 35 kDa, a pl of 7.3 and has hydrophobic characteristics. Data base searches on internal amino acid sequences from the purified SFIl protein revealed no homology with the hydrophobins, but did reveal partial homology with a number of membrane-bound proteins, suggesting that SFIl may be membrane associated (A. Ashby and M. Robb, unpublished observations). SFIl was found in extracts from SF-induced mycelium of a range of field isolates of both mating types of P. brassicae, suggesting that the protein is neither isolate nor mating type specific. SFIl separated as a single peak on FPLC hydrophobic interaction chromatography (Fig. 12B) and internal amino acid sequence data from the purified protein was obtained. Reverse translation allowed oligonucleotides to be generated for PCR, and a unique PCR product of 700 bp was generated. Southern blotting of both MAT 1-1 and MAT 1-2 genomic DNA using the 700 bp PCR probe revealed a different banding pattern between mating-type isolates, but a consistent banding pattern within isolates of the same mating type, suggesting close linkage with the MAT idiomorphs. This is currently being tested by the analysis of progeny from sexual crosses in which co-segregation of hybridizing band pattern and mating type will be analysed. 4. Use of GUS as a tool to study sexual morphogenesis The reporter gene GUS was used to study developmental interactions (Ashby and Johnstone, 1993) with a view to using the technique to study the spatial and temporal expression of developmentally regulated genes during apothecia1 formation in P. brassicae. Both MAT 1-1 and MAT 1-2 isolates were transformed with pNOM102 and reciprocal crosses performed on GUS MAT 1-1 x wt MAT 1-2 and GUS MAT 1-2 x wt MAT 1-1. An analysis of the contribution made by each mating type to fruiting body development was assessed and preliminary results suggested that each mating type differentially contributes to apothecial morphology (Ashby and Johnstone, 1993). The results, in parallel with SEM work, showed that an early interaction after germination of opposite mating-type mycelium is a prerequisite for sexual morphogenesis (see Fig. 3). C. SEXUAL MORPHOGENESIS IN P. BRASSZCAE: A SPECULATIVE SUMMARY
Interaction between newly germinating hyphae is a prerequisite for sexual morphogenesis, with attraction of opposite mating-type hyphae towards one another clearly evident. This implies a role for some hitherto unidentified sex factor in pre-mating. Such a factor may be proteinaceous, and pheromone like in its mode of action. Anastomosis of germinating hyphae involves recognition of "self" and "non-self" with hyphae of opposite mating type, forming dikaryotic hyphae which generate into pseudoapothecia. The post-mating lipoidal SF is produced once sexual development is initiated and
PYRENOPEZIZA BRASSICAE-BRASSICA INTERACTION
0.2
2.0
0.1
1 .o
59
E 0
03 N U
m
s
.-
5
E E
a
u
0.0
0.0 0 (b)
15
30
45
60
Time (minutes)
Fig. 12. Identification and purification of SFIl. (A) Sodium dodecyl sulphate (SDS) polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) of total soluble protein from asexually reproducing culture of P. brassicue JH26 (MAT 1-2) after 15 days incubation (track l), JH26 in the presence of 1.25 mgml-' SF after 15 days incubation (track 2), and individually picked mature fertile apothecia (track 3). Track M corresponds to low-molecular-weight PHAST protein markers (Pharmacia). The arrow highlights the SFIl protein. (B) FPLC profiles of total soluble protein from asexually reproducing cultures of P. brussicae JH26 and JH26 in the presence of 1.25 mg ml-' SF after 15 days' incubation. The large peak from SF-induced extracts corresponds to SFIl. (A. Ashby and M. Robb, unpublished observations.)
60
A. M.ASHBY
stimulates apothecial development at the expense of asexual morphogenesis. At present it is unclear at what stage of development karyogamy and meiosis or “true sex” occurs. The gene(s) at the mating-type locus clearly will play a role in downstream processes that culminate in apothecial development. These will involve the regulation of downstream structural genes such as SFZl and genes involved in the SF biosynthetic pathway. Ultimately, the signal transduction pathways triggered in response to SF will be elucidated and a greater understanding of the cellular processes that facilitate apothecial development obtained. D. IMPLICATIONS
A greater understanding of the processes controlling sexual development in plant pathogenic fungi will ultimately lead to new strategies for disease control. Once SF is purified and a structure obtained, analogues can be generated and screened for their ability to inhibit asexual reproduction while failing to stimulate ascocarp formation, thus preventing both reproduction and dissemination of P. brassicae. Information gained from insertional inactivation experiments will allow us to ascertain whether or not MAT functions are required for pathogenicity and to analyse the role of MAT genes in sexual morphogenesis. In the long term, the role of MAT loci in controlling downstream cascades that lead to fruit-body formation will be established and genes involved in the downstream processes characterized, Such genes may control “shape determination”, and sequence comparison of such genes throughout the Ascomycotina may shed new light on the apparent morphological differences between ascocarps within this division. Equally, in combination with the traditional taxonomic analysis, a comparison of DNA sequences at the MAT loci may provide a unique approach for the classification of members within the Ascomycotina as well as providing useful sequence for the design of PCR-based diagnostic kits. In addition, by understanding the control of fruit-body formation, there may be implications for fermentative biotechnology, allowing control over fungal secondary metabolism, that may give rise to new products. Implications are also evident in the food industries where a greater understanding of the controlling elements of sexual reproduction may lead to the artificial induction of fruit-body formation in edible fungi.
VII. A MOLECULAR VIEW THROUGH THE LOOKING-GLASS: THE P. BRASSICAE-BRASSICA INTERACTION Like any plant-microbe interaction the P. brassicae-Brassica interaction is a dynamic process, and therefore our interpretation of the disease has relied
PYRENOPEZIZA BRASSICAE-BRASSICA INTERACTION
61
on observed sequential changes in development of both the host and pathogen. Traditionally this has been by visual examination, for example, green islands and leaf curl are often observed as early stages of infection and this is followed by the formation of concentric rings of erumpant conidiomata indicating that sporulation and rupture of the cuticular layer has occurred. With the application of molecular biological techniques we are now able to “stop the clock” and analyse component parts of an interaction by in vifro analysis involving gene cloning techniques, as well as looking at the effects of gene knockouts on the ability of the fungus to undergo its normal life cycle in pfanta. By relating molecular findings to visual observations of pathogenesis we are now beginning to build a “molecular picture” of the life cycle of the fungus. This picture is far from complete and will require many more years of dedicated research to unravel. However, as a framework for future research and discussion, I will look through the “molecular looking glass” and try to speculate on some of the cellular processes that may play a role in establishing the life cycle of P. brussicue in planfa. From our current state of knowledge such speculation highlights some of the key questions regarding the P. brassicue-Brussicu interaction that have yet to be addressed. The molecular life cycle of P. brussicae (Fig. 13) begins when either ascospores disseminated by wind currents, which act as primary inoculum in the early spring, or asexual conidia, dispersed primarily by rain splash and acting as secondary inoculum, land on a brassica leaf surface. Adhesion molecules such as hydrophobins may be important, as is the case with the rice pathogen, Mugnoporthe griseu (Talbot et ul., 1993). However, to date, there is no evidence for such involvement in P. brassicue. Spores of P. brussicae germinate in the presence of water droplets and relatively short hyphae are produced prior to penetration, which curiously is never through stomata. Penetration does not seem to be primarily mechanical and one can assume therefore that the process involves degradation of the host cuticle. This could perhaps be mediated by an extracellular cutinase, although there is much controversy surrounding the role of such enzymes as pathogenicity determinants in other fungi (Stahl and Schifer, 1992; Rogers el al., 1994). Non- or weakly pathogenic isolates are poor penetrators, tending to produce longer hyphae on the leaf surface which may be indicative of a decreased level of expression of cutinase or insufficient build-up of pressure at the hyphal tips prior to penetration. Alternatively, some hitherto unknown recognition event may be a prerequisite for successful penetration. P. brussicue has been shown to infect a wide range of brassica hosts, however, with the pressures afforded by modern agricultural practices such as the breeding of resistant cultivars of brassicas and the widespread use of systemic fungicides, a greater selection pressure for more virulent isolates will prevail. Differential interactions between P. brussicue and Brussica sp. may become
62
A. M. ASHBY
Fig. 13. A molecular view through the looking-glass at the life cycle of P. brassicae. The proposed molecular interpretation of the life cycle of the fungus based on recent experimental data combined with a certain degree of speculation. Figures are not drawn to scale.
PYRENOPEZIZA BRASSICAE-BRASSICA INTERACTION
63
more evident with gene-for-gene associations playing a role in early interaction events. Further investigation may initiate a programme of research focused on the identification of resistance genes and their corresponding avirulence gene counterparts, as well as the mechanisms controlling host specificity. Once penetration has occurred, the fungus is protected from the hostile environment of the phylloplane and is likely to have little competition, in stark contrast with most necrotrophic fungi which have to compete with resident microbes. However, as a biotroph, the fungus has to establish biomass within the host, but with little or no disturbance to the host. P. brussicue rarely penetrates the cells of the mesophyll and is localized subcuticularly. The fungus is localized within the tissue in which it initially penetrated and never advances in a systemic fashion throughout the plant, underlining the tight controls that enable the physiological balance of host and pathogen to be maintained. Presumably, because of its biotrophic mode of growth during the early stages of the interaction, biomass must be established gradually and by delicate regulation of gene expression. This process involves tight regulation of extracellular enzyme production and it is probably limited to localized expression of an extracellular protease that allows the fungus to create space for itself by degradation of host glycoproteins such as the hydroxy proline-rich glycoproteins. This subtle breakdown of the host intracellular matrices may also cause localized leakage of nutrients from the apoplast. Fungal-derived cytokinins, which are likely to be produced in response to the stressful environment experienced by the fungus during the biotrophic phase of growth in pluntu, may alter the host cytokinin balance and cause re-direction of nutrients to the site of pathogen ingress, as well as cause retention of chlorophyll which is manifested as green islands on the leaf surface. Changes in the levels of cytokinin production as a result of pathogen ingress mimic the normal plant physiology and therefore give the plant a “false sense of security”, whilst providing localized regions of high metabolic activity within the host which will encourage an increase in fungal biomass. Sporulation may be biomass and space dependent, with space and/or nutrient supply becoming limited, resulting in a stress response by the fungus which presumably triggers asexual sporulation. Rupture of the cuticle causes water loss and desiccation stimulating stress responses in both plant and pathogen. At this point, the in pfuntu environment is dramatically altered, and the pathogen must switch to a different mode of nutrition. This switch to necrotrophy, and ultimately saprotrophy, is essential to survival and involves production, by the fungus, of a battery of extracellular cell wall degrading enzymes including endo-PG, PME, cellulase and protease. Sexual morphogenesis may occur on senescing leaves if germinating spores of both mating types are present. There may be environmental indicators such as polyphenolics associated with lignin degradation, that signal whether or not
64
A. M. ASHBY
the spore is germinating on live or decaying host material. Longer germ tubes may be produced as the fungus searches for living host tissue and during this phase of growth the fungus may display increased susceptibility to environmental stimuli, such as the presence of a compatible mating-type pheromone or the presence of hyphae of the opposite mating type. Since an early interaction of germinating mycelium is required for sexual morphogenesis, this may be more easily achieved once the fungus is survivingas a saprophyte on the decaying leaf surface rather than during early development within the host. The defined time window in which sexual morphogenesis can occur is of significance here since it culminates in the formation of a protective resting structure, the apothecium. The fruiting body provides protection from environmental extremes and allows the pathogen to lay dormant until favourable conditions prevail. The extreme competition experienced by most saprophytes surviving on decaying matter would then be avoided. The nutritional status of the fungus, as well as environmental factors such as temperature, may therefore be important in establishing sexual development in preference to asexual development. The formation of a protective resting structure may also be in response to the development of the host, such as growth, development of flowers, pod formation and crop harvest. Once opposite mating types have interacted, SF triggers a developmental cascade that ultimately culminates in fruiting body formation. From GUS analysis it appears that hyphae exist in a dikaryotic state prior to karyogamy and meiosis, both processes being initiated within the developing apothecium. Regulatory genes at the mating-type locus presumably control SF biosynthesis. SF, in turn, presumably inhibits asexual sporulation, and fungal resource is then targeted towards fuelling sexual morphogenesis. SFIl, a protein that is produced in large amounts and within the first 7 days of development in response to sex factor, is hydrophobic in nature but is not itself a hydrophobin, and probably contributes to the structure of the apothecium. The melanized fruiting bodies act as survival structures which are able to resist desiccation, extreme temperature regimes and the effects of W irradiation. Sexual morphogenesis is an important developmental process for P. brussicue as it provides a means of survival from one growing season to the next. Occurrence of the sexual stage also offers the potential for genetic variability which may affect both pathogenicity and the development of tolerance to fungicides, both factors becoming more predominant as oilseed rape is exploited by agricultural practice. It has also been suggested that the release of ascospores from apothecia may provide an important inoculum source later in the season, reducing the efficacy of fungicide application. Dissemination from the apothecium is by wind currents, spreading inoculum over wider distances once conditions are favourable, either later in the growing season or early in the spring of the following season. This dynamic process continues from season to season, providing that a suitable brassica host is found.
PYRENOPEZIZA BRASSICAE-BRASSICA INTERACTION
65
VIII. CONCLUDING REMARKS Within the last decade a number of molecular tools have been developed for the molecular analysis of filamentous fungi. Such tools will allow scientists to analyse how differential gene expression governs both pathogenesis and sexual morphogenesis in plant pathogenic fungi. With continued scientific input into P. brassicae research, from our group and from others, it is hoped that a true molecular picture of the life cycle of this important plant pathogen will be established. This multidisciplinary approach involving an integration of both conventional plant pathology and molecular and biochemical techniques will yield most progress towards a greater understanding of the biology of plant-microbe interactions and will ultimately lead to the development of novel and sophisticated strategies for disease control.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I am indebted to my colleague Keith Johnstone, for jointly co-ordinating the P. brussicue research in Cambridge, for detailed discussions, for critically reading the manuscript and for helping with the figures. I would like to thank the Royal Society for a University Research Fellowship, past and present members of the Cambridge P. brussicue group, without whose efforts this review would not have been possible, and particularly Alex Murphy, Anthony Clark and Amy Hunter for commenting on the manuscript. I thank Rebecca Stratford and Robert Shields (Plant Breeding International) for sequencing pPROTl and providing pPROTl subclones, Chris Sidebottom for help with internal amino acid sequencing of SFI1, Stefan Drury-Morris for preparing the photographs and Barry Goddard for help with Fig. 13. Finally, I would like to thank my husband, Andy, for critically reading the manuscript, helpful discussions, drawing Fig. 13 and much encouragement, and my daughter, Victoria, for sleeping so blissfully when required. The research carried out in Cambridge was performed under provisions of licence number PHF 17419191 (28) issued by the Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food under the Plant Health (Great Britain) Order, 1987.
REFERENCES Ashby, A . M. and Dyer, P. S. (1992). The secret sex lives of fungi. New Scientist 133, 32-35. Ashby, A . M. and Johnstone, K . (1993). Expression of the E. coli P-glucuronidase gene in the light leaf spot pathogen Pyrenopeziza brassicue and its use as a reporter gene to study developmental interactions in fungi. Mycological Research 97(5), 575-581. Ashby, A . M. and Johnstone, K. (1994). Molecular tools to study sexual development in fungi. I n “Shape and Form in Plants and Fungi” (D. S. Ingram and A.
66
A. M . ASHBY
Hudson, eds), pp. 345-360. Linnean Society of London, Academic Press, London. Ball, A. M. (1989). Analysis of pathogenicity of Pyrenopeziza brassicae. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Cambridge. Ball, A. M., Siddiq, A. A. and Giltrap, N. J. (1990). Assessment of benomyl resistance and mating type in field isolates of Pyrenopeziza brassicae, cause of light leaf spot of brassicas. Plant Pathology 39, 33-37. Ball, A. M., Sawczyc, M. C., Ashby, A. M., Ingram, D. S. and Johnstone, K. (1991a). Transformation of the fungus Pyrenopeziza brassicae, cause of light leaf spot of Brassicas, and complementation of mutants using a genomic library. Experimental Mycology 15, 243-254. Ball, A. M., Ashby, A. M., Daniels, M. J., Ingram, D. S. and Johnstone, K. (1991b). Evidence for the requirement of extracellular protease in the pathogenic interaction of Pyrenopeziza brassicae with oilseed rape. Physiological and Molecular Plant Pathology 38, 147-161. Ball, A. M., Ingram, D. S. and Johnstone, K. (1992). A detached cotyledon test for the isolation of mutants of Pyrenopeziza brassicae defective in pathogenicity determinants. Journal of Phytopathology 136, 204-210. Batish, S. B. (1992). Analysis of pathogenicity of Pyrenopeziza brassicae: cause of light leaf spot of Brassicas. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Cambridge. Beckman, K. B. (1990). The hypersensitive response and resistance of Solanum tuberosum L. to Phytophthora infestans (Mont.) de Bary. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Cambridge. Bolker, M . , Urban, M. and Kahmann, R. (1992). The a mating type locus of U. rnaydis specifies cell signalling components. Cell 68, 441-450. Brian, P. W. (1967). Obligate parasitism in fungi. The Leeuwenhoek lecture, 1966. Proceedings of the Royal Society, Series B 168, 101-118. Cheah, L.-H. and Hartill, W. F. T. (1985). Disease cycle in New Zealand of light leaf spot of brassicas, induced by Pyrenopeziza brassicae, New Zealand Journal of Agricultural Research 28, 567-573. Cooper, R. M. (1984). The role of cell wall degrading enzymes in infection and damage. In “Plant Diseases: Infection, Damage and Loss” (R. K. S. Wood and G. J. Gellis, eds), pp. 13-27. Blackwell Scientific, Oxford. Courtice, G. R. M. and Ingram, D. S. (1987). isolation of auxotrophic mutants of the hemibiotrophic ascomycete pathogen of brassicas, Pyrenopeziza brassicae. Transactions of the British Mycological Society 89, 301-306. Courtice, G. R. M., Ingram, D. S., Johnstone, K., Sawczyc, M. C. and Skidmore, D. 1. (1988). Pyrenopeziza brassicae, cause of light leaf spot of brassica ssp. Advances in Plant Pathology 6, 225-231. DeVos, G., DeBeukeleer, M., Van Montagu, M. and Schell, J. (1981). Restriction endonuclease mapping of the octopine tumour inducing plasmid pTiAch5 of Agrobacterium tumefaciens. Plasmid 6, 249-253. Dyer, P. S., Ingram, D. S. and Johnstone, K . (1992). The control of sexual morphogenesis in the Ascomycotina. Biological Reviews 67, 421-458. Elstner, E. F. (1983). Hormones and metabolic regulation of disease. Biochemical Plant Pathology 19, 415431. Engler, G., Depicker, A., Maenhaut, R., Villarroel, R., Van Montagu, M. and Schell, J. (1981). Physical mapping of DNA base sequence homologies between an octopine and a nopaline Ti plasmid of Agrobacterium tumefaciens. Journal of Molecular Biology 152, 183-208. Figueroa, L., Shaw, M. W., Fitt, B. D., McCartney, H. A. and Welham, S. J. (1994). Effects on previous cropping and fungicide timing on the development of light
PYRENOPEZIZA BRASSICAE-BRASSICA INTERACTION
67
leaf spot (Pyrenopeziza brassicae), seed yield and quality of winter oilseed rape (Brassica napus). Annals of Applied Biology 124, 221-239. Figueroa, L., Fitt, B. D., Shaw, M. W., McCartney, H. A. and Welham, S. J. (1995). Effects of temperature on the development of tight leaf spot (Pyrenopeziza brassicae) on oilseed rape (Brassica napus). Plant Pathology 44, 51-62. Froelinger, E. H. and Leong, S. A. (1991). The a mating type genes of Ustilago maydis are idiomorphs. Gene 100, 113-122. Giasson, L., Specht, C. A., Milgrim, C., Novotny, C. P. and Ullrich, R. C. (1989). Cloning and comparison of Aa mating-type alleles of the Basidiomycete Schizopyllum commune. Molecular and General Genetics 218, 72-77. Gladders, P. (1984). Present and potential disease interaction between oilseed rape and vegetable brassicas. Proceedings of the 1984 British Crop Protection Conference - Pests and Diseuse, pp. 799-806. Farnham: British Crop Protection Council. Glass, N. L., Grotelueschen, J. and Metzenberg, R. L. (1990). Neurospora crassa A mating-type region. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA 87, 49124916. Greene, E. M. (1980). Cytokinin production by microorganisms. The Botanical Review 46, 25-78. Hardwick, N. V., Fitt, B. D. L., Wale, S. J. and Sweet, J. B. (1991). Oilseed rape diseases. Home Grown Cereals Authority Research Review OS4, London: Home Grown Cereals Authority. Huntley, R. (1995). Cytokinins and giberellins in oil palm sex determination. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Cambridge. Mot, T. W. (1984). Studies on the reproduction of Pyrenopeziza brassicae. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Cambridge. Mot, T. W., Ingram, D. S. and Rawlinson, C. J. (1984). Heterothallism in Pyrenopeziza brassicae, cause of light leaf spot of brassicas. Transactions of the Brifish Mycological Society 82(3), 477483. Illot, T. W., Ingram, D. S. and Rawlinson, C. J . (1986). Evidence of a chemical factor involved in the control of sexual development in the light leaf spot fungus, Pyrenopeziza brassicae (Ascomycotina). Transactions of the British Mycological Society 87(2), 303-308. Mot, T. W., Ingram, D. S. and Rawlinson, C. J. (1987). Studies of fungicide resistance in Pyrenopeziza brassicae, cause of light leaf spot disease of oilseed rape and other brassicas. Transactions of the British Mycological Society 88(4), 515523. Inman, A. J., Fitt, B. D. L. and Evans, R. L. (1992). A species of Unguiculuria on oilseed rape, and its importance in studies of the epidemiology of light leaf spot (Pyrenopeziza brassicae). Plant Pathology 41, 646-652. Jeffery, D. C., Jones, G. D. and Jenkins, P. D. (1989). Effects of early infections of light leaf spot (Pyrenopezia brassicae) on oilseed rape (Brassica napus L.). Aspects of Applied Biology 23, 409-415. Jeffery, D. C., Jenkins, P. D. and Gareth Jones, D. (1994). Comparative studies of light leaf spot (Pyrenopeziza brassicae) epidemics on the growth and yield of winter oilseed rape. Annals of Applied Biology 124, 19-25. Kraigher, H., Grayling, A., Wang, T. L. and Hanke, D. E. (1991). Cytokinin production by two ectomycorrizal fungi in liquid culture. Phytochemistry 30, 2249-2254. Kronstad, J. W. and Leong, S . A. (1989). Isolation of two alleles of the b locus of Ustilago maydis. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 86, 978-982.
68
A.
M.ASHBY
Lacey, M. E., Rawlinson, C. J. and McCartney, H. A. (1987). First record of the natural occurrence in England of the teleomorph of Pyrenopeziza brassicae on oilseed rape. Transactions of the British Mycological Society 89( l ) , 135-140. Laloue, M. and Hall, R. H. (1973). Cytokinins in Rhizopogon roseolus. Plant Physiology 51, 559-562. Lewis, D. H. (1973). Concepts of fungal nutrition and the origin of biotrophy. Biological Reviews 48, 261-278. Machlis, L. (1966). Sex hormones in fungi. In “The Fungi’’, Vol. 2 (G. C. Ainsworth and A. S. Sussmann, eds), pp. 415433. Academic Press, London. Maddock, S. E. (1979). Studies of the biology of the light leaf spot disease of oilseed rape and other brassicas. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Cambridge. Maddock, S. E. and Ingram, D. S. (1981). Studies of the perfect stage of the light leaf spot pathogen of brassicas, Pyrenopeziza brassicae. Transactions of the British Mycological Society 77, 207-210. Maddock, S. E., Ingram, D. S. and Gilligan, C. A. (1981). Resistance of cultivated brassicas to Pyrenopeziza brassicae. Transactions of the British Mycological Society 76, 371-382. Majer, D., Mithen, R., Lewis, B. G., Oliver, R. P., deVos, P. and Zabeau, M. (1995). Detecting genetic variation in a fungal population using amplified length polymorphism (AFLP). Presented at the Eighteenth Fungal Genetics Conference, Asilomar, CA (Posters 111, abstract number 40). McCartney, H. A. and Lacey, M. E. (1990). The production and release of ascospores of Pyrenopeziza brassicae on oilseed rape. Plant Pathology 39, 17-32. McCartney, H. A., Lacey, M. E. and Rawlinson, C. J. (1986). Dispersal of Pyrenopeziza brassicae spores from an oilseed rape crop. Agricultural Science, Cambridge 107, 299-305. Mills, L. J. and Van Staden, J. (1978). Extraction of cytokinins from maize, smut tumours of maize and Ustilago maydis cultures. Physiological Plant Pathology 13, 73-80. Miura, G. and Hall, R. H. (1973). trans-Ribosylzeatin. Plant Physiology 51, 563-569. Moore, T. C. (1979) “Biochemistry and Physiology of Plant Hormones”, Springer Verlag, Berlin. Mutasa, E. S., Tymon, A. M., Gottgens, B., Mellon, F. M., Little, P. F. R . and Casselton, L. A. (1990). Molecular organisation of an A-mating type factor of the basidiomycete fungus Coprinus cinereus. Current Genetics 18, 223-229. Nester, E . W. and Gordon, M. P. (1991). Molecular strategies in the interaction between Agrobacterium and its hosts. In “Advances in Molecular Genetics of Plant-Microbe Interactions”, Vol. 1 (H. Hennecke and D. P. S. Vermal, eds), pp. 3-9 Kluwer, Dordrecht. Perucho, M., Hanahan, D., Lipsich, L. and Wigler, M. (1980). Isolation of the chicken thymidine kinase gene by plasmid rescue. Nature 285, 207-210. Picard, M., Debuchy, R. and Coppin, E. (1991). Cloning the mating types of the heterothaliic fungus Podospora anserina, developmental features of haploid transformants carrying both mating types. Genetics 128, 539-547. Powell, G. K. and Morris, R. 0. (1986). Nucleotide sequence and expression of a Pseudomonas savastanoi cytokinin biosynthetic gene: homology with Agrobacterium tumefaciens tmr and tzs loci. Nucleic Acids Research 14: 25552565. Punt, P. J., Oliver, R. P., Dingemanse, M. A., Pouwels, P. H. and Van Den Hondel, C. A. M. J . J. (1987). Transformation of Aspergillus based on the hygromycin resistance marker from E. coli. Gene 56, 117-124.
PYRENOPEZIZA BRASSICAE-BRASSICA INTERACTION
69
Raeder, U. and Broda, P. (1985). Rapid preparation of DNA from filamentous fungi. Letters in Applied Microbiology I , 17-20. Rawlinson, C. J., Sutton, B. C. and Muthyalu, G. (1978). Taxonomy and biology of Pyrenopeziza brassicae sp. nov. (Cylindrosporium concentricum), a pathogen of winter oilseed rape (Brassica napus ssp. Oleifera). Transactions of the British Mycological Society 71(3), 425439. Roberts, I. N., Oliver, R. P., Punt, P. J. and van den Hondel, C . A. M. J. J . (1989). Expression of the E. coli P-glucuronidase gene in industrial and phytopathogenic filamentous fungi. Current Genetics 15, 177-180. Rogers, L. M., Flaishman, M. A. and Kolattukudy, P. E. (1994). Cutinase gene disruption in Fusarium solani f. sp. pisi decreases its virulence on pea. The Plant Cell 6 , 935-945. Sequeira, L. (1973). Hormone metabolism in diseased plants. Annual Reviews of Plant Physiology 24, 353-380. Siddiq, A. A. (1989). Sexual morphogenesis in P. brassicae. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Cambridge. Siddiq, A.A., Ingram, D. S., Johnstone, K . , Friend, J. and Ashby, A. M. (1989). The control of asexual and sexual development by morphogens in fungal pathogens. Aspects of Applied Biology 23, 417426. Siddiq, A. A., Johnstone, K. and Ingram, D. S. (1992). Evidence for the production during mating of factors involved in suppression of asexual sporulation and the induction of ascocarp formation in Pyrenopeziza brassicae. Mycological Research 96, 757-765. Simons, A. J. and Skidmore, D. I . (1988). Race-specific resistance to light leaf spot in Brassica oleracea. Transactions of the British Mycological Society 90, 43 1435. Skidmore, D. I., Ingram, D. S. and Mot, T. W. (1984). Genetic studies with Pyrenopeziza brassicae. In “Proceedings of Better Brassicas ’84 Conference”, pp. 139-143. Dundee: Scottish Crop Research Institute. Skoog, F. (Ed.) (1980). “Plant Growth Substances.” Springer Verlag, Berlin. Staben, C. and Yanofsky, C. (1990). Neurospora crassa A mating type region. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA 87, 49174921. Stahl, D. J. and Schifer, W. (1992). Cutinase is not required for fungal pathogenicity on pea. The Plant Cell 4, 621-629. Staunton, W. P. and Kavanagh, T. (1966). Natural occurrence of the perfect stage of Gleosporium concentricum Grev. Berk. et Br. Irish Journal of Agricultural Research 5 , 140-141. Surico, G. and Iacobellis, N. S. (1992). Phytohormones and olive knot disease. In “Molecular Signals in Plant-Microbe Interactions” (D. P. S. Verma, ed.), pp. 209-227. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL. Talbot, N. J., Ebbole, D. J. and Hamer, J . E. (1993). Identification and characterisation of MPG1, a gene involved in pathogenicity from the rice blast fungus Magnaporthe grisea. Plant Cell 5( 1l), 1575-1590. Thomas, J. E. and Walker, K. C. (1994). Exploitation of disease resistance in oilseed rape cultivars. Aspects of Applied Biology 40, 237-243. Thomas, P. L. (1988). Ustilago hordei, covered smut of Barley and Ustilago nigra, false loose smut of Barley. Advances in Plant Pathology 6 , 415425. Turgeon, B. G., Bohlmann, H . , Ciuffetti, L. M., Christiansen, S. K., Yang, G., Schafer, W. and Yoder, 0. C. (1993). Cloning and analysis of the mating type genes from Cochliobolus heterostrophus. Molecular and General Genetics 238, 270-284. Vollmer, S. J. and Yanofsky, C. (1986). Efficient cloning of genes of Neurospora
70
A.
M.ASHBY
crassa. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA 83, 48694873. Wood, K. V., Lam, Y. A., Seliger, H. H. and McElroy, W. D. (1989). Complementary DNA coding click beetle luciferases can elicit bioluminescence of different colours. Science 244, 700-702. Yarman, D. J. and Giltrap, N. J. (1989). Crop diseases in a changing agriculture. Arable crops - a review. Plant Pathology 38, 459-477. Yelton, M. M., Hamer, J. E . and Timberlake, W. E. (1984). Transformation of Aspergillus nidulans by using a Trp C plasmid. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA 81, 147G-1474.
The Balance and Interplay Between Asexual and Sexual Reproduction in Fungi
M. CHAMBERLAIN* and D . S. INGRAM
Royal Botanic Garden. 20A Inverleith Row. Edinburgh EH3 5LR. UK
I . Introduction
.............................................................................
I1. Initiation of Asexual Sporulation and Sexual Reproduction ..............
71 72
111. Comparisons of Genetic Variation. Physiological Costs and Fitness
between Asexual and Sexual Systems ........................................... A . Does the Sexual System Generate more Variants? ................... B . Is the Sexual System Physiologically more Costly? ................... C . Are Sexual Progeny more “Fit”? ..........................................
IV. Maintaining and Changing the Balance between Reproductive Processes ......................... .................................................... A . Species-determined Equilibria ............................................... B . Genotype-determined Equilibria ............................................ C . Seasonally Maintained Equilibria ........................................... D . Physical and Nutritional Factors ............................................ E . Density and Competition ..................................................... F. The Effect of Mycelial Extracts and Specific Morphogens .......... V. Trade-off between Asexual and Sexual Reproduction
73 73 74 74 74 75 76 77 77 77 78
......................
80
VI . Conclusion ............................................................................... Acknowledgements .................................................................... References ...............................................................................
81 82 82
I . INTRODUCTION All mycelial fungi grow vegetatively. most reproduce asexually. some reproduce only asexually. some only sexually. but most undergo all three *Previously known as M . Jurand Advances in Botanical Research Vol . 24 incorporating Advances in Plant Pathology ISBN 0-12405924-X
Copyright 0 1997 Academic Press Limited All rights of reproduction in any form reserved
72
M. CHAMBERLAIN and D. S. INGRAM
processes in the course of their life cycle. An actively growing fungal mycelium therefore may have a number of possible courses of development open to it. It may continue with purely vegetative growth, it may concentrate on asexual sporulation or it may initiate sexual development, provided that mating has taken place or that the strain is self-compatible. Cochrane (1958) recognized that a major barrier to generalizing about reproduction in fungi is the repeated failure of experimental work to discriminate adequately between growth and sporulation. This still remains a problem, except that in some species there are three courses of action: vegetative growth, asexual sporulation and sexual development. Whether the three courses of action are in fact alternatives or occur in sequence one after another, the balance between them may be a feature of the individual species, population o r genotype and is also fine tuned by environmental factors. The situation is further complicated by the fact that the adaptability to environmental change is itself under genetic control. According to Andrews (1984, 1992), life history theory must account for input and output, both of which reflect allocation of limited time and resources among competing demands. In fungi, which are totipotent and modular, the demarcation between growth and reproduction is not absolute, except that reproduction tends to be associated with dispersal. Spores, both asexual and sexual, tend to be uninucleate and haploid. The dissemination of single-celled propagules allows each generation to start with what Crow (1988) calls “tabula rasa” , allowing deleterious mutations to be eliminated quickly. Dawkins (1982) differentiates two life-history traits, G (growth) and R (reproduction), and discusses the advantages of cycling between the singlecell and multicell states. However, he does not mention the cycling between asexual and sexual phases, which must surely affect both the ecological requirements (Elliott, 1994) and the uniformity-variability equilibrium. While the asexual cycle is mitotic, the sexual cycle consists of two variation-generating events: fertilization and meiosis. There are, therefore, commonly held beliefs that asexual reproduction generates uniform progeny, whereas the sexual process generates genetically different individuals, provided that the mates coming together at fertilization are genetically different from one another. The sexual structures and sometimes the sexual spores themselves are more durable, allowing the organism to resist unfavourable conditions. In some fungal groups the sexual structures also allow for better dispersal.
11. INITIATION OF ASEXUAL SPORULATION AND SEXUAL DEVELOPMENT Whether produced mitotically o r meiotically, the spores of most fungi germinate to give rise to a vegetatively growing mat, each hyphal cell dividing
ASEXUAL AND SEXUAL REPRODUCTION IN FUNGI
73
mitotically to produce a network of hyphae or mycelium. At some stage in the. course of the vegetative growth the mycelium becomes ready for asexual sporulation, a state given the term “competence” (Champe et al., 1981). The sporulation schedule has been worked out for the homothallic species Aspergillus niduluns (reviewed by Champe et al., 1981). A single conidium placed on nutrient agar surface grows vegetatively to form a mycelium for a fixed period of 24 h at 37OC. Then comes a sudden onset of conidiation, which is remarkably synchronous from colony to colony (Axelrod, 1972) and is unaffected by medium composition (Pastushok and Axelrod, 1976). The time of conidiation is, however, temperature dependent and varies inversely with colony density. The induction to conidiate has been worked out to occur 20 h after inoculation, after which follows a fixed maturation period of 4 h. These times appear to be controlled endogenously. Whereas conidiation is a precisely timed event, the decision to sporulate sexually depends on the genetic background and cultural conditions. This may happen several days to more than a week after conidiation is complete. The sexual spores, or ascospores, form following meiotic division within developing asci in closed spherical ascocarps or cleistothecia. Clearly, the later that sexual reproduction is induced, the greater is the ratio of asexual to sexual reproduction. In homothallic species, that is those in which each mycelium can complete the sexual cycle on its own, sexual reproduction is triggered without fertilization between two different strains. In heterothallic species, that is those that require the interaction of two different strains to complete the life cycle, sexual reproduction is initially dependent on the availability of compatible nuclei. It is controlled by two separate systems. The first operates at the population level and regulates the level between inbreeding and outbreeding, and the second is concerned with the sequence leading to sexual morphogenesis. In heterothallic ascomycetes the act of mating does not by itself trigger morphogenesis. Turian (1978) believes that morphogenesis of reproductive structures is a process which is typically under the control of factors other than those which determine sexual compatibility. It may include up to five phases: sexual differentiation, plasmogamy , karyogamy, meiosis and sporogenesis.
111. COMPARISONS OF GENETIC VARIATION, PHYSIOLOGICAL COSTS AND FITNESS BETWEEN ASEXUAL AND SEXUAL SYSTEMS A. DOES THE SEXUAL SYSTEM GENERATE MORE VARIANTS?
The totipotent nature of fungal cells, and hence the opportunity for the propagation of spontaneous mutations and the existence of parasexual systems (Pontecorvo, 1956), have raised the question of whether the
74
M. CHAMBERLAIN and D. S . INGRAM
assumption that the sexual system generates more variants is in fact rigorously justified. One study which confirms this elegantly is a comparison of sexual and asexual populations of Puccinia graminis f.sp. tritici in different parts of North America (Burdon and Roelfs, 1985). The origin of genetic diversity exhibited by the largely asexually reproducing genus Fusarium is hotly debated, with some authors favouring the asexual origin (Gordon, 1993) and others favouring origin from inconspicuous sexual events (literature reviewed by Anderson et al., 1992). B. IS THE SEXUAL SYSTEM PHYSIOLOGICALLY MORE COSTLY?
Another commonly held assumption is that the sexual system is physiologically more costly than the asexual one. To our knowledge there have been no studies in fungi to show how dry matter and energy are apportioned at different stages in the life cycle that are comparable to those carried out in higher plants, for example in Senecio vulgaris (Harper and Ogden, 1970). Studies on how organisms budget their resources in response to the competing demands of growth and reproduction have been carried out in lizards and higher plants (literature reviewed by Giesel, 1976). Composites, such as Tussilago farfura, devote up to 30% of their assimilated energy to reproduction, of which 3-8% is devoted to seeds and >23% to asexual reproduction (Ogden, 1974). Similar studies are needed in the fungi. C. ARE SEXUAL PROGENY MORE “FIT”?
Studies in the grass Anthoxanthum odoratum have shown short-term and immediate fitness advantages for sexually produced progeny (Kelley et al., 1988). Although the mathematical models proposed by Nauta (1994) have predicted that this is also likely to be true in the fungi, there is no experimental proof available to confirm this. Hastings (1992), also on the basis of mathematical models, but in diploid organisms, showed that a large number of asexual divisions in between occasional sexual ones offers an ideal system, since it inhibits the spread of deleterious cytoplasmic genomes (DCGs), which can invade and dramatically reduce the fitness of a sexual population. Although fungi lend themselves well to addressing the above three questions, there is surprisingly little evidence available to provide rigorous answers.
IV. MAINTAINING AND CHANGING THE BALANCE BETWEEN REPRODUCTIVE PROCESSES In the following sections we summarize how the balance between different reproductive processes is maintained in nature and adjusted by genetic and environmental factors.
ASEXUAL AND SEXUAL REPRODUCTION IN FUNGI
75
A . SPECIES-DETERMINED EQUILIBRIA
The strategy theory of Dobzhansky (1950) has been adapted for fungi by Pugh (1980) and Cooke and Whipps (1993) and for fungal pathogens by Andrews and Rouse (1982). The strategy model proposes a spectrum of strategies for survival, at the opposite ends of which are two types of organisms: the r-selected and the K-selected. The former have a short life expectancy and rapidly commit all their available resources to reproduction. The latter have a long life expectancy and either devote only a small proportion of available resources to reproduction at any one time or only commit themselves to reproduction at the end of their life span. Since a diversity of strategies has been found in phylogenetic lineages, one might argue that this points to the fixation of a life-history trait in a given species (Reynolds, 1993). However, as taxonomists often base their classifications on life-history traits, one must beware of circular thinking. There are, nevertheless, several examples of related species apportioning differing ratios of their resources to the two methods of reproduction. In Eupenicillium the balance between asexual and sexual phases of the life cycle varies from species to species. The balance of resources devoted to the two phases depends on the length of the life cycle and hence the interval between consecutive ascospore generations. Those species which show rapid rates of ascostromatal ripening have fragmentary penicilli, and so clearly devote less of their resources to asexual sporulation. By contrast, those species which have ascostromata that are slow to ripen typically produce a larger penicillus with greater numbers of phialides (Pitt, 1979). This indicates that, as long as the sexual cycle generates a quick turnover of ascospores, conidia become less important. Only a few Aspergilli and Penicillia have been found to be heterothallic. Homothallism most likely confers the advantage of bypassing the hit-and-miss business of encountering a mate (also referred to as the “lonely spore hypothesis” by Herskowitz, 1988). The existence of a sexual phase in addition to the prolific asexual phase probably confers an advantage in an ephemeral environment. A homothallic organism with a resting stage in its life cycle would be able to overwinter adverse conditions or oversummer in the semi-arid tropics, like, for example, downy mildews in India. Anderson et al. (1992) question the premise of Pugh (1980) that life strategies are adaptive. Nevertheless, there are certain correlations to be made. For example, asexual reproduction tends to be favoured in fastreproducing Fusarium species, whereas some of the long-lived, slowly colonizing basidiomycetes invest more of their resources in sexual structures, thus achieving longer range dispersal and genetic variation (Anderson et al., 1992). Perhaps the old adage “Do not confine your children to your own learning, for they were born in another time” applies to fungal spores too.
76
M. CHAMBERLAIN and D. S. INGRAM B. GENOTYPE-DETERMINED EQUILIBRIA
While reproductive strategy may become fixed in a given species, the existence within the same species of genetic polymorphism for different reproductive strategies, discussed by Giesel (1976) for higher plants, appears to be operating in the following fungal examples. Many species can exist as either anamorphic (mitotic), teleomorphic (meiotic) or pleomorphic (both mitotic and meiotic) strains. For example, the species Glomerella cingulata includes a large number of pathogenic forms that attack plants of different types. Strains from apple, grape and pepper usually produce both sexual and asexual spores, while those from wild Zpomoea sp., kudzu and okra produce fertile perithecia in abundance, but few or no conidia (Wheeler, 1956). Cultures which produce only conidia are occasionally obtained from all hosts, sometimes from the same lesions that yield cultures of one of the other types. One conidial strain was obtained from an ascospore derived from a predominantly perithecial strain. The progeny of crosses between the original perithecial form and the conidial variant were of the two parental types only, suggesting a simple Mendelian inheritance. A similar situation was found in Gleotinia temulenta (Griffiths, 1958). Mono-ascospore cultures grown from apothecia collected in the field varied genetically in their capacity to reproduce asexually. Some produced huge numbers of conidia, others were only mycelial, and a third category produced both conidia and mycelia. In Fusarium graminearum, Burgess et al. (1975) and Francis and Burgess (1975) found two population groups, one of which rarely forms perithecia while the other readily forms perithecia in culture. In this case the two populations of this species were found to be heterothallic and homothallic, respectively (Francis and Burgess, 1977). Perhaps further studies on this species would disclose a truly polymorphic situation. To date few examples of polymorphism between homothallic and heterothallic individuals in the same population have been found, although the mathematical models proposed by Nauta (1994) predicted that such a situation is to be expected. In Mugnaporthe grisea, the blast fungus of cereals and grasses, the sexual cycle can only be induced under laboratory conditions, but the degree of fertility is highly dependent on host origins (Yaegashi, 1977). The fungus is a heterothallic ascomycete and at least some of the isolates function only as males. Apparently the loss of hermaphroditic function, or maleness, appeared to be due to a single gene mutation (Leung and Williams, 1985). However, since sexual reproduction has not yet been found in nature and an active parasexual system is operating, mechanisms for generating variants in the field are thought to be of somatic origin (Leung and Taga, 1988).
ASEXUAL AND SEXUAL REPRODUCTION IN FUNGI
77
C. SEASONALLY MAINTAINED EQUILIBRIA
Seasonal factors are known to maintain prolific conidium production on living leaves, while the sexual telemorph stages are restricted to dead or dying stems in the autumn. This is the situation, for example, in apple scab Venturia inaequalis (Boone, 1988) and light leaf spot Pyrenopeziza brussicae (McCartney and Lacey, 1990). Similarly, rusts produce large quantities of asexual uredospores during the summer and teliospores only later in the year (Hawker, 1966). These seasonally maintained equilibria may be sustained by endogenous factors which control the natural senescence of the pathogen and its host. D . PHYSICAL AND NUTRITIONAL FACTORS
External factors which are known to affect the switch between the different reproductive processes include general physical and nutritional factors such as temperature, light, humidity and water availability, aeration and pH as well as the quality and quantity of nutrients. The influence of these factors on the reproductive development of fungi has been studied extensively (Hawker, 1966; Turian, 1966; Muller, 1979; Moore-Landecker, 1982; Cooke and Whipps, 1993; Griffin, 1994). However, many of these articles do not specify the type of reproduction involved. There are also review articles on the initiation of asexual reproduction (Clutterbuck, 1978; Smith, 1978) and sexual reproduction (Turian, 1978; van den Ende, 1978) in the excellent synthesis edited by Smith and Berry (1978), but the subjects are dealt with separately. A detailed review of the factors which affect the switch between the two types of sporulation is being prepared (Chamberlain, in preparation). E. DENSITY AND COMPETITION
It has already been mentioned that in Aspergillus nidulans the time of conidiation depends on the density of conidia sown (Champe et al., 1981). A confluent lawn of sown conidia initiates the conidiation process sooner than a single colony derived from one conidiurn. The same was observed in Pyrenopezizu brassicae (personal observation). Increasing the density of single spore inocula also enhances sexual reproduction. In the basidiomycete genus Psathyrella fruiting was promoted on dishes evenly sown with basidiospores compared with dishes inoculated with a single dikaryotic isolate (Jurand, 1975). Interactions between mycelia of different species of fungi have also been widely reported to induce sexual sporulation. For example, Trichoderrna
78
M. CHAMBERLAIN and D. S. INGRAM
strains release volatile antibiotics which stimulate the production of oospores in homothallic species of Phytophthora (Brasier, 1975).
F. THE EFFECT OF MYCELIAL EXTRACTS AND SPECIFIC MORPHOGENS
Given that competition within and between species affects the choice of developmental strategy, it is not surprising that mycelial extracts are also effective. Most evidence points to early stimulation of sexual reproduction or to a swing in the balance between asexual and sexual reproduction in favour of the latter. There are at least 20 independent reports of extracts of mycelia playing a role in switching the balance in favour of sexual development (Table I). Extracts of Pyrenopeziza brassicae, for example, were found to influence the reproductive development of P. brassicae itself (Ilott et al., 1986; Siddiq et al., 1990) and about 40 different species of fungi (Siddiq et al., 1989; Chamberlain et al., 1995). In those species of fungi which reproduce sexually, the effect of the extracts was to promote sexual development at the expense of asexual sporulation, while in those species, e.g. Deuteromycotina, which do not have a sex option, the effect of the extracts was to enhance asexual sporulation. It would appear that much the same pattern of response can be seen from all the other examples listed in Table I. In most of the studies with mycelial extracts the active ingredient has not been characterized, but in a few cases specific morphogens have been discovered. These include trisporic acid, linoleic acid, zearalenone, CAMP, mycosporines, cerebrocides and indole acetic acid (reviewed by Dyer et al., 1992). The effects of some chemicals, antibiotics and metabolites on the production of primordia in sclerotium-producing species are summarized by Cooke (1983). However, attempts to find a universal sex-inducing hormone have so far failed. Another possibility is that some mycelial extracts supply a negative effect in the form of substances antagonistic to growth, or even have a more drastic effect of causing mutilation, injury or other forms of physiological stress. It has been suggested that injured or moribund cells release substances which act on surviving cells and divert them into a new developmental path (Cochrane, 1958). Very early work by Rands (1917) and Kunkel (1918) showed that scraped or broken hyphae stimulate conidiation. This kind of evidence suggests that the primary activity of the extracts is on growth rather than reproduction. It is generally accepted that reproduction in fungi and also in higher plants is initiated by factors which check vegetative growth without drastically poisoning its metabolism. According to the Klebs principle (Klebs, 1898, 1899, 1900) reproduction is favoured by depriving an established mycelium of one or more nutrients (Cochrane, 1958). The edge effect is well known, both in the field situation and in petri
ASEXUAL AND SEXUAL REPRODUCTION IN FUNGI
79
TABLE 1 Effect of extracts of fungal mycelia on the reproductive development of the same or other species of fungi Extract of mycelia Of
Agaricus bisporus Aspergillus nidulans Fusarium spp.
Active on:
Marasmius sp.
Stimulation of fruiting Inhibition of conidium Same species formationlenhanced cleistothecium formation Increased sexual 40 different species reproduction 90% reduction Same species (conidial isolate) of conidiation
Glomerella cingulata (perithecial isolate) Hormodendrum Schizophyllum cladosporioides commune Lenticus edodes Marasmius sp. Neurospora crassa Neurospora crassa Mating type a Mating type A Mating types A'X a
Nature of activity
Same species (filtrate of both mating types) Same species (mating type A) Same species (mating type a) Same species (mating type
Induction of fruiting
Reference Uramaya (1969) Champe et al. (1987)
Nelson (1971) Wheeler (1956) Leonard and Dick (1968) Uramaya (1969)
Stimulation of fruiting Stimulation of perithecium formati on
It0 (1956)
Protoperithecium stimula tion
Islam and Weijer (1972)
N o effect
Islam and Weijer (1972)
Protoperithecium stimulation
Islam (1981)
Stimulation of perithecia Induction of fruiting
Wilson (1927)
Ascocarp stimulation No effect
Ilott et al. (1986)
A)
Venturia inaequalis Schizophyllum Penicillium commune funiculosum Pyrenopeziza brassicae Mated isolates Same species Penicillium spp.
Unmated isolates Unmated and mated isolates
Same species 30 different species
Reduction of asexual sporulation and stimulation of sexual reproduction
Kawai et al. (1985)
Ilott et al. (1986) Chamberlain ef al. (I 995)
80
M. CHAMBERLAIN and D. S . INGRAM
TABLE 1 cont. Schizophyllum commune Sclerotinia sclerotiorum Verticillium sp. Microsclerotial isolate
Pyrenopeziza brassicae Sordaria brevicollis Same species
Stimulation of sexual reproduction Stimulation of sexual reproduction Enhancement of sclerotium formation
Same species
Stimulates production of microsclerotia/ inhibits sporulation Stimulation of perithecium formation Stimulation of apothecia
Several species
Thielavia bassicola
Several species
Pyronema domesticum
Siddiq (1989) Siddiq ( 1989) Bedi (1958)
Brandt and Reese (1964) McKormick (1925) Moore-Landecker (1988)
dishes. Macdonald and Bond (1976) showed in Sordaria brevicollis that protoperithecial production commenced all over the colony only after the mycelial front had reached the edge of the containing vessel. The presence of a growing mycelial front inhibited the differentiation of fruiting bodies. A similar effect has been found in Chaetomium globosum (Buston and Rickard, 1956) and Gelasinospora reficulospora (Inoue and Furuya, 1970).
V. TRADE-OFF BETWEEN ASEXUAL AND SEXUAL REPRODUCTION Most of the above studies seem to indicate that the asexual and sexual reproductive processes are in competition with each other for the availability of resources and that various factors can alter the balance of resource allocation. The same trade-off situation has been observed in the field. Michelmore and Ingram (1980) observed an inverse relationship between intensity of asexual sporulation and the incidence of sexual reproduction in the heterothallic oomycete Bremia lactucae. An “eithedor” situation with sexual organs and conidiophores borne on different parts of the onion foliage was evident in the onion mildew Peronospora schleideniana (McKay, 1939) and in graminaceous downy mildews (Safeeulla, 1976). Simultaneous sexual and asexual sporulation was, however, observed in Peronospora parasitica (McMeekin, 1960) and P. destructor (Berry and Davis, 1957). Michelmore and Ingram (1980) thought that in Bremia lactucae the sexual and asexual processes were antagonistic. However, at lower levels
ASEXUAL AND SEXUAL REPRODUCTION IN FUNGI
81
of sexual reproduction, they occasionally observed both sexual and asexual sporulation in close proximity, apparently involving the same vegetative hyphae. They concluded that at the onset of sporulation there may be a developmental switch which prevents asexual reproduction during sexual differentiation; alternatively asexual sporulation may be suppressed by greater nutritional demands of sexual reproduction which take priority. Observations of trade-off between asexual and sexual reproduction in the field are further confirmed by experimental evidence. In Aspergillus nidulans conidiation and cleistothecium formation are considered to be alternatives (Clutterbuck, 1977). It is evident from the behaviour of mutants and also from variants found in the wild that an excess of either inevitably means a reduction in the other. In mutants with reduced conidiation, resources which would otherwise be employed in asexual reproduction are diverted to cleistothecial production (Martinelli and Clutterbuck, 1971). A negative correlation between the numbers of conidia and ascospores was observed by Chamberlain et al. (1995). Studies in higher plant reproductive ecology have shown many examples of negative correlation between asexual and sexual reproduction. For example, in Pofygonum viviparum, Law et al. (1983) plotted the number of bulbils versus the number of flowers on single inflorescences and found evidence of a highly significant correlation between the two. They concluded that there was a trade-off, so that one could not be increased without reducing the other. In higher plants it is difficult to determine whether the balance between asexual and sexual reproduction is genetically determined or is the result of phenotypic responses to a changing environment. Differences in biomass allocation in Impatiens capensis from two different habitats are shown to be environmentally determined, since the differences are not evident when the plants are transplanted to uniform greenhouse conditions (Abrahamson and Hershey, 1977). The authors refer to the environmentally induced “sedasex” switch as a “plastic switch hitter strategy”. There is also evidence, reviewed by Willson (1983), that competitive pressure induces plants to put a greater proportion of their resources into seeds. It would be plausible to suggest that the situation is similar in the fungi.
VI. CONCLUSION It is clear that a trade-off operates between asexual and sexual reproduction in fungi. The balance of resources allocated to the competing demands of the two modes of reproduction can be determined genetically and can also be regulated by numerous environmental factors. The earlier the switch is “hit”, the greater is the ratio of sexually to asexually produced offspring. There is evidence that competition and stress induce an earlier switch. Mycelial extracts of the same, as well as different, species contain diffusible
82
M. CHAMBERLAIN and D. S. INGRAM
factors which may serve as a signal to neighbouring mycelia of the presence of a potential competitor. Studies on the factors which operate the switch are of considerable economic interest, whether the aim is to control a destructive pathogen or to propagate a beneficial species. They are also of academic interest as they have a bearing on the issue of the sexual process itself. Many fundamental questions still remain unanswered. Is sexual reproduction merely a response to changed circumstances (sensu Williams, 1975)? Are there enough correlations to support the view that sexual reproduction survives despite the costs, because it generates variation, or is its survival related to the fact that in most sexual species of fungi the sexual propagules serve as resting spores? Indeed, the combination of recombinant genomes within a resting structure must enhance considerably the chances of survival of a species faced with adverse environmental conditions. What are the costs? Does it in fact generate significantly more genetic variation than do asexual and parasexual systems combined? Are sexually produced fungal “individuals” more “fit”? Are the different observed life-history traits in related species merely correlates or have they resulted from selection pressures? All these questions urgently require investigation. The situation is probably most easily explained teleologically. Each fungal organism, in its particular niche, “writes” its own hypothetical balance sheet and then, weighing up a multitude of ecological, genetical and physiological factors, “decides” which method to select: asexual, sexual or indeed a carefully tuned balance between the two. All organisms proceed with life cycles in response to information received from the environment (Demetrius, 1975; Giesel, 1976), but some are more adaptable than others. In some cases the balance appears to be fixed in a given species or genotype; at the other end of the spectrum are organisms which adjust their life-history traits readily, the environment playing the part of a flexible “switch hitter”.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We thank the Gatsby Charitable Foundation for financial support and numerous colleagues for stimulating discussions, in particular Drs A. M. Ashby, D. J. Bond, A. F. Dyer, K. Johnstone, K. Jong, R. F. 0. Kemp, J. Ratter and Professor J. Friend.
REFERENCES Abrahamson, W. G. and Hershey, B. (1977). Resource allocation and growth in Impatiens capensis (Balsaminaceae) in two habitats. Bulletin of the Torrey Botanical Club 104, 160-164.
ASEXUAL AND SEXUAL REPRODUCTION IN FUNGI
83
Anderson, J. B., Kohn, L. M. and Leslie, J . F. (1992). Genetic mechanisms in fungal adaptation. In “The Fungal Community, Its Organisation and Role in the Ecosystem” (G. C. Carroll and D. T. Wicklow, eds). Marcel Dekker, New York. Andrews, J. H. (1984). Life history strategies in plant parasites. Advances in Plant Pathology 2 , 105-130. Andrews, J. H. (1992). Fungal life-history strategies. In “The Fungal Community, Its Organisation and Role in the Ecosystem” (G. C. Carroll and D. T. Wicklow, eds). Marcel Dekker, New York. Andrews, J . H. and Rouse, D. I. (1982). Plant pathogens and the theory of r- and K-selection. American Naturalist 120, 283-296. Axelrod, D. E. (1972). Kinetics of differentiation of conidiophores and conidia by colonies of Aspergillus nidulans. Journal of General Microbiology 73, 181184. Bedi, K. S. (1958). The role of stale products in the formation of sclerotia of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum (Lib.) De Bary. Indian Phytopathology 16, 29-36. Berry, S. Z. and Davis, G. N. (1957). Formation of oospores by Perenospora destructor (Bert.) Casp. and their possible relation to epiphytology. Plant Disease Reporter 41, 3-6. Boone, D. M. (1988). Venturia inaequalis, cause of scab of apples. Advances in Plant Pathology 6, 249-262. Brandt, W. H. and Reese, J. E. (1964). Morphogenesis in Verticillium: a selfproduced diffusable morphogenetic factor. American Journal of Botany 51, 922-927. Brasier, C. M. (1975). Stimulation of sex organ formation in Phytophthora by antagonistic species of Trichoderma. I. The effect in vitro. New Phytologist 74, 183-194. Burdon, J . J. and Roelfs, A. P. (1985). The effect of sexual and asexual reproduction on the isozyme structure of populations of Puccinia graminis. Phytopathology 75, 1098-1073. Burgess, L. W., Wearing, A. H. and Toussoun, T. A. (1975). Surveys of the fusaria associated with crown rot of wheat in Eastern Australia. Australian Journal of Agricultural Research 26, 791-799. Buston, H. W. and Rickard, B. (1956). The effect of a physical barrier on sporulation of Chaetomium globosum. Journal of General Microbiology 15, 194-197. Chamberlain, M., Ertz, S. and Ingram, D. S. (1995). Effect of extracts of Pyrenopeziza brassicae on other species of fungi. Mycologia 87, 846-856. Champe, S. P., Kurtz, K. B., Yager, L. N., Butnick, N. J. and Axelrod, D. E. (1981). Spore formation in Aspergillus nidulans: competence and other developmental processes. In “The Fungal Spore: Morphogenic Controls” (G. Turian and H. R. Hohl, eds). Academic Press, London. Champe, S. P., Rao, P. and Chang, A. (1987). An endogenous inducer of sexual development in Aspergillus nidulans. Journal of General Microbiology 133, 1383-1387. Clutterbuck, A. J . (1977). The genetics of conidiation of Aspergillus nidulans. In “The Physiology and Genetics of Aspergillus” (J. E. Smith and J . Pateman, eds), pp. 305-317. Academic Press, New York. Clutterbuck, A. J. (1978). Genetics of vegetative growth and asexual reproduction. In “The Filamentous Fungi, Vol. 111: Developmental Biology” (J. E. Smith and D. R. Berry, eds), pp. 47-73. Edward Arnold, London. Cochrane, V. W. (1958). “Physiology of Fungi.” Wiley, New York. Cooke, R. (1983). Morphogenesis of Sclerotia. In “Fungal Differentiation” (J. E .
84
M. CHAMBERLAIN and D. S. INGRAM
Smith, ed.), pp. 397-418. Marcel Dekker, USA. Cooke, R. C. and Whipps, J. M. (1993). “Ecophysiology of Fungi”, pp. 337 ff. Blackwell Scientific, Oxford. Crow, J. F. (1988). The importance of recombination. In “The Evolution of Sex: An Examination of Current Ideas” (R. E. Michod and B. R. Levin, eds), pp. 56-73. Sinauer Associates, Supderland, MA. Dawkins, R. (1982). “The Extended Phenotype: The Gene as the Unit of Selection.” Oxford University Press, Oxford. Demetrius, L. (1975). Reproductive strategies and natural selection. American Naturalist 109, 243-249. Dobzhansky, T. (1950). Evolution in the tropics. American Scientist 38, 209-221. Dyer, P. S., Ingram, D. S. and Johnstone, K. (1992). The control of sexual morphogenesis in the Ascomycotina. Biological Reviews 67, 421458. Elliott, C. G. (1994). “Reproduction in Fungi.” Chapman & Hall, London. Francis, R. G. and Burgess, L. W. (1975). Surveys of fusaria and other fungi associated with stalk rot in maize in eastern Australia. Australian Journal of Agricultural Research 26, 801-807. Francis, R. G. and Burgess, L. W. (1977). Characteristics of two populations of Fusarium roseurn “Graminearum” in Eastern Australia. Transactions of the British Mycological Society 68, 421-427. Giesel, J. T. (1976). Reproductive strategies as adaptations to life in temporarily hetergeneous environments. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 7 , 57-79. Gordon, T. R. (1993). Genetic variation and adaptive potential in an asexual soilborne fungus. In “The Fungal Holomorph: Mitotic, Meiotic and Pleomorphic Speciation in Fungal Systematics” (D. R. Reynolds and J, W. Taylor, eds). CAB International, Wallingford, UK. Griffin, D. H. (1994). “Fungal Physiology”, pp. 458 ff. Wiley-Liss, New York. Griffiths, E. (1958). Sexual reproduction and variation in Gleotinia temulenta (Prill. and Delacr.) Wilson and Gray. Transaction of the British Mycological Society 41, 461-482. Harper, J. L. and Ogden, J. (1970). The reproductive strategy of higher plants. I The concept of strategy with special reference to Senecio vulgaris L. Journal of Ecology 58, 681-698. Hastings, I. (1992). Why is sex so frequent? Trends in Ecology and Evolution 7 , 278-279. Hawker, L. E. (1966). Environmental influences on reproduction. In “The Fungi: An Advanced Treatise”, Vol. I1 (G. C. Ainsworth and A. S. Sussman, eds). Academic Press, London. Herskowitz, I. (1988). Life cycle of the budding yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Microbiological Reviews 5 2 , 536-553. Illott, T. W., Ingram, D. S . and Rawlinson, C. J. (1986). Evidence of a chemical factor involved in the control of sexual development in the light leaf spot fungus Pyrenopeziza brassicae (Ascomycotina). Transactions of the British Mycological Society 87, 303-308. Inoue, Y. and Furuya, M. (1970). Perithecial formation in Gelasinospora reticulospora: effects of light at two different growth states. Development, Growth and Differentiation 12, 141-150. Islam, M. S. (1981). Sex pheremone in Neurospora crassa. In “Sexual Interaction in Eukaryotic Microbes” (D. H. O’Day and P. A. Horgen, eds), pp. 131-154. Academic Press, New York. Islam, M. S. and Weijer, J. (1972). Development of fertile fruit bodies (perithecia)
ASEXUAL AND SEXUAL REPRODUCTION IN FUNGI
85
in the single strain culture of (Em A) of Neurospora crassa. Folia Microbiologica, Prague 17, 316-319. Ito, T. (1956). Fruit body formation in red bread mould, Neurospora crassa. I. Effect of culture filtrate on perithecial production. Botanical Magazine, Tokyo 69, 369-372. Jurand, M. K. (1975). Breeding biology of the genus Psathyrella. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Edinburgh. Kawai, G., Ikeda, Y. and Tubaki, K. (1985). Fruiting of Schizophyllum commune induced by certain ceramides and cerebrosides from Penicillium funiculosum. Agricultural and Biological Chemistry 49, 2137-2146. Kelley, S. E., Antonovics, J. and Schmitt, J. (1988). A test for short-term advantage of sexual reproduction. Nature 331, 714-716. Klebs, G. (1898). Zur physiologie der Fortpflanzung einiger Pilzer. I: Sporodinia grandis. Jahrbuch fur Wissenschaftliche Botanik 32, 1-69. Klebs, G.(1899). Zur physiologie der Fortpflanzung einiger Pilzer. 11: Saprolegnia mixta. Jahrbuch f u r Wissenschaftliche Botanik 33, 513-539. Klebs, G. (1900). Zur physiologie der Fortpflanzung einiger Pilzer. 111: Allgemeine Betrachtungen. Jahrbuch fur Wissenschaftliche Botanik 35, 80-203. Kunkel, L. 0. (1918). A method of obtaining abundant sporulation in cultures of Macrosporium solani. E&M. Brooklyn Botanic Garden Memoirs 1, 306-312. Law, R., Cook, R. E. D. and Manlove, R. J. (1983). The ecology of flower and bulbil production in Polygonum viviparum. Nordic Journal of Botany 3, 559-565. Leonard, T.J. and Dick, S. (1968). Chemical induction of haploid fruiting bodies in Schizophyllum commune. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science, USA 59, 745-751. Leung, H. and Taga, M. (1988). Magnaporthe grisea (Pyricularia species), the blast fungus. Advances in Plant Pathology 6, 175-188. Leung, H. and Williams, P. H. (1985). Genetic analyses of electrophoretic enzyme variants, mating type and hermaphroditism in Pyricularia oryzae. Canadian Journal of Genetical Cytology 27, 697-704. MacDonald, D. J. and Bond, D. J. (1976). Genetic and environmental factors influencing the production and distribution of photperithecia in Sordaria brevicollis. Journal of General Microbiology 95, 375-380. Martinelli, S. D. and Clutterbuck, A. J. (1971). A quantitative survey of conidiation mutants in Aspergillus nidulans. Journal of General Microbiology 69, 261268. McCartney, H. A. and Lacey, M. E. (1990). The production and release of ascospores of Pyrenopeziza brassicae. Plant Pathology 39, 17-32. McKay, R. (1939). Observations on onion mildew caused by the fungus Peronospora schleideniana. Journal of the Royal Horticultural Society 64, 272-285. McKormick, F. A. (1925). Perithecia of Thielavia brassicola Zopf in culture and the stimulation of their production by extracts of other fungi. Connecticut Agricultural Experimentation Station Bulletin 269, 539-554. McMeekin, D. (1960). The role of oospores of Peronospora parasitica in downy mildew of crucifers. Phytopathology 50, 93-97. Michelmore, R. W. and Ingram, D. S. (1980). Heterothallism in Bremia lactucae. Transactions of the British Mycological Society 75 ( l ) , 47-58. Moore-Landecker, E. (1982). “Fundamental of the Fungi”, 2d edn. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ. Moore-Landecker, E . (1988). Response of Pyronema domesticum to volatiles from microbes, seeds and natural substrata. Canadian Journal of Botany 66, 194-198.
86
M. CHAMBERLAIN and D. S. INGRAM
Muller, E. (1979). Factors inducing asexual and sexual sporulation in fungi (mainly Ascomycetes). In “The Whole Fungus: The Sexual Asexual Synthesis”, Vol. I (B. Kendrick, ed.), pp. 265-282. National Museums of Canada, Ottawa. Nauta, M. (1994). Evolution of genetic systems in filamentous ascomycetes. Ph.D. Thesis, Cip-Gegevens Koninklijke Bibliotheek, Den Haag. Nelson, R. R. (1971). Hormonal involvement in sexual reproduction in the fungi, with special reference to F-2, a fungal estrogen. In “Morphological and Biochemical Events in Plant-Parasite Interaction” (S. Akai and S.Ouchi, eds), pp. 181-205. Phytopathological Society of Japan, Tokyo. Ogden, J. (1974). The reproductive strategy of higher plants. 11: The reproductive strategy of Tussilago farfara L. Journal of Ecology 62, 291-324. Pastushok, M. and Axelrod, E. E. (1976). Effect of glucose, ammonia and media maintenance on the time of conidiophore initiation by surface colonies of Aspergillus nidulans. Journal of General Microbiology 94, 221-224. Pitt, J. I. (1979). “The genus Penicillium and its telemorphic states Eupenicillium and Talaromyces.” Academic Press, London. Pontecorvo, G. (1956). The parasexual cycle in fungi. Annual Review of Microbiology 10, 393-400. Pugh, G. J. F. (1980). Strategies in fungal ecology. Transactions of the British Mycological Society 7 5 , 1-14. Rands, R. D. (1917). The production of spores by Alternaria solani in pure culture. Phytopathology 7 , 316-317. Reynolds, D. R. (1993). The fungal holomorph: an overview. In “The Fungal Holomorph: Mitotic, Meiotic and Pleomorphic Speciation in Fungal Systematics” (D. R. Reynolds and J. W. Taylor, eds), pp. 15-25. CAB International, Wallingford, UK. Safeeula, K. M. (1976). “Biology and Control of the Downy Mildews of Pearl Millet, Sorghum and Finger Millet.” Wesley Press, Mysore. Siddiq, A. A. (1989). The control of sexual morphogenesis in Pyrenopeziza brassicae. Ph.D. Thesis, Cambridge University. Siddiq, A. A., Ingram, D. S., Johnstone, K., Friend, J. and Ashby, A. M. (1989). The control of asexual and sexual development by morphogens in fungal pathogens. Aspects of Applied Biology 23, 417425. Siddiq, A. A., Johnstone, K. and Ingram, D. S. (1990). Evidence of the production during mating of factors involved in uppression of asexual sporulation and the induction of ascocarp formation in Pyrenopeziza brassicae. Mycological Research 96, 757-765. Smith, J. E. (1978). Asexual sporulation in filamentous fungi. In “The Filamentous Fungi. Vol. 111: Developmental Biology ” (J. E. Smith and D. R. Berry, eds), pp. 214-239. Edward Arnold, London. Smith, J. E. and Berry, D. R. (1978). “The Filamentous Fungi. Vol. 111: Developmental Biology.” Edward Arnold, London. Turian, G. (1966). Morphogenesis in Ascomycetes. In “Fungi: An Advanced Treatise. Vol. 11: The Fungal Organism” (G. C. Ainsworth and A. S. Sussman, eds), pp. 339-369. Academic Press, London. Turian, G. (1978). Sexual morphogenesis in the ascomycetes. In “The Filamentous Fungi. Vol. 111: Developmental Biology” (J. E. Smith and D. R. Berry, eds), pp. 315-333. Edward Arnold, London. Uramaya, T. (1969). Stimulative effects of extract from fruit bodies of Agaricus bisporus and some hymenomycetes on primordia formation of Marasmius species. Transactions of the Mycological Society of Japan 10, 73-78. van den Ende, H. (1978). Sexual morphogenesis in the Phycomycetes. In “The
ASEXUAL AND SEXUAL REPRODUCTION IN FUNGI
87
Filamentous Fungi. Vol. 111: Developmental Biology” (J. E. Smith and D. R. Berry, eds), pp. 257-274. Edward Arnold, London. Wheeler, H. E. (1956). Sexual versus asexual reproduction in Glornerella. Mycologia 48, 349-353. Williams, G . C. (1975). Sex and evolution. In “Monographs in Population Biology”. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ. Willson, M. F. (1983). “Plant Reproductive Ecology,” Wiley, New York. Wilson, E. E. (1927). Effect of fungal extracts upon the initiation and growth of Venturia inaequalis in pure culture. Phytopathology 17, 835-836. Yaegashi, H. (1977). On the sexuality of blast fungi. Pyricularia species. Annals of the Phytopathology Society of Japan 43, 432-439.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
The Role of Leucine-Rich Repeat Proteins in Plant Defences
D. A. JONES and J. D. G . JONES
The Sainsbury Laboratory, John Innes Centre, Colney Lane, Norwich, NR4 7UH, UK
I.
Introduction
...........................................................................
11. Resistance Genes Encoding Proteins with Extracytoplasmic LRRs. A. Resistance Genes Encoding Membrane-anchored Proteins with Extracytoplasmic LRRs and no Kinase Domain ............. B. A Resistance Gene Encoding a Membrane-anchored Protein with Extracytoplasmic LRRs and a Cytoplasmic Kinase Domain .......................................................................... C. Avirulence Determinants that Interact with Resistance Proteins Containing Extracytoplasmic LRRs ..................................... D. Activation of Plant Defences by Resistance Genes Encoding Proteins Containing Extracytoplasmic LRRs ......................... 111. Resistance Genes Encoding Proteins with Cytoplasmic LRRs ....... A. Resistance Genes Encoding Proteins with Cytoplasmic LRRs and Potential Leucine Zippers ................................................ B. Resistance Genes Encoding Proteins with Cytoplasmic LRRs and Homology to the Cytoplasmic Domains of Toll and the Interleukin-1 Receptor ...................................................... C. A Gene Encoding a Protein with Cytoplasmic LRRs that is Required for a Resistance Gene to Function ........................ D. Avirulence Determinants that Interact with Resistance Proteins Containing Cytoplasmic LRRs ............................................ E. Activation of Plant Defences by Resistance Proteins Containing Cytoplasmic LRRs ........................................................... IV.
Defence-related Genes Encoding Proteins with Extracytoplasmic LRRs ................................................................................... A. Polygalacturonase-inhibiting Proteins ................................... B. LRR Extensins ................................................................ C. A Viroid-induced LRR Protein ..........................................
Advances in Botanical Research Vol. 24 incorporating Advances in Plant Pathology ISBN &12405924-X
90 91 91 95 97 99 101
102 108 109 113 114 119 120 127 131
Copyright 0 1997 Academic Press Limited All rights of reproduction in any form reserved
90 V.
VI.
D. A. JONES and J. D. G . JONES
Genes Encoding Proteins of Unknown Function with Extracytoplasmic LRRs ........................................................... A. The AWJL Proteins of Wheat ............................................ B. Receptor-like Protein Kinases ............................................
131 131 135
A Gene Encoding a Protein of Unknown Function with Cytoplasmic LRRs ...................................................................................
137
Evolution of Plant LRR Proteins ........................................ The Evolution of LRR Proteins in the Eukaryotes ................ Evolutionary Clues Provided by Intron Arrangements ............ Evolution of Different Specificities in LRR Proteins ..............
138 138 141 143
VIII. The Structure and Molecular Specificity of Plant LRR Proteins ...... A. Inferences about the Structure of Plant LRRs by Comparison with the Known Structure of Porcine Ribonuclease Inhibitor ... B. Inferences about the Structure and Interactions of Extracellular Plant LRR Proteins Based on their Potential Patterns of Glycosylation .................................................................. C. Inferences about the Interactions between Plant LRR Proteins and their Ligands Based on Comparisons with the Interactions between Ribonuclease Inhibitors and Ribonucleases ..............
144
VIT.
IX.
The A. B. C.
Concluding Remarks ............................................................... Acknowledgements ................................................................. References ............................................................................
144
147 150 153 156
156
I. INTRODUCTION After a long drought in our understanding of disease resistance in plants, a flood of information has now been unleashed by the isolation and characterization of a number of disease-resistance and other genes involved in plant defences. Already a recurrent theme is emerging, with genes encoding proteins containing leucine-rich repeats (LRRs) taking centre stage. LRR proteins are involved in specific protein-protein interactions and are confined predominantly to eukaryotes. The existence of LRR proteins in animals and fungi has been known for some time, but has been described only recently and incompletely for plants (for reviews see Kobe and Deisenhofer, 1994, 1995b). The first plant LRR proteins described were receptor serinekhreonine kinases and polygalacturonase-inhibiting proteins (PGIPs) (see sections VB and IVA). In contrast, the existence of disease-resistance genes in plants has been known since the 1900s. These genes confer the capacity to recognize specific races of plant pathogens and to initiate a defence response that is often, but not always, characterized by rapid plant-cell death at the site of infection. Similarly, the existence of genes in plant pathogens, which confer the capacity to be recognized by plants carrying specific resistance genes, has been known
LEUCINE-RICH REPEAT PROTEINS IN PLANT DEFENCES
91
since the 1940s. These genes have been designated avirulence genes. A precise genetic relationship (usually a one-to-one correspondence) exists between resistance genes in plants and avirulence genes in plant pathogens. Based on this relationship, the products of resistance genes and the products of avirulence genes are predicted to interact, resulting in the initiation and transduction of a defence activation signal. All this has been reviewed extensively previously (e.g. Gabriel and Rolfe, 1990; Keen, 1992), but the recent isolation of some avirulence genes, and the more recent isolation of some resistance genes, now allow a more critical assessment of this prediction at the molecular level. The first gene for race-specific resistance to a plant pathogen to be isolated and characterized was the tomato Pto gene for resistance to the bacterium Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato which causes specking in tomato (Martin et al., 1993). Pro encodes a serinehhreonine kinase, but does not contain LRRs. However, it has been shown to require an LRR protein to function (see section JIIC). Subsequent to the isolation of Pto, several resistance genes, all encoding LRR proteins, were isolated in quick succession. These resistance genes fall into two clear classes: those encoding proteins containing extracytoplasmic LRRs with the 24 amino acid consensus LxxLxxLxxLxLxxNxLxGxIPxx (see section II), and those encoding proteins containing cytoplasmic LRRs with the 23 or 24 amino acid consensus LxxLxxLxxLxLxx(N/C/T)x(x)LxxIPxx(see section 111).
11. RESISTANCE GENES ENCODING PROTEINS WITH EXTRACYTOPLASMIC LRRS The first resistance genes to be isolated in this class were the tomato Cf-9 gene for resistance to the fungus Cladosporium fulvum (syn. Fulvia fulva) (Jones et al., 1994), and the rice Xa-21 gene for resistance to the bacterium Xanfhomonas oryzae pv. oryzae (Song et al., 1995). These genes represent two subclasses of membrane-anchored extracytoplasmic LRR resistance genes, distinguishable by the presence or absence of a cytoplasmic serinehhreonine kinase domain. A. RESISTANCE GENES ENCODING MEMBRANE-ANCHORED PROTEINS WITH EXTRACYTOPLASMIC LRRs AND NO KINASE DOMAIN
The tomato C’9 gene for resistance to the fungus C . fulvum (syn. Fulvia fulva), which causes leaf mould in tomato, encodes an 863 amino acid, membrane-anchored, extracytoplasmic, glycoprotein containing 27 imperfect LRRs (originally reported as 28) averaging 24 amino acids in length (Fig. 1) (Jones er al., 1994). The LRRs show a good match to the extracytoplasmic LRR consensus LxxLxxLxxLxLxxNxLxGxIPxx (Table I). However, the
92
D. A. JONES and J . D. G. JONES
LRR domain is interrupted by a short region (domain C2 in Fig. l ) , designated a “loop out” domain, which was originally reported as an LRR, but which actually has little LRR homology. This domain divides the LRR domain into 23 amino terminal LRRs (domain C1) and 4 carboxyl terminal LRRs (domain C3). The short cytoplasmic carboxyl terminus of Cf-9 concludes with the motif KKxx, which as noted previously (Jones et al., 1994), may function to localize the protein to the endoplasmic reticulum. DNA gel blot analysis reveals Cf-9 to be a member of a multigene family with at least 10-12 members. Segregation analysis shows these to all be clustered on the short arm of chromosome 1 of tomato (M. Parniske, D. A. Jones, C. M. Thomas and J. D. G. Jones, unpublished). RNA gel blot analysis reveals only a single class of transcript which presumably contains mRNAs derived from several members of the gene family. Cf-4,located at the same complex locus on the short arm of chromosome 1 as Cf-9, encodes a protein that is very similar to that encoded by Cf-9 (C. M. Thomas, D.A. Jones, P. J. Balint-Kurti, K. Harrison and J. D. G. Jones, unpublished). Interestingly, the carboxyl terminal portion of Cf-4 is identical to Cf-9, suggesting that the specificity differentiating Cf-4 from Cf-9 must reside in the amino terminal portions of these proteins. If specificity of resistance gene function is determined by direct binding of the Avr ligand then the conserved carboxyl termini are presumably not involved in ligand binding. A third Cf gene, Cf-2, isolated from a complex resistance locus located near the centromere of chromosome 6 of tomato, comprises two closely linked, nearly identical genes (designated Cf-2. I and Cf-2.2) encoding 1112 amino acid proteins that differ by only three residues (Dixon et al., 1996). Both Cf-2 genes confer resistance independently. The Cf-2 proteins are membrane-anchored, extracytoplasmic glycoproteins similar to Cf-9, but lack the KKxx motif of Cf-9, suggesting that either Cf-9 functions in a different
Fig. 1. Primary structure of the predicted Cf-9 protein (Jones et al., 1994). The amino acid sequence, shown in single-letter code, has been divided into seven domains A to G. A, the predicted signal peptide; B, the predicted mature amino terminus; C, the LRR domain; D, a connecting domain; E, acidic domain; F, the predicted transmembrane domain; G, basic domain. Domains E, F and G are predicted to anchor and orient Cf-9 in the cell membrane, so that domains B , C and D are extracytoplasmic domains and domain G is a cytoplasmic domain. Domains B and D show homology to the polygalacturonase-inhibitingproteins (PGIPs) (see section IVA) and receptor-like protein kinases (RLPKs) (see section VC) (Jones et al., 1994). Domain C has been divided into three subdomains C1 to C3. C1 and C3, LRR domains; C2, a “loop-out” domain which departs from the LRR consensus. LRRs have been numbered sequentially from the amino terminus. Potential N glycosylation sites are underlined. Residues matching the LRR consensus LxxLxxLxxLxLxxNxLxGxIPxx,in which L and I tend to be substituted by each other and by M, V and F, are highlighted in bold. The vertical lines bracket the region predicted to form a solvent-exposed p sheet.
I
LEUCINE-RICH REPEAT PROTEINS IN PLANT DEFENCES
A
MDCVKLVFLMLYTFLCQLALSSS
B
LPHLCPEDQALSLLQFKNMFTINPWDYCYDIR TYVDIQSYPRTLSW&!&!TSCCSWDGVHCDETTGQ
c1
V LFQLSNL FGEFSE ICHLSKL LKNLTOL SHL VFHLSNL WSASL FSHLTSL LWJJJJNI FTIFEKL LSFNTQL SGLQNL IFSLPSL FKS KTL LLNQKNL ICNLKTL VERNEYL FSVGNIL MINCKYL LGYLFQL TNLFMGL LGNLQTW
IALDLRC KRLDLSF ZHLDLSH HVLRICD RELNLES TTLQLSG QSLHLSV MTLYVDS HELYMGR VFLHLGD KRLSLVN ERLDLSS ECLYLSS VELDLSK SAVTLKQ QLLLLSH ILLDLGS SHLDLSK RVISLHG TLLDLGN KILSLRS QILDLSS KEID
SQ NN SS QY
LQGKFHSE FTGSLISPK FTGLIPSE GLSLVPYNFELL VN ISSTIPSB TE LHGILPER NPQLTVRFPTTK VN IADRIPKS CN LSGPIPKP NH LEGPISH NN FDGGLEF NS LTGPIPSB NH L m I P s w FSGKIQE NK LKGRIPNS NN ISGHISSA NN LEGTIPQCV NR LSGTINTT NK LTGKVPRS NM LNmFPNW NK LHGPIKSSGN NG FSGNLPERI
93
signal peptide
LRRl 1rr2 1rr3 1rr4 1rr5 1rr6 1rr7 1rr8 1rr9 LRRlO 1rr11 1rr12 1rr13 1rr14 1rr15 1rr16 1rr17 1rr18 1rr19 LRR20 LRR21 LRR22 LRR23
c2 ESTGFPEYISDPYDIYYNYLTTISTKGQDYDS lOOpOUt c3 VRILDSN , M I I m KNR IGDLVGL R T L U H NV PQNLsVL 'ESLDLSSNK NH LASLTFL
HMLVEI
FEGHIPSI LEGHIPAS ISGEIPQQ LVGCIPKG
LRR24 LRR25 LRR26 LRR27
D
KQFDSFGmYQGNDGLRGFPLSKLCGG
E
EDQVTTPAELDQEEEEEDSPMISWQ
acidic domain
F
GVLVGYGCGLVIGLSVIYIMSTQ
hydrophobic domain
G
YPAWFSRMDLKLEHIITTKMKKHKKRY
basic domain
TABLE I LRR consensus sequences for plant proteins with extracytoplasmic LRRs and a known or possible role in plant defences Protein
Species
Repeatsa
Consensus sequenceb
Reference
L--L--L--LDLS-N-L-G-IP-a N a
Jones et al. (1994)
LGNL--L--L-L--N-L-GSIP-Y
Dixon et al. (1996)
Xa-21
Lycopersicon pimpinellifolium Lycopersicon pimpinellifolium Oryza sativa
L--L--L--L-L--N-L-G-IpsI I 1
Song et al. (1995)
PGIP
Actinidia deliciosa
Simpson er al. (1995)
PGIP
Antirrhinum majus
PGIP
Glycine max
PGIP PGIP
Lycopersicon esculentum Phaseolus vulgaris
PGIP
Pyrus communis
LRP
Lycopersicon esculentum Lycopersicon esculentum Zea mays
aG-L--L--L-as-NKLTG-IP-S N S L--L--L-SL-LSRNRLSG-IP-H N T a-SLK-L--LDLS-NNL-G-IP-aP L aG-LPNL--L-LSR"Ln;-IP- S S K H + A/G aA-LK-L--L-LS-NNL-G-IP-G P R F--LK-L--L-LS-NNLSG-IPP K T LG-L--L--LDL-NN-L-GTIP-E V I S L--L--L--L-LS-N-F-G-aP-a a N a L--L--L--1DaS-N-F-G-aP-a a a N
Cf-9
Cf-2
LRR extensin LRR extensin
\o P
-
Steinmayr et al. (1994)
P ?
Favaron et al. (1994) Stotz et al. (1994) Toubart et al. (1992) Stotz et al. (1993) Tornero et al. (1996)
D. A. Jones (unpublished) Rubinstein et al. (1995)
aThe number of full-length LRRs is indicated together with the number of incomplete LRRs in parentheses. bAmino acid residues are shown in single-letter code. Residues matching the LRR consensus LxxLxxLxxLxLxxNxLxGxIPxx are highlighted in bold. a, The aliphatic residues L, I, M, V or F; -, any residue; +, positively charged residues K or R. Where single residues are shown these comprise more than 50% of the residues at this position. Where two residues are shown, the two residues together comprise more than 50% of the residues at this position, with the upper of the two being more frequent.
c
P F
LEUCINE-RICH REPEAT PROTEINS IN PLANT DEFENCES
95
cellular location to Cf-2, which might account for the differences in the response to their respective avirulence peptides (Hammond-Kosack and Jones, 1994; Hammond-Kosack et a f . , 1996; May et al., 1996), or this motif has little bearing on the resistance function of these proteins. Each Cf-2 protein has 38 LRRs which show a good match to the extracytoplasmic LRR consensus LxxLxxLxxLxLxxNxLxGxIPxx (Table I). Of these, 34 (LRRs 2-31 and 35-38) are exactly 24 amino acids in length, and 20 (LRRs 6-24) show an alternating structure of two highly conserved repeats designated type A and B, reminiscent of the alternating LRRs of the porcine ribonuclease inhibitor (see section VIIIA). Type A repeats have the consensus EEIGYLRSL(T/N)xL(D/S/G)LSENALNGSIP and type B repeats have the consensus ASLGNLNNLS(M/F/R)L(Y/F/N)LYNNQLSGSIP. These repeats are arranged (AB)3AB4(AB)4A followed by the first five residues of a B repeat. Interestingly, the carboxyl terminal 360 amino acids of Cf-2 show high homology with the carboxyl terminal 352 amino acids of Cf-9, which includes the region that is identical between Cf-9 and Cf-4, suggesting that this region of conservation may play a similar and important role in all three proteins. This region includes the LRR domains C1 and C3, and domains D, E and F, but to a lesser extent the “loop out” domain C2 and domain G (Fig. 2). A “loop out” domain seems to be absent from most other extracytoplasmic LRR proteins and may play an important role unique to the Cf proteins, possibly as a molecular hinge connecting the two flanking LRR regions. It seems unlikely that the conserved flanking LRRs are involved in ligand binding, but it is possible that this region interacts with other protein components of a defence-activation, signal-transduction pathway. The conservation between Cf-9 and Cf-2 in this region suggests that they might interact with similar components, but the difference in the phenotypes conferred by Cf-9 and Cf-2 suggests they may be distinct. Alternatively, the differences in phenotype may be due to a difference in gene expression. Cf-5, located at the same complex locus on chromosome 6 as Cf-2, encodes a protein that is very similar to that encoded by Cf-2, but with fewer LRRs (K. Hatzixanthis, M. S. Dixon, K. Harrison, D. A.Jones and J. D. G. Jones, unpublished). B. A RESISTANCE GENE ENCODING A MEMBRANE-ANCHORED PROTEIN WITH EXTRACYTOPLASMIC LRRS AND A CYTOPLASMIC KINASE DOMAIN
The rice Xa-21 gene for resistance to the bacterium X. o. pv. oryzae, which causes leaf blight in rice, encodes a 1025 amino acid, glycoprotein with an extracytoplasmic receptor domain containing 23 LRRs linked by a single transmembrane domain to a cytoplasmic serinehhreonine kinase domain (Song et al., 1995). The LRRs of Xa-21 also match the extracytoplasmic LRR consensus LxxLxxLxxLxLxxNxLxGxIPxx (Table I). Unlike the Cf genes there is no conspicuous “loop out” within the LRR domain. D N A gel blot
96
D. A. JONES and J . D. G. JONES
c1 C f -9 C f -2
VERNEYL SHLDLSK NRLSWINTT F G U S L EVFDMQN NKLSGTLPTN
LRRl8 LRR29
C f -9 C f -2
FSVGNIL RVISLHG NKLTGKVPRS mIGcsL ISLNLHG NELEDEIPRS
LRR19 LRR30
C f -9 C f -2
MINCKYL TLLDLGN -FPNW LDNCKKL QVLDLGD NQLmFPMW
LRR20 LRR31
Cf-9 C f -2
LGYLFQL KILSLRS NKLHGPIKSSGN LRR21 LGTLPEL RVLRLTS NICLHGPIRSSRA LRR32
C f -9 C f -2
TNLFMGL QILDLSS NGFSGNLPERI EIMFPDL RIIDLSR NAFSQDLPTSL
LRR22 LRR33
C f -9 C f -2
LGNLQTM KEID FEHLKGM RTVD
LRR23 LRR34
c2 C f - 9 C f -2
c3 C f -9 C f -2
ESTGFPEYISDPYDIYYNYLTTISTKGQDYDS KTMEEPS YSSYYDDSWWTKGLELEI VRILDSN M I I M K NRFEGHIPSI LRR24 LRR35 VRILSLY TVIDLSS NKFEGHIPSV
C f -9 C f -2
IGDLVGL R T L U H NVLEGHIPAS LGDLIAI R I L U H NALQGYIPSS
LRR25 LRR36
C f -9 C f -2
FQNLSVL ESLDLSS NKISGEIPQQ LGSLSIL ESLDLSF NQLSGEIPQQ
LRR26 LRR37
C f -9 C f -2
LASLTFL E V L m H NHLVGCIPKG LASLTFL E F L U H NYLQGCIPQG
LRR27 LRR38
Cf-9 C f -2
KQFDSFGmYQGNDGLRGFPLSKLCGG
E
C f -9 C f -2
EDQVTTPAELDQEEEEEDSPMISWQ DPVSEWSALEDQESNSEFFNDF WK
Fa
C f -9 C f -2
GVLVGYGCGLVIGLSVIYIMWSTQ AALMGYGSGLCIGISIIYILISTG
D
G
PQFRTFESNSYEGNDGLRGYPVSKGCGK
C f -9 YPAWFSRMDLKLEHIITTKMKKHKKRY* C f -2 NLRWLARIIEELEHKIIMQRRKKQRGQRNYRRFWNRF* Fig. 2. Comparison of the primary structures of the Cf-9 and Cf-2.1 proteins in the conserved carboxyl terminal portions of the proteins. Various features are indicated as described in Fig. 1, except that identical residues are highlighted in bold.
LEUCINE-RICH REPEAT PROTEINS IN PLANT DEFENCES
97
analysis, with a probe that hybridizes to the Xu-22 coding sequence, revealed a gene family with eight members and segregation analysis showed that at least seven of these co-segregate with Xu-21, indicating a complex resistance locus. RNA gel blot analysis revealed a 3.1 kb band corresponding to the expected full-length Xa-21 transcript, and three additional smaller bands which may correspond to alternative splice products or to other members of the Xu-21 gene family which may have fewer LRRs. The Xa-21 protein shows homology with the receptor-like serinehhreonine kinases TMKl (Chang et al., 1992) and RLKS (Walker, 1993) from Arabidopsis, the receptor-like Cf-9 protein (Jones et a f . , 1994) and the Pto serinekhreonine kinase (Martin et al., 1993). Xu-21 provides a conceptual link between resistance genes that seem to encode a receptor but lack a signalling mechanism (i.e. the Cfgenes) and those that encode a signalling mechanism but lack a receptor (i.e. Pro), suggesting that the Cfgenes may in fact activate plant defences by interaction with a signalling component such as a protein kinase and that Pto may interact with and require activation by a receptor. It also raises the possibility that receptor-like protein kinases with no known function (see section VB) may in fact be resistance proteins analogous to Xa-21.
C. AVIRULENCE DETERMINANTS THAT INTERACT WITH RESISTANCE GENES ENCODING PROTEINS CONTAINING EXTRACYTOPLASMIC LRRs
The C. fulvum Avr9 gene encodes a mature secreted avirulence peptide of 28 amino acids (van den Ackerveken et ul., 1992). This peptide elicits a necrotic response in plants carrying Cf-9, but not in plants lacking Cf-9, and seems likely to be the ligand that interacts directly with the Cf-9 protein. However, binding studies, using 1251 labelled Avr9 peptide, show that membranes from tomato plants lacking Cf-9 bind Avr9 to the same extent as membranes from plants carrying Cf-9 (Kooman-Gersmann et ul., 1996). Membranes from other solanaceous species also bind Avr9. However, these plants although lacking Cf-9, carry Cf-9 homologues that might also bind Avr9. It is possible that only Cf-9 is able to trigger the activation of plant defences in response to Avr9 binding. Thus, the specificity of interaction between resistance and avirulence gene products may be a combination of the ability not only to bind the avirulence ligand but also to generate the appropriate signal. Alternatively, Avr9 may bind to other proteins and produce a high background of binding upon which a low amount of Cf-9-specific binding is superimposed. If Avr9 does bind to other proteins, it is possible that Cf-9 recognizes a conformational change in one of these proteins rather than recognizing Avr9 directly. The Avr9 peptide is folded into three anti-parallel p strands connected by loops and cross-linked by three disulphide bonds forming a compressed barrel-like structure (Vervoort et at., 1996). This structure is extremely small
98
D. A. JONES and J . D. G . JONES
in relation to the Cf-9 protein, implying a very small area of contact. The presumed interactive face of the Avr9 peptide contains a number of positively charged residues. Cf-4 interacts specifically with the C. fufvum Avr4 gene which encodes a mature secreted peptide of 106 amino acids (Joosten et u f . , 1994). There is no amino acid sequence similarity between Avr4 and Avr9, but both have a similar proportion of charged residues (23.5% for Avr4 and 25% for Avr9) and a similar ratio of 2.5 times more basic residues than acidic residues, so Avr4 may also have a positively charged interactive face. The positively charged residues of Avr4 are composed entirely of lysine residues except for a single histidine. Avr4 is also proline rich (16%), and therefore differs significantly from Avr9 which has no proline residues. The Avr2 avirulence determinant, although not yet isolated, also seems to be a small secreted peptide (P. J. G. M. De Wit, unpublished). The uvrXu21 avirulence gene of X . 0. pv. oryzae has not been characterized, but a number of other Xunthornonas avirulence genes, including avrxa5, avrXa7 and avrXal0, form a homologous group of which uvrXu21 may be a member. The uvrXa10 gene has been sequenced and found to encode a protein with tandem-repeats of a highly conserved 34 amino acid motif LTPxQVVAIASxxGGKQALETVQRLLPVLCQxHG (Hopkins et u f . , 1992). These repeats suggest a structural rather than enzymatic function for these avrXa proteins, and therefore that they may interact directly with resistance gene proteins. A protein ligand would also be consistent with the LRR nature of the receptor domain in the Xa-21 protein. Xu-10 and Xu-21 are members of the same resistance gene cluster on chromosome 11 of rice (Ronald et af., 1992), so it seems likely that they may encode related receptor protein kinases that interact with similar avirulence ligands. Homologous avirulence genes from other Xunthomonas pathovars have also been isolated and sequenced. These include the avrBs3 and uvrBs3-2 genes from Xunthomonus cumpestris pv. vesicatoriu (Bonas et al., 1989, 1993), the avrb6 gene from Xunthomonus campestris pv. mulvucearum (De Feyter et af., 1993) and thepthA gene from Xanthomonus citri (Genbank Accession U28802). These genes show variation in the number of repeats of the 34 amino acid motif, with avrb6 having 13.5, avrXalO having 15.5, and avrBs3, avrBs3-2 and pthA having 17.5. These genes also show variation at four positions within the 34 amino acid repeat consensus with A, D, E, Q or V at position 4, N or H at position 12, D, G , I, N or S at position 13 and A or D at position 32. Each gene shows a distinct pattern of residues in these positions and these are thought to determine the avirulence specificity. Deletion analysis of the avrBs3 gene provides additional evidence to support this hypothesis (Herbers et af., 1992). Precise deletions of internal repeats in uvrBs3 has several different effects on pathogenicity towards near-isogenic lines of pepper either carrying Bs3 or lacking Bs3. Some retained avirulence on Bs3, some showed intermediate avirulence and the remainder showed no avirulence. Surprisingly, some of the latter had lost their avrBs3 specificity,
LEUCINE-RICH REPEAT PROTEINS IN PLANT DEFENCES
99
but gained new specificities, including avirulence to the recessive bs3 allele which hitherto did not confer resistance. Similar changes in specificity have also been observed among intragenic recombinants of the pthA gene of X . citri (Yang and Gabriel, 1995b). The generation of new specificity by artificially altering the number of repeats supports a model for the natural generation of new specificity by unequal cross-overs between repeats, which would increase or decrease their number and generate new permutations of the variable residues in the sequence. This may in part explain the different numbers of repeats seen not only for the 34 amino acid repeats of these avirulence genes, but also for the LRRs of the Cf genes of tomato and possibly for the Xu genes of rice. Despite the arguments in favour of a direct interaction between a cell surface receptor like Xa-21 and an avirulence protein like avrXal0, this hypothesis is not easily accommodated by observations that several of these avirulence proteins are o