Advances in Applied Mechanics Volume 18
Editorial Board T. BROOKE BENJAMIN Y. C. FUNG PAULGERMAIN RODNEY HILL L. HOWARTH WILLIAM PRAGER T. Y. Wu HANSZIEGLER
Contributors to Volume 18 F. H. Buss@
c. K. CHU RODNEYHILL JOHNL. LUMLEY
J. N. NEWMAN SHAN-FUSHEN
ADVANCES I N
APPLIED MECHANICS Edited by Chia-Shun Yih DEPARTMENT OF APPLIED MECHANICS A N D ENGINEERING SCIENCE THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN ANN ARBOR, MICHIGAN
VOLUME 18
1978
ACADEMIC PRESS New York San Francisco London A Subsidiary of Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, Publishers
COPYRIGHT @ 1978, BY ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO PART O F THIS PUBLICATION MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM OR BY ANY MEANS, ELECTRONIC OR MECHANICAL, INCLUDING PHOTOCOPY, RECORDING, OR ANY INFORMATION STORAGE AND RETRIEVAL SYSTEM, WITHOUT PERMISSION IN WRITING FROM THE PUBLISHER.
ACADEMIC PRESS,INC.
111 Fifth Avenue, New York, New York 10003
United Kingdom Edition published by ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. (LONDON) LTD. 24/28 Oval Road, London N W 1
7DX
LIBRARY OF CONGRESS CATALOG
CARD NUMBER: 48-8503
ISBN 0-12-002018-1 PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES O F AMERICA
Contents vii
LISTOF CONTRIBUTORS
Aspects of Invariance in Solid Mechanics Rodney Hill 1
Introduction I. Preliminary Concepts 11. Constitutive Descriptions 111. Bifurcation Theory References
3 28 50 72
The Optimum Theory of Turbulence F. H . Busse I. Introduction 11. The Optimum Problem for Turbulent Couette Flow 111. Multi-a Solutions IV. Bounds on the Transport of Momentum V. Bounds on the Transport of Mass VI. Bounds on the Transport of Heat VII. General Discussion References
17 80 84 p4
105 110 115 119
Computational Modeling of Turbulent Flows John L. Lumley 124 128 133 143 152
I. Introduction 11. Mathematical Preliminaries
111. The Return to Isotropy IV. The Rapid Terms V. The Dissipation Equations VI. Transport Terms References
160 174 V
vi
Contents
Unsteady Separation According to the BoundaryLayer Equation Shan-Fu Shen I. Introduction 11. Asymptotic Behavior of the Boundary-Layer Solution
Away from the Wall 111. Separation and the Concept of an Unmatchable Boundary Layer IV. The Semisimilar Boundary Layer V. The General Unsteady Boundary Layer VI. Separation in Lagrangian Description References
177 1a2 1a6 192 203 213 218
The Theory of Ship Motions J. N . Newman I. Introduction 11. History 111. The Boundary-Value Problem IV. Fundamental Solutions V. Two-Dimensional Bodies VI. Slender-Body Radiation VII. Slender-Body Diffraction VIII. The Pressure Force References
222 221 235 244 249 258 266 273 280
Numerical Methods in Fluid Dynamics
C.K . Chu I. Introduction 11. Differential Equations and Boundary Conditions 111. Numerical Analysis Background IV. Pseudophysical Effects: Numerical Dissipation and Dispersion V. Gas Dynamics VI. Navier-Stokes Equations VII. Magnetohydrodynamics References
286 287 292 301 309 317 327 329
AUTHOR INDEX
333
SUBJECTINDEX
339
List of Contributors
Numbers in parentheses indicate the pages on which the authors’ contributions begin
F. H. BUSSE,Institute of Geophysics and Planetary Physics, University of California, Los Angeles, California 90024 (77) C. K. CHU, Department of Mechanical Engineering and Plasma Physics Laboratory, Columbia University, New York, New York 10025 (285)
HILL, Department of Applied Mathematics and Theoretical Physics, RODNEY University of Cambridge, Cambridge CB3 9EW, England (1) JOHNL. LUMLEY, Sibley School of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, Cornell University, Ithaca, New York 14853 (123) J. N. NEWMAN, Department of Ocean Engmeering, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Massachusetts 02139 (221) SHAN-FUSHEN,Sibley School of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, Cornell University, Ithaca, New York 14853 (177)
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
ADVANCES I N APPLIED MECHANICS, VOLUME
18
Aspects of Invariance in Solid Mechanics RODNEY HILL Department of Applied Mathematics and Theoretical Physics Unioersity of Cambridge Cambridge, England
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I. Preliminary Concepts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Tensor Representations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Geometry of Deformation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Strain Measures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D. Stress Measures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E. Generalized Moduli . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. Constitutive Descriptions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Measure Invariance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Elastoplasticity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Some Types of Elastic Response . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111. Bifurcation Theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. First-Order Rate Problem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Primary Bifurcation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Bifurcation under Simple Loadings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1
3 3 9 14 17 24 28 28 35 41
50 50 58 66 12
Introduction This article is conceived primarily as an account of certain interrelated ideas that I have contributed over a long period to the basic mechanics of rate-independent solids, and which retrospectively appear to have proved influential. My previous writings on these matters have been purely seriatim and mainly for specialists. It now seems timely to attempt a unified, definitive, presentation which moreover is directed also to nonspecialists.In addition, I have taken the opportunity to incorporate unpublished items from lectures at the University of Cambridge (these are identifiable in the text by an absence of any attribution). The account opens with a recapitulation of properties of second-rank tensors (some standard, some not) that are peculiarly apt to deformation 1
Copyright @ 1978 by Academic Press. Inc. All rights of reprodudon in any form reserved. ISBN 0-12-002018-1
2
Rodney Hill
geometry and kinematics, and to the subsequent formulation of arbitrary measures of strain and work-conjugate stress, together with their objective fluxes. The overall approach differs substantially in spirit and emphasis from the stereotyped expositions in most monographs and treatises; my experience has been that the approach is accepted readily by students, and I myself would have made little headway without it. Clarity at this stage is indispensable for all that follows, so I have not skimped explanations; often, also, more than one route to a formula is indicated to foster helpful crosslinkages. Among other things, some prominence is given to what has come to be known as my “method of principal axes,” which I recommended as a sure way through tensor algebra which can otherwise relapse into labyrinthine complexity. Central to this method is the representation of tensors on trace axes of deformation that sweep through a Lagrangian reference configuration. A Lagrangian viewpoint is also well-suited to handling pure mechanics, as I have long advocated in relation to incremental boundary-value problems. With “nominal” stress as the primary variable, allied to the notion of convexity with respect to functionals,one has an infallible structural guide when investigating uniqueness of solutions and their extremal characters. Failure of incremental uniqueness, or bifurcation, is arguably the phenomenon that is most typical of continuum response at unrestricted levels of deformation. In view of the widespread current interest in its technical implications, I have treated bifurcation theory in detail here. Since the original publications, I have developed and refined the analysis during successive courses of Cambridge lectures, so hopefully the presentation now has a certain freshness, even for specialists. It may be noticed, incidentally, that I abstain from elaborating a collateral theory of instability for inelastic materials, such as I ventured in the past. It is of course in constitutive analyses of material behaviors that the mathematical apparatus assembled at the outset finds its justification. Restriction on space has compelled me to exclude idealized rigid-plastic response, even though I have always been much concerned with it; likewise only brief reference could be made to finite elasticity as such, mainly on the status of constitutive inequalities. Instead, I have elected to concentrate on the elastoplastic response of metal crystals and polycrystals, because it has become possible recently to say much that is new on the subject. Here again, though, I have had to accept constraints for the sake of an overall unity. On completing the text I met an unexpected difficulty in devising a satisfactory title, notwithstanding the initial conception and the ostensible contents. After reflection it became clear that a subconscious kit-motif had operated decisively and selectively throughout. This is the concept of “invariance,” not in the narrow usage of tensor algebra, but in a variety of guises
Aspects of Inuariance in Solid Mechanics
3
and at several levels of sophistication. Rather than enumerate these in advance, I prefer to let the article speak for itself. If the cumulative effect on a reader, whatever his speciality, is to suggest that invariance in its widest sense deserves more attention in every branch of continuum mechanics, the title will have been vindicated. I. Preliminary Concepts
A. TENSORREPRESENTATIONS 1. Decompositions on Reciprocal Bases
In the interests of simplicity, but with no loss of generality, the analytical framework will be expressed in vector and tensor components on a rectangular Cartesian background (curvilinear equivalents can be generated routinely when needed in particular applications). It is nevertheless essential to recognize the contravariant or covariant character of individual quantities that inevitably enter theories of solid continua. In the main these quantities relate to the geometry and loading of an elemental cell which is “embedded” in a continuing deformation. The symbolism to be described was devised to promote this basic viewpoint, and in that respect it differs from conventional notations in abstract tensor analysis. Usage has convinced me that there are consequent gains in clarity, in ease of manipulation, and in feel for structure. It is convenient to begin by recalling some definitions and terminology, and at the same time establish the notation. A pair of vector bases, al, a2,a3 and b’, b2, b3, are said to be reciprocal when
-
ai bj = ,a:
(1.1) where a dot denotes the scalar product and 6: is the Kronecker symbol. Such triads arise naturally in solid mechanics, for instance as edges of elementary cells that were cubes before deformation. Any vector v can be decomposed either as viai or ujbj where
ui = v * b’, uj = v aj. (1.2) The coefficients ui and uj thus have dual interpretations as components on one basis or as resolutes on the other. Let basis a’, a2, a3 be arbitrarily regarded as primary; then the components uj are called couariant and the ui contrauariant. Let T denote the matrix of components of any second-rank tensor on a rectangular background. Since T is expressible as a linear combination of nine independent tensors, which may in particular be dyads, four types of
Rodney Hill
4
tensor decomposition can be proposed: T = tijai@ aJ= tijbi@ bi = ti.jai @Id = t l j b @ aj.
(1.3)
These respectively define contravariant, covariant, and two kinds of mixed components of T. Equivalently, we have the vector decompositions Tbj = tijai, Taj = t i j b , or the vector resolutions tij
=b
. TbJ,
t i j = ai *
Ta,,
Taj = ti.jai,
Tbj = tljb'
(1.4)
ti' = ai . Tbj.
tfj = b' Taj,
(1.5)
To prove equivalence we need only appeal to the operational identity that defines a dyadic product: (u Q v)w = (v * w)u for any u, v, w. Let I denote the unit 3 x 3 matrix. Then the contravariant and covariant components of the unit tensor of second rank are such that I = gijai@ aj = gijbiQ bj. Equivalently, bj = gijai, gij
= b'
bj,
aj = gijbi, 9I.J .= a.I aj .
-
(1.6)
From (1.4) or (1.5) the mixed components are just 6c. Returning with this to (1.3) we obtain the useful identity a, Q bj = I = bj Q aj.
(1.7) This can alternatively be verified directly since it reproduces (1.2) when in product with any v. The arrays gijand g'j are mutual inverses because of the reciprocity of the triads; they act as metrics of the primary and secondary bases, respectively, in that u v = giju'd = g'ju, u j . They have a role also in the linear relations between tensor components of different types; for @ aj by combining (1.3) and (1.6). instance, t ; j = giktiJsince T = tij(gikbk)
-
2. Change of Basis
Let 9, and
6q
be another pair of reciprocal triads. Then i j p ~=
P
Viai + ijp = (
6 *~ai)u',
(1.8)
-
aj + ?q = ( 6 *~a,)(@ aj)ti? (1.9) The transformation rules for the other types of components are similar, and all the coefficients involve products like i, bi and 6 p ai (which incidentally are elements of mutually inverse matrices). Furthermore, 6p * ai ( p = 1,2,3) @iiP
H,
= t'ja,
.
Aspects of Znvariance in Solid Mechanics
5
are components of ai when decomposed on the other primary basis, and likewise b 9, (i = I, 2, 3). Hence, during a continuing homogeneous deformation, in which both primary bases are embedded, all such products are preserved. It follows as a corollary that the linear relations between tensor components of the same type on any pair of embedded bases are invariant under deformation. This observation underpins much recent work on measures of stress and strain. Nevertheless it seems not to have received due mention in the literature.
-
3 . Induced Tensors
Let any three, noncoplanar, fiber segments which are embedded in a homogeneous deformation be regarded as a primary basis. We write A for the matrix whose columns are the rectangular components of a’, a’, a3 in that order; for brevity this triad will be called the A basis. Similarly we write B for the matrix with columns b’, b’, b3.Note that the inverses A - ’ , B-’ are equal to the transposes B’, A’ when the A and B bases are reciprocal. The characteristic context, as we shall see, is where matrix A is the gradient of a deformation that maps a unit cube into a cell with edges a’, a’, a3. Previous formulae can now be rewritten symbolically. Thus from (1.6) ( g i j )= A’A,
(gi’) = B’B,
(1.10)
and from (1.2) (vi)
= B’v,
(Ui)= A’V,
where here v stands specifically for the column of background components. Especially, we draw attention to the replacement of (1.9, namely, (ti’) = B’TB,
(ti’) = A’TA,
(ti.’) = E T A ,
(ti’) = A’TB,
(1.11)
which will be quoted repeatedly. Suppose T is the array of background components of some tensor that is associated with a deformed configuration specified by gradient A. We can define four other tensors such that their background components are given by the arrays in (1.11). Since these components are equal, respectively, to those of the four representations of T on the A basis, we have the situation envisaged in the invariant property just proved. It follows that, if another embedded triad were introduced, the covariant components of tensor A’TA on that basis before deformation would be numerically equal to the covariant components of tensor T on that same basis after deformation. The same is true for the contravariant and mixed components. In other words, if T components of one type on any deformed basis are transferred to that triad as it was initially, another tensor is generated. It is by definition associated
Rodney Hill
6
with the reference configuration, and will be said to be "induced" from T by the deformation. 4. Kinematics of Embedded Bases
A deformation-rate tensor
r is defined by
Pi = rai
(i = 1, 2, 3),
where
b' = -rbj
( j = 1, 2, 3).
(1.12)
Here a dot denotes the rate of change when the primary basis is embedded in a continuing deformation (the reciprocal basis is not similarly embedded, of course). Symbolically, these may be read as the columns of
A=TA,
8= -rB.
(1.13)
From (1.7) and (1.12) we have the explicit formula
r = Pi 0 b'.
(1.14)
Evidently r is independent of the particular triad, again by the invariant property of transformations between embedded bases. Let
r=6+R where
R = )(r- r), 8 = +(r+ r).
(1.15)
By considering, in particular, the principal fibers of a further infinitesimal deformation, and applying (1.12) to them, we easily recognize R as the material spin and 6 as the Eulerian strain-rate. It is not difficult to show that the spin vector associated with the skew tensor R is
R = )b'
A
a',
(1.16)
with a standard notation for the vector product.
5 . Convected Derivatives Let v be any vector. Consider Dv/Dt, where D/Dt follows a material particle and t is a timelike parameter. We can evaluate this from (1.2) and (1.12) by two routes, namely D/Dt(u'ai)= u'ai + &ai,
D/Dt(vjbj)= ujbj - ujT'bj,
Aspects of Invariance in Solid Mechanics
7
where the primary basis is embedded in a deformation whose rate is r. Let these be written as (D/Dt)V = (dC/6t)V+ l 3 = (sc/6t)V - T'v,
(1.17)
so defhng (dc/6t)V= uiai,
(sc/6t)V = ujV.
(1.18)
These are convected derivatives in the full sense, that is, rates of change of representations on an embedded basis (the superscript or subscript index c is intended as a mnemonic notation to distinguish contravariant or covariant, respectively). The right-hand sides in (1.18) are, of course, independent of the basis, either by (1.17) itself or by differentiating (1.8) taking account of the invariance of the coefficients. Parallel definitions of these convected derivatives, in symbolic form, are (s"/ht)V = A(D/Dt)B'v,
(6Jst)V = B(D/Dt)A'v,
(1.19)
and with (1.13) these lead again to (1.17). A special case of (1.17) and (1.19), familiar from classical dynamics, is obtained by setting A = B = Q,proper orthogonal, with Q = RQ. Then (D/Dt)V = ( 9 / 9 t ) V + Qv, where
( ~ / W= QV( W t ) ( Q ' v )
(1.20)
denotes the convected derivative associated with a rotation Q(t).When R is specifically considered to be the spin of a material deformation, 9 / 9 t will be called the Jaumann flux. Then 9 6' -v =-v 9t 6t
6 v -bv + bv =2 6t
(1.21)
from (1.15) and (1.17). For any second-rank T the analog of (1.20) is DT/Dt = ( 9 T / 9 t )+ RT - M , where 9 T / 9 t = Q ( D / D t ) ( QT Q ) Q .
(1.22)
This may be viewed as a statement that the right-hand side of the first equation is spin invariant; its value is simply the flux of components on a fixed frame.
8
Rodney Hill
In the spirit of (1.19) we define background components of four convected derivatives, D Dt
g..
6cc D T = B - (A’TA)B’, 6t Dt
- T = A - (B’TB)A’,
-
6, D - T = B - (A’TB)A’, 6t Dt
64 , D - T = A - (B’TA)B’. 6t Dt
6t
(1.23)
The theorem on embedded bases confirms that D(B’TB)/Dt,etc., transform tensorially (but, of course, they are not associated representations of the same tensor). Then 6“T/6t, etc., are the fluxes of components on the embedded basis that currently coincides with the rectangular background. By evaluating (1.23) with the help of (1.13), we obtain 6“T
DT _
-+
I‘T+T=hT-T‘T-?T 6t
Dt
-T-T‘T+ St
(1.24)
T=> T + I ‘ T - Tl6t
In combination with (1.22) there results
9T -= 9t
dCC St
-T {
+ b T + T b = -a,,6t
S,C
-T
6t
T - b T - T8 (1.25)
6:
- bT + T b=2 T +bT - Tb 6t
in analogy to (1.21). Immediate corollaries are the connections (1.26)
Equivalently, 9T-< -9t
j3
1
D
[A
(B’TB)A’ + B - (A’TA)B’ Dt
{A
D (ETA)# + B - (A’TB)A’ Dt
by reverting to (1.23) and an arbitrary embedded basis.
(1.27)
Aspects of Invariance in Solid Mechanics
9
B. GEOMETRY OF DEFORMATION 1. Deformation Gradient
Let two configurations of a continuum be related by the mapping 5 -+ x in rectangular coordinates on a common fixed background. These configurations will usually be termed reference and current, respectively, or sometimes initial and final. The mapping is required to be differentiable so that (1.28)
Henceforward A symbolizes the Jacobian matrix whose i j element is aij= d x i / d t j and whose columns are denoted alra,, a3 as before. Physically possible mappings have positive determinant, I A 1, since this is the local volume magnification. Matrix A is called the deformation gradient. It suffices to study only first-order relations, on the usual pragmatic view that the local stress is not known to be affected by higher gradients. Since only ratios of differentials matter, such relations at a particle P are formally the same as those representing homogeneous deformation, namely x = AS
(1.29)
where A = (uij) is independent of 5, now drawn from P. For convenience the present discussion will be phrased in this context, and the mapping (1.29) will be regarded as between initial and final positions of either a particle (material point) or a fiber (material line segment). Any result can be transcribed for inhomogeneous mappings by replacing aij by d x i / d y j and prefacing words such as length, area, volume, fiber, etc., by the qualification “infinitesimal.” Incidentally, by writing the mapping as x = ciai,
(1.30)
we recover the notion of an embedded basis, here one that was initially a unit cube. The equation simply states that each particle keeps the same relative position within the deforming cell, and the invariant location is perpetually tagged by the Lagrangian coordinates 5’. Because of the differentiability restriction, A is uniquely determined by given mappings of just three noncoplanar fibers. Indeed, if x, = AS,, x2 = AS2, x3 = A4, where the matrix of columns, (Sl 5, t3),is nonsingular, the unique solution is A = (x1x2x3)(S15, 5 3 ) - As a matter of fact, this is a convenient way to monitor A experimentally, by observing what happens to the edges of a parallelepiped specimen or to lines scribed on three of its faces.
’.
10
Rodney Hill
In particular, the edges of a reference unit cube, with faces parallel to the coordinate planes, are mapped into al, a,, a,. The solution can be expressed more attractively by introducing the triad q', q2, q3 reciprocal to El, k,, 6,. Then A = XI @ q j
(1.31)
by premultiplying the analog of (1.7) by A. So the solution has the form of a sum of three dyads; in verification, operating on ti we obtain (qj ti)xj = 6Cxj = xi as required. To complete the duality, introduce also the triad yl, y2, y3 reciprocal to xl, x2, x,. Then q', q2,q3 are mapped into this triad by the deformation gradient B such that AB' = I, and consequently B = yj @
by analogy with (1.31). In proof, from (1.31) we have AB' = xj @ (Bqj)which is I by definition of B, and so Bqj = yj by (1.7).
2. Deformation of Area
To find how an embedded plane element changes under deformation we can take a face of the cell gl, p,, 5, as typical. Its vector area, say 5, A t3,is expressible as {tlt, t3}q1, where curly brackets signify the scalar triple product. Correspondingly, the deformed vector area is {x1x2x3}y1.But y' = Bq', just proved, and the ratio of the triple products is equal to the volume magnification IA I. Therefore any plane area u is mapped into IAIBu.
(1.32)
Another method is to appeal to the identity ( A t , ) A ( A t , ) = I A I B ( t 2 A 4,). Alternatively, consider a skew cylinder with basal area u and generators of unit length parallel to the jth coordinate axis; under the gradient A the generators become aj and the volume becomes I A I v j , which can be written identically as 1 A I (Bu) aj. Hence (1.32) is the final area of the common base of the cylinders j = 1,2, 3. 3. Principal Fibers The squared final length of a fiber is x * x = 5 * (A'AK.
(1.33)
Note, in passing, that A'A is symmetric and, as this formula shows, also positive definite (since x * x vanishes only when x = 0, which implies 5 = 0 on account of IA I # 0).The ratio (final length)/(initial length) of a fiber is called its stretch. This is therefore a number that represents an extension when in (1, a)and a compression when in (0, 1).
Aspects of Invariance in Solid Mechanics
11
The squared stretch is stationary with respect to varying fiber orientation when 6 = 5, ( I = 1, 2, 3) such that (A‘AK, = Ar26,
(no sum),
(1.34)
where the eigenvalues:A satisfy IA’A - AzI I = 0. Suppose them to be distinct. Since A’A is positive definite, we know from algebra that the eigenvalues are positive and that the associated quadric surface is an ellipsoid. Its principal axes are orthogonal and, being codirectional with their terminal normals, are by (1.34) in the directions +kr. Such fibers are called principal and the 19 are seem from (1.33) to be their stretches. Let (1.34) be premultiplied by A and combined with (1.29). The result is (AA’)x, = Ar2x,
(no sum),
(1.35)
showing that the principal fibers are also finally orthogonal, since AA’ is likewise symmetric and positive definite. The axes of A‘A and AA’ generally have different orientations though, which for brevity will be called Lagrangian and Eulerian, respectively. Of course, if two principal stretches are equal, all fibers in that plane are principal and the triads are to that extent nonunique. 4. Stretch Tensor
The symmetric tensor A, which is coaxial with the Lagrangian triad and has the principal stretches as eigenvalues, is known as the stretch tensor. That is, Ak, = ArL
(no sum).
(1.36)
In other words, the mapping A stretches the principal fibers like A itself but without rotation. So we have the polar decompositions
A = RA,
B = RA-‘,
(1.37)
where R is the proper orthogonal tensor that represents the final rotation needed to turn the principal fibers from the Lagrangian to the Eulerian directions. That AA-’ is automatically proper orthogonal can be checked by algebra : ( A A - ’ ) ’ ( A A - l )= A - l A ’ A A - l = A - l A 2 A - l = I , while I AA-’ I = + 1, since [ A 1 = 1 A 1 by construction. Since R R = I there is also the decomposition A = (RAR’)R.
(1.38)
12
Rodney Hill
This generates A by an initial rotation R followed by a stretch R A R ; this is coaxial with the Eulerian triad and has the principal stretches as eigenvalues. (If T is the array of background components of any tensor, R'TR is the array of its components on a frame rotated by R from the background, cf. (1.11). Equivalently, if the tensor itself is rotated by R, its background components become RTR'.) In practice, given a deformation gradient, the array A of background components of the stretch tensor can be constructed as follows. Calculate from (1.34) the stretches I , (r = 1, 2, 3) and the associated unit eigenvectors, say. Then apply (1.31) in the context of (1.36):
c,
We thereby recover the spectral decomposition formula, from which standpoint each dyadic self-product would be regarded as the background components of a uniaxial tensor with principal values 1, 0, 0. 5 . Kinematics During a continuing deformation, reckoned relative to a fixed initial configuration, the Lagrangian and Eulerian triads generally rotate against the background. Let RL,RE denote their spins and RL, RE their rotations (when these can be uniquely defined). Then
kL= RLRL,
kE= RERE,
by specializing (1.13). Introduce the spin RR of auxiliary axes rotated from the background by R. Then
RE = RRL,
d = RRR.
By eliminating the rates of rotation we obtain
R ( R E- RR)R= RL.
(1.39)
From (1.13), (1.15), and (1.37) there follow
' R'bR = t(hA-' + A- 'A).
R'(R - Ra)R = ~ ( A A - - A- 'A),
(1.4) (1.41)
In passing, it is worth noting that in the initial configuration itself R = RR = R, regardless of the incipient deformation. It is best to deal with such formulae by choosing a special background, namely, the coordinate frame with which the Lagrangian triad coincides momentarily (the principal stretches being supposed distinct). Then we need
Aspects of Invariance in Solid Mechanics
13
the components of tensors A, A, RLon the Lagrangian triad, say, A,,, A,,, a:, and the components of tensors 8, Q RE,RR on the Eulerian triad, say, E,,, orS, OF,, COP,. Equations (1.39)-(1.41) are thereby reduced to 0 , sE
- UP, = o rL, ,
( 1.42) (1.43)
with no summation over repeated subscripts. From the last two equations we have (1.45) Now apply (1.22)with A as the tensor and RLas the spin, again with the special background. Then
still supposing the principal stretches distinct. Combining (1.44)with (1.46) in the case r = s, we have the useful formula err
=X r I L
( 1.47)
In other words, with the Eulerian triad as basis, the normal components of the Eulerian strain-rate are equal to the rates of the logarithms of the principal stretches, regardless of rotation history. (When the same fibers remain principal there is nothing to be proved.) An elementary proof by pure geometry can be grounded on the stationary' property of eigenvalues, here the principal stretches. Take next the case r # s. By combining (1.43)with (1.46) we find (1.48) and then from (1.42)that
( 1.49) Finally, from (1.44)with (1.46)and use of (1.49),explicit formulae for the spins of the Lagrangian and Eulerian triads are obtained in terms of the
14
Rodney Hill
principal stretches and the Eulerian strain-rate:
(1.50) (1.51) Surprisingly, this important pair first entered the mainstream literature fairly recently (Hill, 1969, 1970,where derivations by pure geometry are given); an earlier mention of the second formula by Biot (1965)went unnoticed.
C. STRAINMEASUREB 1. Scale Functions
Suppose that the reference configuration of a material is fully specified; this includes the orientation of its microstructure in the chosen frame. We fix attention on a unit reference cube with edges parallel to the coordinate axes. Any six quantities that together define the shape of the embedded cell mapped by A from this cube can serve as a measure of strain. In crystal lattice theory, for example, the scalar products ai a, have commonly been used. Even more simple, geometrically speaking, are the lengths of the cell edges and their included angles; however, this set does not transform tensorially with the basis. Such variables will be brought within the general formalism later. For the present we restrict attention to tensor measures; these are made coaxial with the Lagrangian triad to obviate dependence on the rotation R. It is sensible to require that a measure vanishes in the reference configuration and agrees with the classical definition when the deformation is first order. The principal values could therefore be any smooth monotone “scale function” of stretch,f(l), subject to f(1)= 0, f’(1) = 1 (Hill, 1968). The correspondence between shape and measure is then one-to-one, but the connection with cell geometry is not simple, as a rule. However, this degree of generality promotes a desirable perspective, without unduly complicating the analysis in many cases. It has also given rise to the notion of measure invariance, which nowadays has a key role in the mathematical description of material response (see later). The array of background components of a measure will be denoted generically by E. Scale functions in the family (A2” - 1)/2n are often considered, where n may have any value. When 2n is a positive or negative integer, the
Aspects of Invariance in Solid Mechanics
15
corresponding array is E(”)= (A’”
(1.52)
- 1)/2n.
In proof, A2gr = Ar2kr, .. ., in ascending powers and A-’$ = A-le,, ..., in descending powers by repeated multiplication by A and A- respectively; so every A’” is coaxial with A and its principal values are A:”. In particular, the scale functions given by n = 1 and - 1 are by custom attributed to Green and Almansi, respectively. Then
’,
E(’) = +(A2 - I ) = +(A’A - I ) ,
(1.53)
E‘-” = ~1 ( -1A-’) = f ( I - BE),
(1.54)
with direct links with the metrics of the embedded cell and its reciprocal. As a further example, E(’’2) = A - 1 is given by the scale function A - 1 (fractional increase in length) and will be called the “stretch measure.” As n + 0, the limiting scale function is log A, which has long been popular in metallurgical testing. We write
(1.55)
E‘O’ = log A
but of course this notation cannot be read componentwise. However, since logA=(A- l ) - + ( A - l ) ’ + - - ,
O
we have the expansion log A = (A
- I ) -+(A
- I)’
+
a * *
(1.56)
when no principal stretch exceeds 2. Likewise, any scale function can be expanded as a convergent series
f(A)=(A-
l)+ff”(l)(A-
1)2+”‘
when IA - 1 1 is sufficiently small. When all principal stretches are in this interval, E = (A - I ) + +f”(l)(A - I)?
+
1 . .
(1.57)
(Although, by the Cayley-Hamilton identity, any E can be written formally as just a quadratic in A, with certain scalar invariants of A as coefficients, this apparently does not help much in practice). Conjoining (1.56) and (1.57), we have the basic connection log A = E - mE’
+ ...,
2m = 1 +f”(l),
(1.58)
Rodney Hill
16
in some E neighborhood of the reference configuration (Hill, 1968). The scalar parameter m is defined so that it vanishes for the logarithm, and the latter is here accorded the status of a norm with which other measures can be compared. Notice that m = n for members of the family (1.52).
2. Rates of Strain Following Hill (1970) let the fixed background be chosen coincident with the current Lagrangian triad. Then explicit components of the rate of change of any tensor measure can be computed by (1.22) and (1.50) with E and RLin place of T and R. Whence, taking account also of (1.47),
1 e, = A,er'Err
(r = s),
(1.59)
where e, =f (A,), e,' =f'(A,), and e,, are the subsequent components of E on the fixed background. It must be kept in mind that E,, are the components of d on the current Eulerian triad. Note that, as A, + A,, the coefficient of E , becomes A, e,' in the limit. With the Green and Almansi scale functions the formulae reduce to e,, = A,A,E,, (Green),
e,,/AJ,
(Almansi).
(1.61)
Alternatively, these representations follow from (1.53) and (1.54) by differentiation : I?(') = A'bA = A(R'bR)A, E(-l) = B'bB = A-l(R'&R)A-I,
(1.62)
with use of (1.13), (1.15), and (1.37). The point of the polar decompositions is that R'bR is the array of components of b on a frame rotated by R from the background; when this frame is the Lagrangian triad, R'bR is just matrix (c,,) and A is diag(A,, A,, 13),leading immediately to (1.61). Incidentally, A'BA and B'dB are two of the tensors induced from d by the deformation. With the scale function I - 1 (1.59) and (1.60) reduce to (1.44), which was derived independently. With the scale function log A the coefficient of E,, is unity while that of E,, is (1.63)
in ascending powers (Hill, 1970). Since the leading term is second order, (d/dt)log A = R'bR
+ O(E2).
(1.64)
Aspects of lnvariance in Solid Mechanics
17
The componentwise approximation by R'bR is close when 2 < &/Is < 2, say. The comparison is unaffected by the dilatational part of the deformation, and there is strict equality whenever the same fibers remain principal ( E , ~= 0, r # s). Rice (1975) has recommended (1.64) with (1.80) as a convenient approximation in constitutive descriptions of plastic response. Because scale functions are normalized in the reference configuration, rates of strain there agree with one another and with 8. Further, in some neighborhood we have from (1.58) the expansion
+
+
e, = {dikdj,-t m(dikej, djkei,) * * . } e ~ ~ )
(1.65)
in powers of E components on an arbitrary background. Fluxes of any two measures thus differ by jrst-order terms in strain unless their m-values are identical, which is to say that their scale functions have equal curvatures at I = 1. Under unrestricted deformation, on the other hand, the connection between a pair of fluxes is best shown in principal representation
.
ez =
der* . err, de,
~
.
e,*,=
e,* - es* ers er - es
(Ir
# Is),
(1.66)
from (1.59) and (1.60) with e = f ( I ) ,e* = f * ( I ) . Higher rates of strain can be investigated along similar lines, but will not be needed here. Authoritative accounts are Chadwick and Ogden (1971) and Ogden (1974).
D. STRESSMEASURES 1. Objective Components
Let Y denote the array of background components of Cauchy stress, where as usual the first index signifies the plane and the second the direction. Body moments are not envisaged here, so Y is symmetric. When the material is rotated under load without deformation, the Cauchy tensor rotates likewise; the array 9'changes accordingly and hence cannot serve as an objective measure of stress. To construct one, consider the cell al, a2, a3 generated by gradient A from the unit reference cube. The jth face of this cell has vector area I A Ibj from (1.32) and, by Cauchy's basic theorem, is subject to the load IAIYbJ= IAIaiiai= IAlaijbj
(1.67)
as in (1.4); the load has here been decomposed on the edges of the A cell and its reciprocal in turn. The coefficients are therefore unaffected by material rotation and are in that sense objective; the arrays of coefficients can be written symbolically as I A I ITYB and 1 A I A ' Y B , respectively, by (1.11).
18
Rodney Hill
The Lagrangian tensors generated by these background components are objective measures of stress. We note that aside from the immaterial factor I A 1, introduced for the sake of the direct mechanical interpretation, these are tensors induced from Y by the deformation A. Their objectivity may be verified in another way by applying polar decomposition to produce IA IA- ‘(R’YR)A- and I A 1 A(R9R)A- l . The tensor R’YR, induced by the components of Y on the R-rotated frame, is, of course, itself objective (hence also suitable as a measure). Dually, considering the reciprocal B cell, the vector load on itsjth face is I B I Y a , = IBlaijbi= IBlai.,ai.
(1.68)
The arrays of coefficients are I B I A’YA and I B I BYA, which involve the two other tensors induced by 9.The explicitly objective versions are 1 B IA(R‘YR)A and I B IA-’(R’YR)A. In the same spirit we can compute the work done, per unit reference volume, in a further differential increment of deformation of the A cell. The loads on the jth pair of opposite faces may be considered to act at points whose vector separation is aj, and so the differential work is altogether dw = IAlai’ai.da,= IAlaiid(hi*aj). Transcribing symbolically, we say that the stress measure
I A I B Y B is conjugate to &4‘A - I ) ,
(1.69)
the strain measure with Green’s scale function. Likewise, the stress measure
I A I A ‘ Y A is conjugate to i(Z - BB),
(1.70)
the strain measure with Almansi’s scale function. These results can also be reached from (1.62) via w = [ AI Tr(YS),
(1.71)
which we quote here as a standard formula in continuum mechanics. On the other hand, although Tr(YS) = Tr{(R’YR)(R’SR)}
(1.72)
trivially, I A 1 R Y R is not conjugate to any strain measure, since RSR is not a direct flux. The tensor 1AIY occurs repeatedly in the foregoing; it will be called “Kirchhoff stress” and its background components will be denoted by r,,.
Aspects of Invariance in Solid Mechanics
19
2. Work Conjugacy
The connections (1.69)and (1.70)motivate a systematic construction of stress measures, namely, as work conjugates to strain measures with arbitrary scale functions (Hill, 1968). Whatever the choice of measure E, the work differential can always be written as a Pfaffian dw = Tr(TdE).
(1.73)
Then the array T of symmetrized coefficients defines the conjugate measure, a function of both the intrinsic loads and the current strain. The array is associated with the rectangular background and so generates an objective tensor. This program is readily executed in principal representation. Let t,, be the coinponents of T on the Lagrangian triad. From (1.71)and (1.73)we have identically
(1.74) rs
rs
where t,, are the components of Kirchhoff stress on the Eulerian triad. Now substitute from (1.59)and (1.60)and compare coefficients on both sides; the result is
where e, =f (A,),e,' =f '(Ar). In passing, we observe that a conjugate measure is coaxial with the Lagrangian triad (trs= 0, r # s ) if and only if the Kirchhoff stress is coaxial with the Eulerian triad (trs= 0, r # s). During an arbitrary loading program this coaxiality is generally no more than momentary; exceptionally, it is perpetual when the material is isotropic elastic and one of its ground states is taken as reference. Noteworthy special cases of these formulae are t,, = trs/ArAs (Green),
A,Astrs (Almansi),
(1.77)
when f ( A ) = +(Az - 1) and i(1 - A-2), respectively. These complement (1.61),from which they are also self-evident via (1.74).Again, t,, = +(l/Ar
whenf(l) = A - 1.
+ l/As)z,,(stretch measure)
(1.78)
20
Rodney Hill
The array of background components of the conjugate of any measure in the family (1.52) will be denoted P).By inspection the representations (1.77) generate T ( ' ) = lAlA-'(R'YR)A-',
T(-"= IAlA(R'YR)A,
as already shown otherwise in (1.69) and (1.70). Similarly,it can be seem that (1.78) generates T"'2' = 2 1 I A I {A- ' ( R Y R ) ( R ' Y R ) A -'}.
+
Or this follows by substituting (1.41) in (1.72). Equivalently, T(1/2) = &(T(')A+ AT(1)).
(1.79)
This measure was introduced by Biot (1965), though in a very different guise and from another standpoint. Certain manipulative advantages in nonlinear isotropic elasticity have been argued by Ogden (1975,1977), more especially in regard to variation principles involving functionals of stress. Further algebraic connections between measures in the family P )are given by Ogden (1974); we do not pursue the matter here. The conjugate to the logarithmic measure (1.55) will be denoted by Fo). In lieu of a closed-form expression, the approximation
I
T'O' = 1 A R ' Y R
+ O(E2)
(1.80)
may be acceptable at moderate deformations, by (1.64) and (1.72). A compact way of stating equations (1.76) is that trs(er- e,) has an invariant value for each pair r # s, which is therefore known from the Green measure and its conjugate. Together these amount to an assertion that the skew tensor TE - ET is measure-invariant.
(1.81)
A direct proof in these terms is instructive (Hill, 1975, unpublished). Consider any incremental deformation in which the Lagrangian triad rotates but the principal stretches stay fixed. Then the components of every E are stationary in a frame whose spin is RL, and so E = RLE- ERLby (1.22). The rate of working is correspondingly
Tr(Tk) = -Tr{(TE - ET)QL}, which is just twice the scalar product of the vectors associated with the skew tensors TE - ET and RL. Since the work rate is independent of the strain measure, and the components of the spin vector can be assigned at will, the components of (1.81) must be separately invariant.
Aspects of lnvariance in Solid Mechanics
21
3. Objective Rates of Stress
With any reference configuration and any strain measure E, the flux T of the work-conjugate stress T is suitable as an objective rate of stress. Other definitions are conceivable, and some can be useful for specific purposes (e.g., Storen and Rice, 1975). Restriction here to the particular class T is motivated by the wish to exploit the measure invariance that arises from a direct link with mechanical work. It is straightforward to calculate the representation of f on a fixed background with which the Lagrangian triad is momentarily coincident. It is the array DT/Dt in (1.22) with T on the right-hand side given by (1.75) and (1.76) and R by (1.50). The resulting expressions are not particularly illuminating. So we concentrate here on evaluating rates of stress in a reference configuration itself, which is to say where E vanishes but T need not. On the other hand, we allow an arbitrary background. With arbitrary f ( I ) we can apply (1.65) near a reference configuration. Then, from (1.73),
+
+
t i j = (6ik6jI - rn(6ikejI 6jkeif) - * * } t i t )
where Po)denotes the exact conjugate to log A. Now differentiate this as it stands, afterwards setting E = 0, fi = 8,T(O)= 9'. The result is precisely
+
T = f ( 0 ) - rn(Y8 89)
(1.82)
in the reference configuration (Hill, 1968). Now, by applying the first of (1.23) to (1.69) and the second to (1.70), there follows
(1.83)
By comparing these, respectively, with the first or second of (1.25), it can be recognized from (1.82) with rn = 1 or - 1 that in the reference configuration
f ( O ) = ( 9 Y / 9 t )+ Y Tr I ,
(1.84)
the Jaumann flux of Kirchhoff stress (Hill, 1968, 1970). This is a result that merits an independent proof. By definition, as in (1.22),
(D/Dt)(I A I R'YR) = R ' ( 9 / 9 t ) ( I A I9')R
where here 9/9t accompanies the R-rotated frame whose spin is RR.But, in the reference configuration, R = 1 and RR = R, the material spin. Then the last right-hand side coincides with the Jaumann flux of Kirchhoff stress, while the left-hand side is Tto)by (1.80).
22
Rodney Hill
Higher rates of stress can also be investigated along these lines; for a systematic account see Chadwick and Ogden (1971) and Ogden (1974). 4. Nominal Stress Objective measures of stress are, of course, primarily intended for intrinsic, rotation-free, formulations of material behavior. In consequence they are not well-suited to matters of pure mechanics such as the balance of forces within a continuum and the specification of tractions over its surface. For that, there are definite advantages in a nonobjective measure which is based partly on an embedded cell and partly on a fixed background. This choice of variable is supplemented by a bridging equation between the material and mechanical descriptions. The whole procedure is standard practice today; it was fist codified by Hill (1957a,b; l958,1959,1961a,b) in a general theory of uniqueness and stability in elastic or plastic continua. Consider the load vector ni on the ith face of an A cell and denote its rectangular components on the background by nij ( j = 1, 2, 3). Under change of background the array N = (nil)generates a tensor; it will be called nominal stress (since reckoned as load divided by reference area, here a face of the original unit cube). N is affected by a final rotation Q of the cell together with its loading (it becomes N Q ) . N is also nonsymmetric: instead the three restrictions demanded by moment balance are ak hnk = O
Or
Or
aiknkj = Ujknki
A N = (AN)'.
(1.85)
Alternatively, these variants follow by setting zero the work-rate expression, in one or other of the forms
w = n, a.I = n.11b.. JI = Tr(NA), when
(1.86)
k is a pure spin, namely &=aha,,
U11. . = Rik Qk j ,
A = RA,
respectively. By the usual tetrahedron construction the current load on a plane element is Nu,where u is its vector area in the reference configuration. The load is likewise calculable from Cauchy's basic theorem as I A I Y'Bu by (1.32), without assuming symmetry of 9. Comparison gives
IA(-'AN
=Y
(1.87)
and we note that this implies (1.85) in the absence of body moments. Correspondingly, by inserting A = TA in (1.86), and cycling the factors in the
Aspects of Znvariance in Solid Mechanics
23
trace, we obtain W = Tr(ANT) =
I A I Tr(YT),
which returns to (1.71) when Y is symmetric. The objective measure of stress with which N is most directly connected is the conjugate of Green strain, F ' )= I A 1 B ' Y B from (1.69). Thus T(')A' = N
(1.88)
by (1.87). With the decompositions (1.37) there are useful equivalents such as T(')A= NR,
T(')A2= NA,
(1.89)
from which it follows that the value of the invariant (1.81) may be put as f ( N A - A'"). It can be seen from (1.79) that the conjugate of the stretch measure is the symmetric part of NR. Contact between N and any other objective measure can be made, in principle, via (1.75) and (1.76). We turn to the rate form of (1.88). Differentiation leads in the first instance to A N = /IT.(')/I' + AT'"A' = (s""/st)( I A 19) + 1 A 1 YT' by (1.13) and (1.23). Written as
+
I A I-'AN
= [(/sCcY/6t) Y Tr 81
IA /-'A&
= [(9Y/9t)
+ Y(8- 0 )
(1.90) by (1.19, this is a form of the bridging equation mentioned previously (Hill, 1959). If the Jaumann flux is preferred as the objective rate of stress, as in Hill (1939, then
+ Y Tr 81 - 89' - 932
(1.91)
from (1.25); here it is worth keeping in mind the connection (1.84). It may be remarked that (1.90) and (1.91) have been arranged in the manner of (1.87), so that each side is independent of the reference configuration. In the sequel this will on occasion be chosen coincident with the current configuration, in which case A is set equal to I and N interpreted correspondingly. For future reference it is convenient to record at this point the formulae Tr(&A) - Tr(f(')l?(')) = Tr(T(')k'k), Tr(NdA) - Tr(T(')dl?')) = d{Tr(+T("k'k)},
( 1.92)
for arbitrary variations in the rates at a given configuration and stress. These formulae are obtained by coupling the derivative of (1.88) with A'k = g(1)+ A'RA; the final quantity is skew and makes no contribution to the trace.
24
Rodney Hill
E. GENERALIZED MODULI 1. Some Transformation Formulae
The notion of conjugacy between measures (T, E) of stress and strain leads naturally to the idea of an associated tensor of moduli. Suppose the response of a material to incremental loading is either linear or piecewise linear. Then a fourth-rank tensor 9 can be defined such that tIJ. . = 9. rjkl i.kl
(1.93)
where 9 has a uniform value over the whole E space or over each of a number of subdomains. The dependence of 9 on the state of deformation will be considered later for various kinds of material; for the moment, however, our concern is with its dependence on the choice of measure. We seek transformation formulae allowing both for a change of scale function and of reference configuration. Such data conversion is a practical necessity since experimentalists and mathematicians often have different preferences. Before undertaking a general analysis we can read off a useful connection from (1.82).We recall that this requires the current configuration to be taken as reference, so let 9 and 9'' specifically ) denote the respective tensors of moduli associated there with E and E(') (the logarithmic measure). By substituting = 9 8 and Po)= Y(')bit is found, as in Hill (1968) that
on an arbitrary background; note the conventional symmetrization of components under the interchange k t-,1. The qualitative conclusion is that, in a material under load, the moduli are not measure invariant even at zero strain; on the contrary, there is a direct dependence on the local curvature of the scale function, represented by the terms in the parameter m. Turning to generalities, we must argue from the invariance of Tr( TdE)/p; this is the work differential per unit muss, p being the material density in the reference configuration. Distinguishing any other choice of variables by stars, we derive ( P / P * ) ~ $= (aemn/ae$)tmn
(1.95)
since each component of E is a determinate function of the components of E*. Now take the differential of (1.99,holding fixed the two reference densities, and introduce (1.93) along with its starred analog. The upshot is (1.96)
Aspects of Invariance in Solid Mechanics
25
Once again the coupling between curvature and load can be observed, here the terms with second derivatives. Note also that the special formula (1.94) could be recovered by explicitly calculating these derivatives at zero strain from (1.58). The transformation rule is particularly simple when the Green scale function is adopted for both measures and only the reference configuration is changed. By combining (1.62) with (1.83) we find
This indicates that the bracketed quantity on the right is invariant under change of reference configuration, and that its value is the tensor of moduli associated with the Green measure based on the current configuration. The transformation rule is implicit in this statement of invariance; it can be brought into line with (1.96), if one wishes, by equating the bracketed quantity to its starred analog, along with A = A*A, where A is the deformation gradient that converts one arbitrary reference configuration into another. Notice that the secondderivative terms have disappeared from (1.96) since the relation between E and E* is linear. Similarly,
implies the transformation rule for the tensor of moduli associated with the Almansi scale function. Because of the central role of nominal stress in the later developments it is necessary to introduce pseudomoduli such that nIJ. . = g. ijkl alk.
( 1.99)
These are not true moduli since they are partly coupled to the material spin. However, they do have a direct link with the Green moduli and this can stand in place of the bridging equation (1.90). Thus, by differentiating (1.88) in the form nij = t$hjk, we obtain
+
Vijk= l a j n u l u 9 ~ ; ~t p, d j , .
(1.100)
The rule of transformation under change of reference configuration is expressible via the invariance of
I A 1-
laimakugmjul
(1.101)
from (1.90) and (1.13). Its invariant value is the tensor of pseudomoduli in (1.99) when the current configuration is taken as reference for both nominal stress and deformation gradient.
26
Rodney Hill
2. Orthotropic Symmetry
It happens not infrequently that a material is isotropic in some ground state and is subsequently deformed so that three fibers are always mutually perpendicular. Then, regardless of the kind of material, the Cauchy stress is coaxial with these fibers and the only nonvanishing moduli are of type Yrrss and Yrsrs referred to the Lagrangian triad. That is,
where the fluxes are of components on a fixed background coinciding with the triad. The rates of strain are already known from (1.59) and (1.60); the rates of siress can be obtained from (1.22) applied to (1.75) and (1.76). This computation involves the flux of components of Kirchhoff stress on the spinning Eulerian triad, which we can write as
where the subscript REemphasizes that 9/9there follows the Eulerian triad (of the deformation referred to the ground state). This defines an objective tensor of moduli X, also having orthotropic symmetry but not associated with any measure in the sense that Y is. A short calculation, taking account of (1.47) and (1.50), leads to (1.102)
with no summation over repeated indices. with the shear modulus It may on occasion be convenient to link Yrws associated with the convected derivative of Kirchhoff stress in a frame rotating with some other spin, R, say. The required transformation is immediate from (1.22) written as
Aspects of Invariance in Solid Mechanics
27
For example, if R is specifically the material spin, the shear modulus associated with the Jaumann flux is (1.104)
by (1.51). As another example, if R is the spin RR of the R-rotated frame, given by (1.42), then
is the associated shear modulus. If we are primarily interested in the dependence of Yrw,on the strain measure, it suffices to cite a less explicit version of (1.103), namely {2%rs(er - es) - (tr - ts)}(er - es)
(1.105)
is measure invariant. This version can be viewed most simply as a consequence of (1.81) in rate form. To illustrate its application, suppose we want to connect the shear moduli associated respectively with the measures E(') and E('l2). The principal values of 7<') and 7<'/2)can be read from (1.77) and (1.78), whence
In principle this and other such relations are obtainable from (1.96), but less conveniently. When, in particular, the material is isotropic elastic the Kirchhoff stress is coaxial with the Eulerian triad. Then the shearing components oft,, are = 0, r # s. By (1.103), therefore, perpetually zero and S,,,
yrsrs = -1- t, - t, 2 er - e,
#
(I s)
(1.106)
and the invariant (1.105) vanishes. Of course, this expression for the shear moduli is also obtainable directly by combining (1.60) with the analogous equation for ir,.In particular, the shear moduli associated with Green's scale function are given by (1.107)
by (1.77). According to (1.97) the right-hand side is the shear modulus when the current configuration is taken as reference (Hill, 1969).
Rodney Hill
28 11. Constitutive Descriptions
A. MEASURE INVARIANCE 1. Generalized Variables and Transformation Rules This account of material response focuses on applications of the preceding mathematical apparatus in constitutive analyses. For the most part the incremental response may be arbitrarily piecewise linear and tensors of moduli may be arbitrarily path dependent. Time dependence and thermal phenomena, however, are excluded for the sake of brevity and a degree of unity. The illustrations touch on the elasticity of ideal monatomic lattices and of polymeric solids, but mainly concentrate on the elasticity and pla-;ticity of metal single crystals and polycrystals. We begin with some elementary observations to do with the work of deformation (Hill, 1972). A simple notation is an advantage here, along with some enlargement of scope. Let the current shape of an embedded cell be specified by any six geometric variables; we can regard them as generalized coordinates and, adopting the symbolism of Lagrangian mechanics, denote them by qa (a = 1, . . ., 6). As usual the cell can be supposed to be a unit cube in the reference configuration. When, in particular, the change of shape is specified by a tensor strain measure E relative to this configuration, we put q1 = e l l , q2 = e22, q3 = e33; q4 = 2e23, q5 = 2e31, 96 = 2e12. Generalized conjugate variables pa are defined by expressing the virtual work rate of the tractions acting over the cell faces as w = p.9,.
(2.1)
In principle, the pa are determinate functions of the tractions and the qa. In particular, p 1 = tll, p 2 = t22, p 3 = h 3 ; p4 = t23, p 5 = t31, p6 = t12, when the generalized coordinates are derived from some E whose conjugate is the stress measure T. Whenever the incremental response is linear within a domain of coordinate space, we can define there a matrix of generalized moduli as the array of coefficients in the differential relations Pa
= cap 4 p .
The notational correspondence between cap and Zjklin (1.93) is analogous to that between pa and tij;that is, a goes with the pair ij,and /?with the pair kl, both in the same manner. The work of deformation, p a d q a , is generally path dependent; here we concern ourselves only with second-order manifestations of the dependence, when the path segment is infinitesimal. Let this be given parametrically by
S
Aspects of Invariance in Solid Mechanics
29
functions qu(8),8 2 0; then the work is expressible as Joe Puq,'dO = ( P a d ) 0 8 + +(Pa4al)o'82+ O(e3),
where differentiation by 8 is denoted by a prime and evaluation at 8 = 0 by a subscript zero. This can be rearranged as
(PAO) + + P a ' ( 0 ) ~ > ~ q A+O+e"(O)e2) )~ and hence written in brief as 6w = ( p a
+ W')
(2.3)
+ +6pa)6q. + ...,
(2.4) correct to second order. This formula will be referred to as the trapezoid rule of quadrature (it generalizes an elementary approximation in the integral calculus, namely mean ordinate times abscissa interval). It will be applied also in the version 6w = pu6q.
+ +cu86qa6q,+ ...
(2.5 )
where cupare the generalized moduli appropriate to the domain of coordinate space in which the segment 6% falls. Suppose that some other set of coordinates qa* is chosen, possibly along with a different reference configuration; let p and p* be the respective reference densities. Since the work rate per unit mass is coordinate invariant, (P/P*)PU* = (aqv/a4a*)Pp (2.6) generalizing (1.95). Moreover 6w*/p* = Sw/p identically in powers of 8, so by (2.5) and its starred analog we have
to second order. The transformation rule for the moduli follows as an immediate corollary:
generalizing (1.96).The final step in (2.7) incidentally avoids a pitfall that has claimed more than one eminent victim: in transforming (2.4) or (2.5) the
30
Rodney Hill
leading terms also must be evaluated to second order in the new coordinates (otherwise the contributions from a2qr/a%* aq,* are lost). 2. Diflerential lnvariants
With the preceding appreciation of the trapezoid rule, it can be used rigorously to examine path dependence. As an elementary illustration, consider two possible routes between nearby initial and final configurations q, and q, dq, + dq,, namely, via (a) q, dq, and (b) q, + dq,. If the responses to dq, and 6q, are governed by the same matrix of moduli, so that dp, = c,, dq, and dp, = cap Sqs in both (a) and (b), the final values of the conjugate variables by either route are pa + dp, dp,, correct to first order. Then, by (2.4), the respective works per unit reference volume are dqa + (pa + d ~ + a 3dPa) h a , (Pa + (a) (Pa + - t a ~ a )h + (pa + dpa + tdpa) &a, (1' correct to second order, and so the work difference per unit mass is
+
+
+
For path independence it is therefore necessary that the matrix of generalized moduli be symmetric (in particular q j k l = Y k l i j for the tensor of moduli associated with any strain measure); conversely, an absence of symmetry presages path dependence. We see also in (2.9)the embryo of another idea (Hill, 1972): a differential form that is bilinear in the generalized coordinates and their conjugates, and whose value is invariant (since shown to be interpretable in terms of work only). The wider significance of this invariance is that it is independent of material response, nor need the routes be first order but only the resultant changes in the variables. The proof is simple: take the d-differential of (2.6) and construct
and similarly with d and 6 interchanged. Subtraction gives
after canceling terms in the second derivatives. An interpretation in terms of virtual work may be had by reference to a triangular cycle of quasilinear arcs from q, to q, + dq, to q, + 6% and then back to q,. Formally associate with these nodes the respective values pa, pa + dp,, pa + 6p,, pa of the conjugate variables, where dp, and dp, are the resultant increments on routes to
Aspects of Invariance in Solid Mechanics q,
31
+ dq, and qa + 6q, from qa. Then, integrating round the cycle,
f
p a 4.1
do = +(dpa dqa - d
~ dqa) a
+ . *
by (2.4), correct to second order. In the context of pathdependent response, such work is indeed only virtual, since in an actual cycle the true nodal values of the conjugate variables (and the tractions they represent) could differ by first order from those assigned. The bilinear differential form will be invoked later in a constitutive analysis of elastoplastic response. Another coordinate-invariant constitutive property derives from the Pfaffian identity 1 dp,*
P*
6(dqa*)- -1 dp,, 6(dqP)= 6 P
a2qfl
* dqa* dql.)
(2.11)
for infinitesimal &variations of the d-differentials (and not of the current state). This is proved similarly to the equation preceding (2.10). Its import stems from the circumstance that the right-hand side is a perfect &variation. Suppose that the constitutive relations between differential increments of the (p, q ) variables admit a potential with one choice of coordinates so that, say, dp,, d(dq,) is a perfect &variation. Then so is dpa* 6(dqa*)and the differential relations in any other coordinates likewise admit a potential. 3. Constitutive Inequalities and Convexity
It is an open question whether a material under load must be in some sense “intrinsically stable” if the conventional kind of constitutive description is to be admissible. Convincing philosophical or experimental grounds for any particular requirement are lacking, in my opinion. The literature on rubberlike elasticity abounds with idiosyncratic formulations of material stability, as can be seen in the accounts by Truesdell and Toupin (1963) and by Truesdell and No11 (1965). Some needed perspective was introduced by Hill (1970) and augmented by Hill (1975) and by Hill and Milstein (1977) in the context of ideal crystals. We follow this approach here, relaxing where possible any restriction to elasticity. Adequate specification of the loading environment is a prerequisite. During any homogeneous virtual deformation of a test specimen, the tractions must be imagined to “follow” the material, since we are here concerned with an intrinsic property (by contrast, the loads in standard laboratory experiments are often frame dependent and their work is affected by rotation of the specimen). The tractions may, in addition, be deformation sensitive and become different in kind from those in the undisturbed configuration. In any event the virtual work of the tractions on a path segment dq, must be
Rodney Hill
32
specified tc; second order, say
+
(2.12) 6u = p , 6q, jk,, 6q, 6q, + per unit reference volume, where the coefficients k,, depend on the current configuration and the choice of generalized coordinates. In a disturbed configuration, q, + 6q,, the actual state of stress under piecewise-linear response is represented by values p, + c,, dq, of the conjugate variables, whereas the virtual state of stress that would be in statical balance with the follower tractions is represented by values pa + k,, dq,. Relative to this environment the material will be called “stable” if
(6~4 k4,
h,)dqa = (cab - kufi) dqa
>0
(2.13)
for every disturbance. This requirement is automatically coordinate invariant since it is equivalent to 6w > 6u for all sufficiently small disturbances. In fact, since Su/p is invariant, the coefficients k,, transform according to (2.14)
by analogy with (2.8) which reflects the invariance of 6w/p; and by subtracting (2.8) from (2.14) the coordinate independence of (2.13) is apparent in detail. For an elastic material with a strain-energy density w(q,) the definition (2.13) requires that the combined incremental potential energy of the specimen and its loading should be positive for arbitrary disturbances (in this case the moduli c,, have the values a2w/aq, 84,). Thus the definition accords with the classical Lagrange-Dirichlet criterion of stability in relation to dynamical systems. For other materials the mechanical significance of (2.13), or of its failure, is less clear. However, the inequality can still be studied in a conjectural constitutive role; henceforth the discussion is confined to this aspect. Loading environments can be envisaged where the coefficients k,, vanish, relative to a particular set of coordinates. In other words, during any disturbance the environment reacts passively so as to hold constant the p , values representing the tractions. In these circumstances the inequality reduces to (2.15) 6Pa h a = cub 4 4 dq, > 0. When converted into other coordinates, however, this returns to the general form in accordance with (2.14). For elastic materials, in particular, (2.15) becomes (2.16) (a2W/aqa aq,) 6% dq, > 0,
which states that the energy density is locally strictly convex in its arguments, or the Hessian matrix of w is positive definite. This, indeed, is the
Aspects of Invariance in Solid Mechanics
33
version of the inequality most frequently encountered in the literature, whether in the context of elastomers or of ideal lattices. Often, though, the special choice of coordinates has been fortuitous and the stability criterion has been routinely quoted as (2.16) without regard to its lack of invariance. Sometimes, on the other hand, a deliberate choice of coordinates has been motivated merely by a priori notions of what constitutes an appropriate passive environment. Full details can be found in the references cited. Leaving this aspect aside, and without commitment to one or any view of intrinsic stability, we can propose a question that has some general interest. Supposing the incrementally linear response of a material to be given, how does the configurational domain defined by (2.15) depend on the choice of coordinates? For the question to be well-posed it seems necessary that the moduli should depend only on the current coordinates. Then the domain can be surveyed by paths leading from a configuration (which would normally be unstressed) where matrix (c,,) is known to be positive definite. The boundary will consequently be encountered where matrix (c,,) first becomes semidefinite, and thereafter indefinite. Necessarily det(c,,) vanishes there in association with an eigenmode dq, such that
s p a = c,, sq, = 0.
So a boundary point is characterized by local stationarity of the conjugate variables along some path through the point (Hill, 1975). Illustrative calculations for cubic lattices, with various sets of coordinates, are reviewed by Hill and Milstein (1977); the types of eigenmode encountered on paths that make the lattice tetragonal are also classified. Still pursuing the same question, we now restrict the choice of generalized coordinates to tensor measures of strain and revert to the T, E notation. Then, in rate form, (2.15) becomes Tr(Tk) > 0,
T = Yk,
(2.17)
where the scale function and reference configuration are both arbitrary. A comparative study of constitutive inequalities in this class for isotropic elasticity was initiated by Hill (1968, 1970). With a ground state for reference and a background frame coincident with the current Lagrangian triad, we can reduce (2.17) to
by (1.59)and (1.60) with tr = aw/der. Necessary and sufficient conditions for the inequality are therefore that the function w(e,, e,, e 3 )is (i) strictly convex locally and (ii) its first derivatives are ordered algebraically as its arguments. Hence the domain boundary will be encountered where either
34
Rodney Hill
det(a2w/ae, ae,) = 0 or t, = t, (r $; s). The respective eigenmodes are coaxial with the principal fibers or are shears of type E, (r # s). If it happens that the domain of (i) in principal strain space is itself convex, one may show that w(e,, e2, e 3 )is strictly convex globally and (ii) is automatically satisfied, by standard theorems, and likewise for any convex part of any domain (i) whatever. On the other hand, when the current configuration is taken as reference, (2.17) is reducible to Tr[(99/9t)8] > 2m Tr(Y@) - Tr(Yb) Tr 8
(2.19)
by (1.82) and (1.84), remembering that every l? = 8 when E = 0. Comparisons of (2.19) with (2.18) for arbitrary scale functions are naturally intricate; further details can be found in the references mentioned. Little eke has been published on the domains of (2.15) or (2.17) and their coordinate relativity for any particular material, but the whole matter certainly merits further study. Leaving it there perforce, we turn to a comparison of one incremental response with another. In mathematical parlance we turn from absolute convexity to relative convexity. This concept was introduced explicitly in continuum mechanics by Hill (1959), to supplement a theory of elastoplastic bifurcation. More will be said about that later; the intention just now is to prove a general theorem (apparently new), namely, that relative convexity is coordinate invariant. In its simplest setting, given a deformed configuration and the current loading, let cap and Zap be any two matrices of moduli (in practice, one matrix often characterizes an actual response and the other a hypothetical one, but this is not the only interpretation). Then the direction of the inequality (6pa - spa) 6 q a = (cap - z a p )
&a
6qp 2 0
(or > 0)
is invariant under transformation of coordinates, for arbitrary increments of deformation. In proof, by (2.8) with p,,, q,,, qa* given by hypothesis,
= (CPV - z p v )
6% 6%. When each response admits a work function, the inequality is a statement that w is locally convex (or strictly convex) relative to iir. The appropriate generalization for any incremental response whatever is A(Spa - &a) A(6qa) 2 0
(or > 0)
(2.20)
where A(6qa) denotes the difference of any two incremental deformations and A(6pa), A(8pa) the differences of the corresponding responses by the
Aspects of Invariance in Solid Mechanics
35
respective materials. In this version the inequality is a statement that one set of differential response relations are convex (or strictly convex) relative to the other set. The proof runs on exactly similar lines, via the Adifferences of the respective 6- and $-differentials of (2.6). B. ELASTOPLASTICITY 1. Phenomenological Framework
Objective rate equations, with a scope fully commensurate with the experimental data, have long been available for metals at unrestricted strains (Hill, 1958,1959). Their basic structure is nowadays agreed by most authorities, though some details are still unsettled (principally concerning the geometry of yield surfaces for polycrystals, and the path dependence of elastic and plastic moduli). The conventional exposition of such rate equations will be taken for granted; the present intention is rather to view this same framework from a radically different standpoint, which is not so well known. A definitive version was given by Hill and Rice (1972, 1973); with minor additions and rearrangements this is followed here. At the outset the material behavior is portrayed only in outline. First, every attainable state in configuration space is supposed to belong to a compact closed domain wherein the response is purely elastic and admits a work function; the boundary of each maximal elastic domain is a so-called “yield surface,” which must be regarded as associated with each and every interior state. Second, any path leaving a domain begins with a segment where the current state remains on the subsequent yield surfaces; the incremental response is now nonelastic overall, and may for instance be piecewise linear. Third, the shape of a yield surface, and the elasticity within it, are bothfinctionals of the entire path of deformation reckoned from some ground state. This behavior will be formalized at whatever observational level the loading and deformation of a representative element of material (whether single crystal or aggregate) can properly be treated as homogeneous overall. Generalized variables p a , qa (a = 1 ... 6) are then appropriate, as defined previously; they will be denoted collectively by p , q when indicating the primary arguments in dual functions of state. Within a yield surface let 4(q,H) be the work function per unit reference volume, where H symbolizes the complete history of nonelastic straining on the path responsible for that domain. Then, at each interior point, 84 = pa 6qa for arbitrary 6qa at fixed H. Whence PA49 H)= a4(e w a q a
(2.21)
36
Rodney Hill
and so the work function acts as an elastic potential in the usual way, but only within the one domain at each H.There, nonetheless, elastic moduli 9as can be defined by = -Zaa aq,,
%p(q, H)= a24(q,H)/aqa 84s.
(2.22)
Proceeding as in the active part of Legendre’s dual transformation, let $(p, H)be the complementary potential such that 4(q, H )+ +(P, H)= P.4,
(2.23)
subject to (2.21). Assuming that det(Y,,,) # 0 within a domain, we can in principle invert (2.21) uniquely and hence express $ as a single-valued function of the conjugate variables. Then S$ = qa Spa at fixed H,or qa(P, H)= a + ( ~ H , ) / ap a *
(2.24)
Elastic compliances A!,@are defined by 6qa =
dP,,
A ~ SH()P =~ a2$(P, H ) / a ~ app, a
(2.25)
and of course matrices (Yap) and (Aaa) are inverses. It should be kept in mind that 4 and $ within any one domain are so far defined only to within an additive constant, which could be any functional of H ;this arbitrariness will be removed later. Now consider a cycle of qa that includes a history increment d H ; physically, this is the only way to vary H but not q in functions of state. In detail, the path in configuration space begins at a point A of the domain H,then proceeds elastically by any route to a point B on the yield surface, then by a specific nonelastic segment (with prescribed injinitesimal length and direction) to a point C on a subsequent yield surface H + dH and finally returns elastically to A by any route within the new domain. Let the resultant “plastic” increment in any quantity be denoted by dP. For instance, d P 4 means 4(q,H + d H ) - $(q, H)and is a function of q, H,and the specific d H . By partial differentiation, (2.26)
dPp, = (a/aqa)(dp4),
showing that the cycle increment in 4 acts as a potential for the increment in pa. Likewise, in the space of the conjugate variables, a cycle of pa via the images of points A, B, C results in (2.27)
dPqa = (a/apa)(dP$)*
More generally, consider any path from A via B and C to a state pa + dp,, qa + dq, in the domain H + d H . Then the increments in the potentials are
d4 = dP4+ p a &a,
d$ = dP$
+
qa
dpu
(2.28)
Aspects of lnvariance in Solid Mechanics
37
by (2.21) and (2.24), respectively. But (2.23) holds also in the domain H dH, and so
+
d p 4 + dP$ = 0,
(2.29)
which is analogous to the passive part of Legendre's dual transformation. For this more general path there are also the differential relations
dPa = dPPa + %p dqp,
dqa = dP% + A
by (2.22) and (2.25). In particular, taking dp,
+
=0
a p
dPp
and dq, = 0 in turn,
dPq, + Aap dPpp= 0,
dPpa gpdPqp= 0,
(2.30)
(2.31)
which are equivalent forms of a connection between the plastic increments of the conjugate variables in the respective cycles. The new constitutive framework is a version of (2.30)that results when the elastic potentials are introduced by (2.26) and (2.27),namely,
d ~ -, y a p dqp = (a/aqa)(dP4), dqa d ~= p (d/dpa)(dP$). (2-32) These are valid throughout a domain, not just at a yield point; the two sets of equations are, of course, equivalent, but the duality is worth preserving. The distinctive feature of this description is the primary role assigned to elasticity, showing how its history dependence gives rise to nonelastic response. In fact, the terms in (2.32) are so arranged that on the left-hand sides there appear, respectively, the plastic increments in pa after cycling q, and in qa after cycling pa, while on the right-hand sides there appear the gradients of the plastic increments in the elastic potentials. To obtain a work interpretation of the latter increments the variations in the values of 4 and $ along nonelastic segments are now made precise. In a cycle of the coordinates the total work is
$
Pa
dqa = [4(41 H)1:
+ J"
C
B
= [+(q,
Pa
dqa + [4(4, H
H + d ~- 4(q, )
+ J"
+ dH)Ic"
C
B
(Pa
dqa - d 4 ) *
It is obviously simplest to choose d 4 = pa dq, along BC, and then automatically d$ = q, dp, since (2.23)is universal. With this choice, the change in 4 is always the work on a possible route between two configurations, whether in the same domain or not; similarly, the change in $ is always the complementary work. In particular,
Rodney Hi 11
38
Further, when a cycle begins on a yield surface, so that A becomes B, these increments vanish to first order since the values of each integrand differ infinitesimally at the same point of segments BC and CB.
2. Invariance and the Normality Rule Within the present framework the constitutive description is completed by specifying the history dependences of the elastic domain and the work potentials. Owing to lack of data at this time, the program can be pursued realistically in certain directions only. One such has to do with the history dependence of 4 and Ic/ near a yield surface. To this end let (2.32) be rewritten as (&a
-3.P
d4,) 84, = 6(dP4),
(AaP
d ~a 4,)8Pa =
- 8(dP$),
(2.34) where the &differentials are at tixed H and so denote purely elastic increments. These expressions are equivalent to one another by (2.29), and to (dpa 84, - 6Pa d4a) = 8
f
Pa
d4a
(2.35)
by (2.22), (2.25),and (2.33),the matrices gap and M a pbeing symmetric. This establishes an affinity with the general bilinear differential form (2.10);in the present context the variations d and 6 have, of course, a special significance. The resulting coordinate invariance of the left-hand side of (2.35), when divided by density p, is confirmed by the connection here with (8 $ dw)/p, which is the difference of the works per unit mass in neighboring cycles of material configuration. According to Ilyushin's axiom (1961) the total work in a cycle of deformation that involves a nonelastic segment is positive. If that were so, even just for evanescent segments (Hill and Rice, 1973), then d P 4 would be positive throughout an elastic domain, by (2.33). However, this carries no implication for 6 ( d P 4 )at interior points. But it does mean that 6 ( d P 4 )2 0
(2.36)
at any point on a yield surface, since dP+ vanishes there by arrangement. Actually, it suffices for (2.36) that Ilyushin's axiom is further restricted to cycles where both elastic segments are evanescent (Hill, 1968). Let it be supposed, then, on whatever grounds, that dP# is positive in some annular neighborhood of a yield surface. Apply (2.34) in a yield-point state; the 8-variations there are directed into the elastic domain but are otherwise arbitrary. We conclude that dpa - YUP dqs, the plastic increment in p., is codirectional with the inward normal to the yield surface in q-space; at a
Aspects of Invariance in Solid Mechanics
39
vertex, if any, it falls within the cone of limiting inward normals. Likewise dq, - &,, dp,, the plastic increment in qa, is codirectional with the outward normal in p-space or else within the cone of limiting outward normals. Moreover, this normality rule is coordinate invariant-always provided that it is expressed in work-conjugate variables. The geometry of the yield surface itself, on the other hand, is obviously affected by the choice of coordinates. In particular, the direction of the normal is not invariant, nor hence the partition of dq, into elastic and plastic components (Hill, 1967a); physically, cycling one set of pa does not automatically cycle any other, even with the current configuration as a common reference. To set these results in perspective it is worth glancing at the situation when potentials 6,II/ do not exist (acknowledging, however, that Cauchy elasticity is judged by many to be unreal). Normality is governed by the definiteness or otherwise of the bilinear forms
z,
-dPPll 6% = %, dPq, &la, dPq, bP, = dPqa 6q, by (2.31) and the first of (2.22), respectively. When Yap # Ppa, however, these two are no longer equivalent in general, and so simultaneous normality in both spaces is not assured. Indeed, coordinate invariance can be proved for the first form only (Hill, 1972; Hill and Rice, 1972). Thus, from (2.6) and (2.8) with the present notation for moduli, (P/P*)(~P,*- YDfSdq,*) = ( d ~ p- q
v dqv)(aqp/dqa*)
which is (l/P*) dPP,*
= (VP) dPP, &I,.
&a*
(2.37)
This is an unpleasing state of affairs and, of course, there is no appeal to observation. So one could abandon conventional normality and propose instead that the bilinear differential invariant should be positive at a yield point (2.38) >0 where dqa and 6% are, respectively, any outward and inward segments. By applying the trapezoid formula (2.4) to the usual cycle of deformation, we find
dPa
- b ~ dqa a
&a
dpa 6 q u - 6Pa d q a = 6
4
Pa dqa + ~ ( Z B - % a ) dqa 6qp
(2.39)
in replacement of (2.35), correct to first order in each variation. This shows incidentally that the right-hand term is coordinate invariant, as seen previously in (2.9) by a purely elastic cycle. Since this term has indefinite sign, Ilyushin’s axiom must also be abandoned; this is no surprise because
40
Rodney Hill
Cauchy elasticity itself is well known to be incompatible with work expenditure in arbitrary cycles (see, for example, Hill, 1968). Pursuing (2.38) by use in turn of the first of (2.22)and (2.25),we find that dp, - 9,, dq, is codirectional with the inward normal in q-space while dq, - A,, dp, is codirectional with the outward normal in p-space (generalizingas usual at a vertex). Thus, an invariant normality rule still holds in each space, but not in relation to plastic increments (since we have here the transposed matrices of elastic moduli and compliances). 3. Normality: The Regular Case In the six-space of the generalized coordinates a yield surface for any actual material may be expected to be smooth, except possibly at isolated vertices (manifolds with dimension 54). Such singularities will be considered later; for the present the implications of the normality rule are analyzed at a regular point. In q-space let I, be chosen codirectional with the unique normal outward from the domain. Define pa in p-space by dpa = Z, dq,, dqa = A a D dp, (2.40) for arbitrary elastic variations, as in (2.22) and (2.25). Then pa is along the outward normal in p-space, and I a = Z,P,, p a = &a, I, (2.41) since the matrices are symmetric. Let pa, q, be a regular yield point at history H, and let dp,, dq, be the nonelastic segment associated with dH, and necessarily such that I, dq, > 0. By the normality rule we have pa dPa = I a
&a
I 0,
dPp, = -I, dy,
dPq, = pa dy,
dy > 0,
(2.42)
where dy is determined by the specific dH. If, correspondingly, we write dP4 = @(q, H ) dy, where @ + Y = 0 by (2.29), then
I, = -aa/aq,,
dp*
= Y(P, H) dy,
pa = aY/ap,
(2.43)
by (2.26) and (2.27), the gradients being evaluated at the yield point. With the assumption that the incremental response is piecewise linear and continuous, d~ = I a dqalg = p a dpalh (2.4) since dy vanishes with I, dq,. Here g and h are scalar functions of state over the yield surface, and g is necessarily positive. Then dPa = Lap dq,,
dqa = Ma, ~ P P , I a dqa > 0
(2.45)
41
Aspects of Invariance in Solid Mechanics where
Map = A a b + ~ a ~ p / h are the matrices of moduli and compliances for the plastic branch of the constitutive law. In retrospect it can be seen that the diagonal symmetry of these matrices is a direct consequence of normality (and conversely implies it, given continuity of response). It remains to relate g and h. By introducing (2.45) in (2.44), one finds that Lap = y a p
- AmAp/g,
g
-h
(2.46)
= Ampb.
It follows that h is not necessarily one-signed and that three types of stress response are conceivable within this framework (Hill, 1967a). These are
h > 0 (strain-hardening),
g > Ampa,
p a dp, > 0;
h < 0 (strain-softening),
g < &pa,
p, dp,
<0;
(2.47)
h = 0 (ideally plastic), = Aapm pa = 0. Thus, starting from the current yield surface in p-space, the yield point moves respectively outward, inward, or tangential (and in this case dq, is not determined uniquely by dp,). With Cauchy elasticity and continuous response, but no normality rule, the dual equations for the plastic branch have the structure (Hill, 1967a) Lap
=yap
- la
Map = A a p
+m,~o
(2.48)
where
1, = =qbaPLg? P, = Jqd, are normals to the yield surfaces as before, and (2.49) are codirectional with the plastic increments in the generalized variables. There is also the consequential connection (1 + Army)(1 - P S l d ) = 1 which parallels (2.46). Finally, since nonelastic segments are defined by " dpa = A, dq, > 0, 1-P d b
the respective criteria for hardening or softening are pdld < 1 or > 1. It should be kept in mind, however, that hardening is a relative term. dependent on the choice of coordinates, like the partition of dq,. In detail, if the magnitude assigned to the normal A, is arbitrarily adjusted under change
Rodney Hill
42
of coordinates in such a way that I , d q a / p is invariant, then I , transforms like pa. Correspondingly, by (2.37) and the first of (2.48), dy and 1, dq, are also invariant; hence so is g / p when 1, = I , / g as in (2.45). Since I , d q , / p = pa9,, dq,/p and Yap transforms as in (2.8), the transformation rule for pa may be stated thus: pad a , / p is invariant when a, transforms like pa in (2.6). So the change in pais not simple. In consequence neither is the change in ma by (2.49)nor in h by (2.46).Explicit formulae are given by Hill (1967a) in the case when the coordinates are varied within the class of tensor measures of strain with the current configuration as reference. The notion of relative convexity, defined in (2.20),can be nicely illustrated with the constitutive relations (2.40) and (2.45). We aim to compare this piecewise-linear response with the hypothetical linear responses defined (over the entire dq-space) by the moduli Y,, and La,, respectively, and we begin by setting up connections between the associated second-degree forms in the A-differences.The piecewise-linear relations can be expressed in terms of the respective moduli as dPa = Y a p dq, - Ia dy = L., dq, - Ia delg, where d o = g dy - I , dq,,
d B 2 0 if d y = 0 ,
de = O
if d y > 0.
Then A(dPa) A(dqm) = g a b A(dqa) A(dq,) - Ja A(&,) A(dy) A\(&) - L a 44,)A(de)/g* Now A(d0) A(dy) 5 0 with equality if and only if the two increments are both elastic or both nonelastic, while I , A(dqa) A(d0) I 0 with equality if and only if they are both nonelastic ( g being positive). So = La,
L., A(dqa) A(dq,) I A(dPa) A(dqa) I ZfiA(dqa) A(@,)
- A ( ~ YA(dy)* )
(2.50) The conclusion is that the actual piecewise-linear response is more convex than a hypothetical linear response with moduli &,, but less convex than one with moduli gap. A prototype theorem of this kind was first obtained by Hill (1958). Note that the continued inequality can be written as 1
A(&) 5 -A(dPpa) 44,)5 IaIp 44,)A(dq,)/g, where every term is individually coordinate invariant, and hence also the absolute convexity of the relation between -dPp, and dq,. Dual inequalities can be proved in identical fashion, starting from
0I
dqa = d
a b
d ~+ p P a dy = Ma, d ~ + p Pa de/h
43
Aspects of Invariance in Solid Mechanics where d 6 = h dy - p a dp,,
d6 2 0 if dy = 0 ,
d6=O
if dy >O.
The outcome is &a*
A(dpu) A ( ~ P ,+ ) h A ( ~ YA) ( ~ Y5) A(dpa) A(dqu) 5 Ma, A(dpa) A ( ~ P * ) , (2.51)
with equality on the left if and only if the two increments are both elastic or both nonelastic; and equality on the right if they are both nonelastic, but otherwise the stated ordering provided h > 0. There are some cross-links between (2.50) and (2.51): the left and right sides of the latter respectively exceed those of the former, the differences being (Ad6)2/g and (Ad6)2/h.Also, the right-hand inequality in (2.50) and the left-hand inequality in (2.51) are directly connected by the identity
when written for the A-differences and the present constitutive law. However, though the relation between dPqa and dp, is convex when h > 0 and by (2.31) implies convexity of the relation between - dPpuand dq, when Tab is positive definite, we recall that neither condition is coordinate invariant. In the context ofinfinitesimaldeformations Hill (1967b)has analyzed the transmission of such constitutive inequalities from micro- to macro-levels of observation (single crystal to aggregate, say). 4. Normality: The Singular Case
A typical vertex will be supposed convex pyramidal with n tangent hyperplanes (n 2 2). Possible elastic increments from the yield point thus satisfy a set of nonredundant inequalities p: dp, = 1,' 64, I 0,
i = 1, .. ., n.
The outward normals to the hyperplanes in the dual spaces are codirectional with AUi,pai, which are related by (2.41) for each i = 1, . . . ,n. By the normality rule, Ya,jdq, - dp, = Lai dy',
dq, - Mas dp, = p: dy',
dy' 2 0,
(2.52)
with the summation convention, where the n scalars dy' are in principle determined by a specific d H . Correspondingly, the plastic increments in the elastic potentials are d p 4 = @(q, H ) dy',
dP$ = '€"(p,H ) dy'
Rodney Hill
44
+
where 0' Y' = 0 by (2.29), and
1;
=
-aa+/aqar
= aYi/ap,
by (2.26) and (2.27). The gradients here are evaluated at the yield point, of course, and 80' = -Aa' dq, 2 0, dY' = pai dp, I0 in its elastic neighborhood. Piecewise linearity and continuity of incremental response are assumed. In contrast to the regular case, however, this does not carry the analysis much farther. The domain external to the yield pyramid in dq-space can still be dissected arbitrarily by hyperplanes into any number of other pyramids; and in each of these a distinct linear response of type dy' = c,' dq, can be assigned, subject only to continuity between branches as across the yield surface. It is usual to prescribe a dissection indirectly, by laying down connections between dy' and dq,. A possible framework considered by Hill and Rice (1972) in relation to slip deformation of single crystals can be adopted also for aggregates, as suggested independently by Sewell (1972). Suppose that 1,' dq, = g'j dy', when dy' # 0, while 1,' dq, 5 g'j dy', when dy' = 0, where the moduli g'j are functions of state at the vertex; symmetry of matrix (g'j) is not assumed. A suggestion by Sewell (1972, 1974) is advantageous here: any such system of constraints can be rephrased as a set of equations, namely, 9" dy' - 1,' dq, = dB',
de' dy' = 0,
(2.53)
where every dy' and do' is nonnegative. With the hardening moduli
hi' = g i j
- &ipaj
(2.54)
defined in the spirit of ( 2 4 3 , the dual set of equations appears as
hi' dy' - p i dp,
= do',
do' dy' = 0
(2.55)
by (2.52). Qualitative features of the dissections of dp-space obtained from various types of matrix (h'j) are reviewed by Hill (1966); for instance, the dissection is by the pyramidal yield-planes themselves only when (h'j) is diagonal. In passing, the formulae -dPp, dq, = 9" dy' dy',
dPq, dp,
= h"
dy' dy'
should be noticed. Before proceeding farther, the effect of transforming the generalized coordinates should be ascertained. Let the arbitrary magnitude of each normal 2,' be so adjusted that 1,'dq,/p is invariant. Then, by (2.37) and the first of (2.52), each dy' is invariant and consequently the moduli g'j simply vary as the reference density p. Hereafter it is stipulated that matrix (g'j) is positive definite, which is therefore a coordinate invariant requirement (with the incidental implication that dPpa dq, 5 0, going beyond the normality rule).
Aspects of Invariance in Solid Mechanics
45
This stipulation has the effect that (2.52) augmented by (2.53) becomes sufficient to determine dp, when a nonelastic dq, is assigned. A short proof by contradiction goes as follows. Supposing two responses possible, let prefix A denote the difference of any pair of like differentials. Thus
de'
+ A(d0') 2 0,
dy'
+ A(dy') 2 0
subject to
{de'
+ A(dO')}{dy'+ A(dy')} = 0,
and so
A(de') A(dy') I 0.
(2.56)
g" A(dy') A(dy') > 0
(2.57)
By hypothesis, for distinct responses, regardless of the signs of A(dy'). On the other hand, A(dq,) = 0 in (2.53)implies g'j A(dyj) = A(dOi), with resulting incompatibility of (2.56) and (2.57).Hence the set of dy' is unique and so is dp, given by (2.52). When (gij)is not positive definite, examples can easily be constructed where uniqueness fails. In just the same way, positive definite (h'j) is required for unique dy' and dq, when dp, is given. However, the latter requirement is not coordinate invariant; indeed, as was seen even in the regular case, the transformation of h'j is quite complex. But by (2.54) we do have a simple connection between the respective pair of quadratic forms in n variables:
(g" - hi') A(dy') A(d#) = YaD(A: Ady')(A#j Ad#).
(2.58)
Their difference is thus another quadratic form which can be arranged in the six variables :A A(dy'), with matrix (YUs). With this arrangement it must be kept in mind that the variables can vanish collectively for certain nonzero A(dy'), namely those that correspond to any linear dependences between the vertex normals. A necessary and sufficient condition for dependence is the vanishing of the n x n Gram determinant, det(AJr2,'); of course, this happens automatically when n > 6 (the dimensionality of coordinate space). That being said, it obviously suffices for (2.57)that matrix ( V j )be positive definite when, as we shall suppose, the matrix (YUs) of elastic moduli is positive definite (for metal crystals and polycrystals this will ordinarily be the case with conventional choices of coordinates). However, it can then happen in practice that matrix (h'j) is not positive definite, but semidelinite or indefinite, as for instance in crystals deforming by slip when self-hardening of the slip systems is less than their latent hardening. It can happen, too, with artificial though seemingly plausible hardening rules; for example, both det(h'j) and det(g'j) vanish identically when n > 6 if h" = cup&'A$ with any
Rodney Hill
46
coefficients c,, (since h'jqj = 0 for qj such that A,'q' = 0). So the question arises: how can (2.57) be prearranged when matrix (h'j) is indefinite in coordinates for which matrix (Y,,) is positive definite? This is crucial for theories of texture development under progressive deformation, where lack of uniqueness in response has been a serious drawback in the past. In partial answer, one can note that when the vertex normals are independent it suffices for (2.57) that the now-positive Y,, form should dominate the sometimes negative h'j form. Put otherwise, the all-around elastic stiffness of the material must be sufficiently pronounced; in theoretical calculations this can easily be arranged by proportionately increasing the moduli gap. A continued inequality analogous to (2.50) is available under the condition (2.57) guaranteeing uniqueness. For this purpose we need only the matrix of moduli for the particular plastic branch where every dy' > 0 ; by (2.53) this corresponds to the domain of dq-space such that g! A,' d4, > 0 ( i = 1, . . ., n), where g! are elements of the matrix inverse to (g'j). From (2.52) the associated moduli are
hp= Yap - g'l1 I&j.
(2.59)
Note that this matrix is not symmetric unless g'j = SJ'. The derivation now runs on similar lines, beginning with W
P
U
)
A(d4a) = -%a A(d4u) A(d4,) - L,i A(d4a) A(dy') = &p A(d4,) A(d4,) - g! 1 I,' A(d4,) A(dfP).
Appealing next to (2.56) and to g! I,' A(d4,) A(d@ = A(d0') A(dy') - g!
A(dB') A(d@) 5 0,
we obtain Lap
A(d4.z) A(d4,) 5 A(@,) A(d4u) 5 Y a p A(d4a) A(d4,) - 9" A(dy') A(d?).
(2.60) The left-hand inequality is due to Sewell (1972, 1974); it states the (coordinate invariant) relative convexity of the actual piecewise-linear response compared to the hypothetical linear response with moduli (2.59). The righthand inequality is due to Hill and Rice (1972); in view of (2.57) it implies convexity of the relations between -dPpa and d4,. The dual continued inequality, analogous to (2.51), is A(dpu) A ( ~ P @ + )hi' A(dy') A(&') 5 A(dpu) A(d4a) 5 M a p A(dpa) A ( d ~ p ) * (2.61) Here the matrix (2.62) Ma, = Jab + h! lpa'p,' Ja,
Aspects of Invariance in Solid Mechanics
47
is inverse to (L,#)in (2.59) while matrix (h! is inverse to ( h i j ) , which must be supposed positive definite. The left-hand inequality is due to Hill (1966); the right-hand inequality has not been found in the literature. As in the regular case, there are cross-links between (2.60) and (2.61).For instance, the left and right sides of the latter, respectively, exceed those of the former; the differences are g!! A(de') A(d@), as noted by Havner (1977a,b), and h! A(d@)A(d6'). A final remark is relevant to the subsequent account of boundary-value problems for an elastoplastic continuum, in particular the self-adjointnessof the differential system and the existence of a variation principle. We have already noted that matrices (Las)and (Mu&are symmetric if and only if (g'j) and (hi') are, and this can be said of every branch. Equivalently, as may be shown directly from (2.53) and the first of (2.52), dP, Wq,) = dq, WP,) = W P , dq,)
(2.63)
for nonelastic d-increments and arbitrary infinitesimal &variations (of course, the last equality is trivially consequent on the first). Whence (Hill, 1966) the constitutive relations admit a potential function, in that
(2.64) where 2U = dp, dq,. In principle this is expressible as a piecewise quadratic form in dq, or dp,, respectively, via and the branch relations for dy'
C. SOME TYPES OF ELASTIC RESPONSE It is not in my terms of reference to review the present status of theoretical elasticity. Purely within the confines of constitutive analyses, and in the spirit of this article, I aim only to glance at a few developments and to highlight one or two outstanding problems. It is convenient to begin with macro-isotropic artificial rubbers. In the matter of constructing phenomenological work-functions, Treloar (1973, 1976) is a valuable source of all-round information. The unstressed ground state will be taken as reference, and as usual w denotes the free energy per unit reference volume. Until fairly recently, following the precedent set by Mooney and other pioneers, it was customary to fit empirical data only by functions w of polynomial invariants of the stretch tensor, and often the proposed functions were disagreeably complicated. In departing from this tradition, my 1969 paper was (if I am not mistaken) the first (i) to emphasize
48
Rodney Hill
that any symmetricfunction of the stretches is admissible in principle as a candidate w , and (ii) to add point to that remark by showing that the resulting mathematics can actually be made simpler than with invariants as arguments. Elsewhere I noted correspondingly (1969 unpublished, except for a footnote in Ogden 1972a) that empirical data for quasi-incompressible rubbers at very large stretches could be well represented by a simple function, namely w = (p/n)Tr E(")
(2.65)
where E(") is the strain measure defined in (1.52), but 2n need not be an integer. The principal Cauchy stresses satisfy a, - 6,= 2p(e? - ep)),
r Z s,
so p is the classical shear modulus at zero strain. Ogden (1972a)carried this line of enquiry much farther and was notably successful in fitting all the data available from the standard tests on continuum rubbers, just by additive combinations of such functions: (c(")Tr
w= n
E'")},
(nc'")},
p=
(2.66)
n
where the paired values of n and c(") are disposable (only three being needed in general). Changes of volume in both continuum and foam rubbers can be accounted for by an extra additive function of the volume ratio, I, A,& (Ogden, 1972b, 1976). A mathematically attractive proposal of this type, which I have not seen in the literature except for a hint by'Blatz and KO (1962), is
where the parameter v is a generalized Poisson's ratio. The principal Kirchhoff stresses are
If, now, the path of deformation is such that I z = I 3 = A T v it can be seen in the formulae for z2 = z3 that each summed term vanishes separately. This path is therefore produced by uniaxial stress zl, and the ratio of logarithmic transverse contraction to longitudinal extension has the constant value v. Some support for this distinctive property of (2.67) was reported for a polyurethane foam rubber (50% voids by volume) by Blatz and KO, who favored just the single term n = - 1 with v = 2. Whether (2.67) itself has any
Aspects of Inuariance in Solid Mechanics
49
future remains to be seen, but the general notion of conjugate measures of stress and strain does seem to offer a suggestive framework that ought to be explored. Just to mention one example,
F")= Iz Tr E(")I + 2pE'")
(2.69)
where I , p, n are all disposable, admits an isotropic work function and might be regarded as a natural generalization of Hooke's law. Elasticity of a completely different kind is exhibited by a monatomic crystal. Regardless of the interaction "forces," geometric symmetry by itself ensures that any primitive (Bravais) lattice of atoms can be equilibrated by surface loading ("at infinity") alone. Our standpoint will be that every primitive lattice can be regarded, quite simply, as a homogeneous deformation A of a simple cubic array; this is a unifying view not found in conventional texts on crystallography. Then, adopting this array as a convenient reference configuration (with the nearest-neighbor spacing as the unit of length and the cubic axes as background coordinates), the problem is construct appropriate work-functions w ( A ) .As observed by Ericksen (1970), aside from the trivial requirement w(QA) = w ( A ) for every proper orthogonal Q , it is necessary that w ( A q fW(A)
(2.70)
for every unimodular r with integer coefficients. Such deformation gradients r map the simple cubic array onto itself. For, if 6 is a node, so obviously is any l-6 since the components of 5 are integers. Conversely, if q is any node, a 5 can always be found with integer coefficients such that l-6 = q, because the inverse matrix r-' also has f integer coefficients when det r = 1. The group of all such r has just two generators; they can be chosen, for instance, as a rotation of 120" about the direction ( 1 11) and a unit shear over a cube face parallel to a cubic axis. If, now, we consider a deformed configuration A, the new associated group i= of self-mappings is easily identified. Thus, the configuration r becomes Ar under A, while A itself is converted into AT by
r = ArB:
(2.71)
r
It is of course the rotation subgroups of that give rise to the crystallographic classification of lattice symmetries. From our standpoint it is more interesting to remark that (2.71) can be put as
B T A = r,
(2.72)
r
which by (1.11) expresses the invariance of the mixed representation y!, of on the A cell. To date, the construction of closed-form work functions subject to (2.70)
50
Rodney Hill
has not been solved satisfactorily. The exceptional difficulty of the task can be understood from the investigations by Parry (1976, 1977). Of course, if the atomic interactions are modeled by pairwise forces, there is then the classical formula (2.73) w= +(r2)
+1
where the summation extends over all bonds on one atom in the infinite cubic array; r is a typical internodal distance after deformation, and +(r2) is the potential energy of a single pair of atoms. Such infinite sums automatically have the property (2.70), but they are inconvenient in applications. Also, the pairwise model is not too realistic in its macropredictions, except for nickel and a few other substances. For example, regardless of what may be, an inevitable consequence is that the Green moduli have "Cauchy symmetry," viz.
+
g$ = ggjI
(2.74)
not just in the ground state (as is well known) but also under load (Hill, 1975). Specifically,since r2 = (Sij 2eIf))tit j ,
+
It can be recognized from (1.96) that Cauchy symmetry under load does not hold for any other scale function. 111. Bifurcation Theory A. FIRST-ORDER RATEPROBLEM
1. Field Equations
From now on our concern is with the inhomogeneous response of a finite continuum to a quasi-static loading program, and especially with whether or not the response is unique. Constitutive laws will be applied pointwise and are taken to be incrementally linear or piecewise linear, in the sense we have described ; more generally, whenever the analysis allows, the relation between rates of stress and strain can be nonlinear homogeneous of degree one. Various types of incremental loading are envisaged and will be detailed, in particular some that are deformation sensitive; for the moment, though, it is enough to say that all types impose some local condition on the surface velocity and/or its gradient, separately or conjointly. Within the continuum the quasi-static velocity must satisfy second-order equations of continuing
Aspects of Inuariance in Solid Mechanics
51
equilibrium, which will be obtained presently. Supposing that the current geometry, material properties, and state of stress are known, these field equations together with the surface data pose a well-set boundary-value problem for the velocity distribution at each stage of the loading program. This is the first-order “rate problem,” and suitably analytic solutions are called deformation modes. A critical stage may be reached where there exists more than one mode, usually infinitelymany, which is a phenomenon customarily referred to as bifurcation. This strictly means a simple branching of the path of deformation, and in fact the nonuniqueness is probably always reducible to that by reference to rate problems of higher order (for the quasi-static acceleration, etc.); naturally, this involves a sufficiently close specification of the subsequent loading. We shall not venture into this territory here; practically all that is known is limited to continua with simple geometries and to general systems with finite freedoms (e.g., Hill and Sewell, 1960, 1962; Budiansky, 1974; Hutchinson, 1974; Thompson and Hunt, 1973). The field equations will be written from a Lagrangian standpoint, in terms of the tensor of nominal stress nij (Section I,D,4) based on a past or present configuration of the continuum. The reference coordinates of a typical particle are denoted by &, a volume element by d l , and a surface element by d&. Body forces are admitted and are written as y j per unit reference volume. Then, for any part of the continuum, the global equations of linear equilibrium are
jnij dXi + 5 y j d< = 0 which, by the divergence theorem and the usual argument, imply (an,j/aei)
+
=0
(34 locally. Differentiationby a timelike parameter is of course immediate in this formulation, so the first-order equations of continuing equilibrium are just yj
+
(ahij/agi) f j = 0 (34 where nij and f j are rates of change following a particle. From the global rate equation, applied in the standard manner to a disklike volume at an interior jump surface of tiij, it can be deduced that the nominal traction-rate is continuous. The rate of deformation, previously denoted hij, where aij is the deformation gradient a x i / a c i , will henceforth be written as d u i / d r j in terms of the velocity ui. Correspondingly, the rate equations (1.99) for an incrementally linear material are nij
= wijkdt)(aut/atrJ
(3.3)
Rodney Hill
52
where possible spatial variations of the pseudomoduli are indicated by the bracketed symbol 5. Any branch of a piecewise-linear material can be written similarly, provided one keeps in mind that the moduli depend on the particular domain of velocity-gradient space. More generally (Hill, 1959), we could envisage a thoroughly nonlinear response of type
where the potential U is a function of the velocity gradient, necessarily homogeneous of degree two. U is a functional also of the deformation history, while under change of reference configuration it varies simply as the reference density. Relations (3.3) admit as potential the quadratic form
au. aU, u = -1 vijkl(<)
when
J
2
a
%?ijkl
= gklij.
(3.5)
According to (1.100) this symmetry required of the pseudomoduli implies the same symmetry for the objective moduli associated with Green’s scale function, and hence with any other, since diagonal symmetry of the generalized moduli is coordinate invariant by (2.8). As we saw in connection with (2.9), this characterizes any incrementally linear response that is, in a minimal sense, conservative; in particular, therefore, it is automatic for an elastic material that admits a strain-energy potential. For elastoplastic materials we noted in (2.45) its presence at a regular yield point under the normality rule; and, in (2.64),at a singular yield point also when the hardening moduli (2.54) are symmetric. The existence of U is associated with a “reciprocal relation” i i js(aU,/a<,)= (auj/at,)hitij
(3.6) where in general the &variation must be infinitesimal. Exceptionally, when U is the simple quadratic form ( 3 . 9 6uj can be replaced by the finite difference Auj = uj* - uj and we can write equivalently
riij(aUj*/agi)= ir;(auj/ati). From the reciprocal relation there follows the identity
a
(0. J
air..- n.. 60.) J 1J
1J
which establishes the self-adjointness of the field equations and leads immediately by integration to a reciprocal theorem
juj 6yj d< +
uj 6nij d X i =
s
y j 6uj d t
+ 5 tiij 6uj dZi,
(3.7)
Aspects of Invariance in Solid Mechanics
53
within the class of fields satisfying (3.2), (3.4), and the interior jump condition. In particular, for incrementally-linear response, Avj can replace 60, in (3.7), with the result
which is analogous to Betti's theorem in classical elasticity.
2. Surface Data The main categories of loading will now be formulated analytically. The intention is to illustrate the range of possibilities, not to produce an exhaustive classification. Several categories will subsequently be brought within an overall notation, which is a useful shorthand in the analysis of bifurcation. Those that cannot will be treated separately, as we explain by an example. However, once the theoretical guidelines are understood, the procedure for any type of loading is virtually routine. Some standard kinematical formulae are assembled for convenience at the outset. They relate to an embedded surface element whose vector area is dCi = vi dC in the reference configuration, when t = 0 say, and is dSi = ni dS when t 2 0 (both normals are unit and outward from the material). Then at t = 0 we have the convected derivatives
d dS dt -
=
auj
( 6 , - njnl) - dS, 3x1
d dSi = (ni djk - nj 8 i k ) dt
-
where on the right-hand sides d C , v i , tiare replaced by dS, ni, x i to indicate that the current configuration is being taken as reference. An immediate application is to loading by a uniformly pressurized fluid. The vector load on a surface element is
nij(t)d Z i = - p ( t ) dSj(t), where p is the Cauchy pressure. So tiij
and hence, by (3.8),
dSi = - p dSj - p ( d / d t ) dSj,
t 2 0, t
= 0,
Rodney Hill
54
in the current configuration taken as reference. This is a case of “deformation sensitive” (configuration-dependent)loading, which typically is characterized by linear terms in the velocity or its gradient. Their presence is due to factors beyond the control of the experimenter, who for example can here only prescribe p and @.It may be remarked that, with any kind ofexternally applied loading, the net contribution from the gradient terms can arise only from in-surface deformations. Since what happens in the body of the material makes dui/dxj at the surface uncertain to the extent of an additive term qi nj, where qi is an undetermined vector function over S, the net contribution of such dyadic products to the load rate expression is necessarily nil. This is a useful check on the validity of any proposed formula; thus (qlnj q k nk bjI)nI= 0 in (3.9). Loading via contact with a tool is the most common arrangement in engineering practice. The tool may be a movable die or punch, or a fixed foundation or container, and in the simplest case it can be supposed smooth and rigid. Then, when the motion of the tool is predetermined, the vector velocity of each particle of its surface is known, but only the normal component of velocity of the contiguous particle of material, and that only if contact is maintained. So, during a continuous process, we have the following conditional data, with p in (3.9) now standing for the local contact pressure (which in principle is known at t = 0) and uiT denoting the given local velocity of the tool. If p > 0 then ni(ui - u,’) = 0; if p = 0 then either ni(ui- ui’) = 0 with i, > 0, or ni(u, - u,’) I 0 with p = 0.
(3.10)
This data must be complemented by the no-friction condition, and here one must beware of a too-facile analogy with the classical mixed data in infinitesimal elasticity. The nominal traction-rate over the surface is not necessarily purely normal (contrary to statements in the literature), but its tangential component must actually be calculated. Either formally via (3.8) and (3.9), or by a simple ad hoc argument, we have
(aij - ninj)tikjdSk = -pii dS.
(3.1 1)
On the right-hand side the variation of n, follows a material particle of S, and comes partly from any curvature of the tool surface and partly from any rigid-body rotation: )li
= Kij(Uj
- Uj’)
+ eijkoj‘nk
(3.12)
where eijk is the alternating tensor, ojTis the spin of the tool, and K i j is the local curvature tensor of S. If, as is feasible, we arbitrarily choose its com-
Aspects of Invariance in Solid Mechanics ponents so that
icij nj
55
= 0, then
icij =
(6ik - nink)(6, - njn,)
where F ( x , , x2, x3) = 0 is the equation of the surface. A quite different kind of deformation-sensitive loading, discussed by Nemat-Nasser (1968), among others, involves tangential “follower forces.” Here the local traction is perpetually tangent to an embedded fiber element of the surface. It is hard to imagine how this could be realized in practice, except in mean as a resultant over a small but finite area; an example might be a slender column compressed by a terminal force, whose line of action is tied to the centroidal axis. We can write nij(t) dZi = q ( t ) m j ( t )dS(t),
t 2 0,
where m j is the running unit tangent to the fiber element, and qmj = ni aij.By another standard formula, one has
(d/dt)mi= (6ik - mimk)mj(avk/8xj)
(3.13)
at t = 0. If the force magnitude qdS is held fixed, for instance, then tiij
dSi = q(hj, - m,m,)mk(do,/dxk) dS
(3.14)
in the current configuration taken as reference. If, alternatively, the force magnitude is maintained proportional to the fiber length, the nominal traction vector varies as if it were itself embedded in the deformation, so that tiij dSi = qmk(dvj/dxk) dS.
(3.15)
Albeit highly artificial, this case features prominently in the well-known book on elastic stability by Bolotin (1963). These examples, along with others, suggest that all worthwhile cases of nonconditional data can be treated collectively under a unified formalism (Hill, 1962): (3.16) tiij dSi = (Cj dS
+A)
where cj is the controllable part of the incremental loading (independent of material response) and f, is the deformation-sensitive part (a linear homogeneous expression in the velocity and its gradient, allowing for deformability of both tool and material). For instance in (3.9) we have c j = -pn’
j,
f’= P(6iI J
6jk
-
6ij hkl)ni(avl/axk),
(3.17)
while in (3.14) and (3.15) cj is zero andfi is the coefficient of dS as stated. In general the velocity gradient contributions can be written as niejk.(av, /&k) ifdesired, where &jk[nink = 0 (it can happen that e j k t = - q,ilbut this iS
Rodney Hill
56
not necessary).Then, for example, when cj = 0 and there is no direct velocity contribution tofi, the surface data can be put as
fli(Wijk1- q j k l ) aul/axk = 0, from (3.3) with the current configuration as reference. Now consider the following mixed data over the surface S of a continuum. A part S’ is fully constrained so that the vector velocity is prescribed; over the remainder S - S’ the loading is of type (3.16) with at least piecewise continuous cj and These data are called “homogeneous” when S’ is fixed and cj vanishes over S - S’; otherwise they are called “inhomogeneous.” Homogeneous data are said to be “self-adjoint” when
fi.
(fiuj*
- ujfi*) dS
=
I (s Auj
- uj
Afi) dS = 0
(3.18)
where uj and uj* are any pair of continuous and piecewise-continuously differentiable fields whose difference Auj = uj* - uj vanishes over S‘. Sincefi is linear homogeneous, equivalent definitions are
5 (fi6uj - u j S f j ) dS
=0
and
jfi 6uj = iS
u j f j dS
(3.19)
where, within the admissible class of continuous and piecewise-continuously differentiable fields, uj is arbitrary while Suj is any infinitesimal variation that vanishes over S . A work interpretation can be had via (1.86) and (2.4), from which we obtain the second-order formula
5 (nij + ;anij) 6uj dSi
(3.20)
for the virtual work of surface tractions over S in an incremental displacement Suj. Apply this to each of two routes to xi + uj* 6t, namely, direct or via xi uj 6t. The difference in the contributions by the deformationsensitive part of the loading is f(6t)2 x (3.18), which must vanish if this part is conservative in a minimal global sense. To illustrate the self-adjointness criterion we can apply it to fluid-pressure loading. Suppose (3.17) is given over a part S” of the surface. The contribution to (3.18) is reducible to
+
p
curl(v A 6v) d S .
Thus, if the integral of v A 6v round the perimeter of S” is to vanish, S must adjoin only S and not another part of S - S’. Correspondingly, the virtual work of a constant pressure is - p times volume swept out by S”, which is unique only when the motion of its perimeter is prescribed.
Aspects of Inuariance in Solid Mechanics
57
A final remark on pressure loading may be of interest to amplify the preceding statement. The volume swept out by a nonuniform finite displacement u in taking an open surface C into another surface S can be expressed as
3
1
u . (dS
+ dI;) + $
I
u . {(Tr A)I - A’} dC
where dS = I A 1 B dZ as in (1.32). An equivalent formula, here less attractive, was given by Pearson (1956).The first variation of this volume, namely its difference from that swept out by u + 6u, is expressible as
j6u
*
dS
+ f (dur\u).(I + 2 A ) d 5
where the line integral is round the perimeter of C.Since the first term is the volume generated by 6u from S , the geometric interpretation of the second term is obvious; moreover, its structure links it directly with the line integral in the preceding criterion for self-adjointness. Further information on deformation sensitivity in general, and on conservative loadings in particular, can be found in Sewell (1965, 1967). 3. Solution Properties Before embarking on a bifurcation analysis we mention some elementary properties of any solution of the rate problem, whether unique or not. We begin with a statement of the principle of virtual work in terms of the present variables. Let uj be a continuous and piecewise-continuously differentiable field of velocity such that the constitutively associated tiij satisfies (3.2) and applies a continuous traction over any interior jump surface of duj/axi and tiij itself. Let 6uj be any continuous and piecewise-continuously differentiable field whatever, not necessarily infinitesimal. Then (3.21) by the divergence transformation. Now assume the existence of a velocity-gradient potential as in (3.4).By the choice 6oj a v j in (3.21),or by direct transformation, 2
I
1
U d( = nijvj d &
+j
i)jvj
dt,
(3.22)
which stands in analogy to Clapeyron’s formula in linearized elasticity. However, the surface data here are much more diverse, as we have seen. Suppose, for example, that the data are homogeneous and that j J j = 0 within
Rodney Hi 11
58
S, as when the body forces are solely due to the Earth’s gravitational field. The whole rate problem is then homogeneous and in general can have only a null solution, but there may be special configurations, or eigenstates, that admit nontrivial modes uj = wj,say. For these (3.22) reduces to
1U(W)d t
=f
~S,(W)W,dS
(3.23)
when S‘ is fixed and S - S is subject to (3.16) with c j = 0. (For clarity, function dependence on wjor its gradient is made explicit by the bracketed symbol w.)Note, incidentally, that in (3.22) the quantities U d t , ij d t , and nij dXi are invariant for the same material particles under change of reference configuration. So, if preferred, the volume integral in (3.23) could be over the current configuration provided the meaning of symbol U is mentally adjusted. Returning to (3.21) we can rearrange it as
if 6uj is infinitesimal and vanishes over C’.A true variation principle is obtained when the data over S - S’ is self-adjoint as in (3.16)with (3.19), and then (Hill, 1962)
{V(v) - i;uj} d t
-
j
s-S’
{cj
+ fh(v)}uj dS
1
=0
(3.24)
and conversely (by reversing the analytical steps and applying the standard argument of the calculus of variations). In the homogeneous problem corresponding to (3.24) an eigenmode is characterized by
6
[ U(w)
dt -3
1
1
f;(w)wjdS = 0
s-S’
(3.25)
in addition to (3.23), and conversely. When converted into finite-element procedures, of one kind or another, the two principles are currently the preferred basis for computations of deformation paths and primary bifurcations.
B. PRIMARY BIFURCATION 1. Linear Case
With incrementally linear response the inhomogeneous rate problem is linear, and so its solution is unique when and only when the current configuration is not an eigenstate for the associated homogeneous rate prob-
Aspects of Invariance in Solid Mechanics
59
lem. In fact, the difference of distinct velocity solutions would be an eigenmode, while, conversely, arbitrary multiples of an eigenmode could be added to one solution to generate others. Thus, to guarantee uniqueness it is enough to exclude the possibility of eigenmodes. By reference to (3.23) a clearly sufficient condition is
I
4
U(w*) d l - Ifi(w*)wj* dS > 0
(3.26)
for all analytically admissible fields wj* that vanish over S’ but are not identically zero. This expression will be called the “exclusion functional.” To obtain a work interpretation we recall from (3.20) that the secondorder work done by the surface loads and body forces in a virtual displacement 6uj is
I (nij+ 46nij)
6uj dSi
+ I y j 6uj dx
with the current configuration as reference. Likewise, the second-order virtual work of internal deformation is
I
+
(nij f6nij)
a axi (6uj) dx.
-
The energy deficit is therefore
a
f j6nij - (6uj) dx - f j anij 6uj dSi axi
since the first-order terms cancel (virtual work principle) because the current distributions of stress and body forces are in equilibrium. Here bnijwithin S must be calculated from U(6u), with the current configuration as reference, while 6nij over S - S’ must be calculated fromfj(6u). So the deficit is
under fixed constraint over S’, from which we recognize that the exclusion condition prevents eigenmodes simply by ensuring an insufficiency of energy available for eoery admissible displacement. In particular, therefore, for an elastic continuum in a conservative environment, the condition coincides with the classical criterion of stability; this connection was originally made explicit by Hill (1957b), at the same time emphasizing the simplifications resulting from the present Lagrangian formulation. We must now assess the criticality of the exclusion condition, by examining the circumstances of its incipient failure. For this purpose consider a
Rodney Hill
60
path of deformation (actual or conceptual) which is generated by some monotonically varying parameter (a load or a modulus or a geometric dimension, etc.), beginning where the exclusion functional is positive. Suppose that a stage is eventually reached beyond which the functional becomes indefinite. In general the functional at this stage is semidefinite and vanishes for some admissible field. It is evident that such a field necessarily renders the functional stationary. In an eigenstate, by comparison, a mode wj makes the functional vanish (3.23),but need not make it stationary, as we saw in the rearrangement of (3.21). But when the deformation-sensitive data are selfadjoint, the exclusion condition is critical in that either a primary eigenstate does occur where it first fails, by the converse to (3.25), or (for instance) the configuration beyond which it ceases to hold is a point of accumulation for the spectrum of eigenstates. This latter phenomenon has been encountered in particular cases by Biot (1965), Hill and Hutchinson (1975), and Young (1976); there may, of course, be other kinds of pathological behavior. In passing, it may be remarked that inhomogeneous data cannot be prescribed freely in an eigenstate if the rate problem is to admit a solution (cf. an algebraic system of linear equations whose determinant is zero). For example, when there are fixed constraints over C' and the deformationsensitive data over C - C' are self-adjoint, we see by choosing uj* = w j in the reciprocal theorem (3.7) and using (3.18) that the inhomogeneous data must comply with
jyjwj d< + jc j w j dCi = 0 for every distinct eigenmode. This may be regarded as a generalized orthogonality, requiring that the controllable part of the incremental loading should have no component in the eigendirection, so to say. When the inhomogeneous rate problem is self-adjoint and the exclusion condition holds, it can be shown that the guaranteed unique solution makes the functional in (3.24) an absolute extremum over the entire class of admissible velocity fields. We start from (3.26), putting uj* - uj in place of wj*, where uj and vj* are any distinct fields taking the values given over C'. After rearrangement and use of (3.18), we obtain
Now take uj to be the actual solution; the expression on the right transforms to cj(uj* - u j ) dS. yj(uj* - u j ) d< +
j
j
s-S'
Aspects of Invariance in Solid Mechanics
61
Hence the functional in (3.24), evaluated with any vj*, exceeds its solution value. This extremum principle, and its dual with the nominal stress-rate as the primary variable, are due to Hill (1962) with forerunners (1958, 1959, 196la,b). 2. Nonlinear Case The incremental response can now be thoroughly nonlinear as in (3.4). With homogeneous data the condition (3.26) excluding eigenstates is still relevant. Exactly as before this condition is critical under self-adjoint data and an eigenmode is characterized by stationarity of the exclusion functional. It goes without saying, however, that there is no longer an automatic connection between the homogeneous and inhomogeneous problems. So in regard to the latter we must proceed along different lines. Following Hill (1959) the starting point is taken to be the virtual work identity
J” Anij a
-
ati
Avj d t = J” Anij Avj d X i
in the difference Av, = vj* - v j of any presumed pair of distinct solutions to a particular inhomogeneous problem. For prescribed velocities over S’ and the data (3.16) over S - S’, the identity becomes
J” Anij a
-
J”
Avj d t = Af;. Avj dS.
ati
Bifurcation is thus excluded by the requirement
J” Anij a
-
ati
I
Avj d t > AA Avj dS
(3.27)
for every pair of analytically admissible fields taking the values prescribed over S’. Note that this condition takes no account of the particular cj values given over S - S’. It is therefore likely to be oversufficient. For instance, suppose the part S’ is either fixed or absent. Then the null field is admissible in (3.27) and can be paired with any wj* as previously defined, so reproducing (3.26). It follows that (3.27) in this case excludes bifurcations under homogeneous data also and is therefore stronger than (3.26). So typically we have the following sequence of events along a path of deformation: first a segment where (3.27) holds, guaranteeing universal uniqueness; then a segment where (3.27) fails but uniqueness persists; then a critical stage at which the first primary bifurcation occurs under some particular dj distribution; then a succession of stages where primary bifurcations occur under other ij distributions, somewhere among them being the homogeneous data dj E 0.
Rodney Hill
62
Before proceeding, it is perhaps worth mentioning that the condition excluding bifurcations can be weakened whenever one solution is known. In that event the inequality need only be stipulated for pairs having that field as one member. While this situation is common, it appears that the weakened condition has not been noticed or put to any use. Guided by the notion of function convexity,extended to functionals (Hill, 1959, 1961a,b), and by an associated “automatic” procedure for generating extremum principles from uniqueness conditions (Hill, 1956), it will be shown that (3.27) is equivalent to (3.28) for every pair of admissible fields (Hill, 1962). Assuming this result for the moment, choose uj to be the guaranteed unique solution. Then (3.28) transforms to
j AU d t >
(cj
+fi + $A&) Avj dS +
yj Avj d t .
Now
j (fi+ *A&) Au, dS = 4A under the self-adjointness condition (3.18). Hence the solution value of the functional in (3.24) is an absolute minimum within the entire class of admissible fields (Hill, 1962). In proof of the stated equivalence, it is obvious in the first place that (3.27) is implied by (3.28), simply by interchanging v j and vj* in the latter and adding the two inequalities. To proceed in the reverse direction we consider any pair v j and vj* and introduce a continuous sequence of fields v j + AAv j such that A I u j = A Avj, 0 5 1 I 1, where 1is uniform throughout the continuum. Such fields satisfy the constraint data over s’when v j and uI* do, and are therefore admissible in (3.27). Define
j
+(A) = ( A A U - n, where AAoperating on any function means the difference between its values at uj + A Auj and v j . It is required to prove that +(1) > 0. We have
A
4 a a = j AAnijag AAvl d< - j A,& AAvjdS i
Aspects of Invariance in Solid Mechanics
63
and so d 4 / d 1 > 0 when 0 < A 5 1 by (3.27). Since 4(0)= 0 it follows that
#(A) > 0 when 0 < 1I 1, as required. To date, direct application of the uniqueness test (3.27) or (3.28) has been discouraged by the volume integrand not being a single-valued function of Avj, but of v j and vj* jointly. However, the following indirect approach has been found effective. This is based on the notion of an incrementally linear comparison material that is in a sense “less stiff (Hill 1958, 1959, 1961a, 1967~).Let ULdenote its velocity gradient potential at the same local Cauchy stress. Suppose that the exclusion condition (3.26) is provable for material UL in the current configuration under some particular homogeneous data (disregarding trivial rigid-body motions where necessary). Then (3.26) obviously holds also for material U if function U - UL is nonnegative at each point. If, more strongly, function U - UL is convex at each point, then bifurcation is ruled out for material U under any associated inhomogeneous data. In proof we need only observe that (3.27) is identical to (3.26) for material UL,and that then the property of relative convexity, uiz. (3.29) ensures (3.27) for material U . Now, in (2.20), relative convexity was defined in regard to rate equations expressed objectively in work-conjugate generalized variables, and the property was shown to be coordinate invariant. And, in fact, it is equivalent to relative convexity in regard to rate equations expressed nonobjectively in nominal stress and deformation gradient. Equivalence follows from a finite-difference analog of the first of (1.92), namely,
Tr(AN AA) - Tr(Ap’) AE(’)) = Tr(F1)Ak’ Ak),
(3.30)
which can be proved in identical fashion via AN = Ai<”A’
+ F” AA’,
A’ AA
= AE“”
+ A’ AOA.
The right-hand term in (3.30) makes for a nonsimple connection between absolute convexities in the two formulations, but disappears from the connection between relative convexities, viz. (3.29) and A?ltijAe,, 2 At; Aeij,
(3.31)
when this is written in the Green measure and relative to the incrementally linear comparison material in particular. We see further from (1.92) that existence of a velocity-gradient potential U implies, and is implied by, existence of a rate-of-strain potential W such that (when symmetrized in its arguments) $)
=
aw/aq,
2 w = i!!)e!!) V IJ
(3.32)
Rodney Hill
64 where
Moreover, by (2.1I), this existence is a coordinate-invariant property. Function W was introduced by Hill (1959) with the current configuration as reference, in which case the components cij of Eulerian strain-rate are its arguments. With this choice of reference the strain-rate potential associated with any other scale function follows at once from (1.82), namely,
‘i“&” 2 EJ
V =
w + (1 - m ) o i j & i k & j k .
In particular from (1.84), or even (1.25) by going back to first principles, f[(goij/gt)
+ aij&k.]&ij = w +
CijEikEjk.
(3.33)
By introducing (3.32) into (3.27) we both connect the sufficiency condition directly with an objective constitutive description and partially split the volume integrand into terms in rate-of-strain and spin:
It can then be seen qualitatively that the exclusion of bifurcations depends on contributions of type stress times (spin)2 being dominated by those of type modulus times (strain rate)2. This is even more apparent in the exclusion condition for incrementally linear materials when (3.26) is written as
(3.35) Here the current configuration is taken as reference, 2’pIjiIis the corresponding tensor of Green moduli, u j denotes any admissible field vanishing over s’, and cij is its strain rate. When the geometry is such that the admissible class includes fields in which large spins are compatible with small strain rates, as in slender beams and columns, then bifurcation can occur while the stress is still only a fraction of the relevant modulus. For elastic continua (3.35) with fj = 0 coincides with the classical condition for stability under dead loading over S - S’; for such materials and in that particular context, essentially the same inequality was first given by Pearson (1956). For elastoplastic continua, with piecewise-linear response subject to the normality rule, the optimum choice of comparison material at each plastically stressed point is decided by (2.50) or (2.60), respectively, for the regular
Aspects of lnvariance in Solid Mechanics
65
or singular cases (Hill, 1958; Sewell, 1972). According to each left-hand inequality the matrix of moduli defining the material UL should be Lap.in (2.45) or (2.59), corresponding to the “fully” plastic branch. Transliteratmg this into the present notation, when the generalized coordinates are components eij of some tensor measure of strain, we have to set Lijk,
= q ’ j k 1 -!!g
A;jAi,;
r, s = 1, . .., n,
(3.36)
where Aij heij = 0 are the n tangent hyperplanes in strain space at the yield point ( n = 1 in the regular case). Elsewhere in the continuum the tensor of moduli is, of course, taken as the local gjk,. The bifurcation problem is thus reduced, in the first instance, to determining primary eigenstates for this incrementally-linear material. Under compatible inhomogeneous data in such a configuration it can happen that, among the infinity of deformation modes for the UL material, there are those for which the strain rate at every plastically stressed point of the continuum falls in the fully plastic domain of the U material itself. Then, clearly, such modes are also solutions of the given inhomogeneous rate problem for the U material, so a primary bifurcation has been identified. In short, there are circumstances where the whole procedure is critical and not just conservative. The classic example is Shanley buckling, as analyzed by Hill and Sewell (1960,1962)for columns and by Sewell (1963, 1964, 1973) for plates. Further applications are treated by Miles (1971, 1973, 1975), Hutchinson and Miles (1974), Storikers (1975). In recent years the outstanding development is the devising of effective computational techniques (e.g., Hibbitt et al., 1970, Nagtegaal et al., 1974), which have brought within range problems of a complexity that could not be attempted even a decade ago. Representative references in the bifurcation context are Needleman (1972a,b, 1973, 1975a,b, 1976, 1977), McMeeking and Rice (1975), Needleman and Tvergaard (1976, 1977), and Tvergaard (1976a,b, 1977). These references contain a wealth of details that illuminate many aspects of the general theory, but an adequate account could not be attempted in this survey. Instead, we describe in Section II1,C two simple rate problems which, while solvable by pure analysis, are sufficiently nontrivial to underscore important points of principle. 3. Modijcations for Conditional Data Active or passive constraint by smooth rigid tools was instanced as the archetype of data which is conditional in the sense that only the solution as a whole determines which of two mutually exclusive loadings shall apply locally (Section III,A,2). Short of an unwieldy symbolism, data of this kind cannot be handled on a common footing like that in the preceding analysis of bifurcation. It seems more sensible to treat each case separately on its
Rodney Hill
66
merits, and here we follow through the archetypal example to show precisely what is involved. With the total surface now denoted by S + S”, suppose that the vector velocity is prescribed over S‘, self-adjoint nonconditional data (3.16)over S - S‘, and conditional data (3.10)with (3.11) and (3.12)over S . In retracing the steps leading to (3.27)we have to evaluate Anij Avj over S”. Where p > 0 we have from (3.11) and (3.12)successively, An, Avj dSi = - p Ani Avi dS = -picij Avi ADj dS,
remembering that nj Avj = 0 by (3.10).Where p = 0, on the other hand, no more can be concluded than that Anij Avj dS, 5 0,
since the inequality would prevail were contact to be lost in one field but maintained in the other (i, > 0). On the right-hand side of (3.27)we must therefore add the term
-I
picij Avi Avj d S ,
and require the admissible fields to satisfy (3.10).Likewise, on the right of the equivalent uniqueness condition (3.28)we must add one-half of this same term. The proof of equivalence goes as before; the sequence of fields v j + AAv j automatically satisfies (3.10);and to the definition of 4(A)must be added
4
picij
AAviA A v jdS”.
Finally, in the absolute minimum principle characterizing the guaranteed unique solution, we must add to the functional in (3.24)the expression
+
p{+cijvivj - KijviTvj eijkviojTnk} dS“.
We omit details of the algebra, from which it could be seen that the extremum is not analytic, in that the functional has no true stationary value.
c. BIFURCATIONS UNDER SIMPLE LOADINGS 1. All-Around Dead b a d
Consider a continuum whose entire surface is unconstrained and subject only to “dead” loads (ie., iijdSi = 0 with the current configuration as reference). The intention of the following analysis is to locate any primary eigen-
Aspects of Znvariance in Solid Mechanics
67
states. Rigid translations are, of course, formally possible but are of no interest as eigenmodes. So we modify the exclusion condition (3.26) insubstantially to U(v*) dx > 0 for nontranslational fields v*; the material need not be incrementally linear. Correspondingly, we look for configurations where J U(v*) dx 2 0 with equality for some nontrivial field v. Suppose, for simplicity, that the continuum was originally homogeneous and that subsequently it has been uniformly strained. Then U is currently the same function of velocity gradient at every point. By choosing fields v* with arbitrary uniform gradient, we deduce first that the exclusion condition holds when and only when the function U is positivedefinite, and second that U is positive semidefinite in a primary eigenstate and is therefore made zero and stationary by the gradient value of a primary eigenmode. That is, no matter what the surface geometry, a primary eigenmode necessarily has a uniform gradient given by the eigenequations (3.37)
which express the stationarity of the nominal stress within the continuum. Conversely, any field with a uniform gradient satisfying (3.37) is obviously an eigenmode since it keeps the loading dead, but it is not primary when U is only indefinite in that configuration. In terms of the strain-rate potential W, citing (3.32) written with the current configuration as reference, primary eigenmodes are given by 2W(v*) + oij
auk* avk* __ 2 0,
~
axi axj
(3.38)
It is seen that the exclusion condition implies oija:ia;j = (ol
+ 02)wp+ +
*-.
>O
for arbitrary spins with vector components (a1*, a2*,a3*) on the axes of the principal stresses (ol,02, 03).Thus the condition requires the current stress to be within the domain 01
+ 6 2 > 0,
6 2
+ 6 3 > 0,
03
+
01
> 0.
(3.39)
Inequality (3.38), of course, also imposes requirements on the incremental response, which may indirectly restrict the domain even more. The significanceof (3.39), according to the work interpretation of (3.26), is simply that the opposite inequalities would allow the dead loads to do work in certain (virtual) rotations of the continuum.
Rodney Hill
68
It is seen also from (3.38) that an eigenmode must comply with (3.40) These are just the three independent equations that enforce continuing balance of moments of the tractions on a deforming cell; cf. the rate version of (1.85) when nil is stationary, namely, u i k n k j = u j k n k i evaluated in the reference configuration. When referred to a coordinate frame coaxial with the stress, (3.40) reduces to aik(dvj/dxk)
= ojk(dvi/dxk)
(i # j ) .
+ O 2 b 3 = -(61
(3.41) - 62)E12 and two similar. In particular, when o1 + o2 = 0, a rigid rotation about axis x3 is statically possible under the dead loads (which is to say without expen(O1
diture of work), but it may be debarred constitutively; in any event the configuration is said to have an “axis of equilibrium” (trivially if o1 = a2 = 0). As an alternative to (3.40) one may profitably derive (3.41) in elementary fashion, by considering an embedded cell that is currently a principal unit cube and then calculating the incipient lever arms of the dead loads ol,0 2 ,o3 acting at the centroids of opposite faces. Henceforward we take the linear case. Then the first group of eigenequations in (3.38) is y(l1 lk’ lEkl
+ ulE1l
=
(3.42)
and two similar. When there is no axis of equilibrium, the spin components can be eliminated from the second group by means of (3.41), with the result (3.43) and two similar. Then we have six eigenequations altogether in the strainrate components alone; the spin needed to maintain balance of moments can be calculated afterward from (3.41). If, however, an axis of equilibrium is present, say when o1 + o2 = 0, then E~~ = 0 and
+0103 =0
(3.44) replaces the corresponding member of the group (3.43). Suppose that the tensor of moduli has orthotropic symmetry with respect to the axes of stress. Then the six eigenequations decouple: y\:)kl&kl
etc. When n1+ o2 = 0 then o3= 0 (unless o1 = o2 = 0), which points up the previous remark that rotations may sometimes be statically but not
Aspects of Invariance in Solid Mechanics
69
constitutively possible. According to (3.45) there are two distinct types of eigenmode, namely, coaxial with the stress and shearing in a principal plane. To settle which is primary we would need to resort to the inequality in (3.38). When the material is isotropic elastic with work function w ( I l ,I , , 13),the standard elementary formulae for the moduli 9:jisin terms of the principal stretches can be substituted in the first of (3.45). This leads to the eigenequations (3.46) for coaxial modes. Actually, this could have been foreseen ab initio since the conjugate loads are just aw/i31r and coaxiality automatically maintains their alignment with the principal fibers. By (1.107) and the second of (3.45) shearing modes such as c12 # 0 are possible when
a1lI1
or
= a,/&
(3.47)
~ l / &= + 2 / & )
provided I 1 # I,. This can also be established in elementary fashion by requiring that the mode be such as to keep the varying stress axes (determined by the dead tractions on the deforming cell) aligned with the Eulerian triad (determined by the incremental deformation, relative to the ground state). When ,I1= I , , shearing can be examined as a coaxial mode, and det(a2w/aI, an,) factorizes correspondingly. Up to this point the analysis is taken from Hill (1967c, 1975). For isotrop ic elastic materials, an instructive alternative route to eigenmodes keeping the nominal stress stationary has been mentioned recently by Ogden (1977). This centers on using the measure F 1 / 2defined ) in (1.79), which here reduces to NR, where A = RA relative to a ground state. Then N = 0 is equivalent to fC'lz) = T(1'2)(R'12RR) where RR = RR'. With the Lagrangian triad as basis the component eigenequations are
t'y) =0
9
( t y ) - t ( ' / z ) ) W ; s +t!'12'W,R,
= 0,
(3.48)
as in (1.46). Since t!'/') = t , / I , = aw/aI, by (1.78), the first group returns to (3.46). In the second group each pair r # s jointly implies (t!'/,) + tS.'/2))oE= 0, so the group as a whole is equivalent to
6) or (ii)
c!'/~) + tj'/') = 0 t!1/2)
with wP, + 2w),
- &'Iz) =0
with
= 0,
0 : = 0.
These agree with (3.47) and further, by (1.45) and (1.50), w,, =
4+ Is I, -I, ~
70
Rodney Hill
or (ii) which both return to (3.41). 2. All-Around Fluid Pressure
The surface S of a continuum is completely immersed in a uniformly pressurized fluid. We consider the homogeneous self-adjoint rate problem dS over the whole of S, where set by nij dSi
=fi
] . = p ( - au. - - Sauk ij)dSi J a x j axk
from (3.9). Rigid rotations and translations are possible but will not be counted as eigenmodes, so the exclusion condition (3.26) is modified to (3.49) for all straining fields uj*. That this would indeed be an equality for pure spins ui* = o $ x j is easily verified: on the left we would have aij dx)wk*, by (3.38) and on the right, - p ( J x i dSj)W$iiOlr*/,and these are equal by the mean-value theorem of stress analysis, which in this case reads
(I
gij
s
dx = xiajk dSk = - p
s
xi dSj.
Since the surface integral in (3.49) extends over all of S, the divergence theorem can be called on, with the result ~ [ U ( V *+)
fp(yavi* - av.* 1 auj* __ axi axj
axj axi
Suppose that the current state of stress within S is uniform, namely aij = - p dij. Then, on introducing the strain-rate potential defined in (3.32), the inequality becomes
5 { W(v*) + p(&$~j:.-
E$E$)}
dx > 0,
with an integrand involving strain rate alone. By (3.33) this can be reduced finally to (3.50)
71
Aspects of Invariance in Solid Mechanics
where goij
a
-
a aEij
(W(V)
+
P(4EiiEjj
- EijEij)}
is the constitutive law under hydrostatic stress. An equivalent conclusion, but expressed in Kirchhoff stress, was reached by Miles (1973). In retrospect it is possible to convince oneself that the simple inequality (3.50) is “obvious,” when considered in the light of the energetic gloss on the exclusion condition (3.26). To begin with, in any finite deformation of S the work supplied by the constant pressure in the fluid is exactly p times the decrease of volume bounded by S. Also, ifthe Cauchy stress remained equal to - p hij within S, the state of equilibrium would continue and precisely the same work would be absorbed in internal deformation. So the actual shortfall in the supply of energy must be the work absorbed by reason of the constitutive change in Cauchy stress, and this work is +(St)’ times the volume integral in (3.50),to second order. Suppose, henceforward, that the material response is also uniform in the current state. Then, by the line of argument leading to (3.37), though now with strain rate and not velocity gradient as the independent variable, it can be deduced that a primary eigenmode is generally homogeneous. It is in fact any eigensolution of 90ij/9t = 0
(3.51)
that makes the potential function in (3.50) positive semidefinite. Conversely, any other solution of (3.51) is an eigenmode, though not primary, since it evidently keeps the stress hydrostatic, uniform, and compatible with the pressure maintained in the fluid. Note, incidentally, that the Jaumann flux is identical with Daij/Dt,the rate of change of background components, when the stress is hydrostatic. As an illustration consider a material which is homogeneous at zero pressure; then the fundamental path of deformation under varying uniform pressure or tension is such that it remains so. If, further, the microstructure initially has cubic symmetry the ensuing incremental response to prescribed dp is purely volumetric. Hence the cubic symmetry is not disturbed and by induction is retained along the fundamental path. So at any later stage, with coordinates along the cubic axes, we can write Q‘kk/gt
= 31CEkk,
(g/gl)(‘ll- .22)
= 2p(E11
- & 22) ,
9 o , 2 / 9 t = 2pIE12
and two similar pairs. It can be recognized that K is the instantaneous bulk modulus, p the modulus for shearing at 45” to the cubic axes, and p’ the modulus for shearing parallel to the cubic axes. The exclusion condition
Rodney Hill
72
requires that these three moduli are all positive; for isotropic elastic materials a more elaborate analysis with consonant conclusions was given by Miles (1973). From (3.51) the corresponding types of primary eigenmode are (i) purely volumetric: E ~ ~ = E ~ ~ = E ~ q ~ 2# =O0 , ... whenK=O;
(ii) volume-preserving coaxial: &kk = 0,
&12 =
0,... when P = 0;
(iii) volume-preserving shearing: q1= E~~ = E~~ = 0,
c12
# 0, . . . when p‘ = 0.
The first type is trivially coincident with the fundamental path at a stage where the pressure is stationary. Implications for other sets of moduli follow from relations such as y(1) 1111
=K
+ 4P + P,
y C1122 1)
= K -3P
-P,
y(1) 1212=
P’
+ P.
For pairwise interaction models of monatomic lattices the implications of this theory have been reviewed by Hill and Milstein (1977), and extensive computations of the pressure dependence of the moduli for Morse potential models are presented by Milstein and Hill (1977).
REFERENCES BIOT,M. A. (1965). “Mechanics of Incremental Deformations.” Wiley, New York. BLATZ,P. J., and KO, W.L. (1962). Application of finite elastic theory to the deformation of rubbery materials. Trans. SOC. Rheol. 6, 223-251. BOLOTIN,V. V. (1963). “Non-Conservative Problems of the Theory of Elastic Stability” (G. Herrmann, ed.). Pergamon, Oxford. BUDIANSKY, B. (1974). Theory of buckling and postbuckling behavior of elastic structures. In “Advances in Applied Mechanics,” Vol. 14, pp. 2-65. Academic Press, New York. CHADWICK, P., and OGDEN,R. W. (1971). On the definition of elastic moduli. Arch. Rational Mech. Anal. 44,41-53; 54-68. J. L. (1970). Nonlinear elasticity of diatomic crystals. Int. J. Solids Structures 6, ERICKSEN, 951-958. HAVNER, K. S. (1977a). On unification, uniqueness, and numerical analysis in plasticity. Int. J . Solids Structures 13, 625-635. HAVNER, K. S. (1977b). On uniqueness criteria and minimum principles for crystalline solids at finite strain. Acta Mechanica 28, to appear. HIBBITT,H. D., MARCAL, P. V., and RICE,J. R. (1970). A finite element formulation for problems of large strain and large displacement. Int. J . Solids Structures 6, 1069-1086. HILL,R. (1956). New horizons in the mechanics of solids. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 5, 66-74. HILL,R. (1957a). On the problem of uniqueness in the theory of rigid-plastic solids. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 5, 153-161; 302-307.
Aspects of Invariance in Solid Mechanics
73
HILL,R. (1957b). On uniqueness and stability in the theory of finite elastic strain. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 5, 229-241. HILL,R. (1958). A general theory of uniqueness and stability in elastic-plastic solids. J . Mech. Phys. Solids 6, 236-249. HILL,R. (1959). Some basic principles in the mechanics of solids without a natural time. J . Mech. Phys. Solids 7 , 209-225. HILL,R. (1961a). Bifurcation and uniqueness in nonlinear mechanics of continua. In “Problems of Continuum Mechanics,” N. I. Muskhelishvili Volume, pp. 155-164. SOC.Ind. Appl. Math., Philadelphia. HILL, R. (1961b). Uniqueness in general boundary-value problems for elastic and inelastic solids. J . Mech. Phys. Solids 9, 114-130. HILL,R. (1962). Uniqueness and extremum principles in self-adjoint boundary-value problems in continuum mechanics. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 10, 185-194. HILL,R.(1966). Generalized constitutive relations for incremental deformation of metal crystals by multi-slip. J . Mech. Phys. Solids 14, 95-102. HILL, R. (1967a). On the classical constitutive laws for elastic-plastic solids. In “Recent Progress in Applied Mechanics,” F. K. G. Odqvist Volume, pp. 241-249. Wiley, New York. HILL,R. (1967b). The essential structure of constitutive laws for metal composites and polycrystals. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 15, 79-95. HILL,R. (1967~).Eigenmodal deformations in elastic-plastic continua. J . Mech. Phys. Solids 15, 371-386. HILL, R. (1968). On constitutive inequalities for simple materials. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 16, 229-242; 3 15-322. HILL,R.(1969). Some aspects of the incremental behaviour of isotropic elastic solids after finite strain. In “Problems in Mechanics: Deformation of Solid Bodies,” V. V. Novozhilov Volume, pp. 459-466. Leningrad. HILL,R. (1970). Constitutive inequalities for isotropic elastic solids under finite strain. Proc. R. SOC.London Ser. A 314, 457-472. HILL,R. (1972). On constitutive macro-variables for heterogeneous solids at finite strain. Proc. R. SOC.London Ser. A 326, 131-147. HILL, R. (1975). On the elasticity and stability of perfect crystals at finite strain. Math. Proc. Cambridge Phil. SOC. 75, 225-240. HILL,R.,and HUTCHINSON, J. W. (1975). Bifurcation phenomena in the plane tension test. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 23, 239-264. HILL,R., and MILSTEIN, F. (1977). Principles of stability analysis of ideal crystals. Phys. Rev. B 15, 3087-3096. HILL, R., and RICE,J. R. (1972). Constitutive analysis of elastic-plastic crystals at arbitrary strain. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 20, 401-413. HILL,R., and RICE,J. R. (1973). Elastic potentials and the structure of inelastic constitutive laws. S.I.A.M. J. Appl. Math. 25, 448-461. HILL,R., and SEWELL,M. J. (1960). A general theory of inelastic column failure. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 8, 105-111; 112-118. HILL,R., and SEWELL, M. J. (1962). A general theory of inelastic column failure. J . Mech. Phys. Solids 10, 285-300. HUTCHINSON,J. W. (1974). Plastic buckling. I n “Advances in Applied Mechanics,” Vol. 14, pp. 67-144. Academic Press, New York. HUTCHINSON, J. W., and MILES,J. P. (1974). Bifurcation analysis of the onset of necking in an elastic-plastic cylinder under uniaxial tension. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 22, 61-7 1. ILYUSHIN, A. A. (1961). On a postulate of plasticity. Prikl. M a t . Mekh. 25, 503-507. MCMEEKING, R. M., and RICE,J. R. (1975). Finite-element formulations for problems of large elastic-plastic deformation. Int. J. Solids Structures 11, 601-616.
74
Rodney Hill
MILES,J. P. (1971). Bifurcation in plastic flow under uniaxial tension. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 19, 89-102. MILES,J. P. (1973). Fluid-pressure eigenstates and bifurcation in tension specimens under lateral pressure. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 21, 145-162. MILES,J. P. (1975). The initiation of necking in rectangular elastic-plastic specimens under uniaxial and biaxial tension. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 23, 197-213. F., and HILL,R. (1977). Theoretical properties of cubic crystals at arbitrary pressure. MILSTEIN. I. Density and bulk modulus. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 25, 457477. J. C., PARKS,D. M.,and RICE,J. R. (1974). On numerically accurate finite-element NAGTEGAAL, solutions in the fully plastic range. Comput. Methods Appl. Mech. Eng. 4, 153-177. A. (1972a). Void growth in an elastic-plastic medium. Trans. Am. SOC.Mech. Eng. NEEDLEMAN, (December) 964-970. NEEDLEMAN, A. (1972b). A numerical study of necking in circular cylindrical bars. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 20, 111-127. NEEDLEMAN, A. (1973). A numerical study of uniaxial compression in circular elastic-plastic columns. Int. J. Solids Structures 9, 981-998. A. (1975a). Post-bifurcation behaviour and imperfection sensitivity of elasticNEEDLEMAN, plastic circular plates. Int. J. Mech. Sci. 17, 1-14. A. (1975b). Bifurcation of elastic-plastic spherical shells subject to internal presNEEDLEMAN, sure. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 23, 357-367. A. (1976). Necking of pressurized spherical membranes. J . Mech. Phys. Solids 24, NEEDLEMAN, 339-359. NEEDLEMAN, A. (1977). Inflation of spherical rubber balloons. Int. J. Solids Structures 13, 49-42 1. NEEDLEMAN, A., and TVERGAARD, V. (1976). An analysis of the imperfection sensitivity of square elastic-plastic plates under axial compression. Int. J. Solids Structures 12, 185-201. NEEDLEMAN, A., and TVERGAARD, V. (1977).Necking of biaxially-stretched elastic-plastic circular plates. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 25, 159-183. NEMAT-NASSER, S. (1968). On local stability of a finitely deformed solid subjected to followertype loads. Quart. Appl. Math. 26, 119-129. OGDEN,R. W.(1972a). Large deformation isotropic elasticity. 1. On the correlation of theory and experiment for incompressible rubberlike solids. Proc. R. SOC. London Ser. A 326, 565-584. OGDEN,R. W.(1972b). Large deformation isotropic elasticity. 11. On the correlation of theory and experiment for compressible rubberlike solids. Proc. R. SOC. London Ser. A 328, 567-583. OGDEN,R. W.(1974). On stress rates in solid mechanics with applications to elasticity theory. Proc. Cambridge Phil. SOC. 75, 303-319. OGDEN,R. W.(1975). A note on variational theorems in non-linear elastostatics. Math. Proc. Cambridge Phil. SOC.77, 609-615. OGDEN,R. W . (1976). Volume changes associated with the deformation of rubberlike solids. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 24, 323-338. OGDEN,R. W.(1977). Inequalities associated with the inversion of elastic stress-deformation relations and their implications. Math. Proc. Cambridge Phil. SOC.81, 313-324. G. P. (1976). On the elasticity of monatomic crystals. Math. Proc. Cambridge Phil. PARRY, SOC. 80, 189-211. PARRY, G. P.(1977). On the crystallographic point groups and on Cauchy symmetry. Math. Proc. Cambridge Phil. SOC.82, 165-175. PEARSON, C. E. (1956). General theory of elastic stability. Quart. Appl. Math. 14, 133-144.
Aspects of lnvariance in Solid Mechanics
75
RICE, J. R. (1975). Continuum mechanics and thermodynamics of plasticity in relation to micro-scale deformation mechanisms. I n “Constitutive Equations in Plasticity” (A. S. Argon, ed.), pp. 23-75. MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass. SEWELL, M. J. (1963). A general theory of elastic and inelastic plate failure. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 11, 377-393. SEWELL, M. J. (1964). A general theory ofelastic and inelastic plate failure. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 12, 279-297. SEWELL, M. J. (1965). On the calculation of potential functions defined on curved boundaries. Proc. R. SOC.London Ser. A 286, 402-411. SEWELL,M. J. (1967). On configuration-dependent loading. Arch. Rational Mech. Anal. 23, 327-35 1. SEWELL, M. J. (1972). A survey of plastic buckling. In “Stability” (H. Leipholz, ed.), pp. 85-197. Univ. of Waterloo Press, Ontario. SEWELL, M. J. (1973). A yield surface corner lowers the buckling stress of an elastic-plastic plate under compression. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 21, 19-43. SEWELL, M. J. (1974). On applications of saddle-shaped and convex generating functionals. I n “Physical Structures in Systems Theory” (J. J. van Dixhoorn and F. J. Evans, eds.), pp. 219-245. Academic Press, New York. STOR~ERS, B. (1975). On buckling of axisyrnmetric thin elastic-plastic shells. Int. J. Solids Structures 11, 1329-1346. STOREN,S., and RICE,J. R. (1975). Localized necking in thin sheets. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 23, 421-441. THOMPSON, J. M. T., and HUNT,G. W. (1973). “A General Theory of Elastic Stability.” Wiley, London. TRELOAR, L. R. G. (1973). The elasticity and related properties of rubbers. Rep. Progr. Phys. 36, 755-826. TRELOAR, L. R. G. (1976). The mechanics of rubber elasticity. Proc. R. SOC.London Ser. A 351, 301-322. TRUESDELL, C., and NOLL, W. (1965). “The Non-Linear Field Theories of Mechanics,” (S. Fliigge, ed.), Section 87, Handbuch der Physik Band II1/3. Springer, Berlin. TRUESDELL, C., and TOUPIN,R. (1963). Static grounds for inequalities in finite strain ofelastic materials. Arch. Rational Mech. Anal. 12, 1-33. TVERGAARD, V. (1976a). Effect of thickness inhomogeneities in internally pressurized elasticplastic spherical shells. J . Mech. Phys. Solids 24, 291-304. TVERGAARD, V. (1976b). Buckling behavior of plate and shell structures. Proc. 14th Int. Cong. Theor. and Appl. Mech. (W. T. Koiter, ed.), pp. 233-247. North-Holland, Publ., Amsterdam. TVERGAARD, V. (1977). On the numerical analysis of necking instabilities. I n “Proceedings of an International Conference on Finite Elements in Nonlinear Solid and Structural Mechanics,” to appear. YOUNG,N. J. B. (1976). Bifurcation phenomena in the plane compression test. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 24, 77-9 1.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
.
ADVANCES I N APPLIED MECHANICS VOLUME
18
The Optimum Theory of Turbulence F. H. BUSSE Institute of Geophysics and Planetary Physics University of California Los Angeles. California
I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I1. The Optimum Problem for Turbulent Couette Flow . . . . . . . . . . . . A . Basic Relationships . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. The Variational Problem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. The Energy Stability Limit . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I11. Multi-a Solutions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . Convection in a Porous Medium . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. General Properties of the Extremalizing Solutions . . . . . . . . . . . . C . Boundary-Layer Theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. Bounds on the Transport of Momentum . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . Extremalizing Vector Fields . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Comparison with Observations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C . Momentum Transport in a Rotating System . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V . Bounds on the Transport of Mass . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . Turbulent Channel Flow . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Turbulent Pipe Flow . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI . Bounds on the Transport of Heat . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . Convection in a Layer Heated from Below . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. The Infinite Prandtl Number Limit . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VII . General Discussion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . Further Applications of the Optimum Theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Extensions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
77 80 80 82 83 84 84 86 89 94 94 98 101 105 105 108 110 110 113 115 115 117 119
I . Introduction The optimum theory represents an approach toward the understanding of turbulent flows without the introduction of heuristic assumptions which are commonly used in other theories of turbulence .Since there does not seem to be a generally accepted definition of turbulence we shall regard for the 77
Copyright Q 1978 by Academic Press, Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved . ISBN 0-12.M)2018-1
78
F. H.Busse
present purpose a fluid flow as turbulent if the details of the velocity field are too complex to be of interest and only the information about certain average properties is needed. The optimum theory is hardly appropriate for all turbulent systems of this general nature and a more suitable mathematical definition of turbulence will be required later. The main point is that turbulent fluid systems are characterized by an information gap which is neither possible nor desirable to fill. Because of the nonlinearity of the Navier-Stokes equations lack of information about a particular aspect of a turbulent velocity field affects in general the knowledge about all other aspects. In other words, the theoretical description of average quantities cannot be separated from the behavior of the fluctuating velocity field. The attempt to derive equations for average quantities yields an infinite hierarchy of moment equations which can be analyzed only if suitably chosen assumptions are introduced. Highly sophisticated schemes have been developed for this purpose in statistical theories of turbulence, but the heuristic character of the assumptions cannot be eliminated and the theoretical predictions have been successful only in idealized cases such as isotropic homogeneous turbulence. The optimum theory represents an alternative approach in which the lack of information about properties of the fluctuating velocity field is reflected by the theoretical results. Instead of a theoretical prediction of the physically realized average properties, bounds on those properties are obtained. No assumptions are introduced in the theory, with the exception of technical assumptions such as those involved in boundary-layer methods. The optimum theory has thus been capable of producing mathematically rigorous quantitative results in contrast to other theories of turbulence. The idea of the optimum theory is to consider not the manifold of solutions of the basic equations for a particular problem but a larger manifold of vector fields which includes the actual solutions. This manifold of fields shares with the solutions kinematic relationships such as boundary conditions and the energy balance. By generalizing a certain average physical property such as the momentum transport as a functional of the manifold of fields, extremal values of the functional can be determined by variational methods. The extremal values provide the bounds for the values which the property assumes for the subset of the actual solutions of the Navier-Stokes equations. The bounds can be improved, naturally, by using a narrower definition for the manifold of vector fields. In addition to the kinematic and energetic constraints other constraints may be introduced, and in principle it is possible to conceive a hierarchy of constraints such that the bounds approach the extremal values assumed by the actual solutions of the equations of motion. Little work has yet been done on the development of the optimum theory in this direction.
Optimum Theory of Turbulence
19
The optimum theory would be primarily of mathematical interest if there were not strong indications that the physically realized solutions of turbulent fluid flow often tend to optimize transport. Malkus’ (1954b) suggestion that the convection solution of maximum heat transport is the most stable one provided the stimulation for the first development of the theory of bounds by Howard (1963). When the theory was extended and applied to turbulent shear flow (Busse, l968,1969a,b, 1970b) further evidence appeared for the tendency of the realized solution to maximize the transport of momentum or mass. It must be emphasized that there is only a tendency and that in general the realized flow in a turbulent system does not represent the solution of maximum transport. Even in the case of thermal convection the Malkus hypothesis is strictly correct only in the limit of small amplitudes. The tendency toward optimal transport properties is sufficiently strong, however, to cause similarities between the observed structure of turbulent flow and the properties of the extremalizing vector field. The physical insights provided by these similarities are probably the most fascinating results of the optimum theory. Related to those similarities is the model character of the Euler equations determining the extremalizing vector field. The optimum theory would hardly be useful if the variational problems for the extrema of the functionals mentioned above would not be simpler to solve than the basic NavierStokes equations. Even though the Euler equations are highly nonlinear they can be solved analytically in certain cases where a solution of the Navier-Stokes equations would be an impossible task even with the help of modern computers. Because the Euler equations resemble the equations of motion and incorporate some of their nonlinear features while neglecting others, they can be regarded as model equations. The investigation of model equations has had a long history in the theory of turbulence and much of the theoretical understanding of turbulence has been derived from model equations rather than from the basic Navier-Stokes equations. The Euler equations share with the so-called mean field equations the property of optimally combining a reasonably close description of the physics and a mathematical simplicity which often permits analytical solutions. The three main aspects of the optimum theory-the model character of the equations, the similarities between the extremalizing solutions and the structure of the observed turbulence, and the rigorous character of the bounds-provide an unusual variety of facts and insights which should appeal to a wide spectrum of scientists from mathematicians to experimental fluid dynamicists. In this article we attempt to keep the mathematical treatment sufficiently simple that it can be followed by fluid mechanicians with a modest theoretical background. On the other hand, open mathematical problems are pointed out and the limitations of proven mathematical
F. H.Busse
80
properties are mentioned. A more mathematically oriented introduction to the theory of bounds is given by Howard (1972) and in Chapter XI1 of Joseph's (1976) book. 11. 'Ihe Optimum Problem for Turbulent Couette Flow A. BASICRELATIONSHIPS In order to introduce the basic concepts of the optimum theory we consider the simplest physical problem of fluid dynamics, the transport of momentum between two parallel rigid plates moving relative to each other with a constant speed V,. The laminar solution for this problem is plane Couette flow and the corresponding turbulent state is sometimes called turbulent Couette flow. We assume that the fluid is homogeneous and incompressible and that the plates are infinitely extended. For the dimensionless description of the problem the distance d between the plates is the length scale and d2/v is the time scale, where v is the kinematic viscosity of the fluid. The dimensionless Navier-Stokes equations for the velocity vector V are
v x (V x V) + v p + v - vv + ata v = 0,
(2.la)
v.v=o.
(2.lb)
-
Using a Cartesian system of coordinates with the origin halfway between the plates and the z-direction normal to the plates we can write the boundary condition for the velocity vector V in the form a t z = ki,
V = TjRei
(2.2)
where i is the unit vector in the x-direction and the Reynolds number is defined by Re = V, d/v. Assuming that the velocity vector and the pressure are bounded everywhere we introduce two kinds of averages. The average over planes z = const. will be indicated by a bar, the average over the entire fluid layer will be indicated by angle brackets (...), i.e., UWE lim L+oo
j L j L uwdxdy 4E
-
-L
and
(uw)=j
112
Wdz.
(2.3)
- 112
-L
Separating the velocity vector into its mean and fluctuating parts, so that V =U +5
with U
= v,
81
Optimum Theory of Turbulence
we obtain the following equations from (2.1) by first taking the average over planes z = const. and then subtracting it from the original equations: a2 -
az2
u - ata u = aaZ -at+, -
~
a p = a -$?, aZ aZ
-_
-
v x (V x 5) + V(p - p ) + ata 5 + 5 - VQ - 5 -
*
VS + u . v5 + ~.
a u = 0,
-
az
V-i=O. We have used the fact that the component of U normal to the boundary vanishes because of the boundary condition. lii denotes the component of 5 parallel to the plates while is the normal component. By multiplying Eq. (2.6) with i and averaging it over the entire fluid layer we obtain
+
I d - - ( 1512) 2 dt
+ (Iv x 512) +
where the property has been used that some integrals can be transformed into surface integrals which vanish because 5 vanishes at z = k+and because the contributions from the remaining surface become negligible as the volume over which the average is extended tends to infinity. We are interested in turbulent flow under stationary conditions long after any change in the relative motion of the plates has occurred. We define this are indepencase by the assumption that all mean quantities like U or dent of time. It is possible that certain solutions of the Navier-Stokes equations corresponding to coherent oscillations of the fluid layer do not satisfy this property. In that case the above averages could be defined as ensemble averages. With the exception of some singular cases there appears to be no need for such a distinction and we shall not introduce it here. The time independence of mean quantities allows the integration of Eq. (2.4) d -U = - (a&) - Re i, dz
a
where the constant vector of integration has been determined by the boundary condition (2.2). Expression (2.9) can be used to eliminate the mean flow from the energy balance (2.8):
( I V x 5 1’)
+ ( lz - (iM)1’ )
- Re(6,fi)
= 0,
(2.10)
82
F. H. Busse
where fix is the x-component of Q. In accordance with the definition of turbulence under stationary conditions we have neglected the time rate of change of the kinetic energy. The use of the identity
(G(G- (ha)))= ( IG - (a*) 1)’ in the derivation of relationship (2.10) has made it obvious that the average Reynolds stress (6, a ) must be a positive quantity. B. THEVARIATIONALPROBLEM The dimensionless momentum transport in the case of the laminar solution of the above problem, i = 0, U = -zi Re, is given by Re. The xmomentum transport in the z-direction in the case of turbulent flow is given by (2.11) M = Re + (fix$). Since (.*,a) is a positive quantity the momentum transport is bounded from below by the value of the laminar solution. The goal of the optimum theory is to derive an upper bound for (fi,a) at a given value of Re. A particular method of deriving such an upper bound is the determination of the maximum p ( R ) of the functional (u, w ) among all vector fields v that satisfy (~vxV~’)+(~uw-(UW)J2)-R(u,w)=0,
v-v=o, v=O
atz=+&,
(2.12a) (2.12b) (2.12c)
and are bounded everywhere. As before u and w denote tangential and normal components of v. Obviously, the solutions of the Navier-Stokes equations with time-independent average properties are part of the manifold of vector fields v. Accordingly, p ( R ) provides indeed an upper bound for (&a) at a given value Re of R. The advantage of the manifold defined by conditions (2.12)is that the maximum p ( R )can be determined by variational methods, which in general is not possible for the submanifold of the solutions of the Navier-Stokes equations. The upper bounds can be improved when more constraints derived from the Navier-Stokes equations are taken into account, in addition to those given by (2.12). We shall return to this point in Section VI1,B. On the other hand, weaker but more easily accessible results may be obtained if the constraint of V * v = 0 is removed. An exact analytical solution of the variational problem for Couette flow in this case has been obtained by Howard (1972).
83
Optimum Theory of Turbulence
It is inconvenient to solve the variational problem in the formulation given above. Instead the following variational problem is considered. Given p > 0, find the minimum R ( p ) of the functional
among all bounded vector fields v which satisfy (2.12b)and (2.12~)and have (ux w ) > 0. Because the functional (2.13) is homogeneous the amplitude of the minimizing solution v remains undetermined. If the amplitude is chosen such that ( U X d
(2.14)
=P
is satisfied, condition (2.12a) is fulfilled. To complete the proof of the equivalence of the two variational problems it must be shown that R ( p ) is a monotonous function. Following Howard (1963) this can be easily seen from the following sequence of inequalities which hold for p* > p’ with v* and v’ representing the extremalizing solutions for p* and p’,
( 1 wllll - (W’U’) I(p* - p’)
(w’u,’)’
1)’
.
(2.15)
In the limit when p* approaches p’, (2.16) can be deduced whenever v* approaches v’ at the same time. Relationship (2.16) can be used to show that dR(,u)/dp is a decreasing function of p. This follows when relationship (2.16) is used in the first and last term of (2.15).
C. THEENERGYSTABILITYLIMIT The minimum R ( p ) of the functional (2.13) provides a lower bound for the Reynolds number Re at a given value p of (d, ~ )the, Reynolds stress part of the momentum transport. Since R ( p ) is a monotonically increasing function of p and since (dx&) must be positive according to (2.10), no fluctuating flow can exist for Reynolds numbers less than R(0).Indeed, in the limit p = 0
F. H.Busse
84
the variational problem (2.13) becomes identical to the energy stability problem which was originally posed by Reynolds (1895) and Orr (1907). The energy stability limit RE = R(0)determines the region 0 < Re < RE in which laminar Couette flow is absolutely stable such that any arbitrary disturbance of the flow decays exponentially. For Re > RE laminar Couette flow may still be stable but disturbances exist which grow in time, at least initially. For a detailed exposition of the energy stability problem in more general cases, see Joseph's (1976) book. The energy stability problem is always included in the optimum problem as the special limit when the Reynolds stress or an equivalent quantity vanishes. On the other hand, the energy stability problem can be posed in more general cases, since the optimum problem depends on the separation of a mean and a fluctuating part of the velocity field. The energy stability problem is essentially a linear problem giving rise to linear Euler equations even though it provides a general sufficient condition for stability. The optimum problem may be regarded as the nonlinear extension of the energy stability problem in those cases in which the laminar solution is invariant with respect to the averaging procedure. Although the possibilities for the most general applications of the optimum problem have not yet been explored, a straightforward mathematical analysis appears to be possible only in those flow problems which are characterized by laminar solutions that are iddependent of the Reynolds number except for the amplitude factor. 111. Multi-a Solutions
A.
CONVECTION IN A POROUS
MEDIUM
Before discussing the variational problem (2.13) in more detail, we shall consider a simpler problem in order to demonstrate the boundary-layer methods for the solution. The simplest variational problem which retains all relevant mathematical properties of the problem (2.13) is posed by the task to find the minimum F ( p ) of the functional 8 ; p) ={( 1vl2)(
Ive12) + p((We-
(we))2)}(we)-2 (3.1) among all fields v, 6' that satisfy the constraint V * v = 0 and the boundary condition w=e=O a t z = ++. (3.2) As before, w is the z-component of the vector v. This variational problem provides an upper bound for the heat transport F(V,
Optimum Theory of Turbulence
85
in a horizontal porous layer heated from below. Although the equations from which (3.1) has been derived are of doubtful validity in the turbulent regime of convection in a porous medium, we shall consider them nevertheless in order to provide a physical background for the discussion of the variational problem (3.1). The physical parameters of convection in a porous medium are the thickness d of the layer, the applied temperature difference T2 - T,, the viscosity v of the fluid, the Darcy permeability coefficient K, and the thermal diffusivityK of the porous medium. For the nondimensional description of the problem we use d, d2/rc,and (T, - T,) Ra- as units for length, time, and temperature, respectively, where Ra is the Rayleigh number defined below. The Darcy-Boussinesq equations for convection in a porous layer are
'
B(ai/at
+ 5 . vi)= -vp + k(T - T' + i, v-i=o,
aTpt
+i
'
(3.3a) (3.3b)
VT = V ~ T ,
(3.4)
and the boundary conditions are given by
T = Ra(T2 + Tl)/2(T,- T,) T Ra/2
k.i=$=O a t z = ki, (3.5) where k represents the unit vector in the z-direction. The nondimensional parameters of the problem are defined by B
E uK/dZv,
Ra
= ygKd(T2 - T,)/vK,
where g denotes the gravitational acceleration. By taking the horizontal average of Eq. (3.4)and subtracting it from (3.4) we obtain two equations for the mean temperature T and the fluctuating temperature 8 = T - F, i.e.,
(3.7) In accordance with our discussion in the preceding chapter we assume a statistically stationary state and neglect the time dependence of averaged quantities. This allows us to integrate (3.6) and obtain
aaZ T = $9
-
-
($8)
- Ra,
where the constant of integration has been determined by applying boundary condition (3.5). By multiplying (3.3a) by i and (3.7) by 8 and taking the
F. H.Busse
86
average over the porous layer we obtain two dissipation integral relationships: (p12)= (s@, (3-9) ( I V6 )1’ + ((3 - ($6))2) = R a ( ~ 6 ) . (3.10) It is evident that the last equation has been obtained in the same way as relationship (2.10) by eliminating the mean field T with the help of expression (3.8). The dimensionless heat transport H across the porous layer can be obtained from its value at the boundary:
H
= -dT/dz
lz=1,2
=
(&) + Ra.
(3.1 1)
From (3.9) it follows that the heat transport with convection is always larger than the static heat transport and that the latter provides a lower bound for the heat transport of all convective motions. An upper bound p for the convective part ($6) of the heat transport at a given value of Ra can be obtained by finding the maximum p of (we) among all vector fields v, 8 that satisfy Eqs. (3.3b), (3.9), and (3.10) and the boundary condition 8 = w = 0 at z = i~$.Instead of solving this variational problem it is convenient to solve the equivalent problem stated in the beginning of this section. Since the functional (3.1) is homogeneous of degree zero with respect to v as well as with respect to 8 the extremalizing solution can be normalized to satisfy ( IvI’) = ( w e ) and p = ( w e ) . In this case relationship (3.10) is satisfied with F replacing Ra. Accordingly F provides a lower bound for the Rayleigh number Ra at a given value of the convective heat transport p. Since F ( p ) is a monotonic function of p in the same way as discussed in the case of R(p),the two variational problems are indeed equivalent. We have already mentioned that the range of validity of Eq. (3.3a) for a porous medium is doubtful. Since we are more concerned with the mathematical properties of the variational problem than its practical applications we shall not discuss this point in detail and refer the interested reader to Busse and Joseph (1972) and Joseph (1976). B. GENERAL PROPERTIES OF THE EXTREMALIZING SOLUTIONS The Euler-Lagrange equations for an extremum, or more exactly, a stationary value of the functional (3.1), are given by
+ [ ( F + p ) ( w e ) - pG]ek - vz = 0, ( ( V I2)v2e- [(F + p ) ( w e ) - ~ G ]=w 0,
( I ve 12)v
v-v=o,
(3.12a) (3.12b) (3.12~)
Optimum Theory of Turbulence
87
where IL represents the Lagrange multiplier by which the constraint V . v = 0 has been taken into account. Equations (3.12) are clearly similar to Eqs. (3.3) (3.7) if expression (3.8) is inserted in (3.7). The main difference is that the time derivative has disappeared from Eqs. (3.12) and the nonlinear term in (3.12) is solely dependent on the z-coordinate. The constants in front of v and 8 in Eqs. (3.12) can be eliminated if suitable normalization conditions are used. In contrast to Eqs. (3.3) and (3.7) the nonlinearity appears symmetrically in (3.12) since the former equations cannot be derived from a variational principle. As a first step of the solution of problem (3.12) we eliminate (3.12~)by introducing the general representation
v = V x (V x k x ) + V x k+ for the solenoidal vector field v. By taking the z-component of the curl of (3.12a) we find (3.13) This means that the toroidal part V x k+ of the velocity either vanishes or is restricted to horizontal translations or rigid rotations about a vertical axis. We shall neglect these possibilities and assume z 0 since the toroidal component must vanish for the minimizing solution because it makes only a positive contribution to the first term in the wavy bracket of (3.1). In the second step toward a solution of problem (3.12) we introduce a Fourier series representation for the functions x and 8 :
+
N
N
8 = fYN)E
1
@,(Z)~,(X,
y)a; 1/2,
(3.14)
n= 1
where 4, satisfies the equation A, 4, = -an24,,and the orthonormalization condition 4,,4,,,= 6,. In general, the number of modes is assumed to be finite, but the possibility that N tends to infinity is not excluded. The functions W,,On,and 4, and the wavenumbers an depend on the cutoff parameter N of the series, but this dependence will be indicated only where necessary. By taking the z-component of the curl-curl of Eq. (3.12a) an equation for x is obtained. This partial differential equation can be reduced to a system of N ordinary differential equations by multiplying it with 4, and taking the horizontal average after the representation (3.14) has been inserted. After dealing with Eq. (3.12b) analogously we obtain the following
F. H.Busse
88
set of 2N equations
+ +
(d2/dz2- a,2)Wn a,@@, = 0, (d2/dzZ - an2)@, cr,@W, = 0,
n = 1, ..., N ,
(3.15)
where
1
@ ~ F C ( W m 0 , ) + p~ ( W m O , , , ) - ~ W m O m . m
(m
m
Unless indicated otherwise the summation is extended from 1 to N. In addition, we have used our freedom of choice of two normalization conditions by assuming
( Ive(2)= ( I v I ~ ) = 1.
(3.16)
The following general properties of the solutions of (3.15) can be demonstrated : (i) The symmetry of Eqs. (3.15) suggests W, = 0,. This property can be For a comproven by considering the equations for W, + 0,and W, - 0,. plete proof see Busse and Joseph (1972) or Joseph (1976). The problem is thus reduced to
+
(d2/dz2 - an2)@, a,@@, = 0
for n = 1, . .., N .
(3.17)
(ii) The functions 0,are either symmetric or antisymmetric in z. This property originates from the similarity of the problem (3.17) with linear eigenvalue problems. For a proof see the above mentioned references. (iii) It can be assumed that all a, are different. If two alphas are equal, say a, = a,, then O,/O, = const. follows from the following consideration. By multiplying the equation for 0,with 0,and vice versa and subtracting the result we obtain 0,”0, - 02”01 = 0. Integration of this expression and application of the boundary condition 0,= 0 at z = +fleads to
0,’0, - 0,’0, =0
or
(@,/@,)‘
= 0.
Accordingly 0,= c 0 , and the solution of the form (3.14) can be rewritten with N - 1 replacing N and @‘few) = 0 , ( 1 + c2)’/’, a?“)= On+ for n > 1. Using the property a, # a, for n # rn we shall assume a, > a,,, for n > m in the following. (iv) A most important property is expressed by
,
(o,,,’o~) = a,a,(O,,,O,).
(3.18)
Optimum Theory of Turbulence
89
This property can be proven for rn # n by multiplying the nth equation of (3.17) by a; '0, and the rnth equation by a; 'On,subtracting the result and averaging it, which, after partial integration, yields the desired relationship (a,
- a,)/a,a,{(O,'O,')
= 0.
- a,a,(O,O,))
For rn = n (3.18) holds as well but does not follow from Eqs. (3.17). Instead the functional (3.1) must be considered as a functional of the functions 0, and the wavenumbers a,, so that 9(0,,..., 0,; a l , ..., a,; p )
i
]'I[ C I - ' (0,')
J 2 + p COm'-~(OmZ) [m
nt
where J is defined by J
= 1((@:)a;' m
,
(3.19)
m
+ a,(@,')).
(3.20)
Then 9 is minimized with respect to a,. Since the minimizations of F and J with respect to a, are equivalent, relationship (3.18) for rn = n is obtained readily by differentiating (3.20) with respect to a,. The similarity of the solutions 0, with the eigenfunctions of a linear eigenvalue problem suggests that 0, should be a symmetric function of z for odd n and an antisymmetric function for even n. Although this property appears to be borne out by numerical computations it has not yet been proven in general. The asymptotic analysis to be discussed next is not dependent on this property. C. BOUNDARY-LAYER THEORY
In minimizing the functional (3.19) we shall focus our attention on the case of asymptotically high values of p. We regard N as a parameter of the problem and consider the minimum of expression (3.19) with respect to N only after the minimization with respect to all other dependences has been carried out. For simplicity we use as normalization condition for the discussion of this section (3.21) (0,2) = 1.
c
To minimize the functional 9 in the limit of large p, Em0,' must be as close to its average value as is possible in view of the boundary conditions 0,= 0 at z = +f.The drop of Cm0,' toward the boundary value is moderated by the fact that the expression (3.20) for J tends to infinity when ([Em0,' - (Om2)]') tends to zero because ofthe required high values
F . H.Busse
90
- 1/2
-2
FIG. 1. Boundary-layer structure of multi-a-solutions. In the case of convection in a porous medium, W, = Q,.
of one or more of the functions em'. A balance between the two terms within the braces of (3.19) obviously determines the minimum F")(p). In the case N = 1 it is easy to visualize the minimizing solution O1.The dependence of el2 is similar to that shown by the thick line in Fig. 1. Indeed the problem can be solved exactly in this case in terms of elliptic integrals (Busse and Joseph, 1972). The case of N > 1 offers richer possibilities for the solution. Since large derivatives 0,'correspond to high values a,, expression (3.20)can be minimized by using 0,to describe the boundary layer. In order to keep (0,')small, 0,must decay rapidly toward the interior, although not as rapidly as it rises from the boundary value 0,= 0. At the same time 0,- rises from the boundary value 0,- = 0 to ensure 0 , '+ z 1. This process is repeated, as sketched in Fig. 1, until O1 covers the interior of the interval -4 I z I 4. In the following we demonstrate that this heuristic picture does indeed correspond to the asymptotic solutions of the Euler equations of the variational problem. We start by introducing different symbols for the rising and decaying part of the function 0,in the neighborhood of z = -4, for ( z + 3) z O ( P - ~ ~ ) for ( z + 4) = o(p-'*-') 6,([,,)
for n = 1, . . . , N . (3.22)
The procedure at the upper boundary z = 4 is analogous and does not have to be considered separately. It is assumed that the boundary layers scale with powers of p as p tends to infinity. Accordingly the boundary layer coordinates c,, are defined by (3.23)
Optimum Theory of Turbulence
91
We shall assume that 0, differs from zero essentially only in the nth and (n - 1)th boundary layers such that
Gn2+ 6,2+zz 1 for (z + 3) z The functions
for n = 1, . . ., N - 1.
6, and 6, satisfy the boundary @,(O)=O
conditions
an(m)=O
and
(3.24)
(3.25)
and must be matched at their maximum value 1. From the scaling (3.23),
an2= ( O ; ~ ) / ( O , , ~ >
-
m
6;' dC,,//
pr"+r"-l jom
= Prn+rn-l bn2
(1 - 6;- 1) dr,-
0
for n = 2, . . ., N ,
and m
j
a 1 2= pr12
6;' dr, = pr'b12,
(3.26)
0
where (3.21)and (3.24) have been used. Neglecting terms of higher order the boundary-layer approximation of the functional (3.19) can be written in the form
+ 2p1-" jOm (I - 6~')' dcN.
(3.27)
Differentiation of this expression with respect to the exponents r, yields the result that all powers of p in (3.27) must be equal, so that 1 - rN = rN - rN- = ... = r2 - r l
=
rl,
which yields the solution r, = n/(N
+ 1)
for n = 1, . . ., N .
(3.28)
F. H.Busse
92
Accordingly (3.27) can be rewritten in the somewhat simpler form
where
The Euler equations corresponding to a stationary value of the functional (3.29) can be written in the form
6,''+ b,b,+16,, = 0 16~" + bN( 1 - 6 ~ ' ) =60.~
for n = 1, ..., N - 1,
(3.30a) (3.30b)
Equivalently, these equations could be derived by introducing the boundary-layer approximation in Eq. (3.15). The solutions of Eq. (3.30) satisfying condition (3.25) are given by
6, = +sin(b,b,+
l)l/zcn
for 0 I (, I 7~/2(b,b,+~)'/~, (3.31a)
6,= f t a n h [ ( i b ~ / J ) ' / ~ [ ~ ]
for ( N 2 0.
(3.31b)
The endpoint of the interval of c, is the appropriate matching point with the function 6,= f(1 - 6;- ')lj2. We have allowed for both signs of the solutions since only quadratic expressions enter the functional. Antisymmetric functions 0,have opposite signs in the two boundary layers while symmetric functions 0,have the same sign. Using (3.31) in the definition (3.26), the values of b, can be computed. Thus, for n = 1, ..., N - 1, b, = (b,+lb,-l)llz bl = 7~(b~/b,)'/~/2,
(3.32)
bN= 8(bN- /2S)'/'/3.lr which together yield the general expression b, = (7~/2)(8/3~2N1/2)(2"i)/(N+
From the results (3.32) and (3.33) we find
J = 2Nb1,
1)
(3.33)
Optimum Theory of Turbulence
93
and finally
PN)'(p) = p " / ( N + ' ) N (+ N 1)4b12 = x Z N ( N+ 1 ) ( 6 4 , ~ / 9 ~ ~ N ) ' / " + ~(3.34) ). So far we have minimized the functional (3.1) with respect to fields of the form (3.14)with given value of the parameter N . The result (3.34)shows that the minimum F ( p ) among the class of functions {F")(p)) is assumed successively by N = 1, 2, .. ., as p increases. The corresponding upper bound for the convective part of the heat transport in a porous medium is shown in Fig. 2. At finite values of p the conclusions drawn from the boundary-layer analysis are at best tentative and we have distinguished the results for this reason by the superscript from the exact expressions. However, the direct numerical solutions of the Euler equations (3.17) confirm the basic conclusions of the boundary-layer theory as shown by the comparison in Fig. 3 and indicates that the asymptotic theory provides a fair description at finite values of p. The "kinks" in the upper bound curve are also confirmed by a more detailed analysis except that the first derivative is continuous at the transition from F")(,u) to P N + ' ) ( p ) and the discontinuity occurs in the second derivative. The ( N + 1) - a solution branches from the N - a solution at this point in very much the same way as solutions resulting from hydrodynamic instabilities bifurcate from a stationary basic flow. The similarities between the branchings of the optimizing vector fields and the transitions observed in convection are particularly striking. The reader is referred to the discussion in Section VI. A
0
FIG.2. Upper bound for the Nusselt number Nu (= heat transport with convection/heat transport by conduction only) in the case of convection in a porous medium.
94
F. H. Busse
-0.5
-0.4
ZFIG.3. The 2-a-solution at R = 5 0 d : The graph shows numerical computations (solid line) and boundary-layer theory (dashed line) of 0 , and 0,. This figure differs from Fig. 1 of Busse and Joseph (1972) in that an improved numerical approximation has been used.
IV. Bounds on the Transport of Momentum A. EXTREMALIZING VECTORFIELDS The multiple boundary-layer technique developed in the preceding chapter will now be used for the solution of variational problem (2.13). We start by considering the Euler equations for the extremalizing vector field of (2.13), i.e.,
V x (V x V)
+ V7t + w dzd U + ku -
d - U = 0, dz
(4.la)
v.v=o,
(4.lb)
where the expressions d dz
-B
= UW-
(uw) - Ri
and
(4.1~)
R = R ( p ) - ( IV x v I’)/2(UXW)
Optimum Theory of Turbulence
95
have been introduced to demonstrate the similarity of the Euler equations with the basic Navier-Stokes equations (2.6), (2.7), and (2.9) of the problem. The normalization condition (2.14) has been used and IT is the Lagrange multiplier by which the continuity equation has been taken into account. Equation (4.la) represents a “symmetrized” version of Eq. (2.6), d o / & appears in all components of Eq. (4.la), while dU/dz does not appear in the z-component of Eq. (2.6). For this reason the definition (4.1~)is not directly analogous to Eq. (2.9) and l? equals R(p)/2 in the limit p + 0. The properties that time does not enter the variational problem and that nonlinear terms depend only on the z-coordinate are unrealistic features of the Euler equations. The same features, however, allow an analytic solution of the equations for large values of p which is impossible in the case of the equations of motion. In solving Eq. (4.1) we introduce the hypothesis that the minimizing vector field v is independent of the x-coordinate. This hypothesis has been proven in the limit of small p (Busse, 1972c) and the fact that y-independent vector fields lead to much higher values of the functional (2.13) provides additional support for the hypothesis (Busse, 1970b). In view of its importance for the optimum theory of turbulent shear flows it is highly desirable to replace the hypothesis by a rigorous proof. The x-independence of the optimum vector field may be seen in contrast with the fact that the equations of motion (2.6), (2.7), and (2.9) d o not permit a nondecaying x-independent velocity field v. This impression is misleading, however, as a much closer relationship between the optimum vector field and the physically realized velocity field is found in a rotating system (see Section IV,C). An x-independent solenoidal vector field v can be represented in the form u,
= u, = e,
uy
= uy
=
-a+/az,
u,
=
a$/ay.
(4.2)
In the following we shall neglect the term Uyw in the functional (2.13). This is justified because this term makes only a positive contribution to the functional and u i i vanishes for the solutions of the Euler equations derived from the reduced functional. Using the representation (4.2) the dissipation term ( I V x v 1)’ can be written in the form ( I V x v 1 2 ) = (IV~l”+((V2$)’).
(4.31
When the ratio D of the amplitudes of 8 and $ is varied while the product of the amplitudes is kept constant, all terms of the functional (2.13) (in which uyw = 0 is assumed) remain unchanged with the exception of the term (4.3). This term reaches a minimum as a function of D when
( 1 ve 1)’
+ ( ( v ~ $ )=~2() I ve 12)1/2((v2$)2)1/2
(4.4)
96
F . H. Busse
holds. We may thus assume that the minimizing solution of the variational satisfies the property (4.4) and consider the following variational problem in place of (2.13): given p > 0, find the minimum R ( p ) of the functional
among all fields 8(y, z), $(y, z ) that satisfy the boundary conditions
e=$=a$laz=o
a t z = &+
(4.6)
and the condition ( w 8 h ) > 0. We have introduced the function h ( z ) to treat a slightly more general variational problem which can be applied later to the case of channel flow. We assume ((h(z))’) = 1,
= ho.
h(4) = h ( - + )
(4.7)
The case of Couette flow is recovered by specifying h ( z ) = h, = 1. Because the functional (4.5) is homogeneous and of degree zero with respect to 8 and I) we can impose two normalization conditions. We choose
(w eh) = 1, ( w z ) = (ez). (4.8) The form of the functional (4.5) suggests a close similarity of the present variational problem to the problem treated in Section II1,A. The fact that a higher order differential operator occurs in (4.5) and that four boundary conditions must be fulfilled by $ instead of two destroys the symmetry of 8 and w. But the extremalizing fields 8, w are rather similar in all other respects. We consider solutions of the variational problem of the form n= 1
n=l
with +,,(y) satisfying the relationships dZ - + n ( Y ) = -an24n(Y),
(4n4m)
= anm*
dY2 In order to minimize the functional (4.5) in the limit p + 00, must approach the function h ( z ) throughout the interior of the layer. Near the boundary a sharp drop must occur such that the boundary conditions (4.6) become satisfied. The “sharpness” of the drop depends on the balance between the two terms of functional (4.5). The availability of components with different length scales in the Fourier-series representation (4.9)allows one to minimize the functional (4.5) by fields w, 8 with a multiple boundary-layer
Optimum Theory of Turbulence
97
structure. In analogy to (3.221, we assume at the boundary z =
-4
where the boundary layer coordinates c,, are defined by (3.23). Throughout each boundary layer only two components of the representation (4.9) are essentially different from zero such that w,@,
+ w,- ,0,- ,
%
- + iu,- ,0,. ,
it,,@,
%
ho,
for n = 2, . . . , N , (4.11)
is satisfied. In the interior w,0,
= h(z)
(4.12)
must be fulfilled. Because of conditions (4.8) w1 and 0 , have the same order of magnitude in the interior, i.e., s1 = 0, while in the boundary layers different dependences on p must be admitted as shown in expressions (4.10). After taking into account the dependence of the wavenumbers a,, on p, i.e., an2= pqnbn2,
(4.13)
the functional (4.5)can be minimized as a function of the exponents r,,, 4,,,pn, and s, with the result (Busse, 1970b) 1 - 4-" r, = 2 - 4 - N ) ~
qfl=
2 - 4 ' 4-" 2-4-N
9
4-" 2pn=2-4-N'
%=o.
The corresponding p-dependence of the asymptotic minimum l@N)(p) of the functional (4.5) can be written in the form P"(p)
= F ( N ) pl i ( 2 - 4 - N ) .
(4.14)
To obtain an expression for F ( N ) the function R must be minimized with respect to the functions G,,,6,, it,, 6,. Instead of listing the complete set of Euler equations for those functions, we restrict our attention to the equations for the interior dependence, i t , , 6,,which will be needed for a later discussion. These are D - ' b 1 2 i t ,=
with
and
D b 1 2 6 ,= "it,,
(4.15a)
98
F. H.Busse
D denotes the ratio of the second to the first square root in the first term of the right-hand side of (4.5). From Eqs. (4.8) and (4.15a) we conclude D = 1. After the Euler equations are solved in terms of the parameters b,, the boundary-layer approximation of expression (4.5) can be minimized with respect to b,, yielding F ( N ) = 2h0h1(2- 4-N)4Nb12,
(4.16)
where h, is defined by h , z (Ih(z)()/h, = (612)/ho = ( i c 1 2 ) / h o .
The minimizing values of the wavenumber parameters b, are
b,,, = (blh1/44/3/3)1-4-"b 14"
for n = 1, ..., N
-
1,
(4.17)
where 0 = 0.337,
/3 = 0.624
are constants arising from the boundary-layer solutions which have been computed by Howard (1963) and Busse (1969b). We note that the value of /3 is slightly different from that calculated by Busse (1969b), because the integral constraint 3
jm ii11'
dt
+ jw
Qt2
0
0
W
dt
=2
j
(1 -
iis)dt
0
had not been taken into account in that work and its consideration leads to the improved value for 8. Asymptotically, relationship (4.16) yields R(m)(p)
= h;/247/3 (03 /3)1/4p1/2,
(4.18)
which shows the same dependence on p as the solution of the variational problem without the constraint of the continuity equation (Busse, 1969a;see also Howard, 1972). The coefficient of pl/' is lower by a factor 0.38 in the latter case. This close correspondence is another indication that a value lower than (4.18) can hardly be expected if the assumption of x-independent extremalizing vector fields is relaxed. WITH OBSERVATIONS B. COMPARISON
The functions ff("(p) are asymptotic expressions which have been derived under the assumption that p tends to infinity. As in the case of convection in a porous layer discussed earlier, it is reasonable to expect that the expressions (4.14), (4.16) give a fair representation of the exact function R")(p) at
Optimum Theory of Turbulence
99
finite values of p. The absolute minimum among the functions R")(p) exhibits the characteristic property that it is assumed by R"), R(2),and so on, as p increases. Detailed calculations are likely to show that the kinks in minimum R ( p ) correspond actually to discontinuities in the second derivative instead of the first derivative as a literal interpretation of the asymptotic boundary layer results would suggest. But the general character of the curve R ( p ) is not influenced by this distinction. To obtain an upper bound for the momentum transport (2.11) in turbulent Couette flow, the inverse functions jYN)(R)of f i ( N ) ( pmust ) be considered, M
= Re + (fixfi)
IRe
+ ma~,@(~)(Re)].
(4.19)
The comparison of the experimental data with the upper bound (4.19) in Fig. 4 indicates that the upper bound exceeds the measured values by a factor of about 10. It is noteworthy, however, that the measured data parallel the slope of the upper bound. The fact that the momentum transport tends to approach a Re2-law can
FIG.4. The upper bound for the momentum transport M by turbulent Couette flow. The bound for (M/Re) - 1 has been plotted in comparison with the experimental values by Reichardt (1959) for water ( x ) and for air (+ ). The line labeled I indicates the asymptotic bound derived without the constraint of the equation of continuity. (After Busse, 1970b) (Copyright by Cambridge University Press.Reprinted with permission.)
100
F. H. Busse
be understood from the following simple argument. The Reynolds number based on the thickness 6d of the viscous sublayer adjacent to the wall in which the momentum is transported by viscous stresses is Re 6. Re/6 is a measure of the dimensionless momentum transport M since the velocity change across the sublayer is of the order Re. Applying a criterion for the instability of laminar flow, we find that the viscous sublayer becomes unstable if Re 6 2 R,,
(4.20)
where R, is a constant of the order lo3.By expressing the sublayer thickness 6 in terms of the momentum transport, 6 z Re/M this criterion can be rewritten in the form Re2 2 R, M.
(4.21)
.Accordingly, the laminar sublayer will be unstable unless the momentum transport grows like Re'. On the other hand, it follows from (4.19)that M cannot grow stronger than Re2 asymptotically. The momentum transport is thus forced to grow like Re2 which appears to be in approximate agreement with the experimental observations in the Couette case. The similarity between the extremalizing vector field and the observed turbulent flow is more pronounced in the comparison of the mean flow. Using the relationship
(4.22) we find that the right-hand side approaches -R(")(p)/4 as p tends to infinity. The mean shear of the extremalizing vector field thus amounts to 4 of the shear of the laminar solution. Surprisingly, this $law appears to be borne out by the measurements shown in Fig. 5. The persistence of a finite mean shear in a fully developed turbulent flow seems to contradict the intuition that the Reynolds stresses wipe out any mean shear except near boundaries. The logarithmic law of the wall which should be particularly appropriate for the constant stress layer realized in turbulent Couette flow is in obvious disagreement with this result. Since the effects of advection and time dependence are neglected in the optimum theory, a much lower level of correspondence with observations must be expected for the fluctuating vector field. Perhaps the most interesting aspect is the dependence of the characteristic length scale on the distance from the wall. The value of N for which expression (4.14)becomes a minimum at a given value of p is asymptotically determined by
101
Optimum Theory of Turbulence
-0.8
. .
.
2 a.
-1
FIG. 5. The mean velocity in plane Couette flow measured by Reichardt (1959) at Re = 1200 (O), Re = 2900 ( x ), Re = 5900 (+), and Re = 34,000 (A). The straight line describes the asymptotic profile corresponding to the extremalizing vector field.
The boundary-layer scales dn and the associated wavenumbers of the extremalizing vector field approach, therefore, asymptotically the relationships d n -= p-'"(b n bZ n + l )-ll3
+ hl/fl4"-'
for n = 1, ..., N - 1,
dN G p - r N( b ~ h ~ ) - -+l ' h1(CJ/fl)''2/f14N+ ~ ',
(4.23)
i.e., the thickness of subsequent boundary layers differ by a factor of 4. Although for a factor of 4 the boundary-layer assumption made in the analysis appears to be not well satisfied, the rather good agreement with numerical results in similar cases suggests that the boundary-layer description remains essentially correct. Figure 6 shows the boundary-layer structure of the extremalizing vector field. As in Prandtl's mixing-length theory, the characteristic scale is proportional to the distance from the wall. But instead of a continuous spectrum of wavelengths, the length scale changes in steps in accordance with the discrete wavenumber spectrum of the extremalizing vector field. C. MOMENTUM TRANSPORT IN A ROTATINGSYSTEM A basic reason for the differences between the fluctuating component of the velocity field in turbulent shear flow and the extremalizingvector fields is the fact that x-independent fluctuating velocity fields always decay in the
102
F . H.Busse
s
FIG.6. Sketch of the boundary-layer region of the vector field maximizing the momentum transport.
presence of a mean shear flow in the x-direction (Joseph and Tao, 1963). Moreover, linear stability theory for plane parallel shear flow predicts [Squire’s (1933) theorem] that y-independent rather than x-independent disturbances are the most unstable ones. But these properties are restricted to a nonrotating system. The Coriolis force in a rotating system can release the dynamical constraint which prevents the realization of x-independent fluctuating velocity fields. Taylor vortices between differentially rotating coaxial cylinders are the best-known example for such a release of a dynam-
Optimum Theory of Turbulence
103
ical constraint by the Coriolis force. In the following, this example will be studied in the small gap limit where curvature effects can be neglected. The optimum theory formulated in Section II,A holds in rotating systems as well as in a nonrotating system, since the effects of rotation enter the dynamics of an incompressible fluid only in the form of the Coriolis force, which does not contribute to the energy relationship (2.8). f i a t the upper bound is independent of the rotation rate implies, on the one hand, a general applicability to a wide variety of fluid systems. On the other hand, it emphasizes a shortcoming of the optimum theory-at least in the form in which it has been considered up to this point-in that important dynamical effects like those of the Coriolis force are not taken into account as constraints for the optimizing vector fields. In a particular case mentioned below, however, it is obvious that an additional constraint involving the Coriolis force cannot improve the upper bound. We consider the equivalent of Eqs. (2.6) and (2.7) in a rotating system. In the limit when ir is sufficiently small such that nonlinear terms can be neglected, we find
VzS - V(p - p) = 2S2 x v
+U
*
a
a
az
at
VS + $ - U + - S,
V.S=O.
(4.24) (4.25)
In order to eliminate the continuity equation (4.25),we introduce the general representation for the solenoidal field v:
S=V
x
(V x k 4 ) + V
x
k$,
(4.26)
where k is the unit vector in the z-direction normal to the boundaries. The laminar solution of the problem,
(4.27)
U = -Re iz,
is the same as in a nonrotating system if the z-component of &2vanishes, so that fi = n,i
+ 0,j.
Restricting our attention to the case of x-independent stationary solutions of Eq. (4.24), we obtain, after operating with k . V x (V x ) and k V x on (4.24),
az4 - m v -aYz 4
a3 -*=o,
y ay3
a2
V2 7t+b - (Re - 2Qy) aY
a3 ~
aY3
4 = 0.
(4.28)
F. H.Busse
104 The elimination of $ ytelds
V6 - 2R,(Re The solution of this equation, together with the corresponding boundary conditions a 4=-+=V4+=0 atz=
*+,
a2
has first been obtained in the context of the onset of convection in a layer heated from below (Pellew and Southwell, 1940). The minimum Reynolds number for the onset of x-independent disturbances is given by
+ --1708
(4.29) 2% It corresponds to a wavenumber a, = 3.117 of the y-dependence exp{iay}.As a function of R,, the lowest value of expression (4.29) is reached for Re, = 2R,
2R, = (1708)”,.
(4.30)
At this point the value of Re, becomes equal with the minimum value R ( p ) for which a solution of the problem (4.1)exists. Indeed, when the representation (4.26) for the vector field v is used, it can easily be verified (Busse, 1970a) that the problem (4.7)becomes identical to problem (4.28)in the limit p = 0. This implies that in the case (4.30)the instability must occur in the form of infinitesimal x-independent disturbances and that the possibility of subcritical finite-amplitude instability can be excluded. This particular case in which the stability problem is completely solved and in which the optimum problem coincides with the physical state in the limit p = 0, is realized experimentally between two coaxial cylinders with radii R 1 and R,, and angular velocities R1,R, if the small gap limited ( R , - R 1 ) / ( R 2 R , ) 4 1 is approached such that
+
-4- R , - R1 +R, R,+Rl is satisfied. Since the x-component of does not enter the relationship, other experimental realizations can be obtained by an additional relative motion of the cylinders in the axial direction, as in the experiments by Ludwieg (1964) and Nagib (1972). These experiments clearly demonstrate the destabilizing role of the Coriolis force and the Occurrence of the longitudinal vortex in a wide variety of flow configurations. The optimum theory for turbulent flow between coaxial differentially rotating cylinders has been considered for arbitrary radius ratios in the papers
a1 R1
Optimum Theory of Turbulence
105
by Nickerson (1969) and Busse (1972a). The optimum theory indicates a significant variation of the mean flow profile as a function of the parameters of the problem. Because of the scarcity of experimental measurements of the turbulent mean flow, it has not yet been possible to realize the interesting possibilities for a comparison between optimum theory and observations in this case.
V. Bounds on the Transport of Mass A. TURBULENT CHANNEL FLOW Next to Couette flow, the flow driven by a constant pressure gradient in a channel defined by two infinite parallel plates represents the simplest case of fluid motion. The application of the optimum theory to this system can be accomplished by a slight modification of the discussion in Section 11. Assuming that the imposed pressure gradient is directed in the negative x-direction the energy balance becomes
( I v x v* 1)’
+ ( I ii3 - (a*) 1)’
- A,( ri,$12) = 0,
(54 in place of relationship (2.10). Using the average flow in the x-direction for the definition of the Reynolds number Re, the relationship between Re and the magnitude A, of the gradient can be written in the form Re = (U
(
) 1:
i) = - zz : U i = - A, - (li,3z).
(5-2)
The following variational problem provides a lower bound for Re(12)”’ at a given value p of ( ~ ~ , I X J Z ( I ~ ) ~ / ’ ) : Given p 2 0, find the minimum R ( p ) of the functional
among all bounded vector fields v that satisfy (2.12b) and (2.12~)and have (ii, 3z(12)’/’) > 0. In anticipation that (uw) vanishes for the extremalizing solution, this term has been neglected in the definition of the functional. Since R ( p ) is a monotonically increasing function of p, it is equivalent to say that R ( p ) provides a lower bound for Re(12)”’ at a given value p of ( ~ ~ w z ( l 2 ) ’ ~or’ )at a given value ( p + ~(p))(12)’/’of A,. The transport of mass through a channel at given pressure head is thus bounded from below by R ( p ) , while an upper bound is given by A,/12 since (u, w z ) is positive according to the energy balance (5.1).
106
F. H. Busse
The factor 12l” has been introduced in the definition (5.3) in order to apply the analysis of Section IV directly. Following through the steps described by (4.2)and (4.4),the functional (5.3) can be-transformed into the form (4.5) with h ( z ) = z(12)’/2,
and the results (4.16), (4.17),and (4.18)can be applied directly to the present case by using
h , = 4. A more detailed discussion is given by Busse (1970b). Asymptotically the optimizing solution satisfies Prandtl’s wall proximity law which states that the structure of the turbulent flow becomes independent of the Reynolds number if the friction velocity U , and the length U , /v are used as scales for the velocity and the distance from the wall. In the dimensionless units of this paper, the friction velocity Ur is defined by ho = 3112,
where the last equality is approached asymptotically for fully developed turbulence when the transport of momentum is carried almost entirely by the Reynolds stresses. Among the features which have been found to be independent of the Reynolds number in experimental observations of turbulent channel flow is the ratio between the rms value of the x-component of the fluctuating velocity field and the mean flow close to the boundary. Laufer (1951) found 0.18 for this ratio, a more recent value given by Eckelmann (1974) is 0.24. In the optimum theory, this ratio becomes asymptotically
/(3)1’2p% 0.49, C=O
(5.4)
where the value of a@/dtI,=, has been taken from Howard’s (1963) boundary-layer calculation. The result that the value (5.4)is more than twice the observed value is not surprising if it is remembered that the optimum vector field is much more efficient in transporting momentum than the physically realized turbulent velocity field and accordingly grows more rapidly away from this boundary. That the structure of the optimizing vector field is approached qualitatively by the realized turbulent flow is evident from the observations of the longitudinal eddies in the viscous sublayer by
Optimum Theory of Turbulence
107
Kline et al. (1967)and Gupta et al. (1971).Again, the observed eddies are not as close to the wall as the Nth eddy in optimizing solution and thus the observed wavelength A+ =loo based on the friction velocity scale is more than twice as large as the wavelength
The mean profile corresponding to the optimizing vector field exhibits a finite shear as in the Couette case. The measured profiles are slightly flatter toward the center of the channel than the optimal profile shown in Fig. 7. The traditional theoretical description of the mean-flow profile of turbulent shear flow is based on the assumption that the turbulent flow outside the viscous sublayer becomes independent of the viscosity and that the only relevant length scale is the distance from the wall. This leads to the universal logarithmic velocity profile connecting the viscously dominated shear region near the wall and the region outside where the assumption of a constant momentum transport is no longer valid. The optimizing vector field does not conform to the assumption of a single length scale determining the structure of the profile. The presence of the other wall is always felt and the boundarylayer part of the mean profile (not shown in Fig. 7) is proportional to the
FIG. 7. Asymptotic profiles of the mean flow corresponding to the extremalizing vector field in the case of channel flow (a) and pipe flow (b).
108
F. H. Busse
inverse of the distance from the wall rather than depending on it logarithmically. The optimal profile obviously does not fit the observations as well as the suitably adjusted logarithmic profile, although some of the discrepancy may disappear if the boundary-layer theory is replaced by a more accurate numerical solution. The fact, however, that the optimizing vector field does not obey the scaling assumption, together with the evidence that the logarithmic distribution seems to fail in the Couette case, which represents its most appropriate application, casts some doubts on the universal validity of the scaling assumption. B. TURBULENT PIPEFLOW Turbulent flow in circular pipes is easier to realize experimentally than turbulent channel flow. The optimum theory on the other hand becomes somewhat more difficult for a cylindrical geometry because only a discrete spectrum of wavenumbers in the azimuthal direction is available instead of the continuously varying wavenumbers in the case of the channel. A consequence of this property is that the extremalizing solution is not quite independent of the x-coordinate along the axis of the pipe, as is evident from the solution by Joseph and Carmi (1969) in the energy stability limit p = 0. Because the&-dependence is very small, we shall neglect it in the discussion of the extremalizing vector field. Since the results of the optimum theory depend primarily on the boundary-layer structure which is characterized by relatively high values of the wavenumbers, the fact that the parameters @n assume only integer values should not have an appreciable effect. We thus proceed with the application of the theory developed in Section IV. A more exact treatment of the problem has been given by Busse (1972b) in which the property has been taken into account that the interior wavenumber a1 assumes only integer values. The equations corresponding to (5.1) and (5.2) in the case of channel flow are
where a cylindrical system of coordinates (r, 4, x ) has been assumed. The bar indicates the average over surfaces r = const. and the angular brackets denote the average over the infinite volume of the cylindrical pipe whose radius has been set equal to 1. A, is the component of the mean pressure gradient in the negative x-direction. The following variational problem provides a lower bound for 81/2 Re at a given value p of ( 1 i 5 ~ 4 ) 2 ~ / ’ .
Optimum Theory of Turbulence
109
Given p 2 0, find the minimum R ( p ) of the functional
among all bounded vector fields v that vanish at r = 1, satisfy V . v = 0 and have ( u , u, r(2)’/’) > 0. As in the case of channel flow, R ( p )provides a lower bound for 8’12 Re at a given value of A, = 8’/’(p R ( p ) ) as well as at a given value of p. Using the definitions
+
the functional (5.8) can be transformed into the form (4.5) by replacing h(z) with r(2)’/’ and the results (4.16),(4.17),and (4.18)can be applied to the case of pipe flow by specifying
ho = 2’12,
h , = 2.
The relationship between the optimizing vector field and the observed turbulence in pipe flow is essentially the same as in the case of channel flow. The discrepancy between the lower bound R ( p ) and the realized value of Re(8)’12 increases as Re increases. Measurements by Nikuradse (1932) give (see Hinze, 1959)
while the asymptotic result (4.18) yields the lower bound
Because of the circular cross section of the pipe the mean profile of the optimizing vector field differs slightly from the profile for channel flow as shown in Fig. 7. The property that the curvature of the mean profile in the case of pipe flow is higher than in the case of a channel flow at the same maximum velocity agrees with the experimental findings. For the comparison with the observed profile, a more accurate description of the optimal profile is desirable which would take into account the boundary-layer contributions. But this will require a numerical solution of the problem. The structure of optimizing vector field is in many respects similar to the observed structure of turbulent pipe flow. In particular, the observation made by Laufer (1954) that the rate of energy production at a point is approximately balanced by the rate of energy dissipation is reflected by the Euler equations because the advection of energy does not enter the optimum
F. H.Busse
110
problem. The shape of the observed rms velocity distributions is similar to that exhibited by the optimum theory (Busse, 1970b).Another feature of the optimum theory, namely, the equality of the energies dissipated by the mean flow and by the fluctuating motion, is also approximately shown by the observed turbulence. The maximum of the energy production was found by Laufer at a distance (1 - r ) o , zz 11.5 from the wall. Because of its higher transport efficiency the optimizing vector field exhibits this maximum at (1 - r ) o , z 1.70 * (/3/0)’/~ * 4ll3 = 3.15. The number 1.70 represents the value of 5 where QW(l - O W ) reaches its maximum in Howard’s (1963) boundary-layer analysis. Asymptotically this point represents the distance at which the laminar shearing stress is equal to the turbulent shearing stress. We conclude that mainly because of the low correlation coefficient ~ / ( ~ ) 1the” realized , turbulent flow differs in all quantitative aspects from the optimizing vector field. The qualitative similarity between the two fields suggests, however, that the realized velocity field tends to approach optimal transport properties. VI. Bounds on the Transport of Heat
A.
CONVECTION IN A
LAYERHEATED FROM BELOW
The closest correspondence between the optimum theory and the physically realized turbulent flow has been found in the case of thermal convection. In contrast to shear flow turbulence in a nonrotating system the onset of convection is not delayed by dynamical constraints and a gradual development of turbulence characterizes convective systems. In the problem of convection in a layer heated from below the energy-stability limit coincides with the actual onset of convection, and in the special case of stress-free boundary conditions the upper bound for the heat transport equals the physically realized heat transport in the limit of small convection amplitudes. The nondimensional Boussinesq equations for convection in a layer heated from below are identical with Eqs. (3.3) and (3.4) i f f in (3.3a) is replaced by -V2f and the Darcy permeability coefficient K is set equal to d2. In this case the parameter B equals the inverse of the Prandtl number Pr = V / K Accordingly the integral dissipation relationships
( (VfIZ) = ($0)
(6.la)
($8))’)
(6.1b)
and
(lV812)
+ (($8-
= Ra(48)
Optimum Theory of Turbulence
111
are obtained in place of expressions (3.9) and (3.10). Based on relationships (6.1), the variational problem can be formulated which provides an upper bound p on the heat transport by convection ($8) at a given value R ( p ) of the Rayleigh number or, equivalently, a lower bound R ( p ) for the Rayleigh number at a given value p of the heat transport ($8). Since the latter possibility is mathematically more convenient, it will be used here: Given p 2 0, find R ( p ) , the minimum of the functional
among all bounded fields v, 0 that vanish at z = *iand satisfy the equation of continuity, V . v = 0. We have assumed the case of rigid boundaries which is realized in most experimental studies. The case of stress-free boundaries has been considered by Straus (1973, 1976a). The solution of the variational problem (6.2) without the constraint of the continuity equation has been derived by Howard (1963) in analytical form. In the same paper the problem is also solved under the assumption of a single horizontal wavenumber. The technique of multiple boundary layers was developed in connection with problem (6.2) by Busse (1969b). Since the analysis is analogous to those described in Sections II1,B and IV,A, it will not be repeated here. The main result is the asymptotic minimum for the N-a-solution of the Euler equations, where b, is given by 1 4-~)-2. b4(3 - 4 - N , = 4 - 6N(./p)3 (8443)4( 1- 4 - ~ ) ( 1
(6.4)
As in previously discussed cases the absolute minimum R ( p ) is given, one after another, by the functions R")(p) starting with N = 1. The predictions of the boundary-layer theory have been verified by the numerical computations of Straus (1976b). Since some higher order terms have been neglected in the boundary-layer approximation R")(p) for R("(p), the exact upper bound p ( R )shown in Fig. 8 is lower than predicted by the asymptotic theory. The transitions from N to N + 1 in the bounding curve are in good agreement, however. The transitions or "kinks" in the function p ( R ) are a prominent feature of the optimum theory which has a direct physical counterpart in turbulent convection. Schmidt and Saunders (1938) were the first to report a transition in the heat-transport curve beyond the initial transition corresponding to the onset of convection. Malkus (1954a) found six transitions in a thermal decay experiment which is known for its low noise. Since then, transitions
112
F . H.Busse
Ra FIG.8. Upper bound for the Nusselt number Nu for convection in a layer heated from below. The graph shows numerical computations (solid, after Straus, 1976b), and asymptotic results (dashed). (a) and (b) are single-a bounds, (c) and (d) are two-a bounds.
have been found by many experimenters, although the reality of some transitions is doubtful, while others may depend on the Prandtl number of the convection fluid (Willis and Deardorff, 1967; Chu and Goldstein, 1973). The combination of visual observations and heat-flow measurements employed by Krishnamurti (1970) has shown clearly that the transition in the Rayleigh-number range of 1.7 x lo4 to 2.2 x lo4 is caused by the onset of bimodal convection (Busse, 1967; Busse and Whitehead, 1971). Since, in addition to the basic convection rolls, a second system of rolls of higher wavenumber occurs in this case in the thermal boundary layers, bimodal convection is directly analogous to the 2-a-solution of the optimum theory. In the case of the next higher transition observed at a Rayleigh number of about 6 x lo4, a direct analogy is not easily seen, even though the upperbound transition from N = 2 to N = 3 occurs nearly at the same Rayleigh number, namely at R = 6.3 x lo4. Experimenters identify this transition usually with the onset of time-dependent convection; but the Prandtl number dependence expected for such a transition has not been observed. According to the optimum theory a velocity field with a discrete spectrum of the horizontal wavenumber is more efficient in transporting heat than a velocity field with a continuous spectrum. Indications of a discrete spectrum in turbulent convection were found by Deardoff and Willis (1967), but their measurements could not be reproduced in the more recent study of Fitzjarrald (1976). It is difficult to find evidence for a discrete wavenumber spectrum because the normal experimental procedure determines the spectrum of the wavenumber component in a single horizontal direction, while discrete values can be expected only for the total horizontal wavenumber.
Optimum Theory of Turbulence
113
New evidence for several discrete wavenumbers present in the spectrum of convection at Rayleigh numbers of the order of lo5 has been obtained with an optical method by Parsapour (1977). As predicted by the optimum theory the spectrum changes abruptly at the transition points of the heat flux curve, but between these points the wavenumbers tend to decrease rather than increase with increasing Rayleigh number as suggested by the theory. It should be kept in mind that the optimum theory is not capable of giving a detailed picture of the physically realized turbulence especially since a constraint involving the time dependence has not yet been taken into account. But the remarkable similarity between the optimizing vector field and the realized turbulent convection must be interpreted as the tendency of the latter to approach a maximum heat transport. The discrete wavenumbers and discrete transitions observed in turbulent convection provide an important reminder that the commonly acknowledged tendency toward randomness represents only one aspect of fully developed turbulence. On the smooth background discrete peaks seem to persist in the wavenumber spectrum of turbulent transport processes even though they may not always be easily recognizable. Statistical theories of turbulence emphasize the continuous properties of the spectrum, while the importance of discrete wavenumbers is stressed in the optimum theory. B. THEINFINITEPRANDTL NUMBER LIMIT
In the limit when p tends to infinity, the minimum among the expressions (6.3) approaches R‘“’(p) = 3 c ~ ( p ’ f l 4 ~ ~ ’= ~ ) 1’ ’0~. 1 6 ~ ” ~ , (6.5) which implies that the upper bound for the Nusselt number (= total heat transport/heat transport in the case of conduction alone) grows as Ra’” Experimental determinations of the Nusselt number give results scattered around 0.2 . RaO.’* for fluids of moderate Prandtl numbers. Simple dimensional arguments suggest 4 for the exponent. This result is convenient for practical applications, but the dimensional argument are not reliable since they give the wrong answer when applied to the optimum problem. The &power law is in rough agreement with Kraichnan’s (1962) prediction for the heat transport by turbulent convection based on mixing-length arguments. Since the expression [Ra/(ln Ra)3]’’Z derived by Kraichnan for the Nusselt number depends on the hydrodynamic instability of the thermal boundary layer, the expression becomes valid only at Rayleigh numbers in excess of lozo,which is far beyond the present experimental capabilities. The discrepancy between the bound (6.5)and the observed power law has led to a search for additional constraints by which the upper bound for the
114
F. H. Busse
heat transport could be improved. Such a constraint is readily available if the limit of infinite Prandtl number is considered. Since the nonlinear terms in the Boussinesq equation of motion are multiplied by Pr-', the equation of motion becomes linear for infinite Prandtl numbers 0 = -VR
+ k0 + V'V.
(6.6) Solutions of the variational problem (6.2) incorporating the additional constraint (6.6) have been obtained by Chan (1971). In spite of the increased complexity of the problem, the multi-a-solutions of the Euler equations can still be obtained by the multiple boundary-layer method described in Section II1,B. As asymptotic upper bound for the convective heat transport at infinite Prandtl number, Chan obtained p ( R ) 0.152R4I3. (6.7) This expression is remarkably close to the experimentally measured dependence, but it must be remembered that all experiments are carried out at a finite Prandtl number. From numerical solutions of two-dimensional convection (Moore and Weiss, 1973), it is known that the heat transport tends to reach its maximum at Prandtl numbers of the order unity and that the infinite Prandtl-number limit is approached only in the regime Pr > (Ra/RaJ2I3. The result (6.7) is also close to the prediction of the meanfield theory of convection (Herring, 1964) in which all nonlinear terms are neglected in the Boussinesq equations with the exception of those affecting the horizontal mean of the temperature field. The mean-field approximation thus becomes similar to the optimum problem in the limit of infinite Prandtl number and Chan (1971) has shown that the heat transport becomes actually identical in the asymptotic limit of R tending to infinity if the maximizing values of the wavenumbers a, are used. A numerical single-a solution for Chan's problem has been obtained by Straus (1976b). Both numerical and asymptotic solutions have been obtained by Gupta and Joseph (1973) in the analogous optimum problem for convection in porous medium. The infinite Prandtl-number limit has the advantage that the effects of rotation on the upper bound for the heat transport can be considered. The rotation rate R enters the nondimensional description of the problem in the form of the Taylor number T = 4R2d4/v2. Since in physical situations the infinite Prandtl number limit is approached in the form v -+ 00 rather than K -+ 0, a finite and possibly large Taylor number is difficult to achieve in the limit when V/K tends to infinity. The optimum problem in this limit is of mathematical interest, however, because it can no longer be assumed that the vertical vorticity vanishes for the optimizing solution. The Taylor number parameter and the toroidal component of the trial vector field induced by the finite vertical vorticity increase the complexity of the vari-
Optimum Theory of Turbulence
115
ational problem significantly. We refer to the original papers on this subject by Chan (1974), Hunter and Riahi (1975), and Riahi (1977). Another problem for which the infinite Prandtl-number limit is of interest is the problem of doubly diffusive convection, which also is known under the name thermohaline convection after its major physical application. The addition of a second diffusiveprocess affectingthe density can lead to interesting phenomena as for example salt-finger convection which is caused by a destabilizing salt concentration gradient in the presence of a stable thermal stratification. In applying the optimum theory to the problem of doubly diffusive convection, two cases may be distinguished. The salt-finger phenomenon is an example of convection in the case when the low diffusivity is associated with the destabilizing component of the density variation. Straus (1974) analyzed this problem in the infinite Prandtl-number limit. The case when the less diffusive component of the density variation has a stabilizing influence has been considered by Lindberg (1971), who used inequalities to obtain upper bounds on the heat and solute fluxes without actually solving a variational problem.
VII. General Discussion
A. FURTHER APPLICATIONSOF THE OPTIMUM THEORY In the problems considered in the preceding sections a straightforward physical interpretation can be given for the various terms of the energyintegral relationship. In particular, it has been possible to derive bounds for transport quantities from variational problems that arise naturally from the energy balances. In general, intermediate steps will be required. The difficulty of the interpretation of the energy-production term becomes apparent when the case of combined Couette and Poiseuille flow is considered (Busse, 1969a) Neither an upper bound for the momentum transport nor a lower bound for the mean flow can be obtained directly in this case. Instead, a combination of the applied pressure gradient and the applied shear becomes extremalized when a variational problem is formulated in analogy to (2.13). More useful results can be obtained only if additional inequalities are applied. The problem of interpretation becomes amplified when more complicated flow processes are considered. We have already emphasized that the application of the optimum theory in its simplest form is limited to those cases of fluid flow for which a laminar solution exists that depends on a single coordinate only. Turbulent jets and turbulent boundary layers cannot be
F. H.Busse
116
easily attacked by variational methods unless restrictive assumptions are introduced. It is of interest to consider at this point an example of a flow between parallel planes which is quite different from Poiseuille or Couette flow. The application of the optimum theory in this case suggests a new way in which the realized turbulence may tend towards an extremum and a comparison with experimental observations will eventually be of considerable importance. Using the nondimensional description introduced in Section II,A, the flow given by UI = iG(z/4 - z3)/6 (74 is physically realizable in a channel inclined with the angle 4 with respect to the horizontal plane when two different temperatures, TI and T,, are prescribed on the bounding plates. Assuming the limit of vanishing Prandtl number, the problem can be considered on the basis of the hydrodynamic equations (2.1) alone if the effects of gravity are taken into account. The deviations of the temperature from the basic linear profile are vanishingly small as long as thermal conduction dominates over convection effects. The solution (7.1) is stable when the Grasshof number G = yg sin 4 I T, Tl ld3/vZ is sufficiently small (Ayyaswamy, 1974). For large values of G, a turbulent flow must be expected. In order to avoid the distinction of whether the upper or lower plate is heated, the convention is used that the unit vector i indicating the x-axis points upward in the latter and downward in the former case. The mean shear in the case of statistically stationary turbulence is determined by dU/dz = iG( 1/24 - z2/2) + - (a+), (74 and the energy balance for the fluctuating velocity field can be written in analogy to (2.10)
a
0 = (IV x SI')
+ (1113 - (a+) 1)'
- G(u*,+(1/24 - z2/2)).
(7.3) A physical interpretation of the last term in this equation is obtained when the y-component of the mean angular-momentum density of the layer with respect to a point on the median plane is considered. This component is
where h ( z ) = (180)'/2(1/12 - z 2 ) .
(7.5)
Since the last term in (7.4) is positive according to relationship'(7.3), the angular-momentum density of the system in the turbulent state is smaller than in the laminar state at a given value of G, i.e., at a given torque exerted
Optimum Theory of Turbulence
117
by gravity. A lower bound for M y may be obtained from the variational problem: Given p > 0, find the minimum R(p) of the functional
(IV x vl’)
+
4 = ~(u,wh)
( I u w - ( u w ) - ih(u,wh)I’) (u, wh)’
(7.6)
among all vector fields v that satisfy (2.12b), (2.12~)and have ( u , wh) > 0. When the normalization condition (7.7) and the property ( h 2 ) = 1 are used, the extremalizing vector field satisfies relationship (7.3) if G is eliminated by means of Eq. (7.4) and M yis replaced by (720)’”R. Thus R(p) provides a lower bound for MY/(720)”’ at a given value of p or, equivalently, at a given value of G. As in the case of the variational problem (2.13), the extremalizing vector field of the functional (7.6) has the property Uyw = 0. In addition, the property (u, w) = 0 can be anticipated, in which case the functional becomes identical to expression (4.5), after the representation (4.2) has been introduced for v and relationship (4.4) has been used. Accordingly, the analysis of Section IV,A is directly applicable and the results (4.16), (4.17), and (4.18) hold in the present case with P = (uxwh)
There appear to be no experimental data available for the turbulent flow in an inclined heated layer at a sufficiently low Prandtl number. The hypothesis that the realized turbulence tends to minimize the angular momentum density thus has not yet gained observational support. Because of its unusual properties, an experimental investigation of the problem is desirable. There are numerous possibilities for turbulent systems with physical properties depending on a single coordinate like those considered in this paper. The effects of a homogeneous magnetic field have not yet been considered and the possibility of the generation of magnetic fields by turbulent motions leads to other interesting applications of the optimum theory. A first step in the latter direction has been made by Kennett (1974). But the scarcity of observational data in those cases restricts the possibilities for the interpretation of the realized turbulence in terms of the optimum theory. B. EXTENSIONS The major task in the further development of the optimum theory of turbulence is the introduction of additional constraints in order to improve the bounds. Although it is in principle possible to approach the actual solution of the Navier-Stokes equations with the optimum transport by
F. H.Busse
118
adding the hierarchy of moments of the equations as constraints, in practical applications it has proven to be rather difficult to proceed beyond the energetic constraints considered in this article. An attempt has been made in the case of Couette flow (Ayyaswamy and Busse, 1978),but the results have not been very encouraging. By separating the fluctuating velocity field v into its “toroidal” and “poloidal” parts, so that v = V x k+
+ V x (V x k4) = E+ + 154,
where k is the unit vector normal to the plates, and by multiplying the equation of motion (2.6) by V x k+ and by V x (V x k#), two separate energy-integral equations are obtained in place of the single relationship (2.10):
Because of the triple product terms in these relationships, the Euler equations of the corresponding variational problem can no longer be solved by analytical methods. Numerical methods on the other hand are limited to a small range of Reynolds numbers because of the computational expense associated with the three-dimensional representation of the extremalizing vector field. A different aspect of the optimum theory that appears to be promising for future applications is evident from the fact that the variational problem and the extremalizing vector fields are surprisingly similar for different physical situations,’if the appropriate variables are compared. The analogous role of the fluctuating temperature 8 in the problem of convection and of the fluctuating velocity component u, in shear flow turbulence appears to be well confirmed by observations. In Fig. 9 these two variables and the corresponding normal velocity components are shown as functions of the distance from the walls without the use of an adjustable parameter. The similarity suggested by the optimum problem is quite strikingly borne out within the scatter of the measured data. Deardorff (1970) has made use of this property for the scaling of the unstable planetary boundary layer. Similar analogies can be expected in other problems of turbulence and the formulation of a general similarity law for the turbulent transport from rigid walls appears to be feasible. It is appropriate to close this article with the preceding remark since it illustrates the power of the optimum theory as an analytical tool in the interpretation of the structure of turbulent flow. In this respect the know-
Optimum Theory of Turbulence
119
FIG.9. Root mean square (rms.) values of the fluctuating component of the velocity in streamwise direction, ijx/Ur, and normal to the wall, measured by Laufer (1954) at Re = 2.5 x lo4 (+ )and Re = 2.5 x lo5 ( x ). For comparison the rrns values of the temperature fluctuations 0 and of the vertical velocity component w, which were measured in turbulent thermal convection by Deardorff and Willis (1970) at Ra = 2.5 x lo6 ( 0 )and Ra = 1.0 x lo7 (O), are plotted in units resulting from the correspondence of the variational problems. (After Busse, 1970b). (Copyright by Cambridge University Press. Reprinted with permission.)
w/oz,
ledge gained from the optimum theory is complementary to the results of statistical theories of turbulence. Since the latter are developed in the ideal limit of homogeneous isotropic turbulence in which spatial structures disappear, they tend to emphasize random properties of turbulence. The combination of the two approaches may ultimately provide a satisfactory description of physically realized turbulent flows. REFERENCES AYYASWAMY, P. S. (1974). On the stability of plane parallel flow between differentially heated tilted planes. J. Appl. Mech. 41, 554-556. AYYASWAMY, P. S., and BUSSE,F. H.(1978). Improved bounds for turbulent Couette flow. To be submitted. BUSSE,F. H.(1967). On the stability of two-dimensional convection in a layer heated from below. J. Math. Phys. 46, 140-150. BUSSE,F. H.(1968). Eine neuartige Methode zur theoretischen Behandlung turbulenter Transportvorgange. Z . Angew. Math. Mech. 48,T187-Tl90. BUSSE, F. H. (1969a). Bounds on the transport of mass and momentum by turbulent flow between parallel plates. J. Appl. Math. Phys. ( Z A M P ) 20, 1-14.
F. H . Busse BUSSE,F. H. (1969b). On Howard’s upper bound for heat transport by turbulent convection. J. Fluid Mech. 37,457-477. BUSSE,F. H. (1970a). Uber notwendige und hinreichende Kriterien fur die Stabilitat von S t r a mungen. 2.Angew. Math. Mech. 50, T173-T174. B u w , F. H. (1970b). Bounds for turbulent shear flow. J. Fluid Mech. 41,219-240. BUSSE,F. H. (1972a). The bounding theory of turbulence and its physical significancein the case of turbulent Couette flow. Springer Lect. Notes Phys. 12, 103-126. B u w , F. H. (1972b).The bounding theory of turbulence and its physical significancein the case of pipe flow. Symp. Math. 9,493-505. BUSSE,F. H. (1972~).A property of the energy stability limit for plane parallel shear flow. Arch. Ration. Mech. Anal. 47,28-35. BUSSE,F. H., and JOSEPH,D. D. (1972). Bounds for heat transport in a porous layer. J. Fluid Mech. 54, 521-543. BUSSE,F. H., and WHITEHEAD, J. A. (1971). Instab es of convection rolls in a high Prandtl number fluid. J. Fluid Mech. 47, 305-320. CHAN,S.-K. (1971). Infinite Prandtl number turbulent convection. Stud. Appl. Math. 9413-49. CHAN,S.-K. (1974).Investigation of turbulent convection under a rotational constraint. 1.Fluid Mech. 64,477-506. CHU,T. Y., and GOLDSTEIN, R. J. (1973).Turbulent convection in a horizontal layer of water. J. Fluid Mech. 60, 141-159. DEARDORFF, J. W. (1970).Convective velocity and temperature scales for the unstable planetary boundary layer and for Rayleigh convection. J. Atmos. Sci. 27, 1211-1213. DEARWRFF, J. W., and W ~ L I SG. , E. (1967). Investigations of turbulent thermal convection between horizontal plates. J. Fluid Mech. 28, 675-704. ECKELMANN, H. (1972). The structure of the viscous sublayer and the adjacent wall regon in a turbulent channel flow. J. Fluid Mech. 65,439-459. FITZJARRALD, D. E. (1976).An experimental study of turbulent convection in air. J. Fluid Mech. 13,693-719. GUPTA,V. P., and JOSEPH,D. D. (1973). Bounds for heat transport in a porous layer. J. Fluid Mech. 57,491-514. GUPTA,A. H., LAUFER, J., and KAPLAN,R. E.(1971). Spatial structure in the viscous sublayer. J. Fluid Mech. 50, 493-512. HERRING,J. R. (1964). Investigation of problems in thermal convection: Rigid boundaries. J. Atmos. Sci. 21,277-290. HINZE,J. 0. (1959). “Turbulence.” McGraw-Hill, New York. HOWARD,L. N. (1963). Heat transport by turbulent convection. J. Fluid Mech. 17,405-432. HOWARD,L. N. (1972). Bounds on flow quantities. Ann. Rev. Fluid Mech. 4, 473-494. HUNTER,C., and RIAHI,N. (1975). Nonlinear convection in a rotating fluid. J. Fluid Mech. 72, 433-454. JOSEPH,D. D. (1976). “Stability of Fluid Motions.” 2 vols. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg, New
York. JOSEPH, D. D., and CMI, S. (1969). Stability of Poiseuille flow in pipes, annuli, and channels. Quart. Appl. Math. 26, 575. JOSEPH,D. D., and TAO, L. N. (1963). Transverse velocity components in fully developed unsteady flows. J. Appl. Mech. 30, 147-148. KENNETT,R. G. (1974). Convectively-driven dynamos. I n “Notes of the Geophysical Fluid Dynamics Summer Program.” Woods Hole Oceanogr. Inst. Rep. 74-63,94117. KLINE,S. J., REYNOLDS, W. C., SCHRAUB, F. A., and RUNSTADLER,P. W. (1967).The structure of turbulent boundary layers. J. Fluid Mech. 30,741-773. KRAICHNAN, R. H. (1962). Turbulent thermal convection at arbitrary Prandtl number. Phys. Fluids 5, 13741389,
Optimum Theory of Turbulence
121
KRISHNAMURTI, R. (1970). On the transition to turbulent convection. I. The transition from two to threedimensional flow. J. Fluid Mech. 42, 295-307. LAUFER,J. (1951). Investigation of turbulent flow in a two-dimensional channel. N A C A Rep. 1053.
LAUFER, J . (1954). The structure of turbulence in fully developed pipe flow. N A C A Rep. I 1 74. LINDBERG, W. R. (1971). An upper bound on transport processes in turbulent thermohaline convection. J. Phys. Oceanogr. 1, 187-195. LUDWIEG,H. (1964). Experimentelle Nachpriifung der Stabilitats-Theorien fur reibungsfreie Stromungen mit schrauben-linienformigen Stromlinien. Proc. 4th Int. Congr. Appl. Mech., 1045- 105 1. MALKUS, W. V. R. (1954a). Discrete transitions in turbulent convection. Proc. R. SOC.London, Ser. A 225, 185-195. MALKUS,W. V. R. (1954b). The heat transport and spectrum of thermal turbulence. Proc. R. SOC.London, Ser. A 225, 196-212. MOORE,D. R., and WEISS,N. 0.(1973). Two-dimensional Rayleigh-Binard convection. J. Fluid Mech. % ! , 289-312. NAGIB,H. M. (1972). On instabilities and secondary motions in swirling flows through annuli. Ph.D. Dissertation, 225 pp., Illinois Institute of Technology, Chicago. NICKERSON, E. C. (1969). Upper bounds on the torque in cylindrical Couette flow. J . Fluid Mech. 38, 807-815. NIKURADSE, J. (1932). Gesetzmassigkeiten der turbulenten Stromung in glatten Rohren. Forsch. Arb. 1ng.-Wes. No. 356; see also Forsch. Geb. Ing. W e s . 3, 260. ORR,W. McF. (1907). The stability or instability of the steady motions of a liquid. 11. A viscous liquid. Proc. R. Ir. Acad., Sect. A 27, 69-138. PARSAPOUR, H. (1977). A new approach to the detection of Malkus transitions in a horizontal layer of fluid heated from below. Ph.D. Thesis, Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, Troy, New York. A., and SOUTHWELL, R. V. ( 1 9 4 ) . On maintained convective motion in a fluid heated PELLEW, from below. Proc. R. SOC.London, Ser. A 176, 3 12-343. REICHARDT,H. (1959). Gesetzmassigkeiten der geradlinigen turbulenten Couettestromung. Mitteilungen Max-Planck-Institut fur Stromungsforschung, Gottingen, No. 22. REYNOLDS,D. (1895). On the dynamical theory of incompressible viscous fluid and the determination of the criteria. Philos. Trans. R. Soc., Ser. A 186, 123-164. RIAHI,N. (1977). Upper-bound problem for a rotating system. J . Fluid Mech. 81, 523-528. SCHMIDT, R. J., and SAUNDERS, 0.A. (1938). On the motion of a fluid heated from below. Proc. R. SOC.London, Ser. A 165, 216-228. SQUIRE, H. B. (1933). On the stability for three-dimensional disturbances of viscous fluid flow between parallel walls. Proc. R. Soc. London Ser. A 142, 621-628. STRAUS,J. M. (1973). On the upper bounding approach to thermal convection at moderate Rayleigh numbers. Geophys. Fluid Dyn. 5, 261-28 1. STRAUS,J. M. (1974). Upper bound on the solute flux in doubly diffusive convection. Phys. Fluids 17, 52&527. STRAUS, J. M. (1976a). A note on the multi-a solutions of the upper bounding problem for thermal convection. Dyn. Atmos. Oceans I, 7 1-76. J. M. (l976b). On the upper bounding approach to thermal convection at moderate STRAUS, Rayleigh numbers. II. Rigid boundaries. Dyn. Atmos. Oceans I, 77-90. WILLIS,G. E., and DEARDORFF, J. W. (1967). Confirmation and renumbering of the discrete heat flux transitions of Malkus. Phys. Fluids 10, 1861-1866.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
.
ADVANCES IN APPLIED MECHANICS VOLUME
18
Computational Modeling of Turbulent Flows?. JOHN L. LUMLEY Sibley School of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering Cornell University Ithaca. New York
I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. History and Generalities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. General Assumptions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I1 . Mathematical Preliminaries . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Representations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Realizability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111. The Return to Isotropy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. The Reynolds Stress . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. The Heat Flux . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV . The Rapid Terms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. The Heat Flux Integral . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. The Temperature Variance Integral . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D. The Reynolds Stress Integral . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V . The Dissipation Equations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. The Mechanical Dissipation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. The Thermal Dissipation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. The Transport Terms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI . The Transport Terms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. A Gaussian Model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Order of Magnitude Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D . The Pressure Transport . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E. Zeroth-Order Transport Terms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . F. Modifications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
124 124 127 128 128 131 133 133 137 142 143 143 147 147 150 152 152 156
159 160 160 162 165 168 170 171 174
t This work supported in part by the U S. National Science Foundation. Meteorology Program under Grant Number ATM77.22903. and in part by the U . S. Office of Naval Research. Fluid Dynamics Branch. It is a pleasure to acknowledge fruitful discussion with B. Brumley. and the computational help of D. Hatziavromidis . 123
Copyright @ 1778 by Academic Press. Inc All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN 0-12-002018-1
124
John L Lnmley
I. Introduction
A. HISTORY AND GENERALITIES At the 1968 AFOSR-IFP-Stanford Conference on Computation of Turbulent Boundary Layers (Kline et al., 1969),all the methods formally presented were oriented specifically toward the turbulent boundary layer, and most involved some variant of the mixing length formulation. During the Monday afternoon discussion, however, C. Donaldson made an informal presentation (reported on pp. 114-118) in which he strongly supported an idea he was then developing, which he called “invariant modeling.” He said “. ..it has been my feeling that one should keep track of the dynamics of all the second-order correlations of importance.. . . one seeks to express those terms which are unknown ... in terms of the second-order correlations themselves.. . . In making these choices one is constrained only by the requirements of symmetry and the general conservation laws.” And in another place, “Using general tensor notation . .. one.. . seeks.. .the simple invariant form that will reduce to one of the forms generally seen in traditional boundary-layer studies.. . .” Later in the conference, an ad hoc committee was formed to deal with the importance of invariance (consisting of Bradshaw, Donaldson, and Mellor). This committee’s brief report (p. 426) states in part: “Invariance of a particular formulation to coordinate transformation is important . .. particularly .. . if one is attempting to describe threedimensional flows.. . . If one chooses models which are of invariant form, it should be found that these models have the greatest generality; they should have the highest probability of describing turbulent flows which depart from the particular geometry for which the parameters in the model were adjusted to agree with experimental data.” This was the birth of the technique which has become known as “secondorder modeling” (as well as invariant modeling, and which the French school refers to as the one-point closure). During the last decade it has undergone very rapid development in the hands of numerous authors whose work will be mentioned explicitly in the appropriate sections below. The development at the present time is by no means complete, and the present work must be regarded as an interim report. One thing is already clear, however; in many situations of practical importance this technique makes possible computations which often agree with what data are available. Inevitably, the technique is also being applied in many situations in which data do not exist, which must be regarded as a dangerous practice, since the limitations of the technique are not known with any precision. It is primarily the possibility of practical computation which has been responsible for the great interest in this method.
Computational Modeling of Turbulent Flows
125
The method is not without historical antecedents. A good description of the early development of these ideas is contained in Monin and Yaglom (1971, p. 318). Specifically, Kolmogorov (1942) appears to have been the first to suggest characterizing turbulence entirely by its intensity and scale and using this to simplify the equations, an idea which is also used by all authors. Chou (1945a,b, 1947) suggested a number of closure schemes, and in particular was the first to use the equations for the third moments, eliminating the fourth moments by various hypotheses, something which we shall discuss later. Finally, the suggestions of Rotta (1951a,b) and Davidov (1958, 1959a,b, 1961) for the modeling of the pressure-strain correlations and related matters have had extensive influence on the development. of this technique. It is not an exaggeration to say that there is little in use at the present time that was not suggested by these authors. These authors all predated the easy availability of large-scale computers, so that their suggestions, for the most part, could not be explored extensively. Second-order modeling, even in its most stripped-down form, results in general in the simultaneous solution of four partial differential equations in the domain of interest; more elaborate models in a three-dimensional situation might require the simultaneous solution of as many as 36 partial differential equations to obtain the mechanical field only. Fortunately, this is within the capabilities of present computers at a reasonable price, which cannot be said of any other technique. Direct simulation (Orszag and Patterson, 1972) is limited to relatively low Reynolds numbers, but this is not serious, since the large scales (which are responsible for transport) are dominated by inertia, and thus are essentially independent of Reynolds number; however, if there is no homogeneous direction in which averages may be taken, several hundred realizations must be generated to obtain stable statistics, which is prohibitively expensive. There are also problems with initial conditions (Lumley and Newman, 1977): problems of differencing errors in current codes restrict the initial conditions on turbulent structure to fairly unrealistic ones. Almost the entire computational time is used in setting up a realistic turbulence, by which time the mean initial conditions have already changed. Direct simulation is thus not an alternative for practical computation. The various sophisticated closures (Leslie, 1973) suffer from essentially the same problems as the direct simulations and hence are also limited to homogeneous situations. Thus, the second-order modeling is at present the only possibility for practical computation. Second-order modeling may also be said to have as antecedent the work of the school of Rational Mechanics, which had its roots in the work of Stokes (and to a lesser extent Navier), and the modem development of which is associated with the name of Truesdell and his co-workers (with, of course, many others unnamed in between). In early work on non-
126
John L Lamley
Newtonian fluids, closures were developed for flows in particular geometries, relating the stress to the deformation state. Typifyingsuch closures is the power-law fluid, in which the shear stress is assumed proportional to a power of the local strain rate. This is not an invariant formulation and cannot be easily generalized to other geometries and flows. The school of Rational Mechanics, leading to the work of Coleman and No11 (1961), adopted the point of view that it was necessary to discover first the general form for a general geometry and flow, which the dependence of stress on deformation could take, considering the various mathematical and physical restrictions to which it was subject; this would permit the identification of a relatively small number of invariant functions, which could then be determined by experiment in particular geometries, the results being applicable to flows in all geometries. This is practically a statement of Donaldson’s point of view, quoted at the beginning. In fact, the techniques used for the computation of turbulent boundary layers at the Stanford Conference are reminiscent of the situation in continuum mechanics before the advent of rational mechanics; in just a few decades this approach has revolutionized nonNewtonian fluid mechanics, and we may hope that a similar approach will do the same for the computation of turbulent flows. Regarding rational mechanics, it is fair to say that there are those who feel that it hrts been philosophically productive but has not been greatly useful for computations; that in its general form it is too complex, and there are many more fluids in nature than can be easily encompassed by it; and that it is consequently necessary to fall back on the old empiricism for many practical computations. Just so, in turbulence computations, there are those, typified by Bradshaw (personal communication), who feel that the behavior of turbulence is so complex that the search for general closures is probably futile and that practical computations will require empirical techniques developed for the specific geometry. There are also those who feel that the general second-order modeling produces forms too complex to be of use in practical situations. My position is not diametrically opposed to these. Rather, I would say that I believe in the ultimate possibility of developing general computation procedures based on first principles; and under certain circumstances I believe that it is possible to do this rationally by the techniques of second-order modeling. While it may be necessary to fall back on empiricism for computations in complex situations, I believe that rational second-order modeling can at least provide a guide for the construction of the more empirical models and can certainly serve in general to indicate the range of applicability of these techniques. Quite apart from its utility as a practical computational tool, I have found that the attempt to devise models of this kind which behave like turbulence brings to light aspects of turbulent behavior that might never have been noticed. That is, one often finds that experiments do qualitative things which
Computational Modeling of Turbulent Flows
127
models cannot be made to do, no matter how the constants are adjusted. This indicates that a basic physical mechanism has been omitted from the model; if it can be identified and included (often difficult), something fundamental will have been learned about turbulence. This, incidentally, shows that Gauss was not quite correct when he remarked that, given seven constants, he could produce an elephant on a tightrope, and that with nine, he could make it dance.
B. GENERAL ASSUMPTIONS The development of second-order models has proceeded on a somewhat ad hoc basis, the degree depending on the predelictions of the particular author. Although nearly everyone recognizes the desirability of having all terms be tensors of the appropriate rank, with the correct symmetry and other properties (such as the vanishing of traces where appropriate), there has been little consideration of turbulence dynamics beyond this, and almost any convenient quantity with the proper tensor properties has been fair game, without consideration for its behavior at large or small Reynolds numbers, large or small anisotropy, etc. We will try to develop here fragments of a rational approach, from which we will see that the second-order models appear to be an orderly expansion about a homogeneous, stationary turbulence, the large scales of which have a Gaussian distribution. In fact, homogeneous turbulence is observed to be approximately Gaussian in the large scales (Frenkiel and Klebanoff, 1967a,b),even in the presence of homogeneous distortion (Marechal, 1972); what is envisioned here is a turbulence which is made non-Gaussian in the large scales by inhomogeneity, but which would, on the removal of the inhomogeneity, relax to a Gaussian state. The expansion about the homogeneous, stationary state suggests that the ratios of the turbulence length scale to the length scale of the mean flow inhomogeneities and of the turbulence time scale to the time scale of the mean flow evolution are both small. This is essentially a kinetic theory type of approximation. It is known experimentally that these ratios of scales are not small in real turbulence, being in general of order unity (since the turbulence structure and the mean flow inhomogeneity are generally produced by the same mechanism, unlike the artificial situation in a wind tunnel, where a homogeneous turbulence and the associated homogeneous mean shear may be carefully produced by different mechanisms). It is legitimate to ask why one might expect second-order modeling to resemble real turbulence; that is, why one has a right to expect the first term in an expansion in a small parameter to be applicable when the parameter is of order unity. There are many other examples of this phenomenon: for instance, the first two terms in an expansion in small Reynolds number for laminar flow around a cylinder work well up to Reynolds numbers of order 10 (Van
128
John L Lumley
Dyke, 1964). That, of course, is not an explanation. The explanation here probably is this: by following a rational procedure we have created a physically possible phenomenon, not quite real turbulence perhaps, but one which conserves momentum and energy; transports the right amount of everything budgeted (momentum, energy, Reynolds stress, heat flux, etc.), although not by quite the right mechanism; satisfies realizability (so that nonnegative quantities are never negative, Schwarz’ inequality is always satisfied, etc.); behaves correctly for both large and small Reynolds numbers; and reduces to real turbulence in one limit (weak inhomogeneity and unsteadiness). Probably any mechanism that satisfied all of these restrictions would behave about the same. The physical input from experiment is essentially used to fix the amount of transport. Of course, it is also possible, as Donaldson suggests (personal communication), that there is some other basis on which these equations can be derived, under which they have broader applicability. A given set of equations can often be derived from different sets of hypotheses of different degrees of generality. An example is the equations for global energy of a disturbance to Couette flow, which can be derived both from the exact equations and from the equations in the small disturbance approximation (Lumley, 1972).We only claim here to have found a consistent basis. We have already seen that we are making a specific assumption about the probability density of the turbulence; we are also making an assumption about the spectrum: it can be parametrized by the large scales. That is, if we know the characteristics of the large scales and the Reynolds number, then the shape of the rest of the spectrum follows; in fact, all of the statistics of the turbulence are determined by the large scales and the Reynolds number. This suggests two things: the turbulence has had time to come to equilibrium spectrally with the large scales and hence changes in the large scales are slow enough for the small scales to follow, and boundaries and initial conditions are far enough removed to have no direct influence on the present state. Otherwise, these would, in general, introduce another parameter (or several) which should be included.
11. Mathematical Preliminaries
A. REPRESENTATIONS In what follows, we will use a number of ideas familiar to workers in continuum mechanics, but perhaps not so familiar to workers in other areas. The principal concept that we will need is that of the form which an isotropic
Computational Modeling of Turbulent Flows
129
tensor function of other tensors may assume. Many references exist (e.g., Lumley, 1970a), but none covers the subject in quite the way we will need it. Thus, we will give a brief introduction here. Suppose that we have an isotropic symmetric second-rank tensor function of a symmetric second-rank tensor, both of zero trace c$ij(bpp), say. This form will occur when we consider the return to isotropy. We may consider that bij and 4ijare average second-order turbulence moments. First, by an isotropic function we mean that the functional relation is isotropic; that is, it is not dependent on any other suppressed variable, such as the direction of a magnetic field or the axis of a wind tunnel. The values of 4ijare not isotrop ic, but any anisotropy in 4ijis induced by anisotropy of bij;if bij is isotrop ic, 4i, is isotropic. A general technique for determining the dependence of 4ijon bij is to select two arbitrary vectors A , and Bj and form an invariant 4 i j A iBj. This is now a tensor of zeroth rank, having no free indices, and must consequently be the same in any coordinate system, hence, an invariant. As an invariant, it must be a function only of invariants, those that can be made from A , , Bj, and bij. We now must ask what are the independent invariants of this collection of quantities. From the Cayley-Hamilton theorem (Lumley, 1970a, Section A2.6) we know that in three dimensions only the Oth, lst, and 2nd powers of bij are linearly independent since bij must satisfy its own secular equation:
b;
- lb$
+ IIbij - I l l b ; = 0,
(2.1) where b$ = 6,, Kronecker’s delta, and b$ = bikbkj,etc. The quantities I, 11, and 111 are, respectively,
+
I1 = (biibjj - b,Z,)/2, 111 = (biibjjbkk - 3biib;j 2b;)/3! (2.2) Note that bif.is the trace of b$ and not biib,. These quantities (2.2) are the only independent invariants of bij. In addition tofhese, we have the invariants of A , and B,, which are the lengths and included angle of this vector pair, or equivalently A i A i ,BiBi,and A i B i . We have in addition, the invariants that can be constructed between the vectors and the tensor; what is invariant here is essentially the orientation of the vectors relative to the principal axes of the tensor, which should give no more than six quantities. These can conveniently be gotten from the collection A i b i j A j ,A,b$A,, Ai bijB,, A , b$ Bj, BibijBj, B, b: Bj. Higher powers of bijare not independent by the Cayley-Hamilton theorem. We are assuming, incidentally, invariance under the full rotation group; that is, we include invariance under improper rotations, or reflections, presuming that there is no preferred spin to the turbulence relations (not to the turbulence!). We are also working in Cartesian coordinates; the generalization to non-Cartesian systems is relatively straightforward but adds complexity. Note that if bij were not symmetric
I = bii,
130
John L Lumley
there would be other independent invariants, since b , b,, # b, b,, and A, bijBj # Ai bji Bj. Now, 4ijAi Bj is bilinear in Ai Bj, and thus the right-hand side must also be since these vectors are arbitrary. We may thus exclude all forms quadratic in Ai and Bj, and set 4 i j A iBj = a(I, II, III)b$ Ai B, + @(I, II, IIl)b, Ai Bj + y(I, II, III)bi Ai Bj. (2.31 We may now remove the A, and Bj and obtain
4ij= adij + @bij+ y b i ,
(2.4)
where a, @, and y are unknown scalar (invariant) functions of the invariants I, II, and III. If we now include the condition that b, has zero trace, I = 0, I1 = - b i / 2 , and I I I = b i / 3 ; if we take account of the fact that 4ii= 0, then a = 211~13so that
4ij= fibij + y(b$ + 211dij/3).
(2.5)
This form is essentially completely general, granting only that there are no suppressed variables. We have now reduced the determination of the dependence to the determination of two unknown scalar functions of scalar arguments, independent of flow geometry. These considerations can be extended to more complex situations. For example, suppose that chi, were a function of b , and a vector, ci. The invariants of the vectors with each other and with the tensor would now be AB, Ac, Bc, cc, AbB, Abc, Bbc, cbc, Ab’B, Ab’c, Bb’c, cb’c in an obvious notation. The general expression would not only have terms proportional to AB, AbB, Ab’B, but also proportional to AcBc, AcBbc, AcBb’c, BcAbc, BcAb’c, etc., making all possible pairs bilinear in A and B leading to 12 terms in all. The invariant functions would depend on cc, cbc, and cb’c in addition to the previous terms. It is clear that we are including in this way more invariants than we need (more than are independent) since we begin with 18 (two from the set A, B, and c, and one from the set bo, b, and b’), while only 15 appear to be independent (from a consideration of which ones are necessary to determine the projections of the three vectors on the principal axes of bij).It is possible to construct a reduced basis (Lumley, 1970b)which considerably simplifiesthe forms; however, in most cases we will consider if the turbulence is isotropic, b will be proportional to Kronecker’s delta, and the reduced basis will no longer span the space. Thus, it is better to be somewhat redundant, and include extra invariants, in order to have a basis which is valid in all cases.
Computational Modeling of Turbulent Flows
131
B. REALIZABILITY Recently, Schumann (1977) introduced the concept of realizability. He pointed out that no matter what equation is used to predict values o f w , it must have the property that does not allow correlations to exceed the limiting values dictated by Schwarz’ inequality and does not permit negative component energies. One might argue that this is a mathematical nicety so far as the component energies are concerned (although it is clearly important in regard to the correlations); that is, one might feel that the occurrence of vanishingly small component energies is so rare in nature that requiring correct behavior of model equations in that situation is unnecessary. However, anyone who has had experience computing with second-order models knows that a frequent cause of aborted calculations is the occurrence of negative component energies, often associated with recovery from poor initial conditions. There are, in addition, real physical situations in which one component is strongly suppressed, notably in stably stratified buoyant turbulence. Hence, it is physically important and computationally convenient, as well as mathematically nice, to require realizability. The most convenient way of satisfying the requirement is to transform the equation to principal axes of uiuj; now there are no off-diagonal terms; we may designate the component energies in this coordinate system (the eigenvalues) by We now require that if were to vanish, its time derivative too would vanish, so that it arrives at zero with zero slope and cannot cross to negative values. Just how this is implemented, we will see in Section I11 when we discuss the return to isotropy. Note that it was erroneously stated in Lumley and Newman (1977) that the method just presented, satisfying realizability for ,is foolproof only if the direction of the principal axes is not changing with time. That this is not true can be seen by differentiating the eigenvalue relation. That is, if we write at every instant
z.
v,
then differentiation of the second relation and substitution of the first gives: BijX$k)+ ~ X k f=)U:k,Xlk)+ %Xik).
(2.7) If (2.7) is now multiplied by XIk)and if the second equation of (2.6) is used, the second and fourth terms, containing the time derivative of the eigenvector, cancel, leaving -
,i(k) - X !I k ’ B . . X y ,
(2.8) and if it is required that the right side of (2.8) is to vanish when the eigenvalue vanishes, then the condition is satisfied. IJ
132
John L h m l e y
This general concept of realizability has many other applications, which have not been explored before the present work. For example, the equations for intrinsically positive quantities such as the dissipation of energy F must also have the property that the time derivative will vanish if the quantity vanishes. Further, we look at the equation for ?,the total turbulent energy; if ;TI vanishes, the time derivative of must vanish. This is a slightly different requirement from Schumann’s realizability in practice, although included in it in principle. That is, we will implement Schumann’s realizability by requiring that the time derivatives of u& vanish if the component vanishes, even if the other components do not. The sum of the three time derivatives, of course, must be equal to production minus dissipation; if vanishes, the requirement that correlation coefficients not exceed unity will assure the vanishing of the production. However, we must separately assure vanishes to guarantee that the time that the dissipation vanishes when derivative vanishes. Roughly speaking, this means that, as vanishes and if cdoes not, the time derivative of B must go to - 00 to assure that it will also vanish at the same point. The same consideration applies to the temperature variance. Finally, we must consider correlations between unlike quantities, like velocity and temperature, which are also constrained by Schwarz’inequality. These must ke treated by a slightly different technique, because the two do not form a tensor. However, we may still examine the eigenvalues of the correlation matrix. These eigenvalues are nonnegative and vanish in only three cases: if the variance of either variable is zero, or if the correlation coefficient becomes unity in absolute value. If we write the secular equation for the matrix and require that the time derivative of the eigenvalue vanish if the eigenvalue vanishes, we obtain as a condition that the time derivative of the determinant will vanish if any of these conditions is met:
a
a
a
__
-2abub
a
+ > p + 23 = 0
(2.9) for two arbitrary correlated quantities u and b. If we arrange to have 2 vanish when 2 vanishes and the same for b, Eq. (2.9)will be satisfied if ab also vanishes; if the correlation coefficient cannot exceed unity (in absolute value), this will be assured. Hence, we must consider the case of the correlation coefficient approaching unity. If p is the correlation coefficient, we have A _
*
p / p = ab/ab - 2 / 2 2 - $/2p.
(2.10)
Substitution in (2.9) permits us to write --
2pp = ( 1 - p2)(ue2/a2 + b2/b2). -L-
(2.11 )
Hence, if the variances are vanishing, but are not yet zero, and the correlation coefficient rises to unity (i.e., the correlation is not vanishing fast enough), the time derivative of the correlation coefficient must vanish, and
Computational Modeling of Turbulent Flows
133
the equation for the correlation must be constructed in such a way as to assure this. This type of realizability, with regard to velocity-temperature correlations, has been completely neglected until now. In the case of the correlation between a scalar and a vector, such as temperature and velocity, in addition to the constraint on the heat flux along each axis, we may obtain a more general condition:
__
( G j P- e u i e U j ) A i A2j o
(2.12)
for an arbitrary vector A i . The conditions on the individual components are included in this and can be obtained by taking Ai successively parallel to the three axes. However, (2.12) is more general. The easiest way to implement the condition is to transform to principal axes of the tensor in parentheses in (2.12); then a statement equivalent to (2.12) is that all eigenvalues of that tensor must be nonnegative. In these coordinates then, we may write equations like (2.9) in each coordinate direction and assure ourselves of satisfying the general condition (2.12), since each eigenvalue is in the form of the usual Schwarz’ inequality. Again, the development of (2.6-2.8) is applicable, and the fact that the directions of the principal axes are changing in time is irrelevant.
111. The Return to Isotropy A. INTRODUCTION It is part of the folklore in the field that anisotropic turbulence tends to become more isotropic; that is, in the absence of other influences the components interchange energy so as to become more nearly equal, and this exchange process proceeds faster than the decay. The experimental evidence for this is individually not very strong; Fig. I, from Lumley and Newman (1977) is typical. Nevertheless, the evidence taken together is incontrovert-
10
15
20
25
jn
35
4n
45
50
55
i M
FIG.1. The return to isotropy of homogeneous turbulence following a contraction. Measurements of Uberoi. (Lumley and Newman, 1977).
John L Lumley
134
ible: such a return to isotropy does exist, but it appears to be very slow for weak anisotropy. This return to isotropy is produced by the pressure terms. Let us consider a homogeneous flow, without mean velocity gradients. The equation for the Reynolds stress is:
(m+ m)/p- 2VUi.k
uj,k*
-(m+ p,iui)/p = -[(puj).i + (pui),jl/~+
J4Uj.i
(34 Although it makes no difference in this flow, it is customary to remove the transport effects (Tennekes and Lumley, 1972,Section 3.2) from the pressure term, writing =-
+ ui,j)/p*
(3.2) Although Lumley (1975b) has pointed out that this separation is not unique, and (3.2) may not be the most appropriate choice, there are reasons of convenience (which will become apparent in Section VI) for making the separation as in (3.2). We concern ourselves with this matter here because we intend to use the modeling which we devise for this pressure term also in inhomogeneous situations. It is evident from the presence of the strain rate ~ ) the trace vanishes; that is, the term serves only to interin ~ ( u+~u ,~ ~, that change energy among the components, not to create or destroy energy. The viscous term in (3.1), although its primary function is to dissipate uiuj stuff to heat, can also cause interchange of energy among the components at any Reynolds number. Although the term is observed (Monin and Yaglom, 1975, p. 453) to become more isotropic with increasing Reynolds number, in agreement with Kolmogorov’s (1941) hypothesis of local isotropy, if u1 = 0 (which can occur conceptually or computationally, and even approximately in reality) then U1.k U1.k = 0 also. We will add and subtract the trace, which is twice the dissipation of energy: 2 v u x = [ 2 v w k - 2Edij/3] + 2E6ij/3.
(3.3) The deviatoric part (in square brackets) now acts to interchange energy among components, but neither creates nor destroys total energy. If we define -E4ij = p(ui,j uj,i)/p - 2~2Zdij/3 (3.4) then Eq. (3.1) may be written as u,ul = -E4ij - 2Edij/3 and 4ijis dimensionless, has zero trace, and is solely responsible and responsible only for the return to isotropy. The tendency toward equipartition which returns the turbulence to (or toward) isotropy can also be regarded as a decay of Reynolds stress, since it is only a question of being, or not being, in principal axes of the Reynolds stress tensor. It seems natural to consider also the decay of other correlations, notably the heat flux. There is very little evidence for this decay; Fig. 2 is the only known data, reproduced from Warhaft and Lumley (1978a).
+
+
Computational Modeling of Turbulent Flows
135
XlM
FIG.2. Decay of temperature-velocity autocorrelation coefficient in grid-produced turbulence after Warhaft and Lumley (1978a; see also Newman et a/., 1978a). Curves were produced by the analysis of Section 1II.C.
Fortunately, the data show incontrovertible decay of the correlation coefficient. In the same homogeneous flow, without mean velocity or temperature gradients, the equation for the heat flux may be written as
iiJ
= --/p
- (v
+ y)B,iui.i,
(3.5) where y is the thermometric diffusivity. Although it is not at all customary, we will separate the first term on the right-hand side just as we did (3.2):
-DIP = -@),i/p
+ KIP.
(3.6) This is not ordinarily done, since the term obtained (the first on the right) is not in the form of a transport term, although it is a divergence (a transport term should be of the form (q),i for the turbulent transport of a quantity A). However, realizability requires that this term be separately modeled. To see this, suppose that all other terms in the equations are realizable. Then, in
John L Lumley
136 --
--
principal axes of f12uiuj - flui flu,, applying Eq. (2.9), realizability requires
-
--
when Pu,ui = flu, flui. This is clearly true for the unmodeled terms (in their natural form as given in (3.7)). More to the point, however, since we will be modeling the term on the left for inclusion in the Reynolds stress equation, we must include a model of the term on the right in the heat flux equation, and the model must satisfy (3.7). Let us define -
_-
-4!jflujElq
2 - 3 -
- P ,iIp - ( V
-
+ Y)fl,jui.j
(3.8)
so that Eq. (3.5) becomes simply -
~ i =8
-- &,flu, E/q2.
(3.9)
This is not a completely general form, but is sufficiently general for our purposes. The molecular transport part of (3.8) will become essentially zero for high Reynolds-Peclet numbers under local isotropy, but that need not concern us. We also need the equation for the temperature variance:
f12 = -2E0.
(3.10)
We can now apply realizability to these equations. First, if we transform and take = 0, then the right-hand side of (3.4) to principal axes of ~(iu~, must vanish, so that we require 411= -4 (since the dissipation and -other _ components _ are notzero). Next, -~ we transform to principal axes of f12uiu, flui fluj and take pu,uj = 8 ~ fluj. 1 Then, applying Eq. (2.9), we require
Note that, if in addition the one-heat flux vanishes, all components of the Reynolds stress containing u1 vanish; this is equivalent to the vanishing of the one-eigenvalue of the Reynolds stress tensor, and hence by the realizability requirement for the Reynolds stress, the second term on the left of (3.11) must also vanish. From this, if the one-heat flux vanishes, the right -side of (3.11) must vanish. So @ must , have the same principal axes as f12uiuj 0%. BU, . Thus, it must be a function only of that tensor, although it may be a function of invariants of other tensors, parameters, etc.; for, if it were a function of any other vectors or tensors, the principal axes would not be the same.
Computational Modeling of Turbulent Flows
137
B. THEREYNOLDS STRESS Now let us consider dij.If Eq. (3.4) is considered as an equation for q5ij, it is clear that it is determined by the history of the Reynolds stress and the present value of the dissipation. We could write in general
4ij = 4ij(uVj, c v},
(3.12)
that is, a functional of the past values. The kinematic viscosity has been included for generality, although it is not explicitly present in the equation. Time does not appear explicitly, since we anticipate that the relationship will not change with time (although the quantities involved will). The functional will involve integrals over time, however, and the most satisfactory normalization_is_to define a new time d.r = dte/?; this is equivalent to T - to= f In (q2/qo2).This new dimensionless time is monotone in the true time since the turbulence is decaying. The argument of (3.12) contains eight quantities involving two dimensions; hence it is possible to form six independent dimensionless groups. We choose to do this in such a way as to make the role of anisotropy most evident; we will define an anisotropy tensor (3.13) This vanishes identically if the turbulence is isotropic, it is dimensionless, symmetric, and has zero trace; hence, it has five independent components. For the sixth group, we take a Reynolds number R, = (?)'/~Ev.
(3.14)
The factor of nine has been included so that, if we take ? = 3u2, B = u3/l, (3.14) becomes the traditional Reynolds number based on this length and velocity. Hence, (3.12) can be written as a functional of (3.13) and (3.14). Now, we may presume that the turbulence has a fading memory and will ultimately forget its initial state; if changes in the mean state are sufficiently slow relative to the turbulence time scale, (3.12) can be expanded in a functional Taylor series about the present state (see Lumley and Newman, 1977, for details); keeping only the first term, (3.12) reduces to a function of the present values of (3.13) and (3.14). The ratio of the turbulence time scale to the time scale of change of the mean field is almost always of order unity in real turbulence, so such an expansion is not formally justified; however, we will find that the resulting expressions work remarkably well. Thus, (3.15)
John L h m l e y
138
This is now of the form discussed in Section II,A, and we can immediately write the form (2.5)
dij = B(11, Ill, R,)bij+ ~ ( 1 1I,l l , RJ(b$ + 211dij/3).
(3.16)
We must now determine the forms of /3 and y in their dependency on the invariants and on the Reynolds number. (This y is, of course, not to be confused with the thermometric diffusivity.) First, it is instructive to consider how turbulence can be characterized in terms of the invariants. A plot of all turbulence on axes of 11 and I l l is shown in Fig. 3. (Note that our definitions (1.2) are the classical ones and differ from those used in Lumley and Newman (1977) by simple factors: 11 = - 11'12, 111 = 111'13, where the prime indicates the expressions used in that paper.) In Fig. 4, the possible region of variation of the eigenvalues of bij, say bl and b, (since the trace is zero, b3 = -b, - b,) is shown. Each eigenvaluecan be no smaller than - 3, corresponding to the vanishing of that component, and can be no larger than +$, corresponding to the vanishing of the other two. Thus, b , and b, are constrained to lie within the triangle in
-II
(2/27.1/3) . 1D
AXISYHMETRIC
ISOTROPIC 2D
AXISYMMETRIC
I -0.05
0
0.05
01
m FIG.3. Possible states of turbulence parametrized by the independent invariants of the anisotropy tensor after Lumley and Newman (1977). Turbulence must occur within the region (or on its boundaries) delimited by the axisymmetric and two-dimensional states.
Computational Modeling of Turbulent Flows
139
FIG.4. The possible range of variation of the two independent eigenvalues of the anisotropy tensor. Turbulence must occur within the triangular region, or on its edges, which correspond to the two-dimensional state. The maxima and minima of 111 on the curve of constant I1 are indicated, where this curve crosses the lines corresponding to axisymmetric states.
Fig. 4. A constant value of I1 corresponds to the ellipse; if I1 is small in absolute value, the ellipse lies entirely within the triangle; if 1 I1 I is larger, it lies partly outside, and the parts outside are excluded (that is, they do not correspond to possible values of bl and b2).At the largest possible value of -11 = 3, the ellipse just touches the corners, corresponding to the three possible one-dimensional turbulences. On the segments of the ellipse lying within the triangle it is possible to determine the total derivative of 111 with respect to b, or b2 for fixed 11; it is readily found that relative maxima occur where the ellipse crosses the lines joining the apexes to the origin, corresponding to axisymmetric turbulence. Relative minima occur where these lines cross the other sides of the ellipse, when the ellipse is small enough to lie entirely within the triangle, also corresponding to axisymmetric turbulence. The relative maxima correspond in each case to two components being equal and the third being larger than the average, while the minima are the opposite. The minima disappear when the component that is smaller than the average reaches zero. Moving away from the maxima, the value of I11 decreases monotonically until an edge of the triangle is reached, corresponding to two-dimensional turbulence. In the two-dimensional and axisymmetric cases, there are simple relations between I1 and 111 which may readily be found. In the axisymmetric case, if
bij = ( 0b -b/2 0 0
8)
-b/2
, (3.17)
John L Lumley
140
then I1 = -3b2/4 and 111 = b3J4; hence 111 = +2(-11/3)3/2. In the twodimensional case, if bij is placed in principal axes and bl = -f the expressions for I1 and 111 can be readily reduced to give
+ 3111 + I1 = 0.
(3.18)
These lines are shown on Fig. 3. By inspection it is clear that a stronger statement can be made relative to the quantity in Eq. (3.18):
6 + 3111 + I1 2 0
(3.19)
everywhere. Hence, the vanishing of (3.19) can be used as an indicator of two-dimensionality of the turbulence, and we will avail ourselves of that possibility. First, Lumley and Newman (1977) have shown from the data of ComteBellot and Corrsin (1966) that for axisymmetric turbulence in vanishingly small anisotropy,
41 Jb = 2.0 + 8.0/R,?12.
(3.20)
The value of 2 corresponds to no return to isotropy. This can be seen by forming the equation for bij: (3.21) dbijldr = - (4ij - 2bij) so that if q511 = 2b in the axisymmetric case, the value of bij remains unchanged. Hehce, (3.20) suggests that there is no linear return to isotropy at an infinite Reynolds number; the effect is thus either a viscous or a nonlinear effect. By forming the equations for I1 and I l l , and considering very small anisotropy, Lumley and Newman (1977) have shown that y must vanish as the anisotropy vanishes at infinite Reynolds number. We have an additional requirement. The so-called final period of decay (Batchelor, 1956) describes turbulence at a Reynolds number so low that the nonlinear terms may be neglected. Since they are responsible for the return to isotropy, there is consequently no longer any return to isotropy. Consequently, the right-hand side of (3.21) must be zero for a zero Reynolds number. We may now attempt to satisfy these various requirements in the simplest way possible. We will be able to satisfy the conditions with y = 0, giving a relatively simple expression. [Lumley and Newman (1977) give a complete expression, but the form is cumbersome.] If 4ij= /3bij, then by (3.21) we must have /3 2 2 always, since f l < 2 would correspond to the spontaneous increase of anisotropy in the absence of any external agency. There is no proof that this should not happen, but it seems unlikely. Since the expression (3.19) is always positive and vanishes if one of the eigenvalues of bij takes the (i.e., the turbulence becomes two-dimensional), it is tempting to value
-4
141
Computational Modeling of Turbulent Flows
take fl = 2 + F(R,, ZI, Ill)($+ 3111 + 11).This would automatically satisfy realizability for the Reynolds stress. It has the disadvantage that, if the turbulence became two-dimensional, there would be no return to isotropy of the remaining two components. However, it is not our intent here to make a model that behaves properly for two-dimensional turbulence, which is fundamentally different in so many respects. We are interested only in a simple, workable form which satisfies realizability, and since a form & j = C1bij is widely used in the literature (see, e.g., &man and Lumley, 1978), the form proposed is likely to be satisfactory. The unknown function F must be determined so that it vanishes at a zero Reynolds number, takes on the value 8.O/R:l2 for small anisotropy and a large Reynolds number, is always positive, and otherwise fits the existing data. The form
fl = 2 + e~p[-D/R;/~](72/Rj"~
+ A h[l + B(-ZZ + CZZZ)])($ + 3111 + ZZ), A = 80.1,
B = 62.4,
C = 2.3,
(3.22)
D = 7.77
fits the data given in Lumley and Newman (1977) nearly as well as the more complicated expression given there (Fig. 5 ) ; the agreement with the form
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
-ux10*
FIG. 5. The return to isotropy + , , / b (the function from the analysis of Section II1,B) for an axisymmetric flow with negative 111. The light curves are the more complete description of Lumley and Newman (1977), while the heavy curves are the analysis of Section II1,B. The experimental points are those reproduced in Lumley and Newman (1977).
142
John L Lumley
given by Lumley and Newman (1977) is equally good for the axisymmetric case with 111 > 0, for which no data exist. The behavior in Fig. 5 displays the various characteristics we have discussed. Note particularly the fact that the curve arrives at the twodimensional state (- 211 = $) with finite slope which indicates that this state is unstable; if perturbed, there will be a finite rate of return to isotropy. C. THEHEATFLUX
We may now consider +!, beginning from the realizability condition (3.11). Let us introduce a tensor
__
(3.23) D,, = iqqa - eu, euj/P?. This has nonnegative eigenvalues that vanish only if the correlation is perfect in that component. From the realizability condition, we have already , be a function of Dij. It is straightforward but tedious to found that &must show that (in principal axes of D i j ) if D l l = 0, then 2
4 + 3111 + 11 = 3DzzD3,8U1 /@?.
(3.24)
Substituting this in (3.22), and that in (3.11), we obtain for realizability in principal axes of Dij with D l l = 0: =
1
+ r + (F/2)($ + 3111 + 11 -
D22D33),
(3.25)
where F is the expression in (3.22) which multiplies the last set of parentheses. We may identify D Z 2D3, as ll,, the second invariant of the tensor Dij under these conditions. r is the time scale ratio, r = (~/P)(42@). Thus, to satisfy realizability, we could assume = [I
+ Y + (F/2)(3 + 3111 + I I -
llD)]dij
+ gDij + hD$,
(3.26)
where g and h are functions of the invariants of D,,, I,, ll,, and 111,. If we consider decay of the correlation coefficient in an isotropic turbulence, we find, if p is the correlation coefficient,
I, = -p(f$&
- r - l)E/?.
(3.27)
We find 11, = 2( 1 - p2)/9 + f and
- 1 - r = (F/2)(3- 11,)
+ gD11 + hD:l.
(3.28)
With D1 = ( 1 - p2)/3 finally we have d In p/dz = -(8/3 - F/9)(1 - p’) - (h/9)(1 - p2)’.
(3.29)
Excellent agreement with the data of Warhaft and Lumley (1978a) is obtained by taking h = 0, g/3 - F/9 = 1.6 (the curves in Fig. 3 were obtained
Computational Modeling of Turbulent Flows
143
using these values). Until more data are available indicating variation with the Reynolds number, etc., we will use these values. We have a choice; the F appearing in (3.29) is F with I I = I I I = 0, say F,. In defining g in general, we could use either the general F, or just F,. Lacking any information, we will take F because it produces the simplest equation. If we form the equation for the decay of the correlation coefficient of an axial heat flux in an axisymmetric turbulence, we obtain with this choice d In p/dr = -(B - 2)/2 - 3bll/(l
- (1
+ 3b11)
+ 3bll)(l - p2)(1.6+
b11 F/6)
(3.30)
so that the decay rate is increased if b l l is positive (and vice versa). This must await experimental confirmation but has a certain appeal. The axisymmetric form (3.30) is applicable to the conditions of &man and Lumley (1976), where a buoyancy-driven atmospheric surface mixed layer was considered. The heat transfer is entirely vertical, and the turbulence is axisymmetric about the vertical axis. Using Zeman and Lumley’s (1976)fixed value for B = 3.25, we find for the right-hand side of (3.30) a value of -2.44, whereas the value using their equations, which assume a fixed value for 4; = 7.0, is - 4.79; the value we obtain for 4; = 4.65 under their conditions. It seems very likely that the larger value was necessitated by the failure of their rapid terms to satisfy realizability conditions, driving the heat flux to impossibly high values, and requiring a larger return to isotropy term to kekp the heat flux under control. IV. The Rapid Terms A. INTRODUCTION
In what we have done so far, we have considered only homogeneous situations without mean velocity gradients or buoyancy. If we begin from the Navier-Stokes equations for the fluctuating velocity in an incompressible situation (in the Boussinesq approximation, if buoyancy is importantsee Lumley and Panofsky, 1964, Section 2.1),
+ ui,juj+ ui,juj + ui,juj -
+
+
- p , ~ p pie vui,jj and take the divergence, we obtain an expression for the pressure: tii
=
+
(4.1)
-v2pip = 2ui,juj,i ui,juj,i- pie,i. (4.2) This contains two types of terms on the right-hand side. The first and third are linear in the fluctuating quantities, while the second is quadratic. The second term is the nonlinear scrambling (Hanjalic and Launder, 1972) or the
144
John L Lumley
return-to-isotropy term; it is the pressure field associated with the mixing of the turbulence by itself generated by this term which is responsible for the gradual equalization of the energy in the various components of the turbulence. It is the other terms which we wish to examine here. We may conveniently split the pressure into two parts, defining
The correlations with p") are those which have already been modeled in Section 111. The correlations with p") and its gradients are those which we refer to as the "rapid" terms. The term "rapid" is used for two reasons. First, there is a classical problem in turbulence called the rapid distortion problem (Batchelor and Proudman, 1954), in which one imagines that the turbulence is subjected to a velocity gradient so intense that for some little time one may neglect the transport and distortion of the turbulence by itself, and hence neglect p(') and the nonlinear and viscous terms in Eq. (4.1). Since the pressure p") is the only pressure present during this rapid distortion, it is natural to refer to it as the rapid pressure. Second and more important for us, however, it is not difficult to show that, if an initially isotropic turbulence is subjected to a sudden distortion, not necessarily rapid, all correlations in the equations not involving p(l)begin from isotropy and gradually develop anisotropy in response to the distortion; the same is true for the sudden application of a gravitational field. The terms involving p(l), however, are instantly anisotropic. This also justifies the use of the term rapid, and in addition makes clear why it is necessary to model these terms with considerable care; in nearly every situation, they exert a very strong influence on the structure of the anisotropy of the velocity field (see, e.g., Townsend, 1970). Incidentally, the concept of rapid distortion has been extended to the case of the sudden application of a very strong gravitational field (Gence, 1977)within the same approximation. The first of Eq. (4.3) may readily be solved by standard techniques to give p") explicitly in terms of the right-hand side. Of the many solution techniques available, we will use Fourier transforms, which are appropriate to a homogeneous field. Although there are, in general, terms in the various correlations with p") arising from inhomogeneity, consideration of which would require a solution technique for p(') that did not suppose homogeneity, these terms are never considered, and there is no indication that the homogeneous forms are insufficient in any practical situation. For an introduction to the use of Fourier transforms for homogeneous stochastic fields, see Lumley (1970a). Indicating the Fourier transform off by [f], we may write
Computational Modeling of Turbulent Flows
145
To obtain the various correlations that appear in the equations, we must now multiply by the Fourier transform of the appropriate quantity, average, and integrate over the Fourier space. Taking the simplest case first, let us multiply by [el* (the complex conjugate), average, and integrate over Fourier space, designating S the spectrum of temperature variance, s, the spectrum of the heat flux, and s,,, the spectrum of the Reynolds stress for future reference. In all cases the integral of the appropriate spectrum over the entire Fourier space gives the quantity in question. We will indicate an integral over three-dimensional Fourier space by 1dK.
Taking the second part of the integral only, without the buoyancy parameter, we will consider
j” (KqKi/K2)SdK= Iqi,
say.
Now, Iqi must clearly be symmetric. If i is summed on q, the term in parentheses goes to unity and the integral is, by definition, the temperature variance, so that we have as a condition I,, = p.In addition, if the turbulence is isotropic, S is a function only of the magnitude of the wavenumber vector, and hence is spherically symmetric. If the integral is carried out in two steps, first over spherical shells, and second, over the radius, the term in parentheses can be integrated immediately to give
on a spherical shell. If the integral is now carried out over the radius, we have for the isotropic case
We must develop a model for Iqi which satisfies these restrictions. Most authors use the isotropic value for Iqi for all situations. However, we must also satisfy the realizability conditions. Writing Iqij and Iqijk for quantities constructed like Zqi in (4.6),but using S j and S , and applying the realizability condition (2.9)to the equations for the heat flux, taking in account the fact that the realizability conditions must be separately satisfied by the terms multiplying the buoyancy parameter since it may be given any value and orientation (the same being true of the terms multiplying the mean velocity gradient), and using the fact that the spectra and hence Iqi,etc., may be
John L Lumley
146
(say, by unfelicitous initial_conditionsJ-from _ fl, and U i S jwe , obtain (in principal axes of the tensor p u i u j - 8ui 8 u j )
manipulated separately
&I,,
=
F Z , ~ , , GI,,= PI,,,,
G I =, ~ FPz,~~ (4.9)
as the conditions which must be satisfied if either the corresponding velocity component vanishes, or the corresponding correlation coefficient achieves the (absolute) value of unity, or the temperature variance vanishes. If we can assure ourselves that the corresponding condition (4.9) is satisfied when the correlation coefficient achieves unity in absolute value, then by (2.11) the correlation coefficient will be bounded. Hence, if either the temperature variance or the corresponding velocity variance vanishes, the corresponding heat flux will vanish. If we arrange that Iql vanishes when the one-heat flux vanishes, and similarly for the other components, then (4.9) will be satisfied under all conditions. Thus, we must (1) arrange for I , , , to vanish if vanishes, etc., and (2) must satisfy the corresponding member of (4.9) if the correlation coefficient in question becomes f 1. Wyngaard (1975) and &man and Lumley (1978) looked at the horizontally homogeneous case of a vertical temperature and velocity gradient and considered a strong stable stratification which annihilated the vertical velocity and heat flux. The equation for the vertical heat flux in these circumstances is -
ew =
-83
+ p3P.
(4.10)
Since it seems likely that the vertical heat flux should remain zero under these circumstances, they were led to require that 1 3 3 = F as the vertical velocity vanishes. As a general prescription this is, however, not consistent with (4.9), if we assume that the value of lqiis determined entirely by the temperature and velocity fields as we shall. For then, if the velocity and heat flux vanish in any direction, the diagonal component of Iqi in that direction must take on the value p,while the other two must vanish, since lii= p. The condition is immediately violated if two components of the velocity vanish. In fact, an exact condition can be obtained from (4.9). If the horizontal velocity and heat flux vanishes, then the first two of (4.9) are satisfied; if the correlation coefficient in the vertical is unity, then 1 3 3 must vanish, since Ipii= 0 by continuity, and hence 1,33 = 0 since I,, and I,,, are zero (since 8ul and = 0) (see,for example, Lumley, 1970a, Section 4.7). Hence, 1 and I , , cannot both be zero. This exact condition was also invoked by Wyngaard (1975) and &man and Lumley (1978). We may add one final condition: the diagonal components of lqimust be nonnegative, since the temperature spectrum is nonnegative. In the case when the correlation coefficient achieves the value of 1, the conditions (4.9) have a simple interpretation. If u , and 8 are perfectly cor-
,
,,
Computational Modeling of Turbulent Flows
147
related, they are proportional, and consequently the spectra S, S , , and S I 1 are all proportional. Thus, we see that, not only must we construct a model for Iqi consistent with all these conditions, but we must model I,, at the same time, since their limiting values must be coupled. The equivalent conditions on Iqij are I4V. . = I.W J..’ I44J. = 8u.; J I W.. = 0 ; and Inij -,0 as -,0. These have all been discussed before or are completely analogous to conditions on Iqi. We have, in addition, the conditions on Iqij which arise from realizability of the Reynolds stress. We may obtain these conditions by placing the equations for the Reynolds stress in principal axes; if the intensity in, say, the onedirection vanishes, then for the vanishing of the time derivative we require that I,, vanish also (since the one-heat flux vanishes) for arbitrary p . Thus this is not an independent condition.
6
B. THEHEATFLUX INTEGRAL In the past it has been customary to take for Iqij a simple linear combination of G.For example, &man and Lumley (1978) and nearly all other authors use
Iqij = (3)[Si,euj
-
(+)(SijK + Sqj&)].
(4.11 )
This satisfies the first, second, and third of the conditions in Iqij, but it does not satisfy the important condition that it vanish when the j-heat flux vanishes, both required by realizability and by the fact that S j vanishes when the j-heat flux vanishes. This almost surely causes computational difficulties (Zeman and Lumley, 1978). We could attempt to remedy the situation by constructing a very general formalism, expressing Iqij as a function of bijand the heat flux, forming invariant functions, etc. Fortunately, it is possible to construct by inspection a simple expression that at least satisfies all the necessary conditions : 1,ij
= (6,i
-- _ _ -8~,0~i/tl~,8~,)8~j/2.
(4.12)
C. THETEMPERATURE VARIANCE INTEGRAL
The construction of an expression for Iqi which satisfies all requirements of its own and is properly related to the expression (4.12) by realizability conditions is not quite so simple, and we have been unable to find a completely general expression. The following expression has nonnegative eigenvalues, has the proper trace and the proper value under isotropy, but
148
John L Lumley
satisfies realizability exactly only on the total heat flux, not on the components: I 1.4 = eZsi,/3
+ Phi, - (3/2a)(G&,
-
__
-.e~,e~,s,/3).
(4.13)
To see in what senserealizabilityis satisfied, suppose we are in principal axes of the tensor @uiuj - flui 8 u j , and suppose that the correlation is perfect in the one-direction. Then, because off-diagonal terms of the tensor and because -- the leading diagonal term also vanvanish in principal axes, ishes, we may write @u,u, = Bu, Ou, ;substituted in the expression for bqi, this may then be combined with the other terms in (4.13), producing
__
-- _ _
I,, = (eu, eu,/2q2)(s,1 - eu, eu,leu, eu,).
(4.14)
At the same time we have from (4.12) the expression
-- _ _
I,, = (8U,/2)(sq1- eu, eu, /eu,eu,).
(4.15)
These have the same dependence on q ; the realizability condition produces --
eu,eu,
=
(4.16)
which is true only if all components are perfectly correlated (in which case all three realizability conditions will be satisfied exactly). This can occur approximately in free convection, in which the horizontal velocity essentially vanishes; htnce, the expressions (4.12) and (4.13) may be useful in that situation. When 24, = 0, I , , = Ou, 8u,,/2q2; if the horizontal heat flux is small, this will be essentially zero, as is desirable (see Eq. (4.10)).No computations have been done yet with (4.12)-(4.13), and we must regard them as an interim solution since it seems likely that additional terms may be required. Lumley (1975a) suggested that perhaps these rapid terms should be functions of the mean field parameters, that is, the buoyancy parameter and the mean velocity gradient. However, Reynolds (1976) quite correctly pointed out that the Iqi,etc., are determined by the form of the spectra; if the spectra are set by initial conditions in a particular state, the Iqi, etc., will be completely determined independent of the buoyancy parameter and the mean velocity gradient. These will exert their effect as the field evolves, of course, but only by their influence on the form of the spectra. Hence, in determining forms for these terms, we exclude all quantities other than those characterizing the state of the turbulent field, the second-order correlations. Lumley (1975a) also suggested that the expressions for Iqi, etc., must be linear in the second-order quantities. The reasoning was as follows: the rapid terms are those which would appear in rapid distortion theory. Rapid distortion theory is a linear calculation, and therefore results are superposable. We may model rapid distortion theory by using our rapid terms, neglecting return to isotropy and dissipation; hence, our modeling results must also be
Computational Modeling of Turbulent Flows
149
superposable. Hence, the expressions for lqimust be linear in the secondorder quantities. This position seems to have found acceptance (Reynolds, 1976). However, it must be incorrect in some sense, since it is impossible to satisfy realizability with linear expressions. This is a perplexing problem, which deserves further thought. The answer could, of course, be that it is not possible to parametrize even approximately the terms lqiin terms of the second-order quantities; however, I feel that that is unlikely. A more appealing explanation is the following: in rapid distortion theory the solutions are dependent on the time multiplied by the mean velocity gradient due to the linearity; since geometrically different mean velocity fields produce different solutions, the solutions can be expressed as functions of dimensionless structural parameters, constructed from the mean velocity gradient (Lumley, 1975a); due to the way in which time appears, these structural parameters may, in each solution, be replaced post hoc by expressions constructed from the solution variables themselves, producing an apparent nonlinearity. Hence, a general expression, parametrized in terms of the second-order quantities, in the course of a rapid distortion problem, would have certain combinations of these quantities which remained constant, playing the role of structural parameters. It has also been suggested (Lumley, 1975a)that the rapid distortion problems could be used to calibrate the modeling of the rapid terms. While it is possible to construct rapid terms which model the rapid distortion problem quite successfully (Gence, 1977), it now seems likely that this is not a useful procedure. The problem is, that the spectra, for the same values of the large scale parameters (the second order quantities) will, during rapid distortion, have quite different forms from their usual ones, since the strain rate, or buoyancy, is supposed to be sufficiently strong to dominate the nonlinear effects. Thus, the strain rate, or buoyancy, will be felt directly in the small scales of the spectra, which will not have an equilibrium form. It is conceivable that the rapid terms could be modeled incorporating a parameter representing the ratio of the time scale of the distortion to the time scale of the dissipative eddies; during the distortion this is essentially zero, while for the cases we are interested in modeling, it is essentially infinite. One could envision calibrating the model against rapid distortion with the parameter set at one value, and afterwards setting it at the other value. However, this would be a complicated and delicate procedure and seems unlikely to be worth the effort. Since even the extremely crude models for the rapid terms currently in use (which do not satisfy realizability and sometimes not even incompressibility) give results which are in many ways satisfactory, it appears probable that we can, by devising models which do satisfy these conditions, produce results which are completely satisfactory without going to extremes.
John L. Lumley
150
D. THEREYNOLDSSTRESS INTEGRAL We may now consider the rapid terms which multiply the velocity gradient. From Eq. (4.5) we may evidently write the appropriate terms in the heat flux equation as h i
-
=***
- Ui,kUkd + 2Up,,1piq,
(4.17)
and in the Reynolds stress equation as 2up,q1piqj+ 2upsqIpjqi - ui,km - U j , k m ~ i . (4.18) Again, if we rotate to principal axes of the Reynolds stress, and consider the vanishing of, say, the one-component, then for the time derivative of the one-component to vanish we require lplql a dpq. We have used the fact that the velocity gradient U i , j is arbitrary relative to the principal axes of -the Reynolds __ stress and that Ui,i= 0. If we now rotate to principal axes of 02uiuj - 8ui Buj , and apply Eq. (2.9), supposing that the one-eigenvalue, say, vanishes, i.e., that the correlation is perfect in the one-direction, we obtain
uiuj =
* * *
-
-
~21p,q1 = 8% 1,1,
+ Adpq,
(4.19) ~
--
where A is arbitrary, and use was made of the fact that P u i u, = Bui Bu, ,the mean velocity gradient is arbitrary, and Ui,i = 0. We have in addition the lpiqj = lipqj; various symmetry and other conditions on lPw:lpiei= lpijq; lppqj = ii&(which we will term normalization); lpiij = 0 (incompressibility). We can add, finally, that if the turbulence is isotropic, we must have (Crow, 1968; Rotta, 1951a) -
1P4V.. = (4dijdpq - dpid, - dpjdqi)q2/30
(4.20)
obtained by integrating the isotropic form of the spectrum (Lumley, 1970a). The realizability conditions above are new, but all other conditions have been known for some time. The conditions other than realizability can all be satisfied by a linear combination of terms in bij: Iijpq
+ (APijbpq - (i+)(aipbjq + diqbjp + djpbiq + djqbip)l + (?/11)[5dijbpq - (dipbjq + d i q b j p + d j p b i q + djqbip)I
= C[bijapq
+ (?/30)[46ijdpq - dipdjq- diqdjp).
(4.21)
This form was independently devised in different ways by a number of different workers (for a full discussion, see Launder, 1975). The constant C is not determined by the various conditions, and is usually determined empirically. However, different workers obtain different values, when different flows are used for calibration. This is probably because the form (4.21) does not satisfy realizability for any value of C, as can be easily checked. If we
Computational Modeling of Turbulent Flows
151
,
transform to principal axes of b,, suppose that b , = -4,and form Iilplrwe find that it is zero for i # p. However, for i = p # 1 we find ZPlp1 = -bp,(3C
+ a ) / l l + C/11 - ?/330
(no sum)
(4.22)
while for i = p = 1 we find
l l l I l= -C/11
+ 2?/55.
(4.23)
Thus, there is no value of C which will satisfy realizability. Depending on the value which is chosen, this term will either oppose the growth of the offdiagonal terms of the Reynolds stress, not permitting them to grow large enough in some geometries, or permit them to grow too large. In case the other two components of the velocity are equal, we could take C = 2?/5, which would then satisfy realizability, since the diagonal components would then be equal. Launder (1975) suggests a value of 0 . 2 7 5 a (our C = c2 2 / 2 in Launder’s notation). The situation with regard to realizability relative to the heat flux is even worse. There is essentially no relation between IP,,,and It is evident that the failure of realizability is due primarily to the terms of the form 6 , bip, etc., in (4.21), since on setting j = q = 1, we are left with bip,which cannot be made to behave properly. Hence, the entire group of four terms (required by symmetry) must be excluded. It is possible to satisfy all symmetry, incompressibility, normalization, and isotropy conditions with the following expression :
This does not satisfy realizability, however (relative to the Reynolds stress), since in principal axes of bij, if b , , = -$, we have Iilpl
= (?/30)(36i,6p,
- dip).
(4.25)
This, at least, has only delta functions, which could be canceled by the addition of another term. We must create a function to add to (4.24)which is symmetric in i - j and p - q, which has zero trace when i is summed on j and when j is summed on p, which vanishes under isotropy, and which, in principal axes of b,,, if b , = -4, will produce only terms like those of (4.25) so that a coefficient can be chosen to cancel them. Note that the d i p can remain (since the whole expression will be multiplied by U i , ,which is incompressible). It is necessary to go to third order in order to obtain such a term (note that, to be sure of having only terms like those of (4.25)we must never have bi, appearing):
,
bib,,
+ (11/3)bijhPq+ (211/3)6ijb,, + (2Z11/10)6ij6pq- (3111/10)(6ip6jq+ 6jp6iq).
(4.26)
152
John L Lumley
This vanishes under isotropy, has both traces zero, and in principal axes of bij, if b,, = -4, reduces to (taking the ilpl component) dil dP1(-& - 11/3 - 111/10) - (3111/10)dip.
(4.27)
We can satisfy realizability relative to the Reynolds stress by adding (4.26) to (4.24) with a coefficient 27?/( 10 + 9011 + 27111). If we examine the realizability relations relative to the heat flux, we again find that it is not possible the_ general relation, but it is possible to satisfy the relation for the to satisfy_ case of 8ui 8ui = pa,when all components are perfectly correlated (or only one component exists) by the combination of (4.24) and (4.26). Note that there are eight independent expressions which all satisfy the requirements of symmetry, incompressibility, etc., any of which can be multiplied by (4 + 3111 + 11) and added to the combination of (4.24) and (4.26) without condition _ on either heat flux (approximately) or affecting the realizability_ then 4 + 3111 + 11 = 0. Reynolds stress, since if 8ui 8ui = These expressions are forbiddingly complicated, but where is it written that turbulence must be simple? The principle is simple; the result is an odd tensor polynomial on a bounded domain. The complexity is primarily so that the expression will say the same thing regardless of the geometry. It should be emphasized that these expressions are by no means the last word, especially since they have not been tested by computation. They are predicated on the simple form for Zijk, which is, in some respects, the easiest to model. A more complex form could be constructed for Zijkr with constants which could be adjusted to conform to experiment, and which would then lead to more complex forms for Z i j and Zijkl. The failure to satisfy realizability exactly relative to the heat flux may be serious, and it may be necessary to construct these more complicated forms for this reason. These interim forms at least point the way toward improvements on the forms in current use, which do not satisfy realizability in any sense.
e'z
V. The Dissipation Equations A. THEMECHANICAL DISSIPATION The equations for the mechanical and thermal dissipation are in the sorriest state. Whereas realizability and considerable physical reasoning has given substantial form to the equations for the second and third moments, when the equations for the dissipations are reduced by high-ReynoldsPeclet number assumptions (Lumley and Khajeh-Nouri, 1974) what is left is
B + E , i ui +
io+ Eo,i ui+
= - (2/?)+, = - (EoZ/P)Jlg,
(5.1)
Computational Modeling of Turbulent Flows
153
where the dimensionless invariant functions on the right-hand side contain the entire mechanism for the production and destruction of the dissipations. The situation is particularly difficult, because while the dissipation occurs at small scales, it is fixed by large-scale mechanisms; what we are really trying to determine is the rate at which energy or temperature variance is passed along the spectral pipeline to scales at which it can be attacked by molecular transport (see Tennekes and Lumley, 1972, Section 3.2). If the molecular diffusivity is changed in a turbulent flow, it simply changes the scale at which the dissipation occurs, but does not change the level of the dissipation. Since the spectral transport is related to the skewness of the velocity differences at two points (Monin and Yaglom, 1975, Section 21.4) for intermediate separation distances, it would probably make sense to try to model the equation for this quantity, as suggested by D. C. Leslie (personal communication). In the meantime, we must do what we can with what we have. If the Reynolds stress equation is regarded as an equation for the dissipation, we may probably conclude that I(/ is a functional of the history of the Reynolds stress, the heat flux, and the dissipation, as well as the mean velocity gradient, the gravity vector, and possibly the viscosity. Making the same assumption regarding slow changes, we can write II/ as a function of these quantities:
*
*(w,G,E, ui,j,
(54 We cannot exclude the mean velocity gradient and buoyancy vector as we did previously (in other equations) because it is not at all clear that (5.2) is determined solely by the state of the turbulence at a given instant. It is certain, for example, that if the buoyancy vector is zero, a heat flux cannot affect the mechanical dissipation. It also seems clear that the sudden imposition of a mean velocity gradient cannot have any immediate effect on the rate of change of dissipation if the turbulence is isotropic; on the other hand, additional sources of production in the energy equation must cause changes in the level of dissipation. We can thus conclude that the heat flux and buoyancy vector must occur as a product and the mean velocity gradient probably cannot occur without the anisotropy tensor. We may select a collection of nondimensional groupings in (5.2), as =
pi,
-
v).
$ = $(blj, q2ui,jfGGPjh RI)* (5.3) This must now be a function of the invariants that can be constructed from these quantities. Unfortunately, they are numerous, particularly because the mean velocity gradient is not symmetric. Pope (1974; see also Spencer and Rivlin, 1959, 1960) has examined a related problem. A complete list includes 22 invariants, even with the restrictions we have placed on the problem. It is clearly impossible to determine the dependence of a function of 22 variables by any imaginable set of experiments. The list is usually restricted to include only quantities of first degree in the mean velocity gradient and the buoy-
John L Lumley
154
ancy vector on the principle that these may be regarded in the first instance as weak. Such a restricted list is: -
$ = $(ll, I l l , bijq2Ui,j/E,b;TUi,j/E, & f i i / E ,
Gbijfij/E, &bifij/E, R,). (5.4)
It is also consistent with the position that the mean velocity gradient and the buoyancy are weak to expand (5.4) in a series in these quantities, keeping only linear terms: $ = $0
+
$1
+
bijq2Ui,j/E $2b;TUi,j/E
+ 4b3&Bi/Z + $4&bijfij/E + t,bsGbifij/E,
(5.5)
where the coefficients are functions of I I , I l l , and the Reynolds number. Even these are not all used. For example, Zeman and Lumley (1978) use $0
$3
= 3.8
+ 6011/(1 + 3( -211)1'2),
=
+0.95,
=
-3.8,
= 20/( 1
+ 3( -211)'12).
(5.6) These forms are determined on a largely empirical basis; the forms in the denominator of $o and t+b4 are found necessary in computation of the buoyancy-driven atmospheric surface mixed layer, which becomes very anisotropic near the inversion base. The leading constant is the only one that can be determined cleanly: the data of Comte-Bellot and Corrsin (1966) give $4
= 3.78
- 2.77R;
'I2
+ 18.1811 +
(5.7) for large Reynolds number and very small anisotropy (Lumley and Newman, 1977). The correlation coefficient for the Reynolds number variation is0.8, while that for the variation with anisotropy is 0.33, and hence this coefficient should not be taken too seriously. If we consider turbulence without production from either mean velocity gradient or buoyancy, then there are two limiting cases for which values of the leading coefficient can be determined: in the final period of decay, for very small Reynolds number and all anisotropies, Lumley and Newman (1977) determine that $o = they also obtain the same result for one-dimensional turbulence and arbitrary Reynolds number, i.e., for If = -3. In the absence of any other information, they suggest a simple interpolation formula relating these values: $0
v;
+ 0.980 exp[ -2.83R; '/'I[
1 - 0.33
In( 1 - 5511)l.
(5.8) At observed values of anisotropy, this does not differ much numerically from the form used by Zeman and Lumley (1978). $o =
Computational Modeling of Turbulent Flows
155
It has been known for some time that computation schemes of the type discussed here, when calibrated against plane flows, will not predict the development of axisymmetric flows properly, as discussed by Pope (1977). Specifically, the spreading rate of a round jet is overestimated by about 40% (Pope, 1977). Pope suggests that this is due to the omission in (5.5) of a term of the form (Ui,j - Uj,i)(Uj,k- Uk,j)(Ui,k+ Uk,i). The spectral transfer is produced by the stretching of large-scale vorticity (Tennekes and Lumley, 1972, Section 8.2), and this term is intended to represent this process; in particular, the term vanishes in two-dimensional mean flow, when the mean vorticity is normal to the plane of the mean strain rate. In axisymmetric flows, however, this is not true, and the term is nonzero. The inclusion of such a term restores the correct spreading rate for the axisymmetricjet. I feel, however, that the term suggested cannot be quite right, because it is independent of the anisotropy of the turbulence. That is, if the turbulence is isotropic, it should make no initial difference what the geometry of the mean velocity field is. Another possibility presents itself immediately: in developed turbulence, to a zeroth-order approximation, one can set approximately bij oc (Ui,j+ U j , i )(Lumley, 1967), and this can be substituted in the expression proposed by Pope. Evaluating the expression in a plane shear flow, we fmd that it will vanish if b,, (normal to the plane of the shear) vanishes, which it approximately does in plane deformations. This suggests other possibilities that have the same property, in particular 111; it seems more rational that +o should depend on 111 than on Pope’s (1977) suggestion, but this must be determined from a comparison of the decay of isothermal anisotropic turbulence without mean velocity gradients in the axisymmetric case, when 111 # 0, and in the case of plane deformation when it is approximately zero. It is unfortunate that the data are so poor; the determination of t,b from experimental data is equivalent to determining the second derivative of the data, and very little data are sufficiently accurate to permit this. We can adduce one rigorous condition, which is unfortunately of no help in determining the form of our equation. For realizability, it is necessary that e vanish if 7 vanishes. Hence, the F equation must be arranged so that, if vanishes without F, will become infinite so as to drive B to zero. As it stands (5.9, or even (5.3), has this property. We may introduce one further possible criterion. At the edge of a wake or jet, or thermal plume, the production closely balances the dissipation as both vanish (Tennekes and Lumley, 1972, Section 4.2). We have already considered the necessity for assuring that the dissipation vanishes when the velocity vanishes; here, however, we must say something stronger to assure that they vanish together at the proper rate. If they are to vanish at such a rate that (?)”/E is bounded for some n, and production and dissipation are of
+
156
John L Lamley
the same order, then we should have
zz = nz?
= 2nE(P, - e),
(5.9) where we have written P , for the total production, and (5.9) should be valid as both energy and dissipation vanish and production is of the order of dissipation. All the terms in Eq. (5.5) will be of the same order; hence, this suggests that $?, $4, $5 should not be present, and that -4b3 = = $o = 2n. Since +~I! is at least 3.78, n = 1.89 or larger so that the dissipation will go to zero faster than the energy as observed (Tennekes and Lumley, 1972; Section 4.2). Elimination of 4b4 would have caused difficulty in the calculation of Zeman and Lumley (1978); however, what was needed was a reduction of the dissipation production in the case of nearly onedimensional turbulence; this could be achieved in other ways, say, by the introduction of a factor of 4 + 3111 + 11. The equality between and -$3 we will see again when we discuss the equation for the dissipation of temperature variance. B. THETHERMAL DISSIPATION We can now consider the second part of (5.1), the equation for the dissipation of temperature variance. Proceeding in the same way, we obtain the These allow the same set of variables, with the addition of Ee, p,and addition of several invariants and a ratio, r = ie;fz/esE, the time scale ratio, which can appear as a variable in all the coefficients. If we consider the case of decaying anisotropic turbulence without production of any kind, we have
_ -
---
I+P= $ o e ( ~ 111, ~ , r, R,, 8U,i&$FTTI euibijeuj/iPq2,euieujb;/iPz), (5.10) Some authors avoid the entire problem by assigning a constant value to r (Spalding, 1971). However, it seems likely that r may vary depending on local conditions of transport and production. We may form an equation for r, obtaining d In r/dr = r(2 - i,hoe) - (2 - $o). (5.11) Extensive measurements by Warhaft and Lumley (1978b) indicated that, when the turbulence was isotropic, there was absolutely no tendency for r to change during the decay; it could be set at any value initially and would maintain that value until the end of the tunnel. This suggests taking, at least for the isotropic case, (5.12) i,ho0 = 2 - (2 - i,b0)/r. It also suggests that any tendency for the ratio r to tend toward an equilibrium value must be due to anisotropy and/or the production terms, which
Computational Modeling of Turbulent Flows
157
are producing temperature and velocity fluctuations from gradients by the same mechanism. We can write by analogy with (5.5) $* = *oe
+
(5.13)
$18zi&3,i/Eg,
where we have suppressed the other terms, taking the position (at least temporarily) that the temperature equation should not depend directly on the buoyant production or mechanical production (Newman et al., 1978a). If we form the equation for r, we find (designating the mechanical production by P,, the buoyant production by P b and the thermal production by P,) d In r/dz = i - ( t / ~ ~-* 2jP,/&
+ (2 - $l)Pm/E+ (2 + $3)Pb/E- r$$ + (5.14)
where we have designated by $: and the departures of $oe and $o from their isotropic values. Let us consider first an anisotropic decaying turbulence without production. If r has reached its equilibrium value re, which must be determined later, then we expect the time derivative to vanish, so that we must have re $$ =
(5.15)
If it is assumed that $$ is not a function of r, (5.15) fixes its value. Now consider an equilibrium situation with production, but without buoyancy so that P, = 0. We expect that P , = E, and P, = E ~ If. r has reached its equilibrium value re, we must again have the time derivative vanish, which gives (5.16) re($1*- 2 ) = $ l - 2. If we now introduce buoyancy, and let P , + P b = i, we find - $ 1 = $ 3 . Although their forms were somewhat different from those we have assumed, the above relations (with the exception of - $ 1 = t+b3) were approximately satisfied in the work of Zeman and Lumley (1978). These relations provide for an orderly relaxation of the time scale ratio whenever there is anisotropy or production. We obtain, making use of these various relations, d In r/dr = (2 - $,)[(P,
+ P&
-
+
(P,/EB)r/re] $o'(l - r/re).
(5.17)
The fact that the equation for dissipation of temperature variance does not contain, with these assumptions, terms quadratic in the heat flux, is not serious. Newman et al. (1978a) found from an analysis of the data of Alexopoulos and Keffer (1971) that the inclusion of such a term was not warranted by the data. We must now determine a value for re. For vanishing anisotropy and infinite Reynolds-Peclet number it is clear that the number should be near
158
John L. Lumley
unity. A test field model simulation (Newman et al., 1978a; Newman and Herring, 1978) suggests the value 1.0. However, the measurements of Warhaft (Warhaft and Lumley, 1978b) suggest a value of r = 1.34 when the three-dimensional velocity and temperature spectra peak at the same wavenumber, which one would expect in a real equilibrium situation. For a vanishing Reynolds number and all anisotropy, we have the final period of decay. Corrsin (1951)has shown that then re = 0.6. For large anisotropy we may consider one-dimensionalturbulence. Newman et al. (1978a)consider a somewhat special type of one-dimensional thermal turbulence which is isothermal in the direction of the unique velocity component, and take a limit from the not-quite-one-dimensionalcase (because the limit is singular); they find that re has the same value for all Reynolds numbers as it does in the final period of decay. Having only three limiting values of re,it is reasonable to construct an interpolation formula among them, the simplest possible. Newman et al. (1978a) take the variation to be of the same type as was assumed in Eq. (5.8). If the value of 1.34 is taken as the value for re at infinite Reynolds number and vanishing anisotropy, then we have (5.18)
i+bo - 2 = 4r,/3
for all Reynolds numbers and anisotropies, since the limiting values of the two quantities are then related. Putting these various relations together, we obtain
he = 2 - (2 - h 0 ) / 1 + 4 ( h - h 0 ) / 3 ( h - 2), = 2 + 4(Ic11 - 2)/3(h - 21,
(5.19)
where $oo is the isotropic value of @o. The following forms were used by Zeman and Lumley (1978): t,hoe = 3.0(1 =
__
__
+ r/4) - 3ohi&~/r2e2 q2,
+0.97.
(5.20)
Distinction among these various forms will require more experiments on isotropic decay with heat flux and anisotropic decay with heat flux, followed by the same flows with mean velocity and temperature gradients. From the work done so far, it is certain that terms involving the mean gradients of temperature and velocity must be present in the equations, as well as the terms involving anisotropy. Note that we have a realizability requirement on the dissipation of temperature variance: if the temperature variance vanishes without the dissipation, V ,I must become infinite to force the dissipation to zero. However, this condition is satisfied.
Computational Modeling of Turbulent Flows
159
C. THETRANSPORT TERMS In the following section we will discuss the transport terms in the equations for the Reynolds stress and the heat flux. However, the transport terms in the dissipation equations d o not fit in the same picture, because it is not possible to write exact equations for the transport of dissipation, as it is for the transport of velocity and temperature variance, etc. Hence, we will discuss these terms here. We may again apply the somewhat tentative condition that as the dissipation and the velocity variance vanish, they should d o so in such a way that the left member of (5.9) is satisfied. When we wrote (5.9) we had in mind a homogeneous situation, but now the transport terms must also be included. Thus, we must require
+ 2p/p)uk],k = ($b(q?u,),k
=~[(qz
?(Ek),k
(5.21)
as the velocity variance and the dissipation vanish, where we have made use of the homogeneous approximation for the pressure transport (see Section VI). We may satisfy this requirement by replacing throughout in the expression for &k (see Section VI) ( w j ) , k
(5.22)
=wjE,k/M
42
which supposes that b,, remains finite as vanishes; if we then write where q2ukis the expression with the replacement (5.22), the condition (5.21)will be automatically satisfied. This also has the advantage of being independent of the value of n. For example, in the nonbuoyant case we obtain from (6.54)
mk = (3%/5?)&k,
m k
= -(+)(?/&)[3/(10 -(:)Eipu,/u,/q2
+ 4C,)][&,p(u,p + 2 W k w / ? ) -(
~ ~ , ~ p u p / q z ] . (5.23)
Exactly the same consideration can be applied to the transport of Ee. If we and Ee vanish together so that (e')n/Ee remains bounded, presume that then one should require
n(82u,),kEe= @(m),k. This may be satisfied by replacing in the expression for
(eUJj =eu,EB,i/2nZe,
(5.24)
6
= e'ze,j/nEe
(5.25)
and calling the resulting expression (p/rEe)EE. In the nonbuoyant case this results in ___ --= - (e'/~~)[j( 1 C ~ / ~ ) ] [ E ~ , ~ euj ( We u k / e z )- ( + ) ~ ~ . ~ e ~ ~ (5.26)
+
+
e~~/e~
John L Lamley
160 VI. Transport Terms
A. INTRODUC~ION In the equations for second-order quantities, in inhomogeneous flows transport terms appear which are of third order. For example, in the equafor the transport term is ),k; in the equation for it is tion (ui0uk),k. These represent the divergence of the flux of the quantity in question, produced by the fluctuating velocity. In many flows, these terms represent the principal source of energy, heat flux, etc.: for example, in the atmospheric surface layer driven primarily by surface heating, the erosion of the inversion base, and gradual thickening of the surface mixed layer, is due entirely to these terms. To close the equations for second-order quantities, we must somehow express these terms as functions of the second-order quantities. If we approach this problem from the point of view of invariant modeling (Lumley and Khajeh-Nouri, 1974), we would say that, in the nonbuoyant (ignoring the Reynolds case, u,ulu, must be a functional of B and number dependence). Since the third moment must vanish in the case of homogeneity, it must depend on gradients of the arguments of various orders. It is possible to write an expansion, supposing weak anisotropy and inhomogeneity; to first order this gives:
(w
w,
q,
where a and b are unknown constants. This is clearly unsatisfactory,since it makes no distinction among the components. To second order, six more constants are introduced. Each of the fluxes (say of temperature variance or heat flux) will contain as many more undetermined constants. From a practical point of view, there are not enough well-documented experiments to unambiguously determine all these constants. In addition, it is not clear that second order is high enough. We have already seen, in connection with realizability, that it is not generally sufficient to consider anisotropy small in any sense. What is needed is a physical model which will produce a form for the fluxes, consistent with our general form, but with all the constants determined. Classically (see, e.g., Tennekes and Lumley, 1972) a simple mixing length or gradient transport argument was used in a simple shear: (q2/2 + P/p)O
- vT a(?/2)/ay
(6.2) with no attempt made to consider tensor properties. The eddy viscosity used is the same as that obtained (not unambiguously) from the ratio =
Computational Modeling of Turbulent Flows
161
-iiB/(dU/dy). This type of model is currently used in invariant form (Lewellen, 1975):
6= -c(F),jqEjqz/E,
(6.31
where the constant still must be determined from comparison of predictions with some class of experiments. The ?/E may be replaced by some other scalar combination of the correct dimensions, depending on the author’s preferences. With regard to uiuiu,,it was recognized early on (Hanjalic and Launder, 1972) that there was no justification for writing -
- ( ~ ) , ~ q 2 / ~
uiujuk
(6.4)
since the three velocities have equal standing and should be treated equally. Hence, we should write something like uiujuk
(mu,),* +
-(T/c)[(wj),lm +
(vk),m]. (6.5)
The constant of proportionality was optimized by Launder e f al. (1975) at 0.055. Many authors find this forbiddingly complicated, particularly in more complex flows. Since there is not much theoretical justification for it, and since the constant still must be determined from experiment, many prefer to use a simpler form such as (6.4). For example, Daly and Harlow (1970) use (6.4); Launder (1975) recommends a value of the coefficient of 0.125. Hanjalic and Launder (1972) tried to provide justification for the form (6.5). If the equation for ~ i ~ isj written, ~ k it consists of the substantial derivative; production terms of the form U i , , , T and its permutations; and its permutations; dissipressure gradient terms of the form - p . i / u , l p pation terms of the form - vui,,,uj,,, uk - vui,,,uj uk,,, and its permutations; and finally, on the left-hand side a collection of terms of the form:
(m),, -
-
wj(mU, ),l wk(m),I u j ( q I ) , I -
(6.6)
Hanjalic and Launder (1972) suggested the following set of assumptions: neglect all substantial derivatives, production, and dissipation terms; since any rapid terms arising from the pressure gradient correlations will be of the same form as the production terms, neglect them also; replace the pressure gradient correlation with a relaxation term proportional to -
- ui ujuk q2/c
(6.7)
with an undetermined coefficient; in the expression (6.6) introduce a quasiGaussian assumption (Lumley, 1970a): ___. -- -~~
UiUjUkUl
= uiujukul
+
uiukujul
+ ujukuiul.
This collection of assumptions leads to the form (6.5).
(6.8 1
162
John L Lumley
The same set of assumptions was applied to the buoyant case by Zeman and Lumley (1976) with excellent results. Forms for the fluxes were produced which can be identified with definite physical mechanisms (Lumley et al., 1978). The relative success of this technique suggests that the assumptions may be justifiable in some way; that is, there may be some single guiding principle from which they all follow naturally. We can ask a number of questions and make several comments which may help to shed light on this: homogeneous turbulence is observed to be Gaussian in the energy containing range (Frenkiel and Klebanoff 1967a,b) even in the presence of nonzero velocity gradients (Marechal, 1972); departure from Gaussian behavior, therefore, is associated with inhomogeneity (which is clear because nonzero values o f i p j i i k are non-Gaussian and are fluxes); hence, (6.8) is presumably correct only in a homogeneous situation and should carry a correction for inhomogeneity; it would be possible to justify neglecting fourth cumulants (recall that all cumulants of second order or higher vanish for a Gaussian) in an equation for third cumulants if cumulants of successive orders had relaxation times which were successively shorter; if inhomogeneity is responsible for nonzero third moments, a term like U i , , , m is of order &/El relative to (6.7), and if this quantity is small, we could justify neglecting these terms (we have taken Ui,,,to be of order u/l where u and 1 are the scales of the energy containing eddies); finally, how d o we know that (6.7) is the right form? Other linear combinations of third moments are equally attractive. It seems clear that what is needed is a model of turbulence that will relax to Gaussian behavior in the absence of inhomogeneity, successive cumulants relaxing faster, and from the equation for the density (or equivalent quantity) equations for the moments may be obtained. The model must be constructed in such a way that our second moment equations are reproduced unchanged, and the third moment equations are reproduced with as few changes as possible; that is, there are presumably constraints on possible forms, consistent with all moments being derivable from a single density which will relax to a Gaussian distribution in the absence of inhomogeneity. This is a type of realizability although somewhat more subtle. B. A GAUSSIAN MODEL In order to examine these possibilities further, it is simpler to work at first with a passive scalar quantity; the added complexity of a vector quantity such as ui is a nuisance. Consider a quantity 8:
B + eViui + oSiui+ e,iui- 6=
(6.9)
Computational Modeling of Turbulent Flows
163
Since both 8 and ui appear in this equation, we will have to generate an equation equivalent to that for the joint density of 8 and ui. It is convenient to work in terms of the moment generating function, since its derivatives at the origin are the cumulants and it is quadratic for a Gaussian distribution: F = In If the equation for ui iri
G,
G = exp[ik,u, + i ~ ] .
+ ui,juj+ ui,,uj+ ui,juj -a= - p , , / p + pie + vui,jj
(6.10) (6.11)
is multiplied by iki that for 8 is multiplied by il, the two are added, and if the resulting equation is multiplied through by G, averaged and the resulting equation divided by G, we obtain (with a little rearrangement)
F
+ aF/aXj uj + (ik, U,,, + ilO,,) aF/aik, - ik,& aF/ail
+ a2F/axj aik, + (aF/axj)(aF/aikj)- (u,In G),, ~= -ik,p,,G/pG + vik,Gu,,/G + yilG8,jj/G. -
-
--
(6.12)
We have used the fact that G-I
a2G/axjdikj = a2F/axj aik, + (dF/axj)(aF/aikj)
(6.13)
from the definition. Now, the terms on the right-hand side of (6.12) may be rearranged in suggestive forms, and physically appealing assumptions may be made directly regarding the terms. However, one has relatively little feeling for the moment generating function and how it may interact with other quantities. It is more productive to adopt the position that we know what equation we wish to obtain for second order (specifically, the terms on the right of (6.12) must give rise to the rapid terms, the return to isotropy, the pressure transport, and the dissipation) and select for the right-hand side of (6.12) the simplest form that will (a) relax to Gaussian in the absence of inhomogeneity, and (b) will produce the correct second-order terms. Let us consider a joint Gaussian distribution. The moment generating function is given by:
F = - & [ k i k j m + 2 k i l d + l2P].
(6.14)
Let us consider only the return to isotropy terms and the dissipation terms; we will deal with the rapid and pressure transport terms later. Using the simplest forms, we have (with C1 and C, as defined by Zeman and Lumley, 1978) u:u. 1 1 + ... = -C1(E/&(iZpj - 6,,7/3) - 6,,2-?/3, ui +
$+
* a *
=
- Ce(E/z)Q,
*.. = -2$.
(6.15)
John L Lumley
164
The ellipses indicate the omitted terms: production, transport, pressure transport, rapid, etc. We can form the time derivative of F :
p = ... = -i{ki k j [ - Cl(C/z)(ii& - Sij?/3) - 6i,Z/3]
+ 2ki I[ - C , ( E / ~ ) Q +] lz[-2(G/?P)F]},
(6.16)
where the ellipses indicate the other terms omitted on the left side of (6.21)as well as those arising from the rapid and pressure transport terms. Now, in a Gaussian distribution iipq = a2F/aikidikj = F,ij, -
uie = a2F/aikiail = F,il,
(6.17)
-
e2 = a2F/aii ail = F , ~ ~ ,
and we propose as the simplest possible generalization of (6.16)
p + ...= - f { k i
k j [ - ~1 ( E / Z M F , i j
- dij ~ , p p / 3 ) S i j ~ . p p W @ I
+ 2ki I[ - C,j(E/z)F,iJ+ 12[ -2(F,j/P)F,11]}-
(6.18)
In the absence of inhomogeneity, buoyancy, and mean gradients, the terms not shown explicitly in (6.18)vanish. The equation then has solutions other than Gaussian, but which all relax to Gaussian. This is easiest to see in the scalar case, setting k = 0. Then
p = 12 ( E- e /7e
)F,ii*
(6.19)
Indicating the nth cumulant by C,, we have (differentiating n times with respect to i l ) (6.20) C, = -n(n - I)(C,j/eT)C,. If we normalize by Cyz, designating P, = C,/C;'2, we have P, = - n(n - ~)(E,/P)P,.
(6.21)
Hence, all normalized cumulants above the second decay to zero, no matter what the initial values, leaving a Gaussian distribution. The choice of right-hand side in (6.18)is not as arbitrary as it seems. To second order, the - lz?P in (6.16)can be replaced only by - 12F,11,ilFv1,or 2F. The second does not converge to Gaussian, producing constant P,; the third diverges, the coefficient in (6.21)being positive. Hence, the only further generalization would be the inclusion of third and higher derivatives. Equation (6.18)appears to be adequate, however, since it produces terms at third order which are also obtained by simple physical reasoning. For example, in the equation for e", the dissipation term may be written as -
e3/3
-~
+ -.. = y e z e , j j = y ( e 2 e , j ) , , - 2ye,je,je 1:
-22z -2(~,j/?P)8"
(6.22)
Computational Modeling of Turbulent Flows
165
(Zeman and Lumley 1976), where we have used the usual high-Reynolds number approximation, and the idea that fluctuations of O2 and of Eg should be well correlated, so that regions of high O2 dissipate most of it locally. From (6.18) we have (6.23)
which is the same as (6.22). The same is true of the dissipation terms produced at third order from the mechanical part of (6.18Fthey are identical with those obtained from physical reasoning [like that leading to (6.2211.
C. ORDEROF MAGNITUDE ANALYSIS Let us consider now the full equation for the nth cumulant of 8. This equation contains no terms arising from pressure transport or rapid terms, or buoyancy, so that we may obtain it directly from (6.12), using (6.18) as a right-hand side. Cumulants involving velocity also appear, and we will need a designation for them; let us say C . for the cumulant involving 8 n times - 38 uj8. We will consider n greater than 2, and uj once. That is, C3j = so that the last term on the left-hand side of (6.12), being linear in the independent variables, will not contribute. We obtain
& Y-
(6.24)
We wish now to carry out an order of magnitude analysis on this equation, in the case of weak inhomogeneity,in an attempt to identify the more important terms. Let us designate by 8 and u the rms values of 8 and ui, respectively. We will write C , = One,,
Cnj= Pue,,
(6.25)
and we will make the assumption that enj= O(en+l).That is, we presume that since both variables share a distribution they will approach Gaussian together. To fix ideas, let us assume that we are in a nearly parallel, weakly inhomogeneous, steady, two-dimensional flow such as a late wake. Then, from the wake scaling relations, if L and 1 are, respectively, the downstream and cross-stream length scales, U1/L= O(u/l) (Tennekes and Lumley, 1972, p. 109). We also have @ , j = 0(8/l).Such terms as CnjSj are dominated by the
John L..hmley
166
cross-stream gradients, and are hence of order Cnj/l.The orders of magnitude become
c , ,uj: ~ endnull= n(n - l)(Eg/P)dnen[uP/GIn(n- I)], nO,jCn-lj:ne,Pu/I = n(n - l)(Eg/P)Pen[uF/coIn(n- I)],
c , , ~en+ , ~pull : = n(n - l)(G/eZ)Pen[(en+l/en)uP/EgIn(n- 111,
n(n - l)(Eg/@)Cn:n(n
-
l)&/e’)Pe, = n(n - l)(~/@)O”en[l]. (6.26)
Let us designate by 4 = up/&.Of course, in a real wake, or in any naturally occurring turbulent flow, q = O(1). However, we must consider an artificial situation, in which q is small compared to unity, a weakly inhomogeneous situation which could be produced in the laboratory. As q goes to zero, some term in (6.26)must balance the last term. Clearly the first two cannot, since they both vanish. The third is a possibility; this would give qen+l/enn(n - 1) = O(1)
(6.27)
but this would give e3 = O(2/q), e4 = O(12/q2),etc. Here we have used the fact that ez = 1 by definition. Hence, as q goes to zero, all normalized cumulants go to infinity. This is clearly contrary to observation since (as we have already commented) homogeneous turbulence is observed to be Gaussian. The only other possibility is that the quadratic terms balance the last term. Thus, for example, qezen- l/en = O(1)
(6.28)
(ignoring for a moment the various factors of n). This gives en = O(qe,- 1) (again using e2 = 1) and e3 = O(q)so that all normalized cumulants vanish as they ought to, and higher orders vanish faster than the lower orders do. All these terms are of the same order, the general term being given by qek en- k + 1 /en*
(6.29)
Computational Modeling of Turbulent Flows
167
If (6.28) holds, en = O(q'-2), (6.29) is also of order 1 . Hence, the entire collection of quadratic terms must be of order unity. Since there are n - 2 of them, each must be approximately of order ( n - 2 ) - :
'
(J
qe,e,-,+,/e,n(n - 1 ) = O(n - 2 ) - ' .
(6.30)
e, = O(k!(q/2)k-2),
(6.31 )
If
+
then the left-hand side of (6.30)is given by 2(n - k l)/n(n- 1). If we sum this from 2 to n - 1, we have 1 - 2/n(n - I ) , which approaches unity for large n. Hence, (6.31)must be approximately true for large k. Note that (6.31)does not imply that ek+ /ek+ 0 as k + 00 for fixed q, but rather that e,, /ek 0 for fixed k as q + 0. In fact, ek/ek- = kq/2; by picking a small enough q, we can make this ratio as small as we like for the first few cumulants; eventually, however, for k > 2/q, the cumulants will begin to increase. This is to say that the distribution can be made to look Gaussian in as large a neighborhood of the origin as we like, but that far enough out in the tails it will never look Gaussian. This is not a problem, however, since our concern was simply to be able to neglect fourth cumulants in the equation for third cumulants, and this is justified if q is small enough. Using (6.31),the third term becomes --+
qen+ 1 /enn(n - 1 ) = (q2/2)(n+ l)/n(n- 1 )
(6.32)
so that this is a second-order term in q. Hence, to the zeroth order we can write
(4)
C,,jC,-
,j
+ ... +
in
C,- I,jClj= - n(n - l)(Eo/p)Cn.
(6.33)
The neglect of the second-order term (6.32)corresponds to neglecting cumulants of order n + 1 in the equation for cumulants of order n. The neglect of the first-order term corresponds to the neglect of the substantial derivative and the production terms. Note that, in the case of cumulants involving velocity, which can be handled in exactly the same way, the rapid velocity gradient terms are of the same form as the production terms, and hence will also be of first order. We will deal separately with the problem of the buoyant terms, which requires special treatment. Thus, to zerdh order we have
__
30: Buj = - 6(%/8')8"
(6.34)
John L Lumley
168
and 6 E K j + 4e3eUj = - 12(G/e’)(F
- 3822).
(6.35)
Equation (6.34) is the standard mixing length approximation; if we took
o2 a - q u , ( i P / ~ J
(6.36)
we would obtain (6.34) on multiplying by 0, but with an unknown coefficient. Equation (6.34) involves the neglect of the fourth cumulant. To first order in (6.34), we should keep the substantial derivative and production terms (presuming that the time derivative is of the same order as the advective term):
8 + q U j + 30,,-
+ 3cBuj= -6(FB/ p”)e .
(6.37)
To second order we should include a zeroth-order approximation for the neglected term C,,,,; this order approximation for C,, will presumably be of the form (6.35), but we must derive it explicitly, since there may be other complications. Deardorff (1978) has pointed out that, if an equation such as (6.37) is carried for the third-order quantities, then diffusion terms (which will be provided by C , , , ) are essential to stabilize the solutions and prevent the development of spurious peaks. It should be noted that when we made our assumption (6.18), we were essentially neglecting derivatives of order 3 and higher, which we now see will be of first order in q. Thus, while (6.34) and (6.35) are consistent approximations, it is possible that (6.37) neglects terms of the order of those retained. TRANSPORT D. THEPRESSURE We must now turn to consideration of cumulants involving velocity, dealing first with the nonbuoyant case. The rapid terms, as already noted, will cause no difficulty, since they are of the same form as the production terms. The only problem is pressure transport. Traditionally, p,ij is split into a deviatoric part and an isotropic part, which is a transport term (though the split is not unambiguous: Lumley, 1975b). There appears to be no reason to split m k in a similar manner, particularly since it leaves as remainder Pi,ik + which one might expect to be poorly correlated (although one has little intuition for such correlations; in fact ui,,is evidently well correlated with p , and perhaps the two have a common large-scale part which is well correlated with uk). On the other hand, the entire pressure gradient correlation in the second-order equation consists of the rapid and
m,
Computational Modeling of Turbulent Flows
169
the return-to-isotropy parts and the pressure transport; if the pressure gradient terms in higher order equations are obtained from an equation such as (6.18), all must be present, their combination representing the entire term; the term obtained by generalizing the return-to-isotropy part alone being only a piece of the total. The pressure term in Eq. (6.12) may be written as - -
~-
+
-ikip,,G/pG = -iki(pG),i/pG i k i z / p c . The second term on the right may be rewritten as - -
- -
-kikjpui3jG/pG- kilpO,iG/pG
(6.38) (6.39)
-
which is of the form of (6.18). In the equation for ui uj , this produces P(uj,i + ui.j)/P while the first term on the right of (6.38) gives
(6.4)
Thus, the separation (6.38) represents the traditional separation into pressure transport and pressure-strain correlation. Since we are carrying to higher orders the generalization of the second term on the right of (6.38) (from Eq. (6.18)), we must also carry to higher orders the generalization of the first term on the right, so that we will have the entire term. Beginning from Eq. (4.3) in a homogeneous flow we may write
- [p'2']/p = ( K i K j / K 2 ) [ U i U j ] .
(6.42)
Multiplying by [uk]* and averaging and integrating, we obtain (6.43) where Sijk is the spectrum of w k . Although it proved to be dangerous with regard to realizability in Section IV, we will attempt here to express the integral as a linear combination of this triple correlation. If we define
we have the following conditions: Iijpqr = Zjipqr; Iijpqr = Iijqpr; Iijpqj =0; IiiPq = the last but one resulting from incompressibility.Realizability only requires that the term vanish if uk vanishes. The most general linear k contains five coefficients. The application of these conditions form in w determines all the coefficients, resulting in the form :
w,, Iijpqr
= ( f ) G i j u p u q u , - (&)(GirJqq&
+
Gj,ii&&).
(6.45)
John L Lamley
170 Finally, we obtain Iijijr
=
, = (314 1 ur/P - P(2
ur2
(6.46)
and since this does vanish if ur vanishes, it satisfies realizability. Just as our viscous terms-could be obtained through third order by generally replacing E by q2c/q2, the form of (6.46) suggests replacing everywhere (6.47) -PIP = (4*- ?)/5 so that the first term on the right-hand side of (6.38) becomes
- ?)I, (6.48) and this term could be added to the right-hand side of the equation for F. (+)iki[(a/axi
+aF/axi)(F,pp + ~
, p ~ , p
This cannot be correct for all orders, however, since for fifth order and above the cubic term in (6.48)introduces terms of lower degree in q than those we have kept, that is, terms of order q-'. This seems unlikely to be true and suggests that there is more wrong with (6.48) than meets the eye. In fact, there is the same ambiguity regarding the correct form as there was relative to the right-hand side of (6.18). We know the form we wish to produce at second order, (6.46), but several possible general expressions will produce this form. In particular, we could eliminate from (6.48) any term which does not contribute to second order, such as the troublesome cubic term; this could be done by eliminating either the second term in the first parenthesis of (6.48), or the second term in the second, or both. The1 first possibility leaves quadratic terms which contribute to third-order cumulants to zeroth order; computation with these forms shows that the contributions from the pressure terms very much over-correct, leading to negative diffusivities. Hence, we must discard this alternative. The second and third possibilities give no zeroth-order contributions to third-order quantities, but the second will produce zeroth-order contributions to fourth-order quantities. This seems unlikely, and lacking better information we select simply (f)iki(a/aXi)(F,pp
- q2).
(6.49)
Note, incidentally, that the inclusion of this expression produces in the equation for the heat flux a term of the form
-( e p ) , k / P = ( 8 q z ) , k / 5
(6.50)
(see Eqs. (3.6) and (3.7)). This term does satisfy realizability as required. E. ZEROTH-ORDER TRANSPORT TERMS We may now proceed to consider the equation for cumulants including velocity. Let us take first C , j , since it appears in the equation for the temper-
Computational Modeling of Turbulent Flows
171
ature skewness. We know from our discussion above that we may ignore substantial derivatives, production and rapid terms, and higher order cumulants, since our reasoning is equally applicable to equations for cumulants involving velocity. Expression (6.49) may be neglected like the third term in (6.26). Using the notation c,jk for the cumulant involving uj, uk, and temperature n times, we obtain for C,,
qG + 3 ( G ) , k G + 330% + 3(G),k82U, =
+ C & / ? ) ( P / G ) ] ( G - 3eZeUj).
-3@,/F)[1
(6.51)
We have neglected C 3 p pIf. this were inserted in Eq. (6.37), we would have the diffusion terms which stability requires. DifferentiatReturning now to third-order quantities, let us consider ing, we obtain to zeroth order
6.
This is close to the form assumed by previous authors, but here we have a definite value for the coefficient. The zeroth-order approximation for Bui uj is (8ui),kvj
=
Finally, for m
+
+
(%j),k%&
(mj),kak
-[c1(@)(G - 428dij/3) + (2E/3z)fiSij _+ 2c&//q2)8ui~j]. k
(6.53)
we obtain
(uij),pulrup + (u,u,),puiup + (uju,)*puiu, =
-3Cl(E/?)[wk
- ($)(dijfi
- (2E/32)(dij&
+
dikfi
+
+ 6ikfi + djkfi)] djkfi).
(6.54)
Note that if i f j # k # i, then the right-hand side of (6.54) reduces to the form (6.5), but with an explicit coefficient. However, the coefficients are quite different in the different directions. F. MODIFICATIONS In deriving Eqs. (6.15) and the following, we used very simple return-toisotropy forms. If we wish to be more elegant and make use of the material in Section 111, we must consider what is the proper generalization of Eq. (6.18).
172
John L Lumley
In fact, there are many generalizations possible; probably the most convenient is to replace Cl by fi and Ce by &,, leaving the arguments of these functions unchanged; then, when the differentiations are carried out with respect to iki, etc., these quantities act just like C1 and C,, so that the expressions we have derived (6.51)-(6.54) will remain unchanged, except for the simple substitution. The next level of complexity, the substitution of expressions (6.17) in the arguments of /3 and 6fj,would result in the appearance of additional terms in (6.51)-(6.54) corresponding to the differentiation of these coefficients with respect to iki,etc. The additional complexity does not appear to be worth the effort, unless it proves to be necessary. That is, suppose that on computation the coefficients in (6.51)-(6.54)prove to be too large or small; they could be modified by including these terms and adjusted by adjusting the dependency of the coefficients in the Reynolds stress and heat flux equations. We must now consider the effect of buoyancy. If the equation for Cnjis written, a term of the form flj C,, appears on the ri t-hand side. Relative to the return to isotropy term, this term is of order POq /z&n(n - 1). We must make a decision relative to the magnitude of this quantity. One possibility is to say that the influence of buoyancy is weak, that is, the turbulence is primarily shear produced, and the buoyant influence is secondary. PO?/@ is jOlt/u2 where It is a turbulent integral length scale; in supposing this small we are s'aying that the buoyant acceleration PO is small relative to the turbulent acceleration u2/lt. If it is of order q, we can neglect it and the associated rapid terms just like the mean velocity gradient terms. On the other hand, if we are considering a flow that is produced by buoyancy, we must have jOlt/u2 = O(1) (Tennekes and Lumley, 1972, Section 4.6). The buoyancy terms will then be of the same order as the return to isotropy terms, and must be kept to zeroth order, that is, in the expressions (6.51)-(6.54). This, of course, increases the complexity considerably, since the rapid terms in buoyancy must also be kept. These rapid terms may be obtained by the substitution of the expressions (6.17) in the various rapid terms (see Section IV) followed by appropriate differentiation. A simplified version of this gives excellent predictions of the evolution of the buoyancydriven atmospheric surface mixed layer (Zeman and Lumley, 1976, 1978). In the order of magnitude analysis which we carried out on Eq. (6.24), other choices are possible, corresponding to other physical situations. For example, if we had said that &,/eZ = u/l, which is realistic, but that C,j,j = O(Cnj/L),while U i , j= O(u/l)and a,, = O(O/l),which would correspond to a near-equilibrium situation of a turbulence maintained by almost uniform gradients, with weak inhomogeneity, then our small parameter becomes 1/L and the order of magnitude analysis remains the same with the exception of the terms involving the mean velocity and mean temperature
e
Computational Modeling of Turbulent Flows
173
gradients, which become of order one; thus we would have to keep the mean velocity and mean temperature gradient terms, as well as the rapid terms in the mean velocity and mean temperature gradients in the expressions (6.51)-(6.54). Each situation should be considered on its merits. For example, at the inversion base over the atmospheric surface mixed layer, both mean velocity and mean temperature gradients are strong, while the turbulence has been produced primarily by buoyancy. In this situation we may expect that it will be necessary to keep both the buoyancy terms and the terms in the mean gradients in the expressions (6.51)-(6.54). An approximate form of this, keeping the buoyancy terms and the mean temperature gradients, has been worked out in Lumley et al. (1978). Finally, a word of caution is in order. Some situations are not in any sense almost Gaussian. The temperature fluctuations in a heated wake are a case in point. In the intermittent region, the probability density for the temperature fluctuations will have a spike, corresponding to the free-stream temperature, lower than the-local mean (Antonia and Sreenivasan, 1977). This will be combined with an almost Gaussian distribution corresponding to the temperature fluctuations in the turbulent portion of the wake with the average offset to higher temperatures. As one moves toward the axis of the wake, the magnitude of the spike decreases, but never completely disappears, even on the axis, since there is still a small but finite probability of finding oneself in a tongue of nonturbulent fluid engulfed by the wake. This combined density cannot be approximated in any sense by expansions about the Gaussian state. The part of the density corresponding to the fluctuations within the turbulent fluid probably can; the spike, however, must be treated separately. Moments of any order can be written explicitly as moments of the continuous distribution plus terms involving the displacement of the spike from the mean of the continuous distribution and the intermittency (the time spent in the turbulent fluid). A rational approach probably would involve dealing separately with the two parts, using our technique for the continuous part and handling the spike explicitly (Libby, 1975). These considerations apply to any intermittent situation, such as the edge of a wake or jet or boundary layer, the entrainment region at the inversion base in the atmospheric surface rnixed layer, etc. They apply, in addition, to the modeling of chemical reactions. Initially, the reactants are not mixed on a molecular level but may be macroscopically mixed. The density will consist of two spikes, if we imagine reactants such as acid and base that can be identified on a single numerical scale. As the reaction progresses, the spikes will disappear, and a continuous distribution of reactant will appear. Again, we may be able to apply our ideas to the continuous part, but the spikes should be dealt with separately.
174
John L Lumley REFERENCES
ALEXOPOULOS, C. C., and KEFFER, J. F. (1971). Turbulent wake in a passively stratified field. Phys. Fluids 14, 216224. ANMNIA, R. A., and SREENIVASAN, K. R. (1977). Conditional probability densities in a turbulent heated round jet. Australas. Hydraul. Fluid Mech. Con$, 6th, Inst. Eng. Aust. Nat. Conf. Publ. NO. 77/12, pp. 411-414. BATCHELOR, G. K. (1956). “The Theory of Homogeneous Turbulence.” Cambridge Univ. Press, London and New York. BATCHELOR, G. K.,and PROUDMAN, R. 1. (1954). The effect of rapid distortion of a fluid in turbulent motion. Q.J. Mech. Appl. Math. 7, 83-103. CHOU,P.-Y. (1945a). On velocity correlation and the solution of the equation of turbulent fluctuation. Q. Appl. Math. 3, 38-54. CHOU,P.-Y. (1945b). Pressure flow of a turbulent fluid between parallel planes. Q. Appl. Math. 3, 198-209. CHOU,P.-Y. (1947). Turbulent flow along a semi-infinite plane. Q. Appl. Math. 5, 346-353. COLEMAN, B. D., and NOLL,W.(1961). Recent results in the continuum theory of viscoelastic fluids. Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci. 89,672-714. G., and CORRSIN, S. (1966). The use of a contraction to improve the isotropy of COMTE-BELLOT, grid-generated turbulence. J. Fluid Mech. 25, 657-682. CORRSIN, S. (1951). The decay of isotropic temperature fluctuations in an isotropic turbulence. J . Aeronaut. Sci. 18, 417-423. CROW,S. C. (1968). The viscoelastic properties of he-grained incompressible turbulence. J. Fluid Mech. 33, 1-200. DALY,B. J., and HARLOW, F. H. (1970). Transport equations in turbulence. Phys. Fluids 13, 2634-2649. DAVIDOV, B. I. (1958). Phenomenological equation of statistical dynamics of an incompressible turbulent fluid. Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 35, 527-529. DAVIDOV, B. I. (1959a). Statistical dynamics of an incompressible turbulent fluid. Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR 127, 768-771. DAVIDOV, B. I. (1959b). Statistical theory of turbulence. Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR 127,98&982. DAVWV,B. I. (1961). Statistical dynamics of an incompressible turbulent fluid. Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR 136,47-50. DEARDORFF, J. W.(1978). Closure of second- and third-moment rate equations for diffusion in homogeneous turbulence. Phys. Fluids 21, 525-530. F.N., and KLEBANOFF, P. S. (1967a). Higher order correlations in a turbulent field. FRENKIEL, Phys. Fluids 10, 507-520. FRENKIEL, F. N., and KLEBANOFF, P. S. (1967b).Correlation measurements in a turbulent flow using high speed computing methods. Phys. Fluids 10, 1737-1747. GENCE,J. N. (1977). Turbulence homogdne associee A des effets de gravite. Thdse, Docteur Ingenieur, Universite Claude Bernard, Lyon. K.,and LAUNDER, B. E. (1972). A Reynolds stress model of turbulence and its HANJALIC, application to thin shear flows. J . Fluid Mech. 52, 609638. KLME,S. J., MORKOVIN, M.J., SOVRAN, G., and COCKRELL, J. J. (4s.) (1969) Proc. Cornput. Turbulent Boundary Layers-1 968 AFOSR-IFP-Stanford. Thermosci. Div., Stanford University, Stanford, California. A. N. (1941). Local structure of turbulence in an incompressible fluid at very KOLMOOOROV, high Reynolds numbers. Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR 30,299-303. KOLMOOOROV, A. N. (1942) Equation of turbulent motion of an incompressiblefluid. Izu. Akad. Nauk SSSR, Ser. Fiz. 6, 56-58.
Computational Modeling of Turbulent Flows
175
LAUNDER, B. E. (1975). Progress in the modeling of turbulent transport. In “Lecture Series 76: Prediction Methods for Turbulent Flows.” von Karman Inst. Fluid Dyn., Rhode-St.Genese, Belgium. LAUNDER, B. E., REECE,G. J., and RODI, W. (1975). Progress in the development of a Reynolds stress turbulent closure. J. Fluid Mech. 68, 537-566. LESLIE,D. C. (1973).“Developments in the Theory of Turbulence.” Oxford Univ. Press, London and New York. LEWELLEN, W. S. (1975). “Use of Invariant Modeling,” ARAP Rep. No. 243. Princeton, New Jersey. LIBBY,P. A. (1975). On the prediction of intermittent turbulent flows. J. Fluid Mech. 68, 273-295. LUMLEY, J. L. (1967). The applicability of turbulence research to the solution of internal flow problems. In “Fluid Mechanics of Internal Flow” (G. Sovran, ed.), pp. 152-169. Elsevier, Amsterdam. LUMLEY, J. L. (1970a). “Stochastic Tools in Turbulence.” Academic Press, New York. LUMLEY, J. L. (1970b). Toward a turbulent constitutive relation. J. Fluid Mech. 41, 413-434. LUMLEY, J. L. (1972). Some comments on the energy method. In “Developments in Mechanics” (L. H. N. Lee and A. H. Szewczyk, eds.), Vol. 6, pp. 63-88. Notre Dame University Press, Notre Dame, Indiana. LUMLEY, J. L. (1975a). Introduction. In “Lecture Series 76: Prediction Methods for Turbulent Flows.” von Karman Inst. Fluid Dyn., Rhode-St.-Genese, Belgium. LUMLEY, J. L. (1975b). Pressure strain correlation. Phys. Fluids 18, 750. LUMLEY, J. L., and KHAJEH-NOURI, B. (1974).Computational modeling of turbulent transport. Adv. Geophys. 18, 169. LUMLEY, J. L., and NEWMAN, G. R. (1977). The return to isotropy of homogeneous turbulence. J. Fluid Mech. 82, 161-178. H. A. (1964). “The structure of Atmospheric Turbulence” (R. E. LUMLEY, J. L., and PANOFSKY, Marshak, ed.), Interscience Monographs and Texts in Physics and Astronomy, Vol. 12. Wiley (Interscience), New York. O., and SIES, J. (1978). The influence of buoyancy on turbulent transLUMLEY, J. L., ZEMAN, port. J. Fluid Mech. 84, 581-597. MARBCHAL,J. (1972). Etude experimentale de la deformation plane d’une turbulence homogene. J. Mec. 11, 263-294. MONIN,A. S., and YAGLOM, A. M. (1971).“Statistical Fluid Mechanics” (J. L. Lumley, ed.), Vol. 1. MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts. A. M. (1975).“Statistical Fluid Mechanics” (J. L. Lumley, ed.), Vol. MONIN,A. S., and YAGLOM, 2. MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts. J. (1978). Second order modeling and statistical theory modelNEWMAN, G. R., and HERRING, ing of a homogeneous turbulence. J. Fluid Mech. (to be submitted). NEWMAN, G. R., LAUNDER, B., and LUMLEY, J. L. (1978a). Modeling the behavior of homogeneous scalar turbulence. J. Fluid Mech. (to be submitted). NEWMAN, G. R., WARHAFT, Z., and LUMLEY, J. L. (1978b). The decay of heat flux in gridgenerated turbulence. J. Fluid Mech. (to be submitted). G. S. (1972). Numerical simulation of turbulence. In “Statistical ORSZAG,S. A., and PAITERSON, Models and Turbulence,” Lecture Notes in Physics, Vol. 12, pp. 127-147. Springer-Verlag, Berlin and New York. POPE,S. B. (1974). A more general eNective viscosity hypothesis. J . Fluid Mech. 72, 331-340. POPE,S. B. (1977). “An Explanation of the Turbulent Round Jet/Plane Jet Anomaly,” Rep. No. FS/77/12. Imperial College, London. REYNOLDS,W.C. (1976). Computation of turbulent flows. Annu. Reo. Fluid Mech. 8, 183-208.
176
John L Lamley
ROITA,J. C. (1951a). Statistische Theorie Nichthomogener Turbulenz. 1.2. Phys. 129,547-572. ROITA, J. C. (1951b). Statistiche Theorie Nichthomogener Turbulenz. 2. 2.Phys. 132, 51-77. U. (1977). Realizability of Reynolds stress turbulence models. Phys. Fluids 20, SCHUMANN, 721-725. SPALDING,D. B. (1971). Concentration fluctuations in a round turbulent free jet. Chem. Eng. Sci. 26, 95-107. SPENCER, A. J. M., and RIVLIN,R. S. (1959). The theory of matrix polynomials and its application to the mechanics of isotropic continua. Arch. Ration. Mech. Anal. 2, 309-336. SPENCER, A. J. M., and RIVLIN,R. S.(1960). Further results in the theory of matrix polynomials. Arch. Ration. Mech. Anal. 4, 214-230. TENNEKES, H., and LUMLEY,J. L. (1972). “A First Course in Turbulence.” MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts. TOWNSEND, A. A. (1970). Entrainment and the structure of turbulent flow. J. Fluid Mech. 41, 13-46. VAN DYKE,M. (1964). “Perturbation Methods in Fluid Mechanics.” Academic Press, New York. J. L. (1978a).The decay of temperature fluctuations and heat flux in WARHAFT, Z., and LUMLEY, grid-generated turbulence. In “Lecture Notes in Physics,” Vol. 76, pp. 113-123. SpringerVerlag, Berlin and New York. J. L. (1978b). An experimental study of the decay of temperature WARHAFT, Z., and LUMLEY, fluctuations in grid-generated turbulence. J. Fluid Mech. 88,659-684. WYNGAARD, J. C. (1975). Modeling the planetary boundary layer-extension to the stable case. Boundary-Layer Meteorol. 9, 441-460. ZEMAN, 0.. and LUMLEY, J. L. (1976). Modeling buoyancy driven mixed layers. J. A m o s . Sci. 33, 1974-1988. O., and LUMLEY, J. L. (1978).Buoyancy effects in entraining turbulent boundary layers. ZEMAN, A second order closure study. In “Lecture Notes in Physics.” Springer-Verlag, Berlin and New York. To be published.
ADVANCES IN APPLIED MECHANICS. VOLUME
18
Unsteady Separation According to the Boundary-Layer Equation SHAN-FU SHEN Sibley School of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering Cornell Uniuersity lthaca, New York
... . . .... .... ... .... .
177
11. Asymptotic Behavior of the Boundary-Layer Solution Away from the Wall A. The Steady Case . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. The Weakly Unsteady Case . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
I. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
182 182 185
111. Separation and the Concept of an Unmatchable Boundary Layer . . . . . A. The Case of Steady Separation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. The Case of Unsteady Separation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
186 187 189
........ . ......... ......... ......... V. The General Unsteady Boundary Layer , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Finite-Difference Schemes and Local Flow Reversal . . . . . . . . . . . B. The Numerical Example of Telionis, Tsahalis, and Werle . . . . . . . . C. Criterion for the Separation Singularity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI. Separation in Lagrangian Description . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
192 192 195 199
,
.
IV. The Semisimilar Boundary Layer . . . , , . . . . . . . . . . A. Definition and Results of Computation . . . . . . . . . . B. Reformulation of the Semisimilar Problem . . . . . . . C. Separation Criterion and the Goldstein Singularity . .
203 203 207 208 213
A. The Two-Dimensional Boundary-Layer Equation in Lagrangian
Coordinates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Genesis of the Separation Singularity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
214 215 218
I. Introduction It was Prandtl who founded the boundary-layer approximation and, at the same time, introduced the term “separation” to designate the phenomenon that the boundary layer would leave the body surface under certain circumstances. His physical argument was that as the pressure is essentially constant across the thin boundary layer, the slow-moving fluid particles near an immobile wall would eventually lose their forward momentum under 177
Copyright 0 1978 by Academic Press. Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form rmrved. ISBN 0-12-002018-1
178
Shun-Fu Shen
prolonged adverse pressure, and thus act as a barrier to force the flow away from the body surface. Separation in a steady boundary layer was then directly associated with flow reversal, which in turn implies vanishing shear at the wall. Observations seem to support that an adverse pressure gradient is indeed a prerequisite to separation. For the steady two-dimensional boundary-layer equation, a mathematical analysis with an adverse pressure gradient over fixed wall and in the vicinity of the point of flow reversal is contained in the classical paper of Goldstein (1948). It clearly shows that the solution develops a local singularity such that T,
a (x,
- x)’”,
where T, is the wall shear, x is the downstream distance, and x, marks the position of flow reversal along the wall. Furthermore, the displacement thickness tends to infinity as x + x, and no real solution is possible for x > x,. All numerical calculations have confirmed these features, and it has become a tradition to identify the point of vanishing wall shear as the “separation point.” A number of questions of course may be raised, and much recent activity can be found in two different directions. First, if the boundary-layer equation admits no continuation downstream of x,, what must be the different structure in the vicinity of x, such that the physical flow can be properly described? Second, if the wall is moving or the outside flow is unsteady, how does the boundary equation behave when actual separation, in the original Prandtl sense of the breaking away of the boundary layer from the wall, again takes place? The problem of the flow structure near the steady separation point, capable of getting around the Goldstein singularity and penetrating further downstream into the wake region, has attracted many investigators. Since the singularity is apparently forced to occur with a prescribed adverse pressure gradient, allowing for a pressure readjustment due to viscous-inviscid interaction near the separation point holds promise for its removal. In an inverse formulation Catherall and Mangler (1966) propose to prescribe the displacement thickness growth, and Horton (1974) chooses the alternative of specifying the wall-shear variation. By insisting on a “regular” separation, the prevailing pressure gradient can be determined as a consequence. The validity of the boundary-layer approximation up to and beyond the separation point is implied, however. The direct approach of unraveling the flow structure including the unknown pressure modification near the separation point requires a more refined boundary-layer theory. The way is paved after the important discovery of the triple-deck description near the trailing edge of a flat plate, due to Stewartson (1969) and also Messiter (1970). Applying the same technique to the case of the steady separation point, Stewartson (1970) concludes that if the upstream pressure gradient is indeed adverse, the
Boundary-Layer Equation
179
refined structure still is incapable of matching with an ordinary boundary layer downstream. In short, the Goldstein singularity is not removable, and must be considered as “a real phenomenon terminating the flow which, at high Reynolds number, exists upstream.” Conceivably the dilemma is caused by the assumed adverse pressure gradient. As a different starting point it may be postulated instead that the limiting flow as the Reynolds number tends to infinity should be described by the free-streamline theory for inviscid fluids. For the example of a circular cylinder, Sychev (1972) and Messiter and Enslow (1973) thus succeed remarkably to fit in a triple-deck local-interaction model, where the boundary layer has a faoorable pressure gradient upstream and a constant pressure plateau downstream. There is still an adverse pressure gradient locally, but of vanishing strength and over a vanishingly small distance as the Reynolds number tends to infinity. It seems not yet clear how this picture can be reconciled with the observed fact that, even for the circular cylinder, separation seems to have never occurred without an existing adverse pressure gradient upstream. In fact, the recent experimental data of Dobbinga et al. (1972) show a rearward movement of the separation point as the Reynolds number (based on the momentum thickness) is increased. The trend is contrary to the expectation that eventually the limit flow should separate under favorable pressure gradient. Besides, there is also the famous Schubauer experiment over an ellipse, where separation is found to arise after an extended region of adverse pressure gradient, already pointed out in the Addendum of Stewartson (1974). Perhaps the explanation lies in the unavoidable free-stream turbulence, in all experiments, which tend to delay separation. There will undoubtedly be fascinating further development to clarify the flow structure near the separation point. In a detailed study of the flow over the trailing edge of a flat plate, Veldmann (1976) suggests that the triple-deck forms “only the beginning of an infinite series of such regimes.” The introduction of time dependence for unsteady boundary layers cannot help but add greatly to the complexities. But if we restrict ourselves only to the global phenomenon of separation as the breakaway of the boundary layer from the body surface, the primary attention is focused on whether the outer edge of the viscous region no longer lies within a distance of O(v”*), v being the kinematic viscosity, from the wall. Even for boundary layers within which a bubble of reversed flow exists, if the overall thickness remains to be vanishingly small for large Reynolds numbers, clearly the limiting inviscid flow does not separate. We should still have a prescribed pressure distribution for the boundary layer, with possible local refinements near the points of flow reversal. The parabolic nature of the boundary-layer approximation should allow us to continue marching downstream. If the flow is, in fact, already separated, and the prescribed pressure distribution is taken to be that which actually exists just
180
Shan-Fu Shen
outside the free-shear layer, the thickness of the boundary layer (between the body surface and the outer edge of the shear layer) is O( 1) even as v -,0, thus becoming infinite in the boundary-layer scaling. In other words, the naive boundary-layer approximation must exhibit a singularity which terminates its applicability in the presence of separation. It is on these grounds that we concur with Sears and Telionis (1975) in maintaining the traditional boundary-layer equation as a diagnostic tool for unsteady separation. For simplicity, only two-dimensional incompressible laminar boundary layers will be examined. The governing equations are well known, au au au au -+u-+u-=-+u-+at ay at ax
au
a2u
ax
ay2’
(1.1)
au a0 -+-=o, ax ay
where (x, y) denote the Cartesian coordinates along and normal to the wall, respectively, t is the time, (u, u ) are the velocity components in the respective x and y directions, and U = U ( x , t ) is the free-stream velocity at the outer edge of the boundary layer. The kinematic viscosity v is assumed to have been absorbed in the scaling and does not appear. The boundary conditions are, if the wall is fixed, y=o, u=u=o, y -, 00, u -,u(x, t). (1.3) For the initial condition, properly specified velocity distributions are needed, and, in general, there should also be data along x = 0. The emphasis is on the behavior of the solution which may suggest separation through the development of a singularity, with or without the presence of flow reversal (u < 0) in some part of the domain. In contrast to the steady case, our knowledge about such boundary layer in detail, either experimentally or numerically, is still very limited. Particularly important is the distinction between flow reversal and separation (as breakaway) for unsteady flows. Though recognized in the literature, it has been most emphatically stressed by Sears and Telionis (1971). They take the position that, instead of vanishing wall shear, the appearance of a Goldstein singularity, or its like, in the boundary-layer solution is a more universal feature of separation. In the earlier studies of the steady flow over a rotating circular cylinder by Moore (1958) and Ludwig (1964), the vanishing wall shear is shown to be clearly irrelevant for separation and the separation criterion has been replaced by
au/ay = o
at u = 0,
(1.4)
Boundary-Layer Equation
181
referred to as the M-R-S (Moore-Rott-Sears) condition by Telionis (1970). The separation over a rotating cylinder becomes an unsteady phenomenon when viewed from a set of coordinates corotating with the cylinder. Consequently, they are led to propose that the M-R-S condition might prevail for all unsteady boundary layers at separation, when viewed from a suitable set of mooing coordinates. As a concept the moving separation singularity is physically very descriptive, but its genesis and demise in arbitrary unsteady boundary layers need to be clarified by further analysis. The study by Buckmaster (1973), for instance, suggests the possibility of situations where an initial singularity may in fact first disappear before resurfacing again later somehow. But supporting evidences have come forward, mostly from detailed numerical case studies as described in Sears and Telionis (1975). In this paper, we shall review mostly our recent studies of the unsteady boundary-layer equation relevant to the separation problem: the asymptotic approach to separation, outlined in Shen and Nenni (1975), is aimed at the prediction of separation without the boundary-layer details which must be obtained by accurate stepwise integration. Attention is only focused on the behavior of the u-component boundary-layer velocity at the outer edge of the boundary layer. This requires an improved analysis of the asymptotic behavior for steady flow due to Tollmien (1946), and the results are generalized to a class of weakly unsteady flows. It appears that the wall shear can sometimes be retained as a useful indicator when the boundary-layer singularity, hence separation, is encountered. Aside from their basic interest, these findings open up the possibility of practical methods of predicting unsteady separation through approximate boundary-layer calculations. Meanwhile the semisimilar boundary-layer equations are reexamined. The numerical examples provided by Williams and Johnson (1974qb) for these special unsteady boundary layers confirm the details of the M-R-S condition. Our analysis shows that the validity holds for all semisimilar boundary layers, for which the M-R-S condition may be rephrased without the notion of suitable moving coordinates. For the general case, the separation singularity is interpretable as due to the coalescence of the characteristics in the (x, t)-plane, or the crossing of path lines at the same instant. The boundary-layer equation is next formulated in Lagrangian coordinates for a unified treatment of the separation in both steady and unsteady flows. The evolution resulting in separation is followed numerically in a model problem, and singular behavior of the solution is found to occur when at a given time the Lagrangian variable x, the downstream penetration distance, develops a stationary point. This condition formalizes Prandtl's intuitive statement that the piling up of fluid particles is responsible for the boundary layer to break away from the wall. Without the longitudinal diffusion term, the boundary layer equation can predict the piling up only as a singularity, analogous to the shock
182
Shan-Fu Shen
discontinuity in gas dynamics. The crucial mechanism responsible for such an event is, likewise, none other than the wave-steepening in decelerating flows. 11. Asymptotic Behavior of the Boundary-Layer Solution Away
from the Wall A. THESTEADY CASE
Following a straightforward transformation, in the steady case Eqs. (1.1) and (1.2) may be rewritten as
aE- u a2E -
a4-Eag2’
where 4 and I) are basically the von Mises coordinates .x
.Y
4= J Udx, 0
+ =J
udy,
0
and E is the modified dependent variable representing the energy deficit,
E = U 2- u2. The asymptotic behavior of E as I) -+ 00 is obtained by letting u/U 4 1 and reducing (2.1) to the heat equation. It has been given by Tollmien (1946) in terms of an initial profile Eo(+) at 4 = 0 and arbitrary data Eo(4) along = 0. Since ulU -+ 1 is invalid near I) = 0, the condition E = U 2at the wall must be relaxed and 8,(4)may be regarded as resulting from the introduction of an effective slipping velocity. We shall refrain from a display of the Tollmien solution, except to point out that the contribution to the asymptotic solution E at a given station 4 comes mainly from the form of E0(4)near the leading edge 4 = 0; see Fig. 1. This Tollmien layer is therefore passive in nature, wrapping around the boundary-layer core within which are manifested the effects of the true boundary condition at the wall. Near the separation singularity, I) is expected to bifurcate and its use as one of the coordinates becomes obviously undesirable. In order to bring out the proper asymptotic behavior, particularly for the u-component velocity, Nenni (1976; also Shen and Ninni, 1975) uses the dependent variable 2 = U(U - U ) (2.2) and replaces the independent variable I) by
+
q = uy.
(2.3)
Boundary-Layer Equation
183
Tollmien layer, /’\,/-
JI
//
//
/ ,
-
, ’ /- I , , ’ I
A;<;
Equation (2.1) then takes the form
where all the nonlinear terms are gathered in N:
N=
(zU ,
uz u
- 2,)
+ [$
2, dq - 2
u3 u, j”
Z dq\Z,,.
0
(2.5)
The boundary conditions on Z ( 4 , q) are z(430) = - u2,
z(4,m) 0, +
Z(0, q) = Z o ( q ) ,
(2.6)
Zo(q) reflecting the initial velocity uo(q) at x = 0. If the right-hand side is
treated as given, the inhomogeneous heat equation (2.6) has the formal solution, satisfying the exact boundary and initial conditions,
It is now straightforward to evaluate the asymptotic behavior of Z as q -,00. Only the double integral of N in (2.7) is not considered in Tollmien’s linearization, and its contribution to the asymptotic behavior is to be found from
184
Shan-Fu Shen
the behavior of N(&, q’) for q’ small. It becomes necessary to describe Z(4, q) for q small, that is, the velocity profile near the wall. So as long as the boundary layer has yet to reach the singularity, it is expected that for q small, OD
Z
=
C ai(4)qi. i=O
The coefficients ai must satisfy the compatibility relations of the boundarylayer equations through successive differentiation of the latter with respect to q. By substitution of (2.8) into (2.5), it follows OD
where the coefficients ai turn out to be ao= -UU,, a1 = air, a2=
alal’ -2v2
1 (UU, 2
--
+ U,Z),
(2.10)
with a,‘ = dal/d+.
In terms of these coefficients, it follows for q -,co,
(2.11) where b = q/24’/’ and Zo*(q)is the asymptotic representation of the initial profile Zo(q).It is noted that the wall condition enters only through ao, al, ..., and in the higher order terms of lib.
185
Boundary-Layer Equation
B. THEWEAKLY UNSTEADY CASE The above analysis is not difficult to extend to the weakly unsteady case where the free-stream velocity is of the form U(X, t ) =
UO(X)
uo > 0,
+
-
Ul(X, t),
IU,I/V, G 1.
We define again the same variables that lead to (2.4) except replacing U everywhere by U o . For the asymptotic behavior, Z = ( U o - u)Uo < O(1). Now, corresponding to Tollmien’s linearized approximation, the unsteady boundary-layer equation in (x, y, t ) simplifies to
--+--oy-=u 1 az az u ’ az uo at ax uo ay
1*
1 azz + (U,U,),+ -. uo ayz
(2.12)
It indicates that for given initial data on t = 0 and boundary conditions on x = 0, the integration should be along the characteristics d x l U o = dt.
(2.13)
Hence the solution in the (x, t)-plane (Fig. 2) may be constructed separately depending on t 2 t* = 6 d x / U o . In either case, after reinserting the nonlinear terms omitted in (2.12), the governing equation can be reduced to the same form, (2.14) where, for the “large-time” solution, t > t*(x), ,x
(2.15) but for the “small-time” solution, t < t*(x),
5=
c‘
UoZ(x*)dt,
q
=
Voy,
T = t*
‘0
x * = x*(t
+ T),
the inverse of t * ( x * ) = t
- t,
+ r.
(2.16)
The solution of Eq. (2.14) and its asymptotic behavior as -, co can be determined from the same equation (2.11) as previously done for equation (2.4), except for an additive term to Z equal to U o U1. The coefficients ai(#) and a@) become ai(t, t),respectively, satisfying the compatibility relations
Shan-Fu Shen
186 +
t=t“x1
Large-llme
X
FIG.2. Large- and small-time domains and the characteristics as path of integration
following the unsteady boundary-layer equation. Their contributions to the asymptotic behavior of 2 again are exponentially small and of higher order than those from the linear theory. [For details, see Nenni (1976).]
111. Separation and the Concept of an Unmatchable Boundary Layer It has been repeatedly mentioned in the literature that all numerical integrations of the boundary-layer equations break down when the normal velocity and the displacement thickness start to increase their magnitudes precipitously. Thus to locate separation there is no need to examine the boundary-layer profile in detail. In Shen and Nenni (1975), the specific proposal is made to associate separation directly with the condition that the boundary layer should become “unmatchable,” in the sense that the induced normal velocity at the outer edge of the boundary layer attains such a magnitude as to invalidate the basic assumption of u ( R ) ’ / ~ 0(1), R being the Reynolds number. It remains to search for the circumstances under which unmatchability takes place, but frees us at least from preconceived notions about the differences between steady and unsteady separation. Although the asymptotic behavior of 2,essentially the u-component velocity, is found to be insensitive to the local wall conditions, the same cannot be said for the u-component velocity. From continuity, Eq. (1.2), we have
-
As q + 00, the first term on the right-hand side is easily seen to be nothing but the inner behavior of the outer (inviscid) solution, in the language of the method of matched asymptotic expansions. The last term of Eq. (3.1) is due to the boundary layer solution 2. As v -+ 00, it can be identified with
187
Boundary-Layer Equation
a( U6*)/ax,6* being the usual displacement thickness: 6* =
1”
(1
-e
1 ) d y = --
”
v2 0
2 dq.
Thus the “unmatchability condition” amounts to the statement: u’
a (ua*)> O(l), =ax
(3.3)
u‘ denoting the perturbation normal velocity on the inviscid flow. Separation can happen, consequently, if 6* or its x-derivative becomes unbounded. Note that 6* depends on the entire boundary-layer velocity profile, but as an integral is not very sensitive to local details.
A. THECASEOF STEADY SEPARATION It is necessary now to apply Eq. (3.3) first to steady boundary layers and show its equivalence to the criterion of vanishing wall shear and the concomitant Goldstein singularity. What is needed is only a sufficiently accurate representation of 6*. For instance, the Pohlhausen momentum-integral method provides an approximate equation for 6*(x), although it is notoriously unreliable for predicting separation. Furthermore, in general it does not exhibit the Goldstein singularity when the wall shear vanishes. The reason of such failures can only be that the assumed quartic for the velocity profile is too crude. This observation is dramatically demonstrated when, as in Shen and Nenni (1975), an approximation to the wall shear is made by patching together the asymptotic expansion equation (2.11) with a polynomial of the form equation (2.8). When truncated to four terms, Eq. (2.8) becomes explicitly
Z
I-
U 2+ 2(4)”*ba,
- 24b2UU,
+ 23
- +2
b4 a,a,’. u
(3.4)
On the other hand, Eq. (2.11) to O(exp( - b2)/b3) is unaffected by a,. If Eq. (3.8) is used for b i b* and Eq. (2.11) for b 2 b* to form a composite approximation with continuous first derivative (Fig. 3) two conditions are obtained from which b* can be eliminated. We obtain in principle an equation for the wall shear a, : %a,’ = %,4,
u, q.
(3.5) The coefficient a, of course is proportional to the wall shear. Although Eq. (3.5) may be only a very rough description of the shear along the wall, it
Shun-Fu Shen
188
2
FIG.3. Patching of asymptotic solution with polynomial approximation near wall
clearly exhibits the Goldstein square-root singularity at a, = 0 unless the right-hand side vanishes simultaneously, i.e., for special types of the pressure distribution. The displacement thickness 6* contains the integral of Eq. (3.4) from b = 0 to b*, and becomes singular together with al'. Unmatchability thus is seen to lead to the correct features of steady separation as long as the approximate profile near the wall includes the a,a,' term which may be traced to the coefficient a4 as a result of the compatibility conditions. The Pohlhausen quartic is constrained by only the compatibility conditions on a, and az, hence unable to reproduce the proper singularity. The physical significance of the compatibility condition on a4 is pointed out by Nenni (1976) as being the first contribution due to the convective terms in the boundary-layer equation. Its omission is tantamount to replacing the boundary-layer equation with a Stokes approximation, which is unacceptable beyond an extremely thin sublayer. We believe this observation opens up the possibility of improved momentum-integral-type methods for the prediction of separation. Preliminary investigations along this line by S. K. Kim (unpublished) at Cornell University produce encouraging results, but so far appear to require a heavy amount of algebra. The role played by the compatibility relation on a4 as illustrated in the following crude example may be of some interest. Instead of Eq. (6.4) let us return to the physical (x, y)plane and use near the fixed wall y = 0, u =a,y
+ a,yz + a3y3 + a4y4,
(3.6) the coefficients ai, i = 1, 2, 3, 4, being now functions of x only. Then the compatibility conditions, up to a4, are az =
-$UU',
a3
= 0,
a4 = (1/12)a1a1'.
(3.7)
Boundary-Layer Equation
189
We take the asymptotic behavior at large y as simply the free-stream velocity U ( x ) and patch it with Eq. (3.6) by requiring u(y*)= U ,
fil aY
= 0.
y*
The procedure leads to two algebraic equations in terms of y* and a4. Near a , = 0 it is easily found
Goldstein (1948) has quoted Jones (1948) that for the Howarth problem U = 1 - (x/8), separation occurs at x, = 0.959 and the wall shear obeys U,
= 23’2(0.47)(~,- x ) ~ ”= 1.33(~,- x ) ~ ” .
The prediction of Eq. (3.9) is seen to be U,
= [3(1 - &X,)]”~(X, - x)’” = 1.62(~,- x)’”.
Not only is it the proper singularity, but the strength is surprisingly close in this particular case, by means of the crude patching.
B. THECASEOF UNSTEADY SEPARATION Extending the concept of unmatchability to the unsteady case, we should be again looking for the singular behavior of the displacement thickness 6* with respect to either x or t. The patching described above is one way to assume a boundary-layer profile of minimum acceptability for this purpose, and the wall shear is seen to be capable of reflecting the singular behavior. It does not seem unreasonable again to focus on the wall shear. The wall shear in addition is an easily observable quantity in experiments. In real flows, the wall-shear singularity with respect to x or t at the separation point of course will be smoothed out locally, but the smoothing presumably is limited within a vanishingly small distance along the wall for large Reynolds numbers. We may mimic Eq. (2.8) and pose a polynomial approximation of degree rn near the wall as m
1 ai(t, r)qi9
(3.10)
i=O
and require that the compatibility at least up to a4 should be observed. But since the asymptotic behavior of U - u remains exponentiallysmall, any such
Shun-Fu Shen
190
approximation must be sufficiently flexible to represent the large variety of possible unsteady boundary-layer profiles. Otherwise, the displacement thickness might be grossly in error and the deductions therefrom would be totally misleading. For rapid oscillatory changes of the freestream, for instance, the boundary-layer profile may develop “wrinkles” and the needed number of terms in Eq. (3.10) becomes necessarily large. This difficulty is well recognized in the momentum-integral methods for unsteady flows, and the patching procedure, considered as a rough shortcut, must suffer similarly. However, the wall shear cannot escape being the solution of an initial- and boundary-value problem in the (x, tFplane. At least for simpler cases, the way in which a singular behavior develops may be qualitatively examined by the patching procedure. The investigations of Nenni (1976) include both the patching of Eq. (3.10)to his asymptotic solutions for large q, as well as the use of a composite rational-fraction approximation for Z:
where the ps and fs are functions of 5 and z defined by Eq. (2.15) or Eq. (2.16).These coefficients are required to satisfy the compatibility conditions near the wall, up to a4, and to agree with the first two terms of the asymptotic solution for q large. His results are illuminating but the details are cumbersome. Instead of quoting Nenni (1976) further, we shall present a more direct demonstration along the lines of Eqs. (3.6) and (3.8). For more generality than Eq. (3.6), let us allow an extra term for possibly a moving wall, = a0
+ a , y + a2yZ+ a3y3 + a4y4 +
***,
(3.12)
the coefficientsai now depending on both x and t. By direct substitution into Eqs. (1.1) and (1.2), the compatibility conditions are found to be uo
+ a0 ao’ = -p, + 2a2, (3.13)
... where (’) is the time derivative, and ( )’ the x-derivative, and -p, = U,+ UU,.Again truncating Eq. (3.12) as written and applying the crudest patching condition equation (3.8), we get
+ a4y*4 = u - a,y* - a2y*2, 3a3y*2 + 4a4y*4 = -a, - 2a,y*. a3y*3
(3.14)
Boundary-Layer Equation
191
The elimination of y* from the pair in Eq. (3.14) leads to an implicit equation: (3.15) q = 0. = 0, a, must equal ipx, therefore prescribed as
qao, a,, 4, a39 a4,
By Eq. (3.13), for fixed wall a. usual, a3 represents the time rate of change of a, (the wall shear), and a4 depends on the change of a, along the wall. Equation (3.15) then can in principle be cast as, similar to Eq. (3.5), a4 = G(hl, a,,
. . .),
(3.16)
the dots in the parenthesis referring to quantities obtainable from the prescribed free stream. A closer examination of (3.14) shows that y* may be solved from a cubic equation in terms of the coefficients ao, a,, a,, and a3. Equation (3.16) is only an alternate form of either of the pair in Eq. (3.14) with y* so defined. Together with the third line of Eq. (3.13), it may be regarded as the equation for a,. The nature of possible behaviors, even for cases where the profile is well represented by Eq. (3.12), is evidently highly complex. We can nevertheless draw certain qualitative conclusions. If the free stream changes sufficiently slowly with time, it should be possible to expand Eq. (3.16) for b small, a4 = Go(al, ...)
+ G,(a,, ...)bl + G2(al, ...)b12+ ...,
(3.17)
where G o , G,, G,, etc., are obviously the appropriate derivatives of G with respect to a,. When on,ly the linear term in a, is kept, the result may be rewritten as hlhl
+ alal‘ = k,,
(3.18)
with h , and k , depending on a, and other quantities defined by the free stream. An equation of the form of (3.18) has already made its appearance in Shen and Nenni (1975). It is noted to resemble the Burgers equation in gas dynamics; thus the wall shear can develop a singularity analogous to the shock formation through the coalescence of the characteristics of Eq. (3.18). The “shock path” in the (x, t)plane gives the movement of the separation point. As a gas-dynamic shock sometimes starts after a finite time after the disturbance, Eq. (3.18) is seen to be capable of explaining the emergence of separation at finite time under suitable conditions. By retaining the quadratic term in Eq. (3.17), Eq. (3.18) is replaced schematically by
hlhl
+ h Z h l 2+ alal’ = k z ,
(3.19)
192
Shan-Fu Shen
where again, h,, h,, k2 depend on a , and the free stream. An equation similar to Eq. (3.19) can be found in Nenni (1976),whose derivation is based on Eq. (3.11). Nenni’s coefficients corresponding to h , , h,, and k,, however, contain complicated dependences on ti1 and a,. At any rate, Eq. (3.19) suggests that the separation singularity as manifested by the wall-shear behavior is actually considerably more complex than the gas-dynamic analogy of Eq. (3.18). We caution that the patching procedure as described is not to be taken seriously as providing a quantitative answer for the wall shear. The construction is based upon only local properties and must have severe limitations. The next step for reasonable accuracy and more general applicability might be to employ a momentum integral formulation in conjunction with such a patched profile that incorporates the right ingredients to turn properly singular. Our experience with preliminary studies of this type shows that hidden difficulties are abundantly strewn along the path and must be overcome very likely on a case-to-case basis. The major consideration should be the adequate representation of the velocity profile where it contributes most to the displacement thickness. This is most difficult to achieve when the velocity profile ceases to be monotonic. Much experimentation is definitely needed before the practical usefulness of such procedures can be fairly assessed.
IV. The Semisimilar Boundary Layer A. DEFINITION AND RESULTSOF COMPUTATION As an attempt to gain some information for the unsteady flow associated with a diffuser when the angle of divergence varies with time, or an airfoil with time-dependent angle of attack, Tani (1958) has considered a generalization of the Howarth problem with the free-stream velocity
u = 1 - 5,
5 = x/(l
- At),
(4.1) A being a constant. With the usual boundary-layer variable r , ~= y/2(x)’I2 and a series expansion of the stream function $, $ = (x)”2[fo(?) + tfl(r,I)+ t 2 f 2 ( r , I ) + . . .I, (44 a sequence of ordinary differential equations is obtained forfo,fl, . . . . The functions upf5 are solved for the appropriate boundary conditions for fixed wall, ,f;:(O) =h‘(O)= 0,
i = 0,1, 2, . . .,
Boundary-Layer Equation
193
and the conditions at the outer edge,
j,’(co= ) 2,
fl’(co) = $,
$(a)= 0, i
2
2.
5. The calculation for 5 > 0.05 is carried out by the momentum-integral method with an approximate profile
As in the steady case, the series expansion converges slowly with
u = W ( q )- tfl’(?)- -..-
(4.3)
where G ( q )is determined according to Howarth (1938) and given in a tabulated form. He finds thus the flow reversal to occur at = 0.15 for A = 1. In Tani’s problem, $ / ( x ) l i Z is only a function of 5 and q. Following an earlier analysis of Hayasi (1962), Williams and Johnson (1974a) search for the general conditions for the class of “semisimilar” unsteady boundary layers. These have the property that the governing equation is reducible to a form involving only two suitable independent variables t ( x , t) and q(x, y, t ) , and a properly transformed stream function. The standard numerical techniques developed for the steady boundary layers may then be directly borrowed to provide nontrivial examples of unsteady boundary layers, in particular with flow reversal as well as separation. However, the multitude of requirements force them to resort to an “indirect method of solution” by assigning certain a priori conditions, following which a class of admissible free streams is found to be
<
U = U(<),
5 = ( x + kt)/(l - At),
(4.4) A and k being constants. Numerical examples are provided again for the generalized Howarth problem U = 1 - 5, with k = 0 in Williams and Johnson (1974a) and A = 0 in Williams and Johnson (1974b). The former, of course, is just the Tani problem, and the flow reversal point is found to occur also at 5 = 0.15 for A = 1. The latter corresponds to the steady flow over a moving wall. In the Tani problem, the integration is carried out further beyond the reversal point until separation. It is, however, necessary to avoid reverse flows in standard implicit finite-difference schemes, e.g., Blottner (1970), developed for the steady boundary layer. They make the observation that if 5, is the separation point, then the actual separation point x, obeys X,
= <,(1 - At),
dx,/dt =
-At,.
In other words, when viewed from a moving coordinate system with k = At, in Eq. (4.4), the semisimilar solution should resemble a steady boundarylayer solution with standing separation. In the new coordinates, the free stream becomes U = 1 - 5 + A<, and the wall is moving at velocity
194
Shan-Fu Shen
FIG.4. Velocity profile for U = 1 - {, fixed wall, k = 0, according to Williams and Johnson (1974a).
u(<, 0) = At,. We display here only the final equation:
(
f ” ‘ + 1- (1 )ff“- 1 + x 2 1 + At, - 5
s
-t
)(I9 ‘ 7
where f =f (t,q), q = y [ V / ( x - At, t ) ] ” 2 , f = 8f8q, etc., and the boundary conditions are
v o t e that f (5, q ) in Eq. (4.5) is different from Tani’s definition Eq. (4.2).] But, of course 5, is unknown beforehand. An iteration scheme is necessary, by starting with an assumed value 5, and finding out whether the solution does blow up at the same value. A typical solution, for A = 1.0, transformed back to the fixed coordinates is shown as Fig. 4. Note the presence of reverse flow for 5 > 0.15, and the rapid increase of the boundary-layer thickness downstream once flow reversal is encountered. The large flat portion of the velocity profile for u/U < 0 near separation contributes most heavily to the displacement thickness and obviously is difficult to represent with the simple polynomial approximations such as Eq. (3.12). It is also found that, in the moving coordinate system, the solution cannot be continued further downstream as soon ass‘ = 0 is reached somewhere within the boundary layer. Geometrically this point, say (&, q,), is a minimum of the profile f’&, q), hence f”(<,,q.) = &it corresponds to the point of zero shear. These features are in complete agreement with the M-R-Scondition, and
Boundary-Layer Equation
195
I
[,=3.16
t
FIG.5. u-component velocity for U = 1 - t, moving wall, I = 0, according to Williams and Johnson (1974b).
emerge again in the companion moving-wall calculations of Williams and Johnson (1974b). Furthermore, the minimum of the boundary-layer velocity (in moving coordinates) turns out to vary like (t, - t)'/', i.e., [(x, - x)/(l - It)]'/'. Thus the singularity is actually of Goldstein type. These calculations, from a different viewpoint, naturally lend support to the unmatchability condition requiring merely that the o-component velocity at the outer edge of the boundary layer or, equivalently, the displacement thickness should develop a singularity at <,. This is evident in Figs. 5 and 6. As for the calculated wall shear, the trend toward a singularity is progressively more obscure as I becomes larger. The result indicates a loss of sensitivity of the wall shear as a good indicator of separation when the reverse-flow region becomes extensive. It explains the highly complicated form possible for the equation governing the wall shear in Section 111. B. REFORMULATION OF THE SEMISIMILAR PROBLEM In the procedure described above, to avoid the numerical difficulty of the reversed flow, the unknown moving separation point has to be introduced and solved by iteration. An alternative formulation without introduction of the stream function, proposed in Wang and Shen (1977), turns out to be both easier to analyze and simpler to integrate. In addition the physical nature of the separation singularity is also less obscure.
c FIG.6. Displacement thickness for U = 1 - <,fixed wall, k = 0, according to Williams and Johnson (1974a).
196
Shan-Fu Shen
The main feature of the semisimilar boundary layers is that the governing equations may be written in two independent variables [(x, t ) and q(x, y, t). Without loss of generality, let us define u = u(5, q),
u = u(5, q),
q = Y/6(X, t ) ,
(4.7)
4 5 , 00)- W ) , and 6(x, t ) as well as ((x, t ) are yet to be specified. The continuity equation (1.2) becomes 6, 1 u t t x (-qu,) - u - = 0, (4.8) 6
+
+
while the momentum equation (1.1) takes the form
With ii = u, U = u6, two equations are obtained from (4.8) and (4.9) for these variables in terms of ( and q, provided
5 :&:-6x.6,. - -1 = a1:a2:a3:a4:a5, 6’6‘62
(4.10)
where a,, . . . , a,, being dependent on x and t , can at most be functions of 5. The relation (4.10) of course is equivalent to four conditions: (4.11)
Instead of looking for <(x, t ) and 6(x, t), it is convenient to interchange the roles of the independent and dependent variables. The first line of (4.11)may be then recast as XC F2t5 = 0, xg
+ +F
1 tg
= 0,
(4.12)
which, after eliminating x by cross-differentiation, is reduced to (F2
- F1)tac - Fl’tg = 0.
(4.13)
Hence, direct integration gives the general solution
(4.14)
Boundary-Layer Equation
197
A,, B,, and B, being arbitrary functions. It is now straightforward to go
back to the second line of (4.11).We first deduce
h2 = (B2’- F,’t)F4,
(4.15)
and find next, besides the trivial case F , = const.,
Bz = a, F1 + a2,
(4.16)
a, and a, being constants. Hence the combination of (4.14) and (4.16) leads
to (x - az)/(a1 -
=
W).
(4.17)
It appears, consequently, that Williams and Johnson’s solution of admissible [(x, t), Eq. (4.4), is in fact the most general one for semisimilar boundary layers. As for 6(x, t ) , following (4.15) and (4.16),
6,
= (a1 - t)F4(<),
or equivalently, (4.18) 6’ = (x - aZ)(F4/FI). There is therefore some flexibility in the choice of F4(5)to suit the problem. In contrast to Williams and Johnson (1974a,b),Wang and Shen (1977)have simply taken F4 F , , and 6 independent of t. For the Tani problem defined by (4.1), we take a, = l/A, a, = 0, and F , = A< in (4.17) and F4 = 45 in (4.18). The set (4.8) and (4.9) become
-
25n,
- qu,
+ +B,
(4.19)
= 0,
4<(A<+ ilp, - (2qn - B)ci, = 4t(ng + U ) U ,
+ n,,,
(4.20)
where q = y / 2 ( ~ ) ’ /a~= , u, B = 2u(x)’/’. For fixed wall, the boundary conditions are U(<,0) = v(<, 0) = 0,
q 5 , 0 0 ) = U(5), ~ ( 0q,) = u&),
(4.21) gven.
Note that there is no intrinsic advantage to use the normalized velocity ii/U(<)when the solution is sought by numerical integration. It is evident that standard finite-difference schemes developed for steady boundary-layer equations in terms of the continuity and momentum equations should be again directly adaptable. Furthermore, (4.20)is parabolic and of the general form K ( < , up, + ... = u,,,
(4.22)
198
Shun-Fu Shen
with K ( < , ii) = 45(A< + a) in the present case. The coefficient K plays the role of the inverse of thermal diffusivity in the analog heat equation. We have a well-posed problem to continue Do for > 0, so long as K > 0. Thus, for decelerating flows I > 0, local flow reversal will not disrupt the numerical integration until it is sufficiently negative, at least not before K changes sign. It turns out K starts to change sign only at t = t,, as will be shown. There is no need to find the separation position 5, by trial and error. Other than the generalized Howarth flow U = 1 - 5 , two additional examples of semisimilar solutions have been calculated by Wang and Shen (1977) with the formulation (4.19) to (4.21), using the Crank-Nicholson scheme outlined in Blottner (1970).With 5 = x/l - It, the free-stream velocity distributions are prescribed to be:
+
(ii) U = 1 - A , t/(1 T2t), A , , A,, T,, & being positive constants. Figure 7 shows a plot of the modified streamfunction II/ in the (<, q)plane for case (i), $ being defined by $ = 1,h/2(x)”~,where $ is the true stream function according to the usual definition. Although II/ = constant no longer represents the streamline, the bubble beneath II/ = 0 nevertheless indicates the region of reverse flow. In the example K > 0 is maintained in the bubble region and no apparent
7r
7)
IF 0 005
0.01 0.62 0.03 064 0105 006 007 0.08 OD9 010 011 012
t FIG.7. An example of unsteady boundary layer containing a recirculating bubble without separation.
Boundary-Layer Equation
199
instability has arisen due to the presence of reverse flow. As a precaution, the steps in the [-direction are carefully refined to insure that any indication of instability is not suppressed.
C. SEPARATION CRITERION AND THE GOLDSTEIN SINGULARITY We return to (4.22)and observe that in its numerical integration by marching downstream, instability is certain to occur beyond a certain [ when K < 0 for all q. The locus of the condition K = 0 may be thought of as a neutral curve in the (5, q)-plane, and defines a critical point (tC,q c ) when jointly (4.23)
the subscript c denoting the value at (lc,qc). If there are several such points, we take the one with the smallest value of [, so that tCis the minimum critical value beyond which K < 0 in some interval of q. It remains to examine whether the solution necessarily breaks down as the critical point is approached from upstream. In the degenerate case of I = 0, i.e., steady flows, K = u and (4.23) becomes identical to the M-R-Scondition for the separation singularity ([, q,), where both u and the shear vanish. Now for the generalized Howarth flow U = 1 - [ and I > 0, the following results are stated in Williams and Johnson (1974a): I
0
5, 0.117 Ii,
0
0.5 1.0 0.161 0.22 1 - 0.0805 - 0.221
The data are in full agreement with (4.23), if indeed 5, = 5,. These correlations are highly suggestive and have led to the conjecture in Wang and Shen (1977) that the critical point might actually be a barrier of the solution, indicating separation. Because K = 4[(I[ + a) for these semisimilar boundary layers, (4.23) and the M-R-Scondition coincide. The latter is phrased in terms of a moving observer at an unspecified “suitable speed,” which is now specified by satisfying K = 0. By retracing the steps back to (4.9), it is apparent that K is proportional to the forward velocity component of the fluid particle. When in addition dK/dq = 0, physically in an infinitesimally small neighborhood of the critical point all particles cease to advance downstream. From this viewpoint, the breakdown of the boundary layer solution is seen to reflect
200
Shun-Fu Shen
the incipient turning back of these slow-moving fluid particles, as originally pictured by Prandtl in the steady case. Goldstein’s classical analysis of the separation singularity in 1948 was motivated by Hartree’s numerical study of the case U = 1 - x. We now have the computational results of U = 1 - 5 following (4.4) and (4.9, which apparently exhibit the same behavior characterizing the Goldstein singularity. To our knowledge, these represent the only evidence from detailed study in support of the emphatic conviction of Sears and Telionis (1975) that at separation there should be even in unsteady cases “the appearance of the Goldstein singularity . . ., modified us necessary, in the solution of the boundary-layer equations.” (Italics are by the present author.) Other numerical solutions of the unsteady boundary layer are cited as showing also singular behavior, but definitive evidence of the square-root nature of the classical Goldstein singularity is lacking. Their statement presumably should be understood as strongly anticipating a singularity with an unbounded u-component velocity and possibly the Goldstein (square-root) behavior. The formal resemblance of (4.19) and (4.20), for semisimilar boundary layers, to the governing equations for steady flows points to the probable validity of their conjecture. However, there seems to be no previous analysis in open literature. we use (4.11) to rewrite Without specializing the choices of 5 and U(<), (4.8) and (4.9) as (4.24)
with F* = F4(F1 + U ) for brevity. Corresponding to (4.22), it is seen that, for the general case, (4.26) K(u, 5 ) = F4(F1 + u), and the critical point according to (4.23) remains always the same as obtained by the M-R-S conditions of aupq = 0 and specifying u = - F, for the moving coordinates. To study the behavior of the solution upstream and in the vicinity of (t,, q,), let
5 = 5,
- 51,
u = u,
+
Ul,
v=
vc
+ v1, (4.27)
Boundary-Layer Equation
201
where the subscript “c” denotes the value at the critical point and F*‘ = dF*/dS, etc. Equations (4.24) and (4.25) become
= Fc*- F r ’ 5 ,
,
aZu + .. . + -
a1112’
(4.29)
As suggested by the numerical evidence, we pattern after Goldstein (1948) and look for a local solution of the type (4.30) Thus, the terms of O(5,) in the coefficientsof (4.28)and (4.29)are O(x4), and those from q1 are O(x). For the expansion (4.30) up tofl it is sufficient to consider the simplified set: -F4,c
aa
au,
au 1
+ = 0, a111 a111
-- F 3 , c V c -
851 8%
(4.31)
-
- F 4, c u -+[U-11c~cF3,c]-=Fc*+--
at,
aZu
1
a111
(4.32)
By redefining 52
= 51/F4,c>
01 =
112 = 1119
(4.33)
- F3.c11cUc,
these are further reduced to au, av, -_ +--0, a52 a112 au,
-u1 - + U 1 a52
au
(4.34) a2u
-=Fc*+-8112 a1122.
(4.35)
In other words, precisely the same equations as considered in Goldstein
202
Shan-Fu Shen
(1948) govern the behavior offo andf,. But of course the boundary conditions are different, as now the critical point does not lie on the fixed wall. The consequences of this modification have already been formally discussed by Brown (1965) in a different context. Prior to the critical station t,, the velocity profile u,(& q) for 5 given is well defined. As in the steady case, the numerical data for U = 1 - g suggest that there is also no anomaly of u1 as t + 5, from upstream. Assuming this to hold in general, we may therefore write for t2 and q2 small, ui = ao(52) + a1(52)t/2 81 = bO(t2)
+ b,(t,)t/2
+ az(tzhz2 + %(tz)r/z3 +
‘**,
(4.36)
**..
At the critical station 5, = 0, ao(0)= q ( 0 )= 0 by definition, and the compatibility conditions, from substitution of (4.36)into (4.34)and (4.35),yield a2(0)= - F,*,
a3(0)= - bo(0)F,*, etc.
(4.37)
The implication of (4.37) is that, for q, # 0, lim (-00
f:o rr+, = ((2)1’2~a,+~(0), r = 0 , 1 .
(4.38)
It is now possible to borrow directly from Goldstein (1948).A rescaling of the velocity and length suffices to reduce F,* to - 1 and will be omitted here, and (4.30) is understood as having been thus properly scaled. Then the equations forfo andf, are known to be: fo”’ - 3f0 fo”
f,‘”-
+ 2f0’~= 1,
+c3f1” + $cvl’- 4rlfi = 0.
(4.39) (4.40)
The boundary conditions for fo are unchanged from Goldstein’s case, fo(0)=fo’(0)= 0, The solution is still
fo’
-c
as c + 00.
f o = ic3.
(4.41)
Forf,, however, since a3(0)# 0, it is necessary to consider all three independent complementary functions of (4.40). These are c2, hl(c), and gl(c), the details of which are fully described in Goldstein’s paper. The most important property of h , and g1 is that asymptotically both grow exponentially large with c. On the other hand, the exponential growth can be eliminated by a suitable linear combination of h, and 6,: Let w,(c) =
(-a)!
(-2)!
g1
+ 2-(1’4)(-$)! (-2)! hl,
(4.42)
Boundary-Layer Equation
203
-
then w1(Q l4 as ( -,00. Therefore, to satisfy (4.38) we must have in the present case the solution (4.43)
where a1 and /I1are two constants. It goes without saying that B1 is completely determined by a3(0)because of (4.38). As for a l we find it proportional to b,(O). To summarize the solution (4.30) now may explicitly be written as, for fured q2 and T2 + 0, 2 1 2
u1 = 2% [d = [q2'
+ x(2a1C + 4B1r3) + -1
+ 8B1q23 +
* * a ]
+ 4a1q22(<2)1/2+
* . a .
(4.44)
Note that the variables have been rescaled to make Fo* = - 1, and are no longer those originally introduced in (4.30). The terms in the bracket represent the profile at t2= 0, or 4 = tc.The deviation of the velocity u1 (= u - u,) from the profile at tC still varies as ( C 2 ) l I 2 for given q2 # 0 and as the critical 5, is approached from upstream. The critical point is therefore coincident to the separation singularity postulated by Sears and Telionis (1975). Further, we have indeed the true Goldstein singularity as in the steady case, for all semisimilar boundary layers.
V. 'Ihe General Unsteady Boundary Layer A. FINITE-DIFFERENCE SCHEMES AND LQCAL FLOWREVERSAL
For the general unsteady boundary layer, the equations are directly integrated often with a suitable finite-difference scheme. We focus once more on the breakdown of the solution as it progresses in the (x, t)-plane, which signals separation in the present viewpoint. There is no need to reiterate that separation frequently is further downstream from the occurrence of a local flow reversal. Typically the numerical integration is performed as an evolution in time. Let us first discretize time into the set of points t,,, n = 0, 1,2, . . . ,and write U(X,
Y , t n ) = un(x, Y ) ,
~ ( x Y, , t n ) = un(x, Y).
It is obvious that the one-sided difference for the time derivative should be used :
,
At, = t, - t,-
1.
Shan-Fu Shen
204
At each t = t,, the momentum equation (1.1) becomes
au, ax
u,, -
au, u, u,-l a2u, + 0, + -= ( U , + UU,)” + - + ~, a Y At, At, ay2
(5.2)
but the continuity equation (1.2) remains to be au, av, -+-=o.
ax
(5.3)
ay
The boundary conditions (1.3) for fixed wall are un(x, 0) = un(x, 0) = 0,
un(x, 00) = U(X,tn),
(5.4)
and data along x = 0 at t, = 0 are also specified. We have to solve thus a succession of quasi-steady boundary layer equations carrying t, as a parameter, provided u,- l(x, y) at the previous time step is known. The integration of (5.2) is typically by advancing in the x-direction and numerical difficulties arise as soon as u, < 0 for all y at a given x. Because of the boundary condition as y oo,and usually U > 0, negative values of u, may occur over only part of the boundary-layer thickness. A limited amount of local flow reversal is often tolerable, but special handling is required in the finite-difference procedure. The key notion is that, as a convective derivative, u,(au,,/ax) in (5.2) should be approximated with the proper amount of “upstream” influence, the upstream direction depending on the sign of u,,. Let the domain of interest in the (x, y)-plane be now discretized into the set of points (xl, ym),I, m = 0, 1,2, . ..,at which the velocity components are expressed by
-
Un(x1, Ym) = Ul.m,n,
un(xl, Ym) = Ul.m.n-
(5.5)
Two of the successful current schemes in coping with local flow reversal are, with .hx, = XI - XI- 1, (i) the upwind scheme (Phillips and Ackerberg, 1973)
and (ii) the zigzag scheme (Telionis et al., 1973)
Both are first-order accurate, and contain information beyond the station of interest x1 at the previous time tn- 1.
Boundary-Layer Equation
205
The stabilizing effect of (5.6) and (5.7) in the numerical integration is given some insight by Wang and Shen (1977). The implications of a difference formula are made more transparent with the diagrams in Fig. 8, where the grid work is drawn only in the (I, nbplane because all quantities in (5.2) are evaluated at the same level in. The circles denote the points at which the variable u appears in the difference formula. A line connecting two circles denotes that the differenceis taken between them, the arrowhead pointing to the one from which the value at the other end is subtracted. In Fig. 8a, the solid path from (I, n) to (I + 1, n - 1) represents the numerator of (5.6), but the broken-line path through an intermediate point (I, n - l), marked by a cross, is its equivalent, since UI+l.n-l
- U1.n
= ( U I + l . n - l - U1.n-1)
+ (U1.n-1 - U1.n).
It is clear that replacing the path between any two end points in the diagram by any other path through intermediate points does not alter the result. Figure 8a shows that (5.6) is equivalent to
By expanding the variable u of the right-hand side in a Taylor series, it follows that to first order of At and Ax, (5.8) implies the approximation
or
where A1+lJl
= A.xl+l/Atn.
Consequently, the original momentum equation (1.1) is approximated by
=
(V, + UK)I,n + A+1,n
(5.10)
in a quasi-steady form, which may be immediately compared with (4.22). (Note that au/ax In- is assumed known, hence put to the right-hand side.) Similarly, in Fig. 8b the zigzag scheme (5.7) is depicted and the direct path
206
Shun-Fu Shen
(C)
FIG. 8. Diagrams For interpretation OF difference schemes: (a) upwind, (b) zigzag, and (c) time derivative.
from (I - 1, n ) to (I, n) is detoured via the broken-line path in three segments. It may be easily verified that (5.7) is tantamount to replacing (1.1) by
again to first-order accuracy. In both (5.10) and (5.11), the coefficient of au/ax does not change sign unless u ~is, sufficiently ~ negative, since I as the
ratio of the step sizes is always positive. From its appearance, (5.11) is apparently more stable than (5.10) if the same sizes are employed. The diagramming above invites a reinterpretation of (5.1). In Fig. 8c the direct path connecting (I, n - 1) to (I, n ) is detoured via two intermediate points as shown. Therefore (5.1) is seen to imply the approximation: (5.12)
Putting (5.12) into (l.l),we obtain a different picture of (5.2) before taking any specific scheme for au/ax:
(5.13) The structure is similar to that of (5.10).The upwind scheme (5.6) may be regarded as consistent with the onasided time difference (5.1),but the zigzag scheme is apparently not.
207
Boundary-Layer Equation
If we start from (5.13) instead of (5.2), there should be no numerical instability before, in this case, K = (ulVn+ &) changes sign. Although a critical point can be again defined according to (4.23),it in general does not occur at the separation singularity. After all, the choice of the step sizes Ax, and At,, is largely arbitrary, so that unlike for the semisimilar flows of Section IV the stabilization due to unsteadiness is not inherent but artificially introduced. This state of affairs should not be surprising if we recall that in (5.2) K = u,, and the critical point is reached as soon as flow reversal takes place. Nevertheless, either (5.6) or (5.7) enables further integration downstream. The distinction is that (4.22) is an exact equation and all other terms are of O(l), while now the approximation is achieved through the addition and subtraction of the &/ax terms at adjacent points with a resulting stabilization effect. Near the singularity au/ax tends to become unbounded. The approximation must deteriorate since it replaces terms of O(1) by the difference between two large numbers unless, e.g., the step size Ax, is properly adjusted. Apparently the practice is to use increasingly small Ax to avoid the artificial overstabilization in the search of the separation location xs, as mentioned in Telionis et al. (1973). B. THENUMERICAL EXAMPLE OF TELIONIS, TSAHALIS, A N D WERLE In the numerical investigation of unsteady boundary layer separation involving other than semisimilar flows, Telionis et al. (1973) introduce first the coordinate transformation:
x = X(X,
t )=
jxU(x, t ) dx, 0
p = p(x, t ) = yU/(2x)'/2,
(5.14)
-
t = t,
analogous to those adopted by Gortler (1957) in the steady case. The dependent variables (u, u ) are rewritten as (5.15) Omitting the straightforward details, we quote only their final set of equations: aF dG (5.16) 2x - + F +- = 0,
ax
@
Shan-Fu Shen
208
and the boundary conditions:
B=O, F = G = O ; J-Go, F+l. (5.18) The coefficients A iare generally functions of x and Fonly, except that A , is also linear in y. Aside from the a F / a i term, (5.17) and (5.18) may be compared with (4.24) and (4.25) in the semisimilar case, but of course the variables are defined differently. The numerical solution is by the usual approach of approximating the time derivative at r= 6 according to (5.1),
ar ,= F n -A
_
_
At, = t,
-
- t,-
1,
(5.19)
and reducing (5.17) to
(5.20)
Equation (5.20) is of course analogous to (5.2), and together with (5.16) and (5.18) may be solved as again a quasi-steady problem. The special case actually treated by these authors has U = 1 - T(t)x,as a further generalization of the semisimilar Howarth problem U = 1 - of Section IV. The function T ( t )is chosen to be a polynomial representing an increasingly adverse pressure gradient in time, inducing a forward movement of the separation point. The numerical solution is achieved by using the subroutine due to Werle and Davis (1972). The separation point X , ( o is located from the manifestation of lack of convergence of the iteration procedure. The u-component velocity profile remains without anomaly up to the separation point. On the other hand, near separation the u-component velocity rises rapidly and becomes apparently unbounded in the limit, as shown in Fig. 9. (The numbers in the parenthesis denote the number of iterations required to satisfy their convergence criterion.) This feature of an unbounded u-component velocity alone implies a singularity. Without further details, however, it may be referred to as of the Goldstein type only in a vague sense. But we have no qualms to accept the results as substantiating the “unmatchability condition” mentioned in Section 111.
<
C. CRITERION FOR THE SEPARATION SINGULARITY Based on the specific finite-differenceschemes, their inadequacy near separation obviously makes further general discussions difficult. An alternative route might be followed which would be free from any approximation of the singular behavior. As in Goldstein (1948) for the steady case, it may not be
Boundary-Layer Equation
209
X
FIG.9. Typical o-component velocity versus x at p = 0.5 in the example of Telionis et al. (1973).
unreasonable to accept the