Advances in ATOMIC AND MOLECULAR PHYSICS V O L U M E 13
CONTRIBUTORS TO THIS VOLUME BENJAMIN BEDERSON PAUL R. BERMAN ...
30 downloads
1187 Views
20MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Advances in ATOMIC AND MOLECULAR PHYSICS V O L U M E 13
CONTRIBUTORS TO THIS VOLUME BENJAMIN BEDERSON PAUL R. BERMAN MANFRED FAUBEL
I. V. HERTEL THOMAS M. MILLER
R. K. NESBET W. B. SOMERVILLE
W. STOLL J . PETER TOENNIES
ADVANCES IN
ATOMIC AND MOLECULAR PHYSICS Edited by
D. R. Bates DEPARTMENT OF APPLIED MATHEMATICS AND THEORETICAL PHYSICS THE QUEEN’S UNIVERSITY OF BELFAST BELFAST. NORTHERN IRELAND
Benjamin Bederson DEPARTMENT OF PHYSICS NEW YORK UNIVERSITY NEW YORK. NEW YORK
VOLUME 13
@
1977
ACADEMIC PRESS New York
San Francisco
A Subsidiary of Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, Publishers
London
COPYRIGHT 0 1977, BY ACADEMIC PRESS,INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO PART OF THIS PUBLICATION MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM OR BY ANY MEANS, ELECTRONIC OR MECHANICAL, INCLUDING PHOTOCOPY, RECORDING, OR ANY INFORMATION STORAGE AND RETRIEVAL SYSTEM, WITHOUT PERMISSION IN WRITING FROM THE PUBLISHER.
ACADEMIC PRESS, INC.
111 Fifth Avenue, New York, New York 10003
United Kingdom Editiorr priblislred by ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. (LONDON) LTD. 24/28 Oval Road, London N W l
LIBRARY O F CONGRESS CATALOG CARD NUMBER:65- 18423 ISBN 0-12-003813-7 PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Contents vii
LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS
Atomic and Molecular Polarizabilities- A Review of Recent Advances Thomus M . Miller und Benjumin Bederson I. Introduction 11. The Calculation of Polarizabilities 111. Experimental Measurements of Polarizabilities
1V. Future Possibilities for Polarizabilities References
i 10 21
47 51
Study of Collisions by Laser Spectroscopy Paul R . Berman I. Introduction 11. Collisions
Ill. IV. V. VI.
Three-Level Systems Transient Systems Experimental Survey-Theoretical Conclusions References
Outlook
51 60 65 90 100 106
110
Collision Experiments with Laser Excited Atoms in Crossed Beams
I . V . Hertelund W . Stoll I. Introduction 11. Basic Theory I l l . Excitation of Atoms by Laser Optical Pumping IV. Theory of Measurements in Scattering Experiments by Laser-Excited Atoms V. Collision Experiments Vl. Atomic Scattering Processes in the Presence of Strong Laser Fields VII. Conclusions References V
113
I I7 129
157 174 21 I 223 224
vi
CONTENTS
Scattering Studies of Rotational and Vibrational Excitation of Molecules Manfred Faubel and J . Peter Toennies 1. 11. 111. IV. V. VI.
Introduction Potential Hypersurfaces Inelastic Scattering Theory Experimental Methods Recent Experimental Results Summary References
229 238 248 257 274 307 308
Low-Energy Electron Scattering by Complex Atoms: Theory and Calculations R . K . Nesber I. 11. 111. IV.
Introduction Theory Methods Applications References
315 318 337 349 378
Microwave Transitions of Interstellar Atoms and Molecules W . B. Somerville 1. 11. 111. IV. V.
VI. VII. VIII. IX.
Introduction Spectroscopic Formulas Atomic Hyperfine Structure Atomic Fine Structure Recombination Lines Structure in Diatomic Molecules Transitions in Diatomic Molecules Rotation in Polyatomic Molecules Inversion in NH References
AUTHOR INDEX SUBJECT INDEX CONTENTS OF PREVIOUS VOLUMES
383 385 387 390 394 397 403 422 428 430 437 45 1 459
List of Contributors Numbers in parentheses indicate the pages on which the authors’ contributions begin.
BENJAMIN BEDERSON, Physics Department, New York University, New York, New York (1) PAUL R. BERMAN, Physics Department, New York University, New York, New York (57) MANFRED FAUBEL, Max-Planck-Institut fur Stromungsforschung, Gottingen, West Germany (229) I. V. HERTEL, Fachbereich Physik der Universitat Kaiserslautern, Kaiserslautern, West Germany (1 13)
THOMAS M. MILLER, Molecular Physics Center, Stanford Research Institute, Menlo Park, California (1) R. K. NESBET, IBM Research Laboratory, San Jose, California (315) W. B. SOMERVILLE, Department of Physics and Astronomy, University College, London, England (383) W. STOLL,* Fachbereich Physik der Universitat Kaiserslautern, Kaiserslautern, West Germany (1 13) J. PETER TOENNIES, Max-Planck-Institut fur Stromungsforschung, Gottingen, West Germany (229)
* Present address: Messer Griesheim GmbH, Diisseldorf. West Germany. vii
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
ATOMIC AND MOLECULAR POLARIZABILITIES-A REVIEW OF RECENT ADVANCES THOMAS M. MILLER hfolrcirlur Physics Cerilrr. Sturi/?)ri/ Rcwarclt Irr.sritulc>. Mrlllo Purk. Cfr/i/orrliu
arid
B E N J A M I N BEDERSON Physics Di,purrnicwr. New York Uiriorrsirj. Ncw York. New York 1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..................... A. Moments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
B. Matrix Elements . . . . . . ...................... II. The Calculation of Polarizah ..................... A. Summation of Oscillator Strengths . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Effective Quantum Numbers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Perturbation Theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D. R-Matrix Calculations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E. Variational Calculations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . F. Statistical Calculations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111. Experimental Measurements of Polarizab A. Bulk Experiments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Indirect Methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Beam Techniques.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D. Excited States . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E. Simple Molecules . . . . . . ......................... IV. Future Possibilities for Polari ......................... Appendix . . . . ......................................... References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
I 5 6 10 10 11
12 1X
19
42 46 47 49 51
I. Introduction The electric dipole polarizability of an atom or molecule describes the response in lowest order of the field strength of the electron cloud to an externa! electric field. This property plays an important role in those collision processes where the relevant electric field is that produced between collision partners, one or both of which is a neutral atom or molecule. Indeed, some
'\
7: M . Miller and B. Bederson
2
TABLE I MANIFESTATIONS OF THE ELECTRIC DIPOLEPOLARIZABILITY a” Long-range electron- or ion-atom interaction energy Ion mobility in a gas” Relation between a ( v ) and oscillator strengthsc van der Waals constant between systems N, b (Slater-Kirkwood approximation)” “
I/ =
-e2ai2r4
K = 13.876/(ap)”’ cm2/volt sec
15
Dipole-quadrupole” constant C S e
Clausius-Mosotti relationf Dielectric constante Index of refraction” Diamagnetic susceptibility‘
K ( v ) = 1 + 4nna(v) q(v) = I + 2nna(v) zrn‘v e2[uon,a]‘’2/4mc2
Verdet constant’
V ( v )=
Rayleigh scattering cross-section‘ Modified effective range cross-section’
vn d x ( v ) 2mc2 dv U ( V )= (8n/9~‘)(2nil)‘[3a(v)~3r(v’)] 8n2p Z2e2aAk ... o ( k ) = 4nA2 + 3 h2 ~
+ +
Langevin capture cross-section“‘ “0
Casimir-Polder effect“ x is the static polarizability; frequency-dependent polarizabilities are indicated by a(v), which reduce to a for v = 0. Anisotropic effects are not included, except where specifically noted; cgs units are used except where noted. a in units of A3, p is the ion-atom reduced mass in units of the proton mass. Assumes pure polarization interaction - e2a/2r4;classical limit. c,&or is the average oscillator strength over magnetic substates, and refers to a transition between the state whose polarizability is a(vo)and all other states connected to this state by dipole matrix elements. no. , are number of electrons in outer shells of a, 6 . a d , a, are the dipole and quadrupole polarizabilities; ad,aqare the average transition frequencies for dipole and quadrupole transitions (see Stwalley, 1970; Kramer and Herschbach, 1970). For a gas of atoms or of molecules that do not possess permanent electric dipole moments. q ( v ) is the frequency-dependent index of refraction. n is number density. Obtained from Clausius-Mosotti relation, assuming K o 1. q2(v) = K ( v ) . ’ In the approximation that the static polarizability is given by the variational formula
”
@
ATOMIC AND MOLECULAR POLARIZABILITIES
3
low-energy scattering process can be specified accurately by an expression that involves only one parameter-the polarizability. In some circumstances a part of the atom can also be assigned a welldefined polarizability. Thus, the “core polarizability ” refers to the polarizability of the inner shells and is an important parameter in determining quantum defects, nuclear shielding, and polarizabilities of ionized atoms. Clearly, the polarizability is particularly important in interactions where there is little interpenetration of the wavefunctions of the collision partners. The most loosely bound electrons play the largest role in the redistribution of the electron charge in an electric field; the valence electrons generally account for at least 90% of the polarizability of an atom or molecule. The manifestations of the atomic polarizability in collision phenomena are manifold. A testimony to its importance is the frequency with which one encounters an expression involving the polarizability. We have gathered a representative collection and give them in Table I, which also includes some references to frequency-dependent polarizabilities. Some of these expressions have been used as a basis for measuring the polarizability, for example, using dielectric constants or ion mobilities. It is sometimes difficult to track down published polarizability calculations for specific atoms and molecules, since these often appear as intermediate steps in other calculations. One of the best calculations of the polarizability of cesium is that of Norcross (1973), in a paper entitled “ Photoabsorption by Cesium.” Other examples are the papers of Ice and Olson (1975) entitled “Low-Energy Ar’, Kr’, Xe+ + K, Rb, Cs Charge Transfer Total Cross Sections,” and of Garrett (1965), Polarization and Exchange Effects in Slow-Electron Scattering from Lithium and Sodium,” in which atomic polarizabilities were calculated. “
(Table footnotes continued) (see Hirschfelder er 01.. 1954, p. 942 IT.). The correct definition of magnetic susceptibility per atom is
In the very crude approximation that all the energy denominators in the oscillator strength summation for a are equal to the ionization energy, x” = (E/4rnc2)a. j Defined from 0 = V(v)B, where 0 is the angle ofrotation of linearly polarized light through a medium ofdensity n, per unit length, for a longitudinal magnetic field strength B (Faraday effect). a(\,) = $a, ++all; ~ ( v =) a l l - a,. A is the scattering length, p the reduced mass, k the wavenumber of the scattered particle, pu/h (see OMalley et a/., 1962). I ’ is ~ the relative velocity of approach for an ion-neutral pair. V ( r )is interaction energy for two nonpolar molecules, at very large distances [ r 9 c E i / l i ] ,g is a numerical factor, and Ei equals an average over the excitation energies (Casimir and Polder, 1938).
’ ‘
7: M. Miller. a i d B. Bcilerson
4
This article will review recent advances in the experimental and theoretical determination of the polarizabilities of simple atoms and molecules. We will concentrate primarily on static (as opposed to frequency-dependent) polarizabilities, although some discussion of the latter will be presented. Higher-order polarizabilities, which are becoming increasingly accessible to observation because of the availability of high-intensity lasers, will also be briefly discussed. The perturbation of atomic levels by electric fields was first reported by Stark (1913) and independently by LoSurdo (1913). The “Stark effect” was treated theoretically by Epstein (1916), who was later to apply the new quantum theory to the same problem (Epstein, 1926). Polarizability values (related to the quadratic Stark effect ”) are accurately known for the noble gas atoms and for hydrogen, in theory, but the remainder of the periodic table has proven much more difficult to deal with, both theoretically and experimentally. The static electric dipole polarizability of the ground-state hydrogen atom is almost exactly 4.5ai, where a, is the Bohr radius. Across rows of the periodic table, polarizabilities range from hundreds (of a: units) for the alkali metal atoms generally monotonically down to a few for noble gas atoms. Excited atoms have much larger polarizabilities; recent polarizability measurements for atoms in Rydberg orbits have yielded values on the order of 1 0 ’ O a ~In . Fig. 1 we have plotted the polarizabilities of the atoms in the first row of the periodic table. On the same graph we show the polarizability anisotropy, which indicates the importance of the orientation “
FIG.1. Atomic polarizabilities and polarizability anisotropies across the first row of the periodic table. (Results of Werner and Meyer, 1976.)
ATOMIC AND MOLECULAR POLARIZABILITIES
5
of the atom in an external electric field. The anisotropy is largest when the first p electron is added (boron) and becomes smaller for successive P states as the valence shell fills. A. MOMENTS
An atom or molecule in a uniform electric field E has an electric dipole moment p = po
+ a - E + jfl:E2 + 6y iE3 + ...
(1)
We will deal with cases where there is no permanent dipole moment po, only induced moments. Thus this discussion is restricted to the class of all atoms, and homonuclear molecules. For spherically symmetric states p is zero. One is generally concerned only with the polarizability a, a second-rank tensor; however, the kyperpolarizability y (a fourth-rank tensor) is of current interest in relation to laser studies of nonlinear effects in atoms. Higher-order hyperpolarizabilities are not significant in present-day experiments. Practically speaking, for static laboratory fields the induced electric dipole moment is adequately described by the polarizability a. If intense laser radiation fields are also present, then both the polarizability a and the hyperpolarizability y are needed to determine the induced electric dipole moment, although of course for this situation one is referring to a(v), y(v), where v is the frequency of the laser field. For the ground state of the hydrogen atom, the polarizability a, as already mentioned, is 4 . 5 ~ 4 ,while the hyperpolarizability y is exactly 1333.12%; /Hartree. The hyperpolarizability should not be confused with higher-order multipoles of the atomic charge distribution. The full quadrupole moment also contains induced terms, which depend on the electric field strength and on the field gradient. A complete treatment of the dipole and quadrupole expansions and the symmetry properties of the coefficients has been given by Buckingham (1967). All coefficients in these expansions depend upon the frequency of the applied external electric field. We are interested primarily in dc fields and most of our discussion will be for static polarizabilities. The polarizability is not significantly different from its static value for frequencies of the external electric field much less than the frequency corresponding to the lowest excitation energy of the atom. For resonant frequencies or very large frequencies the atom may absorb energy from the external field via excitation or ionization of the atom, and loss of flux to these channels will affect the polarizability. Calculation of the polarizability for complex frequencies yields the total photoionization cross section, proportional to a(io),where i denotes the imaginary part of the angular frequency o. We have not mentioned dipole and quadrupole shielding factors that
T M . Miller and B. Bederson
6
involve different matrix elements than will be emphasized below, but the calculational methods are the same. The dipole shielding factor is the ratio of the change in the electric field at the nucleus due to the redistribution of the atomic charge, to the strength of the external electric field at the nucleus. The dipole shielding factor is determined by the operator P,(cos Oi)/$, where the sum is over the N electrons of the atom, ri and Oi are radial and angular coordinates for the ith electron, and P,(cos Oi) is a Legendre polynomial of order K.The quadrupole shielding factor depends on the operator P,(cos Oi)/r;.Dipole and quadrupole shielding factors are required for the determination of nuclear moments from measurements of atomic hyperfine structure. They correct for the distortion by core electrons of the effectof nuclear moments on the energy of the valence electrons. According to the Hellpann-Feynman theorem (Chang et al., 1968), the dipole shielding factor is unity for a neutral atom and N / Z in general. Application of various theoretical techniques to its calculation provides grounds for comparisons between these techniques.
B. MATRIXELEMENTS It is customary to treat the external electric field as a perturbation. The perturbation hamiltonian is - p E, where p is the dipole operator -e ri . The summation is of the position coordinates ri of the N electrons in the atom. The electronic charge is e. The first-order energy correction (t,b0 I p * E I$o) is zero if the unperturbed state I$o) has definite parity. This is to say that there is no permanent dipole moment. The second-order energy correction W,is quadratic in E,
xi"'
where ri is a unit vector defined by E = En, k denotes a state of the atom of energy & k , and the sum is over all states of the atom except for k = 0. We can compare this energy correction to the negative integral of Eq. (l),
W = -4a:E' (31 in which we have taken po = fl= 0 and have ignored higher-order dipole polarizabilities. We see that the second-order energy correction in perturbation theory may be identified with the polarizability a. The fourth-order energy correction gives 7. If we consider a Cartesian coordinate system (x, y, z), the components of the polarizability tensor are
ATOMIC A N D MOLECULAR POLARIZABILITIES
7
The components of the hyperpolarizability tensor are (Buckingham, 1967) Yijmn
= S(i, j , m, n)
C
kto
where i, j , m,n = x, y, z, and S(i,j, m,n) is a symmetrizing operator implying a summation over all the 24 permutations of i, j, m, n in the expression following S(i,j , m, n). We have already indicated that odd-order energy corrections for spherically symmetric atoms are zero. There are also simplificationsin the a and y tensors for isotropic systems. The a and y tensors themselves must be isotropic; the only second-order isotropic tensors are scalar multiples of the unit tensor 6,; therefore,
aij = aaij (6) where a is a scalar and fully represents the polarizability for S-state atoms. Fourth-order isotropic tensors have nonzero components only when i, j , m, and n occur in pairs. The most general isotropic fourth-order tensor can be written Yijmn
=Bijdmn
+ 4 d i m d j n + d i n a j m ) + v ( a i m 6 j n - dindjm)
(7)
The fourth-order energy correction is w 4=
-2%y34
(8)
which is
where i,j, m,n = x, y, z. Substituting for y i j m the general isotropic formgiven in Eq. (7), we find
W, = -&(A where E Z = Ef
+ 2p)~4
+ E,' + EI. In Eq. (9) we note that
(10) )'xxxx
= yyyy,, = yzzzz =
7: M . Miller urirl B. Bederson
8
A + 2p. so that if we define a scalar 7 = yxxxx = yyyyy = -yzzZz we can write a purely scalar equation,
w4 -- -241'E4 1
(11) For spherically symmetric atoms then, we have the energy given to fourth order by W = Wo - i a E 2 - 1 , E4 241 (12)
The geometric arguments above were given by Grasso et al. (1968). In general, the calculation of atomic polarizabilities will involve nonspherical wavefunctions and the polarizability will depend on the orientations of the atom in the electric field. However, the polarizability tensor components are not necessarily independent. If the electric field direction is chosen to be along the axis ofsymmetry of the atom, the off-diagonal components vanish, and a,, = a,. The dipole operator p is a so-called T operator (Condon and Shortley, 1951) whose components satisfy the same commutation rules with the components J,, J,, and J , of the total angular momentum J as do J,, J,, and J , themselves. The tensor components a,,(m and a,,(rn are then (Bederson and Robinson, 1966) J )
a,,(m,) = A ( J ~+ mf - J ) + B ( J + ~J a&,)
J)
- mf)
+ C(J2 + 35 + 2 + mf) = 2A(J2 - m f ) + 2Bm: + 2C(J2 + 25 + 1 - mf)
where
(13a) (13b)
and p = )PI, and J , J' are the total angular momenta for the t,h0 and j k states, respectively. It can be shown that of the 2(2J + 1) equations represented by Eq. (13), only two are independent. The difference between any two tensor components is a multiple of A - B + C :
+C) - aXx(mJ,) = (m: - m;,)(A - B + C ) - axx(mJ,) = ( J 2 + J - 2mf - m f . ) ( A- B + C )
azz(mJ)- aZZ(mJ,) = 2(m:,
a,,(m,) a,,(m,)
-
mf)(A - B
(14a) (14b) (14c)
ATOMIC A N D MOLECULAR POLARIZARILITIES
9
Therefore, once two independent components are determined, the full polarizability tensor for any mJ can be obtained from Eq. (14). We note from Eq. (13) that the tensor components are independent of the sign of m ,, and that if J = f the polarizability is a scalar. The two independent polarizability quantities are frequently expressed in terms of an isotropic part (the average polarizability) and a nonisotropic part (the anisotropy or the “tensor” polarizability). The average polarizability cl is defined as the average of either a,, or azzover m, . Equivalently, Cr is the average of a,, , a,,,,, and a,, for a given m ,:
or = 4(2a,,
+ a::)
(15)
and B is the same for all m , . The polarizability anisotropy [generally denoted by y(m,), not to be confused with the hyperpolarizability 71 is defined as a,Z(iiiJ) - axx(mJ),a quantity that depends on m,. The “tensor” polarizability a, is similar to the anisotropy except that the m, dependence is removed:
aZ,(m,) = B + c1,(3m$ - J~
- J)/J(2J -
I)
(16)
From Eqs. (13) and (15) it follows that ~ 1 ,=
-+J(2J - l ) ( A - B
+C)
(17)
When the symmetry axis of the atom is exactly parallel to the external electric field, the polarizability is denoted by a ,I ; in the perpendicular case it is aL.In the laboratory the symmetry axis of the atom cannot be oriented exactly along the field direction and instead of a ,I the projection of c1 lI along the field direction is measured, namely, azz (mJ = J). The matrix elements for the polarizability are similar to those for the dimensionless oscillator strengths fok except for the energy factor, where
and
+ 1) = ( J + 1)(2J + 3), q ( J , J - 1) = 4 2 5 - 1) q ( J , J ) = J ( J + I), q(J,J
and me and e are the electronic mass and charge. Comparing Eqs. (13) and (18), the average polarizability may be written
10
7: M . Miller and B. Bederson
This equation is useful because frequently values of fOk are available from experimental or theoretical work on atomic transitions, and an estimate of the average polarizability may be calculated from knowledge of these.
11. The Calculation of Polarizabilities Theoretical calculations of polarizabilities have been made by a variety of techniques-semiempirical, perturbation, variational, and statistical-with some intermixing of these concepts. Some calculations are attempts to obtain “exact” results (or rigorous bounds) to an arbitrary degree of accuracy for specific atoms, while others are aimed at finding a rapid technique that can be more easily applied to any atom, sacrificing accuracy. Fortunately, a number of theorists have investigated the relationship between different methods. A. SUMMATION OF OSCILLATOR STRENGTHS
The simplest theoretical technique for the calculation of dipole polarizabilities involves the summation of oscillator strengths, using Eq. (19). The oscillator strengths satisfy a sum rule 1.fOk
=N
where the summation includes oscillator strengths for all possible electronic transitions including ionization. It would not be feasible actually to obtain a l l f o p ,but Eqs. (19) and (20) allow one to place bounds on the polarizability. If& is taken to represent known oscillator strengths (whether experimental or theoretical), and Fk are the remaining unknown oscillator strengths, then Eq. (20) becomes and the contribution of the unknown oscillator strengths Fk to the polarizability is
An upper bound to the unknown contribution Aa is given by taking the smallest possible energy difference &’:in :
ATOMIC A N D MOLECULAR POLARIZABILITIES
11
Then, we can place bounds on CC:
Dalgarno and Kingston (1959) used the oscillator strength sum rule for the alkali metal atoms. Except for lithium, almost all of the contribution to the sum comes from the resonance transition no S-no P, where tio is the principal quantum number of the ground state. Since only the valence electron is important, N z 1. Dalgarno and Kingston used experimental and theoretical estimates of oscillator strengths and estimated the accuracy of the results to be within about 5 % except for cesium (10%). Their results are in accord with the latest experimental measurements of the alkali polarizabilities. Altick (1964) used experimental oscillator strengths to place bounds on the polarizabilities of the alkaline earth atoms, for which there were no other data at the time. Cohen (1967) determined bounds on the polarizabilities of a number of neutral atoms and ions using experimental and theoretical oscillator strengths. Included were the alkali metal atoms, the alkaline earth atoms, and metastable helium states. [Unfortunately, the experimental resonance oscillator strengths used by Altick and Cohen for the alkaline earth atoms were low (Stwalley, 1971).] The alkali atom calculations tend to compare well to experiment, while the alkaline earth results are somewhat low. Hyman (1974) has calculated the polarizabilities of the alkaline earth atoms from experimental oscillator strengths. B. EFFECTIVE QUANTUM NUMBERS
A semiempirical perturbation method has been developed by Adelman and Szabo (1973), which is an improvement over the coulomb approximation of Dalgarno and Pengelly (1966). They utilize an effective (nonintegral) principal quantum number obtained from the ionization potential, and an effective angular momentum quantum number related to the ionization potential of the closest electric-dipole-allowed state to the state under consideration. Explicit core effects are neglected by Adelman and Szabo, but the use of effective quantum numbers compensates for this neglect to some degree. An analytic expression is given for the 2I-pole static electric polarizability for atoms. The expression is evaluated for the dipole and quadrupole polarizabilities of many neutral atoms and ions. The results for S-state monovalent atoms seem remarkably good. The results for divalent atoms and P-state atoms are somewhat less reliable.
12
7: M . Miller and B. Bederson
C. PERTURBATION THEORY In relation to the early work on the summation of oscillator strengths, it may be said that the goal of perturbation theory is to avoid a summation over states. The average polarizability can be written
where $o is the unperturbed wavefunction and $ the first-order correction. The electronic coordinates are (xi, y i , zi). The first-order correction to the wavefunction satisfies
(Ho -
~ ) l $ l => ei=x1(xi + Yi + zi)1@0)
(251
where H o is the unperturbed hamiltonian and Wothe zeroth-order energy. In the case of spherically symmetric atoms, the average polarizability is simply ~ = 2 e < $ o ICzi1$1> i= 1
(26)
Various approaches have been used to determine Go and $ There is the intuitive idea that a Hartree-Fock procedure should give accurate polarizabilities (Musher, 1967 ; Kreiger and Kaufman, 1976).The most straightforward approach is the so-called coupled Hartree-Fock method of Dalgarno (1959), Allen (1960), and Kaneko (1959). This is a fully self-consistent procedure, which leads to perturbed orbitals that are coupled both by direct and exchange interactions. The solution involves laborious computation (Dalgarno, 1962). However, the results are the best obtainable within the Hartree-Fock approximation, in which the wavefunctions are written as an antisymmetrized product of one-electron spin-orbitals. The perturbed Hartree-Fock wavefunction is variationally determined. The coupled Hartree-Fock method has only been applied to six elements, in the first two rows of the periodic table (also to some ions). There have been efforts to find approximations that uncouple the firstorder Hartree-Fock equations. Comparisons of the various methods have been given by Langhoff et al. (1966), Chang et al. (1968), and Tuan and Davidz (1971).Langhoff and Hurst (1965) have shown that Dalgarno’s original uncoupled Hartree-Fock theory (1962) is equivalent to the application of first-order perturbation theory to the unperturbed Hartree-Fock problem. Other uncoupled approximations retain some additional terms present in the coupled equations but prove easier computationally (Langhoff et al., 1966; Yoshimine and Hurst, 1964; Langhoff and Hurst, 1965). Dalgarno (1962) has shown that his coupled Hartree-Fock method yields polarizabilities correct through first order. The uncoupled schemes all contain error terms of first order. Langhoff et al. (1966)have estimated that the uncoupled
ATOMIC A N D MOLECULAR POLARIZABILITIES
13
Hartree-Fock approximations represent a computational savings between a factor of 4 to 300 over the fully coupled approximation, depending on which uncoupled scheme is used. Tuan et al. (1966), Musher (1967), and Tuan and Davidz (1971) have investigated the possibility of applying double perturbation theory to obtain corrections to the uncoupled Hartree-Fock results, hopefully without a severe increase in computational effort. Musher (1967) has shown that the uncoupled Hartree-Fock approximation corresponds to the leading term in a perturbation expansion, while the coupled Hartree-Fock is correct to one higher order. He shows that an attempt to improve upon the coupled theory with a perturbation correction is fruitless since the self-consistency terms in the coupled theory are caused to vanish, and one ends up with the uncoupled Hartree-Fock approximation. Musher (1967) also shows that the different uncoupled schemes are related as leading terms in a Taylor series expansion of the uncoupled results. He argues that the uncoupling process does not eliminate unwanted ” nonlocal potentials from the problem, but simply creates a series expansion in which the leading term does not contain nonlocal potentials and in which it is hoped that the remaining terms are negligible. Schulman and Musher (1968) performed a perturbation calculation of higher-order terms in the polarizability of the hydrogen molecule. Their results indicated that the corrections followed a geometric progression, and they suggested a “geometric approximation for the polarizability, “
”
(271 where a, and a, are the polarizability and first-order correction to it, obtained with an uncoupled Hartree-Fock approximation with first-order perturbation correction. Amos (1970) showed that the geometric approximation was applicable to all of the uncoupled Hartree-Fock schemes. Tuan (1970) has shown that the geometric approximation is an approximation to the coupled Hartree-Fock result. Tuan and Davidz (1971) have evaluated a number of the polarizability approximations described here, for the helium and beryllium isoelectronic sequences. They find that ageom, evaluated using one particular uncoupled scheme, leads to the closest agreement with the fully coupled result. Tuan and Davidz (1971) allowed for different amounts of self-consistency in their potential, via a parameter 7 that could be chosen between 0 and 1. They used T = 0, J, and 1 in their computations for the helium and beryllium isoelectronic sequences, and found that z = gave the best agreement with the fully coupled results, when the perturbation correction was applied to the uncoupled approximation. The implication is that there is an optimum 7 near f for a given isoelectronic sequence. Stevens and Billingsley (1973) have reported highly refined calculations of ageom = aO(1 - a1 /ao)-
4
14
T M . Miller
and B. Bederson
the polarizabilities of the first-row atoms, including some excited-state polarizabilities. They used an extension of the coupled Hartree-Fock method due to Cohen and Roothaan (1965), which they apply to multiconfigurational self-consistent-fieldwavefunctions. By including higher configurations in their calculations, Stevens and Billingsley were able to investigate the importance of electron correlation on the polarizability. Beryllium showed the greatest lowering of the polarizability below that of the base configuration, as higher configurations were considered. The base configuration yielded a polarizability of 6.75 A3, in agreement with the coupled Hartree-Fack result of Cohen (1965). Mixing of nearby configurations resulted in a polarizability of 5.41 A’. A further interesting result of Stevens and Billingsley is the large anisotropy in the polarizability of boron, which has a 2Pground state. For mL = 0 (external electric field parallel to the atomic symmetry axis), the correlated polarizability is 3.44 A3.For rnL = f 1 (perpendicular case), the correlated polarizability is 2.56 A’, 26% lower. The work of Werner and Meyer (1976), to be discussed below, shows an even larger anisotropy for boron. The work of Stevens and Billingsley is an important contribution to polarizability theory because their method has a wider applicability than do the coupled and uncoupled Hartree-Fock methods, and because an estimate of the accuracy of the calculations can be obtained from the magnitude of the electron correlation effects. Their method can be applied to degenerate as easily as to nondegenerate atoms; excited states may be considered without difficulty, and electron correlation effects may be included. In the work referred to above (Stevens and Billingsley, 1973) the accuracy was estimated to be within 5% for the first-row atoms. However, their result for neon is 10% below the most accurate experimental result. Werner and Meyer (1976) and Reinsch and Meyer (1976) have also applied the method of finite perturbation of Cohen and Roothaan (1965) to determine atomic and molecular polarizabilities. They used two types of wavefunctions, obtained from the pseudo-natural-orbital configuration interaction (PNO-CI) and the coupled-electron-pairapproximation (PNOCEPA) of Meyer (1973). Although the PNO-CEPA wavefunctions are not variationally obtained, they had been found to yield better results in molecular structure calculations.Werner, Reinsch, and Meyer noted two competing electron correlation effects in their calculations: (a) Unoccupied low-lying p orbitals make possible a very effective angular correlation. If one wants to describe a state where two s electrons tend to keep apart from each other by preferring a geometrical configuration on differentsides of the nucleus, one has to admix configurationsto the ground state with the two s electrons excited into two p orbitals. In case there exist
ATOMIC A N D MOLECULAR POLARIZABILITIFS
15
low-lying unoccupied p orbitals in the atom, this means that this type of correlation is favored, in contrast to the case where such orbitals are energetically more expensive. This preference of opposite configurationswill lead to a reduction of the shielding of the nuclear potential and thus a contraction of the valence shell and a reduction of the polarizability. This effect dominates in the left-hand side of rows of the periodic table because there are empty p orbitals available. (b) Electrons tend to avoid each other by one keeping nearer to the nucleus and the other farther away @/out correlation).This is achieved by configurations using orbitals with additional radial nodes and is more effective for a more diffuse distribution since in this case the excitation energies are lower. This effect dominates to the right-hand side of rows of the periodic table. Intershell correlation is mostly of type (a) and is called core polarization. Core polarization is larger in the second row of the periodic table than in the first because the cores are increasing in size. However, core polarization decreases across a row as the valence p orbitals fill up and tend to neutralize each other. Figure 2 shows the relative contributions of electron correlation to the polarizabilities of the first- and second-row atoms, as calculated by Werner and Meyer (1976) and Reinsch and Meyer (1976). Also shown are the corresponding relative changes in (r2)112due to electron correlation, where (r2)l/’ is the mean value of the radial distribution of charge in the valence shell. The calculations ol’Werner and Meyer (1976) cover the atoms lithium through neon, and their results were displayed in Fig. 1. Reinsch and Meyer (1976) extended the calculations through calcium. These polarizabilities compare very well with experiment, where available, and the accuracy is estimated at +2% by the authors. Reinsch and Meyer are extending their calculations to the third row of the periodic table, which will include atoms through krypton. These results will be important since there are presently no reliable theoretical, and no experimental values, across a long row of the periodic table. Some of their preliminary results have been included in a tabulation of average polarizabilities in the Appendix. An interesting result of Reinsch and Meyer’s latest calculations is the finding for gallium that the anisotropy is 70% of the average polarizability. This is the largest atomic polarizability anisotropy yet reported, in the ground state. Werner and Meyer (1976) also point out that ordinary perturbative treatments would have difficulty in including coupling elements between substituted configurations of different pairs, because these effects correspond to three- and four-body interactions, which appear only beyond second-order
16
17: M . Miller and B. Bedrrson
FIG.2. Relative electron correlation contribution to the polarizabilities (upper part) and to the size of the valence shell ? = ( r 2 ) t $ (lower part) for atoms in the first two rows of the periodic table. Dashed lines, valence shell correlation only; solid lines, total including intershell correlation. (From Reinsch and Meyer, 1976.)
perturbation theory. An interesting example is the oxygen atom polarizability where there is a disagreement even in the sign of the polarizability anisotropy, between the results of Werner and Meyer and those of Kelly (1964), who used many-body perturbation theory. Dehmer et al. (1975) and Cummings (1975) have calculated dipole oscillator strength distributions for the first- and second-row atoms, using Hartree-Slater wavefunctions. Their moment S( - 2) is related to the polarizability by u = 4S( - 2)ai and comparisons with more exact treatments of the polarizability were given by these authors. Sternheimer (1962, 1969) has performed extensive atomic structure calculations, numerically computing accurate solutions to the simpler Hartree perturbation equations. In his latest work on the alkali metal atoms, Sternheimer (1969) gave an approximate correction to his earlier polarizabilities, due to shielding of the valence electron by the core from the external electric field. The corrected values are in good agreement with the best experimental results. Sternheimer (1969) remarks that his method is not as accurate, in
ATOMIC A N D MOLECULAR POLARIZABILITIES
17
principle, as the coupled Hartree-Fock method or the BruecknerGoldstone many-body theory. However, the later two methods are considerably more complicated. Kelley (1963, 1964, 1966), Caves and Karplus (1969), Chang et al. (1968), Matsubara et al. (1970), Miller and Kelly (1972), and Doran (1974), have applied the many-body perturbation theory of Brueckner and Goldstone (Goldstone, 1957) to the calculation of atomic polarizabilities. Caves and Karplus (1969) and Chang et al. (1968) have used the diagrammatic method to shed light on the various Hartree-Fock methods of calculating polarizabilities, i.e., which diagrams are excluded from the various approximations. Chang et al. have categorized the contributions of various diagrams in the following way. The intrinsic polarizability is due to the direct perturbation of the individual orbitals by the external electric field. Self-consistency accounts for the further distortion of each electronic orbital through the averaged coulomb and exchange potentials produced by the orbitals. Self-consistency is divided into intra- and intershell consistency, depending on whether the interacting orbitals are in the same electronic shell. Correlation is interpreted as the dynamic dependence of one electron on another. In many-body theory, self-consistency is represented by single-particle excitations,and correlation by two- or more-particle excitations. Conventional Hartree-Fock theory (the coupled theory) includes self-consistency as well as some twobody excitations. The Brueckner-Goldstone many-body calculation is, in principle, exact. If the interelectron potential is chosen to be the Hartree-Fock potential, a number of diagrams vanish. Then, the remaining diagrams may be regarded as improvements over the coupled Hartree-Fock theory. In the case of lithium, treated by Chang et al. (1968), electron correlation proved to be negligible so that their result for the polarizability was close to that of the corresponding coupled Hartree-Fock value. It is useful to display the contributions of the intrinsic, intershell, and intrashell consistency, and correlation diagrams, as Chang et al. have done for lithium. However, in this particular case, the nonintrinsic contributions are on the order of 0.1 %. A similar analysis for atoms such as oxygen or boron would be interesting. We conclude our discussion of perturbation techniques with a remark on the importance of the wavefunctions used in various calculations. Most of the calculations we have referenced utilized analytic functions to represent the single-electron unperturbed Hartree-Fock wavefunctions and the firstorder corrections. Chang et al. (1968) noted that different authors frequently obtain different results using the same method depending primarily on whether their wavefunctions were determined variationally or numerically. If variationally obtained, the properties of the trial functions must be scrutinized. The numerical procedure is more accurate but tedious to set up.
18
T M . Miller and B. Bederson
Because the polarizability is mostly dependent on the valence electrons, the outer part of the radial wavefunctions is most crucial in determining the polarizability. Wavefunctions that differ only slightly can yield greatly different polarizability values. Yoshimine and Hurst (1964) found that careful attention must be paid not only to the selection of the basis functions, but also to the precise determination of the variational parameters. They gave an example in which the solutions to the Hartree-Fock equations were determined precisely enough to give a wavefunction that gave the correct free-atom energy to within 0.0005 hartrees, but the polarizability obtained with this wavefunction was incorrect by a factor of two! Further, it should be noted that the Hartree-Fock wavefunction is not necessarily the best choice for the unperturbed wavefunction, particularly when using an approximate theoretical method. An interesting example is that of Norcross’ (1973) calculation of the polarizability of cesium. He used a semiempirical model potential involving two adjustable parameters, based on the lowest few spectroscopic term values. Norcross’ calculation included the core dipole and quadrupole contributions to the valence-electron hamiltonian (even dynamical effects),a spin-orbit potential with an additional relativistic correction. Norcross’ result is close to that found by Sternheimer, but he shows that individual contributions to the total polarizability are not the same in the two calculations. In Table I1 are given the direct valence-electron polarizability (neglecting the effect of the external electric field on the core) a,; the effect of the dipole moment induced in the core by the valence electron avc; the polarizability of the ionic core a,; and the total polarizability a,, for both the Norcross (1973) and Sternheimer (1969) calculations on cesium. Particularly striking is the difference in the two values for the valence-electron polarizability av. Both values for a, are close to the latest experimental results, (59.6 -t 1.2) x cm3 (Molof et al., 1974a) and (63.3 k 4.6) x cm3 (Hall el al., 1974).
D. R-MATRIX CALCULATIONS Allison et al. (1972a,b) have described the use of the R-matrix (reactionmatrix) theory of Burke et al. (1971) in the calculation of atomic polarizabilities. The method is especially suitable for the calculation of dynamic polarizabilities since the logarithmic R-matrix boundary conditions are well specified, and loss of flux through the boundary surface is easily calculated (photoionization). The perturbed atomic wavefunction is expanded in terms of R-matrix states, which form a complete and rapidly converging basis set in the region of space where the perturbed atomic wavefunction has nonvanishing probability amplitude. Computer programs to generate the R-matrix
ATOMIC A N D MOLECULAR POLARIZABILITIES
19
TABLE I1 CALCULATED
VALUES
POLARIZABILITY a,,
OF THE VALENCE ELECTRON THE CORE POLARIZABILITY
ELECTRONa,,, THE CORE POLARIZABILITY INDUCED BY THE EXTERNAL ELECTRIC FIELDa,, AND THE TOTALATOMIC POLARIZABILITY U , OBTAINEDBY NORCROSS (1973) AND STERNHEIMER (1969) FOR, cESIU@ INDUCED BY THE VALENCE
Norcross Sternheimer
65.72 71.31
9.24 13.26
2.82 3.14
59.30 61.19
The total polarizability is a , = a, + a, - a,,. The value of the ionic core polarizability a, used in obtaining these results in both cases was taken from another source. The units are cm3 for the polarizabilities.
states for any atom had been written earlier (Burke et al., 1971) in connection with low-energy electron scattering calculations. The R-matrix method has been used by Robb (1973,1974,1975)to calculate dynamic atomic polarizabilities of a number of the first-row atoms and to obtain van der Waals coefficients (as did Allison et al., 1972b). Robb and Reinhardt (1974) have calculated photoionization cross sections.
E. VARIATIONAL CALCULATIONS In a uniform external electric field, the total energy of an atomic system will be decreased. A variational procedure can be used to determine a wavefunction Y that minimizes the total energy in the electric field E. The polarizability can be obtained from the calculated energy change Ad, namely, a = lim(-2 A S / E z ) (28) E-0
Chung and Hurst (1966)have applied the variational procedure to ground and excited states of the helium isoelectronic system using a 72-term wavefunction. In the case of He(2'So) 96 terms were included in the variational wavefunction to obtain convergence. [As an aside, we remark that the accurate calculation of the polarizability of He(2%,) is important as it is used as a standard in many of the experimental determinations of atomic polarizabilities.] Chung (1977) has recently calculated dynamic polarizabilities for He(2lS0) and He(2%,) using a variation-perturbation scheme due to Glover and Weinhold (1976).
7: M. Miller and B. Bederson
20
Schwartz (1961) has pioneered the variational approach in calculating atomic polarizabilities, applying it to H - and He. Sims and Rumble (1973)have used the variational procedure described by Weinhold (1972) to determine rigorous lower bounds to the polarizabilities of the beryllium isoelectronic series. The variational formulation is such that systematic improvement of the bound is possible, to any desired extent. Sims and Rumble (1973) presented both the lower bounds and “recommended” values for the beryllium isoelectronic series, obtained with a 105-term unperturbed wavefunction and a 53-term perturbed wavefunction for beryllium. For C2+ and 04+ an 89-term unperturbed wavefunction was used. They estimate the accuracy of their “recommended” results to be better than 2?6. Sims et al. (1976) have also made calculations for atomic lithium and their result is in close accord with experiment and other accurate calculations. Because lithium has been used as a standard in some recent polarizability measurements (Molof er al., 1974b; Schwartz et al., 1974; Miller and Bederson, 1976) we present in Table I11 a comparison of these results. TABLE 111 A
COMPARISON
OF
RECENT
POLARIZABILITY VALUES FOR
ATOMIC LITHIUM
Source Sims rr a/. (1976) (rigorous lower bound) Sims ct a/. (1976) (variation-perturbation) Molof ef al. (l974a) ( E - H gradient balance experiment) Werner and Meyer (1976) (multiconfigurational perturbation) Adelman and Szabo (1973) (effective quantum numbers)
a
(A3)
23.47 24.27 24.3 0.5 24.38 24.3
F. STATISTICAL CALCULATIONS Dalgarno reviewed various theoretical approaches to polarizabilities in 1962 and noted that calculations based on the Thomas-Fermi (TF) model considerably overestimated the polarizability for neutral atoms. Improvement was seen for increasing atomic mass and increasing excess charge. Bruch and Lehnen (1976) have recently calculated the polarizabilities of neutral inert gas atoms using the T F and Thomas-Fermi-Dirac (TFD) statistical models. They found, as did Roberts and DelleDonne (1975), that the T F atom has injinite polarizability on the basis of a variational calculation. An interpretation of this result is that the TF atom completely screens a
ATOMIC AND MOLECULAR POLARlZABlLlTIES
21
static electric field from its interior. Bruch and Lehnen found the TFD polarizabilities for the inert gas atoms to be many times larger than experimental values although there was considerable improvement for larger atomic number. On the other hand, TFD polarizabilities for the alkaline earth atoms beryllium and calcium turn out to be smaller than accepted values.
111. Experimental Measurements of Polarizabilities In 1971, Teachout and Pack published an extensive compilation of experimental and theoretical values of atomic polarizabilities. It is immediately clear from their tabulation that most of the periodic table has not been touched upon by direct experimental work, although there are several theoretical values available for most elements. Very accurate polarizability values for the noble gas atoms are known from experiments in which the dielectric constant is measured with low-frequency fields. The other elements are more difficult to handle experimentally and beam techniques have been applied in some cases, notably with the alkali metal atoms. Optical techniques in vapor cells, or shock tubes, have been applied in a few other cases. For a number of atoms these methods have been used to determine excited-state polarizabilities, even for Rydberg states. A. BULK EXPERIMENTS
The polarizability of atoms or molecules that are in the gaseous state at normal laboratory temperatures, say 77-400°K, can be measured accurately by determining the dielectric constant K of the gas. The polarizability is then (K - 1)/4m", where N is the number density of the gas. The dielectric constant is best measured with an ac capacitance bridge in which the change in the capacitance of a parallel-plate condenser is determined, with and without the gas present. With this method one obtains the average polarizability. For molecules, the polarizability is further an average over the thermal distribution of rotational and vibrational states. Experiments performed with hydrogen molecules at low temperatures, however, have yielded very accurate results for the polarizability for the ground rotational and vibrational states of H2 (see Kolos and Wolniewicz, 1967). Dielectric-constant experiments with atoms are possible only with the noble gases, and the accuracy is superb, -0.1 2)(Orcutt and Cole, 1967).The other elements are atomic gases only at high temperatures where one runs into a number of experimental difficulties, among them pressure gradients, pressure measurements, excitation, and ionization.
22
T. M . Miller and B. Bederson
Microwave interferometry has been used to determine the index of refraction of molecular gases and noble gases, and hence polarizabilities at low frequencies (Newell and Baird, 1965). Optical measurements of the index of refraction q(o)of gases are useful in determining the static polarizability in cases where the photon energy of the probe beam is small compared to the lowest excitation energy of the gas under study. The (frequency-dependent) - 1]/2~N,where N is the gas number density. polarizability is given by [q(o) Optical experiments in vapor cells possess the same limitations as do the capacitance measurements, with one important exception: by measuring the depolarization of the probe beam in passing through a cell, one can determine the relative value of the polarizability anisotropy. Such measurements for H2 have been important in comparisons between experiments and theory for this “simple” molecule. For atomic systems, only the noble gases would seem viable as candidates for optical refractivity work, insofar as static polarizabilities are concerned. However, Alpher and White (1959) were able to use a shock tube to dissociate N2 and 0,in order to determine the index of refraction of nitrogen and oxygen gases. They performed the experiments for different Mach numbers to obtain different degrees of dissociation (33-53 % for N, ,36-9 1 % for 0,) and used three different wavelengths of light (412.2, 451.5, and 544.6 nm). cm3 for the average polarizAlpher and White found (1.13 f 0.06) x cm3 for oxygen. It is interability of nitrogen, and (0.77 f 0.06) x esting that the ratio of E(N,)/E(N) is 1.55, while Z ( 0 , ) / ~ ( 0 ) = 2.11. That is, the polarizability of N, is less than that of two separated nitrogen atoms, but the polarizability of 0,is greater than that of two separated oxygen atoms. Alpher and White did not see any variation of the polarizability with photon wavelength, within the scatter in their data; the values they report are probably close to the static polarizabilities. In the shock tube method, the major part of the tube is filled with the gas under study. The tail end of the tube is filled with a driving gas, perhaps helium, behind a metal diaphragm that has been scratched along desired rupture lines. When the pressure of the driving gas reaches a high value that can be fairly accurately estimated, say 50 atm, the diaphragm ruptures and compression of the sample gas begins. The sample gas and the driving gas remain well separated by a shock front. Moving ahead of this shock front is the sample gas in thermodynamic equilibrium at a high temperature (say, 5000°K).The temperature, pressure, and percent dissociation in the gas can be calculated accurately. Downstream in the shock tube the gas passes between optical viewing ports and one has typically 0.2 msec for interferometric observation. Marlow and Bershader (1964) have used this technique to measure the polarizability of atomic hydrogen, at 587 nm. In their case, the H, was
ATOMIC AND MOLECULAR POLARIZABILITIES
23
70-85% dissociated (4000-5000"K).In the interferometer a fringe shift of about one fringe was observed, with a precision of 674, due to the introduction of the atomic hydrogen gas. With 27 measurements at different initial pressures, the precision of the experiment was improved to 1.5%. Marlow cm3 for the polarizability of atomic and Bershader found 0.683 x hydrogen at 587 nm. They compared this to the polarizability calculated in cm3 (Podolsky, 1928; Dalperturbation theory for 587 nm, 0.691 x garno and Kingston, 1960), a value that is 3.6% greater than the static polarizability. Marlow (1965) later investigated the temperature dependence of the polarizability of H2, motivated by the possible need for such a correction to the data of Marlow and Bershader (1964).He found that a correction cm3 should be applied to the atomic hydrogen result. of -0.004 x The correction is very small because the fractional dissociation of H2 in the shock tube was large.
B. INDIRECT METHODS In Table I we listed a number of formulas involving the polarizability, any of which could be turned around and used to determine polarizability values, with varying degrees of reliability. The use of the dielectric constant of a gas to deduce the atomic or molecular polarizability has proven to be accurate, for example, and even higher-order corrections can be made if warranted. Other techniques that carry no guarantee as to accuracy we will class as " indirect methods." Ion mobilities have been used to determine polarizabilities (Hackam, 1966), for example. The problem here is that such a result depends on the induced dipole force between colliding ions and atoms being the only important force (McDaniel, 1964). Sometimes this is true; but sometimes it is far from being true, most notably when resonant charge transfer takes place. Indirect results are generally of value only when no direct measurements have been made. The tabulation of Teachout and Pack (1971) does not show any indirect measurements for elements for which no other measurements exist, except for radon. Here, the adsorption rate of radon from a surface has been used to deduce the polarizability of radon (Tuck, 1960). C. BEAMTECHNIQUES I . General Remarks
An atomic beam technique was used by Scheffers and Stark in 1934 to measure the polarizabilities of the alkali metal atoms, not too long after the introduction of atomic beam magnetic deflection methods by Gerlach and
24
i? M . Millcr and B. Bederson
Stern in 1924. It was not until the late 1950s that further atomic beam work on polarizabilities was carried out, inspired by development of the atomic beam resonance method in the 1940s. The beam experiments can be separated into two groups: (a) those in which a transverse inhomogeneous electrostatic field is used to induce a dipole moment in the beam atoms and to exert a deflecting force on them; and (b) those in which a homogeneous electrostatic field is used, and a radiation field (optical, rf, or microwave) serves to induce a transition between two Stark-shifted levels of the atoms. In the first type of experiment the full polarizability for a given atomic level is obtained, while in the second only the polarizability difference for the two relevant levels is found. In the deflection experiment, the tensor components of the polarizability may be determined if the beam is somehow state-selected, since the selection of different m, states permits measurements to be made with the atom oriented in different directions with respect to the applied electric field. In the nondeflecting experiments, the difference polarizability may be essentially equal to the full polarizability of the higher-lying level in many cases, since polarizability values increase rapidly as the principal quantum number n increases (n’ if there is no core penetration). By exciting to different m , states then, the tensor components of the higher-lying level may be specified. Thus, both types of experiments have considerable potential. In the sparce amount of data available, we find complementary results rather than redundancy. 2. Electric Deflection Experiments
Conceptually, the simplest polarizability measurement is made in the manner of Scheffers and Stark (1934). A collimated atomic beam is passed through a region where a transverse inhomogeneous electric field has been established.The electric field E at the beam position induces a time-averaged dipole moment
-
pz = a E = a,, E
(29)
in the atoms, where the z direction is chosen to be the direction of E. about which the polarizability tensor is assumed to be diagonal. The electric field gradient interacts with the induced moment to exert a force F , = pr dEfdz (30) on the atoms, and the beam undergoes a deflection from its original course. If the beam is well collimated, the deflection can be detected downstream from the electric field region of the apparatus. The deflected beam is dispersed by the velocity distribution. (There is also broadening caused by the variation of the electric field gradient across the finite beam width.) It is thus
ATOMIC A N D MOLECULAR POLARIZABILITIES
25
necessary to know the beam velocity distribution in order to infer the polarizability from the deflected beam profile. Scheffers and Stark (1934) used an effusive beam source and hence assumed a Maxwellian velocity distribution. Scheffers and Stark (1936) also measured the polarizability of atomic hydrogen (one of the very few such measurements in the literature, even to this day). They used a water-cooled discharge tube to dissociate H 2 , and a Moo3-coated surface as a detector. Reduction of the MOO, by hydrogen produced a visible image of the beam profile. Their result was less than half that calculated quantum mechanically. But Scheffers (1940) later altered their value of the polarizability of atomic hydrogen to (0.6 k 0.2) x cm3 after finding that the temperature of the hydrogen discharge was closer to 600°K than room temperature. The calculated static polarizability is 0.67 x cm3. Scheffer and Stark's apparatus was miniscule by modern standards-the field electrodes and flight path totaled 14 cm. Their alkali atom polarizability results are of historical interest only (30-50% low), but their contribution to beam technology was considerable. No other deflection experiments are recorded until 1952, when Drechsler and Muller reported measurements on barium and lithium. Their work was followed by Liepack and Drechsler (1956) on the metals nickel, copper, molybdenum, and tantalum. This group used a field electron microscope apparatus. They found that if an atomic beam was passed close to the field-emitting tip, the beam was deflected. They detected the undeflected and deflected beams by letting the metal beam deposit on a glass plate. The greatest uncertainty in the experiment involved the calculation of the electric field strength and the field gradient at the beam position. Their result for lithium has been shown to be at least 28% too small, while the barium figure is 90% too large. Their other results are yet to be tested. Zorn and co-workers at Yale, and later Michigan, have also used an electric deflection technique over many years to measure the polarizabilities of the alkali metal atoms (Zorn and Fontana, 1960; Chamberlain and Zorn, 1960, 1963; Hall and Zorn, 1974), strontium (Hall et al., 1968), and metastable-state argon (Johnson, 1970) and helium (Crosby and Zorn, 1977). This group has improved the electric deflection experiments by (1) using an electrode configuration in which the electric field strength and field gradient can better be determined, (2) using an improved measurement technique (called the " small-shift " method), and (3) using a velocity selector in their latest work. As presently set up (Fig. 3) the experiment consists of a beam source, a rotating-disk velocity-selector, a beam collimating slit, deflection electrodes, and a beam detector at the end of a flight path of about 93 cm. A typical deflection pattern is shown in Fig. 4. The electrodes are of the " two-wire''
26
'I: M . Miller and B. Bederson
FIG.3. Schematic diagram of the electric-detlection apparatus used at Michigan. The dimensions are in centimeters. (From Hall and Zorn, 1974.)
configuration (Ramsey, 1956). The field and the tield gradient can be calculated analytically and it can be shown that the value of E dE/dz does not vary significantly over the beam height. The Michigan group has made electrolytic-tank tests and found that fringing fields effectively add 3 % to the length of their electrodes; The beam atoms with an average polarizability d are deflected by an amount
-
2 = f.(dE dE/dz)L?/mu2 (31) as they pass through the electric field electrodes a distance L The atom mass is m and the velocity is u. The net deflection s at the detector plane is directly proportional to 2.In the small-shift method, the beam detector is located off-center at a point where the undeflected beam profile has a large slope. near the half-intensity point. As the deflectingfield is turned on,the detected intensity changes rapidly by an amount A(2, E ) = (dl/dZ)s
(32)
ATOMIC AND MOLECULAR POLARIZABILITIES I
- 0 7
1
+
6
1
ib
I
ii
I
I
1)
ii
27
FIG.4. Deflected and undeflected beam profiles for velocity-selected (547 m/sec) metastable argon, obtained with the Michigan electric-deflection apparatus. (From Johnson, 1970.)
where I ( Z ) is the detected intensity, dZ/dZ the slope of the beam profile at the detector position Z, and s the net beam deflection. Thus, the measurement of A and I ( Z ) enables one to obtain s, then rji, provided that the electric field strength and field gradient at the beam position are known. These quantities are calculated from the electrode geometry and the applied electric potential. In the older " large-shift " method, the beam deflection is on the order of the beam width, and a more complicated analysis of the experiment is required (see Zorn et al., 1963; and Bederson and Robinson, 1966),because the beam profile is broadened due to the velocity dispersion. (No large-shift measurements have been made with the velocity-selected beam.) The use of a velocity selector makes the experiment straightforward. In the older work, knowledge of the beam velocity distribution was crucial. Hall and Zorn (1974)performed deflection experiments both with and without the velocity selector to study uncertaintities associated with the beam velocity distribution. They deliberately introduced background gas into their electrode chamber in order to distort the velocity distribution, and
?: M . Miller and B. Bederson
28
~+++-;
__---
I
FIG.5. The apparent polarizability of cesium determined with an electric-deflection apparatus, with and without beam velocity selection, as the background gas pressure was varied. The results show that significant error can occur if the data obtained without velocity selection are analyzed under the usual assumption that the velocity distribution is undistorted Maxwellian. (From Hall and Zorn, 1974.)
found results that were consistent with suspicions that the older measurements were erroneously low due to inadequate vacuum. Their results for cesium are shown in Fig. 5. Note that the velocity-selected beam gave a polarizability value that was independent of the background gas pressure. These data place quite stringent restrictions on deflection experiments performed without velocity selection. Greene and Milne (1968) have reanalyzed the data in Hall's Ph.D. thesis (1968) and find less stringent requirements. In their analysis they include scattering due to the background gas in the entire apparatus-not just the electrode chamber-and they find a curve for the non-velocity-selected data that rises more steeply than shown in Fig. 5. While Hall's analysis leaves the impression that the apparent cesium polarizability would be considerably in error even for apparatus background pressures of torr, Greene and Milne find that lo-* torr is an adequate vacuum, for non-velocity-selected experiments in a typical 2 m long apparatus. Nevertheless, velocity selection removes the uncertainty and permits measurements to be made in cases where the velocity distribution in the beam is known to be non-Maxwellian, such as with metastable-state atomic beams. Zorn's group has studied sodium, potassium, rubidium, and cesium with the velocity-selected beam (Hall and Zorn, 1974). They have done unpublished work with a non-velocity-selected strontium beam (Hall et al., 1968) and have unpublished results for the average polarizability of metastablestate argon, (Johnson, 1970). The metastable beam was a combination of 'Po and 'P2 argon, but the polarizabilities probably differ by less than 1%. The atom beam was excited by electron impact. More recently, they have studied metastable-state helium, and are able to separate 2'S, and 2'S,
ATOMIC A N D MOLECULAR POLARIZABILITIES
29
effects using a helium resonance lamp to quench the singlet state via 21S0-21P1 excitation followed by 2’P1-1 ‘ S o radiative decay (Crosby and Zorn, 1977). The results of the Michigan group are in good agreement with theory and other experiments. There are no other measurements available for 2’S0 and 23S, helium, but the variational calculations (Chung and Hurst, 1966; Chung, 1977) for helium are expected to be more accurate than is possible to achieve with present experiments. The experimental test is important, however, because 23S1helium is used as a “standard in other polarizability experiments. Crosby and Zorn (1977) found (108 k 13) and (44.6 k 3) A3 for the He(2’So) and He(23Sl) polarizabilities, respectively. These can be compared to the theoretical values of 118.711 and 46.772 A3, respectively (Chung, 1977). Greene and Milne (1968) operated an electric deflection apparatus at Midwest Research Institute, Kansas City, but their results are unpublished. Their apparatus was similar in principle to the Michigan apparatus except that it did not contain a velocity selector and they incorporated a mass spectrometer detector. Greene and Milne had a tuning fork beam chopper that was used to modulate the atomic and molecular beams and to pulse them for time-of-flight checks on the velocity distributions. Greene and Milne were primarily interested in molecular polarizabilities and dipole moments, but measured the polarizabilities of sodium (25.7 x cm3) as a check on their apparcm3) and potassium (44.5 x atus. These values are within a few percent of accepted values. We will mention their molecular results in Section II1,E. ”
3. N YU Experiments and the E-H Balance Method
At New York University, Bederson and co-workers have used both an electric deflection method and a different technique, the “ E-H gradient balance ” method, to measure atomic and molecular polarizabilities. In doing electric deflection work they have not used the small-shift procedure described above, but have deflected the beams distances that are several times the half-width at half-maximum of the forward beam. Deflection spectra are obtained with the beam detector fixed a distance S away from the axis of the undeflected beam. The potential across the deflection electrodes is swept; at some potential V a maximum is observed in the beam intensity. An example is given in Fig. 6 for rubidium atoms (Molof et al., 1974b). If many such spectra are obtained, a plot of V 2 vs S may be made, as shown in Fig. 7 for rubidium atoms and molecules. A linear plot is expected since the induced dipole moment is proportional to E2 (or V’). Molof et a!. (1974b) have shown that some deviation from the ideal occurs since the beam is of
7: M . Miller and B. Brderson
30
2.0.15 mm
.'. ... . . *
I
*
.
4
t r
1 i
5 5 0 5 0 POTENTIAL APPLIED ACROSS POLE PIECES (kV)
0
FIG. 6. Electric deflection spectra for rubidium atoms. The detector was positioned off the beam axis by the distance Z and the potential across the deflection electrodes was stepped at 50 V per point. (From Molof et a/., 1974b).
-
0 0
0.2 0.4 0.6 BEAM DEFLECTION (mm)
FIG. 7. Typical results obtained from electric deflection spectra for Rb and Rb, at 534°K. The applied potential was that corresponding to a maximum in the beam intensity for a particular detector position off axis. The slope of the resulting line is inversely proportional to the average polarizability. (From Molof et a/., 1974b.)
31
ATOMIC AND MOLECULAR POLARIZABILITIES
finite width, and the data (Fig. 7, for example) show this for small beam deflections. For beam deflections that are larger than the undeflected-beam width, the V 2 vs S lines are linear. The equation for the line for an infinitesimal beam with a Maxwellian velocity distribution is V2 = ( 4 k T / ~ E ) s
(33)
where k is Boltzmann's constant, T the temperature of the beam source, and K a geometrical constant of the apparatus. The constant K is the product of the electric field to potential ratio and square of the field gradient to field ratio for the deflection electrodes, and LI(L, + 2L2)/2.The electrodes are L, in length and the distance from the end of the electrode set to the detector is L 2 . Because of the difficulty in determining the apparatus constant K absolutely, the NYU group has chosen to normalize their electric deflection results to known polarizabilities of the alkali metal atoms (Molof er al., 1974b). The normalization was accomplished by making measurements on atoms, then molecules, in the same beam from a single oven source. An inhomogeneous' magnetic field was used to remove atoms from the beam, acting on the atomic magnetic moment of one Bohr magneton. The molecules, with magnetic moments on order of nuclear magnetons, comprised only about 1% of the full beam. The ratio of the slopes of the V 2 vs S deflection lines (Fig. 7) for the species under study and for the "standard" is equal to the inverse ratio of the respective polarizabilities. We will discuss the results of experiments on molecular polarizabilities in Section 111,E;suffice it to say here that the alkali dimer polarizabilities tend to be 50% greater than those of the corresponding atoms, at the temperatures studied by Molof et al. (typically 600°K). With the normalization procedure, the only uncertainties are in the relative potential measurements, the statistical uncertainty, and the uncertainty in the polarizability of the standard. Schwartz et al. (1974) and Miller and Bederson (1976) have studied the alkaline earth atoms with the electric deflection method. In these experiments the normalization was against the lithium polarizability. Lithium was loaded into the oven source along with the alkaline earth. A mass spectrometer was used to separate the deflections of the two beams. The polarizabilities of the alkaline earth atoms tend to be -60'7, of those of the adjacent alkali metal atoms in the periodic table, for the atoms which have been studied thus far (barium, strontium, calcium). The lighter atoms, magnesium and beryllium, are predicted to have polarizabilities further lower than the corresponding alkali atoms in the periodic table ( f and respectively). A comparison of various results for the alkaline earth atoms is given in Table IV. Both the NYU and the Michigan groups have noted that the statistical uncertainty in their data is mostly due to the small shifts in the beam position for unpredictable reasons. They are dealing with tightly collimated,
-
-
a,
'I: M . Miller and B. Bederson
32
TABLE IV
A COMPARWNOF RECENTALKALINE EARTHPOLARIZABILITY VALUES Atom Be
(A3)
Source
5.297
Sims and Rumble (1973) (rigorous lower bound) Sims and Rumble (1973) (variation-perturbation) Robb (1973) (R-matrix method) Werner and Meyer (1976) (multiconfigurational perturbation) Robb (1975) (R-matrix method) Stwalley (1971) (experimental oscillator strengths) Stewart (1975) (Hartree-Fock approximation) Reinsch and Meyer (1976) (multiconfigurational perturbation) Miller and Bederson (1976) (electric deflection experiment) Stwalley (1976) (experimental oscillator strengths) Reinsch and Meyer (1976) (multiconfigurational perturbation) Hyman (1974) (experimental oscillator strengths) Adelman and Szabo (1973) (effective quantum numbers) Schwartz et al. (1974) (electric deflection experiment) Hyman (1974) (experimental oscillator strengths) Adelrnan and Szabo (1973) (effective quantum numbers) Schwartz et al. (1974) (electric deflection experiment) Hyman (1974) (experimental oscillator strengths) Adelman and Szabo (1973) (effective quantum numbers)
a
5.42 f 0.12 5.652 5.600 Mg
11.1 f0.75 11.11 f 0.44 11.51 10.57
Ca
25.0 f 2.5 25.0 f 1.0 22.8 22.8 24.4
Sr
27.6 f 2.2 28.4 30.5
Ba
39.7 f 3.2 35.8 43.6
ATOMIC A N D MOLECULAR POLARIZABILITIES
33
narrow beams traveling over long distances. In the NYU experiments, the beam-collimating slit on the entrance to the electrode set is 0.005 cm wide; the beam travels over 2 m altogether. The beam deflections must be measured with a precision of about 0.0002cm, and must remain steady for periods of at least 15 min. In practice, it is found that random shifts of this order can occur, due to temperature changes or vibrations or whatever. Bederson and his co-workers at NYU devised a new method of measuring polarizabilities, which they call the E-H gradient balance technique (Salop ef al., 1961). In this method the electrodes of the deflecting field are also the pole pieces of a magnetic circuit. The result is that both an inhomogeneous electric and an inhomogeneous magnetic field may be applied in the interaction region of the apparatus. The object is to balance the electric deflecting force against a magnetic force acting on the magnetic moment of the atom. Since magnetic moments are well known, the balance condition permits one to determine the polarizability. One principal advantage of this method is that the balance condition is velocity independent. Thus, one does not need to know the velocity distribution in the atomic beam, the balanced beam intensity is much greater than that of a velocity-dispersed beam, and the balanced beam width is approximately as narrow as that of the undisturbed beam-which leads to greater precision in the data acquisition. Furthermore, since the value of the effective magnetic moment depends on the mF sublevel of the atom, each sublevel can be brought into balance separately and the tensor components of the polarizability may be obtained. That is, magnetic field permits state-selection of the beam. These experiments are performed on the same apparatus as are the pure electric-deflection experiments described above. The apparatus dimensions are given in Fig. 8, and a cross section of the most recent pole pieces they have used is shown in Fig. 9. The pole pieces are soft iron and are insulated from the magnet yoke by a glass vacuum envelope and from each other by quartz spacers. The position ~ 7 5 . -63 5 . 6 - 7 - 1 2 3 - 1
OVEN
%S
iNTERACTlON REGION
fr?I
DETECTOR u)
d
d
L
.-ElI-
FIG. 8. A diagram of the NYU E-H gradient balance apparatus with dimensions in centimeters. (From Molof et a/., 1974a.)
34
T M . M i l l u and B. Bederson
'DETAIL
FIG.9. A cross-sectional view of the iron pole pieces used in the NYU E-H gradient balance apparatus. The pole pieces are 35.6 cm long and the design parameters were a = 0.159, h = 0.172, and c = 0.066 cm. The atqmic beam passes between the pole pieces at the position shown (at 1.2~1). Quartz spacers are indicated by Q. (From Molof et al., 1974a.)
of the beam in the pole pieces is indicated in Fig. 9 and is the optimum position for the beam according to calculations of the uniformity of E dE/az over the beam height. In the interaction region of the apparatus an inhomogeneous magnetic field H is applied across the beam, which acts on the effective magnetic moment p(m,) of a beam particle in the magnetic substrate mF. The magnitude of the transverse magnetic force is p(mF)d H / d z , where d H / d z is the transverse component of the gradient of the magnitude of the magnetic field. If one also applies an inhomogeneous electric field E across the beam, there is an electric force that for a scalar polarizability a is simply aE aE/dz. The induced electric force is always directed toward the direction of stronger field, while the direction of the magnetic force depends on the sign of p(mF). If p(m,) is negative it is possible to adjust the field strengths so that the electric and magnetic forces are equal and opposite. When the forces are so balanced, U E a q a z = p ( m F )m / a z (34) and since atomic magnetic moments are known, it is possible to obtain a by determining E and H when the balance condition of Eq. (34) prevails. Salop et al. (1961) first used this technique to measure the polarizabilities of the alkali metal atoms. If the electric and magnetic fields are congruent, then the balance equation may be written aE2 = p(rn,)H (35) and the result is independent of the ratio of the field gradient to field strength, C, where c = E-' a q a z = H-' a ~ / d z (36)
ATOMIC A N D MOLECULAR POLARIZABILITIES
35
which has been cancelled on both sides of Eq. (35). It is still necessary to know the magnetic field strength H,and in practice the ratio of the electric field strength to the applied potential, K = E/V
(37)
Thus, the balance equation is a K 2 V 2 = p(m,)H
Salop et al. calculated the geometrical constant K and determined the magnetic field strength at the beam position from knowledge of field strengths at which the effective magnetic moments for certain mF values become zero. Thirteen years later, Molof et al. (1974a) studied the alkali metal atoms on an improved apparatus with better data-acquisition equipment. They were able to determine C and K experimentally for their apparatus and concluded that it is difficult to calculate accurate values of these constants. They depend on the precision with which the pole pieces are machined, their spacing, the accuracy with which the beam position is known; and the importance of the fringing fields. In conventional electric deflection experiments, the product C K 2 must be accurately known. In the E-H balance experiment of Salop ef al. (1961), K 2 was required. Molof et al. (1974a)chose to normalize their measurements to the polarizability of 2’S, metastable helium, a value that has been accurately calculated (Chung and Hurst, 1966). With the normalization, the balance equations for the atom in question and for helium provide the unknown polarizability: (39) where and pHe(1) refer to metastable helium in the m, = 1 state, and V and VHeare the applied electric potentials used to achieve balanced beams without changing the magnetic field strength. Examples of the E-H balance data of Molof el al. (1974a) are shown in Figs. 10 and 11. Figure 10 is a coarse scan of the magnetic sublevels of cesium at an intermediate field strength of 1010 G. As the potential across the pole pieces is increased, the components of the beam corresponding to different magnetic sublevels come into balance. Those with the largest magnetic moment require the largest applied potential for balance. The ( F , m F )= (4,4) sublevel has a magnetic moment of one Bohr magneton, independent of magnetic field strength. When clearly resolved, Molof et al. used this sublevel to obtain their polarizability data since there is no ambiguity in p(mF).In routine data acquisition, Molof et al. scanned only over a range of potentials necessary to capture the top part of the balance spectrum for the sublevel of interest in order to achieve greater precision. Typical data a = aH~[p(m~)/pH~(1)](~He/v)2
7: M. Miller and B. Bederson
36
POTENTIAL APPLIED ACROSS POLE PIECES (kV)
FIG. 10. A coarse scan of the potential applied across the E-H gradient pole pieces of the NYU apparatus at a magnetic field strength of 1010 G. The peaks result from a balancing of electric and magnetic forces acting on cesium atoms in different (F, m F ) sublevels. (From Molof et a/., 1974a.)
10
.
> a
26
-
c m
-aa
<
Z
w 4
..'
5a
. . .. f 8
.
a
CESIUM
e
c
1
4
a'
%
i'
I-
3 2
5
t
0
u
0 10.2
10.6
11.0
16.6
I70
I74
POTENTIAL APPLIED ACROSS POLE PIECES (kV)
FIG. 11. Fine scans o f a cesium (F,m F ) = (4.4) E-H balance peak and a balance peak for the m, = I sublevel of Z'S, metastable helium, at a magnetic field strength of 1010 G. In this manner the cesium polarizability is normalized to that of He(2'S,). (From Molofet a/., 1974a.)
37
ATOMIC A N D MOLECULAR POLARIZABILITIES
for the (F, mF)= (4, 4) spectrum in cesium are shown in Fig. 11 along with the 23S,(m, = 1) spectrum for helium, obtained at the same magnetic field strength. Each point in Fig. 11 corresponds to an 8.1 V increment in the applied potential, out of many thousands of volts, hence the precision of the experiment. The latest results for the alkali metal atoms are given in Table V, and are accurate to *2%. They are in excellent agreement with the results of Hall and Zorn (1974), who used electric deflection of velocity-selected beams. They also compare well with recent theoretical calculations. It is important to obtain agreement between experiment and theory in the case of these " one-electron " atoms in which the effects of electron correlation are small. TABLE V A COMPARISON OF RECENT POLARIZABILITY VALUE FOR THE ALKALI METALATOMS, I N UNITS OF cm3 Source
a(Li)
a(Na)
4K)
4Rb)
a(Cs)
~
Molof ef a/. (1974a) ( E - H balance experiment) Hall and Zorn (1974) (electric deflection experiment) Sternheimer (1969) (perturbation theory) Adelman and Szabo (1973) (effective quantum numbers) Werner and Meyer (1976) Reinsch and Meyer (1976) (multiconfigurational perturbation) Sims ef a/. (1976) (variation-perturbation) Norcross (1973) (semiempirical model potential)
23.6 f 0.5
43.4 f 0.9
47.3
0.9
59.6 f 1.2
24.4 f 1.7
45.2 f 3.2
48.7 k 3.4
63.3 f 4.6
24.74
22.33
42.97
45.49
61.19
24.6
23.8
43.2
48.2
61.0
24.38
24.45
42.62
24.3 ? 0.5
24.27 59.3
Molof ef al. (1974a) also measured the polarizabilities of the noble gas atoms in the 3P, metastable levels, using the E-H gradient-balance method. These polarizabilities are interesting because of the similarity of the structure of the metastable-state noble gas atoms to that of the alkali metal atoms. Both possess a single outer electron that dominates the polarizability of the atom. There are differences: the alkali atom has a spherically symmetric core, while the noble gas atom has a p hole in the core; and the outer electron of the alkali atom is more tightly bound than that of the adjacent noble gas atom in the periodic table. The gross one-electron character makes the calculation of these polarizabilities relatively easy on the 10% level of accuracy. The structural differences between the alkali atoms and noble gas
38
T M . Miller. arid B. Bederson
atoms make the calculations fascinating on the 1% level of accuracy. The ground-state alkali metal atom is represented by a scalar polarizability. The 3P2noble gas atom is described by a tensor polarizability with two independent components. In Section I,B we remarked that the polarizability in such a case is commonly specified by all and a l , the polarizability with the electric field parallel and perpendicular, respectively, to the symmetry axis of the atom. In the laboratory, the atom is never oriented exactly along the electric field direction; one measures the 2 component of the polarizability with the atom in different m, sublevels in order to determine the orientational dependence of the polarizability. An example of a coarse scan of the E-H balance spectrum of one of the 3P2noble gas atoms is shown in Fig. 12 for krypton. The m, = 1, 2 balance peaks can be seen. The 2 component of the polarizability for m, = 1, 2 is determined from fine scans of these peaks in association with a scan of the z3S, helium balance spectrum. In Table VI, the results for the metastablestate noble gas atoms are given. The experiment of Molof et al. was a remeasurement of these polarizabilities, to take advantage of the improvements in the newer apparatus. The earlier measurements of Pollack el al. (1964)and of Robinson er al. (1966)are listed in Table VI, and it can be seen that the agreement is excellent. They attribute this to the normalization procedure, which tends to overcome errors in alignment, as long as the beam of the standard atom is congruent with the beam of atoms under study. In Table VII we give the results for the 3Pznoble gases expressed as @and TABLE VI A COMPARISON OF MEASURED VALUES OF THE POLARIZABILITIES a,,(m, = 1) AND azz(m, = 2) OF THE 3P, METASTABLE NOBLEGASATOMS'
MSMB
PRB and RLB
28.4 0.6 26.7 +_ 0.5 49.5 1.0 44.7 f 0.9 52.7 f 1.0 46.8 k 0.9 66.6 1.3 57.4 1.1
28.0 f 1.4 26.7 f 1.3 50.4 3.5 44.5 3.1 53.7 f 2.7 46.7 & 2.3 68.2 3.4 56.8 f 2.8
*
+
*
a MSMB denotes the results of Molof et al. (1974a). PRB denotes Pollack et al. (1964). and RLB denotes Robinson et al. (1966). The polarizabilities are expressed in units of cm'.
,
39
ATOMIC AND MOLECULAR POLARIZABILITIES
u)
t 2
3
K
4 K
k
m
K
a
W I-
a K
If
3 0
.’
s 2 2 --
* s &
0
0
2
0
4
6
*
8
12
10
POTENTIAL APPLIED ACROSS POLE PIECES (kV)
FIG. 12. Coarse scan of the potential applied across the E-H gradient pole pieces of the NYU apparatus at a magnetic field strength of 313 G, for 3P2metastable krypton. The tensor components of the polarizability for all m, are completely determined by a measurement of the potentials corresponding to the maxima of the rn, = 1 and m , = 2 balance peaks. (From Molof et a/., 1974a.) TABLE VII A COMPARISON OF VALUES OF a AND THE “TENSOR ” POLARIZABILITY a, FOR THE ’P2 METASTABLE NOBLEGAS ATOMS, IN UNITSOF cm3 (I
RLB
Ne
B 1x1
Ar
@ a,
Kr
LT
Xe
a1 @ a1
MSMB
PS
Theory A
Theory B
27.8 - 1.1 47.9 - 3.2 50.7 - 3.9 63.6 -6.1
- 0.963
29.6
27.8
-
-
-
50.5 -
48.1
59.9
53.5 62.5 -
- 2.95 -
- 3.90 - 6.03
-
78.2 -
-
MSMB denotes the results of Molof er a/. (1974a), PS denotes Player and Sandars (1969).and RLB denotes Robinson et a/. (1966). Theory A is a modification of Sternheimer’s method, and theory B uses estimates of oscillator strengths from the Coulomb approximation of Bates and Damgaard (1949).
40
7: M . Miller. and B. Bederson
a,, the isotropic and anisotropic parts of the polarizability tensor. These values are compared to the calculations for d by Robinson (Robinson et al., 1966)and with measurements of a, by Player and Sandars (1969).The values of $ of Molof er al. compare best with Robinson’s results based on the Coulomb approximation of Bates and Damgaard (1949).The values of a, of Molof et al. compare very well with those of Player and Sandars, who used an atomic beam resonance apparatus and quote i-5 accuracy. Because Molof et al. obtain a, as the small difference between two large numbers, the values of a, are expected to be accurate only to k 100% for neon, to at best f40% for xenon; but the favorable comparison with Player and Sandars implies that the absolute values of Molof et al. may be much better than claimed. The 3Pz noble gas results of Molof et al. emphasize the capability of the E-H gradient balance technique in determining the tensor components of atomic polarizabilities. The NY U group has also reported results on polarizabilities of metastable states in mercury (Levine et al., 1968). The E-H gradient balance method was used to determine the tensor components of the polarizability of the 6 ~ 6 p ( ~ Pmetastable ,) state of mercury. They used an electric deflection method with the same apparatus to measure the average polarizability of 5d’6~’6p~(~D,) mercury. As before, the results of these experiments were normalized against the polarizability of Z3S, helium. The experiment of Levine et al. was more difficult than the experiments with the metastable noble gases because the metastable mercury atoms have much less internal energy to release at the detector-hence the detection efficiency is much poorer. The NYU laboratory has unpublished results on the polarizability of H2 (Schwartz, 1970) and of In (Stockdale et al., 1976). In both cases the E-H balance method was used.
x,
4 . Atomic Beam Resonance Experiments
In atomic beam resonance experiments, one uses an apparatus shown schematically in Fig. 13. The A magnet is used to select a single magnetic sublevel in the beam. The B magnet is generally set to refocus those atoms that have undergone a spin-flip in the main interaction region, between the A and B magnets. In resonance experiments concerned with polarizability work, the interaction region contains parallel plates that establish a homogeneous electric field. In addition, rf energy can be coupled into the interaction region. A typical case, the study of the metastable noble gas atoms, will be described. The A magnet is used to select a particular magnetic sublevel (say, m, = 0) while the B magnet is set to pass only those atoms that have
ATOMIC AND MOLECULAR POLARIZABILITIES
41
FIG.13. Schematic diagram of an atomic-beam magnetic-resonanceapparatus.Only one of four magnetic field coils around the interaction region is shown. (From Gould, 1976.)
been excited to another rn, sublevel (say, m, = 1) by the ac field in the interaction region. The frequency of the ac field required for the transition depends on the Stark shifts in the energies of the two mJ sublevels involved. Thus, this method yields the difference in the polarizabilities azz(m,) for the two m, sublevels involved, and usually the anisotropic polarizability a, is reported. We have already given the results of Player and Sandars (1969) for the 3P2metastable noble gases in Table VII. They also measured the very small anisotropy in the He(23S,) polarizability, which is due to magnetic spin-spin interactions. Their result, (5.07 f 0.25) x cm3, compares well to the calculation by Angel and Sandars (1968), (5.23 L- 0.21) x cm3, and to the experiment of Ramsey and Petrasso (1969) who found (5.05 f 0.16) x cm3. Gould (1976) has used the atomic beam resonance method to study the 6’P,,2 ground state of thallium. He measured a, = -2.23 x lo-’’ cm3. English and Kagann (1974) have used atomic beam resonance to study the polarizability of c 3 n , metastable H2. English and Albritton (1975) have reported calculations for this state, which is strongly coupled to the a3Xl state of H2. A survey of the modern beam work on polarizabilities shows that most of the effort has been with atoms that can be detected by surface ionization, or with metastable-state atoms that have sufficient energy to liberate electrons at surfaces. The need for good detection efficiency is related to the need for narrowly collimated beams.
42
IT: M . Miller and B. Bederson
D. EXCITEDSTATES
1 . Lower-Lying Short-Lived States In recent years we have seen much experimental work on the polarizabilities of excited states of atoms. We have included metastable states in our general discussion of beam experiments on ground-state atoms, since the techniques have been the same. For short-lived atomic states, however, the deflection methods do not seem practical. Van Raan et al. (1976) have used the deflection method with highly excited p states of cesium (40G n G 60) for which the lifetimes are on the order of milliseconds. The magnitude of the electric fields in this experiment are such that the linear Stark effect dominated the electric moment of the atoms. Homogeneous electric fields have been used by other experimenters to study short-lived states with optical, microwave, or rf transitions indicating the energy shift between two levels in the electric field. Grotrian and Ramsauer (1927), Yao (1932), and Kopfermann and Paul (1943), measured the quadratic Stark effect spectroscopically for some of the 'P states of the alkali atoms. These data, together with those obtained by Marrus et al. (1966, 1969) cover the isotropic and anisotropic parts of the polarizability tensor d and a,, for the lowest zPstates of sodium, potassium, rubidium, and cesium, and for the second excited 2Pstates of potassium and rubidium. Marrus et al. (1966) and Marrus and Yellin (1969) used an atomic beam resonance apparatus. However, in the electric field region of the apparatus, spin-flips are not induced directly with rf radiation. Instead, a resonance lamp is used to excite some of the beam atoms to the 2P1/z.3/2 states. When these atoms decay, one-half end up spin-flipped in the ground state and give a signal at the beam detector. A strong signal is detected at zero field strength and also at a field strength such that the differential energy shift between the ground and excited states brings the transition into resonance with the other member of the hyperfine doublet of the resonance lamp. At this value of EZ,the energy separation between the Stark-shifted ground and excited states is then known, and the differential polarizabilities 312 states between the ground state and the various m, sublevels of the are evaluated. Marrus et al. used the ground-state data of Salop et al. to give the full set of azz(m,) for the 2P,,z,3,2 states of potassium, rubidium, and cesium. [Molof et al. (1974a) corrected the ground-state results later and P applied a small correction to the 2PI,z,312 results of Marrus et al.] The ' polarizabilities are typically 2-4 times the ground-state polarizabilities. Khadjavi et al. (1968) used a level-crossing technique in pure electric fields to measure the anisotropic part of the tensor polarizability a,, for the second excited 'P3,Z state of potassium. Schmieder et al. (1971) measured a, for the
ATOMIC A N D MOLECULAR POLARIZABILITIES
43
second excited 'P3/2 state of potassium with the same apparatus. They also used the method of Bates and Damgaard (1949) to calculate ti and a, for the first,second, and third excited 2P3,2states of the alkali atoms. Their measurements indicate that the calculated values are good to within a few percent. We should point out that E or a, can be positive or negative for the excited states, depending on the location of perturbing states. In a series of measurements (v. Oppen, 1969, 1970; v. Oppen and Piosczyk, 1969; Kreutztrager and v. Oppen, 1973; Kreutztrager et al., 1974) a, was measured for the lowest 3P1and 'P, states of the alkaline earths calcium, strontium, and barium. This group used optical double resonance and level crossing techniques. The polarizabilities were all on the order of 6x cm3 except for the 3P1state of barium, for which they found 0.025 x cm3. The smallness of the latter value was attributed to relative position of the metastable 3Dlevels in barium as opposed to strontium and calcium. Bhaskar and Lurio (1974) have measured a, for the 2'P1 state of helium, using an electric-field level-crossing technique. They created a beam of 2' So metastable helium and in the electric field region they excited some of these atoms to the 2'P1 level with 2 p m resonance radiation. They detected 58.4 nm emission from 2'P1 decay, as a function of electric field strength, in order to determine the Stark shift. They found a, = (33.2 k 1.0) x cm3 obtained cm3, which compares well with a value 33.4 x by calculating oscillator strengths connecting the 21P1 state to nearby S and D states. Baravian et al. (1976) have studied the quadratic Stark effect in excited neon. They used 16-photon pumping of neon, with a neodymium glass laser. cm3 for the 3p'[+], level (Pashen They determined E = 21.8 x notation). Sandle et al. (1975) have measured differential Stark shifts in the 6jP1 cm3 for levels of '"Hg and lQ9Hg.They found -(1.41 k 0.02) x cm3 for IQ9Hg.(In lg8Hg the nuclear '"Hg, and -(0.90 k 0.03) x spin is zero while in I9'Hg it is f.) They compared their lg9Hg results to calculated values and earlier experiments (Khadjavi et al., 1968; Kaul and Latshaw, 1972). The agreement between experiments is excellent, but the theoretical values are 20% off.
-
2. Rydberg States A number of measurements dealing with Rydberg states of atoms have been reported lately: lifetimes,field ionization, collisions, level splittings, and Stark effect measurements (Stebbings, 1976). Hohervorst and Svanberg (1974, 1975) have reported measurements of a, for n = 8,9, 10 2D levels in
44
T M . Miller and B. Bederson
cesium, using a level-crossing technique.’ Two-photon pumping of cesium was accomplished with an rf lamp and a tunable dye laser. Hohervorst and Svanberg found values of a, ranging from 5 x to 5 x 10- cm3.They have also studied potassium and rubidium in the same manner. Fabre and Haroche (1975)used quantum beat spectroscopy to measure a, for n = 10, 11, 12 ’D levels in sodium. They also used two-photon pumping but from two dye lasers. Their values of a, range from -4 x 10-l7 to -12 x cm3. Harvey et al. (1975)and Hawkins et al. (1977)have used Doppler-free two-photon excitation of sodium in order to measure Stark shifts and splittings of the ’S levels for n = 5, 6, 7,8,and of the 2D levels for n = 4, 5, 6. Absolute frequency shifts and splittings of the levels were determined in static electric fields from interferometric detection of the sodium uv fluorescence. The measurement of both ti and a, allows the contributions to the TABLE VIIl
THE RESULTSOF HARVEYel 01. (1975) POLARlZABILlTIES 6
AND
AND HAWKINS el a/. (1977) FOR THE AVERAGE “TENSOR”POLARIZABILITIES a, OF ’s A N D ’D LEVELS OF SODIUM“
Experiment so
State
(GHz) (0.885) (0.202) (0.0776) 0.0345 0.0233
3’SI,Z 42S1j2 52S1:2
6% 2 7’Sl,2
-
82sl,2
4’D,,, 4’D,,, 5’D,,, 5’D,,, 6’D,,, 6’D,,,
HIC
(1.0283) (1.0283) 0.617 0.617 0.388 0.388
Calculated 1
a,
1
a,
Hz
HZ
HZ
Hz
(0.0396)
0.04oO
-
0.7678 5.384 23.36 75.98 203.4 152.4 152.6 1014 1015 398 1 3985
5.2 23.6 76.4 206 156.1 155.3 1033 994 4054 3985
-
- 53.2 - 38.5 - 337 - 252 - 1322 - 995
-
-51.3 - 36.0 - 330 -232 - 1290 - 905
So is the zero-field fine structure interval and HIC is the hyperfine interaction constant. The calculated values were obtained using the method of Bates and Damgaard (1949). Values in parentheses were taken from other sources and included for comparison to the measured polarizabilities. Note that a (A’) = 595.52 x a [Hz/(V/~m)~l.
Our symbols ti for the average polarizability and a , for the tensor part are usually replaced by a. and a’. respectively, in the optical literature.
45
ATOMIC A N D MOLECULAR POLARIZABILITIES
polarizabilities of the D states from the neighboring P and F states to be uniquely separated. The polarizabilities found in this work are given in Table VIII, along with values the authors have calculated using the Coulomb approximation of Bates and Damgaard (1949).The ground state Stark shifts are negligible compared to the measured shifts. Gallagher et al. (1977)have measured a, for the n = 15, 16, 17 D states of sodium. For the n = 17, 18, 19 P states of sodium, they observed a faster change in energy with electric field strength than could be fit against EZ and have evaluated the anisotropic part of the hyperpolarizability tensor 7 ,, as well as a,. Their results are given in Table IX along with values of E and a, TABLE IX THERFSULTSOF GALLAGHER et a/. ( 1977) FOR THE POLARIZABILITIES OF RYDBERG LEVELS OF SODIUP Experiment
16P 17P 18P 19P 15d 16d 17d
Calculated
SO
a,
C
a,
d
1.5487 1.2792 1.0684 0.9029 -0.0286 -0.0240 -0.0198
22 32 50 74 -1060 -1470 - 2780
0.017 0.078 0.22 I 0.590 0 0 0
19.8 31.3 49.0 74.1 - 940 - 1490 - 2290
- 224 - 349
- 542 - 809 2950 47 10 7170
The principal quantum number is n, the zero-field fine structure interval is S o , and C is a coefficient determined when the data are fit to the expression v = So + u,E2/2 CE4, where v is the observed microwave frequency and E the applied electric field strength. Both the d3,* and dS,, states have the same @. The values of u, are for thed,,, statesand u I ( $ )= ~a,(~).Thecalculated values were obtained using the method of Bates and Damgaard (1949). Note that u (A3) = 595.52 x a [Hz/(V/cm)’].
+
that they calculated using the method of Bates and Damgaard (1949). Since the experimental and calculated values of a, agree so well, it may be assumed that the calculated values of E are good. Gallagher et al. used two-photon pumping of a sodium beam in this work. They used rf radiation to induce transitions between levels in the presence of a weak electric field (- 10 V/cm) in order to determine the differential Stark shifts. Field ionization in a stronger, pulsed electric field was used to detect the rf resonance. (It is possible to distinguish different m, states by varying
46
7: M . Miller and B. Bederson
the field ionization potential.) The polarizabilities of the Rydberg states scale as n', and the values reported are on the order of lo9 A3. Gallagher et al. (1976) have measured the nf-ng and ng-nh splittings in sodium for n = 13-17. Freeman and Kleppner (1976) have used these measurements to determine effective (dynamic) dipole and quadrupole polarizabilities of the closed-shell ion core of sodium. This work is significant because of the accuracy with which these quantities may be determined. Using a quantum defect analysis, Freeman and Kleppner find (0.14841 k cm5 for effective dipole and cm3 and (20 & 6) x 0.00022) x quadrupole polarizabilities of the sodium core. They expect that further experiments will allow the determination of the dipole and quadrupole polarizabilities of the atomic core to a few parts in lo4, and even higher order moments may be revealed. Kleppner (1975) believes that these ideas may lead to an experimental value of the Rydberg accurate to better than 1 part in 10". Gallagher er al. have recently obtained results for lithium splittings and core polarizabilities.
E. SIMPLEMOLECULES We do not wish to enter into a full discussion of molecular polarizabilities (see Hirschfelder et al., 1954). However, it seems relevant to mention some research with simple diatomic molecules. Kolos and Wolniewicz (1967) have calculated the polarizability of H2 as a function of internuclear distance using a variational perturbation method and have used the results to tabulate !% and y for u = 0, 0 < J < 31, and 0 < u < 8, J = 0. Here, y is the polarizability anisotropy, u is the vibrational quantum number, and J is the rotational quantum number. They also tabulated results for HD and D, . This calculation is regarded as highly accurate (few parts per thousand) by other workers. Kolos and Wolniewicz refer to several experimental measurements in their paper, and the agreement is very good between theory and experiment. H, is unique in that it is trivial to produce a gas for which u = 0 and J = 0, 1 (the para and ortho modifications) and with extra effort one can obtain a pure parahydrogen gas. Nelissen et al. (1969) used the E-H gradient balance method and electric deflection to study H, . They determined y/3!% for u = 0, J = 1 H, ,and @for (75% u = 0, J = 1 and 25% u = 0, J = 0) H, . Schwartz (1970) used the E-H balance method to find @ for v = 0, J = 1 H,. These beam measurements yielded results that are lower than the calculated values of Kolos and Wolniewicz (1967), but the uncertainties in the beam results are such that a discrepancy is not clear. English and MacAdam (1970) and MacAdam and Ramsey (1972) used an atomic beam resonance apparatus in a direct measurement of the polarizabil-
47
ATOMIC A N D MOLECULAR POLARIZABILITIES
ity anisotropy in H, and D, for u = 0, J = 1. MacAdam and Ramsey found y(H,) = (0.3016 f 0.0005)x cm3 and y(D2)= (0.2917 f 0.0004) x cm3. These values differ from the results of Kolos and Wolniewicz by 0.17 and 0.3"/;;, respectively, for H, and D, . The difference is increased to 0.56% for both H2 and D, if a correction to the theoretical results is made for diabatic effects, i.e., failure of the Born-Oppenheimer approximation (Karl and Poll, 1975). Besides hydrogen, the study of the polarizabilities of loosely bound molecules is relevant to our discussion. Dagdigian et al. (1971), Graff et al. (1972), and Dagdigian and Wharton (1972) have used deflection and resonance methods to study the heteronuclear alkali metal dimers. In the case of NaLi, they were able to determine both ?i and a, since the polarizability was an important contribution to the overall electric dipole moment in their experiment. They found Cr = (40 k 5 ) x cm3 and 7 = (24 k 2) x cm3 for u = 0 NaLi. Molof et al. (1974b) have used an electric deflection technique to measure @ for Liz, Na,, K,, Rb,, and Cs,. The work was described in Section 111,C,3. Their values of ?icorrespond to thermal averages over the rotational and vibrational states at the experimental temperatures 650°K. However, the ground-state polarizabilities differ from these thermal averages by only a few percent (Miller and Molof, 1977). No measurements for a, have been made for the homonuclear alkali dimers. Calculations indicate that a /alis between 1.4 and 2.0 for the alkali dimers. Molof et al. (1974b) found the followingaverage polarizabilities. in units of 10- 24 cm3: Li, (990"K),34 + 3; Na, (736"K), 30 k 3; K, (569"K), 61 f 5 ; Rb, (534°K). 68 f 7; and 91 k 7. Cs, (515"K), Greene and Milne (1968)obtained preliminary results for Na, (37 x 10- 2 4 cm3) and for Na,CI, (32 x cm'). van der Waals molecules can be formed in nozzle beams, and their study provides an interesting link between atomic and molecular structure. In Table I we gave approximate formulas for the van der Waals C6 and C8 coefficients in terms of the dipole and quadrupole polarizabilities of the separated atoms. Stwalley (1970)and Li and Stwalley (1973)have used these concepts in order to analyze spectra obtained for Mg, , for example. Dalgarno and Davison (1966) have reviewed van der Waals interactions. Kramer and Hershbach (1970)have discussed approximate formulas for van der Waals constants.
-
,
IV. Future Possibilities for Polarizabilities We have pointed out that little experimental research has been possible with the open-shell atoms other than the alkali metals and some of the
48
7: M . Miller and B. Bederson
alkaline earths. This situation could improve if an efficient detector of neutral atoms is developed for beam work, e.g., laser fluorescence or cryopumped ionizers. Supersonic beams of atoms have not yet been used in polarizability experiments. Another possibility is the further use of shock tubes to produce atomic gases. Precision measurements of the index of refraction and of the depolarization of scattered light in shock tube interferometry should be possible today. (Thus far, shock tube interferometry has utilized lamps rather than lasers.) The experimentalists have two goals : (1) to achieve a level of accuracy such that electron correlation effects may be observed, and (2) to measure polarizabilities and polarizability anisotropies far the open shell atoms. Theorists have held an advantage over experimentalists at the present time. Sophisticated calculations are enabling us to understand the effects of electron correlation on polarizabilities. (The same is true in other areas of atomic physics, such as in electron scattering.) However, once experimentalists break through present limitations, they will be able to tackle the heavy atoms as easily as the light ones. The same is not true for theory, and there is already an indication (with the alkali metals) that the heavy atoms will be troublesome. Research on the polarizabilities of excited atoms is expected to proceed rapidly. The accuracy with which these measurements can be made makes it possible to specify the role of the ionic core precisely-both its multipole polarization and the effect of penetration by the valence electron. Further research on molecular polarizabilities (insofar as relevant to this article) might be seen to delve into the determination of polarizability anisotropies and the internuclear dependence of a and aI,whether through state selection or with beams of different temperatures. Supersonic molecular beams are found to have low internal energies, and the internal energy can be controlled somewhat in “seeded beams.
,
”
ACKNOWLEDGMENT The work described in this paper that was performed at New York University was supported by the National Science Foundation and the Army Research Office.
49
ATOMIC A N D MOLECULAR POLARIZABILITIES
Appendix RECOMMENDED VALUES FOR ATOMICPOLARIZABILITIES,EXPRESSED IN UNITS OF
Estimated accuracy ( “b)
Atom
‘.Exact” Exact 0.5 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 0.5 2 ”
a 50 50 50 50
50 50 50 50 50 2 2 2 2 2 2 0.5 2
a 50 50
H He Li Be B C N 0 F Ne Na
Mg Al Si
P
S CI Ar K Ca sc Ti V Cr
Mn Fe
co Ni
cu
Zn Ga
Ge As
Se Br Kr Rb Sr
Y Zr
Cm3
Average polarizability 0.666793 0.204956 24.3 5.60 3.03 1.76 1.10 0.802 0.557 0.395 23.6 10.6 8.34 5.38 3.63 2.90 2.18 1.64
43.4 25.0 16.9 13.6 11.4 6.8 8.6 7.5 6.8 6.5 6.1 7.08 8.12 6.07 4.3 1 3.77 3.05 2.48 47.3 27.6 22 18
Notes a
a h C
d d d d d d e d d d d d d d e C
.f
s
f f
s f f
s .r
d d d d d d a b C
f
_ ~ _ f_
(continued)
7: M. Miller and B. Bedrrson
50
APPENDIX-conlinued
Estimated accuracy (",,I
50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 0.5 2 8
50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50
Atom Nb Mo Tc Ru Rh Pd Ag Cd In Sn
Sb Te I Xe
cs
Ba La Ce Pr Nd
Pm Sm Eu Gd Tb DY Ho Er Tm Yb Lu Hf Ta W Re 0 s
Ir Pt Au Hg TI Pb Bi Po
Average polarizability
14 13 10.0 8.6 1.6 6.9 6.3 6.0 4.5 4.4 4.0 3.9 3.9 4.04 59.6 39.7 37 36 34 32 30 29 21 26 25 25 23 23 22 22 20 15 13 10 9 8 1 6.3 5.1 5.1 3.5 3.1 4.0 4.6
Notes
.1' 1' .f 1'
1'
.f
1' 1 a
./
1'
t 1' a e
c
.f
1' ./'
.r .f
1' ./
1' 1' 1' 1' 1' .f
1' 1' 1' 1' 1'
t
.f
.f .f .I' a a
.f
1' f
51
ATOMIC AND MOLECULAR POLARIZABILITIES
Estimated accuracy ( ",J 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50
50 50
50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50
Atom
Average polarizability 5. I 6.3 67 46 53 50 48 46 45 43 41 40 39 38 36 35 34 33 32
At Rn Fr Ra Ac Th Pa U NP Pu Am
Cm Bk Cf
Es Fm Md No
Lw
Notes
f 9 /I /I
f
1
.f
f .I'
1' f
.r
.1'
.I' 1' f 1' .I' i
From Teachout and Pack (1971). From Table 111. ' From Table 1V. From Werner and Meyer (1976) and Reinsch and Meyer (1976). " From Table V. Scaled from self-consistent-field (SCF) calculations by forcing agreement with better values where available. The SCF calculations are those of Thorhallsson et ol. (1968a. 1968b) and Saxena and Fraga (1972). The accuracy in the polarizabilities resultingfrom this scaling is estimated to be *50",, as this is the maximum adjustment in the SCF values that was required. From Tuck (1960). " Extrapolated from columns I A and 2A of the periodic table. ' Extrapolated from the other actinide polarizabilities. @
REFERENCES Adelman. S . A., and Szabo, A. (1973). J. Chem. Phys. 58,687. [Important typographical errors in this paper have been noted by Tang, K. T.. Norbeck, J. M.,and Certain. P. R. (1976). Ihitl. 64,3063.1 Allen, L. C. (1960). Phys. Reo. 118, 167. Allison, D. C. S., Burke, P. G., and Robb, W. D. (1972a). J . Phys. B 5, 55. Allison, D. C . S.. Burke, P. G., and Robb, W. D. (1972b). J . Plrys. B 5, 1431. Alpher, R. A., and White, D. R. (1959). Phys. FIuids 2. 153.
T M . Miller and B. Bederson
52
Altick, P. L. (1964). J . Chem. Phys. 40, 238. Amos, A. T. (1970). J. Chem. Phys. 52, 603. Angel, J. R. P., and Sandars, P. G. H. (1968). Proc. R. Soc. London, Ser. A 305, 125. Baravian, G., Godart, J., and Sultan, G. (1976). Phys. Rev. A 14, 761. Bates, D. R., and Damgaard, A. (1949). Phil. Trans. R. Soc. London, Ser. A 242, 101. Bederson, B., and Robinson, E. J. (1966). Adv. Chem. Phys. 10, 1. Bhaskar. N. D., and Lurio, A. (1974). Phys. Rev. A 10, 1685. Bruch, L. W., and Lehnen, A. P. (1976). J . Chem. Phys. 64, 2065. Buckingham. A. D. (1967). Ado. Chem. Phys. 12, 107. Burke, P. G., Hibbert, A., and Robb. W. D. (1971). J . Phys. B 4. 153. Casimir, H. B. G., and Polder. D. (1938). Phys. Rev. 73, 360. Caves, T. C.. and Karplus. M. (1969). J. Chem. Phys. 50.3649. Chamberlain, G. E.. and Zorn, J. C. (1960). Bull. Am. Phys. Soc. 5, 241. Chamberlain, G. E., and Zorn. J. C. (1963). Phys. Reo. 129, 677. Chang. E. S.. Pu, R. T., and Das, T. P. (1968). Phys. Rev. 174, 16. Chung, K. T. (1977). Phys. Reo. A 15, 1347. Chung. K. T., and Hurst, R. P. (1966). Phys. Rev. 152, 35. Cohen, H. D. (1965). J. Chem. Phys. 43, 3558. Cohen, H. D., and Roothaan, C. C. J. (1965). J . Chem. Phys. 43. S34. Cohen, M. (1967). Can. J . Phys. 45, 3387. Condon, E. U.,and Shortley, G. H. (1951). "The Theory of Atomic Spectra." Cambridge Univ. Press, London and New York. Crosby, D. A., and Zorn, J. C. (1977). Phys. Rev. A 16,488. Cummings, F. E. (1975). J . Chem. Phys. 63, 4960. Dagdigian, P. J., and Wharton, L. (1972). J . Chem. Phys. 57, 1487. Dagdigian, P. J., Graff, J., and Wharton, L. (1971). J . Chem. Phys. 55, 4980. Dalgarno, A. (1959). Proc. R. Soc. London. Ser. A 251, 282. Dalgarno, A. (1962). Adv. Phys. 11, 281. Dalgarno, A., and Davison. W. D. (1966). Adv. At. Mol. Phys. 2, 1. Dalgarno, A., and Kingston, A. E. (1959). Proc. Phys. SOC., London, Sect. A 73, 455. Dalgarno, A., and Kingston, A. E. (1960). Proc. R. Soc. London, Ser. A 259, 424. Dalgarno, A., and Pengelly, R. (1966). Proc. Phys. Soc., London, 89, 503. Dehmer, J. L., Inokuti, M., and Saxon, R. P. (1975). Phys. Rev. A 12, 102. Doran, M. B. (1974). J . Phys. B 7, 558. Drechsler, M., and Miiller, E. W.(1952). Z. Phys. 132, 195. English, T. C., and Albritton, D. L. (1975). J . Phys. B 8. 2123. English, T. C., and Kagann, R. H. (1974). Phys. Rev. Lett. 33,995. English, T. C., and MacAdam, K. B. (1970). Phys. Rev. Lett. 24, 555. Epstein, P. S. (1916). Phys. Z. 17, 148; Ann. Phys. (Leipzig) 50, 489. Epstein, P. S. (1926). Phys. Rev. 28, 695. Fabre, C., and Haroche, S. (1975). Opt. Commun. 15, 254. Freeman, R. R., and Kleppner, D. (1976). Phys. Rev. A 14, 1614. Gallagher, T. G., Hill, R. M., and Edelstein, S. A. (1976). Phys. Rev. A 13, 1448; 14, 744. Gallagher, T. G.. Humphrey, L., Hill, R. M., Cooke, W. E., and Edelstein, S. A. (1977). Phys. Rev. A 15, 1977.
Garrett, W. R. (1965). Phys. Rev. 140, A705. Gerlach, W., and Stern, 0. (1924). Ann. Phys. (Leipzig)7 1 673; 76, 163 (1925). Glover, R. M., and Weinhold. F. (1976). J. Chem. Phys. 65,4913. Goldstone, J. (1957). Proc. R. Soc. London, Ser. A 239, 267. Gould, H. (1976). Phys. Rev. A 14,922. Graff, J., Dagdigian, P. J., and Wharton, L. (1972). J . Chem. Phys. 57, 710.
ATOMIC AND MOLECULAR POLARIZABILITIES
53
Grasso, M. N., Chung, K. T., and Hurst, R. P. (1968). Phys. Rev. 167. 1. Greene, F. T., and Milne, T. A. (1968). Air Force OK. Sci. Res.: Sci. Rep. 68-1879 (unpublished). Grotrian, W., and Ramsauer, G. (1927). Z. Phys. 28, 846. Hackam, R. (1966). J. Appl. Phys. 17, 197. Hall, W. D. (1968). Ph.D. Thesis. University of Michigan (University Microfilms Inc., Ann Arbor, Michigan). Hall, W. D., and Zorn, J. C. (1974). Phys. Rev. A 10, 1141. Hall, W. D., Hoeberling, R. F., and Zorn, J. C. (1968). Bull. Am. Phys. SOC.13, 21. Harvey, K. C., Hawkins, R. T., Meisel, G., and Schawlow, A. L. (1975). Pkgs. Reu. Lerr. 34, 1073. Hawkins, R. T.. Hill, W. T., Kowalski, F. V.. Schawlow. A. L., and Svanberg, S. (1977). Phys. Rev. A 15, 967.
Hirschfelder, J. O., Curtis, C. F., and Bird, R. 8. (1954). "Molecular Theory of Gases and Liquids.'' Wiley, New York. Hohervorst, W., and Svanberg, S. (1974). Phys. Lett. A 48, 89. Hohervorst, W., and Svanberg, S. (1975). Phys. Scr. 12, 67. Hyman, H. A. (1974). J. Chem. Phys. 61, 4063. Ice, G. E., and Olson, R. E. (1975). Phys. Rev. A 11, 111. Johnson, N. B. (1970). Ph.D. Thesis. University of Michigan (University Microfilms Inc., Ann Arbor, Michigan). Kaneko, S. (1959). J . Phys. Soc. Jpn. 14, 1600. Karl, G., and Poll, J. D. (1975). J. Chem. Phys. 12. 2239. Kaul, R. D., and Latshaw, W. S. (1972). J. Opt. Soc. Am. 62, 615. Kelly, H. P. (1963). Phys. Rev. 131,684. Kelly, H. P. (1964). Phys. Rev. 136, B896. Kelly, H. P. (1966). Phys. Rev. 144, 39. Khadjavi, A., Lurio, A., Happer, W. (1968). Phys. Rev. 167, 128. Kleppner, D. (1975). Bull. Am. Phys. SOC.20, 1459. Kolos, W., and Wolniewicz, L. (1967). J . Chem. Phys. 46, 1426. Kopfermann, H., and Paul, W. (1943). Z. Phys. 120, 545. Kramer, H. L., and Herschbach, D. R. (1970). J . Chem. Phys. 53, 2792. Kreutztrager, A., and v. Oppen, G. (1973). Z. Phys. 265, 421. Kreutztrager, A., v. Oppen, G., and Wefel, W. (1974). Phys. LPtt. A 49, 241. Krieger, J. B., and Kaufman, S. E. (1976). Am. J . Phys. 44, 571. Langhoff, p. W., and Hurst, R. P. (1965). Phys. Rev. 139, A 1415. Langhoff, P. W.,Karplus, M.. and Hurst, R. P.(1966). J . Chem. Phys. 44, 505. Levine, J., Celotta, R. J., and Bederson, B. (1968). Phys. Rev. 171, 31. Li, K. C., and Stwalley, W. C. (1973). J. Chem. Phys. 59,4423. Liepack, H., and Drechsler, M. (1956). Naturwissenschaften 43, 52. LoSurdo, A. (1913). Afti Accad. Lincei 22, 665. MacAdam, K. B.,and Ramsey, N. F. (1972). Phys. Rev. A 6, 898. McDaniel, E. W. (1964). "Collision Phenomena in Ionized Gases." Wiley, New York. Marlow, W. C. (1965). Proc. Phys. Soc., London, 86, 73 1. Marlow, W. C.. and Bershader, D. (1964). Phys. Rev. 133, A 629. Marrus, R., and Yellin, J. (1969). Phys. Rev. 177, 127. Marrus, R., McColm, D., and Yellin, J. (1966). Phys. Rev. 147, 55. Matsubara, C., Dutton, N. C., Ishihara, T., and Das, T. P. (1970). Phys. Rev. A I, 561. Meyer, W. (1973). J. Chem. Phys. 58. 1017. Miller, J. A., and Kelly, H. P. (1972). Phys. Rev. A 5, 5 16. Miller, T. M., and Bederson, B. (1976). Phys. Rev. A 14, 1572. Miller, T. M., and Molof, R. W. (1977). (To be published.) Molof, R. W., Schwartz, H. L., Miller, T. M., and Bederson, B. (1974a). Phys. Rev. A 10, 1131.
54
7:M . Miller and B. Bederson
Molof, R. W., Miller, T. M.. Schwartz. H. L., Bederson, B., and Park, J. T. (1974b). J . Chem. Phys. 61, 1816. [In Eq. (A9) of this paper, replace 71 by 71’ and o by 04.] Musher. J. I. (1967). J. Chem. Phys. 46, 369. Nelissen, L., Reuss, J., and Dymanus. A. (1969). Physica (Utrecht) 42, 619. [In Table I of this paper a?(H,) is misprinted and should be (0.75 0.02)A3 (J. Reuss, private communication).] Newell, A. C., and Baird, R. C. (1965). J . Appl. Phys. 36, 3751. Norcross, D. W. (1973). Phys. Rev. A 7, 606. OMalley, T. F., Spruch, L..and Rosenberg, L. (1962). Phys. Rev. 125, 1300. Orcutt, R. H., and Cole, R. H. (1967). J. Chem. Phys. 46, 697. Player, M. A., and Sandars, P. G. H.(1969). Phys. Lett. A 30,475. Podolsky. B. (1928). Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 14. 253. Pollack, E., Robinson, E. J., and Bederson, B. (1964). Phys. Rev. 134, A 1210. Ramsey, A. T., and Petrasso, R. (1969). Phys. Rev. Lett. 23, 1478. Ramsey, N. F. (1956). “Molecular Beams.” Oxford Univ. Press. London and New York. Reinsch, E.-A., and Meyer, W. (1976). Phys. Rev. A 14, 915. Mol. Phys. 31, 855. Robb. W. D. (1973). J. Phys. B 6,945. Robb. W. D. (1974). J . Phys. B 7, L369. Robb, W. D. (1975). Chem. Phys. Lett. 34.479. Robb. W. D., and Reinhardt, W. P. (1974). Cited in Robb (1974). Roberts, R. E., and DelleDonne, M. (1975). Private communication. Cited by Bruch and Lehnen (1976). Robinson, E. J.. Levine, J.. and Bederson, B. (1966). Phys. Rev. 146,95. [Note that a==(1) for Ar is misprinted in the abstract of this paper, but given correctly in Table I.] Salop. A., Pollack, E.. and Bederson, B. (1961). Phys. Rev. 124, 1431. Sandle, W. J., Standage, M.C., and Warrington, D. M. (1975). J . Phys. B 8, 1203. Saxena, K. M. S.,and Fraga, S. (1972). J . Chem. Phys. 57, 1800. Scheffers. H.(1940). physik. Z . 41, 399. Scheffers, H., and Stark, J. (1934). Phys. Z . 35,625. Scheffers, H.,and Stark, J. (1936). Phys. Z . 37, 217. Schmieder, R. W., Lurio, A., and Happer, W. (1971). Phys. Rev. A 3, 1209. Schulman. J. M., and Musher, J. I. (1968). J. Chem. Phys. 49, 4845. Schwartz, C. (1961). Phys. Rev. 123, 1700. Schwartz, H. L. (1970). Ph.D. Thesis. New York University (unpublished). Schwartz, H. L., Miller, T. M., and Bederson. B. (1974). Phys. Reo. A 10, 1924. Sims, J. S.,and Rumble, J. R. (1973). Phys. Rev. A 8, 223 1. Sims, J. S.,Hagstrom, S. A., and Rumble, J. R. (1976). Phys. Rev. A 14, 576. Stark, J. (1913). A k d . Wiss. Berlin 40,932. Stebbings. R. T. (1976). Science 193, 537. Sternheimer, R. (1962). Phys. Rev. 127, 1220. Sternheimer. R. (1969). Phys. Rev. 183, 112. Stevens, W. J., and Billingsley, F. P. (1973). Phys. Rev. A 8,2236; Billingsley,F. P., and Krauss, M.(1972). Ibid. 6, 855. Stewart, R. F. (1975). Mol. Phys. 29, 787. Stockdale, J., Efremov, I., Rubin, K.. and Bederson, B. (1976). fnt. Con6 At. Phys., 5th. 1976, Abstr. p. 408. Stwalley, W. C. (1970). Chem. Phys. Lett. 7,600. Stwalley, W. C. (1971). J . Chem. Phys. 54’4517. Stwalley, W . C. (1976). Private communication. Teachout, R. R., and Pack, R. T. (1971). At. Dora 3, 195. Thorhallsson, J., Fisk, C., and Fraga, S. (1968a). Theor. Chim. Acta 10, 388.
ATOMIC A N D MOLECULAR POLARIZABILITIES
Thorhallsson, J.. Fisk, C., and Fraga. S. (1968b).J. Chem. Phys. 49, 1987. Tuan. D. F-t. (1970).J . Chem. Phys. 52, 5247. Tuan, D. F-t., and Davidz, A. (1971).J. Chem. Phys. 55, 1286. Tuan, D. F-t., Epstein, S. T.,and Hirschfelder, J. 0. (1966).J . Chem. Phys. 44,431. Tuck, D. G.(1960).J. Phys. Chem. 64, 1775. van Raan, A. F. J., Baum, G., and Raith. W. (1976).J . Phys. B 9,L349. v. Oppen, G.(1969).Z . Phys. 227,207. v. Oppen, G.(1970).Z . Phys. 232,473. v. Oppen, G.,and Piosczyk, B. (1969).Z . Phys. 229, 163. Weinhold, F. (1972).Ado. Quantum Chem. 6, 226. Werner, H.-J., and Meyer, W. (1976).Phys. Rev. A 13, 13. Yao, Y. T. (1932).Z.Phys. 17,307. Yoshimine, M., and Hurst, R. P. (1964).Phys. Rev. 135, A 612. Zorn. J. C., and Fontana, P. R. (1960).Bull. Am. Phys. SOC.5, 242. Zorn, J. C.,Chamberlain, G. E., and Hughes, V. W. (1963).Phys. Rev. 129,2566.
55
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
STUDY OF COLLISIONS BY LASER SPECTROSCOPY P A U L R . BERMAN Physics Department, New York University, New York. New York
............................................ ...................................................
1. Introduction 11. Collisions
57
60
A. Approximations 8. Collisional Time C. Analysis of the C A. General Considerations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
B. Line Shape-No Collisions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Line Shape-Collisions: Formal Solution . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
D. Line Shape-Specific Collision Model . E. Line Shape Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . F. Alternative Level Schemes ....................... IV. Transient Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Free Induction Decay (FID) . . . . . . . . B. Two-Pulse Nutation-Delayed Saturate ............... C. Photon Echoes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V. Experimental Survey-Theoretical Outlook A. Experimental Survey . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Theoretical Outlook . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI. Conclusions.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Appendix . . ................................... A. Definitio qs. (3.21) . . . . . . . . . . . B. Derivation of Eqs. (3.57b) ,and (3.65) . . . . Glossary of Symbols . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
65 67 74
80
93 96 100 100 102 106 107
110
I. Introduction A standard problem in atomic and molecular physics is the determination of the differential and total cross section for atom-atom, atom-molecule, or molecule-molecule scattering. In an ideal experiment, both scattering particles can be prepared in pure states characterized by a set of internal quantum numbers plus a value for the atomic or molecular center-of-mass momentum. The output of this ideal scattering experiment will be a deter57
58
P . R. Berman
mination of the cross section for scattering of a particle with internal state a and momentum p by another particle with internal state a’ and momentum p’. By studying the ditrerential and total scattering cross sections as a function of the internal states and relative energy of the particles, one hopes to map out the interatomic potential giving rise to the scattering. A knowledge of the interatomic potential, in turn, enables one to test theoretical calculations of atomic structure, while the values obtained for the scattering cross sections can be used in the analysis of practical systems where these collisional processes are known to occur. The type of experiment that most nearly approaches the ideal mentioned above and that has traditionally served as a standard method for obtaining cross-section data involves the use of crossed atomic or molecular beams. Each beam can be prepared in a fairly well-defined momentum state; therefore, provided the internal state of the atoms in each beam can also be selected, crossed-beam experiments undoubtedly represent the best method for obtaining precise differential scattering cross sections. However, there have been some limitations to beam experiments:
(1) Since beam densities are low, scattering experiments with beams have generally involved atoms in ground electronic or in metastable states; only these states possess populations that are large enough to give rise to detectable scattering signals. (2) The choice of scattering particles is somewhat restricted by detector efficiency. (3) It is difficult to obtain beams with significantly lower than thermal energies. (4) Absolute cross-section measurements are difficult and require careful normalization procedures. ( 5 ) Beam experiments tend to be less modular in nature than the laser spectroscopy experiments to be described below. It would be desirable to develop flexible alternative methods for obtaining collision cross-section data. As is well known, collision e k t s manifest themselves in the line shapes associated with atomic and molecular systems. Lumped under such headings as “ pressure broadening ” or “ collision broadening” owing to the fact that collisions can lead to a broadening of spectral profiles, collision effects have proved a nuisance to many experimentalists. Forced to conduct experiments at pressures where collision effects were significant, but interested in using the, experiments to obtain characteristic atomic parameters in the absence of collisions, one generally employed simple collision theories to describe the observed line shapes and then extrapolated the results to zero pressure. In the extrapolation process, some values for collision rates were invariably obtained. Gradually, it
STUDY OF COLLISIONS BY LASER SPECTROSCOPY
59
became appreciated that line shape studies could yield information on collision effects in atomic and molecular systems. [For a review of some of this work, see Chen and Takeo (1957), Breene (1961),Jeffries (1968),and Berman and Lamb (196911. Line shape studies typically could provide values for elastic, inelastic, transfer, or magnetic relaxation total cross sections. Measurements of differential cross sections were never obtained. The development of tunable narrow-band laser sources has opened up a new vista for spectroscopiccollision studies using " bulb "-type experiments. Using near-resonant monochromatic excitation, one will excite atoms with a specified velocity component in the direction of the field's propagation vector. The excited atoms can then undergo collisions in which their velocities are altered and the velocity changes can be monitored by subjectingthe atoms to a probe field. In this manner, information on the differentialscattering cross section can be obtained from laser spectroscopy.Admittedly, one does not directly obtain a differential'scatteringcross section in such experiments. Rather, the line shape reflects the differential scattering cross section averaged over all perturber velocities and those velocities of the "active" atoms that have not been selected by the laser. Still, some semiquantitative data on the differential scattering cross section may be inferred from the line shape. Moreover, for practical applications such as laser isotope separation, laser pumping schemes, and atmospheric physics, it turns out that the experimental quantity of interest is an average cross section rather than a cross section given as a function of the center-of-mass energy of the colliding particles. Let us compare beam- and bulb-type experiments in light of the limitations of beam experiments discussed above. (1) With the use of lasers, nonthermal excited-state populations can now be achieved. Bulb experiments will require less excited-statepopulation than beam experiments since photon detection efficiencyis generally greater than neutral-particle detection efficiency. In bulb experiments, the laser can easily probe a given transition; in beam experiments, the scattering will now take place from a superposition state that can be quite complicated. A rigorous analysis of scattering from coherently excited states including cascade effects has not yet been carried out. (2) Detection efficiency does not depend on the atomic sample in bulb experiments since it is photons and not particles that are detected. (3) In bulb experiments, one can probe lower than thermal energies of the active atoms by velocity selecting slow atoms using resonant laser radiation. The velocity selection will be for only one component of the active atom; the averaging over the active atom's other velocity components plus the perturbers' velocities substantially reduces the energy selectivity.
60
P . R. Berman
(4) Absolute cross-section measurements arise naturally in bulb experiments if one monitors collision rates vs perturber density. ( 5 ) Bulb experiments are quite flexible in nature, containing components that are easily interfaced with other experiments.
Still, with all their advantages, it.is unlikely that bulb experiments will replace beam experiments for providing precise differential scattering crosssection data. The averaging processes occurring in bulb experiments and the entanglement of the differential cross section in what can be very involved line shapes do not lend themselves to a detailed determination of the differential cross section. The bulb experiments offer more of a macroscopic (in the sense of averaged) picture of the collisional processes occurring within the sample than do beam experiments. With this understanding, we shall forget the beam experiments and discuss the way in which bulb experiments can be used to provide collisional information. To illustrate the potential of bulb-type collision studies, we shall examine the steady-state laser spectroscopy of three-level systems and the transient spectroscopy of two-level systems. Not only will these experiments enable one to obtain total and “poor men’s’’ differential cross sections, but they will also enable one to gather information on collisional processes not characteristically found in beam experiments. Spectroscopic studies involve following the atomic dipole moment or off-diagonal density matrix element associated with a given transition. As will be discussed in Section 11, it is not immediately obvious how one should treat the scattering of off-diagonal density matrix elements. Recent collision theories have purported to offer prescriptions for describing this type of scattering, and laser spectroscopy experiments can provide tests of those theories. Some of the equations to be derived (especiallyin Section 111)may seem a little unwieldy. However, as will be pointed out, each term in these equations is simply a manifestation of a fundamental physical process. In this sense, the line shapes simply reflect the various atom-field and atom-atom interactions occurring within the sample. For convenience, a glossary of symbols is included.
11. Collisions A. APPROXIMATIONS It is not the purpose of this work to present a comprehensive review of recent developments in the theory of the effects of collisions on the line shapes associated with atomic and molecular systems. We shall recall some of the results of these theories, but refer the reader to a recent review article for a more detailed treatment and an extensive bibliography (Berman, 1975).
STUDY OF COLLISIONS BY LASER SPECTROSCOPY
61
In general, the study of collision processes occurring in atomic and molecular systems that are simultaneously subjected to applied radiation fields represents a formidable problem. The complexity of the problem is a sensitive function of the gas pressures involved, the level spacings of the atoms, the applied field strengths, and the specific transitions under investigation. Clearly, if one wishes to study collision processes by spectroscopic techniques, he should choose conditions that allow for a relatively straightforward analysis of the line shapes involved. In this spirit, we shall limit our discussion to physical systems of an extremely simple nature. In addition to neglecting level degeneracy, the following approximations or assumptions will be made: Binary collision approximation: The gas pressure is assumed to be low enough ( 5 several hundred torr) to neglect three-body collisions. In other words, the time between two-body collisions is assumed to be much greater than the duration of these collisions. Adiabatic and impact approximations : These are approximations related to the duration z, of a collision. As long as w , = T;' (wc is typically 10l2sec- ') is not comparable with other system frequencies, the mathematical description of the system is greatly simplified. We shall assume that o, is much less than any of the transition frequencies under consideration. Consequently, collisions do not possess the frequency components necessary to induce transitions between the states shown in Fig. 1 (adiabatic approxi-
a' a
-uHH
FIG.1. The two-level system considered in this work.
mation). Furthermore, it is assumed that w, is much greater than the rate of collisions, the natural decay rates, the rate of field-induced transitions, and the detuning of the applied fields from the atomic transitions. In this limit (impact approximation), the duration of a collision is effectively instantaneous in comparison with the time between collisions, the natural lifetime of the levels, the time required for the fields to induce transitions, and the dephasing time of the atomic dipoles determined by the inverse of the atom-field detunings. The impact approximation enables m e to treat the collision and external field effects independently.
62
P.R. Berman
Foreign gas perturbers: It will be assumed that the density of active atoms is low enough to neglect active atom-active atom collisions. All collision effects will be attributable to collisions of the active atoms with dissimilar atoms (foreign gas perturbers). Thus all effects of collision-induced excitation transfer as well as radiation trapping will be ignored. It is not difficult to find physical systems satisfying the above requirements. Methods for relaxing some of the above restrictions will be discussed in Section V.
B. COLLISIONAL TIME RATE OF CHANGE OF THE DENSITY MATRIX In the context of the above approximations, collisions and atom-field interactions contribute separately to the time rate of change of the density matrix describing the system. Thus, it is possible to isolate the collisions and determine the results of individual active atom-perturber scattering events. In general, the collision interaction will be state dependent; that is, active atoms in state 1 (see Fig. 1) experience a different interaction with perturbers than active atoms in state 2.Thus, as a result of a collision with a perturber, an active atom would follow a trajectory that depends on its wavefunction before entering the collision. There is little conceptual difficulty in assigning different collision trajectories to the populations p1 and pzz of levels 1 and 2,respectively; the state-dependent collision interaction can provide separate trajectories for p1 and pZ2just as a Stern-Gerlach magnet can provide different paths for different spin states. However, it is more difficult to assign a trajectory to the off-diagonal density matrix element p12. A little thought should convince the reader that it is impossible to assign a classical trajectory to plz ,since the collisional contribution to plz involves the quantum-mechanical interference of the state 1 and state 2 scattering amplitudes. This conclusion was reached independently by several groups (Andreeva, 1968;Pestov and Rautian, 1969;Berman and Lamb, 1970,1971; Cattani, 1970; Hess, 1972; Smith et al., 1971a,b;Chappell et al., 1971; Berman, 1972a,b;Alexseev et al., 1972,1973;Zaidi, 1972;Bielicz et al., 1972) who then calculated the change in p12using a quantum-mechanicaldescription for the active atom’s center-of-mass motion. All the results were in general agreement and provided equations for the collisional time rate of change of density matrix elements in which one assigns a velocity to individual density matrix elements rather than the atom as a whole. As will be seen below, a classical interpretation of these equations is possible only under limited conditions. The collisional time rate of change of density matrix elements, subject to the approximations of Section H,A, is given by
STUDY OF COLLISIONS BY LASER SPECTROSCOPY
63
where
and v (or v’) is the active atom velocity, vp (or v’p) the perturber velocity, X the perturber density, Wp(vp) the perturber velocity distribution, v, (or v:) and p the active-atom-perturber relative velocity and reduced mass, respectively,fi(v: - vr) the elastic scattering amplitude for state i, and m and mp the active-atom and perturber masses, respectively. The derivation and explanation of these terms, which arise from simple quantum-mechanical scattering theory, is given elsewhere (Berman, 1972a).One can note here, however, that Tij(v) depends only on forward scattering amplitudes; this result arises owing to the quantum-mechanical interference of the unscattered wave of state i or j with the spherically scattered wave of state j or i, respectively. EQUATION C. ANALYSISOF THE COLLISION I . Diagonal Terms, i = j
If i = j, the analysis of Eq. (2.1) is straightforward. In that case, wi(v’+v) is simply the state i differential scattering cross section averaged over the perturber velocity distribution, and it follows from Eqs. (2.2) and (2.3) that
is the collision rate for elastic scattering in state i, where ai is the total elastic scattering cross section for state i. Both Yi(v’+v) and Tii(v) are real and can be thought to possess the classical limits of a collision kernel and rate, respectively. Equation (2.1) multiplied by dv for i = j gives the collisional diffusion out of and flow into the velocity subspace between v and v + dv for
P . R . Berman
64
state i scattering. Note that one does not have a pure classical limit since the kernels and rates will vary with the state i ; instead a separate classical limit for each population is possible. 2. Noitdiagonal Terms, i $: j
The nondiagonal terms present somewhat more of a problem. A classical limit is possible only if the collision interaction is state independent, j;(v’-v) =.fj(v‘-)v). In that case one recovers a real, state-independent collision kernel and collision rate. The state-independent collision interaction has a pure classical analog since, as far as the collisions are concerned, the atom has no internal structure and collisions serve only to change the velocity of the active atoms. If the collision interaction is state dependent there are still some interesting limiting cases of Eq. (2.I). In the limit of a large ratio of active atom to perturber mass,
qj(v’-+v)
-
. I ’ 6(v - v’)
(. dv, dROr,W,(V,)U,J~(V,-)V:)~~(V,--,V:) (2.5)
and, using Eqs. (2.1)-(2.3) and (2.5), one recovers the result of Baranger (1958a): dPij(V, t ) / d r
=
-$(V)pij(v,
t)
(2.6)
coll
This limit represents the neglect of any velocity changes in the active atoms during collisions. In such a case, the only collisional changes in off-diagonal density matrix elements are changes of phase, leading to the terminology “ phase-changing” collisions. Such collisions are the type considered in classic theories of pressure broadening (Lindholm, 1945; Foley, 1946; and Anderson, 1949) and give rise to the familiar collision broadening and shift of spectral profiles. Thus, the phase-changing collision limit is achieved for those collisions that result in a negligible change in active-atom velocity (a .‘ negligible” change is typically Au 5 y/k, where 11is some decay rate and k a propagation vector).
STUDY OF COLLISIONS BY LASER SPECTROSCOPY
65
Equation (2.6) differs in form from Eq. (2.1) in that a “source” term corresponding to the second term in the rhs of Eq. (2.1)is absent in Eq. (2.6). The absence of a source term in Eq. (2.6) implies that the velocity associated with an off-diagonal density matrix element is unchanged by collisions; i.e., collisions are not velocity changing in their effect on p i j for i # j . A source term does not appear in Eq. (2.6) owing to a large active atom to perturber mass ratio. Another limit in which a source term will not appear occurs when the scattering for state i or j is negligible compared with the other [.fi(vi+vr) z 0 orjj(v:+v,) x 01. In that case, Kj(v’+v) z 0 and it follows from Eqs. (2.1)-(2.3) that the equation for i)ijlcollhas the same form as Eq. (2.6), with the scattering amplitude for the weakly interacting state set equal to zero in Eq. (2.7) for )~;~(v).Collisions appear to be phase changing in nature since all velocity-changingcontributions have been eliminated by the destructive interference of the quantum-mechanical amplitudes giving rise to bij [co,l. Thus, if I ,jJvi+vr) I 3 I .f;(vi+vr) I one can neglect the contribution of state i scattering on bijlcoll, at least to first approximation. When none of the above limits are realized, the equation for pijl c ol l contains an unextricable combination of phase- and velocity-changing effects. To date there has been little progress in treating the general equation. The effects of collisions on Pij for i # j may be summarized as follows: For equal or nearly equal collision interactions for states i and j , a purely classical analog exists and collisions result only in velocity changes. For negligible active-atom velocity changes in collisions or for strongly state-dependent collision interactions, collisions are phase changing in nature, albeit for different reasons. One might expect to find nearly equal collision interactions for states comprising fine structure, hyperfine structure, rotational or vibrational transitions, and strongly state-dependent collision interactions for levels comprising electronic and some vibrational transitions. There have not been any explicit systematic experimental studies of the above ideas to test the state dependence of collision interactions.
111. Three-Level Systems A. GENERAL CONSIDERATIONS Three-level systems offer a convenient method for studying many of the collision effects outlined in Section 11. By systematic study of the line shapes associated with three-level systems, one can, in certain cases, extract the elastic scattering cross sections for the various levels involved. Moreover, information on the differential scattering cross section for scattering in level 2 (see Fig. 2) can be obtained. Theoretical treatments of collisions in threelevel systems have been given by Hgjlsch and Toschek (1970), Rautian et al.
66
P . R . Berman
(b)
(a 1 (C)
FIG.2. The various three-level systems considered in this work: (a) upward cascade, (b) inverted V, (c) V.
(1972), Kolchenko et al. (1973), Beterov et a f . (1973), Ben-Reuven et al. (1976), and Berman (1976),and the presentation below incorporates several features of these theories, while adding some new concepts. In particular, many of the results given below have been discussed by Kolchenko et al. (1973) and Berman (1976), albeit for somewhat different collision models. Typical three-level systems are shown in Fig. 2. We shall analyze the upward cascade shown in Fig. 2a; corresponding results for Figs. 2b and 2c will be given in Section III,F. The 1-2 and 2-3 transition frequencies are o and a’,respectively, and states 1 and 3 have the same parity, which is opposite that of level 2. Each of the levels i ( i = 1,2,3) is populated with a rate density 1,(v), which is assumed to be independent of position. Owing to spontaneous emission, the levels decay with rates yi. The possibility that the spontaneous emission from one level serves to populate another level is specifically excluded here. A limiting case of practical importance is one in which level 1 is a ground state and 1, = 1, = 0. This limit is achieved by letting 11 0, Y1 0, Ll(V)/Y, = Ndv) (3.1) where N 1(v) is the ground-state velocity distribution per unit volume. The three-level system is subject to a “pump” field
-
E(2,t) = iE COS(&!
+ at)
(34
in near resonance with the 1-2 transition and a “probe” field E(2,t) = iE‘ cos(k’2 + at)
(3.3)
in near resonance with the 2-3 transition, where E and E are the amplitudes, - k = - tkg (t = .t 1)and - k’= the propagation vectors, and R and R’ the frequencies of the pump and probe, respectively. The choice of geometry is such that the beams are copropagating (6 = + 1)or counterprop-
k‘z
STUDY OF COLLISIONS BY LASER SPECTROSCOPY
67
agating ( L = - 1). Field E drives only the 1-2 transition and field E' only the 2-3 transition. In a typical experiment, one keeps the pump frequency fixed and monitors either the absorption of the probe or the population of one of the levels as a function of the probe frequency. For the purposes of this discussion, we shall assume that the population of level 3 is monitored (e.g., by fluorescence) as a function of R' for fixed R. B. LINESHAPE-NOCOLLISIONS The wave function for the nth active atom is given by 3
V ( r n Rn t ) = 9
9
1 AY(Rn
3
i= 1
t)$i(rn)
(3.4)
where r, represents all the relative electronic coordinates of atom n, Rn is the center-of-mass coordinate of atom n, i one of the levels of the three-level system, ICli(r,,)a free-atom electronic eigenfunction, and AY(R, , t ) a probability amplitude. Macroscopic density matrix elements pij(R, t ) =
(. C AY(Rn
9
t)A,"(Rn t)* 9
* f l
x 6(R - R,) dR,
(3.5)
are introduced such that .
3
is the total number of active atoms. Using Schrodinger's equation, one can easily obtain the equations of motion for the purely quantum-mechanical quantities pij(R, t). This equation will possess a classical limit provided the fields d o not affect the velocity in a state-dependent manner (Berman, 1972a). Thus, if we neglect the changes in atomic velocity resulting from the emission or absorption of photons from the fields, one can write a transport equation for density matrix elements in classical phase space pij(R, v, t), where R and v now represent the average position and momentum of a wave packet describing the atom. This transport equation (Smith et al., 1971a,b; Berman, 1972a; Alexseev et al., 1972) dpij(R,
V,
t)/dt =
-V
Vpij(R, V, t )
- YijPij(R, V,
+ A~(v)6ij
t)
+ ( i h ) - ' [ H ~+ V(R, t),p(R, V, t)]ij
(3.7)
P. R. Berman
68
has an intuitive form. The contributions to dpij(R, v,
t)/&
are
-
(1) a convective flow term - v Vpij(R, v, t ) ; (2) the rate density Ai(v) dij discussed in Section 111,A; (3) a loss term -yiipij(R, v, t) due to spontaneous emission, where Yij
= (yi
+ Yj)P
(3.8)
(4) the change in pij owing to the free atom Hamiltonian H o , (iA)- ' [ H o , p(R, V, t)]ij = - i ~ i j p i j ( R , V, t )
(3.9a)
with i =j
~
(Ei - Ej)/h,
021
= 0,
032
= W'
(3.9b)
and Ei the free atom eigenenergy of state i; and ( 5 ) the atom-field interaction
(ih)-'[V(R, t), p(R,
V, t)]ij
where the matrix elements Kj(R, t) are given by (3.10) with pij the x component of the dipole matrix element between states i and j. Equations (3.7) have been studied extensively in the literature (Feld and Javan, 1969; Hansch and Toschek, 1970; Beterov and Chebotaev, 1974; Brewer and Hahn, 1975; Salomaa and Stenholm, 1975, 1976). In this Section, we seek only steady-state solutions of Eq. (3.7) and neglect all transient effects. Assuming that field El drives only the 1-2 transition and E2 only the 2-3 transition, introducing the field interaction representation through v, t ) = P12(v) exp[i(ckZ + Qt)]
(3.1la)
p23(R, v, t ) = P 2 3 ( v ) exp[i(k'Z + n't)] exp{i[(k' dc)Z ~ 1 3 ( R v, , t) =
(3.11b)
p&,
+
pii(R,
+ (Q + n ' ) t ] }
(3.11~) (3.11d)
V, t ) = Pii(v)
noting that pij(R, V,
t ) = pji(R, V, t ) * ,
P i j ( V ) = Pji(v)*
(3.12)
substituting Eqs. (3.11) into Eq. (3.7), making use of Eqs. (3.9), (3.10), and (3.12), and employing the rotating-wave approximation (neglecting rapidly
(3.13f)
(3.14) (3.15a) (3.15b) (3.1%)
(3.15d) The dipole matrix elements have been taken to be real without loss of generality. The algebraic set of Eqs. (3.13) may be solved exactly (Hansch and Toschek, 1970; Beterov and Chebotaev, 1974; Brewer and Hahn, 1975). However, the exact solutions do not lend themselves to a simple analysis once collisions are present. It seems highly appropriate, therefore, to consider only perturbutive solutions of Eqs. (3.13) since it is in the weak-field limit that one will have the most sensitive test of collision theories. There will be contributions to the population @33(v)in zero order, in order (z’)~(linear absorption or stimulated emission), and in order (1~’)’ (nonlinear spectroscopy). We will examine only the last term, which represents the change in the absorption of the probe field owing to the presence of the pump field. Experimentally, it is possible to isolate this term by modulating the pump field and measuring the fluorescence from level 3 using phase-sensitive detection. The perturbation chains leading to p33(v) to order (xx’)’ are shown in Table I. This separation will be extremely useful once collisions are in-
P . R . Berman TABLE I
PERTURBATION CHAINS FOR THREE-LEVEL PROBLEM Chain
Density matrix elements
troduced. The contributions of each chain are easily calculated in perturbation theory. For example, the contribution from the first chain is obtained as P\":(V)
- d\OZ)(V) = W ) / Y l
P\lj(v) = ix[q12 x
(3.16a)
-MV)/YZ
+ icku,]-'
12\oZ)(v) - P\":(V)l
(3.16b)
P\zZ)(v) = izV\'Z)(v) - P\ll)(v)l/rz Pi3;(v) = - ix'(gz3
+ ik'u,)-
'P',",v)
bS4J(v) = ix'Fk3J(v) - PS3Z)(v)I/y3
(3.16~) (3.16d) (3.16e)
where the superscript gives the order of the external fields present. The explicit calculation of &4J(v) above, together with similar calculations from the other chains given in Table I, leads to
(3.17) (3.18a) (3.18b)
STUDY OF COLLISIONS BY LASER SPECTROSCOPY
71
are the values of $,,(v) - $,,(v) and $22(v) - fi33(v),respectively, in the absence of any applied fields. We shall take both N(v) and N'(v) to be Maxwellian, with N(v)= NWO(v),
N'(v) = N'W,(V)
%(v) = (nu2)-3'2exp[ - (u2/u2)]
(3.19a) (3.19b)
where u is the most probable speed and N and N' are constants with units of (volume)- l. The level 3 population per unit volume, defined as P33
.(. dvfi33(v)
=
(3.20)
may be obtained by integrating Eq. (3.17) using Eqs. (3.18) and (3.19). Listing the result as a sum of the contributions p i 3 from the three chains given in Table I, one finds
c 3
P33
=
Pi3
(3.21a)
i=1
where Pi3
=
2AN 72 1'3 kuk'u
Re[I'(ki,. irtlz ku lV23
(3.21b)
2AN - - y3kuk'u Ik' c k l u
2 p33
P:3
=-
+
2AN' y3(k'u), I k' ck 1 u
+
(3.21d) A = (XX')'
Y ( x )=
i
1, -1,
(3.22) x >0
.x
(3.23)
and the functions I I,, and l 3 are given in the Appendix [Eqs. (A.4t(A.6)] as functions of the plasma dispersion function (Fried and Conte, 1961). Limiting cases of Eqs. (3.21) may be derived.
P . R . Berman
72 1 . Large Detuning, IA I 9 ku’
For large detunings 1 A I $ ku, it follows most easily from Eqs. (3.17) and (3.20) or from the asymptotic value of Eqs. (3.21) that
for A = - A 5
-~2A Z i ( 2 ) y3 k‘ud’
“(2 -
1)
for A ’ x O
(3.24)
- 2NOZ
AA
1
(3.25)
where Zi(p)is the imaginary part of the plasma dispersion function, defined as .a .-I/’ e - x 2 (3.26) Z ( p )= dx
1
pfx
with Im(p) > 0. For Im(p) e 1, Re(p) 5 1, Zi(p)
‘V
nl” ex~I-[Reb)]’)
(3.27)
Since -y << ku is typical, Eqs. (3.24) and (3.25) represent two broad resonances’ that arise for large pump detunings. The resonances occur at probe detunings A‘ = -A and A’ = 0. It is possible to interpret these resonances in terms of the perturbation chains in Table 1. The first chain is sometimes called a “stepwise” (SW) contribution since it involves the population p’’ of the intermediate state. The resonance conditions for this stepwise process for atoms moving with velocity u, are
A = -tkv,,
A’ =
- k’u,
(3.28)
For large detuning, I A I 9 ku, field El is off-resonance for all velocity subsets and excites these subsets equally, albeit with small probability. With the entire Maxwellian distribution excited by El, the resonance condition on A‘ gives rise to a broad resonance centered at A’ = 0 [see Eq. (3.25)]. The second and third contributions in Table I are sometimes called “coherence” or “ two-quanta’’ (TQ) contributions since they involve the
’ For the impact approximation to remain valid, one must maintain IA Ire< 1, where r , is the duration time ofa collision. Typically, IA I in the range 1010-1012 sec-’ will satisfy both the large detuning criterion and the impact approximation. If k’ = k and = - 1 (’two-photon Doppler-free case”), Eq. (3.24) goes over into a Lorentzian of HWHM For the purposes of discussion, we shall assume that I k’ + ck I u B ;113, although the equations are valid if this inequality does not hold.
73
STUDY OF COLLISIONS BY LASER SPECTROSCOPY
density matrix element p13 rather than the intermediate-state population. These TQ contributions possess resonances at [see Eq. (3.17) lines 2 and 31
+ A = -(k’ + tk)u,
A
(3.29)
A’ = -k’v
(3.30)
In addition, the TQ contribution proportional to N has an additional resonance at
A = -rku,
(3.3 1 )
Equation (3.29) leads to a broad resonance at A + A = 0 [Eq. (3.24)] while Eq. (3.30) gives rise to a contribution to the A = 0 resonance. In the absence of collisions, it is somewhat artificial to distinguish the SW and TQ processes since they cannot be separated. For example, if y1 = 0, one sees that the SW and TQ contributions cancel one another in the term proportional to N in Eq. (3.25). Thus, for y l = 0, N’ = 0, and 1 A [ S ku, there is no resonance at A’ z 0 in the absence of collisions. 2. Near-Resonant Tuning, I A1 < ku
For near-resonant tuning, 1 A I < ku, assuming a large Doppler width, y G ku, k u
(3.32)
the integration of Eq. (3.17) is easily performed [or the asymptotic form of Eqs. (3.21) used] to arrive at 47c’”A P33
=Y2Y3
NfZ
T2 + BZ
-[
+
N ‘ k y 2 r (T: - 6:) Ik’+ rkl (T: +A:)’ @( - k’ - r k ) ]
(3.33)
where
Yz l- - - k- ‘ y , + Ik’+ckI k
k 2
2
+-2
Y3
6 = A’ - c(k’/k)A rl
= 723
61 =
A
(3.35)
+ [ k / ( k- k ) ] Y 1 3
+ [k’/(k - k‘)](A+ A )
and @(x) =
1;
(3.34)
x>o x
(3.36) (3.37)
(3.38)
14
P . R . Berinan
These results have been discussed by many authors (Feld and Javan, 1969; Hansch and Toschek, 1970; Beterov et al., 1973; Beterov and Chebotaev, 1974). Equations (3.28)-(3.31)may all be satisfied by a single velocity subset, leading to a resonance condition 6, = 0 for both the SW and T Q chains. For copropagating waves, the TQ terms in Eq. (3.17) average to zero when the velocity integral is performed, and for counterpropagating waves, the second term in Eq. (3.33) contributes only for k > k’. For arbitrary A, the exact equations (3.21)should be used. For I A 1 on the order of several ku, the line shape takes on a more complicated form, with resonances arising when various combinations of the conditions (3.28)-(3.31) are satisfied (Bjorkholm and Liao, 1976; Salomaa and Stenholm, 1976).
FORMAL SOLUTION C. LINESHAPE-COLLISIONS: It is relatively easy to arrive at a formal expression for the line shape that includes the effects of collisions. In the impact approximation, the contributions to p from collisions [Eq. (2.111is simply added to the rhs of Eqs. (3.13). Steady-state solutions are still possible and each of Eqs. (3.13) takes the form qij(t’:)ijij(v) + rij(v)Pij(v)
- (. dv’Wj(v’+v)fiij(v’) where
q i j ( r z= ) ;‘i h i j + ( 1 kl2 = tk,
k23
= .fij(v)
+ ikijrz) k13 = k‘ + tk
- hij)(ylij
= k‘,
(3.39) (3.40) (3.41)
qij is given by Eqs. (3.15), Tii and W j by Eqs. (2.3) and (2.2), and the .fii correspond to the rhs of Eqs. (3.13) for fiij, e.g., .fIl(V)
= i%[fi21(V) - filZ(V11
”I?.(’)
= i%[@22(v)
- fill(v)]
+ Jl(V)
(3.42a)
- I’%’fil)(v)
(3.42b)
In perturbation theory, Eqs. (3.39) are most easily solved by taking solutions for fiij(v) of the form
1
Pij(v) = dv‘Gij(v’+v).Yij(v’)
(3.43)
where the propagators Gij(v’+ v ) satisfy the equation [tlij(r:) -
+ rij(v)lGij(v’--*v)
1 ~ V ” U $ ~ ( V ” + V ) G ~ ~ ( V ’ - V=’ ’d(v ) - v’)
(3.44)
STUDY OF COLLISIONS
BY LASER SPECTROSCOPY
75
All the effects of collision are included in Eq. (3.44), which in general will be very difficult to solve. However, the formal solution for the line shape in perturbation theory (in the external fields) now follows directly. Using Eqs. (3.39b(3.43) and (3.13) one sees, for example, that the contribution of chain 1 of Table I, given for the no-collision case by Eqs. (3.16), is now replaced by
p\q(v) = ix
I dv’G,,(v’+v)[~~~~(v‘!- $\‘;(v’)]
p$’;(v)
I d~’G~~(v’+v)[p‘j:)(v’) - fi$’;(v’)]
= ix
3i3i(v) = - i f pi4:(v) = ix’
(3.45)
1 d~’G,,(v’+v)p\~;(v’)
1 d~‘G,,(v‘+v)[p~~:(v’)
- $i3J(v’)]
When this contribution is combined with those corresponding to chains 2 and 3 of Table I and Eq. (3.20) is used, one arrives at the formal line shape 3
p33=
CPi33 i=l
where
(3.46a)
P . R . Berman
76 p:3 = - A
(. dv dv4 dv3 dv2 dv1 d v o G 3 3 ( ~ 4 - + ~ )
x
G 2 3 ( ~ +~4)Gi3(V2+V3)G23(Vi 3
x
[G22(Vo+Vi)A2(Vo)
- G33(v0
-+
+V2) vi)b(vo)]
+ conjugate
(3.46d)
Some simplification of these equations is possible regardless of the collision model utilized. First, if the A,(v) represent thermal distributions as has been assumed, collisions can not change these distributions. In other words,
1 dv’G,,(v’+v)L,(v‘)
=A
~ ( ~ ) / ~ ~
(3.47)
Second, the total number of atoms in a given state is unchanged by collisions, i.e., (. dvG,,(v’+v) = l/y, (3.48) a result that is easily obtained by integrating Eq. (3.44) over v for i = j while making use of Eq. (2.4a). Using these results in Eqs. (3.46) and recalling definitions (3.19), one obtains
(. dv d ~ dv, 2 ~v~[G~~(v~+v)
pi3 = -AN(y3)-’
+ G23(V2-*V)*lG2Z(Vl+V2)[G12(VO+Vl) + G 1 2 b o v1 )*I WO(V0) +
(. dv dv, dvl d v o G 2 3 ( ~ 2 + ~ )
p:3 = -AN(y3)-’ 13(v 1
1 wO(vO)
v2)G 1 2(v0
+ conjugate p:3 =
(3.49a)
(3.49b)
1
AN'(^,)-^ dv dv2 dv, dvo G23(v2--rv)G13(v1
-+v2)
+
x G 2 3 ( v o - - r ~ , ) W O ( ~ O conjugate )
(3.49c)
We now turn our attention to the choice of a collision model, which will give rise to specific propagators. D. LINESHAPE-SPECIFIC COLLISION MODEL In choosing a collision model, the major question to ask oneself is whether or not, to first approximation, the collision interaction is state dependent, since the answer to this question will provide the form for the collision
77
STUDY OF COLLISIONS BY LASER SPECTROSCOPY
kernel, as discussed in Section II,C,2. Another important factor is the activeatom to perturber mass ratio since this also affects the nature of the collision terms. The simplest model and the one we choose here is a model in which collisions are phase changing in their effect on off-diagonal density matrix elements, i.e., iij(v)
1
=
-Y$h(v)ijij(V),
(3.50)
i#j
coll
where y5h is given by Eq. (2.7). As discussed in Section II,C,2, this type of equation will arise for either a large active atom to perturber mass ratio or a strongly state-dependent collision interaction. In the latter case, one should approximate yfih by neglecting the collision contribution from the weakly interacting state. The negative of the rhs of Eq. (3.50) replaces the second and third terms of Eq. (3.39) and using Eqs. (3.39), (3.43), and (3.44), one obtains the off-diagonal propagators Gij(v’+v) = [vij(vZ)
+ Y ~ ~ ( v ) ] 6(v - ’ - v’)
(3.51)
The range of validity of this model for the off-diagonal elements as well as some alternative models will be discussed at the end of this section. For the diagonal terms, there is no problem of interpretation, since collisions are solely of a velocity-changing nature. The only place where velocitychanging collisions enter the calculation is in the G22(v1+v2) factor of Eq. (3.49b). Collisions in levels 1 and 3 do not affect the line shape for reasons discussed above Eqs. (3.49). The line shape will not be critically sensitive to the form of kernel Wz2(v’+v) used in Eq. (3.44) for G,,(v‘+v) and we shall use the phenomenological kernel of Keilson and Storer (1952), WZZ(V’+V)= r , , [ n ( A ~ ) ~ ] - ~exp[’ ~ (v
- uv’)’/(Au)’]
(3.52a)
is the (speed-independent) rate of collisions in state 2, u is a where parameter between 0 and 1, and (Au) = (1 - U ~ ) ’ ’ ~ U
(3.52b)
fi
times the rms velocity change per collision. For u z 1 one has weak is collisions; for u z 0 one has “strong” collisions since, on average, each collision thermalizes the sample. Other kernels, based on physical potentials, have been given by Kolchenko er al. (1972), but Eq. (3.52a) provides a good first approximation with simple analytic properties. Equation (3.44) for G22(v’--+v’)with the kernel W22(v’+v) given by (3.52) and ~ ~ ~ ( = v y2 , ) can be solved by iteration (Keilson and Storer, 1952; Borenstein and Lamb, 1972) and one obtains G 2 2 ( ~ ‘ - -V)+ =
“
qv
- v’)
ri
1
r22n
‘9 ;,(E)
1 exp [n’i2(A~n)]3
v - u”v’
[( -
”
~
Au,,
)]
(3.53)
78
P. R. Berman
where
ri = 7 2 + r 2 2
(3.54)
(Au,,) = (1 - a2")li2u
(3.55)
The first term corresponds to atoms that have not undergone collisions, and the nth term in the summation corresponds to the average effect of n collisions. We now have values for all the propagators needed in Eqs. (3.49). Only phase-changing collisions enter in p53 and p i 3 since the chains leading to these terms (Table 1) do not contain the population f~~~as an intermediate term. The net modification in the line shape formulas owing to phasechanging collisions is the replacement of uij by qij
= qij
+ yfih(v)
(3.56)
In the p i 3 term of Eq. (3.49a), the propagator G,,(v'+v) will enter, but the integrals that arise are not difficult (see the Appendix for the evaluation of this term) provided we neglect the speed dependence ofyfih(v),which we now do.' Consequently, when the propagators (3.51) and (3.53) are substituted into Eqs. (3.49), one obtains the line shape P33
=
where Pi3
=
1P i 3
(3.57a)
2AN ri y3 kuk'u
(3.57b)
[
x Im I , ( i423
__ ii112
"13
k'u' ku ' I k ' + t k l u '
c,
V(k' + ck)]
(3.57~)
It is usually a very good first approximation to neglect the u dependence of rch.especially if the ratio of active-atom to perturber mass is 2 1.
STUDY OF COLLISIONS BY LASER SPECTROSCOPY
79
2AN
P:3
=
- y3(k'u)' I k'
+ ck I u
x Im [ I 3 ( -i q Z 3
k'u ' I k'
+ ck I u ,Y ( k ' + t k ) ) ]
"13
(3.57d)
which is the generalization of Eqs. (3.21) to include collision effects. In the limit of large detunings I A I > ku, corresponding to the no-collision Eqs. (3.24) and (3.25), one finds P33
P33
-
2A(N
-
N')
i613
- 73 (k'+rkluAzZi(Ik'+ek[u)
for A' z - A
(3.58)
2A
- ____ y 3 k'uA2
(3.60)
and for future reference
+
A
+ Sfr 1 = 3 A + A' + Sfi
d = Im q l Z= A
(3.63a)
A' = Im
(3.63b)
~
For near-resonant tuning I A 1 < ku in the Doppler limit
fij4 ku, k'u
(3.64)
Eqs. (3.57) reduce to
(3.65)
P . R . Berman
80
where
tk' Aa = A' - -A k
r c =k' k i + 1k'2 + R3 , r r d
= rb@(k
-
(3.66a)
k' Ab = A' + 7 (A+ A ) k-k
(3.66b)
k A, = -A k
(3.66~)
-
k' +7 (A+ A ) k - k
- k')
+ T,@(k' - k),
+ A,O(k' - k )
(3.66d)
and @(.u) is the step function given in Eq. (3.38). Before analyzing the line shapes (3.58),(3.59),and (3.65). it might be useful to indicate when one would expect this collision model to be applicable. As stated previously, the model is valid for large active-atom to perturber mass ratios or for strongly state-dependent collision interactions. If states 1,2, and 3 belong to different electronic configurations, one could expect the collision interaction to be strongly state dependent. Different electronic configurations for the various levels may be easily realized in the upward cascade of Fig. 2a. On the other hand, in the V " schemes of Figs. 2b and 2c, levels 1 and 3 may be part of the same electronic configuration. In that case one might want to take collisions as velocity changing rather than phase changing in their effect on P l 3 , at least to first approximation. Some consequences of such a model will be mentioned below and, in particular a method for checking the effect of collisions on fiI3 will be given. It should be noted that analytic solutions are obtainable only for very simple collision kernels when one considers the effects of velocity-changing collisions on off-diagonal density matrix elements. If levels 1 and 2, 2 and 3, or all three levels are in the same electronic configuration (e.g., vibration-rotation transitions), another collision model may be necessary that will be much more complicated than the one considered above. The collision model we have chosen should be applicable to many physical systems and has the important advantage of being the simplest type of model that one could imagine. "
E. LINESHAPEANALYSIS Even for the simple collision model chosen above, there are eight collision and z) that must be parameters (rrl,rph,, rph,,Spl, Sp!, Sps, determined. These parameters are related to collision cross sections in the various levels through Eq. (2.7) and to the rate and strength of collisions in
STUDY OF COLLISIONS BY LASER SPECTROSCOPY
81
level 2 through the kernek (3.52). Even though the number of parameters is large, systematic line shape studies can lead to a unique determination of each quantity. To simplify the analysis, we shall take
N = O Physically, this limit corresponds to having only level 1 populated in the absence of applied fields, as would be the case if level 1 were the ground state. The situation in which N' # 0 does not lead to any additional problems (provided one can experimentally determine N and N'), but also does not provide any new collisional information. 1. Large Detunings, IA I b ku
Systematic line shape studies should begin in the large detuning limit with the line shape given by Eqs. (3.58) and (3.59). a. A' 2 -A. Equation (3.58) represents a resonance at
-
A
+ A ' = A + A' + Sp!
=0
having a width that corresponds to the convolution of a Gaussian of width ( I k' + t k I u ) with a Lorentzian of width ( 7 1 3 + rph3).The " resonance condition for each velocity subgroup of atoms that leads to this TQ resonance [corresponding to condition (3.29)in the no-collision case] is
-
A' + A = - ( k '
+ (k)r,
f13
(3.67)
Since L',takes on a wide range of values, Eq. (3.67)can be satisfied by a large range of A', and the resonance is broad, except for the "Doppler-free" case I k' + t k I zi 4 F 1 3 . In any event, studies of the line shape (3.58)as a function of pressure can lead to values for and Sp); . Another interesting feature of the line shape for A' z -A, I A I b ku, is its sensitivity to the collision model. As seen from chain 2 in Table I and Eqs. (3.13f) and (3.67),the line shape in this region is a measure of the effect of collisions on jI3 since it is the TQ contribution that is being probed. If collisions are phase shifting in their effect on j , there is a line broadening and shift given in Eq. (3.58). However, if the collision interaction in levels 1 and 3 were the same, collisions would be velocity changing in nature in their effect on 6 1 3 , Eq. (3.58) is no longer valid, and one should observe a ITUYYOWirrg of the line with increasing pressure (Dicke, 1353; Galatry, 1961; Rautian and Sobelman, 1967).Consequently, the line shape in this region can help to indicate whether collisions are '' phase changing" or "velocity changing" in By the"width" of a Lorentzian. we shall mean its half-width at half-maximum (HWHM). and by the width of a Gaussian. we shall mean its HWHM,'(ln 2)' '.
82
P . R . Berman
their effect on p 1 3 , i.e., whether the collision interaction is the same or different for levels 1 and 3. b. A' % 0. Equation (3.59) with N = 0 corresponds to a broad resonance at A' % O with contributions from both the SW and TQ chains. Velocity-changing collisions in level 2 play no role here since the detuning I d I is so large that the population of level 2, which depends on the absorption of field El through the factor F = f1,/[(fld2
+ (A + ckuz)21
-
fl,/(~)z
(3.68)
is approximately independent of u, . On the other hand, one sees from (3.68) that the contribution of the SW chain will increase with increasing pressure owing to the presence of f,, , and this feature is reflected in the line shape (3.59). Consequently, pressure studies of the amplitude of (3.59) can lead to a value for F:!. Moreover, pressure studies of the width (convolution of a Gaussian of width k'u with a Lorentzian of width f 2 3 ) and shift of the resonance can provide values for re! and S $ . It might be noted that linear spectroscopy on the 1-2 and 2-3 transitions can provide independent measures of r:!, Sp!, re!, and Se!.
2. Near-Resonant Tuning, I A I c ku; Copropagating Waves (t = 1) Apart from Sf! all the phase-shifting parameters can be determined from the large detuning case. In order to obtain values for the rate of velocitychanging collisions r2,and the collision strength parameter a, the field El must be tuned inside the Doppler width of the 1-2 transition. As mentioned in Section III,D, only the SW chain serves to probe the velocity-changing collisions. The SW chain can be isolated in the Doppler limit (3.64) if copropagating waves are used, since the velocity integration leads to a cancellation of the TQ contributions. For c = 1, Eq. (3.65) is
(3.69)
This equation for the SW contribution has a very simple physical interpretation. The first term corresponds to those atoms that have not under-
STUDY OF COLLISIONS BY LASER SPECTROSCOPY
83
gone velocity-changing collisions. For these atoms, the field El excites a velocity ensemble
ku,
=
-A f f l z
(3.70)
and the field E2 will be resonant with this ensemble if
A' = - k'v,
(3.71) f [(k'/k)f12 + f23] In other words, the resonance occurs at A, = A' - ( k ' / k ) A = 0 with a halfwidth at half-maximum (HWHM) of (k'/k)f,, + f z 3 = r,,, which is precisely what one finds in the first term of Eq. (3.69). The nth term in the summation in Eq. (3.69) corresponds to an atom having made n velocity-changing collisions in level 2 before being excited to level 3. Equation (3.70) still describes the excitation by the first field, while Eq. (3.71) is replaced by fz3
= (k'/k)A
6' = -k[f,(u,; A/k
& flz/k) &
f23
(3.72)
where fn(u,; up) represents the distribution of velocities u, after n collisions for atoms initially having velocity up . For the Keilson-Storer kernel, f,(v,; u:) is approximately a Gaussian of width (Au,) [Eq. (3.55)] centered at u, = anup, so that (3.72) represents a resonance centered at A' = d'(k'/k)A with a width that is the convolution of a Gaussian of width k(Au,) with a Lorentzian of width a"(k'/k)flz + f z 3 . This contribution to the line shape may be found in the plasma dispersion function in Eq. (3.69) with a weighting factor (r2*/r\)" giving the probability for n collisions during the lifetime of level 2. The actual line shape (3.69) will depend on the ratio of the parameters appearing in that equation. In particular, the quantity
0) = r 2 2 / 7 2
(3.73)
gives the effective number of velocity-changing collisions occurring in the lifetime of level 2 and consequently determines the number of terms entering the summation in Eq. (3.69). Another important ratio is k(Au,,,)/T,; if this ratio is greater than unity, velocity-changing collisions give rise to a distinct contribution to the line shape, owing to the fact that the velocity changes are large enough to significantly alter the velocity distribution of atoms excited by the field El. If this ratio is less than unity, velocity-changing collision effects are hidden in the homogeneous line width. Line shapes resulting from various valves of ( n ) and k(Au(,,))/r, are discussed below. Recall from Eqs. (3.52) and (3.55) that
(Au,) = (1
- aZn)l'Zu,
(Au) = (Aul) = ( 1 - a2)1'2u
and that the Doppler limit (3.64) is assumed.
84
P . R. Berman
a. ( n ) arbitrary, k(Au(,,))6 y12, ~ 2 3 . In this case, velocity-changing collisions are very weak (a z 1) and have a negligible effect on the line shape. The limiting form of Eq. (3.69)is (3.74) with all velocity-changing collision effects absent. b. ( n ) < 1, k’(Au) > r,,. In this case, only one term in the summation in Eq. (3.69) must be considered. The value of a is sufficiently different from unity to clearly distinguish the effects of velocity-changing collisions,and the limiting form of (3.69) is
The line shape consists of a contribution from atoms that have not undergone velocity-changing collisions, plus a “ shoulder ” arising from atoms that have been partially thermalized as a result of one average collision. Since ( n ) < 1 and r,,< k’(Au), the relative amplitude of the shoulder is small, and a careful line shape analysis will be necessary to verify its existence. c. ( n ) T J k u %. 1, a(”) z 0. In this limit, there have been a sufficient number of collisions to thermalize the sample in level 2 before absorption of field E, . In the sum in (3.69),(Au,,) x u for most n, and (3.69) reduces to
x {r,,(n)d/2(kU)-
exp[ - ( & / k ’ ~ ) ~ ] }
(3.76)
The line shape consists of a broad Gaussian background arising from atoms that have become thermalized in level 2 as a result of collisions. To satisfy the condition ( n ) = r22/y2 % 1 and the Doppler limit
r,,= [r23+ (k’/k)f,,]
6 ku,
one must generally find a system where the decay rate y z is considerably less than y1 or y 3 . d. k(Au) 2 y,,, 7 2 3 ; k(Au(,,))< I-,,. As will be discussed below, it may be possible to satisfy these conditions over a fairly wide range of (n). In the limit that k(Au(,,)) < r,,,velocity-changing collisions are not strong enough to remove atoms from the holes burned in the atomic velocity distribution by the pump field. The line shape will be a Lorentzian, slightly modified by the presence of velocity-changing collisions.
STUDY OF COLLISIONS BY LASER SPECTROSCOPY
85
To determine the range of (n) for which the conditions k(Au) > 712
3
723
(3.77a)
(3.77b) k(Au(n>) < ra and the Doppler limit (3.64) can both be maintained, one must first examine the implications of Eqs. (3.77) on the strength parameter a of the KeilsonStorer kernel. It follows directly from Eqs. (3.55) and (3.64) that condition (3.77b) can be met only if (1 - a2(n))1/2 < Ta/ku 4 1
(3.78)
Thus, condition (3.77b) is achieved only for "weak " collisions a
x I,
x 1
(3.79)
Equations (3.55) and (3.79), in turn, can be used to obtain the relationship (Au,,)/(Au) = [(I - a2")/(l - a2)]1/2x n'/'
(3.80)
The allowed range of (n) follows most easily if one uses Eqs. (3.66a), (3.60), (3.34), and (3.73) to write r, in the form
r, = r(i+ ~ ( n ) )
(3.81)
where (3.82) and T are pressure independent. A lower limit on (n) is determined from Eqs. (3.77b), (3.81), and (3.80) to be
(n) > {[k(A~)Tl(n>int- 1)W-l
(3.83)
+
is the integer part of (1 (n)). An upper limit on (n) is where obtained from the Doppler limit (3.64) and Eq. (3.81) as (n) c ku/TW
(3.84)
For typical values such as W x 5, ku/T z 50, k ( A u ) r x 2, Eqs. (3.83) and (3.84) may be satisfied in the range 0.4 c (n) c 10. Thus at very low pressures ((n) 4 l), k(Au) > r,, so that it is impossible to satisfy Eqs. (3.77). However, in a wide intermediate pressure range, the limiting conditions (3.77) can be satisfied. At still higher pressures ((n> % l), the Doppler limit no longer holds. The line shape is determined from Eq. (3.69). The imaginary part of the plasma dispersion function appearing in Eq. (3.69) will consist of the convolution of Gaussian and Lorentzian terms [see Eq. (3.26)]. If the Lorentzian component is expanded in a series about u, = 0 based on the fact that the
P . R. Berman
86
Gaussian function of width k(Au,) will be sharply peaked compared with the Lorentzian function of width r, ,and if Eqs. (3.79), and (3.77b) are used, one can find the asymptotic form of (3.69) to be P33
-
-
[
4n1I2N exp - ( ; ) 2 ] Y2 kur-0
~
r 2
(3.85)
with m
x2 = ( Y 2 / G )
c (r22/~:)"[k'(A~")12
(3.86)
n= 1
Using Eq. (3.80), one may carry out the summation in Eq. (3.85) and obtain x2 = (~2/r:)[~(~~)12(r22/r~)/[1 - (r22/r;)~2 = [k'(A~)]'(
(3.87)
where the second line follows from Eqs. (3.54) and (3.73). The bracketed term in the denominator of (3.85) is small compared with r: + A:, so that the line shape remains nearly Lorentzian in nature. The HWHM of the line r; is found to be
r; = ra+ +x2/r, =
(n> r(1+ B(n>)+ 32 [k(Au)I2 f 1+W(n) -~
(3.88)
Since W ( n ) 2 1 over the range of allowed (n), the net effect of velocitychanging collisions is to add a nearly constant contribution to r,. For example, if W = 8.0 and k(Au)/r, = 2.0, one must have (n) 2 0.2 to satisfy Eq. (3.83). In the range 0.2 < 01)< 1.5, a graph of ravs (n) appears to be linear with the correct slope of 8.0 but with an intercept l . 5 r rather than The possibility of such extrapolation anomalies have been discussed by other authors from somewhat different viewpoints (Alexseev et al., 1973; Kolchenko et al., 1973). Such anomalies have been found experimentally (Bagaev et al., 1972; Meyer et al., 1975; Cahuzac et al., 1976; Mattick et al., 1976), although it is not yet clear that their origin lies in the above process. In summary, studies of near resonant tuning for L = 1 allow for a determination of TZz,a, and Sfi through the use of Eq. (3.69) together with the values of the parameters determined from the large detuning case. The effects of velocity-changing collisions are most discernible in cases where k(Au) > r,. Typical line shapes [Eq. (3.69)] are shown in Figs. 3 and 4 for k' = k, A/ku = 0.5, and collision parameters T , / k u = 0.1, Sqh,/ku = -
r.
STUDY OF COLLISIONS BY LASER SPECTROSCOPY I
I
87
I
A =0.5ku
~0.0 = i a
0
'
A'/ku
FIG.3. The line shape [Eq. (3.69)] p 3 3 (in arbitrary units) vs probe detuning A/ku for k' = k and a pump detuning A/ku = 0.5. The collision parameters are TJku = 0.1, Sqh,/ku = -SPl/ku = 0.02, rz2/yZ = (n) = 1, a = 0.8 (Au = 0.614)corresponding to moderately strong collisions at pressures on the order of several torr.
I
'
A'/ku
FIG.4. The line shape [Eq. (3.69)] p a l under the same conditions as in Fig. 3, except (n) = 5.
P . R . Brrman
88
SP;/ku = 0.02, a = 0.8, and ( n ) = 1 (Fig. 3), or (n) = 5 (Fig. 4). (The different values of ( n ) might reflect different values of ll2.) The collision parameters correspond to moderately strong collisions [(Au) = 0.6~1 at pressures typically on the order of several torr. Each line shape consists of a collision-broadened and shifted Lorentzian component arising from atoms that have not undergone velocity-changing collisions, plus a redistribution component arising from atoms that have become partially thermalized as a result of collisions in level 2. The relative amplitude of the redistribution term to the Lorentzian term increases with ( n ) , as can easily be seen in Figs. 3 and 4.
3. Near-Resonant Tuning: Counterpropagating Waves (6
=
- 1)
Since all the collision parameters can be determined by cases ( 1 ) and (2) above, this situation can provide a consistency check for the values of the variables. The line shape will be more complicated than the copropagating case since chains 2 and 3 of Table I now enter into the calculation. The line shape is given by Eq. (3.65)and can be asymmetric since collisional shifts give rise to somewhat different positions for the resonances. There is also the possibility that the TQ contribution is much narrower than the nocollision part of the SW contribution [e.g.. if r,, 4 r,]. giving rise to a narrow peak superimposed on the Lorentzian contrihution from the SW chain. In Table 11. a summary of the method for obtaining the collision parameters is presented.
TABLE II COLLISION
PARAMETERS DETERMINED USING UPWARD CASCADE LINE SHAPES
Pump" detuning
Copropagating ( + ) or counterpropagating ( - )
IAI % kit
k
6, = 0
[ A 1 % krr
+
A'+A=O
1A1 < kii
+
1A1 < k r r
-
6' = (k' k)8 6' z z " ( k ' k)d 6' z - ( k ' k)h
Resonance posit ion
-
h' z -z
"
(k' k @
Parameters determined
ry:. r;; . s;: ry:. SP: sy:. r12. Consistency check on all parameters
89
STUDY O F COLLISIONS BY LASER SPECTROSCOPY
F. ALTERNATIVE LEVEL 'SCHEMES
I . Altrrrtative Three-Lmel Systems The results for the upward cascade can be translated into other three-level systems as follows: For the inverted V (Fig. 2b). tr+counterpropagating, copropagating, A'+ -(A' - SZp!), (A + A')+ (A - A' + ST!). For the V (Fig. 2c), t = 1 +counterpropagating, t = - I + copropagating, A + -(A - ST!), (A + A')+ -(A - A' - ST!).
t = -1
-,
-
For these level schemes, one is more likely to have the possibility of an equal collision interaction for levels I and 3. 2. Two-Luvrl Systems
If levels 1 and 3 actually coincide, the three-level system reduces to a two-level system. From a theoretical and experimental viewpoint, two-level systems can be more complicated than three-level ones. First, the assumption that field E, drives only the 1-2 transition and E2 only the 2-3 transition is no longer tenable since the 1-2 and 2-3 transitions are now identical. The presence of two fields driving the same transitions can lead to both spatial and temporal beats in the polarization. The basic equations will be of a somewhat different form than those discussed in Section 111.9 but can still be solved easily in perturbation theory. For strong fields, one must use numerical methods to solve the equations (Stenholm and Lamb, 1969; Feldman and Feld. 1970; Holt, 1970), in contrast to the threelevel problem, where analytic solutions were possible. Second, the collision interaction in levels 1 and 3 is now identical so that collisions are "velocity changing" rather than '' phase interrupting" in their effect on p t 3 = p , ,. Consequently, the line shape formula will contain contributions from velocity-changing collisions in both levels I and 2; it is no longer possible to isolate a single level in which to study velocity-changing collisions as was possible in the three-level case.' Since the two-level system is a degenerate inverse V, the case of counterpropagating waves and near-resonant tuning will have contributions only from SW terms. The line shape is analogous to Eq. (3.69).and for detunings
' If one of the states has a much slower natural decay rate than the other. velocity-changing collisions in the more rapidly.decaying state will have little effect on the line shape. In this limit. one can again study velocity-changing collisions in a single level.
90
P. R. Berman
A and A' of the pump and probe, respectively, one finds that the nonlinear probe absorption I, is given by
ifl2( 1 + u") + u"A + A'
zi(
~
k(Au,)
(3.89)
where it has been assumed that k' 5 k. Velocity-changingcollisions in both levels enter the line shape. For copropagating waves the situation is more complex since the TQ processes contribute. The line shape has been discussed by Kolchenko et al. (1973). The TQ processes give rise to narrow resonances of width (yl rl1) and ( y 2 r22) centered at R' = R; in addition, there is the SW contribution. It may be possible to analyze the line shape to obtain the individual rates for velocity-changingcollisions in levels 1 and 2, but due to the presence of both SW and TQ contributions the line shape analysis will be difficult.
+
+
IV. Transient Systems The theory discussed in Section 111 neglected all transient effects and was concerned only with experiments in which the external fields acted for times much greater than the relaxation times associated with the given systems. There is another class of experiments where the transient phenomenon itself is analyzed to obtain information on the relaxation processes in atomic and molecular systems. Clearly, such experiments must be carried out on time scales on the order of the relaxation times associated with the system. Transient experiments are complementary to steady-state ones for collisional studies. Transient and coherent transient methods have been used extensively in NMR work (Abragam, 1961) to obtain values for relaxation and diffusion constants in liquids. Only recently have coherent transient techniques been used in optical spectroscopy, where the short decay times require that the external fields be applied in times on the order of tens of nanoseconds. Techniques for producing transients in the optical domain have involved using short light pulses (Kurnit et al., 1964; Abella et al., 1966; Patel and Slusher, 1968; Bolger et al., 1976; Aartsma and Wiersma, 1976), dc stark fields to switch molecules into or out of resonance with continuously applied
STUDY OF COLLISIONS BY LASER SPECTROSCOPY
91
fields (Brewer and Shoemaker, 1971; Brewer and Shoemaker, 1972; Berman et al., 1975; Loy, 1976), or, most recently, electrooptic frequency switching of a cw laser beam (Brewer and Genack, 1976). In all of these experiments, one effectively applies a pulse or series of pulses to an atomic system and observes the transient response of the system. Transient experiments are well suited for independently determining population and polarization decay rates; in steady-state experiments these two effects were superimposed in the line shape. Moreover, experiments involving two or more pulses (such as photon echo experiments) enable one to determine in a unique manner whether collisions are velocity changing or phase changing in their effect on off-diagonal density matrix elements. Such clear tests were absent in the steady-state domain. On the negative side, transient experiments have usually involved large field strengths and the accompanying problems of power-dependent effects. In addition, the interpretation of collision rates may itself be a function of the excitation pulse structure, as will be discussed below. Several types of coherent transient experiments will be discussed. The theory of collisions in transient experiments has been developed by several authors (Scully et al., 1968; Schmidt et al., 1973; Doktorov and Burshtein, 1973; Heer, 1974; Berman et al., 1975; Stenholm, 1975): we shall point out some of the general conclusions reached by these authors. Only transients in two-level systems will be considered (Fig. 1); transient effects in threelevel systems have attracted recent interest (Shoemaker and Brewer, 1972; Brewer and Hahn, 1973; Loy, 1976; Leite er al., 1976) and may prove fruitful for future collision studies, but they will not be discussed here. In all cases, we shall consider only the eflects ro lowest (nonlinear) order in the applied fields. Strongfield effectswill introduce major complications into the analysis of collision phenomena.
A. FREEINDUCTION DECAY (FID)
In FID, the two-level system is subjected to the pulse shown in Fig. 5a. In the first stage, the applied cw field gives rise to steady-state values for density matrix elements P1l(v), P,,(v), P2,(v). Subsequently the field is abruptly terminated and one observes the transient decay of the system’s polarization. In the absence of collisions, the steady-state value of P,,(v, t = 0) may be obtained by solving Eqs. (3.13) with x‘ = 0. The well-known result (Torrey, 1949; Brewer and Shoemaker, 1972; Hopf et al., 1973) is
P . R. Berman
92
FIG.5. The applied electric field amplitudes E(t), which give rise to the transients discussed in Section IV: (a) gives rise to free induction decay, (b) gives rise to two-pulse nutation, and (c) gives rise to photon echo.
where
+ 2X2Y1z(Y;' + Y
3 (4.2) and the notation is the same as that used in Section 111. We have not yet made the weak-field assumption for reasons that will become obvious. Since the width of the velocity the preparatory field was on for a time ,:;y% distribution created by the field is the power-broadened homogeneous one (Y;2)2
vl2
= (Y12)2
lk*
When the field is removed, P,,(v, t) satisfies the free-atom equation
so that for t
> 0,
which, in the Doppler limit (3.32) reduces to6
The polarization is proportional to -1m(p12) and therefore exhibits a
-
The FID signal also has a rapidly decaying component (decay time l/ku) which is not indicated in Eq.(4.5). I should like to thank Professor M.Feld for a discussion on this point.
STUDY OF COLLISIONS BY LASER SPECTROSCOPY
93
+
simple exponential decay with rate (yI2 y i 2 ) . However, as is evident from Eqs. (4.2) and ( 4 4 , the polarization goes to zero in the weak-field limit. The outlook for collisional studies using FID is not good owing to the necessity for having strong fields to observe detectable signals. Collisional processes such as phase-interrupting effects on pl and velocity-changing effects on p12,pll, or p22 will all tend to increase the bandwidth of excited atoms and consequently lead to a more rapid FID. The time dependence of the different processes might be somewhat different, but it will be difficult to separate the various components in the decay signal. In addition, the switching techniques for FID (Brewer and Shoemaker, 1972) have involved changing the laser or atomic frequency rather than turning off the laser. The new laser frequency can be resonant with another velocity subset of atoms, which will also emit a transient optical nutation signal (Brewer and Shoemaker, 1971; Hopf et al., 1973).The total signal will then consist of both the FID and the optical nutation, which complicates the line shape even more.
ABSORPTION B. TWO-PULSE NUTATION-DELAYED SATURATED The principle of two-pulse or delayed nutation (Berman et al., 1975)and delayed saturated absorption (Hansch et al., 1971; Brochard and Cahuzac, 1976) is really the same. One subjects the sample to the two-pulse sequence shown in Fig. 5b. The first pulse creates changes in the populations of states 1 and 2. In the weak-field limit, these changes are proportional to x2 and manifest themselves as holes burned into the population velocity distributions. The width of the holes will depend on the ratio of ylz or Fl2 to the frequency bandwidth wL associated with the laser pulse (wLis the inverse of pulse duration time). The width will be given by the maximum of wL/kand y12/k;ifwL 4 y 1 2 , the preparation is effectively steady state. Thus, the velocity bandwidth uo excited by the first pulse is given by uo = max(f,,/k, wL/k)
(4.6) The changes in the populations will be denoted by [Ap,,(v, t)], [ApZ2(v, t)]. These population changes evolve in time and are probed by the second pulse, which has the same bandwidth as the first. Either the absorption or optical nutation signal of the second pulse can be monitored. In the case of delayed saturated absorption the pulses are generally chosen to be counterpropagating. If one measures the change in absorption (or amplitude of the optical nutation signal) of the second pulse produced by the presence of the first pulse, assuming both pulses are resonant with the same velocity subset of atoms, then in effect one is measuring the total number of atoms left in the
P . R. Berman
94
hole burned by the first pulse. The delayed absorption signal will be sensitive to all prooesses that have removed atoms from the velocity hole created by the first pulse. Such processes include decays of the atoms to any other levels resulting from spontaneous emission or inelastic collisions, in addition to those velocity-changing collisions that have resulted in velocity diffusion out of the hole. In this way, two-pulse nutation or delayed saturated absorption experiments are well suited for measuring all inelastic relaxation rates and velocity-changingcollision rates for the various populations. An alternative method for studying velocity-changing collisions with delayed saturated absorption is to vary the frequency of the second pulse and measure its absorption spectrum (Hansch et al., 1971). As velocitychanging collisions increase the velocity width of the holes, the absorption spectrum will correspondingly broaden, ultimately reaching the limit of absorption from a thermalized sample. To illustrate the above concepts, we consider the case 7, +Y,, w L + L wLw19rll (4.7) which might correspond to level 1 being the ground or a metastable state. The decay of level 2 is so fast that it may be neglected, and the absorption change signal arises from [APl ,I. The condition wL 9 yl, rl ensures that no relaxation of level 1 occurs during a time equal to the width zL of the pulse. will ensure that the hole width is determined by f,, The condition wL G f 1 2 rather than wL [See Eq. (4.6)]. The lowest-order change in fill is easily calculated in perturbation theory as
where zL is the pulse width. For the Keilson and Storer kernel, the value of [Afil ,(v, t ) ] will be (Keilson and Storer, 1952; Berman, 1974) [APl1(v, t ) ] = (. dv’G(v’+v, t)[APlI(v’, O)]
(4.9)
with G(v’+v, t) =exp[-(y,
+
+ r1,)t]{6(v - v‘)
(n!)-’[n(A~,)~]-~’~ n= 1
x
(rl
exp{- [(v - anv’)/(A~n)I2})
(4.10)
The change in P12 produced by the combined action of the two pulses is given by [see Eq. (3.13d) with x’-0, X+X‘, A+A’] [AfilZ(v, t)] = -WIAPll(v, t)3/[fl2
+ @‘ + ku,)]
(4.1 1)
95
STUDY OF COLLISIONS BY LASER SPECTROSCOPY
where A‘ is the detuning of the second pulse and we have taken k z k. The absorption change signal is proportional to the negative imaginary part of the velocity integral of [Afi,,(v, t)], and using Eqs. (4.9b(4.11)in addition to a simplifying but not necessary assumption that k(Au) B
f,,
one obtains the absorption-changesignal for two pulses separated by time T to be -1m
1dv[Afi,,(v,
T)] = 2 n 1 / 2 ~ 2 ~ exp[’ ~ L N( d / k ~ ) ~ ] ( k u r ~ ~ ) - ~
(4.12)
The signal consists of two parts, which are analogous to the two terms in Eq. (3.69) of the steady-state theory. The first term is the normal saturated absorption signal arising from atoms that have not undergone velocitychanging collisions, and the second is the summation term arising from atoms that have had their velocities changed in collisions. If rllt < 1, the summation term may be neglected and the probe absorption-change signal as a function of A’ will be a Lorentzian of HWHM 2 f 1 , centered at d‘ = cA. For higher pressures or delay times (r, T % l), the summation term dominates the line shape; the probe absorption-change signal will be approximated by a Gaussian of width ku centered at & = 0. Thus, by measuring the width, central frequency, and shape of the absorption-change signal spectrum for different values of rl,z (by varying either the pressure or delay time), one can arrive at some idea of the strength and rate of velocitychanging collisions in level 1. If one chooses not to measure the frequency spectrum of the absorption, but simply the absorption for resonant tuning d = dl = 0, the absorption change signal takes the form
,
-1m
1dv[AP,,(v,
t)] = 2n1~2~Z~’t,N(k~f12)-1H(~) (4.13)
with H ( t ) = exp[-(y,
[i
+ Tll)z] + nl/’f
n= 1
(&)v] k ( W
(4.14)
P. R. Berman
96
For
f12 /k(Au) < 1 as assumed, (4.15)
and one has a simple method for determining rll at various pressures. by Should inelastic collisions be present, one would determine (r, + rine’) /k(Au) is not totally negligible due to pressure or power this methpd. If f I 2 , should keep the second term in Eq. (4.14). In that broadening in f l Zone case, H ( z ) starts at a value of 0.5 at z = 0 and asymptotically approaches ( 7 ~ ~ / ~ f , ~ exp(-y,z) /ku) when rlltb 1. There are some restrictions on two-pulse nutation experiments. It is only possible to easily measure two-pulse nutation signals if all transients between the pulses have died away. These transients decay in a time =Z min[(f12)- l , (oL)‘1, which restricts the time 7 between pulses to (4.16)
On the other hand, to observe velocity-changing collisions in level i, one must have (4.17) (yi + rii)t 5 1 for reasonably large signals. Thus, if Fl2 > oL,then two-pulse nutation experiments are practical only if (yl rl1) < f 1 2 or (yz r22) 4 f 1 2 . This limiting case was discussed above and can provide useful information on velocity-changing collisions in the slowly decaying state. one must If both (yl + rll)and (y2 TZ2)are on the order of f12-, increase the intrapulse transient decay rate by choosing wL b r12. In that case, the width of the hole is given by (4.6) and, consequently, the rate at which velocity-changing collisions deplete the hole will be functions of wL.Under these conditions, two-pulse nutation experiments are best suited for providing a measure of the total hole depletion rate (inelastic plus velocitychanging collision contributions) for a given pulse excitation scheme. These results can be useful in the analysis of the photon echo experiments to be described below.
+
+
+
C. PHOTONECHOES
When a two-level system is subjected to the pulse scheme shown in Fig. Sc, it is possible to observe “photon echoes ” (Kurnit et al., 1964; Abella et al., 1966; Pate1 and Slusher, 1968; Brewer and Shoemaker, 1971) that are analogousto spin echoes ( H W , 1950) of NMR.The theory of photon echoes in gases (Scully et al., 1968; Gordon et al., 1969) and the effects of collisions on echoes (Schmidt et al., 1973; Doktorov and Burshtein, 1973; Heer, 1974; Berman et al., 1975) have been discussed by a number of authors. Basically, the theory of photon echoes without collisions is straightforward (Carr and Purcell, 1954). The first pulse creates some value for the
STUDY OF COLLISIONS BY LASER SPECTROSCOPY
97
off-diagonal density matrix element P12(v, t = 0). Between t = 0 and the application of the second pulse at t = r, the atom oscillates freely, with Plz given by PlZ(V.
t ) = expHy12 + i(A + k ~ , ) I t ) P l 2 ( V , 0)
(4.18)
There will be a dephasing of the dipoles due to a distribution of velocities. At t = T a pulse of area II = J x ( t ) dt (Carr and Purcell, 1954) is applied whose net effect is to change P12 into its complex conjugate P12(v, 7 ) = exp(-yl22) exp[i(A + k ~ , ) r ] P 1 2 (O)* ~,
(4.19)
For t > T the atom again oscillates freely, with Pl2 given by Pl,(V,
t > 2) = exp{-[?12
- i(A + kuz)17>
x expHy12 + i(A = exp(-y12t)
+ kuz)l(t - 7)>P12(V, O)*
exp[-iA(t - 27)]
x exp[ - iku,(t - 2r)]P12(v,0)*
(4.20)
One immediately sees that the effect of the second pulse has been to start the dipoles rephasing. At time t = 2r, the dipoles are all in phase again and the echo signal is emitted. The normalized echo amplitude R at t = 22 will be defined here as = Im
1 dvj12(v, t = 2r)/1m (. dvj12(v,o)*
(4.21)
For the no-collision case, (In light of the discussion of Section IV,B, one will have to use a pulse bandwidth wL < y12 in order to observe the echoes.) The use of photon echo experiments for collision studies should now be obvious. Any collisional process that interferes with the dephasingrephasing of the dipoles will diminish the echo amplitude so that studies of G vs the pulse delay r can yield collisional data. Moreover, it will be shown below that 6 can have a dependence on 7 that will determine whether collisions are velocity changing or phase changing in their effect on P12. 1. Phase-Interrupting Collisions
If collisions are phase interrupting in nature, the only effect on the echo amplitude is to replace y I 2 by fyh,and b(z)= exp(-2Qh,
7)
(4.23)
P. R. Berman
98
One finds a simple exponential decay of echo amplitude as a function of pulse separation. By varying the pressure, one can determine rl;; as a function of pressure. If one state dominates the collision interaction, the elastic scattering cross section for that level will be obtained. 2. Velocity-Changing Collisions
If collisions are velocity changing in their effect on P12 there will be two processes that can lead to a decrease of the echo amplitude. First, velocitychanging collisions can remove atoms from the velocity hole burned by the first pulse; such atoms are effectively lost from the system since they will not be resonant with the second pulse. Such collisions act as inelastic ones for the system, and together witk other inelastic processes give rise to a factor is the total inelastic collision exp(-2rQt) in the echo amplitude, where rQ rate. It will be assumed that TQ can be measured in a two-pulse nutation experiment. The second effect of velocity-changing collisions is to interfere with the dephasing-rephasing of the atomic dipoles that led to a perfect cancellation of the Doppler phase factor at time t = 2t. For a rigorous calculation of the echo amplitude, one must solve the transport equation dfiI2(v,t ) P t = -[y12 -
+ i(A + ku,)]P12(v,
t)
(rQ+ T)fi12(v9 t , (4.24)
for the time regions 0 < t < t,t < r < 2t. The quantities W(v'+v) and r a r e the kernel and rate, respectively, for velocity-changing collisions. Without going into a formal solution of Eq. (4.24), one can obtain a good feeling for the time dependence of &(r)by some simple arguments. The Doppler phase factor exp{- [iko,(t - 2r)I) in Eq. (4.20)vanishes at t = 22 in the absence of collisions. Roughly speaking, one should replace this factor at t = 27 by exp[-2ik(AuZ)r], where Ao, is the change in velocity in time 27. This factor will overestimate the effects of collisions since, in reality, the changes do not act over the entire time interval. However, the form of the time dependence will be the same as that in the more rigorous solutions. Thus, we take the echo amplitude to go as (4.25) with the average over collision histories and the assumption that ((Au,)~'" = 0 for integer n. The echo amplitude will have different forms for ( [ k ( A ~ ~ ) t ]4~1) and ([k(A~,)t]~)>> 1.
')
STUDY OF COLLISIONS BY LASER SPECTROSCOPY
a. ([k(Au,)zI2) &(2)
< 1.
-
99
In this limit, Eq. (4.25) becomes
eXp[-2(y1,
rQ)T][1 - 2k2((A~,)Z)~2]
(4.26)
The value of ((Au,)’) will be approximately equal to [the number of colli) one collision = ( A u ) ~ to / ~ within a sions in time 22 = 2 r ~ x] [ ( ( A U ~ ) ~for factor of two for the Keilson-Storer kernel (3.52)]. Therefore, ((Au,)~) 5 rr(Au)2
which, when used in Eq. (4.26) along with the fact that ([k(Au,)~]~) < 1, gives rise to a value for the echo amplitude &(z)
-
exp[-2(y12
+ TQ)?]e ~ p [ - 2 r k ~ ( A u ) ~ t ~ ]
(4.27)
As mentioned above, the effect of velocity-changing collisions was overestimated. More rigorous calculations (Doktorov and Burshtein, 1973; Heer, 1974; Berman et al., 1975) give &(2)
-
],
+
From Eq. (4.27) or (4.28), one notes that velocity-changing collisions give rise to a t3 dependence. The presence of this dependence in the echo amplitude decay will be an indicator of the presence of velocity-changing collisions. One must use pulse separations such that k(Au)z g 1, which is practical only for weak collisions Au < u. b. ([k(Au,)tI2) 9 1. In this limit, the cosine factor in Eq. (4.25) will average to zero for any atom that has undergone collisions. The contribution to the echo amplitude will occur from only those atoms that have not collided. Since the probability for no collisions in a time 22 is exp( -2rt), Eq. (4.25) yields the linear exponential decay &(z) exp[-2(y1, r&]exp(--2rt) (4.29) Thus, for k(Au)z 9 1, the form of the decay is the same as for phase-interrupting collisions. In summary, one can distinguish between phase-interrupting and velocitychanging effects on PI, only if the entire range of k(Au)zcan be monitored. If collisions are velocity changing in nature, there will be a t 3contribution in the echo decay for k(Au)r 1; if collisions are phase interrupting in nature, only a linear decay will be seen. As mentioned above, observation of the region k(Au)t 4 1 is practical only for weak collisions Au 4 u. For the weakcollision case, a solution of the transport equation for the entire range of k(Au)t has been carried out (Berman et al., 1975) with the result given by
-
+
-+
(4.30)
P . R . Berman
100
V. Experimental Survey -Theoretical Outlook A. EXPERIMENTAL SURVEY
The development of high-precision laser spectroscopy has been one of the most exciting research areas in atomic and molecular physics during the past ten years. Initial interest has centered on high-resolution spectroscopy,but there have been several experimental studies of collision effects. Some representative experiments are listed below. With the increased availability of commercial narrow-band tunable dye lasers and the increased awareness of the potential of laser spectroscopy for collision studies, one can reasonably expect that a new wave of laser spectroscopy experiments designed to explore collision processes will have already begun by the time this article appears, 1. Steady-State Experiments
Bischel et al. (1975, 1976a,b) have observed the upward cascade corresponding to Fig. 2a using counterpropagating waves to study vibrational transitions in CH3F and NH3 perturbed by various gases. They used a large detuning ]A I B ku and probed the region A’ z -A so that their results would correspond to Eq. (3.58). The molecular systems studied were not simple three-level systems, and inelastic collisions played a big role in determining the line shape, but the general conclusions reached in Section I11 should still apply. Their observations are very interesting and may be at variance with theory. The broadening of the line with increased pressure predicted by Eq. (3.58) is readily observed, although a large part of the broadening can come from inelastic collisions. Of gneater interest is the shift. A shift was observed for CH3Fperturbed by CH3F but not for CH3F perturbed by He or CFJ. The absence of shifts for foreign gas broadening of CH,F might indicate an equal collision interaction for levels 1 and 3 of Fig. 2a, which in turn implies that Eq. (3.58) is no longer valid. In that case, the line could narrow with increasing pressure. The fact that narrowing was not observed may be attributable to a large inelastic collision rate that masks the narrowing. The shift in the selfbroadening of CH3F has not been explained. For NH, perturbed by NH3, HZ, D,, He, and Xe no observable shift was detected, but for NH3 perturbed by Ne, a shift of 0.38 MHz/torr comparable to the broadening rfhj/2~ = 0.29 MHz/torr was found. This result is hard to explain as is the fact that, for NH3 perturbed by Ne, where the observed shift indicates a state-dependent collision interaction, evidence for collisional narrowing was found. A possible explanation is that the collision interaction for levels 1and
STUDY OF COLLISIONS BY LASER SPECTROSCOPY
101
3 is almost the same, giving rise to some collisional narrowing in first approximation; the small amount of broadening and shift is due to the slight difference between the interaction potentials. Biraben et al. (1975) examined the electronic 3 S 4 3 P 4 4 D transition in sodium for counterpropagatingwaves with I A I B ku, A z -A, k' = k. For neon perturbers, a broadening of rph,/2a = 16.0 MHz/torr and shift Sqh,/2a= 7.0 MHz/torr were found, with the line shape given by Eq. (3.58). Note that the broadening is much larger than that for the NH,-Ne interaction discussed above, indicating that the collision interaction for the levels in NH, may possibly be nearly equal. Rousseau et al. (1975) observed the forward Raman scattering of I, with I, perturbers for the case I A 1 B ku. The spectrum they obtained exhibited the resonances predicted in Eqs. (3.58) and (3.59). Carlsten and Szoke (1976a,b)examined the effect of Ar collisions on the resonance fluorescence of the 'P!-'S, strontium transition for I A 1 % ku. In effect, the line shape was again given by Eqs. (3.58) and (3.59) but was modified owing to strong-field effects. The impact approximation was not valid for some of the large detunings they used. The use of such detunings, while not applicable to the theory presented here, can be used to probe very strong collisions and to map out the interatomic potential at close particle separation. Beterov et al. (1973) probed the 2s,-2p4 transition in neon with a strong field applied to the coupled 2s2-2p, transition. Both copropagating and counterpropagatingbeams were used in the presence of neon perturbers and the pump field tuned to resonance A = 0. A line shape of the form (3.65)was observed and analyzed to yield various collision cross sections. The summation term in Eq. (3.65) could not be directly monitored since it was obscured by a large Gaussian background, presumably due to radiation trapping or resonant exchange (see discussion in Section V,B,l,b) on the 2s, level. For a better discrimination of the summation term, detunings A # 0 are advisable. Hansch and Toschek (1969) and Keil et al. (1973) also did saturation spectroscopy on neon but took a case where the 2p4 level was the coupled one. Radiation trapping and resonant exchange effects were no longer significant and the line shape for A = 0 with helium and neon perturbers was monitored. The results were consistent with Eq. (3.65)with a weak-collision model, ct x 1. Other groups have used saturated absorption on two-level transitions. In almost all these cases (as well as some of the above) strong enough fields were used to influence the line shape somewhat. Smith and Hansch (1971) observed a line shape in agreement with Eq. (3.89) for the 6328 transition in neon. The summation term in Eq. (3.89) was obscured by a large Gaussian background as in the experiment of Beterov et al. (1973). Brechignac
102
P . R. Berman
and Vetter (1976) observed a line shape in agreement with Eq. (3.89) for the 557 nm transition of krypton perturbed by xenon consistent with a model of weak collisions a x 0.9. There was a weak Gaussian background in their observed signal due to excitation transfer, strong collisions, or radiationtrapping effects. Brechignac and Vetter (1976) also performed a saturated absorption experiment in pure krypton, where they observed a much larger Gaussian background than for the Kr-Xe case. In pure krypton, one of the levels of the 557 nm transition is metastable (the addition of xenon serves to quench the metastable and to reduce its lifetime). Consequently, the large Gaussian background can arise from excitation transfer, radiation trapping, or collision effects. The strength of collisions is unimportant since a sufficient number of collisions occur within the lifetime of the metastable to thermalize the sample. 2. Transients
Hansch et al. (1971) measured the spectrum of delayed saturated absorption in sodium perturbed by argon. They observed the increase in width with increased delay time given in Eq. (4.12) and fit their data to a weak-collision model. Brochard and Cahuzac (1976) monitored the delayed saturated absorption at line center of barium perturbed by xenon or krypton. Their results were consistent with Eqs. (4.13) and (4.14) and they fit their data to a strong collision model. Both of these experiments depend on an effective collision rate and are not directly sensitive to the type of collision model chosen. Schmidt et al. (1973) and Berman et al. (1975) performed photon echo experiments on vibrational transitions in CH3F perturbed by CH3F. Their results were consistent with Eq. (4.30) with a value Au = 85 cm/sec (weak collisions), supporting the contention that collisions are velocity changing in nature for this vibrational transition. On the other hand, Brewer and Genack (1976) observed photon echoes on an electronic transition in I2 perturbed by 12, exhibiting a simple exponential decay as in Eq. (4.23) consistent with collisions being phase interrupting in their effect on the offdiagonal density matrix element associated with this electronic transition. These photon echo data are in accord with earlier statements that one might expect a state-dependent collision interaction for the levels involved in electronic transitions and a state-independent collision interaction for the levels involved in some vibrational transitions.
B. THEORETICAL OUTLOOK The prescribed path for future theoretical calculations is somewhat ill defined at the present moment. It is possible to envision a wide variety of
STUDY OF COLLISIONS BY LASER SPECTROSCOPY
103
calculations that either expand upon or modify the theory presented in Sections II-IV. However, as must be evident from the results for the simple collision models considered in Sections I11 and IV, it will be extremely difficult to uniquely interpret the line shapes arising from situations where complicated collision models or complicated atom-field interactions have been assumed. Nevertheless, we shall list some possible extensions of the theory below. In all cases the binary-collision approximation will be maintained; if three-body collisions are important, the overall theoretical approach followed in this work would have to be modified. 1 . Nondegenerate Levels-Elastic Collisions
The theoretical description of nondegenerate two- and three-level systems in which inelastic collisions play no role, given in Sections II-IV, can be modified in several ways. a. Improved or different collision models. Instead of using the phenomenological Keilson and Storer kernel to describe the elastic scattering for a given level (i.e., for velocity-changing collisions associated with diagonal density matrix elements), one can attempt to obtain kernels derived from some assumed interatomic interaction potentials. Kolchenko er al. (1972) and Borenstein and Lamb (1972)evaluated kernels for potentials containing a repulsive core with an attractive interaction at larger separations. The net result of these calculations is that one can approximate the collision kernel by a sum of two kernels of the Keilson-Storer type. The first accounts for the repulsive core and, for active atom-perturber mass ratios 5 1, can contain large-angle scattering effects associated with " strong " collisions (a significantly different from unity in Keilson-Storer kernel). The second kernel accounts for the somewhat weaker collisions (a x 1) associated with the long-range attractive potential. The trouble with these approaches is that they introduce yet two additional collision parameters. Moreover, the definition of a " weak " collision is somewhat arbitrary, since it will be the ratio of k(Au) to the various decay rates in the problem that will determine whether velocity-changingcollisions will manifest themselves in the line shape. Perhaps at this stage it is best to try to fit the line shapes with a single Keilson-Storer kernel and to examine the consistency of the model for various ratios of active-atom to perturber mass. The choice of a collision kernel to associate with the off-diagonal density matrix element p I 2 in the general case of arbitrary collision interactions for levels 1 and 2 is by no means obvious. Little or no progress has been made in the evaluation of Eq. (2.2) and in its subsequent usage in the transport equation. First, one must choose or calculate the interatomic potential; second, one must evaluate the scattering amplitudes for the chosen poten-
104
P . R. Berman
tial; third, one must carry out the integrations in Eq. (2.2); and finally, one must solve the transport equation for p12with the kernel WI2(v’-*v) that was obtained. Since each step in this chain is far from trivial, it seems advisable to continue to attempt to fit data with the assumption that collisions are either phase interrupting or velocity changing (but not both) in their effects on p12,at least to first approximation. b. Resonant exchange effects; radiation trapping. If the perturber atoms are the same as the active atoms, new effects are possible. For example, if level 1 of Fig. 2a is the ground state, it is possible to transfer population p22 or “coherence” p12from the “active atom” to the perturber during a collision by resonant excitation exchange. In addition, the same transfers can be effected by the emission and absorption of real photons (radiation trapping) between levels 2 and 1 The transfer of population in these cases is easily analyzed. Since the perturber atoms that receive the excited-state population have a velocity uncorrelated with that of the active atom (which had been excited by a velocity-selective laser field), the effect of a transfer of population involves an effective thermalization of the velocity distribution and has the appearance of “strong” collisions. The transfer of coherence is more complicated owing to the quantum-mechanical nature of the scattering process. Although detailed calculations have not been performed, it seems reasonable to conclude that, for strongly statedependent collision interactions, Pl2 can be transferred in only very weak collisions, where quantum-mechanical interference effects do not lead to the phase destruction of plz in the atom receiving the excitation. Resonant effects are best studied by the level scheme of Fig. 2a. By probing the 2-3 transition, the radiation trapping and resonant exchange on the 1-2 transition can be monitored. The line shape with resonant perturbers will be more difficult to analyze than that with foreign gas perturbers owing to the additional resonant processes present. c. Strong-feld effects. In many experiments, the pump field is too strong to justify a perturbation theory approach. The presence of strong fields greatly complicates the calculation of the effects of velocity-changingcollisions. The field burns a hole in the velocity distribution, collisions tend to replenish the hole, the field tends to reestablish the hole, etc. Only for simple collision models are analytic solutions possible. The major effect of a strong field on offdiagonal density matrix elements is to provide a power-dependent broadening. Thus, strong-field effects serve to mask collisional contributions to the line shape. d. Breakdown of the impact approximation. For very large detunings IA IrC 2 1 (7, is the duration time of a collision),the impact approximation is no longer valid. Such detunings are particularly useful for studying the
STUDY OF COLLISIONS BY LASER SPECTROSCOPY
105
interatomic potential at close interatomic separation (Hedges et al., 1972; Carlsten et al., 1976). They are not useful for probing velocity-changing collisions since the phase change k(Au)t resulting from velocity-changing collisions is negligible over the effective time scale t = A - I of the radiation process. In the region where the impact approximation is no longer valid, the collision width can depend on the detuning (Zaidi, 1975;Srivastava and Zaidi, 1975). 2. Degenerate Levels-Inelastic
Collisions
The two- and three-level systems discussed in Sections 11-IV are highly idealized. In general, levels 1, 2, and 3 (Fig. 2) each contain a number of degenerate sublevels. Collisions will affect both diagonal and offdiagonal sublevel density matrix elements (collisional relaxation of magnetic substates). There may be additional levels not shown in Fig. 2, to which level 1, 2, or 3 is coupled by inelastic collisions. Finally, the energy separation of levels 1and 3 in Figs. 2b and 2c may be small enough to permit a coupling of the levels by inelastic collisions. Thus, inelastic collisions can couple levels totally within the "system" or can couple a level within the system to an external level. Collisions taking atoms into the system from external levels are included in the pumping terms h,(v). a. Coupling to an external level. The effect of such inelastic collisions on populations is simply to increase their decay rate. The effect of these collisions on off-diagonal density matrix elements is to leave Eqs. (2.2) and (2.3) unchanged. However, the forward elastic scattering amplitudes appearing in Eq. (2.3) implicitly contain the effects of inelastic collisions. By use of the optical theorem in Eq. (2.3), one can show that the effect of inelastic collisions is to add a term
+.y'
(. dvpWp(vp)u~oj"(v,) + ajyv,)]
to Re[rij(v)] (Baranger, 1958b). The quantity ojn(vr)is the inelastic scattering cross section for state i, so that inelastic collisions add an incoherent contribution to the collision width. As can be seen from Eq. (2.3) there will be a corresponding change in Im[rij(v)] owing to the variation in Re[f;:(v,-v,)] or Re[f/(v,--,v,)*] resulting from inelastic collisions. The change in 1m[rij(v)] implies that inelastic collisions can give rise to a shift in the absorption maximum of the i-j transition. b. Coupling within the system. The effect of collisions on populations is not difficult to understand. Collisions can transfer populations from one
106
P. R. Berman
level to another, with an associated change in velocity. Using the laser spectroscopic techniques outlined in Section 111, one can study such inelastic processes as magnetic reorientation, fine structure changing, and rotational reorientation collisions. In an ideal experimental setup, one excites a given level with a given velocity, allows collisions to transfer this population to a second level with an associated redistribution of velocities, and probes a transition containing this new level. An experiment of this type was recently carried out by Apt and Pritchard (1976)to measure the velocity dependence of fine-structurechanging collisions in sodium produced by argon and xenon perturbers. The effect of collisions on off-diagonaldensity matrix elements is again difficult to assess. The specific selection rules and allowed changes in velocity for collisional transfer of “coherence ” (off-diagonal density matrix elements) are not yet well established.
VI. Conclusions The use of laser spectroscopy to probe collision effects in atomic and molecular systems is a relatively new field. The experimental and theoretical work that has been undertaken represents the first step in this field. There is a need for mutual guidance between the experimentalist and theorist. As more experimental data become available, the path that future theoretical calculations should follow will become more apparent. In turn, the theorists can recommend experiments explicitly designed to test existing theories. Systematic theoretical and experimental investigations will be required to untangle the line shapes and uniquely determine the collision parameters. From a theoretical point of view, the experimental conditions that are easiest to analyze would incorporate the following components: (1) active atoms approximating the idealized two- or three-level system (atoms with no hyperfine structureand large he-structure splittings are best), (2) foreign gas perturbers, (3) weak external fields, (4) transition frequencies allowing the use of a wide range of detunings with available lasers. The active-atom density should be low enough (510” atoms/cm3)to allow for the neglect of radiation trapping and resonant excitation exchange effects, while the perturber density should be low enough ( 5 300 torr) to ensure that the binary collision approximation is valid. It is probably true that bulb-type experiments will never replace beam experiments for the precise determination of differential scattering cross sections. However, laser spectroscopy holds great promise as a tool for obtaining the macroscopic collision parameters associated with atomic and molecular systems.
STUDY OF COUISIONS BY LASER SPECTROSCOPY
107
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Part of this chapter was prepared while I was a guest at the Laboratoire Aime Cotton, Orsay, France. The hospitality shown to me during my stay is gratefully acknowledged, as are the stimulating discussions with Drs. C. Brechignac, P. Cahuzac, 0.Robaux, and R. Vetter. I should also like to thank Professor Peter Toschek of the University of Heidelberg for our many conversations concerning the physics of two- and three-level systems, and Professor H. Brown of New York University for his comments concerning the state of the art in beam experiments. The author's research has been supported by the United States Army Research Office.
Appendix A. DEFINITION OF Zl, Z2, 1,
IN
EQS.(3.21)
In order to arrive at Eqs. (3.21), which result from the velocity integration of Eq. (3.17), the following integrals must be evaluated: 1l(Pl, P2
9
6 2 / d
The quantities cl, c2, c3 = f1 and the expressions must be written such that Im pi > 0. The integrands may be expanded by partial fractions and the resulting expressions yield plasma dispersion functions (3.26)on integration. In this way, one obtains Il(Pl9 P29 12(P19 P2 P3 9
9 €9
4 = -M(P19 P29 4[Z(Pl) - 4 / 4 2 I 1 4 = WP1. P2 6)[11(Pl9 P3 6') 9
9
- 611(P2 P3 9
13(P19 P2
9
(A.4)
9
(44.5)
6/41
€1= -M(fll, P2 r)iczl(Pl, P2 €1 + 2[1 + PlZ(P1)l) 9
1
(A4
P . R. Bermun
108
where W P l * 112
3
= l/(112
- CPl)
and the differential equation dZ(P)/d11 = -2[1
+ PZ(11)l
has been used in arriving at Eq. (A.6). In the extreme Doppler limit. lm(pi) 4 1, Re(pi) 5 1, one may use Eq. (3.27) and the fact that M(pl, p 2 , () is sharply peaked at Re(pl)= c Im(p2) to obtain the asymptotic forms fl(pl,1 1 2 , c) I~CCLI. 112,
113.
c,
d)
-
-
- 2 i 7 P M ( p 1 , p 2 . - 1) x exP{-[Re(C11)l2} a,.
-I
(A4
-2ia1/2M(pl, p 2 , c) x exP{-[Re(111)l2} x
- cM(112 13(Plr 112 + c)
’c
- 1) 4,. -I
[M(113 1 1 1 1 9 1
113
’I
- 1) &,d, - 11
-2in1’2[M(p19 p z
t
(A.9)
- I)]’
x eXP{-[Re(111)l2} a,.
-1
(A. 10)
which may be then used in deriving Eqs. (3.33) and (3.65). The asymptotic form for large detunings I Re[pl and/or p2 and/or p3] I % 1 are most easily derived directly from Eqs. (A. 1F(A.3).
B. DERIVATION OF Em. (3.57b) AND (3.65) We should like to indicate the derivation of Eq. (3.57b) and the first two terms of Eq. (3.65). By using the propagators (3.51) and (3.53) and Eqs. (3.40) and (3.56) in Eq. (3.49a). one can obtain
I 1
x S(v - v’)
+
c* (fl)[R’/’(AU,)]~ r22
n= 1
v - anv’ exPI-(w)
+ conjugate
I
1
’
(A.11)
STUDY OF COLLISIONS BY LASER SPECTROSCOPY
109
The contribution from the 6(v - v’) term is easily seen to consist of a sum of terms of the type (A.1) and leads to the first term in Eq. (3.57b). In the summation term, the substitution x = u, - a”u:,
u, = x
+ a”u:
leads to v’ integrals that again are of the type (A.1). The integrals over v’ lead to the I, functions appearing in the summation term of Eq. (3.57b) and integration over x explicitly remains in that equation. To go from Eq. (3.57b) to Eq. (3.65) in the Doppler limit (3.64), one need only use the asymptotic form (A.8) for I , . By using this asymptotic limit and the definition (3.26) one immediately arrives at the first two lines of Eq. (3.65).
Glossary of Symbols I. COLLISION SYMBOLS
’:
rC or (wJ duration time of a collision wj(v’+v); i # j: complex collision ”kernel” defined by Eq. (2.2) ri,(v); i # j: complex collision parameter defined by Eq. (2.3) W $ ( V ’ ~ V )real : collision kernel for scattering in state i defined by Eq. (2.2) r,;(v) = y i ( v + v ’ ) dv‘: rate of velocity-changing collisions in state i defined by Eqs. (2.3)and (2.4) yth(v): complex collision parameter characterizing phase-shifting collisions defined by Eq. (2.7) Gij(v’ +v): time-independent collision propagator defined by Eqs. (3.43) and (3.44) Gij(v’+ v, t): time-dependent collision propagator defined by Eqs. (4.9) and (4.10) Wz2(v’+v) = r22[~(Au)2]3’ze x d -[(v - 01v’)’/(Au)~]}: Keilson-Storer kernel 01: parameter with a value between 0 (“strong” collisions) and 1 (“weak” collisions). (Au) = ( I - a2)”’u: root two times the rms velocity change per collision (u is the most probable speed of the thermal distribution) (Au). = ( I - a2n)1’2u: related to the rms velocity change after ) I collisions
I
r; = 7z + rZ2
= Re yEh: phase-interrupting width parameter Sch -!J = Im 7$’: phase-interrupting shift parameter = .*.. + rp! IJ 1 IJ IJ d = A S$ & = A’ S$!
r..
+ + 7
-t A = A + A fi..‘ J = v I.1. + ..?h
A
+S 2
r,,.rh,I-<. r,, Am.A,, , Ac, A,,: line shape parameters defined by Eqs. (3.66) rQ:rate of inelastic collisions ( a ) = rz2/y2: average number of velocity-changing collisions occurring in level 2 within its 1J
lifetime
11. OTHER SYMBOLS A = R - (0:”pump” detuning A’ = R’ - w ’ : probe detuning x. x’: field strengths in frequency units
P. R. Berman
110 A = (xx’)’
N &/YZ - 11l ~ i N’ = 1 2 l Y 2 - & l Y 3
+ iA = Y 2 3 + iA 413 = Y 1 3 + i(A + A) A, &, Al: line shape parameters in the absence of collisions defined by Eqs. (3.34)-(3.37) 7L or (0J-I: pulse duration time in transient systems O(x): step function, = 1 for x < 0, =O for x > 0 Y(x):= 1 for x c 0, = - 1 for x > 0 W,(v):Maxwellian velocity distribution
412
=YlZ
423
r,
rllr(vz) = Y l
q,,(v,) =
‘I,, + ik,,v,; i # j ; k12 = ck, k,,
= k’, k , , = k‘
+ ck
REFERENCES Aartsma, T. J., and Wiersma, D. A. (1976).Int. Con& Quantum Electron., 9th Z Y l 6 , Paper p. 8. Abella, I. D., Kurnit, N. A.. and Hartmann, S. R. (1966).Phys. Rev. 141,391. Abragam, A. (1% 1 ). “The Principles of Nuclear Magnetism.” Oxford Univ. Press. London and New York. Alexseev, V. A., Andreeva, T. L., and Sobelman. I. I. (1972).Sou. Phys.-JETP 35,325. Alexseev, V. A., Andreeva, T. L., and Sobelman, I. 1. (1973).Sou. Phys.-JETP 37,413. Anderson, P.W.(1949).Phys. Rev. 76,647. Andreeva, T.L. (1968).Sou. Phys.-JETP 27,342. Apt, J., and Pritchard, D. E. (1976).Phys. Rev. Lett. 37,91. Bagaev. C. N., Baklanov, E. V.,and Chebotaev. V. P. (1972).JETP Lett. 16,9. Baranger, M.(1958s).Phys. Rev. 111,481. Baranger, M.(1958b).Phys. Rev. 112,855. Ben-Reuven, A., Jortner, J., Klein, L., and Mukamel, S. (1976).Phys. Rev. A 13, 1402. Berman,P. R. (1972a).Phys. Rev. A 5,927. Berman, P. R. (1972b).Phys. Rev. A 6,2157. Berman, P. R. (1974).Phys. Rev. A 9,2170. Berman, P. R. (1975).Appl. Phys. (W.Ger.) 6, 283. Berman, P. R. (1976)Phys. R w . A 13,2191. Berman, P. R.,and Lamb, W.E. (1969).Phys. Rev. 187,221. Berman, P. R., and Lamb, W.E. (1970).Phys. Rev. A 2, 2435. Berman, P.R., and Lamb, W.E. (1971).Phys. Rev. A 4, 319. Berman, P. R., Levy, J. M.,and Brewer, R. G. (1975).Phys. Rev. A 11, 1668. Beterov, I. M.,and Chebotaev, V. P.(1974).frog. Quantum Electron. 3, 1. Beterov, I. M.,Matyugin, Y. A., and Chebotaev, V. P.(1973).Sov. Phys.-JEW 37,756. Bielicz, E., Czuchaj, E., and Fiutak, J. (1972).Acta Phys. Pol. A 41,327. Biraben, F.,Cagnac, B., and Grynberg, G. (1975).J . Phys. (Paris) 36, L41. Bischel, W.K., Kelly, P.J., and Rhodes, C. K. (1975).Phys. Rev. Lett. 34,300. Bischel, W.K., Kelly, P.J., and Rhodes, C. K. (1976a).Phys. Rev. A 13, 1817. Bischel, W.K.. Kelly, P. J., and Rhodes. C. K. (1976b).Phys. Rev. A 13, 1829. Bjorkholm, J. E.,and Liao, P.F. (1976).Phys. Rev. A 14. 751. Bolger. B., Baede, L.. and Gibbs, H.M.(1976)Opt. Commun. 18,67. Borenstein, M.,and Lamb. W.E. (1972).Phys. Rev. A 5, 1311.
STUDY OF COLLISIONS BY LASER SPECTROSCOPY
111
Brechignac, C., and Vetter, R. (1976). Private communication. Breene, R. G. (1961). "The Shift and Shape of Spectral Lines." Pergamon, Oxford. Brewer, R. G., and Genack, A. Z. (1976). Phys. Rev. Lett. 36,959. Brewer, R. G., and Hahn, E. L. (1973). Phys. Rev. A 6,464. Brewer, R. G., and Hahn, E. L. (1975). Phys. Rev. A 11, 1641. Brewer, R. G., and Shoemaker, R. L. (1971). Phys. Rev. Lett. 27,631. Brewer, R. G., and Shoemaker, R. L. (1972). Phys. Rev. A 6,2001. Brochard, J., and Cahuzac, P. (1976). J. Phys. B. 9,2027. Cahuzac, P., Robaux, O., and Vetter, R. (1976). J. Phys. B 9,3165. Carlsten, J. L., and Szoke, A. (1976a). Phys. R m . Lett. 36, 667. Carlsten, J. L., and Szoke, A. (1976b). J. Phys. B 9, L 231. Carlsten, J. L., Szoke, A., and Raymer, M. G. (1976). Int. Con& Quantum Electron., 9th, 1976, Paper 0.10a. Carr, H. Y., and Purcell, E. M. (1954). Phys. Rev. 94,630. Cattani, M. (1970). Lett. Nuovo Cimento SOC.Itbl. Fis. 4, 346. Chappell, W. R., Cooper, J., Smith, E. W., and Dillon, T. (1971). J . Stat. Phys. 3.401. Chen, S. Y., and Takeo, M. (1957). Rev. Mod.Phys. 29.20. Dicke, R. H. (1953). Phys. Rev. 89,472. Doktorov, A. B., and Bunhtein, A. I. (1973). Sou. Phys.-JETP 36,411. Feld, M. S., and Javan, A. (1969). Phys. Rev. 177,540. Feldman, B. J., and Feld, M. S.(1970). Phys. Rev. A 1, 1375. Foley, H. M. (1946) Phys. Rev. 69, 616. Fried, B. D., and Conte, S. D. (1961) "The Plasma Dispersion Function (Hilbert Transform of the Gaussian)." Academic Press, New York. Galatry, L. (1961). Phys. Rev. 122, 1218. Gordon, J. P., Wan& C. H., Patel, C. K. N., Slusher, R. E., and Tomlinson, W. J. (1969). Phys. Rev. 179,294. Hahn, E. (1950). Phys. Rev. 80,580. Hansch, T. W., and Toschek, P. E. (1969). IEEE J . Quantum Electron. 5, 61. Hansch, T. W., and Toschek, P. E. (1970). Z. Phys. 236,213. Hansch, T. W., Shahin, I. S.,and Schawlow, A. L. (1971). Phys. Rev. Lett. 27, 707. Hedges, R. E. M., Drurnrnond, D. L., and Gallagher, A. (1972) Phys. Rev. A 6, 1519. Heer, C. V. (1974). Phys. Rev. A 10,2112. Hess. S.(1972). Physica (Utrecht) 61, 80. Holt. H. K. (1970). Phys. Rev. A 2, 233. Hopf, F. A.. Shea, R. F., and Scully. M. 0. (1973). Phys. Rev. A 7,2105. Jeffries,J. T. (1968). '' Spectral Line Formation." Ginn (Blaisdell), Boston, Massachusetts. Keil, R., Schabert. A., and Toschek. P. (1973). Z.Phys. 261, 71. Keilson, J.. and Storer. K. E. (1952). Q. Appl. Math. 10, 243. Kolchenko, A. P.. Rautian, S. G.. and Shalagin. A. M. (1972). Rep. N.ucl. Phys. Inst.. Inst. Semiconduct. Phys., USSR. Acad. Sci. (1 should like to thank the Laboratoire Aim6 Cotton for providing a French translation of this article.) Kolchenko. A. P., Pukhov, A. A.. Rautian, S. G., and Shalagin, A. M. (1973). Sou. Phys.JETP 36,619. Kurnit. N. A.. Abella. 1. D., and Hartmann. S.R. (1964). Phis. Reu. Lett. 13. 567. kite. J. R. R., Sheffield, R. L.. Ducloy. M.,Sharma. R. D.. and Feld. M. S. (1976). Phys. Ren. A 14. 1151. Lindholm. E. (1945). Ark. Mat. Astron. Fys. 32. 1. Loy, M. M. T. (1976). Phys. Rev. Lett. 36. 1454 Mattick, A. T., Kurnit, N. A.. and Javan, A. (1976). Chum. Phys. Lett. 38, 176. Meyer, T. W., Rhodes, C. K.. and Haus. H. A. (1975). Phys. Rev. A 12, 1993.
112
P . R. Berman
Patel, C. K. N., and Slusher, R. E. (1968). Phys. Rev. Lett. 20, 1087. Pestov. G., and Rautian, S. G. (1969). Sou. Phys.-JETP 29,488. Rautian, S . G., and Sobelman, I. 1. (1967). Sou. Phys.-Usp. 9, 701. Rautian, S.G., Smirnov, G. I., and Shalagin, A. M. (1972). Sou. Phys.-JETP 36, 619. Rousseau. D. L., Patterson, G. D., and Williams, P. F. (1975). Phys. Rev. Lett. 34. 1306. Salomaa, R., and Stenholm, S. (1975). J . Phys. B 8. 1795. Salomaa. R., and Stenholm, S. (1976). J . Phys. B 9, 1221. Schmidt, J., Berman, P. R.,and Brewer, R. G . (1973). Phys. Rev. Lett. 31, 1103. Scully, M., Stephen, M. J., and Burnham, D. C. (1968). Phys. Rev. 171,213. Shoemaker, R. L.,and Brewer, R. G. (1972). Phys. Rev. Lett. 28, 1430. Smith, E. W., Cooper, J., Chappell. W. R., and Dillon, T. (1971a). J . Quant. Spectrosc. Rudiat. Transfer 11, 1547. Smith, E. W., Cooper,J., Chappell, W. R., and Dillon, T. (1971b). J . Quant. Spectrosc. Rudiat Tranger 11, 1567. Smith, P. W., and Hansch, T.W. (1971). Phys. Rev. Lett. 26, 740. Srivastava, R. P., and Zaidi, H. R. (1975). Can. J. Phys. 53, 84. Stenholm, S. (1975). Internal Rep. Res. Inst. Theor. Phys. Univ. of Helsinki. Stenholm, S.,and Lamb, W. E. (1969). Phys. Rev. 181,618. Torrey. H. C. (1949). Phys. Rev. 76, 1059. Zaidi, H. R. (1972). Can. J. Phys. SO, 2792. Zaidi, H. R. (1975). Can. J. Phys. 53, 76.
COLLISION EXPERIMENTS WITH LASER EXCITED ATOMS IN CROSSED BEAMS I . V . HERTEL and W . STOLL* Fachbereich Physik der Llniversitat Kaiserslautern Kaiserslautern, West Germany
I. Introduction
................................................. .... ....
B. The Language of Multipole Moments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111. Excitation of Atoms by Laser Optical Pumping . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Theoretical Considerations . . . . . . . B. Experimental Aspects of Optical Pumping . . . . . . . . . .
IV. Theory of Measurements in Scattering E
A. The Percival-Seaton Hypothesis : Electron Spin and/or Nuclear Spin Uncoupling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Explicit Expressions for Scattering Multipole Moments in Terms of Scattering Amplitudes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V. Collision Experiments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. General Aspects . . . . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Inelastic Electron-Scattering Processes from C. Total Scattering Cross Sections for Low-Energy Electron Scattering from Sodium 3’P,,, Using Recoil Techniques . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D. Elastic Atom-Excited Atom Scattering at Therm E. Fine-Structure-Changing Transitions in Heavy-Par F. Electronic to Vibrational Energy Transfer . . . . . . VI. Atomic Scattering Processes in the Presence of Strong A. Free-Free Transitions and Similar Phenomena . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Coherent Superposition of Ground and Laser-Ex ..................... mately Resonant Atom Excitation . . . . .
................
References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
113 117 117 119 129 129 142 157 157 162 174 175 179 191 193 200 203 211 212 216 223 224
I. Introduction The past two decades have seen much progress in atomic collision physics, which is now included in standard textbooks of enormous size (e.g., Massey et al., 1969-1974). Both experimental techniques and theoretical methods
* Present address: Messer Griesheim GmbH, Diisseldorf, West Germany. 113
114
I . 1/: H u t e l and W Stoll
have been more and more refined and have been applied to a large variety of interacting systems. This has led to an improved understanding of the basic interaction mechanisms underlying atomic scattering processes and has yielded suitable methods of theoretically describing or even predicting them. However, one is still unable to give satisfyingdescriptions of even seemingly simple collision problems. Of course, the Schrodinger equation in the nonrelativistic limit is exactly valid for all atomic collision phenomena so far encountered. It renders, however, little physical insight into specific processes of interest, and what may be called an understanding of a particular process often depends on personal taste. For instance, the elastic scattering of ground-state atoms by other such atoms is adequately described in the range of thermal energies by a knowledge of the interatomic potentials as a function of the internuclear distance only, and even the inversion of the problem is possible, since the underlying differential equation is solvable to a high degree of accuracy (Buck, 1974). In contrast, problems that seem to belong to the simplest situations in atomic collision physics, such as electron scattering by atomic hydrogen and helium, are far from being solved, especially when inelastic processes and ionization are taken into account. They cannot be described in such simple ways as the previous case since the governing equations are an infinite set of coupled integrodifferential equations resisting any attempt to be solved exactly, although even there considerable progress has been achieved. Completely intractable at present, in a more than statistical manner, seems to be the situation where complex heavy-particle processes such as electronic to vibrational energy transfer or even reactive scattering are under consideration. Not only are the computational methods in question, but even the equations to be solved. Thus, the situation is still unsatisfactory, especially if one considers binary atomic collisions as elementary processes for any interaction within any kind of bulk matter. The progress that has been made in atomic collision physics has been due, on the one hand, to the large amount of processes studied, and on the other hand, to the rigorous investigation of more and more refined details of atomic cross sections. It is a long way from predicting a rate constant in which the various averaging procedures over different energies, scattering angles, etc., may statistically cancel computational errors, to (for instance) the understanding of a complex differential scattering amplitude for an inelastic process including, say, spin analysis (Bederson. 1969. 1970), which poses many more critical requirements on any theoretical approach. Steps toward this end have been, to mention just a few. the investigation of resonances in electron scattering (Schulz, 1973),methods of phase shift analysis (Andrick, 1973),experiments with polarized electrons (Kessler, 1976),or in heavy particle scattering the observation of rainbow and supernumerary
COLLISIONS WITH LASER EXCITED ATOMS
115
rainbow oscillations (Pauly and Toennies, 1965). Among the most fruitful methods have been experiments with crossed beams investigating differential cross sections. If one surveys the literature it becomes clear that the bulk of the experimental material is concerned with atomic species in the electronic ground state. Metastable atoms have occasionally been subject to investigations but no crossed-beam experiments with short-living atoms optically accessible from the ground state have been performed until recently. Obvious experimental difficulties have prevented the preparation of excited species in an atomic beam. Such atoms typically live for sec only and at thermal energies travel around cm during that time. However, with the advent of tunable narrow-band lasers, especially cw dye lasers, the situation has changed and it has become clear that it should be possible to excite atoms optically within the scattering region of an otherwise conventional crossed-beam experiment (Fig. 1). In this way a B beam
FIG.1. Schematic arrangement for the investigation of scattering processes from laserexcited atoms (A + h ~ , =~ A*) , in a crossed-beam experiment. After the collision A* B + A' + B'. either A' or B' may be detected.
+
steady-state upper-state population could be reached that may be comparable to the ground-state population. It, for the moment, we assume atom A to be simply a two-level system, then the ratio of the excited-state number density to the total number density would be given by
where A is the exciting wavelength and u,, the spectral radiation density.' At present we just note that with laser intensities of less than 1 W/cm2 and a bandwidth comparable to the natural linewidth ( z 10 MHz) one may obtain nearly equal population of ground and excited state. It is obvious that these possibilities make possible a large variety of novel studies in atomic collision physics that offer more than just an extension of the usual experiments with ground-state atoms and metastables. That is to
' The latter definition will have to be modified somewhat on closer inspection for highintensity fields.
116
I . I/: Hertel and W Stoll
say, one may make specific use of the inherent properties of the exciting laser light, namely its monochromaticity, well-defined polarization, and high intensity. When an atomic beam is excited, it is free of internal collisions and, for right angle intersection with the laser, free of Doppler broadening. Then the laser properties allow us very specifically to select the state into which the atom is excited. Specific fine- and hyperfine-structure states may be chosen as well as a particular combination of substates. Thus, one may now design experiments to study in detail differential cross sections for finestructure or even hyperfine-structure transitions, or for transitions among substates with different angular momentum projection quantum numbers (so-called phase-changing transitions). In this context it should be remembered that nearly all atoms easily accessible for collision experiments hitherto used have been in an s state or at least in a spherical isotropic mixture of substates. In contrast, the novel techniques allow us to prepare states with an angular momentum different from zero and to vary systematically the alignment and orientation of the resulting nonspherical interaction potentials. Thus, a much more sensitive test of any theory is given than in the usual experiments where one averages over unobserved projection substates. The new area of study is thus a logical step on the way to exploring more and more details of collisional interaction as indicated above. It is obvious that full use of these possibilities can only be made in crossed-beam experiments. Therefore, the present article will be restricted to this type of experiment exclusively. In spite of the attractive features of the new field, few scattering experiments have actually been performed, largely because of the fact that only a few atoms are accessible to this type of preparation, due to the availability of suitable lasers. At present one is essentially restricted to sodium, using the most convenient cw Rhodamine 6G laser to excite the Na(3’P) resonance state. However, rapid progress in laser technology may very soon change this situation. Nevertheless, the possibilities, difficulties, and limitations of the experimental methods are now understood, initial experimental results have emerged, and a theory of measurement has been developed and probed in a variety of interesting cases. Thus, it seems adequate to review the situation as it stands. The present work should therefore be viewed as a means of disseminating the experience hitherto gained, and we hope thereby to stimulate new experiments exploiting these techniques. Most of our knowledge stems from electron-scattering experiments that were first reported by Hertel and Stoll (1973) and followed more recently by Bhaskar rt al. (1976). Electron scattering by laser-excited Na(32P3,2)serves as a test case for understanding the method and its results. Only recently have differential heavy-particle scattering experiments been reported by Carter et al. (1975b). followed by
COLLISIONS WITH LASER EXCITED ATOMS
117
Diiren and collaborators (1976). The interpretation of the latter experiments is still under discussion, and the same is true for an investigation of the quenching of excited sodium by molecules, first reported by Hertel et al. (1976). Besides presenting the available experimental and theoretical material, it is the intent of the present review to clarify some open questions concerning the optical pumping process as well as the theory of measurement, as far as it is specifically related to scattering experiments involving laser-excited atoms. The language of multipole moments is used throughout the paper. We hope. however, to present the necessary mathematical apparatus, together with some perceptual aids that may give easier access into this field, especially to experimental physicists. On the other hand, we think it is worthwhile to give a comprehensive survey of the necessary formulas and to illustrate their use by suitable experiments, thereby omitting some minor errors that have occurred in previous publications. We start with some general remarks on the language of multipole moments and its application to scattering processes by laser-excited atoms, and then give a new interpretation for the meaning of scattering multipole moments. This is followed by a discussion of the optical pumping process for the target preparation, which is the crucial part of the experiment. We then investigate the applicability of rate equations, the time development of the state multipole moments during pumping, and possible excitation mechanisms and other relevant experimental aspects of optical pumping. We then discuss in detail the theory of measurement, and we shall concentrate not only on inelastic electron scattering but also on scattering experiments with spin analysis and on elastic and fine-structure-changingheavy-particle collision problems. Next we report on scattering experiments and illustrate the application of the new techniques to these and other problems. In the final section we make some remarks on scattering processes in strong laser fields. In particular, we discuss some recent experiments on free-free transitions and the effects that may be observed due to a coherent superposition of ground and excited states of the laser-excited atom. It does turn out that these, fortunately, may be neglected as far as the subject of the present review is concerned.
11. Basic Theory A. GENERAL ASPECTS Scattering processes by laser-excited atoms deserve a special theoretical treatment, although in principle the calculation of the relevant transition matrix elements (scattering amplitudes) is subject to standard atomic colli-
sion theory. In fact, the scattering amplitudes fnjm. 61,Jk, k) that describe a ~ a state collisional transition from a state with quantum number’ i i J to with njm are just the complex conjugate to those describing the inverse process from an originally laser-excited atom (the in- and outgoing collision wave vectors G and k are also inverted). However, the usual procedure of averaging over all initial probability p ( m ) and summing over all final states
is not done in such a simple way for scattering by laser-excited atoms. Such atoms are prepared in a well-defined combination of substates I.jm). One can usually find a coordinate frame in which the laser-excited atoms are easily described as an incohcrent superposition of states with different projection quantum number In, each having a probability w(m). That is to say, the excited-state density matrix is diagonal, o,(m. m‘) = d,,,w(m). in a coordinate frame that henceforth is named the photon frame (ph). Its zph axis is parallel to the electric vector E for linear polarization (n light) and parallel to the incident light direction for circular polarization (o light) (see Section 111). However, the collision process is usually described best in a different frame, the collision frame (col), for which the zCoIaxis may be parallel to the initial or final interparticle axis and the x,,, axis lies in the scattering plane. Thus the amplitudes given in the col frame have to be transformed into the photon frame, or the diagonal atomic density matrix has to be rotated into the collision frame. The scattering intensity will be determined by a coherent superposition of different I .jm) states and
Consequently, such experiments provide much more detailed information on scattering processes than do conventional scattering experiments, especially since one has the freedom to choose a variety of relative orientations of the ph frame with respect to the col frame. Equation (3) may be further evaluated in a conventional manner, as was done by Hertel and Stoll (1974a). However, the latter description does not bring out clearly all the possibilities provided by optical pumping. One uses with advantage the language of alignment and orientation parameters as introduced into atomic collision physics by Fano and Macek (1973), which has been applied to the problem under investigation by Macek and Hertel (1974). It presents a
* Here and in the following we shall identify laser-excited states with unbarred quantum numbers, while all other atomic states will be designated by barred symbols.
COLLISIONS WITH
LASER EXCITED ATOMS
119
transparent picture of the experimentally observed phenomena for a variety of accessible parameters. This description in terms of irreducible tensor operators or state multipole moments will be illustrated by experimental data in the following way: (1) Geometrical and dynamical factors are clearly disentangled. (2) The observables reflect the symmetry of the experimental setup, which facilitates the discussion of the possibilities of the experiment and emphasizes the special predictions of different theories. (3) The observables are measured by a suitable choice of experimental parameters and are easily computed from commonly used scattering amplitudes. The language of multipole moments is a standard subject of textbooks (see, e.g., Rose, 1967; Edmonds, 1964; Brink and Satchler, 1971) and is usually applied in optical pumping experiments (see the review by Happer, 1972). Nevertheless, atomic collision physicists seem to be reluctant to use it. Thus some explanatory remarks seem appropriate, since this language is the most convenient description for any type of experiment involving changes in the coordinate frames of target preparation, collisional system, and/or detection device. In particular, spin-polarized collision studies and experiments with polarized molecules might adequately be analyzed in terms of the theory discussed here for atoms prepared by laser optical pumping. All questions arising from coherent or incoherent superposition of scattering amplitudes to and from an electronic level can be elegantly treated in this language.
B. THELANGUAGE OF MULTIPOLE MOMENTS 1. Dejnition of Multipole Moments and Description of’ the Scattering Process
Following Macek and Hertel (1974), the scattering process of particles B (e.g., of an electron) by a laser-excited atom A* with quantum numbers njm leaving the atom in a state q%, A*
+ B + A’ + B’
is described in terms of the time inverse process, where the states fij are usually taken to have an isotropic population (other cases are discussed in Section IV). One may view such a process as the preparation of a particular combination of Injm) states, since the asymptotic wave function has the form (in the center of mass system): exp(ikr) @ ( B ’ ) . exp(ikr) * tpilfi + @(B)- 7 Ye,,,
(4)
I . r/: H i w d and W Stoll
120
with Ycol=
C f:;:
a1,ii $ n j m
(5)
m
where $ n j m , $81m stand for the atomic and @(B),@(B)for the other particles' wave functions before and after collision. respectively. In the actual scattering process, the atom is prepared by optical pumping in a state Ypumwhich is usually different from Ycol.Then the scattering intensity I is given by the projection of one state onto the other: I x ~(Ypu,,,~Yc,,l)~2. As an example, the scattering intensity would be ( I (.jmlYcol) I )' = ((Vco,1 jm)(jmI Ycol))if just one state I jm)were excited optically. The brackets ( ) indicate an average over all unobserved states iijtfi and also over unobserved quantum numbers of B and B. such as the electron spin. Obviously 1 jm)(jmI represents the statistical (density) operator of the atom excited in this special way. More generally, one has to sum over all projection quantum numbers according to their statistical weight. In a general form, the differential scattering cross section is given by I ( 9col) = 1 0 Tr w = 10
1
Pmm, am*m
m'm
(6)
where I . is the differential cross section for an isotropic initial iij state population given in Eq. (2). The density operators p and u are those for the atom excited by the time inverse collision from an isotropic fij state distribution [Eqs. (4) and (S)], and for the atom excited by optical pumping, respectively. Since we may choose a particular photon frame where om,, = S,,,,, w(m), Eq. (6) reduces to a single summation over m. The collisional density matrix is given in the collision frame by pmm,= Cq,, , with
where p(B) is the probability of finding a specific particle in state B in the initial collision system and p(B'), p(?), p(tii) are the detection probabilities for particular quantum numbers B', 7, and ti& respectively. Macek and Hertel have evaluated Eq. (6) by making use of the possibilities of expanding the density matrices into state muhipole moments P k q and (Tkq [see Fano, 1953, and Brink and Satchler, 1971, Eqs. (6.64) and 6.65)]: P j m . jm'
=
C
pkq(.i)(k
Ij
-~im')(-)~-'-'"
(81
kq
and inversely P k q W
=
C
mm'
Pjm.j m O
- mjm' I h)(-)k - j - m
(91
COLLISIONS WITH LASER EXCITED ATOMS
or in operator form rtl=
1 I ,jm')(jm I ( j - mjm' Ikq)( -
)k-j-m
mm'
121
(10)
where in our terminology Pkq = (rf'> Both pkqand T : ~are ~ irreducible tensor operators of rank k. Equations (8) and (9) may also be written for an atom excited by optical pumping. Then by inserting these expressions into Eq. (6) one obtains by orthogonality of the Clebsch-Gordon coefficients the scattering intensity z PkqO&-q.Now, since we have chosen a photon frame (ph) where omm, = d,, w(m), we have only one nonzero component of the optically excited multipole moments of the atom:
Zq
ckq= d,, M ' ( k )= dqo
1 w ( m ) ( j - mjm IkO)( -
)"-j-"'
m
(11)
Finally, our scattered intensity becomes I = I,
cw(k)(q)
(12) describe the atom after the time inverse The state multipole moments collision process with respect to the photon frame and may be calculated if Yco, is known.
(rtl)
2. Real Multipole Moments and Frame Transjorination Before actually comparing the experiment one has to transform the (rbkl) from the col frame [where they may be easily computed from Eqs. (6)-(911 to the ph frame to which Eq. (12) refers. This is done by rotation through the appropriate Euler angles. First, however, it is useful to introduce real quantities rather than the usual complex ones. Experimental observables are always real and the number of independent parameters may often be reduced by obvious symmetry relations (see below). Letting p denote k l , the real tensor operators T are connected to the usual complex ones by G kl P
- 1/$(i)(p-1)/2[(-pTI
7?t!= 7-p,
7?#!
= 0,
+
o
pT[!Iq], q=o
(13)
With these relations the real spherical harmonics become
Y t i ( 0 ,a) = n- "28,,(COS
0)cos q@ Y f l ( 0 , a) = n- 1/2:pk,(cos0)sin qa Y t ! @,a)= ( 2 4 - 1/29,,(cos 0).
}
q >0
(14)
I . c! Hertel and W Stoll
122
Here the SP, are the normalized Legendre polynomials of Bethe and Salpeter (1957),which relate to the usual complex spherical harmonics by
Y$)(@,a) = (27r)-1’2( -)qpkq(cos 0) exp(i@),
q 20
with the orthogonality relation
Y r j Y$s*dQ = 6,. 6,,y 6 k k * The real operators exhibit reflection symmetry and hermiticity explicitly. One sees directly that the Yg are real and that they transform as Yiy + pY$ under reflections in the zx plane. For later use we also give the real rotation matrices: 9’‘;.
c y p , = (-)-q[(-p
i2$, 4 p ,
cos(qa
+ q’y) d;k,!(/3)
+ p’ coS(qx - 4’7) dtlq48)1, = (-)-‘Q‘(-Psin(qa + q’y) d$!,(p)
+ sin(qa - q’y) dt!,,(/3)], 9?$,,@,‘= (-p+q’J2 d$( @o+,o+ = dgJ(/3),
cos(qa + q’y), p’ sin(qa q’y),
+
for p = p‘, k Z q, q’ > 0 for p # p‘. k 2 q, q’ > 0 for p = p’, q or q’ = 0 for p # p’, q or q’ = 0
q = q’.= 0
(15)
As a next step we note that the description of the experimental parameters ( 7 : l ) in terms of projection operators is not unique and other representations with more direct physical meaning may be preferable. To obtain such a substitution (Fano and Macek, 1973;Macek and Hertel, 1974)we recall that the Wigner-Eckart theorem allows us to replace any matrix element of an irreducible tensor operator of rank k by the corresponding one of another such operator. The same is true for averages, and thus3
with the reduced matrix element ( j 1 7[k1 11 j ) = (2k + 1)”’. Equation (16)may be inserted into Eq. (12);it allows a great flexibility in the choice of III4kp’ and lends itself to various interpretations of the experimental observables. It may, e.g., be constructed from angular momentum operators j , ,j , ,j z We use the notation of Edmonds (1964) for the redudmatrix elements.
COLLISIONS WITH LASER EXCITED ATOMS
123
using special polynomials: sometimes called the multipole-moment owrators. With this choice of the ratio of reduced matrix elements becomes (Macek and Hertel, 1974)
Using Eqs. ( 1 6 k ( 18) we obtain for the scattering intensity from laser-excited atoms 1 = IokrW(k)V(k)<7$’$(ph)) &=O
where 3”(k)= u(”)(F) and k,,,= 2F, when the atom is described in a hyperfine coupling scheme. We shall discuss in Section IV how to modify this when hyperfine interaction or even spin-orbit interactions do not play an essential role. Finally, transformation to the collision frame is done by
(Q$(ph)) =
2
(TJ(col))Cbk,‘(O,a)
q=o. p = f 1
(20)
where 0 and @ are the spherical coordinates of the photon frame, i.e., the E vector for d i g h t excitation and the light axis for 0 light.5 By variation of these angles, in principle all scattering multipole moments can be measured experimentally. From Eq. (17) (footnote 4) we find that by reflection on the x-z plane, the tensors F:j transform as p j: -,p(-)&T[&l because each pair of j , and Vi in qP Eq. (17) changes sign under reflection. Since the collision system is invariant to reflections in the scattering plane, we have
(q! (col)) = 0,
for k even
(T$!(col)) = 0, for k odd. (21) For reference we give the real spherical harmonics up to rank 2 and the multipole operators derived from them in Table I. These operators are constructed in a general way by polarizing (FalkoB and Uhlenbeck. 1950: Brink and Satchler. 1971) the real (Fano. 1960) solid harmonics,
$*C:L
+ l))1’aY$(C3.
= $(4n/(2k
@) (17)
3
Tl(j,j, ....j) = i t . C._.= il.
( j i ,j i 2 ...j , ) . V i , Vi,... Vii,C$
1
where i denotes real rectangular coordinates. For consistency. we use here real solid harmonics,which are related to spherical harmonics by Eq. (1 7).
’
124
I . K Hertel and W Stoll TABLE I REALS O L I D HARMONICS A N D MULTIPOLE OPERATORS UP TO RANK 2
The expectation values (qd) = Tr of (T[b-’) and (T,!) relate to the more commonly used orientation and alignment parameters (in the nonstandard normalization by Fano and Macek, 1973):
pqy
(F;!) = j ( j + 1)01-
(qkk,1)
In the following we prefer to use the parameters since they transform under rotation by application of real rotation matrices Eq. (15), in pole moments contrast to the 0 and A parameters. As seen, up to 2kmaa contribute to the scattering intensity, in principle. From Eqs. (9) or (17) we have k,,, = 2j. Thus, if the hyperfine quantum number determines the process k,,, = 2F, and in scattering from Na(3,P3,,, F = 3) one could in principle observe multipole moments of rank 6 (64-pole moment). If the electronic angular momentum J = $ were relevant one could observe rank-3 moments (octopole moments) and if L = 1 determines the scattering process, quadrupole moments would be the highest moments participating in Eq. (19). Of course, the corresponding W(k) have to be nonzero, as discussed in Section 111.
3. Some Examples of Multipole Moments The observables ( F ! ) )describe the atom after the time inverse process. To get a better feeling for the physical significance of the multipole moments we discuss some examples. a. Spin Polarization. The simplest case may be an atom in a ’Sl,, state with the nuclear spin decoupled, just having an electron spin, polarized with a polarization P = (nt - nJ)/(nt + nl), in the usual definition. Here
125
COLLISIONS WITH LASER EXCITED ATOMS
4)
j = s = i,the electron spin. From definition we have p(& = (1 + P)/2 and p( -9, -$) = (1 - P)/2. In the multipole description k,,, = 2s = 1 and the ( 7 $ l ) describe the state. From Eq. (17) we have
7-p=s,,
Fly = s,,
F1” = sy
Since we take p to be diagonal, only (s,) # 0 and we find
( F p ) = (s,)
= (fils,lfi)p(fi)
+ (+ - 41sz14 - $ ) p ( - +
- $) = i
P
Thus, this orientation parameter simply is one-half the spin polarization. From Eq. (21) we see that such an atom cannot be produced in a collision process from an unpolarized atom. Generally the (Ti,)are expectation values of the atomic angular momentum vector. b. Quadrupole Moment. As a second example, we discuss the physical interpretation of the alignment of a collisionally excited p state atom, as it is measured in the time inverse scattering by a laser-excited p state. This scattering quadrupole moment describes the atom by the three numbers (T’,;) (q = 0, 1, 2). Let us first give an upper and lower bound for the zero component. The Wiper-Eckart theorem gives
For the reduced matrix element (L 11 TtZ1 1 L ) we insert the value given by Fano and Racah (1968) p. 79) and evaluate the 3 - j symbol to obtain ((LA4 F,2’ILA4)) = (3M2 - L(L 1)). The averaging ( ) has two limiting cases defined by pure M 2 = L2 and M 2 = 0 states, respectively. Thus the upper and lower bounds are given by
+
I
-L(L
+ 1) < (F:’(L)) < (2L - 1)L
(231
and in particular for a p state, -2
,< ( T p ( L ) ) < 1
This sometimes gives a useful consistency check on the experimental observations. We now try to find a connection to the electronic charge distribution in the atom after collisional excitation, for which one usually has a better physical feeling than for expectation values of irreducible tensor operators. we recall that the elecFrom electrodynamics (e.g., Jackson,