DEDICATION
The genesis of this book can be traced back to July 2003, the date of the Carbon 2003 Conference. This presented Eduardo J. Bottani and myself with an excellent opportunity to introduce our project to lain Craig, the Commissioning Editor with whom we discussed the scope and contents of the book. Soon afterwards, the publication of the book was approved by Elsevier Science and we established initial contacts with some prospective authors. However, the unexpected death of Eduardo J. Bottani on October 24,2003, meant that I now had a dual responsibility, not only to the publisher and the authors who had already agreed to contribute chapters, but also to the memory of Eduardo, to whom I wish to dedicate this book. Needless to say, I accept full responsibility for any faults in the editing as Eduardo passed away before we began the work in earnest. Prof. Eduardo Jorge Bottani was born in Bahia Blanca, Argentina, on July 2, 1955. After completing his studies in Chemistry (speciality: Physical Chemistry) at the Universidad Nacional de La Plata (UNLP), he went on to gain a PhD in the same university and speciality in 1982. His thesis, carried out under the supervision of Prof. Lydia E. Cascarini de Torre, was entitled "Study of interactions in physically adsorbed molecules." Except for several periods ofstudy abroad, first at Louvain-Ia-Neuve, Belgium, and later at State College, PA, USA (with Prof. W.A. Steele), Eduardo J. Bottani spent most of his life in La Plata and his entire professional career at INIFTA, a renowned research institute devoted to Basic and Applied Physical Chemistry. It was here while a member of the Physical Adsorption Laboratory that he held several positions as a research scientist for CIC. Towards the end of his life he also collaborated with Profs A.J. Arvia and E.A. Castro, successive directors of the Institute, in organizational tasks. While carrying out his scientific research, he taught General, Inorganic and Physical Chemistry at UNLP (his Alma Mater which, I regret to say, returned him much less than he had given her). Later on, he was given the post of Visiting Professor at the Universidad Nacional del Litoral (UNL) in the city of Santa Fe, where, together with Prof. H.S. Odetti, he formed a flourishing research team. I first met Eduardo on October 12, 1992, when Lydia Cascarini and he welcomed me at Ezeiza Airport in Buenos Aires (the date is easy to remember as it was exactly 500 years to the day after a famous discovery known to all mankind). This was the beginning of a period of collaboration that has culminated in the production of this book. Since 1999, Eduardo J. Bottani spent one month a year in Oviedo, where we combined our efforts in investigating gas physisorption on different materials such as carbon blacks, fullerenes, and carbon v
vi
Dedication
nanotubes. Moreover, he and I shared an interest in art (especially architecture) and made many weekend visits to different monuments of our Spanish cultural heritage. At the time he passed away, Prof Bottani was Deputy Director of INIFTA and General Secretary of the Argentine Chemical Society (Asociaci6n Qu£mica Argentina, AQA). Shortly before, he had been appointed Editor-in-Chief of the Journal of the Atgentine Chemical Society, where he took up the challenge of converting the traditional Anales de la AQA into a truly international journal. He was also responsible for the organization of a number of Argentine Conferences on Chemistry. All of these facts about his life show that Eduardo J. Bottani was at the summit of his career at the time of his death, sadly yet another unfortunate case of a gifted person with a promising future brought to a premature end. Eduardo is survived by his wife Jovita Montoni de Bottani, daughter Estefania, and sons Eduardo and Ezequiel, to whom, together with his mother, Dona Elvira Gar6foli de Bottani and rest of the family, friends, and colleagues I offer this book as a token of my esteem. Juan M.D. Tasc6n
FOREWORD
It has been a great pleasure for me to write a foreword for this very interesting book on Adsorption by Carbons in response to an invitation I first received from the editors in August 2003 when the book was still only a project. This invitation has afforded me the opportunity and the privilege of uniting the efforts of an outstanding group of renowned scientists as authors of the different chapters, some of whom have been either my colleagues or disciples. Part 1 of the book is of an introductory nature. Thus, Chapter 1 provides an updated overview of adsorption by carbons, differentiates the features of adsorption on nonporous and porous carbons, and identifies the main obstacles still hindering the study of gas adsorption by porous carbons. Recent major developments and research needs in this field are also mentioned. Chapter 2 presents a survey of carbons in the context of adsorption and classifies them on the basis of structural criteria. This chapter might help nonspecialists in carbon to find materials that they can use for adsorption purposes. Part 2 of the book addresses the fundamental aspects of adsorption by carbons. The first few chapters deal with the energy aspects of gas adsorption. Thus, Chapter 3 focuses on thermodynamic quantities, with particular attention being paid to their significance and relation to experimental results. Cursory descriptions of the classical and statistical thermodynamic approaches are presented in the form of essential equations. Chapter 4 presents two types of simulation techniques (Monte Carlo and Molecular Dynamics) that help us to understand the behavior of molecules on surfaces of carbons and other materials. It is pointed out that the former method is more useful for studying transport properties, whereas the latter provides information about the thermodynamic properties at the adsorbent/adsorbate interface. New areas under development in this field are outlined. Chapter 5 focuses on models of porous carbons that are useful for predicting and explaining the behavior of adsorbed phases. The discussion encompasses both classical single-pore models (e.g., the well-known slit-shaped pore) as well as more realistic models that include factors such as connectivity or tortuosity. The connection between models and experimental techniques and the need for improving methods of obtaining experimental data are emphasized. Chapter 6 deals with adsorption hysteresis or, to be more precise, the origin of adsorption hysteresis. It addresses the peculiar characteristics of hysteresis in the case of carbon adsorbents, namely, structural lability and the presence of surface chemical structures (principally, oxygenated groups) that modify the energetics and wettability behavior of carbon surfaces. The surface heterogeneity of carbons is analyzed in Chapter 7 on the basis that practically all real adsorbents XVll
xviii
Foreword
are heterogeneous. The big differences within the ensemble of carbon materials (ranging from higWy homogeneous graphites to extremely heterogeneous activated carbons) are discussed and the factors that cause heterogeneity are analyzed. The wetting of solid surfaces by liquids is addressed next in Chapter 8. To analyze the wetting of carbon, the study was extended from graphite (by far the most widely studied carbon surface) to include other materials such as carbon nanotubes, the geometry of which greatly affects the wetting properties. The theory and simulation of gas adsorption on carbon nanotube bundles is addressed in Chapter 9, which focuses on the structural, dynamic, and thermal properties of gases adsorbed at sites such as grooves between pairs of nanotubes, interstitial channels, or inner spaces inside the individual tubes. This chapter serves as a background for Chapter 15, which belongs to Part 3 of the book. The section on fundamentals ends with Chapter 10, which follows two general approaches (the generalized Gaussian model and the bivariate model) to characterize the energy topography of carbon surfaces. The former model is attractive due to its simplicity and works well with substrates with a rough-surface adsorptive energy. The bivariate model is applicable to heterogeneous surfaces with two kinds of sites. The series of 10 chapters that constitute Part 3 of the book deals mainly with the use of adsorption as a means of characterizing carbons. Thus, the first three chapters in this section complement each other in the use of gas-solid or liquid-solid adsorption to characterize the porous texture and/or the surface chemistry of carbons. Porous texture characterization based on gas adsorption is addressed in Chapter 11 in a very comprehensive manner and includes a description of a number of classical and advanced tools (e.g., density functional theory and Monte Carlo simulations) for the characterization of porosity in carbons. Chapter 12 illustrates the use of adsorption at the liquid-solid interface as a means to characterize both pore texture and surface chemistry. The authors propose these methods (calorimetry, adsorption from solution) to characterize carbons for use in such processes as liquid purification or liquid-solid heterogeneous catalysis, for example. Next, the surface chemical characterization of carbons is comprehensively treated in Chapter 13, which discusses topics such as hydrophilicity and functional groups in carbon as well as the amphoteric characteristics and electrokinetic phenomena on carbon surfaces. The next block (Chapters 14-18) is principally devoted to the characterization of several types of carbon that deserve attention for their novelty. Thus, fullerenes, which are dealt with in Chapter 14, are studied as adsorbents with various objectives in mind: for the fundamental investigation of their surface energetics; as tools for the preconcentration and analysis of species in solution; or even as possible substrates for hydrogen storage. This last topic is still a "hot" one in the case of carbon nanotubes, which explains why two whole chapters (besides Chapter 9) have been dedicated to this type of material. One of them (Chapter 15) addresses hydrogen adsorption from a more theoretical point of view, while the other (Chapter 16) takes a look at the actual knowledge obtained from the experimental results published in the literature and therefore
Foreword
xix
offers the reader a complementary, more practical view. Chapter 15 identifies two problems that continue to obstruct progress in research, namely, the variability of the materials being studied by different teams and the lack of reliable computational methods for determining adsorption potentials or chemisorption interactions. Chapter 16 discusses the nature of different types of adsorption sites on nanotube surfaces and concludes that further research is needed to make such sites more easily identifiable, particularly high energy binding sites. The next two chapters deal mainly with the use of adsorption to characterize porous solids. In the case of activated carbon fibers (Chapter 17), methods to characterize microporosity, and particularly ultramicroporosity, by physical adsorption are of particular relevance for understanding the behavior of these adsorbents and extending the range of their applications. Moreover, in Chapter 18 the pore structure of ordered mesoporous carbons is shown to differ greatly from that of conventional activated carbons for which most of the available data treatment methods have been developed. Therefore, suitable procedures for correctly analyzing the pore structure of these novel carbons are proposed in this chapter. Two chapters related with the solid-liquid interface conclude Part 3. The electrochemical behavior of carbons is the subject of Chapter 19, which discusses the characteristics of carbon electrode materials with reference to concepts such as roughness or fractality, and also the electrochemical kinetics on carbon electrodes. Chapter 20 deals with the application of scanning probe microscopy to the study of inorganic and organic adsorbates deposited on highly oriented pyrolytic graphite (HOPG) at the submonolayer and monolayer level. The basal plane surface of HOPG is taken as a model system, thanks to its atomic-scale smoothness and low chemical reactivity. Part 4 of the book deals with the applications of adsorption in different fields of technology with explanations as to why carbons exhibit a particular behavior. First of all, gas-phase applications are addressed, either for the removal of pollutants (both volatile organic compounds and inorganic gases, Chapter 21) or for gas separation and storage (Chapter 22). These two chapters present comprehensive summaries of the surface science involved in these important processes and provide clues for selecting the right carbons to be used as adsorbents. Another application of carbons in the field of energy is that of electrochemical energy storage. Chapter 23 discusses the two most important current lines of investigation, namely, lithium batteries and supercapacitors, and relates their performance to carbon characteristics and identifies present research needs. Finally, Chapters 24-27 deal with the environmental applications of carbons as adsorbents for the removal of pollutants from aqueous solutions. These four chapters are highly complementary. Thus, Chapter 24, which addresses the problems associated with the removal of inorganic species, finds its "alter ego" in Chapter 25, which deals with the adsorption of organic solutes from dilute aqueous solutions. Both chapters provide insights into the fundamental reasons for the performance exhibited by a carbonaceous adsorbent. The global topic of water purification using carbons as adsorbents is addressed in Chapter 26, which
xx
Foreword
deals with the science and technology involved in the removal of a surprising variety of pollutants from water employing activated carbon, either in powdered or in granular form. Finally, Chapter 27 is somewhat complementary to Chapter 25 as it discusses the sorption of viscous organics (as opposed to dilute organic solutes). However, there is a significant difference in the type of adsorbent. Indeed, the removal of viscous organics (e.g., heavy oils and biomedical molecules) requires a macroporous adsorbent (e.g., exfoliated graphite) rather than a microporous one. From the preceding overview it is easy to imagine the enormous effort required of the editors and the authors of the different chapters to bring this important piece of work to a satisfactory conclusion. I believe that this will become a reference book for any person interested in the subject of adsorption and carbons. It will be useful not only to those beginning their study of activated carbons and related materials, but also to specialists wishing to further explore this interesting field of research. New discoveries are constantly being made in this area, leading to the solution of numerous problems, both of a theoretical nature and in the applied field ofmodern science and technology. Let me convey again my congratulations to the editors and my esteem for Prof Bottani of whom I have a fond memory. Finally, may I wish Prof Tascon further success in this interesting field of research. Prof Dr. Juan de Dios Lopez-Gonzalez Granada and Madrid, Spain
PREFACE
The essential aim of this work is to fill the gap that exists between the fields of adsorption and carbon materials, an area that, to our knowledge, has not been encompassed so far in one single book. Several books address the phenomenon of adsorption from both a fundamental and an applied perspective, while publications on the structure, properties, and applications of carbons, either general or restricted to specific types of materials, are increasingly common. There are, also, a number of works devoted to porosity in carbons or other solids. However, adsorption is involved in many areas other than porosity characterization. In short, the interplay between adsorption and carbon materials has not been addressed yet in one volume. There is a vacuum of knowledge between both fields that, if filled, could give birth to new concepts and ideas. Adsorption cannot occur without the active and mutual participation of the adsorbent and adsorbate. Indeed, the book is purposely entitled "Adsorption by Carbons" (rather than, for instance, "Adsorption on Carbons") to emphasize the dynamic character of adsorption and the active participation of the carbonaceous adsorbent, which not only provides adsorption sites but also attracts adsorbates to its surface. The book consists of four parts. Part 1 which is the shortest (two chapters), introduces the reader to the field of adsorption by carbons and to the realm of carbon materials. The following eight chapters address the fundamental aspects of adsorption by carbons through such topics as adsorption energetics, computer simulations, modeling, surface heterogeneity, and so on. Indeed, this second part ofthe book develops a series ofconcepts that contribute to a better understanding of what follows in the third section, in which adsorption is mainly envisaged as a tool to characterize carbon surfaces. The third part, consisting of 10 chapters, begins with a look at the adsorption methods used to study the porous texture and surface chemistry of carbons, and then follows with chapters devoted to several novel types of materials to conclude with a discussion on certain aspects of the electrochemistry of adsorption by carbons. Finally, the fourth part (seven chapters) deals with the most significant technological applications of adsorption by carbons, either at the gas-solid or at the liquid-solid interface, which have direct implications especially for the fields of environment and energy. Overall, the ensemble of 27 chapters tries to cover the subject of adsorption by carbons as comprehensively as possible. In my view, the main strength of the book derives from the stature of the contributing authors. I have always thought that Eduardo Bottani and I were being a little overambitious (perhaps even daring?) in inviting the best specialists in the various areas to contribute chapters. Some were our friends, others were XXI
xxii
Preface
just acquaintances we had met at conferences, and there are still a few whom I still do not know personally. But all of them share one thing in common, and that is that they are leaders in their respective fields. The important thing is that we succeeded in our invitation, and I am very happy with the result of this collective effort. The book has an undeniably international flavor, as it includes authors from 13 different countries. Apart from a possibly slight imbalance in favor of the New World (USA and Argentina), the geographical distribution of the authors is fairly representative of the places where adsorption by carbons is being investigated. I will purposely avoid citing authors' names here, as this would make the preface outstandingly long. Let me simply thank all the authors collectively for having accepted the invitation to produce their chapters, for the care they have taken in preparing them, and for their continued willingness to help me. My thanks are extended to the staff of Elsevier, particularly lain Craig, Commissioning Editor, Kristi Green, Administrative Editor, and Sunita Sundararajan, Project Manager, for their very professional assistance at many stages of book's preparation. Last but not least, my warmest thanks go to Prof Dr Juan de Dios LopezGonzalez for having accepted to write a foreword to this book. Neither Eduardo Bottani nor I are direct descendants of the scientific school that originally spread from Granada University under his guidance. The international reputation that the Spanish-speaking scientific community enjoys in the field of adsorption by carbons owes much to the efforts of that school. Interestingly, the first papers that came to the attention of Eduardo and myself at the beginning of our research careers in the late 1970s were those of Professor Lopez-Gonzalez and coworkers. Thus we shared the same introductory academic experience in two such distant places as far apart as La Plata and Madrid! I refer, of course, to physical distance, since few countries are so close to each other emotionally as are Argentina and Spain. Juan M.D. Tascon
LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS
Alejandro J. Arvia Instituto de Investigaciones Fisicoquimicas Te6ricas y Aplicadas (INIFTA) Universidad Nacional de La Plata-Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Cientificas y Tecnicas La Plata, Argentina
[email protected] Teresa J. Bandosz Department of Chemistry City College of New York New York, NY, USA
[email protected] Fran~ois
Beguin Centre de Recherche sur la Matiere Divisee CNRS-U niversite Orleans Cedex, France
[email protected] Henry Bock Department of Chemical and Biomolecular Engineering North Carolina State University Raleigh, NC, USA
[email protected] Hans-Peter Boehm Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry University of Munich, Germany
[email protected] Mary J. Bojan Department of Chemistry The Pennsylvania State University University Park, PA, USA
[email protected] Agustin E. Bolzan Instituto de Investigaciones Fisicoquimicas Te6ricas y Aplicadas (INIFTA) UNLP-CIC-CONICET La Plata, Argentina
[email protected] (or)
[email protected] XX111
xxiv
List of Contributors
Eduardo J. Bottani Instituto de Investigaciones Fisicoquimicas Te6ricas y Aplicadas (INIFTA) UNLP-CIC-CONICET La Plata, Argentina M. Mercedes Calbi Department of Physics Southern Illinois University Carbondale, IL, USA
[email protected] Diego Cazorla-Amoros Departamento de Quimica Inorganica Universidad de Alicante Alicante, Spain
[email protected] Milton W. Cole Department of Physics The Pennsylvania State University University Park, PA, USA
[email protected] Hans Darmstadt Departement de genie chimique Universite Laval Quebec, Canada
[email protected] Renaud Denoyel MADIREL, CNRS-Universite de Provence Marseille, France
[email protected] DuongD. Do School of Engineering University of Queensland St Lucia, Qld, Australia
[email protected] HaD. Do School of Engineering University of Queensland St Lucia, Qld, Australia
[email protected]
List of Contributors
Catherine Faur-Brasquet Ecole des Mines de Nantes Nantes cedex, France
[email protected] Elzbieta Frackowiak Institute of Chemistry and Technical Electrochemistry Poznan University of Technology Poznan, Poland fracko@fct. put.poznan.pI Silvina M. Gatica Department of Physics The Pennsylvania State University University Park, PA, USA
[email protected] Keith E. Gubbins Department of Chemical and Biomolecular Engineering North Carolina State University Raleigh, NC, USA
[email protected] Michio Inagaki Faculty of Engineering Aichi Institute of Technology Yakusa, Toyota, Japan
[email protected] Norio Iwashita National Institute of Advanced Industrial Science and Technology Onogawa, Tsukuba, Japan
[email protected] Timur S. Jakubov Department of Applied Chemistry Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology Melbourne, Australia
[email protected] J. Karl Johnson Department of Chemical and Petroleum Engineering University of Pittsburgh Pittsburgh, PA, USA National Energy Technology Laboratory Pittsburgh, PA, USA
[email protected]
xxv
xxvi
List of Contributors
Feiyu Kang Department of Materials Science and Engineering Tsinghua University Beijing, China
[email protected] Pierre Le Cloirec Ecole des Mines de Nantes Nantes cedex, France
[email protected] Angel Linares-Solano Departamento de Quimica Inorganica Universidad de Alicante Alicante, Spain
[email protected] Amelia Martinez-Alonso Instituto Nacional del Carbon, CSIC Oviedo, Spain amelia@incar. csic. es Aldo D. Migone Department of Physics Southern Illinois University Carbondale, IL, USA
[email protected] Carlos Moreno-Castilla Departamento de Quirnica Inorganica Facultad de Ciencias Universidad de Granada Granada, Spain
[email protected] Gayle Newcombe Cooperative Research Centre for Water Quality and Treatment Salisbury, South Australia Australia
[email protected] James P. Olivier Micromeritics Instrument Corp., Inc. Norcross, GA, USA
[email protected]
List of Contributors
xxvii
Jorge Pikunic Department of Chemical and Biomolecular Engineering North Carolina State University Raleigh, NC, USA
[email protected] Antonio J. Ramirez-Pastor Laboratorio de Ciencias de Superficies y Medios Porosos Universidad Nacional de San Luis, CONICET San Luis, Argentina
[email protected] Jose L. Riccardo Laboratorio de Ciencias de Superficies y Medios Porosos Uniyersidad Nacional de San Luis, CONICET San Luis, Argentina
[email protected] Franfoise Rouquerol MADIREL, CNRS-Universite de Provence Marseille, France
[email protected] Jean Rouquerol MADIREL, CNRS-Universite de Provence Marseille, France
[email protected] Ryong Ryoo National Creative Research Initiative Center for Functional Nanomaterials and Department of Chemistry (School ofMolecular Science BK21, Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology Daejeon, Korea
[email protected] (or)
[email protected] Roberto C. Salvarezza Instituto de Investigaciones Fisicoquimicas Te6ricas y Aplicadas (INIFTA) La Plata, Argentina
[email protected] Kenneth S.W. Sing BruneI University Uxbridge, UK
[email protected]
xxviii
List of Contributors
Shivaji Sircar Department of Chemical Engineering Lehigh University Bethlehem, PA, USA
[email protected],
[email protected] William A. Steele Department of Chemistry The Pennsylvania State University University Park, PA, USA
[email protected] Fabian Suarez-Garcia Instituto Nacional del Carbon, CSIC Oviedo, Spain
[email protected] Juan M.D. Tascon Instituto Nacional del Carbon, CSIC Oviedo, Spain
[email protected] Fernando Teran Arce Instituto de Investigaciones Fisicoquimicas Teoricas y Aplicadas (INIFTA) Universidad Nacional de La Plata-Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Cientificas y Tecnicas La Plata, Argentina
[email protected] Masahiro Toyoda Faculty of Engineering Oita University Oita, Japan
[email protected] Eugene A. Ustinov School of Engineering University of Queensland St Lucia, Qld, Australia
[email protected] Maria E. Vela Instituto de Investigaciones Fisicoquimicas Teoricas y Aplicadas (INIFTA) Universidad Nacional de La Plata-Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Cientificas y T ecnicas La Plata, Argentina
[email protected]
List of Contributors
Giorgio Zgrablich Laboratorio de Ciencias de Superficies y Medios Porosos Universidad Nacional de San Luis CONICET, San Luis, Argentina Departamento de Quimica Universidad Aut6noma Metropolitana-Iztapalapa Mexico D.F., Mexico
[email protected]
Jose L. Zubimendi Instituto de Investigaciones Fisicoquimicas Te6ricas y Aplicadas (INIFTA) Universidad Nacional de La Plata-Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Cientificas y Tecnicas La Plata, Argentina
xxix
OVERVIEW OF PHYSICAL ADSORPTION BY CARBONS Kenneth S.W. Sing Brunei University, Uxbridge, UK
Contents Introduction Physisorption on Nonporous Carbons 1.3 Physisorption by Porous Carbons 1.4 Concluding Remarks References
1.1
1.2
3 5 7 11 12
1.1 INTRODUCTION Physical adsorption (physisorption) phenomena were already well-known in the early years of the twentieth century, when various attempts were made to explain the underlying principles [1]. Some investigators followed Polanyi [2] in picturing the adsorbed state (the adsorbate) as a thick multimolecular film under the influence oflong-range forces emanating from the surface. Others were more strongly influenced by the monumental work of Langmuir [3] and considered that the adsorbate was normally in the form of a monolayer. A third approach, which was based on the application of the Kelvin equation, drew attention to the role of capillary condensation [4, 5]. The interest in physisorption was further strengthened in 1938 by the publication of the Brunauer-Emmett-Teller (BET) theory ofmultilayer adsorption [5, 6]. Over the past 50 years the BET theoretical model has been subjected to a considerable amount of criticism [7], but the BET method has remained the most popular procedure for determining the surface area ofadsorbents, catalysts, and various other porous and finely divided materials. Adsorption by Carbons
ISBN: 978-0-08-044464-2
© 2008 Elsevier Ltd.
All rights reserved.
3
4
Chapter 1 Overview of Physical Adsorption by Carbons
Langmuir had mentioned in his 1916 paper [3] that it was inconceivable that a well-defined monolayer could be formed in very narrow, molecular-sized pores of an activated carbon, but it was left to Dubinin [8, 9] to introduce the concept of "micropore filling." In his original theory of volume filling, Dubinin [8] adapted Polanyi's concept of the adsorption potential expressed as a temperatureinvariant characteristic curve. It was subsequently realized [7, 10, 11] that a physisorption isotherm of the typical "Langmuir" shape (now referred to as a Type I isotherm [10]), is generally associated with micropore filling and not monolayer coverage. It is also generally accepted that micropore filling is dependent on the overlap of adsorption forces [7] and should not be regarded as a form of capillary condensation since it does not involve the formation of a meniscus. Three groups of pores of different width, w, were defined by Dubinin [9]. The classification, which was adopted in a revised form by the IUPAC [10], is as follows: in micropores w<1"'V2 nm; in mesopores W 1"'V2-50 nm; in macropores W >1"'V50 nm. It also expedient [11] to subdivide the micropores into ultramicropores (w <1"'V1 nm) and supermicropores (w 1"'V1-2 nm). However, all these dimensions are somewhat arbitrary and imprecise because the stages of pore filling are dependent on the gas-solid system as well as the pore geometry [11]. Similarly, there is no precise definition of the currently popular term "nanopore," which is often applied to a pore in the supermicropore or narrow mesopore range. Highly porous carbons can be produced from a variety of natural and synthetic precursors [11, 12]. Relatively inexpensive activated carbons are useful adsorbents, but generally their surface and pore structures are exceedingly complex [11, 13]. However, it is now possible to prepare a number of more uniform carbonaceous adsorbents. For example, molecular sieve carbons (MSCs) are available with narrow distributions of ultramicropores, which exhibit welldefined molecular selectivity [11], and carbon nanotubes, aerogels, and membranes are also amongst the most interesting advanced materials for research and development [12, 14]. Carbon blacks with specific surface areas of up to 100 m 2 / g can be regarded as essentially nonporous [15] since they give reversible Type II isotherms in the IUPAC classification [10]. Early physisorption measurements on carbon blacks [1] were designed to test the validity of surface areas determined the BET method [6]. Carbon blacks were considered [5] to be especially suitable for this purpose because the discrete nature of their spheroidal particles allowed electron microscopy to be used for the evaluation of the particle size distribution. Certain well-characterized carbon blacks are still extremely useful as reference adsorbents [11, 16]. In its original state, the surface of a carbon black is energetically heterogeneous [15], but as discovered by Beebe et al. [17] the heterogeneity is considerably reduced by heat treatment in an inert atmosphere. As a result of this form of "graphitization," adsorption isotherms of the noble gases and lower hydrocarbons are transformed from Type II to Type VI in the IUPAC classification [10] - the latter having stepwise multilayer character [7, 11, 18]. By studying the energetics of adsorption of many polar and nonpolar molecules on highly I"'V
1.2
Physisorption on Nonporous Carbons
5
graphitized carbon blacks, Kiselev and his coworkers were able to confirm [19] that the gas-carbon interactions were essentially nonspecific (i.e., insensitive to the polar nature of the adsorptive molecule). In contrast, polar molecules (dipolar or quadrupolar) were found to undergo pronounced specific interactions with exposed hydroxyls or cationic sites on the surface of oxides and zeolites. In recent years various new experimental techniques and computerized procedures have become available for the determination and analysis of physisorption data. It is perhaps all the more surprising that some widely used methods are still based on old and over-simplified principles. This short overview is not intended to provide a critical survey of current research on gas adsorption by carbons and indeed the recent advances in research and development are amply described in the following chapters of this book. However, it is pertinent in this introductory overview to draw attention to some of the major obstacles, which have restricted progress and which now offer the opportunity for further research. The distinctive features of gas/carbon physisorption systems are also briefly compared with the adsorptive behavior of oxides and zeolites.
1.2 PHYSISORPTION ON NONPOROUS CARBONS As already indicated, a well-defined stepwise (Type VI) isotherm is obtained when a noble gas or lower hydrocarbon is adsorbed on a basal graphitic surface at an appropriate temperature [7, 11]. The regular steps can extend up to four or five molecular layers, but become less sharp with increased distance from the adsorbent surface. An increase in temperature also produces a progressive blurring of the layer-by-layer adsorption [7]. The appearance of such regular multilayer steps in isotherms on uniform surfaces supports the view that (a) the influence of the surface structure can extend well beyond the first adsorbed layer and (b) the multilayer steps are associated with a form oflocalized physisorption. Exfoliated graphite and graphitized carbon black are especially useful for studying monolayer structures and phase changes in the subrnonolayer region of physisorption isotherms [11, 18]. Small discontinuities may be due to a bimodal distribution of surface sites [18] or other abnormal effects [11], but on a uniform surface such substeps are associated with two-dimensional (2-D) phase changes [11]. These 2-D transitions on graphite can be clearly revealed and characterized by means ofadsorption energy [20] or heat capacity [21] measurements. There is no sign of any stepwise character in the reversible Type II isotherms of argon, krypton, and the lower hydrocarbons on ungraphitized carbons [11]. Similar Type II isotherms are also given by the adsorption of these nonpolar gases on most inorganic oxides - an exception being methane on the (100) face of MgO [11]. These results are of course consistent with the heterogeneous nature of ungraphitized carbon and oxide surfaces. Turning now to nitrogen adsorption at 77 K, we find that ungraphitized carbons, oxides and other nonporous adsorbents all give typical Type II isotherms 11
6
Chapter
1
Overview of Physical Adsorption by Carbons
and when they are normalized (or reduced to unit area) these isotherms are almost identical over a wide range of pipO. On the surface ofgraphitized carbons, however, nitrogen isotherms at 77 K are of "hybrid" shape. In the multilayer range above plpo rv 0.5 they have the characteristic Type II shape, but at lower plpo they are stepwise (a fairly sharp first layer step and a wavy second layer step). The fact that at 77 K the path of the nitrogen multilayer isotherm is rather insensitive to change in the adsorbent structure is of some practical importance. It is one reason why nitrogen adsorption is used for the assessment of the surface area and pore size distribution [7, 11]. When physisorption occurs on the heterogeneous surface of an ungraphitized carbon or an oxide, an increase in surface coverage is normally accompanied by a progressive decrease in the differential energy of adsorption [11, 21]. On the graphitized surface any initial decrease in adsorption energy is restricted to a region of very low surface coverage and thereafter the differential energy either remains almost constant or increases to a maximum at high surface coverage. In this respect, there is an interesting difference between the behavior of n-hexane and benzene [11]. In the case of hexane, the marked increase in adsorption energy is the result of fairly strong lateral interactions between the adsorbed molecules, whereas the almost constant adsorption energy given by benzene appears to indicate very little adsorbate-adsorbate interaction over a wide range of surface coverage [11, 21, 22]. Interpretation of the variation of differential adsorption energy with surface coverage may not always be straightforward. For example, a strong adsorbentadsorbate interaction may allow some compression of the monolayer resulting in repulsion rather than attraction between neighboring molecules [23]. Also, the almost constant differential adsorption energy may be due to compensation between the effect of surface heterogeneity and the attractive adsorbateadsorbate interactions [24]. In the case of adsorption on a uniform surface, Henry's law is to be expected at low surface coverage [11,22]. Unless the operational temperature is relatively high, the Henry's law region is normally restricted to a very small part of the isotherm (e.g., below plpo rvl x 10-4 ) and the deviations may be in either direction. From a fundamental standpoint, the virial analysis of low-coverage adsorption data is important since it is analogous to the treatment of imperfect gases and nonideal solutions [22]. Many different equations have been used to interpret monolayer-multilayer isotherms [7, 11, 18, 21, 22] (e.g., the equations associated with the names: Langmuir, Volmer, Hill-de Boer, Fowler-Guggenheim, Brunauer-EmmettTeller, and Frenkel-Halsey-Hill). Although these relations were originally based on adsorption models, they are generally applied to the experimental data in an empirical manner and they all have limitations of one sort or another [7, 10, 11]. The multilayer Frenkel-Halsey-Hill (FHH) equation is usually expressed in the following form: log
pO) k ( -p =n-r
(1.1)
1.3 Physisorption by Porous Carbons
7
where n is the amount adsorbed at the relative pressure pj pO and k and rare empirical constants [7, 22]. The FHH plots of log [log (p jpO)] vs log n are generally linear over a wide multilayer range (e.g., pjp°1'"'...l0.4-0.9). A characteristic value of r is obtained from the slope of the FHH plot. In the case of nitrogen adsorption at 77 K on nonporous carbons and silicas, the derived values of r are generally remarkably constant (r = 2.70), which confirms the almost "universal" character of the nitrogen multilayer [11]. Linear FHH multilayer plots are also given by other adsorptives such as butane, neopentane, methanol, dichloromethane, and benzene, but the corresponding values of r appear to be somewhat more variable [11, 25-28]. Recent fundamental studies of physisorption by nonporous carbons have involved the application of molecular simulation [23, 29], density functional theory, and lattice gas models [30]. Important aspects studied have included the way in which the molecular packing in each layer is likely to be affected by a systematic alteration of the lattice parameters and interaction energies and the resulting changes in the isotherm shape [21, 30].
1.3
PHYSISORPTION BY POROUS CARBONS
Activated carbons having BET areas well in excess of 1000 m 2 / g can easily be prepared by the carbonization and activation of a variety of precursors [11, 12]. By the carefully controlled carbonization and activation of uniform precursors (e.g., viscose rayon) under conditions of low burnoffit is possible to obtain ultramicroporous carbons having molecular sieve properties and giving high-affinity, reversible Type I isotherms [11] (designated Type la) with no detectable supermicroporosity or mesoporosity. Many activated carbons have complex nanoporous structures as revealed by the composite nature of their physisorption isotherms [11]. For example, hysteresis loops of Type H4 in the IUPAC classification [10] are usually obtained after extensive burnoff More uniform nanoporous and mesoporous carbons can be produced, however, by the application of special pretreatment and activation procedures [11, 12]. Certain carbon aerogels also give well-defined Type IV isotherms [14]. As already indicated, much of the pioneering work on micropore filling was carried out by Dubinin [8, 9]. The first version of the temperature-invariant "characteristic curve" for micropore filling was expressed in the exponential form (1.2)
where np is the micropore capacity, A is the "adsorption affinity," and E is a characteristic energy for the given system. From Eqn (1.2), we can easily
8
Chapter
1
Overview of Physical Adsorption by Carbons
arrive [7] at the well-known Dubinin-Radushkevich (DR) equation in its usual linear form
log(n)
= log (n
p) -
Dlog
2
(~)
(1.3)
where the constant D is related to E. Thus, the plot of log (n) against lo~ (po Ip) should be linear with slope D and intercept log (n p ). To obtain vp (the micropore volume) from np ' it is necessary to assume that the density of the adsorbate is the same as that of the liquid adsorptive at the operational temperature [11]. Ultramicroporous carbons generally give linear DR plots [7, 11] over wide ranges of pipO, but the extent of the linear region is much more restricted with most nanoporous carbons [11]. Also, DR plots on many nonporous and mesoporous carbons exhibit similar ranges of linearity [7]. Since D, E, and np are all empirical parameters, their significance is questionable. In consequence, it must be emphasized that the simple DR plot cannot always give a true assessment of the effective micropore volume [11]. The Dubinin-Astakhov (DA) equation, which was proposed as a more general characteristic curve equation [9], can be conveniently expressed in the form
.!!..- = exp np
[_(~) N] 13 Eo
(1.4)
where N is another empirical constant and E is replaced by f3E o (13 being a scaling factor). A limited amount of experimental evidence appears to confirm an inverse relation between Eo and the pore width, w, and also between Nand the extent of the pore size distribution (the extreme value of N = 3 being given by an ultramicroporous carbon molecular sieve). A complementary approach introduced by Stoeckli and his coworkers [31, 32] was based on the notion that the simple DR equation is invalid if the microporosity is heterogeneous. It was argued that the overall isotherm can be regarded as the sum of the DR isotherms corresponding to individual groups of micropores and that for a continuous distribution ofpore size the summation can be replaced by integration. A Gaussian pore size distribution was assumed and the integral transform was solved by the use of a mathematical device equivalent to an "error function." The mathematical elegance of Stoeckli's contribution is impressive, but it must be kept in mind that it does not allow for the effects of surface heterogeneity or changes in the various molecular interactions in controlling the different stages of pore filling [11]. In addition to the well-known monolayer equations already referred to (e.g., the Langmuir, Hill-de Boer and virial equations), there are others such as those associated with the names of Freundlich, Sips, and Toth, which have been applied to physisorption isotherms on microporous solids [11]. These relatively simple, empirical equations are useful for the interpolation and extrapolation of chemical engineering data, but they are not capable of throwing any new light
1.3 Physisorption by Porous Carbons
9
on the mechanisms of surface coverage or pore filling. As pointed out by various authors [7, 11, 18], the range of fit of a particular equation is not enough by itself to confirm the validity of the underlying theory. It follows that all derived quantities such as surface area and pore size require critical appraisal before their physical validity can be accepted [7, 10, 11]. Considerable interest has been shown in recent years in the presentation of physisorption isotherms in a generalized integral form. This kind of generalized treatment was first applied to the submonolayer region [21], but much of the current interest is centered on the analysis ofmicropore filling isotherms [33, 34]. In principle, the approach provides a means of constructing model isotherms by systematically combining hypothetical "local" isotherms and energy distribution functions. Thus, the generalized expression for the overall adsorption, n(p) can be written in the integral form
n(p) = no
f n*(p, E)f(E)dE
(1.5)
where no represents either the monolayer capacity or the micropore capacity, n*(p, E) is the local isotherm corresponding to the adsorption energy E, and f(E) is the distribution function for the adsorption energy. Although Eqn (1.4) can be derived from Eqn (1.5), it is not possible to arrive at an unambiguous interpretation of the energy distribution function without additional information since f (E) may be associated with surface heterogeneity and/or a micropore size distribution. Thus, for the filling of micropores an equivalent generalized expressIon IS
n(p)
= np
f n*(p, w)f(w)dw
(1.6)
where f (w) is now the micropore size distribution. Various empirical procedures, which can be used for the analysis ofphysisorption isotherms, are based on the comparison with standard adsorption data obtained on nonporous reference materials [7, 11]. These procedures have the advantage that they do not depend on any a priori assumptions concerning the mechanisms of adsorption or pore filling. The standard isotherm on the chemically similar reference adsorbent is plotted either as a multilayer thickness curve of t vs pipO or preferably in the reduced form of as vs pipO. The dimensionless quantity as is defined as nlns ' ns being the amount adsorbed at a preselected plpo (usually 0.4). The as plot is constructed by plotting n for the given nanoporous adsorbent against the corresponding as for the nonporous reference. Deviations from linearity can be attributed to the various stages of micropore or mesopore filling and, if certain conditions are satisfied, it is possible to derive approximate values of internal and external areas and ultramicropore and supermicropore volumes [11]. By analyzing the as plots of many adsorptives on various nanoporous carbons, Sing and his coworkers have obtained a considerable amount of experimental evidence [11, 35] to support the view [35] that the mechanisms of micropore filling are to a large extent dependent on the ratio of pore size:molecular
10
Chapter
1
Overview of Physical Adsorption by Carbons
diameter. If the pore width is no more than about two molecular diameters (i.e., if w<"'-'2o-) there is a significant overlap of adsorbent-adsorbate interactions [35,36] and the ultramicropores are filled at very low plpo. This has been termed [7, 35] "primary micropore filling" and is manifested in a pronounced distortion of the initial part of the isotherm [37] - and the corresponding as plot. The wider micropores (supermicropores) are filled over a range of higher plpo by a cooperative process [11, 35], after monolayer adsorption has taken place on the pore walls, but before the onset of capillary condensation [7]. Two major problems are encountered in the classical interpretation ofthe capillary condensation range ofa physisorption isotherm. The first is concerned with the validity of the Kelvin equation and the second with the existence of adsorption hysteresis. It is generally accepted that the Kelvin equation breaks down completely below a certain pipO when the condensate loses its stability [7, 11]. In addition to this complete failure of the Kelvin equation, it now seems likely [11, 14, 38] that the effective values of surface tension and molar volume require progressive adjustment as the pore width is reduced below, say, 10 nm. The presence of adsorption hysteresis cannot be reconciled with the laws of classical thermodynamics. It is evident that there are various forms of adsorption hysteresis [7], which require different explanations [7, 39, 40]. In the capillary condensation range, well-defined hysteresis loops are generally associated with delayed condensation or percolation [11] through pore networks or "ink bottles" [38, 39]. In the case of activated carbons, delayed condensation is likely to be the most important mechanism [11], but we cannot rule out the other effects. The computational procedures now used in the application of density functional theory and molecular simulation for the prediction and analysis of physisorption isotherms are based on the statistical mechanics of confined fluids [14]. These important advances are described in several chapters of this book and therefore the present introductory remarks are confined to a few general comments. Whichever computational procedure is adopted [39, 40], it is first necessary to define a 3-D model of the pore structure within a solid of known and uniform composition [14]. It has been customary to assume that the pores of different width are all of the same shape (e.g., slits in activated carbons). Further assumptions made by many investigators are that the filling or emptying of each group of pores can occur independently and reversibly, that the internal surface is uniform and that the solid-fluid and fluid-fluid interactions can be expressed in terms of standard potential functions [14]. The Monte Carlo method is generally considered [14, 39] to be the most convenient means of using computer simulation to generate adsorption equilibrium data by application of the Boltzmann distribution law in order to accept or reject the random movements of large numbers of molecules. Although the thermodynamic parameters may be readily changed, grand canonical Monte Carlo (GCMC) molecular simulation is usually preferred with the chemical potential being taken as the independent variable. Because of the present availability of commercial software, the nonlocal version of density functional theory (i.e., NLDFT) is now widely used for pore
1.4 Concluding Remarks
11
size analysis. With the aid ofNLDFT, it has been possible to generate a series of "individual pore isotherms" for nitrogen adsorption at 77 K on a wide range of graphitic slit-shaped pores [14, 34]. The NLDFT-derived isotherms have been found to be in excellent agreement with results obtained by GCMC simulation and also in broad agreement with the corresponding experimental data [14, 40]. The NLDFT calculations have shown inter alia the effects produced by changing the operational temperatures and the dimensions of the probe molecules. For example, although the molecular dimensions of nitrogen and carbon dioxide are similar, their adsorptive behavior was shown [40] to depend on the difference in operational temperatures (e.g., 77 K for nitrogen and 273 K for carbon dioxide). Indeed, this difference had already been successfully exploited by RodriguezReinoso and his coworkers [41] by using carbon dioxide at 273 K for probing the very narrow pores (of w "'-'0.35 nm) in activated carbons. The highly distinctive character of the adsorption of water vapor by porous carbons has long been of great interest [5, 7]. Some microporous carbons give well-defined Type V water isotherms, the steep riser often being associated with a fairly narrow hysteresis loop. The low affinity of the carbon surface for water is evidently due to the small number of hydrophilic sites and the relatively weak nonspecific interactions [11] (dispersion forces). However, the initial uptake of water at low p/ pO can be increased by surface oxidation, which leads to the formation of additional hydrophilic sites and the appearance of a small knee [7] (i.e., a change in isotherm shape from Type V to Type IV). The clustering of hydrogen-bonded water molecules finally leads to complete pore filling of narrow slit-shaped pores [33,42]. This is in contrast to the hydrophobic behavior of Silicalite [11, 42], which has an interconnected tubular pore structure. Thus, thin layers of hydrogen-bonded water molecules can be accommodated in slitshaped pores of "'-'0.5 nm, but this is not possible in tubular pores of similar width because it would involve too much distortion of the hydrogen-bonded water structure [42, 43].
1.4
CONCLUDING REMARKS
As already indicated, there are two related obstacles have impeded progress in the vast amount of research on the physisorption of gases by porous carbons. First, we have to contend with the complexity of the surface and pore structure ofmost carbon adsorbents; and secondly, we have to face the difficulties involved in the interpretation of physisorption isotherms. The simplest structural model for a microporous carbon is the slit-pore model, in which each pore is in the form of a parallel-sided and rigid graphitic slit. It is also assumed that the filling and emptying processes are not dependent on the spatial arrangement of the pores. It therefore follows that for a given gas/carbon system and temperature, the notional thermodynamic state of the adsorbate (e.g., its chemical potential and enthalpy) is solely dependent on the distribution of
Chapter
12
1
Overview of Physical Adsorption by Carbons
slit width. Obviously, this simple model cannot account for nonequilibrium effects such as delayed condensation or network percolation or for any significant variation of pore shape. Although the slit-pore model is still popular, it is evident [43, 44] that considerable refinement of the model is now possible. For example, allowance can be made for nonuniformity of the internal surface in the form of pit defects and corrugated layers [44]. Also included in the more sophisticated models [44] are randomly etched graphite surfaces and different assemblages of microcrystals of graphite or graphene platelets. By the statistical modeling of the topological features of pore networks [45] and the application of fractal analysis [46], it is also possible to identify various short-range patterns and different degrees of structural disorder. The rapid developments now taking place in the computer modeling of pore networks are of considerable interest to both theoreticians and experimentalists. We can expect further progress in this direction, but as pointed out by Levitz [45] it must be kept in mind that a particular statistical model may not be a unique representation of the real material. It is therefore equally important to extend the present limited range of well-characterized ordered and partially disordered carbons. The development of user-friendly equipment has facilitated the use of gas adsorption alongside other techniques for the characterization of highly active carbons of all types. In the near future, the limitations of the most popular procedures for the analysis of physisorption isotherms and the derivation of surface areas and pore size distributions (e.g., by the BET, DR, and Barrett-JoinerHalenda (BJH) methods) will inevitably remain a serious handicap. However, it should be kept in mind that it is always useful to closely examine the isotherm shape and apply an empirical method of analysis [11]. There is no immediate prospect of finding any suitable alternative to nitrogen for routine physisorption measurements, but in future nitrogen adsorption at 77 K should be regarded as only the first stage in the characterization of porous carbons. The next stage will depend on the nature of the carbon and its application (e.g., for gas storage or separation, water treatment, respiratory protection or catalysis). This is likely to involve equilibrium and dynamic adsorption measurements with selected probe molecules of different size, shape, and molecular structure. We can also anticipate an increased need for chemical engineering data, which will necessitate multicomponent adsorption measurements at high and low pressures.
REFERENCES 1. Deitz, V.R. (1944). Bibliography of Solid Adsorbents. National Bureau of Standards. 2. Polanyi, M. (1916). Adsorption of gases by a solid non-volatile adsorbent. Verb. Deut. Physik. Ges., 18, 55-80. 3. Langmuir, I. (1916). Constitution and fundamental properties of solids and liquids. I. Solids. J. Am. Chern. Soc., 38, 2221-95.
References
13
4. Foster, A.G. (1932). Sorption of condensable vapors by porous solids. I. Applicability of the capillary theory. Trans. Faraday Soc., 28, 645-57. 5. Brunauer, S. (1944). The Adsorption of Gases and Vapors. Oxford University Press. 6. Brunauer, S., Emmett, P.H., and Teller, E. (1938). Adsorption of gases in multimolecular layers.]. Am. Chern. Soc., 60, 309-19. 7. Gregg, S.J. and Sing, K.S.W. (1982). Adsorption, Suiface Area and Porosity. Academic. 8. Dubinin, M.M. (1955). A study of the porous structure of active carbons using a variety of methods. Q. Rev. Chern. Soc., 9, 101-14. 9. Dubinin, M.M. (1966). Porous structure and adsorption properties of active carbons. In Chemistry and Physics of Carbon (P.L. Walker, ed.). Marcel Dekker, pp. 51-119. 10. Sing, K.S.W., Everett, D.H., Haul, R.A.W., et al. (1985). Reporting physisorption data for gas/solid systems. Pure Appl. Chern., 57, 603-19. 11. Rouquerol, F., Rouquerol, ]., and Sing, K. (1999). Adsorption by Powders and Porous Solids. Academic. 12. Rodriguez-Reinoso, F. (2002). Production and applications of activated carbons. In Handbook of Porous Solids (F. Schuth, K.S.W. Sing and ]. Weitkamp, eds). Wiley/VCH, pp. 1766-827. 13. McEnaney, B. (2002). Properties of activated carbons. In Handbook of Porous Solids (F. Schuth, K.S.W. Sing, and]. Weitkamp, eds). Wiley/VCH, pp. 1828-63. 14. Pikunic, ]., Lastoskie, C.M., and Gubbins, K.E. Molecular modeling of adsorption from the gas phase. In Handbook of Porous Solids (F. Schuth, K.S.W. Sing, and ]. Weitkamp, eds). Wiley/VCH, pp. 182-236. 15. Sing, K.S.W. (1994). Physisorption of gases by carbon blacks. Carbon, 32,1311-7. 16. Badalyan, A. and Pendleton, P. (2003). Analysis of uncertainties in manometric gas adsorption measurements. Langmuir, 19, 7919-28. 17. Beebe, R.A., Biscoe,]., Smith, W.R., and Wendell, C.B. (1947). Heats ofadsorption on carbon black.]. Am. Chern. Soc., 69, 95-101. 18. Young, D.M. and Crowell, A.D. (1962). Physical Adsorption of Gases. Butterworths. 19. Kiselev, A.V. (1965). Non-specific and specific interactions ofmolecules ofdifferent electronic structures with solid surfaces. Disc. Faraday Soc., 40, 205-18. 20. Rouquerol,]., Rouquerol, F., and Grillet, Y. (1989). Energetical aspects ofnitrogen and argon adsorption. Pure Appl. Chern., 61, 1933-36. 21. Rudzinski, W. and Everett, D.H. (1992). Adsorption of Gases on Heterogeneous Suifaces. Academic. 22. Steele, W.A. (1974). The Interaction of Gases with Solid Surfaces. Pergamon. 23. Aronovich, G.L. and Donohue, M.D. (2001). Surface compression in adsorption systems. Colloids Surf. A, 187, 95-108. 24. Vernov, A. and Steele, W.A. (1993). Computer simulations ofbenzene adsorbed on graphite. In Fundamentals ofAdsorption IV (M. Suzuki, ed.). Kodansha, pp. 695-701. 25. Carrott, P.J.M., Ribeiro Carrott, M.M.L., Cansado, I.P.P., and Nabais, ].M.V. (2000). Reference data for the adsorption of benzene on carbon materials. Carbon, 38,465-74. 26. Carrott, P.J.M., Ribeiro Carrott, M.M.L., and Cansado, I.P.P. (2001). Reference data for the adsorption of methanol on carbon materials. Carbon, 39, 193-200. 27. Carrott, P.J.M., Ribeiro Carrott, M.M.L., and Cansado, I.P.P. (2001). Reference data for the adsorption ofdichloromethane on carbon materials. Carbon, 39, 465-72. 28. Carrott, P.J.M. and Sing, K.S.W. (1989). Multilayer adsorption of nitrogen and alkanes by non-porous carbons and silicas. Pure Appl. Chern., 61, 1836-40.
14
Chapter 1 Overview of Physical Adsorption by Carbons
29. Sweatman, M.B. and Quirke, N. (2001). Characterization of porous materials by gas adsorption: comparison of nitrogen at 77 K and carbon dioxide at 298 K on activated carbon. Langmuir, 17, 5011-20. 30. Do, D.D. and Do, H.D. (2002). Analysis of adsorption data of graphitized thermal black with DFT-lattice gas theory. Adsorption, 8, 309-24. 31. Stoeckli, H.F., Houriet,J.P., Perret, A., and Huber, U. (1979). The adsorption of simple gases by strongly activated carbons in relation to heterogeneity. In Characterization of Porous Solids (S.J. Gregg, K.S.W. Sing, and H.F. Stoeckli, eds). Society of Chemical Industry, pp. 31-9. 32. Stoeckli, H.F. Characterization of microporous ca~bons by adsorption and immersion techniques. In Porosity in Carbons O.W. Patrick, ed.). Edward Arnold, pp.67-92. 33. Jorge, M. and Seaton, N.A. (2002). Characterization of the surface chemistry of activated carbon by molecular simulation of water adsorption. In Characterization of Porous Solids VI (F. Rodriguez-Reinoso, B. McEnaney, J. Rouquerol, and K. Unger, eds). Elsevier, pp. 131-8. 34. Sweatman, M.B. and Quirke, N. (2001). Modeling gas adsorption in slit-pores using Monte-Carlo simulation. Mol. Simul., 27, 295-321. 35. Carrott, P.J.M. and Sing, K.S.W. (1988). Assessment of microporosity. In Characterization of Porous Solids I (K.K. Unger, J. Rouquerol, K.S.W. Sing, and H. Kral, eds). Elsevier, pp. 77-100. 36. Everett, D.H. and Powl, J.C. (1976). Adsorption in slit-like and cylindrical micropores in the Henry's law region. J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. I, 72, 619-36. 37. Kenny, M., Sing, K.S.W., and Theocharis, C. (1993). The use of high-resolution adsorption measurements for the study ofporous solids. In Fundamentals ofAdsorption IV (M. Suzuki, ed.). Kodansha, pp. 323-32. 38. Ravikovitch, P.1. and Neimark, A.V. (2002). Density functional theory of adsorption in spherical cavities. Langmuir, 18, 1550-60. 39. Vishnyakov, A. and Neimark, A.V. (2003). Monte Carlo simulation test of pore blocking effects. Langmuir, 19, 3240-7. 40. Neimark, A.V. and Ravikovitch, P.I. (2000). Density functional theory of adsorption hysteresis and nanopore characterization. In Characterization of Porous Solids V (K.K. Unger, G. Kreysa, and J.P. Baselt, eds). Elsevier, pp. 51-60. 41. Rodriguez-Reinoso, F., Garrido, J., Martin-Martinez, J.M., et al. (1989). The combined use of different approaches in the characterization of microporous carbons. Carbon, 27, 23-32. 42. Carrott, P.J.M., Kenny, M.B., Roberts, R.A., et al. (1991). The adsorption ofwater vapor by microporous solids. In Characterization of Porous Solids II (F. RodriguezReinoso, J. Rouquerol, K.S.W. Sing, and K.K. Unger, eds). Elsevier, pp. 685-92. 43. Kaneko, K. (2000). Specific intermolecular structures of gases confined in carbon nanospace. Carbon, 38, 287-303. 44. Bandosz, T.J., Biggs, M.J., Gubbins, K.E., et al. (2003). Molecular models of porous carbons. In Chemistry and Physics of Carbons, Vol. 28 (L.R. Radovic, ed.). Marcel Dekker, pp. 41-228. 45. Levitz, P.E. (2002). Statistical modeling of pore networks. In Handbook of Porous Solids (F. Schuth, K.S.W. Sing, andJ. Weitkamp, eds). Wiley/VCH, pp. 37-80. 46. Neimark, A.V. (2002) Fractal analysis. In Handbook of Porous Solids (F. Schuth, K.S.W. Sing, andJ. Weitkamp, eds). Wiley/VCH, pp. 81-105.
OVERVIEW OF CARBON MATERIALS IN RELATION TO ADSORPTION Juan M.D. Tasc6n Instituto Nacional del Carbon, CSIC, Oviedo, Spain
Contents Introduction Structures of Elemental Carbon: Carbon Allotropes and Polytypes 2.3 The Sp2 Carbon Forms: Graphitic, Graphitizable, and Nongraphitizable Carbons 2.4 Structural Characterization of Carbon Materials: The Basic Structural Units and Their Stacking and Orientation Degrees 2.5 Conclusions Acknowledgments References 2.1
15
2.2
17 21
24 42 43 43
2.1 INTRODUCTION The importance of adsorption for different carbon materials and, conversely, the contribution of each type of carbon to the field of adsorption is very different. This reflects the wide variability in properties of solid carbons [1, 2], which makes their surface properties important in very different fields and for different reasons. Thus, graphite, due to its relatively simple structure, has often been used as a model material to simulate the adsorption of different molecules on its surface, or to carry out adsorption measurements on a well-controlled surface. Likewise, carbon blacks, particularly those thermally treated ("graphitized"), have often been used as reference nonporous adsorbents, as they only exhibit an external surface. The absence of open porosity and high chemical inertia are attributes that make glass-like carbon a material frequently used in Adsorption by Carbons ISBN: 978-0-08-044464-2
© 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
15
16
Chapter
2
Overview of Carbon Materials in Relation to Adsorption
electrodes for electrochemical applications; for this reason, glass-like carbon has special relevance for liquid-solid adsorption in the context of electrochemistry. Furthermore, the adsorption behavior (for both gases and liquids) of highly porous carbons such as activated carbons is of great interest because of their relevance for technologies such as pollution control, heterogeneous catalysis, or gas and electric energy storage to mention just a few applications [3]. It is not surprising therefore that a great number of adsorption studies on carbons have been carried out using these materials as adsorbents. A corollary to this is the vast abundance of adsorption studies addressing the characterization of (micro)porosity in activated carbons. On the opposite side of the spectrum of surface area development, carbon fibers (CFs) [4, 5], used principally as reinforcement in composites, are virtually nonporous and exhibit a surface area that is only slightly greater than their geometrical area. Since the surface characteristics of carbon fibers are important in fields such as interfacial fiber-matrix behavior in composites, researchers in this area have adapted their methodologies, or developed new ones, to study adsorption on these low-surface area solids. This explains, for instance, the widespread application of inverse gas chromatography to this class of carbons [6]. Newer fibrous forms of carbon such as carbon nanofibers (CNFs) and carbon nanotubes (CNTs) are also being studied for their adsorption properties, although in this case the aim is to investigate not only their interaction with matrices in composites, but also their possible use as media for gas storage. The examples given above show that, although only a few types of carbons (particularly activated carbons) appear to dominate the scene where carbonaceous solids and adsorption are concerned, the carbon materials involved belong to very different classes, from highly crystalline to highly disordered. Carbon fibers (more specifically, those produced from pitches) reproduce within themselves the wide variety of carbon properties, depending chiefly on the nature of the precursor and preparation conditions. Thus, in order to provide an overview of carbons in relation to adsorption, it is necessary to be comprehensive and consider all possible classes of carbon materials, though paying particular attention to those that are most relevant to adsorption. This approach is the one adopted this chapter, which mainly attempts to classify the carbons, compare their 'properties, and introduce them to those interested in their adsorption behavior. The classification criteria used here are chiefly associated with crystalline structure (particularly, nanotexture), which we believe to be the property that offers the most thorough classification of carbon materials. Whenever available, structural models (rather than e.g. micrographs) will be used here to schematically illustrate the structural features of the various classes of carbonaceous solids. For more extensive or detailed information on carbon materials, the reader is referred to a number of comprehensive publications [1, 2, 7-15], some of which are particularly focused on structural aspects [11-14]. In this chapter, we will try to follow the terminology norms for carbon as a solid developed by the International Committee for Carbon Characterization and Terminology, and later adopted by the IUPAC [16]. Some
in
2.2
Structures of Elemental Carbon: Carbon Allotropes and Polytypes
17
previous reviews [7, 8] also include detailed information on the terminology employed for these materials. For the adsorption terminology (especially in connection with the characterization of porous solids, pore size classification, etc.), we will follow the corresponding IUPAC norms [17,18].
2.2 STRUCTURES OF ELEMENTAL (ARBON: (ARBON ALLOTROPES AND POLYTYPES
Carbon has an atomic number of 6 and its ground-state electron configuration is [He]2s22p 2. Like some other p-block elements (e.g., P, S, Sn), solid elemental carbon exhibits the phenomenon of allotropy (i.e., occurrence of the element in different forms that vary in structure and equation of state). Although other approaches (e.g., LCAO) have been used [7, 13] to justify the occurrence of different structures for this element in solid form, the hybridization concept provides a very intuitive explanation and is very useful for classifying carbon-based solids. In this approach, one of the s electrons can be promoted and hybridized with different numbers of p orbitals to give rise to three types of hybrid orbitals: Sp3, Sp2, and sp. These are at the origin of the three basic carbon structures, respectively, diamond, graphite, and carbynes. Table 2.1 summarizes the relationship existing between the type ofchemical bond, the stereochemistry, and the corresponding structures for carbon in solid form. In the diamond structure, carbon atoms are present in Sp3 hybridization, with a tetrahedral stereochemistry and a face-centered cubic structure that is shown in Fig. 2.1. Besides natural diamond, synthetic diamond has been produced since General Electric first announced its successful high-pressure synthesis in 1955. Sintered polycrystalline diamond, different types ofdiamond films, and diamondlike carbon are other types ofdiamond-related synthetic materials, some ofwhich are noncrystalline [13, 19]; these solids have their own terminology [10,20]. Unlike other carbonaceous solids, diamond has a rather limited and specific relevance to adsorption. Indeed, ever since the publication of a pioneering work Table
2.1 Relationship between hybridization, stereochemistry, and structures of solid carbon
Sp3
Tetrahedral
Sp2
Planar trigonal
sp
Linear
Diamond Lonsdaleitea Hexagonal graphite Rhombohedral graphitea Carbynes
aThese can be regarded as polytypes rather than different structures.
18
Chapter
2
Overview of Carbon Materials in Relation to Adsorption
(a)
(c)
Figure 2.1 Relationship between the graphite (a), lonsdaleite (b), and diamond (c) structures: c is the interlayer distance. (Reprinted from Re£ [23] with permission from Elsevier.)
in 1961 when an industrial diamond powder was first used as an adsorbate for nitrogen and argon [21], adsorption work on diamonds has mainly tended to confine itself to well-defined surfaces [22]. A second type of solid made up of carbon atoms in Sp3 hybridization is lonsdaleite. This structure consists of tetrahedra of carbon atoms assembled into a wurtzite-type hexagonal network. Lonsdaleite, a rare mineral, has been found in meteorites (e.g., the famous metallic meteorite Canyon Diablo, Coconino Co., Arizona, USA). Lonsdaleite can also be prepared by subjecting graphite to static pressure [19]. Figure 2.1 shows an analogy existing between lonsdaleite, diamond, and graphite structures, where the cross-hatched hexagons of carbon atoms adopt boat, armchair, and planar configurations, respectively [23]. As is well known, fullerenes are the only molecular solids in the realm of carbon materials. Their structure consists of polyhedra formed by the assembling of a series of pentagonal and hexagonal rings of carbon atoms. The hybridization state of fullerenes is intermediate between Sp3 and Sp2 (the Sp3 character deriving from the curvature in the polyhedron), this state being [24] Sp2.28 for the molecule of C 60 or buckminsterfullerene, the archetype of this carbon structure. Something similar occurs with carbon nanotubes, where curvature is present in the cylinder itself and in the two fullerene hemispheres that are thought to close up its ends. More information on this point is given below in this section, when the ternary diagram (CSp3, C Sp2, Csp) of carbonaceous solids is discussed. The review by Bandosz et al. [15] contains much information on a number of fullerene-related materials such as exo- and endohedral fullerenes, heterofullerenes (e.g., C s9 N, C 69 N), and fullerites (i.e., molecular solids formed by the aggregation of fullerenes at moderate temperatures and pressures; they can in turn condense into polymerized fullerites or accommodate intercalate species to form fullerite intercalation compounds). Graphite is the next allotrope of carbon. This consists of sheets of Sp2 carbon atoms with a planar trigonal stereochemistry that form a flat, condensed
2.2
Structures of Elemental Carbon: Carbon Allotropes and Polytypes
19
a
a A
A
c
A
B
B
A
A
A
Simple hexagonal graphite
Bernal graphite
Rhombohedral graphite
Figure 2.2
Graphite structures: simple hexagonal, Bernal hexagonal, and rhombohedral: a is the distance between nearest-neighbours, and c is the interlayer distance. A, B, C denote the stacking sequence ofgraphenes. (Reprinted from Ref. [25] with permission from Elsevier.)
system of hexagonal rings. In turn, these sheets, called graphenes, are bound to each other in the z-axis direction by a very weak metallic-type bond (similar in strength to van der Waals forces). Two possible types of graphene stacking exist (Fig. 2.2): hexagonal, Bernal type (ABAB ... sequence), and rhornbohedral (ABCABC ... sequence). The so-called simple hexagonal structure (AA ... sequence) [25], also depicted in Fig. 2.2, is only hypothetical. The rhombohedral structure is irreversibly transformed into the hexagonal one at temperatures above 1600 K. For this reason, it is not found in synthetic graphites obtained by thermal treatment. In addition, attempts to prepare pure rhombohedral graphite have so far failed. Due to the minor importance of rhombohedral graphite, from this point on, the terms "hexagonal graphite" and "Bernal graphite" will be referred to simply as graphite. In fact, this simplification has already been explicitly accepted by the IUPAC terminology norms [16]. Carbynes are white solids made up of carbon atoms with sp hybridization. Two main possibilities [23] exist for this linear structure: polyine (-C:=C-C:=C-) and polycumulene (==C==C==C==C==); theoretical predictions and experimental evidence also point to the existence of cyclic carbynes [10]. According to a classification based on the type of bond present (Table 2.1), and also according to chronology, carbynes (rather than fullerenes) should be considered as the third allotropic form of carbon. Our scarce knowledge of carbynes and doubts about whether they really exist in pure form [10, 15, 26] are factors that have contributed to this erroneous interpretation. Moreover, lonsdaleite and rhombohedral graphite should be considered as polytypes rather than new structures with a different equation of state [27]. Strictly speaking, therefore, they should not be regarded as true allotropes of carbon (Table 2.1). A series of impure varieties termed (X- and ~-carbynes, chaoite, carbon VI, and carbons VIII-XIII have been reported. Some of these solids have a natural origin (e.g., chaoite was discovered in the crater of the meteorite Ries, Bavaria, Germany), whereas others have been synthesized through reactions such as the oxidative dehydropolycondensation of acetylene [28]. This type of structure has been detected in macroscopic amounts in the presence of heteroatoms, e.g., in polyvinyl cyanides, H-(C=C)n-CN (where n = 2 - 4). Attempts to prepare
Chapter
20
2
Overview of Carbon Materials in Relation to Adsorption
large quantities of carbynes led a decade ago to the discovery [29] of carbolites, a class of solids with a low mass density that exhibits different structures depending on the gas present when they were synthesized. The fact that the structure of carbolite is complementary to that of graphite and a series of intriguing physical properties make this esoteric (according to Dresselhaus [30]) carbon phase appealing. Phase diagrams for carbon typically depict the zones where diamond, lonsdaleite, and graphite exist (plus those for the liquid and vapor states) without considering the rest of the solid phases. Some diagrams that are very rich in detail, such as the one shown in Fig. 2.3, depict several zones of formation of metastable phases or spontaneous transformations (depicted as A up to ]), this knowledge having been obtained principally from efforts to convert graphite into diamond [31]. However, no information is provided on other carbon phases. Thus, authors such as Dresselhaus [30] and Donnet [32] have suggested the need to define precisely the areas of stability of novel carbon forms and include them in such diagrams. For instance, Delhaes [13] has suggested a tentative area for carbyne existence that encompasses ~4000-5000 K, and zero to a few gigapascal. In this regard, the ternary diagram shown in Fig. 2.4 represents a significant step forward as it shows the different carbon materials as a function of the type of hybridization [27]. The three corners in the triangle correspond to the Sp3, Sp2, and sp "pure" states, and along the three sides are carbon forms with intermediate hybridization states spn. Thus, along the Sp2_Sp3 side are the carbon nanotubes (near the Sp2 corner) and fullerenes (2 < n < 3, where n increases with the decreasing number of carbon atoms in the fullerene molecule, i.e., with an increasing degree of curvature). The two other sides of the triangle include
50 I I
30
r
DIAMOND
20
II
E
40
C? Q. ~
:; (/)
Q)
a:
I
,
~
Q)
(/)
G
~H
,F
, \
, .....
D
LIQ.
t
10
! 0 0
1000
3000 4000 2000 Temperature (K)
5000
6000
Figure 2.3 Phase diagram for carbon. The letters indicated correspond to various transformations between graphite, diamond, and lonsdaleite. (Reprinted from Ref. [31] with permission from Elsevier.)
2.3 The Sp2 Carbon Forms: Graphitic, Graphitizable, and Nongraphitizable Carbons
21
Diamond lonsdaleite
~Ollapse Carbyno(polyyne)diamonds mLCp (m=3,0
C20 , P/H=oo C21 , P/H=3 . C22 , P/H =2 Fullerenes
\
~
'Amorphous
'~carb.o. n.\~. .
/.
Hypothetical D-G hybrids
C82 , P/H =0.6
C73 , P/H =0.5
Condensation
Polycyclic , / networks
Carbyne
Monocyclic ...-... Graphynes ~ Layer-chain rings, carbons mLCp cyclo[N]carbons (m = 2, 0 < P < 1)
Graphite
Figure 2.4 Ternary diagram (Csp 3, C Sp 2, Csp) of carbonaceous solids. (Reprinted from Ref. [27] with permission from Elsevier.)
materials such as the less-known "graphynes" and monocyclic cyclo [N] carbons (1 < n < 2), and the hypothetic "superdiamonds" (1 < n < 3, n =f. 2). There are similar diagrams for more specific types of carbon materials - for instance, the ternary diagram (CSp 3, C Sp 2, H), which can be used to classify noncrystalline carbons such as amorphous carbon (a-C) films, hydrogenated carbon (a-C:H) films, or diamond-like carbons (DLC), to mention just a few [10, 13].
2.3
THE Sp2 CARBON FORMS: GRAPHITIC,
GRAPHITIZABLE, AND NONGRAPHITIZABLE CARBONS
Carbonaceous solids that are inside the triangle in Fig. 2.4 obviously contain mixtures of the three hybridization states. Japanese researchers [33, 34] recently coined the term "carbon alloys" to designate materials typically made up of carbon atoms in multicomponent systems, where the components undergo physical or chemical interactions with each other. This very broad concept extends to mixtures of different phases (as occurs, for instance, in carbon-carbon composites), and also to materials containing heteroatoms. The interesting point in the present context is that, according to the above definition, carbon atoms with different hybrid orbitals are considered as different components.
22
Chapter
2
Overview of Carbon Materials in Relation to Adsorption
The ensemble of carbon materials containing the three types of hybridization includes many materials of practical interest, which are often referred to as "engineering carbons." In what follows, we will group all of these (Sp3+Sp2+Sp) solids under the common term "carbon forms." If one excludes some specific cases such as that of "diamond-like" amorphous carbon, these materials mainly contain carbon atoms in Sp2 hybridization. According to Marsh [35], "Although diamond has a greater emotional appeal than graphite as an allotrope of carbon structure, it is the graphite lattice which dominates discussions of structure within carbons." Indeed, it has become commonplace to consider the majority of carbon forms within the framework of the (hexagonal, Bernal type) graphite lattice, which is taken as reference for the highest degree of structural perfection. Hiittinger [36] has highlighted the potential of this anisotropic lattice as a common framework for many high-performance carbon materials, while Chung [37] has reviewed the special physical and chemical properties on which many applications of graphite and related solids are based. Both authors have identified oxidation sensitivity as one of the main shortcomings for practical applications, especially at high temperatures. The IUPAC [16] has adopted as a criterion for considering a material as graphite (or, more precisely, as a graphitic carbon), the requisite that the graphenes therein must be arranged parallel to each other in a tridimensional crystalline network. Conversely, one should not use the term graphitic carbon/material for solids (nongraphitic carbons), which do not exhibit a longrange tridimensional graphitic structure, even if they have been heat-treated at temperatures > 2500 K, in the so-called graphitization process. Nongraphitic carbons can in their turn be subdivided into graphitizable and nongraphitizable. As early as 1951, Franklin [38] established a classification into graphitizable and nongraphitizable carbons based on whether they were transformed or not into graphite by thermal treatment at 2273 K, and proposed the structural models that are reproduced in Fig. 2.5. According to Franklin's concept, graphitizable solids contain a series of units oriented in an approximately parallel fashion to each other (pregraphitic arrangement). In nongraphitizable
~~!IJb
~,~~~\\\~
~~C~~ ~~~~-'~~ Figure 2.5 Franklin's original schemes for graphitizable (lift) and nongraphitizable (right) carbons. (Reproduced from Re£ [38] with permission from the Royal Society.)
2.3 The Sp2 Carbon Forms: Graphitic, Graphitizable, and Nongraphitizable Carbons
23
solids, however, these units are arranged randomly and are cross-linked by disordered carbon species. The precise nature of these cross-links was not specified. It was assumed that on heating at high temperatures, these cross-links may be broken, but the activation energy needed for the motion of whole crystallites is high, and graphite is not formed. This model has been (and is still) widely accepted by the carbon community, despite its being considered as oversimplified, since in actual fact it is known that there is a continuum with no gap between extreme graphitizable and nongraphitizable situations [39]. Later on, the IUPAC [16] established a definition of nongraphitizable (also termed nongraphitizing) materials as "those non-graphitic solids that are not transformed into graphitic carbon by a simple thermal treatment at temperatures up to 3300 K and atmospheric pressure or lower" (i.e., through the graphitization process). This definition is empiric and somewhat arbitrary. The most representative type of nongraphitizable carbons is char, defined as a product of carbonization ofnatural or synthetic organic matter that has not passed through a fluid stage during carbonization. Other typically nongraphitizable carbon forms are carbon black, soot (plus aciniform carbon, an unsuccessful term that was coined to encompass the two previous types), glass-like (or "glassy") carbon, activated (also termed "active") carbon, wood charcoal, and many types of coal (bituminous coking coal and some anthracites being exceptions). The so-called graphitizable (also termed graphitizing) materials constitute a group that is complementary to the previous one. The IUPAC has simply defined them as those nongraphitic carbons that upon heat treatment are converted to graphitic carbon. The most representative type ofgraphitizable material is coke, which has been defined as a solid rich in nongraphitic carbon produced by the pyrolysis of an organic material that has passed, at least in part, through a liquid or liquid-crystalline stage during the carbonization process. There are a number of coke types, according to the precursor (e.g., petroleum coke, pitch coke, coal coke), the heat treatment temperature (e.g., green coke, calcined coke), or a combination of these and the production process (e.g., fluid coke, delayed coke, sponge coke, needle coke). Pyrolytic carbon, carbonaceous mesophase, and many types of pitch and carbon fibers (excluding, for instance, isotropic pitches and carbon fibers derived from them) are typical examples of graphitizable carbon forms. The difference between the definitions for char and coke derives from the formation of a mesophase or liquid crystal during the pyrolysis of certain types of precursors of carbons with a high degree of structural perfection [40]. Carbonaceous mesophase is formed from polyaromatic molecules with a laminar structure that are grouped together in parallel stacking by means of van der Waals forces (mesogens). Mesogens therefore adopt a pregraphitic arrangement that will transform into graphitic carbon when they are heated at higher temperatures. As an illustration of the thermal behavior of a typically graphitizable material, Fig. 2.6 shows a succession of optical micrographs for a pitch that generates mesophase during pyrolysis [40]. The initially formed mesogens group into anisotropic mesocarbon microspheres, which become separated from the
24
Chapter
Mesogens
2
Overview of Carbon Materials in Relation to Adsorption
Mesophase
Coalesced mesophase
Coke
Figure 2.6 Scheme of the carbonization process of a pitch (temperature increases from left to right). (Reproduced from Re£ [40] with permission from Taylor and Francis Group.)
fluid isotropic phase. As the temperature increases, polymerization and condensation reactions take place, the microspheres grow and coalesce, and viscosity increases until solidification takes place in the form of anisotropic coke. There are some exceptions to the rule that graphitizable materials must pass through a fluid stage to transform into graphite. On the one hand, it is well known that sucrose and other simple organic compounds give rise to nongraphitizable carbons, whereas they melt at low temperatures before the beginning of carbonization. However, this is not a significant exception since this involves just melting (""'459 K for sucrose) rather than carbonaceous mesophase formation and the like. Another, more important, exception is that of highly ordered graphitic carbon that can be produced by the carbonization-graphitization of polyimides, which takes place through the formation of a system of flat pores without any mesophase formation [41]. Moreover, the final product of this transformation has been shown to be one of the most perfect types of synthetic graphite ever produced, comparable in structural order to highly oriented pyrolytic graphite [1, 2]. Therefore, the above classification into graphitizable and nongraphitizable solids, which is phenomenological and somewhat arbitrary, is not strictly speaking true, and can only be considered as an approximate rule for classifying materials with a predominant Sp2 character into two main classes depending on their ability to transform into graphite.
2.4
STRUCTURAL CHARACTERIZATION OF CARBON
MATERIALS: THE BASIC STRUCTURAL UNITS AND THEIR STACKING AND ORIENTATION DEGREES
As Fig. 2.6 reveals, optical microscopy with polarized light makes it possible to distinguish various intermediate products formed from a precursor of graphitic carbon at different stages of pyrolysis. The observed morphology is the so-called optical texture, which enables carbon solids to be classified according to their degree of anisotropy. Besides optical microscopy, other techniques
2.4 Structural Characterization of Carbon Materials
25
with a higher degree of resolution, principally transmission electron microscopy (TEM), have significantly contributed to the characterization of the structure of carbon materials. To return to the case above, this technique provided direct evidence for the formation of flat pores and their sudden transformation into graphitic flat sheets at 2823 K upon the graphitization of Kapton polyimide. In this process, plane stacking changed from turbostratic (i.e., disordered in the c direction, see Section 2.4.3) to graphitic [41]. Oberlin and her group [42,43] have been widely recognized for their extensive studies of carbonaceous materials by TEM, mainly by combining selected area diffraction with dark-field and light-field imaging. One of the important concepts they established is that of basic structural unit (BSU) , defined as a planar aromatic structure of less than 10-20 rings and between two and four layers. A related concept is that of local molecular orientation (LMO), defined as an array ofBSUs with a near-common orientation. The arrangement ofBSUs, with a higher or lower degree ofLMO (in general, the regions of LMO are similar in size to the individual BSUs for carbons prepared at temperatures between 873 and 1273 K [39]), has increased our understanding of the mechanism ofgraphitization considerably. Thus, a high degree of cross-linking between the BSUs in nongraphitizable carbons leads to only a slight growth in the extent and order of LMO. On the other hand, lack of cross-linking in graphitizable carbons will allow the BSU elements to rearrange and coalesce with thermal treatment. The BSU concept also helps to explain the presence of intrinsic pores in certain carbon materials [44]. Figure 2.7 sketches the possible arrangements ofBSUs in carbons [42]. These can be reduced to two symmetries: spherical or cylindrical. All possible textures derive from these two basic arrangements if one considers the variable radii of curvature of lamellae; thus, an infinite radius of curvature gives rise to flat lamellae. We will come back to this figure when discussing the types of orientation found in carbonaceous materials (Sections 2.4.1 to 2.4.3). X-ray diffraction (XRD), generally considered the "ideal" technique for the structural characterization of materials, not only allows the structures of different carbon allotropes and polytypes to be distinguished from each other, but also enables the degree to which the structure of a given carbon form departs from the ideal graphite structure to be determined. By applying the Debye-Scherrer equation (adapted to carbon materials by Warren) to the (002) and (10) peaks, it is possible to calculate, respectively, the height (Lc) and width (La) of the graphitelike crystallites in these solids. Emmerich [45] has provided a useful comparison of the trends of variation of L c and Lc with heat treatment temperature for graphitizable and nongraphitizable carbons. The recent efforts of a group of Japanese researchers to normalize the application of XRD to carbon materials also deserves special mention [46]. Raman spectroscopy is another useful technique for classifying carbon materials according to structural criteria. Thus, the Raman spectra ofmost carbon forms contain, at least, two main bands termed G band (after graphite, r-v1575 cm- i ) and D band (after defects, r-v1355 cm- i ) [47]. Figure 2.8 illustrates the evolution of these two bands and the second-order spectrum (2600-3200 cm- i , G' band
26
Chapter
2
Overview of Carbon Materials in Relation to Adsorption
-
1nm (a)
(d)
I.
Fiber. axiS
(f)
Figure 2.7 Sketches ofthe possible arrangementofbasic structural units (BSU)s. (a and b), true spherical symmetry (a, concentric texture; b, radial texture); (c-e), statistical spherical symmetry (c, crumpled sheets ofpaper; d, lamellar structure with infinite radius ofcurvature or infinite local molecular orientation (LMO); e, lamellar structure with a long-range statistical orientation); (f and g), cylindrical symmetry (f, true cylindrical symmetry; g, statistical cylindrical symmetry). (Reproduced from Re£ [42] with permission from Taylor and Francis Group.)
at '"'-'2700 cm- 1) for carbon solids with a different degree of structural order (decreasing from top to bottom in this figure) [48]. One can clearly see the decrease in intensity and widening of the D band, the parallel increase in the G band, and the disappearance of the G' band when moving progressively from
27
2.4 Structural Characterization of Carbon Materials
GC2
.' .....
GA2
OCA
_~ .. W.' _
~'
j ".,.•.... ._~
OVA
FC1
CM3 f
1000 1200 1400 1600 1800
$
•
2600 2800 3000 3200
Figure 2.8 Raman spectra of various carbon materials with an approximately decreasing degree ofstructural order in the following sequence: natural graphite (GC2), high surface area graphite (GA2), calcined needle coke (QCA), green needle coke (QVA), isotropic carbon fiber (FC1), and subbituminous coal (CM3). (Reprinted from Ref. [48] with permission from Elsevier.)
graphites to higWy disordered materials such as coals. The intensity ratio of the G and D bands as well as their wavenumbers and widths are useful quantitative criteria for comparing the degree of structural order of different carbon forms. The information provided by XRD is not equivalent to that obtained from Raman spectroscopy. Rather it is complementary. More specifically, XRD reflects the degree of graphitization in terms of the stacking of the basic constituents, whereas Raman spectroscopy reflects their degree of orientation. This is illustrated in Fig. 2.9, which shows the variation of two parameters derived from each of these techniques (respectively, the graphite-like interlayer spacing dOO2 ' and the [ID/(ID+ Ie)] intensity ratio) for a wide and varied set of carbons (including 45 different samples of graphitic, graphitizable, and nongraphitizable solids) [49]. For low values of both parameters, a horizontal line is obtained where data corresponding to various types of graphite accumulate. For these materials, d002 approaches the ideal value of 0.3354 nm. However, the graphite
28
Chapter
2
Overview of Carbon Materials in Relation to Adsorption
0.41
• •
0.39
•
E
c
......... C\I
0
0.37
0
u
0.35
0.33 0
20
40
60
80
100
'01(10+ 'G) (%)
Figure 2.9
Comparison of structural parameters deduced from X-ray diffraction and Raman spectroscopy for a wide set of carbon materials. (Ref. [49] - reproduced by permission of the Royal Society of Chemistry.)
samples studied correspond to solids with different degrees of BSU orientation; therefore, the Raman intensity ratio varies from 0 to f"V40 %. A transition zone (line of intermediate slope) is followed by a zone with a wide dispersion of points that corresponds to the most disordered materials studied. For these materials, the [ID/(ID+ Ie)] ratio oscillates between 60 and 80 %, whereas d002 increases (vertical straight line). Here, the solids have their BSUs oriented at random and do not significantly differ from each other as examined by Raman spectroscopy. However, by means ofXRD they can be differentiated from the degree of stacking of graphenes inside their basic units (d002 varies from f"V0.35 to >0.40 nm). The importance ofthe degree oforientation ofthe basic constituents ofcarbon materials is highlighted in Fig. 2.10, proposed as early as 1985 by Inagaki [50], which depicts the main types of orientation found in carbons. This scheme has many points in common with the one shown in Fig. 2.7. In the following subsections we will use these two schemes as a basis for describing the main classes of nanotexture (defined here as arrangement of BSUs) found in carbonaceous solids, which afford a useful classification for understanding the behavior of carbons both in general and as adsorbents. Although, strictly speaking, lamellar and random orientations are special cases of spherical symmetry [42], we will treat them as separate types of texture to facilitate the classification of carbon solids into a larger variety of types. 2.4.1 Planar Orientation
This type of orientation is characteristic of graphite, of which some very perfect forms, such as kish graphite (precipitated from molten iron at high temperatures), highly oriented· pyrolytic graphite (HOPG), polyimide-derived
29
2.4 Structural Characterization of Carbon Materials
ORIENTED TEXTURE
RANDOM TEXTURE
PLANAR ORIENTATION
:I:~;e~
WS?
~ RANDOM ORIENTATION
f~~t1
~~COaXial
~~fer~nce AXIAL ORIENTATION ~~IS ~ ("'- ~ Radial Concentric
Reference point
POINT ORIENTATION
~
~ Radial -~---....
-----... - - - - -.... ~
Degree of orientation Degree of graphitization Heat treatment temperature
Figure 2.10 Types of orientation of the basic constituents of carbon materials. (Reprinted from Re£ [1] with permission from Elsevier.)
graphite films, or natural graphite flakes (e.g., from Ticonderoga [New York, USA], Madagascar, or Sri Lanka) represent paradigmatic cases of a high degree of structural order in the realm of carbon materials. As indicated in Section 2.1, some of the major connections of graphite with adsorption work have to do with carrying out measurements on a well-controlled surface, or, in the case of theoretical studies, to use its structure as a model for simulating the adsorption of different molecules on its surface. Moreover, HOPG is a material of choice for techniques such as scanning tunneling and atomic force microscopies and, as such, has often been used to directly visualize large molecules adsorbed on its surface. It is well known that various atoms, ions, and even molecules can be received into the graphite interlayer space between hexagonal layers of carbon atoms. In this way, intercalation compounds with rather unique properties are formed [1, 51]. When graphite intercalation compounds such as graphite hydrogen sulfate are subjected to very rapid heating (or flash heating), a type ofgraphite made up of flakes called exfoliated graphite is produced. Exfoliated graphite has a worm- or accordion-like shape with numerous macropores [44] (the macropores being the spaces left between successive flakes) and has a close relevance to adsorption, either for fundamental work (as it has a highly homogeneous surface) or connected with applications, either per se (e.g., in the removal of oil spills from sea water) [52], or as monolithic supports to deposit other adsorbent or catalyst phases [53]. A less widely known type of graphite is "high surface
30
Chapter
2
Overview of Carbon Materials in Relation to Adsorption
area graphite," produced by extensive milling [54] and used as catalyst support or adsorbent [55]; it exhibits surface areas ranging between 100 and 300 m 2 / g. Various intermediate situations between perfect planar orientation and random orientation are found in solids such as pyrolytic carbons and cokes (i.e., typically graphitizable materials). Heat treatment temperature and the type ofprecursor (in the case ofcokes) are the main factors that determine the actual arrangement, i.e., tending toward either planar or random orientation. Unlike these solids, natural microcrystalline graphite (also termed "amorphous" graphite in certain contexts) should be classified as a randomly oriented material. This type ofgraphite is made up of very small domains that are oriented at random toward each other. Inside each domain, graphenes are stacked as in the most perfect types of graphite. The empty circle at the intersection of the two dashed lines in Fig. 2.9 corresponds to a natural microcrystalline graphite (from Mexico), which, according to the Raman band intensity ratio [ID/(ID+ Ie) = 67.5 %], is among the most randomly oriented materials studied by Cuesta et al. [49], whereas on the basis of XRD (d002 = 0.335 nm) it presents a high degree of graphitization. Likewise, synthetic isotropic high-density graphite, produced by cold isostatic pressing for use in a number of applications such as the structural parts of nuclear fission reactors [1], must be considered as randomly oriented from the point of view of nanotexture. On the other hand, graphite foams [56, 57], which are produced from mesophase pitches, are materials made up of an interconnected network of long graphite filaments and thus they exhibit isotropic material properties, though only on the macroscopic scale. On the nanoscale, however, they exhibit high Lc and La values, indicative of the presence of large graphitic domains. 2.4.2 Axial Orientation
Axial orientation is typical of materials with a tubular geometry (indeed, a fibrous morphology of carbon materials is possible, thanks to this axial orientation scheme). Axial orientation encompasses two extreme characteristic types: coaxial and radial. One of the best examples of coaxial orientation of BSUs is that of multiwall carbon nanotubes (MWCNTs), which consist of a series of concentric cylinders. Figure 2.11 shows one of the many examples of TEM micrographs of MWCNTs from the literature [58]. The parallelism of graphenes (in the so-called Russian doll arrangement) can be clearly seen and follows approximately the model that is depicted in an inset in the same figure. However, MWCNTs generally contain defects such as pentagonal and heptagonal rings, the presence of which produces bending and/or capping of individual nanotubes to yield structures such as carbon nanobamboos [59] and nanocones [60] (also termed nanohorns). The latter type of material has been quite frequently studied as adsorbent by Iijima, Kaneko and coworkers [61]. As in the case of fullerenes, readers interested in further information on these and other even more exotic nanotube-related solids (e.g., nanotubes with helical and toroidal structures) are referred to the review by 13artdosz et al. [15]. Adsorption by carbon nanotubes (especially the single-wall ones, SWCNTs) constitutes the
2.4 Structural Characterization of Carbon Materials
31
Figure 2.11 TEM image ofa concentric multiwall nanotube. The scale bar is 4 nm. The inset in the upper left comer illustrates the concentric arrangement of graphenes. (Reproduced from Re£ [58] with kind permission of Springer Science and Business Media.)
subject of Chapters 9, 15, and 16, and thus, we feel that the relevance to adsorption of these materials does not need to be dwelt upon any more at this point. Closely related to MWCNTs are CNFs, which can also be produced by the decomposition of hydrocarbon gas in the presence of transition-metal catalyst particles (catalytic chemical vapor deposition, CCVD) [62]. CNFs are highly graphitizable [63] as their main constituent is a layer ofpyrolytic carbon grown on an initially hollow graphitic filament generated on a catalyst particle. Some CNFs exhibit coaxial orientation, there being some doubt as to the distinction between them and MWCNTs [64]. CNFs can exhibit other characteristic nanotextures. One is the so-called platelet type, formed by platelets that are stacked on top of each other perpendicularly to the fiber axis. Other types are the herringbone and stacked-cup ones, which are depicted in Fig. 2.12; these two types of CNFs can be grown by the same method (chemical vapor deposition, CVD) , and they exhibit similar TEM images but differ in nanotexture and, hence, in their properties and potential applications [65]. As in the case of CNTs, CNFs are being actively investigated as adsorbents (if necessary, after activation), mainly in connection with gas storage.
32
Chapter
(a)
(b)
2
Overview of Carbon Materials in Relation to Adsorption
(c)
(d)
Figure 2.12 (a) and (c) Atomic models of stacked-cup and herringbone carbon nanofibers and (b) and (d) their respective simulated TEM images. (Reprinted from Ref. [65] with permission from Elsevier.)
The other extreme type of axial orientation consists of a radial alignment of carbon layers. This is typically found in ultrahigh-modulus, mesophase-pitchbased carbon fibers, which exhibit a radial arrangement in the cross-section of the fibers. Figure 2.13 shows two SEM micrographs of this type of fibers, where wedge-arranged straight layers are clearly visible, especially in the lower micrograph [66]. According to Mochida and coworkers [67,68], melt spinning (which is the basis of the preferred process for producing these fibers) is the most important step for determining the structures of mesophase-pitch-based CFs. During this process, microdomains (already present in the liquid crystal mesophase pitch) are aligned parallel to the fiber axis, forming fibrils. The fibrils are made up of a number of pleat units aligned parallel to the fiber axis. In turn, the pleats are composed ofgraphitic units. The radial open wedge probably forms by anisotropic shrinkage along the circumference of the fibers in the outer area at high temperature. Edie [69] has summarized the types of traverse textures that occur in mesophase-pitch-based CFs. The corresponding schemes are reproduced in Fig. 2.14, which highlights the striking variety of nanotextures that can be obtained from this type of precursor. It is worth mentioning at this point that the term" graphite fibers," still overused in certain contexts, is only justified when the material has a three-dimensional graphitic order. This term should therefore be limited to a few highly ordered mesophase-pitch-based CFs, which are truly graphitic, the general term "carbon fibers" being applied to the rest of the CFs. Less ordered, polyacrylonitrile (PAN)-based high-modulus and high-strength CFs have an intermediate, statistically cylindrical symmetry, which can be
2.4 Structural Characterization of Carbon Materials
33
Figure 2.13 SEM micrographs of mesophase-pitch-based carbon fibers. (Reprinted from Re£ [66] with permission from Elsevier.)
Radial
Onion-skin
Flat-layer
Radial-folded
Random
Line-origin
Figure 2.14 Traverse textures of mesophase-pitch-based carbon fibers. (Reprinted from Ref. [69] with permission from Elsevier.)
34
Chapter
2
Overview of Carbon Materials in Relation to Adsorption
generated by introducing an elongation parallel to the fiber axis into the socalled crumpled sheets of paper model (Fig. 2.7, c and g) (see below) [42]. More detailed accounts on the nanotexture of these important carbon forms can be found elsewhere [70]. As is well known, the main field of application of CFs is as a reinforcement of polymeric matrices in composite materIals for aeronautic, aerospace, and other advanced uses. Improvement of the degree of adhesion between CFs and binders in these composites depends to a large extent on the surface properties of the fibers. This has been the motive of much research work on the surface properties of CFs, including many adsorption studies, which have been reviewed by various authors [4, 5,71]. Much less ordered than PAN-based high-strength CFs are the isotropic CFs. They are produced by the carbonization of isotropic pitch fibers (or other fibrous precursors such as phenolic resins or cellulose, including rayon), without any attempt to obtain a preferred orientation of the polyaromatic molecules in the fiber direction. Consequently, they have a random nanotexture and belong to the "low modulus" class of CFs [16]. Rather than being used for high-performance reinforcement purposes, they find their application as thermal insulators for furnaces or as reinforcements for cement [1]. Another important use of isotropic CFs is as a feedstock for the production of activated carbon fibers, a material dealt with in Section 2.4.4.
2.4.3 Point Orientation Like axial orientation, point orientation, which is characteristic of materials with a spherical geometry, falls into two extreme characteristic types. One is concentric, found, for instance, in carbon blacks [72] and carbon nanoonions [73], both of which consist of successive concentric spherical layers of BSUs. Figure 2.15 is a TEM image [74] of several carbon nano-onions (also termed multilayered fullerenes), which clearly illustrates the phenomenon of point concentric orientation. Many similar (but generally not so clear-cut) micrographs have been published for submicrometric, spherical carbon black particles as examined by TEM. A "venerable, and much reproduced" [75] model for the nanotexture of this material [76] can be seen in Fig. 2.7a. Carbon blacks have many connections with adsorption work since the inert nature of their surface and virtual absence of porosity (while exhibiting [15] external surface areas of up to 150 m 2 / g, thanks to their small particle size) have made them suitable as reference nonporous carbon materials, especially those that have been thermally treated at high temperatures. However, it is necessary to be cautious on this point since it is common in the literature to refer to such solids as "graphitized carbon blacks." It is true that, upon heat treatment, the outermost layers of certain carbon blacks may become polyhedral through the wiping-out of defects at boundaries between BSUs [77]. Correspondingly, graphitization begins to occur there, but the size of the flat regions is known never to surpass about one-third of the particle diameter [42]. Therefore, carbon blacks are generally considered nongraphitizable as a whole [15].
2.4 Structural Characterization of Carbon Materials
35
Figure 2.15 High-resolution TEM micrograph of carbon nano-onions. (Reprinted from Re£ [74] with permission from Elsevier.)
Carbon black is produced industrially in the form of different products (e.g., furnace black, thermal black, channel black, lampblack, acetylene black) with specific properties. In addition to the relevance of carbon black for basic research on adsorption, or as a reference solid, applications of this material in fields such as elastomer reinforcement, as modifier of certain properties of plastics (UV protection, electrical conductance, color), or as xerographic toners make its surface and interfacial properties extremely important. Soot is a randomly formed particulate material similar in nature to carbon black. The main (pragmatic, rather than conceptual) difference between these two carbon forms is that soot is generally formed as an unwanted by-product of incomplete combustion of pyrolysis, whereas carbon black is produced under strictly controlled conditions. Bansal and Donnet [78] have reviewed various possible mechanisms for the formation of soot and carbon black. Soot can retain a number of tars and resins on its surface. There is therefore some interest in studying the adsorption of polyaromatic hydrocarbons in soots, especially those of environmental significance such as diesel soot. Fullerene soot (also known as fullerene black, as in fact it is produced under controlled conditions) is a material generated in various fullerene synthesis processes by condensation of carbon species from the gas phase [79]. The subject of soot versus fullerene formation led the discoverers of buckminsterfullerene to propose a new mechanism for soot formation, known as the icospiral growth mechanism [80], which was refined later [81]. In this model, growth takes place in the form of a spiraling structure which, depending on the availability of a number of pentagonal rings, will either close up (fullerene) or curl around itself like a nautilus shell (soot). This is a field to which adsorption work
Chapter
E C
1J ,
2
Overview of Carbon Materials in Relation to Adsorption
0
-->..
A _-+ ----.... G-- ~__~ _.....~....
IISS-lllJI
A
o
B
11 11 1111'1 II.
c
m:n.-:::::z:ma E
F
Figure 2.16 Schematic model of the alignment of aromatic layers in carbon spherules with radial point orientation of basic structural units (BSUs). Several types of sections and the corresponding cross-sections of the spherules are also indicated. (Reprinted from Ref. [82] with permission from Elsevier.)
could contribute interesting results in order to clarify (i) the still eXIstIng controversy about the possible connection between fullerenes and soot/carbon black formation and (ii) the structure of soot/carbon black particles, which remains unresolved [75] despite the fact that these materials are among the oldest known carbonaceous solids. The radial arrangement is the other extreme type of point orientation. One of the carbon materials exhibiting a nanotexture very close to this model is the carbon spherule formed from mixtures of polyethylene and polyvinyl chloride by carbonization under pressure (30 MPa) [82]. A similar, although less "perfect" situation corresponds to mesophase spheres (Fig. 2.6), which are close to the radial point orientation near their surface. However, in their centers the orientation of the layers is not radial [83]. Figure 2.16 shows a model for the nanotexture of carbon spherules, where small aromatic layers are assumed to align approximately on circular conical surfaces with a common vertex at or near the center of the spherule. This proposed model was supported by an electron microdiffraction study of various micro-areas of sections of the spherules and by scanning electron microscopy, which evidenced the formation of a definite system of cracks on heat treatment to 3073 K [82].
2.4.4 Random Orientation Positioned directly opposite to planar orientation in Fig. 2.10 is random orientation, which is typical of highly disordered carbon materials such as chars, activated carbons, wood charcoals, or low-rank coals. The basic constituents of these materials are randomly intermingled, many of the spaces between them forming either opened or closed pores. "Pure" random orientation is found in
2.4 Structural Characterization of Carbon Materials
37
carbon materials just after the carbonization of some precursor polymers, and also in glass-like carbon [2]. The latter carbon form is nongraphitizable and exhibits uncommon properties such as impermeability to gases and extremely low chemical reactivity. One of the structural models proposed to account for the behavior of glass-like carbon is the "ribbon" model of Jenkins and Kawamura [84, 85], illustrated in Fig. 2.17. This assumes that the molecular orientation in the polymer precursor material is retained to some extent after carbonization. According to this model the "fibrils" in the polymer become curved and twisted ribbons of graphite-like carbon. Since the basic constituents of glass-like carbon cannot be directly imaged by TEM due to their very small size, the modeling of their nanotexture has often been based on a TEM examination of high-temperature-treated samples. Thus, the "shell" model, proposed by Shiraishi [86] for heat-treated glass-like carbon, involves cage-like components enclosing closed pores [87]. The hexagonal layers are locally oriented in a concentric scheme. This model is considered [2] to be realistic as it agrees with the presence of closed porosity in this material and, hence, gas impermeability. More recently, Harris [75, 88] proposed a new structural model that is applicable to nongraphitizable carbons in general, based on fullerene-like elements. This model is based on the examination ofTEM images, where fullerene-related particles have been observed by the authors in nongraphitizable carbons, in most of the cases treated at high temperatures. According to this DI0del, these carbons consist of discrete fragments of curved carbon sheets, in which pentagonal and heptagonal rings are dispersed at random throughout networks of hexagons. Harris has argued that this model, schematized in Fig. 2.18, is applicable to glass-like carbons prepared at temperatures of around 1273 K, since this structure probably has a low reactivity and permeability to gases compared with the "ribbon" model, particularly if there is a high proportion of completely closed particles. Glass-like carbons treated at higher temperatures are probably formed by larger basic building blocks that resemble incomplete giant fullerenes.
j • • • Lc
t
Figure 2.17 Jenkins-Kawamura "ribbon" model for glass-like carbon. (Reproduced from Ref. [85] with permission from the Royal Society.)
Chapter
2
Overview of Carbon Materials in Relation to Adsorption
Figure 2.18 Harris model for the structure of nongraphitizable carbons based on fullerenelike elements. (Reproduced from Ref. [88]. Copyright Maney Publishing.)
The next carbon forms that we will consider within the random orientation framework are activated carbons (ACs) (as well as the chars from which they are prepared). ACs (and highly porous carbons in general) have a disordered structure, which is not, however, amorphous, as has been sometimes claimed. In ACs, there is a certain two-dimensional order, but no three-dimensional graphitic ordering. The disorder in the c direction is termed "turbostratic." This concept was coined to describe a graphite-like structure with a random orientation of layer planes along the a axis and a rotation of layer planes along the c axis, so that the interlayer spacing is 0.344 nm (cf 0.335 nm in a graphite single crystal). Early models used to describe the structure of ACs included the Franklin model itself (Fig. 2.5), and a ribbon-like structure [89] somewhat similar to the Jenkins and Kawamura model for glass-like carbon (Fig. 2.17). Interestingly, these models were based on results obtained with polyvinylidene chloride (PVDC) (or Saran) char, a typical nongraphitizable material (unlike the wellknown graphitizability of polyvinyl chloride [PVC] char). Various arguments have been used to criticize these and other models based on the occurrence of Sp3 carbon besides Sp2 carbon in nongraphitizable materials [10, 75]. Oberlin and coworkers [42,90] (Fig. 2.7c) used a "crumpled sheets of paper" model to describe the nanotexture of porous carbons. Figure 2.19 depicts this model and includes an enlarged sketch of pores in sucrose-based carbons [91]. In Fig. 2.19a, each zone of molecular orientation is represented by a shaded area inside of which each individual stack is shown either as a rectangular unit or as two parallel segments depending on whether they are observed in perspective
39
2.4 Structural Characterization of Carbon Materials
(a)
(b)
Figure 2.19 Sketches of crumpled sheet nanotexture of a sucrose-based high-temperature char. (a) Enlarged representation of pores and (b) model of crumpled sheets of paper. (Reprinted from Re£ [91] with permission from Elsevier.)
or edge-on. In sucrose-based carbons, which are typically nongraphitizable, the BSUs are locally oriented in very small regions, so that the LMO is smaller than 10 nm, and the LMOs are distributed at random in a given fragment. According to Rouzaud and Oberlin [91], during the release of heteroatoms that takes place when the sucrose is carbonized, the diameter ofLMOs remains practically constant, whereas their thickness decreases. Due to this, numerous small pores develop with an irregular entangled shape following the crumpled sheets of paper model [39]. Harris and coworkers [92, 93] have proposed that their model that is based on fullerene-like elements developed for nongraphitizable carbons in general (Fig. 2.18) may be applicable to PVDC chars and sucrose chars heat-treated to 2373-2873 K, where they detected closed nanoparticles that were usually faceted and often hexagonal or pentagonal in shape. The authors argue that such particles derive from fullerene-related structures present in the original, freshly prepared carbons (when examined by TEM, the low-temperature carbons were usually featureless and did not reveal a detailed structure, although occasionally some very small closed particles were found there) [88]. The model based on these findings (Fig. 2.18) predicts a micropore size of the order of 0.5-1.0 nm, which is similar to the pore sizes observed in many (ultra)microporous chars or carbons activated to low burn-off The empty spaces left between the fullerene-like fragments in Fig. 2.18 are not slit-shaped, but Harris [75] argues that micropores in carbons may have random shapes, as has been found either experimentally or by theoretical calculations. Harris [75] has also pointed out that his model based on fullerene-like elements has some connections with the so-called random schwarzite structure [94], which is based in turn on the ordered schwarzite structure [95] (the term schwarzite was coined after the German mathematician H.A. Schwarz, who first investigated the periodic minimal surfaces). The key feature of schwarzite is the occurrence
Chapter
4°
(a)
2
Overview of Carbon Materials in Relation to Adsorption
(b)
Figure
2.20 Possible structures for ordered schwarzite (a) and random schwarzite (b). (Reprinted with permission from Ref. [94]. © 1992 The American Physical Society.)
of negative curvature (in the Gaussian sense of the word) due to the presence of heptagonal rings. In an ordered schwarzite there is only negative curvature (Fig. 2.20a), whereas random (amorphous) schwarzites (Fig. 2.20b) contain pentagons (besides heptagons) and therefore combine concave and convex surfaces to yield solids that contain pores of molecular dimensions. Whatever the significance of the similarity between Harris' and schwarzite models (the random schwarzite shown in Fig. 2.20b should contain pores in the order of 0.5-1.0 nm, as in the model in Fig. 2.18), it is certain that schwarzites, if they occurred, would bring a new flavor to adsorption studies on carbons in both fundamental and applied fields. Their structure is continuous, with no edges or dangling bonds and would act as a kind of carbon sponge [96] with homogeneous pores of (perhaps tunable) molecular dimensions. Studies on the simulation of gas adsorption on schwarzites are reviewed in Chapter 14. However, despite many attempts to synthesize schwarzites [15], these efforts seem to have been fruitless to date, at least in the case of the ordered ones. Something similar occurs with certain hypothetical combinations (Fig. 2.4) of Sp3, Sp2, and sp hybridized atoms (graphdiynes, fullerenediynes), which could form potentially porous, molecular carbon solids [96, 97]. To obtain these, active research programs based on synthetic chemistry routes have been launched [15, 98]. To return to activated carbons, these can occur in very different physical forms: granular (or particulate), powdered, fibrous, or even membrane (the latter can be either unsupported, or, more commonly, supported). These basic physical forms can be combined with binders and extruded to form pellets, monoliths, or even paper. All of these materials, which are very frequently used as adsorbents, differ significantly in shape, but not in their intrinsic nanotextural features. All of them are isotropic and have their BSUs randomly oriented. Although they are specifically treated in Chapter 17, activated carbon fibers (ACFs) and derived cloths and felts deserve special mention here due to their uniform pore size distribution (PSD) and small and uniform fiber diameter, which confer on them, respectively, both size selectivity and rapid
2.4 Structural Characterization of Carbon Materials
41
adsorption/desorption kinetics. As announced at the end of Section 2.4.2, ACFs are produced from nongraphitizable (and hence isotropic) fibrous precursors [99, 100], and therefore, their nanotexture is also random. Indeed, anisotropic carbon fibers cannot be activated physically, and perhaps only chemical activation with a strong alkali may render them porous. The uniformity in pore size of ACFs is generally attributed to their small diameter (rv 10 f.Lm), so that many pores are directly open to the outer surface, porosity development proceeding by pore deepening rather than the creation of new pores. In some outstanding cases of pore size homogeneity such as polyaramid-derived ACFs, a certain "memory effect" seems to exist, whereby a highly ordered structure in the precursor yields a denser, less defective char than those prepared from other precursors [101, 102]. Carbon molecular sieves (CMSs) are porous carbons with an even narrower distribution of pore size (or, more precisely, of pore entrance size), which have the ability to differentiate between molecules of similar dimensions on the basis of adsorption kinetics. A key step in producing CMSs is the deposition of carbon on pore entrances [103], which is carried out usually by the CVD of hydrocarbons. Needless to say, CMSs have a nanotexture that is as randomly oriented as that of the parent ACs or ACFs on which the CVD was carried out. A type of carbon with a characteristic bimodal PSD is carbon gel [104]. The porosity of carbon gels consists of mesopores located between the constituent particles (or "nodules" [105]) and micropores located within these particles [15]. The various existing types of carbon gels (carbon xerogels, aerogels of cryogels) differ from each other in the type of drying (evaporative, supercritical, or freezedrying, respectively) to which their organic precursor gels (e.g., resorcinolformaldehyde gels) were subjected. Carbon gels retain to a large extent the mesoscopic structure of their parent organic gels [15]. They are therefore nongraphitizable and isotropic. Their nanotexture is random, as one might expect for carbons derived from the polymers used to produce the parent organic gels. We will not discuss here models for pores in carbons, as this topic is treated in Chapter 5, and elsewhere in specialist [15] or general reviews [106, 107]. For similar reasons, we will not discuss porosity control [44, 108] in detail. However, porous carbons prepared by the template technique, especially the ordered ones, deserve special attention. Ordered mesoporous carbons have been known to scientists since 1989 when two Korean groups independently reported their synthesis using mesoporous silicas as templates [109, 110]. Further achievements have been described in more recent reports [111, 112]. One might have expected that the nanotexture of these materials would merely reflect the nature of the precursor used, namely phenol-formaldehyde [109] or sucrose [110] in the two first ordered mesoporous carbon syntheses (as is well known, these two precursors would have yielded randomly oriented, isotropic carbon had they been pyrolyzed/activated under more conventional conditions). However, the mesopore walls in some ordered mesoporous carbons exhibited a graphite-like, polyaromatic character [113, 114], as described in Chapter 18. This information was obtained by nitrogen adsorption at low relative pressures, as in classical
Chapter
42
2
Overview of Carbon Materials in Relation to Adsorption
studies of highly homogeneous exfoliated graphite surfaces [115-117], and were in agreement with XPS results. Ryoos group has gone a step further and prepared a family of mesoporous carbons composed of graphitic framework structures consisting of discoid graphene sheets. This was the first case of porous carbons having a structural regularity on both the meso- and atomic scale [118]. The range of mesopores achievable by the template method is limited by the structure of the available templates. To overcome this limitation, Li and Jaroniec [119] developed a method, whereby, in contrast with the so-called colloidal templating technique (which involves a fluid-type carbon precursor), the so-called colloid-imprinted carbons are prepared by imprinting solid particles ofa mesophase pitch (used as carbon precursor) with colloidal silica particles. The primary pore structure ofthe resulting mesoporous carbons (which have spherical mesopores in the ""'-'6-60 nm range) can be preserved upon graphitization. In addition, the latter treatment made the resulting materials more energetically homogeneous and attractive for chromatographic separations [120]. The case of zeolite-templated, ordered microporous carbons (ZTCs) appears even more intriguing. Kyotani and coworkers [121, 122] were the first to succeed in synthesizing this type of material by carbonizing a precursor (acrylonitrile, furfuryl alcohol) polymerized in zeolite nanochannels, followed by the deposition of carbon from propylene by CVD. Some of the ZTCs obtained had [123] a BET surface area as high as 4100 m 2 / gl, (the surface area value decreased to 3730m2 /g 1 when calculated by the "subtracting pore method" [124]) a finely tailored micropore size and a long-range periodicity originating from the parent zeolite. The material was observed by scanning tunneling microscopy [125] to consist of carbon clusters about 1 nm in size. The porosity therefore is probably made up of the voids that separate the clusters. These clusters must have formed inside, and adapted themselves to the supercages of the zeolite Y template, and would appear to consist of nanographenes with a curved topology. In connection with the latter point, we believe that the recent discovery [126] of a method to isolate individual graphenes may pave the way for unexpected findings in the field of carbons in general and in that of adsorption by carbons in particular. This first example of a truly bidimensional material that is also the thinnest conceivable object will shed light on whether or not graphenes of different sizes are flat or curved, continuous or discontinuous, and whether they may be made to curl into, e.g., random, or even ordered, schwarzites. We are undoubtedly at the dawn of an exciting new era of carbon science.
2.5
CONCLUSIONS
The well-known basic structures of diamond and graphite are offset by others (carbynes) which, although they are scarce and even their existence is doubted, contribute to our understanding of structural trends in carbonaceous solids as a function of the type of chemical bond present.
References
43
Carbon forms with major Sp2 hybridization may be phenomenologically classified into graphitizable and nongraphitizable. The criterion established to differentiate these two classes is too empirical, and there are important exceptions (e.g., polyimide-derived carbons) to this rule. Nevertheless, these two concepts are useful for purposes of classification. Structural criteria provided by techniques such as X-ray diffraction, Raman spectroscopy, and, especially, transmission electron microscopy help to establish a rational classification of the wide range of carbon materials. The degrees of graphitization and orientation of the basic constituents justify the properties of very different types of carbon solids. The planar, axial, point, and random types of orientation of the BSUs, plus the situations in between, give rise to a wide variety of solids that have different relations with adsorption. Although random nanotexture is particularly relevant as it gives rise to a well-developed porosity, other nanotextures are also important in relation to other aspects of adsorption by carbons. Models developed to describe the molecular structure of carbons are subject to continuous improvements due to the need to obtain accurate descriptions of features evidenced by experimental results.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Financial support from the Spanish CSIC is gratefully acknowledged.
REFERENCES 1. Inagaki, M. (2000). New Carbons. Control of Structure and Functions. Elsevier. 2. Inagaki, M. and Kang, F. (2006). Carbon Materials Science and Engineering - From Fundamentals to Applications. Tsinghua University Press. 3. Bansal, R.C. and Goyal, M. (2005). Activated Carbon Adsorption. Taylor and Francis. 4. McKee, D.W. and Mimeault, V.J. (1973). Surface properties of carbon fibers. Chem. Phys. Carbon, 8, 151-243. 5. Ehrburger, P. (1990). Surface properties of carbon fibres. In Carbon Fibers, Filaments and Composites Figueiredo, C.A. Bernardo, R.T.K. Baker, and K.J. Hiittinger, eds). Kluwer Academic Publishers, pp. 147-161. 6. Bottani, E.J. and Tasc6n, J.M.D. (2004). Energetics of physical adsorption of gases and vapors on carbons. Chem. Phys. Carbon, 29, 209-423. 7. Edwards, LA.S. (1989). Structure in carbons and carbon forms. In Introduction to Carbon Science (H. Marsh, ed.). Butterworths, pp. 1-36. 8. Marsh, H. (1997). Carbon materials: an overview of carbon artifacts. In Introduction to Carbon Technologies (H. Marsh, E.A. Heintz, and F. Rodriguez-Reinoso, eds). Publicaciones de la Universidad de Alicante, Chapter 1, pp. 1-34.
a.L.
44
Chapter
2
Overview of Carbon Materials in Relation to Adsorption
9. Schlagl, R. (1997). Carbons. In Handbook ofHeterogeneous Catalysis, Vol. 1 (G. Ertl, H. Knazinger, andJ. Weitkamp, eds). Wiley-VCH, pp. 138-91. 10. McEnaney, B. (1999). Structure and bonding in carbon materials. In Carbon Materials for Advanced Technologies (T.D. Burchell, ed.). Pergamon, Chapter 1, pp. 1-33. 11. Bourrat, X. (2000). Structure in carbons and carbon artefacts. In Sciences of Carbon Materials (H. Marsh and F. Rodriguez-Reinoso, eds). Publicaciones de la Universidad de Alicante, Chapter 1, pp. 1-97. 12. Fiala,J. (2000). New structures in carbon-based materials. In Sciences of Carbon Materials (H. Marsh and F. Rodriguez-Reinoso, eds). Publicaciones de la Universidad de Alicante, Chapter 2, pp. 99-115. 13. Delhaes, P. (2001). Polymorphism in carbons and parent materials. In Design and Control of Structure of Advanced Carbon Materials for Enhanced Peiformance (B. Rand, S.P. Appleyard, and M.F. Yardim, eds). Kluwer, pp. 3-27. 14. Bourrat, X. (2001). Characterisation of carbon structure. In Design and Control of Structure of Advanced Carbon Materials for Enhanced Peiformance (B. Rand, S.P. Appleyard, and M.F. Yardim, eds). Kluwer, pp. 43-64. 15. Bandosz, T., Biggs, M.J., Gubbins, K.E., et a1. (2003). Molecular models for porous carbons. Chem. Phys. Carbon, 28, 41-228. 16. Fitzer, E., Kachling, K.-H., Boehm, H.-P., and Marsh, H. (1995). Recommended terminology for the description of carbon as a solid. Pure Appl. Chem., 67, 473-506. 17. Sing, K.S.W., Everett, D.H., Haul, R.A.W., et a1. (1985). Reporting physisorption data for gas/solid systems with special reference to the determination of surface area and porosity. Pure Appl. Chem., 57, 603-19. 18. Rouquerol, J., Avnir, D., Fairbridge, C.W., et al. (1994). Recommendations for the characterization of porous solids. Pure Appl. Chem., 66, 1739-58. 19. Wilks, J. and Wilks, E. (1994). Properties and Applications of Diamond. ButterworthHeinemann. 20. Gielisse, P.J. (1998). Mechanical properties of diamond, diamond films, diamondlike carbon and like-diamond materials. In Handbook of Industrial Diamonds and Diamond Films (M.A. Prelas, G. Popovici, and L.K. Bigelow, eds). Marcel Dekker, Chapter 3, pp. 49-88. 21. Lopez-Gonzalez, J.D., Deitz, V.R., and Carpenter, F.G. (1961). Adsorption of nitrogen and argon on mineralogical graphite and diamond at 77 and 90 o K.J. Phys. Chem., 65,1112-19. 22. D'Evelyn, M.P. (1998). Surface properties of diamond. In Handbook of Industrial Diamonds and Diamond Films (M.A. Prelas, G. Popovici, and L.K. Bigelow, eds). Marcel Dekker, Chapter 4, pp. 89-146. 23. Heimann, R.B., Kleiman, J., and Salansky, N.M. (1984). Structural aspects and conformation of linear carbon polytypes (carbynes). Carbon, 22, 147-55. 24. Haddon, R.C., Palmer, R.E., Kroto, H.W., and Sermon, P.A. (1993). The fullerenes: powerful carbon-based electron acceptors. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. Sere A - Phys. Sci. Eng., 343, 53-62. 25. Charlier, J.-C., Gonze, X., and Michenaud, J.-P. (1994). First-principles study of the stacking effect on the electronic properties of graphite(s). Carbon, 32, 289-99. 26. Kavan, L. and Kastner, J. (1994). Carbyne forms of carbon: continuation of the story. Carbon, 32, 1533-6. 27. Heimann, R.B., Evsyukov, S.E., and Koga, Y. (1997). Carbon allotropes: a suggested classification scheme based on valence orbital hybridization. Carbon, 35, 1654-8.
References
45
28. Kudryavtsev, Yu. P., Evsyukov, S., Guseva, M., et al. (1997). Carbyne - a linear chainlike carbon allotrope. Chem. Phys. Carbon, 25, 1-69. 29. Tanuma, S.1. and Palnichenko, A. (1995). Synthesis of low density carbon crystal "carbolite" by quenching of carbon gas.]. Mater. Res., 10, 1120-5. 30. Dresselhaus, M.S. (1977). Future directions in carbon science. Annu. Rev. Mater. Sci., 27, 1-34. 31. Bundy, F.P., Bassett, W.A., Weathers, M.S., et al. (1996). The pressuretemperature phase and transformation diagram for carbon; updated through 1994. Camon, 34, 141-53. 32. Donnet, J.B. (2006). Les allotropes du carbone: une grande famille. Actualite Chimique, 295-296, 115-18. 33. Tanabe, Y. and Yasuda, E. (2000). Carbon alloys. Carbon, 38, 329-34. 34. Yasuda, E., Inagaki, M., Kaneko, K., et al. (eds) (2003). Carbon Alloys: New Concepts to Develop Carbon Science and Technology. Elsevier. 35. Marsh, H. (1986). Structure in carbons. In Carbon and Coal Gasification Figueiredo and J.A. Moulijn, eds). Martinus Nijho£I: pp. 27-56. 36. Hiittinger, K.J. (1990). The potential of the graphite lattice. Adv. Mater., 2, 349-55. 37. Chung, D.D.L. (2002). Review graphite.]. Mater. Sci., 37, 1475-89. 38. Franklin, R.E. (1951). Crystallite growth in graphitiZing and non-graphitizing carbons. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A, 209, 196-218. 39. Oberlin, A. (1984). Carbonization and graphitization. Carbon, 22, 521-41. 40. Granda, M., Santamaria, R., and Menendez, R. (2003). Coal tar pitch: composition and pyrolysis behavior. Chem. Phys. Carbon, 28, 263-330. 41. Inagaki, M., Takeichi, T., Hishiyama, Y., and Oberlin, A. (1999). High quality graphite films produced from aromatic polyimides. Chem. Phys. Carbon, 26, 245-333. 42. Oberlin, A. (1989). High-resolution TEM studies of carbonization and graphitization. Chem. Phys. Carbon, 22, 1-143. 43. Oberlin, A., Bonnamy, S., and Rouxhet, P.G. (1999). Colloidal and supramolecular aspects of carbon. Chern. Phys. Carbon, 26, 1-148. 44. Inagaki, M. and Tascon, J.M.D. (2006). Pore formation and control in carbon materials. In Activated Carbon Surfaces in Environmental Remediation (T.J. Bandosz, ed.). Elsevier, pp. 49-105. 45. Emmerich, F.G. (1995). Evolution with heat treatment of crystallinity in carbons. Carbon, 33, 1709-15. 46. Iwashita, N., Park, C.R., Fujimoto, H., et al. (2004). Specification for a standard procedure of X-ray diffraction measurements on carbon materials. Carbon, 42, 701-14. 47. Tuinstra, F. and Koenig, J.L. (1970). Raman spectrum of graphite. J. Chem. Phys., 53, 1126-30. 48. Cuesta, A., Dhamelincourt, P., Laureyns, J., et al. (1994). Raman microprobe studies on carbon materials. Carbon, 32, 1523-32. 49. Cuesta, A., Dhamelincourt, P., Laureyns,J., et al. (1998). Comparative performance of X-ray diffraction and Raman microprobe techniques for the study of carbon materials. J. Mater. Chem., 8, 2875-9. 50. Inagaki, M. (1985). Microstructure of carbon materials (in Japanese). Tanso, 122, 114-21.
a.L.
Chapter
2
Overview of Carbon Materials in Relation to Adsorption
51. Akuzawa, N. (2003). Intercalation compounds. In Carbon Alloys. New Concepts to Develop Carbon Science and Technology (E. Yasuda, M. Inagaki, K. Kaneko, et aI., eds). Elsevier, pp. 99-108. 52. Inagaki, M., Kang, F., and Toyoda, M. (2004). Exfoliation of graphite via intercalation compounds. Chern. Phys. Carbon, 29, 1-69. 53. Celzard, A., Mareche,J.F., and Furdin, G. (2005). Modelling of exfoliated graphite. Prog. Mater. Sci., 50, 93-179. 54. Seibold, K.J. and Fischer, F.G. (1973). Properties of high surface area graphite. Carbon, 11, 683. 55. Castillejos-Lopez, E., Bachiller-Baeza, B., Nevskaia, D.M., et al. (2006). Interactions between toluene and aniline and graphite surfaces. Carbon, 44, 3130-3. 56. Klett, J., Hardy, R., Romine, E., et al. (2000). High-thermal-conductivity, mesophase-pitch-derived carbon foams: effect of precursor on structure and properties. Carbon, 38, 953-73. 57. Gallego, N.C. and Klett, J.W. (2003). Carbon foams for thermal management. Carbon, 41, 1461-6. 58. Bhushan, B. (ed.) (2004). Springer Handbook of Nanotechnology. Springer, p. 43. 59. Lee, C.J., Park, J.H. and Park, J. (2000). Synthesis of bamboo-shaped multiwalled carbon nanotubes using thermal chemical vapor deposition. Chern. Phys. Lett., 323, 560-5. 60. Iijima, S., Yudasaka, M., Yamada, R., et al. (1999). Nano-aggregates of singlewalled graphitic nano-horns. Chern. Phys. Lett., 309, 165-70. 61. Yang, C.M., Noguchi, H., Murata, K., et al. (2005). Highly ultramicroporous single-walled carbon nanohorn assemblies. Adv. Mater., 17, 866-86. 62. Endo, M., Kim, Y.A., Matusita, T., and Hayashi, T. (2001). From vapor-grown carbon fibers (VGCFs) to carbon nanotubes. In Carbon Filaments and Nanotubes: Common Origins, Differing Applications? (L.P. Biro, C.A. Bernardo, G.G. Tibbetts, and Ph. Lambin, eds). Kluwer Academic Publishers, pp. 51-61. 63. Paredes, J.I., Burghard, M., Martinez-Alonso, A., and Tascon, J.M.D. (2005). Graphitization of carbon nanofibers: visualizing the structural evolution on the nanometer and atomic scales by scanning tunneling microscopy. Appl. Phys. A, 80, 675-82. 64. Biro, L.P., Bernardo, C.A., Tibbetts, G.G., and Lambin, Ph. (2001). Carbon Filaments and Nanotubes: Common Origins, Differing Applications? Kluwer Academic Publishers, pp. 343-5. 65. Kim, Y.-A., Hayashi, T., Naokawa, S., et al. (2005). Comparative study of herringbone and stacked-cup carbon nanofibers. Carbon, 43, 3005-8. 66. Cho, T., Lee, Y.S., Rao, A.M., et al. (2003). Structure of carbon fiber obtained from nanotube-reinforced mesophase pitch. Carbon, 41, 1419-24. 67. Yoon, S.-H., Korai, Y., and Mochida, I. (1996). Axial nano-scale microstructures in graphitized fibers inherited from liquid crystal mesophase pitch. Carbon, 34, 941-56. 68. Mochida, I., Yoon, S.-H., Takano, N., et al. (1996). Microstructure of mesophase pitch-based carbon fiber and its control. Carbon, 34, 941-56. 69. Edie D.D. (1998). The effect of processing on the structure and properties of carbon fibers. Carbon, 36, 345-62. 70. Oberlin, A., Bonnamy, S., and Lafdi, K. (1998). Structure and texture of carbon fibers. In Carbon Fibers, 3rd edn a.-B. Donnet, T.K. Wang, J.e.M. Peng, and S. Rebouillat, eds). Marcel Dekker, pp. 85-159.
References
47
71. Wang, T.K., Donnet, J.-B., Peng, J.C.M., and Rebouillat, S. (1998). Surface properties of carbon fibers. In Carbon Fibers, 3rd edn G.-B. Donnet, T.K. Wang, J.C.M. Peng, and S. Rebouillat, eds). Marcel Dekker, pp. 231-309. 72. Donnet, J.-B., Bansal, R.C., and Wang, M.-J. (eds) (1993). Carbon Black Science and Technology, 2nd edn. Marcel Dekker. 73. Ugarte, D. (1992). Curling and closure of graphitic networks under electron-beam irradiation. Nature, 359, 707-9. 74. Roy, D., Chhowalla, M., Wang, H., et al. (2003). Characterisation of carbon nano-onions using Raman spectroscopy. Chern. Phys. Lett., 373, 52-6. 75. Harris, P.J.F. (2003). Impact of the discovery of fullerenes on carbon science. Chern. Phys. Carbon, 28, 1-39. 76. Heidenreich, R.D., Hess, W.M., and Ban, L.L. (1968). A test object and criteria for high resolution electron microscopy. J. Appl. Cryst., 1, 1-19. 77. Hess, W.M. and Herd, C.R. (1993). Microstructure, morphology and general physical properties. In Carbon Black Science and Technology G.-B. Donnet, R.C. Bansal, and M.-J. Wang, eds). Marcel Dekker, Chapter 3, pp. 89-173. 78. Bansal, R.C. and Donnet, J.-B. (1993). Mechanism of carbon black formation. In Carbon Black Science and Technology G.-B. Donnet, R.C. Bansal, and M.-J. Wang, eds). Marcel Dekker, Chapter 2, pp. 67-88. 79. Dresselhaus, M.S., Dresselhaus, G., and Eklund, P.C. (1996). Science of Fullerenes and Carbon Nanotubes. Academic Press, Chapter 3, pp. 110-42. 80. Zhang, Q.L., O'Brien, S.C., Heath, J.R., et al. (1986). Reactivity of large carbon clusters - spheroidal carbon shells and their possible relevance to the formation and morphology of soot. J. Phys. Chern., 90, 525-8. 81. Kroto, H.W. and McKay, K. (1988). The formation of quasi-icosahedral spiral shell carbon particles. Nature, 331, 328-31. 82. Hishiyama, Y., Yoshida, A., and Inagaki, M. (1982). Microstructure of carbon spherules. Carbon, 20, 79-84. 83. Brooks, J.D. and Taylor, G.H. (1969). The formation of some graphitized carbons. Chern. Phys. Carbon, 4, 243-86. 84. Jenkins, G.M. and Kawamura, K. (1971). Structure of glassy carbon. Nature, 231, 175-6. 85. Jenkins, G.M., Kawamura, K., and Ban, L.L. (1972). Formation and structure of polymeric carbons. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A, 327, 501-17. 86. Shiraishi, M. (1984). Introduction to Carbon Materials (in Japanese). Carbon Society ofJapan, p. 29. 87. Yoshida, A., Kaburagi, Y., and Hishiyama, Y. (1991). Microtexture and magnetoresistance of glass-like carbons. Carbon, 29, 1107-11. 88. Harris, P.J.F. (1997). Structure of non-graphitising carbons. Intern. Mater. Rev., 42, 206-18. 89. Ban, L.L., Crawford, D., and Marsh, H. (1975). Lattice-resolution electronmicroscopy in structural studies of non-graphitizing carbons from polyvinylidene chloride (PVDC). J. Appl. Cryst., 8, 415-20. 90. Oberlin, A., Villey, M., and Combaz, A. (1980). Influence of elemental composition on carbonization. Pyrolysis of kerosene shale and kuckersite. Carbon, 18, 347-53. 91. Rouzaud, J.N. and Oberlin, A. (1989). Structure, microtexture, and optical properties of anthracene and saccharose-based carbons. Carbon, 27, 517-29.
Chapter
2
Overview of Carbon Materials in Relation to Adsorption
92. Harris, P.J.F. and Tsang, S.C. (1997). High-resolution electron microscopy studies of non-graphitizing carbons. Phil. Mag. A, 76, 667-77. 93. Harris, P.J.F., Burian, A., and Duber, S. (2000). High-resolution electron microscopy of a microporous carbon. Phil. Mag. Lett., 80, 381-6. 94. Townsend, S.J., Lenosky, T.J., Muller, D.A., et al. (1992). Negatively curved graphitic sheet model of amorphous carbon. Phys. Rev. Lett., 69, 921-4. 95. Mackay, A.L. and Terrones, H. (1991). Diamond from graphite. Nature, 352, 762. 96. Benedek, G., Vahedi-Tafreshi, H., Barborini, E., et al. (2003). The structure of negatively curved spongy carbon. Diamond Relat. Mater., 12, 768-73. 97. Diederich, F. and Rubin, Y. (1992). Synthetic approaches toward molecular and polymeric carbon allotropes. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 31,1101-23. 98. Bunz, U.H.F., Rubin, Y., and Tobe, Y. (1999). Polyethynylated cyclic p-systems: scaffoldings for novel two and three-dimensional carbon networks. Chem. Soc. Rev., 28, 107-19. 99. Mays, T.J. (1999). Active carbon fibers. In Carbon Materials for Advanced Technologies (T.D. Burchell, ed.). Pergamon, Chapter 3, pp. 95-118. 100. Menendez-Diaz, A. and Martin-Gu1l6n, I. (2006). Types of carbon adsorbents and their production. In Activated Carbon Surfaces in Environmental Remediation (T .J. Bandosz, ed.) . Elsevier, pp. 1-47. 101. Freeman,J.J., Gimblett, F.G.R., Hayes, R.A., et al. (1991). Adsorptive properties of activated carbons prepared from Kevlar*. In Characterization of Porous Solids II (F. Rodriguez-Reinoso, J. Rouquerol, K.S.W. Sing, and K.K. Unger, eds). Elsevier, pp. 319-28. 102. Villar-Rodil, S., Suarez-Garcia, F., Paredes, J.I., et al. (2005).Activated carbon materials of uniform porosity from polyaramid fibers. Chem. Mater., 17,5893-908. 103. Yang, R.T. (2003). Adsorbents. Fundamentals and Applications. Wiley-Interscience, Chapter 5, pp. 79-130. 104. Pekala, R.W. and Kong, F.M. (1989). Resorcinol-formaldehyde aerogels and their carbonized derivatives. Abstr. Pap. Am. Chem. Soc., 197, 113. 105. Job, N., Thery, A., Pirard, R., et al. (2005). Carbon aerogels, cryogels and xerogels: influence of the drying method on the textural properties of porous carbon materials. Carbon, 43, 2481-94. 106. Byrne, J.F. and Marsh, H. (1995). Introductory overview. In Porosity in Carbons: Characterization and Applications O.W. Patrick, ed.). Edward Arnold, pp. 1-48. 107. McEnaney, B. (2002). Properties of activated carbons. In Handbook of Porous Solids, Vol. 3 (F. Schuth, K.S.W. Sing, and J. Weitkamp, eds). Wiley-VCH, pp. 1828-63. 108. Kyotani, T. (2000). Control of pore structure in carbon. Carbon, 38, 269-86. 109. Ryoo, R., Joo, S.H., and Jun, S. (1999). Synthesis of highly ordered carbon molecular sieves via template-mediated structural transformation. J. Phys. Chem. B, 103, 7743-6. 110. Lee, J., Yoon, S., Hyeon, T., et al. (1999). Synthesis of a new mesoporous carbon and its application to electrochemical double-layer capacitors. Chem. Commun., 2177-8. 111. Lee, J., Han, S., and Hyeon, T. (2004). Synthesis of new nanoporous carbon materials using nanostructured silica materials as templates. J. Mater. Chem., 14, 478-86.
References
49
112. Ryoo, R. and Joo, S.H. (2004). Nanostructured carbon materials synthesized from mesoporous silica crystals by replication. Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal., 148, 241-60. 113. Darmstadt, H., Roy, C., Kaliaguine, S., et al. (2002). Surface chemistry of ordered mesoporous carbons. Carbon, 40, 2673-83. 114. Darmstadt, H., Roy, C., Kaliaguine, S., et al. (2003). Pore structure and graphitic surface nature of ordered mesoporous carbons probed by low-pressure nitrogen adsorption. Microp. Mesop. Mater., 60, 139-49. 115. Dupont-Pavlovsky, N. (1965). Adsorption d'azote et d'argon sur des gels de silice dans Ie domaine des basses pressions d'equilibre. Bull. Soc. Chim. Fr., 1269. 116. Duval, X. and Thorny, A. (1975). Interpretation of krypton adsorption-isotherms on exfoliated graphite. Carbon, 13, 242-3. 117. Thorny, A. and Duval, X. (1994). Stepwise isotherms and phase transitions in physisorbed films. Surf. Sci., 299-300, 415-25. 118. Kim, T.-W., Park, I.S., and Ryoo, R. (2003). A synthetic route to ordered mesoporous carbon materials with graphitic pore walls. Angew. Chern., 42, 4375-9. 119. Li, Z. and Jaroniec, M. (2001). Colloidal imprinting: a novel approach to the synthesis of mesoporous carbons. J. Am. Chern. Soc., 123, 9208-9. 120. Li, Z. andJaroniec, M. (2004). Colloid-imprinted carbons as stationary phases for reversed-phase liquid chromatography. Anal. Chern., 76, 5479-85. 121. Ma, Z., Kyotani, T., Liu, Z., et al. (2001). Very high surface area microporous carbon with a three-dimensional nano-array structure: synthesis and its molecular structure. Chern. Mater., 13, 4413-15. 122. Ma, Z., Kyotani, T., and Tomita, A. (2002). Synthesis methods for preparing microporous carbons with a structural regularity ofzeolite Y. Carbon, 40, 2367-74. 123. Matsuoka, K., Yamagishi, Y., Yamazaki, T., et al. (2005). Extremely high microporosity and sharp pore size distribution of a large surface area carbon prepared in the nanochannels of zeolite Y. Carbon, 43, 876-9. 124. Kaneko, K., Ishii, C., Ruike, M., and Kuwabara, H. (1992). Origin of superhigh surface area and microcrystalline graphitic structures of activated carbons. Carbon, 30, 1075-88. 125. Paredes, J.I., Martinez-Alonso, A., Yamazaki, T., et al. (2005). Structural investigation of zeolite-templated, ordered microporous carbon by scanning tunneling microscopy and Raman spectroscopy. Langmuir, 21, 8817-23. 126. Novoselov, K.N., Geim, A.K., Morozov, S.V., et al. (2004). Electric field effect in atomically thin carbon films. Science, 306, 666-9.
ENERGETICS OF GAS ADSORPTION BY CARBONS: THERMODYNAMIC QUANTITIES Eduardo J. BottanP and Juan M.D. Tasc6n 2 Ilnstituto de Investigaciones Fisicoqufmicas Te6ricas y Aplicadas (lNIFTA), UNLP-CIC-CONICET, La Plata, Argentina; 21nstituto Nacional del Carb6n, CSIC, Oviedo, Spain
Contents 3.1 Introduction 3.2 Classical Thermodynamics 3.3 Statistical Mechanics 3.4 Thermodynamic Quantities and Experimental Results 3.5 Conclusions Acknowledgment References
3.1
53 54 59 66 71
71 72
INTRODUCTION
This chapter is concerned with the energetics of gas adsorption on carbons, or more specifically the thermodynamic quantities involved when carbon materials are employed as the adsorbents. Out of these solids, activated carbons, due to their exceptional surface area development and consequent technological implications, are the carbonaceous adsorbents that have attracted the attention of most publications. A more comprehensive account of the energetic aspects of adsorption on carbons has been published elsewhere [1]. The behavior of molecules adsorbed on the surface of a solid depends on the properties of both the adsorbent surface and the adsorbate itself Among the most relevant characteristics of the adsorbent are its chemical nature, its Adsorption by Carbons ISBN: 978-0-08-044464-2
© 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
53
Chapter 3 Energetics of Gas Adsorption by Carbons: Thermodynamic Quantities
54
topography, and the presence of impurities. For the adsorbate, it is important to consider molecular size, shape, and its electronic configuration. It has also been demonstrated that temperature or, more precisely, the thermal energy of the adsorbate and lateral interactions are factors from which a balance is established that defines the thermodynamic properties of the adsorbed phase. Since it is the interactions that determine the behavior of the adsorbed phase, the problem reduces itself to one single concept: energy. This justifies the relevance of the thermodynamic aspects of adsorption that constitute the subject analyzed here. Relevant previous publications on adsorption energetics include, besides the classical text by Gregg and Sing [2], a more recent book by Rouquerol et al. [3] on adsorption by powders and porous solids. This book covers thermodynamic aspects of adsorption at the gas-solid and liquid-solid interfaces, and an entire chapter is devoted to adsorption on activated carbons. In addition, two books by Bansal et al. [4, 5] review in commendable detail the literature on adsorption by activated carbons. The task of reviewing the thermodynamics of gas adsorption by carbons is complicated by several factors. One of them is the variability of carbon materials discussed in Chapter 2. Another is the large amount of published literature, produced over a long period and generated under very different environments and thus potentially very different conditions. This has prompted us to focus our analysis on recent work, assuming that older studies may be outdated by new ones thanks to advances in instrumentation and to the logical progress of SCIence. This chapter includes cursory descriptions of the classical and statistical thermodynamic approaches to gas adsorption in the form of a summary of the main equations. These aspects provide the basic knowledge necessary to design, understand, and interpret the experiments and the data derived from them. We complete this with a brief description of the basic principles and applications that constitute the bridge between theory and experiments. In every section, a certain logical order of presentation is maintained. We group the results obtained on homogeneous surfaces followed by those obtained from heterogeneous solids. Each group begins with adsorption of simple gases and is followed by other adsorbates of increasing complexity. Finally, papers dealing with adsorption of gas mixtures are discussed.
3.2
CLASSICAL THERMODYNAMICS
Several formalisms have been developed leading to what may be called practical thermodynamics. These treatments include the analog of solution thermodynamics, where the adsorbent and the adsorbate are considered as components in a two-phase equilibrium [6]. Another way to study the system is to use the surface excess approach, whereby the properties of the adsorbed phase are determined in terms of the properties of the real two-phase multicomponent
3.2 Classical Thermodynamics
55
system and the properties of the same system without an interface [7]. This method could be considered as an extension of solution thermodynamics [8]. Its main shortcoming is that specification of the reference system is sometimes problematic. The most preferred approach for studying the thermodynamics of adsorption on solids considers the adsorbed phase as a distinct phase located on the surface of the solid, which is considered to be inert. Here, the concept of inertness of the adsorbent presupposes that no chemical reactions between it and the adsorbate are possible, and that the structure of the solid is rigid. Thus, in this formalism, the properties of the adsorbent and the gas phase are not explicitly included in the calculation. According to the law of conservation of energy, the total energy U is a constant provided that the system is isolated and its volume remains constant. Thus, oUS,V,n
=0
(3.1)
where V is the volume, n is the amount of substance, and S is the entropy. Equation (3.1) can be applied to the gas alone if the solid adsorbent is considered inert. Following the treatment developed by Hill in his classical papers on the thermodynamics of small systems [9], it is possible to divide the adsorption space into small elements. These elements are sufficiently large to enable the characterization of the gas contained in them, and small enough to allow the thermodynamic properties inside them to be considered as local ones. Since the first law of thermodynamics must be valid for each of the space elements, Eqn (3.1) takes the form (3.2) where the superscript identifies the space element and J.L is the chemical potential. Equation (3.2) represents the energy changes due to the reversible transfer of thermal energy between different space elements, the reversible work due to volume changes, and the energy due to the reversible transfer of gas molecules across the boundary of the space element. A more useful form of Eqn (3.2) can be derived through the concept of spreading pressure, by assuming that the force per unit area perpendicular to the surface of the solid is different from the force per unit area on the plane parallel to the surface. The resulting equation is dU(a)
= TdS(a) -
c/J(a)dA(a) -
pd V(a)
+ j.Ldn(a)
(3.3)
Equation (3.3), written for the adsorbed phase, can be used to derive expressions relating to experimental quantities like the amount adsorbed at a given temperature and pressure, such as
{s(a) - S(g)} d T = {V(a) -
V(g)}
dp + ~d
(3.4)
56
Chapter 3 Energetics of Gas Adsorption by Carbons: Thermodynamic Quantities
where p is the vapor pressure of the adsorbed layer, and where the tildes indicate a mean molar quantity. From Eqn (3.4), it is possible to obtain ClausiusClapeyron-type expressions. Moreover, ifthe spreading pressure is kept constant,
sea) v(a) -
S(g)
(3.5)
V(g)
or, if a constant temperature is maintained,
(d¢) = dp
[v(a) _
V(g)]
n(a)
A
T
(3.6)
Several enthalpies can be obtained to describe the adsorption equilibrium. The first is the so-called equilibrium enthalpy, qeq:
_q = eq
[;(a)
+pv(a) + cPA n(a)
-
[;(g)
-pV(g)
(3.7)
Assuming that the gas phase is ideal and that the density of the adsorbed phase is close to the density of the bulk liquid it is possible to arrive at (3.8a) or dlnp ) ( dT cf>
(3.8b)
Equation (3.8) shows that the equilibrium enthalpy can be calculated from experimental data, i.e., if the dependence of the isotherm on temperature at constant spreading pressure is known. However the use ofEqns (3.8a) and (3.8b) is cumbersome because it requires the previous calculation of the spreading pressure instead of the use of raw experimental data, i.e., n(a) vs p. Furthermore, the molar quantities appearing in Eqn (3.7) are not the natural variables for adsorption systems. In preference to molar quantities, partial molar entropy and internal energy are generally used; these quantities measure the changes in these properties when an infinitesimal change occurs in the number of adsorbed moles at constant temperature, pressure, and area. To be able to relate these quantities to experimental measurements, differentiation of the chemical potential of the adsorbed phase (in Eqn (3.7)) and rearrangement finally leads to (3.9) This expression gives the definition ofthe enthalpy known as isosteric enthalpy of adsorption. Equation (3.9) can be simplified to
T (V(g) -
(3.10) v(a))
3.2 Classical Thermodynamics
57
Again, as in the case of Eqn (3.8), if the adsorbed phase is assumed to be liquid-like, Eqn (3.10) reduces to
(
dlnp ) dT n,A
(3.11)
There is at least one other enthalpy related to the experimental data. This enthalpy is obtained in a calorimetric experiment under adiabatic conditions. The experiment consists of adding gas, in a reversible manner, to the calorimeter containing the adsorbent. An alternative process could be considered as a way to simplify the problem. Instead of adding gas to the system, imagine that the adsorbed molecules are transferred from the gas phase to the adsorbed phase by the action of a piston that changes the gas phase volume by an amount d V(g) . Assuming that the area of the adsorbate is unchanged during the process, that the adsorbed phase is liquid-like, and that the gas phase is ideal, it is possible to derive the expression _ qad -
qst
+ V (g)
(
dp ) d (a) n
(3.12) ad
This relationship shows that it is possible to calculate the isosteric enthalpy of adsorption from calorimetric experiments. In summary, it has been shown how the enthalpies of adsorption are obtained either calorimetrically or from the dependence of the isotherms on temperature. Although the definitions given above for the different enthalpies of adsorption are rigorous, it is necessary to show that they exhibit the same properties as the enthalpy of vaporization, i.e., the heat necessary to vaporize one mole ofliquid at constant pressure and using a reversible and isothermal process. Moreover, only the isosteric enthalpy is related in a simple way to the heat required in a process that is reversible and isothermic. Suppose that moles of adsorbate are transferred to the gas phase at constant temperature and pressure. According to the first law of thermodynamics:
an
(3.13) If the area of the solid is kept constant, this expression leads to
(oQ) A
ou(a)) = (On(a)
On(a) + T,p,A
OV(g)) +p ( - on(g) On(g)
(OU(g))
-On(g)
on(g)
+ p (ov(a)) -On(a)
on(a) T,p,A
(3.14)
Using the definitions of mean molar and partial molar quantities, Eqn (3.14) becomes (3.15)
Chapter 3 Energetics of Gas Adsorption by Carbons: Thermodynamic Quantities
58
Since Bn(g)
= -on(a) = On, Eqn (3.15)
can be written as (3.16)
According to Eqn (3.9) this quantity is equal to the isosteric enthalpy, qst' which turns out to be equal to the heat per mole evolved in the reversible transfer of an infinitesimal amount of adsorbate from the adsorbed phase to the gas phase at constant temperature, pressure, and area. Up to this point the essential equations have been presented. Now, it is possible to analyze the work carried out in connection with the classical thermodynamic approach. The first systematic study of a thermodynamic adsorption quantity was perhaps the work done by de Boer and coworkers [10] on the determination, interpretation and significance of the enthalpy and entropy of adsorption. Their papers analyzed almost all aspects of the experimental determination of the entropy and how to interpret the values obtained in terms of two extreme models, i.e., those of mobile and localized adsorption, which today have lost much of their usefulness. To catalog the behavior of the adsorbed film as localized or mobile is a very simplistic solution and it has been demonstrated [9] that in most cases the adsorbed film is neither completely localized nor completely mobile. This approach also is somehow outdated because numerical simulations provide a better microscopic interpretation of the system's behavior. Fomkin et al. [11] have reported a slightly different treatment in which they use Eqn (3.11) to calculate the isosteric heat of adsorption of perfluoropropane adsorbed on PAC (powdered activated carbon) microporous carbon. Agarwal et al. [12] determined the entropy of the adsorbed phase for methane, ethane, ethylene, propane, carbon dioxide, and nitrogen adsorbed at high pressures on activated carbon. Bottani et al. [13] also employed the classical approach to obtain the entropy of the adsorbed phase for N 2 and CO 2 adsorbed on "graphitized" carbon blacks. The authors discussed several problems regarding the precision of the obtained values using Eqn (3.11) or equivalent equations, and how they could be employed to characterize the surface of carbonaceous materials. More recently, Sircar et al. [14] employed the Gibbsian Surface Excess model to describe the multicomponent adsorption of gas mixtures. They also showed that this model for multicomponent adsorption could define unambiguously the isosteric heats of adsorption for the components of a gas mixture. These variables can be experimentally determined using multicomponent differential calorimetry and then be used to describe the nonisothermal behavior of practical adsorbents. Mezzasalma [15] employed a condition of maximum irreversible entropy production in the framework of a variational procedure where the isotherm equations are represented by a convergent sequence of ordinary functions. Milewska-Duda et al. [16] employed the thermodynamic approach described above to derive an adsorption isotherm, similar to the BET equation, which
3.3 Statistical Mechanics
59
can describe adsorption in microporous structures provided that restrictions for pore capacity are taken into account. Asnin et al. [17] demonstrated that the classical thermodynamic approach does not contradict the molecular statistical theory and that it yields equations that are more general. Based on Eqn (3.4) and similar expressions for the internal energy, they analyzed the particular case of the Freundlich adsorption isotherm. With data obtained from Kr adsorption on high-modulus carbon fibers, Drzal et al. [18] determined the isosteric heat of adsorption and the entropy of the adsorbed phase and demonstrated that such fibers, which undergo a high-temperature graphitization treatment, possess a very homogeneous surface very similar to that of the basal plane of graphite. Sircar [19] has presented a thermodynamic treatment ofgas mixture adsorption on heterogeneous adsorbents with particular emphasis on the estimation of the isosteric heat of adsorption. He stated that the isosteric heat of adsorption on an energetically heterogeneous adsorbent could vary substantially depending on the fractional loadings of the adsorbates, which, in turn, depend on the equilibrium gas-phase pressure, temperature, and composition. Myers [20] has developed thermodynamic equations for adsorption of multicomponent gas mixtures on microporous adsorbents based on the principles of solution thermodynamics. He argued that the conventional spreading pressure and surface variables, which describe bidimensional films, must be abandoned for adsorption in micropores, in which spreading pressure cannot be measured experimentally or calculated from intermolecular forces. Li et al. [21] recently reviewed the progress made in predicting the equilibria of multicomponent mixture adsorption. They discussed the problems encountered in applying theories developed for subcritical mixtures to supercritical gases. In a recent paper, Chiang et al. [22] reported values of the free energy, enthalpy, and entropy of adsorption of volatile organic compounds (exemplified by benzene and methylethylketone) on seven samples of activated carbon. The starting point for their development was Eqn (3.11) for the isosteric heat of adsorption. Linders et al. [23] determined adsorption heats from the adsorption equilibrium constant and found that these values agree quite well with those obtained from uptake experiments using the integrated form ofEqn (3.11). They analyzed the experimental data obtained for n-butane adsorbed on two commercial activated carbons (Kureha and Sorbonorit B3) and for hexafluoropropylene adsorbed on activated carbon.
3.3
STATISTICAL MECHANICS
The statistical mechanics formalism is probably the most efficient way to connect molecular models with experimental data. We present here a brief summary of the most important equations used for numerical simulations. Of all the statistical ensembles that can be employed, the canonical and grand canonical
60
Chapter 3 Energetics of Gas Adsorption by Carbons: Thermodynamic Quantities
are the most popular. We also restrict our treatment to classical statistical thermodynamics. Thus no quantum effects are taken into account. The probability that molecules 1, 2, 3, ... , N are in the volume elements dr l' dr 2' • • • , dr N located at r l' r 2' •• • , r N is given by the Boltzmann expression (3.17)
where
zt)
is the normalization factor given by (3.18)
Here V is the volume available to the gas molecules and U(r 1 , r 2 , ••• , r N ) is the potential energy of the N molecules. Thus U can be taken as the sum of two terms, gas-solid (Ugs ) and gas-gas (Ugg ) interaction energies: N
L
U(r1,r2, ... ,rN)=LUgs(r;)+
Ugg(rij)
(3.19)
l~i<j~N
i=l
It must be pointed out that this expression implicitly contains terms that depend on the orientation of the molecule with respect to the surface and the orientation of a given molecule with respect to its neighbors when the molecules are nonspherical. Equation (3.19) assumes that the potentials are additive and pairwise; since it does not include three-body or higher terms, this must be considered as an effective potential [8]. A system that is constrained to have a constant number of molecules, volume, and temperature constitutes a canonical ensemble. The thermodynamic properties of the system can be calculated from the corresponding partition function, Q(N, V, 7) [24]. For the adsorbed phase the partition function can be written as z(a) N Q( N " V T) -- N!A3N
(3.20)
where A is a factor that includes the kinetic properties of the molecule. Equation (3.20) shows that the partition function can be written as the product of a configurational factor and a kinetic or nonconfigurational factor, A. This greatly simplifies the application of this approach to the theory of physical adsorption [8]. The main assumption implicitly contained in Eqn (3.20) is that the structural properties of the molecules are independent of the intermolecular interactions in all the important configurations of the system. Even though there is evidence to suggest that this is not strictly true, it is possible to derive the appropriate expressions to calculate the extent of the changes in those properties
61
3.3 Statistical Mechanics
when the molecule is adsorbed. The thermodynamic properties of the system can be calculated from the following expressions:
(3.21)
A=-kTlnQ alnQ )
U=-k a(l/T) (
Q) aln-kT ( av(a)
(3.22) N,v(a),A
(3.23)
P-
N,T,A
Q
A,. (aln o/-kT - -)
aA
(3.24) NT vCa)
where A is the Helmholtz free energy, U is the total energy, p is the pressure, and
(3.25)
where V* is the volume of the gas in its standard state and thus equal to NkT. Using Eqns (3.20) and (3.22) give -U(a)
== k [ alnZt) ]
a(l/T)
_ vCa) A NCa)
3
kN(a) aInA a(l/T)
(3.26)
Equations (3.20) and (3.25), for the gas phase, gives
- U(g)
3
==
kN(g) -alnA -a( 1/ T)
(3.27)
From Eqns (3.26) and (3.27)
au(a) [ a 2 lnZt) ] U = aN(a) = -k aNa(l/T)
alnA 3
-(a)
vCa) ,A,NCa)
+k a(l/T)
(3.28)
and u(g)
fJ(g)
=-
N(g)
alnA 3
= k--a(l/T)
(3.29)
62
Chapter 3 Energetics of Gas Adsorption by Carbons: Thermodynamic Quantities
Since the isosteric heat is given by
qst =
_U(a)
+ [;(g) + kT
(3.30)
substituting Eqns (3.28) and (3.29) into (3.30) yield
qst
=k[
a2lnZt) ]
+ kT
(/)
aNa 1 T
(3.31)
VCa),A,NCa)
In the canonical ensemble approach, the adsorbed phase is treated as a separate phase with a known volume and containing a fixed number of molecules at constant temperature. This approach is somewhat unrealistic even though the results obtained can be successfully correlated with experimental data [8]. If we consider that the gas-solid interactions induce a smooth gradient in the density of the gas as the surface is approached, another formalism is necessary. The solution is obtained by adopting the grand canonical ensemble, in which the fixed variables are the volume, temperature and chemical potential. The unknown quantities would be, e.g., the number of molecules, energy, and pressure. The chemical potential of the adsorbed phase, once the equilibrium condition has been achieved, is equal to the chemical potential of the gas phase, which is determined from the density at a point far from the surface. The amount adsorbed, N(a), can be defined as the difference between the total number of molecules in the system, N, and N*, the number of molecules in a hypothetical system of equal volume but with no gas-solid interactions. The grand partition function for the system with gas-solid interactions is given by
a= L
N~O
Q N (V, T) exp
(J-LN)
(3.32)
kT
where QN is the canonical partition function and J-L is the chemical potential. Assuming ideal behavior for the gas, and using Eqn (3.20), the following set of equations can be derived for the thermodynamic properties of the system: alnS) N- ( N ) ( alna T, V,A alnS )
U=-k ( a(l/T)
(3.33)
(3.34) JL,V,A
4>A+pV = kT In
a
(3.35)
As indicated at the beginninmg of this section, the statistical mechanics approach is employed to connect molecular models with experimental data. It is used as well to give a theoretical basis to empirical models or to test
3.3 Statistical Mechanics
other theoretical models. For example, an isotherm equation was derived by Chen and Yang [25] for the adsorption of gases and vapors on microporous and mesoporous solids based on statistical mechanics principles. The empirical Dubinin-Astakhov (DA) and Dubinin-Radushkevich (DR) equations were then shown to be approximated forms of such an isotherm equation. Another example is the isosteric heat of adsorption of simple fluids on flat surfaces derived from a two-dimensional equation of state. Good agreement was found between the calculated values and the experimental results taken from the literature [26] for many adsorbate-adsorbent systems. The comparison was satisfactory for a wide variety of adsorbate-adsorbent systems, which was taken as an indication that molecules confined within micropores may be treated as two-dimensional fluids. Garbacz et al. [27] also derived an expression for the isosteric heat of a partially mobile monolayer of a single gas on a heterogeneous adsorbent surface. They optimized the model parameters in order to describe several sets of experimental data, especially the ones containing "graphitized" carbon black as an adsorbent. Floess and VanLishout [28] calculated the adsorption energy for different surfaces and pore configurations summing the Lennard-Jones potential for the gas-solid interaction of a molecule with a graphite finite-size basal plane surface. They showed that restricted diffusion occurs only for a small range of pore sizes between c. 0.64 and 0.58 nm. In larger pores, the adsorbate is mobile, whereas pores smaller than 0.58 nm are assumed to be largely inaccessible. Murata and Kaneko [29] proposed a new equation of the absolute adsorption isotherm [30] for a supercritical gas in order to describe the adsorption of methane on activated carbons. The environmental aspects of supercritical gases confined in nanospaces have been reviewed by Kaneko [31]. The model assumes that the adsorption in micropores is slightly enhanced compared with that on a flat surface. The authors supported this assumption on the basis of comparison plots of experimental data obtained on activated carbons and flat surfaces like nonporous carbon black. Several aspects of the adsorption of self-associating molecules in microporous structures have been developed by Talu and Meunier [32]. Their approach is similar to that of the chemical interpretation of nonideality of vapor and liquid phases. The theory leads to type V isotherm behavior and can explain the transition between types I and V. The data at one temperature are represented by three parameters: Henry's law constant, saturation capacity, and reaction constant for "cluster" formation in the micropores. To describe a set ofisotherms obtained over a certain temperature interval, the theory can be used with five temperature-independent parameters to determine the entire phase behavior including the heat of adsorption. Besides obtaining a good agreement with experimental data, they found that the dimerization enthalpy of water in the micropores is lower than that in the vapor phase. Rudzinski and Panczyk [33] have recently reviewed the classical theories of adsorption and desorption kinetics and concluded that models based on the absolute rate theory were challenged by new theories linking the rate of adsorptiondesorption with the chemical potentials of bulk and adsorbed molecules. Of the
Chapter 3 Energetics of Gas Adsorption by Carbons: Thermodynamic Quantities
latter theories, the so-called statistical rate theory deserved the most advanced theoretical development. This model is based on both quantum mechanics and statistical thermodynamics. In particular, it uses as starting point both the Langmuir isotherm and the integral adsorption equation. The authors concluded that the parameters obtained with the statistical rate theory reproduced very well the behavior of both the kinetic and equilibrium aspects of isothermal adsorption measurements, and the parameters had a fully physical meaning. The absolute rate theory can fit the kinetic adsorption measurements at constant temperature (kinetic adsorption isotherms) using many sets of parameters, but some of the parameters determined always lacked physical meaning. Pan et al. [34] used the nonlocal density functional theory (DFT) [35] and the three-process Langmuir model (TPLM) [36] to predict the adsorption heats of propane and butane on carbon and compared these results with experimental data determined from isotherms measured on BAX-activated carbon (Westvaco) in the 297-333 K temperature interval. Both models agreed in showing that the adsorption heat for butane was c. 10 kJ/mol higher than that of propane at the same loading. The satisfactory agreement found prompted the authors to propose the use of the DFT method as it requires only one experimental isotherm in contrast with the numerous isotherms required by the classic technique. Following the same approach, Pan et al. [37] also predicted the adsorption heats of three binary gas mixtures (C0 2-C 2 H 4 , CH 4-C 2 H 6 , and CH 4-C 3 H g ) on homogeneous (BPL-6 carbon) and heterogeneous carbons (Westvaco BAX) at 350 K (here, homo/heterogeneity refers to the pore sizes). The isosteric heats showed complex behavior for the nonideal systems (the CH 4 -C 2 H 6 and CH 4-C 3 H g gas mixtures). Adsorbent heterogeneity played an important role in determining the behavior of the isosteric heats compared with the pure states. The authors attributed these differences to effects caused by the presence of the other (opposing) component of the mixture and to differences in the intermolecular forces between the adsorbate molecules. Myers [38] proposed an equation of state for the adsorption of mixtures of gases in porous materials. Even though the examples shown in this paper concerned adsorption on zeolites, the results can be employed to explain adsorption on porous carbonaceous materials. The author introduced the desorption quantities (enthalpy, entropy, and free energy), which have the advantage of being linearly correlated with the desorption properties of the pure components of the mixture. Bhatia [39] studied the transport of adsorbates in microporous random networks in the presence of an arbitrary nonlinear local isotherm. The transport model was developed by means of a correlated random walk theory, assuming pore mouth equilibrium at an intersection in the network and a local chemical potential gradient driving force. The author tested this model with experimental data of CO 2 adsorption on Carbolac measured by Carman and Raal [40]. He concluded that the experimental data are best predicted when adsorbate mobility, based on the chemical potential gradient, is taken to have an activation energy equal to the isosteric heat of adsorption at low coverage, obtained from the Henry's law region. He also concluded that the choice of the local isotherm
3.3 Statistical Mechanics
65
affects the predictions for the dependence of the diffusivity on coverage, even among isotherms that fit the equilibrium data equally well. Shekhovtsova and Fomkin [41] developed a discrete site model to describe the adsorption of methane on microporous adsorbents. The model was tested with adsorption on zeolite NaX and an activated carbon. A sharp decrease in the heats of adsorption was observed at high adsorbed amounts even in the supercritical temperature range. A multilayer adsorption theory was developed by Wang and Hwang [42] to describe the behavior of several adsorbates on activated carbons. The adsorbates employed included several alkanes, hydrogen sulfide, and carbon monoxide. The isosteric heats of adsorption for all gases were determined using the Clausius-Clapeyron equation. Cerofolini and Rudzinski [43] have reviewed the theoretical principles of single gas and mixture adsorption on heterogeneous surfaces. Their review is chronologically arranged from the earliest to the latest approaches. In the same book, Tovbin [44] reported the application of lattice-gas models to explain mixed-gas adsorption equilibria on heterogeneous surfaces; he also discussed [45] the kinetic aspects of adsorption-desorption on flat heterogeneous surfaces. The book [46] also contains other papers on different aspects of adsorption for the reader interested in surface diffusion processes. It is generally accepted that the adsorption of binary and ternary vapor mixtures by activated carbon beds can be successfully described by combining the Dubinin equation with the theory of Myers and Prausnitz [47]. A major advantage of this approach lies in the simplicity of the parameters required to describe the adsorption of vapor mixtures over a wide range of pressures and temperatures. Moreover, the combination of this method with computer simulation models developed by Ladugie et al. [48] extends the theory to the case of dynamic adsorption by activated carbons. Wintgens et al. [49] employed this approach to investigate the adsorption of vapor mixtures on activated carbons. The components were immiscible in the liquid state. They concluded that it
is possible to predict the adsorption of vapor mixtures corresponding to miscible and immiscible liquids if the variation of the characteristic energy of one component is taken into account. Riccardo and coworkers [50, 51] reported the results of a statistical thermodynamic approach to study linear adsorbates on heterogeneous surfaces based on Eqns (3.33)-(3.35). In the first paper, they dealt with low dimensional systems (e.g., carbon nanotubes, pores ofmolecular dimensions, corners in steps found on flat surfaces). In the second paper, they presented an improved solution for multilayer adsorption; they compared their results with the standard BET formalism and found that monolayer capacities could be up to 1.5 times larger than the one from the BET model. They argued that their model is simple and easy to apply in practice and leads to new values of surface area and adsorption heats. These advantages are a consequence of correctly assessing the configurational entropy of the adsorbed phase. Rzysko et al. [52] presented a theoretical description of adsorption in a templated porous material. Their method of solution uses expansions of size-dependent correlation functions into Fourier series. They tested
66
Chapter 3 Energetics of Gas Adsorption by Carbons: Thermodynamic Quantities
their method for model systems composed of hard spheres, or more specifically a hard sphere fluid in a polydisperse hard sphere disordered quench matrix.
3-4
THERMODYNAMIC QUANTITIES
AND EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS
The connection between experimental results and thermodynamic quantities gives rise to different problems depending on the experimental design employed to obtain the data. In what follows we will analyze the relationship between the various heats of adsorption and the experimental data obtained under different conditions. To obtain enthalpy variations directly from experiments, it is necessary to carry out these experiments at constant pressure (or spreading pressure), but in general experiments are not carried out under these conditions. This is the reason why Letoquart et al. [53] recommend expressing the experimental data in terms of internal energy. In this way, writing the necessary expressions to calculate all the thermodynamic quantities is straightforward. Another problem arises from the fact that most thermodynamic equations have been deduced for a closed system, which is often not the experimental situation [53]. As usual, we consider the solid adsorbent to be inert, in the sense that its internal energy is constant at constant temperature and its total surface area is kept constant. For the gas phase, we assume ideal behavior. In any experimental setup that constitutes an open system, what is measured is the heat exchange with the surrounding media, which includes the exchange of matter and a certain amount of work. In this case, one is tempted to introduce thermodynamic potentials, i.e., to introduce entropy. Nevertheless, we feel it more prudent to find a way to relate the experimental data with the internal energy without introducing any additional hypothesis. The evaluation of internal energy change allows the energy conservation law to be used in two ways. We assume that our system contains c components distributed among 'P phases. During the adsorption process the system receives some work (W), heat (Q), and a certain amount of moles of the ith component (LlNi ) from the exterior, each one having a known molar internal energy, B ie . Under these conditions the change in internal energy is given by i=c
~E
= W+Q+" L...J B·
Ie
~N.I
(3.36)
i=l
Alternatively, if the ith component has a molar internal energy Bij when it is in the jth phase (where Nij represents the number of moles of the ith component present in the jth phase), the internal energy change can be written as j=cp i=c
LlE
= LLLl (NijBij) i=l i=l
(3.37)
3.4 Thermodynamic Quantities and Experimental Results
Using Eqns (3.36) and (3.37) it is easy to obtain the expression that gives the experimentally determined thermal effect, Q, in terms of the internal energies. The result is j=({) i=c
i=c
"" d (N..lJ e lJ..) - "" Q = "" ~~ ~ e·Ie dN. - W I
j=l i=l
(3.38)
i=l
Consider an infinitesimal transformation that takes the system from one equilibrium state to another one that is close to it. To calculate the amount of heat involved in the transformation it is necessary to derive Eqn (3.38). Thus (3.39) where we have used the fact that dN = dNa + dNg . If we also use the fact that the gas admitted into the adsorption cell is at the same temperature (thus its internal energy does not change), it is possible to write Eqn (3.39) as follows: (3.40) N ow it is necessary to calculate the work involved, d W. Given that the gas is ideal, it follows that:
dW=PoV
(3.41)
This equation is easily transformed into (3.42) Considering that the total volume of the system is constant, Vg , the change in the number of gas moles can be expressed in terms of the pressure. Thus Eqn (3.42) leads to
dW = RTdNa + VgdP
(3.43)
Substituting into Eqn (3.40): (3.44) This equation can be written in an equivalent form to show that it corresponds to a differential heat of adsorption. (3.45) This is in fact an isothermal heat of adsorption. The last term, which depends on the experimental setup, is obtained from the calibration of the equipment
68
Chapter 3 Energetics of Gas Adsorption by Carbons: Thermodynamic Quantities
and the slope of the isotherm. We must now consider the fact that Eqn (3.45) is valid if the gas is reversibly admitted into the adsorption cell, a condition that is seldom obtained. We must now develop the expressions corresponding to a finite addition of gas. The heat experimentally measured corresponds to a change in the number of adsorbed moles, flNa = N z - N l . Equation (3.45) must be integrated, giving
The result is
Q = (B az -
Bg ) N aZ - (B al - Bg ) N al -
RT (Naz - N al )
-
Vg (Pz - Pl )
(3.47)
The first and second terms of this equation are the integral heats of adsorption, Qint. Thus,
Q
= Qint_ Qint-RTdN z 1 a
Vg (PZ -P) 1
(3.48a)
We have shown that the experimentally measured heat exchange is directly connected to the integral heat of adsorption at constant temperature. The experimental data needed to perform the calculation are Q, the number of moles adsorbed at two pressures, these pressures and the volume of the adsorption cell (the so-called dead space). In a completely analogous way, it is possible to obtain an expression corresponding to the adiabatic heat of adsorption. The final result is
(3.48b) Now we will discuss a series of papers using the classical thermodynamic, the statistical thermodynamic, direct determination of the heat of adsorption, or a combination of these methods. The theory behind each paper has been outlined in the previous sections as well as in the present one. Della Gatta [54] has considered the energy changes occurring during adsorption in gas-solid and solution-solid systems in connection with the measurement of the adsorption enthalpies. He focused on the description of heat-flow microcalorimeters and calibration techniques. Piper et al. [55] have published a good description of an adiabatic calorimeter. Other types of calorimeters are the conduction calorimeter (the temperature of the sample is made equal to the surrounding temperature by simple conduction), compensation calorimeters (the sample temperature is made equal to the surroundings by means of power compensation), and the "isoperibol" calorimeter (this is a conventional temperature rise calorimeter, also known as Thomsen or Berthelot calorimeter) [3].
3.4 Thermodynamic Quantities and Experimental Results
Groszek [56, 57] studied the adsorption of simple gases (C0 2, CH 4 , S02' 02' He, and N 2) on microporous carbons using flow adsorption microcalorimetry. Shen and Bulow [58] demonstrated that the isosteric adsorption technique (Eqns (3.11) or (3.31)) is a useful and effective tool to obtain highly accurate thermodynamic data for microporous adsorption systems like the heat of adsorption given by Eqn (3.47). They studied the adsorption of CO 2 and N 2-0 2 mixtures on a super-activated, almost entirely microporous, carbon (M-30, from Osaka Gas) and three faujasite-type zeolites. They also estimated the energetic heterogeneity of the solids due to specific interactions between the adsorbate and the solid. Salem et al. [59] determined several thermodynamic functions from the excess and absolute adsorption isotherms for N 2, Ar, and methane on an activated carbon (AS, used for respiratory protection) and on a 13X zeolite. They concluded that for a consistent thermodynamic interpretation ofhigh-pressure excess adsorption data it is necessary to consider the specific adsorption quantities (the ones that can be measured directly). However, such quantities depend very much on the initial values of adsorption, i.e., the region of Henry's law. If this region is not included in the experimental data, the integral molar and specific adsorption quantities are estimated with a systematic error of unknown magnitude. Another conclusion they reached is that a molecular interpretation of high-pressure adsorption data can be achieved only by using the absolute isosteric and differential molar adsorption quantities. In the case of microporous solids, this is relatively easy to do; however, it is a very difficult task in the case of macroporous and nonporous solids. Rychlicki and Terzyk [60] determined the heat of adsorption and the integral molar entropy of methane adsorbed on microporous carbons with different degrees of oxidation. They found that the oxidation of the micropore surface affected the adsorption of methane because of the existence of an endothermic effect during adsorption probably due to specific adsorbate-adsorbent interactions. A similar effect was found in the case of CCl4 adsorption [61, 62]. These authors also studied the adsorption of methanol, ethanol and CCl4 on a series of microporous carbons [63] and compared the data obtained with the adsorption of the same adsorbates on a "graphitized" carbon black. They concluded that at low coverage, association of the studied gases in the micropores does not occur. The adsorption of gas mixtures has been extensively studied. For example, Wendland et al. [64] applied the Born-Green-Yvon approach using a coarse grained density to study the adsorption of subcritical Lennard-Jones fluids. In a subsequent paper, they tested their equations with simulated adsorption isotherms of several model mixtures [65]. They compared the adsorption of model gases with an equal molecular size but different adsorption potentials. They discussed the structure of the adsorbed phase, adsorption isotherms, and selectivity curves. Based on the vacancy solution theory [66], Nguyen and Do [67] developed a new technique for predicting the multicomponent adsorption equilibria of supercritical fluids in microporous carbons. They concluded that the degree of adsorption enhancement, due to the proximity of the pore
70
Chapter 3 Energetics of Gas Adsorption by Carbons: Thermodynamic Quantities
walls, is different for different adsorbates and that it increases with a decrease in pore size. They found good agreement between their model and experimental data. Do and Do [68] have recently reviewed the adsorption of supercritical fluids in porous and nonporous carbons. Ustinov and Do [69] proposed a model for binary mixture adsorption accounting for energetic heterogeneity and intermolecular interactions based on statistical thermodynamics. This model is able to describe the molecular rearrangement of a mixture in a nonuniform adsorption field inside a cavity. The Helmholtz free energy obtained has upper and lower limits, which define a permissible range in which all possible solutions may occur. One limit corresponds to a completely chaotic distribution of molecules within a cavity, and the other to a maximum ordered molecular structure. Their model can also describe the negative deviations from Raoult's law exhibited by N 2-0 2 mixtures. Bakaev and Steele [70] developed a lattice gas model of mixed adsorption on heterogeneous surfaces. The model considers an ideal mixture since it is assumed that the difference between the energies of the components on each adsorption site is the same. They showed that mixing at constant spreading pressure in this case is equivalent to that at constant coverage. The interaction between adsorbed molecules induces deviations from ideality, but the excess chemical potentials of the components calculated in the random mixing approximation depend linearly upon mole fractions, unlike the regular bulk solutions, which for the same approximation have a quadratic dependence on mole fractions. Experimental separation factors (selectivities) for methane-ethane mixtures on activated carbon [71] were compared with those calculated according to the lattice gas model of mixed adsorption [70] or by means of the ideal adsorption solution theory (lAST). The lattice gas model under discussion provided only rough evaluations of the selectivities in mixed adsorption but, unlike the lAST predictions, showed no dependence on the composition of the gas phase or its total pressure. According to the authors, the main limitation of the lattice gas model is that of the Langmuir model as a whole, namely, the requirement that the adsorption capacities of all the components in a mixture be equal. More recently, Ustinov and coworkers [72, 73] developed a thermodynamic approach based on an equation of state to model the gas adsorption equilibrium over a wide range of pressure. Their model is based on the Bender equation of state, which is a virial-like equation with temperature dependent parameters based on the Benedict-Webb-Rubin equation of state [74]. They employed the model [75, 76] to describe supercritical gas adsorption on activated carbon (Norit R 1) at high temperature, and extended this treatment to subcritical fluid adsorption taking into account the phase transition in elements of the adsorption volume. They argued that parameters such as pore volume and skeleton density can be determined directly from adsorption measurements, while the conventional approach of He expansion at room temperature can lead to erroneous results due to the adsorption of He in narrow micropores of activated carbon. More recently, Li et al. [77] have reviewed the thermodynamic basis ofa novel model ofthe combined cycle ofa solar-powered adsorption-ejection refrigeration
Acknowledgment
71
system. They described the adsorption isotherms using a virial-like equation and the heats of adsorption were calculated with expressions derived from Eqn (3.48a).
3.5
CONCLUSIONS
The determination ofadsorption thermodynamic quantities such as adsorption heats can now be performed through direct or indirect methods with a great degree ofaccuracy. The foundations of gas-solid interface calorimetry have been well established by combining adsorption microcalorimetry with adsorption in quasi-equilibrium. The experimental results reported so far, obtained from different calorimetries, concur with the values calculated from adsorption isotherms. There is a more or less generalized agreement that the isosteric adsorption heat is strongly affected by the microstructure of the adsorbent, particularly in the case of porous solids. This magnitude is better suited for structural analysis than other thermodynamic quantities. The use of the Clausius-Clapeyron equation to determine the isosteric adsorption heat has several limitations both theoretical and experimental, that are well known. Gas mixture adsorption is a field that is still waiting for a better theory to explain the experimental data. The Ideal Adsorbed Solution Theory cannot explain all the facts and needs to be replaced by a new model that includes nonideal effects, and adsorbent surface heterogeneity in particular. This field is acquiring increasing relevance because of its technological implications. Adsorption calorimetry, based on the use of different adsorbates, is now employed to probe the effects of various types of surface modification treatments on the surface chemistry of solids. The technique is employed in particular to investigate and characterize activated carbons. Recent studies show good agreement between the results from this technique and immersion calorimetry. In summary, the determination of thermodynamic quantities is almost a standard routine connected to the majority of experimental and simulation techniques. Thermodynamic models for adsorption can now be validated using both experimental and computer simulation results. New developments are regularly reported concerning new adsorption equations or models to explain experimental data of a very different nature.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
Financial support from the Spanish CSIC is gratefully acknowledged.
72
Chapter 3 Energetics of Gas Adsorption by Carbons: Thermodynamic Quantities
REFERENCES 1. Bottani, EJ. and Tasc6n, J.M.D. (2004). Energetics of physical adsorption of gases and vapors on carbons. Chem. Phys. Carbon, 29, 209-423. 2. Gregg, SJ. and Sing, K.S.W. (1982). Adsorption, Surface Area and Porosity, 2nd edn. Academic Press. 3. Rouquerol, F., Rouquerol,J., and Sing, K. (1999). Adsorption by Powders and Porous Solids. Principles, Methodology and Applications. Academic Press. 4. Bansal, R.C., Donnet, J.B., and Stoeckli, F. (1988). Active Carbon. Marcel Dekker. 5. Bansal, R.C. and Goyal, M. (2005). Activated Carbon Adsorption. Taylor and Francis, Chapter 2, pp. 67-143. 6. Myers, A.L. and Monson, P.A. (2002). Adsorption in porous materials at high pressure: theory and experiment. Langmuir, 18, 10261-73. 7. T6th, J. (2003). On thermodynamic inconsistency of isotherm equations: Gibbs' thermodynamics.]. Colloid Interface Sci., 262, 25-31. 8. Steele, W.A. (1974). The Interaction of Gases with Solid Surfaces. Pergamon Press. 9. Hill, T.L. (1994). Thermodynamics of Small Systems. Dover Publications. 10. de Boer, J.H. (1953). The Dynamic Character of Adsorption. Clarendon Press. 11. Fomkin, A.A., Nikiforov, Yu.V., Sinitsyn, V.A., and Savel'ev, E.G. (2002). Adsorption ofperfluoropropane on the PAC microporous carbon adsorbent. Russ. Chem. Bull., Int. Ed., 51, 2161-4. 12. Agarwal, R.K., Amankwah, K.A.G., and Schwarz,J.A. (1990). Analysis ofadsorption entropies of high pressure gas adsorption data on activated carbon. Carbon, 28, 169-74. 13. Bottani, E.G., Llanos,J.L., and Cascarini de Torre, L.E. (1989). Entropy determination from physisorption isotherms: a useful tool for carbon surface characterization. Carbon, 27, 531-6. 14. Sircar, S., Mohr, R., Ristic, C., and Rao, M.B. (1999). Isosteric heat of adsorption: theory and experiment.] Phys. Chem. B, 103, 6539-46. 15. Mezzasalma, S.A. (1999). Hysteresis and isotherm equations in gas-solid adsorption from maximum entropy production.]. Phys. Chem. B, 103,7542-50. 16. Milewska-Duda, J., Duda, J.T., Jodlowski, G., and Kwiatkowski, M. (2000). A model for multilayer adsorption of small molecules in microporous materials. Langmuir, 16, 7294-303. 17. Asnin, L.D., Fedorov, A.A., and Cheekryshkin, Yu.S. (2000). Thermodynamic quantities of adsorption described by Freundlich isotherm. Russ. Chem. Bull., 49, 178-80. 18. Drzal, L.T., Mescher, J.A., and Hall, D.L. (1979). The surface composition and energetics of Type HM graphite fibers. Carbon, 17, 375-82. 19. Sircar, S. and Cao, D.V. (2002). Heat of adsorption. Chem. Eng. Technol., 25, 945-48. 20. Myers, A.L. (2002). Thermodynamics of adsorption in porous materials. AIChE ]., 48, 145-60. 21. Li, M., Zhou, L., Wu, Q., and Zhou, Y.P. (2002). Progress in predicting the equilibria of multi-component gas/solid adsorption. Prog. Chem., 14, 93-7.
References
73
22. Chiang, H.L., Huang, C.P., and Chiang, P.C. (2002). The adsorption of benzene and methylethylketone onto activated carbon: thermodynamic aspects. Chemosphere, 46, 143-52. 23. Linders, M.J.G., van den Broeke, L.J.P., Nijhuis T.A., et al. (2001). Modelling sorption and diffusion in activated carbon: a novel low pressure pulse-response technique. Carbon, 39, 2113-30. 24. Hill, T.L. (1960). An Introduction to Statistical Thermodynamics. Addison-Wesley. 25. Chen, S.G. and Yang, R.T. (1994). Theoretical basis for the potential theory adsorption isotherms. The Dubinin-Radushkevich and Dubinin-Astakhov equations. Langmuir, 10, 4244-9. 26. Valenzuela, D.P. and Myers, A.L. (1989). Adsorption Equilibrium Data Handbook. Prentice Hall. 27. Garbacz, ].K., Kowalczyk-Dembinska, H., and Dabrowski, A. (1996). Partially mobile adsorption of single gases on graphitized carbon black surfaces. Adsorpt. Sci. Technol., 14, 69-76. 28. Floess, ].K. and VanListhout, Y. (1992). Calculation of adsorption energies in carbon micropores. Carbon, 30, 967-73. 29. Murata, K. and Kaneko, K. (2001). The general equation of supercritical gas adsorption isotherm. J. Phys. Chem. B, 105, 8498-503. 30. Murata, K., Miyawaki, ]., and Kaneko, K. (2002). A simple determination method of the absolute adsorbed amount for high pressure gas adsorption. Carbon, 40, 425-8. 31. Kaneko, K. (1999). Control of supercritical gases with solid nanospaceenvironmental aspects. In Adsorption and its Applications in Industry and Enviromental Protection, Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis, Elsevier, Vol. 120B (A. Dabrowski, ed.). pp. 635-756. 32. Talu, O. and Meunier, F. (1996). Adsorption ofassociating molecules in micropores and application to water on carbon. A IChE J., 42, 809-19. 33. Rudzinski, W. and Panczyk, T. (2002). Remarks on the current state of adsorption kinetic theories for heterogeneous solid surfaces: a comparison of the ART and SRT approaches. Langmuir, 18, 439-49. 34. Pan, H.H., Ritter, ].A., and Balbuena, P.B. (1998). Isosteric heats of adsorption on carbon predicted by density functional theory. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 37, 1159-66. 35. Lastoskie, C.M., Quirke, N., and Gubbins, K.E. (1997). Structure of porous adsorbents: analysis using density functional theory and molecular simulation. In Equilibria and Dynamics of Gas Adsorption on Heterogeneous Solid Surfaces, Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis, Elsevier, Vol. 104 (W. Rudzinski, W.A. Steele and G. Zgrablich, eds). pp. 745-75. 36. Drago, R.S., Burns, D.S., and Lafrenz, T.]. (1996). A new adsorption model for analyzing gas-solid equilibria in porous materials. J. Phys. Chem., 100, 1718-24. 37. Pan, H., Ritter,].A., and Balbuena, P.B. (1999). Binary isosteric heats of adsorption predicted from density functional theory. Langmuir, 15, 4570-78. 38. Myers, A.L. (2003). Equation of state for adsorption of gases and their mixtures in porous materials. Adsorption, 9, 9-16. 39. Bhatia, S.K. (1994). Transport of adsorbates in microporous solids: arbitrary isotherm. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A, 446, 15-37. 40. Carman, P.C. and Raal, F.A. (1951). Diffusion and flow of gases and vapours through micropores. 3. Surface diffusion coefficients and activation energies. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A, 209, 38-58.
74
Chapter 3 Energetics of Gas Adsorption by Carbons: Thermodynamic Quantities
41. Shekhovtsova, L.G. and Fomkin, A.A. (1990). Discrete site model for methane adsorption on microporous adsorbents. Bull. Acad. Sci. USSR Div. Chem. Sci., 39, 867-70. 42. Wang, C.H. and Hwang, B.J. (2000). Characterizing the adsorption behaviors of various adsorbates on activated carbons via the multi-layer theory. J. Chin. Inst. Chem. Eng., 31, 333-8. 43. Cerofolini, G.F. and Rudzinski, W. (1997). Theoretical principles of single- and mixed-gas adsorption equilibria on heterogeneous solid surfaces. In Equilibria and Dynamics of Gas Adsorption on Heterogeneous Solid Suifaces, Studies in Suiface Science and Catalysis, Elsevier, Vol. 104 (W. Rudzinski, W.A. Steele and G. Zgrablich, eds). pp. 1-103. 44. Tovbin, Y.K. (1997). Application of lattice-gas models to describe mixed-gas adsorption equilibria on heterogeneous solid surfaces. In Equilibria and Dynamics of Gas Adsorption on Heterogeneous Solid Suifaces, Studies in Suiface Science and Catalysis, Elsevier, Vol. 104 (W. Rudzinski, W.A. Steele and G. Zgrablich, eds). pp. 105-52. 45. Tovbin, Y.K. (1997). Theory of adsorption-desorption kinetics non flat heterogeneous surfaces. In Equilibria and Dynamics of Gas Adsorption on Heterogeneous Solid Suifaces, Studies in Suiface Science and Catalysis, Elseveir, Vol. 104 (W. Rudzinski, W.A. Steele and G. Zgrablich, eds). pp. 201-84. 46. Rudzinski, W., Steele, W.A., and Zgrablich, G., eds. (1997). Equilibria and Dynamics of Gas Adsorption on Heterogeneous Solid Suifaces, Studies in Suiface Science and Catalysis, Elsevier, Vol. 104. 47. Myers, A.L. and Prausnitz, J .M. (1965). Thermodynamics of mixed-gas adsorption. AIChEJ., 11, 121-7. 48. Ladugie, P., Lavanchy, A., and Touzani, R. (1992). Study of a simple model for chemical adsorption by active carbon beds. Math. Eng. Ind., 3, 247-64. 49. Wintgens, D., Lavanchy, A., and Stoeckli, F. (1999). Static adsorption, by activated carbons, of vapour mixtures corresponding to immiscible liquids. Adsorpt. Sci. Technol., 17,761-9. 50. Ramirez-Pastor, A.J., Pereyra, V.D., and Riccardo, J.L. (1999). Statistical thermodynamics of linear adsorbates in low dimensions: application to adsorption on heterogeneous surfaces. Langmuir, 15, 5707-12. 51. Riccardo, J.L., Ramirez-Pastor, A.J., and Roma, F. (2002). Multilayer adsorption with multisite occupancy: an improved isotherm for surface characterization. Langmuir, 18, 2130-4. 52. Rzysko, W., Sokolowski, S., and Pizio, 0. (2002). Theory of adsorption in a polydisperse templated porous material: hard sphere systems. J. Chem. Phys., 116, 4286-92. 53. Letoquart, C., Rouquerol, F., and Rouquerol, J. (1973). Heats of adsorption.l. Heats of physisorption derived in terms of internal energy from experimental data. J. Chim. Phys., 70, 559-73. 54. Della Gatta, G. (1985). Direct determination of adsorption heats. Thermochim. Acta, 96,349-63. 55. Piper, J., Morrison, J.A., Peters, C., and Ozaki, Y. (1983). Heats and entropies of adsorption ofN 2 on grafoil at 79.3K.J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. I, 79, 2863-74. 56. Groszek, A.J. (1997). Heats of adsorption and desorption of CO 2, CH 4 , S02' O 2 and N 2 on microporous carbons. Carbon, 35, 1399-405.
References
75
57. Groszek, AJ., Avraham, I., Danon, A., and Koresh,].E. (2002). Interaction of0 2 , N 2 and He at room temperature with carbon molecular sieves sensed by adsorption measurements. Colloid Surf. A, 208, 65-70. 58. Shen, D. and Bulow, M. (1998). Isosteric study of sorption thermodynamics of single gases and multi-component mixtures on microporous materials. Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 22, 237-49. 59. Salem, M.M.K., Braeuer, P., Szombathely, M.V., et al. (1998). Thermodynamics of high pressure adsorption of argon, nitrogen, and methane on microporous adsorbents. Langmuir, 14, 3376-89. 60. Rychlicki, G. and Terzyk. A.P. (1995). Energetics of methane adsorption on microporous activated carbons.]. Therm. Anal., 45,1183-7. 61. Rychlicki, G., Terzyk, A.P., and Szymanski, G.S. (1993). Thermodynamic properties of CCl4 adsorbed on microporous activated carbon. Polish]. Chern., 67, 1121-30. 62. Rychlicki, G., Terzyk, A.P., and Zawadzki, ]. (1994). The influence of carbon surface oxidation on thermodynamic properties of carbon-tetrachloride adsorbed at different temperatures. Polish]. Chern., 68, 557-63. 63. Rychlicki, G., Terzyk, A.P., and Zawadzki,]. (1993). Low-coverage adsorption of methanol, ethanol and carbon-tetrachloride on homo and heterogeneous surface differential heat and integral molar entropy. Polish]. Chern., 67, 2019-28. 64. Wendland, M., Salzmann, S., Heinbuch, D., and Fischer,]. (1989). Born-GreenYvon results for adsorption ofa simple fluid on plane walls. Mol. Phys., 67,161-72. 65. Wendland, M., Heinbuch, D., and Fischer,]. (1989). Adsorption of simple gas mixtures on a plane wall: Born-Green-Yvon for structure, adsorption isotherms and selectivity. Fluid Phase Equil., 48, 259-77. 66. Ding, L.P. and Bhatia, S.K. (2001). Application of heterogeneous vacancy solution theory to characterization of microporous solids. Carbon, 39, 2215-29. 67. Nguyen, C. and Do, D.D. (2001). Multicomponent supercritical adsorption in microporous activated carbon materials. Langmuir, 17, 1552-7. 68. Do, D.D. and Do, H.D. (2003). Adsorption of supercritical fluids in non-porous and porous carbons: analysis of adsorbed phase volume and density. Carbon, 41, 1777-91. 69. Dstinov, E.A. and Do, D.D. (2002). Mixed gas equilibrium adsorption on zeolites and energetic heterogenity of adsorption volume. Langmuir, 18, 3567-77. 70. Bakaev, V.A. and Steele, W.A. (1996). Adsorbed mixtures on a heterogeneous surface. The lattice gas model. Langmuir, 12, 6119-26. 71. Richter, E., Schutz, W., and Myers, A.L. (1989). Effect of adsorption equation on prediction of multicomponent adsorption equilibria by the ideal adsorbed solution theory. Chern. Eng. Sci., 44, 1609-16. 72. Dstinov, E.A., Vashchenko, L.A., and Polyakov, N.S. (2001). Statistical model of equilibrium adsorption of non-ideal mixtures on zeolites. Russ. Chern. Bull., 50, 220-7. 73. Dstinov, E.A., Do, D.D., Herbst, A., et al. (2002). Modeling of gas adsorption equilibrium over a wide range of pressure: a thermodynamic approach based on equation of state.]. Colloid Interface Sci., 250, 49-62. 74. Benedict, M., Webb, G.B., and Rubin, L.C. (1940). An empirical equation for thermodynamic properties of light hydrocarbons and their mixtures I. Methane, ethane, propane and n-butane.]. Chern. Phys., 8, 334-45.
Chapter 3 Energetics of Gas Adsorption by Carbons: Thermodynamic Quantities
75. PoIt, A., Platzer, B., and Maurer, G. (1992). The Bender equation of state for 14 polyatomic pure substances. Chern. Tech. (Leipzig), 44, 216-24. 76. Platzer, B. and Maurer, G. (1993). Application of a generalized Bender equation of state to the description of vapour-liquid equilibria in binary systems. Fluid Phase Equilibria, 84, 79-110. 77. Li, C.H., Wang, R.Z., and Lu, Y.Z. (2002). Investigation of a novel combined cycle of solar powered adsorption-ej ection refrigeration system. Renewable Energy, 26~ 611-22.
MONTE CARLO AND MOLECULAR DYNAMICS Mary
J.
Bojan and William A. Steele
Department of Chemistry, The Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA, USA
Contents 4.1 Introduction 4.2 Overview of Computer Simulations 4.3 Conclusions References
4.1
77 78
97 98
INTRODUCTION
Computer simulations have become an indispensable tool in the efforts to forge links between the behavior of molecules on the atomic level and experimentally measurable properties. This has been especially true in the area of surface science in general and specifically in studies of carbon surfaces. Due to the abundance of experimental data for gases interacting with carbon surfaces, and because carbon surfaces are relatively simple, many of the pioneering simulations of surface phenomena involved studies of gases interacting with homogeneous (graphite) and heterogeneous carbon surfaces. Pioneering studies include the Monte Carlo (MC) simulations of Ar interacting with graphite by Rowley et al. [1-3] and the molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of N 2 on graphite by Talbot et al. [4-6]. As computers became more powerful, the expense of computing dropped, making it possible to simulate systems of ever-increasing size and complexity. At the same time, the complexity and cost of experimental work has made simulations even more indispensable since simulation results often suggest interesting directions for experimentation while they continue to aid in the interpretation of the results. The goal of MC and MD simulations is to calculate properties of a particular macroscopic thermodynamic system from the configurations (positions and Adsorption by Carbons ISBN: 978-0-08-044464-2
© 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
77
Chapter 4 Monte Carlo and Molecular Dynamics
velocities) of many microscopic states. The techniques differ in their approach to generating the configurations. With MC a completely stochastic (probabilistic) algorithm is used, while in MD, the method is deterministic. In this context an ensemble is a collection of a large number of systems (made up of particles) constructed to be a replica on a macroscopic level of the thermodynamic system of interest. In MD, the configurations in a particular thermodynamic ensemble are generated by solving the equations of motion for the collection of classical particles (atoms or molecules) moving in a potential field created by other particles or by a surface. In MC, new configurations are generated by making random changes to molecular positions that are accepted when they drive the system toward the desired thermodynamic ensemble. The experimentally accessible properties of a system are state functions such as p (density), j.L (chemical potential), TJ (shear viscosity), C v (heat capacity), D (diffusion coefficient), and S(k) (structure factor). They depend on the thermodynamic state of the system characterized by variables such as temperature (T), pressure (P), volume (V), and number of particles (N). The configurations determined in MC and MD simulations are the positions (and momenta, for MD) of particles at an instant in time (or space). The collection of these configurations describes the mechanical (or microscopic) state of the system. Statistical Mechanics provides the connection between the thermodynamic state and the mechanical state. Simply put, the theory tells us that if I know the positions of a collection of molecules as a function of time, I know everything about the thermodynamic properties of the system. This means properties such as P, j.L, S (entropy), E (internal energy), and phase equilibria, can be calculated from the configuration information. Furthermore, if the positions and velocities of a collection of molecules as a function of time are known, everything about the dynamic properties of the system can be determined as well (e.g., transport coefficients, diffusion, spectroscopic properties, and response times). There is an important assumption underlying these statements: that I know how the particles interact with each other and their surroundings, i.e., it is assumed that we know the potential energy surface = U pot • Thus the goal of MD and MC simulations is to produce a large number of configurations constructed in such a way as to be replicas on a microscopic level of the thermodynamic system of interest. In this way, the configurations can be used to determine the thermodynamic and dynamic properties of interest and can be studied to understand the microscopic behavior that gives rise to thermodynamic properties.
4.2
OVERVIEW OF COMPUTER SIMULATIONS
It is impossible in a short space to explain all that one needs to know to understand and perform computer simulations. Here we will attempt to lay the framework and refer the reader to texts [7-10] where the details can be
79
4.2 Overview of Computer Simulations
explored. Both MD and Me simulations can be broken into the following steps. (1) (2) (3) (4)
Select a model Initialize a system Generate configurations (positions and momenta) using either MC or MD Calculate properties of interest from the configurations
4.2.1
Selecting the Model This can be broken into three main steps:
(1) Describe how the molecules interact with each other and the surroundings (or define the potential energy surface Upot ) (2) Set dimensions and boundaries (3) Choose the ensemble
4.2.1.1
Potential energy surface
The most important step in the simulation is the development of the potentials. The more closely the model potential fits reality, the more reliable the results will be. The ideal potential then would be a potential that is obtained from a quantum electronic calculation. However, such potential energy surfaces are complex and time consuming to calculate, and difficult to use directly. In practice, most model potentials take simple mathematical forms with parameters that can be determined either from experimental data or by fitting to results of ab initio calculations. Fortunately, there are many good publications devoted to the development of models for gas-surface interactions in general [11] and specifically for interactions of gases with carbon surfaces (Steele) [12-16] so only
a brief description need be given here. The models for gases interacting with carbonaceous surfaces can be broken into terms that depend on the coordinates of the interacting particles and the surface. First, one must describe the interaction of the adsorbate molecules with one another. For monatomic adsorbates, this can be done via an approximate (double) sum over distinct pairs of interacting molecules: (4.1) U2
(rij) is a function that describes the pair interaction and rij is the distance
between the interacting particles and equals Iri 12-6 potential function is commonly used:
-
~
I.
The Lennard-Jones (L-J)
(4.2)
80
Chapter 4 Monte Carlo and Molecular Dynamics
where B gg and lTgg are the potential well depth and hard sphere collision diameter, respectively, and the gg subscripts indicate parameters determined for the adsorbate-adsorbate interaction. The values of the parameters are obtained from previous studies of the bulk phases [13]. If a more complex adsorbate is being studied, (N2 , CO 2 , water, etc.) the orientation dependence should be added to the model. For the linear N 2 molecule, e.g., a three-site L-J pair potential is typically used [17]. The three sites correspond to the N atoms and the center of mass. The interaction between the atomic sites is taken to be a L-J 12-6 potential function, and partial charges are placed on the three sites in the molecule to reproduce the known quadrupole moment. The other essential term in the description of the model describes the interaction ofthe molecule with the carbon surface. In the earliest computer simulations of carbonaceous surfaces, graphite was chosen as a model system since there was already a great deal of experimental data available and because the development of a model potential to describe the interaction of molecules and atoms with the surface was relatively easy. Typically, the description of the interaction of a monatomic molecule with the graphite surface is approximated as a sum of the interaction of an adsorbate particle with each atom in the surface.
U1
(r;)
= 4e~ [ (~~
y2- (~~ r]
(4.3)
Ul (rJ = 4egs [ ( ~s 12 _ ( ~~' )6] )
where U 1 (ri ) is a function that describes the interaction often denoted by ugs (ri ) and ri is the distance between the interacting particle and a C atom in the surface. In the basic model of the potential, U 1 (rJ is taken to be a L-J (12-6) function, but here B gs and lTgs are often determined through use of combining rules:
B gs
= ( BggB ee )
1/2
,
(4.4)
where the CC subscript denotes parameters for the interaction of pairs of C surface atoms. In most studies, the value for the carbon surface parameters is taken to be Bee = 34 K and cree = O.34nm. These were determined by fitting the L-J 12-6 potential to experimental data. (See Chapter 2 in Steele's book for review of early development of potential parameters [16].) In the work of Rowley et al. [1-3], the grand canonical Monte Carlo (gcmc) method was used to simulate Ar interacting with graphite. The surface was approximated as a continuum. In such a case, the sum in Eqn (4.3) is replaced by an integral in the x, y, and z dimensions (the graphite solid) and the potential reduces to a L-J 9-3 form that is a function only of the distance of the atom
4.2 Overview of Computer Simulations
81
from the surface. A slightly more realistic potential frequently used is known as the summed 10-4 potential. It is the result of assuming that the variation in the potential in the basal plane of graphite is negligible so that one can integrate the 12-6 function in the x and y dimensions and leaving a potential form where one must sum over the planes (layers) of graphite.
(4.5) Here Zi is the distance of the adsorbate above the surface, as is the area per carbon in the graphite basal plane, and the sum over j denotes the jth layer in the graphite with zij( = Zi + jd) being the distance of the adsorbate from the jth layer and d is the distance between basal planes (= 0.340 nm). An early use of this potential was in the high-temperature study of the adsorption of methane in porous carbon ofBojan et al. [18]. For studies where the periodicity of the graphite surface plays a role in the determination of properties, (e.g., low-temperature determinations of the structure oflayers adsorbed on graphite), the Fourier expanded molecule-surface potential of Steele is commonly used [4-6, 19]. For complex geometries such as heterogeneous surfaces (see Bojan et aI., coal pores [20]) and fullerenes [21] (Martinez-Alonso et aI., Ar on C 60 ), a full sum ofthe direct atom-atom potentials is needed. In the recent simulation studies of carbon nanotubes, some studies have used asummed atom-atom potential description (e.g., see the work of Stan et al. [22]) while others use a continuum cylindrical pore model [23, 24]. These two terms (the adsorbate-adsorbate interaction and the adsorbatesolid interaction) are the essentials that must be included in the interaction potential. However, depending on the degree ofaccuracy needed in the potential description, terms can be included to take three body effects into account. Although this contribution to the gas-surface potential can account for as much as 10% of the interaction [25], to simplify computations, three-body interactions are often included implicitly via parameters in the potentials. Potentials of this nature are referred to as effective pair potentials. 4.2.1.2 Boundary conditions
Once the model potential has been selected, appropriate system size and boundary conditions must be set. When working with a flat surface (e.g., graphite), the solid surface is typically located at Z = 0 and a reflecting wall is placed at a distance Zmax above the surface. Any particles that reach this top of the simulation cell undergo an elastic collision. This is done to insure conservation of mass. The height above the plane is chosen to minimize volume size without influencing the properties of the adsorbed system. The x and y dimensions of the system are made as large as possible (or as needed), given the constraints of the model and computer resources. At the x and y borders, periodic boundary conditions are typically imposed. This is the mathematical equivalent of having
82
Chapter 4 Monte Carlo and Molecular Dynamics
an infinite surface in the x and y dimensions. This is done simply by having particles that cross a simulation boundary on one side of the simulation cell enter the simulation cell on the other side, with the same direction (and speed). For a model where a periodic surface potential is being used, the x and y dimensions must be an integral number of unit cells so that there will be no discontinuities in the potential at the boundaries. For studies in cylindrical pores (nanotubes, coal pores), the carbon potential defines the x, y dimensions (or r, () dimension) and periodic boundary conditions are imposed along the z-dimension (axis of the cylinder) rendering the pore effectively infinite in length. Details of how these boundary conditions are implemented in a simulation can be found in books such as those by Allen and Tildesley [7], Frenkel and Smit [8], and Haile [9]. In choosing system size, one must also consider the properties being calculated. The size must be chosen to reproduce the proper thermodynamic state (e.g., give the appropriate density) and the dimensions must be large enough so that the imposition of periodic boundary conditions does not affect the value of the properties being calculated. In practice, this means that the dimensions of the box must be large compared to the extent of the long-range interactions or the correlation length of the property of interest. Most attractive interactive forces die away quickly so that boundaries on order of 5 or more molecular diameters are usually sufficient when calculating many thermodynamic properties such as density and energy distributions, chemical potential, and structure. However, for properties that depend on interactions that do not die away quickly (such as electrostatic energies) or properties where the correlation length is long, larger system sizes are necessary. Problems with size effects (incorrect results due to use of small system sizes) have been seen, e. g., in simulation studies of surface solid formation and surface melting. For example, see the recent work by Roth [26], where the structure and melting of Kr adsorbed on graphite was studied using MD simulation. Roth found that the use of a small system size resulted in an increase in the melting temperature of 10K or more depending on the system size when reflecting boundary conditions were used. In other words, when too small a system size is used, the surface structure appears to be more ordered than in a very large system.
4.2.1.3 Ensemble selection Since the goal of a simulation is to calculate properties of a particular macroscopic thermodynamic system from the configurations of many microscopic states, the final consideration in model selection is the choice of the thermodynamic state of the system. This can be done by fixing three thermodynamic variables (such as pressure, P, temperature T, internal energy, E) and designing the simulation so that these functions remain constant throughout the calculation. The choice of the thermodynamic state defines the ensemble and since the ensemble is chosen based upon the properties of interest, more details about the different ensembles will be given in Section 4.2.4.3.
4.2 Overview of Computer Simulations
4.2.2 Initialization Once the model has been chosen and set up, the simulation needs only to be initialized. The key in initializing the simulation is to be sure to start at some reasonable configuration. This means that all particles in the initial configuration must have positions (and velocities in an MD simulation) that are inside the simulation boundaries and that particles do not overlap. One way to do this is to assign specific (lattice) positions to the number of particles in the simulation cell using the particles' diameter (at least) to provide for adequate spacing between particles. Another simple way to initialize is to use a configuration (positions and velocities) from a previous simulation that used the same geometry. A third way is to use the gcmc algorithm for creating and deleting particles to initialize the system, i.e., allow particles to be created in this algorithm until the required density (or number of particles) is achieved then switch to the algorithm for the ensemble being used in the simulation. Once initial positions and velocities of the particles in the simulation have been assigned, a number of simulation steps are done to equilibrate the system. The total number of steps that is needed in this part depends on the model and the density of the system. In practice, the investigator must ascertain the number of steps needed for equilibration for their situation. This is done by monitoring one or more of the average properties as a function of time (or number of steps). When the block averages (averages taken over small blocks of time say 500-1000 steps) remain constant, one can assume that the system has equilibrated and data gathering (or production) runs can begin. During the data-gathering phase of the simulation, configurations and thermodynamic averages can be saved. These are the results that are used to calculate the properties of interest.
4.2.3 Generating Configurations Although there are variations: the two main ways of generating configurations (positions or positions and velocities) are MD and MC techniques. These two methods will be described by considering a collection of atoms or molecules (particles) in the canonical or microcanonical ensemble, i.e., we will assume that the number of particles, the volume and either the temperature (T) or total potential energy (E) are held constant in the simulation. (NVT, NVE). MC and MD techniques for generating configurations in the other ensembles (with other thermodynamic variables held constant) have been developed and are described in Allen and Tildesley [7] and Frenkel and Smit [8].
4.2.3.1 Molecular dynamics In MD, solving the classical equations of motion generates configurations (positions and momenta). These can be written as
rnd 2 r
Newton's equation F = rna = - second-order differential equation dt 2
Chapter 4 Monte Carlo and Molecular Dynamics
dr p v=-=Hamilton's equation dt m d coupled first-order differential equations d F=mv=J!..
dt
dt
where m is the mass, F is the force, a is the acceleration, t is the time, v is the velocity, p is the momentum = mv, and r is the position. Given the initial positions and velocities of the particles, the initial accelerations can be calculated from the forces.
F
=-
dUtot(r) dr
= ma
(4.6)
where Utot(r) is the potential that describes the interaction of the particles in the simulation with each other and with the solid or any other external field. Integrating the equations of motion produces positions and velocities of the particles as a function of time. The algorithms for solving these equations are well known with the Verlet and Predictor-Corrector methods being the most commonly used. (For further details of the derivation and implementation of these algorithms see Allen and Tildesley [7], and Frenkel and Smit [8].) In a typical simulation, it is necessary to perform on the order of 40 000 or more steps in the integration and use 500-1000 configurations to calculate the dynamic and thermodynamic averages needed to determine the properties of interest. Because the integration of the equations of motion is done with respect to time, it is the size of the time step (dt in the equations of motion) that determines the stability (correctness) of the solutions. Physically, this means that the time step must be small compared to the characteristic timescale of the properties of interest to obtain meaningful results. For dynamic properties such as diffusion, the time steps needs to be two or three orders of magnitude smaller than the characteristic timescale of the property. For example, in the simulation studies of diffusion in cylindrical carbon pores [27], the mean square displacements of adsorbed molecules needed to be calculated for over 5 s in order to obtain surface diffusion constants. The requirement is that the mean square displacement become linear in time within this time (see Fig. 4.1). To get stable results a time step of 1.6 x 10-3 ps was assumed and approximately 3000 time steps (300 configurations) were used to determine the diffusion constants. For simulations where properties such as density, chemical potential, and energy are being calculated, time steps on the order of 10- 3 ps are typical and give stable thermodynamic results. However, if the systems being studied are undergoing processes with longer timescales (e.g., solid rearrangements or chemical reactions), longer timescales are needed and often multiple time scales need to be considered. Because the time dependence of atomic properties is known, both thermodynamic and dynamic properties can be calculated. This is the main advantage of MD as a method for generating configurations.
85
4.2 Overview of Computer Simulations
6....-----------r"'----------.. NP=10
NP=30
NP=50 NP=60
NP=75 NP=90
o........ :;;;;;;....---------'---------~ 5.0 2.5 0.0 Time (ps)
Figure 4.1 The time dependence of the mean square displacements for adsorbed methane at T = 300 K in the direction parallel to the pore axis is shown for a range of time sufficient for the squares of the molecular displacement to become linear functions of time. NP denotes the total number of molecules in the pore. The slopes of the linear portions of the plots give the self-diffusion constant D = 2 x slope.
4.2.3.2 Monte Carlo The basic approach to generating configurations using Me can be outlined using the following steps: (1) Generate configurations by assigning coordinates randomly, i.e., choose three random numbers (RN) between 0 and 1 for each molecule. These RN determine the x, y, and z coordinates of each particle. (2) Test the configuration: Is it acceptable? The criteria for acceptance are based on the potential energy of the configuration. One calculates Utot = total potential energy of the particles in the configuration. Then the probability of acceptance is given by P = N exp [ - Utot/kT] , where N exp is a normalizing factor so that P will range from o to 1. If the configuration has total potential energy that is negative, the probability P will be unity and the configuration will be accepted. However, if the total potential energy is positive, P will be small and the probability is high that the configuration will be rejected.
The problem with this basic approach is that when configurations are generated randomly, many impossible configurations are generated: For example, it
86
Chapter 4 Monte Carlo and Molecular Dynamics
is highly probable that two particles in a randomly generated configuration will overlap (occupy the same space). This results in an enormous positive energy, and the probability of that configuration existing is negligibly small. In other words, if we start a simulation by randomly assigning positions to all of the particles, we will usually find ourselves in a region of space far from equilibrium. In fact most configurations generated randomly will be be rejected, thus rendering the technique useless. The solution to this is to use a technique known as importance sampling or often referred to as SMART MC (see Frenkel and Smit [8, Chapter 3] for a beautiful explanation). In this technique a simulation is started with particles whose positions are already at or near equilibrium (this is the SMART part of it) and as we generate new configurations, these configurations are tested. If a newly generated configuration is highly improbable, the configuration is rejected and we return to the previous (probable) configuration and try again. In other words, if we ever start to move away from equilibrium, we take a step back (reject the move) and try moving in another direction. One of the simplest and earliest methods used to generate configurations can be used to illustrate the process. In this method (the Metropolis Method), new configurations are generated by randomly selecting a particle then displacing that particle by a small amount. The direction and size of the displacement is determined by the selection of more random numbers chosen to determine dx, dy, and dz, which represent the distance moved in the x, y, and z directions, respectively. The maximum size of the displacement (which depends on the system size, density of particles, temperature, etc.) is set during initialization. Once a new configuration has been generated the energy change that occurs due to the displacement is calculated: (4.7)
If ~ U is negative, the new configuration is accepted. If ~ U is pOSItIve, the configuration is accepted with a probability that will eventually produce a Boltzmann distribution. This is done by choosing another random number between 0 and land if exp[-~U/kT] is greater than the random number, the new configuration is accepted. However, if exp[-~U/kT] is less than the random number then the configuration is rejected. It is important to note that in order for the MC simulation technique to work, the sequence of configurations must form a Markov Chain. A Markov Chain is a sequence of trials that satisfy the following conditions:
(a) The outcome of each trial belongs to a finite set of outcomes called the state space. (b) The outcome of each trial depends only on the outcome of the trial that immediately preceeds it. In computer simulations, one scheme that is guaranteed to produce a Markov Chain imposes the condition of microscopic reversibility [7, 8]. This is simply
4.2 Overview of Computer Simulations
the condition that the probability of a transition (change to a new state) must be equal to the probability of the new state reverting back to the original state. In the Metropolis Method, a Boltzmann distribution is used to decide the probability of each transition. We can select other distributions (other ways of sampling) as long as we make sure that the condition of microscopic reversibility is satisfied. This becomes desirable when the efficiency of the simulation is low (when the percent of accepted moves is small). Techniques that use modified distributions for sampling are known as biased sampling techniques and are discussed in Chapter 13 of Frenkel and Smit [8]. For many MC simulations the maximum size of the displacement (dx, dy, dz) can be adjusted so that the percentage of moves that will be accepted is about 50 %. This percentage is easily adjusted by increasing the displacement to reduce the acceptance ratio or decreasing the displacement to increase the ratio. The actual value can be varied with density, i.e., the higher the density, the smaller the displacement needed to achieve high acceptance rates. Although some studies have been done to try to determine the best acceptance criteria [28], in practice, the value is usually determined via trial and error. There are many variations on the Metropolis Method. The most common is probably the gcmc method as developed by Norman and Filinov [29]. In this method, the chemical potential, volume, and temperature of the system are held constant and the number of particles is allowed to vary in each step of the simulation. This is done by adding creation and deletion steps to the Metropolis algorithm, and the acceptance criteria (probability distribution function for acceptance) is defined as a function of the chemical potential and density of the state. Unlike the displacement move, the acceptance rates for the creation/deletion move is typically small: rv2-10 % with the smaller acceptance ratios corresponding to simulations at high density. It is easy to understand why this occurs when one realizes that newly created particles are placed in randomly chosen locations within the simulation cell. As the density ofthe system increases, the chances that a particle will be created in a space already occupied by another particle is rather high and overlapping configurations are always rejected. The acceptance rates can be improved by incorporating a biased sampling scheme into the algorithm. See, e.g., Bojan et al. [30], where a nonuniform distribution function derived from the average potential field of the adsorbed molecules was used to increase the efficiency of the sampling distribution. A similar scheme is employed by Jiang and Gubbins [31] in their Gibbs ensemble MC simulation of CH 4 on graphite. So far, the discussion of MC algorithms has applied to monatomic adsorbates. When an adsorbate with orientation dependence is being studied, the MC displacement step should be followed by a random reorientation of the chosen molecule as well. The addition of this type of move, like the creation/deletion step, is likely to decrease acceptance probabilities and thus the efficiency of the simulations. Cracknell et al. [32] describe a biased sampling technique that is appropriate for increasing the efficiency of this step. A very clear description of
88
Chapter 4 Monte Carlo and Molecular Dynamics
14
r----r-----.~-""""P"'_-
........--...__-__r"--...._-~__.
.......
12
A
A ••••
.........
10
"......
....
8
.'
6
...... .~
:'
IJA
,,
4 ,.
,.
'''·'·'·'·'···;:;1~~.::-·
~_
....... ,
....
.,. ,.
,.
.....
.
~ ~/
2
T=195.5K
Ia.'. -m
JI.'.
II.·············· T =233.2 K T=273.2K
.:.".. ...... ··8"~_._._.-M-._._._._~._._._.-M._._·_·-M._·_·_·_""
_ _.L-.J 700 800
0_1III!~.::.:.:.~~_.L..._--.L._--lL..-_...I.-_-..L
o
100
200
300
400
500
600
P (Torr)
Figure 4.2 Simulated isotherms are compared with the experimental data for CO 2 at the temperatures indicated. The curves for T> 195 K show the experimental data from Re£ [34] and the points are simulated. At 195 K, the curve shows the data of Beebe et ale [35], the triangles show the experimental data from Ref. [34] and the circles show simulated data from Ref. [34].
the gcmc algorithm as it applies to the adsorption of water in graphite slit pores is given in a recent paper by Uhlberg and Gubbins [33]. As in MD simulations, a MC simulation is performed for a number of moves to reach equilibrium. In most MC methods, the number of attempted moves to equilibrate is on order of 1 to 100 million. This is followed by another 100 million moves that provide the configurations needed to determine the desired thermodynamic averages. Using the gcmc simulation technique, Bottani et al. [34] studied the adsorption of CO 2 on graphite at four different temperatures. Figure 4.2 is a comparison of the simulation with experimental results showing excellent agreement. Each point on the simulated isotherms was obtained using the gcmc algorithm to generate 2 x 106 configurations. After each set of 100 moves the total number of particles (N) in the simulation cell is recorded and an average of the number of particles is obtained by averaging the 2 x 104 values of N obtained in this way. Since the chemical potential is fixed, the pressure can be calculated and by repeating this process at many values of the chemical potential the adsorption isotherm is obtained. Once the connection between experiment and simulation has been established, the investigators can explore the molecular configurations in the adsorbed film in more detail. Figures 4.3 and 4.4 show results obtained from the CO 2 simulation study that are not experimentally available. The first layer adsorption (Fig. 4.3) can be used to determine the monolayer capacity and thus the area per molecule in the monolayer (Am) as a function of temperature. However
4.2 Overview of Computer Simulations
100 90 80
en
70
"S
60
(5
50
Q)
() Q)
.s ;£
T=273.2K
T = 195.5 K
40 30 20 10 0
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
N tot [molecules]
Figure 4.3 Plots of the simulated values of the number of molecules in layer 1 (Nt) versus the total number adsorbed (Ntot ) are shown for three temperatures. Note that Nt = 78 for a total number of 90 molecules at 195 K.
the area per molecule depends on the orientation of the CO 2 molecule on the surface. The molecule occupies much less space (and Am would be much smaller) if the molecule stood on end as opposed to lying flat on the surface. The snapshot of the CO 2 configuration at 195 K (Fig. 4.4) shows the orientation of the molecules on the surface and thus tells much about the structure of the adsorbate. The inclusion of the known quadrupole moment as part of the CO 2-C0 2 interaction energy has a significant effect on the simulated isotherms, which do not agree with experiment if the quadrupolar interactions are omitted. Furthermore, this interaction favors pair orientations that are T -shaped. The fluid molecules shown in the lower panel of Fig. 4.4 are mostly parallel to the surface and often in T -configurations. (Note that the low-temperature two-dimensional (2D) solid for CO 2 forms a herringbone lattice with all pairs in nearly T -orientations.) Taken together, these data help provide a more detailed picture and understanding of both the experimental and simulation results.
4.2.4 Determining Properties from Configurations The determination of dynamic and thermodynamic properties from computer simulations relies upon the assumption that observed (macroscopic) properties can be calculated by finding the time-averaged value of the property from MD « A > time) or the ensemble-averaged value of a property from MC) « A > ens') The goal of a computer simulation is to generate enough states or configurations of the system of interest to be able to evaluate such time or ensemble averages.
Chapter 4 Monte Carlo and Molecular Dynamics
9°
Figure 4.4 Shapshots of 90 molecules of adsorbed CO 2 at 195 K. The black bands indicate the central carbon atoms in each molecule. The upper panel is a side view of all 90 molecules and the lower panel is a top view of the 78 molecules in the first layer only.
4.2.4.1 Ensemble averaging In a MC simulation, the ensemble average of a property is determined by summing the value of the property in each configuration and dividing by the total number of configurations [7]. In general,
A obs = (A) ens A obs = (A)ens
= (A (f (r))) = -
1
Tobs
Tobs
= (A(f(r))) =
LA (f (r))
(4.8)
T=l
1
Tobs
-
LA(f(T))
'T obs T=l
where A obs is the observed value of a property,
ens is the ensemble-averaged value of the property, fer) is the generalized coordinates (positions only) T is the index over state points, and 'Tobs is the total number of states or points generated by the MC prescription.
91
4.2 Overview of Computer Simulations
For example, in the simulation of Ar and CO 2 on C 60 fullerene by MartinezAlonso et al. [21] , the simulated isotherm was compared to experimental isotherms. Using a grand canonical ensemble, the isotherm was obtained by calculating the average number of particles in the simulation cell (Nens ) for each fixed value of the chemical potential using the MC method to generate configurations (positions of the particles in the simulation cell). 1
N ens = (N(r)) = -
Tobs
LN(r)
(4.9)
robs T=l
1
N ens = (N(r)) = -
Tobs
LN(r)
robs
1
where N(r) is the total number of particles in the simulation volume in the rth configuration. In addition to the isotherm, the configurational information can be used to obtain local density distributions of the particles on an adsorbing surface. For instance, if the adsorbent is made up of C 60 particles, the density as a function of distance from the surface shows the layers of adsorbate forming and lends insight into the structure of the surface layers as shown in Fig. 4.5. 2.5 , . . - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - . ,
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0 .....__ __...,..,IIII__...J....__;;;;;L...._...4.__ 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2.0 2.2 ~
__1__
2.4
__L.,;;;===___L__........&_._
2.6
2.8
3.0
___L._---J
3.2
3.4
Z(nm)
Figure 4.5 Simulated densities of Ar at 77.5 K (thick line) and CO 2 at 195.5 K (thin line) adsorbed on an fcc array of C60 molecules approximated as spherical bodies are plotted as a function ofdistance from the solid adsorbent. Adsorption on the outermost layer ofC60 spheres produces three density peaks: one at 1.4 nm in the deep (and strongly interacting) crevices located in the centers ofthe squares formed by four C60 molecules; one at 1.8 nm in the crevices between pairs of neighboring C60's; and one at rv2.1 nm for adsorbed molecules directly over a C60. Peaks at larger distances reflect structure in the adsorbed fluid, with the CO 2 density decreasing to zero after second layer formation at 195.5 K because of its relatively small amount in the simulation box compared to the Ar multilayer densities at 77.5 K.
92
Chapter 4 Monte Carlo and Molecular Dynamics
4.2.4.2 Time averaging In MD simulations, both the positions and velocities of the particles are calculated and because their time dependence is known, both thermodynamic and dynamic properties can be calculated. This is the main advantage of MD as a method for generating configurations. In this case, the time-averaged properties can be evaluated [7]:
A obs = (A)time
lim
1 {tobs
= (A (r(t))) = - - 1n
A (f(t))dt tobs 0 tobs lim 1 A obs = (A)time = (A(r(t)) = - - - A(r(t))dt tobs~oo tobs 0
(4.10)
tobs~oo
f
where A obs is the observed value of a property, < A >time is the time-averaged value of the property, and is the generalized coordinates (positions and momenta) as a function of time. In the recent simulation by Matties and Hentschke [36, 37], the adsorption and melting ofbenzene on graphite was studied via MD simulations. In addition to determining static properties such as the center of mass density distributions and tilt angles as a function of temperature by obtaining time averages, they were also able to obtain dynamic properties such as the surface diffusion constants in the monolayer and the orientational velocity autocorrelation function (OVAF).
ret)
OVAF = Z (r)
= (vxy (t) • vxy (t + r))
(4.11)
This function is a measure of the reorientation of the component of the velocity vector parallel to the surface vxy . It is calculated by choosing a molecule and following its motion as a function of time for a specified time period, averaging the velocity autocorrelation function (the dot product of the 2D vector velocity at the time t, vxy(t) with the velocity at a later time in the trajectory (vxy(t + r)). This average is calculated for all molecules and for many different initial starting times. The determination of this function can be used to understand the motion of the adsorbed benzene molecules on the surface. Negative values of this time-correlation function are the result of a constraining environment representative of a solid structure so it serves as an indicator of the transition from a solid to a liquid monolayer as temperature is increased [36]. Matties and Hentschke [37] are also able to show that even at high coverage (multilayer adsorption) and high temperature there is some semblance of solid order in the adsorbed benzene layers (see Fig. 4.6).
4.2.4.3 Results using different thermodynamic ensembles Historically, simulations using the microcanonical ensemble were among the earliest ones reported. The algorithm is easy to 5mplement both conceptually
93
4.2 Overview of Computer Simulations
0.04
180.......200··+---
0.02 0
E I\J
-0.02 240 ---260 -
-0.04
280 ··41·'-'· _~~_ ...
---------- -. 300 -..
-0.06
320 .-..--
-0.08 -0.10
o
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0 T
0.04
1.2
1.4
1.6
1.8
2.0
(pS)
200 -+-220-+-
(b)
0.02
240··.····-
0
E
I\J
-0.02 260--
-0.04
280 ---300··..·•·• 320 .....--·
-0.06 -0.08 -0.10 0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
1.4
1.6
1.8 2.0
T(pS)
Figure 4.6 Linear velocity time correlation functions are shown for benzene on graphite at coverages of two (a) and three monolayers (b). These curves are averages over all molecules of the product of the molecular velocity vector parallel to the surface at time zero and the value of this vector at time r, normalized to unity at time zero. Numbers at the right denote temperature in Kelvin. Curves for the highest temperatures decay monatomically to zero, as is typical for weakly interacting fluids where there is no significant cage formation. The negative values for Z(r) indicate anticorrelation in the velocity direction, characteristic of motion within a constraining cage.
and technically since the volume (V) (simulation boundaries) and the number of particles (N) remain constant. In addition, the total potential energy (E) is held constant: (N, V, E). Although the total density (N/ V) is constant in a bulk phase, in simulations of surface phenomena the presence of the external potential (adsorbing surface) produces large variations in the density, making this ensemble useful for studying structures of adsorbed phases and energy distributions.
94
Chapter 4 Monte Carlo and Molecular Dynamics
Furthermore, while the total energy is held constant, the energy is distributed between the molecules adsorbed and in the gas phase. Therefore, the distribution of energy between these two phases can be explored and compared to experimental isosteric heats of adsorption. For example, the paper by Steele et al. [38] summarizes the results obtained for N 2 adsorbed on graphite using MD simulations in the microcanonical ensemble. Besides calculating heats of adsorption, they were able to study how the energy of the adsorbate molecules varied along the surface and use this to understand the 2D phase diagram of N 2 on graphite and the role of the quadrupole moment in the formation of the surface structures. However, despite the ease of simulations in this ensemble, it is not easy to devise an experiment where the internal energy is held constant and it is more natural to look for a technique that corresponds to the more common experimental situation of constant temperature. Canonical ensemble (N, V, T) is a variation on the microcanonical ensemble where the temperature is held constant rather than the energy. In the constraint method described by Evans and Morris [39], this is done in a MD simulation by rescaling the velocities to maintain a constant kinetic energy. A more rigorous algorithm developed by Nose [40] and reformulated by Hoover [41] introduces an additional degree of freedom into the simulation that acts as a heat bath. Energy is exchanged with the artificial coordinate and its velocity introduced to maintain a constant temperature, but nevertheless allowing for fluctuations in the kinetic energy. Studies of these techniques show that the Nose algorithm does indeed produce the correct canonical distribution in both position and momentum space. However, the isokinetic scheme has been shown to give correct canonical ensemble averages for properties that depend on coordinates [42]. Kim and Steele [43] used isokinetic MD simulations to study the phase diagram of the methane monolayer on a corrugated graphite surface. They were able to compare their simulation results for the structure of the methane monolayer to the results of neutron scattering experiments and found good agreement. Trajectory plots (plots of positions of the molecules as a function of time) obtained from this simulation at four temperatures are shown in Fig. 4.7. These traj ectories show the transition from a commensurate to an incommensurate solid, even hinting at the possibility of a two-phase coexistence. The study of phase transitions and structure is one of the goals of computer simulations; however, determining the pressure in the canonical and microcanonical ensemble can be difficult. It is done using either thermodynamic integration [44, 45], or the test particle method of Widom [46]. Both of these techniques are computationally intensive, so the development of an ensemble where the pressure can be held constant is desirable. In the isobaric, isothermal ensemble (fixed P, N, T) the pressure is held constant by varying the volume of the simulation cell. Finn and Monson [47] have developed a method for studying adsorption in an isobaric algorithm. Unfortunately, if this method is used in a simulation involving a solid surface one would have to be sure that variations of the volume are accompanied by increases or decreases in the surface area of the adsorbent. This can create significant problems in the potential
4.2 Overview of Computer Simulations
95
:-~:.: ... :~;;T!
I
.- __ _
--\l....~t ~.
••
.
~-::~. ~
~.I~;1 \ • : • • ~ .~~ .
:.~. :r-.v:. ~. ·
. ·:·:·:·:·.·,i~!
~
o~
~
• •
r
I
""
~, ~ ~ ~ t •\ .~ , ••••••••••••••• 'I
• • • • • • • • • • • • ' • • • • • • • 'j
. . . . . . . '! o. . . . . . . . . . I ... .. ..... ..
..................... 'I
..
I'
;1
~
•
•
•
•
•
l J ' •
•
"
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
• •
•
•
•
• •
•
•
lit
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
• •
•
-
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
t
•
•
•
•
to
•
•
~~ ~ '.' ,,~~ !oI·f-""'.""""'-' ;
.~ ~~·:-:-:-:t / ~1i:.: ·:·: ~ N .: ~
J.
1
51 K
56K
Figure 4.7 Plot of the in-plane trajectories of adsorbed molecules at four temperatures are shown here for an incommensurate solid methane monolayer adsorbed on graphite. At the lowest temperatures, the figures show large solid patches with a few drifting particles near the patch edges. As T increases, molecules begin to enter different sublattices and to jump from one to another. (Each plot has a duration of 88 ps.) The dots are for molecules that are vibrating over a single site on the graphite and those molecules that shift from one site to another give rise to larger excursions. The trajectory plots at 55 and 56 K seem to indicate the two-phase coexistence. This possibility is supported by simulated methane-methane interaction histograms for these temperatures that show two peaks in the energy distribution, one near the maximum value for solid and one near the maximum value for the liquid. The fact that this behavior extends over a range of T is probably a finite size effect.
description (discontinuities at the boundaries must be avoided) as well as in the determination and interpretation of most structural properties. Another popular method for studying phase transitions involves the use of the grand canonical ensemble (fixed /-L, V, T), which is most commonly implemented using the MC method (gcmc) described in Section 4.2.3.2. Since the development of this technique it has become the method of choice for the determination of structural and thermodynamic properties of most adsorbateadsorbent systems. For example, Bottani et al. have recently presented gcmc simulation results for gases such as N 2 , Ar, and CO 2 adsorbed on carbon nanotubes [48] and on C 60 [49]. In their studies, the authors simulate the adsorption isotherms (number ofa particles as a function of P or /-L), and energy distributions that allow comparison of their simulations with experiments. Furthermore, after
Chapter 4 Monte Carlo and Molecular Dynamics
establishing a firm connection between simulation and experiment, the authors use the density profiles obtained from the simulation to understand where gas molecules adsorb. In studies of bundles of carbon nanotubes, by looking at density distributions they see significant adsorption in the interstitial channels and external surface at low pressures before all interior sites are full even though it is clear that adsorption inside nanotubes is preferred to adsorption outside the tubes (see Fig. 4.8). The Gibbs ensemble is a technique that allows one to study phase equilibria without an interface, by combining two simulations at the same time. In this method originally proposed and developed by Panagiotopoulos [50] two simulation cells are set up: each cell represents one of the two phases in equilibrium with each other. In this algorithm, the total N, V, and T are held constant; however, N and V vary in the separate simulation cells. The acceptance conditions for the various MC moves maintain the same chemical potential (i.e., equilibrium) in the two simulation cells. The method involves the execution of three types of MC trial moves. The first is the displacement of a randomly
(a)
(c)
(b)
35,.----------, o
46
Q
o
41 36 31 ~ 26
21 16 11 6
6 11 1621 2631 3641 46
X
Figure 4.8 Maps of the average density of nitrogen adsorbed in three nanotube bundles. The contours are for constant density in the x, y planes; Le., for an observer looking in the z direction parallel to the pore axes. The pore diameters are (a) 1.37 nm, (b) 1.43 nm, and (c) 0.69nm. The in-plane coordinates x, yare defined so that unit x, y== 0.07, 0.14nm, respectively. The larger blobs show density contours inside the tubes and the smaller ones are for molecules adsorbed in the interstices between the hexagonally packed tubes. The interaction potential for the N 2 is diatomic; thus, the approximate molecular length is 0.1 nm greater than the width which is 0.35 nm. The consequence is that the tube of (c) is too small to admit the N 2 molecules so that the adsorption shown there is essential all interstitial. Also, in (a) and (b), the N 2 appears to lie parallel to the tube axis and is adsorbed on the tube walls. The differences between the (a) and (b) contours are at least partly due to the differences in the numbers of molecules in these systems. These amount to 334 and 199 in (a) and (b).
4.3 Conclusions
97
chosen molecule in each cell to maintain internal equilibrium. The second is a change in the volume of one of the simulation cells that is accompanied by a corresponding volume change in the other such that the total volume remains constant. The third type of move involves the transfer of a randomly chosen particle from one simulation cell to the other (to maintain chemical equilibrium). Panagiotopoulos [51] extended the technique to simulate the coexistence offluids adsorbed in micropores. In this study, he simulated both the coexistence between the pore fluid and the bulk fluid (to obtain the adsorption isotherm) and capillary condensation in cylindrical pores. Since its development this method has been used in studies of both vapor-liquid [31] and liquid-liquid [52] phase transitions in carbon nanopores.
4-3
CONCLUSIONS
MC and MD are versatile techniques that have been shown to be powerful methods of enhancing our understanding of molecular behavior both of carbon surfaces and of the many other solid adsorbents presently in use. Although this chapter has dealt with the basics of computer simulation, there are many areas where simulators have been active that have not been dealt with in the chapter (e.g., see Chapters 5,6,8-10, and 15). In general, MD is used when transport properties are desired and MC, when thermodynamic properties are the subject of interest. An important feature is that a wide variety of experimental systems are encountered in this field, starting with flat, homogeneous, chemically uniform surfaces such as graphite, metals, and single crystals of ionic material. The algorithms initially developed to deal with such cases were soon modified and altered to handle porous materials or materials with impurities and/or imperfections in their exposed surfaces. This has enabled the researcher to dispense with the older theories that by necessity included approximations that inevitably had the possibility of invalidating the results of analyses based on such oversimplified models. It is probably fair to say that many of the advanced algorithms now in use might never have been developed if they were not required for the simulation of relevant adsorption systems. Fortunately, the advances in the analysis of complex adsorption systems have coincided with the impressive improvements in computing power needed to carry out these analyses. There are still new and exciting areas under development. These include the path integral Monte Carlo (PIMC) method where quantum systems interacting with graphite can be studied. Manousakis et al. have used the PIMC technique to study 4He and H 2 films [53-57] on graphite. They are able to simulate the low temperature structural properties, including 2D phase transitions. Johnson et al. have developed a path integral gcmc technique that allows them to calculate adsorption isotherms. Using this method, Wang and Johnson have simulated H 2 and He in carbon slit pores [58] and carbon nanotubes [59]. They have studied
Chapter 4 Monte Carlo and Molecular Dynamics
H 2 storage in graphite nanofibers [60], the feasibility of using carbon nanotubes to separate hydrogen isotopes [61] and phase behavior of H 2 and He isotopes in nanotubes [62]. Another exciting new direction that is developing is a technique known as reverse MC [63] (also see Chapter 5 of this book). In this method, rather than performing a simulation to gather configurations on an assumed solid, MC moves are made on the atomic configuration of a simple model adsorbent in an attempt to move from the original configuration to a configuration, which agrees with a previously chosen experimental property of the adsorbent such as the structure factor. The generation of carbon adsorbents whose structures match the available experimental data has been investigated by Gubbins and coworkers [64-67] using this method. Reference [66] gives a brief review of previous efforts to deal with the structural problem for porous carbons. Once model adsorbents are generated using the constrained Me technique, Gubbins et al. perform standard gcmc simulations ofN2 adsorbed on their model systems to determine pore size distributions, porosity and heats of adsorption of the model surfaces. Although this technique is quite computer-intensive, the resulting structures appear to be good representations of porous carbon as indicated by the agreement with experiment of simulations of the adsorption of simple gases in the model samples.
REFERENCES
1. Rowley, L.A., Nicholson, D., and Parsonage, N.G. (1976). Grand ensemble Monte Carlo studies of physical adsorption I. Results for multilayer adsorption of 12-6 argon in the field of a plane homogeneous solid. Mol. Phys., 31, 365-87. 2. Rowley, L.A., Nicholson, D., and Parsonage, N.G. (1976). Grand ensemble Monte Carlo studies of physical adsorption II. The structure of the adsorbate. Critique of theories of multilayer adsorption for 12-6 argon on a plane homogeneous solid. Mol. Phys., 31, 389-407. 3. Rowley, L.A., Nicholson, D., and Parsonage, N.G. (1978). Long-range corrections to grand canonical ensemble Monte Carlo calculations for adsorption systems. J. Comput. Phys., 26, 66-79. 4. Talbot, J., Tildesley, D.J., and Steele, W.A. (1984). A molecular dynamics simulation of nitrogen adsorbed on graphite. Mol. Phys., 51, 1331-56. 5. Talbot, J., Tildesley, D.J., and Steele, W.A. (1986). Molecular dynamics simulation of fluid N 2 adsorbed on a graphite surface. Faraday Disc. Chem. Soc., 80, 91-105. 6. Talbot, J., Tildesley, D.J., and Steele, W.A. (1986). A molecular dynamics simulation of the uniaxial phase of N 2 adsorbed on graphite. Suif. Sci., 169, 71-90. 7. Allen, M.P. and Tildesley, D.J. (1987). Computer Simulation of Liquids. Oxford University Press.
References
99
8. Frenkel, D. and Smit, B. (2002). Understanding Molecular Simulation, From Algorithms to Applications, 2nd edna Academic Press. 9. Haile, J.M. (1992). Molecular Dynamics Simulations: Elementary Methods. J. Wiley and Sons. 10. Balbuena, P.B. and Seminario, J.M. (eds) (1999). Molecular Dynamics, From Classical to Quantum Methods. Elsevier. 11. Bruch L.W., Cole, M.W., and Zaremba, E. (1997). Physical Adsorption: Forces and Phenomenon. Clarendon. 12. Steele, W.A. (1973).The physical interaction of gases with crystalline solids. I. Gas-solid energies and properties of isolated adsorbed atoms. Surf. Sci., 36, 317-52. 13. Steele, W.A. (1978).The interaction of rare gas atoms with graphitized carbon black.]. Phys. Chem., 82, 817-21. 14. Watts, R.O. and McGee, I.J. (1976). Liquid State Chemical Physics. Wiley. 15. Maitland, G.C., Rigby, M., Smith, E.B., and Wakeham, W.A. (1987). Intermolecular Forces: Their Origin and Determination, Tables A3.1 and A3.2. Clarendon, pp.565-66. 16. Steele, W.A. (1974). The Interaction of Gases with Solid Surfaces. Pergamon Press. 17. Murthy, C.S., Singer, K., Klein, M.L., and McDonald, I.R. (1980). Pairwise additive effective potentials for nitrogen. Mol. Phys., 41, 1387-99. 18. Bojan, MJ., van Slooten, R., and Steele, W.A. (1992). Computer simulation studies of the storage of methane in microporous carbons. Separation Sci. Technol., 27, 1837-56. 19. Vernov, A.V. and Steele, W.A. (1986). Computer simulation of the multilayer adsorption of fluid N 2 on graphite. Langmuir, 2, 219-27. 20. Bojan, M.J., Vernov, A.V., and Steele, W.A. (1992). Simulation studies ofadsorption in rough-walled cylindrical pores. Langmuir, 8, 901-8. 21. Martinez-Alonso, A. Tascon, J.M.D., and Bottani, EJ. (2001). Physical adsorption of argon and CO 2 on C 60 fullerene.]. Phys. Chem. B, 105, 135-9. 22. Stan, G., Bojan, M.J., Curtarolo, S., et al. (2000). Uptake of gases in bundles of carbon nanotubes. Phys. Rev. B, 62, 2173-80. 23. Calbi, M.M., Gatica, S.M., Bojan, MJ., and Cole, M.W. (2001). Phases of neon, xenon, and methane adsorbed on nanotube bundles.]. Chem. Phys., 21, 9975-81. 24. Maddox, M.W. and Gubbins, K.E. (1995). Molecular simulation offluid adsorption in buckytubes. Langmuir, 11, 3988-96. 25. Kim, H.Y. and Cole, M.W. (1987). Three-body contribution to the adsorption potential of atoms on graphite. Phys. Rev. B, 35, 3990-4. 26. Roth, M.W. (1998). Bond-orientational structure and melting signature in krypton physisorbed onto graphite at complete coverage. Phys. Rev. B, 57, 12520-9. 27. Bojan, M. J., and Steele, W. A. (1993). Computer simulation studies of diffusion in physisorbed monolayers. Mater. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc., 290, 127-34. 28. Kolafa. J. (1988). On optimization of Monte Carlo simulations. Mol. Phys., 63, 559-79. 29. Norman, G.E. and Filinov, V.S. (1969). Investigations of phase transitions by a Monte Carlo method. High Temp. (USSR), 7, 216-22. 30. Bojan, MJ., Bakaev, V.A., and Steele, W.A. (1999). Smart Monte Carlo algorithm for the adsorption of molecules at a surface. Mol. Simul., 23, 191-201. 31. Jiang, S. and Gubbins, K. E. (1995).Vapor-liquid equilibria in two-dimensional Lennard-Jones fluids: unperturbed and substrate-mediated films. Mol. Phys., 86, 599-612.
100
Chapter 4 Monte Carlo and Molecular Dynamics
32. Cracknell, R.F., Nicholson, D., Parsonage, N.G., and Evan, H. (1990). Rotational insertion bias: a novel method for simulating dense phases of structured particles, with particular application to water, Mol. Phys., 71, 931-43. 33. Ulberg, D.E. and Gubbins, K.E. (1994). Monte Carlo implementation on the Connection Machine 2; water in graphite pores. Mol. Simul., 13,205-19. 34. Bottani, E., Bakaev, V.A., and Steele, W.A. (1994). A simulation/experimental study of the thermodynamics properties of CO 2 on graphite. Chem. Eng. Sci., 49, 2931-9. 35. Avgul N.N. and Kiselev A.V. (1970). In Chemistry and Physics of Carbon, Vol. 6, p. 65 (P. Walker, ed.). Marcel Dekker. 36. Matties, M.A. and Hentschke, R. (1996). Molecular dynamics simulation of benzene on graphite. 1. Phase behavior of an adsorbed monolayer. Langmuir, 12, 2495-500. 37. Matties, M.A. and Hentschke, R. (1996). Molecular dynamics simulation of benzene on graphite. 2. Phase behavior of adsorbed multilayers. Langmuir, 12, 2501-4. 38. Steele, W.A., Vernov, A., and Tildesley, DJ. (1987). Studies of the adsorption of N 2 on the graphite basal plane by computer simulation. Carbon, 25, 7-17. 39. Evans, DJ. and Morriss, G.P. (1983).Isothermal isobaric molecular dynamics ensemble. Chem. Phys., 77, 63-6. 40. Nose, S. (1984). A molecular dynamics method for simulations in the canonical ensemble. Mol. Phys., 52, 255-68. 41. Hoover, W. G. (1985). Canonical dynamics: equilibrium phase-space distributions. Phys. Rev. A, 31, 1695-7. 42. Nose, S. (1984). A unified formulation of the constant temperature molecular dynamics methods.]. Chem. Phys., 81, 511-19. 43. Kim, H.-Y. and Steele, W.A. (1992). Computer-simulation study of the phase diagram of the CH 4 monolayer on graphite: corrugation effects. Phys. Rev. B, 45, 6226-33. 44. Kofke, D.A. (1993). Gibbs-Duhem integrations: a new method for direct evaluation of phase coexistence by molecular simulations. Mol. Phys., 78, 1331-6. 45. Kofke, D.A. (1993). Direct evaluation of phase coexistence by molecular simulations via integration along the coexistence line.]. Chem. Phys., 98, 4149-62. 46. Widom, B. (1963).Some topics in the theory offluids.]. Chem. Phys., 39, 2802-12. 47. Finn, J .E. and Monson, P.A. (1988). Adsorption equilibria in an isobaric ensemble. Mol. Phys., 65, 1345-61. 48. Paredes, J.I., Suarez-Garcia, F., Villar-Rodil, S., et al. (2003). N 2 physisorption on carbon nanotubes: computer simulation and experimental results.]. Phys. Chem. B, 107,8905-16. 49. Martinez-Alonso, A. Tasc6n, J.M.D., and Bottani, EJ. (2000). Physisorption of simple gases on C 60 fullerene. Langmuir, 16, 1343-8. 50. Panagiotopoulos, A.Z. (1987). Direct determination ofphase coexistence properties of fluids by Monte Carlo simulation in a new ensemble. Mol. Phys., 61, 813-26. 51. Panagiotopoulos, A. Z. (1987). Adsorption and capillary condensation of fluids in cylindrical pores by Monte Carlo simulation in the Gibbs ensemble. Mol. Phys., 62,701-19. 52. G6zdz, W.T., Gubbins, K.E., and Panagiotopoulos, A.Z. (1995). Liquid-liquid phase transitions in pores. Mol. Phys., 84, 825-34. 53. Pierce, M. and Manousakis, E. (1998). Phase diagram of second layer of 4He adsorbed on graphite. Phys. Rev. Lett., 81, 156-9.
References
101
54. Pierce, M. and Manousakis, E. (1999). Path-integral Monte Carlo simulation of the second layer of 4He adsorbed on graphite. Phys. Rev. B, 59, 3802-14. 55. Pierce, M. and Manousakis, E. (1999). Monolayer solid 4He clusters on graphite. Phys. Rev. Lett., 83, 5314-17. 56. Nho, K. and Manousakis, E. (2002). Submonolayer molecular hydrogen on graphite: a path integral Monte Carlo study. Phys. Rev. B, 65, 115409-1-12. 57. Nho K., and Manousakis, E. (2003). Commensurate-incommensurate transitions in quantum films: submonolayer molecular hydrogen on graphite, Phys. Rev. B, 67, 195411-1-7. 58. Wang, Q. and Johnson, J.K. (1998). Hydrogen adsorption on graphite and in carbon slit pores from path integral simulations. Mol. Phys., 95, 299-309. 59. Wang, Q. and Johnson, J.K. (1999). Molecular simulation of hydrogen adsorption in single-walled carbon nanotubes and idealized carbon slit pores.]. Chern. Phys., 110, 577-86. 60. Wang, Q. andJohnson,J. K. (1999). Computer simulation of hydrogen adsorption on graphitic nanofibers.]. Phys. Chern. B, 103,277-81. 61. Challa, S.R., Sholl, D.S., and Johnson, J.K. (2002). Adsorption and separation of hydrogen isotopes in carbon nanotubes: multicomponent grand canonical Monte Carlo simulations.]. Chern. Phys., 116,814-24. 62. Gatica, S.M., Stan, G., Calbi, M.M., et al. (2000). Axial phase of quantum fluids in nanotubes.]. Low Temp. Phys., 120,337-59. 63. McGreevy, R.L. and Pusztai, L. (1988). Reverse Monte Carlo simulation: a new technique for the determination of disordered structures. Mol. Simul., 1, 359-67. 64. Pikunic, J., Clinard, C., Cohaut, N., et al. (2002). Reconstruction method for the characterization of porous carbons. Stud. Suif. Sci. Catal., 144, 19-26. 65. Pikunic, J., Clinard, C., Cohaut, N., et al. (2003). Structural modeling of porous carbons: constrained reverse Monte Carlo method. Langmuir, 19, 8565-82. 66. Thompson, K.T. and Gubbins, K.E. (2000). Modeling structural morphology of microporous carbons by reverse Monte Carlo. Langmuir, 16, 5761-73. 67. Pikunic, J., Pollen, J.-M., Thompson, K.T., et al. (2001). Improved molecular models for porous carbons. Stud. Suif. Sci. Catal., 132, 647-52.
MODELS OF POROUS CARBONS Henry Bock, Keith E. Gubbins, and Jorge Pikunic Department of Chemical and Biomolecular Engineering, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, NC, USA
Contents 5.1 Introduction 5.2 Experimental Probes
1°3 1°4
5.3 Molecular Models of Carbons 5.4 Adsorption, Diffusion, Reaction 5.5 Conclusions Acknowledgments References
106
5.1
121 127 128 128
INTRODUCTION
Except for the fullerenes, carbon nanotubes, nanohorns, and schwarzites, porous carbons are usually disordered materials, and cannot at present be completely characterized experimentally. Methods such as X-ray and neutron scattering and high-resolution transmission electron microscopy (HRTEM) give partial structural information, but are not yet able to provide a complete description of the atomic structure. Nevertheless, atomistic models of carbons are needed in order to interpret experimental characterization data (adsorption isotherms, heats of adsorption, etc.). They are also a necessary ingredient of any theory or molecular simulation for the prediction of the behavior of adsorbed phases within carbons - including diffusion, adsorption, heat effects, phase transitions, and chemical reactivity. Because the chemical and physical processes involved in the synthesis of disordered porous carbons are not well understood, attempts to develop mimetic modeling procedures, in which theory or simulation methods are used to mimic Adsorption by Carbons ISBN: 978-0-08-044464-2
© 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
103
Chapter 5 Models of Porous Carbons
1°4
the complete synthesis, are difficult or impossible. There have been a few attempts to use ab initio or semiempirical methods to study some particular part of the synthesis route (see Section 5.3.3.2 below). Nevertheless, the great majority of attempts to model porous carbons can be classified as reconstruction methods, in which an atomistic model of the carbon is constructed that is consistent with available experimental structure data, usually X-ray scattering or transmission electron microscopy (TEM). The simplest reconstruction models are single-pore models, of which the slitpore model is the most widely used. The pore structure is represented as a collection of single, nonconnected pores of varying width, and in some cases varying wall thickness or wall heterogeneity. In the slit-pore model, the pores have parallel walls composed of graphene sheets; frequently these are treated as smooth and structureless. This model is widely used to estimate the pore size distribution, feR), where H is pore width, by assuming that the adsorption isotherm is a linear combination of isotherms calculated for pores of different sizes. While convenient, the slit-pore model neglects many important features of real disordered carbons, including pore connectivity, wall roughness, curved and defective graphene sheets, pores of wedge, and other shapes. These neglected features are known to play an important role in many processes in adsorbed phases, such as diffusion, phase changes, and chemical reactions. More recently, more sophisticated atomistic modeling methods have been proposed for disordered carbons that take these features into account at the cost of increased complexity and the need for more experimental data. In this chapter we give an account of the most useful and promising current methods for modeling porous carbons (Section 5.3). For completeness of the discussion we also include (Section 5.2), a brief account of the most important experimental methods for characterizing carbons. Following the section on models, we provide a review ofsome ofthe recent work on predicting the behavior of adsorbed phases within such model carbons (Section 5.4), including adsorption, heats of adsorption, diffusion, and chemical reactions. A more comprehensive review of the types of carbons, experimental methods for studying them, and molecular models has appeared [1] and covers the literature up to 2000.
5.2
EXPERIMENTAL PROBES
In 1917 Debye and Scherrer performed the first powder X-ray scattering experiments on diamond, graphite, and several amorphous carbons (chars) [2]. From their experimental results, Debye and Scherrer concluded that amorphous carbons consist of small graphitic units of about 30 atoms. Scattering is sensitive to the distance between the scattering particles. If a certain distance, d, appears in a periodic fashion, we find constructive interference of the scattered radiation of wavelength, A, at an angle, 2fJ with respect to the incident radiation following Bragg's law, d = A/2sin fJ. The scattering pattern of carbon blacks and activated
5.2 Experimental Probes
105
carbons consist of the (002) three-dimensional (3D) peak and several (hk) twodimensional (2D) peaks. The (002) 3D peak indicates stacking of individual graphitic layers and allows the determination of the inter layer distance, d = 0.32-0.38 nm; 0.3354 nm is found for graphite. The absence offurther 3D peaks is caused by horizontal distortion of the individual graphene sheets within the stack, i.e., by turbostratic ordering. The 2D peaks provide information about the ordering within the graphene sheets and the carbon-carbon distance (0.1415 nm for graphite). Porous carbons generally show less inlayer ordering than graphite and usually a larger interlayer spacing, d002 . The dimensions of the graphene stacks can also be determined from the scattering data. For activated carbons, a stack height of 1 nm (2-3 layers) and a stack width of 1-3 nm is found. Strong scattering but no peaks in small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) (2fJ < 15°) indicate the existence of a nonperiodic pore network at length scales beyond the interlayer spacing [3]. Information about pore morphology and topology, i.e., about the relative position and orientation of the graphitic crystallites and their connectivity is accessible using TEM or HRTEM. The basic principles of TEM are similar to those of conventional light optical microscopy. The contrast in TEM originates from scattering of electrons on the atoms of the porous carbons. Scattered electrons do not pass through the small opening of the objective aperture, thus denser regions of the carbon appear darker in the TEM image since they cause more scattering. In TEM, only the direct beam passes trough the aperture; while in HRTEM also diffracted beams contribute to imaging. This results in a higher resolution and allows not only the determination of qualitative information such as shape and orientation of the pores but also quantitative information such as pore size distributions. It is even possible to obtain the interlayer distance, d002 . Since the graphene sheets in activated carbons are finite and have defects, as seen from X-ray scattering, it is obvious that they are terminated by heteroatoms, such as H, 0, N, S, and P. These atoms generate heterogeneities in the walladsorbate interaction and thus their inclusion is essential for the adsorption properties of carbon materials. To include heteroatoms in models of amorphous carbons, we must know which and how many functional groups a specific carbon material contains and where they are located. Table 5.1 lists a number of methods which can be used to identify these functional groups. The Boehm titration is a wet chemical method where a sequence of bases with increasing basicity (pKa ) is used to titrate (neutralize) substances having a pKa less or equal to that of the base. Thus it is a reliable method to obtain general information about the surface acidity. Modern potentiometric titration significantly improves the pKa resolution compared to the Boehm titration. The usage of nonaqueous solvents as in calorimetric titration increases the pKa range that can be probed. All titration methods are, however, insensitive to the chemical nature of the functional groups, only their acidity is measured. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) uses X-rays to eject core electrons (ls) from carbon, oxygen, nitrogen, or other heteroatoms. The binding energy
Chapter 5 Models of Porous Carbons
106
Table 5.1 Methods for the characterization of activated carbons (Adapted from Ref. [1].)
Small-angle X-ray scattering X-ray diffraction Transmission electron microscopy Gas adsorption Boehm titration Potentiometric titration Calorimetric titration Temperature-programmed desorption (TPD) Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy Immersion calorimetry Flow adsorption Inverse gas chromatography
Total surface area (open and closed pores) mean pore size Mean crystallite size, carbon-carbon pair correlation function 2D images of the pore structure, matrix correlation function Porosity, pore size distributiona , surface area a pKa of functional groups, their number pKa of functional groups, their number pKa of functional groups, their number Type of oxygen functional groups (strong or weak acids)/their number Type of functional groups (number) Type of functional groups, amount of heteroatoms (number of groups) Number of primary adsorption centers (oxygenated groups) Average polarity Average acidity
aThe introduction of an approximate model or a theory is needed to extract this data from the experiments.
of the core electron is measured. Thus XPS is sensitive to the atom type and to the way this atom is bound to its environment. Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) probes molecular vibrations. FTIR spectra are usually analyzed qualitatively by comparison with FTIR spectra of known organic compounds. Gas adsorption is sensitive to various properties of carbons, such as pore size, surface area, and porosity. Thus, it can be used itself to analyze carbon materials. However, the data interpretation relies on appropriate models to connect the adsorption results to properties of the carbon material (see Section 5.3).
5-3
MOLECULAR MODELS OF CARBONS
5.3.1 Regular Porous Carbons Regular porous carbons are carbon materials with a simple pore geometry; they include carbon nanotubes, fullerenes, and schwarzites. If carbon nanotubes are considered for sensor applications, ab initio models are necessary to test whether adsorption of a certain molecule (e.g., N0 2 ) generates a change of the electron density of the nanotube that is large enough to use the nanotube in a sensor [4].
5.3 Molecular Models of Carbons
107
Classical models of carbon nanotubes can be subdivided into two groups: explicit geometric and mean-field models [1]. An explicit model for a single-wall nanotube is obtained by rolling-up a graphene sheet (see Section. 5.3.2) to form a cylindrical surface. Geometric constraints determine possible nanotube diameters, unit cells, and symmetries (zigzag or armchair) [5, 6]. For the carbon atom-adsorbate atom potential [6] the Lennard-Jones (LJ 12-6) potential is often used. If the adsorbate is not sensitive to the atomistic details of the nanotube, e.g., the adsorbate atoms are much bigger than the carbon atoms, a mean-field model can be derived [7]. The mean-field potential is obtained by representing the nanotube wall by an areal density of carbon atoms (LJ 12-6) rather than their explicit positions and integrating along the azimuthal and longitudinal direction (see also Section 5.3.2). The resulting potential depends only on the (normal) distance between the adsorbate and the nanotube. The integration can also be performed numerically, which might be advantageous if more complicated nanotube structures are considered [8]. The extension to multiwall nanotubes and bundles or ropes is straightforward. One obtains the total adsorbate-nanotube potential by superposition of the individual single-wall nanotube potentials. Especially in heterogeneous bundles it is necessary to find the equilibrium configuration of the bundle [9]. In the case of explicit models the relative orientation (rotation) of the individual walls of multiwalled nanotubes and the relative orientation (rotation) of individual nanotubes in a bundle must be decided too [1]. Another interesting polymorph of carbon is fullerene. Although adsorption on individual fullerene molecules and on the surfaces offullerene crystals is not widely studied, explicit [10] as well as mean-field [11] models are available for individual fullerene molecules. The fullerene crystal can be modeled by placing individual (model) fullerene molecules on the sites of an fcc lattice, to match the symmetry and density ofthe real solid [12] or to match equilibrium structures obtained from computer simulations offullerene crystals [10]. A model for a defective crystal can be obtained by removing some ofthe fullerene molecules [13]. Besides fullerenes, nanotubes, and graphite, which are finite or (quasi) infinite in one or two dimensions, regular carbon materials that are infinite in three dimensions, called schwarzites, exist. Schwarzites can be synthesized inside zeolites or other ordered porous silica materials [14]. Thus, their topology and morphology is similar to that of the template, i.e., they consist of an extended network of channels and cages, each one being separated from a neighboring one by a graphene-like wall comprising five- and eight-membered rings. Explicit models for several schwarzites are available in the literature [14].
5.3.2 Disordered Porous Carbons: Simple Geometric Models The evolution of molecular models for disordered porous carbons is strongly connected with the advance of experimental techniques such as diffraction methods and electron microscopy. First, X-ray studies on carbon blacks revealed that these materials consist of a wealth of small graphitic crystallites.
108
Chapter 5 Models of Porous Carbons
The spatial arrangement of these graphitic crystallites determines the pore structure, i.e., the pore morphology and topology. As a consequence, all simple models of porous carbons are based on stacks of graphene sheets representing the pore walls. As in the case of nanotubes discrete as well as mean-field models of single graphene sheets or stacks of them are available. In several cases, both descriptions have been combined in hybrid models. A discrete model of a graphene sheet is obtained by placing (model) carbon atoms on a - 2D hexagonal lattice with lattice constant (carbon-carbon bond length) e. The values of e measured in disordered carbons are usually very similar to that of graphite. Thus, the carboncarbon bond length of graphite, e = 0.1415 nm, is usually used to construct the simple models discussed here. Carbon atoms as well as the adsorbate molecules are often modeled by the LJ 12-6 potential, (5.1) where Gfc and O"fc are the fluid-carbon energy and distance parameters, l respectively, and r is the distance separating two atoms or molecules. The total fluidwall interaction energy of an adsorbate molecule, j, with the graphene sheet is given by the sum, Li cP L] (rij) , which runs over all wall (carbon) atoms, i. This readily defines an explicit model for adsorption on a single graphene sheet. If we can disregard the atomistic nature of the graphene sheet, the sheet is sufficiently characterized by an areal carbon density. A mean-field model is obtained by replacing the sum over individual carbon atoms by an integral of the LJ potential over the area of the graphene sheet. If the sheet is assumed to be infinite in lateral dimensions one obtains the well-known Steele (10-4) potential [15] (5.2) where Psd is the areal number density of carbon atoms in the graphene layer. (Since the structure of graphite is known, the number density of carbon atoms in graphite can be calculated: Ps =2.0/(d12 J'3(3/2)) ~ 114nm- 3 .) With similar integration methods one obtains mean-field potentials for graphene sheets that are finite in one or more directions [1]. A model for a finite stack of graphene layers is obtained by summing over individual graphene layers modeled as described above. The spacing between the layers, d, is usually assumed to be that of graphite, d = d002 = 0.3354 nm. 1
Parameters for LJ potentials between unlike particles are usually obtained from the LJ potentials for the like-like interactions using Lorentz-Berthelot mixing rules, Ore = ,J0ffOee and arc = 1/2 (aff + aeJ. For graphite 0ee ~ 38.7 x 10- 23J and ace ~ 0.34 nm. A list of adsorbate parameters can be found in Ref [15].
5.3 Molecular Models of Carbons
1°9
For simple models this is reasonable, since deviations from this value measured for activated carbons are usually smaller than 0.03 nm and structural simplifications may be more serious. In explicit models ofgraphene stacks the registry ofadjacent layers has to be considered. The thermodynamically stable polymorph ofgraphite is hexagonal graphite having an ABA stacking. The position of the B layer with respect to an A layer can be obtained by starting from a perfectly aligned system (AAA) and displacing every second layer along an arbitrary bond by one bond length. In hybrid models the structure of the first few layers is considered explicitly, while for all other layers a mean-field description is adopted. To derive an even simpler description of a semi-infinite graphite substrate that is infinite in all directions but semi-infinite in the direction perpendicular to the graphene layers, the substrate is represented by a 3D carbon density. Volume integration gives the Steele (9-3) potential [15],
(5.3) Another mean-field potential, which is often used, is obtained by areal integration over the first layer of a semi-infinite graphite substrate and volume integration over all others. This gives the well-known (10-4-3) Steele potential [15],
U z (
) -
211'8
fcPc
[2
10
4
4]
afc a 2 d - -afc - -afc fc 5( z ) ( z) 3d(z+O.61d)3
(5.4)
These different wall models can now be assembled such that they confine some spatial region which represents the pore. The simplest and most widely used case is the slit pore. A slit pore of width, H, is created by placing two mutually parallel and laterally infinite graphene stacks at a distance, H, apart. Pores shaped like rectangular prisms are obtained by placing four graphene stacks at the side faces of the prism. To avoid overlap the graphene stacks are laterally finite or semi-infinite in the dimension perpendicular to the long axis of the prism [16, 17]. TEM images of many specimens reveal that the pore walls are usually not parallel. Because of this observation, a model for pores shaped like triangular prisms has been developed [18]. It is important to notice that the latter two models differ from the slit-pore model not only by pore morphology but also by the appearance of high-energy sites at the edges, generated by proximity of the two walls. Hybrid models are usually used to study defective surfaces. In these models the internal surfaces of a slit pore, defined by a stack of mean-field layers, are "coated" by one or more graphene layers with explicit atomic structure. To generate defects one or more carbon atoms are removed from one or more explicit graphene layers [19, 20]. All models discussed in this section are single-pore models describing the morphology of a single pore. The topology of the disordered material,
110
Chapter 5 Models of Porous Carbons
i.e., connectivity of pores, as well as the variety of pore sizes is completely disregarded, which significantly limits the predictive capabilities of these models. In recent years experimental techniques have been improved, providing much more detailed information of carbon materials. As described in the following section, this information is used together with sophisticated theoretical and simulation methods to obtain more detailed and more reliable models for disordered porous carbons.
5.3.3 Disordered Carbons: More Realistic Models 5.3.3.1 Reconstruction methods The goal of reconstruction methods is to build model pore structures that match experimental structure data (including surface chemistry data) for the real materials, at least in a qualitative way. For example, models can be constructed that match the experimental structure factor, Seq), or TEM data, by reverse Monte Carlo (RMC), off-lattice reconstruction, or other methods. Reconstruction methods can in principle be used to build a model for any type of porous material. However, considerable care and thought is needed in applying such methods, since the experimental data does not correspond to a unique molecular structure. For example, a range of atomic structures could give rise to the same S( q) curve or TEM data. This ambiguity can be reduced by incorporating constraints into the model development, so that unphysical structures cannot result, and by using more than one kind of experimental data in the fitting process. The simple geometric models mentioned above (see Section 5.3.2) can be thought of as the most basic form of reconstruction methods, in which the pore topology is based on electron micrographs of the material (e.g., cylindrical, slit-shaped), and the structure of the pore walls is assumed to be that of graphite. In the case of activated carbons, it is common to use a slit-pore model with graphitic pore walls. The only adjustable parameter is then the pore size, which may be estimated from electron micrographs. This model may be refined by including a distribution of pore sizes. The porous material is then modeled as a collection of independent and unconnected slit-shaped pores with graphitic pore walls, and a pore size distribution is determined so that the calculated adsorption isotherm matches the experiment [21]. There have been several improvements to the slit-pore model and the description based on the concept of a pore size distribution. These improved models are also constructed by making detailed observations of the experimental data (electron micrographs, X-ray diffraction, adsorption isotherms, etc.), extracting more relevant features of the pore topology and the structure of the pore walls, and including these features in the models. For example, a 2D distribution of pore size and pore-wall thickness may be used, instead of a pore size distribution [22]. Most of these improvements are described in detail in a recent review [1].
5.3 Molecular Models of Carbons
111
The recent trend, driven by the increase in computing power, is to build all-atom models of porous carbons by solving a multidimensional inverse problem. The atomic positions in a system of carbon atoms, and perhaps other species, are stochastically changed to match experimental structure data. The RMC procedure [23] is useful to produce configurations that match a target structure factor, S(q), or pair correlation function, g(r). Target structure factors are usually obtained from X-ray diffraction. In addition, SAXS may be used to extend the structure factor to lower values of q, provided that X-ray diffraction and SAXS can be performed for an overlapping range of angles [24]. Target pair correlation functions may be obtained by taking the inverse Fourier transform of the structure factor. This operation, however, is particularly vulnerable to the limitations of the experimental data [25, 26], e.g., truncation errors. It is thus preferable [27] to use an alternative method, such as the so-called MC g(r) [26]. The idea of this inverse procedure is to stochastically modify a pair correlation function until its Fourier transform matches the experimental structure factor. The procedure is analogous to a lD RMC. Since the numerical pair correlation function can be generated for arbitrarily large r-values (limited only by the experimental q resolution), truncation errors are avoided in the Fourier transform. The resulting pair correlation function may be used as the target function in the RMC procedure, instead of the experimental structure factor, significantly reducing the computational cost and thus allowing the study of larger systems. In RMC, random moves, i.e., changes in the configuration of the system, are performed as in the metropolis MC algorithm. Random moves are accepted or rejected so that the difference between the calculated and target S( q) or g(r) is minimized. If g(r) is used as the target function, the parameter to be minimized is: nexp
L X2 =
[gsim (rJ -
gexp
(rJ]2
i=l
- - n -- - - - - - ex p
L
(5.5)
[gexp (rJt
i=l
where nexp is the number of experimental points, gsim (ri ) is the simulated g(r) and gexp (ri) is the experimental g(r) evaluated at rio The moves are accepted with probability:
Pace
= min [ 1, exp { -
;x (X~ew - X~ld) }]
(5.6)
where the subscripts old and new indicate before and after the move, respectively, and Tx is a weighting parameter or effective temperature. It is important to note that, although the parameter Tx does not have a thermodynamic meaning, it behaves like temperature. The parameter X is therefore minimized when the effective temperature is close to zero. The original RMC procedure prescribes that T x should be proportional to the variance of the target function.
112
Chapter 5 Models of Porous Carbons
However, assuming that the error in the target function is relatively low, any arbitrarily low value would be appropriate. An alternative is to change the effective temperature in the frame of the simulated annealing method [28] to increase the chances of finding the global minimum of the parameter x, instead of a local minimum. Simulated annealing has been successfully used in RMC modeling of carbons [27, 29]. As mentioned above, a set of experimental data does not necessarily correspond to a unique molecular structure. Moreover, even unphysical structures may be consistent with a set of experimental data. It is therefore necessary to carefully choose a set of constraints to limit the number of possible structures. The uniqueness theorem of statistical mechanics [30, 31] provides a guide to the number and type of constraints that should be applied in the RMC method in order to get a unique structure [32]. For systems in which only two- and three-body forces are important, the uniqueness theorem states that a given set of pair correlation function and three-body correlation function determines all the higher correlation functions. In other words, assuming that only two- and three-body forces are important, the RMC method must be implemented along with constraints that describe the three-body correlations [27]. One way ofimplementing constraints is in a rigid way. For example, Thomson and Gubbins [33] have modeled an activated mesocarbon microbead with RMC along with the following constraints: (1) any atom can only have two or three neighbors, (2) all the carbon-carbon bond lengths are 1.42 A, and (3) all the bond angles are 120 The advantage of doing this is that when these three constraints are applied together, basic carbon units, or plates, can be defined. These plates are rigid aromatic sheets of Sp2-bonded carbon, which resemble the structure of graphene segments. Many-atom moves that accelerate the convergence process can then be applied. For example, Thomson and Gubbins included three types of stochastic moves: (1) plate translation-rotation, (2) ring creation-annihilation, and (3) plate creation-annihilation. Only those moves that improve the fit to the experimental radial distribution function are accepted, i.e., the effective temperature was set to zero. In their resulting models, the graphene segments are roughly aligned (see Fig. 5.1) but their shape, size, and relative angles of tilt are different. The match between the simulated and the experimental g(r) is excellent for interatomic distances greater than 5 A (see Fig. 5.1). However, deviations occur at smaller distances. Two possible reasons for this discrepancy are (1) truncation errors in the Fourier transform of the experimental structure factor to obtain the radial distribution function, producing unphysical features in the target radial distribution function, and (2) overly rigid constraints on the RMC platelet shape. While the constraints applied by Thomson and Gubbins are reasonable for many graphitizable carbons, the use of graphene microcrystals as the basic units fails to account for ring defects and nonaromatic rings that are important in many activated carbons used in adsorption applications. A better match to the target g(r) may be obtained by allowing the formation of defects in the form of nonaromatic rings and by including heteroatoms [34]. 0
•
5.3 Molecular Models of Carbons
113
(a)
(b) 10
5 ~
"'-
0
~ ~
---Target -5
-10
- - - - . Simulated - - _ . Initial 0
5
10
15
20
Angstroms
Figure 5.1 Activated mesocarbon microbead RMC model. (a) Structural representation of the converged structure. The spheres represent carbon atoms that are shown at a scale much less than their van der Waals radii for reasons of clarity. (b) C-C radial distribution functions (RDF). The experimental RDF (solid line), the simulated, converged RDF (long-dashed line), and the initial simulated RDF (dotted line) are shown. The numbers indicate the different peaks of the RDF. (Adapted from Ref. [33].)
Chapter 5 Models of Porous Carbons
114
Pikunic et al. [27] have implemented a set ofjlexible constraints in the RMC procedure. Assuming that most carbon atoms have Sp2 hybridization, they constrain the coordination number of carbon atoms and the bond angles using a set of simple expressions:
(5.7) and
ifJ2
= -1
no
L n8
i=l
[
cos (OJ) -
COS
(2.-!!... )]2
(5.8)
3
where N 3 /N is the fraction of carbon atoms with carbon coordination number of 3, i.e., the fraction of carbon atoms that are bonded to three other carbon atoms. The target value ofN3 /N is estimated from the experimental composition data (H/C and OIC ratios) [27]. In graphite, for example, the fraction would be equal to one (Ji are the different bond angles in radians, and no is the total number of bond angles. This expression is based on the assumption that the angular contribution to the potential energy is proportional to the sum over all C-C-C bond angles of the squared difference between the cosine of the actual bond angle and the cosine of the equilibrium bond angle, which are 21T/3 radians for Sp2 hybridization. This dependence of the potential energy with bond angle is consistent with bond-order potentials (e.g., Tersoff and Brenner potentials) [35-37]. The reconstruction method, termed constrained reverse Monte Carlo (CRMC), consists of simultaneously minimizing three order parameters: the usual X2 , along with 82, and 0/ 2. The procedure allows building configurations of carbon atoms that have the same pair correlation function as the real material, as well as bond angles and carbon coordination number consistent with the experimental composition and the assumption of Sp2 hybridization. The acceptance probability prescribed in the original RMC method is replaced with
The parameters TifJ/Tx and Ts/Tx ' which determine the relative weight of the three order parameters, are kept fixed. Pikunic et al. [27] found that the resulting structures are not very sensitive to the specific values of the weighting parameters. RMC simulations are performed using this expression for the acceptance probability, in the frame of simulated annealing. Pikunic et al. [27] modeled two carbons manufactured by pyrolysis of saccharose at up to 400°C and at up to 1000°C. The resulting cokes are termed
5.3 Molecular Models of Carbons
115
CS400 and CS1000, respectively. The inputs to the reconstruction procedure, described above, were the compositions (H/C and OIC ratios), skeletal densities obtained by mercury porosimetry, and pair correlation functions from X-ray diffraction and SAXS. The pair correlation functions of the converged models, shown in Fig. 5.2 (dashed line), are in excellent agreement with the target functions. The fact that the agreement is better for CS400 seems to indicate that the minimization method is more effective for more disordered and less dense materials. Snapshots of the CRMC converged structure for cokes CS400 and CS1000 are shown in Figures 5.3 and 5.4 respectively. Pikunic et al. also developed a simple method to simulate TEM of simulated structures. They assume that the material is quasi-amorphous. Diffraction contrast due to crystalline registry is therefore negligible compared to mass-thickness (a)
6..,.----------------------."
5'+--tt--------------------I '-
3'
0>
~--~.
- ----------------------1
2
0 0
2
4
8
6
10
12
14
r(A) (b) 6
5
4 :; 3 0>
2
o ,'t--...-r"',,···,.....,.....·--,,·,""""~·,·,'·'''·'l'·'''··'''w'''f·'''·''''',.
o
2
4
....'If·,....,·>W·"",··,,....·..••.. y ..··,..•.. ,·..·.,·....,.., ..,·..~..·•.. • ..•••.... 1'..·,.....·•......·"'..........·......·"'..•·....·......-1
6
8
10
12
14
r(A)
Figure 5.2 Pair correlation functions of the saccharose-based carbons (a) CS400 and (b) CS1000: target (solid line) and converged CRMC structure (dashed line). (Adapted from Ref. [27].)
116
Chapter 5 Models of Porous Carbons
Figure 5.3 Snapshot of the CRMC converged structure for CS400. The simulation box is separated in four sections for clarity. The gray cylinders represent C-C bonds. (Adapted from Ref. [27].)
contrast, which can be calculated using Beer-Lambert's law. Experimental and simulated TEM micrographs for CS400 are shown in Fig. 5.5. It is important to note that many features of the experimental imaging procedure are not included in the simulations, e.g., scattering, transfer function of the microscope, sample thickness. Therefore, the contrast of the simulated images is not quantitatively comparable with that of the experimental images. However, most structural features observed in the experiments, highlighted in Fig. 5.5, are also present in the simulated images. Moreover, topological changes of the material upon heat treatment, as revealed by comparison of the experimental TEM images of CS400 and CS1000, are also observed in the simulated images (see Ref [27]). Although the comparison is qualitative, it is reassuring that the structural models are consistent with experimental structure data that is independent from the method's inputs. These models have also been geometrically characterized and tested against adsorption data (see Section 5.4); the predicted heats of adsorption are in excellent agreement with experiment.
5.3 Molecular Models of Carbons
117
Figure 5.4 Snapshot of the CRMC converged structure for CS1000. The simulation box is separated in four sections for clarity. The gray cylinders represent C-C bonds. (Adapted from Re£ [27].)
Further improvements to RMC-based reconstruction methods include implementing more sophisticated procedures than simulated annealing for finding the global minimum of the order parameters, such as parallel tempering. Improvement efforts may also be aimed at refining the constraints to describe three-body correlations. One alternative is to use a semiempirical interatomic potential [35, 36] as the three-body constraint. The reconstruction method would be equivalent to a biased MC simulation in the canonical ensemble. This idea has been implemented recently to model the local structure (not the porosity) of an industrial char [38] by using the environment dependent interaction potential [39] to describe three-body interactions. The resulting models resemble disordered and buckled graphitic structures, with a small number of five- and seven-atom rings. An alternative is to generate an initial structure using RMC, and subsequently relax it by performing MC or molecular dynamics simulations with a realistic Hamiltonian, e.g., semiempirical potentials or tight binding. Finally, improvements may also be aimed at replacing the RMC procedure with one recently developed by Rutledge [40], which incorporates the target function
Chapter 5 Models of Porous Carbons
118
(a)
Experiment
Simulations
(b)
Experiment
Simulations
(c)
Experiment
Simulations
Figure 5.5 Experimental TEM micrographs of CS400 (left) and simulated images for three beam directions (right). The 5 nm scale applies for the four images. (a) HigWighted are examples ofdot-like segments, (b) short segments, and (c) stacks of short segments. (Adapted from Re£ [27].)
5.3 Molecular Models of Carbons
119
into a semigrand Me simulation by introducing a generalized, polydisperse composition space. The advantage of this method is that it retains the character of a thermodynamic system; the target function and semiempirical potential can be handled together without adjustable parameters.
5.3.3.2 Ab Initio and mimetic simulation methods Semiempirical and ab initio approaches
Because of their computational intensity and the chemical complexity of the synthesis of porous carbons, a full mimetic simulation using ab initio (i.e., from the beginning, or first principles) methods is not yet feasible. Nevertheless, some ab initio and semiempirical calculations have been reported that throw some light on parts of the synthesis process, at least for idealized systems. Ab initio or first principles methods seek to describe the electrons of a chemical system through solution of the many-body Schrodinger equation (Hamiltonian), and so do not require any experimental input [41]. In semiempirical methods, the many-electron problem is simplified in some way, and then some parameters obtained from experiment or higher level ab initio calculations are included in order to get good results. Semiempirical methods are not true ab initio methods, since they make use of experimental information, but they are particularly useful for dealing with large systems where more computationally demanding methods are impossible to apply. Pappano et al. [42] have used a semiempirical method to study the polymerization of phenanthrene and anthracene, relevant to the carbonization process. The resulting polymerized phenanthrene material contained holes and curvature induced by the presence of five-membered rings, whilst the polymerized anthracene system contained little curvature. Chen and Yang, in a series of studies at both the semiempirical [43] and, more recently, ab initio [44] levels, have studied the gasification of graphite by CO 2 , H 2 0, and 2 , which is of relevance to activation. They considered both uncatalyzed systems and those catalyzed by alkali and alkaline metals, indicating under what conditions catalytic effects are likely to prevail and suggesting reaction mechanisms. Ma et al. [45] used a semiempirical method to study the inhibitive effects of boron on gasification, whilst Kyotani and Tomita [46] used an ab initio method to consider the reaction of carbon with NO and N 2 0. Because they are so computationally intensive, ab initio and semiempirical studies are limited to models that are about 10 rings or less. In order to study more realistic carbon structures, approximations in the form of the Hamiltonian (i.e., Schrodinger equation) are necessary. The tight-binding method, in which the many-body wave function is expressed as a product of individual atomic orbitals, localized on the atomic centers, is one such approximation that has been successfully applied to amorphous and porous carbon systems [47]. Charlier et al. [48] used the tight-binding model to study distorted stacking of graphene layers, termed pregraphitic or turbostratic carbon. The turbostratic structure was obtained by generating an amorphous cluster of graphene plates that
°
120
Chapter 5 Models of Porous Carbons
contained 24 graphene layers and 35 736 carbon atoms. The disordered packing was found to more closely resemble the Bernal stacking of graphite (ABAB) in density and shape. The tight-binding method has also been applied to amorphous carbons, with an emphasis on studying the electronic structure [49, 50]. Wang et al. [51] used tight-binding molecular dynamics (TBMD) to simulate a high-temperature quench of liquid carbon at various densities to produce a porous carbon. Forces were calculated through a combination of the tightbinding orbitals and the Coulomb repulsion of the carbon nuclei. Different initial carbon densities were found to lead to different bonding arrangements. A high initial density resulted in diamond-like carbon characterized by a large fraction of Sp3 bonding sites (72 %). Low carbon density resulted in an amorphous carbon structure with curved graphene sheets, containing many nonaromatic five-, six-, and sevenfold carbon rings. An approach that is attractive and that can be applied to a wide range of types of carbons is to combine the tight-binding method with RMC to determine carbon structures and properties. In this approach the RMC method is first used in conjunction with experimental structure data (usually in the form of smalland wide-angle X-ray or neutron scattering data) to determine a molecular structure for the carbon that is a good approximation to the true structure, and includes longer range structural features. Tight-binding calculations are then carried out to relax the structure and to incorporate local bonding and interactions into the framework. Rosato et al. [29] carried out such a procedure for amorphous carbons by applying the RMC method to experimental radial distribution function data from scattering, followed by TBMD to capture shortrange bonding configurations. More recently, Pellenq et al. [52] have used a similar approach, using tight binding Me in place ofTBMD, to develop realistic models of several microporous carbons based on carbonization of saccharose. Such approaches are quite flexible and should be able to provide reasonably realistic molecular structures at both short and longer ranges for a wide variety of carbons. Probabilistic approaches
Because of the computational intensity of the deterministic approaches described above, several attempts have been made to develop stochastic-based mimetic models. The gasification of polyaromatic molecules has been modeled by Kyotani et al. [53] using a MC process where the probability of a carbon reacting is determined using Huckel molecular orbital (HMO) theory [54]. It should be possible to extend this approach to more complex structures, given the simplicity of HMO theory. Stochastic approaches have been used to model coal devolatilization using the DVC (depolymerization, vaporization, and crosslinking) model (e.g., Refs [55-57]). In one such approach [57], the precursor is modeled by sites representing molecular fragments of varying molecular weight and chemistry connected by labile links that may be broken with a probability defined by their reactivity. It may be possible to extend such methods to study the carbonization of other precursors, in addition to coal.
5.4 Adsorption, Diffusion, Reaction
5.4
121
ADSORPTION, DIFFUSION, REACTION
One of the main purposes of developing structural models of porous solids is to predict the effects of confinement on the properties of adsorbed phases, e.g., adsorption isotherms, heats of adsorption, diffusion, phase transitions, and chemical reaction mechanisms. Once a structural model for a particular porous solid has been chosen or developed (see Section 5.3), it is necessary to assume an interaction potential between the solid (adsorbent) and the confined fluid (adsorbate), as well as a fluid-fluid potential, and to decide on a theory or simulation method to calculate the property of interest [58]. A great many such studies have been reported in the literature, particularly for simple pore geometry models, and we do not attempt to review them here. Instead we present a few examples of such studies, with emphasis on those involving more realistic pore models. It is common to assume a LJ 6-12 potential (Eqn (5.1)) to model the repulsive and dispersion interactions between a carbon atom and a nonpolar adsorbate atom, e.g., argon, xenon. For polar fluids, such as water and nitrogen, it may be necessary to include charges explicitly or a dipole or quadrupole [31]. An alternative approach is to model the adsorbate as a LJ 6-12 fluid. This approach, although somewhat simplistic, may be suitable for nonpolar adsorbates with low quadrupole moment, e.g., nitrogen. The adsorbent-adsorbate potential parameters are usually obtained from ab initio calculations or by fitting to lowcoverage adsorption properties such as the Henry's constant, on ideal, nonporous adsorbents, e.g., graphite [59, 60]. The application of statistical thermodynamic theories, such as density functional theory, and classical models to gas adsorption has been recently reviewed [21, 61]. These methods are usually restricted to simple geometric models (Section 5.3.2). Molecular simulation, on the other hand, can be used to predict adsorption properties in any porous carbon model, including those described in Section 5.3.3. The most widely used simulation method for studying adsorption behavior is GCMC [59, 62, 63]. These simulations can be routinely performed today on personal computers for systems of several nanometers, allowing the estimation of adsorption isotherms and heats of adsorption. Provided that the structural models are realistic, and that the adsorbate-adsorbent interaction parameters are carefully determined from experiment or ab initio calculations, excellent predictions can be obtained. An example is shown in Fig. 5.6. The lines show experimental isosteric heats of adsorption of argon in two disordered porous carbons obtained from pyrolysis of saccharose at 400°C (CS400) and 1000°C (CS1000). Structural models for these two materials were obtained using a CRMC method [27] (see Section 5.3.3.1). These models were subsequently used in GCMC simulations [64], with argon-carbon interaction parameters obtained in an independent study [65]. The predicted isosteric heats of adsorption are in excellent quantitative agreement with experiment. It is important to note that the models of CS400 and CS1000 were obtained from
122
Chapter 5 Models of Porous Carbons
20
(5
16
E
-~~
..~~
12
_ ~ ,
8
4+----,.-----r--------,---~------I
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
Figure 5.6 Isosteric heat of adsorption of argon at 77 K. Experiment: CS400 (dashed line) and CS1000 (solid line). Simulations: CS400 (circles) and CS1000 (squares). (Adapted from Ref. [64].)
experimental structure data, and no parameters were adjusted to match the adsorption data. The "true" pore size distribution obtained geometrically, from atomic positions, is shown in Fig. 5.7(a). It is obvious that CS400 and CS1000 have very similar pore size distributions. However, the potential energy of an adsorbate atom confined in these two models is quite different (Fig. 5.7(b)). Moreover, as evidenced in Fig. 5.8, the nitrogen adsorption isotherm obtained in a collection of slit pores with the same pore size distribution differs from those in CS400 and CS1000 [66]. These differences are likely due to the nongraphitic structure of disordered porous carbons as well as topological differences. It has been shown that different degrees of curvature alone, in carbonaceous materials, may cause differences of tens ofkJ/mol in zero-coverage isosteric heats of adsorption [67]. These results indicate that characterization methods based on the slit-pore model and the concept of a pore size distribution are not suitable to describe disordered porous carbons. A strong test of the realism of a molecular model of a porous carbon is the study of diffusion of the confined adsorbate molecules. Pikunic [68] has used molecular dynamics simulation to study self-diffusion of argon in the CRMC models of the saccharose-based microporous carbons CS400 and CS1000, with pore size and energy distributions shown in Fig. 5.7. He found ballistic motion (mean squared displacement proportional to (2, where ( is the elapsed time) at very short times, follovved by a transition to single-file diffusion (mean squared displacement proportional to (0.5) at longer times. There was no Fickian regime (mean squared displacement proportional to t). This prediction has not yet been confirmed by experiment. There have been a number of simulation studies of the adsorption of water in carbon slit pores [69] and in carbon nanotubes [70]. Segarra and Glandt [71] were the first to study water adsorption using a more realistic model of the porous
5.4 Adsorption, Diffusion, Reaction
123
(a) 1.2 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ,
0.8
-_J:
0.6
Q..
0.4
0.2
....
04---.....,..--..L~r___--_r_--.....,..~~::-.,.._--
2
3
4
5
7
6
8
H(A) (b) 0.7 - . - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ,
A
·,.-,:'. ·- .: ·. ·... ·.
0.6 0.5
•
S
·.
~ Q..
I
·. ···: .... ......
0.4 0.3
0.2
.'
:
r ·:
0.1
~.
0........,......,..-r--p~..,....,._._.,........_;;..."'I"""'"'r'...........'1"""1". . .~..,.....~_r_~~r--.-......._i
o
5
10
15
20
25
30
-U(KJ/mol)
Figure 5-7 (a) Pore size distribution ofthe models ofCS400 (solid line) and CS1000 (dashed line). The test particle is a simple model of nitrogen. (b) Adsorbent-adsorbate potential energy distribution for a single nitrogen molecule in the models of CS400 (solid line) and CS1000 (dashed line) at 77 K. (Adapted from Ref. [28].)
carbon. The model consisted of randomly oriented platelets of graphite, with a dipole uniformly distributed over the edge of the platelets to mimic the activation. The SPC (simple point charge) model was used for the water interaction. Although these calculations gave adsorption isotherms that were qualitatively similar to the experimental results, subsequent work [72] suggest that their model of the surface sites is not sufficiently inhomogeneous to predict the correct trends in low adsorption data and in heats of adsorption. McCallum et al. [73] studied water adsorption in a Norit-activated carbon derived from peat moss and oxidized using 30 % hydrogen peroxide. The activated carbon was modeled as being
12 4
Chapter 5 Models of Porous Carbons
0.8 0.6
~
~
0.4 0.2
O.....-=::;;... . . . . . . . . . . . . . .==:IIIL--...-----...----........ 1.0E-12
1.0E-Q9
1.0E-Q6
1.0E-Q3
1.0E+00
P/PO
Figure 5.8 Nitrogen adsorption isotherms at 77 K in an assembly of independent graphitic slit pores with a pore size distribution equal to that shown in Fig. 5.7(a) (solid line), and in two realistic models of porous carbon: CS400 (squares) and CS1000 (circles). Fractional filling is shown as a function of relative pressure. (Adapted from Ref. [68].)
made up of noninterconnected slit pores having a distribution of pore widths that approximated the experimental material, and whose surfaces are decorated with model OH groups at a site density of 0.675 sites per square nanometer, as estimated from experiment. H-bonding sites on water molecules and OH groups were modeled as square well sites, and the one H-bond site parameter on the OH groups was fitted to low-pressure adsorption data. The predicted isotherm from GCMC simulations was in generally good agreement with experiment (Fig. 5.9). Brennan et al. [74] used GCMC simulations to study the adsorption ofwater in a
0.03
.
,'."
'
.
'
N
-€ (5
0.02
E
Sen
en Q)
0
x
Q)
0.01
~
0.00 ~zm:al_e==:..i.~-+----+-----+---~ 1.0 0.4 0.6 0.8 0.2 0.0
P/Po
Figure 5.9 Adsorption of water from experiment and simulation at 298 K. The solid line and open circles represent the experimental data; the dashed line and filled circles show the simulated isotherm obtained using simulated isotherms for discrete pore widths together with the experimental pore size distribution. (Adapted from Re£ [73].)
5.4 Adsorption, Diffusion, Reaction
12 5
more realistic model of an activated mesocarbon microbead sample from Osaka Gas Company. The carbon model was prepared by the RMC procedure of Thomson and Gubbins [75], by matching the model structure to the experimental structure factor, and consists of connected slit-like pores between graphene microcrystals. The pores were decorated with oxygenated surface sites placed randomly on the edge carbons of the graphene microcrystals; these sites were taken to be CO groups, and their interaction was modeled using the OPLS (optimized potentials for liquid simulations) model. For the water interaction a point charge model due to Errington and Panagiotopoulos [76] was used, with potential parameters that were optimized for vapor-liquid coexistence properties. A range of site densities, from zero to 2.25 CO per square nanometer were studied, covering the entire experimentally accessible range. The adsorption behavior was found to be strongly dependent on the site density, with significant uptake of water occurring at lower pressures for higher-site densities. For a typical oxygenated site density of 0.65 site/nm2 , the presence of adsorbed water was found to dramatically decrease the connectivity of the available pore space (Fig. 5.10). This pore-blocking effect due to water clusters forming around oxygenated sites provides an explanation of the large decrease in capacity and selectivity observed in industrial adsorbers due to humidity in the gases entering the adsorber. Confinement in porous carbons can have a large effect on chemical reactions, changing the yield, reaction rate, and even the reaction mechanism in some cases. Strong effects occur due to increased density of the adsorbed phase, selective adsorption of reactants or products, strong electronic interactions between the reacting species and the pore walls that can change the potential energy surface of the reaction and bond strengths, reduced dimensionality, etc. The effect on equilibrium yield is most easily studied, since it depends only on the initial reactants and final products, and not on the reaction path or mechanism. The reactive MC method [77], in which trial forward and backward reaction
(a)
(b)
(c)
Figure 5.10 Available pore space when water is present in an activated carbon. The sequence of figures represent different amounts of water present: (a) P/Po = 0, (b) P/Po = 0.10, (c) P/Po = 0.14. Carbon atoms, surface sites, and water molecules have been removed to enhance visualization of the pore space. (Adapted from Re£ [74].)
Chapter 5 Models of Porous Carbons
126
moves are incorporated, has been successfully used to study several reactions in slit-pore carbons and carbon nanotubes, including the reactions 2NO = (NO)2 [78, 79], N 2 + 3H2 =2NH 3 [78, 79], and the esterification reaction [80] CH3 COOH + C 2H sOH = C 2H sOOCCH 3 + H 20. In each of these cases, the yield is increased due to confinement within the carbon. The effect is particularly dramatic for the case of the nitric oxide dimerization reaction. The simulations predict an increase in yield of the dimer by one to two orders of magnitude at lower (liquid range) temperatures, the effect being larger in carbon nanotubes than in slit pores due to the additional confinement (Fig. 5.11). In the simulations, the increase is primarily due to the increased density of the adsorbate phase. Even larger increases are observed in the experimental studies [81, 82], possibly due to a change in the bonding energy of the dimer due to interaction with the walls (an effect that was not taken into account in the simulations). For the ammonia synthesis and esterification reactions, which are carried out at higher temperatures, a smaller but significant increase in yield (up to a factor of 2) is predicted, and in these cases it is due to selective adsorption. No experimental studies are available for these reactions, so these results cannot be verified. Fewer studies of the effect of confinement in carbons on reaction mechanism and rates are available. By assuming that confinement has no influence on the reaction path or transition state, it is possible to use reactive MC simulation to determine the equilibrium concentration of the transition state species, and then use this together with transition state theory to predict the effect of confinement on reaction rates. This was the basis of a study by
1.0 2NO=(NO)2 0.8 C\I
0
~
15
0.6
c 0
:u ~
0.4
Q)
(5 ~
....--.2.5aNO 0--03.0aNO . - - . 3.5aNO
¢--¢ 4.0aNO ~4.5aNO
0.2
4o--
BULK 0.0 115.0
125.0
135.0
145.0
155.0
165.0
Temperature/K
Figure 5.11 Mole fraction of dimers for the pore phase at a constant bulk pressure of 0.16 bar, for various pore widths expressed as multiples of aNO' where aNO is the LJ diameter for the NO molecule (0.3172 nm). (Adapted from !-te£ [78].)
5.5 Conclusions
127
Turner et al. [83] of the HI decomposition reaction, 2HI = H 2 + 12 , in carbon slit pores and carbon nanotubes. Large increases occurred (by up to a factor of 60) in the reaction rate, due to selective attraction of the transition state species to the pore walls. This selective attraction arises because the transition species is larger than other molecular species in the reaction mixture and has a stronger dispersion interaction with the carbon wall. More rigorous and complete calculations require the use of a dual scale approach, involving ab initio methods to determine the potential energy surface of the reaction, and atomistic molecular dynamics simulations to determine reaction rates [41].
5.5
CONCLUSIONS
The structural models available for porous carbons can be roughly divided into two classes: simple geometric models, such as collections of slit- or wedgeshaped pores, and more complex models in which pore connectivity, tortuosity, and curved and defective carbon sheets are included. The simple geometric models are easy to apply, and can give a good account of adsorption when the pore size distribution is fitted to experimental data. Such models are now incorporated into the software of most sorptometers, and are used to estimate surface areas and pore size distributions. However, such models omit many important features of porous carbons, including pore connectivity, tortuosity, variations in pore shape, and chemical heterogeneity of the surfaces. Such models may give poor results even for adsorption if extrapolated to temperatures or adsorbate gases far from the region of fit. They are particularly poor in representing diffusion in carbons, where connectivity, tortuosity and surface heterogeneity have a large influence on the diffusive flux. Diffusion rates calculated using slit-pore models can be in error by an order of magnitude or more. In recent years, several more realistic models have been proposed, which attempt to include connectivity, variations in pore morphology, defective ring structures, curved carbon plates, and so on. These more complex models include the virtual carbon model, the chemically constrained model and RMC models. None of these models are yet fully developed or tested, but they offer the prospect of considerably more sophisticated and accurate modeling of carbons. What is needed, are carefully designed efforts to test and refine these models through collaborative research programs involving complementary, experimental, and modeling studies. Eventually, it should be possible to replace the simple geometric models by the more complex models in practical applications, such as predictions of adsorption, separations, and diffusion rates. The existing structural models are overwhelmingly of the reconstructive type, in which the model is constructed based on experimental structural data. This is a result of the complex and poorly understood synthesis of the carbons. Mimetic simulation methods, in which the synthesis is modeled using molecular or ab initio simulations, have been successfully used for some other porous materials,
Chapter 5 Models of Porous Carbons
128
e.g., porous glasses [84] and MCM-41 [85]. Such approaches are desirable since they can produce unique and physically realistic structures. Moreover, they offer insight into the synthetic route itsel£ and may suggest ways to improve it. Some attempts to model a part of the synthetic process using mimetic ab initio methods have been made (see Section 5.3.3.2). At first sight it would seem hopeless to attempt mimetic methods to simulate the entire synthetic process for activated carbons. However, reasonably successful intermolecular potentials exist for carbon (e.g., Ref [35]). These cannot be expected to produce realistic structures for activated carbons via direct simulations. The synthetic process involves many chemical reactions, the details of which are largely unknown, and the final carbon structures are not equilibrium ones. However, it may prove possible to improve the models by incorporating the potential in the reconstruction in some way. While the principal stumbling block remains the development of more realistic models, improvements in experimental techniques are also needed. In the measurements of structure by diffraction or TEM, higher resolution and accuracy are desirable to provide a clearer picture of the atomic and surface structure. In the case of TEM measurements, the development of methods to obtain 3D structures, as opposed to the 2D thin-film structures currently possible, would provide a major advance. In the surface chemistry studies, further resolution of both the location and species of surface groups is needed.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We thank the National Science Foundation (grant no. CTS-0211792) and Department of Energy (grant no. DE-FG02-98ER14847) for support of this research and the National Partnership for Advanced Computational Infrastructure for providing computing time.
REFERENCES 1. Bandosz, T.J., Biggs, M.J., Gubbins, K.E., et al. (2003). Molecular models of porous carbons. In Chemistry and Physics of Carbons (L.R. Radovic, ed.). Marcel Dekker, pp. 41-228. 2. Debye, P. and Scherrer, P. (1917). Interferencen an regellos orientierten Teilchen im Rontgenlicht III. Physik Zeitschr., XVIII, 291-301. 3. Ruike, M., Kasu, T., Setoyama, N., et al. (1994). Inaccessible pore characterization of less-crystalline microporous solids. J. Phys. Chern., 98, 9594-600. 4. Peng, S., Kyeongjae, C., Pengfei, Q., and Hongjie, D. (2004). Ab initio study of CNT N0 2 gas sensor. Chern. Phys. Lett., 387, 271-6.
References
12 9
5. Dresselhaus, M.S., Dresselhaus, G., and Saito, R. (1995) Physics of carbon nanotubes. Carbon, 33, 883-91. 6. Rafii-Tabar, H. (2004). Computational modeling of thenno-mechanical and transport properties of carbon nanotubes. Phys. Rep., 390, 235-452. 7. Tjatjopoulos, G.J., Feke, D.L., and Adin Mann, J., Jr. (1988). Molecule-micropore interaction potentials. J. Phys. Chem., 92, 4006-7. 8. Maddox, M.W. and Gubbins, K.E. (1995). Molecular simulation offluid adsorption in Buckytubes. Langmuir, 11, 3988-96. 9. Shi, W. and Johnson, J.K. (2003) Gas adsorption on heterogeneous single-walled carbon nanotube bundles. Phys. Rev. Lett., 91, 015504-1-4. 10. Cheng, A and Klein, M. L. (1991). Molecular dynamics simulation of solid Buckminsterfullerenes. J. Phys. Chem., 95, 6750-1; Molecular-dynamics investigation of orientational freezing in solid C 60 . Phys. Rev. B 1992, 45, 1889-95. 11. Hernandez, E.S. and Cole, M.W. (2003). Adsorption of atoms and fluids on spherical surfaces. Phys. Rev. B, 68, 125418-1-8. 12. Martinez-Alonso, A., Tascon, J.M.D., and Bottani, E.J. (2001). Physical adsorption of Ar and CO 2 on C 60 fullerene. J. Phys. Chem. B, 105, 135-9. 13. Tascon, J.M.D. and Bottani, E.J. (2002). Nitrogen physisorption on defective C 60 . J. Phys. Chem. B, 106, 9522-7. 14. Valencia, F., Romero, A.H., Hernandez, E., et al. (2003). Theoretical characterization of several models of nanoporous carbon. New J. Phys., 5, 123.1-16. 15. Steele, W.A. (1973). The physical interaction of gases with crystalline solids. Surf Sci., 36, 317-352; Steele, W.A. (1974). The Interaction of Gases with Solid Suifaces. Pergamon Press, Chapter 2.
16. Bojan, M.J. and Steele, W.A. (1998). Computer simulation in pores with rectangular cross-sections. Carbon, 36, 1417-23. 17. Davies, G.M. and Seaton, N.A. (1998). The effect of the choice of pore model
18. 19. 20. 21.
22.
on the characterization of the internal structure of microporous carbons using pore size distributions. Carbon, 36, 1473-90. Bojan, M.J., van Slooten, R., and Steele W. (1992). Computer simulation studies of the storage of methane in microporous carbons. Sep. Sci. Technol., 27, 1837-56. Maddox, M.W., Quirke, N., and Gubbins K.E. (1997). A molecular simulation study of pore networking effects. Mol. Simul., 19,267-83. Turner, A.R. and Quirke N. (1998). A grand canonical Monte Carlo study of adsorption on graphitic surfaces with defects. Carbon, 36, 1439-46. Pikunic, J., Lastoskie, C.M., and Gubbins, K.E. (2003). Adsorption from the gas phase: theory. In Handbook of Porous Solids (F. Schuth, K. Sing, andJ. Weitkamp, eds). Wiley-VCH, pp. 182-236. Nguyen, T.X. and Bhatia, S.K. (2004). Characterization of pore wall heterogeneity in nanoporous carbons using adsorption: the slit pore model revisited. J. Phys.
Chem. B, 108, 14032-42. 23. McGreevy, R.L. and Pusztai, L. (1988). Reverse Monte Carlo simulation: a new technique for the determination of disordered structures. Mol. Simul., 1, 359. 24. Pikunic, J., Clinard, C., Cohaut, N., et al. (2002). Reconstruction method for the characterization of porous carbons. Stud. Surf Sci. Catal., 144, 19-26. 25. Soper, A. K. (1989). In Springer Proceedings in Physics, Vol. 40. (M. Davidovic and A.K. Soper, eds). Springer, p. 189. 26. Soper, A. K. (1990). An amateur guide to the pitfalls of maximum-entropy. Inst. Phys. Conf Ser., 107,57-67.
130
Chapter 5 Models of Porous Carbons
27. Pikunic, J., Clinard, C., Cohaut, N., et al. (2003). Structural modeling of porous carbons: constrained reverse Monte Carlo method. Langmuir, 19, 8565-82. 28. Kirkpatrick, S., Gelatt, Jr, C.D., and Vecchi, M.P. (1983) Optimization by simulated annealing. Science, 220, 671-80. 29. Rosato, V., Lascovich, J.C., Santoni, A., and Colombo, L. (1998). On the use of the reverse Monte Carlo technique to generate amorphous carbon structures. Int. ]. Mod. Phys. C, 9, 917-26. 30. Henderson, R.L. (1974). Uniqueness theorem for fluid pair correlation-functions. Phys. Lett., 49A, 197-8. 31. Gray, C.G. and Gubbins, K.E. (1984). Theory cifMolecular Fluids. Clarendon Press, p.178. 32. Evans, R. (1990). Comment on Reverse Monte Carlo simulation. Mol. Simul., 4, 409. 33. Thomson, K.T. and Gubbins, K.E. (2000). Modeling structural morphology of microporous carbons by Reverse Monte Carlo. Langmuir, 16, 5761-73. 34. Pikunic, J., Pellenq, RJ.-M., Thomson, K.T., et al. (2001). Improved molecular models for porous carbons. Stud. Suif. Sci. Catal., 132, 647-52. 35. Brenner, D.W. (1990). Empirical potential for hydrocarbons for use in simulating the chemical vapor deposition of diamond films. Phys. Rev. B, 42, 9458-71. 36. TersofL J. (1988). Empirical interatomic potential for carbon, with applications to amorphous carbon. Phys. Rev. Lett., 61, 2879-82. 37. Horsfield, A.P., Bratkovsky, A.M., Fearn, M., et al. (1996). Bond-order potentials: theory and implementation. Phys. Rev. B, 53, 12694-712. 38. Petersen, T., Yarovsky, I., Snook, I., et al. (2004). Microstructure of an industrial char by diffraction techniques and Reverse Monte Carlo modelling. Carbon, 42, 2457-69. 39. Marks, N. (2001). Generalizing the environment-dependent interaction potential for carbon. Phys. Rev. B, 63, 35401-1-7. 40. Rutledge, G.C. (2001). Modeling experimental data in a Monte Carlo simulation. Phys. Rev. E, 63, 021111-1-5. 41. For a review of ab initio and semi-empirical methods see: Santiso, E. and Gubbins, K.E. (2004). Multi-scale molecular modeling of chemical reactivity. Mol. Simul., 30, 699-748. 42. Pappano, P.J., Mathews, J.P., and Schobert, H.H. (1999). Structural determination of Pennsylvanian anthracites. 24th Biennial Conference on Carbon Extended Abstracts, American Carbon Society, pp. 202-3. 43. Chen, S.G. and Yang, R.T. (1997). Unified mechanism of alkali and alkaline earth catalyzed gasification reactions of carbon by CO 2 and H 2 0. Energy Fuels, 11, 421-7. 44. Chen, N. and Yang, R.T. (1998). Ab initio molecular orbital study of the unified mechanism and pathways for gas-carbon reactions.]. Phys. Chem. A, 102,6348-56. 45. Ma, X., Wang, Q., Chen, L.Q., et al. (1997). Semi-empirical studies on electronic structures of a boron-doped graphene layer - implications on the oxidation mechanism. Carbon, 35,1517-25. 46. Kyotani, T. and Tomita, A. (1999). Analysis of the reaction of carbon with NO/N 2 0 using ab initio molecular orbital theory.]. Phys. Chem. B, 103,3434-41. 47. For a review of the tight-binding method see: Goringe, C.M., Bowler, D.R., and Hernandez, E. (1997). Tight-binding modeling of materials. Rep. Prog. Phys., 60, 1447-512.
References
13 1
48. Charlier, J.C., Michenaud, J.P., and Lambin, P. (1992). Tight-binding density of electronic states of pregraphitic carbon. Phys. Rev. B, 46, 4540-3. 49. Lee, C.H., Lambrecht, W.R.L., Segall, B., et al. (1994). Electronic-structure of dense amorphous-carbon. Phys. Rev. B, 49, 11448-51. 50. Stephan, U., Frauenheim, T., Blaudeck, P., andJungnickel, G. (1994). Pi-bonding versus electronic-defect generation - an examination of band-gap properties in amorphous-carbon. Phys. Rev. B, 49, 1489-501. 51. Wang, C.Z., Qui, S.Y., and Ho, K.M. (1997). O(N) tight-binding molecular dynamics study of amorphous carbon. Compo Mater. Sci., 7, 315-23. 52. Pellenq, R.J.-M., Bichara, C., Jain, S.K., et al.(2005). paper in preparation. 53. Kyotani, T., Ito, K., Tomita, A., and Radovic L.R. (1996). Monte Carlo simulation of carbon gasification using molecular orbital theory. AIChE J., 42, 2303-7. 54. Stein, S.E. and Brown., R.L. (1987). Pi-electron properties of large condensed polyaromatic hydrocarbons.]. Am. Chem. Soc., 109,3721-9. 55. Solomon, P.R. and Fletcher, T.H. (1994). 25th Symposium (International) on Combustion, The Combustion Institute, Pittsburgh, pp. 463-74. 56. Jones, J.M., Pourkashanian, M., Rena, C.D., and Williams, A. (1999). Modeling the relationship of coal structure to char porosity. Fuel, 78, 1737-44. 57. Mathews, J.P., Hatcher, P.G., and Scaroni A.W. (1998). Devolatilization, a molecular modeling approach. Am. Soc. Preprints, 43, 136. 58. Nicholson, D. and Parsonage, N.G. (1982). Computer Simulation and the Statistical Mechanics of Adsorption. Academic Press. 59. Steele, W. A. (1974). The Interaction of Gases with Solid Surfaces. Pergamon Press. 60. Bruch, L. W., Cole, M. W., and Zaremba, E. (1997). Physical Adsorption: Forces and Phenomena. Clarendon Press. 61. Lastoskie, C.M. and Gubbins, K.E. (2000). Characterization of porous materials using density functional theory and molecular simulation. Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal., 128,41-50. 62. Allen, M.P. and Tildesley, D.J. (1987). Computer Simulation of Liquids. Clarendon Press. 63. Frenkel, D. and Smit, B. (2002). Understanding Molecular Simulation, 2nd edn. Academic. 64. Pikunic, J., Llewellyn, P., Pellenq, R.J.-M., and Gubbins, K.E. (2005). Argon and nitrogen adsorption in disordered nanoporous carbons: simulation and experiment. Langmuir 21, 4431-40. 65. Steele, W.A. (1978). Interaction of rare-gas atoms with graphitized carbon-black. ]. Phys. Chem., 82, 817-21. 66. Coasne, B., Pikunic, J.P., Pellenq, R.J.M., and Gubbins, K.E. (2003). Comparison between adsorption in pores of a simple geometry and realistic models of porous materials. Mater. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc., 790, 53-8. 67. Jiang, J., Wagner, N.J., and Sandler, S.I. (2004). A Monte Carlo simulation study of the effect of carbon topology on nitrogen adsorption on graphite, a nanotube bundle, C60 fullerite, C168 schwarzite, and a nanoporous carbon. Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys., 6, 4440-4. 68. Pikunic, J.P. (2003). Ph.D. Dissertation, North Carolina State University. 69. For a review of work up to 2000, see: Brennan, J.K., Bandosz, T.J., Thomson, K.T., and Gubbins, K.E. (2001). Water in porous carbons. Colloids Surf. A, 187-8, 539-68.
132
Chapter 5 Models of Porous Carbons
70. Striolo, A., Chialvo, A.A., Gubbins, K.E., and Cummings, P.T. (2005). Water in carbon nanotubes: adsorption isotherms and thermodynamic properties from molecular simulation. J. Chern. Phys. 122, 234712. 71. Segarra, E.l. and Glandt, E.D. (1994). Model microporous carbons microstructure, surface polarity and gas-adsorption. Chern. Eng. Sci., 49, 2953-65. 72. Gordon, P.A. and Glandt, E.D. (1997). Adsorption of polar gases on model silica gel. Langmuir, 13, 4659-68. 73. McCallum, C.L., Bandosz, TJ., McGrother, S.C., et al. (1999). A molecular model for adsorption of water on activated carbon: comparison of simulation and experiment. Langmuir, 15, 533-44. 74. Brennan, J.K., Thomson, K.T., and Gubbins, K.E. (2002). Adsorption of water in activated carbons: effects ofpore blocking and connectivity. Langmuir, 18,5438-47. 75. Thomson, K.T. and Gubbins, K.E. (2000). Modeling structural morphology of porous carbons by reverse Monte Carlo. Langmuir, 16, 5761-74. 76. Errington, J.R. and Panagiotopoulos, A.Z. (1998). A fixed point charge model for water optimized to the vapor-liquid coexistence properties. J. Phys. Chern. B, 102, 7470-5. 77. Johnson,J.K., Panagiotopoulos, A.Z., and Gubbins, K.E. (1994). Reactive canonical Monte Carlo: a new simulation technique for reacting and associating fluids. Mol. Phys., 81, 717-33. 78. Turner, C.H., Johnson, J.K., and Gubbins, K.E. (2001). Effect of confinement on chemical reaction equilibria: the reactions 2NO=(NO)2 and N 2+ 3H2 = 2NH3 in carbon micropores.J. Chern. Phys., 114, 1851-9. 79. Turner, C.H., Pikunic, J., and Gubbins, K.E. (2001). Influence of chemical and physical surface heterogeneity on chemical reaction equilibria in carbon micropores. Mol. Phys., 99, 1991-2001. 80. Turner, C.H. and Gubbins, K.E. (2003). Effects of supercritical clustering and selective confinement on reaction equilibrium: a molecular simulation study of the esterification reaction. J. Chern. Phys., 119, 6057-67. 81. Kaneko, K., Fukuzaki, N., Kakei, K., et al. (1989). Enhancement of NO dimerization by micropore fields of activated arbon-fibers. Langmuir, 5, 960-5. 82. Byl, 0., Kondratyuk, P., and Yates, J.T. (2003). Adsorption and dimerization of NO inside single-walled carbon nanotubes - an infrared spectroscopic study. J. Phys. Chern. B, 107, 4277-9. 83. Turner, C.H., Brennan, J.K., Johnson, J.K., and Gubbins, K.E. (2002). Effect of confinement by porous materials on chemical reaction kinetics. J. Chern. Phys., 116,2138-48. 84. Gelb, L.D. and Gubbins, K.E. (1998). Characterization of porous glasses: simulation models, adsorption isotherms, and the BET analysis method. Langmuir, 14, 2097-111. 85. Siperstein, F.R. and Gubbins, K.E., (2001). Synthesis and characterization of templated mesoporous materials using molecular simulation. Mol. Simul., 27, 339-52; Siperstein, F.R. and Gubbins, K.E. (2003). Phase separation and liquid crystal self-assembly in surfactant-inorganic-solvent systems. Langmuir, 19, 2049-57.
THE REASONS BE-HIND ADSORPTION HYSTERESIS Timur S. Jakubov Department of Applied Chemistry, Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology, Melbourne, Australia
Contents Introduction Capillary Condensation Hysteresis and the Kelvin Equation Hysteresis and Adsorption-Induced Strain of Adsorbents Low-Pressure Hysteresis Pore Network and Interconnectivity Some Peculiarities of the Adsorption Hysteresis for Carbonaceous Adsorbents References
6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5 6.6
6.1
133 135 136 137 137 138 140
INTRODUCTION
The phenomenon of hysteresis is widespread in nature. Behavior of many systems in physics [1], chemistry [2], biology [3], social science [4, 5], and interdisciplinary sciences [6] exhibit hysteresis. The most general reason for existing of these phenomena is as follows: if we reverse the path in the control variables space, we do not necessarily reverse the path in state variables space. Physically it means that there are two or more different local minima and only one corresponds to the thermodynamic equilibrium state, the others must be metastable. These persisting metastable states are responsible for the origin of hysteresis. Among these systems adsorption hysteresis stands out because of its direct and close connection with a number of other complicate phenomena and relevant Adsorption by Carbons ISBN: 978-0-08-044464-2
© 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
133
134
Chapter 6 The Reasons Behind Adsorption Hysteresis
functions, which in turn are a real challenge to a researcher. Among them are capillarity, criticality of confined fluids, surface phase transition, wettability and contact angles, curvature of interface and surface tension, influence of external potential fields, etc. Physical experiment, molecular simulation, and density functional theory approach are the dominant tools in studies of behavior of confined fluid at present. The first experiment in which adsorption hysteresis was observed was reported [7] in 1897. However, it took several decades before the status of the phenomenon of hysteresis in adsorption science was conclusively established. During this period a large body of experimental evidence was provided first and foremost in thorough studies by Zsigmondy [8], Anderson [9], Lambert and coworkers [10-15], Rao [16], and several others. In succeeding years, a number of new experimental investigations [17-23] was performed using a more advanced technique. The discussion of the works prior to 1967 can be found in the excellent Everett's review [24]. Beginning in 1993, a series of experiments [25-41] has been performed on ordered mesoporous adsorbents with a wellcharacterized pore structure such as MCM-41 with cylindrical and SBA with cage-like pores. In the context of present-day knowledge the adsorption hysteresis originates from the following main reasons: capillary condensation in the pores with specific geometry (however, it should be noted that, if the overlap of surface forces of the opposite walls in the fine pores takes place, a capillary condensation hysteresis may be developed, which is not connected with particular geometry of the pores [42]); elastic and plastic deformations of adsorbents during adsorption process; surface phase and structural phase transitions; kinetic effects associated with the existence of the potential energy barriers at the points of entrance into and egress from the fine pores; superposition of the several effects. According to modern classification, recommended by IUPAC [43], four general types of hysteresis loops designated by the symbols Hl, H2, H3, and H 4 are distinguished. Their shapes below are shown schematically in Fig. 6.1. Below we consider the most important occurrences of the adsorption hysteresis related to the most common reasons.
c:: -0 (J.) .c
oen
"C
ro
E ~
o
E
Relative pressure, p/Po
Figure 6.1 Four general types of adsorption hysteresis.
6.2 Capillary Condensation Hysteresis and the Kelvin Equation
6.2
135
CAPILLARY CONDENSATION HYSTERESIS
AND THE KELVIN EQUATION
According to deduction the classical Kelvin equation [44], which describes the dependence of the saturated vapor pressure on the curvature of interface in two-phase system, is rigorous one, when it is employed for the free (not confined) liquid because this equation takes into consideration only the action of the surface tension forces at the liquid-vapor interface. The present-day refined form of Kelvin's equation may be expressed as [45]
(6.1)
where lIi is the molar volume of the liquid, (j is the liquid/vapor interfacial tension, rm is the mean radius of curvature of the liquid/vapor interface, p and Poo are the saturated vapor pressures over curve and plane interfaces, respectively, and T and R have their usual meanings. To this must be added that (j and lIi depend on radius of curvature and pressure, respectively. However, in actual practice, the Kelvin equation is of frequent use in description of fluids confined in small pores or capillaries of solid. In this case the role of potential field of solid is not only comparable to the surface tension forces, but in some situations it predominates the contribution of the surface tension and the employment of the classical Kelvin equation becomes questionable and is limited by sufficiently large size of capillary [46]. Furthermore, the liquid layer with cylindrical shape, for instance, without the external potential field of cylindrical symmetry cannot exist, as absolutely unstable and nonequilibrium state. Consequently, the Kelvin equation can be used for description of the behavior of the liquid in the small pores or capillaries, only if it is generalized so that the impact of solid wall potential is taken into account. In the presence of the potential field the confined liquid behavior changes qualitatively. Just the wall potential define a limiting thickness of stable liquid layer in pore. Only if the size of pore is relatively large and the limiting thickness is less than radius of pore a capillary condensation may occur, otherwise, it does not take place [40, 47]. Thus, without considering the influence of wall potential the Kelvin equation can be only improved, but not generalized. Historically, however, considerable attention has been given to corrections to the Kelvin equation arising from the thickness of adsorbed layer and the dependence of surface tension on curvature of interface. The first problem was initially considered as monolayers by Foster [48] and more recently as a function of equilibrium pressure of the system by Cohan [49], Derjaguin [50], Foster [51], and Brockhoff and de Boer [52,53]. The initial approaches of Foster and Cohan
Chapter 6 The Reasons Behind Adsorption Hysteresis
136
reduced the radius R in cylindrical capillary to R-t, where t is the thickness of the adsorbed film. However, as it was shown by Derjaguin [50], that correction to the Kelvin equation depends on the attractive part of the solid-fluid potential function and replacing R by R - t is not generally valid. Derjaguin recognized that the interface contained a transition zone between the wetting adsorbed film on the solid surface and the meniscus of the confined fluid, where surface forces and capillary forces act simultaneously. This early result was recovered more recently from a modern density functional approach by Evans et al. [54]. Regarding to surface tension, after Gibbs' original formulation [55] the first results were obtained by Tolman [56], Koenig [57], and Buff [58] who derived the differential equation linking surface tension with radius of curvature. However, the integration of this equation is entail rough assumption regarding the Tolman length 8 - the distance between the Gibbs surface of tension and the equimolar surface - which was considered as constant and equal 8 (the planar limit of 8). Recently, the validity of Tolman's assumption has been evaluated [59, 60] in terms of the dependence of magnitude and sign of 8 on droplet size. It was shown that the planar limit is valid, if droplet contains more than 106 atoms, that is R > 22.5 nm - almost upper limit of mesopores (by argon at 90 K). The sorption potential of a confined fluid in a long open-ended cylindrical capillary was calculated by Barrer et al. [61] and subsequently by Nicholson [62] both of whom employed a sorption potential, which included elliptical integrals of the first and second kind. Integrals were evaluated numerically by fitting to a ninth-order polynomial function. Saam and Cole [63] expressed the attractive part of a cylindrical wall potential in terms of a hypergeometric function and calculated substrate potential as a function of inner radius of capillary. The potential energy profiles for atoms adsorbed in slit-like as well as in cylindrical pores in the Henry's law region are presented in the work of Everett and Powl [64]. The effective one-body potential as well as the wall-fluid potential has been calculated by Evans et al. [65] and Peterson et al. [66] in further studies to detail adsorbed phase behavior in cylindrical and slit-like pores. More recently Tja~opoulos et al. [67] obtained the expression for the interaction potential for the test fluid molecule with a monolayer surface forming a cylindrical pore wall also in terms of a hypergeometrical function. Then summing the interaction potential over 10 cylindrical surfaces with the same spacing, surface number density and Lennard-Jones parameters, authors reproduced the potential energy graphs obtained by numerical integration of this potential function. 00
6.3
HYSTERESIS AND ADSORPTION-INDUCED STRAIN
OF ADSORBENTS
Some dimensional changes of solid adsorbents accompany any adsorption process. However, the strain of adsorbents is not always responsible for adsorption hysteresis. For instance, the adsorbents with sufficiently small pores do not
6.5 Pore Network and Interconnectivity
137
exhibit hysteresis [40, 47], whereas deformation of the adsorbents occurs. Often the strain is merely the attendant phenomenon, but it nonetheless has an impact on quantitative characteristics of the hysteresis loop. For instance, the strain of the porous solid affects on contact angle and surface tension of confined fluid and consequently on capillary condensation. This problem was studied in particular by Lester [68] and Rusanov [69, 70]. In the absence of the other reasons sorbent's strain produces an adsorption hysteresis if either the deformation of solid is irreversible or the relaxation time of sorbent is essentially greater than the time necessary for establishment of the adsorption equilibrium. In these cases, the adsorption and desorption isotherms do not have a common reversible part. In the former case the hysteresis usually disappears in the repeat experiments. Recently, the simultaneous measurements of the adsorption - desorption isotherms, associated deformation curves and heat of adsorption for a number of systems were performed by Tvardovski et al. and reported in a series of papers [71-75]. Although the authors advocated that deformation ofsorbent is the universal cause of adsorption hysteresis, in actually, their experiments lend support to our outlined point of view.
6.4
LOW-PRESSURE HYSTERESIS
As is known [24] the hysteresis loop may persist to the lowest pressure in absence of a hysteresis closing point. This phenomenon referred to, as low-pressure hysteresis (LPH) is more frequent for microporous adsorbents particularly for active carbon. LPH has been the subject of some purposeful experimental investigations and theoretical hypotheses [76-80]. Not counting the systems with irreversible sorbent's deformation when hysteresis loop is observed in all range of relative pressure, the LPH has its origin above all in the kinetic effects associated with overcome the potential barrier at the open end of fine pores. As was shown in the work by ]akubov and Mainwaring [81], the behavior of the potential field at the open end of sufficiently narrow pores always exhibits the existence of potential barriers not only for inward diffusion, but also for outward diffusion. In addition, these barriers, generally, are unequal in magnitude. Moreover, the contraction of adsorbent that often occurs at low relative pressure may gives birth to the barrier for outward diffusion for pores, which have not had the barrier for inward diffusion.
6.5
PORE NETWORK AND INTERCONNECTIVITY
Finally, it is worth mentioning briefly of such a factor as interconnectivity of the pores, which significantly complicated theoretical studies ofthe adsorption systems with hysteresis. The investigation of this problem dates back to the
138
Chapter 6 The Reasons Behind Adsorption Hysteresis
pioneering work of Fatt [82] and since then has been intensively studied by many other researches. Basically, two kinds of the models for interconnected pore networks have been advanced and developed: structurally regular lattice models of the various complexity [62, 83-85] and the random or stochastic models [86-89]. In regard to methods and approaches used for examination of these models, the main method is the application of percolation theory [90-95] where critical percolation probabilities have been calculated by Monte Carlo methods [96] or probabilistic methods [84]. Numerous studies (we referred to just a small number of these works) lead to the general conclusion: capillary phenomena in such porous materials can produce irreversibility arising from pore-blocking effect [96-101]. Thus, the interconnectivity of pores is one more contributor of the adsorption hysteresis phenomena.
6.6
SOME PECULIARITIES OF THE ADSORPTION
HYSTERESIS FOR CARBONACEOUS ADSORBENTS
In the closing section we will enlarge on the distinctive characteristics of adsorption hysteresis, which are typical for porous carbonaceous adsorbents. The peculiarities associated with adsorption on active carbon, in particular, with hysteresis phenomenon owe its origin to two major factors. The first one lies in the fact that porous carbon adsorbents, as a rule, are structurally labile, especially the carbon of steam-gas activation. Every adsorption-desorption cycle involving a thermal treatment leads to the irreversible changes of adsorbents, and only after several training cycles the adsorbent reaches a stable state. The second factor is related to the surface chemical structures on active carbons, in particular, with their ability to oxidize easily and form the oxide adsorption centers such as hydroxyl, carbonyl or carboxyl groups. As a result the energetics and wettability of the surface changes that influences essentially on the adsorption isotherm and hysteresis. The difference between adsorptiondesorption isotherms for oxidized and reduced adsorbents is clearly demonstrated in Fig. 6.2. It should be noted that the range of relative equilibrium pressure in the hysteresis area is the same for both isotherms, whereas the amounts adsorbed are significantly different. Furthermore, the mechanism of adsorption of the nonpolar hydrocarbon (benzene) and polar adsorbate (water) on active carbon differs greatly. This difference is well represented in Fig. 6.3. In particular, the curves in Fig. 6.3 show that the hysteresis area of benzene corresponds to the adsorption in mesopores, and results from capillary condensation, whereas the hysteresis area of water corresponds to the adsorption in micropores, and thus cannot result from capillary condensation. Dispersion interaction, plays a dominant role in the case of benzene, but is not significant for water. The main mechanism of water adsorption by carbonaceous adsorbents includes the formation of hydrogen bounds
6.6 Some Peculiarities of the Adsorption Hysteresis for Carbonaceous Adsorbents
139
40
Ci
32
0 0
,.-....
~ "'0
24
Q)
.0
0 en
"'0
ctI
16
'E ::::J
0
E
«
8
PVDC-600 (degassed 10000 C) 0
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
Relative vapor pressure • Adsorption • Desorption
Figure 6.2 Adsorption-desorption isotherms of water on PVDC carbon before and after outgassing at 1273 K (Reprinted from Ref. [102] with permission from Elsevier).
0.4
2 0.3
:§
M
E 0.2
~
s:
0.1
o
0.5
pips Figure 6.3 Adsorption-desorption isotherms of benzene (1) and water (2) at 293 K on active carbon. AG-2 (Wo = 0.322 cm3 /g, Eo = 18.1 kJ/mole) (Reprinted from Re£ [103] with permission from the Editorial office of "Russian Chemical Bulletin").
Chapter 6 The Reasons Behind Adsorption Hysteresis
between water and oxygen complexes on the surface of adsorbent, as well as between the molecules of water.
REFERENCES 1. Pippard, A.B. (1985). Response and Stability. Cambridge University Press. 2. Vidal, C. and Pacault, A. (eds) (1981). Nonlinear Phenomena in Chemical Dynamics. Springer. 3. Lotka, A.J. (1925). Elements of Mathematical Biology. William and Wilkins. 4. Elster, J. (1976). A note on hysteresis in the social sciences. Synthese, 33, 371-91. 5. Franz, W. (ed.). (1990). Hysteresis Effects in Economic Models. Physica-Verlag. 6. Scott, A.C. (1977). Neurophysics. John Wiley & Sons. 7. van Bemmelen, J .M. (1897). Die adsorption. Das wasser in den kolloiden, besonders in dem gel der kieselsaure. Z. Anorg. Chem., 13, 233-356. 8. Zsigmondy, R. (1911). Ober die struktur des gels der kieselsaure. Theorie der entwasserung. Z. Anolg. Chem., 71, 356-77. 9. Anderson, J.S. (1914). Die struktur des gels der kieselsaure. Z. Physik. Chem., 88, 191-228. 10. Lambert, B. and Clark, A.M. (1929). Studies of gas-solid equilibria. Part II. Pressure-concentration equilibria between benzene and (a) ferric oxide gel, (b) silica gel, directly detennined under isothennal conditions. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A, 122, 497-512. 11. Lambert, B. and Foster, A.G. (1931). Studies of gas-solid equilibria. Part III. Pressure-concentration equilibria between silica gel and (a) water, (b) ethyl alcohol, directly detennined under isothermal conditions. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A, 134, 246-4. 12. Lambert, B. and Foster, A.G. (1932). Studies of gas-solid equilibria. Part IV. Pressure-concentration equilibria between ferric oxide gels and (a) water, (b) ethyl alcohol, (c) benzene, directly determined under isothennal conditions. Proc. Roy. Soc. Lond. A, 136, 363-77. 13. Foster, A.G. (1934). The sorption of methyl and ethyl alcohols by silica gels. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A, 146, 129-40. 14. Foster, A.G. (1934). The sorption of vapours by ferric oxide gel. I. Aliphatic alcohols. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A, 147, 128-40. 15. Foster, A.G. (1935). The sorption of propyl and butyl alcohols by silica gels. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A, 150, 77-83. 16. Rao, K.S. (1941). Hysteresis in sorption.]. Phys. Chem., 45, 500-39. 17. Amberg, C.H., Everett, D.H., Ruiter, L.H., and Smith, F.W. (1957). Studies in the thermodynamics of adsorption and adsorption hysteresis. In Proceedings of the 2nd International Congress Surface Activity, Vol. II Schulman, ed.). Butterworths, pp. 3-16. 18. Dubinin, M.M., Bering, B.P., Serpinsky, V.V., and Vasil'ev, B.N. (1958). The properties of substances in the adsorbed state: studies of gas adsorption over a wide temperature and pressure range. In Surface Phenomena in Chemistry and Biology a.F. Danielli, K.G.A. Pankhurst and A.C. Riddiford, eds). Pergamon Press, pp. 172-88.
a.H.
References
19. Stoeckli, H.F., Kraehenbuehl, F., and Morel, D. (1983). The adsorption of water by active carbons, in relation to the enthalpy of immersion. Carbon, 21, 589-91. 20. Nguyen Thi Minh Hien, Serpinskii, V.V., Neimark, A.V., and Moskovskaya, T.A. (1986). Capillary condensation and the porous structure of adsorbents. Bull. Acad. Sci. USSR. Div. Chem. Sci., 35, 1550-3. 21. Nguyen Thi Minh Hien, Serpinskii, V.V., and Yakubov, T.S. (1986). Adsorption of n-pentane on silica gel. Bull. Acad. Sci. USSR. Div. Chem. Sci., 35, 1554-7. 22. Nguyen Thi Minh Hien and Serpinskii, V.V. (1987). Temperature dependence of the hysteresis loop in capillary condensation. Bull. Acad. Sci. USSR. Div. Chem. Sci., 36, 2246-8. 23. Burgess, C.G.V., Everett, D.H., and Nuttall, S. (1989). Adsorption hysteresis in porous materials. Pure Appl. Chem., 61, 1845-2. 24. Everett, D.H. (1967). Adsorption hysteresis. In The Solid-Gas Interface, Vol. 2 (E.A. Flood, ed.). Marcel Dekker, pp. 1055-113. 25. Branton, P.J., Hall, P.G., and Sing, K.S.W. (1993). Physisorption of nitrogen and oxygen by MCM-41, a model mesoporous adsorbent.]. Chem. Soc. Chem. Commun., 1257-8. 26. Branton, P.J., Hall, P.G., Sing, K.S.W., et al. (1994). Physisorption of argon, nitrogen and oxygen by MCM-41, a model mesoporous adsorbent.]. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans., 90, 2965-7. 27. Branton, P.J., Hall, P.G., and Sing, K.S.W. (1995). Physisorption of alcohols and water vapour by MCM-41, a model mesoporous adsorbent. Adsorption, 1,77-82. 28. Branton, P.J., Hall, P.G., Treguer, M., and Sing, K.S.W. (1995). Adsorption of carbon dioxide, sulfur dioxide and water vapour by MCM-41, a model mesoporous adsorbent.]. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans., 91, 2041-3. 29. Branton, P.J., Sing, K.S.W., and White, J.W. (1997). Adsorption of carbon tetrachloride and nitrogen by 3.4 nm pore diameter siliceous MCM-41.]. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans., 93, 2337-40. 30. Ravikovitch, P.I., O'Domhnaill, S.C., Neimark, A.V., et al. (1995). Capillary hysteresis in nanopores: theoretical and experimental studies ofnitrogen adsorption on MCM-41. Langmuir, 11, 4765-72. 31. Neimark, A.V., Ravikovitch, P.I., Griln, M., et al. (1998). Pore size analysis of MCM-41 type adsorbents by means of nitrogen and argon adsorption.]. Colloid Interface Sci., 207, 159-69. 32. Rathousky, J., Zukal, A., Franke, 0., and Schulz-EklofL G. (1994). Adsorption on MCM-41 mesoporous molecular sieves. Part 1. Nitrogen isotherms and parameters of the porous structure.]. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans., 90, 2821-6. 33. Rathousky, J., Zukal, A., Franke, 0., and Schulz-Eklof£ G. (1995). Adsorption on MCM-41 mesoporous molecular sieves. Part 2. Cyclopentane isotherms and their temperature dependence.]. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans., 91, 937-40. 34. Morishige, K., Fujii, H., Uga, M., and Kinukawa, D. (1997). Capillary critical point of argon, nitrogen, oxygen, ethylene, and carbon dioxide in MCM-41. Langmuir, 13, 3494-8. 35. Morishige, K. and Shikimi, M. (1998). Adsorption hysteresis and pore critical temperature in a single cylindrical pore.]. Chem. Phys., 108, 7821-4. 36. Morishige, K. and Ito, M. (2002). Capillary condensation of nitrogen in MCM-41 and SBA-15.]. Chem. Phys., 117,8036-41. 37. Morishige, K. and Tateishi, N. (2003). Adsorption hysteresis in ink-bottle pore. J. Chem. Phys., 119,2301-6.
Chapter 6 The Reasons Behind Adsorption Hysteresis
38. Kruk, M.,Jaroniec, M., and Sayari, A. (1997). Application oflarge pore MCM-41 molecular sieves to improve pore size analysis using nitrogen adsorption measurements. Langmuir, 13, 6267-73. 39. Kruk, M., Jaroniec, M., and Sayari, A. (2000). Nitrogen adsorption study of M CM-41 molecular sieves synthesized using hydrothermal restructuring. Adsorption, 6, 47-51. 40. Kruk, M. andJaroniec, M. (2000). Accurate method for calculating mesopore size distribution from argon adsorption data at 87 K developed using model MCM-41 materials. Chem. Mater., 12, 222-30. 41. Long, Y., Xu, T., Sun, Y., and Dong, W. (1998). Adsorption behavior on defect structure of mesoporous molecular sieve MCM-41. Langmuir, 14,6173-8. 42. Derjaguin, B.V. and Churaev N.V. (1976). Polymolecular adsorption and capillary condensation in narrow slit pores. J. Colloid Interface Sci., 54, 157-75. 43. Sing, K.S.W., Everett, D.H., Haul, R.A.W., et al. (1985). Reporting physisorption data for gas/solid systems with special reference to the determination of surface area and porosity. Pure Appl. Chem., 57, 603-19. 44. Thomson, W. (1871). On the equilibrium of vapour at a curved surface of liquid. Phil. Mag., 42, 448-52. 45. Rowlinson, J.S. and Widom, B. (1982). Molecular Theory of Capillarity. Clarendon Press. 46. Fisher, L.R. and Israelachvili, J.N. (1981). Experimental studies on the applicability of the Kelvin equation to highly curved concave menisci. J. Colloid Interface Sci., 80, 528-41. 47. Dacey,J.R. and Thomas, D.G. (1954). Adsorption on saran charcoal. A new type of molecular sieve. Trans. Faraday Soc., 50, 740-8. 48. Foster, A.G. (1934). The sorption of vapours by ferric oxide gel. 1. Aliphatic alcohols. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A, 147, 128-40. 49. Cohan, L.H. (1938). Sorption hysteresis and the vapor pressure on concave surfaces. J. Am. Chem. Soc., 60, 433-35. 50. Derjaguin, B.V. (1940). Theory of capillary condensation and other capillary phenomena with allowance for the disjoining action ofpolymolecular liquid films. Acta Physicochim. USSR, 12, 181-90. 51. Foster, A.G. (1952). Sorption hysteresis. Part II. The role of the cylindrical meniscus effect. J. Chem. Soc. Lond. Part II, 1806-12. 52. Broekho~ J.C.P. and de Boer, J.H. (1967). Studies on pore systems in catalysis. IX. Calculation of pore distributions from the adsorption branch of nitrogen sorption isotherms in the case ofopen cylindrical pores. A. Fundamental equations. J. Catal., 9, 8-14. 53. Broekhof£ J.C.P. and de Boer, J.H. (1968). Studies on pore systems in catalysis. XII. Pore distributions from the desorption branch of a nitrogen sorption isotherm in the case of cylindrical pores. A. An analysis of the capillary evaporation process. J. Catal., 10, 368-76. 54. Evans, R. and Marini Bettolo Marconi, U. (1985). The role of wetting films in capillary condensation and rise: influence of long-range forces. Chem. Phys. Lett., 114,415-22. 55. Gibbs, J.W. (1961). The Scientific Papers, Vol. 1. Dover Publications. 56. Tolman, R.C. (1949). The effect of droplet size on surface tension. J. Chem. Phys., 17,333-7.
References
143
57. Koenig, F.O. (1950). On the thermodynamic relation between surface tension and curvature. J. Chern. Phys., 18, 449-59. 58. Buf£ F.P. (1951). The spherical interface. 1. Thermodynamics. J. Chern. Phys., 19, 1591-4. 59. Koga, K., Zeng, X.C., and Shchekin, A.K. (1998). Validity of Tolman's equation: how large should a droplet be? J. Chern. Phys., 109, 4063-70. 60. Granasy, L. Semiempirical van der Waals/Cahn-Hilliard theory: size dependence of the Tolman length.]. Chern. Phys. 1998, 109, 9660-3. 61. Barrer, R.M. (1951). Multilayer sorption in terms of an equation of state. Trans. Faraday Soc., 47, 773-87. 62. Nicholson, D. (1975). Molecular theory of adsorption in pore spaces. Part 1. Isotherms for simple lattice models. J. Chern. Soc. Faraday Trans. I, 71, 238-55. 63. Saam, W.F. and Cole, M.W. (1975). Excitations and thermodynamics for liquidhelium films. Phys. Rev. B, 11, 1086-105. 64. Everett, D.H. and Powl,j.C. (1976). Adsorption in slit-like and cylindrical micropores in the Henry's law region.]. Chern. Soc. Faraday Trans. 1,72,619-36. 65. Evans, R., Marini Bettolo Marconi, D., and Tarazona, P. (1986). Capillary condensation and adsorption in cylindrical and slit-like pores.]. Chern. Soc. Faraday Trans. 11,82, 1763-87. 66. Peterson, B.K., Walton, P.R.B., and Gubbins, K.E. (1986). Fluid behaviour in narrow pores.]. Chern. Soc. Faraday Trans. II, 82, 1789-800. 67. Tjatjopoulos, GJ., Feke, D.L., and Mann, j.A., jr (1988). Molecule-micropore interaction potentials.]. Phys. Chern., 92, 4006-7. 68. Lester, G.R. (1967). Contact angles on deformable solids. In Wetting. Society of Chemical Industry, pp. 57-93. 69. Rusanov, A.I. (1975). Theory of elastically of the wetting deformed bodies. 1. Deformation with a finite contact angle. Colloid]. USSR, 37, 614-22. 70. Rusanov, A.I. (1975). Theory of elastically of the wetting deformed bodies. 2. Equilibrium conditions and work of deformation with a finite contact angle.
Colloid]. USSR, 37,614-22. 71. Tvardovski, A.V., Fomkin, A.A., Tarasevich, Yu.I., et al. (1994). Investigation of cation-substituted vermiculite deformation upon water vapor sorption. J. Colloid Interface Sci., 164, 114-18. 72. Tvardovski, A.V., Fomkin, A.A., Tarasevich, Yu.I., and Zhukova, A.I. (1997). Hysteresis phenomena in the study of sorptive deformation of sorbents. J. Colloid Interface Sci., 191, 117-19. 73. Tvardovski, A.V., Fomkin, A.A., Tarasevich, Yu.I., and Zhukova, A.I. (1999). Adsorptive deformation of organo-substituted laminar silicates.]. Colloid Interface Sci., 212, 426-30. 74. Tvardovski, A.V., Fomkin, A.A., Tarasevich, Yu.I., and Zhukova, A.I. (2001). Sorptive deformation of organo-substituted laminar silicates and hysteresis phenomena.]. Colloid Interface Sci., 241, 297-301. 75. Yakovlev, V.Yu., Fomkin, A.A., and Tvardovski, A.V. (2003). Adsorption and deformation phenomena at the interaction of CO 2 and a microporous carbon adsorbent.]. Colloid Interface Sci., 268, 33-6. 76. Bailey, A., Cadenhead, D.A., Davies, D.A., et al. (1971). Low pressure hysteresis in the adsorption of organic vapours by porous carbon. Trans. Faraday Soc., 67,
231-43.
144
Chapter 6 The Reasons Behind Adsorption Hysteresis
77. McEnaney, B. (1974). Low pressure hysteresis in the sorption of carbon tetrachloride vapour on polymer carbon.]. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. I, 70, 84-94. 78. Linares-Solano, A., Rodriguez-Reinoso, F., Martin-Martinez, J.M., and LopezGonzalez, J.D. (1984). Adsorption of hydrocarbons on air-reacted activated carbons. II. High and low pressure hysteresis. Ads. Sci. Technol., 1, 317-27. 79. Kabanova, a.N., Yakubov, T.S., and Serpinskii, V.V. (1988). Low-pressure hysteresis in the cyclopentane-activated charcoal system. Bull. Acad. Sci. USSR. Div. Chem. Sci., 37, 1311-14. 80. Mather, R.R. (1997). Analysis of pore properties from low pressure hysteresis in nitrogen adsorption isotherms. In Characterisation ofPorous Solids IV (B. McEnaney, T.]. Mays, J. Rouquerol, F. Rodriguez-Reinoso, K.S.W. Sing and K.K. Unger, eds). The Royal Society of Chemistry, pp. 314-18. 81. Jakubov, T.S. and Mainwaring, D.E. (2002). Potential fields and barriers to diffusion in narrow cylindrical capillaries. Mol. Simul., 28, 751-9. 82. Fatt, I. (1956). The network model of porous media I: capillary pressure characteristics. Petrol. Trans. A.I.M.E., 207, 144-59. 83. Haynes, J.M. (1975). Porous media: structures and models. In Colloid Science, Vol. 2 (D.H. Everett, ed.). The Chemical Society, pp. 101-29. 84. Doe, P.H. and Haynes, J.M. (1979). Mechanistic aspects of capillary hysteresis in pore networks. In: Characterisation of Porous Solids (S.]. Gregg, K.S.W. Sing and H.F. Stoeckli, eds). Society of Chemical Industry, pp. 253-65. 85. Neimark, A.V. (1983). Development of the capillary condensation and adsorption theory in mesoporous adsorbents based on the porous structure lattice models. Dokl. Acad. Sci. USSR, 273, 384-8. 86. Ksenzhek, a.s. (1963). Capillary equilibrium in porous media with intersecting pores. Russ.]. Phys. Chem., 37, 691-4. 87. Mason, G. A. (1971). Model of the pore space in a random packing of equal spheres.]. Colloid Interface Sci., 35, 279-87. 88. Liu, H., Zhang, L., and Seaton, N. (1993). Analysis of sorption hysteresis in mesoporous solids using a pore network modeL]. Colloid Interface Sci., 156, 285-93. 89. Mann, R., Youse£ H.N.S., Friday, D.K., and Mahle, J.]. (1995). Interpretation of water isotherm hysteresis for an activated charcoal using stochastic pore network. Adsorption, 1, 253-64. 90. Broadbent, S.R. and Hammersley, J.M. (1957). Percolation processes. I. Crystals and mazes. Proc. Camb. Phi/os. Soc., 53, 629-41. 91. Hammersley, J.M. (1957). Percolation processes. II. The connective constant. Proc. Camb. Phi/os. Soc., 53, 642-5. 92. Wall, G.C. and Brown, R.].C. (1981). The determination of pore-size distributions from sorption isotherms and mercury penetration in interconnected pores: the application of percolation theory.]. Colloid Interface Sci., 82, 141-9. 93. Neimark, A.V. (1984). Analysis of capillary condensation and desorption processes by means of percolation-theory methods. Colloid]. USSR, 46, 813-19. 94. Neimark, A.V. (1991). Percolation theory of capillary hysteresis phenomena and its applications for characterization of porous solids. Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal., 62, 67-74. 95. Liu, H., Zhang, L., and Seaton, N.A. (1993). Sorption hysteresis as a probe of pore structure. Langmuir, 9, 2576-82.
References
145
96. Maddox, M.W., Quirke, N., Gubbins, K.E. (1997). Simulation studies of pore blocking phenomena in model porous networks. In Characterisation of Porous Solids IV (B. McEnaney, T.J. Mays, J. Rouquerol, et aI., eds). Royal Society of Chemistry, pp. 65-72. 97. Mason, G. (1982). The effect of pore space connectivity on the hysteresis of capillary condensation in adsorption-desorption isotherms. J. Colloid Inteiface Sci., 88,36-46. 98. Mason, G. (1983). A model ofadsorption-desorption hysteresis in which hysteresis is primarily developed by the interconnections in a network of pores. Proc. R. Soc. Land. A, 390, 47-72. 99. Mason, G. (1988). Determination of the pore-size distributions and pore space interconnectivity of Vycor porous glass from adsorption-desorption hysteresis capillary condensation isotherms. Proc. R. Soc. Land. A, 415, 453-86. 100. Ravikovitch, P.I. and Neimark, A.V. (2002). Experimental confirmation of different mechanisms of evaporation from ink-bottle type pores: equilibrium, pore blocking, and cavitation. Langmuir, 18, 9830-7. 101. Vishnyakov, A. and Neimark, A.V. (2003). Monte Carlo simulation test of pore blocking effects. Langmuir, 19,3240-7. 102. Bansal, R.C., Dhami, T.L. and Prakash, S. (1978). Surface characteristics and surface behaviour of polymer carbons. II Adsorption of water vapor. Carbon, 16, 389-95. 103. Dubinin, M.M. (1981). Adsorption of water vapor and microporous structures of carbonaceous adsorbents. Bull. Acad. Sci. USSR. Div. Chern. Sci., 30, 9-23.
THE SURFACE HETEROGENEITY OF CARBON AND ITS ASSESSMENT James P. Olivier Micromeritics Instrument Corp., Inc., Norcross, GA, USA
Contents 7.1 Introduction 7.2 Theoretical Background 7.3 The Application of Density Functional Theory 7.4 Results for "Nonporous" Carbons 7.5 Activated Carbons 7.6 Conclusions References
7.1
147 15 1 153 156 160 165 165
INTRODUCTION
Today, there is probably universal agreement that virtually all real adsorbents are energetically heterogeneous; that is, they display a distribution of adsorptive potentials. Carbons as a class encompass a very wide range of such heterogeneity, from virtually uniform graphites to extremely heterogeneous carbon blacks and microporous activated carbons. Each of these categories presents its own challenges for the quantitative assessment of heterogeneity. 7.1.1
The Adsorptive Potential
In the context of this discussion, surface heterogeneity will be expressed in terms of the adsorptive potential of the material. The adsorptive potential is a measure ofthe net attraction between a solid surface and an adsorbed probe molecule. For physical adsorption, these forces arise chiefly from London-type dispersion interactions (van der Waals forces) resulting from induced-dipole/induceddipole and higher multipolar attractions which in turn depend on the size, Adsorption by Carbons ISBN: 978-0-08-044464-2
© 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
147
Chapter 7 The Surface Heterogeneity of Carbon and Its Assessment
polarizability, and magnetic susceptibility of the interacting particles (atoms or molecules). Additional contributions may come from coulombic interactions, or from induction forces brought about by the operation of a surface electric field on induced or permanent dipoles of resident molecules. The net potential due to these forces acting on an adsorbed molecule is generally short ranged and is the summed effect from all nearby surface atoms. The contribution of the dispersion forces to the total potential can be well approximated by the Lennard-Jones (LJ) equation for pairwise interaction [1]; (7.1) In Eqn (7.1), cP is the potential, B the depth of the potential well, s the molecular separation, and (J" the separation at which cP = O. For an adsorptive molecule at the adsorbent surface, the total dispersion potential, U LJ , is the sum of its pairwise interactions with each atom of the solid: (7.2) In Eqn (7.2), Su is the distance from the adsorbed molecule to the solid atom j having energy parameter Bj . It is readily seen from Fig. 7.1 that over 90 % of the value of U LJ is provided by the surface atoms within 3-4 molecular diameters of the adsorbed molecule. It is clear that any irregularity in the local chemical composition, density, or geometry of the surface will cause a variation in the adsorptive potential at that point. If the surface topography is locally re-entrant, so as to constitute a fine pore of molecular dimensions, then the
2~---------------------'-----,
<5
E
..........
~
o
i.. ~
:~,.:_.--.:.:..:.:.:.:,.:.~~
~-
=:3
::>
co E (1) (5
a.
-2-1
-4
-//,
I
············•·
··········•
···
·1
I
en
(1)
c o """')
1
-6
U Cii
c c
(1)
.....J
-10
+----i-----T-------T-----,-------r----1
o
234
5
6
Relative distance from surface
Figure 7.1 The potential experienced by a molecule near a solid surface according to Eqn (7.2). The parameters chosen represent nitrogen near a graphite slab.
149
7.1 Introduction
adsorptive potential can be more than doubled. Since the effects of surface chemical heterogeneity and the effects of porosity on the adsorption isotherm are both expressed through the same adsorptive potential, we can anticipate some difficulty in separating the two causes. We shall see that such a separation is possible when the smallest pores in the material to be characterized are large enough to have negligible effect on monolayer formation. However, for microporous adsorbents such as activated carbon, this is not possible and other assumptions must be made. 7.1.2
Thermodynamic Meaning of the Adsorption Potential
In the preceding section, we have presented the idea that real surfaces can be, and usually are, "energetically heterogeneous" in that they provide regions of varying attractive potential to physically adsorbed molecules. In describing a surface energy characteristic, an energy function that is independent of temperature and concentration is desirable. Such a quantity is conveniently defined by the potential energy difference between the lowest energy state of the adsorptive molecule in the gas phase and its lowest energy state in the adsorbed phase, both at infinite dilution [2]. In this way we obtain a quantity that is independent of the kinetic states of the molecule in either phase and that measures most directly the adsorptive potential of the system. The adsorptive potential, Ua, is therefore defined for a homotattic suiface [2] as
ua =
a
pads -
a
E vib
(7.3)
a
where a pads is the potential energy per mole lost by an isolated molecule in moving from a distant point to its equilibrium adsorbed position. The second term on the right is the zero-point vibrational energy of the adsorbed molecule with respect to the surface. While a pads corresponds to the depth of the potential well in Fig. 7.1, we should note that a pads may differ from ULJ if mechanisms other than dispersion forces are at work. When a molecule is adsorbed, the process is accompanied by the liberation of heat that may be measured calorimetrically. The experimentally measured heat can be related to a thermodynamic quantity, the differential heat of adsorption, by relationships that depend on the specifics of the calorimeter used [3]. The differential heat of adsorption, qdiff, on a homotattic surface at any isotherm point is related to Ua by q diff
= Uo (a E vib _ a E aVib ) _
dE tr _ dErot
+a pia
(7.4)
where the term CE vib - aE~ib) is the thermal vibrational energy per mole of adsorbate in excess of the zero-point energy, dE tr and dErot are the kinetic energy changes on adsorption due to loss in translational and rotational degrees of freedom, and apia is the energy of interaction with all neighboring adsorbed molecules. This latter term is clearly dependent on surface concentration and could be estimated by an equation analogous to Eqn (7.2).
Chapter 7 The Surface Heterogeneity of Carbon and Its Assessment
150
Another thermodynamic quantity, qst, the isosteric heat of adsorption, can be calculated from the temperature dependence of the adsorption isotherm by obtaining the slope of the adsorption isostere and is defined by (7.5a)
where na is the moles adsorbed, and g V and a V are the molar volumes of the gas and adsorbed phases, respectively. Neglecting the molar volume of the adsorbed phase relative to the gas phase and assuming the gas phase is ideal gives the more familiar expression
Slnp) t ( 8(1/1) na = qS /R
(7.5b)
It can be shown that the differential and isosteric heats are related by (7.6)
The importance of Eqn (7.4) is that it expresses the differential heat of adsorption in terms of a number of concepts that have a readily visualized physical basis; it reasserts and emphasizes that the differential heat of adsorption contains inter alia separate expressions for the adsorbate-adsorbent interaction and the adsorbate-adsorbate interaction; and since all the other experimentally determined heats of adsorption are related to qdiff, the same conclusion also holds true for them. The quantity Va' expressing as it does the adsorbate-adsorbent interaction stripped of all other incidental energy changes such as lateral (fluidfluid) interaction, work terms, and kinetic and vibrational energy changes, is
-----....-------+---
Bulk phase
~
e> (J) c:
(J)
~
0
-------t
+--~--t-----t--&------t==......
C (J) (5
a..
a _.....-+-_--1.--
0.0
Evib
aEovib
0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 Distance from surface (molecular diameters)
4.0
Figure 7.2 A schematic diagram of the various energy changes taking place on adsorption.
15 1
7.2 Theoretical Background
more suitable than any of the experimentally measured heats as an index of the fundamental "affinity" of a solid surface for adsorbing a particular gas molecule. The relation of the various heats of adsorption to the adsorptive potential is shown schematically in Fig. 7.2. It should be noted that while heat lost from a system is thermodynamically a negative quantity, it is a custom of long-standing to employ a positive sign in adsorption science. This is frequently confusing to newcomers to adsorption studies. For a more complete and detailed discussion of the thermodynamic quantities ofinterest in physical adsorption, the reader is referred to Chapter III of Ref [3].
7.2
THEORETICAL BACKGROUND
7.2.1 The Integral Equation of Adsorption
Although the concepts are somewhat older, the most widely used model for describing adsorption on an energetically heterogeneous surface was first explicitly stated by Ross and Olivier [4, 5]. The model postulates that the surface' of a real solid is composed of small patches of different adsorptive potential that adsorb independently of one other. The distribution of adsorptive potentials, Uo, among these patches may be represented by a continuous distribution function:
1 da fa= AdU. =f(Uo)
(7.7)
°
where fa is the patch (or site) frequency per unit energy interval on a surface of area A. The distribution function must normalize to unity, as was pointed out by Hill [6], since we are dealing with a surface of finite extent; that is, !(Uo)dUo = 1, over the range of energies considered significant. At any equilibrium pressure p under isothermal conditions, the quantity adsorbed per unit area, q, on a given surface patch will depend only on the adsorptive potential of that patch according to a function: or more generally q = q (P, Uo)
(7.8)
The observed total amount adsorbed, Q at pressure p is then the sum of the contributions from each patch of surface, i.e., (7.9) Equation (7.9) is therefore the general form for any adsorption isotherm and corresponds to equation IV-4 ofRef [3]. Equation (7.9) is now often referred to as "the integral equation of adsorption" or "the generalized adsorption integral." The function q(p,Uo) is called the kernel function or the local isotherm. The local isotherm can take various forms, depending on the geometry of the system that Eqn (7.9) is being used to describe.
Chapter 7 The Surface Heterogeneity of Carbon and Its Assessment
7.2. 2 Solving and Using the Integral Equation of Adsorption 7.2.2.1 Analytic solutions
Referring to Eqn (7.9), we see that in any treatment of surface heterogeneity, we have to deal with three functions, any two of which, if known, assumed or determined can be used in theory to obtain the third. Equation (7.9) represents a Fredholm's integral of the first kind. The solution of equations of this type is well known to present an ill-posed or ill-conditioned problem. For our purposes, this means that the data, Q(P), can be "well represented" by many function pairs in the integrand; hence, simply fitting the data does not guarantee that the kernel function or the distribution are individually "correct." In addition, the mathematical difficulties of handling Eqn (7.9) analytically have severely restricted the number of possible variations that have been published and these are now only of historical interest. No analytic solution of Eqn (7.9) has yet been made based on reasonable models of multilayer adsorption incorporating adsorbate-adsorbate interaction; such a solution may not be possible. 7.2.2.2 Numerical solutions
Unlocking the utility ofEqn (7.9) has been a challenge for decades. The period of renewed adsorption research activity in the decade of the 1950s happened at a time when high-speed electronic computing was just becoming available to researchers in this field. This made the numerical solution of Eqn (7.9) a feasible undertaking. For the first time, it was possible to at least calculate the numerical values of Q(P) from the integral equation of adsorption using more theoretically sophisticated kernel functions that incorporated adsorbate-adsorbate interaction, together with a reasonable distribution function. Equation (7.9) can be rewritten in discrete form as a summation over all significant adsorptive potential patches: (7.10) where we have replaced Ua with the less specific equivalent, B i . The first such solutions were carried out by Ross and Olivier [4, 5] and are tabulated in Ref [3]. Using Gaussian distributions of adsorptive potential of varying width, they computed tables of model isotherms using kernel functions based on the Hill-de Boer equation for a mobile, nonideal two-dimensional gas. It was not actually possible to fit data to the computed models using numerical methods in 1957, so Ross and Olivier developed a technique to find the best fitting model for an experimental isotherm data set by means of graphical overlays. They found that excellent fits to the experimental data could be obtained provided that the degree of heterogeneity was not too great. As pointed out above, a good fit to the data does not in itself verify a kernel
7.3 The Application of Density Functional Theory
153
function or the distribution. However, as the adsorbent becomes more and more homotattic, its isotherms should approach agreement with the kernel function. This was shown to be the case for adsorption measurements on a series of carbons graphitized at increasing temperatures, culminating in the highly graphitized carbon black, P-33, whose isotherms of argon and nitrogen at 77 K and 90 K are closely fitted by the Hill-de Boer equation in the monolayer region. By also correctly describing the heat of adsorption as a function of quantity adsorbed for heterogeneous surfaces, this work confirmed Eqn (7.9) as a powerful tool for investigating surface heterogeneity and the validity of the two-dimensional nonideal gas model for the kernel function. In later work, Ross and Morrison [7, 8] were able to make several advances. The van der Waals equation of state for real gases, which is the basis of the Hill-de Boer equation, is known to be rather inaccurate. Ross and Morrison based their kernel function on a two-dimensional form of the much better virial equation of state. But more importantly, advances in computing resources made it possible to solve Eqn (7.10) for the unknown distribution function using a nonnegative least squares method, rather than assuming a form a priori [9]. Again, it was found to be difficult to fit uniquely isotherm data for surfaces that were more than moderately heterogeneous. The major limitation lies in the fact that the kernel functions used were only models for monolayer adsorption, yet it is well known that adsorption proceeds to multilayers as pressure is increased. To ensure that the more strongly adsorbing portions of the surface remained in the monolayer range, only the lowest pressure portion of the isotherm can be used. This means that the low adsorptive energy portions of the surface contribute little to the total amount adsorbed, making their estimation uncertain. If higher pressure data are included in Q(P), then multilayers exist on some surface patches, which are then not correctly modeled by the monolayer kernel function. Further advances had to await the theoretical development of an improved kernel function.
7.3
THE ApPLICATION OF DENSITY FUNCTIONAL THEORY
While good descriptions of adsorption on uniform surfaces in the submonolayer region have been available for decades, only since the 1990s has accurate calculation ofthe whole isotherm, including the multilayer region, been demonstrated [10]. These calculations use a modified nonlocal density functional theory (MNLDFT). The first use of multilayer local isotherms calculated by MNLDFT in obtaining a measure of surface energetic heterogeneity for several solid adsorbents was reported in 1996 [11]. The formalism of density functional theory (DFT) has received considerable attention as a way to describe the adsorption process at the fluid-solid interface. The older approach was to treat the adsorbate as a separate, two-dimensional phase existing in equilibrium with the bulk gas phase. This model works well
154
Chapter 7 The Surface Heterogeneity of Carbon and Its Assessment
in the monolayer region, but at higher surface concentrations the formation of multilayers requires adopting some sort of three-dimensional model in order to account for increasing adsorbate-adsorbate interaction and the diminishing adsorption potential contribution. Using density functional theory, the adsorptive can be treated as a single, inhomogeneous fluid phase. The fluid varies in density from that of the bulk gas to a much higher value at the adsorbent surface in response to the strength and configuration of the surface adsorptive forces. In this paradigm, there is no separate adsorbed phase; indeed, the concept of a monolayer capacity, fundamental to the two-phase paradigm has disappeared as well. The benefit of this approach is that the isotherm can be modeled from the Henry's law region through to saturation, and even above the adsorptive's critical temperature. In particular, the ability with DFT to model physical adsorption in a pore space of slit-like or cylindrical geometry has led to potentially useful methods for extracting surface area and pore size distribution information from experimental adsorption isotherms [12, 13]. The predictions of density functional theory have been reported to compare well with the results of simulations [14, 15] using Monte Carlo or molecular dynamics methods. Stringent comparisons to real data have been made by us [10] for the adsorption of nitrogen and argon on the near-homotattic surface of a highly gr~phitized carbon, Sterling FT-G(2700). In performing such comparisons, the only unknown intensive parameter is the LJ pairwise interaction energy X f between the adsorbate and adsorbent atoms. Using the customary Tarazona [16] prescription (with corrected weight functions [17]) for the free-energy density functional, we have found that the experimental isotherm data in the monolayer region of coverage can be moderately well described by DFT calculations; however, in the multilayer region of the isotherm, the quantity adsorbed per unit area is significantly over predicted. Later work [10] has shown that a modification to the mean field approximation used to calculate the attractive component of the configurational chemical potential leads to theoretical isotherms that agree closely with experiment over a six-decade range of pressure. An example is shown in Fig. 7.3, along with the results of the unmodified NLDFT of Tarazona [17].
7.3.1 The Deconvolution Method The integral equation of adsorption, Eqn. (7.9), can be rewritten in specific units as
Q(P)
=
f deq(p, e)j(e)
(7.11)
where Q(P) is the total quantity of adsorbate per gram of adsorbent at pressure p, q(p,X) , the kernel function (the local isotherm), describes the adsorption
isotherm for an ideally homotattic surface characterized by an interaction energy e as quantity of adsorbate per square meter of surface, and f(e) the surface area distribution function with respect to e. The quantity e(Eqn. 7.1)) as we
7.3 The Application of Density Functional Theory
0.5
~
g:
-r-----------------~_:r_'1
-0-
0.4
(J)
155
Data
--- MNLDFT --- NLDFT
('I)
E
~
0.3
-0
Q)
-eo ~
0.2
ECO
0.1
CO ~ :::J
o
0.0 ..................~~-........_--,.__--r__--.....__-___4 1e-6 1e-5 1e-4 1e-3 1e-2 1e-1 1e+0 Relative pressure
Figure 7-3 A comparison of experimental data for nitrogen adsorbed at 77 K on Sterling FT-G(2700) graphite with the modified nonlocal density functional theory [10] (MNLDFT) and unmodified [1 7] nonlocal density functional theory (NLDFT).
shall see is closely related to the adsorptive potential and can be equated to the quantity a pads in Eqn. (7.3) and in Fig. 7.2. While DFT allows us to calculate values for q(p, 8), it of course provides no analytic form for the function, and in general the form of f(8) is also unknown. However, by using carefully designed numerical methods, model isotherms calculated by MNLDFT can be used in carrying out the inversion of the discrete form of the integral equation of adsorption. In this way one can determine the effective adsorptive potential distribution of the adsorbent from the experimental adsorption isotherm. The method used can be expressed by (7.12) where Q(P) is the experimental adsorption isotherm interpolated onto the vector p of pressure points, q(p, 8 ij ) a matrix of quantity adsorbed per square meter, each row calculated by MNLDFT for a value of 8 at pressures p, andf(8J a vector of positive or null values whose terms represent the area of surface in the sample characterized by energy Xi' The total surface area of the sample is given by
The solution values desired are those positive numbers that most nearly, in a least squares sense, solve Eqn. (7.12). Additional constraints on the solution may be required to stabilize the deconvolution process [18, 19]. The formulation and solution of Eqn. (7.12) differs from previous work in an important way. In previous attempts, Q(P) was the amount adsorbed at the
Chapter 7 The Surface Heterogeneity of Carbon and Its Assessment
experimental pressures, p. This required that q(p, XJ be calculated for that specific set of pressures, and that the size ofJ (XJ be no greater than the number of experimental points. Not only does this result in a large computing task for each data set, it causes the evaluation ofJ(XJ to be subject to a varying bias, depending on how many and where on the pressure scale the isotherm points were measured. The automatic adsorption equipment available today permits a large number of experimental points to be measured and the resulting isotherms can be interpolated accurately onto a predetermined optimized set of pressures. Hence, the vector p can be chosen to best represent the kernel function over the wide pressure range required by the set of Xi. If we consider m members of the set of X and a vector p of length n, it is clear that n X m must hold. If n = m, the solution vector J (X) can be "noisy" because of even small imperfections in the data or model. For n > m, the solution is smoother because of the additional data constraints. Various other regularization techniques have been proposed to mitigate the inversion problem; in this work we use the method of co-minimization of the second derivative of f(X) together with an overdetermined matrix for which n > 2m.
7.3.1.1 Parameters of the model matrix For use with Eqn.(7.12), a model matrix was calculated by the MNLDFT method [10] using the parameters suitable for nitrogen at 77.3 K. For convenience, the values of X were specifically the values of X sf / k used to calculate the wall potential V(z) of that reference, and ranged from 20 to 100 K in steps of 2.0 K (approximately 1/2RT). Relative pressure points were chosen in geometric progression from 1 x 10-6 to 0.6 with 40 points per pressure decade. Model isotherms were normalized to 1 m 2 of surface.
7.4
RESULTS FOR "NONPOROUS" CARBONS
Synthetic and natural graphites and carbon blacks are arguably nonporous, though the small spaces between primary particles in a carbon black agglomerate may act as pores in some materials. Additionally, the prismatic surfaces of natural graphite may display "missing" graphene planes that in effect become shallow slit-like pores. If such pores have a width less than about 1 nm, they will report as very high energy regions in the adsorptive energy distribution. The data reported here were obtained using a Micromeritics ASAP 2010 equipped with optional 10- and 1-torr pressure transducer. Low-pressure data were corrected for thermal effusion.
157
7.4 Results for "Nonporous" Carbons
7.4.1 Synthetic Graphitic Carbons Heating a graphitizable thermal carbon black to high temperature in an inert atmosphere produces some of the most energetically uniform surfaces known. One reason for this lies in the shape of the particles formed. Electron micrographs [3] reveal that the individual particles are doubly truncated polygonal (principally hexagonal and octagonal) bipyramids consisting of minute radiating crystals. The exposed surface of each crystal is the graphite basal plane. The surface of the whole faceted particle is therefore entirely composed of the carbon layer plane of crystalline graphite with no exposed prismatic surface. To confirm the deconvolution algorithm, we show in Figs. 7.4(a) and (b) the result of applying Eqn. (7.12) to the experimental data contained in Fig. 7.3. Since this data set was used in developing the MNLDFT model, we would expect to recover a monomodal energy distribution with esf / k = 57.0 K, as used in the fit shown in Fig. 7.3. The best fit contained contributions from the classes representing esf / k = 56 and 58, with an area weighted mean of 56.7 K, which is satisfactory agreement. The total surface area obtained is 12.4m2 jg. The BET (stands for Brunauer, Emmett, and Teller) area of this certified reference material is 11.1 m 2 j g. Because the MDFT model ignores the slight corrugation of the wall potential, the commensurate film transition seen at 0.008 relative pressure is not reproduced. Figure 7.5 , (a) and (b), illustrates the application of Eqn. (7.12) to the nitrogen isotherm obtained with Vulcan 3-G(2700). While graphitized at the same temperature as the Sterling FT, Vulcan has previously been reported as less uniform than the Sterling material [14]. As additional evidence, note that the commensurate film transition near 0.008 Pre! seen in Figs. 7.3 and 7.4 is not
(a) 6 - r - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - , -
f
(b) 10 . , . . . . . - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ,
5 •
~
en 4
-
Experimental data MNLDFT fitted
8
ME
()
:;; 3 Q)
.c
~
"'C
2
eel
~1 c: eel
2
::J
o
0
1e-6 1e-5 1e-4 1e-3 1e-2 1e-1 1e+0 Relative pressure
0+--.,.----r------..LL1r----r---r--------l o 20 40 60 80 100 120 csf/k (K)
Figure 7.4 (a) The expe9mental data (points) of Fig. 7.3 fitted by Eqn (7.12) using the deconvolution method (solid line). (b) The adsorptive potential distribution for the Sterling graphite.
Chapter 7 The Surface Heterogeneity of Carbon and Its Assessment
(a) 40 - r - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - , 1 E " " " 1 (b) 40 - , - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ,
~ 0..
~ (f)
•
35 -
Experimental data DFTfitted
~ S
30
,£.
Q)
u
"0
~ 20
~ 20
o
::J CIJ
CIJ
~
«;
15
'E Q)
~
~
E ~
10
::J
o
30
co co ~
ME 25
10
(.)
E
5
o -+-------r::::y;.;...=..---r-----r-----r----.----f 1e-6
1e-5
1e-4
1e-3
1e-2
1e-1
1e+0
O-t----.,.---20 40
80
100
Relative pressure
Figure 7.5 (a) A comparison of experimental data for nitrogen adsorbed at 77 K on Vulcan 3-G(2700) (points) with the fit given by the modified nonlocal density functional theory (MNLDFT) models (line). (b) The adsorptive potential distribution for the Vulcan 3 graphite.
experimentally detected on the Vulcan surface. The area weighted mean value ofXsf / k is 56.1 K, and the total reported surface area is 80.78 m 2 I g. The surface area by BET is 73.5 m 2 /g.
7.4.2 Natural Graphites Natural graphites differ from those described above chiefly in their morphology. While equally crystalline, virtually all possible growth, cleavage, and fracture surfaces are present along with the extended basal surfaces. Interest in characterizing these materials has grown because of their importance in batteries for light-weight energy storage. The performance of a graphite anode in a lithium ion battery is known to be strongly related to the graphite's surface properties, in particular to the surface area and to the relative extent of basal plane and prismatic crystallite surfaces exposed to the electrolyte [20]. The presence of prismatic surface is necessary to allow the intercalation of the Li+ ion into the bulk of the graphite. In principle, therefore, graphites with a higher ratio of prismatic to basal surfaces should yield superior performance. We illustrate this in Fig. 7.6, (a) and (b). We see that the fine-grinding procedure has the expected result of increasing the total surface area, from 6.28 to 25.78 m 2 I g. In addition, the adsorptive potential distribution has been broadened. If we consider the central peak in these distributions, between say 50 to 60 K, to represent the graphite basal plane, we see that the fraction of basal plane has been reduced in the ground material, which indeed gives superior anode performance.
159
7.4 Results for "Nonporous" Carbons
KS75
(a)
Area =6.28 m2/g
20
(b)
40 60 80 Adsorptive potential (K)
100
120
KS75KM
6........----------------------. Area = 25.76 m2/g 5
O-+----~
o
20
40 60 80 Adsorptive potential (K)
100
120
Figure ].6 (a) The adsorptive potential distribution of a natural, low surface area graphite. (b) The same material after a fine-grinding procedure, showing a slightly broadened distribution and increased surface area.
7.4.3 Carbon Blacks An example of a much more heterogeneous surface is shown in Fig. 7.7. The adsorbent in this case is a carbon black designated C4, used by ASTM committee D24 as a reference reinforcing black. Again we see that the MNLDFT models provide an excellent fit to the adsorption data. The total surface area by the present method is 138.69 m 2 /g; the BET method gives 129.63 m 2 /g. The weighted mean value ofXsf/k is 53.61 K. The central mode of the distribution is seen to be somewhat lower than that for the graphites.
Chapter 7 The Surface Heterogeneity of Carbon and Its Assessment
160
(b) 12 - r - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ,
(a) 50 • -
Experimental data Fitted MNLDFT models
-
~
10
5
m
8
(ij (ij
'E Q) E Q)
~
6
4
2
0-+---r------,r-----r---r----,--~__1
1e-7 1e-6 1e-5 1e-4 1e-3 1e-2 1e-1
Relative pressure
1e+0
o -+-----r--
o
20
40
60
80
100
120
Adsorptive potential (K)
Figure 7-7 (a) A comparison of experimental data for nitrogen adsorbed at 77 K on ASTM carbon black C4 (points) with the fit given by the modified nonlocal density functional theory (MNLDFT) models (line). (b) The adsorptive potential distribution for the carbon black.
7.5
ACTIVATED CARBONS
The carbons discussed up to this point display a range of adsorptive potentials created chiefly by their surface roughness and chemistry; thus, their isotherms can be quite accurately modeled by a system of free, homogeneous surfaces of varying adsorptive potential. Their heterogeneity is then described by the area distribution of those potentials. Activated carbons cannot be energetically characterized by this method. These materials have a much more complex structure, providing many possible sources of energetic heterogeneity. As in developing any characterization method, one wishes to define and use the simplest model that yields reasonable and useful results.
7-5-1 Assumed Structure Activated carbons are usually visualized as an assemblage of graphitic planes arranged in a near-parallel fashion, thus creating a microporous solid having approximately slit-like pores of molecular dimensions. The resulting overlapping wall potentials produce greatly enhanced adsorptive potentials, so one may argue that the energetic heterogeneity of the material is to a large extent controlled by the distribution of its pore widths rather than the detailed nature of the pore walls themselves. Several current characterization methods are based on this simple model. However, within the slit pore structure, the pore walls may be of different and varying thickness, from a single carbon layer to essentially graphitic (more than five layers) and can also be of varying lateral extent. The graphene planes within a wall unit may have some crystalline stacking order, i.e., as in
161
7.5 Activated Carbons
hexagonal (aba ... ) or rhombohedral (abca ... ) graphite or may be completely turbostratic, with no discernable relationship. In addition, a wall unit may carry certain functional groups, typically containing oxygen, nitrogen, or sulfur, on its surface or especially at its periphery. Locally, a number of wall units may be ordered in a parallel fashion, creating a domain having a slit pore structure. At longer range, the orientation of these locally ordered domains is probably uncorrelated, leading to the possibility of interdomain pore spaces of indeterminate geometry and with perhaps a larger average width than that of the slit pores within the more ordered domains. In addition, it is by no means clear that such a structure is totally rigid. That is, it is possible that dilation and/or contraction of domains may occur as a result of the pressure tensors within the pore system [21, 22]. While still greatly simplified, the above picture leads to several sources of differing adsorptive potential. In estimated order of importance, these are as follows: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
The The The The The
distribution of pore widths distribution of wall potentials distribution of wall unit and domain size or area form and distribution of interdomain porosity quantity of functional groups
At the time of this writing, commercially available software includes only the first of these.
7.5.2 Example Applications of the Simple Model The commonly used DFT-based methods for characterizing activated carbon assume that the pores are geometrically slits with smooth, unterminated graphitic walls of constant wall potential. The experimental data are then modeled as a system of homogeneous, confined slits of varying width. The energetic heterogeneity of the material is therefore completely expressed in terms of its distribution of pore widths. The integral equation of isothermal adsorption, Eqn (7.12), for the case of pore-size distribution can be written as the convolution
Q(P)
=
f dH q(p, H)j(H)
(7.13)
where Q(P) is the total quantity of adsorbate per gram of adsorbent at pressure p, q(p, H), the kernel function, describes the adsorption isotherm for an ideally homoporous material characterized by pore width H as the quantity of adsorbate per square meter of pore surface, and j(H) is the desired pore surface area distribution function with respect to H. The kernel function is calculated by DFT for a confined fluid [10, 14, 15] and Eqn (7.13) solved by the methods already discussed.
Chapter 7 The Surface Heterogeneity of Carbon and Its Assessment
162
Isotherms for argon at 87 K adsorbed on typical activated carbons are shown in Figs 7.8 and 7.9, along with the reconstructed isotherm resulting from the pore width distributions shown. While the fit to the data is satisfactory in both cases, inspection of the pore width distributions obtained for these and many other activated carbon samples reveals a disturbing similarity: they all show deep minima at regular multiples of the probe molecule diameter, particularly near 1 nm (3xXo) [21,23]. This can be traced to packing effects inherent in the kernel function models that seem to be missing in the real data. Figure 7.10 shows how the pore fluid density as calculated by DFT varies with pore width, with density maxima near the pore width distribution minima. (a)
~
ICJ)
400
.
350 -
(b) 0.06 Experimental data DFTfitted
300
~ Q)
E 0.04
"'E 250 ~
:::I
(5
U
Q)
e0
>
200
~
co
as 150
'E 0.02 Q) E
~
as :::I 0
0.03
0 C.
UJ
u
~
~ 0.05
'"E
100
~ 0
E
50
0.01 0.00
0 1e-7 1e-6 1e-5 1e-41e-3 1e-21e-11e+0 1e+1
10 Pore width (A)
Relative pressure
100
Figure 7.8
(a) A comparison of experimental data for argon adsorbed at 87 K on Carbosieve G activated carbon (points) with the fit given by the nonlocal density functional theory (NLDFT) models (line). (b) The pore width distribution for the carbon. (a)
700
f
600
'"E
500
l-
en
. -
(b) Experimental data NLDFT fitted isotherm
"0 Q)
"0
E
Q)
0.05
:::I
(5
400
>
0.04
Q)
0a. co
300
'E Q) E Q) U
200
(tj
::::J
0
E
E
(tj
~
Ci ;;-- 0.06 ~
~
.c 0en
0.07
100
~
0 1e-71e-61e-5 1e-4 1e-3 1e-2 1e-1 1e+0 1e+1
Relative pressure
0.03 0.02 0.01 0.00 10
100
Pore width (A)
Figure 7.9 (a) A comparison of experimental data for argon adsorbed at 87 K on activated carbon RH572 (points) with the fit given by the nonlocal density functional theory (NLDFT) models (line). (b) The pore width distribution for the carbon.
7.5 Activated Carbons
0.040
M E ()
~--------------------,
0.038
..........
<5
E, ~
0.036
·00 c
CD "0 "0
0.034
·S ~
~
0
a.
0.032
0.030 100
10
Pore width (A)
Figure 7.10 The average pore fluid density in pores of various widths as calculated by nonlocal density functional theory (NLDFT). Note the periodic nature of the density, with density maxima near the positions of the minima in the distributions shown in Figs 7.8 (b) and 7.9(b).
7.5.3 Advanced Activated Carbon Models The simple model ofan activated carbon, pictured as a set of homogeneous graphitic planes arranged in a parallel fashion so as to form slit-like pores, needs to be developed further. From the above enumerated list of factors causing heterogeneity, the variation in wall potential is next in importance to variation in pore width. Remembering that the distribution of adsorptive potentials is totally reflected in the adsorption isotherm of a given material, we realize that a decrease in assumed average wall potential will result in a decrease in the deduced average pore width in order to compensate. With two distributed variables to contend with, one is faced with a choice of assuming a priori that the two variables are correlated in some fashion, or they are totally uncorrelated. Bhatia [24] has advanced convincing arguments that, in order to account for the observed surface areas, the pore wall units in an activated carbon must have thicknesses primarily in the range of one to three graphene planes, leading to significantly lower wall potentials than assumed in the simple model discussed above. The adsorptive potential of a wall unit composed of n graphene planes can be calculated by integrating Eqn (7.1) for the case of an adsorptive molecule and a set of graphene planes of infinite extent: (7.14) where ¢ft(z, n) is the potential acting on a single adsorptive molecule at distance z from the surface of a stack of n planes separated by a distance ~ for graphite. The quantity Ps is the area density of carbon atoms in the graphene sheet (0.382 A-i), (Tft for the LJ separation, and eft the LJ potential well depth. In Fig. 7.11,
Chapter 7 The Surface Heterogeneity of Carbon and Its Assessment
-5
(5
.§ ...,
---1Iayer ................... 2 layers - - - - - - 3 layers _ .. _ .. _ .. - 4 layers - - - Slayers
-6
~
ro E
-7
Q)
0c.. Q)
>
-8
a «
\'" \'" '"
\ ~....
.
.. ' .;::
..... ·~h ..' h r .
~".
-9
....,6;
......&~
....
\ ~\"
0 (/)
1:'
\'"
~""
~;;
;~.-<
~/.':
:"'o.. __ -:-_~ __ ..""".
-1 0 -+-----,-----'T""'"-----r------"T----r----~ 0.85 0.90 0.95 1.00 1.05 1.10 1.15
Relative distance from surface
Figure 7.11 The adsorptive potential between nitrogen and a pore wall of different thicknesses near the potential minimum as calculated by Eqn (7.14).
we show plots of Eqn (7.14) for values of n from 1 to 5. The effect of wall thickness on adsorptive potential is seen to be quite significant for less than four layers. At five layers, the wall acts like an infinitely thick slab. By assuming that the wall thickness is distributed randomly, following a Poisson distribution, and that the average wall thickness is correlated with pore width, Bhatia is able to solve Eqn (7.13) by the usual means without introducing new parameters. The results yield both a pore width distribution and a wall thickness distribution. Compared with the simple model, this method yields pore width distributions that are shifted toward smaller widths, as expected. However, the distributions are similarly multimodal, showing periodic minima notably near 1 nm pore width. A second advanced approach currently under development has been reported by Ustinov and Do [23]. These workers make no assumptions about possible correlations between wall thickness and pore size. Indeed, they assume that the pore wall adsorptive potentials are variable without assuming a specific source and have an energy distribution independent of pore width. The adsorption integral can then be written as a double convolution. The kernel function is first convolved over the distribution of pore wall energies, then over the pore width distribution to match the experimental data. The model isotherms for the range of energies and pore widths are calculated by DFT in the usual way. Surprisingly, the solution of the equation is a reasonably straightforward iterative task and not overly time-consuming on modern equipment. The first reports using this method are quite encouraging. The pore width distributions obtained are significantly less complex than given by the simple model, without the anomalous periodicity, and the fit to the data is notably supenor.
References
This model, however, implicitly assumes that the behavior of a locally heterogeneous pore can be modeled as the linear sum oflocally homogeneous pores of the same width having different wall potentials. This would seem to be justified only if the pore widths are small compared with the scale of the locally uniform patches or domains within a given pore. This would be expected to be the case in activated carbon micropores. However, the equation would not be applicable to mesopores, for instance, where the range of the local heterogeneity is small compared with the pore dimensions [25].
7.6
CONCLUSIONS
We have seen that carbon materials encompass a very wide range of energetic heterogeneity as expressed through the variation in adsorptive potential. When the material is essentially nonporous, it can be characterized in a straightforward fashion by the deconvolution of the appropriate adsorption integral with interaction energy as the distributed parameter. The complex structure of activated carbon requires a different approach. In this case, the geometric heterogeneity of the micropore structure is best expressed primarily in terms of the micropore size distribution, although this simplest model is not entirely free from artifacts in the calculated distribution. Recognition of the inherent heterogeneity of the pore wall unit itself has, in early work, shown hope ofproviding a major advance in characterizing activated carbon structures.
REFERENCES
1. Lennard-Jones, J.E. and Dent, B.N. (1928). Cohesion at a crystal surface. Trans. Faraday Soc., 24,92-107. 2. Sanford, C. and Ross, S. (1954). Homostatic surface: A suggested new word. J. Phys. Chern., 58, 288-8. 3. Ross, S. and Olivier, J.P. (1964). On Physical Adsorption. New York: Interscience. 4. Ross, S. and Olivier, J.P. (1961). On physical adsorption. 12. Adsorption isotherm and adsorptive energy distribution of solids. J. Phys. Chern., 65, 608-15. 5. Olivier, J.P. and Ross, S. (1962). On physical adsorption. 16. Physical interaction of H 2 , D 2 , CH 4 , and CD 4 with graphite. Proc. R. Soc. (London), 265A, 447-54. 6. Hill, T .L. (1949). Statistical mechanics of adsorption. 6. Localized unimolecular adsorption on a heterogeneous surface. J. Chern. Phys., 17, 762-71. 7. Ross, S. and Morrison J.D. (1975). Computed adsorptive-energy distribution in the monolayer (CAEDMON). Surf. Sci., 52, 103-19. 8. Morrison, J.D. and Ross, S. (1973). The second and third virial coefficients of a two-dimensional gas. Suif. Sci., 39, 21-36.
166
Chapter 7 The Surface Heterogeneity of Carbon and Its Assessment
9. Sacher, R. S. and Morrison, J.D. (1979). An improved CAEDMON program for the adsorption isotherms of heterogeneous substrates. J. Coil. Interface Sci., 70, 153-66. 10. Olivier, J. (1995). Modeling physical adsorption on porous and nonporous solids using density functional theory. J. Porous Mater., 2, 9-17. 11. Olivier, J. (1996). The determination of surface energetic heterogeneity using model isotherms calculated by density functional theory. In Proceedings of the Fifth International Conference on Fundamentals of Adsorption (M.D. LeVan, ed.). Boston: Kluwer Academic Publishers, pp. 699-707. 12. Seaton, N.A., Walton, J.P.R.B., and Quirke, N. (1989). A new analysis method for the determination of the pore size distribution of porous carbons from nitrogen adsorption measurements. Carbon, 27, 853-61. 13. Olivier, J.P., Conklin, W.B., and Szombathely, M.V. (1994). Determination of pore-size distribution from density-functional theory - A comparison of nitrogen and argon results. In Characterization of porous solids III (COPSIII), Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis, Vol. 87 O. Roquerol et aI., eds). Amsterdam: Elsevier, pp. 81-9. 14. Lastoskie, M., Gubbins, K.E., and Quirke, N. (1993). Pore size heterogeneity and the carbon slit pore: A density functional theory model. Langmuir, 9, 2693-702. 15. Lastoskie, C.M., Gubbins, K.E., and Quirke, N. (1993). Pore size distribution analysis of microporous carbons: a density functional theory approach. J. Phys. Chem., 97, 4786-96. 16. Tarazona, P. (1985). Free-energy density functional for hard-spheres. Phys. Rev. A, 31, 2672-9. 17. Tarazona, P., Marconi, U.M.B., and Evans, R. (1987). Phase-equilibria of fluid interfaces and confined fluids - nonlocal versus local density functionals. Mol. Phys., 60,573-95. 18. Lawson, C.L. and Hanson, RJ. (1974). Solving Least Squares Problems. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall. 19. Jaroniec, M., Kruk, M., Olivier, J.P., and Koch, S. (2000). A new method for the accurate pore size analysis ofMCM-41 and other silica based mesoporous materials. COPS V. In Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis 128 (K.K. Unger et aI., eds). Amsterdam: Elsevier, pp. 71-80. 20. Winter, M., Moeller, K.C., and Besenhard, J.O. (2003). Carbonaceous and graphitic anodes: basic aspects. In Science and Technology of Advanced Lithium Batteries (G.A. N azri and G. Pistoia, eds). New York: Kluwer Academic Publishers, Chapter 5, pp. 144-94. 21. Olivier,J.P. (1998). Improving the models used for calculating the size distribution of micropore volume ofactivated carbons from adsorption data. Carbon, 36, 1469-72. 22. Reichenauer, G. and Scherer, G.W. (2001). Effects upon nitrogen sorption analysis in xerogels. J. Coil. Interface Sci., 236, 385-6. 23. Ustinov, E.A. and Do, D.D. (2004). Application of density functional theory to analysis of energetic heterogeneity and pore size distribution of activated carbons. Langmuir, 20, 3791-7. 24. Bhatia, S.K. (2002). Density finctional theory analysis of the influence of pore wall heterogeneity on adsorption in carbons. Langmuir, 18, 6845-56. 25. Maddox, M.W. Olivier, J.P., and Gubbins, K.E. (1997). Characterization of MCM-41 using molecular simulation: heterogeneity effects. Langmuir, 13(6), 1737-45.
WETTING PHENOMENA William A. Steele Department of Chemistry, The Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA, USA
Contents 8.1 Introduction 8.2 Wetting on Carbon 8.3 Conclusions References
8.1
167 175 180 181
INTRODUCTION
The wetting of solid surfaces by liquids has been studied for many years, both theoretically and experimentally. Useful reviews of this work include those by de Gennes [1], Dietrich [2], Adamson (Chapters 10, 13, and 16 in [3]), and Sullivan and Telo de Gama [4]. Before beginning a discussion of this phenomenon in the case of vapors condensed onto solid carbons, it is helpful to summarize some general features of wetting. Thus, the characteristics of the wetting of solids by liquids will be briefly described in this introductory section, to be followed by a discussion of some of the experimental and simulation studies of vapors on carbon surfaces. The first point to note is that there are two distinctly different approaches to this problem: one, which will be called macroscopic, is based primarily on interpretations of the measured contact angles for a liquid droplet on a surface. The contact angle is generally defined as the angle between two lines, one tangent to the liquid surface and the other to the solid surface, meeting at the point where the droplet surface touches the solid. Observations of this angle are often interpreted using Young's equation [5] that relates the contact angle Ow to the surface tensions of the three phases involved, namely, Ylv' Yls' and Ysv' Adsorption by Carbons ISBN: 978-0-08-044464-2
© 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
167
168
Chapter 8 Wetting Phenomena
the surface tension at the liquid-vapor, the liquid-solid, and the solid-vapor interface, respectively. A calculation of the work for an infinitesimal increase of the liquid-solid contact area yields Young's equation: (8.1) Evidently, the two quantities that determine the contact angle are Yls - Ysv and Ylv. The physically relevant values of contact angles are limited by the fact that cos Ow must be less than 1 and greater than -1. A value of Ow = 0 corresponds to complete wetting of the surface by the liquid, i.e., to the situation where the droplet has spread into a thin layer covering the entire solid surface. The other limit of 180 corresponds to no wetting (=drying) , i.e., a droplet that has not spread at all and thus is in touch with the surface only at the point of contact between the nearly spherical liquid drop and the planar solid. If the surface tensions are such that the calculated cos Ow becomes greater than + 1, the system is said to undergo a wetting transition where the surface is completely wet for all calculated values of cos Ow > 1; on the other hand, if the calculated values of wetting angle become less than -1, a drying transition occurs. The surface tension to be substituted in Eqn. 8.1 consists of a liquid-vapor tension which has the usual value modified by the presence of significant gas-solid interactions for the molecules in a very thin layer of fluid (in contrast to that for the bulk liquid which is often used in the calculation of this quantity). The surface tensions involving the solid are more problematic. For instance, it is implied that the solid surface is planar and homogeneous in the derivation, which is frequently not the case for real surfaces of interest. 0
There are several complicating factors that tend to reduce the utility of this
macroscopic approach. First, one often finds that values of observed contact angles depend upon whether the droplet is spreading or contracting, which indicates that the system is not in thermodynamic equilibrium as is implicit in the derivation of Young's equation. Second, most solids have rough or nonplanar surfaces especially in pores or powders, or the surfaces may be chemically heterogeneous. Both these factors complicate the calculation of contact angle from Young's equation. However, statistical mechanical expressions for the elements of the pressure tensor Pxx ' Pyy, and Pzz are well known (chapter 3 in [6], Section 4d in [7], [8]). Here x and yare taken to be parallel to the surface and z is perpendicular to the surface. Since Pzz does not depend upon z, it is essentially the vapor pressure of the spreading liquid. However, P xx and Pyy are dependent upon z and approach Pzz at large distances from the surface. An integration of (Pxx + Pyy )j2 - Pzz over x, y, and z will give the area times the surface tension of the gas-liquid interface. The theoretical expressions for the pressure tensor give the explicit relationship between the molecular interactions and the computed (or measured) surface tensions. The interactions involved are those for the molecules in the fluid near the surface interacting with each other (gasgas energies) and with the underlying solid (gas-solid energies). This approach to surface tension usually involves computer simulations to obtain the pressure tensor and from them the values of the surface tension of the liquid adsorbate.
8.1 Introduction
1.0 ....-------------------.---~
,
,,
~
, '" ,, "
0.5
G;"
en 0
0.0 1.0
u
c;
3.0
__..I
~
_
-
"
"
..a.-
"
-1.0
"
-0.5
Figure 8.1 Cosines ofthe contact angles for a Lennard-Jones (LJ) fluid on a graphitic surface
e:,
are plotted versus the ratio of the gas-solid interaction well depth to the gas-gas well depth. The fluid-solid interaction was evaluated using a simplified interaction potential and the resulting curves are shown for two values of the reduced temperature T= kT/ egg. The dashed parts of the curves are estimates reflecting the fact that unreasonably long simulation runs were required to obtain reliable results in this region. At the upper and lower boundaries of the figure, the slopes of the curves change discontinuously to zero, corresponding to complete wetting (for increasing along the upper boundary) or complete drying (for along the lower boundary). decreasing
e:,
e:,
Such simulations also allow one to evaluate the adsorption isotherm for a given set of molecular interactions so that the simulation of wetting behavior via the adsorption isotherm is related to the contact angle through simulation of the elements of the pressure tensor. Figure 8.1 shows simulated contact angles [9] for a fluid with LennardJones (LJ) gas-gas interactions interacting with a 9-3 wall (a simplified version of the gas-solid potential for a graphitic solid) with repulsive and attractive interactions varying as Z-9 and Z-3, respectively, where z is the fluid atom-solid surface distance). The contact angles were evaluated for several temperatures and potential functions by substituting simulated surface tensions into Young's equation. The figure shows the angles obtained for two temperatures (T* = kTj egg) as a function of the energy well-depth ratio e: defined above. The curves shown all have discontinuous changes in slope (to zero) at the limits of + 1 and -1. This is associated with a first-order transition from partial wetting to either complete wetting of the wall-fluid interface when the calculated values of cos (J become greater than +1, or complete drying when the value becomes less than -1. Evidently, the intermediate values of cos (J shown in the figure correspond to partial wetting as a function of the energy ratio
e:.
Chapter 8 Wetting Phenomena
170
An alternative theoretical approach to the evaluation ofthe solid-liquid surface tension which is particularly useful at low pressure and coverage is based on an integration of the Gibbs adsorption equation (Eqn 2.60 in [7]) that can be written as (8.2) where na is the number of moles adsorbed, A is the area, and Pb and Pb are the density and pressure of the bulk gas, respectively. As will be discussed below, this expression is particularly useful for calculations of the solid-fluid surface tension denoted here by y. For example, suppose the coverage is small enough for Henry's law to be valid. Then the coverage na will be given by (8.3) If the surface coverage is small enough for Eqn 8.3 to be valid, an integration of Eqn 8.2 gives RTP K
H y = - - -b - -
(8.4)
A
In Fig. 8.2, the points are the results obtained by evaluating the transverse component of the pressure tensor obtained from Monte Carlo simulation and the line is the result of an integration of the Gibbs adsorption isotherm using the simulation data. The vertical dashed line shows the saturation vapor pressure.
0.5
0.4
0.3
-'"'/ 0.2
0.1
0.0 0
10
5
15x 10-3
p*
Figure 8.2 Solid-fluid surface tension y* = ya 2 / e for the Ar-C0 2 system [10] at kT/ e = 0.88, where e and a are the Ar-Ar well-depth and size parameters for a LennardJones (LJ) potential (elk = 120 a = 3.4 A) plotted as a function of the reduced pressure 0
,
3
p* = pa Ie.
17 1
8.1 Introduction
14
12 10 8 6
Nonwetting Partial wetting Wetting Prewetting Monolayer
._...-+...._.
4
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
Figure 8.3 Isotherms are shown for the types of adsorption that can occur for simple gases on a flat homogeneous adsorbent surface. With the exception of the prewetting isotherm, the nature of the interactions that produce these isotherms is discussed in the text.
Clearly, any isotherm equation that gives a good representation of na as a function of Pb can be used in the Gibbs equation to evaluate the solid-fluid surface tension as a function of coverage. In the so-called microscopic approach, one obtains wetting properties from the adsorption isotherms for a vapor on a solid. Here we show how the isotherms can vary from drying to wetting as the interaction potentials are changed. These isotherms show coverage () = na / nmono as a function of x = PI Po, where na is the number of moles adsorbed, nmono the number of moles in a monolayer, and Po the bulk vapor pressure at a fixed T. Figure 8.3 shows the following: (i) For very weak interactions, the adsorbed phase is essentially a twodimensional ideal gas; thus, a plot of () versus x will be linear with a small slope given by the Henry's law. The theoretical expression for K H is well known:
KH = _1 kT
f
[exp( -us(z)/kT) -l]dz
(8.5)
where z is distance from the surface and us(z) is the gas-solid interaction for a flat homogeneous surface. If na remains small for pressures over the entire range up to the condensation pressure Po, gas-gas interactions have a negligible effect on the isotherm so that one has a "drying" system. (ii) When the attractive gas-gas interactions become strong enough to significantly affect the isotherm, it takes on the characteristics of what is known
172
Chapter 8 Wetting Phenomena
as "partial wetting." In this case, the isotherm is moderately curved upward to lie above the Henry's law straight line and intersects the PI Po = 1 line at a moderately small coverage. The virial isotherm equation (p. 107 in [6]) is one way to introduce the effect of (weak) gas-gas interactions. Thus, it gives the isotherm that was used to construct the curve shown in Fig. 8.3. Partial wetting isotherms are known as Type VI or Type VII in the usual classification scheme (p. 534 in [3]). (Although calculations of the contact angles associated with such isotherms do not appear to have been performed in sufficient detail to fill in the quantitative aspects of this picture, there seems to be no great difficulty in making such calculations, at least for simple model surfaces.) (iii) A "wetting" isotherm that shows the usual "knee" at the completion of the monolayer plus a steep increase as PI Po approaches unity is also shown. (It is known as a Type II isotherm (p. 534 in [3]).) Gas-solid interaction energies that are strong compared to the experimental value of kT lead to steep rises in the amount adsorbed at submonolayer coverages. As is well known, when the amount adsorbed approaches monolayer coverage, the effect of the repulsive gas-gas interactions at high 2D densities is to make the isotherm flatten out and thus produce the knee. (iv) An isotherm that exhibits the thin-to-thick vertical jump known as a "prewetting" transition is also shown [11, 12]. In common with the wetting isotherm, the prewetting isotherm also shows a steep increase as PI Po approaches unity. An extensive literature exists that deals with questions concerning changes in wetting behavior with changing temperature [13-22]. For example, what is the order of the thermodynamic transition from partial to complete wetting or drying that take place at various values of T? Theory indicates that these transitions are indeed first order below a wetting critical temperature T we. Figure 8.4 is a temperature-density phase diagram for a system made up of a gas plus fluid in contact with a uniform solid surface [13, 23]. Drying, wetting, and prewetting lines as well as the wetting critical temperature (denoted by T e in this figure) are all shown. In addition to the computer simulations of the wetting of atomic adsorbates on simple, planar homogeneous surfaces [10, 24-32], the theory of wetting on heterogeneous [33-39] surfaces has been considered. In particular, Cassie's law [33] was proposed over 50 years ago to deal with planar surfaces that consist of patches of chemically heterogeneous surface. This law was obtained from the simple assumption that the surface excess free energy is the sum of distinct contributions for each of the chemically different regions. Swain and Lipowsky [34] and Henderson [35] have derived a statistical generalization of this law and the deviations from it because of the dependence of the local surface tension upon position or shape of the boundary. Frink and Salinger [36] have presented a numerically more complex theory of this problem and have calculated both contact angles and surface-phase transitions for chemically heterogeneous surfaces. Computer simulations [37-39] were carried out for gases adsorbed on surfaces
173
8.1 Introduction
T
p
Figure 8.4 Schematic phase diagram for an adsorption system exhibiting prewetting. The solid curve shows the coexistence of gas and liquid phases in contact with the surface and is nearly the same as the curve for the bulk material, somewhat modified because of the effects of the gas-solid interactions upon the adsorbate phases. The adsorbate gas-liquid critical temperature (denoted by T c in this figure) depends upon the gas-solid potential but is not very different from that for the bulk. (A simulated value of 0.94 was obtained for a truncated LJ 12-6 potential [23], compared with the bulk T c: of1.23 for the same model.) The dashed curve is the prewetting line where thin and thick films can coexist and Tic is the prewetting critical temperature where the difference between thick and thin films vanishes.
of slit pores with walls consisting of alternating strongly and weakly interacting strips. A few of the results are shown in Fig. 8.5 where reduced units were used so that dimensionless energies and distances were defined by dividing by Egg and reduced distances by (Tgg' where gg denoted well depth and size parameters for the LJ fluid adsorbate. In some cases, liquid bridges were formed by stratified liquid stabilized by the strong strips. Figure 8.5 shows local densities p(x, z) obtained for surfaces made up of parallel strips separated by reduced distances sz/ {Tgg. The fluid-solid energies of adsorbate atoms were given by sums over the solid of 12-6 pair energies with parameters that made surfaces with strips of alternating strongly and weakly attractive solid atoms. For kT/ B gg = 1, the figure shows strong alternations in density with the weakly attracting surface showing negligible adsorption over much of its area, and moderate adsorption in the form of molecular strata between the strong strips at the smaller strip separations. Phase diagrams were obtained for some of these model systems and compared favorably with those for a mean-field lattice.gas model. [40, 41]. Thus, these systems can exhibit wetting that is very different from that described earlier. Other theoretical work on this problem is that of Henderson [42], who considered the properties of a fluid adsorbed in a parallel-walled pore with grooved walls; Bryk et al. [43] simulated a gas adsorbed on a number of rough surfaces created by placing a disordered quenched layer of hard spheres on a substrate interacting with the adsorbed atoms via a LJ 9-3 potential. Simulations showed that the system exhibits wetting, prewetting, and partial wetting for
I
I I I I I I I
ena Phenom Wetting 8 r te p a Ch
I I I I I
I I I I I I I I I I I
-6
I I
I I I I I I I I I
3.5
I I I
I I I I I I I I I I I
2
-6
I I
I I I I I I I I I I
3.5
-3 .5
I I
I I I I I I I
3
I I I I
-6
2
I I
N
I I I I I I
x'"
~
I I I
a rbed o n as a d s o s g a h J) t a (L Sz th ones nnard-J are d e n o te d b y e L (c) a r ips d fo simulate ons b e tw e e n str c e d units. p (x , z) u ti d s ra e a ie r p it e s in s n it h Sz . The cal de 8.5 Lo striped surface 7.2, 7.5, 8.2, w ulation ally n, of l chemic o t h e r sim n the to p d o w n e A th . r m e o r lay ed o alues, f r ] is bas gh o u t e a -4
4
lly r o u ces [44 ace o f atomica us surfa the (100) surf order o e e n th e f g o o r ickness o n hete atoms o n o r i n d to be a first- by easing th i n g properties t n bed eare e b r o ads ett h a t app y p e r t u r toms f w tl w o h f g e o n v li o s a y g ti d a ly le ulations n o r de t was on ns (one o r t w o r o d u c t i o l solid. T h e sim erfect solid tha o ti c e f r sta impe e p rfect cry ansition for th ncentration o f tr o c g r e w e t t i n c t i o n o f a small du h e i n t r o u n i t cell). surface
I I I
I I I I I I I I I I I I
I I I I I I I I I I I I I
I I I
175
8.2 Wetting on Carbon
8.2
WETTING ON (ARBON
The various forms of solid carbon provide an important group of adsorbents for wetting studies. They can be graphitized to exhibit chemically and physically homogeneous surfaces that are characterized by relatively strong gassolid interactions for nonpolar adsorbates such as the rare gases. To illustrate some of these ideas, Table 8.1 summarizes the well depths of the gas-graphite interaction potential for most of the rare gases on graphite. Here, 8 gs is the well depth for an isolated gas-atom interacting with the solid, 8 gg is the well depth is the ratio of the two well depths, for gas atoms with LJ pairwise interactions, and Ter is the rare gas critical temperature, shown here to indicate the temperature range in which one might study wetting behavior of these systems. Note that the values of gas-gas well depths shown here are for the effective interaction of a pair of atoms in the dense liquid phase and differ somewhat from those obtained from second virial coefficients measured in the gas. The well depths (in energy units divided by the Boltzmann constant) have been obtained from the experimental Henry's law constants for these adsorption systems. A comparison of the energy ratios in Table 8.1 for the rare gas-graphite systems with the data of Fig. 8.1 illustrates the fact that all these gases can wet the graphite surface. The experiments that established this are those of Thomy, Duval, and coworkers, published over 30 years ago. [47-49], for krypton, xenon, and methane (among others) adsorbed on exfoliated graphite. Roughly 20 years later, Morrison and coworkers [50, 51] extended these studies by measuring isotherms to considerably higher coverages and over a range of (low) temperatures for Kr, Xe, and CH 4 and showed that the complete wetting behavior indicated in the earlier work actually appears to be partial wetting when the range of coverage of the measurements is sufficiently extended. Plots of the isotherm data given
8:
Table 8.1 Well depths of the gas-graphite interaction potential for rare gases on graphite -
,
.;;)
Neon Argon Krypton Xenon
;~ 340 959 1255 1932c
0: /
,-
C"
34 120 160 221
-
-
cr t
v
_
l:S¥
--
44.5 157 209 290
10 8 8
9
aThese values were obtained by fitting experimental Henry's law constants to the theoretical expression for potentials obtained by assuming that the gas-solid interaction energy is given by a pairwise sum over the carbon atoms of LennardJones (LJ) inverse 12-6 functions of separation distance [45]. bFrom fits of experimental liquid state data to simulations of the LJ liquid [46]. CCorrected value.
Chapter 8 Wetting Phenomena
---r-----r----..,..-----r-----....--
25,...----......
~
Ii
,
N 15 E .......... <5 E
~
•
70K + 75K )( 80 • vap70K - vap 75 K ---._vap 80 K •._.•.•..
20
-+
Ii .i
~
•
~
.sas
j(
c:: 10
~
J
1+ +1.
.l
!
• i; ! I
~ )C)q
I
)(
+ +
5
. •
i
x
)(
)(
)/C
x·
•
)(
•
xX
•
•
•
•
0 0
0.5
1.5
2
2.5
3
Pressure (torr)
Figure 8.6 Experimental isotherm data for Kr at three temperatures on graphitized carbon black.
in Ref [50] for Kr at three temperatures are shown in Fig. 8.6 and indicate partial wetting. The coverages at which these Kr isotherms meet the bulk vapor pressure lines are estimated to be 9.2 ± 0.3 (70K), 11.6 ± 0.3 (75K), and 17.3 ± 0.5 (80 K), in units of micromoles per square meter. Denoting coverages by na , the authors fitted the results for all three gases at several temperatures to an equation of the form (8.6) where k is an arbitrary constant and Tw is the temperature for wetting-partial wetting. The analysis gives Tw/Tcr = 0.40 for each gas, where T cr is the bulk critical temperature. This result might lead one to guess that the films are sufficiently thick (over five layers) at the transition to partial wetting to give properties that are no longer sensitive to the gas-solid interactions. In contrast to the strong interactions and consequent wetting often observed for nonpolar gases on graphite, the nonchemical interactions of these gases with metals can be quite weak compared with their gas-gas interactions. For example, calculations of the ratios of the gas-solid to the gas-gas well depth for the inert gases and hydrogen on alkali metals give values that are much smaller than those summarized in Table 8.1, varying from 2.0 to 0.9 as the metal atomic number increases [52]. Clearly, the wetting properties of these systems will differ considerably from those for the rare gases on graphite. Polar gases on graphite will be nonwetting if the dipolar interactions in the adsorbed phase are sufficiently strong. Water on graphitized carbon black is a
177
8.2 Wetting on Carbon
well-known example because the water dipoles make quite small contributions to the water-graphite interaction compared to the dipolar (i.e., H-bond) part of the fluid energy. Similar considerations may apply to other dipolar molecules. Consequently, the experimentalist must take great care to exclude partial oxidation of the substrate that gives rise to polar centers near the points of oxidation. (A few of the large number of papers reporting experiments on these systems are cited in Refs. [53-63].) Such sites will interact strongly with polar adsorbates to form clumps of polar adsorbed molecules in the vicinity of the imperfections on or in the adsorbent surface. (Nitrogen also appears to interact strongly with polar sites on carbon surfaces, probably due to the interaction of its quadrupole moment with the electrostatic fields associated with polar imperfections.) It is believed that adsorbed clumps will serve as nuclei for droplet formation, thus facilitating wetting. The picture presented here would lead to the conclusion will produce quite that inclusion of strongly polar gas-gas interactions in small values of this parameter for such gases on highly purified graphite, which is thus a rationale for their nonwetting behavior. The dipole moment JL and polarizability a (a major factor in determining attractive part of the "van der Waals" energy) are summarized in Table 8.2 for a few simple molecules; these polarizabilities can be compared with the values shown for a couple of nonpolar molecules. In addition to isotherm measurements, other experimental probes used in the studies cited here include determinations of the coverage dependence of the heats of adsorption on carbon, particularly for water. For example, a microcalorimetric study [55] of the heats of adsorption of water on several chemically modified high-surface-area carbons found some heats greater than 50 kJ/mole (compared to 44 kJ/mole for the condensation of pure water) the large heats were ascribed to chemical adsorption and are most likely due to the reaction of water with strongly polar groups on the carbon surfaces; as the adsorption proceeded, heats were observed that were roughly equal to the water heat of condensation, and finally heats less than 42 k]/mole that presumably
e:
Table 8.2 Selected dipole moments and polarizabilities a
HF H 20 NH3
CH 3 0H C 2 H s OH CH 3 Cl Ar
N2 a Polarizabilities
1.91 1.85 1.47 1.71 1.69 1.71
o o
2.46 1.48 2.22 3.23
5.10 4.53
1.66 1.76
for nonspherical molecules are averages over the three principal axes.
Chapter 8 Wetting Phenomena
came from physical adsorption on the relatively nonpolar hydrophobic parts of the surfaces. When these carbons were reacted with H 2 at 950°C, the heats of water adsorption were small enough to indicate hydrophobicity; subsequent oxidation at 150°C showed significant increases in the amount adsorbed and the heat of adsorption of water on the surfaces. In a different study [57], ozone treatment of graphite produced dramatic increases of the heats of adsorption of water, thus changing the surface from hydrophobic to hydrophilic. Although water-water interaction potentials are well understood by now, the molecular water-graphite interaction potential remains the subject of extensive studies. Reviews of previous work on this problem have been published by Werder et al. [64] and by Pertsin and and Grunze [65] in conjunction with their theoretical-simulational paper. A considerable number of simulation studies of water on carbon surfaces and in carbon pores have been reported. The conclusions reached were primarily that the thermodynamics and structure of water-graphite system are extremely sensitive to the range and orientation dependence of the water-graphite interaction potential. In fact, the adsorbed water molecules in the monolayer are found to be highly oriented, even when using orientation-independent water-graphite potential models. This orientation dependence is ascribed to the tendency of the water molecules to maximize the H-bonding to their neighbors in the adsorbed film by minimizing the number of H-bonds oriented toward the graphite surface. Much work in the theoreticalsimulational area remains to be done on this system (particularly, simulations over an extended temperature range are needed). Jaffe et al. [66] have summarized the calculations of the contact angle for nanometer-scale droplets of water on graphite using various model potentials for the water-graphite interaction. It was noted that experimental measurements of this angle [67, 68] are not all in agreement, but it was concluded that values of 85° ± 2° and 42° ± 7° are reasonable. The simulations are for nanometer-size droplets and thus are not fully compatible with the experiments. Simulated values obtained run from 0° to 111 °C but Jaffe et al. list five water-graphite potentials that yield simulated contact angles close to their recommended value of85-89°. The simulations also give angle-averaged minimum interaction energies in the range -5.8 to -7.0 kJ/mole for isolated water molecules on graphite. In simulations of the watergraphite or water-carbon pore systems [64-66, 70-75], it is straightforward to evaluate the average number of H-bonds per water as a function of separation distance between the water and the solid surface. For instance, Walther et al. [71] find that the average number of bonds per molecule in the contact layer is 3.1 and 3.5 for the adsorption in pure water, and Shevade et al. [75] obtained results of 2.9 and 3.7 for the water in a 50:50 mixture of water and methanol. Other simple polar molecules (see Table 8.2) whose adsorption on graphite has been studied include ammonia [76-80], methanol [81, 82], and ethanol [81, 83-85]. An interesting difference between water and the alcohols is that the dipolar bonding (H-bond) network is three dimensional in bulk water but two dimensional in the alcohols where linear chains are formed. It appears that this network is disrupted in monolayer films of water, but not of the alcohols. This
8.2 Wetting on Carbon
179
is one of the reasons for the difficulty of water wetting on graphite, but its ease for the alcohols. The interactions of methanol and ethanol with active carbons having varying degrees of oxidation have been studied by Stoekli and coworkers [81]. They showed that measured energies of interaction were larger for ethanol than methanol, and that the energies increased linearly for both molecules as the oxygen content of the solid adsorbent increased, similar to water adsorption. Thus, both the hydrocarbon parts of the alcohols and their dipoles make important contributions to their interaction with partially oxidized carbon adsorbents. The temperature dependence of the isotherms of ammonia on graphite has been carefully studied in conjunction with neutron diffraction measurements [76]. Figure 8.7 shows that this system exhibits several types of behavior ranging from partial wetting at the two lowest temperatures studied, to what may be prewetting at the three intermed