ADVANCES IN
Applied Microbiology VOLUME 36
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
ADVANCES IN
Applied Microbiology Ed...
30 downloads
1608 Views
18MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
ADVANCES IN
Applied Microbiology VOLUME 36
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
ADVANCES IN
Applied Microbiology Edited by
SAUL L. NEIDLEMAN Vacaville, California
ALLEN I. LASKIN Somerset, New Jersey
VOLUME 36
Academic Press, Inc. Horcourt Brace Jovanovich, Publishers
San Diego New York Boston London Sydney Tokyo Toronto
This book is printed on acid-free paper. @ Copyright 0 1991 BY ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. All Rights Reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher.
Academic Press, Inc. San Diego, California 92101 United Kingdom Edition published by ACADEMIC PRESS LIMITED 24-28 Oval Road, London NWI 7DX
Library of Congress Catalog Card Number:
ISBN 0-12-002636-8 (alk. paper)
PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 91929394
9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
59- 13823
CONTENTS Microbial Transformations of Herbicides and Pesticides
DOUGLAS J . CORKAND JAMES P . KRUEGER I. Introduction ....................................................... I1. History of Microbial Conversions..................................... I11 Entry and Movement of Herbicides in the Environment ................ IV Taxonomy of Degradative Organisms ................................. V. Kinetics of Biodegradation by Microorganisms ........................ VI . Factors Affecting Biodegradation Kinetics ............................. VII . Biochemical Mechanisms of Aerobic Chloroaromatic Metabolism ....... VIII . Cometabolism ...................................................... IX Biochemical Mechanisms of Anaerobic Aromatic Metabolism ........... X. Molecular Biology of Degradative Microorganisms ..................... XI . Molecular Biology of Chloroaromatic Degradation ..................... XI1 Dicamba Biodegradation: A Case Study ............................... XI11 Growth Kinetics in Liquid Culture ................................... References .........................................................
. .
.
. .
1 2 4 5 7 10 21 29 32 36 37 44 49 63
An Environmental Assessment of Biotechnological Processes
M . S . THAKUR. M . J . KENNEDY.AND N . G . KARANTH I . Introduction ....................................................... I1. Ecological Consequences of the Release of Microorganisms ............. 111 Risk Assessment .................................................... IV Case Studies ....................................................... V. The Regulation of Biotechnological Processes ......................... VI . Conclusions ........................................................ References .........................................................
. .
67 69 73 75 80 82 83
Fate of Recombinant Escherichia coli K-12 Strains in the Environment
GREGGBOGOSIANAND JAMES F. KANE
. Introduction .......................................................
I I1. I11. IV. V. VI .
Construction and Properties of pBR322 ............................... Fate of E. coli and Related Organisms in Water ........................ Fate of E. coli and Related Organisms in Soil .......................... Fate of E . coli and Related Organisms in Sewage ....................... Fate of E . coli K-12in the Mammalian Intestinal Tract .................. V
87 89 100 104 108 113
vi
CONTENTS
.
VII Alternative Detection Methods for Recombinant Organisms in the Environment ....................................................... VIII . Conclusions ........................................................ References .........................................................
120 121 123
Microbial Cytochromes P-450 and Xenobiotic Metabolism
F . SIMASARIASLANI
. . . .
I Introduction ....................................................... I1 General Properties of Cytochromes P-450 ............................. 111 Microbial Cytochromes P-450........................................ IV Conclusion ......................................................... References .........................................................
133
134 139 173 174
Foodborne Yeasts
T . DEAK I. I1. I11. IV . V. VI .
Introduction ....................................................... Characteristics and Classification of Yeasts ............................ Ecology of Yeasts ................................................... Specific Habitats .................................................... Methods of Isolation and Enumeration ................................ Methods of Identification ............................................ References .........................................................
179 180 183
194 228 234 258
High-Resolution Electrophoretic Purification and Structural Microanalysis of Peptides and Proteins
ERIKP . LILLEHOJ AND VEDPAL s. MALIK I . Introduction ....................................................... I1. Polyacrylamide Gel Electrophoresis .................................. 111. Structural Analysis of Proteins Directly Eluted from One- and Two-Dimensional Polyacrylamide Gels ............................... IV . Structural Analysis of Proteins Electroblotted from One- and Two-Dimensional Polyacrylamide Gels ............................... V. Electrophoretic Micropreparative Procedures as Part of a Comprehensive Purification Strategy ................................................
280 281 290 303 315
CONTENTS
vii
VI . Applications of Microsequence Analysis of ElectrophoreticallyPurified Proteins ........................................................... VII . Quality Control of Recombinant Proteins .............................. VIII Prospective Directions .............................................. References .........................................................
318 323 327 329
INDEX ................................................................... CONTENTSOF PREVIOUSVOLUMES ...........................................
339 361
.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Microbial Transformations of Herbicides and Pesticides DOUGLASJ. CORK*AND JAMES P. KRUEGER~ *Department of Biology Illinois Institute of Technology Chicago, Illinois 60616 'Fitch, Even, Tabin and Flannery Chicago, Illinois 60603 I. Introduction 11. History of Microbial Conversions 111. Entry and Movement of Herbicides in the Environment
IV. Taxonomy of Degradative Organisms V. Kinetics of Biodegradation by Microorganisms VI. Factors Affecting Biodegradation Kinetics A. Structure B. Solubility C. Adsorption/Desorption D. Adaptation Rate E. Moisture, Temperature, and Nutrients F. Rates of Chloroaromatic Degradation VII. Biochemical Mechanisms of Aerobic Chloroaromatic Metabolism A. Demethylation B. Dehalogenation C. Ring Cleavage D. Chlorocatechol Metabolism VIII. Cometabolism IX. Biochemical Mechanisms of Anaerobic Aromatic Metabolism X. Molecular Biology of Degradative Microorganisms XI. Molecular Biology of Chloroaromatic Degradation Cloning of Pseudomonas Genes in the Escherichia coli Vector, pUC XII. Dicamba Biodegradation: A Case Study XIII. Growth Kinetics in Liquid Culture A. Effect of Dicamba Concentration B. Dependence of Activity on pH C. Effect of Temperature D. Growth Kinetics in Soil E. Growth Chamber Study F. Field Study References
I. Introduction
The use of xenobiotics has increased during recent decades. Herbicide and pesticide usage has benefited modern society by improving the quality and quantity of the world's food supply, while keeping the cost 1 ADVANCES IN APPLED MICROBIOLOGY. VOLUME 36 Copyright 0 1991 by Academic Press, Inc. All rights of reproductionin any form reserved.
2
DOUGLAS J. CORK AND JAMES P. KRUEGER
of that food supply reasonable. However, increased usage of chemicals has resulted in environmental concerns. Microorganisms in soil and water can transform many synthetic organic chemicals. The development and integration of microbes or their activities with the use of herbicides and pesticides can enhance the beneficial effects of chemical usage while eliminating some of the environmental concerns. Microbes can provide a means to eliminate unwanted residues from the environment, protect previously susceptible crops from herbicide or pesticide damage, and provide a source of genetic material for the development of herbicide-resistant crops or pesticide-producing plants. A fundamental understanding of a microbe’s degradative kinetics under various conditions, its biochemical systems, and its molecular biology are vital in maximizing the potential benefits of its use. II. History of Microbial Conversions
Microbial transformations have long been beneficial to mankind. More recently, these transformations have had environmental and chemical applications. Over billions of years, microorganisms have evolved an extensive range of enzymes, pathways, and control mechanisms in order to degrade a wide array of aromatic compounds. Microorganisms have been isolated that can degrade benzene (Dagley et a]., 1964), phenol (Feist and Hegeman, 1969), naphthalene (Davis and Evans, 1964), salicylate (Chakrabarty, 1972), toluene (Chakrabarty, 1976), and p- and m- hydroxybenzoate (Johnson and Stanier, 1971). There are a few instances in which catabolic pathways have evolved that are specific for chlorinated substrates (Dorn and Knackmuss, 1978a; Gibson, 1978). Haloaromatic-assimilating strains have been obtained by (1)enrichments from nature, (2) in vivo genetic manipulations, and (3) in vitro genetic manipulations. Enrichments have been used to show the involvement of microbes in the degradation of synthetic compounds such as 2 &dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D) (Bollag et al., 1968; Loos, 1975) 2,4,5-trichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4,5-T) (Rosenberg and Alexander, 1980), atrazine (Kaufman and Kearney, 1970),and some isomers of polychlorinated biphenyls (Ahmed and Focht, 1972).Pure cultures of bacteria that have been enriched for, isolated, and characterized can utilize 2chlorotoluene, 3-chlorotoluene, 3,4-dichlorotoluene, 2,4-dichlorobenzoate, 3 &dichlorobenzoate, and 5-chlorosalicylate as sole carbon and energy sources for growth (Vandenbergh etal., 1981; Pierce etal., 1983; Crawford e t a / . , 1979). The first report of in vivo construction of a catabolic pathway for the mineralization of chloroaromatic compounds was conducted with
TRANSFORMATIONSOF HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES
3
Pseudomonas sp. strain B13 and Pseudomonas putida mt-2, using 4chlorobenzoate (Reineke and Knackmuss, 1978). Strains were isolated that could degrade 3- and 4-chlorobenzoate. Similar methods have been used by others to develop strains that grow on 3-chlorobenzoic acid (Chatterjee et al., 1981) and 3,5-dichlorobenzoic acid (Chatterjee and Chakrabarty, 1982). Techniques such as plasmid-assisted molecular breeding have been used to develop a microbe capable of degrading 2,4,5-T (Kellogg et al., 1981). Advances in technologies associated with molecular biology have resulted in the construction of haloaromatic-degrading organisms. Organisms have been constructed that have the ability to degrade chlorosalicylate and chlorobenzoate (Lehrbach et al., 1984). For example, a strain of Pseudomonas sp. has been manipulated to completely mineralize dichloronaphtalene or convert it to the corresponding dichlorosalicylate (Durham and Stewart, 1987). The bioremediation industry is an excellent example of the application of degradative organisms to environmental cleanup. Table I lists TABLE I COMPANIES DEVELOPING XENOBIOTIC-DEGRADING MICROBES Company/location
Application
Advanced Mineral Technology/Golden, Colorado Air Products and Chemicals/Trexlertown, Pennsylvania Amgen/Thousand Oaks, California Battelle/Columbus, Ohio Bioclean/Bloomington, Minnesota BiotechnicalCambridge, Massachusetts Chemical Waste ManagemenKhicago, Illinois Celgene/Summit, New Jersey Ciba-Geigy/Greensboro, North Carolina Detox/Dayton, Ohio Dow/Midland, Michigan Ecova/Redmond, Washington Flow/Orange, California G.E./Schenectady, New York Genex/Gaithersburg, Maryland Groundwater Technology/Norwood, Massachusetts Homestake Mining/Reno, Nevada IGTKhicago, Illinois
Heavy metals Organics Trichloroethylene Chlorinated aromatics Pentachlorophenol Phenol Toxic waste Chlorinated aromatics Herbicides Organics Chlorophenols Solvents Sewage Polychlorobiphenyl Toxic waste Solvents Cyanide Coal Tars, sulfides, chlorinated aromatics Dicamba Herbicides Chlorinated aromatics Herbicides
IITRUChicago, Illinois Monsanto/St. Louis, Missouri Occidental ChemicaUGrand Island, New York Sandoz Crop Protection/Des Plaines, Illinois
4
DOUGLAS J. CORK AND JAMES P. KRUEGER
some of the companies involved in bioremediation and their applications. Others have used degradative organisms as a source of genetic material for the development of herbicide-resistant plants. Glyphosate and bromoxynil degradative genes have been transferred via Agrobacterium tumefaciens to produce resistant tobacco and other plant species (Stalker et a]., 1988).
Ill. Entry and Movement of Herbicides in the Environment
Herbicides enter the soil and water as a result of direct. application and runoff from plant surfaces, as an integral part of the weeds killed by them, via aerial transport and deposition because of earlier volatilization, via wind drift or wind-blown soil particles with adsorbed residues, from spillage, from water used to clean equipment, and from disposal of packing. Figure 1 illustrates the routes of entry of herbicides into the Aerial transport spillage, washing, and disposal of containers
Wind-drift Photodecomposition
-, mineralorganic
Transport in soil
s
.*-
Desorption and diffusion
Chemical transformation
Microbial transformation
Leaching
FIG.1. Entry and transformationof herbicides in the environment (Torstensson,1988).
TRANSFORMATIONSOF HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES
5
environment and some of the transformations that take place. Once in the environment, herbicides are subject to photochemical, chemical, and biological effects capable of causing transformations in the compound’s chemical structure. Biological and nonbiological processes work together to degrade herbicides. In nature it is difficult to distinguish between the two modes of degradation in most cases (Ashton, 1982).Though some reactions are clearly nonbiological, such as photolysis, others, such as hydrolysis, can be either nonbiological or biologically mediated. Examples of reactions that can transform herbicides in the environment are shown in Table 11. Mineralization or complete biodegradation of an organic molecule in water and soil is almost always a consequence of microbial activity. Few abiotic mechanisms in nature totally convert organic compounds to inorganic products (Alexander, 1981).Whether or not a herbicide is adsorbed, absorbed, activated, inactivated, persistent, short-lived, mobile, stationary, or will eventually constitute a residue problem may depend upon its transformation by soil microorganisms. The microbial metabolism of herbicides can be classified as indicated in Table 111. IV. Taxonomy of Degradative Organisms
Microbes that are natural components of soil and water environments are potential agents for the biological transformations of aromatic compounds that enter the ecosystem. Microorganisms usually occupy a TABLE I1
REACTIONSTHATCANTRANSFORM CHEMICALS IN THE ENVIRONMENT Category Photo1ysis Hydrolysis Oxidation Dehalogenation Deamination Decarboxylation Methyl oxidation Hydroxylation Sulfur oxidation Reduction Oxime metabolism Ester cleavage C-N cleavage C-S cleavage C-Hg cleavage S-N cleavage
Example Aldrin Diazinon 2,4-D
Chlorophenols Aniline Bifenox Isopropylnaphtha Dicamba Aldicarb DDT Aldicarb Malathion Alachlor Benthiocarb Ethylmercury Oryzalin
Reference Matsumura (1982) Matsumura (1982) Sandrnann and Loos (1988) Steiert et al. (1987) Zeyer et al. (1985) Leather and Foy (1977) Yoshida and Kojima (1978) Smith (1974) Andrews et al. (1971) Pfaender and Alexander (1972) Jones (1976) Paris eta). (1975) Tiedje and Hagedorn (1975) Ishikawa et al. (1976) Kimura and Miller (1964) Golab et al. (1975)
6
DOUGLAS J. CORK AND JAMES P. KRUEGER TABLE 111 GENERAL CLASSIFICATION OF THE MICROBIAL METABOLISM OF HERBICIDES"
Reaction type Enzymatic
Nonenzymatic
a
Description Incidental metabolism: herbicide does not serve as an energy source Metabolism by generally available enzymes Metabolism due to generally present broad-spectrum enzymes (hydrolases, oxidases, etc.) Metabolism due to specific enzymes present in many microbe species Analog-induced metabolism (cometabolism) Metabolism by enzymes utilizing substrates structurally similar to pesticides Catabolism: herbicide serves as an energy source Herbicide or part of the molecule is readily available source of energy for microbes Herbicide is not readily utilized; some specific enzyme must be induced Detoxification metabolism Metabolism by resistant microbes Participation in photochemical reactions Contribution through pH changes Contribution through production of inorganic and organic reactants Contribution through production of cofactors
From Matsumura (1982).
volume of less than 0.1% of the soil, but are responsible for numerous transformations that cycle elements and energy in nature. Microbial densities may be as high as lo9 per gram of soil, with a biomass up to several tonnes per hectare (Torstensson, 1988). The microbial population exists in a dynamic equilibrium formed by interactions of abiotic and biotic factors that can be altered by modifying environmental conditions. Microbes are able to degrade a wide variety of chemicals, from simple polysaccharides, amino acids, proteins, lipids, etc. to more complex material such as plant residues, waxes, and rubbers. Some important degradative bacteria that occur in water and soil environments are described in Table IV. Pseudomonas strains are extremely common and are often the predominant members of the populations selected from natural sources, such as soil, polluted waters, and sediments, for their ability to grow on single compounds as sole carbon sources (Ribbons and Williams, 1982). Pseudomonas strains are facultative aerobes, as some can use nitrate as a terminal acceptor for a limited number of substrates. Aerobically grown pseudomonads can be described as Gram-negative unicellular rods,
TRANSFORMATIONSOF HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES
7
TABLE IV CLASSIFICATION OF DEGRADATIVE BACTERIA THATOCCUR IN WATER AND SOIL' ~~~
Description
Family
Gram-negativeaerobic rods and cocci
Facultatively anaerobic Gram-negativerods Endospore-forming Grampositive rods and cocci ~
~
~
~~~~~
~
~
Genus
Pseudomonadaceae
Pseudomonas, Xanthomonas
Azotobacteraceae Rhizobiaceae Methylococcaceae Neisseriaceae -b Enterobacteriaceae
Azotobacter Rhizobium, Agrobacterium Methylomonas, Methylococcus Momxella, Acinetobacter Alcaligenes, Flavobacteriurn Escherichia, Enterobacter, Serratia, Proteus Aerornonas Bacillus
Vibrionaceae Bacillaceae ~
From Bergey's Manual of Systematic Bacteriology (1984). Affiliation uncertain.
with the long axis straight or curved, but not helical. They do not form spores, stalks, or sheaths. The energy-yielding metabolism is respiratory, never fermentative or photosynthetic. All use molecular oxygen as a terminal oxidant, except for several that can use denitrification as an alternative anaerobic respiratory mechanism. All are chemolithotrophs, though some are facultative chemolithotrophs that use Hzas an energy source (Stanier et al.,1966).The genus falls into five main groups by the criterion of ribosomal RNA homology [Table V). The predominant biological feature of the pseudomonads is their biochemical diversity [Stanier et a]., 1966). Strains of Pseudomonas spp. are capable of utilizing over 100 different compounds. Pseudomonas spp. have been reported as being capable of growing on alkanes, mono- and polycyclic hydrocarbons, salicylate, heterocyclics, phenolics, and aliphatic and aromatic halogenated compounds (Ribbons and Williams, 1982).Table VI lists some of the catabolic activities of Pseudomonas spp. and other degradative organisms. V. Kinetics of Biodegradation by Microorganisms
Microorganisms grow in a wide spectrum of physical and chemical environments. Growth of microorganisms and other physiological activities are a response to the physiochemical environment. Growth rate, like a chemical reaction rate, is a function of chemical concentration.
DOUGLAS J. CORK AND JAMES P. KRUEGER
8
TABLE V CLASSIFICATION OF PSEUDOMONAS SPECIES INTO RNA HOMOLOGY GROUPS" rRNA homology group ~
% GC in DNA ~
67 59-63 61-62 61-66 63-64 66 67-68 65 69 69 67 62 62-64 66-67 66 67 66-68
1
2
3 4 5
a
Species
~~
P. aeruginosa P. fluorescens P. putida P. stutzeri P. rnendocina P. alcaligenes P. cepacia P. caryophylli P. pseudomallei P. mallei P. acidovorans P. testosteroni P. facilis P. diminuta P. vesicularis P. rnaltophilia Xanthomonas sp.
From Ribbons and Williams (1982).
The relationship between growth rate and substrate concentration can be described by the Monod model: where p is the specific growth rate, pmaxis the maximum specific growth rate, S is the substrate concentration, and Ks is a constant equal TABLE VI BACTERIA THATCANDEGRADE CHLOROAROMATIC COMPOUNDS Organism
Substrate
Reference
Alcaligenes denitrificans Pseudomonas cepacia Bacillus circulans Alcaligenes sp. Pseudornonas sp. Pseudomonas putida Bacillus brevis Alcaligenes eutrophus Flavobacterium sp. Arthrobacter sp. Pseudomonas sp. Pseudomonas maltophilia
2&Dichlorobenzoate 2.4.5-T Metolachlor 1,3-Dichlorobenzene Atrazine 3-Chlorobenzoate 5-Chlorosalicylate 2,4-D Pentachlorophenol 4-Chlorobenzoic acid 3,5-Dichlorobenzoate Dicamba
Van Den Tweel et 01. (1987) Chatterjee et al. (1982) Saxena et a]. (1987) DeBont et al. (1986) Behki and Khan (1986) Chatterjee et al. (1981) Crawford et al. (1979) Perkins and Lurquin (1988) Steiert et al. (1988) Marks et 01. (1984) Reineke and Knackmuss (1980) Fujimoto and Cork (1991)
TRANSFORMATIONSOF HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES
9
to the substrate concentration when p = 0 . 5 ~ The ~ ~specific . growth rate can be calculated by the following equation: fd
= In 2Ip
where td is the time required to double cell mass or cell number. A graphic representation of the Monod model is shown in Fig. 2. Some physical and biological meaning can be attributed to the two constants in the Monod model. The value of P m m is the maximum specific growth rate in a given chemical medium at specified temperature and pH. The value of K, is inversely proportional to the affinity the microorganism has for the substrate (Wang et al., 1979). When the concentration of a utilizable organic substrate is considerably in excess of the bacterium’s K, value, logarithmic or exponential kinetics of growth occurs. If the cell density is so great that the quantity of substrate is insufficient to support a significant increase in cell mass, then the kinetics of disappearance of organic chemicals present at high levels (in excess of K,) is zero order, or linear with time. Two patterns of kinetics can be envisioned when a single bacterial species is provided with a mineralizable substrate at concentrations below the K, value. In the first pattern, there is no increase in cell number either because the concentration of substrate is too low to
Substrate Concentration FIG.2. The Monod model for microbial growth.
10
DOUGLAS J. CORK AND JAMESP. KRUEGER
support growth, or because the initial cell number is too large, relative to the quantity of organic compound, to permit an appreciable increase in cell mass. At constant biomass and limiting substrate levels, the rate is proportional to the concentration of substrate; this is typical of firstorder kinetics. In the second pattern, few cells of the active species are present initially. Under these conditions the bacteria will grow, but at a rate that falls constantly with diminishing substrate concentrations. A growth pattern in which there is an increasing cell number encountering a decreasing nutrient resource resembles the classical logistic growth curve (Alexander, 1985). The kinetics expected at different chemical concentrations and cell numbers are shown in Fig. 3. The shapes of the curves for chemical disappearance that coincide with these kinetics are illustrated in Figs. 4 and 5. VI. Factors Affecting Biodegradation Kinetics
The rate of microbial decomposition of a chemical in soil and in liquid medium is mediated by three factors: (1)the availability of the chemical to the microorganism or enzyme system that can degrade it, (2) the quantity of these microorganisms or enzyme systems, and (3) the
Monod nithout growtt
First order
/
order
Monod
Logarithmic
(with growth)
Initial Substrate Concentration
FIG. 3. Kinetic models as a function of initial substrate concentrationand bacterial cell density (Alexander, 1985).
TRANSFORMATIONSOF HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES
11
Time FIG. 4. Disappearance curves for chemicals that are mineralized as related to firstorder, zero-order, and Monod growth kinetic models (Alexander, 1985). 1
Time
FIG.5. Disappearance curves for chemicals that are mineralized as related to logistic, logarithmic, and Monod kinetic models (Alexander, 1985).
12
DOUGLAS J. CORK AND JAMES P. KRUEGER
activity level of these organisms or enzyme systems. The availability of a chemical to a microbial population in soil or liquid medium is determined by the physical properties of that chemical. The chemical’s structure and its resulting solubility in water, dissolution rate, and adsorption/desorption characteristics in soil are properties that determine availability (Bollag, 1974,Goulding et a]., 1988;Alexander, 1981;Stucki and Alexander, 1987;Ogram et a]., 1985).Biodegradation rates of available organic substrates have been shown to be directly related to microbial biomass and the activity of that biomass (Anderson, 1984).Environmental factors such as pH, temperature, soil moisture level, and soil composition are important regulators of microbial activity, and therefore of the degradation rate of a chemical (Vaishnav and Babeu, 1987). A. STRUCTURE The introduction of substituents on a benzene ring influences its degradation considerably. Minor alterations in structure frequently cause a drastic change in the susceptibility of such compounds to biotransformations. Introduction of polar groups such as OH, COOH, and NH2 may provide the microbial system a site of attack. Halogen or alkyl substitutions tend to make the molecule more resistant to biodegradation (Bollag, 1974).Degradation rates of chlorine-substituted aromatic compounds are dependent on the position of the substituents and the degree of substitution (Goulding et a]., 1988). Table VII shows that monochlorosubstituted isomers were generally degraded more rapidly than di- or trichloro derivatives. Monochlorophenols were more rapidly assimilated than monochlorobenzoic acids. Both 3,4- and 3,sdichlorophenols were more difficult to degrade than 2,3-,2,5-, and 2,6-dichlorophenols. Dichlorobenzene isomers were completely degraded whereas dichlorobenzoic acids were less efficiently removed due to the position of the chlorines.
.
B SOLUBILITY In general, compounds with low water solubility tend to be more resistant to microbial degradation than are compounds of higher water solubility. Chemicals having low solubilities in water may not provide sufficient carbon to support microbial growth. Low ambient concentrations of substrate may result in a decreased penetration rate into the cell and too few molecules per unit time to allow enough energy for the organism to maintain itself (Alexander, 1981).To mineralize or grow on substrates having low solubilities in water, microorganisms may require
TRANSFORMATIONS OF HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES
13
TABLE VII DEGRADATION RATESAND PERCENTAGE REMOVALOF CHLOROSUBSTITUTED AROMATIC COMPOUNDSO Substrate
Removal (Yo)
2-Chlorobenzoic acid 3-Chlorobenzoic acid 2-Chlorophenol 4-Chlorophenol 2,6-Dichlorobenzoic acid 3,5-Dichlorobenzoic acid 2,6-Dichlorophenol 2,3-Dichlorophenol 2,5-Dichlorophenol 3,4-Dichlorophenol 3,5-Dichlorophenol l&Dichlorobenzene 1,3-Dichlorobenzene 1,4-Dichlorobenzene
100 100 100 100 52 81 100
100 100 44 52 100 100 100
Removal rate (mg/liter/hour)
Incubation time (hours)
4.10 1.57 5.10 4.80 2.57 1.65 4.80 4.60 2.10 0.53 1.04 NDb ND ND
96 96 96 96 168 168 72 72 144 168 168 96 96 96
From Goulding et al. (1988).
Rate not calculated.
some physiological adaptations. Bacteria may facilitate the uptake of poorly soluble compounds by producing emulsifiers [Guerra-Santos et ~ l .1984). , Modification of the cell surface may increase its affinity for hydrophobic substances and thus facilitate their absorption (Neufeld et QI., 1980) Organisms may grow only at the expense of the compound dissolved in solution. Therefore, the rate of dissolution of such chemicals would govern the rate of their biodegradation [Stucki and Alexander, 1987). C. ADSORPTION/DESORPTION The binding of xenobiotics to soil may involve various interactions such as ionic or covalent bonds, van der Waals forces, hydrogen bonds, charge transfer, and hydrophobic bonds. Each contributes not only to the binding but also to the extent of the subsequent release (Dec and Bollag, 1985). In most cases, herbicides and pesticides reversibly partition between the soil solution and soil organic matter (Karickhoff, 1981). The adsorption/desorption characteristics of a chemical in soil may determine its availability to degradative organisms. Comparison of the half-lives of the chemical with data describing its adsorption showed that there was a direct correlation between the amount of
14
DOUGLAS J. CORK AND JAMES P. KRUEGER
chemical in solution and the rate of dissipation (Torstensson, 1988). When pesticides such as paraquat and diquat are intercalated into clay, they are isolated from the degrading organisms and protected form intracellular degradation (Burns and Audus, 1970;Weber and Coble, 1968).Other authors have indicated that pesticide sorption might either enhance or decrease microbial degradation rates in soil (Ogram et al., 1985).Because bacteria themselves may be sorbed, it is conceivable that bacteria and herbicides may be sorbed on adjacent locations on the soil surface, thereby facilitating the scavenging of the chemical by the sorbed bacteria. Three models have been proposed by Ogram et al. (1985)to describe the effects of sorption of bacteria and 2,4-D on the biological degradation rates of 2,4-D. The sorption of 2,4-D and bacteria were characterized by the following equations: For 2,4-D, S = KDC For bacteria,
Ns = KBNW where S and Ns are the amounts of 2,443 and bacteria, respectively, sorbed on soil; KD and KB are the respective sorption coefficients; and C and Nw are the solution-phase concentrations of 2,4-D and bacteria, respectively. The first model states that only 2,4-D in solution is degraded and that it is degraded only by bacteria in solution. The model is expressed as follows: dTldt = - K,CN,W where dTldt is the change in mass of pesticide over time, K, is the degradation rate coefficient, and W is the volume of water in the system. Model 2 states that bacteria in a given phase only degrade 2,4-D in that phase. This model is expressed as follows: dTldt =
-
(K,CN,W
+ K,,SN,M)
where K,, is the rate coefficient for degradation in sorbed phase and M is the mass of soil. The third model states that only 2,4-D in solution is available for degradation but bacteria in both sorbed and solution phases would be capable of degrading 2,4-D. This model is as follows: dTldt = - (K,CN,W
+ KswCNsM)
where K,, represents the combined effects of the rates at which sorbed bacteria encounter 2,4-D, take it up, and then mineralize it to COz.
TRANSFORMATIONS OF HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES
15
If model 1 is correct, then K, (degradation rate coefficient) should be constant with varying soil/solution ratios and for different soils. For 2,4-D, K , increased with increasing soil/solution ratios. As the soil solution ratio increases, sorption of both bacteria and 2,4-D should increase. The increase in K, with increasing soil/solution ratios suggests that sorbed 2,4-D was being degraded or that sorbed bacteria may have been degrading 2,4-D. If model 2 accurately describes the situation, then K,, values (rate coefficient for degradation in sorbed phase) should be the same for all soils. As sorption of both 2,4-D and bacteria increased in various soils, the calculated values of K,, decreased, suggesting there may have been at least partial protection of 2,4-D from degradation when it was sorbed. , and K,, (combined degradation rate If model 3 is correct, then K coefficient) will be constant with varying soil types and soil/solution ratios. This model describes the data for 2,4-D. Sorbed 2,443 was completely protected from biological degradation and sorbed and solutionphase bacteria degraded solution-phase 2,4-D with almost equal efficiencies (Ogram et a]., 1985).
D. ADAPTATION RATE An understanding of adaptations of microbial communities to organic chemical exposure is critical for predicting chemical degradative ratios. The mineralization of many organic compounds by microorganisms is often preceded by an acclimation period. The acclimation period is the time interval during which biodegradation is not detected. The acclimation time required for a microbial population to degrade a chemical can be influenced by the rate and frequency of exposure to that chemical. Soil microorganisms have been shown to degrade 2,4-D more rapidly after repeated exposure to 2,4-D (Torstensson, 1988).A graphic representation of the effects of repeated applications of a herbicide is shown in Fig. 6. High or low concentrations of a chemical may increase the acclimation period. The acclimation period for degradation in soil of the herbicide picloram increased as its concentration increased (Grover, 1967).High concentrations of a chemical may be toxic or inhibitory to the microbial populations present. At low concentrations of the compound, the long acclimation may be the result of slow growth of the mineralizing organisms or low concentrations of substrate (Wiggins and Alexander, 1988). Additionally, evidence exists that one compound may shorten the acclimation period needed before another is degraded. The acclimation of sewage microflora to 3-chlorobenzoate or 4-
16
DOUGLAS J. CORK AND JAMES P. KRUEGER
Time FIG.6. Effect of repeated herbicide application on acclimation (Torstensson, 1988).
chlorobenzoate reduced the acclimation time for mineralization of other monosubstituted aromatic hydrocarbons (Haller, 1978). The adaptation process may involve one or a combination of (1)induction or derepression of enzymes specific for degradation pathways of a particular compound; (2) a random mutation in which new metabolic capabilities are produced, allowing degradation that was previously not possible; or (3) an increase in the number of organisms in the degrading population (Aelion et al., 1987). An induction signal may come from the chemical substrate itself or from other chemicals present. It has been reported that the phenylurea herbicide monuron could induce an acylamidase in Bacillus sphaericus that is capable of hydrolyzing the herbicide linuron, although monuron itself is not a substrate (Engelhardt et al., 1973). An acclimation period may result from the time required for the appearance of a new genotype after a mutation or genetic exchange occurring during exposure to the compound. For example, adaptation of Acinetobacter calcoaceticus to the degradation of aniline has been attributed to a mutation in the natural population with the involvement of a plasmid-carried gene (Wyndham, 1986).Studies in the mineralization of 4-nitrophenol indicated that the acclimation time resulted from the time needed for a small population to become suffi-
17
TRANSFORMATIONS OF HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES
ciently large to give detectable loss of the chemical (Wiggins and Alexander, 1988).In this study, the growth of mineralizing organisms was affected by predation by protozoa and competition for inorganic nutrients.
E. MOISTURE, TEMPERATURE, AND NUTRIENTS It is the environment that actually controls the biodegradation process and has a greater influence on the process than microorganisms per se (Vaishnav and Babeu, 1987).Inhibition of microbial activity by a low or high temperature and extremes of pH may result in the persistence of potentially mineralizable compounds. Soil composition, percentage of organic matter, nutrient levels, and moisture levels are important regulators of microbial degradative activity. The kinetics of 2,4-D degradation for soil samples incubated at four moisture tensions and four temperatures is shown in Table VIII. Degradation occurred by a slow first-order reaction (slow phase), which, under some conditions, was followed by a rapid first-order reaction (fast TABLE VIII EFFECTS OF SOILMOISTURE TENSION AND TEMPERATURE ON THE RATE OF 2,4-D DECOMPOSITION IN SOIL INCUBATED WITH 25 pg 2,4-D PER GRAMOF SOILa
Temperature (“Cl 20
27
30
35
a
Moisture tension
Decomposition rate (Ccg/g/day)
(bas1
Duration of slow phase (days)
Slow phase
Fast phase
0.10 0.33 0.50 1.00 0.10 0.33 0.50 1 .oo 0.10 0.33 0.50 0.00 0.10 0.33 0.50 1.00
36 >90 >90 >90 28 90 >90 >90 >63 >63 >63 >42 >42 >42 >42 >42
0.123 0.075 0.038 0.026 0.230 0.140 0.128 0.075 0.238 0.125 0.126 0.253 0.151 0.117 0.127 0.058
0.887
From Parker and Doxtader (1983).
* No fast phase observed.
-b
18
DOUGLAS J. CORK AND JAMES P. KRUEGER
phase). The rate of decomposition of 2,4-D decreased with increasing soil moisture tensions for temperatures between 20 and 35°C. The decrease was a result of the reduced activity of the 2A-D-degradingmicroorganisms arising form decreased water availability and increased 2,4-D solution concentration (Parker and Doxtader, 1983). The effects of soil water content and soil temperature on the degradation of 2,4,5-T are shown in Table IX. The optimal temperature for 2,4,5-T degradation was 30°C and the optimal soil water content was 25% (Chatterjee et a]., 1982). Generally, chemicals were found to have biodegraded to a greater extent in waters enriched with both nutrients and microbes than in those receiving either amendment alone (Vaishnav and Babeu, 1987). Table X illustrates that effects of nutrient and microbial additions on first-order biodegradation rate constants and half-lifes of selected chemicals in natural waters. A sufficient microbial population capable of utilizing the chemical is also important for biodegradation. For example, the soil degradation of the herbicide 2,4,5-T was increased by increasing the concentration of a 2,4,5-T-degradingorganism (Table XI).
F. RATESOF CHLOROAROMATIC DEGRADATION Degradative organisms have been isolated that can transform a number of chloroaromatic compounds. The rates at which pure cultures of TABLE IX EFFECTS OF SOILMOISTURE AND TEMPERATURE ON THE DEGRADATION OF 2,4,5-T IN SOIL TREATED WITH 1000 pg/g 2,4,5-T AND INOCULATED WITHP. Cepacia AC1100"
Incubation temperature
Soil water
2,4,5-T
content
degradation
("C)
(%I
(%Ib
20 30 37 42 30 30 30 30 30
20 20 20 20 15 25 50 75 90
52 73 56 32 78 95 89 58 57
, From Chatterjee et al. (1982). As determined by GC analysis.
19
TRANSFORMATIONSOF HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES TABLE X
EFFECTSOF NUTRIENT AND MICROBE ADDITION ON FIRST-ORDER RATECONSTANTSAND HALF-LIVES OF CHEMICALS IN LIQUIDMEDIUM" Acclimated microbes added
Nutrients and acclimated microbes added
NDb
ND
0.029 (24) 0.009 (77)
0.008 (87) 0.044 (16) 0.016 (43)
0.082 ( 8) 0.062 (11) 0.031 (22) 0.018 (39)
Nutrients added
Chemical Benzene t-Butylbenzoate Hexadecane Naphthalene
ND
From Vaishnav and Babeu (1987). Half-lives are given in parentheses. No difference from controls.
these organisms degrade various chlorinated compounds in liquid medium and in soil have been determined in a number of cases. Figure 7 shows the release of I4CO2from I4C-labeled 2,4-D incubated with a culture of Alcaligenes sp. Up to 40% of the substrate radiocarbon was mineralized to COz in 20 hours (Amy et al., 1985). A pure culture of Pseudomonas cepacia ACllOO has been isolated that is capable of growing on 2,4,5-T as its sole source of carbon and energy (Karns et al., 1984).After a 24-hour incubation of 0.1 mM 2,4,5-T with P. cepacia in liquid medium, 83% of the chloride was released. Soil contaminated with as much as 20,000 pg of 2,4,5-T per gram of soil showed greater than 90% degradation after six weekly treatments with P. cepacia. Furthermore, a strain of P. putida has been isolated that can degrade 3-chlorobenzoate (Chatterjee et al., 1981).After a 48-hour incubation of 7.5 mM 3-chlorobenzoate with P. putida, about 80% of the TABLE XI EFFECT OF MICROBIAL CONCENTRATION ON 2,4,5-T DEGRADATION IN SOILo Organisms per gram of soil ~-
2,4,5-T
degradation
(%Ib
~~
5 5 5 5
0
2.2 x 105 2.2 x 10" 2.2 x 107 ~~
Incubation period (days)
~
From Chatterjee et 01. (1982). As determined by GC analysis. Not detectable.
NDC 50 66 81
20
DOUGLAS J, CORK AND JAMESP. KRUEGER
Time (Hours)
FIG.7. Release of 14C02from a culture of Alcaligenes incubated with [14C]2,4-D (Amy et al., 1985).
chloride was released as inorganic chloride into the medium. Additionally, three species of Pseudomonas sp. were isolated that were capable of utilizing the herbicide atrazine as a sole carbon source (Behki and Khan, 1986). Strains were able to increase in cell number when incubated with atrazine as a sole carbon source (Table XII). Strains of Bacillus sp., Fusarium sp., and Mucor sp. have been identified that can transform the herbicide metolachlor, but cannot completely mineralize it (Saxena et al., 1987).Organisms were able to transform up to 70% of the metolachlor present at a concentration of 50 pg/ml. TABLE XI1
GROWTHOF PSEUDOMONAS STRAINS ON ATRAZINE AS A SOLE CARBONSOURCEO Viable celldm1 ( x 10’) Strain
Initial
After 14 days
192 195 555
1.48 3.10 2.42
19.40 16.72 14.90
a
From Behki and Khan (1986).
21
TRANSFORMATIONSOF HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES
VII. Biochemical Mechanisms of Aerobic Chloroaromatic Metabolism
The majority of aromatic compounds are converted by bacteria to catechol or protocatechuate (Figs. 8 and 9). Catechol and protocatechuate become starting substrates for subsequent oxidative cleav-
06 CHOH-COOH
CO-COOH COOH
L- tryp tophan
anthracene
CO-CHZ-CHNH2-COOH
benzaldehyde
6 benzoate
benzene
formylkynurenine
1
0"'
CO-CH2-CHNHZ-COOH
L-kynurenine
phenol FIG.8. Aromatic compounds that can be converted to catechol (Gottschalk,1979).
DOUGLAS 1. CORK AND JAMES P. KRUEGER
22
co-coou
CI10H-COOH
OH
013
p-hydroxybenzoyl formate
p-hydroxy-lmandelate
HOCOOH
HO COOH
p- toluat e
OH
P-hY droxybenzaldehyde I
0
shikimat e
I
COOH
benzoate
quinate
OH
J
{OOH
o - O O H
OH
oti
ite
G OOHC H 3
benzoate
OH
protocatechuate FIG. 9. Aromatic and hydroaromatic compounds that can be converted to protocatechuate (Gottschalk, 1979).
age reactions. Chlorinated aromatic compounds can be converted to catechol, protocatechuate, or their corresponding chlorocatechol or protocatechuate by reactions described in Table 11. For example, various soil bacteria have been reported to cleave the ether linkage of 2,4-D to produce 2,4-dichlorophenol (Beadle and Smith, 1982). The catabolism of 2-chloroaniline involves 3,6-dioxygenation to yield 3-chlorocatechol (Latorre et a]., 1984). Also, nonselective dioxygenation was responsible
TRANSFORMATIONS OF HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES
23
for the conversion of chlorinated benezoates into the respective catechols (Reineke and Knackmuss, 1978). Two processes that are especially important in the initial degradation of chloroaromatic compounds are demethylation and dehalogenation. A. DEMETHYLATION A demethylase enzyme that converts 4-methoxybenzoate to 4hydroxybenzoate has been characterized (Bernhardt et a]., 1975). The 4-methoxybenzoate-O-demethylase is a multienzyme system described as an iron-containing and labile-sulfur-containing monooxygenase. The demethylase enzyme consists of an NADH-dependent reductase and a monooxygenase. The NADH reductase contains FMN and an ironsulfur complex. The iron-sulfur complex appears to be essential for the catalytic function of the reductase and may mediate the transfer of electrons from NADH to the monooxygenase. The monooxygenase appears to be a dimer containing an iron-sulfur chromophore. A proposed mechanism of action for the demethylase enzyme system is shown in Fig. 10.
B. DEHALOGENATION A crucial point in the biodegradation of chloroaromatic compounds is the removal of halogen substituents from the organic compound. Dechlorination mechanisms can be classified as follows: (1) displacement of halogen through hydrogen, (2) displacement of halogen by hydroxyl, (3) oxygenolytic halogen-carbon bond cleavage, and (4) chloride elimination from nonaromatic intermediates. Halogen removal may occur at an early state of the degradative pathway with reductive, hydrolytic, or oxygenolytic elimination of the chlorosubstituent. Alternatively, nonaromatic structures may be generated that spontaneously lose the halide. Displacement of halogen through hydrogen is mainly an anaerobic process and is also referred to as reductive dechlorination. Anaerobic microbial consortiums have been shown to remove chloride without alteration of the aromatic ring (Suflita et al., 1982). Dechlorination occurred under methanogenic conditions, appeared to be enzymatic, and it occurred after induction and because of a low substrate K, of 67 pM. Loss of activity at temperatures above 39°C was observed, and the enzyme exhibited a high degree of substrate specificity. The reducing power required for reductive dechlorination was obtained from the hydrogen produced in the acetogenic oxidation of benzoate. Aerobic
24
DOUGLAS J. CORK AND JAMES P. KRUEGER
I R-H
1
R H
s
-' 1 \\
' 'FeIII\'/'FeIII(II)< -S-
Reductase eFel I I
nooxygenase
(oxld ized)
T
1
1- '
H
H20
\
2e- 0 H H FIG.10. Proposed reaction mechanism of the 4-methoxybenzoate monooxygenase (0-demethylase)enzyme system (Bernhardt et al., 1975).
TRANSFORMATIONS OF HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES
25
reductive dechlorination has also been demonstrated with a strain of Alcaligenes denitrificans incubated with 2,4-dichlorobenzoate (Van Den Tweel et al., 1987). It has been demonstrated that a halogen can be directly replaced on a benzene ring by a hydroxyl group (Johnston et al., 1972). Other studies have shown that 4-chlorobenzoate is converted to 4-hydroxybenzoate before being degraded via the protocatechuate pathway (Chapman, 1975). The mechanism of the dehalogenation process has been determined by experiments using "Oz and Hz180 (Marks et a]., 1984; Muller et a]., 1984). Data indicated that the dechlorination reaction utilizes water, not molecular oxygen, as the hydroxyl donor. The results showed that the conversion of 4-chlorobenzoate to 4-hydroxybenzoate proceeded via a hydrolytic cleavage of the carbon-chlorine bond. Oxygenolytic halogen-carbon bond cleavage is another mechanism to remove halogen substituents from haloaromatic compounds. The mechanism involves the fortuitous dehalogenation of the substrate by a dioxygenase enzyme. This method of dehalogenation has been demonstrated by a Pseudomonas sp. that degrades 2-fluorobenzoate (Milne et al., 1968).Dehalogenation was the result of nonselective dioxygenation by a benzoate 1,2-dioxygenase. The mechanism is illustrated in Fig. 11.
/"
NADHz
FIG.11, Dehalogenation by nonselective dioxygenationby a benzoate 1,2-dioxygenase (Milne et al., 1968).
26
DOUGLAS J. CORK AND JAMES P. KRUEGER
Chloride elimination can occur after ortho cleavage of chlorocatechols. Some compounds, such as 3-chlorobenzoate, may only be dehalogenated after ring fission (Dorn and Knackmuss, 1978b).Chloride appears to be eliminated spontaneously after the carbon-halogen bond has been labilized through isomerases or reductases (Reineke and Knackmuss, 1988). Studies on the cyclosiomerase enzyme in the metabolic pathway of 3-chlorobenzoate indicated that dehalogenation was a secondary reaction of the cycloisomerization of halomuconic acid (Schmidt and Knackmuss, 1980).
C. RINGCLEAVAGE The aromatic rings of catechol and protocatechuate are cleaved via the reactions of the ortho- or meta-cleavage pathways illustrated in Figs. 1 2 and 13. The reactions of the catechol and protocatechuate branch are catalyzed by different enzymes. There is, for example, a catechol-1,2oxygenase and a protocatechuate-4,5-oxygenase. The products of either cleavage, cis, cis-muconate and 3-carboxy-cis,cis-muconate, yield in two subsequent reactions the first common intermediate, 4-oxoadipate enol lactone. This compound is degraded further to yield succinate and acetyl-CoA. The channeling of diverse compounds into a few central pathways benefits the microbe by simplifying regulatory circuits, genetic control, and reducing energy requirements (Harayama et al., 1987). The meta-cleavage pathway uses catechol-2,3-dioxygenaseto open the ring adjacent to the hydroxyl groups. Further metabolism leads to the formation of pyruvate, formate, and acetaldehyde. The catabolism of catechol produced during the metabolism of naphthalene by PseudoI I I O ~ Q Sspp. has been shown to involve the meta pathway in which the first reaction was catalyzed by catechol-2,3-dioxygenase (Barnsley, 1976). Toluene and substituted toluenes have also been shown to be degraded via the meta pathway (Chatfield and Williams, 1986). Oxygenase enzymes are responsible for the incorporation of the oxygen molecule directly into the organic substrate to yield hydroxyl groups. Oxygenases are classified as either dioxygenases or as monooxygenases. The monooxygenases are also referred to as hydroxylases or mixed-function oxidases. The dioxygenases catalyze incorporation of two atoms of oxygen, and the monooxygenases incorporate only one atom. Most dioxygenase enzymes characterized contain Fe(I1) but have no labile sulfur. Several dioxygenase enzymes that have been crystallized are nonheme iron proteins and others, such as tryptophan dioxygenase,
27
TRANSFORMATIONSOF HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES
protocatechuate
catechol
4
COOH COOH
D -carboxy
cis, cis-muconate
c o=c HooC o ,
c=o
Y-carboxy-
muconolactone
4-oxoadipate
en%
,
;~~~3c;~;~
lactone
CoA
succinate
succinyl-CoA
FIG.1 2 . Reactions of the ortho-cleavage pathway. 1, Catechol 12-oxygenase; 2, muconate-lactonizing enzyme; 3, muconolactone isomerase; 4 , protocatechuate 3,4oxygenase; 5, carboxymuconate-lactonizingenzyme; 6, carboxymuconolactone decarboxylase; 7,oxoadipate enol lactone hydrolase; 8, oxoadipate succinyl-CoA transferase; 9,oxoadipyl-CoA thiolase (Gottschalk, 1979).
are heme enzymes (Metzler, 1977).The dioxygenase enzyme is typically made up of four subunits with a molecular weight of about 40,000 each (Crawford et al.,1975;Que et al.,1981).Dioxygenase enzymes are active when the iron is in the ferrous form. The formation of a Fe(II)-02 complex may be an essential first step. A proposed mechanism is as follows: Fe(I1)-0, + Fe(III)+-02 + Fe(II1) (ferriheme) (oxygenated complex) 02- (attacking reagent)
28
DOUGLAS J. CORK AND JAMESP. KRUEGER
catechol
protocatechuate
noH COOH
\CHO
2-hydroxymuconic
H o o c ~ ~ ~ o H CHO
2-hydroxy semialdehyde
6
oxopent-4-enoate
carboxvpentenoate
HOOC HCOH"~ E'O
CH3
COOH
oxovalerate
+
\
rCH. COH
r
1
4& pyruvate
MCOOH
CH3
c=o
I COOH
oxovalerate
acetaldehyde
2 pyruvate FIG. 13. Dissimilation of cathechol and protocatechuate by the pathways involving meta cleavage. 1, Catechol 2,3-oxygenase; 2, muconic semialdehyde hydrolase; 3, 2oxopent-4-enoic acid hydrolase; 4, oxovalerate aldolase; 5, protocatechuate 4,soxygenase; 6, carboxymuconic semialdehyde hydrolase; 7, 2-oxo-4-carboxypent-4-enoic acid hydrolase; 8, oxovalerate aldolase (Gottschalk, 1979).
Monooxygenase enzymes are classified as external or internal. Monooxygenases that require a cosubstrate in addition to the substrate being hydroxylated are known as external monooxygenases. If the substrate being hydroxylated also serves as the cosubstrate, then the monooxygenase is classified as internal. Most internal monooxygenases contain flavin cofactors and are devoid of metal (Metzler, 1977). A well-
TRANSFORMATIONS OF HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES
29
characterized monooxygenase is salicylate hydroxylase. Salicylate hydroxylase is a flavoprotein that catalyzes the hydroxylation and simultaneous decarboxylation of salicylate (White-Stevens and Kamin, 1972). The enzyme contains one FAD and one polypeptide chain per 57,200 molecular weight, and exhibits a strong specificity for substrates bearing hydroxyl and carboxyl substituents at the ortho position.
D. CHLOROCATECHOL METABOLISM Chlorocatechols are generally degraded by an ortho fission pathway. Meta cleavage of chlorocatechols may result in toxic or dead-end intermediates (Reineke et al., 1982). Normal dioxygenase and cycloisomerase enzymes exhibit low activity for halogenated substrates (Schmidt and Knackmuss, 1980). However, dioxygenase and cycloisomerase enzymes that have a high affinity for chloroaromatic substrates have been identified (Dorn and Knackmuss, 1978b). In Pseudomonas sp. strain B13, catechol and chlorocatechols were assimilated via two separate othro-cleavage pathways (Reineke and Knackmus, 1988). Correspondingly, two types of isofunctional enzymes for ring fission were found. Pyrocatechase I was present in cells grown on benzoate and was highly specific for catechol. Pyrocatechase I1 was induced when S-chlorobenzoate was the growth substrate. Pyrocatechase I1 had a high activity for the chlorosubstituted benzene. Two types of isofunctional enzymes were also found for cycloisomerization of cis,cis-muconate and cis,cischloromuconate. Cycloisomerase I was highly specific for cis,cismuconate whereas cycloisomerase I1 had high activity for 2chloromuconate and 3-chloromuconate. The proposed metabolisms of 3-chlorobenzoic acid and 4-chlorocatechol are shown in Fig. 14. A number of microbes have been isolated and identified that can metabolize 2,4-D (Bollag et al., 1968; Fisher et al., 1978; Sandmann and Loos, 1988; Don and Pemberton, 1981).A proposed metabolic pathway for the degradation of 2,4-D is shown in Fig. 15. The ether linkage of 2,4-D is cleaved by enzymes present in various soil bacteria (Bollag et al., 1968). The resulting 2,4-dichlorophenol is converted to chlorocatechol by a phenol hydroxylase. VIII. Cornetabolism
The term cometabolism implies the concomitant but incomplete oxidation of a nongrowth substrate during the growth of a microorganism on a utilizable carbon and energy source. Characteristics of cometabolism are that (1)the energy derived from oxidation of the cometabolite
30
DOUGLAS J. CORK AND JAMESP. KRUEGER
HO
COOH
J
6.” c1
5.
HO COOH
c1
QooH
4
3
COOH
HC
c1 HOOC HOOC
c1-
J
5
Rc
COOH (COOS 6 CH2
, c=o /COO13
I1 HC
,/ C H 2 C=O
TCA cycle
H0OC-CH2-C0-C~-~~-~00~
FIG. 14. Proposed catabolic route of 3-chlorobenzoic acid to maleoyl acetic acid and proposed pathway for the metabolism of 4-chlorocatechol (Schmidt and Knackmuss, 1980; Chatterjee et al., 1981).
alone does not support microbial growth, (2) transformations of the cometabolite involve advantageous utilization of existing nonspecific enzyme systems, (3) utilization of the cometabolite is associated with increased oxygen consumption, and (4) production of waste products is stochiometrically related to the disappearance of the cometabolite (Hul-
TRANSFORMATIONS OF HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES
31
2.44
ac<
L-alanine
c1
HOOC
HOOC\ HOOC QIC1
"OCQ
H
O
O
:
&
j
"-'
HOOC i
COOH
HoocQo
"""'0 \;"' HOOC
\
HooC HOOC
Succinic acid
COSCoA
HOOC Chlorosuccinic a c i d
FIG.15. Pathway for the degradation of 2,4-D (Fisher et a]., 1978).
bert and Krawiec, 1977). The basis for cometabolism is the supply of energy, cofactors, or metabolites at various levels, from the transformation of one substrate, to processes such as substrate transport, enzyme biosynthesis, or functioning involved in the transformation of a second substrate (Torstensson, 1988). Cometabolism is effected by a number of bacterial genera that are widespread in natural ecosystems (Horvath and Alexander, 1970).
32
DOUGLAS J. CORK AND JAMES P. KRUEGER
Evidence is available that cometabolism may be an important phenomenon in the breakdown of herbicides and pesticides (Alexander, 1967). Halogen-substituted organic compounds have been reported to be subject to cometabolism by a variety of bacteria unable to multiply at the expense of these substrates (Smith and Cain, 1965). An example of the cometabolism of 2,3,64richlorobenzoate is shown in Fig. 16. The cometabolism of 1-and 2-chloronaphthalene, monochlorophenol, propachlor, alachlor, and cycloate has also been reported (Morris and Barnsley, 1982; Spokes and Walker, 1974; Novick and Alexander, 1985). IX. Biochemical Mechanisms of Anaerobic Aromatic Metabolism
Anaerobes may possess capacities to degrade some xenobiotic compounds that are considered recalcitrant under aerobic conditions. Numerous studies have shown that substituted benzoates, including
"0 COOH
cI CI
OH
I
clocl OH CI
FIG. 16. Possible pathways for the formation of 3,5-dichlorocatechol resulting from cometabolism of 2,3,6-trichlorobenzene (Horvath, 1971).
TRANSFORMATIONS OF HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES
33
chlorinated aromatics and nitro- and aminoaromatics, aromatic hydrocarbons, and phenolic compounds can be broken down under anaerobic conditions by bacteria (Grbic-Galic and Vogel, 1987; Knoll and Winter, 1987; Sleat and Robinson, 1984; Zeyer et al., 1986). Anaerobic conditions are created when oxygen consumption exceeds supply. Examples of anoxic ecosystems include soils with impeded drainage, soil subsurfaces, stagnant water, some groundwater, municipal landfills, sewage treatment digesters, industrial plants that produce methane from organic waste, the alimentary tract of animals, and sediments of the ocean and other bodies of water. The anaerobic metabolic fate of organic compounds and their mineralization to COz (and CH4) depend on the availability of light or inorganic electron acceptors such as NO3-, SO4’-, or COz. The anaerobic degradation of aromatic compounds can be carried out by (1) photosynthetic anaerobic metabolism, (2) metabolism by nitrate-reducing bacteria, (3) anaerobic dissimilation through sulfate respiration, (4) anaerobic fermentation, and (5) anaerobic fermentation by an undefined methanogenic consortium (Evans and Fuchs, 1988). Organic compounds can serve as the major source of electrons and carbon for the purple phototrophic, nonsulfur bacteria belonging to the family Rhodospiraceae (Berry et al., 1987). A large variety of aromatic compounds were shown to be degraded by the photosynthetic bacterium Rhodopseudomonas palustris (Harwood and Gibson, 1988). A reductive pathway for the anaerobic photocatabolism of benzoate by photosynthetic bacterium has been proposed (Fig. 17). Nitrate-reducing bacteria couple the oxidation of organic compounds with water to the exergonic reduction of nitrate via nitrate to N2 or NH3. Energy is derived mainly from electron transport phosphorylation during nitrate respiration, and cell carbon is derived from breakdown products of the organic compound. Microbial catabolism of aromatic compounds under anoxic conditions and in the presence of nitrate has been reported by several authors (Nozawa and Maruyama, 1988; Braun and Gibson, 1984; Taylor and Heeb, 1972; Zeyer et al., 1986).An example of anaerobic catabolism of aromatic compounds by denitrifying bacteria is shown in Fig. 18. Sulfate-reducing bacteria couple the oxidation of organic compounds with water to the exergonic reduction of sulfate via sulfite to sulfide. Energy is derived mainly from electron transport phosphorylation during sulfate reduction. Cell carbon is derived from breakdown products of the organic compound. Sulfate reducers are responsible for degradation of organic matter in marine environments that contain approximately 27 mM sulfate (Evans and Fuchs, 1988). High levels of sulfate may completely inhibit the degradation of haloaromatic substrates.
34
DOUGLAS J. CORK AND JAMES P. KRUEGER
0
\ COOH
$. Metabolic pool FIG.17. Proposed reductive pathway for the photocatabolism of benzoate by Rhodopseudomonas palustris (Berry et al., 1987).
However, the degradation of simple alkyl phenols occurred faster under sulfate-reducing conditions. The metabolism of p-cresol under sulfatereducing conditions involved initial hydroxylation of the aryl methyl group to form p-hydroxybenzyl alcohol. This intermediate was subsequently completely mineralized (Suflita et a]., 1988). Fermentative microorganisms derive their energy from substratelevel phosphorylation reactions. Organic compounds serve as electron donors and acceptors. Microbes have been isolated that could fermentatively degrade resorcinols (Tschech and Schink, 1985). Bacterial methanogenesis is a process common to many anoxic ecosystems. This strictly anaerobic process is associated with the decom-
TRANSFORMATIONSOF HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES
0 COOH
35
0 COOH
OH
OH
\ 0/ COOH
OH
OH
HO
OH FIG. 18. Anaerobic catabolism of aromatic compounds by the denitrifying bacteria Pseudomonas sp. strain PN-1 (Berry et al., 1987).
position of organic matter in anoxic muds and sediments, and in anaerobic sewage digesters (Zeikus, 1977). Methane bacteria are able to use only a few simple compounds to support growth: COZ + 4H2 + CH4 + 2H20 4HCOOH + CH4 + 3CO2 + 2HZO 4CHaOH + 3CH4 + COz + 2Hz0 CHJOOH + CH4 + COZ
36
DOUGLAS J. CORK AND JAMES P. KRUEGER
Because these organisms can use only simple compounds to support growth, they must rely on syntrophic associations with fermenters that degrade complex organic compounds into usable substrates. Normally, the syntrophic associations between methane bacteria and fermenters are obligatory. Some microorganisms have evolved enzyme systems that degrade benzoid structures under anaerobic conditions through reduction of the benzene ring followed by cleavage. Anaerobic hydroxylation of benzene and toluene to phenol and p-cresol has been demonstrated (Evans and Fuchs, 1985).The reactions involved are endergonic with most electron acceptors and therefore require energy or a positive electron acceptor: toluene + HzO+ p-cresol + Hz benzene + HzO+ phenol + Hz
Go = + 7 1 kJ/mol Go = + 7 3 kJ/mol
Reductive dehydroxylation or dehalogenation are often used as energyyielding reactions. A stable methanogenic bacteria consortium was enriched from sludge and was found capable of dehalogenating and often mineralizing a variety of halobenzoates to CH4 and COz.The primary degradative event was the removal of aryl halide from the aromatic ring (Suflita et a]., 1982).An anaerobic methanogenic consortium was shown to be responsible for the reductive metabolism of 2,4,5-T (Suflita et d.,1984). Dechlorination of 2,4,5-T occurred at the para position. X. Molecular Biology of Degradative Microorganisms
Plasmids are autonomous genetic elements that replicate independently of the chromosome and encode a wide range of functions in many bacteria. Many plasmid-determined bacterial characteristics are important in medicine, agriculture, and the environment. Such characteristics include (1)virulence properties and antibiotic resistance, (2) the ability of nitrogen-fixing Rhizobium strains to nodulate roots of legumes, (3) antibiotic production by Streptomycetes, and (4) the metabolism of xenobiotic compounds. Degradative plasmids represent a group of naturally occurring plasmids that code for the enzymes capable of dissimilation of complex organic compounds. Many such compounds are toxic to the microorganism. The presence and expression of genes carried by degradative plasmids allow the host cell to quickly reduce the toxic concentration of the substrate. Degradative plasmids may encode a complete degradative pathway, such as that for xylene or toluene, or partial degradative steps, such as those taking naphthalene to salicylate (Farrell and Chakrabarty,
TRANSFORMATIONSOF HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES
37
1979). Properties of some typical degradative plasmids are given in Table XIII. Genes for catabolic steps in a degradative pathway may evolve in different microorganisms followed by their assembly on the same plasmid in a single organism (Farrell and Chakrabarty, 1979). There is now evidence that transposable elements, rearrangements of genetic material, and transfers between unrelated strains can all contribute to the assembly of new degradative plasmids (Broda et al., 1981). Geneticengineering techniques have been used to construct plasmids that code for the catabolism of haloaromatic compounds (Rojo et al., 1987; Ramos et al., 1987; Reineke and Knackmuss, 1979; Reineke et a]., 1982). The evolution of new degradative capacities has also been accelerated by the use of plasmid-assisted molecular breeding (Kellogg et al., 1981). The transmissible nature of the genes specifying the dissimilation of xenobiotic compounds may lead to a rapid spread of degradative capabilities in the microbial population once a degradative plasmid has evolved (Chakrabarty, 19 72).
XI. Molecular Biology of Chloroaromatic Degradation
The molecular mechanisms of chloroaromatic compound degradation have been well defined for a number of different systems. Plasmid DNA is responsible for encoding complete degradative pathways, for compounds such as xylene or toluene, or partial degradative steps, such TABLE XI11 OF SOMETYPICAL DEGRADATIVE PLASMIDS PROPERTIES
P1asmid ____
SAL TOL PJPl PJP~ pJP3 CAM XYL pAC31 pAC25
pwwo
NAH XYL-K
Molecular mass ( x los Da)
Degradative pathway _____~
Reference
~
Sa1icy1ate Xylene/toluene 2-4-D 2,4-D 2,4-D Camphor Xylene 3,5-Dichlorobenzoate 3-Chlorobenzoate Toluene Naphthalene Xyleneltoluene
40, 48, 55 75 58 36 52 150 10 72 68 117
46 90
Chakrabarty (1976) Chakrabarty (1976) Fisher et al. (1978) Don and Pemberton (1981) Don and Pemberton (1981) Chakrabarty (1976) Chakrabarty (1976) Chatterjee and Chakrabarty (1982) Chatterjee et al. (1981) Broda et al. (1981) Chakrabarty (1982) Chakrabarty (1982)
38
DOUGLAS J. CORK AND JAMES P. KRUEGER
Chromosomal
Bsnzoala Did Dshydrogenare
6
+
-4
OH
OH
CI
K k
4-ClC
Plasmid CI
0 COOH
ds -Denel~.ans
Chromosomal? Plasmid or
[
trans .Dienslsctone
0
1[
Maleylacetate Maleylacelale Reduclase
% :;c m :(H i3 - Keloadipale
'I
FIG. 19. Mechanism of 3-chlorobenzoate degradation in Pseudomonos sp. (Chakrabarty et al., 1989).
TRANSFORMATIONSOF HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES
39
as the conversion of naphthalene to salicylate (Farrell and Chakrabarty, 1979). One of the most complete outlines of the genetic organization and regulation of chloroaromatic metabolism has come from studies of the dissimilation of 3-chlorobenzoate (3-Cba), 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid, and 2,4,5-trichlorophenoxyaceticacid (Chakrabarty et al., 1989). The latter two phenoxy alkanoic acids have long been used as herbicides. All three compounds are similar by the presence of a carboxy moiety and chloride ions. The degradation of 3-chlorobenzoate employs the use of plasmid-encoded, as well as chromosome-encoded, enzymes (Fig. 19). As documented previously, the initial step involves the use of a dioxygenase, which is subsequently followed by ortho cleavage and ultimate conversion to succinate. Subcloning experiments have shown that plasmid pAC27 encodes a chlorocatechol degradative pathway that consists of three enzymes: (1) pyrocatechase 11, (2) muconatelactonizing enzyme 11, and (3) hydrolase 11. All three genes are clustered on a 4.2-kb BglII fragment (Fig. 20). 2,4-D degradation has been delineated in Alicaligenes eutrophus (Don et al., 1985).The complete mechanism is shown in Fig. 21. The initial reaction is catalyzed by a monooxygenase and is followed by a hydroxylase-mediated catalysis. These steps are chromosomally mediated. Subsequent steps have been shown to be plasmid encoded. Ring breakage occurs via the ortho-cleavage pathway. Physical mapping of this plasmid has been established by transposon mutagenesis (Weightmann et al., 1984). Degradation of 2,4,5-T is accomplished by chromosomal genes of P. cepacia strain ACllOO (Sangodkar et al., 1988). Through a series of enzymatic steps, 2,4,5-T is completely mineralized to COz. In an effort to delineate this
&A
=+.
I.
BgSc
l Bg
l B
- clc B
(ORF3)
.I 1.
HS
I
I
P
P
ck D
I S
I Bg
FIG. 20. Organization of plasmid pAC27-encoded chlorocatechol degradative (clc) genes involved in the dissimilation of 3-chlorobenzoate. Steps A, B, and D are mediated by clc A, clc B, and clc D, respectively, encoding pyrocatechase 11, muconate-lactonizing enzyme 11, and hydrolase 11. The location of the promoter is indicated by the arrow. The initiation codon of clc B overlaps with the stop codon of clc A. The restriction sites are designated as follows: Bg, BgllII; Sc, SacII; B, BarnHI; H, HindIII; S, Salk P, PstI (Chakrabarty et al., 1989).
DOUGLAS J. CORK AND JAMESP. KRUEGER
40 OCH-COOH IfdA 2,4-D
.&aE;lLe OH
OH
(&&ichlorccatechol
HYDROXYIASE CI MONOOXYGENASE CI 2,4-D 2,CDichlorophenol
CI
2,4-Dichloro- cis, cismuconate CI
’COOH trsn~CHLORODIENELACTONE ISOMERASE
0
1
tfdE
Chlorornaleylacetate
T
I
CHLORODIENELACTONE
‘ P 2 C O O H
0
p-Ketoadipate
FIG. 21. Proposed pathway for the degradation of 2,4-Dby Alcaligenes eutrophus JMP134(pJP4)(Don et a]., 1985).
operon, transposon mutagenesis with Tn5 was used to generate mutants blocked in 2,4,5-T degradation. Using this technique, a mutant (PT88) was isolated. This mutant was capable of producing a bright red compound in growth medium in the presence of glucose and 2,4,5-T. Subsequently, culture supernatants were analyzed by gas chromatography and mass spectroscopy to reveal 5-chloro-2-hydroxy hydroquinone [CHQJ These and other experiments led to the conclusion that CHQ
TRANSFORMATIONSOF HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES
41
must be an obligatory intermediate of 2,4,5-T degradation. When mobilizing a cosmid-clone bank of the ACllOO genome into PT88 (CHQ-), a hybrid cosmid (pUS1) carrying a 25-kb insert was discovered. This insert complemented the CHQ- phenotype of PT88. Southern hybridization experiments have shown this 25-kb insert to have a chromosomal origin (Fig. 22).
pus1
c1
-
-
5 - CHLORO 2 - HYDROXY 1.4 BENZOQUINONE (RED)
FIG.22. Genetics of degradation of 2,4,5-T in AC1100. Broken arrows indicate unidentified conversions. Bold arrow indicates the nonenzymatic reaction occurring because of a block in CHQ metabolism in PT88.Hatched bars represent cloned ACllOO chromosomal DNA complementing PT88.Arrows in PUS1 and pUS1029 show the direction of transcription of chq gene(s). Hyphenated bar in PUS1029 shows the deletion. The restriction sites are designated as follows: B, BarnHI, Bg, BflII; C, CIaI; H, HindIII; P, PstI; R, EcoRI; S , SalI; X, XbaI; Xh, XhoI (Sangodkar eta]., 1988).
42
DOUGLAS J. CORK AND JAMES P. KRUEGER
Plasmid-encoded enzymes have been implicated in the breakdown of the herbicide dicamba (3,6-dichloro-2-methoxybenzoicacid) by Pseudomonas strains. This assertion has been substantiated by the instability of the dicamba-degrading phenotype when these strains are grown in rich medium in the absence of dicamba. In addition, induced loss of the phenotype occurs when strains are treated with mitomycin C (Krueger, 1989). This phenomenon was observed by Chakrabarty et al. (1989) with 2,4,5-T-degrading P. cepacia. In soil treatment studies, AClOO cells with 2,4,5-T-degradative abilities rapidly disappeared from the soil samples once the 2,4,5-T levels diminished. Plasmid-borne phenotypes are often lost through segregational instability in the absence of the appropriate selection pressure. OF Pseudomonas GENES IN THE Escherichia CLONING coli VECTOR,pUC
In order to delineate the genes responsible for chloroaromatic degradation, researchers have used a variety of cloning vehicles. For cloning large inserts, bacteriophage vectors such as the A phage (Charon 4A) may be used. With this technique, inserts of up to 7-20 kb may be cloned without disrupting the viability of the phage. Cosmid vectors allow the insertion of up to 45-kb fragments, with the added advantages of phage packaging and propagation and plasmidlike replication. The genetic delineation of 2,4,5-T degradation in P. cepacia has been achieved through the use of the broad-host-range cosmid vector pCP13 (Chakrabarty et al., 1989). When smaller fragments are to be cloned, commercial plasmid preparations are ideal. One such vector, pUC, has been used to study several genes in the polychlorinated biphenyl degradation pathway found in a strain of P. cepacia (Khan and Walia, 1990). This group of plasmids, developed from the single-stranded bacteriophage M13, provides easy selection of recombinant Escherichia coli clones (Fig. 23). Selection of recombinant clones is twofold: First, the presence of the 0-lactamase gene codes for the enzyme, which is able to break down the R-lactam ring of penicillin analogs, namely, ampicillin. Thus, only transformed E. coli cells containing the plasmid will be viable in the presence of this antibiotic. Second, the polylinker region of pUC is located within the lac z gene of the lactose operon. The lac z gene of pUC codes for only a portion of the active R-galactosidase enzyme. When present in an E. coli host (strains JM103 or JM101) containing the AM15 (a partial deletion of the lac z gene) mutation on the F’ episome, complementation of both protein products results in a fully active R-galactosidase molecule. Upstream of lac z in pUC is the promoter/operator region
43
TRANSFORMATIONSOF HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES Taq I
coding sequence for B-galactor idarc
Mae I1 Hae I1
Teq I
ATG ACC ATG ATT ACG M T KC(xiG GGA T CCG K GACCTG CAG CCA AGClTG G€A CTG
Mlfipll&X€13
ATG ACC ATG A T ACG CCA AGCTTG GGC TGC AGG TCG ACT CTA GAG GAT C C c m (irr,AGCTCG M T TCA C K G@2
Lmm
PSI
s.11 Aal
h n
f i i
A
Brmm
SIII
~
I
Srml
FIG.23. The multiple cloning sites of M13mp7,8,9,10,11and pUC 7,8,9,12,13 (Messing, 1983).
u
UHrm
Xrml
44
DOUGLAS J. CORK AND JAMES P. KRUEGER
of the lactose operon. The above-mentioned host strain also contains the lacIQ mutation, resulting in the overproduction of lactose repressor protein. Thus, the operon may be induced by lactose or a lactose analog (IPTG).In the presence of such as isopropyl-8-D-thiogalactopyranoside (X-gal), IPTG and 5-bromo-4-chloro-3-indoyl-R-~-galactopyranoside host cells containing pUC reveal a blue color (a colored product from X-gal cleavage) upon colony formation on Luria broth (LB) plates at 37°C. When, however, the insert is cloned within this polylinker sequence, disruption of the 8-galactosidase-coding sequence results, yielding an inactive portion of R-galactosidase. Recombinant clones then are distinguished from nonrecombinant transformants by their lack of blue color. Due to its inducible characteristic, pUC plasmids may also be used as expression vectors (Steele, 1983). A fragment cloned within the lac z region may be induced to form a fusion polypeptide. A limitation to the use of these plasmids is that the lac regulatory region does not contain the UV 5 mutation, and is therefore subject to catabolite repression in the presence of glucose (Messing, 1983). In order to remedy this problem, Messing (1983) developed a growth medium without glucose, which thereby allows induction of the desired gene products. XII. Dicamba Biodegradation: A Case Study
Twenty of the leading United States pesticide manufacturers are listed in Table XIV. Structures of some important herbicides are shown in Fig. 24, and some important physical and chemical properties of dicamba are given in Table XV. Dicamba is used as a pre- and postemergent herbicide for the control of annual and perennial broadleaf weeds and several grassy weeds. Dicamba is similar in herbicidal action to phenoxy alkanoic acid herbicides, such as 2,443, but belongs to the class known as the benzoics. The specific mode of action of dicamba is unknown. The symptomatology produced (abnormalities in flowering and in leaf and stem formation) indicates that dicamba acts to limit the transport or action of auxins in plants. Resistant plant species absorb, translocate, and metabolize dicamba, whereas susceptible species cannot easily do so. Dicamba is synthesized in a series of reactions starting with 1,2&trichlorobenzene (Fig. 25) Dicamba is chemically stable and there is considerable evidence suggesting that the degradation of dicamba in aerobic soils and water is biologically mediated (Harger,1975; Smith, 1973; Smith and Cullimore, 1975; Scifres et al., 1973).Aerobic soil metabolism studies have demonstrated that dicamba is metabolized to C02 and that 3,6-dichlorosalicylate is the major metabolite (Harger, 1975; Smith, 1973). However, the
TRANSFORMATIONSOF HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES
45
TABLE XIV TWENTY LEADING UNITED STATESPESTICIDE MANUFACTURERSO Abbott Laboratories American Cyanamid Company BASF Wyandotte Corporation Chevron Chemical Company Ciba-Geigy Corporation Dow Chemical Company E.I. du Pont de Nemours and Company Elanco Products Company Fermenta Plant Protection Company FMC Corporation Hoechst-Roussel Company ICI Americas Inc. Mobay Chemical Corporation Monsanto Company Nor-Am Chemical Company Rhone-Poulenc Inc. Rohm and Hass Company Sandoz Crop Protection Corporation Uniroyal Inc. Valent USA Corporation From Crop Protection Chemicals Reference (1989).
TABLE XV PHYSICAL AND CHEMICAL PROPERTIES OF DICAMBA Empirical formula: Molecular weight: Physical state: Color: Odor: Melting point: Boiling point: Specific gravity: Vapor pressure (25°C): Dissociation constant: PK~: OctanoUwater coefficient: Flash point: Hydrolysis: Oxidation: Strong acid: Strong base: Solubility of dicamba acid (gramdliter of water at 25%): Solubility of dicamba Na salt (grandliter of water at 25°C): Solubility of dicamba K salt (gramslliter of water at 25'c):
CBHBCIZO~ 221.04 Crystalline solid White Odorless 114-116°C Decomposes at >200°C 1.57 3.41 x mm Hg 1.16 X lo-' 1.94 0.1 150°C Stable Stable Resistant Resistant 6.5 360 480
46
DOUGLAS J. CORK AND JAMES P. KRUEGER
CI CH,
METOLACHLOR
CGN
l
2,4-D
CH,OCH,NCCH,CI
I
OH
BROMOXYNIL
ALACHLOR
FIG.24. Structures of some important herbicides.
identification of biological factors involved in the metabolism of dicamba has not been accomplished. There are no previous reports in the literature on the metabolism of dicamba by a pure culture of microorganisms. Increased bacterial growth and increased O2 consumption have been reported when soil organisms capable of growth on o-anisate were grown on dicamba in the presence of this compound (Ferrer et a]., 1985). However, no analytical data on the disappearance of dicamba were presented. The biological degradation of dicamba has been investigated and documented by Krueger et al. (1989, 1990, 1991; Krueger, 1989). As mentioned previously, this chloroaromatic compound affects the growth of annual and perennial broadleaf weeds, as well as several grassy weeds. Unfortunately, dicamba affects the growth of certain commerical crops, namely, soybean. Using I4C-labeled dicamba, Krueger demonstrated the ability of Pseudomonas species to completely miner-
47
TRANSFORMATIONSOF HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES
6+ @ 6 3,4-dichlorophenol
CI
CI
distilled off
-
CI
pressure
CI
pressure OH', MeOH
Q: J COOH
3.6-dichlorosalicylate
CI
COOH
dicamba
cl&~H~=-~ OCH3
CI
FIG.25. Chemical synthesis of dicamba.
alize dicamba to ' * C 0 2 . Through thin-layer chromatography and highpressure liquid chromatography, Krueger and Cork proposed a pathway for microbe-mediated dicamba degradation (Fig. 26). By the structure of the intermediates and the absence of anaerobic metabolism of dicamba, the mechanism of dicamba degradation is thought to be similar to those previously discussed.
48
DOUGLAS J, CORK AND JAMES P. KRUEGER
co <x)(IH
+ g . - - + c Q 2
OH
0
cl
FIG.26. Proposed pathway for the degradation of dicamba (Krueger, 1989).
Bacteria capable of utilizing the herbicide dicamba as a sole carbon source were obtained by enrichment from soil and water with a long history of dicamba exposure. Three strains that grew rapidly in liquid medium containing dicamba were identified by biochemical tests and by GC analysis of whole cell fatty acid profiles as follows: strain DI-6, Pseudomonas sp.; strain DI-7, Moraxella sp.; and strain DI-8, Pseudomoms sp. The organisms isolated that degrade dicamba represent genera that are commonly found in water, soil, and sewage and are often responsible for the decomposition of man-made chemicals in the environment. Members of the genus Pseudomonas are known to possess a wide range of degradative activities and have the ability to develop new degradative activities. Long-term intermittent exposure (approximately 25 years) of microbes to dicamba in the storm water retention ponds at the dicamba manufacturing facility appears to have provided the selective conditions necessary to develop dicamba-degrading capabilities. An excellent example of the development and spread of herbicide-degrading activity has been demonstrated for phenoxyacetic acid herbicides. A large number of the different genera that have been isolated are capable of degrading these herbicides (Helling et al., 1981).
TRANSFORMATIONS OF HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES
49
XIII. Growth Kinetics in Liquid Culture
When dicamba-degrading organisms (strains DI-6, DI-7, and DI-8) were grown in liquid media containing 1000 pg/ml dicamba, an average of 97% of the chloride was released after 30 hours (Table XIV). The absorbance at 274 nm (wavelength of maximum absorbance for dicamba) decreased to zero. Chloride release and the decrease in absorbance at 274 nm indicate complete removal of dicamba. Radioassay of the media indicates that up to 80% of the substrate carbon is mineralized to COz (Fig. 27). The substrate carbon remaining in the media was probably incorporated into cell biomass because the cell number increased (Table XVI). Initial reactions in the metabolism of dicamba by microorganisms and subsequent increases in biomass require an expenditure of energy by the microbe. The evolution of l4COZfrom phenyl-labeled [14C]dicambasuggests that dicamba is fragmented to compounds that are channeled into oxidative cycles (the Krebs cycle) from which the organism can derive useful energy. Mineralization of 2,4-D to COz, with a corresponding increase in biomass, has also been demonstrated. Up to 40% of the substrate radiocarbon from 2,4-D was mineralized to COz in 20 hours. (Amy et a]., 1985). 80'
70
..
60. m
250. C
8
a 30.
....QY, ,.,-0. .........
2010.
6
.... ........... ........ ............... Control .................. 5....... ...A/
.'
..........
20 30 Time (Hours) FIG.27. Removal of soluble 14C from liquid medium containing 1000 pg/ml (14C]dicamba by three dicamba-degradingstrains and an uninoculated control. 0
10
DOUGLAS J. CORK AND JAMES P. KRUEGER
50
TABLE XVI GROWTH KINETICSOF DICAMBA-DEGRADING ORGANISMS I N LIQUIDCULTURE CONTAINING 1000 pg/ml OF (14C]DICAMBA
Strain DI-6
DI-7
DI-8
Time (hours) 0 6 24 30 0 6 24 30 0 6 24 30
Viable cells perm1
2.1 x 7.5 x 1.3 x 6.8 X 7.8 x 8.5 X 9.8 X 1.0x
lo8 108 109
lo9 107
lo8 10’ 109
1.ox lo8
1.4 X lo8 1.1x 109 1.0x 109
Absorbance (274 nm)
Dicamba (pg/ml)”
2.36 2.38 NDc ND 2.38 2.56 ND ND 2.43 2.56
818 828 <10
ND ND
Based on absorbance at 274 nm. Based on chloride release. ND, Not detectable; limit of detection = 10 j&d
Total chloride (pg/ml)
Removal
0 26 325 334 0 15 296 315 0 11 151 290
0 8.1 101.2 104.0 0 4.7 92.2 98.1 0 3.4 47.0 90.3
(%lb
dicamba.
A. EFFECTOF DICAMBACONCENTRATION
The dicamba-degrading strain DI-6 (Pseudomonas sp.) was inoculated into media containing 100, 500, 600, 800, 1000, or 1500 pg/ml of [14C]dicamba.The media were radioassayed and cell dry weights were determined at 0, 6, 16, 20, 24, and 30 hours. A comparison of dicamba degradation kinetics at different dicamba concentrations is shown in of 0.1325 ocTable XVII. The maximum specific growth rate (pmax) curred at a concentration of 1160 pg/ml dicamba. One-half the maximum specific growth rate is 0.0663, which corresponds to a Ks concentration of 750 pg/ml of dicamba (Fig. 28). The maximum dicamba mineralization rate of 24.63 pg/ml/hour occurred at 1000 pglml dicamba (Table XVII), Increasing concentrations of dicamba prolonged the initial lag phase. Other authors have also observed a prolonged lag phase with cells grown on increasing concentrations of chlorobenzene (Reineke and Knackmuss, 1984). The specific growth rate of strain DI-6 decreased when the dicamba concentration was increased from 1000 to 1500 pg/ml. The hyperbolic Monod function does not describe this growth rate and substrate relationship for toxic or inhibitory compounds. The Haldane modification
51
TRANSFORMATIONSOF HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES TABLE XVII COMPAMSON OF DICAMBA DEGRADATION KINETICSAT DIFFERENT DICAMBA CONCENTRATIONS IN LIQUID CULTURE Dicamba concentration (CLg/ml)
Dicamba mineralization (pg/ml/hour)
Specific growth rate
Doubling time (hours)
100 500 600 800 1000 1500
0.25 5.25 10.75 24.63 42.75 21.25
0 0.0347 0.0385 0.0578 0.1386 0.0815
ND" 20 18 12 5 8.5
(I
Lag phase (hours) ND 4 5 5 13 15
No doubling in cell dry weight detected.
+
0.1L h a x
0.1: 0.12 0.1 1 0.1 t
- 0.09 5
(u
c
2m 3
+
0.Of 0.07 1
+
.
0 . 0 0 y 100 300
,
..
500
. 700
kS
- 1-1-1-1 900 110(
1300
1500
Substrate Concentration (pg/rnl)
FIG.28. Growth kinetics of dicamba-degradingstrain DI-6 on dicamba liquid medium.
52
DOUGLAS J. CORK AND JAMES P. KRUEGER
of the Monod equation has been used to describe the toxic effects of pentachlorophenol (Klecka and Maier, 1985). The Haldane modification is as follows:
+ + S2/Ki)
p = pmax(s/KS S
where Ki is the inhibition constant. The sharp decline in specific growth rate from 1000 to 1500 pg/ml dicamba is not described by this equation. More data at higher concentrations are needed to further evaluate this equation.
B. DEPENDENCE OF ACTIVITY ON pH Dicamba-degradingcultures (DI-6,DI-7 and DI-8) were used to inoculate liquid media containing 1000 pg/ml [14C]dicambaat pH 4.0, 5.0, 6.0, 7.0, and 8.0. Cultures were incubated at 30°C on a shaker and aliquots of each medium were radioassayed at zero time and at 24 hours. The effect of pH on dicamba-degrading activity in liquid culture is shown in Table XVIII.All three organisms removed approximately the same amount of substrate 14C at pH 7.0 and 8.0. The ability to remove substrate I4C decreases when pH is decreased. However, strain DI-8 was TABLE XVIII ACTIVITY OF DICAMBA DEGRADERS AT VARIOUS pH VALUES IN 1000 p g h l [ ''C]DICAMBA LIQUID MEDIUM
Strain DI-6
Initial PH 4.0 5.0
6.0
DI-7
DI-8
7.0 8.0 4.0 5.0 6.0
Substrate carbon removed after 24 hours
(%I 1.6 21.5 38.9
61.6 61.1 0.0 1.0 37.0
7.0
70.0
8.0 4.0 5.0 6.0 7.0 8.0
66.0 31.8 31.0 30.7
65.6 66.0
TRANSFORMATIONS OF HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES
53
able to remove 31.8% of the substrate 14C even at pH 4.0. The ability of these organisms to degrade dicamba over a wide range of pH values may make them useful for removing dicamba from a wide variety of aquatic and soil environments. C. EFFECTOF TEMPERATURE Dicamba-degrading strains DI-6, DI-7, and DI-8 were inoculated into media containing 1000 pg/ml [14C]dicamba.Cultures were incubated at 5,15, 25,30, 35, and 40°C and the media were radioassayed at 0,6, 24, 30, and 48 hours. The removal rates of dicamba at those temperatures are compared in Fig. 29. The optimum temperature for removal of dicamba for all three strains is 30°C. Strain DI-6 had a wider temperature
+
C+.rin
Temperature (“c)
FIG.29. Rate of dicamba mineralizationby dicamba-degradingorganisms as a function of temperature.
54
DOUGLAS J. CORK AND JAMES P. KRUEGER
activity range, as the removal rates were similar at 25 and 30°C. Dicamba removal rates were low at 5 and 15°C. However, organisms were not killed at low temperatures, as dicamba removal was evident when the temperature was brought to 30°C after 30 hours. All strains were killed when incubated at 40°C.
D. GROWTHKINETICSIN SOIL Kenyon loam soil [Table XIX) was treated with ['4C]dicamba to yield a concentration of 3.4 pg/gram dicamba in moist soil. This is equivalent to an application rate of approximately 2 lb/acre when incorporated into two inches of soil. Treated soil (50 g dry equivalents) was added to serum bottles and inoculated with strain DI-6, DI-7, or DI-8. Bottles were sealed and incubated in the dark at 25°C. At 1 , 3 , 7 , 1 4 ,and 2 1 days all samples were flushed with COz-freeair. After 2 1 days, Exhaust air was bubbled through 1.5 NKOH to trap 14C02. soil was analyzed for dicamba and 3,6-dichlorosalicylic acid according to the Sandoz Crop Protection Corporation GC residue method AM0766.
An average of 63.7% of the dicamba applied to soil was metabolized to CO, in the inoculated soils, compared to only 2.2% in the uninoculated soils after 2 1 days (Fig. 30). The highest degradation rates occurred between zero time and 1 day in all of the inoculated treatments. GC
analysis indicates nearly complete removal (98% or greater) of dicamba
TABLE XIX PROPERTIES OF KENYON LOAMSOIL Soil property evaluated Organic carbon (a/") Organic matter (%) (calculated from % organic carbon] Cation exchange capacity (mEqi100 g) pH (in deionized water] 75% of 0.33-bar level (grams of water/100 g dry soil] Bulk density (g/cm3) Sand(%) Silt (Yo) Clay [%I Textural class Bacteridgram of soil Fungilgram of soil Actinomycetes/gram of soil
Result 2.2 3.8 20.4 6.2 24.2
1.6 34.0 41.0
25.0
Loam 6.3 x 105 3.2 x lo4 2.6 X lo5
TRANSFORMATIONSOF HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES
55
70
Strain #6 Strain #8 Strain #7
60
50
d" 0 0
c
40
P
-N .-
EJ a, C
5 c
30
C a,
2 a, a
20
10
0 10
20
Time (Days) FIG. 30. Mineralization of ['4C]dicamba to ''C02 in soil inoculated with dicambadegrading organisms.
and greatly reduced accumulation of 3,6-dichlorosalicylic acid after 2 1 days (Table XX). In the uninoculated control, 66.2% of the applied dicamba remained and the concentration of 3,6-dichlorosalicylic acid was equivalent to 19.7% of the applied dicamba. Dicamba mineralization by microorganisms in soil might also be influenced by the soil composition, nutrient levels, percentage of organic matter, and temperature.
DOUGLAS J. CORK AND JAMES P. KRUEGER
56
TABLE XX GC ANALYSIS OF DICAMBA-TREATED SOIL 21 DAYSAFTERINOCULATION WITH DICAMBA-DEGRADING ORGANISMS~ Dicamba (&gram moist soil)
3,6-Dichlororsalicylic acid (pg/gram moist soil)
DI-6
NDb
0.014
DI-7
0.019 0.067 2.250
0.075 0.260 0.670
Strain
DI-8 Uninoculated a
Initial concentrationof dicarnba was 3.4 Fg/g of moist soil. Not detectable:limit of detection for dicarnba and 3,6-dichlorosalicylic acid was 0.01p g / g each.
E. GROWTHCHAMBER STUDY Pots of Wisconsin clay loam soil (Table XXI) were treated with dicamba to yield the following concentrations (pounddacre): 0,0.5, 4.0, and 8.0. Treated soils were incubated at 15'C for 2 weeks. After 2 weeks, pots from each treatment rate were inoculated with strain DI-6, DI-7, or DI-8. Pea seeds (a dicamba-susceptible plant species) were planted in pots immediately after inoculation and 2 and 5 days after inoculation. After 2 1 days, pea seedlings were harvested and weighed. The concentration of dicamba in soil was determined by high-pressure liquid chromatography (HPLC) analysis of the soil at inoculation and at 1 and 5 days after inoculation (Krueger et af., 1991). TABLE XXI PROPERTIES OF WISCONSIN CLAYLOAMSOIL Soil property evaluated
Result
Organic carbon (yo] Organic matter (%) [calculated from % organic carbon) pH (in deionized water) pH (in 0.01M CaCl2] 75% of 0.33-bar level (grams of water/100 g dry soil) Sand (%) Silt (%) Clay (YO) Textural class Bacteria/gram of soil Fungi/gram of soil Actinomycetes/gram of soil
4.6
8.0 6.8
6.5 20.7 67 0
33 Clay loam 7.6 X lo6 4.0 x 104 8.4 x 105
57
TRANSFORMATIONSOF HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES
Inoculation of dicamba-treated soil with dicamba-degrading organisms resulted in a higher percentage emergence and increased total pea seedling weight for all treatment groups (Tables XXII-XXIV). Pea seedlings planted immediately after inoculation had significantly higher weights over the uninoculated controls at the 0.5- and 4.0-lb/acre rates. Pea seedlings planted 2 or 5 days after inoculation had significantly higher weights over the uninoculated controls at all rates. Some treatments at the 0-lb/acre rate showed lower than expected percentage emergence. Factors such as seed quality and age, position of the pot in the incubator, temperature variation in the incubator, and shading may all contribute to the variability in these types of experiments. Though the general trends support the stated conclusions, more replicates are needed to confirm these trends. Dicamba-degrading organisms were able to decrease the herbicidal activity of dicamba quickly at all concentrations to a level wherein pea seedlings could survive. Any alteration in the structure of dicamba will decrease its herbicidal activity, so extensive metabolism is not neces-
TABLE XXII
WEIGHTSOF PEASEEDLINGS PLANTED IN DICAMBA-TREATED SOILIMMEDIATELY AFTER INOCULATIONWITH DICAMBA-DEGRADING ORGANISMS" Weight of roots (grams)
Total weight (grams)
Emergence
Strain
Weight of leaves and stems (grams1
DI-6 DI-7 DI-8 Uninoculated DI-6 DI-7 DI-8 Uninoculated DI-6 DI-7 DI-8 Uninoculated DI-6 DI-7 DI-8 Uninoculated
2.22 2.22 2.78 1.84 1.74 2.35 2.18 0 0 0 0.43 0 0 0 0 0
3.18 2.69 2.59 2.36 1.81 2.45 2.56 1.08 1.17 1.17 1.98 1.18 1.07 0.64 0.82 0.62
5.40 4.91 5.37 4.20 3.55 4.80 4.74 1.08 1.17 1.17 2.41 1.18 1.07 0.64 0.82 0.62
88 100 100 63 63 100 100 0 25 13 38 13 25 0 0 0
Dicamba concentration (lb/acre) 0
0.5
4.0
8.0
(YO)
'Soil inoculated with dicarnba degraders 14 days after dicamba treatment; pea seedlings harvested 2 1 days after inoculation.
58
DOUGLAS J. CORK AND JAMES P. KRUEGER TABLE XXIII WEIGHTS OF PEA SEEDLINGS PLANTED IN DICAMBA-TREATED SOIL 2 DAYSAFTER INOCULATION WITH DICAMBA-DEGRADING ORGANISMS'
Dicamba concentration (lb/acre) 0
0.5
4.0
8.0
Weight of roots (grams)
Total weight [grams)
Emergence
Strain
Weight of leaves and stems (grams)
DI-6 DI-7 DI-8 Uninoculated DI-6 DI-7 DI-8 Uninoculated DI-6 DI-7 DI-8 Uninoculated DI-6 DI-7 DI-8 Uninoculated
1.54 1.73 2.69 1.60 1.35 2.08 1.92 0.11 1.15 1.76 1.98 0 0.99 1.67 1.61 0
2.55 2.39 3.02 2.16 1.70 2.70 2.24 1.20 2.70 2.46 2.51 1.61 2.22 1.48 2.11 0.85
4.09 4.12 5.71 3.76 3.05 4.78 4.16 1.31 3.85 4.22 4.49 1.61 3.21 3.15 3.72 0.85
50 25 100 50 50 100 100 25 75 100 100 0 50 100 50 0
(%I
Soil inoculated with dicamba degraders 14 days after dicamba treatment; pea seedlings harvested 19 days after inoculation.
sary. Organisms were able to survive and have activity in the presence of naturally occurring microfauna in a soil and at a temperature at which dicamba persistence is sometimes a problem. Dicamba-degrading organisms may be useful as a crop inoculum to protect previously susceptible crops and therefore increase the range of crops on which dicamba can be used. HPLC analysis for dicamba confirms that dicamba is rapidly removed in inoculated soil at all concentrations (Table XXV). The half-life of dicamba in soil was reduced dramatically (<1 day) at all concentrations. The half-life of dicamba in other aerobic soil studies, wherein no inoculation was used, has been reported to vary from 17 to 45 days, depending on the soil tested (Smith, 1974).
F. FIELDSTUDY A field study was conducted at a typical midwestern field site located in northern Illinois. Soil characteristics are presented in Table XXVI. Each of the following amounts (pounddacre) of dicamba were sprayed
59
TRANSFORMATIONS OF HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES TABLE XXIV WEIGHTS OF PEASEEDLINGS PLANTED I N DICAMBA-TREATED SOIL5 DAYSAFTER INOCULATIONWITH DICAMBA-DEGRADING ORGANISMS"
Dicamba concentration (lblacre) 0
0.5
4.0
8.0
Weight of roots (grams)
Total weight (grams)
Emergence
Strain
Weight of leaves and stems (grams)
DI-6 DI-7 DI-8 Uninoculated DI-6 DI-7 DI-8 Unin ocu 1ated DI-6 DI-7 DI-8 Uninoculated DI-6 DI-7 DI-8 Uninoculated
2.07 1.28 1.37 2.06 2.44 2.36 1.38 0.83 1.38 1.59 0 0 1.04 1.80 2.02 0
2.71 1.66 2.08 2.71 3.18 2.36 1.79 2.03 2.51 1.99 1.90 1.34 1.95 2.08 2.62 1.13
4.78 2.94 3.45 4.77 5.62 4.72 3.17 2.86 3.89 3.58 1.90 1.34 2.99 3.88 4.64 1.13
75 50 75 100 100 100 75 50 75 75 25 0 25 75 100 0
(%I
'Soil inoculated with dicamba degraders 14 days after dicamba treatment;pea seedlings harvested 16 days after inoculation.
TABLE XXV FIRST-ORDER RATE CONSTANTS AND HALF-LIVES OF DICAMBA I N SOILINOCULATED WITH DICAMBA-DEGRADING ORGANISMS Initial dicamba concentration (lb/acre) 0.5
4.0
8.0
Strain
First-order rate constant
tl/z (days)
Uninoculated DI-6 DI-7 DI-8 Uninoculated DI-6 DI-7 DI-8 Uninoculated DI-6 DI-7 DI-8
0.17 0.96 0.97 2.93 0.30 1.55 1.32 1.43 0.33 1.52 19.36 1.31
4.0 0.7 0.7 0.2 2.3 0.4 0.5 0.4 2.1 0.4 0.1 0.5
60
DOUGLAS J. CORK AND JAMESP. KRUEGER TABLE XXVI PROPERTIES OF KANESVILLE LOAMSOIL Soil property evaluated
Result
Organic carbon (Yo] Organic matter (Yo) (calculated from Yo organic carbon] Cation exchange capacity (mEq/100 g] pH (in deionized water) 75% of 0.33-bar level (grams of water/100 g dry soil) Bulk density (g/cm3) Sand (Yo) Silt (Yo] Clay (%I Textural class
2.6 4.4 22.9 6.6 24.0 1.3 24.0 50.0 26.0 Loam
onto the entire surface of 12 plots each (2 x 4 feet plots): 0,0.5,2.0, and 8.0. All plots were allowed to incubate 2 weeks to simulate a preemergent treatment. After 2 weeks, plots from each treatment rate were inoculated with strain DI-6, DI-7, and DI-8. Organisms were incorporated into the soil by tilling the plots to a 5-inch depth. One row of soybeans (dicamba-susceptible species) was planted in each plot at 0,7, and 32 days after inoculation. Plants were grown to maturity and harvested. The number of plants and their weights and lengths were recorded. Dicamba-degrading organisms were able to protect soybeans planted in dicamba-treated soil from dicamba injury in field test plots. Differences were most dramatic in the 8.0-lbiacre rate in which the uninoculated plots did not show any germination or subsequent stand of soybeans (Table XXVII). In this treatment, strain DI-6 provided the greatest dissipation of dicamba as measured by the soybean bioassay. The lack of significant differences at the lower concentration rates was probably due to higher than average rainfall. Heavy rain may have leached dicamba away from the root zone and lowered the dicamba concentration below an effective level at the lower rates, thereby decreasing treatment differences. Dicamba degradative activity in the field represents a significant step toward the practical application of dicamba-degrading organisms. Degradation occurred in a typical midwestern agricultural soil (Kanesville loam) exposed to natural air and soil temperatures in the presence of naturally occurring soil microfauna. Results of this field study indicate that dicamba-degrading organisms have a strong potential for use as a crop inoculum.
TRANSFORMATIONSOF HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES
61
TABLE XXVII HEIGHT AND WEIGHT OF MATURE SOYBEANS PLANTED IN SOIL TREATED WITH 8.0 Ib/acre DICAMBA Average weight
Strain
Average number of stemsa
(lb)
Average stem height (inches)
Uninoculated DI-6 DI-7 DI-8 Uninoculated DI-6 DI-7 DI-8 Uninoculated DI-6 DI-7 DI-8
0 3 0 0 0 5 2 0 0 8 3 2
0 2.1 0 0 0 3.4 0.1 0 0 1.6 0.1 0.1
0 32.58 0 0 0 27.70 3.22 0 0 16.38 5.27 5.50
Days after inoculation 0
7
32
Average of three plots.
The ability of strains DI-6, DI-7, and DI-8 to rapidly mineralize a wide range of dicamba concentrations over a range of pH and temperature values in liquid medium demonstrates their potential for use in spill cleanup. All three strains were able to mineralize up to 80% of the substrate carbon in dicamba to COz in 2 1 days. No metabolites of environmental concern were formed. Strain DI-6 mineralized 1000 pg/ml dicamba at a rate of 24.63 pg/ml/hour. The maximum specific growth rate of 0.1386 occurred at 1160 pg/ml dicamba and the K, concentration was 750 pg/ml dicamba. Because these organisms are the result of natural selection and adaptation, their release into the environment should not be a concern. Dicamba-degrading strains were able to metabolize dicamba in several different soils in the presence of naturally occurring soil organisms. Strains DI-6, DI-7, and DI-8 showed the ability to rapidly mineralize dicamba in Kenyon loam soil. An average of 63.7% of the dicamba applied to soil was metabolized to COz in the inoculated soil, compared to only 2.2% in the uninoculated soil after 21 days. Greatly reduced concentrations of 3,6-dichlorosalicylate were evident in inoculated soils. The half-life of dicamba in Wisconsin clay loam soil treated with 0.5, 4.0, or 8.0 lb/acre of dicamba and inoculated with dicambadegrading strains was reduced to less than 1 day. Dicamba-degrading organisms were able to metabolize dicamba at lower concentrations in
62
DOUGLAS J. CORK AND JAMES P. KRUEGER
soil than in liquid medium, If dicamba metabolism is occurring in the liquid phase of the soil, then the actual concentration of dicamba in a given liquid-phase microenvironment around a soil particle may be high. The higher dicamba concentration in a given microenvironment may enhance dicamba degradation. Dicamba-degrading organisms have excellent potential as a crop inoculum to protect susceptible plant species from dicamba damage. Dicamba-degrading organisms were able to protect pea seedlings (dicamba-susceptible species) from dicamba in soil treated with up to 8.0 lb/acre dicamba. Pea seedlings planted immediately after inoculation had significantly higher weights over uninoculated controls at the 0.5- and 4.0-lb/acre rates. Pea seedlings planted 2 or 5 days after inoculation had significantly higher weights over uninoculated controls at all rates. Dicamba metabolism occurred at low temperature (15"C),which demonstrates the ability of these organisms to remove dicamba herbicidal activity in cooler climates, where dicamba persistence is sometimes a problem. Dicamba-degrading organisms were able to protect soybeans (dicamba-susceptible species) planted in dicamba-treated soil from dicamba injury in field test plots under natural conditions. Differences were found in the 8.0-lb/acre rate, where the uninoculated plots did not show any germination or subsequent stand of soybeans. The normal application rate of dicamba is 0.125 to 0.5 lb/acre. Growth in plots where 8.0 lb/acre was applied represents a 16- to 80-fold safety factor over the normal application rate. Dicamba degradative activity in the field represents a significant step toward the practical application of dicamba-degrading organism. Results of the field study indicate that dicamba-degrading organisms have a strong potential for use as a crop inoculum. Dicamba-degrading organisms could provide the genetic material needed for the development of dicamba-resistant crop species. Plasmidcontaining dicamba degraders would be important tools for genetic analysis and gene cloning. Dicamba would be an excellent candidate for expanded usage on currently susceptible crops due to its efficacy and unlikely occurrence of dicamba resistance arising in weed species. In conclusion, the widespread use of xenobiotics has been reviewed, with special emphasis given to usage and detoxication of haloaromatic herbicides and pesticides. Although all xenobiotics cannot be degraded as rapidly as the herbicide dicamba presented in the case study, we feel that the approach summarized for the degradation of dicamba provides a useful model for the enrichment, isolation, and characterization of transformation kinetics of most xenobiotic-degrading microorganisms. It has become apparent that microorganisms that successfully degrade
TRANSFORMATIONSOF HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES
63
xenobiotics have wide-ranging applications in such diverse areas as the transformation of important agricultural compounds and the bioremediation of toxic land-filled compounds. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Selected parts of Section XI were taken from Mr. Clyde Danganan’s M. S. thesis at IIT. He is presently pursuing his Ph. D. in Dr. A. M. Chakrabarty’s lab at the University of Illinois, Chicago, on a Ford Foundation Minority Fellowship. We appreciate the continued assistance of Dr. Benjamin Stark, IIT Department of Biology, in the area of recombinant DNA technology.
REFERENCES Aelion, C. M., Swindoll, C. M., and Pfaender, F. K. (1987).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 53, 2212-2217.
Ahmed, M., and Focht, D. D. (1972).Can. J. Microbiol. 19,47-52. Alexander, M. (1967).“Agriculture and the Quality of Our Environment,” pp. 331-342. Am. Assoc. Adv. Sci., Washington, D.C. Alexander, M. (1981).Science 211, 132-138. Alexander, M. (1985).Environ. Sci. Technol. 18,106-111. Amy, P. S., Schulke, J. W., Frazier, L. M., and Seidler, R. J. (1985).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 39, 1237-1245. Anderson, J. P. (1984).Soil Biol. Biochem. 16,483. Andrews, N. R., Bagley, W. P., and Herret, R. A. (1971).J. Agric. Food Chem. 19,727-730. Ashton, F. M. (1982).“Biodegradation of Pesticides,” pp. 117-129. Plenum, New York. Barnsley, E. A. (1976).J. Bacteriol. 125,404-408. Beadle, C. A., and Smith, A. R. (1982).Eur. J. Biochem. 123,323-332. Behki, R. M., and Khan, S. (1986).J. Agric. Food Chem. 34,746-749. “Bergey’s Manual of Systematic Bacteriology” (1984).Williams & Wilkins, Baltimore, Maryland. Bergmann, J. G., and Sanik, J. (1957).Anal. Chem. 29,241-243. Bernhardt, F., Pachowsky, H., and Staudinger, H. (1975).Eur. J. Biochem. 57,241-256. Berry, D.F., Francis, A. J., and Bollag, J. M. (1987).Microbiol. Rev. 51,43-59. Bollag, J. M. (1974).Adv. Appl. Microbiol. 18,75-130. Bollag, J. M., Briggs, G. G., and Dawson, J. E. (1968).J. Agric. Food Chem. 16,829-833. Braun, R.,and Gibson, D. T. (1984).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 48,102-107. Broda, P., Downing, R., Lehrbach, P. McGregor, I., and Meulien, D. (1981).“Molecular Biology, Pathogenicity, and Ecology of Bacterial Plasmids,” pp. 511-517. Plenum, New York. Burns, R. G., and Audus, L. J. (1970).Weed Res. 10,49-58. Chakrabarty, A. M. (1972).J. Bacteriol. 112,815-823. Chakrabarty, A. M. (1976).Annu. Rev. Genet. 10,7-30. Chakrabarty, A. M., Sangodkar, U. M. X., Aldrich, T. L., Hargland, R. A., Johnson, J., Rothmel, R. K., and Chapman, P. J. (1989).Acta Biotechnol. 9,301-316. Chapman, P. J. (1975).Abstr. Annu. Meet. Am. SOC.Microbiol. p. 192. Chatfield, L. K., and Williams, P. A. (1986).J. Bacteriol. 168,878-885. Chatterjee, D. K.,and Chakrabarty, A. M. (1982).Mol. Gen. Genet. 188,279-285 Chatterjee, D. K.,Kellogg, S. T., Hamada, S., and Chakrabarty, A. M. (1981).J. Bacteriol. 146.639-646.
DOUGLAS J, CORK AND JAMES P. KRUEGER
64
Chatterjee, D. K., Kilbane, J. J,, and Chakrabarty, A. M. (1982).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 44,514-516.
Crawford, R. L., Hutton, S. W., and Chapman, P. J. (1975).J. Bacteriol. 121,794-799. Crawford, R. L., Olsen, P. E., and Frick, T. D. (1979).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 38, 379-384.
“Crop Protection Chemicals Reference” (1989).Chem. Pharm. Press, New York. Dagley, P. S., Chapman, P. J., Gibson, D. T., and Wood, J. M. (1964).Nature (LondonJ 202, 775-778.
Davis, J. I., and Evans, W. C. (1964).Biochem. J. 91,251-261. DeBont, J. M., Vorage, M. W., Hartmans, S., and Van Den Tweel, W. J. (1986).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 52,677-680. Dec, J., and Bollag, J, (1988).Soil Sci. SOC.Am. J. 52,1366-1371. Don, R. H., and Pemberton, J. M. (1981).J. Bacteriol. 991,681-686. Don, R. H., Weightmann, A. J., Knackmuss, H. J., Timmis, K. N. (1985).J. Bacteriol. 161, 85-90.
Dorn, E., and Knackmuss, H. J. (1978a).Biochem. J. 174,85-94. Dorn, E., and Knackmuss, H. J. (1978b).Biochem. J. 174,73-84. Durham, D.R., and Stewart, D. B. (1987).J. Bacteriol. 169,2889-2892. Engelhardt, G., Wallnofer, P. R., and Plopp, R. (1973).Appl. Microbiol. 26,709. Evans, W. C., and Fuchs, G. (1988).Annu. Rev. Microbiol. 42,289-317. Farrell, R., and Chakrabarty, A. M. (1979).“Plasmids of Medical, Environmental and Commercial Importance,” pp. 97-109. Plenum, New York. Feist, C. G., and Hegeman, G. D. (1969).J. Bacteriol. 100,869-877. Ferrer, M. R., Moral, A. D., Ruiz-Berraquero, F., and Ramos-Cormenzana, A. (1985). Chemosphere 14,1645-1648. Fisher, P. R., Appleton, J., and Pemberton, J. M. (1978).J. Bacteriol. 135,798-804. Fujimoto, S., and Cork, D. J. (1991,August). Sac. Ind. Microbiol. Annu. Meet., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Gibson, D. T. (1978).“Microbial Transformations of Aromatic Pollutants,” pp. 187-204. Pergamon, New York. Golab, T.,Bishop, C. E., Donoho, A. L., Manthey, J. A., and Zornes, L. (1975).Pestic. Biochem. Physiol. 5,196-204. Gottschalk, G. (1979).“Bacterial Metabolism,” pp. 113-140. Springer-Verlag, New York. Goulding, C., Gillen, C. J., and Bolton, E. (1988).J. Appl. Bacteriol. 65,1-5. Grbic-Galic, D., and Vogel, T. M. (1987).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 53,254-260. Grover, R. (1967).Weed Res. 7,61-67. Guerra-Santos, L., Kappeli, O., and Fiechter, A. (1984).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 48, 301-305.
Haller, H. D. (1978).J. Water Pollut. Control Fed. 50,2771-2777. Harayama, S.,Mermod, N., Rekik, M., Lehrbach, P. R., and Timmis, K. N. (1987). J. Bacteriol. 169, 558-564. Harger, T. R. (1975).Ph.D. Thesis, Univ. of Kentucky, Lexington. Hawood, C. S., and Gibson, J. (1988).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 54,712-717. Helling, C. S., Kearney, P. C., and Alexander, M. (1971).Adv. Agron. 23, 147-240. Horvath, R. S.(1971).J. Agric. Food Chem. 19,291-293. Horvath, R. S., and Alexander, M. (1970).Appl. Microbiol. 20,254-258. Hulbert, M. H., and Krawiec, S.(1977).J. Theor. Biol. 69,287-291. Ishikawa, K., Nakamura, Y . ,and Kuwatsuka, S.(1976).Nippon Moyaku Gakkaishi 1,49. Johnson, B. F., and Stanier, R. Y. (1971).J. Bacteriol. 107,468-475. Johnston, H. W., Briggs, G. G., and Alexander, M. (1972).Soil Biol. Biochem. 4,187-190. Jones, A. S. (1976).J. Agric. Food Chem. 24, 115-117. Karickhoff, S. (1981).Chemosphere 10,833-846.
TRANSFORMATIONSOF HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES
65
Karns, J. S.,Kilbane, J. J., Chatterjee, D. K., and Chakrabarty, A. M. (1984).“Genetic Control of Environmental Pollutants,” pp. 3-21. Plenum, New York. Kaufman, D. D., and Kearney, P. C. (1970).Residue Rev. 32,235-265. Kellogg, S.T., Chatterjee, D. K., and Chakrabarty, A. M. (1981).Science 214, 1122-1135. Khan, A. A.,Walia, S. K. (1990).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 56,956-962. Kimura, Y., and Miller, V. L. (1964).J. Agric. Food Chem. 12, 253-257. Klecka, G. M., and Maier, W. J. (1985).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 49,46-53. Knoll, G., and Winter, J. (1987).Eur. J. Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 25,384-391. Krueger, J, P. (1984).M.S. Thesis, Illinois Inst. Technol., Chicago. Krueger, J. P. (1989).Ph.D. Thesis, Illinois Inst. Technol., Chicago. Krueger, J. P., Butz, R. G., Atallah, Y. H., and Cork, D. J. (1989).J. Agric. Food Chern. 37, 534-538.
Krueger, J. P., Butz, R. G., and Cork, D. J. (1990).J. Ind. Microbiol. 5,147-152. Krueger, J. P., Butz, R. G., and Cork, D. J. (1991).J. Agric. Food Chern. (in press). Latorre, J., Reineke, W., and Knackmuss, H. J, (1984).Arch. Microbiol. 140,159-165. Leather, G. R., and Foy, C. L. (1977).Pestic. Biochem. Physiol. 7,437-442. Lehrbach, P. R., Zeyer, J., Reineke, W., Knackmuss, H. J., and Timmis, K. N. (1984). J. Bacteriol. 158,1025-1032. LOOS,M. A. (1975).“Herbicides: Chemistry, Degradation,” pp. 1-128. Dekker, New York. Marks, T. S., Smith, A. R., and Quirk, A. V. (1984).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 48,10201025.
Matsumura, F. (1982).“Biodegradation of Pesticides,” pp. 67-85. Plenum, New York. Messing, J. (1983).Methods Enzymol. 101,20-78. Metzler, D.E. (1977).“Biochemistry,” pp. 615-625. Academic Press, New York. Miller, L., and Berger, T. (1985).“Hewlett-Packard Application Note,” 228-41. HewlettPackard, Palo Alto, California. Milne, G. W., Goldman, P., and Holzman, J. L. (1968).J. Biol. Chem. 243, 5374-5376. Morris, C. M., and Barnsley, E. A. (1982).Can. J. Microbiol. 28, 73-79. Muller, R., Thiele, J., Klages, U., and Lingens, F. (1984).Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 124,178-182.
Neufeld, R. J., Zajic, J. E., andGerson, D. F. (1980).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 39,511-517. Novick, N. J., and Alexander, M. (1985).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 49,737-743. Nozawa, T., and Maruyama, Y. (1988).I. Bacteriol. 170,5778-5784. Ogram, A. V.,Jessup, R. E., Ou, L. T., and Rao, P. C. (1985).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 49, 582-587.
Paris, D. F., Lewis, D. L., and Wolfe, N. L. (1975).Environ. Sci. Technol. 9,135-138. Parker, L. W., and Doxtader, K. G. (1983).J. Environ. Qual. 12,553-558. Perkins, E. J.,and Lurquin, P. F. (1988).J. Bacteriol. 170,5669-5672. Pfaender, F. K., and Alexander, M. (1972).J. Agric. Food Chem. 20,842-846. Pierce, G. E., Robinson, J. B., and Colaruotolo, J. R. (1983).Dev. Ind. Microbiol. 24, 499-507.
Que, L., Wisdom, J., and Crawford, R. L. (1981).J. Biol. Chern. 256,10941-10944. Ramos, J.L., Wasserfallen, A., Rose, K., and Timmis, K. N. (1987).Science 235,593-596. Reineke, W., and Knackmuss, H. J. (1978).Biochim. Biophys. Acta 542,412-423. Reineke, W., and Knackmuss, H. J, (1979).Nature (London) 277, 385-386. Reineke, W., and Knackmuss, H. J. (1980).J. Bacteriol. 142,467-473. Reineke, W.,and Knackmuss, H. J. (1984).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 47, 395-402. Reineke, W., and Knackmuss, H. J. (1988).Annu. Rev. Microbiol. 42,263-287. Reineke, W., Jeenes, D. J., Williams, P. A., and Knackmuss, H. J. (1982).J. Bacteriol. 150, 195-201.
Ribbons, D. W., and Williams, P. A. (1982).“Genetic Engineering of Microorganisms for Chemicals,” pp. 211-231. Plenum, New York.
66
DOUGLAS J. CORK AND JAMES P. KRUEGER
Rojo, F., Peiper, D. H., Engesser, K. H., Knackmuss, H. J., and Timmis, K. N. (1987).Science 238,1395-1398.
Rosenberg, A., and Alexander, M. (1980).J. Agric. Food Chem. 28,297-302. Sandmann, E. R., and Loos, M. A. (1988).Can. J. Microbiol. 34,125-130. Sangodkar, U. M. X., Chapman, P. J., and Chakrabarty, A. M. (1988).Gene 71,267-277. Saxena, A., Zhang, R., and Bollag, J. M. (1987).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 53,390-396. Schmidt, E.,and Knackmuss, H. J. (1980).Biochem. J. 192,339-347. Scifres, C. J., Allen, T. J., Leinweber, C. J., and Pearson, K. H. (1973).J. Environ. Qual. 2, 306-309.
Sleat, R., and Robinson, J. P. (1984).J. Appl. Bacteriol. 57,381-394. Smith, A. E. (1973).J. Agric. Food Chem. 21,708-710. Smith, A. E. (1974).J. Agric. Food Chem. 22,601-605. Smith, A., and Cain, R. B. (1965).J. Gen. Microbiol. 41,XVI. Smith, A. E., and Cullimore, P. G. (1975).Weed Res. 15, 59-62. Spokes, J. R., and Walker, N. (1974).Arch. Microbiol. 96,125-134. Stalker, D. M.,McBride, K. E., and Malyj, L. D. (1988).Science 24,419-422. Stanier, R. Y., Pallerone, N. J., and Doudoroff, M. (1966).J. Gen. Microbiol. 43, 159-271. Steele, R. E. (1983).Focus 8,3-30. Steiert, J. G., Pignatello, J. J., and Crawford, R. L. (1987).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 53, 907-910.
Steiert, 1. G., Thoma, W. J., Ugurbic, K.,and Crawford, R. L. (1988).J. Bacteriol. 170, 4954-4957.
Stucki, G., and Alexander, M. (1987).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 53, 292-297. Suflita, J. M., Horowitz, A., Shelton, D. R., and Tiedje, J. M. (1982).Science 218,115-116. Suflita, J. M., Stout, J., and Tiedje, J. M. (1984).J. Agric. Food Chem. 32,218-221. Suflita,J. M., Gibson, S . A., and Beeman, R. E. (1988).J. Ind. Microbiol. 3, 179-194. Taylor, B. F.,and Heeb, M. J. (1972).Arch. Microbiol. 83,165-171. Tiedje, J. M., and Hagedorn, M. L. (1975).J. Agric. Food Chem. 23,77-81. Torstensson, L. (1988).Outlook Agric. 17,120-124. Tschech, A., and Schink, B. (1985).Arch. Microbiol. 143,52-59. Vaishnav, D. D., and Babeu, L. (1987).Bull. Environ. Contam. Toxicol. 39,237-244. Vanderbergh, P. A., Olsen, R. H., and Colaruotolo, J. F. (1981).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 42,737-739.
Van Den Tweel, W. J., Kok, J. B., and DeBont, J. A. (1987).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 53, 810-815.
Wang, D. I., Cooney, C. L., Demain, A. L., Dunnill, P., Humphrey, A. E., and Lilly, M. D. (1979).“Fermentation and Enzyme Technology,” pp. 57-97. Wiley, New York. Weber, J. B. (1977).“Science,” pp. 59-71. South. Weed Sci. SOC.,Auburn, Alabama. Weber, J. B., and Coble, H. D. (1968).J . Agric. Food Chem. 16,475-478. Weightmann, A. J.,Don, R. H., Lehrbach, P. R., and Timmis, K. N. (1984).“Genetic Control of Environmental Pollutants,” p. 47.Plenum, New York. White-Stevens, R. H., and Kamin, H. (1972).J. Biol. Chem. 247,2358-2370. Wiggins, B. A., and Alexander, M. (1988).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 54,2803-2807. Wyndham, R.C. (1986).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 51, 781-789. Yoshida, T., and Kojima, H. (1978).Chemosphere 6,497-501. Zeikus, J. G.(1977).Bacteriol. Rev. 41, 514-541. Zeyer, J., Wasserfallen, A., and Timmis, K. N. (1985).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 50, 447-453.
Zeyer, J., Kuhn, E. P., and Schwarzenbach, R. P. (1986).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 52, 944-947.
An Environmental Assessment of Biotechnological Processes M. S. THAKUR,* M. J. JSENNEDY,~~' AND N. G. KARANTH" * Fermentation Technology and Bioengineering Discipline Central Food Technological Research Institute Mysore-570013, India Industrial Processing Division Department of Scientific and Industrial Research Petone, New Zealand I. Introduction A. Historical Perspective B. Potential Benefits C. Hazards and Problems to Date D. Motivation 11. Ecological Consequences of the Release of Microorganisms A. Dispersion of Microorganisms in the Environment B. Survival of Microorganisms in the Environment C. Genetic Exchange in the Environment 111 Risk Assessment Direct Risk to Humans IV. Case Studies A. Food Bioprocesses B. Pharmaceutical and Enzyme Bioprocesses C. Waste Treatment D. Chemical Bioprocesses E. Mining F. Agriculture V. The Regulation of Biotechnological Processes The Problems of Regulating Biotechnology VI. Conclusions References
I. Introduction
Biotechnology has many definitions (Smith, 1988),which is a reflection on its diverse range of applications. Coombs (1986) defines biotechnology as the application of organisms, biological systems, or biological processes to manufacturing and service industries.
Present address: Industrial Development-Wellington, Department of Scientific and Industrial Research, Lower Hutt, New Zealand.
67 ADVANCES IN APPLIED MICROBIOLOGY, VOLUME 36 Copyright 0 1991 by Academic Press, Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved.
68
M. S. THAKUR ET AL.
A. HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE
Mankind has been harnessing biological processes for thousands of years. For example, the ability of yeast to make alcohol in the form of beer was known to the Sumerians and Babylonians before 6000 BC (Demain and Solomon, 1981). Mankind has also been trying for a similar period of time to manipulate the genetic content of animals and plants by cross-breeding. For example, a Babylonian tablet dating back to about 4000 BC gives the pedigree of five generations of horses, showing how characteristics of the head and mane were transmitted; stone carvings from ancient Egypt show men cross-pollinating the date palm, the obvious purpose of which is to improve the quality of fruit (Winchester, 1977).
However, it has not been until this century that mankind has learned to change purposefully the genetic content of organisms in a direct way without depending on the process of reproduction. Mutations in DNA were induced in the laboratory by means of X-rays as early as 1927, and later a wide range of mutagenic radiations and chemical mutagens were developed (Hopwood, 1981). The 1970s saw a quantum leap in mankind’s ability to manipulate the genetic content of an organism, with the first successful experiment in gene cloning occurring in 1973 (Antebi and Fishlock, 1986).
B. POTENTIAL BENEFITS The potential benefits of genetic engineering are numerous. The current benefits are primarily in medicine and agriculture. In medicine, the development of human insulin, human growth hormone, tissue plasminogen activator, and numerous vaccines stands out. In agriculture, there is interest in developing plants resistant to heat, cold, frost, insects and pests, herbicides, metals, salt, and drought (Demain, 1986). Some biotechnology products, such as bovine growth hormone, are of dubious benefit. Public pressure and the overproduction of milk or meat may slow or stop the commercialization of animal growth hormones. AND PROBLEMS TO DATE C. HAZARDS
Mankind, unfortunately, has not had an unblemished track record when it comes to the effect of technology on the environment. Several serious chemical accidents have occurred in the past decade due to the improper use of technology. No one can forget the tragedies of the poisonous gas leak in Bhopal, the radiation leak at the Chernobil nuclear power plant, and the Exxon Valdez oil spill in Alaska. In a broad sense,
ENVIRONMENTAL BIOLOGICAL PROCESSES
69
biotechnology already has had several adverse environmental effects, including “killer” bees (Mellon, 1988), the poisonous Lenape potato (Wickelgren, 1989), the Japanese beetle (Smith and Hardley, 1926), the European gypsy moth (Forbush and Fernald, 1896), the Chinese chestnut blight (Merkel, 1906), Dutch elm disease (Huber, 1987), and antibiotic-resistant varieties of pathogenic organisms (Slater, 1985; Levy, 1986).
D. MOTIVATION Recent advances in genetic engineering have created the potential for large benefits to society, but they have also meant that many genetically novel organisms are interacting with the environment. The hazards and risks associated with the release of new organisms into the environment and also the hazards of traditional biotechnology have not been fully understood. In numerous cases, many of the important data on environmental interactions are not known. This article summarizes the ecological consequences and potential risks of the release of traditional and genetically modified organisms into the environment. Each major biotechnology process area is then evaluated with respect to the hazard it may pose to the environment. Finally, the structure and some of the problems involved in the regulation of these processes are outlined as starting points for further investigation. II. Ecological Consequences of the Release of Microorganisms
There are two main areas for concern when introducing a new species into the environment or into a part of the environment where it has not previously been present. The first concern is that the new species will display traits that negatively affect the environment or other species within it. The second concern is that genetic traits in the released organism will be transferred to other organisms, which will further disrupt the ecological balance. Most environmental releases follow the pattern of release, dispersion, survival, and then interaction with the environment. The interaction can be on a physical or genetic level. A. DISPERSION OF MICROORGANISMS IN THE ENVIRONMENT
The three major pathways of environmental dispersion are air, water, and vectors. Vectors are moving solid surfaces and may be either biological or physical. Viable airborne microorganisms can be transported by
70
M. S.THAKUR ET AL.
wind currents over a long distance and their survival may be prolonged through association with aerosols, soil, or other particles. Microbial transport in surface water or groundwater is difficult to predict because of its dependence on complex physical mechanisms, such as attachment to particles. Biological dispersion is either in the intestinal tract, in the hemolymph or salivary glands, or on the body surface of a variety of vertebrate and invertebrate animals. Physical dispersion is on the surface or in internal spaces of man-made material, equipment, or vehicles (Barnthouse and Palumbo, 1986).
B. SURVIVAL OF MICROORGANISMS IN THE ENVIRONMENT When a species is introduced into a new ecosystem in which no ecological barrier exists, its population reaches a considerable level in a short time (Pimmentel, 1985). This applies to microorganisms, for example, the introduction of Chinese chestnut blight into American chestnut trees (Merkel, 1906);to plants, for example, the introduction of the ragwort plant into New Zealand pasture; to insects, for example, the introduction of the Japanese beetle into the United States (Smith and Hardley, 1926); and to animals, for example, the introduction of the European rabbit into Australia (Stead, 1935).The reasons for such population explosions can be found in the factors that effect organism survival in the environment. The survival of all microorganisms depends upon a number of environmental conditions, for example, temperature, sunlight, moisture, nutrients, and biological interactions (Barnthouse and Palumbo, 1986). Other important factors affecting the survival of introduced microorganisms include competition among microorganisms sharing the same ecosystem and dispersion of the microorganism. Toxin production is a pathogenic trait for which there is no known survival feature (Levy, 1986).
Levy (1986) lists the following mechanisms and requirements for survival of microorganisms released into a new environment: (1) adherence to human tissue, (2) colonization on a human or animal body, (3) trace amounts of iron and other essential elements, (4) resistance to the antimicrobial activity of serum, and (5) formation of a capsule to resist adverse conditions in the new environment. Once established, some microorganisms can survive even in meager environments for long periods of time. For example, Vibrio cholerae is reported to have longterm persistence in potable and brackish water (Huq et al., 1983; Roberts eta]., 1982).
ENVIRONMENTAL BIOLOGICAL PROCESSES
71
C. GENETIC EXCHANGEIN THE ENVIRONMENT Once release, dispersion, and then survival within the new environment has occurred, the organism is capable of transferring its genetic traits to other members of the ecosystem. Although the designers of most novel organisms would prefer very little genetic exchange to take place, this cannot be guaranteed, as there are numerous examples of genetic exchange within the environment. The potential for gene transfer is quite large. Genes can be transferred between the same species. Burton et al. (1974) showed the transfer of multiple-drug-resistance plasmids between different strains of Staphylococcus aureus in the kidneys of mice. Gene transfer can occur between members of the same genus. Hartmann et al. (1979) have shown that, in a mixed culture of Pseudomonas sp. strain B13 and Pseudomonas putida mt2, the TOL plasmid was transferred from P. putida mt2 to Pseudomonas sp. strain B13. Gene transfer can occur between different genera. Grabow and Prozeski (1973) studied the transfer of multiple-drug-resistance plasmids in the bacterial population of the tertiary treatment stage of a wastewater treatment plant. It was shown that drug-resistance plasmids were transferred between Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhi in vitro and that, in the wastewater, there was a threefold increase in coliforms carrying drug resistance. In mixed bacterial infections of burn tissue, Roe et al. (1971) found that the plasmid P I , carrying resistance to carbenicillin, was transferred between the genera Escherichia, Pseudomonas, Proteus, and Klebsiella. A postulated pathway of gene exchange between microorganisms can be seen in Fig. 1. Gene transfer can occur between microorganisms and plants. For example, an Agrobacterium sp. can transfer some of its plasmid DNA to dicot plant cells. Industrially important stains of Agrobacterium include Agrobacterium tumefaciens and Agrobacterium rhizogenes (Chilton et al., 1983). Gene transfer can occur between microorganisms and animals and, more significantly, between microorganisms and man. Smith (1975, 1977) showed that a high frequency of R-factor (gene) occurred in vivo in sheep rumens. The R-factor gene occurred by transfer from E. coli, and the same result was observed in pigs and calves and in the human gastrointestinal tract. Most of the above examples occurred in the laboratory or under man-made conditions. However, there are many examples of gene transfer in the natural environment. For example, gene transfer between E.
72
M. S. THAKUR ET AL.
VMENTl
Bordetella
1 ANIMAL HOSTS I
I
Rhodospirillum
I
I
Bacteroides
FIG.1. Postulated pathways of genetic exchange between microorganisms. Adapted from Sayler and Stacey (1986).
coli strains within the intestinal tract, the natural environment for E. coli, has been reported (Marshall and Levy, 1980; Marshal et al., 1981; Petrocheilou et al., 1976).Transfer of plasmids on normal skin surface is also known (Lacey and Richmond, 1974). Lacy and Leary (1975a,b) demonstrated the transfer of drug-resistance plasmid RP1 from Pseudomonas aeruginosa to E. coli and from E. coIi to Pseudomonas glycinea on a plant surface. Renney et al. (1982) suggested that the environmental conditions occurring on the plant surface are suitable for plasmid transfer.
ENVIRONMENTAL BIOLOGICAL PROCESSES
73
Hada and Sizemore (1981)reported that more plasmid-containing bacteria were found in polluted coastal areas and that bacteria isolated from unpolluted areas had fewer plasmids. Similarly, more plasmidcontaining Pseudomonas species isolates were detected from a polluted area of a river than from a nearby unpolluted site (Burton et al., 1982). Plasmid transfer among soil microorganisms is assumed to occur regularly and to be of significance (Slater, 1985).Weinberg and Stotzky (1972)showed that a gene can be transferred between E. coli strains in soil. Schift and Klingmuller (1983)showed that the broad-host-range plasmid pRDl carried by E. coli could transfer to just over 1% of the total soil population. The most significant negative effect of gene exchange in the environment to date has been the transfer of antibiotic-resistance genes to organisms harmful to man. This problem is widespread. Bacteria resistant to antibiotics have been isolated in numerous places, for example, in hospital waste, raw sewage, water receiving sewage effluent (Fontain and Hoadley, 1976;Linton et al., 1974;Bell et al., 1981;Corliss et al., 1981;Sturtevant and Feary, 1969;Grabow and Prozesky, 1973),sediment from an off-shore sewage dump site (Timoney et al., 1978),coastal sediments (Grabow et al., 1975;Goyal and Hoadley, 1979),marine water (Smith, 1970, 1971;Feary et al., 1972;Smith et al., 1974;Goyal and Hoadley, 1979),estuaries and rivers (McNicon et al., 1980;Kelch and Lee, 1978),fisheries (Watanabe et al., 1971;Aoki et al., 1973),animal feed, abattoirs (La Font et al., 1981;Goyal and Hoadley, 1979),p h t s and soil (Talbot et al., 1980;Cole and Elkan, 1979),and drinking water (Armstrong et a]., 1981). In 1984,in West Bengal, India, 90,000people were seriously affected and 3290 died due to acute diarrhea. This epidemic was spread over the entire state of West Bengal and in 13 districts of Orissa, Assam, and Tripura. The National Institute of Cholera and Enteric Diseases in Calcutta suggested that the epidemic was due to new strains of virulent, antibiotic-resistant bacteria that were being generated by local ecological factors. These bacterial strains were resistant to ampicillin, tetracycline, and chloromycetin. Similar cases were also observed in Bastar in the state of Madhya Pradesh, India (Thakur, 1988).
Ill. Risk Assessment
Risk may be defined as a measure of the likelihood and severity of harm and is generally assessed through three types of investigations (A1 Bourquin and Seidler, 1986):(1)exposure assessment (determining the
74
M. S. THAKUR ET AL.
conditions of exposure), (2) hazard identification (attributing adverse effects to the hazard), including dose-response assessment (relating exposure to effects), and (3) risk characterization (estimating overall risk). A useful descriptive model for the risk absessment of a biotechnology application was presented in a report by the U.S. Office of Technology Assessment in 1981. The report suggests a series of events that need to be considered in the assessment (Fiksel and Covello, 1986): 1. Formation: The creation of genetically altered microorganisms through deliberate or accidental means. 2. Release: The deliberate release or accidental escape of some of these microorganisms into the environment. 3. Proliferation: The subsequent multiplication, genetic reconstruction, growth, transport, modification, and death of these microorganisms in the environment, including possible transfer of genetic material to other microorganisms. 4. Establishment: The establishment of these microorganisms within an ecosystem niche, including possible colonization in human or other biota. 5. Effect on humans and ecological effects: Human or ecological effects occur, due to the interaction of the organisms with some host or environmental factor.
The hazardous situations that may arise are described by Krimsky and Fraenkel (1985) as follows: 1. A novel organism might be released into the environment with unpredictable and possible irreversible effects on the environment. 2. The release of a new microbial agent may infect humans or animals. 3. A conventional pathogen might have its host range broadened. 4. A rapid rise in application of large-scale biotechnological processes could result in bioeffluent that would place additional stress on the quality of land and water resources. 5. Organisms engineered to perform useful functions in the environment might produce adverse secondary effects of an unanticipated nature.
DIRECTRISK TO HUMANS
To evaluate the risk potential to humans we must first take into account how these microorganisms gain entry into humans. Humans have a natural protection against most bacterial infections, i.e., the skin and stomach. The skin maintains the sterile internal environment of
ENVIRONMENTAL BIOLOGICAL PROCESSES
75
human beings. Bacteria gain entry through abrasions and cuts in the skin. A similar kind of barrier exists throughout the intestinal tract and mucous membranes. Naturally occurring bacteria have intrinsic traits that aid in their ability to colonize, and protect against competitive colonization by invading potential pathogens (Levy, 1986). Human infection depends on four major interacting factors (Levy, 1986): (1)the intrinsic traits, including pathogenicity, of the organisms, (2) the numbers of invasive organisms, (3) the health of the individual, and (4) the first and second lines of antimicrobial defense. Human infections can occur with low doses of pathogen (Levy, 1986). For example, infection has been reported with a dose of just 10 microorganisms (tularemia; see Table I). An indirect measure of infection potential can be obtained from an evaluation of the relative frequency of various organisms in causing laboratory-acquired infection (see Table 11; the two entries for Streptococcus result from independent studies). A more direct measure would be the number of cases of infection per number of total exposures, but often these data are not available. There are several lists that classify microorganisms based on their hazards to humans. For example, the working group on “Safety in Biotechnology of the European Federation of Biotechnology” has accepted a classification of microorganisms based on their pathogenicity (Kuenzi et al., 1985; Frommer et al., 1989).These classifications provide a good starting point for the evaluation of the risk involved in the release of a microorganism into the environment. IV. Case Studies
Genetically engineered organisms are being exploited to develop processes for the production of many important biologics. Some of the bioprocesses that might use genetically engineered organisms are TABLE I INFECTIOUS DOSEREQUIREDFOR DISEASE TO OCCUR”
Disease or agent
Route
Dose
Tularemia Shigella flexneri Anthrax Typhoid fever Cholera Escherichia coli
Inhalation Inhalation Inhalation Ingestion Ingestion Ingestion
10 180 1300
Adapted from Levy (1986).
1o5 1o8 108
76
M. S . THAKUR ET AL. TABLE I1
KNOWN LABORATORY-ACQUIRED INFECTION FROM 1930 TO 19744 Disease or agent
Number of cases
Number of deaths
Brucellosis Typhoid Tularemia Tuberculosis Streptococcus Leptospirosis Salmonellosis Relapsing fever Anthrax Erysipeloid Diphtheria Streptococcus Rate bite fever Glander Syphilis Cholera Plague Neisseria meningitides Pseudomonas pseudomallei Clostridium Tetanus toxin Mixed infection Dermatomycosis Coccidioidomycosis Histoplasmosis Sporotrichosis Blastomycosis
423 256 225 176 78 68 48 45 45 43 33 29 21 20 15 12 10 8 8 6
5 20 2 2 4
5 5
161 93 71 12 11
0 0
2 5 0 0
1 0 0
0 4 4 1 0 0 0 0 0
2 1 0 2
From Levy (1986).
(1) food bioprocesses, (2) pharmaceutical and enzyme bioprocesses, (3) waste treatment, (4) chemical bioprocesses, (5) mining, ( 6 )and agri-
culture. A. FOODBIOPROCESSES
A wide variety of food products are made by utilizing the action of microorganisms. Many of these processes have been practiced for thousands of years, for example, the production of cheese, beer, wine, and vinegar. The main hazard involved with the use of microorganisms in food bioprocesses is the contamination of the food product with toxic chemicals. There are many examples of serious illness and, more rarely,
ENVIRONMENTAL BIOLOGICAL PROCESSES
77
death occurring due to the consumption of food contaminated with toxigenic fungi (Smith, 1985). Though contamination of food products can be avoided, many industrial strains of microorganisms produce toxic compounds. For example, Maing et al. (1973) and Yokotsuka et al. (1967) investigated several industrial strains of Aspergillus spp. used in food fermentation. About 30% of these strains produced aflatoxinrelated compounds. The use of a genetically engineered yeast has already caused problems in the food industry. In Japan, the Kitono Homare Shuzo company stopped making sake using a yeast fused with a killer yeast that would destroy any invading microorganisms. This was because of the danger of the killer yeast contaminating other fermentation tanks, necessitating the establishment of a separate facility (Martin, 1989).
B. PHARMACEUTICAL AND ENZYME BIOPROCESSES Biotechnology enables manufacture of a wide range of drugs, therapeutics, and enzymes. Microbial enzyme products must meet strict specifications with regard to toxicity and other safety aspects geared toward protecting the manufactury workers (Aunstrup et al., 1979). Most enzyme products cannot be made 100% pure and may contain potentially harmful compounds from the fermentation broth, because purification is rarely completely effective. For example, toxic phospholipase C, which is formed by several pathogenic bacteria, along with other unknown toxins may be present in crude preparations of microbial enzymes or other products (Aunstrup et al., 1979).Like all proteins, enzymes are antigenic and may cause an allergic reaction-the most important factor is the amount of “dust” that arises from handling the enzyme. Enzyme preparations should preferably be encapsulated in an inert material (Aunstrup et al., 1979; Harris and Rose, 1972). Historically, the most visible problems involving enzymes and human health have been in the production of detergent proteases. These problems, involving enzyme dusts, have now been solved by encapsulation technology, but the problem was severe enough to lead to the formation of guidelines by an ad hoc committee on enzyme detergents of the Medical Sciences Division of the United States National Academy of Sciences (Ward, 1983). Another problem occurs in the area of vaccine production. Extreme care is required in the inactivation of the virus to ensure that no residual live virus is present in the vaccine (Jawetz et al., 1974). Genetic engineering may enable us to bypass this hazard. The gene that encodes for the viral coat protein can be placed on a plasmid in a bacterium, thereby
78
M.S.THAKUR ET AL.
enabling the bacterium to produce the viral protein in large quantities through conventional fermentation (Paul, 1981).However, this leads to another problem, which also affects other protein products. All products, especially those for human use, should be free of bacterial DNA, and the complete removal of DNA from many products is a problem. Complex analytical procedures are often required to verify that the product is indeed nucleic acid free. C. WASTETREATMENT In wastewater treatment, organisms are used in an effluent stream that enhances their growth, thereby helping them break down organic materials. Microorganisms and their activity are used to detoxify and degrade sewage and industrial wastes (Andern and Lockett, 1914; Jones, 1976). The activated sludge process, developed early in this century, has depended on indigenous microorganisms in the waste stream. However, today, inoculum cultures for use in waste treatment are marketed by about 20 companies all over the world (Gamer, 1979). Efforts are underway to improve the efficiency of treatment plants by adding specially cultured or genetically engineered bacteria (Krimsky and Fraenkel, 1985).Pseudomonas putida endowed with multiple compatible plasmids from other strains, giving unique multisubstrateutilizing capabilities, has been patented (Chakrabarty, 1974). The specific plasmids were for octane, xylene, m-xylene, camphor, and salicylate degradation. Microorganisms have been developed on a laboratory scale for degrading industrial organic compounds such as polychlorinated biphenyl and the herbicide 2,4,5-trichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4,5-T) (Krimsky and Fraenkel, 1985). The degradation of many xenobiotic compounds (Best et al., 1985) is often the result of concerted metabolic activity by different members of a stable, highly interactive microbial community (Senior et al., 1976). Slater (1985) reported that a haloaromatic compound can be degraded by microorganisms. Dorn et al. (1974) isolated Pseudornonas sp. strain B13, which can grow on benzoate. In the case of wastewater treatment, the microorganisms may have a direct man-made pathway into the environment. Some policy managers are concerned that novel organisms developed for sewage treatment may constitute a new form of pollution (Johnston, 1981).
D. CHEMICAL BIOPROCESSES Various acids, solvents, and other chemicals have been manufactured by microbial fermentation. According to Eveleigh (1981), microorganisms currently produce about 200 substances of commercial value.
ENVIRONMENTAL BIOLOGICAL PROCESSES
79
Problems may arise if the microorganism used to produce a valuable product is a pathogen. Production of gibberellic acid in a solid medium by Gibberellafujikuroi, which is a pathogen to the rice plant, may pose a problem to rice crops if proper care has not been taken to remove the plant pathogen in downstream processing. Another example of a plant pathogen is Xanthomonas campestris, which produces xanthan. Zaugg and Swartz (1982)have noted that the biochemical industry has a poorer record than the pharmaceutical industry in areas related to worker safety and environmental protection.
E. MINING Bacteria have been used to leach metals from low-grade ores of copper and uranium. The genus Thiobacillus is commonly used for this purpose (Norris and Kelly, 1982;Tuovinen, 1986).Zaugg and Swartz (1982) cite the following potential hazards in the use of organisms in the mining industry: 1. Bacterial leaching operations that generate large quantities of sulfuric acid acidify water supplies. 2. Thiobacillus and related species may acquire the ability to infect humans by natural interaction with pathogenic organisms. 3. Metals concentrated by bacteria from dilute mine water can accumulate in the food chain.
F. AGRICULTURE 1. Microorganisms
The deliberate release of microorganisms to control plants and insects is of great significance, because widespread dispersion of the microorganisms is practiced. Currently, 13 microbial pesticide agents are approved and registered with the Environmental Protection Agency. These 13 organisms are marketed in 75 different products for use in agriculture, forestry, and insect control (Betz et al., 1983). Bacillus thuringiensis carries a gene that codes for a protein called Bt toxin. The protein breaks down in the gut of some insects to form poisonous polypeptides, disrupting the gut membrane and eventually killing the insect (Wickelgren, 1989).The release of the plant pathogen Puccinia chondrillina has been used successfully to control skeleton weed in Australia (Klingman and Coulson, 1982). [For a list of the genetically engineered microorganisms that have been approved (or are under consideration) by the United States Environmental Protection Agency under the Toxic Substances Control Act for field tests, see the publication by the National Wildlife Federation (1990).]
80
M. S.THAKUR ET AL.
2. Plants, Insects, and Animals
Numerous trials of genetically engineered plants are now underway. [For a list of genetically engineered plants that have been approved (or are under consideration) by the United States Department of Agriculture under the Federal Plant Pest Act for field tests, see the publication by the National Wildlife Federation (1990).] The potential problem with genetically altered plants is that changes in the genetic structure might enable production of toxic products. Wickelgren (1989)states that a new gene might alter a plant’s ability to produce toxins either by increasing levels of the plant’s natural toxin or by coding for a new toxic product. Shuffling of genes has elevated levels of natural plant toxins in the past, according to J. Doyle, Director of the Agriculture and Biotechnology project of the Environmental Policy Institute in Washington, D.C. In 1980,he noted that scientists bred a new kind of potato that had an increased concentration of toxin. The USDA later pulled the poisonous “Lenape” potato off the market (Wickelgren, 1989). In 1973, plant breeders produced by accident a corn cultivar that was highly susceptible to a common leaf fungus, and corn crops in the United States, from Louisiana to Maine, were destroyed (Mellon, 1988). A transgenic organism is defined as an organism engineered to contain DNA from dissimilar parent organisms. Transgenic mice, pigs, cows, sheep, fish, and insects have been produced. Animals are genetically modified to produce leaner meat with improved nutritional properties. Attempts are being made to produce drugs such as blood clot-dissolving enzymes in mice or cows. Some scientists are interested in producing leaner pork by introducing a growth hormone gene into pigs. Unexpectedly, the pigs containing the growth hormone gene were arthritic, blind, and lacked competent immune systems (Mellon, 1988). An inadvertent effect was caused when traditionally genetically modified “killer” bees caused 700 deaths in Central and South America. V. The Regulation of Biotechnological Processes
The potential hazards resulting from the release of genetically engineered organisms into the environment were initially raised at the Gordon Research Conference on Nucleic acids in July, 1973 (Hartl, 1985).One of the early local initiatives for regulation of recombinant microorganisms was a 3-week moratorium by Cambridge, Massachusetts, on recombinant DNA research at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and Harvard University. Later in 1976,Cambridge passed an ordinance for the safe use of microorganisms (Huber, 1987).Today
81
ENVIRONMENTAL BIOLOGICAL PROCESSES TABLE 111 THEUNITEDSTATESFEDERAL BIOTECHNOLOGY FRAMEWORK"
Agency
Status
United States Department of Agriculture
United States Environmental Protection Agency United States Food and Drug Administration United States National Institutes of Health
Jurisdiction
Plant Pest Act
Plant pests
Virus-Serum Toxin Act Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act Toxic Substances Control Act Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act
Animal biologics Pesticides
Guidelines for research involving DNA molecules
Chemical substances Food, drugs, biologics, and cosmetics Organisms produced by certain modern techniques
Organisms currently regulated Plants, invertebrate animals, and microorganisms Microorganisms Microorganisms
Microorganisms Plants, animals, and microorganisms Plants, animals, and microorganisms
Adapted from Mellon (1988).
there is an extensive network of agencies and regulations governing the use of genetically modified organisms (see Table 111). THEPROBLEMS OF REGULATING BIOTECHNOLOGY The regulations governing biotechnology are complex and government approval is required for field testing genetically novel organisms. These regulations have led to high costs and long delays for companies wishing to test new products in the environment. For example, due to the strict regulation of biotechnological products in the United States Genentech encountered needless delays and expenses while the USDA and FDA argued for more than a year over which agency should regulate the company's new bovine interferon (Huber, 1987). The regulations attempt to strike a balance between protecting the environment and man while at the same time not stifling new advances and benefits to society. One of the consequences of the comprehensive regulation of biotechnology in some countries is that often these regulations are avoided
82
M. S. THAKUR ET AL.
by conducting trials in other countries, where regulation is not as strict. For example, researchers at Oregon State University went to New Zealand to conduct field trials against the insect-borne Sindbis viruses that plague animals (Huber, 1987). Some biotechnology companies are collaborating with Japanese companies so that tests can be conducted abroad without United States government involvement (Huber, 1987). VI. Conclusions
Rapid advances in genetic engineering since the 1970s have created the potential for large benefits to society through the development of novel organisms and new products. The development of these organisms has been so successful that there has been a rapid increase in the number of government-approved releases of genetically engineered organisms over the past few years. However, this potential is balanced by the introduction of new problems and potential hazards. Historically, mankind has not dealt well with the introduction of new technology or species into the environment, and many inadvertent negative effects have been observed. Biotechnology is no exception to this. One of the most significant problems facing the release of a novel organism into the environment is a lack of data. One of the major concerns is that a significant amount of gene exchange occurs between various species. Bacterial antibiotic resistance provides the most spectacular example of this. If we cannot adequately describe in detail the effects of the release on the environment, then the risk associated with an exposure cannot be assessed. To protect public safety and the environment, the United States and many other countries have created a number of regulatory agencies and regulations. These regulations try to set a balance between overburdening the industry with excessive requirements that limit the development of many beneficial products and avoiding environmental damage and risks to the public health. Unfortunately, strict regulations in some countries have led to exposure to unknown risks in other countries that lack adequate regulations. ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The authors gratefully acknowledge the use of facilities at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and the University of Maryland, Baltimore County, in the preparation of this article.
ENVIRONMENTAL BIOLOGICAL PROCESSES
83
REFERENCES A1 Bourquin, and Seidler, R. (1986).In “Biotechnology and the Environment, Research Needs” (G. S . Omenn and A. H. Teich, eds.), pp. 18-69.Noyes Data Corp., Park Ridge, New Jersey. Andern, E., and Lockett, W. T. (1914).J. SOC.Chem. Ind. 33,1122-1124. Antebi, E., and Fishlock, D. (1986).“Biotechnology: Strategies for Life.” MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts. Aoki, T., Eugusa, S . , and Watanabe, T. (1973).Jpn. J. Microbiol. 17,7-12. Armstrong, J. L., Shigeno, D. S . , Caomiris, J. J., and Seidler, R. J.(1981).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 42,277-283. Aunstrup, K., Andereson, O., Falch, E. A,, and Nielsen, T. K. (1979).In “Microbial Technology” (H. J. Pepper and D.Perlman, eds.], pp. 281-309. Academic Press, New York. Barnthouse, L. W., and Palumbo, A. V. (1986).In “Biotechnology Risk Assessment, Issues and Methods for Environmental Introductions” (J. Fiksel and V. T. Covello, eds.), pp. 109-128. Pergamon, New York. Bell, J. B., Macrae, W. R., and Elliott, G.E. (1981).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 42,204-210. Best, D. J., Jones, J., and Stafford, D. (1985).In “Biotechnology Principles and Application” (I. J. Higgins, D.J. Bes, and J. Jones, eds.), pp. 213-256. Blackwell, Oxford. Betz, F., Levin, M., and Rogul, M. (1983).Recomb. DNA Tech. Bull. 6,135-141. Burton, G. C., Hirch, D. C., Blenden, D. C., and Zeigler, J. L. (1974).In “The Normal Microbial Flora of Man” (F. R. Skinner and J. G . Carr. eds.), pp. 241-253. Academic Press, London. Burton, N. F., Day, M. A., and Bull, A. T. (1982).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 44,1026-1029. Chakrabarty, A. (1974).U S . Pat. 3,813,316. Chilton, M. D., Defronon, A., and Fraley, R. (1983).Miami Winter Symp. 15th Abstr. Cole, M. A., and Elkan, G. H. (1979).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 37,867-870. Coombs, J.(1986).“Dictionary of Biotechnology,” Elsevier, New York. Corliss, T. L., Cohen, P. S . , and Cabelli, V. J. (1981).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 41, 959-966.
Demain A. L. (1986).“Lecture Notes in Industrial Microbiology Course 20.821.” Mass. Inst. Technol., Cambridge. Demain, A. L., and Solomon, N. A. (1981).In “Industrial Microbiology and the Advent of Genetic Engineering.” Freeman, San Francisco, California. Dorn, E., Hellwing, M., Reineke, W., and Knackmuss, H. J. (1974).Arch. Microbiol. 99, 61-70.
Eveleigh, D. E. (1981).Sci. Am. 245, 155-178. Feary, T. W., Sturtevant, A. B., and Linkford, J. (1972).Arch. Environ. Health 25,215-220. Fiksel, J. R., and Covello, V. T. (1986).In “Biotechnology Risk Assessment, Issues and Methods for Environmental Introductions” (J. Fiksel and V. T. Covello, eds.), pp. 8-9. Pergamon, New York. Fontain, T. D., and Hoadley, A. W. (1976).Health Lab. Sci. 13,238-245. Forbush, E. H., and Fernald, C. H. (1896).“The Gypsy Moth, Portheria Dispar.” (Linn) Wright & Potter, Boston, Massachusetts. Frommer, W., Ager, B., Archer, L., Brunius, G., Collins, C. H., Donikian, R., Frontali, C., Hamp, S.,Houwick, E. H., Kuenzi, M. T., Kramer, P., Lagast, H., Lund, S . , Mahler, J. L., Normand-Plessier, F., Sargeant, K., Tuijnenburg Muijs, G., Vranch, S. P., and Werner, R. G. (1989).Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 309,541-552.
a4
M. S. THAKUR ET AL.
Gasner, L. L. (1979).In “Microbial Technology” (H. J. Pepper and D. Perlman, eds.), pp. 211-222. Academic Press, New York. Goyal, S. M., and Hoadley, A. W. (1979).Rev. Microbiol. 10, 50-58. Grabow, W. 0.K., and Prozesky, 0. W. (1973).Antirnicrob. Agents Chernother. 3, 175180.
Grabow, W. 0. K., Prozeski, 0.W., and Burger, J. S. (1975).Water Res. 9 777-782. Hada, M. S.,and Sizemore, R. K. (1981).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 41,199-202. Harris, R. G., and Rose, T. J. (1972).Br. Pat. 1,343,963. H a d , D. L. (1985).In “Engineered Organisms in the Environment: Scientific Issues” (H. 0. Halvorson, D. Pramer, and M. Ragul, eds.), pp. 83-88. Am. SOC.Microbiol., Washington, D.C. Hartmann, J., Reineke, W., and Knackmuss, H. J. (1979).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 37, 421-428.
Hopwood, D. A. (1981).In “Industrial Microbiology and the Advent of Genetic Engineering.” Freeman, San Francisco, California. Huber, P.W. (1987).Technol. Rev. Nov./Dec., pp. 57-65. Huq, A., Small, E. B., West, P. A., Huq, M. I., Rehman, R., and Colwell. R. R. (1983).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 45,275-283. Jawetz, E., Melnick, J. L., and Adelberg, E. A. (1974).Review of Medical Microbiology,” 11th Ed. Lange Med. Publ., Los Altos, California. Johnston, J. B. (1981).Proc. Genet. Eng., Int. Conf. Reston, Va. 4, 184-191. Battelle Mem. Inst., Seattle, Washington. Jones, G. L. (1976).Process Biochern. 11,3-5. Kelch, W. J., and Lee, J. S. (1978).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 36,450-456. Klingman, D. L., and Coulson, J. R. (1982).Plant Dis. 66,1205-1209. Krimsky, S., and Fraenkel, A. H. (1985).In “Comprehensive Biotechnology” (M. MooYoung, ed.), Vol. 4,pp. 609-632. Pergamon, New York. Kuenzi, M., Assi, F., Chemiel, A., Collins, C. H., Donikian, M., Dominguez, J. B., Financsek, L., Fogarty, L. M., Frommer, W., Hasko, F., Hovland, S., Houwink, E. H., Mahler, J. L., Sandkvist, A., Sargent, K., Sloover, C., and Tuijnenburg Muijs, G. (1985).Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 21,1-6. Lacey, R. W., and Richmond, M. H. (1974).Ann. N.Y.Acad. Sci. 236,395-412. Lacy, G. H., and Leary, J. V. (1975a).J. Gen. Microbiol. 88,49-57. Lacy, G. H., and Leary, J. V. (1975b).Ann. N.Y.Acad. Sci. 236,395-412. La Font, J.P., Guillot, J. F., Chaslus-Dancla, E., Dho, M., and Eucher-Lahan, M. (1981). Bull. Inst. Pasteur [Paris) 79,213-231. Levy, S.R. (1986).In “Biotechnology Risk Assessment, Issues and Methods for Environmental Introductions” (J. Fiksel and V. T. Covello, eds.), pp. 56-74. Pergamon, New York. Linton, K. B., Richmond, M. A., Bevan, R., and Gillespie, W. A. (1974).1. Med. Microbiol. 7,91-102.
McNicon, L. A., Aziz, K. M. S., Huq, I., Kaper, J. B., Lockman, H. A., Remmers, E. F., Spira, W. M., Voll, M. J., and Colwell, R. R. (1980).Antirnicrob. Agents Chernother. 17, 477-483.
Maing, I. V., Ayers, A. C., and Koehler, P. F. (1973).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 25, 1015-1017.
Marshal, B., and Levy, S.B. (1980).Nature [London) 286,524-525. Marshal, B., Schluederberg, S., Tachibana, C., And Levy, S.B. (1981).Gene 14,145-154. Martin, C. C.(1989).Genet. Eng. News 9(8),1-15. Mellon, M. (1988).“Biotechnology and the Environment: A Primer on the Environmental
ENVIRONMENTAL BIOLOGICAL PROCESSES
85
Implications of Genetic Engineering,” pp. 12-64. Nat. Biotechnol. Policy Cent. Environ. Qual. Div., Nat. Wildl. Fed., Washington, D.C. Merkel, H. W. (1906).N.Y. Zool. SOC.Annu. Rep. 10,97-103. National Wildlife Federation (1990).“The Gene Exchange,” Vol. 1(1),pp. 1-11. Natl. Wildl. Fed., Washington, DC. Norris, P. R., and Kelly, D. P. (1982).In “Microbial Interactions and Communities” (A. T. Bull and J. H. Slatter, eds.), pp. 443-474. Academic Press, New York. Paul, J. K. (1981).”Genetic Engineering Applications for Industry,” Chemical Technology Review, No. 197.Noyes Data Corp., Park Ridge, New Jersey. Petrocheilou, V. J., Grinsted, J,, and Richmond, M. H. (1976).Antimicrob. Agents Chemother. 10, 753-761. Pimmentel, D. (1985).In “Engineered Organisms in the Environment: Scientific Issues” (H. 0. Halvorson, D. Pramer, and M. Ragul, eds.), pp. 129-140. Am. SOC.Microbiol., Washington, D.C. Renney, D. C., Kally, W. J., and Robert, W. P. (1982).In “Microbial Interactions and Communities” (A. T. Bull and J. H. Slatter, eds.), pp. 287-322. Academic Press, New York. Roberts, N. C., Siebeling, R. J., Kaper, J. B., and Brandford, H. B., Jr. (1982).Microb. Ecol. 8, 299-312.
Roe, E., Jones, R. J., and Lowbury, E. J.L. (1971).Lancet i, 149-152. Sayler, G., and Stacey, G. (1986).In “Biotechnology Risk Assessment, Issues and Methods for Environmental Introductions” (J. Fiksel and V. T. Covello, eds.), pp. 35-74. Pergamon, New York. Schift, W., and Klingmuller, W. (1983).Recomb. DNA Tech. Bull. 6,101-102. Senior, E., Bull, A. T., and Slater, J. H. (1976).Nature [London) 263,476-479. Slater, J. H. (1985).In “Engineered Organisms in the Environment: Scientific Issues” (H. 0. Halvorson, D. Pramer, and M. Ragul, eds.), pp. 83-88. Am. SOC.Microbiol., Washington, D.C. Smith, H. W. (1970).Nature [London) 228,1286-1288. Smith, H. W. (1971).Nature [London) 234, 155-156. Smith, J. E. (1985).In “Comprehensive Biotechnology” (M. Moo-Young, ed.), Vol. 4,pp. 543-585. Pergamon, New York. Smith, J. E. (1988).In “Biotechnology” (J. E. Smith, ed.), pp. 1-10. Arnold, London. Smith, L. B., and Hardley, C. H. (1926).U.S.Dep. Agric., Circ. No. 363,1-66. Smith, M. G.(1975).Nature [London) 261,348. Smith, M. G. (1977).J. Med. Microbiol. 10,29-35. Smith, P. R., Farrel, E., and Dunican, K. (1974).Appl. Microbiol. 27,983-984. Stead, D. G. (1935).“The Rabbit in Australia.” Winn, Sydney. Sturtevant, A. B., and Feary, T. W. (1969).Appl. Microbiol. 18,918-924. Talbot, H. W., Yamamoto, D. Y., Smith, M. W., and Seidler, R. J. (1980).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 39,97-104. Thakur, M. S. (1988).Nat. Summer Inst. Sir Hari singh Gour Univ., Sagar [M.P.), India Pap. Timoney, J. F., Port, J., Giles J., and Spanier, J. (1978).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 36, 465-472.
Tuovinen, 0. H. (1986).In “Workshop on Biotechnology for the Mining, Metal-Refining and Fossil Fuel Processing Industries” (H. L. Ehrlich and D. S. Holmes, eds.), pp. 65-72. Wiley (Interscience), New York. Ward, 0. P. (1983).In “Microbial Enzyme and Biotechnology” (W. M. Fogarty, ed.), pp. 251-288. Appl. Sci., London.
86
M. S. THAKUR ET AL.
Watanabe, T., Aoki, T., Ogata, Y., and Eugusa, S. (1971).Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci. 182, 383-410. Weinberg, S. R., and Stotzky, G. (1972).Soil Biol. Biochem. 4,171-180. Wickelgren, I. (1989).Sci. News 136(8),113-128. Winchester, A. M. (1977).“Heredity: An Introduction to Genetics,” 3rd Ed. Barnes & Noble, New York. Yokotsuka, T., Sasaki, M., Kikuchi, T., Asao, Y., and Nabuhara, A. (1967). Nippon Nogei Kagaku Kaishi 41,32-38. Zaugg, R. H., and Swartz, J. R. (1982). Recomb. DNA Tech. Bull. 5, 7-13.
Fate of Recombinant Escherichia coli K-12 Strains in the Environment GREGGBOGOSIANAND JAMES F. KANE Animal Sciences Division Monsanto Company St. Louis. Missouri 63198 I. Introduction 11. Construction and Properties of pBR322 A. Conjugational Transfer of pBR322 B. Stability of pBR322 C. Factors Affecting Conjugational Transfer 111. Fate of E. coli and Related Organisms in Water Conjugational Transfer with Organisms Inhabiting Water IV. Fate of E. coli and Related Organisms in Soil A. Survival in Sterile Soil B. Survival in Nonsterile Soil C. Conjugational Transfer with Organisms Inhabiting Soil V. Fate of E. coli and Related Organisms in Sewage Conjugational Transfer with Organisms Inhabiting Sewage VI. Fate of E. coli K-12 in the Mammalian Intestinal Tract Conjugational Transfer with Organisms Inhabiting the Mammalian Intestinal Tract VII. Alternative Detection Methods for Recombinant Organisms in the Environment VIII. Conclusions References
I. Introduction
The advent of modern recombinant DNA techniques has ushered in an era of increasing use of engineered organisms for the production of desired proteins and other types of products. Most commonly, such production systems employ Escherichia coli K-12 strains containing recombinant plasmids derived from pBR322. The number of literature and patent reports of such systems is increasing rapidly, and E. coli protein production systems are now used on a commercial as well as a research scale. Typically, commercial production of proteins from recombinant strains of E. coli involves large-scale fermentation of the production strain. These industrial fermentations range in size from hundreds of liters to tens of thousands of liters, with culture densities attaining 1 X lo9 to 1 X 10" cells/ml (Calcott eta]., 1988). (or more] recombinant E. coli cells The prospect of up to 1 x being inadvertently released into the environment during some type of catastrophic industrial accident has ignited considerable interest in the 87 ADVANCES IN APPLIED MICROBIOLOGY, VOLUME 36 Copyright 0 1991 by Academic Press, Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved.
88
GREGG BOGOSIAN AND JAMES F. KANE
determination of the likely consequences of such an event. Such interest has centered on whether recombinant E. coli K-12 strains can survive in natural environments and whether the recombinant plasmid they contain can be transferred to indigenous inhabitants of these environments. All of the studies to date have failed to grapple with the far more complicated question of what the environmental impact would be of such survival or transfer if it were to occur. This article is a review of the scientific literature dealing with the survival of E. coli K-12 strains containing recombinant plasmids derived from pBR322 and the potential to transfer such plasmids to other organisms in the environment. Studies involving transfer from other species of organisms or of other types of plasmids are included when pertinent. In addition, factors affecting such transfer are also considered. The environments covered in this review are soil, water, sewage, and the mammalian intestinal tract. Since the advent of recombinant DNA research, several more general reviews that have been published cover aspects not included here (Curtiss et al., 1977; Chatigny et al., 1979; Sharples, 1983; Stotzky and Babich, 1984, 1986; Rissler, 1984; Strauss et al., 1986; Regal, 1987;Roszak and Colwell, 1987; Tiedje eta]., 1989). The E. coli strain K-12 was isolated in 1922 from the feces of a convalescent diphtheria patient at the Stanford Medical School (Bachmann, 1987). The strain was stocked in the culture collection of the bacteriology department at Stanford, and was used as an E. coli standard in microbiology courses in that department. Years of laboratory cultivation led to the loss of the K and 0 antigens from this strain (I. Orskov and Orskov, 1960; F. Orskov and Orskov, 1961). Many subsequent studies, reviewed in this article, demonstrated that strains of E. coli K-12 did not persist in nonsterile water, soil, sewage, or the conventional mammalian intestinal tract. These studies indicated maximal survival times of approximately 15 days in water, 20 days in soil, 10 days in sewage, and 3-6 days in the intestinal tract of normal hosts. In considering the survival of E. coli K-12 strains in environments such as these, and the potential for transfer of recombinant plasmids from these strains to indigenous microbial inhabitants of such environments, several points should be kept in mind. The conjugative transfer of pBR322 or its derivatives requires several conditions. First, a conjugative plasmid is required to mediate conjugative pore formation. Second, a mobilization plasmid is required to provide trans-acting components of the transfer complex. Third, the pBR322 plasmid or derivative thereof has to contain functional born and nic sites (see later) involved in
ENVIRONMENTAL FATE OF RECOMBINANT E. coli K-12
89
transfer. Additionally, the only known habitat for E. coli is the intestinal tract of warm-blooded vertebrates (Brenner, 1984; Stanier et al., 1986). The presence of E. coli in soil or water is taken as evidence of recent (within 1 to 2 days) fecal contamination (Geldreich, 1966). Finally, as discussed in this review, E. coli K-12 is a strain not suited for survival in sewage or the mammalian intestinal tract. These features place E. coli K-12 strains at’a distinct disadvantage in environments outside the laboratory. When compounded with the stringent conditions required for gene transfer plus the limitations of pBR322-type plasmids, it is not surprising that the transfer of recombinant plasmids from strains of E. coli K-12 to indigenous inhabitants of water, soil, sewage, or normal intestinal tracts, in their natural environments, has never been demonstrated. II. Construction and Properties of pBR322
The plasmid pBR322 (Bolivar et al., 1977) is one of the most widely used cloning vehicles because of the extensive body of information on its structure and function (reviewed in Balbas et al., 1986, 1988). pBR322 consists of three distinct segments: a gene encoding tetracycline resistance, a gene encoding ampicillin resistance, and an origin of DNA replication. The tetracycline-resistance gene is derived from the naturally occurring R-factor pSCl01. The mechanism of action of this gene product places it in the class C tetracycline-resistance group, in that tetracycline is actively excluded from the cell. The ampicillinresistance gene is derived from the transposon Tn3. This gene encodes a TEM-1-P-lactamase, which catalyzes the conversion of penicillins to inactive penicilloic acids by hydrolysis of the p-lactam ring. pBR322 contains a relaxed (associated with replication proteins in vivo) origin of replication derived from pMB1. Plasmids pMBl and ColEl have essentially identical origins of replication; the only difference is a 2base-pair inversion (this is found at coordinates 2731-2732 on pBR322). Thus, pBR322 is said to have a ColEl-type origin of replication. In addition to the origin of DNA replication (ori), adjacent sequences from pMBl are also present on pBR322. These include the basis of mobility site (bom) and the site at which the plasmid DNA is nicked prior to transfer (nic), both of which are involved in conjugational transfer, and the repressor of primer (rop) gene. The rop gene encodes the 63-amino-acid Rop protein, which participates in the negative regulation of the frequency of initiation of DNA replication at ori (Cesareni et a]., 1984).
90
GREGG BOGOSIAN AND JAMES F. KANE
A. CONJUGATIONAL TRANSFER OF pBR322 Conjugational transfer is a process by which plasmid DNA is transferred (or mobilized) from one cell to another, usually with cells of the same species. The conjugative transfer of plasmid DNA is a complex process, requiring the concerted action of many gene products (reviewed in Clark and Warren, 1979; Willetts and Wilkins, 1984; IppenIhler and Minkley, 19861. Many large conjugative plasmids (such as F) are capable of autonomous transfer, whereas much smaller plasmids (such as ColE1) can only be transferred from a donor cell that also contains a conjugative plasmid. The role of the conjugative plasmid in mobilization of other plasmids seems to be to provide pilus-mediated cell contact and to mediate conjugation pore formation. As stated above, ColEl is a nonconjugative but mobile plasmid that contains two DNA segments, mob and bom, that are involved in mobilization (Warren et al., 1978). This plasmid appears to be transferred whole and unaltered, with no reports of cointegrates forming between ColEl and resident conjugative plasmids. The transfer of ColEl is an active rather than passive process, because Mob- derivatives of ColEl have been found. The conjugational mobility of ColEl appears to require both a diffusible gene product(s), encoded by the mob gene(s),and a mobility site on the plasmid DNA, designated born. The Mob- derivatives of ColEl can be mobilized if the donor cell also contains the plasmid ColK. Apparently, the ColK plasmid encodes a similar diffusible product(s) that is capable of complementing the missing mobilization factor(s) of the Mob- ColE1. Derivatives of ColEl that are Bomcannot be transferred. This deficiency cannot be complemented by an intact ColK plasmid. Another site on ColE1, termed nic, serves as the origin of conjugational transfer; as mentioned previously, it is the site at which the ColEl DNA is nicked prior to transfer. The nic site is located within the born site (Warren et al., 1978). 1. Function of the Mob Site
To test whether pBR322 can be mobilized, a series of biparental and triparental matings were performed (Bolivar et al., 1977). A biparental mating is one in which the conjugative plasmid and the nonconjugative plasmid coreside in one strain (the donor), and a second strain containing a chromosomal marker serves as the recipient. Selection is made for the presence of the resistance markers on the nonconjugative plasmid and the chromosomal marker of the recipient. For the biparental matings, E. coli K-12 strain C600 containing two plasmids was mated with the nalidixic acid-resistant E. coli K-12 strain SF185. In one set of
ENVIRONMENTAL FATE OF RECOMBINANT E. coli K-12
91
matings, C600 contained both the Mob+ plasmid ColEl and either the conjugative plasmid F-Km (of the FI incompatibility group) or the conjugative plasmid Rldrd (of the FII incompatibility group). Conjugative plasmids are classified into incompatibility groups on the basis of their inability to coexist in the same cell (Datta, 1979);in general, identical or related plasmids are incompatible and heterologous plasmids are compatible. Equal amounts of Luria broth (L-broth) cultures of both C600 containing either of the plasmid pairs and SF185 were mixed and held with no agitation for 24 hours at 37°C. In this type of biparental mating, ColEl was transferred to SF185 at a frequency of about 0.5 transfers/ cell124 hours. In the second set of biparental matings, C600 contained both pBR322 and either the F-Km or Rldrd conjugative plasmids. The mating with SF185 was performed in the same manner. In this case, no transfer of pBR322 to SF185 could be detected (< 1 X transfers/ cell124 hours). From this result, it was concluded that pBR322 was Mob-. A triparental mating is one in which the conjugative plasmid resides in one strain (the donor), the nonconjugative plasmid to be tested for mobilization resides in another (the intermediate), and a third strain carrying a chromosomal marker serves as the final recipient. The triparental mating thus tests for the ability of the conjugative plasmid to be transferred to the intermediate and there mobilize the nonconjugative plasmid for transfer to the final recipient. Selection is made for the resistance markers present on the nonconjugative plasmid and the chromosome of the final recipient. In this case, six different donors were tested, namely, E. coli K-12 strain J5-3, containing one of the following conjugative plasmids: F-Km (of the FI incompatibility group), Rldrd (of the FII incompatibility group), R144 (of the Ia incompatibility group), N3 (of the N incompatibility group), Sa (of the W incompatibility group), or RSF1040 (of the X incompatibility group). Two intermediate strains were tested, E. coli K-12 strains C600 or ~ 1 7 7 6containing , pBR322. The final recipient was E. coli K-12 strain W1485-1 (nalidixic acid resistant). The three strains (donor, intermediate, and final recipient) were grown at 37OC in L-broth containing diaminopimelate (DAP) and thymine to a density of 1-9 x lo8 celldml, and equal volumes of each culture were mixed and held at 37°C without agitation for 1, 4, or 24 hours before selective plating. In all cases, no transfer of pBR322 to W1485-1 could be detected (<1x transfers/cell/N hours). As a control, an intermediate strain containing the Mob+ plasmid pRSF2124 (ColE1 with an ampicillin-resistance gene) was used; this plasmid was transferred to W1485-1 at a frequency of 1 x lo-* transfers/cell/4 hours.
92
GREGG BOGOSIAN AND JAMES F. KANE
The observations of Bolivar et al. (1977)were confirmed and extended in a subsequent paper (Young and Poulis, 1978). A biparental mating was performed using strain C600 containing the conjugative plasmid F and pBR322 as the donor and a streptomycin-resistant derivative of C600 as the recipient, The strains were grown in minimal medium to midlogarthmic phase, equal quantities mixed, and held at 37°C with gentle shaking for 1 hour. Although the recipient cells were found to have received the F plasmid at a frequency of 8 X 10-1 transferslcelll hour, no transfer of pBR322 to the recipient could be detected (<2 x transfers/cell/hour). Two Mob+ control plasmids were used, pSF2124 and pGM706; both are ColEl with antibiotic-resistance elements. In identical biparental matings, pSF2124 was transferred to the recipient cells at a frequency of 1.4 x 10-1 transfers/cell/hour and pGM706 was transferred to the recipient cells at a frequency of 5 X lo-’ transfers/cell/hour. Next, Young and Poulis investigated the effect of the Mob+ ColK plasmid on the mobilization of pBR322 by conjugative plasmids. The E. coli K-12 strain GWllO containing the conjugative plasmid R64drdll (of the Ia incompatibility group], the Mob+ ColK derivative ColK235, and pBR322, as well as C600 containing the conjugative plasmid F and ColK235 and pBR322, were used as donors in biparental matings with streptomycin-resistant C600 as recipient, as described above. The R64drdll factor transferred to the recipient cells at a frequency of about 3 x 10-1 transfers/cell/hour; the F factor was transferred to the recipient cells at a frequency of 8 x 10-1 transfers/ cell/hour. In the presence of F and ColK235, no transfer of pBR322 to the transfers/cell/hour). However, recipient could be detected (<2 x in the presence of R64drdll and ColK235, the recipient cells received pBR322 at a frequency of 6 x lo-’ transfers/cell/hour. The pBR322 was found to have been transferred unaltered. From the results of the first biparental mating, it was concluded that a diffusible product(s) encoded by the mob gene(s) of ColEl (in this case, the ColEl derivatives pSF2124 or pGM706) was required for efficient mobilization of these ColEl derivatives by F or R64drdll. Furthermore, pBR322 was found to be defective; it does not carry the required mob gene(s) involved in ColEl transfer. From the result of the second biparental mating, it was concluded that ColK could provide the missing factor(s) in trans for R64drdll but not for F. Although the F factor mobilized ColEl effectively, it mobilized ColK very poorly (Hardy, 19751, suggesting that the conjugative factors from F and ColK were incompatible in effecting transfer. The nature of the mob region on ColEl has recently been elucidated (Boyd et al., 1989). The region was found to be composed of four
ENVIRONMENTAL FATE OF RECOMBINANT E. coli K-12
93
structural genes, all of which were required for mobilization of ColEl by the conjugative plasmid R64drdll. The four genes were designated mbeABCD; the mbeA gene encodes a 517-amino acid protein of molecular weight 58,000, the mbeB gene encodes a 172-amino acid protein of molecular weight 20,000, the mbeC gene encodes a 107-amino acid protein of molecular weight 13,000, and the mbeD gene encodes a 77-amino acid protein of molecular weight 9000. Similar proteins were found to be encoded by the corresponding region on ColK; these four genes were designated mbkABCD (Boyd et al., 1989). ColA is another colicinogenic plasmid with a mob region similar to that of ColEl and ColK (Morlon et al., 1988a);in the presence of R64drdl1, a derivative of the Born+ Mob- plasmid pUC8 carrying the ColA Mob+ region could be mobilized (Morlon et a]., 1988b). Presumably, pBR322 could be mobilized in the presence of a conjugative plasmid such as R64drdll and the Mob+ plasmid ColA. The four genes in the mob region of ColA were designated mbaABCD (Boyd et al., 1989). 2. Function of the bom and nic Sites
In addition to the diffusible factors encoded by the mob genes, the bom and nic sites on pBR322 were shown to be essential for mobilization by conjugative plasmids (Twiggand Sherratt, 1980).A derivative of pBR322 was constructed in which the HaeII fragment B was deleted; this is a deletion of 622 base pairs between the HaeII sites at coordinates 1731 and 2353 of pBR322, and includes the bom and nic sites as well as the rop gene. The resulting plasmid was designated pAT153. As a result of the deletion of the rop gene, the copy number of pAT153 was 1.5 to 3-fold higher than the parental plasmid pBR322. Biparental mating experiments were performed with pBR322 and pAT153; in this report, the E. coli K-12 strains used were not identified and the mating conditions were not specified. In the first biparental mating, the donor strain contained the conjugative plasmid R64drdll and either pBR322 or pAT153; no transfer of either nonconjugative plasmid to the recipient strain could be detected (<8 x transfers/cell for pBR322, and <1 x lop5 transferdcell for pAT153). In the second biparental mating, the donor strain contained R64drdll and the Mob+ plasmid ColK and either pBR322 or pATl53. With this donor strain, pBR322 was transferred to the recipient strain at a frequency of 9 X lo-’ transfedcell but no transfer of pAT153 to the recipient strain could be detected transferdcell). An additional biparental mating was done (<4 x with a derivative of ColE1, which lacked the same HaeII fragment: transfer of this plasmid was also undetectable. Thus, deletion of the bom
94
GREGG BOGOSIAN AND JAMES F. KANE
and nic sites rendered ColEl Mob- and eliminated the ColK-dependent R64drdll-mediated transfer of pBR322. The function of the bom and nic sites on pBR322 was further investigated by Covarrubias et al. (1981), who flipped the orientation of the HaeII fragment B to create the plasmid pBR3286. Biparental matings were performed with E. coli K-12 strain J53 containing either the conjugative plasmid R64drdll or R64drdll plus the Mob+ plasmid ColK, as well as either pBR322 or pBR3286, as the donor and E. coli K-12 strain J54 (nalidixic acid resistant) as the recipient. For the matings, the donor and recipient strains were grown in L-broth at 37°C until a density of 1 x 10' cells/ml was reached; the cultures were then mixed in a 1: 10 ratio of donor to recipient, respectively, and held without shaking at 37OC for 90 minutes prior to plating on a selective medium. In the presence of R64drdl1, no transfer of either pBR322 or pBR3286 to strain J54 could be detected (c2.5 x lo-' transfers/cell/90 minutes for transfers/cell/90 minutes for pBR3286). In pBR322, and C5.7 X the presence of both R64drdll and ColK, pBR322 was transferred to transfers/cell/90 minutes, but no strain J54 at a frequency of 6.4 x transfer of pBR3286 to strain J54 could be detected (<5.6 x transfers/cell/90 minutes). It was concluded that the orientation of the bom and nic sites relative to ori was crucial to the conjugational transfer of pBR322. Further investigations on the bom and nic sites were performed by Finnegan and Sherratt (1982) (Table I). They compared the activity of the diffusible gene products from the Mob+ plasmids ColK and ColEl on the transfer of pBR322. The ColEl mob gene products were provided by the plasmid pGJ28, a ColD replicon carrying the ColEl mob genes; pGJ28 was used as the source of the ColEl mob genes because ColEl and pBR322 (which has a ColEl-type origin of DNA replication) cannot coexist in the same cell. Three duplicate sets of biparental matings were performed for this analysis. The matings were carried out by mixing equal volumes of mid-logarithmic-phase L-broth cultures of donor cells TABLE I
FREQUENCY OF TRANSFER OF pBR322 AS A FUNCTION OF THE Mob+ PLASMID Conjugative plasmid R64drdll F'-lac-pro R388
Mob+ plasmid
Recipient
ColK pGJZE(ColE1) pGJ28(ColEl)
CSH27 CSH5l CSH51
Frequency of transfer of pBR322 8x
5.4
X
and 4.2 x lo-' >1 lo-* and 1.6 X low4
lo-'
ENVIRONMENTAL FATE OF RECOMBINANT E. coli K-12
95
with stationary-phase L-broth cultures of recipient cells, and holding the cells at 37°C for 2-3 hours without agitation prior to plating on selective medium. In this investigation, the identity of the E. coli K-12 strain used as donor was not reported. In the first set of biparental matings the donor strain contained the conjugative plasmid R64drdl1, the Mob+ plasmid ColK, and pBR322, and the recipient strain was CSH27; pBR322 was transferred to CSH27 at frequencies of 8 x lo-' and 4.2 x lo-' transfers/cell/2-3 hours. In the second set of biparental matings the donor strain contained the conjugative plasmid F' lac pro, the Mob+ plasmid pGJ28, and pBR322, and the recipient strain was CSH51; in both duplicate matings, pBR322 was transferred to CSH51 at a frequency of >1 transfer/cell/2-3 hours (i.e., all of the recipient cells had received at least one pBR322 molecule). In the third set of biparental matings the donor strain contained the conjugative plasmid R388 (of the W incompatibility group), the Mob+ plasmid pGJ28, and pBR322, and the recipient strain was CSH51; pBR322 was transferred to CSH51 at frequencies of 5.4 x lop4 and 1.6 x transfers/cell/2-3 hours. From these results, it was concluded that pBR322 can be mobilized from cells containing a conjugative plasmid and a plasmid providing the products of the mob genes from either ColK or ColE1. Additionally, these workers made deletion derivatives of pBR322, which narrowed the location of the born and nic sites down to a 141-base-pair HhaI fragment between coordinates 2 2 1 1 and 2352. In contrast to the results of Covarrubias et al. (1981),it was found that the orientation of the born and nic sites relative to ori made no difference on conjugational transfer. Finnegan and Sherratt suggested that Covarrubias et al. may have flipped a DNA fragment that resulted in an inactivated born site. 3. Deletion Derivatives of pBR322
A widely used derivative of pBR322 that lacks the rop gene and the born and nic sites is pBR327 (Soberon et al., 1980). This derivative was generated by partially digesting pBR322 with EcoRII to remove the fragment between coordinates 1441 and 2501, followed by treatment with S1 nuclease and religation to yield a plasmid that had lost a total of 1089 base pairs. This new plasmid, pBR327, was sequenced across the region of the deletion. The following DNA sequence was found:
***
GGCGCATCTCGGGCCGCGTTGCTG
I
I
2520 The coordinates given below the sequence are those of pBR322. The 1420
96
GREGG BOGOSIAN AND JAMES F. KANE
deletion end points lie within the 3-base-pair joint highlighted by the asterisks above the sequence; because of a 3-base-pair duplication in the region of the deletion end points, the exact location of the deletion end points could not be assigned. Because pBR327 lacks the rop gene, the copy number was elevated relative to that of pBR322; by one estimate, the copy number of pBR322 was 18 and that of pBR327 was 51 (Covarrubias et al., 1981).In addition, pBR327 lacks the born and nic sites, and so should not be mobilized under conditions that do mobilize pBR322. As stated above, this was the case for pAT153, a pBR322 derivative with a similar deletion of the born and nic sites (Twigg and Sherratt, 1980).Two biparental mating experiments with pBR327 confirmed this expectation (Covarrubias et al., 1981).The biparental matings were performed with E. coli K-12 strain J53 containing either the conjugative plasmid R64drdll or R64drdll plus the Mob+ plasmid ColK, as well as pBR327, as the donor and E. coli K-12 strain J54 (nalidixic acid resistant) as the recipient. For the matings, the donor and recipient strains were grown in L-broth at 37°C until a density of 1 x 10’ cells/ml was reached; the cultures were then mixed in a 1: 10 ratio of donor to recipient, respectively, and held without shaking at 37°C for 90 minutes prior to plating on a selective medium. In the presence of R64drdl1, no transfer of pBR327 to strain J54 could be detected (<7.8 x transfers/cell/90 minutes). In the presence of both R64drdll and ColK, no transfer of pBR327 to strain J54 could be detected (<4.8 x lo-’ transfers/cell/90 minutes). Control matings with pBR322 resulted in transfer in the presence of both R64drdll and ColK. In summary, the conjugational transfer of pBR322 requires three separate components: 1. Intact born and nic sites on the pBR322 plasmid molecule. 2. The four proteins encoded by the mbeABCD genes of a ColEl plasmid, or the similar proteins from a ColK or a ColA plasmid. 3. A conjugative plasmid. 4. Conjugational Transfer of Portions of pBR322
There have been two reports of transfer of portions of pBR322 in the presence of only a conjugative plasmid. Dougan et al. (1978) carried out a series of biparental matings in which the donor was either E. coli K-12 strain C600 or strain ~ 1 7 7 6each , containing both pBR322 and either the conjugative plasmid Rldrd or the conjugative plasmid R64-11 (of the Ia incompatibility group), or the conjugative plasmid N31 (of the N incompatibility group), and the recipient was strain SF185. The donor and recipient strains were grown at 37°C in L-broth containing DAP and thymine to densities of about 2.5 x lo7 cells/ml, and equal volumes of
ENVIRONMENTAL FATE OF RECOMBINANT E. coli K-12
97
each culture were mixed and held at 37°C without agitation for 6 hours before selective plating. With the donors that contained conjugative plasmid R64-11 or N31, no transfer of pBR322 to strain SF185 could be detected (<1 X lo-' transfers/cell/6 hours). However, with the donors that contained conjugative plasmid Rldrd, ampicillin resistance was transfers/ transferred to strain SF185 at a frequency of about 1 x cell/6 hours. An explanation for this observation was provided by Gealt et al. (1985), who performed a triparental mating using E. coli K-12 strain ~ 1 7 8 containing 4 the conjugative plasmid R100-1 as the donor, E. coli K-12 Dap- strain ~ 2 6 5 containing 6 pBR322 as the intermediate, and E. coli K-12 strain ~ 1 9 9 7(Dap+ and nalidixic acid resistant) as the recipient. The cultures were grown independently in L-broth prior to mixing; equal volumes of each culture (containing about 1.5 x 10' cells/ml of the intermediate, and about 2 X lo9 celldm1 of the donor and recipient) were mixed and held without agitation for 25 hours at 37°C before plating on a selective medium. Under these conditions, ampicillin resistance was transferred to ~ 1 9 9 at 7 a frequency of about 1 X lop4 transfers/cell/25 hours. Examination of the plasmid DNA present in the ampicillin-resistant ~ 1 9 9 7derivatives revealed that a cointegrate had formed between pBR322 and R100-1, consisting of the entire ampicillin-resistance element of pBR322 and all of R100-1. Thus, conjugational transfer of whole plasmids cannot always be detected by antibiotic resistance alone. In the absence of a mobilization plasmid, only segments of pBR322-derived plasmids can be transferred by conjugative plasmids; such segments can include antibiotic resistance genes, yielding false positive results. B. STABILITY OF pBR322
The maintenance and genetic stability of pBR322 has been investigated in a variety of studies. The presence of pBR322 had no effect on the efficiency of plating the E. coli K-12 strain ~ 1 7 7 either 6 on Luria agar (L-agar) containing DAP and thymine, or on M9 salts-casamino acid agar containing DAP and thymine, and no effect on the survival of ~ 1 7 7 6 in DAP-less media (Bolivar et al., 1977). There have been reports of plasmid loss when cultures of plasmid-containing cells were grown either in nutrient-limited chemostats or in batch cultures for over 30 generations. In glucose-limited or phosphate-limited chemostats without antibiotic selection, pBR322 was lost from E. coli K-12 strains W3110, W5445, and HBlOl after about 30 generations (Godwin and Slater, 1979; Jones et al., 1980;Wouters et al., 1980). Similarly, Vernet et al. (1985) found that in a phosphate-limited chemostat without antibi-
98
GREGG BOGOSIAN AND JAMES F. KANE
otic selection, pBR322 was lost from E. coli K-12 strain BW270 after about 25 generations. These results were in contrast to those of Noack et al. (1981), who observed that in glucose-limited or nitrogen-limited chemostats without antibiotic selection, pBR322 was stable for 75 generations in E. coli K-12 strains GY2354 or GM31. These apparent differences in plasmid stability likely can be attributed to different host cells and growth-limiting conditions. It would not be unexpected that the cellular responses to phosphate limitation would be different from those of glucose or nitrogen limitation. However, glucose limitation was common to the work of both Noack et al. and Jones et al., so it is worth examining their results more closely. Noack et al. used a limiting glucose concentration of 0.05% in a medium containing 0.01% casamino acids and the trace metals iron and manganese. Jones et al. used 0.02% glucose, with only the amino acids required by the hosts and calcium as supplements. Though these apparent differences in stability may implicate the role that the host strain has in this process, one should not discount the variations in the media used by these investigators as a possible explanation for the discrepancies. Chiang and Bremer (1988)examined the stability of pBR322 and some of its derivatives in the E. coli B/r strain HB117 grown in batch cultures. In these experiments the strain was inoculated into L-broth without antibiotics and was grown to maximal density and subcultured into fresh L-broth. Growth and subculturing were repeated over a 3- to 4-day time period. Under these growth conditions, pBR322 was lost from the cells within 60 generations. In addition to the question of the maintenance of pBR322, it is also important to determine the integrity of the plasmid DNA in the cells after extended periods of growth. Noack et al. (1981) isolated pBR322 from cells grown 75 generations in a chemostat and found that the plasmid was structurally unaltered. These results suggested that the maintenance of the plasmid in the majority of the population for such a long period of time did not predispose the plasmid to structural changes. In the chemostat experiments conducted by Jones et al. (1980), only 1% of the E. coli population retained pBR322 after 30 generations; nevertheless, plasmid DNA isolated from these cells did not differ in any respect from the parental pBR322. Thus, despite a condition that favored the loss of plasmid, no structural changes could be detected. Similar results were obtained by Reinikainen and Virkajarvi (1989)from strain HBlOl containing pBR322. After 300-400 generations in an Lbroth chemostat containing ampicillin (the growth-limiting factor in this case was unknown), the pBR322 plasmid was genetically stable.
ENVIRONMENTAL FATE OF RECOMBINANT E. coli K-12
99
C. FACTORS AFFECTING CONIUGATIONAL TRANSFER The biparental and triparental matings described above were all carried out under similar laboratory conditions. For the most part, both donor and recipient strains were grown at 37°C in L-broth, and were mixed in L-broth and held without agitation or with very gentle agitation at 37°C in order to facilitate conjugational transfer. Obviously, these conditions do not mimic those that would be encountered in natural environments. Studies on plasmid transfer in natural environments, or under conditions approximating natural environments, will be discussed in more detail below. There have been a number of studies addressing the question of what factors may affect conjugational transfer (reviewed in Holloway, 1979; Reanney et al., 1983; Freter, 1984). The rate of transfer of a variety of conjugative plasmids between E. coli K-12 strains has been shown to be affected by the growth rates of the donor and recipient strains, the state of aerobiosis, and the temperature. Plasmid DNA transfer was much more rapid with cells in the midlogarithmic phase of growth than in the stationary phase (Ozeki et al., 1962; Broda et al., 1977; Cullum et al., 1978; Levin et al., 1979), although the rate of cell-to-cell contact formation dropped more slowly as the cultures entered stationary phase (Cullum et al., 1978). Conjugational transfer rates were found to be relatively insensitive to cell density and to the donor-to-recipient ratio (Levin et al., 1979). The rate of transfer of conjugative R-factors was unaffected by aerobic versus anaerobic mating conditions (Moodie and Woods, 1973). The transfer of the conjugative plasmid Rldrd-19 between E. coli K-12 strains was found to proceed well at temperatures of 27-37"C, poorly at temperatures of 17-22"C, and not at all at 15°C (Singleton and Anson, 1981). In laboratory experiments with mixed populations of E. coli strains, either plasmid free or containing conjugative or nonconjugative plasmids, the plasmid-containing cells were quickly relegated to minority status but were never lost (Stewart and Levin, 1977; Levin and Stewart, 1980; Helling et al., 1981). The presence of a nonconjugative plasmid did not affect the ability of E. coli K-12 strains to participate in conjugation (Levin and Rice, 1980). In natural populations of E. coli, the occurrence of strains containing conjugative plasmids was low (about 20%), but was the same as it had been in the so-called preantibiotic era (Hughes and Datta, 1983); the difference was that in the postantibiotic era, conjugative plasmids were observed to almost always carry genes encoding resistance to a broad variety of antibiotics. The point is that the
100
GREGG BOGOSIAN AND JAMES F. KANE
presence of such plasmids did not impart any advantage to the cell in natural populations (Stewart and Levin, 1977; Levin and Stewart, 1980), and therefore plasmid-containing cells constituted a low proportion of the total population. This low frequency of occurrence of conjugative plasmids in natural populations of E. coli was consistent with the observation that such populations exhibited a low rate of genetic recombination (Selander and Levin, 1980). The type of pili encoded by the conjugative plasmid had a significant effect on the relationship between conjugational transfer rates and the physical state of the mating medium (Bradley, 1981). With donors that contained conjugative plasmids from the Ia,K, FII, H1, J, V, or com9 incompatibility groups, the pili produced were flexible and the rate of conjugational transfer was unaffected by liquid versus surface matings. With donors that contained conjugative plasmids from the C, D, TI or X incompatibility groups, thick flexible pili were produced and the rate of conjugational transfer was 50-250 times greater with surface matings than with liquid matings. With donors that contained conjugative plasmids from the M, N, P, U, or W incompatibility groups, rigid pili were produced and the rate of conjugational transfer was 2000-30,000 times greater with surface matings than with liquid matings. Similar results were observed with other species of bacteria (Genthner et al., 1988). The relative effectiveness of a variety of mating methods was assessed with several species of bacteria, confirming these other studies (Walter et a]., 1987). Finally, for conjugational transfer to occur, the donor must be able to survive under the conditions of the environment where the mating is to take place. This is a relatively simple condition to meet under laboratory conditions, but may not be the case in natural environments. The fate of E. coli K-12 strains, with and without pBR322-derived plasmids, in the environment will be discussed in each of the sections below. In addition, the conversion of such strains to viable donors, via the receipt of the necessary conjugative and mobilization plasmids, will also be considered. Ill. Fate of E. coli and Related Organisms in Water
The inability of E. coli and related species of bacteria to survive in natural sources of water has been examined by a variety of investigators. In general, the approach is to determine the viable cell count of the test strain in untreated water as well as in a sterilized sample of the water. Liang et al. (1982) determined the survival of a number of Enterobacteriaceae in lake water. When Salmonella typhimurium was added to
ENVlRONMENTAL FATE OF RECOMBINANT E. culi K-12
101
lake water at an initial concentration of 4.2 x lo4 cells/ml, the number of viable cells dropped to 33 celldm1 after 6 days and to undetectable levels after 8 days. When sterile lake water was used, the number of viable organisms remained at about 1 x lo4 cells/ml for the first 5 days, dropped to about 1 X lo3 celldm1 by day 15, and remained at that level through day 20 (the end of the study). It was concluded that other organisms present in nonsterile lake water subjected the S. typhimurium cells to predation, parasitism, lytic enzymes, or toxins, and thus negatively impacted the viability of the test strain. In a similar study Flint (1987) measured the survival of a nalidixic acid-resistant E. coli K-12 strain in untreated river water upstream and downstream of a sewage treatment plant. No analyses of these two water sources were provided, but the time required to decrease the viable cell count by 2 logs (= tg9) was different. With the upstream water source, the tg9 was 2.5 days, whereas in the downstream water the tg9 was 6 days. When the E. coli K-12 strain was inoculated into autoclaved samples of the water sources, the viable cell count remained constant for >ZOO days. It is important to note that the cells did not grow appreciably in this water and at best increased their numbers by approximately twofold. Flint also reported that the rates of cell death were temperature dependent. With a starting concentration of approximately 1 x lo6 cells/ml, the number of viable cells dropped to undetectable levels in 2 days at 37"C, 4 days at 25"C, 8 days at 15"C, and 15 days at 4°C. In sterile river water with an initial concentration of about 1 x lo6 cells/ml, the number of viable cells remained constant over a period of 260 days (the end of the study) at 4 and 15"C, and for 14 days (the end of the study) at 25°C; at 37"C, the number of viable cells dropped to undetectable levels in 8 days. In similar studies with Pseudomonas cepacia and Alcaligenes sp., survival was enhanced when the water samples were supplemented with substrates specifically degraded by the test organism (Steffan et a]., 1989).
The impact of a plasmid on the survival of E. coli has also been examined. Flint reported that the patterns of cell death in his studies were unaffected when the cells contained the conjugative plasmids Rldrd-19 (of the FII incompatibility group) or R144-3 (of the I incompatibility group). Schilf and Klingmuller (1983) reported that plasmidbearing strains of E. coli were unable to survive in nonsterile pond water at various temperatures. Two strains of Enterobacteriaceae, one containing the conjugative plasmid pRD1 and the other containing the conjugative plasmid RP4, as well as E. coli K-12 strain J5 containing the conjugative plasmid RP4 and E. coli K-12 strain JC5466 containing the conjugative plasmid pRD1, were individually added to nonsterile pond
102
GREGG BOGOSIAN AND JAMESF. KANE
water to a concentration of 5 x lo5 celldml; indigenous bacteria were present in the pond water at a concentration of 8.7 x lo4 cells/ml. Under these conditions, the plasmid-bearing Enterobacteriaceae declined by three orders of magnitude in 17-18 days at 4°C and in 8 days at 20°C; the two E. coli K-12 strains declined by three orders of magnitude in 15-22 days at 4°C and in 8 days at 20°C. The levels of the indigenous flora remained constant for the duration of the experiment. Similar results were reported by Smith et al. (1974) with E. coli in seawater and Sanchez and Toranzos (1989) with E. coli K-12 strain DHI containing a derivative of pBR322 (with a small insert) suspended in a diffusion chamber in a river. WITH ORGANISMS INHABITING WATER CONJUGATIONAL TRANSFER
In addition to the question of how long it takes E. coli to die in the environment, there is the additional question of the capacity for genetic transfer by conjugation in these milieu. Toranzo et al. (1984) isolated a variety of bacterial species (from the genera Aeromonas, Citrobacter, Vibrio, and Enterobacter) containing from 1to 5 plasmids (from 1.5 to 90 MDa) with various antibiotic-resistance markers from freshwater fish. These microorganisms were grown overnight in trypticase soy broth and mixed with E. coli K-12 strains at a ratio of 1:2. These mating mixtures were left at 25°C for 18 hours before measuring the number of E. coli that received a plasmid. Based on their experimental description, the cell densities in these tests would have been between 1 x 10' and 1 x 10' cells/ml (both donor and recipient) of broth. These investigators reported relatively low transfer frequencies of about 3 X lo-' to 3 X lo-* transfers/cell/l8 hours, despite the optimized conditions for transfer. Additionally, the indigenous donors only transferred one plasmid and in each case it was the largest in the donor cell. Thus, these conjugative plasmids did not effectively mobilize the other resident plasmids in the donor cells. Many E. coli strains isolated from natural water sources, however, contained conjugative plasmids. In British rivers containing insufficiently treated human sewage, about 50% of the E. coli isolates were resistant to at least one of six tested antibiotics (Smith, 1970);the number of isolates resistant to each antibiotic exhibited the following pattern: ampicillin S- streptomycin > tetracycline > neomycin > chloramphenicol S- nalidixic acid. About 86% of the chloramphenicolresistant isolates were able to transfer this resistance to an F- E. coli K-12 strain, and about 48% transferred the resistance to a S. typhimurium phage type 29 strain. Although the details of the experimental
ENVIRONMENTAL FATE OF RECOMBINANT E. coli K-12
103
procedures were lacking, Smith reported that the transfer of the other antibiotic resistances to an F- E. coli K-12 strain was about 60% for the tetracycline-resistant isolates, 100% for the neomycin-resistant isolates, about 65% for the ampicillin-resistant isolates, about 60% for the streptomycin-resistant isolates, and 0% for the nalidixic acid-resistant isolates. The nalidixic acid resistance was concluded to be chromosomally determined. About 8% of the total E. coli population in a river was found to contain R-factors (Shaw and Cabelli, 1980).In laboratory filter matings for 1hour at 35OC with E. coli K-12 strain CSH26 (nalidixic acid resistant) as recipient, about 50% of these R-factor-containing river isolates were able to transfer the R-factor (at a frequency of about 1 X lo-* transfers/cell/hour). About 10% of R-factor-containing river isolates of Enterobacteriaceae (including strains of E. coli, Klebsiella pneumoniae, Proteus vulgaris, Proteus mirabilis, Enterobacter sp., and Salmonella sp.) were able to transfer the R-factors in laboratory matings to an E. coli K-12 recipient (Kralikova et al., 1983).A different approach to study conjugational transfer to an environmental situation was used by Gowland and Slater (1984).In their experiments, donor and recipient E. coli K-12 strains were suspended in dialysis bags and placed in pond water. The transfer of an R-factor was observed at a frequency of 1-2 x transfers/cell/l92 hours. However, the detection of transfer required cell concentrations of >1 x 10'' celldm1 (for both donor and recipient) of pond water in the bag. When the cell concentration in the dialysis bag was lowered to 1 x 10' cells/ml, no conjugational transfer could be detected even after 360 hours. Trevors and Oddie (1986) reported that with E. coli K-12 strain MA527 containing a conjugative R-plasmid as the donor, and K-12 strain C600 (nalidixic acid resistant) as the recipient, no transfer of the R-factor was observed in sterile stream water at 30, 22, or 15°C. When the water was supplemented with nutrient broth to a final concentration of 0.32% transfer was observed at all temperatures at a frequency of about 3 X loT5 transfers/cell/48 hours. In sterile river water at 15 or 25OC, when an E. coli K-12 strain containing either conjugative plasmid Rldrd-19 or R144-3 was used as the donor and an E. coli K-12 nalidixic acid-resistant strain was used as the recipient, no transfer was observed. Part of the explanation for these observations may be that E. coli grown in water has fewer outer membrane proteins than does E. coli grown in a rich medium, and thus water-grown cells may be less amenable to conjugation pore formation (Chai, 1983). The transfer of R-factors from E. coli K-12 strains to bacteria indigenous to water has also been examined (Schilf and Klingmuller, 1983). The E. coli K-12 strains J5 and JC5466, containing a broad-host-range
104
GREGG BOGOSIAN AND JAMESF. KANE
conjugative plasmid (either RP4 or pRDl), were mated on solid media (tryptone agar plates) at 37°C for 16 hours with individual strains of bacteria isolated from either a pond or a brook. Over 600 bacterial isolates were tested. Approximately 17.3% of the bacteria from water were found to be potential recipients for both conjugative plasmids; most of these were members of the Enterobacteriaceae. The frequency of transfer ranged from 1 X to 5 X lop6transfers/cell/l6 hours. Using the same E. coli K-12 donors, the matings were repeated in nonsterile pond water. The E. coli K-12 donors were added to a concentration of 1 x 10' celldm1 and the indigenous bacterial recipients, initially present at 8.7 x lo4 cells/ml, were raised to 3 x lo7 cells/ml by adding bacteria from the same source propagated in L-broth. Under these conditions, no transfer of either conjugative plasmid to the indigenous bacterial recipients could be detected (<3.3 x lo-' transfers/cell/24 hours). It was further demonstrated that strains bearing either of the conjugative plasmids declined with time in nonsterile pond water. In the study by Flint (1987) described above, conjugational transfer was tested in nonsterile river water with donors containing the conjugative plasmids Rldrd-19 (of the FII incompatibility group) or R144-3 (of the I incompatibility group). No transfer was detected. This is significant because these plasmids produce flexible pili that appear to be most suited for forming conjugational pairs in a liquid medium (Bradley, 1981). It is also worth noting that the cells did not grow in this medium and in fact exhibited a steady loss in viability, suggesting that conjugation requires more favorable conditions. IV. Fate of E. coli and Related Organisms in Soil
Soil is a very complex natural environment whose many variables have been shown to have significant effects on microbial viability and on transfer of genetic information between microorganisms (reviewed in Stotzky, 1986; Fredrickson and Seidler, 1989; Stotzky et a]., 1989). The survival of introduced organisms in soil has been addressed by a number of investigators. A. SURVIVAL IN STERILE SOIL When E. coli K-12 strain W3110 containing the conjugative plasmid R702 was suspended in L-broth and introduced into sterile soil, the initial concentration of approximately 5 x l o 4 cells/g of soil increased to about 3 x 10' cells/g by day 3, and remained at that level until day 1 7
ENVIRONMENTAL FATE OF RECOMBINANT E. coli K-12
105
(the end of the study) (Devanas et al., 1986b).In the absence of nutrient addition (i.e., saline instead of L-broth as the diluent), the cells remained viable but the increase in cell number was much less marked. The same behavior was exhibited by the E. coli K-12 strain DU1040 (nalidixic acid resistant) containing the conjugative plasmid RlOO derivatives pRR226 or pDU202, and the E. coli K-12 strain ~ 1 7 7 con6 taining the pBR328 derivative pESO19. Similar results were found with E. coli K-12 strain HB101, either plasmid free or containing the plasmid pBR322 or pBR322 with an 800-base pair insert into the ampicillinresistance gene. The viable cell number of these strains increased from 1 X lo5 cells/ml to about 1 x 10' cells/ml, and then remained at that level for 27 days (the end of the study) (Devanas et al., 1985a; Devanas and Stotzky, 1986). These results suggest that E. coli can survive and grow in sterile soil provided some additional nutrients are supplied. B. SURVIVAL IN NONSTERILE SOIL
Sterile soil is not likely to be found in nature. Therefore, it is important to assess the capability of Enterobacteriaceae to compete with indigenous soil microbes for survival. In a silty loam soil of pH 6.7, S. typhimurium introduced at approximately 1 x lo8 cells/g of soil decreased to about 2.5 x lo3 cells/g by day 1 4 (the end of the study) (Liang et al., 1982). Introduced E. coli K-12 strains decreased approximately 2 logs from an initial concentration of about 5 x lo4 cells/g of soil by day 24 [the end of the study) (Devanas et al., 1986b). This particular soil contained a total of about 5 x lo7 indigenous organisms per gram, of which about 1 x lo5 to about 1 x lo6 were Gram-negative organisms. No transfer of any of these plasmids from the E. coli strains to the indigenous organisms was detected. When E. coli K-12 strain HB101, with or without a plasmid, was inoculated into nonsterile soil, the viable cell count decreased from 1 x lo5 cells/ml to undetectable levels in 2 1 days if the initial inoculum was composed of saline. Viable cells remained through 27 days (the end of the study) with little or no decrease in numbers if the initial inoculum was composed of L-broth. Differences in survival in nonsterile soil have been observed with other strains of E. coli K-12 (Devanas et al., 1985b). In an abstract, Sjogren (1989) reported that an environmentally derived multiple-antibiotic-resistant strain of E. coli survived for over 2 years in a sandy loam soil maintained at 10°C and at saturating moisture. These results demonstrated that E. coli does not compete effectively with indigenous microorganisms in soil, and that colonization of soil by E. coli is an improbable event.
106
GREGG BOGOSIAN AND JAMES F. KANE
C. CONJUGATIONAL TRANSFER WITH ORGANISMS INHABITING SOIL 1. Conjugational Transfer in Sterile and Nonsterile Soil
In a recent study of the conjugational transfer of an R-factor from the E. coli K-12 strain HBlOl to a strain of Rhizobium fredii in sterile soil, the maximum transfer was found to occur at 28"C, with a soil moisture content of 8% of field capacity, a pH of 7.25, clay at 15%, and organic matter at 5% (Richaume et al., 1989).Conjugational transfer of R-factors between E. coli K-12 strains was higher in aerobically incubated soil than in anaerobically incubated soil (Trevors and Starodub, 1987), and was not observed in soil with a pH below 4.7 (Krasovsky and Stotzky, 19873,although no difference was seen in the pH range from 6.15 to 7.45 (Trevors and Starodub, 1987). In a study of conjugation and transfer of chromosomal markers between E. coli K-12 strains in sterile soil, the clay mineral montmorillonite was found to enhance growth and conjugation, but the clay mineral kaolinite did not (Weinberg and Stotzky, 1972). However, in liquid mating experiments with E. coli K-12 strains, montmorillonite was found to inhibit conjugational transfer of Rldrdtransfers/cell/24 hours to 19 (from a transfer frequency of 2.2 x 1.2 x lo-* transfers/cell/24 hours, at 22°C) (Singleton, 1983).Soil moisture is known to be critical; transfer of an R-factor between E. coli K-12 strains did not occur in sterile soil below a moisture level of 25% of field capacity, whereas it did occur at a frequency of about 1 x transferdcell at a moisture level above 25% of field capacity (Devanas et al., 1986a).The optimum soil moisture content for E. coli K-12 matings was determined to be from 60 to 80% of field capacity (Trevors and Starodub, 1987). The metabolic state of the donor is also important; preincubation of a donor E. coli K-12 strain in soil for 7 or 14 days reduced the transfer of the conjugative plasmid RP4 to Pseudomonas aeruginosa (Devanas, 1989). Addition of nutrients to the soil usually had a positive effect. With E. coli K-12 strain MA527 as the donor and E. coli K-12 strain C600 (nalidixic acid resistant) as the recipient, no transfer of a conjugative R-factor was observed in a sterile sandy loam at pH 7.2 (Trevors and Oddie, 1986);when nutrient broth was added to the soil to a level of 0.32% transfer was observed. In this case, the transfer exhibited a temperature response. The frequencies were 9.8 x lo-' transfers/cell/24 hours at 15"C, 2.5 x transfers/cell/24 hours at 22"C, and 1.4 x transfers/cell/24 hours at 30°C. It was subsequently shown that the addition of nutrient broth to sterile soil enhanced the survival of E. coli K-12 donors, recipients, and transconjugants (Trevors, 1987). However, in nonsterile soil no transfer of a
ENVIRONMENTAL FATE OF RECOMBINANT E. coli K-12
107
conjugative R-factor occurred between E. coli K-12 strains either with or without a 5% L-broth supplementation (Devanas et al., 1986a).Transfer of a conjugative plasmid (this plasmid was not described in the paper) between an E. coli K-12 donor and a nalidixic acid-resistant E. coli K-12 recipient was observed in both sterile and nonsterile soil (Berg and Trevors, 1990). In the nonsterile soil, the E. coli donor and recipient cells were added to a concentration of about 1 x lo5 to 1 x lo6 cells/g of soil. The frequency was 1.7 x transfers/cell/24 hours at 30°C. 2. Laboratory versus in Situ Conjugational Transfer
In a laboratory liquid mating, an E. coli K-12 strain was found to be capable of transferring a variety of F' plasmids to a soil isolate of Pseudomonas fluorescens biotype IV at a frequency of about 1 x transfers/cell/2 hours (Mergeay and Gerits, 1978).However, the transfer of a plasmid from E. coli to an indigenous soil organism in situ has never been observed. The transfer of R-factors from E. coli K-12 strains to bacteria indigenous to soil has been examined in detail (Schilf and Klingmuller, 1983). The E. coli K-12 strains J5 and JC5466 containing a broad-host-range conjugative plasmid (either RP4 or pRD1) were mated on solid media (tryptone agar plates) at 37OC for 16 hours with individual strains of bacteria isolated from agricultural soil. Over 600 bacterial isolates were tested. Approximately 1.3% of the bacteria from soil were found to be potential recipients for both conjugative plasmids; most of these were members of the Pseudomonadaceae. The frequency of these to 4.5 X transfers/cell/l6 exchanges ranged from 7.1 x hours. Using the same E. coli K-12 donors, the matings were repeated in nonsterile soil. The E. coli K-12 donors were added to a concentration of 1 x 10' cells/g of soil and the indigenous bacterial recipients were raised to 1 x 10' cells/g of soil by adding bacteria from the same source propagated in L-broth. Under these conditions, no transfer of either conjugative plasmid to the indigenous bacterial recipients could be detected (
108
GREGG BOGOSIAN AND JAMES F. KANE
in 77 days at 4°C and in 37 days at 20°C;the plasmid-bearing P.fluorescens strain declined by two orders of magnitude in 220 days at 4°C and in 70 days at 20°C.The two E. coli K-12 strains declined by four orders of magnitude in 72-90 days at 4°Cand in 32-42 days at 20°C.The levels of the indigenous flora remained constant for the duration of the experiment. In a different experiment, with an E. coli K-12 strain as donor and a P. aeruginosa strain as recipient (both introduced into the soil for the mating), the conjugative plasmid RP4 was transferred to the recipient both in sterile and nonsterile soil, but not to any of the indigenous soil organisms (Devanas and Stotzky, 1987). The same was observed with various E. coli strains containing several different types of plasmids, as discussed in the preceding paragraph (Devanas et al., 1986b). The E. coli K-12 strain J53 was capable of transferring the conjugative plasmid RP4 in nonsterile soil to a variety of added recipients (strains of E. coli K-12,Enterobacter aerogenes, K.pneumoniae, P. vulgaris, and P. aeruginosa) (Devanas et al., 1988),but not to indigenous soil organisms. In a related area, the generalized transducing bacteriophage P1 has been found to be capable of transducing chromosomal markers between E. coli K-12strains added to sterile and nonsterile soil, but not to any indigenous soil organisms (Zeph et al., 1987,1988;Zeph and Stotzky, 1988,1989). Whereas conjugational transfer between E. coli and microorganisms indigenous to the soil can be readily demonstrated in the laboratory, no transfers have been reported to occur in nonsterile soil. This is a significant point and indicates that the nonsterile soil environment does not support this type of gene transfer. In almost every case in which transfer has been reported, the cell numbers of donor and recipient required are exceptionally high relative to the numbers generally found in the environment. V. Fate of E. coli and Related Organisms in Sewage
Sewage streams and treatment plants, and water contaminated with raw or insufficiently treated sewage, are environments particularly conducive to the survival and growth of E. coli. As such, studies on the transfer of genetic material in sewage are of special interest when considering the potential of recombinant plasmids to spread to environmental organisms. Survival of E. coli and related organisms in sewage, and transfer of naturally occurring and recombinant plasmids, have been examined in a variety of situations. In a laboratory-scale waste treatment facility, E. coli K-12 strain DP5OsupF was lost at a rate of 1-2 logs/day (Sagik and Sorber, 1979).
ENVIRONMENTAL FATE OF RECOMBINANT E. coli K-12
109
The survival of S . typhimurium in raw sewage was followed in a shaking flask maintained at 30°C (Liang et al., 1982). In nonsterile sewage, with an initial inoculum of about 1 x lo4 celldml, the number of surviving organisms dropped to undetectable levels by day 10 of the study. In sterile sewage with the same initial inoculum, the number increased to about 1 x lo6 organisms by day 4, and held at that level until day 12 (the end of the study). Grabow et al. (1973) reported that R+ E. coli strains were found to survive better than R- strains in sewage maturation ponds, and to increase in number during sewage treatment (Grabow et a]., 1975);however, no difference in the survival of R+ versus R- E. coli strains was observed in dialysis bags immersed in rivers or lakes (Grabow et al., 1975). Free pBR322 DNA was shown to be degraded in raw sewage with a half-life of 2 minutes (Phillips et al., 1987). CONJUGATIONAL TRANSFER WITH ORGANISMS INHABITING SEWAGE The occurrence of transferable R-plasmids in sewage has been examined by a number of investigators (reviewed in Grabow et al., 1974; Kralikova et al., 1986; Gealt, 1988). In one study, a municipal sewage stream was found to contain about 1 x lo6 E. coli cells/ml, and a hospital sewage stream contained about 5 x lo5E. coli cells/ml; of these cells, about 20% contained R-factors (Grabow and Prozesky, 1973). About 50% of the R-factor-containing strains from the hospital isolates, and about 28% from the municipal isolates, were able to transfer the Rfactors in laboratory matings to a plasmid-free fecal E. coli isolate (nalidixic acid-resistant strain E25); in this study, the matings were performed by mixing overnight nutrient broth cultures and holding them at 37°C for 24 hours without agitation. A related study found that R-factors occurred in about 88% of the organisms from hospital sewage and in about 43% from municipal sewage (Fontaine and Hoadley, 1976). These R-factors could be transferred in in vitro matings to E. coli strain 1932 (obtained from the Centers for Disease Control) from about 62% of the hospital R+ isolates and from about 91% of the municipal R+ isolates. These investigations further demonstrated transfer (at a frequency of about 1 x loM4transferdcell)of R-factors from unidentified indigenous fecal coliforms to Salmonella cholerae-suis in an in vitro sewage system. In this test the recipient cells were present at high levels (4 to 5 logs higher) compared to the indigenous donors. Another study found coliforms in hospital and domestic sewage at levels of 4.8 X lo5to 7.6 X lo7 cells/ml; of 1000 antibiotic-resistant isolates, 413 were able to transfer their resistance to a laboratory recipient, again using optimized in vitro conditions (Linton et al., 1974). Grabow et al. (1975) isolated R+ E. coli strains from a river and were able to transfer the R-factors in laboratory
110
GREGG BOGOSIAN AND JAMES F. KANE
matings to fecal E. coli strain E25 at frequencies of about 1 X transferdcell in nutrient broth and 1 x transfers/cell in sterile wastewater. One river isolate was observed to carry out such a transfer at a 10-fold higher frequency at 20°C than at 37°C. Beaucage et al. (1979) reported that fecal isolates of E. coli and K. pneumoniae containing R-factors that were isolated from rats were able to transfer those Rfactors to strains of E. coli K-12. In this study the recipients and donors were grown overnight in brain-heart infusion broth from a starting concentration of approximately 1 x lo7 celldm1 to final densities of 1 x lo9 cells/ml. The E. coli K-12 was reported to receive the R-factor, but transfer frequencies were not recorded. A total of 865 sewage isolates of R-factor-containing Salmonella spp. were tested in laboratory matings with a nalidixic acid-resistant strain of E. coli K-12 (Alcaide and Garay, 1984). The matings were performed in L-broth for 18 hours at 37°C without agitation. About 30% of the Salmonella sewage isolates were able to transfer their R-factors to the E. coli recipient, at frequencies of about 1 x to 2.5 x transfers/ ce11/18 hours. Sewage isolates of E. coli containing R-factors were used as donors in laboratory filter matings for 24 hours at 37°C with E. coli K-12 strain J53 (nalidixic acid resistant) as recipient; about 50% of the E. coli sewage isolates were able to transfer their R-factors to the E. coli K-12 recipient at frequencies of about 1 x transfers/cell/24 hours (Abdul and Venables, 1986). A study was performed on the survival of transconjugants in a mixture of sterile sediment and sterile seawater obtained from a sewage sludge marine dump site (Stewart and Koditschek, 1980). The donor was E. coli strain W510, an R+ river isolate, and the recipient was a nalidixic acid-resistant strain of E. coli K-12. Both donor and recipient were added to the sterile sediment and seawater mixture at an initial level of about 1 x 10' cells/ml; these levels dropped to about 1 x lo4 cells/ml by day 4 of the study, and held at that level until day 28 (the end of the study). Transconjugants were detected after 24 hours, although no frequencies were determined. The viable cell number of the transconjugants remained at a constant level in the sediment until the end of the study. The transfer of an R-factor from E. coli to fecal organisms was studied using an E. coli K-12 strain containing the conjugative plasmid R1 (of the FII incompatibility group) as donor (Corliss et al., 1981);the recipients were 22 fecal isolates of E. coli and one fecal isolate of Citrobacter freundii. Laboratory filter matings were performed for 1 hour at 37°C; the R1 plasmid was transferred to all of the recipients at frequencies of to about 1 x transfers/cell/hour. The transconabout 1 x
ENVIRONMENTAL FATE OF RECOMBINANT E. coli K-12
111
jugants so obtained were backcrossed to E. coli K-12 strain CSH26 by the same mating method; the E. coli transconjugants transferred the R1 plasmid to CSH26 at frequencies of about 1 x to about 1 x transfers/cell/hour, and the C. freundii transconjugant transferred the R1 plasmid to CSH26 at a frequency of about 1 x 10-1 transfers/cell/ hour. An R+ sewage isolate of E. coli was used as donor and a river isolate of E. coli was used as recipient in a study of the effects of temperature on conjugational transfer (Altherr and Kasweck, 1982). In laboratory matings in L-broth for 1hour, the R-factor was transferred at frequencies of transfers/cell/hour at 15"C, about 1 x transfers/ about 4 X cell/hour at 20°C and 25"C, about 4 x transfers/cell/hour at 30°C, and about 1 x lo-' transfers/cell/hour at 35°C. When the matings were performed in a membrane diffusion chamber suspended in a settling tank in a sewage treatment plant, the transfer frequencies were about transfers/cell/hour at 22°C and about 1 x transfers/ 3.2 X cell/hour at 29.5"C. When the membrane diffusion chambers were suspended in a river about 500 m downstream from a sewage plant effluent transfers/cell/hour at point, no transfer could be detected [<3.1 x 18°C and <7.6 x lo-* transfers/cell/hour at 28.5"C). Similar findings were found in a study of the effect of temperature, pH, and cations on conjugational transfer in wastewater (Khalil and Gealt, 1987). Mach and Grimes (1982) used membrane diffusion chambers suspended in a settling tank of a sewage treatment plant to examine the transfer of R-factors from noncoliform sewage isolates to clinical specimens or sewage isolates of E. coli. In this case, both donor and recipient were present at approximately 1 x lo6 to 1 x lo7 cells/ml. When the donor was a sewage isolate of Salmonella enteritidis, the transfer fretransfers/cell/3 hours. When the donor quency was about (1-3) x was a sewage isolate of P. mirabilis, the transfer frequency was slightly lower at (0.4-1) x transfers/cell/3 hours. Alternatively, with an R+ E. coli strain as donor and a sewage isolate of Shigella sonnei as recipient under the same mating conditions, the transfer frequency was about (0.4-1) x transfers/cell/3 hours. These results demonstrate the capacity of the indigenous microorganisms to participate in conjugational transfer even when inoculated at relatively low cell densities. Transfer of the plasmid pBR325 [which is pBR322 carrying an additional gene encoding chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (Balbas et al., 1988)l in sterile wastewater was studied by Gealt et al. (1985), who performed a triparental mating using E. coli K-12 strain ~ 1 7 8 4 containing the conjugative plasmid R100-1 as the donor, E. coli
112
GREGG BOGOSIAN AND JAMES F. KANE
K-12 Dap- strain KA1661 containing pBR325 as the intermediate, and E. coli K-12 strain ~ 1 9 9 7(Dap+ and nalidixic acid resistant) as the
recipient. The cultures were grown independently in L-broth and then washed prior to mixing; equal volumes of each culture (containing about 1 x 10’ cells/ml of the intermediate, donor, and recipient) were mixed in sterile wastewater and held without agitation for 25 hours at 37°C before plating on a selective medium. Under these conditions, ampicillin resistance was transferred to ~ 1 9 9 at 7 a frequency of about 7x transfers/cell/25 hours. Examination of the plasmid DNA present in the ampicillin-resistant ~ 1 9 9 7derivatives revealed that a cointegrate had formed between pBR322 and R100-1, consisting of the entire empicillin-resistance element of pBR322 and all of R100-1. Using a sewage isolate of Enterobacter cloacae as recipient in an otherwise identical mating, transfer of ampicillin resistance as a cointegrate with transfers/cell/25 R100-1 occurred at a frequency of about 1 x hours. Using a sewage isolate of E. coli as recipient, transfer of ampicillin resistance as a cointegrate with R100-1 occurred at a frequency transfers/cell/25 hours. When the same matings were of about 1 x performed in L-broth instead of sterile wastewater, ampicillin resistance was transferred as a cointegrate with R100-1 at frequencies of transfers/cell/25 hours to the E. coli K-12 strain ~ 1 9 9 7 about 2 x recipient, about 1 x lov5transfers/cell/25 hours to the E. cloacae reciptransfers/cell/25 hours to the sewage E. coli ient, and about 4 x recipient. Similar triparental matings were performed using either a sewage isolate of R+ E. coli or a sewage isolate of R+ K. pneumoniae as donor, E. coli K-12 strain GM31 containing the plasmid pBR325 as interme7 acid resistant) as recipient diate, and E. coli K-12 strain ~ 1 9 9 (nalidixic (McPherson and Gealt, 1986). The matings were performed in either L-broth or sterile wastewater for 25 hours at 37°C without agitation. In L-broth, ampicillin resistance was transferred as a cointegrate with R100-1 at frequencies of about 1 x lop6to about 1 x transfedcell/ 25 hours to the E. coli K-12 strain ~ 1 9 9 recipient, 7 and in sterile wastetransfers/cell/ to about 1 x water at frequencies of about 1 x 25 hours. Several studies have been published on the transfer of recombinant plasmids in laboratory-scale waste treatment facilities. A triparental mating was performed in such a facility, using E. coli K-12 strain ~ 1 7 8 4 containing the conjugative plasmid R100-1 as the donor, E. coli K-12 strain HBlOl containing the plasmid pHSVlO6 as the intermediate, and E. coli K-12 strain ~ 1 9 9 7(nalidixic acid resistant) as the recipient (Mancini et al., 1987). The plasmid pHSVlO6 is a pBR322 derivative
ENVIRONMENTAL FATE OF RECOMBINANT E. coli K-12
113
carrying the herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase gene. Under these conditions, ampicillin resistance was transferred to the recipient; some of these transconjugants had also acquired the thymidine kinase gene. In all cases, transfer occurred as a cointegrate with the R100-1 plasmid. It was observed that at least 1 x 10’ donor cells/ml were required before any transfer could be detected. A similar mating was performed using only the E. coli K-12 strain HBlOl containing the plasmid pHSVlO6 and an uncharacterized mixture of indigenous sewage organisms (Gealt et al., 1988). Transfer of the thymidine kinase gene to some of the indigenous organisms was detected, although whether this occurred as a cointegrate was not stated. Presumably, suitable donors and recipients were present in the original population of indigenous organisms. A strain of P. putida containing the recombinant plasmid pDlO survived in a laboratory-scale waste treatment facility for 8 weeks (the end of the study) (McClure et al., 1989).Some of the indigenous sewage organisms were found to have picked up genes from the pDlO plasmid. VI. Fate of E. coli K-12 in the Mammalian Intestinal Tract
From the beginning of the recombinant DNA era, one of the major concerns raised was that the use of E. coli as a host organism posed a significant risk of unintentional release via the alimentary tract of humans. Accidental ingestion by molecular biologists of recombinant strains of E. coli is still considered the most likely route of escape of cloned genetic material. Although E. coli K-12 strains are not likely to survive in the environment of the mammalian intestinal tract (see below), there is concern that recombinant genetic material could be transferred to indigenous intestinal flora and become widely disseminated in those organisms. The studies reviewed below suggest that E. coli K-12 strains do not survive in the mammalian intestinal tract long enough to participate in active conjugational transfer. The E. coli K-12 strain was isolated in 1922 from the feces of a convalescent diphtheria patient at the Stanford Medical School (Bachmann, 1987). It should be noted here that the designation “K-12” is a strain catalog number, and does not indicate anything about the K antigen of the strain. Ordinarily, E. coli strains are serologically determined by their 0, K, and H antigens. However, that is not possible with the K-12 strain, as years of laboratory cultivation have led to the loss of detectable 0 and K antigens (1. Orskov and Orskov, 1960; F. Orskov and Orskov, 1961);the K-12 strain does have the H antigen, of a serological type designated H48. Furthermore, it has been observed that though the K-12 strain of E. coli is pathogenic when injected intravenously, intra-
114
GREGG BOGOSIAN AND JAMES F. KANE
peritoneally, or intracranially in mice, it is from 1 x lo3to 1 x 104-fold less pathogenic than are wild-type strains of E. coli (Levy et al., 1978). Numerous studies have shown that E. coli K-12 lacks the pili, fimbriae, or adhesins necessary for adhesion to mammalian intestinal cells (Smith and Huggins, 1976, 1980; Williams et al., 1978; Clancy and Savage, 1981; Hull et al., 1981; Laux et al., 1986; Karch et al., 1987). In addition to having lost the 0 and K antigens normally found on the outer surfaces of wild-type strains of E. coli, the K-12 strain of E. coli is presumed to have lost the ability to produce the pili and fimbriae required for adhesion to mammalian intestinal cells; of course, E. coli K-12 strains do produce other types of pili and fimbriae (Eisenstein, 1987).
Colonization of the mammalian intestinal tract by E. coli is a complex and surprisingly poorly understood process (Cohen and Laux, 1985). It is presumed that colonization involves binding between bacterial adhesins and intestinal receptors. During replication, some colonized bacteria are sloughed off into fecal material, thus the persistence of a specific bacterium in feces is taken as evidence of colonization by that bacterium. In conventional mammals (i.e., those not germ-free or treated with antibiotics), the normal intestinal organisms occupying the sites of colonization also affect the ability of introduced organisms to become established (Caugant et al., 1981; Duval-Iflah et al., 1981; Onderdonk et al., 1981). The E. coli inhabitants of mammalian intestines fall into two groups, those that persist over a long period of time (many months), termed residents, and those that persist for a short period of time (a few days to a few weeks), termed transients (Sears et al., 1950). It has been observed that resident strains of E. coli always eventually disappear and are replaced by new resident strains of E. coli. Cultures of E. coli strains isolated from the feces of human volunteers, and then swallowed in large numbers by those same volunteers months to years later, were often recovered from the feces but did not become established as residents (Sears et a]., 1950). It has been observed that the antagonism of a resident strain of E. coli against an inoculated strain of E. coli is abolished if the intestine is supplied with a fermentable carbon source which the inoculated strain can use but the resident strain cannot (Ozawa and Freter, 1964). Several studies have demonstrated the crucial role plasmids play in the ability of strains of E. coli to colonize the mammalian intestinal tract. The plasmid ColV has been associated with pathogenicity in calves, and ColV' strains are better able to survive in the human intestinal tract than are ColV- strains (Smith and Huggins, 1976, 1978, 1980); these properties were not found to be associated with the plasmid ColE.
ENVIRONMENTAL FATE OF RECOMBINANT E. coli K-12
115
Although ColV-containing strains were more pathogenic in the peritoneum (Finn et al., 1982), the presence of ColV did not increase the survival of E. coli K-12 strains in the human intestinal tract (Smith, 1978). Clancy and Savage (1981) reported that E. coli K-12 strains containing ColV exhibited two- to threefold greater adherence to mouse intestinal epithelium in vitro than did isogenic ColV- strains. The plasmid ColIb, found in a human enteropathogenic strain of E. coli, was necessary for the adhesion of this strain to human intestinal mucosa in vitro (Williams et al., 1978). When the ColIb plasmid was transferred to a nalidixic acid-resistant strain of E. coli K-12, the strain was able to adhere to human intestinal mucosa cells. Pathogenic strains of E. coli expressed adherence properties not often found in normal intestinal isolates. Two types of pili were associated with these adherence properties, and when the structural genes for the pilin proteins were cloned onto a plasmid and put into an E. coli K-12 strain, the transformant had the adherence properties of pathogenic strains (Hull et al., 1981). Other pathogenic strains of E. coli were found to contain a large plasmid associated with the formation of a certain type of fimbria (Karch et al., 1987). When the plasmid was moved into a K-12 strain of E. coli, the same fimbriae were made and the transformants were able to adhere to cultured human intestinal cells. It was concluded that the large plasmid contained the fimbrial structural genes, or regulatory genes necessary for their expression, or both. A similar plasmid, carrying the structural gene for the glycoprotein K88 adhesin subunit of a type of fimbria, was moved into an E. coli K-12 strain; the transformant expressed the fimbriae and was able to adhere to mouse intestinal cells in vitro (Laux et al., 1986). The plasmid effect on survival in the human intestinal tract appears to be dependent on the properties of the plasmid with respect to the external structures that it can control. In this regard it is not surprising that the presence of R-factors has been shown to affect negatively the survival of fecal E. coli isolates in the human intestine in vivo (Anderson, 1974). The question of whether E. coli K-12 strains are able to colonize the mammalian intestinal tract has been directly addressed by a number of investigators. In one study with a single human volunteer, seven different E. coli K-12 strains were individually tested (Smith, 1975). All seven strains contained antibiotic-resistance markers; one was prototrophic and the others had various auxotrophies. In this human volunteer, the initial resident E. coli were present at a level of about 1 X lo7 cells/g of feces. The test organisms were orally administered in doses of about 1 x lo9 organisms. All seven test strains persisted for 3 to 4 days and then were no longer detectable. The levels of the resident E. coli organ-
116
GREGG BOGOSIAN AND JAMES F. KANE
isms were unaffected. A nalidixic acid- and streptomycin-resistant derivative of the E. coli K-12 strain W3110 was orally administered in a dose of about 1 x lolo organisms to a human volunteer, and persisted for 9 days (Williams, 1977). In another test with four human volunteers, E. coli K-12 strain ~ 1 7 7 with 6 or without the plasmid pBR322 was orally administered in doses of about (1-2) x lolo organisms (Levy and Marshall, 1979). The E. coli K-12 strains were recovered from the feces of these volunteers for up to 4 days after administration. A further test with four human volunteers involved the oral administration of about 1 x lolo cells of E. coli K-12 strain ~ 1 6 6 with 6 or without the plasmid 6 a typical E. coli pBR322 (Levy et al., 1980; Levy, 1984). Strain ~ 1 6 6 is K-12 strain, not debilitated like ~ 1 7 7 6 In . this test, the E. coli K-12 strains were recovered for up to 6 days after administration. The conclusion from all of these tests is that strains of E. coli K-12 are unable to colonize the conventional human intestinal tract. Several similar studies have been performed with rats and mice. It was observed that though a wild-type E. coli K-12 strain could colonize 6 germ-free rats and mice, the debilitated E. coli K-12 strain ~ 1 7 7 could not (Wells et al., 1978). Other studies confirmed that the debilitated E. coli K-12 strains ~ 1 7 7 and 6 DP50supF were killed in the conventional mouse intestine (Freter et al., 1979,1983a). The E. coli K-12 strainx1666 was not killed in the conventional mouse intestine, but did pass through without any multiplication. Germ-free mice were colonized by E. coli K-12 strain ~ 1 6 6 but 6 not by strain ~ 1 7 7 6Germ-free . mice fed E. coli K-12 strain ~ 1 7 7 6with or without the plasmid pBR322 cleared both strains in 18-24 hours (Levy and Marshall, 1979). A variety of streptomycin-resistant strains of E. coli K-12 were able to colonize streptomycin-treated mice (Cohen et al., 1979; Myhal et al., 1982).A test with conventional mice involved the oral administration of about 1 x lolo cells of E. coli K-12 strain ~ 1 6 6 with 6 or without the plasmid pBR322 (Levy et al., 1980; Levy, 1984). In this test, the E. coli K-12 strains were recovered for up to 6 days after administration, but did not colonize the mice. Laux et al. (1982) pretreated mice with doses of streptomycin for 4 days, at which point the indigenous population was reduced from lo8 cells/g of feces to <10 cells/g. The mice were inoculated with a streptomycin-resistant strain of E. coli K-12 and were maintained on streptomycin treatment. Under these conditions, E. coli K-12 was able to colonize the intestinal tract and to persist at a level of about (1-5) x lo8 organismdg of feces. Apparently, E. coli was the only facultative microorganism measurable in the fecal samples. A strain of E. coli K-12 containing the plasmid pBR322 was orally administered in a dose of about 1 X 10' organisms to conventional, germ-free, and antibiotic-
ENVIRONMENTAL FATE OF RECOMBINANT E. coli K-12
117
treated mice (Smith et al., 1985).The strain did not colonize the conventional mice, but did colonize the germ-free and antibiotic-treated mice, persisting at a level of about 1 x lo7to 1 x 10' organisms/g of feces. The conclusion from these tests was that though E. coli K-12 strains could not colonize conventional mice, they could colonize germ-free or antibiotic-treated rats and mice. Presumably, strains of E. coli K-12 are unable to compete with indigenous mammalian intestinal organisms for sites of colonization; however, E. coli K-12 strains are not completely defective in colonization ability. CONJUGATIONAL TRANSFER WITH ORGANISMS INHABITING THE MAMMALIAN INTESTINAL TRACT Transfer of R-factors in mammalian intestines has been detected in a variety of investigations. In the conventional human intestinal tract, transfer of R-factors from fecal strains of E. coli to fecal strains of S . sonnei has been observed (Farrar et al., 1972).When human fecal isolates of E. coli were made R+ and reingested orally, no transfer of the R-factor to indigenous flora was seen unless the human volunteers were treated with antibiotics to which the R-factor encoded resistance (Anderson et al., 1973). A human volunteer with a resident E. coli population of about 1 x lo6 to 1 x lo7 organismdg of feces was orally administered about 1 x l o l o E. coli containing an F-tetR plasmid; 24 hours later, 20 transconjugants per gram of feces were detected, but 48 hours later no transconjugants were detected (E. S. Anderson, 1975). Following a regime of tetracycline treatment, a human volunteer was found to have a resident E. coli population with an R-factor encoding tetracycline resistance; 9 months later, the same strain was still resident, but an additional resident strain of E. coli that was identified contained the same R-factor (Petrocheilou et al., 1976). Transfer of R-factors from fecal isolates of E. coli to resident E. coli strains has been observed in pigs (Gyles et al., 1978)and from Serratia liquifaciens to fecal isolates of E. coli in germ-free rats (Duval-Iflah et al., 1980).In laboratory matings, a strain of E. coli K-12 was capable of transferring an R-factor to a fecal isolate of E. coli, and vice versa (Corliss et al., 1981).In a study of genetic exchange of nonplasmid DNA, the exchange of chromosomal markers between E. coli K-12 strains (where the donor was an Hfr, F', or F strain) was observed in germ-free mice (Jonesand Curtiss, 1970). Both chromosomal and plasmid DNA were found to be rapidly degraded by nucleases in the intestinal tracts of rats (Maturin and Curtiss, 1977). Several factors have been identified that affect the transfer of R-factors in the mammalian intestine. Multiplication of both donors and recipi-
118
GREGG BOGOSIAN AND JAMESF. KANE
ents was found to be required for R-factor transfer in germ-free and in conventional mouse intestines; this was true for transfer from E. coli to K. pneumoniae and Shigella flexneri as well as for transfer from S. flexneri to E, coli (Kasuya, 1964). Transfer of R-factors from E. coli to S. typhimurium in conventional mouse intestines was observed only if both donors and recipients were capable of multiplication (Guinee, 1965).The number of donors orally administered is also important. In a study of the transfer of an R-factor from a fecal E. coli isolate to a resident E. coli strain, no transfer was observed with an oral dose of about 1 x 10' organisms, whereas transfer was observed with an oral dose of about 1 x 10' organisms (Smith, 1969). The transconjugants did not persist for more than 6 days and the R- residents were unaffected. It was observed that the presence of Bacteroides fragilis in the intestinal tract inhibits conjugational transfer between E. coli strains [ J. D. Anderson, 1975), but a later study contradicted this finding (Duval-Iflah et al., 1980).
The transfer of nonconjugative plasmids in the mammalian intestine has been examined in numerous studies. An E. coli K-12 strain containing a nonconjugative plasmid encoding tetracycline resistance, and containing as well the conjugative plasmid F, I+, or A2+, was orally administered in doses of about 1 x 10' organisms to human volunteers. The E. coli K-12 strains did not persist for more than 4 days and no transfer of tetracycline resistance to resident E. coli strains was observed (Smith, 1975).A nalidixic acid- and streptomycin-resistant derivative of the E. coli K-12 strain W3110 containing the plasmid ColV was orally administered in a dose of about 1 x 1010 organisms to a human volunteer; the ColV plasmid was transferred to resident strains of E. coli (Williams, 1977). Apparently, a triparental mating had occurred involving a conjugative plasmid from one of the resident E. coli strains. The debilitated E. coli K-12 strain ~ 1 7 7 6containing , pBR322, was administered to a human volunteer in a dose of about 2.3 x W0 organisms; individual isolates of this strain from the feces of this volunteer were shown not to have picked up any conjugative plasmids in transit (Levy and Marshall, 1979). The prototrophic E. coli K-12 strain ~ 1 6 6 6con, taining pBR322, was administered to a human volunteer in a dose of about 1 X 10" organisms and persisted for 6 days; no transfer of pBR322 to any indigenous fecal organisms was detected (Levy et al., 1980). An E. coli K-12 strain ~ 1 6 6 6containing three plasmids-the conjugative plasmid pLM2 (of the P incompatibility group), the conjugative plasmid pSL222-4 (of the FII incompatibility group), and the plasmid pBR322-was administered to human volunteers and conventional mice; the strain persisted for 3.5-6 days in these subjects. The
119
ENVIRONMENTAL FATE OF RECOMBINANT E. coli K-12
conjugative plasmid pSL222-4 was transferred to endogenous fecal bactransferddonor cell ingested. This teria at a frequency of about 1 x rate of transfer is probably an overestimate, as it included new recipients that had arisen by multiplication. Transfer of the conjugative plasmid pLM2 and the plasmid pBR322 to endogenous fecal bacteria was not detected (<1 x lo-'' transfers/donor cell ingested) (Marshall et al., 1981; Levy and Marshall, 1981).In germ-free mice, the transfer of the conjugative plasmid Rldrd-19 between E. coli K-12 strains was actually inhibited when the donor also contained the plasmid pBR322 (Freter et al., 1983b). In germ-free mice, when E. coli K-12 strain ~ 1 6 6 6 containing pBR322 was present at a level of about 1 x 10" organismdg of feces, along with a mixture of four human fecal E. coli strains at a level organismdg of feces, no transfer of the plasmid of about 1 x pBR322 to any of the fecal E. coli isolates was observed (Levy, 1984). A series of studies in human volunteers yielded some insight into the factors affecting transfer of nonconjugative plasmids (Levine et a]., 1983a,b; Levy, 1984; see also Table 11). In the first experiment, a fecal TABLE I1 CONJUGATIONAL TRANSFER I N THE INTESTINALTRACT Experiment
E. coli strain tested Tetracycline administered Colonization occurred Transconjugants formed Nonconjugative plasmid Mobilization plasmid Conjugative plasmid
1
OF
HUMANS~
3
2
4
5
Fecal
Fecal
Fecal
Fecal
K-12
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
?
?
?
No
Yes
No
Yes
No
No
None
pBR325
pBR325
pBR325
pBR325
PJBK~~
None"
From residentd
None"
Nonec
From residente
None'
F
F
F
~
For each experiment, E. coli was orally adminstered to the volunteers. pJBK5 is a derivative of the mobilization plasmid ColE1. The presence or absence of a mobilization plasmid was not specifically determined; the absence of such was inferred from the observed lack of transfer. Because transfer did occur, a mobilization plasmid was presumably picked u p from a resident organism. A conjugative plasmid was detected in these strains, presumably from a resident organism. 'The presence or absence of a conjugative plasmid was not specifically determined; the absence of such was inferred from the observed lack of transfer.
120
GREGG BOGOSIAN AND JAMES F. KANE
E. coli strain was transformed with the plasmid pJBK5, which is a plasmid ColEl derivative with a gene encoding resistance to tetracycline. This strain was orally administered to 15 human volunteers, followed by treatment with tetracycline for 10 days. Under these conditions, the donor strain was able to colonize all of the humans volunteers. After 10 days, 9 (60%) of the human volunteers had transconjugants in their feces, although these transconjugants did not persist for more than 3 days. Apparently, a triparental mating had occurred, involving a conjugative plasmid from the indigenous flora. Indeed, such a conjugative plasmid was detected in the transconjugants. In the second experiment, a fecal E. coli strain was transformed with the plasmid pBR325, which is a pBR322 derivative with a gene encoding chloramphenicol resistance. This strain was orally administered to 15 human volunteers, followed by treatment with tetracycline for 10 days. Under these conditions, no transconjugants were detected. In the third experiment, the conjugative plasmid F-ampR was added to the fecal E. coli strain containing pBR325, and this strain was orally administered to 20 human volunteers. After a 10-day tetracycline treatment, 13 (65%) of the human volunteers had transconjugants in their feces, which persisted for 1-6 days. The fourth experiment was a repeat of the third experiment, with the omission of the tetracycline treatment. Under these conditions, no transfer of the pBR325 was detected. The fifth experiment was a repeat of the third experiment, with an E. coli K-12 strain being substituted for the fecal E. coli strain. In this case, even in the presence of tetracycline, the donor was cleared from the feces in 5 days or less; no transconjugants could be detected. It was concluded from these studies that transfer of pBR325 to indigenous human intestinal flora does not occur when the donor is an E. coli K-12 strain, nor does it occur with fecal E. coli strains as donors in the absence of tetracycline treatment. VII. Alternative Detection Methods for Recombinant Organisms
in
t h e Environment One of the most difficult technical aspects of studying the transfer of genetic material to organisms in complex environments is the detection of transconjugants, particularly if the frequency of transfer is relatively low. In all of the studies cited above, genes encoding resistance to one or more antibiotics were used to mark the donors, the recipients, and the genetic material being tested for transfer; some of the studies also employed chromosomal genotypic markers to distinguish donors and recipients from one another and from indigenous microorganisms. All of these studies had inherent limitations imposing lower limits of detec-
ENVIRONMENTAL FATE OF RECOMBINANT E. coli K-12
121
tion, which imparted a relatively low sensitivity to the measurements. The highest levels of sensitivity required the use of test strains that could be plated on media containing antibiotics in concentrations and combinations allowing for the growth of the fewest number of microorganisms indigenous to the habitat being studied (Mallory et al., 1982). A variety of other techniques have been developed, meant to be used either alone or in conjunction with standard marking methods, which can raise the level of sensitivity, including immunological techniques, radioactive markers, fluorescent markers, DNA fingerprinting, nucleic acid hybridization, biotinylated probes, bioluminescence, and a variety of techniques to detect proteins encoded by the DNA being tested for transfer (reviewed in Jain et al., 1988; Newman, 1989).A set of bacteriophages that has been assembled permits rapid biotyping of E. coli K-12 strains, distinguishing them from other strains of E. coli (van Leeuwen et al., 1979). Transposons have been employed to raise detection limits in soil studies (Frederickson et al., 1988).A colorimetric method using the enzyme 2,3-catechol dioxygenase has shown promise in studies involving soil and sewage (Lyon and Walter, 1989). One of the newest techniques, involving the use of the polymerase chain reaction (PCR), has been demonstrated to increase the level of sensitivity dramatically (Chaudhry et al., 1989). Raising the limits of detection in such studies will permit more sophisticated experiments to be designed, leading to a better understanding of the transfer of genetic material in complex environments. VIII. Conclusions
Strains of E. coli K-12 do not persist in nonsterile water, soil, sewage, or the conventional mammalian intestinal tract. The studies reviewed here reported maximum survival times, under optimal conditions, of about 15 days in water, about 20 days in soil, and about 10 days in sewage. It was observed that strains of E. coli K-12 were unable to adhere to mammalian intestinal cells and did not colonize the conventional mammalian intestinal tract; they were cleared in 3-6 days from conventional human and mouse intestines. The E. coli K-12 strains were able to colonize germ-free or antibiotic-treated rats and mice, but not antibiotictreated humans. The presence of conjugative and nonconjugative plasmids was observed to impart an additional disadvantage to E. coli K-12 strains in these environments, particularly in the mammalian intestinal tract. For the conjugational transfer of pBR322 or a derivative of pBR322, several conditions must be met. The pBR322 plasmid must have intact
122
GREGG BOGOSIAN AND JAMESF. KANE
born and nic sites; a derivative such as pBR327, which lacks these two sites, is unable to be transferred. The pBR322 plasmid must be in a donor strain that also contains both a conjugative plasmid and a plasmid that can provide the four mob gene products necessary for transfer; in the absence of the mob gene products, a few studies have demonstrated the low-frequency transfer of portions of pBR322 plasmids as cointegrates with conjugative R-factors. The donor strain must be able to not only survive, but actually to multiply in the environment in which the transfer is to occur; conjugation does not occur in the absence of growth. The donor strain must retain the pBR322 plasmid; in the absence of selective pressure, pBR322 is rapidly lost from host E. coli K-12 strains. The conjugational transfer of pBR322 or derivatives of pBR322 from strains of E. coli K-12 to indigenous inhabitants of water, soil, sewage, or the mammalian intestinal tract, in their natural environment, has never been demonstrated. Given the stringent conditions required, coupled with the limitations of pBR322 and E. coli K-12 strains, this is not an unexpected result. Particularly clear is the observation that E. coli K-12 strains do not survive in these environments. These results are reassuring from the point of view of using recombinant E. coli K-12 strains in large-scale fermentations. Of course, negative results such as these do not mean that, in the event of an accidental release of a recombinant E. coli K-12 strain, there is an absolute certainty that transfer of the plasmid to indigenous inhabitants of the release site will not occur. What is lacking in all of the studies to date is any systematic appraisal of the possible consequences of such transfer events. Such an appraisal must take into account the nature of the substance being produced by the recombinant organism. An array of other questions remains to be answered as well, including the mechanism of death of E. coli K-12 strains in the environment and the impact of various environmental factors. The fate of recombinant E. coli K-12 strains in the environment is an important and interesting issue that will continue to attract increased attention.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We gratefully acknowledge the assistance of Lynn Backus for performing dozens of literature searches and Randy Hastings for photocopying hundreds of articles. Michael Heitkamp provided a great deal of material for the section on the mammalian intestinal tract, and engaged in many helpful discussions with us. Ray Seidler of the United States Environmental Protection Agency Environmental Research Laboratory provided us with several relevant EPA manuals and other material.
ENVIRONMENTAL FATE OF RECOMBINANT E. coli K-12
123
REFERENCES Abdul, P., and Venables, W. A. (1986). Occurrence of R-plasmids in porcine faecal waste and comparison of their transfer rates in laboratory mating systems and anaerobic digesters. Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 24, 149-152. Alcaide, E., and Garay, E. (1984). R-plasmid transfer in Salmonella spp. isolated from wastewater and sewage-contaminated surface waters. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 48, 435-438. Altherr, M. R., and Kasweck, K. L. (1982). In situ studies with membrane diffusion chambers of antibiotic resistance transfer in Escherichia coli. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 44,838-843. Anderson, E. S. (1975). Viability of, and transfer of a plasmid from, E. coli K-12 in the human intestine. Nature (London) 255, 502-504. Anderson, J. D. (1974). The effect of R-factor carriage on the survival of Escherichia coli in the human intestine. J. Med. Microbiol. 7, 85-90. Anderson, J. D. (1975). Factors that may prevent transfer of antibiotic resistance between gram-negative bacteria in the gut. J. Med. Microbiol. 8,83-88. Anderson, J. D., Gillespie, W. A., and Richmond, M. H. (1973). Chemotherapy and antibiotic-resistance transfer between enterobacteria in the human gastro-intestinal tract. J. Med. Microbiol. 6,461-473. Bachmann, B. J. (1987). Derivatives and genotypes of some mutant derivatives of Escherichia coli K-12. In “Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium: Cellular and Molecular Biology” (J. L. Ingraham, K. B. Low, B. Magasanik, M. Schaechter, and H. E. Umbarger, eds.), pp. 1190-1219. Am. SOC.Microbiol., Washington, D. C. Balbas, P., Soberon, X.,Merino, E., Zurita, M., Lomeli, H., Valle, F., Flores, N., and Bolivar, F. (1986). Plasmid pBR322 and its special-purpose derivatives-a review. Gene 50, 3-40. Balbas, P., Soberon, X., Bolivar, F., and Rodriguez, R. L. (1988). The plasmid, pBR322. In “Vectors: A Survey of Molecular Cloning Vectors and Their Uses” (R. L. Rodriguez and D. T. Denhardt, eds.), pp. 5-41. Butterworth, Stoneham, Massachusetts. Beaucage, C. M., Fox, J, G., and Whitney, K. M. (1979). Effect of long-term tetracycline exposure (drinking water additive) on antibiotic-resistance of aerobic gram-negative intestinal flora of rats. Am. J. Vet. Res. 40, 1454-1457. Berg, G., and Trevors, J. T. (1990). Bacterial conjugation between Escherichia coli and Pseudomonas spp. donor and recipient cells in soil. J. Ind. Microbiol. 5, 79-84. Bolivar, F., Rodriguez, R. L., Greene, P. J., Betlach, M. C., Heyneker, H. L., Boyer, H. W., Crosa, J. H., and Falkow, S. (1977).Construction and characterization of new cloning vehicles. 11. A multipurpose cloning system. Gene 2,95-113. Boyd, A. C., Archer, J. A. K., and Sherratt, D. J. (1989). Characterization of the ColEl mobilization region and its protein products. Mol. Gen. Genet. 217,488-498. Bradley, D. E. (1981). Conjugative pili of plasmids in Escherichia coli K-12 and Pseudomonas species. In “Molecular Biology, Pathogenicity, and Ecology of Bacterial Plasmids” (S. B. Levy, R. C. Clowes, and E. L. Koenig, eds.), pp. 217-226. Plenum, New York. Brenner, D. J. [1984). Facultatively anaerobic rods. In “Bergey’s Manual of Systematic Bacteriology” (R. N. Krieg, ed.), Vol. 1,pp. 409-423. Williams & Wilkins, Baltimore, Maryland. Broda, P., Cullum, J., and Collins, J. F. (1977). Plasmid spread through Escherichia coli populations. In “Plasmids: Medical and Theoretical Aspects” (S. Mitsuhashi, L. Rosival, and V. Krcmery, [eds.), pp. 469-472. Avicenum, Prague.
124
GREGG BOGOSIAN AND JAMES F. KANE
Calcott, P. H., Kane, J. F., Krivi, G. G., and Bogosian, G. (1988). Parameters affecting production of bovine somatotropin in Escherichia coli fermentations. Dev. Ind. Microbiol. 29, 257-266. Caugant, D. A., Levin, B. R., and Selander, R. K. (1981). Genetic diversity and temporal variation in the E. coli population of a human host. Genetics 98,467-490. Cesareni, G., Cornelissen, M., Lacatena, R. M., and Castagnoli, L. (1984). Control of pMBl replication: Inhibition of primer formation by Rop requires RNAI. EMBO J. 3, 13651369. Chai, T.-J. (1983).Characteristics of Escherichia coli grown in bay water as compared with rich medium. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 45, 1316-1323. Chatigny, M. A., Hatch, M. T., Wolochow, H., Adler, T., Hresko, J., Macher, J., and Besemer, D. (1979). Studies on release and survival of biological substances used in recombinant DNA laboratory procedures. Recomb. DNA Tech. Bull. 2, 62-67. Chaudhry, G. R., Toranzos, G. A., and Bhatti, A. R. (1989). Novel method for detecting genetically engineered microorganisms in the environment. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 55, 1301-1304. Chiang, C.-S., and Bremer, H. (1988). Stability of pBR322-derived plasmids. Plosmid 20, 207-220. Clancy, J., and Savage, D. C. (1981). Another colicin V phenotype: In vitro adhesion of Escherichia coli to mouse intestinal epithelium. Infect. Immun. 32, 343-352. Clark, A. J., and Warren, G. J. (1979). Conjugal transmission of plasmids. Annu. Rev. Genet. 13, 99-125. Cohen, P. S., and Laux, D. C. (1985). E. coli colonization of the mammalian colon: Understanding the process. Recomb. DNA Tech. Bull. 8, 51-54. Cohen, P. S., Pilsucki, R. W., Myhal, M. L., Rosen, C. A., Laux, D. C., and Cabelli, V. J. (1979).Colonization potentials of male and female E. coli K-12 strains, E. coli B, and human fecal E. coli strains in the mouse GI tract. Recomb. DNA Tech. Bull. 2, 106-1 13. Corliss, T. L., Cohen, P. S., and Cabelli, V. J. (1981). R-plasmid transfer to and from Escherichia coli strains isolated from human fecal samples. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 41,959-966. Covarrubias, L., Cervantes, L., Covarrubias, A., Soberon, X., Blanco, A., Kupersztoch-Portnoy, Y. M., and Bolivar, F. (1981). Construction and characterization of new cloning vehicles. V. Mobilization and coding properties of pBR322 and several deletion derivatives including pBR327 and PBR328. Gene 13,25-35. Cullum, J . , Collins, J. F., and Broda, P. (1978). The spread of plasmids in model populations of Escherichia coli K-12. Plasmid 1, 545-556. Curtiss, R., 111, Clark, J. E., Goldschmidt, R., Hsu, J. C., Hull, S. C., Inoue, M., Maturin, L. J., Sr., Moody, R., and Pereira, D. A. (1977). Biohazard assessment of recombinant DNA molecule research. In “Plasmids: Medical and Theoretical Aspects” (S. Mitsuhashi, L. Rosival, and V. Krcmery, eds.), pp. 375-387. Avicenum, Prague. Datta, N. (1979). Plasmid classification: Incompatibility grouping. In “Plasmids of Medical, Environmental and Commercial Importance” (K. N. Timmis and A. Puhler, eds.), pp. 3-12. Elsevier/North-Holland, Amsterdam. Devanas, M. A. (1989). The metabolic state of donor and recipient cells affects conjugation frequencies and plasmid transfer to indigenous bacteria in soil. Abstr. Annu. Meet. Am. SOC.Microbiol. p. 353. Devanas, M. A., and Stotzky, G. (1986). Fate in soil of a recombinant plasmid carrying a Drosophila gene. Curr. Microbiol. 13, 279-283. Devanas, M. A., and Stotzky, G. (1987).Survival and conjugal transfer of plasmid RP4 from
ENVIRONMENTAL FATE OF RECOMBINANT E. coli K-12
125
Escherichia coli to Pseudomonas aeruginosa in soil: Effect of clay minerals and nutrients. Abstr. Annu. Meet. Am. SOC.Microbiol. p. 303. Devanas, M. A., Rafaelli-Eshkol, D., Kambysellis, M., and Stotzky, G. (1985a). Fate in soil of a recombinant plasmid carrying a Drosophila gene. Abstr. Annu. Meet. Am. SOC. Microbiol. p. 218. Devanas, M. A., Rafaelli-Eshkol, D., and Stotzky, G. (1985b). Survival and recovery of plasmid-containing strains of Escherichia coli from soil. Abstr. Annu. Meet. Am. SOC. Microbiol. p. 218. Devanas, M. A., Harsell, C., Wu, C., and Stotzky, G. (1986a). Plasmid transfer in Escherichia coli in sterile and nonsterile soil. Abstr. Annu. Meet. Am. SOC.Microbiol. p. 241.
Devanas, M. A., Rafaeli-Eshkol, D., and Stotzky, G. (1986b). Survival of plasmidcontaining strains of Escherichia coli in soil: Effect of plasmid size and nutrients on survival of hosts and maintenance of plasmids. Curr. Microbiol. 13, 269-277. Devanas, M. A., Arroyo, C., Aspiras, M., Berger, A., Bernard, A., Deleo, J., Gutzmore, J., Metha, N., and Stotzky, G. (1988). Intergeneric conjugal transfer of RP4 in soil. Abstr. Annu. Meet. Am. SOC.Microbiol. p. 298. Dougan, G., Crosa, J. H., and Falkow, S. (1978). Mobilization of the Escherichia coli plasmid ColEl (colicin E l ) and ColEl vectors used in recombinant DNA experiments. J. Infect. Dis. 137, 676-680. Duval-Iflah, Y., Raibaud, P., Tancrede, C., and Rousseau, M. (1980). R-plasmid transfer from Serratia liquefaciens to Escherichia coli in vitro and in vivo in the digestive tract of gnotobiotic mice associated with human fecal flora. Infect. Immun. 28, 981-990. Duval-Iflah, Y., Raibaud, P., and Rousseau, M. (1981). Antagonisms among isogenic strains of Escherichia coli in the digestive tracts of gnotobiotic mice. Infect. Immun. 34,957-969. Eisenstein, B. I. (1987). Fimbriae. In “Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium: Cellular and Molecular Biology” (J. L. Ingraham, K. B. Low, B. Magasanik, M. Schaechter, and H. E. Umbarger, eds.), pp. 84-90. Am. SOC.Microbiol., Washington, D.C. Farrar, W. E., Jr., Edison, M., Guerry, P., Falkow, S., Drusin, L. M., and Roberts, R. B. (1972). Interbacterial transfer of R factor in the human intestine: In vivo acquisition of R-factor-mediated kanamycin resistance by a multiresistant strain of Shigella sonnei. J. Infect. Dis. 126, 27-33. Finn, T. M., Arbuthnott, J. P., and Dougan, G. (1982). Properties of Escherichia coli grown in vivo using a chamber implant system. J. Gen. Microbiol. 128, 3083-3091. Finnegan, J., and Sherratt, D. (1982). Plasmid ColEl conjugal mobility: The nature of bom, a region required in cis for transfer. Mol. Gen. Genet. 185, 344-351. Flint, K. P. (1987). The long-term survival of Escherichia coli in river water. J. Appl. Bacteriol. 63, 261-270. Fontaine, T. D., and Hoadley, A. W. (1976). Transferable drug resistance associated with coliforms isolated from hospital and domestic sewage. Health Lob. Sci. 13,238-245. Fredrickson, J. K., and Seidler, R. J. (1989). Evaluation of terrestrial microcosms for detection, fate, and survival analysis of genetically engineered microorganisms and their recombinant genetic material. U.S. Environ. Prot. Agency Doc. EPA-600/3-89043. Fredrickson, J. K., Bezdicek, D. F., Brockman, F. J., and Li, S. W. (1988).Enumeration of Tn5 mutant bacteria in soil by using a most-probable-number-DNA hybridization procedure and antibiotic resistance. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 54, 446-453. Freter, R. (1984). Factors affecting conjugal plasmid transfer in natural bacterial communities. In “Current Perspectives in Microbial Ecology” (M. J. Klug, and C. A. Reddy, eds.), pp. 105-114. Am. SOC.Microbiol., Washington, D.C.
126
GREGG BOGOSIAN AND JAMES F. KANE
Freter, R., Brickner, H., Fekete, J., O’Brien, P. C. M., and Vickerman, M. M. (1979). Testing of host-vector systems in mice. Recomb. DNA Tech. Bull. 2,68-76. Freter, R.,Brickner, H., Fekete, J., Vickerman, M. M., and Carey, K. E. (1983a).Survival and implantation of Escherichia coli in the intestinal tract. Infect. Immun. 39,686-703. Freter, R., Freter, R. R., and Brickner, H.(1983b).Experimental and mathematical models of Escherichia coli plasmid transfer in vitro and in vivo. Infect. Immun. 3 9 , 6 0 4 4 . Gealt, M. A. (1988). Recombinant DNA plasmid transmission to indigenous organisms during waste treatment. Water Sci. Technol. 20, 179-184. Gealt, M. A., Chai, M. D., Alpert, K. B., and Boyer, J. C. (1985). Transfer of plasmids pBR322 and pBR325 in wastewater from laboratory strains of Escherichia coli to bacteria indigenous to the waste disposal system. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 49, 836-841. Gealt, M. A., Cleveland, P., and Vettese, M. (1988).Transfer of genetically engineered DNA sequences (GEDS) to indigenous wastewater bacteria in a laboratory-scale treatment facility. Abstr. Annu. Meet. Am. SOC.Microbiol. p. 254. Geldreich, E. E. (1966). “Sanitary Significance of Fecal Coliforms in the Environment,” Publ. WP-20-3. Cincinnati Water Res. Lab., US.Dep. Inter., Cincinnati, Ohio. Genthner, F. J., Chatterjee, P., Barkay, T., and Bourquin, A. W. (1988). Capacity of aquatic bacteria to act as recipients of plasmid DNA. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 54,115-117. Godwin, D., and Slater, J. H.(1979). The influence of the growth environment on the stability of a drug resistance plasmid in Escherichia coli K-12.J. Gen. Microbiol. 111, 201-210. Gowland, P. C., and Slater, J. H.(1984). Transfer and stability of drug resistance plasmids in Escherichia coli K-12. Microb. Ecol. 10,1-13. Grabow, W. 0. K., and Prozesky, 0. W. (1973). Drug resistance of coliform bacteria in hospital and city sewage. Antimicrob. Agents Chemother. 3, 175-180. Grabow, W. 0. K., Middendorff, I. G., and Prozesky, 0. W. (1973). Survival in maturation ponds of coliform bacteria with transferable drug resistance. Water Res. 7, 15891597. Grabow, W. 0. K., Prozesky, 0. W., and Smith, L. S . (1974). Drug resistant coliforms call for review of water quality standards. Water Res. 8,1-9. Grabow, W. 0. K.,Prozesky, 0. W., and Burger, J. S . (1975). Behavior in a river and dam of coliform bacteria with transferable or nontransferable drug resistance. Water Res. 9, 777-782. Grabow, W. 0. K., van Zyl, M., and Prozesky, 0. W. (1976). Behavior in conventional sewage purification processes of coliform bacteria with transferable or non-transferable drug resistance. Water Res. 10,717-723. Guinee, P. A. M. (1965). Transfer of multiple drug resistance from Escherichia coli to Salmonella typhirnurium in the mouse intestine. Antonie van Leeuwenhoek 31, 314-322. Gyles, C., Falkow, S., and Rollins, L. (1978). In vivo transfer of an Escherichia coli enterotoxin plasmid possessing genes for drug resistance. Am. J. Vet. Res. 39, 14381441. Hardy, K. G. (1975). Colicinogeny and related phenomena. Bacteriol. Rev. 39,464-515. Helling, R. B., Kinney, T., and Adams, J. (1981).The maintenance of plasmid-containing organisms in populations of Escherichia coli. J. Gen. Microbiol. 123, 129-141. Holloway, B. W. (1979). Plasmids that mobilize bacterial chromosomes. Plasmid 2,1-19. Hughes, V. M., and Datta, N. (1983). Conjugative plasmids in bacteria of the “preantibiotic” era. Nature (London) 302, 725-726. Hull, R. A., Gill, R. E., Hsu, P., Minshew, B. H.,and Falkow, S . (1981). Construction and
ENVIRONMENTAL FATE OF RECOMBINANT E. coli K-12
127
expression of recombinant plasmids encoding type I or n-mannose-resistant pili from a urinary tract infection Escherichia coli isolate. Infect. Immun. 33,933-938. Ippen-Ihler, K. A., and Minkley, E. G. (1986). The conjugation system of F, the fertility factor of Escherichia coli. Annu. Rev. Genet. 20,593-624. Jain, R. K., Burlage, R. S.,and Sayler, G. S. (1988).Methods for detectingrecombinantDNA in the environment. CRC Crit. Rev. Biochem. 8,33-84. Jones, I. M., Primrose, S. B., Robinson, A., and Ellwood, D. C. (1980).Maintenance of some ColEl-type plasmids in chemostat culture. Mol. Gen. Genet. 180, 579-584. Jones, R. T., and Curtiss, R., 111 (1970). Genetic exchange between Escherichia coli strains in the mouse intestine. J. Bacteriol. 103, 71-80. Karch, H., Heesemann, J., Laufs, R., O’Brien, A. D., Tacket, C. O., and Levine, M. M. (1987). A plasmid of enterohemorrhagic Escherichia coli 0157:H7 is required for expression of a new fimbriae antigen and for adhesion to epithelial cells. Infect. Immun. 55, 455-461.
Kasuya, M. (1964). Transfer of drug resistance between enteric bacteria induced in the mouse intestine. J. Bacteriol. 88, 322-328. Khalil, T. A., and Gealt, M. A. (1987). Temperature, pH, and cations affect the ability of Escherichia coli to mobilize plasmids in L broth and synthetic wastewater. Can. J. Microbiol. 33, 733-737. Kralikova, K., Krcmery, V., Sr., and Krcmery, V., Jr. (1983). Incidence of gentamicinresistant bacteria and those with R plasmids, transferable to E. coli K-12, in municipal waste waters. Recomb. DNA Tech. Bull. 6, 98-100. Kralikova, K., Krcmery, V., Sr., and Krcmery, V., Jr. (1986). Antibiotic resistance and transferable resistance in Enterobacteriaceae in municipal waste waters. Recomb. DNA Tech. Bull. 9, 59-64. Krasovsky, V. N., and Stotzky, G. (1987). Conjugation and genetic recombination in Escherichia coli in sterile and nonsterile soil. Soil Biol. Biochem. 19, 631-638. Laux, D. C., Cabelli, V. J., and Cohen, P. S. (1982).The effect of plasmid gene expression on the colonizing ability of E. coli HS in mice. Recomb. DNA Tech. Bull. 5 , l - 5 . Laux, D. C., McSweegan, E. F., Williams, T. J., Wadolkowski, E. A., and Cohen, P. S. (1986). Identification and characterization of mouse small intestine mucosal receptors for Escherichia coli K-12 (K88ab). Infect. Immun. 52, 18-25. Levin, B. R., and Rice, V. A. (1980).The kinetics of transfer of nonconjugative plasmids by mobilizing conjugative factors. Genet. Res. 35, 241-259. Levin, B. R., and Stewart, F. M. (1980). The population biology of bacterial plasmids: A priori conditions for the existence of mobilizable nonconjugative factors. Genetics 94,425-443.
Levin, B. R., Stewart, F. M., and Rice, V. A. (1979). The kinetics of conjugative plasmid transmission: Fit of a simple mass action model. Plasmid 2, 247-260. Levine, M. M., Kaper, 7. B., Lockman, H., Black, R. E., Clements, M. L., and Falkow, S. (1983a). Recombinant DNA risk assessment studies in humans: Efficacy of poorly mobilizable plasmids in biologic containment. J. Infest. Dis. 148, 699-709. Levine, M. M., Kaper, J. B., Lockman, H., Black, R. E., Clements, M. L., and Falkow, S. (1983b).Recombinant DNA risk assessment studies in man: Efficacy of poorly mobilizable plasmids in biologic containment. Recomb. DNA Tech. Bull. 6,89-97. Levy, S. B. (1984). Survival of plasmids in Escherichio coli. In “Genetic Manipulation: Impact on Man and Society” (W. Arber, K. Illmensee, W. J. Peacock, and P. Starlinger, eds.), pp. 19-28. ICSU Press, Paris. Levy, S. B., and Marshall, B. (1979).Survival of E. coli host-vector systems in the human intestinal tract. Recomb. DNA Tech. Bull. 2, 77-80.
128
GREGG BOGOSIAN AND JAMES F. KANE
Levy, S. B., and Marshall, B. (1981). Risk assessment studies of E. coli host-vector systems. Recomb. DNA Tech. Bull. 4,91-98. Levy, S. B., Sullivan, N., and Gorbach, S. L. (1978). Pathogenicity of conventional and debilitated Escherichia coli K-12. Nature (London) 274, 395-396. Levy, S. B., Marshall, B., and Rowse-Eagle, D. (1980). Survival of Escherichia coli hostvector systems in the mammalian intestine. Science 209, 391-394. Liang, L. N., Sinclair, J. L., Mallory, L. M., and Alexander, M. (1982). Fate in model ecosystems of microbial species of potential use in genetic engineering. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 44, 708-714. Linton, K. B., Richmond, M. H., Bevan, R., and Gillespie, W. A. (1974). Antibiotic resistance and R factors in coliform bacilli isolated from hospital and domestic sewage. J. Med. Microbiol. 1, 91-103. Lyon, F., and Walter, M. (1989). A colorimetric assay for use in detecting, tracking, and enumerating genetically engineered microorganisms in the environment. Abstr. Annu. Meet. Am. SOC.Microbiol. p. 353. McClure, N. C., Weightman, A. J., and Fry, J. C. (1989). Survival of Pseudomonas putida UWCl containing cloned catabolic genes in a model activated-sludge unit. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 55, 2627-2634. Mach, P. A., and Grimes, D. J. (1982). R-plasmid transfer in a wastewater treatment plant. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 44, 1395-1403. McPherson, P., and Gealt, M. A. (1986). Isolation of indigenous wastewater bacterial strains capable of mobilizing plasmid pBR325. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 51, 904909. Mallory, L. M., Sinclair, J. L., Liang, L. N., and Alexander, M. (1982). A simple and sensitive method for assessing survival in environmental samples of species used in recombinant DNA research. Recomb. DNA Tech. Bull. 5, 5-6. Mancini, P., Fertels, S., Nave, D., and Gealt, M. A. (1987). Mobilization of plasmid pHSVlO6 from Escherichia coli HBlOl in a laboratory-scale waste treatment facility. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 53,665-671. Marshall, B., Schluederberg, S., Tachibana, C., and Levy, S. B. (1981). Survival and transfer in the human gut of poorly mobilizable (pBR322)and of transferable plasmids from the same carrier E. coli. Gene 14, 145-154. Maturin, L., Sr., and Curtiss, R., 111 (1977). Degradation of DNA by nucleases in intestinal tract of rats. Science 196, 216-218. Mergeay, M., and Gerits, J. (1978). F’-plasmid transfer from Escherichia coli to Pseudomonas fluorescens. J. Bacteriol. 135, 18-28. Moodie, H. L., and Woods, D. R. (1973). Anaerobic R factor transfer in Escherichia coli. J. Gen. Microbiol. 76, 437-440. Morlon, J., Chartier, M., Bidaud, M., and Lazdunski, C. (1988a). The complete nucleotide sequence of the colicinogenic plasmid ColA. High extent of homology with ColE1. Mol. Gen. Genet. 211, 231-243. Morlon, J., Sherratt, D., and Lazdunski, C. (1988b).Identification of functional regions of the colicinogenic plasmid ColA. Mol. Gen. Genet. 211,223-230. Myhal, M. L., Laux, D. C., and Cohen, P. S. (1982). Relative colonizing abilities of human fecal and K-12 strains of Escherichia coli in the large intestines of streptomycintreated mice. Eur. J. Clin. Microbiol. 1, 186-192. Newman, A. R. (1989).Tracking genetically engineered microorganisms. Anal. Chem. 61, 1001-1003. Noack, D., Roth, M., Geuther, R., Muller, G., Undisz, K., Hoffmeier, C., and Gaspar, S. (1981). Maintenance and genetic stability of vector plasmids pBR322 and pBR325 in Escherichia coli K-12 strains grown in a chemostat. Mol. Gen. Genet. 184, 121-124.
ENVIRONMENTAL FATE OF RECOMBINANT E. coli K-12
129
Onderdonk, A., Marshall, B., Cisneros, R., and Levy, S. B. (1981). Competition between congenic Escherichia coli K-12 strains in vivo. Infect. Immun. 32, 74-79. Orskov, F., and Orskov, I. (1961). The fertility of Escherichia coli antigen test strains in crosses with K-12. Acta Pathol. Microbiol. Scand. 51,280-290. Orskov, I., and Orskov, F. (1960). The H antigen of the “K-12” strain. A new E. coli H antigen: H 48. Acta Pathol. Microbiol. Scand. 48,47. Ozawa, A., and Freter, R. (1964).Ecological mechanism controlling growth of Escherichia coli in continuous flow cultures and in the mouse intestine. J. Infect. Dis. 114, 235-242.
Ozeki, H.,Stocker, B. A. D., and Smith, S. M. (1962). Transmission of colicinogeny between strains of Salmonella typhimurium grown together. J. Gen. Microbiol. 30, 201-221.
Petrocheilou, V., Grinsted, J., and Richmond, M. H. (1976). R-plasmid transfer in vivo in the absence of antibiotic selection pressure. Antimicrob. Agents Chemother. 10, 753-761.
Phillips, S. J., Dalgarn, D. S., and Young, S. K. (1987). Recombinant DNA in wastewater: Plasmid degradation kinetics. Abstr. Annu. Meet. Am. SOC.Microbiol. p. 303. Reanney, D. C., Gowland, P. C., and Slater, J. H. (1983). Genetic interactions among microbial communities. Symp. SOC.Gen. Microbiol. 34, 379-422. Regal, P. J. (1987). Models of genetically engineered organisms and their ecological impact. Recomb. DNA Tech. Bull. 10, 67-85. Reinikainen, P., and Virkajarvi, I. (1989). Escherichia coli growth and plasmid copy numbers in continuous cultivations. Biotechnol. Lett. 11,225-230. Richaume, A., Angle, J. S.,and Sadowsky, M. J. (1989).Influence of soil variables on in situ plasmid transfer from Escherichia coli to Rhizobium fredii. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 55,1730-1734.
Rissler, J. F. (1984). Research needs for biotic environmental effects of geneticallyengineered microorganisms. Recomb. DNA Tech. Bull. 7, 20-30. Roszak, D. B., and Colwell, R. R. (1987). Survival strategies of bacteria in the natural environment. Microbiol. Rev. 51, 365-379. Sagik, B. P., and Sorber, C. A. (1979). The survival of host-vector systems in domestic sewage treatment plants. Recomb. DNA Tech. Bull. 2,55-61. Sanchez, E. J., and Toranzos, G. A. (1989). In situ survival of two strains of genetically engineered microorganisms. Abstr. Annu. Meet. Am. SOC.Microbiol. p. 354. Schilf, W., and Klingmuller, W. (1983).Experiments with Escherichia coli on the dispersal of plasmids in environmental samples. Recomb. DNA Tech. Bull. 6,101-102. Sears, H. J., Brownlee, I., and Uchiyama, J. K. (1950). Persistence of individual strains of Escherichia coli in the intestinal tract of man. J. Bacteriol. 59, 293-301. Selander, R. K., and Levin, B. R. (1980).Genetic diversity and structure in Escherichia coli populations. Science 210,545-547. Sharples, F. E. (1983). Spread of organisms with novel genotypes: Thoughts from an ecological perspective. Recomb. DNA Tech. Bull. 6,43-56. Shaw, D. R., and Cabelli, V. J. (1980). R-plasmid transfer frequencies from environmental isolates of Escherichia coli to laboratory and fecal strains. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 40, 756-764.
Singleton, P. (1983). Colloidal clay inhibits conjugal transfer of R-plasmid Rldrd-19 in Escherichia coli. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 46, 756-757. Singleton, P., and Anson, A. E. (1981). Conjugal transfer of R-plasmid Rldrd-19 in Escherichia coli below 22°C. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 42, 789-791. Sjogren, R. E. (1989). Soil survival of Escherichia coli: Laboratory microcosms and field plots. Abstr. Annu. Meet. Am. SOC.Microbiol. p. 353.
130
GREGG BOGOSIAN AND JAMES F. KANE
Smith, C., Jr., Milewski, E., and Martin, M. A. (1985).The effect of colonizing mice with laboratory and wild type strains of E. coli containing tumor virus genomes. Recomb. DNA Tech. Bull. 8,47-51. Smith, H. W. (1969).Transfer of antibiotic resistance from animal and human strains of Escherichia coli to resident E. coli in the alimentary tract of man. Lancet 1, 11741176.
Smith, H. W. (1970).Incidence in river water of Escherichia coli containing R factors. Nature (London) 228,1286-1288. Smith, H. W. (1975).Survival of orally administered E. coli K-12 in alimentary tract of man. Nature (London) 255, 500-502. Smith, H.W. (1978).Is it safe to use Escherichia coli K-12 in recombinant DNA experiments? J. Infect. Dis. 5, 655-660. Smith, H. W., and Huggins, M. B. (1976).Further observations on the association of the colicine V plasmid of Escherichio coli with pathogenicity and with survival in the alimentary tract. 1. Gen. Microbiol. 92,335-350. Smith, H. W., and Huggins, M. B. (1978).The effect of plasmid-determined and other characteristics on the survival of Escherichia coli in the alimentary tract of two human beings. J. Gen. Microbiol. 109,375-379. Smith, H. W., and Huggins, M. B. (1980).The association of the 018,K1, and H7 antigens and the ColV plasmid of a strain of Escherichia coli with its virulence and immunogenicity. J. Gen. Microbiol. 121,387-400. Smith, P. R., Farrell, E., and Dunican, K. (1974).Survival of R+ Escherichia coli in sea water. Appl. Microbiol. 27,983-984. Soberon, X.,Covarrubias, L., and Bolivar, F. (1980).Construction and characterization of new cloning vehicles. IV. Deletion derivatives of pBR322 and pBR325. Gene 9, 287-305.
Stanier, R. Y., Ingraham, J. L., Wheelis, M. L., and Painter, P. R. (1986).“The Microbial World,” pp. 439-452. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey. Steffan, R. J., Breen, A., Atlas, R. M.,and Sayler, G. S. (1989).Monitoring genetically engineered microorganisms in freshwater microcosms. 1.Ind. Microbiol. 4,441-446. Stewart, F. M., and Levin, B. R. (1977).The population biology of bacterial plasmids: A priori conditions for the existence of conjugationally transmitted factors. Genetics 87,209-228.
Stewart, K. R.,and Koditschek, L. (1980).Drug-resistance transfer in Escherichia coli in New York bight sediment. Mar. Pollut. BuH. 11,130-133. Stotzky, G. (1986).Influence of soil mineral colloids on metabolic processes, growth, adhesion, and ecology of microbes and viruses. In “Interactions of Soil Minerals with Natural Organics and Microbes” (P. M. Huang and M. Schnitzer, eds.), pp. 305-428. Soil Science Society of America, Madison, Wisconsin. Stotzky, G., and Babich, H. (1984).Fate of genetically-engineered microbes in natural environments. Recomb. DNA Tech. Bull. 7, 163-188. Stotzky, G., and Babich, H. (1986).Survival of, and genetic transfer by, genetically engineered bacteria in natural environments. Adv. Appl. Microbiol. 31,93-138. Stotzky, G.,Devanas, M. A,, and Zeph, L. R. (1989).Methods of studying bacterial gene transfer in soil by conjugation and transduction. U.S. Environ. Prot. Agency Doc. EPA-60013-89-042.
Strauss, H. S., Hattis, D., Page, G., Harrison, K., Vogel, S., and Caldart, C. (1986).Genetically-engineered microorganisms: 11. Survival, multiplication, and genetic transfer. Recomb. DNA Tech. Bull. 9,69-88.
ENVIRONMENTAL FATE OF RECOMBINANT E. coli K-12
131
Tiedje, J. M., Colwell, R. K., Grossman, Y. L., Hodson, R. E., Lenski, R. E., Mack, R. N., and Regal, P. J. (1989). The planned introduction of genetically engineered organisms: Ecological considerations and recommendations. Ecology 70,298-315. Toranzo, A. E., Combarro, P., Lemos, M. L., and Barja, J. L. (1984). Plasmid coding for transferable drug resistance in bacteria isolated from cultured rainbow trout. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 48, 872-877. Trevors, J. T. (1987). Survival of Escherichia coli donor, recipient, and transconjugant cells in soil. Water Air Soil Pollut. 34,409-414. Trevors, J. T., and Oddie, K. M. (1986). R-plasmid transfer in soil and water. Can. J. Microbiol. 32, 610-613. Trevors, J. T., and Starodub, M. E. (1987). R-plasmid transfer in nonsterile agricultural soil. Syst. Appl. Microbiol. 9, 312-315. Twigg, A. J., and Sherratt, D. (1980). Trans-complementable copy-number mutants of plasmid ColE1. Nature (London) 283, 216-218. van Leeuwen, W. J., van Embden, J. D. A., and Guinee, P. A. M. (1979). Identification of E. coli K-12 derivatives by means of bacteriophages. Recomb. DNA Tech. Bull. 2, 36-40. Vernet, T., McDonald, I. J., Cameron, D. R., and Visentin, L. P. (1985).Stable maintenance in chemostat-grown Escherichia coli of pBR322 and pACYC184 by disruption of the tetracycline resistance gene. Biosci. Rep. 5, 29-37. Walter, M. V., Porteous, A., and Seidler,R. J. (1987).Measuring genetic stability in bacteria of potential use in genetic engineering. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 53, 105-109. Warren, G. J., Twigg, A. J., and Sherratt, D. J. (1978).ColEl plasmid mobility and relaxation complex. Nature (London) 274, 259-261. Weinberg, S. R., and Stotzky, G. (1972). Conjugation and genetic recombination of Escherichia coli in soil. Soil Biol. Biochem. 4, 171-180. Wells, C. L., Johnson, W. J., Kan, C. M., and Balish, E. (1978). Inability of debilitated Escherichia coli ~ 1 7 7 to 6 colonize germ-free rodents. Nature (London) 274, 397. Willetts, N. S., and Wilkins, B. (1984). Processing of plasmid DNA during bacterial conjugation. Microbiol. Rev. 48, 24-41. Williams, P. H. (1977). Plasmid transfer in the human alimentary tract. FEMS Microbiol. Lett. 2, 91-95. Williams, P. H., Sedgwick, M. I., Evans, N., Turner, P. J., George, R. H., and McNeish, A. S. (1978). Adherence of an enteropathogenic strain of Escherichia coli to human intestinal mucosa is mediated by a colicinogenic conjugative plasmid. Infect. Irnmun. 22, 393-402. Wouters, J. T. M., Driehuis, F. L., Polaczek, P. J., van Oppenraay, M.-L. H. A., and van Andel, J. G. (1980).Persistence of the pBR322 plasmid in Escherichia coli K-12 grown in chemostat cultures. Antonie van Leeuwenhoek 46, 353-362. Young, I. G., and Poulis, M. I. (1978). Conjugal transmission of cloning vectors derived from ColEI. Gene 4, 175-179. Zeph, L. R., and Stotzky, G. (1988). Transduction by bacteriophage P1 in soil. Abstr. Annu. Meet. Am. SOC.Microbiol. p. 298. Zeph, L. R., and Stotzky, G. (1989). Use of a biotinylated DNA probe to detect bacteria transduced by bacteriophage P I in soil. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 55, 661-665. Zeph, L. R., Onaga, M. A., and Stotzky, G. (1987).Transduction in soil. Abstr. Annu. Meet. Am. SOC.Microbiol. p. 303. Zeph, L. R., Onaga, M. A., and Stotzky, G. (1988). Transduction of Escherichia coli by bacteriophage PI in soil. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 54, 1731-1737.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Microbial Cytochromes P-450 and Xenobiotic Metabolism F. SIMASARIASLANI Central Research and Development Department E. 1. du Pont de Nemours and Company, lnc. Wilmington, Delaware 19880 I. Introduction 11. General Properties of Cytochromes P-450 111. Microbial Cytochromes P-450 A. Procaryotic Cytochromes P-450 B. Eucaryotic Cytochromes P-450 IV. Conclusion References
I. Introduction
Cytochromes P-450, which are a special class of heme-containing multicomponent enzymes, are widely distributed in mammalian, plant, and microbial systems. These enzymes have been the subject of numerous extensive reviews in the past. For some of the more recent articles, readers are referred to reviews by Guengerich (1987),Dawson and Smith Eble (19861, and Black and Coon (1987). Due to their versatility and wide distribution in biological systems, cytochromes P-450 have been recognized to play a central role in the oxidative metabolism of chemicals of pharmaceutical, agricultural, and environmental significance. Although numerous mammalian cytochromes P-450 have been extensively studied, detailed research on their microbial counterparts for many years has been limited to the P-450 systems of Pseudomonas putida and to some extent to Saccharomyces cerevisiae. However, during the past few years more attention has been focused on other microbial cytochromes P-450, and a number of procaryotic and eucaryotic P-450 enzymes of microbial origin have now been purified to homogeneity and studied in detail. The studies have emphasized the central role of these enzymes, similar to their mammalian counterparts, in the oxidation of chemicals of an endobiotic and xenobiotic nature. Considering current concern about the fate of various recalcitrant xenobiotic chemicals in the environment, the significant role that oxidative enzymes (such as P-450) play in the toxification/detoxification of chemicals cannot be overemphasized. It is therefore this author’s intention to present herein the most recent information available on various microbial P-450 enzymes so that this article may serve as a reference for those investigators interested in such enzymatic systems. 133 ADVANCES IN APPLIED MICROBIOLOGY. VOLUME 36 Copyright 6 1991 by Academic Press, Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved.
134
F. SIMA SARIASLANI
II. General Properties of Cytochromes P-450
The reduced CO adducts of all cytochromes P-450 generate distinct spectra by absorbing maximally between 447 and 452 nm. Cytochromes P-450 are usually multicomponent systems and require the participation of other ancillary proteins for their catalytic functions. There are basically two major types of P-450 systems reported to date (Fig. 1).The system identified in the cytoplasmic reticulum of eucaryotic organisms (Type I), consists of a FAD- and FMN-containing reductase for transport of electrons from NADPH to the P-450 component. In this type of organization, electrons are donated from NADPH to the NADPH-cytochrome P-450 reductase that cycles between one- and three-electron reduced forms. The NADPH-cytochrome P-450 reductase is composed of two domains, a small hydrophobic domain in the N-terminus region that binds both the membrane and the P-450 component, and a large hydrophilic domain that contains the C-terminus and binds both flavins. In this case, the flow of electrons occurs from FAD to FMN and then to the P-450 component in two sequential one-electron steps. It appears that one reductase can transfer electrons to more than one P-450 component
Type I1
Reductase
FIG.1. The arrangement of various components within Type I and Type I1 cytochromes P-450.
MICROBIAL CYTOCHROME P-450
135
in mammalian systems (Black and Coon, 1987). The microsomal P-450 enzymes exhibit broad and overlapping catalytic activities and are perhaps the most nonspecific enzymes known. In contrast, the second type of P-450 system (Type 11),which has been identified in mitochondria and bacteria, generally possesses very tight substrate specificities. Type I1 P-450 systems, in addition to a FADcontaining reductase, use a small redox iron-sulfur protein (ferredoxin) for transfer of electrons to the terminal P-450 component. Figure 2 depicts the prosthetic nature of the protein components involved in electron transport in Type I1 P-450 systems. A third type of organization of P-450 components has been reported by Fulco and co-workers for the P-450 system of Bacillus megaterium (Nahri and Fulco, 1987).In this bacterium a catalytically self-sufficient P-450, which does not require the presence of ancillary electron transport proteins, performs its oxidative reactions in the presence of the reduced pyridine nucleotide. Cytochromes P-450 contain a single iron porphyrin IX (heme) prosthetic group ligated to the apoprotein by a unique cysteine thiolate bond. Figure 3 depicts the structures of various adducts of P-450 enzymes. All P-450 enzymes studied to date have a common catalytic
R
Prosthetic group of the reductase component (flavin adenine dinucleotide)
FIG.2.
Prosthetic group of the ferredoxin component (the [2Fe-2S1
Prosthetic group of the cytochrome P-450 component (heme, protoporphyrin IX) The prosthetic nature of various components of Type I1 cytochromes P-450.
136
F. SIMA SARIASLANI
NA
Xm,-394nm
Enzyme
B
418 nm
Enzyme
450 nm
Enzyme FIG. 3. (A] The high-spin ferric cytochrome P-450with an absorption maximum of -394 nm. (B) The low-spin ferric cytochrome P-450with an absorption maximum of -418 nm. (C) The GO-bound ferrous cytochrome P-450,which exhibits the characteristic absorption at -450 nm. Adapted from Black and Coon (1987),with permission.
cycle (Fig. 4) through which they reductively cleave molecular oxygen and bring about hydroxylation of their substrates. The sequence of events of the P-450 catalytic cycle, during which many unusual shortlived intermediates are formed, is summarized as follows: 1. In the first step, substrate binding occurs. This step is thought to be very rapid and in most cases changes the spin state of iron from low (hexacoordinate) to high (pentacoordinate), giving rise to a Type I spectrum. In the case of low-spin P-450 enzymes, this step facilitates the subsequent electron uptake. On the other hand, P-450 enzymes isolated in high-spin form do not need substrate binding for reduction. 2. In the second step, the flavoprotein reductase donates one electron and reduces the substrate-bound iron complex to generate a ferrous high-spin enzyme complex. 3. In the third step, molecular oxygen binds the ferrous enzyme complex and the unstable ternary oxy complex is formed. 4. A second electron transfer from the flavoprotein reductase in the fourth step generates the peroxo intermediate.
MICROBIAL CYTOCHROME P-450
137
5. During the fifth step, heterolysis of the 0-0 bond produces one molecule of water and a reactive intermediate. Indirect approaches have been used to establish the exact nature of this unstable intermediate. For example, binding and reduction of molecular oxygen in the native P-450 catalytic cycle can be circumvented by a variety of artificial twoelectron oxidizing agents such as alkyl hydroperoxidases and iodosylbenzene. These biomimetic reactions, which do not need NAD(P)H or molecular oxygen, are not inhibited by carbon monoxide (Groves, 1985; Tabushi, 1988; Okamoto et aJ., 1989). In these reactions the peroxide oxygen is transferred to the substrate. The catalytic intermediate generated in this case is more stable than that generated in the native P-450 cycle and has therefore allowed investigators to propose structures such as the oxoiron(1V) porphyrin cation radical or oxoiron(V) complex as the unstable intermediate of the native P-450 cycle (Imai eta]., 1989). 6. In the final step of this catalytic cycle, substrate oxygenation occurs and the low-spin ferric enzyme becomes available for a second cycle.
-
Reactions catalyzed by various cytochromes P-450 have recently been reviewed by Guengerich (1990). These reactions include:
Substrate (S) Fe"' ferric low spin
Fe&(S) femc high spin
Fe'h (S)
t
ferrous high spin
t
A
NAD(P)H e
1
FIG.4. The catalytic cycle of cytochromes P-450.
138
F. SIMA SARIASLANI
C-H -C-OH FIG.5. Carbon hydroxylation by cytochromes P-450(Ortiz de Montellano, 1989).
1. Carbon hydroxylation, during which an alkane is converted to a primary, secondary, or tertiary alcohol (Ortiz de Montellano, 1989; Groves and Subramanian, 1984) (Fig. 5). 2. Heteroatom oxygenation, which has been shown with compounds containing nitrogen and sulfur (Neal and Alpert, 1982; Frederick et al., 1982) (Fig. 6). 3. Dealkylation (heteroatom release), which involves either oneelectron abstraction from the heteroatom or hydrogen atom abstraction (Guengerich, 1984) (Fig. 7). 4. Epoxidation of olefins and aromatic rings, which is thought to be a stepwise reaction involving discrete radical and/or cationic intermediates. Epoxidation of olefins is usually accompanied by retention of stereochemistry (Guengerich and Macdonald, 1984) (Fig. 8). 5. Oxidative group migration (NIH shift), which can be indicative of epoxidation; however, direct transfer of substituents can also occur (Daly et al., 1972; Miller and Guengerich, 1982) (Fig. 9). 6. Dehydrogenation, in which the substrate loses Hz, similar to reactions observed with dehydrogenases (Ortiz de Montellano, 1989; Bocker and Guengerich, 1986) (Fig. 10). 7 . Mechanism-based inactivation includes a variety of reactions, such as heteroatom oxygenation, heteroatom release, epoxidation, and oxidative group migration. Intermediates-formed, such as acetylenes and terminal olefins, can inactivate the P-450 enzymes (Bocker and Guengerich, 1986; Ortiz de Montellano and Correis, 1984). 8. Reduction processes, which in some cases involve two-electron processes, occur with polyhalogenated methanes (carbon tetrachloride and halothane), azo dyes, nitro groups, N-oxides, and epoxides (Pohl et al., 1984) (Fig. 11). 9. Another type of reaction that has recently been attributed to P-450 enzymes is the stepwise reductive cleavage of xenobiotic hydroperoxides and biologically occurring hydroperoxides as outlined in Fig. 12 (Coon and Vaz, 1988).
In the following discussions, procaryotic and eucaryotic cytochromes P-450of microbial origin will be reviewed separately.
-c-
-
-C-O FIG.6. Heteroatom oxygenation by cytochromes P-450(Neal and Alpert, 1982).
MICROBIAL CYTOCHROME P-450
OH
-
- R-CH
[R-Cl
I
-
RH
139
+
O=C\
/
FIG.7. Heteroatom release (dealkylation) by cytochromes P-450(Guengerich, 1984).
/
~
>c = c\
A/
\
/c-c\
FIG.8. Epoxidation by cytochromes P-450(Guengerich and Macdonald, 1984).
R1\
,c=c\
/ R2
-\ /R' / c - C\-R2
FIG. 9. Oxidation group migration by cytochromes P-450 (Miller and Guengerich, 1982).
CH-CHC=C FIG. 10. Dehydrogenation by cytochromes P-450(Ortiz de Montellano, 1989).
+ leC- R c. + R FIG.11. Reduction by cytochromes P-450(Pohl et al., 1984).
-
XRR'COOH XRCO + R'H FIG. 12. Reductive cleavage of hydroperoxides by cytochromes P-450(Coon and Vaz, 1988).
ill. Microbial Cytochromes P-450
A. PROCARYOTIC CYTOCHROMES P-450
Procaryotic P-450 enzymes are generally multicomponent soluble systems that fall within the Type I1 category (Fig. 1) with respect to the organization of their electron transfer components. These P-450 systems were extensively reviewed by Sligar and Murray (1986). The majority of these enzymes are either extremely substrate specific or act only on a limited number of structurally related substrates. However, isolated examples of procaryotic P-450 enzymes with a different redox component organization or with versatile catalytic activities have also been
140
F. SIMA SARIASLANI
reported. Various procaryotic P-450 systems, which are involved in xenobiotic oxidation, are reviewed below: 1. Pseudomonas putida
Cytochrome P-450 systems have been identified in various strains of P. putida (Unger et al., 1986a). a. Pseudomonas putida (ATCC 17453). The cytochrome P-450 (P450,,,) system of P. putida involved in stereo- and regiospecific hydroxylation of camphor at the 5-eXO position (Fig. 13A) has been studied
(A)
P. pulida (Wild type) v
9
&.-
5-Exo ( 100%)
Camphor (B) P. pulida (Y96 mutant)
-
5-Exo (92%)
6-Ex0 (4%) 3-EXo (4%)
5-Exo (82%)
6-Ex0 (15%)
3-Exo (2.5%)
5-Exo ( 6 3 % )
6-Ex0 (31%)
347x0 (6%)
5-Exo (45%)
6-Ex0 (47%)
3-Exo (2.5%)
9-Hydroxy (0.1%)
(A) P. pufida (Wild type)
-
9-Hydroxy (0.5%)
l-CH3-norcamphor
(B) P. pufida (Y96 mutant)
-
(A) P. pulida (Wild type)
Norcamphor
(B) P. pufida (Y96 mutant)
-
$-Ex0 (36%)
6-Exa (41%)
3-Exo (23%)
FIG.13. (A] Oxidation of camphor, l-CH,-norcamphor, and norcamphor by P-450,., of Pseudornonas putida. (B) Oxidation of camphor, l-CH3-norcamphor, and norcamphor by P. putida (Y96 mutant) (Atkins and Sligar, 1988,1989).
MICROBIAL CYTOCHROME P-450
141
in great detail. Comprehensive reviews discussing this cytochrome P-450 system and its crystal structure have previously been published (Sligar and Murray, 1986; Poulos, 1986). Herein, the most recent information on this P-450 system will be reviewed. This multicomponent system, which was initially identified and characterized by Gunsalus and co-workers in the 1960s (Hedegaard and Gunsalus, 1965), is currently being studied in several laboratories. The P-45OC,, system is composed of a 45,000-Da cytochrome P-450 [P450cam), a 11,726-Da [2Fe-2S] ferredoxin (putidaredoxin), and a 48,000Da FAD-containing NADH-specific ferredoxin reductase (putidaredoxin reductase). Each of these components has been studied in great detail (Unger et a]., 1986b). The crystal structure of P-45OC,, has been resolved with highresolution X-ray crystallography (Poulos, 1986). Elucidation of the P-45OC,, structure has made considerable contributions to the advancement of our understanding of the mechanism of action of P-450 enzymes. These studies have shown that P-45OC,, is an asymmetrical, 30-kthick triangular prism-shaped protein with 1 2 helical segments (A-L), which contribute to 45% of its structure, and four antiparallel p pairs. The heme, which is completely surrounded by the protein, is positioned between helix L [proximal helix) and helix I (distal helix). The substrate is buried in an internal pocket above the heme distal surface adjacent to the oxygen-binding site. The orientation of camphor in the active site allows for contact between its C5 and the activated iron-bound oxygen atom for the production of the 5-eXOhydroxycamphor. The structures of both camphor-bound and camphorfree forms of P-45OC,, have been studied in detail (Poulos, 1988). In the camphor-free P-45OC,,, the substrate pocket of the enzyme is filled with five water molecules. In addition, a sixth water molecule forms a ligand with the heme iron at L6. No significant conformational changes are observed upon binding of the substrate to the enzyme. Raag and Poulos (1989) studied the X-ray structure of the ternary complex between CO, camphor, and P-45OC,, and showed that whereas camphor maintains its nonbonded contact with CO, it moves about 0.8 A, allowing the oxygen atom of the CO molecule to nestle in the enzyme’s groove. Crystallography studies have also indicated that the high stereo- and regiospecificity of P-45OC,, are achieved through specific interaction of several amino acid residues, with the substrate, at the active site of the enzyme (Poulos et al., 1987).In particular, studies with camphor-bound P-450 have indicated the presence of a hydrogen bond between the carbonyl moiety of camphor and the active site residue tyrosine-96. In
142
F. SIMA SARIASLANI
addition to X-ray crystallography, site-directed mutagenesis has been used to study the mechanism of camphor hydroxylation by P-45Ocam. Recently, Atkins and Sligar (1988, 1989) described the influence of the site-specific mutation of three active site residues-valine-295, valine247, and tyrosine-96-on the regiospecificity of P-45OCamduring oxidation of camphor and two of its analogs, 1-CH3-norcamphorand norcamphor (Fig. 13B). Replacement of tyrosine-96 by phenylalanine (mutant Y96F), through site-directed mutagenesis, destroys the strict regiospecificity observed in camphor oxidation (Fig. 13B). In addition to 5-exohydroxycamphor, 6-exo-, 3-eXO-, and 9-hydroxycamphors were also formed during camphor oxidation by this mutant. On the other hand, oxidation of norcamphor and l-CH,-norcarnphor by the wild-type P . putida usually results in the formation of several hydroxylated metabolites. Hydroxylation of norcamphor by the Y96F mutant generated similar metabolites, except that hydroxylation at the 3-position was significantly increased (from 2.5 to 23%). A similar effect was observed when 1-CH3-norcamphor was used as substrate for this mutant. These results underline the directive role played by the putative hydrogen bond between the substrate and tyrosinel96 of the active site in the regiospecificity of P-450,,,-catalyzed reactions. Atkins and Sligar (1989) have also studied the effect of hydrophobic interactions between substrate and the active site of P-45OCa, by changing valine-295 to isoleucine (mutant V295I) and valine-247 to alanine (mutant V247A). When camphor binds the enzyme, these residues are in contact with its 8,9-gem-dimethyl groups and 6- and 10-carbon atoms. It was concluded that these hydrophobic interactions had negligible effects on the control of regiospecificity of camphor hydroxylation by P-45OCa,. On the other hand, because hydroxylation of camphor analogs (1-CH3-norcamphor and norcamphor) was influenced by these mutations, Atkins and Sligar (1989) proposed that the steric bulk of the side chain of alanine-247 affects substrate orientation in these reactions. Recently Imai et al. (1989) showed that threonine-252 plays an important role in camphor hydroxylation by P-450,,, . When threonine-252 was replaced by alanine or valine, the reaction was uncoupled and HzOz was produced from Oz. As a result, the amount of 5-exohydroxycamphor produced was appreciably decreased. On the other hand, when threonine-252 was replaced by serine, the monooxygenase activity was not impaired. Based on these results, Imai et al. proposed that uncoupling of oxygen and subsequent HzOz production is due to the lack of a hydroxyl side chain in alanine and valine in the mutant enzyme.
MICROBIAL CYTOCHROME P-450
143
As mentioned above, P-45OCa, is a multicomponent system that, in addition to the P-450 component, requires participation of NADH, putidaredoxin, and putidaredoxin reductase for substrate turnover. In an interesting study, Smith Eble and Dawson (1984) substituted putidaredoxin reductase and putidaredoxin with an artificial electron mediator such as phenazine methosulfate (PMS) and studied the hydroxylation of camphor by this system. In this reaction, in which transfer of electrons from NADH to P-45OC,, was mediated by PMS, 5-exohydroxycamphor was formed as the reaction product. Addition of 2,3dimercaptopropanol or putidaredoxin to the NADH/PMS/P-45OCa, system was accompanied by a 4- or a 20-fold increase in product formation, respectively. These effects were enhanced dramatically when O2was constantly bubbled through the system. These studies provided the first example of an oxygen-dependent P-450-catalyzed reaction in which an artificial electron mediator replaced the indigenous redox proteins. Molecular biology studies have revealed that the CAM plasmid in P. putida PpGl encodes for the enzymes involved in the early steps of camphor oxidation (Koga et al., 1985, 1989; Unger et al., 1986b). These include 5-exo-hydroxycamphor dehydrogenase (camD gene), and the three P-45OCa, components, putidaredoxin reductase (camA), putidaredoxin (camB), and P-450,,, (camC). The genes form the camDCAB operon and are under negative control by the camR gene located immediately upstream from the camD gene (Koga et al., 1986). In an independent study, Peterson et al. (1990) reported that a 2.2 x lo3 base pair BamHI-StuI fragment from camphor-grown P. putida cells contained two open reading frames that encode for putidaredoxin and putidaredoxin reductase. A potential transcription termination site was found 3' to the putidaredoxin-coding region. The sequence coding for the FAD-binding site in the reductase is close to the N-terminus (residues 6-24), whereas the NADH-binding site lies between residues 151 and 169. Both genes were subcloned and were independently expressed in Escherichia coli. When the rare start codon of GTG of putidaredoxin reductase was changed to ATG, an 18-fold increase in the level of expression of this protein was observed (Peterson et al., 1990).This is a significant finding because it allows isolation of a large amount of protein for detailed biochemical studies. In addition to 5-ex0 hydroxylation of camphor, P-45OC,, has been used for other types of reactions. Reductive dehalogenation of chloropicrin, polyhalomethanes, and chloronitromethanes was accomplished by whole cells of P. putida containing P-45OCa, (Castro et al., 1983, 1985). The final product of chloropicrin degradation was nitromethane
144
-
F. SIMA SARIASLANI
-
C13CNOz CIZCHNOZ CICHzNOzCH3NOz FIG.14. Oxidation of chloropicrin to nitromethane by Pseudomonas putida containing P-450 cam (Castro et al., 1983, 1985).
(Fig. 14). Trichloronitromethane and chloroform were the fastest and the slowest reacting substrates, respectively. Castro et al. (1988) later compared the stoichiometries and kinetics of reduction of trichloromethane, bromotrichloromethane, carbon tetrachloride, ethylene dibromide, and 1,2-dibromo-3-chloropropaneby iron(I1) deuteroporphyrin IX, rat liver P-450PB,P-45OCam,and whole cells of P. putida. Polyhalomethanes underwent reductive hydrogenolysis in all systems studied. Quantitative conversion of the vicinal halides by all the P-450 systems studied resulted in the formation of olefins (Fig. 15). These studies indicated that halides that undergo a quick bond cleavage step exhibit a steric inhibition effect on P-45OCam,whereas the mammalian P - 4 5 0 ~ ~ remains unaffected. Castro et al. concluded that the heme moiety in P-450~ could ~ be more accessible than the heme in P-45Oca,. b. Pseudomonas putida (PpG777). A second cytochrome P-450 system, which is induced by linalool and performs the first two steps of linalool oxidation (Fig. 16), has been identified in P. putida (incognita, strain PpG777) (Ullah et al., 1990). This three-component system consists of a 43,700-Da FAD-containing reductase (reductaseu,), a 12,800Da ferredoxin with a [2Fe-2S] cluster (ferredoxinli,), and a 44,800-Da P-450 component (P-4501~~). In reconstituted systems in which putidaredoxin reductase was used with P-45Oljn and ferredoxinli,, hydroxylation of linalool occurred at less than 10% of the rate observed with the native component. The second product of the linalool hydroxylation reaction is 8-oxolinalool, which is also mediated by the linalool monooxygenase system. In spite of certain similarities, P-450cam and P-45O1in possess distinct physical properties. Hoa et al. (1989)investigated the pressure-induced spectral changes in these cytochrome P-450 systems. P-4501~~ is much more stable under increasing pressure compared to P-45Ocam. On the other hand, although formation of P-42Olin was accompanied with precipitation of the protein and its unfolding, interconversion of P-45Ocam to P-42OCa, occurred without loss of its tertiary structure. Hoa et al.
FIG.15. Conversion of vicinal halides to olefins by various P-450 systems (Castro et al., 1988).
145
MICROBIAL CYTOCHROME P-450
Linalool
8-Hydroxy lindool
8-Oxolinalool
FIG.16. Oxidation of linalool by P-4501i, of Pseudomonas putida (incognita) (Ullah et al., 1990).
(1989) proposed that p-4501in possesses a rigid structure but that P450,,, is more elastic. 2. Bacillus megaterium
Independent studies in two laboratories with two separate strains of B. megaterium have resulted in identification of two vastly different cytochrome P-450 systems in this organism. a. Bacillus megaterium (ATCC 14581). Extensive studies performed in Fulco’s laboratory at the University of California in Los Angeles have led to the characterization of a unique cytochrome P-450 from B. megaterium (ATCC 14581) (Miura and Fulco, 1975; Matson and Fulco, 1981) that hydroxylates both long-chain fatty acids and their corresponding amides and alcohols. The position of the hydroxyl group on the substrate molecule regulates its oxidation by this P-450 enzyme. The 0-1,w-2, and w-3 monohydroxy products of the unsubstituted and saturated fatty acids cannot act as substrates for the enzyme. Among the saturated fatty acids, the order of activity for hydroxylation of the substrates was c15 > c16 > c14 > C17 > c13 > C18 = C12. For amides this order was C14 > Clz > C15 > c16 and for alcohols it was c 1 4>c 1 3 = c15 > C12 > CIS. Kim and Fulco (1983) investigated the effect of 19 barbiturates on P-450 induction in B.megaterium and found that 13 of these chemicals induced the enzyme. Among the substrates tested, secobarbital, thiamylal, and methohexital were very good inducers. Kim and Fulco reported that the enzyme induction was higher with lipophilic substrates. At least three distinct P-450 enzymes are induced by phenobarbital in B. megaterium. One of these P-450 enzymes, P-45OBM-1,which is a 47,439-Da enzyme with 410 amino acids (Schwalb et a]., 1985),has recently been cloned (He eta]., 1989).P-450BM-1exhibits 27% sequence homology to P-450,,, but is four amino acids smaller. Fulco and co-workers concluded that P - 4 5 0 ~belongs ~ - ~ to a new gene family. This enzyme is distinct from P-45oBM-3,which will be discussed
146
F. SIMA SARIASLANI
later. The catalytic function of P-450BM-1is still unknown; however, this P-450 exhibits fatty acid monooxygenase activity in the presence of iodosylbenzene diacetate. Recent studies in Fulco’s laboratory have concentrated on the third enzyme of this series, designated P-450BM-3. P - 4 5 0 ~ ~is3a unique single-component enzyme system that performs the NADPH-dependent oxygenation of a variety of fatty acids in the absence of other electron transport proteins. Due to the presence of noncovalently bound FAD and FMN in its structure, P-450BM-3 possesses a distinctive absorption spectrum in the 450- to 475-nm region. This enzyme contains both a P-450 and a NADPH:P-450 reductase component in a single protein. Phenobarbital induces cytochromes P-450 in other strains of B. megaterium that cross-react with P-45oBM-3 antibodies. Nahri and Fulco (1987) showed that when the substrate-bound P-45oBM-3 is subjected to limited trypsin digest, two domains (polypeptides) with molecular weights of 66,000 and 55,000 are formed. The 66,000-Da domain, which contains the FAD and the FMN moieties, performs the NADPH-dependent reduction of cytochrome c and is derived from the C-terminus of P-450BM-3. Three heme-containing peptides (TI, TII, and TIII) constitute the 55,000Da domain. All these peptides exhibit the characteristic spectral properties of P-450 in the presence of CO and dithionite. The 55,000-Da TI component, which binds substrate, contains the N-terminus of P-450BM-3. The TI1 and TI11 components do not bind substrate and lack the first 9 and 15 amino acids of the N-terminus of P-450BM-31respectively. When P-~~CIBM-~ was digested in the absence of substrate, only the 54,000-Da TI1 and the 53,500-Da TI11 peptides were generated, indicating that perhaps one or more residues of the first nine N-terminus amino acids of P-45oBM-3 are involved in substrate binding. Following cloning and sequencing of the self-sufficient P-450BM-3, Wen and Fulco (1987) succeeded in expressing this gene constitutively in E. coli. Because this recombinant constitutive protein could not be induced by phenobarbital, they introduced the cloned gene back into B. megaterium and observed that although its expression was constitutively repressed, it was induced by phenobarbital. Based on these results Wen and Fulco proposed that perhaps interaction of phenobarbital with a repressor-type molecule, which is absent in E. coli, is a prerequisite for P-450BM-3 induction. After sequencing a 5-kb DNA fragment that contained the P-45oBM-3 gene, Ruettinger et al. (1989) estimated a molecular weight of 117,641 for the self-sufficient protein. The P-450 domain of P-450BM-3 exhibits homology (25%) with the fatty acid o-hydroxylase of P-450 family IV. On the other hand, the reductase domain of this enzyme exhibits 33%
MICROBIAL CYTOCHROME P-450
147
sequence homology with the NADPH:reductases of mammalian liver. Although both P-450 and the reductase domains of P-450BM-3 define new gene families, they contain highly conserved regions that exhibit up to 50% sequence homology with their mammalian counterparts. S1 mapping of the mRNA for P-45oBM-3 indicated a nucleotide length of 3339 2 10 bases for this molecule. Wen et al. (1989) recently examined the effects on gene expression of 5' and 3' deletion derivatives obtained from a 1.6-kb DNA fragment that includes the regulatory region and 88 bases of the N-terminus of P-450BM-3. They concluded that the P-450BM-3 gene, which is under positive control, requires binding with at least one trans-acting factor, probably a protein, to activate transcription from the P-450BM-3promoter. Barbiturates might facilitate binding of this protein with the gene to exert their inducer effect. It is also possible that barbiturates either increase the rate of the protein synthesis or retard its degradation. Additionally, barbiturates might also facilitate the release of the protein from the cell membrane and thus make it accessible to plasmid or chromosomal DNA in the cytoplasm. Detectable expression of P-45oBM-3 is achieved only when a minimum of 0.6-0.7 kb of chromosomal DNA, immediately upstream from the translation start site of the BM-3 gene, is present. Boddupalli et a]. (1990),who have recently overexpressed P-45oBM-3 in E. coli, have shown the hydroxylation of palmitic acid by this recombinant P - ~ ~ O BatMa- rate ~ of 1600 mol/min/mol of heme. Lauric and myristic acids were hydroxylated, regardless of their initial concentrations, into two metabolites. A 1:l stoichiometry of oxygen or NADPH consumed per molecule of substrate oxidized was observed with these substrates. However, when palmitic acid was used as substrate, the ratio of oxygen or NADPH consumed per molecule of substrate oxidized was dependent on the concentration of the substrate used. At high concentrations (>zoo p M ) ,monohydroxylation of palmitic acid resulted in the formation of three metabolites and a stoichiometry of 1:l was observed for oxygen and palmitic acid consumption. When lower concentrations (<50 pM) of palmitic acid were used, additional metabolites were formed and a stoichiometry of 3:l was observed for oxygen and palmitic acid consumption. Boddupalli et al. have concluded that some of the metabolites formed in this case can undergo additional hydroxylation to yield polyhydroxy or hydroxyketone products. b. Bacillus megaterium (ATCC 13368). The Second P-450 system (P-450,,,) identified in B. megaterium (ATCC 13368) by Berg et al. (1975) has been studied in far less detail. P-450me, performs the NADPH-dependent 15P-hydroxylation of 3-oxo-A4 steroids. In an attempt to identify the P-450me, inducer, Berg and Rafter (1981)examined
148
F. SIMA SARIASLANI
a number of substrates and classical mammalian P-450 inducers. They concluded that none of the substrates tested could act as the inducer for the enzyme. However, it is noteworthy that the medium used for cultivation of this bacterium contains soybean extract. Therefore, based on findings in our laboratory, which will be discussed later, the possibility that one of the ingredients in the soybean extract might act as the inducer for P-450megshould be considered. In contrast to P-450BM-3, P-450megis a multicomponent system and has been resolved into three components (Berg et al., 1976). These components consist of a reductase (megaredoxin reductase), which was identified as a 55,000-Da NADPHdependent FMN-containing flavoprotein, a 13,000-Da ferredoxin (megaredoxin), and a 52,000-Da terminal P-450 component (P-45Omeg).Table I summarizes the steroid substrates utilized by P-450meg. Berg et al. (1979) have shown that adrenal ferredoxin and either adrenal ferredoxin reductase or rabbit microsomal P-450 reductase can replace megaredoxin and megaredoxin reductase in P-450BM.3-reconstitutedassays. 3. Xanthobacter s p .
A cytochrome P-450 system that performs the NADPH-dependent hydroxylation of cyclohexane to cyclohexanol was identified by Trower et al. (1985). This cyclohexane-inducible P-450 is multicomponent and catalyzes oxidative reactions on a variety of hydrocarbons, as shown in Table I1 (Warburton et al., 1990). Compounds such as alkyl-substituted cycloalkanes, a bicyclic terpene, some aromatic hydrocarbons, and heterocyclic structures act as substrates for this P-450 system. On the other hand, P-menthane, straight chain alkanes, and dicyclohexyl are not oxidized. 4. Acinetobacter calcoaceticus
Growth on n-hexadecane as the sole carbon and energy source induces cytochromes P-450 in a variety of Acinetobacter strains (Asperger et al., 1981).When A. calcoaceticus cells are grown in a defined medium with n-hexadecane as the sole source of carbon, a particulate P-450 enzyme can be obtained after treatment with EDTA/lysozyme (Asperger et al., 1985a) or Triton X-100 (Muller et a]., 1989). However, addition of n-hexane to organisms growing in a complex medium results in the production of a mixture of soluble P-450/P-420. The membrane-bound n-hexadecane-inducible P-450 system of A. calcoaceticus is multicomponent (Asperger et al., 1985a) and has been resolved into a highly purified P-450, and into partially purified preparations of ferredoxin and ferredoxin reductase components. In reconstitution experiments using these components, long-chain n-alkanes were oxi-
TABLE I HYDROXYLATION OF VARIOUS STEROIDS BY CELL-FREE EXTRACTSOF Bacillus megoteriuma Substrate 4-Androstene-3 ,I7-dione Testosterone Progesterone 20a-Hydroxyprogesterone 17a-Hydroxyprogesterone Deoxycorticosterone Corticosterone Estrone Estradiol Estriol Dehydroepiandrosterone Pregnenolone 5a-Dihydrotestosterone Ba-Androstane-3a,17/3-doil SP-Pregnane-3a,ZOa-doil 5a-Androstane-3a,17/3-3,17-disulfate Adapted from Berg et al. (1976). with permission.
Hydroxylated product 15/3-Hydroxyandrostenedione 15/3-Hydroxytestosterone 6P-Hydroxyprogesterone 15P-Hydroxyprogesterone 15j3-Hydroxy-20a-dihydroprogesterone 15/3,17a-Dihydroxyprogesterone 15j3-Hydroxydeoxycorticosterone 15/3-Hydroxycorticosterone Not metabolized Not metabolized Not metabolized Not metabolized Not metabolized Not metabolized Not metabolized Not metabolized Not metabolized
Specific enzyme activity (nmol/mg protein/30 min] 0.7 0.4 0.4 1.6
1.4 1.5 2.0
0.06
150
F. SIMA SARIASLANI TABLE I1 SUBSTRATE SPECIFICITY OF CYCLOHEXANE HYDROXYLASE IN CELL EXTRACTSOF Xanthobacter sp."
Substrate
Specific activity (nmol O2 consumed/min/mg protein)
Cyclohexane Cyclopentane Cyclooctane Cyclodecane Methylcyclohexane Ethylcyclohexane Methylcyclopentane Ethylcyclopentane Benzene Toluene Octane Decane Undecane Dodecane Hexadecane Methylenecyclohexane l-Methyl-l,4-~yclohexadiene Cyclohexene Cyclohexene oxide p-Menthane Pinane Pyrrolidine Dicyclohexyl Quadricyclane NADPH oxidase
22.9 16.5 6.7 3.8 14.4 3.4 11.9 9.4
5.1 3.9 <0.9 <0.9 <0.9 <0.9 <0.9 6.2 15.7 46.5 25.1 co.9 10.9 12.5 <0.9 7.8 2.5
From Warburton et al. (1990),with permission.
dized. Induction of P-450 by an intermediate of the w-oxidation of n-alkanes was ruled out when the primary and secondary alcohols, n-alkanoic acids, and also amines could not act as inducers for A. calcoaceticus P-450 (Kleber et ai., 1985). However, induction by different ketones and olefins was observed. In addition to n-alkanes, longchain phenylalkanes, ethylbenzene, toluene, xylenes, biphenyl, and indene induce high levels of cytochrome P-450 in A. calcoaceticus (Kleber et a]., 1985; Asperger et al., 1985b). The low-spin P-450 system of A. caicoaceticus, which has a molecular weight of 52,000, has an absolute requirement for NADH. Binding studies with this P-450 system indicate formation of a Type I1 difference
151
MICROBIAL CYTOCHROME P-450
spectrum when octylamine is used as substrate. However, such spectral changes were not detected in the presence of n-alkanes or aniline (Muller et al., 1989). 5. Moraxella sp.
A soluble cytochrome P-450 system is induced in Moraxella sp. GU2 following its growth on guaiacol or 2-ethoxyphenol (Dadas et al., 1985). This enzyme performs the side chain hydroxylation of guaiacol, generating catechol and formaldehyde. 6. Rhizobium japonicum
Several cytochromes P-450 of unspecified function have been reported in R. japonicum (Dus et al., 1976). These enzymes have been observed both from symbiotic cells grown anaerobically in a nitrateorganic medium and from aerobically grown cells. Some of these cytochromes have exhibited significant cross-reactivity with antibodies from P-450,,, (Dus et al., 1976)and the mammalian P - 4 5 0 ~(Appleby ~.~ and Daniel, 1965). 7. Actinomyces
A number of cytochromes P-450 enzyme systems with versatile catalytic functions have been reported in various microorganisms belonging to Actinomycetes. These systems are discussed below: a. Sacchropolyspora erythraea. This organism, which was previously classified as Streptomyces erythreus, catalyzes the hydroxylation of 6-deoxyerythronolide B to erythronolide B (Fig. 17). Two cytochromes P-450, one iron-sulfur protein and two NAD(P)H-dependent ferredoxin reductase components, were isolated from this organism (Shafiee and Hutchinson, 1987,1988).These enzymes were proposed to 0
6-Deoxyerythronolide B
Erythronolide B
FIG.17. Conversion of6-deoxyerythronolideB to erythronolideB by the P-450system of Sacchropolyspora erythraea (Shafiee and Hutchinson, 1987,1988).
152
F. SIMA SARIASLANI
be involved in hydroxylation of 6-deoxyerythronolide; however, because the catalytic activities reported for in vitro-reconstituted assays are extremely low (4.8-13 mol/hour/mg protein), the in vivo involvement of these components in hydroxylation of 6-deoxyerythronolide is questionable. b. Streptomyces carbophilus. 3-Hydroxy-3-methylglutaryl coenzyme A reductase (HMG-CoA reductase) is one of the key enzymes in cholesterol biosynthesis. Inhibition of this enzyme therefore might play a role in control of cholesterol biosynthesis. One of the selective inhibitors of HMG-CoA reductase is Pravastatin sodium, which is generated by hydroxylation of compactin (sodium ML-236B carboxylate). Compactin (Fig. 18) induces two immunologically indistinguishable cytochromes P-450 (P-450,,a-1 and P-450,,a.2) in S . carbophilus (Matsuoka et al., 1989). These P-450 enzymes have molecular weights of around 46,000 and contain 46 and 47% hydrophobic residues in their amino acid compositions. c. Streptomyces setonii. A cytochrome P-450 that 0-demethylates the lignin-related compounds veratrole and guaiacol (Fig. 19) has been reported in S. setonii (Sutherland, 1987). d. Streptomyces sp. The presence of a gene encoding for a P-450like protein in a Streptomyces sp. was recently reported by Horii et al. (1990). This gene (chop), which is located upstream of the cholesterol oxidase (choA) gene, encodes for a protein containing 381 amino acids and with a molecular weight of 41,668. A certain degree of homology can be detected between the chop gene and the other reported cytochrome P-450 genes. Examination of extracts of the wild-type organism and a recombinant Streptomyces lividans carrying the chop gene revealed the presence of the characteristic CO difference spectrum in both organisms. These authors have speculated that this cytochrome P-450 might be involved in cholesterol oxidation in Streptomyces sp. No enzymatic activity has yet been demonstrated for this protein.
...’
N a C 0 0 7 OH
T
HO
.8;‘ ’
FIG.18. Hydroxylation of compactin to pravastatin sodium by the P-450 system of Streptomyces carbophilus (Matsuoka et al., 1989).
153
MICROBIAL CYTOCHROME P-450
Veratrole Guaiacol FIG. 19. 0-Demethylation of veratrole and guaiacol by the P-450 system of Streptomyces setonii (Sutherland, 1987).
e. Streptomyces griseolus. In addition to a constitutive cytochrome P-450 (P-45OcoN), two soluble and immunologically distinct cytochromes P-450 (P-450su1 and P-45OSu2)with molecular weights of 46,000 have been identified in S. griseolus (ATCC 11796) (Romesser and O'Keefe, 1986; O'Keefe et al., 1988). These multicomponent enzymes, which are induced by sulfonylurea herbicides, perform various types of oxidative reactions on these xenobiotics. Representative reactions catalyzed by P-45OSul and P-45OSu2are shown in Fig. 20. Two small sulfonylurea-induced ferredoxins (Fd-1 and Fd-a), each containing a single [3Fe-4S] cluster, have also been purified and characterized in s. griseolus (O'Keefe et al., 1990). Cloning and sequencing of the genes for these proteins have indicated that the gene for Fd-1
Chlorsulfuron COOCH3
6
SOzNHCONH
4 '
4"'
N-
p;> CH3
SUl , su2
su1 *
* pN-jH3 N-
COOH
CH20H
CH3
Sulfometuron methyl
SUl , su2
/ Chlorimuron ethyl
OCH-3
by SU2
E$' OH
FIG.20. Oxidation of selected sulfonylurea herbicides by the P-450 system of Streptomyces griseolus. From J. A. Romesser (personal communication), with permission.
154
F. SIMA SARIASLANI
(sauB) is located downstream of the gene for P - 4 5 0 and ~ ~ that ~ the gene ~ ~ deduced . amino acid for Fd-2 (subB) follows the gene for P - 4 5 0 ~The sequences of each of these proteins have indicated a molecular weight of -7000 for these proteins. Recently Omer et al. (1990) cloned, sequenced, and expressed the ~ ~ ~ The deduced genes encoding for P-450sul (suaC) and P - 4 5 0 (subC). amino acid sequences of the suaC and subC genes were compared to that of P-45OCam.Only a few amino acids in the N-terminus region of the three P-450 enzymes (residues 1-62 in P-45OCam)are conserved. However, strong homology is observed in the C-terminus part of the proteins, particularly with residues associated with O2 binding (residues 244-252), with an unknown function (residues 284-290), and with the heme pocket (residues 350-366). The highest level of homology was observed in the regions involved in the attachment of the heme moiety to the apoprotein. For example, the P-45OCamsequences for the thiolate-proximal ligand of the heme, the pocket surrounding it, and the amino acid residues (Arg-112, Arg-299, and His-355) providing the hydrogen bonds for the propionate groups of the heme are highly conserved in P-450sul and P-450suz. Omer et al. (1990) reported an overall homology of 29.7 and 29.4% to P-450BM-1 and 25.9 and 27.8% to P45OCamfor P - 4 5 0 and ~~~ P-450suz, respectively. Comparison of the amino acid sequences of P - 4 5 0 ~ and ~ ~P - 4 5 0 ~ ~ ~ with the P-450 (105C1) gene a Streptomyces sp. (see Section III,A,7,d) showed greater than 40% homology among these genes, indicating that they belong to the same gene family. However, because less than 30% homology was observed for P-450su1 and P-450suz compared with other reported P-450 sequences, these two P-450 genes were assigned to a new gene family and designated P-450 105A1 and P-450 105B1, respectively. In addition, in light of the fact that the DNA sequences encoding for both P - 4 5 0 and ~ ~ ~P-450su2 show strong homologies in cross-hybridization and in dot plot comparison studies, Omer et al. (1990) proposed that suaC and subC genes might have originated from one another by a gene duplication event. Recent genetic studies (Harder et al., 1990) have shown that both P - 4 5 0 ~and ~ ~P-450suz possess similar substrate specificities and are induced by sulfonylurea as well as phenobarbital. Deletion mutants of S . griseolus, which lack the structural genes for P - 4 5 0 ~ and ~ 1 its ferredoxin Fd-1 (suaC and suaB, respectively), metabolize sulfonylurea compounds at a very slow rate compared to the wild-type strain. These mutants metabolize sulfonylureas through induction of P-45OSuz and its ferredoxin Fd-2. Aniline significantly enhances the induction of P450s~ when ~ added to cells in addition to sulfonylurea. This effect is less distinct with P-450su1.
MICROBIAL CYTOCHROME P-450
155
f. Streptomyces griseus. We have been studying the enzymatic systems of another Streptomyces species, i.e., S . griseus (ATCC 13273), which is involved in the oxidation of a diverse array of xenobiotics. It should be noted that the P-450 system of S. griseus (P-45OsOy)is vastly different from the P-450 system of S. griseolus ( P - 4 5 0 and ~ ~ ~P - 4 5 0 ~ ~ ~ ) discussed above. For a summary of the various reactions catalyzed by S. griseus, readers are referred to a previous article (Sariaslani et al., 1989a). Our studies have shown that growth of S. griseus in a soybean flourenriched medium induces a multicomponent cytochrome P-450 enzyme system (P-45OsOy)that enables this organism to mediate diverse reactions (Sariaslani and Kunz, 1986). This soluble cytochrome P-450, which can also be induced with the isoflavonoid constituent of soybean flour, genistein, mimics its mammalian counterparts in its ability to oxidize a diverse array of structurally unrelated xenobiotics. The 47,500-Da P-45OsOythat has been purified to homogeneity (Trower et al., 1989a) differs from its other procaryotic counterparts in that it exists in high-spin state in the absence of its substrate. A limited number of substrate-free high-spin cytochromes P-450 have previously been identified from rat liver (Patten et al., 1986) and rabbit liver sources (Haugen and Coon, 1976).The spin state of P-45osOyis dependent upon the pH of its supporting buffer. Further research is required to unravel the exact mechanism of spin-state shift in P-45OsOy. Involvement of P-45OS0, in the oxidative reactions performed by S. griseus was confirmed when a special mutant of S. griseus (AMY mutant) was used. AMY mutants, which do not produce aerial mycelia, are sometimes spontaneously generated during the complex life cycle of Streptomyces. An AMY mutant of S. griseus that grew rapidly in soybean flour-enriched medium did not produce cytochrome P-450 during its various stages of growth. These cells could not perform the oxidative reactions commonly observed with the wild-type organism (Sariaslani et al., 1989b; Sariaslani and Stahl, 1990). Reconstitution experiments have indicated that P-450soyis a multicomponent enzyme system. Homogeneous preparations of P-45OsO,, in addition to NADPH, required the presence of spinach ferredoxin reductase and spinach ferredoxin for substrate turnover. In these reconstituted assays, P-45OsOyperformed a variety of reactions such as aromatic, benzylic, and alicyclic hydroxylations, 0-dealkylation, N-oxidation, nonaromatic double-bond epoxidation, and N-acetylation on a diverse array of xenobiotics (Trower et a]., 1989b). Selected examples of reactions catalyzed by P-45OsOyare listed in Table 111. We have recently observed that P-45OsOymimics mammalian P-450 systems (White et al., 1984) in producing multiple products during
F. SIMA SARIASLANI
156
TABLE 111 SELECTED EXAMPLES OF REACTIONSPERFORMED BY CYTOCHROME P-450,,, Streptornyces griseus Substrate Aromatic hydroxylation Benzene Chlorobenzene Toulene Naphthalene Biphenyl 17P-Estradiol Benzo[a]pyrene Aniline Alicyclic hydroxylation Cyclohexane Benzylic oxidation Toluene 0-Dealkylation 7-Ethoxycoumarin Nonaromatic double-bond epoxidation Precocene I1 N-Acetylation Aniline
OF
Product(s) Phenol [catechol and hydroquinone (with partially purified P-450,,,)] 2-Chlorophenol; 4-chlorophenol 2-Methylphenol 1-Naphthol 2-Hydroxybiphenyl; 4-hydroxybiphenyl 2-Hydroxyestradiol; 4-hydroxyestradiol plus an unidentified hydroxyestradiol 3-Hydroxybenzo[a]pyrene plus other unidentified hydroxylated benzo(a)pyrenes 2-Aminophenol; 4-aminophenol Cyclohexanol Benzaldehyde 7-Hydroxycournarin cis- and trans-precocene dihydrodiols Acetanilide
camphor oxidation (Sariaslani et al., 1990). The major reaction product identified was 6-endo-hydroxycamphor (60%). Other minor metabolites were identified as 3-endo-hydroxycamphor (2%), 5-endohydroxycamphor (7%), and 5-exo-hydroxycamphor (9%) (Table IV). As mentioned before (Section 111, A,l), high-resolution X-ray crystallographic studies and site-directed mutagenesis with P-45OCa, have indicated that the presence of tyrosine-96 is required for hydrogen bonding between the active site and the carbonyl moiety of camphor (Atkins and Sligar, 1988). Alignment of the P-45OsO,amino acid sequence with that of P-45OCa, indicated that tyrosine-96 is not conserved in P-450,,, (M. K. Trower and F. S. Sariaslani, unpublished observations). Because it is generally believed that procaryotic and eucaryotic P-450 enzymes possess similar tertiary structures, it can be assumed that absence of this residue in P-450,,, contributes to its lack of regio- and stereoselectivity in camphor oxidation. We have exploited the metabolic capabilities of S. griseus in xenobiotic metabolism for activation of promutagenic chemicals (Sariaslani
157
MICROBIAL CYTOCHROME P-450 TABLE IV
OF VARIOUS HYDROXYLATED CAMPHORS PRODUCED BY PROCARYOTIC AND SUMMARY EUCARYOTICSYSTEMS'
P450-origin
Hydroxylated camphors
Pseudomonas putida P-450,.,, wild type
Pseudomonas putida, mutant Y96F 4
5-eXO-
(92%)
OH
4
5
6-exoR+S (4%)
3-eXO(4%)
OK&
Rabbit liver, P-450~~2
4
OH
OH 5-eXO-
(14%)
3-endo(16%)
O
(0.1%)
+ other unidentified hydroxylated camphors (7%)
5-endo(63%)
OH
5-eXO(9%)
5
9-hydroxy
OH
3-endo-
5-endo-
(2%)
(7%)
6-endo(60%)
Adapted from Sariaslani et ol., 1990, with permission.
and Stahl, 1990). In these studies, S. griseus cells enriched in P-45OsO, replaced the rat liver microsome (S9)fraction in a modified Salmonella/ Ames plate incorporation assay. The S. griseus whole cells activated a variety of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, aromatic amines, and small aliphatic molecules (Tables V and VI). The activated promutagens in turn reverted Salmonella typhimurium strains TA98 and TA1538. The P-45Os0,-enriched cells activated promutagens such as 3,3'-
TABLE V MUTAGENIC ACTIVITY IN Salmonella typhimurium STRAIN TA98"
Cell paste"
Supernatantb Chemicals
Und
1:2
1:lO
1 : 100
Und
1:2
1:lO
1: 100
42* 2.7* 4.7* 2.5* 2.6* 1.1 4.2* 0.4
2.5* 2.1* 1.0 1.9 2.3* 1.1 1.4 0.3
1.o 1.7 1.3 1.0 1.2 1.7 0.6
1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.3 2.2* 1.1
35* 33* 18* 9.2* TNTC * 2.3* NT 0.3
26* 24* 11* 10* 16* 5.8* NT 1.7
11* 39* 8* 7.6*
2.4* 1.4* 1.1 4.8*
4.3* 1.5
4.4* 0.9
2.6* 1.5
0.8 1.2
14* 0.9
18* 1.4
20* 1.7
1.8 0.6
3.5* 0.8
1.6 1.o
1.5 1.0
Aromatic amines
I2
W cn
3,3'-Dimethylbenzidine 3,3'-Dimethoxybenzidine Benzidine 2- Aminoacetylfluorene 2- Aminoanthracene 2.4-Diaminotoluene
4-Aminobipheny l 4-Chloro-2-nitroaniline
1.o
NT
NT
2.2* NT 1.0
1.8 NT 0.7
Polycyclic aromatics Benzo[a]pyrene
7.12-Dimethylbenzanthracene Small aliphatics Chloropicrin N-Nitrosodimethy lamine
2.5* 1.8
1.9 3.8*
1.6 2.8*
6.8* 1.3 0.9 1.8
From Sariaslani and Stahl (1990),with permission. Results expressed as mutagenic ratios from at least two experiments. All results marked with asterisks reflect a greater than twofold increase in induced revertants compared to control; Und, undiluted test material, and 1: 2, 1 : 10, and 1: 100 are dilutions thereof. NT,Not tested; TNTC, too numerous to count. a
TABLE VI MUTAGENIC ACTIVITY IN Salmonella typhirnuriurn STRAIN TA1538" ~
~~
Supernatantb Chemicals
Cell pasteC
Und
1:2
1:lO
1: 100
Und
46* 2.7* 17* 5.4* 0.2 1.2 1.8 0.6
2.9* 3.8* 2.9* 2.6* 0.4 1.1 1.6 0.6
1.2 2.2* 1.8 1.8 0.6 NT 1.4 0.8
1.1
1.7 1.4 1.6 1.3 NT 0.8 1.3
28* 23* 86* TNTC* 22* 1.2
2.6* 1.3
3.3* 1.6
2.6* 1.0 1.1
1:2
1:lO
1; 100
23* 53* 16* 19* 12* NT
1.2 1.7 1.5 12* 1.2
NT
0.2
NT 1.3
1.4
NT 1.8
2.6* 1.8
18* 0.3
17* 0.7
19* 1.2
4.5* 0.8
1.0
0.9
1.9
Aromatic mimes 3,3'-Dimethylbenzidine 3,3'-Dimethoxybenzidine Benzidine 2-Aminoacetylfluorene 2-Aminoanthracene 2,4-Diaminotoluene 4-Aminobiphenyl 4-Chloro-2-nitroaniline
NT
40* 28* 30* 18* 53*
NT
NT
Polycyclic aromatics Benzo[alpyrene
7,12-Dimethylbenzanthracene Small aliphatics N-nitrosodimethy lamine ~~~~~~
1.0
1.1 ~
2.4*
1.0
~
From Sariaslani and Stahl (1990),with permission. Results expressed as mutagenic ratios from at least two experiments. All results marked with asterisks reflect a greater than twofold increase in induced revertants compared to control, Und, undiluted test material, and 1:2, 1 :10,and 1 :100 are dilutions thereof. NT, Not tested; TNTC, too numerous to count.
160
F. SIMA SARIASLANI
dimethylbenzidine, 3,3’-dimethoxybenzidine,2-acetylaminofluorene, benzidine, 2-aminoanthracene, 2,4-diaminotoluene, 4-aminobiphenyl, benzo[a]pyrene, chloropicrin, and N-nitrosodimethylamine. Of the promutagens tested, 7,12-dimethylbenzanthracene and 4-chloro-2nitroaniline were not activated by S. griseus cells. In parallel tests, rat liver microsomes failed to activate N-nitrosodimethylamine. Results obtained in this study underline the catalytic similarity that exists between rat liver cytochromes P-450 and S. griseus P-450,,,. In a recent study we have shown that genetically engineered strains of S. griseus containing an inactivated genetic marker can both activate promutagenic chemicals and also report their presence (Buchholz et al., 1991) (Table VII). Results obtained in these studies underline the potential of the S. griseus enzymatic system for use as an activator and reporter of promutagenic chemicals. As mentioned above, P-450,,, of S. griseus is a multicomponent system that requires the participation of a ferredoxin reductase and a ferredoxin for transfer of reducing equivalents for NAD(P)Hto the terminal P-450 component. We have identified a soybean flour-inducible 7Fe ferredoxin (S. griseus ferredoxin) in extracts of S. griseus; this ferredoxin can couple electron transfer between spinach ferredoxin reductase and P-450,,, in in vitro-reconstituted assays (Trower et al., 1990a). This protein contains a [3Fe-4S] and a [4Fe-4S] cluster and is the first 7Fe ferredoxin identified that appears to possess a catalytic function. The complete primary structure of S. griseus ferredoxin has been determined by Edman degradation of the whole protein and peptides obtained through enzymatic digestions (Trower et a]., 1990b).This protein contains 105 amino acids and has a calculated molecular weight, including seven irons and eight sulfurs, of 12,291. Analysis of the primary structure of S. griseus ferredoxin has indicated a high degree of homology (73%) to that of the 7Fe ferredoxin from Mycobacterium smegmatis. The binding domain for the Fe-S clusters lies in the N-terminus region and exhibits more than 50% homology with other reported 7Fe ferredoxins. This homology is particularly striking because the cysteine residues that are involved in binding the two Fe-S clusters are all conserved. We have recently identified a soybean flour-induced NADHferredoxin reductase in soluble extracts of S. griseus (Ramachandra and Sariaslani, 1990). This NADH-dependent ferredoxin reductase, which is now partially purified, has an absolute requirement for Mg2+ and can couple electron flow to P-450,,, through the intermediacy of S. griseus ferredoxin, adrenodoxin, and the ferredoxins from spinach and Clostridium pasteurianum.
161
MICROBIAL CYTOCHROME P-450 TABLE VII
SUMMARY OF MUTAGENIC RATIOSFOR Streptomyces griseus STRAINSH69 AND FS2 FOR CHEMICALS TESTED AT 200pg/ml CONCENTRATION^ Mutagenic ratio Chemical Acetonitrile 9-Aminoacridine 2-Aminoanthracene Ascorbic acid 1,2-Benzanthracene 2,3-Benzanthracene Benzene" Benzidine Benzo[a]pyrene Biphenyl Butylated hydroxytoluene Caffeine Catechol Chlorobenzene 2-Chloroethanol 1,3-Dichloropropane
9,10-Dimethyl-1,2-benzanthracene 1,4-Dioxane Ethidium bromide Glycine Hydroquinone Mannitol
N-Methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosguanidine Mutagen ICR-291 Naphthalene Nitrobenzene 2-Nitrofluorene p-Nitrophenol Phenol Phenolphthalein Potassium chloride cis-Stilbene trans-Stilbene Toulene Vanillin
Source
H69
FS2
Fisher Sigma Sigma Fisher Aldrich Aldrich Sigma Sigma Sigma Aldrich Sigma Calbiochem Sigma Aldrich Aldrich Kodak Sigma Aldrich Baker Fisher Sigma Sigma Sigma Polysciences Sigma Baker Aldrich Sigma Sigma Kodak EM Sciences Aldrich Aldrich Aldrich Sigma
7.84 2.56 2.19 0.27 3.30 0.72 1.89 9.84 6.23 0.62 0.20 1.10 0.98 1.84 1.48 1.19 8.46 0.97 Toxicb 1.10 0.35 0.99 2.50 1.83 1.55 1.61 4.16 0.84 0.44 1.34 0.36 0.09 1.45 0.56 1.22
0.025 1.40 4.07 0.16 4.83 0.52 10.10 9.40 3.3 0.67 0.15 1.09 0.23 0.51 5.23 2.76 1.88 5.55 Toxicb 2.25 0.16 0.59 2.24 3.00 1.42 3.49 1.51 0.60 0.16 0.93 0.07 0.16 1.38 0.87 1.52
Benzene was used at 100 pglml concentration. Cells from ethidium bromide stage I1 flasks failed to grow or generate spores.
162
F. SIMA SARIASLANI
To date, P-450,,, is the only reported procaryotic cytochrome P-450 that resembles its mammalian counterparts in its broad substrate specificity and also in its ability to activate promutagenic chemicals. Further biochemical and molecular studies for unraveling the exact mechanism of action of this interesting protein are currently being pursued in our laboratory and, through collaborative efforts, in other laboratories. B. EUCARYOTIC CYTOCHROMES P-450 Microbial eucaryotic P-450 enzymes generally fall within the Type I category with respect to the organization of their redox components (Fig. 1).The particulate and unstable nature of microbial eucaryotic cytochromes P-450 has rendered them difficult to isolate and purify. It is therefore not surprising that only a limited number of eucaryotic cytochromes P-450 have been purified to homogeneity and studied in detail. The most thoroughly studied microbial eucaryotic cytochromes P-450 are the enzymes from S. cerevisiae and Candida albicans. 1. Saccharomyces cerevisiae
Previous reports had indicated that, following semianaerobic growth of S. cerevisiae on glucose, a microsomal cytochrome P-450 ( P - 4 5 0 1 4 ~ ~ ) is induced in this fungus (King et al., 1982; King and Wiseman, 1987). The low-spin, 58,000-Da P-45014DM catalyzes the NADPH-dependent 14a-demethylation of lanosterol to 4,4-dimethyl-5a-cholesta-8,14,24trien-38-01 (Fig. 21), which is an essential reaction in the ergosterol biosynthesis pathway. The P-45014DM possesses broad substrate specificity and oxidizes a wide array of complex molecules, such as benzo[a]pyrene, R-naphthylamine, and cyclophosphamide. In addition to the P-45014DM obtained from semianaerobically grown S. cerevisiae, Aoyama et al. (1981) have reported the presence of an immunologically and catalytically similar P-450 in the microsomal fractions of aerobically grown yeast. Diniconazole is a potent fungicide and a strong inhibitor of the 14ademethylation reaction in fungi. Yoshida et al. (1986) have shown that the inhibitory effect of this fungicide is due to its interaction with P-45014DM. While both R(-) and S(+) isomers of diniconazole inhibit P-45014DMjthe R(-) isomer is a much more effective inhibitor than is the S( +) isomer. Spectral studies have revealed that although both isomers interact with P-45014DM through their azole moieties, their P-450 complexes respond differently to CO addition. The R( -)/P-45014DMcomplex reacts very slowly and its conversion to CO/P-45014DM is incomplete, whereas the s(+)/P-45014DMcomplex reacts readily. It therefore
163
MICROBIAL CYTOCHROME P-450
HO
p-
1
OH t3H
O 'H
t
J
HO
~ ~Saccharomyces cereFIG. 21. 14a-Demethylation of lanosterol by the P - 4 5 O I 4 of visiae. After Aoyama et al. (1989), with permission.
appears that the more effective herbicide produces a much tighter complex with P-45014DM. Recently, Aoyama et al. (1989) examined the interaction of lanosterol, 3-epilanosterol, 3-oxolanosta-8,24-diene, 3-methylenelanost-8-ene, and lanosterol acetate with P - 4 5 o l 4 (Fig. ~ ~ 22). Among the substrates examined, 14a-demethylation was observed with 3-epilanosterol and 3oxolanosterol but 3-methylene and 3-acetate derivatives could not serve as substrates for the enzyme. Based on these results, Aoyama et al. (1989) suggested that formation of a hydrogen bond between the 3hydroxyl group of the substrate and a specific amino acid in the active site of the enzyme might be a prerequisite for the catalytic activity. Immunologic studies with specific antibodies to P-45014DM have shown that this enzyme, which is essential for ergosterol biosynthesis in yeast, is constitutively expressed in various Saccharomyces strains (Kaergel et al., 1990.) The P-45014~M from different species of Saccharomyces are immunologically different but possess a few common antigenic sites. During cloning and sequencing of P-45014DM, Kalb et a ] . (1987) reported the identification of an open reading frame of 530 codons consisting of the structural gene and the flanking regions for lanosterol 14ademethylase of S. cerevisiae. This single-copy gene is essential for the yeast's aerobic growth. Examination of the deduced amino acid se-
164
1
F. SIMA SARIASLANI
2
3
4
5
FIG.22. Structures of various lanosterol derivatives examined with the P-45014D~ of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. 1, Lanosterol; 2, epilanosterol; 3, 3-oxolanosta-8,24-diene; 4, 3-methylenelanost-8-ene; 5, lanosterol acetate. From Aoyama et al. (1989),with permission.
quence of P-45014DM has revealed the presence near the N-terminus of a hydrophobic segment that may be a transmembrane domain. Comparison of this sequence with those of eight other eucaryotic cytochromes P-450 has indicated that P-45014DM is the first member of a new P-450 gene family that is designated P-45OL1 (Kalb et al., 1987). In addition, the data have indicated that P-45014DMexhibits more homology to its mammalian counterparts than to the procaryotic enzymes. The NADPH-cytochrome P-450 reductase of S. cerevisiae was purified to apparent homogeneity by Aoyama et al. (1978). This 83,000-Da component, which contains 1 mol of FAD and 1 mol of FMN, reduces P-45014DM and the cytochrome b, of S. cerevisiae. Addition of this NADPH-cytochrome P-450 reductase to reconstituted assays with rabbit liver P-450 enzymes facilitates N-demethylation of benzphetamine. Presence of a second P-450 in S. cerevisiae was reported by Yoshida et al. (1985).This P-450 ( P - 4 5 0 ~ ~was 1 ) obtained from a mutant strain of S. cerevisiae that could not perform the 14a-demethylation of lanosterol. Studies on the spectral properties of partially purified P - 4 5 0 ~ ~have 1 revealed that the absorption spectrum of the oxidized cytochrome is similar to that of a native low-spin P-450 bound to a strong nitrogenous ligand such as pyridine or 1-methylimidazole, It has therefore been proposed that the sixth coordination ligand of P - 4 5 0 might ~ ~ ~ contain a nitrogen, for example, from histidine, instead of a water molecule or an oxyamino acid as is seen with other P-450 enzymes (Yoshida et al., 1985).The P - 4 5 0 ~ enzyme ~1 is the only example of a P-450 containing a nitrogenous ligand as the sixth ligand to the heme (Fig. 23). Although P - 4 5 0 ~ ~is1immunologically indistinguishable from P-45014DM,it exhibits no catalytic activity toward lanosterol (Aoyama et al., 1987) and interacts differently with diniconazole, which is a specific inhibitor of P-45014~~.
MICROBIAL CYTOCHROME P-450
Heme environment of cytochromes P-450
165
Heme environment of P-450,,,
FIG.23. Comparison of the heme environment of P-450 enzymes with that of P-45OScl (Yoshida et al., 1985).
Functional differences between P-45014DM and P - 4 5 0 ~raise ~ ~ the question as to the similarities and/or differences in the primary structures of the two proteins. Because peptide maps of P - 4 5 0 1 4 ~and ~ P4 5 0 ~generated ~ ~ , by limited proteolysis, were very similar, cloning and sequencing of the genes for the enzymes was pursued as a means of identifying subtle differences between these two proteins. Following cloning and sequencing of both P-45014DM and P-450SG1, Ishida et a]. (1988) showed that only one amino acid, glycine-310, was substituted by aspartate in P-45OScl. This is a highly significant finding because it indicates that a single amino acid substitution can have drastic effects on an enzyme’s catalytic activity. Further studies by these investigators revealed that a single amino acid substition does not always lead to this enzyme’s inactivation. For example, analysis of the amino acid sequence of P-45014DMfrom another S. cerevisiae mutant (mutant DBY939), which performs the l4a-demethylation reaction, revealed that although in this protein asparagine-433 was substituted by lysine, the 14a-demethylase activity was not affected. 2. Candida
Presence of cytochromes P-450 involved in xenobiotic metabolism has been reported in three different species of Candida. a. Candida albicans. A 51,000-Da microsomal cytochrome P-450 purified from C. albicans performs the NADPH-dependent 14ademethylation of lanosterol in the presence of dilauroylphosphatidylcholine and oxygen (Hitchcock et al., 1989a,b).Similar to P - 4 5 O l 4 ~ ~ from S. cerevisiae and the rat liver enzyme, this P-450 performs the entire three-step reaction of lanosterol oxidation to yield 4,4dimethyl-5a-cholesta-8,14,24-trien-3-01. Because the catalytic activity of this enzyme, when lanosterol was used as substrate, was lower than those observed with Saccharomyces and rat liver enzymes, Hitchcock et al. (1989b) proposed that perhaps the true substrate for this enzyme is
166
F. SIMA SARIASLANI
24-methylene-24,25-dihydrolanosterol,rather than lanosterol. The specificity of P-45014DM from C. albicans differs from its S. cerevisiae counterpart in that the Candida enzyme possesses a very tight substrate specificity and cannot oxidize other structurally diverse substrates in reconstituted assays (Hitchcock et al., 1989b). Two allelic forms of the P-45014DM gene were isolated from C. albicans using a S. cerevisiae P-45014DM probe (Kirsch et al., 1988). Expression of these genes in either S. cerevisiae or C. albicans resulted in an increase in the P-45014DM concentration, followed by resistance to the inhibitors of the P-45014DM such as imidazole antifungal drugs. Lai and Kirsch (1989) determined the nucleotide sequence of C. albicans P-45014DM and found a very high degree of homology between the Saccharomyces and the Candida enzymes. Based on these results they concluded that the P-45014DM genes from S. cerevisiae and C. albicans are closely related. b. Candida tropicalis. A hydrocarbon-inducible cytochrome P-450 (P-450alk) has been identified in C. tropicalis (Lebeault et al., 1971; Gmunder et al., 1981).The P-450alk is induced by n-alkanes with at least 10 carbon atoms and by long-chain alkenes and alcohols. The P-450alk, which catalyzes the NADPH-dependent oxidation of fatty acids and hydrocarbons at their w-position (Table VIII), has been resolved into P - 4 5 0 , NADPH cytochrome c reductase, and thermostable lipid fractions. In reconstitution experiments the NADPH-cytochrome P-450
TABLE VIII SUBSTRATE SPECIFICITY OF CYTOCHROME P-450a1k
FROM
Candida tropicalis"
Compound tested
Specific activity (nmol product/min/mg protein)
Laurate Myristate Undecanoate Decanoate Palmitate Stearate Octanoate Hexanoate Hexadecane Decane Octane
3.1 2.8 2.3 2.2 1.2 0.9 0.8 0.5 0.8 0.2 0.2
Adapted from Lebeault et al. (1971),with permission.
MICROBIAL CYTOCHROME P-450
167
reductase and the lipid fractions could be replaced by the corresponding fractions from rat liver microsomes. The spin state of P-450alk is dependent on the ionic strength of the supporting buffer (Mansuy et al., 1980). Increase in the ionic strength of this buffer was accompanied by about 30% conversion of the low-spin enzyme to high spin. Conversely, when the ionic strength of the medium was decreased, the original high-spin enzyme was converted to low spin. Additionally, hydrophobic alcohols converted the high-spin P-45Oa1k to the low-spin enzyme. Binding of nitrogenous ligands, isocyanides, and phosphines to the ferric and ferrous enzyme induces spectral changes similar to those reported for other P-450 enzymes. Mansuy et al. (1980) have indicated that a high proportion of P-45Oa1k is in high-spin state in C. tropicalis microsomes. Because addition of the substrate, tetradecane, to P-45oalk was not associated with detectable spectral changes, Mansuy et al. (1980) speculated that a cofactor, which is lost during enzyme preparation, might be required for transport of tetradecane to the active site of the enzyme. The NADPH-cytochrome P-450alkreductase fraction was purified by various chromatography steps (Bertrand et al., 1980). The 76,000-Da pure enzyme contains 1 mol of FAD and 1 mol of FMN per mole of enzyme. Sanglard and Loper (1989) studied the gene coding for P-450alk and showed that expression of the P-450alk gene of C. tropicalis in S. cerevisiae endows the latter organism with the ability to o-oxidize lauric acid. The deduced amino acid sequence for P-45Oa1k showed very low homology when compared with nine known P-450 gene families. It was therefore concluded that this gene was the first member (Al) of a new gene family (L11) Reexamination of the genomic library of the P-45Oa1kgene has recently revealed the presence of other P-450 genes in this library (Sanglard and Fiechter, 1989). A second tetradecane-inducible P-450 gene identified in this library was designated P-45Oa1k2to distinguish it from the originally isolated P-450 (P-45Oa1kl).Because other P-450 genes are present in this library, Sanglard and Fiechter have concluded that the heterogeneity exhibited in this gene family resembles that usually seen in higher eucaryotes. c. Candida rnaltosa. The third P-450 identified in a Candida species is a membrane-bound n-alkane-hydroxylating enzyme from c. maltosa that hydroxylates long-chain n-alkanes to their corresponding fatty alcohols (Schunch et al., 1989). Candida maltosa resembles other eucaryotic systems in containing a P-450 and a NADPH-cytochrome c reductase component. Cloning of this enzyme has shown that it consists of 521 amino acids, two putative transmembrane segments in the N-
168
F. SIMA SARIASLANI
terminus, which presumably function to anchor the protein to the lipid bilayer, and a characteristic heme-binding sequence in the C-terminus region. This P-450 exhibits strong homology with the alkane-inducible P-450 gene from C. tropicalis. 3. Fusarium oxysporum
Presence of a very stable cytochrome P-450 enzyme system, composed of three P-450 isozymes, has been reported in F. oxysporum (Shoun et al., 1983). This soybean oil/soybean flour-inducible P-450 system, which catalyzes the NAD(P)H-dependent oxidation of fatty acids such as lauric acid at w - l , w - 2 , and w-3 positions, has been found in both soluble and particulate fractions of F. oxysporum. At least three cytochromes P-450, a NADPH-cytochrome c reductase, a NADHferricyanide reductase, and a cytochrome b5 have been identified in these cells (Shoun et al., 1989a). Concomitant induction of these components with cytochromes P-450 has led Shoun et al. to propose a role for them in the reactions performed by cytochrome P-450 of F. oxysporum. Growth of the organism in a medium containing glycerol, in addition to the soybean derivatives, resulted in the induction of high levels of the particulate enzyme that was associated with high-activity fatty acid hydroxylase. Shoun et al. (1985) proposed that the soluble cytochromes P-450 might be orginating from the particulate fractions during enzyme preparation. Recent studies in the same laboratory (Shoun et al., 1989b) have shown that a soluble P-450, of unspecified function, is induced in this fungus in the presence of nitrate or nitrite. This P-450 is sensitive to high aeration rates. When nitrate was replaced by ammonium chloride, only the particulate P-450 was induced. 4. Cunninghamella bainieri (echinulata)
Whole cells of C. bainieri possess broad substrate specificity and perform the aromatic hydroxylation and the N- and 0-demethylation of a variety of xenobiotic substrates. Ferris et al. (1973) have proposed that a P-450 enzyme system, similar to the enzymes found in liver microsomes, is responsible for these reactions. Whole cells of C. bainieri hydroxylate naphthalene, aniline, anisole; N-demethylate aminopyrine; 0-demethylate 4-nitroanisole; and perform reduction of nitro and azo groups. Preliminary experiments revealed hydroxylation of benzo[a]pyrene by particulate fractions of C. bainieri. The nature of the inducer for this P-450 is obscure; however, it is noteworthy that the medium used for this organism’s growth contains soybean. The possibility therefore exists that, similar to S. griseus cytochrome P-450,,, (see
MICROBIAL CYTOCHROME P-450
169
Section III,A,7,f), one of the ingredients in soybean might act as the inducer of P-450 in C. bainieri. Further investigations by Ferris et al. (1976) confirmed that the aryl hydroxylase activity of C. bainieri is due to the presence of a P-450 enzyme system in this organism. This P-450 system, which appears to be composed of P-450 and NADPHcytochrome c reductase components, has a strict requirement for NADPH [Ferris eta)., 1984). Independent studies by Gibson et al. (1984a) have shown the presence of a particulate P-450 enzyme system in C. bainieri that Ndemethylates codeine. Various substrates such as codeine, norcodeine, diazepam, and tetradecane acted as the enzyme’s inducer. The Ndemethylation of codeine in crude extracts required the presence of NADH, NADPH, and Fez+. The stability of the P-450 was increased when it was stored at 4°C in a nitrogen atmosphere, allowing kinetic studies to be performed [Gibson et al., 1984a). Formation of the chemically labile carbinolamine intermediate and therefore involvement of a C-oxidation mechanism during P-450-mediated codeine oxidation was suggested through 13C NMR studies [Gibson et al., 1984b) [Fig. 24). 5. Aspergillus ochraceus
An inducible P-450 system was identified in A. ochraceus [Ghosh and Samanta, 1981). This enzyme catalyzes the NADPH-dependent hydroxylation of progesterone at the C,, position (Fig. 25). Because in vitro
CHa
Norcodeine
N- Hydroxymethyl codeine
FIG.24. Oxidation of codeine by the P-450enzyme of Cunninghamella bainieri (Gibson et al., 1984bj.
F. SIMA SARIASLANI
170 COCHpR
COCHpR
0
Progesterone (R=H) Substance S (R=OH)
1la-Hydroxyprogesterone (R=H) 11-epi-Hydrocortisone (R=OH)
FIG.25. Hydroxylation of progesterone by the Aspergillus ochraceus P-450system (Ghosh and Samanta, 1981).
hydroxylation of progesterone was detected only when both postmitochondrial supernatant and microsomal fractions were combined, Ghosh and Samanta (1981) proposed a multicomponent nature for this P-450 system. Further research is required to elucidate the exact nature of this enzymatic system. 6. Nectria haematococca Some fungi are relatively tolerant to the phytoalexin toxins produced by many plant tissues. Van Etten's group (Matthews and Van Etten, 1983; Desjardins et a]., 1984; Desjardins and Van Etten, 1986) have shown that resistance of the plant pathogen fungus, N. haematococca, to this toxin is due to the presence of a cytochrome P-450 system in this organism. This microsomal P-450 system, which has been resolved into P-450 and NADPH-cytochrome P-450 reductase fractions, performs the demethylation of the pea's major phytoalexin, pisatin (Fig. 26). The relatively high rate of pisatin detoxification by microsomal preparations of N. haematococca, 20 nmol/min/mg protein, is indicative of the role that this enzyme might have in the virulence of this fungus in pea. Although the unstable nature of the P-450 component prohibited its purification to homogeneity, the 84,000-Da NADPH reductase com-
Pisatin
3,6a-di hydroxy-8,9met hylenedioxypterocarpan
FIG.26. Demethylation of pisatin by the P-450 enzyme of Nectria haernatococca (Desjardins and Van Etten, 1986).
MICROBIAL CYTOCHROME P-450
171
ponent has been completely purified. The catalytic activity in reconstituted assays was restored when the NADPH reductase of N. haematococca was added to the extracts. Addition of the NADPH reductase from rat liver microsomes to these assays was far less effective in restoring the activity (Desjardins and Van etten, 1986). Although the enzyme was NADPH dependent, addition of NADH to reconstituted assays containing NADPH stimulated the substrate turnover. 7. Trichosporon cutaneum
Presence of cytochrome P-450, NADPH-cytochrome c-reductase, and cytochrome b5 fractions was reported in T. cutaneum cells grown under conditions of oxygen limitation (Laurila et al., 1984). This microsomal P-450 performs the demethylation of aminopyrine at a rate of 0.9nmol/ nmol P-450/min. The physiological role of this P-450 system was proposed to be related to changes in lipid composition of the cells as a consequence of ethanol formation. 8. Claviceps purpurea Ambike et al. (1970) have reported on the presence of microsomal cytochrome P-450 and cytochrome b5 in C. purpurea; these cytochromes have been implicated in alkaloid biosynthesis. Further research is required to identify various components and the catalytic role of this P-450 enzyme. 9. Cyanidum caldarium
The unicellular red alga, C. caldarium, possesses an oxygenase enzyme system that is involved in the biosynthesis of phycobilin from heme (Fig. 27) (Cornejoand Beale, 1988).This oxygenase system can be classified as a P-450 system because of the nature of its components and its catalytic activity. Although this unique oxygenase is obtained from an algal source, it exhibits the attributes of procaryotic P-450 systems. This enzymatic system, which is soluble in nature, has been resolved into three fractions (fractions 1-111). In vitro activity in reconstituted assays requires the presence of all three fractions, molecular oxygen, substrate, NADPH, and a second reductant. The 22,000-Da fraction I, which appears to be a ferredoxin-like component, can be replaced by commercially available ferredoxins such as that from Porphyra umbilicalis and, to a lesser extent, by spinach ferredoxin. The 38,000-Da fraction 11, the monooxygenase component, is the heme-binding component. The difference between this monooxygenase and the other reported P-450 systems is that in the C. caldarium enzyme system, heme is
F. SIMA SARIASLANI
172
CH \
CH3
Biliverdin IXa CHZ
CH2
CH2
CH2
COOH
COOH
I
I
I
I
y
3
Protoheme H3C
Phycocyanin FIG.27. Oxidation of protoheme by the oxygenase of Cyanidium caldarium (Cornejo and Beale, 1988).
the substrate and not the cofactor for the P-450. The presence in this fraction of a reduced CO-adduct absorption spectrum, similar to other reported P-450 enzymes, has not been shown yet. The 37,000-Da fraction I11 is a ferredoxin-linked cytochrome c reductase. Replacement of fraction I11 with spinach ferredoxin-NADP+ oxidoreductase in reconstituted assays resulted in very low catalytic activity. Fraction I11 has not been obtained in homogeneous form and it is therefore not clear whether it is a flavoprotein. Compounds such as ascorbate, isocorbate, phenylenediamine, and hydroquinone serve as the secondary reductant in this reaction. Cornejo and Beale (1988)have suggested that the second reductant might possess a nonenzymatic function such as trapping hydroxyl radicals generated by other reaction components. 10. Lodderomyces elongisporus
An alkane-inducible P-450 system was reported in this yeast (Riege et al., 1981).The low-spin P-450 of L. elongisporus is particulate and its reduced CO adduct exhibits an absorption maximum at 447nm. The NADPH-cytochrome P-450 reductase of this system has been purified to homogeneity and has been shown to have a molecular weight of 79,000, with one FAD and one FMN. Hydroxylation of n-hexadecane by
MICROBIAL CYTOCHROME P-450
173
the reconstituted system was enhanced when nonionic detergents such as Prawozell WON-100 were added to the mixture, suggesting a possible role for lipids in this P-450-dependent alkane oxidation (Honeck et a]., 1982).
IV. Conclusion
Microbial communities play a significant role in the degradation of novel man-made chemicals that are constantly released into our environment. Discovery of several new procaryotic and eucaryotic cytochromes P-450 in recent years has underlined their ubiquitous distribution in microbial systems. The fact that these enzymes are involved in the degradation of various natural and synthetic chemicals is indicative of their significance in such reactions. As chemical industries continue the production and release of various chemicals into our environment, the next decade or so will undoubtedly witness the discovery of other microbial cytochromes P-450 involved in xenobiotic degradation. Development of new procedures for purification of unstable and membrane-bound (particulate) enzymes has allowed characterization of a number of new microbial P-450 enzymes in recent years. To date, our information about most of these enzymes is very scant; however, with new powerful spectroscopic and molecular techniques at our disposal, unraveling the mechanism of action of at least some of these enzymes in the near future in inevitable. During the past decade we have witnessed an explosion of activites in harnessing the enzymatic potential of microorganisms as biocatalysts for various organic syntheses. The information outlined in the preceding pages reveals the diversity of the catalytic activities of microbial cytochromes P-450. Some of these enzymes possess very tight substrate specificities and others are capable of oxidizing a wider range of structurally diverse substrates. The inherent regio- and stereospecificities exhibited by most cytochromes P-450 are indicative of their potential for application in biocatalytic processes. Techniques such as molecular modeling and site-directed mutagenesis, which will allow production of “designer” cytochromes P-450 with desired selectivity and efficiency, could be instrumental in establishing these enzymes as industrial biocatalysts. Another potential application for cytochromes P-450 is employment of some of the microbial enzymes, which can mimic mammalian cytochromes P-450, such as the procaryotic P-450,,, from S . griseus and the eucaryotic P-45014DMfrom S. cerevisiae, in the development of convenient test systems for the detection of mutagenic chemicals. The advan-
174
F. SIMA SARIASLANI
tages of employing such test systems include, but are not limited to, the ease of preparative scale production of the microbial cytochromes P-450, the reduced dependence on animals for such studies, and the relative low cost of these preparations compared to those from mammalian sources. ACKNOWLEDGMENT
I thank R. G. Stahl, Jr., Muralidahra Rarnachandra, and Michael Trower for critically reading the manuscript and Donna King and Law6 Kurych for assistance in typing. REFERENCES Ambike, S. H., Baxter, R. M., and Zahid, N. D. (1970).Phytochemistry 9,1953-1958. Aoyama, Y., Yoshida, Y., Kubota, S., Kurnaoka, H., and Furumichi, A. (1978).Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 185,362-369. Aoyama, Y., Okikawa, T., and Yoshida, Y. (1981).Biochim. Biophys. Acta 665,596-601. Aoyarna, Y., Yoshida, Y., Nishino, T., Katsuki, H., Maitra, U. S., Mohan, V. P., and Sprinson, D. B. (1987).J. Biol. Chem. 262,14260-14264. Aoyama, Y., Yoshida, Y., Sonoda, Y., and Sato, Y. (1989).Biochirn. Biophys. Acta 1006, 209-213.
Appleby, C. A., and Daniel, R. M. (1965).In “Oxidases and Related Redox Systems” (T. E. King, H. S. Mason, and M. Morrison, eds.), pp. 515-528. Univ. Park Press, Baltimore, Maryland. Asperger, O., Naumann, A,, and Kleber, H.-P. (1981).FEMS Microbiol. Lett. 11,309-312. Asperger, O.,Muller, R., and Kleber, H.-P. (1985a).Dev. Biochem. 27,447-450. Asperger, O.,Stuwer, B., and Kleber, H.-P. (1985b).Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 21, 309-312.
Atkins, W. M., and Sligar, S. G. (1988).J. Biol. Chem. 263, 18842-18849. Atkins, W. A., and Sligar, S. G. (1989).J. Am. Chem. SOC.111,2715-2717. Berg, A.,and Rafter, J. J. (1981).Biochem. J. 196, 781-786. Berg, A., Carlstrom, K., Gustafsson, J. A., and Ingelrnan-Sundberg, M. (1975).Biochem. Biophys. Aes. Commun. 66,1414-1423. Berg, A., Gustafsson, J. A., Ingelman-Sundberg, M., and Carlstrom, K. (1976).J. Biol. Chem. 251,2831-2838.
Berg, A., Ingelrnan-Sundberg, M., and Gustafsson, J. A. (1979).Acta Biol. Med. Ger. 38, 333-344.
Bertrand, J. C., Gilewics, M., Bazin, H., and Azoulay, E. (1980).Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 94,889-893. Black, S. D., and Coon, M. J. (1987).Adv. Enzymol. 60,35-87. Bocker, R., and Guengerich, F. P. (1986).J. Med. Chem. 29, 1596-1603. Boddupalli, S. S., Estabrook, R. W., and Peterson, J. A.(1990).J. Biol. Chem. 265,42334239.
Buchholz, S. E., Orner, C. A., Viitanen, P. P., Sariaslani, F. S., and Stahl, R. G., Jr. (1991). Submitted for publication. Castro, C. E.,Wade, R. S., and Belser, N. 0. (1983).J. Agric. Food Chem. 31, 1184-1187. Castro, C. E., Wade, R. S., and Belser, N. 0. (1985).Biochemistry 24,204-210. Castro, C. E., Yokoyama, W. H., and Belser, N. 0. (1988).J. Agric. Food Chern. 36,915-919. Coon, M. J., and Vaz, A. D. N. (1988).Prog. Clin. Biol. Res. 274,497-507.
MICROBIAL CYTOCHROME P-450
175
Cornejo, J. and Beale, S.I. (1988).J. Biol Chem. 263, 11915-11921. Dadas, A., Gal, D., Barrelle, M., Sauret-Ignazi, G., Sterjiades, R., and Pelmont, J. (1985). Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 236,585-592. Daly, J. W., Jerina, D. M., and Witkop, B. (1972).Experientia 28,1129-1149. Dawson, J. H., and Smith Eble, K. (1986).Adv. Inorg. Bioinorg. Mech. 4,1-64. Desjardins, A. E., and Van Etten, H. D. (1986).Arch. Microbiol 144,84-90. Desjardins, A. E., Matthews, D. E., and Van Etten, H. D. (1984).Plant Physiol. 75,611-616. Dus, K., Goewert, R., Weaver, C. C., Carey, D., and Appleby, C. A. (1976).Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 69,437-445. Ferris, J. P., Fasco, M. J., Stylianopoulou, F. L., Jerina, D. M., and Jeffrey, A. M. (1973). Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 156,97-103. Ferris, J. P., MacDonald, L. H., Patrie, M. A., and Martin, M. A. (1976).Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 175,443-452. Ferris, J. P., Aleksejczyk, R. A., and Martin, M. A. (1984).Biochemistry 23,3370-3371. Frederick, C. B., Mays, J. B., Ziegler, D. M., Guengerich, F. P., and Kadlubar, F. F. (1982). Cancer Res. 42,2671-2677. Ghosh, D., and Samanta, T. B. (1981).J. Steroid Biochem. 14,1063-1067. Gibson, M., Soper, C. J., and Parfitt, R. T. (1984a).Anal. Chim. Acta 163, 175-183. Gibson, M., Soper, C. J., Parfitt, R. T., and Sewell, G. J. (1984b).EnzymeMicrob. Technol. 6, 471-475.
Gmunder, F. K., Kappeli, O., and Fiechter, A. (1981).Eur. J. Appl. Biotechnol. 12, 135142.
Groves, J. T. (1985).J. Chem. Educ. 62,928-931. Groves, J. T.,and Subramanian, D. V. (1984).J. Am. Chem. SOC.106,2177-2181. Guengerich, F. P. (1984).Annu. Rev. Nutr. 4,207-232. Guengerich, F. P. (1987).Prog. Drug Metab. 10, 1-54. Guengerich, F. P.(1990).CRC Crit. Rev. Mol. Biol. 25,97-153. Guengerich, F. P., and Macdonald, T. L. (1984).Acc. Chem. Res. 17,9-16. Harder, P. A., O’Keefe,D. P., Romesser, J. A,, Leto, K. J,, and Omer, C. A. (1991).Mol. Gen. Genet. (in press). Haugen, D. A., and Coon, M. J, (1976).J. Biol. Chem. 251,7929-7939. He, J.-S., Ruettinger, R. T., Liu, H.-M., and Fulco, A. J. (1989).Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1009,301-303.
Hedegaard, J., and Gunsalus, I. C. (1965).J. Biol. Chem. 240,4038-4043. Hitchcock, C. A., Brown, S. B., Evans, E. G. V., and Adams, D. J. (1989a).Biochem. J. 260, 549-556.
Hitchcock, C. A., Dickinson, K., Brown, S. B., Evans, E. G. V., and Adams, D. J. (1989b). Biochem. J. 263,573-579. Hoa, G. H., Primo, C. D., Donadaine, I., Sligar, S. G., Gunsalus, I. C., and Douzou, P. (1989). Biochemistry 28,651-656. Honeck, H., Schunch, W.-H., Riege, P., and Muller, H.-G. (1982).Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 106,1318-1324. Horii, M., Ishizaki, T., Paik, S., Manome, T., and Murooka, Y. (1990).J. Bacteriol. 172, 3644-3653.
Imai, M., Shimada, H., Watanabe, Y., Matsushima-Hibiya, Y . , Makino, R., Koga, H., Horiuchi, T., and Ishimura, Y.(1989).Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U S A . 86, 7823-7827. Ishida, N., Aoyama, Y., Hatanaka, R., Oyama, Y., Imajo, S., Ishiguro, M., Oshima, T., Nakazato, H., Noguchi, T., Maitra, U. S., Mohan, V. P., Sprinson, D. B., and Yoshida, Y.(1988).Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 155,317-323. Kaergel, E., Aoyama, Y., Schunck, W.-H., Mueller, H.-G., and Yoshida, Y. (1990).Yeast 6, 61-67.
176
F. SIMA SARIASLANI
Kalb, V. F., Woods, C. E., Turi, T. G., Dey, C. R., Sutter, T. R., and Loper, J. C. (1987).DNA 6, 529-530.
Kim, B. H., and Fulco, A. J. (1983).Biochem, Biophys. Res. Commun. 116,843-850. King, D. J., and Wiseman, A. (1987).In “Enzyme Induction, Mutagen Activation and Carcinogen Testing in Yeast” (A. Wiseman, ed.), pp. 115-167. Harwood, New York. King, D. J., Azari, M. R., and Wiseman, A. (1982).Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 105, 1115-1121.
Kirsch, D. R., Lai, M. H., and O’Sullivan, J. (1988).Gene 68,229-237. Kleber, H.-P., Muller, R., and Asperger, 0. (1985).FEMS Symp. 23,89-95. Koga, H., Rauchfuss, B., and Gunsalus, I. C. (1985).Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 130, 412-417.
Koga, H., Aremaki, H., Yamaguchi, E., Takeuchi, K., Horiuchi, T., and Gunsalus, I. C. (1986).J. Bacteriol. 166,1089-1095. Koga, H., Yamaguchi, E., Matsunaga, K., Aramaki, H., and Horiuchi, T. (1989).J. Biochem. (Tokyo) 106,831-836. Lai, M. H., and Kirsch, D. R. (1989).Nucleic Acid Res. 17,804. Laurila, H., Kappeli, O., and Fiechter, A. (1984).Arch. Microbiol. 140, 257-259. Lebeault, J., Lode, E. T., and Coon, M. J. (1971).Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 42, 413-419.
Mansuy, D., Carlier, M., Bertrand, J., and Azoulay, E. (1980).Eur. J. Biochem. 109, 103108.
Matson, R. S., and Fulco, A. J. (1981).Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 103,531-535. Matsuoka, T., Miyakoshi, S.,Tanszawa, K., Nakahara, K., Hosobuchi, M., and Serizawa, N. (1989).Eur. J. Biochem. 184,703-713. Matthews, D. E., and Van Etten, H. D. (1983).Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 224,494-505. Miller, R. E., and Guengerich, F. P. (1982).Biochemistry 21,1090-1097. Muira, Y., and Fulco, A. J. (1975).Biochim. Biophys. Acta 388,305-317. Muller, R., Asperger, O., and Kleber, H.-P. (1989).Biomed. Biochim. Acta 48,243-254. Nahri, L. O.,and Fulco, A. J. (1987).J. Biol. Chem. 262,6683-6690. Neal, R. A., and Alpert, J. (1982).Annu. Rev. Pharmacol. Toxicol. 22,321-339. Okamoto, T., Sasaki, K., and Tachibana, M. (1989).Bull. Inst. Chem. Res., Kyoto Univ. 67, 169-195.
O’Keefe,D. P., Romesser, J. A., and Leto, K. J. (1988).Arch. Microbiol. 149,406-412. O’Keefe,D. P., Gibson, K. J., Emptage, M. H., Lenstra. R., Romesser, J. A., Litle, P. J., and Omer, C. A. (1991).Biochemistry 30,447-455. Omer, C. A., Lenstra, R., Litle, P. J., Dean, C., Tepperman, J. M., Leto, K. J., Romesser, J. A,, and O’Keefe,D. P. (1990).J. Bacteriol. 172,3335-3345. Ortiz de Montellano, P. R. (1989).Trends Pharmacol. Sci. 10,354-359. Ortiz de Montellano, P. R., and Correis, M. A. (1984).Annu. Rev. Pharmacol. 23,481-503. Patten, J. C., Ning, S. M., Lu, A. Y. H., and Yang, C.S.(1986).Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 251, 629-638.
Peterson, J. A., Lorence, M. C., and Amarneh, B. (1990).J. Biol. Chem. 265,6066-6073. Pohl, L. R., Schulick, R. D., Highet, R. J., and Georger, J. W. (1984).Mol. Pharmacol. 25, 318-321.
Poulos, T. L. (1986).In “Cytochrome P-450,Structure, Mechanism and Biochemistry” (P. R. Ortiz de Montellano, ed.), pp. 505-523. Plenum, New York. Poulous, T. L. (1988).Adv. Inorg. Biochem. 7, 1-36. Poulos, T. L., Finzel, B. C., and Howard, A. J. (1987).J. Mol. Biol. 195, 687-700. Raag, R.,and Poulos, T. L. (1989).Biochemistry 28,7586-7592.
MICROBIAL CYTOCHROME P-450
177
Ramachandra, M., and Sariaslani, F. S. (1990).Abstr. Annu. Meet. Am. SOC. Microbiol. p. 272.
Riege, p., Schunck, W.-H., Honeck, H., and Mueller, H.-G. (1981).Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 98,527-534. Romesser, J. A., and O’Keefe, D. P. (1986).Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 140,650659.
Ruettinger, R. T., Wen, L. P., and Fulco, A.J. (1989).J. Biol. Chem. 264, 10987-10995. Sanglard, D., and Fiechter, A. (1989).FEBS Lett. 256,128-134. Sanglard, D., and Loper, J. C. (1989).Gene 76, 121-136. Sariaslani, F. S.,and Kunz, D. A. (1986).Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 141,405-410. Sariaslani, F. S.,and Stahl, R. J., Jr. (1990).Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 166, 743-749.
Sariaslani, F. S . , Trower, M. K., and Buchholz, S. E. (1989a).Dev. Ind. Microbiol. 30, 161-171.
Sariaslani, F. S., Trower, M. K., and Kunz, D. A. (1989b).Biocatalysis 2,151-160. Sariaslani, F. S.,McGee, L. R., Trower, M. K., and Kitson, F. G. (1990).Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 170,456-461. Schunck, W. H., Kargel, E., Gross, B., Wiedmann, B., Maeursberger, S . , Kope, K., Kiebling, U., Strauss, M., Gaestel, M., and Mueller, H.-G. (1989).Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 161,843-850. Schwalb, H., Narhi, L. O., and Fulco, A. J. (1985).Biochim. Biophys. Acta 838,302-311. Shafiee, A., and Hutchinson, C. R. (1987).Biochemistry 26,6204-6210. Shafiee, A., and Hutchinson, C. R. (1988).J. Bacteriol. 170,1548-1553. Shoun, H., Sudo, Y., Seto, Y., and Beppu, T. (1983).J. Biochem. (Tokyo) 94,1219-1229. Shoun, H., Sudo, Y., and Beppu, T.(1985).J. Biochem. (Tokyo) 97,755-763. Shoun, H., Sudo, Y., Sato, K., and Beppu, T. (1989a).Agric. Biol. Chem. 53,2153-2161. Shoun, H., Suyama, W., and Yasui, T. (1989b).FEBS Lett. 244,ll-14. Sligar, S.G., and Murray, R. I. (1986).In “Cytochrome P-450,Structure, Mechanism and Biochemistry” (P. R. Ortiz de Montellano, ed.), pp. 429-504. Plenum, New York. Smith Eble, K., and Dawson, J. H. (1984).Biochemistry 23,2068-2073. Sutherland, J. B. (1987).Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 52,98-100. Tabushi, I. (1988).Coord. Chem. Rev. 86,l-42. Trower, M. K., Buckland, R. M., Higgins, R., and Griffin, M. (1985). Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 49, 1282-1289. Trower, M. K., Sariaslani, F. S., and Kitson, F. G. (1989a).Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 157,1417-1422. Trower, M. K., Sariaslani, F. S . , and O’Keefe, D. P. (1989b).J. Bacteriol. 171, 1781-1787. Trower, M. K., Emptage, M. H., and Sariaslani, F. S.(1990a).Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1037, 281-289.
Trower, M. K., Marshall, J. E., Doleman, M. S . , Emptage, M. H., and Sariaslani, F. S. (1990b).Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1037,290-296. Ullah, A. H., Murray, R. I., Bhattacharyya, P. K., Wagner, G. C., and Gunsalus, I. C. (1990). J. Biol. Chem. 265,1345-1351. Unger, B. P.,Gunsalus, I. C., and Sligar, S. G. (1986a).J. Biol. Chem. 261, 1158-1163. Unger, B. P.,Sligar, S. G., and Gunnsalus, I. C. (1986b).Bacteria 10,557-589. Warburton, E. J., Magor, A.M., Trower, M. K., and Griffin, M. (1990).FEMS Microbiol. Lett. 66. 5-10.
Wen, L. P., and Fulco, A. J. (1987).J. Biol. Chem. 262,6676-6682. Wen, L. P.,Ruettinger, R. T., and Fulco, R. J. (1989).J. Biol. Chem. 264, 10996-11003.
178
F. SIMA SARIASLANI
White, R. E., McCarthy, M. K., Egeberg, D., and Sligar, S. G. (1984).Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 228,493-502. Yoshida, Y., Aoyama, Y., Nishino, T., Katsuki, H., Maitra, U. S . , Mohan, V. P., and Sprinson, D. B. (1985).Biochern. Biophys. Res. Cornrnun. 127,623-628. Yoshida, Y., Aoyama, Y., Takano, H., and Kato, T. (1986).Biochern. Biophys. Res. Comrnun. 137,513-519.
Foodborne Yeasts T. DEAK Department of Microbiology University of Horticulture and Food Industry Budapest, H-1118, Hungary I. Introduction 11. Characteristics and Classification of Yeasts 111. Ecology of Yeasts
A. Sources and Vectors of Contamination B. Intrinsic Properties of Foods C. Extrinsic Parameters D. Implicit Parameters E. Processing and Preservation IV. Specific Habitats A. Fruits and Vegetables B. Fruit Juices and Soft Drinks C. Alcoholic Beverages D. High-Sugar Products E. Cereals and Bakery Products F. Meat, Poultry, and Fish G. Dairy Products H. Fermented, Salted, and Acid-Preserved Foods V. Methods of Isolation and Enumeration A. Sample Preparation B. Methods of Enumeration C. Media D. Selective Procedures E. Novel Techniques VI. Methods of Identification A. New and Improved Identification Methods B. The Simplified Identification Method C. Description of Main Groups of Foodborne Yeasts References
I. Introduction
Yeasts are undoubtedly the most important microorganisms exploited by mankind. Their traditional application stems from the end products of alcoholic fermentation, i.e., ethanol and carbon dioxide, which are exploited on a large scale in industrial processes for producing bread, wine, beer, other alcoholic beverages, and ethanol itself (Rose, 1977). In addition to these items, a variety of other metabolic products of yeasts have been used commercially (e.g., enzymes, vitamins, lipids, and carotenoids), and the whole cell mass is also produced in large quantities for baker’s yeast and fodder yeast (Rose, 1979; Dziezak, 1987). 179 ADVANCES IN APPLIED MICROBIOLOGY, VOLUME 36 Copyright 8 1991 by Academic Press, Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved.
180
T. DEAK
With the advent of modern biotechnology, newer methods for the exploitation of yeasts have been developed, such as utilization of waste products and natural substrates (hydrocarbons and methanol) for the production of yeast cell mass (Phaff, 1986; Berry et a]., 1987). By the methods of genetic manipulation (recombinant DNA techniques and protoplast fusion), yeast metabolism can be altered to produce foreign proteins (Spencer et al., 1983). By the same techniques, industrialproduction strains used in traditional processes can be improved (Panchal et al., 1984; Snow, 1985; Alexander, 1986). Compared to their great economic contribution, the disadvantages yeasts present to humans are of secondary importance. Only few species can be considered as human pathogens, and none of them is known to cause food intoxication (Hurley et a]., 1987). Undoubtedly, fresh and processed foods and other industrial raw materials and products are liable to yeast spoilage. Yeasts normally play a small role in spoilage; however, conditions favorable to their growth can be a major factor in deterioration and may cause great economic loss. This can be the case, for example, with acidic or high-sugar-content foods in which bacterial competition is restricted. Yeast activity often results in dramatic events as a consequence of alcoholic fermentation, yielding excessive amounts of carbon dioxide. Subtle changes can be equally undesirable. In order to avoid these problems and to control yeast spoilage, both the properties of the yeast involved and the environmental factors influencing its activity must be studied (Peppler, 1977; Miller, 1979). The present article aims to update the state of knowledge on the ecology of food spoilage yeasts and the methods of studying them. It is not intended to be an exhaustive review, as the subject has been covered by a number of excellent reviews and treatises (Walker and Ayres, 1970; Walker, 1977; Beuchat, 1978, 1987; Phaff et a]., 1978; Miller, 1979; Rhodes, 1979; Peppler, 1980; Skinner et al., 1980; Davenport, 1981). Recently an excellent review chapter has appeared comprehensively covering the role of yeasts in food spoilage (Fleet, 1990). II. Characteristics and Classification of Yeasts
Yeasts are traditionally characterized, classified, and identified by morphological and physiological criteria (Kreger-van Rij, 1987). To these, new criteria have been introduced concerning the biochemistry and molecular biology of yeast cells. Data on the chemical composition of cell walls, capsular polysaccharides, whole cell hydrolysates, antigenic determinants, and enzyme patterns provide valuable information for yeast taxonomy (Phaff, 1984). However, the most important ap-
FOODBORNE YEASTS
181
proach is the determination of DNA base composition and homology, as well as the sequence of ribosomal RNA, which can be used to elucidate not only the degree of relatedness but also to reveal evolutionary connections (Walker, 1985;Kurtzman and Phaff, 1987;Blanz and Unseld, 1987).
Molecular taxonomy has reformed yeast classification and has become of prime importance to the distinction of species. However, the sophisticated biochemical and genetic methods cannot be applied in routine identification procedures, and the classification of yeasts among other fungi is still primarily based upon characteristics of sexual reproduction (von Arx, 1981;von Arx and van der Walt, 1987).Criteria used for the description and classification of yeasts have been described in detail by van der Walt and Yarrow (1984)and summarized recently by Kreger-van Rij (1987).In the following discussion, only those morphological and physiological criteria will be mentioned and will be referred to later in the description of foodborne yeasts and their identification. From a taxonomic point of view, yeasts are not homogeneous and their taxonomy is not stable. For practical purposes, yeasts may be defined as unicellular fungi in which vegetative reproduction occurs mainly by budding. Although a single cell is the predominant form of yeasts, some yeasts produce filaments like other fungi. These may be well-developed true hyphae or chains of cells forming pseudohyphae. These forms, collectively called yeastlike organisms, are borderline between filamentous fungi and unicellular yeasts. Moreover, many filamentous fungi can be induced to form a yeast phase, and some pathogenic fungi are also dimorphic in that they form yeastlike cells in the invaded tissue (Shepherd et al., 1985;de Hoog et al., 1987). It seems that during evolution, adaptation to unicellular life forms may have occurred several times among groups of fungi. Consequently, yeasts can be assigned to different fungal taxa. Those yeasts that form spores by sexual reproduction can be classified accordingly to the appropriate fungal division. The so-called true yeasts are traditionally considered a group of ascomycete fungi. However, the endogenous formation of sexual spores in these yeasts differs substantially from the characteristic development of ascospores in that yeasts lack dicaryotic ascogenous hyphae and ascocarps. Hence, this group of yeasts can be considered as a separate division of fungi for which the names Endomycota (Barr, 1983) or Zymomycota (Novak, 1981)have been suggested. The mode of spore formation varies among true yeasts. Cells of Saccharomyces are diploid and directly transform into sporangia when the
182
T.DEAK
spores form. In Zygosaccharomyces, conjugation between independent haploid cells precedes sporangium formation, whereas in Torulaspora, conjugation occurs between the mother cell and its bud. Other modes of sporulation can also be found in other genera. Spores may remain in the sporangium until the time of germination, or spores may easily be liberated from sporangia (e.g., in Kluyveromyces). This can be of diagnostic value, as well as the shape of the spores (e.g., spherical, kidney, or needle). Sometimes spores are surrounded with a brim that gives them a hat or saturn shape (e.g., in many Pichia). Although the morphological features of spores play an important role in yeast classification, they can be properly studied only by electron microscopy. Moreover, for a variety of reasons, spores are not consistently formed. When the yeast strain is haploid and heterothallic (i.e., the opposite mating types can be found in separate colonies), spore formation does not occur in isolated culture. Even many homothallic yeasts often require special conditions to induce spore formation. Hence, many yeasts are known, and in fact have been first described, in asexual form, called the anamorph (or imperfect) state, as compared to the teleomorphic (perfect) state, in which the yeasts reproduce sexually by the formation of spores. Unfortunately, a yeast often bears different names in the two states: the teleomorphic name is used to describe the species and the anamorphic name reduces to a synonym (e.g., Hanseniaspora uvarum, whose anamorph is Kloeckera apiculata). Some yeasts reproduce sexually by teliospores and others reproduce by basidia. These yeasts clearly show basidiomycetous affinity; moreover, they may also form hyphae with clamp connections. Some of them are true basidiomycetes, whereas others are more similar to the smuts. They are usually isolated in the anamorphic state because selfsporulating strains are rare. Their haploid anamorphs have been grouped in various imperfect genera such as Rhodotorula, Cryptococcus, and Sporobolomyces. The characteristic mode of yeast asexual propagation is budding. According to modern terminology introduced for fungi, budding is a type of conidiation (von Arx, 1979),and the buds are blastoconidia. Several types of budding occur among yeasts. Notable is bipolar budding (annelloconidiation), which lends the cell a peculiar lemon shape (e.g., in Hanseniaspora). Otherwise, yeast cells are mostly round, oval, or cylindrical. When certain strains form septate hyphae, buds may arise from them, or sometimes the hypha breaks up into arthroconidia. This is actually what happens with the single cells in the genus Schizosaccharomyces, wherein the characteristic vegetative reproduction is called fission, and no budding cells occur.
FOODBORNE YEASTS
183
Of the physiological criteria used for classifying and identifying yeasts, the most important are fermentation and assimilation, although a number of other properties are also generally considered. Mention should be made of two tests that recently have become important for the distinction of basidiomycetous yeasts. These are the diazonium blue B (DBB)and the urease color reactions (Hagler and Ahearn, 1981).They are especially useful criteria for the characterization of imperfect yeasts that do not reproduce sexually. Efforts to form homogeneous genera of imperfect yeasts according to their connection with, or affinity to, perfect counterparts have not yet been fully successful. It has been suggested that the genus Candida should retain only the endomycetous anamorphic species (van der Walt, 1987;Weijman et al., 1988).This largest yeast genus has become a reservoir of all imperfect forms that cannot be assigned to any other genera. Even the former Torulopsis species have been merged with Candida because the formation of pseudohyphae appeared to be an unreliable character (Yarrow and Meyer, 1978). Thus, the taxonomy of yeasts is far from complete; moreover, the frequent changes of names and classification may result in a confusing situation. Ill. Ecology of Yeasts
The modern concept of microbial ecology considers every food item as a habitat of microorganisms. Every food has a characteristic microflora, which is a specific association of microorganisms. The origin, development, and succession of this association are governed by environmental ecological factors that influence the physiological expression of the genetic constitution of the microbial cells. Raw and processed foods become contaminated by microorganisms from the environment. Only a part of this primary microflora will survive under the selective pressures exerted by the internal and external environments of foods. Those microorganisms will be favored that possess the proper physiological attributes to respond the ecological determinants. Interactions among microorganisms also influence the development of microbial colonization. Eventually, a particular microbial community will develop. If the environmental factors permit, this characteristic microflora will turn into a specific spoilage association. All of these dynamic changes are determined by the ecological factors of a given food. The ecological principles of food microbiology outlined above were laid down by Mossel and Ingram (1955)and are now widely accepted (ICMSF,1980;Hobbs, 1986).The same general principles can be related
184
T.DEAK
to yeasts occurring in foods. In the following sections, ecological determinants are discussed as they relate specifically to foodborne yeasts. In doing this, five groups of ecological parameters will be considered: (1)sources and vectors of contamination, (2) intrinsic, abiotic properties of foods, (3) extrinsic, abiotic factors of storage and transportation, (4) processing and preservation, and (5) biotic, implicit properties of microorganisms. AND VECTORS OF CONTAMINATION A. SOURCES
Yeasts can be found in most natural habitats, such as soil, plants, animals, and fresh and marine water. Many reviews have dealt with the relationship of yeasts with their natural environments. Phaff et al. (1978)presented a broad overview of yeasts associated with soils, water, plants, and animals. These topics have been updated recently by Phaff and Starmer (1987),Hagler and Ahearn (1987),and Hurley et al. (1987). From an ecological point of view, these natural habitats are ubiquitous and are general sources of contamination of foods. Several yeast species are typical inhabitants of soil ( e g , Schwanniomyces and Lipomyces species), and a much larger variety of yeast occurring in soil represents the yeast flora associated with plants and animals above the surface. For these yeasts, soil serves more as a reservoir than as a specific habitat. Hanseniaspora species, for example, occur very commonly in orchard and vineyard soils and get there from fruits that fall to the ground. Some vegetables may be directly contaminated by yeasts from soil. Insects are the most important vectors in the distribution of yeasts in nature. Mechanisms of yeast distribution by insects, animals, air, and water have been reviewed by Davenport (1976). Yeasts are often intimately associated with some insects; e.g., bark beetles have been shown to be the sources of several yeast species (Kreger-van Rij, 19841. Drosophila and honeybees are important vectors of yeast dissemination in foods. Specific sources of contamination are previously spoiled food materials, and transporting containers and processing equipment may serve as transmitters in facilities that fail to maintain satisfactory hygienic measures. Geotrichum was involved in a well-documented case of “machinery mold” contamination (Eisenberg and Cichowicz, 1977; Splittstoesser et al., 1977). It has also been proved that the main sources of Saccharomyces wine yeast are the winery equipment, presses, and barrels (Rosini et al., 1982).
FOODBORNE YEASTS
185
B. INTRINSIC PROPERTIES OF FOODS Intrinsic parameters are those physical, chemical and structural properties inherent in foods that primarily determine the fate of the microbial population in the foods. With respects to yeasts, the most important intrinsic factors are water activity, nutrients, and acidity. 1. Water Activity
In food microbiology, the availability of water for microorganisms is generally expressed in terms of water activity, a,, which relates to the concentration of solutes in a food (Brown, 1976; Tilbury, 1980b). The majority of yeasts are somewhat less sensitive to the lowering of a, than most bacteria and can grow at minimum a, values, around 0.95-0.90. A particular group of yeasts is of special importance for being able to grow at much lower a, values in the presence of high concentrations of either sugar or salt. These yeasts, which have long been called “osmophilic,” are important spoilage organisms in certain foods. The term, however, is misleading for two reasons. The osmotic pressure is not directly related to the physiology of these yeasts, and they do not really require a high solute concentration for growth, but rather are able to thrive at low a, values. Hence, the term “xerotolerant” has been coined to describe these yeasts (Anand and Brown, 1968). In the earlier literature an extremely low a, tolerance of yeast, 0.620.65, was recorded (for a survey see Jermini and Schmidt-Lorenz, 1987a). Later investigations did not confirm these data. Two other surveys have been published (Tokouka et al., 1985; Jermini et al., 1987),but neither noted yeast growth at a, 0.7 or below, and out of some 140 freshly isolated strains, only four grew better at a, 0.91 than at higher a, values. Values of less than 0.7 a, not only inhibited yeast growth but also caused slow death of cells, with a decimal reduction time of 57-445 hours at a, 0.626 (Jermini and Schmidt-Lorenz, 1987a). The principal xerotolerant yeasts are species of the genus Zygosaccharomyces. The most common is Zygosaccharornyces rouxii, strains of which showed a minimum a, 0.76 for growth, whereas optimum was above 0.95. Other Zygosaccharornyces species occur less frequently in foods and show less a, tolerance, e.g., Zygosaccharornyces bailii did not grow below a, 0.85 (Jermini et al., 1987). Tokouka et al. (1985) listed some 30 yeast species that showed a certain degree of sugar tolerance in that growth occurred in the a, range 0.912-0.876. They were isolated from high-sugar-containing foods. In addition to Z. rouxii, Zygosaccharomyces bisporus, Candida lactis-condensi, Debaromyces
186
T.DEAK
hansenii, Pichia anomala, Schizosaccharomyces octosporus, Schizosaccharomyces pombe, Torulaspora delbrueckii, and several Candida species were listed. The minimum a, value of growth is influenced by the nature of the solute and by other ecological factors (e.g., temperature). Growth of Z. rouxii ceases at a, 0.85 when salt is used to lower the a,, whereas the minimum value for growth is less in the presence of sugars. Conversely, D. hansenii, Candida krusei, and some other yeasts are noted for their high salt tolerance. The physiological basis of xerotolerance in yeasts is attributed to the synthesis and intracellular accumulation of polyols (glycerol, arabitol, and erythritol) at low a, values. Polyols are thought to be compatible solutes, both compensating for the concentration difference across the cell membrane and allowing the metabolic enzymes to function (Brown, 1978). 2. Nutrients
A comprehensive review concerning the nutrients used by yeasts was presented by Rose (1987).The most important nutrients for yeasts are carbohydrates, which serve as both growth and energy sources. The aerobic utilization of a substance for growth is called “assimilation” by zymologists. Fermentation means the anaerobic metabolism of carbohydrates to ethanol and carbon dioxide. The term “yeast” is often associated with fermentation; however, nearly half of the presently known yeast species lack the ability to ferment sugars. Only a few sugars, mostly hexoses and oligosaccharides, can be fermented by yeasts. The range of carbon sources that are utilized aerobically is much wider, and includes hexoses, pentoses, alcohols, organic acids, and some other carbon compounds. Differences in the fermentation and assimilation of carbon sources are important diagnostic characters in yeast taxonomy and identification. The ability to decompose complex carbohydrates is restricted to a few yeast species. Utilization of starch is of particular interest for industrial production of yeast cell mass (single-cell protein, SCP) from starchcontaining agricultural wastes. Schwanniomyces and Lipomyces species possess enzymes with various amylase activities. The former can only partially utilize starch for lack of debranching enzyme activity; the latter is able to utilize starch completely. Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Candida utilis are unable to hydrolyze starch. A special biotype of S. cerevisiae (formerly recognized as a separate species, Saccharomyces diastaticus) can, however, completely hydrolyze starch (McCann and Barnett, 1986).
FOODBORNE YEASTS
187
Pentose utilization, particularly fermentation of xylose, may be potentially a useful property of some yeasts for the industrial production of ethanol from the hydrolysis products of hemicellulosecontaining plant materials. Other possible carbon sources for SCP production by yeasts are hydrocarbons, and several yeasts are able to grow on these substances (Barnett et al., 1983; Phaff, 1986). A number of yeasts show pectolytic activity, although the enzymes responsible for this differ among the species (Sanchez et al., 1984; Call et al., 1985). Both organic and inorganic sources of nitrogen can be utilized by yeasts for growth. Although very few species can hydrolyze proteins extracellularly, short peptides can be transported into the cell and utilized intracellularly (Yamada and Ogrydziak, 1983). Amino acids, amines, and urea are suitable nitrogen sources for practically all yeasts, as are inorganic ammonium salts. Nitrate utilization is, however, confined to certain species or genera of yeasts, and this is a valuable diagnostic character used for identification purposes. In addition to basic carbon and nitrogen sources, inorganic microelements and small amounts of complex organic growth factors, mostly vitamins, may be required for the growth of yeasts. These requirements are normally fulfilled adequately in natural substances and foods. Yeasts vary widely in their requirements for minerals and growth factors. Many species synthesize all of the necessary vitamins for growth and propagate vigorously in vitamin-free media. Others require certain vitamins, and this can be used for identification purposes (Barnett et al., 1983). Biotin appears to be the most commonly required vitamin; some species require niacin, thiamine, pantothenic acid, folic acid, riboflavin, or m-inositol. Certain yeasts are notable for their exacting properties, e.g., a strain of S. octosporus grows poorly in synthetic media unless supplemented with adenine. Dekkera (and Brettanomyces) species require high concentrations of thiamine for growth. 3. Acidity
Most yeasts tolerate a wide range of pH and grow readily at values between 3 and 8. In general, yeasts prefer a slightly acidic medium, with an optimum pH between 4.5 and 6.5. Yeasts show a remarkable tolerance to pH. Many species, such as C. krusei, Pichia membranaefaciens, Brettanomyces intermedius, and Saccharomyces exiguus, are able to grow at pH values as low as 1.3-1.7 (Pitt, 1974). This tolerance depends on the type of the acidulant; organic acids are more antimicrobial than inorganic acids. Of the former, propionic acid is more inhibitory than acetic, lactic, or citric acid (Walker, 1977). Moon (1983) found that 20 mM propionate, 150 mM acetate, and 350 mM lactate caused 50%
188
T. DEAK
reduction of growth rate in yeasts isolated from spoiled fermented foods. The effectiveness of an acid depends on the lowering of pH and on the specific antimicrobial property of the acid, which is carried by the undissociated molecule. Consequently, the pH and the pK, value of an acid strongly influence the antimicrobial activity. The physiological basis of the effect of pH on yeasts is not yet completely understood. It is generally believed that the maintenance of a proton gradient across the plasma membrane against a constant intracellular pH of about 6.5 is vital for a yeast cell (Borst-Pauwels, 1981). The ability of yeasts to grow at low pH may depend on energy-requiring transport systems that pump protons out of the cell, thus preventing acidification of the cell interior (Deak, 1978).The pH of the environment affects appreciably other physiological behaviors of the yeast cell, such as heat tolerance and resistance to chemical compounds. C. EXTRINSICPARAMETERS The two most important factors in the external environment of a food affecting yeast growth and activity are temperature and oxygen levels, or more generally, the surrounding atmosphere. 1. Temperature
The temperature relations of yeasts have been reviewed by Watson (1987),and this topic will be covered here only briefly. The vast majority of yeasts live in a range of diverse habitats whose temperature domain falls between 0 and 45°C. Accordingly, most yeasts can be classified as mesophiles on the basis of temperature limits for growth. Quite a number of yeasts are capable of growing around 0°C and even a few degrees below zero, as well as at 25-30 "C. Some other yeasts, among them many Cryptococcus and Candida species, exhibit an optimum growth temperature below 20°C. These can justifiably be considered phychrophilic. At the other extreme, there exist only a few yeasts (all associated with the digestive tract of animals) whose minimum temperature for growth is above 20°C and whose maximum temperature is about 46-48°C. These are called thermophiles, although their cardinal temperatures for growth are not comparable with those of obligate thermophilic bacteria. Of the common foodborne yeasts, Kluyveromyces strains are noteworthy for their relative high maximum growth temperature of around 42-45°C. Otherwise, many yeasts do not grow at or above 37°C and this sometimes serves as a useful diagnostic property for some species.
FOODBORNE YEASTS
189
The temperature of growth is influenced by other environmental factors. It is a general phenomenon that the optimum temperature for growth is elevated in solutions of high sugar or salt concentration. In a study by Jermini and Schmidt-Lorenz (1987c), examples were given for growth of xerotolerant yeasts of the shift of cardinal temperatures toward higher values with decreasing a,. In normal media the minimum temperature was 4°C for the strains studied; at a, values less than 0.92, none of them grew below 6°C. On the other hand, an increase of solute concentration (up to 60% w/w glucose) raised the maximum growth temperature by 4-6°C up to 42°C. 2. Atmosphere Composition
Contrary to common belief, yeasts are basically aerobic organisms. Some genera (e.g., Cryptococcus and Rhodotorula) are strict aerobes, whereas others are facultative and can also carry out an alcoholic fermentation. Characteristic members of yeast genera, such as Saccharomyces and others, when submerged in liquid, bring about a vigorous fermentation of sugars but soon stop growth and propagation for lack of available oxygen. This is because all yeasts require molecular oxygen for the synthesis of certain cellular constituents, such as unsaturated fatty acids and sterols (Rose, 1987). Facultative yeasts switch their metabolism from aerobic respiration to fermentation and vice versa, depending on the availability of molecular oxygen (the so-called Pasteur effect), or on the concentration of glucose (the Crabtree effect) (Fiechter et al., 1981; Lagunas, 1981). A peculiar group of yeasts (Dekkera species and their anamorphs, Brettanomyces) ferment glucose more rapidly under aerobic than anaerobic conditions (the so-called Custer’s effect; Carrascosa et al., 1981). Fermenting yeast species have a selective advantage over the strictly aerobic species, and it is these that can thrive under low oxygen tension in beverages and in deeper layers of thick food pieces, where they may cause fermentative spoilage of products. Certain fermentative yeasts appear to be rather insensitive to high levels of carbon dioxide. Brettanomyces species have been found to be the most COz-tolerant yeasts and are the main spoilage yeasts of carbonated beverages. Candida intermedia, P. anomala, and Z. bailii also tolerated about 0.5 MPa pressure of dissolved COz (Ison and Gutteridge, 1987). Certain Saccharomyces strains used in champagne production are able to ferment under high pressures of COz. The factors relating to the resistance or sensitivity of yeasts to carbonation are not fully understood. Growth and metabolic activity are both adversely affected in most yeasts at pCOz values above 0.3 MPa (Jones and Greenfield, 1982).
190
T. DEAK
D. IMPLICIT PARAMETERS Implicit parameters refer to the genetically determined physiological attributes of microorganisms whose ultimate expression is the ability and rate of growth under a given set of environmental (extrinsic and intrinsic) conditions. In addition, the interactions among members of a population, particularly antagonistic and synergistic effects on each other, are also considered as important biotic, implicit determinants. Growth of yeasts that primarily propagate vegetatively by budding can be described in a manner analogous to unicellular, dividing bacteria, and the increase in cell number or cell mass with time can be characterized by the specific growth rate ( p )or the mean generation time (tg).
Relatively few studies have been made on growth of yeasts on natural substrates. The growth kinetics of yeasts has been mainly studied in batch and continuous cultures in connection with their industrial application (Fiechter et al., 1987).To a good approximation, yeast growth can be characterized with a growth rate in the range of 0.17-0.35/hour ( t g , 4-2 hours), although some yeasts grow much more slowly ( e g , Brettanomyces species). In general, the growth rates of yeasts are slow compared with those of bacteria, and mold growth is much slower than that of yeasts. This gives a certain advantage to bacteria over yeasts in colonization of most foods. However, under certain conditions, e g , in acidic or high-sugar-containing food, yeasts can easily overgrow bacteria. In plant materials, cellulose and starch hydrolysis by molds is often followed by the development of yeasts that are only able to utilize the hydrolysis products of these polysaccharides. This and many other examples can be cited for interactions between yeasts and other microorganisms (Phaff et a]., 1978). These interactions are either based on differences in the metabolic capabilities to compete for available nutrients, or in the physiological constitution (sensitivity or resistance) related to metabolic products or environmental factors affecting growth. Ethanol produced by fermenting yeasts is a well-known example of an antagonistic metabolic product that inhibits bacteria and yeasts. Worth mentioning is the production of killer toxins by many yeasts, because these are not only likely to affect yeast populations in natural habitats, but can also be exploited in the industrial use of yeasts (Young, 1981; Heard and Fleet, 1987). E. PROCESSING AND PRESERVATION
Perhaps the most dramatic changes in the composition of the microflora of a food happen during its processing, which brings about great modifications in the physical and chemical conditions. Preservation by
FOODBORNE YEASTS
191
heat treatments or addition of chemicals may kill the majority of cells present or select for resistant types of microorganisms. 1. Heating
In general, the heat resistance of yeasts is about the same as that of vegetative cells of bacteria. Beuchat (1981a,b) indicated that death of most yeast cells occurred within 30 minutes at 50°C or 10 minutes at 60°C. Put et al. (1976) made a comprehensive study of the heat resistance of 120 yeasts representing some 30 species isolated mainly from soft drinks. Their method was to determine the survival of buffered yeast suspensions of about lo5 cells/ml at pH 4.5 from 55 to 65°C for 10 and 20 minutes. These conditions were chosen because yeast populations often do not show linear survival curves enabling one to determine the decimal reduction time (D) and its temperature dependence (z value) (Barillere et a]., 1985a,b). These authors concluded that about half of the strains studied did not survive 10 minutes at 62.5"C and none survived heating for 20 minutes at 65°C. Strains of S. cerevisiae showed the highest heat resistance in that they survived 10 minutes at 65°C. In addition to S. cerevisiae, strains of Kluyveromyces marxianus, Z. bailii, and Z. rouxii also showed moderate degrees of heat resistance, surviving 20 minutes at 62.5"C. In order to overcome the uncertainties caused by tailing of survival curves, Reichart (1979) devised a new method to measure and calculate D and z values. By applying this method it was found that the D value for the most sensitive yeasts (e.g., Cryptococcus strains) was less than 1 minute at 50"C, whereas most yeasts showed a lethality at 55°C with a D value of 0.6-4.6 minutes, and the z value ranged from 3 to 7°C (Torok and Reichart, 1983). These ranges of D and z values have also been measured by other authors (Barreiro et al., 1981; Juven et a]., 1980; Splittstoesser et a]., 1986). Spores of yeast possess considerably more heat resistance than do vegetative cells. Put and De Jong (1982a,b) showed that spores exhibited a heat resistance 50- to 350-fold greater than vegetative cells. Splittstoesser et al. (1986) confirmed this finding and showed that the D value at 55°C was 106 minutes for S. cerevisiae spores compared to 0.9 minutes for vegetative cells. In addition to the differences in types and origin of strains and the extent of sporulation, the main factors influencing heat resistance are the composition and pH of the heating medium. The heat resistance of yeasts is influenced in solutions containing sugars and/or salt. Sucrose in 15 to 60% concentrations protected yeasts against heat inactivation, and this was attributed to the dehydration of cells caused by solutes (Corry, 1976). Salt behaved similarly only in lower concentrations (up
192
T. DEAK
to 6%) but in higher concentrations it enhanced the heat inactivation of some yeasts (Beuchat, 1981a). It appeared that the protective effect of salt against heat inactivation correlated with the growth tolerance to NaC1; for example, P. membranaefaciens, lssatchenkia orientalis, and D. hansenii possessed higher heat resistance in the presence of salt, but salt enhanced the heat destruction of Rhodotorula rubra. Compared to heat resistance in various solutions, yeasts are much more resistant to dry heat. Scott and Bernard (1985) obtained for several yeasts D values of 1to 2 minutes at temperatures of 110-125°C, with z values from 9 to 13°C. Decrease of pH, addition of preservatives, and organic acids generally increase the rate of heat destruction of yeasts (Beuchat, 1981b). Lowering the pH from 5 to 2.5 caused, without exception, more rapid inactivation. Potassium sorbate and sodium benzoate in concentrations of 0.1 to 1.0% and organic acids (citric, malic, and especially acetic acid) in concentrations of 0.1 to 3% acted synergistically with heat. This effect can clearly be demonstrated in model systems; however, Beuchat (1982) pointed out that rates of inactivation were not markedly affected by various concentrations of citric, malic, and tartaric acids normally found in fruit juices and purees. Moreover, the protective effect of certain natural components and/or added sugar against heat inactivation could reduce the synergistic effect of preservatives and organic acids (Beuchat, 1983a). Ethanol sensitizes yeasts to heat, which is advantageous to product stabilizing achieved by hot filling of bottled table wines (Splittstoesser et al., 1975). Heating may cause not only direct destruction of yeast but also a sublethal stress for those cells that immediately survived heat treatment (Beuchat, 1984).These stressed and injured cells may recover or may die subsequently, depending on the circumstances. This phenomenon can be advantageous to the quality and shelf life of the food product. The slow die-off of heat-injured yeast has been demonstrated in dried vegetables and other commodities whose previous processing included a certain degree of heat treatment. On the other hand, recovery for demonstration and enumeration of injured cells requires optimum growth conditions, and these were subject of detailed studies (Stecchini and Beuchat, 1985). 2. Freezing
Compared to heat inactivation, the effects of reduced temperature and freezing on yeast have received less attention. Yeasts in general survive freezing in high percentages of the inital viable cell number. Indeed, freezing and freeze-drying are effective and routinely used methods for
FOODBORNE YEASTS
193
the preservation and storage of yeast strains in culture collections (Kirsop and Snell, 1984). This involves quick freezing close to the temperature of liquid nitrogen (-196°C) or at least to -80°C by applying deep freezer apparatuses. For food preservation and in commercial practice, relatively higher temperatures in the range of -15 to -25°C are applied and are attained at much slower freezing rates. Under these circumstances, the survival ratio is less and the freezing injury is higher. This is mainly attributed to the formation of internal ice crystals and/or crystallization in the environment, causing intracellular dehydration and membrane damage (Ingram and Mackey, 1976). In addition to the cooling rate and freezing temperature, the extent of cell death and low-temperature injury depends on many other factors, such as species and strain differences, pH, and solute concentration. In general, food constituents such as sugars, starch, amino acids, and proteins have a protective action, whereas organic acids and preservatives enhance the lethal effect of freezing and thawing and the slow inactivation during frozen storage. The effect of the thawing and warming rates is difficult to separate from the direct effect of freezing itself. During slow thawing, recrystallization of ice is considered as a major cause of further injury. Repeated freezing and thawing cause increased inactivation of cells (Meyer et al., 1975).Osmotolerant yeasts, which possess a particular membrane structure and metabolic system for osmotic regulation (Brown, 1978; Morgan and Witter, 1980), are more sensitive to the lethal effect of freezing than are other yeasts. In a recent study, Jermini and Schimdt-Lorenz (1987b) showed that a single freezing to -25°C and thawing after 24 hours caused an approximate reduction of viable cells of Z. rouxii. After 4 months storage at -25"C, only 1 5 to 40% of cells originally present survived. Repeated freezing and thawing (five or six times] reduced the viability of 0.1% or less. 3. Preservatives
The commonly used food preservatives, benzoic acid, sorbic acid, and sulfuric acid, are weak acids with undissociated lipophilic forms that easily penetrate the cell membrane (Cole and Keenan, 1986; Warth, 1986).
The maximum tolerated levels of benzoic and sorbic acids ranged from 0.5 to 1 mM for H. uvarum, P. anomala, K. marxianus, and S. cerevisiae, whereas other yeasts, such as I. orientalis, S. pombe, Z. bailii, and Saccharomycodes ludwigii were more resistant, tolerating 3 to 4 mM (Warth, 1985). Resistance to these preservatives was often associated with resistance to SOz in a concentration range of 0.05-
194
T. DEAK
2.8 mM. This may be due to common nonspecific effects on cell membrane functions and energy generation (Detik and NovBk, 1972a; Freese et aI., 1973), although preservatives may also have specific actions (Liewen and Marth, 1985). The main inhibitory effect of sorbic acid and benzoic acid was to reduce cell yield, and at higher concentrations the growth rates and lag times were also affected. In contrast, SO2 did not greatly inhibit cell yield and growth rates but produced extended lag times (Warth, 1985). When used in their acceptable concentrations, the organic preservatives do not kill microorganisms but inhibit their proliferation (Restraino et al., 1982). On the other hand, free SOz can cause rapid loss in cell viability (Schimz, 1980). Inhibition of growth may cease when the effective concentration decreases due to breakdown and metabolism (Deak and NovBk, 1972b) or chemical binding (King et al., 1981).Certain yeasts, such as S. Iudwigii and Z . bailii, show notable resistance to preservatives. This can be explained by the induction of an active transport system that pumps preservative molecules out of the cells (Warth, 1977). In the case of SOz it was suggested that resistance was partly due to the ability of yeast cells to produce and excrete acetaldehyde, which binds sulfite (Stratford et aI., 1987). Ethanol, although not considered as a preservative in the strict sense, has a well known antimicrobial effect that is exploited in the production of alcoholic beverages intimately associated with yeasts. Yeasts differ widely in their capacity to produce and tolerate ethanol (Casey and Ingledew, 19861. Ethanol tolerance is related to membrane composition (Thomas et al., 1978; D’Amore and Stewart, 1987) and membrane function coupled to proton transport (Juroszek eta]., 1987),whereas the rate and capacity of ethanol production depend on the levels and activities of key enzymes involved in alcoholic fermentation (Sharma and Tauro, 1987).
IV. Specific Habitats
The specificity of yeast habitats in foods is determined by the ecological factors discussed previously. Governed by the ecological determinants, each specific group of food becomes colonized by a characteristic microflora. In this environment, yeasts are associated with other microorganisms (molds and bacteria) and often are in the minority, especially in relation to bacteria. In the following discussion our interest will be focused exclusively on yeasts, Some foods are rich in nutrients and do not exhibit any restrictive conditions and hence contain a wide variety of yeasts. Others are highly
FOODBORNE YEASTS
195
selective and contain only a few species. Some yeasts are ubiquitous and commonly occur in all kinds of foods. Other species are regularly associated with a given type of food, and these are, in most cases, but not necessarily, the dominant and prevailing species of the yeast flora. Still other yeasts may occur occasionally in a given habitat and their occurrence can be considered fortuitous. It should be noted that the composition of yeast communities is affected by the changes of selective pressures during processing and storage; however, the succession of species can equally be a characteristic course. Distribution of yeasts in foods has been gathered from numerous surveys made by various workers. Several extensive reviews and detailed studies on the association of yeasts with raw and processed foods have been published [do Carmo-Sousa, 1969; Last and Price, 1969; Walker and Ayres, 1970; Phaff et a]., 1978; Phaff and Starmer, 1980; Skinner et a]., 1980), and the taxonomic treatises also provide information on the origin of specific yeast isolates (Lodder, 1970; Kreger-van Rij, 1984). Barnett et al. (1983) compiled lists and keys for yeasts in foods, wine, beer, and nonalcoholic beverages. The following discussion will be directed to specific associations of yeasts with ecologically determined main types of foods, and covers predominantly the literature since 1970. Literature data are summarized in a tabulated form (Table I). A. FRUITS AND VEGETABLES Fruits and vegetables are fresh, living, or moribund, withering parts of plants, rich in nutrients. The determining ecological factor differentiating fruits and vegetables is the pH, which ranges from 3 to 5 in fruits, and this together with high levels of soluble carbohydrates makes them primary habitats for yeasts and molds. Vegetables, on the other hand, have a somewhat higher pH, which renders them more susceptible to bacterial invasion (Deak, 1979; ICMSF, 1980; Brackett, 1987). Yeasts form a part of the natural microflora of most fruits and vegetables, although their relative proportion varies from commodity to commodity and is influenced by environmental, harvesting, and storage conditions (Dennis and Buhagiar, 1980). The population of yeasts on sound fruits has been the subject of numerous studies. Davenport (1976) carried out extensive microecological surveys in English orchards and vineyards. Sources of yeasts included all parts of apple trees and vine plants as well as soil, air, and animal vectors. The main conclusion was that yeasts may differ quantitatively and qualitatively according to the parts examined, and the microflora also differed according to the season, cultivar, and site. Nevertheless, certain yeast
TABLE I
OCCURRENCE OF COMMON FOODBORNE YEASTSPECIES' Species Conodido dbicons
Fresh fruits and vegetables Grapes (13)
Nonalcoholic beverages Soft drinks
Alcoholic beverages
Hi&-sugar products
Grains and cereal products
Must (67)
(96.111)
-
Soft drinks (111). mango juice (125) Soft drinks
Condido contorelli
-
(96,111,112) -
Candido cotenuloto
-
Condido opicola
Condido boidinii
Fruits (129)
Must (140)
Refined sugar
-
(128.140). raisins (34)
Wine (67.140). beer (4,140) Wine (34,67), must (140) Apple juice (10) Wine (34), sherry (67)
-
m
Condido diddensioe
-
Soft drinks (111)
Condido etchellsii
-
Soft drinks (132), apple
-
Must (671, wine (70)
juice (10) Condido globmto
-
Mango juice (125)
Wine (34). must (67,106)
Dates (137)
Apple juice (10). Must (67). wine (70). beer (53) soft drinks
-
Dairy products Cheese (38)
Fermented and preserved foods Fish sauce (29)
Dairy products (127)
Dairy products
Olives (48)
11271
Jam (128)
-
Shellfish (14)
Dairy products
Beef (32), poultry (140). sausage (711, shellfish (14) Beef (57). fish (59).shellfish
Cheese (140)
(1271
Sugar (140)
Raw sugar (137). dried fruits (73). syrups (128) Molasses (921, raw sugar -
Cocoa fermented (101)
-
Olives (48)
Sausage (71)
-
-
Poultry (59).fish (59), shellfish
-
Soy sauce (87). brine (42). pickles (24). olives (137) Brine (121,idli
-
Beef (32), fish
-
-
(14,1401
(134)
(14)
(137)
Candido inconspicua
Beef (32). shellfish (14) Beef (23). sausage (19)
-
CL
W
Meat, fish, and shellfish
Cheese (127)
(103,137)
Cocoa (fermented) [lol), salad
(841
Condido intermedio
Corn (16.35)
Soft drinks (96,111)
Wine (67,701
Molasses (92)
-
Sausage (191, beef (23.57), shellfish (20). poultry (591
Yoghurt (1271, cheese (115)
dressing (17) Chilled salads 164)
Condido loctis-condensii
Condido magnolioe
Condida norvegica
Condida pampsilosis
Red currants (341 -
Corn (16.35)
Soft drinks (132)
Wine (70). must 1671
Soft drinks (132)
Must (49)
Softdrinks (111) Cider (1401,
Soft drinks (96,111)
winery (31,1401 Must and wine (67,70),palm sap (21, must 11061
Wine (671, sake (141). beer
Candida rugoso
Condensed milk (140), refined sugar (1281.dried fruits (731, candies (129) Concentrated {uices (1901 -
Molasses (92)
-
Bread (119)
-
-
1881
Condida sake
Strawberries (151,figs (94). corn (34)
Soft drinks (96,111,1121
Wine (34,67,70), winery (11.311. must (931, beer (4)
Sugar cane (1)
-
Condida stelloto
Grapes (33,50), figs 11371, apples 1101. fruits (122,123,137) Corn (16). rice (137). tropical fruits (100)
Soft drinks 174,961
Must (491, wine (44,54,55, 63.67.70.79)
Molasses (92)
-
Wine (34,671. beer (88). palm sap (21, baker’s yeast 146)
Molasses (921, raw sugar (137)
Condida tropicolis
Fruit juices (7.10,ll. 96,125)
Shellfish (14)
Shellfish (141, beef (321 Beef (611, poultry 1591, sausage (18,19,71], fish (28.1031, shellfish (20,651 Beef (32). poultry (59). sausage (71)
Cheese (139)
Brine (42). salad dressing (96)
Dairy products (1271
Brine (121, olives (1371, salads (64) Olives (48)
-
Cheese (38)
Cheese (115,124). yoghurt (5.511, butter (1401
Shellfish (14). beef (32,611
-
Shellfish (141, beef (23)
-
Pickles (241, brine (87,1401, tape 1301, cocoa (fermented) (101).salads (17,64,107) Pickles (351, olives (48)
Cocoa (fermented) (1011, fermented food (113,134). salads (64) Cocoa (fermented) (1011
Grains (120). dough (1091
Shellfish (14) beef (23). fish 1591
Cheese (38,139)
Fermented fish (107). idli (134). brine
(continued )
TABLE I (Continued) Species
Fresh fruits and vegetables
Nonalcoholic beverages
Alcoholic beverages
Condido versotilis
Corn (35)
Soft drinks l132), apple juice (10)
Wine (67.70)
Condida vini
Fruits (122,123)
Soft drinks (84)
Condido zeylonoides
Grapes (341, fruits
Wine (34,67,70, 78,136), winery (80). beer (531, baker’s yeast (461 Wine (3467.78)
-
High-sugar products
Grains and cereal products
Raw sugar (1371, concentrated juice (128) Molasses (92)
-
Beef (23,32,57)
-
Beef (32)
Flour ( 1 2 0 )
(122,123)
Citeromyces motritensis
Cryptococcus olbidus
Wine (141)
Corn (35). wheat (68). fruits (10,15,33,34), tropical fruits
Soft drinks (132)
Wine (67)
-
Molasses (92). refined sugar (128) -
Meat. fish, and shellfish
Grains and flour (120)
Beef (23,32,57,61), sausage (32). lamb (72). meat (5).fish (65.103) Beef (23). shellfish, (14)
Dairy products
Fermented and preserved foods
Cheese (127), yoghurt (126)
Soy sauce (87), brine (42)
-
Salads (9)
Dairy products (127)
Cocoa [fermented) (1011
Dairy products (127)
Olives (48)
-
Beef (23.32.61), sausage (711, seafood (59,65,103)
Soy sauce (87). salads (64)
(1001
Cryptococcus humicolus
Cryptococcus lourentii
Grapes (93). apples (101, tropical fruits (1001 Corn (35,76), strawberries (151, grapes 150)
Soft drinks (111) Wine (141)
-
-
Beef (23.32). seafood (65)
Dairy products (51
Cocoa (fermented) (1011
__
Must (491, wine (671, winery (11)
-
Grains (68.120)
Beef (32,57,61), lamb (72). seafood (65)
Cottage cheese (13). dairy products (5)
Salads (64)
Debammyces hansenii
Corn (35). Fruit juices grapes (50). (10,37,96,125) fruits (33,1291, tropical fruits (62,100)
Debammyces polymorphus Dekkero onomnla
Grapes (67)
Must (67.106), wine (34,701, beer 141, winery (11,341, baker's yeast (46)
Molasses (92). raw sugar (1,128), jam (60.129), syrups (22). confections (90)
Bread (3)
Beef (32,57,61), Milk (39). sausage YOghUfi (18,19.32,137), (126,127), ham (21). fish cheese (27,28,103.137), (40.44.45. shellfish 89,114,124, 127) (14.20)
Wine (70) Beer (4.53.961, Iambic beer
Dried fruit (73)
Dough (61
Sausage (71)
-
Cider (10) Soft drinks (58.96)
-
Soft drinks (96)
Beer (4,531, wine (67,701, Iambic (1351, must (93) Wine (34,671. beer (88)
Salad dressing (17). olives (48). brine (42), idli (1341, dosa (118). cocoa (fermented) (1011
-
-
-
-
-
-
Brine (12) -
(1351
Dekkero intermedia
Endomyces fibuliger
Tropical fruits
-
(100)
-
Dough (1091, bread (119)
L (D (D
Geeotrichum candidum
Corn (35). grape rot (521, tomato rot
Honseniaspom occidentalis
Apples (10). grapes (64)
Honseniaspom osmophila
Grapes (93)
Hanseniosporn uvarum
Grapes Fruit juice (33,54,75,102), (37,125,137), sofi fruits cider (10). (15,50,122,123), drinks (37) figs (69), oranges (133)
-
-
Fruit juice (105), palm sap (2)
-
WI Winery (31). Concentrated must (671, juice (137). wine (70) raisins (34) Apple juice (10) Must (49,637.93). wine (70) Must (49,63,106), wine (44,45,70, 1361, winery (31). beer (4,531
Dried figs (137)
-
-
Sausage (18.191, ham (21)
-
Cheese (38,40391, milk (391, yoghurt (137) -
Cocoa (fermented) (1011, fermented food (30,107) Cocoa (fermented) (1011 Cocoa (fermented) (1011 Cocoa (fermented) (1011 Cocoa (fermented) (101)
(continued )
TABLE I (Continued) Species Hyphopichia burtonii
Fresh fruits and vegetables Dates (108)
Nonalcoholic beverages Soft drinks (37) fruit juice
Alcoholic beverages Must (67)
High-sugar products
Grains and cereal products
Meat, fish, and shellfish
-
Grains (68). flour (120). bread
Ham (211, beef (23). seafood
11191
112.51
lssotchenkio orientolis
Corn (161, Soft drinks (84,111), fruit grapes (33.50). fruits juice (10,125) (122.123).
Issatchenkia terricolo
tropical fruits (100.137.138) Apricot (34)
Mango juice (1251
Kluyveromyces Ioctis
Figs (94)
Kluyveromyces marxianus
Fruits (122,123) Soft drinks (84) apple juice
Must (49,671, Molasses (92). wine (70,811, dried figs winery (31). (137) beer (88). baker's yeast (461 Must (49), winery (31) Sherry (67) Sugar cane (1)
Dough (121)
(651
Shellfish (14), poultry (591
-
Sausage (19)
-
Beef (23)
0 0
(961
Kluyveromyces thermotolernns
Grapes (64)
Lodderomyces elongisporus
Grapes (93)
Fruit juice
Molasses (92). sugar cane (1,8),dried figs (137)
Wine (67.70)
Raw sugar (1371, marzipan (128). raisins
(10.96)
1129)
Metschnikowia pulcherrima
Grapes (75,1021 fruits (10,33,62.122. 123).corn (35)
Soft drinks (96.1 11,112) Cider (10).
mango juice (125)
Concentrated juices (137) Wine (54,55,70), Raisins (34) winery (311, must (67) Must (141)
Fermented and preserved foods
Dairy products (127).cheese (25,139)
Fermented fish (1071, SOY sauce (871, tape (301, silage (82) Cocoa (fermented) (10,101), brine (34,42,137), idli (134)
Yoghurt (51). cheese (139)
-
N
Must (1061, wine (671, beer (4,881
Dairy products
-
-
Shellfish (14). beef (23)
Sausage (19)
Fermented food (1131
Yoghurt (126). cheese (25,114,124). cream (137) Cocoa Kefir (25,41), (fermented) yoghurt (511. cheese (1101 (25,38,40, 45,114,131) Cheese (25)
-
-
Pichio anomolo
Corn (16.35). Fruit juice grapes (33,341, (37.105). soft fruits drinks (10,100,122, (111.112)
Wine (34.54.67, 70.78), winery (311,beer (53,961
Dried fruits (731,
Grains (68).flour (1201
molasses
Poultry (59,137). sausage (71). shellfish (14)
Cheese (127). yoghurt (127)
(92).
confections
123)
1129)
Pichio conodensis
Must (67). wine (70)
Pichio etchellsii
-
Pichio farinoso
Figs (94). apples
FNit juice (37)
-
(10)
Concentrated juices (137)
Wine (34,67). palm sap (2) Wine (34,671, palm sap (2)
Grains (120)
-
-
-
Flour (68)
Beef (32) -
Olives (12,481, tape (30). idli (134). pickles (24). cocoa (fermented) (101).soy sauce (87) Pickles (24). silage (82). tape (30) Olives (48) Soy sauce (871, cocoa (fermented) (1011
Pichia fermentons
Oranges (1331,
Soft drinks (96,1301, apple juice (10)
N
s
Pichia guilliermondii
Pichia jadinii
Pichia membmnoefaciens
Corn (351, figs (137), fruits (1OSO) -
Grapes (33.75.93).
fruits (34,69,94,137),
corn (16)
Must (67). wine (34.70.78), beer (53)
Wine (67,70), palm sap (2). beer (88) (111,112,130) Apple juice (10) Must (67). wine (34,701, beer (4,53). baker’s yeast (46) FNit juices Must (67.93), (96,111,112, wine (31.34.70, 125) 781, beer (4,53). cider Fruit juices (37). soft drinks
Raisins (34). molasses (92). raw sugar (137) Refined sugar
Wheat (68)
-
(128)
Beef (571, shellfish (14)
Cheese (89). milk (131)
(641
Sausage (711, seafood (65), shellfish (14)
Concentrated juices (128)
Dairy products
Pickles (34), brine (n), olives (48) Pickles (34)
1127)
Cane sugar (1). Bread (119). flour molasses (120) (92). raisins
Fish (59,103). beef (32)
Cheese (40.89)
Salads (13,961, olives (48). brine (12). cocoa (fermented]
Cheese (131)
Brine (12,137)
Dairy products
Tape (30), brine
(341
(101
Palm sap (2). must (49,67)
Pichio ohmeri
Cocoa (fermented) (101)salads
(1011
Raw sugar (1371.
confections 11291
Pichio subpelliculoso
Apples (10)
Winery (11). must (67,101)
Raw sugar (1371, dried fruits (73)
Dough (6)
-
(127)
(42,137) ~
(continued)
TABLE I (Continued) Species
Fresh fruits and vegetables
Nonalcoholic beverages
Rhodosporidium infirmominiatum
Corn (35)
Rhodotomla glutinis
Grapes (75.93) Orange juice 171 hits (10.15,33,100). corn (35)
Rhodotomlo minuta
Grapes (67,931
Apple juice (10)
Rhodotomlo mucilaginosa
Corn (35,761,
Orange juice (7)
-
Alcoholic beverages
High-sugar products
Grains and cereal products
Winery (11)
-
-
Palm sap (21, must (67,106), winery 111,311,wine (701.beer (4). baker's yeast (461
-
Wheat (681,flour (120)
-
-
Wine (34.67,70). winery (11,311, baker's yeast (46)
-
-
Must (36,641. wine (43)
-
nks
Must and wine (34,54,55, 63,74,79, 93.106.136). palm sap (21, sake (66).beer 188.1041
N
0
N
fruits (10,15,96,100]
Sacchammyces bayonus
Grapes (36.64)
Sacchammyces cerevisiae
Grapes (31,3334, 64,751, tropical fruits (100,137)
soft
(47,971
-
Honey (95). Dough (6,1091, raisins (1291, bread (119). confections flour(120) (90).apple concentrate (34)
Meat, fish, and shellfish
Dairy products
Fermented and preserved foods
Beef (23.61). lamb (72). seafood (65) Beef Milk (1241, (23,32,57,61), cheese (38). fish Yo&& (1261 (5,27.59,103), poultry (137). seafood (5665)
Salads (64)
Beef Dairy products (23.32.57.61). (1271 sausage (8.71). fish (103). poultry (591 Sausage (18.71) Cheese (131: fish (27.59.103). meat (23.32,57). shellfish (56,65)
Olives (48). salads (64)
-
Poultry (59). shellfish ( 2 0 )
Olives (48). salads (64)
Salads (64). salad dressing 1171
Cocoa (fermented] (101) Cheese (25,1241, Cocoa kefir (41). (fermented) YOghUrt (101.110). fermented fish (51,126) (1071,dosa (1181,olives (48.137),salad dressing (17) -
Soacchammyces exiguus
Cherries (96)
Softdrinks (111)
Must and wine
Molasses (128)
Bread (119). dough (86,109)
Poultry (59,1371, shellfish (14), beef (23)
-
-
-
(67.70.741. beer (4,88,96)
Kefir (41)
Cocoa (fermented) (101), idli (134). brine (42). salads 19.13)
Soacchammyces kluyveri
Grapes (34)
Soft drinks
Sacchammycodes ludwigii
Grapes (50)
Apple juice (10)
Wine (34.67,70)
Olives (12)
(112,130)
Must (49,124), wine (55,67,70,80),
cider (101, palm sap (21. beer (41 Must (67)
Schizosocchmmyces octosporus
Candies (1371, honey (95). molasses
Filled bakery goods (116)
(1291 N 0
Schizosacchoromyces pombe
Grapes (36.75)
Must (36.124), wine (67), palm =P (21
Raisins (341, cane juice
Filled bakery goods (116)
-
(1371.
Cocoa (fermented) (1011
molasses Spombolomyces roseus
Rice (15,851, corn (76). fruits
ToNlaspom delbrueckii
Grapes (50,671, apple (10,961
Wine (141)
(92.129) -
-
Sausage (71)
Cheese (13)
-
(10,15,33,100)
Trichospomn cutaneum
Grapes (341, apples (101, oranges (137)
Soft drinks (111.112)
Must (74.106). wine
Orange concentrate
l54,70,831,
(601,
winery (11,341
molasses (92.95). raw sugar (137). honey (95). raisins (129)
Must (67). baker's yeast 1461
-
Bread (3,119)
-
Cheese (25,139)
Cocoa (fermented) (101).brine 142)
-
Sausage ~18.19.211, beef (23). fish 1591
Milk (39)
Cocoa (fermented) (101). dosa (118),salads (641, dressing 1171
(continued )
TABLE I (Continued) Species Trichosporon pullulons
Fresh fruits and vegetables Fruits (10,341
Nonalcoholic beverages Mango juice (1251
Alcoholic beverages Winery (311, must (67)
High-sugar products -
Grains and cereal products Grain and flour (1201
Meat, fish, and shellfish
Dairy products
Beef (32.57.61). ham
__
l21.23.711. lamb (72).fish
(1011.
(14.20.65)
-
Yorrowio lipolytica
Strawberries
N
0
Zygosocchoromyces boilii
&
Molasses (92)
-
-
-
-
-
(111,112)
(961
Zygooscus hellenicus
Soft drinks
Winery (31). wine (67) Wine (67)
Grape rot (52) Grapes (33.67). fruits (10.34)
Soft drinks (140) Must (49,671, Soft drinks (97,111)* fruit juices (61.96)
wine (141) Must (74).wine (34.67.70, 77,78,79.136), palm sap (2)
Fruit concentrate
Bread (119)
Beef (23.32)
-
Dairy products
(1271 Beef (5,32.57.61), Milk (124). sausage (71). cheese seafood (65) (5.13.25.40) Beef (57). shellfish (14)
-
Cocoa (fermented) fermented food (113). idli (1341, salads (64)
(28).shellfish
Wickerhamiella domercqioe
Fermented and preserved foods
-
Salads (64,961, mayonnaise (831
-
Salad dressing (96.1171.
(34,67,128),
pickles (42.1371.
dried fruits l137), molasses
cocoa (fermented) (~OI), salads
(921
19)
Zygosocchoromyces bisporus
Grapes (67). apples (10)
Soft drinks
Wine (70)
(111,112)
lam (961. syrups (22). raw sugar
Filled bakery goods (116)
(101)
(1371.
molasses (129).fruit concentrate Zygosocchoromyces fermentati Zygosacchoromyces microellipsoides
Grapes (64)
Soft drinks
Must (106)
(1281 -
-
(96,111,112) -
Soft drinks (84,111,112, 130).fruit juices (96)
Must (67).wine (1411
Molasses (92)
Cocoa (fermented)
Flour (68)
Zygosocchommyces rouxii
Grapes (34)
-
Wine (34,671
Syrups (22,26,60,
1371, molasses (92,129). raisins (1291, marzipan
Filled bakery goods (116)
Beef (23)
-
Cocoa (fermented) (101). fermented fish (107), SOY sauce (871, brine (42)
(60).
confections (901
Numbers in parenetheses are references: (1)Andersonet al. (1988); (2)Atputharajah et al. (1986); (3)Azar et al. (1977);(4) Back (1987); (5) Banks and Board (1987);(6) Barber et al. (1983);(7) Barreiro et al. (1981); (8)Barwald and Hamad (1984); (9) Baumgart (1982);(10) Beech and Carr (1977); (11)Belin (1979);(12) Brackett (1987);(13) Brocklehurst and Lund (1985); (14) Buck et al. (1977); (15) Buhagiar and Barnett (1971);(16) Burmeister and Hartman (1966); (17) Cantoni and Comi (1988); (18) Comi and Cantani (1980a); (19) Comi and Cantoni (1980b); (20) Comi and Cantoni ( 1 9 8 0 ~ )(21) ; Cami and Cantoni (1983);(22) Comi and Cantoni (1984);(23) Comi and Cantoni (1985); (24) Comi et al. (1981a); (25) Comi et al. (1981b);(26) Comi et al. (1982); (27) Comi et al. (1984);(28) Comi et al. (1983); (29) Crisan and Sands (1975); N
cn
(30) Cmnket 01. (1977); (31) Cuinier (1980); (32) Dalton et al. (1984);(33) Davenport (1976); (34)Dehk (1988);(35) Deakand Beuchat (1988);(36) Delfini (1985); (37) Dragoni and Comi (1985); (38) El-Bassiony et al. (1980);(39) Engel (1986a); (40) Engel (1986b); (41) Engel et al. (1986); (42) Etchells et al. (1975);(43) Farris and Ruggin (1985); (44) Fleet et al. (1984); (45) Fleet and Mian (1987); (46) Fowell(l965);(47) Gardini and Guerzoni (1986);(48) Garrida Fernandez et al. (1985); (49) Goto (1980);(50) Goto and Yokotsuka (1977);(51) Green and Ibe (1987); (52) Guerzoni and Marchetti (1987);(53) Hardwick (1983); (54) Heard and Fleet (1986a); (55)Heard and Fleet (1986b); (56) Hood (1983); (57) Hsieh and Jay (1984); ( 5 8 )Ison and Gutteridge (1987);(59) Jay (1987); (60)Jermini et al. (1987); (61) Johamsen et al. (1984); (62)Juven et al. (1984); (63) Khayyat et 01. (1982); (64) Kobatake and Kurata (1980b); (65) Kobatake and Kurata (1980a);(66) Kodama and Yoshizawa (1977); (67) Kunkee and Goswell (1977); (68) Kurtzman et al. (1970); (69) Lachaise (1977); (70) Lafon-Lafourcade (1983); (71) Leistner and Bem (1970); (72) Lowry and Gill (1984); (73) Madan and Gulati (1980); (74) Mauricio et al. (1986);(75) Messini et al. (1985);(76)Middelhoven and van Baalen (1988); (77) Mindrik (1980); (78) Mintirik (1981);(79) Mintirik (1983); (80)Mindrik and Navara (1977);(81)Moline (1984);(82) Moon and Ely (1979);(83) Muys (1971); (84) Muzikar (1984); (85)Nakase and Suzuki (1985); (86) Ng (1976);(87) Noda et al. (1982); (88)Novellie and de Schaepdrijver (1986);(89) Nunez et al. (1981); (90).OrszAghova and Kieslingerovd (1984); (92) Parfait and Sabin (1975);(93) Parish and Carol1 (1985);(94)Pignal et al. (1985);(95) Poncini and Wimmer (1986); (96) Put et al. (1976); (97) Put and De Jong (1982b); (100) Rale and Vakil(1984);(101)Ravelomanana et 01. (1985); (102)Rosini et al. (1982);(103) Ross and Morris (1965); (104) Rbcken (1983); (105) Rockenet 01. (1981); (106) Ruizet al. (1986); (107)Sakai et al. (1983);(108) Saliket al. (1979); (109) Salovaara and Savolainen (1984); (110) Sanchez et al. (1984); (111)Sand (1974); (112) Sand et al. (1976); (113) Sandhu and Waraich (1984);(113a) Sand and van Grinsven (1976b);(114) Schmidt and Lenoir (1980); (115) Seham et al. (1982); (116) Seiler (1980); (117) Smittle and Flowers (1982); (118) Soni et al. (1986); (119) Spicher (1986); (120) Spicher and Mellenthin (1983); (121) Spicher et al. (1979); (122) Stallarovd (1976); (123) Stollarovh (1982); (124) Suarez and Inigo (1982); (125) Suresh et al. (1982); (126) Suriyarachchi and Fleet (1981);(127) Tilbury et 01. (1974); (128) Tilbury (1976);(129) Tokouka et al. (1985); (130) Torok and Deik (1974);(131) Tzanetakis et al. (1987); (132) Uchida et al. (1980); (133) Vacek et al. (1979);(134) Venkatasubbaiah et 01. (1985);(135) Verachtert and Dawoud (1984); (136) Vojtekovi and Minirik (1985); (137) Walker and Ayres (1970); (138) Warnasuriya et 01. (1985); (139) Zein et 01. (1983);(140)Kreger-van Rij (1984); (141) Barnett et 01. (1983).
206
T.DEAK
groups were common to all stages of apple and grape development and these could be considered as resident microorganisms. These possess characteristics that enable them to survive and reproduce on the plant habitats. The main resident species on apple are H. uvarum, Metschnikowia pulcherrima, D. hansenii, Sporobolomyces roseus, and Cryptococcus albidus. Yeast phases of Aureobasidium pullulans and Cladosporium herbarum (black yeasts) are also permanent members of the microflora. Mature and sound grapes harbor most frequently M. pulcherrima, H. uvarum, Candida stellata, D. hansenii, Rhodotorula glutinis, P. membranaefaciens, 1. orientalis, P. anomala, S. cerevisiae, and Z . bailii. In contrast to the resident organisms, a large number of various species may become transient members of the microflora. Their occurrence depends mostly on dissemination by animal vectors and they can survive if conditions are favorable. About 20 to 30 species have been reported as transients from apples and grapes [Davenport, 1976). Extensive research has been conducted on the distribution of yeasts on grapes (Davenport, 1974; Goto and Yokotsuka, 1977; Rosini et al., 1982; Messini et al., 1985). The flora consists of both fermentative and oxidative species, represented by H. uvarum and M. pulcherrima, respectively. Although a number of other yeasts can also be found on the skin of the grapes (e.g., C. albidus, R. glutinis, D. hansenii, C. stellata, and P. membranaefaciens), S. cerevisiae is not among the main resident organisms and its population increases only after the grapes begin to mature. Studies of grape yeasts have been mostly conducted in connection with the fermentation of must, and will be considered further in a discussion of wine yeasts. Detailed investigations on the frequency and dominance of natural yeast species on various fruits grown in temperate zones (cherries, red and white currants, and plums) showed that H. uvarum, M. pulcherrima, and Candida vini formed the permanent and ubiquitous cornponent of the associations. Additionally, s. cerevisiae, P. anomala, K. marxianus, C. stellata, I. orientalis, and Candida zeylanoides were found frequently (StollarovB, 1976, 1982). Strawberries appeared to differ from other fruits in the predominance of cryptococci. Buhagiar and Barnett (1971) found C. albidus (45Y0), Cryptococcus laurentii (32%), and Cryptoccus macerans (7%) among the yeast isolates from sound strawberries, with Candida fragariorum, H. uvarum, and R. glutinis (2-4% each) and five other species in the minority. The dominant species, i.e., Hanseniaspora guilliermondii, M. pulcherrima, and D. hansenii, from a Mediterranean fruit, pomegranate, were similar to those found on fruits of temperate zones (Juven et al., 1984). Tropical fruits (pineapple, banana, kiwi, papaya, etc.) harbored a
FOODBORNE YEASTS
207
mixed yeast flora consisting of P. anomala, Pichia guilliermondii, Pichia sydowiorum, T. delbrueckii, Candida versatilis, and Candida apicola as well as species commonly found on other fruits, S. cerevisiae, H. guilliermondii, R. glutinis, and C. albidus (Tokouka et al., 1985; Rale and Vakil, 1984; Warnasuriya et al., 1985). Lachaise (1977) found in figs a specialized yeast, Candida fructus, but the fermentative spoilage was caused by P. guilliermondii, P. membranaefaciens, Hanseniaspora valbyensis, H. uvarum, Candida sorboxylosa, C. stellata, and I. orientalis. Pignal et al. (1985) showed an intimate interaction between the yeast flora of figs and the fruit-inhabiting drosophilas. Common species were H. valbyensis, P. membranaefaciens, Endomycopsella vini, Candida pseudointermedia, and others. Spoilage of fresh fruits usually results from the fermentative activity of yeasts; nevertheless, a wide variety of poorly or nonfermenting yeasts have been described from rotting oranges, mangos, and dates (Vacek et al., 1979; Salik et al., 1979; Suresh et al., 1982). Species such as M. pulcherrima, D. hansenii, I. orientalis, Hyphopichia burtonii, Trichosporum cutaneum, and others were frequent; however, the fermentation was brought about by H. uvarum or H. valbyensis, P. guilliermondii, Pichia fermentans, Pichia kluyveri, and to a lesser extent S. cerevisiae. Yeasts are also normal colonizers of vegetables, although the predominant microorganisms on healthy, fresh vegetables are usually bacteria. Yeast activity becomes apparent when circumstances become favorable to them, e.g., during the lactic acid fermentation of vegetables (see later). Yeast populations on vegetables range from less than lo3 up to and above lo6 per gram. Basidiomycetous yeasts usually dominate the population; among them several new species have been described, e.g., Bullera crocea and Bullera armeniaca on cauliflower and cabbage (Buhagiar et al., 1983). Fresh corn was mainly inhabited by Rhodotorula ingeniosa, C. laurentii, S. roseus, Sporidiobolus salmonicolor, and R. rubra (Middelhoven and van Baalen, 1988). Besides the predominating basidiomycetous yeasts (R. rubra, R. glutinis, C. albidus, and C. laurentii) Deak and Beuchat (1988) also found a range of fermenting ascomycetous yeasts on sweet corn, although they were present as a minority in the population (H. uvarum, C. intermedia, Candida oleophila, P. guilliermondii, and 10 other species). In agreement with the preceding findings, Nakase and Suzuki (1985) found ballistospore-forming basidiomycetous yeasts in 86% of all yeasts on leaves and stems of the rice plant. Sporobolomyces roseus, B. crocea, and Bullera alba were the most frequent, with some Bullera strains
208
T. DEAK
probably representing yet undescribed species. Although the yeasts, with few exceptions, are not capable of attacking plant tissues, certain yeasts have been associated with decay of fruits and vegetables. Best known is the role of Geotrichum candidum in causing sour rot in tomato (Moline, 1984), but certain other yeasts (H. uvarum, C. stellata, I. orientalis, and E. vini) have been associated with sour rot disease of grapes (Guerzoni and Marchetti, 1987). It should be warned that fresh fruits and vegetables may transmit human pathogenic yeasts. Of 254 vegetable and 186 fruit samples from markets in Delhi, 5 contained Cryptococcus neoformans (Pal and Mehrotra, 1985). Candida albicans (as its synonym Candida stellatoidea) has been reported on grapes (Parish and Caroll, 1985).
B. FRUITJUICES AND SOFTDRINKS Microbiological spoilage of nonalcoholic beverages is mostly due to yeasts. This is because soft drinks meet the growth requirements of yeasts while providing an unsatisfactory ecological niche for most other microorganisms (Berry, 1979; Deak, 1980). Yeast growth shows up as sediment, haze, deposit, and off-taste. If fermentation occurs, it may result in blowing up of cans or exploding of bottles. The cause of spoilage can rarely be ascribed to fruit juice concentrates or syrups and other ingredients, but more often it is found in the processing line itself. Critical foci of contamination are the proportioning pumps, holding tanks, and bottle washers (Sand et al., 1976). Based on 3600 samples collected during a 4-year period, Sand (1974) established a relationship between the keeping quality of soft drinks and contamination of the processing equipment. Yeasts occurring most frequently in line samples were also found in bottled beverages. Candida species boidinii, intermedia, sake, apicola, and parapsilosis and P. anomala and Yarrowia lipolytica were isolated in high frequency from raw materials. Torulaspora delbrueckii, consistently occurred on equipment and raw materials but was rarely encountered in bottled beverages. Spoilage was caused most frequently by S. cerevisiae, which originated mainly from materials used for beverages. Sand and van Grinsven (1976a,b) made a comprehensive study of bottled beverages produced in various countries. They isolated some 30 species; the most frequent isolates were S. cerevisiae, Z. bailii, Z. bisporus, Zygosaccharomyces florentinus, Zygosaccharoromyces fermentati, Zygosaccharomyces microellipsoideus, C. stellata, C. parapsilosis, Brettanomyces naardensis, Dekkera intermedia, and P. anomala. Torok and Deak (1974) isolated, in decreasing order of their frequencies, S.
FOODBORNE YEASTS
209
cerevisiae, P. fermentans, Candida lambica, and Saccharomyces kluyveri from Hungarian soft drinks. Zygosaccharomyces rouxii, Z. microellipsoideus, and P. guilliermondii were represented by single isolates. Muzikar (1984),summarizing results of many years of study of nonalcoholic beverages, also stated that the most frequent yeasts found were T. delbrueckii, Z. microellipsoideus, D. hansenii, Candida inconspicua, C. vini, and I. orientalis. Dragoni and Comi (1985)reported that 40% of natural juices made from peaches, pears, and apricots was contaminated by yeasts, most frequently by H. uvarum, D. hansenii, Candida haemulonii, P. guilliermondii, and Pichia etchellsii, whereas P. anomala, H. burtonii, T. delbrueckii, Z. rouxii, Z. bisporus, and Z. bailii occurred occasionally. By combining the addition of preservatives and a mild heat treatment (pasteurization), the storage life of soft drinks can be greatly increased. The necessary heat treatment can be based on the heat resistance of the spoilage yeasts. This topic has been intensively studied by Put et al. (1976) and was discussed earlier in this review. The spoilage potential has been evaluated in model fruit drink systems (Gardini and Guerzoni, 1986; Cole et al., 1987; Ison and Gutteridge, 1987) and from these studies it can be concluded that the most notorious spoilage organisms in nonalcoholic beverages are S . cerevisiae, D. anomala, and Z. bailii for their high resistance to pH, COz pressure, preservatives, and heat. C. ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES Production and consumption of alcoholic beverages have continuously aroused the interest of human beings since the earliest times. A tremendous variety of these drinks has evolved and yeasts are the principal contributors in the production of each of them. The most important beverages are, also from an economic viewpoint, wine, beer, and distilled spirits (Rose, 1977). 1. Wine
Wine microbiology has been the subject of a large number of studies. Much interest has been focused on the composition and succession of yeast flora on ripening grapes, in the course of fermenting must, in the bottled wine, and also in and around the winery and wine cellars. Several reviews have appeared on these topics (Kunkee and Goswell, 1977;Lafon-Lafourcade,1983;Goswell, 1986b).A list of yeasts found on grapes, in must, in wines, and on winery equipment has been compiled by Kunkee and Amerine (1970)and was revised and updated by Kunkee and Goswell (1977) and Lafon-Lafourcade (1983).
210
T. DEAK
After crushing, grapes contain a large number of yeasts. Numerous studies on the growth of yeasts during wine fermentation have shown that the early to middle stages of must fermentation are dominated by a mixed flora of non-Saccharomyces yeasts indigenous to grapes, such as H. uvarum, C. stellata, 1. orientalis, M. pulcherrima, and P. anomala (Davenport, 1974; Rosini et al., 1982; Fleet et al., 1984; Parish and Caroll, 1985; Heard and Fleet, 1986a). The yeast flora follows a definite succession during fermentation, which can be characterized by one or more dominating species. The determining factor in the composition of the yeast flora is the increase of alcohol concentration after the onset of fermentation. Hanseniaspora uvarum predominates in early stages of must fermentation in Middle European and California wineries, whereas other apiculate yeasts, such as Hanseniaspora osmophila, are commonly found in early must from grapes of warmer regions, e.g., Spain, Southern Italy, Israel, and the southeastern United States (Parish and Caroll, 1985). In Japan, H. uvarum also represents the major yeast in must, making up 40 to 72% of the population. Candida stellata is also widely distributed (13 to 19%). Metschnikowia pulcherrima, reported as a major yeast in musts in Europe, was isolated in small numbers only (Goto and Yokotsuka, 1977). Addition of sulfur dioxide brings about a rapid decrease in total counts of yeasts and a reduction in wild yeast species. Saccharomycodes ludwigii was, however, isolated in high frequencies from sulfited must (Minarik and Navara, 1977; Goto, 1980). Saccharomyces cerevisiae rarely occurs in large numbers in early must. Its main sources are the surfaces of various winery equipment rather than grapes (Belin, 1979; Cuinier, 1980; Rosini et al., 1982).As the fermentation progresses, wild yeasts die off due to their sensitivity to ethanol at concentrations of 2-6% (v/v), but S. cerevisiae proliferates and completes the fermentation (Fleet et al., 1984). This general picture does not change much even if starter strains of S. cerevisiae have been inoculated (Heard and Fleet, 1985). However, as the temperature of fermentation increases above 25OC, S. exiguus and Z . bailii become dominating (Mauricio et al., 1986), and if the temperature decreases to 10°C, the growth and survival of non-Saccharomyces yeasts may greatly increase (Heard and Fleet, 1988). Studies carried out in different part of the world on the natural succession of species during fermentation revealed the same general pattern; however, minor differences can be noted (Ethiraj et al., 1979; Vojtekovti and Mintirik, 1985; Ruiz et al., 1986; Heard and Fleet, 1986a). After the completion of fermentation, any further yeast activity is harmful to the quality of wine. The majority of yeasts are removed from
FOODBORNE YEASTS
211
wine by racking, filtration, and other cellar procedures. If the wine is kept in bulk, spoilage may be caused by Dekkera species and S. ludwigii; both impact the flavor of the wine (Goswell, 1986b).The major spoilage yeasts in wine stored in tanks or barrels are film-forming species such as C. vini, C. zeylanoides, Candida rugosa, 1. orientalis, and P. membranaefaciens (Minarik, 1981). It is to be noted that a special type of wine (sherry) can be produced if the wine is kept under a film of yeast that is composed of special biotypes of S. cerevisiae (Farris and Ruggin, 1985; Sancho et al., 1986; Goswell, 1986a). In the bottle, even a very moderate growth of yeast is unacceptable because it results in clouds, deposits, and poor flavor. Production lines are usually contaminated by various yeasts that can get into the bottled wine. In addition to Z. bailii, frequent spoilage yeasts in bottled wine are S. cerevisiae, C. rugosa, P. membranaefaciens, C. vini, and others (Minarik et al., 1983). Many studies have been carried out to determine the spoilage potential of these yeasts and to assess the maximum acceptable number of yeast cells in wine. The main inhibitory factor to yeast growth is ethanol content. Wild and wine yeasts are usually inhibited at 12% ethanol, but Z. bailii is more tolerant. Moreover, it shows a pronounced resistance to food preservatives (Thomas and Davenport, 1985). Zygosaccharomyces bailii contamination originates partly from habitats in the winery (Minarik, 1983), but mainly from concentrated grape juice used in wine production (MinBrikand Hanicovh, 1982). This species can be considered the main causative agent of serious spoilage of bottled wine (Minarik, 1980).It has been demonstrated that only a few viable cells in a bottle of wine may be sufficient to cause spoilage (Deak, 1986b). 2. Beer
The two main types of beer, lager and ale, are fermented with different strains of yeasts that have traditionally been considered separate species of Saccharomyces, uvarum (S. carlsbergensis) and cerevisiae, respectively. The two types can be distinguished by physiological differences. Lager yeast is a bottom fermentor and has the ability to produce an extracellular enzyme, a-galactosidase, with which it ferments the disaccharide melibiose and the trisaccharide raffinose. The top-fermenting S. cerevisiae is unable to ferment melibiose; only the fructose part of the raffinose molecule is fermented after splitting by invertase. In addition, lager strains tend to flocculate and settle at the bottom of the fermenter and top-fermenting strains are less flocculant. Though the latter are able to ferment at higher temperatures (up to 37-38"C), the lager yeasts exhibit a maximum of 34°C (Stewart, 1987).
212
T. DEAK
Though these differences are straightforward regarding the industrially used brewing strains, there is a problem classifying them on the basis of minor and inconsistent physiological differences as contrasted with the high degree of DNA relatedness. Based on DNA homology, taxonomists have lumped a number of former Saccharomyces species into one, S. cerevisiae (Kreger-van Rij, 1984). Recently, however, redetermining DNA relatedness, Vaughan-Martini and Martini (1987) reestablished the species Saccharomyces bayanus and suggested that Saccharomyces pastorianus (S. uvarum, S. carlsbergensis) may represent a natural hybrid between this and S. cerevisiae. Owing to its low pH (about 4.0),the boiling of wort, and the addition of hops, beer is an inhospitable medium for most bacteria, and only some lactic acid bacteria and wild yeasts can grow in it. Wild yeasts produce turbidity and flavor defects. One of the most obnoxious wild yeast contaminants is Saccharomyces diastaticus (now considered as a biotype of S. cerevisiae), which can ferment the dextrins of beer and produce an off-odor as well. Postcontamination of beer rarely causes serious problems; contamination of pitching yeast is, however, a great risk, and wild yeasts at this stage are less readily distinguishable. A number of methods suitable for identification of such infecting organisms have been developed, and these will be mentioned later. Wild yeasts can be divided into two groups: Saccharomyces and non-Saccharomyces. Of 120 strains of wild yeasts, Back (1987) identified 18 species other than Saccharomyces, and two Saccharomyces species other than S. pastorianus. The latter were S. exiguus and S. cerevisiae (nonbrewing strains, previously called S. bayanus, S. chevalieri, S. ellipsoideus, and S. diastaticus). The most frequent other yeast species were P. anomala, P. membranaefaciens, D. hansenii, C. sake, R. glutinis, and Dekkera claussenii. Ale and lager beer are not only made by different strains of brewery yeasts, but also differ in wild yeast contamination. In top fermentation, the most frequent wild yeasts are Pichia media, C. vini, and Candida ishiwadae; the bottom-fermenting strains are S. cerevisiae (Rocken and Marg, 1983). The commonest procedure for preservation of beer is heat pasteurization. Canned and bottled beers are pasteurized at about 60°C, for a time sufficient to destroy vegetative bacteria and yeasts. In draft beer sold in vats or barrels unpasteurized, a broader variety of wild yeasts may develop and cause problems if the beer is not kept cold enough. The majority of spoilage yeasts are Saccharomyces species, and only 20-30% of wild yeasts are members of other genera, such as Dekkera lintermedia, anomala, claussenii, and lambica), Candida (inconspicua and vini), Pichia (fermentans, membranaefaciens, jadinii, and
FOODBORNE YEASTS
213
anomala), H. uvarum, D. hansenii, and T. delbrueckii (Rocken, 1983; Back, 1987; Lawrence, 1988). Lambic is a special Belgian beer with a sour taste obtained by spontaneous fermentation of a grain mash made from barley and wheat. Microorganisms that are considered spoilage organisms in classical beer production are considered here as ne