MARCEL DEKKER, INC.
NEWYORK BASEL
This book is printed on acid-free paper. Marcel Dekker, Inc. 270 Madison Avenue, N...
211 downloads
2581 Views
102MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
MARCEL DEKKER, INC.
NEWYORK BASEL
This book is printed on acid-free paper. Marcel Dekker, Inc. 270 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10016 tel: 212-696-9000; fax: 212-685-4540 aster
Marcel Dekker AG Hutgasse 4, Postfach 8 12, CH-4001 Basel, Switzerland tel: 41-61-261-8482; fax: 41-61-261-8896 http://ww~.dek~er.com The publisher offers discounts on this book when ordered in bulk quantities. For more information, write to Special Sales/Professional Marketing at the headquarters address above.
Neither this booknor any part may be reproducedor transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, microfilming, and recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system,without permission in writing from the publisher. Current printing (last digit) 10987654321
Silicon is the earth’s most abundant element. Silicon dioxide, or silica, appears in the form of crystalline minerals (principally quartz), stones, etc. It is prepared industrially on a large scale in the form of powder of small particlesize and high surface area. Silica has numerous applications. For instance, quartz enters into the preparationof ceramics, whereas silica powder has many applications in our lives. Silica belongs to the limited number of finely divided mineral oxides whose surface properties have been studied extensively for years. ono graphs and specialized conferences are currently devoted to the study of silica. It is quite difficult to describe in a single volume the vast amount of information available in the literature. For this volume, we chose to concentrate our efforts ona given subject-the study of adsorptionon silicasurfaces. Adsorptionon silica is fundamentaltoimportantapplications, dernonstrated by the invaluable behavior of silica a support in chromatographic phases, catalysts, etc. More recently, silica has become an efficient additive or reinforcement agent for rubber used in the preparation of tires. Its presence decreases rolling resistance, thus saving gasoline and consequently reducing air pollution. The unique adsorption properties and reactivity of silicain part explain this peculiar behavior. This is just one timely example that demonstrates the necessity for further investigation for a better understanding of the surface and adsorption characteristics of silica. The book gives, an introduction, historical overview and discussion of the state-of-the-art of silica research. The first chapters allow nonspecialists to update their knowledge of silica surface characteristics.
he topics discussed include: (1) the surface chemistry of silica essentially ed to the existence of hydroxyl or silanol groups, which differ in nature gy, revealed by modern high performing techniques such IR spectroscopies; (2) morphology at the nanoscale and mesoscale, y quantitative image analysis and molecular computer modeling; (3) porosity determined by thermogravimetry methods; (4) surface energy sical interaction potential, shown by inverse gas chromatography, ilica is commonly exposed to water in the formof vapor or liquid and thus it is important to learn more about the state and special properties of adsorbed water molecules. Indeed, subsequent solute adsorption processes have to take into account the electrical properties of the silica-water interface and adsorbed thisgeneral introd~ction to silica, adsorption on nonmodified and silica surfaces becomes the major concern of the book. Adsorption from the gas phase, currently widely described in the literature, is in this book discussed in relation to ion-bombarde~silica samples. Thenature of theadsorptionmedium,eitherwaterororganicliquids, stronglyinfluencestheadsorptionprocess.oreover, bents, such heavymetalcationsandsurfactants, need to be considered separately from ~ ~ c r u ~ u l e cspecies, ~ l a r such polyelectrolytes and polymers used for the stabilization of silica suspension-supported enzymes and natural macrom~lecules finding interesting applications in biology. All these situations are examined in the book. ne chapter focuses on adsorption from organic solutions, whichis of particularsignificance,especiallyforliquidchromatographyseparationtechniques.Adsorptionprocessesdeterminetheperformance modified silica used chromatographicsupport.Forimportantpracticalapplications such the ~ a n u f a c t u r i n gof polymeric (silicone) materials containing silica, hot melts for adhesives, etc., the fundamental study of the adsorption from the melt deserves special attention, and two chapters are devoted to this aspect. reas adsorption on silica is beneficial for many applications, the manipon and or inhaling of finely divided, high-surface-area silica particles may generate health problems of great concern, discussed here. Finally, examples are provided detailing timely studies. First, the preparation of s so porous silica with controlled surface chemistry and subsequent adsorption characteristics is presented, and then the role of silica particles in phase transformation water and heterogeneous nucleation processes in the atmosphere is addressed. n summary, this book contains a wealthof information on adsorption that will be useful not only for newcomers in the field of silica science but also for those with general interest in adsorption phenomena. I am convinced that much progress will be made in the near future, following the d e v e l o p ~ e n of t moreexacttheoriesandtheappearance of moresophisticatedanalytical
methods (e.g., nano~icroscopies) allowing scientists to examine adsorption at the molecular level along with powerful computer s i ~ u l a t i o n , I twill not be very long before another comple~entaryvolume on this subject is necessary. I would like to thank all the contributors, who prepared excellent chapters. I acknowledge the dynamism and constant support of the publish in^ team at Marcel Deltker, Inc.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Preface iii Contri~utors xi 1. Brief Historical Review andCurrentState-of-the-Art Unger Dipika
of Silica
1
Infrared and N M R Characterization of the Silica Surface 9 Barry A . D. 3.
Silica SurfaceChemicalProperties G a ~ aM l . S. El Shajii
35
4.
Adsorptionon Silica Surfaces 63 Vla~i~ir
5.
Nanoscale and Mesoscale Morphology of Henri Van
6.
Ther~ogravi~etric Approach for Determining Porosity of Silica Gels 16’7
Silica Surfaces
119
Jncek
7. Surface Energetics of Silica Investigated by Inverse Gas Chromatography 205 Eugine Henri Vergelati vii
olecular Dynamics Simulation of Polyatomic Molecules in ode1 Silica Pores 243
Aleksander
ehaviorat Silica Surfaces 277 Jonathan P. and M . Dove 10. SurfaceandInterfaceStructure Jacques 11.
of Silicas 297
e ChargeandZetaPotential of Silicain ic SolventsandWater 343
Mixtures of
~arek
12. AdsorptiononIon-~ombarded Gianfranco ~erofolini,L.
Silica
rption of Heavy Metal Cations on
369
Silica
399
ification of Silica-Water Interfacial ehavior by Adsorption rfactants,Polymers,andTheirMixtures 441
Zhang olynler and Polyelectrolyte ~dsorption-Stability of ilica Suspensions 463 16. Adsorption and Chemisorption of Enzymes and Other Natural Macromolecules on Silicas 523
~ertykh
17. Adsorption on Silica Surfaces from Solution and Its Impact onChromatographicSeparationTechniques 565 D~ika V. ~ h w a l d ,
18. Adsorption of Polydimethylsiloxane Chains on Plane Silica Surfaces Liliane Liger, Hubert Hervet, ~ a r t i a Deruelle l 19. Adsorption of PDMS on BareFumed Silica Surfaces 621 Jean-Pierre Cohen
645
20.
Modulation of Silica Pathogenicity by SurfaceProcesses Bice and W i l ~ i aE.~ Wallace
21.
DesigningSurfaceChemistryinMesoporous Glen E. Fryxell Jun
22.
Fumed Silica as a Host for Study of Large Surface-to-~olume Ratio Problems in Finely Divided Aqueous Systems: ~ m ~ l i c a t i o nfor s theAtmosphere 689
Bogdan Index
747
Silica
665
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Institut de Chimie des Surfaces et Interfaces, Mulhouse, France Department of Physics, Universityof Helsinki, Helsinki, Finland Institute of Physics,University
of Silesia,
Poland STMicroelectronics,Agrate,Italy Department
of Physics, University Joseph
Fourier, Grenoble, France
V. Lomonosov
Department of Chemistry, M. Moscow State University, Moscow, Russia
e Rhodia-Silicone,Rhodia,SaintFons,France School of EarthandAtmospheric Institute of Technology, Atlanta, Georgia
Sciences, Georgia
Institutfur ~norganische ChemieundAnalytischeChemie, Johannes Gutenberg-Universit~t, Mainz, Germany Department of Chemistry,Faculty
of Science, Ain
Department of Material Sciences, Battelle Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, Richland, Washington Department of Inorganic, Physico-Chemical, and Material Chemistry, University of Torino, Torino, Italy Department of Chemistry,SimonFraserUniversity,Burnaby, British Columbia, Canada Department of Adsorption and Planar Chromatograp~y, Maria Curie Sklodowska University, Lublin, Poland Institut fur Anorganische Chemie und Analytische Chemie, Johannes Gutenberg-Universitat, Mainz, Germany Laboratoire de Physique des Fluides France, Paris, France
Organiscis, Coll6ge de
r Applied Geology and Geochemistry, Northwest National Laboratory, Richland, Washington
InstitutfurTechnischeChemie,TechnischeUniversitat Munchen, Garching bei Munchen, Germany Department of Electrochemistry, Technical University of Lublin, Lublin, Poland, and Department of Physical Chemistry, Abo Akademi, Abo, Finland ar InstitutfurAnorganischeChemieundAnalytischeChemie, Johannes Gutenberg-Universitat, Mainz, Germany r
LaboratoiredePhysiquedesFluidesOrganisks,
Department of Material Sciences, Battelle Pacific National Laboratory, Richland, Washington
Coll6ge de
Northwest
EniChem, Centro Ricerche di Novara, Novara, Italy Department of Chemistry, University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
r InstitutdeChimiedesSurfacesetInterfaces,Mulhouse, France Universitk Franche Comtk-UFR de Techniques, BesanCon, France
Sciences et
Department of Chemistry, University of Perugia, Perugia, Italy HenryKrumbSchool New York, New York
of Mines,ColumbiaUniversity,
Institute of Surface Chemistry, National Academyof Sciences, Kiev, Ukraine Institut AnorganischeChemieundAnalytischeChemie, Johannes Gutenberg-Universitat, Mainz, Germany e* Centre de Recherche sur la Matiire Diviske, CNRS, and Universitk d'Orlkans, Orlkans, France Rhcine Poulenc Industrialisation, CR Carriires, Saint Fons, France U.S.NationalInstitute Health, Morgantown, West Virginia
OccupationalSafetyand
lskii Institute of SurfaceChemistry,NationalAcademy Sciences, Kiev, Ukraine
of
Henry Krumb School of Mines, Columbia University, New York, New York
"Current Laboratoire de Physico-Chirnie, Structurale et Macrornolkculaire, Ecole SupCrieure de Physique et Chirnie Industrielles, Paris, France.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Anorganische fur Institut Chemie und Analytische Chemie, Johannes ~utenberg-Universitat,Mainz, Germany
I.
1
Classical Period
11. Microparticulate Porous 111. SilicaAdvances Sol-Gel in
Silicas for Chromatographic Separations 2 2 Chemistry
IV. Mesostructured 2 Silica Materials V. Perspectives References
4 4
Following the invention of silica sols and gels in the 1920s and the manufacture of pyrogenic silica in the 1940s, finely dispersed and porous silicas became a subject of intensive research and development during the period 1950 to 1970. A number of internationally reputed scientists from both academic and industrial backgrounds havemadesubstantialcontributionsto this field, including R. K. Iler ( ~ i l m i ~ g t o 'USA), n, H. Bergna [2] ( ~ i l ~ i n g t o USA), n, A. V.Kiselev and his school (Moscow, Russia), C. Okkerse (Vlaardingen, The Netherlands), D. Barby [3] (Warrington, US), J.T.Fripiat(Orleans,France), A. Morrow(Ottawa, Canada), K. S. W. Sing (Fairfield, UK), and H. K. Ferch (Hanau,Germany), among others. During this period the formation of colloidal silicas, pyrogenic silica and silica xerogels, and precipitated silicas was studied in great depth with the aim of manufacturing products of technical importance with reproducible properties. These
materials have found widespread application as fillers, lubricants, and adsorbents. The annual production amounts to about onemillion metric tons. Comprehensive studies were also undertaken to characterizethe silica surface in order to assess its adsorption behavior and its chemical reactivity. This led to a family of silica-based derivatives with controlled surface functionalities ranging from hydrophobic to polar surface characteristics.
The aforementioned achievements prepared the way for refined silica adsorbents which were chemically tailored and hence employed in chronlatographic separations, mainly in the liquid phase [4].Between theyears 1970 and 1980, n-alkyl silanized mesoporous spherical silicas were developed, which created the basis for the advancement of so-called reverse-phase high-performance liquid chromatograPLC) [5-71. This separation method is currently widely employed for the high~resolutioll separation of complex mixturesin the chemicaland p ~ a r ~ a c e u t i c a l industries, as well as environmental, food, and toxicological analysis. The main factor contributing to its success was the development of synthetic pathways in which both the pore structural properties andparticle size distribution of the silica spheres were adjusted and controlled during the manufacturing process. Apart from hydrophobic silanized silicas, other chemically bonded silicas have been synthesized with aspecifically desired type, density, and topographyof ligands [S]. These types of tailored adsorbents are not only employed for high-resolution analytical separation but also in process chromatography where they are used for the purification and isolation of value-added synthetic and natural products.
In the 1980s a renaissancein silica chemistry appeared whichwas rooted in the field of sol-gel chemistry [S]. During the course of this period, nanostructured silicas were synthesized as nanoparticles, monoliths, and coatings. These achievements were primarily accomplished due to the use of high-resolution spectroscopic and other related techniques, which enabled researchers to elucidate the mechanism of formation at nanoscale dimensions and, thus, to analyze the surface properties in greater detail than was previously done. This field is still a major focus of research and development.
Initiated by theadvances of the te~plate-drivensynthesis of silica-rich, highly shape-selective zeolites, such as in the 1970s, researchers of the Mobil Oil Corporation recently developed anew family of ordered mesoporous silica [lo-121. This materials breakthrough was accomplished by using surfactant liquid crystals (with longn-alkyl chains) as structure-directing agents to produce a new generation of silicate and alu~inosilicate mesoporous molecularsieves (MMS) in the 1990s [3-
151 A thorpugh controlof pore size was attained with pore diameters tunable from 15 to 300 A and narrow poresize distributions. Furthermore, the materialspossess very high specific surface areas 700 m2/g) and pore volumes. reck and his team at Mobil Oil Corporation designated this family of mesoporous silicas as M41S, which consists of hexagonal phase (pbm) referred to as MCM-41, a cubic phase (Ia3d) known as M ~ ~ - 4and 8 , alamellar phase knownas MCM-50 [12]. These materials were synthesized in basic solutions in which silicate oligoanions (I-) are structured by the cationic surfactant (S"). Extensive research led to the conclusion that, during the synthesis of these materials, mesostructured silica/organic assemblies were formed owing to electrostatic interactions, which in turn formed periodic structures. ~ostsyntheticremoval of the surfactant species yielded an ordered mesoporous silica, namely ~ C ~or ~- C ~~ - l 4This 8 . discovery has, indeed, inspired scientists on a global scale to research creatively into the design, synthesis, modification, and application of these materials 16-18] Stemming from the pioneering research of Mobil scientists, a whole new range 1s have been synthesized ranging from imperfectly ordered [19], KIT [20], and MSU [21-241, to orderedsilicas, such as and SBA [28,29]. Allthese novel materials require a structuredirecting agent for their formation the latter organic molecules can be cationic [30-351, anionic, gemini 1361, orneutralsurfactants [37-391 and larger triblock copolymers [40-44]. When the template is changed, the surfactant (S) and inorganic (I) interaction is modified (S"I", S'X-I", SoIo,S-I'); the properties of the resulting material are affected, such as the porewall chemistry, surfacesilanol concentration, thermal and hydrothermal stability, and pore size. The painstaking investigation into the synthesis mechanism of the assembly of these materials enabled researchersto realize that factors such as the temperature, precursors, additives, surfactant, and concentration of reagents were certainly cting the chemistry at the inorganic/organic interface in the reaction mixture and hence the physicochemical nature of the product.Several synthesis mechanisms have been developed throughout the world by employing a number of techniques and various synthesis media [45-511. ~nderstandingthe mechanism of formation of these mesostructured materials laid the foundations for thesynthesis of silicas with highly defined pore size, pore shape, and pore dimensionality; hence, materials for which the adsorption behavio was thoroughly studied [52,53]. Moreover, these mechanistic concepts were successfully applied to other oxidic mesoporous adsorbents.As the wallsof these materials did not consist of crystalline material, research over the last five to six years has shown that one can dictate the framework composition from silicates to metallosilicates [54,55] (e.g., Al, V, Ti-silicates) to nonsilicates such as Nb, Al, Zr, Zr-P, and Ti-P oxides, and sulphates and aluminophosphates [56-651. One of the most recent advances has been the use of block coEolymers 140-441 for the preparation of mesoporous materials with pores 300 A. Furthermore, scientists have been able to fabricate mesoporous silica thin films [66-691, spheres [38,70-773, fibers [78], and monoliths [79] using sol-gel chemistry and emulsion chemistry [80-821.
er
So it appears that materialsscientists, in the truesense of the word, are researching in new realms of creativity to design mesoporous materials of controllable size, morphology, and chemical composition with pore sizes spanning the entire mesopore range for numerous current and potential applications including catalysis, sensors, separations, and optoelectronics.
With the knowledge accumulated so far it seems realistic to suggest that the scale of tailoring the pore sizes of high regularity will extend from the microporous to that of the whole mesoporous range. In addition to this, the macroscaledimensions, i.e., particle formation, can be controlled in such a way as to produce monodispersed nanoparticles, submicron-sized particles, and particles in the millimeter size range. Monolithic silicas with bimodal and multimodal pore size distributions are in their initial phase of processing using organosilicate composites as synthetic intermediates. Silica surfaces can also be functionalized and imprinted to yield a high selectivity and specificity with respect to molecular recognition. The advances in modern silica chemistry will have a substantial impact on the development of miniaturized high-resolution analyticalsystems, sensors, and other devices.
1. R. K. Iler, The Chemistry Silica, Wiley Interscience. New York, 1979. 2. H. E. Bergna. The Colloid C~emistrysilica? Advances in Chemistry Series 234, American Chemical Society, Washington D.C., 1994. D. Barby, in C~aracterization Powder S ~ r f a c e s D. Parfitt and K. S. W. Sing, eds.), Academic Press, London, 1976, pp. 353-421. 4. K. K. Unger, Porous Silica Its Prop~rtiesand Use as a Support in C o ~ ~ m Liquid n Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1979. Chro~atograp~zy, K.K. Unger, Packings and S t a t i o ~ a rPhases ~ in Clzromatograp~icT e c h ~ i ~ u e ~ s , Marcel Dekker, New York, 1990. 6. R. P. Scott, Silica and Bonded Phases, John Wiley and Sons, New York, 1993. 7. M. J.J. Hetem, Chemically Silica Swfaces in Chromatography, ~undamental Study,Hiithig Verlag, Heidelberg, 1993. 8. E. F. Vansant,P.vanderVoort,and K. Vrancken, Characteri~atio~ ~ o d ~ c a t i oofnthe Silica S ~ r j a c eElsevier, , Amsterdam, 1995. 9. C. Brinker and G. W. Schereer, Academic Press, London, 1990. 10. T.Kresge, E. Leonowicz, W. J. Roth, J. C. Vartuli, and J. Beck. Nature, 359710 (1992). 11. J. Beck, C. T,Chu, I. D. Johnson, C. Kresge, E. Leonowicz, W. J. Roth, and J. C. Vartuli, US.Patent 5,108,725 to Mobil Oil Corporation (1992). 12. J. Beck, J. C. Vartuli, W. J.Roth, M. E. Leonowicz,C. Kresge, K. D. Schmitt,C. W. Chu, D. H. Olson, E. W.Sheppard, S. B. McCullen, J. B. Higgins, and J. L. Schlenker. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 114:10834 (1992).
13. J. C. Vartuli, C. T. Kresge, M. E. Leonowicz, A. S. Chu, S. B. McCullen, I. D. Johnson, and E. W. Sheppard. Chem. Mater. 6: 1816 (1994). 14. J. C. Vartuli, C. T. Kresge, E. Leonowicz, S. Chu, S. B. McCullen, I. D. Johnson, and E. Slzeppard. Chem. Mater. 6:2070 (1994). 15. C. Vartuli, K. D. Schmitt, C. T. Kresge, J. Roth, M. E. Leonowicz, S. B. McCullen, S. D. Hellring, J. S. Beck, J. L.Schlenker, D. H. Olson,and E. Sheppard. Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal. 8453 (1994). 16. A. Corma and D. Kumar, in Trends ~ f f t e ~ i fCf l~s e ~ i(R. ' ~Catlow t ~ ~and A. Cheetham,eds.), NATO AS1Series,KluwerAcademicPublishers,498:403 997). 17. A. Sayari and P. Liu. Microporous Mater. 12:149 (1997). 18. D. M. Anotelli and J. Y. Ying. Curr. Opin. Colloid Interface Sci. 1:523 (1996). 19. P. T. Tanev, and T. J. Pinnavaia. Science 267:865 (1995). 20. Y. H. Yu, Y. Sun, and Gao. Cat. Lett. 47: 167 (1997). 21. S. A.Bagshaw, T. Kemmitt, andN. B. Milestone. Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 22:419 (1998). 22. S. Bagshaw, F. DiRenzo, and F. Fajula. Chern. Comm. 18:2209 (1996). 23. X. M. Zhang, R. Zhang, J. S. Suo, and S. B.Li. Chem. Lett. 8:755 (1988). 24. P. T. Tanev, Ye Liang, and T. J. Pinnavaia. Am. Chem. Soc. 119:8616 (1997). 25. T. Ishikawa, M. Matsuda, Yasukawa, K. Kandori, S. Inagaki, T. Fukushirna, and S. Kondo. J. Chem. Far. Trans. 92:1985 (1996). 26. K. Hamaguchi and H. Hattori. React. Kinet. Catal. Lett. 61:13 (1997). 27. S. Inagaki and Y. Fukushima. Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 21567 (1998). 28. W. Z. Zhou, H. M, A. Hunter, P. Wright, Q. F. Ge, and J. M.Thomas. J. Phys. Chern. B 1025933 (1998). Y. Zhao, Q. S. Huo, J. L.Feng,B. F. Chmelka, and C. D. Stucky. J. Am. 29. Chem. Soc. 120:6024 (1998). 30. G. D. Stucky, Q. Huo, Firouzi, B. F. Chmelka, S. Schacht, I. G. Voigt-Martin, and F. Schiith. Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal. 105:3 (1996). 31. Q. Huo, D. I. Margolese, U. Ciesla, D. G. Dernuth, P. Feng, T. Gier, P. Sieger, A. Firouzi, B. F. Chrnelka, F. Schiith, and C. D. Stucky. Chem. Mater. 6:1176 994). 32. Q. Huo, D. I.Margolese, U. Ciesla, P. Feng, T. E. Gier, P. Sieger, R. Leon, P. Petroff, F. Schiith, and G. Stucky. Nature 368:317 (1994). 33. C. Glinka, J. Nicol, G. D. Stucky, E. Ramli, D. Margolese,and Q. Huo, in in P Q ~ Q U ~S f f t e r i f f lMater. s; Res. Proc., (S. Kornarneni, D. M. Smith, and J. S. Beck, eds.), Materials Research Society, Pittsburgh, P. A. 1995, 371, p. 47. 34. L. M. Bull, D. Kumar, S. P. Millar, T. Besier, M. Janicke, C. D. Stucky, and B. F. Chmelka. Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal. 84:429 (1994). Monnier, F. Schiith, Q. Huo, D. Margolese, D. Kumar, M. 35. G. D. Stucky, Krishnamurty, P.Petroff, A. Firouzi, M. Janicke, and B. F. Chmelka. Mol. Cryst. Liq. Cryst. 240:240 (1994). 36. Q. Huo, R. Leon, P. Petroff, and G. D. Stucky. Science 268: 1324 (1995). 37. R. Mokaya and W. Jones. J. Chem. Soc. Chern. Comm. 8:981 (1996). 38. M. Griin, Lauer, and K. K. Unger. Adv. Mater. 9:254 (1997).
39. E. Prouzet and T. J. Pinnavaia. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed, Engl. 36:516 (1997). 40. A. Bagshaw, S. A. Prouzet, and J. Pinnavaia. Science269:1242(1995). 41. A. Tuel and S. Gontier. Chem. Mat. 8:114(1996). 42. P. T. Tanev and T. Pinnavaia. Science 271:1267 (1996). 43. M. Templin, A. Franck, A. D. Chesne, H. Leist, Zgang, R. Ulrich, U. Schadler, and U.Wiesner, Science 278:1795 (1997). 44. D. Zhao, J. Feng, Q. Huo, N. Melosh, C. H. Fredrickson, B. F. Chmelka, and G. D. Stucky. Science 279:548 (1998). 45. A. Monnier, F. Schiith, Q. Huo, D. Kumar, D. Margolese, R. S. Maxwell, G. D. Stucky, M. Krishnamurty, P. Petroff, A. Firouzi, M. Janicke, and B. F. Chmelka. Science 261: 1299(l 993). 46. A. Firouzi, D. Kumar, L. Bull, T. Besier, P. Sieger, Q. Huo, S. A. Walker, J. A. Zasadzinski, C. Glinka, J. Nicol, D. Margolese, C. D. Stucky, and B. F. Chmelka. Science 267:1139 (1995). 47. A. Firouzi, F. Atef, A. G. Oertli, G. D. Stucky, and B. F. Chmelka. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 119:3596 (1997). 48. C. U. Chen, S. Q. Xiao, and M. E. Davis. Microporous Mater. 4: 1 (1995). 49. C. U. Chen, H. X. Li, and E. Davis. Microporous Mater. 2: 17 (1993). 50. C. Y. Chen, S. L. Burkett, H. X. Li, and M. E. Davis, Microporous Mater. 2:27 (1993). 51. A. C. Voegtlin, F. Ruch, J. L. Guth, J. Patarin, and L. Huve. Microporous Mater. 9:95 (1997). 52. P. J. Branton, P. G. Hall, and K. S. W. Sing. J. Chem. Soc. Chem. Comm. 16:1257 (1993). 53. P. L. Llewellyn, Y. Grillet, F. Schiith, and H. Reichert. Microporous Mater. 3:345 (1994). 54. Kolodziejski,A.Corma, M.T.Navarro,and J. Pkrez-Pariente.Solid State Nucl. Magn. Reson., 2:253 (1993). 55. M. Janicke, D. Kumar, G. D. Stucky, and B. F. Chmelka. Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal. 84:243 1994). 56.A.Imhof and D. Pine. Nature, 389:948(1997). 57. F. Vaudry, Khodabandeh, and M. E. Davis. Chem. Mater. 1451 (1996). 58. A. Bagshaw and T. J. Pinnavaia. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 35:1102 (1996). 59. D. M. Antonelli and J. Y. Ying. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 34:2014 (1995). 60. D. M. Antonelli and J. Y. Ying. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 35:426 (1996). 61. M. Antonelli and J. Y. Ying. Chem. Mater. 85374(1996). 62. Z, R. Tian, W. Tong, J. Y. Wang, N. G. Duan, V.V. Krishan, and S. L. Suib. Science 267:926 (1997). 63. T. Holland, P, K. Isbester, C. F. Blanford, E. J. Munson, and A. Stein. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 119:6796 (1997). 64. Zhao, Luan, and L. Kevan. Chem. Comm. 11:1009 (1997). 65. U.Ciesla, Schacht, G. D. Stucky, K. K. Unger, and F. Schiith. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 35:541 (1996). 66. H. Sang, N. Coombs, 1. Sokolov, and G. A. Ozin. Nature 381:589 (1996). 67. I. A. Aksay, M. Trau, I. Honma, N. Yao, L. Zhou, P. Fenter, P. M.Eisenberger, and S. M. Gruner. Science 2732392 (1996).
68. S. H. Tolbert, T. E. Schaffer, J. Feng, K. Hansrna, and G. D. Stucky. Chern. Mater. 9:1962 (1997). E. Martin, M. Anderson, J. G. Odinek, and P.P. Newcomer.Langmuir 69. 13:4133 (1997). 70. Q. Huo, Feng, F. Schuth, and G. D. Stucky. Chem. Mater. 9: 14 (1997). 71. P. J. Bruinsrna, A. Y. Kim, J. Liu, and S. Baskaran. Chern. Mater. 9:2S07 (1997). 72. S. Schacht, Q. Huo, I. G. Voigt-Martin, G. D. Stucky, and F. Schuth.Science 273:768 (1996). 73. M. Grun, Lauer, K. K. Unger, A. Matsomoto, and T. Tutsurni. Adv. Mater. 3:254 (1997). 74. G. Buchel, M.Grun, K.K. Unger, A. Matsumoto, and K. Tsutsurni. Supramolec. Sci. 5:2S3 (1998). 7s. K. Schumacher, M.Grun and K. K. Unger. Microporous Mesoporous Mater., in press. 76. K. Schurnacher, C. du Fresne von Hohenesche, K. K. Unger, R. Ulrich, A. du Chesne, U. Wiesner, and H. W. Spiess. Adv. Mater., submitted. 77. M. Grun, K. K. Unger, A. Matsurnoto, and K. Tutsurni. Microporous Mesoporous Mater., in press. 78. Q. Huo, D. Zhao, J. Feng, K. Weston, S. K. Buratto, and G. D. Stucky. Adv. Mater., 9974 (1997). 79. M. T. Anderson, J. E. Martin, J. G.Odinek, P. P. Newcomer, and J. Wilcoxon. Microporous Mater 13 (1997). 80. D. Velev, T. A. Jede, and R. F. Lobo. Nature 389:447 (1997). 81. S. Schacht, Q. Huo, I. G. Voigt-Martin, G. D. Stucky, and F. Schuth. Science 273:768 (1996). 82. M. Ogawa. Chern. Soc. Chem. Comrn. 1O:1149 (1996).
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Department of Chemistry, Universityof Ottawa, Ottawa, ent of Chemistry, Simon Fraser University, Burnaby, British C o l ~ l ~ b iCanada a,
Introduction I. TI. ~ibrationalSpectroscopy General spectral features and surface silanol groups B. Low-wavenumber spectral data C. Siloxane sites 111. NMR Spectroscopy 'H spectroscopy B. 2 9 ~spectroscopy i C. l70spectroscopy References
9 10 10 15 18 20 23 26 29
30
In a bookwhich is concerned with adsorption on silica surfaces it is first necessary to describe the nature of the silica surface, and several sections of this chapter will deal with aspectsof this problem. In this chapter, we will describe two of the most widely used spectroscopic techniqueswhich have been used to characterize thesilica surface andadsorbed species thereon;vibrationalspectroscopy and solid-state P" spectroscopy.Theformerhas beenused foroverfortyyears and is so pervasive that it is now widely used to study adsorbed species on surfaces under several guises, such as trans~issioninfrared (IR), Rarnan, diffuse reflectance IR (DRIFTS), photoacoustic IR, and total reflectance IR. On the other hand, solidstate NMR is relatively new as applied to studies of surfaces, the methodology is
rrow
still under active development, and some appropriate background material will be presented. The two techniquesare far more powerful when combined in asingle study than the sum of their contributions would suggest. This synergy results from the complementary information which each technique can produce, which in turn can point to additional experiments for the other technique. Thus, whereas vibrational spectroscopy can provide detailed information regarding hydrogen bonding, physical adsorption, and chemisorption,it cannot readily determine if a species on the surface is mobile, nor can it give a quantitative measure of the number of adsorbed species of various types without cumbersome calibrations to determine extinction coefficients which themselvescan vary accordingto surface coverage.NMR, on the otherhand,canprovidequantitativedata relative to the absolutenumbers of adsorbed species and it can provide information relative to the motional freedom of these species. Both methods yield qualitative data relative to the structure of adsorbed species, via the well-known group frequency conceptin vibrational spectroscopy, and chemical shift data in NMR. This can beused to determine the nature of the functional groups present either on the surface of silica itself, or in adsorbed species. Apartfromits historical position ofbeing developedahead of solid-state NMR,IR spectroscopyremains so populartodayas an analytical technique because current Fourier transform IR (FTIR) spectrometers are very inexpensive and an IR spectrum under favorable circumstances can be recorded in about one second. Although some special sampling techniques are required, these again are inexpensive and it is very easy to obtain spectra of samples under vacuum or in the presence of a controlled atmosphere, however reactive that atmosphere is. On theotherhand, solid-state NMR requires expensive equipment(abouttenfold more so thanFTIRinstrumentation)andthe sensitivity is much less, often requiring data acquisition times lo2 to lo4 longer. Further, if samples are to be sampledinvacuum or undercontrolledatmosphericconditions,then NMR probeshave to bespecially constructed to withstandthe rigors of spinning sealed-in-glass samples at about 3 kHzusingthemagicanglespinning(MAS) method. This chapter will give a brief overview of the utilization of both methods for studying the surface of silica. Some examples of the power of the combined use of these methods havebeen published
Vibrational spectroscopy has had a profound effect on our understanding of the surface chemistry of silica. Indeed, it has been the model system for the use of IR spectroscopy for probing the surface chemistry of oxides, the first studies having been carried out in late 1950. The books written by Hair [3] and Little [4] in the 1960s have become “classics” with respect to the early use of IR spectroscopy for studying the surface properties of silica and adsorbed species thereon.
The most common method which has been used to record the IR spectrum of silica has been to compact a high-surface-area silica (200 to 300 m2/g) into a selfsupporting disk which contains from to 10 mg of SiOz per cm2. By using this preparation technique the disk can then be conveniently mounted in a suitable vacuumchamberwheresubsequentvacuumactivationcan be carried out in order to remove adsorbed water or other contaminants, and adsorption experiments at the gas-solid interface can easily be carried out. This chapter will only be concerned with infrared studies of silica in vacuum and/or in the presence of an adsorbate. The IR spectrum of a typical self-supporting disk of a pyrogenic or fumed silica after heating under vacuum for1 h at 150°C is shown in Fig. 1A. Pyrogenic or fumed silicas (some trade names are Aerosiland Cab-0-Sil) are made by the flame hydrolysis of SiCI4 at 1000°C. These nonporous silicas have a low bulk density, and adsorbed water canbe removed by evacuation at 20°C. However, the spectral properties are identical when evacuation is carried out at 150°C; evacuation at the latter temperature is preferred in order to remove any trace impurities which maybe present. The spectrum is characterized by a sharp absorption band at 3747 cm-' with a broad tail to low wavenumber having a maximum near 3550 cm-' (see Fig. 2A for an expanded view). The sharp peak is due to the OH stretching vibration of isolated non-hydrogen-bondedSiOH or Si(OH)2 groups and the broad tail having a peak near 3550 cm" is due to these groups when they are H-bonded. The weak broad features between 2000 and 1300
0
A,IR spectrum of a self-supporting diskof silica, and B, a thin film of In both cases the silica had been heated under vacuum at 150°C for l h.
0
c m -1
IR spectra of Si02 disks: A, after activation under vacuumat 150°C, and B, 450°C; C, the difference spectrum, i.e., subtraction of curve B from A.
cm"' are due to overtones and combination modes of bulk Si02 vibrations and the region of total absorption between 1300-1000cm" and from 850-750 cm-l are due to absorption of IR radiation by bulk modes of Si02. The latter vibrational modes also are common properties of silica gel and precipitated silica, although there are differences in the region associated with theOH stretching modes of the various silanol groups. These differences will be discussed later after we have considered the silanol spectral region of a fumed silica in more detail. The IR spectrum in the OH stretching region shown on an expanded wavenumber scale in Fig. 2A. Additional weak features near 3720 and 3650 cm" can be discerned and we will comment on these later. The hydrogen-bonded hydroxyls start to condense to liberate water when silica is heated above 15OoC,the reaction being [5]:
I
Si
The majority of the H-bonded silanols condense in this way when silica isheated at 450°C under vacuum, and a typical IR spectrum is shown in Fig. There is an intensified peak at 3747 cm" due to isolated silanols and an asymmetric tail to low wavenumber.
The spectral changes are more clearly seen from “difference” spectra, that is, subtracting the spectrum for the 450°C activated sample from the 150°C one, as shown in Fig. 2C. Peaks going down represent new features which are created upon heatingfrom l50 to 450°C and peaksgoing up representspectral features lost during the heat treatment. Consider a chain of H-bonded silanols which contain an odd number of OH groups. In the example of three OH groups below, the terminal OH which is not H-bonded absorbs at 3720 cm-l, whereas those which are H-bonded absorb at about 3550 cm-’. Heating results in the process:
which creates one siloxane site, one water molecule, and an isolated SiOH group (3747 cm”). The net effect is an increase in the number of isolated SiOH groups and an increase in the intensity of the 3747 cm-’ IR band; this would not occur if the chain contained an even number of OH groups. Although IR spectroscopy is admirably able to distinguish between hydrogenbonded and free silanols, it is not able to differentiate between single or geminal hydroxyls; NMR, however, can make this distinction and this aspect will be discussed later in Section 111. A fully hydroxylated silica of whatever origin contains about 4.6 OH groups of all types per nm2. Heating to about 450°C reduces this number to about l .4/nm2. has It been known for many years13-51 that as long as the silica is not heated above about 450”C, the processes illustrated in reaction schemes (l) and (2) are reversible(wewill discuss later what happens if higher temperatures are used). There is a weak spectral feature near 3650 cm-l which can be seen in Fig. and 2C. This is known to be due to SiOH groups which are perturbed by interparticle contact; such OH groups are inaccessible to many reactants, depending on their steric size[7,8]. This effect is illustrated in Fig. 3,which showsthe stretching region of a silica which had been heated under vacuum at 150°C (Fig. 3A), the spectrum after complete reaction with TiC14 (Fig. 313) and the difference spectrum (Fig. 3C). The last spectrum (3C) is that of the silanol groups which have reacted. The reaction withTiC14 is veryfast and is complete (i.e., there no further spectral change) after about 60 [7,8]. The basic initial reactions are: Si0H
TiCI,
cl+
SiOTiCl,
HCl
(3)
Si0 TiC1, I-
TiC1,
(4)
Si0H can be seen in Fig. 3, although all of the isolated silanols (3747 cm”) and most of the H-bonded silanols (3550 cm-’) react, there is a large residual peak near 3650 cm-’, due to the silanols which are inaccessible to this reactant.
00
spectrum of a disk of fumed silica after heating under vacuum at 150°C for 1 h. B, IR spectrum of A after complete reaction with excess Tiel4. C, difference spectrum curve minus curve B showing the spectral changes as a result of the reaction with TiC14.
~e have previously shown that the number of residual inaccessible silanols (the intensity of the 3650 cm-' peak) after complete reaction with different reactive hydrogen sequestering agents increases as the steric size of the reactant increases [7,8]. Silanol groups also undergo H/D exchange with deuterated alcohols (ROD) and in the same studywe examined theeffect of the steric size of R on the extent of exchange of these perturbed SiOH or Si(OH)2 groups. Although fumed silicas are favored for IR spectroscopic studies, gels and precipitated silicas are more commonlyused for N M R studies because of their greater bulk density, and therefore, greaterconcentration of surface species perunit
volume. Indeed, muchof the workto be described later in the contextof NMR,and in later chapters, is relative to gels and precipitated silicas. The groups of Burneau and Lavalley [9-1 11 in France have carried out extensive vibrational investigations of the silanol groups on fumed silica, silica gel, and precipitated silica. Thenumber of silanol groups which are inaccessible toa reactant is generallygreateron gels and precipitatedforms ofsilica thanon fumed silicas, but this is mainly due to the mesoporous nature of these materials. Moreover, we haveconfirmed that this is true evenin the special case of a nonporous precipitated silica which was studied comparatively relative to fumed silica [8]. Although gels and precipitated silicas show spectral features which are similar to fumed silica when activated under vacuum at 450°C or higher (namely a relatively sharp IR band at 3747cm" due to isolated silanols), for room temperature or 150°C activation there is generally a much more intense "band" due to and inaccessible silanols than is observed in the caseof a fumed silica [8illustrates this point for a precipitatedsilica, and should be compared with Fig. 3 insofar as the identical manipulation was carried out, Fig. 3being relative to a fumed silica, Fig. 4 for a precipitatedsilica. Note that the region associatedwith the inaccessible silanols (3650 cm") and the H-bonded silanols (3550 cm-') is much more intense both before and after reaction with Tic& for the (particularly compare the spectra after complete reaction, Figs reader is referred to the literature for a more detailed IR comparison of these materials [8-121.
Much of the earlier IR work which was related to the adsorption of molecules on silica was concerned with studying the disappearance of features associated with SiOH stretching vibrations, and, if applicable, looking at the appearance of new features due to adsorbed species [3-51. This has been relatively straightforward if theadsorbedmoietycontainsa "light" functionalgroup,generallyone which containsahydrogenatom.Therefore,adsorbed specieswhich contain CH, or NH, functionalities are easily detected because their CH or NH stretching and deformation vibrations lie above 1300 cm". Below this, self-supporting disks of silica are opaque to IR radiation except for two regions of partial transparency between 1000 and 850 cm-' and from about '750 to 550 cm" (see Fig. M ) . (The situation is more extreme for disks of other oxides, e.g., Ai2@, Ti02, or Zr02, whichare totally absorbing below 1000 to 800 cm-l withoutanywindows of transparency 131.) Accordingly, the traditional methods of IR transmission spectroscopy do not permit access to the low-wavenumber spectral region, a region where most of the important functionalities other than hydrogen are expected to absorb, for example, most metal-oxygen modes, or modes (Y is a transition metal or S, P, etc.). Thus, when TiC14 adsorbs on silica to yield a SiOTiC13 surface species, the SiOTi modesareexpected to lie nearl000cm-' and the TiC13 stretching modes are expected to lie near 500 to 400 cm"' and both spectral regions are inaccessible to IR radiation when using the self-supporting disk IR transmission method.
IR spectrum of a disk of precipitated silica after heating under vacuum at 150°C for h. B, IR spectrum of after complete reaction with excess Tiel4. C, difference spectrum curve minus curve B showing the spectral changes as a result of the reaction with Tiel4.
It can be argued thatothermethodspermit access to the low-wavenumber spectral region, such as Raman spectroscopy and diffuse reflectance spectroscopy ( ~ R I F T S )It . is beyond the scope of this review to comment on the deficiencies of these methods; thereare manywhen compared to the well-understood transmission method, both from the experimental and theoretical points view. In 1984 one of us developed a new method for obtaining IR trans~ission spectral data for adsorbed species on silica [14]. With the then adventof FTIR methods and the ability to carry outspectral subtraction, we reasoned that if the quantity SiOz could be reduced to the extent that even the strongest bulk SiOSi mode was not totally absorbing, then one shouldbe able to detect new vibrational modeseven in spectral regionswherethe silicais strongly absorbing. The reduction in the quantity of adsorbent was achieved by forming a thin film of silica on an optically transparent substrate. The latter was initially NaCl (low-wavenumber limit about 600 cm-'), but more recently this has included ZnSe (500 cm"), KBr (400 cm"),
AgCl (300 cm"), CsI (200 cm-') and silicon 200cm">. Wide-rangemid-IR spectrometers have at best a CsI beam splitter, and the practical low-wavenumber limit of trallsmission is 200 cm-'. (Other beam splitters will permit lower wavenumber access, but at the expense of not being able to observe spectral features in the 4000 to 1000 cm" region, and for surface studies, it is essential to also be able to observe spectra in the latter spectral region.) We will show a recent example of the utility of the method. TheIR spectrum of a thin filmofsilicais shown in Fig. 1B. In spite of therebeingstronginfrared absorptionsat 1100,800, and 480 cm", spectral subtraction of this spectrum from that which is observed following chemisorption of a reactant can yield spectral features which were formerly obscured when using a self-supporting disk. We will illustrate thepower of this methodfromastudy of theadsorption of P(CH3)2Cl on silica, a reaction which eventually yields a stable SiOP= O(CH3)2 surface species [l]. (In that study, shifts and 31P solid-state NMR wereused to confirm the identity of the surface species.) Figure 5 (top) shows the spectra (1500-750 cm") of silica before (solid curve) and after (dotted curve) the reaction, respectively. Figure 5 (bottom) shows the difference spectrum at about ten times the original absorbance scale. Allof the peaks are better resolved and the peaksat 1244 cm" (peak A) and 1045 cm-' (peak B), which previously could notbe clearly seen, are characteristic of P = O and SiOP
1600
860
Top: thin-film spectra of silica before (solid line) and after (dotted line) the chemisorption of P(CH3)2CI. Bottom:differencespectrum (dotted minussolid) scaled about tenfold relative to the top spectra.
vibrational modes respectively. These bands also underwent the expected "0 shift when the reactant was adsorbed on an "0-exchanged silica [l]. The remaining modes, which are due to CH3 deformation and rocking modes, did not exhibit any shift after '*0exchange. The P= 0 and Si0P modes could never be detected using a self-supporting diskof Si02, andthis example serves to illustrate the utility and methodology behind the thin film, or "TF" technique. The method has been extensively used by Tripp and Hair 15-17] to study silane-modified silicas.
The surface of silica also contains siloxane bridges which are generally unreactive although it seems clear that some very reactive metal alkyls such as AlMe3 are capable of reacting as follows [18]: Si0Si
AlMq
Si0AlMe2
SiMe
(5)
However most of the reactive so-called hydrogen-sequestering agentswhich readily react with silanols do not react with the normal unstrained siloxane groups which are present at the surface. An exception occurswhen silica is heated under vacuumat temperatures greater than about 450°C. This causes the remaining low-wavenumber asymmetry of' the residual isolated silanol peak at 3747cm-' to disappear and the peak becomes progressively narrower and more symmetrical, as shown inFig. 6. The peak intensity also decreases as the activation temperature increases, and heating at about 1200°C willresult in complete dehydroxylation.It is been known for sometime that elimination of the isolated hydroxyls yields a surface that is increasingly hydrophobic and the rehydrationby reactions or (2) are increasingly irreversible [3,4]. Accompanying these changesis the growth of a pair of strong IR bands at 908 and 888 cm" (Fig. whose intensity increases as the temperature used to activate the silica increases, reaching a maximum when the silica is totally dehydroxylated [19221. The 908/888 cm" bands, and the weak shoulder near 932 cm", have been attributed to a highly strained four-membered siloxane ring 1231:
The site is highly reactive, facilitating the dissociative chemisorption of H 2 0 , 1,221. The reaction with ammoniaor methanol yields a new ber 3741 cm-') and SiNH2 or Si0CH3 respectively, whereas withwatertwogroupsaregenerated.Sucha dissociative chemisorption of these molecules does not occur on the normal siloxane sites which are present on the surface of silicas which have been heated at temperatures below 450°C. Finally the site also hasa Lewis acidcharacter because itcan facilitate the reversible coordination of pyridine, ammonia, or trimethylamille [20]. The number of these sites is small, being about 0. 15/nm2 for a totally dehydroxylated silica irtyfold fewer thanthe number of silanols on a fully hydroxylated silica. the IR signature of these sites canjust beseenwhen
Inf
0 .B
0.6
0.2
cm”
Infrared spectrum in the region of tbe isolated silanol group (3747 cm”) after heatinga disk in vacuum for1 h atthe indicated temperature in degrees Celsius.
silica is heated at about 500°C under vacuum, the temperatureat which silica starts to become increasingly hydrophobic. Therefore, although limited in number, the importance of these sites probably lies in their extreme reactivity and in discussing the nature of chemisorbed species formed on silicas where reaction temperatures are maintained in excess of 450°C for any length of time, it is important to realize that side reactions with these types of site, in addition to expected reactions with silanols, may occur. Thesesites have also been implicated in the anchoringof some unusual organometallic species on silica, and their importance in the use of silica as a catalyst support for surface organometallic chemistry must not be overlooked. For example,ithas recentlybeen shown [24] that rhenium derivatives can be attachedto silicawhen these sites are present, thea reactionwith 0 3 R e 0 yielding a pair of adjacent SiORe03 species, or with Me3SiORe03 toyield adjacent SiOMe3 and SiORe03. Lastly, Raman spectroscopy hasalso been able to show evidence for other cyclic siloxane sites on silica, the so-called “defect D2 and D l ” sites which are characterized by vibrations near 608 and 490 cm-’ which have been respectively attributed to six- and eight-member ring systems[25,26]. These sites are much less reactive than
1
0.8
0.6
L Q00
Infrared spectrum in the "window" region of partial transparency between 1000-800 cm-'afterheating at thesametemperatureasforFig. 5 showingthe appearance of the 908/888 cmw1 band&asthetemperature of activationunder vacuumincreases.From bottom to top, 1000°C, l lOO"C, and l1 50°C.
the highly strained four-member site andthereader literature for a discussion [25,26].
is referred to the original
can be used to study any nucleus of nonzero spin. In the context of silica es, the nuclei of interest are 'H, "Si, and 1 7 0 . The natural abundances of theseare respectively 99.99%, 4.7%,and0.04%.It is thusapparentthat 170 spectroscopy will be difficult unless enriched samples are used.Apart from nuclear abundance, theintensity an NMR signal is determined by the magnetogyric ratio of the nucleus, y, being proportional to its cube. As a result of this, the per-nucleus signal strengths for 'H, 2p§i, and 1 7 0 are in the ratio 1.0:0.0079:0.0025, and it is is by far the easiest nucleus to observe; indeed it is trivially easy with modern instrumentation to obtain the spectrum of 'H in the surface hydroxyl
layer of a high-area silica sample. Unfortunately, the useful information content of such a spectrum may be rather low infm). NMR of solids presents challenges not foundin NMR of liquids. In particular, the direct magnetic dipolar interaction between nuclei is averaged to zero by isotropic rotation in liquids. This is not the case in solids; the dipolar interaction is often the dominant spectral feature, and becauseit is anisotropic it leads to broad powder patterns with polycrystalline or amorphous samples. Similarly, chemical shift is anisotropic; in liquids it is averaged to its trace, but in solids it is not, and broad powder patterns can again arise. These problems are typically overcome by the experimental techniques of high-power decoupling, and magic angle spinning For an introduction to these techniquesand their chemical applications, see Fyfe [27]. For a more detailed discussion, see Schmidt-Rohr and Spiess [28]. A further difficulty is presented by nuclei which have spin (S for 1 7 0 ) . Such nuclei possess an electric quadrupole moment, and thus interact withelectric field gradients in their environment. This interaction is typically much larger than any other, and can lead to extremely broad powder patterns. For nuclei ofhalf oddinteger spin, the transition is not affected by the quadrupole interaction to first order [29] but the interactionis generally so strong that the second-order term yields significant broadening and line shift, in presently available fields [30]. resolution spectra of quadrupolar nuclei may be obtained via double-axis rotation [31,32], by dynamic angle spinning [33] or by two-dimensional multiple-quantum correlation spectroscopy [34]. The first two of these techniques arevery demanding experimentally, since theyinvolvehigh-speedspinning at two different angles, either simultaneously or sequentially. This is especially true for surface-chemical work where atmospheric integrity is important. The recently developed multiplequantum technique shows much promise, and the first surface studies are beginning to appear [35]. It should be noted that the second-order quadrupole interaction introduces an shift, which remains after anisotropies have been removed by one of the above techniques. This adds to the chemical shift, and the two can only be separated by experiments at different fields, or by estimation of the quadrupole term from a powder pattern. Multiple-quantum spectroscopyis an increasingly important NMR technique. It involvesthegeneration and indirect detection of multiple-quantumcoherence. “Coherence” isused here to mean an off-diagonalelement in thespindensity matrix. spin S has 2 s 1 possible values of the m quantum number, ranging from --S to S. Thus a system of k coupled spins has a total of (2s l)k spin quantum states, and is characterized by a ( 2 s (2s densitymatrix. Each quantum state may be characterized by the quantum number
i
If the density matrix contains a nonzero element connecting states and quantum coherence is said to exist in the spin system [36], where p familiar example is thesingle-quantumcoherencecreated between the states of a single spin by a 90” pulse.
a pand
Only single-quantum coherence can be directly created by RF irradiation, and detected in aspectrometer. ~ultiple-quantumcoherencecan be created by the interplay between irradiation,couplings,anddelays andcan be detected indirectly by reconversion to single-quantum coherence, after a period of evolution. The results are often presented as two-dimensional spectra. There are two potentially important uses of this in surface chemistry. ~ultiple-quantumcoherence can exist in spin systems only if spins are coupled. Thus its observation is direct evidence of such coupling ar-coupled spins in solids can be used to estimate the size of the ates This could be used, for example, probe to the existence pairs on Si02. The other application is tothe high-resolution spectr of quadrupolar nuclei, notedabove. a For odd-integral half spin, iple-quantum coherence between states of the same lml, e.g., the three-quantum coherence between and is not affected to first order by thequadrupolecoupling,buthasa different second-order dependence from the single-quantum 14) transition. Thus t~o-dimensionalcorrelation of the one- and three-quantum spectra permits the a high-resolution spectrum 1341. the great potential advantage over IR spectroscopy that intensity l~easurementis st~aightforward, inprinciple. The intensity of a signal is directly proportional to the total number of spins. Thus relative intensities are obtained from relative areas of resonance lines, and absolute intensities from comparison with a standard. A complication arises from thefinite time required forspin-lattic~ relaxation, the process of thermal equilibration of spins with their surroundings. Normally spectra other than 'H will require signal averaging of many (often thousands scans to obtain a satisfactory sigrral-to-noise ratio. In this situation, the observed signal will be proportional to (1 exp(-t/Tl)), where t is the repetition time for spectral scans, and is the spin-lattice relaxation time. (This assumes exponential relaxation, which is common, but not universal If t is not long compared to the intensity will be reduced, leading to incorrect absolute intensities, to incorrect relative intensities if different resonances are associated with different TIvalues, a not uncommon occurrence. ~nfortunately,there are many papers in the surface-chemical literaturewhere no effort has been made to demonstrate that a sufficiently long t value was used. For spin nuclei of low ~agnetogyricratio, such as 2gSi,the spin-lattice relaxation time can be embarrassingly long, leading to excessive time required for recording of a spectrum; for example delaysof 5 min were required to obtain accurate relative intensities in silicon carbide samples In such a situation it is common to utilize the technique of cross-polarization [40]. In this technique, magnetization is transferred from an abundant nucleus, usually 'H, to the observed nucleus X, e.g., 2gSi. Thishastwoadvantages: in favorable cases, the X nucleus signal is increased in theratio yH/yx, afactor offive inthe case, andthe experimental repetition time is determined not by of X, but by the usually much shorter of *H. For problemsinvolving surfaces, anotheradv cross-polarizationfrom surface-localized H, e.g., in thesurface makes possible the surface-specific observation of the X nucleus, because crosspolarization is not effective over distances exceeding a few angstroms.
i)
With the advantages of cross-polarization goes a disadvantage loss of quantitative accuracy. The signal enhancement is rarely the ideal maximum value quoted above. Cross-polarization takes place under spin-locked conditions, and rotatingframe relaxation of either H or may take place, leading to a reduction in magnetization during the time necessary for cross-polarization. The intensity of the observed signal is thus determined by a competition between cross-polarization and relaxation rates, and is a function of the experimental time interval allowed for cross-polarization. The cross-polarization rate depends on the dipolar coupling between H and X, which varies as rE&. If H and X are not directly bonded, this distance will depend on structural parameters that may notbe known. If the vector is moving, it is the average over the motion that will be relevant. If MAS is used, the rate canbe highly sensitive to the spinning speed [41], although this effect can be reduced by more complicated experiments [42]. Relaxation rates are dependent mainly on the proximity of other spins, particularly 'H, and paramagnetic impurities, and also on the motional frequencies of the relaxingnuclei. None of this inforlnation is likely to be known and there can obviously be large differences betweendifferent species on asurface. The result of this is that neither relative nor absolute intensities obtained with cross-polarization canbe considered reliable unless cross-polarization and relaxation rates have been measured, and corrections made for the effects of the latter.
Not surprisingly, the first reported N M R study on Si02 was the observation of the surface hydroxyls.O'Reilly et al. [43] observed the resonanceon a broadline instrument, and inferred from its Lorentzian shape that the surface protons constitute a dilute, randomly populated dipolar-coupled system [44]. The line shape has been further investigated by Freude et al. [45]. These authors also find Lorentzian lines, but the widths are not quantitatively accounted for by random filling of either a two- or three-dil~ensiollallattice. O'Reilly and coworkers found the line width to be independent of temperatureupto 280°C. Laterworkers [46] observed line narrowing above 150"C, which was attributed to proton diffusion on the surface. Certainly narrowing must occur when the motional frequency becomes comparable to the static line width. Possibly this occurs at different temperatures for different silica preparations. It has also been found [46] that physisorption of perdeuterated molecules leads to narrowing of thesurface proton line, even forsuch weakly interacting adsorbates as hexane. This mustbe due to induced motion of the protons, but the mechanism is unclear. Further advances in proton spectroscopy were not possible until the advent of line-narrowing techniques. Schreiber and Vaughan [47] used multiple-pulse methods on a static powder sample, and were thus able to measure the chemicalshift of surface protons, and its anisotropy. They found an absolute proton concentration of 1.6 nm"2 (773 K pretreatment), an isotropic chemical shift of 4 ppm and an anisotropy of 7 ppm. The data were fitted with an axially symmetrical shielding pattern, but slight deviations would not havebeen detected. This a small chemical shift anisotropy, compared with water, alcohols andionic hydroxyls [48] and may be indicative of rapid rotation about the Si- 0 bond.
Bernstein et al. [49] performed multiple-pulse measurements withsimilar results, and estimated that fast 0 -Si rotation with a Si 0 -H angle of 136-142" is required to explain the small observed anisotropy. These authors also performed the first MAS study of Si02, obtaining a protonline width of 150 Hz, on a 60 MHz instrument, and a measured isotropic shift of 2.5 ppm for the SiOH protons. The first MAS results with sealed samples, permitting atmospheric control,were obtained by Cay [SO]. For Si02gel evacuated at 450"C, a line width of 100 Hz was obtained on a60 MHz instrument. The isotropicshift was measured as 1.2 ppm. A remeasurement of the same sample on a 150 MHz instrument [51] found a line width of 115 Hz, and an isotropic shift of 1.8 ppm. The fact that the line width is only slightly dependent on the spectrometer field indicates that it mostly does not result from a dispersion of isotropic shifts (otherwise an increase by a factor of 2.5 would be expected). The main source of line width mustbe incomplete averagingof the homogeneous dipolar interaction [52] at the 3 kHz spinning speed employed; since the proton TIvalue is several seconds, it is unlikely that paramagnetic impurities play an important role. In contrast, pyrogenic silica evacuated to 800 or 1000°C shows [51,53] a narrow line at a shift of 1.8 ppm with width approximately proportional to field, about 0.3 ppm on both instruments. This shows that a small dispersion of isotropic chemical shifts can be observed, when the proton density is reduced sufficiently to allow complete suppressionof the dipolar couplingby MAS. An obvious step toward still better resolution is to combine MAS with multiplepulse line narrowing (CRAMPS) in an attempt toremove residual dipolar interactions. It should be notedthatmultiple-pulsetechniques also havethe effectof scaling chemical shift by a factor less than one 154,557, and it isby no means obvious that one will improve resolution by achieving a further narrowing that is greater than the shift contraction. This point has been investigated experimentally by Dec et al. [56] who find that CRAMPSgives a dramatic improvementin spectral quality for proton-rich organic solids, but only a slight improvement for untreated silica gel. From this work one would expect little or no improvement for asilica in which the proton density has been reduced by dehydration. The CRAMPS technique has been reviewed in detail by Maciel et al.1551. CRAMPS was first applied to silica by Rosenberger et al. [57]. A line width of 0.5 pprn was obtained on silica gel activated at 400°C. Only a single line was found, and these authors point out that, while separate lines of SiOH and Si(OH)2 are clearly visible in 29Si spectra present techniques do not seem able to resolve them in the ' H spectrum. (Lippmaa and coworkers [SS] observed two proton lines on Aerosil degassed at 730°C. The presentauthors have not been able to reproduce this result with Cab-0Sil, and other reports of this do not appear in the literature.) Subsequently, Macieland coworkers have appliedCRAMPS to silica gel [59,60] evacuated at room temperature and at500°C (see Fig. S), and to Cab-0-Si1 samples [61] treated at temperatures up to 650°C. Untreated silica gel shows a narrow peak at 3.5 ppm due to physisorbed water, together with a broad peak at about3.0 ppm, and a narrow peak at 1.7 ppm. The water peak is identified by the fact that it is removed on evacuation at room temperature. Evacuation at up to 200°C leaves the other two peaks intact. Evacuation at 500°C removes the broad peak, leaving the narrow one at 1.7 ppm. This behavior permits these peaks to be assigned as H-
'H CRAMPS spectra of silica gel subjected to increasingly stringent activation conditions. Top, untreated, bottom 9 h vacuum treatment at 500°C. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 60. Copyright 1993, American Chemical Society.)
bonded (broad) and isolated (narrow) hydroxyl groups, by analogy with infrared results. Relaxation experiments were carried out [59] to determine the rate of dipolar spin flips among the protons. The results show that the hydrogen-bonded protons communicate among themselves on a time scale of l00 whereas, perhaps surprisingly, communication between these and the isolated silanols requires several milliseconds, suggesting that the average distances involved may be two to three times greater. The subsequent paper [60] deals mainly with the properties of physisorbed water. It does show, however, that the proton spectra of surface OH groups are essentially unchanged at temperatures below ambient. The CRAMPS results on Cab-0-Si1 E611 are similar to those for silica gel. Hbonded silanols are removed upon treatment at 450" C, leaving only an isolated silanol resonance at 2.0 ppm. For lower temperature treatments, the H-bonded resonance is somewhat narrower than observed on silica gel. Interestingly, an isolated OH signal is observed on surfaces covered withH20.This suggeststhat some OH groups are inaccessible to H20, a result confirmed by observation of H-Si cross-polarization on a sample exchanged with D20. Multiple-quantul~ proton NMR of Cab-0-Si1 hasbeen studied by Gerstein and coworkers [62,63]. In the first of these papers, which gives good exposition of the method,it found, surprisingly, thattreatment in liquid H20,followedby drying and Hz treatment at 400°C leads to a lower proton density, and smaller clusters of interacting protons, compared to sample in which the H20 treatment was omitted. In the subsequent paper, variety of treatment temperatures was used. For a sample treated at 120"C, the maximum observable order of multiple-
quantum coherence grew continuously with the excitation time, indicating a continuous distributionof surface protons.For samples treated at higher temperatures, a saturation of multiple-quantumorder was observed,corresponding to sevenproton clusters for 400°C treatment, and four-proton clusters for 500°C.
29SiNMR was introduced as an important surfxe-chemical technique by the classic paper of Maciel and Sindorf [64]. These authors studied the 29Sisignals arising fromcross-polarization by thesurfaceprotons ofsilicagel. Three lineswere observed (Fig. 9), at -91, 100, and -109 ppm. These were assigned, based on cross-polarization dynamics and by analogy with aqueous silicate systems, to silicons bearing two, one and no -OH groups, respectively. These species are often written in abbreviated form as Q2, Q3, and Signals were measured for a range of cross-polarization times, so that correction for rotating-frame relaxationand for differences in cross-polarization rates was possible. This leads to a ratio of 0.29 for the concentration of Si(OH)2 relative to SiOH. A figure is also reported for concentration of nonhydroxylated silicon, but it should be treated with care. Because of the r-3 dependence of dipolar coupling, cross-polarization is dominated by surface layer atoms. However, at long contact times, there will be increasing contributions from the second, and possibly deeperlayers. Such effects were recognized, but not included in the quantitative analysis of this paper.
29SiCP/MAS spectrum of silica gel. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 64. Copyright 1980, American Chemical Society.)
A surface Si(OH), grouping might be expected to show a29Sichemical shift near -80 ppm. There is one example of this in the literature: Severin and Vankan 1651 prepared this species by treatment of partially dehydroxylated silica gel with followed by hydrolysis. The group was found to have low thermal stability, probably accounts for its absence from natural silicas. Brei [66] attempted to perform the same reaction on Aerosil, but failed to produce any silanetriol. In a subsequent paper by Sindorf and Maciel[67] silica gelsfrom several sources were compared, and their reaction with hexamethyldisilazane ( H M ~ Swas ) studied. The Me3Siline resulting from the reactionis well separated from native resonances. After determining the mass of Me3Si gravimetrically, its resonancewas used as an internal standard to determine absolute concentrations of SiOH and Si(OH)2 onthe surface. Thetotalhydroxylconcentration was nearlyconstant among the various gel samples, ranging from 4.3 to 5.2 The ratio of Si(OH):! to SiOHvaried by a factor of two among the different preparations, rangingfrom 0.09 to 0.20. Thediscrepancyincomparison to thehighervalue found in Ref. 64 was not discussed. It was found that the rate of reaction of Si(OH)2 with HMDS is three times that of SiOH. A paper by Linton et al. [68] on reactivity with trimethylchlorosilane also reports the geminal diols to be more reactive, by a factor of 17 at low fractional reaction. Sindorf and Maciel 1691 also investigated silicagel samplesevacuated at temperaturesashigh as 11OO"C, andsamplesprepared by rehydratingthese with liquid H20. ~nfortunately,cross-polarizationdynamics were not investigated above 500°C; the decreased proton density resulting from higher-te~peraturetreatmentmightchangetherelevantparameters,andonecannot be confident of quantitative accuracy the highest at temperatures used. Furthermore, no information wasgiven regarding possible loss of surface area at hightemperatures. It wasfoundthat initially geminalhydroxyls are removed more rapidly than isolated ones, leading to a minimum in their relative Concentration of about 12% for 400°C treatment temperature. From about 400700°C they are removed more slowly, leading to a relative maxil~umof 24% at 650"C, above which temperature their fractionalpopulation declines again. Treatment at 800°C (the highest temperature for which NMR data are reported) reduces both types of hydroxyl to approximately 15-20%of their initial concentrations. The rehydration appears to be kinetically controlled, and, as found by previousworkers,can beveryslow forsamplesdehydrated tothehighest temperatures.Rehydration toform geminal OH groupsappearsto be faster, since for samples rehydrated after treatment at 300"700"C, the geminal fraction is larger than in thestarting gel. Studiesinvolvingreactionwith HMDS [71] showedgoodagreement between absolute OH concentrationsdetermined by NMR and by mass loss. There is asmalldiscrepancy at low temperatures, which may be due to adsorbed H20. On a fully hydroxylated surface, all hydroxyls cannot be reacted with because of the size of the Me3Si group. If hydroxyls were removed randomly by high-temperature treatment, one would expect that eventually complete reaction would becomepossible. This is not observed, indicatingeither that dehydroxylation is not random, that the silylation reaction (which was carried out in the liquid
phase) has kinetic limitations or that all of the surface is not accessible to the reagent. Chuang et al. studied H-Si cross-polarization in silicagel samples that had been exchangedwith D 2 0 by variousprocedures.Suchspectra will show 29Si signals only from silicons that are close to an unexchanged proton, It was foundthat several percent(depending ontheexchangemethod) of protons could not be exchanged. These were attributed to "interior" silanols. striking feature of the CP spectra was the absence of a geminal diol peak, indicating that these species must befully deuterium-exchanged, and remote from the residual protons. It is clear from the results of Maciel and Sindorf that nonhydroxylated silicon cannot be reliably measured by cross-polarization. Fyfe and coworkers haveattemptedtoovercome this limitation by using 90" pulse excitation. This requires a measurement of the spin-lattice relaxation times of all species, and use of interpulse delays which are long in comparison with the longest Using the same silica gel as the Maciel group (Fisher type good agreement was obtained for the ratio of Si(OH), to SiOH. The paper can be criticized on the grounds that the authors did not assess the possible role of physisorbed H 2 0 and ambient O2 as relaxation agents for the surface layer, but not for the interior A longerrelaxationtimeforinterior(nonhydroxylated) silicon wouldmakethe apparent amount of nonhydroxylated species too small. In spite of this objection, elemental analysis (for C) of a sample silylated with Me3SiCl appears to indicate that correct results were obtained. In addition to silica gels, 29SiNMR has been applied to the study of pyrogenic silicas by several authors. In general, the lines are broader than in gels, and deconvolution procedures are often required to determine the different Si(OH)n groupings. It is known fromNMR studies of crystalline silicates that 29Sishifts are sensitive to structural influences, especially the Si-0Si bond angle. Thus the wider lines observed in pyrogenic silicas are generally attributed to greater structural randomness, associated with their high temperature of preparation. Lippmaa et al. [58] observed the presence of SiOH and Si(0H)2 on air-equilibrated Aerosil. Morrow and Gay studied Cab-0-Si1 which had been vacuum treated at temperatures up to 1OOO"C, and showed that Si(OH)2 groupings persist up to the highest temperatures. Unfortunately these papers do not present quantitative data. Lkonardelli et al. found that Aerosil has SiOH and Si(OH)2 concentrations similar to those found on a series of porous silicas (the preparation of this sample is not well described). Brei reported from cross-polarization studies that Si(OH)2 constitutes 15% of the hydroxylated silicon on Aerosil, but it is not clear whether adequate relaxation ~easurementswere made. Brei, like Sindorf and Maciel observed that a fraction of the OH groups cannot be silylated, after pretreatment of the surface up to 400°C. In addition, he showed that the unreacted silanols are associated withan infrared band at 3360-3380 cm"'. This band is known [8] to arise from hydroxyls perturbed by interparticle contact. Thus the question of whether thermal treatment randomly removes hydroxyls from noncontacting areas of the silica surface appears to remain open.
The study of Cab-0-Si1 by Liu and Maciel [61) also included 29Siobservations. Experiments included variable contact times, permitting correction of differences in cross-polarizationdynamics.An interesting result is thatuntreatedCab-0-Si1 shows a higher fraction of geminal diols than does silica gel. A ratio as high as 0.3 was reported, although this involved deconvolutionof a peak in which separate lines are not apparent, and no error analysis was given. As with silica gel, a fraction of the surface hydroxyls are not exchangeable with D20.However, this includes a substantial population of diols, not seen on gel samples. Several workers [25,78-811 have carried out 29Siexperiments on sol-gel-derived silicas. In general the spectral features are similar to those observed on other types of silica. These papers tend to focus more on the details of the hydrolysis and gelation processes, thanon thestructure of the finishedsilica. Thereappears [79,80] to be atrendtowardhigherproportions of Si(OH)2 with lower p hydrolysis, but the quantitative accuracy of these papers is uncertain.
As mentioned above, the only magnetic isotope of oxygen, 1 7 0 has spin and thus is quadrupolar. Besides introducing difficulties, the quadrupole interaction provides anothercharacterizationparameter,thequadrupolecouplingconstant, which can be observed in addition to the chemical shift. The obviously interesting surface group, which is not probed by other forms of NMR, is the siloxane bridge. The formation of such bridges, or other structures, in the dehydrosylation of silica would be a very interesting study. There is a problem with surface selectivity for quadrupolar nuclei, in that cross-polarization is less straightforward than with spin nuclei [82,83] and for unfavorable parameter values may fail, or lead to severe intensity distortions. Surface selectivity might,however, be obtained by other means, such as exchange [84] of surface OH with H2170, or by cross-relaxation with optically polarized inert gases (85,861. Liquid-phase '70spectroscopy has been reviewed by Kintzinger (871 and there are several published surveysof simple solid oxides [88,89] and of silicates. Much of the latter work, and applications to zeolites has been reviewed by Engelhardt and Michel [go]. Two crystalline phases ofsilica, cristobalite [32], and coesite [91] have been studied by hi~h-resolution1 7 0 spectroscopy. The latter possesses oxygen in five different environments with widely differing Si 0 Si bond angles. It is found that the quadrupole coupling constant, its anisotropy, and the chemical shift correlate with this bond angle. The quadrupole couplingvaries from l to 6.1 MHz as the bond angle changes from 137" to 180", whilethe chemicalshift changes from 58 to 29 ppm over the same range. There appearso far tobe only three publishedinvestigations [92-941 of high area amorphous silicas using 1 7 0 spectroscopy. Allof theseworkershaveprepared enriched silicas by reaction of SiCI4 with H2170, and the 1 7 0 is presumably uniformly distributed throughout the sample. In none of these cases is a surface area measurement reported. Geissberger and Bray [92] measured OH concentration by proton NMR, which might providean estimate of surface area. ~nfortunately their ratio of OH concentrations at degassingtemperatures of200°C and 500°Cis
markedly different fromwhat is normally observed,makingsuchestimates uncertain. Probably the surface area is 100 m2/g within a factor of two. Because of the uniform enrichment, the 90" pulse-excited spectra of these samples will be mainly characteristic of interior oxygens. These three papers report quadrupole couplings of 5.2, 5.8 and 5.0 Mhz respectively, none of which seems surprising, given the aboveresults for crystalline silicas. Walter et al. used H-Q cross-polarization to specifically observe the oxygen of surface OH groups; a distinctly different quadrupolecoupling of 4.0 MHz wasfound, similar tothat observed in a solid sample of triphenylsilanol. These results are of considerable interest, and indicate that a high-resolution study of surface-enriched silica would probably yield important results.
1. B. A. Morrow and S. J. Lang. J. Phys. Chem. 98: 133 19 (1994). 2. I. D. Gay, A. J. McFarlan, and B. A. Morrow. Phys. Chem. 95: 1360 (1991). 3. M. L. Hair, Infrare~Spectroscopy in Surjuce Cl~emistry,Marcel Dekker, N.Y., 1967. 4. L. H. Little, Infrare~Spectra A d s o r ~ Species, e~ Academic Press Inc., London, 1966. 5. B.A. Morrow. Stud. SurfaceSci. Cataly. 57A:A161(1990). 6. L. T. Zhuravlev.Langmuir3:316(1987). 7.B.A. Morrow and A. J. McFarlan. J. Non-Cryst. Solids 120:61 (1990). 8. B.A. Morrow and A. J. McFarlan. Langmuir 7:1695(1991). 9. A. Burneau, Barres, J. P. Gallas, and J. C. Lavalley. Langmuir 1364 (1990). 10. P. Gallas, J. C. Lavalley, A. Burneau, and Barres. Langmuir 7:1235(1991). 11. A. Burneau, B. Humbert, 0. Barres, J. P. Gallas, and J. C. Lavalley, in The Colloid Chemistry Silica (H. Bergna,ed.),AmericanChem.Soc.Adv.inChem. Series, 234, 1994, pp. 199-222. 12.B. A. Morrow and A. J. McFarlan. Phys. Chem. 96:1395 (1992). 13. D. T. Molapo, Ph. D. Thesis, University of Ottawa, 1998. 14. B. A. Morrow, C. P. Tripp, and R. A. McFarlane. J. Chern. Soc. Chem. Commun., 1282 (1984). 15. C. P. Tripp and M. L. Hair. Langmuir7:923(1991). 16. C. P. Tripp and M. L. Hair. Langmuir 8:1961 (1992). 17. C. P. Tripp and M. L. Hair. Phys. Chem. 975693 (1993). 18. M. Bartram, A.Michalske, and J. Rogers, Jr. J. Phys.Chem.95:4453 (1991). 19.B.A. Morrow and I. A. Cody. Phys.Chem.79:761(1975). 20. B. A. Morrow and I. A. Cody. J. Phys. Chem. 80:1995 (1976). 21.B. A. Morrow and I. A. Cody. J. Phys. Chem. 1998 (1976). 22.B. A. Morrow, I. A. Cody, and L. S. M. Lee. Phys. Chem. 80:2761 (1976). 23. T. A. Michalske and B. C. Bunker. J. Appl. Phys: 56:2686 (1984). 24. L. Scott and J.". Basset. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 116:12069(1994). 25. C. Brinker, R. J. Kirkpatrick, D. R. Tallant, B. C. Bunker, and B. Montez. J. Non-Cryst. Solids 99:418 (1988).
26. B. Humber, A. Burneau, J. P. Gallas, and J. C. Lavalley, J. Non-Cryst. Solids 143:75 (1992). 27. C. A. Fyfe, Solid State Chemists, C.F.C. Press, Guelph, Ont., 1983. ~ 28. K. Schmidt-Rohrand H. W.Spiess, Multidimensional S o l i d - S ~ ~ tNe M and Polymers, Academic Press, London, 1994. s ~ a g n e t i s Oxford ~, UniversityPress, 29. A.Abragam, The ~ r i ~ c ~ l eNuclear London, 1961, pp. 232-261. 30. C. A. Fyfe, G. C. Gobbi, J. S. Hartman, J. Klinowski, and J. M. Thomas. J. Phys. Chem. 86:1247 (1982). 31. Y. Wu, B. Q. Sun, A. Pines, A. Samoson,and E. Lippmaa. J. Magn. Reson. 89:297 (1990). 32. B: Chmelka, K. T. Mueller, A. Pines, J. Stebbins, Y. Wu, and J. W. Zwanziger. Nature 339:42 (1989). 33. K. T.Mueller, B. Q. Sun, G. C. Chingas, J. W. Zwanziger, T. Terao, and A. Pines. J. Magn. Reson. 86:470 (1990). 12779 34. A.Medek, J. S. Harwood, and L.Frydman. J. Am.Chem.Soc. (1995). K. Keskinen. J. Phys.Chem. 35. P. Sarv, C. Fernandez, J.-P. Amoureux,and 19223 (1 996). 36. R.R. Ernst, G. Bodenhausen, and A. Wokaun, in Principles Nuclear Mag~etic Resonance in One and ~imensions,Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1987,pp. 43 et seq. 37. J. Baum and A. Pines. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 108:7447 (1986). 38. R.A. Assink, M. Boslough, and R. T. Cygan. J. Magn. Reson. A 106:l 16 (1994). 39. G. R.Finlay, J. S. Hartman, M. F. Richardson, and B. L. Williams. J. Chem. Soc. Chem. Comm. 159 (1985). 40. A. Pines, M. G. Gibby, and J. S. Waugh. J. Chem. Phys. 59:569 (1973). Stejskal, J. Schaefer, and J. S. Waugh. J. Magn. Reson. 28:105 (1977). 41. E. Heidiger, B. H. Meier, and R. R. Ernst. Chem. Phys. Lett. 213:627 (1993). 42. 43. D. E. O’Reilly, H. P. Leftin, and W. K. Hall. J. Chem. Phys. 29:970 (1958). 44. See. Ref. 29, pp. 125-128. 45 D. Freude, D. Muller, and H. Schmiedel. Surf. Sci. 25:289 (1971). 46. B. Staudte. Z. Phys. Chern. (Leipzig) 255:158 (1974). 47. L. Schreiber and R. W. Vaughan. J. Catal. 58:413 (1975). 48. T.M. Duncan, A Compilation O~Chemical Shijt Anisotro~ies, The Farragut Press, Chicago,1990. 49. T.Bernstein, H. Ernst, D. Freude, I. Jiinger, B. Sauer, and B. Staudte. Z. Phys. Chem. (Leipzig) 262:1123 (1981). 50. D. Gay. Magn. Reson. 58:413 (1984). 51. Gay. Unpublished results. 52. M. Maricq and J. S. Waugh. J. Chem. Phys. 70:3300 (1979). 53. B. A. Morrow and I. D. Gay. J. Phys. Chem. 922569 (1988). 54. U. Haeberlen, High Resolution N M R in Academic Press, New York, 1976, pp. 61, 96, 106-113. G. E.Maciel, C. E.Bronnimann, and B.Hawkins.Adv.Magn.Reson.14:125 990).
rrow and
56. S. F. Dec, C. E. Bronnimann, R. A. Wind, and G. E. Maciel. J. Magn. Reson. 82:454 (1989). 57. H. Rosenberger, H. Ernst, G. Scheler, I. Junger, and R. Sonnenberger. Z . Phys. Chem. (Leipzig) 263346 (1982). 58. E.T. Lippmaa, A. V. Samoson, V. Brei, and Yu. I. Gorlov. Dokl. Akad. Nauk S.S.S.R. (Phys. Chem.) 259:403 (1981). E. Bronnimann, R. C. Zeigler, and G. E. Maciel. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 110:2023 59. (1988). 60. D. R. Kinney, 1.3. Chuang, and G. E. Maciel. J. Am. Cllern. Soc. 115:6786 (1993). 61. C. Liu and G. E. Maciel. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 103 996). 62. B. C. Gerstein, M. Pruski, and S.-J. Hwang. Analytica Chimica Acta 283:1059 (1993). 63. S.-J.Hwang, D. 0. Uner, T. S. King, M. Pruski, and B. C. Gerstein. J. Phys. Chem. 993697 (1995). 64. G. E. Maciel and D. W. Sindorf. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 102:7606 (1980). 65. J. W. Severin and J. J. Vankan. Philips J. Res. (1990). 66. V. V. Brei, J. Chem. Soc. Farad. Trans. 90:2961 (1994). 67. D. W. Sindorf and G. E. Maciel. J. Phys. Chern. 865208 (1982). 68. R. W. Linton, M. L, Miller, G. E. Maciel, and B. L. Hawkins. Surf. Interf. Anal. 7:196 (1985). 69. D. W. Sindorf and G. E. Maciel. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 105:1487 (1983). 70. R. K. Iler, in The C h e ~ i s t ~ y Silica, Wiley, New York, 1979, pp. 544-547. 71. D. W. Sindorf and G. E. Maciel. Phys. Chem. 875516 (1983). 72. Chuang, D. R.Kinney, and G. E. Maciel. J. Am. Chem. 11.523695 (1993). 73. C. A. Fyfe, G. C. Gobbi, and G. J. Kennedy. J. Phys. Chem. 89:277 (1985). 74. J. Klinowski, T.A. Carpenter, and J. M. Thomas. J. Chem. Soc. Chem. Comm. 956 (1986). 75. G. Engelhardt and R. Radeglia. Chem. Phys. Lett. 108:271 (1984). Non-Cryst.Solids 76. R. F. Pettifer, R. Dupree, I. Farnan,andU. Sternberg. 106408 988). 77. LConardelli, L. Facchini, C. Fretigny, P. Tougne, and A. P. Legrand. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1146412 (1992). (1989). 78. A. Vega and G. W. Scherer. J. Non-Cryst. Sol. L. Walter, A. Wokaun, and A. Baiker. Mol. Phys. 71:769 (1990). 79 80. U. Darnrau, H. C. Marsmann, 0. Spormann, and P. Wang. J. Non-Cryst, 164 992). 81. R. H. Glaser, G. L.Wilkes, and C. E. Bronnimann, J. Non-Cryst.Sol.113:73 (1989). 82. A. J. Vega. J. Magn. Reson. 9650 992). 83. W.Sun, J. T. Stephen,L. D. Potter, and U. Wu. J. Magn.Reson. A 995). A. Morrow and A. Devi. Can. Chem. 48:2454 (1970). 84. 1 1604 85. T.Rddm, Appelt, R. Seydoux, E. L. Hahn, andA. Pines. Pllys. Rev. B 55: (1997). 86. E. Brunner, R. Seydoux, M. Haake, A. Pines, and J. A. Reimer. Magn. Reson. 130:145 (1998).
87. J.-P. Kintzinger, in N M R , Basic P r ~ n c ~ Z e s Progress, Vol. 17 (P. Diehl et al., eds.) Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 198 1. 88. G. L. Turner, S. E. Chung, and E. Oldfield. Magn. Reson. 64316 (1985). 89. T. J. Bastow, and S. N. Stuart. Chern. Phys. 143:459 (1990). 90. G. Engelhardt and D. Michel, inHig~-Resolurion Soli~-Srate o ~ s i l i ~ a tand es Zeolites, Wiley, Chichester, 1987, pp. 336-343. 91 P. J. Grandinetti, J. H. Baltisberger, I. Farnan, J. F. Stebbins, U. Werner, and Pines. Chern. Phys. 99:12341 (1995). E. Geissberger and P. J. Bray. J. Non-Cryst. Sol. 54121 (1983). 92. 93. T.H. Walter, G. L. Turner, and E. Oldfield. J. Magn. Reson. 76:106 (1988). 94. C. Jiiger, R. Dupree, S. C. Kohn, and M. G. Mortuza. J. Non-Cryst. Sol. 1.5595 (1 993).
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
~ e p a r t m e nof t Chemistry, Faculty of Science, Ain Shams University, Cairo, Egypt
Introduction I.
35
TI. Surface ~unctionality
36
III. HydroxylatedSurface ofSilica
38
IV.Types
40
of SurfaceHydroxyls
~ydroxylationin Relation to the Method of Preparation A.Pyrogenic silica B. Silicagel and precipitated silica
40 41 43
VI. Activity of Different Types of Surface Species A. Protolytic and ion exchange properties B. Hydrogenbonding C. Activity based on abstraction of proton from surface silanols
45 46 49 52
VII. ~ o d i ~ Surface ed of Silica
54
References
59
Silica, S i Q , is a giant atomic structurein which each silicon atom is bonded to four oxygen atoms, and eachoxygen atom to two silicon atoms in such a way that each silicon atom is at thecenter of a regular tetrahedronof oxygen atoms. Itis a solid of high melting point(1 density between 2 and 3 g/cm3 and refractive index in the range 1.5-1.6. The electronic con~gurationof the silicon atom suggests the idea of the formation of bondsbased on tetrahedrally orientedhybrid sp3 orbitals. Naturally occurring silica comprises quartz, tridyrnite, cristobalite, coesite, keatite,
i stishovite, and opal. These polymorphs exhibit a framework of tetrahedral motif; however, the pattern of linkage for each one is different, which appears in the different structural, physical, and chemical properties. Stishovite, a high-temperature form of silica, is unique among these polymorphs in being characterized by a skeleton in which silicon atoms are octahedrally 6-co-ordinated to oxygen atoms. Hybrid sp3 orbitals are presenteven if the silicon is bonded to three oxygen atoms only, but it is no longer stable when silicon remains bonded to only two oxygen atoms 111. It is known, however,that owing to free orbital silicon can co-ordinate octahedrally, provided that the ligand is small and slightly polarizable. In the case of silica the usual defects of Frenkel and Schottky type are less probable owing to the extremely high energy of chemical bonds. According to Mckinnis and Sutton [27 the breaking of Si-Q bonds becomes more frequent only at high temperatures in melts 120-250°C above the liquidus temperature of the composition. Oxygen, the bridge-forming element, has two unpaired electrons on the and 2p, orbitals, and the silicon atom possesses a vacant orbital. This usually results in more-or-less pronounced components which,if superpositioned over bonds in such a way to produce a uniform increase of the energy of all the bonds, the resultant structure is resistant to high temperatures. The presence of n levels in SiQ2 has been demonstrated by X-ray spectroscopy The four oxygen atoms in the tetrahedronwhich compete for theuse of the free orbiials of silicon reach equilibrium, resulting in equal Si-Q distances (1.62 f0.01A)of partial covalent (50%) character. TheSi- Q- Si angle changes onlyif the oxygen polarizability increased due to temperature rise, and the possible variation within wide limit results in the disappearance of the long-range order, as in the case in amorphous silica. TwoSiQ4groupshave neverbeen found to havemore than one oxygen atom in common. This is due to the stability of the electron configuration of the Si4' (complete octet) and its strong positive force field resulting from the highchargeandsmall size, whichleads to the stability of corner, shared SiQ4 tetrahedra.
It is generally acceptedthat surface ions are exposedto anasymmetrical forcefield. Their electronic orbitals being deformed, and the polarized ions havingoptical and chemical properties whichdiffer from those of the ions of the same type locatedin the symmetrical forcefield of the interior. What may notbe overlooked is the fact that the physics and chemistry of surfaces are dominated by polarization phenomena [4]. It is, therefore, not the chemical composition but primarily the surface configuration whichis the basis of the reactivity ofsilica. Surface functionality refers collectively to the chemical functional groups that terminate the bulk structure of the solid and their immediate environment. Surface groupsare constrained by the rigid three-dimensionalnetwork that backs upthe surface. Thus,some groups maybe forced into contact with each other,and in other cases some groups that would normally react with each other may be held where they cannot assume the proper orientationto react. At the surfaceof silica the structure terminates with siloxane links, Si- Q Si, as those communicated in the bulk, or silanol groups,
Si-OH. The latter is the result of incomplete condensation during the polymerization process through which the massive structureis formed and/or the tendency of the surface oxygemto formtwo bonds as other atoms in the interior. The proton is the most suitable candidate to beusedby surface oxygens to complete their bonding, which is supplied by water that is normally present in the media around the surface (during processing). Hydrous silica is therefore that formed in presence of water (liquid or vapor), and it is characterized by high population of surface hydroxyls. Anhydrous silicas are formed at high temperatures and recovered from the gas phase in dry atmosphere; its surface appears to accommodate a very small number of hydroxyls if water is omitted. Hydroussilica isthe most important when adsorption is considered, since these surface hydroxyls represent thekey of activity of silica in any process taking placeat the surface. The least important propertyof silica as a desiccant relies completely upon silica hydroxylation. The surface of hydrous silica can be visualized an extending domain of Si0- Si bonds and the relativelyhigh polarizability of the large oxygen ion compared with the small silicon ion makes it imperative that the surface is formed by oxygen ion alone. The implication is that at the uppermost layer of the extending joined tetrahedra, theoxygen atoms reside at a higher level than that accommodating the surfacesilicon atoms. When theseoxygens attach to protons to form hydroxyls on thesurfacethelatteraretherefore at higherpositions than thelinked silicons. Brunauer et al. [57 reported value of 129 f 8 ergs/cm2 at 23°C for the total energy of the silanol surface of silica which is only slightly higher than the total surface energyof liquid water, 118.5 ergs/cm2 This slight difference in surface energies made Brunauer et al. suggest that the chemical compositionof the surfaces, H 2 0 and Si02 should show considerable similarity if the hydroxyls on silica are on top and thesilicon atoms are below the OH groups. A similar suggestion was also made by Iler ["l. If the silicon atoms are 011 top, or even on the same level with the surface OHS it would be difficult to understand the close similarity between the surface energiesof water and hydrous silica. The recognition of silanol groups as surface functional groupswas easily achieved by using infrared spectroscopy;surfacegroupsare differentiated from internal groups by behavior of absorptionbandsas molecules are physically adsorbed.Anatomor nnolecule physically adsorbed (via H-bonding for example) near a surface group perturbs motions of atoms of the group, causinga shift in its stretching frequency as aresult of hydrogenbonding. Since forces responsiblefordisplacement of absorption bands act over distances of a few angstroms at most, displacementof an absorption band by a physically adsorbed vaporindicates that the groups causing the band are in exposed positions, i.e., surface species. Bands due to internal functional groups ordinarily do notchange in intensity or frequencyasvaporsare physically adsorbed. Isotopic band shift in the IR spectrum was also useful in this respect. In considering the vibration of atoms the chemical bondis often equated with the spring concept of the harmonicoscillator. The strength of the chemical bondis considered analogous to the strength of the spring in the simple harmonic oscillator, that is, the force constant. ~ u a n t u m - m e c ~ a ~ iconsiderations cal have shownthat the vibration of a diatomic molecule can be reduced to the motion of a single particle of reduced
mass, where l/pm l/ml l/m2, andm l , are the masses of the two atoms of the diatomic molecule. The relation between the force constant,k , and can be written as:
k In which c is the velocityof light (3 10" cm and i j is the wavenumber (frequency) at which the molecule has to vibrate. For two molecules of two different masses, one can write i j l / i j 2 considering k is the same in both S. If the OH group is treated as a simple diatomic harmoricoscillator, thus for and OD (D deuterium) we have (16/9 17/ 16)' (17/9)'/2 1.37, which means that the ratio between OH and OD frequencies is 1.37. Subjecting silica to D 2 0 and recording the infrared spectrum revealed the shift of the originally present band at 3750 cm-" (attributed to freely vibrating surface OH group) to appear at 2750 cm-'. The ratio 3750/2750 1.36 agrees well with the calculated one. This observation has led to the conclusionthat theisotopic band shift is due toexchange of the protonof the OH group withD of D20, and for this to occurthe OH group has to be located onthesurface as the nature of the exchange does not permit OH groups not on the surface to come into play. The use of infrared spectroscopy in combination with adsorption of different species was the subject of a very large body of research devotedeither to characterizing the surface of different silicas, or to studying the activity of the functional groups differently distributed onthesurface ofsilica. Computer-interfacedequipment made the technique invaluable in these respects. The work undertaken by Prof. Morrow and Prof. Davydov highlights this area.
Ideally, if the a r r a n g e ~ e n of t tetrahedra is to keep them stacked in an ordered design that is repeated in a regular manner all over the surface, then a long-range ordered structure has to result. Consequently, a regular distribution of the surface hydroxyls is to be expected in which all of them are equally separated making the surface of very low degree of heterogeneity. Naturally occurring polymorphs of silica exhibit variable degrees of crystallinity with which modeling of the surface structure may be a practical approach and the distribution of surface hydroxyls may beassessed depending on crystallographic data.In 1958, De Boer and Vleeskins [8] suggested a model basedon the (l 11) face of p-cristobalite or similar [aces of B-cristobalite. On such ideal surfaces, hydroxyls are separated by about 5 A andareina hexagonalarrFngement (Fig. that corresponds toan OH concentration of 4.55 per 100 A2, close to the value of4.6 they found experimentally in the case of various silica gels. Peri and Hensley [9] visualized the (100) face of p-cristobalite as silicon atoms each connected to a pairof hydroxyl groups located in rows (Fig. 2). Recent studies on silica gels using solid-state Si2' NM have shown that no single previously proposed model gives a completely adequate description of the surface structure of synthesized silica [lo]. The results indicated that silica surface is quite heterogeneous and may contain segments of surface resembling both the (1 11) and (100) faces of cristobalite. Synthesized silica, being
0 0 OH
Hexagonal arrangement of the ( I De Boer and Vleeskins. (From Ref. S.)
face of p-cristabolite as described by
aproduct of thepolymerization process, exhibits heterogeneity resulting from irregular packing of macromolecules as well as incomplete condensation between these macromolecules. At the surface the situation is further complicated by the unequal distribution of forces acting on surface atoms, in contrast to those in the bulk.Thesurfacestructure, therefore, dependsonthemethods of preparation being in wet media or in gas phase. In wet media, the packing of hydroxylated macromolecules and their mutual condensation are, due to high viscosity, subject to steric hindrances, which may result in incomplete condensation of neig~boring molecules. In gasphase,thelack of high viscosity introducesmorefreedom during formation of macromolecules. The absence of steric hindrances gives the molecules more flexibility during condensations, which results in a more ordered skeleton.
Rows of hydroxyls on the (100) face of p-cristabolite as described by Peri and Hensley. (From Ref. 9.)
4
Studies of different objectives (adsorption, hydration, dehydroxylation, and modification) have revealed that the surface hydroxyls on different silicas and even on samples of the same typeof silica are not of the same kind,and therefore are notof the same reactivity. The silicon atom on the surface may attach to one or two silanol groupsto completeitscovalency of four when its linking tothe bulk involves respectively three or two Si-0Si bridges. single Si-OHtype may be present as an isolated group where its nearest neighbors exert little or no effect on it! bonding. The distance between a pair of single isolated silanols is on average 5 as estimated from crystallographic data of crystalline silica. A single group may present near another one where both groups can mutually affect each other; the proqinenteffect is hydrogen bonding. Hydroxylswhich are separatedby more than 3.1 appear incapable of hydrogen bonding, while the strongest hydrogen Ponds must iFvolve some optimum distancewhich is considerably spaller than 3.1 A (2.4 to 2.8 A) [l l]. Silanols situated at distance shorter than2.8 A are called in the sense that they can interacteither mutually or simultaneously withan adsorbate molecule. Twosilanol groups linked to the same surfacesilicon atom are called which are not necessarily accessible to mutual hydrogen bonding, yet suitable to interact simultaneouslywith an incomingadsorbate.Theterms and are shorthand sometimes used for vicinal and geminal silanols. Two structures, Si 0 and Si (OH)3, can exist in theory, but no positive evidence has been presented to support their actual presence in any known cornpound.
The distribution of silanols on the surface a single vicinal or geminal type is a direct consequence of the way in which the building monomers are condensed during the process of polymerization, leading to the formed rigid structure. The geminal typeis the most evident pictureof incomplete condensation where twoOH groups escaped from being involved in the polymerization via the condensation process. Thecondensation ofsimple monomers, R,Si(OH),, x y 4and x 4, has been visualized to proceed through the hydroxyl groups belonging to individual molecules. This results in the evolution of two types of OH groups, those on the end Si atoms which are involved in further condensationgiving linear polymers, while the others on theSi atoms not at theend give rise to cross-linkage. The latter type of linkage causes the polymerized structure to extend in a threedimensional array which, upon solidification, forms an interlocking structure. This network constitutes the primary particles of which the massive material of silica is formed. The way in which these primary particles are formed determines to a large extent the physical and chemical properties of the resulting silica. Furthermore, the size and shape of these primary particles, which may control the density of their packing and the strength of the bonds between them, appears the basis on which the classification of different silicas depends.
Conveniently, silica gel, precipitated silica, and powders are the most important categories where adsorption is concerned. The patent literature tends to use the terms gel and precipitate in a way indicating that both types are similar. However, Barby [12] suggests that gel can bedefined as distinct froma precipitate and reported “a true precipitated silica is a dry silica with no long or short distance characteristic structure.” This definition classes precipitates as structureless silicas rather than a class of different manufacture. On the other hand, Weiser [l31 considers theonly difference between a precipitate and a gel is that a precipitate encloses onlypart of the liquid in which it is formed. Thedistinction between silica gel and silica powder also does not appear more evident. Silica gel may be considered as a coherent, rigid three-dimensional network of contiguous particles of colloidal silica, and silica powder may consist of small granules of silica gels or of coherent aggregates of submicron particles that are linked together in extremely weak networks. The outstanding book of Iler [l41 cites many other subdivisions of silica, and the interested reader should consultthis book for details. Both silica gels and powders are classified as microamorphous. Frondel [15] reported that amorphous silica is not truly amorphous but consists of regions of local atomic order, or crystals of extremely small sizes, which by careful X-ray diffraction studies appear to have the cristobalite structure. A broad, but perhaps less confusing, way of classification is one that classes silica in a high-temperature vapor-phase product as pyrogenicor fumed silica, and silica nucleated and grown from aqueous solutions supersaturated with monomeric Si(OH)4, and this includes gels and precipitates.
Anhydrous amorphous silica can be made in one of the following ways: 1. Vaporizing Si02 in an arc or plasma jet and condensing it in a stream of dry inert gas. 2. Oxidizing the morevolatile S i 0 in the vapor phase with air and condensing the Si02. 3. Oxidizing or hydrolyzing silicon compounds such as SiH4, SiC14 or HSiC1, in the vapor state with dry oxygen or in a hydrocarbon flame. The homogeneous medium causes the formation conditionsfor each silica particle to be the same, and a very narrow particle size distribution !i obtained with a diameter of 10-20 nm. The primary particles are only 10-20 A in diameter and closely packed, and the internal pores of the final particles are usually impervious to nitrogen but are detectable by water adsorption. It is concluded [l61 that the initially formed very small particles assume the translationalvelocities of large gas molecules and that final particle size is determined by collision and coalescence. The logarithm of final size is proportional to logarithm of growth time, and this isused to explain the observation that there is an increase in particle size with increase in silica concentration. The silica prepared in the vapor phase is generally of ahighdegree of hydrophobicity;however,thetypepreparedaccording to method 3 is the least hydrophobic of the three. This type of silica is commonly known as Cabosil@ in the USA (Cabosil@ registered trademark of Godfrey L.
Cabot, CO.), and Aerosil@ in Europe (Aerosil@ registered trademark of Degussa, erm many). Silanol groups at thesurface are predominantly isolated fromeach other. The high-temperature conditions make the rate of arrangement of silica tetrahedra enormously high, and since configuration with local order resembling that in the crystal must be the stable one, the tetrahedra tend to form a more ordered configuration. a consequence, a large fraction of surface silanols is situated on sites that are well separated from each other. Furthermore, pyrolysis of silicon compounds is likely to require a high temperature to achieve a sintered material, and this leads to a consequent decrease in adjacent OH groups through condensation during processing. Higher temperatures appear to favor the formation of singly isolated silanols. For instance, isolated OH groups are presentson thesurface of Aerosil OX 50 (low-surface-areaAerosilprepared ata higher temperature than other Aerosils) in a higher density than on higher-area counterparts Aerosil 200 and 300 (prepared at lower temperature than 50) The increase in particle size with increase in silica concentration favors the suggested arrangement of buildingtetrahedraasa result of preparationconditions. However,asthe resulting structure is not crystalline ona macroscale to be detected by ordinary x-ray diffraction, some incomplete condensation of silanol groups takes place, leading to the presence of a small number of geminal hydroxyls[10,18]. It is to be noted that chromatographic experiments indicated that silicasof different sourcesmayvary greatly inproperties andthat even batch-to-batch variations are quite common [19,20]. Thus, it seems that it is not valid to make statements on the silanol group types or density without taking into considerationtheaging of thesample.Storingasample of Aerosilforoneyear was found to result in a decrease in the number of isolated silanols and an increase in the total concentration of silanols as well as bridged groups [17]. This alteration is attributed to a cleavage of strained siloxane groups by absorbed water. It has been shown that Aerosil 200 contains 2.5 mg of water per gram solid in the form of physically adsorbed water just after preparation. Upon aging, this water causesrupturing of some siloxanes, transforming them to silanols, which increases the total density of silanol groups and decreases the density of isolated groups through the higher probability of hydrogen bonding. value of 1.8 OH/ nm2 for three-day-old Aerosil 200 (LiAlH4 method) corresponded to 2.65 OH/ nm2 for a one-year aged sample. With sufficiently aged Aerosil silicas(130-380 m2/g)the silanol group density is virtually independent of the specific surface area and amounts to an average value of about 2.5 OH/nm2. Again the value for a sample of Aerosil 50 is lower than this average. The concentration of surface hydroxyls measured by estrification with methanol at 200°C is found to be in therange 2-4OH/nm2 Carrottand Sing[22] reported ona slight aging of thepyrogenicare silica TIC800 overaten-yearperiodwitha loss of surfacearea andthedevelopment of interparticle mesoporosity. While it is concluded thatthe silanol density is independent of the specific surfacearea, the distribution of the groups as isolated or interacting is shown above to vary with surface area. These results indicate the strong dependence of the resulting surface ofsilica ontheconditions of preparationand storage. Therefore,the
decision about the extent of hydroxylation of a pyrogenic silica sample has to be made cautiously, taking into consideration the history of the sample.
Iler 141 drew attention to the fact that there is a close relation between formation of silica gel and of precipitate, and that factors like concentration and presence or absence of a coagulant, e.g., Na ions, are of major importance in this respect. A major difference from the pyrogenicsilica is that both gels and precipitates are wet media products. In wet media many factors intervene either separately or in an interlocking manner, making the situation more complicated than in the case of interactions in the gas phase. Different processes overlap and so they are not easily recognized. Factorslike pH, concentration,time, and temperature make the followup of the working reactions not particularly straightforward. In the silicic acid system, the formation ofgel has usually been ascribed to polymerization through the condensation of Si(OH)4 into siloxane chains, then branchingthe cross-linking toformathree-dimensionalmolecularnetwork. Flemming [23] observed that the temperature coefficients of polymerization were different in acidic and slightly basic solutions, suggesting that different mechanisms might be involved in these twodifferent pH regions. Brady et al. [24] found that the activation energy of polymerization (kcal/mol) is f0.5 at pH 5.5, 9.6 f0.3 at pH 8.5, and 14.6 f0.5 at pH 10.5 in the presence of KC1. At an early stage in the polymerization, the silicic acid is converted to spherical particles about 1-2 nm in diameter. These amorphous particles then grow in size and decrease in number by the phenomenon of Ostwald ripening. Under most conditions, further increase in molecular weight involves the chaining together of the particles into the growing microgel network until a gel is formed. The rate of condensation of monomeric silicic acid is a minimum at pH 2, the isoelectric point of silica in water; however, the process does not stop completely, also the gelling process does not suffer from extreme retardation. So it is not OH" or H' in solution which governs this condensation reaction, but it is the surface charge of the particles themselves; during this condensation the surface chargevaries. Silica particles do chain together into a uniform gel structure at this pH, and the structure is not any different from the formed one more rapidly at higher pH, e.g., 3-5. Since the formation of the SiSi bond between two colliding particles requires not only an SiOH group on one surface but also an ionized SiO- on the other surface, it appears that some ionization must occur even at the isoelectric point, pH 2. But because the overall net chargeis zero there must also be present an equal numberof positive charges of the kind present at lower pH values. The transformation of silica sols into firm homogeneous gels suggeststhat most, if not all, silica gel networks may be made up of discrete particles rather than chains of individual Si04 tetrahedra. It is not possible, however, to grow the silica particles to a large size before gelling. At low pH the silicic acid is stable long enough to cast the gel into a desired form and the particles ultimately remain less than 2-3 nm in diameter. At pH 4-10, except at low silica concentration, the presence of sodium ions causes very rapid precipitation or gelling, so that growth of discrete particles before gelling is impossible. Iler [25] showed that in gel formation the network probably extends through
the medium and forms a rigid structure before all the polysilicic acid units become attached. In a rapid precipitation or gelling, silica tetrahedra link together helterskelter with little opportunity to assume local crystalline order. This tends to produce a surface on which adjacent silanol groups areclose enough to each other and are therefore predominantly hydrogen bonded. Wetmediaprocessingmayproceed using colloidal silica, soluble silicate or hydrolysis of silicon alkoxides. The strong influence of pH was shown clearly in neutralized soluble silicate solutions [26] and colloidal silica and similar behavior is reported in nonaqueous silica gels derived from silicon alkoxides [28]. The similarity in aqueous and nonaqueous systems leads to thesuggestion that the surfacechemistryoperating in colloidal silica systems is also present in silicon alkoxide systems. In all cases porous silica is produced. When a gel is formed by mixing concentrated solutions, an immense number of nuclei are formed close to one another, so that theprimary particles are unable to reach as large a size as with more dilute reagents. Even if the latter gel is subsequently dried to the same proportion of water, the large size of its primary particles will give it a somewhat more weakly bonded structure and coarse texture. Furthermore, in the actof gelation the more concentrated, andhence more rigid, gel is unable to accommodate stresses set up between initiation and completion of gelation. Readjustments of internal linkages give rise to a spontaneous shrinkage or syneresis, which is most marked for concentrated gels. Once silica gelhas set it cannot be made to swell and repeptize by placing in pure water, i.e., it is irreversible. Similarly, when a gel shrinks on dehydration, losing avolumeapproximatelyequal to thevolume of liquid water removed, such shrinkage is irreversible. Irreversibility both of the gel formation and gel shrinkage is due toirreversibility of the condensation by which Si-0Si links are formed. The implication is that wet media processing results in porous silicas. The prevailing porosity, however, differs according to the way in which the prepared gel is subjected to thedrying step following its formation, Xerogels are derivedby natural evaporation in which the stress in the pores may be large enough to disrupt the structure. This type ofgelis 60% dense and has a reduction of 40 to in volume. When the drying process takes place in an autoclave so that the solvent is removed above its critical point (hypercritical technique), the resulting Aerogel lacks excessive cracking and stresses in the pores. The resulting gel is about 10% dense and shows little shrinkage. Eventually different textures result depending on the mode of drying, and the existence of different porosities has to have a marked effect on the final state of hydroxylation. Quantitative (total number) and qualitative (distribution of the OHS as isolated, vicinal, or geminal) differences in the extent of hydroxylation is to be expected.Hydroxyls which may be uniformly distributed on a flat surface as widely separated groups may exhibit different characteristics, and therefore reactivity, if they are contained in pores. According to Avnir and Farin (291, because of the existence of pores, clusters of OHS naturally appear in spite of a uniform distribution. As the density of isolated silanol groups decreases with increasing specific surface area, the acknowledged increase of the latter upon prevailingof microporosity supports the conclusionabout the effect of porosity on the type of resulting hydroxyls. The hypercritical technique used in the
preparation of aerogels causes thesegels to retain, to a greater extent, the porosity that is destroyed in case of xerogels. Indeed, aerogelswere found topossess a higher density of interacting hydroxyls (not isolated) than xerogels, as well as a higher total density of hydroxyls [30]. The shrinkage taking placein the case of xerogels is responsible, in part, for the lower total density of OH groups compared with the aerogels. different way of controlling the drying of a prepared gel is the use of drying control chemical agents CCAs) [31] including formamide, glycerol, and several organic acids, such as oxalic acid. This method is widely used with gels prepared from organosilicones. mentioned before, the gelling process takes place before the primary particles reach a large and frequent (common)size that results in pores of wide distribution range. The drying control agent acts on controlling the resulting pores, making them predominantly large (basic agent) or small (acidic agent) with a limited range of distribution in both cases. The effect is primarily on the formed primary particles that are large in the former case and small in the latter case. The increased population of interacting OHS in the case of small-pore gels is thus to be expected in contrast to the case of large-particle, large-pore gels. These latter gelsresemble thereforethepyrogenic silicas in which thegrowth of the primary particles results in non- or macroporosity, and the surface is characterized by a high density of isolated hydroxyl groups. It has to be noted, however, that interacting hydroxyls rnay predominate over theisolated ones on precipitated silica in spite of nonporosity [32], whichemphasizes therole of the preparation methodin determinin~the final picture of the resulting surface. The classification of solids as porous or non usually depends 011 the assessment of porosity using sorbate; nonetheless, a solid which is nonporous to NZrnay be porous to water. sconti~~lities in the solid structure which areeven smaller than those accessed by water may exist, but cannot be called pores, since there is no atom small enough to igure 3 schematically represents the act of gelation (a), leading to particles of ng intra- andinterparticle porosities (b). In (c process of condensationleads to a random distribution of 0 particle surface. The coalescence of two particles of the type results in the type shown in (d), and the surface that may result as a final product (not to scale) is shown in (e) The schem in represents the situation when a poreaccommodatesa large number of groupswhichareduetogeometric considerations accessible to hydrogen bonding in the major part, and (g) represents the different ways in which the condensation between Si04 tetrahedra may take place.
In bonding of thetype G- 0 the electrostatic repulsionamongbonded and nonbonded electron pairs on oxygen causes the the oxygen atom to value greater than 100" 1331. Thegroup whichitself has other atoms or fragrne ontheproperties of theasafunctionalgroup,itmay be that
Schematic representation of many aspects of silica gel and precipitate (for details see text).
other atoms attachedto M will also exert influences on the propertiesof OH. These effects may be through chemical bonding or cross-space, and in either case, the influence will be of electrostatic character [341. Zt might be expected that A XM-0 AX&H is electronegativity) either bond in M -0-H might break, suggesting that in such case MOH might act either as a base (break at M bond) or as an acid (breakat 0 -H bond). Thisis true in the caseof silica whereat the local environment of OH thegroup C is Si03 in which M isSi, thus 1.7, 1.4 taking 3.2,2.1, and 1.8 for 0, H,and Sirespectively. The Si-0 bond angle at oxygen is estimated to be113"
In wet media, pH plays an important role in determining the reactivity of solid surfaces. In acid solutions PZC, point of zero charge) protonation takes place, making the dangling hydroxyl positively charged, acting as an anion exchanger, and in basic solutions PZC) deprotonated sites predominate and cation adsorption can take place. For silica, the surface hydroxyls are characterized byweak acidity, where the acid dissociation constant of Si-OH is estimated to be [36-381. The high electron affinity of the Si ion causes thefree electron pairs on the
ilic
oxygen atomto beof relatively low activity, makingthe basicity also low. Protonation of Si-OH appears of very low probability; the proton association constant for the reaction 'H
Si
O H 5 Si
OH:
is characterized by log -1.9 [39], which indicates how low the probability of surface silanol protonation is. The estimated log K for the protonation of the siloxane link is extremely low, -16.9[39], which means that this group can be considered inert toward the process of protonation. Similarity of protolytic behaviors of silica and silicic acid has been emphasized [39,40], which contradicts the behavior of many metal (hydr)oxides. It has been argued 1411 that the less condensed packing of O(H) and the location of reactive groups above the surface maybe the origin of close similarity with the situation in solution. Also, it has been concluded that the titrable interface of silica/aqueous phase appearsdifferent from many other metal oxidesand hydroxides, and may be unique, and the treatment through the MUSIC approach showed that the charge attribution is different in the case of silica 1411. The charge density of the metal cation in oxide or hydroxide controls its protolytic characteristics, and this parameter, expressed as where is the metal charge and r its radius, was found to be related to the PZC through an empirical equation of the form:
in which (CN)(>is the coordination numberof oxygen in the metal oxideor hydroxide, and B are adjustable constants [42]. The successof such an empirical equation in predicting the PZC of17 metal oxides and hydroxides is illustrated in (Fig. 4) where the calculated values show agreement with experimental values through a straight line of slope 0.97 passingthroughthe origin. The equation predicts a value of PZC for silica which does not match the usual reportedexperimental values forsilica of different origins; the value forsilica lies near the straight line passing through the values for other samples; however, it belongs to the upper abscissa scale (negative values). This observation again emphasizesthat even when the protolytic behavior of manymetaloxides and hydroxidescan beassessed empirically, silica shows an odd behavior. The exchange of metal ions with the weakly acidic silanol groups of silica has been visualized as:
M"'
m(-SiO€€)
M(OSi-):-"
mH+
(3)
in which m is 1 or 2, where the exchangeis reversible in acid solutions [43-45], and the bonding in the formed surface complex is essentially ionic [46-49]. The Eigand ~ r o ~ e r t i e s the s ~ r f a c esi~anoEs arenot basically changed by the u t t ~ ~ h silica. e d On the other hand, factors like pH, charge density on the mental cation, the chelating effect of cations, and the stability constant of the metal-hydroxo complex, appear to be the controlling factors. The surface activity of silica toward adsorption of cations, together with its high specific surface have oriented the attention of the
-12
-8
-4
Relationbetweenexperimental and calculated PZCs using Eq. (2). The value for silica follows the upper abscissa. (Based on data from Ref. 42.) researchers in the field of catalysis toward its use as a catalyst support. The objective of a supportedcatalyst is to benefit from the high surface area of the support to accommodate a highly dispersed phase of the active substance, to achieve a longacting high activity, in contrast to the short halflife in the case of an unsupported catalyst. The supporting process involves the loading of the desired species on the surface of the support through an impregnationstep, followed by calcination, then reduction to reach to the metallic state. As the particle sizeof the phase to be reduced decreases, theafter-reductionproduct exhibits ahigh dispersity with expectedhigh activity. In most cases, however,silica-supported catalysts were not acknowledged as good catalysts, since silica primarily interacts weakly with the starting materials, for which, upon calcination, the formed weak bonds are broken, resulting in an aggregated phase that increases in size. At the reduction step this phase results in a poorly dispersedspecies with a consequent low catalytic activity. Nevertheless, the weaknessof interaction between silica hydroxyls and the starting material has been found to show some dependence on the distribution groups. In the system Mo-silica it was noted that the weakest interaction is that involved MOO:- moiety and a pair of vicinal OH groups which are widely separated, and as the separation decreases the interaction survives even after calcination at 500°C [SO]. The widely separated groups result in adsorbed M O species, the bonding of which does not withstand even temperatures lower than 400°C In this respect, pyrogenic silica is the least desirable type of silica where, firstly, its
surface area is usually lower than that of many porous silica gels or precipitates, and secondly, its surface is dominated by isolated (unpaired) silanols.
The hydrogen bond is more generally represented as A- H. where B is any CT or electron donor site (Lewis base), and A may be one of the following: C,N,P, S, Se, F, Cl, Br, I. One source of activity of the silica surface is the ability of the silanol groups to formhydrogen bonding either of homo-intermolecular or heterointermolecular type [52]. Homo-intermolecular hydrogen bonding takes place between adjacent silanol groups on the surface of silica in which one group acts as proton do$or, and the other as proton acceptor.As mentioned before, a distance less than 3 A is required to produce an interaction of this type. In some cases the distribution of silanols, according to preparation methods, enables the formation of an extending domain of H-bonded groups, or the presenceof a pair of OH groups which are perturbed veryweaklyby H-bonding.Infraredspectroscopycan easily now distinguish between all theseotypes of surface hydroxyls. Isolated silanol groups are those located far 5 A) from neighboring groups, and these groups are not able to form homo-intermolecular H-bonding except after heating to very high temperatures 1000°C) wherethe movementof bulk materials permitstheir presence near other, normally isolated, groups. However, the recognition of this case does not seem probable where the action of heat that caused the isolated groups to approach eachothereventually results in their involvement in condensation reaction. In porous silica, two isolated OH groups on opposite walls can interfere in hydrogen bonding due to geometric considerations. The H-bonded groups are the source of activity of silica surface toward thermal treatments. At temperatures above 2OO"C, surface dehydroxylation starts involving those groups entering in strong H-bonding, and above 400°C the more widely separated, but still able to interact in p groups come into play. The formed siloxane links in place of the condensed groups above 400°C are considered unsymmetrical and are of different reactivity fromthesymmetrical links that are formed below400°C. The latter are further shown to be similar to those in the bulk [54] as concluded from the consecutive increase in the intensity band at 470 cm"' due to bending mode of Si-0-Si in the DRIFT spectrum ofsilicagel heated up to 400°C (Fig. The intensity of the band at470 cm-' is inferred from its relative intensity if compared with the mostintense band at 1200-1000 cm-', and the differences in intensity have not been due to differences in sample mass as judged from the constancy of the overtone bulk band (1860 cm"). The spectral features of the Si 0 -Si bending band (470 cm") at different heating temperatures are represented in (Table 1). Adsorption of organicsubstancesfromnonaqueousmediaproceeds via the hereto type of H-bonding in which the silanol group on silica acts as hydrogen donor in most cases. The interaction is mainly controlled by the situation in media rather than by the activity of the silanols. Factors like functional group, geometry, size of the adsorbate molecule, and the nature of the used solvent are found to determine theresulting picture on thesilica surface. Benzene interacts through the electron cloud delocalized on the whole ring, while butanol reacts through its
too 1600
IiOO
800
DRIFT spectra ofsilicagel(Kieselgel60,Merck)heated (From Ref. 54.)
Spectral Features of the Si-0 at Different Heating Temperatures Temperature ("C) 100 200 300 400
up to 400°C.
Si Bending Band (470 cm
lo3 (a.u.)
Peak intensity 77 84 130 154
(cm") 70.4 73.0 75.3 75.3
group, which is a strongerinteraction than in the caseof benzene. Benzene isfound to be successively replaced by butanol as the butanol concentration in the liquid mixture is consecutivelyincreased upto 100% Someinorganic salts that dissolve to someextent in organicsolventswhena little water is present are found adsorbable on silica through interaction with surface silanols Hydrogen-bondedwater, when onlya little is present, formsathin layer that holds the salt, and when the surface hydroxyls are masked by different alcohols that are known to have high affinity to form H-bonding with surface Q adsorption of the salt occurs. On the other hand, an excess of water increases the solubility of the salt in the organic solventso that adsorption does not occur. The fullctionality of the adsorbate molecule may cause the interaction to proceed so that twosurface silanols areinvolvedthroughhydrogenbonding in which the silanols may act as proton donor and proton acceptor. With aromatic hydrocarbons the porosity of the used silica plays the most important role. The preferential adsorption on the OH groups that are of higher population in pores than in open regionsmakesthe systemof great potentiality when separation is considered. Obviously, the pore sizes have to be in the range that permits the accplnmodation of the adsorbate molecules. Purely microporous silicas (radius A) may beof little importance and/or unsuitable to the purpose of interest. Adsorption from the vapor phase lacks the intervention of factors like p precipitation, dissolution, or nature of solvent, yet the functionality, size, geometry, and pressure of adsorbate molecules together with porosity of silica remain working and controlling factors. When the functionality of the adsorbate enables both mono- and birnode bonding to occur, the interaction mode depends on the coverage. stronger mode of adsorption of 1,~-dimethoxyethaneinvolving both methoxy groupshydrogen-bonded to two silanols (vicinal) constitutes the dominant mode of interaction at low surface coverage In the presence of excess the mode of interaction changes mainly to the weaker one, involving one from an isolated O to onemethoxygroup, and completecoverage of isolated groups is accompanied by only I I of the extending adjacent interacting silanol groups. Activity of silica toward adsorption of water vapor relies completely on the formation of hydrogenbonding both to single and paired OHS. Spectroscopic evidence indicates that in the beginning stages of adsorption, water draws oxygen down [58] making respectively one ortwo H bonds withisolated or adjacent vicinal silanols. The interaction via one silanol group is very weak[59,60] if cornpared with that involving adjacent pairof OH groups. At laterstages, hydrogen-bonded water clusters are formed beforeall the single hydroxyls are taken up. This is explained on the basis of energetic considerations. The calorimetric heat of a single hydroxylwater bond is 6 kcal/mol which is lessthan the heatof liquefaction water, kcal/mol, therefore wateris energetically favored in the liquid compared to the bonding by a single hydroxyl. On the other hand, multiple bonding of water to the surface OHSis accompanied by higher heat of adsorption, in which case the surface occupied to a large degree before the clustering occurs. The clustered molecules arernore translationally androtationally restricted in their motionthanthose weakly bound to the silanols, and therefore have a lower entropy. Thus, at low
coverages, water adsorption on silanols is favored by entropy, whereas at higher coverages, water clustering is favored by energy stabilization in clusters. The differences in the strength of adsorbed water on single and paired indicate that the pyrogenic silica will behave differently than silica gel or precipitate. Zettlemoyer [62] showed that the flame-hydrolyzed Cabosil silica has hydrophilic/hydrophobic site ratio of about 1:4, whereas the dehydrated HiSil (precipitated) hasaratio of1:1.7. Also,theprecipitated silicais shown to be hilic than the Cabosil as measured by their respective surface area )/A(Nz),of 1.09 !nd 0.38 For silica samples with adsorbed water t least 50 to 70 A in thickness, the adsorbed films undergo a phase transition with heats lie below those for the ice-water transition [64]. The lower heats in the case of HiSil compared with Cabosil are interpreted in terms of an alteration in structure and propertiesof adsorbed waterby the silica surface. This is an effect whose magnitude decreases with increasing distance from surface. the The strength of the interaction and the distance to which it extends from the surface increase withan increase in the hydrophilic characterof the surface, that forHiSil is greater than for Cabosil. The iSil surface, which is highly hydroxylated, affords an opportunity for each adsorbing H 2 0 molecule to form multiple hydrogen bonds to surface silanols. Since hydrogen bonds to water molecules arehighly directional, the position and orientation of the molecules in the first monolayer are strongly determined by the silica surface. This layer also influences the structure of the next layer, and it can be visualized as the persistence of a surface-depende~t structure to a considerable distance from the surface itself. The Cabosil surface, on the other hand, is not fully hydroxylated, and contains numerous isolated silanol groups, so water molecules adsorbed on thesesites retain a greater degree of freedom and the structurillg influence of the surface in this case would be expected to be less pronounced than in case of the HiSil sample. The covalent characterof the Si Si bond on the surfaceof silica that has not been subjectedthermaltreatmentmakes these sites hardly reactive toward wateradsorption.asurementsona pristine silica surface, i.e., one which had never been in contact with a high relative humidity or with aqueous, media, have shown that the process is dynamic and depends on temperature, partial pressureof water vapor, and the contact time Activity of silo thermal treatments toward water is thoroughly covered
he reaction of the surface hydroxyls may can substitute the hydrogen atom of the the metal, or metalloid, atom
that the adsorbate molecule he reaction with this hydro-
n different sizes; TiC14 and BC13 may react bifunctionally, whereas Al(Me)3, and essentially HMDS do not; Ca(Me), is a monome se, while Al(Me)3 is a dimer; 61, only react at an appreciable rate in the gas phase with silica at temperatures of the orderof 350°C. Thisimplies that the properties of the adsorbate are the determining factors of the extent of interaction with silica. The ability of a reactant to react bifunctionally is important in determining the initial reactivity of the H-bonded silanols relative to those that are isolated, and its size determinesthenumber ofinaccessible or blocked silanols 1661. However, it can be said that a difference in the reactivity of isolated and bonded silanols may be of significance in determining the strength of interacti with a specific HS agent. It is supposed that Al(Me)3 preferentially reacts with isolated OH groups [67], since the lone pairs of electrons on their oxygen atoms are readily available to interact with molecules having the electron acceptor property. The oxygen atoms in the hydrogen-bonded hydroxyls, in contrast, have their lone-pair electrons participating in the hydrogen bond,and such oxygen atoms will necessarily be less reactive toward electron acceptor molecules. ~otwithstanding, some authors believe that the reaction of silica with A1(Me)3 proceeds mainly via the hydrogen-bonded sites, and even the strained siloxane bridges formed due to heating at 700°C are more reactive than the isolated OH groups [68]. Alcohols have been shown to undergo condensation reaction with surfacesilano1 groups on silica. The reaction may involveboth isolated and H-bonded groups depending on the sizeof the alcohol. Methanol was found to react withboth isolated and interacting silanols [67]. With increase in the size of the alcohol the free hydroxylsaremore susceptible due to steric effects[69] and theextent of reaction shows some dependence on the structure of the alcohol. Thus, primary alcohols are found to react to a somewhat greater extent than secondary alcohols, and the product is thermally more stable. ~nsaturationin the 2-position modifies reactivity, while beyond the 2-position the effect appears negligible. The surface of silica adsorbing alcohols exhibits good hydrolytic and thermal stability [69]. The no nun if or^ distribution of surface hydroxyls on silica is the reason Eo activity in the adsorption processes since the reactivity of a single isolated group differs fromthat of apairand essentially fromagroupperturbe extended mutual hydrogen bonding. This fact can be seen clearly in the process of wateradsorptionthatcanproceed either weakly throughone sing1 toan isolated OH group,orstrongly via twobondstoapair of adjacent,oups. Although the functionality of the adsorbate potentially affects the adsorption process, the distribution of groups appears to play an important role. monofunctional adsorbate requires the presence of a single OH group; however, the extentof adsorption will be higher when theOH groups are distributed so that no clustering takes place, otherwise steric factors, depending on the size of the adsorbate, will intervene to limit the extent of adsorption. One canexpect that the strongest mode of adsorption takes placein the caseof a monofunctional adsorbate and a partially hydroxylated silica. On the other hand, highly a dehydroxylated surface mayrepresent the other extremeof reactivity in the adsorption process. The extent of hydroxylation of silica,as discussed before, is the consequenceof the origin and history of the specific type of silica.
The usual picture on the surface of silica is the presence of regions composed of siloxane links interrupted by sites exposing silanol groups. The numberand type of the latter on a“ ~ i r g i n sample ’~ are related to the class and history of the silica. The term virgin refers to the after-production sample, that is, the sample synthesized and subjected to no further treatment. process that makes silica cast off the nature of itssurface is amodification process, resulting in amodified surface. Although the different modes of preparation lead to different extents of surface hydroxylation, the preparation method does not seem to be included among the different ways that are considered as a sourceof modification. Whatever the mode of preparation, it results in a certain degree of hydroxylation which is inherent in the details of the processes takingpart in theoverall preparation method. Thermal treatments that cause surface dehydroxylation can be considered as a source of modificatioll, since it results in a surface accommodating fewer hydroxyls than it has to according to the method of preparation. It has to be noted, however, that this kind of modification is temporary in the major part as it has longbeen known that rehydroxylation can be effected, even though dehydroxylation is drastic, with liquid water either at room temperature or at slightly higher thermal level. In contrast to the normal natureof silica surface, the modified surface exposes, instead of the normal silanol groups, Si-0-M groups where M is any species except H and may be simple or complex. The simplest picture of a modified silica surface is that of the surface covered repeatedly and regularly with such links in which M is a single species that reacts in the same way with surface OHS. Of this kind of modified silica is that in which the lnodification takes place via interaction with an alcohol that results in a surface covered, albeit incompletely, with Siwhere R is alkyl group derived from the alcohol. The initial heterogeneity of the surface may lead, even with a noncomplex modifier, to heterogeneously modified silica. The situation becomes more complex when the modifier of the type that can react via more than one groupin its skeleton. (Figure 6) shows many possibilities in which (3-amino~ropy1)triethoxysilane can modify the surface of silica A modifier mayreact differently with the different functionalities on the surface, leading to different forms of modified silica. Boron trichloride (BC13) may react with isolated or vicinal OHS in addition to bridges leading toa surfacecomposed o i-0-BC12, (=Sil, and SiCl. Thereplacement of Si-0 h Si-C1 can be also achieved through the reaction of silica with SOC12,CC14,C12,SiC14, and SiHC13 The BC13-modified silica may result in chemically adsorbed BNHz groups through the reaction with NH3 attemperatures less than 100°C according to the reaction:
which is complete after 30 min. At temperatures greater than 200”C, secondary amines are increasingly formed through a consecutive reaction mechanism forming a borazine-like structure (B3N3H6) on thesilica surface. At 300°C the NH3 reacts solely with the surface boron species to form secondary amine groups
Different possibilities in which (3-aminopropyl) triethoxysilane (APTS)may modify the surface of silica. (Adapted from Ref. 70.)
Si
0
B(Cl),]
7NH3
Si
0
(NH2)B+ NH
4NH4Cl
A fast chemisorption of NH3 was also shown [73] to take place at room temperature on SiC14- and CC14-modified silica (composed of SiCl), forming SiNH2 groupsand NH4C1. However,aftersublimation of the NH4C1, the GSiNH2 formed could revert to the =Sic1 group via reaction with HCl at 600°C [35]. A surface dominated by =SiNH2 species can be obtained by a total substitution of the surfacesilanols on silica pretreated at 800°C through the reaction 300°C at in an NE13 flow [SO]. An esterified silica surface is obtainable through a modification step involving the reaction with an alcohol. The pyrolysis of the methoxy groups of methylated Aerosil, obtained from the reaction with methanol [81], produced Si-0 SiH2 on the surface, and prolonged outgassing caused the eliminationof hydrogen from SiH2 with the formation of Si radicals whose presence is confirmed by ESR [81]. This silica permits thedissociative chemisorption of hydrogen to occur readily at temperatures as low as 25"C, which is well known to be improbable in case of normal silica. Esterification of silica occurs more readily with primary and secondary alcohols containing two or more carbon atoms [82]. ~odificationby tertiary alcohols does not proceed readily and furthermore, the modifier decomposes by dehydration at elevated temperatures. The esterified silica surface is preferentially wetted by at er-immiscible organic liquids, andasthe degree of esterification increases it becomes less hydrophilic and more organophilic. It is interesting to note that the adsorption of nonpolar adsorbate is also affected by the silanol content of silica surface; the heat of adsorption of nitrogen at about -196°C decreases as a function of the surface silanol content Heat of adsorption of nitrogen is more sensitive to replacement of hydroxyl groups with
alkoxy groups than it is to the removal of hydroxyl groups through dehydroxylation [84]. The importance of nitrogen as adsorbate stems from being the recommended adsorptive, except with solids of very low surface area, for evaluation of both the surface area and pore size distribution from a single adsorption isotherm [85]. The evaluation of the specific surface area makes use of the famous BET equation [86] that has the linear form: l
P
V(P0
C-1P
P)
where is the volume equivalent to a monolayer coverage, and Po is the vapor pressure of the adsorbate. The constant C has been given the form:
where E lis the average heat of adsorption of the first layer, and EL is the heat of liquefaction of the adsorbate. Itis the value of this C constant, calculated from the slope and the intercept of the linear relation P) versus that has been taken as a measure of the heat adsorption, and its value determines theapplicability of Eq. (4) to surface area determination. The postulates used in deriving the applied equation emphasize neglecting the adsorbate-adsorbate interaction if compared withtheadsorbate-adsorbentinteraction,inthebeginning of adsorption. This implies that a complete monolayer takes place u n i f o ~ ~ lbefore y the multi~ayer formation, suggested by the theory in [86], begins. These conditions are accompanied by a high valueof the C constant, greater than50 an approximation, and the decrease in the value of C is taken as an indication of the intervention of the adsor~ate-adsorbate interaction duringthe monolayer formation. In this case the evaluated area suffers from uncertainty that increases with the drastic decrease in the value of C. With modified silica surface, the replacementof the silanols, which are the high-energy nitrogen adsorption sites [83] leads to decrease in the heat of adsorption of nitrogen, for which the obtained value of area has to be taken with caution. Itis helpful in this respect that the casesof very lowvalues of C correspond to type I11 or adsorption isothermsof nitrogen 1851 which are convex to the axis over a large range enclosing the monolayer formation region of PIP0 (0.05he data in these cases are not amenable to the BET method for evaluation of surface area.On the other hand, the decrease, upon modification, of high-energy adsorption sites was found advantageous, being accompanied by more uniform surface superior for chromatography [87]. major problem for good performance in gas-solid cllromatography is the surface heterogeneity of the solid adsorbent. When ordinary silica gels are used as column packing material, the resulting solute usually asyl~metricalwith the rear edge of the peak having tailing ause of the variability of adsorption energy for thedifferent adsorption sites, the solute molecules remain on the active or high-energy sites for a longer time than the average,giving rise to peak tailing. This tailing decreases the effectiveness of the colunnn and makesquantitativemeasurementsmore difficult. A better performance is obtainedwithmoreuniform silica obtained by substitution of more inert groups for the active surface silanols. Effective modifiers in this respect
ilic
are alcohols, chlorosilanes, and hexamethyldisilazine [88-901 that reducethe adsorption of molecules such as H20, HC1, and C6H6. Furthermore, because of its high rigidity and slight tendency to swell, silica gel functionalized with organofunctional groups was shown to be highly selective in the exchange process and therefore a good candidate to be used in high-performance liquid-exchange chromatography [91]. Silica modified gel with pyridinium ion, Si(CH& N+C5H5C1-, was shown to selectively adsorb Cu(I1) as CuC142- fromethanol solution, and the dimeric Cu2C162- fromacetonesolution [92]. For Co(TI), the adsorbed species was the tetrahedral C O C ~ complex ~ ~ - from both solvents; however, the adsorption was much higher from acetone than from ethanol solution. The ability of organofunctional groups to absorb metal ions from nonaqueous solutions has been revealed by using a modified silica with different organofunctionality for preconcentration and separation of metal ions dissolved in organic solvents [93-95]. In the process of supporting a catalyst, the first step involves a bond formation between the catalyst precursor and the surface of the support. This leads to a modified surface which, in the case of silica, exposes ESi links, where M may be MO,Cr, or other elements which differ in their affinities toward bonding tosilica. The calcination step, which in most cases comprises heatingup to 500°C results in the breaking of a great number of such links, leaving only the strongly held species. This thermal treatment, in addition, leads to a considerable amount of dehydroxylation. Removal of OH groups upon condensation occurs by random interactions of adjacent hydroxyls from therichest areas, and up to800"C, the density of isolated OH groups increases by virtue of condensation of silanol groups pairs from a group composed of an odd number. A. distinguished state of dehydroxylation exists when a pair of OH groups are presentin an isolated manner in the sense that they form bonds with each other only, being not a part of an extending donlain of cluste groups. This pair of OH groups results in two IR bands at 3720 cm" due to the protonacceptor group, and at 3520-3540 cm" due to proton donor group196,971. However, this pair of OH groups is not present on the silica heated to 500°C [32,66]. The essence a normal surface silica is the probable presence such a pair of silanol groups as long as the heating t e ~ p e r a t u r e does not exceed and their absence in case the s ~ m p ~heated e at 500°C or h i g ~ e r The . detection of the above-mentioned IR bands on the surfaceof silica gel heated 500°C has been reported in the case of ~o-nlodifiedsilica [50 Fi 7 The results are interpreted in terms of the weak bonding in ESi-0which are present on the surface as (=Si -0)2 -MO, and which up0 leave 2(ESi 0)in their positions. The bulk waterthat may evolvedue to heating at 500°C may easily hydrolyze thesesites, resulting in 2( ESi 0 are necessarily quite near to each otherso as to be H-bonded groups. The behavior of terminal group is judged from the defined character of the band at 3720 cm" (12% MO)and attributed to the environmental nearby these silanols. The surface is dominated either by an isolated OH group, or a siloxane group ehydroxylation of groups that primarily escaped the interaction The consecutive increasein the intensity of the considered bands was shown to be accompanied by a decreasein the intensity of the
4000
3200
Wavenumbers
spectra of silica loaded with different Ref. 50.)
of MO.(From
ilica
band at 3750 cm", due tofreely vibrating isolated groups. When thenewly formed OH groups are positioned near to an isolated group, the latter suffers from perturbation via hydrogenbonding, which leads to adecrease in its IR band. Therefore a modified surface results, which exposesdifferent surface functionalities than should be expected on a surface heatedat 500°C. Thesilanol pairs detected in this case are considered as groups that have been protected from condensation through the involvement in a weak interaction with the M O species. Although no studies have been conducted to test the properties of this modified surface, it has to be less hydrophobic than normal silica heated at the same temperature. In all cases, modification of silica surface was due to one ortwo demands, either developing anew surface of different activity, or probing thefunctionality that may present. The nonuniform distribution of surface silanols is the working factor in both cases. The difference in activities of isolated, vicinal, or geminal groups has motivated the work concernedby masking or even depleting one kind, keeping, as a dominant type, one or two of the other types. Modification in relation to characterization has benefited from the different modes of interaction exhibited by different types of OHS toward modifiers of different activities. The vast amount of literature onmodified silicas reveals the highlevel of interest in the surfaceof silica. The silica surface plays acrucial role in determining its activity in the process of adsorption. The appearance of this surfaceshowsastrongdependenceonthe method through which the underlying matrix has been formed. Numerous factors significantly affect the formation of the three-dimensional network in the bulk, which leads to a wide scope of variations that canbe obtained through the control of a specified group of parameters. It follows that one can obtain many kinds of silica of variable properties fulfilling a specific number of requirements. This gives silica a particularflexibility, making itof usein several fields. far as the surface is concerned,a very broad area of objectives coversthevastrange ofspecificity displayed by the surface of silica in different media. A surface exhibiting variable pictures whenused undercontrolledconditionsfurnishesmanyadvantageous properties, making it useful for many purposes. Silica with its fascinating nature is one of those few materials lending themselves to fields of different disciplines. The adsorption process, by its definition, finds the surface of silica as an excellent candidatethatbothpermitsitsoccurrenceand highlights thebasic principles involved in it. Silica and adsorption are strongly related to each other, and the interesting properties of silica surface appear to be the key to this relation.
1. A. R. Ruffa. Phys. Rev. Lett. 25:650 (1970); Non-Crystalline Solids 13:37 (1973/ 1974). 2. C. L. Mckinnis and J. W. Sutton. J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 42:194 (1959);24250 (1959). C. G. Dodd and G. L. Glen. J. Appl. Phys. 39:5377 (1968). 4. K. Fajans and N. J. Kreidl. J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 105 (1948). 5. Brunauer, D. L. Kantro, and C. H. Weise. Canad. J. Chem. 34:1483 (1956). W. D. Harkins and G. Jura. J. Am.Chem. Soc. 66:1362 (1944).
7.
K. Her, The Chemistry
Silica, Cornel1 University Press, Ithaca, N. Y., 1955
8. J. H. De Boer and J. M. Vleeskins. Proc. K. Ned. Akad. Wet. Ser. B: Palaento]. Geol. Phys. Chem. B61:85 (1958). 9. J. B. Peri and L. Hensley. J. Phys. Chern. 72:2926 (1968). 10. D. Sindorf and G. E. Maciel, J, Am. Chem. Soc. 105:1487 (1983). G. C. Pirnentel and A. L. McClellan, The ~ y ~ r o Bond, ~ e n F. Freeman Co., San Francisco, CA, 1960. 12. Barby, in C~~racterizfftion Surjaces (C. D.Parfitt and K. S. W. Sing, Academic Press, New York, 1976, p. 402. 13. Weiser, Chemistry, 2nd ed., Wiley, New York, 1953, p. 307. 14. R. K. Iler, The C h e ~ i s t r y 2nd ed., Wiley,New York, Chichester, isbane, Toronto, 1979. 15. System DANA, 7th ed., Vol. 3, Silica ~ i ~ e r a l s , Frondel, Wiley, New York, 1962, p. 154. 16. G. D. Ulrich. Combust. Sci. Technol. 4:47 (1971). 17. annemacher. J. Colloid Interface Sci. 125:61 (1988). 18. A. P. Legrand, Y. Chevallier, and J. C. Morawski. Colloids 19, H. A. Classens, L. J. M. van de Yen, J. W. de Haan, and C. A. Cramers, J. High esolut. Chromatogr. Chromatogr. Commun. 6:433 (1983). 20. eiderer er, K. Albert, E. Bayer, L. J. M. van de Ven, J. W. de Maan, and C. A. ramers. Phys. Chern. 944189 (1990). 21. J. Fripiat. ACS Syrnp. Ser. 194:165 (1982). 22. P. M. Carrott and K. S. Sing. Adsorption Sci. Technol. 1:31 (1984). 23. Flernming. Physik Chem. 41:427 (1902). 24. A. P. Brady, A. G. Brown, and H. Huff. J. Colloid Interface Sci. 8:264 (1953). K. Iler. Phys. Chem. 57:604 (1953). 25. 26. K. R. Anderson, L. S. Dent-Glasser, and D. N. Smith, in S o l u ~ Silicates l~ (J. lcone, ed.), ACS Syrnposium Series 194, 1982, p. 115. Shafer, D. D. Awschalom, and J. Warnock. Appl. Phys. 61:5438 (1987). 27. Coltrain, S. M. Melpolder, and J. M. Salva, in ~ l t r a s t r u c t ~ r e 28. ~ a t e r i ~(D. l ~ sR.Uhlrnann and D. R. Ulrich, eds.), Wiley, NewYork, 1992, p. 69. 29. D.Avnir and D.Farin. Nature 308:261 (1984). 30. A. C. de Pradel and B. Irnelik. C. R. Acad. Sci. 242122 (1956). 31. L.Hench and D. Ulrich, ~ l t r a , s t ~ u c t Processing ~re Ceramics Glasses and C o ~ ~ o s i tWiley, e ~ ~ , New York, 1984, p. Morrow and A. McFarlan. Langrnuir 7: 1695 (1991). 32. 33. R. Cillespie. Chern. Ed. 40:295 (1965). C h e ~ i s t r yof ON Group, Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs,N. J., 34. L. P. Clapp, 1967. 35. Peri. Phys. Chem. 70:2937 (1966). Dugger, H. Stanton, B. N. Irby, B. L. McConnell, W. W. Curnmings, and 36. R. W. Maatrnan. J. Phys. Chem. 68:757 (1964). 37. ~arshall, G.L. Ridgewell, C. M. Rochester,and J. Simpson.Chern. Ind. (London) 19:775 (19741.
38. M. L. Hair and W. Hertl. J. Phys. Chem. 74:91 (1970). 39. T. Hiemstra, W. H. van Riel~sdijk,and G. H.Bolt. J. Colloid Interface Sci. 133:91 (1989). 40. P. W,Schindler, B. Fiirst, R. Dick, and P. V. Wolf. J. Colloid Interface Sci.5.5:469 (1976). 41. T, Hiemstra, J. C. M. De Wit, and W. H. van Riemsdijk. J. Colloid Interface Sci. 133:105 (1989). 42. G. M. S. El Shafei. J. Colloid Interface Sci. 182:249 (1996). 43 J. H. Stanton and R. W.Maatman. J. Colloid Sci. 18:132 (1963). 44. A. M. Petrov. Tr. Khim. i Khirn. Technol. 1:229 (1958). 45 D. N. Strazhesko and G. F. Yankovskaya. Ukr. Khim. Zh. 2.5:471 (1959). 46. S. S. Bhatnagar, K. N. Mathur, and P. L. Kapur. Indian J. Phys. 3:53 (1928). 47. M. T. Rogers and R. van der Vennen. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 7.5:1751 (1953). 48. C. M. Frensh and J. P. Howard. Trans. Faraday Soc. .52:712 (1956). 49 R. J. Faber and M. T. Rogers. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 81:1849 (1959). 50. C. M. S. El Shafei and M. M. Mohamed. Colloid Surf. 94267 (1995). 51. M. M. Mohamed and G. M.S. El Shafei. Spectrochemica Acta A .51:1525 (1995). ~ n gDekker, , New York, 52. M. D. Joeslen and L. Schaad. Hydrogen ~ o ~ ~Marcel 1974. 53. B. A. Morrow and I. A. Cody. J. Phys.Chern.79:761(1975);80:1995(1976); 80:2761(1976). 54. G. M. S. El Shafei and M. Mohamed. J. Colloid Interface Sci. 17.5:518(1995). 55. D. C. Jones and L. Outridge. J. Chem. Soc. 1574 (1930). 56. R. W. Maatrnan, A. Geertsema, H. Erhage, G. Baas, and M. Du Mez. J. Phys. Chem. 72:97 (1968). 57. J. A.Anderson and C. H. Rochester. J. Chem.Soc. Faraday Trans. I 85:3505 (1 989). 58. K. Klier and A. C. Zettlemoyer. J. Colloid Interface Sei. 58216 (1979). 59. H. Knozinger, in The ~ ~ ~ ~ Bond o g (P. e Schuster, n G. Zundel, and C. Sandrofy, eds.), North Holland, Amsterdam, 1976. 60. J. Texter, K. Klier, and A. C. Zettlemoyer.Prog.Surf.MembraneSci.12:327 (1978). 61. D. R. Bassett. Thesis, Lehigh University (1967). 62. A. C. Zettlemoyer. J. Colloid Interface Sci. 28:343 (1968). 63. P. B. Barraclough and P. G. Hall. J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. I 74:1360 (1978). 64. M. N. Plooster and S. N. Gitlin. J. Phys. Chem. 7.5:3322 (1971). 65. V. R. Deitz and N. H. Turner. J. Phys. Chem. 7.59718 (1971). 66. B. A. Morrow and A. J. McFarlan. J. Non-Crystalline Solids 220:61 (1990). 67. D. J. C. Yates, G. W. Dembinski, W. R. Krell, and J. J. Elliott. J. Phys. Chern. 73:911 (1969). 68. J. Kunawicz, P. Jones, and J. A. Kockey. Trans. Faraday Soc. 67:848 (1971). 69. R. J. Azrak and C. L. Angell. J. Phys. Chem. 773048 (1973). 70. G. S. Caravajal, D. E. Leyden, G. R. Quinting, and C. E. Maciel. Anal. Chem. 60:1776 (1988). 71. K. Possemiers, K. C. Vrancken, P. van der Voort, and E. F. Vansant. J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. I 91:2173 (1995).
72. 73. 74. 75. 76. 77. 78. 79 80. 81. 82.
83. 84. 85. 86. 87. 88. 89. 90. 91. 92. 93. 94. 95. 96. 97
G. A. Blomfield and L. H. Little. Canad. J. Chem. 51:1771 (1973). P. Fink and I. Plotzki. Wiss. Tech. Univ. Friedrich Schiller 29:815 (1980). M. P. McDaniel. J. Phys. Chem. 85:532 (1981). M. L. Hair and W. Hertl. J. Phys. Chem. 73:2373 (1969). H. P.Boehm and M. Schneider. Z. Anorg. Allg. Chem. 301:326 (1959). P. vanderVoort, I. G. D’Hamers, and E. F. Vansant. J. Chem.Soc. Faraday Trans. 86:3751 (1990). P, van der Voort, 1. G. D’Hamers, K. C. Vrancken, and E. F. Vansant. J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. I 87:3 174(1 99 Possemiers, P. van der Voort, and E. F. Vansant. J. Chem. Soc.Faraday Trans. I 92:679 (1996). Tech.IJniv.FriedrichSchiller P.Fink, 1. Plotzki, and G. Rudakoff.Wiss. 39:2 17 (1 990). C. Morterra and M. J. D. Low. Phys. Chem. 73:327 (1969). C. C. Ballard, E. C. Broge. R. K. Her, D. S. St. John, and J. R. McWhorter. J. Phys. Chem. 65:20 (1961). J. W. Whalen. Phys. Chem. 72: 1557 (1967). W. K. Lowen and E. C. Broge, J. Phys. Chem. 65:16 (1961). Reportingphysisorption data for gaslsolidsystems.PureAppl.Chem.57:603 (1985). Brunauer, P. H. Emmett, and E. Teller. J. Am. Chem. 60:309 (1938). J. Sore11 and R. Rowen Jr. Anal. Chem. 42: 1712 (1970). A.V, Kiselev, in (M. V. Swaay, ed.), Butterworth, London, 1962, p. 34. 2440 Bohemen, H. Langer, R. H. Perrett, and J. H. Purnell. Chem. (1 960). J. H. Purnell, Wiley, New York, 1962, pp. 108-109. M.Grimpel and K. Unger. Chromatographia 17:200 (1983). Y. Gushikem and M. S. Iamamoto. J. Colloid Interface Sci. 134:275 (1990). R.F. Sturgeon, S. S. Berman, S. N.Willie, and J. A. H. Desaulniers. Anal. Chem. 53:2337 (198 P. Sutthivaiyakit and A. Kettrup. Anal. Chim. Acta 169:331 (1985). J. C. Moreira and Y. Gushikexn. Anal. Chim. Acta 176:263 (1985). A. Morrow, I. A. Cody, and L. S. M. Lee. J. Phys. Chem. 80:2761 (1976). P. Hoffmann and E. Knoezinger. Surf. Sci. 188:181 (1987).
V Department of Chemistry, M. Moscow State University, Moscow, Russia
Lomonosov
I. Silica Chemistry Surface Adsorption 63 and chemistry SurfaceA. silica of adsorbents Determination of surface silanol groupconcentrationon silica72 C. Molecular interactions at adsorption of various compounds on silica surface D. Peculiarity of adsorption water on silica E. Evaluation of energy of hydrogen bonds of silanol groups on silica F. Chemical ~odification silica of surface Silica adsorbents deposited with carbon layers H. Silica grafted with fullerene molecules I.modification Adsorption silica of J. Application of hydroxylated and modified silica
63 74 79 86 87 93 95 97 100
Conclusion
113
References
114
Many papers and monographs (e.g., Refs 1-5) have been dedicated to the investigation of adsorption properties and surface chemistry of silica. Silica is one of the most important adsorbents used in chemical technology and chromatography, for immobilization of enzymes, a catalyst support, well filler for polymer l ~ a t ~ r i aand l s raw materials foroptical products and so forth. Through the study of surface chemistryof silica, intermolecular interaction adsorption on silica well the mechanism of adsorption on silica has become of great importance. Many
laboratories and groups around the worldinvestigate properties of silica and a lot of information on properties of silica has been collected. Some of the mainresults on surface chemistryand adsorption propertiesof silica obtained in the laboratory of adsorption and gas chromatography founded by Professor A. V. Kiselev (Chemistry Department of M. Lomonosov, Moscow State University) are presented. For the investigation of silica surface chemistrydifferent physicochemical methods are used, such as adsorption, adsorption calorimetry, chromatography, and optical and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy. Infrared (IR) spectroscopy has provedto be one of the most informative methodsof investigation of silica surface chemistry, which makes it possible to determine both qualitative and quantitative compositions of functional groups on silica surfaces and inside silica particles, as well observe the interactions of functional groups with adsorbed molecules and their participation in chemical reactions. It was found that surface samplesof different forms of silica such as Aerosilhighly dispersed silica (pyrogenic silica), Aerosilogels, prepared from aerosils by hydrothermal treatment, silica gels, and porous glass in a limiting hydroxylated state, havesimilar properties. So the results of investigation of surface propertiesof different silicas are comparable. In silica there are single or "free"(3750cm") and hydrogen-bonded (3550 cm") surface silanol (hydroxyl)groups and intraglobular silanol groups (3650 cm") (Figs and 2) which may be detected only after deuterium exchange reaction of vapor D 2 0with surface silanol groups [6,7]. The quantity of free and hydrogenbonded silanol groups may be changed by heating silica samples or by chemical reaction with modifiers. The 3650 cm" band is attributed to intraglobular silanol spectra of silica containing adsorbed water in the region 40003000 cm" in all cases have overlapping bandsof both water molecules and silanol groups hydrogen-bonded with each other and with water molecules.So it is difficult only from the spectral data in this region to distinguish silanol groups from hydroxyl groups of water molecules. In the region 8 0 0 0 ~ 0 0 0cmm1there are overtone bands of stretching vibrations of silanol groups and water (2uOH) as well as combination bands of water and silanol groups (uOH S) which do not overlap with the first two bands. So these bands can be used for detection of the presence or absence of water in silica Spectra of silica in this region can be obtained using apile of pressed thin plates of Aerosil. The transparency of such a pile in the ~ 0 0 0 ~ 0 cm-' 0 0 region is quite enough to register good IR spectra with a double-beam spectrometer. Figure 3 shows IR spectra of liquid water (l) consisting of two bands: overtones of stretching frequency of vibrations of interacting water hydroxyl groups 7000 cm") and a combination band of stretching and deformation frequency of water hydroxyl groups S200 cm-') as well spectra Aerosil 163 m2/g) standing in air with adsorbed water(2). In the spectrum there are broad bandsin the region 7000 cm" consisting of overlapping bands of surface silanol groups (2usiOH), surface silanol groups perturbed by adsorbed water molecules, and the adsorbed water molecules themselves (2uOH), band S300 cm-' (uOH S) of adsorbed water, as well as a combination band 4550 cm" (vsiOH S) of silanol groups.
Infrared spectra of Aerosils with different specific surface area (I 180, I1 136, 111 100, and IV m2/g) evacuated at 200"C, before ( l ) and after (2) deuteriumexchangereaction at ambienttemperature(a)andafterevacuation at 400°C (From Ref. 7.)
Evacuation of samples uptoTorratambienttemperature even after lh result in large decrease of band 5300 cm-' (Fig. 3) and after 9 h this band practically disappears from the spectrum. Aerosil with adsorbed waterwas investigated by IR spectra in the region of the deformation frequency of water 8H20[lo].The adsorbed water band at 1620 cm-' disappeared from the spectrum of nonporous silica at evacuation at room temperature. It means that adsorbed water is removed from the surface of nonporous silica at ambient tern erature as was determined in [9,lO]. The evacuation of Aerosil at 150°C up to 10" Torr did not result in visible changes in the spectrum. This means that at evacuation of silica up to 150-200"C, dehydration of the surface took place, but not dehydroxylation. Thus if the sample includes water in any state, in the spectrum the band S300 c111-l should exist. Figure 4 shows the comparison of two spectra ofsilica: (a) Aerosil with S 163 m2/g and(b) Aerosilogel withS SO m2/g preparedby hydrothermal treatment Aerosil which contained a remarkable concentrationof intra-
J.
Distinguishing of bands of surface hydrogen-bonded silanol groups(dotted lines) in infrared spectra of Aerosils with different specific surface area (I 180, 11 136, I11 100 m2/g)after evacuation at 2OO"C, (1) before and (2) after deuterium exchange reaction at ambient temperature with D 2 0 vapor. (From Ref. 7.)
globular silanol groups [6]. The comparison of spectra of these silica containing adsorbed water shows thatintensity of the 5300 cm" band is larger for Aerosil at about equal sample thickness of tablets: 0.33 and 0.26 g/cm2 respectively. Such a difference is due to a distinction in specific surface area of samples. After evacuation at 150°C for 2 h (curves 2) the combination band of molecular water disappeared. Deuterium exchange reaction at room temperature makes it possible to replace all accessible hydroxyl groups of silica by groups In spectra 3a and 3b (Fig. 4) there are the bands of groups SiQD for both samples but of different intensity. In the Aerosil spectrum the band 5430 cm-' (overtone of band SiQD) is more intense than for Aerosilogel because of the difference in specific surface area of samples. In the spectrum of region ~000-6000 cm", band (2usioa) disappears almost completely; at the same time in the Aerosilogel spectrum thereis a band of intraglobular hydroxyl groups inaccessible fordeuteriumexchangereactions at ambient temperature.
Infrared spectra of liquid water (1) and Aerosil with adsorbed water before (2) and after evacuation (3-7).
Thus the bands 3660-3650 cm" and 7150 cm"' are due to intraglobularsilanol groups but not water moleculesexisting inside silica globules. Dehydration of pure silica occurs at ambient temperature, but the rate of this process depends on the porosity of the adsorbent. For removal of adsorbed water from fine porous silica, a long time or elevated temperature are needed. The energy of interaction of bonded and intraglobular silanol groups with each other can be characterized qualitatively by a shift of frequency of the ~ a x i m u mof their bands. ~uantitatively,theenergy of interaction of silanol groupscan be evaluated by using the changesin integral intensity of bands of these groups, taking into consideration the correlation between integral intensity and hydrogen bond energy 1 Thus to determine the energetic characteristics of different silanol groups of silica it isnecessary to evaluate the integral intensity of bands of surfaces free and hydrogen bonded as well as intraglobular hydroxyl groups of silica.
where aOH is concentration of hydroxyl groups in samples (~mol/m2), and are intensity of initial and transmitted radiation with frequency U , B is a measure for limiting values of aps, the integral intensity of the band, S is specific surface area (m2/g) and plate mass per unit area (g/cm2).
cm"
Infrared spectra of Aerosil (a) and Aerosilogel (b): (1)sampleswith adsorbed water before evacuation, (2) after evacuation at 150°C for h, and (3) after deuterium exchange reactionat ambient temperature and evacuation 150°C.
The true integral intensity of a band of free silanol groups on a silica surface, can be evaluated from spectra of silica plates of different thickness, prepared from Aerosil samples havingdifferent aoH, and S. For determination of aOH the correlation between aoH and temperature of evacuation for different samples of Aerosils was used for which the aoH were determined by different methods. a result the averageaOH values were accepted for Aerosil samples evacuated at 700, 800, 900, and 1000°C respectively, 2.0, 1.5, 1.1, and 0.7 p/mol/m2, or 1.2, 0.9, 0.6, and 0.4 groups/m2. The calculated true integral band intensity of free silanol groups on a silica surface, AOH, is 9.8 pmol" cm The bands of surface silanol groups of silica evacuated at 200 and 450°C can be distinguished by graphical subtraction of overlapping bands of intraglobular silano1 groups from the spectra of Aerosil evacuatedat 200 and 450°C before and after a deuterium exchange reaction of D 2 0 with silanol groups. The band area of hydrogen-bondedsurface silanol groups can be found by graphical subtraction of the free silanol group band from the spectra of Aerosil evacuated at 200°C. Then taking into consideration that, under heating from 200 up to 450"C, the silica sample loses 3.7 pm01 OH/m2 [7],it is possible to evaluate integral intensity of these hydroxyl group bands. For two samples of Aerosil with
163 m2/g the average integral intensity of hydrogen-bonded surface silanol groups is B 43.7 pmol" cm ~121. For determination of spectral and energetic characteristics of intraglobular silano1 group band silicas with a large quantity of these groups are needed. Silica samples under hydrothermal treatment transform into wide-pore silica adsorbents. Such adsorbents have large a quantity of intraglobular hydroxyl groups. Fordetermination of the integral intensity of theintraglobularhydroxylgroupband, Aerosilogels with specific surface area 109, 50, and 13 m2/g, prepared by hydrothermal treatment of Aerosil were used 1121. Areas of the band 3650 cm"' were determined from infrared spectra of these Aerosilogels after deuterium exchange reaction with vapor D 2 0 at ambient temperature and evacuation at 150°C. For calculation of integral intensity it is necessary to know the concentratio11 of intraglobular silanol groups, which can be determined by loss of sample weight after calcination at 1000°C in air. At this temperature, il1traglobular and most of the surface silanol groups are removed. In 131 it was shown that after evacuation of silica at 750-8OO"C, there are no intraglobular silanol groups in the spectra. Small concentrations of residual surface hydroxyl groups at 1000°C can be evaluated from the dependence of surface concentration of hydroxyl groups on calcination temperature 171. Thequantity of intraglobular silanol groups in silicas can be determined by subtraction of the amount of surface hydroxyl groups from the loss of mass sample at 1000°C calcination. The integral intensity of intraglobular silanol groups was calculated from
S
where cOHis the concentration of intraglobular groups 0 (pmol/g), is plate massperunitarea (g/cm2), andthe integral is area o band 3650 c111-l of intraglobular silanol groups(cm-').The limits of integration were from 4000 to 3000 cm-'.Calculated integral intensity of intraglobular silanol groups is pmol" cm 1121. Now it is possible to evaluate the concentration of intraglobular silanol groups in Aerosil with S 163 m2/g using the area of the 3650 cm"' band and integral intensity. In this case, to determinetheconcentration of intraglobular silanol groups of Aerosil by loss of weight at calcination is very difficult because the main change of weight will be determined on the whole by removal of surface silanol groups, and the precision of the experiment does not make it possible to evaluate the change of mass, owing to removal of intraglobular silanol groups. For two samples of Aerosil evacuated at 200°C the average concentration of illtraglobular silanol groups was 0.144 mm01 OH/g, that is, about 10% of surface silanol groups. The dependence of intraglobular silanol group concentration on. specific surface area of silica is shown in Fig. Concentration of these silanol groups of silicas prepared by hydrothermal treatment and evacuated at tem~eraturesnot higher than 150-200°C reaches a constant value with decreasing specific surface area of the sample. It means that the degree of polycondensation of silicic acid is approximatelythesamewhen large particles of hydrothermalsamplesareformed. ncreasing the surface area, i.e., decreasing the diameter of globules, results in a
Concentration of intraglobular silanol groups of silica samples with different specific surface area. (From Ref. 12.)
decrease of shared intraglobular silanol groups of silica and in the limit, the concentration of these silanol groups is zero. For silica samples with specific surface area S 200-300 m2/gand higher, theconcentration of intraglobular silanol groups is negligible and concentration of surface hydroxyl groupsof silica samples can be determined by simple calcination, by weight loss. For determinat~on of the concentrationof surface silanol groups of samples with smaller specific surface area as well as silica adsorbents with chemically modified surfaces, other methods have to be used. In Aerosil evacuatedat 450°C the average concentrationof intraglobu~arsilanol groups 0.049 mm01 OH/g, i.e., more than half these groups at such heating are removed. Heating of Aerosil at 750-800°C results in removing all intraglobular silanol groups 121. Evacuation at heating from 200 to 450°C results in not only removal of some intraglobular silanol groups and a decrease of intensity of the 3660 cm"' band, but also shift of frequency to larger wavelength at 20 cm". The asymmetrical band 3660 cm"' at heating of Aerosil decreases irregularly. This means that there is the distributio~of intraglobular silanol groups on energy interactions similar as for hydrogen-bonded surface silanol groups of silica. If we compare the changes of concentration and specific surface area of different silica (Aerosil) silanol groups with temperature of evacuation it is possible to find the interesting regularity presented in Fig. 6. The most essential changes in the structure of sample occur at temperatures above 450°C when free hydroxyl groups are removed. The removal of hydrogen-bonded silanol groups does not result in visible changes in structure of particles, their density or specific surface area. So rehydroxylation of silica, heated up to 450"C, makes it possible to return to the initial state, but rehydroxylation of silica heated at higher temperatures results in formation of other samples with smaller specific surface area. Intraglobular silanol groups are formed during the silicic acid polycondensation process at hydrotherl~al treatment ofsilica or in its synthesis. At formation of three-dimensionalpolymersfrom silicic acid not all hydroxylgroupscanform water molecules. As a result, amorphous silica with large quantity of intraglob-
150
Concentration changes of various silanol groups of Aerosil with S 163 m2/gat heating of samplefrom 200 to 1000°Cas well asspecificsurfacearea changes.
ular silanol group is formed, and violation of structure with formation offine channels (micropores) occurs. Formation of ultrapores is probably determined by the structure of the initial silica being the framework of a new structure. clarify the influence of initial silica structure on concentrationof intramolecular silanol groups and on the variety of ultraporosity, samples of Aerosilogel with S 47 m2/g, prepared by hydrothermal treatment of Aerosil A175 and silica gel with S 123 rn2/g, prepared by hydrothermal treatment of initial silica gel with s 220 m-/g, were investigated by an infrared method 214.1, Study of the deuterium exchange reaction of silanol groups of these samples by IR spectroscopy shows that both silica gel and Aerosilogel prepared by hydrothermal treatment contain a considerable quantityof intraglobular silanol groups which are relatively more available for deuterium exchange with D 2 0 for silica gel. Exchange reaction occurs noticeably even at ambient temperature and most of the intraglobular silanol groups exchange at 200°C. Deuterium exchange of D20 with intraglobular silanol groups of Aerosilogel at ambient temperature hardly occurs and only at very slow passes at 200°C This means that Aerosilogel has extremely narrow ultrapores, these being gaps between polysilicic acid chains not fully reacted with each other. In infrared spectra of porous glasses the intraglobular or intraskeleton silanol groups are manifested also. At removal of the borate phase by alkali, very fine canals are produced.Onlysmallwater molecules canpenetratethese canals. Depending on the conditions of alkalization and the composition of boron-silica glass, porous glasses with different specific surface areas and containing various intraskeleton silanol groups are formed 151. Concentration of intraglobular silanol groups can be determined by the NMR method 161if beforehand all surface silanol groups are replaced by OD groups using the deuterium exchangereaction. By this method, concentrationof intraglobular silanol groups in samples of Aerosilogel with S 50 m2/g was determined [17].
Theconcentrations of intraglobular silanol groupsdetermined by the IVMR method and by weight at calcination coincide quite well [13,17]. Thus the combinationof the infrared method with deuterium exchange reaction and reaction of dehydroxylation makes it possible to determine the maxima of absorption bands of three main types of silica hydroxyl groups and also determine their concentrations, but onlyin silica samples from which it is possible to prepare rather transparent plates in the region 4000-2200 cm".
Adsorption properties of adsorbents and supports aswell as fillers of polymers are mainly determined by concentration of surface silanol groups. To determine the concentration of silanol groups fromIR spectra by integral intensity of band silanol groups in many casesisdifficult becauseit is too complicated and sometimes impossible to prepare transparent adsorbentplates in the infrared region spectrum. To increase transparency of adsorbent plates, sometimes these plates are placed in carbontetrachloride orin oil. But determination.of concentration of surface hydroxyl groups from infrared spectra obtained in such a way is rather difficult. In Refs 18 and 19 the method of determination of surface silanol group concentration by deuterium exchange with mass-spectrometric controlis presented. It is accepted that the isotopic composition of water in thegasphaseunderthe adsorbent is equal to theisotopic composition of surfwe groups capableof deuterium exchange reaction, i.e., it is considered that the coefficient of separation of isotopic water molecules onthis adsorbent is equal to 1. Probably such an approximation canbe accepted for many cases because the coefficient of separation differs from by less than the measurement error by this method, which is several percent. The values of concentration of surface silanol groups of nonporous and highly porous silica determined by the deuterium exchange method and other chemical methods are similar [7]. Determination of isotope composition of surface silanol groups may be simplifiedbyusing infraredspectranot of thesamples themselves but of suitable auxiliary adsorbents having high transmittance, for exampleAerosil. An ampoule holdingasampleunderinvestigationcontainingaknownportion of D20 is connected toan optical cellwith a plate of an auxiliary adsorbent (Aerosil), thespectrum ofwhichwas detected preliminarily. After isotopic equilibration between samples under investigation, the vapor phase and Aerosil plate infrared spectrum of this plate is detected again, It possible to consider that isotopic compositions of surface silanol groups of the Aerosil plate being in contact with the adsorbent under investigation and in the vapor phase are the same as the isotopic composition of surface silanol groups of adsorbent. This isotopic cornposition can be determined by the initial spectrum of Aerosil and the spectrum after isotopic equilibration with the adsorbent under investigation [20]. Thus the deuteriumexchangemethodwithmass-spectrometric(MS)controlmay be replaced by the same method with IR spectroscopic control [20]. This method can be applied for determination of surface concentration of any groups
-NHz, NH, capable of deuterium exchange reaction with D2Q on any adsorbents. The quantityof hydroxyl groups on adsorbent surface aoH can be determined by
where ([Hl/[D])a~~~rben~m([Hl/[Rl)Ae~~~il @OD initial I>OD equilibrate)/ DODequilibrate, mDz0 and are mass of D20 taking part in the deuterium exchange reaction and mass of adsorbent, ROD log is the optical density of 2760 cm" band free OD groups on the Aerosil surface. If the specific surface area of adsorbent S is known, then the concentration of surface hydroxyl groups can be calculated:
This method was used for determination of concentration of silanol groups on surfaces of two adsorbents used in liquid chromatography, silica gel LiChrosorb SI 60 and silanizedsilicagel LiChrosorb RP 2. The average surface concentrations of silanol groups for LiChrosorb SI 60 and LiChrosorb RP 2 were 8.0 and 4.5 pmol/m* f 5% respectively. Surface concentration of silanol groups of the first sample is thesameasfor all limiting hydroxylated silica[7,21], andfor modified silicagel LiChrosorb RP 2theconcentration of hydroxylgroups is much smaller. Thismeans that not all hydroxylgroupsareremovedfromthe surface, but only free hydroxyl groups; hydrogen-bonded surface silanol groups remain [7,8]. Other auxiliary adsorbentshavinghydroxylgroups available fordeuterium exchange reaction may be polymer film framework structures [22], for example, polyester-melamine film [17]. In contrast withAerosil, this film is a poor adsorbent of water and so there is no need of evacuation at high temperature for removalof adsorbed water. Many polymers, prepared by polycondensation reaction and polyaddition, have remaining functional groups with "active" hydrogen which do not take part in the reaction of polymer formation owing to steric hindrance. These grou (hydroxyl groups) are responsible for wide bands in the region 3700-3000 cm-'of infrared spectra owingto formation of intra- and intramolecular hydrogen bonds that may take part in deuterium exchange reaction with vapor D2Q, which results in corresponding changesof spectra: the band in the region 3700-3000 cm-' disappears and the bandin 2700-2200 cm-' appears. The deuterium exchange rate very high, so the kinetics of deuterium exchangein the film will bed e t e r ~ i n e don the whole by the diffusion process. The surface concentration of hydroxyl groups of LiChrosorb Si 100 was determined with polyester-melamine film as auxiliary adsorbent [17]. After evacuation of LiChrosorb Si 100 at 150°C the average concentrationof surface silanol groups was TZOH f0.5 QH/nm2 which is similar to the values for all hydroxylated silica [2 l]. Thus the deuterium exchange method with spectroscopic control has turned out to be asimplemethod of determination of surfweconcentration of hydroxyl groups of adsorbent any nature.
At adsorption of nonionogeniccompounds on hydroxylated silica surfacetwo types of main interactions are manifested: van der Waals being universal for any compounds and interaction with formation of hydrogen bonds between the surface silanol groups and adsorbed electron donor molecules. Hydrogen bonding in many cases brings the essential contribution to the adsorption energy and so determines the adsorption process. Many studies have been dedicated to investigation of hydrogen bonds of silanol groups on adsorption. One of the brightest manifestations of the formation of hydrogen bonds, is changes in infrared spectra of interacting proton donor groups. Athydrogenbonding between hydroxylgroups of acid and base molecules, a decrease of stretching vibrationfrequencies of the OH group observed,The most sensitive spectral characteristic of hydrogenbondingnevertheless is the changes of integral intensity of the stretching band of acid hydroxyl groups [23]. Since on the silica surfacethereare both free and hydrogen-bonded silanol groups, it is important to investigate the role of each kind of groups in adsorption of various compounds. The investigation of the participation of free and bonded silanol groups in adsorption was made in Refs 24-27. In Ref. 24, the very small difference between the isotherms of diethyl ether adsorption onsilica evacuated at 150 and 400"C, i.e., on silica having free and bonded surface silanol groups and on silica with only free silanol groups, means that the main adsorption species of hydroxylated silica are free silanol groups [24]. Infrared study of adsorption of many classes of organic cornpounds supports this statement [24-271. In Fig. 7 the spectra of Aerosil evacuated at 200 and 400°C before and after adsorption of triethylamine, dibutyl and diethyl ethers, tetrahydrofurane, cyclopentanone,acetone, acetonitrile, ethyl acetate, andnitromethaneat different vaporpressuresarepresented. As a result of adsorption of compoundson Aerosilevacuated at 200"C, in thespectratheband 3750 cm-' offree silanol groups decreases in intensity and shifts to a lower frequency and a broader band of perturbed silanol groups is seen before adsorption as free silanol groups as well as bands of groups -CH, appear.The frequency of thebandmaximum of perturbedhydroxylgroupschangeswithincreasingadsorbate pressure. If one accepts that only free hydroxyl groups take part in adsorption 1241 and the band of bonded silanol groups has to be unchanged, then it is possible to make a graphical subtraction of the band of bonded silanol groups from the common broad-bandperturbed silanol groups. By suchasubtractionit is possible to distinguish theonlyband of silanol groupsperturbed by adsorbedmolecules which before adsorption were free. Maxima of these distinguished bands (dotted lines) are at the same wavenumber (Fig. 7). On the silica surface the only free silanol groups exist on evacuation at 400°C and therefore on adsorption of the c o ~ p o ~ l nin d ,the spectrum the only hydroxyl group band perturbed by adsorbed molecules appears. Figure 7 shows that maxima of silanol group bands perturbed by adsorbed molecules on silica evacuated at 200 and 400°C coincide [24]. A similar picture is observed on adsorption of alcohols [25,26].
400°C
0.5
0
0
3800
3200
3800
3200
3200
3800
3200
Infrared spectraofAerosilbeforeand after adsorption ofvarious compound vapors at different surface coverage, evacuated at 200°C (a) and 400°C (b) (drop lines are determined by subtraction of the bonded surface silanol group band from the general band of perturbed silanol groups). Ref. 27.)
Thus it is important to know not only the concentration of hydroxyl (silanol) groups on the silica surface but the relative quantity of free and bonded silanol groups, i.e., qualitative composition of silanol groups. In Ref. 28 the influence of the only residual free silanol groups of amino silica gel, but not residual bonded surface silanol groups, on retention of electron donor compounds in gas chromatography was demonstrated. To investigate interaction of free silanol groups on adsorption of various compounds by the infrared method it is more convenient to use samples evacuated at 400450°C or at higher temperature when on the surface only free silanol groups exist and the band of free silanol groupsbecomessymmetrical. In Aerosilsample was evacuated at 800°C andtheinfraredspectrumhasonlya narrow, almost symmetrical, band of stretching vibration of surface free silanol groups; it was very convenient to follow the changesof this band on adsorption of various compounds. The determinationof integral intensity of surface free silanol groups has been presented. For calculation of integral intensity of these groups perturbed by adsorbed molecules, the following equation was used:
where AoH is integral intensity of theband offree silanol groups, is area under the curve recalculated in optical density of silanol groups band perturbedby adsorbed molecules, is area under the curveof the band of free silanol before adsorption and S& is the area under the curveof the band of residual free silanol groups after adsorption. In Fig. 8 spectra of Aerosil evacuated at 800°C before and after adsorption of various organic compounds as well as the spectrum of Aerosil in liquid CC rom these spectraby Eq. (5) integral intensity AOH...M and Avow, band of stretching vibration of free silanol groups of Aerosil perturbedby adsorbed ecules were calculated. n Fig. 9 the correlations between energetic and spectral characteristics of hydrogen bonds at interactionof surface free silanol groups with organic bases at adsorption from gas phase as well as of phenol with various organicbases in solution alitative and quantitative correlations between therl~odynamic andspectroscopic characteristics of formation of hydrogen bonds in solution and on adsorption of various molecules on the surface of pure silica are similar and may be presented by the same equations. The main deviation from relationships found rved at hydrogen bonding of pyridine with hydroxyl groups. he valuesof ASiOH...Mand AvOH, as well as heats of f o r ~ a t i o lof l the hydrogen bond of surface silanol gorups ofsilica ..Mon adsorption ofseries of compoundsfromargontotriethylamine (see 9) gradually increase. The relative contribution of hydrogen energy bondiith silanol groupsto thecommon energy of interaction with the surface on adsorption for this series of compounds also increases. For argon and saturated hydrocarbons this contribution ison1 a few percent and for triethylamine it is about 50% of the common energy. interaction of saturated hydrocarbons withfree silanol groups theintegral intensity
-L"."""-
N
N
Infrared spectra of Aerosil evacuated at 800°C before and after (2,3) adsorption of various compounds at different surface coverage. (From Ref. 11
band OH increases about 1.2 times but, on interaction with triethylamine,intensity increases 25 times 1l]. Correlation between the energyof hydrogenbondformation(kJ/mol) and changes of integral intensity both for solution and adsorption can be expressed by
This equation maybe used for evaluation of the energyof hydrogen bonding using spectral data. The measurement of integral intensity in the adsorption system is a rather complicated problem. So for evaluation of integral intensity changes it is possible to use (AoH)~] -0.59
0.147(AuOH)4
Heats of compound adsorption on dihydroxylated silica surfaces are usually near their heat of condensation. So the common heatof adsorption of a compound on a hydroxylated silica surface at 0.5 can be evaluated by condensation heat and from
Thevalue of can be calculated by the shift of the stretching vibrationband of hydroxyl groups (Au0I-I from Eqs (6) and (7).
As already discussed, on adsorption of electron donor compounds and alcohols on a hydroxylated silica surface, free silanol groups are the most important and hydrogen-bonded surface silanol groups do not take part in adsorption of such compounds [24-273. From spectral data it follows that, for adsorption of water on hydroxylated silica, not only free silanol but also bonded surface silanol groups are very important 1261. For understanding of the mechanism of water adsorption and investigation of the participation of various surface functional groups of silica the thermodynamic characteristics of wateradsorption were determined.Measurement of water adsorption 1291 anda spectral investigation [30] were carried outonthe same sample of silica-Aerosil with S 163 Isotherms of adsorption at different temperatures were determined from the vacuum adsorption line with a calibrated microburette. As was discussedearlier, physical adsorbed water canbe removed by evacuation even at ambient temperature. For investigation of the adsorption of water on a fully hydroxylated silica surface the sample was evacuated at 40 and 150°C. For measurement of water adsorption on a silica surface having commonly only free silanol groups, the sample was evacuated at 450°C. Fully dehydroxylated silica surfaces cannot be achieved even by evacuation at 1000"C, so for the preparation of a silica sample with an almost dehydroxylated surface, Aerosil was evacuated at 900°C. At this temperature there is no remarkable sintering and at the same time the concentration of residual silanol groups is small. Aerosil evacuated at 900°C can be considered as silica with siloxane groups (Si-Si) only on surface.
80
Davydov
Adsorption of water on silica samples evacuated at temperatures higher than 200°C is nonreversible because of chemisorption of the water, resulting in restoration of hydroxyl (silanol) groups on a partly dehydroxylated (depending on temperature of evacuation) silica surface. The degree of rehydroxylation increases with increasing water vapor pressure over silica, time of contact of water vapor with the surface and temperature of the sample. So for measurement of physical adsorption but not chemosorption on a partly dehydroxylated surface of Aerosil it was necessary to reduce the contact time of water vapors and work in region of relatively small relative water pressure PIPo and possibly at low temperature. To fulfill these demands after measurement of one or two adsorption points the sample again was evacuated at a corresponding temperature and only after that the next adsorption points were measured. Adsorption values and vapor pressure were fixed for 1 h. Preliminarily it was found that on the same sample with a fully hydroxylated surface the adsorption equilibrium was attained in that time. So this time was adopted, but the quantity of chemisorbed water was still too small and in all following points was not increased because of the evacuation of the sample at the corresponding temperature. Owing to this, it was possible to consider the isotherms of water adsorption on Aerosil evacuated at 450 and 900°C as close to the equilibrium adsorption isotherms. Differential heats of water adsorption on silica evacuated at 450 and 900°C cannot be determined by a calorimeter, owing to the long experiment time and therefore chemosoption process to some extent. Even a small quantity of chemisorbed water will make a relatively large contribution to the common heat effect, especially at small coverage. So measurements of the isotherm of water adsorption at different temperatures on silica samples with surfaces dehydroxylated to different extents taking in to consideration all above-mentioned precautionary measures, are probably the only method of evaluation of physical adsorption energy and of the contributions of different functional groups to the common energy of water interaction with the silica surface. In Fig. 10 the isotherms of water adsorption on Aerosil evacuated at different temperatures are presented. The isotherms of water adsorption on Aerosil evacuated at 40, 150, and 450°C are reversible (desorption points on samples evacuated at 900°C are not determined). From these isotherms the isosters were determined and presented in Fig. 11. The isosters are near to lines and can be used for calculation of heats of adsorption. The isotherms of water adsorption at 20°C on Aerosil evacuated at 40 and 150°C practically coincide. This means that surface chemistry of samples evacuated at 40 and 150°C are similar and that it is possible to remove physically adsorbed water, i.e., to dehydrate the surface without removing the silanol groups at low rather than elevated temperatures. This is correct only for nonporous and mesoporous silica. In Fig. 12, isosteric heats of water adsorption are presented. Isosteric heats of water adsorption on Aerosils evacuated at 40 and 150°C are similar, which is expected because of the coincidence of the corresponding water adsorption isotherms. The isosteric heats of water adsorption on silica evacuated at 450"C, i.e., carrying only free hydroxyl groups, are much smaller than the heats of adsorption on Aerosil evacuated at 15O"C, i.e., carrying both free and hydrogen-bonded sur-
Adsorption on Silica Surfaces
81
1
I-
2 0
900 O C L?
I
2
p,Wa
FIG. 10 Isotherms of physical adsorption of water vapors at different temperatures on Aerosil preliminarily dehydrated at 40 and 150°C and partly dehydroxylated by evacuation at 450 and 900°C (open symbols are adsorption, closed are desorption). (From Ref. 29.)
face silanol groups. For Aerosil evacuated at 450°C the heats of water adsorption are near the heat of water condensation but exceed it slightly. On fully dehydroxylated samples carrying on the surface mainly siloxane bonds the heats of physical water adsorption at small coverage are smaller than the heat of water condensation and gradually come near to it with increasing surface coverage. Such changes of heats of adsorption with quantity of adsorbed water are usual for adsorption of water on adsorbents with hydrophobic surfaces. So surfaces of silica carrying mainly siloxane bonds may be considered as “hydrophobic.” Such a surface is unstable and in contact with water vapor is gradually hydrolyzed. But it is
0.5
-0.5
0.
0.75
-0.5
0.5 0.25
f0
Isosters of water vapor adsorption on silica, evacuated at different temperatures.
50
Isosteric heats of physical adsorption of water vapors on Aerosil surfaces containillg both free and hydrogen-bondedsilanolgroups(evacuation at 40 and l.SO"C), containing mainly free silanol groups (evacuation at and on highly dehydroxylatedAerosilsurfacescontainingmainlysiloxane bonds (evacuation at 900°C). (From Ref. 29.)
important that siloxanebonds existing on hydroxylated silica surfaces maybe considered as hydrophobic parts of hydroxylated silica adsorbents. Additionalinformationaboutthemechanism of wateradsorptionon silica surfaces may be obtained by simultaneous measurement of water adsorption and registration of the spectrum of silica with adsorbed water [30]. In this case it is possiblequiteaccurately to attribute values of adsorptionto spectral changes. Usually adsorption measurements are carried out on samples of relatively large massandinfrared investigations are carried out on smallthin tablets, i.e., for adsorption and spectral investigations different samples are used. Moreover, cornparison of adsorption and spectral data is complicated by the fact that the tablet of adsorbent is heated by IR spectrometer radiation and the temperatureof the tablet is higher than ambient temperature; but usually this temperature is not measured, and owing to this it is not possible to attributespectra data to adefinite quantity of adsorbed water. Investigation of the mechanismof water adsorptionin the overtone regionof the spectrum is suitable because of the possibility to observethe 5300cm"' band attributed to adsorbed water; at the same time, owing to the small intensity of overtone bands it is necessary to use a thick tablet of adsorbent mass for which it is sufficient to precisely determine the quantity of adsorbed water by a calibrated microburette. Thus to each quantity of adsorbed water can be attributed an infrared spectrum. If, to determine spectra in a monochromatic beam, in such a case strong heating of the tablet is avoided, its temperature willbe near to ambient temperature [30]. Figure 13 shows that the increase of adsorbed water results in an increase of intensity of the combination band of stretching and deformation vibrations of water molecules at 5300 cmm1 and a decrease of intensity of the overtone band of stretching free surface silanol groups at 7326 cm-'. This means that free silanol groups take part in adsorption of water. In Fig. 14 the changes in optical density of the 5300 cm-' and 7326 cm" bands with increasing adsorbed water concentration, on silica surfaces are presented. For samplesevacuated at 25 and 150"C,with theincrease of concentration of adsorbed water at small coverage the optical density of the 5300 cm" band of water increases and the optical density of the 7326 cm" band of free silanol groups decreases. Approximately the same picture is observed for Aerosil evacuated at 450°C. Afterevacuation of samples at 1050"C, on the silica surface there is a slow process of chemisorption of water, but the water adsorption is very small, so it was difficult to register the changes of optical density of the 7326 cm"' band, These results also show that both free andhydrogen-bondedsurface silanol groupstakepartinphysicaladsorption of water,Similar results presented in Fig. 14 were obtained using reflectance spectra for Aerosil samples evacuated at temperatures higher than 500°C [31]. Thus the existence of silica surface bonded silanol groups essentially increases water adsorption capacity of the surface. Free silanol groups on the silica surface take part in water adsorption both in the case where on the surface there are also bonded silanol groups and in the case where free silanol groups exist alone. The decrease of free silanol group concentration results in a decrease of adsorption
Infrared spectra of Aerosil evacuated at different temperatures before and after (2-13) adsorption of increasing amounts of water. (From Ref. 30.)
0.2
W
Correlation of adsorption and spectra data for water adsorption on Aerosil (symbols with points inside are desorption). (From Ref. 30.)
capacity relative to water and in an increase of nonreversible chemisorption of water. Monolayer capacity of water on hydroxylated silica (Aerosil) under investigation formally evaluated by the BET equation is 6.04 pmol/m2. From Fig. 14 one can see that at such coverage not all free silanol groups disappear. Probably this can be explained by the formation of clusters, as was proposed in First, portions of water adsorb on free silanol groups. Then, as vapor pressureincreases, adsorption of water occurs on free silanol groups and on already adsorbed water molecules, with formation of clusters. The heat of water adsorption on silica surfaces with only free silanol groups is not much different from heat of water condensation (Fig. 12) and probabilities of adsorption on adsorbed water molecules and on free silanol groups are Comparable. Figure 14 shows also that approximately the same numberof free silanol groups interact with adsorbed molecules but at different relative pressures when the same quantity of water adsorbs on silica surfaces carrying both free and bonded silanol groups and on silica surfaces with only free silanol groups. It means that adsorbed water molecules on free silanol groups form some more hydrogen bonds with the oxygen of bonded surface silanol groups of silica. In this case the energy of water adsorption will be larger. At higherrelative pressures adsorptionof water occurson both silanol groups and adsorbed water. Thus the existence of silica surface bonded silanol groups probably increases energy of interaction of water with free silanol groups. But more important is the existence of free silanol groups, although the energy of bonding water molecules with them is not so large. if, to remove free silanol groups from silica surface by
reaction with trimethylchlorosilane, the surface bonded silanol groups remain on the surface, then they are accessible for adsorption of water. Nevertheless heats of water adsorption onmodified silica becomemuch smallerthan on the hydroxylated silica surface [32j. Low heats of water adsorption cannotbe explained by screening of bonded surface silanol groups by grafted trimethylsilyl groups since deuterium exchange of bonded surface silanol groups is easily carried out [7,8] and therefore residual bonded silanol groups are accessible for interaction with water. Neverthelessthesurface of theadsorbent becomes hydrophobic similar to the case of removing free and bonded surface silanol groups by heating of silica at high temperature (Fig. 12) when strained siloxane Si bonds are formed. These siloxane bonds are hydrophobic from the point of view of physical adsorption of water, but these bonds can be broken gradually by contact with water molecules.This also means thatthe energyof interaction of water molecules with bonded silanol groups only is not very high 1321. Thus free silanol groups are the most important species of adsorption of water on silica. The peculiarity of adsorption of water on silica in comparisonwith adsorption of othercompounds is probablyconnectedwiththe possibility to form hydrogen bonds not only with surface silanol groups of silica but also with each other. Experimental data show that alcohols interact with free silanol groups in the same way as electron donor molecules [26,27].
Correlation between energetic and spectral characteristics of theformation of hydrogen bonds in solutions is the same as for adsorption systemsand is probably universal, which makes it possible to evaluate energetic characteristics of adsorption and the contributions of hydrogen bond energy to the common energy of adsorption by using only spectral data. Energy of hydrogen bonds of surface and intraglobular silanol groups of silica can possibly also be evaluated by use of these correlations from spectral data. In Table 1 the energyof interaction between silanol groups on the surface and in the volume of globules of silica obtained using integral in~ensity are presented. From this table one cansee that surface bondedsilanol groups have greaterintegral intensity, strongerhydrogenbonds,agreater shift of vibrationfrequency and smaller distance between silanol groups in comparisol~with intraglobular silanol groups of silica. So at heating, surface silanol groups are removedfirst (temperatL~re from 150-200 to 400450°C). Intraglobular silanol groups also are partly removed from silica at thesetemepraturesbecause of the existing distancedistribution between the silanol groups, but at 400450°C intraglobular silanol groups still exist in rather great quantity inside silica (Fig. Surface bonded silanol groups are removed almost completely under these conditions. From data of Ref. 33 and spectral data it is possible to evaluate the average distance between silanol groups which is presented in Table The distancebetween free silanol groups has to be larger than 0.310 mm.
SpectralCharacteristicsandEnergy Silanol Croups Silica
Surface free Surface bonded Intraglobular
3750 3550 3650
200
of HydrogenBonds of Interacting
9.8 43.7 0.283 35.5 0.293
0.310
11.7 9.2
vSioH frequency of maximum band of silanol groups; AvsioH shift frequency; integral intensity of band; ~ j s i o ~ . . . heat ~ of hydrogen bond formation; l? distance between oxygen OH. .O. Ref. 12.
Surface silanol groups of silica can be involved in chemical reactions with various organic and inorganic compounds which make it possible to graft to the silica surface different functionalgroups and by this method to changeadsorption properties of surfaces of silica adsorbents. In monographs and reviews many reactions are presented, by means of which on hydroxylated silica surfaces it is possible to create relativelyhigh concentrations ofnew functional groups. The most promising chemical modification reactions of silica surfaces are those with chlorosilanes, silanols, disilazanes, and esters of silicic acid. Also other types of chemical reactions are used for preparation of adsorbents for immobilization of enzymes [37]. The reaction of chlorosilanes with surface silanol groups of silica occurs at a highrate at hightemperatures Butmore suitably, this reactioncan be achieved in organic solvents by using amines as donor electrons. The influence of electron donors on the rate of reaction of modification silanols with surface silanol groups of silica wasinvestigated in detail It was shown that even a donor such as water accelerates this reaction. But the presenceof water at modification of silica by di- and trichlorosilanes may result in polycondensation of silanes. Usually, as a donor of electrons the amines, e.g., pyridine or triethylimine [43-45] are used. The mechanism of reaction of chlorosilanes was investigated by infrared spectroscopy (e.g., Refs and S), by means of which it was possible to determine not only the appearanceof grafted functional groups on adsorbent surface but tofind which silanol groups take partin ~odificationreactions. In these reactions the most important are free surface silanol groups. The bonded surface silanol groups can only partly interact with dichlorosilanes. So it is difficult to obtain a concentration grafted modifying groups greaterthan that of free silanol groups. If branched or big volume groups are grafted, then the concentration may onlybe smaller. In the case where a polycondensation process is used in chemical modification by di- or trichlorosilanes, theconcentration of graftedmodifyinggroupscan be more thantheconcentration of free silanol groups of hydroxylated silica. Detailed
investigations of modification reactions carried out later show that the concentration of grafted groups was about 4 ,urnol/m2 [34]. Chemical modification reactions may be controlled by the presenceof carbon on theadsorbent [46]. Infraredspectroscopycan beused notonlyfor qualitative composition of grafted groups but also for quantitative evaluationof carbon content on the adsorbent surface. In Ref. 43, for chemical modification of silica the following chlorosilanes were used: diphenyldichlorosilane, methylphenyldichlorosilalles, methyl-~-phenyl-ethyldichlorosilane, and chlorosilaneswithunsaturated andsaturatedhydrocarbon groups--methylvinyldichlorosilalle, dimethyldichlorosilane, and octadecyltrichlorosilane. Chemical modification of silica was carried out on silica gels: LiChrosorb SI 60, LiChrosorb SI 100, LiChrospher SI 100, LiChrospherSI 500, and LiChrospher SI 1000 (Merk), and Silacorb 600 (Lahema). The degree of coverage by grafted modifying groups on silica surfaces can be determined by the carbon content of the modified adsorbent [46]. For LiChrosorb SI 100 modified by different chlorosilanes the carbon content was determined by combustion in a rnicrocalorimeter. In Table 2 the results on determination of modification degree of silica surface are presented. Table2 shows that degree of modification of adsorbent is rather high and probably is near to complete coverage by corresponding functional groups. In accordance with the area occupiedby grafted functional groups thelargest content of these groups is obtained with modification by dimethyldichlorosilane and the smallest one with modification by diphenyldichlorosilane. The average area of benzene in a dense monolayer on silica is about 49 A2 [47]. The average area per grafted Si(C6H5)2 group inmodified samples is about 8 1 A2, i.e., is near to the van der Waals area of two benzene molecules in a dense monolayer. If one takes into consideration that phenyl groups in the modifying layer are arranged not parallel to the surface but at angles to each other, it is possible to consider that all surfaces of the adsorbent are coyered by phenyl groups. Table 2 shows that the area per Si(CH& group is 39 A2. This means that the
Carbon Content in Silica Gel LiChrosorb SI 100 ( S 285 m2/g) Modified by DifferentDichlorosilanes (C), Average Concentration of Modifying Groups per Mass of Adsorbent and PerUnit of Surface (a), well Area of Grafted Modifying Groups and Number of Carbon Atoms in Modifying Groups
Si(C6HS)2 12 si(cH3)(cH2)2(c6H5) 9 si(cH3)(c6H5) 7 Si(CH3)CH CH2 3 Si(CH3)2 2 Ref.
7.69 8.32 6.47 3.51 2.70
0.527 0.770 0.770 56 0.975 45 1.125
2.04 3.04 2.96 3.66 4.2 1
81
39
surface of thesample modifiedby dimethyldichlorosilane is almostcompletely covered byo methylgroups, since, on average,one free silanol groupoccupies about 33 A2 onthehydroxylated silica surface(evacuated at 200°C)[7]. It is possible to consider that practically all free silanol groups took part in the modification reaction with the surface of such samples [S]. Bonded surface silanol groups remaining on the surface after modification are under the modifyinglayer and probably areaccessible only to small molecules such as water. It is possible that a very small number of free silanol groups may remain on the surface as a defect of coverage and may be detected by a c~romatographic separation process. Samples modified by diphenyldichlorosilanes and methyl-~-phenylethyldichlorosilane have the largest concentration of carbon atoms on the surface (Table 2). The area of the Si(C6H5)2 grafted groupis only about two times larger than the Si(CH3)2 group, but the number of carbon atoms of the first is six times larger than the second. So it is possible to propose that the adsorption potential of silica modifiedby diphenyldichlorosilane willbe higher in comparison with a sample modifiedby dimethyldichlorosilane. The comparison of area per grafted group, the number of carbon atomsin each and their structure makes it possible to predict that the adsorption potential of silica modified by methyl-~-phenylethyldichlorosilane, diphenyldichlorosilanes and will be similar to or higher than that of samples modified by dimethyldichlorosilane and carrying on their surfaces only methyl groups. very suitable method of qualitative and quantitative control of the modification reaction is infrared spectroscopy, making it possibleto observe the graftingof modifying groups and to evaluate their surface concentration (Fig. 15). To decrease scattering by the pressed silica gel plate, the spectra of samples are determined in carbon tetrachloride. In carbontetrachloride the band of free silanol groups at 3750 cm-' of untreated silica shifts by 58 cm to a lower frequency [l l] and in the spectrum there is a broad band at 3700-3000 cm" consisting of overlapping bands of free silanol groups perturbed byCC14 and of surface bonded silanol groups.From Fig. 15 onecan see that after chemicalmodifications by chlorosilanes on the surface ofsilicagel the bonded silanol groups still remain and the bands of corresponding groups appear. To make a quantitative analysis of graftedfunctionalgroupsfrominfrared spectra only is quite difficult, since it is necessary to know the extinctioncoefficient ut reproducibility of modification reactions or degree of coverage after modification without exact quantitativeanalysis of content grafted functional groups on surface is quite simple. In Fig. 16 the infrared spectraof silica with different specific surface areas after chemical modificationby diphenyldiclllorosilane are presented. The degreeof coverage of the surface by phenyl groups after modification canbe evaluated from the band at 3083 cm-'. From the spectra presented in Fig. 16 it is possible to evaluate the productlira is the extinctioncoefficient, and is the concentrationof grafted groups to the adsorbent surface) and to compare it for different samples for evaluation of the reproducibility of the modification reactionand for determination of the degree of surface coverage. Calculations showthat Ka for samples withsimilar
3200 cm”
Infrared spectra of untreated silica gel LiChrosorb SI 100-1 and modified by various dichlorosilanes (2-6) (samples beforehand were evacuated at 200°C to Torr and placed in CC14), (2) diphenyldichlorosilane, (3) methyl~henyldichlorosilane, (4) dimethyldichlorosilane, methylvinyldic~lorosilane,and (6) methyl-@phenylethyldichlorosilane.(From Ref. 43.)
specific surface areaand particle diameter aswell identical conditions of reaction are similar, although Ka decreases a little with increase of specific surface area on untreated silica gel. It is probably connected with steric difficulties at ~ o d i ~ c a t i o n of part of narrow pores. In calculating Ka it isnecessary to take into consideration that the specific surface areaof modifiedsamples decreases because of increasing of adsorbent, owing to the attachment of modifying groups at practically the same area of sample. This decrease will be larger for adsorbents with higher specific surface area at the same degree of modification. If the K value of grafted groups is known, then it is possible to evaluate the concentration of modifying groups on the silica surface by infrared spectra. The concentrationof grafted diphenylsilyl groups canbe calculated from spectra because the value of a for LiChrosorb SI 100 was determined earlier from the content of carbon on the modified surface and the coefficient of extinction K was determined, which is the same for all samples.
cm"
Infrared spectra of silica gels modified bydiphenyldichlorosilanes (samples beforehand were evacuated at 200°C to Torr and placed in CC14): (I) LiChrosorb SI 60(500 m2/g), LiChrosorb SI 300 (286 m2/g), LiChrospher SI 500 (50 m2/g), and (4) LiChrospher SI 1000 (20 m2/g). (From Ref. 44.)
In Table 3 the concentrations of diphenylsilyl groups on surfaces of different silica samples, takinginto consideration changesof specific surface areaof modified adsorbentsarepresented.Thedatashowthatconcentrations of diphenylsilyl groups on the surface for all adsorbents are nearly the same and are near to full coverage. tenfold change in specific surface area has a relatively small influence on concentrationof grafted diphenylsilyl groups per square meter of silica samples. One technique in chemical modification of silica is covering of the surface of silica by a polymer layer both by adsorption of the polymer from solution and by p o l y ~ e r i ~ a t i oofn monomers on the surface (e.g., Ref. 38). It is possible to one or more ends of polymeric chains of fragments on the silica surface. In Ref. 48 the
~oncexltrationof Crafted ~ ~ ~ h e n y lCroups s ~ l y ~ on Samples with SpecificSurfaceArea and DifferentDiameter of Particles dp Sample
Silasorb 600 1.6 LiChrosorb SI 60417 1.7 L~chrosorbSI 60 417 LiChrosorb SI 100 .9 LiChrosorb SI l 100 49 LiChrospher SI 500
45
5 5 5 265
256
7 10
process of copolymerization of N-vinylpyrrolidone on silica surfaces was investigated by infrared spectroscopy. The preparation of silica with a grafted copolymerof ~-vinylpyrrolidone chains occurs in two stages: first, grafting to the silica surface methylvinylsilyl groups by reaction of vinyltriethosysilane or methylvinyldichlorosilane with silanol groups, and then copolymerization of attached methylvinylsilyl groups with N-vinylpyrrolidone. Figure 17 shows spectra of various silica gels after reaction with =CH, in the presence of (C2H&N and after reaction with e in the presence of a catalyst. After the silanization reaction the bands of -"CH3 and -CH=CH2 appear in the spectra. Intensities of the bands, taking into consideration the thicknessof plates are in accordance with thespecific surface areaof adsorbents. After the polymerization reaction bands of viny practically disappear from the spectra and there are intense bands of groups of hydrocarbon chains and pyrrolidonerings. The absence in spe at 3020 and 3060 cm-l may indicate that the reaction of grafted vinylsilyl groups in copolymerization is complete. The appearance on the silica surface of pyrrolidone rings can be detected from the bandat 3350 cm-' of overtone vibrationof C ples with large specific surface area s 300 m2/g the intensity of groups and bondedsilanol groups so large that in the region samples became nontransparent. 3800
3000
em"
l '
Infrared spectra of silicagels after reaction with methylvinyldichlorosilanes in the presence of Et3N and following reaction of polymerization with Nvinylpyrrolidon (2) (samples were evacuated beforehand at 200°C to lo-' Torr and placed in CC14).
One of the forms of modification of the silica surface is the covering of this surface by carbon layers (49-54). If it would be possible to deposit on the surfaces of silica pores the carbon layers with formation of graphite planes, then such an adsorbent would be ideal from the point of view of chromatography owing to uniformity of surface, hydrolytic resistance, and possibility to regulatepore size adsorbents. ~nfortunately,upto the present, such anadsorbenthasnot been prepared. Silica adsorbents with carbonlayers have properties similar to those of hydrophobic chemically modified silica with high adsorption potential, but the efficiency of columns with such adsorbents usually is not too high. In some papers [55-5'73 it was demonstrated that silica adsorbents with carbon layers can be prepared by pyrolysis of CH4 and CC14 mixtures. The carbon layer deposition reaction occursat relatively low temperature, so the porous structureof silica does not change, while the methods of deposition of pyrocarbon on silica surfaces at 850°C and higher may result in noticeable structural changes. Infrared spectroscopy in this case is a suitable method for the study of changes of the surface chemistry of silica. For spectral investigation, Aerosil with l65 m2/g was usedfrom which transparent plates wareprepared by pressing. The Aerosil plate, in a holder, was placed in a reactor where the deposition of a carbon layer on the surface of the Aerosil was carried out under different conditions and the infrared spectraof this plate then recorded. Deposition of the carbon layer was carried out on a pure surface and a surface with grafted trimethylsilyl groups [58]. The reaction of trimethylchlorosilane was realized in flow CH4 at 400-420°C. In Fig. infrared spectra of untreated Aerosil and(2-6) after deposition of a carbon layer in a flowing CC14 and CH4 mixture at 400°C are presented. After heating of the Aerosil in the mixture of CC14 and CH4 for1 h there are no changes in the sample spectrum but the transparency decreases with time owing to formation of the carbon layer. To accelerate the processof deposition of the carbonlayer in these conditions, it is possible to modify the silica surface by reaction with tri~ethylchlorosilane from the gas phase.At 400°C this reaction occurs with a high rate. In Fig. 18b the spectra of Aerosil (1) before and (2) after reaction of silica surface with trimethylchlorosilane at 400°C in flow CH4 arepresented. In h the reaction of free silanol groups withtrimethylchlorosilane finishes and in spectrum 2 bands of -CH3 groups appear and band of free silanol groups at 3750 cm" disappears. After passing the CC14 and CH4 mixture across the surface of the modified samplefor 1 h the plate transparency decreases. Intensity of bands of -CH3 groups considerably decreases. This means that grafted trimethylsilyl groups take part in the process of formation of the carbon layer. In 4 h the Aerosil plate becomes almost nontransparent (6). Thus it is possible to accelerate the formation of carbon layers on silica surfaces by apreliminary silanization reaction. The acceleration of the formation rate of the carbon layer from the CC14 and CH4 mixture on the modifiedsilica surface is probably connected with formation of higherconcentrations of hydrocarbongroupsnearthesurface in comparison with the case when unmodified silica is placed in CH4 at atmospheric pressure.
Infrared spectra of Aerosil: (a) (1) heated in CH4 at 400"C, h; after passing a mixture of CH4 and CC&at 400"C, 1 h; the same, h; (4) the same, h; the same, 4 h; the same, 5 h; (1) heated in CH4 at 4OO0C, h; after reaction with(CH3)3Sic1 at 400"C, h; after passing mixture CH4 and CC14 at 400"C, 1 h; (4) the same, h; (5) the same, 3 h; the same, 4 h. (From Ref. 58.)
At the adsorption of CH4 on the silica surface is much smaller than the concentration of grafted methyl groups. From the spectra in Fig. 18a, b one cansee that at formationof the carbon layer on the silica surface the structures with hydrocarbon groups do not form, or their concentration is too small. Except for the concentration of hydrocarbon groups near surface, the rate of deposition of the carbon layer obviously depends on the flow rate of the gas mixture and temperature of the sample surface. Noticeable commencement of the carbon layer deposition reaction from the CC14 and CH4 mixture probably occurs at 400°C and the rate of this reaction quickly increases at higher temperatures. The peculiarity of this process is the increase of specific surface area of adsorbent after nucleation of the carbon phase on the silica surface. This means that after deposition of carbon in such conditions there are no dense uniform graphite carbonlayers on the silica surface since during deposition of the graphite layers the specific surface area of adsorbent should remainpractically unchanged. This result is supported by the C constant of the BET equation for nitrogen adsorption on untreatedsilica and silica with deposited carbon.For initial silica samples, C is about 160, which is usual for silica, for silica treated by trimethylchlorosilane at 400°C in flow CH4 is about 20, for silica treated by CC14 and CH4mixture in an hour C about 60 and with deposited different quantity of carbon in different time C equals several hundred, which is smaller than the value of about 1000 for graphitized carbon black During pyrolysis CC14 and CH4 mixture the particles of carbon are probablydeposited between silica particles as a new carbon phase that results in an increase of specific surface area of prepared adsorbent.
To avoid formation of this new carbon phase between silica particles it is probably necessary to remove hydrocarbon from gas phase, i.e., to replace CH4 by CO2 as the carrier gas. In this case the pyrolysis of CC14 at 400°C on silanized silica surfaces results in the formation of only carbon film on silica surface [60]. The specific surface area of silanized silica gel changes very little and the C constant of the BET equation for nitrogen adsorptionincreases from about 50 for untreated silanized silica gel (LiChrosorb SI-60) to 80-90 for samples treated for different times at 400°C. It means that decomposition of CC14 occurs on the surface of adsorbent and the forming carbon layer is not porous, but at the same time it is not a graphite layer, since C for this adsorbent is much smallerthan forgraphitized carbon black lOOOj. Reposition of carbon layers on hydroxylated silica surfaces can also be realized by treatment of silicaat 400°C with a vapor mixture of CC14 and chlorosilanes [e.g., C12Si(CH3)2] inCO2 as thecarrier gas. In this case, at first the silanization reaction occurs and then formation of the carbon layer. Comparison of gas chromatographic data on retention, heats of adsorption of different class compounds aswell the contributionsof various functional groupsof molecules to these characteristics shows that the adsorption potentialof silica with a carbon layer higher than for untreated silica but smaller than carbon adsorbents such as Carbopack or graphitized carbon black. At the same time the influenceof residual polar (silanolj groups ofsilica surface on retention of polar compounds is remarkable [61],
The discovery of a new carbon modification-fullerenes [62] and the development of a method for its preparation on macroscopic scale E631 makes it possible to use carbon clusters (molecules) for modification of silica surfaces. By bonding fullerene molecules to the silica surface it possible to prepare the carbon-containing adsorbents with a smaller adsorption potential in comparison with carbon adsorbents, which has some practical uses. InRef. 64,silicamodified withbonded fullerene c60 by reaction of surface silanol groups with chlorosilane derivatives of fullerene is described. The most simple derivatization reactionof fullerenes is that with primary amines [65]. This reaction was used for immobilization of fullerene to silica surfaces [66]. The first step of immobilization of fullerene is modification of silica by y-arninopropyltriethoxysilane and then reaction of fullerene with grafted y-arninopropylsilyl groups. Of course for immobilization of fullerenes on silica it is possible to use aminosilicas, these being commercial products. Silicamodified by fullerenes has some peculiarity from the point ofviewof changes of the specific surface area of the prepared adsorbent. Usually, chemical modification of silica results in a decreaseof specific surface area of adsorbents if a porous surface layer is not formed. The bonding ofrelatively large “spherical” fullerene c60 molecules forms additional surfaces owing to these molecules that should result in an increase of specific surface area of silica adsorbents [66]. Silica adsorbents with differing content of immobilized fullerene were prepared by changing of solvent composition and temperature.
In Fig. 19a the results of measurements of specific surface area of adsorbents with different amounts of bonded fullerene are shown. After reaction of the silica with ~-al~inopropyltrietho~ysilane, the specific surface area of adsorbent becomes smaller in comparison with untreated silica gel. Usually at chemical modification andafterimmobilization of fullerene the specific surfacearea of adsorbent increases; this increase is approximately proportional to the contentof immobilized fullerene. So it is possible to evaluate the specific surface area of i~mobilizedfullerene. The specific surface area of fullerene molecules bonded to silica calculated from the correlationbetween fullerene surface and contentof immobilized fullerene is about 725 m2/gfromdataonnitrogenadsorptionat 77 K (Fig. 19b). The geometrical surface and specific surface area of isolated fullerne molecules can be calculated by using the van der Waals diameterof the molecule, 1.0 nm From geometric dimensions of fullerene molecules the specific surface area should be 2620 m2/g. The experimental value is 3.6 times smaller. This may be owing to the use for determination of surface area as adsorbate nitrogen molecules with 0.162 nm2 in a dense monolayer. In this case the meanlinear dimension of the adsorbed nitrogen molecule is about 0.4 nm, which differs not too much from the diameter of fullerene molecules. Another reason is probably connected with the impossibility of nitrogen molecules to interact with all surfaces of spacer-bonded fullerene molecules owing to contact of the bonded fullerene molecules with each other or with the surface of the silica adsorbent. If one proposes the uniform distribution of arninopropyl groups with concentration 1.9 pmol/m2 for one of our samples (usual concentration of amino groups of aminosilica) then the average distance between amino groupswill be about 0.834 nm. This meansthat the arrangementof can be only in the manner presented in Fig. 20 and concentration of bonded fullerene molecules is 0.53 pmol/m2, i.e., only about 28% of amino groups can be involved in reaction of modi~cationby full-
M n
0-
(a) Changes ofspecific surface area ofsilicagel LiChrosorb SI 100 before and (2) after chemical modification by ~-aminopropyltriethoxysilane,and (3) after il~l~obilization of various amounts of correlation between the increasing of surface area of silica geland amountof immobilized fullerene,(From Ref. 66.)
Model of distribution of immobilized fullerene moleculeson the surfaceof gel.
erene CGO.Experimentally determined concentration of bonded is 0.54 pmol/ m2. From Fig. 20 one can see that only small molecules such asN2, H20, etc. can penetrate between the attached fullerene molecules at the highest concentration of fullerene on the silica surface. One important problem is the determination of the surface concentration of immobilized fullerene on silica. As it has turned out, the adsorption of dyes from water solution is the most simple method of determination of this concentration. The adsorption properties of silica with bonded fullerene are determined by the concentration of immobilized fullerene. The greater the concentration of immobilized fullerene, the larger the specific surface area of adsorbent the higher adsorption of dye (Fig. 21) but the adsorptionof Rhodamine B well as Rhodamine relative to immobilized fullerene concentrationfor all adsorbents is practically common and the limiting adsorption of dyes on silica with bonded C60 isvery near toone (Fig. 22). This meansthat one molecule of dyeadsorbs on onemolecule of bonded fullerene and the isotherm of dye adsorption can be used for determination of the concentration of inmobilized fullerene on silica,
Changing the adsorption properties of silica surface can be realized not only by chemical modification withgrafting some groups to the surface, but by adsorption modification when bifunctional molecules form strong adsorption bonds with functional groups of the silica surface. As result the strong adsorption modifying layer is formed on the silica surface [68-711. In ion-pair and ligand-exchange chromatography the pretreatment of the column is possible to consider as adsorption l~odifi~ation of adsorbent surface170,711. Although the mechanismof separation in
80
L
0
Adsorption isotherms of Rhodamine B from water solution on silica gels: KSK-2 and (9) LiClxosorb Si withvarious (1,2) LiChros~herSI concentrations of immobilized fullerene: (2) (6) (7) 121, and (9) 232 p,mol/g. (From Ref. 66.)
8 c12
Relative adsorption of Rhodamines B and 6 1s withimmobilizedfullerene. (1) Rhodamine (From Ref. 66.)
from water solutions on and(2)Rhodamine 6C.
ion-pair chromatographyis not completely clear, the role of adsorption modifiersis probablyconnectedwithstrongadsorption ofpositively or negatively charged groups with hydrocarbon chains from water solution on the hydrophobic modified silica surface, which takes part in separation of acids, salts, and bases. In the caseof ligand-exchange chromatography, example, ~-alkylderivatives of a-amino acids adsorb onhydrophobized surfacesof silicaowing to interactionof the hydrophobic partof the molecule with the hydrophobiclayer of adsorbent, and then form ion complexes(usually Cu2+);such an adsorbent is capable of separating racemic mixtures of amino acids on optical isomers completely [71]. For separation of carbohydrates, at present the most often used silica gels are those with bonded ~-aminopropylsilyl groups[72]. On chemically modified adsorbents with grafted -NH2 groups the separation of carbohydrates occurs as a result of differences in energyof interaction of their moleculeswith electrondonor amino groups, But adsorption modifiers can be used also to form on the silica surface the layer of amino groups, as adsorption modifiers have tobe molecules which, at one end molecules can be retained strongly on the silica surface owing to relatively strong adsorption bond and at the other end these molecules have to be amino groups turned tosolution. was mentioned, amines form strong hydrogen bonds with surface silanol groups of silica. So convenient molecules for formation on silica surfaces of strong electron-donor groups turned to solution are diamines. In Fig. 23 the models of a silica surface with grafted-NH2 groups by chemical modification and with NH and "H2 groups of adsorbed molecules from solution owingto stronghydrogen bonds of diamines withsilanol groups of surface are presented. Ethylenediamine and piperazine are strong bases. Their molecules are attached by hydrogen bonds of one amino group to SiOH and other amino groups can form hydrogen bonds with molecules having electron-acceptor groups. Silanol groups are moreacidic than hydroxyl groupsof carbohydrates for example. So diamine molecules form stronger bonds with the silica surface than carbohydrates in solution, whichmakes it possible to separate carbohydrates on silica surfaces by an adsorption modification [68,69]. The concentrationof diamine in solution necessary for the formationof a dense monolayer on the silica surface is determined by the equilibrium adsorption con-
Models of ~ o d i f y i nlayer ~ of silica surface after chemical modification ~-a~inopropyltriethoxysilane (a), and after adsorption l~odification piperazine and et~ylenediamine(c). (From Ref. 68.)
stant in solution. The larger the adsorption constant, the smaller the concentration of diamine in solution needed. Of two diamines used, ethylenediamine and piperazine, themore suitable asanadsorptionmodifier piperazine being a solid compoundmoderatelysolubleinwater. Incontrastwithethylenediamine,the moleculeof piperazine isrelativelyrigid and does not change conformation on adsorption. So one of two amino groups turn to solution.
Silica is an important material which is widely usedin industry, technology,science, protection of the environment, etc. We mention a few applications of silica in more detail with regard to silica samples inscience and chromatography. One example of pyrogenic silica is Aerosil (or Cabosil), which is used as a model sample for investigation of silica surface chemistryby infrared spectroscopy, since from this silica it is very easy to prepare transparent plates in the infrared region of the spectrum. Samples of this silica have been used from the earliest studies up to thepresent The adsorption properties of pyrogenic silica in the hydroxylated state are similar to properties of other samplesof hydroxylated silica so Aerosil has turnedout tobe very useful for investigation of the mechanism of adsorption on silica, chemical modification of silica, transformation of silica under heating, etc. For the same reason Aerosil (Cabosil) was used as supports of catalyst (metal) for investigation of the mechanism of catalytic reaction by infrared spectroscopy (e.g., Refs 73-75). As an example, in Figs 24 and 25 the spectra of Cabosil with deposited platinum before and after adsorption of hydrogen and benzene are presented Spectral investigation shows that under 400 Torr of hydrogen, in the
5
h,
Infrared spectra of Cabosil with deposited platinum: (1) after adsorption of hydrogen (a) and deuterium (b) at -400 Torr at ambient temperature, (2) after evacuation of gas phaseat ambient temperatureand (3) at -400 Torr of hydrogen or deuterium at -300°C. (From Ref. 76.)
Infrared spectra of Cabosil with deposited platinurn: (1) after evacuation, (2) after adding benzene vapor(-40 Torr), after evacuationof benzene vapor, (4) after adding hydrogen(“400 Torr), after evacuationof hydrogen, after adding hydrogen, (7) after evacuation of gas phase, (8) after adding hydrogen, and(9) after evacuation of gas phase. operations atambient temperature. (From Ref. 76.)
spectrum of Cabosil-supported platinum, bands, at 2128 cm-’ or 1527 cm-l for deuterium appear. After evacuationof the sampleat room temperature these bands disappear. These bands are attributed to bands of hydrogen and deuterium bonded with platinum, since, at ambient temperature, adsorptionof these gases on silica is negligible. At 300°C the bends at 2128 and 1527 cm“ were practically unobservable even at 400 Torr of hydrogen or deuterium respectively (Fig. 24). Onadsorption of aromatichydrocarbons on silica-supportedplatinum it is possible to observe intermediate compounds able easily to accept and to return hydrogen. Figure 25 shows the spectrum (1) silica-supported platinum, (2)
sample with adsorbed benzeneat room temperature. In spectrum 2 there are >CH bands of aromatic rings. After evacuation of benzene at room temperature, physically adsorbed benzeneis removed and in the spectrum only a broad band at 3040 cm" of very small intensity is observed (3). After adding hydrogen 400 Torr), in the spectrunn the intense bands of -CH2 at 2935 and 2859 cm" appear (4). After evacuation of hydrogen at room temperature these bands practically disappear (5). But addition of a new portion of hydrogen 400 Torr) results in the appearance in the spectrum of these bands with almost the same intensity (6). At evacuation these disappear again (7). Repeating these cycles results in the same pictures, (8) and (9). This means that on adsorption of benzene on the platinum surface a Chemisorption complex is formed which is able to accept and to lose hydrogen very easily [73-751. Similar pictures are observed chemisorption of toluene, p-xylene, and mesitelene on silica-supported platinurn 1761. odified silica is widely used as an adsorbent forliquid chromatography. A lot of modifying groups canbe attached to silica surfaces for separation any organic compounds from simple to complicated biologically active substances and polymer molecules. Many separations can be made on silica with bonded alkyl groups and with octadecylsilyl groups in particular (ODS silica gel). Alkyl chains attached to the surface, owing to conformational mobility, may change the thickness of the modifying layer depending on eluentcomposition.Attachment of diphenylsilyl groups to silica surfaces makes it possibleto endow the adsorbent with hydrophobic properties of the surface the same as ODs silicagel, and at the same time achieve a thickness of modified layer independent of eluent composition. Silica with grafted diphenylsilyl groups was used for separationof cardiac glycosides and steroid hormones and forinvestigation of mechanism of their adsorption and separation [45, 69,77,78]. In Figs and 27 the separationsof some cardiacglycosides, which are the most important and effective biologically active compounds for treatment of abnormal circulation of the blood due to high blood pressure, atherosclerosis, and infarction
1.
Separation of (l) convallatoxin and (2) desglucoheiroto~inon silicagel with bonded diphenylsilyl groups from 3:7 ethanol-water used as the eluent (temperature: 40°C). (From Ref. 78.)
of the miocardia, are presented.In reversed-phase liquid Chromatography the main intermolecular interactions determining retention are the van der Waals interaction of molecules with hydrophobic groups attached to the silica surface and the strong intermolecular interactions of the eluent molecules with each other. In the case of chromatography of cardiac glycosides, the molecules of which contain aglycone and glycone (sugar part), the intermolecular interactions are rather complicated. First of all, it is possible to note the effect of the geometry of molecules on retention. Figure 26 shows the separation of desglucoheirotoxin and convallatoxin [78]. These molecules are identical from the pointof view of their general formulae but the same aglycone, strophantidin, is connected with a-l-rhamnose in convallatoxin and p-D-gulomethylose in desglucoheirotoxin. Such a difference results in various configurations of the whole molecules. a result the more flat desglucoheirotoxin moleculeis retained more strongly than the convallatoxin molecules, and they can be separated on silica with bonded diphenylsilyl groups. evaluate the role of glycone and aglycone in retention of cardiac glycosides on silica with bonded diphenylsilyl groups some artificial mixtures were prepared chrol~atograms,which are presented in Fig. 27. The glycoside mixtures were chosen in such a manner that the glyconeswere similar in size in each compound group. Thisfigure illustrates that the aglycone structure, the number of hydrophilic and hydrophobic groups and the position of these groups in the aglycones have a great influence on the retention of cardiac glycosides. For example, in Fig. 27a all compounds may be subdivided into three types of glycosides: glycoside with the most hydrophilic oubagenin-aglycone, glycosides with the strophantidin aglycone and glycoside with the oleandrigenin aglycone. The effect of properties of aglycone on retention of glycosides is demonstrated most clearly in the separation of lanatosides and C having the same glycone (Fig. 27d). Themosthydrophobicaglyconein this mixture is digitoxigenin. Therefore lanatoside has the longest retentiontime. Introduction of one hydroxyl group in the CI6position decreasesby more than a factorof two the retention time of lanatoside B, while introduction of hydroxyl groupsto position C12decreases the retention time of lanatoside C by a factor of five in comparison to lanatoside Figure 27d demonstrates also that glycosides with the same aglyconeare separated according to the hydrophilic and hydrophobic properties of the glycone. Separations of some estrogens onsilica gelwith bonded diphenylsilyl groups are presented in Fig. 28 [45,69]. The order of elution from the columnis determined by hydrophilic and hydrophobic properties of these steroid hormones. ~ydroxylatedsilica gels also can be used for separation of cardiac glycosides in thin-layer chromatography (TLC) using benzene-ethanol eluent [79]. The mechanismof separation in this case will be different. The main interaction is that of hydroxyl groups of cardiac glycosides with surface silanol groups ofsilica and interaction of hydrocarbon groups with eluent molecules. In Table4, comparison of the contribution of different functional groups of cardiac glycosides to adsorption on silica with bonded di~henylsilyl groups and adsorption on hydroxylated silica are presented. The data of Table 4 showthat in reversed-phase liquid chromatography, i.e., on separation of cardiac glycosides on hydrophobized silica the only hydrocarbon
Ho
OH
(b)
CHs
4
I
1
C
0'1 k
20
I0
f-
,
30 Y,minoms
I
J
30
7,min
FIG. 27 Separation of cardiac glycosides mixtures on silica gel with bonded diphenylsilyl groups. Eluent: ethanol-water in the following proportions: (a) 7:13, (b) 3:7, (c) and (d) 2:3. Temperature: (a) and (d) 50°C, (b) 40"C, (c) 60°C. Peaks: (a) (1) G-strophanthin, (2) convallatoxin, (3) desglucoheirotoxin, (4) erysimin, ( 5 ) cymarin, (6) oleandrin; (b) (1) corelborin-n, (2) olitoriside, (3) K-strophanton-B; (c) (1) K-strophanthoside, (2) digoxin, (3) digitoxin, (4) acetyldigitoxin; (d) (1) desacetyllanatoside C, (2) lanatoside C, (3) lanatoside B, (4) lanatoside A. (From Ref. 78.)
Separation of estrogens hormones on silica gel with bonded diphenylsilyl Croups at 50°C. Eluent: ethanol-water (a) 7:13, (b) Peaks: (a) (1) estriol, (2) estradiol, (3) ethynylestradiol,and (4) estron;(b) (1) estradiol, (2) mestranol, (3) estradiol valerianate, (4) estradiol benzoate, (5) estradiol dipropionate. (From Ref. 69.)
Contributions of Various Groups of Cardiac Glycosides to Their Retention on Silica from Benzene-Ethanol Mixture (3:1) at Ambient Temperature 1nk' (on TLC data) andonSilicawithBonded ~iphenylsilylGroups from Ethanol-Water Mixture (35:65) at 50°C Ink' (on HPLC data)
-0.096 0.052 0.115 0.218 0.593 0.309 0.285 0.762 0.600 0.612 0.343 0.403
0.193 -0.136 -0.659 -0.278 -0.49 1 -1.533 -0.809
1
-0.720
Ref. 79.
groups of their molecules increasetheretention (Ink' 0) and all hydrophilic groups decrease the retention (Ink' 0) but in normal-phase chromatography, on separation on hydroxylated silica the hydrophilicgroupsincreasetheretention owing to hydrogen bonding with silanol groups and hydrocarbon groups decrease the retention. Silica with bonded poly-~-vinylpyrrolidoneis used for separationof proteins. In this case the modifying layer protects proteins from strong adsorption on hydroxylated silica. The grafting of N-vinylpyrrolidone groupsis usedfor coatingof silica capillary walls on separation of proteins by capillary zone electrophoresis ~-vinylpyrrolidone groupsgrafted to silica surfaces include both hydrocarbon and electron-donor fragments. So such adsorbents can be used for separation of polyaromatic hydrocarbons and proton-donor compounds. In Fig. 29, separation of some aromatic hydrocarbons on silica with bonded poly-~-vinylpyrrolidone from heptane is presented. The order elution corresponds to the molecular mass of the compounds. In Fig. 30a, b, the separations of very polar compounds (acids) are presented. Gallic acid sometimes is used as a nonadsorbedcompoundfordetermination of the void volume of columnsin reversed-phase liquid chromatography,owingtostronginteraction of sucha hydrophilic molecule withaqueous eluents. This molecule practically doesnot adsorb on the hydrophobic surface of modified silica. But on silica with bonded N-vinylpyrrolidone groups, gallic acid has the highest retention for compounds in mixtures under investigation (Fig. 30a). In Fig. 30b, the separation of some derivatives of benzoic acid as an example of separation of hydrophilic compounds on silica with bonded ~-vinylpyrroiidone are presented. The elution order is deter-
5
min
Separation of some polyaromatic compounds on silica gel Silasorb 300 by N-vinylpyrrolidone. Eluent: heptane. Temperature: 40°C. (1) toluene, fluorene, (3) anthracene, (4) triphenylene, perylene.
mined not only by interaction of carboxyl groups of separating molecules with pyrrolidone groups bonded to the silica surface but by substituted groups with eluent molecules. After the discovery of fullerenes and the development of the method of their preparation. on macroscopic scale [62,63] the problems of separation, purification, and analysis of fullerenes arise. It was found that silicas with different bonded modifiers are very useful adsorbents for separation and analysis of fullerenes by HPLC [81-861. Separation of fullerenes on silica gel itself ispossible, but selectivity is not high and it is necessary to have a very effective column to separate and A more useful adsorbent for separation issilica with bonded diphenylsilyl groups.Theseparation is based onthestronger interaction of fullerenes with
I Separation of some aromatic acids on silica gel Silacorb 300 modified by ~-vinylpyrrolidone.Eluent: phosphate buffer (pH 2, I 1S). Temperature: 40°C. (a) (1) benzoic acid, (2) 3,4-dihydrobenzoic acid, (3) gallic acid; (b) phenylalanin, (2) p-an~inobenzoicacid, (3) p-nitrobenzoic acid, (4) benzoic acid, (5) p-oxybenzoic acid, (6) p-chlorobenzoic acid, (7) p-toluic acid.
phenyl groups on silica surfaces than with n-hydrocarbon molecules used as eluent. For the separation of fullerenes, silica with bonded octadecylsilyl groups is widely used. Adding alcohol to the eluent makes it possibleto separate oxide of fullerene from fullerene. For separation of fullerenes it is possible to use hydrogen bonding between fullerene molecules havingto some extent aromatic propertiesand bonded to silica surface hydroxyl groups. A column with the silica gel LiChrosorb Diol is very useful for analysis not only of fullerene itself but also oxide derivatives of fullerenes [8 1,821. At present many typesof stationary phaseson bases of modified silicahave been prepared for effective separations not only of fullerenes but also their derivatives [64, 8 1-86]. naryphasessuchastripodal arrange~ents three 2,4-dinicovalently attached through a Clo spacer a m to silica er" [83] as well as silica with bonded groups 2-(1-pyrenyl)ethyl, 3(1-pyrenyl)propyl, 2-nitrophenylethyl, 3-(~-nitrophenoxy)propyl[84], tetraphenylporphyrin [85], and dinitroanilinopro~yl [86] can be used for separation of fullerenes not only on analytical but on semipreparative and preparative scales.
40
Separation of fullerenesonsilicagelswithbondeddiphenylsilylgroups (a), with bonded octadecylsilyl groups (b),and silica gel LiChrosorb Diol (c). (From Ref. 81.)
For separationof fullerenes on preparative scale, activated carbon is used (e.g., Ref. 87). Silica with a deposited carbon layer can also be used for separation and purification of fullerene in semipreparative scale In Fig. 31a, b, c the separationsof fullerenes on different modified silica gelsare presented. In Fig. 32a, b the separations of oxide derivatives of fullerenes on the silica gel LiChrosorb Diol are demonstrated. Figure 33 shows the semipreparative separation of and on silicagel with deposited carbon layer. Fullerenes can be separated on silica with bonded fullerene (Fig. 34) (64,881. Application of adsorption modification of silica can be demonstrated on separation of carbohydrates. In this case hydrogen bondingbetween the hydroxyl groups of carbohydrate molecules and amino groups bonded to the surface silica adsorbents is used. In a number of publications the separationsand analysis of carbohydrates are carried out on silicamodifiedby ~-amonopropyltriethoxysilane(e.g., Ref. 72). Adsorption modification for the formingof amino group layers for this purpose can also be used. Figure 35 shows the separationof sugar mixture on hydroxylated silica gel, and on silica gel with pieperazine adsorbed from eluent, as well as on silica gel with bonded ~-amonopropylsilyl groups [68,69]. From this figure it can be seen that on the hydroxylated silica surface this mixture of carbohydrates practically cannot be separated from the acetone-water eluent because the difference in intermolecular interaction of carbohydrates withsilanol groups of adsorbents from water solution is too small. Moreover, acetone and water molecules of the eluent are competitors, forming quite strong hydrogen bonds with silanol groups. After addition of piperazine to the eluent, satisfactory separation of the sugar mixture takes place. The elution order of the carbohydrates monosaccharides, then disaccharides, and finally trisaccharides, in accordance with the increasing numberof
6
0
~eparationofoxidederivativesoffullerenes(a) c 6 0 and (b) onsilica gel LiChrosorb Diol. c 6 0 ; (2) C 6 0 0 ; (3) C6005 (4) c6003;(5) c6004 (6) C6005; (1) C60; (2) (3) C7,0; (4) C7002; C7003.(From Ref. 82.)
proton-donor groups in their molecules. Similar separation of the same mixture takes place on silica with bonded amino groups. The effect of molecular geometryon retention of carbohydrates of silica adsorption modified by piperazine is important. In Fig. 36 the separationsof some pentose and hexose stereoisomers are presented. By using the adsorption modifier piperazine it is possible to completely separate these isomers on hydroxylated silica gel. The elution order of mannose, glucose, galactose on the one hand, and lyxose, xylose, arabinose on the other, is determined by the similarity in the geometry of
Se~ipreparativeseparation of fullerenes deposited carbon layer. (From Ref. 60.)
and
on silica gel with
L
fullerene
Separation offullerenes (1) (From Ref. 88.)
and (2)
on silica gel withimmobilized
30
Separation of carbohydrate mixture on hydroxylated silica gel at 20°C from 4:l acetone-water eluent on hydroxylated silica gel (a), on silica gel adsorbed from eluent piperazine and on silicagel with bonded aminopropylsilyl groups (c). Peaks: (1) ribose; (2) xylose; (3) fructose; (4) glucose; (5) sucrose; (6) cellobiose; (7) melezitose; (8) raffinose. (From Ref. 68.)
their structure, Inspite of the fact that the numberof hydroxyl groupsin all pentose is the same (as well as for hexose also) the different geometrical arrangement of hydroxylgroups in their molecules makes it possible toseparatetheisomers completely. Adsorption modifiersin liquid chromatography in some cases makes it possible to replace compounds used for chemical modification. In water eluents, adsorbents with bonded amino groups have basic media which result in removal of bonded NHz groups from the silica surface. The column in this case loses capacity with time. By using anadsorptionmodifierthesurface of theadsorbent is always covered by an adsorbed layer of modifier if its concentration in the eluent is sufficient and the column works stably. Some kindof adsorption modification takes place during deposition of fullerene on silica surfaces by evaporation of solvent from thefullerene solution added to the silicagel. Theadsorptionandchromatographicproperties ofsilica essentially change. On silica with deposited fullerene it is possible to separate ethers (Fig. 37) [61j,
2
4
0
l0
30
min
0
"0. 30
r, min
Separation ofhexose (a)andpentose(b)isomersonsilica gelwith adsorbed piperazine from eluent. Eluent: (a) and (b) 9:l acetone-waer, both including 0.44 mg/ml piperazine. Peaks: (a) (1) talose; (2) mannose; (3) glucose; (4) galactose; (b) ribose; (2) lyxose; (3) xylose; (4) arabinose. (From Ref. 68.)
In recent years, for investigation ofsilica surface chemistry the method of cross-polarization ~agic-angle-spinningnuclearmagneticresonance (CP NMR has been used. In Refs 89 and 90 this method makes it possible distinguish to single and geminal silanol groups, the concentration of which is relatively small compared with all surface silanol groups of silica. The review of investigations of silica by this method is presented in Ref. 5. Unfortunately there are few data on differences in interactions with adsorbed molecules and in chemical modification reactions between single free and geminal silanol groups. But even if these differences exist, and they should exist, the main relationships of adsorption properties already determined cannot be changed noticeably because the concentration of geminal silanol groups is not so high. Moreover, by infrared spectroscopy it is difficult to find the difference in frequency of single and geminal silanol groups and only by such a sensitive method as"Si (CP MAS) has it been possible to distinguish them and therefore differences in properties of single and geminal silano1 groups should not be so noticeable.
" I " 8
(a) Separation of some etherson silica gel with deposited fullerene (extract mainly a mixture -85% and 15%). (b) For comparison chromatogram diethyl ether on initial silica gel. Ref. 61.)
The investi~ationof adsorption of col~poundsfrom ~ulticomponentsolutions including aqueous solutions on hydroxylated and modified silica adsorbents is of great interest for technology, chromatography, and e~vironmental protection. The main results of these investigations are presented in Ref. 9 l .
l . L. A. 2. A. New 3.
Little. Spectra Species (with supplementary chapters by Kiselev and I. Lygin), Academic Press, London, New York, 1966. ~ h y , Press, Kiselev and Ya. 1. Yasbin. ~ a s - ~ d s o r ~Ct ~i or o~ ~ u t o g r ~Plenum York, 1969. Unger. Silica, Its Pro~ertie~s and Use S ~ ~ p o in rt L~~uid Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1979. 4. Her. The C h e ~ i s t r y Silica, A Wiley-Interscience Publishers, New York, 1979. 5. P. Legrand, (ed.), The S ~ r f a c e~ r o ~ e r t i e s Silicas, Wiley Sons Ltd, New York, 1998. 6. Ua. Davydov and A. Kiselev. Zhur. Fiz. Khim. (J. Phys. Chem., Russian) 37:2593 (1963).
7. V. Ya. Davydov, A. V. Kiselev,and L. T.Zhuravlev. Trans. Faraday Soc. 60:2254 (1964). 8. V. Ya. Davydov, L. T. Zhuravlev, and A. V. Kiselev. Zhur. Fiz. Khim. (J. Phys. Chem., Russian) 38:2047 (1964). 9. V. Ya. Davydov, A. V. Kiselev, V. A. Lokutsievskii, and V. Lygin. Zhur. Fiz. Khim. (J. Phys. Chem., Russian) 47:809 (1973). Ar~ltiunyan,A. V.Kiselev, and T.I. Titova. Dokl. Acad. Nauk SSSR 10. B. 251:1148 (1980). 11. G. Curthoys, V. Ya. Davydov, A. V. Kiselev,S. A. Kiselev, and B. Kuznetsov. J. Coll. Interface Sci. 48:58 (1974). Kiselev, and S. A. Kiselev. Kollooid Zhurn. (Colloid 12, V. Ya. Davydov, A. Russian) 41:227 (1979). 13. N.V. Akshinskaia, V. Ya. Davydov, A. V. Kiselev, and Yu. S. Nikitin. Kolloid Zhur. (Colloid Russian) 28:3 (1966). 14. R.L. Gorelik, Ya. Davydov, L. T. Zhuravlev, G. Curthoys, A. V. Kiselev, and Yu. S. Nikitin. Kolloid Zhurn. (Colloid Russian) 35:456 (1973). 15. R. L. Gorelik, V. Ya. Davydov, S. P. Zhdanov, L. T. Zhuravlev, C. Curthoys, A. V.Kiselev, and Yu. S. Nikitin.Kolloid Zhurn. (Colloid Russian)35:1152 (1973). Basic ~ r i n c ~ l e s Vol. 7, Springer, Berlin, etc., 1972, Pfeifer. 16. 53. Ya. Davydov, A. V. Kiselev, H. Pfeifer and Yunger. Zhur. Fiz. Khim. (J. 17. Phys. Chem., Russian) 57:2535 (1983). 18. L. T. Zhuravlev, A. V. Kiselev, V. P. Naidina, and A. L. Poliakov. Zhur. Fiz. Khim. (J. Phys. Chem., Russian) 37:2258 (1963). in ~ x ~ e r i ~ e n teth a l hod in ~ ~ s o r ~ t iand on ~ o l e c ~ l ~ r 19. L. T. Zhuravlev, C ~ r o ~ a t o g r a(V. ~ ~P. y Dreving and A. V. Kiselev, eds.), MSU, Moscow, 1973, pp. 250-272. Davydov, A. V.Kiselev, S. A. Kiselev, and V.0.-V. Polotnyuk. J. 20. V. Interface Sci. 74378 (1980). 21 L. T. Zhuravlev. Langmuir 3:316 (1987). Kiselev. Kolloid Zhurn. (Colloid 22 V. Ya.Davydov, T. V. Erexneeva, and A. Russian), 43:144 (1981). 23. A. V.Togansen. Teor.Eksperirn.Khim.(Theor.Exp.Chem.,Russian)7:302 (1971);Intensity InfraredSpectra and HydrogenBonds, Moscow, Moscow State University, 1969. 24. V. Ya. Davydov,A. V.Kiselev, and V. I. Lygin.Kolloid Zhurn. (Colloid Russian) 25: 152 (1963). 25. V. Ya. Davydov, A. V. Kiselev, and V. I. Lygin. Zhur. Fiz. Khim. (J. Phys. Chem., Russian) 37:469 (1963). 26. V. Ya. Davydov and A. Kiselev. Kolloid Zhurn. (Colloid Russian) 30:353 (1968). 27. V. Ya. Davydov, A. V. Kiselev, and B. V. Kuznetsov. Zhur. Fiz. Khim. (J. Phys. Chem., Russian) 39:2058 (1965). 28, V. Ya. Davydov, T. M. Roschina, N. M. Khrustaleva, and A.A. Mandrugin, Zhur. Fiz. Khim. (J. Phys. Chem., Russian) 67:2428 (1993).
29. 30. 31. 32. 33. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41. 42. 43. 44. 45. 46.
47. 48. 49. 50. 51. 52. 53. 54.
Ya. Davydov and A. Kiselev. Kolloid Zhurn. (Colloid J., Russian) 42:348 (1980). Ya. Davydov, A. Kiselev, V. A. Lokutsievskii, and I. Lygin. Zhur. Fiz. Khim. (J. Phys. Chem., Russian) 48:2267 (1974). C. Zettlemoyer and K. Klier. Surface C ~ e ~ i s tof r yOxides. Disc. Faraday Soc. 1971, No. 52, pp. 46-49. Yu. Babkin and A. Kiselev. Zhur. Fiz.Khim. (J. Phys.Chem.,Russian) 36:2448 (1965). C . S. Pimentel and A. L. McClellan, The ~ ~ d r o g eBond n (L. Pauling ed.), San Francisco, London, 1960. L. Boksanyi, 0. Liardon, and E. Sr. Kovats, in Advances and Interface Science, 1976, Vol. 6, pp. 95-137. A. Tertykh and L. A. Beliakova. C ~ e ~ ~Reactions i c a ~ with ~ a r t i c ~ a t of i oSilica ~ Surface, Naukova Dumka, Kiev, 1991. A. Dabrowski and V. A. Tertykh (eds.),Adsorption on New ~norganic 99, Elsevier, Amsterdam, Sorbents Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis, 1996. Beresin, B. K. Antonov, and K. Martinek(eds.), ~ ~ ~ o ~ i IEnzymes. ized ~ o d e r nState and Perspectives 1, MSU, Moscow, 1976. Silica 98. Extended Abstracts Oral and Poster ~resentations,Mulhous, France, 1-4 September,1998. A. Kiselev, B. V. Kuznetsov, and S. N. Lanin, J. Coll. Interface Sci. 69:148 (1979). K. Unger, K. Berg, and E. Gallei. Kolloid Z. Z. Polymer. 234:1108 (1969). K. Berg and K. Unger. Kolloid Z. Z. Polymer. 246:682 (1971). Ya. Davydov and I. Nazarova. VestnikMosk.Univ.(Russian)Series2, Chemistry 29:580 (1988). Davydov, M. Elizalde Gonzalez, A. Kiselev, and K. Lenda. Chromatographia l#: 13 (1981). Ya. Davydov, M. Elizalde Conzalez,and A. Kiselev, J. Chromatogr. 204293 (1981). A. P. Arzamastsev, V. Ya. Davydov, M. Elizalde Gonzalez,A. Kiselev, and R. Rodionova. Khirn.-Farm. Zhur. (Chern.-Pharm. J., Russian) 17:494 (1983). W. Wemetsberger, M. Kellerman, and Ricken. C h r o ~ a t o g r a p ~ i10:726 a (1 977). V. Ya. Davydov, A. V. Kiselev, and B. Kuznetsov. Zhur. Fiz. Khim. (J. Phys. Chem., Russian) 6#:1 (1970). L. B. Zubakova, N. Borisova, S. K. Koroleva, V. Ya. Davydov, and C . N. Filatova. Prikl. Khirn. (J. Appl. Chem., Russian) 60:1491 (1987). N. K. Bebris, R. G.Vorobieva, A. V. Kiselev,Yu. S. Nikitin, L. Tarasova, I. Frolov, and Ya. Yashin, J. Chromatogr. ll7:257 (1976). W. Colin and G. Cwiochon. J. Chromatogr. 137:19 (1977). J. H. Knox, B. Kaur, and G. R. M i l ~ ~ a rJ.d .Chromatogr. 352:25 (1986). K. K. Unger. Anal. Chem. 55:361A (1983). Plzak, F.P. Dousek, and J. Jansta. J. Chromatogr. 147:137 (1978). C . G. Guiochon and H. Colin. Chromatogr. Rev. 4:2(1978).
55. E. P. Smirnov, N. A. Bogomolov, S. I. Koltsov, and V. B. Aleskovskii. Zhur. Prikl. Khim. (J. Appl. Chem., Russian) 52:2590 (1979). 56. P. A. Tesner, E. V. Denisevich, and I. Yu. Kulikov. Kinetika i kataliz (J. Kinet. Catalysis, Russian) 25:990 (1984). 57. E. V. Denisevich and P. A. Tesner. Neftekhimia (Petrochemistry, Russian) 21:552 98 1). Ya. Davydov and V. I. Nazarova.VestnikMosk.Univ.(Russian)Series2, 58. Chemistry 29:580 (1988). 59. V. Ya. Davydov and V. I. Nazarova,VestnikMosk.Univ.(Russian)Series2, Chemistry 32:127 (1990). 60. V. Ya. Davydov and G. N. Filatova.Vestnik Mosk. Univ.(Russian)Series2, Chemistry 37:357 (1996). 61. V. Ya. Davydov, T. M.Roschina, G. N. Filatova, and N. M.Khrustaleva. Vestnik Mosk. Univ. (Russian) Series 2, Chemistry 36:518 (1995). 62. H. W. Kroto, J. R. Heath, S. C. O'Brien, R. F. Curl, and R. E. Smally. Nature 318: 162 986). 63. W. Kratschmer,L. D, Lamb, K. Fostinopoulos, and D. R. Huffman. Nature 347:354 (1990). 64. Y. Saito, H. Ohta, H. Terasaki, H. Nagashima, and K. Jinno. J. HighResol. Chromatogr. 18:569 (1995); Separation of Fullerenes by Liquid Chromatography (K. Jinno, ed), RSC, UK, 1998. 65. F. Wudl, A. Hirsch, K. C. Khemani, Suzuki, P.-M. Allemand, A.Koch, and Srdanov,in ~ ~ l l e r e n e sSynthesis, : Properties and C h e ~ i s t r y Large Carbon Hammond and V. J. Kuck, eds.), The American Chemical Soc., Clusters Washington, D.C., 1991, p. 161. 66. V. Ya. Davydov, G. N. Filatova, and T. D.Khokhlova. Mol. Mat. 10:125 (1998). and 67. M. S. Dresselhaus, G. Dresselhous, and P. C. Eklund, in Science Carbon ~anotubes,Academic Press, San Diego, 1995, p. 63. 68. M. Boumahraz, V. Ya. Davydov, and A.V.Kiselev. Chromatographia 15:751 (1982). y Proceedings the Advances in Li4uid 69. V. Ya. Davydov, in C h r o ~ ~ t o g r a p h'84, Chro~atography,Szeged, Hungary (H. Kalasz and L. S. Ettre, eds.), Akademiai Kiado, Budapest, 1986, pp. 351-373. 70. L. R. Snyder and J. Kirkland. ~ntrod~ction to ~ o ~ e Liquid r n Cl~~o~ato~ru~hy, 2nd ed., Wiley-Interscience, New York, 1979. 71. V. A.Davankov,A. S. Bochkov,A.A.Kurganov, P. Rourneliotis, and K. K. Unger. Chrornatographia 13:677 (1980). 72. M. Verzele, G. Simoens, and F. Van Darnme. Chromatographia 23:292 (1987). 73. N. Sheppard and J. W. Ward. J. Catalysis 15:50 (1969). 74. B. A. Morrow and N. Sheppard. Proc. Roy. Soc. A. 311:391 (1969). 75. N. Sheppard and C. De La Cruz in Advances in Catalysis (D. D. Eley, W. Haag, B. Gates, and H. Knozinger, eds), Academic Press, San Diego, Vol. 41, 1996, pp. 1-112; Vol. 42, 1998, pp. 181-312. 76. V. Ya.Davydov, in~ x p e r i ~ e n t~u l e t h ino Adsorption ~ ~ and C h r o ~ ~ ~ t o ~ r(Yu. aphy Nikitin and R. S. Petrova,eds.),MoscowUniversity,Moscow,1990, 193-211.
77. V. Ya. Davydov. J. Chromatogr. 356: 123 (1986). 78. V. Ya. Davydov, M. Elizalde Gonzalez, and A. V. Kiselev.J. Chromatogr. 248:49 (1982). 79. Ya. Davydov and G. N. Filatova. VestnikMosk.Univ.(Russian)Series2, Chemistry 37:128 (1996). C. Vidal-Madjar, Sebille, and J. C. Diez-Masa. J. Chromatogr. A. 80. R. J. 730:2139 (1996). 81. V. Ya. Davydov,in Adsor~tionon and ~ o d ~ rnorganic e d or bent^^ (A. DabrowskiandV. A. Tertykh, eds.)StudiesinSurfaceScience and Catalysis, Vol. 99, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1996, pp. 899-914. 82. Ya. Davydov, 0. M.Knipovich,M. V. Korobov, N. B. Tamm,and G. N. Filatova. Vestnik Mosk. Univ. (Russian) Series 2, Chemistry 38:238 (1997). 83. C. J. Welch and W. H. Pirkle. J. Chromatogr. 609239 (1992). 84. Kimata, K. Hosoya, T. Araki, and N. Tanaka. J. Org. Chern. 58:282 (1993). H. Francis. 85. C. E. Kibbey, M. R. Savina, B. Parseghina, M. E. Meyerhoff, and Anal. Chem. 65:3717 (1993). R. Ruoff, D. C. Lorents, and R. Malhotra, in F ~ l l ~ r e ~Recent ~es. 86. D. S. Advances in the Chemistry and Physics Fullerenes and R e l ~ ~ e d ~ a t e(K. ~ i M. als Kadish and R. Ruoff, eds.), The Electrochemical Soc., ~ e n n i ~ g t oN. n , J., 1994, pp. 191-199. 87. W. A. Scrivens and M. Tour. Org. Chem. 575032 (1992). Ya. Davydov, L. Feltl, G. N. Filatova, T. D. Khokhlova, Pacakova, and 88. Stulik, in Fuller~nes.Recent Advances in the C h e ~ i s t r yand Ph-vsics ~ ~ l l e r e ~ e s elated ater rials (K. M. Kadish and R. S. Ruoff, eds), The Electrochemical Soc., ~ennington, 1997, Vol. 4, p. 567. 89. G. E. Maciel and D. W. Sindorf. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 102:7606 (1980). 90. D. W. Sindorf and G. E. Maciel. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 103:4263 (1981). ion ~ o d ~ e d ~ o r ~ e n (A. ts Ya. Davydov,in ~ ~ ~ ~ o r ~ tNew 91. Dabrowski and V. Tertykh, eds.),StudiesinSurfaceScience and Catalysis, Vol. 99, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1996, pp. 673-703.
Centre de Recherche sur la Matikre Universith d'Orlhans, Orleans, France
Tntroduction TI. Curvature and Confinement A. A pinch of stereology and mathematical morphology connectivity and Curvature 128 in silicas From C. two-dimensiollal three-di~ensional to ~dsorption,disorder, and c o n f i ~ ~ m e n t Adsorption, disorder, curvatureand 111. Roughness, Scale Invariance, and Scale invariance: self-similarit Thenanoscaletexture of silicas and their surfaceroughness Experinlental methods and 154 evidence Conclusion eferences
119 123 123 134 139 141 143 146 150 163 163
This chapter is devoted to a simple question: does the of the surface of silica influenceits adsorption properties? A this is a general questionwhich. is not limited to silicas. Any porous medium be described as interface exploring the embedding th.ree-dimensional space partitioning it into two subspaces: matter and void. The morphological complexity of that interface, from subnanometric to macroscopic scale, is virtually unlimited. It is the result of all the elemen"Current ~ ~ ~ l i a t i oLaboratoire n: de Physico-Chirnie, Structurale et ~a~rornoleculaire, Ecole SupQieure de Physique et Chirnie Industrielles, Paris, France.
tary processes involved in the material synthesis. Considering the variety of processes involved in amorphous silica synthesis (polymerization, growth, aggregation, sintering, and drying, to quote a few), some of them occurring in thermodynamic equilibrium conditions and some in out-of-equilibrium conditions, it is no wonder that Silicaland offers a particularly rich variety of landscapes, being rivaled in that only by porous carbons. This morphological complexity is usually classified in three categories corresponding to three structural levels. At atomic and molecular level,when interpreting the molecular size-dependenceof monolayer or multilayer adsorption, it is common to think in terms of At larger scales, when discussing adsorption capacities, capillary condensation,or adsorption~esorptionhysteresis, the concepts invoked are those of and At even larger scales, when considering adsorption kinetics or hysteresis phenomena again, the notion of may be introduced.Although this clear and simple hierarchical classification may be relevant (Fig. la), it is in no way guaranteed that it applies to all situations. Even simple concepts such as pore and pore rnay be difficult to apply in disordered porous materials. Silica aerogels, for instance (Fig. lb) [l], are probably an extreme case of such a difficulty, buttheproblem is raised for all silicas outsidethe crystalline ones. Similarly, distinguishingthepocketsdue to surfaceroughnessfromthose whichrnaybe called "pores" may become a purely semantic matter in some cases (Fig. IC) [2]. Fortunately, in the overwhelrning majority of cases, the problem of describing a complex interface rnay be put more generally by introducing parameters or properties suchascurvature,correlation length, or scale invariance, whichwillbe developed further in the following. ince the purpose of this chapter is to discuss shape and nlorphology,it is naturalto refer to ~nfortunately, images ofsilica suitable for quantitative analysis, at the right l ~ a g n i ~ c a t i ofor n discussing adsorption or condensation, are extremelydifficult to obtain." Even more difficult (actually, impose, for the time being) is to obtain three-dimensional (3D) representations. No imaging tech-nique (magnetic resonance microimaging, x-ray microtomograetc.) so far reaches the necessary resolution. Most of the time, the nanoscale and mesoscale morphological information we have corning, via models, from scattering tech-niques or from the adsorption data themselves. In spite of this, we stantial part of this chapter to the as-quantitative-as-possible mages or 3D structures. The reason is that, with the development of computer modeling methods of all kinds, the trend is clearly towards the comparison of experimentaladsorption data withcomputeddataobtained by MonteCarloormoleculardynamicssimulations in modelporousstructures morphologically as similar as possible to the real material (Fig. 2). Thus, faithful representation of the real material willbe essential, as willbe the quantitative deter~inationof the important morphological parameters. "This is not the case for other mineral or biological porous media like rocks, or bones, where the interest shifts towards mechanical or hydrodynamic transport properties and where the relevant length scales are well above the micrometric level.
(a) 2D section through a hypothetical porous material where the notions of surface roughness, pore size, pore shape, and pore network would have obvious meanings. sketch of the structure of a silica aerogel. (Adapted from Ref. What is the meaning of pore size and pore shape in such a case? (c) 2D section through a porous calcium silicate hydrate. (From Ref. 2.) What is the difference between surface roughness and pore size distributio~in such a case? Before ill~~strating this approach, we will spend some time recalling some basic morphological notions and their relation with the surface morphology of one or another familyofsilicas. Although fractal concepts have beenextensivelyused since the early 1980s to analyze adsorption on silicas and other porous solids, they will not represent the main focus of this chapter." We deliberately chose to diversify our tools in a pragmatic spirit. We also gave up covering the immense literature where adsorption data were correlated in some way or another to
sdace energy
chemistry molecular dynamics
The scheme which is likely to become the general scheme for studying the adsorption properties of disordered porous materials in the near future. Realistic 2D and representations of the material at nano- and mesoscales are the cornerstones of the process.
morpbological feature (pore size, fractal dimension, etc.). If an emphasis of some kind has to be put forward in this chapter, it is definitely on methodology and generic phenomena.
Curvature is a key parameter in any growth, condensation, or coalescence process in solution or in the gas phase, since it controls, in association with the surface energy and via the Kelvin equation, thesolubility of the vapor pressureof a solid or liquid surfaceinequilibriumconditions,* In its simplestform,fora spherical meniscus, a particle or a droplet of radius r, the Kelvin equation reads [4] R T ln(a/ao)
2
where ais the activity in the gasor solution phase, y the surface energyof the solid, and its molar volume; a0 is the activity over a flat surface, R is the universal gas constant for anideal gas, and Tis the absolute temperature. Incrystalline particles, the surface energy dependson the typeof crystal face and this leads to well-defined equilibrium shapes.In amorphous materials, may be assumed to be constant, like in liquids. Among other things, the Kelvin equation predicts that small particles will have a larger solubility and vapor pressure than large particles, which is the basis for the well-known Ostwald ripening processin which small particles tend to disappear to feed the growth of the larger ones. This is potentially an intrinsic part of any amorphous silica synthesis, whether in solution for gels and precipitated silicas or in the gas phase for high-temperature silicas. However, silicas are not simple collections of independent “elementary” spherical particles. They are, at least, connected and partially sintered assemblies of spheres with a broad distribution of convex or concave local curvatures, which means that mass transfer during synthesis has taken a much more subtle form than in the above description. In addition, this distribution of local curvatures introduces strong local bias in multilayer adsorption and condensation. Furthermore, curvature may be the signature of connectivity, which is importa~t for diffusion. It is therefore interesting to spend some time examining the ways curvature and connectivity may be defined and mea