As of 2008 Museum Tusculanum Press has taken over the series Monographs on Greenland | Meddelelser om Grønland. Manuscripts should be sent to: Museum Tusculanum Press University of Copenhagen 126 Njalsgade, DK-2300 Copenhagen S DENMARK
[email protected] | www.mtp.dk Tel. +45 353 29109 | Fax +45 353 29113 VAT no.: 8876 8418 Guidelines for authors can be found at www.mtp.dk/MoG Orders Books can be purchased online at www.mtp.dk, via
[email protected], through any of MTP’s distributors in the US, UK, and France or via online retailers and major booksellers. Museum Tusculanum Press bank details: Amagerbanken, DK-2300 Copenhagen S :: BIC: AMBK DK KK :: IBAN: DK10 5202 0001 5151 08 More information at www.mtp.dk/MoG About the series Monographs on Greenland | Meddelelser om Grønland (ISSN 0025 6676) has published scientific results from all fields of research on Greenland since 1878. The series numbers more than 345 volumes comprising more than 1250 titles. In 1979 Monographs on Greenland | Meddelelser om Grønland was developed into a tripartite series consisting of Bioscience (ISSN 0106-1054) Man & Society (ISSN 0106-1062) Geoscience (ISSN 0106-1046) Hence Monographs on Greenland | Meddelelser om Grønland was renumbered in 1979 ending with volume no. 206 and continued with volume no. 1 for each subseries. As of 2008 the original Monographs on Greenland | Meddelelser om Grønland numbering will be continued in addition to the subseries numbering. Further information about the series, including addresses of the scientific editors of the subseries can be found at
www.mtp.dk/MoG
Denmark-Greenland in the twentieth Century
Denmark-Greenland in the twentieth Century Axel Kjær Sørensen
Meddelelser om Grønland · Man & Society 34
Axel Kjær Sørensen: Denmark – Greenland in the twentieth Century. – Meddelelser om Grønland, Man and Society 34. Copenhagen, The Commission for Scientific Research in Greenland, 2006. © 2006 by The Commission for Scientific Research in Greenland Publishing editor Kirsten Caning Printed by Special-Trykkeriet Viborg a-s No part of this publication may be reproduced in any form without the written permission of the copyright owners. Front cover: The South Greenland provincial council in session 1939. Photo Arctic Institute. Scientific Editor: Hans Christian Gulløv, National Museum of Denmark, Frederiksholms Kanal 12, DK-1220 Copenhagen K, Denmark. Phone (+ 45) 3313 4411, fax (+ 45) 3347 3322, email
[email protected] About the monographic series Meddelelser om Grønland Meddelelser om Grønland, which is Danish for Monographs on Greenland, has published scientific results from all fields of research in Greenland since 1879. Since 1979 each publication is assigned to one of the three subseries: Man & Society, Geoscience, and Bioscience. This publication is no. 34 in the series Man & Society. Man & Society publishes papers that contribute significantly to studies in Greenland concerning human beings, in research fields such as anthropology, archaeology, arts, economics, education, ethnology, history, law, linguistics, medicine, psychology, religion, social science. Papers dealing with borderline subjects as for instance exploitation of natural resources and environmental research may be referred to one of the series Bioscience, Geoscience, or Man and Society according to what is considered appropriate from an editorial point of view. For more information and a list of publications, please visit the web site of the Danish Polar Center http://www.dpc.dk All correspondence concerning this book or the series Meddelelser om Grønland should be sent to: Danish Polar Center Strandgade 100 H DK-1401 Copenhagen Denmark tel +45 3288 0100 fax +45 3288 0101n email
[email protected] Accepted July 2006 ISSN 0106-1062 ISBN 978-87-90369-89-7
Chapter 1
Contents
Preface 9
Faroese fishing in Greenlandic waters 54 The Negotiations in 1939 59
Greenland before 1900 11 Changes in traditional Greenlandic society 15
The Second World War 62
Growth in population 15
Towards the War 62
Occupation 16
The Situation for Greenland in April 1940 62
Greenlandic society at the turn of the century 16
The relations with Kauffmann and the United States 63 The agreement on bases, 1941 65
Years of reform 1900-1912 20
Supplies and sale 66
Greenland enters struggle between political parties in
Greenlandic production 69
Denmark 20
The Administration 71
Turbulence in Greenland 22
The Provincial Councils 71
The Act of 1905 concerning church and education
The press 73
in Greenland 23
Schools 74
The Governing Act of 1908 24
A political incident 74
The preparatory work, 1903-07 24
East Greenland 76
Economic issues 26
Back in Denmark 78
The terms of the Act 27 The revision of 1912 31
The immediate postwar years 80 Positions in the summer of 1945 80
The Daugaard-Jensen period, 1912-1940 33
The Negotiations in 1946 86
Population growth and employment 34
Criticism and tensions, 1946-1948 90
Change in the Economy 35
The Americans in Greenland 93
Fishery 36
The fishermen in Esbjerg 94
Sheep breeding 38 Other social developments 39 Cultural Developments 41
The reform of 1950 96 The Start in the Permanent Greenland Committee 96
The Greenlandic debate 41
Meeting the provincial council 98
Peqatigiinniat 42
The Great Greenland Commission 101
Schools 43
Settlements and investments 102
Teaching Danish in the schools 44
Political and administrative reform 102
Political Development 47
Education and cultural issues 103
Provincial councils 47
Health care 104
More Legislation 1925 48
Economy and business 105
The Preparations in Greenland 48
Qaanaaq and the East Coast 107
The 1920 committee 49
Making the suggestions into laws 107
The Passing of the Governing Act 50
The abolition of Greenland’s colonial status 108
The Act on Hunting and Fishing 52 The 1926 law on Old Age Pensions in
The development in the 1950s 111
Greenland 53
The Labour market 112
The quarrel with Norway over East Greenland 53
Health care 113
5
CONTENTS
Education 114
The Political Parties 164
Housing 115
Politics 164
Primary production 115
The concentration policy 164
The impact of the modernization on Greenland 117
Leaving the EEC 167
The reaction in Greenland 117 The political debate 120
Faroese fishing in Greenlandic waters 120
The Greenlandic flag 168 A brief review of the situation in 2000 168 Epilogue 169
The concentration policy 121 Appendix 1
Adjusting the course 124
Governors and High Commissioners in
The Greenland Committee of 1960 124
Greenland 170
Greenlandic reaction in public 130
Changing attitude to integration 132
Appendix 2
School Policy 133
The Provincial Councils 1911-1979 171
The teachers 133 Privatisation and Self Government 134
Appendix 3
Greenlandic reactions outside the provincial
Home Rule Parliament 1979-2000 (Grønlands
council 135
Landsting) 178
The debate in parliament 136 The Holsteinsborg Conference 139
Appendix 4
Home Rule Government 182 The road to home rule 142 Voting on the Common Market 143
Appendix 5
The Greenlandic Home Rule committee 146
Members of the Permanent Greenland Committee
Home Rule negotiations in the commission 147
1925-1963 (Grønlandsudvalget) 184
Mineral resources 149 Membership of EEC 150
Appendix 6
Implementation of the Home Rule 1979 151
Members of the Greenland Council 1964-1979 (Grønlandsrådet) 185
A more Greenlandic Greenland 152 The population 152
Appendix 7
The economy 153
Members of the Danish Parliament elected by
Fishing 153
Greenland 186
Hunting 153 Mining 155
Appendix 8
Other occupations on land 156
Ministers for Greenland 187
The companies 157 The Greenlandic finance 161
References 188
The Block Grant 161 The Balance of Trade 162
6
Index 193
List of figures 1. Kayaks carried over the ice 13 2. Nuuk 1910 14 3. Danes in Nuuk 1915 17 4. A Greenlandic pasture 25 5. South Greenland Provincial Council 1911 30 6. Municipal Council in Nuuk 1927 31 7. Jens Daugaard-Jensen 33 8. Greenland halibut 34 9. Piles of dried and salted cod 35 10. Class room in a settlement 1936 43 11. King Christian X in Nuuk 1921 46 12. Ships anchored in Faroese Harbour 1930 55 13. Sheep farm 1936 68 14. Fishing from rowing boat 70 15. South Greenland Provincial Council 1939 72 16. US Coast Guard Combat Cutter Eastwind 1944 76 17. Base Blui West One 1945 77 18. Eske Brun and C.F. Simonÿ 81 19. Augo and Frederik Lynge 112 20. Helicopter in health service 113 21. Class room in a settlement 1961 114 22. A warehouse 2006 154 23. Royal Arctic Line carrier 157 24. Aircraft in Kangerlussuaq 158 25. Ilisimatusarfik 159 26. The old harbour in Nuuk 2003 160 27. Cargo on the quay in Uummannaq 161 28. The Greenland Flag 168
List of tables 1. Population of West Greenland (except Thule), 1789-1901 15 2. Occupation of Greenlanders (%) 16 3. Europeans Jobs Occupied by Greenlanders (%) 16 4. Population of Greenland 1901-38 (-Thule) (with Danish growth rate for comparison) 35 5. Greenlanders by occupation 1911-1945 (%) 35 6. Proportion of Greenlanders in European occupations 1911-30 (mining excluded) 36 7. Proportion of Greenlanders in colonial service, 1911-45 36 8. Building of fish processing plants in Greenland 1910-1939 38 9. Settlements by size of population 38 10. Distribution of money income by kind among the Greenlanders 39 11. Lending from the Greenlandic funds to house building and business equipment 40
7
12. Health sector in Greenland 40 13. School and church staff in Western Greenland, 1910-37 43 14. Issues raised in the Provincial Councils by members (%) 47 15. Provincial council members by occupation, 1911-39 47 16. Imports by countries (tons) 67 17. Total Yearly Landings of Cod (tons, whole fresh fish) 69 18. Funds collected in Greenland during the war 79 19. Type of Family houses in the building programme of 1950 104 20. Mortality 1950 and 1960 114 21. Development in education 115 22. Government investment in Greenland 1948/49-1958 116 23. Primary Production in Greenland 1945-1958 116 24. Distribution of income in Greenland by source 117 25. Private Enterprise in Greenland 1960 excluding Fishery, Hunting And Farming 117 26. District Court Statistics, Greenland 118 27. Distribution of law cases about paternity and other civil cases. Percent 119 28. Investment plan for Greenland 1966-1975 128 29. Greenland Population 1930-1970 137 30. Fish Production 1960 - 1970. 1000 tons 137 31. Distribution of the Work Force 1976 and 1996 by Sector 153 32. Hunters in Greenland 1993-2001 155 33. Distribution of the work force 1996 156
List of diagrams 1. Native sale 21 2. Seal catch 1887-1934 West Greenland per inhabitant 36 3. Variations in Surface Temperature (degrees Celsius) 37 4. Greenland exports by value ( DKK.) 37 5. Greenlanders’ income from sales to the Trade Department (actual prices) 39 6. Consumption in Greenland of imported food 41 7. War Time Bases in Greenland 66 8. Mortality and Fertility in Greenland 115 9. Population in Greenland by origin 119 10. Greenlanders and Danes in Greenland 1970-2000 152 11. Local work force in public service 153 12. Greenlandic fishing 1978-2000 154 13. Seal catch and trading in of seal hides 1978-2000 155 14. Minerals’ Proportion of Export Value 156 15. Transfer from Denmark, at current prices 1980-2000 162 16. Transfer from Denmark at constant prices (1981) 1979-2001 163 17. Gross Domestic Incomes at Disposal in Greenland 1979-2001 163 18. Elections for the local parliament (Landstinget) 164 19. Percentage of the population outside the towns 1886-2002 165
8
Preface
What is told on the following pages is a history of the Danish-Greenlandic relationship over one hundred years. It covers the history of Danish Greenland policy, and the history of political and economic development in Greenland. With only a very basic knowledge of Greenlandic I had to base my account on sources written in Danish. This is less of a problem than might be supposed because the language of administration has been Danish, including even the minutes from the local political assemblies. Over the years much Greenlandic writing has also been translated including some novels, and anything written to the authorities in Greenlandic has been translated. Nevertheless, the account is necessarily that of an outsider unable to fully analyse the linguistic expressions of the Greenlanders. Written in a Danish context it covers Danish Greenland policy and its background in and impact on Greenland society. This Danish perspective is predominant at the beginning, but as the Greenlanders took over more and more of the administration it is almost lacking in the latter part, dealing mostly with developments in Greenland. Many colleagues are to be thanked for discussions over the years, but in particular publisher Christopher Hurst, London, and my colleague at the University of Gloucestershire John R. Howe who has been indispensable in rooting out the many Danish expressions in the script. Any shortcomings are however mine.
9
Greenland before 1900
Greenland is an arctic/sub arctic country with a permanent ice cap covering the whole inland area and in places projecting into the sea. Human habitation is only possible in the coastal area of 350,000 square km. Up till recent times the permanent ice was impassable. All communication had to be by ship along the coast and in the northern part by foot or dog-sledge on the frozen sea and fiords in winter. The first known settlements in Greenland date from around 2,500 B.C. and were found in the most northerly part called Peary Land. They were established by Eskimo tribes from Arctic America. In the following centuries more came in larger or smaller groups, the latest about 1000 A.D. Greenland’s relationship with Europe started in the Viking Age. In 982 people from Iceland settled in the southern part of Greenland in the Qaqortoq (Julianehaab) and Nuuk (Godthaab) areas, which were not at that time occupied by the Eskimos. The Norse settlements in Greenland as well as in Iceland were free, independent societies for a couple of centuries. However, in 1261 Iceland, mostly inhabited by Norwegian settlers, accepted a subordinate status under the Norwegian crown and the settler community in Greenland did likewise. Bergen in Norway became the link to the two dependencies in the North Atlantic. In 1380 Denmark and Norway became a double monarchy, soon with Denmark in the leading role. Thus Greenland became a part of the possessions of the Danish crown. However the possession of Greenland added little to the king’s power because the Norse population there died out about 1500 following a period of 100 years out of all contact with other parts of the realm. In fact, their extinction was not realised in Denmark till much later. The actual circumstances surrounding the disappearance of the Norse population in Greenland are still an unsolved riddle although there have been many hypotheses. Among the plausible ones is an evident worsening of the climate and assumed competition for means of subsistence with incoming Eskimo settlers.
Although no relationship with Greenland had been maintained for centuries the Danish kings still regarded it as one of their dependencies, but despite several attempts contact was not re-established till 1721. This re-colonization of Greenland was seen at the start as a reopening of contact with an old part of the realm, but it became hardly distinguishable in character from any other colony acquired at that time. A Norwegian priest, Hans Egede, set out to bring the true Lutheran faith to the descendants of the ‘Old Norse’ who were believed to be still living in the darkness of Catholicism. He found none, but kept looking. However, he did find a ‘wild’ population, which he began to Christianise. As the years passed and knowledge of the Greenland territory grew, the hope of finding Norse descendants vanished, and the contact made in 1884 with the Eskimo tribe at Ammassalik on the east coast extinguished the last hope. No more unknown areas existed where Norse descendants could be living. The fact that the Norse population was no longer there, and that the new population of Eskimos was non-white and non-christian made no difference to the Danish king. The territory was regarded as being under indisputable Danish sovereignty on an equal footing with Iceland and the Faroe Islands. Despite their quite different origins the inhabitants were regarded as the King’s subjects because they lived in his land, and the King for his part felt entitled to rule over them as well. However it has to be understood that this was the Danish point of view. For their part the Greenlanders have always regarded Greenland as their country and the Danes or Norwegians as foreigners. They have tolerated the foreign presence, and to a certain extent have also used it for their own benefit. For his part the Danish King was free to think of the Greenlanders as his subjects. After all, he did them no harm. At first the main ‘civilising’ task was to Christianise the local population, a mission that was supposed to be financed by the profits from trade. In 1731 11
GREENLAND BEFORE 1900
the priorities came clearly into the open when a new king ordered that the establishment in Greenland be abandoned because it ran a substantial deficit. Hans Egede successfully appealed to the king’s conscience to allow the mission work to continue. Since then no Danish government has ever taken any initiative to abandon Greenland. The missionaries had a clear policy: paganism was to be rooted out, and therefore they did not tolerate shamanism or any other part of the Greenlanders’ culture which they considered to be rooted in heathenism. Modern research has claimed that in this way the missionaries destroyed the weak structure of authority within Greenlandic society. The policy of the Trading Company was more cautious. It soon realised that buying hunting products from the Greenlanders was the only way to make a profit. Thus from 1776, organised as a state company named the Royal Greenland Trade Department, it encouraged and supported traditional hunting, leaving Greenlandic society otherwise untouched. This led to the growth of a latent antagonism between the two services. The missionaries were certainly inclined to interfere in Greenlandic society as they regarded their mission as having a higher priority than that of the Trading Company. The result of this schism was a paternalistic native policy. Legal and administrative interference was possible, but the regulations were vaguely formulated and put into practice with caution. In the Instruction of 1782 which laid the foundation for Danish rule in Greenland, it was stipulated that the King’s servants should ‘meet the inhabitants with love and meekness, come to their assistance whenever they can, set a good example, and take care that they come to no harm in any way.’ The instruction continues: ‘Should anything indecent be committed by the Greenlanders, like either theft or various coarse vices, then the merchant must advise them in a most indulgent
way to abstain from it. Should this fail, or should the felony be very coarse indeed, they should be punished according to the circumstances and the character of the crime.’1 In case of epidemics or famine among the Greenlanders, they should be given provisions, those for the poorest being free. For the Greenlanders this was hardly very oppressive. In 1856 Hinrich Rink, inspector in South Greenland, characterised the Greenlanders’ perception of their legal position as follows: first, they should be helped and fed when they were genuinely in need; and second, they should be set a good example and given admonitions, but only punished according to the circumstances of the particular case when they really broke the rules.2 One could say that this showed a very exact understanding of the instruction of 1782. In 1814 Denmark lost another war. This time the cost was the cession of Norway to Sweden with the exception of Greenland, Iceland and the Faroe Islands. It is not entirely clear how Denmark managed to exclude these dependencies from the cession. However, a British divide-and-rule policy towards Denmark and Sweden seems a plausible explanation.3 The loss of Norway did not affect the administration of Greenland, which had never been ruled as a part of Norway, but the great historical transformations in the wake of the Napoleonic Wars did. The widespread process of industrialisation and the increased power of political liberalism were both developments with profound impact in Greenland. The minor impact was felt in economic policy. The state trade monopoly was maintained, especially after an experiment with a private trade department decisively failed in 1840. The purposes of the state monopoly were then more clearly formulated. Thus, in that year a commission agreed that the state ought not to profit from the trade, but rather let any surplus benefit the Greenlanders. The financial authorities accepted
1. “med kærlighed og sagtmodighed omgås indbyggerne, være dem til hjælp i hvad man kan, foregå dem med gode eksempler, samt nøje tilse, at dem ingen uret eller overlast i nogen måde vederfares.” and “Skulle noget usømmeligt af grønlændere begås, som enten tyveri eller andre grove laster, da må købmanden med al lemfældighed formane dem til at afstå derfra. Frugter dette ikke, eller forseelsen er særdeles grov, straffes de derfor efter omstændighederne og forbrydelsens beskaffenhed.” (Bobé 1936: 371). 2. Letter to the Minister of the Interior by Rink (1856: 233): “1) at de skulle hjælpes og fødes, når de virkelig trænger til det; 2) at man skal foregå dem med et godt eksempel, samt formane dem, og kun når de virkelig forser sig, straffe dem efter bedste skøn.” 3. Gad 1979: 187-205.
12
GREENLAND BEFORE 1900
Fig. 1. Light kayaks are easily carried ashore from open water and over the ice bream. The photo is from around 1900 and proba-
bly taken near Qeqertarsuaq in Northwest Greenland. Photo Jens Daugaard-Jensen/Arctic Institute.
this, although they insisted that a decent rate of interest on the state’s investments in Greenland had to be paid first. The trade surplus was ploughed back into Greenland in two ways. First, the prices paid to the Greenlandic producers were raised to stimulate their purchasing power. Second, some expenditure was initiated to benefit the whole society. In 1845 two teacher training colleges were established to improve the quality and increase the number of teachers of primary schools, and another physician was employed to raise health standards. A few Greenlanders were sent to Denmark for further education. In 1837 luxury articles such as coffee, tea, sugar and pearled grain were released for sale generally having previously been withheld from the market to avoid ‘spoiling‘ the Greenlanders. The sale of spirits and beer was still restricted. Against this background it seems fair to conclude that the material living standards of Greenlanders improved during this period, based on a sound economic foundation in trade. The influence of political liberalism in Greenland reached its high point with the establishment of local assemblies, which gave elected Greenlanders the opportunity to participate in local government. Such
assemblies are a well-known feature in colonial administration, especially in the British colonies where at first the councils were composed of higher civil servants and in some cases also of white colonists. Later, natives were admitted and the council’s authority grew. In the end the councils developed into parliaments based on universal suffrage, and the administration became a responsible government. This stage marked the transition from colony to dominion, and the last governor could be welcomed as the first High Commissioner. In Greenland something vaguely resembling the British colonial councils existed under the terms of the Instruction of 1782, which required the colony manager to listen to his employees’ advice if he was uncertain how to handle a case. The provision was little used, and by the middle of the 19th century the issue was opened from quite another angle, inspired by the introduction of local assemblies in Denmark in 1841 headed by the local priest. Each district in the colony got in 1857 a guardians’ council with the highest-ranking civil servants and appointed Greenlanders as members. The council was empowered to appoint new members when a vacancy occurred among the Greenlanders. Set up in 1857 as an experiment, they were put 13
GREENLAND BEFORE 1900
Fig. 2. Nuuk 1910. The white house to the left was build for Hans Egede, the first missionary in Greenland from 1721 to 1736,
and it is the oldest building in Greenland. The Greenland governors resided here for many years. The church and the nearby house of the dean are seen further up the hillside. Photo Morten P. Porsild/Arctic Institute.
on a permanent basis in 1862. As in Denmark a priest (missionary) headed the council, and the colony manager was accountant. Their principal task was to take over poor relief, which till then had been administered by the Trade Department’s staff. The councils were also allowed to spend money on any project which they considered to be the common good in the district. Their income was directly related to production, since the Trade Department contributed 20 per cent of the value of its purchases of Greenlandic products. A socalled re-partition was introduced to promote the utmost economy with public funds and to encourage industry. This envisaged that all funds remaining after payment of expenses should be divided among the Greenlandic seal-hunters according to the size of their catch, which meant in other words that the more industrious got the larger shares. In addition to their economic duties the guardians’ councils also held judicial powers where Greenlanders were concerned. Civil cases and minor offences could be dealt with summarily on the spot, but for major offences the council only held powers of inquiry and had to refer the case to the governor suggesting a suitable punishment. There were no written laws apart from three short paragraphs outlining illegal activities: (1) Unauthorised use of property belonging to 14
others such as using their tools without permission; damaging such tools; keeping other hunters’ catches without payment; taking possession of driftwood which another person had already dragged above the high water mark; (2) Simple theft and evident disobedience to the authorities; (3) Capital crimes such as manslaughter and other serious offences such as concealment of births. In all other cases unwritten Greenlandic law applied. The Danish authorities were obviously very reluctant to impose rules, which might contradict the Greenlandic sense of justice. Not much research has been done into the activities of the guardians’ councils. However, from the published accounts it is clear that a series of precedents were made, either following the direct rulings of the authorities or as approval of suggestions from the guardians’ councils. The history of this development will not be told here, but it should be noted that the fight against contagious venereal diseases from the crews of visiting ships led to some firm prohibitions such as a ban in 1890 on Greenlandic women going on board those ships. The guardians’ councils operated till 1911 when their authority was transferred to new municipal councils. The historical assessment of their activities
GREENLAND BEFORE 1900
has varied with time. All the same, it seems fair to say that the councils played an important part in the establishment of democratic processes in Greenland. This point was made by Oldendow in 19364. The commercial principles, which were laid down in the instruction of 1782, applied almost unchanged till 1950. The prices of goods sold to the Greenlanders (trading-out) and the prices for Greenlandic produce (trading-in) were the same all along the coast regardless of internal transportation costs. The reason for this was to maximise the catch by inducing the Greenlanders to cover as large a hunting ground as possible. Thus the Greenland economy operated on highly politicised prices. To the prices laid down in Copenhagen for goods destined for Greenland were added varying percentages to cover freight and other costs according to the importance of the goods in question to local production in Greenland. Quite low percentages were put on producer goods such as rifles, gunpowder, lead, iron and steel. Stoves and coal were even sold at a loss in the nineteenth century in order to get more blubber for export rather than being used locally in the traditional way for heating. The trading-in prices were set with a view to the Greenlanders retaining what they needed to maintain production over the long term. Economically speaking this was so they could provide for investments, in real terms keeping blubber for heating and hides for clothes and for coating the kayaks and boats. While the profit on the goods sold in Greenland could hardly cover the costs of providing them, that on Greenlandic products sold in Copenhagen financed the entire Danish presence in Greenland – at least when the trade did not incur losses. Seen over the period 1721-1900 it could be argued that the Danish state did not lose on the Greenland trade. An account from 1904 made the balance Dkr. 3.5 million in favour of the state.5 This result was due to the royalties from the cryolite mining at Ivittuut which had begun in 1857, totalling Dkr. 4.1 million.6 Annually from the 1880s the trade department was unable to cover its overall expenses even with the royalties.
Table 1. Population of West Greenland (except Thule), 1789-
1901. The figures for 1789-1824 are taken from the literature, the rest are from official censuses. The figure for 1789 is too unreliable to calculate a growth rate. Greenlanders
1789 1805 1816 1824 1834 1840 1845 1850 1855 1860 1870 1880 1890 1901
5,122 5,888 5,836 6,331 7,356 7,877 8,501 9,352 9,648 9,648 9.586 9,72 10,207 11,19
Europeans
Growth rate per annum % Greenland Denmark
0.71
196 251 234 225 248 232 239 280 309 262
-0.08 1.02 1.51 1.15 1.54 1.93 0.63 0.00 -0.06 0.14 0.49 0.84
0.87 0.77 1.03 0.84 1.28 1.31 1.05 0.99 0.99 1.11
Changes in traditional Greenlandic society Obviously changes took place in Greenlandic society from 1721 to 1900, and it can be assumed that the Danish presence played a major part in this. Growth in population As table 1 shows, the Greenlandic population has grown steadily except for the years 1805-16 (the war of 1807-14) and 1855-70. The stagnation and decrease 1855-70 only occurred in southern Greenland. Apart from that, growth has been more uneven than in Denmark, doubtless because of the smaller number of people. Table 1 also shows the few Europeans (most of them Danes). The variation in numbers of the Europeans was probably due to involuntary winter stays by ship’s crews. From these figures it could be argued that Greenland can support about 5,000 people with its traditional mode of production. Growth would then be the result of division of labour by gradual incorporation in the world market through Denmark.
4. Oldendow 1936: 69. 5. Rigsdagstidende Vol. B 1904/05: 150 ff. 6. Statistiske Meddelelser 1912, 4. R. 39 b. 2: table 18 A.
15
GREENLAND BEFORE 1900
Table 2. Occupation of Greenlanders, % (official censuses).
1834 European occupations Administration Trade Mission, church, school Other All Greenlandic occupations Hunters Fishermen Other All Number employed
1860
1890
1901
0.0 5.6 8.2 0.0 13.8
1.1 7.4 9.1 0.0 17.6
1.8 6.3 3.8 0.2 12.1
0.0 6.2 4.7 2.0 12.9
86.2
82.4
87.9
86.2 1,290
82.4 1,971
87.9 2,407
72.4 14.6 0.1 87.1 2,749
Occupations Pre-colonial Greenland was a society of hunters and gatherers. With the colonisation new ways of earning a living were introduced, as the Greenlanders were drawn into the work of the mission and the trade department. In the nineteenth century this Greenlandisation became a very conscious policy because local labour was much cheaper than workers imported from Europe. The development is shown in table 2. The figures for occupations are somewhat unreliable for earlier periods. The numbers of people employed full-time in European occupations are reliable enough, but part-time employment is harder to estimate. The same consideration applies to Greenlandic occupations. Fishermen were first counted separately in 1901, but fishing had already been an activity earlier, since the Greenlanders‘ traditional hunting included fishing. Only significant changes are worth noticing. The table shows that the percentage of Greenlanders in European occupations fluctuated around 15 per cent. Nevertheless, because of a growing population while the number of Europeans barely changed, the Greenlandic share of European occupations was increasing. Table 3 shows this. Greenlanders occupied nearly all the subordinate positions, and during the century they formed also a growing proportion of the skilled workers. Only at the top level was there a reverse trend. None of the 3-4
Table 3. Europeans jobs occupied by Greenlanders, % (official
censuses).
Catechists Crew (labourers, sailors, apprentices) Midwives Artisans Formen, skippers Outpost managers Colony managers, manager assistants Overall percentage No. of Greenlanders European jobs, total
1834
1860
1890
1901
100
100
100
99
75 0 34 13 0
88 95 62 68 30
100 100 82 87 51
100 98 99 87 64
7 59 175 297
3 73 248 477
4 78 291 373
0 86 355 415
doctors or the 10-13 missionaries was a Greenlander in this period.
Greenlandic society at the turn of the century Some 11,000 Greenlanders lived in small settlements scattered along the west coast from Qaqortoq (Julianehåb) in the south to Upernavik in the north. On the east coast a single trading and mission station was established at Ammassalik in 1894. Some 400 Greenlanders had their homes in this area. In 1910 a mission and trading post was founded in the Qaanaaq area to serve about 200 people. The Danish state was reluctant to extend its trade monopoly to this area, so the station was a private initiative.7 However in 1937 it was taken over by the state. Along the west coast were approximately 200 settlements, the number of inhabitants ranging from around fifty to 300-400. Their material lives were mostly based on subsistence economy with seal hunting as the main occupation. The seal meat was eaten; most of the blubber was sold to the Royal Greenland Trade Department but only a quarter of the hides were sold.8 The remainder were used for the kayaks and umiaks9 and for clothing. Income from what they sold was spent on imported tools, mainly sewing needles
7. Müntzberg & Simonsen 1996: 210. 8. Lists of catches in SSOG-46: table 156; sales in Meddelelser 1882-1908. 9. An umiak is a large skin-clad boat rowed by 8-10 women, used for transporting people and goods only.
16
GREENLAND BEFORE 1900
Fig. 3. This is a picture of all Danes living in Nuuk in April 1905. They are placed on the staircase of the house of the dean, C.W.
Schultz-Lorentzen. Photo C.W. Shultz-Lorentzen/Arctic Institute.
and knives, but also rifles, with one for every two male inhabitants.10 Wooden boats from Denmark were introduced in the 1880s; in 1900 there were 157 and still more were to come.11 Consumption of imported food was modest. The total of imported meat would have given only 11 grams if it had been consumed just by the Europeans. A considerable quantity of fresh meat was delivered by the Greenlandic hunters to the Europeans, and is in fact recorded abundantly in contemporary sources.12 The same calculation on imported butter and fat would imply that the Europeans consumed 52 grammes a day, which is probably suffi-
cient. Other provisions such as flour, groats, biscuits and coffee were imported in greater quantities than the Europeans could consume, and a proportion was clearly sold on to the Greenlanders. If shared equally it would give them a daily ration of 10 grams of coffee and 84 grams of cereal,13 – a somewhat modest contribution to their nutritional needs –. The extent of the subsistence economy can also be seen from the fact that the 85 per cent of the Greenlanders who were hunters and fishermen sold goods to earn an average of Dkr. 100 a year. By contrast the lowest-paid workers in Greenland were paid between Dkr. 250 and 600 a
10. There were just over 2,000 rifles in Greenland and a male population over 14 years of age of a mere 4,000 (SSOG-12: table 10, 3A). 11. SSOG-12: table 10. 12. Marquardt 1992: 174 13. SSOG-12: table 16.
17
GREENLAND BEFORE 1900
year.14 Even if we include the hunters’ private sales to the non-hunters, it is safe to characterise the native economy as predominantly one of subsistence. In the smallest settlements (bopladser) the Greenlanders could live their lives pretty much undisturbed by the Danish presence apart from the overall conditions of their existence stemming from it. No Europeans lived permanently there. There might be a native community council member and a so-called ‘reader’ to teach the children reading and writing when he could spare the time. Maybe they were lucky enough to have one of the fifty-five native midwives in their settlement;15 if not, they had to go to the nearest trading station or colony. That journey could take a day, if indeed the weather conditions allowed travelling at all. The trading post (udsted) had a store where the Greenlanders could sell their produce and buy imported goods. The store manager was a civil servant, often a native who got his goods from the colony to which he belonged and to which the Greenlandic products were transported. The trading post also had a room for church and teaching undertaken by educated native catechists. From 1845 onwards there was formal teacher training in the country, and long before the turn of the century nearly all adults were able to read and write. The trading post was very much a native community. The store manager could be a Dane – a quarter of them were at that time – but in that case he would be fluent in Greenlandic and often married to a Greenlander. Several times a year, however, the schooner from the colony would call for commercial and administrative reasons and might bring in people who could only communicate through an interpreter. A visiting physician would certainly need one, whereas a visiting priest would not since the Danish priests serving in Greenland were thoroughly educated in the Greenlandic language. The biggest station in each district was called a colony. At the time there were thirteen of them. From south to north in order (Danish names in brackets): Qaqortoq (Julianehåb), Paamiut (Frederikshåb), Nuuk (Godthåb), Maniitsoq (Sukkertoppen), Sisimiut (Holsteinsborg), Aasiaat (Egedesminde), Qasigiaanguit (Christianshåb), Ilulissat (Jakobshavn), Qeqertar14. SSOG-12: table 27; Report 1908: 59. 15. Census 1901 (Statistiske Meddelelser 4-14-5).
18
suaq (Godhavn), Appat (Ritenbenk), Uummannaq and Upernavik and on the east coast: Ammassalik. In each district a colony manager, a Dane, was the superior of all staff except the priests and catechists, and the physician – if you were so fortunate to have one of the three in Greenland living in your colony. In that case you would also have a small hospital, often with a nurse educated in Denmark. The Danish educated priests of whom nearly every colony had its own were responsible for all school and church matters in the district. Usually the colony was provided with a Dane second in command. He ran the store, and supervised the work of the skippers of small boats, carpenters, coopers, and common labourers who were employed in the service of the Trade Department. A colony foreman, often a craftsman himself, usually undertook the actual supervision. Economically, each of the thirteen colonies functioned independently and had direct communication with Copenhagen. However, the colony managers were subordinate to the two inspectors, one in Qeqertarsuaq for the northern part of the west coast, and the other in Nuuk for the southern part. The inspectors were the highest-ranking civil servants, and had overall supervision of all activity in Greenland except – once again – the church and school. They had direct access to the minister responsible for Greenlandic affairs. Most were recruited from the ranks of the Royal Greenland Trade Department, and following old practice, all cases referred to the minister passed via the board of that Department which thus effectively administered Greenland. The Department had the monopoly of all commerce with the Greenlanders, and its servants in Greenland were in charge of nearly everything related to the administration of the community. Thus Greenlandic society at the turn of the century had been profoundly influenced by the European presence since 1721. Paganism had disappeared from the west coast and left behind a people as Christian as any. Thanks to the mission the language had become a written one, finding its long-lasting shape in the orthography of the Moravian Brother Samuel Kleinschmidt in the mid-nineteenth century. Another profound feature was the racial mixture with the Euro-
GREENLAND BEFORE 1900
peans, partly as the result of relations with visiting sailors and other fortuitous romances, partly as the result of regular intermarriage especially among the humbler strata of the colonial staff. In the late nineteenth century racial mixture was so common that the official censuses ceased to distinguish between genuine Greenlanders and crossbreeds. All were counted as Greenlanders. Although the public services as well as trade and communication had been set up by the Danes, about 15 per cent of the Greenlanders were employed by the Royal Greenland Trade Department or by the church and school authorities. Most undisturbed was the primary occupation, the catching of sea mammals based on one man hunting from a kayak. In the north, from Disko Bay and further north, the dog sledge was still an indispensable means of transport during winter. Among manufactures the imported rifles, iron and steel had long been indispensable. The Greenlandic language had survived. There had been no cultural imperialism due to the Lutheran practice of reaching souls in their native tongue. Borrowed words to describe imported goods and ideas existed, but surprisingly many were translated into Greenlandic. Many others were so greenlan-
dised that their European origin was hard to trace including, for example, Christian names borne by almost all Greenlanders. Hitherto this society had been administered by rules made by the Royal Greenland Trade Department and the government. The Danish Parliament set up in 1849 had only taken part in Greenlandic matters when the economy was involved. When debating the yearly budget, which covered Greenland as well as the metropolis, Parliament was eager to keep expenses low, especially by reducing the size of the administration, which it thought was overstaffed. Twice – in 1851 and 1863 – Parliament set up special commissions to look into the matter, but the recommendations in the resulting reports were not acted upon. By 1863 even a recommendation to prepare for the abolition of the trade monopoly came to nothing. The overall objective – the well being of the Greenlanders – and probably the fear of incurring greater expenses later – induced the government to carry on with the established system At the turn of the century that part of the picture changed.
19
Years of reform 1900-1912
The period between the turn of the century and 1912 was a turbulent one where Greenlandic affairs were concerned. For the first time the Danish Parliament passed acts concerning Greenland. The Greenland mission became a separate church in 1905. They also established two provincial councils (landsråd), one for the north and one for the south of the west coast and sixty-two municipal councils (kommuneråd). These were intended to expand the Greenlanders’ participation in the governance of their provincial affairs. In this period too efforts to encourage new economic activities in Greenland were intensified. The cause of this transformation could be sought in conditions in Greenland or circumstances in Denmark. Had development in Greenland been so misconceived that something had to be done? Or was there a new political climate in Denmark that spilt over to Greenland to make a new start? The latter certainly seems to be the case. There is little evidence of deteriorating conditions in Greenland, which might have provoked reformers to take action. Some statistics suggest a decline in the seal catch, while others indicate a steady rise in the standard of living. The statistics for the seal catch before 1903 are defective, but lines can be drawn deduced from the sales of hides and blubber to the Royal Greenland Trade Department. The sale of seal hides to the Department reached peaks in 1885 and 1894, but overall the level in 1900 was only slightly lower than ten years before, and blubber sales show a fluctuating but generally upward trend to 1911. Living conditions seemed to have improved. The number of people living together in one house gradually decreased. From an average of ten people per house in 1880, the number fell to 8.4 in 1890 and 7.5 in 1901.16 Research in some places seems to suggest that this meant more space per person.17 The distribution of poor relief decreased dramatically during the 1880s 16. SSOG-46: table 31. 17. SSOG-46: table 35.
20
and 1890s, which may mean improved living conditions, but it may also be the result of a more restrictive practice. The revised rules from 1881 stated that aid should be given only when people were in danger of starving while the wording of the 1872 rules was “aid for those who by winter time did not have the most essential clothing and tools’. Over all, however, the evidence certainly suggests that no decline had taken place; rather there was an improvement. If any tension existed in Greenland, it was found in the guardians’ councils. In these the missionaries were supposed to co-operate with the Trade Department officials. The system had worked since the 1860s and a modus vivendi had been found. The sharpening of the latent tension around the turn of the century clearly seems to have received its impetus from changes in the political climate in Denmark as new missionaries came to Greenland with new ideas.
Greenland enters struggle between political parties in Denmark Under the Danish constitution of 1849, revised in 1866, governments were appointed by the King. The Conservative administrations of the 1880s and 90s thus governed with a majority of their opponents in the lower chamber, though with a majority in the upper chamber. From 1901, after years of political struggle, it became a fixed principle that the government could not hold office when opposed by a majority in the lower chamber. In Danish historiography this is called ‘the change of system’, and it cleared the way for social and political reforms, for which the new party in power – the Liberal Left, consisting of the wealthier farmers and progressive liberals from the towns – had long strived. However, the new government had to take the Conservative majority in the upper chamber
YEARS OF REFORM 1900-1912
Diagram 1. Native sale (SSOG-46:
table156).
4 3,5 3 2,5 2 1,5 1 0,5 0 1882
1892
1902 Barrels of blubber/natives
into account, which made the urban liberals uneasy, and after 1901 the growing Labour Party, the Social Democrats, ended its co-operation with the Liberal Left which had lasted from the days of struggle for new constitutional practice. The tensions within the governing party led to a new party, the Radical Left, being formed in January 1905. Its supporters were progressive liberals in the towns and small farmers. Already as a group within the ruling party these voters had brought Greenland into Danish party politics, with the willing support of the Social Democrats. The rallying points were rule by the people, social equality and intellectual freedom. The administration of Greenland was well suited to push forward general principles. The unhampered rule by civil servants, the exclusion of Greenlanders from political influence, the low standard of living compared to Denmark, all were vigorously attacked. But first the situation had to be made known outside the offices of the Royal Trade Department. An opportunity for this arose in 1902. A well-known journalist and writer, Mylius-Erichsen, who aired his radical views with a sharp-pointed pen in the newspaper Politiken, was allowed to visit Greenland by the new Minister of the Interior despite warnings from the Trade Department. Thus the socalled ‘Literary Expedition’ took place in 1902-4. In his application Mylius-Erichsen had not concealed his intention to look at Greenland with a critical eye, and his articles from the summer of 1902 were full of criticism of the Royal Trade Department. From the begin-
1912
1922
1932
Sealhides/natives
ning he made it clear that his purpose was to shed light on the country and its administration.18 Enlightenment was a banner of the Radical Left. No articles could reach the press while the Literary Expedition remained isolated in Qaanaaq in 1903, but politicians who later joined the Radical Left found other corners of the administration where enlightenment was needed. In 1903 some cases were discovered of staff helping themselves to “redundant” goods from the Trade’s warehouse in Copenhagen. C. Th. Zahle, later a member of the Radical Left and Prime Minister, acknowledged the precautions taken by the government, but spoke in Parliament of a small enclave left over from old autocratic regime where carelessness was the norm, in which light and fresh air were needed. The Social Democrats backed him eagerly. The newspapers Politiken and Socialdemokraten pursued the issue and filled their pages with stories from former employees of the administration about malpractices. The board of the Royal Trade Department and other civil servants denied the accusations in the press, but the Minister of the Interior could not ignore the criticism and ordered an investigation. Although this eventually cleared the accused, the heated debate inevitably left the public with the impression that something was rotten in the state of Greenland, and created a perfect basis for demanding changes in the way it was governed. Further impetus came from critical voices in Greenland as well.
18. I thank Jens Peter Andersen for allowing me to use his unpublished thesis for this account.
21
YEARS OF REFORM 1900-1912
Turbulence in Greenland19 The discussion in Greenland was entirely a matter for the Danish civil servants. The Greenlanders did not participate at all, and in their monthly magazine Atuagagdliutit the heavy criticisms of Greenlandic affairs were not mentioned.20 From the very beginning of colonisation in 1721 Trade Department and Mission had different objectives. The Mission’s objective was to bring Christianity to the heathen, and the Trade Department’s was to secure the economic foundation of the Mission and if possible earn a profit for its financial backers, private citizens and the Crown. Each branch of the colonial administration thought of itself as the more important, and this often led to local quarrels. Naturally, as friendship may follow strange trails, there is much evidence of cordial relations between individual missionaries and colony managers. When the guardians’ councils were established, the two branches were brought together with the missionary as chairman. It was painful for the Trade Department to be subordinate to a missionary, even more so, if he should be absent and a native senior catechist took the chair in his place.21 Such latent tensions broke out openly when new personnel from Denmark came to Greenland. Among the latter the missionary C.W. SchultzLorentzen was pre-eminent. As chairman of the Aasiaat guardians’ council, he soon came to be at odds with the board of the Royal Trade Department. A trivial case concerning erratic book-keeping in 1899 became a matter of principle when Schultz-Lorentzen disputed the board’s authority to decide in the matter and wanted the case heard by the Minister of the Interior. However, the Minister decided in favour of the board, also on the question of principle. Later, when SchultzLorentzen was transferred to Nuuk as missionary and head of the teacher training college, and consequently became chairman of the guardians’ council there, trouble started again. In 1903 the hunters in the fiord of Kangerluarsussuaq (Grædefjorden) had been denied a store at their settlement, which the guardians’ council deplored at its autumn meeting. It was far from usual for guardians’ councils to have words with the board of
the Trade Department, and it became worse when the Danish members of the council paid for a commodity depot at Kangerluarsussuaq out of their own pockets. This was open defiance of the inspector’s and the board’s wisdom. Finally in 1904, the board authorised the Trade Department to establish a depot of its own in Kangerluarsussuaq. Perhaps the outcome whetted the appetite of Schultz-Lorentzen, for more was to come, and in Nuuk he did not stand alone as in Aasiaat. Together with the physician Gustav Koppel, he developed new rules of procedure for the guardians’ council to give the Greenlandic members the greatest possible influence. The two reformers returned to the original idea about the creation of the guardians’ councils, in their words: to initiate municipal self-government that would be independent both of the Trade Department and of the Mission. They argued that the guardians’ councils had to be empowered to criticise the inspector’s and the ministry’s administration of Greenlandic funds. The guardians’ council in Nuuk approved the new rules at its spring meeting in 1904, and during the summer Schultz-Lorentzen and Koppel were active propagating their ideas. At a meeting at Paamiut in August, attended mostly by missionaries, the so-called ‘Frederikshåbpunkter’ (the agenda from Paamiut) were approved. They criticised the board’s suggestion for new rules for the guardians’ councils (to be dealt with later) asserting that the guardians’ councils should formulate the new rules themselves. Also the Greenlanders’ lack of real influence over their own affairs was criticized. Their efforts succeeded inasmuch as the Paamiut guardians’ council supported the proposals on their autumn meeting. Before that, however, the course of events in Nuuk became turbulent. In August the inspector dismissed Schultz-Lorentzen from the guardians’ council on dubious grounds. He protested forcefully, and in response sent his new rules of procedure in a circular letter to all guardians’ councils to be implemented forthwith. He was attempting to be ahead of the board with a fait accompli. Such an open rebellion gained however limited support. Even the newly-appointed guardians’ council chairman in Nuuk had second thoughts as he revealed
19. The following is based on Andersen 1979, who has used unpublished sources in the National Archives. 20. Karen Langgård 1999: 50. 21. Oldendow 1936: 70.
22
YEARS OF REFORM 1900-1912
by enclosing a private letter to the other chairmen telling them to avoid misinterpretation of the rules of procedure because that might, as he put it, nourish the existing distrust and suspicion of the authorities. Avoiding the issue was easy for the chairman in charge at Maniitsoq who was the colony manager because both the missionary and the catechist were unable to attend. He simply returned the circular letter to Nuuk without discussing it with the guardians’ council at all. In Qaqortoq the guardians’ council was also slightly irritated by the way Schultz-Lorentzen had acted, but felt able to support his main idea. Only in Paamiut and Ilulissat were reactions positive. The other seven guardians’ councils said nothing – apparently the circular letter was not even put on their agenda. So no united front against the Trade Department’s board was created. It was hardly a Greenlandic ‘uprising’ since no Greenlander had participated in the discussions which were confined to some Danish civil servants who, to judge by their arguments, were inspired by the new tide in Denmark and tried to change the prevailing system in Greenland as well. The board of the Royal Trade Department viewed the matter very seriously, and wanted to see the participants put on trial for their indiscipline. But before that could be done, events in Denmark had moved on to the point where a new act of Parliament was introduced, which would reduce the power of the Trade Department in Greenland and increase the Greenlanders’ influence to a far greater degree even than Schultz-Lorentzen and Koppel had suggested. No charges were brought against them. On the contrary, in 1904 SchultzLorentzen had already been co-opted to help in the preparation of new laws for the church and education in Greenland. Koppel was honourably discharged from the service in 1906 with his pension.22 The Act of 1905 concerning church and education in Greenland23 The first result of the debate in the early years of the twentieth century was the act of 1905 which regulated
and improved both the church and education. This was the first legislation passed by the Danish Parliament specifically for Greenland. The act was passed at a time when the reformers in Denmark were clarifying their main points regarding Greenland. The rallying points became: separation of the Trade Department from the civil administration in Greenland and municipal self-government for the Greenlanders. One of the reformers, Mylius-Erichsen, had returned home with the ‘Literary Expedition’ in 1904, and severely criticised the Greenland administration in an internal report. From bottom to top, no one was spared, and Mylius-Erichsen offered to join a committee dedicated to the Greenlanders’ welfare.24 The Ministry reacted in a relaxed way to this far from relaxed criticism. Later, it used Erichsen as a special expert on Greenland, perhaps hoping thereby to preempt criticism from the Radical Left. The main issue arose in the Finance Committee on 17 December 1904 when the Minister of the Interior promised to consider the possibility of separating administration and trade.25 The following month C.Th. Zahle again showed his interest in Greenland policy when he spoke in favour of reform during the debate on the budget bill in January 1905. In his phrase a major reconstruction was needed to promote the culture and selfgovernment of the Greenlandic nation.26 A clear connection existed between these initiatives in Denmark and the reformers in Greenland. Mylius-Erichsen referred explicitly to them in his report, and Zahle in his speech referred to ‘a very renowned and capable civil servant in the mission’ and especially the report produced by Schultz-Lorentzen when the bill concerning the church and education in Greenland was on the agenda in February.27 Several times over the years, missionaries had suggested improvements in the education of both children and catechists. The new Liberal Left government accepted the task, and asked Schultz-Lorentzen to work together with the other missionaries in Greenland to produce a report on the future organisation of
22. Reports 1907: 1. 23. The following section is totally based on Andersen 1979. 24. Mylius-Erichsen 1904; Andersen 1979: 41 f. 25. Minutes from the Committee of Finance 17 December 1904 (Andersen 1979: 42). 26. RTFF 1904-05: 1960; Andersen 1979: 43. 27. RTFF 1904-05: 1954, 2722 ff. On both occasions Zahle regretted that he was not a personal acquaintance of the person in question.
23
YEARS OF REFORM 1900-1912
the school system. Their report suggested enlarging the school for catechists by (among other things) employing a teacher educated at a Danish teacher training college, thus attaching more weight to ordinary school subjects in Greenland’s still predominantly religious education. The ensuing Act embodied this proposal. Other regulations were made to augment the number of Greenlandic educated catechists. The bill unanimously passed both chambers of Parliament, which was regarded as a victory for the reformers in Greenland – the more so since it so abundantly represented the ideas of Schultz-Lorentzen. In 1906 he was appointed the first rural dean in Greenland, a position created by the act.
The Governing Act of 1908 The preparatory work, 1903-07 In April 1903 the new director of the Royal Trade Department, Carl Ryberg who had been appointed in 1902, urged the Minister of the Interior to scrutinise the rules governing the guardians’ councils with a view to making changes. The administration of justice required particular attention, but also poor relief, subsidy, and repartition (the technical term used to describe the yearly repayment to the hunters of the balance left over in the coffers of the guardians’ councils) should also be revised. The intention to reform was immediately communicated to the guardians’ councils to enable them to comment on a draft version the following year. As mentioned above, some of the Danes in Greenland were dissatisfied by the passive role envisaged for the guardians’ councils in this procedure; they wanted greater changes than those the director suggested. However, Ryberg persisted with his suggestion despite the criticism from the missionaries in Greenland, which was essentially that the guardians’ councils should be placed directly under the Ministry of the Interior, thus by-passing the Royal Trade Department. Up till this point the suggestion was consistent with the reformers’ ideas, but where greater influence for the Greenlanders was concerned,
Ryberg went much further than the reformers. He wanted to exclude Danes altogether from membership of the guardians’ councils, leaving the Greenlanders alone to decide – although under the close supervision of the inspector and with the colony manager as accountant.28 However, it was no longer possible merely to revise the guardians’ councils, since Zahle as we have seen already, had presented the main demand in his speech on the budget: self-government in Greenland and separation of the trade from the administration. Parliament very much favoured stimulating the economy and education of the Greenlanders to achieve self-reliance and a ‘higher culture’. By passing the law on church and education in April 1905, it had already done something as we have noted for the cultural side of society. Meanwhile, from February 1905 Mylius-Erichsen was strongly criticising the Danish administration of Greenland. He had supporters in the press, and the criticism grew into a real assault on the Trade Department and its director Carl Ryberg, who finally responded by requesting to be tried for his conduct of affairs. He was totally acquitted.29 Thus the minister of the interior received Ryberg’s proposal in a time of crisis, and he did not endorse it straight away, asking for comments from among others Schultz-Lorentzen and Mylius-Erichsen. They were told that a bill separating the trade department and the administration was being prepared. The two reformers saw no merit in Ryberg’s proposal. Schultz-Lorentzen especially criticized the exclusion of Danes from the guardians’ councils arguing that this placed the assemblies totally in the power of the inspector.30 Even if Schultz-Lorentzen genuinely wished to secure real influence for the Greenlanders, we must bear in mind that Ryberg’s proposal would have prevented the missionaries playing the role in the guardians’ councils which they had hitherto played with good results. As well as asking experts in Denmark, the Ministry also consulted the guardians’ councils directly in August 1905 on their views concerning reform. This inquiry received a most peculiar treatment. The in-
28. Letter of 7 June 1906 from the Director to the Minister of the Interior, National Archives (Oldendow 1936: 87-90; Andersen 1979: 52ff). 29. Oldendow 1936: 94-7; Gad 1946: 193f; Andersen 1979: 51f. 30. Andersen 1979: 55.
24
YEARS OF REFORM 1900-1912
Fig. 4. Very few pastures are available in Greenland, and the growing season is too short and cold to produce fodder enough for
even a small herd of cows. Attempts are made though, e.g. on this pasture near Qaqortoq, about 1900. Cows were also held in the Norse period. Photo Henrik Deichmann/Arctic Institute.
spector for South Greenland, Ole Bendixen, openly sought to avoid it by sending the guardians’ councils a string of leading questions instead of the consultation document; he was forced to recall these letters and send the Ministry’s letter. In spite of this, only the Sisimiut guardians’ council put the request on the agenda, the rest is silence.31 However, the Ministry did receive an answer. In November 1905 the inspector for North Greenland, Jens Daugaard-Jensen, dispatched his ‘strictly personal views‘ to the Ministry. He agreed with Ryberg on excluding Danes from the elected councils, and went further in proposing the abolition of the guardians’ councils, and their replacement by an advisory council in each of the two inspectorates. These councils should be consulted on the enactment of laws and regulations for Greenland. Local admini-
stration of poor relief and the subsidy would be the responsibility of new municipal councils. However, the administration of justice would have its own organisation. Daugaard-Jensen also favoured separation of the trade from the administration in Greenland and the administration of Greenland from Denmark.32 With this proposal Daugaard-Jensen thrust himself into the midst of the ongoing debate. The debating group was soon enlarged. In 1902, a new association had been formed, the Danish Atlantic Islands, its main purpose being to retain the Danish Virgin Islands in the West Indies. The association’s members were colony administrators and important businessmen, who wanted to strengthen the bonds between the colonies and the mother country by making them more profitable to Denmark. The Green-
31. Andersen 1979: 58-62. The author went through the minutes from the Guardians’ councils and found no record of any discussion. 32. Oldendow 1936: 106-14; Andersen 1979: 62 f.
25
YEARS OF REFORM 1900-1912
landic section of the association was heavily weighted by the radical reformers in the debate, among them Schultz-Lorentzen and Mylius-Erichsen, who used the association to make contact with influential circles which were certain to be sympathetic to the idea of separating the trade and the administration. Their membership did not however mean that their concerns were focused on Danish business rather than the Greenlanders as Schultz-Lorentzen later clearly demonstrated. The anxious controversy over Greenlandic matters also engaged the old guard. The civil servants in the administration and especially the Trade Department felt that they had been subjected to many unjust accusations, and in 1905 to counteract them they founded the Greenlandic Society, of which civil servants, retired as well as active, could become members. Its object was to tell the public the truth about Greenland and to work for the benefit of Greenlandic society and the civil servants there. The Society made suggestions to the authorities, and from 1906 published a yearbook, which in 1953 became a monthly periodical, which is still in print. Throughout the years the Greenlandic Society has taken part in the ongoing debate on Greenland and published a series of books. In 1926 its membership was opened to the public. Economic issues Besides administrative and political reforms the reformers in Greenland wanted to modernise the economy by introducing new occupations for the Greenlanders since they did not consider that sealing could provide them with a living. Animal husbandry and commercial fishing were suggested. Cattle and sheep had been raised in the medieval Norse settlements, and it was argued that it should be made possible again. In fact sheep farming had begun on a modest scale in this period. On his own initiative a Greenlandic priest, Jens Chemnitz, kept a few sheep at his vicarage in Narsaq Kujalleq, South Greenland, and the experiment was copied by other private operators. Not till 1913 did the Royal Trade Department become involved, creating breeding stations to produce a stock of sheep and to advise Greenlanders wanting to try their hand in the business. Fishing was more promising. In the middle of the nineteenth century some fish was exported, but that came to an end as the supply of fish declined. How26
ever, by 1903 Atlantic salmon and halibut were included in the monopolised export, because Danish civil servants had begun to export these fish privately, and the Trade Department wanted part of the profits. No shift in policy was intended. As the debate progressed, the Royal Trade Department repeatedly stressed that sealing had always been the foundation of the Greenlandic economy and would continue to be in the future. Other occupations were welcome provided they did not harm the sealing. Reformers in Greenland, backed by the new political majority in Denmark, continued to put pressure on the Trade Department to become involved in developing fisheries, and in 1906 a Faeroese, Napoleon Andreasen, was hired to try deep sea fishing in Greenlandic waters. No cod in significant quantities was found. Adolf S. Jensen continued state-initiated fishery experiments from 1908, again with little success. However, commercial fishing for halibut started in 1910 in the south, almost exclusively in a single fiord, Alluitsoq. These endeavours can be seen as a response to pressure from the Danish political establishment, the more so since private enterprise had become interested in the opportunities in Greenland. Private enterprise had its place in Greenland, but did not form part of the economic life of the Greenlanders. Since the 1860s a private company had mined cryolite in Ivittuut, but it was an entirely expatriate business. All workers were imported from Denmark and no contact between them and the local population was allowed. The mining company paid the state royalties, which were tacitly placed at the disposal of the Royal Trade Department, thus helping to cover part of the overall deficit. By the turn of the century more companies had become interested. In 1902 a wholesale dealer, Berneburg, got a twenty-year concession to mine anything except cryolite in Greenland. The concession was on the same terms as the cryolite mining: no local labour, no contact with the population and a royalty to the state. Until the 1930s the company mined copper, graphite and mica at several small sites. Such an enterprise was welcomed by the Royal Trade Department, since it presented no threat to the sealing and the trading monopoly. Another application from a private company concerning whaling could be handled inside the overall policy because the Royal Trade Department managed
YEARS OF REFORM 1900-1912
to turn it into a joint venture in 1903-4. Commercial whaling was not considered a desirable occupation for Greenlanders, and as co-partner the Royal Trade Department could ensure that its interests were respected. However, the Minister of the Interior feared the enterprise would run at a loss and rejected the application. More threatening to the traditional policy were four new applications in 1905. Three of them were from relatively small companies that wanted to engage in deep-sea fishing as well as fishing in the fiords and rivers; they also wanted to buy fish from the Greenlanders and employ them in the industry. The fourth application was from the Consortium, a group of large Danish businesses also active in the Danish Atlantic Islands – and supported by some of the Greenlandic reformers. The Consortium would do it all: fishing, whaling, sheep rearing, reindeer breeding, eider ducks, and fox rearing for furs. The company wanted to employ Greenlanders. The Royal Trade Department firmly rejected these applications. The buying of fish from the Greenlanders and their employment with the interested companies would endanger the sealing making the population more dependent on European imported food. Furthermore, fishing might in time become an occupation for the Greenlanders, but letting these companies in would make it almost impossible for the Greenlanders to compete. The Trade Department considered the consortium’s proposed procedure for employing and paying their workers objectionable. Not only would the Consortium exploit the business opportunities in Greenland on a massive scale, but it also would change the Greenlanders into employees working for low salaries. The Trade Department predicted the extinction of the Greenlandic population if such enterprises were allowed. However, the Ministry wanted a second opinion, and referred the applications to Schultz-Lorentzen and Daugaard-Jensen. It wanted their opinion not only on the project but also on the maintenance of the state monopoly itself. Although the two referees wanted reforms in Greenland, they completely sup-
ported the Trade Department in rejecting the applications. As Schultz-Lorentzen bluntly put it, ‘the sole aim of private capital is to enrich itself at the expense of the Greenlandic population’.33 The unanimous rejection of the idea of breaking the Trade Department’s monopoly by the Ministry’s advisers effectively settled the case. Later in the year the Ministry set up a committee to look more closely into the Royal Trade Department, but the scope of revision was restricted with the statement that ‘the trade shall continue be a monopoly under the Crown’.34 The committee was composed of three wholesale merchants, two ship-owners and three civil servants. Its sole task was to examine the working of the Trade Department, and not surprisingly the majority of the private businessmen concluded that its expenses could be reduced. The civil servants, especially the director of the Royal Trade Department, expressed their scepticism at the realism of the suggested reduction. The committee’s report, completed in February 1908, had no relevance to the Governing Act, which had already been prepared for Parliament about January 1907. The bill was to a large extent an extension of DaugaardJensen’s proposal duly elaborated by the civil servants in the Ministry, the Trade Department and the inspectors. However, the Minister of the Interior, Sigurd Berg, had had no response from the guardians’ councils, so in the summer of 1907 he went to Greenland to confer with them in person. On 15 February 1908 the bill was at last presented to parliament where it got through easily, perhaps because it had been so thoroughly prepared over a long period, perhaps because everyone agreed with its main principles. The terms of the Act35 The Act concerning the Governing of the Colonies in Greenland became law on 27 May 1908. It definitively separated Trade from Administration. The Trade Department became a special division, headed by a trade manager who had direct access to the Minister, as had the director of the administration. This division, still bearing the name ‘the Royal Trade Department’, controlled the purchase of goods for Greenland,
33. Answer of February 1906 (Andersen 1979: 74). General on private enterprise, see Bro 1991. 34. Report 1908: 3. 35. The information is taken from ‘Rigsdagstidende’ publishing the minutes of the Danish Parliament, and from ‘Grønlands Landsråds Forhandlinger’ (LR), the minutes of the Greenland provincial councils.
27
YEARS OF REFORM 1900-1912
the sale of Greenlandic produce, trade inside Greenland, and transport to and from Greenland. The argument put forward for this separation from the administration was that with business experts to run it, the Trade Department would work more economically. On the other hand the task of administering Greenlandic society had become so complex that a special department was needed. In this way, it was asserted, the system would be best fitted to handle the Greenlanders’ interests. The business argument had its followers among wholesale dealers and shipowners and in the ranks of parliamentarians. It was equally appealing for those who wanted profits to go to the state as for those who wanted the Greenlanders to have them. The separation of trade from administration was the over-arching idea of the reforming civil servants who had long before raised this question in Greenland. It also had its supporters in Parliament, especially in the Radical Left Party and the Social Democrats. The Trade Department was not supposed to operate entirely independently in Greenland. The heads of the administration, the two inspectors, retained a supervisory role to ensure that the Department was run in a way that enabled the Greenlanders’ economy to thrive. The two inspectors should keep an eye on the Trade Department’s setting of prices, the setting-up of trading posts, and the volume of produce bought from the Greenlanders. In Copenhagen the director of the administration was responsible for the Trade Department in general. Thus the difference between the new system and the old was negligible. The desire to improve the trading economy was made explicit, but this was to be achieved by selling operations in Denmark, not by improving the local economy to the detriment of the Greenlanders. On the contrary, it was intended to make them better off. In economic terms the intention was to make Greenland self-sufficient. The Radical Left Party and the Social Democrats tried hard to incorporate in the act a guarantee that the Greenlandic population would benefit from any profit in Greenland, even from mining concessions. The majority of the internal Parliamentary committee agreed that any profits the Trade Department made should benefit Greenland, but those from mining were another matter. At the second reading in Parliament, the spokesman for the governing Liberal Left Party 28
maintained the view that the government and Parliament should be free to dispose of any profits which might come from for example a profitable gold mine. This is probably why the act stated only that the monopoly trade should be carried out at the state’s expense. Again, this is not greatly different from the earlier basis of economic policy. From the 1880s the state had run a deficit on Greenland, even allowing for the royalties from the cryolite mine. More radical changes appeared in the politicaladministrative structure. The guardians’ councils were abolished and their responsibilities divided between two new agencies: provincial councils and municipal councils; the latter had the task of administering poor relief and subsidies, and were also entitled to provide services for the common good in the municipality. The remainder of the revenue was to be distributed, as before, among the producers i.e. the hunters and fishermen. All in all, sixty municipalities were established on the West Coast, ranging from thirty to 360 inhabitants. The electoral system remained unchanged from the guardians’ councils, the franchise being restricted to heads of families who could elect only proficient or formerly proficient seal hunters. The Radical Left Party and Social Democrats tried in vain to introduce eligibility for males aged twenty-five and over, but the government stuck to the possibility of electing a proficient younger seal hunter and excluding an inferior older one. Thereafter, the Minister sought the views of the provincial councils before amendments to the proposals were made. The hearings took place in 1911-13, and the final decree of 16 June 1913 broadly incorporated the councils’ proposals bringing radical change. The voting age was fixed at twenty-two, and any man aged twenty-five who was subject to Greenlandic justice (see later) could stand for election regardless of occupation provided he had not received poor relief or been sentenced for a misdemeanour less than a year before the election. There were some deviations from the proposals of the provincial councils. In the North they had argued that receiving poor relief should not exclude a person from joining the electorate, and in the South they wanted the Greenlandic priests and senior catechists included, although they were subject to Danish justice. While the municipal councils continued the local administration of the guardians’ councils, greater
YEARS OF REFORM 1900-1912
responsibilities were assigned to the new provincial councils whose members were elected by the municipal councils. Qualifications were the same as for the municipal councils so no Danes were eligible. SchultzLorentzen was not pleased, but the Danish parliamentarians upheld Ryberg’s 1905 proposal. As the Minister of the Interior said in Parliament, ‘It is essential to know the Greenlanders’ opinion – the Danes can be reached through other channels’. Not surprisingly, at the first election all members were seal hunters except for three who had presumably retired from that occupation. The councils were to meet once a year to discuss matters of common concern for the province. Issues could be put on the agenda by the Danish government or the Greenland administration, or by the councils themselves as they pleased. However, the provincial councils had only an advisory function. The government had no obligation to hear the provincial councils before enacting laws concerning Greenland, but as the importance of the councils increased, the government generally sought their advice. Their decision-making powers were restricted to the funds in their care. There were three funds: the municipal funds, the provincial funds and the common fund. They were financed, as in previous years, by a charge of 20 per cent on the purchase price of Greenlandic produce for export paid by the Royal Trade Department. A new source was opened with the Act of 1908, which introduced a 2 per cent duty on all salaries paid to Greenlanders. The income from the charge and duty was divided among the three funds. The local municipal fund got two-thirds, the provincial fund two-ninths, and the common fund got the remaining one-ninth. The freedom of the provincial councils to decide how to spend their fund was limited. If the inspector agreed, they could support municipal funds that were in deficit, and reward capable hunters with loans for house-building and the purchase of rifles – like the former guardians’ councils. The Minister had to authorise any other use of the money and also controlled the common fund with the aim of benefiting the Greenlandic population in general. The provincial councils were entitled to suggest how the fund should be applied. We shall see later how the Greenlandic agencies spent the money. New structures were also introduced in the ad-
ministration of justice. From the beginning of colonisation in the eighteenth century, the incoming Danes had remained under Danish civil and criminal law, while the Greenlanders managed their justice as they had done since time immemorial. Little by little, the inspectors had taken over responsibility for dealing with serious criminal offences of Greenlanders such as murder and arson. However, civil law remained in the hands of the Greenlanders without interference from the Danish authorities. That system was continued in a modified form in the guardians’ councils, in which the Greenlandic members were to give their verdict before the Danish members had their say. Criminal offences were placed under the inspectors. However, the highest-ranking Greenlanders in the administration were placed under Danish laws. This dual system was recognised by the act of 1908 which placed all persons designated as of ‘Greenlandic nationality’ under Greenlandic justice except Greenlanders with high rank in the civil service who were appointed directly by the crown or the minister such as the colony managers and priests. The existence of separate systems of justice, for the colonisers and the colonised, in this case the Danes and the Greenlanders is a common feature of colonial empires. It is often considered discrimination against the natives. A closer look at the rules in Greenland will reveal whether this was indeed the case there.36 It was ruled that the municipal councils would decide cases concerning inheritance and the administration of a deceased Greenlander’s belongings, normally according to common Greenlandic custom. If considerable capital or goods were in question, an official division between the heirs should take place. If the deceased had been employed in public service, the inspector should participate in administering the estate – apparently, in order to secure the administration its outstanding debts. The inspector administered the estates of persons placed under Danish law, although his verdicts could be appealed to the Danish High Court. Both systems aimed to protect the interests of minors. The municipal council judged civil cases between Greenlanders in an ordinary trial, while the inspector, accompanied by two Danish lay judges, settled suits against persons under Danish law. If no settlement was
36. Kgl. Anordning vedr. Retsplejen i Grønland af 18/5-1910 in B&K 1910: 172.
29
YEARS OF REFORM 1900-1912
Fig. 5. The South Greenland Provincial Council in session for the first time in 1911. The gentleman in uniform is inspector Ole
Bendixen. Photo Arctic Institute.
reached, the case would be tried in Copenhagen. A mixed court would try civil cases between people belonging to different systems. Each colony district had a mixed court with the inspector as chairman, and two Danes and two Greenlanders as lay judges. It is not easy to say which system best served the interests of an injured party – e.g. how a Greenlandic malefactor’s treatment by the municipal council would compare with that of a mixed court. Systematic research of the years 1938 to 1948 has shown that the Greenlandic attitude of mind was more lenient to malefactors than a Danish court would have been37 so the injured party might have enjoyed better protection under Danish than Greenlandic law. Criminal law – which in Greenland covered all cases to which punishment was attached, was considerably milder under Greenlandic than under Danish law, especially where the severity of fines and the nature of other punishments was concerned. The municipal councils were authorised to fine the Green-
landers for offending against the rules set by the councils. Other cases against Greenlanders were brought before the mixed courts in which the Greenlandic members had to vote first, then the Danes, and finally the chairman. The inspector had to ensure the legality of the procedure, but there was also a right of appeal. Criminal offences were to be judged by the standards set for the guardians’ councils in 1872,38 which fall into three categories according to the sentence which could be imposed by the court: 1.
A fine of Dkr. 4 payable to the provincial fund and an indemnity to the person against whom an offence had taken place. This could be levied by the mixed courts for use without permission of property such as tools belonging to others, damaging such property, keeping another person’s catch of fish or seals without payment, taking into possession drift wood which somebody else had already dragged above the high tide mark.
37. Goldschmidt 1957. 38. Preliminary regulations of the Guardians’ Councils and their funding 31 January 1872 (Lovtidende 1872).
30
YEARS OF REFORM 1900-1912
Fig. 6. A municipal council meeting in Nuuk 1927. Every settlement over 100 inhabitants elected members to the municipal councils which at least should have 3 members. They wore a badge on the sleeve and an official cap outdoors because they also had certain police functions beside distributing poor relief and acting as court in dispute among Greenlanders. Photo Arctic Institute.
2.
3.
A fine of Dkr. 10 to the provincial fund and an indemnity to the victim. This could be imposed in a case of plain theft. Furthermore, a clear case of disobedience to the authorities and superiors was punishable by this penalty. With capital crimes the mixed courts would investigate the case, and refer it to the inspector. This would be the case with manslaughter cases and other serious crimes including clandestine childbirth.
enough to warrant imprisonment or dismissal from the civil service, the inspector acted in the capacity of examining judge, and judgment in the case was referred to Copenhagen. The intention was clearly that those subject to Danish law in Greenland should get more severe penalties than those under Greenlandic law, but whether this was in fact what happened is not clear.
The revision of 1912 The inspector could fine anybody placed under Danish law who broke the by-laws of the municipal councils, and he could increase the fines according to the parallel Danish rule and the offender’s financial position. The intention was that the impact of the fines on the Danes should be no less than on the Greenlanders. Only Danes could be charged with infringing the trade monopoly, there was no law forbidding the Greenlanders from bypassing the Trade Department in their sales, although they forfeited their right to ‘repartition’ if they did so. If a case against a Dane was serious
The passage of the 1908 act was expected to meet all Greenland’s needs. There was no one who did not have cause for satisfaction. The Greenlanders were taking a greater part in administration, and institutions had been set up to make their views known to the Danish political world. The Trade Department had been separated from civil administration, to some extent at least. Still, satisfaction was not universal. Schultz-Lorentzen continued to criticise both the exclusion of Danes from the Greenlandic councils and the amount 31
YEARS OF REFORM 1900-1912
of power exercised by the inspectors39 though his views were largely ignored, but the separation of the Trade Department and administration proved almost impossible. Because the Greenlanders’ interests were considered paramount, the administration was inevitably involved in all trade issues in the capacity of either decision-maker or adviser. Relations between Ryberg, the head of the administration, and the new head of the Trade, Oscar Wesche, were strained, and confusion began to appear. Although the inspectors and the health service were unquestionably under the direction of the administration, the colony managers and other staff had obligations to the Trade Department as well. In the case of contradictory orders, which was to be obeyed?40 The remedy was to re-shape the Act of 1908 and create a single command system for all Greenlandic issues. A single director was put in charge over all staff
39. Oldendow 1936: 129. 40. Oldendow 1936: 133. 41. The Act of 8 June 1912 (B&K 1912, 3: 340-42).
32
in all branches, including schools and churches. Over these matters the director would be answerable to the Minister for Church and Education, but in all other maters to the Minister of the Interior. Under the director a trade manager should buy and sell in Denmark and be advisor to the director on all trade matters. Apparently to mitigate the exclusion of Danes from the Greenlandic councils, the Danish civil servants in Greenland were allowed – singly or collectively – to make representations to the inspector on questions of general interest to Greenland or to themselves, and the Minister could allow them to meet officially for this purpose.41 After this peace reigned for a long time in matters concerning Greenland, partly because of the soundness of the act, and partly because Jens DaugaardJensen, who became director in 1912, had a special gift for getting things done smoothly.
The Daugaard-Jensen period, 1912-1940
These were quiet years for politics and administration. Management was centred on the Administration of Greenland (Grønlands Styrelse), which had complete overall control of the different services. The main fields were civil administration, trade, church and education, and health. There were also the Trade Department’s business in Denmark and transport to Greenland. The director held all the threads in his hands. It may seem as if Daugaard-Jensen enjoyed
absolute power, but the situation was not quite as it had been formerly. Parliament had become more watchful, and now the Greenlandic councils existed to voice Greenlandic opinion. Despite these limits the Administration continued to dominate in Greenland, and every aspect of its society. It controlled, it supported, and it saw to it that the tasks were carried out. There was a story in Greenland that when a little girl in school heard about baby Jesus being placed in a
Fig. 7. Director of the Greenland Administration Jens Daugaard-Jensen (1871-1938) in his office in Copenhagen in the 1920es.
He served in the Greenland administration all his life, started as an assistant in 1893 and became the inspector for Northern Greenland in 1900. 1912-1938 he was Director of the Administration of Greenland. His competence earned him respect and trust not least of the Greenlanders. He cautiously led the Greenlandic society into modern times and was one of the most important civil servants in twentieth century Greenland. Photo Arctic Institute.
33
THE DAUGAARD-JENSEN PERIOD, 1912-1940
Fig. 8. A Greenland halibut caught in western Greenland in the 1920es. The commercial halibut fishing in south Greenland took place in open sea. It started 1910 under Danish managers who towed the Greenlanders’ small boats to the fishing places to set the long lines. Photo Holger Dan Møller/ Arctic Institute.
manger, she cried out: ‘Why didn’t the Administration send a cradle?’ The almighty Administration was certainly a present reality.
Population growth and employment From the 1880s the population had grown steadily, and the growth became even more rapid in the first half of the new century as can be seen in table 4. The lower rate 1911-21 was in part due to the deadly influenza epidemic in the summer of 1919 which resulted in 249 deaths, and a reduction in the total population of 126 persons in that year. Note that the growth rate in Greenland was maintained after 1920 while decreasing in Denmark due to a decline in fertility. 34
Greenlandic occupation structure remained very stable until 1930, as is shown in table 5. Unfortunately there was no census between 1930 and 1945, so it is not possible to determine whether the shift in occupation apparent in 1945 took place in the 1930s or during the war. Among the Greenlandic occupations a marked shift to fishing took place. We will look into this issue later. The censuses reveal which positions Greenlanders held in European occupations. Table 6, unfortunately only up to 1930, shows that Greenlanders dominated the first four categories with relative fewer as foremen and skippers. Only three Danes were employed in this category in 1911, ten in 1930. Among the priests the Greenlanders grew to have a solid majority. Only at the highest-level was Greenlandic participation modest.
THE DAUGAARD-JENSEN PERIOD, 1912-1940
Fig. 9. Cod was the main catch. Piles of dried and salted cod in a fishery house in Paamiut 1919. Photo Jens Daugaard-
Jensen/Arctic Institute.
The proportion of Greenlanders in the different branches of colonial service is shown in 7. Significant changes occurred in administration and mining. The growth of Greenlandic employment here was due to a growing number of jobs in the Greenlandic councils and advances in communication. The opening of a coalmine at Qullissat in 1924 explains the growth in mining jobs. The difference in 1930 between the employed with or without families is simply due to the excess of young unmarried men among the Danes. These changes in employment structure were caused by changes in the economy between 1912 and 1940 to which we now turn.
Table 4. Population of Greenland 1901-38, except Thule, with
the Danish growth rate for comparison). * 1930-40.
Europeans 1901 1911 1921 1930 1938
262 382 266 399 383
Growth rate Greenlanders Greenland Denmark 11,190 12,510 13,401 15,345 16,970
1.12 0.69 1.52 1.27
1.190 1.190 0.930 0.80*
Change in the Economy Between the wars Greenland experienced a shift from an age-old subsistence economy to a modern fishing
Table 5. Greenlanders by occupation 1911-1945, %. * Family
included. 1911 European occupations Administration 2.9 Trade 6.3 Church and education 6.0 Other 0.6 Total 13.8 Greenlandic occupations Hunters 73.0 Fishermen 11.1 Other 0.1 Total 84.2 Numbers employed 2,902
1921
1930
1930*
1945*
3.6 7.7
2.9 7.4
1.8 8.6
2.3 18.0
6.3 0.7 18.2
4.3 1.7 16.2
5.1 1.2 16.8
6.5 7.1 33.9
66.5 15.1 0.2 81.8
49.0 32.0 2.8 83.8
n.a. n.a. n.a. 83.2
41.6 20.1 4.4 66.1
3,154
4,139
15,32
16,457
35
THE DAUGAARD-JENSEN PERIOD, 1912-1940
Diagram 2. Seal catch 1887-1934 West
9
Greenland per inhabitant. 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 1887
1892
1897
1902
1907
1912
1917
1922
economy, a shift which had been seen earlier in other parts of the North Atlantic. In the later 19th century Iceland and the Faroe Islands shifted from a predominantly agrarian society to sea fishing as the main economic activity. In Greenland the shift from a hunting society was in many ways a greater leap. In none of the three places did changes occur overnight, but in Greenland they were certainly very rapid. Let us look at the details. Sealing declined from about 1910 from an annual level of eight seals per inhabitant to barely five in 1934 as can be seen in diagram 2. Fortunately, and certainly related to the decline in the seal catch, there was an expansion in two new industries: fishing and sheep-breeding. Fishery Even minute changes in the climate have a profound impact on a society at the margin of habitation such as Greenland throughout its history. From drilling of the ice core it can be deduced that the Norse immigration took place towards the end of a mild period with average temperatures of a half degree Celsius above those at the end of the twentieth century. The Norse disappearance took place during a cold period which reached its lowest point around 1350 with an average temperature of two degrees Celsius below our times. About 1700 the average temperature rose by one degree, and renewed colonisation took place. It continued in spite of a slight fall of a half degree till 1900 when a new warmer period began.42 From about 1870 the temperature has been recorded on a regular basis, 36
1927
1932
Table 6. Proportion of Greenlanders in European occupations
1911-30, mining excluded.
Catechists Crew Midwives Artisans Foremen and skippers Trading post managers Priests Colony manager and manager assistants Proportion of Greenlanders in European occupations Number in European occupations (Greenlanders and Danes
1911
1921
1930
100 100 99 94 96 78 18
100 100 99 98 90 85 71
97 100 100 93 76 83 77
9
4
6
87
91
84
508
616
728
Table 7. Proportion of Greenlanders in colonial service, 1911-
45. * Family included. ** Administration and health service combined.
Administration Health service Trade Church, education Mining and similar Overall proportion Overall number (Greenlanders and Danes)
1911
1921
1930
30 90 83 95 8 65
80 90 87 98 14 75
57 84 83 96 30 72
83+ 91 97 52 86
702
763
932
2,958
42. Dansgaard 1975: 72.
1930* 1945* 63 88 95 91 85 91
6,126
THE DAUGAARD-JENSEN PERIOD, 1912-1940
Diagram 3. Variations in Surface
Temperature (degrees Celsius). Variations April-September in West Greenland between Paamiut and Disko, 5-year deviation from average, 1876-1915 (TG Grønland 1965: 400).
and its precise development can be plotted as in diagram 3. The decisive change in temperature began in 1916 and reached an all-time peak about 1930. How many fish this change brought into the Greenlandic waters cannot be known, but the catch rose explosively. In diagram 4 the value of the fish catch is set against that of the traditional hunting products. These statistics record the amount brought to Denmark during a calendar year and therefore differ slightly from annual figures from Greenland, which are reckoned in fiscal years (April – March). Obviously the main trends are the same. Fishery products rose
steadily from an insignificant beginning in 1915 to a peak in 1930, intersecting the curve for hunting products in 1923. The change from seal hunting to fishing was most marked in the South, and had weightier consequences than a mere exchange from the rifle and harpoon to the fishing line. Boats were needed as well as landbased factories to process the fish, which in those days meant producing salted fish. The number of wooden boats owned by Greenlanders rose rapidly from 157 in 1900 to 287 in 1920, and 1,471 in 1935. Soon the first motorboats owned by Greenlanders made their appearance. In 1925 there were only two, eight in 1929,
1800000 1600000 1400000 1200000 1000000 800000 600000 400000 200000
Diagram 4. Greenland exports by value,
DKK (Danish Statistical Yearbook).
19 05 19 07 19 09 19 11 19 13 19 15 19 17 19 19 19 21 19 23 19 25 19 27 19 29 19 31 19 33 19 35 19 37 19 39
0
Hunting
Fishing
Other
37
THE DAUGAARD-JENSEN PERIOD, 1912-1940
Table 8. Building of fish processing plants in Greenland 19101939 (SSOG-46: table 196).
1910-14 1915-19 1920-24 1925-29 1930-34 1935-39
Plants built
m2
total m2
11 3 24 21 52 14
725 129 1506 1077 3144 1104
725 854 2360 3427 6571 7675
thirty-eight in 1934, and in 1939 seventy-two. Some were paid for in cash, but most were financed by loans from the administration. The building and operation of the fish processing plants were tasks for the administration. The Greenlanders themselves had no experience of running a fishing industry and had no capital to invest. During the years 1910-39 125 fishing plants were built, a development shown in table 8. These figures show a rise in processing capacity, but we cannot be certain whether it met the actual needs. The south provincial council was constantly asking for longer opening hours and additional buildings. The change to fishery could explain the migration from the smallest settlements to the bigger ones, which took place in this period, but there must be or have been other factors as well since the phenomenon also occurred in North Greenland where fishing was still a supplementary occupation. Sheep breeding43 Only in the southern part of Greenland, that is the district of Qaqortoq (Julianehåb), did climatic conditions allow a significant amount of animal husbandry. As
has been mentioned, in 1906 the priest at Narsaq Kujalleq (south of Nanortalik), Jens Chemnitz, gave it a try using sheep from the Faroe Islands, and systematic breeding began in the state breeding stations in 1913-1915. With the milder climate the herds grew steadily. In 1915 there were only 200 sheep, 2,000 in 1926, 5,000 in 1929, and about 10,000 in 1936. Then came two hard winters, which reduced the flocks to 7,000. The number of sheep farmers also increased. During the 1920s they numbered 100, and shortly before the Second World War 200; however, only about fifty had sheep rearing as their main business. Thus in the overall economy sheep-farming was of minor importance, except in Qaqortoq district, which was hardest hit by the dwindling of the seal stock; there sheep-farming also led to a dispersion of settlements because conditions for sheep farming were most advantageous deep in the fiord lands, while sealing was most promising at the outer coast. The meat produced – between 22 and 48 tons a year – was mainly sold in Greenland to the quarry at Ivittuut and to ocean-going ships. The rest was sold in Denmark in widely varying quantities. As a new occupation sheep farming certainly had the attention of the administration and the provincial councils. The latter offered loans for building of sheepcotes (1920), and in 1925 they ruled that sheep farmers could share the so-called repartition, which originally was meant for seal hunters. This gesture was a vindication of the new occupations in the ongoing debate between the Greenlanders about who counted as a real Greenlander. This topic will be dealt with below. By 1936 sheep were so numerous that marking was made compulsory.
Table 9. Settlements by size of population (SSOG-46: table 21).
<50 1886 1901 1921 1938
23 56 46 30
North Greenland 51-200 >200 39 38 45 46
0 1 3 7
Total
<50
62 95 94 83
34 44 31 29
South Greenland 51-200 >200 39 38 43 40
4 4 7 11
Total Total 77 86 81 80
139 181 175 163
43. SSOG-46: section 9; Sigurdsson 1938; Walsøe 1936; Christensen 1946; G-50 5, I: 124-38; Minutes from the Provincial Councils 1911-35.
38
THE DAUGAARD-JENSEN PERIOD, 1912-1940
Diagram 5. Greenlanders’ income from
sales to the Trade Department (actual prices) (SSOG-46 table 282).
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0 1899
1904
Other social developments The shift in basic economic activity had an impact on many parts of society. The modernisation and Europeanisation of society might have happened anyway, but there can be no doubt that the decline of sealing and the growth of fishing speeded the process. The money economy became ever more dominant. Public statistics cannot show every aspect of that process, but the development in money income from the trading-in of Greenlandic products can be shown, see diagram 5. Clearly visible is the distinct rise in the 1920s, when the money income from trading-in more than doubled. This diagram understates the money actually in circulation, because besides trading-in, the Greenlanders earned money from sales to private citizens and from salaries. The distribution of different kinds of money
1909
1914
1919
1924
1929
1934
1939
income has been calculated for some districts. Table 10 shows one from Disko Bay (Qasigiannguit) and another from South Greenland (Qaqortoq). Seen over these thirty-eight years a shift of 10 per cent of income from trading-in to wages is significant, but not dramatic. The selling of Greenlandic products – fish and seals – still counted for over one-third of the income. The increased money income was used for investment in businesses, building houses, and the purchase of imported food – necessary to compensate for the decline in sealing. From 1901 to 1930 the number of dwelling-houses grew from 1,503 to 2,525, proportionately more than the increase in population. Thus the number of inhabitants per house was declining, namely from 7.5 in 1901 to 6.1 in 1930,44 resulting in more space per person.45 In addition domestic heating was improved since almost all the Greenlanders’
Table 10. Distribution of money income by kind among the Greenlanders (SSOG-46: tables 444-5).
1899-1904 1910-14 1920-24 1930-1934 1935-38
Wages
Qaqortoq district Trading-in
Miscell.
Wages
Qasigiannguit district Trading-in
Miscell.
40.9 46.4 51.0 41.8 50.0
48.6 43.2 40.7 46.6 36.2
10.5 10.4 8.3 11.6 13.8
42.3 40.3 46.3 44.7 52.1
48,6 51.2 45.5 45.1 38.2
9.1 8.5 8.2 10.2 9,7
44. SSOG-46: table 31. 45. SSSOG-46: table 35, 36.
39
THE DAUGAARD-JENSEN PERIOD, 1912-1940
Table 11. Lending from the Greenlandic funds to house build-
ing and business equipment (SSOG-46: table 63).
1915-26 1927-31 1932-36
House building (%)
Business equipment (%)
Total Dkr
68.4 86.4 86.4
31.6 13.6 13.6
32,272 164,553 234,464
Table 12. Health sector in Greenland (SSOG-46: tables 41, 42).
* 1900.
1910 1930 1935
Expenses Dkr
Doctors
85,186 314,239 393,459
7 10 10
Nurses Midwives
4 11 16
84 100 112
Beds
*30 240 325
houses were fitted with stoves. Thus some of the increased cash income was used to improve living conditions. To a large extent the money for houses and business equipment was borrowed from Greenlandic funds which, as mentioned earlier, were generated from the Trade, so in a sense their source would be Greenlandic production at least if there was a trade surplus overall. This had not in fact been the case since 1885 except for some years during the First World War. From 1935, however surpluses were produced by the increased demand for cryolite used for making aluminium, which in turn was used for building aircraft. The earlier deficit was made up by the Danish treasury, but carefully recorded so that Greenland could repay it should that ever be possible. In those days balancing the government budget was a virtue also where colonies and dependencies were concerned. No state financing of economic activities in those areas was intended, but in Greenland it happened by default. Most of the lending from the Greenlandic funds was for house building, as shown in table 11. The improvement in housing conditions should have benefited health, but expenses also grew in the expanding health sector. It appears that this expenditure was not related only to health conditions and 46. SSSOG-46: table 330. 47. SSSOG-46: table 456.
40
needs, but followed an overall expansion of the economy. Compared to Denmark, Greenland had more midwives and hospital beds but fewer nurses. The ratio of doctors was similar. No clear picture of the health of the population emerges from the figures. The differences between Denmark and Greenland were too great for any valid comparison to be made. The general opinions aired in contemporary sources were that there was more disease in Greenland than in Denmark, and that the health service was less comprehensive, partly at least due to the vast distances between settlements in Greenland. The change to fishing resulted in a greater trade in goods with the outside world. The decline in the huge amounts of meat from sealing necessitated increased food imports. Diagram 6 shows the two kinds of food for which demand rose in that period. This development had profound implications. The daily sugar intake per person had grown from 12.5 grams in 1899 to 98.8 grams in 1938. In spite of this increase of 700 % it was still some 15 kilos a year less than Danish consumption. Likewise daily consumption of cereals and beans rose from 66.3 grams to 162.2 grams in 1938. Seen in terms of bread it corresponded to an increase from two to five slices daily.46 The proportion of imported food consumed by the Greenlanders has been calculated. In 1910-15 imported food accounted for 22%, in 1915-20 for 24%, and in 1930-5 for 50%.47 Individual consumption of other imported goods rose too: clothes, wood products, fuel, ironware and tools, while goods such as coffee, tea and tobacco were in constant demand. This increased trade demanded a corresponding increase in internal transport capacity. More numerous and heavier coastal freighters were used. The total of register tonnage rose from 466 in 1900 to 1,487 in 1938. Because motor power replaced sails at the same time, the quicker voyages meant a significant expansion in transport capacity above the growth in tonnage. Transatlantic freighters also replaced sails with motors, which reduced voyage time. The average transit time for Copenhagen – Greenland – Copenhagen in 1900 was ninety-nine days; in 1938 it had dropped to fifty-eight. The number of ocean freighters was nearly
THE DAUGAARD-JENSEN PERIOD, 1912-1940
Diagram 6. Consumption in Greenland
of imported food per inhabitant (SSOG-46, Table 315, 329).
80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10
18 99 19 01 19 03 19 05 19 07 19 09 19 11 19 13 19 15 19 17 19 19 19 21 19 23 19 25 19 27 19 29 19 31 19 33 19 35 19 37
0
cereals
the same, but thanks to the higher speeds more trips could be made in a year. Thus the transatlantic tonnage capacity rose from 5,576 in 1900 to 9,998 in 1920 and 25,480 in 1930.48 Not only did transport of goods across the Atlantic increase but other forms of communication rose as well. The number of letters sent to Greenland in 1900 was 3,297, but it had risen to 14,100 by 1930 and to 25,350 by 1939.49 Wireless telegraphy was introduced in 1925 with three stations (Qeqertarsuaq, Nuuk and Qaqortoq). By 1939 there were twenty-seven stations all over Greenland. The transmitting station was Qaqortoq from where the traffic was cabled to Reykjavik in Iceland and thence to Copenhagen. Already in 1927 a short-wave transmitter in Qaqortoq could send the traffic all the way to Copenhagen; the number of telegrams rose from 300 in 1925 to 6,500 in 1930 and 13,000 in 1939.50 Thus a tremendous change had taken place before the Second World War so Greenland was in no way an untouched aboriginal society. Commercial fishing had largely overtaken hunting as the primary occupation of the people, and this involved a much greater trading relationship with the outer world at large, and an expansion of the internal structure of society. Even if
sugar
some of these developments might have taken place anyway, it is fair to conclude that the decline in the stock of seals and the arrival of a huge quantity of fish precipitated the modernisation of Greenlandic society in this period.
Cultural Developments The Greenlandic debate51 At the beginning of the twentieth century Greenlanders began to discuss the future of their country and their own role in the process. This could have been in reaction to Danish discussions of the question or to the changes taken place in Greenlandic society. In their monthly periodical from 1861 they had encouraged each other to be more industrious as seal hunters, more skilful in rowing kayak and more far-sighted in storing enough of the catch to last through the winter. The perspective was clearly that they depended on the seals – but could use fish as a supplement when sealing produced insufficient catches. By the turn of the century when fish became a product to be traded-in, a fierce debate took place between defenders of traditional sealing and advo-
48. SSSOG-46: table 72a, 72b. 49. SSSOG-46: table 199. 50. SSSOG-46: table 211. Radiotelegraphy was already in use in the cryolite mine at Ivittuut and in Ammassalik in 1924. 51. Since the 1980s, scholars at Ilisimartusarfik (the University of Greenland) have researched texts printed in Greenlandic, especially the newspaper Atuagagdliutit from 1861 and Avangnâmioq (the northern magazine) from 1913. Their publications enable non-Greenlandic readers to get an impression of what was going on among the Greenlanders.
41
THE DAUGAARD-JENSEN PERIOD, 1912-1940
cates of new ways. The strong feelings stemmed from the fact that sealing was a core element in their selfidentification as Greenlanders: a good Greenlander was a good Christian and a good hunter. When hunting from kayaks the Greenlanders greatly excelled the Europeans, who for their part encouraged the Greenlanders to achieve excellence in hunting because its products were what kept the society in being.52 The traditionalists maintained that fishing could be no more than supplementary because fish could not provide them with the hides with which they covered their kayaks and umiaks, while the advocates of new ways argued that with a dwindling stock of seals the society would die out if nothing else could be found. If other nations could subsist on fish, so could the Greenlanders. The debate on national self-consciousness was fed by another stream. The group of Greenlanders with European occupations: employees in the trade, the church, and the school system had hitherto supported the traditional view that a real Greenlander was a seal hunter, but now some of them opposed the idea that seal hunting should be the test for being a true Greenlander. A more modern notion of nationalism was expressed, based on common language, history and love of country.53 Clearly a new group of people was fighting for its right to a place in society. Peqatigiinniat The sense of a new era dawning also stimulated the setting up of Greenlandic organisations notably with the founding of the Peqatigiinniat association in 1908.54 Its roots were mainly Christian, its stated purpose to promote a Christian way of life in togetherness and induce others to do the same. This was clearly
inspired by contemporary revivalist movements in Denmark: while the Greenlanders took the initiative and called the meetings, they were supported by the Danish missionaries, not least Schultz-Lorentzen who in 1908 reported to friends in Denmark the happy news that a true revivalist movement had been founded.55 The revivalist trend was not the only one in Peqatigiinniat. Concern for this world was a constituent part of the movement. If any outside influence for this is to be found it may be the Folk High School movement in Denmark based on the ideas of the priest, poet, and parliamentarian, N.F.S. Grundtvig, who argued that a true and industrious human life was a prerequisite condition to a true Christian one.56 Certainly, the strong national tone in Grundtvig’s writings is to be found also in Peqatigiinniat, but as a Greenlandic one. The Greenlandic parallel to the songbook of the Danish Folk High School from 1908, Erinarsuutit, did contain Christian as well as patriotic songs that praised the country, and which are still regarded as the heart of Greenlandic song. The outstanding contributors were Jonathan Petersen in Nuuk and Henrik Lund in Narsaq, who wrote a national anthem. Its last verse was: It is no longer good to hold oneself back Kalaallit, arise and go forward! A human life is to be valued; Start believing in what you can do for yourselves.57 The movement spread along the coast from Qaqortoq in the south to Disko Bay, but it did not reach the northern districts of Uummannaq and Upernavik due to lack of interest among the local missionaries,58 or the East Coast and the Qaanaaq area.
52. Langgård 1999: 40-50. 53. Langgård 1999: 57. 54. The association in Nuuk was initiated on 13 March 1908, the date most often cited as the starting point (Thuesen 1988: 90). However, a similar association was formed on 7 September 1907 in Maniitsoq (Petersen 1990: 107), and already in 1906 enlightening meetings in the parish of Narsaq Kujatdleq were summoned under the name ‘peqatigiinniat’ (Langgård 1998: 16). Even if ‘peqatigiinniat’ literally means association, the term was only used for this kind of organisation. For other meetings and organizations other words were used. The reason why the Nuuk initiative is seen as the starting point may be that it alone aimed to spread the idea to other parts of Greenland. 55. Thuesen 1988: 87. 56. Langgård (1999: 52) points to this. 57. Translated by the author. The Greenlanders were often reproached for their ‘self-restraint’ by the more audacious among them. 58. Thuesen 1988: 98f.
42
THE DAUGAARD-JENSEN PERIOD, 1912-1940
Fig. 10. Teaching at the small settlement Saqqarliit in 1936. Judged from the altar in the background the room also served as church.. Photo Jette Bang/Arctic Institute.
In the beginning there were weekly meetings with prayer and Bible reading, but there were also talks on how to improve the material conditions of life. Members visited the sick, collected funds for church building, and arranged great summer meetings, 600 people gathered at Ilulissat in 1912 to hear the Gospel and speeches about the need for material progress.59 Peqatigiinniat still exists in some places, but it lost its momentum in the 1920s. Its significance lay in its ability to gather native citizens around the idea of progressing in the same direction as other civilised countries. Such movements are a common feature in all colonial societies. Schools Education is the key to progress, and the spokesmen for the Greenlanders repeatedly pressed for teachers in Greenland to be qualified. Over the period 1900-40 the number of school and church staff developed as shown in table 13. Clear trends were that Greenlandic preachers took over from the Danish ones, that Danish and Greenlandic teachers trained in Denmark began to arrive,
and that the number of catechists without education decreased. There was also an increase in the number of people whom the preachers and teachers had to
Table 13. School and church staff in Western Greenland, 191037 (SSOG-46: table 394, 399, 404). * 1921.
1910
1920
1930
1937
Danish priests and qualified preachers 12 7 5 6 Greenlandic priest and qualified catechists 4 10 12 13 Danish teachers 0 0 4 9 Greenlandic teachers 0 0 3 4 Catechists (educated at college) 45 60 68 69 Catechists (educated otherwise) 52 49 56 78 Catechists (without education) 83 62 46 45 Total 196 188 194 224 Children attending school 2,67 2,870* 2,64 3,345 Population 12,486 13,474* 15,527 16,917
59. Petersen 1990: 114.
43
THE DAUGAARD-JENSEN PERIOD, 1912-1940
serve. In 1910 there were 14.8 children per teacher and 63.7 people per preacher, and in 1937 these numbers had increased respectively to 16.3 and 83.3. The school curricula were expanded. More hours were devoted to reading and writing, also to scripture, history and science. A novelty in this period was the teaching of Danish: beginning in the 1920s it rose sharply until the war – according to the rural dean this was more a sign of growing popular interest, rather than the teachers’ ability and facility in the language.60 Teaching Danish in the schools The growing interest in the teaching of Danish in the Greenlandic schools may seem at odds with the nascent pre-nationalism of that period, but clearly the Greenlanders’ nationalism was not directed against their colonial masters the Danes, whom they viewed as friends dedicated to furthering their progress. Indeed this was the official policy, and the Danes with whom the Greenlanders came in contact were civil servants sent to Greenland to implement that policy, and those they met in Denmark mostly held similar views. At the teacher training college Danish had always been taught as a means of gaining access to a bigger literature and wider horizons of knowledge, and that was exactly why Greenlandic parents now wanted their children to learn Danish: they should be equipped to cope with the new times ahead. Furthermore, because the upper layer of society in Greenland consisted of Danes, a Greenlander would feel more important knowing their language. This was the view of an experienced observer, the later rural dean Aage Bugge a Dane born and raised in Greenland.61 Introducing the Danish language in Greenland had never been part of official policy, partly because of the missionary aim to reach souls using their own language, and partly also because of the practical obstacles. And there was no need to learn Danish as long as the main goal was the preservation of a traditional, high-producing seal economy. With the introduction of a more diversified economy and the need to learn new occupations brought in from abroad the choice
60. B&K 1934: 212. 61. Bugge 1931: 5-19. 62. See among others Plamenatz 1973. 63. Bugge 1931: 10f. 64. LR-N 1919 in B&K 1920: 318.
44
was either to translate everything into Greenlandic or to use the working language associated with the innovations. This is the core problem where the modernisation of a traditional society is concerned. It is well known for example from the spread of industrialisation in eastern Europe that the better the Czechs mastered the German language the better they could manage in the new machine age. This development produced in response a more vigorous Czech nationalism to preserve the national identity.62 A similar development took place in Greenland, but not until several decades after the Second World War. For the time being the Greenlanders chose Danish as the instrument of their own progress. Already in 1914 Mathias Storch, later (1927) rural dean in North Greenland advocated to his colleagues in the church that Danes should be employed as teachers, but he did not gain support for this proposal. In 1919 the suggestion was carried through the convention,63 and the reluctant Danes became convinced that this was actually the wish of the Greenlanders. The question was also raised in the provincial councils (see below). A member from the north deplored in 1919 that the Danish priest had left because this had resulted in a deterioration of the children’s knowledge of Danish.64 Against this background it was natural for the committee which was to prepare a revision of the governing law for Greenland in 1920 unanimously to recommend the introduction of Danish as a subject in Greenlandic schools. The committee stated the purpose of the policy was to develop the Greenlanders’ moral and economic maturity to the point where they would be able to live in free communication with the rest of the world once the present state of isolation had come to an end. They believed that to achieve this end it was essential to attach Greenland as closely as possible to Denmark and bring Danish civilisation and culture to the country. This was their reason for supporting the teaching of Danish in Greenland. The ethnocentricity of their language was not uncommon at a time when the idea of ‘the white man’s burden’ still lingered on, but it was
THE DAUGAARD-JENSEN PERIOD, 1912-1940
indicative of the general mood among the Greenlanders that the proposal was also supported by the few of them on the committee. The reading of the bill in Parliament took place in 1923 and the Liberal Left, the Social Democrats and the Conservatives were supportive, stressing that the introduction of Danish was the wish of the Greenlanders. The degree of emphasis on the benefit to them and the assurance that such a move could give for the attachment of Greenland to Denmark in the future varied among the members. The spokesman for the Liberal Left Party, J.C. Vanggaard, stated unequivocally that the Greenlanders should be made as Danish as possible so that the country could later be opened up without the danger of losing it. The Radical Left expressed fears that compulsory teaching in Danish would offend the nascent national movement in Greenland, and remained unconvinced by the minister’s assurance that it was the Greenlanders’ own wish.65 Due to other circumstances the bill was postponed in 1923 and a parliamentary delegation travelled to Greenland to meet the two provincial councils and a number of municipal councils to seek the views of the Greenlanders. Doubts as to the reality of the demand to make Danish a subject in their schools were made clear by the fact that the delegation asked this same question in all its consultations. Everywhere the Greenlanders strongly supported Danish-language teaching.66 This closed the issue. At the next reading of the bill in Parliament in January 1925 support for compulsory teaching of Danish in Greenland was total. Compulsion was not an issue. The subject was so highly esteemed in Greenland that all children who had the opportunity participated.67 On the same occasion in 1925 compulsory school attendance was introduced for all children aged between seven and fourteen as in Denmark. Until then children in Greenland had started to attend school as soon as they wanted it, often much earlier than seven, and continued till their confirmation which was often
after the age of fourteen. Thus, the change had the peculiar result of reducing the number of pupils. In 1921 the percentage of children aged between five and fourteen attending school was 78.9, but in 1930 it had dropped to 68.7.68 In this matter the Danish politicians could be sure that they were on solid ground. Not only was the bill carried through Parliament unanimously, but all social levels in Greenland were also in favour. Further assurance could be found in the speech, which the explorer and writer Knud Rasmussen gave before Parliament in February 1925 having just completed his famous fifth Thule expedition from Greenland through the Inuit areas of North America which had won him tremendous acclaim. He reported the positive experience in Alaska where English had been the compulsory medium since 1890. He subscribed to the American view that only by letting the Eskimos slip into the ruling culture could they have a chance of survival.69 The years up to the Second World War saw no change of public opinion in Greenland in this matter – indeed the Greenlandic politicians pressed for improvement in the teaching of Danish. In 1935 the ministry tried to conciliate by describing the goal as leading the children to read, speak and write Danish.70 However, the problem was not the zeal for education but finding qualified teachers. Therefore in 1937 Pastor G. Egede suggested in the provincial council that the teaching of Danish should be expanded by sending more teachers from Denmark to Greenland. This was agreed,71 but the following year the ministry answered that the results of the ongoing teaching should first be evaluated, and that Danish teachers would have trouble in teaching Greenlandic children who only understood Greenlandic. But Pastor Egede was determined and raised the question again; once more the provincial council supported him unanimously arguing it was necessary beyond any doubt to learn Danish as a link to the outside world, and because Danish is a cultural language. (probably
65. RTFF 1922-23: 2762-3958. 66. Vanggaard 1923: 27, 31, 36, 42, 52, 57, 60, 61, 71 and 90. The message was repeated in Parliament on 27 January 1925 (RTFF 1924-25: 4080 ff). 67. Aage Bugge (1926: 44). 68. Aage Bugge in his report for 1933/4 in B&K 1935: 464; SSOG-46: tables 22, 404. 69. Rasmussen 1925: 5. 70. Decree of 24 May 1935 §11 (B&K 1935: 586). 71. LR-S 1938: 9.
45
THE DAUGAARD-JENSEN PERIOD, 1912-1940
Fig. 11. The Danish King Christian X visited Nuuk in 1921 to celebrate the 200 years anniversary of Danish rule. He is saluting women wearing their finest dresses. Photo Harald Lindow/Arctic Institute.
meaning that it is a vehicle for art and science). It was impossible to take the Greenlanders back to their traditional stage, and that was why the endeavour should be to make them capable of competing with other nations.72 The ministry gave in and in 1939 announced that it would try to get more Danish teachers to Greenland.73 Similar examples of seeking new goals were to be found in other aspects of Greenland’s cultural life. In 1930 Pastor Mathias Storch published a novel, ‘Strejflys over Grønland’ (Gleam of Light over Greenland), in which a single provincial council speaking for the whole of Greenland, and Greenlandic representation in the Danish Parliament were envisaged. Through education and cooperation with the Danes the Greenlanders should become capable of having an open
72. LR-S 1938: 35. 73. LR-S 1939: 101. 74. Bugge 1931: 6.
46
economy in free communication with the outside world. In 1931 Augo Lynge, later a prominent politician, published a book ‘Ukiut 300-nngornerat’ (300 years after) which foresaw a modern Greenland with factories and a deep sea fishing fleet working in friendly cooperation with Danes. Thus there is no doubt that the Greenlandic elite was much in favour of a modernised Greenland, and saw assimilation with Denmark and the Danish language as the only possible way forward. To what extent the common Greenlander shared this view cannot now be determined. There is no evidence that the spokesmen lacked support. Aage Bugge wrote in 1931 that the passive incomprehension of the introduction of Danish teaching, which could be felt at times in certain circles, was definitely on the way out.74
THE DAUGAARD-JENSEN PERIOD, 1912-1940
Political Development Provincial councils The role in society of the provincial councils which were set up in 1911, and the exact nature of their cooperation with the authorities in Denmark have not yet been systematically analysed. In 1936 Knud Oldendow (the office head of the Greenland administration) wrote a survey for the councils’ twenty-fifth anniversary. Considering his position and the occasion for writing it, the book has virtues. It carefully characterises the inspectors and governors and conveys the nature of the issues debated; most of them are raised by the authorities but others raised by the members. Oldendow implies cautiously that the inspectors/ governors should be credited with the smooth running of the councils. The trend over time is a growing capability on the members’ part to use the councils to promote development in Greenland. This observation was later confirmed by counting the issues raised by members compared to those put before the councils by the authorities. Research into the minutes of the periods 1911-16 and 1934-8 reveals that whereas 37% of the issues raised by the members in the first period concerned Greenland as a whole, as many as 72% fell into that category in the second period. Table 14 indicates that a smooth development had taken place between the periods. The minutes also reveal the occupational balance of the members (Table 15). The replacement of hunters by employees, especially catechists, is obvious. Other self-employed occupations apart from hunting were only represented in the southern provincial council – by a carpenter and a writer. It was usual for nearly all members to be replaced at each election. This could hardly be explained by dissatisfaction on the part of the electorate since it had no direct vote. The election committees were quite small – rarely with more than ten members, so the high rate of replacement is likely to mean that membership was seen by the election committees’ members as a rotating duty. Some individual cases may illustrate certain aspects of the work in these councils. In 1911 the administration put a number of issues before the councils to be added to a newly ratified act toget-
Table 14. Issues raised in the Provincial Councils by members, % (SSOG-46: table 57).
1911-15 1916-20 1921-5 1926-30 1930-5
16.8 % 23.3 % 36.1 % 43.1 % 60.6 %
Table 15. Provincial council members by occupation, 1911-39.
1911 Self employed Hunters 17 Others – Employed Church and school 5 Trade and crafts – Others 1
1917
1923
1927
1933 1939
18 –
10 –
7 1
9 –
4 2
2 3 –
6 5 2
8 5 2
8 2 4
6 8 3
her with some other cases in which Copenhagen wanted rules that would apply in the whole of Greenland. Reaching a decision took a considerable time because if the two councils reached different opinions, the administration in Copenhagen would send them back to get agreement. The provincial councils were very reluctant to yield to each other’s opinions, so in some cases different rules were issued for the North and the South. Typical cases were those about where Greenlanders were allowed to build houses, and the question of who could benefit from the repartition of common funds.75 Some issues raised in 1911 were not resolved till 1916. The inspector for North Greenland wanted to introduce rules laying down which municipality had the responsibility of paying poor relief when individuals moved between municipalities, and laying an obligation on a house holder to maintain those living his house. A member in the North Greenland provincial council suggested that the municipalities should be permitted to pay an allowance to members for attending meetings, and although the inspector regarded the suggestion as unreasonable, the matter was pursued in the following years, and was finally accepted in 1916.76 Most of the rules common to the whole of Greenland, which arose from the discussions in the provin-
75. B&K 1913-17: 50, 140, 232, 234. 76. B&K 1916: 410.
47
THE DAUGAARD-JENSEN PERIOD, 1912-1940
cial councils, came from their own initiatives. If north and south agreed, the ministry would often simply implement the agreement, such as the order of 22 July 1914 on the handling of firearms.77 In other cases the final rules represented a blend of northern and southern views, such as the all-important possibility of lending funds for the construction and purchase of more expensive equipment.78 Even when issues were put before the councils by the administration in Denmark, the councils did not automatically accept suggestions. When the inspector in Nuuk suggested that borrowers should pay 4% interest on loans, all members strongly disagreed and argued that loans should be interest-free. On top of that, it was agreed that if borrowers’ repayments were regular, they should have their debt reduced by 4% of the repayment. If this was not a special Greenlandic understanding of the idea of interest, it was certainly consistent with the age-old Danish way of disciplining the Greenlanders: not by punishing failure to follow rules, but by rewarding compliance. The final rules allowed interest-free loans, but did not include a reward for prompt repayment.79 Most of the issues raised by the members concerned minor improvements in everyday life like the ability (1913) to buy petroleum for hunting expeditions, and the idea (1914) of teaching orphans and the children of civil servants in kayak rowing at public expense.80 But certain issues caused a loud and clear protest to be delivered to the government in Copenhagen. In 1924 Denmark agreed to let Norwegians hunt in the uninhabited areas of East Greenland, but although East Greenland did not come within the jurisdiction of the provincial councils both addressed the matter in the same year. They were outraged because they assumed it would damage their own hunting, and because they had heard nothing about the agreement with Norway before it came into force. The provincial councils’ statement brought them to the
point of renouncing their allegiance to Denmark. In the South provincial council they thought it ‘quite incomprehensible’ that the government could do such a thing without having ‘a moment’s doubt‘ as to whether such an agreement would be harmful to the Greenlanders and thus weaken their trust in Denmark.81 In the north the tone was even sharper. The agreement was a Danish ‘failure’, ‘Denmark had forsaken the Greenlanders’, ‘an unexpected and crushing blow to everyone in Greenland’ Denmark had ‘nullified all the expectations for the future which the Greenlanders had vested in it.’ Hereafter there was ‘no possibility of a genuine cooperation with Denmark.’ The mood was well expressed by the hunter Ludvig Siegstad who in no way gave the impression of being a naive colonial, ‘even if the Greenlanders are insignificant people, they know very well that elsewhere in the world governments do not make decisions of such crucial importance to an entire people without consulting them first, and the Greenlanders had certainly expected Denmark to ask them before a decision was made concerning a land which they call their own.’ The council concluded by thanking all who had supported their case. This obviously excluded the Danish government.82 This episode was unique at the time, and certainly gave Denmark a salutary warning as to how far it could go without forfeiting the loyalty of the Greenlanders. Trust in Denmark had its limits when the Greenlanders felt their interests threatened. More Legislation 1925 The Preparations in Greenland The governing act of 1908 stipulated in its final paragraph that a revision should be made no later than ten years after the first election of the provincial councils. The act of 1912 obliged the Minister to let Greenlandic issues be discussed in a committee to be made up mainly of men on active service in Greenland. Thus no immediate reason for establishing the committee has
77. B&K 1914: 238. 78. Regulation of 21 July 1914 (B&K 1914: 227). 79. LR-S 1911 in B&K 1913: 63. 80. LR-S 1912 in B&K 1913: 104; LR-N 1912 in B&K 1913: 130; LR-S 1913 in B&K 1914: 194. Petroleum was not for sale generally to the Greenlanders due to the danger of setting the houses on fire. 81. B&K 1925: 289f. The Agreement of 9 July 1924 was approved by Parliament 26 June and announced 28 July. The provincial councils responded on 1 August 1924. Somebody must have taken immediate action to let them know. 82. B&K 1925 p. 301-304.
48
THE DAUGAARD-JENSEN PERIOD, 1912-1940
to be looked for in the circumstances of December 1920. The ministry had already asked the provincial council members to discuss the impending revision with the people, so that they could make their recommendations at the council meetings planned for 1920. There seems to have been lively debate all over Greenland: so many suggestions were presented at the council meetings that the total was not even listed, and of course some were accepted and others rejected by the councils. The ensuing lists of the two councils were very different because the proposals submitted to them were different, and because neither council knew what the other had proposed. There was not enough time for the usual procedure of comparing proposals via the long transatlantic communication route to and from Copenhagen. This procedure prevented the Greenlanders from presenting an agreed Greenlandic position. The two provincial councils did agree in wanting to allow Danes in Greenland to be eligible for council membership, and to maintain the current voting age of twenty-two and the age of eligibility at twenty-five. This was because a small group of Greenlanders had hitherto been unable to vote, namely those appointed to their positions by the King or the Minister. They were subject to Danish laws and hence had no voting rights, as in the case for example of the catechists with authorisation to preach. Both provincial councils wanted them included in the electorate, either on an equal footing with other native Greenlanders (southern council) or through inclusion in the Danish electorate (northern council). The provincial councils disagreed over the issue of repartition. In the South they wanted the funds to be used by the community while in the North they wanted the current situation to continue. Each provincial council had proposals the other did not have, of differing political importance. The North proposed a district elected council at an intermediate level between the municipal and provincial council. This would of course expand the Greenlanders’ political influence in their own affairs. In the South the council urged that one council should not be able to stop the other implementing rules which the latter desired. As has been seen, neither leg-
islation nor practice prevented different rules from emerging in the two parts of the country. In spite of this, the South provincial council had felt itself overruled when the government made common rules based on the views of the North. Furthermore, the South provincial council wanted more power placed in the hands of the inspector by expanding his authority to approve the decisions of the municipal councils. It also wanted to expand the power of the council itself by having an elected rather than an appointed chairman, and it wanted direct access to the Ministry by-passing the Greenland administration in Copenhagen. It seems that the Greenland administration was beginning to be seen in the same light as its predecessor the directorate for the Royal Greenlandic Trade Department before 1912 – as an obstacle to the uncensored views of the Greenlanders reaching those responsible for political decision-making in Denmark. In a display of self-consciousness ahead of its time the South provincial council deliberately kept its distance from the Greenlanders appointed to the new committee, who had not been elected by the provincial councils and therefore could not represent them on the committee.83 This episode typifies a common feature of colonial political history: the desire of local authorities – whether native or sent out from the home country – for more power to be transferred from the centre. It also shows a sharp awareness of their position and role among the Greenlandic politicians in the early 1920s. The 1920 committee As stipulated by the 1908 Act the committee consisted almost entirely of ‘men in active Greenlandic service’. Members were the two inspectors, trading post managers, and a couple of colony managers, physicians, priests, and officials in the central administration. There were 22 in total excluding the chairman, director Daugaard-Jensen, who apparently did not participate in the discussions. Three of the members were Greenlanders: Pastor Karl Chemnitz of Nuuk; the trading post manager David Olsen of Sisimiut; and Rural Dean M. Storch of Ritenbenk. Knud Rasmussen was also a member although he was not in the Greenlandic service. Born of a Greenlandic mother and a Danish father he had a foot in both camps. In his works
83. The debate of the South provincial council in B&K 1921: 374-6, of the North provincial council in B&K 1921: 282-8, 393.
49
THE DAUGAARD-JENSEN PERIOD, 1912-1940
Greenlanders as well as Danes were referred to as ‘we’, and in Greenland he counted as a Dane.84 The situation was advantageous to the official class. The political task had been done by the provincial councils and the administrative work of preparing the report for decision by Danish politicians was now to be done by the committee. A characteristic of the report of 1921 was that it was divided into minority statements from varying groups within the committee, as if everyone wished to state his own opinion rather than work out a firm body of proposals. In forty-three cases the members were at odds. Close analysis of these cases reveals two groups, whose views were closer to each other than to anybody outside the group. This was a majority group of thirteen, counting among others the personnel from the Trade Department and the two inspectors. A more radical minority group of seven counted among others SchultzLorentzen and Knud Rasmussen. Among the Greenlanders Chemnitz stood firmly with the minority group, and Storch usually did while David Olsen mostly sided with the majority. These were not fixed groups because some or all who usually voted with the minority group sometimes actually jointed the majority. In spite of these divergences the committee agreed on several important points. One was the essential purpose of Danish rule in Greenland: ‘the development of the Greenlanders to self-reliance, that is to a moral and economic maturity that will enable them to live in free communication with the rest of the world in the future when the present isolation is ended.’85 What was to be done? As mentioned earlier, the answer was to tie Greenland to Denmark as closely as possible. The committee also agreed on righting the wrong of 1908 when Danish officials had been denied access to the elected assemblies in Greenland. It proposed a new assembly based on districts in which they would fill up to half of the seats, and proposed further that Danes who had lived in Greenland for two years or longer should have ordinary voting rights and eligibility for
both the municipal councils and the provincial councils. Over this the committee agreed with the provincial councils. The members also unanimously agreed on extending the teacher training college in Nuuk with a branch to prepare Greenlanders for work in the trade and the administration, so eventually there would be more Greenlanders in higher positions. The committee not only commented on the proposals from Greenland, but made recommendations on its own initiative. Where production was concerned it emphasised traditional sealing and barely noticed the new fisheries. The committee attributed the success of the emerging fishery to exploration, and recommended that sealing also should be thoroughly explored and sustained by experts. This, however, never happened. The committee had better luck in proposing old age pensions in Greenland, which the North provincial council had already discussed in 1920. Both parties assumed that this would be financed from the Greenlandic funds, on which the expense had fallen hitherto. The proposal became law in 1926, however, with financial support from Denmark to give higher pensions than had been envisaged in 1920. Thus, of the proposals from the provincial councils, the committee had supported some, ignored some, and made others of their own. The Passing of the Governing Act of 192586 The bill for the government of Greenland was first introduced in 1922, but was postponed till 1924 because of a parliamentary election and the consequent return of Denmark’s first Social Democratic government. The bill it proposed was however nearly identical to that of 1922 and was based on the majority and significant minority recommendations of the 1920 committee. The profits on the Greenland trade would be divided into two halves, one going to Greenland and the other into a special emergency fund to be used in case of future deficits. If this fund exceeded the current investment in Greenland, calculated at Dkr. 6 mil-
84. Karen Langgård 1998: 11. 85. Report 1921: 15: ‘Grønlændernes udvikling til selvstændighed, det vil sige en sådan modenhed i moralsk og økonomisk henseende, at de kan blive i stand til at leve i fri forbindelse med den øvrige verden, når landets nuværende afsondringstilstand engang i fremtiden ophører’. ‘Selvstændighed’ meaning ‘standing by yourself’ is in the text translated as ‘self-reliance’, because the term ‘independence’ would imply a breaking from Denmark which was in no way envisaged. 86. RT 1924-25.
50
THE DAUGAARD-JENSEN PERIOD, 1912-1940
lion, a new decision would be necessary. With this the usual policy for nearly a century was written into the law. Denmark should not profit from the Greenlanders’ toil, but kept the option open to profit from any other economic activities that might arise. Following a recommendation by the 1920 committee a new district based assembly was introduced – the ‘sysselråd’ – consisting of the municipal council chairmen and the members of the provincial council elected in the district. The numbers would be increased by Danish civil servants becoming members to equal the number of Greenlanders. The election procedure for the provincial council remained unchanged. Members were chosen by electoral assemblies of members of the municipal councils and district councils in the constituency. All Danish parties happily supported the Greenlandic wish to allow Danes to be elected to their assemblies. In fact only two were elected before the Second World War, the physician Laurent Christensen of Qaqortoq (1933-38), and Morten P. Porsild, head of the Arctic Research Station in Qeqertarsuaq in 1927-38. While the numbers qualified to be elected to the provincial councils were thus increased the councils’ rôle and tasks remained unchanged. However, the power to make loans and support for construction and purchase of working tools by Greenlanders were transferred to the new district councils with the exception of loans to sheep farmers, which continued to be administered by the South provincial council. The district councils were also entrusted with the approval of regulations decided in the district’s municipalities. Municipal councils still maintained public order and relieved needy people whether or not they were considered to have brought their situation on themselves. However, relief for the physically disabled was to be paid for by the new district councils because this was a costly item and recipients were not evenly spread among the municipalities; The district was thus moving in to even out the financial burden between the municipalities. These retained the right to spend on any matter defined as ‘for the common good’ but the rest of the income was to be distributed to the providers as before. There were also changes in the judicial system. The governor (new title landsfoged) was to be the judge in all cases tried under Danish law, with appeal to the Danish provincial court in Zeeland and he should have qualifications similar to those of judges in
Denmark. In criminal cases he had the role of prosecutor as well as judge who passed sentence. When these cases resulted in more than a fine or confiscation they were handed over to Copenhagen for final decision. For those subject to Greenlandic law the jurisdiction was shifted from the municipalities to a district court. The appointed chairman of the district council backed up by equal numbers of Danes and Greenlanders were judges in all cases under Greenlandic law. If there were procedural flaws, the governor could quash the verdict, but otherwise the district decision was final. Parliament went beyond approving the proposals from the 1921 committee and the Ministry, and decided that the Ministry of Education should be involved in planning the Greenlandic school system and the further education of catechists in Denmark. Furthermore, an inspector to supervise Greenlandic schools should be appointed. The law laid down that the Danish Ministry of Health should have a say in all health care matters concerning Greenland. A clear tendency of these regulations was to end the Greenland administration’s sole responsibility for Greenlandic matters. It also signalled a wish to make conditions in Greenland more similar to those in Denmark. Parliament also clarified the intention behind the Greenland trade, ‘All trading in Greenland shall have the purpose of improving the economic conditions of the Greenlandic population, and it is reserved for the Danish state, supervised by the Ministry of the Interior. The Greenlanders are permitted to trade freely with each other,’ and it decided on a standing parliamentary committee exclusively to keep an eye on Greenlandic matters. The Minister was not happy fearing that this would interfere in the administration. However, the law did not address what became the most important question in the coming years: the progress of Greenlandic economic life. The Danish parliamentarians were much more concerned with development in fishing and sheep rearing than the committee of 1920 had been perhaps in response to the ever-growing fishery in Greenland or simply because these occupations were much more familiar to the parliamentarians than sealing and fowling. However, nothing came out of the debate, with only J.C. Vanggaard of the Liberal Left suggesting that certain selected Danes should settle in Greenland as pioneers in fishing and sheep farming. References were made in the debates to the need for financial sacrifices where Greenland was con51
THE DAUGAARD-JENSEN PERIOD, 1912-1940
cerned, but balanced budgets were the creed of the day, and the Greenland administration saw itself as obligated to keep the yearly deficits as low as possible, just as formerly. The Minister shared this opinion; in a speech in 1927 he saw in the deficits a serious danger of Denmark losing Greenland because he feared that the Danish taxpayer would not foot the bill indefinitely.87 This fiscal policy meant an extremely frugal administration and reluctance to invest, but in spite of this, during the next ten years the accumulated deficit rose to Dkr. 3 million, and Parliament underwrote it willingly. From 1936 ordinary income and special income from royalties increased, and by 1940 the accumulated balance had reached a surplus of Dkr. 9.2 million. The key factor was the royalties from cryolite mining which rose from Dkr. 2 million in 1930 to Dkr. 7.5 million towards the end of the decade. The Act on Hunting and Fishing88 The governing act we have been considering was related partly to the administration of Greenland and partly with the relations to Denmark. The act on hunting and fishing was to shield Greenland from the world outside. Some regulations were maintained such as the internationally agreed demarcation line three nautical miles from the coast inside which only Greenlanders and Danes residing in Greenland could operate89. No one else could go inside the zone without advance permission. New sections of the act established a more detailed procedure for punishing trespassers, and dealt with the explicit jurisdiction of the governor. An expansion of foreign fishing was expected, so dealings with foreign fishing fleets would be an inescapable part of the governor’s future work. The Minister explained that the growing stock of fish would attract foreign interest so a legal framework was needed. Parliament agreed and only made a small alteration to the bill to the effect that fines for trespassing should go to the Danish treasury and not to
Greenlandic funds. Fines had not been authorised in previous regulations. In the debate C. Zahle of the Radical Left took the opportunity to argue that Danish and Faroese fishermen and sheep farmers should be allowed to settle in Greenland and operate as pioneers, and the Conservative Halfdan Hendriksen raised the possibility that Faroese fishermen could have stations on land to support their fisheries outside the 3 nautical miles limit. The Minister, C.N. Hauge, promised to consider these suggestions favourably. Some years later, on 20 March 1929, a new government issued a regulation on acquisition of farmland in Greenland by Danish farmers, to whom ‘the Administration found occasion to allocate land in order to be pioneers in farming’.90 This idea came not from the Greenlanders, who favoured regulation but had not mentioned Danish farmers settling,91 but from the Permanent Greenland Committee.92 The provincial council wrote to the Committee that ‘it was definitely against giving Danish farmers land that could be used by the Greenlanders, but it had not suggested change in the regulation because the administration was still in charge of finding occasion to allot land to the Danes, and thus no real change in prevailing rules had been made’.93 This was a very subtle way to indicate that the council were against giving land to Danes, but it did not protest because it trusted the administration would find no occasion since the Greenlanders could use all land. It would appear that governor Oldendow substantially contributed to this sort of interpretation. The provincial council was flatly against it, but he must have persuaded it to have trust in the Greenland administration and not protest directly. After all, it was his duty as an official to carry out the intentions of his Minister. The Permanent Greenland Committee remained unpersuaded, and urged the administration to find suitable Danish farmers to settle in Greenland. It preferred Danish to Faroese farmers although the
87. Hauge 1926-27. 88. Proposal of 27 February 1925 (RTFF 1924-25: 5478). First reading 4 March 1925 (RTFF 1925: 5692-96). 89. The article 2 continued: ‘and for those to whom the Ministry will issue special permits according to the hitherto existing regulations.’ At the time the Faroese were already knocking at the door, and this extension was meant to open it. 90. B&K 1929: 218. 91. LR-S 14 July 1926 in B&K 1927: 628. 92. Minutes 18 May, 1 June, 28 June and 29 June 1929 (Archives, Permanent Greenland Committee). 93. Minutes 19 December 1928 (Archives, Permanent Greenland Committee).
52
THE DAUGAARD-JENSEN PERIOD, 1912-1940
Faroese were accustomed to working in mountainous terrain and thus in theory better suited to Greenland, but Danes would bring the Danish language and culture with them. In the period that followed the administration apparently paid more attention than the Permanent Greenland Committee to the views of the provincial council. Thus in 1939 the new director, Oldendow, could tell those taking part in the Danish-Greenlandic negotiations that advantage had not been taken of the permission to settle Danish farmers in Greenland. This was ‘because the atmosphere was unfavourable’.94 This is a typical case of colonial administrators fighting hard to defend the interests of ‘their’ natives from the encroachment of other interests. This time the administrators won, but it was a victory they were unable to repeat. The 1926 Act on Old Age Pensions in Greenland The social security system in Greenland was simple: families were supposed to take care of their members, although people in extreme need could be helped from municipal funds. The 1920 committee had found the existing system unfair to those who were careful with their means and suggested an old age pension available to all. An additional reason for this was that an old age pension had been a civil right in Denmark for people without means since the 1890s.95 The new Social Democratic government that took office in 1924 was sympathetic. The minister in charge of Greenland visited his province the following year and this convinced him that ‘age-old Communism’ in which the people shared what little they had was ‘diminishing or had disappeared altogether’ through the influence of an expanding money economy. On the basis of his report the Permanent Greenland Committee assisted in preparing the bill.96 The law gave an old age pension to every Greenlander over fifty-five who was unable to provide for himself, his wife, and any children under sixteen, provided that he led a respectable life and stayed clear of the law and poor relief in the previous three to five years. The district councils were to deal with the appli-
cations and pay the costs, being reimbursed by the treasury up to a limit of. Dkr. 100 per person and Dkr. 150 per couple per year. This was about twice the amount suggested by the 1920 committee, and therefore much more than anybody had asked for. It was only between one third and a quarter of the old age pension in Denmark, but since wages for unskilled work were ten times higher in Denmark than in Greenland, the pensioners in Greenland were relatively well off. In presenting their case to Parliament the Minister referred to the Greenlanders as ‘constitutional Danish citizens’ with the probable implication that the state was responsible for taking care of them as other citizens. Parliament needed apparently no persuasion, and passed the bill. The provincial councils were not consulted before the bill was passed, and thus its enactment was made conditional on their acceptance. But no problems were expected, and in fact both provincial councils expressed their hearty thanks for the gift.97 The quarrel with Norway over East Greenland On 5 April 1933 the International Court in the Hague ruled that occupation of areas of East Greenland by the Norwegians was without legal basis and therefore invalid. This put a stop to a public quarrel with Norway over Greenland, especially the eastern side, which had soured relations between the two kindred peoples. ‘Occupation’ of areas of Greenland sounds somewhat dramatic, but the events themselves were on a modest scale. On 28 June 1931 five Norwegian trappers planted the Norwegian flag at a point on the east coast and declared the area between Carlsberg Fjord in the south and Besselfjord in the north to be Norwegian. It was an uninhabited coastal expanse of 450 km. and included the area where Norwegian (and Danish) hunting was allowed under the 1924 agreement. But who in Denmark or Greenland would lose a moment’s sleep over what certain Norwegians had said to each other during a stay in East Greenland? However, it became a matter of high policy on 10 July when the Norwegian government accepted responsibility for the trappers’ actions, although it did nothing else to give
94. Minutes of 22 August 1928 (Archives, Permanent Greenland Committee). 95. Report 1921: 78f. 96. Minutes 27 October 1925 (Archives, Permanent Greenland Committee). 97. B&K 1927: 625, 644.
53
THE DAUGAARD-JENSEN PERIOD, 1912-1940
substance to the occupation. Denmark immediately brought the case before the International Court in The Hague. The private pressure group in Norway supporting the occupation acted again on 12 July 1932 ‘occupying’ the area, also uninhabited, south of Ammassalik extending to the southern tip of Greenland. This occupation was also covered by the International Court’s verdict of 5 April 1933. The background in Norway was a general Norwegian endeavour to acquire possessions in Arctic and sub-Arctic areas, such as the Svalbard archipelago in 1920 and Jan Mayen in 1929 to protect their hunting interests.98 This episode of rivalry between two European states over a territory outside Europe had all the elements of an imperialistic quarrel. Denmark legitimised its sovereignty over Greenland on the basis of medieval history and the Treaty of Kiel 1814, but had exercised authority only in the colonised districts after 1721. Uneasy over a possible challenge to its possession of Greenland it had extracted a declaration from the United States in 1916 related to the sale of the Danish West Indies that the USA ‘will not object to the Danish Government extending their political and economic interests to the whole of Greenland.’99 In the following years Denmark received similar declarations from other countries, and only Norway refused to cooperate in spite of a pledge from its foreign minister to do so.100 Consequently, on 21 May 1921Denmark declared that its control extended to the whole of Greenland, and a month later the Greenland Administration closed the East Coast to foreigners. Norway protested, and the negotiations to secure the continuance of its fur trapping in uninhabited areas of East Greenland resulted in the agreement of 1924, already mentioned. The precarious situation in East Greenland drove the Danes to step up their activity to maintain their sovereignty. Colonisation of the Ittoqqortoormiitdistrict north of Ammassalik was strongly advocated by nationalistic circles in Denmark, who paid for this
to be done although it was subsequently taken over by the Danish government. Scientific expeditions were operating, and there was some private fur-trapping. In 1920-4 the ‘Østgrønlandske Kompagni’ operated but it went bankrupt in spite of government aid. 1929 saw the start-up of the ‘Østgrønlandsk Fangstselskab Nanok’ but it too got into financial trouble, despite private and government support. However, it continued to operate, and some of its trappers later joined the wartime sledge patrol. It finally ceased its activities in 1952 when the government’s financial support ended. The assertion of sovereignty was by then no longer needed.101 The verdict from The Hague was received with much rejoicing in Greenland. In 1933 the provincial councils took the initiative in thanking the government, pledging their trust, and expressing their best hopes for the future. In the South the King was congratulated on the recognition of his and the Greenlanders’ right to the whole of Greenland, and the government was thanked for its efforts to win the case, the outcome of which ‘carries in itself promises of a still more cordial connection between our country and Denmark and years of peaceful cooperation for the honour of Denmark and the benefit of Greenland.’ In the North authors of the statement were explicitly stated to be the Greenlandic members to avoid the impression that it had been dominated by the single Danish member of the council, Morten P. Porsild. It read ‘We will only belong to the Danes. May Denmark protect our land and its sea. May the two nations, the Danes and the Greenlanders combine in cooperation and progress.’102 Faroese fishing in Greenlandic waters The case in East Greenland was one of external danger where Danish and Greenlandic interests coincided. However, the situation on the west coast was more complicated: the intruders were not foreigners, but Faroese from another part of the Danish realm. To the Greenlanders the situation in the East and the West
98. Blom 1973: 13. 99. Signed by Robert Lansing, New York, August 4, 1916 (Danmarks traktater efter 1814: 596). 100. The Norwegian side is analysed by Ida Blom (1973). The verdict from the Hague is published by the Danish Foreign Ministry in ‘Haag-dommen af 5. April 1933.’ 101. Brun 1952. 102. B&K 1933: 83, 176.
54
THE DAUGAARD-JENSEN PERIOD, 1912-1940
Fig. 12. Eight Faroese trawlers anchored in Faroese Harbour in 1930. In the beginning, the harbour was just an anchoring place, later supplied with quays, ware houses etc by the users. The Greenland Administration built a radio station and placed a controller at the harbour. Photo The Greenland Administration/Arctic Institute.
was the same: a threat to their very existence. The Danish government saw it in an altogether different light, being also government of the Faroese. Changes in the fishing industry were crowding the Faroese out of their local fishing grounds. Their hand lines and long lines were being damaged by the trawls of British and Germans vessels, and they lacked the capital to invest in modern equipment. So instead they headed north to Iceland and Greenland, and because their boats were relatively small they needed land stations to store their catch. Letting the Faroese into inner Greenlandic waters created several problems. First, it would be a break with the age-old policy of isolation, which would be difficult to impose on other countries if it was once broken: the trade monopoly could not then be upheld because there would be no way of preventing unauthorised trade. The protective aspect of isolation would be lost. Secondly, fishing by others in inner Greenlandic waters could be detrimental to the Greenlanders’ fishing and hunting with the increased activity probably scaring away seals and other prey – the
latter argument was repeatedly emphasised by the Greenlanders. The Danish government had to mediate between Faroese and Greenlandic interests.103 The government chose to support the Faroese, but not in everything they wanted. They did not get free access to fish in all waters, including the fiords, and they were not allowed to employ Greenlanders in their industry. Land for settlement of Faroese was out of the question. In 1927 they did get a land station near Ravns Storø near Arsuk in south Greenland to support their fishing in international waters. This place was 70 nautical miles from the fishing grounds, and solved no real problems for the Faroese, so they kept up the pressure. In 1927 a long struggle began in the course of which the government, by annual renewable laws, gradually extended the rights of the Faroese in Greenlandic waters. The struggle was with the provincial councils who according to the 1925 law were to be consulted in such matters. In June 1925 the South Greenland provincial council stated in principle with no dissenters, that for the time being it could not consent to opening up the
103. The Faroese side is treated by Wåhlin & Kristensen (1996: 63-88).
55
THE DAUGAARD-JENSEN PERIOD, 1912-1940
country wholly or partly to Danish or foreign citizens. This was because of the great amount of work being put into the development of the new businesses of sheep rearing and fishing, and its potential for Greenland. Such opportunities should be reserved for ‘the land’s own children’. But in spite of this the council consented to the governor’s proposal to allow the Faroese to have the station at Ravns Storø on condition that there should be no fishing in territorial waters including the fiords, and that trial fishing should only be allowed for Danish ships and crews and not foreigners. The general requirements for the land station were that (1) it must be a natural harbour not lived in by Greenlanders or used by them for hunting, and situated far from inhabited settlements; (2) the government must employ a supervisor at the station to ensure compliance with the laws; (3) the visiting ships must pay fees for services rendered; (4) access to the harbour must be granted to each ship individually; and (5) no Greenlander could be employed in the cleaning of fish. On the other hand, the provincial council would welcome specially qualified and interested Greenlanders participating in the fishing on equal terms with Danish crew; in fact the council would make it a condition for the permit that these Greenlanders would be taken onboard for instruction. The North Greenland provincial council agreed on the same principles.104 Thus, the provincial councils were not entirely against it, so after prior application the Minister gave a one-season permit in 1926 for the use of the natural harbour at Ravns Storø. The Faroese were far from satisfied. The government then gave in and passed an interim law, which allowed Danish fishing boats – again after prior application – to operate in Greenlandic territorial waters outside the skerries in the period 1 June – 15 October 1927. The area was also extended up to 64007’ N, totalling 97 nautical miles. The government explained this by reference to the difficult situation of the Faroese, and was uneasy at not having consulted the provincial councils first, but promised that they would be heard if there should be
104. 105. 106. 107. 108.
56
B&K 1926: 436-8, 456f. Here Danish also means Faroese. RTFF 1926-27: 5284. RTFF 1926-27: 5303-09. B&K 1928: 28. LR-S 19 July 1927 in B&1927: 741-43.
later moves to make the interim law permanent.105 All the political parties were for this arrangement, and with only a Conservative, Victor Pürschel, warned against yielding to the ‘nationalistic’ Faroese arguments and granting them a concession that both Greenlandic provincial councils had opposed, and which could be detrimental to Greenlandic fishing.106 But Parliament, moved by the social needs of the Faroese, passed the act of 30 May 1927. The inconveniently situated harbour at Ravns Storø was replaced by another 54 nautical miles north later in the year close to the rich fishing banks of the Davis Strait. The new location was named Faroese Harbour107 Even though the provincial councils could not be consulted before the bill was passed, they could be and were consulted afterwards. For the South Greenland provincial council’s meeting in July 1927 governor Oldendow, the chairman, had collected the heavy artillery. Besides the law text and the deliberations in Parliament he had provided the members with a copy of the report from the 1920 committee, a copy of a speech given by the former minister C.N. Hauge and about fifty newspaper articles covering the debate on the matter in Denmark. On top of that he reminded the provincial council of its heavy responsibility in the matter, and that it should issue a statement if it found the interim law consistent with Greenlandic interests, and if therefore the law should be made permanent. He himself understood the benevolent attitude of the Danes to the Faroese, but urged the council only to consider the interests of the Greenlanders. So in important aspects the future of Greenland could depend on the answers from the provincial councils. One can doubt whether the members believed his final declaration of personal detachment from the council’s verdict.108 The south provincial council was unequivocally against the law and against the relocation of the harbour from Ravns Storø, but was in no position to reverse it. It was afraid that this was merely a first step towards letting the Faroese into the fiords where they would rob the Greenlanders of their fishing grounds.
THE DAUGAARD-JENSEN PERIOD, 1912-1940
The council also commented on the other elements in the Governor’s package: it explicitly denounced lifting the monopoly at this particular time, and possibly admitting Faroese sheep farmers as settlers. But it also expressed confidence in the Danish management of Greenland, resulting in the Greenlanders becoming more self-sufficient.109 The North provincial council was not directly involved, but was consulted anyway, and its answer was confused. A majority statement expressed anxiety over the interim law and its possible extension, and vehement denunciations from member Mathias Storch at letting strangers in who had never at any time benefited the Greenlanders, and from member Frederik Lynge who protested against the passing of the law without prior consultation with the provincial councils. Other members were more sympathetic towards the prospect including the Danish member Morten Porsild who saw development potential in allowing the Faroese fishermen to teach the Greenlanders.110 In 1928, the same procedure was followed as in 1927. The unchanged act was passed in Parliament, and the provincial councils were asked for their comments on it. Meanwhile, the Faroese had offered to take Greenlandic crew aboard their boats on equal terms in order to give them experience of modern fishing. In the South they had acquiesced in the situation and made no protest, but there was lively debate about the benefit to Greenlanders on the Faroese boats. The majority opinion was against. In the North the council protested at not having been heard before the decision was made hand, but acquiesced in the fait accompli. A majority here was also against the Faroese fishing fleet having Greenlandic crews.111 In each subsequent year the act was passed, and the provincial councils were not heard any more even when some extension of the rights of the Danish fishing fleet was granted. In 1931 the area where fishing was allowed in territorial waters outside the skerries was extended further north, so that it now covered 180 nautical miles. A delegation from the Danish Parlia-
109. 110. 111. 112. 113. 114.
ment travelled to Nuuk to persuade the South Greenland provincial council to recommend the opening of another harbour to the Faroese fishermen. To pacify the Greenlanders the Faroese member of the delegation, Samuelsen, a member of Parliament, spoke about the hardship of the Faroese fishermen and promised not to raise again the question of fishing in the fiords and the use of Greenlanders in Faroese fishing. The Greenlanders were swayed by this appeal and agreed to the new harbour on condition that the promises made by the Faroese were honoured, and that a more efficient system of control was introduced and thus end the numerous violations of rules by the Faroese fishermen. They were not asked to comment on the extension of the fishing area.112 In 1934 the new harbour was opened at Toqqusaq in the Maniitsoq district, and the South Greenland provincial council agreed to opening Faroese Harbour to vessels of all nationalities – this was implemented in 1937. In 1936 the provincial councils were asked also to agree to an extension of Faroese fishing within the skerries, which both firmly rejected. The situation seemed deadlocked: the Faroese exerted pressure, the Greenlanders resisted, and in 1937 the Danish government prolonged the interim law for 5 years. Meanwhile Faroese fishing in Greenlandic waters continued to grow. From 5% of all Faroese fishing in 1926 it reached nearly 50% in the late 1930s,113 and about 40% of Faroese cutter crew were employed there.114 Not till the end of January 1939, when a new permanent law was passed were the Provincial Councils asked again. The procedure began with a meeting between the Faroese and Prime Minister Thorvald Stauning at which it was agreed to re-open Toqqusaq and Ravns Storø, and that another harbour should be established between Sisimiut and Aasiaat, all three being equipped like Faroese Harbour. Inshore fishing was allowed in the skerries but not in the fiords. The total coastline where fishing was allowed was also extended to a total distance of 425 nautical miles, from Arsuk in the south to Attu in the north. The Greenland
B&K 1927: 744-50. LR-N 10-11 August 1927 in B&K 1927: 794-800. LR-S 2 August 1928 in B&K 1928: 81-91; LR-N 23 July 1928 in B&K 1928: 133-5. LR-S 22 July 1931 in B&K 1931: 735-743. Wåhlin & Kristensen 1996: 65. Fiskeriårbogen 1933-38.
57
THE DAUGAARD-JENSEN PERIOD, 1912-1940
administration in Copenhagen had resisted this on behalf of the Greenlanders but in vain. The agreement was presented as a bill in Parliament, and carried through, giving the Prime Minister the authority to implement the law after consulting the provincial councils in Greenland.115 In the debate in Parliament much emphasis was given to the needs of the Faroese and to the arguments that the interests of the Greenlanders were not being jeopardised.116 During the following months letters reached the Permanent Greenland Committee from Greenland expressing anxiety and objections to the fact that the law had been passed before they could have their say.117 However, someone in the Danish political establishment must have been concerned about the reaction in Greenland for later on the Prime Minister pledged to let a Danish-Greenlandic commission meet and propose what should be done in Greenland. The newly-appointed director for the Greenland administration, Knud Oldendow, was sent to Greenland to ‘make them understand ... and comply’, as one member put it in a parliamentary debate.118 Even though Oldendow had had a hard job as governor in 1927 persuading the South provincial council it was much worse now. The law had been passed, and it contained substantial extensions of the rights of the Faroese fishing fleet in Greenlandic waters. The Prime Minister had put his authority behind the Faroese case right from the beginning in January. Oldendow had counteracted it as best he could, but his task now was to get the provincial council to accept without the loss of their goodwill towards the Greenland administration and Denmark. As soon as the meeting began the pressure built up. The chairman, Governor Aksel Svane, appealed to the council to consider the status of Greenland as a part of the realm, and the importance of having good and harmonious relations with the Danish government. He urged the members to put themselves in the position of the Danish government and to trust that it had mediated between Faroese and Greenlandic interests in the best possible way. Oldendow was on the
115. 116. 117. 118.
58
defensive from the beginning. In his speech he brought a greeting from the King, on whose behalf he asked the members to pass it on to their constituencies. This was not lost on the audience: the royalist Greenlanders rose to their feet to honour the monarch. Oldendow asked the members to understand that the Prime Minister had only acted as he had done because he had no choice. Finally, he requested the councils to appoint two members each to participate in the Danish-Greenlandic negotiations in the autumn. With this invitation the two issues raised the year before – representation in the Danish Parliament and the amalgamation of the two provincial councils into one – were referred to the forthcoming commission. In the debate the members were unequivocal in their rejection of the new law. The only consolation they could see was the reported support of Oldendow. Nevertheless, because the law had been passed in Parliament they did not vote against it – perhaps influenced by the words of the chairman, Aksel Svane, who spelt the situation out clearly during the debate: ‘You must not forget that the most important point to be considered is the progress of the Greenlandic economy and culture. If the steady progress made hitherto is to continue then everybody has to ensure that the provincial councils and the Greenland administration are able to cooperate. A rift between the provincial councils and the government is much more dangerous than the intrusion of the Faroese. It would also become a rift between the provincial councils and the Greenland administration.’ In other words: if you want to remain on good terms with us, your closest friends, then do as we ask! The final statement of the provincial council was as follows: ‘The provincial council, taking all circumstances into consideration, is resigned to the law in question and does not contest its contents. This is because of a firmly rooted confidence in the Greenland administration, and because we fully understand the circumstances which forced the government to make the law. However, we make no secret of our regret that our right to be consulted on all matters concerning Greenland was set aside. It is our firm precondition that no further concessions
Wåhlin & Kristensen 1996: 79-83. RTFF 1938-39: 4483-98. Minutes 10 and 26 May 1939 (Archives, Permanent Greenland Committee). J.S. Vanggaard 6 March 1939 (RTFF 1938-39: 4899).
THE DAUGAARD-JENSEN PERIOD, 1912-1940
can be given, and that an efficient fishery inspection will be established according to our later proposals.’ It was carried seven votes for one against and three abstaining.119 This had been a hard lesson in terms of practical politics, and the sound of arm-twisting lingered among the mountains throughout the summer. The new law turned out to be of little benefit to the Faroese: later that year the Second World War broke out and no Faroese fishing took place in Greenlandic waters during the war. The Negotiations in 1939 The negotiations to which the provincial councils were invited in 1939 were initiated in the Danish Parliament by the Conservatives – a clear signal of their interest in Greenland. Victor Pürschel stated in the Permanent Greenland Committee in March 1938 that he wished to discuss the following matters: the position of the Greenlanders under the Constitution, their possible representation in Parliament, the differences between wages paid to Danes and Greenlanders in Greenland, the unsatisfactory teaching of Danish in the Greenlandic schools, and the access of Danish private individuals to operate in Greenland. He also wanted a committee to consider guidelines for the future development of relations between Denmark and Greenland. The committee accepted the relevance of the questions, but preferred to treat these ‘in a confidential discussion by people with special insight.’ 120 The Conservatives did not give up. In October 1938 they proposed in the Upper House of Parliament a bill setting up a commission of twenty men to look into Greenlandic matters and suggest changes. Again, Greenland’s supposed riches were the primary consideration: the mineral resources and the extension of fishing had to be researched. It was argued that some employment could also be created for Danes. Finally, the internal situation of the country needed to be examined.121 In short this looks like a typical colonial policy – to maximise the value of the dependency to the colonial power – and as such was in line with the practice of the
other European colonial powers of the time, such as Britain in Nigeria with Lugard’s ‘Dual Mandate’, and the French ‘mise en valeur’, not to speak of the Belgian and Dutch policy in the Congo and East Indies (now Indonesia) respectively. To the Liberal and Social Democratic side of Parliament the Conservative proposal appeared too wideranging. First, the Permanent Greenland Committee refused to accept that it could not handle the issue so a commission was not needed.122 Then in the first reading in Parliament Thorvald Stauning, the Prime Minister, refused a commission, but supported the idea of looking into the matter. An internal Parliamentary committee continued the discussion, and a series of questions to the Prime Minister in December 1938 probably reveal where the hard-core interest lay. How much was the Greenland administration spending on mineral research? What was the total royalty from the cryolite mining, and how often had the director of the Greenland administration consulted the Permanent Greenland Committee in the last five years? This last question revealed a tense relationship between the Committee and director Daugaard-Jensen. Finally, some questions were asked about health conditions and schools in Greenland. The Prime Minister was still sympathetic to an enquiry, but not by a commission; the forum should be the Permanent Greenland Committee attended by the Greenland administration and representatives from the provincial councils. The Greenlandic delegates: Pastor Gerhard Egede, the teacher Augo Lynge, the trade manager Frederik Lynge and Pastor Jens Olsen arrived in Copenhagen in the middle of July, the negotiations took place between 1 August and 7 September, but with the outbreak of war in Europe they had to be brought to a hasty end so that the delegates could return safely to Greenland. A report was drawn up, but never published. The outcome of the negotiations made no noticeable difference, because there was general acceptance of the prevailing financial policy whereby development in Greenland should be funded as part of the
119. LR 1938-1947: 126. 120. Minutes from 16 March 1938, draft letter to the Prime Minister May 1938 (Archives, Permanent Greenland Committee, Box 4). 121. RTA: Law of 19 October 1938. 122. Minutes 26 October 1938 (Archives, Permanent Greenland Committtee).
59
THE DAUGAARD-JENSEN PERIOD, 1912-1940
Greenland Administration’s budget. This was why any suggestion that greater financial efforts should be made resulted in a promise from the administration to scrutinise the cost of the various ideas. And of course the administration’s wishes for Greenland were hampered when the country was cut off from Denmark by the German occupation in April 1940. The significance of these negotiations was primarily that they took place at all. For the first time representatives of the provincial councils negotiated Greenland policy directly with the Danish political establishment. Even if they did not altogether succeed in bypassing the almighty administration, they had come close to doing so. The work of the committee was largely planned by the Danes.123 Numerous issues concerning the Greenlandic society were put on the agenda, including the possibility of abandoning Greenland’s isolation. The last of the forty-nine points on the agenda was ‘special questions, which the Greenlandic representatives want to discuss’ The provincial councils did not have the opportunity to prepare for the discussions, but the point of departure on every point was the position of the provincial councils on the issue, if any. Mineral research, the question which had aroused most interest among Danish Conservatives, lost its force during the discussions. Oldendow gave a report on the current state of coal mining and marble quarrying, and neither he nor the committee suggested any expansion. The Prime Minister reported on mineral research, but this was not even included in the final report. As for fishing by the Greenlanders, which had slightly declined during the late 1930s, the Greenlandic delegation raised a number of questions, all urging expansion and further mechanisation, but these were fended off. The Greenland administration promised to investigate whether the number and size of fish processing plants and their business hours could be increased, and to look into the possibility of sending more Danish fishery experts to Greenland. The demand for higher prices was simply refused. This reluctance was due to the acceptance by everyone of the need for balanced budgets. The subcommittee on
fisheries had agreed with Oldendow that all these suggestions had to be evaluated by the administration to avoid any ‘excessive expenses’.124 In the same way deepsea fishing and fishing for other species besides cod and common halibut was curtailed, and the question of factory processing of the catches was not addressed although it was put on the agenda. The debate on farming, which in Greenland means sheep-farming, centred round the possible benefit of allowing a few Danish sheep farmers to settle and become pioneers in the field. The possibility had existed since 1929, but had never been activated because the Greenlanders opposed it. Now the Greenlandic delegates were sympathetic to the idea, but wanted it discussed in the provincial councils first. This apparent change of view was only slight. The Greenlanders were used to Danish experts being hired by the Greenland administration to teach them new occupations. Such experts were used for fishing, and in the discussion in 1939 the committee emphasised the educational aspect; not much in the minutes and reports suggested that the Danish sheep-farmers should settle as colonists. For the Danes there was another angle as well, outspokenly expressed by J.C. Vanggaard of the Liberal Left. His agenda was to argue that private business was superior to the sheep-farming stations run by the administration in Greenland. His tone was openly nationalistic: it was important to use ‘loyal Jutland farmers’ rather than Faroese with their ‘separatist tendencies’.125 But Oldendow was strongly against letting Danish farmers settle in Greenland. He did not believe that they could make a living out of it, and was very reluctant to take the sparse pastureland from the Greenlanders and give it to Danes. Nevertheless, the committee viewed the idea in a generally favourable way. Kr. Lynge had raised the question of a coastal shipping line in Greenland in the South provincial council in 1938. He believed that the new impulses and experiences, which were resulting from this, would benefit the Greenlanders, as would increased trade between north and south. The 1939 committee discussed the
123. Report, minutes of head- and subcommittees, and appendixes (Archives, Permanent Greenland Committee). 124. Minutes from subcommittee on fishery 7 August 1939 (Archives, Permanent Greenland Committee). 125. Minutes from subcommittee on fishery 22 August 1939: 8 (Archives, Permanent Greenland Committee).
60
THE DAUGAARD-JENSEN PERIOD, 1912-1940
matter sympathetically, but referred it for further treatment by the administration and the provincial councils. Health conditions were treated in the usual way. First an expert gave a detailed report of the situation and the administration’s plans for the future, then the committee asked some questions, and finally the expert report was summarised in the overall report, which stated that the committee was satisfied with the plans and wished to see them realised. Such a procedure could indicate that the administration already operated as satisfactorily as possible within the budget. The main issue concerning education in Greenland became the teaching of Danish in the schools. This divided the committee and the Greenlanders. A newspaper article by their colleague from the South, Augo Lynge, upset Jens Olsen and Frederik Lynge from North Greenland. The article argued that the Greenlandic language was ill suited for transferring new learning to Greenland and therefore had no future. Frederik Lynge responded that if this happened Greenlandic would be excluded from the family of civilised languages, and argued that the Greenlanders should keep their Eskimo language which they shared with other Eskimo peoples: their identity was embedded in the language. Jens Olsen said that the priorities of the Greenlanders’ love were: their country, their language, and Denmark. In arguing his case Augo Lynge admitted to having previously been ‘an Eskimo nationalist’, but was now convinced that the Greenlanders had to learn Danish, and have it as a teaching language so as to be capable of attending higher education in Denmark. On the Danish side Vanggaard was the most radical. He scolded Th. Povlsen of the Radical Left for not being willing like Augo Lynge to see Danish introduced in Greenland; this, he claimed, was perverse national-
ism. Oldendow was also strongly opposed to any danification of Greenland. He had asked thirty of his Greenlandic friends, and an overwhelming majority wanted to stick to their own language. He thought that a tiny group of educated Greenlanders scattered throughout the country wanted Danish as the medium of instruction.126 This episode is also characteristic of discussions between colonizer and colonized in the decolonisation process. The most westernised natives were on the committees, and in those days had a strong desire to Europeanise as much as possible in order to achieve economic progress. The colonial officials knew how few the élite were, and how different they were in outlook from their countrymen, and therefore sided with the silent majority. The officials were probably right, but they lost in the end when the views of the native élite prevailed, although in Greenland this process did not take place until the 1970s. The final committee report took the line of the majority in the middle. The importance of keeping the Greenlandic language was emphasised along with the wish to improve the teaching of Danish in Greenland. The administration was told not to shirk either difficulties or expense. In the final pages of the main report the Greenlanders gave their view. They bluntly rejected that Greenland should be opened up to others for the time being. What they wanted was a vigorous effort to develop Greenlandic society so free communication with the world outside could be established. They also rejected the idea of Danish fishermen and farmers settling in Greenland. These opportunities should be reserved for the Greenlanders. The negotiations came to an abrupt end because of the outbreak of war. The final meeting was on 7 September, and two days later the Greenlanders were on their way home where they arrived safe and sound.127
126. The term ‘Eskimo’ was used in the Danish minutes. The Greenlandic-speaking delegates had used the word ‘inuit’ in their own language, which is now generally used in Danish in stead of Eskimo. The debate took place on 1-2. September (Minutes 1939: 63-90). 127. Jens Olsen published a report of his participation in the Greenlandic magazine, Avangnâmioq. It was translated into Danish and is in the archives of the Permanent Greenland Committee, box 4, sheet 3, appendix 6.
61
The Second World War128
Towards the war The outbreak of war in Europe in September 1939 did not catch Greenland and the Greenland administration in Copenhagen completely off-guard. In the summer of 1939 extra raw materials for manufacturing tools, medicine and food supplies for the hospitals were sent to Greenland. Together with the normal supplies, these should have sufficed for three or four years. Just after the outbreak of war another 1,000 tons of emergency supplies were sent. In the autumn of 1939 daily life in Greenland continued as usual, but behind the scenes, the governors and the administration exchanged telegrams about how to manage a possible emergency. For example, ration cards were printed. Before the occupation of Denmark on 9 April 1940 two ships with supplies had left for Greenland. Together with the ship from the Cryolite Mining Company, the Julius Thomsen, they arrived safely in Greenland. But the biggest ship, the Disko, was caught fully loaded at the quayside in Copenhagen.129 Thus maritime traffic between Denmark and Greenland came to a stop, and was not
resumed till five years later, simply because neither the Americans nor the British would allow the government in German-occupied Denmark to have any authority in Greenland. The news of occupation was immediately brought to Greenland, and soon travelled far and wide. A Danish expedition on the Bache peninsula in Ellesmereland, Canada, got the message carved by visiting Polar Eskimos from Qaanaaq on a tin can in their depot: ‘The Germans have captured the Danes and robbed them of their food. Only the King has not been taken. There is no more petroleum at the trading posts.130 Inuit did not have a word for war between states so this was a pretty accurate description of the occupation, and good advice to be sparing with petroleum products.
The situation for Greenland in April 1940 The occupation of Denmark presented Greenland with immense problems. How could it avoid being occupied by the belligerent powers? The Germans had Norway
128. A comprehensive history of Greenland during the Second World War has not yet been written. However, Greenland’s relations with the United States, and especially the question of the American bases from 1941, have been treated in scholarly works. Finn Løkkegaard researched these relations 1940-2 in his doctoral thesis of 1968. And Bo Lidegaard, in his doctoral thesis about the Danish ambassador Henrik Kauffmann in Washington, also covered Kaufmann’s connections with Greenland. Both these publications have extensive English summaries. German scholars have treated the German war effort in the Arctic (see Henkels 1978; Nusser 1979; Rohwer 1968; Selinger 1991). The situation in Greenland during the war is described in a sequence of survey articles by the local authorities (see GSA 1946). The printed material from the administration in Nuuk is essential, and a magazine in Danish, Grønlandsposten, printed from 1942 in Nuuk conveys the mood in the country. In this account I have also used material from the archives of the Permanent Greenland Committee in Copenhagen in which the reports from the governors in 1940 and 1945 have been useful, as has the survey of development in Greenland during the war made by the Greenland administration in Copenhagen. This survey is based on what was known in Copenhagen, especially from telegraphic correspondence between Greenland and America, which could be tapped in Copenhagen. Thus, this material is more rewarding for the period between the autumn of 1939 and the summer of 1940 concerning what should be done if relations were cut off, and what was done when they were. 129. Report Greenland Administration 1945: 3.12. 130. In Greenlandic: ‘tyskit danskit tiguvait neqigssautaunigdlo arsârdlugit kunge kisiat tigunago, tassa niuvertoqarfît tamarmik orssiúsivtiujung(naerput).’ For a linguistic analysis, see Sørensen 1981.
62
THE SECOND WORLD WAR
also and could take the northern route to Greenland. Defences were non-existent, and could not possibly be organised with the means at hand. The German threat was made rather less acute by the British occupation of the Faroe Islands in April and Iceland in May; but that only brought the British threat closer. The United States initiated a hands-off policy towards Greenland by secretly telling Britain and Canada not to occupy Greenland to protect the cryolite mine in Ivittuut, but would not at that time intervene itself. However, the fortunes of war might change that situation. Another problem was supplies. How and from where could deliveries reach Greenland? In spite of the extra supplies shipped across in 1939, some perishable goods were needed every year, and if the war dragged on, there would be a shortage of all the other items as well. How and where could Greenland products be sold? Previously all communications had been with Denmark, and now this route was closed. Supplies were vital. Should they fail and an emergency happens, the Greenlanders’ trust in Denmark could be damaged beyond repair. For the administration safeguarding the living standards of the Greenlanders became tantamount to keeping Greenland for Denmark. In December 1940 they reported to the government that so far they had had no occasion to choose between their priorities which were, first, to ensure that Greenland continued to be a Danish crown colony and, second, to prevent the population being deprived of the necessities of life.131
The relations with Kauffmann and the United States Because of the close proximity of Greenland to the American continent the two governors had in reality no choice in their foreign policy but to come to an understanding with the United States, not least because of the situation with supplies. Canada was at the time a less attractive alternative because it had joined Britain as belligerent, and such a relationship
could bring Greenland into the war. Furthermore, the United States did not favour an exclusive GreenlandCanada link. Both countries established a diplomatic presence in Nuuk in 1940, but trade with Canada was not established till 1941. Seeking a relationship with the United States was not simple. The governors must not appear to be inviting the Americans to come and take over the administration. First the governors decided to wait for instructions from Copenhagen, but meanwhile they made a radio announcement that they would endeavour to secure the normal summer supplies from America.132 The link to the United States had to be via the Danish legation in Washington. Already on 9 April Henrik Kauffmann, the minister there, had initiated his own policy independent of Copenhagen. He aimed to be the acknowledged representative of all Danish interests that were beyond the grasp of the Germans in order to make every asset available for the fight against Germany. Greenland and Danish ships outside Danish waters were the most valuable assets. To play this role Kauffmann needed to be accepted by the Danish diplomatic corps abroad and the local authorities in Greenland, and accordingly he initiated communication with them. On 13 April he cabled to the governors that he would no longer take orders from Copenhagen, and informed them that the United States tacitly accepted him as competent to negotiate on Danish interests despite this. Furthermore he planned to establish a committee in the United States to take charge of supplies to Greenland. The governors did not immediately reply, and on 16 April he cabled again stating that Britain would not allow any contact with Denmark and that they had to act independently. The governors had received no orders from Copenhagen, so in reply they gave cautious and non committal acceptance.133 The Greenland administration and Kauffmann had conflicting views of their relative positions. Kauffmann assumed that he had taken on the rôle of Copenhagen, while the governors knew that by the act of 1925 they were the supreme authority when Copen-
131. Report Greenland Administration 1945: app. The governors’ report had reached the government through the American embassy. 132. MvGA 1940-41: 4; Løkkegaard 1968: 85. 133. Løkkegaard 1968: 85f.
63
THE SECOND WORLD WAR
hagen was out of reach so Kauffmann was now their representative! At first Washington supported the view of the governors, and in April the State Department gave its view that the governors were what remained of a sovereign Danish government, and undertook to acknowledge any authority they vested in Kauffmann.134 However, Kauffmann finally won, and the decisive factor here was the agreement of 1941 concerning the bases in Greenland, which was made with Kauffmann. This resulted in a complete break between Kauffmann and Copenhagen, and an official US acknowledgement of him as a free and independent agent. The US government also gave him control of all Danish assets in the USA, so he had effectively the final say in Greenlandic matters as well, if he and the governors should disagree. This was unambiguously stated to Kauffmann by the State Department in October 1941.135 The governors were very much of one mind when it came to relations with the United States. The goodwill of the Americans was paramount, and their wishes had to be complied with. But there was a difference in their attitude on the appropriate degree of compliance. Eske Brun, the governor of North Greenland, believed that willing compliance was the best means to maintain Danish sovereignty in Greenland, while Aksel Svane, governor of South Greenland, preferred to yield only when in a position of unambiguous coercion. His attitude was parallel to that of the Danish government towards the German occupying forces: only to bend before an obviously superior force. He telegraphed the King in April 1941 that he accepted the base agreement only because of ‘the extreme coercion of the situation’.136 The difference became clear in public when Svane gave a newspaper interview in the United States in August 1941, arguing that Danes abroad, especially those in Greenland, should follow the neutral line of their home government and not speak as if they were belligerent. ‘A good Dane is a quiet Dane’. This caused trouble for him, and for the rest of the war
134. 135. 136. 137. 138. 139.
64
he had no influence.137 Strictly Svane had been the most loyal to his government, but the course of war forced him, and not Brun, into a defensive posture when he returned to Denmark in 1945. Between Brun and Kauffmann there was complete agreement on high policy. Both chose to side with the Allies against Germany and were ready to make the resources they commanded available for the fight, but there was rivalry between them over who had the final say in Greenlandic issues. Personal ambitions may have played a part, but in addition their priorities were different. Brun’s was to lead Greenland unharmed through the war in order to keep the Greenlanders loyal to Denmark, while Kauffmann had a broader goal to secure the best possible position for Denmark after an Allied victory. While the United States was prepared to accord precedence to Kauffmann in October 1941, Brun never did so. As late as 1942 he would not accept Kauffmann as the final arbiter in Greenlandic financial matters or that he had assumed any of the powers formerly exercised by the Greenland administration in Copenhagen.138 The main question which divided them, was the importance of supplies to Greenland. Kauffmann wanted greater reductions so that the Greenlanders, like the Danes back in Denmark, would have to lower their living standard somewhat: in other words, the Greenlanders should bear some of the burdens of the war and thus be able to put a larger surplus at Denmark’s disposal after the war. Brun answered emphatically that the Greenlanders already lived at subsistence level and could not tolerate any reduction, and that if Danish sovereignty was to continue, the Greenlanders should not loose their confidence in the Danish regime. He argued that confidence would be undermined if the Greenlanders’s conditions were to deteriorate.139 The direct cause of this discussion was control of the revenue from the cryolite mine, but there is no record of a serious clash. After all, they agreed on over-
Internal Note, State Department (Løkkegaard 1968: 89). Løkkegaard 1968: 468-74. Telegram of 12 April 1941 (Report from the Greenland Administration 1945: 43). Løkkegaard 1968: 460-62. Exchange of telegrams April-May 1942 (Report from the Greenland Administration 1945: 41-43). Letter from Brun to Kauffmann, 17 May 1942 (Løkkegaard 1968: 446).
THE SECOND WORLD WAR
all policy, and Kauffmann had to rely on advice from within Greenland to assess what was needed, and did not wish to get involved in Greenland’s internal affairs.
The agreement on bases, 1941 Maintaining a hands-off policy in Greenland towards Britain and Canada steadily became more difficult for the United States. Aircraft were the main offensive weapon on the Allied side, and they were mainly produced in America. The biggest could fly non-stop from Newfoundland to Scotland, but the smaller ones had to be freighted on ships, something that became ever more difficult as German submarine warfare intensified. However, smaller planes could also be flown over if they could land and refuel on the way – which is where southern Greenland entered the picture: with an airfield there, the fighters could fly Canada-Greenland-Iceland-Scotland safely out of reach of the German submarines. In the winter of 1941 joint pressure from Britain and Canada for a base in Greenland persuaded the Americans to act, and in February 1941 they decided to build the base themselves. The prospect of Allied victory was better now that Hitler had lost the air battle over southern England in the autumn of 1940, and in March 1941 the Lend-Lease agreement was signed. Now Britain could draw on American resources, and the United States was as close to being a belligerent as possible without loosing neutral status. To maintain this image of neutrality where Greenland was concerned it was necessary that the Greenlandic authorities asked for protection. Interim protection of the cryolite mine in Ivittuut had already been established in 1940 when the Greenlandic authorities obtained permission from the United States to buy a gun and to hire US personnel to operate it. This should prevent stray German submarines from trying their luck at the mine. When the Americans got the impression that Kauffmann was an easier person with whom to reach
an agreement than the governors, he was naturally their choice as interlocutor. During the negotiations he was therefore acknowledged as the highest representative of Danish interest in the United States, as already mentioned. On 5 April 1941 the two governors were then confronted with a ‘fait accompli’, which they could only accept or reject. Both accepted it, Svane emphasising that he had approved under coercion, while Brun only complained about the short notice and the incomplete text presented to them. The agreement was dated 9 April 1941 thus alluding to the German occupation of Denmark exactly a year earlier. The agreement authorised the United States to establish such bases as were necessary to fend off attacks on Greenland. Danish sovereignty over Greenland in general as well as over the bases was confirmed although the Americans exercised jurisdiction over the bases. The agreement was to be valid until the two parties agreed that ‘the present dangers to the peace and security of the American Continent have passed’. (Article X)140 This article was the tricky part. In spite of the stipulation that each party after ‘due consultation’ could give notice of its intention to terminate or modify the agreement, the clause gave the United States a leverage over post-war Denmark in view of their relative strength. Legally it was indisputable that neither Kauffmann nor the governors had any authority to conclude agreements that were absolutely binding on Denmark. Copenhagen dismissed Kauffmann, but not the governors. The reason was probably that if they were removed the way would be open for direct American administration of Greenland – an outcome which appealed to neither the Danes nor the Germans.141 When the war ended Denmark was still unsure whether it would be accepted as ally, and therefore one of the first actions of the Danish Parliament after liberation in May 1945 was to give retrospective approval to the agreement and make Kauffmann a member of the liberation government. The bases were established very quickly. In May 1941 the Americans surveyed possible locations, and in July the work began. Six months later the base was
140. Reprinted in Løkkegaard (1968: 362-7) in both languages. 141. Løkkegaaard’s opinion (1968: 395f). 142. Brun 1946 a: 48 ff.
65
THE SECOND WORLD WAR
Diagram 7. War Time Bases in
Greenland. Legend: Flyvebase (amr.) = American air base; Vejrstation (amr.) = American weather station; Marinestation (amr.) = American naval base; Radiopejlestation o.l. (amr.) = American direction finder station; Vejrmeldestation (dansk) = Danish weather reporting station (Kjær Sørensen 1983: 96).
ready to use.142 By the end of the war the Americans had seventeen stations dispersed all over Greenland, four of which were air bases. The nine weather stations run by the Danish administration were concentrated around the Narsarsuaq air base in the south. It is difficult to judge the effect of the bases on daily life in Greenland. Most were far from inhabited places, and fraternisation with the local people was prohibited. Probably, the contact was no greater than could be expected when the nights were bright and clear and there was curiosity on both sides, although greater problems did occur around the base at Ammassalik (see below). 66
Supplies and sale The cryolite was the decisive export item as it had been before the war, and financed the deficit arising from trade in other commodities. The mineral was used as flux in the production of aluminium, essential for aircraft construction. Thus, cryolite had been in great demand since the mid 1930s, and the fact that Copenhagen was out of reach was no problem. Business relations had already been established before the war with the Pennsylvania Salt Manufacturing Company (Pennsalt) which had bought 25% of the production from Ivittuut, and could easily buy more, as could the Aluminium Company of Canada (Alcan),
THE SECOND WORLD WAR
which bought through the Americans. Production before the war had been around 50,000 tons of which 40,000 went to Denmark. In 1940 about 42,000 tons were shipped to the United States and Canada, in 1941 62,000 and in 1942 85,000. For the rest of the war shipments were smaller, averaging around 50,000 tons in 1940-4, as before the war.143 However, prices rose slightly during the war and the earnings were therefore sufficient to cover the necessary imports. An interim board consisting of the governors, the government supervisor at the mine, and the manager of the mine was set up to legalise the sales.144 As already mentioned Kauffmann had by October 1941 managed to get control over the use of the income. Already in June 1940, he had got US$ 500,000 from the Danish government to finance purchases for Greenland, and on both sides of the Davis Strait preparations for getting supplies were well under way. In April Kauffmann had set up a Greenland Committee in the United States for trading. He acted fast to pre-empt any action by the American Red Cross. He did not want emergency aid for Greenland, but merely sought normal business relations.145 On this point he agreed with the governors. When governor Brun arrived with a small delegation in July 1940 he had to co-operate with Kauffmann’s committee because Kauffmann had charge of the money. Immediately after the occupation of Denmark the US government had seized Danish assets in the United States, and Pennsalt was not allowed to release payments received for the cryolite to the governors.146 Cooperation between the ‘Greenlanders’ and the DanishAmerican committee was not very good, and it was not improved in the spring of 1941 when governor Svane became a US resident. In the autumn of 1941 Kauffmann’s committee was dissolved, and a section of the Danish embassy took over the task of buying and sell-
143. 144. 145. 146. 147. 148. 149. 150. 151.
Table 16. Imports by countries (tons) (GP 1943: 140; MvGA 1940-5: 184, 241).
United States Canada Portugal Total
1942
1943
1944
7,108 9,851 1,525 118,484
6,054 5,295 1,585 22,934
7,020 5,797 1,570 14,387
ing. The section was headed first by Svane, and from April 1942 by Tage Nielsen, a former employee of the Danish shipping company Lauritzen and the American trading partner Gillespie & Co. was replaced by the New York branch of the Danish Ø.K. (East Asiatic Company).147 No details of what was supplied were published either at the time or after the war, but it does not seem that any serious shortages occurred. Some perishable foods were lacking, like potatoes, vegetables, pork, and dairy products during the summer of 1940.148 Delays occurred due to the lack of shipping, and some goods were lower quality than previously. New items were also introduced to replace those which were no longer obtainable. Some of these were a clear improvement. For example, the Colza oil previously used for lightning was unavailable, as were lamps using animal fat. So in the autumn of 1940 petroleum was introduced for indoor lightning,149 an event still remembered as a revolutionary improvement of daily life by those who were children at the time.150 Rationing had already been prepared in 1940 but was not put into effect until October 1942. Cereals of all kinds except rye bread, rye flour and sugar products were included – not due to lack of supplies but in an attempt to rely more on Greenlandic products.151 Apparently the rationing was also sound financially,
Report Greenland Administration 1945: 85-87; Lerche 1946: 65f. Report Greenland Administration 1945: 35. Løkkegaard 1968: 74-83. Løkkegaard 1968: 91. Brun 1945: 30. Governors’ report 28 December 1940: 2 (Archives, Permanent Greenland Committee). Brun 1945: 48. Ole Berglund pers. comm. 1980; Ulloriannguaq Kristiansen in Gynther & Møller (1999: 252). Governors’ report 28 December 1940: 43 (Archives, Permanent Greenland Committee).
67
THE SECOND WORLD WAR
Fig. 13. The mild climate in South Greenland allows for sheepherding at a modest level. This is a sheep farm at Narsaq Kujalleq in the far south, 1936. Photo Jette Bang/Arctic Institute.
because imported foods were sold at a loss, at least if the cost of freight and trading were included.152 While daily consumption barely changed, the repair and renewal of machinery caused problems. The Americans could not deliver spare parts which therefore had to be produced at an extra cost. By 1945 much machinery was nearly worn out. There was an acute shortage of shipping tonnage. The Allies needed all that was available, so the large supply ships that had previously called in at all harbours in Greenland no longer did, so instead the goods 152. Trade inspector Axel Malmqvist (1946: 110). 153. Brun 1945: 30f.
68
were landed at a few transit harbours, and from there distributed along the coast by schooners. The complete supply system consisted of four main harbours: Qaqortoq, Nuuk, Maniitsoq and Aasiaat. Qullissat on Disko served for the transit of technical items, and Sisimiut for marine equipment and for tools in general.153 Opinions differed on the success of this system. On the one hand the ocean freighters spent fewer days in harbour, and the coastal route used for distribution by schooners was something the Greenlanders had long called for. On the other hand the frequent
THE SECOND WORLD WAR
reloading caused damage and losses. However the war and the consequent lack of tonnage forced the transit system into existence, and there was no choice. Except for the transit system distribution in Greenland was unchanged. It was handled by the same personnel, who calculated prices according to the same principles as those used hitherto. The central entrepot abroad was now New York instead of Copenhagen, and American firms instead of Danish ones delivered supplies. Purchases could be made by post as before the war, the only difference being that deliveries were not from Dahls Varehus in Copenhagen but Sears and other US firms whose catalogues were printed in colour! The American market was important, but it did not enjoy a monopoly: some coal, flour, wood, sugar and textiles were obtained from Canada and salt was still mostly delivered direct from Portugal as before the war.154 Greenlandic exports, like imports can only be stated approximately. Cryolite was sold to the United States and Canada, but there was little demand in America for the other main article, salted fish. From 1941 exports to Portugal were resumed, and during the war most of the salted fish was sold here. However, small-scale deliveries went to Spain and the US,155 and seal oil and seal hides periodically found a market in America, but there was no demand for sheep products excepting the hides. The sheep products were therefore used in Greenland, except that the wool was processed into knitting yarn in Canada.156 The overall balance of trade has not been investigated. There were rising prices for both exports and imports, but whether this meant an improvement or worsening of the term of trade is unclear; during the war, no staff was available to make such calculations.157 After the war, Brun and Svane stated that Dkr. 23 millions from the cryolite income had been allocated to cover the trade deficit on other goods. This made an average of Dkr. 4.6 million a year and thus an increase of nearly 50% over the pre-war average of Dkr. 3.1 million. However, Brun maintained that the
154. 155. 156. 157. 158. 159.
Table 17. Total yearly landings of cod (tons, whole fresh fish). Conversion factor from fresh to cleaned fish: 14:10 (GSA 1946: 112).
1938/9 1939/40 1940/1 1941/2 1942/3 1943/4 1944/5
Tons
Value (Dkr)
6,565 7,050 7,573 10,398 11,273 11,543 12,311
257,910 276,964 297,511 445,629 483,128 497,700 571,582
supplies in stock was increased by Dkr. 6-7 million leaving an actual deficit of about Dkr. 3.3 million, and thus the same level as before the war.158
Greenlandic production For some time before the war fish had been the main product. It was exported as salted cod, and cod was plentiful during the war. Thus the catch nearly doubled during the war and thanks to rising prices fishermen’s income more than doubled. The cod was both salted and dried; nearly all of the latter was sold in Greenland while the former was mostly exported. Production of the traditional Greenlandic products also rose during the war. Blubber was traded in on a yearly average of 881 tonnes in 1940/4 a rise of 30% on the four years before the war where the average had been 679 tonnes. Seal hide production rose by 67% from an average of 15,500 hides a year in 1932/6 to 25,900 in the first four years of the war. Whether this was due to a larger catch or a larger sale from an unchanged catch cannot be ascertained because the catches were not printed during the war. It was not due to rising prices, because higher prices for these products were first introduced in March 1945.159 The business that ranked third in importance,
Malmqvist 1946: 104; Report Greenland Administration 1945: 64, 139f. Report Greenland Administration 1945: 64f, 69. Report Greenland Administration 1945: 147f. Brun 1945: 23. Minutes 30 January 1946: 17f (Archives, Permanent Greenland Committee). Figures for the production, see MvGA 1940-45.
69
THE SECOND WORLD WAR
Fig. 14. The first commercial fishery took place from rowing boats often tugged to the fishing place by a motorboat. Photo The Greenland Administration/Arctic Institute, 1919.
namely sheep farming, also increased during the war. This was due to mild winters and the farmers becoming more experienced. Ewes numbered 6,989 in 1939, and about 15,000 in 1945, and earnings from sheep farming accordingly doubled from Dkr 35,756 in 1939 to 70,744 in 1945.160 Whether this progress in Greenlandic production meant a corresponding rise in living standards is unknown because basic figures for consumption and consumer prices are incomplete. However, some of the main trends are discernible. The administration tried as far as possible to keep prices unchanged, but it did not fully succeed. The trading-in prices for fish were raised, as were those for shark and codfish liver. The trading-out prices were also raised although the price setting system was continued. This meant that prices for most essential foods and tools remained low regardless of purchase prices abroad. In order to maintain a certain balance in the economy a complicated
procedure for calculating higher prices was introduced. If purchase prices abroad exceeded selling prices in Greenland by more than 50-67%, then the selling prices were fixed at 80-85% of the purchase prices. This would certainly cause a deficit, because neither freight nor trading costs were included. However, some fixed prices were raised in 1942 and 1943. In March 1945 they were fixed at a assumed post-war level – this meant a rise from 15 to 100%, but again no clear picture emerges.161 Brun claims in his report that the general economic development during the war lead to a rising standard of living for the free Greenlandic producers (of fish, and the products of hunting and sheep), and that the living standard for Greenlanders in employment was maintained by a general wage increase of 15% and the introduction of an allowance for families with children. Meanwhile, the real wages of the employed Danes decreased somewhat due to their higher consumption of imported goods.162
160. Christensen 1946. 161. Announcements about the Administration of Greenland, Nuuk, 1940-5, pp. 32, 90ff. Brun 1945: 22f. 162. Brun 1945: 22-5.
70
THE SECOND WORLD WAR
The Administration The war did not catch the governors totally off-guard when they assumed their new role as supreme authority. Already in August 1939 the Greenland administration in Copenhagen had drawn the governors’ attention to their general authority stated in the law article 10 part 3: ‘As the representative of the Danish government the governor is the general authority in the country (i.e. Greenland), and is authorised to make such arrangement as is needed to safeguard the needs of the population in extraordinary situations.’ Referring to this law the governors declared on 23 April 1940 that they had taken over the authority of the Danish government until normal communications could be restored. In that capacity their power equalled the power of an autocratic monarch, executive, financial and legislative. They had to consult the provincial councils, but as ‘government’ they had the final say, because no decision in the provincial councils was valid without approval of the minister in charge. And the minister was now the governor! This change, forced by circumstances, meant that everything could be done much faster; it was no longer necessary to wait for decisions from Copenhagen. Everything could be decided in Greenland and executed right away. Eske Brun remembered the situation as ‘quite pleasant’.163 No autocratic monarch ever ruled in a political vacuum, and the governors did not do so during the war. They worked hard to continue the administration in the same spirit as before, and in order to do that they needed the loyal co-operation of the population including the provincial councils. They seem to have succeeded, – if at bad moments they ever feared obstruction from the Greenlanders, this according to the records was unfounded. When on 9 April 1940 the division from Denmark took place the governors were at their respective offices, Svane in Nuuk and Brun in Qeqertarsuaq, but it soon became clear that all essential functions needed to be carried out at one place. Nuuk was chosen because the US and Canadian consulates were 163. 164. 165. 166.
there, and it remained accessible by ship during the winter. The governors also decided that one of them should be in the United States to organise supplies to Greenland, and Brun was to go first. In July 1940 he and his small delegation went off to the United States, and immediately found themselves at odds with the Greenland Committee appointed by Kauffmann. Kauffmann persuaded the US State Department to request Brun to return to Greenland in October 1940 in spite of his plans to stay in America for the whole winter.164 Brun stayed at the cryolite mine in Ivittuut during the winter of 1940/1, and Svane took a short trip to America in November-December. In April 1941 Brun returned to Nuuk, and in June Svane left for America, and thus things remained for the rest of the war, whether because the Americans wanted only one governor in charge in Greenland as Svane suggested after the war,165 or because of his unfortunate public statements in August 1941 as Kauffmann later hinted.166 From 1941 there was in effect a central administration in Nuuk because there was only one governor and all foreign business and all government actions took place there. Here too were the central offices of the trade administration and the district physician who took over the health administration of all Greenland. The district physician for North Greenland had been on vacation in Denmark in April 1940, and he remained stranded there during the war. Already before the war the church and schools had their main office in Nuuk. The only teacher training college and the only rural dean was placed there. Judged by the reports from the central administration in Nuuk the system worked well. How it was viewed along the coast remains unknown.
The provincial councils Bearing the Norwegian ‘occupation’ in East Greenland in mind, it was not surprising that the Greenlanders closed ranks around the Danes in times of danger. But
Niels Højlund pers. comm. 1971. See also Højlund 1972: 14, note 4. Løkkegaard 1968: 174-80. Svane 1945: 15. Kauffmann’s Greenland Report 1944 (Løkkegaard 1968: 477).
71
THE SECOND WORLD WAR
Fig. 15. The South Greenland provincial council in session 1939. At this meeting, the council was asked to accept a law allowing an expansion of the Faroese fishery, a law which was already carried in Parliament. That is why the new director of the Greenland Administration, Knud Oldendow, was present. He is seen to the left at the window. The gentleman to his right is Governor Aksel Svane. The two Danes alone wearing ties.. Photo Arctic Institute.
what to be done when the protector himself needed protection? This powerful expression of the mood of the time has often been quoted: ‘For the moment we are like young birds separated from their mother, uneasily flying around and calling her.’167 The new situation in April 1940 had to be discussed with the provincial councils, but they could not convene till 3 May, and by then the governors had already established the connection with the United States. The provincial councils now had to agree, but this was not a problem. They were informed of the situation and the plans for supplies from America, and the meeting passed off with no awkward incidents. All who took the floor expressed their confidence in the Danish administration, and gratitude to the Ameri-
cans, and the necessary resolutions were carried. The meeting lasted only one day.168 Only two more meetings were held during the war, in 1941 and 1943 – for some reason 1942 and 1944 were skipped. The two councils held joint meetings if for no other reasons than that only one governor was resident in Greenland. The issues brought forward by the members dominated the agendas because the councils had no legislation from Denmark to comment on, and because the governors suggested no changes that were not absolutely necessary for carrying on business. Further legislation had to be postponed till the end of the war. The issues raised by the members arose from the problems of daily life. As representatives of the Green-
167. Lecture on Greenlandic radio by Abel Kristiansen, 4 December 1942 (Grønlandsposten 1 February 1943: 25 ff). 168. MvGA 1940: 1-10.
72
THE SECOND WORLD WAR
landic producers and consumers they expressed the wishes of producers for higher prices for their products and labour, and of consumers for prices of consumer goods to be lower. They also suggested that more fish processing plants should be built, and more motorboats obtained, and complained of the poor quality of goods. Governor Eske Brun as chairman said that in general the best available goods were being acquired and sold at a loss to keep prices down; that everything possible was being done to further business; and that all suggestions to improve business, the supply situation and the methods of distribution would be investigated. In 1943 Brun directly asked the provincial councils to speak frankly about the wishes and hopes of the Greenlandic population for Greenland when the world reorganised after the war. The response was limited to a few issues that should be postponed till after the war when the connection with Denmark could be re-established. The two war-time meetings were very much alike in the sense that the procedures consisted mostly of a dialogue between single members and the chairman, especially in 1941 when the chairman tried to persuade the members to make decisions, which could be put into effect. In 1943, by contrast, he let the members debate and make decisions, which afterwards as ‘government’ he was unable to approve and carry out in full. The personal relationship between the provincial councils and Eske Brun has only been recorded in general terms. They speak of great trust in the governor, and in his firm conduct of affairs – an impression, which the minutes bear out. He promised to rectify any muddle and investigate every single complaint. Several times he emphasised that Danes had no privileges in regard to supplies compared to the Greenlanders. When told by a member that some Danes had circumvented the regulation on foreign currency, he characteristically answered: ‘I can guarantee you that if I discover any Dane violating the rules on dollars the person in question will regret it for the rest of his life’.169 One can still only speculate whether the influence of the provincial councils on the administration of Greenland was greater during the war than before. Theoretically they might have exerted a greater influ-
ence since no second opinion was forthcoming from Copenhagen, and their wish to continue after the war as a single provincial council with one governor wielding enhanced authority suggests that they felt they had a greater say.
The press The distribution of news in Greenland before 1940 was very sparse. All families were provided with the magazine, Atuagagdliutit, free of charge, but it was only distributed along the coast once a year. Thus its 200-odd pages were unable to carry news. In 1941 the provincial councils suggested that it should be distributed twice and not once a year, and so it was. A smaller magazine printed in Qeqertarsuaq at Disko, Avangnâmioq, was distributed monthly in North Greenland, but it too contained no news as such. The provincial councils financed both these magazines. In Narsaq Frederik Høegh issued and sold the magazine Sujumut, and in Nuuk Augo Lynge issued Tarqissuut. This was the full extent of the written media. However, already before the war a brief summary of news was telegraphed from Nuuk to the local stations, and along with other announcements this was posted on the notice board in the trading shops. This system was continued after the forced rupture from Denmark. However, the new situation called for more regular information to counteract all sorts of rumours – this was known in Greenland as ‘kamikmail’, after the traditional short boot of the Greenlanders. In December 1941 Eske Brun set up a broadcasting station in Nuuk, and hired a stranded biologist Christian Vibe and the Greenlandic publisher of Atuagagdliutit, Kristoffer Lynge, to run it. Daily for one hour in the evening this station broadcast in Danish and Greenlandic news which it received from foreign stations, as well as talks, interviews, plays and music. Broadcasts began on 5 January 1942 and initiated an immediate and dramatic spread of information. Not everybody owned a radio; in 1942 only 100 did so but by 1945 this had grown to 400. Some radios were placed in community centres, and listening in at a neighbour’s house was said to be a common practice,
169. LR 1943: 10.
73
THE SECOND WORLD WAR
with the result that the news travelled far beyond the actual number of receivers.170 Radio had come to stay. After the war broadcasting continued to expand, and is still the most important medium for discussion in Greenland, ahead of television. Another phenomenon born during the war was the Danish-medium magazine Grønlandsposten, edited by Christian Vibe. According to the statement of Eske Brun in the first issue published on 16 March 1942 the idea behind it was to create a link between Danes in Greenland. Publication was twice a month; in contrast to the Greenlandic magazines it was not free, and advertisement space had to be paid for. Even so, it was widely distributed, also among Greenlanders who could read Danish. The magazine carried small pieces on daily life and is thus a good source for providing the background to administrative sources to life in Greenland. It also contained articles and a small amount of debate. After the war it was edited for two years in Denmark, and then in 1947-50 again in Nuuk to be merged with the Atuagagdliutit in 1952. Thereafter it was bilingual, and is still published (2005).
In the autumn of 1942 steps were taken to establish Danish schools, and according to a proclamation of 21 August schools could be authorised if certain requirements regarding the number of pupils, the quality of the teaching staff, and the curriculum were met. The number of pupils had to be ‘enough to count as a real school’. Any child ‘who had Danish as a natural means of expression and was able to understand subjects taught in Danish’ would be accepted. At least one of the teachers should already be employed in the Greenlandic educational system, and all of them should themselves have adequate education. The curriculum should be the same as at the Copenhagen grammar schools. These new schools were supervised like the Greenlandic ones by the local authorities and the rural dean.172 They were tiny: in 1942/3 schools were established at Qaqortoq, Nuuk and Aasiaat with a total of twenty-three pupils, and in the following year Ivittuut and Paamiut were added, and the number of pupils grew to thirty-eight. By 1944/5 there were thirty-six pupils in total as the school in Ivittuut had closed.173 The Danish schools continued for some years after the war; in 1946/7 the one in Nuuk had nine pupils.174
Schools A political incident The war created a new institution for teaching: a Danish school for the children of the Danish civil servants. Hitherto these families had taught their younger children themselves sometimes by hiring a private Danish teacher to serve several families. When the children were about ten years old they were sent to boarding schools or stayed with relatives to finish school in Denmark with the result that children were often separated from their parents for several years. The war made Denmark inaccessible, so new ways had to be found. In the summer of 1941 about ten older children were sent to schools in the United States and Canada, but as the war dragged on this solution had to be discontinued because of the danger from German submarines.171 170. 171. 172. 173. 174. 175.
74
Private citizens too were responsible for some notable initiatives and a growing number of youth associations and sports clubs and leisure activities of all kinds were reported. In 1942 Augo Lynge established one of the biggest youth associations, named Nunavta Qitornai (the children of our country). Lynge’s aim was to awaken the youth to a new era that was opening and take responsibility for Greenland in close co-operation with the Danes.175 The emphasis on the Greenlandic initiative may have caused problems for Augo Lynge because in 1943 he was transferred from the teacher training college in Nuuk to a continuation school in Aasiaat 600 km. to the north. While it was normal for
Vibe 1946 Bugge 1946: 71-78. Proclamation in MvGA 1942: 98. Announcements about the Administration of Greenland 1944 p. 260. Meddelelser 1946-48: 14. Augo Lynge opening speech printed in the journal of the association Inuusuttoq (The Young). Quoted from the Danish version by Ulloriannquaq Kristiansen (Gynther & Møller 1999: 253). For a comprehensive analysis of the political ideas of Augo Lynge, see Thorleifsen 1991.
THE SECOND WORLD WAR
priests and teachers to be stationed at different places during their careers, it was rumoured that in this case his political activity had become inconvenient for the local authorities. When Augo Lynge’s relocation became known in Nuuk, the inhabitants met to discuss the matter. The headmaster of the teacher training college forbade the students to participate on the grounds that they should not be allowed to discuss their teachers in public, but nearly twenty students disregarded the ban. A meeting of the teaching staff was summoned on 19 March 1943 to decide on an appropriate punishment, and the headmaster had obtained the agreement of the supervisor, rural dean Aage Bugge, and the governor Eske Brun in advance that an example must be made of the student rebels. The question divided the teaching staff. The most open dissident was Jonathan Petersen, the Greenlandic poet and composer, who refused to accept that the reason for the transfer of Augo Lynge was the need for an experienced teacher in Aasiaat. He had heard rumours of other reasons. He also totally disagreed with banning students from participating in meetings in the town, and even questioned the headmaster’s authority to do so. Other teachers pointed out to him that being in charge of a boarding school the headmaster had the authority to tell the students how to behave, and they were obligated to comply with the rules and orders. Reluctantly, Jonathan Petersen accepted a mild punishment for violating an order. Augo Lynge himself agreed that discipline had to be upheld although he could see little harm in allowing the students to participate in the meeting, and he advocated leniency. He was not pleased with the prospect of leaving Nuuk, but he said later in the summer that he had come to terms with it. Other members of the teaching staff were firm that the need for discipline required disobedience to be punished. At a further meeting the next day the staff agreed that three of the offenders should be expelled at once, and others should have their movements restricted in different ways. The harsh reaction
of the teaching staff was too much for the rural dean, who pleaded with them to consider mitigating circumstances. Consequently the final verdict was that the three students could stay if they apologised unconditionally, which they did.176 What makes this incident more than a trivial disciplinary issue in a boarding school is that the inhabitants of Nuuk were upset by the prospect of having Augo Lynge transferred to Aasiaat and began to look for other reasons besides the official one; and the reaction of the headmaster in Aasiaat, Mikael Gam, suggests that they may have good reason for doing so. When informed of the transfer Gam sent a telegram expressing his surprise and requested an explanation. He obviously never got one, because in his later report for 1942-3 he was still asking the same question.177 One of the Danish members of the board of the Youth Association, Finn Gad, later well-known as a historian of Greenland, and at the time on the staff of the teacher training college, felt that he had to explain to the Danes in Greenland what the Nunavta Qitornai stood for, since it had got a bad reputation and been misunderstood. He assured the public that the Nunavta Qitornai bore no grudge against anyone except the complacent and those who were content with their own superior knowledge – and biases.178 It seems clear that his target was someone in local society. After the war a discussion in the Permanent Greenland Committee seemed to raise the issue again. A Greenlandic participant, Hans Lynge, criticised the head of the teacher training college for having forbidden the students to be members of the Christian Youth Association. He was corrected by Schultz-Lorentzen who said that the college did not want its students to be members of certain associations in Nuuk. Another Danish teacher from Greenland, Willy Borum, further explained: ‘The ban on membership of associations is aimed only at the political ones, not the Christian ones.’ It is only fair to add that the Danish parliamentarians disagreed with the ban.179 If nothing else, this incident shows that some of the local authorities in Nuuk dur-
176. Minutes from meetings of the teaching staff at the college (National Archives, Nuuk, 23.02/1.1.2). 177. National Archives, Nuuk. The telegram and the report are printed as exam texts, edited by Daniel Thorleifsen, at the university of Greenland summer 2000. 178. Gad 1943: 88f. 179. Minutes 8 March 1946 (Archives, Permanent Greenland Committee).
75
THE SECOND WORLD WAR
Fig. 16. US Coast Guard Combat Cutter Eastwind, one of two American vessels operating at the east coast of Greenland in 1944, unloading captured German supplies at Sandodden to the Danish sledge patrol. Photo US Coast Guard/Arctic Institute.
ing the war were alert to possible subversive activity by the Greenlanders.
East Greenland Before the war the two eastern settlements, Ammassalik and Scoresbysund, had been administered and serviced directly from Copenhagen, and when this was no longer possible, in 1940 and 1941, the task fell to schooners from the west coast. From 1942 they were served by American ships, which had to supply their own stations anyway. The statistics show no sign of falling supplies: during the five years trading-out increased by 30% despite a 35% decrease of trading-in. This can only be due to a rise in money income, for which no explanation is known.180 The most direct contact between the Americans and the Greenlanders was in the Ammassalik district. 180. Mikkelsen 1946: 155-166. 181. Mikkelsen 1946: 155-166. 182. The following is based on Ib Paulsen (1946: 168-185).
76
Already in 1941 a weather station was installed in the Ammassalik settlement, and moved to the Kulusuk peninsula in 1943. An airfield was built at Ikagteq between the two principal trading posts, Kuummiut and Sermiligaq. The base here could hold 800 men, and contact with the local people could not be prevented despite a strict curfew. The main problem was the propensity of the Greenlanders to collect food from the American waste tip. Even after seven deaths from rotten meat the activity went on until the Americans took stronger precautions to ensure that the curfew was observed.181 Otherwise the most dramatic events and the only real acts of war took place north of Scoresbysund.182 The importance of this area was the presence of the weather stations from which the weather in Western Europe could be predicted. Before the war only four such stations with radio contact existed: a Danish scientific station in Mørkefjord (nearly 77° NL), a Dan-
THE SECOND WORLD WAR
Fig. 17. The American base Blui West One at Narsarsuaq, South Greenland, 1945. Photo Jette Bang.
ish station on Eskimonæs 300 km. to the south which also functioned as a police station (nearly 74° NL), a Danish station at Ellaø 200 km. further south (nearly 73° NL), and a Norwegian station in Myggebugten (73° 30’ NL). The direct distance from Ellaø to the settlement of Ittoqqortoormiit was 300 km., but since the only means of transport was dog sledge and it had to avoid mountains and open water, the actual travelling distance was considerably longer. After the occupation of Denmark the governors forbade the Danish stations on the East Coast to send their messages uncoded. The Norwegian governmentin-exile shut down the Norwegian station in 1940, and in the process arrested the crew of another station being constructed by workers sent out from Germanoccupied Norway. According to the defence agreement of April 1941 the Americans took over the surveillance of the east coast. As part of this operation Governor Eske Brun established a Greenlandic sledge patrol to cover the coast from Kap Dalton south of Ittoqqortoormiit to Franske øen (Ile de France) on 78° NL, a direct distance of 1,000 km. The patrols were manned by the private trappers, including one Norwegian, and by
Greenlanders from Scoresbysund. They started their service on 1 August 1941 and their task was to locate any attempt by the enemy to establish stations along the coast. If they found any, they were to notify the Americans who would then destroy them. In this way a German telegraph station was discovered in the winter of 1941/2 and captured by the Americans. The patrols were not supposed to engage in fighting themselves, but a fight did take place in the spring of 1943. The Germans had landed a small force on Sabine island 100 km. northeast of Eskimonæs. The Danish patrols were then reorganised as military units to be protected by the Geneva Convention in case they were captured. The Germans attacked the station at Eskimonæs, but the crew escaped to Ellaø under cover of darkness. Later in March the Germans ambushed a three-man Danish patrol, killing one of them, Eli Knudsen, and taking the other two prisoners. One of these, Peter Nielsen, was allowed to leave a few days later to give Eli Knudsen a proper burial, having done which he took the opportunity to continue to Ellaø. The other, Marius Jensen, arrived in May at Ittoqqortoormiit with the German commander from Sabine island, Lieutenant Hermann Ritter, as his prisoner. The story was 77
THE SECOND WORLD WAR
that Jensen had overpowered Ritter when the two of them were alone, and taken him the 300 km. south to Scoresbysund. For his deed he was decorated with the American Legion of Merit and the British Empire Medal. The German station was bombed and destroyed by American planes.183 Back in 1943 Marius Jensen never told how he managed to capture the German commander, but many years later gave an explanation which made the deed easier to understand. Lieutenant Ritter had been a trapper at Svalbard before the war and spoke Norwegian, which is easily understood by Danes; actually he was acquainted with the Norwegian Henry Rudi from the sledge patrol. He was drafted for the Wehrmacht, and put in charge of the operation at Sabine island in a war with which he had no sympathy. By being deliberately careless about carrying his gun when Jensen was around, Ritter more or less arranged to be captured and led by the experienced Jensen to inhabited areas. He was obviously a nice guy, and the authorities in Ittoqqortoormiit had the greatest difficulty in preventing the local people from liking him.184 In April 1944 the patrols were again involved in open conflict. They attacked a German station near Shannon island, but failed, though without any casualties on the Danish side. The Americans took care of the station itself. Several more stations were discovered and taken out by the Americans without the Danish patrols being involved. In the great theatre of war the incidents in northeast Greenland were of little significance but they clearly demonstrated the attitude of the Danish administration in Nuuk, which wanted to contribute to the best of its ability.
Back in Denmark The activities of the Greenland Administration in Copenhagen during the war were necessarily very modest. They had no supplies to arrange for; none of the countless issues, which the governors and provin-
cial councils usually sent to Copenhagen to be decided; no legislation to prepare. The redundant staff was allocated to other ministries, the rest was occupied in making a report describing the development in Greenland based on the archives. The result was published 1942-47 as Sammendrag af statistiske Oplysninger om Grønland (Summary of Statistical Information on Greenland) which has been a major source for my survey of the material development in Greenland before the Second World War. In addition to this work the Administration tried to get all available information from Greenland. The telegraph line was closed on 9 April 1940, and not reopened till 22 April. Thereafter people were allowed to communicate family news, but any administrative messages were out of the question. Censorship existed at both ends of the line. Private letters now and then got through to Greenland, some of them were printed in Grønlandsposten without saying how the letter had circumvented the blockade. A much more important source for the Greenland Administration was illegal listening to the telegraphic traffic between Nuuk and the United States. This material was the main source for a 163-page report in March 1945 made by the administration. Not much could be done except wait and see. Director Oldendow tried to reach the United States in 1940 to administer Greenland from there, but the Americans would not let him in. The Permanent Greenland Committee was told that he had intended to go on to Greenland if he had succeeded in getting to the United States.185 In Denmark the main political problem regarding Greenland was to avoid provoking the Germans to do anything which could endanger Danish sovereignty over Greenland. Until 1942 the Germans were equally eager to avoid giving the Americans reasons to take over in Greenland. This might be the reason why Copenhagen did not react to the governors when they signed the base agreement in 1941. The government was piqued by the action, but kept its regrets to itself.186
183. Brun 1946 a: 55. A full report of casualties should include the disappearance of the freighter Hans Egede 1942 with its crew of twenty-three men. As late as 1968 it was established that it had been sunk by the German submarine U-587 south of Newfoundland on 4 March 1942. See Rohwer 1983: 83. 184. Odsbjerg 1990: 91-94. 185. Minutes 7 May 1940 and 22 May 1940 (Archives, Permanent Greenland Committee). 186. Løkkegaard 1968: 395.
78
THE SECOND WORLD WAR
In the Permanent Greenland Committee developments in Greenland were eagerly followed, and the minutes can give some impression of their political judgement.187 Director Oldendow became a frequent guest in the committee. It seems that he shared his information with the committee. Immediately after the occupation the committee could hardly understand the actions of Kauffmann and the governors. To Danish politicians the government was still in business and running Denmark and her dependencies in spite of the German occupation. Denmark was not belligerent, and they could not understand and accept that the outside world acted as if she was controlled by Germany. The Liberal Leftist, Vanggaard, and the Conservative, Ellinger, were especially upset by the blunt insubordination of Kauffmann and the governors. They were completely unable to understand the buying of supplies in the United States in 1940, because extra supplies had been sent from Denmark to Greenland. Oldendow showed more understanding for the need to get extra supplies when possible. As time went by, the view gained foothold that Kauffmann and the governors were acting in what they deemed the best interest for Denmark, and that they had to consider the American view. On 7 May such views were aired by the Social Democrat, Hauberg, and by the Radical Leftist, Oluf Steen on 19 June 1940. The politicians were very suspicious about the real American intentions in Greenland. From the autumn of 1941 when the base agreement became known, and the United States entered the war this sort of worry became more sporadic in the fewer and fewer meetings. But some meetings were held, also after 29 August 1943 when the Danish government resigned in protest against German actions. For the rest of the war no new government was appointed, and the Permanent Secretaries carried out normal administration holding clandestine meetings with the politicians when needed. The last meeting in the committee during the war was on 7 December 1944. As at the previous meetings its main business was a report from Oldendow about conditions in Greenland.
Table 18. Funds collected in Greenland during the war.
For reconstruction in Denmark 84,015 For allied war efforts (sent to the British government) 40,1 For aid to refugees (sent to Stockholm) 38,9 For Red Cross (sent to the American Red Cross) 4,8 For a memorial for those drowned in the loss of the Hans Egede in Nuuk 2,25 Total 170,065
The war resulted in great changes in Greenland. Supplies and sales moved to the United States, and the administration was centralised in Nuuk. Financially speaking there was progress during the war in respect of production as well as living standards especially for the Greenlandic providers. The American presence at the bases inevitably brought the Greenlanders into contact with foreigners, especially in the district of Qaqortoq and Ammassalik. But most things remained unchanged. As little as possible was changed in rules and regulations. The Danish administration continued unaffected, politically as well as in trade and supplies. The trading monopoly and restricted access to the country was upheld in full for the American bases. The political main aim: to maintain Greenland under Danish sovereignty and the Greenlanders’ adherence to Denmark was never threatened – on the contrary. All sources testify the still unabated wish of the Greenlanders to share the future with Denmark. Money was even collected to help Denmark to overcome the devastation of war. The purposes and amounts in Dkr. Are listed in table 18.188 This was a substantial amount for the 20,000-odd Danes and Greenlanders in Greenland. Not until the winter of 1944/5 did the very few articles written by Greenlanders in Grønlandsposten begin to reflect on what should be done after the war. They were concerned with equal salaries for Danes and Greenlanders, equal jurisdiction and more teaching also in Danish. The main aim was greater selfreliance for Greenlanders. There was absolutely no illwill towards Denmark, but rather confidence that their wishes would be realised through co-operation with the Danes.189
187. Archives, Permanent Greenland Committee 1940-4. 188. Grønlandsposten 1945: 219. 189. Trading post manager Nicolaj Rosing in Grønlandsposten 16 February 1945: 38-40.
79
The immediate postwar years
There was equal rejoicing in Greenland and Denmark at the news of the German capitulation. Reports from along the whole coast told of spontaneous demonstrations of joy in a shared Danish-Greenlandic celebration. The years of uncertainty were over, connections with Denmark could be resumed, and a bright new era beckoned. On 5 May the reunion telegrams flew across the Atlantic full of hope for the future. Oldendow was most specific, acknowledging that there had been changes in Greenland during the war, and saying that he would be very receptive to suggestions for change.190 There is no reason to doubt the good intentions, but people’s experiences during the war had been different, the main division being between those who had served in Greenland, and those who spent the war years in Denmark. Different experiences created different ideas for the future.
Positions in the summer of 1945 For Denmark in May 1945 the main problems were to be recognised as a partner on the winning side in the war, and to restore normal foreign trade. During the war Germany had been the sole market, and this was destroyed overnight. Greenland had always been a minor issue in Danish politics, and was run largely by the Greenland administration. It had attracted some political interest before the war, and more was to come now, but the government seems to have devoted little energy to the question. It expected to resume control on the same lines as before the war, continuing to take into account the wishes of the Greenlanders. Oldendow had the task of restoring normal relations. He had taken over on the death of DaugaardJensen in 1938,