DEVELOPMENTAL ORIGINS OF AGGRESSION
DEVELOPMENTAL ORIGINS OF AGGRESSION
Edited by RICHARD E. TREMBLAY WILLARD W. HART...
36 downloads
3427 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
DEVELOPMENTAL ORIGINS OF AGGRESSION
DEVELOPMENTAL ORIGINS OF AGGRESSION
Edited by RICHARD E. TREMBLAY WILLARD W. HARTUP JOHN ARCHER
THE GUILFORD PRESS New York London
© 2005 The Guilford Press A Division of Guilford Publications, Inc. 72 Spring Street, New York, NY 10012 www.guilford.com All rights reserved No part of this book may be reproduced, translated, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, microfilming, recording, or otherwise, without written permission from the Publisher. Printed in the United States of America This book is printed on acid-free paper. Last digit is print number: 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Developmental origins of aggression / edited by Richard E. Tremblay, Willard W. Hartup, John Archer. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 1-59385-110-3 (hardcover : alk. paper) 1. Aggressiveness. 2. Aggressiveness—Longitudinal studies. 3. Child psychology. I. Tremblay, Richard Ernest. II. Hartup, Willard W. III. Archer, John, 1944– BF575.A3D45 2005 155.2′32—dc22 2004025158
In memory of Joan McCord (1930–2004), colleague, role model, and friend
(left to right): Richard E. Tremblay, Joan McCord, Willard W. Hartup, and John Archer.
About the Editors
About the Editors
Richard E. Tremblay, PhD, is Professor of Pediatrics, Psychiatry, and Psychology at the University of Montreal and Director of the Inter-University Research Unit on Children’s Psychosocial Maladjustment. He is also Director of the Centre of Excellence for Early Childhood Development, Canada Research Chair in Child Development, Molson Fellow of the Canadian Institute for Advanced Research, Fellow of the Academy of Experimental Criminology, and Fellow of the Royal Society of Canada. For over 20 years, he has conducted a program of longitudinal and experimental studies addressing the physical, cognitive, emotional, and social development of children from conception onward to understand the development and prevention of antisocial behavior. Willard W. Hartup, EdD, is Regents’ Professor Emeritus and former Director of the Institute of Child Development at the University of Minnesota. Dr. Hartup has spent many years researching friendship and peer relations in child development, antipathies and their significance, and conflict and aggression in childhood and adolescence. He obtained an EdD degree from Harvard University, and has received the G. Stanley Hall Award for Distinguished Contributions to Developmental Psychology from the American Psychological Association and Distinguished Scientific Contribution Awards from both the Society for Research in Child Development and the International Society for the Study of Behavioural Development. John Archer, PhD, is Professor of Psychology at the University of Central Lancashire, Preston, United Kingdom. He received a PhD from the University of Bristol in 1970. A Fellow of the British Psychological Society and President of the International Society for Research on Aggression, his research is concerned with human aggression, grief and loss, and sex differences. Dr. Archer is also author of several books, including Sex and Gender (with Barbara Lloyd) and The Nature of Grief; numerous book chapters; and over 100 articles in refereed journals covering psychology, medicine, and biology. In recent years, he has published a number of meta-analytic reviews on topics connected with sex differences in aggression. vii
Contributors
Contributors
John Archer, PhD, Department of Psychology, University of Central Lancashire, Preston, United Kingdom Chawki Benkelfat, MD, Department of Psychiatry, McGill University, Montreal, Quebec, Canada Michel Boivin, PhD, Research Unit on Children’s Psychosocial Maladjustment, School of Psychology, Laval University, Quebec City, Quebec, Canada Mara Brendgen, PhD, Department of Psychology, University of Quebec at Montreal, Montreal, Quebec, Canada Sylvana Côté, PhD, School of Psychoeducation, University of Montreal, Montreal, Quebec, Canada Ginette Dionne, PhD, School of Psychology, Laval University, Quebec City, Quebec, Canada Joseph L. Flanders, BSc, Department of Psychology, McGill University, Montreal, Quebec, Canada Afra Foroud, MSc, Canadian Centre for Behavioural Neuroscience, Department of Psychology and Neuroscience, University of Lethbridge, Lethbridge, Alberta, Canada Uberto Gatti, MD, Section of Criminology and Forensic Psychiatry, University of Genoa, Genoa, Italy Paul L. Gendreau, PhD, School of Psychoeducation, University of Montreal, Montreal, Quebec, Canada Willard W. Hartup, EdD, Institute of Child Development, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota Dale F. Hay, PhD, School of Psychology, Cardiff University, Cardiff, Wales, United Kingdom ix
x
Contributors
D. Lynn Homish, BSc, Western Psychiatric Institute and Clinic, University of Pittsburgh Medical Center, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania David Joubert, MA, MCA, Department of Psychology, University of Quebec at Montreal, Montreal, Quebec, Canada Eric Lacourse, PhD, Department of Sociology, University of Montreal, Montreal, Quebec, Canada Rolf Loeber, PhD, Western Psychiatric Institute and Clinic, University of Pittsburgh Medical Center, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania Tania Mazzarello, BSc, Department of Psychology, University of Quebec at Montreal, Montreal, Quebec, Canada Daniel S. Nagin, PhD, H. J. Heinz III School of Public Policy and Management, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania Tomáë Paus, MD, PhD, Departments of Neurology and Neurosurgery, and Psychology, McGill University, Montreal, Quebec, Canada Sergio M. Pellis, PhD, Canadian Centre for Behavioural Neuroscience, Department of Psychology and Neuroscience, University of Lethbridge, Lethbridge, Alberta, Canada Vivien C. Pellis, PhD, Canadian Centre for Behavioural Neuroscience, Department of Psychology and Neuroscience, University of Lethbridge, Lethbridge, Alberta, Canada Daniel Pérusse, PhD, Department of Anthropology, University of Montreal, Montreal, Quebec, Canada Jordan B. Peterson, PhD, Department of Psychology, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada Robert O. Pihl, PhD, Departments of Psychology and Psychiatry, McGill University, Montreal, Quebec, Canada François Poulin, PhD, Department of Psychology, University of Quebec at Montreal, Montreal, Quebec, Canada Elisa Romano, PhD, Department of Psychology, University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada Jean Richard Séguin, PhD, Research Unit on Children’s Psychosocial Maladjustment, Department of Psychiatry, University of Montreal, Montreal, Quebec, Canada Stephen J. Suomi, PhD, Laboratory of Comparative Ethology, National Institute of Child Health and Human Development, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, Maryland Richard E. Tremblay, PhD, Departments of Pediatrics, Psychiatry, and Psychology, University of Montreal, Montreal, Quebec, Canada
Contributors
Tracy Vaillancourt, PhD, Department of Psychology, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada Stephanie H. M. Van Goozen, PhD, School of Psychology, Cardiff University, Cardiff, Wales, United Kingdom Frank Vitaro, PhD, Research Unit on Children’s Psychosocial Maladjustment, School of Psychoeducation, University of Montreal, Montreal, Quebec, Canada Philip David Zelazo, PhD, Department of Psychology, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada Mark Zoccolillo, MD, Department of Psychiatry, Montreal Children’s Hospital, Montreal, Quebec, Canada
xi
Preface
Preface
It has been over 30 years since the publication of a book giving a detailed overview of the state of knowledge on the developmental origins of aggressive behavior (de Wit & Hartup, 1974). Much has changed during this time. Most of the developmental work published in the 1974 book was based on crosssectional studies of small samples of school-age children. The focus of attention was on aggressive events and the situations that instigate them. Over the past 30 years, investigators have conducted longitudinal studies of large samples of children assessed repeatedly from birth to adulthood. Results from these studies are telling unexpected stories. For example, children appear not to be learning to use physical aggression as they grow older; rather they appear to be learning not to use physical aggression. As expected, girls use physical aggression less often than boys from infancy to adolescence; however, they use another form of aggression (indirect aggression) more often than boys from early childhood to adulthood. Such findings are clearly of interest for our general understanding of human nature. Philosophers have argued for centuries on the origins of antisocial behavior. Rousseau defended the thesis that humans are created good and become evil through the influence of society, and Hobbes argued that a wicked person was simply a child who had not grown up. In 1973, Albert Bandura wrote, “People are not born with preformed repertoires of aggressive behavior; they must learn them in one way or another” (p. 61). The findings from research on the development of aggressive behavior are also extremely important for the prevention and treatment of violent behavior. Violence is still a serious problem in our modern societies. To help children learn alternatives to violent behavior, we need to understand the development of aggression and its alternatives. Every professional who works with children and adolescents needs to understand the developmental origins of aggression. Technological progress over the past 30 years has enabled investigators to combine longitudinal studies of large samples of children over their lifespans with molecular assessments of their genetic material and assessments of xiii
xiv
Preface
hormones and neuromodulators through blood and saliva samples and brain imaging. More sophisticated statistical techniques provide researchers with tools to make better use of twin samples and repeated measurements over long periods of time. This volume provides a timely overview of the best research and the key questions at the beginning of a new era, which will lead to a synthesis of genetic, brain, behavior, and environmental research.
REFERENCES Bandura, A. (1973). Aggression: A social learning analysis. New York: Holt. de Wit, J., & Hartup, W. W. (Eds.). (1974). Determinants and origins of aggressive behavior. The Hague: Mouton.
Contents
Contents
I. INTRODUCTION 1
The Development of Aggression: Where Do We Stand?
3
Willard W. Hartup
II. THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION IN ANIMALS AND HUMANS 2
Subtypes of Aggression in Humans and Animals
25
Paul L. Gendreau and John Archer
3
Play Fighting: Aggression, Affiliation, and the Development of Nuanced Social Skills
47
Sergio M. Pellis, Vivien C. Pellis, and Afra Foroud
4
Genetic and Environmental Factors Influencing the Expression of Impulsive Aggression and Serotonergic Functioning in Rhesus Monkeys
63
Stephen J. Suomi
5
The Developmental Origins of Physical Aggression in Humans
83
Richard E. Tremblay and Daniel S. Nagin
6
The Beginnings of Aggression in Infancy
107
Dale F. Hay
7
Play and the Regulation of Aggression
133
Jordan B. Peterson and Joseph L. Flanders
8
Indirect Aggression among Humans: Social Construct or Evolutionary Adaptation?
158
Tracy Vaillancourt
9
Proactive and Reactive Aggression: A Developmental Perspective
178
Frank Vitaro and Mara Brendgen
10
Homicide, Violence, and Developmental Trajectories Rolf Loeber, Eric Lacourse, and D. Lynn Homish
xv
202
xvi
Contents
III. DETERMINANTS OF AGGRESSION 11
Genetics and the Development of Aggression
223
Daniel Pérusse and Paul L. Gendreau
12
Mapping Brain Development and Aggression
242
Tomáë Paus
13
Neuromodulators in the Development and Expression of Inhibition and Aggression
261
Robert O. Pihl and Chawki Benkelfat
14
Hormones and the Developmental Origins of Aggression
281
Stephanie H. M. Van Goozen
15
Executive Function in Early Physical Aggression
307
Jean Richard Séguin and Philip David Zelazo
16
Language Development and Aggressive Behavior
330
Ginette Dionne
17
The Intergenerational Transmission of Aggression and Antisocial Behavior
353
Mark Zoccolillo, Elisa Romano, David Joubert, Tania Mazzarello, Sylvana Côté, Michel Boivin, Daniel Pérusse, and Richard E. Tremblay
18
Peer Relationships and the Development of Aggressive Behavior in Early Childhood
376
Michel Boivin, Frank Vitaro, and François Poulin
19
Social Capital and Physical Violence
398
Uberto Gatti and Richard E. Tremblay
20
Sex Differences in Aggressive Behavior: A Developmental and Evolutionary Perspective
425
John Archer and Sylvana Côté
IV. CHALLENGES FOR THE FUTURE 21
The Developmental Origins of Aggression: Where Are We Going?
447
Richard E. Tremblay and Sylvana Côté
Index
465
Part I INTRODUCTION
The Development of Aggression INTRODUCTION
1 The Development of Aggression Where Do We Stand? W ILLARD W. H ARTUP
Three changes have occurred in research on the development of aggression. First, both theoretical and empirical attention have shifted from the aggressive act, on one hand, to the development of aggressive individuals, on the other; that is, from aggressive events and the situations that instigate them to aggressive children assessed within ecological systems. Investigators no longer examine the effects of exposure to aggressive models (Bandura & Walters, 1963), for example, but rather the developmental consequences of reciprocities in social interaction involving individuals, bilateral and transactional processes in family and peer interaction, gene–environment permutations, and contextual components (including exposure to aggression and violence in the community). A second change is the emerging synthesis between research on aggression and research on antisocial behavior (Tremblay, 2000). Everyone knows that aggression and antisocial behavior are overlapping but not identical constructs. Nevertheless, because aggressive behavior is relatively stable as an individual characteristic, and because stable aggression predicts antisocial behavior during adolescence and adulthood for males at least (Moffitt, Caspi, Rutter, & Silva, 2001), it no longer seems wise to separate these terms in thinking about social development and adaptation. Third, a trend toward more developmentally oriented studies of aggression has emerged. What was known about aggression in childhood and adolescence in the late 1960s was quite nondevelopmental: The relevant work dealt with contingencies in observation or social interaction that increased aggression in the child, usually in constrained situations and with little attention to age differences. Normative studies encompassed only a few years (in early 3
4
INTRODUCTION
childhood), and the events associated with individual differences in the real world were not much remarked on (see Feshbach, 1970). To be concerned with development, however, is to be concerned with continuities and discontinuities in harm-doing activity across the lifespan, especially during the years before maturity, along with changes across time in the morphology and functioning of aggressive behavior, the reorganization of various mental structures as these involve aggression, and the role of violence in the development of attitudes toward oneself and others (Hartup & DeWit, 1974). By the 1980s, new ideas were percolating through the entire field of social and emotional development even though long-term longitudinal data were scarce. Studies linking aggression in early childhood with aggression in adolescence and adulthood were extremely rare; even cross-sectional studies were not abundant. But the zeitgeist was shifting. Ross Parke and Ronald Slaby (1983) knew it, and called their chapter for the Handbook of Child Psychology, “The Development of Aggression.” Ahead of its time, this chapter led the way to fundamental changes in research and research strategy highlighting developmental processes in the emergence of aggression and antisocial behavior. Nowadays, the major studies of aggression and antisocial behavior are definitely developmental, and most use longitudinal data to search for determinants, dynamics, and outcomes of these behaviors. Against the background of these comments, several issues are now discussed in terms of how things have changed and what we might expect in the near future in understanding the development of aggression: First, what changes? Three issues are considered: (1) construct selection, (2) normative change versus individual differences, and (3) child development versus lifespan perspectives. Second, what are the determinants of developmental change in aggression and antisocial behavior? Again, three issues are addressed: (1) nativism versus empiricism, (2) socialization and relationships, and (3) the ecological context.
WHAT CHANGES? Aggression, like most human activity, changes with age both in its incidence and in the processes leading to its instigation. But which changes are meaningful? Not every change in language and cognitive activity at every level of analysis is meaningful, nor is every change in aggression and antisocial behavior. Our first task, then, is to identify those changeworthy behaviors that have some significance in behavioral adaptation across time.
Construct Selection One must proceed cautiously through the thicket of constructs available in the current aggression literature. Merely specifying a workable construct that can
The Development of Aggression
5
be called “aggression” is difficult. Saying that aggression is “intentional harm doing” or “harm doing for its own sake” may be reasonable for the ordinary user of the English language, but it is fraught with difficulties for scientists who want to describe relevant phenomena with precision: Intentions cannot be observed easily; instigating conditions are difficult to separate from the structure of the aggressive act; outcomes are difficult to specify; and we can’t always tell whether the act has been aversive to the victim (Bandura, 1973; Hartup & De Wit, 1974; Coie & Dodge, 1998; Tremblay, 2000). Moreover, similar measures across age (if not equivalent ones) must be used in many forms of developmental analysis (e.g., specifying developmental trajectories and pathways), and one cannot always count on this equivalence. Researchers have made much progress by becoming more global in defining aggression and antisocial behavior, that is, by making increasingly greater use of global constructs drawn from natural language. Many investigators rely on ordinary observers (parents, teachers, and children) to tell them when aggression occurs and what some of its implications are. For example, elementary school children are asked to tell us which classmates “start fights.” When they answer, the reliability and validity of these nominations turn out to be substantial even though we do not know the circumstances under which the target child may start fights, the behaviors used in fighting, the consequences to the child’s companions, or the goals achieved by the target child. At certain times, however, these “down and dirty” measurement strategies will not work, that is, for determining whether babies “start fights” or whether 3-year-old and 13-year-old aggression reflect the same functional dynamics. Particulars about instigation, motor patterns, and consequences (functions) are needed in those instances even if it is difficult to obtain them. One endeavor needs to be encouraged strongly: construct selection at intermediate levels of conceptual complexity. First, certain older constructs need to be maintained. Consider that physical and verbal aggression have been distinguished from one another for many years (Goodenough, 1931), and several examples will show that this distinction remains useful: 1. Neither physical aggression nor most forms of antisocial behavior occur as frequently among females as among males, and gender differences in aggression cannot be understood without taking this into consideration. 2. Physical aggression among females during childhood does not predict adolescent antisocial behavior as it does for males (Broidy et al., 2003), and we do not completely understand this. Other midlevel constructs must be preserved, for example, violent versus nonviolent aggression, instrumental versus hostile aggression, and proactive versus reactive aggression. Bullying and victimization are also uniquely useful constructs. It may be time to resurrect other old constructs such as prosocial versus antisocial aggression; this one has languished since Robert Sears and
6
INTRODUCTION
his colleagues could not find differential correlates in the doll play of kindergarten children more than 40 years ago (Maccoby, 1992). But we must put this old wine in new bottles. New midlevel constructs are badly needed. Relational (or indirect) aggression has evoked considerable interest in the last decade (Crick et al., 1998; Vaillancourt, Chapter 8, this volume) Research shows that relational aggression is more frequent among females than among males, although its sequelae are not remarkably different (Crick et al., 1998; Vaillancourt, Chapter 8, this volume). It is not really surprising that harm doing may occur in normatively different ways in males and females; it is only surprising that it took us so long to realize this. Natural language may or may not furnish us with the complete conceptual armamentarium needed for research on aggression and antisocial behavior. As a consequence, the research community needs to look beyond the dictionary for constructs that will invigorate their work.
Normative Change or Individual Differences? Once upon a time, the following item appeared regularly on the exams for my graduate course: “Discuss the similarities and differences between the study of normative issues in developmental psychology and individual differences: Demonstrate how each of these issues informs the other about developmental process.” Historically, developmental psychology has been much concerned with both issues, with students of cognitive development emphasizing normative continuities and change rather than the emergence of individual differences (except for investigators interested in the IQ); students of social and personality development, however, have been interested mainly in individual differences. Normative change, of course, refers to age-related changes that are universal or characteristic of major population groups rather than developmental variations within or between groups. Aggression researchers, especially earlier ones, were interested in normative questions ranging from the ontogeny of anger regulation (Goodenough, 1931), to delinquency (Glueck & Glueck, 1950), to verbal mediation in the child’s response to aggressive modeling (Coates & Hartup, 1969). Contemporary researchers remain interested in normative assessment of aggression, as revealed in Figure 1.1 which shows data on hitting, biting, and kicking in a Canadian sample (Tremblay et al., 1996). These behaviors peak at about 27 months for both boys and girls, with slightly more boys than girls showing them “sometimes” or “frequently.” Frequencies decline steadily thereafter and are not often evident (but not completely absent) by age 12. These data represent one of the most comprehensive normative reports on physical aggression existing anywhere. Normative studies, however, are increasingly difficult to distinguish from differential studies of aggression. Normative and differential research on ag-
The Development of Aggression
7
FIGURE 1.1. Hitting, biting, and kicking (boys and girls ages 2–11 years). From Tremblay et al. (1996). Statistics Canada information is used with the permission of the Minister of Industry, as Minister responsible for Statistics Canada. Information on the availability of the wide range of data from Statistics Canada can be obtained from Statistics Canada’s Regional Offices, its website at www.statcan.ca, and its toll-free access number 1-800-2631136.
gression have blurred together, underscoring something we have known all along but have chosen to ignore: Most normative changes in aggression are constrained by variations among individuals. Recent studies show dramatically that individual-to-individual variations in developmental pathways are ubiquitous. Some of these developmental variations are associated with gender, social class, and ethnicity. Indeed, one can describe many relevant differences between the sexes in developmental trajectories, even though the basic processes by which children acquire certain types of aggression may not differ between boys and girls (Moffitt et al., 2001). Even among children of a single race or gender, however, normative changes encompass a range of individual differences. Nowhere is this conclusion more clearly revealed than in a recent manuscript that brings together data from six well-known longitudinal studies (Broidy et al., 2003). In every instance, semiparametric analyses reveal multiple types of developmental change. For example, four trajectories in physical aggression can be identified within a male sample from Montreal studied by Nagin and Tremblay (1999; Tremblay & Nagin, Chapter 5, this volume). Two are similar to those identified in a number of longitudinal studies: (1) high levels of aggression among a relatively small group of boys that persist across childhood and into adolescence and (2) low aggression that persists across childhood and characterizes a much larger group. Two other trajectories were also identified in these data:
8
INTRODUCTION
(3) one that begins with high levels of aggression and declines steadily as time goes on (boys sometimes called “desistors” or “recovered” aggressors) and (4) one that begins at more moderate levels and also declines. One other example included in this six-site investigation, the so-called Dunedin (New Zealand) studies of Moffitt and her associates (Moffitt, Caspi, Rutter, & Silva, 1996; Broidy, et al., 2003), revealed three distinct trajectories instead of four: (1) a small group of consistently aggressive boys, (2) a large group of consistently nonaggressive boys, and (3) another stable group of moderately aggressive boys. No cluster of decliners was identified in this study. The remaining studies in the investigation show either three- or fourcluster patterns, with only one (based on a sample from the United States) showing a trajectory of physical aggression that increases across childhood (Broidy et al., 2003). Developmental trajectories derived from longitudinal studies of girls are similar to those obtained with boys but also different: For example, four distinctive patterns were obtained in another Quebec study that are similar to those obtained for boys, but with the following exceptions: (1) Scores were decidedly lower than those for boys across the board, and (2) the desistors among the females declined more sharply across childhood into adolescence than those among the boys (see Broidy et al., 2003). Once again, a small group of chronic aggressors emerged, as well as a larger group of consistently nonaggressive girls. Among the girls in the Dunedin (New Zealand) sample, again, the trajectories are much like the boys’, except scores are lower and the decline in two groups is a bit greater (see Broidy et al., 2003). Normatively, then, the existence of two particular trajectories seems ubiquitous—a high level of aggression that is continuous throughout childhood and into adolescence and a low level of aggression that is equally consistent across age. Other patterns, including those characterized by aggression that declines during childhood and those typified by increases around the time of puberty, occur in some data sets but not others. No one is entirely certain as to why these sample-to-sample variations occur in the types of trajectories identified. Moreover, clear evidence does not yet establish the reasons for the variations that exist. Some investigators believe that persistent and high levels of aggression across childhood (much more common in boys than in girls) may have biological determinants, whereas “adolescence-limited” aggression may be derived from social experience, especially experience with aggressive peers (Moffitt et al., 2001). Other investigators, however, believe that dysfunctional family relationships in early childhood differentiate persistently aggressive boys from those showing other developmental patterns (Aguilar, Sroufe, Egeland, & Carlson, 2000). These questions are now at center stage in the research on the development of aggression. One conclusion, however, cannot be questioned: Normative change in aggressive behavior must be evaluated in the context of individual differences. The obverse is also true, namely, that individual differences must be evaluated in the context of normative change.
The Development of Aggression
9
Developmental trajectories in aggression development also differ according to characteristics of the individuals involved. For example, my own work with colleagues (Haselager, Cillessen, Van Lieshout, Riksen-Walraven, & Hartup, 2002; Hartup, Cillessen, Haselager, Scholte, & Van Lieshout, 2002a) shows a connection between developmental trajectories in aggression and sociometric status among boys. We examined, first, trajectories in composite measures of peer-reported and self-reported aggression between the ages of 6 and 11 among rejected boys (that is, boys who were peer rejected at a relatively early age). Groups emerging in a cluster analysis somewhat resembled the normative samples from Montreal and other sites (see Figure 1.2): Three more-or-less stable groups (highly aggressive, moderately aggressive, and persistently nonaggressive), as well as one that showed marked decreases in aggressive activity across the 5 years studied (a desistor subgroup). Discriminant function analysis shows that the highly stable aggressive group differed from the other three in social maladaptation, again consistent with the results of numerous studies. The only distinctive characteristic of the children who declined in aggression is that they also increased in cooperation over the period and were better liked by their peers as time went on. Shown in the Figure 1.3 are trajectories in aggressive behavior that emerged when we examined longitudinally a group of 87 boys who were all popular at age 6 (fair-haired boys, we might call them). Cross-sectional cluster analyses (not shown here) revealed differences among these popular children even at this age: Some were more aggressive and less cooperative than others. Two groups, however, emerged from a cluster analysis of the longitudinal
FIGURE 1.2. Developmental pathways of aggressive behavior in four clusters of initially rejected boys. From Haselager, Cillessen, Van Lieshout, Riksen-Walraven, and Hartup (2002). Copyright 2002 by the American Psychological Association. Reprinted by permission.
10
INTRODUCTION
FIGURE 1.3. Developmental pathways of aggression in three initially popular clusters. From Hartup, Cillessen, Haselager, Scholte, and Van Lieshout (2002a).
data—one group composed of individuals who were consistently nonaggressive and another group of individuals (15% of the subjects) who changed decisively in the direction of greater aggressiveness. These increasingly aggressive children were distinctive. Concomitant with their increasing aggression were decreases in cooperativeness and increases in peer rejection. Most interesting, though, are data available for 47 of these boys when they were 14 years of age: Discriminant function analysis identified two functions that successfully discriminated these boys from the other groups: (1) they were more sociable, were less inhibited, and achieved more poorly in school and (2) they were less well liked and more likely to engage in aggression, as well as in more bullying and victimization, than members of the other groups. These results suggest that synergies involving sociometric status and aggressive trajectories must be taken into account in order to describe, on one hand, “model” boys (stable, nonaggressive, popular boys) and, on the other hand, “toughs” (popular kids who are increasingly antisocial and not turned on by school) (Rodkin, Farmer, Pearl, & Van Acker, 2000). The message is clear: Normative change in aggression and antisocial behavior is meaningful only in the context of differential analysis. And the reverse may also be true: individual differences can be understood only in the context of normative analysis. Consideration of these combined forces is necessary to understanding both the development of aggression and social adaptation more generally.
Child Development versus Lifespan Perspectives Owing mainly to child-oriented societal forces, over most of the last century primary attention was given to developmental changes occurring in childhood
The Development of Aggression
11
rather than to changes occurring in adolescence or adulthood. Most studies of aggression and its development at the beginning of the child development movement were devoted to young children (Goodenough, 1931; Dawe, 1934); juvenile delinquency was studied among adolescents by sociologists and psychiatrists (Thrasher, 1927; Glueck & Glueck, 1934), but other aspects of adolescent aggressive behavior were largely ignored. These truncated perspectives dominate developmental science even today, although they have been modified in various ways—i.e., the doctrine of early experience is questioned in important aspects (Schaffer, 2002) and lifespan perspectives are promulgated as frameworks for examining developmental changes (Baltes, Lindenberger, & Staudinger, 1998). The bias toward childhood studies of behavioral development stems from theoretical/scientific sources as well as the nature of the early child welfare movement in the United States and elsewhere (Hartup, Johnson, & Weinberg, 2001). First, developmental science was heavily influenced in the early 20th century by psychoanalysis, on one hand, and learning theories, on the other, including their assumptions that development during the early years has pervasive and long-lasting consequences in both cognitive and social development. At the same time, social activists came to believe that the road to general societal progress begins with changes made in the lives of children and families, especially during a child’s early years. Parent education, social welfare services, and early childhood education were expanded greatly in many countries to assist in this effort. Services to adolescents were also improved, especially those relating to juvenile delinquency, but community welfare in the larger sense did not encompass lifespan considerations. Meanwhile, criminologists were discovering that childhood antecedents account for a large amount of variance in adolescent and adult crime (Glueck & Glueck, 1950; McCord, 1979). Clearly, short-term studies of children or adolescents were not going to be able to furnish an adequate basis for social intervention. More recent investigators utilize increasingly longer-term studies of aggression and antisocial behavior. Although infancy and early childhood are not encompassed by most of these studies, longitudinal analysis beginning in childhood and ending in early adulthood teaches us a great deal. We are in debt to David Farrington, Rolf Loeber, Robert Cairns, Leonard Eron and Rowell Husemann, John Coie, Joan McCord, and many others for work like this. It has been difficult to extend these studies through the life course, beginning in infancy and ending in middle or old age. Moffitt et al.’s (2001) work is notable for the fact that the data set begins with measurements at age 3, and newer studies (e.g., Tremblay, 2000) begin prenatally and remain open-ended. Studies ranging from middle childhood to young adulthood are still more common than those covering a longer term, and cradle-to-grave studies do not exist. Nevertheless, the message of lifespan developmentalists is being taken with increasing seriousness: Understanding adaptational problems requires developmental perspectives that extend beyond childhood and adolescence,
12
INTRODUCTION
and the coherence of human development, whether outcomes are good or bad, can be assessed only in terms of both growth and decline in behavioral function. Must we wait for geriatric data on the Montreal subjects or the Dunedin sample before studying the decline in aggression and antisocial behavior that is known to mark middle and old age? Probably not. Overlapping longitudinal studies—some beginning in adolescence, some beginning later—can unravel the conditions responsible for decline in antisocial behavior with age. One can argue, then, that normative change must be studied not only within the context of individual differences, but also within the context of the life course.
WHAT ARE THE DETERMINANTS OF BEHAVIOR CHANGE? Our ultimate goal is to identify the conditions responsible for normative development of aggression within the context of individual differences. As everyone knows, explanation in the behavioral sciences is extraordinarily difficult. Most developmental change is multidetermined, and causation is buried deeply within the genome and the mind. Moreover, the time separating “cause” from “effect” in human development is frequently decades, not moments, and change within one behavioral domain is entangled with changes in others. One cannot synthesize everything that has been written about the determinants of aggression in the space available here. Instead, several “tensions” or “dialectics” remaining in this field are discussed.
Nativism versus Empiricism The notion that human beings begin life with “innate ideas” and “inborn proclivities” appears in our most ancient religious and philosophical texts. Also expressed in classical philosophical writing is extreme empiricism, the argument being that nearly everything about human behavior—including aggression—derives from the individual’s commerce with the world. Most modern writers, though, view the development of aggression (like many other traits) as constrained by intrinsic structures (these may include the physiological and neural structures necessary to arousal, anger, learning, attention, language, and emotional regulation). The structures in question are species-wide and both determine the success of individual adaptation and make individual differences possible. Although relatively little is known about the processes through which these innate structures are deployed in behavioral development, especially in social and emotional behavior, the evidence suggests that relationships with others (including caretakers, friends, and enemies) are important vectors. The task, then, is to specify both the intrinsic and experiential contributions to developmental acquisitions and the manner in which they “synthesize” or “interact.”
The Development of Aggression
13
Recent studies in molecular genetics suggest that allelic variations may commonly interact with social and relationship experience in determining the aggressive phenotype. Suomi (Chapter 4, this volume) discovered that variations in the serotonin transporter gene (5-HTT) interact with rearing conditions to affect a variety of outcomes, including aggression and position in the dominance hierarchy, among rhesus monkeys. So-called “short” allelic variations are associated with nonaggressive maladaptations—but for peer-reared individuals and not mother-reared individuals. In other words, attachment to a maternal figure moderates the effects of the genetic variations. The findings also partially explain why peer rearing does not produce extremely aggressive animals in all cases. In recent work with human beings, Caspi et al. (2002) discovered an interaction between parental maltreatment and levels of monoamine oxidase A (MAOA) genetic expression (MAOA is a gene located on the X chromosome that encodes an enzyme that metabolizes various neurotransmitters, rendering them inactive). Maltreated boys in a large longitudinal sample possessing the genotype associated with high levels of MAOA expression were less likely to have antisocial problems in the course of their development than those with genotypes associated with low levels of MAOA expression. Results of this study help to account for the fact that, although harsh parental discipline and maltreatment of young boys is related to aggressive and antisocial outcomes, not all maltreated children grow up to victimize others. In addition to these studies, process-oriented prospective studies are needed (beginning earlier than most existing studies) to explain the manner in which so-called biological variations contribute to individual differences in aggressiveness and antisocial behavior. One hopes that investigators will not simplistically consider factors like maternal IQ, maternal age, and maternal social adjustment as well as child IQ, child memory, attention disabilities, and child temperament to be exclusively biological indicators (Moffitt et al., 2001), nor attachment histories to be exclusively social indicators. These constructs are only the roughest indications of intrinsic or social structures, respectively, and the manner in which they work. We need new expertise in psychoendocrine measurement in infancy and beyond, temperament, emotional processes in infancy and early childhood (Thompson, 1998), and behavioral regulation in early relationships between the child and his or her caretakers. Implications of the neuropsychological history for the child’s social and emotional history must be studied along with experience. Overall, refinements in methods for studying psychological processes in the development of aggression are just as important as advances in gene mapping.
Socialization: From Unilateral to Bilateral Constructions Although there were many indications in earlier writings that children are “socializing creatures” as well as “socialized ones” (Baldwin, 1897), a consensus concerning a two-way or bilateral view of childhood socialization was
14
INTRODUCTION
reached only recently (Bell, 1968). The notion that social adaptation is the outcome of interaction between the child and others, rather than some sort of one-way social-molding process, is now accepted by almost everybody.
Parent–Child Relationships With respect to the development of aggression, one does not find many studies that deal directly with social interaction or social relationships within the family. Most commonly, investigators enter measures like the following into their regression models as predictors of child or adolescent outcomes: (1) child characteristics—temperament, intelligence, troublesomeness, memory and attention problems, impulsivity, and personality and (2) parent characteristics— warmth versus negativity, family coercion and inconsistent discipline, punishment and punitiveness, along with abusive parenting (Coie & Dodge, 1998). The ensuing regressions allow us to examine main and interaction effects among these child and maternal characteristics, but not the social exchanges between parents and children from which changes over time actually emanate. One of the most brilliant achievements of the last century is the “performance theory” formulated and tested by Gerald Patterson and his associates. This socialization model specifies the parameters and contingencies occurring in family interaction that instantiate troublesomeness among young boys, maintain it, and supply the basis for the attitudes that characterize these same boys in their early interactions with other children outside the home. These relationships, in turn, involve them in increasingly violent behavior (Patterson, Reid, & Dishion, 1992). In other studies, certain mileage can be gained by using global measures of family conflict, maternal punitiveness, and harsh discipline, but the “performance model” makes clear that such measures are only proxies for measures of social interaction. One concludes that microanalytic approaches to socialization studies of the development of aggression are needed as well as macroanalytic ones. Most parent–child measures also do not pass muster as relationships constructs. Relationships are usually defined as aggregates of interaction between individuals who have formed expectations about one another that guide interpersonal behavior over time (Hinde, 1997). It so happens that relationships are the social contexts within which most development occurs: (1) basic skills in language and communication, (2) competence in coping with both social and nonsocial problems, and (3) the attitudes and abilities needed for constructing other relationships. Relationships theory, however, has not penetrated very deeply into research on the development of aggression. Parental punitiveness or harsh discipline (common measures) are parent characteristics, not dimensions of the parent–child relationship. Similarly, maternal warmth does not describe a relationship between mother and child. Exactly what this omission means for research is not really known. Diana Baumrind (1971) had considerable success earlier in describing permissive relationships between parents and children and showing that these were associated with early ag-
The Development of Aggression
15
gression. Some investigators have consistently reported cross-time correlations between disorganized attachment patterns in infancy and early childhood with manifestations of aggression and antisocial behavior in middle childhood and adolescence (Renken, Egeland, Marvinney, Mangelsdorf, & Sroufe, 1989). Others report similar findings, especially among vulnerable children, for example, children who live in chaotic, poor families with a single parent (see Coie & Dodge, 1998). And, in the Dunedin data set (Moffitt et al., 2001), a relationships measure (“relationship with parents,” based on items like trust, communication, and lack of alienation between adolescents and their parents) turns out to be a better predictor of adolescent aggression (–.44, –.47) than measures of harsh discipline (.19, .27). No one would argue that relationship constructs are the only ones that account for significant variance in adolescent aggression. We have sufficient evidence to argue, however, that relationships measurement definitely belongs in studies of the family antecedents of aggression, especially as we look forward to research dealing with gene–environment interactions.
Peer Relationships Until recently, the significance of peer relations in the development of aggression and antisocial behavior was considered to be mostly a unidirectional process. That is, the prevailing view was that kids get into trouble because they are exposed to the exhortations and examples of deviant peers and are rejected by better-adjusted associates, an occurrence that lowers self-esteem and restricts access to well-socialized companions. Sometimes the interaction between child characteristics (e.g., earlier disruptiveness or troublesomeness) and peer experience (e.g., social rejection by other children) is examined in relation to aggressive outcomes. In most instances, significant variance in child or adolescent aggression flows additively from both child sources (including earlier aggression or compliance difficulties) and the attitudes and behaviors of other children (Coie & Dodge, 1998). Additional variance in the development of aggression, however, may be traced to close relationships with other children, including (1) friends, (2) enemies, and (3) bully–victim relationships (see Boivin, Vitaro, & Poulin, Chapter 18, this volume).
Friends Friendship dyads, in general, are neither more nor less aggressive or antisocial than “neutral” dyads (Hartup, Verhoeven, DeBoer, Scholte, & Van Lieshout, 2002b). Among individual children and adolescents, those who have friends are not as troubled as those who do not, but “not having friends” does not predict aggression very well either concurrently or over time (Hartup, 1996). Friends, however, are more similar to one another in both aggressiveness and antisocial behavior than nonfriends (Haselager, Hartup, Van Lieshout, &
16
INTRODUCTION
Risken-Walraven, 1998; Hartup et al., 2002b), a situation that can also be observed in social networks or cliques (Cairns & Cairns, 1994). Moreover, these similarities reflect more than “birds of a feather flock together.” The day-today interaction that occurs between antisocial friends actually increases their antisocial behavior over time, especially among children already identified as aggressive and rejected (Dishion, 1990; Tremblay, Masse, Vitaro, & Dobkin, 1995). Most likely, this happens because the interaction between aggressive children and their friends is more contentious and conflict-ridden than interaction between nonaggressive friends (Dishion, Andrews, & Crosby, 1995). In addition, overtly aggressive children are not notably intimate with one another nor as exclusive in their relationship attitudes as their nonaggressive counterparts (Grotpeter & Crick, 1996). Thus, aggressive friends are aggressive risks. Friendship quality also contributes significant variance to the development of aggression in childhood and adolescence. In general, unharmonious friendships exacerbate the individual child’s problems in school, create adjustment difficulties, and increase aggressiveness. In many instances, however, friendship quality has a greater effect on children who are at risk in social development than on those who are not. For example, Poulin, Dishion, and Haas (1999) found significant interaction effects between boys’ antisocial behavior (delinquency) at age 13–14 and friendship quality at that same age (harmoniousness) in relation to antisocial behavior one year later, at age 14–15. The greatest effects of low-quality friendships on subsequent delinquency occurred when baseline delinquency levels were high rather than low. In other words, the friendship construct was more strongly related to developmental outcome among vulnerable individuals than among less vulnerable ones. Overall, friends may or may not support good developmental outcome. Empirical studies tell us that aggressive friends (or unharmonious relationships) are risk factors inasmuch as the children are not well socialized, instigate aggressive behavior (e.g., train one another in deviancy), and do not instigate effective regulatory controls. In addition, friendships that are not harmonious instigate increases in aggressive behavior over time, possibly for some of the same reasons, and mainly among children who are at risk (Boivin et al., Chapter 18, this volume).
Enemies Social networks also include relationships that are not based on social attraction but, rather, are rooted in antipathy, animosity, and enmity. The term “mutual antipathies” describes this relationships category; the word encompasses “being enemies” as well as other relationships maintained on the basis of social aversion. Recent studies (Hartup et al., 2002b) show that differences in aggression and antisocial behavior between adolescents who do not like each other are greater than differences between nonenemies (individuals in
The Development of Aggression
17
neutral dyads). This confirms the “repulsion hypothesis,” which states that individuals dislike those who are different from themselves (Rosenbaum, 1986). Adolescents in mutual antipathies are also substantially more antisocial and aggressive than in “control” or “neutral” dyads, as well as more internalizing and victimized by others. These differences are consistent with earlier analyses of individual children and adolescents in this same data set, which suggest that involvement in mutual antipathies is a risk marker. That is, both children and adolescents who are involved in mutual antipathies show more fighting and bullying, social ineffectiveness, and victimization than those who are not so involved. Peer rejection was a covariate in these analyses, so the variance associated with mutual antipathies is unique. These results characterize both boys and girls who are involved in same-sex antipathies, and boys, but not girls, who are involved in mixed-sex antipathies (Abecassis, Hartup, Haselager, Scholte, & Van Lieshout, 2002). Results from several other studies of mutual antipathies and their correlates are not entirely consistent, although these results have been replicated in three instances (see Hodges & Card, 2003).
Bully–Victim Relationships Some bullies and victims dislike each other, some are neutral toward one another, and some are friends. The correlation between bully–victim status and friendship attraction is negative but moderate in magnitude (Perry, Finnegan, Hodges, Kennedy, & Malone, 1993). Although the literature on bullying and victimization is substantial, most of the relevant studies are monadically oriented, that is, centered on questions such as “What makes a bully?” or “What makes a victim?” rather than on ongoing bully–victim relationships. Great progress has been made in understanding bullying and victimization during the last 30 years (see Rigby, 2002), but relationships-oriented ideas are only slowly making their way into this area. As it turns out, both friends and enemies bear on these situations: For example, increases in victimization are inversely related to the number of externalizing problems evinced by friends, suggesting that victims with externalizing friends may well be protected by them (Hodges & Perry, 1999). A significant relation also exists between characteristics of children’s enemies and victimization: The aggressiveness, physical strength, and victimization experienced by a child’s enemy uniquely predicts the child’s own victimization (Card & Hodges, 2003). Much more, however, remains to be learned about relationships between bullies and victims, their varieties, and their vicissitudes.
Relations among Relationships The social networks of most children and adolescents include friends, neutral associates, enemies, and sometimes bullies or victims. Do these relationship experiences moderate one another in the development of aggression? Does in-
18
INTRODUCTION
volvement in one relationship affect correlates of the other? Recently, my colleagues and I (Hartup et al., 2002b) examined adolescent friendship dyads as a function of whether one or both individuals is also involved in a mutual antipathy (i.e., has an enemy). We also asked whether antipathy dyads vary in psychological adjustment as a function of whether one or both individuals has a mutual friend. First, we gathered together all dyads in a large data set in which the adolescents (14-year-olds) mutually nominated each other as “someone you especially like,” as well as all dyads in which the participants mutually nominated each other as “someone you don’t like at all.” Results show that friends with mutual antipathies are both more antisocial and more aggressive than friends without mutual antipathies or those in which only one child has an enemy. Peer victimization and internalizing behavior are also greater among friends in which one or both children have mutual antipathies. Second, we examined pairs of adolescents who did not like one another as well as whether either adolescent had a mutual friend. Antisocial behavior is less frequent among the adolescent enemies who also have friends than among those who do not. Peer victimization is lower, too, when one or both enemies have a friend. But differences are not significant for aggressive behavior according to whether enemies also have friends. Overall, then, friends are more antisocial when they also have enemies; concomitantly, enemies have lower antisocial behavior scores when they also have friends. Aggressiveness, however, is not moderated in the same way: Friends with enemies are more aggressive than friends without, but friendships do not appear to be strong enough to lessen the aggressiveness that accompanies involvement in a mutual antipathy.
Does Context Make a Difference? Currently, the most advanced ideas being pursued about contextualism and development do not include the notion that person and environment can be conceived dualistically. Gone are notions that persons cause environmental change and vice versa. Instead, the modern view treats the person and the environment as integrated or fused; neither is an entity that can be described sensibly without reference to the other, and development is the story of change over time in this integrated system. One must consider development to be characteristic of biological and social systems, not an attribute of either individuals or contexts. Conventional (dualistic) contextualism is well represented in research on the development of aggression. Cross-national studies show differences in developmental trajectories (Broidy et al., 2003); cross-cultural studies, the same (Whiting & Whiting, 1975). There is also clear evidence that ecological factors like neighborhood violence have a great deal to do with the early onset of aggressive behavior. These scenarios, however, are not simple. As Schwartz and colleagues (Schwartz, Gorman, Toblin, & Abou-ezzedine, 2003) demon-
The Development of Aggression
19
strate, exposure to community violence is consistently related to childhood aggression only among children who are involved in a relatively large number of mutual antipathies with other children. Once again, a relationship factor increases risk in the development of aggression among children who are already vulnerable. These results move us a step or two from dualistic notions about individuals and the community because, in this case, relationship systems are seen to moderate the effects of external conditions. Community and societal variables will remain in research on the development of aggression, but notions about the “environment” need to be rethought in terms of ecological systems theory (Gatti & Tremblay, Chapter 19, this volume).
CONCLUSION Conclusions to this survey of research on aggression and its development are relatively straightforward: Conceptualization and empirical studies dealing with the development of aggression need to organized as a series of “nests.” 1. Normative change needs to be nested theoretically in the context of individual differences and within long-term (i.e., lifespan) perspectives. 2. The development of aggression can be understood only when the earliest genetic expressions are examined as nested in early social experience, especially individual social histories and close relationships. 3. The aggressive act must be considered as nested within a broad and complex ecology of harm doing and antisocial behavior. We stand at the edge of the nest, then, regarding what we know about the development of aggression.
REFERENCES Abecassis, M., Hartup, W. W., Haselager, G. J. T., Scholte, R. J. H., & Van Lieshout, C. F. M. (2002). Mutual antipathies and their significance in childhood and adolescence. Child Development, 73, 1543–1556. Aguilar, B., Sroufe, L. A., Egeland, B., & Carlson, E. (2000). Distinguishing the earlyonset-persistent and adolescent-onset antisocial behavior types: From birth to 16 years. Development and Psychopathology, 12, 109–132. Baldwin, J. M. (1897). Social and ethical interpretations in mental development. New York: Macmillan. Baltes, P. B., Lindenberger, U., & Staudinger, U. M. (1998). Life-span theory in developmental psychology. In W. Damon (Series Ed.), R. M. Lerner (Vol. Ed.), Handbook of child psychology: Vol. 1. Theoretical models of human development (5th ed., pp. 1029–1144). New York: Wiley. Bandura, A. (1973). Aggression: A social learning analysis. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
20
INTRODUCTION
Bandura, A., & Walters, R. H. (1963). Social learning and imitation. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston. Baumrind, D. (1971). Current patterns of parental authority. Developmental Psychology Monographs, 4(1), 1–103. Bell, R. Q. (1968). A reinterpretation of direction of effects in studies of socialization. Psychological Review, 75, 81–95. Broidy, L. M., Nagin, D. S., Tremblay, R. E., Bates, J. E., Brame, B., Dodge, K. A., Fergusson, D., Horwood, J. L., Loeber, R., Laird, R., Lynam D. R., Moffitt, T. E., Pettit, G. S., & Vitaro, F. (2003). Developmental trajectories of childhood disruptive behaviors and adolescent delinquency: A six site, cross-national study. Developmental Psychology, 39(2), 222–245. Cairns, R. B., & Cairns, B. D. (1994). Lifelines and risks. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. Card, N. A., & Hodges, E. V. E. (2003) Parent–child relationships and enmity with peers: The role of avoidant and preoccupied attachment. In E. V. E. Hodges & N. A. Card (Eds.), Enemies and the darker side of peer relations (pp. 23–37). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass. Caspi, A., McClay, J., Moffitt, T. E., Mill, J., Martin, J., Craig, I. W., Taylor, A., & Poulton, R. (2002). Role of genotype in the cycle of violence in maltreated children. Science, 297, 851–854, Coates, B., & Hartup, W. W. (1969). Age and verbalization in observational learning. Developmental Psychology, 1, 556–562. Coie, J. D., & Dodge, K. A. (1998). Aggression and antisocial behavior. In W. Damon (Series Ed.), N. Eisenberg (Vol. Ed.), Handbook of child psychology: Vol. 3. Social, emotional, and personality development (pp. 779–862). New York: Wiley. Crick, N. R., Werner, N. E., Casas, J. F., O’Brien, K. M., Nelson, D. A., Grotpeter, J. K., & Markon, K. (1998). Childhood aggression and gender: A new look at an old problem. In D. Bernstein (Ed.), Nebraska Symposium on Motivation: Vol. 45. Gender and motivation. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press. Dawe, H. C. (1934). An analysis of two hundred quarrels of preschool children. Child Development, 5, 139–157. Dishion, T. J. (1990). The peer context of troublesome child and adolescent behavior. In P. Leone (Ed.), Understanding troubled and troublesome youth (pp. 128–153). Newbury Park, CA: Sage. Dishion, T. J., Andrews, D. W., & Crosby, L. (1995). Anti-social boys and their friends in early adolescence: Relationship characteristics, quality, and interactional process. Child Development, 66, 139–151. Feshbach, S. (1970). Aggression. In P. H. Mussen (Ed.), Carmichael’s manual of child psychology (Vol. 2, pp. 159–259). New York: Wiley. Glueck, S., & Glueck, E. T. (1934). One thousand juvenile delinquents. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Gleuck, S., & Glueck, E. T. (1950). Unraveling juvenile delinquency. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Goodenough, F. L. (1931). Anger in young children. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press. Grotpeter, J. K., & Crick, N. R. (1996). Relational aggression, overt aggression, and friendship. Child Development, 67, 2328–2338. Hartup, W. W. (1996). The company they keep: Friendships and their developmental significance. Child Development, 67, 1–13.
The Development of Aggression
21
Hartup, W. W., Cillessen, A. H. N., Haselager, G. J. T., Scholte, R. J., & Van Lieshout, C. F. M. (2002a). Heterogeneity among popular boys: Subtypes and developmental trajectories. Unpublished manuscript, University of Minnesota. Hartup, W. W., & De Wit, J. (1974). The development of aggression: Problems and perspectives. In J. De Wit & W. W. Hartup (Eds.), Determinants and origins of aggressive behavior (pp. 595–620). The Hague: Mouton. Hartup, W. W., Johnson, A., & Weinberg, R. A. (2001). The Institute of Child Development: Pioneering in science and application. In W. W. Hartup & R. A. Weinberg (Eds.), Child psychology in retrospect and prospect: The 32nd Minnesota Symposium on Child Psychology (pp. 227– 257). Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum. Hartup, W. W., Verhoeven, M., DeBoer, R., Scholte, R. J. H., & Van Lieshout, C. F. M. (2002b, August). Heterogeneity of mutual friendships and mutual antipathies: A cross-sectional study. Paper presented at the biennial meeting of the International Society for the Study of Behavioural Development, Ottawa (Canada). Haselager, G. J. T., Cillessen, A. H. N., Van Lieshout, C. F. M., Riksen-Walraven, J. M. A., & Hartup, W. W. (2002). Heterogeneity of social behavior in peer rejected boys across middle childhood: Developmental pathways and their correlates. Developmental Psychology, 38, 446–456. Haselager, G. J. T., Hartup, W. W., Van Lieshout, C. F. M., & Riksen-Walraven, J. M. A. (1998). Similarities between friends and nonfriends in middle childhood. Child Development, 69, 1198–1208. Hinde, R. A. (1997). Relationships: A dialectical perspective. Hove, UK: Psychology Press. Hodges, E. V. E., & Card, N. A. (Eds.) (2003). Enemies and the darker side of peer relations. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass. Hodges, E. V. E., & Perry, D. G. (1999). Personal and interpersonal antecedents and consequences of victimization by peers. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 76, 677–685. Maccoby, E. E. (1992). The role of parents in the socialization of children: An historical overview. Developmental Psychology, 28, 1006–1017. McCord, J. (1979). Some child-rearing antecedents of criminal behavior in adult men. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 37, 1477–1486. Moffitt, T. E., Caspi, A., Dickson, N., Silva, P., & Stanton, W. (1996). Childhood-onset versus adolescent-onset antisocial conduct problems in males: Natural history from ages 3 to 18 years. Development and Psychopathology, 8, 399–424. Moffitt, T. E., Caspi, A., Rutter, M., & Silva, P. A. (2001). Sex differences in antisocial behavior. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. Nagin, D., & Tremblay, R. E. (1999). Trajectories of boys’ physical aggression, opposition, and hyperactivity on the path to physically violent and nonviolent juvenile delinquency. Child Development, 70(5), 1181–1196. Parke, R. D., & Slaby, R. (1983). The development of aggression. In P. H. Mussen (Series Ed.), E. M. Hetherington (Vol. Ed.), Handbook of child psychology: Vol. 4. Socialization, personality, and social development (pp. 547–641). New York: Wiley. Patterson, G. R., Reid, J., & Dishion, T. J. (1992). Antisocial boys. Eugene, OR: Castalia Press. Perry, D. G., Finnegan, R. A., Hodges, E. V. E., Kennedy, E., & Malone, M. (1993, August). Aggressive and victimized children’s relations with parents and peers. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Psychological Association, Toronto.
22
INTRODUCTION
Poulin, F., Dishion, T. J., & Haas, E. (1999). The peer influence paradox: Friendship quality and deviancy training within male adolescent friendships. Merrill-Palmer Quarterly, 45, 42–61. Renken, B., Egeland, B., Marvinney, D., Mangelsdorf, S., & Sroufe, L. A. (1989). Early childhood antecedents of aggression and passive-withdrawal in early elementary school. Journal of Personality, 57, 257–281. Rigby, K. (2002). Bullying in childhood. In P. K. Smith & C. H. Hart (Eds.), Blackwell handbook of childhood social development (pp. 549–568). Oxford, UK: Blackwell. Rodkin, P. C., Farmer, T. W., Pearl, R., & Van Acker, R. (2000). Heterogeneity of popular boys: Antisocial and prosocial configurations. Developmental Psychology, 36, 14– 24. Rosenbaum, M. E. (1986). The repulsion hypothesis: On the nondevelopment of relationships. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 51, 1156–1166. Schaffer, H. R. (2002). The early experience assumption: Past, present, and future. In W. W. Hartup & R. K. Silbereisen (Eds.), Growing points in developmental science (pp. 24–46). Hove, UK: Psychology Press. Schwartz, D., Gorman, A. H., Toblin, R., & Abou-ezzedine, T. (2003). Mutual antipathies in the peer group as a moderating factor in the association between community violence exposure and psychosocial maladjustment. In E. V. E. Hodges and N. A. Card (Eds.), Enemies and the darker side of peer relations (pp. 39–54). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass. Thompson, R. A. (1998). Early sociopersonality development. In W. Damon (Series Ed.), N. Eisenberg (Vol. Ed.), Handbook of child psychology: Vol. 3. Social, emotional, and personality development (pp. 25–104). New York: Wiley. Thrasher, F. M. (1927). The gang. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Tremblay, R. E. (2000). The development of aggressive behaviour during childhood: What have we learned in the past century? International Journal of Behavioral Development, 24, 129–141. Tremblay, R. E., Boulerice, B., Harden, P. W., McDuff, P., Perusse, D., Pihl, R. O., & Zoccolillo, M. (1996). Do children in Canada become more aggressive as they approach adolescence? In Human Resources Development Canada & Statistics Canada (Eds.), Growing up in Canada: National longitudinal survey of children and youth (Catalogue 89-550, pp. 127–137). Ottawa: Statistics Canada. Tremblay, R. E., Masse, L. C., Vitaro, F., & Dobkin, P. L. (1995). The impact of friends’ deviant behavior on early onset of delinquency: Longitudinal data from 6 to 13 years of age. Development and Psychopathology, 7, 649–667. Whiting, B. B., & Whiting, J. W. M. (1975). Children of six cultures. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Part II THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION IN ANIMALS AND HUMANS
THE DEVELOPMENT Subtypes of Aggression OF AGGRESSION
2 Subtypes of Aggression in Humans and Animals P AUL L. G ENDREAU and J OHN A RCHER
From the elementary fencing behavior of fruit flies to the lunging attack of mice or rats, and from the biting of dogs to the more subtle form of indirect aggression in humans, the expression of aggressive behavior becomes increasingly sophisticated and diversified as animals increase in neural complexity. Comparable transformation is observed during the course of human ontogeny. Children first bite, hit, push, and kick (Tremblay et al., 1999); then gradually, they may come to choose more indirect, socially oriented forms of aggression such as spreading negative rumors about a classmate or attempting to alter relationships (Björkqvist, Lagerspetz, & Kaukiainen, 1992). The expression of aggression undoubtedly reaches a peak of complexity in adulthood, not only in terms of expression but also with regard to its multiple causes and consequences (Loeber & Day, 1997). The fact that aggression is not a unitary or homogeneous phenomenon is clearly not in dispute among scientists. More challenging, however, is the need to provide a definition of aggression that would satisfy researchers from most (or, it is hoped, all) spheres of expertise (Archer & Browne, 1989). Some authors have argued that this is an impossible mission because the concept of aggression involves too many variables and determinants and, more particularly, a significant part of social and moral judgment (e.g., Johnson, 1972). Others avoid using the term aggression because of its diffuse meaning (e.g., Patterson & Cobb, 1973), or declare that reaching a consensus on a definition is not necessary to perform a meticulous analysis of aggression (e.g., Cairns, 1979). Finally, some researchers have maintained that aggression is essentially an inadequate concept that ought to be replaced by more precise terminology (e.g., coercive control; Tedeschi & Felson, 1994; Felson, 2002). 25
26
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
Before reaching a potential agreement about a definition, a first step is to describe and classify the different types of aggression. As Moyer (1968) argued, “progress in understanding the general phenomenon of aggressive behavior can only be made when the various aggressions are carefully and operationally defined” (p. 65). Hence, several attempts have been made to sort the different forms of aggression into discrete categories. Various taxonomies have been offered for both animal and human aggression, based on the similarity of behavioral expression, contextual characteristics of the eliciting stimulus, functional significance, motivational underpinning, or underlying neurophysiological mechanisms. In this chapter we review the diverse forms of aggression in both animals and humans in an attempt to integrate the current knowledge into a coherent theoretical and practical framework. We argue that a better understanding of the concept of aggression requires a systematic examination of the various proximal and distal forces that induce, facilitate, or maintain the development and expression of the different subtypes of aggression in both humans and animals. Comparing the similarities and dissimilarities of these multiple forces in a variety of species, and among individuals within a given species, is the only possible strategy for formulating a universal taxonomy of aggression.
COMPARING DIFFERENT LEVELS OF PHYLOGENETIC AND ONTOGENETIC ORGANIZATION The Risk of Anthropomorphism and Zoomorphism To recognize the phylogenetic sophistication of aggression, it is important to discriminate between subtypes of aggression that are unique to humans and those that are also present in other species. The ontogenetic sophistication of aggression will become manifest only by differentiating subtypes of aggression that are expressed during a specific developmental period from those that occur throughout ontogeny. Distinctions should be articulated behaviorally, functionally, and neurobiologically. At the behavioral level, a number of aggression-related behaviors are strikingly similar among many species, even in those that are extremely distant in phylogenetic terms. For instance, a “boxing” stance (an upright posture observed during fighting) is shown by fruit flies, rats, and humans. Although the behavioral repertoire of flies and rodents is more complex than one would expect (Chen, Lee, Bowens, Huber, & Kravitz, 2002; Barnett & Marples, 1981; Gendreau, Gariépy, Petitto, & Lewis, 1997), it does not reach the range of human behavioral expression. Nevertheless, one may ask how is it possible that such unrelated species exhibit similar forms of aggression. What do flies, rodents, and humans have in common besides possessing pairs of limbs and being able to display a similar motor-expressive pattern? At the functional level, fruit flies and rats do not fight for money or pride, but both can fight for sexual access and territoriality, as humans sometimes do. At the neurobiological level, the divergence is con-
Subtypes of Aggression
27
siderable. The rudimentary nervous system of a fruit fly is made up of a mere 250,000 neurons, and the brain of an adult rat weighs more or less 2 g. With its 100 billion neurons, the 1.4-kg human brain is at a different level of complexity. Nevertheless, rats and humans share similar brain structures and pathways, and, like fruit flies, they can develop addiction to cocaine, nicotine, and alcohol (Bainton, Tsai, Singh, Moore, Neckameyer, & Heberlein, 2000), suggesting a certain degree of neurobiological similarity. Cross-species comparisons call for differentiating behavioral and neurophysiological characteristics that are homologous (i.e., having a common evolutionary origin) from those that are simply analogous (i.e., likeness in function but not in evolutionary origin). When analyzing behavioral and/or physiological similarity between species, we run the risk of anthropomorphism, that is, viewing animals as having human-like qualities, or zoomorphism, that is, mistakenly perceiving human behavior as the mirror image of animal behavior (Cairns, 1979). For instance, contrary to the controversial and sensationalist opinion of authors in the past (e.g., Ardrey, 1966), predatory behavior in animals should not be equated with hunting or warfare in humans. Although these behaviors may share some common neuroevolutionary processes, the function of predatory behavior is to supply food, thus enhancing the probability of survival. Human hunting, at least in modern society, is often motivated only by the pleasure that the activity provides, and not by the necessity to gain food. Predation targets other species, whereas warfare is directed at other humans. Likewise, matching children’s and adults’ behavior on the basis of their expressive similarity, something one could adventurously call “adultomorphism” or “pedomorphism,” depending on the direction of the comparison, is not uncommon. A child hitting another child in kindergarten and an adult hitting a colleague at work are events that—albeit similar in their expression and to some extent in their immediate consequences (i.e., physical hurt)—clearly differ in terms of antecedents and long-term consequences. In sum, any definition of aggression that does not address the issue of phylogenetic and ontogenetic similarity and contrast encourages a static or reified view of a complex phenomenon.
Early Taxonomies of Aggression Animal models of aggression provide a strong conceptual base for approaching the study of human aggression. Moyer (1968) established seven categories of aggressive behavior based on their functional values and stimulus-bound characteristics: predatory aggression, intermale aggression, fear-induced aggression, irritable aggression, territorial defense, maternal aggression, and instrumental aggression. A possible eighth category, sex-related aggression, was also suggested. As Moyer himself mentioned five years later, however, “definition of the kinds of aggression on that basis alone now appears too restrictive: the kinds of aggression vary on a number of different dimensions,
28
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
and all of them must be considered in the definition of each kind” (Moyer, 1973, p. 12). The dimensions that Moyer referred to were the specificity of the eliciting stimulus, the presence or absence of an emotional display, the sex of the attacker, and the neurophysiological correlates. With these four “dimensions” in mind, Moyer (1973) finally rejected territorial defense as a subtype of aggression. Although Moyer’s taxonomy was primarily targeting animal aggression, reference was also made to human behavior; however, the uniqueness and complexity of human aggression was not specifically addressed. The use of the categories to describe and differentiate human aggression undoubtedly leans toward zoomorphism. A similar comment can be made regarding Wilson’s sociobiological taxonomy (Wilson, 1980). Although most of the subtypes of aggression (i.e., territorial, dominance, sexual, parental disciplinary, weaning, moralistic, predatory, and antipredatory aggression) were meant to be theoretically applicable to both animals and humans, there are obvious exceptions. Weaning aggression, for example—that is, occurring when parents “gently attack” their offspring to make them stop begging for food—is clearly more relevant to animal behavior. The opposite can be said of moralistic aggression, which for Wilson (1980) represents advanced forms of reciprocal altruism that reduce the manifestation of aggression via rules, codes of punishment, or enforced conformity. In conjunction with the risk of zoomorphism and/or anthropomorphism, a major problem with Moyer’s and Wilson’s taxonomies is that they are based on an eclectic set of criteria. These involve a specific target (e.g., prey, predator, another male), a specific context (e.g., territorial, maternal, weaning), a specific function (e.g., to dominate, to obtain sexual access) or the concomitant occurrence of an emotional state (e.g., fear, anger), or a learning process (e.g., instrumental, moralistic). As argued by Archer and Browne (1989), one should try to be more explicit, and perhaps more restrictive, in terms of which criteria are used to divide aggression into distinct classes. Archer (1988) proposed a simpler classification on the basis of function by distinguishing forms of aggression that are “competitive,” “protective,” and “parental.” Parental aggression can be viewed as an extension of protective aggression, involving the protection of those recognized as genetically related and dependent. Predation was omitted from this scheme because, as argued in an earlier article (Archer, 1976), Moyer (1968) actually presented good evidence for the neural and motivational separation of the two forms of behavior. The argument was that the motivational systems underlying aggression and predation had evolved independently of one another; a good example is provided by cats, who show very different types of behavior and emotional states when fighting one another and when stalking prey. However, it is undoubtedly the case that the systems controlling predation and aggression are more related in some cases, for example, in the case of mouse killing by rats (e.g., Karli, 1956), in cannibalism in chimpanzees (Bygott, 1972), and more widely in the case of male infanticide. In humans, the link between hunting and aggression may be more complex.
Subtypes of Aggression
29
At about the same time that Moyer proposed his taxonomy and suggested four dimensional criteria to discriminate subtypes of aggression in animals, similar attempts were made to categorize the different forms of aggression in humans. Buss (1961) suggested that aggression be dichotomized along three behavioral dimensions: physical–verbal, active–passive, and direct–indirect. In 1969, Pulkkinen formulated a bidimensional (and bicriteria) model characterizing human aggression (see Pulkkinen, 1987). A first dimension was related to the expression of aggression, ranging from indirect forms to more direct ones. A second dimension concerned the defensive–offensive dichotomy, which was determined by the presence or absence of proximal threatening stimuli. Although these models have the merit of being parsimonious, they are not truly pertinent to animal aggression, as indirect forms of aggression are exclusive to humans and, possibly, nonhuman primates (Campbell, 1999). In addition, a model depicting behavioral or contextual features in terms of a continuum (poles or axes) may not be appropriate for some distinctions, because it postulates quantitative differences between the different forms of aggression. An aggressive act can fluctuate in intensity, but it cannot be half direct and half indirect.
A MULTILEVEL ANALYSIS OF AGGRESSION IN ANIMALS AND HUMANS Aggression is a dynamic, multifaceted social-emotional process that calls for a careful examination of its various antecedents, expressions, and consequences (or functions). The adoption of a dynamic and multifactorial perspective when investigating the foundations of aggression and other types of social behavior in humans and animals was ardently advocated by Cairns (1979). Cairns stressed the importance of using adequate criteria in order to generalize from one phylogenetic level to another and from one developmental stage to another. Observing a similar feature in two or more species (e.g., boxing) or in a child and an adult (e.g., hitting) is not enough to conclude that these behaviors serve the same function and derive from the same proximal or distal antecedents. This principle has a significant impact on how aggression is ultimately defined and how the different forms of aggression can be grouped. Figure 2.1 summarizes the major domains or themes of investigation in aggression research. This is an extended representation of Cairns’s model of what he called “polythetic analysis,” that is, the examination of aggression from multiple conceptual angles. The first three domains encompass the proximal (eliciting context and neurophysiological mechanisms) and the more distal antecedents of aggression, which are perceptible only through a longitudinal, developmental analysis. The fourth domain relates to the expression of aggression, whereas the fifth and the sixth cover the consequences of aggression to others (harm) and to self and society (social/emotional function), respectively. One must recognize that there are important differences between, as well
30
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
FIGURE 2.1. Polythetic analysis of aggression. Based on Cairns (1979).
as within, species in terms of variables that influence the development and expression of aggression. Nevertheless, this thematic framework probably covers most subtypes of aggression found in the scientific literature and can be generally applied to both animal and human research. Obviously, dichotomizing aggression as direct versus indirect or as producing physical versus mental harm may be more appropriate and applicable to human behavior than to rat or fruit fly aggression. It is also important to note that even if most subtypes of aggression have been established on the basis of a single criterion, it is always possible to relate them to other criteria. Therefore, overlap between criteria is clearly the rule rather than the exception. For example, parental aggression in animals serves an obvious long-term function (i.e., survival of offspring), but it can also be described in terms of antecedents, either proximal (e.g., perception of a prey, underlying neurophysiological mechanism) or more distal (e.g., genetic predisposition). Common sense would dictate that we follow the temporal sequence of aggression, beginning with its antecedents, then considering its expression, and finishing with its consequences for others and the self. We decided to go the opposite way, starting with the first and most obvious outcome of aggression (its consequences for others and self) and then considering elements that necessitate a more thorough examination of the problem (e.g., distal antecedents and developmental issues). This upward presentation of the different components of aggression ends with a provisional integrative representation of the most significant subtypes of aggression and their underlying processes.
Subtypes of Aggression
31
SUBTYPING AGGRESSION ON THE BASIS OF ITS CONSEQUENCES ON OTHERS AND SELF Based on Harm and Injury Harm or injury to others is the foremost indicator that an aggressive act has occurred. This is perhaps why it has been a common criterion for qualifying aggression (Berkowitz, 1981; Rule, 1974). In its most simplified form, aggression has been defined as the delivery of noxious or painful stimuli to another individual (Buss, 1961) or as a response resulting in injury (Rule, 1974) or as “damage or destruction of some goal entity” (Moyer, 1968). Some authors specified that the targeted individual ought to “be motivated to avoid such treatment,” in order to exclude cases of sadomasochism (Baron, 1977). Research has traditionally focused on physical harm, but with increasing frequency, has been including mental or psychological harm as a potential consequence of aggression, as in the case of indirect aggression or persistent bullying. A number of issues have been raised concerning the validity of harm as a criterion for assessing or qualifying aggression. First, as potential harm, either physical or psychological, seems inherent to all forms of aggression, it has little discriminatory value. In addition, assessment of harm is not only contingent upon the nature of the aggressive action (a hit by a 2-year-old may not hurt an adult), but it is also conditional on the victim’s sensibility. Some individuals may be hypersensitive to external stimulation and may be more prone to feel physically and/or mentally harmed. Assessment of harm is indeed a highly subjective matter. Even from a behaviorist perspective that targets the observable behavior of the aggressor (delivery of noxious stimuli), a judgment must be made to determine whether pain or harm has been inflicted or not. Furthermore, the harm criterion has little value for subtyping aggression in animals. Automated bite-recording devices to measure the intensity of noxious delivery by aggressive primates and rodents have been designed (Ulrich, Dulaney, Arnett, & Mueller, 1973) but the devices turned out to be too impractical and restrictive (Knutson, 1973).
Based on Intent, Motivation Descriptive models of aggression have often emphasized the cognitive/motivational antecedent of aggression. An influential paper by Feshbach (1964) was critical in establishing two major types of aggression based on harm, or, more specifically, on the motivation to harm. If injury (to a person or object) was the primary goal of the action (pleasure or satisfaction following injury being the main reward), it was labeled hostile aggression. If injury was not the main purpose and the action was executed for reward other than the pleasure of injuring, then it was termed instrumental aggression. More specifically, Feshbach (1964) defined instrumental aggression as any act that produces harm and that “is directed toward the achievement of nonaggressive goals.” These
32
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
“nonaggressive” goals include getting attention and acquiring an object or a resource. Although differentiating aggression based on the presence of hostile intention has been a dominant and relatively valid conceptual dichotomy in aggression research (Atkins, Stoff, Osborne, & Brown, 1993), it raises theoretical problems. First, aggression can be both hostile and instrumental (Bushman & Anderson, 2001; Hartup & De Wit, 1974). Second, labeling aggression as hostile is rather tautological. Are there nonhostile, friendly forms of aggression? This semantic glitch should not hinder the fact that some people may gain a considerable satisfaction or pleasure from hitting and injuring someone, whereas others may benefit more from the social or materialistic consequences of their aggressive action. It is important to note that getting pleasure from producing harm to someone may not be the most common motivational antecedent of aggression. Indeed, for many explanatory models (e.g., Archer, 1976; Berkowitz, 1993; Dollard, Doob, Miller, Mowrer, & Sears, 1939), bringing an end to a situation that is annoying and removing an irritant or a discrepancy from what is expected are frequent motivational precursors of aggression. Nonetheless, both pleasure-motivated aggression and relief-motivated aggression imply an emotional outcome or reward that is either pleasurable (positive reinforcement) or a release from a previously noxious state (negative reinforcement). Whether we call Feshbach’s categories of aggression hostile versus instrumental, annoyance-motivated versus incentive-motivated (Zillman, 1978), or emotionally rewarding versus materialistically/socially rewarding, does not really matter if an unambiguous definition is provided. Researchers with a social-interactionist perspective (Tedeschi & Felson, 1994) view aggression (which they term “coercive power”) as being motivated by interpersonal goals—to control others, to maintain justice, or to defend social identity. From the perspective of the actor, all aggression is therefore instrumental in that it pursues one of these social goals. However, these situations can just as readily be viewed as removing an irritant (i.e., negative reinforcement), and it may be confusing to regard such situations—which inevitably involve anger—as instrumental in nature. For the purposes of clarity, it is probably better to restrict the term “instrumental” to cases involving positive reinforcement of aggression by a reward unconnected with activation of the aggression system. This would highlight the parallels between such human cases as robbery and rape (Felson, 2002) and the use of conventional reinforcers such as food or water to facilitate animal aggression (e.g., Ulrich, Johnston, Richardson, & Wolff, 1963). Feshbach (1971) and Rule (1974) proposed a different taxonomy by subdividing instrumental aggression into personally motivated aggression and socially motivated aggression. Personally motivated aggression is different from hostile aggression in that the primary goal is not to hurt but to obtain reward via inflicting injury. Yet aggression is said to be socially motivated when the primary goal is to gain a social advantage. Even in the authors’ views, however, the distinction between these subtypes of aggression was problematic,
Subtypes of Aggression
33
because of the difficulty in assessing motivation, intent, or feeling. Sears (1961) suggested the term prosocial aggression to distinguish aggressive behavior considered as socially and morally acceptable. However, to the same extent that the term hostile aggression is certainly a truism, the expression “prosocial aggression” appears to be an oxymoron. Naming an aggressive act as prosocial or antisocial depends too much on individual viewpoints to be a useful categorization criterion. Physically punishing a child to prevent the occurrence of a life-threatening situation (e.g., crossing a high-traffic road) may have a justifiable intention and long-term benefits. From the child’s perspective, however, the immediate consequences of being spanked by a parent or being slapped by a peer may not differ much. Moreover, any act of terrorism or war can be considered legitimate and morally acceptable from the aggressor’s perspective. From the victim’s point of view, the immediate and harmful consequences do not depend on how good the intention was. It has been claimed that behavior should be at once intentional (motivation to injure) and harmful to be classified as being aggressive (Berkowitz, 1993; Dollard et al., 1939). As with the nature and intensity of harm, however, intent is a concept that is difficult to prove and easy to deny (Loeber & Hay, 1997). It also imposes serious limitations in investigating aggression in children or animals (Tremblay, 2000). For these reasons, although intent is certainly central to the definition of aggression, it may not be an adequate criterion in practical terms for establishing a taxonomy of aggression applicable to both animals and humans (children and adults). Intention may be also problematic in cases of indirect aggression where the perpetrator seeks to cover up his or her actions.
SUBTYPING AGGRESSION ON THE BASIS OF ITS EXPRESSION Categorizing aggression on the basis of its behavioral expression has been a popular criterion as it circumvents the pitfalls of intrinsic notions such as instinct, motivation, drive, or intent to harm. Unfortunately, too many behavioral responses that have little in common have been subsumed under the label of aggression. Display of aggressive behavior is species-typical and agedependent, as it is manifestly constrained by morphogenetic, neurophysiological, and maturational factors unique to each species and developmental stage. Topographical descriptions of aggressive interactions in animals have been performed systematically (Barnett & Marples, 1981; Grant & Mackintosh, 1963; see also Pellis, Pellis, & Foroud, Chapter 3, this volume). Although attempts have been made to extend the ethological approach in children (Blurton-Jones, 1967; McGrew, 1972) much less has been achieved regarding the operationalization of specific aggressive behavior in humans (Knutson, 1973; Tremblay, 2000). Buss (1961) was among the first to offer a behavioral taxonomy of human aggression by dichotomizing it along the physical–verbal, active–passive, and direct–indirect dimensions. The active–passive dimension is
34
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
debatable, however, because it is difficult to determine whether behavioral inactivity (e.g., not helping someone in need) was intended or not. The physical– verbal and the direct–indirect dimensions are more defendable. They are more useful when applied to humans, although animals often begin aggressive encounters with threat displays, including vocalizations (Archer, 1988). In animals, direct aggression is straightforward, involving bodily contact such as biting, hitting, or pushing. Some behavioral elements that do not involve any physical contact, such as threat and thrust (Grant & Mackintosh, 1963), are clearly direct and aggressive, as their objective is to intimidate and they are often precursors of genuine attack. In humans, Blurton-Jones (1972) also labeled as aggressive a number of nonphysical behaviors that were temporally related to other more obvious aggressive actions. In humans, however, the expression of aggression is far more complex and includes a broader assortment of direct and indirect actions. Direct forms of aggression comprise physical assault and a range of verbal behaviors that may be hostile in content or in tone. These verbal behaviors may occur with or without physical attack. In humans, direct aggression is somehow equivalent to overt aggression (Crick, 1996). Indirect aggression is at the other end of the behavioral dichotomy, consisting of actions aimed at harming others that involve some kind of social intermediary between the aggressor and the victim. The course of action is often delayed and subtle, as there is no physical contact. The psychological effects, however, may persist over a long period. This can be achieved through gossiping and ostracizing, which ultimately may damage peer relationships or social status, or through actions aiming at reducing accessibility to resources. Research on indirect aggression has grown substantially in the last few years, as this may be the most prevalent form of aggression during adolescence and adulthood (Björkqvist et al., 1992). It is the only form of aggression that may be more prevalent in females than in males (Campbell, 1999). Indirect aggression overlaps with two further categories, relational (Crick, Grotpeter, & Bigbee, 2002) and social (Galen & Underwood, 1997) aggression. Relational aggression emphasizes damage to relationships as a way of harming someone. As this can include face-to-face statements such as “I’m not friends with you anymore,” relational aggression is therefore not always direct (Coyne, Archer, & Eslea, 2004). Social aggression is a wider category that includes both relational and indirect forms, along with expressions such as negative facial expressions or body movements.
SUBTYPING AGGRESSION ON THE BASIS OF ITS ANTECEDENTS Proximal Contextual and Emotional Elicitors Proximal antecedents, either contextual or emotional, are the most frequently used criteria for discriminating subtypes of aggression, particularly in animals. A wide range of social and nonsocial contextual/situational variables have
Subtypes of Aggression
35
been used to elicit aggressive behavior in animals (Archer, 1976, 1988). Social elicitors include the presence of a prey or exposure to a same-species, samesex conspecific either in the home cage (resident–intruder paradigm) or in a novel environment. These social encounters are often combined with prior or concomitant experimental manipulations (e.g., social isolation, food deprivation, electric shock) that alter the neurobehavioral state of the potential aggressor. These predisposing factors, which influence the potency of the elicitors (Hinde, 1974), represent an important issue in aggression research. A decisive factor is the presence or absence of a threatening elicitor. When a situation is clearly threatening or perceived as threatening, an arsenal of behavioral responses is put in motion to protect the individual from pain, injury, and, possibly, death. Responses to threat range from harmless reactions, such as heightened immobility (i.e., freezing, crouching), escape, and holding off the threatening assailant with stretching of the upper limbs (boxing), to fierce attack and delivery of noxious stimuli. This constellation of responses has been traditionally subsumed under the label “agonistic behavior” (Scott & Fredericson, 1951). The notion of aggression as a response to potential threat to an animal’s welfare is central to theories that conceive of aggression as an aversion, whereby the animal is motivated to avoid a situation. This contrasts with an appetite, whereby the animal is motivated to approach or seek out a situation (Craig, 1928). Aversion-based theories seek to identify the mechanism through which animals or humans detect threats, and they include the frustration– aggression hypothesis (Dollard et al., 1939), the discrepancy model of animal aggression (Archer, 1976), and the theory of threatened egotism (Baumeister, Smart, & Boden, 1996). Pain is another “emotional” antecedent of aggressive behavior. Animals exposed to painful stimulation (e.g., electrical shocks, sudden heat, bite) will start fighting against each other or will attack an inanimate object if tested alone (Archer, 1989/1990; Ulrich & Azrin, 1962). Blanchard and Blanchard (1981) have convincingly argued that such pain-induced aggression is analogous to fear-induced defensive aggression. Archer (1989/1990) suggested that, although this is the case in laboratory setups involving repeated painful shocks, an isolated single painful stimulus may under natural conditions evoke anger-induced offensive aggression. Overall, aggressive behavior can be generated by a variety of external stimuli that are threatening or painful, and these stimuli activate, to different degrees, both the peripheral and the central nervous systems. In pain-induced aggression, activation of the nociceptors and/or thermal receptors sets in motion neural pathways that control the expression of aggressive behavior, and, in this case, the threshold for fear is easily reached. Then, determining whether aggression is mediated by fear or anger will depend on which brain regions are activated during attack. Under threatening circumstances, aggression may be offensive or defensive (Blanchard & Blanchard, 1989), that is, anger or fear motivated. In humans, responses to provocation broadly similar to threats in animals have
36
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
been termed reactive aggression. Thus, reactive aggression is an impulsive, negatively valenced act displayed in response to a threat or provocation (Dodge, & Coie, 1987; Vitaro, Gendreau, Tremblay, & Oligny, 1998). It stems from the frustration–aggression hypothesis that viewed aggression as a “primordial reaction . . . whenever pleasure-seeking or pain-avoiding behavior is blocked” (Dollard et al., 1939, p. 21). Interestingly, it is not so much contextual stimuli per se that determine whether aggression will be labeled as reactive, but the perception that the individual has and what he or she makes of it. Indeed, an interesting finding in human research is that reactively aggressive children more readily perceive an ambiguous situation as threatening or hostile (Dodge & Coie, 1987; Vitaro, Brendgen, & Tremblay, 2002). This attributional/perceptual bias and behavioral hypersensitivity to what typically should be mild, nonthreatening stimulation is reminiscent of what is observed in animals after prolonged social isolation (Gendreau, Gariépy, Petitto, & Lewis, 1998) or after successive defeat experiences (Keeney & Hogg, 1999). These animal paradigms may be more relevant to human reactive aggression than paradigms using clear life-threatening conditions. Conversely, proactive aggression occurs with more forethought and does not seem to be associated with any apparent proximal elicitor. It is more controlled, more premeditated, and less emotionally reactive. It can be understood in terms of social learning, as a result of previous external reinforcement (Bandura, 1973; Patterson & Cobb, 1973). Discriminant and convergent validity of these subtypes of aggression has been provided by an increasing number of empirical reports (Dodge & Coie, 1987; Poulin & Boivin, 2000; Pulkkinen, 1996; Vitaro et al., 1998, 2002). Contrary to the dichotomy hostile–instrumental, which is determined by the nature of the motivation (goal is to hurt vs. goal is to gain), reactive and proactive forms of aggression are differentiated by the presence of a prior provocative event and the short delay before enactment. The distinction between reactive and proactive aggression, however, is problematic, as it depends on no provocation being identified, and what constitutes a provocation varies considerably between individuals. Looking at someone the wrong way may be classed as a provocation in a subculture where everyone is on the lookout for signs of disrespect. Having said this, the category proactive aggression (i.e., aggression without obvious provocation or threat) may alert us to cases, primarily among young men, where fights are sought for no apparent reason other than to inflict a physical defeat on another person.
Brain Mechanisms The use of psychic or inner states to qualify aggression is not necessary when examining the direct and observable effects of lesions and stimulations of specific areas of the brain. The brains of humans and other mammals share many structures, pathways, and neurochemical properties, reflecting the long and progressive transformation of the brain during evolution. In the last four de-
Subtypes of Aggression
37
cades an increasing body of evidence has accumulated describing the role of specific neural circuits in the expression of different types of aggression. Numerous sites within the neocortex and subcortical structures have been identified as central in mediating aggressive behavior. Moyer (1968, 1973) was among the first to relate specific neural circuitries and distinctive neuroendocrinological status to subtypes of aggression. Particular attention was given to the amygdaloid complex, the various hypothalamic nuclei, and other parts of the so-called limbic system (e.g., septum, cingulate cortex). Moyer (1973) argued that each of the subtypes of aggression that he had previously identified (except for instrumental aggression) had its own set of neural circuits. Functions associated with the expression of specific forms of aggressive behavior have indeed been localized in the brain (Valzelli, 1981; Panksepp, 1998). As Panksepp pointed out, however, there are more subtypes of aggression based on the proximal contextual antecedents than there are subtypes based on neural processes. In other words, similar brain circuitry may allow different types of aggression to be expressed; what differs are the eliciting circumstances and the perceptual processing. As we will see, this has a significant impact on our attempt to produce a parsimonious taxonomy of aggression. Panksepp (1998) denoted distinct neural circuitry for no more than three subtypes of aggression in the brains of rats and cats: predatory aggression, affective or rage-like aggression (which may coincide with defensive aggression identified by Blanchard & Blanchard, 1989); and intermale aggression (what the Blanchards called offensive aggression). So-called predatory aggression (or quiet-biting attack in the laboratory) can be generated by stimulation of the dorsolateral hypothalamus and involves activation of the ventral part of the periaqueductal gray. It is believed to be primarily mediated by what Panksepp (1998) termed the seeking or the appetitive motivational system of the brain. If so, this contrasts with the emphasis on aversive motivation in most theories of aggression (see above). This system involves not only the lateral hypothalamus but also most structures that are innervated by neurons releasing dopamine and serotonin. Abnormal development of the prefrontal cortex has been associated with antisocial personality disorder (Raine, Lencz, Bihrle, LaCasse, & Colletti, 2000), and people diagnosed with this disorder have been shown to display more proactive forms of aggression (Chase, O’Leary, & Heyman, 2001). This would be consistent with their seeking out situations in which to display aggressive actions. In contrast, the affective subtype of aggression is mediated by different and more primitive (Archer, 1988) interactive neural circuits, what Panksepp (1998) termed the fear system and the rage system. Affective aggression involves the ventrolateral–medial hypothalamus, several amygdaloid nuclei, and the dorsal part of the periaqueductal gray, to cite just a few (Gregg & Siegel, 2001). It is important to note that this subcortical circuitry operates relatively independently of neocortical input. The neurophysiological basis of intermale (or intrasexual) aggression has not been well established. Panksepp (1998) mentioned that the brain circuitry of intermale aggression may interact with
38
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
both the seeking and rage systems, but is somehow relatively independent. The evidence for this is clearly not overwhelming, but Panksepp (1998) reported that brain lesions that impair predatory and affective aggression do not affect intermale aggression. Obviously, this is an extremely simplified account of very complex brain mechanisms involving many more structures and neurotransmitter systems (see Gregg & Siegel, 2001). Although primitive forms of aggression, such as those elicited by stimuli perceived as painful, threatening or annoying, may be processed through brain circuitry highly similar to that of other species, the sophistication and diversification of aggression in humans necessarily implies the existence of brain processes unique to our species. Our neocortex, which does not complete its maturation before adulthood (Giedd et al., 1999), plays an important inhibitory role in more primitive brain structures, therefore controlling the expression of social/emotional reactivity. The gradual transformation of the brain during development may explain the progressive shift in the expression of aggression from early childhood to adulthood, that is, direct, reactive, and physical forms of aggressive behavior being gradually substituted by more indirect, controlled, and nonphysical forms (see Vaillancourt, Chapter 8, this volume).
Developmental Issues What differentiates humans from animals is not only the increased complexity of the human brain, the advanced cognitive skills and social world, but the longer developmental period that is necessary for organizing behavior (Cairns, 1979; Hinde, 1974). As mentioned in the preceding section, the expression of aggression changes throughout ontogeny, with physical aggression reaching its peak in early childhood (Tremblay et al., 1999) and relationally oriented forms of aggression gradually emerging in late childhood/early adolescence (Björkqvist et al., 1992). Hartup (1974) observed that aggression develops from being first object-oriented (instrumental) to being more person-oriented (hostile) aggression (see also Caplan, Vespo, Pedersen, & Hay, 1991). Hinde (1992) proposed one of the few categorizations of aggression exclusive to childhood. He discriminated instrumental (or specific) aggression (aiming at gaining or retrieving an object or situation), teasing aggression (aggression unrelated to acquiring a specific object or situation), defensive aggression (in response to an attack), and game aggression (that results from rough-and-tumble play). Hinde suggested that childhood instrumental and defensive aggression were somehow equivalent to reactive–impulsive aggression as observed in adulthood. Teasing aggression had its adult counterpart under the label of “spontaneous aggression.” No further distinction between impulsive and spontaneous aggression and no adult correspondence for game aggression were provided. A social–developmental analysis of the functional and expressive characteristics of aggression from early childhood to adulthood is indispensable for
Subtypes of Aggression
39
our understanding of the different ontogenetic pathways to more sophisticated forms of aggression. Hinde’s distinction between subtypes of aggression in childhood was clearly a step toward establishing a developmental topology of aggression. One may question, however, the need to use different taxonomical labels for children and adult aggression, especially when there is correspondence between the different subtypes. In addition, characterizing one form of aggression as impulsive and another as spontaneous is confusing. Finally, game aggression (or rough-and-tumble play) is clearly motivationally distinct from other forms of aggression (Blurton-Jones, 1972; Smith, 1974). In the end, we need to agree on a general taxonomy that is applicable throughout development, not only to a specific period. Once this is achieved, the developmental trajectory of the different subtypes of aggression can be investigated. The onset and stability of aggression during ontogeny has been an important issue in developmental and clinical sciences. Moffitt (1993) proposed a developmental taxonomy of conduct disorders based on the onset and persistence of antisocial behavior (which relates to aggression). Specifically, conduct disorders could be described as life-course persistent (behavioral problems start during childhood and persist throughout childhood up to adolescence and adulthood) or as adolescence-limited (when problems emerge and end during adolescence) Discriminating between early- versus late-onset conduct disorders has been a valuable clinical classification (American Psychiatric Association, 1994). The relationship between individual development and the transformation of aggression over time in boys and girls, in both expression and function, is central to the science of aggression. We now recognize the gender-dependent development and use of physical aggression (Tremblay et al., 1999) and the gradual emergence of hostile (Caplan et al., 1991; Hartup, 1974) and indirect (Björkqvist et al., 1992) aggression. Similarly, reactive aggression seems to appear first (as tantrums) or may be a more prevalent form of aggression early on (Loeber & Hay, 1997). However, children prone to display proactive forms of aggression may be more at risk of exhibiting delinquent activities in adolescence (Vitaro et al., 2002). Finally, recent evidence suggests that reactive and proactive aggression in boys and girls may have different etiological antecedents (Connor, Steingard, Anderson, & Melloni, 2003). Many important issues remain to be investigated regarding the onset and developmental trajectory of the different forms of aggression across gender and sociocultural background.
AN INTEGRATIVE MODEL OF AGGRESSION The goal of this chapter is to provide a summary of conceptual and theoretical issues related to the categorization of different subtypes of aggression in humans and animals. Finding an appropriate taxonomy seems to be a recurrent problem in aggression research. A taxonomy is, by definition, a classification based on similarities of a specified characteristic. Suggesting a taxonomy for
40
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
subtypes of aggression based on a single criterion or for a single species is one thing, but conceiving one that encompasses the multiple ontogenetic and phylogenetic aspects of this phenomenon is more challenging. Aggression is not a behavior, or a set of genes, or a brain mechanism. It is a complex social phenomenon that conveys so many meanings, takes so many forms, results from so many proximal and distal antecedents, and has so many consequences that a universal taxonomy seems an unachievable puzzle. It has identifiable underlying brain processes, but those are dependent upon context, emotional state, and previous learning experience (reinforcement). It is important to note that aggression is a phenomenon in constant transformation, both phylogenetically and ontogenetically. Hinde (1974) summarized well the challenge of elaborating a taxonomy for subtypes of aggression in both humans and animals: “The range validity of any generalizations we make is inversely related to their precision. As more diverse phenomena are included within our category of aggressive behavior, our generalizations inevitably become less precise” (p. 4). The primary problem with respect to categorizing aggression into different subtypes is to select a parsimonious set of criteria that integrate most forms of aggression. In this regard, some criteria, despite being relevant to our better understanding of aggression, do not appear to be essential for establishing a categorization. Harm to others, for instance, either physically or psychologically induced, may be the first, more expeditious consequence of aggression, but it has little taxonomic value. Therefore, we settled on a simplified taxonomic model that encompasses the most significant and discriminative features of aggression (Figure 2.2). These include the antecedent (to determine whether aggression is proactive or reactive), the expression (to determine whether aggression is direct or indirect), and the function (to determine whether aggression was produced only to hurt or to benefit socially). Other important elements of aggression, such as distal antecedents (past experience, biological or genetic predisposition), aggressor’s emotional–perceptual bias, basic neurobiological mechanisms, and learning, were also integrated. The first step in identifying the form of aggression should be to determine whether there is a proximal contextual elicitor. If there is no apparent proximal antecedent, then aggression is proactive. This form of aggression is primarily controlled by the neocortex, more particularly the prefrontal cortex and the descending corticolimbic pathways. When a proximal antecedent can be identified, then aggression is said to be reactive. This behavioral output involves various motivational/emotional states (e.g., fear, pain, anger, or annoyance) that are under the control of subcortical, primarily limbic, structures. In reactive aggression, perception of the eliciting stimulus is the key for judging the pathological nature of the response. Hypersensitivity to certain contexts and stimulations may indicate heightened anxiety or heightened fearfulness (paranoia). Both proactive and reactive aggression can be expressed directly or indirectly, and they can target either the source of stimulation or a substitute person/object (displaced aggression). Then the aggressive action may pro-
Subtypes of Aggression
41
FIGURE 2.2. A simplified taxonomical model of aggression based on context, neuroaffective processes, consequences on self, and learning.
vide a pleasurable reward from harming (hostile aggression), a social/materialistic reward (instrumental aggression), or both. Following these consequences, learning (reinforcement) will take place and certainly influence individual development.
CONCLUDING REMARKS Aggression is always a timely topic. The news media provide an incessant flow of information on the shocking nature of human behavior. We were just finishing this chapter when we heard the news that three teenage girls were facing charges of attempted murder for allegedly trying to poison a classmate by adding copper sulfate, a highly toxic substance, to her drink. What aggressive category does poisoning fit into? It undoubtedly relates to physical harm, but without a clear, direct physical action. It is a physical action but with an indirect, concealed behavioral twist. Although it is a planned, proactive-like aggressive action, it is likely a retaliatory response to some prior event or situation. This is a good example of the difficulty in fitting every act of aggression into a definite category or model. Do we need more research to produce a better taxonomy? Reaching a consensus on this issue may not be as necessary as continuing our thorough analysis of the wide range of proximal and distal
42
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
forces that influence the development and expression of aggression (Cairns, 1979). It is important to refine our knowledge of the many genetic, biological, and social factors that induce, facilitate, or maintain aggression throughout development. Eventually, a universally agreed-upon taxonomy, at once parsimonious and comprehensive and integrating both animal and human aggression, may emerge.
REFERENCES American Psychiatric Association. (1994). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (4th ed.). Washington, DC: Author. Archer, J. (1976). The organization of aggression and fear in vertebrates. In P. P. G. Bateson & P. Klopfer (Eds.), Perspectives in ethology (Vol. 2, pp. 231–298). New York: Plenum Press. Archer, J. (1988). The behavioural biology of aggression. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. Archer, J. (1989/1990). Pain-induced aggression: An ethological perspective. Current Psychology: Research and Reviews, 8, 298–306. Archer, J., & Browne, K. (1989). Concepts and approaches to the study of aggression. In J. Archer & K. Browne (Eds.), Human aggression: Naturalistic approaches (pp. 3– 24). London: Routledge. Ardrey, R. (1966). The territorial imperative. New York: Atheneum. Atkins, M. S., Stoff, D. M., Osborne, M. L., & Brown, K. (1993). Distinguishing instrumental and hostile aggression: Does it make a difference? Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 21, 355–365. Bainton, R. J., Tsai L. T., Singh, C. M., Moore, M. S., Neckameyer, W. S., & Heberlein, U. (2000). Dopamine modulates acute responses to cocaine, nicotine and ethanol in Drosophila. Current Biology, 10, 187–194. Bandura, A. (1973). Social learning theory and aggression. In J. F. Knutson (Ed.), The control of aggression: Implications from basic research (pp. 201–250). Chicago: Aldine. Barnett, S. A., & Marples, T. G. (1981). The “threat posture” of wild rats: A social signal or an anthropomorphic assumption? In P. F. Brain & D. Benton (Eds.), Multidisciplinary approaches to aggression research (pp. 39–52). Amsterdam: Elsevier/North Holland Biomedical Press. Baron, R. A. (1977). Human aggression. New York: Plenum Press. Baumeister, R. F., Smart, L., & Boden, J. M. (1996). Relation of threatened egotism to violence and aggression: The dark side of high self-esteem. Psychological Review, 103, 5–33. Berkowitz, L. (1981). The concept of aggression. In P. F. Brain & D. Benton (Eds.), Multidisciplinary approaches to aggression research (pp. 3–15). Amsterdam: Elsevier/ North Holland Biomedical Press. Berkowitz, L. (1993). Aggression: Its causes, consequences and control. New York: McGraw-Hill. Björkqvist, K., Lagerspetz, K. M. J., & Kaukiainen, A. (1992). Do girls manipulate and boys fight?: Developmental trends in regard to direct and indirect aggression. Aggressive Behavior, 18, 117–127.
Subtypes of Aggression
43
Blanchard, D. C., & Blanchard, R. J. (1989). Experimental animal models of aggression: What do they say about human behavior? In J. Archer & K. Browne (Eds.), Human aggression: Naturalistic approaches (pp. 94–121). London: Routledge. Blanchard, R. J., & Blanchard, D. C. (1981). The organization and modelling of animal aggression. In P. F. Brain & D. Benton (Eds.), The biology of aggression (pp. 529– 562). Rockville, MD: Sijhoff & Noordhoff. Blurton-Jones, N. G. (1967). An ethological study of some aspects of social behaviour of children in nursery school. In D. Morris (Ed.), Primate ethology (pp. 347–368). Chicago: Aldine. Blurton-Jones, N. G. (1972). Categories of child–child interaction. In N.G. Blurton Jones (Ed.), Ethological studies of child behaviour (pp. 97–127). London: Cambridge University Press. Bushman, B. J., & Anderson, C. A. (2001). Is it time to pull the plug on the hostile vs. instrumental aggression dichotomy? Psychological Review, 108, 273–279. Buss, A. H. (1961). The psychology of aggression. New York: Wiley. Bygott, J. D. (1972). Cannibalism among wild chimpanzees. Nature, 238, 410–411. Cairns, R. B. (1979). Social development: The origins and plasticity of interchanges. San Francisco: Freeman. Campbell, A. (1999). Staying alive: Evolution, culture, and women’s intrasexual aggression. Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 22, 203–252. Caplan, M., Vespo, J. E., Pedersen, J., & Hay, D. F. (1991). Conflict and resolution in small groups of one- and two-year-olds. Child Development, 62, 1513–1524. Chase, K. A., O’Leary, K. D., & Heyman, R. E. (2001). Categorizing partner-violent men within the reactive-proactive typology model. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 69, 567–572. Chen, S., Lee, A. Y., Bowens, N. M., Huber, R., & Kravitz E. A. (2002). Fighting fruit flies: A model system for the study of aggression. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science USA, 99, 5664–5668. Connor, D. F., Steingard, R. J., Anderson, J. J., & Melloni, R. H., Jr. (2003). Gender differences in reactive and proactive aggression. Child Psychiatry and Human Development, 33, 279–294. Coyne, S. M., Archer, J., & Eslea, M. (2004). We’re not friends anymore! Unless . . . ”: The frequency and harmfulness of relational, indirect and social aggression. Manuscript submitted for publication. Craig, W. (1928). Why do animals fight ? International Journal of Ethics, 31, 264–278. Crick, N. R. (1996). The role of overt aggression, relational aggression, and prosocial behavior in the prediction of children’s future social adjustment. Child Development, 67, 2317–2327. Crick, N. R., Grotpeter, J. K., & Bigbee, M. A. (2002). Relationally and physically aggressive children’s intent attributions and feelings of distress for relational and instrumental peer provocations. Child Development, 73,1134–1142. Dodge, K. A., & Coie, J. D. (1987). Social-information-processing factors in reactive and proactive aggression in children’s peer groups. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 53, 1146–1158. Dollard, J., Doob, L. Miller, N., Mowrer, O., & Sears, R. (1939). Frustration and aggression. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press. Felson, R. B. (2002). Violence and gender reexamined. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.
44
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
Feshbach, S. (1964). The function of aggression and the regulation of aggressive drive. Psychological Review, 71, 257–272. Feshbach, S. (1971). Dynamics and morality of violence and aggression. American Psychologist, 26, 281–292. Galen, B. R., & Underwood, M. K. (1997). A developmental investigation of social aggression among children. Developmental Psychology, 33, 589–600. Gendreau, P. L., Gariépy, J. L., Petitto, J. M., & Lewis, M. H. (1997). D1 dopamine receptor mediation of social and nonsocial emotional reactivity in mice: Effects of housing and strain difference in motor activity. Behavioral Neuroscience, 111, 424–434. Gendreau, P. L., Petitto, J. M., Gariépy, J. L., & Lewis, M. H. (1998). D2-like dopamine receptor mediation of social-emotional reactivity in a mouse model of anxiety: Strain and experience effects. Neuropsychopharmacology, 18, 210–221. Giedd, J. N., Blumenthal, J., Jeffries, N. O., Castellanos, F. X., Liu, H., Zijdenbos, A., Paus, T., Evans, A. C., & Rapoport, J. L. (1999). Brain development during childhood and adolescence: A longitudinal MRI study. Nature Neuroscience, 2, 861– 863. Grant, E. C., & Mackintosh, J. H. (1963). A comparison of the social postures of some common laboratory rodents. Behaviour, 21, 246–259. Gregg, T. R., & Siegel, A. (2001). Brain structures and neurotransmitters regulating aggression in cats: Implications for human aggression. Progress in Neuro-Psychopharmacology and Biological Psychiatry, 25, 91–140. Hartup, W. W. (1974). Aggression in childhood: Developmental perspectives. American Psychologist, 29, 336–341. Hartup, W. W., & De Wit, J. (1974). The development of aggression: Problems and perspectives. In J. De Wit & W. W. Hartup (Eds.), Determinants and origins of aggressive behavior (pp. 595–620). The Hague: Mouton. Hinde, R. A. (1974). The study of aggression: Determinants, consequences, goals and functions. In J. De Wit & W. W. Hartup (Eds.), Determinants and origins of aggressive behavior (pp. 3–27). The Hague: Mouton. Hinde, R. A. (1992). Some complexities in aggressive behaviour. In A. Fraczek & H. Zumkley (Eds.), Socialization and aggression (pp. 3–10). Berlin: Springer-Verlag. Johnson, R. N. (1972). Aggression in man and animals. Philadelphia: Saunders. Karli, P. (1956). The Norway rat’s killing response to the while mouse: An experimental analysis. Behaviour, 10, 81–103. Keeney, A. J., & Hogg, S. (1999). Behavioural consequences of repeated social defeat in the mouse: Preliminary evaluation of a potential animal model of depression. Behavioral Pharmacology, 10, 753–764. Knutson, J. F. (1973). Aggression as manipulatable behavior. In J. F. Knutson (Ed.), The control of aggression: Implications from basic research. (pp. 253–295). Chicago: Aldine. Loeber, R., & Hay, D. (1997). Key issues in the development of aggression and violence from childhood to early adulthood. Annual Review of Psychology, 48, 371–410. McGrew, W. C. (1972). An ethological study of children’s behaviour. London: Academic Press. Moffitt, T. E. (1993). Adolescent-limited and life-course-persistent antisocial behavior: A developmental taxonomy. Psychological Review, 100, 674–701. Moyer, K. E. (1968). Kinds of aggression and their physiological basis. Communications in Behavioral Biology, 2, 65–87.
Subtypes of Aggression
45
Moyer, K. E. (1973). The physiological inhibition of hostile behavior. In J. F. Knutson (Ed.), The control of aggression: Implications from basic research (pp. 9–38). Chicago: Aldine. Panksepp, J. (1998). Affective neuroscience: The foundations of human and animal emotions. New York: Oxford University Press. Patterson, G. R., & Cobb, J. A. (1973). Stimulus control for classes of noxious behavior. In J. F. Knutson (Ed.), The control of aggression: implications from basic research (pp. 145–199). Chicago: Aldine. Poulin F., & Boivin, M. (2000). Reactive and proactive aggression: Evidence of a two-factor model. Psychological Assessment, 12, 115–122. Pulkkinen, L. (1987). Offensive and defensive aggression in humans: A longitudinal perspective. Aggressive Behavior, 13, 197–212. Pulkkinen, L. (1996). Proactive and reactive aggression in early adolescence as precursors to anti- and prosocial behavior in young adults. Aggressive Behavior, 22, 241– 257. Raine, A., Lencz, T., Bihrle, S., LaCasse, L., & Colletti, P. (2000). Reduced prefrontal gray matter volume and reduced autonomic activity in antisocial personality disorder. Archives of General Psychiatry, 57, 119–127. Rule, B. G. (1974). The hostile and instrumental functions of human aggression. In J. De Wit & W. W. Hartup (Eds.), Determinants and origins of aggressive behavior (pp. 121–141). The Hague: Mouton. Scott, J. P., & Fredericson, E. (1951). The causes of fighting in mice and rats. Physiological Zoology, 24, 273–309. Sears, R. R. (1961). Relation of early socialization experiences to aggression in early childhood. Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 63, 466–492. Smith, P. K. (1974). Aggression in a preschool playgroup: Effects of varying physical resources. In J. De Wit & W. W. Hartup (Eds.), Determinants and origins of aggressive behavior (pp. 97–105). The Hague: Mouton. Tedeschi, J. T., & Felson, R. B. (1994). Violence, aggression, and coercive actions. Washington, DC : American Psychological Association. Tremblay, R. E. (2000). The development of aggressive behaviour during childhood: What have we learned in the past century? International Journal of Behavioral Development, 24, 129–141. Tremblay, R. E., Japel, C., Pérusse, D., Boivin, M., Zoccolillo, M., Montplaisir, J., & McDuff, P. (1999). The search for the age of “onset” of physical aggression: Rousseau and Bandura revisited. Criminal Behavior and Mental Health, 9, 24– 39. Ulrich, R. E., & Azrin, N. H. (1962). Reflexive fighting in response to aversive stimulation. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 5, 511–520. Ulrich, R. E, Dulaney, S., Arnett, M., & Mueller, K. (1973). An experimental analysis of nonhuman and human aggression. In J. F. Knutson (Ed.), The control of aggression: Implications from basic research (pp. 79–111). Chicago: Aldine. Ulrich, R. E., Johnston, M., Richardson, J., & Wolff, P. (1963). The operant conditioning of fighting behaviour in rats. Psychological Record, 13, 465–470. Valzelli, L. (1981). Psychobiology of aggression and violence. New York: Raven Press. Vitaro, F., Brendgen, M., & Tremblay, R. E. (2002). Reactively and proactively aggressive children: Antecedents and subsequent characteristics. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 43, 495–505.
46
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
Vitaro, F., Gendreau, P. L., Tremblay, R. E., & Oligny, P. (1998). Reactive and proactive aggression differentially predict later conduct problems. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 39, 377–385. Wilson, E. O. (1980). Sociobiology: The abridged edition. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Zillman, D. (1978). Hostility and aggression. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
THEFighting Play DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
3 Play Fighting Aggression, Affiliation, and the Development of Nuanced Social Skills S ERGIO M. P ELLIS, V IVIEN C. P ELLIS, and A FRA F OROUD
In traditional New Guinean society, if two men—strangers to each other— were to meet on a path between their respective villages, they would then likely, if they wished to avoid bloodshed, begin to list all the people to whom they were related in the hope of discovering some common ground between them (Diamond, 1997). Although having the skill to win in a potentially aggressive encounter is important, this New Guinean practice illustrates that having the skill to avoid unnecessary aggression may be just as important. It is becoming clear that aggression is but a part of a larger tool kit for gaining advantage in a complex social world. This appears to be true not just for humans, but for many social mammals (de Waal & Aureli, 2000). In such a world, knowing who and when to fight becomes important, and thus so does having the cognitive skills to gather the information required to make the appropriate decisions. Placing aggression into a broader social context has implications for the understanding of the developmental processes that shape aggression. The problem lies not only in learning how and when to use aggression, but also in knowing how to assess the situation so as to determine whether a nonaggressive approach would be a more suitable solution. In this chapter we show that play fighting can provide a vehicle for the development of such skills. Play fighting resembles serious fighting in that the partners compete for access to some advantage. Most often, this advantage takes the form of biting or striking another individual on a particular body target (Aldis, 1975). The targets competed over during play fighting can be those that in adulthood are 47
48
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
used in conspecific aggression, sex, or predation. Despite these differences in targets, all forms of play fighting have play-typical rules of attack and defense in common (Pellis & Pellis, 1998a). In contrast, during conspecific aggressive encounters, in the early stages of sexual encounters and in predatory encounters, the opponents follow the rules of attack and defense typical of serious fighting. For play fighting to remain playful, it needs to follow the 50:50 rule (Aldis, 1975; Altmann, 1962). That is, each pairmate has to win close to 50% of the playful encounters. Such a win:loss ratio requires that the rules of attack and defense differ from those that apply to serious fighting (Pellis & Pellis, 1998a). When an attack is launched during a serious fight, the attacking animal has to guard against retaliation from the opponent. Typically, in order to do so, the attacker simultaneously incorporates some defensive tactic into its attack, which limits the defender’s opportunity to counterattack (Pellis, 1997). Similarly, when defending itself against a serious attack, the defender uses an intensity in its defense that reduces the likelihood of a successful penetration by the attacker (Pellis, 1997). In contrast, during play fighting, the attacker rarely incorporates defensive maneuvers in its attack, thus facilitating successful counterattacks by the defender (Pellis & Pellis, 1998a). In addition, when defending itself against a playful attack, the defender will use an intensity of defense that is lower than that in serious fights, increasing the likelihood of a successful contact by the attacker (Pellis & Pellis, 1998a). That is, in play fighting, the tactics of attack and defense are decoupled so as to ensure that each animal can successfully contact the partner. This contrasts sharply with serious fighting, in which an animal may deliver injurious, or even lethal, attacks if the opponent leaves its target exposed (Blanchard, Blanchard, Takahashi, & Kelly, 1977; Geist, 1971; Pellis & Pellis, 1992). In the following text, we show that given its rule structure, play fighting can provide fertile ground for learning a variety of social skills. Detailed studies of the development of play fighting in rats (Pellis, 2002b) provide a model for understanding how play fighting may be used for sharpening the social skills needed to straddle the subtle divide between competition and cooperation effectively (Pellis, 2002a).
PLAY FIGHTING IN RATS1 In rats, play fighting involves attack and defense of the nape (Figure 3.1). Successful contact with the nape involves gently rubbing the nape with the nose (Pellis & Pellis, 1987; Siviy & Panksepp, 1987). Nape contact is a target typical of adult sexual encounters (Pellis, 1988, 1993), whereas agonistic attacks involve bites directed at the lower dorsum or the face (Blanchard et al., 1977; Pellis, 1997). To defend themselves against playful nape contact, rats use the same tactics of defense that are used in serious aggression, but modify them to match both the differences in targets (Pellis & Pellis, 1987) and the differences
Play Fighting
49
FIGURE 3.1. A sequence of play fighting is shown for a pair of 31-day-old rats. Note that the attacking rat (on the left), lunges toward its partner’s nape. The defending rat avoids nape contact by turning to supine. From this on-top/on-bottom position, both rats make attempts to contact each other’s napes. Adapted from Pellis and Pellis (1987). Copyright 1987 by Wiley. Adapted by permission.
in the rules of execution of those tactics (Pellis & Pellis, 1998a). Even though most common in the juvenile phase (Meaney & Stewart, 1981; Panksepp, 1981; Thor & Holloway, 1984), play fighting in rats persists well into young adulthood (Adams & Boice, 1983, 1989; Pellis & Pellis, 1991b). Indeed, play fighting between adults occurs among many mammalian species, in both sexual and nonsexual encounters (Pellis & Iwaniuk, 1999b, 2000). However, whether the context is sexual or nonsexual, such play fighting appears to be used to assess and manipulate the other animal, be it human or nonhuman (Breuggeman, 1978; Pellis & Iwaniuk, 1999b). When it occurs in subadults and adults, play fighting appears to be used in two general contexts—for social bonding and for social testing (Pellis & Pellis, 1996; Pellis & Iwaniuk, 1999b, 2000; Smith, Fantella, & Pellis, 1999). Social bonding may include courtship and pair bonding, as well as nonsexual social affiliation. Social testing most typically involves some form of jostling for social status. The distribution of these functions vary across species, with some species using them only for affiliation, some using them only for dominance testing, and some using them for both (Pellis, 2002a). In rats, play fighting is used for both these purposes (Pellis, Pellis, & McKenna, 1993; Smith et al., 1999). It should be noted that in rats, as in many other mammals, play fighting is more frequent among males (Pellis & Pellis, 1990, 1997), although preferences for which sex is the most attractive as a play partner may change during
50
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
development (Meaney & Stewart, 1981). With regard to the social uses of play fighting, only male rats show the context-specific modulation of content that is consistent with such uses (Pellis, Field, Smith, & Pellis, 1997). In some other species of mammals, females also appear to use play fighting for social assessment and manipulation (Pellis, 2002a; Pellis & Iwaniuk, 2000). For the present purposes, in this discussion of rats, males are the focus of consideration. Play fighting in rats has several features useful for the analysis of the development of social skills. First, the difference in targets between play fighting and serious fighting makes it easy to differentiate between these two forms of fighting. This is very useful for identifying cases where play fights escalate into serious fights. By using a switch in target as a marker, it was found that playful encounters escalate into serious ones if one of the partners breaks the playtypical rules of attack and defense. That is, if one of the pair stops allowing the partner an opportunity for reciprocal contact, the partner may switch to an aggressive attack (Pellis & Pellis, 1998a). Second, adults use play fighting in clearly functional contexts, allowing us to identify the social skills needed and so evaluate play fighting earlier in development to ascertain whether the opportunity to acquire such skills is present. To explain what those skills entail, we describe the social uses of play fighting among adult male rats. This understanding then sets the stage for interpreting the developmental changes in play fighting present in this species.
THE ADULT USES OF PLAY FIGHTING Within a colony, adult male rats form a dominance hierarchy (Blanchard & Blanchard, 1990; Calhoun, 1962; Flannery & Lore, 1977) in which subordinates initiate more playful encounters with dominants than they do with each other (Pellis et al., 1993). When playfully contacted by a dominant, subordinates are more likely to roll over onto their backs, a response typical of juveniles (Panksepp, 1981; Pellis & Pellis, 1987), whereas when contacted by another subordinate, they are more likely to remain standing and push against the attacker with their flanks (Pellis et al., 1993), a response typical of a dominant male (Pellis & Pellis, 1991a, 1992). In the absence of dominance relationships, postpubertal males are more likely to stand and push than to roll over to supine (Pellis & Pellis, 1990; Smith, Field, Forgie, & Pellis, 1996; Smith, Forgie, & Pellis, 1998, Smith et al.,1999). Thus, the increased soliciting of playful contact by subordinates toward dominants, and the juvenile-like response toward those dominants, suggests that the play fighting is used as a means of maintaining “friendly” relations with dominants (Pellis et al., 1993). However, not all subordinates are equally obsequious. The greater the dominance asymmetry between pairmates, the more juvenile-like the playful responses by the subordinate (Pellis & Pellis, 1992).
Play Fighting
51
Indeed, it is those pairmates that are the least asymmetrical in their play relations that are the most likely to escalate the playful encounter into a serious fight (Pellis & Pellis, 1991a). Similarly, when male rats that are unfamiliar with each are placed into a neutral arena, it is the dominant–dominant combination that is the most likely to escalate into a serious fight (Smith et al., 1999). Close inspection of these escalations suggests that the play fighting preceding the serious fight is “rougher.” These observations also suggest that when animals are testing each other in regard to their opponent’s capability to maintain or gain a position of superior dominance, the play can then be escalated into a quasi-aggressive intensity. Therefore, there are two extremes in the style of play that are available to an individual—a gentler form, which is seen when a subordinate is maintaining familiarity with a dominant, and a rougher form, which is seen when one rat is probing another one for its weaknesses. As previously described, these differences in play intensity among adult male rats can be explicitly converted into formal rules of engagement and can provide a rat with the basis for judging how such play can be used to assess and manipulate its partner. For example, when a subordinate rat uses play fighting as a means of social bonding with the dominant male in the colony, it bends the 50:50 rule in the dominant’s favor, whereas when a subordinate uses play fighting to probe the dominant for weakness, or when it encounters an unfamiliar rat, it bends the rule in its own favor. In the latter case, the rat can assess how much of a deviation from equality the opponent will tolerate before retaliating aggressively. A simple rule of thumb may operate in such a scenario. If the dominant or unfamiliar rat tolerates the bending of the 50:50 rule in the opponent’s favor, the opponent may then bend the rule further, until the relative status of the pair is reversed. However, if the dominant starts to respond forcefully, there is still time for the opponent to back down before the encounter escalates into a serious fight. Many primates and carnivores that have affiliative signals that can be used to indicate playful intention may have a capacity for greater flexibility along this playful–serious gradient, as such signals can be used to diffuse unwanted escalations (see Bekoff, 1995; Boulton, 1994; Pellis & Pellis, 1996, 1997). What all these social uses of play fighting have in common is that they involve assessment and manipulation of the partner. As such, they are consistent with evolutionary game theory models that show that if an animal can assess the opponent’s fighting ability relative to its own, potentially damaging fights can be avoided (Parker, 1974). The benefits derived from such assessment could thus have been the selective advantage for the evolution of play fighting as a social tool in rats and other mammals. What the present analysis offers is a window into the causal mechanisms that make such an assessment possible. Furthermore, given the cognitive demands associated with such functions, the question arises as to whether play in the juvenile phase is organized so as to facilitate the development of these skills.
52
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
IMPLICATIONS FOR OUR UNDERSTANDING OF THE PLAY OF JUVENILES All muroid rodents studied thus far appear to have a form of play fighting that resembles the species-typical patterns of adult precopulatory behavior (Pellis, 1993). The resemblance is in both the body targets attacked and in the defensive maneuvers that are used to block these attacks. During postweaning development, these playful interactions grow increasingly like the adult sexual encounters (Pellis & Pellis, 1998b). The rat, however, exhibits a strikingly different developmental pattern. Although in the rat the target competed over during play fighting is the same as for sexual encounters (Pellis & Pellis, 1987), the pattern of defense differs. During sexual encounters the female rat primarily evades the male’s contact, while during play fighting the attacked partner does so in only 20–25% of contacts (Pellis & Pellis, 1987). Moreover, the form of the contact promoting defense also differs. During precopulatory encounters, female rats rarely flip over onto their backs (<10%), typically doing so only when mounted (work in progress). However, during play fighting, juvenile rats flip over onto their backs in response to more than 50% of contacts. With the onset of puberty, the males switch to partially rotating their body axes and pushing the attacker with their flanks (Pellis & Pellis, 1987, 1990). When play fighting emerges before weaning, the predominant pattern of defense is the same as that seen in postpubescent male rats—the partially rotated defense. This is striking because the partially rotated defensive posture requires the rat to shift its body weight backward onto its hind feet and to balance its forequarters in a horizontal, cantilevered position, a feat of postural coordination beyond the capacity of preweanling rats, which typically fall over. In the days following weaning, the full rotation to supine defensive tactic becomes predominant (Pellis & Pellis, 1997) and remains so until puberty (Pellis & Pellis, 1990). Therefore, in rats, not only is the defensive component of play fighting different from that which is present in adulthood at all developmental stages, but the juvenile phase is also marked by a reversal of the pattern of defense initiated before weaning and regained at puberty (Pellis, 2002b). These highly structured developmental changes suggest that the play present in the juvenile phase is organized so as to maximize specific experiences. The question is, what are those experiences? When, in the juvenile phase, a rat is introduced to a partner following short-term social isolation (6–24 hours), there is an increase in the level of play relative to other social behavior, such as social investigation (Panksepp, 1981; Panksepp & Beatty, 1980; Pellis et al., 1997). Increasing the length of the isolation (1–2 weeks) also leads to a preferential increase in play (Varlinskaya, Spear, & Spear, 1999), but such longer-term deprivation also results in long lasting deficiencies of social behavior in adulthood (Hol, van den Berg, van Ree, & Spruijt, 1999; van den Berg et al., 1999a). These deficits seem to be more in the motivation to engage in social behavior than in the ability to engage in appropriately sequenced bouts of the social interaction
Play Fighting
53
(van den Berg, van Ree, & Spruijt, 1999b). More prolonged social deprivation, lasting for all of the juvenile phase, leads to more generalized deficits in social and nonsocial behavior (DaSilva, Ferreira, Carobrez, & Morato, 1996; Einon, Morgan, & Kibbler, 1978). With regard to social and sexual behavior, these deficits appear to involve a reduced ability to respond to the movements of the partner (e.g., Larsson, 1978; Einon et al., 1978; Pellis, Field, & Whishaw, 1999). It is important to note that rats that have been socially isolated as juveniles have deficits in regulating the intensity of their defensive responses to social partners (Byrd & Briner, 1999; Potegal & Einon, 1989; van den Berg et al., 1999a) and to the stresses arising from such contact (Von Frijtag, Schot, van des Bos, & Spruijt, 2002). How, then, does wrestling, which arises from supine defense and leads to one partner standing on top and the other lying on its back (on-top/on-bottom), provide for the development of valuable social and nonsocial skills? When in this on-top/on-bottom configuration, the on-top rat has two ways of standing and thus supporting its weight (Foroud & Pellis, 2003). In both cases, the on-top rat stands on the on-bottom rat with its forepaws and uses them to restrain its partner’s movements. The difference between the two postures is in the placement of the hind paws. In the first posture, the on-top rat places its hind paws on the ground (see Figure 3.1e), whereas in the second posture the hind paws are placed on its supine partner’s body. However, in the latter case, the wriggling and squirming supine partner provides an unstable base; this makes it difficult for the on-top rat to maintain its balance and successfully restrain its supine partner. When the on-top/on-bottom configuration first appears, at about the time of weaning, the on-top rat adopts a more stable on-the-ground placement of its hind paws in approximately 80% of cases (Foroud & Pellis, 2002). This is true for puberty and thereafter (Foroud & Pellis, 2003). Surprisingly, during the juvenile phase, the rate of adopting the more stable placement declines to about 30–40% (Foroud & Pellis, 2002, 2003). This decline does not arise as a byproduct of the greater level of playfulness in the juvenile phase (Foroud & Pellis, 2002), nor is it dependent on social experience (Foroud, Whishaw, & Pellis, 2004). Rather, just as in the case of the pubertal switch to using the complete rotation tactic more often in the juvenile phase, the switch to the less stable on-top configuration appears to be a programmed pattern of development. However, there is a major consequence associated with adopting the less stable postural configuration—it facilitates the partner’s ability to counterattack and so gain the upper hand. The context of 22 role reversals from the ontop/on-bottom position in 11 pairs of male juvenile rats was analyzed. Role reversals arise when the on-bottom rat successfully counterattacks and reverses its position relative to its partner. In 70.5% of the role reversals, the ontop rat adopted the less stable postural configuration. That is, role reversals are significantly more likely when the on-top rat stands on its partner with its hind feet (sign test: X = 9, p < .05). Thus, by standing in the less stable position, the on-top rat increases its chances of losing the encounter, or perhaps,
54
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
more accurately, increases the opportunity for allowing the partner to reciprocate the contact. These data show that the juvenile phase is peculiar not only because of the increase in the use of the supine defense by defenders (Pellis & Pellis, 1990, 1997), but also because of the change that occurs at this time in the behavior of the attacking partner (Foroud & Pellis, 2002, 2003). It is as if by combining an increased likelihood of rolling over to supine by the defender with an increased likelihood of standing on the supine partner by the attacker, the rats are exaggerating the possibility for reciprocation by placing themselves in a more disadvantageous position. This combination is unique to the juvenile phase. That is, when play fighting is at its most gentle (defense mostly involves rotation to supine and the on-top attacker mostly adopts the unstable standing position), it is at its most frequent. Conversely, when play fighting is at its most frequent, it is at its least rough (Figure 3.2). Not only may such an exaggerated reciprocation allow for an elevated level of play fighting to occur in the juvenile phase, but it also may provide the learning experiences useful for adults to make fine-grain judgments about themselves in relation to their conspecifics. The on-top/on-bottom configuration with the less stable standing posture provides an experience of continuous change. That is, the on-top rat must continuously recalibrate its own position because of the changes that occur in its stability. These changes arise from a combination of its own movements with those of its supine partner. But at what level of vigor in the supine animal’s squirming should the on-top animal increase or decrease its own vigor in
FIGURE 3.2. The developmental changes in “roughness,” as measured by whether the rats use the partial rotation defense tactic and adopt the stable on-top posture, are contrasted with the developmental changes in the frequency of play fighting in rats. During the infantile and adult phases, when the frequency of play fighting is low, play is rougher. In contrast, during the juvenile phase, when the frequency of play fighting is at its highest, play is less rough.
Play Fighting
55
its attempt to gain the advantage? By having to make these judgments in the context of having its own sensorimotor skills compromised, the rat may be learning to integrate cues from its own body with those of its partner and so, at the same time, be learning how to apply appropriate levels of force to a highly dynamic situation. Several lines of evidence support this possibility.
THE MODIFIED PATTERN OF PLAY FIGHTING IN JUVENILE RATS AS A TOOL FOR ENHANCING SOCIAL–COGNITIVE SKILLS We have shown that the rat is a species in which the adults use play fighting for various social functions and the juveniles have a highly modified form of play. This is not true for all species that play as juveniles (Pellis & Iwaniuk, 1999a). Most other rodents that have been studied do not use play fighting as adults. Indeed, the play fighting of these juveniles mimics that of the adulttypical context from which the play elements are derived (Pellis & Pellis, 1998b). Thus, for example, voles not only attack and defend the targets typical of sexual encounters when they play fight, but they also use the tactics of attack and defense with the same frequencies as are typical of adults (Pellis, 1993). Furthermore, species differences between voles, such as the use of these tactics during play fighting, are consistent with adult differences in the use of these same tactics in sexual encounters (Pellis & Pellis, 1998b). As has been noted, in rats, the discordance between the use of tactics in play fighting and their use in adult sexual encounters cannot be so explained. This implies that the play fighting present in extant species cannot be viewed as having the same content for all species. Rather, with the advent of novel functions, new control systems must have evolved so as to regulate the behavior appropriately (Pellis, 1993). Again, the rat provides some clues as to how such layering of functions and control systems may have evolved. Rats decorticated at birth engage in play as juveniles (Panksepp, Normansell, Cox, & Siviy, 1994; Pellis, Pellis, & Whishaw, 1992) and are able to follow the 50:50 rule. However, they fail to exhibit the juvenile reversal in complete and partial rotation. That is, they preferentially use the partial rotation tactic before weaning and on into adulthood (Pellis et al., 1992). Decorticated rats also fail to show the modulation of the on-top rat in its standing posture, in that at all ages they most frequently use the least stable position (Foroud et al., 2004). Furthermore, as adults, decorticates do not modulate their defensive tactics with a change in partner. Rather, they mostly use the partial rotation tactic whether confronted by a dominant or a subordinate pairmate (unpublished observations based on data collected in Pellis et al., 1992). These findings suggest that interacting with a partner using the 50:50 rule involves subcortical neural mechanisms, but that modulating the pattern of defense with age, or with different partners, involves cortical systems. Furthermore, we have found that these two forms of cortical modulation are, in themselves, dissociable. Although neonatal ablation of the prefrontal cortex
56
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
does not disrupt the age-related modulation, it does appear to disrupt the relationship-based modulation (work in progress). We have also found that rats that are reared in isolation during the juvenile phase fail to exhibit the relationship-based modulation (work in progress). Given that the prefrontal cortex is not fully mature until puberty (van Eden, Kros, & Ulings, 1990)—that is, after the peak period of play in the juvenile phase—it is highly likely that this structure is involved in learning the subtle skills needed to assess and manipulate other rats during social interactions. The rat thus provides a basis for a model for the evolution of play fighting. As has been argued, for play fighting to occur, an animal must have the ability to use the 50:50 rule. As the neural control systems needed for this appear to be subcortical, they may provide the basis for commonality in the presence of such play in mammals, birds (Fagen, 1981), and, perhaps, reptiles (Burghardt, 1998).2 Most species that play fight do not exhibit the same range of elaboration of the 50:50 rule as do rats; most have only the basic, subcortical reciprocation mechanism. In rats, the developmental and partnerbased modifications of the 50:50 rule appear to involve additional cortical systems. Furthermore, cortical mechanisms appear to be needed to gain the cognitive benefits of such play (Pellis et al., 1992). Therefore, we predict that only species with a modified form of play, such as that which exists in rats, would suffer from cognitive deficiencies if deprived of play experience in the juvenile phase. Data from experiments by Einon and her colleagues appear to support this prediction. Rats, but not three other commonly used laboratory rodents, suffer long lasting cognitive deficits if socially isolated in the juvenile phase (Einon, Humphreys, Chivers, Field, & Naylor, 1981). Clearly, for a variety of species, there is a necessity for detailed comparisons of the organization, development, and functions of play fighting to be mapped against the effects of social isolation. Another aspect of the comparative distribution of play fighting is that even for species that have the additional rat-like mechanisms for modulating the 50:50 rule, the pattern of juvenile play experience is likely to vary with species-specific demands in the subtlety needed to modulate social interactions. We predict that the degree of rehearsal in moving along the 50:50 gradient should correlate with the degree of flexibility (and hence uncertainty) in adult social relationships. A preliminary comparison of the play fighting of two species of macaques suggests such a possibility (work in progress). Although the targets and tactics of the two species are the same, the magnitude of the deviations from the 50:50 rule that are tolerated before play fights are terminated differ. Whereas Japanese macaques (Macaca fuscata) tolerate only a narrow range of rule attenuation, in Tonkean macaques (Macaca tonkeana) the range is quite large. The social organization of Japanese macaques is rigidly hierarchical, with subordinates usually accepting punishment from a dominant. In contrast, the social hierarchy of Tonkean macaques is more relaxed, with subordinates likely to retaliate against transgressions by a domi-
Play Fighting
57
nant (Thierry, 2000). Thus, the need to assess subtle cues and to be more cognizant of the boundaries of manipulation is likely to be more important in Tonkean than in Japanese macaques. Individual differences also offer an opportunity to study the developmental, social, and neural processes that regulate reciprocity during play fighting. For example, some rats are more playful than others, and there are individual differences in regard to responsiveness to the movements of a partner. Some of these individual differences are related to endogenous levels of dopamine activity (Pellis & McKenna, 1992). A more striking example has been shown for populations of rhesus macaques (Macaca mulatta). About 5–10% of the juvenile males are hyperactive and impulsive. After a few playful interactions with these animals, other juveniles avoid further contact with them. It appears that because of their impulsiveness, their play quickly becomes rough, often escalating into serious aggression. These impulsive individuals have deficits in their serotonin metabolism (Suomi, 2002). Thus, both for rats and monkeys, individual differences in behavior can be linked to differences in the activity of particular neurochemical systems. In regard to behavior, the example of the rhesus monkeys (described earlier) serves to underscore the importance of following the rules governing play fighting so as to avoid escalation into full-blown aggression (Boulton, 1994). Also of relevance to the present discussion is the finding that rearing conditions with appropriate social experiences can attenuate the impulsiveness of these individuals (Suomi, 2002). These data thus reinforce the claim made here, that for mammals with at least the level of play organization that exists in rats, emotional and cognitive skills that are relevant to social behavior can be influenced by the experiences gained from play fighting as juveniles. The neural and comparative data presented here support the idea that when play fighting is used by adults for social assessment and manipulation, juveniles’ play fighting is modified so as to enhance the opportunity to maximize the experiences that refine the social–cognitive skills useful for adulthood. Rats show all facets of these combined changes—play is retained for adult purposes, the content of juvenile play is modified relative to that of preand postjuvenile play, and the addition of novel cortical mechanisms enable age- and context-specific modulation of the tactics of attack and defense, and thus of the 50:50 rule. Furthermore, there is evidence that during the juvenile phase, social experiences, such as those provided by play fighting, are critical for rats to learn how to modify their responses so as to take into account the movements of conspecifics (Pellis et al., 1999), and that such learning is dependent on cortical mechanisms (Pellis et al., 1992). As can be seen, there are, in rats, nonlearned, maturational changes that occur in the content of play fighting during development. Further, there appear to be neural mechanisms that permit learning to occur from the experiences arising from these changes in play. These changes may be present in a variety of species, including humans. Several lines of evidence support this suspicion.
58
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
CONCLUSION The sequential use of attack and defense during play fighting ensures that the 50:50 rule is followed. Having the ability to modify the sequential pattern of use of these tactics to exaggerate the win:loss ratio either in the partner’s favor or in the performer’s favor provides a means for using play fighting as a tool for social assessment and manipulation. Social assessment and manipulation can occur in two seemingly opposite functional contexts: Play fighting can be used to maintain the status quo or to overturn the status quo. To maintain unchanging relationships, repeated play fights can reveal that no change in the win:loss ratio has occurred. That is, the relative advantage in play has remained unchanged. Such use of play fighting for the reinforcement of existing relationships has been described in a variety of species, including rats (Pellis, 2002a) and New World deer (Geist, 1981), and among familiar boys (Pellegrini, 1994, 1995). To change social relationships, repeated play fights can be used to alter the win:loss ratio. That is, the relative advantage to one of the participants is changed; this permits the one that is doing the testing to ascertain whether the partner is able to tolerate such a change; this may then provide the testing partner with an opportunity to reverse the current relationship. This use of play fighting, for testing and reversing existing relationships, has also been described in a variety of species, including rats (Pellis, 2002a), Old World deer (Geist, 1982), adolescent chimpanzees (Paquette, 1994), and boys in unstable social relationships (Pellegrini, 1994, 1995). The social–cognitive skills that enable play fighting to be used to assess and manipulate conspecifics are the ones that are probably of general use in social interactions. Most critically, these skills are the ones that enable animals to make subtle decisions about the correct course of action to take—an action that carefully straddles competition and cooperation so as to maximize the advantage to the performer. We have suggested here that the experiences gained by juveniles when play fighting can enhance the development of these skills in some species, such as rats. If, in this regard, humans are found to be similar to rats—and there is some evidence that they are (Pellegrini & Smith, 1998)— then it may be necessary to reconsider policies that prevent children, especially boys, from engaging in playful contests.
NOTES 1. The work described here is mostly based on domesticated Norway rats (Rattus norvegicus). Even though domestication can greatly modify developmental processes and behavior (Coppinger & Coppinger, 2001), the little evidence available from wild rats observed in free-living and captive conditions suggests that the basic patterns of play described for the domestic form are also present in the wild type (Boreman & Price, 1972; Robitaille & Bovet, 1976; Seward, 1945). 2. The origin of the 50:50 rule is beyond the scope of the present chapter, but it is likely to have arisen from the reciprocity needed for copulation to occur. That is, at its most primitive, play
Play Fighting
59
fighting may be a precocial expression of sexual behavior by juveniles (Kramer & Burghardt, 1998; Pellis, 1993).
REFERENCES Adams, N., & Boice, R. (1983). A longitudinal study of dominance in an outdoor colony of domestic rats. Journal of Comparative Psychology, 97, 24–33. Adams, N., & Boice, R. (1989). Development of dominance in rats in laboratory and seminatural environments. Behavioural Processes, 19, 127–142. Aldis, O. (1975). Play fighting. New York: Academic Press. Altmann, S. A. (1962). Social behavior of anthropoid primates: Analysis of recent concepts. In E. L. Bliss (Ed.), Roots of behavior (pp. 277–285). New York: Harper. Bekoff, M. (1995). Play signals as punctuation: The structure of social play in canids. Behaviour, 132, 419–429. Blanchard, D. C., & Blanchard, R. J. (1990). Behavioral correlates of chronic dominance–subordination relationships of male rats in a semi-natural situation. Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews, 14, 455–462. Blanchard, R. J., Blanchard, D. C., Takahashi, L. K., & Kelly, M. J. (1977). Attack and defensive behaviour in the albino rat. Animal Behaviour, 25, 622–634. Boreman, J., & Price, E. (1972). Social dominance in wild and domestic Norway rats (Rattus norvegicus). Animal Behaviour, 20, 534–542. Boulton, M. J. (1994). The relationship between playful and aggressive fighting in children, adolescents and adults. In J. Archer (Ed.), Male violence (pp. 23–41). London: Routledge. Breuggeman, J. A. (1978). The function of adult play in free-ranging Macaca mulatta. In E. O. Smith (Ed.), Social play in primates (pp. 169–192). New York: Academic Press. Burghardt, G. M. (1998). Play. In G. Greenberg & M. M. Haraway (Eds.), Comparative psychology: A handbook (pp. 725–735). New York: Garland. Byrd, K. R., & Briner, W. E. (1999). Fighting, nonagonistic social behavior, and exploration in isolation-reared rats. Aggressive Behavior, 25, 211–223. Calhoun, J. B. (1962). A “behavioral sink.” In E. L. Bliss (Ed.), Roots of behavior (pp. 295–315). New York: Harper. Coppinger, R., & Coppinger, L. (2001). Dogs: The startling new understanding of canine origins, behavior and evolution. New York: Scribner. DaSilva, N. L., Ferreira, V. M. M., Carobrez, A. D. P., & Morato, G. S. (1996). Individual housing from rearing modifies the performance of young rats on the elevated plusmaze apparatus. Physiology and Behavior, 60, 1391–1396. de Waal, F. B. M., & Aureli, F. (Eds.). (2000). Natural conflict resolution. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press. Diamond, J. (1997). Guns, germs and steel: The fates of human societies (pp. 271–272). New York: Norton. Einon, D., Humphreys, A. P., Chivers, S. M., Field, S., & Naylor, V. (1981). Isolation has permanent effects upon the behaviour of the rat, but not mouse, gerbil, or guinea pig. Developmental Psychobiology, 14, 343–355. Einon, D., Morgan, M. J., & Kibbler, C. C. (1978). Brief periods of socialization and later behavior in the rat. Developmental Psychobiology, 11, 213–225. Fagen, R. (1981). Animal play behavior. New York: Oxford University Press.
60
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
Flannery, K., & Lore, R. (1977). Observations of the subterranean activity of domesticated and wild rats (Rattus norvegicus): A descriptive study. Psychological Record, 2, 315–329. Foroud, A., & Pellis, S. M. (2002). The development of “anchoring” in the play fighting of rats: Evidence for an adaptive age-reversal in the juvenile phase. International Journal of Comparative Psychology, 15, 11–20. Foroud, A., & Pellis, S. M. (2003). The development of “roughness” in the play fighting of rats: A Laban Movement Analysis perspective. Developmental Psychobiology, 42, 35–43. Foroud, A., Whishaw, I. Q., & Pellis, S. M. (2004). Experience and cortical control over the pubertal transition to rougher play fighting in rats. Behavioural Brain Research, 149, 69–76. Geist, V. (1971). Mountain sheep. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Geist, V. (1981). Behavior: Adaptive strategies in mule deer. In O. C. Wallmo (Ed.), Mule and black-tailed deer of North America (pp. 157–223). Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press. Geist, V. (1982). Adaptive behavioral strategies. In J. W. Thomas & D. E. Toweill (Eds.), Elk of North America (pp. 214–277). Harrisburg, PA: Stackpole Books. Hol, T., van den Berg, C. L., van Ree, J. M., & Spruijt, B. M. (1999). Isolation during the play period in infancy decreases adult social interactions in rats. Behavioural Brain Research, 100, 91–97. Kramer, M., & Burghardt, G. M. (1998). Precocious courtship and play in emydid turtles. Ethology, 104, 38–56. Larsson, K. (1978). Experiential factors in the development of sexual behaviour. In J. B. Hutchinson (Ed.), Biological determinants of sexual behavior (pp. 55–86). New York: Wiley. Meaney, M. J., & Stewart, J. (1981). A descriptive study of social development in the rat (Rattus norvegicus). Animal Behaviour, 29, 34–45. Panksepp, J. (1981). The ontogeny of play in rats. Developmental Psychobiology, 14, 327–332. Panksepp, J., & Beatty, W. W. (1980). Social deprivation and play in rats. Behavioral and Neural Biology, 30, 197–206. Panksepp, J., Normansell, L., Cox, J. F., & Siviy, S. M. (1994). Effects of neonatal decortication on the social play of juvenile rats. Physiology and Behavior, 56, 429– 443. Paquette, D. (1994). Fighting and play fighting in captive adolescent chimpanzees. Aggressive Behavior, 20, 49–65. Parker, G. A. (1974). Assessment strategy and the evolution of fighting behavior. Journal of Theoretical Biology, 47, 223–243. Pellegrini, A. D. (1994). The rough play of adolescent boys of differing sociometric status. International Journal of Behavioral Development, 17, 525–540. Pellegrini, A. D. (1995). A longitudinal study of boys’ rough-and-tumble play during early adolescence. Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology, 16, 77–93. Pellegrini, A. D., & Smith, P. K. (1998). Physical activity play: The nature and function of a neglected aspect of play. Child Development, 69, 577–598. Pellis, S. M. (1988). Agonistic versus amicable targets of attack and defense: Consequences for the origin, function and descriptive classification of play-fighting. Aggressive Behavior, 14, 85–104.
Play Fighting
61
Pellis, S. M. (1993). Sex and the evolution of play fighting: A review and a model based on the behavior of muroid rodents. Journal of Play Theory and Research, 1, 56–77. Pellis, S. M. (1997). Targets and tactics: The analysis of moment-to-moment decision making in animal combat. Aggressive Behavior, 23, 107–129. Pellis, S. M. (2002a). Keeping in touch: Play fighting and social knowledge. In M. Bekoff, C. Allen, & G. M. Burghardt (Eds.), The cognitive animal: Empirical and theoretical perspectives on animal cognition (pp. 421–427). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Pellis, S. M. (2002b). Sex differences in play fighting revisited: Traditional and nontraditional mechanisms of sexual differentiation in rats. Archives of Sexual Behaviour, 31, 17–26. Pellis, S. M., Field, E. F., Smith, L. K., & Pellis, V. C. (1997). Multiple differences in the play fighting of male and female rats: Implications for the causes and functions of play. Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews, 21, 105–120. Pellis, S. M., Field, E. F., & Whishaw, I. Q. (1999). The development of a sex-differentiated defensive motor-pattern in rats: A possible role for juvenile experience. Developmental Psychobiology, 35, 156–164. Pellis, S. M., & Iwaniuk, A. N. (1999a). The roles of phylogeny and sociality in the evolution of social play in muroid rodents. Animal Behaviour, 58, 361–373. Pellis, S. M., & Iwaniuk, A. N. (1999b). The role of adult play: A comparative analysis of play and courtship in primates. Ethology, 105, 783–806. Pellis, S. M., & Iwaniuk, A. N. (2000). Adult–adult play in primates: Comparative analyses of its origin, distribution and evolution. Ethology, 106, 1083–1104. Pellis, S. M., & McKenna, M. M. (1992). Intrinsic and extrinsic influences on play fighting in rats: Effects of dominance, partner’s playfulness, temperament and neonatal exposure to testosterone propionate. Behavioural Brain Research, 50, 135–145. Pellis, S. M., & Pellis, V. C. (1987). Play fighting differs from serious fighting in both target of attack and tactics of fighting in the laboratory rat Rattus norvegicus. Aggressive Behavior, 13, 227–242. Pellis, S. M., & Pellis, V. C. (1990). Differential rates of attack, defense and counterattack during the developmental decrease in play fighting by male and female rats. Developmental Psychobiology, 23, 215–231. Pellis, S. M., & Pellis, V. C. (1991a). Role reversal changes during the ontogeny of play fighting in male rats: Attack versus defense. Aggressive Behavior, 17, 179–189. Pellis, S. M., & Pellis, V. C. (1991b). Attack and defense during play fighting appear to be motivationally independent behaviors in muroid rodents. Psychological Record, 41, 175–184. Pellis, S. M., & Pellis, V. C. (1992). Juvenilized play fighting in subordinate male rats. Aggressive Behavior, 18, 449–457. Pellis, S. M., & Pellis, V. C. (1996). On knowing it’s only play: The role of play signals in play fighting. Aggression and Violent Behavior, 1, 249–268. Pellis, S. M., & Pellis, V. C. (1997). The pre-juvenile onset of play fighting in rats (Rattus norvegicus). Developmental Psychobiology, 31, 193–205. Pellis, S. M., & Pellis, V. C. (1998a). The play fighting of rats in comparative perspective: A schema for neurobehavioral analyses. Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews, 23, 87–101. Pellis, S. M., & Pellis, V. C. (1998b). The structure-function interface in the analysis of play fighting. In M. Bekoff & J. A. Byers (Eds.), Animal play: Evolutionary, comparative and ecological aspects (pp. 115–140). Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
62
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
Pellis, S. M., Pellis, V. C., & McKenna, M. M. (1993). Some subordinates are more equal than others: Play fighting amongst adult subordinate male rats. Aggressive Behavior, 19, 385–393. Pellis, S. M., Pellis, V. C., & Whishaw, I. Q. (1992). The role of the cortex in play fighting by rats: Developmental and evolutionary implications. Brain, Behavior and Evolution, 39, 270–284. Potegal, M., & Einon, D. (1989). Aggressive behavior in adult rats deprived of playfighting experience as juveniles. Developmental Psychobiology, 22, 159–172. Robitaille, J. A., & Bovet, J. (1976). Field observations on the social behaviour of the Norway rat, Rattus norvegicus (Berkenhout). Biology of Behavior, 1, 289–308. Seward, J. P. (1945). Aggressive behavior in the rat: I. General characteristics: Age and sex differences. Journal of Comparative Psychology, 38, 175–197. Siviy, S. M., & Panksepp, J. (1987). Sensory modulation of juvenile play in rats. Developmental Psychobiology, 20, 39–55. Smith, L. K., Fantella, S.-L., & Pellis, S. M. (1999). Playful defensive responses in adult male rats depend on the status of the unfamiliar opponent. Aggressive Behavior, 25, 141–152. Smith, L. K., Field, E. F., Forgie, M. L., & Pellis, S. M. (1996). Dominance and age-related changes in the play fighting of intact and post-weaning castrated male rats (Rattus norvegicus). Aggressive Behavior, 22, 215–226. Smith, L. K., Forgie, M. L., & Pellis, S. M. (1998). Mechanisms underlying the absence of the pubertal shift in the playful defense of female rats. Developmental Psychobiology, 33, 147–156. Suomi, S. J. (2002). How gene–environment interactions can shape the development of socioemotional regulation in rhesus monkeys. In B. S. Zuckerman, A. F. Zuckerman, & N. A. Fox (Eds.), Emotional regulation and developmental health: Infancy and early childhood (pp. 5–26). New Brunswick, NJ: Johnson & Johnson Pediatric Institute, L.L.C. Thierry, B. (2000). Covariation of conflict management patterns across macaque species. In F. Aureli & F. B. M. De Waal (Eds.), Natural conflict resolution (pp. 106–128). Berkeley, CA: University of California Press. Thor, D. H., & Holloway, W. R., Jr. (1984). Social play in juvenile rats: A decade of methodological and experimental research. Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews, 8, 455–464. van den Berg, C. L., Hol, T., van Ree, J. M., Spruijt, B. M., Everts, H., & Koolhaas, J. M. (1999a). Play is indispensible for an adequate development of coping with social challenges in the rat. Developmental Psychobiology, 34, 129–138. van den Berg, C. L., van Ree, J. M., & Spruijt, B. M. (1999b). Sequential analysis of juvenile isolation-induced decreased social behavior in the adult rat. Physiology and Behavior, 67, 483–488. van Eden, C. J., Kros, J. M., & Ulings, H. B. M. (1990). The development of the rat prefrontal cortex. In H. B. M. Ulings, C. G. van Eden, M. A. Corner, & M. G. P. Feenstra (Eds.), Progress in brain research: Vol. 85. The prefrontal cortex. Its structure, function and pathology (pp. 169–183). Amsterdam: Elsevier. Varlinskaya, E. I., Spear, L. P., & Spear, N. E. (1999). Social behavior and social motivation in adolescent rats: Role of housing conditions and partner’s activity. Physiology and Behavior, 67, 475–482. Von Frijtag, J. C., Schot, M., van des Bos, R., & Spruijt, B. M. (2002). Individual housing during the play period results in changed responses to and consequences of a psychosocial stress situation in rats. Developmental Psychobiology, 41, 58–69.
THE DEVELOPMENT Genetic and Environmental OF Factors AGGRESSION in Rhesus Monkeys
4 Genetic and Environmental Factors Influencing the Expression of Impulsive Aggression and Serotonergic Functioning in Rhesus Monkeys S TEPHEN J. S UOMI
This chapter is dedicated to the memory of Markku Linnoila, who passed away 5 years ago following a sudden recurrence of cancer. At the time of his death at age 50, Dr. Linnoila was the Scientific Director of the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism (NIAAA) and was clearly expanding an already extraordinary research career. I first met him more than 20 years ago; at that time he was a recently appointed laboratory chief in the NIAAA and I was being recruited from the University of Wisconsin to develop a new laboratory in a different institute of the National Institutes of Health (NIH), the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development (NICHD). Within minutes of being introduced to each other, we decided to form a longterm collaboration, wherein his laboratory would analyze cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) concentrations of monoamine metabolites collected from rhesus monkeys that would be reared in different physical and social environments at the new primate facility that was being developed in the Maryland countryside. Moreover, he proposed to provide postdoctoral support for my senior graduate student from Wisconsin, J. D. Higley, in order to maintain our collaboration. At that time I had no idea how unusual this collaboration was, given the tradition of intense competition for resources between the different institutes within the NIH. Higley is now a tenured scientist in the NIAAA, our collaborative efforts actually have expanded over the years, and although Markku is no longer with us, his remarkable vision and his spirit persist in full force. 63
64
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
This chapter summarizes a program of research inspired by Linnoila that has focused on the development of excessive physical aggression in a subgroup of young male rhesus monkeys, with an emphasis on findings linking such patterns of behavior to an apparent deficit in central serotonin metabolism. I begin by describing the social organization of rhesus monkeys in natural settings and how aggression typically emerges and is subsequently socialized during the juvenile years. Next, I summarize evidence that demonstrates a striking association between excessive physical aggression and deficits in central serotonin metabolism for rhesus monkeys, as has been found in humans and other primate species. I then characterize the biobehavioral developmental trajectories of individuals prone to engage in inappropriate and excessive aggression and present evidence regarding the relative heritability of these phenomena. Next, studies of the long-term consequences of excessive aggression for monkeys growing up in free-ranging environments are examined, followed by a summary of the ubiquitous effects of differential early social rearing experiences. Finally, I present some recent findings demonstrating that allelic variation in a specific gene implicated in serotonin metabolism can have dramatically different developmental consequences for monkeys as a function of their early social rearing history.
SOCIAL ORGANIZATION, SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT, AND THE SOCIALIZATION OF AGGRESSION IN RHESUS MONKEYS The primate facility that was built by NICHD in the Maryland countryside near the town of Poolesville has enabled us to study rhesus monkeys growing up under conditions that simulate most basic aspects of their natural physical and social environments. In nature, rhesus monkeys reside in large social groups (troops) that can range in size from several dozen to several hundred individuals. Each troop is composed of several different female-headed families (matrilines) that each span several generations of kin, plus numerous immigrant males. This pattern of social organization derives from the fact that rhesus monkey females stay in the troop in which they were born for their entire lives, whereas virtually all rhesus monkey males emigrate from their natal troop around the time of puberty, usually in their 4th or 5th year of life, and most eventually join other troops. Rhesus monkey troops in nature are also characterized by multiple social dominance relationships, including distinctive hierarchies both between and within families, as well as a hierarchy among the immigrant adult males (Lindburg, 1971). Although male status superficially appears to be a function of relative tenure—that is, the longer a male has been living in the troop, the more likely he is to be high in rank—in point of fact male dominance status seems to be more a function of social skill in joining and maintaining coalitions, not only with other males but especially with high-ranking females in the troop (Berard,1989). In sum, the dominance status of a rhesus monkey de-
Genetic and Environmental Factors in Rhesus Monkeys
65
pends not so much on how big and strong it is, but rather who its family and friends are—and the latter is clearly dependent on the development of complex social skills during ontogeny. Rhesus monkey infants spend virtually all of their initial days and weeks of life in physical contact with their biological mother, during which time they form a strong and enduring specific attachment bond with her. In their 2nd month of life, infant monkeys begin to explore their immediate physical and social environment, using their mother as a secure base to support such exploration (cf. Suomi, 1995). Over the next few months these infants spend increasing amounts of time engaging in extensive social interactions with other group members, especially peers. Social play with peers soon becomes their predominant social activity and remains so until puberty. During this time play interactions become increasingly gender-segregated and involve patterns of behavior that appear to simulate virtually all adult social activities, including various forms of aggression (Ruppenthal, Harlow, Eisele, Harlow, & Suomi, 1974; Suomi & Harlow, 1975). Aggression is a normal and necessary part of every rhesus monkey’s overall behavioral repertoire—indeed, most primatologists consider rhesus monkeys to be among the most aggressive of all primate species. Rhesus monkey aggression can range in intensity from mere facial threats and vocalizations to vigorous chases and actual physical attacks, including slapping, hitting, hair pulling, and biting with sufficient intensity to produce lasting tissue damage or even death. The capability for aggression is crucial for survival in the wild, not only from the standpoint of defending one’s self and offspring from predators and nonspecific competitors, but also in maintaining social order and enforcing the complex dominance hierarchies characteristic of all rhesus monkey troops. However, uncontrolled, unpredictable, and violent aggression within any troop could drive members apart and destroy it as a social unit. Therefore, aggression must be socialized—it must be minimized or at least largely ritualized in intragroup interactions, but it must also remain a viable response in order to counter external threats or other dangers. Socialization of aggression for young rhesus monkeys involves not only learning in which circumstances and toward what targets aggressive behavior might be appropriate, but also gauging the relative intensity of the attack or response called for and the appropriate time and means for terminating an aggressive bout or for avoiding it altogether. Indeed, learning whom not to attack, as well as how to moderate aggressive impulses, is as important in the socialization process as is honing one’s fighting skills. Aggression typically emerges in a rhesus monkey’s behavioral repertoire at about 6 months of age, and it initially appears in the context of rough-andtumble play (Symonds, 1978). Biting, hair pulling, wrestling, and other forms of physical contact are basic components of rough-and-tumble play directed toward peers, which occurs with increasing frequency among males in the second half of their first year of life and becomes the predominate type of play for the rest of their juvenile years (Harlow & Lauersdorf, 1974). Although
66
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
some form of virtually all behavioral components of adult aggressive exchanges can be seen in the rough-and-tumble play bouts of young males, the intensity of such interactions is usually quite controlled and seldom escalates to the point of potential physical injury—if it does, the play bout is almost always terminated immediately, either via adult intervention or by one or more of the participants backing away themselves. The importance of these play bouts with peers for the socialization of aggression becomes apparent when one considers that rhesus monkey infants reared in laboratory environments that denied them regular access to peers during their initial months consistently exhibited excessive and socially inappropriate aggression later in life (e.g., Alexander & Harlow, 1966; Harlow & Harlow, 1969).
INDIVIDUAL DIFFERENCES IN AGGRESSION AND SEROTONIN METABOLISM Both laboratory and field studies of rhesus monkeys and other nonhuman primate species have reported striking individual differences in the levels and types of aggression exhibited by monkeys of like age and gender, especially when displayed in circumstances where the aggression is neither provoked nor socially appropriate (e.g., Bernstein, Williams, & Ramsay, 1983; Steklis, Brammen, Raleigh, & McGuire, 1985), much as has been the case in recent human surveys and clinical investigations (cf. Lahey, Moffitt, & Caspi, 2003). Over the past two decades numerous studies, including several by Linnoila (e.g., Linnoila, 1988; Linnoila, DeJong, & Virkkunen, 1989; Linnoila et al., 1983), of child, adolescent, and adult males who engaged in unusually and violently aggressive activities have reported links between such aggression and apparent deficits in serotonergic functioning, such that those aggressive individuals tended to have unusually low CSF concentrations of the primary central serotonin metabolite 5-hydroxyindoleacetic acid (5-HIAA). Given these findings from the human clinical literature and with the strong encouragement of Linnoila, my colleagues and I decided to test the so-called serotonin hypothesis (cf. Coccaro & Murphy, 1990) in the rhesus monkey colony. Accordingly, we collected and assayed CSF samples for concentrations of 5-HIAA from a cross-sectional sample of infant, juvenile, and young adult monkeys representing both genders and three different early-rearing backgrounds. We also had considerable background data regarding levels of aggression exhibited by monkeys of comparable age, gender, and rearing history, although nobody had previously put those two data sets together. When we then did so, what seemed striking was the degree to which differences in CSF 5-HIAA concentrations were inversely related to differences in the incidence of aggression, whether the comparison involved age, gender, or rearing condition differences. For example, infant monkeys display minimal levels of aggression, juvenile monkeys show some, typically in the context of play, and adolescents and young adults, especially males, tend to exhibit the highest levels of aggressive behavior for any age-gender subgroup. We found exactly the
Genetic and Environmental Factors in Rhesus Monkeys
67
opposite to be true for 5-HIAA concentrations: Infants had the highest levels, juveniles’ concentrations were significantly lower, and postpubertal monkeys (especially males) had the lowest concentrations (Higley, Suomi, & Linnoila, 1990b). Equally striking was the finding that short-term longitudinal CSF 5HIAA data obtained from a subset of these monkeys, collected under vastly different environmental circumstances, revealed remarkable stability across both situations and individuals, suggesting a trait-like characteristic for the CSF 5-HIAA measure (Higley, Suomi, & Linnoila, 1990a). Given the findings, we began a concentrated effort to explore this apparently inverse relationship more fully in our Poolesville rhesus monkey population. A series of prospective longitudinal studies replicated and extended our basic findings from the initial cross-sectional analyses. We found that approximately 5–10% of our monkeys exhibited impulsive behavioral tendencies and general social incompetence. Males in this subgroup became involved in a disproportionate number of aggressive exchanges with other group members. Females in this subgroup typically engaged in fewer overt acts of physical aggression than those males, but more than most other females. They also were less likely to engage in positive affiliative behaviors such as social grooming. Monkeys in this subgroup also consistently had lower CSF 5-HIAA concentrations than their peers of like age and gender (Higley & Suomi, 1996).
DEVELOPMENTAL TRAJECTORIES FOR IMPULSIVELY AGGRESSIVE MONKEYS We now know that rhesus monkeys with chronically low CFS 5-HIAA concentrations typically begin to distinguish themselves from their peers in their early play interactions. This is especially true for low–5-HIAA males: They seem to lack the ability (or perhaps the motivation) to moderate their behavioral responses to playful initiations from peers, and by late childhood their rough-and-tumble play bouts often escalate into more serious aggressive exchanges. Not surprisingly, most of these males soon come to be avoided by those around them, and as a result they become increasingly isolated socially (Figure 4.1). Moreover, low–5-HIAA juvenile males often seem unable (or unwilling) to follow social rules inherent in rhesus monkey dominance hierarchies (Higley, Suomi, & Linnoila, 1996d). For example, they may directly challenge a dominant adult male, a foolhardy act that often leads to serious injury, especially when they seemingly refuse to back down or exhibit appropriate submissive behavior once defeat becomes obvious. Juvenile females with chronically low CSF 5-HIAA concentrations tend to exhibit low levels of social grooming, and although they are generally involved in fewer overtly aggressive acts than their male counterparts, they too tend to become relatively isolated socially as they are growing up, typically drifting to the bottom of the dominance hierarchy within their social group (Higley et al., 1996a).
68
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
FIGURE 4.1. Aggressive male rhesus monkey.
Longitudinal studies (e.g., Higley, Suomi, & Linnoila, 1992) have demonstrated that individual differences in CSF 5-HIAA concentrations tend to be remarkably stable from infancy to early adulthood, despite steady and significant developmental decreases in overall CSF 5-HIAA concentrations throughout childhood and adolescence. Given this stability and the inverse relationship between CSF 5-HIAA concentrations and impulsive aggressiveness (cf. Higley et al., 1996d), it appears possible to predict an individual’s likelihood of becoming impulsively aggressive later in life from its CSF 5-HIAA values exhibited during infancy. Moreover, as previously noted, individual differences in CSF 5-HIAA concentrations remain relatively stable across a variety of both stressful and benign environmental circumstances, unlike most indices of central nervous system activity. These findings therefore suggest that the CSF concentration of 5-HIAA can serve as a marker of an individual’s propensity to engage in impulsively aggressive actions, even when assessed under circumstances in which no overt aggression is being displayed (Higley, Suomi, & Linnoila, 1991b). Recent research has shown that individual differences in impulsive aggressiveness and CSF 5-HIAA concentrations are also predictive of individual differences in the propensity to consume alcohol in a “happy hour situation.” Over the past decade Higley and his colleagues have developed an experimental paradigm in which group-living rhesus monkeys are given the opportunity to consume an aspartame-flavored 7% alcohol (ETOH) beverage, a nonalcoholic aspartame-flavored beverage, and/or plain tap water for
Genetic and Environmental Factors in Rhesus Monkeys
69
daily 1-hour periods within their familiar social group (e.g., Higley et al., 1991a). Impulsive adolescent monkeys who have low CSF 5-HIAA concentrations tend to consume excessive amounts of alcohol when placed in this happy hour experimental paradigm (Higley et al., 1996c). Researchers have also demonstrated a significant relationship between degree of alcohol intoxication and serotonin transporter availability in these monkeys (Heinz et al., 1998).
GENETIC FACTORS AND STRAIN DIFFERENCES Several studies involving rhesus monkeys whose genetic backgrounds have been well characterized and who have been raised from birth in controlled laboratory environments have demonstrated significant heritability for individual differences in CSF 5-HIAA concentrations. One investigation compared paternal half-siblings (same father, different mothers, with no physical exposure to their biological father at any time) and unrelated individuals reared under identical conditions. Heritability analyses revealed significantly greater concordance of CSF 5-HIAA concentrations among same-gender paternal half-siblings than among unrelated same-sex control subjects matched for age and rearing history. Another study utilized cross-fostering procedures, in which infants were separated from their biological mothers within the first week of life and raised thereafter by an unrelated multiparous female. CSF concentrations for the cross-fostered infants, assessed at 6 and 18 months of age, more closely resembled the CSF 5-HIAA concentrations of their biological mothers than those of their foster mothers (Higley et al., 1993). These findings provide compelling (albeit indirect) evidence of heritable influences on central serotonin metabolism, as well as risk for the development of impulsive aggressiveness, in laboratory-reared rhesus monkeys. A completely different line of research linking low serotonin metabolism with impulsive behavioral tendencies originated from serendipitous observations by the personnel caring for and testing rhesus monkey infants in the Poolesville facility’s neonatal nursery. Our colony has had a self-sufficient breeding program since its inception; that is, we have not had to bring in any rhesus monkeys from outside sources in order to carry out our basic research program. All of our breeders were either born in the laboratory or were part of the original colony that had been moved to the Poolesville facility from the University of Wisconsin Harlow Primate Laboratory in the mid-1980s; all of the Wisconsin monkeys, in turn, were descendents of wild rhesus monkeys imported from India prior to 1971. In contrast, some other primate facilities at the NIH have imported rhesus monkeys from China over the past two decades. Anecdotal reports by researchers and animal caretaking staff alike have suggested that rhesus monkeys of Chinese origin were unusually aggressive, difficult to train, and otherwise generally intractable. One NIH laboratory using rhesus monkeys imported from China was
70
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
carrying out contraception research; because that laboratory lacked nursery facilities, unwanted infants that were the product of contraceptive failures were sent to us to be raised in our neonatal nursery. Maribeth Champoux, who oversees the nursery research and caretaking staff, soon noticed that those infants with parents of Chinese origin were unusual in several respects, not the least of which was their tendency to bite nursery staff while being hand-fed during their first week of life, a phenomenon we had never previously experienced with our own infants. Champoux subsequently tested other Chinese-origin infants with the lab’s standardized neonatal test battery and found significant deficits in their activity state control and their visual orienting capabilities during their first month of life, relative to the normative standards established for infants whose parents came from the lab’s breeding colony (Champoux, Suomi, & Schneider, 1994). CSF samples were obtained from Chinese-derived infants throughout their first 6 months of life, and their CSF 5-HIAA concentrations were compared with those of the lab’s Indian-derived infants. The Chinese-derived infants were found to have significantly lower CSF 5-HIAA concentrations from 3 to 4 months onward (Champoux, Higley & Suomi, 1997). Moreover, behavioral observations of these youngsters of Chinese origin revealed higher frequencies of impulsive and aggressive behaviors during their first 2 years of life than those observed in like-reared peers born into the lab colony (followup observations are currently under way). In addition to providing an empirical basis for insights based on anecdotal observations, these studies comparing Indian- and Chinese-derived infants established a predictive relationship between measures of basic biobehavioral characteristics during the neonatal period and patterns of serotonergic function and behavioral tendencies later in life.
FIELD STUDIES Given that low CSF 5-HIAA is associated with a host of behavioral tendencies throughout development that seem, at best, problematic for rhesus monkeys maintained in captive environments, a reasonable question is whether similar phenomena can be found in wild populations of rhesus monkeys—and if so, what the adaptive consequences for such individuals might be. Through Linnoila’s good offices, we established a collaboration with David Taub and Patrick Mehlman, and more recently continued with Greg Westergaard, that gave us access to a free-ranging population of approximately 4,000 rhesus monkeys that have been living for many years on Morgan Island, a sea island on the South Carolina Atlantic coast. These monkeys are provisioned but receive no special veterinary treatment, and except for periodic trapping of specified individuals for biological sampling, these monkeys are not subject to any experimental interventions. Analyses of CSF samples obtained from free-ranging juvenile, adolescent,
Genetic and Environmental Factors in Rhesus Monkeys
71
and adult male rhesus monkeys residing on this sea island found 5-HIAA concentrations closely resembling those obtained from males in the Poolesville colony in terms of absolute values, age-related differences, and stability of individual differences across repeated sampling and across major developmental transitions (e.g., natal troop emigration). Moreover, the strong inverse relationship between CSF 5-HIAA concentrations and the rate of escalating aggression consistently reported in laboratory studies was at least as strong in this field population of rhesus monkey males and, similarly, first appeared in the context of play with peers. Like their captive counterparts, these wild rhesus monkey juveniles with low CSF 5-HIAA concentrations frequently turned routine rough-and-tumble play bouts into episodes involving serious aggressive exchanges, and they were also more likely to commit obvious social blunders that typically elicit physical attacks from larger and more socially dominant troop members (Higley et al., 1992a). Juvenile males with low CSF 5HIAA concentrations were also more likely to take long, potentially dangerous leaps from treetop to treetop, sometimes falling to the ground and injuring themselves. We found a significant inverse linear relationship between the relative frequency of such leaps and CSF 5-HIAA concentrations that paralleled the negative relationship between CSF 5-HIAA values and the incidence of escalating aggression (Mehlman et al., 1994; Figure 4.2). The long-term outlook for young rhesus monkey males with low CSF 5HIAA concentrations is not very promising in free-ranging environments such as Morgan Island. Ostracized by their peers and frequently attacked by adults of both genders, most of these young males are physically driven out of their
FIGURE 4.2. Impulsive juvenile male monkey taking dangerous leap.
72
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
natal troop prior to 3 years of age, long before the onset of puberty (Mehlman et al., 1995). These impulsive young males generally lack the social skills to be able to join another troop; indeed, they even seem unable to join an all-male gang. As a result, most of these males become solitary, and virtually all of them perish within a year, long before becoming physically capable of reproduction (Higley et al., 1996b). Given the previously noted finding that individual differences in CSF 5HIAA concentrations appear to be highly heritable, along with the fact that most male rhesus monkeys with unusually low CSF 5-HIAA concentrations fail to survive to reproductive age, one might reasonably ask how it could be possible for as many as 10% of rhesus monkeys in wild populations to have chronically low CSF 5-HIAA concentrations. Three possible explanations readily come to mind. One possibility is that the few males with low CSF 5HIAA that do survive to adulthood sire a disproportionately large number of offspring (the “silver bullet” hypothesis). Recent observational data obtained from the Morgan Island population suggest that this hypothesis is exceedingly unlikely. In point of fact, the low CSF 5-HIAA males who do survive tend to be actively avoided by most females. In the few circumstances in which consort behavior with a female actually occurs, those males tend to engage in fewer mounts per copulatory sequence (rhesus monkeys are serial mounters), are less likely to ejaculate before the sequence is terminated, and have a lower probability of inseminating the females when they do ejaculate than do other males in the population (Mehlman et al., 1997). A more plausible possibility is that the propensity for developing chronically low central serotonin metabolism is passed on to the next generation of rhesus monkeys primarily through the female, rather than the male, genome. Young female rhesus monkeys with low–5-HIAA concentrations are indeed impulsive and aggressive and tend to be generally incompetent socially (Westergaard et al., 2003). Unlike males, however, they are not expelled from their natal troop but instead remain in their respective families for the rest of their lives. Moreover, they engage in relatively normal reproductive behavior, and they clearly produce and rear offspring—offspring that therefore may well be at increased genetic risk for low CSF 5-HIAA concentrations.
EFFECTS OF DIFFERENTIAL EARLY SOCIAL EXPERIENCE A third possible mechanism for cross-generational transmission of deficits in serotonergic functioning is derived from recent studies of maternal behavior in captive rhesus monkey groups. We have found that females with chronically low CSF 5-HIAA concentrations tend to exhibit significant abnormalities in their maternal behavior, often resulting in the development of insecure and/or disorganized attachment relationships with their infants. Other recent data suggest that infants who develop the least secure attachment relationships with their mothers are also the most likely to develop deficits in their central
Genetic and Environmental Factors in Rhesus Monkeys
73
serotonin metabolism (cf. Suomi, 1999). Thus, an alternative possible means of cross-generational transmission of the propensity for having chronically low CSF 5-HIAA concentrations may be via aberrant maternal care, or other forms of social stimulation, that offspring might experience during development. According to this view, the mother’s behavior toward offspring may be more relevant for cross-generational transmission of the phenomenon than her genes. Of course, these two potential pathways are not necessarily mutually exclusive (Suomi & Levine, 1998). In fact, an increasing body of data from laboratory studies of monkeys reared under different social circumstances has demonstrated that early social experiences can profoundly affect both the development of impulsive aggressive tendencies and central serotonin metabolism alike. Some of the most compelling findings have come from longitudinal studies of peer-reared monkeys, that is, infants that were permanently separated from their mothers at birth, hand-reared in the neonatal nursery for their first month of life, and then placed in small social groups with like-reared age mates (cf. Harlow & Harlow, 1969). In most of the relevant studies the peer-reared subjects were moved into larger social groups containing both peer-reared and motherreared age mates at 7 months of age, and they remained in these larger social groups at least until puberty, if not beyond (e.g., Higley & Suomi, 1996). During their initial months these infants readily developed strong social attachment bonds to each other, much as mother-reared infants develop attachment relationships with their own mothers. However, because peers are not nearly as effective as a normal monkey mother in reducing fear in the face of stress or in providing a secure base for exploration, the attachment relationships that these peer-reared infants developed were almost always “anxious” or “insecure” in nature (Suomi, 1995). As a consequence, whereas the peer-reared monkeys exhibited relatively normal physical and motor development, their early exploratory behavior was somewhat limited. They seemed reluctant to approach novel objects, and they tended to be shy in their initial encounters with unfamiliar peers. Moreover, even when peer-reared infants interacted with their same-age cage mates in familiar settings, their emerging social play repertoires were generally retarded in both frequency and complexity. For example, peer-reared monkeys were more likely to play with only one partner at a time rather than with multiple partners simultaneously, as mother-reared youngsters quickly come to prefer, and their play bouts were usually limited to relatively brief exchanges rather than the extended interactions that may go on for several minutes at a time among mother-reared peers. One explanation for the relatively poor play performance of peer-reared monkeys is that their cage mates had to serve both as attachment objects and as playmates, a dual role that neither mothers nor mother-reared peers have to fulfill. Perhaps as a result, they typically dropped to the bottom of their respective dominance hierarchies when they were eventually grouped with mother-reared monkeys their own age (Higley et al., 1996d).
74
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
Early peer-rearing also tended to make young rhesus monkey males more impulsive. Like the previously described impulsive monkeys growing up in the wild, peer-reared males initially exhibited aggressive tendencies in the context of juvenile play; and as they approached puberty, the frequency and severity of their aggressive episodes exceeded that of mother-reared group members of similar age. Peer-reared females tended to groom (and be groomed by) others in their social group less frequently and for shorter durations than their mother-reared counterparts and, as before, they usually remained at the bottom of their respective dominance hierarchies. These differences between peerreared and mother-reared age mates in aggression, grooming, and dominance continued to be relatively robust when the monkeys were subsequently moved into new social groups, and they generally remained quite stable throughout the juvenile and adolescent years. An important finding was that early peer-rearing was also associated with diminished central serotonin metabolism throughout development. Significant group differences between peer-reared infants and their mother-reared counterparts appeared within the first month of life, and these differences were maintained throughout the rest of the 7-month period of differential rearing, even though CSF 5-HIAA concentrations dropped dramatically for both rearing groups during this period. Moreover, peer-reared subjects continued to have significantly lower CSF 5-HIAA concentrations than their motherreared counterparts after they were moved into the same large social groups, and these differences persisted through puberty. Finally, peer-reared adolescent monkeys consistently consumed larger amounts of alcohol under comparable conditions than their mother-reared age mates (Higley, Hassert, Suomi, & Linnoila, 1991a). Follow-up studies also demonstrated that the peer-reared subjects quickly develop a greater tolerance for alcohol, which can be predicted by their CNS serotonin turnover rates, which in turn appear to be associated with differential serotonin transporter availability (Heinz et al., 1998).
GENE–ENVIRONMENT INTERACTIONS The previously described association between turnover rate and serotonin transporter availability led Markku Linnoila to help us establish a collaboration with Peter Lesch at the University of Wurzburg. Lesch and his colleagues recently characterized the serotonin transporter gene (5-HTT), a candidate gene for impaired serotonergic function in that it mediates serotonin neurotransmission, plays a critical role in brain serotonin homeostasis, and is a target for both selective serotonin reuptake inhibiting (SSRI) antidepressant compounds and certain drugs of abuse (Lesch et al., 1996). They have shown that length variation in the 5-HTT gene-linked polymorphic region (5-HTT-LPR) results in allelic variation in 5-HTT expression. The short allele of the 5-HTTLPR confers low transcription efficiency to the 5-HTT gene promoter, and lower 5-HTT mRNA levels are found in humans with the short allele, suggest-
Genetic and Environmental Factors in Rhesus Monkeys
75
ing that the low 5-HTT expression may result in decreased serotonergic function (Heils et al., 1996). Although this genetic polymorphism was first detected in humans, it also appears in rhesus monkeys and, in fact, is found uniquely among simian primates and humans (Lesch et al., 1997). We recently have characterized a total of 237 rhesus monkeys in our Poolesville colony using polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-based genotype analysis in order to determine allelic frequency involving the short (398bp) and long (419bp) PCR fragments in the promoter region of the 5-HTT gene. These analyses revealed that the relative frequency of the homozygous long allele (LL) was approximately three times that of the relative frequency of the heterozygous short allele (LS). Curiously, only two subjects in the entire sample had the homozygous short allele (SS). However, among the 237 monkeys that were genotyped, 34 were of Chinese descent or were Chinese–Indian hybrids, and among these monkeys the relative frequency of the LS allele was more than twice as high (55% vs. 23%) as it was for monkeys of exclusively Indian origin. Moreover, consistent with our previous findings, as a group the Chinese/hybrid monkeys had significantly lower concentrations of CSF 5HIAA than their Indian-derived counterparts when age and gender factors were statistically partialled out. The suggestion that these subgroup differences in 5-HIAA concentrations, not to mention the behavioral differences described earlier, might be in part attributable to strain differences in the relative frequency of 5-HTT genetic polymorphisms represents an attractive, albeit as yet unproven, hypothesis. Some of the monkeys in the previously described Indian-derived subgroup had been peer-reared, whereas others had been reared by their biological mothers since birth. We found that the relative frequency of subjects possessing the short 5-HTT allele did not differ significantly between the two rearing groups, which was not surprising given that these monkeys had been more or less randomly preassigned to their respective rearing conditions at birth. Because we had collected CSF samples from those monkeys during their 2nd and 4th years of life under comparable experimental conditions (and while they were all living in comparable social groups), it was possible to determine whether their 5-HIAA concentrations differed as a function of their 5-HTT polymorphic status, as might be expected from the extant literature. Interestingly, we did find such a predicted relationship, with individuals possessing the LS allele having significantly lower 5-HIAA concentrations—but only among peer-reared subjects. For mother-reared subjects, 5-HIAA concentrations were essentially identical (and well within the normative range) for monkeys possessing either allele (Bennett et al., 2002; see Figure 4.3). Thus, these analyses demonstrated a significant genotype–environment interaction, wherein the ultimate effect of a polymorphism in a specific gene for a given individual appeared to be highly dependent on the specific early experience of that individual. In this case, mother-rearing appeared to buffer the infants from potentially deleterious effects of the LS allele on serotonin metabolism.
76
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
FIGURE 4.3. CSF concentrations of 5-HIAA in peer-reared LL, peer-reared LS, mother-reared LL, and mother-reared LS monkeys. The gene x rearing environment interaction is the result of significantly lower CSF 5-HIAA concentrations in peer-reared LS monkeys than the other three subject groups. From Bennett et al. (2002).
A different form of gene–environment interaction was suggested by the analysis of alcohol consumption data: Whereas peer-reared monkeys with the LS allele consumed more alcohol than peer-reared monkeys with the LL allele, the reverse was true for mother-reared subjects, with individuals possessing the LS allele actually consuming less alcohol than their LL counterparts (Bennett, Lesch, Heils, & Linnoila, 1998). A similar reversal was found for relative levels of alcohol intoxication (Barr et al., 2004). In other words, the LS allele was a risk factor for excessive alcohol consumption among peer-reared monkeys but was apparently a protective factor for mother-reared subjects. We are currently carrying out additional analyses involving other behavioral and physiological measures that had already been collected on these same mother- and peer-reared monkeys of known 5-HTT allelic status. For example, Champoux et al. (2002) examined the relationship between early rearing history and 5-HTT allelic status on measures of neonatal neurobehavioral development during the first month of life and found further evidence of maternal buffering. Specifically, infants possessing the LS allele who were being reared in the laboratory neonatal nursery showed significant deficits in measures of attention, activity, and motor maturity relative to nurseryreared infants possessing the LL allele, whereas both LS and LL infants who were being reared by competent mothers exhibited normal values for each of these measures. Other analyses (e.g., Barr et al., 2003) have yielded similar gene–environment interactional patterns of apparent maternal buffering of aggressive behavior. We believe that this buffering pattern will prove to be ubiquitous across a wide range of measures of rhesus monkey behavioral and biological functioning throughout development.
Genetic and Environmental Factors in Rhesus Monkeys
77
SUMMARY AND PERSPECTIVES This chapter has outlined a program of research investigating the development of excessive and socially inappropriate aggression in a subgroup of rhesus monkeys, biological correlates, and factors that can shape such development. The chapter described how aggression is typically socialized during the infant and juvenile years and contrasted this developmental pattern with that of the subgroup of individuals who consistently exhibit such aggression, as well as other behavioral manifestations of impulsivity and consistent deficits in a measure of central serotonin metabolism. These biobehavioral patterns emerge early in development, are maintained through puberty if not beyond, and are at least in part heritable. Male monkeys that develop these patterns in nature seldom survive beyond puberty, whereas females developing parallel patterns of inappropriate aggression and serotonergic dysfunctioning usually survive to bear and rear offspring—unfortunately, often in less than optimal fashion. Early rearing experiences can clearly influence the development of these biobehavioral patterns, even those with demonstrated heritability. Indeed, it appears that genetic and early experiential factors can and do interact to shape individual developmental trajectories. In particular, good mothering appears to somehow protect offspring at genetic risk for developing problems in behavioral and biological functioning when they are reared in less socially supportive settings (see Figure 4.4). My colleagues and I believe that the implications of these most recent findings are of considerable importance in a variety of domains. Beyond demonstrating that whether or not a particular genetic polymorphism has specific biobehavioral consequences may depend on certain early experiences, the present findings readily suggest several potentially promising avenues for future studies of impulsive aggressiveness in monkeys. One approach would be to become increasingly molecular in scope, focusing on demonstrations of specific gene expression, as well as delineating possible mechanisms by which specific early rearing experiences might trigger and/or otherwise influence gene expression. Indeed, this approach is currently being followed in an elegant program of research with rodents by Meaney and his colleagues (cf. Francis, Champagne, Liv, & Meanen, 1999). A second approach might focus on determining the generality of this and other types of gene–environment interaction with respect to other genes associated with particular human psychopathologies, as an increasing number of candidate genetic polymorphisms become identified and functionally characterized. Recently, Caspi et al. (2002) reported a specific gene–environment interaction involving a polymorphism in one monoamine oxidase A (MAOA) receptor gene and adverse early social experiences across a large cohort of adolescents and young adults in New Zealand. Individuals who possessed one form of the polymorphism were disproportionately likely to have been seriously involved in the juvenile justice system, but only if they had been abused
78
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
FIGURE 4.4. Rhesus monkey mothers, each holding an infant.
as children. We have basically replicated the overall pattern of these findings in our Poolesville rhesus monkey colony in a very recent study focusing on a functionally similar MAOA polymorphism (Newman et al., in press), and we are currently examining potential gene–environment interactions, as well as possible gene–gene interactions, in several other candidate genes. A third possible avenue for study involves identifying potentially optimal rearing environments that might serve to minimize the risk for developing psychopathology, or actually turn that risk into a potentially adaptive advantage. For example, we are currently in the middle of a cross-fostering experiment, in which infants selectively bred to have low versus high CSF 5HIAA concentrations are being foster-reared by mothers who differ systematically in their own CSF 5-HIAA concentrations. We are also studying the maternal behavior of females with chronically high versus low CSF 5HIAA concentrations at the Morgan Island field site, with the goal of determining the long-term adaptive consequence for offspring of differing genotypes. It is truly unfortunate that Markku Linnoila is no longer with us to help advance these endeavors. I think he would have been pleased with what has been found to date, and I’m certain he would be eager to press onward in the effort he urged us to begin so many years ago—using research with rhesus monkeys to better understand the basis for the relationship between serotonergic functioning and the expression of impulsive aggression in humans throughout development.
Genetic and Environmental Factors in Rhesus Monkeys
79
REFERENCES Alexander, B. K., & Harlow, H. F. (1966). Social behavior of juvenile rhesus monkeys subjected to different rearing conditions during the first 6 months of life. Zoologia Jahrb Physiologia, 60, 167–174. Barr, C. S., Newman, T. K., Becker, M. L., Parker, C. C., Champoux, M., Lesch, K. P., Goldman, D. A., Suomi, S. J, & Higley, J. D. (2003). The utility of the non-human primate model for studying gene by environment interactions in behavioral research. Genes, Brain, and Behavior, 2, 336–340. Barr, C. S., Newman, T. K., Lindell, S. G., Champoux, M., Lesch, K. P., Suomi, S. J., Goldman, D. A., & Higley, J. D. (2004). Interaction between serotonin transporter gene variation and rearing condition in alcohol preference and consumption in female primates. Archives of General Psychiatry, 61, 1146–1152. Bennett, A. J., Lesch, K. P., Heils, A., &., Linnoila, M. (1998). Serotonin transporter gene variation, CSF 5–HIAA concentrations, and alcohol-related aggression in rhesus monkeys (Macaca mulatta). American Journal of Primatology, 45, 168–169. Bennett, A. J., Lesch, K. P., Heils, A., Long, J., Lorenz, J., Shoaf, S. E., Champoux, M., Suomi, S. J., Linnoila, M. V., & Higley, J. D. (2002). Early experience and serotonin transporter gene variation interact to influence primate CNS function. Molecular Psychiatry, 7, 118–122. Berard, J. (1989). Male life histories. Puerto Rican Health Sciences Journal, 8, 47–58. Bernstein, I. S., Williams, L., & Ramsay, M. (1983). The expression of aggression in Old World monkeys. International Journal of Primatology, 4, 113–125. Caspi, A., McClay, J., Moffitt, T. E., Mill, J., Marin, J., Craig, I. W., Taylor, A., & Poulton, R. (2002). Role of genotype in the cycle of violence in maltreated children. Science, 297, 851–854. Champoux, M., Bennett, A. J., Shannonm C., Higley, J. D., Lesch, K. P., & Suomi, S. J. (2002). Serotonin transporter gene polymorphism, differential early rearing, and behavior in rhesus monkey neonates. Molecular Psychiatry, 7, 1158–1163. Champoux, M., Higley, J. D., & Suomi, S. J. (1997). Behavioral and physiological characteristics of Indian and Chinese-Indian hybrid rhesus macaque infants. Developmental Psychobiology, 31, 49–63. Champoux, M., Suomi, S. J., & Schneider, M. L. (1994). Temperamental differences between captive Indian and Chinese-Indian hybrid rhesus macaque infants. Laboratory Animal Science, 44, 351–357. Coccaro, E. M., & Murphy, D. L. (1990) Serotonin in major psychiatric disorders. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press. Francis, D. D., Champagne, F. A., Liu, D., & Meaney, M. J. (1999). Maternal care, gene expression, and the development of individual differences in stress reactivity. Annals of the New York Academy of Science, 896, 66–84. Harlow, H. F., & Harlow, M. K. (1969). Effects of various mother–infants relationships on rhesus monkey behaviors. In B. M. Foss (Ed)., Determinants of infant behaviour (Vol. 4, pp. 15–36). London: Metheun. Harlow, H. F., & Lauersdorf, H. E. (1974). Sex differences in passions and play. Perspectives in Biology and Medicine, 17, 348–360. Heils, A. Teufel, A., Petri, S., Stober, G., Riederer, P. Bengel, B., & Lesch, K. P. (1996). Allelic variation of human serotonin transporter gene expression. Journal of Neurochemistry, 6, 2621–2624. Heinz, A., Higley, J. D., Gorey, J. G., Saunders, R. C., Jones, D. W., Hommer, D., Zajicek,
80
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
K., Suomi, S. J., Weinberger, D. R., & Linnoila, M. (1998). In vivo association between alcohol intoxication, aggression, and serotonin transporter availability in nonhuman primates. American Journal of Psychiatry, 155, 1023–1028. Higley, J. D., Hasert, M. L., Suomi, S. J., & Linnoila, M. (1991a). A new nonhuman primate model of alcohol abuse: Effects of early experience, personality, and stress on alcohol consumption. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 88, 7261– 7265. Higley, J. D., King, S. T., Hasert, M. F., Champoux, M., Suomi, S. J., & Linnoila, M. (1996a). Stability of interindividual differences in serotonin function and its relationship to severe aggression and competent social behavior in rhesus macaque females. Neuropsychopharmacology, 14, 67–76. Higley, J. D., Mehlman, P. T., Taub, D. M., Higley, S., Fernald, B., Vickers, J. H., Suomi, S. J., & Linnoila, M. (1996b). Excessive mortality in young free-ranging male nonhuman primates with low CSF 5–HIAA concentrations. Archives of General Psychiatry, 53, 537–543. Higley, J. D., Mehlman, P. T., Taub, D. M., Higley, S. B., Vickers, J. H., Suomi, S. J., & Linnoila, M. (1992a). Cerebrospinal fluid monoamine and adrenal correlates of aggression in free-ranging rhesus monkeys. Archives of General Psychiatry, 49, 436– 441. Higley, J. D., & Suomi, S. J. (1996). Reactivity and social competence affect individual differences in reaction to severe stress in children: Investigations using nonhuman primates. In C. R. Pfeffer (Ed.), Intense stress and mental disturbance in children (pp. 3–58). Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press. Higley, J. D., Suomi, S. J., & Linnoila, M. (1990a). Developmental influences on the serotonergic system and timidity in the nonhuman primate. In E. M. Coccaro & D. L. Murphy (Eds.), Serotonin in major psychiatric disorders (pp. 27–46). Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press. Higley, J. D., Suomi, S. J., & Linnoila, M. (1990b). Parallels in aggression and serotonin: Consideration of development, rearing history, and sex differences. In H. van Praag, R. Plutchik, & A. Apter (Eds.), Violence and suicidality (pp. 245–256). New York: Bruner/Mazel. Higley, J. D., Suomi, S. J., & Linnoila, M. (1991b). CSF monoamine metabolite concentrations vary according to age, rearing, and sex, and are influenced by the stressor of social separation in rhesus monkeys. Psychopharmacology, 103, 551–556. Higley, J. D., Suomi, S. J., & Linnoila, M. (1992b). A longitudinal assessment of CSF monoamine metabolite and plasma cortisol concentrations in young rhesus monkeys. Biological Psychiatry, 32, 127–145. Higley, J. D., Suomi, S. J., & Linnoila, M. (1996c). A nonhuman primate model of Type II excessive alcohol consumption? Part 1: Low CSF 5–HIAA concentrations and diminished social competence correlate with excessive alcohol consumption. Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research, 20, 629–642. Higley, J. D., Suomi, S. J., & Linnoila, M. (1996d). A nonhuman model of Type II alcoholism? Part 2: Diminished social competence and excessive aggression correlates with low CSF 5–HIAA concentrations. Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research, 20, 643–650. Higley, J. D., Thompson, W. T., Champoux, M., Goldman, D., Hasert, M. F., Kraemer, G. W., Scanlan, J. M., Suomi, S. J., & Linnoila, M. (1993). Paternal and maternal genetic and environmental contributions to CSF monoamine metabolites in rhesus monkeys (Macaca mulatta). Archives of General Psychiatry, 50, 615–623.
Genetic and Environmental Factors in Rhesus Monkeys
81
Lahey, B. B., Moffitt, T. E., & Caspi, A. (2003). Causes of conduct disorder and juvenile delinquency. New York: Guilford Press. Lesch, K. P., Bengel, D., Heils, A., Sabol, S. Z., Greenberg, B. D., Petri, S., Benjamin, J., Muller, C. R., Hamer, D. H., & Murphy, D. L. (1996). Association of anxiety-related traits with a polymorphism in the serotonin transporter gene regulatory region. Science, 274, 1527–1531. Lesch, L. P., Meyer, J., Glatz, K., Flugge, G., Hinney, A., Hebebrand, J., Klauck, S. M., Poustka, A., Poustka, F., Bengel, D., Mossner, R., Riederer, P., & Heils, A. (1997). The 5–HT transporter gene-linked polymorphic region (5–HTTLPR) in evolutionary perspective: Alternative biallelic variation in rhesus monkeys. Journal of Neural Transmission, 104, 1259–1266. Lindburg, D. G. (1971). The rhesus monkey in north India: An ecological and behavioral study. In L. A. Rosenblum (Ed.), Primate behavior: Developments in field and laboratory research (Vol. 2, pp. 1–106). New York: Academic Press. Linnoila, M. (1988). Monoamines and impulse control. In J. A. Swinkels & W. Blijeven (Eds.), Depression, anxiety, and aggression (pp. 167–172). Houten, The Netherlands: Medidact. Linnoila, M., DeJong, J., & Virkkunen, M. (1989). Monoamines, glucose metabolism, and impulse control. Psychopharmacy Bulletin, 25, 404–406. Linnoila, M., Virkkunen, M., Scheinin, M., Nuutila, A., Rimon, R., & Goodwin, F. K. (1983). Low cebrospinal fluid 5–hydroxyindoleacetic acid concentration differentiates impulsive from nonimpulsive violent behavior. Life Sciences, 33, 2609–2614. Mehlman, P. T., Higley, J. D., Faucher, T., Lilly, A. A., Taub, D. M., Vickers, J., Suomi, S. J., & Linnoila, M. (1994). Low cerebrospinal fluid 5–hydroxyindoleacetic acid concentrations are correlated with severe aggression and reduced impulse control in free-ranging nonhuman primates (Macaca mulatta). American Journal of Psychiatry, 151, 1485–1491. Mehlman, P. T., Higley, J. D., Faucher, I., Lilly, A. A., Taub, D. M., Vickers, J. M., Suomi, S. J., & Linnoila, M. (1995). CSF 5–HIAA concentrations are correlated with sociality and the timing of emigration in free-ranging primates. American Journal of Psychiatry, 152, 907–913. Mehlman, P. T., Higley, J. D., Fernald, B. J., Sallee, F. R., Suomi, S. J., & Linnoila, M. (1997). CSF 5–HIAA, testosterone, and sociosexual behaviors in free-ranging male macaques during the breeding season. Psychiatric Research, 72, 89–102. Newman, T. K., Syagailo, Y., Barr, C. S., Wendland, J., Champoux, M., Graessle, M., Suomi, S. J., Highley, J. D., & Lesch, K. P. (in press). Monoamine oxidase: A gene promoter polymorphism and infant rearing experience interact to influence aggression and injuries in rhesus monkeys. Biological Psychiatry. Ruppenthal, G. C., Harlow, M. K., Eisele, C. D., Harlow, H. F., & Suomi, S. J. (1974). Development of peer interactions of monkeys reared in a nuclear family environment. Child Development, 45, 670–682. Steklis, H. D., Brammen, G. L., Raleigh, M. J., & McGuire, M. T. (1985). Serum testosterone, male dominance, and aggression in captive groups of vervet monkeys (Cercopithecus aethiops sabacus). Hormones and Behavior, 19, 156–165. Suomi, S. J. (1995). Influence of Bowlby’s attachment theory on research on nonhuman primate biobehavioral development. In S. Goldberg, R. Muir, & J. Kerr (Eds.), Attachment theory: Social, developmental, and clinical perspectives (pp. 185–201). Hillsdale, NJ: Analytic Press. Suomi, S. J. (1999). Attachment in rhesus monkeys. In J. Cassidy & P. R. Shaver (Eds.),
82
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
Handbook of attachment: Theory, research, and clinical applications (pp. 181– 197). New York: Guilford Press. Suomi, S. J., & Harlow, H. F. (1975). The role and reason of peer friendships. In M. Lewis & L. A. Rosenblum (Eds.) Friendships and peer relations (pp. 310–334). New York: Basic Books. Suomi, S. J., & Levine, S. (1998). Psychobiology of intergenerational effects of trauma: Evidence from animal studies. In Y. Daniele (Ed.), International handbook of multigenerational legacies of trauma (pp. 623–637.) New York: Plenum Press. Symonds, D. (1978). Play and aggression: A study of rhesus monkeys. New York: Columbia University Press. Westergaard, C. G., Suomi, S. J., Chavanne, T. J., Houser, L., Hurlye, A. C., Cleveland, A., Snoy, P., & Higley, J. D. (2003). Physiological correlates of aggression and impulsivity in free-ranging female primates. Neuropsychopharmacology, 28, 1045– 1055.
THE DEVELOPMENT Physical Aggression in Humans OF AGGRESSION
5 The Developmental Origins of Physical Aggression in Humans R ICHARD E. T REMBLAY and D ANIEL S. N AGIN
We here saw the native Fuegan; an untamed savage is I really think one of the most extraordinary spectacles in the world.—the difference between a domesticated & wild animal is far more strikingly marked in man . . . with difficulty we see a fellowcreature. —DARWIN (1832/1985, pp. 302–303)
The aim of this chapter is to summarize our present knowledge on the development of physical aggression from early childhood to adulthood, and to discuss the mechanisms that could explain this development. We define physical aggression as the use of physical force against another person with an object (e.g., stick, rock, bullet) or without (e.g., slap, push, punch, kick, bite). The verbs fight, assault, attack, and bully are often used to summarize the actions during a physical aggression. Antecedents and consequences can be used to subdivide this subcategory of aggressions (see Gendreau & Archer, Chapter 2, this volume). However, inasmuch as most developmental studies of physical aggression have not made these distinctions, we will generally refer to an overall category of physical aggression.
THE SOCIAL–HISTORICAL–PHILOSOPHICAL–MORAL CONTEXT OF RESEARCH ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF PHYSICAL AGGRESSION Physical aggression is a socially “hot” topic. An act of physical aggression can make the difference between life and death. Physical violence is omnipresent daily in the mass media of modern societies (Bushman & Anderson, 2001) in 83
84
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
the same way that it is a constant preoccupation for animals living in the wild. Physical aggression is of concern as much to the health professionals (World Health Organization, 2002) as to the social–psychological well-being professionals (U.S. Human Capital Initiative, 1997). Concerted efforts to suppress physical aggression in human interactions is one of the major historical social transformations observed in countries of the Western world in the later part of the 20th century. A half-century ago, it was generally considered normal for elementary school teachers to physically punish students for spelling errors. Elementary school principals used leather straps to discipline disruptive students. Caning was still in use in English public and state schools. In other words, some forms of physical force against others were considered morally acceptable, and were even recommended. Note that in all of these examples an adult uses physical force against a child. Two learning specialists who spent their careers studying nonhuman primates conclude that physical punishment is the natural pedagogical tool (Premack & Premack, 2003). There is now a strong movement to make these practices criminal acts. Some go as far as to argue that parents should not take their children in their arms without asking the children for their permission. Zero tolerance has become the rule concerning physical aggression on the school playground, in the neighborhood, and at home, between spouses and between parents and children. Not using physical force against another human has become the hallmark of a civilized human. The difference in attitudes between 1950 and 2000 is certainly striking. But the difference is still more impressive when we compare late-20th-century attitudes to those of past centuries. Consider the educational practices in one of the great eras of the English public schools. When the 24-year-old Charles Darwin described to his sister the marked difference between “an untamed savage” and his civilized compatriots, the famous educationist and scholar Thomas Arnold had been appointed headmaster of Rugby for less than 4 years. Harold Nicolson (1955) writes that Arnold was convinced that the boys should be whipped to learn their moral responsibilities. To enforce his “muscular Christianity,” he organized a disciplinary system in which older boys ruled by fagging and by beating the younger boys. All accounts of 19thcentury English public schools indicate that bullying was not the exception but the rule. Nicolson cites the following description from Thackeray: “There are at this present writing 500 boys at Eton, kicked and licked and bullied by another 100” (1955, p. 263). Previous centuries were not less violent. Consider the general use of torture and homicide by kings and priests during the most civilized times of Erasmus, Luther, Galileo, Mozart, and Voltaire. Indeed, Eisner (2003) documents that homicide rates in western Europe declined 50- to 100-fold over the past 5 centuries. And what did the civilized Romans enjoy most on a nice leisurely afternoon? A bloody battle among gladiators and starved lions! From an evolutionary perspective, aggression is a solution to a problem (Archer, 1988). From a social, historical, and moral perspective, humans de-
Physical Aggression in Humans
85
cide at different places and times which solutions are acceptable. Concerning the use of the word aggress, the American Heritage Dictionary (1985) says: “Though the verb aggress has a long and honorable history, it has lately come to be associated primarily with the jargon of psychology and is often objected to.” Indeed, there seems to have been much change in our attitudes toward the use of physical force by humans. But how deeply rooted is this change? The two world wars of the 20th century killed close to 30 million soldiers, Hitler managed to exterminate approximately 6 million Jews, and nearly 200,000 Japanese civilians were killed by two atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. The United States saw a huge increase in homicides and other violent crimes during the 1990s, mainly among adolescents and young adults (Blumstein & Wallman, 2000; McCord, Widom, & Crowell, 2001). On December 31, 2002, the number of persons in U.S. prisons was equivalent to approximately half the population of Norway (2 million), and a year earlier the richest country in the history of humanity had close to 70 prisoners waiting to be executed for crimes they committed before they were 18 years of age (Bureau of Justice Statistics, 2003; Steinberg & Scott, 2003). Planes are hijacked to destroy skyscrapers filled with thousands of people. We are still killing tens of thousands of people to gain control of a country, and in some European cities conflicts force children to go to school under the protection of the army. The physical violence described here victimizes millions of humans, but only a very small minority of the inhabitants of the wealthy countries will be among these victims. Paradoxically, this fortunate minority, who are less and less at risk of being physically aggressed by a parent, a teacher, a spouse, a neighbor, a stranger, or a soldier, are using a large part of their financial resources and leisure time to consume fictive depictions of physical violence on television, in movies, and in electronic games. This behavior of the most civilized humans in the history of humanity is certainly quite a puzzlement. But still more puzzling is the contrast between this strange addiction to fictive violence by humans who have been educated not to use physical violence, and the results of research published in the top scientific journals, which conclude that the more individuals look at physical violence, the more they become physically aggressive (Anderson & Bushman, 2002; Johnson, Cohen, Smailes, Kasen, & Brook, 2002). Thanks to modern technology, citizens of present-day industrialized nations have, during their lives, seen more physical aggressions causing death than any Roman who had a lifelong Coliseum season ticket. By what peculiar process are these hungryfor-physical-violence modern humans passing laws to eradicate physical violence from their daily lives?
THE AGE–VIOLENT CRIME CURVE Two important scientific committees published reports in the 1990s on the causes and prevention of violence. The U.S. National Research Council panel
86
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
(Reiss & Roth, 1993) concluded that “modern psychological perspectives emphasize that aggressive and violent behaviors are learned responses to frustration, that they can also be learned as instruments for achieving goals, and that the learning occurs by observing models of such behaviors. Such models may be observed in the family, among peers, elsewhere in the neighborhood, through the mass media, or in violent pornography, for example” (p. 7, emphasis in original). Four years later the report of the U.S. Human Capital Initiative (1997) coordinating committee on reducing violence concluded: In short, watching violent movies and television shows year after year and listening to brutal lyrics set to throbbing music can change one’s attitudes about antisocial, aggressive behavior. In children it can lead to more aggressive behavior and also can evoke unwarranted fears and defensive actions. Whatever the violent content, movies and television exert powerful influences through visual imagery and dramatic characterizations; video games may have similar effects. (p. 12)
Figure 5.1 is a representation of the age-specific rate (per 100,000) of individuals arrested (United States) and accused (Canada) for violent offenses (physical aggressions) in 2001. It can be seen that violent offenses appear in preadolescence, increase sharply during adolescence, and then decrease slowly. If young humans learn to physically aggress by imitation of aggressions observed in the home, in the neighborhood, and in the media, the increase in physical violence during adolescence makes sense. The older they are, the more they have observed acts of physical aggression, and the more likely they are to do what they have seen. The beauty of these data is not only that they confirm the prevalent psychological theory, but they replicate the data that Adolphe Quetelet (1833), the Belgian astronomer/statistician, started collecting in the late 1820s. This was at the time Thomas Arnold was becoming headmaster of Rugby and Charles Darwin was a student at Cambridge. While Darwin was traveling around the world to catch beetles and observe volcanoes, the Belgian astronomer/statistician decided to quantify the physical, cognitive, and moral development of humans. The age–crime curve is probably the most robust criminological observation (see Sampson & Laub, 2003). However, if social learning explains the increase in physical violence during adolescence, it does not explain the decrease during adulthood. Quetelet, who was interested in moral development, but also in cognitive and physical development (he invented the Body Mass Index), used a biological explanation (intensity of physical strength and passions), which is close to the modern biological explanation that challenges the social learning hypothesis. The modern explanation is testosterone (see Ellis & Coontz, 1990; Harris, Rushton, Hampson, & Jackson, 1996; Tremblay et al., 1997; and Van Goozen, Chapter 14, this volume). T, as it is known by endocrinologists, has been shown to correlate with physical violence and not only increases substantially from early to late adolescence, but also decreases
Physical Aggression in Humans
87
FIGURE 5.1. Age–crime curve in 2001 in the United States and Canada.
during adulthood, hence following the age–violent-crime curve. Testosterone has the added power to explain the sex difference in physical aggression. Indeed, T is the male hormone. Although the adrenal glands and ovaries of women produce T and this production increases during adolescence, the levels of T at the end of adolescence are 20 times higher in males than in females. From this perspective, in his explanation of the causes of antisocial behavior, Quetelet would have been closer to the truth than Jean-Jacques Rousseau, the most famous advocate of the theory of social learning as an explanation of bad behavior (Rousseau, 1762/1979). T feeds muscles and thus increases strength: the fuel for Quetelet’s strength and passion hypothesis.
AGGRESSION BEFORE PUBERTY The main problem with the age–violent-crime curve studies is that they focus on adolescents and adults. Criminologists have tended to neglect humans before the start of adolescence because they cannot be considered legally delinquent. Since Quetelet, at least, criminologists have fed on data produced by the legal system. Only very recently have they started to study precursors of criminal behavior before adolescence. Do humans physically aggress each other before the start of adolescence? The age–violent-crime curve figures give the impression that physical aggressions appear with the legal age for criminal
88
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
responsibility as if lawmakers had chosen the age for criminal responsibility after detailed studies of child development. Those who decided to study elementary school children to understand the precursors of adolescent delinquency discovered that elementary school children use physical aggression before puberty increases their production of T, and before they have accumulated 12 or 13 years of social learning. The Columbia County Study, initiated in the state of New York in 1960, was one of the rare longitudinal studies of elementary school children specifically focused on aggression. More than 800 third-grade schoolchildren rated each other on different behavioral dimensions, including aggression, to test the social learning hypothesis. Following the analysis of the first wave of data when the children were 8 years old, the investigators gave the following summary of their findings: “It is fair to say that all the major findings of that analysis were consistent with the hypothesis that aggression may be learned by a child from his interactions with his environment” (Lefkowitz, Eron, Walder, & Huesmann, 1977, p. 37). Note that this was a conclusion drawn from cross-sectional data. Later analyses of data collected at ages 8, 19, and 30 revealed relatively high correlations between aggression assessments at these different points in time (Huesmann, Eron, Lefkowitz, & Walder, 1984). These results led Eron (1990), in his presidential address to the International Society for Research on Aggression in 1990, to conclude that aggression crystallizes at 8 years of age. Thus, the social learning of aggression would occur much earlier than the start of the age–violent-crime curve. But there were two important limitations with the Columbia County Study. First, the aggression scale used at age 8 should have been labeled a “disruptive behavior” scale (e.g., who does not obey the teacher, who gives dirty looks, who does things that bother others, who is always getting in trouble). Only 2 of the 10 items referred specifically to physical aggressions (who starts a fight over nothing; who pushes and shoves children). The second limitation is that the data collection points had 10-year gaps, making it impossible to study developmental trajectories. Fortunately, a similar U.S. study was initiated 20 years later and collected annual data on physical aggression. The Carolina Longitudinal Study followed 220 boys and girls from 4th to 12th grade and obtained assessments of physical aggression from the students and the teachers (Cairns & Cairns, 1994). Analyses of these data painted an unexpected picture in regard to the “social learning” and “testosterone” hypotheses. The information from teachers, as well as from students, showed a clear mean decrease in the frequency of physical aggression from 10 to 18 years of age, and this was true for males as well as for females (Cairns, Cairns, Neckerman, Ferguson, & Gariépy, 1989). How could longitudinal data from a population sample of American adolescents, living in a southern state, show a physical aggression curve exactly the reverse of the age–violent-crime curve? One explanation could be that although the majority of youth reduce the frequency of physical aggressions as they grow older, a minority are increasing
Physical Aggression in Humans
89
their frequency of physical violence and are being processed through the legal system that generates the statistics for the age-crime curve. To test this hypothesis, we needed to go beyond a description of the mean developmental trajectories of a given sample and identify the different types of developmental trajectories that children were following. Nagin and Tremblay (1999) used a semiparametric mixture model with a longitudinal sample of more than 1,000 kindergarten boys in schools from low socioeconomic areas of Montreal to describe these different trajectories. Why use males from low socioeconomic areas to study the development of physical aggression? The answer can be found in the report “Reducing Violence” from the U.S. Human Capital Initiative (1997) coordinating committee: “Certain environmental conditions not only trigger violence, they can also seem to teach aggressive or violent behavior patterns. For example, poverty is associated with both sudden violent outbursts and long-term, habitual aggression” (p. 11). Results (Figure 5.2) from teacher ratings confirmed the North Carolina data. The large majority of boys from the poorest inner city areas of Canada were using physical aggression less frequently as they grew older. Only a very small group of boys (4%) did not show the declining trend; these were the boys who had the highest levels of physical aggression in kindergarten, which remained at the highest level until adolescence. When interviewed at ages 15 and 17, they were the boys who reported the highest frequency of physical violence and those the ones most frequently found guilty of infractions before
FIGURE 5.2. Physical aggression trajectories. From Nagin and Tremblay (1999). Copyright 1999 by the Society for Research in Child Development. Reprinted by permission.
90
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
18 years of age. Thus, the increase in the age-crime curve during adolescence for physical aggressions would be produced by the fact that, during this period, the police and judicial system start arresting and convicting individuals who have been physically aggressing others at least since kindergarten. An international team of investigators replicated these finding using five other longitudinal studies in Canada, New Zealand, and the United States (Broidy et al. 2003).
AGGRESSION BEFORE SCHOOL ENTRY Figure 5.2 clearly shows that all the boys tended to be at their peak level in frequency of physical aggression at 6 years of age, when they were at the end of their kindergarten year. If this is the case, when do such children start to use physical aggression? Is the social learning of physical aggression occurring during the kindergarten year? Studies of preschool children suggest that if humans need to learn to physically aggress, the learning occurs before school entry. There is a long history of case studies of physical aggression in young children. One of the first publications of a “developmental origins of aggression” study appeared during the reign of the Roman Emperor Arcadius (A.D. 395–408). The 46-year-old Augustine of Thagaste (397/1960, p. 49), later known as St. Augustine, when writing his Confessions, realized that he could not remember his first sins. Instead of concluding, like Sigmund Freud, that he needed to “psycho-analyze” himself, he decided to observe babies, reasoning, in all humility, that they must be doing what he did at their age. Following these observations he writes: “Were these things good . . . [when] my parents, and many other prudent people who would not indulge in my whims, when I struck at them and tried to hurt them as far as I could because they did not obey orders that would be obeyed only to my harm?” One millenium and a half later, in the “Rage” section of the The Expression of the Emotions in Man and Animals, Darwin (1872, p. 243) wrote: “Every one who has had much to do with young children must have seen how naturally they take to biting, when in a passion. It seems as instinctive in them as in young crocodiles, who snap their little jaws as soon as they emerge from the egg.” Fifty-nine years after this other jewel by Darwin, two books were published by two women who pioneered 20th-century quantitative studies of early human social-emotional development. The two books used different methodologies. Katharine M. Bantham Bridges was a professor of psychology in the McGill department of psychology and a psychologist in the university’s nursery school. Her book (Bridges, 1931) presented social development and emotional development scales created by daily observations of 2–5-year-old children in the nursery school. One of her conclusions was that children, more than adults, were susceptible to anger expressed by physical aggression. Interestingly, 2 years later, she introduced a paper on the observation of 62 chil-
Physical Aggression in Humans
91
dren, between 3 weeks and 2 years of age, by writing that “the trends of development” between 2 and 5 years of age described in her previous book “must have had their beginnings in early infancy” (Bridges, 1933, p. 36). Her 3month cross-sectional observation of infant interactions led her to the conclusion that by 1 year of age children start “to struggle slightly for possession” of objects, and by 15 months “aggressive attacks are indulged in at this stage for their own sake and are not out-grown till well after two years of age” (p. 48). At exactly the same time, Florence Goodenough (1931), a professor at the University of Minnesota Institute of Child Welfare, was studying anger in young children by asking “intelligent parents,” mostly college graduates, to keep records of their children’s anger outbursts during a 1-month period. Two children were not yet 1 year old (7 and 11 months), 9 were between 17 and 23 months, 13 were between 26 and 35 months, 10 were between 36 and 46 months, and the 11 others ranged from 53 to 94 months. One thousand eight hundred and seventy-eight anger outbursts were recorded, for a mean of approximately 1 outburst per 10 hours of observation. As shown in Figure 5.3a, the 17- to 23-month-olds had the highest mean, with 1.3 outbursts per 10 hours. Interestingly, data from a longitudinal study of temper tantrums reported by the mothers of a sample of 126 Belgian children at the end of the 1950s led to very similar results (Sand, 1966; Figure 5.3b). Goodenough and Sand specifically studied the frequency of physical and verbal aggressions during the angry outbursts. They both concluded that as they grow older, children use fewer physical aggressions. Goodenough specifically concluded that with age they attempt more often to hurt the feelings of others (see Vaillancourt, Chapter 8, this volume). An observational study of French children’s social interactions in daycare during the 1970s reported on the frequency of physical aggressions, as compared with other forms of social interactions, for children of different age groups (Restoin et al., 1985). A total of 30 hours of filmed interactions were coded. Results represented in Figure 5.3c show a trend that is very similar to those in parent reports in Figures 5.3a and 3b. The relative frequency of physical aggression increases from the first year after birth to the second, and then decreases. Holmberg (1977) also found that physical attacks increased from 12 to 30 months, and then decreased from 30 to 42 months, when she observed 16 boys and girls interacting with peers in the United States. Recently, similar results were obtained with parent reports in two large Canadian-based longitudinal and cross-sectional studies. From 9 months to 30 months of age the proportion of children who are reported to use physical aggressions increases substantially (Tremblay, 2004); in addition, the frequency of use appears to increase up to nearly the end of the third year after birth (Tremblay et al., 2004). This remarkable increase is then followed by a continuous decline in frequency (Côté Vaillancourt, LeBlanc, Nagin, & Tremblay, 2004; Tremblay et al., 1996). Clearly, the same general developmental picture is drawn whether we use data from different times (1920s, 1970s, or 1990s), data from different countries (Belgium, Canada, France or the United States), data from different re-
92
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
FIGURE 5.3a. Frequency of anger outbursts for 10 hours of observation. Data from Goodenough (1931).
porting sources (filmed interactions in day care, parents’ detailed records, or parents’ recall of behavior in the past months), or data from different methodologies (cross-sectional or longitudinal, calculated as an absolute frequency over a given period of time, a relative percentage of social behaviors, a percentage of individuals using the behavior, or a general estimate of the frequency of the behavior). Frequency of anger outbursts and physical aggression increase rapidly from the first year after birth to approximately the third, and then the frequency decreases. Unfortunately, none of the longitudinal studies that started in early childhood have yet reported on physical aggression up to the end of adolescence. From the Restoin et al. (1985) data it appears that at the peak frequency of physical aggression in a day care environment, physical aggression represents one in four social interactions. This is certainly a high frequency of ag-
FIGURE 5.3b. Percentage of children reported to have a temper tantrum at least every day. Data from Sand (1966).
Physical Aggression in Humans
93
FIGURE 5.3c. Relative frequency of aggressive behavior between peers from age 6 to 36 months in day care centers. Data from Restoin et al. (1985).
gressions, but even at the worst of times, there are more prosocial or neutral social interactions than there are physically aggressive ones. This can probably be said for any social group, whether it is composed of nonhuman primates (see de Waal, 2000; also see Suomi, Chapter 4, this volume) or Hell’s Angels. Social life would probably be impossible within a group where physical aggression is the most frequent form of social interaction. However, it does appear clear that most humans have used physical aggression before they reach 36 months of age, that humans use physical aggression most often between 18 and 42 months after birth, and that if humans are learning to physically aggress through imitation, this learning is happening in the first 2 years after birth, not by watching television and playing video games in middle childhood or adolescence. After many decades of training chimpanzees to use “language,” David and Ann Premack (2003, p. 72) wrote: “Biting, hitting, kicking, scratching, pushing are natural reactions to the offensive behavior of another individual. These require no training.”
CAUSES OF PHYSICAL AGGRESSION DURING EARLY CHILDHOOD The causes of physical aggression during early childhood can be considered from many different perspectives, both with reference to the sequence of events (e.g., proximal and distal causes) and with reference to the level of analysis (e.g., behavioral, psychological, physiological, genetic). For example, from the proximal perspective we can investigate the time, the place, and the events that appear to trigger physical aggression by an infant. We can also focus on the emotional characteristics of the child prior to, during, and after an agonistic interaction. Such investigations could target the external expression (e.g., facial expression) or the physiological expression (e.g., heart rate, cortisol levels).
94
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
Most observers of proximal causes of physical aggressions by infants and toddlers have concluded that anger is the main “emotional” antecedent, and that this anger is provoked either by something that prevents the child from getting what he or she wants, or by a request for the child to do something he or she does not want to do (e.g., Bridges, 1933; Goodenough, 1931; Hay, Chapter 6, this volume). The most frequent situational “cause” of physical aggressions among young children is competition for desirable objects or space. Note that these motivations appear not very different from those that lead adult humans to war between countries, inasmuch as these tend to be instigated by competition over desirable resources (e.g., oil) or territories (e.g., for access to the sea). Thus, in humans, as in other species, from the beginning of life onward, the function of many instances of physical aggressions is competition for resources (see Archer, 1988). The developmental trajectories described earlier in this chapter do not help much in identifying proximal causes of physical aggressions, but they do help in understanding distal causes. The distal perspective tends to look for the mechanisms that are put in place over a long period of time and explains at least two different mechanisms: (1) how an individual acquires the ability to physically aggress and (2) why he or she tends to use this ability. For example, the social learning hypothesis appears to argue that a human who has never witnessed a physical aggression in his life could not use physical aggression, even when extremely angry, because he or she would not have “learned” to physically aggress. It is a very different argument from the one stating that infants do not need to learn to physically aggress, but the more they witness physical aggressions the more they are likely to use them when they become angry. The first part of the prior sentence refers to mechanism (1), and the second part refers to mechanism (2). The developmental data we have presented in this chapter appear to indicate that children do not need to have seen models of physical aggression in order to start using physical aggression (onset), unless this learning through models occurs for almost every child during the first 9–15 months after birth. Indeed, by 17 months of age most children are reported by their parents to have used some form of physical force to get what they want or to express their anger (Tremblay et al., 1999a). The developmental trajectories of physical aggression also indicate that having frequently observed models of physical aggression generally does not lead to an increase in the frequency of physical aggression. This can be concluded from the fact that, as they grow older, the majority of children have seen more and more instances of physical aggression, and their frequency of physical aggression decreases. If models of physical aggression have an impact, it is probably by reducing the speed at which children learn not to use physical aggression. Indeed, the declining frequency of physical aggressions with age indicates that the vast majority of children are learning not to use physical aggression as they grow older. It could be argued that the reason for the decline is the reduction of occasions for conflict as children grow older.
Physical Aggression in Humans
95
However, the increase in verbal and indirect aggressions with age (see Vaillancourt, Chapter 8, this volume) suggests that reasons for physical aggressions remain, but that children are learning other ways to deal with them. The developmental trajectories described in this chapter indicate that living with others, even in violent environments, forces individuals to learn, as they grow older, to gain some control over their social behavior. Thus, there seems to be much more pressure to learn not to physically aggress than to learn to physically aggress. Even children in “high-risk” families are likely to observe a greater proportion of nonphysically aggressive interactions in their environment, because there is a high probability that no social group could survive for long if the majority of their interactions were physically aggressive. There has been much research over the past 2 decades on the “onset” of children’s disruptive behaviors, such as physical aggressions, property “offenses” (e.g., stealing), and hyperactivity. Most of that work has focused on school-age children (e.g., Lahey et al., 1999; Loeber, Green, Keenan, & Lahey, 1995; Tremblay, Pihl, Vitaro, & Dobkin, 1994). The longitudinal data we have examined from infancy onward leads us to think that physical aggression is not a behavior children learn, like reading or writing, nor an illness children “catch,” like poliomyelitis or smallpox. It is rather a behavior like crying, eating, sleeping, grasping, throwing, and running, which young humans exhibit when the physiological structure is in place, but then learn to control with experience. The learning-to-control process implies regulating one’s needs to accommodate those of others, and this process can be labeled “socialization” (see Paus, Chapter 12, as well as Séguin & Zelazo, Chapter 15, this volume). It is not hard to understand why the evolutionary process would give humans a genetic program that codes for all the basic mechanisms to react to hunger and to threat. Young children’s muscles are activated to run, push, kick, grab, hit, throw, and yell with extreme force when hungry, when angry, or when they are strongly attracted by something. In his Expression of the Emotions, Darwin (1872) anticipates present-day brain imaging techniques when he describes the reddening of the skin during a state of rage and gives this example: “With one of my own infants, under four months old, I repeatedly observed that the first symptom of an approaching passion was the rushing of the blood into his bare scalp” (p. 240). Stating that humans are genetically programmed to be able to physically aggress when needed, is different from stating that the frequency of the physical aggression they use is genetically programmed. Thus, although all 18-month-olds who have developed normally can, and possibly do, physically aggress, not all do so at the same frequency and with the same vigor. The trajectories shown in Figure 5.2 clearly indicate that these individual differences exist at any given point, but also over time. The gene–environment mechanisms are probably very similar to the developmental trajectories of growth in height. Genes code for the growth mechanisms, but there are individual differences in this coding, as well as environmental differences (e.g., access to food) that lead to individual differences in growth in height. Thus,
96
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
these individual differences in the frequency of physical aggressions can be due to a large number of causes—for example, individual differences in the genetic coding for serotonin (see Pihl & Benkelfat, Chapter 13, this volume), testosterone (Van Goozen, Chapter 14, this volume), or language development (see Dionne, Chapter 16, this volume), or cognitive development (see Séguin & Zelazo, Chapter 15, this volume), or to environmental differences such as tobacco use during pregnancy (see Wakschlag, Pickett, Cook, Benowitz, & Leventhal, 2002), birth complications (see Arseneault, Tremblay, Boulerice, & Saucier, 2002), parental care (see Gatti & Tremblay, Chapter 19, this volume; Raine, Brennan, & Mednick, 1997; Zoccolillo et al., Chapter 17, this volume), and peer characteristics (see Boivin, Vitaro, & Poulin, Chapter 18, this volume). However, the individual differences that we observe are very likely to be due to interactions between many of these mechanisms, and hence to epigenetic mechanisms (Francis, Diorio, Plotsky, & Meaney, 2002; Francis, Szegda, Campbell, Martin, & Insel, 2003; Raine, 2002; Tremblay, 2003; Weaver et al., 2004). Dionne, Tremblay, Boivin, Laplante, and Pérusse (2003) showed, with a large sample of 19-month-old female and male twins, that variance in mothers’ reports of physical aggression was explained about equally by genetic and environmental factors. Similar results were observed with an older sample of twins for assessments of antisocial behavior (e.g., Arseneault et al., 2003; Slutske et al., 1997), but the Dionne et al. study shows that both the genetic and environmental distal causes of physical aggression are in place by 19 months of age, long before the violent video games and the delinquent peers. A similar story is being told by the molecular genetic studies of physical violence. With a longitudinal study of a New Zealand male birth cohort, Caspi et al. (2002) observed that children of abusive and neglectful parents who had a genotype leading to high levels of monoamine oxidase A (MAOA) expression were at much less risk of having a disposition toward violence as young adults and being convicted for violent crimes. We need molecular genetic and twin studies to identify which environmental factors interact with which genetic factors to explain the individual differences in developmental trajectories of physical aggression from early childhood to adulthood. The following is an example of the first few steps in a program of longitudinal studies that pursues this aim. A large population sample of newborns (singletons and twins) are assessed annually from 5 months onward, with physical aggression assessed annually from 17 months (Dionne et al., 2003; Tremblay et al., 2004). Semiparametric statistical analyses of physical aggression data at 17, 30, and 42 months with the singletons indicated that there were three different developmental trajectories (Figure 5.4). Variables measuring parental characteristics before birth were used as predictors of the probability that a child would be on the high-level physical aggression trajectory. Controlling for all other measured variables, the best predictors were presence of a sibling (odds ratio [OR] = 4.00), mother’s history of antisocial behavior before the end of high school (OR = 3.1), mother’s age
Physical Aggression in Humans
97
FIGURE 5.4. Trajectories of physical aggression from 17 to 42 months of age. From Tremblay et al. (2004).
when her first child was born (OR= 3.1), low family income (OR= 2.6), and a mother who smoked (OR= 2.2). Two variables measured at 5 months of age also contributed to the prediction: mother’s coercive parenting (OR = 2.3) and family dysfunction (OR = 2.2). This list of predictors for high levels of physical aggression from infancy to toddlerhood is amazingly similar to the variables that have traditionally been shown to predict physical aggression during the school years and delinquency during adolescence (Bovet, 1951; Brennan, Grekin, & Mednick., 1999; Loeber & Dishion, 1983; Nagin & Tremblay, 2001; Tremblay & LeMarquand, 2001). This would be expected if those who have high levels of physical aggression during childhood and adolescence were frequent users of physical aggression during early childhood. Some of the predictors point to causal mechanisms, and others are markers of unclear mechanisms. For example, the sibling variable appears to indicate that young children who have a target are much more likely to use physical aggression (Dunn & Munn, 1985). The smoking variable replicates the increasing number of longitudinal studies suggesting that nicotine has a negative effect on fetal brain development (Brennan, 2003; Fergusson, Woodward, & Horwood, 1998; Wakschlag et al., 2002). Antisocial behavior of the mother during her adolescence could be a marker for many causal mechanisms (see Keenan & Shaw, 1994). First, it could be a marker for some form of genetic transmission of a propensity to impulsive and aggressive behavior (see Caspi et al., 2002; Suomi, Chapter 4,
98
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
this volume; and Pihl & Benkelfat, Chapter 13, this volume). It could also be a marker for the quality of the environment the mother is creating for the child both during the prenatal (e.g., quality of nutrition, stress) and postnatal (e.g., maternal care) periods (Francis et al., 2003). Finally, it could be a marker for both the genetic and environmental contribution of the father, inasmuch as there is much assortative mating (e.g., Rowe & Farrington, 1997). Similarly, family income is probably a marker for many different causal mechanisms, some of which could be quality of nutrition during the prenatal and postnatal periods The two predictors measured at 5 months of age (maternal coercive behavior toward the child and family dysfunction) suggest that children who use physical aggression more frequently than others during infancy are the victims and witnesses of a disproportionately large amount of physical aggressions during their first year after birth. We need more detailed observational and physiological studies of parent–child interactions in these families during the first 12–18 months to understand the mechanisms by which the adult behaviors have an impact on the child’s propensity to use physical aggression. Cross-fostering experiments like those done by Francis et al. (2003), Weaver et al. (2004), and Suomi and his colleagues (see Chapter 4, this volume) would give better insights into causal mechanisms than studies that are limited to observations. Obviously, it would be hard to do such studies with humans. However, prevention experiments that aim to help high-risk families to give better care to their children during early childhood (e.g., Campbell & Ramey, 1994; Olds et al. 1998) could be used to understand the mechanisms that prevent children from behaving as if physical aggression were the best option for adjusting to their environments.
CONCLUSIONS I can say in my own favour that I was as a boy humane, but I owed this entirely to the instruction and example of my sisters. I doubt indeed whether humanity is a natural or innate quality. —DARWIN (1876, p. 11)
The first aim of this chapter was to summarize our present knowledge of the development of physical aggression from early childhood to adulthood. Unfortunately, none of the large longitudinal studies of humans followed from early childhood to adulthood seem to have collected repeated measures of physical aggression throughout the study. Thus, to describe the lifespan intraindividual changes in the physical aggression of humans, we had to put together a patchwork of longitudinal studies that covered different age periods with samples from different populations. Figure 5.5 is a rough representation of this patchwork. The physical aggression trajectories from adolescence to adulthood are modeled on the data from White, Bates, and Buyske (2001); those from childhood to adolescence are inspired by data from Broidy et al.
Physical Aggression in Humans
99
FIGURE 5.5. Age–physical aggression curves (hypothesized). From Tremblay (2003). Copyright 2003 by The Guilford Press. Reprinted by permission.
(2003) and Lacourse et al. (2002); and the preschool to elementary school trajectories are adapted from Côté et al. (2004), and Tremblay et al. (2004). The patchwork shows that the peak in frequency of physical aggressions for the large majority of humans is most probably between the end of the 2nd and 4th year after birth. This representation of physical aggression development has a shape similar to the traditional age–violent-crime curve. There is a sharp increase in frequency, a peak that does not last very long, and a slow decline. Note that even those who can be considered on a chronic physical aggression trajectory are slowly declining in physical aggression, with a possible brief increase during adolescence. By adulthood the individual differences in frequency are possibly the smallest. Although the shapes of the curves are similar, moving the peak in frequency of physical aggression from 18 months to 3 years of age should qualitatively change the way we think about the second aim of this chapter, defining the mechanisms involved in the development of physical aggression. St. Augustine (397/1960) can be paraphrased to express one of the obvious differences: Thank God (or nature!) that humans have weak limbs at the age when they most often use physical aggression. We believe that the observed developmental trajectories seriously question the social learning hypothesis as it continues to be expressed, especially with reference to media violence (e.g., Johnson et al., 2002). There is also no evidence that aggression is like an appetite that needs to be satisfied (Archer, 1988; Lorenz, 1966), but it appears very unlikely that humans need to observe physical aggression to initiate its use. If they do, the learning must be occurring in the first 15 months after birth, and that learning would be universal. What appears more certain, from the observed developmental trajectories, is that humans learn not to use physical ag-
100
THE DEVELOPMENT OF AGGRESSION
gression by learning alternatives. Some children learn more quickly than others, and girls are overrepresented in this group (see Archer & Côté, Chapter 20, this volume). However, if humans learn more or less rapidly to use alternatives to physical aggression, it is important to note that this behavior remains in the behavioral repertoire and can be used when the need arises. Because we tend to forget this, there is always much surprise when a quiet, law-abiding citizen suddenly physically aggresses a neighbor, a spouse, or a work mate. Most investigators, and indeed, most humans, forget that physical aggression is not in itself a “bad,” “destructive” behavior. It is a solution for securing resources and surviving in a given environment (Archer, 1988). Humans have inherited the ability to use that solution, but they have also inherited the ability to use many other strategies, including cooperation and conflict resolution, that are not based on physical force (see Peterson & Flanders, Chapter 7, this volume, and de Waal, 2000). We are slowly creating a social environment in which the physical aggression solution generally becomes a much less adaptive strategy than its alternatives. Young children will spontaneously cooperate and fight, but they need to learn which of the alternatives is the most effective in which situation. Some, because of their genetic makeup, will more easily learn some solutions than others. Similarly, some environments will tend to facilitate some solutions more than others. The gene–environment interactions will favor different developmental trajectories. The simple law that Darwin put forward was that those who will thrive are those who will be most able to learn to use the solutions that are most appropriate for the problems they face. In a social group that does not tolerate physical aggression, it is better to use a form of aggression that is less sanctioned. This does not mean that a punch in the nose is more harmful than an indirect aggression to a person’s reputation. It simply means that a group of humans have decided that conflicts should not be solved by physical force. There was a time, not long ago, when conflicts between men of honor were solved by a duel using pistols, swords, or fists; in our 21st-century civilization there is an increasing trend to se