Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
This page intentionally left blank
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical Music, M...
174 downloads
932 Views
1MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
This page intentionally left blank
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical Music, Masculinity, and Mayhem Kelly Kessler
© Kelly Kessler 2010 All rights reserved. No reproduction, copy or transmission of this publication may be made without written permission. No portion of this publication may be reproduced, copied or transmitted save with written permission or in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, or under the terms of any licence permitting limited copying issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency, Saffron House, 6-10 Kirby Street, London EC1N 8TS. Any person who does any unauthorized act in relation to this publication may be liable to criminal prosecution and civil claims for damages. The author has asserted his right to be identified as the author of this work in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. First published 2010 by PALGRAVE MACMILLAN Palgrave Macmillan in the UK is an imprint of Macmillan Publishers Limited, registered in England, company number 785998, of Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS. Palgrave Macmillan in the US is a division of St Martin’s Press LLC, 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, NY 10010. Palgrave Macmillan is the global academic imprint of the above companies and has companies and representatives throughout the world. Palgrave® and Macmillan® are registered trademarks in the United States, the United Kingdom, Europe and other countries. ISBN-13: 978–0–230–23049–1 hardback This book is printed on paper suitable for recycling and made from fully managed and sustained forest sources. Logging, pulping and manufacturing processes are expected to conform to the environmental regulations of the country of origin. A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Kessler, Kelly, 1972– Destabilizing the Hollywood musical : music, masculinity and mayhem / Kelly Kessler. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references. ISBN 978–0–230–23049–1 1. Musical films—United States—History and criticism. 2. Masculinity in motion pictures. I. Title. PN1995.9.M86K48 2010 2010027524 791.43 6—dc22 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 19 18 17 16 15 14 13 12 11 10 Printed and bound in Great Britain by CPI Antony Rowe, Chippenham and Eastbourne
To My Dad – The perfect synthesis of Gene Kelly and Clint Eastwood My Mom – His Doris Day And Elizabeth – The tune behind my production number
This page intentionally left blank
Contents
List of Figures
ix
Acknowledgments
xi
Introduction: The Musical and Masculinity Take a Turn for the Ambivalent How did this all happen?—Theoretical, formal, and industrial roots How the arcadias disappeared 1 Nothing Is Comin’ Up Roses: The Desertion of Narrative Utopia People won’t say we’re in love—The dissolution of romance The state of community and a utopian future Case study: The narrative of Zoot Suit Conclusion 2 On a Clear Day You Can See the Cracks in the Scenery: Visual Reflexivity and Realism Trump Nostalgic Idealism Camerawork and editing: I can see right through you Mise-en-scène: It’s the real deal right here in River City—Well maybe Case study: Tommy’s conjunction of ambivalent narrative and aesthetics Conclusion 3 Wanna Sing and Dance? These New Guys Are Ambivalent About It New stars: They laughed, cried, and tried to punch each other’s lights out Wanna sing: Ah, I’m ambivalent about it Ambivalent dance: We didn’t dance all night Case study: Twyla Tharp, rock, no-name stars, and Hair Conclusion vii
1 10 23
27 32 49 52 58
60 62 69 78 85
87 91 102 112 126 132
viii Contents
4 The New Guard’s Musical Masculinity Performance of masculinity in the arcadian musical Masculine ambivalence is nothing to sing about Conclusion
133 135 139 164
Epilogue: I Could Go On Singing Dancing into the millennium The groovin’ eighties and nineties: Teens and tots The millennial upturn Conclusion
166 168 169 180 201
Appendix A
204
Notes
217
Bibliography
237
Index
245
List of Figures
Cover photo: The Village People’s leather man sports a glamorous version of his traditional duds to do the “Milkshake” with a sexy blonde in Can’t Stop the Music (1980). Directed by Nancy Walker (Associated Film Distribution/Photofest) 1 The Zoot Suit ensemble poses on stage in the final moments of the film as they highlight the overt theatricality of the narrative. (Universal Pictures/Photofest) 2 With its pseudo-set of scaffolding and priests in vaguely Middle Eastern garb and S&M-reminiscent leather gear, Jesus Christ Superstar’s mise-en-scène underscores the constructed nature of narrative and masculinity. Everything is a temporary construction to be torn down by the film’s end. (Universal/Photofest) 3 Evoking the extreme stylization of the film, Tommy emerges from his bizarre “Acid Queen” sadistic steel cocoon with faux stigmata and stylized crown of thorns. (Columbia Pictures/Photofest) 4 Steve Martin’s Dr Maxwell in Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band subverts the grace or charisma of Astaire and Kelly and fully embraces the chaotic performance style of the comedian’s own stand-up persona. (Universal Pictures/Photofest) 5 Sweet Charity’s “Rich Man’s Frug” embodies the generic break between arcadian coupled dance and the stilted body positions and estranged relationships projected through the choreography of Bob Fosse. (Universal/Photofest) 6 As Hair opens, Twyla Tharp’s choreography for “Aquarius” creates an amorphous mass of counterculture humanity. (United Artists/Photofest) 7 The Bugsy Malone boys project genre and gender critique as they embody their grownup counterparts in costume and stance while wielding childlike whipped cream weapons. (Paramount/Photofest) ix
54
77
84
98
123
129
154
x
List of Figures
8 The Rocky Horror Picture Show ensemble enjoys an aqua-orgy as Frank-N-Furter convinces Brad, Janet, Columbia, and Rocky that sexual fluidity beats heterosexual monogamy any day. (20th Century-Fox/The Kobal Collection) 9 Like many films of the mid-eighties, Beat Street targets the MTV generation with urban aesthetics, contemporary dance styles, and a story of hard knocks and redemption. (Orion Pictures/Photofest) 10 Julie Taymor uses her trademark hyper-stylization to create a visual/aural estrangement between character, action, music, and voice in the draft board scene from Across the Universe. (Sony Pictures/Photofest)
163
175
189
Acknowledgments
I have always been a slave to the musicals of the stage and screen. I waited with great anticipation for the annual airings of Mary Poppins and The Wizard of Oz on broadcast television in the seventies and eighties. I waited with bated breath for my summer trips to the St Louis MUNY to see the Hudson Brothers in The Wizard of Oz, Joe Namath in Li’l Abner, or Lynn Redgrave in The King and I. I thought my life had been changed forever when I saw the 1989 touring company of Les Misérables. Little did I know that these formative childhood and adolescent moments would structure the basis of my early graduate and professional academic careers. First and foremost, I would like to thank my parents for instilling a love of the musical, a passion for motion pictures, and an obsession with television, and for allowing me the space to enjoy, mock, and critique them all as both guilty pleasures and worthy objects of consideration. Aside from a lifelong love of the musical, this book grew out of questions raised in a feminist film theory independent study with Janet Staiger and ultimately out of my dissertation at the University of Texas at Austin. I would like to give my undying thanks to both Janet Staiger and Thomas Schatz. Janet not only watched far more musicals than she would have likely preferred for a half decade, but she has given me endless guidance, support, and friendship. I could not have completed this project without her. Tom has also given me indispensible help through both his work on genre and his continued advice and support. My further gratitude goes to Mary Kearney and Stacy Wolf for their help and guidance on early incarnations of this project. A passel of others have been of great help in both the formation of my musical passions and the more practical materialization of the book. Gordon and Gail Mueller helped form my early stages of musical appreciation and love of Hollywood history and memorabilia. The King and I commemorative plate they kindly gifted me when I was 18 has watched over this entire writing process. As always, my extended family has given me constant mocking support. My brother Greg culled his library contacts, the yellow pages, the internet, and all other possible sources to aid in uncovering films and citations that eluded me. His xi
xii Acknowledgments
obsessive-compulsive behavior was simultaneously helpful and entertaining. Thank you to Cissy Hubbard for her occasional flair for the synonym and Joseph Flauto for his early role of mentor and his at times indignant support. A number of unexpected folks also helped with the final stages of this project. Professional baseball combined with Sue Medelsohn and Ellen Crowell equaled heartwarming and encouraging musical conversations. As I pushed through a couple decades of (often painful) musicals for the epilogue, my Facebook posse was of great help. Tchad Elliot, Patrick Goss, Dominic Vecchiollo, and the rest of you, your diatribes on bad musicals and the ups and downs of Evita helped a girl survive a long summer of Earth Girls are Easy and Beat Street. Tremendous thanks to Palgrave for their support of this project and specifically my editors Christabel Scaife and Catherine Mitchell. I appreciate their commitment to this project and their encouragement and support through the process. Thanks are also due to various anonymous readers who provided incredibly helpful advice and encouraged me to raise questions that had until then gone under-interrogated. Much appreciation also goes out to the folks at Photofest, Kobal, The Margaret Herrick Library, and the University of Southern California’s Warner Bros. Archive for their graciousness and help in finding or helping me find photos, publicity materials, and production documentation. I would also like to give a warm thanks to my colleagues at DePaul University for their support and encouragement and the University for generously granting me funds to cover my image fees. I would be highly remiss if I were not to give much deserved shoutouts to my girls who helped me survive the overall process. Sharon Ross, thanks for the support, the margaritas, and the compassionate ear. Amanda Lotz, I am exceedingly grateful for your emotional support and incredibly helpful advice on a subject you did not even want to know about. Caroline Frick, thank you for being one of the only people who actually cared that musicals existed and knew why they were funny (and for rambling endlessly with me about them). Susan McLeland, I feel strongly that I cannot repay you enough for your support as a friend and reader. I cannot express how much your fresh eye and enthusiasm for the project helped me make it through the final revisions. I will always owe you margaritas. Last but certainly not least, I need to thank Elizabeth Flauto. She has supported me through this project for nearly a decade. She has edited umpteen versions (and was graciously granted jewelry for many of them). One cannot overestimate the love and devotion it takes for one to sit through endless screenings of Lost Horizon—a film that makes
Acknowledgments
xiii
her “want to throw up”—and Xanadu. I cannot imagine another person who would have survived the singing, the dancing, the editing, and the kvetching. I am fully aware that I do not sound like Shirley Jones or dance like Gene Kelly. She has truly seen this project from beginning to end and it and I are better for her presence. She is my Doris Day, Jane Powell, Shirley MacLaine, Gwen Verdon, and Ginger Rogers rolled into one.
This page intentionally left blank
Introduction: The Musical and Masculinity Take a Turn for the Ambivalent
“This is a happy, hand-clapping, foot stomping, country type of musical with all the slickness of a Broadway show. It offers songs, dances and romancing in such a delightful package that word-of-mouth could talk it into solid business at the box-office.”1 In its review of Seven Brides for Seven Brothers (1954), Variety goes straight to the heart of a popular form of the Hollywood musical genre in the era of the studio system. From the coming of sound well into the 1950s, the Hollywood movie musical often served a dual role: profiting for the studios and reaffirming traditional American values. While often one of the pricier genres to produce—with yards upon yards of bespangled costumes, grand sets, and herds of hoofers—the musical also established itself as a financial winner and public favorite. Contract stars such as Gene Kelly, Fred Astaire, Judy Garland, and Deanna Durbin crooned, belted, and danced their ways into the hearts of America as they saved their towns and clanged their trolleys. All was well in St Louis, Paris, and O-K-L-A-HO-M-A as guys found their gals and warring groups of singing farmers and cowmen, Americans and Russians, and soldiers and civilians found a cause around which to gather. As social and industrial climates changed, however, so would the face, place, and style of the musical genre. With the changing shape of the studio system in the 1950s, star contracts disappeared, budgets dropped, and the musical waned as the go-to-gal for the studios. In 1965, the film version of The Sound of Music burst onto the scene as Maria united nuns, surly captains, problematic children, and antiNazi Germany. With a similar idealistic flair as many earlier musicals, the film became a national phenomenon and financial windfall for 20th Century-Fox. With fingers crossed, fans and studio heads hoped that this would be the resurrection of the musical everyone knew, loved, 1
2
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
and paid top dollar to see. Much to the dismay of 20th Century-Fox— who followed The Sound of Music’s success with big-budget musical bombs Doctor Dolittle (1967) and Hello, Dolly! (1969)—Julie Andrews’s descent from the Austrian Alps could not repair the damage caused by the restructuring of the film studios, an emergent influence of the French New Wave and American avant-gardes, and a mélange of racial, sexual, and political unrests. Although a number of musicals would follow the success of The Sound of Music, many would ultimately deviate from the genre’s earlier dominant form that touted social stability through a haze of idealistic Americana and hetero courting. Instead, a form more reflective of contemporary conflict, sexual and gendered tastes, cinematic norms, and musical styles reigned, temporarily replacing the solid Howard Keel with performers more in line with The Who’s trippy Keith Moon (Tommy [1975]), the suave Fred Astaire with crooning tough guys like Clint Eastwood (Paint Your Wagon [1969]) and Burt Reynolds (At Long Last Love [1975], The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas [1982]), and the athletically graceful Gene Kelly with a frenzied Steve Martin (Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band [1978], Pennies from Heaven [1981]). Surely the early days of the musical had seen their share of dark and troubling narratives, although such stories often either appeared in non-integrated backstagers (The Country Girl [1954], A Star is Born [1954], Applause [1929]) or solved their community problems by the story’s end (Hallelujah [1929], Carousel [1956], Cabin in the Sky [1943]). Regardless of such exceptions, happy-go-lucky, love-centric stories dominated and came to define the integrated version of the genre helmed by artists such as Garland, Kelly, Astaire, and Richard Rodgers and Oscar Hammerstein. As times changed, however, so did the form once destined to reinforce social norms and present a musical utopia for all. Through stars, styles, and stories, men and their problematic narratives of infidelity, psychological struggle, and career pressure became the prevailing face of integrated musical fare from the mid-sixties to the early eighties. This conflicted masculinized version often replaced or at least problematized the woman-centered world of familial stability, romance, and monogamy common to the pre-sixties version of the movie musical. While Hollywood still churned out the occasional Half a Sixpence (1967), Song of Norway (1970), and Thoroughly Modern Millie (1967) reflecting the generic norms of an earlier filmic, theatrical, and ideological age, films such as Tommy, At Long Last Love, All That Jazz (1979), and Pennies from Heaven—in whole or part—cemented an edgier version of the integrated musical form, rife with irresolvable social conflict, visual and aural innovation, and a challenge to the overall stability
The Musical and Masculinity Take a Turn 3
of gender and sexual expectations. At times these films provide an overall generic overhaul rife with sex, drugs, and social unrest; and at others they simply inflect largely old-school narratives with stylistic or ideological flairs that complicate a perhaps assumed “happily ever after” (like happy endings complicated by Popeye’s [1980] stylistic frenzy, The Pirate Movie’s [1982] knowing intertextuality, or Bugsy Malone’s [1976] critique of the gangster genre). At least one reviewer felt the shift occurring as The New Yorker framed Tommy as something very un-Seven Brides and “deeply unmusical.” Highlighting far less “happy, hand-clapping” and “foot stomping,” the reviewer described the entire viewing experience as assaultive as he suggested tactics for surviving the screening. “The only way to stick it is to sit up—right in the non-pot-smoking section— not leaning back, because the quintaphonic speaker system would burst your eardrums from behind as the sound comes out of the back exits, and not sitting forward, because the picture bangs images at your nose like a four-year-old jumping out at you from behind a curtain. Tommy is a peekaboo for thugs.”2 The idealism commonly evoked by the musicals of the studio system era had left the building. Beginning with musicals produced in 1966 and following through to 1983—the years between the genre’s cinematic “rebirth” with The Sound of Music and the final year to see more than one integrated musical before an extended drought—this book investigates the generic form and content common to the genre in this oft-overlooked period of the Hollywood musical and examines the films’ relationships to each other, their predecessors, and a greater projection of social and gendered reality.3 Although early examples of the film musical include occasional instances of romantic, racial, or cultural instability (Melody Cruise [1933], Way Down South [1939], and so on), folks such as Astaire, Kelly, and Russ Tamblyn repeatedly hoofed and flipped their ways into a more stable view of America and marital bliss as narratives washed over such problems with their happy-go-lucky endings. A close look at the 1966– 1983 integrated musicals illustrates a wide scale shift in generic form, a recurrent reflection of social unrest, and an overall expression of a conflicted sense of community, personal and professional expectations, and construction of gender. Although musical vehicles did not wholly abandon the more idyllic form of the thirties, forties, and fifties, these later films more often articulated the troubled ideology common to motion pictures of other genres by the late 1960s. As Vietnam, Watergate, and the Women’s, Civil, and Gay Rights Movements marched forward, the idealism once strongly linked to a surging postwar America and the musical genre waned. Many musicals of the late 1960s to early 1980s
4
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
bear the battle scars of the social and artistic struggles alongside which they emerged. They provide an excellent lens though which to examine the ultimate instability of genre and study how social change both drives and finds itself represented in the shifting product. Despite similar changes occurring on the Broadway and off-Broadway stages at the same time—as shows such as Hair (1968), Oh, Calcutta (1969), Godspell (1971), and Jesus Christ Superstar (1971) rocked the theatrical boat with their sex, drugs, and rock-n-roll—this book will focus solely on the shifts occurring on the big screen. Since the reciprocal relationship between stage and screen musicals has always been paramount, the book will credit the contributions of the theatrical world. Just over half of the integrated musicals produced during the 1966–1983 period were first produced on or off-Broadway; however, the bulk of the study’s focus will remain on the films themselves. Despite the sharing of narratives and generic tropes with their stage-bound cousins, the filmic musicals remain unique. The generic norms expressed through the cinematic medium transcend the stories and songs provided by Broadway counterparts. Camelot (1960) on stage and Camelot (1967) on screen—with its later release, non-singing stars, mod costuming, and minimalization of actual singing and dancing—are simply two different animals. Films such as Paint Your Wagon and The Boy Friend (1971) experienced major changes between stage and screen, not only in style but also in narrative; similarly, Hal Prince’s highly successful Broadway production of Cabaret (1966) was stripped of all integrated numbers for its Bob Fosse-helmed film version (1972). Despite their theatrical origins, films such as these ultimately became uniquely cinematic products. I therefore will not differentiate between musicals made specifically for the screen (such as All That Jazz, At Long Last Love, One From the Heart [1982]) and those first performed on stage (like Hair [1979], The Wiz [1978], and Godspell [1973]). Cinematic visuals, unique integration of sound/song and image, and the specific position of the motion picture industry as star factory weigh equally on both original film musicals and Broadway transfers, and both types speak equally to the genre revision occurring between the mid-sixties and early-eighties. In the end, these cinematic specificities drive this study. Alongside changes occurring in visual, narrative, and musical form within this cinematic version of the genre, a resultant shift in gendered norms emerges. Garland, Durbin, Jane Powell, and Esther Williams, as well as stage divas such as Mary Martin and Ethel Merman had stood at the center of many musicals.4 As the musical genre often spotlighted the primacy of successful hetero romance, women and their domestic
The Musical and Masculinity Take a Turn 5
realm commonly took center stage. Her ability to snare her prospective beau repeatedly led to the successful (and over-determined) resolution of the narrative. Seven brides found their seven brothers. Fred and Ginger negotiated their differences through dance. On leave soldiers found their sweeties in On the Town (1949). As the genre recurrently reinforced the necessity of coupling, the films themselves commonly produced strong marriage-driven women and men who would ultimately buckle under the need for companionship. Both Thomas Schatz and Rick Altman focus on such romantic unions, identifying them as the bedrock of the musical structure.5 They argue that whether the story’s frame engages with gangsters, cowboys, socialites, or businessmen, chances are the romantic hero will find his heroine and the two will live happily ever after. Narrative conflicts seldom reach a degree of complexity which cannot be overcome by the love of a good woman and a dazzling final number. Wholesome entertainment and entertainers can save family and country, aid in finding true love, and make performers out of diegetic—and by proxy nondiegetic—audience members. Similar to Schatz and Altman, Richard Dyer’s “Entertainment as Utopia” positions the film musical as projecting a utopian sensibility powerful enough to overcome any internal incoherence though a combination of idyllic narrative tropes, visuals, sounds, and singers.6 Their concepts regarding the musical and romance underscore the more idyllic view of the musical and its resultant projection of gendered norms that this study argues began to wane by the mid-1960s. As the dominant form of the genre changed in the 1966–1983 period—as a result of social, artistic, and industrial shifts—narrative, aesthetic, and performative changes within the genre led to transformations in the overall gender dynamic within the Hollywood musical. The new troubled musical masculinity takes to the screen and complicates established generic norms of companionate marriage and a blended community. Although Steven Cohan argues that musical masculinity was always complicated through his examination of queerness and camp performance within the MGM musical, I would argue that these later films take what Cohan saw as performative underpinnings or gender incongruities (such as the performed masculinity of Kelly in The Pirate [1948] or Anchors Aweigh [1945] or the connotative queerness of chorus boys in Ziegfeld Girl [1941]) and place them on the surface text for overt consideration. Despite Kelly’s perceived camp nature or moments of queerness, his characters—as Cohan notes—were always on the prowl for a dame.7 At the end of the day such performances still diegetically reinforced the heterosexual and romantic dictates that drove the genre. That strong association with the celebration
6
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
of heterosexual (monogamous) romance and successful male providers wanes in this later period as many of the films illustrate an overt and contrary pattern of unsatisfactory resolutions including unrequited love (Sweet Charity [1969], At Long Last Love, Funny Girl [1968]), failed male professional ventures (Camelot, Pennies from Heaven), and death of central male characters (Godspell, Hair, The Rocky Horror Picture Show [1975], All That Jazz).8 Using Judith Butler’s concept of performativity—in which gender can only truly articulate itself through repeated performances of a set of norms that become read as “masculine” or “feminine”—this book ultimately considers the destabilization of both the musical genre and a stable notion of masculinity in the musicals of the 1966–1983 period through an examination of emerging generic dictates.9 In negotiation of the recurrent problem of defining a generic corpus, my study of the 1966–1983 period focuses solely on integrated musicals. As with the definition of the musical genre itself, scholars have discussed the concept of integration by focusing on various textual, extratextual, and otherwise stylistic elements. John Mueller and Jerome Delamater discuss integration in a broad sense. Mueller considers the mere inclusion of musical numbers—ranging from show numbers and love duets to dream ballets and dramatically sung soliloquies—as integration, and Delamater considers integration as the pinnacle of the musical’s evolution though a discussion of the joint impact of narrativeforwarding song and nondiegetic stylistic elements such as dance style and cinematography.10 He states: The nature of the film musical lies not simply with the idea that the musical numbers and dances, in particular, should advance the plot but also suggests an integration of the entire cinematic process. The way in which dances in a particular film are photographed, for example, suggests a kind of integration of the filmmaking process and that together they contribute to the integrity of the film.11 Less sweeping in its definition, this book will examine integration in a more specific sense than Mueller, but a less qualitative or hierarchical sense than Delamater. I will be examining the subset of the musical genre that encompasses only films that include characters spontaneously bursting into song. These major and minor characters sing to celebrate, lament, and express inner desires or communal bonding.12 Popularized by the works of Jerome Kern, Rodgers and Hammerstein, and ultimately MGM’s Freed Unit, the more fully integrated musicals artistically, stylistically, and
The Musical and Masculinity Take a Turn 7
textually tie together the musical’s storytelling and its inclusion and incorporation of music. More than merely slotting in a popular Cole Porter tune or new numbers from Tin Pan Alley to show off the vocal or choreographic prowess of the musicals’ performers, Altman cites the integrated musical as being a “product of numerous attempts to develop closer ties between narrative and musical numbers.”13 Music becomes inextricably linked to the narratives, functioning as a mode of character and plot development. Rodgers and Hammerstein, for example, not only use their musical numbers to express the feelings and frustrations of their heroes and heroines, but also to illustrate stylistic specificity that identifies and explores those characters (for example, the traditional Chinese sounds in Mei Li’s numbers in Flower Drum Song [1961] versus the jazzier riffs performed by the more Americanized night club performers/owners, or Nellie’s bubbly numbers in South Pacific [1958] versus Emile’s more somber stylings). Altman identifies this trend in his work on the dual-focus narratives of musicals, citing integrated character-specific performance—rather than traditional causal relations—as driving or defining the film’s direction. His example of Gigi (1958) examines the juxtaposed solos, scenes, and styles of Gaston and Gigi and the ultimate musical and relational integration that emerges though their romantic union.14 In addition to illuminating story and character, the process of integration pulls the musical further away from the artifice of “performance.” As the Music Man’s (1962) library spontaneously becomes the locale for a romantic musical conflict between Marian the librarian and Professor Harold Hill, the world of River City, Iowa becomes a musical one. Characters naturalize performances by using their surroundings— ladders, books, shelves—as part of their performances. Jane Feuer points to the use of bricolage, non-choreography (dance based on more natural movement), and folk dance as minimizing the artifice of musical performances and drawing the viewing audience into the recognizable world of the film rather than the mythic world of professional performers.15 More than other forms of the genre, the integrated variety uses musical performance to help create an altered reality in which musical self-expression supersedes everyday means of communication. Duets, solos, communal dances, and individual hoofing convey the thoughts, feelings, and conflicts of those who live within the integrated musical. Focusing solely on this style of the genre prevents confusion caused by a messier discussion of which films fall into the category of “musical.” Surely, by omitting films that fall outside the scope of integration I also eliminate various musical films commonly identified with the
8
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
performers, styles, and directors of the time (most notably Martin Scorsese’s New York, New York [1977] and Liza Minnelli in Cabaret). However, by focusing solely on integration and not the personally fraught biopic (The Buddy Holly Story [1978], The Coal Miner’s Daughter [1980]), at times culturally or interpersonally disquieting entertainer narrative (Cabaret, A Star is Born [1976], New York, New York, Nashville [1975]), dance movie (Saturday Night Fever [1977], The Turning Point [1977]), concert documentary (Woodstock [1970], Gimme Shelter [1970]), or songfilled cartoon (Jungle Book [1967], Fox and the Hound [1981]), I am able to focus in on what makes these quintessential musicals specific to this period of American culture, Hollywood, cinematic expression, and my critical goals at hand. With this, the sole focus on integrated musicals also complicates notions of personal performance as men specifically must negotiate projections of gender in competition with social conceptions connecting performance of song and dance with a suspect masculinity.16 (Do real men sing and dance? Does the term chorus boy conjure up images of rugged strength and virility?) In the biopic or entertainer musical, men perform to make a living. In The Buddy Holly Story and Cabaret, Holly and the Master of Ceremonies must perform for their livelihoods. The spontaneous appearance of song and dance in integrated musicals denies such a constant realistic motivation for allying male performance with acceptable cultural norms (active, gainful employment).17 Instead, Camelot’s King Arthur and Lost Horizon’s (1973) male ensemble must sing and dance to express complex emotions to themselves and others—a trait more inherently associated with sentiment-driven femininity rather than traditional rationality-driven masculinity. My approach to genre study is surely rooted in the more classical studies of Schatz, Dyer, Altman, and Feuer; however, my take on the genre resists conceptualizing the musical as either (a) a staid form or (b) one saddled by a predetermined evolutionary path. The musical— in this case the integrated musical—did not spring forth fully formed with a predictive style of generic evolution. While this study does not focus on either audience response or the industrial positioning of the musical genre, it does examine the ways in which elements external to the texts themselves—texts which have always been somewhat variant but I argue shifted in terms of dominant form from period to period— left their marks on the products produced during specific time periods. Whether reflective of cultural movements, artistic trends, or industrial shifts, the dominant form musicals took in the period 1966–1983 surely illustrates a change from those commonly associated with
The Musical and Masculinity Take a Turn 9
an earlier stage of the genre. As Altman has argued in response to much genre theory—admittedly much of the musical scholarship that I use here, including his own—genre is never wholly coherent, universally received, or industrially stable.18 Rather, genres and genre films will be interpreted divergently based on context (time, audience, studio need). Rather than entrenching the musical in an ahistorical cocoon, this study brings historical context to the genre as it uncovers or activates a significant faction of the Hollywood musical that has historically been erased or marginalized through a veil of classical musical and Hollywood scholarship. As I highlight the historical shifts that have taken place within the musical, I will use the adjectives arcadian and ambivalent to identify the broad characteristics associated with the two divergent styles—the former more prevalent in the 1930s, 1940s, and 1950s and the latter becoming dominant in the mid to late 1960s. These labels came out of a struggle to avoid strict periodization—for example classical versus post-classical, studio system versus post-studio system, or early versus late. Characteristics attributed to the arcadian musical do not wholly disappear in 1966; rather another popular version of the genre emerges alongside the traditional as social, industrial, as stylistic shifts usher in a broadening contemplation of the genre and its traditionally conservative mores. Similarly, the dark and socially contentious qualities this book will identify in the ambivalent version of the musical popular in the 1966–1983 period did not emerge as if from nowhere. Many backstagers, as well as early integrated films had presented extremely dark storylines of family estrangement, murder, and manipulation (although often only to resolve such problems by the film’s end). Aside from discouraging categorization based strictly on chronology, I also hoped to circumvent the use of a confusing jargon such as “new wave” musical, which simultaneously conjures up images of Jean-Luc Godard’s Breathless (1960) and eighties bands such as Flock of Seagulls and Duran Duran. Instead, I chose terms that evoke the spirit of the overriding themes, styles, and aesthetics related to the two musical forms. Arcadian refers to the version of the musical genre most commonly implied by critics and outlined by scholars such as Feuer, Schatz, Dyer, and Altman. They identify this form of the genre—most common in the earlier years of the movie musical—as one whose films strive toward ideological stasis and communal unification—whether through clear-cut resolutions, heterosexual unions, unifying song and dance, or idealistic mise-en-scène. It projects an idealistic view of a pre- and postwar culture scrambling to maintain a homogenous, traditional, and perfectly gendered society.
10
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
Ambivalent, however, evokes the complexity and uncertainty of both the genre and times. This form holds dominance in the 1960s, 1970s, and 1980s as the visual and social utopia of the arcadian wanes in light of a more complicated and contentious view of society. A sense of uncertainty arises in the musical, projected through a combination of narratives, visuals, performances, and performers and reflecting its contextualization amid various forms of industrial and social unrest. Rising divorce rates, Vietnam, gay rights, the new Motion Picture Association of America’s (MPAA) rating system, splintering studios, changes in marketing, the French New Wave, and New American Cinema render the splashy arcadian musical both socially anachronistic and industrially outdated and ill-advised. Idealistic musicals give way to inconclusive narratives, ideologically complex and inconclusively driven characters, unclear notions of morality and social norms, and variations of realistic mise-en-scène. Films reflect both a disdain for earlier generic idealism— now appearing socially incompatible—and a formal and ideological freedom associated with growing trends within the industry. Throughout, the examination of this more recent contentious form of the genre will highlight the tension between established generic norms, industrial freedom, and a historical context rife with social upheaval and uncertainty.
How did this all happen?—Theoretical, formal, and industrial roots My approach to genre grows out of the concept that generic forms serve as more than simple molds into which filmmakers can place their stories in hopes of replicating earlier successes. Rather, genre serves as a mutual contract between the filmmakers, spectators, and the society at large. Schatz argues that these forms must continue to speak to the social mores and conflicts that they seek to represent and diegetically solve. Through repeated (and to some extent popularly successful) articulations of themes, visuals, characters, and communities, genre forms emerge. Characters, stories, and places become imbued with the meanings and ideologies associated with previous films of that genre. Once the form fails to speak to a contemporary society, it becomes useless.19 Whether wholly reflective of actual audience reception, the forms the musical takes surely reflect—through its darkening plots, dance styles, and singing techniques—a shift, and one that does directly speak to cultural, industrial, and artistic changes at large. Focusing largely on the earlier films of the studio system age and
The Musical and Masculinity Take a Turn 11
later-produced replicas, scholarship and popular press coverage alike have often eschewed the moral and formal complexity recurrent in the musical. Instead, the mere mention of the Hollywood musical often invokes the memory of Maria and Captain Von Trapp ascending the Alps to an all-nun voiceover choir of the uplifting “Climb Every Mountain” or a rousing performance of that pro-entertainer tune “There’s No Business Like Show Business.” This notion of a rather stable generic sense of musical idealism drives much musical scholarship. Altman, Schatz, and Dyer identify a utopian sensibility and/or the romantic couple as the device which drives the genre’s storytelling and leads to this rather simple and consistent narrative resolution. Before the film starts, the audience knows this romantic duo will unite successfully. Schatz places the musical under the category of “social integration,” identifying it as a genre in which narratives repeatedly raise issues regarding conflicting moral beliefs and end with some kind of celebration or communal display of social values. With a grand wedding or celebration, narrative conclusions leave the viewer perceiving Dyer’s utopian sensibility or experiencing a temporary feeling that overwhelming social quandaries can be solved acceptably.20 Dyer argues that through a language of music and dance, the arcadian musical presents “complex or unpleasant feelings (e.g., involvement in personal or political events; jealousy, loss of love, defeat) in a way that makes them seem uncomplicated, direct and vivid, not ‘qualified’ or ‘ambiguous’ as day to day life makes them.”21 In bestowing an artificial feeling of satisfaction through unrealistically simple solutions to daily life, the films present a false sense of security in the created utopia. By constructing two conflicting ideals as unquestionably congruous, this logic suggests a utopian sensibility can be established and all problems will appear surmountable. A genre built on this type of ideological duplicity and internal incoherence must negotiate its narrative contradictions or tensions, often through its opposing lovers.22 Feuer and Altman highlight the overall generic importance of binaries such as work/entertainment, communal/individual, and amateur/entertainer to legitimize the larger projects of social integration and show biz glorification. A conflation of these binaries often leads to the idealization of performer and performance. The music and the people function as saviors within the genre. Altman states, “From film to film the specific incarnation of the work/entertainment duality may change, but in one way or another every musical somehow manages to build its thematic complex around its very status as a form of entertainment.”23 Similarly, Feuer
12
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
highlights the interpellation of the audience through the resolved tensions between community and individual and amateur and professional. As the romance is secured, community and amateurishness come to the forefront and are deemed ideal. The audience can be successfully integrated into the world of the narrative, as its subject position therein is deemed necessary. To resolve the tension between the romantic couple, the characters must be fully integrated into a community compatible with its divergent needs.24 Dyer finds such negotiations a product of the film’s representational (plot, characters, stars) and nonrepresentational (such as color, texture, movement, rhythm, and camerawork) signs.25 This combination of elements allows a film to remain “entertaining” even when possessing plot points not wholly leading to or rationalizing happy-go-lucky closure. In such cases, the utopian nonrepresentational elements compensate for the problematic representational signs and project a tenuous sense of utopia. (For example, the forced and quickly resolved final marriages in Seven Brides for Seven Brothers or Gentlemen Prefer Blondes [1953] may not make sense, based on narrative action or character traits, but they sure look swell.) As the later more ambivalent-leaning films present an increasing number of plots that fail to resolve themselves and incorporate more realistic settings and harsher rock-driven musical beats, this argument that the musical can generally negotiate its representational and non-representational contradictions comes into question. This critically and academically dominant form of musical idealism has deep historical roots formed and strengthened by social, theatrical, industrial, and cinematic events. A combination of theatrical formats— such as comic and ballad operas, operettas, and musical plays—and regulations placed on American cinema by the Production Code Administration (PCA) set the scene for what critics and scholars would ultimately define as the musical genre or those integrated musicals with strong arcadian tendencies. Establishing norms for musical performance, romance, and community, these theatrical and cinematic forms combined and negotiated social and industrial shifts to culminate in an image of nostalgic musical integration and standardized notions of setting, plot and characters, music, and community. The arcadian use of popular music and smooth transition into and psychological motivation for song evolved from early musical forms. The ballad opera and operetta set the standard for the integrated musical’s combination of spoken dialogue and popular music, just as the subsequent rise of the Broadway narrative-focused musical— specifically the early works of Kern (Show Boat [1927]) and Rodgers
The Musical and Masculinity Take a Turn 13
and Hammerstein (Oklahoma! [1943], Carousel [1945], Flower Drum Song [1958])—popularized a financially lucrative musical play in which music and dialogue could be easily integrated. Kern and Rodgers and Hammerstein would standardize the inclusion of musical arrangements tailored to characters’ specific psychological states. Julie painfully recalls her undying love for a charlatan in Show Boat’s “Bill” while The King and I’s (1951) King of Siam soliloquizes his frustrations over a general state of uncertainty in the world in “A Puzzlement.” These shows would also normalize techniques used to ease the transition from spoken voice into song, such as the sound of a horse’s hooves in Oklahoma! (1955) or the use of a transitional stage device (recitative) where spoken dialogue is performed with a melodic variation as to ease into full singing voice (as with Maria’s ruminations on raindrops and kittens prior to her full-blown singing of “My Favorite Things” in The Sound of Music). Early musical ventures in European and American operettas set the scene for film musicals by popularizing settings based on nostalgia and artifice. Composers such as Rudolf Friml, Kern, and George and Ira Gershwin often relied on “exotic lands” or nostalgic versions of the frontier or urban America to create an air of the unusual or ideal. Rather than striving for a sense of the local real, these vehicles relied on broad strokes that connoted a sense of unusual place. Similarly, American composers like George M. Cohan constructed an idealized notion of America, evoking a sense of nationalism with songs such as “Yankee Doodle Boy” and “You’re a Grand Old Flag.” This practice of idealizing space in the musical translated into the popular Rodgers and Hammerstein vehicles that found prominence both on stage and screen. The team—who retained tight controls over their projects as they transferred from live to filmed performance—strengthened the visual association to this type of artificiality or idealization of setting. Rodgers and Hammerstein’s films avoided fully integrating location shooting until The Sound of Music, and consequently reinforced the notion of an arcadian land separate from the problems of actual society.26 Both regulation and cultural change would nudge the film musical further toward an arcadian view of society and heterosexual romance. As with its sense of place, the genre’s foundation of romance as the basis for conflict originates in the first operettas whose major premises involved the romantic entanglements of their heroes, heroines, and villains.27 In the early years, Warner Bros. specialized in bawdy broads on the lookout for sex, dough, and fame. Just as 42nd Street (1933) depicts men sneaking out of woman-only rooms and implies the perks of the casting couch, Gold Diggers includes straight-talking dames and
14
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
moments of sexual titillation through performance. Busby Berkeley’s Gold Diggers of 1933’s (1933) “Pettin’ in the Park” aptly illustrates early displays of sexuality that would later be verboten. The song’s chorus decries the joys and perils of public displays of affection as a stage full of men try to get the best of their sweeties. More forward than almost any respectable Rodgers and Hammerstein heroine, these ladies are plagued by a recurring randy baby (actor Billy Barty dressed in infant garb) and ultimately cast in silhouettes that imply the entire bevy of chorines are in their scanties or stark naked. The bawdiness associated with these early nonintegrated backstagers would ultimately dissipate under pressure from the PCA, and film musicals shifted away from lascivious plotlines to narratives that reinforced coupling through musical integration and the normalcy and necessity of companionate love. 42nd Street’s Anytime Annie—who only said no once and then she didn’t hear the question—finds herself replaced by Oklahoma!’s Ado Annie who, although she “Can’t Say No,” is allowed to marry her true love, rather than suffer public mocking as a loose woman. Along with a secure heterosexual union and proper sexual behavior, a sense of shared values emerged as standard throughout the genre. Schatz, Feuer, Dyer, and Altman all identify the musical as approaching utopian possibilities or reinforcing communal middle-class values. Nonintegrated or negligibly integrated backstage musicals often emphasized the importance of the group (42nd Street, Gold Diggers cycle), as did the “let’s put on a show” films (Babes on Broadway [1941], One Hundred Men and a Girl [1937]). In both styles, music and performance exist as the means to successfully bring together a community in strife. During both the Depression and World War II, musicals often played the role of unifier, reinforcing or imagining a cultural desire to bring the American people together for some sort of healing. George F. Custen discusses Darryl Zanuck and the 20th Century-Fox musicals between the wars—films often set in nostalgic versions of the Midwest or Northeast— as the great unifiers, while simultaneously highlighting their ability to erase or evade cultural conflict. He states, “Most Fox musical entertainment was a struggle to reconcile what Shirley’s [Temple] narratives almost always united: the values associated with urban, ethnic vaudeville and modernity and those extolled in a pre-Tin Pan Alley, allwhite Protestant musical universe found most often in the rural small town.” Temple could unite a country split by ideology and economic depression by creating unity through narratives that avoided topics of irresolvable controversy.28 Similarly, Garland, Mickey Rooney, and Durbin brought the community and their families together. Backstage
The Musical and Masculinity Take a Turn 15
the hoofers joined forces to save the show. Star-studded reviews such as Columbia’s Stars on Parade (1944) or Warner Bros.’s This is the Army (1943) sought to raise morale for the troops and reinforce the stickto-itiveness of the country. As the war ended and the genre further solidified its style with the more fully integrated works of MGM’s Freed Unit and the spate of successful Broadway musical transfers, the postwar culture at large sought to reinforce community values, proper gender norms for men and women, and the strength of the American middle-class. While adhering to theatrical norms and the film industry’s somewhat puritanical ideological project, the musical genre eschewed various narrative and aesthetic standards of the cinematic medium. Classical Hollywood cinema as described by David Bordwell, Kristin Thompson, and Janet Staiger typically possesses logical cause and effect-driven linear narratives pushed forward by individuals with personal agency; this compositional dominance is supported by self-effacing camerawork, overt motivation for actions, and a clear-cut conclusion. In short, the form plays itself out making evident the events and individuals who cause diegetic change and ultimately lead to a resolution of the narrative conflict, while encased in a standardized—though continually evolving—set of narrational norms that hide, rather than announce, the means by which they were created. Continuity editing— shot-reverse-shots, eye line matches, maintaining axis orientation—as well as effective presentation of onscreen and implication of off-screen space work to present a diegetic world as a seemingly real one. Cinematographic choices, visual and aural editing, framing, and choices in mise-en-scène function together to mask the mechanics of the filmmaking process.29 The integrated arcadian Hollywood musical deviates from the norms commonly associated with classical Hollywood form and style. The genre’s over-determined narratives and the style of musical inclusion as popularized by its archetypal forms make adherence to traditional cinematic norms difficult and ultimately unnecessary. Music and budding romance take precedence over the actual development of the film’s story—the details of which appear nearly irrelevant due to the foregone generic narrative conclusion. (Grease’s [1978] thuggish Danny will make amends with his virginal Sandy; Silk Stockings’ [1957] cold Russian comrade will fall for the charmingly American Astaire; and Gigi’s title character will find love with the seemingly antagonistic Gaston.)30 Music cures all ills, whether through a Powell ballad or an Astaire and Rogers waltz. Couples, individuals, and communities use song and dance as their means to enact and solve conflict and project a
16
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
united front. Damn Yankees’ (1958) “Whatever Lola Wants” and Seven Brides for Seven Brothers’ “Spring, Spring, Spring” work through and project sexual tension and conflict musically, rather than in a seamless narrative fashion. Group numbers and the celebratory/curative function of music unite communities in The Music Man’s “Wells Fargo Wagon” or The Unsinkable Molly Brown’s (1964) “He’s My Friend.” In addition to its narrative role, the very means by which music functions in the integrated musical works against the dictates of classical Hollywood cinema. Characters randomly burst into song, breaking any semblance of linkage with the “real” and believable world. Kelly and Garland turn full front, breaking the fourth wall, to speak directly to the audience member—reversing the masking of artifice accomplished by any self-effacing visual style. The narrative ultimately performs the union of the romantic couple, by means of a burst of visual excess—the production number—rather than as a result of a satisfactory alleviation of narrative conflict. The climax often occurs as song, dance, and grandiose visual displays coalesce to create an extravagant sensual exhibition. With a final burst of energy, panache, and singin’ and dancin’ such production numbers celebrate communal values and heterosexual romance and belie the traditional closed narrative system common in Hollywood filmmaking. Questions are—perhaps superficially—answered, although not fully explained. (The wedding may have occurred, but the audience will not hang around to see if the marriage falls apart.)31 Within Hollywood’s environment of innovation and repetition, the aforementioned conventions and standardized formats emerged to associate the musical with such arcadian tendencies. Transferring some productions largely lock, stock, and barrel from Broadway successes, responding to social change and threats of regulation, and adjusting to the abilities and limitations of contemporary cinematic technology, a lucrative and popular form of the film musical surfaced. By the 1960s, however, the film musical had all but played itself out. Scholars have hypothesized about several possible reasons as to why the film industry could no longer support the genre. Firstly, by the end of the 1950s the motion picture industry had exhausted Broadway’s smash hits.32 At this point, Broadway transfers garnered the most confidence from film producers seeking financial success. Although New York was still churning out musical successes, the number of new shows had declined as the revenues for the stage suffered a postwar decline. Secondly, scholars such as Gerald Mast point to the aging of the Broadway musical in the 1950s. No longer focusing on contemporary music or dances as the Gershwins,
The Musical and Masculinity Take a Turn 17
Cole Porter, and Irving Berlin had previously, new musicals such as The King and I, Kismet (1953), Candide (1957), and The Music Man (1958) kept their distances from the emerging sounds of rock-n-roll and popular country and the non-partnered dances that accompanied those musical styles and may have enticed young audiences. Rock-n-roll did appear on the Broadway stage as early as 1960 with the harmless Elvis spoof Bye, Bye, Birdie (that would be remade into a film with teen idol Bobby Rydell in 1963), but not until the late sixties did musical plays such as Hair and Jesus Christ Superstar use rock-n-roll to evoke rebellion and contemporary social mores. (Rock was used in film musicals prior to the late 1960s, but often a more sanitized version thereof: Elvis films that softened his lascivious image, the fluffy Beach Party cycle, and the like.) As the genre aged and avoided these emerging musical forms, the success of the Broadway pop single also waned. Consequently, the sound and audience aged with the genre.33 Thirdly, by 1948 the government had declared the five major studios—Paramount, MGM, 20th Century-Fox, Warner Bros., and RKO—participants in an oligopoly and forced them to divest of their exhibition wings within the next five years and immediately cease practices such as block booking and blind buying.34 This industrial shift—as well as wartime income tax hikes that had encouraged stars to go freelance or incorporate—affected both the availability and grooming of stars for the musical genre. Following the transformation of the studio system, the genre suffered in terms of number and consistent aesthetic. Also, post-disintegration, studios began to farm out production of films and/or their resources. No longer did films bear a definitive studio stamp, as the uniformity of production bodies such as MGM’s Freed Unit gave way to a system bereft of any single organizing force.35 The director’s voice often held more sway than that of the producer’s as the studios’ role became more of an economic one. Finally, critics such as Marc Miller have claimed that by the late 1950s and mid 1960s audiences were sufficiently jaded by social issues (Vietnam, Civil Rights, Women’s Rights, and so on) such that the conciliatory ending associated with the dominant form of the musical appeared old-fashioned and obsolete.36 As the 1960s began, the occasional movie musical would achieve financial success: West Side Story (1961), Gypsy (1962), My Fair Lady (1964), and The Sound of Music. Each film illustrates visual, ideological, and casting shifts that would deviate from the genre’s established cinematic roots. All four films demonstrate the effects of the demise of contracted star stables, as well as a manifestation of the blockbuster mentality. Studios sold the films on the celebrity of stars known
18
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
for attributes other than their abilities to sing. Dubbing replaced the substandard voices of Natalie Wood—who appears in two of the four— Rosalind Russell, Christopher Plummer, Audrey Hepburn, and Richard Beymer.37 Although earlier musicals had used stars not known primarily for their musical abilities—James Cagney, Marlon Brando, and Victor Mature—the star system had also cultivated musical standbys such as Kelly, Nelson Eddy, Dick Powell, Garland, and Martin who provided the performative energy and pizzazz that had become associated with the genre. As film musicals declined in number and studio-groomed musical stars failed to emerge films appeared to rely more heavily on selling dubbed celebrity over actual vocal talent. Although earlier musicals did use dubbing—whether of the actual performer’s voice for simple clarity’s sake or otherwise—high profile non-singers in film musicals often abstained from singing (William Holden in the non-integrated The Country Girl, James Mason in A Star is Born) or sang in a comical vein (Red Skelton in Neptune’s Daughter [1949], Tom Ewell in State Fair [1962]) as the films focused on these actors’ other known talents rather than their musical abilities. Concurrent to musicals of the early 1960s struggling to find surefire box-office draws to replace the waning musical star, new musicals on stage and screen sought to rev up the relevancy of settings and themes. Straying from the comfortable nostalgia indicative of the genre, West Side Story integrated a music and dance style more contemporary than most and centered its narrative on a grittier, more pessimistic topic.38 Similarly, Gypsy ends with its heroine Rose delusional and cracking under the pressure of abandonment and unrealized dreams. West Side Story and The Sound of Music—both directed by Robert Wise—strayed from the brightly colored, denotative, studio-created sets popularized by Rodgers and Hammerstein films and others such as Guys and Dolls (1955) and The Court Jester (1956). Instead, both use a grittier location shooting to capture a heightened sense of detail, realism, and space and begin with helicopter shots descending upon New York and the Alps respectively.39 Shot on location, the cinematography and miseen-scène were far from the manmade cornfields and nostalgic tunes of Oklahoma!’s simpler West side. From celebrity to narrative and aesthetics, the musicals of the 1960s began to show the generic cracks that would come to define the genre in the following decades. Concurrently, non-musical films pushed the boundaries of the Production Code. Films such as Kiss Me Stupid (1964) and Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf (1966) pressed on with risqué dialogue and sexual situations. In 1966 an early version of the contemporary motion picture
The Musical and Masculinity Take a Turn 19
rating system replaced the Code, paving the way for darker and more adult subject matter. By the mid 1960s, the film industry at large experienced a major shift in production that would take advantage of this revision in censorship protocol. Arthur Penn (Bonnie and Clyde [1967]), Robert Altman (M∗ A∗ S∗ H [1970]), and Mike Nichols (Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf and The Graduate [1967]) embodied what would be termed the New American Cinema, a movement that simultaneously questioned American culture and Hollywood’s narrative and aesthetic norms. This followed on the heels not only of new weakened regulation, but also a long history of avant-garde film in Europe and the United States. From Sergei Eisenstein’s forays into dialectic montage in the 1920s to the American boom of avant-garde in the 1940s, 1950s, and 1960s with the films of artists such as Kenneth Anger (Fireworks [1947] and Scorpio Rising [1964]), Maya Deren (Meshes in the Afternoon [1943] and The Very Eye of Night [1954]), and Stanley Brakhage (Dog Star Man: Part I-IV [1962–1964]), these types of films forego traditional linear narrative (if not eschewing narrative altogether for more abstract or associational structures).40 The cinematic movement of the 1960s and 1970s further reflects the seeds planted by the French New Wave. Critics-cum-filmmakers François Truffaut (The 400 Blows [1959] and Jules and Jim [1962]) and Jean-Luc Godard (Masculine Feminine [1966] and Two or Three Things I Know About Her [1967]) spearheaded this film movement marked by quick and cheap production of films that bucked the traditions of classical Hollywood cinema. Foregrounding production techniques, often focusing on the shot or mise-en-scène rather than the cut, and creating inconclusive narratives, these directors forewent the singular, causal, linear conflict and resolution of Hollywood style, instead presenting narratives and visuals that articulate the injustice, confusion, despair, and absurdity of contemporary life. Troubling the viewing position by the use of the jump cut and an absence of the establishing shot, these films create holes once effaced by visual technique and linear, closed narratives of much popular Hollywood film.41 Whether by using visual non-sequiturs, porous narratives, or merely intense studies of a visual object, both the avant-garde and the French New Wave serve as definitive precursors to the types of innovation seen in the New American Cinema—and ultimately the more ambivalent musicals—of the 1960s and 1970s. These new films simultaneously defied classical Hollywood form and popular notions of morality. Steve Neale describes the narrative,
20
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
aesthetic, and ideological shifts associated with New American Cinema as posing such a challenge to established norms: The use of devices such as the zoom, telephoto lenses, slow motion and split-screen have destroyed the dramatic and spatio-temporal unity that founded classical mise-en-scène with its economy, density and “subtlety” of signification; plot-linearity and its corollary, the goal-oriented hero, have been replaced by narrative fragmentation and troubled, introspective protagonists; genre conventions have to a large extent been broken down, to be replaced by “realism” compromised by traditional dramatic values and the exigencies of narrative conventions or use of older generic conventions invested with an empty nostalgia or a knowing cynicism, or both.42 Foregrounding the self-awareness of this type of cinema, Thomas Elsaesser describes a move toward styles such as parody, pastiche, and adaptation, and narrative journeys that “foreground themselves and assume the blander status of a narrative device, sometimes a picaresque support for individual scenes, situations, and set pieces, another time ironically admitted pretext to keep the film moving.”43 Allowing a high level of reflexivity, ambivalent morality, internal contradiction in human action, and ideologically problematic social norms, these films embraced aesthetic experimentation, social realism, and an articulation of the palpable discontent occurring in a nation struggling though multiple assassinations, Civil and Women’s Rights Movements, and emerging sexual revolutions. Seemingly contrary to the arcadian tenets of the musical genre, these characteristics would nonetheless find their way into many musical films of the late 1960s, 1970s, and 1980s.44 Simultaneous to these developments in style and regulation in the 1960s, the musical finally embraced the socially contentious form of rock-n-roll. The industry had been courting the flush teenage market with quasi-musicals or pop musicals for decades. Rock-heavy nonmusicals such as Blackboard Jungle (1955) and films that included musical performance (Rock Around the Clock [1954], Don’t Knock the Rock [1956]) ushered in a new form of music-driven youthful danger. Although not integrated musicals, these films—both through content and audience response—brought the threatening image of the teenager to the fore.45 In a generic form traditionally associated with community and nostalgia, these rock films highlighted a violent or raucous path adults feared as looming for the budding teen demographic. With the success of the Elvis Presley films in the 1950s, pop stars flooded the
The Musical and Masculinity Take a Turn 21
quasi-musical. Young men such as Frankie Avalon (Beach Party [1963], I’ll Take Sweden [1965]), Pat Boone (April Love [1957], State Fair), Bobby Rydell (Bye, Bye Birdie), Fabian (Hound Dog Man [1959], High Time [1960]), and Bobby Darin (State Fair) popularized clean-cut film heroes with a beat. Despite this influx of pop and rock stars, the musical seemed to keep generically iconoclastic rock performances, sex, and teenage frenzy to a respectable minimum.46 (Even the hypersexual Elvis usually appeared less racy as his cinematic self.) However, concurrent with social critiques becoming more prevalent within film musicals, the pop star gave way to the rock star whose persona and musical style were more difficult to merge with the genre’s clean and idealistic narrative closures. By the mid 1960s, rock-n-roll musicals had taken on a sharper edge, both in terms of visual style and subject matter. The Beatles’ A Hard Day’s Night (1964) strayed from traditional musical fare to a narrative based on the frenzy of adoring fans and swinging lifestyles, as well as “arty,” shaky cameras and short shot lengths that replicated the harried lives of the band. Not a traditional celebration of wholesome musical and communal harmony, the film peppered the frenzied narrative with nondiegetic music from the Beatles, occasional performances of the band, and numbers that walked the line between integration and diegetic musical performance, pushing the boundaries of traditional musical norms by creating a story of unclear causality. The Monkees and Arlo Guthrie continued the trend with Head (1968) and Alice’s Restaurant (1969), presenting varying images of drug use and 1960s counterculture revolution. Rock music ushered out the nostalgic reification of hegemonic social norms and welcomed contemporary youth rebellion associated with sex, drugs, and rock-n-roll. Films such as these and Phantom of the Paradise (1973) dismiss the arcadian notion that music serves as a form of social glue. (With Paul Williams as devil/evil record producer who buys and enslaves the soul of a rock composer whose face has been horridly disfigured in a freak record press accident, one truly has to see it to believe it.) Instead, a darkened view of entertainment and entertainers frame the industry and performers as jaded, corrupt, lascivious, and anti-establishment—denying the narrative idealization of the entertainer Feuer and Altman identify as common in earlier films. A similar pessimism and hedonism would take hold of many of the integrated musicals of the period, now free to dabble in the darker side of society without the constraints of the Production Code. Through the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, the musical morphed and morphed again, negotiating musical forms, the role of music, and the role of the visual in both theatrical and cinematic musical
22
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
performance. The musical play a la Rodgers and Hammerstein would find popular and financial success on stage and screen and help to define this lucrative genre. On film, vehicles that fell outside of the integrated musical—star-studded revues, biopics, and some backstagers—helped in the continued transformation of the genre and its popular meaning. By the mid to late 1960s, reflecting a restructuring of the motion picture industry and the associated changes in economic, hiring, production, and distribution patterns, the once high-priced, big box-office musical genre declined in popularity as it struggled to survive in its new context. An alternate version of the integrated musical, contrary to the community-preserving, marriage-glorifying films of the 1940s and 1950s became dominant. Whether through the genre hybridization of Lost Horizon (disaster pic-cum-musical) or the cynical rock-n-roll stylings of The Who’s Tommy, the space for nuns to chortle over solving a problem like Maria or all of New York’s problems to be worked out by Judy Holliday parked at her Bells are Ringing (1960) Susanswerphone desk quickly decreased. The following chapters will begin to interrogate how such changes manifest themselves in the overall structure and connotation of these emerging genre films. Despite an overall decline in the economic viability of the musical during this period—with only a handful finding critical and economic success—an alternate view of the genre emerges through the time’s highs (Sweet Charity, Fiddler on the Roof [1971]) and lows (Lost Horizon). This shift in generic dictates or emergence of a new dominant form is by no means black and white. Films of this period negotiate their relationships with arcadian and ambivalent tendencies. While films such as Thoroughly Modern Millie and Grease more fully embrace norms of an earlier age, Tommy and All That Jazz almost wholly reject the formal and ideological norms of the musical’s more idealistic era and others such as Xanadu (1980), Popeye, Bugsy Malone, and Can’t Stop the Music (1980) exist in a state of tension between the two. Although an argument can surely be made that earlier musicals too vacillated between the dark and the idealistic, I argue that this later period shows a much more drastic turn. This body of films’ disdain for previously established norms and engagement with the contemporary state of social unrest and uncertainty consequently merge with developing visual and musical styles to present a newer and less affirming vision of the movie musical. While not all musicals illustrate drastic changes in style and content, nonetheless a shift in the dominant generic form from arcadian to ambivalent can be seen within the stories, visuals, performances, and performers of many of the integrated musicals of the 1966–1983 period.
The Musical and Masculinity Take a Turn 23
How the arcadias disappeared This book explores the splintering form and related gendered ramifications of the Hollywood musical by focusing on various building blocks of the genre through a lens of social and industrial change. By examining discrete elements related to the musical’s generic form—aesthetics, narrative, song and dance, and celebrity—the later popularized ambivalent form and its overall deviation from the earlier dominant arcadian become clear. The optimism of Hit the Deck (1955) gives way to the social and emotional complexity of Hair and All That Jazz. The visual nostalgia of Guys and Dolls transforms into the ahistorical realism/theatricality of Jesus Christ Superstar (1973) and Pennies from Heaven. Song, dance, and stardom lose their iconic meanings as Kelly’s and Astaire’s generically predetermined performances give way to generically iconoclastic performances by Aerosmith and The Who, while many films discard the traditional production number or communal performance altogether, leaving the community disintegrated. Examining narrative thrust and resolution, Chapter 1 focuses on the ambivalent narratives common to the 1966–1983 musicals and their engagement with a struggling America and changing Hollywood. During this period, many films feature a pattern of unsatisfactory resolutions. Love loses its hallowed place as relationships fail (Sweet Charity), take on non-monogamous/non-heterosexual overtones (The Rocky Horror Picture Show), or simply disappear (The Little Prince [1974]). Death and failure (Camelot, Hair, All That Jazz) also take center as these narratives eschew the over-determined reconciliations more reflective of an earlier musical era. Such new vehicles repeatedly foreground social unrest through racial difference, ultimately questioning the standard conciliatory and celebratory endings common to the musicals of a previous age. An examination of the period also highlights old and new forms of diegetic disruptions common to the genre, as the celebratory production number wanes in favor of framed narratives or performances within a performance (Jesus Christ Superstar, Godspell, Man of la Mancha [1972], Zoot Suit [1981]) that highlight the constructed nature of the diegetic world. Chapter 2 builds on Chapter 1 and illustrates how visual conventions associated with this newly powerful form of the genre reject the traditional projection of nostalgia in the musical. Complementing the more contentious narratives and following trends in New American Cinema, many musicals employ in vogue cinematic techniques (such as subjective shooting, montage sequences, disjointed shots, and shorter shot
24
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
length) that result in centering, decentering, or making the once idealistic subject appear strange or introspective. These retooled aesthetics that evoke introspection (All that Jazz, Fiddler on the Roof ), generic parody (Pennies from Heaven [the musical], Bugsy Malone [gangster]), visual, historical, and emotional “realism” (1776 [1972], Hair), extreme stylization (Tommy, Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band), or overt theatricality (Zoot Suit, Jesus Christ Superstar) compound the darker view of society promulgated by the repetition of new narrative tropes. These edgier forms of visual representations reject the simplistic nostalgia associated with the more arcadian musical while, along with changes in narrative structure, they project an inspection of human relationships, individual thought, and social stereotypes. While the Hollywood musical has relied heavily on the performance of human bodies and voices to carry out its utopic narratives, the 1966– 1983 period illustrates the significance of musical style, performance, and celebrity in the projection of a cinematic world view. Chapter 3 focuses on the performance of song and dance and the ways in which the musical’s new leading men challenge the defining characteristics of the genre. Not only does the level of narrative celebration wane, but also the overall level of joy associated with music and entertainment rapidly declines in these musicals reflective of ambiguous social norms and a darkening view of the entertainment industry. This diminution of music/dance as a spontaneous and public display of joy manifests itself through various characteristics: the prominence of non-singers/dancers who negligibly demonstrate emotion in their performances (Richard Harris, Rex Harrison, Peter Finch), voiceover singing (On a Clear Day You Can See Forever [1970], Goodbye, Mr. Chips [1969], Lost Horizon), overt cross-age and cross-sex vocal dubbing (Pennies from Heaven, Bugsy Malone), the integration of the hard edge of rock-n-roll (Tommy, Hair, Jesus Christ Superstar), and new robotic, overtly sexualized, and amorphous choreography (largely due to the contributions of Bob Fosse and Twyla Tharp).47 Along with changes in form and performance styles, the ambivalent musical saw a major influx of new leading players. Focusing specifically on musical men—who often took the narrative reins as stories repeatedly switched from female to male driven—Chapter 3 also examines the extra- and intertextual baggage that accompanies the new stars into the ambivalent form of the musical. New male stars often create a rift between celebrity personae and arcadian idealism (and more so than new female counterparts such as Linda Ronstadt, Bernadette Peters, and Kristy McNichol). As the studio system ceased the cultivation of new
The Musical and Masculinity Take a Turn 25
musical stars and those in existence outgrew their statuses as leading men, new stars identified primarily with the musical failed to emerge; rather, various alternate types of entertainers assumed the role of musical male. How do these personae like Keith Moon, Clint Eastwood, and Steve Martin merge with their musical characters and provoke different types of physical performances? How—via extratextual meaning based on their preexisting careers—are these men able to affect the types of stories told in these musical films? Chapter 4 examines the ways in which the characteristics of this newly dominant form of the musical ultimately impact upon the oftoverlooked presence of the male body and the overall presence of men and masculinity within the genre. Narratives shift to foreground male problems, performances foreground a construction of gender that deviates from the stable husband, and new male stars bring chaos, anarchy, and hypermasculinity to a genre once based on orderly communities and domestic providers. Looking at how issues of actor choice, performance, and narrative and aesthetic conventions converge to create an overall image of genre-specific masculinity, I use Butler’s notion of performativity to examine the construction of gender in the arcadian articulation of the musical. Subsequently, the information gleaned from the previous three chapters illustrates the musical’s widening range of acceptable or articulated masculinities. The building blocks—mise-en-scène, narrative, performance, and stars—of this darker and more ambivalent form of the genre combine to create an overall presentation of masculinity that deviates from the one repeated throughout the arcadian. No longer saddled to the domestic sphere and now presented through various versions of musical performance (integrated, performance within a performance, gender-switching) and gendered/sexual identity (breadwinner, playboy, bisexual), men and their emerging associated masculinities materialize as something less restrained than the one most popular in the earlier incarnation of the genre and more overtly complex than the queered and camped version identified by Cohan. Taking an unclear stand on hegemonic norms and foregrounding the actual construction—rather than “nature” or essence—of masculinity, these musicals manufacture masculinity as something ambivalent, fluid, variant and more reflective of its time. Finally, I conclude with an extended epilogue that takes a look into the present, examining the movements occurring within the genre from the mid-eighties through the first decade of the new millennium. Dividing the period into pre- and post-Evita (1996), it examines the integrated drought of the mid-eighties to mid-nineties and the new mini-musical
26
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
boom at the turn of the new millennium. Like the previous decades of film musicals, the styles that dominated these two phases of the genre reflect both the industrial and social conditions of their time. Abandoning the edginess of the New American Cinema for a high concept, high energy, high synergy musical, the pre-Evita period relied most heavily on animated Disney blockbusters (The Little Mermaid [1989], Beauty and the Beast [1991], The Lion King [1994]) and the dance-heavy non-integrated films like Footloose (1984) and Dirty Dancing (1987). Dependent on the teen audience and MTV-style visuals, these films would visually and thereby ideologically impact the mini-boom of the post-Evita period as they established a visual presentation of song and dance that obscured physical performance in favor of a music video-influenced aesthetic that featured quick paced cutting, back-to-back montage sequences, and striking images more likely to sell a look than tell a story. Through an examination of these new narratives and visuals, as well as the genre’s growing affinity for self-referentiality, generic parody, and pastiche, the epilogue examines the sense of social apathy reflected by the films and reflective of the target-marketed, hyper-mediated Generation X culture. With its projection of an idealized America and good old fashioned values, the musical once stood as one of the formative genres of Hollywood. Through the years, the genre surely waned—although the turn of the century has shown signs of a new invigorated interest in the genre. The book provides a deeper look into a period of this bedrock genre that for reasons economic, qualitative, or otherwise has been marginalized. Although films such as The Boy Friend, Lost Horizon, The Little Prince, and 1776 may not have created the cultural splash associated with Singin’ in the Rain (1952), South Pacific, or Mary Poppins (1964), they speak volumes about the state of Hollywood, changing norms within the film industry and the greater society of the sixties, seventies, and eighties, and the ideological ramifications of a genre often considered consistently conservative or mere fluff.
1 Nothing Is Comin’ Up Roses: The Desertion of Narrative Utopia
Throughout the 1966–1983 period of the Hollywood musical, the genre experienced a major shift in tone—musical and otherwise. Appearing to respond to major changes in the industry, filmmaking style, motion picture regulation, and the tumultuous American culture, a musical more reflective of social and cultural mores began to overtake the more idealistic version that had been popular through the previous decades. Despite a sprinkling of Hello, Dolly!s and Annies (1982), stories, visuals, and sounds deviated from previous norms, projecting an ambivalence toward entrenched generic dictates and the ideals they projected. These films popularized a new set of musical tropes that would—through repetition—begin to solidify a new dominant version of the genre more reflective of contemporary mores. Although not as monetarily successful as in the earlier days of the musical, the genre revision did more aptly reflect the kind of social contract film genres supposedly represent between those in the industry and the viewers who (hopefully) fill theatres. The ambivalence directed toward traditional generic themes in the Hollywood musical takes a firm hold of film narratives during this later period. In their seminal works on genre and the musical, both Thomas Schatz and Rick Altman identify romance and the unification of differing social groups as the bedrock of the classical musical structure.1 Whether the story’s frame engaged with gangsters, cowboys, socialites, or businessmen, romantic heroes most often found their heroines. The two then overcame their social differences and lived happily ever after. In such films, narrative conflicts seldom reached a degree of complexity that could not be overcome by the love of a good woman and a dazzling final dance number. The simplicity of conflict resolution highlighted by Altman and Schatz and theorized in Richard Dyer’s 27
28
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
conceptualization of the utopic sensibility of the musical genre shone through a significant faction of the musicals of the thirties, forties, fifties, and early sixties. Richard Adler’s and Jerry Ross’s The Pajama Game (1957) exemplifies the narrative style highlighted as forming the basis of the early generic structure. Based on the Broadway hit, and starring Doris Day and John Raitt, the film centers on an impending workers’ strike in a pajama factory. Divided solidly between the workers and the management, the community needs to heal wounds inflicted by the conflicting desires of the two groups. The narrative seeks to mend this division through a romance plotline involving Day’s Babe Williams, the head of the grievance committee/union rabble-rouser and Raitt’s Sid Sorkin, the new Superintendent of Sleeptite Pajamas who is hired to block the strike and negotiate a contract amenable to the needs of both groups—although his alliance lies with management. As Babe and Sid negotiate their budding romance, their relationship becomes inextricable from the union negotiation over the proposed seven-anda-half-cent raise. Bob Fosse choreographs a stylized, syncopated work stoppage that heightens the work-oriented conflict while challenging the budding romance. Ultimately, the prospect of a love lost for a lousy seven-and-a-half cents pushes Sid to act. The strike ends, love continues, and happiness ensues. A love strong enough to resolve company conflict allows the bridging of management–labor difference and leads to an inexplicable production number in which happily united couples model pajamas for no apparent reason. Joy, commerce, and romance reign triumphant. Similar conflicts and resolutions exist across the genre. Silk Stockings confronts the opposing needs of a frigid Russian comrade (Cyd Charisse) and a dancing producer (Fred Astaire); female backwoods ingenuity, frontier entertainment, and the male ego clash in Irving Berlin’s Annie Get Your Gun (1950). Such clear-cut conflicts and resolutions resound through earlier decades of the genre. Such films adhere to what this book refers to as arcadian norms of the form, embodying romance and utopian sensibilities and centering on two characters who must succeed in their romance to overcome external conflicts (business, class, politics) that otherwise keep them in different worlds (or at least on different sides of the town, mountain, or horse). Only their union and the consequential renunciation of external conflict can resolve this musical narrative and lead the characters into a world where they can coexist peacefully. Although romances, bonded communities, enchanting entertainers, and promises of a future utopia stand solidly at the center of the more arcadian sixties and seventies films such as Half a Sixpence, Grease,
Nothing Is Comin’ Up Roses
29
Finian’s Rainbow (1968), and Hello, Dolly!, more important to this study is the large group of films that emerge eschewing such relational idealism for more conflicted views of the once traditional themes of love, community, and entertainment. The ambivalence that these films project toward the once safely recurrent themes of the genre strongly reflects the triumvirate of external forces weighing down on emergent Hollywood product: social, industrial, and stylistic shifts. Movie musicals coming from both the stage and created specifically for the screen challenged the curative social function of arcadian or classical musical narratives as they embraced the artistic/ideological styles of the French New Wave and New American Cinema and reflected a hopeless or irresolvable social pressure related to rising divorce rates, an unpopular war, and concurrent battles for civil, women’s, and gay rights. No longer reflective of the homogenous containment culture, these films often retain narratives that engage with the themes popular in earlier musicals—community, romance, and entertainment—but present no such comfortable resolutions. Contentious subjects were not wholly foreign to earlier musicals, even those that ultimately embraced arcadian values. In The American Film Musical Altman discusses the folk musical as including distress and rupture within its narrative communities, much like this later ambivalent group. Citing examples such as gang warfare (West Side Story), a corrupt gambling partner (Hallelujah), the devil (Cabin in the Sky), the Immigration Department (Flower Drum Song), a hurricane (Porgy and Bess [1959]), and sickness or death (Riding High [1950] and Little Nellie Kelly [1940]), Altman states, “The genius of the folk musical is that it manages both to mythify the American past and yet, by making the process of mythification visible, to retain before our eyes the very dangers which necessitated that process to begin with.” Although presenting a somewhat darker view of humanity common in the later musicals, the diegetic threat is cleanly (or at least temporarily through the climactic production number) alleviated by the folk musical’s end. West Side Story’s gangs see the error of their ways through the death of Tony. The new and old worlds join together in Flower Drum Song. The son returns to his family in Hallelujah, and Petunia and Little Joe ascend to Heaven in Cabin in the Sky.2 Despite momentary rupture in the darker folk musicals, commonly wholesome entertainment and entertainers do save family and country, aid in finding true love, and make winners out of the diegetic—and by proxy the viewing—audience. To the contrary, musicals of this 1966–1983 period frequently stray from the comfortable world of idealism and nostalgia to embrace a
30
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
sense of ambivalence toward its characters and their worlds, ones more indicative of the prevailing real-world social and artistic realities. These realities stand contradictory to the more peace-affirming themes of earlier films. By this point in American history, the likelihood of the happy union had come into question in the social consciousness. Between the late fifties and seventies, the stability of social forces that spoke to the bedrock of the genre came more forcefully into question. The mediated rise of the playboy lifestyle—touted by Hugh Hefner and Playboy magazine—and scientific research that highlighted the medical dangers of the career/family-driven white collar male questioned the husband/worker ideal—the role commonly embodied by the musical male hero.3 The American divorce rate, which had held relatively firm through the 1950s, saw steady increase from the mid-1960s through the early 1980s. Between 1965 and 1975, the rate of divorce nearly doubled.4 The simultaneous shift in generic tone or narrative focus to one less keen on the primacy of monogamous heterosexual coupling speaks to both Schatz’s argument regarding the need for social relevance in the maintenance of generic codes and Marc Miller’s suggestion that America’s political, racial, and sexual upheaval led to the decline of the genre.5 Simultaneous to the cracks emerging in the image of the nuclear family, during these later decades of the musical, the United States suffered significant upheaval on both national and international fronts. With the escalation of the war in Vietnam, a growing sense of “us” and “them” emerged, whether that dichotomy represented the people/government, young/old, protestors/patriots, or American soldiers/Jane Fonda. Far from the “honorable wars” in Europe and Asia that occurred during the musical’s heyday or the communal sense of unity as the nation rallied around the flag—while ignoring dirty little secrets of Italian, German, and Japanese internment camps—an overwhelming sense of social unrest and irresolvable conflict permeated the later part of the sixties and early part of the seventies. To compound the conflict surrounding Vietnam, a flurry of social movements destroyed any sense of national harmony. Surely racial, sexual, and gendered divisions pre-dated the unrest associated with the respective social movements, but not until the sixties and seventies did they impress themselves as strongly on the social psyche. In contrast to the post-World War II glorification of Levittowns (subtext “white flight”) or the solidification of the postwar family (read the repression of working women and proliferation of popular images of the suburban housewife), these decades brought the rise of second wave feminism, the Stonewall riots, nationally televised
Nothing Is Comin’ Up Roses
31
race riots in Watts and Detroit, and the assassinations of both Martin Luther King, Jr and Malcolm X. While simmering below the surface in the previous decades, the unmitigated inequality within American society came rushing to the fore and in direct conflict with all that the Hollywood musical had traditionally evoked—whiteness, harmony between divergent groups, and economic and domestic success. The same media once used to reinforce stringent social norms increasingly projected the undermining thereof. While the pre- and post-World War II drive toward containment culture and homogeneity had played well in much of the mainstream media and within the historically conservative musical genre, print and television news more frequently brought social unrest into America’s living rooms—and in living color. Reflecting an adherence to trends popularized by the French New Wave and emerging into Hollywood through the New American Cinema, by 1966 more movie musicals projected the social ambivalence common in such films, as well as narrative stylings of incoherence and inconclusiveness that produced a lasting sense of confusion or unrest. As in non-musical French and American films such as The 400 Blows, Masculin-Feminin, Nashville, and The Graduate, trends emerged that when incorporated into the musical genre led to more complex narratives that surpassed two-dimensional notions of human nature and conflict resolution. Inconclusive endings of both The 400 Blows and Nashville rebuke the narrative closure and, as critics have argued, hegemonic reinforcement of classical Hollywood film. The youthful drug dealers, robbers, and murderers of Bonnie and Clyde and Easy Rider (1969) simultaneously popularized the antihero, a new narrative staple who transcended the ideological reaffirmation of the traditional Hollywood hero while still retaining the position of narrative focus or power. These new narrative trends in films simultaneously fractured norms regarding narrative structure and questioned the maintenance of a filmic status quo. Reflective of the social unrest occurring outside the diegesis, these films questioned the righteousness of those in power (adults, law abiding citizens, the police, the military) while also problematizing those who stood in opposition to the power structure (often youth or youth countercultures). As these non-musical films challenged the norms of narrative resolution and moral clarity, the musical followed in lockstep as emergent narratives embraced ideological ambivalence, thereby complicating one of the most traditionally socially reaffirming Hollywood genres and reproducing the lack of ideological and narrative clarity popularized by their European and American predecessors.
32
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
The social unrest and artistic shifts occurring at this time ultimately manifest themselves in the themes already popularized by the genre. Those films described here as ambivalent musicals reflect the contemporary moment through their more troubled relationship with romance, community, and entertainment. Rather than presenting these elements as a pyramid of social stability and communal gaiety, the films engage with them through new artistic mores that easily articulate the ambivalence in America’s social landscape. The ever-present romance would ultimately turn unstable, aberrant, or irrelevant, while the community— once the site of the musical’s celebratory finale—appeared as splintered or absent as the real-world communities on the pages of the New York Times, and entertainment and entertainers as dystopic and scandal-ridden as corrupt disc jockeys and the hedonistic mavens of Studio 54.
People won’t say we’re in love—The dissolution of romance Sex and love far from disappear from musicals during the 1966– 1983 period. As a real life sexual revolution and post-“pill”/pre-AIDS frenzy waged on for both men and women, musicals both retained old familiar notions of romance and infused the genre with more contentious notions of love, sex, and relationships. At times abandoning the romance formula altogether for one more akin to the melodrama, the double protagonist identified by Altman and Schatz often disappears in the later musicals as the male’s personal and public journeys—and overall moral (or immoral) fiber—take center in the narrative and highlight the legitimacy of singlehood or personal struggles outside of the codified heterosexual couple. Shattered romance As the divorce rate and cries for free love rose and Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf and The Graduate provided scathing critiques of the dirty underbelly of suburban American marriage and the American dream, many new musicals forewent even the gesture of the status quo-affirming (and once imperative) wedding festivity or celebratory conclusion. Instead they left a lasting impression of the protagonist’s physical or moral downfall, the couple’s incompatibility, or an overall sense of hopelessness or ambivalence toward love and romantic union. Instead of happily joining their couples in a rousing production number of communal gaiety—as does Oklahoma! with the reprise of
Nothing Is Comin’ Up Roses
33
“Oh What a Beautiful Morning”—many films of this period embrace an overall cynicism regarding love and marriage. Still engaging with the subject of romance, these films often illustrate the impossibility of the arcadian ideal and/or critique the hero’s/heroine’s attempt to continue down a road to marital bliss. Indicative of this trend, Sweet Charity, At Long Last Love, Camelot, and Funny Girl underscore the emergent reluctance of musicals to conform to the old mold. Instead, they overtly dispute the “love can conquer all” tenant that drove so many earlier musicals.6 At Long Last Love and Sweet Charity both exemplify the pessimistic views of romance reflective of this diegetic and historical period. Gone is the expected final kiss. Instead of building a narrative on the assumption of ultimate conciliatory resolution—as discussed by Altman in his discussion of narrative construction within the genre film—they send a shock to the generic system, concluding the films with no resolution. They not only reject the primacy of the romantic union, but also the necessity of any kind of final decision or closure. Shirley MacLaine’s trusting dime-a-dance Charity can only aspire to be the heroine of the arcadian musical. Established as an honorable, idealistic girl who just happens to work in a sleazy business, she moves from man to man, being robbed by her fiancé Charlie and stashed in a closet by movie star Vittorio Vitalle, until she meets the supposed man of her dreams, Oscar Lindquist, while trapped in an elevator. Sensitive, timid, and violently claustrophobic, Oscar appears ideal for Charity. Altman has after all described the perfect musical pair as embodying opposite characteristics.7 If the man represents freedom, the woman must represent restraint. If the man is a professional entertainer, the woman must be an amateur. By reinforcing the notions that opposites attract, the characters are able to synthesize seemingly incongruous character types, walks of life, or factions of society—as long as they both possess an underlying desire for romance, couplehood, and communal harmony. The personal victories thereby ultimately create one vision of peaceful coexistence, suggesting the possibility for social utopia. In the arcadian musical Charity and Oscar would overcome different backgrounds, and the love that develops as he makes her feel like a lady and she helps him overcome his claustrophobia would conquer all. Instead, through their repetition, darker narratives like Sweet Charity reinforce the incongruous nature of opposites and the overwhelming cynicism of society and the musical genre. Abandoned at the altar because Oscar is haunted by thoughts of Charity’s bevy of ex-lovers and Charlie’s name tattooed on her shoulder, Charity must continue to hope for change and love in a world that gives her no reason to expect her dreams will come true.
34
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
Oscar does not change his mind and sweep her off her feet in the end. Her female friends do not comfort her and create an alternate utopia of female friendship (for she is too embarrassed to admit to them that she has failed in her escape from the dime-a-dance life). She must simply walk alone, watching the other couples spoon in the park, hoping that someday she too can find happiness in a society contemptuous of her past and continuously creating road blocks for a changed future.8 Similarly, Peter Bogdanovich’s homage/satire of the 1930s musical At Long Last Love works against arcadian conventions. Whereas Sweet Charity highlights the impossibility of merging romance between two different worlds, At Long Last Love presents a world full of irreconcilable sameness and improbable love. The narrative centers on four characters and their varying sets of romances: privileged playboy tycoon Michael Oliver Prichard III or MOP (Burt Reynolds), poor little rich girl Brooke Carter (Cybill Shepherd) who is forever waiting for her next check from mother, singer and dancer Kitty O’Kelly (Madeline Kahn), and Little Orphan Annie obsessed exotic gambler Johnny Spanish (Duilio Del Prete). Although Kitty and Johnny lack the economic capital of Brooke and Michael, the four appear immediately compatible and romance blooms as MOP and Kitty and Johnny and Brooke strike up relationships. The action minimizes the social conflict or division as the four dance, sing Cole Porter numbers such as “Friendship,” drink as only the social elite can, and party. The number “Well Did You Evah?” highlights the similarity within the group and difference between them and the society in which they circulate. As the foursome radiates life, passion, joy, and music, the greater society—depicted by the nameless social elite—emanates conformity and ambivalence toward life itself. At a high-toned society party, the four mock the stiff propriety of the guests as they report fictitious and horrific accidents—avalanche, cosmic collision, cannibalism—to guests who each retain their decorum and identically note what a swell party it is. However, the interchangeable nature of the characters leads to partner swapping, and ultimately, the film ends with unhappiness for all and an unclear resolution regarding the relationships. It ends as it begins, with a close-up of a music box of two pairs of dancing partners. As the music plays, the two couples swap partners and continue dancing, mirroring the ending of the film. As the men and women desire different mates, they dance at a society event, suffering a similar form of apathy earlier mocked by the foursome. Rather than synthesizing energy and calm, the group relocates from one to the other, failing in romance and losing the energy and
Nothing Is Comin’ Up Roses
35
passion associated with it. Romance cannot conquer all. It may just be one more route to ennui.
Lusty musicals Another way in which musicals of the later period reflect a cynicism toward hetero-monogamy and embrace alternative sexual options is by abandoning the communal bond of companionate love and romance for acts of carnal lust. Early musicals surely implied sex. After all, those theatre folk in the early backstagers always seemed to be up to something. Theatre folk aside, as early as Love Me Tonight (1932), extreme randiness entered musical narratives, with the oversexed Maurice pursuing and ultimately wooing the frigid Princess Jeanette. One year later the ambivalent-leaning pre-Code Melody Cruise centered on adulterous affairs and a fear of commitment. Seven Brides for Seven Brothers surely implies some mattress squeaking—for only the birth of the married couple’s child and the claim that the baby was actually the illegitimate product of one of the unwed brothers and his captive beloved can urge the girls’ fathers to allow the climactic sextuple marriage. Oklahoma!’s Ado Annie proudly proclaims that she “can’t say no,” only to say yes to her intended, Will Parker. In each film, however, sex (implied or otherwise) ultimately creates a path to marriage. Amid the sexual revolution and the 1969 release of Everything You Always Wanted to Know About Sex (But Were Afraid to Ask) and prior to the 1980s AIDS panic, the genre challenged its earlier dictum by engaging with more overtly debauched notions of male–female (or male–male) relations. Films such as Paint Your Wagon, The Rocky Horror Picture Show, Pennies from Heaven, and All That Jazz infuse contemporary topicality and contentious morality into musical narratives with premarital, extramarital, and/or non-monogamous, non-heterosexual sex as the locus of communal disharmony and personal dissatisfaction. Similarly, films use infidelity as a major narrative catalyst to maudlin conclusions (Camelot and A Little Night Music [1977]) or simply foreground the sex act in ways seldom seen in the Code era musical genre (The Boy Friend—orgy, Man of la Mancha—rape, 1776—sex as a relief for writers block, Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band—sex as corporate corruption). The temptation to deviate from traditional rules regarding sex, love, and marriage pushes many such narratives toward conclusions that do not and ultimately cannot mirror the traditional conciliatory romantic resolution once so common to the genre.
36
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
Paint Your Wagon, focuses on the polyandrous relationship of Pardner (Clint Eastwood), his mining partner Ben (Lee Marvin), and a recently purchased Mormon woman, Elizabeth, whose husband sells her off while traveling through the all-male mining town. Prior to the arrival of Elizabeth, the men live seemingly happy lives eating, drinking, fighting, and dancing with one another. Not until the female arrival does anyone stop to interrogate his own lifestyle. Though officially married to Ben, Elizabeth takes a liking to Pardner, resulting in a happy and socially sanctioned threesome.9 With the intrusion of an upstanding Christian family on No Name City—at this point harboring the threesome and making quite a name for itself as a bastion of prostitution and liquor—the perversity of the Ben–Pardner–Elizabeth arrangement becomes evident to its participants. Illicit or unconventional sex acts and an invasion of rigid morality lead to an eventual dissolution of community. The film concludes with Ben moving on to prospect elsewhere and Pardner, a farmer by trade, remaining to live properly with Elizabeth. Both All That Jazz and Pennies from Heaven project these similar ambivalences toward the form and the legitimate place of sex/romance. All That Jazz’s director/choreographer Joe Gideon (Roy Scheider)—based on the film’s director Bob Fosse—vacillates between his ex-wife Audrey, current girlfriend Kate, daughter Michelle, various lovers, and the confrontation of his limited mortality in the dream world of Angelique the virgin/therapist/angel figure. Rife with sex, drugs, cigarettes, and more sex, Joe’s life is on a crash course with disaster. In the same way, Pennies from Heaven places unnatural sex as the cause of all narrative calamities. From Arthur’s (Steve Martin) unwanted advances toward his wife, a fetish for lipstick on her nipples, and implications of anal sex, to his extramarital affair with Eileen/Lulu (Bernadette Peters) that results in a pregnancy, abortion, and ultimate prostitution, the film places the cause of Arthur’s downfall solidly on his carnal lust. The Rocky Horror Picture Show takes a similar tack toward the notion of heteronormativity and monogamy, while simultaneously embracing the more self-reflective qualities of New American Cinema in its overt awareness of its generic critique. In a knowing wink to arcadian norms, the film begins with the number “Dammit Janet” in which its upstanding leading man Brad Majors (Barry Bostwick) professes his love to his girlfriend (Susan Sarandon) after a friend’s wedding. As he flits through the churchyard, cemetery, and church itself, he decries his undying love for her as he presents her with a ring. Like more traditional arcadian films, the number establishes the wholesome version of romance promulgated
Nothing Is Comin’ Up Roses
37
by earlier articulations of the genre. Directly following the serenade, however, the newlywed’s shaving cream graffitied wedding car cruises across the screen—and foregrounding the suspect positioning of sex— reads, “She got hers, now he’ll get his.” Ultimately, Janet and Brad enter a world of transvestitism, bisexuality, and group sex. Sex between Janet, Brad, bisexual/transvestite Frank-N-Furter (Tim Curry), and the monster Rocky may momentarily bring the two worlds closer together in arcadian fashion—culminating in an Esther Williams-esque swimming pool orgy—but ultimately this newly formed community is destroyed at the hands of incestuous alien siblings Riff Raff and Magenta. After the murders of Frank-N-Furter and Rocky, Janet and Brad crawl through the castle’s rubble dressed in fishnets and corsets and bereft of the innocence they once possessed. As with Ben and Pardner—both rejecting arcadian norms and failing to establish new acceptable social alternatives—the peace found in alternate modes of sexual expression cannot bear the burden of society, even one far removed from reality. Like the social struggle waging between the free love generation and the traditional mores of their parents, instability and social unrest remain at the center. Further, such narrative deviance reflects a new freedom in cinematic expression found in the wake of the dissolution of the Production Code. Like the controversially touted X-rated Midnight Cowboy (1969), these recurrent conflicts reflect the medium’s drive to integrate more overtly sexual subject matter and test regulatory and social boundaries of the medium. Such narratively ambiguous and sexually explicit films push boundaries seldom challenged by early Code-era musical narratives. Although often casting moral aspersions through their disastrous— or inconclusive—conclusions, the sexual and communal possibilities expressed in these narratives short-circuit the over-determined process of meaning-making often associated with genre films. As argued in Pierre Bourdieu’s discussion of discursive critique within the doxic society—one in which the established order “goes without saying and is therefore unquestioned”—the mere uncovering of the arbitrariness of the assumed unquestionable norm brings that norm into question.10 While such ambivalent musicals often reinforce the naturalness or at least safety of monogamous heterosexual relationships, alternate sexual behavior articulates additional possibilities and not only questions the normalcy of relationships portrayed in arcadian musicals, but ultimately changes their status as the solitary option. Such musicals construct a much messier society, one that cannot always provide a proper solution. Reinforcing the notion of generic social relevance, these
38
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
more ambivalent films show the cracks in the façade of the stability of the society in which they were produced. As in contemporary America, these musicals’ inhabitants will not always make safe decisions in life and love. Rather, unchained sexual desire or a complicated society— two characteristics often lacking from earlier musicals—may cloud the protagonists’ decisions and lead toward a murky outcome.
Who needs romance, let’s talk about me Musicals of this period not only challenge the old notions of musical utopia by questioning romance as pure or foolproof, but further reject the very basis of arcadian style by decentering the characters and conflicts that stood at the center: couples and coupling. In the wake of shifts in motion picture regulation, the once nearly-mandatory romantic core of the genre gave way to complex and individual-focused narratives. Underscoring this emergent ambivalence toward earlier norms and limitations and incorporating contemporary critique of gender norms, more films placed their focuses elsewhere, highlighting personal quests or internal struggles rather than romantic coupling. Contemporary challenges to established gender norms for both men and women came to the fore during this period—both socially and filmically—challenging normalcy of tradition/traditional roles, the righteousness of political leaders, and the definition of male courage. In American culture, Betty Friedan was questioning the destined role of women and their “problem that has no name” and a new and invigorated feminist movement took hold and raged-on. Despite this cultural focus on the social construction of femininity, the musical was turning from its female-focused romance narratives to ones that focused more heavily on men.11 Like non-musical films that challenged generic tropes of masculinity—such as revisionists Westerns like McCabe and Mrs. Miller (1971), Little Big Man (1970), Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid (1969), and Billy Jack (1971)— many new musicals turned a similar critical eye to male rather than female struggle for identity. As the couple became decentered in this once traditionally-termed feminine genre, men and their non-romantic woes came into focus. The musical male repeatedly shifted his focus from romance to career, internal conflict, or larger philosophical concerns. He turned from a man driven by a seemingly biological destiny to mate and procreate to one mired in his own sense of personal struggle, ambition, and place within the greater society. In essence, this type of shift both rejected and questioned the primacy of the heterosexual union and, at times, the very stability of generic closure.
Nothing Is Comin’ Up Roses
39
Even a film such as Fiddler on the Roof, commonly discussed with regard to its attention to marriage, relationships, and romance, merely uses such relational conflicts as a means to complicate overarching themes regarding tradition and social change. Ultimately, whether Tevye’s daughters marry the tailor, the revolutionary, and the gentile and live happily ever after is secondary. These relationships activate moral struggles for the women’s father. They force decisions and compromises regarding a larger view of life; the romances themselves are not central to the overall conclusion of the narrative. While adding to the family drama, they do not impact upon the overall ousting of the Jews from their community. Similarly, 1776’s women—Abigail Adams and Martha Jefferson—solely function as outlets for their husbands’ emotions/libidos. Several scenes use the convention of John and Abigail speaking through letters (although they appear to be having complex two-way conversations). These interactions allow John to express complex emotions regarding his work in Congress to an appropriate confidant in ways unseemly in the company of his fellow politicians.12 This relationship mainly acts as a legitimated locus for soliloquy. Hair’s Sheila serves as a similar catalyst or icon. Ultimately coupling with neither Berger nor Claude—perhaps the true dual protagonists in the film—her socialite status simply works to complicate the class wars occurring between the middle-class hippies, working-class drafted farm boy, and the New York elite. Her role as domestic or even sexual partner is ultimately irrelevant. The decentering of romance in films such as these creates space for more isolated public or personal journeys and complex social critique. Many films of this later period eschew the pretense of romantic focus by wholly or largely omitting such relationships on the part of their protagonists and constructing narratives that solely revolve around personal quests, religious journeys, and cultural struggles. Without the conciliatory coupled ending and expected successful romance, the social critique and individual journeys become more biting and complicated. Inconclusive endings and stories unfettered by cheerful romance mirror their non-musical Hollywood counterparts, reflect the grittiness of post-Code Hollywood, and rebuke the safety of much of the period’s more traditional and often sanitized television offerings. Bonnie and Clyde’s glamorous, freewheeling escape from boredom and poverty violently erupts in a hailstorm of bullets. Easy Rider’s psychedelic journey toward personal enlightenment results in ideological bankruptcy and Billy and Wyatt’s ultimate demise. As with these antiheroes who simultaneously challenge the status quo and fail in attempts to subvert it,
40
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
this emergent musical style produced a conflicted yet critical vision of society and humankind not common in the earlier Hollywood musicals’ traditional—or at least recuperated—gender roles and wedding banquets.13 Along these lines, journeys of personal enlightenment—rather than romance—drive The Wiz, The Little Prince, and Tommy. Casting aside any suggestion of romantic involvement for leading men or women, they examine the emotional growth of Dorothy, The Pilot, and Tommy respectively. With no identifiable love interest for the protagonists, these films focus on the internalization of the personal conundrums felt by their lead characters, playing out self-exploration without the burden of a guaranteed recuperation in their conclusions. The Little Prince focuses almost solely on the pitfalls of contemporary society via the perspectives of The Pilot and the Little Prince. An upper-class boy shunned by his elders, The Pilot discovers the need for kinship as the Little Prince articulates the inanity, depravity, and tenderness of the world through his solitary interactions with various planets/rulers (a landhogging king, a warmongering general, and a reality-constructing historian), the cunning snake, and the fox. Ultimately, the narrative quite simply follows the emotional journeys of the two, illuminating the need for joy and kinship on the part of the once solitary and somber Pilot. Further denying the possibility of meaningful relationships, however, the Little Prince dies, only providing a lasting shadow of companionship. Reinforcing the ambivalent musical’s push toward personal introspection and discovery in a world hostile to personal needs, Tommy focuses on the title character’s journey into manhood. The morally bankrupt and lascivious natures of his mother and stepfather greatly affect Tommy’s development, but the story of the boy remains solitary— highlighted by his initial deafness, blindness, and muteness. Like The Little Prince, Tommy’s narrative relies not on the interactions of a couple, but the personal discoveries of an individual. Others act on Tommy until his bizarrely liberating discovery of pinball and the eventual regaining of his senses. Once cured of his physical ailments, he is free to act upon others, creating Tommy’s Holiday Camp/Pinball religious cult. In the end, a camper riot destroys the boy’s utopic settlement and the film’s final image depicts Tommy standing alone atop a mountain: no true love, no visible success, but an indeterminate image of conquest and possibility. As in real life and typified by other contemporary cinema, the film depicts no true conclusion, simply a pseudo-resolution to a series of misadventures and an implication of more to come.
Nothing Is Comin’ Up Roses
41
Films like How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying (1967), 1776, and Camelot (though more invested in the romance than most) instead center their narratives on the career-driven exploits of their main characters. Whether corporate or political, the stakes in these films’ conflicts intensify around issues regarding the protagonists’ professional rather than personal lives. Like the narratives of personal exploration, these films enter into investigations of individual actions in the complicated world of work.14 This shift regarding narrative placement of the career further underscores a social prioritization of the self over the family and community. Whereas arcadian musicals too build stories around careers, often such films merely use those vocations as backdrops for a budding romance or otherwise joyous occasion (for example, actors in The Band Wagon [1953], the military in South Pacific, and modeling in Funny Face [1957]). 1776 restructures the musical narrative to focus more heavily on the political process and conflicts. While female characters remain in the periphery, the bulk of the narrative hashes out conflicts occurring between battling factions of the Continental Congress. Unfettered by the conciliatory ending, the film speaks to its post-Watergate audience as it critiques backroom dealings and highlights infighting occurring within and between varying states and the concessions and conflicts often glossed over in the idealistic history lesson made of the signing of The Declaration of Independence. Instead of serving as a mere backdrop, the political process is the primary plot of the narrative. Negotiations over slavery, apathy regarding the state of the militia and dying soldiers, class disputes, and battling personalities become the center of the story. The personal journey and business venture merge as films at times sideline love for the spiritual quest for some sort of superior being or consciousness. Whether through an actual Christ tale, the Christ-like Tommy, or Shangri-La’s Lama, films capitalize on the absence of conciliatory ending/romance to steer narrative focus toward an interrogation of the internal moral, philosophical, and ethical conflicts associated with the acceptance of a higher being in a living society. These musicals reject the notion that trust and faith serve as clear barometers for successful familial or romantic relationships and are often antithetical to uncomplicated resolutions. In the more arcadian Cabin in the Sky, Petunia and Little Joe struggle with worldly desires and issues of faith but ultimately earn entrance to an ideal Heaven. In later films, however, protagonists struggle with desires for spiritual devotion within the context of complicated, changing societies in which such faith poses contradictions to the status quo or danger to the faithful. Jesus Christ Superstar, for example, puts a contemporary spin on Judas’s religious
42
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
quandary and forces an investigation of contemporary politics, community pressure, and individual crises of faith. With no clear conclusion, the focus remains on the inconclusiveness of religion in a world based on politics and wary of faith. Individual stories and choices outweigh a clean resolution.15 Lost Horizon engages in a similar quandary, although the answer appears less elusive than Jesus Christ Superstar’s when a planeload of hijacked Americans and Englishmen seek aid from a band of natives (led by an Asian Sir John Gielgud) who lead them to Shangri-La. They must ultimately search themselves for the true meaning of happiness as they discover they have been kidnapped to a social utopia. But paradise comes with a catch; anyone who stays must never return to his or her home in the United States or England.16 He or she must decide whether a utopian vision serves as a paradise or prison. Much like the quests portrayed in the Christ musicals and Tommy, Lost Horizon questions a greater system of beliefs, concept of society, and the ultimate meaning of life. Romance is not the meaning of life but only a piece of a greater picture. Further, unlike Bing Crosby’s Going My Way (1944) and Say One for Me (1959), religion and spiritual exploration do not function simply as means to bring joy, cloak evil, or service shenanigans. These ambivalent films reach to pessimistic or troubled visions of religion as a central locale at which large unanswerable questions may be posed and struggled over—a characteristic itself incongruous with the clean and mandatory closure of many earlier films, yet almost expected in non-musical films of this period and reflective of America’s troubled decades.
Social disarray or disenfranchisement Although earlier musicals had commonly dealt with some sort of cultural struggle, many musicals of this period present sharper, less recuperable critiques of the dominant system.17 These films complement contemporary social unrest with more nuanced diegetic pictures of cultural struggle. This is partly due to more complicated representations of race relations than are common to most musicals. Films such as South Pacific and Show Boat (1951) serve as anomalies as they engage with race and ethnicity through their main and subplots. Ultimately, however, both films minimize the racial threat within their narratives. South Pacific separates its interracial couple through an honorable soldier’s death, and the makers of Show Boat chose an obviously white star (Ava Gardner) to portray its mulatta character.18 Rejecting topics that
Nothing Is Comin’ Up Roses
43
thwart easy resolution, arcadian-styled narratives seldom engaged with racial diversity or inequity.19 Flower Drum Song, Porgy and Bess, and early African-American musicals such as Moon Over Harlem (1939) and Stormy Weather (1943) place non-white characters in mono-racial/mono-ethnic worlds where otherness need not compete with or negotiate the dominant group’s place in the social hierarchy because that group remains visibly absent throughout the film. Films such as Road to Hong Kong (1962) and Hit the Deck, to the contrary, present racial difference within the white world, but do so in a manner that relegates otherness to a secondary position. Bob Hope, Crosby, and Joan Collins don yellowface in Road to Hong Kong, trivializing racial difference, while 1955’s Hit the Deck relegates non-white characters to secondary roles that can easily be separated from the main narrative and its ideological stakes. (A group of African-American servants arbitrarily appears to hoof it up and accompany the white sailors in a rousing version of “Hallelujah.”) Although films such as Tommy, Godspell, and Sweet Charity flirt with racial critique while more fully embracing a liberal pluralist view of society that embraces difference without fully interrogating it, others tackle such problematic issues head-on and embrace the troubled social implications of presenting more integrated ensembles. Zoot Suit’s engagement with the Zoot Suit riots and related murders, systemic racism in the justice system, and discord within the Latino community, much more fully acknowledges social inequity and irresolvable social conflict than a film like Flower Drum Song, which engages with in-group conflict while white-washing a recent troubled history of Asian relations in the United States. Although Hair fails to interrogate deeply the politics or backgrounds of its hippies, socialites, farmers, or soldiers—a pitfall of much film and the musical specifically—the film’s music and overall narrative probe farther and more overtly into American racial, generational, and political dissent than most film musicals before or since. Hair uses its romance plotline to provide access to class conflicts as Berger and the others crash a party given by socialite Sheila’s parents and horrify the upper-class with their carnal verve for living in “I’ve Got Life.” Both Hair’s musical numbers—often tongue-in-cheek examinations of racial, political, or generational conflict—and its overall narrative avoid idealizing the accomplishments or personal value systems of the hippies.20 The African American member of the group, Hud, possesses a groovy quality as he rebukes racism by reappropriating terms such as “jigaboo,” “pickaninny,” “Little Black Sambo,” and “swamp guinea” in “Colored Spade.” However, unlike Sammy Davis, Jr’s
44
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
psychedelic finger snapping Daddy in Sweet Charity, Hud avoids being either totally exoticized by his race or idealized for his political voice. Rather, his fiancée and young son unexpectedly appear on the scene. To the horror of his hippie comrades, Hud attempts to use his counterculture clout and associated heightened state of being to rationalize the abandonment of his family. Ultimately, the fiancée forces her way into and becomes part of the group. Whereas this shows signs of the conciliatory happy resolution, it remains a complication of racial integration in the genre. Neither ignored, idealized, nor villainized, Hud’s shortcomings add to both the roundness of his character and the overall complication of the social issues this revised form of the genre seeks to interrogate. The film ends—following Berger’s death, killed after being shipped to Vietnam when mistaken for Claude during a prank—with the ensemble standing over Berger’s grave in Arlington National Cemetery. Neither altogether optimistic nor cynical, neither idealizing accomplishments of that specific cultural movement nor denigrating them, Hair concludes with both an ambivalent stance toward the cultural moment and its players and ambiguously with questions, rather than answers. Following social trends of the times, many of these later musical narratives use the tropes of the more classical incarnation of the genre to challenge their very legitimacy in a mid to late twentieth century context. While denaturalizing heterosexual coupling and domestic monogamy these films attack assumptions that had formed the base of arcadian musical norms, and allow the genre to reestablish a sense of social and artistic relevance by further complicating the very idea of a stable and knowable society.
We won’t just entertain you In addition to reflecting an overall sense of social discontent and latching on to popular trends in non-musical cinema of the time, movie musicals from this period also projected ambivalence to established norms by embracing the overall growing cynicism that had emerged over the past decades toward the entertainment industry and entertainers. From the earliest days of the musical, musical films had used entertainment settings as a means to legitimize the performance of song and dance. Although occasional non-integrated backstagers such as Ziegfeld Girl, Applause, and Glorifying the American Girl (1929) present the pitfalls or seedy side of the industry, musical narratives had often served as articulations of a “the show must go on” or “let’s do it for the team” mentality (The Band Wagon, Babes on Broadway, Footlight
Nothing Is Comin’ Up Roses
45
Parade [1933]). Pulling together against all odds, such performers tout the glories of music and live performance as Broadway, summer stock, and community theatre casts often prove more resilient than the postal system when it comes to seeing a project through to the end. Later musicals would eliminate this narrative means of communal bonding by more commonly placing entertainment and entertainers under the microscope and situating them as sources of corruption and overall luridness.21 The through-line of darkness that emerged with regard to the entertainment industries not only underscored the overall emergent ambivalence toward the possibility of reaching a diegetic utopian sensibility—as promised in earlier versions of the genre and highlighted by Dyer—but also reflected varying strains of discontent brewing within the television, film, and music industries. In the buildup to World War II skyrocketing income taxes for highly paid professionals had made it beneficial for major stars to forgo long-term contracts, incorporate themselves, and hire themselves out to studios on a picture-by-picture basis. In the decade following the war a string of events further weakened studios’ control over stars’ finely-tuned personae: Olivia DeHavilland’s successful legal case against Warner Bros. ruled that studios could not control actors for longer than the designated length of their contracts; the House Un-American Activities Committee’s communist accusations (1947/1951) helped to taint the glow of Hollywood stars; and structural changes associated with the Paramount Decision further damaged the studio-star relationship. By the late forties and early fifties, fewer and fewer stars were signing the kind of long-term contracts that had strongly controlled their public images and appearances and had included strict morality clauses. Compounding the legal, financial, and structural studio shakeups of the forties, Hollywood scandal rags such as Confidential, On the QT, and Whisper actively capitalized on the new unrestrained celebrity activity and what Mary Desjardins refers to as the “changing climate around obscenity, as well as the complexities of current libel and privacy laws.”22 Desjardins argues in her examination of the rise of and conflict over celebrity tabloids that, “Knowledge of the stars was regulated by Hollywood to create desire and maintain certain boundaries of sexuality—monogamous heterosexuality practiced by people of the same race.”23 This same notion of morality had rested at the base of the musical genre. No surprise that in the wake of the erosion of the original “dream factory” and its stable of stars that this darker faction of the musical genre would reflect the emergent less-than-wholesome or trustworthy image of the showman.
46
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
Simultaneous to Hollywood’s loosening grasp on the public images of its stars, both the television and music industries found themselves in the midst of major public relations crises. In 1959 the House Subcommittee on Legislative Oversight was holding highly publicized hearings about the television quiz show scandals. The honesty of the living room medium had come into question when investigations brought to light backstage dealings that had provided answers to and coached quiz show contestants in hopes of bulking up ratings. Just one year later, the radio industry came under similar scrutiny as the Payola investigations brought to light the fact that disc jockeys and music hosts such as Alan Freed and Dick Clark had been cultivating suspect relationships and economic arrangements with record companies for the promise to spin their artists’ records. By the seventies, decades of scandal and the lasciviousness and corruption associated with Studio 54’s drugged-up, sexed-up, and wholly selfabsorbed celebrities (Donna Summer, Liza Minnelli, and Andy Warhol, among others) ultimately appeared to taint show business in these later musicals. No longer do entertainers and the entertainment industry evoke the hopefulness, joy, and wholesomeness that pushed arcadian musicals to their celebratory conclusions. The healing once implicit in these popular narratives gave way to cynicism and tongue-in-cheek mockery. Eric Clapton’s over-the-top healing cult of Marilyn Monroe creates a rock-as-religion sideshow in Tommy. All That Jazz and The Boy Friend use infidelities, dream-orgies, drugs, and heartless businessmen to create a show business much too perverse and sinister for an understudy magically to become a star as in 42nd Street.24 In All That Jazz, the financial backers of Joe’s new Broadway show reveal themselves as slimy businessmen through their responses to his heart attack. While showing support to his face, they secretly joke that being able to cash in the show’s insurance policy in the event of Joe’s death would make his new musical the first Broadway show to make a profit without ever opening. This type of cold backstabbing deviates from the warmth and community often associated with the entertainment business in the more arcadian musicals and underscores the overall cynicism of the emergent form. Compounding the images of personal and corporate corruption forming within the various media industries, a spate of record label buyouts and mergers and the corporate excess of drug-driven labels like disco king Casablanca sullied any notion of innocence or authenticity associated with the music industries. Reflecting the cynicism of the time, Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band presents an irresolvable rift between
Nothing Is Comin’ Up Roses
47
big business and homespun music. Not only does the potential destructive nature of music come to the fore, but also the inherent evil of corporate entertainment rears its ugly head. In the style of 1970s rock and disco, Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band (The Bee Gees and Peter Frampton) sign with a major label and immediately suffer the moral and physical consequences. Under the influence of label bigwigs and their whores, the boys become drug addicts and sex fiends. Their hometown (Hometown U.S.A.) subsequently transforms into a den of iniquity while an evil doctor (Steve Martin), musicians (Aerosmith), and a mind-controller (Alice Cooper) attempt to use magical instruments to take over the world. Although all is ultimately recuperated through the magic of deus ex machina Billy Preston, his magic coronet, and an extra-diegetic star-studded rendition of the theme song, the narrative maintains the corruption of big business and its influence on wholesome rock-n-roll music.25 Accompanying the narrative trend toward questioning the intentions of entertainers and the entertainment industry, an associated trend emerges of framing narratives within performances that both reinforces this cynicism toward entertainers and reflects the self-reflective forms of New American Cinema and The French New Wave. This disruption of narrative flow draws attention to the filmic mechanism, demystifying any sense of enclosed diegetic space. The musical had always embraced such practices in the breaking of the fourth wall by singers or the integration of mini-musical narratives within the diegesis (Berkeley’s stage-bound extravaganzas, In the Navy’s [1941] military revue), but the films of this period push the breaking of narrative fluidity further by playing with the presence (or invisibility) of the diegetic audience. Altman and Feuer both point to such audiences as representing, previewing, and forming the opinions and responses of the real movie-going audience. By making that audience one with the diegetic audience, the arcadian forms of the musical foreground their intention to coerce the non-diegetic audience into accepting the utopian sensibility projected by the films’ narratives.26 To the contrary many films of this later period instead use the foregrounding of diegetic performance to underscore the spatial or ideological gulf that exists between the viewer, any possibility of social harmony, and those at the center of the films’ narratives. Beyond simply putting on a show for the diegetic (and non-diegetic) audience as many backstage musicals do, Godspell and Jesus Christ Superstar overtly sever the connection between the performers and movie-watching audience by placing the storytelling process within
48
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
some form of audience-less performance. The former includes skits of parables performed by the ensemble for the ensemble and the latter a full-blown theatrical performance—framed by the cast members constructing the stage and donning costumes—staged in the desert for no one. As Godspell begins, John the Baptist magically appears into the hectic lives of each member of the ensemble. Leaving his or her current life—student, waitress, parking lot attendant, cab driver, garment worker, dancer, model—each runs to Central Park’s Bethesda Fountain and musically washes away his or her sins. From that point on, the performers and audience members are one and the same, as no additional New Yorkers appear until the crucifixion of Christ brings uniformed police officers to drag him away. Not until the ensemble members joyously carry Christ over the Brooklyn Bridge do New Yorkers—at the beginning of the film an integral part of the ensemble members’ unfulfilling lives—reappear to repopulate the city. This type of audience-less performance destabilizes the role of the diegetic audience; their removal further distances the narrative from an overt reestablishment of the status quo by removing those who may preview the desired response of the theatrical audience. The very place of performance for performance’s sake comes into question as the communal power of song and dance falls on no ears in these already ideologically conflicted narratives.27 A Little Night Music and The Boy Friend similarly toy with the connotation of audience relationships as the reality of the diegetic performance gives way to varying degrees of narrative integration. Both films begin with the players putting on shows in the presence of theatrical audiences. Shy of using this technique to form a connection between the theatrical and movie-going audience, both films quickly dispose of their theatrical audiences, with A Little Night Music’s audience fading away as a narrative revolving around a series of infidelities takes the shape of a fully realized and no longer stage-bound film narrative. The Boy Friend uses a convention resembling a perverse exoticized version of the traditional dream ballet to erase the diegetic audience from the theatrebound narrative as the diegetic show’s numbers transform the actors into toga-wearing members of an orgy, dancing gnomes, and giant sexualized Rolls Royce hood ornaments. As the audience disappears during the dream sequences, they need not identify with nor support the sordid world depicted by the bizarre hallucinations. The constructed reality of stage performance and the role of the audience continually slip to the background as these films, indicative of entertainment-focused musicals of this time, foreground the depravity of entertainment and its residual effect on a character’s craft.
Nothing Is Comin’ Up Roses
49
The state of community and a utopian future The ambivalence discussed in this chapter directed toward previously activated generic norms and manifest in these later musical narratives, commonly results in the unsettling of the bedrock qualities of the Hollywood musical—a united community and a conclusion that implies the possibility of some form of utopia.28 Problematizing or sidestepping the concept of romance, the narrative outcomes of these later films commonly progress with more cynical or ambivalent notions regarding the possibility of a unified community and utopian society. With more complicated narratives that cast aspersions at the possibility of knowledgeable, sensitive, inclusive, and honest societies, simplistic conclusions become improbable. This lack of narrative assuredness instead produces shattered, dishonest, divisive, delusional, and invisible societies at large. I would never dare to claim that no musicals of this period maintain the same sense of communal harmony and utopian sensibility so often discussed and quite popular in earlier decades of the genre. Musicals of this period such as Half a Sixpence, Thoroughly Modern Millie, Doctor Dolittle, Hello, Dolly!, Grease 1 and 2 (1982), and The Pirate Movie present communities that ultimately overcome their differences—class or clique-based—to conclude with fully bonded groups that see the possibility of a utopic future. More important in the examination of the specificities of this period, however, is the large group of musicals produced that retain elements of social dissent at their narratives’ ends. Some films produce communities more decimated than others as their stories end, and such films maintain a contemptuous view toward earlier established notions of the genre and the worlds it commonly sought to replicate. The complexity and skepticism of these narratives at times provides a glimpse of or hope for some kind of utopian future, although a splintered society stands in the way of such a reality. Films such as Sweet Charity, Camelot, Paint Your Wagon, and Lost Horizon find narrative resolution in forever divided worlds. Although Charity’s and King Arthur’s stories end with a twinkle of hope, neither character exists in a society truly capable of making his or her dreams come true. Charity crumbles after being left at the altar by Oscar who is unable to accept her sordid past, and she finds herself unable to confront her friends with the reality of yet another failed love. Though depressed, she dons a smile while passing happy couples in the park. She remains glued to social conditioning regarding love and marriage in a society that shows no evidence of providing her with such an end. Similarly, the twinkle
50
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
in King Arthur’s eye seems hopeless as he hangs his resolve on the knowledge that his kingdom, now crushed under the weight of his wife’s and best friend’s infidelity and an impending war, will be remembered for what it once was. Such a conclusion presents no utopian end, only a delusional hope for others to idealize his failure. Cultural mores regarding proper sexual behavior for women and the impending revolution make these narrative options incongruous with the protagonists’ dreams. The hope for a utopian future exists, but in these worlds this optimism is fruitless, as a reality reflective of contemporary cultural rifts and an irresolvable narrative crush the dream. Mirroring Charity’s and Arthur’s seemingly fruitless dreams of contentedness, films like The Little Prince, On a Clear Day You Can See Forever, and Goodbye, Mr. Chips present half-hearted resolutions as their characters find some degree of happiness and contentedness through the loss of love or death of a loved one; the knowledge of past joys allows them to retain some form of solitary joy existing apart from communities that once threatened them. Some narratives embrace the emergent cynicism of the genre by projecting pessimism toward the future as they reject the possibility of a unified community or end inconclusively. Mirroring the hopelessness of Mike Nichols’ sadomasochistic couple in Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf or the less dramatic despondency of William Friedkin’s Boys in the Band (1970) or The French Connection (1971), many of these darker musicals create narrative societies unable to secure any form of future assuredness and end as they began, in media res. Both At Long Last Love and Xanadu embrace unclear romantic conclusions, still unsure whether or not the lovers will find happiness, while both 1776 and Man of la Mancha present supposed moments of hope that implicate layers of impending dissent and uncertainty. Just as the signing of The Declaration of Independence occurs with lingering conflicts regarding slavery and regional interests hanging in the balance, Man of la Mancha fades as Cervantes marches out of the prison—in which he has won over his fellow inmates with his stories of Don Quixote—to an uncertain fate at the hands of the Inquisition. These narratives project the larger sense of social unrest indicative of the 1960s and 1970s and reject full victories to present small successes that are quickly subsumed by the ever-looming worries of imperfect worlds. Bereft of the conciliatory romance and resistant to the cleanly blended communities that result in new, more giving and accepting societies, the hope for a utopian future often fades before the credits roll. A final group of films transcends any sense of ambivalence toward earlier dictates of the musical genre and ends conclusively with
Nothing Is Comin’ Up Roses
51
unsalvageable and devastated communities. The Rocky Horror Picture Show’s final—although often omitted—number “Super Heroes” leaves the remaining living characters crawling through the rubble of the decimated castle, while Hair’s surviving hippies, Sheila, and Claude sing “Let the Sunshine In” at Berger’s grave as the camera pans out to a presentday peace rally in Washington, D.C. Even within Hair’s glimmer of hope projected through the peace rally, the film makes it obvious that society has not overcome its propensity toward violence; the counterculture has not won. The decline of the concluding production number during this period only reinforces this narrative reticence toward communal harmony. Often associated with the concluding celebration, a large production number with excessive displays of performance and merrymaking traditionally brought communities together—both those within the diegesis and by proxy those sitting in the theatre—in one big final shebang.29 A reprise such as The Music Man’s “Seventy-Six Trombones” or Mary Poppins’ “Let’s Go Fly a Kite” united the ensembles in celebrations of their new unified communities. This tradition fades—whether because of creative design or shifts in performance style or performer type as discussed in Chapter 3—reinforcing the lingering skepticism of the ambivalent musical, as many narratives end with splintered nonmusical groups, rather than bonded performing ones.30 Even though Jesus Christ Superstar’s final number “Superstar” bears the signs of an all out production number with glitzy costumes, a big dance number, and the entire ensemble, the actual film ends as the youths pack up the trappings of their play and ride off in their bus. This type of relegation of the production number to the position of second to last refocuses the narrative on its ambivalent or unsettled positions taken toward religion, the story, and cultural divisions that remained outside the diegesis. Many of the more ambivalently fashioned films avoid this grand gesture of communal unity altogether, to foreground the destabilization of community with concluding moments implicating the isolation indicative of their protagonists’ solo or introspective journeys. Without connections outside of the school, Goodbye, Mr. Chips’ protagonist retires only to live on the campus, blending generations upon generations of boys, confusing grandson for grandfather. In the end he takes a solitary walk down the town road to an underscoring of “Fill the World with Love.” Lost Horizon’s Richard treks through the Himalayas without regard for his own safety, only focusing on his return to Shangri-La. As he discovers the signpost marking the entrance to Shangri-La, the maudlin Burt Bacharach theme song “Lost Horizon” plays in voiceover. Only Arthur sings the final reprise of “Camelot,” the rest of his followers musically
52
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
absent as they prepare for war as he hangs on to his dream of his once successful kingdom. The inability of these narratives to unite the entire group comes through in the final moments of a protagonist’s narrative, musical, and performative isolation.
Case study: The narrative of Zoot Suit The decided shift in favored narrative tone, focus, and style during this period and its relationship to—or deviation from—the kinder and gentler musical can be seen throughout a film such as the R-rated Zoot Suit. Even the very rating of the film points to its edgier nature. (What would have to occur for Rodgers and Hammerstein to garner an R rating?) Luis Valdez’s violent Chicano-themed film pulls no punches and foregoes the mono-racial infighting of Cabin in the Sky or Flower Drum Song (and their corresponding conciliatory endings) to construct a narrative of personal struggle, social inequity, and ambivalent conclusions. Based on Valdez’s play of the same name, the film chronicles a fictionalized version of the Los Angeles Zoot Suit Riots and Sleepy Lagoon murders and the ensuing imprisonment and trial of Henry Leyvas (here Henry Reyna) and his “gang.” The incident on which the film was based occurred in Los Angeles in 1942. As World War II raged, a separate war was raging on the barrio streets of L.A. Police officers and military men were cracking down on so-called zoot suiters, mostly young Mexican men who identified as Chicano, used pachuco slang, and—during a time of rationing—wore “drapes” or cuffed pants and long jackets.31 Often engaging more with their own culture and African American music, these young men and women eschewed the dictates of the white culture that failed to allow them to thrive for one more favorable to their situation. In 1942, amid a conflict between different groups of Mexican youths, a misunderstanding occurred when Leyvas’s friends headed into a party to retaliate for a beating Leyvas and his girlfriend had taken at the hands of the local Downy gang. By the evening’s end, one man was dead. Within a week, the Los Angeles police had rounded up over 600—mostly Mexican and African American—youths on suspicion of murder. In the end Leyvas and 22 of his friends would stand trial for the murder of José Díaz. Leyvas’s true story includes acts of police abuse, a corrupt and biased judicial system, and a popular press that thrived on sensationalizing the story to the detriment of a fair trial. On January 12, 1943, 17 of the men would be found guilty of various charges and Leyvas and two others guilty of murder and sentenced to life in prison at San Quentin. While
Nothing Is Comin’ Up Roses
53
Leyvas was in prison, violence between servicemen and zoot suiters escalated. On October 2, 1944 the Leyvas case was dismissed on appeal and the men were set free. Leyvas would soon find himself in other sorts of legal trouble, spending an additional decade in prison before he settled down to operate a restaurant and counsel members of the local Chicano youth moment. Neither an encouraging nor wholly cautionary tale, the very premise of Zoot Suit and its connection to a real conflicted moment in American history runs contrary to the generic formula identified by scholars such as Schatz and Altman.32 From beginning to end, Zoot Suit defies the status quo affirming narratives of arcadian musicals and foregrounds the characters’ otherness, their resistance to being consumed into Anglo culture, and the injustice present in the filmic—and real historical—communities. Combining sung and spoken English with pachuco slang from the first musical number, the film sets Reyna and his community apart from dominant white culture. The continued use of unsubtitled Spanish and pachuco slang foregrounds the gulf between the film’s protagonists and the Hollywood machine through which it was released (distributed by Universal Pictures). Both through the language the film uses and the narrative it presents, a world emerges that defies the utopia of many early musicals for a world of conflict, resistance, and questions (rather than answers). The story’s form, focus, and content ally it with the emerging popular style defined here as the ambivalent musical. Replete with contradictions, ambiguities, and social and personal revolt, the film’s narrative emphasizes the impossibility of clean resolutions and bonded communities. This fluid sense of reality emerges immediately both through the film’s pretense of presenting the story as a performance within a performance—as the story of Henry Reyna takes place on an actual stage in front of an actual audience—and the immediate introduction the mythical narrator/Henry’s alter ego, “El Pachuco” (Edward James Olmos) (Figure 1). He emerges posturing across the stage in his jet black zoot suit and blood red shirt and ultimately halts the opening swing dance number through a snap of his fingers and a flick of his switchblade. Addressing the audience he states: Ladies and Gentlemen, the mono you’re about to see is a construct of fact and fantasy. But relax, weigh the facts and enjoy the pretense. Our pachuco realities will only make sense if you grasp their stylization. It was a secret fantasy of every vato living in or out of the pachucada to put on the zoot suit and play with the myth. Más chucote que la chingada. ¡Pues, órale!.
54
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
Figure 1 The Zoot Suit ensemble poses on stage in the final moments of the film as they highlight the overt theatricality of the narrative. (Universal Pictures/Photofest)
With this aside, the film opens by addressing the audience, alerting them to the pretense and fantasy of the performance, and asking that they play along. Unlike Feuer’s discussion of the diegetic audience, El Pachuco’s audience is not asked to become one with the viewed community, but to recognize its subjectivity and “weigh the facts.” Rather than encouraging an acceptance of the world of the performance, the diegetic audience—as well as the viewing audience—is visually and aurally encouraged to take a Brechtian viewing position of distanciation.33 They must distance themselves from the action, consider what they see, and (possibly even) take action—as the film will conclude with possibilities and questions that encourage further contemplation. Characteristics other than those guiding aural presentation of the film tie Zoot Suit more closely to the ambivalent dictates of the musical than the arcadian. Like musicals such as Jesus Christ Superstar, The Little Prince, and 1776, the film centers not on the romantic quest of its dual protagonists or the unification of battling factions of a community. Instead, the personal and social struggles of the male protagonist Reyna—and by proxy Leyvas—take center stage. Although the Sleepy Lagoon murder occurs in response to the attack on Henry and his sweet girlfriend Della, the relationship with Della does not guide Henry’s choices or the
Nothing Is Comin’ Up Roses
55
story itself. Romance takes a decided back seat to the social, judicial, and personal conflicts Henry encounters. Even though the story injects a character reminiscent of the lover’s rival—in this case Jewish advocate Alice Bloomfield for whom Henry falls—this love triangle goes nowhere, as Della never gains knowledge of the burgeoning relationship and Alice places her advocacy for Henry and others above an idealistic notion of romance. His relationship with the Chicana Della—who goes to a delinquent school for girls for defending him—does not triumph over all and bring Henry over to the clean-cut American way of life; neither does a burgeoning romance with Alice prove that there is no black, brown, and white or Chicano, Anglo, or Jewish. In the end, Henry’s romantic fate remains unclear, not even important enough to garner a solid conclusion. With the romance firmly sidelined, the narrative of Zoot Suit instead mirrors one more akin to the male melodrama. Although not focusing on the religious quests of Tommy, Godspell, or Jesus Christ Superstar or the career ventures of Camelot, How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying, or 1776, Zoot Suit centers soundly on the struggles of Henry Reyna to maintain his sense of self-respect and culture in a society that seeks to rob him of both. This personal journey takes hold of the narrative from beginning to end. Instead of attempting to unite a community or cool the fire inside a hot-blooded lover, the film focuses mainly on the struggle of Reyna and the mythic presence of El Pachuco. Otherworldly characters are not uncommon to musicals (Carousel’s Billy Bigelow, Damn Yankees’ Mr Applegate, and Cabin in the Sky’s General and Lucifer Jr), but El Pachuco possesses more substance than these characters. He directs the audience, controls all musical numbers, and forces Henry to consider the ramifications of the actions of whites upon his social and personal standing. El Pachuco’s participation more fully develops the male melodrama, aiding in articulating the rationale for choices made by the film’s protagonist and exploring the emotional world that guides those choices. Through the interactions between El Pachuco and Henry, the narrative focus results in a much more well developed protagonist than common to most musicals—as the predetermined conciliatory narrative closure associated with the arcadian requires little actual character development from anyone. Such protagonists’ emotional lives seldom go beyond basic characteristics such as “loyal,” “macho,” or “regretful.” Fred Astaire’s characters in Top Hat (1935) and Swing Time appear to want little more than to dance and win the girl. His social position, long-term goals, family allegiance, and cultural status matter very little. In Zoot
56
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
Suit, however, Henry struggles though each of these issues throughout. He struggles to do right by his family. He negotiates the position of Latin lover and respectful boyfriend as he resists Della’s advances the night of the murder. He struggles to assimilate into a society that rejects his culture, as the film begins with his final hurrah before he leaves for the Navy. He defends this decision to serve as El Pachuco mocks “muy Popeye the sailor man, huh?” and states “Muy patriotic, huh? The Japs have sewed up the Pacific. Rommel’s kicking ass in Egypt, but the Mayor of L.A. has declared an all-out war on Chicanos. On You. ¿Te curas?” Shortly after this, the film shifts back to the roundup of young Chicanos and Henry’s assault by the police during interrogation. Throughout, the film shifts between Henry’s interrogation of his own situation and the oppression of Henry and his friends by a corrupt system. Ultimately, Henry’s goal is not to achieve any kind of personal or professional relationship, but to maintain his sense of self and dignity at the hands of a system and society who disdain him. The types of personal battles that Henry must fight further highlight the narrative and ideological shift occurring in the musical during this period. Unlike many non-white or somewhat racially integrated musicals of earlier years (Way Down South, Hallelujah, Cabin in the Sky, Flower Drum Song), Zoot Suit does not either center on a resolvable conflict within one cultural community (church going vs. gambler or old world vs. assimilated American) or result in the ultimate assimilation into or acceptance of a white status quo (for example, good slave owners are fine folk in Way Down South). Rather, the film depicts Reyna as a victim of a corrupt and racist white system. When at the mercy of the correctional and judicial systems, Henry withstands physical abuse and coercion, a sensationalist press that works to rig the trial, and a judge and prosecutor whose ethnic biases sit on the surface of their decisions (to force the defendants to wear the same clothes they had been wearing for two months, to forgo haircuts, to rise in the courtroom each time their names are called by a witness). Despite Henry’s release upon appeal, social prejudice does not melt away as a product of a few aberrant officials. In addition to preventing assimilation back into dominant society through the exposure of a corrupt system, the story further foregrounds itself as separate from white society by emanating from within the Chicano community and engaging with its language, customs, and concern for cultural appearance both inside and outside of the community. Throughout, the use of pachuco slang prevents a complete immersion into the narrative by those who cannot understand the language and
Nothing Is Comin’ Up Roses
57
dialect. Although anyone can understand the surface story, viewers unfamiliar with pachuco slang cannot fully grasp the complexity of Henry’s thoughts and desires. Almost all of the music, including the matching opening and concluding production numbers performed to the song “Pachuco Suave,” are almost wholly in Spanish. El Pachuco constantly speaks with Henry (who is the only character capable of seeing or hearing him), shifting between Spanish and English and continually challenging the decisions—both helpful and hurtful—made by white lawyers, legal aides, and judges. He recurrently situates Chicanos as Other, not to marginalize or exoticize them but to stress their specificity and history. The inclusion of the white Tommy Roberts as one of the four young men imprisoned for the murder creates almost a reversal of the idealism once seemingly so inherent to the musical genre. Rather than allowing a non-white to enjoy the success and perks of white society, the treatment of Tommy highlights the system’s blatant rejection of anything associated with the Chicano culture. While talking to Alice Tommy says, “Listen Alice, I know what you’re trying to do for us, and that’s reet, see? Shit. Most Paddies would probably like to see us locked up for good. Now I’m in here because I hung around with Mexicans, but I grew up with these vatos. And I’m pachuco too, see. Simón, esa.” In an arcadian narrative, this moment of candor with a sympathetic secondary character would likely lead to a grand reconciliation or epiphany. The inequality of the situation would possibly come to light or at least be recognized by the greater group. In the case of Zoot Suit, Tommy and the boys win their appeal, but no social change appears on the horizon. Finally, to contradict the very core of the traditional conciliatory ending of many musicals, Zoot Suit rejects the possibility of a clean resolution. In its presentation of a society and life rife with conflict and ambiguities, the film foregoes the clear-cut ending for one open to individual interpretation. The audience must “weigh the facts.” As the men gain their release from prison and Henry reappropriates his zoot suit, he says to El Pachuco “we won, didn’t we?” His alter ego says, “And that’s a perfect way to end this play. Happy ending y todo. Ah, but life ain’t like that, Hank.” As he snaps his fingers, the newspaper man who has ill-represented Henry throughout the film says, “Henry Reyna went back to prison in 1947 for robbery and assault with a deadly weapon. While incarcerated he killed another inmate and wasn’t released until 1955, when he got into hard drugs. He died of the trauma of his life in 1972.” El Pachuco sneers at the reporter and says, “That’s the way you see it, ese, but there’s other ways to end this story.” He snaps his fingers again—as
58
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
continuous controller of the film’s reality—and the company dances to “Pachuco Suave” as characters present alternate possibilities for Henry’s future. As they dance and Henry puts a ring on Della’s finger, an aged version of Henry’s brother states, “Henry Reyna went to Korea in 1950. He was shipped there on a destroyer and defended the 38th parallel, but he was killed at Inchon in 1952, being posthumously awarded the Congressional Medal of Honor.” Immediately Alice says, “Henry Reyna married Della Barrios in 1948. They still live in Los Angeles. They have five kids, three of whom are attending university, speaking pachuco slang, and calling themselves Chicanos.” El Pachuco continues singing and the company continues dancing as characters extol final thoughts on Henry: Attorney: Henry Reyna, the born leader. Judge: Henry Reyna, the zoot-suiter. Tommy: Henry Reyna, my friend. Sister: Henry Reyna, my brother Parents: Henry Reyna, our son. Della: Henry Reyna, my love. El Pachuco: Henry Reyna, El Pachuco. The man, the myth still lives. This inconclusive ending challenges dominant stereotypes of the Latino convict, yet simultaneously resists a full recuperation into dominant Anglo society. Despite the dark reality of Leyvas’s post-appeal life, the film creates both positive and negative possibilities and challenges the assuredness of a musical conclusion and the pessimism of a social problem film.
Conclusion Films that, like Zoot Suit, confound the narrative traditions common to the more idyllic form of the musical, abound in the 1966–1983 period. Through their narrative foci, ideological complexity, and character development, many musicals of the sixties, seventies, and eighties deviate from the early arcadian form. By embracing the trends emergent in more cutting-edge American and European films of the time, they subvert the very stability of the romance plotline and recuperable society. The conflicted or contradictory stance these film musicals take toward once entrenched norms regarding romance and community challenges the genre’s ability to produce a sense of inevitability with regard to finding suitable solutions to the conflicts that hamper society.
Nothing Is Comin’ Up Roses
59
By challenging the naturalness of monogamous romance, subverting romance as a customary and supreme path, and additionally questioning the stability and overall goodness of music and show business, the complications resting on the surface of contemporary society become foregrounded as the possibility for some form of vicarious musical social utopia fades to the background. Concurrent with the narrative refocus on questions and a lack of answers, these films—through this ambivalence and pessimism toward the genre and societal norms—allow the musical to reassume its place of social relevance (even if failing to find the economic viability of its earlier years). Embracing the darker artistic and social norms of the time, the genre produces a voice indicative of contemporary mores and no longer so anachronistic in its projection of a lost idealism. As these films broaden the acceptable and expected narratives for the musical genre, social and personal problems emerge in more complex ways. In allowing for unanswered questions, wider expressions of individuality, and social conflict, the films’ narratives may not neatly resolve the social issues they interrogate, but they certainly provide for the possibility of more complex answers—or lack thereof—than many musical storylines of the past.
2 On a Clear Day You Can See the Cracks in the Scenery: Visual Reflexivity and Realism Trump Nostalgic Idealism
Narrative elements of the musical, once so fully linked to the harmonious union of heterosexual couples, took a darker turn ideologically reflective of social conflict of the sixties and seventies and artistically reminiscent of shifts occurring both within the entertainment industries and motion picture style itself. The mixture of narrative darkness, egocentrism, and ambiguity prevalent in these integrated movie musical products of the late sixties to early eighties projects a generic ambivalence toward earlier established norms, and rather embraces the uncertainty prevalent in both the political and artistic moment. Compounding this narrative ambivalence that projects the genre as neither idealistic nor wholly nihilistic, a new sense of visual complexity emerged that embraced psychological subjectivity, community separation, and generic self-reflectivity. As with narrative shifts that destroyed the hazy idealism once so indicative of the musical, technical stylization closely reflects the innovations of the French New Wave and New American Cinema, as well as American and European avant-garde movements and these movements’ seeming opposite, Italian neo-realism. Techniques such as short shot length, jump cuts, freeze frame, and image superimposition help to replicate character subjectivity as these narratives turn in on themselves and often focus on the conflicted emotions and personal journeys of their protagonists. Along with such editing and cinematographic techniques, realistic, stylized, and theatrical styles of mise-en-scène emerge to project worlds that confront the intricacies of human experience. Rejecting the broad strokes Rick Altman cites as denoting less complicated times or more ambiguously exotic places, these new musicals commonly lack the idealistic images of 1950s soda 60
On a Clear Day You Can See the Cracks in the Scenery 61
shops, turn of the century Paris, or “ye olde timey” England. Instead of a golly, gosh, aw shucks conception of reality that legitimizes even the most absurd narrative turns, many of these new musicals instead turn to dark stylization, overt theatricality, or stark realism to reject the visual safety of a watercolor nostalgia. The musical had often supported its overarching arcadian project by creating a perfect and simplified visual world, one that would account for the idealism of the characters and Richard Dyer would argue projected a utopian sensibility.1 To underscore their more complex and nuanced narratives, many musicals of this later period present more realistic visual representations of their topics than once common. Rick Altman argues the arcadian practice of using exoticized or nostalgized locales establishes a distance between reality and narrative by creating a mysterious other world or world known but rearranged to a point of nostalgia and safety.2 For example, the contrived color schemes of Guys and Dolls and Seven Brides for Seven Brothers aid in rendering less threatening supposedly seedy or rough surroundings. The gangsters of New York take on a goofy and hapless feel as they cavort in their vibrantly colored urban wonderland. Similarly, the rough backwoodsmen of Seven Brides don ice cream-colored outfits as they capture the hearts of their abducted sweeties. Dyer discusses this magical synthesis as a byproduct of the utopian sensibility created through the mixture of representational (plot, characters, stars, mise-en-scène) and nonrepresentational (color, texture, movement, rhythm, camerawork) signs. Within any given cinematic text, the two may encounter some form of dissonance, rendering the film simultaneously utopic and ideologically unsatisfactory.3 Whereas Seven Brides includes narrative violence and overt manipulation on the parts of the characters, the mise-enscène evokes a dreamlike version of the American frontier, costumes reject rough-hewn colors and textures for more colorfully pleasing ones, and even moments of narrative violence, sadness, or manipulation occur as rhythms, camerawork, and choreography evoke life, energy, and unity. Such a contradiction allows for the film to remain “entertaining” while possessing a less than problem-free plot as the utopic nonrepresentational and representational elements compensate for the problematic ones. However, as more plots fail to resolve themselves utopically, simultaneously non-representational and representational elements associated with visuals—as well as the harsher rock-driven musical beats of many new musicals—fail to evoke the utopian sensibility necessary to overcome the pessimism and ambiguity established narratively and an ultimate lack of “entertainment” takes over.
62
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
Camerawork and editing: I can see right through you The visual style most commonly associated with classical Hollywood cinema, one that seamlessly unfolds the intended version of the story, commonly emerges through highly communicative yet selfeffacing visual technique. David Bordwell describes this as, “the invisible observer,” stating “The invisible observer narration is itself fairly effaced . . . we can already see that classical narration quickly cues us to construct story logic (causality, parallelism), time, and space in ways that make the events before the camera our principal source of information.”4 He goes on further to note that “momentary disorientation is permissible only if motivated realistically.”5 Such narrative and visual techniques, as Bordwell discusses, work to present a hermeneutically sealed and clear-cut objective story that works toward ultimate narrative closure. The musical has historically worked against such goals. Since the visual innovation of Busby Berkeley in the 1930s and 1940s, musicals have eschewed classical style and taken on varying levels of visual theatricality or excess, particularly in their musical numbers. Berkeley’s techniques often focus on individual body parts or the overall screen picture created by the movements of the group, as in the crotch and leg shots in 42nd Street’s “Young and Healthy.” Such camerawork disassociates the image with burgeoning unions or physical performance of dance, and instead transforms bodies into visually pleasing or shocking shapes. In addition to these visual spectacles, the arcadian musical often engages in the use of visual techniques that eschew traditional invisible narrative and editing style either through the breaking of the fourth wall or in the ubiquitous dream ballet. These practices draw attention away from the narrative’s nostalgic reality to the more overt fantasy of the dream. Within these later and more generically ambivalent musicals, however, overt visual choices that defy realistic motivation often exist outside flights of dreamlike fancy, drawing more attention to those choices as they transcend generic norms and expectations. In addition to foregrounding deliberate techniques, these choices complement narrative practices popularized in this phase of the genre. Visual disassociation amplifies emergent generic destabilization and underscores the musical’s associations with the art cinema as directors, editors, and cinematographers take advantage of techniques such as the zoom, jump cut, extreme close-up (ECU), and the insertion of still photographic images to aid in connecting the visual representations of characters to the often dark emotional experiences that accompany them. Bordwell and Janet Staiger describe this subjective construction
On a Clear Day You Can See the Cracks in the Scenery 63
of the visual as associated with the popularization of directionless protagonists—much like those peopling this new phase of the musical genre. A conception of realism also affects the film’s spatial and temporal construction, but the art cinema’s realism here encompasses a spectrum of possibilities. The options range from a documentary factuality (e.g. Il posto) to intense psychological subjectivity (Hiroshima mon amour) . . . . Violations of classical conceptions of time and space are justified as the intrusion of an unpredictable and contingent daily reality or as the subjective reality of complex characters.6 As Mike Nichols, Robert Altman, and Martin Scorsese were using creative cinematography and editing in The Graduate, McCabe and Mrs. Miller, and Mean Streets (1973) to compound their critiques of genre, complacency, and deviance and visually depict their protagonists’ states of obsession, boredom, and chaos, the musical integrated such visual stylings to underscore its increased psychological depth. In both musical and non-musical vehicles, elements such as quick cutting and point of view shooting assist in capturing the immediacy of a moment, visually depicting the heightening of the character’s stakes, or pulling away from the fluid narrative and interrogating internal conflict. Reflecting the musicals’ increased rejection of previous generic norms and its emergent questioning of the primacy of heterosexual union, such heavy-handed cinematographic choices highlight the individual and his or her inner turmoil. Films such as Man of la Mancha and All That Jazz, both sidelining the romance for a focus on the internal struggles of less-than-perfect men, exemplify this shift as they integrate cinematography indicative of non-musical cinematic movements to highlight the characters’ estrangement from community and overwhelmingly solipsistic existences. Like many heroes—or antiheroes—in these newer musicals, they reject social norms and become enslaved by their own skewed personal visions. Man of la Mancha’s Alonso Quijana (alter ego to Don Quixote and hero of the jailed Cervantes’ tale) emerges as a mere shell of a man. Weakened by age and delusions of grandeur, he attempts to maintain his façade of a knight errant. Director Arthur Hiller implements highly subjective filming techniques like POV shooting when Quijana is trapped on the giant/windmill or short shots and quick movements to portray the doddering man’s disorientation when faced by the Knight of Mirrors and his own dilapidated visage. Rather than focusing on the generically traditional folly of the hero, such visuals
64
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
underscore the hero’s weakness and detachment from social norms in a uniquely cinematic way. In a similar fashion, All that Jazz uses visual and aural gimmicks to pull the focus to Joe’s physical and emotional weaknesses, such as Fosse’s technique of dropping diegetic sound from the track when Joe suffers his heart attack during a rehearsal. As the camera cuts from cast member to cast member as he or she laughs hysterically—unaware of Joe’s condition—the sound and visuals undermine the traditional norms of the genre and highlight the fragility of human life, the hero’s isolation from others, and the impotence of the show business community.7 Such generic innovation in visual technique simultaneously highlights the new sense of pessimism and isolationism within the genre and at times places a contemporary stamp on a once-considered throwback form by embracing not only the emotional subjectivity of contemporary filmmaking, but also the psychological projection of contemporary drug culture. Whether through low-budget films like The Trip (1967), New American Cinema hallmark Easy Rider’s psychologically sadomasochistic New Orleans scenes, Woodstock’s purple haze, or Laugh-In’s (1967) psychedelic televised groove, the burgeoning drug culture of the late 1960s was leaving its stamp across genres and media. The same drive to escape or subvert traditional norms repeatedly appears throughout the musicals of this period by both visual/psychological and narrative means (Hair, A Funny Thing Happened on Way to the Forum [1966], Sweet Charity, All That Jazz, The Boy Friend, Zoot Suit).8 Forum fun-lovingly replicates the sexualized psychodelia of Laugh-In during a visit to the neighboring Grecian whorehouse. The camera zooms in and out and shakes about, visually recreating the men’s unrestrained sexual stimulation as exoticized, half-naked whores dance.9 All That Jazz uses the psychological projection of drug addiction to underscore the hedonistic and self-involved tendencies of these new musical antiheroes by projecting a related visual and aural frenzy and personal isolation. Far from the frivolity of Forum, Joe Gideon’s out-of-control lifestyle and declining health connect directly to his drug use and his inability to cope or connect in the real world. He repeatedly returns to his bathroom where a series of ECUs show him imbibing his morning cocktail of classical music, eye drops, Dexedrine, antacid, a shower, and a cigarette. The close proximity of the shot to the drugs, his hands, and his bloodshot eyes creates a heightened sense of chaos (only momentarily stifled by his routine stimulant ingestion). The focus on the ceremony emphasizes the chaos of his out-of-control life and the self-destructive means used to maintain it. Whether used fun lovingly or to denote the self-destructive
On a Clear Day You Can See the Cracks in the Scenery 65
or escapist natures of problematic self-absorbed protagonists, this infusion of drug culture into the genre, both allows for further focus on individual needs, desires, and sensations, and inextricably links the films to the contemporary moment, one incompatible with the once-unified musical community and instead rife with irresolvable cultural conflict and generational rift. Camerawork and musical performance In addition to integrating in vogue camera and sound techniques to highlight the genre’s new focus on individualism and communal estrangement, the ambivalence of the genre toward more arcadian technique emerges during this period through filming styles accompanying the performance of song and dance. The physical performance of song and dance once stood as the cornerstone of the genre and its clearest projection of communal and romantic harmony. At times creating an almost theatrical feel to the dance, camerawork in the more arcadian musicals often captured the couple or community as a whole singing and dancing their ways into a peaceful resolution. The camera follows Fred and Ginger around the dance floor to capture their bodies moving as one toward a suitable narrative conclusion. Jane Feuer points to the use of bricolage, non-choreography—dance based on more natural movement—and folk dance as minimizing the artifice of musical performances and drawing the viewing audience into the recognizable world of the film rather than the mythic world of professional performers.10 Similarly, Gene Kelly’s acrobatic dances, whether he is joined by Jerry the mouse (Anchors Aweigh) or Vera-Ellen (On the Town), command the screen as the camera follows him across the dance floor, the docks, or the Museum of Natural History. Leo Braudy refers to Kelly’s everyman dances as the great unifier, [Dance] tries to subvert reality through its new energy, an energy available to everyone in the audience through Kelly’s insistence on the nonprofessional character, the musical self that wells from inside instead of being imposed from without, whether by training, tradition, or society.11 By placing the dance front and center, this energy and the physical closeness of the hero or heroine and his or her community take narrative focus. This same attention to spontaneous integrated performance— projecting a lack of realism and a happy-go-lucky air—was also at the heart of a common critique of the illogical and hopelessly out-of-touch
66
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
nature of the genre as it entered the tumultuous sixties. Whether a product of this stage of the genre’s more critical take on old generic expectations, a response to popular technique, or a result of the decline in viable singing and dancing stars (in the wake of the studio system’s dissolution), many of the more ambivalent musicals of this period use self-conscious narration—through cinematography, editing, and special effects—to sever their musical numbers from the actual performing bodies and voices of their performers. Musical numbers of this period often create a sense of estrangement between performer and performance and instead focus on the subjective emotions of the characters. This allows for the films to develop more complexity of character while not wholly abandoning the music of the musical and simultaneously diminishing the connotative fluff associated with bodily performance. A common technique used during this period to integrate music while detracting from nostalgized musical performance is the integration of Hollywood montage (Tommy, Godspell, Forum, Camelot, and The Pirate Movie).12 Although not absent from earlier musicals, as dance—and capable star dancers—became less prominent in these later vehicles, such montage sequences commonly masked musical performance, created a space to project cynicism about the ideological project of musical integration, and/or shifted focus back to plot development or personal emotion. In all cases, the unification of community discussed by Feuer and the transfer of energy discussed by Braudy give way to the more critical or contemplative functions of music. Forum and The Pirate Movie, for example, use the montage sequence to draw attention to the conventions of Hollywood films and arcadian musical norms specifically. Their primary love songs, “You’re Lovely” and “How Can I Live Without Her” respectively, use the montage sequence in lieu of actual dance. In both cases, the lovers can be heard in voiceover as the films abandon any adherence to natural time and instead snippets of their romances appear on the screen. In both cases the lovers enact trite rituals of courtship—running hand in hand, kissing, and attempting to impress a lover with feats of physical strength. Although the style deviates from arcadian technique, the visuals mirror the focus on romance; however, in both cases the romantic gestures are undermined. Forum provides a reprise where two men parodically sing the same number and enact the same rituals. The Pirate Movie invokes a similar cynicism as the montage sequence encompassing its main love duet shows the central couple— Freddie and Mabel—performing similar courtship rituals as those in Forum, but through a different lens of absurdity (for example, singing part of the duet as Freddie responds to Mabel’s disembodied singing
On a Clear Day You Can See the Cracks in the Scenery 67
face in a basin of water or dining on the shore as a waiter in tux and tails emerges from the sea to serve them and immediately re-submerges himself after doing so). Both sequences and their series of self-conscious scenes highlight the insincerity of the moment and the musical’s emergent less-than-reverent views toward romance. In such evocations of romance, narration stands at a distance from the actions portrayed, and the visual device of the montage provides a space—outside of traditional integration of song and dance—to cynically comment on preexisting generic codes and the overall fantasy—rather than utopia—of the diegetic moment. The same montage technique is also used to a less humorous effect during this stage of the genre as it embraces the form more like films of the New American Cinema. As Simon and Garfunkel’s “Sounds of Silence” and “April She Will” underscore the action in The Graduate’s summertime montage, Nichols uses an extended montage sequence to quickly and somberly develop his hero’s psychological decline and the rise and fall of his cross-generational adulterous affair. The musical had traditionally relied on the united performance of the romantic couple or what Altman identifies as a process of dual matching performances to illustrate a couple’s burgeoning relationship. Camelot—including even less dance than its dance-light stage version—uses the montage sequence in “If Ever I Would Leave You” to show the development of Lancelot and Guenevere’s affair.13 Although the film shows little of their actual affair, this montage sequence deepens the narrative development of their relationship while simultaneously visually de-emphasizing Lancelot’s performance of the song or the couple’s united performance of romance. Here the energy of performance fails to emerge to accompany the ultimate betrayal of the genre’s core: monogamous romance or marriage. Aside from the montage, other techniques replace the visual focus on bodily performance of song and dance and turn toward a focus on internal struggle. Static camerawork still centers the body, as was the case in dance-heavy musicals, but many films of this later period omit dance in favor of minimalist editing and still camerawork that refocuses attention on the face and emotion. Camelot repeatedly uses a shift between static close-up and medium shot. In both Arthur’s and Guenevere’s opening numbers the camera remains almost, if not entirely, on the character singing. It does not pan to an ensemble surrounding him or her. It does not track out to capture the movement of the character or his or her bodily performance of the number; rather, the focus remains largely on the face of the singer. Instead of the welcoming kingdom present in
68
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
all of their dancing communal glory, visual focus remains on the static king and queen-to-be and their concerns for their impending marriages sight unseen. By focusing on a still and solitary performer, the number visually draws attention to internal struggles: excitement, panic, nervousness. Although the breaking of the fourth wall also occurs in arcadian musicals as with Maurice Chevalier’s performance of “Thank Heaven for Little Girls” in Gigi (1958), films such as Camelot eschew the humorous wink attached to such numbers. Instead, these moments draw attention to emotional stakes of isolated, complex characters. This task of drawing the viewer into the psyche of the performer and away from the physical performance of song and dance further emerges through the use of voiceover—to be discussed in more detail in the next chapter—and through heavy-handed visuals. Like the foregrounding of psychological subjectivity outside moments of song and dance, films use these techniques to highlight the complexity of character development and the incompatibility of the narratives with the clean choices and conclusions common to the arcadian norms popularized in earlier films. Rather than a celebratory number announcing the marriage of young lovers, Fiddler on the Roof uses superimposition, deep space, and subjective sound to visually replicate internal monologue. To imply a stoppage of the narrative action and an engagement with the protagonist Tevye’s personal struggle, Norman Jewison pulls him away from the ongoing action. Although actually narratively quite close to those with whom he talks, the camera shows the others far in the distance as Tevye looks directly into the camera. He drifts into soliloquy and ultimately Perchik and Hodel appear in long shot and in focus as Tevye remains in medium close-up to create a deep space/deep focus configuration. The camera visually distances the real world as Tevye goes inside himself to consider the quandary placed before him. In addition, this scene uses the technique of superimposition to draw further attention to Tevye’s thoughts. As he thinks about his daughter and considers the look in her eyes as she stands with the man she loves, in ECU Hodel’s eyes dissolve onto the screen and over the ongoing scene. The cinematographic choices frequently employed in these films ultimately help in not only focusing on the emotions of the characters— again attempting to connect to a more nuanced version of humankind rather than a utopic one—but also to foreground the construction of the film. By more strongly augmenting traditional self-effacing Hollywood camerawork used in the arcadian with more obvious in vogue tricks of the trade, these films further emphasize the disjointedness or constructedness of the image/narratives. This shooting style further underscores
On a Clear Day You Can See the Cracks in the Scenery 69
the new generic tendency of examining communal division as it works to dismantle the heart of arcadian musical form: the air of normalcy and tranquility commonly associated with the integration of song and dance.
Mise-en-scène: It’s the real deal right here in River City—Well maybe Dyer’s notion of a utopian sensibility projected through the musical genre not only applied to shooting styles, but paralleled Altman’s attention to the nostalgic and fantasy elements commonly found in musical mise-en-scène. As with other narrative and technical elements of the genre, however, shifts occurred after the mid-sixties that encouraged a rejection of such a utopia. The arcadian use of nostalgic periods or simpler times had helped to reinforce or underscore the genre’s already conciliatory narratives. Musicals such as Oklahoma!, The Music Man, The Wizard of Oz (1939), The Court Jester, and Gigi created safe spaces to work through foregone conclusions that genre norms had dictated would ultimately reinforce the contemporary status quo—unity, heterosexual monogamy, communal harmony.14 Narratively and aesthetically, such films had created simplistic paintings of their periods or times gone by, rather than detailed, realistic re-creations. Versions of the South, New York, St Louis, or Paris viewed through a haze of idealized memory remained distanced from life’s unsolvable problems. Later trends in the genre, however, rebuke such idealized historical shorthand and strengthen the musical’s ability to depict more ideologically ambiguous stories and contemporary images.15 Such trends in mise-en-scène complement the musical’s overall turn toward psychological realism or complexity by integrating a combination of realism, a contemporized nod toward historical fashion, ironic or parodic stylization, and/or self-aware theatricality. The harsh light of reality No claim could ever be made that earlier musicals are wholly without nods to realism. To certain degrees many—if not most—of these musicals included various levels of realistic mise-en-scène, whether choices in lighting, the ways in which clothing reflected real garments of a given time, or how settings clearly evoked the overall feel or aesthetic of a specific period. Even fanciful and idealistic integrated musicals such as Guys and Dolls, The Wonderful World of the Brothers Grimm (1962),
70
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
and South Pacific use period-inspired costumes; however, they simultaneously retain idealized or slightly cartoonish natures that play toward Dyer’s notion of utopia with bright colors and paper doll-like cutouts of authentic clothing. At the end of the day, such costumes—although retaining the overall shape or cut of their authentic motivators—possess a simplicity in color and cut that help to evoke the possibility of a utopia beyond reality. Whether through the presence of pristine blues that mirror the freedom of the ocean in South Pacific or the bright blocks of color that compliment the idealized version of New York City signs and city colors in Guys and Dolls, such costumes take artistic license to imply the period but evoke a specific visual ideal. The play on reality that emerges through many of these later films of the sixties and seventies tilts the scales toward the darker realism of the day, rather than the simplicity of the fairytale version. Like the aforementioned musicals, Camelot and Lost Horizon embrace partial truths in their design schemes; however, they play on historical/regional accuracy and current-day fashion trends. Whereas Guys and Dolls infuses 1930s style with a color scheme evocative of cartoon gangsters, both Lost Horizon and Camelot infuse their Arthurian and Asian dress with a contemporary flair. Rather than drawing on a more peaceful time or aesthetic, they draw on contemporary generational division. Camelot’s costuming takes on an air of youthful rebellion with its mod and hippie-inspired leather patchwork, Beatles haircuts, fitted menswear, peasant-inspired clothing, and flowered accessories. These choices in design aid in connecting an already problematic narrative to contemporary youth subcultures and their attendant associations of dissent, drug use, and rebellion. Lost Horizon makes a similar choice in its creation of a visual binary that evokes the dissent existent in contemporary America. Prior to the groups’ landing in Shangri-La, they don clothing indicative of conservative tradition and their personal hang-ups—suits, ties, fedoras, overcoats—and then switch to an everyday Shangri-La dress that reflects the seventies but has been infused with Asian traditions—Pacific Islander tribal dress, Middle Eastern caftans, Cantonese collars and fasteners, and Tibetan religious wear to name a few. Like Camelot, this design concept highlights existent conflicts occurring outside of the narrative and visually takes sides, placing an Eastern cool indicative of youth culture in the land of a supposed utopia. Reflective of this stage of the genre, however, neither land and neither style truly projects such a utopia, as the narrative ends somewhat ambiguously and neither view comes out wholly satisfying.16 Unlike the more idealistic gangsters, cowboys, and maidens of musicals gone by, these hybrid visuals compound the narrative
On a Clear Day You Can See the Cracks in the Scenery 71
projection of irresolvable conflict and social distress rather than mute it. Like an “Italian neorealism light” and reflective of elements of the French New Wave and New American Cinema, the musicals of this period often drew largely on a less obviously cinematic view of reality to help project a less theatricalized version of society, and rather to embrace a simpler realism that reflected the everyday problems encountered by the protagonists. Such visual aesthetics mirror either contemporary society or a historical period and thereby discard the nostalgic or utopic safety of arcadian visuals and instead situate narratives in spaces that appear to have the potential to house real actions and resolutions (or lack thereof, as a major characteristic of these narratives is their inability to resolve life’s problems). Hair and Fiddler on the Roof exemplify this trend as they stick to more location shooting and realistic costuming and settings outside of their dream sequences. As both films’ narratives involve struggle over the changing state of generational rifts and political developments, their mise-en-scènes reflect a similar complicated reality. Both films avoid the highly colorful palettes or fantastical visuals often associated with arcadian communal celebrations. Fiddler on the Roof ’s settings are largely comprised of actual underdeveloped Yugoslavian towns and costumes consist mainly of earth tones, simultaneously suggesting a sense of historical realism and a solemn or restrained atmosphere. With the exception of “Tevye’s Dream,” this realism remains throughout the film.17 Similarly, aside from its druginduced “Hari Krishna,” Hair uses real military bases and uniforms and contemporary clothing to aid in the creation of an overall sense of realism. Using the diversity of New York City to provide an active youth culture, major draft board, and upper-class society, the film uses real locales such as Central Park and Washington Square Park to bring these groups together and to construct their individual enclaves. Through the film’s choices in setting and costume, it transcends the exaggerated and overly groovy version of hippiedom present in Sweet Charity’s “Rhythm of Life.” Instead, mise-en-scène embraces the imperfection, mess, dirt, and eclecticism that would be connected with a large group of people implied to be living outside of mainstream society and, in the words of Hair, “ain’t got no money.”18 Attention to realistic detail invites an association with the real, rather than stylized nostalgia. Musicals of this period also use realism in conjunction with stylization to project the musical’s ambivalence toward earlier generic norms. By creating multiple worlds divided cleanly by their visual style— one fanciful and one grounded in the historical real—they project
72
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
the genre’s resistance to embrace the creation of utopian societies and instead show those utopias as existing outside the bounds of a harsher reality. Films such as Godspell, All That Jazz, Xanadu, and Man of la Mancha move between aesthetic styles, one oppressive and one more freeing. The films create these disparate worlds to project the opposite of Altman’s nostalgic worlds of possibility and Dyer’s clean utopias. Instead, they serve as a dividing line between an oppressive reality and the possibility of an out-of-reach fantasy. Godspell, for example, begins filled with the bustle of a contemporary New York City. Shot on location, the opening shows the characters surrounded by overwhelming crowds and noise of the city. Horns honk. Music blares. In the midst of this commotion, each member sees a vision of John the Baptist, abandons his or her mundane life, and rushes to Bethesda Fountain to wash his or her cares/sins away. The initial crowds and hassle of New York contrast to the remainder of the film. Once the narrative shifts to the world of John the Baptist and Jesus, the realism of the city—and the presence of any other people—disappears until the end of the film. New York City becomes a playland more akin to the location shooting that created the sailors’ adventureland in On the Town. Childlike stylization—clown makeup, Superman shirts, wigs, hats, and costumes—becomes Godspell’s dominant aesthetic. Resembling hippies/clowns/children in a world of found objects that magically transform into playthings and props, the characters become completely separated from their previous selves. Wearing face paint and layered found articles of clothing, they travel around a New York City absent of any other people. They inhabit a New York City bereft of its corruption and crowds. In contrast to On the Town, where the sailors cavort in a similar Big Apple, the film has already projected the harsh reality (and will return to it at the film’s end). Godspell’s idyllic world of the parables does not take over. The utopian sensibility perhaps created through the sights, sounds, and textures of the film’s middle, disappears at the film’s end, as the real New York City, rife with its crowds and daily grind, reappears after Jesus’s crucifixion. The utopia disappears. Whereas the more arcadian musicals tend to use idealized spaces to legitimize unrealistic solutions to real problems, films that embrace this doubled visual style propose ideals that can possibly help one to function in a world that the film presents and accepts as flawed.19 Similar doublings occur throughout this stage of the genre. In Xanadu, Club Xanadu, much like Godspell’s abandoned New York City, appears limitless in its possibility for building cultural and generational bridges in a Los Angeles already presented as artless and loveless. Both costumes
On a Clear Day You Can See the Cracks in the Scenery 73
and settings shift to the fantastical with the appearance of the muse, Kira. She punctuates the humdrum world and club with brightly colored special effects and stylized fashions denoting stereotypical notions of late 1970s’ rock-n-roll and 1940s’ big band. Fantastical costumes infuse fantasy and color and illustrate possibilities that exist in an otherwise dull world. Stylization illustrates the hope for a more perfect society, a hope that—as with the death of Jesus—dwindles with Kira’s eventual departure and the film’s return to an emptier reality.
Stylization and generic parody As often as using the evocation of contemporary trials through the use of visual realism, these films use forms of overt stylization to drive a wedge between established generic norms and the genre’s emerging jaundiced eye toward such standards. Rather than using such stylization in the same vein as the more arcadian musicals—to create a sense of visual idealism that parallels narrative simplicity—these films more commonly develop stylized visual schemes to produce either overt critiques of established genres through satiric winks toward their visual norms (The Pirate Movie, Bugsy Malone, The Rocky Horror Picture Show, Pennies from Heaven, or At Long Last Love) or to create visually assaultive worlds that project a clear and irresolvable evil (Tommy, The Wiz, or Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band). Films such as Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band, Tommy, and The Wiz use artistic flights of fancy to create cartoonish worlds that visually emphasize the possibility for extreme evil and in some cases extreme good. Although on the surface utilizing a technique that had traditionally set the scene for idealistic resolutions, such later films take this nostalgia and merge it with an extreme visual projection of contemporary corruption or conflict. Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band begins with images that connote the peaceful times gone by of Meet Me in St Louis or State Fair. The brightly-colored town square of Heartland U.S.A., comprised of such idyllic haunts as its timeless city hall and community gazebo, however, quickly morphs into an equally stylized inner-city jungle at the hands of film’s villain, the Evil Mr Mustard. This turn is what differentiates the stylization common in these films from that identified by Altman and Dyer as producing a utopic sense of nostalgia, and instead it highlights the cynicism with which such films approach the ideological underpinnings of the more traditional form of the genre. After acquiring the magic drum, Mr Mustard buys all of the local real estate and converts
74
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
the town into a haven for big business, hookers, and seedy hangouts. Gone are the idyllic town square, Sgt. Pepper Museum, and farmer’s markets; instead, exaggerated images of contemporary life clutter Heartland: video games, gyrating punks, and a giant cartoonish hamburger advertisement atop of the town square gazebo. Such imagery continues throughout the film critiquing big music and big corruption: the record executive B.D.’s convertible limousine/bar on wheels (that contrasts to the boys’ Wizard of Oz-reminiscent hot air balloon), lamé-clad hookers trolling adult theatres, oversized dollar bills for bad guys to flaunt, and gigantic brandy snifters (into which B.D. sneaks drugs to manipulate the innocent lead singer Billy). Complementing these giant symbols of urban corruption, the film takes continual shots at contemporary computerization. From Mr Mustard’s “Computerettes”—his talking/singing robotic harlots—to Father Sun’s (Alice Cooper’s) manipulation of America’s scout uniform-clad youth via mechanized brain washing (as psychedelic images of Sun accompany the repeated phrase, “we hate love, we hate joy, we love money”), stylized contemporary technology leads to abject evil. The exaggerated visual depictions of destructive contemporary technology and the disturbing urban/rural and folk/commercial binaries allow for the creation of a clear and exaggerated sense of good and evil. Unlike the musical binaries discussed by Altman, Schatz, and Feuer, these cannot be transcended by synthesis of opposites. Many of these darker musicals also take advantage of mise-en-scène reminiscent of arcadian stylization to communicate a satiric take on Hollywood genre, the musical and otherwise. By using narrative conventions and visual expectations of established genres, the aforementioned films, as well as Bugsy Malone (gangster films), The Pirate Movie (pirate films), The Rocky Horror Picture Show (B-sci-fi and musicals), and Pennies from Heaven (musicals) add an additional layer of critique to their stories. Each recognizing and toying with the traditional norms of their respective genres, such films use codified visual codes and generic icons to underscore predetermined narrative and ideological expectations to either critique them or use them as a means to foreground the disingenuousness of the genre in which they are being applied. This sweeping critique of genre as a narrative form cuts to the heart of the musical’s new cynicism toward tidy narratives and clean conclusions. The Pirate Movie, for example, uses recognizable costume pieces (Indiana Jones’s hat, whip, and leather jacket, Christopher Atkins’s—who play’s Freddie—loincloth from Blue Lagoon [1980], Inspector Clouseau’s hat and trench coat) and sight gags (pie fights, visual poses of movie
On a Clear Day You Can See the Cracks in the Scenery 75
romance, and hip modern versions of pirate dress) from Hollywood products or established genres to highlight the film’s disassociation with reality and immersion in fabricated popular culture. Instead of hearkening back to a time of nostalgic safety, this technique foregrounds the lack of a true original. These films cannot so easily translate a sense of safety and stability into a real world through the articulation of repeated generic codes or a water-colored version of the comfortable past. Instead, this dislocation or displacement of generic norms foregrounds the false worlds created in Hollywood films as the only possible locales for such ideal living. The acknowledged falsity forces a wedge between the cinematic and real worlds, much like the missing diegetic audiences of Godspell and Jesus Christ Superstar rob the theatrical audiences of their intermediary or diegetic stand-in. Specifically critical of the musical genre itself, both The Rocky Horror Picture Show and Pennies from Heaven use visual and ideological arcadian norms to produce a sense of self-awareness and critique of the very genre they embody. Such self-awareness seems largely lacking in the earlier days of the film musical. Singin’ in the Rain, for example, does poke fun at the early days of the genre, but it simultaneously reinforces its arcadian roots through the romance narrative (the boy gets the right girl and the right girl gets the career) and visual pleasantries (such as bright colors, energetic movement). The visual conventions of the musical used by these later films aid in the execution of an ambivalent take on the genre that confronts its traditionally rosy outlook.20 As Pennies from Heavens’ characters suffer negative life experiences, glamorous visuals associated with musicals of the 1930s immediately transform the dismal realities of their surroundings to create worlds that should supply idealistic outcomes improbable in the characters’ real lives. As the film’s hero Arthur fails to secure a loan for his record business, the film shifts to a reality reminiscent of a 42nd Street or Gold Diggers production number. Now wearing matching stylized costumes, dancing on giant coins, and shot in grand Berkeley-esque fashion, people and the world around them abandon a life where dreams do not come true for one that guarantees they will. In the end, however, the fantasy visual fades back to the reality of Arthur’s failed attempt to secure a loan. Throughout the film, as lives become more lurid and hopeless, optimistic musical numbers spring forth at unexpected moments: an adulterous affair, a wife’s contemplation of murder, a murderous drifter’s dinner, and a pimp’s propositioning of an innocent woman hitting the skids. The fantasy of arcadian conventions cuts through the gloom of these unlikely musical activities to present an impossible ideal that once only the musical could
76
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
supply. These stylized visual utopias continue throughout the film, even including a diegetic screening of Astaire and Rogers’s Follow the Fleet (1936) as a backdrop for a final grasp at impossible happiness. In contrast to the films they mimic, however, the use of such arcadian musical conventions only highlights the hopeless desperation that takes hold of the narrative after the production number fades and reality returns. Theatricality In addition to stylization and realism, these later films also illustrate a Brechtian trend toward the use of overt theatricality as a means to foreground the construction of the film. Bertholt Brecht’s modernist approach to what he deemed epic theatre partially relied on the distancing of the actor from the character and the audience from the performance through embracing the practices of alienation and distanciation. Brecht claimed: The spectator was no longer in any way allowed to submit to an experience uncritically (and without practical consequences) by means of simple empathy with the characters in a play. The production took the subject-matter and the incidents shown and put them through a process of alienation: the alienation that is necessary to all understanding. When something seems “the most obvious thing in the world” it means that any attempt to understand the world has been given up.21 Much like the techniques discussed earlier in this chapter that evade the subtlety and self-effacement of continuity editing, the use of overt theatricality within these movie musicals further foregrounds the artifice of the narratives by announcing their constructedness. As these performances within performances emerge upon diegetic stages, they break any probability of a seamless narrative/passive reception and further damage the utopian sensibility or social cure-all discussed by Altman, Schatz, and Dyer. Instead, they present the problems of the narratives through a lens of Brechtian distanciation for audience consideration. Jesus Christ Superstar and Zoot Suit commit most fully to this self-referential framework, the former developing a mise-en-scène that mixes onscreen set building and costume changing with various periods and aesthetics and therefore draws constant attention to its own artifice. Beginning with the actors constructing the set and unloading their costumes, the film makes no pretense regarding the authenticity of its version of the Christ story (Figure 2). Instead, Jewison infuses
On a Clear Day You Can See the Cracks in the Scenery 77
Figure 2 With its pseudo-set of scaffolding and priests in vaguely Middle Eastern garb and S&M-reminiscent leather gear, Jesus Christ Superstar’s mise-en-scène underscores the constructed nature of narrative and masculinity. Everything is a temporary construction to be torn down by the film’s end. (Universal/Photofest)
the ancient locales of Israel with contemporary 1970s fashion and sensibilities. The colors and cuts of costumes—hippie-like flowing robes, swinging medallions, and leather accessories—evoke a sense of the present and the social mores that go along with them: sexual, gendered, and generational. Settings that combine real Biblical locales with modern props and scaffolding constantly reference the film as a production. For example, depicting Jesus’s destruction of the corrupt temple markets in a scene that includes modern gun trading, whores, and other “hot” goods ties the corruption of the narrative to the present. This theatrical combination of period, a practice that occurs throughout the film, prevents a seamless presentation of narrative action as representative of a realistic—or singular idealized—period. Zoot Suit uses a similar technique as it takes place within an actual theatre, beginning outside of the building, following audience members in, and then proceeding in such a manner that never implies the story is taking place in a fully realized world. Sparse, non-realistic scenery and
78
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
limited space force a restrained form of stage action. This presentational style foregrounds the calculated choices made within the film, as a fully-developed or realistic mise-en-scène gives way to minimal stage pieces: a jail, a witness stand, a car. The theatricality allows for more rational inclusion of random musical numbers. In the case of Zoot Suit, musical numbers either stem from dance numbers, the carnival atmosphere of the courthouse or white society, or asides from the mystical El Pachuco. This visual style helps underscore the biases of the social system by presenting that system not as a realistic whole, but as a caricaturized body, as the scarcity of setting pieces places importance on those few present. The characters’ courtroom positions take on more symbolic or iconic statuses when detached from a real world. Using highly stylized set pieces such as giant newspaper flats, the overt theatricality directs attention to the overarching social meanings of the film, rather than allowing it to function on a solely character-driven narrative level. Implicated as part of the mise-en-scène and ensuing social drama, the diegetic theatrical audience (and therefore according to Feuer the viewing audience) appears alongside the diegetic courtroom audience members who sit in the first few rows of the theatre watching the injustice unfold. Instead of welcoming all with the passed-along-song, the film implicates everyone in the reigning social injustice by invading spaces generally reserved for the invisible moviegoer. Through a heavyhanded visual style and the blending of actor and audience space in such an ideologically loaded narrative, the story becomes secondary as the larger social issues visually take the fore.
Case study: Tommy’s conjunction of ambivalent narrative and aesthetics Illustrating an overall rejection of arcadian dictates, Ken Russell’s Tommy shows how ambivalent choices in both narrative and visuals coalesce to create this divergent image of the musical genre. Abandoning the idealistic notions of visual and ideological utopia, Tommy—as strongly as any film of the period—integrates violence, betrayal, and capitalist manipulation to an effect of creating a world in which an arcadian end cannot emerge as triumphant. Through the combination of a somewhat realistic historical time and extraordinarily stylistic visuals, the film injects abject evil into a genre that often sought to uncover the good within all situations. Russell’s films commonly assault the senses with such stylized vulgarity. A similar effect exists within the extreme sexualization of characters through dream sequences in The Boy Friend,
On a Clear Day You Can See the Cracks in the Scenery 79
as well as non-musicals like The Devils (1971). When earlier musicals such as Mary Poppins and The Wizard of Oz combine somewhat realistic times and places with special effects and fantastical elements, they create worlds of clear-cut good and evil, in which ultimately good-hearted protagonists triumph. The evil of the wicked green witch and the dark winged monkeys stand firmly apart from the pastel and brightly colored munchkins, good witch, and scarecrow who represent all that is good and worthy in the land of Oz. In contrast, the exaggerated visuals of Tommy work to establish the warped world of Russell’s film. To further augment the darkness created through stark depictions of lust and violence, Tommy combines realism and stylization to help articulate the boy’s skewed perception of life. After the sight of his mother’s lover, Frank, murdering his father renders Tommy blind, deaf, and mute, the use of highly stylized imagery visually heightens his sensory deprivation. Punctuating the boy’s blindness and overall helplessness, the world of the film materializes as larger than life. Contrary to the arcadian musical’s use of stylization to represent an idealistic or nostalgic world, Tommy uses these techniques to comment on significant social or personal conflicts. Similar to those in Sgt. Pepper and The Wiz, Tommy’s stylized depictions of life, surroundings, and characters allow a satiric articulation of family, money, and religion at a time when all were coming under attack and within a genre that had revered the traditions of religion and family. Instead of wrapping universal problems in small everyday stories, it depicts epic conflicts that visually attack the senses. Whether highly colorful and idealized images of Christmas, the giant boots of the pinball wizard, Cousin Kevin’s torture devices (like spikes on the toilet), or the bizarre hypodermic needles, snakes, and bodily twitches of the Acid Queen, the world seems impossible to control. From beginning to end, Tommy creates a story where evil controls the narrative. In a musical world bereft of unity, condemnatory of wholesome romance and family, and filled with personal isolation, the film never manages to overcome the extreme evil presented to its protagonist. Even by the film’s end, any clear sense of triumph over evil evades the narrative. As the film begins, Tommy’s mother (Ann-Margret) and her pilot husband cavort in the woodlands, make love in a waterfall, and conceive Tommy. Only momentarily does this outpouring of love and family devotion survive. By the conclusion of the rock opera’s first full musical number, the pilot leaves his wife to go off to war and appears to die in a fiery wreck. From this point on, the narrative takes a dark turn as the mother sets out to find a new father for the angelic-looking Tommy. Instead of a kind Daddy Warbucks (Annie) or Uncle Henry (Wizard of Oz),
80
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
she finds herself in the arms of the greasy-holiday-camp-green coat Uncle Frank (Oliver Reed). The film foregoes wholesome family-building for an immediate turn toward sex and violence. The scarred father returns to his family and catches his wife in bed with Frank, who murders him in front of the spying Tommy. Crouching into the boys face, the murderous couple sing that he didn’t see or hear it and won’t say “nothin’ to nobody never in his life.” The trauma renders the boy blind, deaf, and dumb. The majority of the film then chronicles the manipulation and maltreatment of the boy at the hands of his family. Neglected, poked and prodded, tortured, and molested, the helpless Tommy can only seek solace in his own reflection—through which he sees his dead father—and ultimately pinball. Even with the regaining of his senses, Tommy languishes at the hands of his greedy family as they build an evil moneymaking pinball empire, which finally crumbles at the violent hands of his enraged followers. The film ends in an ambiguous fashion, as Tommy flees the compound after the campers revolt and murder his parents. He runs through the water and emerges in silhouette at the top of a mountain—much as his father had stood at the beginning of the film. Like many of these later musicals, the film lacks a conclusive ending. Will Tommy recover? Has he found some kind of awakening? Aesthetic choices made throughout the film—montage, crosscutting, costumes, setting, special effects—punctuate the real pain that exists in this world and establish the darkness of the tale. After the father leaves the idyllic love nest, the film shows his tragic flight crosscut with his frightened wife’s panicked premonition regarding his fate. Like the realistic expulsion of the Jews from Anatevka in Fiddler on the Roof or a graphic war film, the visuals clearly present the impending doom of this broken family. Following the couple’s return from their lovemaking, they part ways after finding a dead child in the rubble of a bombed-out building. As the wife runs back to her house and closes herself in her encaged, bomb-protected bed, she fretfully looks at a picture of her husband. The film cuts to her husband’s bloody hand as it tries to keep power over the plane’s controls. With the sounds of bombs bursting in the background, stylistic choices heighten the sense of panic and horror as the film cuts repeatedly between the pilot’s blown-out, flame-engulfed window and the mother’s terror-stricken face. This is no fleeting look of hysteria soon to be quenched by the comfort of a safely returning husband or supportive family. Rather, the filmmakers choose to instill early the possibly of actual death and destruction, as the next scene shows her receive word of her husband’s death. As the pilot returns home, having
On a Clear Day You Can See the Cracks in the Scenery 81
survived the crash and only burned, the film uses multiple close-ups to capture the disturbing nature of the murder and its participants. With no diegetic sound—only underscoring—during the murder, close-ups of the father, Frank, and the mother show the violent reaction to the discovery of the affair and its aftermath. A quick close-up of the father screaming upon finding his wife in bed with Frank leads to a medium close-up of the mother’s sweaty naked body covered by a sheet, and then one of Frank grabbing a lamp and smashing it against the father’s face. Throughout, the scene cuts to multiple quick shots of a shocked and angelic Tommy watching the entire transaction. With the first diegetic sound of the scene, the mother screams/sings in panic about what the boy saw as the camera cuts between her sweaty naked body and messy hair and Frank’s leering face as he stands over the father’s dead body. This scene blatantly equates lust with violence and deception without a haze of the musical’s cure-all idealism. The visual choices made here accentuate the darkness of the scene and the desires and luridness of the characters. Earlier musicals like Hallelujah, Carousel, and Oklahoma! disrupt communal harmony with murder but eschew the close graphic detail of the act (and the murdered folk in such films usually have it coming). Visual choices—for narrative or regulatory reasons—often decentered stark portrayals of murders and corpses. To the contrary, later films such as Tommy, The Rocky Horror Picture Show, Godspell, and Jesus Christ Superstar focus visually on violent acts of murder, the suffering of the sympathetic characters murdered, and often the deviant intentions of the murderers. On a most basic level, Tommy’s narrative rejects the bedrock of many Hollywood musicals. Beginning with the murder of the heroic soldierfather, the film equates sex with murder and financial gain and decenters familial love. Throughout, the film presents problematic notions of motherhood and family as visual choices work to highlight the problematic positioning of the mother as nurturer and/or caregiver. Through costume, acting choices, and camerawork, both the mother and Frank appear grotesque and unable and unwilling to show love. Their concerns lie firmly with personal pleasure and monetary gain. As the film progresses, Tommy’s mother shows less and less concern with the fate of her son. Although she initially seems distraught by what they have done to the boy, any lingering sense of virtuous motherhood disappears as she and Frank embrace the lives they have built with each other. One main way in which the film visually reinforces this notion is through repeated imagery that leads to the parents abandoning their helpless
82
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
son with problematic caretakers and objects. As they leave Tommy with sadistic Cousin Kevin, with drunk and lurid Uncle Ernie, and standing staring at himself in front of the mirror, the two repeat a short song where the mother asks Frank to legitimize the decision. Her concern appears dismissive as she asks in distorted speech as she exaggeratedly applies her lipstick and eyeliner, fixes her bizarre chic tri-tiered leopard print hat, yawns, and drinks a cocktail as she stands or sits in excessive displays of furs and jewels. All the while, Frank answers mindlessly as he laughs at the newspaper, fixes his greasy hair, and shoves food into his mouth. During the number “Champagne” the perversity of her social positioning and role of mother come together in an outlandish display of materialistic simulated sex as she humps the wet furniture after the television explodes flooding the room in a lake of chocolate, beans, and suds. Later, in the same room, she seductively rubs against Tommy and throws him through the mirror, the only object aside from a pinball machine that has ever interested him. His expulsion from the room and immersion in the water below miraculously allow him to recover his senses. Although the overall meaning of much of this can be disputed, the over-the-top visuals telegraph societal conflicts, making it difficult for the story to overcome its assaultive imagery and successfully negotiate the conflicts that drive the tale. As stylized ambivalent films forego over-determined conciliatory endings, they often include more character development or examination of the internal workings or feelings of the characters. When the narratives surpass the boy meets girl, boy struggles for girl, and boy gets girl (and everyone worthwhile lives happily ever after) scenario, additional consideration must be paid to the developments of characters and the overall story. Much like in All That Jazz and Fiddler on the Roof —but in a much more stylized fashion—Tommy incorporates visual elements to highlight the mental processes of the blind, deaf, and dumb boy. For example shortly after the murder, the film shifts to a location that would generally evoke a sense of joy and family bonding. With Frank, the mother, and Tommy dressed in matching outfits, they journey to an amusement park. As the adults react joyously to the rides, Tommy remains stone-faced. The scene then shifts to a highly stylized representation of Tommy’s thoughts. A starry night appears with disco balls flying through it. As the trio rides an airplane ride, an image of a smiling Tommy sitting on the lap of his pilot father in the cockpit of a plane appears. Tommy’s superimposed head then appears through the lights of the Ferris wheel. The camera zooms into his eye and the image of
On a Clear Day You Can See the Cracks in the Scenery 83
father and son reappears. Shortly thereafter, Tommy wanders away from the family, arms outstretched, feeling his way through an arcade as the film cuts to an image of the boy with a large black box covering his sensory deprived head. He stumbles around the seaside shore and then back into the real arcade as he stares at himself in a funhouse mirror— the first of many times Tommy stares into a mirror. As the camera then zooms forward into his eye, it reveals his father standing at the water holding a giant glowing orb. (The orb returns throughout the film in scenes where the sensory deprived boy sees stylized images of himself in the mirror.) That image then cuts to a sky filled with stars, planes, and crosses with pinballs bouncing between them and ultimately zooms to his Christlike father standing prostrate on one of the planes. His head then turns into a ball that cracks open to show mirror images of a smiling Tommy that splinters into a ball with countless images of the boy playing, jumping, and running. He then frolics similarly in front of the funhouse mirror until his family reappears, whereupon he again stands motionless. Throughout, the film compliments the complex storyline by visually recreating the trauma felt by its main protagonist—a trauma never fully overcome. The film also uses stylized visuals to project the evil that exists outside Tommy’s isolated world of imagination. This exaggerated sense of reality—combined with moments of relative realism—helps to underscore the impossibility of reconciliation within the narrative. Not only does the story not call for the kind of recuperation common to the musical, but those who exist within the world of the film display levels of evil, sadism, and perversion that would be difficult to overcome in a diegetic world so bereft of a bonded community or a truly heroic or effective protagonist. Many of Tommy’s adversaries—Cousin Kevin, Uncle Ernie, The Acid Queen, and The Pinball Wizard—appear highly exaggerated. Design elements like the giant spikes on Cousin Kevin’s booby trapped toilet increase his already sadistic presence. The mélange of creepy items—rubber gloves, tubes, unappealing liquor concoctions, corsets, women’s panties—with which Uncle Ernie surrounds himself, coupled with his bizarre heavy breathing, make him appear even more problematic and vile. The film’s stylization hits its height in perhaps one of the most disturbing moments of the film, “The Acid Queen” number. Tina Turner, who plays the drug-addled seductress hired by Frank for Tommy, traditionally exhibits exaggerated performative elements. Throwing her head and arms around when she sings, she appears larger than life even outside of the film. With the Acid Queen’s sparkly red dress, long cigarette holder, and red patent leather platform heels
84
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
she presents an imposing figure to be thrust upon the innocent and unaware Tommy. The camera shakes as it follows her around. She walks straight into close-up as she approaches the camera. The scene is composed of bizarre images, from her near-naked assistants wearing little but the structure of a hoop undergarment to her full-body armor loaded with hypodermic needles. As the Acid Queen shrieks her lyrics and encases Tommy in the armor, she appears superimposed and in double over the suit and she zooms toward and away from the screen as the armor spins. Ultimately, the spinning suit shrinks as she becomes larger and Tommy disappears into her mouth. As the armored drug dungeon opens, it reveals a Christlike Tommy with faux stigmata, loin cloth, and hands full of pinballs/artillery, his damaged father, and a skeleton with snakes crawling through it (Figure 3). Typical of this period, Tommy uses these types of visuals to highlight the already problematic narrative elements. The story not only lacks sympathetic characters or support for a helpless child, but also Tommy’s adversaries—and supposed supporters—are so far beyond the evil of a musical menace like
Figure 3 Evoking the extreme stylization of the film, Tommy emerges from his bizarre “Acid Queen” sadistic steel cocoon with faux stigmata and stylized crown of thorns. (Columbia Pictures/Photofest)
On a Clear Day You Can See the Cracks in the Scenery 85
Jud Frye (Oklahoma!) or Lucifer Jr (Cabin in the Sky), that the ability to narratively overcome such obstacles seems less probable. Ultimately, Tommy escapes the clutches of his parents—who die at the hands of revolting campers—but the conclusion remains ambiguous. He flees the destroyed camp, jumps off a pier, and swims to the mountains. In the end, he lacks any human connection with another living being. Visually and narratively he exists in a vague location of triumph and isolation. As it does with narrative, the ambivalence of many later musicals pushes past simplistic approaches to mise-en-scène common in the arcadian version of the genre. Instead, through choices in setting, costumes, and cinematography many of these Hollywood musicals of the 1966–1983 period toy with levels of realism and parody common in the edgier non-musical films of the day to heighten either their association with real (rather than nostalgized) worlds and conflicts or underscore the predetermined ideological bent of Hollywood generic conventions. By increasing levels of stylization in parts of the cinematic whole, these films usher in larger-than-life aesthetics complementing their exaggerated emotional or moral stakes. Further, they separate idealized worlds from more realistic ones and use overt theatricality that both highlights artifice and creates a space for self-conscious social critique. These aesthetics compound the impact of narrative shifts occurring and visually foreground the ambiguity and ambivalence implicit in this new dominant incarnation of the genre.
Conclusion The reigning musical form of this period deviates from the once prevailing generic style, following cinematic trends of the time, embracing social conflict, and presenting more complex representations of human experience through the manipulation of the visual sphere. Unfettered by the once common (and seemingly imperative) nostalgic sense of space, these films follow visual trends of New American Cinema, art cinema, neo-realism, and modernist theatre to buck the idealistic traditions of the musical. By presenting ambivalence or cynicism as the status quo, these films popularize a different incarnation of the genre ideally suited to interrogating social crises and the everyday struggles of life. Emergent styles of cinematography and mise-en-scène disengage the musical from its prior association with the idealized or nostalgized; rather, new generic norms stylistically draw out the inanity of life, present nuanced problems within the real, or foreground the complex
86
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
mental processes involved in the decision making process. Through highly communicative camerawork, use of still photography, unrealistic diegetic sound, voiceover, parodic use of the montage sequence, and variations of reality and theatricality, these films coalesce to create a new generic variant capable of combining music with stories that break through the ideological limitations previously set for the genre.
3 Wanna Sing and Dance? These New Guys Are Ambivalent About It
The undercurrents of generic change manifest in the movie musicals’ emergent visual and narrative trends of the late sixties to early eighties were both reflected in and compounded by the genre’s shifting relationship with the roles of performers and performance. Whether due to modifications in the acting pool or changes in narrative focus, a decided shift in performer and performance style occurs during this period that further challenges the more idealistic phase of the genre. Where once the genre had been inextricably linked to energetic song and dance, community-bonding production numbers, and powerful professional and studio groomed musical talent, this new group of films displayed a tendency to eschew the finesse, naturalism, and idealism once inherent in musical performance. Performers and performances constructed a darker view of musical society, an overall conflicted view of the genre, and an embracing of the social struggles circulating in American society during the films’ releases. They ideologically assault early norms and compound diegetic shifts by moving away from the projection of spontaneous performance as indicative of an inner truth, joy, and communal harmony. A combination of intertextual star meaning and shifting norms regarding vocal quality, means of presenting the sung word, dance style and ability, and the context of such performances systematically highlight the connotative significance of song and dance in the musical motion picture. Simultaneously, they paint a picture of the genre more reflective of contemporary social unrest and shifting cultural norms. The maintenance of the arcadian vision of the musical had relied heavily on the connotative stability provided by performance-related elements. Broadway stars such as Fred Astaire, Eddie Cantor, Mary Martin, and Ethel Merman had brought the legitimacy of the live theatre 87
88
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
to motion pictures. Bing Crosby, Frank Sinatra, and Doris Day lent the cachet of popular music to the genre in films such as Birth of the Blues (1941), Pal Joey (1957), and Love Me or Leave Me (1955) respectively, while hoofers drawn from other avenues of performance or schooled by the studio system stables brought mastery of various styles of dance to the screen via the help of Broadway choreographers such as Michael Kidd (Seven Brides for Seven Brothers, Guys and Dolls), Agnes de Mille (Carousel, Oklahoma!), Jerome Robbins (On the Town, West Side Story), and Robert Alton (Barkleys of Broadway [1949], Call Me Madam [1953]). These artists, their professional legitimacy, and their uncompromised skill blended flawlessly with the norms of the musical genre emerging through repeated stories, visuals, and performances. These earlier integrated musicals inextricably linked life to song and dance as stars’ performances seamlessly blended into everyday activities and characters found musical performance the best or only way to express life, love, or communal bonding. As integral components of both the more utopic and the darker, more generically conflicted musicals—whether through their presence or structuring absence—song and dance help to set the ideological tone of these genre films. Many films of the earlier period use these performance practices to underscore the over-determined ideological project of the genre itself. They abound with the energy of the trained singing voice. Whether through Martin, Sinatra, Merman, or Howard Keel, the voices—like the stars themselves—became synonymous with the genre as a whole. These real singers brought an energy and emotional authenticity connected to the trained voice. The songs spoke through their melodic and passionate articulations of the characters’ experiences. Even dubbed musical stars such as Audrey Hepburn (Funny Face, My Fair Lady), Rossano Brazzi (South Pacific), Christopher Plummer (Sound of Music), and Rosalind Russell (Gypsy) present a front of professionalism and competence.1 Although Brazzi and Plummer may not be singing “Some Enchanted Evening” or “Edelweiss,” it appears as if their characters could be. Voice and body merge easily, one flawlessly implying the other. This congruity avoids detracting from the performances at hand. Scholars repeatedly connect the inclusion of song to the furthering of the narrative romance and an overall expression of joy, truth, and naturalness. Rick Altman’s very concept for the musical relies on the existence and simultaneous performance of the romantic couple. Through similar solos and ultimate duets, the inevitability of the couple’s union came to the fore.2 He argues that as the two articulate their feelings
Wanna Sing and Dance?
89
about life and love through song, their differences and eventual similarities become obvious. In such films, song and the use of recitative—or the seamless transition from spoken word to song—simultaneously disrupt and forward the narrative, allowing the character to drift into more detailed monologues that elaborate on personal motivation in ways unlikely in “realistic” dialogue or contrived asides. Constructed as something connected to ultimate truths, joys, and emotions, song blends into the narrative not only through recitative, but also through the natural blending of the sung melody with the “rhythm of life.” The sounds of the city—racetracks in Guys and Dolls or crowded trains in The Music Man—or country—the clip clop of horses hooves in Oklahoma! or whips in Calamity Jane (1953)—provide sounds of life that then merge into the sung tune. Rendering life and song synonymous, such onomatopoeia and rhythmic articulation situate the musical performance within the reality of the diegetic world. Such choices further highlight the continuity and calm of the narrative. Through vocal transition/quality and narrative intention, sung portions of the more arcadian musicals help to support the overall utopian notion of easily solved conflicts and united communities. Similarly, such musicals commonly use dance as a complement to song in the quest to unite the community. Films render natural these seemingly disruptive performative acts that demonstrate the internal joy of those who inhabit the fictional communities. Both through style and narrative positioning of dance, these musicals—whether in a 1940s On the Town or 1960s Half a Sixpence—support the notion that the narrative community rests on the attainable brink of utopia and peaceful cohabitation. As with song, dance can emerge from the mundane: horse riding, house cleaning, or wood chopping. Life evokes the physical performance of dance as daily activities easily merge into syncopated bodily movement. Expressions of joy, sorrow, or confusion become heightened as dance—like song—more fully expresses emotion or character intention than day-to-day movement can. Both Jane Feuer and Altman explore the smooth transition from everyday activities to dance through discussions of tinkering or bricolage and the response to the innate rhythm of everyday activities. Altman describes dance as a logical extension of life.3 Just as The Music Man’s trains become song, Annie’s floor scrubbing becomes a dancing revolt and Damn Yankees’ baseball players turn sport into a choreographed celebration to articulate the heightened dramatic moments of the characters’ lives. Feuer similarly evokes the power of naturalizing dance through the integration of everyday objects into
90
Destabilizing the Hollywood Musical
performance.4 In The Unsinkable Molly Brown, Molly suddenly dances with the accoutrements of royalty in “I Ain’t Down Yet” as she and her brothers gather a blanket, bucket, and broom to create a costume. Gene Kelly is particularly apt at converting everyday items into tools for dance numbers, as, for example, garbage can lids become overblown tap shoes in It’s Always Fair Weather (1955) or a mop becomes a dance partner in Thousands Cheer (1943). These devices simultaneously imply the normalcy or naturalness of dance and its unpremeditated nature. Such dances appear neither planned nor choreographed by professionals; rather they spring from the activities and the lives of normal members of the community. Within these narratives, dance carries with it a curative power to be used in the dancer’s everyday life. Along with naturalizing dance through integration, earlier musicals often simultaneously prioritize the dancing event as one that highlights its communal significance. While the passed-along-song brings the community together in voice, various types of dance unite that same group through their physical expression of joy and togetherness. Whether a giant Charleston/traditional Asian folk/square dance in Flower Drum Song that celebrates the Chinese-Americans’ assimilation into American society or a rousing folk-dance inspired romp of a picnic in Carousel or The Pajama Game, large dance numbers can visually create an exuberant sense of communal unity more concisely than the spoken word. Conversely, such displays—exemplified by West Side Story’s balletic rumbles and cat fights—provide heightened moments of physical action to play out overt conflicts existent between rivaling factions of the society that must ultimately be overcome through the magical resolution of conflicting ideologies.5 Along with diegetically-driven numbers, the arcadian musical often relies on the narrative work accomplished through the dream ballet, a vehicle used widely by Kelly (On the Town, An American in Paris [1951], Singin’ in the Rain) and others (The Girl Most Likely’s [1957] “The Happiest Girl Alive,” Oklahoma!’s “Out of My Dreams,” Flower Drum Song’s “Look Away”). The dream ballet provides magical insight unavailable to the waking mortal as it allows the dreamer to recognize conflict and seek out resolution in ways she or he is unable to while awake. Additionally, the final production number, often in the shape of a wedding or some other form of celebration, halts the narrative and floods the screen with performative excess at the moment of conflict resolution. Films like Billy Rose’s Jumbo (1962) use the final production number to remove magically the film’s lingering conflict altogether. Although Jumbo concludes with the loss of the circus to the big business circus
Wanna Sing and Dance?
91
owner, upon regaining possession of the prize elephant Jumbo, the two sets of lovers join together in a rousing production number celebrating “What is a Circus.” The performance and celebration of romantic union and the glory of circus life overshadow the ultimate failure of the hero and heroine to attain what they physically (beyond romantically) desire: their successful and family-run business. The arcadian incarnation of the genre commonly uses folk dance to connote traditional social mores the narratives seek to preserve, as well as amalgamations of jazz, tap, ballet, ballroom, and soft-shoe that evoke feelings of romance, unity, and energy. These filmic moments provide visual reinforcement of the ultimate narrative goal: the magical resolution of the utopic conclusion and an uncomplicated synthesis of conflicting value systems and social practices. As these later musicals’ narratives more frequently reflect cultural rifts and overall shifts or ambiguity with regard to real-world gender dynamics, performances of song and dance underscore these divisions and relational tensions. Cultural revolutions surrounding Vietnam, counterculture rebellion, and the sexual revolution manifest themselves in more sexualized, individualized, or mechanical dance, as the fluidity and narrative unity of paired song and dance give way to alternative performance styles. An erotic Bob Fosse replaces a jubilant Michael Kidd and hearkens back to the pre-Code days of unabashedly sexualized dance. Gene Kelly goes the way of the waltz or swing as Clint Eastwood and rock-n-rollers inflect the genre with generic and social rebellion. Such performances reflect, compound, and are compounded by darkening stories, actors’ disparate abilities, and in vogue musical and cinematic styles. The expectation in many of these later films that a Kelly or Keel would ultimately belt out a hopeful number while artfully sweeping his dance partner/lover off of her feet could only lead to disappointment. Although the musicals of the mid-sixties to early eighties retain some visual, aural, and ideological elements reflective of an earlier time and more idealistic notion of the genre, many illustrate a significant displacement of dance, change in the presentation of song, and an overall shift in