CHAIVER
1
DNA Sequencing Hugh G. Grifin
and Annette M. Grifin
1. Introduction Methods to determine the sequenceof D...
70 downloads
1375 Views
21MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
CHAIVER
1
DNA Sequencing Hugh G. Grifin
and Annette M. Grifin
1. Introduction Methods to determine the sequenceof DNA were developed in the late 1970s (1,2) and have revolutionized the science of molecular genetics. The DNA sequences of many different genes from diverse sources have been determined, and the information is stored in international databanks such as EMBL, GenBank, and DDBJ. Many scientists now accept that sequence analysis will provide an increasingly useful approach to the characterization of biological systems. Projects are already underway to map and sequencethe entire genome of organisms such as Escherichia coli, Saccharomyces cerevisiae, Caenorhabditis elegans, and Homo sapiens. In the recent past, large-scale sequencing projects such as these were often dismissed as prohibitively expensive and of little short-term benefit, while DNA sequencing itself was seen as a repetitive and unintellectual pursuit. However, this view is now changing and most scientists recognize the importance of DNA sequence data and perceive DNA sequencing as a valuable and often indispensable aspect of their work. Recent technological advances, especially in the area of automated sequencing, have removed much of the drudgery that used to be associated with the technique, and modern innovative computer software has greatly simplified the analysis and manipulation of sequence data. Large-scale sequencing From Methods m Molecular Biology, Vol. 23. DNA Sequencmg Protocols Edited by. H. and A. Gnffm Copyright Q1993 Humana Press Inc., Totowa,
1
NJ
2
Griffin
and Griffin
projects, such as the Human Genome Project, produce the DNA sequences of many unknown genes. Such data provide an impetus for molecular biologists to apply the techniques of reverse genetics to produce probes and antibodies that can be used to identify the gene product, its cellular location, and its time of appearancein the developing cell (3). A function can be assigned by mutant analysis or by comparison of the deduced amino acid sequence with proteins of known function. Therefore, DNA sequencing can act as a catalyst to stimulate future research into many diverse areas of science. The two original methods of DNA sequencingdescribed in 1977 (1,2) differ considerably in principle. The enzymatic (or dideoxy chain termination) method of Sanger (I) involves the synthesis of a DNA strand from a single-stranded template by a DNA polymerase. The Maxam and Gilbert (or chemical degradation) method (2) involves chemical degradation of the original DNA. Both methods producepopulations of radioactively labeled polynucleotides that begin from a fixed point and terminate at points dependent on the location of a particular base in the original DNA strand. The polynucleotides are separated by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, and the order of nucleotides in the original DNA can be read directly from an autoradiograph of the gel (4). Although both techniques are still used today, there have been many changes and improvements to the original methods. While the chemical degradation method is still in use, the enzymatic chain termination method is by far the most popular and widely used technique for sequence determination. This process has been automated by utilizing fluorescent labeling instead of radioactive labeling (Chapters 33-37), and the concepts of polymerase chain reaction (PCR) technology have been harnessed to enable the sequencing reaction to be “cycled” (Chapters 21, 26, and 34). Other recent innovations include multiplexing (Chapter 28), sequencing by chemiluminescence rather than radioactivity (Chapter 29), solid phasesequencing (Chapter 25), and the use of robotic work stations to automate sample preparation and sequencing reactions (Chapter 38). 2. Maxam and Gilbert Method In the original Maxam and Gilbert method (2) a fragment of DNA is radiolabeled at one end and then partially cleaved in four different chemical reactions, each of which is specific for a particular base or
DNA Sequencing
3
type of base. This results in four populations of labeled polynucleotides. Each radiolabeled molecule extends from a fixed point (the radiolabeled end) to the site of chemical cleavage, which is determined by the DNA sequence of the original fragment. Since the cleavage is only partial, each population consists of a mixture of molecules, the lengths of which are determined by the base composition of the original DNA fragment. The four reactions are electrophoresed in adjacent lanes through a polyacrylamide gel. The DNA sequence can then be determined directly from an autoradiograph of the gel. The original method has been improved over the years (5). Additional chemical cleavage reactions have been devised (6), new end-labeling techniques developed (7,8), and shorter, simplified protocols have been produced (Chapter 32). The main advantage of chemical degradation sequencing is that sequence is obtained from the original DNA molecule and not from an enzymatic copy. It is therefore possible to analyze DNA modifications such as methylation, and to study protein/DNA interactions. Chemical sequencing also enables the determination of the DNA sequence of synthetic oligonucleotides. However, the Sanger method is both quicker and easier to perform and must remain the method of choice for most sequencing applications. 3, Sanger Method The Sanger (or chain termination) method (I) involves the synthesis of a DNA strand from a single-stranded template by a DNA polymerase. The method depends on the fact that dideoxynucleotides (ddNTPs) are incorporated into the growing strand in the same way as the conventional deoxynucleotides (dNTPs). However, ddNTPs differ from dNTPs becausethey lack the 3’-OH group necessaryfor chain elongation. When a ddNTP is incorporated into the new strand, the absence of the hydroxyl group prevents formation of a phosphodiester bond with the succeeding dNTP and chain elongation terminates at that position. By using the correct ratio of the four conventional dNTPs and one of the four ddNTPs in a reaction with DNA polymerase, a population of polynucleotide chains of varying lengths is produced. Synthesis is initiated at the position where an oligonucleotide primer anneals to the template, and each chain is terminated at a specific base (either A, C, G, or T depending on which ddNTP was used). By using the four different ddNTPs in four separate reactions the com-
4
Griffin
and Griffin
plete sequence information can be obtained. One of the dNTPs is usually radioactively labeled so that the information gained by electrophoresing the four reactions in adjacent tracks of a polyacrylamide gel can be visualized on an autoradiograph. The original method used the Klenow fragment of DNA polymerase I to synthesize the new strands in the sequencing reactions, and this enzyme is still used today (Chapter 12). Other enzymes such as Sequenase (Chapter 14), T7 polymerase (Chapter 13), and Taq polymerase (Chapter 15) are also widely used. Each enzyme has its own particular properties and qualities, and the choice of polymerase will depend on the type of template and the sequencing strategy employed. 4. Templates
for DNA Sequencing
The polymerase reaction requires single-stranded template. This is usually achieved by utilizing Ml3 phage that can produce large amounts of just one strand of DNA as part of its normal replicative cycle. Double stranded (replicative form) Ml3 can also be isolated, and this is used to clone the DNA fragment to be sequenced. The qualrty of DNA sequencedata achieved using Ml3 template is extremely good and many researchers prefer to subclone to Ml3 prior to sequencing. Sequencing reactions can be performed directly on plasmid DNA, the double stranded molecule being denatured prior to sequencing. Recent innovations in DNA purification techniques and the availability of improved polymerases have greatly enhanced the quality of data produced by plasmid sequencing methods (Chapters 14, 18, and 19). Sequence determination can also be performed directly on cosmid clones (Chapter 21), lambda clones (Chapter 20), and on PCR products (Chapters23-25). In particular, the adventof cycle sequencing(Chapter 26) has vastly increased the range of templates that can be used. 5. Sequencing
Strategies
A lot of sequencing performed is confirmatory sequencing to check the orientation or the structure of newly constructed plasmids, or to determine the sequence of mutants. This type of sequencing can be easily achieved by subcloning a restriction fragment into Ml3 and sequencing using the universal primer. Alternatively, a custom-designed oligonucleotide primer can be synthesized and sequencing performed without the need for any subcloning.
DNA Sequencing
5
The determination of long tracts of unknown sequence, however, requires careful planning and the utilization of one of a variety of strategies including: the shotgun approach, directed sequencing strategies, and the gene walking technique. A random, or shotgun, approach involves subcloning random fragments of the target DNA to an appropriate vector such as Ml3 (Chapter 7). Sequencesfrom these recombinants are determined at random until the individual readings can be assembled into a contiguous sequence. This is achieved using a sequence assembly computer program (9,lO). The disadvantage of this method is the redundancy in the sequence data obtained, each section of DNA being sequenced several times over. However, the strategy benefits from making no prior assumptions about the DNA to be sequenced, such as base composition or the presence of certain restriction sites. Directed strategies usually involve the construction of a nested set of deletions of the fragment to be sequenced. Progressive deletions of the fragment are generatedwith a nuclease,eachdeletion being approximately 200-300 bp. Following deletion the fragments are recloned into Ml3 or a plasmid vector adjacent to the universal primer site. The subclones are then sequenced in order of size, with the sequence of each clone overlapping slightly with the one before. In this way, a large tract of contiguous sequenceis determined on one gel. The disadvantage is the labor and time involved in constructing the deletions. Several methods are available for deletion construction including the use of exonuclease III (Chapter 8), T4 DNA polymerase (Chapter 9), and DNase I (Chapter 10). It is essential to sequence both strands of the DNA and this usually entails generating two sets of deletions. Perhaps the simplest method of sequencing is the gene walking technique (Chapter 11). This involves the initial sequencing of approximately 200-400 bp of the end of a cloned fragment using the universal primer (the sequence of the other end can be achieved with the reverse primer). This sequence information is then used to design a new oligonucleotide primer, which will provide the sequence of the next 200-400 bp, and so on across the entire length of the insert. This method is the least labor intensive because no deletion construction or generation of random clones is necessary, and template DNA can be made in the one batch since the template is the same for all sequencing reactions. However, the delay involved in synthesizing a new oli-
Griffin
and Griffin
gonucleotide primer before the next reaction can be performed may considerably prolong the time taken to sequence a long tract of DNA. The cost of oligonucleotide synthesis may also be prohibitive. 6. Automation
in DNA Sequencing
One of the major advances in sequencing technology in recent years is the development of automated DNA sequencers. These are based on the chain termination method and utilize fluorescent rather than radioactive labels. The fluorescent dyes can be attached to the sequencing primer, to the dNTPs, or to the terminators, and are incorporated into the DNA chain during the strand synthesis reaction mediated by a DNA polymerase (e.g., Klenow fragment of DNA polymerase I, Sequenase, or Taq DNA polymerase). During the electrophoresis of the newly generated DNA fragments on a polyacrylamide gel a laser beam excites the fluorescent dyes. The emitted fluorescence is collected by detectors and the information analyzed by computer. The data are automatically converted to nucleotide sequence. Several such instruments are now commercially available and are becoming increasingly popular (11; Chapters 33-37). Other aspects of the sequencing procedure that are being automated include template preparation and purification, and the sequencing reactions themselves. Robotic workstations are currently being developed to perform these tasks (Chapter 38). 7. Cycle Sequencing Cycle sequencing is a new and innovative approach to dideoxy sequencing. Its advantages over conventional sequencing techniques are that the reactions are simpler to set up, less template is required, the quality and purity of template are not as critical, and virtually any single- or double-stranded DNA can be sequenced (including lambda, cosmid, plasmid, phagemid, M13, and PCR product). In this method, a single primer is used to linearly amplify a region of template DNA using Taq polymerase in the presence of a mixture of dNTPs and a ddNTP. Either radioactive or fluorescent labels can be used, making cycle sequencing technology as relevant to automated processes as it is to manual methods (Chapters 26, 34-36). As in conventional dideoxy sequencing methods, cycle sequencing involves the generation of a new DNA strand from a single-stranded
DNA Sequencing template, synthesis commencing at the site of an annealed primer, and terminating on the incorporation of a ddNTP. The difference is that the reaction occurs not just once but 20-30 times under the control of a thermal cycler (or PCR machine). This results in more and better sequence data from less template. The process of denaturing a doublestranded molecule is eliminated, with denaturation occurring automatically in the thermal cycler. The development of cycle sequencing techniques has made a major contribution to DNA sequencing methodology, improving the reliability and efficiency of DNA sequence determination and eliminating time-consuming steps. 8. Aim of This Book The purpose of this book is to provide detailed practical procedures for a number of DNA sequencing techniques. Although protocols for DNA sequencing methods are available elsewhere, there was a need for a book that comprehensively covered the vanguard techniques now being applied in this rapidly evolving field. Each contribution is written so that a competent scientist who is unfamiliar with the method can carry out the technique successfully at the first attempt by simply following the detailed practical procedures that have been described by each author. Even the simplest techniques occasionally go wrong, and for this reason a “Notes” section has been included in most chapters. These notes will indicate any major problems or faults that can occur, their sources, and how they can be identified and overcome. Since the purpose of this book is to describe practical procedures and not to go into great depth regarding theory, a comprehensive reference section is included in most chapters, enabling the reader to refer to other publications for more detailed theoretical discussions on the various techniques. References 1. Sanger, F., Nicklen, S., and Coulson, A. R. (1977) DNA sequencing wrth chaintermmator inhibitors. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci USA 74, 5463-5467. 2. Maxam, A. M and Gilbert, W (1977) A new method for sequencing DNA Proc. Natl. Acad. Scl USA 74,560-564.
3. Barrell, B. (1991) DNA sequencmg: present limitations and prospects for the future. FASEB J 5,40-45 4. Sambrook, J., Frrtsch, E F., and Maniatrs, T. (1989) Molecular Cloning. ,4 Laboratory Manual 2d ed , Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press, Cold Spring Harbor, NY.
Griffin
and Griffin
5 Maxam, A. M. and Gilbert, W. (1980) Sequencing end-labeled DNA with basespecific chemical cleavages. Meth. Enzym. 65,499-560. 6. Ambrose, B J. B. and Pless, R. C. (1987) DNA sequencing. Chemical methods. Meth. Enzymol. 152,522-538. 7. Volckaert, G. (1987) A systematic approach to chemical DNA sequencing by subcloning in pGV451 and derrved vectors. Meth Enzym. 155,23 l-250 8 Eckert, R. L. (1987) New vectors for rapid sequencing of DNA fragments by chemical degradation. Gene 51,247-254. 9. Dolz, R. (1993) Fragment assembly programs, in DNA sequencmg: Computer Analysis ofSequence Data, (Griffin, A. M. and Grrffm, H. G., eds.), Humana Press, Totowa, NJ. (Ch. 2). 10 Staden, R. (1992) Managing sequencing projects, m DNA sequencing. Computer Analysis of Sequence Data, (Griffin, A. M. and Griffin, H. G., eds.), Humana Press, Totowa, NJ. (Ch 17). 11 Hunkapiller, T , Karser, R J., Kopp, B F , and Hood, L. (1991) Large-scale and automated DNA sequence determination. Science 254,59-67
&IAE’TER
Ml3 Cloning Their Contribution
2
Khicles to DNA Sequencing
Joachim
Messing
1. Introduction For studies in molecular biology, DNA purification has been essential, in particular for DNA sequencing, probing, and mutagenesis. The amplification of DNA in E. coli by cloning vehicles derived from M13mp or pUC made expensive physical separation techniques like ultracentrifugation unnecessary.Although today the polymerase chain reaction is a valuable alternative for the amplification of small DNA pieces (I), it cannot substitute for the construction of libraries of DNA fragments. Therefore, E. coli has served not only as a vehicle to amplify DNA, but also to separate many DNA molecules of similar length and the two DNA strands simultaneously. For this purpose, a bacteriophage like M 13 can be used. The various viral cis- and trunsacting functions are critical not only for strand separation, but also to separate the single-stranded DNA from the E. coli cell by an active transport mechanism through the intact cell wall. Although it may have been somewhat surprising to some how many changes in its DNA sequence the phage tolerated, manipulations of this amplification and transport system have been extended today even to the viral coat proteins for the production of epitope libraries (2). Much of the work is now more than a decade old, but experience has confirmed the usefulness of some simple biological paradigms. TechFrom Methods m Molecular Biology, Vol 23’ DNA Sequencmg Protocols Edlted by. H and A Gnffm Copyright 01993 Humana Press Inc , Totowa,
9
NJ
10
Messing
niques that were new and limiting fifteen years ago included automated oligonucleotide synthesis and the use of thermostable enzymes, which add a critical dimension to molecular biology today. Neither necessarily replaces the previous techniques, but they create greater flexibility, enormously accelerate scientific investigations, and even make certain analyses possible for the first time. However, DNA sequencing of larger contigs (several overlapping sequences that can be linked) have benefited from economizing on the synthesis of new oligonucleotides (3,4). Even in the absence of automated oligonucleotide synthesis in the earlier years, the concept of a universal primer could be developed by alternative techniques. 2. Development
of DNA Sequencing A Discussion
Techniques:
In 1974, at one of the first meetings on the use of restriction endonucleases in molecular biology some of these ideas became clear, Work on the chemical synthesis of a tRNA gene was presented, and the initial work on sequencing phage $X174 using restriction fragments as primers for the plus-minus method was discussed. At that time, oligonucieotide synthesis required a major effort and could not easily be generally applied. Restriction fragments offered an alternative. They could be used as primers for DNA synthesis in vitro and for marker-rescue experiments to link genetic and physical maps of viruses like SV40, both forerunners for DNA sequencing and sitedirected mutagenesis. There were several reasons to use @X174 as the first model in developing DNA-sequencing techniques and determining the sequence of an entire autonomous genome. First, it was one of the smallest DNA viruses; it is even smaller than M13. Second, the mature virus consists of single-stranded DNA, eliminating the need to separate the two strands of DNA for template preparation; this is even more critical if one wishes to use double-stranded restriction fragments as primers. Third, a restriction map was superimposed on the genetic map by marker-rescue experiments (5). The latter feature still serves today as a precondition for other genomes. Restriction sites were critical as signposts along the thousands of nucleotides and provided the means to dissect the double-stranded replicative form or RF of @X174 in small, but ordered pieces that permitted the DNA sequencing effort
Ml3
Cloning Vehicles
11
to proceed in a walking manner along the genome. Today the restriction map can be replaced by any DNA sequence (e.g., STS), since the synthesis of oligonucleotides is so rapid that researchers can use the DNA sequence that was just read from a sequencing gel to design and produce an oligonucleotide to extend the sequencing gel further in the 5’ direction. Therefore, the use of oligonucleotides instead of restriction fragments in such a primer walking method would have enormously accelerated the @X174 project. At the Cleveland Conference on Macromolecules in 1981, after a talk that I had given, the replacement of shotgun sequencing by such a method was suggestedby a colleague, who, as a pioneer in DNA synthesis and its automation, saw a perfect match of this emerging technology with DNA sequencing. Another expert in the chemical synthesis of DNA, Michael Smith, had more interest in the applications than improving the method, and had switched from the diester method to the phosphoramidite method (6), as well as conceiving the idea of using oligonucleotides in marker rescue (7). These innovative researchers pioneered marker rescue and established the physical and genetic map of $X174 (5). It is clear that today’s protein engineering had its roots right there with the right people at the right time, because they also recognized that oligonucleotides could eliminate the need for strand separation for DNA sequencing (8), and developed this method until it reached greater maturity (4,9). Even double-stranded DNA sequencing with universal primers became easier with the development of the pUC plasmids (IO). Despite all the advantages of choosing @X174 as a model system, Sanger’s group nearly picked a different single-stranded DNA phage, fd. In principle, E. coli has two different types of single-stranded DNA phage, represented by $X174 and fd. The first is packaged into an icosahedral head; it kills and lyses the host cell, but does not require F pili, which are receptor sites on the surface of the cell wall encoded by F factors. Its host range is restricted to E. coli C. Phage like fd can only infect male-specific E. cd, producing pili at their surface that are packaged in a filamentous coat and discharged from the cell without lysis; infected cells can continue to divide. These differences are critical, but there was another reason for choosing fd originally, The major coat protein encoded by gene VIII of the phage, a very small but very abundant protein, had been sequenced by protein sequen-
12
Messing
cing methods. Therefore it seemed obvious, particularly to those who had pioneered protein sequencing, to use protein sequenceto check the DNA sequence. The protein sequence allowed the design and synthesis of an oligonucleotide that would prime in vitro DNA synthesis within the coat protein gene. Furthermore, the derived DNA sequence had to match the protein sequence. Of course, the codon redundancy of many amino acids made it difficult to design a unique primer, and it might have been not too surprising that the approach did not lead to the correct DNA sequence (11). It turned out later that this was not caused by the choice of codons, but to a mistake in the protein sequence instead, Still, the paradigm of reverse genetics again has its roots right there. 3. Replication Systems and Ml3 In 1974, a research group at the Max Planck Institute of Biochemistry in Munich became interested in viruses, initially in E. coli more than in mammalian cells. The “Abteilung” was organized in subgroups, and one subgroup was interested in developing in vitro rephcation systems using both bacteriophage and small plasmids. This had a strong biochemical emphasis, and the researchers rapidly began to learn about single-stranded DNA replication. Eleven years earlier, Hofschneider had isolated a similar filamentous phage from the Munich sewers that he named after a series of phage with the initial M (12). Number 13 was the one that was studied most. Looking for a different research topic than plasmids or DNA replication, the possibility of combining Ml3 phage production with the in vitro DNA synthesis-based method of DNA sequencing was seen. Although this might have been obvious to those familiar with phage replication, innovative methods were needed for adaptation to DNA cloning techniques. The walking method for sequencing $X174 was the strategy used at that time, and some thought that it would be difficult to clone large fragments into Ml3 (although the author’s record was around 40 kb) and that a walking method might therefore have a limited use. Logically, the only alternative to the walking method was the use of shotgun clomng and a universal primer. The replicative form of Ml3 could be used to clone DNA fragments of a size slightly larger than necessary for single sequencing reactions, and a universal sequence near the cloning site would be used as a primer.
Ml3 Cloning Vehicles This would shift the work from preparing primers to preparing templates, which still remains more economical (13). If they were numerous, cloning was much faster than any biochemical technique, and with these thoughts in mind, a plan took shape to construct in vitro recombinants of phage Ml3 without using existing methods. One might recall that in vitro recombinants were usually based on drugresistance markers. This led to the development of plasmid vectors with unique cloning sites that were scattered ail over the plasmid genome (14). 4. Transposons Mutagenesis Both Zinder’s and Schaller’s laboratory had in mind, and actually later used, transposons to develop f 1 and fd transducing phage (15,16). However, one could predict that such a course of experiments, although useful for plasmid cloning vehicles, would be less useful for M13. It seemed plausible, and such an experiment could demonstrate that, in contrast to $X174, filamentous phage can accommodate additional DNA by extending the filamentous coat; infected cells can be treated like plasmid-containing cells. To some degree this had already been proved since one group had already described mutants of more than unit length (17). Another advantage of transposon mutagenesis was that insertion mutants would be naturally selected. This was one of the biggest obstacles from the beginning. Although plasmids and bacteriophage h were natural transducing elements, filamentous phage had never been shown to have this property, and it was not obvious whether insertion mutants would be viable. This was difficult because it was already known that amber mutants of most viral genes not only cause abortive infection, but also lead to killing of the host, something that does not happen when these mutations are suppressed. Therefore, insertion mutants that can be used as plasmids would kill the cell. It was thus predictable that insertion mutants had to be restricted to noncoding regions. Therefore, a decision was made to use a restriction enzyme that recognized at least two different sites in the intergenic region of the RF. Rather than asking whether the intergenic region contains a target site for transposons, the restriction map showed that it was possible to get at least two different insertion mutants within the intergenic region. The only difficulty in such an experiment was
14
Messing
to find conditions where the restriction enzyme would cut RF only once at any of the possible target sites, so that a population of unit length RF could be ligated to the appropriate marker DNA fragment. However, there was another reason not to use drug-resistance markers. Infected cells still divide, but very slowly. Therefore, selection takes much longer than with plasmids, but it makes it very easy to distinguish infected from noninfected cells on a bacterial lawn. A single infection grown on a bacterial lawn forms a turbid plaque. If bacterial cells are then transfected by the calcium chloride technique of Mandel and Higa (18), a transformed cell can be recognized as a plaque. Hence, no selection technique is necessary, but the ability to distinguish between wild-type M 13 and M 13 insertion mutants would remain a problem. Although it was quite plausible to think of the histochemical screen used for bacteriophage hplac by Malamy et al. (19), the la& gene would have been a large insertion. However, it turned out that, rather than using entire genes as markers, one could clone only the portion encoding the amino-terminal and the repressible control region, and provide the rest in tram by the host of the phage. This became clear when Landy et al. (20) wrote on the purification of an 800-bp Hind11 fragment from hplac capable of a-complementation in a cell-free transcription-translation system. An informal sequence of this fragment showed that it was 789-bp long and included the first 146 codons of the ZacZ gene, but it was still necessary to assemble many components and purify several restriction endonucleases. Work began after some strains and purified Zac repressor were traded; this allowed the purification of the 789-bp Hind11 fragment out of about fifty other restriction fragments by simply filtering the DNA/lac repressor complex through a nitrocellulose filter. After adding IPTG, it was possible to recover the DNA in solution. Using DNA-binding proteins for purifying and cloning promoter regions is now a well established technique, but ligating restriction fragments via blunt ends was not established at the time when this experiment was ready. As described elsewhere (21), only two transformants were obtained-one of them was saved and named M 13mp 1. Electron microscopy proved that added DNA was packaged as a filamentous phage and produced as single-stranded DNA (22,23). Now the path took a more formal shape. Not only would the histochemical screenwork by detecting a blue among colorless plaques, but
Ml3 Cloning Vehicles 1 2 3 4 5 6 ATG ACC ATG ATT AC-
7 8 TCA CTG (+ GGmAT TC CT TA AG (-
15 9 10 WlJmpl GCC GTC (+ or Viral strand) or viral strand) or complementary strand)
12 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 M13mp2 A CTG GCC GTC (+ or Viral ATG ACC ATG ATT ACE AAT TC EcoRI
strand)
Fig. 1. Creation of an EcoRI sue by chemical mutagenesis. By screening the nucleotides of the first ten codons of the 1ucZ gene, we found that the sequence GGATTC could erther be converted into an EcoRI site GAATTC or a BamHI sue GGATCC by a single base change. Since there already was a BumHI site in gene III, but no EcoRI site m M13mp1, and I had an ample supply of EcoRI enzyme purified myself, we decided to select the GAATTC site that also changed codon GAT for asparttc acid to AAT for asparagine (24).
it could be reversed. One uncertainty was how to introduce new restriction sites in the right region, Such a site had to be unique for M 13mp 1
and positioned not somewhere in the viral genome, but in the ZacZ region, so that insertion mutants would not give rise to a-complementation. Inspection of the sequence showed that there were not many sequences in the amino-terminal region that could be converted in a single step into a unique restriction site. Attempts to use EcoRI linkers that became available at the time to “marker rescue” them did not succeed. Without somebody to synthesize oligonucleotides that were more homologous to the Zac region, it was hopeless. As an alternative, a chemical mutagen was tried. It was known that methylated G could mispair with uracil or thymine, therefore, by methylating the single-stranded Ml3 DNA with nitrosomethylurea, a mutation could be introduced into the minus strand and the subsequent RF molecules (Fig. 1). Unfortunately, there was no good genetic selection for this procedure. It would require brute-force methods of enriching EcoRI-sensitive RF from a transformed phage library by gel electrophoresis of linear versus circular molecules. Still, it was hard to believe when this author isolated RF that was not only sensitive to EcoRI, but had exactly the predicted base change in codon 5 of the 1acZ gene (24).
16
Messing
The same mutagenesis led to two more EcoRI mutants and a mutant RF that was resistant to BumHI, a site within gene III. At that time, there was still much concern that many mutations might not be tolerated because of changes in the protein sequence or the secondary structure of RNA. Therefore, changes in the lac DNA should probably occur at a higher frequency than in the viral DNA. Furthermore, the aminoterminus of the 1acZ gene appeared to be more flexible since it was demonstrated that fusion proteins retained P-galactosidase function. On the other hand, this author did not recognize the tremendous selection power for suppressor mutations. In other words, any mutation that was introduced could potentially be compensated for by another mutation somewhere else. The primary mutant might give a low titre, but because of the growth advantage a suppressor mutant would rapidly take over. An example of such a case is M 13mp 1, Later, Dotto and Zinder (25) showed that insertion mutants at the mpl Hue111 site gave a low titre phenotype: Since M13mpl gave a normal titer, they searched for a suppressor mutation. Codon 40 in gene II of M 13mp 1 was indeed changed. 5. The Need for a Universal
Primer
Researchers continue to use chemical mutagens to get rid of restriction sites. The reason for this becomes clear when they return to the use of Ml 3 in DNA sequencing. The EcoRI site in M13mp2 allowed cloning by screening for colorless plaques. Now one could readily purify these plaques and prepare a template for sequencing the inserted DNA. Still, as with the $X174 project, a restriction fragment from the adjacent Zuc DNA needed to be purified as a primer, and such a fragment was subcloned into a plasmid for convenience (26). Such a primer fragment still needed to be denatured since it was doublestranded, and had to be cut off after the sequencing reaction to produce a shift of the 3’ end in the sequencing gel. Although such a protocol could still be improved on, a more serious obstacle arose suddenly from the concern over the biological containment of Ml 3 recombinant DNA. The NIH Recombinant Advisory Committee (RAC) thought that the conjugation proficient E. coli host strains could lead to the spread of Ml3 infection and pose a risk in using Ml3 as a cloning vehicle. On the other hand, using one of the truD or tru1 mutants reduces conjugation by a factor of 106, but they
Ml3 Cloning Vehicles
17
still were infectious to M13. Since this F factor carrying the traD mutation was wild-type lac, a histochemical screen with the mp vectors would not be possible, and one would have to return to drug-resistanttype M 13 vectors. The scientific reasoning of RAC is hard to understand. First, nobody argued against Agrobacterium tumefaciens as a plant transformation vector, although it was conjugation proficient and could easily spread in the environment. Second, F pili were never made under stress or anaerobic conditions, something that was already known as “phenocopies.” Conjugation in the human gut was in any case nearly zero. Third, Ml3 infection per se reduces conjugation by a factor of 106. It was hard to argue with so many well known scientists at that time, so a new seriesof E. coli strains (JM series) all carrying the Ml5 deletion on the F’ traD36 episome was constructed. Since it was a concern of NIH, it was necessary to summarize the status of all the strains for potential users in the NIH Bulletin (27). Although DNA sequencing of eukaryotic origin by Ml3 cloning was now possible, preparation of the primer from the plasmid was still cumbersome. It was clear that an oligonucleotide to replace the restriction fragment as a universal primer was needed. Inquiries regarding the synthesis of a universal primer by a commercial supplier revealed that the cost of such an attempt made it out of the question A further attempt and timely support produced success, not only with a universal primer but also with another application of oligonucleotides (3). In 1978 this author made another interesting observation, namely that in-frame insertions of linkers in the EcoRI site could still give a positive color reaction, One of these isolates, called M13mp5, could be used to clone both EcoRI and Hind111 fragments at the same site and with the same primer for sequencing (27). The utility of creating cloning sites on top of each other was based on the universal primer concept, but in turn caused the development of multiple cloning sites (MCS) or polylinkers that are now found in all cloning vehicles and provide many additional uses (Fig. 2). Therefore, work began on the synthesis of an oligonucleotide that could be inserted into the EcoRI site and generate restriction sites recognized by six basepair cutters like BamHI, AccI, SmaI, or Hind11 useful for cloning either bluntended fragments or fragments with sticky ends produced by four base cutters like Sau3A, TaqI, and HpaII (Fig. 3) (consistent with a DNA
18
Messing
A
Kanr
ECORI-BamHI-SalI-PstI-SalI-BamHI-EcoRI AccI AccI HincII HincII
B
EcoRI-SmaI-BamHI-SalI-PstI-Hind111 XmaI AccI HincII
Imp8 1
HindIII-PstI-SalI-BamHI-SmaI-EcoRI AccI HincII
(mpg 1 XmaI
--->3 ’ ~xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx~ <---exoII1 GAATTCCCGGG CTTAAGGGCC<-- exoVII----> BarnHI 5
I--
GCCAAGCTT ACGEGGTTCGAA PstI
Fig. 2. Symmetric (a) and asymmetric (b) polylinkers. Two other “tricks” were used m the construction of polylmkers. One type of polylmker was symmetrical where all sites except the central one occurred twice. By cloning a drug-resistance marker into the central site, the polylinker could be used in a linker scanning method of coding regions (10) and (34). The other type of polylinker was a pair, where two vectors contain an array of sites only once, but each of them m the opposite onentation Cloned DNA no longer could be cloned out with a single enzyme as in the first type, but DNA could be cloned by using two different sites at the same time. This had the advantage that the orientation of a cloned fragment could be determined. By using a vector pair, both orientations can be obtained with the same pair of restriction cuts and therefore each strand of a restriction fragment could become the viral strand of Ml3 and available as a template for sequencing Furthermore, by using two restriction enzymes that produce 3’ and 5’ overhangs, one can either use It for cloning oligonucleotlde hbrarles or to generate umdlrectional deletions with exonuclease III
shotgun sequencing approach). This also required a renewed chemical mutagenesis to eliminate the AccI and the HincII sites naturally occurring in M13. All single mutations were combined by marker rescue to give rise to M13mp7 (3). This was just the system, but did shotgun sequencing succeed?
Ml3 Cloning Vehicles
Unique
vector
sequence
19
Compatible
target
G'GATC C C CTAG'G
N'GATC N N CTAG'N MYbOT
GT'CG AC CA GC'TG
NT’CG AN
sites
NA GC'TN NC'CG
GN
NG GC'CN GTC'GAC CAG'CTG HincII
NNN'NNN NNN'NNN Restrlction
enzymes
AALL, HaeIII,
like
etc.;
Ba.UlorExoIIIIV; sheared
and repaired
DNA
Fig. 3. Sticky and blunt-end cloning of small fragments mto unique cloning sites. By destgning a unique sequence for the M13mp vectors that were recogmzed by restriction enzymes that could cut a hexanucleotide sequence in various ways by etther producing sticky ends of 4 or 2 bases, or blunt ends, the variety of DNA fragments that could be cloned next to the umversal primers were endless Note that the sequence GTCGAC was recognized by SufI, AccI, and H&II, each producing different ends. In our sequencing project wtth cauliflower mosatc virus we generated small DNA fragments for shotgun DNA sequencing by cleaving CAMV with EcoRI*, Mb&, HpaII, TagI, HincII, HueIII, and A/u1 (28) Later we used DNaseI (35), sonication (30), and a combination of exonuclease III and VII to generate blunt ends (36)
Initially, lack of funds and proper laboratory facilities made a demonstration impossible. Financial support finally arrived, however, and a dedicated research team began producing the sequence of cauliflower mosaic virus on the side (8031 bp). This was accomplished in a record time of three months, and the results were finally published a year later (28).
20
Messing
6. Conclusion During the same time, several researchers reported that they could not finish their work on sequencing the mitochondrial DNA if they could not use a host for Ml3 approved by the NIH guidelines. This author gave them not only the JM strains, but also the newly developed M13mp7 for blunt-end cloning to facilitate their work. Although this author’s work was not published, having been rejected by PNAS as trivial at the time, in the end, I recognized that there was no sense in competing but that the scientific community should be used as a laboratory at large, and this indeed became reality (29). Becoming overwhelmed by requests for strains and protocols, the newly developing reagent companies were turned to for help. Their educational and service role helped immensely to disseminate the knowledge needed to train students and investigators in academia and industry in M 13 cloning, sequencing, and site-directed mutagenesis (30). Along the way, the first Apple-based software on shotgun sequencing was developed (31,32), in addition to a textbook for an undergraduate course (33). A good overview of M13mp, pUC vectors, and helper phage has also appeared (21). As with all methods of wider scope, modifications and refinements have been produced in many laboratories as many chapters in this book show. However, some principles have not changed: whenever there is a way to use a cell or parts of one as a machine, scientists seem to get ahead faster and cheaper, and that is what biotechnology is all about. Acknowledgment Most of this author’s work on Ml3 was supported by the Deutsche Forschungs Gemeinschaft, grant no. 5901-9-0386, and the Departments of Agriculture and Energy, grant no. AC0243 lER10901. References 1. Saiki, R. K., Gelfand, D. H., Stoffel, S , Scharf, S. J., Higuchi, R., Horn, G. T., Mullis, K. B., and Ehrlich, H A. (1988) Primer-directed enzymatic amplification of DNA with a thermostable DNA polymerase. Science 239,487- 491 2. Scott, J. and Smith, G. (1990) Searchmg for peptIde ligands with an epitope library. Science 249,386 -390. 3. Messing, J., Crea, R., and Seeburg, P. H. (1981) A system for shotgun DNA sequencing. Nucl. Acids Res. 9, 309-321. 4. Norrander, J., Kempe, T., and Messing, J (1983) Improved Ml3 vectors using oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis. Gene 26, 101-106.
Ml3 Cloning Vehicles
21
5. Edgell, M. H., Hutchison, C. A., III, and Sclair, M. (1972) Specific endonuclease R fragments of bacteriophage $X174 deoxyribonucleic acid. J. Viral. 9,574-582 6 Beaucage, S. L. and Caruthers, M H. (1981) Deoxynucleoside phosphoramidites-a new class of key Intermediates for deoxypolynucleotide synthesis. Tetrahedron Lett. 22, 1859-l 862. 7. Hutchison, C. A., III, Phtlhps, S., Edgell, M. H., Gillam, S., Jahnke, P., and Smith, M (1978) Mutagenesis at a specific position in a DNA sequence. J. Biol. Chem. 253,655 l-6560. 8. Smith, M , Leung, D W , Gillam, S., Astell, C. R , Montgomery, D. L., and Hall, B D (1979) Sequence of the gene for iso-1-cytochrome C in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Cell 16, 753-761. 9 Zoller, M and Smith, M. (1982) Oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis using M13-derived vectors. an efficient and general procedure for the production of point mutations in any fragment of DNA. Nucl. Acids Res. 10,6487-6500 IO. Vieira, J. and Messing, J (1982) The pUC plasmtds, an M 13mp7 derived system for msertion mutagenesis and sequencing with synthetic universal prtmers Gene 19,259-268. 11 Sanger, F , Donelson, J E., Coulson, A. R., Kossel, H., and Fischer, H (1973) Use of DNA polymerase I primed by a synthetic ohgonucleotide to determine a nucleotide sequence in phage f 1 DNA. Proc. Nat1 Acad. Ser. USA 70,1209-l 2 13 12. Hofschneider, P H (1963) Untersuchungen uber “kleine” E coli K12 Bacteriophagen M12, M13, und M20. Z. Naturforschg. Mb, 203-205. 13. Davison, A. J. (1991) Experience in shotgun sequencing a 134 kilobase pair DNA molecule DNA Sequence 1,389-394 14 Bolivar, F , Rodriguez, R. L., Greene, P. J., Betlach, M. V., Heynecker, H L , Boyer, H. W , Crosa, J. W , and Flakow, S (1977) Construction and characterization of new cloning vehicles. II. A multipurpose cloning system. Gene 2,95-l 13 15. Herrmann, R., Neugebauer, K., Zentgraf, H., and Schaller, H. (1978) Transposition of a DNA sequence determining kanamycin resistance into the singlestranded genome of bacteriophage fd MOE Gen. Genet. 159, 17 1. 16 Vovis, G F. and Ohsumi, M. (1978) The filamentous phages as transducing particles, m The Single-Stranded DNA Phages (Denhardt, D. T , Dressler, D., and Ray, D S , eds ), Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory, Cold Spring Harbor, NY, pp 445-448 17 Salivar, W. O., Henry, T. J., and Pratt, D. (1967) Purtfication and properties of diploid particles of coliphage M13. Virology, 32,41-5 1 18. Mandel, M. and Higa, A (1970) Calcium-dependent bacteriophage DNA mfection. J. Mol Blol., 53, 159-162. 19 Malamy, M H., Fiandt, M , and Szybalski, W. (1972) Electron microscopy of polar insertions in the lac operon of Escherichia co11 Mol. Gen Genet 119, 207-222 20 Landy, A , Olchowski, E , and Ross, W. (1974) Isolation of a functional lac regulatory region. Mol Gen Gene& 133,273-28 1. 2 1. Messing, J. (1991) Clonmg m Ml 3 phage or how to use biology at its best Gene 100,3-12
22
Messing
22 Messing, J , Gronenborn, B., Muller-Hill, B., and Hofschnetder, P H. (1977) Frlamentous cohphage Ml3 as a cloning vehtcle insertion of a HrndII fragment of the fat regulatory region m the Ml3 rephcattve form in vitro Pruc Natl. Acad. SCL USA 74,3642-3646. 23. Messing, J. and Gronenborn, B (1978) The filamentous phage Ml3 as carrter DNA for operon fusions in vitro, m The Single-Stranded DNA Phages (Denhardt, D T., Dressler, D., and Ray, D. S., eds.), Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory, Cold Spring Harbor, NY, pp. 449-453. 24 Gronenborn, B. and Messing, J. (1978) Methylatron of single-stranded DNA m vttro mtroduces new restrtctrons endonuclease cleavage sites. Nature 272, 375-377 25 Dotto, G. P. and Zmder, N D (1984) Reduction of the mmimal sequence for mmatton of DNA synthesis by qualitative and quantttatrve changes of an mltrator protein Nature 311,279-280 26. Heidecker, G., Messmg, J , and Gronenborn, B. (1980) A versatile prrmer for DNA sequencing m the M13mp2 clonmg system Gene 10,69-73. 27 Messing, J (1979) A multrpurpose cloning system based on the single-stranded DNA bacteriophage M13. Recombinant DNA Technical Bulletin, NIH Publtcanon No. 79-99,2, No. 2,43-48 28 Gardner, R. C., Howarth, A J., Hahn, P 0, Brown-Leudi, M , Shepherd, R J., and Messmg, J. (198 1) The complete nucleotide sequence of an mfectious clone of cauliflower mosaic virus by M13mp7 shotgun sequencmg. Nucl Acrds Res. 9,2871-2888 29 Holden, C (1991) Briefings Science 254,28 30. Messing, J (1983) New Ml3 vectors for clonmg. Methods Enzymol. 101,20-78 31 Larson, R. and Messing, J. (1982) Apple II software for Ml3 shotgun DNA sequencmg Nucl Acids Res 10, 39-49 32 Larson, R. and Messing, J. (1983) Apple II computer software for DNA and protean sequence data DNA 2,3 l-35. 33 Hackett, P. H., Fuchs, J A , and Messing, J (1984) An introduction to recombmant DNA techniques Basic Experiments in Gene Manzpulution BenjaminCummings, Menlo Park, CA 34 Messing, J., Vieira, J , and Gardner, R (1982) Codon insertion mutagenesis to study functional domains of P-lactamase In vrtro mutagenesis Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory, Cold Spring Harbor, NY, pp 52 35 Messmg, J. and Seeburg, P H (1981) A strategy for hrgh speed DNA sequencing, in Developmental Biology Using Purified Genes (Brown, D. and Fox, F , eds ), ICN-UCLA Symposia on Molecular and Cellular Biology, vol 23 Academic, NY, pp 659-669. 36 Yanisch-Perron, C , Vieira, J , and Messing, J (1985) Improved Ml3 phage cloning vectors and host strains, nucleottde sequences of the M 13mp and pUC vectors Gene 33,103-l 19
hAP!l’ER
Cloning
3
into Ml3
Qingzhong
Yu
1. Introduction The bacteriophage M 13 has been developed into a cloning vector system for obtaining single-stranded DNA template required for the dideoxy chain termination method of sequencing DNA (1,2). General aspects of bacteriophage Ml3 as a cloning vector system are reviewed in Chapter 2, and the preparation of foreign DNA fragments for Ml3 cloning is described in Chapter 7. In this chapter the preparation of Ml3 vectors and the ligation of foreign DNA fragments (inserts) into Ml3 vectors are described. 2. Materials 2.1. Preparation
of Replicative
Form
(RF) Ml3
DNA
1. L-Broth: Bacto-tryptone l%, bacto-yeast extract O.S%,NaCl 1%. 2. 2X YT: Bacto-tryptone 1.6%, bacto-yeast extract 1%, NaClO.5%. 3. M9 minimal medium: Na,HFQ, . 7H20 12.8 g, IU-12P043 g, NaC10.5 g, NH&l 1.0 g, 20% glucose 20 mL, Hz0 to 1 L. 4. BacteriophageM13: A single blue plaque from a freshly transformed plate. 5. E. coli JM 103 or JM 109: A colony grown on an M9 minimal agar plate. 6. Solution 1: 50 mII4 Glucose, 25 mM Tris-HCI, pH 8.0, 10 rniI4 EDTA, pH 8.0, autoclaved and stored at 4°C. From. Methods m Molecular Brology, Vol 23. DNA Sequencmg Protocols E&ted by- H. and A Gnffm Copyright 01993 Humana Press Inc., Totowa,
23
NJ
24
YU
7. Solution 2: 0.2M NaOH, 1% SDS, freshly mix together equal volumes of 0.4M NaOH and 2% SDS stocks before use. 8. Solution 3: 60 mL 5M Potassium acetate, 11.5 mL glacial acetic acid, 28.5 mL H20, stored at 4OC. 9. TE: 10 mM Tris-HCl, pH 8.0, 1 mM EDTA, pH 8.0. 10. Phenol-chloroform: Mix well equal volumes of TE (pH 8.0)-saturated phenol (nucleic actd grade) and chloroform (AR grade), stored at 4°C m a dark glass bottle. 11. 3M NaAc, pH 5.2, stored at 4°C. 12. Ethanol: Absolute alcohol, stored at -20°C. 13. RNase: 1 mg/mL DNase-free pancreatic RNase A. 2.2. Preparation of Ml3 Vectors 1. Restriction enzymes. 2. 10X RE buffers. 3. Calf intestinal alkaline phosphatase (CIP). 4. 10X CIP dephosphorylation buffer. 5. Proteinase K 10 mg/mL. 6. 10% SDS. ’ 7. 0.5M EDTA, pH 8.0. 8. 3M NaAc, pH 7.0, stored at 4°C. 9. 10X TBE: Tns base108 g, Boric acid 55 g, EDTA 92H20 9.5 g, HZ0 to 1 L. 10. 0.8% Agarose gel in 1X TBE. 2.3. Ligation of Inserts into Ml3 Vectors 1. T4 DNA ligase. 2. 10X Ligation buffer. 3. 10 mM ATP, stored at -20°C. 4. Ml3 vectors (prepared as described in the methods section). 5. Inserts (having termini compatible with the vectors).
All enzymes and buffers are stored at -20°C. Other solutions can be stored at room temperature except when indicated otherwise. 3. Methods
A number of M 13 vectors have been constructed (.2,3) and are commercially available from several companies. Therefore, it would be more convenient to purchase the Ml3 vectors than to prepare them oneself. Sometimes, however, you may need a Ml3 vector with a special cloning site to fit your cloning strategy. Thus the preparation
of Ml3 vectors is described below.
Cloning
25
into Ml3
3.1. Mini
Preparation
of
RF Ml3 DNA
1. Inoculate 5 mL of L-Broth in a 20-mL sterile culture tube (e.g., universal) with one bacterial colony (e.g., JM103 or JM109) from an M9 minimal agar plate. Incubate at 37OCin an orbital shaking incubator overnight. 2. Add 50 l,tL of the bacteria culture to 2 mL of L-Broth in a 5-mL culture tube (e.g., bijoux). Inoculate this culture with Ml3 bacteriophage by touching a single blue plaque from a transformatton plate with a sterile toothpick and washing its end m the culture. Incubate the infected culture at 37°C for 4-5 h m an orbital shaking incubator. 3. Transfer 1.0-l .5 mL of the culture to a microfuge tube and centrifuge at 12,OOOgfor 2 min at room temperaturein a microfuge. Remove supernatant to a fresh tube, being careful not to disturb the pellet. If desired, the single strand Ml3 (single-stranded) DNA can be prepared from the supernatant. 4. Remove any remaining supernatant by aspiration from the tube containing the bacterial pellet. Resuspend the pellet by ptpeting it or vigorous vortexing in 100 pL of solution 1 and leave at room temperature for 5-10 mm. 5. Add 200 cls,of freshly prepared solution 2. Close the tube and mix the contents by mvertmg the tube rapidly five times. Do not vortex. Store the tube on ice for 5 mm. 6. Add 150 pL of ice-cold solution 3. Vortex the tube gently m an inverted position for 10 s. Store on ice for 5 min. 7. Centrifuge at 12,OOOgfor 5 min and transfer the supernatant to a fresh tube. 8. Add an equal vol of phenol:chloroform, mix by vortexing for 20-30 s. Spin as in step 7 and transfer the aqueous phase (top layer) to a fresh tube. 9. Add 2 vol of ethanol, mix by vortexing, and stand for 5 min at room temperature. 10. Spin as m step 7 and remove the supernatant by gentle asptratton. 11, Wash the pellet with 1 mL of 70% ethanol. Spin for 2 mm m the same orientation of the pellet. Remove the supernatant as m step 10. Vacuum dry for 3-5 mm or air-dry for 10 min. 12. Dissolve the pellet m 20 pL of TE (pH 8.0) contammg RNase (20 pg/ mL) to remove RNA. Vortex briefly. The double-stranded RF Ml 3 DNA is now ready for analysis by digestion with restriction enzymes.
3.2. Preparation
of
Ml3 Vectors
3.2.1 Digestion with a Single Restriction Enzyme (RE) 1. Digest RF Ml3 DNA with a single RE in the followmg reaction: RF Ml3 DNA 10 $L (400 ng) Restriction enzyme 3-5-fold excess 10X appropriate buffer 2 pL make up to 20 pL total vol H2O
26
YU
Incubate for 2 h. Remove 2 pL of the reaction and analyze the extent of digestion by electrophoresis through 0.8% agarose gel, using undigested Ml3 DNA as a marker. If digestion is mcomplete, add more RE and continue the incubation. 2. When digestion is complete, extract the Ml3 DNA with phenol:chloroform and precipitate DNA with 0.1 vol of 3M NaAc, pH 5.2, and 2.5 vol of ethanol for 1 h at -20°C or overnight if convenient. 3. Recover the DNA by centrifugation at 12,OOOgfor 10 min in a microfuge. Wash the pellet with 70% ethanol and vacuum dry. Dissolve the pellet in 20 p.L of TE, pH 8.0. Now it is ready to use for ligation with inserts if dephosphorylatton is not required. 3.2.2. Dephosphorylation
of Ml3
Vectors
4. The single RE-dtgested Ml3 vector can be dephosphorylated by treatment with calf intestinal alkaline phosphatase (CIP) to reduce the background of nonrecombinant molecules formed by circularization of the vector during ligation. To 20 pL of linearized Ml3 vector obtained in step 3, add: 10X CIP buffer 5 pL CIP 1 U/100 pmoles for protruding 5’ termmt 1 U/2 pmoles for blunt or recessed termim make up to 50 pL total vol H20 5. Incubate for 30 min at 37OCfor protruding 5’ termini vectors. For blunt or recessedterminus vectors, incubate for 15 min at 37”C, then add the same amount of CIP and continue incubation for a further of 45 min at 55°C. 6. At the end of the incubation period, add the following to the reaction: 10% SDS 2.5 pL (final concentration 0.5 %) 0.5 pL (final concentration 5 n-&f) 0.5M EDTA (pH 8.0) 10 mg/mL proteinase K 0.5 pL (final concentration 100 Clg/mL) Incubate for 30 min at 56OCto remove the CIP. 7. Cool the reaction to room temperature, and extract with phenol:chloroform twice. Add 0.1 vol of 3M NaAc, pH 7.0, mix well and add 2.5 vol of ethanol. Mix and store at 20°C for 1 h or overnight. Recover the DNA as in step 3. The final pellet is dissolved in 20 pL of TE, pH 8.0. Now it is ready to use for ligation with inserts. 3.2.3.
Digestion
with
Two Restriction
Enzymes
8. If a different RE digestion is required for generating a Ml3 vector with incompatible termini (forced dtrectional cloning vector), the DNA recovered in step 3 above is dissolved in 10 pL of TE (pH 8.0) and steps l-3 are repeated with the second RE. To check the extent of the digestion by the second RE, set up a separate RE digestion reaction with the sec-
Cloning into Ml3
27
ond RE in the same ratio of RF Ml 3 DNA and the enzyme. Analyze the digestion by electrophoresis as m step 1. 9. If two different enzymes require the same buffer condition, the RF Ml3 DNA can be digested simultaneously with both REs. To momtor the extent of the digestion, set up two reaction mixtures with the two REs separately as controls. After the RF Ml3 DNA has been completely digested, repeat steps 2-3. The final pellet is dissolved in 20 pL of TE, pH 8.0. It is ready to use for ligation with inserts. 10. For vectors digested with two different REs it is not necessary to dephosphorylate to reduce the background. But, to avoid religation of the small fragment generated by RE digestion of the polycloning sites into the M 13 vectors, it can be removed by electrophoresis through agarose gel or polyacrylamide gel (refer to Chapter 10 in Volume 2 of this series). 3.3. Ligation of Inserts into Ml3 Vectors 1. Set up ligation reaction m the followmg order: Ml 3 vector 1 r-1L(20 w) 10 mM ATP lc1L 10X ligation buffer 1 pL inserts l-4 pL (3-5-fold molar excess) T4 DNA ligase 5 U for blunt termini 1 U for cohesive termmi make up to 10 pL total vol H2O Incubate at 14OC overnight. Then store at -2OOC or use directly for transformation. 2. Set up two control reactions contammg the same components except that in the place of the mserts, be sure that one control contains H,O, and the other contains an appropriate amount of a test DNA that has been successfully cloned mto the Ml3 vector on a previous occasion. Incubate under the same conditions as m step 1. 3. After ligation, analyze 1 pL of each ligation reaction, using the same amounts of the Ml3 vector and inserts without ligase as control, by electrophoresis through 0.8% agarose gel to check that the ligation has been successful. 4. Transform 5 w of the remaining ligation sample mto competent bacteria of the appropriate strain of E. coli, e.g., JM103 or JM109. 4. Notes 1 Bacteria carrying an F’ episome (e.g., JM103 or JM109) can grow m M9 muumal medium, but much more slowly than m L-Broth and do not survive prolonged storage at 4°C. It is, therefore, better to streak a master culture of the bacteria on the M9 minimal agar plate every month
28
YU
The master culture bacteria should be stored at -70°C in L-Broth containing 15% glycerol. 2. Bacteriophage Ml3 can drffuse a considerable distance through the top agar on the transformation plate. Therefore, it is important to pick up a single blue plaque that is well-separated from its neighbors to avoid crosscontamination with other plaques. And it is also better to pick up a single blue plaque from a freshly transformed plate to get a good yreld of RF Ml3 DNA. 3. Since RF Ml3 DNA remains Inside infected bacteria and Ml3 phage progeny containing single-stranded M 13 DNA is released to the medium, it is important to remove any remaining supernatant from infected bacterial pellet in step 4 of the mmipreparation of RF Ml3 DNA to mmimaze single-stranded Ml3 DNA contammation. Even so, sometimes the mmiprepared RF Ml3 DNA is still contaminated with singlestranded Ml3 DNA, which may confuse the pattern of DNA fragments obtained by RE digestion. However, it can be distinguished from the RF Ml 3 DNA by analyzing RE-digested and undigested RF Ml 3 DNA by electrophoresis through the same agarose gel. Because the singlestranded M 13 DNA cannot be digested by REs commonly used in M 13 cloning, Its migration through the gel does not change after RE drgestion, whereas the digested RF Ml3 DNA will change its migration through the gel. 4. When recovermg Ml 3 DNA after centrifugation of precipitated samples, sometimes the Ml3 DNA pellet is not visible. Therefore, it is necessary to carefully remove the supernatant and leave a little bit (20-30 l.tL) behind in the tube to minimize the loss of the DNA. Do likewise when washing with 70% ethanol, then vacuum dry. 5. To remove CIP which may affect subsequent ligation of Ml3 vectors with inserts after dephosphorylation, an alternative method is to mactivate the CIP by heating at 70°C for 10 min in the presence of 5 mM of EDTA, pH 8.0, and then extract with phenol:chloroform. Because EDTA precipitates from solution at acid pH if its concentration exceed 5-10 mM, the 3M NaAc, pH 7.0, is used instead of the commonly used 3M NaAc, pH 5.2, for precipitation of dephosphorylated Ml 3 DNA. 6. The efficiency of ligation of blunt termini is somewhat lower than for ligation of cohesive termini. To improve the efficrency of the ligation of blunt termmi, higher concentration of inserts and T4 DNA hgase is required. The extent of ligation of Ml3 vectors with inserts can be checked by electrophoresis through 0.8% agarose gel, using unhgated Ml3 vectors and inserts as control. Normally, the ligated Ml3 vectors with inserts will mrgrate slowly through the gel because of the increased
Cloning into Ml3
29
molecular weight, sometimes glvmg fuzzy or smeared bands which mdlcates the extent of the ligation.
Acknowledgment The author wishes to thank D. Cavanagh for advice in the preparation of the manuscript.
References 1 Messmg, J. (1983) New Ml3 vectors for cloning Meth Enzymol. 101,20-79 2. Sanger,F., Nicklen, S , and Coulson, A. R. (1977) DNA sequencmg with chamterminating mhlbltors Proc. Nat1 Acad. Sci. USA 74, 5463-5467 3 Yamsch-Perron, C , Vlelra, J., and Messing, J (1985) Improved M 13 phage cloning vectors and host strains: nucleotlde sequences of the M13mp18 and pUC19 vectors. Gene 33,103-l 19.
&IAFTER
Transfection
4
of E. coli with
Ml3 DNA
Fiona M. lbmley
1. Introduction In recent years several techniques have been described for the introduction of DNA molecules into strains of E. coli by transformation or transfection. These are based on the findings of Mandel and Higa (I) who demonstrated that incubation of cells with naked bacteriophage h DNA in cold calcium chloride resulted in uptake of virus and that a transient heat-shock of the mixture greatly enhancedthe efficiency of transfection. Subsequently, this method was used to introduce a variety of circular and linear DNAs into strains of E. coli, and many variations in the technique have been described that are aimed at increasing the yield of transformants or transfectants. The central requirements for success are the presence of multivalent cations, an incubation temperature close to O”C, and a carefully controlled heatshock at 42OC,but a number of other compounds and procedures have been found to increase efficiency in some or all strains of E. coli that have been tested. The mechanisms involved in DNA transformation of cells are not fully understood and even with the most efficient methods that are available the proportion of cells that become “competent” for transformation is limited to around 10% of the total population. The procedures for Ml3 transfection of E. coli cells are simple, requiring the establishment of a log phase bacterial culture, the prepaFrom Methods m Molecular Bfology, Vol. 23 DNA Sequenong Protocols Edlted by Ii. and A Gnffm Copyright 01993 Humana Press Inc , Totowa,
31
NJ
32
Tomley
ration of competent cells and the introduction of DNA into these cells, Fresh cells can be prepared for each transfection or, alternatively, frozen aliquots of competent cells can be stored at -70°C and thawed as required. This chapter includes two alternative procedures for preparing competent cells, one based on the original Calcium method and a second based on that of Hanahan (2). 2. Materials 1. An E, co11 strain smtable for propagating bacteriophage Ml 3 vectors. Recommended strains include JMlOl, JM103, JM107, JM109, TGl, and TG2 (see Note 1). 2. Bacterial growth media: Sterilize by autoclaving in suitable ahquots a. L-broth: 1% tryptone, 0.5% yeast extract, 200 mM NaCl. b. SOB-broth: 2% tryptone, 0.5% yeast extract, 10 mM NaCl, 2.5 mM KCl, pH 7.0. Just before use, add Mg2+ to 20 mM from a sterile ftltered stock of 1M MgC12, 1M MgSO+ c. H-agar: 1% tryptone, 140 rniV NaCl, 1.2% bacto-agar. To pour plates, melt agar by boiling or microwavmg, cool to around 50°C and pour mto Petri-dishes on a level surface (15-20 ml/plate). Once agar has set, dry plates by storing inverted at 37°C for several hours before use. d. H-top agar: 1% tryptone, 140 mM NaCl, 0.8% bacto-agar. Melt agar as above and hold at 48OC m a waterbath until needed. 3. Sterile, detergent-free 1-L conical flasks fitted with porous tops or cotton-wool bungs and an orbital incubator capable of shaking these vigorously (around 250 rpm) at 37°C. 4. 50-mL polypropylene tubes (e.g., disposable Falcon 2070 or reusable Oakridge, sterile and detergent-free), and a centrifuge, preferably refrigerated, capable of spinning these tubes at 4,000g. 5. Transformation buffers (see Note 2): a. 100 mM Calcium chloride: Store 1M CaC12 at -20°C m 1.5-mL aliquots. When needed, thaw, dilute to 15 mL, filter, and chill on ice. b. TFB: 10 mM K-MES, 100 mM RbCl or KCl, 45 mMMnC12. 4H20, 10 mM CaC12. 2H20, 3 mM hexamminecobalt chloride. Make up a 1M stock of MES, adJust the pH to 6.3 with 5M KOH, and store at -20°C m IO-mL ahquots. To make up 1 L of TFB, use one 10 mL aliquot of IM K-MES, add all the other salts as solids, filter, and store m 15mL aliquots at 4OC, where tt is stable for over a year. It is important that the final pH of the buffer is 6.15 f 0.1. c. FSB: 10 mM potassium acetate, 100 rniV KCl, 45 mM MnC12 . 4H20, 10 mM CaCl, . 2H20, 3 rruV hexammmecobalt chloride, 10% glyc-
Transfection
of E. coli Cells
33
erol. Make up a 1M stock of potassium acetate, adjust the pH to 7.2 with 2M acetic acid, and store at -20°C in lo-mL ahquots. To make up 1 L of FSB, use one lo-mL aliquot of 1M potassium acetate, add the other salts as solids, glycerol to lo%, adjust the pH to 6.4 with 0.W HCl (N.B. if you add too much, do not attempt to readjust the pH with base: discard the batch and start again), filter, and store in 15mL aliquots at 4°C. During storage, the pH of this buffer drifts down to 6.1-6.2 and then stabilizes. d. DMSO/DTT (see Note 3): Make up 1M potassium acetate as in step 5c, above, and store in 100~& aliquots. Take a fresh bottle of highest grade DMSO, divide into IO-mL aliquots and store m sterile, tightly capped tubes at -7OOC. To make up 10 mL of DMSO/DTI’, use one lOO+L aliquot of 1M potassium acetate, 9 mL DMSO, 1.53 g of DTT, sterilize through a filter that will withstand organic solvents (e.g., Millex SR, millipore), and store in 300-w aliquots at -20°C. 6. Fresh cells/X-gal/IPTG: Make this up just before you need it, calculating the volumes required for your total number of samples. Per sample, take 200 pL of fresh E. coli cells and gently add 40 pL of X-gal (20 mg/ mL m dimethylformamide) and 40 p.L of IPTG (24 mg/mL in water). 7. Sterile, disposable 5-mL tubes (e.g., Falcon 2054).
3. Methods All the methods relate to the preparation of competent cells from a 50 mL log-phase culture. 3.1. Preparation
of Log Phase Cells
1. Pick a single bacterial colony from a fresh plate, or take 500 pL of a fresh overnight culture, and transfer into 50 mL of L-broth (for Calcium method) or SOB-broth (for Hanahan method) in a conical flask. Set up duplicates, one for preparing competent cells and the other for fresh plating cells that are required in step 3 of Section 3.4. 2. Incubate flasks at 37OCwith vigorous shaking until the cell concentration reaches around 5 x 107/mL. For most E. coli strains this means an Abe,,of between 0.3 and 0.4, and will take around 3 h incubation from a single colony, around 2 h from an overnight culture. 3. Transfer the contents of one flask to a sterile, precooled, 50-mL tube and store on ice for 10 mm to cool the cells. 4. Pellet cells by spinning at 4000g for 10 min and carefully pour off the broth, mverting the tube to drain away the last traces. Choose either method .2 or .3 for making competent cells, with all steps carried out aseptically.
34
Tomley
3.2. Fresh or Frozen Competent Using Calcium Chloride
Cells
1. Suspend cells in 10 mL of cold O.lM CaCl*, store on ice for 5 min, then pellet as in step 4 of Section 3.1. 2. Suspend cells gently in 2.5 mL of cold O.lM CaClz and incubate on ice until ready for use. At this point cells can be dispensed m small aliquots into cooled sterile 1.5-mL tubes, snap-frozen in liquid nitrogen, and stored at -70°C until needed, when they should be thawed rapidly then immediately stored on ice.
3.3. Fresh or Frozen Competent Using Hanahan Method
Cells
1. Suspend cells in 10 mL of cold TFB (for fresh) or FSB (for freezing), store on ice for 10 mm then pellet as m step 4 of Sectton 3.1, 2. Suspend cells gently in 4 mL of cold TFB or FSB and store on me. 3. Add 140 pL of DMSO/DTT (for fresh) or DMSO alone (for freezing), mix immediately by gentle swirling, and store cells on ice for 15 min. 4. Add a further 140 pL of DMSO/DTT or DMSO, and mix immediately. Fresh cells should be stored on ice for at least 15 min then dispensed m small aliquots mto cooled 5-mL tubes. For freezing cells, proceed with step 5, below. 5. Dispense cells in small aliquots into cooled 5-mL tubes, snap-freeze m liquid nitrogen, and store at -70°C until needed. Thaw ahquots rapidly, then store cells on ice for 15 mm prior to use.
3.4. Introduction of Ml3 DNA to Competent and Generation of Progeny Plaques
Cells
1. Incubate tubes of competent cells m an rcewater bath. For most purposes 50-pL aliquots of cells will generate sufficient plaques, but more may be used if very high numbers are required (see Notes 4 and 5). 2. Carefully add 5 pL of an Ml3 ligation containing approximately 40400 ng total DNA to each ahquot and swirl gently (see Note 6). Leave m the icewater bath for 30-45 min. In addition to the ligations, two transformation controls should be included, one containing 5-10 pg of ds circular Ml3 DNA, and one containmg no DNA. 3. Meanwhile, melt sufficient H-top agar (3 ml/plate, plus a few mL excess) and keep It m a waterbath at 48OC. Just before moving on to step 4, below, take the second flask of cells (from step 1 of Section 3.1.) and make up sufficrent fresh cells/X-gal/IPTG mix (280 pL/plate). 4. Transfer the tubes of competent cells/ligations to a rack in a waterbath, preheated to 42°C and leave for exactly 90 s without shaking (see Note
Transfection
of E. coli Cells
7). Transfer rapidly back into the icewater bath and make up to 200 pL with SOB-broth (minus MgZ2+). If you think you are going to get too many plaques, then split the samples at this point, e.g., leave a 180 pL in the first tube and transfer 20 pL to a second. 5. Add 280 pL of fresh cells/X-gal/IPTG mix to each sample then, working one sample at a time, add 3 mL of H-top agar, mrx quickly, and pour onto a dry H-agar plate. Be careful not to mtroduce air bubbles. 6. Allow plates to dry thoroughly then incubate overnight at 37°C (see Note 8). Plaques formed by wild-type Ml 3 will be blue, and those formed by recombinants will be white (see Note 4).
4. Notes 1. Host bacteria can be stored for short periods at 4°C on mmtmal (M9) agar, which maintains the F’episome, but should be replated frequently from a master stock stored at -7OOC in L-broth plus 15% glycerol. 2. For making up and storing all transformation buffers: use only high quality pure water, e.g., Milli-Q or equivalent; use sterile, detergent-free glassware or plasticware; 9 sterilize solutrons by filtration through 0.45pm pore filters, e g., Nalgene or Acrodisc. 3. In the original Hanahan method, DMSO and DTT solutions were added sequentially. However, the efficiency of transformation is just as high rf they are added together (3). 4. The number of plaques that are obtained from each transfection varies enormously and is dependent on many factors, such as the amount of DNA added, the ratio of insert to vector in the ligation reaction, the efficiency of ligation, and the efficiency of transformatron. As a guide, closed circular Ml3 DNA should give over lo7 plaques&g using the Hanahan method thus the control transfected with 10 pg of ds Ml3 DNA should yield over 100 plaques. Vector DNA that has been linearized then religated to an excess of Insert with compatible ends will give anything from 102-lo4 less plaques per pg, depending on the religation efficiency, thus, each test transfection of 40-400 ng may give between 40 and 40,000 plaques. For the Calcium method, the numbers of plaques are around 2-lo-fold lower. Freshly prepared Calcium-treated cells can be stored for up to 48 h in CaCl, at 4OC and the efficiency of transfection increases up to six-fold over the first 24 h then declines to the original level (4). 5. The efficiency of transformation using frozen competent cells is reduced compared to freshly prepared cells but, unless very high numbers of plaques are required, frozen cells are adequate and very convenient, l
l
36
Tomley
6. The volume of ligated DNA added to the cells should not exceed 10% of the total volume. 7. The length of time for heat-shock is calibrated for Falcon 2054 tubes and for others the heat-up time may be different. 8. It is important that agar plates are thoroughly dried before top agar 1s poured onto them.
References 1 Mandel M. and Higa A (1970) Calcium-dependent bacteriophage DNA mfection J. Mel Biol. 53, 109-118. 2 Hanahan D. (1983) Studies on transformation of Escher&ia coli with plasmids J Mol. Blol 166,557-580. 3 Sambrook J , Fritsch E. F , and Maniatrs T (1989) ‘Preparatron and Transformation of competent E coli,’ m Molecular Cloning, A Laboratory Manual, 2nd ed , Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press, Cold Spring Harbor, NY, pp 1 74-1.84 4 Dagert M and Ehrlich S D (1979) Prolonged incubation m calcium chloride improves the competence of Escherichia colr cells Gene 6,23-28
Ml3 Phage Growth and Single-Strand DNA Preparation
1. Introduction Ml3 phages do not lyse their host, but are released from infected cells as the cells continue to grow and divide. Cells infected with Ml3 have a longer replication cycle than uninfected cells, and as the infection proceeds, areas of slower-growing cells can be visualized as turbid plaques on lawns of E. coli (1). Well-separated plaques contain cells infected with phages derived from a single transformation event and these can be picked and regrown to provide pure stocks of recombinant phage particles and DNA. During infection of its host cell, the single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) of the phage is converted and amplified into double stranded replicative forms (RF) that are intermediates in the production of progeny ssDNA. These ssDNA molecules are packaged into a protein coat and extruded out of the cell and, since there is no size constraint on packaging, recombinants containing foreign DNA are readily produced. From liquid culture, packaged particles are readily recoverable from the broth and the ssDNA can be rapidly extracted (2,3). The method is straightforward, and because Ml3 phages replicate rapidly, both phage growth and DNA purification can be carried out in one day provided that a fresh overnight culture of host bacteria is available. From* Methods m Molecular Slology, Vol. 23: DNA Sequencrng Protocols E&ted by. H. and A. Griffin Copynght 01993 Humana Press Inc., Totowa,
37
NJ
38
Tomley
2. Materials 1. An E. coli strain suitable for propagating bacteriophage Ml3 vectors Recommended strains mclude JMlOl, JM103, JM107, JM109, TGI, and TG2. 2. 2X TY broth: 1% tryptone, 1% yeast, 100 mM NaCl. Sterthze by autoclaving in 50-mL aliquots. 3. Stertle culture tubes for growmg up 1.5 mL cultures (e.g., disposable lo-mL Falcon tubes or glass/plastic universal bottles) and an orbital incubator for shaking the tubes vigorously at 37OC. 4. A mrcrofuge and 1S-mL mrcrofuge tubes. 5. Solutions a. PEG/NaCl: 20% PEG, 2.5M NaCl. Make up 100 mL at a trme and sterilize by ftltration. Store at 4°C. b. TE: 10 mA4Tris-HCl, 1 mIt4 EDTA (pH 8.0). For convenience, store 1M Tris-HCl, 100 mM EDTA, pH 8.0, m I-mL aliquots at -20°C. When needed, thaw, dilute to 100 mL, check the pH, filter, and store at room temperature. c. Phenol: Use high-grade redistilled phenol stored at -2OOC in aliquots of 100 -500 mL. To equtlibrate, warm to room temperature, then melt at 65°C and add hydroxyquinoline to 0.1%. To the melted phenol, add an equal volume of 0.5M Trts-HCl, pH 8.0, mtx for a few minutes to allow phases to separate, and take off the upper layer (buffer). Do repeated extractions with O.lM Trts-HCl, pH 8.0, unttl the pH of the phenolic phase gets up to around 7.8. Extract once wrth TE, remove the aqueous phase, then store the phenol at 4°C in a dark bottle under a layer of fresh TE (around 20 mL for 100 mL phenol). Fresh phenol should be prepared once a month. d. Chloroform: Use high-grade chloroform that has not been exposed to the air for long periods of time. Mix 24.1 with isoamyl alcohol and store m a tightly capped bottle at room temperature. e. 3M sodium acetate, pH 5.2: Dissolve solid sodmm acetate in water, adjust the pH to 5.2 with glacial acetic actd, dtspense into aliquots, autoclave, and store at room temperature. f. Ethanol: For convenience, store in tightly capped bottles at -20°C.
3. Method 1. Pick a single colony from a freshly streaked plate of a suitable E. coli host strain into 10 mL of 2X TY m a conical flask and grow with shaking at 37°C overmght. 2. Dilute the overnight culture 1:OOin 2X TY to give sufftctent fresh culture for 1.5 ml/plaque. Ahquot 1.5-mL vol into sterile tubes.
Liquid
Culture and SSDNA Preparation
39
3. Carefully touch a sterile toothpick into a well-separated single plaque and wash the end of the toothpick in a 1.5-mL aliquot of fresh cells (see Notes 1 and 2). This IS sufficient to transfer Infected cells from the plaque to the new culture. Incubate the 1.5-mL cultures with vigorous shaking at 37°C for 4.5-5.5 h (see Notes 3 and 4). 4. Transfer cultures to 1.5~mL microfuge tubes and spin for 5 min in a microfuge. 5. Transfer supernatants to clean tubes making sure the pellet is undisturbed, add 200 uL of PEG/NaCl to each, vortex well, and leave at room temperature for at least 15 min. 6. Spin for 5 min in microfuge to pellet the phage particles. Remove the PEG-containing supernatant with a pipet, respin the tubes for a few seconds and carefully remove all remaming traces of supernatant from around the phage pellet using a drawn-out Pasteur pipet (see Note 5). The phage pellet should be visible at the bottom of the tube. 7. Add 100 pL of TE to each phage pellet and vortex vigorously to ensure that they are properly resuspended, then add 50 pL of phenol, vortex well, and leave for a few minutes. Vortex again and spin for 2 mm to separate the phases. 8. Carefully remove the upper aqueous layer into a fresh 1.5~mL tube, being careful to leave behind all the precipitated material at the interface. 9. Add 50 pL of chloroform, vortex and spin for 1 min to separatethe phases (see Note 6). 10. Carefully remove the upper aqueous layer into a fresh 1.5-mL tube, add 0.1 vol of 3M sodium acetate and 2.5 vol of absolute ethanol and precipitate the DNA. 11. Spin in microfuge for 5 min and remove the ethanol by aspiration, being careful not to disturb the DNA pellet that is often barely visible at this stage. Add 200 l,tL of 70% ethanol, spin for 2 min, remove the ethanol very carefully, and dry the pellet either under vacuum for a few minutes or by leaving the open tubes on the bench until dried by evaporation, 12. Dissolve the pellet in 30 pL of TE. At this stage, a few microliters (2-5 pL) can be removed and run on a minigel to check the quality and yield of DNA (see Note 7). The remainder of the DNA should be stored at -20°C until required.
4. Notes 1. If plaques have been picked and regrown on plates as colonies (e.g., because of the need to screen inserts by hybridization), cultures for ssDNA preps are prepared by touching the toothpicks onto the colomes and washing in the 1 S-mL fresh cells.
40
Tomley
2. Once plaques have been obtamed, it is best to grow phages and purify the DNA as quickly as possible as there is an increase m plaque contamination and a deterioration m quahty of DNA obtamed tf plaques are stored at 4°C. 3. Do not grow up 1.5mL cultures for extended perrods of time as this increases the possibtlity of selecting for mutants and also increases cell lysis and htgher levels of contaminating host chromosomal DNA. 4. Do not grow at temperatures above 37°C because although the host cells ~111grow the ytelds of Ml3 phages drop rapidly with increasing temperature. 5. Make sure all the PEG is removed as this causes high backgrounds m sequencing reactions. 6. The chloroform extraction can be omitted, but the highest quality templates are obtamed tf rt 1sincluded. 7 A yield of ssDNA of between 5 and 10 pg/mL ts normal. If the final pellet 1ssuspended in 30 pL of TE, approx 4-8 pL IS ample for obtaming high-quality sequence using standard dtdeoxy methods.
References 1 Marvm, D. A. and Hohn, B. (1969). Filamentous bacterial viruses. Bacteriol Rev. 33, 172-209. 2 Bankier, A. and Barrell, B. G. (1983) “Shotgun DNA Sequencing.” In Techniques in the Life Sciences (Biochemistry), ~0185, Techniques in Nuclerc Acid Biochemistry (Flavell, R A , ed ), pp l-34, Elsevier, Amsterdam 3 Sambrook, J., Fntsch, E. F., and Maniatis, T. (1989) “Small-scale preparation of single-stranded Bacteriophage Ml3 DNA.” In Molecular Closmg, A Laboratory Manual. 2nd Ed., Cold Sprmg Harbor Laboratory Press, Cold Sprmg Harbor, NY, pp 4-29,4-30.
&4PTER
6
Ml3 Phage Growth and DNA Purification Using 96 Well Microtiter Trays Alan l! Bankier 1. Introduction The growth and purification of M 13 DNA from small volume (1 SmL) cultures is a rapid and easily performed procedure (1). The samples can be processed in microcentrifuges in disposable polypropylene tubes and yield sufficient, pure single-stranded DNA (4 M) for five or more sequencing experiments. Even when several cultures are to be grown and purified simultaneously, up to 100 can be processed to completion in a day. The handling of this number of samples is tedious, however, and much time is spent opening and closing tubes and transferring tubes in and out of microcentrifuges. One hundred small volume phenol extractions and ethanol precipitations tasks even the more dedicated sequencer. When contemplating larger sequencing projects, the thought of processing the several thousand recombinants needed is indeed daunting. Shotgun sequencingof 100kb requires over 3000 random templates (2,3) and each template is rarely sequencedmore than just the once. Clearly, any further simplification of the procedure would be of great benefit. If reduced yields can be tolerated, one solution lies in the use of microtiter trays (4,5). Phage can be grown, in small volume, in the ninety-six wells of a microtiter tray and, by modification of conventional purification methods, they can also be processedin the trays. Using microtiter From: Methods m Molecular Wology, Vol. 23’ DNA Sequencrng Protocols EdIted by H and A Gnffm Copynght 01993 Humana Press inc., Totowa,
41
NJ
42
Bankier
trays removes most of the tedious handling needed when tubes are
used and makes the process even quicker. Several microtiter trays can be handled at once, making the preparation of several hundred recombinants fairly trivial. Each culture provides sufficient DNA for 2-3 conventional sequencing experiments. A small residue can be kept in a library for regrowth, should this become necessary. The procedure is summarized in Fig. 1.
2. Materials 1. Autoclaved 2X YT broth: 1% bactotryptone, 1% yeastextract, 0.5% NaCl. 2. Sterile polystyrene 96-well microtiter trays (e.g., Cornmg cell wells) There appears to be little advantage to using either tissue culture treated or nontreated plates. 3. Rigid plastic “sandwich” boxes (with lids) approx dimensions 12 x 18 x 6 cm. These are used simply as a convement holder for microttter trays, providmg sufficient air supply for good phage growth but maintaming an isolated environment. The trays can be held m position within the boxes using blocks of foam sponge. 4. Sterile, uncoated, wooden toothpicks. 5. A benchtop centrifuge capable of spinning microtiter trays at speeds up to 4000 rpm (such as the I.E.C. Centra 4X). If this speed cannot be attained, the centrifugation times will need to be extended. 6. PEG/NaCI: 20 % polyethylene glycol (mol wt 6000-8000), 2.5M sodium chloride. 7. T.E.: 10 mM Tris-HCl, pH 8.0,O.l mM Na,EDTA. 8. T.E./SDS: 1% sodmm dodecyl sulfate in T.E. 9. Ethanol/NaOAc: 95% ethanol and 3M sodium acetate, pH 5.0, equrlibrated usmg acetic acid, combined in the ratio 25: 1. 10. Self adhesive microtiter plate sealers (e.g., Cornmg 3095).
3. Method 1. Prepare an overnight culture of suitable host strain (e.g., TGl or JM109) by toothpickmg a single colony into 10 mL of 2X YT. Grow the culture at 37°C m an orbital shaker at 300-350 rpm for 18 h. 2. Make a dilutton of the stationary phase, overnight culture 1: 100 m 2X YT (25 mL for each plate of 96 phage cultures) and pipet 250 pL into each well of the microtiter tray(s). 3. Transfer a single recombinant phage into each well by carefully touchmg the center of the plaque with a sterile toothpick and flushing the toothpick pomt by rotating it m the diluted cell culture in the well. Take care to touch the plaque only lightly and to avoid touchmg any neighbor-
Preparing
Ml3
DNA in Microtiter
Toothplck
Plaques
1 Grow
I
I
6 Hours
Pellet
1
Cells I Supernatant
1 Transfer PEG
43
Trays
Preclpltate
Phage
I Phaae In SDS
Denature
1
I
1 Ethanol
Preclpltate
DNA 1
I Redissolve Fig. 1 A
DNA In T.E.
summary of template growth and purification m mrcrotiter trays.
mg plaques. As a guide, rt should only just be apparent which plaques have been lifted (see Notes 1-3). 4. Secure the tray, uncovered, inside a plasttc box fitted with a lid. Place the box instde an orbrtal shaker and grow the culture for 6 h at 37OCat a speed of 300 rpm(see Notes 4-7). 5. Remove the culture tray from the box and centrifuge it for 10 min at 4000 rpm. Using a multichannel pipet, very carefully remove 200 pL of the supernatant and transfer it to a clean microtiter tray (see Note 8). 6. Repeat the centrrfugatton step and very carefully transfer 150 pL of supernatant to a clean tray. 7. Add 30 pL of PEG/NaCI to each well, cover the tray with a plate sealer to isolate each well, and mtx tt thoroughly (a multttube vortexer is very convenient) leave it at room temperature for 15 min (see Note 9). 8. Centrifuge the tray for 10 min at 4000 rpm and discard the supernatant. This IS most easily done by inverting the tray sharply (catching the supernatant in disinfectant) and leaving the inverted tray on tissue to drain for 5 min with occasional gentle tapping.
44
Bankier
9. Add 50 pL of T.E./SDS to each well and seal the tray completely with a plate sealer. Ensure complete dissolution of the phage pellet by shaking the tray in a multitube vortexer for 2-3 mm. Put the tray lid on over the sealer, and place the tray m an incubator at 80°C for 20 mm (see Note 10). 10. Remove the tray and allow tt to cool to room temperature. Add 125 pL of ethanol/NaOAc to each well, cover the tray with a plate sealer, and mtx It thoroughly. Leave the DNA to precipitate at room temperature for 15 mm (see Note 11). 11. Centrifuge the tray for 10 mmutes at 4000 rpm and discard the supernatant by invertmg the tray sharply. Add 200 pL of 95% ethanol to each well to wash the pellet and immediately discard the supernatant as before. Leave the tray inverted on tissue to dram for 5 mm and dry the pellets under vacuum for 5 mm. 12. Redissolve the DNA in 20 pL of T.E., seal the tray with a plate sealer, and store it at -20°C. 4. Notes 1, Always dispose of phage and cell contaminated materials by soaking m dtstnfectant/autoclavtng.Bad technique can contammate stocksand can even result in the growing of hundreds of individual cultures of the same phage 2. Recombinant phage can be stored m T.E. at 4°C for many days or even weeks and 1s preferable to storage on agar plates. Plaques can be toothpicked into 15 pL of T.E. m individual wells of a 96-well mrcrottter tray, sealed with a plate sealer and stored in a refrigerator. When DNA is to be prepared from these recombinants, tt ts only necessary to add 250 pL of diluted host cells and continue wtth described procedure. 3. Optimal results are only obtained using the healthiest of cells that are growing vtgorously. The overnight culture should be started using a single colony from a minimal media plate that was streaked from frozen stock host cells no more than about one week prevtously. 4. When using an orbital shaker havmg a bed designed for tubes, the sandwich boxes can be secured m posmon by glumg cylindrtcal feet of appropriate size and spacing to the bottom of the boxes The feet will then slot mto the tube holes holding the box m place. Tubes and trays can then be shaken stmultaneously and without changing shaker format. 5. Ml3 phage growth is very sensitive to both temperature and rate of shakmg. Ensure that the temperature is not permuted to rise even margmally above 37°C and that the shaker 1srestricted to between 30&350 rpm. 6. The frequency of poor sequence quality increases wtth prolonged phage growth times. Do not exceed the recommended period of 6 h.
Preparing
Ml3 DNA in Microtiter
Trays
7. When insufficient time exists for complete processing of the samples, it is best to set up the phage cultures late m the day. The tray can be placed m the shaker, at room temperature, connected to the voltage supply through a timer set to turn it on in the early hours of the morning. The following day, 6 h after the timer is set to start, the tray of cultures can be processed to completion. 8. The most difficult aspect of this procedure is transfer of the phage supernatant without disturbing the cell pellet, and it is this difficulty that necessitates a second cell centrifugation step. It takes a steady hand and a keen eye to handle a multichannel pipet accurately and consistently without stirring up cells. One solution is to fabricate a pipet holder that constrains the height of the pipet and permits a microtiter tray to be stepped in columns beneath it. The most consistent results, however, have been obtained using a robotic workstation, as described in Chapter 38. 9. It IS very important to completely redissolve the PEG precipitated phage. Incomplete dissolution results in reduced yields and poorer quality. Using a flat bed multitube vortexer at maximum speed for 2-3 min is the easiest way to do this. 10. At the elevated temperatures used during the SDS step, microtiter tray plate sealers tend to warp and peel off. Putting the tray lid on durmg this incubation helps to keep the sealer m place and minimizes evaporation loss. 11. Ethanol tends to dissolve the adhesive used on plate sealers. Once mixed, do not be tempted to repeat the shaking.
References 1, Messing, J and Bankier, A. T. (1989) The use of single-strandedDNA phage in DNA sequencing,in Nucleic Acids Sequencing. A Practical Approach (Howe, C. J. and Ward, E. S., eds ), IRL Press, Oxford, pp. l-36 2. Bankrer, A. T., Beck, S., Bohm, R., Brown, C. M., Cerny, R., Chee, M. S., Hutchison, C. A., III, Kouzarides, T., Martrgnetti, J. A., Preddie, E., Satchwell, S. C., Tomlinson, P., Weston, K. M., and Barrell, B. G. (1991) The DNA sequence of the human cytomegalovirus genome. DNA Sequence 2, l-12. 3 Davrson, A. J (1991) Experience m shotgun sequencmg a 134 kilobase pair DNA molecule. DNA Sequence 1,389-394. 4. Eperon, I. C (1986) Rapid preparation of bacteriophage DNA for sequence analysis in sets of 96 clones, using filtration. Anal. Biochem. 56,406-412. 5 Smith, V., Brown, C. M , Bankrer, A. T., and Barrell, B. G. (1990) Semiautomated preparation of DNA templates for large-scale sequencing projects. DNA Sequence 1,73-78
&AE’TER
Generation
7
of kdom Fragments by Sonication Alan
CCBankier
1. Introduction Except for all but the shortest of sequencing projects, the resolution limits of polyacrylamide gels (being somewhat less than 1 kb) prevents determining the entire sequencein one run. There are several ways to overcome this by subcloning or by primer walking. Each has its advantages and disadvantages.These alternatives should be considered whenever a new project is undertaken.Frequently, the best approach would in fact use more than one method. A high proportion of large-scale sequencing projects use random cloning and sequencing(shotgun sequencing) to produce in excess of 95% of the data, and then employ more directed means to complete it (I-3). The shotgun method (4) benefits from making no prior assumptions about the DNA to be sequenced,such as base composition or the presence of certain restriction enzyme sites. The DNA to be sequenced is randomly broken down to clonable sizes, optionally size selected, and subcloned. Sequences from these recombinants are determined at random until the individual readings can be joined together by virtue of overlaps. There are several ways of producing random breaks either enzymatically or physically. Enzymic methods such as DNAse 1 (5) require calibration for each enzyme preparation, to accurately assessits activFrom Methods m Molecular Biology, Vol. 23: DNA Sequencrng Protocols Edited by: H. and A. Griffm Copyrlght 81993 Humana Press Inc., Totowa,
47
NJ
48
Bankier
ity, and for each DNA solution since the degree of enzyme action is specific to the length of the DNA and its concentration. Physical methods such as sonication (6,7), are insensitive to concentration and, to a high degree, even length. Mechanical shearing has a greater effect on larger molecules; the shorter the length, the more difficult it is to shear. The effect of this is that a wide range of initial lengths (from hundreds of bases to hundreds of kilobases) will be reduced to a similar size range when the limits of a particular device is approached. The size range generated will be solely dependant on the power of the sonicator or the force used in the physical process. When using a sonicator this is very easy to control. The method described here uses a Heat Systems Ultrasonics (Farmingdale, NY) W-385 sonicator fitted with a cup horn. The benefits of using a cup horn are that samples in a few microliters can be sheared and no potential for crosscontamination exists. Several samples can even be processed simultaneously. Any sonicator can be used all that is needed is a simple time course of sonication, at a given power setting, to determine the minimum time needed to give the desired size range. Any unwanted DNA can be used for thus time course. 2. Materials 1. 10X Ligase buffer: 500 mM Tris-HCI, pH 7.5, 100 mM magnesium chlorrde, 100 mA4dithiothreitol, 10 mM ATP, 250 clg/mL bovine serum albumen. 2. T4 DNA ligase. 3. A Heat Systems Ultrasonics W-385 somcator fitted with a cup horn probe, or any other precalibrated somcator. 4. Chasemix: 0.5 mMdATP, 0.5 mMdCTP,0.5 n-uV!dGTP, 0.5 mMdl’“TP. 5. Klenow fragment DNA polymerase. 6. T4 DNA polymerase. 7. 20% P.E.G.: 20% polyethylene glycol (mol wt 6000-8000), 1M NaCl. 8. A flat bed agarose gel apparatus. This need only be a minigel system of dimensions 10 x 10 cm or even smaller. 9. Low melting temperature agarose. 10. 10X T.B.E.: 108 g Tris base, 55 g boric acid, 9.3 g Na,EDTA dissolved and made up to 1 L m deionized water. 11. T.B.E. dye mix: 0.1 g xylene cyan01 F.F., 0.1 g bromophenol blue, 20% sucrose in T.B.E. buffer. 12. 3M sodium acetate, pH 5.0 equilibrated using acetic acid. 13 T.E. buffer 10 mM Tris-HCl, pH 8.0,O.l mM Na,EDTA.
Generating Fragments
by Sonication
49
3. Method 1. Self-ligate 5-10 pg of the DNA to be sequenced by mixing m a microcentrifuge tube: 5-10 pg of the linear DNA, 3 pL 10X ligase buffer, 10 U T4 DNA hgase (use 100 U for blunt-ended fragments), make up the volume to 30 pL with sterile distilled water, and incubate at 15°C for 2 h (see Notes 1 and 2). 2. Position the tube m the cup horn filled with tee-cold water so that the bottom of the tube is just above but not touching the probe. Sonicate the sample on full power for 20 s. Using a W-385, this produces a peak in size around 1 kb (see Note 3). 3. End-repair the somcated fragments by adding to the tube 4 pL of chase mix, 10 U of Klenow fragment DNA polymerase, and 10 U of T4 DNA polymerase. Incubate the reaction for 30 mm at 37OC and heat-kill the enzymes by heating to 70°C for 10 mm. Add distilled or deionized water to 50 pL and ethanol precipitate the DNA. 4. Redissolve the fragments in 100 l.tL of T.E. and selectively precipitate the fragments longer than 400 bp by adding 66 pL of 20% P.E.G.IlM sodium chloride and leaving on ice 10 min. Centrifuge the tube for 10 mm in a microcentrifuge and remove all of the supernatant. Briefly respin the tube and remove any residual P.E.G. Redissolve the DNA in 50 pL of T.E. This should provide sufficient material for 50 blunt hgation/cloning experiments that, under ideal conditions, would yield several thousand recombmants (see Notes 4 and 5).
4. Notes 1. As little as 1 pg of DNA can be used to prepare sonicated fragments, but smce the overall efficiency of the process is low, it IS not recommended. 2. The mechanism of physical shearing tends to break molecules around their center. If the starting material is a linear molecule, the subfragments produced, therefore, will not have a random distribution. By simply self-ligating the linear molecule, a truly random fragment generation is produced. 3. If the only available sonicator is one fitted with a direct immersion probe, it is very important to clean it thoroughly to avoid crosscontamination. The required sonication time is also likely to be much shorter, as short as a few seconds. 4. The method described here uses P.E.G. precipitation for stze selection. Alternatives to this include size selection from agarose or no selection at all. For agarose selection, load the entire sonicated, end-repaired sample onto a l-cm slot on a low gelling temperature agarose minigel. Run the sample m 2-3 cm and cut out the size range needed. The fragments can be purified by any of the many described procedures (8).
50
Bankier
5. Fragments purified from low gelling temperature agarose frequently fail to hgate. This is assumed to be caused by mhlbitors not removed during the phenol extraction/ethanol preclpltatlon. The assumption would seem to be substantiated by the observation that the problem IS associated with particular batches of agarose. Similar inhibition by agarose contaminants would occasionally appear to prevent adequate end repair. If either of these 1s suspected, the only recourse is to try altemative batches of agarose or alternative means of fragment purification.
References 1. Chee, M S., Bankier, A. T , Beck, S., Bohm, R., Brown, C. M., Cerny, R , Horsnell, T , Hutchison, C. A., III, Kouzarides, T , Martignetti, J A., Predche, E , Satchwell, S C , Tomhnson, P , Weston, K M , and Barrell, B. G (1990) Analysis of the protein-coding content of the sequence of human cytomegalovlrus strain AD169, m Current Topics in Mzcrobzology and Immunology vol. 154, (McDougall, J. K., ed.), Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Heidelberg, pp. 125-169. 2. Baer, R., Bankier, A. T , Biggm, M D., Deininger, P. L., Farrell, P. J., Gibson, T. J., Hatfull, G , Hudson, G. S., Satchwell, S. C , Segum, C , Tuffnell, P S , and Barrell, B. G. (1984) DNA sequence and expression of the B95-8 EpsteinBarr virus genome. Nature 310,207-211 3. Davison, A. J. and Scott, J E (1986) The complete DNA sequence of vancellazoster virus J. Gen. Virol 67, 1759-l 816 4. Messing, J. and Bankier, A T (1989) The use of single-stranded DNA phage in DNA sequencing, in Nucleic Acids Sequencing. A Practical Approach (Howe, C. J. and Ward, E. S., eds.), IRL Press, Oxford, pp. l-36. 5. Anderson, S. (1981) Shotgun DNA sequencing usmg cloned DNAse l-generated fragments. Nucleic Acrds Res. 9,3015 6 Deininger, P. L. (1983) Random subcloning of sonicated DNA: application to shotgun DNA sequence analysis. Anal. Biochem. 129,216. 7 Bankier, A.T., Weston, K. M. and Barrel], B.G. (1987) Random clonmg and sequencing by the Ml3ldideoxynucleotide chain termrnatlon method, in Methods in Enzymology vol. 155, (R. Wu, ed.), Academic Press, London, pp. 51-93. 8. Sambrook, J , Fritsch, E. F., and Maniatis, T. (1989) Molecular Cloning: a Laboratory Manual 2nd ed Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press, Cold Spring Harbor, N Y
CHAPTER8
Generation of a Nested Set of Deletions Using Exonuclease III George
Murphy
1. Introduction Exonuclease III (Exo III) will digest double-stranded DNA in a 3’ to 5’ direction if the DNA is blunt-ended or possessesa 5’ overhang. It will not digest if there is a 3’ overhang of three or more bases, or if the 3’ end has had thiophosphate-containing bases incorporated into it. In order to generate a set of insert deletions using Exo III it is necessary to cut the polylinker twice with different restriction enzymes so that the cut end nearest the primer site possesses a 3’ overhang, or has thiophosphate residues at the 3’ end, and the end of the polylinker attached to the insert possessesa 5’ overhang or blunt end. If this can be achieved, digestion with Exo III will result in progressive deletion of the 3’ end of the insert, leaving a single-stranded 5’ overhang that can be removed by treatment with mung bean nuclease (I) or exonuclease VII (Exo VII). The blunt ends thus formed are ligated, a suitable host transformed, and colonies are picked at random and screened for insert size (2), following which a suitable range of inserts is then sequenced. One of the advantages of using directed deletions is the accuracy with which insert sizes can be measured by restriction enzyme digestion. Size selection is an essential part of this technique since there is a very broad distribution in size of insert obtained at each timepoint, From Methods m Molecular Wology, Vol 23 DNA Sequencing Protocols Edited by H and A Gnffln Copynght 01993 Humana Press Inc , Totowa,
51
NJ
52
Murphy
even if a clearly defined band is observed when the rate of deletion is being measured. A rapid screening procedure employing the isolation of crude plasmid from colony streaks, or more easily from small cultures grown up in microtiter wells, is outlined here. The number of clones that can be screened in a working day using this method is limited only by the running of the gels, as the isolation of crude plasmid takes about 30 min. Selected transformants can then be miniprepped and a more accurate estimation made of their insert size by restriction enzyme digest.
2. Materials 2.1. Exonuclease
Deletions
2.1.1. Linearizing the Insert 1. 10X TA buffer: 330 mM Trrs-acetate (pH 7.9), 660 mM potassium acetate, 100 mA4 magnesium acetate, 40 mM spermrdme, and 5 mM DTT NaCl can be added to TA buffer for those enzymes requumg a higher salt concentration. 2. Phenol/chloroform: Equal volumes of phenol (equilibrated wrth TE) and chloroform:isoamyl alcohol (25: 1 v/v). 3. Chloroform. 4. Sepharose-CL-6B: Equilibrate the Sepharose (Pharmacia, Upssala, Sweden) in TO.lE and adjust to a packed gel: buffer ratio of 2:l. 5. 10X Exo III buffer: 500 mM Tris-HCl, pH 8.0, 50 mM MgC12, and 10 mh4 DTT. 6. TE: 10 mM Tris-HCl (pH S.O), 1 mM EDTA. 7. TO.lE: 10 mM Tris-HCl (pH 8,0), 0.1 mM EDTA. 2.1.2. Protecting the Primer Site with Thiophosphates 1, 10X TM: 100 miJ4 Tris-HCI, pH 8.0, 50 mM MgCl*. 2. Thio-dNTPs: 20 mM in each thiophosphate dATP, dCTP, dGTP, or dTTP (Amersham, Arlington Heights, IL), pH 8.0. 3. Klenow fragment of DNA polymerase (BRL, Richmond, LA) 4. Phenol/chloroform. 5. Chloroform. 6. Sepharose-CL-6B. 2.1.3. Digestion with Exo III 1. Exo III (BRL). 2. Stop buffer: 10 mM Tris-HCl, pH 8.0, 10 mM EDTA. 3. 10 Exo VII buffer: 500 mM potassium phosphate pH 7.9,90 mM EDTA and 10 mM DTT.
Exonuclease
Deletions
53
2.1.4. Blunting the DNA 2.1.4.1. BLUNTING WITH MUNG BEAN NUCLEASE 1. Mung bean nuclease buffer: 30 mkf sodium acetate,50 miJ4NaCl, 1 rnk! ZnCl*, 1 mM cysteine, 0.001% (v/v) triton, and 5% (v/v) glycerol. 2. Mung bean nuclease (BRL). 3. Phenol/chloroform. 4. Chloroform. 5. Sodium acetate: 3M sodium acetate, pH 5.0. 6. 96% Ethanol. 7. TE. 2.1.4.2. BLUNTING WITH Exo VII EXONUCLEASE 1, Exo VII buffer. 2. Exo VII (BRL).
3. Sodium acetate. 4. Ethanol. 5. Sepharose-CL-6B. 6. TE. 7. 10X TA buffer. 8. T4 DNA polymerase (BRL). 9. dNTPs: Solution 2.5 mM m each of dATP, dCTP, dGTP, and dTTP.
2.1.5. Ligation 1. 10X Ligation buffer: 500 rnkf Tris-HCl, pH 7.5, 100 mJ4 MgC&, 100 mM DTT, 10 mM spermidine, 10 mkf ATP, and 1 mg/mL BSA. 2. T4 DNA ligase (BRL). 2.2. Template Screening 1. LB: 1% bacto tryptone, 0.5% bacto yeast extract, and 1% NaCl (all w/v). 2. Protoplasting buffer: 20 mM Tris-HCl, pH 7.5, 5 mM EDTA, 50 rnk! NaCl, 20% w/v sucrose, 100 clg/mL RNase A, and 100 crg/mL lysozyme. 3. Lysis buffer: 2.5 mM EDTA, 2% SDS, 10% w/v sucrose, and 0.04% w/v bromophenol blue. 4. Gel buffer: 1X TBE, 0.05% SDS (w/v). 5. Gel stain: 0.5 pg/mL ethidium bromide in water. 3. Methods 3.1. Exonuclease Deletions To prepare the DNA for Exo III treatment the sample is first digested with two restriction enzymes, one leaving a blunt end or a 5’ overhang at the end of the insert to be deleted, the other protecting the
54
Murphy
vector primer site from deletion by leaving a 3’ overhang of at least three bases. As an alternative, the digestion is performed in two steps. In the first step the site to be used to protect the priming site is 3’ endfilled with thiophosphates. In the second step the insert is prepared for deletion by digesting off its 3’ thiophosphate protection with an enzyme leaving a blunt end or a 5’ overhang (see Notes 1 and 2). 3.1.1. Linearizing the Insert 1. Mix 15 pg DNA, water, 8 pL 10X TA buffer, and 40 U of both restriction enzymes m a total volume Notes 3 and 4).
of 80 pL. Digest for 2 h at 37°C (see
2. Add 50 pL phenol/chloroform and vortex for 1 min before centrrfuganon at 10,OOOgfor 4 mm. Repeat the extraction with 50 pL chloroform. 3. Spin-dtalyze the sample on acolumn prepared from 500 pL of Sepharose slurry (see Chapter 19 and Note 5). Add 14 pL 10X Exo III buffer, adjust the volume to 140 pL, and use 70 p.L for digestion with Exo III, storing the remainder of the sample at -20°C. 3.1.2. Protecting
the Primer Site with Thiophosphate
1. Perform steps l-3 from Section 3.1.1. above as far as the spin-dialysis, but using in step 1 40 U of the restriction enzyme distal to the site to be used to expose the insert (i.e., the restriction site closest to the primer site of the vector).
2. Add 10 pL 10X TM and 2 pL of thlophosphate-dNTPs, followed by 15 U Klenow fragment of DNA polymerase Incubate 30 mm at room temperature.
I in a total volume
of 100 pL
3. Heat at 65°C for 10 min then cool to room temperature. 4. Add 10 pL of 1OX TA, 40 U of an enzyme that will produce a blunt end or a 5’ overhang
at the end of the insert, releasing
the thiophosphate
labeled site, and water to 120 pL. Incubate for 1 h at 37°C. 5. Extract with phenol/chloroform and chloroform as above then spm-dialyze the sample on a column prepared from 600 & Sepharose slurry (see Chapter 19). Contmue as m 3.1.1. above.
3.1.3. Digestion with Exo III The prepared sample is then treated with Exo III to progressively delete through the insert and samples removed at appropriate times, including a zero-time sample. 1. Premcubate the sample for 2 mm at 37°C then add 125 U Exo III Mix rapidly and immediately
remove 10 pL to (1) 10 pL stop buffer if using
Exonuclease
55
Deletions
mung bean nuclease to generate blunt ends, or (ii) to 1.5 pL 10X Exo VII buffer and 4 pL water if usmg Exo VII. Place on ice. 2. Remove a 10 l.tLsample as above every minute for 6 mm. Heat the samples for 10 mm at 65°C then cool to room temperature (see Notes 6,7, and 8). 3.1.4. Blunting
the DNA
Two methods may be usedto generateblunt ends for ligation. The use of mung bean nucleaseis more rapid than the method with Exo VII, but has the disadvantage of causing occasional loss of the primer site due to “nibbling-back” or destruction of DNA caused by digestion from nicks or through an excessive ratio of enzyme to substrate. Use of Exo VII has the additional advantage that up to five times more colo-
nies are obtained per Itg of DNA than in the nuclease S 1 method. 3.1.4.1. BLUNTING WITH MUNG BEAN NUCLEASE 1. Add 100 pL mung bean buffer containing 100 U/mL mung bean nuclease to each sample. Incubate at 37OC for 30 min. 2. Extract with 100 pL phenol/chloroform, followed by 50 pL chloroform, centrtfugmg each time at 10,OOOgfor 4 mm. 3. Add 12 cls,sodium acetate and 400 pL ethanol to each sample and leave at -70°C for 1 h before centrifugation at 10,OOOgfor 10 mm. Rinse with cold ethanol, dry the pellet and dissolve m 20 pL TE.
3.1.4.2. BLUNTING WITH Exo VII NUCLEASE AND T4 DNA POLYMERASE 1. Add 1.5 U Exo VII to each tube and incubate for 1 h at 37°C then heat at 65°C for 15 mm. 2. Add 10 pL water and spin-dialyze the sample on a spin-column made from 250 pL Sepharose slurry (see Chapter 19) to remove phosphate that will otherwise interfere with ligation, add 3 pL sodium acetate and 100 pL ethanol and leave at -70°C for 1 h before centrifugation at 10,OOOgfor 10 min. Rinse with cold ethanol, dry the pellet and dissolve in 10 6 TE. 3. Add 2 pL 10X TA buffer, 1 pL dNTPs, 5 U of T4 DNA polymerase and water to 20 pL. Incubate at 25’C for 30 min. Heat at 65°C for 10 min then cool to room temperature. 3.1.5. Measurement of the Rate of Deletion and DNA Ligation
In order to ascertain the rate of deletion and to determine which DNA samples should be ligated and used for transformation, part of the sample is run out on an agarose minigel. Large inserts in small
56
Murphy
vectors may be separated directly, but it is often more accurate to cut out the remaining insert with a suitable restriction enzyme with a site on the polylinker distal to the end subjected to deletion. 1. Take 8 pL of the blunted sample and add 1 pL 10X TA and 10 U of an polylinker enzyme cleaving at the undeleted end of the insert or Pvu II, which cuts m the flanking lac regions of many vectors. Digest for 1 h at 37°C and then separate on a suitable agarose gel. Ligate suitable timepoints (see Note 9). 2. Add 3 pL of the remaining sample to 3 pL 10X ligation buffer, 3 U T4 DNA ligase and water to 30 pL 3. Incubate at 15°C overnight. Use 3 pL of the ligation mixture to transform 200 pL of competent cells and plate out all the sample 3.2. Template Screening Following deletion and transformation, colonies are picked at random from each timepoint and screened for insert size. A rough approximation of size is obtained through sizing intact plasmid using protoplast lysis. This is followed by making minipreps and screening them by restriction digest. 3.2.1. Screening by Streaking Colonies 1. Prck twelve colonies from each timepoint, usmg sterile toothpicks. Streak each colony onto a fresh LB plate prepared with a suitable antibiotic and marked on the bottom into twelve sectors. Grow overnight at 37°C. 2. Scrape off about 0.5-l cm of each streak with a pipet tip, picking up as little agar as possible, and transfer to a 0.5~mL microcentrifuge tube containing 10 pL of protoplasting buffer, vortexing vigorously to disperse the sample. Leave the tip m the sample for loading onto the gel. Incubate for 15-30 min at room temperature (see Note 10). 3. At the same time prepare Insert size markers, combmmg streaks of cells transformed either with the vector or with vector contammg the fulllength insert. 4. Load the samples onto a 0.7% agarose gel, into wells preloaded with 5 pL of lysis buffer. Use a supercoiled DNA ladder (BRL) as a size marker (see Notes 11 and 12). 5. Leave the gel for 5 mm after loading to ensure lysis of the cells, then run the gel at 50 V for 15 mm before mcreasmg to 100 V and runnmg until the dye band runs off the bottom of the gel. 6. Stain the gel and photograph the DNA bands.
Exonuclease
57
Deletions
3.2.2. Screening Using Microtiter Plates 1. Add 100 pL LB plus ampicillm to each required microtiter well and maculate with a single colony. Incubate at 37°C overnight, shaking at about 150 rpm. To prevent evaporation of the medium it is best to place autoclave tape over the wells. 2. Remove 10 pL of the medium to a second microtiter plate containing 5 pL of protoplasting buffer in each well. Incubate and run on an agarose gel as above.
4. Notes 1. A potential problem with this strategy, particularly with long inserts, IS the need to find two restriction enzyme sites in the region between the insert and the primer site that will satisfy the above conditions and are also not present in the insert. The more sites there are in the polylmker, the easier this process becomes. For this reason vectors such as Bluescript (Stratagene) are ideal for this approach. If inserts can be cloned mto the central sites of the Bluescript polylinker then it may be possible to delete the insert from either end, with the additional advantage that three priming sites exist at each end of the polylinker. 2. By Judicious selection of enzyme sites close to the insert and using thiophosphates to block exonuclease activity it may be possible to delete through an insert m several stagesif enough sites are left on the primer side of the polylinker to provide a second lmearization satisfying the criteria for Exo III digestion. 3. It is essential that the initial digestions with restriction enzyme to open up the insert for deletion go to completion. The presence of nonlmearized plasmrd will eventually result in the recovery of large numbers of fulllength inserts during template screening. 4. The amount of DNA to be digested depends on the length of insert that it is desired to remove. The values suggested in the methods are sufficient to provide about 1 J.QDNA per time-point over 6 mm of treatment, with a deletion rate of around 200 bp/min, that should provide enough deletion to sequence an insert of around 1.5 kb. The suggested amounts and volumes should be increased proportionately for longer inserts. There is a broadening of the size-range of the insert in samples taken at later time-points. 5. It is unnecessary to use caesium gradient-purified DNA for this technique, although use of such DNA has the advantage that enough material is available for several trials to determine the rate of deletion. In this laboratory, deletions are mainly performed on miniprep DNA to
58
Murphy
avoid the time-consuming process of caesium gradient banding. The use of spm-columns to clean up linearized DNA provides excellent substrates for dtgestion. However, the digestion rates of miniprep plasmtd DNA tend to be more variable than when using more purified material. If using mmiprep DNA the plasmid from two overnight lo-mL cultures are pooled m a volume of 100 pL. This provides enough material for stx trials of the digestion rate if 30 & is used per lmearization. 6. The activity of Exo III falls off with length of incubation and so if a longer insert 1sbeing treated later, samples should be taken at longer intervals than the imtial samples. For example, if digesting an insert of 5 kb the amount of DNA, exonuclease and the reaction volumes should be tripled, and samples 7-12 removed at 2 mm intervals, with samples 13-l 8 being removed every 5 mm. 7. Substantial variation m the rate of digestion is often observed, because of factors such as quality of the Exo III and purity of the DNA substrate. If insufficient or excessive digestion rates are observed, the digestion may be repeated using the retained portion of the linearized plasmid and altering the amount of enzyme used. 8. Since Exo III is moderately temperature sensitive, the rate can also be controlled by altering the digestion temperature, a particularly useful parameter if only a few nucleottdes need to be removed (e.g., in studies on promoter location). If, under the conditions used, 200 bp are removed every mmute at 37”C, then about 120 bp will be removed at 30°C and 50 bp at 20°C. 9. When the rate of Exo III deletion is measured by cutting out the insert before gel separation, any change in mobility of the vector band indicates substantial digestion through the primer site. If this is observed the samples should not be ligated, as the primer sites will have been lost. 10. If the initial screening for insert size 1s done by streaking out the transformant, some practice is required in Judging the amount of cells to take. After vortexmg, the solution should be turbid rather than dense. Better results are obtained when too little, rather than too many, cells are used. The mimmum sample which can still be seen on the gel would be about half of the cells from a large colony on the original plate. 11. When screening the transformants by protoplast lysis tt is important not to use a submerged gel. Buffer should be added to the gel tank until tt is a few mm below the gel surface. Failure to do thts will result in the DNA being sucked out of the well by changes in surface tension as the SDS in the lysis buffer mixes wtth the gel buffer. 12. After a first round of screenmg by protoplast lysts, it is preferable to screen again by making muuprep DNA and measuring the insert size
Exonuclease Deletions
59
more accurately by restriction enzyme digest. If a restriction enzyme site on the end of the polylinker has been used to protect the primer site, it will clearly be removed during the linearization process. The Pvu II sites flanking the polylinker in pUC and Bluescript plasmids provide useful sites for digestion m such circumstances, or other rare sites in the vector close to the insert may be used.
References 1. Henikoff, S. (1984) Umdirectional digestlon with exonuclease III creates targeted breakpoints for DNA sequencing. Gene 28,351-359 2 Wen-Qin, X and Potts, M (1989) Quick screening of plasmid deletion clones carrymg Inserts of desired sizes for DNA sequencing. Gene Anal Tech. 6,17-20
&IA.FTER
9
Sequential Deletions of Single-Stranded DNA “Cyclone Sequencing”
George Murphy 1. Introduction A major problem of the directed deletion of double-stranded DNA using Exonuclease III (Chapter 8) is the necessity to find two enzyme sites to open up the insert for digestion and to protect the primer site. The “Cyclone Sequencing” technique of Dale, McClare, and Houchins (1) overcomes this problem as it is totally independent of the restriction sites in the insert. In this procedure single-stranded Ml3 is hybridized to an oligomer that spans the Hind111(even-numbered M 13 phage) or EcoRI site (odd-numbered phage) of the polylinker, generating a region of double-stranded DNA. This region is digested with the appropriate enzyme, linearizing the phage, and then the 3’ to 5’ exonuclease activity of T4 DNA polymerase is used to digest through the insert. The 3’ end is then homopolymer tailed using terminal transferase and the original oligomer used to create the double-stranded region, which has a 3’ end complementary to the homopolymer tail, is reannealed across the restriction site and the homopolymer tail. After ligation the DNA is used to transform competent cells and the resulting plaques picked at random for screening. The procedure has the great advantage that, as the restriction site used to linearize the DNA is regenerated in this procedure, the insert may be deleted in several stages. From Methods In Molecular B!ology, Vol. 23. DNA Sequencmg Protocols Edlted by Ii and A Griffin Copynght 01993 Humana Press Inc , Totowa, NJ
61
62
Murphy
T4 DNA polymerase does not digest single-stranded DNA at an even rate, so that the size-dispersion of templates is considerable.It is therefore essential to screen templates for size of insert before sequencing, rather than pick plaques at random from each time point. The large size of the Ml3 vectors, particularly if the insert is short, makes direct selection of templates by insert size difficult. Aliquots of randomly selected clones may be separatedovernight on agarosegels, but accurate sizing of small inserts may not be possible. A more sensitive, though time-consuming, alternative is to estimate insert size by hybridizing to single-stranded DNA complimentary to the insert followed by nuclease S1 digestion (2). This can be performed either on purified template or directly on the phagecontaining supernatant after the cells have been removed. The problem of insert size-selection when using large Ml3 vectors is eliminated if phagemid vectors are used. These can be propagated as plasmids, but single-stranded DNA can be generatedthrough the use of helper phages. 2. Materials
2.1. DNA Preparation 2.1.1.
Single-Stranded
Ml3
DNA
1. Minimal medium: Minimal medium Ingredients are autoclaved separately then mixed aseptically. MIX together 887 mL water, 10 mL 20% (w/v) glucose, 1 mL 1M MgS04, 1 mL O.lM CaCl*, 1 mL 1M thiamine HCl, and 100 mL M9 salts (7 g Na2HP0,, 3 g KH,PO,, 1 g NH&I, and 0.5 g NaCl in a total vol of 100 mL). 2. YT: 8 g bacto tryptone, 5 g yeast extract, and 5 g NaCl in a vol of 1 L. 3. PEG: 20% (w/v) PEG (PEG 8000, Sigma, St. LOUIS,MO) in 2.5MNaCl 4. TE: 10 m&I Tris-HC1 pH 8.0, 1 mM EDTA. 5. Phenol/chloroform: Equal volumes of phenol, equlhbrated with TnsHCl, pH 8.0, and chloroform:lsoamyl alcohol, (25: 1 v/v). 6. Chloroform. 7. Sodium acetate: 3M sodium acetate, pH 5.0. 8. 96% (v/v) ethanol. 9. Bacterial host strain: JMlOl, JM109, or XLl-Blue (Stratagene). 2.1.2. Plasmid
Rescue
1. Helper phage: VCSM13 helper phage (Stratagene), selected on kana-
mycin (20 pg/mL). 2. YT. 3. PEG. 4. Phenol/chloroform.
Cyclone Sequencing
63
2.2. Restriction Enzyme and T4 Polymerase Digestion 1. Annealing buffer: 100 mM Tris-HCl, pH 7.4, 100 mM MgCl,. 2. Primers: 20 pg/mL m deionized water, RD29 if digesting with HindIII, or RD20 if using EcoRI. 3. Hind111 or EcoRI (BRL). 4. Polymerase buffer: 330 mM Tris acetate, pH 7.9, 660 mM potassium acetate, 100 mM magnesium acetate, 5 mM DTT, and 1 mg/mL BSA. 5. T4 DNA polymerase (BRL).
2.3. Homopolymer
Tailing
and Ligation
1. Nucleotides: 0.2 mM dATP or dGTP. 2. Terminal transferase (BRL). 3. ATP: 10 mM ATP in Tris-HCl pH 8.0. 4. T4 DNA ligase (BRL). 2.4. Template
Screening
2.4.1. Screenmg by Size Selection on Agarose Gels 1. Loading buffer: 0.25% bromophenol blue in 50% glycerol, 100 mM EDTA and 1X TBE. 2. 10X TBE: 162 g Tris, 27.5 g boric acid, and 9.5 g EDTAn. 3. SDS solution: 1% (w/v) SDS, 0.2M EDTA, pH 8.0. 4. Ethidium bromide: Stain gels m water containing 0.5 g/mL ethidmm bromide. 2.4.2. Screening Using N&ease Sl Digestion 1. Nuclease Sl buffer: 30 mM sodium acetate, pH 4.5,4 mM ZnS04, and 250 mM NaCI. 2. Nuclease Sl (BRL). 3. SDS solution. 4. Loading buffer. 5. 10X TBE.
3.1. Preparation
3. Methods of Single-Stranded
Ml3 DNA
1. Grow an overmght culture of a suitable host m 10 mL munmal medium. If using XLI-Blue, grow on YT contammg 12.5 pg/mL tetracyclrne. Add 5 mL of the overnight culture to 45 mL YT prewarmed to 37°C and grow with vigorous shaking at 37°C for 1 h. Add one well-isolated plaque from a transformation of host cells with vector plus msert DNA and grow for 6 h.
64
Murphy
2. Spin down the cells at 10,OOOgfor 5 min and decant the supernatant to a fresh tube without carrying over cells. 3. Add 5 mL of PEG, mix and leave for 30 mm before centrifugation for 10 min at 10,OOOg.Decant most of the supernatant, spin again for 30 s and remove all the remaining lrqurd with a drawn-out Pasteur. 4. Suspend the phage pellet in 1 mL TE and add 500 pL phenol/chloroform. Vortex for 1 min, then centrifuge at 10,OOOgfor 4 mm and remove the supernatant to a fresh tube. Repeat the phenol/chloroform extraction 5-6 times until no precipitated material is observed at the interface. A final extraction is carried out with 500 pL chloroform. Vortex for 20 s and centrifuge as above. 5. Transfer the supernatant to 100 pL sodium acetate and 3 mL ethanol and leave at -70°C for 1 h before centrifugation for 10 min. Rinse with cold ethanol, centrifuge, and dry the pellet before dissolving in 0.5 mL TE. 3.2. Isolation of Single-Stranded DNA by Plasmid Rescue 1. Use a fresh overnight culture of host cells and fresh helper phage of known titer. Inoculate 45 mL of YT medium m a 250-mL flask with 5 mL of overnight culture of bacterial host cells and grow with vrgorous shaking to an AS6aof 0.3, equivalent to about 2.5 x lo8 cells. 2. Add helper phage to a multiplicity of infection of 20: 1 phage:cells and continue shakmg for 8 h. Heat the cells to 65OCfor 10 mm and centrifuge at 10,OOOgfor 15 min. At this stage the supernatant can be stored at 4OC overnight. 3. Add 5 mL PEG, mix, and leave for 30 min before centrifuging at 10,OOOg for 20 min. Decant off the supematant, centrifuge briefly, and remove the remnants of liquid with an asptrator. 4. Dissolve the phage pellet m 2 mL TE and add 2 mL phenol/chloroform. Vortex for 1 min, centrifuge at 10,OOOgfor 5 min and transfer the supernatant to a fresh tube. Repeat the phenol/chloroform extraction until there is no prectpitate at the interface, usually 5-6 times. 5. Perform a final extraction just with chloroform, add 0.2 mL sodium acetate and 6 mL ethanol and leave at -20 “C for 1 h. Centrifuge, rinse with ethanol, dry, and dissolve in 0.5 mL TE. 3.3. Preparation of DNA for Sequencing DNA for sequencing can be prepared by either of the above methods, scaling the incubation volume down to 1.5 tnL, and adjusting all other volumes accordingly. Inoculate the medium with one well-isolated plaque or colony and resuspend the final purified DNA in 30 ltL TE.
Cyclone Sequencing 3.4. Restriction
65
Enzyme
and T4 Polymerase Digestion T4 DNA polymerase has a slow 3’ to 5’ exonuclease activity, but lacks any 5’ exonuclease function. Single-stranded DNA is linearized by hybridizing an oligonucleotide primer to the 3’ end of the polylinker, generating a double-stranded Hind111 or EcoRI site. This site is then cleaved with the appropriate restriction enzyme and the insert progressively deleted with T4 DNA polymerase. 1. Combme smgle-stranded DNA (4 pg), 8 pL 10X annealing buffer, 2 pL of RD20 (for an EcoRI digest), or 4 pL of RD29 (for a Hind111 digest) m a volume of 60 pL. Heat to 65°C for 10 mm and cool slowly to room temperature over 1 h (see Notes l-3). 2. Add 40 U of restrrction enzyme and increase the volume to 80 pL. If using HindIII, incubate at 37°C for at least 3 h, preferably overmght, before inacttvatmg the enzyme by heating at 85°C for 10 mm. With EcoRI, incubate for 1 h at 42°C and mactlvate by heating to 85’C for 10 mm. 3. Check for complete digestion by separating 10 pL of the sample on a 0.7% agarose gel, alongside uncut DNA as a control (see Note 4). 4. Cool to room temperature and add 10 pL 10X T4 DNA polymerase buffer, 8 U T4 DNA polymerase, and water to 100 pL. Remove 25 pL samples every 15 mm and heat to 65’C for 10 mm to macttvate the polymerase (see Note 5).
3.5. Homopolymer
Tailing
and Ligation
Following insert deletion the DNA is then recircularized by adding on a homopolymer tail to the 3’ end with terminal transferase and rehybridizing with the primer used to linearize the DNA. This primer has a 3’ end complementary to the homopolymer tail and anneals to this as well as the original restriction enzyme site. The annealed DNA is then ligated and used to transform competent cells. 1. To each 25 JJLdigest add 2 J.ILof 0.2 mM dGTP (for RD20 annealed samples) or dATP (for RD29 annealed samples), 5 U terminal transferase, and water to 30 pL. Incubate at 37°C for 20 mm and heat at 65°C for 10 mm before cooling (see Note 6). 2. Remove 10 pL as nonannealed control and add 1 pL of RD20 or RD29 (20 pg/mL) to the remainder. Anneal as for the restrtctton enzyme digest (Section 3.4.) then cool to room temperature. 3. Add 3 cls, ATP, 2 U T4 DNA ligase, and water to 30 pL. Incubate at room temperature for at least 90 min.
66
Murphy
4. Dilute 2 + of the control to 15 @, and use 1 pL of the control or from the ligated sample to transform 200 ~JLof competent cells.
3.6. Screening Transfbrmants for Size of Insert A nested set of deletions for sequencing is identified by screening for insert size. Screening by separation of crude phage supernatant on agarose gels is rapid but provides only a rough indication of size, while the use of nuclease S 1 digestion is slower but provides a much more accurate estimate. 3.6.1. Screening of Phage-Containing Supernatant by Agarose Gel 1. Add 15 pL of the phage-containing cell supernatant to 1 pL 1% SDS and 5 + loading buffer. 2. Electrophorese overnight on a 20-cm 0.7% agarose gel in TBE buffer at 50V. 3. Visualize the phage by stammg with ethldlum bromide. 3.6.2. Screening of the Phage-Containing Cell Supernatant by Nuclease Sl Digestion 1. Combme 50 @ of the phage suspension with an equal volume of solution from a transfection using a full-length insert m the opposite onentation and add 8 pL SDS/EDTA. 2. Incubate at 65°C for 1 h, cool to room temperature, and extract with 50 cls,each of phenol/chloroform, followed by 50 $ of chloroform, then ethanol precipitate. 3. Dissolve the DNA m 10 pL of Nuclease Sl buffer containing 200 U/ mL of Nuclease Sl and incubate for 30 min at 37°C 4. Add 5 $ loading buffer and separate on an agarose gel.
4. Notes 1. For even-numbered Ml 3 vectors the annealmg 1sperformed with the Hind111site oligomer RD 29, whde for odd-numbered vectors the EcoRI site primer RD 20 ISused DigestIon with EcoRI 1svmually complete after one hour, but dtgestlon with Hind111may require overnight incubation 2. Since the restrictton site used to linearize the DNA is recreated durmg the ligation reactton, it can be reused If a further round of deletmg 1s needed because no clones are recovered m which the insert IS completely deleted
67
Cyclone Sequencing
3. Because the procedure works with as Irttle as 2 pg of DNA for one reaction set, template from normal 1S mL sequencing-type cultures of M 13 DNA may be used. 4. It IS essential to check for complete digestion by separating a small sample of the digest on a 0.7% agarose gel, because even traces of uncut DNA will produce a high background of full-length insert in the templates. Thts background can be removed by separating the digested DNA on a 0.7% agarose gel and recovering the DNA before exonuclease treatment. 5. T4 DNA polymerase will remove about 30 bases/mmunder the conditions given here and the mean digestion rate remains linear over an hour. There is a wide variation of digestion rates between batches of T4 polymerase, however, and it may be advisable to estimate the rate of digestion using larger initial amounts of DNA and separating an aliquot of the digest on an overnight gel or measuring the length of insert remaining. 6. It is important to keep the length of homopolymer tail to as short a length as is consistent with efficient annealing to the oligomer. Long tails, particularly G tails with RD20, may create problems when they are sequenced. T7 DNA polymerase has a better capacity to read through G-C tatls than Klenow.
References 1. Dale, R. M. K., McClure, B. A., and Houchins, J. P. (1985) A rapid singlestranded strategy for producing a sequential seriesof overlapping clones for use in DNA sequencing,Plasmid 13,3 l-40. 2. Oshima,R. G. (1988) Rapididentification of Ml3 phagedeletionsfor sequence analysis.Biotechniques 6,s IO-5 11.
Subcloning
for DNA Sequencing
Gary M. Studnicka, Shau-Ping Lei, Hun-Chi Lin, and Gary Wilcox
1. Introduction Chemical (I) and enzymatic (2) methods for determining DNA sequences have revolutionized the techniques of molecular genetics and subsequently our understanding of the gene. The use of singlestranded Ml3 bacteriophage (3-5), in conjunction with Sanger’s dideoxy chain-termination sequencing procedure (2), has greatly increased the rate at which genes can be analyzed. One prerequisite for an efficient sequencingstrategy is a set of subcloneswhose endpoints areevenly distributed along the entire sequence. Shotgun subcloning methods (6,7) require rigorous fractionation of the DNA fragments before cloning, to insure appropriately sized subclones in the final library. Since clones are then chosen at random from the library, shotgun methods are very inefficient at completing the last few small sequencegapsthat remain near the end of the project. Various nonrandom subcloning methods have also beendeveloped,utilizing partial restriction digests(8), BAL-3 1 digestion (9), exonuclease III digestion (l&13), and DNase I (14). The method described here (15) is an improvement of Hong’s procedure (14). It requires two unique restriction sites, separated by only a short distance within the polylinker region of the vector, as shown in Fig. 1. Its overall objective is to create a deletion that begins at the first site, removes the second site along with a large piece of the cloned From Methods in Molecular Biology, Vol. 23 DNA Sequencrng Protocols Edlted by H and A Grifhn Copynght 01993 Humana Press Inc , Totowa, NJ
69
70
Studnicka
et al.
polylmker redrictlon altas
re&rictmn
sites
Fig. 1 Diagram of subcloning strategy The large ctrcle represents the complete cloning vector m crrcular double-stranded form (elements are not drawn to scale) Its sequencing primer region is shown as a small grey arc at the upper left, and the cloned inserted gene fragment (to be sequenced) is shown as a long black arc at the right. The vector’s polylinker region contains many adjacent restriction sites, two of which are utilized in this subcloning procedure. Cleavage at the first site provrdes the fixed endpoint for the deletion, and digestion with DNase I provides the random endpoint for the deletion. Cleavage at the second site ensures that nondeleted vectors and other aberrant forms are destroyed. Additional restriction sites are present m the polylinker regions on either side of the cloned insert
insert, and terminates at some random point withm the insert. Partial digestion with DNase I is used to linearize the circular double-stranded vector and create a random endpoint for the deletion. The first restriction digest createsthe fixed endpoint for the deletion, so that the excised fragment can separate from the rest of the vector. The two endpoints of the linearized and deleted vector are then made blunt using Klenow fragment, and the vector is recircularized with T4 DNA ligase. The second restriction digest destroys the circularity (and thus the transfection efficiency) of most aberrant molecules that escaped linearization and deletion, or that contained a mislocated random endpoint (e.g., in the vector genes or in the primer region), or were ligated as
Subcloning
for DNA Sequencing
71
concatemers. After transfection, plaques that contain the desired subclones in high yield are harvested. 2. Materials 1. TYE broth: 15 g tryptone, 10 g yeastextract,5 g NaCI, fill to 1 L with water. 2. Double-stranded RF (“replicative form”) DNA of the inserted vector (e.g., M13mplO or M13mpl l), prepared as described (16) from 0.5 L overnight cultures in TYE broth. The DNA is purified by the alkaline method (26), and then further purified by cesium chloride-ethidmm bromide equilibrium gradient centrifugation. 3. DNase I buffer (10X): 200 mM Tris-HCl, pH 7.5, 10 mM MnCl,, 1 mg/ mL bovme serum albumin, as described (I 7). 4. TE buffer: 10 n&f Tris-HCl, pH 7.60.1 mM EDTA. 5. Universal buffer (1X): 50 mM Tris-HCl, pH 7.8,5 mM MgCI,, 25 mM NaCI, 10 n&f (NH,),S04. 6. PEG solution: 13% polyethylene glycol8000, 1.6M NaCl, asdescribed (18). 7. H buffer: 6.6 rnZt4Tris-HCl, pH 7.4, 6.6 mM MgCl,. 8. Klenow fragment (DNA polymerase I large fragment). 9. Two different restriction endonucleases that cut uniquely, only within the polylinker of the vector, on the same side of the cloned insert. 10. Two other restriction enzymes (with unique sites) that can excise the subcloned fragment to determine its size. 11. Agarose gel apparatus, 1 and 1.5% agarose gels, tracking dye. 12. T4 DNA ligase buffer: 50 mM Tris-HCI, pH 7.5, 10 rru!4 MgCl*, 5 rnJt4 dithiothreitol, 0.2 mM ATP. 13. Competent E. coli cells, obtained by treating a culture of rapidly growmg log-phase cells with cold calcium chloride, as described (3). 14. DNase I (Worthington), prepared as described (141, and stored at -20°C.
3. Method 1. Dilute 10X DNase I buffer IO-fold immediately before use. Suspend 12.5 pg circular double-stranded vector DNA in 240 pL of 1X DNase I buffer. Aliquot this into five 1.5~mL Eppendorf tubes (48 pL each). Serially dilute DNase I to concentrations of 0.5,0.25,0.125,0.062, and 0.03 1 ng/pL. Add 2 pL of each diluent to each tube to give final DNase I concentrations of 20, 10, 5, 2.5, and 1.25 pg/pL. Incubate at room temperature for 5 mm. 2. Add an equal volume of phenol saturated with TE buffer to stop the reaction. Remove the aqueous layer and extract with an equal volume of chloroform. Mix 5 pL (‘/lo vol) of each sample with 1 pL of tracking dye, and run on 1% agarose gel to determine optimal digestion conditions.
72
Studnicka
et al.
3. Select samples that contam sufficient smgle-cut linearized vectors, but that do not have the prominent smear typically associated with multiple DNase I digestions. Three distmct bands will appear m each track of the gel: Open circular forms run slow, closed circular forms run in the middle, and single-cut linear forms run fast. Small overly digested fragments will appear as a smear running faster than the lmear forms (see Note 1). Combme contents of appropriate tubes and precipitate the DNA with ethanol. Resuspend the DNA pellet in 200 pL of universal buffer. Digest with the first restriction endonuclease for 2 h at 37°C. 4. Heat to 68°C for 10 mm. Add 200 pL PEG solution and place mixture on ice for 1.5 h. This step preferentially precipitates large DNA molecules, leaving small pieces (includmg the deleted fragments) m solution. 5 Centrifuge at 4°C for 10 mm. Resuspend DNA m 100 pL TE buffer. Repeated PEG precipitation normally is not required. Extract with equal volumes of phenol. Extract with 50:50 phenol plus chloroform. Extract with chloroform. Ethanol precipitate. Resuspend the DNA pellet m 20 pL of H buffer. Add 5 U of Klenow fragment (DNA polymerase I large fragment) and incubate at room temperature for 15 mm. 6. Ethanol precipitate. Resuspend the DNA pellet m 200 Ils, of T4 DNA ligase buffer, add 40 U of T4 DNA ligase, and incubate overrught at 4OC. Blunt-end ligatton proceeds most efficiently at low temperature overnight. 7. Heat to 68°C for 15 min to inactivate enzyme acttvity. Add 100 pL universal buffer (1X) contammg an appropriate amount of NaCl for the second restriction enzyme (if it requires some), since the T4 DNA IIgase buffer contains no NaCl. Save one half of the sample as a control. Digest the other half with second enzyme for 2 h at 37’C. 8. Transfect 5 pL of digested sample mto 0.2 mL of competent E. co11 strain JM103 and plate (see Note 2) as described (3) 9. About loo-150 plaques per plate should be expected (see Note 3). Grow isolated plaques m 5 mL of TYE broth supplemented with JM 103 bacteria for 8 h or overnight, as described (3). 10. Harvest bacteriophages and prepare minilysate RF DNA, asdescribed (16) 11. Double digest with appropriate endonucleases (one at each end of the insert) to excise the subcloned fragment and determme its size on a 1.5% agarose gel. 12. Sequence according to Sanger (2).
4. Notes 1 In selecting DNase I digestion conditions, it is important to avoid samples with multiple hits (Indicated by a fast-runnmg smear on the gel), but the mclusion of samples with significant amounts of circular forms does
Subcloning
for DNA Sequencing
not matter. The restrictton endonuclease digestion at the second site destroys the transfection efficiency of circular forms, and thus eliminates unwanted background. 2. It takes less than two days from DNase I digestion to plating, and there is no bias toward subclones with small deletions. 3. Starting with 12.5 pg of DNA, this improved method produced approximately 10,000 plaques, and thus increased the transfectant yield by 60fold over that of the original procedure (14).
References 1. Maxam, A. M and Gilbert, W. (1977) A new method for sequencing DNA Proc Natl. Acad Sci. USA 74,560-564.
2. Sanger, F., Nicklen, S., and Coulson, A. R (1977) DNA sequencing with chainterminating inhibitors. Proc. Natl. Acad. Set. USA 74, 5463-5467. 3 Messing, J., Crea, R., and Seeburg, P. H. (1981) A system for shotgun DNA sequencing. Nucl. Acids Res. 9,309-321.
4. Vieira, J. andMessing,J. (1982) The pUC plasmids,an M13mp7-derived system for insertion mutagenesis and sequencing with synthetic universal prtmers. Gene 19,259-268 5 Messmg, J. and Vieira, J (1982) A new pair of Ml3 vectors for selecting either DNA strand of double-digest restriction fragments Gene 19,269-276. 6. Anderson, S (1981) Shotgun DNA sequencing using cloned DNase I-generated fragments. Nucl Aads Res 9,3015-3027. 7 Deininger, P. L (1983) Approaches to rapid DNA sequence analysis. Anal. Biochem 129,216-223 8 Lamperti, E. D. and Villa-Komaroff, L. (1990) Generation of deletion subclones for sequencing by partial digestion with restriction endonucleases. Anal. Biochem. 185, 187-193. 9. Poncz, M., Solowiejczyk, D., Ballantine, M., Schwartz, E , and Surrey, S. (1982) “Nonrandom” DNA sequence analysis in bacteriophage Ml3 by the dideoxy chain-termination method. Proc. Natl. Acad See. USA 79, 4298-4302 10. Guo, L. H. and Wu, R. (1982) New rapid methods for DNA sequencing based on exonuclease III digestion followed by repair synthesis Nucl. Acids Res 10,
2065-2084. 11. Henikoff, S. (1984) Umdirectional dtgestion with exonuclease III creates targeted breakpoints for DNA sequencing. Gene 28, 351-359. 12 Henikoff, S (1990) Ordered deletions for DNA sequencing and m vitro mutagenesis by polymerase extension and exonuclease III gapping of circular templates Nucl. Acids Res. 18,2961-2966 13 Gronostajski, R. M and Sadowski, P. D (1985) Determmatton of DNA sequences essential for FLP mediated recombination by a novel method J Biol. Chem. 260, 12,32O-12,327. 14. Hong, G. F (1982) A systematic DNA sequencing strategy .I Mol. Biol. 158, 539-549
74
Studnicka
et al.
15 Lm, H.-C., Lei, S.-P., and Wilcox, G. (1985) An improved DNA sequencmg strategy Anal. Biochem. 147, 114-119. 16. Ish-Horowitz, D., and Burke, J. F. (1981) Rapid and efficient cosmtd clonmg Nuci Acids Res. 9,2989-2998. 17. Rigby, P W J., Dieckmann, M , Rhodes, C , and Berg, P. (1977) Labelmg deoxyribonucletc acid to high specific activity by nick translation with DNA polymerase I. J Mol. Biof. 113,237-251 18 Lis, J T. (1980) Fractionatton of DNA fragments by polyethylene glycol induced precrpitation. Meth. Enzymol 65, 347-353
&APTER
Sequencing Ulrike
11
Using Custom Designed Oligonucleotides
Gerischer
and Peter Diirre
1. Introduction The dideoxy chain termination DNA sequencing procedure introduced in 1977 (I) has the advantage of being fast, simple to perform, and very accurate. Therefore, it became the method of choice to obtain several hundred bases of sequence information per reaction. The procedure is based on the enzymatic elongation and radioactive labeling of oligonucleotides that are complementary to the beginning of the single-stranded DNA template. Chain extension competes with the infrequent but specific termination by incorporation of a dideoxyribonucleotide. The products of four nucleotide-specific reactions can be separated on a polyacrylamide gel. An autoradiogram of such a gel finally provides the sequence information. Detailed descriptions of the various modifications of this method have been presented in preceding chapters of this volume. The synthetic oligonucleotide primer required for the synthesis of the labeled strands can easily be synthesized in automatic synthesizers or by hand, the latter of which is more laborious. Various so-called “universal sequencing” and “reverse sequencing” primers, complementary to the beginning of the polylinker region in Ml3 Zac cloning phages and plasmids, are commercially available. Specifically designed oligonucleotides can also be prepared upon request by several molecular biological companies, From: Methods m Molecular Biology, Vol 23. DNA Sequencmg Protocols E&ted by: H and A. Gnfftn Copyright 01993 Humana Press inc., Totowa,
75
NJ
76
Gerischer
and Diirre
In principle, there are three different ways of obtaming DNA sequenceinformation by the dideoxynucleotide method. The first strategy involves sequencing of randomly cloned fragments by using only commercially available primers complementary to regions close to the insertion site. This methodology requires a high number of recombinant clones, many time- and money-consuming sequencing reactions, and a computer for putting the data together into a whole. Alternatively, defined subclones can be constructed, characterized, and finally sequenced. This approach is more straightforward, but also takes a lot of work and time. The second procedure makes use of a set of different deletions in the original DNA fragment, originating close to the commercially available primer. These nested deletions extend various lengths along the target DNA. Thus, the longer the deletions are the more new target DNA is brought into sequencing range (see also Chapters 8,9, and 10). Again, this procedure requires additional recombinant DNA work on the original clone and the preparation of many DNA templates. The third approach is based on start of sequencing with primers that are complementary to a known sequence. This can either be the vector or any other sequence adjacent to the DNA to be analyzed. Sequencing proceeds by successive synthesis of new primers at the edges of the newly obtained sequence in such a way that their 3’ ends are pointing off into the unknown target DNA. This method is quick and straightforward, but usually requires the availability of a DNA synthesizer. 2. Materials Synthesis of oligonucleotides may be performed by hand (24) or can be done by several molecular biological companies. The latter possibility certainly is easierbut also time-consuming and relatively expensive. The most convenient way to obtain specific primers is the use of an automatic DNA synthesizer. If such a machine is available an oligonucleotide (17mer) can be prepared within approximately 2.5 h. When using an automatic DNA synthesizer chemicals such as solvents, protected deoxyribonucleoside-3’-0-cyanoethyl phosphoramidites, and special reagents are normally provided by the manufacturer (see Note 1). Cheaper offers from different companies are usually acceptable, provided the quality of these chemicals is high. Special attention should be paid to contamination with water. Water repre-
Custom Primer-Directed
Sequencing
77
sents the main problem in efficient oligonucleotide synthesis, and should therefore be kept away from all reagents and solutions. Since solvents are hazardous, care should be taken to perform the synthesis in a well-ventilated area. Detailed manual methods and the necessary equipment and material have been described in a previous volume of this series (2,3). For postsynthetic procedures such as deprotection, cleavage of the oligonucleotide from the support, and removal of impurities the following materials are required: 1. 25% ammonia m water (solution should be of highest quality). 2. Sephadex G-25 columns. It is recommended to work with prepacked columns that give a defined elution profile. 3. Sterile water or TE buffer (10 mM Tris-HCI, pH 7.5, 1 mM EDTA).
3. Design of Primers Working with custom primers, new oligonucleotides
are designed
according to the results of the first sequencing reactions with primers complementary to the beginning of the polylinker region in all M 13 lac cloning phages and plasmids. Thus, determined sequences serve to plan the next primer and so on. As a rule for primer design the formula : Primer length = 18 + 1 extra nucleotide for each 2% off of 50% G + C has been reported (5). This is because oligonucleotides with too high an A + T-content might not prime satisfactorily with special template DNA strands. However, working with an A + T-rich organism (Clostrz’dium acetobutylicum) we routinely used 17mer primers (6) with G + C-contents between 2 and 9 nucleotides and never experienced any problems. New primer and known sequence should well overlap to ensure that the starting nucleotides of the new part can be read and to have an internal control of each sequence start. As a rule of thumb the 3’
end of the primer should be located about 30-40 nucleotides from the end of the already known sequence. Before synthesizing a primer its sequenceshould be compared carefully to the whole known sequence of template DNA and vector (preferably by means of a computer program). This will identify regions where undesired hybridizations could take place. Of special importance in this respect are the last ten 3’-terminal bases. More than 80% homology in this region might cause major background
problems,
Gerischer and Diirre particularly in G + C-rich templates (5). If undesired homology indeed can be found, a new primer should be designed (see Note 2). In general, it is not possible to predict the functionality of a new primer. Even oligonucleotides that are designed according to all rules might fail. In such a case synthesis of a different primer is recommended. 4. Synthesis
of Primers
Detailed procedures for manual oligonucleotide synthesis have been described in a previous volume of this series (2,3). Using an automatic DNA synthesizer the instructions of the respective manufacturer should be followed exactly. Therefore, only the principle of a standard method (using phosphoramidites) and the postsynthetic procedures will be described here. To avoid undesired reactions during synthesis, the hydroxyl group at position 5 of the monomers is protected by a 4,4’-dimethoxytrityl group, the hydroxyl group at the phosphorus atom by a P-cyanoethyl moiety, and primary ammes either by benzoyl groups (N6 in case of deoxyadenosine, N4 in case of deoxycytidine) or by the isobutyryl group in position N2 of deoxyguanosine. Thymidine is usually not protected (3). A fully protected dA monomer is shown in Fig. 1. The first nucleotide is coupled via its 3’-OH group and a spacer to a solid support such as silica, glass, or plastic beads. Then its S-dimethoxytrityl group is split off and the next monomer is added using the activator tetrazole. After a wash to remove this substance and unreacted nucleotides, unreacted Y-OH groups are acetylated (capping). Oxidation of the phosphite triester bridge renders the molecule ready for the next round of elongation (3). After completion of the synthesis the oligonucleotide is separated from the support by a short centrifugation (2000 g, 1 min) to remove residual solvent and incubation in 25% ammoma (15 h at 55°C). Care should be taken to completely submerge the support using an appropriate tube, Residual air bubbles can be removed by short centrifugation (2000 g, 1 min). The support is then taken out of the solution and centrifuged in a tube to obtain the residual liquid (2000 g, 1 mm). Both solutions are pooled and represent a crude mixture of a variety of oligonucleotides and some ammonium salts in ammonium hydroxide. The concentration of impurities is higher the longer the sequence of the oligonucleotide is. Removal of ammonia and other impurities
Custom Primer-Directed
Sequencing
79
/\ 0 P-OCHzCHzCN
Fig 1. Protected dA monomer using the phosphoramldlte
method (3).
is achieved by size exclusion chromatography on Sephadex G-25. The use of prepacked columns is recommended. Equilibration and elution is done with sterile water or TE buffer (seeNote 3). For sequencing reactions it is usually unnecessary to further purify the primer (which could be done by HPLC or gel electrophoresis). However, if the sequence of the oligonucleotide allows hairpin formation by selfcomplementation, denaturing conditions might be necessary in the purification procedure. 6. Sequencing
Reaction
Automatic DNA synthesizers such as Gene Assembler Plus (Pharmacia LKB GmbH, Freiburg, Germany) have a coupling efficiency of 98% under optimal conditions. Thus, one usually obtains a highly concentrated primer solution after removal from the solid support. Many sequencing protocols recommend the use of 10 ng primer per sequencing reaction, Using a 0.2~pm01 capacity support column in
80
Gerischer
and Diirre
the above mentioned machine we routinely obtain approx 600 ~18oligonucleotide (in 1.5 mL buffer). The concentration can be determined by measuring the absorbance at 260 nm (1 corresponds to 3 1 p.g/mL). This solution is diluted loo-fold and 2 w are used for sequencing in the annealing reaction. We also routinely used 1 p.L of the undiluted endproduct and the results were as good as with less primer. Sequencing was performed as described in Chapter 13 of this volume. A complete cycle of designing and synthesizing a primer, performing the sequencing reaction, and analysis of the DNA sequence can be done in 48 h. Thus, every 2 d approx 400 bases of new sequence information become available. If subclones, or similar clones, and the necessary sequencing equipment are at hand, this number could easily be increased. This might be desirable in large sequencing projects. Advantages of this method are that no additional steps such as subcloning (including recombinant DNA work, transformation, and plasmid characterization), medium preparation for cultivation of clones, and template isolation from a large number of clones are necessary. A possible disadvantage might be the costs for primer synthesis. Using an automatic sequencer, the cost comes to approx $40-50 per 17mer.
6. Notes 1. Synthesis reagents for an automatic DNA synthesizer were found to be stable for at least 3-4 wk under laboratory conditions. 2. We strongly recommend to check the template sequence carefully after every elongation. Ambiguous regions can thus be resequenced at once which might help to avold later unnecessary primer synthesis. Direct computer analysis will also enable the identlflcatlon of matching stretches if sequencing was started from both ends of the template. If only the end of a newly obtained sequence 1s read and used for new primer design this could finally lead to unnecessary sequencmg of large parts of the vector. 3. If there are any doubts concerning the quality of the synthesis, the o11gonucleotlde can be examined m a sequencing gel (20% polyacrylamide, 8M urea) by comparison with an oligonucleotide of good quality or with a commercially available oligonucleotide marker. Visualization can be performed by UV-shadowing (by simply putting the gel on a fluorescent thin layer chromatography plate and dluminatmg It with UV light at 254 nm [7]) or by autoradrography after kinasmg the oligo-
Custom Primer-Directed
Sequencing
81
nucleotide with [‘y- 32P]ATP. Attention: Polynucleotide kinase shows unfavorable reaction kmettcs with a C at the S-end. The back reaction under these conditions is much stronger than the forward reaction. 4. Oligonucleotides synthesized as primers might also serve additional functions. They might be used in primer extenston expertments to determine transcription start points or for sequencmg a large number of mutants in a defined region within a short period of time. They can also be used as probes to detect specific DNA fragments by Southern hybrtdization.
Acknowledgments Work reported from this laboratory has been supported by grants
from the Bundesminister fiir Forschung und Technologie and the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft. References 1. Sanger,F., Nlcklen, S., and Coulson, A. R. (1977) DNA sequencmg with chamterminatmg mhrbitors. Proc. Natl. Acad. Scr USA 74, 5463-5467 2. O’Callaghan, D. M and Donnelly, W. J. (1988) Ohgonucleotrde synthesis using the manual phosphotriester method, in Methods in Molecular Biology, vol 4. New Nucleic Acids Techniques (Walker, J M , ed >, Humana, Clifton, NJ, pp 165-192. 3. White, H. A. (1988) Manual ohgonucleotide synthesis using the phosphoramidite method, in Methods in Molecular Biology, vol. 4: New Nucleic Acids Techniques (Walker, J. M., ed ), Humana, Clifton, NJ, pp 193-213. 4. Gait, M. J. (1984) Oligonucleotide Synthesis-A Practical Approach. IRL Press, Oxford. 5. Barnes, W. M. (1987) Sequencing DNA with drdeoxyrrbonucleotides as cham terminators: Hints and strategies for big projects. Methods Enzymol. 152,538556. 6. Gerischer, U. and Durre, P. (1990) Cloning, sequencmg, and molecular analysis of the acetoacetate decarboxylase gene region from Clostridium acetobutylicum. J. Bacterial. 172,6907-69 18. 7. Thurston, S J and Saffer, J. D. (1989) Ultraviolet shadowing nucleic acids on nylon membranes. Anal Biochem. 178,41-42.
&IAPTER
12
Dideoxy Sequencing Reactions Using Klenow Fragment DNA Polymerase 1 Alan II Bankier 1. Introduction Historically, DNA sequencing by primed synthesis and chain terminators has been performed using the Klenow fragment of DNA polymerase 1 (I). This enzyme was derived from E. coli. DNA Pol I which, in addition to polymerase activity, has both 3’-5’ and S-3’ exonuclease activities. As described in Chapter 1, the principle of dideoxy sequencing is that four base specific sequence reactions are performed. Each reaction generates a large range of product lengths with a single 5’ end common to all fragments, and 3’ ends that terminate at every possible occurrence of a specific nucleotide. The four sets of products are fractionated through a polyacrylamide gel and the position of a specific base can be deduced by virtue of the comparison of each fragment’s length (2). The native enzyme would be no good for this procedure since the 5’-3’ exonuclease would destroy the unique 5’ end, and hence the reference point. The Klenow fragment is a proteolytic derivative of Pol I lacking this 5’-3’ exonuclease, but retaining both the polymerase action and the 3’-5’ exonuclease action, This latter enzymic action serves a useful function in terms of “proofreading” the polymerase incorporation From Methods m Molecular Biology, Vol 23’ DNA Sequencing Protocols Edlted by H and A Grlffln Copynght 01993 Humana Press Inc , Totowa,
83
NJ
Bankier
84
and thereby improving fidelity. However, some problems encountered with Klenow DNA sequencing can be attributed to the presence of this action. Klenow polymerase is far from ideal for use as a sequencing enzyme. It is fairly simple to describe the properties of the perfect enzyme. The ideal qualities of a sequencing enzyme are: 1. It should be easily preparedm large quantities. 2. It needs to be stable upon storagefor considerableperiods. 3. The enzyme should acceptall deoxy and dideoxy nucleotides and analogues as substrateswith equal affinities and high fidelity. 4. The polymerase action should be highly processive over nucleotide extensionsto 1 kb andbeyond,eventhrough regionsof secondarystructure within the template.
5. This activity should remain high, even in suboptimal conditions. 6. It should be inexpensive.
Klenow enzyme does not fully match any of these criteria. So why is it still used? The answer is that none of the other commercially available enzymes, described for use in DNA sequencing, fully match these requirements either, although some are much better than others. The Klenow enzyme is fairly well understood, and many of its failings can be compensated for by an experienced user. It comes closer than some of its rivals in meeting certain aspects of the ideal description. The use of Klenow, at least for the moment, is on the decline, in favor of the use of T7 polymerase and its derivatives, such as Sequenase (Chapter 14), and of the thermally stable enzymes, such as 7izq polymerase (Chapter 15). Sequenaseproduces a much more even band intensity pattern and, under ideal conditions, can give visually stunning results. The thermally stable enzymes that can be used in amplification or cycling procedures are particularly useful for fluorescence based automated systems where increased yields of reaction products, and hence signals, is of high importance. The simplicity of the procedures used for sequencing with Klenow, lend themselves very well to the manual handling of many samples simultaneously (3,4). This makes Klenow an acceptable alternative for large scale, radioactive sequencing. The methods described here assume that sequencing is being performed on single-stranded DNA derived from M 13 cloning vehicles
Sequencing
Using Klenow Polymerase
85
(51, although simple modifications can broaden this applicability. The template quantities assume a concentration of DNA around 0.125 pg/ pL. This is typical of the yield to be expected from a conventional prepa-
ration of a 15mL culture, dissolved in less than 50 pL. Making this assumption, it is not normally necessary to assay the concentration
any more accurately. The procedure for microtiter tray preparation, described in Chapter 6, also yields template DNA of around this con-
centration, although in smaller volume. These methods also describe reagent volumes for a single sequence reaction. This is seldom the case, but actual reagent volumes can simply be scaled. Very often, because the method employs microtrter trays, the most convenient numbers of samples handled simultaneously are 8, 12, and 24, or multiples thereof. These numbers are also convenient in terms of how many samples can be loaded onto standard sized polyacrylamide gels. In these radioactive sequencing reactions, any a-labeled nucleotide
triphosphate can be used although the reagents described here are specifically for dATP. Currently used radiolabel markers are 32P (I), 35S (6), or 33P (7). The first method detailed here is the conventional technique whereby chain extension/termination and incorporation of the labeled nucleotide occur in the same step. The second method separates the
labeling step from termination. This latter approach is reported to give readings over a longer length but is sensitive to template DNA concentration and has shorter incubation times, making the processing of lots of samples difficult. 2. Materials All materials and chemicals used in molecular biology techniques should be considered to be a potential health hazard and need to be handled with this in mind. Where appropriate, some materials have been singled out as being particularly hazardous. 2.1. Materials Common to Methods 1 and 2 1. Nonsterile, untreated 96-well microtiter trays such as Falcon 3911 or preferably heat resistant polycarbonate microtiter trays (e.g., Techne, Duxford, England, Hi-Temp 96, cat. no. FMW 11). 2. Synthetic oligonucleotide primer at a concentration of 0.5 pmol/pL in TE. This molecule should be between 15 and 30 nucleotides in length.
Bankier
86
3.
4. 5. 6. 7. 8.
9.
10. 11.
12.
13.
It should also hybridize specifically m the 5’ region of the template DNA that is to be sequenced. For templates derived from the Ml 3 series of vectors, or vectors having related polylmker cloning regions, a single “universal” primer (5’ d(GTAAAACGACGGCCAGT)) can be used. The template DNA to be sequenced, at a concentratton of around 0.05 pmol/pL. Thts corresponds to a concentration of around 0.125 pg/pL of Ml3 DNA, the approximate yield from a standard 1.5 mL preparation being around 5 pg. TM buffer: 100 mM Trts-HCl, pH 8.5, 50 mM MgC12 . TE buffer: 10 mM Tris-HCl, pH 8.0,O. 1 mM Na*EDTA. Distilled or deionized water. Microtiter tray plate sealers (e.g., Costar cat. no. 3095). Deoxynucleotide triphosphates, dATP, dCTP, dGTP, and d?Tp dissolved m TE to 50 mM and diluttons of these stocks to give 0.5 mM working solutions. These solutions can be stored at -20°C for years although it is best to freeze them m ahquots to prevent repeated freeze/thaw cycles. Dideoxynucleotide trtphosphates, ddATP, ddCTP, ddGTP, and ddTTP dissolved m TE to 10 mM workmg solutions These solutions can be stored at -20°C for years although it is best to freeze them m aliquots to prevent repeated freeze/thaw cycles. O.lM dithiothreitol (Cleland’s reagent). Store at -2OOC. 35S, 32P, or 33P alpha labeled dATP at ~400 Ci/mmol, 10 mCt/mL. These materials are a potential health hazard and should be handled and disposed of appropriately. The 35S analog has a much lower energy emission (35S 0.16 MeV 33P, 0.248 MeV, and 32P, 1.7 MeV) and can be used without radiation shields. Klenow fragment DNA Polymerase I at a concentration of around 5 U/ pL or higher. Enzyme at a lower concentration adds a proportionally higher amount of glycerol to the reactions, which can affect electrophoresis unless an ethanol precipitation is performed. Formamide dye mix: 100 mL deionized formamide, 0.1 g xylene cyan01 F.F., 0.1 g bromophenol blue, 2 mL 0.5MNa2EDTA. This solution seems stable at ambient temperatures for several months, but it is recommended that aliquots be stored frozen. Formamide is hazardous and may cause irritation to skm and eyes. 2.2. Materials
Specific
to Method
1
1. Four nucleottde-speciftc dideoxy nucleotide mixes (ddNTP/dNTPs) as follows: ddATP mix: 250 w dCTP, 250 l.uW dGTP, 250 l.uW dTTP, 10 w ddATP.
Sequencing
Using Klenow
Polymerase
87
ddCTP mrx: 12.5 w dCTP, 250 @4 dGTP, 250 w dTTP, 80 pIU ddCTP. ddGTP mix: 250 pAI dCTP, 12.5pA4dGTP, 250 @4 dlTP, 160 pA4 ddGTP. ddTTP mix: 250 w dCTP, 250 w dGTP, 12.5 @4 dTTP, 500 ruz/l ddTTP. These solutions are prepared using the workmg nucleotxde solutrons and can be kept for years at -20°C. 2. Chase mix: 0.5 rn/WdATP, 0.5 mMdCTP, 0.5 mMdGTP, 0.5 mJ4dTTP. 2.3. Materials Specific to Method 2 1. Labeling mrx: 7.5 @I dCTP, 7.5 rJM dGTP, 7.5 @4 dTTP. 2. Four nucleotide-specific termmatron mixes (ddNTP/dNTPs) as follows: A mix: 25 p/U dATP, 250 w dCTP, 250 piU dGTP, 250 @4 dTTP, 300 /.uI4ddATP. C mix: 250 @4 dATP, 25 p/U dCTP, 250 w dGTP, 250 @4 dTTP, 100 @4 ddCTP. G mix: 250 w dATP, 250 w dCTP, 25 w dGTP, 250 w dTTP, 150 w ddGTP. T mix: 250 p/t4dATP, 250 @I dCTP, 250 w dGTP, 25 @4 dTTP, 500 /.&I ddTTP.
3. Methods Two methods of sequencing using Klenow polymerase are described here. The first is a single-step labeling and termination procedure, the second employs an initial labeling step, followed by a termination step. 3.1. Single-Step Labeling and Termination 1. Prepare a drlutron of the primer in sequence reaction buffer TM as follows: 1 pL primer (0.5 pmol/pL), 1 pL TM, 6 pL distilled water. Aliquot 2 pL of this primer dilution onto the sides of four adjacent wells of a disposable mrcrotrter tray (see Notes 1-3). 2. Dispense 2 pL of the template DNA into each of the same four wells, on the opposite side from the primer. Cover the wells to form an arrtight seal using a nonporous food wrap, such as Saranwrap@, or using a self-adhesive plate sealer. 3. Centrifuge the tray briefly (accelerate rapidly to 1000 g and rmmedtately stop) to combine and mix the droplets, and place the microtiter tray in an incubator at 55°C for at least 30 min (see Notes 4 and 5). 4. Centrifuge the tray to recover any condensation and add 2 pL of each specific dideoxy nucleotrde mix (ddNTP/dNTPs) to the side of one of
88
Bankier
the four wells (assign each well in the order the polyacrylamide gel will be loaded (seeNote 6). 5. Prepare a label/enzyme mix, on ice, as follows: 6 pL drstilled water, 1 pL O.lM dithiothreitol, 0.5 pL radiolabeled dATP (10 mCi/mL, - 400 Gil mmol), 0.5 pL Klenow DNA Polymerase (5 U/pL). Mix the reagents by gently pipeting up and down(see Note 7). 6. Dispense 2 pL of the label/enzyme mix onto the side of each well, centrifuge the tray briefly, and place it at 37OCfor 15 min (see Notes 8 and 10). 7. Add 2 pL of nucleotide chase solution to each of the wells, centrifuge the tray briefly, and place it at 37°C for 15 minutes (see Note 9). 8. Inactivate the enzyme by adding 2 pL of formamide stop solution to each of the wells and centrifuge the tray briefly (see Notes 12 and 13). 3.2. Two-Step
Labeling
and
Termination
1. Usmg a single well of a microtiter tray or a microcentnfuge tube, add and mix: 1 pL primer (0.5 pmol/pL), 1 pL TM, 8 pL template DNA (= 1 pg), Cover the well to form an airtight seal or cap the tube and place it in an incubator at 55°C for at least 30 min (see Notes 1, 2,4, 5). 2. Toward the end of the annealing period, dispense 2.5 pL of the four termination mixes into four adjacent wells of a microtiter tray. 3. Centrifuge the annealing container to recover any condensation and add: 2 pL labeling mix. 1 pL O.lM dithiothreitol (Cleland’s reagent). 0.5 pL radiolabeled dATP (10 mCi/mL, = 400 Ci/mmol). 0.5 pL Klenow DNA Polymerase (5 U&L). 2 pL distilled water. Mix the reagents by gently pipeting m and out and leave at room temperature for 5 min (see Note 7) 4. Aliquot 3.5 pL of the labeling/extenston reaction into the four termmation wells and centrifuge the tray briefly to mix the reagents. Place the tray at 37°C for 5 mm (see Notes 10 and 11). 5. Inactivate the enzyme by adding 2 pL of formamrde stop solution to each of the wells and centrifuge the tray briefly (see Notes 12 and 13).
4. Notes 1. Unlike many recommended buffers for DNA sequencing,the TM described here does not contam sodium chloride. Some sequence dependent, template secondary structures, which inhibit polymertzatton, are stabilized m salt soluttons. Removal of the sodium chloride improves the results on these templates without adversely affecting routine sequencmg with Klenow polymerase.
Sequencing
Using Klenow Polymerase
89
2. Microtiter trays are recommended as the reaction vessel; they are ideally suited to the small volumes employed, they are disposable, many samples can be handled at once, no caps need to be opened or closed, and individual contamers do not need to be labeled for identification. 3. In the two-step labeling/extension method, all of the reagent volumes have been standardized at 2 pL. This means that a single microliter pipet can be used for all additions. It also becomes possible to use a repetittve dispenser to greatly speed up multiple additions. The most convenient of these repetitive dispensers is a simple ratchet fittmg for a Hamilton gastight microliter syringe. When used with an LTlOO syringe fitted with a luer, disposable tip adapter, 50 x 2 pL additions can be made from a single charging of a disposable tip. 4. Annealing of the template DNA to primer can be carried out at a wide range of temperatures and incubation times. Using a single temperature of 55°C gives a good compromise between mcubatton time and ease of handling. The precise temperature is not crittcal. 5. Once annealed, the template/primer can be stored for several weeks at -2OOCwithout noticeable deterioration. This can be convenient for largescale sequencing (using robotics in particular) or when lack of time prevents continuing with the procedure. 6. The ratio of the dideoxy:deoxy nucleotide within a particular mix mfluences the rate of termination within that reaction. At low terminator concentration, chain extension will proceed farther. The mixes described here should be regarded as a starting point from where fine-tunmg can begin. By altering this ratio within the working nucleotide terminator mix, a peak of distribution of bands within the desired range can be easily obtained. 7. Klenow fragment DNA polymerase should be kept at a constant cold temperature whenever possible (especially when diluted). When removing an aliquot from the stock, it is best done rapidly within the confines of the freezer. 8. Sequence extensions usmg Klenow can be carried out at ambient temperature rather than at 37OCwithout noticeable deterioration of the end result. 9. It is possible to omit the chase step, as an extreme measure m minimizing the handling of large numbers of samples, by mcreasmg the extension time to around 30 min. Under these conditions, be sensitive to the signs of incomplete extension (termination in all four lanes at positions Immediately before “A” bands, the concentration limited, radiolabeled nucleotide). Usually it is best to assume the chase IS necessary rather than generate a large number of useless reaction products. 10. Microtiter tray thermal cyclers are very convenient for DNA sequenc-
90
Bankier
ing. The annealing, extension, and denaturation can all be carried out without transferring the tray between drfferent locations. 11. The two-step labeling/termmation procedure becomesdtfficult when many samples are being processedstmultaneously. The short incubation periods and the many ptpetings involved make it difficult to standardize the reaction conditions. One way to overcome thts problem is to predispense the termination mixes prior to startmg. Also, carefully aliquot the labeling mixture as droplets on the side of the wells immediately
after mixing.
Ter-
mination reactions can then be started at the appropriate time by driving the droplets to the bottom of the well by brief centrifugatton. I2 If the sequence reaction samples are to be stored for any period of time before loading on a polyacrylamide gel, it is best to freeze the samples without
adding formamrde.
Normally
no degradation
1s apparent upon
storage in formamide but, occastonally, a degradation smear can appear after only a short period. 13. Despite the many tmprovements in the field of DNA sequencing, there are still many areas where things can go wrong. Since many of the reagents store well at -20°C it is highly recommended that a complete control kit is kept m the freezer. Problem solvmg IS simply a question of substituting reagents into this control system until the source of the problem is pinpointed. By far the most common problems are associated with template purity and enzyme quality.
References 1. Sanger, F., Nicklen, S , and Coulson, A. R. (1977) DNA sequencing with chainterminating inhibitors Proc Nat1 Acad. Sci USA 74, 5463-5467. 2 Bankier, A. T. and Barrell, B. G (1983) Shotgun DNA sequencing, rn Techniques in Life Sciences, Nucleic Acid Biochemistry vol. B5, (Flavell, R. A , ed.), Elsevier Scientific Publishers, Ireland, pp. l-34. 3. Bankier, A T , Weston, K. M , and Barrell, B G (1987) Random cloning and sequencing by the M13/dideoxynucleotide chain termination method, in Methods in Enzymology vol. 155, (Wu, R., ed.), Academic, London, pp. 51-93 4. Bankrer, A. T. and Barrell, B. G. (1989) Sequencing single-stranded DNA using the chain termination method, in Nuclerc Acids Sequencrng. A Practical Approach (Howe, C. J. and Ward, E. S., eds.), IRL Press, Oxford, pp. 37-78 5. Messing, J. and Bankier, A T (1989) The use of single-stranded DNA phage in DNA sequencing, in Nucleic Acids Sequencing. A Practical Approach (Howe, C. J. and Ward, E. S., eds.), IRL Press, Oxford, pp l-36 6 Biggin, M. D , Gibson, T. J., and Hong, G. F. (1983) Buffer gradient gels and 35S label as an aid to rapid DNA sequence determination Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 80,3963-3965.
7. Zagursky, R J., Conway, P S , and Kashdan, M A. (1991) Use of 33P for Sanger DNA Sequencing Biotechniques 1,37-38
&A.E’TER
13
Dideoxy Sequencing Reactions Using T7 Polymerase Peter Diirre and Ulrike
Geriscker
1. Introduction The chain termination DNA sequencing procedure introduced by Sanger and coworkers in 1977 (I) meant a revolutionary achievement in fast, simple, and accurate deciphering of DNA fragments. Long stretches of this nucleic acid could from then on be sequenced within a relatively short time. The method makes use of the enzymatic elongation of specific oligodeoxyribonucleotide primers that are complementary to a specific sequence of the DNA template. Four different reaction mixes each contain all four conventional deoxyribonucleotide triphosphates (dNTPs) plus a small amount of one dideoxyribonucleotide triphosphate (ddNTP), an analog that leads to chain termination since the lacking 3’-hydroxyl group prevents formation of a phosphodiester bond with a succeeding nucleotide. The four assays each contain a different dideoxynucleotide triphosphate. The chain extension reaction thus competes with the infrequent but specific termination by a ddNTP. This leads to a mixture of DNA fragments of varying lengths that all possess the same 5’-end owing to the common primer. Since one of the dNTPs contains a radioactive isotope (either 32P or 35S) these fragments become radioactively labeled and can be detected by autoradiography after separation by gel electrophoresis. The corresponding sequence is derived from the From. Methods m Molecular S/ology, Vol 23 DNA Sequencmg Protocols Edlted by. H and A Grlffm CopyrIght 01993 Humana Press Inc , Totowa,
91
NJ
92
Diirre and Gerischer
band pattern of the four different reaction mixtures. Single-stranded phage and denatured double-stranded plasmid DNA can serve as a template, thus opening the possibility to use a large variety of vectors for cloning. Primers that are complementary to various regions of the multicloning sites of these vectors are commercially available from a number of molecular biological companies or can easily be synthesized in the lab (compare Chapter 11). The sequencing reaction is catalyzed by DNA polymerases such as Klenow fragment of Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I, reverse transcriptase (from Avian Myeloblastosis Virus [AMV] or MoloneyMurine Leukemia Virus [M-MLV]), a number of thermostable polymerases (from Thermus aquaticus [Tuq], Thermus thermophilus [Tth], Thermococcuslitoralis [Vent,], Bacillus stearothennophilus pst]), and T7 DNA polymerase. Originally, the Klenow fragment was used for dideoxy sequencing. However, this enzyme has a low processivity, meaning that it will randomly dissociate from the template and thus give rise to fragments that were not terminated by incorporation of a dideoxyribonucleotide. Thus, only relatively short sequences can be determined reliably in one run. Furthermore, chain elongation proceeds at a relatively low rate, secondary structures of the template create a problem, special nucleotides used in case of band compressions are not equally well incorporated, and the enzyme is very sensitive to contaminants in template preparations. Reverse transcriptase can better cope with problems caused by secondary structures in the template DNA, but thermostable polymerases usually are the method of choice in this case since even stable secondary structures are precluded at temperatures of 70-75°C. The bacteriophage T7 DNA polymerase complex consists of two polypeptides, the gene 5 product encoded by the phage and thioredoxin encoded by the E. coli host (2,3). This enzyme is now widely used for dideoxy sequencing because of its high processivity, high rate of polymerization, and tolerance for nucleotide analogs. Since the enzyme has been reported to possess a high 3’-5’ exonuclease activity (4,5) two different ways have been used to render it suitable for sequencing. One approach was to modify the enzyme either chemically by oxidation (6,7,Jor genetically to remove the exonuclease activity. The resulting products are known under the trade name “Sequenase” and
DNA Sequencing
Using T7 Polymerase
their use is described in Chapter 14. The other approach made use of a specific FPLC-purification of cloned T7 DNA polymerase to obtain a protein suitably low in exonuclease activity. Such a preparation proved to be similarly advantageous or even superior to modified T7 polymerase (8). This chapter describes the dideoxy sequencing procedure using unmodified T7 DNA polymerase. 2. Materials 2.1. Primers Various primers for a number of commonly used cloning vectors are commercially available (e.g., from Amersham [Arlington Heights, IL], GIBCO BRL [Gaithersburg, MD], International Biotechnologies Inc. [New Haven, CT], New England Biolabs [Beverly, MA], Pharmacia LKB [Piscataway, NJ], Sigma [St. Louis, MO], Stratagene [La Jolla, CA], United States Biochemical Corporation [Cleveland, OH]). Alternatively, appropriate primers can be synthesized by automatic machines or by hand (compare Chapter 11). The concentration of primer in the annealing reaction should be approx 0.11 w (corresponding to 0.67 pg/mL for a 17mer). However, even much higher concentrations have been used successfully (compare Chapter 11). 2.2. Template Preparation (Double-Stranded Plasmid DNA) 1. STEbuffer: 100mM NaCl, 10mM Tr~s-HCl,pH 7.5,l mM EDTA, pH 7.5. 2. Lysozyme solution: 50 mM glucose, 50 rnk! Tris-HCl, pH 8.0, 10 mM EDTA, pH 8.0. This solution should be autoclaved or filter sterilized and stored at 4°C. Prior to use 5 mg/mL crystalline lysozyme are added and completely dissolved. 3. SDS solution: Sodium dodecyl sulfate (l%, w/v) m NaOH (0.2M). Prepare fresh before use. Store at room temperature. 4. Sodrum acetate solution: 3M sodium acetate, pH 4.8. This solution IS prepared by dissolving 246.1 g of waterfree CH,COONa m 500 mL HzO, adjusting the pH to 4.8 with glacial acetic acid, and then adjusting the volume to 1 L. Store at room temperature. 5. Isopropanol: 100% (v/v). 6. Phenol/chloroform solution: Melt crystalline phenol at approx 50°C. Equilibrate the liquid with 0.2M Tris-HCI, pH 7.8. Only dlstllled phenol should be used. Do not use higher concentrated buffers for equili-
94
Diirre
and Gerischer
bration, smce that will affect phase separatton. MIX chloroform and lsoamyl alcohol m a ratio of 24: 1. Mix this new solution with the equiltbrated phenol in a ratio of 1:l to obtain the final reagent. Store m a brown glass bottle (if possible, under a nitrogen atmosphere) at 4°C. 7. Ethanol: 96 and 70% (v/v). 8. TE buffer: 10 mM Tris-HCl, pH 7.5, 1 r&f EDTA, pH 7.5. 9. RNase solutron: 10 mM Trrs-HCl, pH 7.5, 15 n&I NaCl, RNase (2 mg/ mL). Dissolve enzyme completely and keep the solutton at 100°C for 15 min to inactivate possible DNase contaminants. Let cool to room temperature, divide in small ahquots, and store at -20°C. 10 Chloroform solution, MIX chloroform and isoamyl alcohol tn a mtto of 24: 1. 2.3. Sequencing Reactions 2.3.1. Primer Annealing 1. Template: single- or double-stranded DNA, 0.25 pg/pL. 2. NaOH solutton: 2M NaOH. 3. Sodmm acetate solution: 3M sodmm acetate, pH 4.5. For preparatton see Section 2.2., step 4. 4. Ethanol: 96 and 70% (v/v). 5. Primer solution: 0.8 @4 in TE buffer or H20. 6. Annealing buffer: 280 mMTris-HCI, pH 7.5,100 m/t4MgCl,, 350 mM NaCl. 7. DTE solutton: 0.3M dithioerythrttol. 2.3.2. Labeling Reaction 1, T7 DNA polymerase, FPLC-purified, suitable for sequencing (Pharmacta LKB). Be careful to keep the enzyme constantly at -20°C. For takmg an ahquot the polymerase should be removed only briefly from the freezer. The aliquot IS then diluted wrth drlutron buffer and used for sequencing. The dilutton can be kept on Ice until the sequencing reactions are set up. 2. Drlutron buffer: 20 mM Trts-HCI, pH 7.5, 5 nut4 drthroerythrttol, 50 pg/mL bovine serum albumin. 3. Radioactive nucleotide: [a-32P]dATP or [a-35S]dATPaS, 370 MBq (10 mCl)/mL and 370 463 MBq (10 -12.5 mCi)/mL, respectively. Both nucleotides are mcorporated equally well mto the growing obgodeoxyribonucleotlde chain by T7 DNA polymerase. Using 35S,sharper bands are obtained in the autoradrogram and, as a result of the avoidance of scattering, longer sequencescan be deciphered in one run. The shelf life of this isotope IS longer, and the radiation dose of the personnel IS reduced (9). Advantages of 32Pare that shorter exposure times are required and that the sequencing gel does not need to be dried before autoradiography.
DNA Sequencing
Using T7 Polymerase Table 1 of Termination
Composition A-Mix
Component stock solution, mM dATP (1) dCTP (1) dGTP (1) dTTP (1) ddATP (0.5) ddCTP (0.5) ddGTP (0.5) ddTTP (0.5) Sequencing buffer MgC12 (50) Tris-HCl, pH 7.5 (200) NaCl(250) H2O
Mixes
C-Mix
G-Mix
T-MIX
PL
w
PL
PM
PL
w
w
PM
15 15 15 15 3
150 150 150 150 15
15 15 15 15
150 150 150 150
15 15 15 15
150 150 150 150
15 15 15 15
150 150 150 150
-
3 -
20
3
20 10 40 50
17
-
15
-
15 3 20
20 10 40 50
17
-
10 40 50 17
15 10 40 50
17
4. Labeling mtx: 1.375 p.M dCTP, 1.375 @I dGTP, 1.375 @I dTTP, 333.5 mM NaCl. This mix can be stored m alrquots at -20°C.
5. DTE solutron: 0.3M dithioerythrrtol. 2.3.3. Termination
Reaction 1, Termmation mixes: dATP, dGTP, dCTP, dTTP, ddATP, ddCTP, ddGTP, ddTTP, concentratronssee Table 1 (see Note 1). 2. Sequencing buffer: Composition see Table 1. 3. Stop solution: 95% (v/v) formamide, analytical grade, 20 mM EDTA, pH 7.5, 0.05% (w/v) xylene cyanol, 0.05% (w/v) bromophenol blue.
This solution should be stored at -20°C (if possible, under a nitrogen atmosphere). T7 DNA polymerase is also available in a kit, together with most of the required solutions (Pharmacia LIB). The composition of these solutions was not disclosed by the manufacturer. Sequencing using the reagents described above yields results that are practically identical to those obtained by the premade sequencing kit (Fig. 1). However, use of this kit saves the time for preparation of the solutions and, furthermore, provides so-called “read long sequencing mixes” that allow sequencing of up to 1000 nucleotides per run if a high resolution sequencing equipment is available.
96
Diirre
and Gerischer
Fig. 1, T7 DNA sequencing using different solutions and reagent mixtures. (A) Results from sequencing using solutions and chemicals described in this chapter. (B) Results using a commercially available sequencing kit from Pharmacia LKB. A part of the DNA sequence of Closrridium acefoburylicum, a strictly anaerobic, sporeforming bacterium, is shown. A 6% sequencing gel has been used. G, A, T, C, products from sequencing reactions.
2.4. Gel Electmphomsis The respectivematerials and methods aredetailed in Chapters16 and 17. 2.5. Autoradiography 1. Acetic acid: 10% (v/v). 2. X-ray film: Kodak (Rochester, NY) or Amersham. 3. Light-protected box for washing and autoradiography
of the gel.
3. Method 3.1. PrimQrs Primer design and synthesis are detailed in Chapter 11.
DNA Sequencing
Using T7 Polymerase 3.2. Template
97
Preparation
Isolation procedures of single-stranded phage DNA and doublestranded plasmid DNA suitable for sequencing are described in other chapters of this volume. In case of plasmid DNA we found a modification of the method of Birnboim and Doly (10) especially well suited. This procedure is detailed below. 1. Centrtfuge 5 mL of bacterial culture grown overnight at 6,000g for 5 min at 4°C. 2 Discard supematantand suspendthe sedimenttn 150pL lysozymesolution. 3. Transfer the preparation to a sterilized microcentrifuge cup and mcubate for at least 5 mm at room temperature. 4. Add 300 pL SDS solution and mix gently by hand for a few seconds 5. Immedtately add 225 uL sodium acetate solution. 6. Mix gently by hand for a few seconds and Incubate for 15 mm at 0°C 7. Centrifuge for 5 min at 4°C m a microcentrtfuge at maximal speed. Use either a model with coolmg system or place centrifuge in the coldroom 8. Transfer supernatant to a new microcentrifuge cup using a microliter prpet with sterilized tip. Be very careful to take only the supernatant 9. Add 600 pL isopropanol to precipitate the DNA and vortex a few seconds, 10 Incubate for 5 mm at room temperature. 11. Centrifuge for 5 mm at room temperature in a microcentrifuge at maximal speed. 12. Remove supernatant completely and rinse sediment with 1 mL cold ethanol (70%). 13. Let the sediment au dry (3-5 min) and then suspend it m 100 pL TE buffer. 14. Add 1 pL RNase solution and incubate for 15 min at room temperature. 15. Add 260 pL H,O and 40 pL sodium acetate solution. 16. Add 1 vol of phenol/chloroform solution. Attention: Wear gloves to avoid any harm to your fingers if spilling this solution 17. Vortex a few seconds and centrifuge for 5 mm at room temperature m a microcentrifuge at maximal speed. 18. Transfer upper phase to a new microcentrifuge cup and add 1 vol chloroform solution. 19. Mix gently by mvertmg the closed cup several times. 20. Centrifuge a few seconds for phase separation and transfer upper phase to a new microcentrifuge cup 21. Add 2 vols of cold ethanol (96%) to precipitate the DNA and vortex a few seconds. 22. Incubate for 15 mm at -70°C.
98
Diirre
and Gerischer
23. Centrifuge for 10 mm at 4OC in a microcentrifuge at maximal speed. 24. Rinse sediment with 1 mL cold ethanol (70%) and mix briefly. 25. Centrifuge for 10 min at 4°C m a microcentrifuge at maximal speed and discard supernatant. 26. Dry the sediment under vacuum (3-5 mm) and then suspend it in 20 pL TE buffer. This procedure usually yields 10 -20 pg plasmid DNA from a 5mL culture. 3.3. Sequencing Reactions The procedure described below represents a modification method of Tabor and Richardson (6).
of the
3.3.1. Primer Annealing Whereas single-stranded phage DNA can be used directly as a template, double-stranded plasmid DNA must be denatured first. 1. Pipet 8 pL double-stranded plasmid DNA (contau-nng 2 pg nucleic acid) mto a sterilized microcentrifuge cup. 2. Add 2 pL NaOH and vortex the cup briefly. 3. Centrifuge the cup for a few seconds m a microcentrifuge at maximal speed to concentrate the complete solution at the bottom of the cup. 4. Incubate the cup for 10 min at room temperature. 5. Add 7 pL sterilized HZ0 and 3 pL of sodium acetate solution. 6. Add 60 pL of cold (-20°C) ethanol (96%), mix well and incubate the cup for 20 mm at -70°C. 7. Centrifuge for 10 min at room temperature m a microcentrifuge at maximal speed and discard supernatant. 8. Add 300 pL of cold ethanol (70%) and mix briefly. 9. Centrifuge for 10 mm at room temperature in a microcentrifuge at maximal speed. 10. Remove the supernatant carefully and dry the sediment under vacuum (3-5 mm). 11. Suspend the pellet in 10 pL sterihzed H20. 12. Add 2 pL annealing buffer, 2 pL of primer solution, and 1 pL of DTE solution. 13. Incubate for 20 mm at 37°C. 14 Keep the cup at room temperature for at least 10 mm. If the sequencing reaction is not carried out subsequently, the solution should be stored at -20°C until needed. For single-stranded DNA the following procedure can be used:
DNA Sequencing
Using T7 Polymerase
99
1. Pipet 10 pL template (contaming 2 pg DNA) into a sterthzed microcentrifuge cup. 2. Add 2 Ils, of primer solution, 2 pL of annealing buffer, and 1 pL of DTE solution, 3. Vortex the cup briefly. 4. Centrifuge the cup for a few seconds m a microcentrifuge at maximal speed to concentrate the complete solution at the bottom of the cup. 5. Incubate the cup for 10 mm at 60°C. 6. Keep the cup at room temperature for at least 10 mm. If the sequencing reaction is not carried out subsequently, the solution should be stored at -20°C until needed. 3.3.2. Labeling Reaction Since T7 DNA polymerase exhibits a high processivity and a high rate of polymerization the proper sequencing reaction is divided into two parts. In the first stage (labeling reaction) low concentrations of the four deoxyribonucleotides and a relatively low temperature result in the formation of short oligodeoxyribonucleotide chains (approx 2030 bases). Since a radioactive nucleotide is present in the reaction mixture, all fragments become uniformly labeled, which is important for equal band intensities in the autoradiography step. In the second stage (termination reaction) the four standard reactions mixtures are set up that contain high concentrations of the four deoxyribonucleotides and a single dideoxyribonucleotide each. Higher temperature
and nonlimiting dNTP concentration then allow a high rate of polymerization that is only terminated by incorporation of a ddNTP. 1. Dilute T7 DNA polymerase with dilution buffer to a concentration of 1.5 u&L. 2. Add 0.8 -1 l.tL radioactive dATP (370 p.Bq-10 pCi) to the microcentrifuge cup contammg annealed primer/template. 3. Add 3 ~.ILlabeling mix. 4. Add 1 pL DTE solutton. 5. Add 2 pL diluted T7 DNA polymerase. 6. Mix by pipeting several times up and down in the cup with a mlcroltter pipet and a sterilized tip. 7. Incubate for exactly 5 min at room temperature and then proceed directly with the termination reactton. 3.3.3. Termination Reaction 1. Prepare the 4 termmation mixes. This should be done in advance (e.g., during the incubation period of the annealing reaction).
100
Diirre and Gerischer
2. Set up appropriate vials for the termination reaction (microcentrifuge cups or a microtiter plate) and mark them carefully with “A,” “C,” “G,” and “T.” 3. Pipet 2.5 pL of the respective termmation mix into the correspondmg cup or well. 4. Warm mixtures to 37°C in a water bath (takes approx 1 mm). 5. Pipet 4.5 pL of the labeling mixture into each cup or well. Use a fresh tip for each transfer. 6. Mix briefly by pipetlng several times up and down with the rmcrohter pipet. 7. Incubate the reaction mixture for exactly 5 mm at 37°C. Since 4 reactions have to be processed,use defined time intervals (e.g., 30-60 s) for pipetmg to ensure that every mixture was incubated the same amount of time. 8. Add 5 pL of stop solution to each cup or well. 9. Mix briefly by pipettng several times up and down with the microliter pipet. 10. Denature template and oligodeoxynucleotides by heating the cups or microtiter plate for 3 mm at 80°C. Il. Put vials on ice. 12. Load 1.8-2 pL of each mixture onto a sequencing gel. The remammg material of the termination reactions can be stored at -20°C and used for further sequencing runs if necessary. Be sure to denature the mixtures agam before loading onto a gel. 13. In order to read as many bases as possible, 2 samples from each reaction mixture should be run on the same gel, with a period of electrophoresis (approx 2-3 h, until the first colored marker band reaches the end of the gel) between the two loadmgs. 3.4. Gel Ebctmphoresis The respective methods are detailed in Chapters 16 and 17. 3.5. Autoradiography 1. After fmlshmg the electrophoresis as detailed m the above-mentioned chapters remove the glass plates from the sequencing equipment. 2. Remove one of the plates so that the gel still sticks to one glass plate. 3. Put gel on plate into a horizontal box and cover it with 2 L acetic acid (10%) (see Notes 2 and 3). 4. Incubate for 30 -40 min at room temperature with occasional agitation to remove the urea from the gel. 5. Dry gel on plate at 80°C for 90 mm. Liquid should be wiped off the plate before putting it mto the oven. Alternatively, the gel can be transferred to Whatman filter paper and dried on an ordinary gel dryer. If 32P-labeled dATP is used, drying is optional. Instead, the gel can be
DNA Sequencing
Using T7 Polymerase
101
covered with a plastic wrap. Suitable X-ray film is then put on top of it and exposed at -20 or -70°C for approx 4 h. 6. Cover the gel directly with a suitable X-ray film and expose it overnight (35S-labeling) in a light-protected box at room temperature. 7. Develop the film according to the manufacturer’s instructions and determme the sequence (see Note 4).
4. Notes 1. To avoid band compressions by G-G or G-C band pairing nucleotide analogs such as 7-deaza-dGTP, 7-deaza-dITP, or dITP can be used instead of dGTP. Complete premade mixes with c7dGTP and c7dITP are available from Pharmacia LKB. 2. To remove urea from sequencing gels with a final acrylamide concentration of more than 12%, the acetic acid wash solution should contam 2% (w/v) glycerol. Otherwise, the gel might crack upon drying. 3. The acetic acid wash solution might be reused for not more than four times. This will help to reduce the amount of radioactive waste. 4. Starting with prepared template DNA and primers one round of sequencmg including the autoradiography can be performed m 24 h (calculating overnight as exposure time). 5. Using this procedure we found that even PCR-products could be directly sequenced after only one phenol treatment, one chloroform extractton, and one ethanol precipitation as described in Section 3.2. 6. If multiple sequencing reactions with the same double-stranded plasmid are planned, it is recommended to use a large amount of plasmid in the denaturation reaction. This will save time for future sequencing reactions. The denatured DNA after being dissolved in 10 pL sterilized HZ0 can be stored at -20°C.
Acknowledgments We thank R. Fischer, K. Herwig, and U. Sauer for helpful discussions and preparation of Fig. 1. Work reported from this laboratory has been supported by grants from the Bundesminister fiir Forschung und Technologle and the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft. References 1. Sanger, F., Nlcklen, S., and Coulson, A R (1977) DNA sequencing with chainterminating inhibitors. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 74, 5463-5467. 2 Modrich, P and Richardson, C. C. (1975) Bacteriophage T7 deoxyribonucleic acid replication in vitro. Bacteriophage T7 DNA polymerase. An enzyme composed of phage- and host-specified subunits J Blol Chem. 250,55 15-5522
102
Diirre
and Gerischer
3 Mark, D F. and Rtchardson, C C (1976) Escherichia colr thioredoxin A subumt of bactertophage T7 DNA polymerase Proc Nut1 Acad. Sci. USA 73, 780-784 4 Hori, K , Mark, D. F., and Richardson, C. C. (1979) Deoxyribonucleic actd polymerase of bacterrophage T7. Characterizatton of the exonuclease activrties of the gene 5 protein and the reconstituted polymerase. J Blol Chem 254, 11,598-l 1,604 5 Adler, S. and Modrtch, P (1979) T7-induced DNA polymerase. Charactertzation of associated exonuclease acttvtttes and resolutton mto btologtcally actrve subunits. J Blol Chem 254, 11,605-l 1,614 6. Tabor, S. and Rtchardson, C. C. (1987) DNA sequence analysis with a modrfied bacteriophage T7 DNA polymerase. Proc Nat1 Acad Sci USA 84,47674771. 7 Tabor, S and Rrchardson, C C (1987) Selectrve oxidation of the exonuclease domain of bactertophage T7 DNA polymerase. J Biol Chem 262, 15,33015,333. 8. Krtstensen, T., Voss, H , Schwager, C , Stegemann, J., Sproat, B., and Ansorge, W. (1988) T7 DNA polymerase in automated dtdeoxy sequencing. Nucl. Aczds Res 16,348 l-3496. 9 Van Helden, P. D (1988) Use of 35S nucleottdes for DNA sequencmg, m Methods in Molecular Biology, vol. 4. New Nucleic Acids Techniques (Walker, J. M., ed ), Humana, Chfton, NJ, pp. 81-88. 10 Birnborm, H. C. and Daly, J (1979) A rapid alkaline extraction procedure for screening recombinant plasmid DNA. Nucl. Acids Res 7, 15 13-1523
&WI’ER
14
Dideoxy Sequencing Reactions Using Sequenase Version 2.0 Hugh G. Griffin
and Annette M. Grij”fZn
1. Introduction The dideoxy chain-termination method of DNA sequence analysis involves the synthesis of a DNA strand by enzymatic extension from a specific primer using a DNA polymerase (I). Several different enzymes are available for this purpose each having different qualities and properties. The use of the Klenow fragment of DNA polymerase I, DNA polymerase, and T7 DNA polymerase in DNA sequence analysis is described elsewhere in this volume. Bacteriophage T7 polymerase is an enzyme which has both a DNAdependent DNA polymerase activity and a 3’-5’ exonuclease activity, and can be used for DNA sequence analysis. However, the nucleotide analogs incorporated into the DNA strand by the polymerase activity are efficiently removed again by the exonuclease activity (2). The 3’-5’ exonuclease activity associated with T7 DNA polymerase also means that this enzyme does not undergo strand-displacement synthesis (2). In addition, the exonuclease activity has the effect of lowering processivity (the average number of nucleotides polymerized on a particular primer-template prior to dissociating), and giving an apparent polymerase activity much lower than it otherwise might be (2). From Methods m Molecular Bology, Vol 23 DNA Sequencing Protocols E&ted by Ii and A Grlffm Copynght 01993 Humana Press Inc , Totowa,
103
NJ
104
Griffin
and Griffin
Some years ago a chemically modified version of T7 DNA polymerase was produced that lacked most of the exonuclease activity but retained all of the polymerase activity (3,4). This chemically modified enzyme was called Sequenase. Later, a genetically engineered version of T7 DNA polymerase was produced which had a total absence of 3’-5’ exonuclease activity, was extremely stable and had a higher specific activity than the chemically modified enzyme (2,.5,6). This form of the enzyme was named Sequenase Version 2.0. Sequenase and Sequenase Version 2.0 have proven themselves to be very useful for dideoxy sequencing. They have properties markedly different from those of T7 DNA polymerase and other enzymes used for DNA sequencing. These properties include low (Sequenase) or no (Sequenase Version 2.0) 3’-5’ exonuclease activity, high processivity, high rate of polymerization, and efficient incorporation of nucleotide analogs (dITP, a-thio-dATP, 7-deaza-dGTP, dideoxy NTP’s, etc.). Both versions of the enzyme have higher processivity; a single molecule will incorporate thousands of nucleotides before dissociating from the template than the Klenow fragment of E. coli DNA polymerase I, whose processivity is only about lo-50 nucleotides (7). The rate of polymerization by Sequenaseis about 300 nucleotides per second compared with rates of 30-45 nucleotides per second for the Klenow fragment (7). The Sequenase enzymes can be used directly in the sequencing protocols available for other DNA polymerases. However, a special two-step protocol has been developed and appears to give better and more reliable results with Sequenaseand SequenaseVersion 2.0 (2,7). Template DNA is purified by standard techniques (described elsewhere in this volume) and is annealed to the oligonucleotide primer. The first step of the two-step reaction is the labeling step and is performed by mixing annealed template-primer DNA, dNTP’s including labeled nucleotide, and Sequenase. In this step, extension occurs for a limited number of bases utilizing most of the labeled nucleotide. In the second, or termination step, the reaction mixture is split into four aliquots. Each aliquot is added to a mixture of additional dNTP’s and a single dideoxynucleotide. Polymerization will only continue until a dideoxynucleotide is incorporated into the growing chain. This incorporation occurs randomly, providing the necessary range of sequence-dependent terminations. The entire two-step reac-
Sequencing
with Sequenase
105
tion can be performed in about ten minutes. The reactions are stopped by the addition of EDTA and formamide, heat denatured, and electrophoresed on an acrylamide gel. The unique characteristics of Sequenase Version 2.0 (high processivity, absence of 3’-5’ exonuclease activity, and efficient use of nucleotide analogs) produce radioactive bands of more uniform intensity and less background radioactivity than those obtained usmg other polymerases (2,6,7), and make it the enzyme of choice when sequencing long tracts of DNA. 2. Materials 1. Sequence Version 2.0 enzyme. 2. Enzyme dllutton buffer: 10 nnI4 Trrs-HCI, pH 7.5, 5 mM drthtothrettol, 0.5 mg/mL bovme serum albumm. 3. Sequenase buffer 5X concentrate: 200 nM Trrs-HCI pH 7.5, 100 mM MgC12, 250 rnk! NaCl 4 Primer DNA 0.5 pmol/pL. Universal primer available commercrally from many sources or use custom-designed primer. 5. Dithiothrertol O.lM. 6. Labeling mix 5X concentrate: 7.5 pkf dGTP, 7.5 pk! dCTP, 7.5 @! dTTP (see Note 1). 7 ddG termmatron mix* 80 w dGTP, 80 j&I dATP, 80 J..&IdCTP, 80 pkI dTTP, 8 @4 ddGTP, 50 n-&I NaCl. 8. ddA termination mix: 80 pA4dGTP, 80 pk! dATP, 80 @4 dCTP, 80 pk! dTTP, 8 @I4ddATP, 50 mM NaCl. 9. ddT termmatton mix: 80 pkI dGTP, 80 pkI dATP, 80 pkf dCTP, 80 @4 dTTP, 8 J&I ddTTP, 50 miI4 NaCl. 10. ddC termination mix: 80 pA4dGTP, 80 pk! dATP, 80 pi14dCTP, 80 w dTTP, 8 pkf ddCTP, 50 mM NaCl. 11. Labeled dATP: [a-35S]-dATP (see Note 2). Specific activity should be 1000-1500 Ci/mmol. 12. Stop solutron: 95% formamrde, 20 mikf EDTA, 0.05% bromophenol blue, 0.05% xylene cyanol.
All solutions should be stored at -20°C and kept on ice when thawed for use. Sequenase enzyme should be stored at -20°C (not m a frost free
freezer). Dilute the enzyme in ice-cold dilution buffer when required. Sequenase Version 2.0 is available from United States Biochemical Corporation (USB), PO Box 22400, Cleveland, Ohio, 44122 USA, or from USB c/o Cambridge Bioscience, 25 Signet Court, Stourbrrdge Common Business Centre, Swann’s Road, Cambridge CB5 8LA,
106
Griffin
and Griffin
England. USB offers a sequencing kit that includes all the buffers and nucleotide mixes needed for sequencing with Sequenase, the universal primer, control Ml3 DNA, and Sequenase Version 2.0 enzyme. Alternatively, the individual buffers and nucleotide mixes can be purchased separately. Radioactive safety procedures should be adhered to when handling solutions containing radioactively labeled nucleotides. Radioactive waste should be disposed of properly. 3. Methods 3.1. Annealing Reaction 1. In a small centrifuge tube (seeNotes 3 and 4) setup the following reactton: Primer (0.5 pmol/pL) 1 pL Sequenase buffer (5X) 2 pL 1 pg Ml3 or 5 pg plasmid (see Note 5) DNA Sterile drsttlled water to 10 pL. 2. Place in a 65OC waterbath for 2 mm. Allow to cool slowly to 30°C over a period of about 30 mm (see Note 6). Place on ice (see Note 7). 3.2. Labeling Reaction (see Note 1) 1. Dilute the labeling mrx concentrate 1:5 (1 + 4) wtth water (see Notes 5 and 12). 2. Dilute the Sequenase enzyme 1:8 in ice-cold enzyme dilution buffer. 3. To the annealed primer-template add further soluttons as follows: Primer-template lo& Dithiothreitol (O.lM) lI.IL Diluted labeling mix 2w [a-35S] dATP (10 @4, 10 pCi/pL) 0.5 pL Diluted Sequenase 2 clL* 4. Mix and incubate for 2 min at room temperature (see Note 8). 3.3. Termination Reactions (see Note 1) 1. Label four tubes G, A, T and C (see Notes 3 and 4). 2. Add 2.5 pL of ddGTP termmatton mtx to tube G. Add 2.5 pL of ddATP termmatton mtx to tube A. Add 2.5 pL of ddTTP termination mix to tube T. Add 2.5 pL of ddCTP termination mtx to tube C. 3. Prewarm the four tubes by mcubatmg at 37°C for 1 mm (see Note 9). 4. Add 3.5 cts,of the labeling reaction to each of the four tubes, mtxmg after the addition.
Sequencing with Sequenase
107
5. Incubate at 37OCfor 5 min. 6. Add 4 pL of stop solution to each tube. 7. Heat the tubes at 80°C for 2 min immedtately prior to loading on a gel (see Notes 10-12).
4. Notes 1. If compresston artifacts are a problem m the sequencing gel (often seen with G-C rich templates) try running dITP reactions alongside the dGTP reactions. Compressions occur when the newly synthesized DNA strand does not remain fully denatured during electrophoresis and can usually be eliminated using dITP. The reactions are performed as normal using dITP labeling mix and dITP termination mixes. The dITP labeling mix (5X concentrate) contains: 15 piJ4 dITP, 7.5 pJ4 dCTP, and 7.5 @4 dTTP. The dITP termination mixes are as follows: ddG termination mix (for dITP): 160 ~JVdITP, 80 pit4 dATP, 80 luV dCTP, 80 luV dl’TP, 1.6 pA4 ddGTP, 50 mM NaCI. ddA termination mix (for dITP): 80 l.uV dITP, 80 pJ4 dATP, 80 l,uV dCTP, 80 @4 dTTP, 8 l&V ddATP, 50 mM NaCI. ddT termination mix (for dITP): 80 lU4 dITP, 80 l.&f dATP, 80 @k! dCTP, 80 pil4 dTTP, 8 @f ddTTP, 50 mM NaCl. ddC termination mix (for dITP): 80 l.Ul4dITP, 80 @4 dATP, 80 l.04 dCTP, 80 l.uV dTTP, 8 @4 ddCTP, 50 mM NaCI. 2. Either [a-32P]-dATP or [a-35S]-dATPcan be used although [a-35S]-dATP has the advantagesof htgher resolution, operator safety,and longer half-life. 3. Multi-well microtiter plates with “V-bottom wells are ideal for performing sequencing reactions. The annealing and labeling reactions with Sequenase are probably more conveniently performed in small microcentrifuge tubes and the microtiter plates used for the terminatton reactions. 4. When using multi-well microtiter plates, ensure that samples do not evaporate by using a lid or, if necessary, plastic film. Sticky tape placed over the wells is also useful for this purpose, but take care that samples do not splash when removing it. 5. To read sequence very close to the primer (within 30 bases) it may be necessary to use more template DNA (about 2 pg M13) and to dilute the labeling mix 1:15 rather than 1:5. 6. Allowing the template-primer annealing mixture to cool from 65OC to room temperature is best achteved by incubation in a small beaker of 65°C water that is allowed to stand at room temperature for about 30 min. 7. It is recommended that the annealed template-primer is stored on ice and used within 4 h.
Griffin
and Griffin
8. Do not perform the labeling reaction at a temperature above 20°C or for longer than 5 mm. To do so may result in pause sites close to the primer. 9. Do not perform the termmations at temperatures below 37°C or for longer than 5 min. To do so may cause pause sites above 100 bases from the primer. Performing termination reactions at higher temperatures (up to 50°C) may improve results in some cases 10. When using 35S,the sequencing reactions can be stored at -20°C for up to 1 wk before electrophoresls. Denature by heating at 80°C for 2 mm immediately prior to loading. 11. Incubation steps, especially the denaturatlon at 80°C for 2 min, are best performed in a water bath rather than an incubator. This is because samples may not equilibrate to the desired temperature in an incubator m the relatively short mcubatlon times used m this protocol. 12. Sequence 300 -400 bases from the primer should be readily obtained following the normal procedure. There are two ways to extend the sequence further. One is by increasing the nucleotlde concentration m the labeling reactlon. To achieve this, use the labeling mix undiluted and double the amount of radioactive Isotope. The other method 1sto change the ratio of deoxynucleotldes m the termination step. This is readily achieved usmg the Sequence Extendmg Mix marketed by USB. Increasing the deoxy concentration with respect to the dideoxy concentration ~111extend the sequence further from the primer. Note that the quality of gel electrophoresis will limit the amount of sequence
information
obtainable.
References 1 Sanger, F , Nicklen, S., and Coulson, A R. (1977) DNA sequencmg with chaintermmatlon inhibitors. Proc. Natl. Acad Sci USA 74, 5463-5467. 2. Fuller, C. W. (1988) Sequenase Version 2.0. CJSBEdltorlal Comments 15, l-4 3. Tabor, S. and Richardson, C. C (1987) DNA sequence analysis with a modified bacteriophage T7 DNA polymerase. Proc. Natl. Acad Scl USA 84,4767477 1 4 Tabor, S and Richardson, C. C (1987) Selective oxldatlon of the exonuclease domain of bacteriophage T7 DNA polymerase J Blol. Chem. 262, 15,33015,333. 5. Tabor, S. and Richardson, C. C. (1989) Effect of manganese ions on the incorporation of dideoxynucleotldes by bacteriophage T7 DNA polymerase and Escherirhia coli DNA polymerase I. Proc. Nat1 Acad. SCL USA 86, 40764080 6 labor, S. and Richardson, C C (1989) Selective mactlvatlon of the exonuclease activity of bacteriophage T7 DNA polymerase by rn vitro mutagenesis J Biol Chem 264,6447-6458. 7 Fuller, C. W (1988) DNA Sequencing. USB Editorial Comments 14, 1-7.
Dideoxy Sequencing Reactions Using Taq Polymerase Fabrizio
Arigoni
and P. Alexandre
Kaminski
1. Introduction Tuq DNA polymerase is a highly stable polymerase isolated from the thermophilic organism Thermus aquaticus. Because of its unique
properties this enzyme has been extensively used for amplification of DNA fragments by the polymerase chain reaction (PCR). In addition, the thermostability of Tuq DNA Polymerase has proven to be extremely useful for sequencing single-stranded templates by the dideoxy chain termination reaction (l-3). The advantage of sequencing with Tuq DNA polymerase is that the reaction can be extended at high temperature, thus eliminating most band compression encountered when sequencing G + C-rich templates or hairpin regions. This method is particularly useful when sequencing DNA from organisms with a high G + C content where ambiguities are frequently found on the gels (see Fig. 1). Currently several companies have developed sequencing kits using Tuq DNA polymerase. We have tried the TAQenceTM (U.S. Biochemicals, Cleveland, OH) and the Tuq multiwellTM (Amersham, Arlington Heights, IL) kits, both of which gave comparably good results. However these kits are relatively expensive and similar results can be obtained by preparing the different solutions with little loss of time. Here we describe a protocol From Methods in Molecular B/ology, Vol 23 DNA Sequencmg Protocols Edlted by H and A Gnffm Copynght 01993 Humana Press Inc , Totowa, NJ
109
110
Arigoni
and Kaminski
Fig. 1. Autoradiography of polyacrylamide gel comparing sequence of a G + C rich DNA template with Tuq DNA polymerase using either dGTP (I) or 7-deazadGTP (II) in the reaction mixes. All reactions were performed as described in the text using an M 13mp 19 derived single-stranded templates labeled by incorporation of [(x-~~S] dATP. The reactions were analyzed on a 6% polyacrylamide-urea gel using 0.5X TBE buffer (see Chapter 16). The brackets indicate the area of compression caused by secondary structure formed by the template DNA that are resolved by the 7-deaza-dGTP substitution.
Sequencing
with Taq Polymerase
111
based on the chain termination reaction as described by Stambaugh and Blakesley (4) that involves two major steps. The first step is the so-called extension reaction, or labeling reaction, that includes annealing of a synthetic primer to the template DNA and synthesis of the complementary strand including radioactively labeled dATP. This step is carried out at relatively low temperature (45°C) to avoid separation of the primer and the template DNA. The second step, the termination reaction, is carried out at 70°C in four different tubes, each containing a mixture of nucleotides and one of the four dideoxynucleotides (ddNTP). The dideoxynucleotides are nucleotide analogs that lack the 3’-OH group necessary for chain elongation. Once a ddNTP has been incorporated the reaction will be terminated. Since the ddNTPs are incorporated randomly, the reaction will give rise to DNA fragments from several to hundreds of nucleotides in length. The reaction is then stopped with a solution containing EDTA and formamide, and separated on a polyacrylamide-urea electrophoresis gel. Despite the high temperature at which the reaction is carried out, some clones are reluctant to denaturation, and band compression will still form during electrophoresis. This artifact can be eliminated by substituting dGTP with 7-deaza-dGTP, a dGTP analog that forms weaker bonds with dCTP, thus weakening the secondary structure formed (5). 2. Materials 1. 10X Reaction buffer: 700 rnIt4 Tris-HCl , pH 8.8, 20 mM MgC12, 1% Triton X-100. 2. Taq DNA polymerase (Cetus or Beckmann) 5 U&L. 3. 5X Labeling mix: 12 @V dCTP, 12 @4 dGTP, 12 pII4 dTTP. 4. [a-35S] dATP > 600 Ci/mmol 5. Termination mixes: Prepare the 4 termination mixes named TMA, TMC, TMG, TMT at the following concentration in Hz0 shown in Table 1. If 7-deaza-dGTP is to be used, replace dGTP by 7-deaza-dGTP at the same concentration in all termination mixes as well as in the labeling mrx (see Notes 4 and 8). 6. Stop solution: 95% formamide, 20 rmt4 EDTA, 0.05% bromophenol blue, 0.05% xylene cyan01 FF. 7. Single-stranded DNA (l-2 pg) resuspended in TloEo 1 buffer (10 nuI4 Tris-HCl, 0.1 n&I EDTA, pH 8.0). For preparation of template DNA (see Chapters 5 and 6). 8. Prtmer: 0.5 pmol; usually 15-20mer.
112
Arigoni
and Kaminski
Table 1 Four Termmatlon Mixes TMA ddATP ddCTP ddGTP ddTTP dATP dCTP dGTP dTTP
100 25 250 250 250
pM
w ~.IM @4 j.M
TMC
TMG
TMT
100 pkl -
3o@f 250 w 250 @cl 25 w 250 /.IM
l(@cIM 250 pA4 250 pM 250 @I 25 w
250 25 250 250
@f w /.&I /.M
3. Method 1, To anneal the template and primer, combme the followmg in a 1.5mL Eppendorf tube (see Notes 3 and 7): 9.5 pL smgle-stranded template DNA (l-2 pg), 1.6 pL 10X reaction buffer, 1 pL primer (0.5 pmol). Close the tube, place it at 70°C m a heating block filled with water, and allow it to cool slowly by placing the heating block at room temperature until the temperature reaches about 30°C. Centrifuge the tube briefly to collect the droplets formed on top and store on ice. The labelmg reaction should be performed on the sample in the following hour. 2. To carry out the labelmg reactton, add the followmg (see Notes l-3): 2 pL 1X labeling mix, 1 ltL [a-35S] dATP, 1 pL Taq DNA polymerase (dilute m 1X reaction buffer to 2.5 U&L). Incubate at 45°C m a water bath for 5 mm. 3. For the termination reaction, prepare four different mtcrocentrifuge tubes labeled A, C, G, and T, each contammg 3.5 & of the correspondmg termination reaction (3.5 @LTMA in the tube labeled A, 3.5 pL TMC in the tube labeled C, etc.). If several clones are sequenced at the same time it is advtsable to prepare the tubes contammg the termmatton mtxes m advance and to store them on ice, capped to prevent evaporation. Add 3.5-w aliquots of the labeling reaction to each of the 4 tubes and place them immediately in a waterbath at 70°C for 5 min. Remove the reaction tubes from the water bath, let them cool to room temperature, add 3.5 pL Stop solution, and store on ice until ready to deposit on gel. Heat the samples 5 min at 70°C and load 2-3 pL on a high resolution polyacrylamtde gel (see Notes 4-6). The reaction mixture can be frozen and kept at -2O’C for several days. Samples should always be heated 5 mm at 70°C before loading.
Sequencing
with Taq Polymerase
113
4. Notes 1. When performing sequencing reaction, be sure to respect the same order as described in the protocol. 2. Use only 7-deaza-dGTPtermmation nuxes with 7-deaza-dGTPlabeling mtx. 3. Reactions can be performed in microtiter plates, which are particularly useful when several samples are to be analyzed. However, great care should be taken to avold excessive evaporation. 4. dNTP and ddNTP concentration were optimized to sequence DNA from organisms with high G + C content (65%) and may have to be adjusted for other organisms. This is best done by altering the ddNTP concentratron m the different termination mixes (Le., if the A lane is too faint in the bottom of the gel, increase the ddATP concentration 2-3 folds in the TMA mix). 5. The amount of sequence Information obtained by this protocol ranges from several nucleotldes to 350 -400 nucleottdes, and is mostly limited by gel electrophoresls. 6. Some compression may also appear when sequencing with 7-deazadGTP but generally at different places than those observed with dGTP. Therefore, we recommend running both reactions m parallel when sequencing a G + C rich hairpin region. 7. S-end-labeled primers can also be used for sequencing, m this case omit the [a-35S] dATP m the labeling reaction. 8. From our experience, 7-deaza-dGTP appears to be lessstable than dGTP, which can result in fuzzy bands on the gel. Therefore, labeling and termmation mixes with 7-deaza-dGTP should be freshly prepared or aliquoted when stored at -2OOC. 9. The annealing step can be replaced by heating at 45°C for 10 min after denaturing at 70°C for 2 min and subsequent cooling on ice, however, we observed that when using nonpurifed synthetic oligonucleotide as primer, heating at 70°C as described in this protocol gives higher quality results. This is particularly true when the oligonuceotide is relatively G + C rich.
Acknowledgments The authors wish to thank J.-P. Aubert and C. Elmerich in whose laboratory this work was carried out. We also would like to thank C. Vieille for providing technical data and D. Maze1 for critical reading of the manuscript.
References 1. Sanger,F., Nlcklen, S.,andCoulson,A. R. (1977) DNA sequencingwith chain terminating inhibitors Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 74, 5463-5467.
114
Arigoni
and Kaminski
2 Innis, M. A , Myambo, K. B., Gelfand, D. H , and Brown, M A D (1988) DNA sequencing with Thermus aquaticus DNA polymerase and direct sequencing of polymerase chain reaction-amplified DNA Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA f&9436-9440
3. Brow, M. A. D. (1990) Sequencing wtth Tuq DNA polymerase, in PCR Protocols. A Guide to Methods and Applications (Innis, M , Gelfand, D., Snmski, J., and White, T , eds.), Academic, NY, pp 189-196. 4. Stambaugh, K. and Blakesley, R. (1988) Extended DNA Sequencmg with Klenow Fragment. The Kilobase Sequencingm System Focus 10:2,29-3 1 5. Barr, P. J., Thayer, R. M., Laybourn, P , NaJarion, R C., Seela, F , and Tolan, D. R. (1986) 7-deaza-2’-deoxyguanosine-S-triphosphate: enhanced resolutton in Ml3 dideoxy sequencing. Biotechnrques 4,428-432
&TARTER
Pouring and Buffer-Gradient Paul
16
Linear Sequencing
Gels
Littlebury
1. Introduction The products of sequencing reactions are separated on thin, low percentage (usually 6%) polyacrylamide gels. Normally, these gels are 40-50 cm in length, 20 cm wide, and between 0.3 and 0.4 mm thick. Longer gels (to enable more sequence to be read from a single run) up to 100 cm in length can be poured, as can wider gels (to enable more clones to be loaded onto a single gel). However, these larger gels are more difficult to handle after electrophoresis, that IS, during fixing, drying, and autoradiography. The methods given in this chapter deal only with the “standard” size sequencing gels, but the principles are the same for larger gels, except that more gel mix will be needed, and different sizes of combs, spacers, and glass plates may be needed. Sequence gels are poured between two plates of glass, separated by two thin spacers, ensuring that a constant thickness of gel is maintained (changes in the thickness of the gel will alter the migration rate of the samples). The gel is also loaded and run when it is still in this mold, with the glass plates providing support for the fragile gel. A consequence of this is that one of the plates has a notch cut from it, several centimeters deep, and is almost the width of the plate. Thus plate will subsequently be referred to as the “notched” plate. This From Methods m Molecular B!ology, Vol. 23 DNA Sequennng Protocols Edited by H and A Grtfm Copyright 01993 Humana Press Inc , Totowa, NJ
115
116
Littlebury
enables contact between the gel and running buffer at the anode. Sample wells are also formed at this end by inserting a comb, made from material of the same thickness as the spacers, into the gel immediately after pouring. Both the combs and the spacers can be bought commercially, or they can be made using modeling card (PlastikardTM) that is cut according to requirements. A typical comb for a 20-cm wide gel would have 50 teeth (2 mm wide; 3 mm deep), to enable 12 clones to be loaded per gel. Instructions will be given in this chapter on pouring both linear and buffer gradient gels. Linear gels are the simplest to pour, but usually only 200-250 bases of sequence can be read per clone. Buffer gradient gels (I) increase the amount of sequence that can be read in comparison to a linear gel, but pouring one correctly takes a little practice. Buffer gradient gels work by slowing the migration rate of DNA molecules in the final 30% of the gel, thus reducing the spacing between adjacent bands, allowing more sequence to be read from one gel. This effect is achieved by increasing the ionic concentration of the gel mix in the final 30% of the gel’s length. Buffer gradient gels are, therefore, poured using two gel mixes of differing ionic concentration, the mix with the higher ionic concentration being poured first, followed by the mix with the lower ionic concentration. Care must be taken when pouring the gel to ensure that the gradient forms properly, in order to avoid distortion of the resultant sequence bands. 2. Materials 1. 10X TBE: 108 g trizma base, 55 g boric acid , 9.3 g EDTA (di-sodium salt). Make up to 1 L with deronized water. Drscard when a precipitate forms. 2. 40% Acrylamide (19: 1): 380 g acrylamrde, 20 g NJ!‘-methylene bisacrylamide. Make up to 1 L with deionized water, add 20 g Amberlrte MB 1 resin and stir gently for 10 min. Falter and store at 4°C (see Note 1). 3. 0.5X TBE Gel MIX: 75 mL 40% Acrylamrde (19:1), 25 mL 10X TBE, 230 g urea (ultrapure grade). Make up to 500 mL with deionized water. Filter and store at 4OC for up to 1 mo. 4. 5X TBE Gel MIX: 30 mL 40% Acrylamide (19:1), 100 mL 10X TBE, 92 g urea (ultrapure grade). Make up to 200 mL with deiomzed water. Filter and store at 4OC for up to 1 mo. 5. 25% Ammomum persulphate: 25% (w/v) m deionized water, and should only be kept for about 1 wk at 4°C.
Linear and Buffer-Gradient
Gels
117
6. TEMED: N,N,N’,N’-Tetramethyl-1,2-diaminoethane. 7. Dimethyl dichlorosilane solution: For silanizing glass plates. 8. Glass plates: 50 x 20 cm. 9. Spacers and combs: Spacers: 50 x 0.5 cm x 0.35 mm thick PlastikardTM. Combs: 5 x 15 cm x 0.35 mm PlastikardTM, 10. Waterproof tape: [The above items are available from most molecular biology suppliers.] 11. 4X “Bulldog” or “Foldback” clips.
3. Methods 3.1. Preparation of Sequencing
Plates
1. Wash one pair of plates in warm water, and then rinse them with distilled water. If the plates are cleaned after each use, there ~111be no need to use detergents on them. Allow the plates to air dry. 2. Working in a fume hood, silanize one surface of each plate (see Note 2). To do this, spread approx 2 mL of stlanizmg solutton over the selected surface using kimwipes, taking care to ensure that the enttre surface of the glass plate is covered. The plates are then left to dry in the fume hood for 5-10 min. 3. Wipe each plate with a small quantity of ethanol. Ensure that the plates are well polished, and free of dust that may otherwise encourage the formation of air bubbles when the gel is poured (see Note 3). 4. Lay one spacer along each of the long edges of one plate (usually the unnotched one). Lay the second plate directly onto the first plate so that the two silanized sides form the inner surfaces of the mold assembly. 5. Clamp the plates together on one side using Foldback clips, and seal along the other side and the bottom of the plates with gel sealmg tape. Transfer the clips to the sealed side, and then seal the remaining side. If desired, a second layer of tape could be used along the bottom and the corners of the plates to further reduce the risk of leaks.
3.2. Pouring
a Linear
Sequencing
Gel
1. Allow 50 mL of 0.5X TBE gel mix to warm to room temperature. 2. Add to this gel mix 100 pL of 25% ammonium persulphate and 100 pL of TEMED. Mix by swtrlmg. 3. Take the gel mix up into a 50-mL syringe (without a needle), and inject the mix between the plates, maintaining a steady flow. The rate of flow of gel mix into the mold can be controlled by altering the angle at which the plates are held.
118
Littlebury
4. Once the gel mold has been filled to the top, insert the comb just past the teeth. Clamp the edges of the plates at the top and bottom, to ensure that a uniform gel thickness is maintained. Leave the gel to polymerize for 30 min. 3.3. Pouring a Buffer Gradient Gel 1. Allow sufficient gel mix to warm to room temperature. For a 50-cm long buffer gradient gel: 50 mL 0.5X TBE gel mix, 10 mL 5X TBE gel mix, 2. Add 100 pL each of TEMED and 25% ammonium persulphate to the 0.5X TBE gel mix, and 20 pL of each to the 5X TBE gel mix (see Note 4). 3. Using a 25-mL Pasteur pipet, take up 7 mL of 0.5X TBE gel mix, followed by 7 mL of 5X TBE gel mtx (see Note 5). The two gel mixes should be mixed together at the interface by introducing a few air bubbles into the pipet. 4. Pour this mix into the mold either down one stde or down the center, 5. As soon as the ptpet IS empty, lower the mold to the hortzontal to stop the flow of gel mix. Take the remaining 0.5X TBE gel mix into a 50mL syringe, and fill the gel mould to the top, washing the gradient mtx to the bottom. Insert the comb, and clamp the plates, leavmg the gel to polymerize for 30 mm. 4. Notes 1. Acrylamide is a potent neurotoxm, the effects of which are cumulative Gloves and a mask should always be worn when weighing out solids, and when handling solutions containing acrylamtde, and gels should be poured in plasttc trays to contain sptllages and leaks. Polymerized acrylamide is considered to be nontoxic, although gloves should still be worn, as there may be residual unpolymerized acrylamtde present. 2. Many workers silamze only one of the glass plates, the theory being that the gel will stick to the nonsdanized plate. In practice, the gel seems to stick to either plate with equal frequency, and silanizmg both plates seems to aid the pouring of the gels. 3. Bubbles can be removed m one of two ways, should they occur. The gel assembly can be raised vertically and the glass lightly tapped to dislodge the bubble, which should then rise to the top of the gel. Alternatively, a piece of used X-Ray film cut to form a long strip can be used to push the bubble to the side, where it will not affect the running of the samples. 4. The rate at which the gel polymerizes can be altered by changing the amount of TEMED added to the gel mrx. It 1soften helpful, when first pourmg buffer gradient gels, if the amount of TEMED is reduced by
Linear and Buffer-Gradient
Gels
119
10-20 pL. This ~111gave the inexperienced worker a little more time to pour the gel, and remove any bubbles that may have occurred during pouring. 5. When using buffer gradient gels, it is possible to change the gradient simply by altering the relative ionic concentratton of the two mixes. For example, if more 5X TBE mix is added during step 3., the gradient would become steeper.
Reference 1. Biggin, M. D., Gibson,T J., and Hong, G. F. (1983) Buffer gradientgels and35S label asanaid to raprdDNA sequencedetermination Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci USA 80,3963-3965
&LWl?ER
17
Electrophoresis of Sequence Reaction
Samples
Alan l! Bankier
1. Introduction The underlying principle of both main DNA sequencing methods by Sanger (I) and Maxam and Gilbert (21, is the ability to fractionate and resolve long, single-stranded DNAmolecules that differ in length by only one nucleotide. Denaturing polyacrylamide gels have been reported to give interpretable separation of molecules up to 0.6 kb in length, on l-m long gels (3). More practical systems for extended readings employ shorter buffer gradient gels (see Chapter 16), multiple loadings, giving run lengths of around 3 and 6 h, and reduced acrylamide concentration down to as low as 3.5%. Even using these techniques, a more reasonable estimate of the limit to accurate sequence that can be obtained on a routine basis, is 450-500 nucleotides per template. The redundant nature of shotgun procedures, where gel running tends to be the rate limiting step, make it more efficient to accept a reading of up to 350 nucleotides from each single run on a buffer gradient gel or a wedge gel (4-6). Following electrophoresis, the gel is subjected to autoradiography, where the position of each band can be visualized by virtue of the radioactive nucleotide incorporated during polymerization. Samples visualized by chemiluminescence (see Chapter 29), currently use similar exposure to film for detection. Fluorescence-based autoFrom. Methods m Molecular Biology, Vol 23. DNA Sequencmg Protocols Edited by H and A Gnffm Copynght 01993 Humana Press Inc , Totowa, NJ
121
122
Bankier
mated procedures (see Chapters 34-37) use direct in-gel detection without the need for gel handling and autoradiography. Direct autoradiography of wet gels, covered with Saranwrap@, is possible with 32P-labeled sequence reactions, but a considerable improvement in resolution is observed when the gel is dried. Particles from radioactive emissions in the lower part of the gel radiate outward in all directions and the resulting exposure on the film, positioned on the upper surface of the gel, appears broad and diffuse. If the gel is dried before autoradiography, this radiant “spread” is dramatically reduced. When 35S label is used, drying is essential because of the lower energy of emission. Drying is most conveniently carried out on a heated, vacuum gel drier, and takes less than one hour. Having negotiated all of the pitfalls of subcloning, risked one’s health handling hazardous materials, fiddled with almost nonexistent volumes of reagents, and successfully manipulated a very fragile gel that often seems bent on self-destruction to produce an autoradiograph, perhaps the hardest part remains. Reading sequencing films accurately is a skilled process. Although some broad guidelines can be learned from a chapter like this, there is no substitute for practical experience gained from comparing deduced sequences with known sequences and reconciling any differences. Several film scanners are available, with software intended to interpret sequencing data, notably the Amersham Autoreader (Amersham, Arlington Heights, IL). The accuracy of these devices is continually improving, but they are totally dependant upon being “fed” good quality input. At the end of it all, it can be very difficult to accept that the film may be truly unreadable.
2. Materials 1. A gel electrophoresis apparatus. This need not be too complicated, since satisfactory results can be obtained using very cheap and simple systems. 2. A high voltage power supply capable of at least 2000 V (d.c. output). For a 20 x 50 cm x 0.3-mm thick gel, the running conditions are around 1500 V at 30 mA. 3. 10X TBE: 108 g Tris base, 55 g boric acid, 9.3 g NazEDTA dissolved and made up to 1 L in deionized water. 4 Formamide dye mix: 100 mL deionized formamide, 0.1 g xylene cyan01 FF, 0.1 g bromophenol blue, 2 mL 0.5M Na,EDTA. There seems to be little or no deterioration of results using dye mix that has been stored at ambient temperatures for several months, but it is recommended that
Polyacrylamide
Gel Electrophoresis
123
aliquots be stored frozen. Formamide is hazardous and may cause irritation to skm and eyes. 5. Narrow or flattened point, disposable pipet tips for gel loading. A small volume Hamilton syringe with a fine gage needle can also be used. Experrenced users frequently prefer to use drawn-out capillaries fitted to a mouth pipet, but this practice should be avoided on safety grounds. 6. Whatman 3MM paper, cut just larger than the size of the gel. 7. Saranwrap@ or equivalent, nonporous food wrap. 8. Slab gel drier, Savant SGD4050 or BioRad SE1 125B. 9. A high vacuum pump. Oil pumps require considerable maintenance and are quickly damaged by acetic acid if the gels are fixed before drying. Teflon diaphragm pumps are cheaper and are low maintenance (e.g., Vacuubrand GMBH). 10. Fuji RX or equivalent, X-ray film. Some films are considerably faster (and more expensive) but may not be suitable for automatic processors. 11. Light-tight film cassettesfor autoradiography. 12. Chemicals for film processing.
3. Methods The processdescribed in this chapter can be broadly categorized under three headings: gel running, autoradiography, and film reading. 3.1. Gel Running 1. Remove any sealing tape from the bottom of the polymerized gel, remove the well former from the top of the gel and wash the well(s) under runnmg deionized water (see Note 1). 2. If using a “shark’s tooth” comb, carefully insert it until the teeth just enter the gel surface evenly across the full width of the gel. 3. Assemble the gel in the electrophoresis apparatus with the well recess of the glass plate facing the upper buffer chamber and fill the upper and lower chambers with 1X TBE. 4. Thoroughly flush the top of the well with TBE, usmg a Pasteur pipet or syringe, to remove any unpolymerized acrylamide. It is not absolutely necessary to prerun the gel, but if desired, put the cover on the apparatus and connect it to a high voltage power supply and run it at around 30 V/cm for 30 mm (see Note 2). 5. If the sampleshave been stored at -20°C allow them to thaw and add 2 pL of formamide dye mix to each. Immediately before loading, denature the samples and place them on ice. Samplesprepared in tubes should be denatured for no longer than 3 mm in a boiling waterbath. If microtiter trays were used, place the trays, uncovered, in an incubator at 80°C for 20 mm.
124
Bankier
6. Isolate the gel running apparatus from the power supply and flush the wells at the top of the gel to remove the urea that will have diffused out of the gel. 7. Using a narrow polypropylene tip fitted to a small volume pipet, load around 2 p,L of sample into each well. The same tip can be used repeatedly by rinsing the tip once in the bottom buffer chamber. If difficulty is encountered with air pockets trapping some residual sample in the tip, it is easier to discard it into the radioactive waste and to use a clean tip (see Notes 3 and 4). 8. When all the samples are loaded, put the cover on the apparatus and connect it to a high voltage power supply. Electrophorese the gel at around 30 V/cm, until the bromophenol blue reaches or has migrated off the bottom of the gel (see Notes 5 and 6).
3.2. Gel Drying
and Autoradiography
1. When the run is complete, disconnect the electrophoresis unit from the power supply, discard the top buffer, and dispose of the radioactive bottom buffer m the recommended manner. Remove the gel/glass assembly from the unit and remove any remainmg sealing tape. 2. With the notched plate uppermost, pry the two glass plates apart by inserting a thin spatula between them and carefully twisting or levering it. Should the gel prefer to stick to the notched plate, simply remove the spatula, turn over the whole gel/glass assembly, and pry off the backplate. If the gel perststs in sticking equally to both plates, the whole assembly is best submerged in water or 10% acetic acid where the gel is free to float off the upper glass plate when pried open. The gel can be held in position during subsequent handlmg, using a piece of firm plastic netting (see Note 7). 3. Submerge the gel in around 1 L of 10% acetic acid m a seed tray for lo-15 min to dialyze out the urea. If the tray does not have a ridged base, gently agitate the solution periodically. Remove the gel, still on the glass plate, and dram off as much liquid as possible (see Note 8). 4. Transfer the gel to 3MM paper by placing a sheet smoothly and evenly on top of the gel by “rolling” the curved paper across from one end, or outward from the center. Gently ensure complete direct paper/gel contact over the whole gel and then peel the paper back and away from the glass. 5. Cover the gel with a layer of Saranwrap@ and cut off any excess 3MM paper or plastic wrap. Trim the top and sides of the gel to fit Into a slab gel drier and dry the gel for 15 mm under vacuum at 80°C. 6. Remove the plastic wrap from the dry gel and place it m a light-tight X-ray film cassette m direct contact with X-ray film. Exposure times will vary
Polyacrylamide
Gel Electrophoresis
125
dependingupon whtch label hasbeenused.If the entire samplehasbeen loaded and the label was 35S,exposuretimes between 18-36 h should be adequate.When using 32P,the ideal exposurecan be as short as 1 h (seeNote 9). 7. Processthe X-ray film according to the supplier’s recommendations. 3.3. Film Reading In principle, the interpretation of a single sequence from four tracks on an autoradiograph should be simple. Because the individual molecules are separatedaccording to size, all that is required is that the positions of successive bands from bottom to top are noted. If the next band IS in the A track, then the next base in the sequencemust be an A. Several different problems may disrupt this idealized situation. It may not be clear which band comes next, particularly if the bands in question are in the outer tracks. Two or more bands may appear to occupy the same vertical position, or spurious bands may even prevent an absolute assignment at a particular position. Some positions expected within an even “ladder” of bands may appear to be vacant. Superimposed upon this will be the effects of poor template quality, less than perfect sequence reactions, and gel running and autoradiography problems. Probably the most important lesson to learn when reading sequence films is when not to read. Most mistakes are made by trying to read sequencesof inferior quality or by reading too far up the gel into regions of poor resolution. Eventually sequence-reading mistakes will have to be reconciled with other, more accurate readings, and this can be very time consuming. Very often, some weeks or months later, when the film is read again, the first impression is one of disbelief that it could have been read at all. Guidelines on reading sequence films range from the general, to a description of the very specific artifacts expected from particular cloning or sequencing strategies. Because of the broad nature of the chapters in these volumes, only the more relevant points will be listed and then in a general way. Many of the artifacts can be attributed to specific reagents and can be verified using a control system. 3.3.1. General Tips on Reading Sequences
1. Since many of the anomalousmobility problems associatedwith gels are predominantly related to high G/C sequences,it makes sense to
126
Bankier
have these two tracks adjacent to each other. The most commonly used track orders are ACGT and TCGA. 2. Before starting, make a general assessment of the quality of the data and decide whether or not it is worth reading. This overall inspection would consider the sharpness of the bands, the presence of background smear, and whether extra bands are present. 3. Ensure an optimum exposure. Too short an exposure can conceal the presence of weak bands, particularly when Klenow is used. Too long an exposure will increasethe background smear and accentuateartifact bands. If 32Pis used, over-exposure wtll dramatically reduce resolution, 4. Mark out or mask the four lanes to avoid confusion with other tracks, and mark the end-point. This may be the point where the quality or resolution falls below the required standard, or where a short insert meets the vector. 5. Reading the spaces between bands can be as important as reading the bands themselves. It should always be considered whether or not there is “space” for the band m question. Where there is ambigutty regarding the exact order of bands, it can often be deduced from the comparative spacing of consecutive bands within a track m the immediate vicmity. One should have some idea of how many bands to expect in a particular gap. 6. If consistent difficulty is encountered in interpreting the correct register of bands, a sharkstooth comb may prove to be beneficial. When these are used, there is often a small overlap between adjacent tracks, making order interpretation simpler. 7. Do not stop reading in “mid-sequence.” Once started, read the entire sequence from bottom to top. It is quite common, after a break, to recommence reading from the wrong point, particularly when the sequence is of a repetitive nature. 8. Speckles and streaks on autoradiographs usually arise from particles or small bubbles in the gel and can generally be avoided. Ensure that the glass plates are scrupulously clean before pouring the gel, and avoid using tissues that drop particles to wipe down their surfaces. 9. Patches of fuzziness can be attributed to regions of the gel not being m direct, intimate contact with the film, or with differential polymerization of the gel matrix. These patches can also be caused by regions of overheating in the gel by running it too fast. 3.3.2. Common Problems and Artifacts in Sequences 1. A high background smear is generally specific to the template DNA. Further purification of the template, using phenol or chloroform extractions and ethanol precipitation, is not always successful.
Polyacrylamide
Gel Electrophoresis
127
2, Variations in band intensity are an intrinsic property of most enzymes, particularly Klenow. These are generally base sequence specific and occur in a predictable manner. Sequenase used m the presence of manganese produces a very even band intensity. 3. “Pile-ups,” where bands appear in the same position in all four tracks, result from nonspecific terminations, Typical causesare secondary structure within the template that the polymerase has difficulty passing through (different polymerases and different batches of the same polymerase can cope with this to varying degrees), and renaturation of a double stranded template causing a block to polymerization. This is quite common in sequencing PCR products. Both of these problems can often be reduced by destabilizing the structure, for example, by increasing the temperature of the extension reaction or reducing the salt concentration in the reaction. Failing this the polymerase has to be changed, since the most likely cause will then be poor quality enzyme. 4. Faint extra bands, or “shadow” bands, in other tracks can have one of several causes. If the shadow bands appear only in adjacent tracks, a sample may have spilled over between wells. Also random distribution of faint bands can indrcate a second background sequence. This may be caused by a contaminating plaque inadvertently picked off the agar plate, a lower abundance template resulting from a deletion during phage growth, or nonspecific priming. Finally, some faint artifact bands are polymerase-specific and appear at base sequence-dependent posttrons. 5. A generally clean, but very weak, sequence is caused by low template or primer concentratron, or by inefficient priming resulting from too high an annealing temperature. 6. Compressions, where band spacings are reduced or nonexistent at a specific point in a sequence, followed by a region of abnormally large spacing, result from secondary structure during gel electrophorests. 7. An uneven distribution of band intensity is indicative of an incorrect dideoxy:deoxy nucleotide ratio. A peak of intensity at a shorter length implies too high a dideoxy concentration, and a high intensity at longer lengths too low a dideoxy nucleotide concentration. When using a twostep labeling procedure, as recommended for Sequenase,a similar intensity problem is caused by variations in template concentration such as low template concentrations producing an increase m intensity of the longer molecules. 8. No signal at all m a single track is usually caused by accidentally missing the addition of a single ingredient. No signal in a set of four tracks, on the other hand, would indicate that the primer or buffer was omitted from the annealing, no template was recovered from the DNA prepara-
Bankier tion, the primer 1sInappropriate, or a deletton has occurred durmg growth of the recombinant that encompassed the priming site.
4. Notes 1. It is important to rinse the wells immediately after removing the slot former, as any unpolymerized acrylamide may subsequently polymerize and leave an uneven gel surface. Flushing the wells lust before loading removes any urea that may have dialyzed out of the gel, making it easier to load the samples as a tight band. 2. The presence of “smiling,” where samples toward the edge of the gel migrate slower than those in the center, is a consequence of variations of heat loss (and hence temperature) across the width of the gel. This can be mmimized m two sample ways: First, by not loading samples in the outermost 2 cm on each side of the gel, because this 1swhere the temperature difference is greatest, and second, by placing an alummmm sheet on the outer surface of the glass plate, because this evens out the temperature across the gel. More sophisticated and expensive methods of temperature control are available, but except for particular situations, such as in automated systems, it is unlikely they will be needed. 3. If possible, tt is better to load the sample around l-2 mm from the bottom of the well, giving a sharp sample band, rather than to let it trickle down from the top. 4. The extended denaturation period for mtcrotiter trays is intended to reduce the volume so that the entire sample can be loaded. The duration can be altered to adjust this volume, For example, fan assisted ovens will require a much shorter time. Only a fraction of samples denatured in tubes can be loaded since their volume is not reduced considerably. Do not attempt to overload the wells. As a guide, the sample height should be less than the well width, but ideally much less. 5. The conditions described in this method refer to running the gel at a constant voltage. In practice, though, it 1sbest to run denaturmg gels at constant power. This IS because the gel temperature is the most important factor to control. An internal gel temperature of 60-70°C should be attamed. For 20 x 50 cm x 0.3 mm thick gels a constant power of 35-40 watts is sufftcient. In caseswhere compresstons still exist this may need to be even higher to increase the gel temperature. 6. The precise time at which to stop electrophoresis will of course depend upon the length of the primer and the distancefrom the primer that sequence is to be read, as well as the concentration of acrylamtde in the gel. On 6% gels the Ml 3 cloning sitescorrespond approximately to the position of the bromophenol blue marker dye when the universal primer is used.
Polyacrylamide
Gel Electrophoresis
129
7. When opening the glass plates, do not lever against the “ears” of the notched plate. These tend to be fairly fragile and easily broken. 8. There is no need to fix gels before they are dried. Without fixing they will take 45-60 min to dry on a vacuum gel drier at 80°C. If no drying facilities are available, it is possible to air dry them overnight. 9. The introduction of thin gels and 35S label was designed to improve resolution. Using smgle-sided film can improve the resolution of autoradiographs even more, although care must be taken to ensure that the emulsion side faces the dried gel and the Saranwrap@ is removed.
References 1 Sanger, F , Nicklen, S , and Coulson, A R. (1977) DNA sequencmg wtth chamterminating mhrbitors. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA ,74,5463-5467. 2. Maxam, A. M. and Gilbert, W. (1977) A New Method for Sequencing DNA Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci USA 74,560-564.
3 Ansorge, W. and Barker, R. (1984) System for DNA sequencing with resolution of up to 600 base paus. J Biochem. Blophys. Meth. 9,33-47. 4. Bankier, A. T. and Barrel], B. G. (1983) Shotgun DNA sequencing, m Techniques in Life Sciences, Nucleic Acid Biochemistry vol. B5 (Flavell, R. A , ed.), Elsevier Screntific Publishers, Ireland, pp. l-34. 5 Biggin, M. D., Gibson, T. J., and Hong, G. F. (1983) Buffer gradient gels and 35S label as an aid to raptd DNA sequence determination Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 80,3963-3965.
6. Bankier, A. T and Barrell, B. G. (1989) Sequencing smgle-stranded DNA using the chain termmation method, m Nucleic Acids Sequencing: A Practical Approach (Howe, C J and Ward, E. S., eds.), IRL Press, Oxford, pp. 37-38.
Plasmid
Sequencing
Hugh G. Grij’j%t and Annette M. Griffin
1. Introduction The dideoxy chain-termination method of DNA sequence analysis involves the synthesis of a DNA strand from a single-stranded template (I). The enzymatic synthesis is initiated at the site where an oligonucleotide primer anneals to the template. The most consistently satisfactory sequencing results are probably obtained by using bacteriophage M 13 (2,3) or phagemid (4) single-stranded DNA as the template. However, plasmid DNA that has been denaturedcan also serve as satisfactory template DNA. It is particularly important when preparing plasmid DNA for sequencing to give the utmost care and attention to the DNA isolation and purification techniques. Most problems that occur with plasmid sequencing are related to poor quality template. CsCl-ethidium bromide gradient preparations of plasmid DNA (5) can be used as template for sequencing but do not necessarily provide better results than mini-prep DNA. Many plasmid mini-prep methods are available for preparing template for sequencing. Denaturation is usually achieved with the use of alkali or by boiling (in the presenceof primer). Several excellent methods are presentedelsewhere in this book. This chapter presents a mini-prep method that involves an alkaline lysis procedure (6) followed by DNA purification by GENECLEAN@ -a commercial kit for the purification of DNA. The From. Methods In Molecular &logy, Vol. 23 DNA Sequencing Protocols E&ted by H and A Griffin Copynght 01993 Humana Press Inc , Totowa, NJ
131
132
Griffin
and Griffin
GENECLEAN@ kit is based on the principle that DNA will bind to a silica matrix, whereas DNA contaminants will not bind and can be removed by repeated washing of the silica-DNA matrix (7). The DNA is then denatured by alkali and sequenced using Sequenase Version 2.0. Although few people would claim that sequencing of plasmid DNA consistently provides as good results as sequencing M 13 or phagemid templates, with careful attention to template preparation very satisfactory results can be achieved. Sequencing plasmid DNA has the advantage of eliminating the need to subclone fragments into M13, and also enables both strands to be sequenced from the same plasmid by the use of reverse primers.
2. Materials 1. GET buffer: 50 mM glucose, 10 mM EDTA, 25 n&f Tris-HCl pH 8 0. This solution should be autoclaved for 15 mm at 10 lb/m2 (68.9 kPa) and stored at 4°C. 2. Lysozyme buffer: 20 mg/mL lysozyme m GET buffer. Make up fresh. 3 5M NaOH. 4. 10% sodium dodecyl sulfate (sodium lauryl sulfate, SDS). 5.2 n-&f EDTA. 6. Alkaline SDS: 200 mM NaOH, 1% SDS. Make up fresh as follows: 200 pL 5M NaOH, 500 pL 10% SDS, 4.3 mL water. 7. 3M sodium acetate, pH 4.8. AdJust pH to 4.8 with glacial acetic acid. 8. Phenol-chloroform: This is prepared by mixing equal amounts of phenol and chloroform. If desired, the mixture can be equilibrated by extracting several times with 0.1M Tris-HCl, pH 7.6, although this is not essential 9. 100% ethanol. 10. 70% ethanol. 11. GENECLEAN@ kit. This is available from BIO 101 Inc., PO Box 2284, La Jolla, CA, 92038-2284, or from Stratech Scientific, 61-63 Dudley Street, Luton, Bedfordshire, LU2 ONP, England.
3. Methods 3.1. DNA Preparation 1. Harvest the cells from 5 mL of over-night broth culture by centrifugation (see Note 1). 2. Resuspend the pellet m 100 J.JLof lysozyme buffer and transfer to a 1.5-mL microcentrifuge tube, then incubate on ice for 30 min (see Notes 2 and 3) 3. Add 200 pL of alkaline SDS. Vortex, then incubate on ice for 5 mm.
Plasmid
Sequencing
133
4. Add 150 pL of 3M sodium acetate, pH 4.8. Vortex, then incubate on ice for 20 min. 5. Centrifuge at 12,000g in a microcentrifuge for 10 mm and transfer 0.4 mL of supernatant to a new tube. 6. Extract twrce with an equal vol of phenol-chloroform.
3.2. DNA Purification
(Using GENECLEAN@
Kit)
1. Add three vols of NaI stock solution from the GENECLEAN@ kit (see Notes 7 and 8) to the phenol-chloroform extracted mini-prep. Use a 2-mL microcentrifuge tube if necessary. 2. Add 5 pL of glassmilk suspension (supplied with the kit). Mix, and incubate for 5 min at room temperature. 3. Centrtfuge for 5 s in a microcentrifuge. 4. Remove the supernatant and wash the pellet three times with NEW wash (supplied with the kit). 5. Carefully remove the last traces of NEW wash from the pellet. 6. Elute the DNA in 100 pL of water.
3.3. Alkali
Denaturation
1. To 86 pL of the purified DNA, add 4 cls, 5M NaOH and 10 pL 2 mM EDTA, then incubate at 37OC for 30 min (see Note 9). 2. Neutralize by adding 10 pL of 3M sodium acetate, pH 4.8. 3. Precipitate with two vols of 100% ethanol at -70°C for 15 min. 4. Centrifuge for 2 mm m a microcentrifuge to pellet precipitated DNA. 5. Wash pellet with 70% ethanol. 6. Dry under vacuum and redissolve pellet in 7 pL water.
3.4. Primer-Template
Annealing
Reaction
1. In a small microcentrifuge tube, set up the following reaction: 1 pL primer (0.5 pmol/pL), 2 pL Sequenase buffer (5X) (see Chapter 14), 7 pL denatured plasmid DNA. 2. Place in a 65°C waterbath for 2 mm. Allow to cool slowly to 30°C over a period of about 30 min. Place on ice (see Note 10).
3.5. Sequencing These are performed
Reactions
as described in Chapter 14.
4. Notes 1. It is important to remove all the broth supernatant from the cell pellet following centrifugation of the bacterial culture. 2. It is important to ensure that the bacterial pellet is fully resuspended in lysozyme buffer. This can be achieved by vigorous vortexmg.
Griffin
and Griffin
3. Some authors point out that lysozyme 1sunnecessary for alkaline lys~s based mini-preps (5). We have found that although lysozyme is not essential, better lysis IS achieved by its use. 4. An RNase step is not necessary m this protocol. 5. A small excess of template DNA may be helpful when sequencing plasmid DNA. Aim to use about 5 pg. 6. This protocol is designed for use with the htgh copy-number pUC series of plasmids (8) and their derivatives. If lower copy-number plasmids are to be used (such as pBR322 and derivatives) it may be necessary to scale-up the procedure to achieve the same yield of plasmid DNA. 7. Mini-prep plasmid DNA is often contaminated by small oligodeoxynbonucleotides and ribonucleotides that can act as primers and produce faint background bands, stops, and other artifacts in the gel. Inhibitors of DNA polymerase may also be present. In our experience purification of the DNA prep by the GENECLEAN procedure, combined with the use of Sequenase Version 2.0 for sequencing, alleviates these problems. 8. Other commercial kits such as US Bioclean (available from United States Biochemical Corporation, PO Box 22400, Cleveland, OH, 44122, or from Cambridge Bioscience, 25 Signet Court, Stoursbridge Common Business Centre, Swann’s Road, Cambridge, CB5 8LA, England) or noncommercial procedures and protocols based on similar principles as GENECLEAN (7) may also work satisfactorily. 9. Double-stranded supercoiled DNA is best denatured by the alkaline denaturation method. Linear DNA can be successfully denaturated by boiling (in the presence of primer). 10. Annealing can also be achieved by warming the annealing reaction mrx to 37°C for 15-30 min. 11. The use of longer primers (25-29 nucleotides) may help reduce artifactual bands when sequencing denatured double-stranded DNA. 12. SequenaseVersion 2.0 works well for double-stranded DNA sequencing.
References 1, Sanger, F , Nlcklen, S., and Coulson, A. R. (1977) DNA sequencing with chamtermmating inhibitors. Proc Nat1 Acad. Sci. USA 74,5463-5467. 2 Messing, J , Gronenborn, B , Muller-Hill, B , and Hofschnelder, P H (1977) Fllamentous coliphage Ml3 as a cloning vehicle: Insertion of a Hind111 fragment of the lac regulatory region in Ml3 replicative form in vitro Proc Nat1 Acad SCL USA 74,3642-3646
3 Messing, J. (1983) New Ml3 vectors for cloning. Meth. Enzymol. 101,20-78 4 Zagursky, R J. and Berman, M. L. (1984) Clonmg vectors that yield high levels of single-stranded DNA for rapld DNA sequencing. Gene 27, 183-19 1. 5 Sambrook, J., Fritsch, E. F , and Maniatls, T (1989) Molecular Cloning-A
Plasmid
Sequencing
135
Laboratory Manual. Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press, Cold Spring Harbor, New York. 6 Birnboim, H. C. and Doly, J (1979) A rapid alkaline extraction procedure for screening recombinant plasmid DNA. Nucleic Acids Res. 7, 15 13-l 523 7. Vogelstein, B. and Gillespie, D. (1979). Preparation and analytical purrfrcatron of DNA from agarose Proc Natl. Acad Sci USA 76,615-619. 8 Vieira, J. and Messing, J. (1982) The pUC plasmrds, an Ml3 mp7-derived system for insertion mutagenesis and sequencing with synthetic universal primers. Gene 19,259-2&I.
Plasmid
Sequencing
George Murphy
1. Introduction In double-stranded DNA sequencing the two DNA strands must first be separatedto enable the primer to bind to the priming site. This may be done by treating the DNA with alkali. Conventionally, use of the alkali denaturation method involves neutralization of the sample by acid treatment followed by ethanol precipitation and recovery of the DNA by centrifugation. The time-consuming processof ethanol precipitation may be avoided by neutralizing the alkali-treated DNA and recovering the sample in its original volume by passagethrough a spin-dialysis column. The use of spin-dialysis confers the additional advantage of cleaning-up the template by removing traces of low molecular weight compounds that may interfere with the sequencing reactions. The method used here to prepare plasmid is a variation on the boiled-lysis method (I) using a rapid approach avoiding phenol extraction. 2. Materials 2.1. Plasmid Preparation 1. LB: 1% (w/v) bacto tryptone, 0.5% (w/v) bacto yeast extract, and 1% (w/v) NaCI.
2. Suspensionbuffer 50 n&I Tris-HCl, pH 8.0,25% (w/v) sucrose. 3. MSTET: 50 m&I Tris-HCl, pH 8.0, 50 mZt4EDTA, 5% (v/v) Tnton-X100, and 5% (w/v) sucrose. From Methods In Molecular Biology, Vol 23. DNA Sequencmg Protocols Edited by* H and A Gnffln CopyrIght 01993 Humana Press Inc , Totowa,
137
NJ
138
Murphy
4. Lysozyme solution: 40 mg/mL in 50 mM Tris-HCl, pH 8.0, 50% glycerol (v/v). 5. TE: 10 mM Tris-HCI, pH 8, 1 mM EDTA. 6. Sodium acetate: 3M sodium acetate, pH 5.0. 7. Isopropanol. 8. Ammonium acetate: 7.5M ammonium acetate. 9. 96% (v/v) ethanol. 2.2. Denaturation 1. RNase A: Dissolve 10 mg pancreatic RNase A in 10 mM Tris-HCl, pH 8.0, 15 r&4 sodium chloride. Boil for 15 min and cool slowly. Dispense into 50-pL aliquots and store at -20°C. Dispose of any used solution once thawed. 2. Sodium hydroxide: 1M sodium hydroxide, 1 mM EDTA. 3. TO.lE: 10 mM Tris-HCl, pH 8.0,O.l r&4 EDTA. 4. Sepharose: equilibrate Sepharose-CL-6B (Pharmacia, Piscataway, NJ) m TO.lE and adjust to a packed gel:supematant ratio of 2: 1. Store at 4 “C. 5. Glass beads: 200 p diameter (Sigma, St Louis), washed in deiomzed water and autoclaved. 2.3. Annealing 1. 5X Buffer: 200 ti Tris-HCI, pH 7.5, 100 mM MgC& and 250 mM NaCl. 2. Primer: 10 pg/rnL in deionized water. 3. Methods 3.1. Plasmid Preparation 1. Using a toothpick, place a bacterial colony into 10 mL LB m a flatbottomed screw-top bottle and grow for 15-18 h at 37”C, shaking at 200-250 rpm and using antibiotic selection if required. 2. Centrifuge the cells at 1500g for 10 min. Decant the supernatant and leave the inverted bottle to dram for 5 min on absorbent paper. 3. Resuspend the cells by vortexing vigorously in 100 pL suspension buffer, then transfer the suspension to a 1.5-mL microcentrifuge tube. 4. Add 600 pL MSTET solution then spot 14 pL of lysozyme solution onto the inside of the tube. 5. Cap the tubes, mix the contents thoroughly by shakmg, and transfer immediately to a boiling waterbath for 1 mm. 6. Place the tubes on ice for 1 mm, then centrifuge at 10,OOOgfor 30 mm at 4OC. 7. Remove the gelatmous pellet with a toothpick. Alternatively, to reduce contammation with chromosomal DNA, use a mrcropipet to transfer the supernatant to a fresh tube.
Plasmid
Sequencing
Method
1
139
8. Add 60 pL sodium acetate and 600 pL isopropanol and leave for 5 min before centrifuging at 10,OOOg for 10min. Aspirate off the supematant,recentrifuge for 5 s, and remove all traces of liquid. Resuspend m 200 pL TE. 9. Add 100 pL ammonium acetate. Leave on ice for at least 30 min then centrifuge for 15 min. 10. Remove the supernatant to a fresh tube and add 750 pL ethanol. Leave at -20°C for 30 min then centrifuge as above. Rinse with 80% ethanol, air dry, and dissolve in 50 pL TE (see Note 1).
3.2. Denaturation 1. Mix 18 pL of a plasmid miniprep with 2 pL of RNase A and incubate for 15 min at 37°C. Add 5 pL sodium hydroxide and incubate a further 15 min at 37OC.If using cesium gradient purified DNA, use 15 pg in 20 pL TE without RNase treatment. 2. Pierce the base of a 0.5-mL centrtfuge tube from the inside with a 21-G needle so that about 2/3 of the needle bevel emerges. Place the tube inside a 1S-mL centrifuge tube completely pierced through the bottom with the same needle. 3. Add 25 pL of a slurry of glass beads in water to the bottom of the 0.5 mL tube, followed by 300 pL of the Sepharose slurry, taking care not to disturb the glass beads (see Notes 2 and 3). 4. Place the assembly onto a suitable receiver tube of at least 5 mL vol and centrifuge in a swing-out rotor at 200g for 4 min. Transfer the 0.5-mL tube to an intact 1.5-mL test-tube and use as quickly as possible to prevent drying of the gel matrix (see Note 4). 5. Add the denatured sample to the top of the gel of the spin-dialysis tube, being careful not to disturb the gel layer. Centrifuge at 200g for 4 min and use the dialysate immediately.
3.3. Annealing 1. If sequencing with 35S-dATP, 8 pL of the prepared template is added to 2 pL buffer and 1 pL of primer. For sequencing with 32P-dATP use only 5 pL of template and make the final volume up to 11 pL with water (see Notes 5-7). 2. Incubate at 37°C for 15 min and centrifuge the tubes briefly to spin down any condensation (see Note 8). 3. Dispense 2.4 pL to each of four tubes and continue as in Chapter 13, using T7 DNA polymerase as the sequencing enzyme (see Note 9).
4. Notes 1. The rapid plasmid preparation used here provides template of good sequencing quality. DNA produced by other methods such as alkaline
Murphy lysis may also be used, but the boiled-lysis methods appear to produce templates that generate fewer artifacts upon sequencing. Cesium gradient purified DNA provides a useful control against which other techmques can beJudged, as the DNA is far less contammated than mmiprep DNA. However, some background is often ob