DEEP OCEAN CIRCULATION PH YSlCAL AND CHEMICAL ASPECTS
FURTHER TITLES IN THIS SERIES Volumes 1-7, 11, 15, 16, 18, 19, ...
215 downloads
1740 Views
18MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
DEEP OCEAN CIRCULATION PH YSlCAL AND CHEMICAL ASPECTS
FURTHER TITLES IN THIS SERIES Volumes 1-7, 11, 15, 16, 18, 19, 21, 23, 29 and 32 are out of print. 8 E. LlSlTZlN SEA-LEVEL CHANGES 9 R U PARKFR STU'DY OF BENTHIC co MMuNITIES 10 J.C.J. NIHOUL (Editor) MODELLING OF MARINE SYSTEMS 12 E.J. FERGUSON WOOD and R.E. JOHANNES TROPICAL MARINE POLLUTION 13 E. STEEMANN NIELSEN MARINE PHOTOSYNTHESIS 14 N.G.JERLOV MARINE OPTICS 17 R.A. GEYER (Editor) SUBMERSIBLES AND THEIR USE IN OCEANOGRAPHY AND OCEAN ENGINEERING 20 P.H. LEBLOND and L.A. MYSAK WAVES IN THE OCEAN 22 P. DEHLINGER MARINE GRAVITY 24 F.T. BANNER, M.B. COLLINS and K.S. MASSIE (Editors) THE NORTH-WEST EUROPEAN SHELF SEAS. THE SEA BED AND THE SEA IN MOTION 25 J.C.J. NIHOUL (Editor) MARINE FORECASTING 26 H.G. RAMMING and Z. KOWALIK NUMERICAL MODELLING MARINE HYDRODYNAMICS 27 R.A. GEYER (Editor) MARINE ENVIRONMENTAL POLLUTION 28 J.C.J. NIHOUL (Editor) MARINE TURBULENCE 30 A. VOlPlO (Editor) THE BALTIC SEA 31 E.K. DUURSMA and R. DAWSON (Editors) MARINE ORGANIC CHEMISTRY 33 RHEKINIAN PETROLOGY OF THE OCEAN FLOOR 34 J.C.J. NIHOUL (Editor) HYDRODYNAMICS OF SEMI-ENCLOSED SEAS 35 B. JOHNS (Editor) PHYSICAL OCEANOGRAPHY OF COASTAL AND SHELF SEAS 36 J C J NIHOUL (Editor) HYDRODYNAMICS OF THE EQUATORIAL OCEAN 37 W. LANGERAAR SURVEYING AND CHARTING OF THE SEAS 38 J C J NIHOUL (Editor) REMOTE SENSING OF SHELF SEA HYDRODYNAMICS 39 T.ICHIYE (Editor) OCEAN HYDRODYNAMICS OF THE JAPAN AND EAST CHINA SEAS 40 J.C.J. NIHOUL (Editor) COUPLED OCEAN-ATMOSPHERE MODELS 41 H. KUNZENDORF (Editor) MARINE MINERAL EXPLORATION 42 J.C.J NIHOUL (Editor) MARINE INTERFACES ECOHYDRODYNAMICS 43 P. LASSERRE and J.M. MARTIN (Editors) BIOGEOCHEMICAL PROCESSES AT THE LANDSEA BOUNDARY 44 I.P. MARTINI (Editor) CANADIAN INLAND SEAS 45 J C.J. NIHOUL (Editor) THREE-DIMINSIONAL MODELS OF MARINE AND ESTUARIN DYNAMICS 46 J C J NIHOUL (Editor) :3?,A,L&-SCALE TURBULENCE AND MIXING IN THE
THE
47 M.R. LANDRY and B.M. HICKEY (Editors) COASTAL OCENOGRAPHY OF WASHINGTON AND OREGON 48 S.R. MASSEL HYDRODYNAMICS OF COASTAL ZONES 49 V.C. LAKHAN and A.S. TRENHAILE (Editors) APPLICATIONS IN COASTAL MODELING 50 J.C.J. NIHOUL and B.M. JAMART (Editors) MESOSCALE SYNOPTIC COHERENT STRUCTURES IN GEOPHYSICAL TURBULENCE 51 G.P. GLASBY (Editor) ANTARCTIC SECTOR OF THE PACIFIC 52 P.W. GLYNN (Editor) GLOBAL ECOLOGICAL CONSEOUENCES OF THE 1982-83 EL NINO-SOUTHERN OSCILLATION 53 J. DERA (Editor) MARINE PHYSICS 54 K. TAKANO (Editor) OCEANOGRAPHY OF ASIAN MARGINAL SEAS
Elsevier Oceanography Series, 59
DEEP OCEAN C IRC ULATI0N PHYSICAL AND CHEMICAL ASPECTS
Edited by
T. Teramoto Department of Information and Computer Sciences, Kanagawa University, Tsuchiya, Hiratsuka, Kanagawa 259-12, Japan
ELSEVIER
Amsterdam - London - New York -Tokyo
1993
ELSEVIER SCIENCE PUBLISHERS B.V. Sara Burgerhartstraat 25 P.O. Box 21 1, 1000 AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands
ISBN: 0 444 88961 2
0 1993 Elsevier Science Publishers B.V. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the publishers, Elsevier Science Publishers B.V., Copyright & Permissions Department, P.O. Box 521, 1000 A M Amsterdam, The Netherlands. Special regulations for readers in the U.S.A.- This publication has been registered with the Copyright Clearance Center Inc. (CCC), Salem, Massachusetts. Information can be obtained from the CCC about conditions under which photocopies of parts of this publication may be made in the U.S.A. All other copyright questions, including photocopying outside of the U.S.A., should be referred to the copyright owner, Elsevier Science Publishers B.V., unless otherwise specified. No responsibility is assumed by the publisher for any injury and/or damage t o persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the materials herein. This book is printed on acid-free paper. Printed in The Netherlands.
V
Preface This book comprises the final report of the project research titled the Dynamics of the Deep Ocean Circulation. The project was organized and conducted under the chairmanship of myself for four fiscal years from 1987 to 1990, with financial support of the Ministry of Education, Science and Culture of Japan under the grant in aid of Priority Area Programme. As will be described in Chap. 1 in more detail, the project needed to involve research groups who had sufficient experiences in long-term current measurements, accurate chemical analyses of dissolved heavy metals and isotope tracers, numerical and hydraulic modellings, sediment trappings, and so on. These experiences had been gained through two preceding research projects, the first of which bore the title, “Fundamental Studies on Preservation of Ocean Environment”, and the second, the “Ocean Characteristics and their Changes.” The former was carried out for four years from 1975 to 1978 under the chairmanship of Prof. Y. Horibe and the latter for four years from 1981 to 1984 under the chairmanship of Prof. K. Kajiura. Both were financially supported by the Ministry of Education, Science and Culture, too. I am greatly indebted to these supports and express my sincere gratitude to these chairmen. Throughout the period of research, I had arranged symposia several times, in which ocean scientists who were not directly committed to the project also joined. Comments and criticisms given there were very helpful for the promotion of the project. Here, I would like to express my sincere gratitude to Dr. Susumu Tabata, the former senior scientist of the Institute of Ocean Sciences in Sidney, B. C., CANADA, for reviewing whole the papers involved and giving valuable advices and appropriate comments.
Toshihiko TERAMOTO Kanagawa, University, 1992
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
vii
Table of Contents Preface T.Teramoto
.................................
v
Chapter 1: Motivation of the Project Research and a Hypothetical Circulation model presented prior to the Research Motivation of the Project Research and a Hypothetical Circulation Model Presented Prior t o the Research T. Teramoto . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3
Chapter 2: Structure of Subsurface Water Circulation and Associated Distribution of Water Properties Deep Water Properties and Circulation in the Western North Pacific M. Kawabe . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Density Field along 12"N and 13'N in the Philippine Sea I<. Uehara, I(. Taira and A. Masuda . . . . . . . . . .
...
17
..........
39
Abyssal Boundary Current along the Northwestern Perimeter of the Philippine Basin M. Chaen, M. Fukasawa, A. Maeda, M. Sakurai and M. Takematsu . . . 51 Deep Circulation in the Shikoku Basin Measured with the SOFAR floats K. Taira and D. Yanagimoto . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
69
Chapter 3: Circulation and Mixing of Water as Deduced from Distribution of Chemical Tracers Chemistry and the Oceans:* An Overview Y. Nozaki . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
...................
83
Philippine Sea Abyssal Waters in the Northwestern Pacific: Characterization from Tracer-Tracer Diagrams
T. Gamo
...................................
91
Dynamics of the Japan Sea Deep Water Studied with Chemical and R a d i e chemical Tracers S. Tsunogai, Y. W. Watanabe, I(. Harada, S. Watanabe, S. Saito and M. Nakajima . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 105 Instrumental Development for Measurement of Phosphate in Seawater and Some Discussion of Nutrient Distributions in the North Pacific K. Fujiwara and H. Tsubota . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 121 Actinium-227: A Steady State Tracer for the Deep-sea Basin-wide Circulation and Mixing Studies 139 Y. Nozaki . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
...
Vlll
Distributions and Mass-balance of 2399240Pu and 137Cs in the Northern North Pacific 157 Y. Nagaya and K. Nakamura . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
Trace Metals in the North Pacific - Recent Development of Clean Techniques and their Applications t o Ocean Chemistry H. Tsubota, S. Nakamura and K. Shitashima . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 169 Distribution of Dissolved Organic Nitrogen in the North Pacific Ocean Y. Maita and M. Yanada . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
185
Determination of Some Oxyacid Elements and Manganese in Seawater and their Distributions in Some Unique Environments of the North Pacific E. Nakayama, Y. Sohrin and K. Isshiki . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 199
Chapter 4: Vertical Flux of Chemical Substances and their Behaviours in the Deep Oceans Seasonal Variation of Lithogenic Flux in Japan Trench Continental Slope Measured by Sediment Trap S. Noriki, R. Saito, C. Saito and S . Tsunogai . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21 1 Vertical Fluxes of Organic Materials in the Northern North West Pacific and Breid Bay, Antarctica, with Special Reference in the Effect of Phytoplankton Bloom N. Handa and T. Nakatsuka. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 221 Organic Composition of Sinking Particles (JT-01) in Japan Trench as Revealed by Pyrolysis Gas Chromatography/mass Spectrometry R. Ishiwatari, S. Yamamoto, N. Handa and Y. Nozaki . . . . . . . . . 235
Chapter 5: Modelling of Subsurface Water Circulation and Associated Dynamical Processes Numerical Modelling of the Philippine Sea M.Kubota . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.................
255
The Occurrence of Vacillation in a Model Ocean Driven by Wind, Heat and Salinity Flux K. Takeuchi and Y. Kashino . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 273 Modelling of Western Pacific Abyssal Circulation - Preliminary Experiment N. Suginohara, S. Aoki and M. Nakata. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Diagnostic Approaches on Deep Ocean Circulation N. Imasato, H. Nagashima, H. Takeoka and S. Fuji0
285
. . . . . . . . . . . 307
Laboratory Experiments of Dense Water Descending on Continental Slope Y. Nagata, R. Kimura, H. Honji, Y. Yamazaki, K. Kawaguchi and T. Hosoyamada . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. 333
ix Chapter 6: Development of Acoustic Technology for Ocean Measurement Target Parameter Estimation by Linear-Period h4odulated Signal W. Mitsuhashi and H. Mochizuki . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
....
353
A Low Frequency Underwater Sound Source and Control Technique of Transducer Directivity .365 H. Hachiya and M. Okujima . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Development of Multipaths Inverted Echosounder T. Takeuchi and K. Taira . . . . . . . . . . . .
..............
375
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Chapter 1 Motivation of the Project Research and a Hypothetical Circulation model presented prior to the Research
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Deep Ocean Circulation. Physical and Chemical Aspects edited by T. Teramoto 0 1993 Elsevier Science Publishers B.V. All rights reserved.
3
Motivation of the Project Research and a Hypothetical Circulation Model Presented Prior to the Research Toshihiko TERAMOTO*
1.
Motivation of the Project Research
The subtropical area of the western North Pacific is much different in topographic feature from that of the western North Atlantic. The former is characterized by the Izu-Ogasawara-Mariana Ridges running almost longitudinally across the western part of it and the latter, by the Grand Banks occupying the north of the western part of it (Fig. 1). The difference, however, does not actually exert any serious influence upon the surface subtropical circulation, and the circulations in the both oceans are almost similar in configuration. In another words, the Kuroshio flowing along the continental boundary and the subsequent Kuroshio Extension flowing into the central ocean of the Pacific correspond well in their combination t o the Florida Current and the subsequent Gulf Stream of the Atlantic. In contrast to this, the characteristic bottom topographies described above seem t o affect greatly t o the deep circulations of the oceans. According t o the deep circulation model hypothetically delineated by Stommel and Arons (1960), the deep western boundary current in the North Pacific flows along the eastern side of the above-stated ridges and not along the continental boundary but that in the North Atlantic flows closely along the continental boundary (Fig. 1). Thus, the Philippine Sea, which is bounded by the continental boundary in the west and with the ridges in the east, has long been considered to be isolated in the deep layer from the main part of the North Pacific (Fig. 1). This leads t o an understanding that the deep water of the sea is almost stagnant and is old in age. The age determination with 14C indicated the deep water of the Philippine Sea is younger by about 200 years than that of the main North Pacific (Gamo, personal communication). This fact suggests that the deep western boundary current branches into the sea through the Yap-Palao Trough on the Mariana ridge soon after the current flows into the northern hemisphere upon passing over the equator (Fig. 2). This implies the deep Philippine Sea water is also involved in the deep circulation of the North Pacific. What is the configuration of the deep circulation of the western North Pacific? This question motivated the author t o programme the present project research. *School of Science, Kanagawa University Tsuchiya 2946, Hiratsuka, Kanagawa 259-12, Japan
4
Fig. 1. The bottom topography of the world ocean (lower panel) and the configurational model of the deep circulation by stommel and Arons (upper panel) (Open university/Pergamon). The programme is naturally expected t o give a solution to the question on what the flow configuration under the Kuroshio is, a question t h a t has long been borne in minds of many Japanese oceanographers.
2. 2.1.
The Subsurface Circulation Model Presented to be Verified through the Project Research The mid-depth circulation model
Through long-term measurements of vertical profile of velocity in the Kuroshio area south of Japan, the level of no motion is determined to be a t the depth around
5
Fig. 2 . The detailed bottom topography of the Philippine Sea and western North Pacific (Mogi, 1972). 2,000 m (Fukasawa and Teramoto, 1986). Thus, on taking the reference level at the isobaric surface of 2,000 db, the contour maps of geopotential anomalies on the isobaric surfaces of 1,000 and 3,000 d b for the Philippine Sea and western North Pacific (Fig. 3) are drawn on the basis of accurate hydrographic observations (Kaneko and Teramoto, submitted to J. Oceanogr.). The figure gives the configurational model of the mid-depth circulation, which has a two-layer structure separated at the isobaric surface of 2,000 db. The mid-depth used here is defined t o involve depths below 1,000 m and above 3,000 m. The most characteristic feature of the configuration is the elliptic eddy occupying the whole area of the Shikoku Basin (Fig. 2 ) . The eddy is commonly of the size of about 1,200 km in longer diameter and 600 km in shorter one both in the upper and lower mid-depth layers but is rotating clockwise in the upper layer and anticlockwise in the lower one. The geostrophic velocity profile associated with the eddy is almost equal t o t h a t from the direct measurements stated above. Through the water-mass analysis, the mid-depth water of the Philippine Sea and western North Pacific is understood to be classified typically into three water types; that is, the South Philippine Sea Water, Shikoku Basin Water and Northwest Pacific Water (Kaneko and Teramoto, submitted t o J. Oceanogr.). These water types, each of which is identified here by a combination of S (Salinity), DO
6
Fig. 3. Contour maps of geopotential anomaly on isobaric surfaces of 1,000 d b (upper panel) and 3,000 d b (lower panel) for the Philippine Sea and western North Pacific. The reference level is put at, 2,000 d b surface. (Dissolved Oxygen) and DSi (Dissolved Silica) of water, are defined as averages of
S,DO and DSi of water samples from ten stations in regions of 10'00' to 13"02'N, 125'37' t o 137'00'E in the South Philippine Sea, 32'30' to 33'32'N, 135'49'to 138'05'E in the Shikoku Basin and 29'55' to 35"56'N, 146'34' to 160'00'E in the western North Pacific, respectively. Actually, waters of S, DO and DSi in ranges of twice the standard deviations in distributions of S, DO and DSi over the ten stations are regarded as those of water types under consideration. Thus, the water
7
31.61
-
- 31.61 JI 6234.61-
SBW :31.6a 34.59-
'
'
,
'
I
NwPW
.
a
SBW
A
SPS\\' - 0 3 1
DO (mi
Fig. 4. S-DO diagramme (left upper panel) and DSi-DO diagramme (left lower panel) on the isopycnal surface of 0-0 = 27.70 for water samples in the Philippine Sea and western North Pacific. Positions for these water samplings are shown by the use of six kinds of symbol, which are used to identify the six areas illustrated on the right panel of the figure. Squares with symbols of SPSW, SBW and NWPW on the diagrammes indicate the domains for water types of south Philippine Sea Water, Shikoku Basin Water and Northwest Pacific Water, respectively. types are specified not at points but within square domains on S-DO and DO-DSi diagrammes as illustrated for the isopycnal surface of cr0 = 27.70 in Fig. 4. This isopycnal surface almost corresponds with isobaric surface of 2,000 db. The geographic distribution of these three water types on the isopycnal surface of = 27.70 is drawn in Fig. 5 (Kaneko and Teramoto, submitted t o J. Oceanogr.). Upon comparison of this figure t o Fig. 3 it is clearly indicated that the area of the Shikoku Basin Water in the mid-depth layer around 2,000 d b coincides very well with those occupied by the elliptic eddy described above. As suggested from S-DO and DO-DSi relations in Fig. 4, the Shikoku Basin Water cannot be formed through the linear horizontal mixing of waters of the other two water types. And so, the formation seems to be made through vertical mixing associated with the eddy motion of the intense vertical shear of velocity.
8
. . . .
m m m m m m
Fig. 5. The geographical distributions of water types of SPSW SBW (A)and NWPW ( W ) on the isopycnal surface of ~0 = 27.70.
2.2.
(0):
The deep circulation model
As seen on S-DO-DSi diagramme in Fig. 6, the square domains for the water type of the Shikoku Basin Water overlap with those of the South Philippine Sea Water for the deep layer around the isopycnal surface of 0 0 = 27.77. This surface corresponds to the isobaric surface of 3,000 db. The deep layer mentioned here implies the layer between 3,000 and 4,000 ni in depth. Thus, the deep layer of the whole Philippine Sea including the Shikoku Basin is known t o be filled with the South Philippine Sea Water. Then, the question arises on where the origin of this water is. For the purpose of tracing the characteristics of the water in contrast t o the North Pacific Water, Kaneko and the author draw S-DO (upper panel) and DSi-DO (lower panel) diagrammes in Fig. 7 for water samples from three groups of station in the following cruises; that is, the Ryofu-Maru Cruise along 137"E in the Philippine Sea, the Hakuho-Maru Cruise along 158"E in the western North Pacific and GEOSECS EXPEDITION almost along 180" in the equatorial area over the northern and southern hemispheres (Fig. 7). These diagrammes for the isopycnal surface of ce = 27.77 indicate that the deep Philippine Sea Water can be traced t o branches 08 from the deep equatorial water at around sta. 4 of the GEOSECS EXPEDITION near 10"s and t h a t the deep Northwest Pacific Water, on the contrary, from the deep equatorial water at around sta. 1 of the GEOSECS EXPEDITION near 5"N. These facts suggest that a part of the deep western boundary current, which flows northwards after passing through the Samoan Passage (Fig. 7), branches eastwards into the Philippine Sea and that the rest of the current flows further northwards
9
31.G5
t
1301
2.8
3.0
3.2
3.4
DO ( i d P ) Fig. 6 . S-DO diagramme (upper panel) and DSi-DO diagramme (lower panel) on the isopycnal surface of uo = 27.77 for water samples in the Philippine Sea and western North Pacific. Symbols used are the same as in Fig. 5.
into the western North Pacific along the Izu-Ogasawara-Mariana Ridge. As delineated in Fig. 8 (Kaneko and the author), the isolines for DSi and DO on the isopycnal surface of U Q = 27.77 are almost of the longitudinal, configuration, which is clearly different from the latitudinal one on the isopycnal surface of CTQ = 27.55 in the same figure. The latter surface agrees almost with the isobaric surface of 1,500 db, where the circulation is delineated as in Fig. 9(b). The current associated with the circulation on this surface is zonal and the isolines is parallel t o the current except for the western boundary region. On taking into consideration the fact that in the deep layer the isolines for DSi and DO are longitudinal and also the fact that the deep current directly measured flows westwards in the northern boundary region, the author modelled hypothet,ically the deep circulation of the Philippine Sea as illustrated in Fig. 9(d) on referring t o the world deep circulation
10 3 4 . 701
I
1.0
I. 5
2.5
2.0
3:5
3.0
D I S S O L V E 0 O X Y G E N (ml/l)
22!
%-\ 5'6
1
-3 .4
.5 1.0
1.5
2.0
nissnLvEo
2.5
3.0
-6
3.5
O X Y G E N rml/li
Fig. 7. S-DO diagramme (left upper panel) and DSi-DO diagramme (left lower panel) on the isopycnal surface of = 27.77 for water samples from stations of three cruises; Ryofu-Maru Cruise along 137"E (A), Hakuho-Maru Cruise along 158"E ( 0 )and GEOSECS EXPEDITION almost along 180" ( W ) . Station maps for the three cruises are shown in the right panel. model by Stommel and Arons (1960), in which the boundary current, interior flow and the associated upwelling play the essential role in combination. On summarizing these results the author, prior to commencing our project research, presented the layered model for the subsurface circulations of the Philippine Sea and western North Pacific as illustrated in Fig 9(b), (c) and (d) in contrast to that for the surface circulation (Fig 9(a)). The verification of the model through measurements as well as the understanding of the mechanism to produce the circulation provided the most important subjects to be worked out in our project research. In the modelling, the bottom circulation is omitted because of its serious dependency upon the bottom topography, which is very complicated.
3.
Flow Diagramme of the Project Research The project consists of research groups of the following specific activities:
11
i?b.F' "
~
"
'136'
"
'
' 'llti' ' "
"
' " lio' " " " "160' ' ""I
'
170''
" "
Fig. 8. The geographical configurations of isolines for DSi and DO distributions on the isopycnal surface of o g = 27.77 (left panel) and those on the isopycnal surface of ot)= 27.55 (right panel). (1) long-term Eulerian measurements of subsurface boundary current by the use of moored arrays of current meters. (2) Lagrangian measurements of subsurface interior flow by the use of SOFAR Float system. (3) accurate hydrographic observations with CTD and Rosette Water Sampler to obtain the distribution of geopotential as well as concentrations of dissolved
oxygen and silica. (4) accurate measurements of distributions of chemical tracers such as natural and artificial radionuclides, dissolved heavy metals and so on. (5) subsequent trapping of drifting sediments for long time t o reveal the transporting and diffusing processes of chemical substances in the deep ocean. ( 6 ) simulation and assimilation of subsurface circulation processes by means of numerical and hydraulic models.
12
Fig. 9. T h e configurational model of circulations in the surface layer between 0 t o 1,000 m (left upper panel), the upper mid-depth layer between 1,000 t o 2,000 m (left lower Panel), the lower mid-depth layer between 2,000 t o 3,000 m (right upper panel) and the deep layer between 3,000 t o 4,000 m (right lower panel) for t,he Philippine Sea and western North Pacific.
(7) development of new technologies t o make possible the more accurate measurements, quicker measurements and measurements of new qualities. These research activities have been organized in close mutual combination in accordance the flow diagram shown in Fig. 10.
References Fukasawa, M., and T. Teramoto, 1986. Characteristics of deep circulation off Cape Shionomisaki before and after formation of large meander of the Kuroshio in 1981. J. Oceanogr. SOC.Japan, 42(1), 53-68. Kaneko, I., and T. Teramoto, 1985. Water exchange between Shikoku-Philippine Basin and the North Pacific Ocean. In: Ocean Characteristics and their Changes, K. Kajiwara (ed.), Koseisha-Koseikaku, Tokyo, pp. 54-77 (in Japanese). Mogi, A., 1972. Bathymetry of the Kuroshio region. In: The Kuroshio, Its Physical aspects, H. Stommel and K. Yoshida (eds.), University of Tokyo Press, Tokyo, pp. 54-
1,
Numerical modeling Hydrauric modeling Data assimilation-----l
Exploratlon of mechanisms of ocean circulation
>-<
)- ,
Eulerian current measurements i&Lagranqian current measurements LCTD measurements
Delineation of deep ocean circulation
<
1
Preliminary presention of a hypothetical circulation model
Establishment of deep circulation model h
I Sediment trapping
of acoustic technology for ocean measurement
A
I
Exploration of substance cycle
chemical tracer distribution in the deep ocean
Fig. 10. T h e flow diagramme of the project research.
Water sampling and analysis
CL
w
14 80. Stommel, H., and A. Arons, 1960. On the abyssal circulation of the world ocean 11. Deep-sea Res., 6, 217-233.
Chapter 2 Structure of Subsurface Water Circulation and Associated Distribution of Water Properties
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Deep Ocean Circulation, Physical and Chemical Aspects edited by T. Teramoto 0 1993 Elsevier Science Publishers B.V. All rights reserved.
17
Deep Water Properties and Circulation in the Western North Pacific Masaki KAWABE*
Abstract Circulations of deep water in the Philippine Sea and the western North Pacific are examined from distributions of water properties, mainly c ~ 3and dissolved oxygen. 3 41.52 and 41.48 (around 4000 db), On the isopycnal surfaces of ( ~ between western boundary current, which carries high-oxygen water from the South Pacific, passes the Central Pacific and Melanesian Basins, and then flows northward through the central region of East Mariana Basin: it does not enter the Philippine Sea directly. On the other hand, the current on the 41.45 surface (about 3000 db) flows into the Philippine Sea and brings highoxygen waters directly, since the sea fully opens to the south of 12'30". Water circulation is greatly different between 41.48 and 41.45. The western boundary current seems to be weak on the 41.30 surface (about 2000 db). Waters between 41.51 and 41.48 flow into the Philippine Sea through the deepest gap of the Izu-Ogasawara-Mariana Ridge around 12'N, 139'E. Water at deeper than the gap does not enter a t all. The inflow water has clearly less oxygen than the water carried by the western boundary current. It spreads from the West Mariana Basin to the Shikoku and Philippine Basins. Oxygen on deep isopycnal surfaces in the Philippine Sea is much higher than that in the western North Pacific. This is probably caused by not only the inflow water having relatively high oxygen but also a convergence of upward oxygen flux.
1.
Introduction
Deep water cannot be produced in the North Pacific (Stommel, 1958; Warren, 1983), and it comes from the Antarctic after a long trip along the western boundary of the South Pacific. The mixed water of the Antarctic Bottom Water and the Circumpolar Water goes northward east of New Zealand and along the TongaKermadec Ridge, and enters the Central Pacific Basin through the Samoan Passage (Reid and Lynn, 1971; Warren, 1973; Reid and Lonsdale, 1974; Mantyla, 1975). The water originally shows a clear salinity maximum which is a remnant of the North Atlantic Deep Water, but the maximum becomes deeper and less clear due to mixing as it moves northward (Mantyla and Reid, 1983). Then, the core-shaped salinity maximum disappears north of the Samoan Passage, and the maximum *Ocean Research Institute, University of Tokyo, Minamidai, Nakano-ku, Tokyo 164, Japan
18 salinity of deep water is observed at the sea bottom in the North Pacific (Reid and Lynn, 1971). Concentration of dissolved oxygen also attains its maximum at the bottom. After passing through the Samoan Passage, flow paths are different by depth. The flow well examined so far is that of the Pacific Bottom Water which is steered by 5000-m isobaths. Part of the bottom water in the Central Pacific Basin flows eastward, passes through the Horizon and Clarion Passages, turns northward at the southeast of the Hawaiian Ridge, and finally enters the Northeast Pacific Basin (Edmond et al., 1971; Reid and Lonsdale, 1974; Mantyla, 1975). Other part flows out through the Wake Island Passage, and extends t o the Northwest Pacific and East Mariana Basins (Mantyla, 1975). The bottom water finally reaches the Northeast Pacific Basin through the northern margin of the Pacific and the passage north of the Hawaiian Ridge. Pioneer works of deep circulation in the North Pacific such as Wooster and Volkmann (1960) and Knauss (1962) also treat the near-bottom circulation controlled by 5000-m isobaths. At this depth, the Philippine Sea is perfectly separated from the main part of the North Pacific by the Izu-Ogasawara-Mariana Ridge. In the present study, water properties and circulation at lesser depths, mainly about 4000-m depths, will be examined. The difference in bottom topography by depth causes a difference in path of the western boundary current and in water exchange through the Izu-Ogasawara-Mariana Ridge (A to B in Fig. la) and the Kyushu-Palau Ridge (a t o b in Fig. la). The word “western North Pacific” will be used for the region except the Philippine Sea, although the word usually includes it. Mantyla and Reid (1983) concluded the inflow into the Philippine Sea through the deep gap north of the Yap Island and described briefly the water circulation in the Philippine Sea, on a basis of the global maps of water properties near the sea bottom. The near-bottom distributions are effective t o study a bottom-water move, but a slow adiabatic motion like a deep-water circulation actually occurs on a neutral surface, any motion along which does not change potential energy. A neutral surface at an arbitrary pressure coincides with the isopycnal surface referred t o the pressure (McDougall, 1987). Hence, the isopycnal surfaces with a large reference pressure must be used for the study of deep-water circulation (Reid and Lynn, 1971). The potential density referred t o 3000 db, ~ 7 3 ,will be used here. The deep inflow into the Philippine Sea was concluded also from the vertical distribution of water properties in the Philippine Sea (Sudo, 1982; Uehara and Taira, 1990), but it has not been confirmed with direct measurements of water current. I will examine the inflow by comparing the distributions of water properties with bottom topography and between the inner and outer regions of the Philippine Sea. It is well known that dissolved oxygen on an isopycnal surface in the Philippine Sea is much richer than that in the western North Pacific, as it is shown, for example, in the figures on isopycnal surfaces a t depths of about 1000 m, 2000 m and 3000 m in Kaneko and Teramoto (1985). This is a unexpected phenomenon t h a t the isolated marginal basin, where waters must be stagnating, is filled with
19 oxygen-rich, namely young waters. Many oceanographers are interested in this phenomenon, but it has not been described concretely and exactly. This is another issue in this paper.
2.
Data
Many hydrographic data were used in this study. The data sources are ocean expeditions INDOPAC (Scripps Institution of Oceanography, 1978), GEOSECS (National Science Foundation, 1982), EURYDICE (Scripps Institution of Oceanography, 1986) and WEPOCS (Joint Institute for Marine and Atmospheric Research, 1986) and Japanese cruises by R / V Hakuho Maru (Ocean Research Institute, 1971, 1975,1981, 1983,1988), Kaiyo Maru (Sudo, 1978, 1979), Ryofu Maru (Japan Meteorological Agency, 1982, 1989) and Takuyo (Japan Maritime Safety Agency, 1987). Moreover, from the historical hydrographic dataset kept by the Japan Oceanographic Data Center (JODC Reference 87-099), the data after 1964 taken down t o deeper than 3000 m were retrieved and used after checking d a t a quality. Data of isobath and water depth (5’ x 5’ mesh) were provided from the Japan Oceanographic Data Center (JODC Reference 84-037, 87-097), and were used t o draw isobaths and bottom topographies.
3.
Features of Massive Ridges
Bottom topographies steer deep-water current, and, as a result, have a decisive influence on distributions of water properties in deep layers. In particular, the ridge shown with the thick line of A to B in Fig. l a is greatly important to water exchange between the western North Pacific and the Philippine Sea. This main ridge is composed of some lesser ridges, i.e., the Shichito-Iojima Ridge, the West Mariana Ridge, and ridges connecting the islands of Yap, Palau and Sonsorol. It is generally called the Izu-Ogasawara-Mariana Ridge. A gap deeper than 4000 m exists only between 11’35” and 11’55’N, having a maximum depth of about 4450 m (Fig. l b ) . This is the deepest passage connecting the Philippine Sea with the western North Pacific. Gaps deeper than 3500 m increase to five. Three of them, including the deepest one, are located between 10’15” and 12’10” in the area which is often called the Yap-Mariana Junction. Other two gaps around 8’20” and between 1’50” and 2’30” connect the West Caroline Basin with the West Mariana and Philippine Basins, respectively. They are, however, expected to play much smaller roles in water exchange between the Philippine Sea and the outer regions than the gaps in the Yap-Mariana Junction, because of small width of the former gap and obstruction by many seamounts around the latter gap. At a depth of 3000 m, the deep gaps increase their widths, and some gaps add in the south of 8’40”. As a result, the ridge south of 12”30’N is much less effective as a barrier of water exchange, whereas the ridge north of 12”30’N is still a complete barrier. Passages of water increase more at a depth of 2000 m. At this depth, the ridge south of 30”N does not significantly prevent the water exchange between the Philippine Sea and the western North Pacific.
20 The Kyushu-Palau Ridge (a t o b in Fig. la) plays an important role in water exchange between the basins in the Philippine Sea. This ridge has four gaps deeper than 4000 m, which are located from 17'45" to 18"15'N, 19"N to 19"25'N, 22"N t o 23'20" (this divides into two gaps at deeper than 4050 m), and 23'55" t o 24'20" (Fig. lc). Another deep gap is shown around 30"30'N in Fig. lc, but it shoals t o about 4000 m just t o the west. Therefore, water exchange at deeper than 4000 m is only possible between the northern parts of the West Mariana and Philippine Basins. At depth less than 4000 m, passages of water much increase, and waters can also exchange between the southern parts of the West Mariana and Philippine Basins and between the Shikoku and Philippine Basins.
4.
Deep-Water Circulations Deduced from the Distributions of Water Properties
Figures 2 and 3 show vertical distributions of potential density referred t o 3000 d b ( a 3 ) ,potential temperature referred t o the sea surface, salinity and dissolved oxygen along about 13"N (S1 in Fig. la) and 23ON (S2). Density in the
~,
Rise
" Q
Fig. 1. (a) Map of the Philippine Sea and the western North Pacific. Thin lines are 4000-m isobaths. Thick lines of A to B and a t o b show the Izu-Ogasawara-Mariana Ridge and the Kyushu-Palau Ridge, respectively. The lines S1 and S2 indicate the sections, water properties on which are shown in Fig. 2 and 3. Dots on the lines are stations of hydrographic observation. (b) Section of the Izu-Qgasawara-Mariana Ridge (A t o B in Fig. la). (c) Section of the Kyushu-Palau Ridge (a t o b in Fig. la).
21 A
B 0
5
10
,131
132
1
.
1
,
b
BN
10
,
4
140
1
,
I
1
,
133
8
30
25
,
8
_ I _ _ I _
143
20
15
U ! 1, 1
0 .
8
8
137
134
20
15 i
1
<
,
135
I
1
, , ,
35N
__Lt.
140
,
,
25
,
,
,
140E1
a
,
3,O , 3,2 N ,
136
Fig. 1. (continued) western North Pacific shows simply layered stratification at all depths, while in the Philippine Sea a similar stratification is seen only at shallower than the isopycnal surface of u3 = 41.48 (about 3700 db), and the density stratification between 41.48 and 41.52 is different by basins and latitudes. 3 41.30, 41.45, On a basis of these characteristics, six isopycnal surfaces ( ~ = 41.48, 41.49, 41.50 and 41.52) are selected, and dissolved oxygen on these surfaces is mapped in Fig. 4. They are believed to reflect flow distributions. On the other hand, salinity is highly uniform on an isopycnal surface of 41.45 and more, and t h e uniformity increases with depth. Hence, salinity only on the 41.30 surface is shown in Fig. 5.
22 4.1. Deep-water circulation in the western North Pacific The isopycnal surface of C T ~= 41.52 exists between 4100 d b and 5100 d b in the western North Pacific (Fig. 2a, 3a). Dissolved oxygen on this surface shows that high-oxygen waters coming from the South Pacific flow northwestward through the Central Pacific and Melanesian Basins, then proceed northward in the central region of the East Mariana Basin, and reach around 25"N, 156"E (Fig. 4a). This is expected t o be a path of the western boundary current around 4000 db. Although the further downstream path cannot be supposed exactly from the oxygen map, distribution of oxygen higher than 3.8 ml1-I suggests that the current changes the direction t o eastward and northwestward. Part of the waters flowing eastward appears t o enter the Northeast Pacific Basin through the north of the Hawaiian Ridge, like the Pacific Bottom Water, while other parts turn northward along the Emperor Seamount Chain, and turn again westward along 35"N. The waters likely proceed north and south of the Shatsky Rise, and encounter the high-oxygen waters flowing northwestward from 25"N, 156"E. The concentration of oxygen much decreases as approaching t o the Izu-Ogasawara Ridge, and a further continuation of the circulation cannot be inferred. Similar circulation is suggested also on the isopycnal surfaces of C T ~ = 41.50, 41.49 and 41.48 (Fig. 4b,c,d). 4.2.
Inflow to the Philippine Sea in deep layers
The maximum density in the Philippine Sea is 41.517 and is found near the bottom in the region close t o the deepest gap in the Yap-Mariana Junction (Fig. 2a). The densest water is 1.080 or 1.099"C in potential temperature, 34.688 or 34.693 in salinity, and 3.73 ml 1-1 in oxygen (Fig. 2b,c,d). Waters having almost the same properties are found just outside the Philippine Sea at a depth of bottom of the deepest gap (INDOPAC Station at 10"52'N, 140"ll'E): 0 3 = 41.514, PT = 1.103"C, S = 34.693 and 0 2 = 3.74 ml 1-l. The depth of the gap is 4454 m according t o the depth data averaged in 5' x 5' grids, whose value corresponds t o 4522 db. Thus, the outside waters around the gap bottom occupy the deepest layer of the Philippine Sea near the gap, and the deeper waters in the western North Pacific, which are denser than 41.52, do not exist in the Philippine Sea. This strongly suggests that water in the western North Pacific flows into the Philippine Sea, but the water is limited to that at shallower than the bottom of the deepest gap. No other inflow at deeper than 4000 m is permitted by bottom topography (Sec. 3). The existence of the deep inflow into the Philippine Sea has been concluded by many authors (e.g., Sudo, 1982; Mantyla and Reid, 1983; Uehara and Taira, 1990), and they described that the water coming from the South Pacific flows into the Philippine Sea. However, the distribution of oxygen does not show a direct inflow of the oxygen-rich water coming from the South Pacific (Fig. 4b, c). The entrance region of the West Mariana Basin is occupied by relatively low-oxygen waters, which can be traced t o the western region of the East Mariana Basin. The inflow water may be carried by southward current along just east of the Mariana Ridge. Such current is actually shown in the map of geopotential anomaly referred
23 to 1200 d b in Moriyasu (1972). Another inflow at shallower than 4000 m occurs through the southernmost deep gap between the West Caroline and Philippine Basins. This is inferred from the existence of water of C T ~ = 41.49 in the southeast end of the Philippine Basin (Fig. 4c) and low oxygen in the south end of the basin on the 41.48 surface, which can be traced t o the West Caroline Basin (Fig. 4d). The distributions of water and oxygen do not suggest a significant outflow from the Philippine Sea on the 41.48 and deeper surfaces. Probably only inflow, at least net inflow, occurs through the gaps of the Izu-Ogasawara-Mariana Ridge. The inflow water must go t o the upper layer due t o the mass conservation, and, in other words, the upward mass flux occurs in the Philippine Sea. 4.3.
Deep-water circulation in the Philippine Sea
Waters entering through the deepest gap in the Yap-Mariana Junction occupy the West Mariana Basin on the surface of cr3 = 41.50 (Fig. 4b). The extension of water increases on the 41.49 surface; part of the water extends northward and enters the Shikoku Basin, while the remainder enters the northern region of the Philippine Basin through the deep gaps of the Kyushu-Palau Ridge between 17"N and 25"N (Sec. 3), and moreover extends t o the west and south in the Philippine Basin (Fig. 4c). This shows a water circulation along the sea bottom in the Philippine Sea. Similar description was yielded by Mantyla and Reid (1983). The waters denser than 41.50 spread northward along the western slope of the Mariana Ridge in the eastern region of the West Mariana Basin (Fig. 2a, 3a, 4b). This is consistent with the northeastward flow near the entrance shown by Uehara and Taira (1990), and seems to coincide with the flow along isobaths calculated numerically by Kubota and Ono (1992). Topographic /3 effect of the ridge slope may be essential to the bottom flow in the West Mariana Basin. The isopycnal surface of C T ~ = 41.49 deepens greatly over the Kyushu-Palau Ridge towards the Philippine Basin (Fig. 3a).l The 41.51 surface similarly deepens over the deepest gap of the Izu-Ogasawara-Mariana Ridge towards the West Mariana Basin, as the 41.51 surface in Fig. 2a is deeper than 4400 d b whose value is the depth of 41.51 at the just outer station. The 41.50 and 41.49 surfaces deepen downstream also in interior regions of the West Mariana and Philippine Basins, respectively (Fig. 2a, 3a). These show a large downstream gradient of horizontal pressure over the ridges and in the interior regions of the basins, since water motions are probably smaller at lesser depths. The pressure gradient in the bottomattached layer may balance with bottom friction, and may be essential t o the water movement of spreading over the ridges and on the sea bottom. Accompanied by the deepening of isopycnal surfaces, waters with C T ~more than 41.49 disappear gradually along the circulation. In other words, the density stratification at deeper than the 41.48 surface weakens in the downstream direction, and finally disappears in the southern part of the Philippine Basin. Potential temperature, salinity and oxygen also show similar changes (Fig. 2 and 3). As a result, the lNote that the Kyushu-Palau Ridge in Fig. 3 is a small mountain at 137'E, not a large one at 135'E. The large mountain is the southern end of the Oki-Daito Ridge.
24
I00
200
300
400 db
500
600
700 1
1000
2000
5000
4000 d b
5000
6000
7000
Fig. 2. Vertical distributions of water properties along S1 (about 13"N). (a) a 3 ( K P and M in the figure show the Kyushu-Palau and Mariana Ridges respectively), (b) potential temperature ("C), (c) salinity, (d) dissolved oxygen (ml 1-'). waters of a3 between 41.48 and 41.49 occupy the largest volume in the Philippine Sea. They have potential temperature between 1.2"C and 1.3"C, salinity between 34.68 and 34.69, and dissolved oxygen between 3.5 ml 1-' and 3.6 ml 1-'. The 41.48 surface is quite shallower than 4000 db, and the waters of v3 = 41.48
25
1000
2000
3000
4000 db 5000
6000
7000
Fig. 2.
(continued)
can exchange through many gaps of the Kyushu-Palau Ridge, not only between the northern parts of the West Mariana and Philippine Basins but also between their southern parts and between the Shikoku and Philippine Basins. In fact, westward flow from the West Mariana Basin to the Philippine Basin through the gap around ll"20'N is suggested by the low-oxygen belt probably made of the inflow water (Fig. 4d). This coincides with the westward flow at 12.5"N in the Philippine Basin shown by Uehara and Taira (1990) using a geostrophic calculation referred
26
120E
Fig. 3.
130
140
150
160
170
180
Same as Fig. 2 except for S2 (about 23"N). The arrows of
K P and OM in Fig. 3a show the Kyushu-Palau and Ogasawara-Mariana Ridges, respectively. to 1500 db. The extension of low oxygen suggests that the flow continues from the West Mariana Basin, and is confined meridionally. The flow is strong and almost barotropic below 3000 db according to the geostrophic calculation, while the oxygen on the 41.45 surface suggests a similar westward flow (Fig. 4e). The entire water between 41.45 and 41.49 appears to flow westward. Although oxygen
27 I20E
i30
i40
150
160
170
130
140
150
160
170
I000
7000
3000
4000 db
5000
6000
1000 1 20E
180
1000
2000
3000
4000 d b
5000
6000
7000
Fig. 3. (continued) does not clearly show other flows, the waters less than 41.49 can exchange through many other gaps in the Kyushu-Palau Ridge. Water circulation at shallower than the 41.49 surface may be modified from that in the deeper layer close t o the bottom.
28 4.4.
Water circulation at shallower depths much less influenced by the ridges
At a depth of the surface of t73 = 41.45 (about 3000 db), the Izu-OgasawaraMariana Ridge opens south of 12'30". The Philippine Sea, the West and East Caroline Basins and the Melanesian Basin are linked directly. As a result, the waters with high oxygen above 3.2 ml l-l, coming from the South Pacific, flow directly into the Philippine Sea through these basins, without entering the East Mariana Basin (Fig. 4e). This is a large difference from the circulation on the deeper surfaces. Less-oxygen waters between 3.1 ml 1-1 and 3.2 ml 1-1 exist at the outer edge of the high-oxygen waters. Parts of them extend northward in the East Mariana Basin, while others enter the Philippine Sea and occupy its southeastern region. This suggests that a northward flow exists in the central area of the East Mariana Basin, as in the deeper layers, and a westward flow separates and enters directly the Philippine Sea. The less-oxygen inflow water passes over the ridge between 10"N and 12O30'N. The oxygen distribution, thus, suggests only inflow in the whole of passage south of 12"30'N. Absence of significant outflow from the Philippine Sea is the same as in the deeper layers. This concludes that a net vertical flux of water in the Philippine Sea is upward, at least, at deeper than the 41.45 surface, and the upward transport increases at a lesser depth. Since the area of the 41.45 surface in the Philippine Sea is little different from that of the 41.48 surface, the upwelling velocity must increase upward at least between these surfaces. This implies that the current is northward in the interior region of the Philippine Sea in which the linear steady balance of vorticity, ,!?v = f . dw/dz, is dominant, where f and ,!? are the Coriolis parameter and its latitudinal change rate, u and w are meridional and vertical velocities, and t is the upward coordinate. On the 41.30 surface (about 2000 db), the western boundary current is suggested from the distribution of oxygen higher than 2.6 mil-' (Fig. 4f). However, the highoxygen waters occupy only a little part of the Philippine Sea, and less-oxygen waters with large range between 2.3 ml 1-1 and 2.6 mi 1-1 occupy the wide area. The western boundary current may be less strong on this surface, and water conversion due t o lateral mixing may be effective. Since the Izu-Ogasawara-Mariana Ridge on this surface opens widely south of 30"N, it is possible that low- and high-oxygen waters flow into the Philippine Sea from the north and south respectively, and mixed waters with medium oxygen flow out in between.
5.
High Concentrations of Dissolved Oxygen on Isopycnal Surfaces in the Philippine Sea
Oxygen on a n isopycnal surface in the Philippine Sea is much richer than t h a t in the western North Pacific (Fig. 4). This characteristic is especially remarkable on the surfaces of t73 = 41.48 and 41.45. The region north of about 10"N in the western North Pacific on the 41.48 surface is occupied by water with oxygen lower than 3.4 ml l-', except a small region east of the north Japan (Fig. 4d). On the other hand, most region on the surface in the Philippine Sea is occupied by oxygen
29 higher than 3.4 ml 1-1 and partly by higher than 3.5 ml 1-l. It should be noted that high-oxygen waters more than 3.5 ml 1-1 do not come from the South Pacific, and they exist only in the almost closed basins: the Philippine Sea and the West and East Caroline Basins. Low-oxygen waters less than 3.2 ml 1-1 spread in the northeastern region of the western North Pacific and the region just east of the IzuOgasawara Ridge. Great difference in concentration of oxygen is found between east and west of the Izu-Ogasawara Ridge. Similar distribution is seen on the 41.45 surface (Fig. 4e). High-oxygen waters more than 3.2 ml 1-' occupy most of the Philippine Sea, while low-oxygen waters less than 3.1 ml 1-1 occupy most of the western North Pacific, and oxygens lower than 3.0 ml 1-1 exist in the northern region including just east of the Izu-Ogasawara Ridge. Oxygen and salinity on the 41.30 surface show large meridional variations decreasing northward (Fig. 4f, 5 ) . The isopleths of salinity extend almost zonally, and the distribution is not different between the Philippine Sea and the western North Pacific. On the other hand, the distribution of oxygen is different between them; oxygen in the Philippine Sea is rather uniform between 2.4 ml 1-1 and 2.6 ml l-l, while in the western North Pacific it shows a similar zonal structure t o salinity. The isopleths of oxygen between 1.8 ml 1-' and 2.3 ml 1-1 run meridionally over the Ogasawara Ridge, and they do not enter the Philippine Sea. Oxygen in the Philippine Sea is much higher than that in the western North Pacific on the 41.30 surface also. It should be noted that the difference in concentration of oxygen between the east and west of the Izu-Ogasawara Ridge is larger on shallower isopycnal surfaces. The difference reaches more than 0.6 ml 1-1 on the 41.30 surface. The characteristic of high oxygen in the Philippine Sea is seen also on the 41.49 and 41.50 surfaces (Fig. 4b, c) and on an isopycnal surface at about 1000 d b (Kaneko and Teramoto, 1985). This characteristic holds true in the thick layer down to the sea bottom, at least from 1000 db. Roughly describing, oxygen in the western North Pacific is high in the south region and low in the north. For example, just east of the Izu-Ogasawara-Mariana Ridge, it is low north of about 24"N and relatively high in the south (Fig. 4b to 4e). The main entrance to the Philippine Sea at deeper than the 41.48 surface, i.e., the deepest gap of the ridge, faces the south region filled with high-oxygen water. This is a first reason for the characteristic of high oxygen in the Philippine Sea. However, it is not all. We must notice the facts that oxygen in inner regions of the Philippine Sea is higher than that around the entrance, and that higher-oxygen waters than that coming from the South Pacific exists in the Philippine Sea on the 41.48 surface. These cannot be explained by lateral mixing because of no oxygen source in the Philippine Sea. Consumption of oxygen must result in a downstream decrease of oxygen, contrary t o the facts. The high oxygen may be formed and maintained by convergence of oxygen flux, which is mainly due to the advection of upward velocity. The upward flux from the lower layer is probably effective on this process for the layers around and less than 41.48. However, it is not available for deeper layers, e.g., the layers between 41.49 and 41.50 and between 41.50 and 41.51, because they
30
Fig. 4. Lateral distributions of dissolved oxygen (ml l-l) on isopycnal surfaces. (a) cr3 = 41.52, (b) 41.50, (c) 41.49, (d) 41.48, (e) 41.45, (f) 41.30. touch the sea bottom without a lower layer in most region. A mechanism of the high oxygen on the 41.49 and 41.50 surfaces may not be simple. Higher oxygen must be provided from the deeper layer at the entrance of the West Mariana Basin
31
l"2 0
130
140
150
160 E
I70
180
whiich disappears in a slightly downstream region. Effective transfer of oxygen may be accomplished through a bottom Ekman layer. On the 41.45 and shallower surfaces, the large inflow of high-oxygen water from thc2 South Pacific, carried by the western boundary current, must play a great role
32
N
30
in high oxygen in the Philippine Sea. This may cause the large difference in oxygen between the east and west of the Izu-Ogasawara Ridge on the shallow surfaces.
33
Fig. 5. = 41.30.
6.
Lateral distribution of salinity on the isopycnal surface of
g3
Summary
Characteristics and circulations of deep water in the North Pacific (0-40°N, 120"E-180") are examined using vertical distributions of water properties along 13"N and 23"N and lateral distributions of oxygen on six isopycnal surfaces of ( ~ 3= 41.30, 41.45, 41.48, 41.49, 41.50 and 41.52. Salinity is highly uniform on the 41.45 and deeper isopycnal surfaces. The degree of uniformity increases with depth. Therefore, paths and characteristics of deep flow are studied mainly using distributions of dissolved oxygen. Density stratification in the Philippine Sea is almost common everywhere at shallower than the 41.48 surface (about 3700 db), while it is spatially different in deeper layers between 41.48 and 41.52. The deep-layer stratification gradually weakens downstream along the circulation of bottom water, and finally the density becomes homogeneous in the south region of the Philippine Basin. As a result, the water with C J ~ between 41.48 and 41.49 occupies the largest volume in the Philippine Sea. Potential temperature, salinity and dissolved oxygen show almost the same stratifications as density. The respective properties of the largest volume water are between 1 2 ° C and 1.3"C, 34.68 and 34.69, and between 3.5 ml 1-1 and 3.6 ml 1-l. Since flows along the sea bottom steered by 5000-m isobaths have been examined well previously, shallower flows are examined in this study. On the 41.52 surface (a little deeper than 4000 db), the western boundary current carrying high-oxygen waters from the South Pacific flows northwestward through the Melanesian and
Central Pacific Basins, and then proceeds northward in the central region of the East Mariana Basin. The flow separates t o eastward and northwestward branches around 25"N, 156"E. The eastward flow appears t o separate again: one proceeds further eastward and enters the Northeast Pacific Basin through the north of the Hawaiian Ridge, while the other turns t o north along the Emperor Seamount Chain, turns again t o west along 35"N, and, after passing the Shatsky Rise, joins the other branch flow from 25"N, 156"E. Largest difference from the bottom flow results from the difference of topographic restriction that the current on the 41.52 surface can pass the Melanesian Basin, which closes for the bottom water. Main circulation of water between 41.48 and 41.51 is almost the same as that of 41.52, since the western boundaries in these layers are little different. However, there is a difference in terms of inflow into the Philippine Sea. Major entrance for waters between 41.48 and 41.51 is the deepest gap of the Izu-Ogasawara-Mariana Ridge located around 12"N, 139"E. The waters at deeper than the gap, which are denser than 41.52, do not enter the Philippine Sea, and less dense waters flow into there. Although less important, a gap at the southern end of the ridge is another entrance for the 41.48 and 41.49 waters. It should be noted that the high-oxygen waters coming from the South Pacific do not directly enter the Philippine Sea on these surfaces. Less-oxygen waters, which are probably formed by lateral mixing between the high-oxygen water from the South Pacific and low-oxygen water from the north, seem t o be carried t o the Philippine Sea by southward flow along just east of the Mariana Ridge. The inflow waters denser than 41.50 spread northward along the bottom slope in the west flank of the Mariana Ridge, and water of 41.50 spreads almost everywhere in the West Mariana Basin. Water of 41.49 extends to the Shikoku Basin, while it enters the Philippine Basin through the gaps of the Kyushu-Palau Ridge between 17"N and 25"N. It moreover extends to the west and south in the Philippine Basin. This is the water circulation in the Philippine Sea creeping along the sea bottom. Shallower circulations are expected to be modified by flows through many gaps of the Kyushu-Palau Ridge, such as a westward flow through the gap at ll"20'N. The 41.49 and deeper surfaces change the depth spatially; horizontal pressure in the bottom-attached layer has a downstream gradient over the gaps of the IzuOgasawara-Mariana and Kyushu-Palau Ridges as well as in interior regions of the West Mariana and Philippine Basins. The pressure gradient may balance with bottom friction, and may be essential to the inflow through the gaps and water spread in the basins along the sea bottom. Largest change of water circulation, including the western boundary current, is seen between the isopycnal surfaces of 41.48 and 41.45. On the 41.45 surface (about 3000 db), the entrance of the Philippine Sea greatly enlarges and fully opens south of 12"30'N, so that the western boundary current carrying high-oxygen waters flows directly into the Philippine Sea from the South Pacific by the way of the Melanesian Basin and the West and East Caroline Basins. The inflow transport on the 41.45 surface must be much larger than that on the 41.48 and deeper surfaces. Oxygen maps suggest only the inflow into the Philippine Sea for the 41.45 and deeper surfaces. This results in a upward flux of water in the Philippine Sea which
35 increases as a depth decreases. This leads t o the conclusion t h a t the upwelling velocity increases upward, at least, between the surfaces of 41.45 and 41.48, since the area of surface in the Philippine Sea is little different between them. This implies that the current at least in this layer is northward in a wide interior region of the Philippine Sea, where vorticity is balanced between the p and horizontaldivergence terms. Path of the western boundary current on the 41.30 surface (about 2000 db) is similar to that on the 41.45 surface, but distributions of oxygen and salinity are clearly different between these surfaces. On the 41.30 surface, they show large meridional variations with a northward decrease, and, in particular, salinity remarkably shows a zonal band structure. In the Philippine Sea, high-oxygen waters from the South Pacific occupy little part, and concentration of oxygen has a large range. The inflow flux by the western boundary current must not be dominant, while water conversion due to lateral mixing may be effective. Outflows from the Philippine Sea and other inflows may occur on the 41.30 surface, unlike the 41.45 and deeper surfaces. High oxygen in the Philippine Sea and low oxygen just east of the Izu-Ogasawara Ridge are common characteristics on every isopycnal surfaces between 41.30 and 41.50; so that, the concentration of oxygen is greatly different between the east and west of the ridge. The difference is larger a t lesser depth, reaching more than 0.6 ml 1-l on the 41.30 surface. This is probably due to the large oxygen flux into the Philippine Sea carried by the western boundary current on the 41.45 and shallower surfaces. Two reasons are considered for higher oxygen in the Philippine Sea. One is that the inflow waters have relatively high oxygen, because the entrance of the Philippine Sea is located in the south region filled with high-oxygen waters. The other is a convergence of oxygen flux caused by advection of upward velocity. The latter reason possibly explains t h a t oxygen in inner regions is higher than that near the entrance, and that higher oxygen than that from the South Pacific exists in a part of the Philippine Sea on the 41.48 surface.
Acknowledgment
I thank Dr. H. Sudo for helpful discussion and providing files of the Kaiyo-Maru data, Dr. I. Kaneko for providing d a t a files which he compiled and used in his study, the Japan Oceanographic Data Center for providing historical hydrographic data, and Mrs. M. Kawabe for kind help t o compile d a t a files, draw useful figures and so on. I also thank Drs. T. Teramoto and K. Taira for giving me a chance t o study deep-water circulation. References Edmond, J. M., Y. Chung, and J. G. Sclater, 1971. Pacific Bottom Water: Penetration east around Hawaii. J. Geophys. Res., 76, 8089-8097. Japan Maritime Safety Agency, 1987. Results of oceanographic observations for WESTPAC 1986. Data Report of Hydrographic Observations, No. 2, 79 pp. Japan Meteorological Agency, 1982. The Results of Marine Meteorological and Oceanographical Observations, No. 70, 261 pp.
Japan Meteorological Agency, 1989. The Results of Marine Meteorological and Oceanographical Observations, No. 79, 360 pp. Joint Institute for Marine and Atmospheric Research, University of Hawaii, 1986. Hydrographic Observations from the First U.S. Cruise of the Western Equatorial Pacific Ocean Circulation Study (WEPOCS), June-July 1985. R. Lukas, and M. Tsuchiya (ed.), 350 pp. Kaneko, I., and T . Teramoto, 1985. Sea water exchange between the Shikoku-Philippine Basin and the western North Pacific Basin. In: Ocean Characteristics and their Changes, K. Kajiura (ed.), Koseisha-Koseikaku, pp. 54-77. Knauss, J. A., 1962. On some aspects of the deep circulation of the Pacific. J. Geophys. Res., 67, 3943-3954. Kubota, M., and K. Ono, 1992. Abyssal circulation model of the Philippine Sea. Deep-sea Res., 39, 1439-1452. Mantyla, A. W., 1975. On the potential temperature in the abyssal Pacific Ocean. J. Mar. Res., 33, 341-354. Mantyla, A. W., and J. L. Reid, 1983. Abyssal characteristics of the World Ocean waters. Deep-sea Res., 30, 805-833. McDougall, T. J., 1987. Neutral surfaces. J. Phys. Oceanogr., 17 , 1950-1964. Moriyasu, S., 1972. Deep waters in the western North Pacific. In: Kuroshio - Its Physical Aspects, H. Stommel and K. Yoshida (ed.), Univ. of Tokyo Press, Tokyo, pp. 387-408. National Science Foundation, 1982. Geochemical Ocean Sections Study (GEOSECS) Pacific Expedition, Vol. 3, Hydrographic Data 1973-1974. w . S. Broecker, D. w. Spencer and H. Craig (ed.), 137 pp. Ocean Research Institute, University of Tokyo, 1971. Preliminary Report of the Hakuho Maru Cruise KH-70-1, 3 February - 5 March 1970. Y. Horibe (ed.), 46 pp. Ocean Research Institute, University of Tokyo, 1975. Preliminary Report of the Hakuho Maru Cruise KH-73-1 (IBP Cruise), 10 January 6 February 1973. A. Hattori (ed.), 45 PP. Ocean Research Institute, University of Tokyo, 1981. Preliminary Report of the Hakuho Maru Cruise KH-75-3 (Lyra Expedition), 14 May -- 2 June 1975. Y. Horibe (ed.), 76 PP. Ocean Research Institute, University of Tokyo, 1983. Preliminary Report of the Hakuho Maru Cruise KH-80-2 (CYGNUS Expedition), 25 April - 18 June 1980, and KH-82-1 (CEPHEUS Expedition), 22 January - 17 March 1982. Y. Horibe (ed.), 78 pp. Ocean Research Institute, University of Tokyo, 1988. Preliminary Report of the Hakuho Maru Cruise KH-87-1 (WESTPAC), 22 January - 10 March 1987. T. Teramoto and K. Taira (ed.), 139 pp. Reid, J. L., and P. F. Lonsdale, 1974. On the flow of water through the Samoan Passage. J. Phys. Oceanogr., 4, 58-73. Reid, J. L., and R. L. Lynn, 1971. On the influence of the Norwegian-Greenland and Weddell seas upon the bottom waters of the Indian and Pacific oceans. Deep-sea Res., 18, 1063-1088. Scripps Institution of Oceanography, University of California, 1978. Data Report, Physical, Chemical and Biological Data, INDOPAC Expedition, 23 March 1976 - 31 July 1977. SIO Reference 78-21, 424 pp. Scripps Institution of Oceanography, University of California, 1986. Data Report, Physical, Chemical and Current Meter Data, EURYDICE Expedition Leg X, 10 May - 1 2 June 1975. SIO Reference 86-20, 30 pp. Stommel, H., 1958. The abyssal circulation. Deep-sea Res., 5, 80-82. ~
37 Sudo, H., 1978. Physical data from the hydrographic survey on marine organism in relation to deep-sea disposal of radioactive wastes in the central western North Pacific aboard R. V. Kaiyo Maru in 1972 to 1974. Datum Collect. Tokai Reg. Fish. Res. Lab., 7, 1-40. Sudo, H., 1979. Physical data from the hydrographic survey on marine organism in relation to deep-sea disposal of radioactive wastes in the central western North Pacific aboard R. V. Kaiyo Maru in 1978 and 1979. Datum Collect. Tokai Reg. Fish. Res. Lab., 8, 1-48. Sudo, H., 1982. Hydrographic surveys in the central western North Pacific on the deep-sea disposal of radioactive wastes - Deep water characteristics and circulation. Japan Fisheries Agency, 174 pp. (in Japanese with English abstract and legends) Uehara, K., and K. Taira, 1990. Deep hydrographic structure along 12'N and 13'N in the Philippine Sea. J. Oceanogr. SOC.Japan, 46, 167-176. Warren, B. A , , 1973. Transpacific hydrographic sections at Lats. 43's and 28's: The SCORPIO Expedition - 11. Deep water. Deep-sea Res., 20, 9-38. Warren, B. A., 1983. Why is no deep water formed in the North Pacific? J. Mar. Res., 41, 327-347. Wooster, W. S., and G. H. Volkmann, 1960. Indications of deep Pacific circulation from the distribution of properties at five kilometers. 3. Geophys. Res., 65, 1239-1249.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Deep Ocean Circulation, Physical and Chemical Aspects edited by T. Teramoto 0 1993 Elsevier Science Publishers B.V. All rights reserved.
39
Density Field along 12"N and 13"N in the Philippine Sea Katsuto UEHARA, Keisuke TAIRA and Akira MASUDA*
Abstract
Hydrographic casts down to the bottom along two zonal sections at 12'N and 13'N (from 144'E to 127'E) were made with a CTD. Their analysis verified the existence of cold and saline abyssal water between the Mariana Ridge and the Kyushu-Palau Ridge. This result provides evidence of flow into the Philippine Sea through the gap called the Yap-Mariana Junction. The properties of deep water are variable in the West Mariana basin but quite homogeneous in the Philippine Basin, indicating the transitional nature in the West Mariana Basin and the existence of older bottom water in the Philippine Basin.
1.
Introduction
The Philippine Sea is the sea which locates to the south of Japan and comprises the westernmost part of the North Pacific Ocean (Fig. 1). For the depth below 4000 m, the Izu-Ogasawara and Mariana Ridges separate the Philippine Sea from the main Pacific Ocean and restricts the horizontal exchange of abyssal water except through the several narrow gaps. In reality, the map of the horizontal distribution of temperature, salinity, and dissolved oxygen compiled by Moriyasu (1972) using CSK data shows an apparent difference between the Philippine Sea and the main Pacific Ocean for the levels below 3000 m. In the North Pacific Ocean, including the Philippine Sea, the surface water cannot be dense enough t o form an existing abyssal water (Warren, 1983) and the abyssal water characterized by low salinity and high oxygen content are considered t o be supplied from the south (Stommel and Arons, 1960; Warren, 1981). Accordingly, abyssal water of the Philippine Sea must be supplied from outside. Additional data, including those obtained from the Indopac Expedition, have provided some information on this subject. The distribution of water characteristics shown by Mantyla and Reid (1983) and by Kaneko and Teramoto (1985) suggest a flow of bottom water into the Philippine Sea through the gap to the southwest of Guam, which is called the Yap-Mariana Junction. However, Mantyla and Reid (1983) used hydrographic data at the bottom layer only and the depth is different from station t o station while Kaneko and Teramoto (1985) analyzed the data mainly in upper 3000 m. The inflow through the Yap-Mariana Junction is not fully delineated. *Ocean Research Institute, University of Tokyo, 1-15-1, Minamidai, Nakano-ku, Tokyo 164 Japan
40 In order t o detect this inflow more clearly, hydrographic observations were carried out in the southern Philippine Sea along 12"N and 13"N, from 144"E t o 127"E during R/V Hakuho-Maru Cruise KH-87-1 leg 2 of 8-17 February 1987. In this manuscript, we made an analysis of the CTD dataset obtained from this cruise. Emphasis is placed on depicting the hydrographic structure of abyssal and bottom layers in the southern Philippine Sea. The existence of distinctly cold, saline and dense bottom water in the West Mariana Basin is shown in cross sections of 12"N and 13"N. We also examined the vertical profile of each station for the depth below 3000 db. We found homogeneous distribution in the Philippine Basin and rather variable structures in the West Mariana Basin. Also, in the West Mariana Basin, water tends t o get warmer, less saline, and less dense as it gets farther from the Yap-Mariana Junction. These results provide strong evidence for the inflow of cold, saline, and dense bottom water through the Yap-Mariana Junction into the West Mariana Basin. In the
N -
30"
20"
10"
0"
120"
130"
140"
E
150"
Fig. 1. Topography around the Philippine Sea and the hydrographic stations of the Hakuho Maru Cruise KH-87-1 leg 2. Numerals represent station numbers.
41 30.
25.
20.
W
a
13
?
15.
W
Q
2
W
t-
J
2
10.
2
W
-t
2
5.
0.
34.2 34.4
34.6 34.8
35.0 35.2
SALINITY(PSU)
Fig. 2. T-S diagram of the CTD data. Temperature is shown in potential temperature referred t o 0 db pressure. Isopycnal lines of potential density referred t o 0 d b is shown as contour lines. Philippine Basin, the bottom water was slightly colder and denser in the western part than in the eastern part. This may be indicating the existence of a broad western boundary current toward the south along the eastern rise of the Philippine Trench.
2. 2.1.
0bservat ion Measurement and data analysis
The topography of the Philippine Sea and the location of the hydrographic stations are shown in Fig. 1. The Izu-Ogasawara Ridge and the Mariana Ridge
42 separate the Philippine Sea from the North Pacific Ocean at a depth greater than 3000 m. The Kyushu-Palau Ridge along 135"E divides the Philippine Sea into the Philippine Basin and the West Mariana Basin. There is a gap with a sill depth of 5000 m t o the south of Guam called the Yap-Mariana Junction, which connects the Philippine Sea with the North Pacific Ocean. Hydrographic stations were occupied with a Neil Brown Mark IIIb C T D and a Rosette multi-sampler. At each station, CTD d a t a were recorded t o the bottom layer of 3000-6000 d b and water sampling was made at 1 2 levels. A zigzag course was adopted to examine the hydrographic structure at both 12"N and 13"N. Dense CTD casts were made around 135"E to examine possible effects of the KyushuPalau Ridge on the bottom water distribution. Calibration of CTD d a t a were made by referring the d a t a obtained from sampled water and reversing thermometer to reduce the systematic error of the C T D sensor. Afterwards, the d a t a are recompiled into 2 d b interval data. For station 209 (below 4000 db) and station 222, we could not get enough number of valid d a t a for station 209 (below 4000 db) and station 222, so they are not included in the dataset. Estimated error of the dataset is less than 0.01"C for temperature and 0.0037 psu (practical salinity unit) for salinity.
2.2.
Results
Surface layers In the surface layer of upper 200 db, strong baroclinic feature is found. Geostrophic calculation shows a surface confined westward flow with intensity exceeding 20 cm/s (not shown), which indicates the North Equatorial Current (e.g., Toole et al., 1990). There is a salinity maximum exceeding 35.0 psu at about 110-130 d b in depth (Fig. 2). Beneath this thin layer, there is a salinity minimum a t the depth of 600-800 d b or around 26.5 in sigma-theta (potential density referred to 0 pressure). In the succeeding section, we will deal with the deep and bottom layers below the salinity minimum.
Cross sections of 12"N and 13"N Figures 3(a), (b), and (c) show the cross-sectional distributions along 12"N of potential temperature theta-4 referred to 4000 db, salinity S, and potential density sigma-5 referred to 5000 db, respectively. Figures 4(a), (b), and (c) show the crosssectional distributions along 13"N. Above 3500 db, which is roughly the depth of the Kyushu-Palau Ridge, no apparent difference can be seen between the water properties in the West Mariana Basin and those in the Philippine Basin. Obvious differences, however, appear below 3500 db; the most prominent feature is the marked contrast of water properties between both sides of the Kyushu-Palau Ridge around 135"E. Colder, more saline, and denser abyssal water exists in the West Mariana Basin (eastern side of the ridge), whereas it is absent in the Philippine Basin (western side of the ridge). Vertical and horizontal distributions are highly variable in the West Mariana Basin. This is an indication that the West Mariana Basin is nearer t o the source of abyssal water. Dissolved oxygen content measured
43
-4--
3000
c
4000
5000
6000
1
125"
LONGITUDE
u5
130"
135' LONGITUDE
140'
E
(12"N)
1000
2000
125'
130'
135" LONGITUDE
140'
E
Fig. 3. The distributions along 12"N cross-section: (a) potential temperature theta-4 (referred t o 4000 db), (b) salinity S, and (c) potential density sigma-5 (referred t o 5000 db). The numerals at the top denote the station numbers. from sampled water shows higher values at the bottom layer in the West Mariana Basin (Watanabe et al., 1988), indicating that abyssal water is relatively young there. In the Philippine Basin, water of slightly lower temperature and large density is found in the western bottom layer as indicated by isotherms of 1.565"C and 1.57"C in Figs. 3(a) and 4(a) along both 12"N and 13"N. This water may spread over few
44
---
-
3000
D
a
__--
E
r
2
3000
-
D
4000
2 4000
5000
5000
nil-----
6000
6000 125'
~
130"
135'
E
140'
125"
130"
135"
140'
E
LONGITUDE
LONGITUDE
u5 (13'N)
---
3000
Iz( 9
P
4000
5000
6000
125'
130"
135'
140"
E
LONGITUDE
Fig. 4. The same as Fig. 3 except along 13"N hundred kilometers, although the westernmost part of the basin was not observed. It is not clear whether this water is significantly colder, because the temperature difference is less than 0.005"C which is as large as half the measurement error. T h e bottom water in the western Philippine basin has properties closer to the bottom water in the West Mariana Basin. These features indicate the existence of a broad and weak southward flow in the western part of the Philippine Basin.
45 Vertical profile of all CTD stations Figures 5(a), (b) show the vertical profiles of theta-4, S, and sigma-5 for depth below 3000 db, respectively. The profiles are drawn with different types of lines according t o the following geographical classification: 3000
3500
a: 3
4500
0)
0 W
a: a
5000
5500
Fig. 5. The vertical distributions of (a) theta-4, (b) S, and (c) sigma5 below 3000 db: - -, on the south-eastern flank of the Mariana Ridge; - _ - , in the West Mariana basin; - - -,in the eastern part of the Philippine Basin; and - in the western part of the Philippine Basin. An error bar is inserted in each figure.
46
I44E-127E
P0
TE
NT I A
Fig. 5 .
L D E N S I T Y ( k g Irn
1 )
(continued)
(1) the southeastern flank of the Mariana Ridge (stations 202 and 204; outside of the Philippine Sea), (2) near the shallowest portion of the Mariana Ridge (stations 201 and 2031, ( 3 ) the West Mariana Basin (stations 205-210), (4) near the Kyushu-Palau Ridge (stations 211-213, 008, and Oll), which is about 3500 m deep, ( 5 ) eastern part of the Philippine Basin (stations 214-219), (6) western part of the Philippine Basin (stations 220-223).
For stations 201 and 203, profiles are not included in the figures because depths are shallower than 2000 db. The profiles for stations 222 and 209 (below 4000 db) are not available because the raw data are erroneous. Above 4000 db, deep water southeast of the West Mariana Ridge (stations 202 and 204) is the coldest and most saline when compared at the same depth. The water retains the characteristics of the abyssal water from the south. The vertical profiles of region (1) are distinguished from those inside the Philippine Sea (regions 3 t o 6) at depths shallower than 4000 db. In the Philippine Sea, the profiles for stations in the West Mariana Basin (regions 3 and 4) are separated from those in the Philippine Basin (regions 5 and 6) below 3500 db. The depth corresponds t o the sill depth of the Kyushu-Palau Ridge, which divides the Philippine Sea into the two basins. The water in the Philippine Basin is remarkably homogeneous below 4000 db. It is warmer, less saline, and less dense compared t o the water in the West Mariana Basin. This implies that the Philippine Basin is far from the source of abyssal water. On the other hand,
47 2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
- 0.5
Depth (db)
1000
2000
3000
4060
5000
6000
Depth ( d b )
Fig. 6. The vertical distributions of stability for the stations (a) 205210, (b) 214-223 for the depth below 1000 db, respectively. Stability is defined in terms of the Brunt-V ais a1 a frequency (cph). Five adjacent data (10 d b in depth) were fitted t o calculate a density gradient. Positive value represents the stable state, i.e., the density gets denser as the depth increases.
48 the water in the West Mariana Basin has a large variation within a relatively small zonal scale. In the West Mariana Basin, water properties are changing rapidly from those in the North Pacific Ocean to those in the Philippine Basin. It is to be noted that station 206 rather than 205, has a vertical distribution similar t o those at stations 202 and 204 in the western North Pacific Ocean. This is most clear for salinity profiles as shown in Fig. 5(b). Station 206 is nearest to the Yap-Mariana Junction which is located at around 11"N and 139"E (Fig. 1). Accordingly, we can state that abyssal water flows into the Philippine Sea through the Yap-Mariana Junction. When we compare the vertical profiles for regions (5) and (6) in the Philippine Basin, rather small though systematic difference can be found in the temperature and density profiles. The western side of the Philippine Basin is slightly colder and denser than the eastern side as discussed in the previous section.
3. Summary and Discussion CTD measurements were made down to the bottom along 12"N and 13"N in the Philippine Sea. The most important result is that the existence of cold and saline water was verified in the deep region of the West Mariana Basin below 3500 db. Water of these properties has been inferred t o enter the Philippine Sea through the Yap-Mariana Junction in previous data analyses by Mantyla and Reid (1983) and Kaneko (1984). At station 206, which is the station nearest to the Yap-Mariana Junction, we observed the coldest, most saline, and densest bottom water in the Philippine Sea. The marked contrast of water properties between the West Mariana Basin and the Philippine Basin can be ascertained from the instrumental accuracy. Also both the horizontal and vertical gradients are compared between the east and west sides of the Kyushu-Palau Ridge. The deep water has a variable structure in the West Mariana Basin, but is homogeneous in the Philippine Basin. We may say, therefore, that the present result gives evidence of flow into the Philippine Sea through the Yap-Mariana Junction. The vertical profiles of stability of the water in the West Mariana Basin and the Philippine Basin for the depth below 1000 d b are shown in Figs. 6(a) and (b), respectively. In the Philippine basin, the stability is almost neutral below the depth of 4200 db. This suggests that although the difference of the water properties between the West Mariana Basin and the Philippine Basin become apparent from 3500 d b (Fig. 5a and b), there may be a gap at the Kyushu-Palau Ridge with a depth of 4200 d b and the water underneath retains the characteristic of the sill depth. In the West Mariana Basin, on the other hand, we can see some signals showing the variable nature of water properties: the variations of the stability between the stations are large compared with those in the Philippine Basin, and the stability does not come to zero value (i.e., there are potential density gradients at most depths) except for the depth below 5000 d b at station 206. It is not clear from our dataset whether the homogeneous distribution of density below 5000 d b reflects the sill depth of the Yap-Mariana Junction because there is only one station which has d a t a deeper than 5000 d b in the West Mariana Basin. The water density in the western part of the Philippine Basin increases slightly
t o the west (Figs. 3, 4 and 5 ) . This might be interpreted as a broad western boundary current flowing equatorward. It is impossible t o substantiate this speculation at present. At least, t h e variation is quite small, beyond t h e present precision of data.
Acknowledgement We would like t o thank Prof. T. Teramoto, Dr. M. Kawabe, a n d Mr. S. Kitagawa for their support and discussions during t h e study. We also thank the crews a n d t h e participants of t h e cruise of t h e R/V Hakuho Maru.
References Kaneko, I., 1984. Structure of mid-depth water in the Philippine Sea. Ph. D. Thesis, University of Tokyo, Tokyo, 97 pp. Kaneko, I., and T. Teramoto, 1985. Sea water exchange between the Shikoku-Philippine Basin and the western North Pacific Basin. In: Ocean Characteristics and their Changes, K. Kajiura (ed.), Koseisha-Koseikaku, pp. 54-77. Mantyla, A. W., and J. L. Reid, 1983. Abyssal characteristics of the World Ocean Waters. Deep-sea Res., 30, 805-833. Moriyasu, S., 1972. Deep waters in the western North Pacific. In: Kuroshio - Its Physical Aspects, H. Stommel and K. Yoshida (ed.), Univ. of Tokyo Press, Tokyo, pp. 387-408. Stommel, H., and A. B. Arons, 1960. On the abyssal circulation of a world ocean - 11. An idealized model of the circulation pattern and amplitude in oceanic basins. Deep-sea Res., 6, 217-244. Teramoto, T., and K. Taira, 1988. Preliminary Report of The Hakuho Maru Cruise KH-87-1, Ocean Research Institute, University of Tokyo, 38 pp. Toole, J. M., R. C . Millard, Z. Wang, and S. Pu, 1990. Observations of the Pacific North Equatorial Current Bifurcation at the Philippine Coast. J. Phys. Oceanogr., 20, 307-318. Warren, B. A., 1981. Deep circulation of the world ocean. In: Evolution of Physical Oceanography, B. A. Warren and C. Wunsch (ed.), MIT Press, Cambridge, pp. 6-41. Warren, B. A., 1983. Why is no deep water formed in the North Pacific? J. Mar. Res., 41, 327-347. Watanabe, S., S. Noriki, C. Saitoh, and Y . Watanabe, 1988. Distribution of chemical tracers in the Philippine Sea. In: Preliminary Report of The Hakuho Maru Cruise KH-87-1, T. Teramoto and K. Taira (ed.), Ocean Research Institute, University of Tokyo, pp. 30-34.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Deep Ocean Circulation, Physical and Chemical Aspects
edited by T. Teramoto 0 1993 Elsevier Science Publishers B.V. All rights reserved.
51
Abyssal Boundary Current along the Northwestern Perimeter of the Philippine Basin Masaaki CHAEN: Masao FUKASAWA: Akio MAEDAt Masahito SAKURAIf and Masaki TAKEMATSUf
Abstract Abyssal currents along the northwestern perimeter of the Philippine Basin were measured by moored current meters at three sites, which are located southeast of Okinawa, southeast of Taiwan, and the northern extremity of the Kyushu-Palau Ridge. Total length of observation was about 550 days at each site. Southeast of Okinawa and southeast of Taiwan, mean currents with magnitudes of 4.3 cm/sec and 1.3 cm/sec, respectively, were observed a t 400 m above the sea bottom at stations where water depth is greater than 4,000 m. The mean currents were parallel to the local bottom contour and flowing with the upslope on their right. Intensification of the mean current toward the bottom is clearly found on the slope of southeast of Okinawa. At the northern extremity of the Kyushu-Palau Ridge, the observed current does not show a stable abyssal current with a predominant direction, although the site is located at the narrow, deep passage between the Shikoku Basin and the northern portion of the Ryukyu Trench. Strong currents with opposite directions occurred intermittently and alternately. These results suggest that a steady abyssal current exists at depths greater than about 3,000 m along the northwestern perimeter of the Philippine Basin, and that the deep water exchange between the Shikoku and Philippine Basins occurs intermittently. Existence of an abyssal circulation system is also suggested in the northern part of the Philippine Basin, separated from the circulation in the northern part of the Shikoku Basin as suggested in previous studies.
1.
Introduction
T h e Philippine Sea is a marginal sea, separated from the Pacific Ocean by t h e Shichito, Ogasawara and Mariana Ridges. Figure 1 shows a schematic m a p of the topography around the Philippine Sea adapted from Mogi (1972). At depths greater than 3,000 m, the Philippine Sea is connected t o the North Pacific Ocean only through a few trenches caved at the eastern and western ends of the Yap Ridge, *Faculty of Fisheries, Kagoshima University 'Faculty of Marine Science and Technology, Tokai University *Faculty of Engineering, Kagoshima University §Research Institute for Applied Mechanics, Kyushu University
52 where Yap Islands are located. In the center of the Philippine Sea, the north-south oriented Kyushu-Palau Ridge separates the Philippine Sea into the eastern and western parts at depths greater than 3,500 m. The northern and southern basins of the eastern part of the Philippine Sea are the Shikoku and West Mariana Basins, respectively. The basin of the western part is called the Philippine Basin. The Philippine Sea is a favorable field for us t o carry out an experiment concerning the abyssal circulation. Stommel and Arons (1960a; 1960b) proposed the
Fig. 1. Topographic features of the Philippine Sea including basins, ridges, and trenches after Mogi (1972; 1979) and location of current meter mooring sites (black circles). Basins A: Amami Basin, B: Kita-Daito Basin, C: Minami-Daito Basin. Ridges 1: Shichito-Iwoto Ridge, 2: NishiShichito Ridge, 3: Ogasawara Ridge, 4: Mid-Mariana Ridge, 5: East Mariana Ridge, 6: West Mariana Ridge, 7: Yap Ridge, 8: Kyushu-Palau Ridge, 9: Amami Plateau, 10: Daito Ridge, 11: Oki-Daito Ridge. Trenches a: Nankai Trough, b: Ryukyu Trench, c: Philippine Trench, d: Yap Trench, e: Palau Trench.
53 model for the abyssal circulation in the world ocean. In their model, the Philippine Sea is completely neglected because it is almost separated from the North Pacific Ocean at abyssal depths and does not contain any source of deep water in it. However, their abyssal circulation model could be applied for the Philippine Sea, because it is large enough having the horizontal scale longer than 2,000 km, is deep enough having a distinct thermocline, and has a source of deep and bottom waters. If the abyssal circulation in the Philippine Sea is clarified, it is also useful to understand the abyssal circulation in the world ocean. In the past ten years, intensive studies have been made for the Philippine Sea. Concerning the abyssal boundary current associated witfh the abyssal circulation system, Fukasawa and Teramoto (1986) and Fukasawa e t al. (1986) observed the abyssal boundary current along the northern perimeter of the Shikoku Basin, by moored current meters maintained during about five years. Their results strongly suggest that a steady abyssal boundary current exists at depths greater than about 3,000 m along the northern and northwestern perimeters of the Shikoku Basin, suggesting the existence of an abyssal circulation system, a t least, in the Shikoku Basin. With respect t o the inflow of deep water into the Philippine Sea through the Yap and Palau Trenches caved at both sides of the Yap Ridge, Kaneko (1984) analyzed chemical tracer data as well as CTD (Conductivity/Temperature/Depth recorder) d a t a show that chemical properties of the deep water in the Philippine Sea are almost the same as those of the deep water south and southeast of the East Mariana and Yap Ridges. The results show the evidence of the inflow of the North Pacific deep water into the Philippine Sea through the trenches. On the basis of the results obtained in the Philippine Sea, the direct measurements of the abyssal current in the Philippine Sea were carried out in the research project, Priority Area Programme entitled “Dynamics of the Deep Circulation”, 1987-1989 represented by Prof. T. Teramoto. In the programme, two kind of direct measurements of mid and deep ocean currents were carried out in the Philippine Sea; one was the SOFAR float trackings - a Lagrangian measurement of current - by Taira et al. (1990), and the other was the current meter moorings - a n Eulerian measurement of the current - by our group. The objectives of the Eulerian measurement were t o measure the abyssal boundary current along the northwestern perimeter of the Philippine Basin, and to estimate the volume transport of the deep and bottom waters flowing into the Philippine Basin via the West Mariana Basin. For the first objective, three mooring sites, RT, BC and C T were maintained along the northwestern perimeter of the Philippine Basin, as shown in Figure 1. According t o the detailed description of the bottom topography of the northwestern perimeter of the Philippine Basin by Mogi (1979), a trench stretches along the Ryukyu Islands and the Philippine Islands, making the western boundary of the Philippine Sea. The Ryukyu Trench along the Ryukyu Islands is divided into three sections by the seamount south of Miyako Island and the western extension of Amami Plateau. Water depths of the deepest parts are 7,130 m for the southern portion, 7,881 m for the central portion, and 5,998m for the northern portion. The central portion is the deepest
54
fE Fig. 2. Locations of mooring stations at Site RT situated southeast of Okinawa. Bottom topography is shown with contour intervals of 1 km sketched from a chart No.6302 published by the Hydrographic Department, Maritime Safety Agency, Japan (M. S. A., Japan; Approval No. 030065). Areas deeper than 4,000 m are shaded. and the longest. The northern one is surrounded by the Amami Plateau and the Kyushu-Palau Ridge; it is deeper than the Nankai Trough by about 1,000 m. For the second objective, seven mooring lines were deployed on the slopes of the Yap and Palau Trenches. However, almost half of the current meter data were unusable, because of troubles associated with battery supply of d a t a recorders. Additional observation by two mooring lines was carried out at the same location on the slope of the Yap Trench from April 1990 to April 1991. In this paper, the results of the abyssal boundary current. obtained by current meter moorings along the northwestern perimeter of the Philippine Basin are reported. Detailed studies based on the current meter d a t a will be carried out by collaborators in near future. The results for our second objective will be reported elsewhere including those obtained by the additional observation.
55 Table 1. Summary of current meter moorings at sites RT, BC, and CT.
Station
Location
RT1
25'34" 128'09'E 25"29'N 128"12'E 25"24'N 128"18'E
RT2
RT3 BC1 BC2 BC3 BC4 BC5 BC6
CT5 CT6
Water depth
4,570
RT31 RT32
Meter depth (m) 2,130 3,130 2,650 3,650 3,170 4,170
2,500
BCll BC12 BC21 BC22 BC31 BC32 BC41 BC42 BC51 BC52 BC61 BC62
1,100 2,100 2,800 3,800 3,400 4,400 2,280 3,280 3,250 4,250 3,900 4,900
87/03/01-87/11/01 87/03/01-87/09/08 87102128-87/10/29 87102128-87/10/03 87102128-87/10/09 87102128-87/09/21 87/11/01-88/05/24 87/11/01-88/05/24 87111101-88/05/24 87111101-88/05/24 87/11/01-88/05/24 87111101-88/05/24
245 191 242 217 223 205 205 205 205 205 205 205
CT51 CT52 CT61 CT62
2,990 3,990 2,940 3.940
87111110-89/05/13 87/11/10-89/04/28 87111110-89/05/11 87/11/10-89/05/13
550 535 548 550
(4
21"34'N 121'49'E 21"36'N 1 21"59'E 21"40'N 122'07'E 21"36'N 1 21"54% 21'42" 122"04'E 21"42'N 122'09'E 30"07'N 132"2 2'E 30"13'N 132"26'E
Current meter
3,530
RTll RT12
4,050
RT2 1
RT22
4,200 4,800 3,680 4,650 5,300
4,390 4,340
Observational period
Duration (days) 87/11/03-89/05/12 556 258 88108127-89/05/12 229 88108127-89/04/14 235 88108127-89/04/19 552 87111103-89/05/08 540 87/11/03-89/04/26
Observations and Data
2. 2.1.
Mooring stations
Figure 2 shows the locations of the current meter moorings at site RT and a sketch of the bathymetry southeast of Okinawa. The three RT stations were maintained at depths of 3,530 m t o 4,570 m on the northwestern slope of the central portion of the Ryukyu Trench, and were named RT1, RT2, and RT3 from inshore to offshore. Summary of the moorings, including location of station, water depth, current meter depth and mooring period is shown at the top panel in Table 1. The observation was started in November, 1987; continued in August, 1988 after retrieving first mooring, and ended in May, 1989. The total length of observation is about 550 days for all stations except station RT2, where the first mooring was
not retrieved. Figure 3 shows the locations of current meter moorings at site BC and a sketch
56 120'E
125'E
I5'E Fig. 3. Same as Fig. 2 except for Site BC located in the Bashi Channel southeast of Taiwan. of the bathymetry southeast of Taiwan. Summary of the moorings is shown in the middle panel of Table 1. The observation was started in March, 1987 and ended in May, 1988. When the second mooring lines were deployed in November, 1987, the mooring lines were not deployed at the same location as the first mooring stations BC1, BC2 and BC3 because of existence of the strong surface current. As a result, the current observation at site BC was made at six different stations with a mooring period of about 200 days. The first stations BC1, BC2 and BC3 correspond somewhat t o second stations BC4, BC5 and BC6, respectively. Figure 4 shows the locations of the current meter moorings at site C T and a sketch of the bathymetry southeast of Kyushu. Summary of the moorings is shown at the bottom panel in Table 1. The observation was started in November, 1987 and ended in May, 1989. The total length of observation was about 550 days; it is as long as that for site RT also. The moorings for our second objective were located on the slopes of the Yap and Palau Trenches at the eastern and western ends of the Yap Ridge. The site was named Y P after the Yap Ridge.
2.2.
Mooring lines and data sampling
In this observation, most of the mooring lines were composed of two current meters, an acoustic release, glass buoys and a weight as shown in Figure 5 . The
57 total length of a mooring line was about 1,470 m. The current meters were set at about 1,400 m and 400 m above the sea bottom in most mooring lines. Current meters were numbered by increasing depth on the mooring. For example, the current meters at the upper and lower layers at station RT1 were named R T l l and RT12, respectively. The current meter used in this observation were the rotor type Anderaa cufrent meters, named RCM4, RCMS, RCMG, and RCM8. Deployment and retrieval of the mooring lines were made on board T / S Keiten-Maru of the Faculty of Fisheries, Kagoshima University. CTD casts necessary to clarify the density field in the abyssal layer were not carried out, during the current meter mooring. Current meter d a t a were sampled at one hour interval throughout the observational period. The raw data were pre-processed by a 48 hour half power Gaussian filter filtering high frequency components, and the output of this filter was subsampled every one hour to make the data set for the present analysis.
130'E
135'E
Fig. 4. Same as Fig. 2 except for Site C T located a t the northern extremity of the Kyushu-Palau Ridge southeast of Kyushu.
58
4
RADIO BEACON
GLASS BALLS
i
B 1I
b
GLASS BALLS
ROPE GLASS BALLS
i
ACOUSTIC RELEASZ
WEIGHT 525kg
Fig. 5. Sketch of a mooring line.
3. Results 3.1.
Site RT
Site RT is located on the northwestern slope of the central portion of the Ryukyu Trench. The objective of observation is to examine the existence of abyssal boundary currents along the northwestern boundary of the Philippine Basin. The stick diagrams of current are shown in Figure 6; here the current data is subsampled once a day after taking the 72 hours running mean for the d a t a set mentioned in the previous section. The variations of the current for RT31 and RT32 fairly resemble t o each other; both currents flow with almost the same predominant direction. Figure 7 shows the stick diagram of the current for RT32 minus that for RT31, which demonstrates t h a t the current at the lower layer are faster than that
59 meter de th
water deFth
I
t
I I S I I S I IS 1 1 s I I S I 1s I I S I IS I IS O C T NOV OEC JAN F E E f l A R APR H A T JUb
s I I S I I S I IS I I S I IS I I S I I5 I 1 5 I IS IUL AUG S E P O C T NOV O E C J A N FEE M A R APR flAT
I988
Fig. 6. Stick diagrams of the current at stations RT1, RT2, RT3. Each stick shows the speed and direction of the current which is subsampled once a day at 0O:OO time after smoothing by a 72 hours running mean as well as a 48 hour half-power Gaussian low-pass filter.
rl LE P-
I I S I15 I IS I I S I I S I IS I IS I IS I IS I IS I I S I IS I I S I I j I IS I IS I I S I I S I IS I O C T NOV OEC J A N F E E MAR APR f l A 1 JUN JUL AUG S E P O C T NOV DEC JlrN FEE M A R APR f l A T
115
1988
Fig. 7. Stick diagrams of the current for RT32 minus RT31.
at the upper layer, and that the difference is very stable in direction. Such a feature of the abyssal current observed a t station RT3 is almost the same as t h a t observed at the northern perimeter of the Shikoku Basin (Fukasawa et al., 1986). Similar characteristic features of the mean current and variations of current are also found for stations RT1 and RT2, which are located at lesser depths than station RT3, though the former is not so clear as those for station RT3. The offshore extent of the abyssal current at site RT cannot be determined because there are no data concerning the density field in this region as mentioned previously. The basic statistics of current data are shown at the top panel in Table 2;
60 they include speed and direction of mean current, variance of currents (major and minor axes and their orientations) and the ratio of kinetic energy of current variations (ke) to t h a t of the mean current (km). The statistics at station RT3 are especially noticeable among others; namely, the mean currents for RT31 and RT32 have almost the same direction and the current speed for RT32 (400 m above the sea bottom) is faster than t h a t for RT31 (1,400 m above the sea bottom) by about 3 cm/sec. Moreover, the major axes and their orientations of the variance of currents for RT31 and RT32 are almost the same. Those observed results suggest t h a t there exists an abyssal boundary current flowing along the local bottom contour and with the upslope on its right on t h e northwestern slope of the central portion of t,he Ryukyu Trench. The vertical extent of the bottom intensification of the mean current is estimated t o be about 1,800 m above the bottom by the linear extrapolation of the mean current speeds for RT31 and RT32.
3.2.
Site BC
Site BC is located on the slope in the Bashi Channel southeast of Taiwan. The objective of the observation is t o examine the existence of the abyssal boundary current along the western boundary of the Philippine Basin, where the basin has the broadest width in the east-west direction. The stick diagrams of current are shown in Figure 8. Currents for BC31 and BC32 show similar variation during three months from July to September, 1987. The mean current speed for BC32 (400 m above the bottom) was larger than that for BC31 (1,400 m above the bottom) by about 1 cm/sec as shown later, and the current direction for BC31 and BC32 was south-southeast, or parallel t o the local bottom contour. This result suggests t h a t an abyssal boundary current along the local bottom contour existed at t h a t time. T h e vertical extent of this abyssal boundary current at station BC3 is estimated t o be about 1,600 m by linear extrapolation of the d a t a for upper and lower current meters. Similar features are also found for station BC2, though they are clear only for two months from August to September, 1987. At station BC6, the deepest mooring station a t site BC, currents for BC61 and BC62 had almost the same current speed and direction with similar periodic variation. The basic statistics of current d a t a are shown in the middle panel of Table 2. T he variabilities of current are large for site BC compared with site RT. At both stations BC3 and BC6 (offshore stations where the water depth is greater than 4,800 m), the variability is small compared with other stations a t site BC, and the mean current speed for both stations are also weak. Therefore the kinetic energy ratio Ke/Km is large. These statistics suggest t h a t the abyssal currents observed at site BC are unstable, and t h a t such a clear abyssal boundary current as found a t site RT does not exist at site BC. Although some abyssal boundary currents along the local bottom contour seem t o be observed in short period at stations BC2, BC3 and BC6, it is difficult t o decide whether those currents are abyssal boundary currents or not, because those appeared only in shorter period and also because we have no density data.
61 me ler depth water depth
(a)
"'"r
-
U
2.500
m
-
N
m U
N U
mN N
"
-a
m v m C N l
U
a3
IS
I
IS
1
JAN
L
FEE
IS
IS
HAR
APR
I
IS
I5
1
1
JUN
HAT
IS
15
I
JUC
I
AUG
IS
SEP
I
IS
1
OCT
1987
meter depth water depth d
* u m
f.4 v
U m
-
In
m U (Y
In
m U
d
(D
m U UY f.4
m
U
I
15
OCT
I
IS NOV
I
IS OEC
I
IS JAN
I
IS FEE
I
IS HAR
I
15
APR
I
IS
MAT
Fig. 8. Same as Fig. 6 except for (a) stations BC1, BC2, and BC3, and (b) stations BC4, BC5, and BC6.
62 Table 2. Statistics of current meter data at sites RT, BC, and CT. Variability of currents is represented in the form of a variance ellipse; length and orientation of the major axis are tabulated, and also length of the minor axis is shown in parentheses. ke and km are the eddy kinetic energy and mean kinetic energy, respectively. Current meter number
Duration
Mean current speed direction
Variability Axis length direction (cm/sec)2 (deg.) 28 (10.0) 40 22 22 ( 3.0) 29 ( 8.4) 32 34 17 ( 3.9) 32 11 ( 3.5) 51 1 2 ( 4.1)
ke/km
(days) 556 258 229 235 552 540
(cm/sec) 2.0 1.9 2.4 3.1 1.2 4.3
(deg.) 37 200 53 227 247 224
BC12 BC21 BC22 BC31 BC32 BC41 BC42 BC51 BC52 BC61 BC62
245 191 242 217 223 205 205 205 205 205 205 205
2.5 4.9 5.3 1.3 0.5 1.3 5.5 2.3 0.4 0.2 0.9 0.7
189 348 360 142 53 175 177 6 352 143 341 289
125 (20.0) 123 ( 9.8) 214 (21.0) 24 ( 2.1) 19 ( 2.8) 18 ( 2.2) 82 (14.0) 86 ( 4.3) 5.4( 1.6) 30 ( 2.5) 15 ( 2.4) 15 ( 2.5)
1 3 172 166 170 171 10 4 178 168 178 166
23.7 5.5 8.3 14.7 105.0 12.3 3.2 16.7 42.4 611.0 21.9 39.8
CT51 CT52 CT61 CT62
550 535 548 550
0.9 0.9 0.6 2.0
5 234 305 150
11 ( 5.6) 17 ( 4.7) 27 (24.0) 15 ( 7.0)
19 14 65 92
19.1 28.8 153.0 5.2
RTll RT12 RT2 1 RT22
RT31 RT32 BCll
3.3.
10.0 7.2 6.6 2.2 10.3 0.9
Site CT
The site CT is located at the northern extremity of the Kyushu-Palau Ridge, where the junction of the Shikoku Basin and the northern portion of the Ryukyu Trench exists. The junction forms a narrow, deep passage as shown in Figure 4. There are no other junctions between them around this area. The objective of observation at site C T is t o examine the existence of the deep water exchange between the Shikoku and Philippine Basins via the northern portion of the Ryukyu Trench. The stick diagrams of current at site CT are shown in Figure 9. Those for
63 meter depth water depth
c _
lOcm/se
5%
53
"7 T
I IS I15 1 1 5 I IS I IS I IS I I S I I S I I S I IS I IS 1 1 5 1 1 5 I15 I 1 5 I 1 5 I15 I I S 1 IS I IS O C T NOV OEC JAN FEB nAR A P R R A T JUN JUL AUG SEP O C T N O V OEC JAN FEE R A R APR R A T JUN
1988
1989
Fig. 9. Same as Fig. 6 except for stations CT5 and CT6. CT52 and CT62 (400 m above the sea bottom) show t h a t strong currents toward the north or east and those toward the south or southeast appeared intermittently and alternately; namely, there was no stable current with a predominant direction as observed at station RT3. For CT52, very strong currents toward the southsouthwest continued for about 40 days in February and March, 1989. Similar strong current also appeared intermittently in November, 1987, and May through July, 1988. These strong currents contribute t o the mean current as shown later. On the other hand, mean current direction for CT62 is calculated t o be 150"T, which is the direction perpendicular to the axis of the passage. It is because strong currents toward the east and those toward the south-southwest alternately appeared, resulting in cancellation of the component parallel t o the axis of the passage, and leaving the component perpendicular t o the axis of the passage. The variation of current for the upper current meters was nearly the same as that for the lower meters; that is, the strong current also intermittently occurred at CT51 and CT61 throughout the observational period, except for latter half from September, 1988 for station CT6, when current directions for CT61 and CT62 were opposite t o each other. The basic statistics of current d a t a are shown at the bottom panel in Table 2. The mean currents for upper and lower current meters had different current direction, both for stations CT5 and CT6. It is curious because those current meters were moored within the narrow, deep passage. The mean currents for lower current meters (400 m above the bottom) at both stations had different current directions; current direction for CT52 was 234"T, parallel t o the axis of the passage, while that for CT62 was 150"T, perpendicular t o the axis of the passage.
64 These results show that no stable abyssal current existed along the passage between the Nankai Trough and Ryukyu Trench. This conclusion is consistent with that of Fukasawa et al. (1986), who showed that the abyssal current toward the Philippine Basin occurred intermittently at a site (station KPO in their paper) near the present passage in the Shikoku Basin. At the same time, it is suggested that there is a case where the vertical extent of the abyssal current is less than 1,400 m above the sea bottom; for instance, only the current for lower layer was strong at site CT from March t o May, 1989 as shown in Figure 9.
0E '
Fig. 10. Mean current vectors for RT32, BC32, CT52, and CT62. The current meters were moored 400 m above the bottom. The current meter number, the current meter depth, the bottom depth, and ke/km with parentheses are shown for each station. Also shown are results from similar current measurements in the Shikoku Basin by Fukasawa and Teramoto (1986) and Fukasawa et al. (1986). Bottom topography is shown with contour intervals of 2 km sketched from a chart No.6302 published by the Hydrographic Department, M. S. A., Japan.
65 4.
Discussion
It has been suggested by the determination of 14C in the deep and bottom waters that the abyssal circulation in the Philippine Sea has the time scale of several hundreds years (Watanabe, 1989, personal communication). There is always a question on the representativeness in time and space of the observed value by the current measurement as is the case in all the such observations. In this observation, our observed currents are decided t o be the stable abyssal current or not on the basis of the flow stability, the basis which is used by Fukasawa et al. (1986). And it is also assumed that the abyssal boundary current has the same spatial structure both in the Shikoku and Philippine Basins. This assumption seems to be reasonable, because both basins are filled with the deep and bottom waters having the same origin through the Yap and Palau Trenches, and waters below 3,000 m depth in both basins have almost the same water characteristics (Kaneko, 1984). Figure 10 shows the abyssal currents related to the abyssal boundary current observed in this study. Also shown are those observed in the Shikoku Basin in the past several years, including observations at stations CS3, CS4, CS5, CA and KPO, which were made from April, 1981 to November, 1985 (Fukasawa et al., 1968). The strong abyssal boundary currents flowing t o the west and southwest are found at the northern perimeter of the Shikoku Basin. Fukasawa et al. (1986) reported t h a t the mean currents being parallel to the local bottom contour and flowing with the upslope on their right were strongly bottom controlled at depths greater than 3,000 m near the shelf toe and the eastern foot of the Kyushu-Palau Ridge. These mean currents were so stable t h a t the ratio ke/km scarcely exceeded unity. In this observation, the southwestward abyssal boundary current was found along the local bottom contour on the northwestern slope of the central portion of the Ryukyu Trench; its mean current speed was 4.3 cm/sec and the ratio ke/km was 0.9. This abyssal current is concluded to be stable considering the value of ke/km, which is comparable t o those obtained in the Shikoku Basin by Fukasawa et al. (1986). At the toe of the western slope of the Philippine Basin in the Bashi Channel, the mean current toward the south was weak and the value of ke/km was large, and hence the abyssal current is concluded t o be unstable. The deep and bottom waters in the Shikoku and Philippine Basins seem to be exchanged through the narrow, deep passage at the northern extremity of the Kyushu-Palau Ridge, but, no stable abyssal current was observed in the passage. The deep and bottom waters in both basins seem to be exchanged by the strong but intermittent alternating current. The flow pattern of the observed abyssal boundary current is approximately reproduced in a numerical model by Kubota and Ono (1991), but the estimated current speeds in the numerical model do not agree with the observed magnitudes. Another discrepancy is the abyssal boundary current in the passage at site C T mentioned above; the numerical model shows a considerable stable flow there. We do not understand the reason for the difference, but it might be related with the surface current condition. At depth of 1,500 m near site C T , the current condition was sluggish with clockwise turnings several times in an area of 150 km in the northeast direction and 100 km in the east-west direction according t o a trajectory of
66 a SOFAR float for about 200 days after deployed in November, 1988 (Taira et al.,
1990). Further study is required on the current condition from surface t o abyssal depth at the western part of the Shikoku Basin.
5.
Conclusions and Remarks
We made the abyssal current measurements using current meter moorings at several stations in the Philippine Sea to describe features of the abyssal boundary current and to estimate the volume transport of the deep water flowing into the Philippine Basin. In this paper, we report features of the abyssal current along the northwestern perimeter of the Philippine Basin and at the junction between the Shikoku and Philippine Basins. Current meters were set at depths greater than 2,500 m on the northwestern slope of the central portion of the Ryukyu Trench southeast of Okinawa and a t the toe of the western slope of the Philippine Basin southeast of Taiwan. The obtained data at depths greater than 4,000 m indicated the existence of the bottom intensified mean current which are parallel to the bottom contour and flowing with the upslope on their right, similar to currents at the northern perimeter of the Shikoku Basin as described by Fukasawa et al. (1986). The existence of an abyssal boundary current is strongly suggested on the northwestern slope of the central portion of the Ryukyu Trench. The vertical extent of the bottom intensification of the mean current is estimated to be about 1,800 m above the bottom on it. In the narrow, deep passage between the Shikoku and Philippine Basins located at the northern extremity of the Kyushu-Palau Ridge, current meter data indicate no stable abyssal current with a predominant direction. It might be suggested that the deep water transport through the passage between the basins occurs intermittently by strong alternating currents. As mentioned in Introduction, one of our important purposes was not achieved; namely, we were not able to estimate the volume transport of deep water flowing into the Philippine Basin, because data analysis was delayed including data from additional observation. Estimating this volume transport is crucial to build up the abyssal circulation model and to discuss the distribution of deep water properties in the basins of the Philippine Sea. The present observation suggests that the abyssal circulation in the Philippine Basin is more or less separated from that in the Shikoku Basin. Two current observations mentioned below should be made. One is the observation on the southern slope of the Oki-Dait,o Ridge, which is located at t,he northern boundary of the Philippine Basin as shown in Figure 1. The other is the observation at the passage between the Kyushu-Palau and Daito Ridges. Through this passage, the deep water may be supplied from the Philippine Basin into the Kita-Daito Basin and into the Amami Basin north of the Amami Plateau. According t o the numerical model of the Philippine Sea by Kubota and Ono (1991), another abyssal circulation exists in the southern part of the Philippine Basin. Therefore the observation at the western slope of the Philippine Trench is also useful for clarifying the abyssal circulation in the Philippine Sea.
67 Acknowledgement We would like t o express our gratitude t o Professor T. Teramoto of Kanagawa University, Program Scientist of this research program for his valuable suggestions and encouragement throughout the present study. We wish t o express our sincere thanks t o Professor K. Taira of Ocean Research Institute, University of Tokyo for his useful advice and help throughout this study. We are very grateful t o the captain and the crew of T/S Keiten-Maru, Faculty of Fisheries, Kagoshima University, for their sincere help. We thank Messrs. S. Kitagawa of Ocean Research Institute, University of Tokyo, N. Kita of Research Institute for Applied Mechanics, Kyushu University, and T. Yamashiro of Faculty of Engineering, Kagoshima University for their assistance on board. We also thank Drs. S. Imawaki and H. Ichikawa of Faculty of Fisheries, Kagoshima University for improving the manuscript and their help throughout this study.
References Fukasawa, M., and T. Teramoto, 1986. Characteristics of deep current of Cape Shionomisaki before and after formation of the large meander of the Kuroshio in 1981. J. Oceanogr. SOC.Japan, 42, 53-68. Fukasawa, M., T. Teramoto, and K. Taira, 1986. Abyssal current along the northern periphery of Shikoku Basin. J. Oceanogr. SOC.Japan, 42, 459-472. Kaneko, I., 1984. Structure of Mid-depth Waters in the Philippine Sea. Doctor’s thesis, University of Tokyo, 92 pp. Kubota, M., and K. Ono, 1991. Steady abyssal circulation in the Philippine Sea (submitted for publication). Mogi, A., 1972. Bathymetry of the Kuroshio Region. In: Kuroshio - Its Physical Aspects, H. Stommel and K. Yoshida (ed.), University of Tokyo Press, Tokyo, 517 pp. Mogi, A., 1979. An Atlas of the Sea Floor around Japan, Aspect of Submarine Geomorphology. University of Tokyo Press, Tokyo, 92 pp. Stommel, H., and A. B. Arons, 1960a. On the abyssal circulation of the world ocean I. Stationary planetary flow pattern on a sphere. Deep Sea Res., 6, 140-154. Stommel, H., and A. B. Arons, 1960b. On the abyssal circulation of the world ocean - 11. An idealized model of the circulation pattern and amplitude in oceanic basins. Deep Sea Res., 6, 217-233. Taira, K., S. Kitagawa, K. Uehara, H. Ichikawa, H. Hachiya, and T. Teramoto, 1990. Direct measurements of mid-depth circulation in the Shikoku Basin by tracking SOFAR floats. J. Oceanogr. SOC.Japan, 46, 296-306.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Deep Ocean Circulation, Physical and Chemical Aspects edited by T. Teramoto 0 1993 Elsevier Science Publishers B.V. All rights reserved.
69
Deep Circulation in the Shikoku Basin Measured with the SOFAR Floats Keisuke Taira and Daigo Yanagimoto*
Abstract
Tracking of the SOFAR floats were made from April 1988 to January 1991 by releasing twelve floats at 1000 m, 1500 m, 2000 m, 3000 m and 4000 m in the Shikoku Basin. The receivers were moored in five periods and trajectories were obtained for nine floats. Deep circulations and eddy diffusivity inferred from the trajectories of the floats are described.
1.
Introduction
The Shikoku Basin is located south t o Japan (Fig. 1). The Kuroshio, the western boundary current of the North Pacific Ocean, is flowing in the upper layer of the basin entering through Tokara Strait and going out over Izu Ridge. Although the water depth of Tokara Straight and Izu Ridge is hundreds meters, the Kuroshio has a deep current structure in the Shikoku Basin (e.g., Worthington and Kawai, 1972; Taft, 1978). The circulation at mid-depth in the Shikoku Basin is much different from that at the surface measured with the GEK and the satellite-tracking of surface drifters. The direct current measurements in the recent years suggest a deep counter clockwise circulation in the Shikoku Basin. Taira and Teramoto (1981) showed a northward mean flow of 3 cm s-l at 1670 m depth under the northward flowing Kuroshio west to Hachijojima. Nishida and Kuramoto (1982) showed a weak northward deep flow along the western flank of the Izu Ridge. Taira and Teramoto (1985) showed that a north flow at near bottom layer turned t o the southwest along an isobath of Nankai Trough. Their measurements were made along the northeastern perimeter of the Shikoku Basin. A westward flow was observed under the eastward Kuroshio off Omaezaki (Ishizaki et al., 1983) and off Shionomisaki (Fukasawa et al., 1986). Along the western perimeter of the Shikoku Basin, a southward deep flow was observed in the east t o Tanegashima, Okinawa and Taiwan (Chaen et al., personal communication). Circulations in the Shikoku Basin are subject t o cold and warm water masses. South t o the Kuroshio path, a warm water mass is located off Shikoku. The center of the warm water mass shifts westward by about 300 km during the large meandering path of the Kuroshio appears. A large cold water mass off Kii Peninsula appears to the north of the Kuroshio when the Kuroshio path meanders. *Ocean Research Institute, University of Tokyo,
Minamidai, Nakano-ku, Tokyo 164, Japan
70
34
32
30
28
130
132
134
136
138
140
Fig. 1. Bathymetry of the Shikoku Basin, mooring stations of SOFAR receivers ( R l , R2 and R3). Current records at limited numbers of moored stations are subject to the bottom control and to the flows associated to the water masses. A Lagrangian measurement of current, or tracking of water parcel a t the mid-depth, is most requisite to elucidate the deep circulations in the Shikoku Basin. Tracking of neutral floats over several hundreds km distance for several hundreds days was planned as one of the core subjects of the Priority Area Programme “Dynamics of the Deep Circulation, 1987-1989” represented by Prof. T . Teramoto. Twelve SOFAR floats were released in the Shikoku Basin at the depth of 1000 m (2 floats), 1500 m (4 floats), 2000 m (2 floats), 3000 m (2 floats) and 4000 m (2 floats). The tracking was made from April 1988 to January 1991. The circulation inferred by the float trajectories and Lagrangian flow characteristics are described. A part of this study may be found in Taira et al. (1990) and in Yanagimoto (1992).
2.
Tracking Observation and Data Analysis
We used a SOFAR float with capability depth of 6500 m, manufactured by Webb Research Corporation. Two glass balls are used both for buoyancy and for pressure housing. One glass ball contains control unit, and the other battery unit. Outer diameter of the glass ball is 43.2 cm. The float transmits sound waves of
71 Table 1. Float number, drift depth and position, water depth, and date of the deployment. The float number shows the time of the first emission, i.e., FOO emitts signals at OOh and 12h on each day. No. FOO F01 F02 F03 F04
F05 F06 F07 F08 F09 F10 F11
Depth 1500 m 1000 m 1000 m 1500 m 2000 m 2000 m 1500 m 3000 m 3000 m 1500 m 4000 m 4000 m
Latitude 30’00’N 30’00’N 32’51” 29’52” 30’00’N 32’51” 30’00’N 30’00’N 32’50” 29’52” 30’00’N 32’50”
Longitude 135’59’E 134’59’E 136’31’E 135’25’E 135’00’E 136’31’E 136’00’E 134’59’E 136’32’E 135’25’E 135’00’E 136’33’E
w.d. 4410 m 4628 m 4161 m 3521 m 4623 m 4486 m 4390 m 4626 m 4498 m 3530 m 4618 m 4492 m
Deploy date 17 April 1988 27 June 1989 22 June 1989 3 Nov. 1988 27 June 1989 22 June 1989 17 April 1988 27 June 1989 22 June 1989 3 Nov. 1988 27 June 1989 22 June 1989
780 Hz for 80 seconds two times every day for tracking. The sound source is a piezo-electric, bending element with a resonator of aluminum tube 60 cm long and 30 cm in diameter. The 0oat is t o be deployed at drifting depth after buoyancy balance in the laboratory. Buoyancy balance of the SOFAR floats was made in a cylindrical tank 60 cm in the inner diameter and 170 cm long. The tank was filled with seawater. The procedure of balance is described in Taira et al. (1990). In the deployment from a ship, the SOFAR float was hung down to the sea surface by rope with a wedge stopper. The wedge was pulled away after the resonator tube was filled with seawater. The floats released from the R/V Hakuho Maru in April 1988, from the T / S keiten Maru in November 1988, and from the R / V Tansei Maru in June 1989. The release depth, position, and date are tabulated in Table 1. The float is named in terms of signal emission time. For example, float F01 transmits at 0100 and 1300 on each day. A SOFAR receiver is composed with a hydrophone array of eight elements, a signal processor and a digital cassette recorder. The hydrophone array of 3.5 m overall length is tuned for sound waves from horizontal direction and it is set in the SOFAR channel, i.e., at the sound speed minimum layer of about 1000 m depth in the Shikoku Basin. A wave train of 780 Hz with an unit amplitude is generated in the signal processor and it is multiplied with the received signal which is clipped t o have an unit amplitude. Output signal of the multiplier has a maximum amplitude when the 80 second signal from a SOFAR float is received. The largest four amplitudes within every 10 minutes and their arrival time are recorded on a cassette tape. The SOFAR receivers were moored at three stations in the Shikoku Basin with a separation of about 250 km (Fig. 1). The first sets were moored from April 1988
72 Table 2. Mooring data of the SOFAR receivers. %.No. R1-1 R2-1 R3- 1 R1-2
R2-2 R3-2 R1-3 R2-3 R3-3 R1-4 R2-4 R3-4 R1-5 R2-5 R3-5
Latitude 32’30” 28’59” 28’59” 32’30” 29’01” 29’0 1’N 32’30” 29’01” 29’01” 32’31’N 29’00” 29”02” 32’28” 28’58” 29’00”
Longitude 136’02’E 133’30’E 136’00’E 136’02’E 133’30’E 136’00’E 136’01’E 133’30’E 136’00’E 136’02’E 133’30’E 136’05’E 136’03’E 133’30’E 136’00’E
Depth 4640 m 3380 m 4430 m 4600 m 3340 m 4250 m 4600 m 3340 m 4250 m 4631 m 3369 m 4495 m 4582 m 3363 m 4417 m
Set date 16 April 1988 18 April 1988 17 April 1988 27 Oct. 1988 1 Nov. 1988 2 Nov. 1988 27 Oct. 1988 1 Nov. 1988 2 Nov. 1988 23 June 1989 11 Aug. 1989 27 June 1989 14 April 1990 19 April 1990 20 April 1990
Recovery date 27 Oct. 1988 1 Nov. 1988 2 Nov. 1988 27 June 1989 11 Aug. 1988 27 June 1989 23 June 1989 11 Aug. 1989 27 June 1989 14 April 1990 19 April 1990 20 April 1990 1 2 Jan. 1991 23 Jan. 1991 14 Jan. 1991
t o October 1988, the second from October 1988 to June 1989, the third from June 1989 t o November 1989, the fourth from November 1989 t o April 1990, and the fifth from April 1990 t o January 1991 (see Table 2). Records from the receivers were not always of high quality. Some of them were not obtained due t o malfunction of the recording unit or due to the water leakage of the hydrophone array. Fortunately, at least two records were available for each mooring period. The float positions were determined from the arrival time at two stations by the method described in Taira et al. (1990) for the period from 20 April 1988 t o 27 June 1989, and for the period from 19 June 1989 t o 12 January 1991 by the method described by Yanagimoto (1992). In the former method a Cartesian coordinate is assumed, and in the latter a spherical coordinate is used. The battery life of the receivers was about 240 days. A complete data set for 440 days from 1 2 April 1988 to 20 June 1989 was obtained for the listening stations at R1 and R2. There were data gaps between the mooring periods except for the period.
3. Trajectories of SOFAR Floats Drifting at 1500 m Depth Four floats were deployed at 1500 m in Shikoku Basin, two on 17 April 1988 at 30’N and 135”59’E,two on 3 November 1988 at 29’52” and 133’25’E (see Table 1). Fig. 2 shows the trajectories for 440 days from 12 April 1988 t o 20 June 1989. Circles on the trajectories show every 50 days after deployment. The trajectories of the floats showed flows at 1500 m depth in the Shikoku Basin classified into three: 1) clockwise circulation in the central part, 2) northward and southward flows along the western perimeter of the basin, and 3) sluggish flow in the western part of the basin. Floats F03 and F06 were tracked in the period from 19 June
73
28 130
-*
132
I
134
-
I
I
136
138
140
Fig. 2. Trajectories of the SOFAR floats at 1500 m from 20 April 1988 to 27 June 1989 for floats FOO and F06, and from 6 November 1988 t o 27 June 1989 for floats F03 and F09. 1989 t o 12 January 1991, and these trajectories are described in Section 4).
Clockwise circulation in the Shikoku Basin Fig. 3 shows trajectories of floats FOO and F09. Float FOO drifted eastward for several days after deployment, but it turned t o south and then t o t h e west. It 3.1.
turned to the north on 220 day after deployment. From 250 day t o 350 day, it made a cyclonic turn around at 31'30" and 133'30'E. After the turn, it flowed northeastward. Float F09 was deployed 200 days after float FOO, and it flowed northeastward after a cyclonic turning with about 10 km diameter at around 30'30" and 133'30'E. The float flowed southeastward, and it showed quick cyclonic turnings of about ten around at 30"20'N and 138"30'E. Two trajectories showed a clockwise circulation in the Shikoku Basin. A diameter of the circulation is estimated t o be about 500 km. A period of 400 days for one turn gives a mean speed of 4.5 cm s-l. Drift of F09 from 50 day t o 100 day gave a mean speed of 11 cm s-'. The trajectory of float F09 shows quick cyclonic turnings around 30"20'N and 138'30'E. The area is located on the western slope of the Izu Ridge where water depth is beween 1500 m and 3000 m. T h e elliptic trajecories are 80 km long in the northwest and 25 km in the northeast. T h e velocity amplitudes are about 80 cm s-' for the north component and 40 cm s-l for the east component, and the period is about 8 days.
74
PI
-
132
I
.
134
I
1
I
136
138
140
Fig. 3. Trajectories of the SOFAR floats at 1500 m from 20 April 1988 to 27 June 1989 for float FOO, and from 6 November 1988 t o 27 June 1989 for float F09.
/
28 130
Pl
-
132
I
134
-
I
I
136
138
140
Fig. 4. Trajectories of the SOFAR float F06 at 1500 m from 20 April 1988 t o 27 June 1989. 3.2.
Northward and southward flows along the western perimeter
Fig. 4 shows trajectory of float F06, which was deployed on the same day and at nearly the same position as float FOO. Two trajectories were identical for several
75
28 130
PI
I
-
132
F03 I
134
-
I
I
136
138
140
Fig. 5. Trajectories of the SOFAR float F03 at 1500 m from 6 November 1988 t o 27 June 1989. days, but float F06 flowed t o the west until 150 day. It flowed t o the north until 200 day, and then it flowed southward along an isobath of 1500 m. From 250 day to 380 day, it flowed into the Shikoku Basin with a clockwise turning. It flowed again southward until the end of tracking. The speed of the southward flow was about 4 cm s-'. The trajectories estimated t o be lying in the western area where water depth smaller than 1500 m. This was considered t o be caused by a delay of the clock of the float by about 20 seconds.
3.3.
Sluggish flow in the western part of the basin
Fig. 5 shows trajectory of float F03 which was deployed on 3 November 1988 at 30°N and 133'25'E. It stayed in a square of 100 km in the north direction and 150 km in the east direction. A mean drift speed was less than 2 cni s-'. The float made clockwise turnings of several times. 3.4.
Trajectories of the floats at 1500 m from 19 June 1989 t o 12 January 1991
Fig. 6 shows trajectories of floats F03 and F06 in the period from 19 June 1989 to 12 January 1991. Float F06 appeared to the east of Kyushu and entered again into the deep Shikoku Basin. This shows that the southward flow under the Kuroshio is not stable. When it crossed the bottom contour, clockwise turnings with a period of 4 days were observed. The float went northeastward along the isobath south to Shikoku. The float appeared east to the Kyushuu-Palau Ridge in the beginning of the fifth period, and it flowed northwestward. Float F03 moved northward, and it returned near t o the deploy position after counter clockwise turning.
76
28 130
132 134 136 138 140 Fig. 6. Trajectories of the SOFAR floats F03 and F06 at 1500 m in the period from 19 June 1989 to 1 2 January 1991.
34
32
30
28 130
132
134
136
138
140
Fig. 7. Trajectories of the SOFAR floats F01 and F02 at 1000 m in the period from 19 June 1989 to 1 2 January 1991.
77
28" 130
U
d
132
I
134
*
I
I
136
138
140
Fig. 8. Trajectories of the SOFAR floats F04 and F05 at 2000 m in the period from 19 June 1989 to 1 2 January 1991.
period
4.
Trajectories of the SOFAR Floats at 1000 m, 2000 m and 3000 m Depth
Eight floats were released a t 1000 m, 2000 m, 3000 m and 4000 m in June 1989 (See Table 1). The signals from float F08 deployed at 3000 m, floats F10 and F11
78 Table 3. Eddy viscosity and relaxation time estimated from the SOFAR float tracking. The values for the western North Atlatic Ocean are given by Riser and Rossby (1983). Sea area
depth (m)
Shikoku Basin
1000 1500 2000 3000 700 2000
Western North Atlantic Ocean
Eddy diffusivity ( 106cm2s-1) E-W N-S 25 13 11 9.9 6.6 7.7 4.9 4.5 45 18 9.0 2.6
Relaxation (day) E-W 8.1 6.9 14 7.6 18 15
time
N-S 7.1 6.2 16
17 7.0 7.0
deployed at 4000 m depth were sporadically received by one of three receivers. T h e trajectories of these floats were not obtained. Fig. 7 shows trajectories of floats F01 and F01 deployed at 1000 m. Float F01 deployed off Kii Peninsula first flowed southward, and it showed a clockwise turning, then a counter clockwise turning, and a clockwise turning. T h e drifting speed was about 8 cm s-'. Fig. 8 shows trajectories of floats F04 and F05 deployed at 2000 m depth. Float F04 made clockwise turnings. Float F05 flowed southward, and then it turned to northeastward. A mean drifting speed was about 3.2 cm s-'. Fig. 9 shows the trajectory of F07 at 3000 m. Mean drift speed was about 3.3 cm s-'. The flow is similar to t h a t at 2000 m depicted by float F04.
5.
Eddy Diffusivity Estimated from Lagrangian Velocities
Tracking of a SOFAR float is by quasi-Lagrangian measurements of water movement on an isobaric surface since the float is equipped with buoyancy-adjusting gear t o keep the pressure constant. T h e correlation function of Lagrangian velocity gives a n eddy diffusivity and a relaxation time (e.g., Riser and Rossby, 1982). The eddy diffusivity k is estimated by
1 t
k=
R(r)dr
(1)
where R ( r ) is the auto-correlation function of Lagrangian velocity v l , i.e., R(7)= vl(t)vl(t - 7). Th e relaxation time I represents a time scale of velocity correlation, and is estimated by rt
The estimated eddy diffusivity and relaxation time are shown in Table 3. The eddy diffusivity is larger at 1000 m and it decreases with the depth. The eddy
79 diffusivity for the east component is two times as large as that for the north component. It is not clear why the difference comes from because the drift speeds and their root-mean-squares are of the same magnitude for both components. At the deeper layers, eddy diffusivity is similar for the east and north components. The relaxation time varies from 4.5 day to 17 day, and it has a tendency t o increase with the depth. Riser and Rossby (1982) estimated the eddy diffusivity and the relaxation time from the trajectories of the SOFAR floats at 700 m and 2000 m in the recirculation of the Gulf Stream in the western North Atlantic. Their results are also shown in Table 3. The eddy diffusivity in the North Atlantic is of the nearly same magnitude as in the Shikoku Basin. The eddy diffusivity for the east component is nearly 3 times as large as that for the north component. The relaxation time is from 7 day t o 18 day, which is similar t o that observed in the Shikoku Basin.
6.
Summary
Twelve SOFAR floats were released in the Shikoku Basin at the depth of 1000 m (2 floats), 1500 m (4 floats), 2000 m (2 floats), 3000 m (2 floats) and 4000 m (2 floats). The receivers were moored at three stations in the five periods from April 1988 to January 1991. The signals from the floats a t 4000 m and from one at 3000 m were not received at more than two stations. The trajectories were obtained for nine floats. Circulation at 1500 m depth measured from April 1988 t o June 1989 may be summarized as: 1) a clockwise circulation around the Shikoku Warm Water Mass centered around at 31"N and 136"E. Two floats made a clockwise turning around the water mass with a diameter of about 400 km at a mean drifting speed of 4.5 cm s-'. 2) a southward flow under the northward flowing Kuroshio in the east t o Kyushu. One float revealed the southward flow of 4 cm s-l speed. The float first flowed northward, and it went out t o central portion of Shikoku Basin on a midway of southward drift. Although the southward flow was not steady, it was suggested to be one part of a anti-clockwise circulation at deep layers along the perimeter of the basin, which had been shown by the records of moored current meters. 3) a sluggish flow in the western part of the basin. One float deployed at 29"52'N and 133"25'E remained in a limited area about 100 km in the east direction and 150 km in the north direction for 234 days. However, the trajectory of the float crossed several times those of the floats drifting around the Shikoku Warm Water Mass and of the float flowing under the Kuroshio. Some of the above flow characteristics were confirmed at other depth and in the remaining periods. The Kuroshio path was rather unstable in the latter half of the tracking observations, and a further analysis on the distribution of the water masses is requisite. The trajectories of the floats revealed several cyclonic and anticyclonic eddies in the Shikoku Basin. Among them, the cold eddies at 1500 m depth in the west to the Izu Ridge were the most remarking. The shape was elliptic about 80 km long in the northern-northwest and 25 km long in the western-southwest, and the period was 8 days. The cyclonic turns were observed from March t o June 1988.
T h e eddy diffusivity estimated from t h e drift speeds of t h e floats varies from
4 . 5 - 2 5 ~ 1 0cm2sP1, ~ a n d t h e relaxation time is 5.4-17 days.
References Fukasawa, M., T . Teramoto and K.Taira, 1986. Abyssal currents along the periphery of Shikoku Basin. J. Oceanogr. SOC.Japan, 42, 459-472. Ishizaki, H., 0 . Asaoka, S. Konaga, and M. Takahashi, 1983. Direct measurement of near-bottom current on the continental slope off Omaezaki, central Japan. Pap. Met. Geophys., 33, 257-268. Nishida, H., and S. Kuramoto, 1982. Deep current of the Kuroshio around the Izu Ridge - Large meander of the Kuroshio in 1975-1980 (IV). Rept. Hydrogr. Res., Tokyo, N0.17, 241-255. Riser, S. C., and H. T. Rossby, 1982. Quasi-Lagrangian structure and variability of the subtropical western North Atlantic circulation. J. Mar. Res., 41, 127-162. Taft, B. A, 1978. Structure of the Kuroshio south of Japan. J. Mar. Res., 16, 77-117. Taira, K., and T. Teramoto, 1981. Velocity fluctuation of the Kuroshio near the Izu Ridge and their relationship to current path. Deep-sea Res., 28, 1187-1197. Taira, K., and T . Teramoto, 1985. Bottom currents in Nankai Trough and Sagami Trough. J. Oceanogr. SOC.Japan, 41, 388-398. Taira, K., S. Kitagawa, K. Uehara, H. Ichikawa, H. Hachiya and T . Teramoto, 1990. Direct measurements of mid-depth circulation in the Shikoku Basin by tracking SOFAR floats. J. Oceanogr. SOC.Japan, 46, 296-306. Worthington, L. V., and H. Kawai, 1972. Comparison between deep sections across the Kuroshio and the Florida Current of Gulf Stream. In: Kuroshio, Its Physical Aspects, H. Stommel and K. Yoshida (ed.), University of Tokyo Press, pp. 371-385. Yanagimoto, D. (1992). Observation of mid-depth circulation in the Shikoku Basin by tracking the SOFAR floats. Master Thesis, University of Tokyo, 48 pp.
Chapter 3 Circulation and Mixing of Water as Deduced from Distribution of Chemical Tracers
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Deep Ocean Circulation, Physical and Chemical Aspects edited by T. Teramoto 0 1993 Elsevier Science Publishers B.V. All rights reserved.
83
Chemistry and the Oceans: An Overview Yoshiyu ki N 0Z AKI*
Abstract
Chemical oceanographers are concerned with the composition and distribution of elements and isotopes in ocean water. Their determination is a basic study of marine science which not only satisfies human’s curiosity but also can help us to understand various oceanographic processes. A focus is placed on global change.
1.
Introduction
In the last few decades of 20th century, it has become increasingly convincing that the ocean plays significant role on our global environment. This trend has led us to currently reinforce a need of comprehensive study of the world oceans through international cooperation. Along the line, two major international oceanographic programs are now going on, which are the World Ocean Circulation Experiments (WOCE) and the Joint Global Ocean Flux Study (JGOFS). WOCE deals with physical ocean circulation and JGOFS deals with the biogeochemical cycling in the ocean. Both of which are very important, because the ocean acts as a significant modifier of the world climate through exchange of heat, water and COz across the air-sea interface. There is no doubt that without having detailed knowledge of the oceanic behavior, it is impossible to precisely predict the future trend of global climatic change, which may be caused by human use of fossil-fuels and reduction of terrestrial biosphere. Chemical oceanographers are concerned with the composition and distribution of elements in seawater, and eight papers contained in this chapter cover a wide range of interests from analytical method t o tracer modelling. Nevertheless, it seems clear t o me that all these efforts are directed toward improving our knowledge of the global system. To demonstrate this, I briefly review the history of chemical analysis of seawater. Present status and some future directions of chemical oceanography are also described.
2.
A Historical Review
The composition of major elements was established by the end of 19th century, when the British Challenger expedition was carried out. Since then, significant efforts of marine chemists have been devoted t o determine trace elements in seawater. However, this was not an easy task for many of the heavy metals because their * O c e a n Research I n s t i t u t e , University of Tokyo, Minamidai, Nakano-ku, T o k y o 164, J a p a n
84 Table 1. Some heavy metal concentrations in seawater (nmol/kg) adopted in various review articles
Element Fe cu Ag Au Pb Bi
Goldberg (1963) 180 50 3 0.02 0.2 0.1
Brewer (1975) 36 8 0.3 0.02 0.2 0.1
Quinby-Hunt & Turekian (1983) 0.7 2 0.03 0.06 0.005 0.05
Nozaki (1992) 0.6 2 0.02 0.00015 0.005 0.00015
concentrations are extremely low, and the water samples are very easily contaminated. It is a famous story t h a t a German chemist, Fritz Haber tried to recover gold from seawater in order for his mother country t o be able t o pay the deficit t h a t resulted from the World War I. His attempt completely failed, however, because the concentration of gold in seawater was at least three orders of magnitude lower than the value given a t the time when the program was started, as he found after his ten-year elaborated work. There are a number of other stories showing t h a t the values reported for heavy metal concentration in seawater decreased with time and some examples for this trend are given in Table 1. Of course, these are not real but artifact. This tendency continued even when the last major oceanographic program, the Geochemical Ocean Section Study (GEOSECS) was initiated in around 1970. The GEOSECS was aimed at obtaining the section map of various geochemical parameters in the world oceans, but it could not include trace elements except for Ba because of the lack of analytical consistency, and therefore its focus went on radionuclides and stable isotopes. It was since 1976 t h a t reliable d a t a for some heavy metals such as Cu, Ni and Cd became available owing t o the careful improvement of methods. In the following 15 years to date, there has been an accelerated quantum leap in our knowledge of trace elements in seawater. Figure 1 shows the most recent d a t a set for trace element distribution in the North Pacific given in the form of periodic table. If this were made 5 t o 10 years ago, perhaps one third to a half could be incorrect or unfilled. Even now, there is still lack of d a t a for some platinum metals, R h and Os, and Nb and Ta etc., but there is a good hope that all the d a t a will be filled by the year 2000 so far as the current efforts are continued. Although determining trace element and isotopic composition of seawater is a very basic study of marine geochemistry, it should be realized t h a t it is not only for satisfaction of human’s curiosity but also very important in solving various oceanographic problems related to global change.
3.
Where We Stand Now
All agree that the ocean plays a significant role on the global environment through exchange of heat and materials with other reservoirs across the boundaries and its internal physical and biogeochemical cycling. However, the problem is t h a t
Trace elememt distributions - 1
c
m
a,
0
0
.-0 c .0
m n
a,
5 .-c
in the Pacific Ocean
- I
......
...
!U. ;17 .......
............
85
: ........r \ ir\ ..
Fig. 1 A part of periodic table showing the vertical profiles of elements in the North Pacific Ocean.
86 we do not understood the system well enough to precisely predict the future trend of global change. Toward resolving the problem, chemistry of the ocean is very important in the following three aspects.
3.1.
Their usefulness as tracers of ocean circulation
Various chemical tracers of steady-state and transient nature such as 14C, 3HHe, Freons etc. are being measured in the WOCE program following the tradition of GEOSECS and the Transient Tracer in the Ocean (TTO). The tracers listed in Table 2 are considered to be useful to estimate the rates of basin scale circulation, ventilation, and thermocline mixing, which are somewhat difficult to obtain by other means. One of the major advances since GEOSECS is that analytical techniques have been considerably improved. For example, tandem accelerator mass spectrometry is now successfully applied t o the determination of 14C and “Be and revolutionarily reduced the amount of water needed for measurement from 200 L to less than 1 L for 14C and from thousands to a few tens of liters for 1°Be. A new high-sensitivity gas chromatographic method made it possible to use anthropogenic chlorofluorocarbons as novel tracers of physical circulation, in particular for the study of thermocline ventilation. 3 H and 3He are now routinely measured by mass spectrometry rather than the conventional gas counting method employed during GEOSECS. Further improvement of analytical techniques of potentially valuable tracers seems likely. They include a resonance ionization mass spectrometry for 39Ar, a continuous flow a-scintillation detection for 2 2 7 Aand ~ a high abundance sensitivity mass spectrometry for Pu. Trace elements can also serve as water mass tracers provided that convenient and precise methods are available. For example, Mn and Al, and CH4 are useful to survey the deep-sea hydrothermal vents which are hardly traced by regular properties like salinity and nutrients. A1 is also useful to follow the fresh water discharge from rivers and the Mediterranean outflow in the North Atlantic (Measures et al., 1986). The ocean circulation is undoubtedly an important control of global climate. Extensive upwelling of nutrient-rich deep water to the surface, if it occurs more than usual, enhances the ocean productivity and thereby reduces atmospheric COZ. It also carries cold water up to the surface so that the surface temperature may be reduced. Thus, any change of ocean circulation can influence the global climate. Chemical tracers provide one of the useful tools t o study such physical oceanographic behavior. 3.2.
Their importance in biological processes
It has been well known that the micro-nutrients such as N, P, K, Fe etc. are essential for plant growth. For terrestrial plants, it is hard to believe that Fe can act as a limiting nutrient because it is very abundant in soil. However, in the ocean, Fe is highly reactive and has a short residence time. And therefore, it is likely that the lack of Fe (which is necessary to form enzyme “cytochrome”) can limit phytoplankton growth. Martin and Fitzwater (1988) collected seawater using a clean technique, and made the culture experiments with and without addition of Fe. They observed enhanced plant growth with Fe, suggesting that Fe indeed acts as a limiting nutrient. Martin et al. (1989) also made a careful seawater measurements
Table 2.
Transient and radioactive tracers useful for the study of ocean circulation
Tracer
Species
1) Chlorofluorocarbons 2) Tritium 3) Helium-3 (a) decay product (b) primordial 4) Radiocarbon (a) man-made (b) natural 5) Radium-226 6) Argon-39 7) Silicon-32 8) Actinium-227 9) Radium-228
Diss. gas unreactive HTO unreactive
10) Kripton-85 11) Strontium-90
12) Cesium-137
Reactivity
Time Range
< -3Oy < -3Oy
Source Function Atmosphere (gas exchange) Atmosphere (fallout)
Diss. gas unreactive one month-30 y Decay of tritium Diss. gas unreactive Earth’s interior reactive HCO, reactive HCO, reactive Ra2+ Diss. gas unreactive reactive H2Si03 reactive A&O; slightly Ra2+ reactive Diss. gas u n re act i ve Sr2+ slightly reactive reactive cs+ slightly reactive
< -30 y 20-50,000 y 50-5,000 y 20-1,000 y 30-700 y 5-100 y 0.5-30 y
Atmosphere Atmosphere Sediment Atmosphere Atmosphere Sediment Sediment
(gas exchange) (gas exchange)
Water Volume Needed for Detection
< l L < l L
< 0.1 L < 0.1 L 1L
(gas exchange) (fallout)
200 L 20 L 1500 L 1500 L 200 L 200 L
< 30 y < 30 y
Atmosphere (gas exchange) Atmosphere (fallout )
200 L 50 L
< 30 y
Atmosphere (fallout)
50 L 00
88 and found that the surface waters in the higher latitude regions are depleted in Fe, although some N and P are still remained in it. It has been further argued that, during the last glacial time, the high-latitude ocean productivity may be enhanced due t o increased wind-blown Fe supply, and this mechanism can explain why the atmospheric CO;? was approximately 90 ppm lower than the present day pre-anthropogenic level, as indicated by the ice-core C02 study (Neftel et al., 1982). Based on these, hot arguments are now going on, regarding whether or not the counter-balancing the increasing atmospheric C 0 2 due to fossil-fuel burning by the artificial Fe fertilization in the Antarctic region is feasible. The arguments are now under significant controversy and further experiments are needed t o resolve the questions. But what I want to point out here is t,hat measurement of Fe in seawater has been a real basic study in trace element geochemistry regardless of its biological significance and could not be accomplished until recently because of the difficulty of obtaining and handling water samples without contamination from the surroundings, i.e., rust of ship. Perhaps, Martin did not expect such an importance in the global change, when he started to work on Fe. This example clearly tells us that upgrading of broad ocean science is essential to our better understanding of the global system. 3.3.
Their usefulness as a paleoceanographic indicator
In the course of measuring some heavy metals in sea water, it was found t h a t Cd
is well correlated with P throughout the ocean. From this, Ed Boyle of MIT came up with an idea t h a t Cd in foraminiferra of deep-sea sediments may be used to deduce phosphate concentration in the paleo-ocean. After elaborated development of cleaning technique, he succeeded to obtain down-core Cd/Ca records which added important constraints on the geochemical cycling together with 0 and C isotope records. One of the important outcomes is a new view that, during the last glacial time, the rate of deep water formation in the North Atlantic was significantly smaller than today. Again, this change of ocean circulation and the resultant chemical redistribution may be related to the climatic change and various models are proposed to reproduce the lower atmospheric concentration of C02 during the last glacial time (see Boyle, 1988). Similarly, Ba/Ca and Ge/Si ratios in calcareous and siliceous tests may also serve as paleo-oceanographic indicators, because Ba and Ge are remarkably well correlated with alkalinity and dissolved Si throughout the ocean (Chan et al, 1977, Froelich and Andreae, 1981). These new techniques should help us to understand what happened on the ocean circulation and biogeochemical cycling in the past and t o predict what is going t o happen in the future.
4.
Concluding remarks
These three examples described above are all based on the fact t h a t we are now able t o measure chemical constituents of seawater well accurate enough t o use them as oceanographic tracers. Future development of techniques will provide more automated, precise and accurate methods. Using those techniques, we will be able to explore more sophisticated phenomena in the ocean. It has been a dream of marine
geochemists to obtain detailed three dimensional map of geochemical properties in the world oceans. A part of it may be achieved by WOCE hydrographic program. However, it is not planned t o cover any aspects of the geochemical cycling on a global scale. Originally, this must be a part of jobs of JGOFS, but unfortunately, it is now oriented to the process study and the global description is left behind. Therefore, we will need to have another world-wide ocean program in the near future which certainly requires international cooperation. One possible strategy is t o build a new vessel equipped with all analytical capabilities and let it do mapping along her track. It may take more than 5 years to complete the Pacific Ocean and perhaps 20 years for the world oceans. But certainly, it will contribute significantly to our better understanding of the global change.
Acknowledgement
I gratefully acknowledge the funding agency t o the priority area research program “Dynamics of the Deep Ocean Circulation”, the Ministry of Education, Science and Culture, Japan for support. References Boyle, E., 1988. The role of vertical chemical fractionation in controlling the late Quaternary atmospheric carbon dioxide. J. Geophys. Res., 93, 15701-15714. Brewer, P. G., 1975. Minor elements in sea water. In: Chemical Oceanography, Vol. 1, 2nd Edition, J. P. Riley and Skirrow (ed.), Academic Press, London, pp. 415-496. Chan, L. H., D. Drummond, J. M. Edmond, and B. Grant, 1977. On the barium data from the Atlantic GEOSECS Expedition. Deep-sea Res., 24, 613-649. Froelich, Jr., P. N., and M. 0. Andreae, 1981. The marine geochemistry of germanium: Ekasilicon. Science, 213, 205-207. Goldberg, E. D., 1963. The ocean as a chemical system. In: The Sea, Vol. 2 , M. N. Hill (ed.), Interscience Publ. John Wiley & Sons, New York, pp. 3-20. Martin, J. H., and S. E. Fitzwater, 1988. Iron deficiency limits phytoplankton growth in the north-east Pacific subarctic. Nature, 331, 341-343. Martin, J. H., R. M. Gordon, S. E. Fitzwater and W. W. Broenkow, 1989. VERTEX: Phytoplankton/iron studies in the Gulf of Alaska. Deep-sea Res., 36, 649-680. Measures, C. I., J. M. Edmond, and T. D. Jickells, 1986. Aluminum in the northwest Atlantic. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta, 50, 1423-1428. Neftel, A., H. Oeshger, J. Schwander, B. Stauffer, and R. Zumbrunn, 1982. Ice core sample measurements give atmospheric COz content during the past 40,000 years. Nature, 295, 220-223. Nozaki, Y., 1992. Trace elments in sea water: Their mean concentrations and North Pacific profiles. Chikyukagaku (Geochemistry), 26, 35-39. Quinby-Hunt, M . S., and K. K . Turekian, 1983. Distribution of elements in sea water. EOS, 64, 130-131.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Deep Ocean Circulation, Physical and Chemical Aspects edited by T. Teramoto 0 1993 Elsevier Science Publishers B.V. All rights reserved.
91
Philippine Sea Abyssal Waters in the Northwestern Pacific: Characterization from Tracer-Tracer Diagrams Toshitaka GAMO*
Abstract
In an effort to elucidate the origin of the Philippine Sea bottom water (PSBW), recent reliable chemical data of deep and bottom waters as well as bottom topographic features in the northwestern Pacific Ocean including the Philippine Sea were compiled and examined in detail. Although the PSBW is a branch from the bottom western boundary current flowing northward through the western Pacific Ocean, chemical characteristics of the PSBW were found to be significantly deviated from the trends of the main northwestern Pacific bottom water in Tp (potential temperature)-Oz, Tp-Si, and Tp-A14C diagrams. It was inferred that the PSBW is strongly influenced by vertical mixing between the PSBW and the overlying Philippine Sea deep water, whose characteristics are different from those of the main northwestern Pacific deep water, probably due to the topographic barrier of Izu-BoninMariana Ridge sequence.
1.
Introduction
The bottom water in the Pacific Ocean is replenished by the Antarctic Bottom water (AABW) flowing northward as a bottom western boundary current (Sverdrup et al., 1942; Stommel, 1958; Stommel and Arons, 1960; Knauss, 1962; Reid et al., 1968; Edmond et al., 1970; Craig et al., 1972). Wooster and Volkman (1960), Mantyla (1975) and Mantyla and Reid (1983) discussed the direction and branchings of the bottom current by mapping abyssal distributions of potential temperature and dissolved oxygen in the Pacific Ocean. The water below the depth of 5 km is defined as the bottom water in this paper. Figure 1 shows a generally believed bottom water circulation pattern connecting four major basins (A-D) in the western Pacific Ocean. Basins A, B, and C are the southern, central and northern basins, respectively, according t o the classification by Wooster and Volkman (1960). Basin D corresponds to the Philippine Sea. These basins are connected by narrow passages: the Samoan Passage between basins A and B with a sill depth of about 5,000 m (Reid and Lonsdale, 1974; Craig et al., 1981b), and the Wake Island Passage between basins B and C with a sill depth of >5,180 m (Chase et al., 1971). These passages are topographic constrictions against *Ocean Research Institute, University of Tokyo, Minamidai, Nakano-ltu, Tokyo 164, Japan
92
Fig. 1. A general bottom circulation pattern in the western Pacific Ocean connecting four basins A, B, C and D. The bottom topographic map was prepared by the GEOSECS Operating Group (Craig et al., 1981b). the northward bottom current. Although behaviors of the bottom current through basins A, B and C have been relatively well documented so far (e.g., Mantyla and Reid, 1983), little attention has been paid t o the behavior of bottom water from basins B to D as well as the origin of the Philippine Sea bottom water. Spatial variations of physical and chemical tracers in seawater give us useful information on water circulation and mixing processes. The purpose of this paper is t o characterize the Philippine Sea bottom water by comparing it with the other bottom waters in the Pacific Ocean using appropriate tracer-tracer diagrams. Emphasis will be placed on bottom water modification processes from basins B t o D in relation to bottom topographic features around basin D.
93 2.
Chemical Tracers
Tracers used in this study are potential temperature (Tp), salinity (S), dissolved oxygen ( 0 2 ) , silicate (Si) and carbon-14 (A14C). Data of Tp, S , 0 2 and Si are referred from those of the GEOSECS Pacific Expedition in 1973-1974 (Craig et al., 1981a), those of the INDOPAC Expedition Legs I1 and I11 in 1976 (Scripps Inst. Oceanogr., 1978), and those of VEGA Expedition in 1978 (Horibe, 1978). The locations of stations and their depths are listed in the Appendix. A14C data in the Pacific Ocean were referred from those of GEOSECS ("Ostlund and Stuiver, 1980), Horibe and Gamo (1980), Gamo et al. (1987), and Watanabe et al. (1987), and those in the Philippine Sea were from Horibe and Gamo (1980), Broecker et al. (1986), and Watanabe et al. (1987). In order t o evaluate d a t a consistency among the different expeditions, two pairs of stations with almost the same locations were selected for comparing S, T p , 0 2 and Si d a t a between GEOSECS and INDOPAC, and between INDOPAC and VEGA. The former location is a pair of GEOSECS station 223 (34"58'N, 151"51'E) and INDOPAC Leg-1 Station 87 (35"02'N, 151"55'E), and the latter is a pair of INDOPAC Leg-3 Station 24 (13"03'N, 136'30'E) and VEGA Station 4 (12"54'N, 136'27'E). Intercomparison of A14C values between GEOSECS d a t a and our measurements was described by Gamo et al. (1987). Systematic cruise-to-cruise shiftas of Tp, S, 0 2 , Si, and A14C were proved to be almost insignificant: less than the error of measurement for T p (f0.01"C) and S (f0.003), less than f 2 pmol kg-' for 0 2 , f 5 pmol kg-' for Si, and f 0 . 5 % for A14C.
3.
Geographical Settings and Previous Works
Figure 2 is a simplified depth chart of the Philippine Sea and its surroundings. The Philippine Sea is a lozenge-shaped basin, the depth of which is roughly in the range of 5000-6000 m, except for the Ryukyu and Philippine Trenches (maximum depth: 10,030 m) along the western margin of the Philippine Sea. To the east of the Sea, a sequence of Izu, Bonin, Mariana, Yap and Palau islands forms an almost continuous topographic high. This topographic sequence is called "South Honshu Ridge" according t o the topographic map by Chase et al. (1971). The South Honshu Ridge is a topographic barrier surrounding the eastern and southern sides of basin D. The westward bottom water (depth > 5 km) from basin B is supposed to pass through the East Mariana Basin, being greatly hindered from entering the Philippine Sea by the topographic barrier. Judging from the detailed topographic features, only one route is available for the bottom water to enter basin D: a narrow passage between the Yap and Mariana Islands (Yap-Mariana Junction) as indicated by the thick arrow in Fig. 2. Its sill depth is 5,000 m according to Uehara and Taira (1990). Detailed CTD-hydrocasts along 12"N and 13"N in the Philippine Sea have verified the existence of cold and saline bottom water in the southern Philippine Sea between the South Honshu Ridgz and the Kyushu-Palau Ridge, which evidences bottom water inflow from the East Mariana Basin to the southern Philippine Sea (Uehara and Taira, 1990).
94
Fig. 2. A bathymetric map of the Philippine Sea and its surroundings. Thin lines represent the 4 km contours. The thick arrow between the Mariana and Yap Islands shows the most probable route for the bottom current entering into the Philippine Sea (Yap-Mariana Junction). Filled circles and squares stand for INDOPAC and VEGA stations, respectively. Previous works on water chemistry around the Philippine Sea have suggested that the topographic barrier of the South Honshu Ridge might be responsible for unique characteristics of the Philippine Sea abyssal waters. Moriyasu (1972) showed that Tp, S and 0 2 values below 4,000 m depth are significantly different between
95 the Philippine Sea and the northwestern Pacific. Kaneko and Teramoto (1985) mapped the horizontal distributions of T p , S, 0 2 and Si along isopycnals of ug = 27.30, 27.70, and 27.77 (approximate depths of 1000, 2000, and 3000 m, respectively), showing that the isopycnal water exchanges between the Philippine Sea and the northwestern Pacific are more greatly restricted by the bottom topography as the isopycnals become deeper.
4.
Characterization from Tracer-Tracer Diagrams
As a bottom water flows away from its origin, its characteristics are gradually modified from the original ones. This is mainly due t o the following three processes: (i) filtering out of the deepest (densest) water by the sills, (ii) vertical mixing with overlying deep waters, and (iii) in situ physical and chemical processes. The modification is reflected in the distribution of appropriate physical and chemical tracers in seawater. For example, bottom water T p increases due to (i) filtering out of the coldest water, (ii) vertical mixing with overlying warmer deep waters, and (iii) geothermal heating, while 0 2 decreases due t o (i) filtering out of the 02-rich bottom water, (ii) vertical mixing with deep waters which are poorer in 0 2 , and (iii) 0 2 consumption by in situ decomposition of organic matter. A X-Y plot of an appropriate pair of tracers (a tracer-tracer diagram) is useful for bottom water characterization. Figure 3(a)-(d) show the tracer-tracer diagrams (S, 0 2 , Si, A14C versus T p ) for the western Pacific bottom waters below a depth of 5 km. It is apparent that the tracer-tracer characteristics vary from basin t o basin, reflecting bottom water modification processes. As expected above, the Tp0 2 diagram (Fig. 3(b)) indicates that an increase of bottom T p is accompanied by a decrease in 0 2 according t o the northward bottom flow path shown in Fig. 1. It is noteworthy that the relationship between T p and S, 0 2 , Si or A14C is not a simple straight line, but has two remarkable discontinuities as described below: (1) a marked bending point between basins A and B, and (2) significant standoff of basin D characteristics from a smooth trend connecting basins B and C. A proper interpretation for the first discontinuity may come from the vertical mixing between bottom water and overlying deep water in basins A and B in addition t o the sill filtering effect. In basin A, the northward AABW is modified by vertical mixing with the overlying Circumpolar deep water (CDW). On the contrary, basin B bottom water is not significantly affected by CDW but rather modified by basin B deep water. Figure 4(a)-(c) compare the tracer-tracer diagrams (Tp-S, Tp-02, and Tp-Si) of deep and bottom waters below 500 m depth among the four basins. As shown in Fig. 4, CDW is significantly higher in 0 2 and S values, and lower in Si than the deep water in basin B. These difference of deep water characteristics between basins A and B is thought t o play a significant role in producing the A-B bendings shown in Fig. 3(a)-(d). Before discussing the second discontinuity, we define the following abbreviations for convenience. The northwestern Pacific excluding the Philippine Sea, i.e., basin C, is simply called “the northwestern Pacific”, and the bottom water (depth
96
1
t 0.5
1.o
Potential Temperature
("C)
Fig. 3. Tracer-tracer diagrams below the depth of 5 km in the western Pacific Ocean. (a) Tp-S, (b) Tp-02, (c) Tp-Si diagrams (data sources are Craig et al. (1981a), Scripps Inst. Oceanogr. (1987), and Horibe (1978)), and (d) Tp-A14C diagram, where open circles are from "Ostlund and Stuiver (1980), filled squares from Horibe and Gamo (1980) and Gamo et al. (1987), an open triangle from Broecker et al. (1986), and filled triangles from Watanabe et al. (1987).
> 5 km) in the northwestern Pacific is called NWPBW (North-Western Pacific Bottom Water). The Philippine Sea bottom water is abbreviated t o PSBW. The origin of NWPBW and PSBW must be commonly basin B as shown in Fig. 1. Why do the characteristics of the PSBW and NWPBW show so significantly different trends from each other as shown in Fig. 3(b)-(d)? Since the Tp-S diagram
97
0.5
1 .o
Potential Temperature
0.5
("C)
1.0 Potential Temperature
Fig. 3.
("C 1
(continued)
(Fig. 3(a)) shows little standoff of PSBW, the idea of higher heat flow in basin D than basin C may be rejected.
5.
Modifications of the Source Bottom Water by Vertical Mixing
Since vertical mixing with an overlying deep water is an important process t o alter the tracer-tracer characteristics of a bottom water as already shown in the case of the A-B bending in the previous section, deep waters in basins C and D may provide a clue to solve the problem. As mentioned in Section 3, it has been known that the deep waters in basins C and D have different characteristics due t o the topographic barrier of the South Honshu Ridge. Then it should be examined
98 whether the difference between the PSBW and NWPBW is related t o the difference of the deep water characteristics between the two basins. In Fig. 4(a)-(c), Tp-S, Tp-02, and Tp-Si diagrams of the deep and bottom waters below 500 m depth were compared among basins A-D. These diagrams clearly demonstrate that the deep water characteristics are significantly different between basins C and D. The Tp-S diagram of basin D is simply sandwiched by those of the basins B and C (Fig. 4(a)), while the Tp-02 and Tp-Si diagrams (Fig. 4(b) and (c)) are remarkably different in their shapes between the two basins. Basin C has relatively a sharp 0 2 minimum layer with 0 2 concentration of 20-50 pmol kg-' centered at T p = 3-4OC, while basin D has a broader 0 2 minimum with higher O2 values (60-100 pmol kg-') at T p = 446°C. As for Tp-Si diagram, basin C deep water has a well developed Si maximum layer centered at T p = 1.52.0°C, while basin D shows much less Si maximum layer centered at slightly less T p range. It is of interest that the Tp-S diagram (Fig. 3(a)) shows less standoff of the PSBW than the T p - 0 2 , Tp-Si, and Tp-A14C (Fig. 3(b)-(d)). This is probably because the depth of salinity minimum, which occurs at approximately 700 m depth in the midlatitudinal northwestern Pacific Ocean, is shallower than the depths of
I
0
I
--
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
5
I
10
Potential Temperature ("C) Fig. 4. (a) Tp-S, (b) Tp-02 and (c) Tp-Si diagrams of deep and bottom waters below the depth of 500 m in basins A (+), B (A), C ( 0 ) and D (0) (Craig et al., 1981a; Scripps Inst. Oceanogr., 1978; Horibe, 1978).
99 01
0
I
I
I
I
I
I
,
5 Potential Temperature ("C) Fig. 4.
I
10
(continued)
the 0 2 minimum (at about 1,200 m depth), Si maximum (2,300-2,500 m), and A14C minimum (2,000-2,500 m). The barrier effect of the South Honshu Ridge is much smaller at the salinity minimum depth (700 m) than those at the maximum or minimum depths (1,200-2,500m) for the other components. The salinity minimum water can therefore easily exchange between the basins C and D, while it may be more difficult for the 0 2 minimum, Si maximum and A14C minimum waters in basin C to enter basin D. The vertical distributions of 0 2 and Si in the northwestern Pacific are characterized by well developed mid-depth minimum and maximum, respectively (see Craig et al., 1981b). In contrast, the magnitudes of 0 2 minimum and Si maximum in the basin D are much less than those in basin C. This is probably because the supply of 02-poor and Si-rich intermediate water from the northwestern Pacific to the Philippine Sea is restricted by the barrier of the South Honshu Ridge as mentioned above. This barrier effect may contribute t o the higher 0 2 values in the basin D deep water below the 0 2 minimum layer than those in the basin C deep water as shown in Fig. 4(b). On the other hand, Reid and Mantyla (1978) showed that the mid-depth water circulation in the western Pacific carries 02-rich intermediate water from the south Pacific along the western boundary current. This process may also play a role in maintaining high 0 2 values in basin D deep water. Figure 5 schematically illustrates the bottom water modification processes in basins C and D. When the westward branched bottom water from basin B passes
100
0
200
,
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
5
I
I 10
Potential Temperature ("C) Fig. 4.
(continued)
through the Yap-Mariana Junction, it must be modified not only by the sill filtering effect but also by vertical mixing with basin D deep water which is richer in 0 2 , poorer in Si and probably has higher A14C value than the northwestern Pacific deep water. On the other hand, the northward bottom current through the Wake Island Passage is modified t o the NWPBW under the influence of basin C deep water. This is probably the reason why the bottom Tp-02, Tp-Si, and Tp-A14C characteristics (Fig. 3(b)-(d)) are significantly different between basins C and D. It should be noted that the one-way steady bottom currents as simply illustrated by the branched arrows in Fig. 5 are rather conceptional and qualitative ones. In the real ocean, there may be active isopycnal mixing, repeated cyclonic circulations in a basin as well as the steady bottom currents. In the course of such complicated water movements with various time scales, bottom water in a basin will be gradually modified by the three main processes (filtering effect, vertical mixing and in situ chemical process) as discussed in Section 4.
6.
Concluding Remarks
Bottom Tp-02, Tp-Si and Tp-A14C diagrams in the western Pacific Ocean demonstrated that the PSBW has different characteristics from those of the NWPBW, in spite of the fact that both bottom waters are branched from a common source of the central Pacific Basin bottom water. This difference is attributable
101 South Honshu Ridge
, ,
\M v
Bottom Current
Basin B
Fig. 5. A schematic illustration showing modification processes of the bottom waters in basins C and D. The arrows represent the movement and branching of the bottom water originated from basin B, and the two cylinders indicate the deep waters in basins C and D. The width and thickness of the arrows and cylinders are not quantitative. to bottom water modification processes, particularly t o vertical mixing between the source bottom water and the overlying deep waters. The tracer-tracer diagrams show t h a t the Philippine Sea deep water is richer in 0 2 and poorer in Si than the deep water of the northwestern Pacific Ocean, which may cause t h e difference between the PSBW and NWPBW characteristics. It is suggested t h a t the topographic barrier of the Izu-Bonin-Mariana ridge sequence (South Honshu Ridge) plays a dominant role in characterizing the Philippine Sea deep water by obstructing horizontal deep water exchange between the Philippine Sea and the northwestern Pacific Ocean.
Acknowledgement The author wishes t o thank Prof. Y. Horibe for his superior direction t o tracer studies. Thanks are also due t o Drs. M. Fukasawa and I. Kaneko for valued discussion. This study was financially supported by the grant-in-aid “Dynamics of the Deep Ocean Circulation” (Nos. 62610504 and 62610002) from t h e Ministry of Education, Science and Culture t o the University of Tokyo.
References Broecker, W. S., W. C. Patzert, J. R. Toggweiler, and M. Stuiver, 1986. Hydrography, chemistry and radioisotopes in the southeast Asian basins. J. Geophys. Res., 91, 14345-14354. Chase, T. E., H. W. Menard, and J. Mammerickx, 1971. Bathymetry of the North Pacific. Scripps Institution of Oceanography and Institute of Marine Resources. Craig, H., Y . Chung, and M. Fiadeiro, 1972. A benthic front in the south Pacific. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett., 16, 50-65.
102 Craig, H., W. S. Broecker, and D. Spencer, 1981a. GEOSECS Pacific Expedition, Vol. 3. U.S. Government Printing Office, 137 pp. Edmond, J. M., Y. Chung, and H. Craig, 1970. Pacific bottom water: penetration east around Hawaii. J. Geophys. Res., 76, 8089-8097. Gamo, T, Y. Horibe, and H. Kobayashi, 1987. Comparison of oceanic A'*C data with those of GEOSECS: vertical profiles in 1973 (GEOSECS) and in 1980 at (30°N, 170'E) in the northwestern Pacific Ocean. Radiocarbon, 29, 53-56. Horibe, Y., 1978. Preliminary report of Hakuho Maru Cruise KH-78-1: VEGA Expedition (unpublished). Horibe, Y., and T. Gamo, 1980. Chemical characteristics of the Cold Water mass of Kuroshio. In: The Kuroshio IV (Proc. 4th CSK Symp.), Tokyo, pp. 360-370. Kaneko, I., and T. Teramoto, 1985. Sea water exchange between the Shikoku-Philippine Basin and the western North Pacific Basin. In: Ocean Characteristics and their Changes, K. Kajiwara (ed.), Koseisha-Koseikaku, Tokyo, pp. 54-77 (in Japanese). Knauss, J. A., 1962. On some aspects of the deep circulation in the Pacific. J. Geophys. Res., 67, 3943-3954. Mantyla, A. W., 1975. On the potential temperature in the abyssal Pacific Ocean. J. Mar. Res., 33, 341-354. Mantyla, A. W , and J. L. Reid, 1983. Abyssal characteristics of the world ocean waters. Deep-sea Res., 30, 805-833. Moriyasu, S., 1972. Deep waters in the western north Pacific. In: Kuroshio: Its Physical Aspects, H. Stommel and K. Yoshida (ed.), University of Tokyo press, pp. 387-408. "Ostlund, H. G and M. Stuiver, 1989. GEOSECS Pacific Radiocarbon. Radiocarbon, 22, 25-53. Reid, J. L., H. Stommel, E. D. Stroup, and B. A. Warren, 1968. Detection of a deep boundary current in the western South Pacific. Nature, 217, 937. Reid, J. L., and P. F. Lonsdale, 1978. On the flow of water through the Samoan Passage. J. Phys. Oceanogr., 4, 58-73. Reid, J. L., and A. W. Mantyla, 1978. On the mid-depth circulation of the north Pacific Ocean. J. Phys. Oceanogr., 8 , 946-951. Scripps Institution of Oceanography, 1978. Data report, physical, chemical and biological data, INDOPAC Expedition. Univ. of California, San Diego, Scripps Inst. Oceanogr. Ref. 78-21, 424 pp. Stommel, H., 1958. The abyssal circulation. Deep-sea Res., 5, 80-82. Stommel, H., and A. B. Arons, 1960. On the abyssal circulation of the world ocean - 11. Deep-sea Res., 6, 217-233. Sverdrup, H. U., M. W. Johnson, and R. H. Fleming, 1942. The Oceans: Their Physics, Chemistry and General Biology. Prentice-Hall, New York, 1087 pp. and K. Taira, 1990. Deep hydrographic structure along 12 N and 13 N in the Uehara, K., Philippine Sea. J. Oceanogr. SOC.Japan, 46, 167-176. Watanabe, S., M. Nakajima and S. Tsunogai, 1897. 14C in abyssal waters of the Philippine Basin. Annual Meeting of the Oceanographical Society of Japan, Shimizu, October 1987, Abstr. No. 361 (in Japanese). Wooster, W. S., and G. H. Volkman, 1960. Indications of deep Pacific circulation from the distribution of properties at five kilometers. J. Geophys. Res., 65, 1239-1249.
103 Appendix. List of stations in basins A-D referred in this study. GEOSECS, INDOPAC, and VEGA data are according to Craig et al. (1981a), Scripps Institution of Oceanography (1978), and Horibe (1978). Station No. Basin A GEOSECS-257 -263 -269 -282 -290 -293 -296 -303 -306 Basin B GEOSECS-229 -231 -239 -241 -246 -251 Basin C GEOSECS-204 -212 -213 -214 -217 -222 -223 -224 -225 -226 -227 INDOPAC Leg-2- 6 -7 -8 -9 -11 -14 -15 -16 VEGA-11 VEGA-12
Location
Depth(m)
(10"1O'S, (16"39'S, (23"59'S, (570353, (58"00'S, (52"40'S, (440595, (38"22'S, (32'503,
169'58'W) 167'04'W) 174'26'W) 169"36'E) 174"OO'W) 178"05'W) 166'42'W) 17Oo04'W) 163'38'W)
5,180 5,713 5,999 5,213 5,316 5,335 5,342 4,841 5,624
(12"53'N, ( 14"07'N, ( 5"53'N, ( 4"33'N,
( o"oo's, ( 4"34'S,
173"28'E) 178"34'W) 172"OO'W) 179'00'E) 178"59'E) 178"57'E)
5,730 5,663 5,774 5,738 5,412 5,376
(31"22'N, (30"00'N, (31"00'N, (32"01'N, (44"40'N, (40"lo", (34"58'N, (34" 15'N, (32"37'N, (30"34'N, (25"00'N, (31"43'N, (3l"4 1'N, (28"58'N, (28" 16'N, (26"01'N, (22"30'N, (22"28'N, (22"32'N, (29"40'N, (34" 16'N,
150"02'W) 159"50'W) 168'27'W) 176"59'W) 177'03'W) 160"30'E) 151"50'E) 141'58'E) 161"55'E) 170'36'E) 170"05'E) 142" 12'E) 143'20'E) 143'48%) 142'49'E) 143O14'E) 145"02'E) 145"54'E) 147"31'E) 146'16%) 142"OO'E)
5,410 5,733 5,683 5,306 5,762 5,579 6,131 9,739 5,948 5,491 5,900 9,100 5,801 5,862 4,949 4,484 4,517 7,526 5,766 6,120 9.000
104 Appendix. Station No. Basin D INDOPAC Leg-3-23 -24 -25 -26 -27 -28 -29 -30 -31 -35 -36 -39 -40 -41 -42 -44 -45 -46 -47 -48 -49 -50 -51 -52 -54 -55 VEGA-1 VEGA-2 VEGA-3 VEGA-4 VEGA-5 VEGA-7 VEGA-8 VEGA-9
(continued) Location
(13"00'N, (13"03'N, (12"59'N, (13"01'N, (12"59'N, (13"01'N, ( 12" 59'N, (12"59'N, (13"02'N, (19"38'N, (20"00'N, (22"35'N, (22"35'N, (22"37'N, (23" 15'N, (22"28'N, (22"26'N, (19"20'N, (20"55'N, (22" 31'N, (22" 31'N, (22"32'N, (22"29'N, (22"33'N, (19"31'N, (18"26'N, (26"11'N, (22"00'N, ( 17" 35'N, (12"54'N, (18"11'N, (26"12'N, (30"31'N, (31"30'N,
138O59'E) 136'30'E) 133"58'E) 132"29'E) 130" 48'E) 128'59'E) 127"43'E) 126"40'E) 125"37'E) 123"53'E) 123"13'E) 122"ll'E) 123'06'E) 124"20'E) 124"43'E) 126"32'E) 129'34'E) 13l"06'E) 131"57'E) 132" 27'E) 134"OO'E) 135"59'E) 137'20'E) 139'25'E) 140"06'E) 141"14'E) 136'42'E) 137" 5 1'E) 137'14'E) 136" 27'E) 132" 25 'E) 129'36'E) 134'02'E) 137"OO'E)
Depth(m) 5,000 5,461 5,517 5,717 5,939 5,737 5,442 5,374 8,076 5,452 5,206 4,800 5,661 5,735 6,566 5,919 6,231 5,993 5,978 5,592 5,450 5,294 4,490 4,523 4,964 4,656 5,300 4,425 5,150 5,400 6,000 6,370 4,490 4,150
Deep Ocean Circulation, Physical and Chemical Aspects edited by T. Teramoto 0 1993 Elsevier Science Publishers B.V. All rights reserved.
105
Dynamics of the Japan Sea Deep Water Studied with Chemical and Radiochemical Tracers Shizuo TSUNOGAI, Yutaka W. WATANABE, Koh HARADA, Shuichi WATANABE, Shimei S A I T O a n d Michio NAKAJIMA"
Abstract
Chemical and radiochemical tracers have been used to make clear the dynamics of the Japan Sea deep water including its chemical alteration. They are the Si-0 combination, tritium, CFCs (trichlorofluoromethane and dichlorodifluoromethane), C-14 and Ra-226. The Si-0 diagram method has revealed a small areal variation of the Japan Sea deep water except water in a small basin surrounded by the Yamatotai Rise and its coastal upwelling off Japan. The tritium and Ra-226 combination method is applied to a box model with three layers and four boxes, which is based on the vertical profiles of tracer components including conservative and nutrient elements. The result shows that the turnover time of the Japan Sea water for vertical mixing is about 100 yrs and the residence time of the whole Japan Sea water except the warm Tsushima current water is about 1000 yrs, indicating that the Tsushima current flowing through the Japan Sea makes little interaction with the Japan Sea Proper Water. The difference between the apparent C-14 age of the Japan Sea deep water of 300 years and the turnover time is originated in the delay in the air-sea gas exchange equilibrium of carbon dioxide. The gas transfer velocity has been calculated to be 1.5 m/day. The vertical profiles of CFCs also support the estimated water exchange rates between the reservoirs, but our present data are insufficient to explain their small apparent gas exchange rates less than 0.1 m/day. The oxygen consumption rate of the Japan Sea deep water is nearly equal to that of the Pacific deep water indicating that the Japan Sea is not fertile, while the regeneration rate of silica in the Japan Sea is much larger than that in the Pacific.
1.
Introduction
Recently chemical and radiochemical tracers have been well used t o reveal t h e oceanographic problems especially in t h e dynamic aspects of water movement (e.g., Broecker and Peng, 1982) a n d will play a major role in t h e many international projects such a s W O C E (World Ocean Circulation Experiment). In this s t u d y we have tried t o apply t h e tracer method t o t h e J a p a n Sea water as a n example for making a future extensive study program in t h e North Pacific. Those tracers are *Department of Chemistry, Faculty of Fisheries, Hokkaido University, Hakodate 041, Japan
106 the dissolved silica-oxygen combination, Ra-226, tritium (H-3), radiocarbon ((2-14) and chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs). The Japan Sea ( 1 . 0 1 3 ~ 1 0km2) ~ is one of the largest marginal seas in the world (Menard and Smith, 1966). The Japan Sea is isolated from the Pacific except the four straits of which sill depths are shallower than 130 m (Fig. l), although its maximum and mean depth are, respectively, 4036 m and 1667 m. Thus the deep water of the Japan Sea should be formed within the sea, probably in winter in the northern area (Uda, 1934; Fukuoka, 1965). The Japan Sea water below 200-300 m is occupied by a remarkably uniform water mass, which is called the Japan Sea Proper Water having relatively low temperature of 0.1-0.3"C and low salinity of 34.0-34.1 psu as compared with the Pacific Deep Water. Since the Japan Sea deep water contains much dissolved oxygen, it is presumed t h a t the vertical mixing is active and its turnover time is short (Uda, 1934). Indeed the carbon-14 age of the bottom water has been determined t o be 300 years (Gamo and Horibe, 1983). On the other hand, Harada
Fig. 1. The Japan Sea. Isobaths of 200, 1000 and 3500 m depth are shown. Solid circIes with numbers are the observation stations occupied by Horibe (ed., 1981).
107 and Tsunogai (1986) have reported the relatively high concentration of Ra-226 in the deep Japan Sea water showing its longer residence time within the sea, whereas Watanabe et al. (1991) have found the bomb tritium in the deep Japan Sea water more than 2000 m depth indicating an active vertical mixing. In this study we have tried t o give a unifying interpretation t o these apparently incompatible results with a quantitative model calculation.
2.
Si-0 Diagram Method
A classical Si-0 method is applied t o the Japan Sea water for understanding its structure before the discussion on its dynamics obtained by using modern tracers. The Si-0 method has been successfully applied to the North Pacific water (Tsunogai, 1987). For example, one of the results clearly shows t h a t the Pacific Deep water in the western North Pacific flows along the Kuril-Kamchatka Trench and into the eastern North Pacific via the north end of the Emperor Seamount chain and the Aleutian Trench. Here we have treated the Japan sea water observed by Horibe (ed., 1981) in the same manner. The Si-0 diagram of the Japan Sea water is completely different from those
Pacific
200
0 -
2oo(uM/kg)
300
Fig. 2. Si-0 diagram for waters collected in the Japan Sea, the Antarctic Ocean (AAO), the western South Pacific (WSP), the eastern South Pacific (ENP), the western North Pacific (WNP), the central North Pacific and the Bering Sea (BS).
108
!ol
$,.,,*,
\
137'21' E
tN
Fig. 3. Concentrations of dissolved silica (Si in pM), nitrate (N in pM) and phosphate (P in pLM), and potential temperature ( T p in "C) at Sta. 18. in the other oceans (Fig. 2). This is evidence t h a t the Japan Sea is isolated and its deep water is formed independently of the neighboring Pacific and its marginal seas. It is interesting to note that the silica content in the Japan Sea deep water below the oxygen minimum layer is the highest among those containing the same amount of dissolved oxygen in the world ocean, although its absolute value (80 pM) high. This is probably due to the same cause for the relatively high concentration of Ra-226 in the Japan Sea deep water (Harada and Tsunogai, 1986), which is discussed later. The vertical profile of dissolved silica in the Japan Sea (Fig. 3 ) shows t h a t the concentration of silica increases markedly with depth down to about 1000 m depth and the increase rate largely steps down in the deep water below the depth, where those of temperature, nitrate and phosphate are almost constant with depth. T h e vertical profiles of silica between the 200-1000 m depth are different from station t o station but are parallel with each other (Fig. 4). The horizontal distribution of dissolved silica a t the 600 m surface is compared in Fig. 5 . We can see the highest value at the station nearest t o the Japanese coast, Sta. 13, indicating the upwelling of 100-200 m in the intermediate water a t Sta. 13 near the coast as compared to Sta. 1 4 which is 65 km apart to the offshore. The upwelling is confirmed by the Si-
109 20
40
60
Si
r
(m)
Fig. 4. Vertical profiles of dissolved silica (in pM) at Stas. 13, 14 and 15 occupied by Horibe (ed., 1981).
0 diagram given in Fig. 6a, where the S i - 0 curve for the water below 280 m depth or containing dissolved silica more than 40 pM at Sta. 13 (Fig. 6a) substantially coincides with those at other stations in the diagram. The Si-0 diagrams for the Japan Sea deep water below 1000 m at various stations (Fig. 6) coincide fairly well with each other except one station, Sta. 22, in a small basin surrounded by the Yamatotai Rise (Fig. 6b). The concentration of silica increases with depth even in the deep water at Sta. 22 (water depth, 2200 m). Therefore the highest concentration of dissolved silica is not found in the main Japan Sea basin deeper than 3500 m, depth, but found in the bottom of the Yamatotai basin (around Sta. 22 in Fig. 1). This may indicate t h a t the bottom water of the Yamatotai basin is more stagnant but the main basin water is vertically well mixed. In the surface 200 m layer the concentrations of dissolved silica and other components are variable from station to station. At Stas. 24 and 25 near the Tsushima Strait, the lower oxygen (< 200 pM) and higher silica(> 10 p M ) water at about 100 m depth (Fig. 6c) is clearly distinguished in the Si-0 diagram (as compared t o Fig. 6a,b). The water may have originated in the water flowing from the bottom of the continental shelf region of the East China Sea through Tsushima Strait. Based on the vertical distributions of dissolved silica and conservative elements such as water temperature described above. The Japan Sea water can be divided into three layers, the surface (0-200 m), the intermediate (200-1000 m) and the deep (below 1000 m depth) layers. According to Harada and Tsunogai (1986), the
110 surface layer is further divided into the wa, d cold surface reservoirs. The warm surface is covered by the warm Tsushima current which makes a steep thermocline preventing the water exchange with the deep water. The boundary between the warm and cold surface reservoirs is not clear and the area and depth of the cold surface region may be enlarged in winter when the surface is cooled. In the intermediate water below 300 or 400 m the concentration of silica increases almost linearly and largely with depth (e.g., Figs. 3 and 4). This indicates t h a t the vertical mixing is prevailing rather than the advective flow (upwelling) in the intermediate water of a large part of Japan Sea, which can not be clearly realized by non conservative dissolved oxygen and nutrients which are influenced by the decomposition of organic matter and by the conservative elements of which vertical variation is small. The usefulness of silica is due t o its regeneration at the bottom.
3. Transient Tracers and the Vertical Mixing in the Japan Sea 3.1.
Vertical profiles of transient tracers
We have determined the concentrations of tritium (Watanabe et al., 1991), CFCs (Watanabe et al., 1988), C-14 (Watanabe et al., 1989) and Ra-226 (Harada
45-
Fig. 5 . Horizontal distribution of dissolved silica (in pM) a t 600 m depth. Solid points indicate the observation stations.
111 and Tsunogai, 1986). The water samples for tritium, C-14 and CFCs were collected in 1987 and 1988, and their vertical profiles were determined at 7 , 1 and 7 stations for tritium, C-14 and CFCs, respectively. The more detailed report on the CFCs and C-14 data will be reported elsewhere. In Fig. 7 their mean values are shown, where their scales are designed to make the comparison easy. Tritium (half-life, 12.4 yrs) in the present seawater has been produced chiefly by the H bomb explosions in the 1960’s and transported t o the sea surface. The rapid decrease in its concentration with depth (Fig. 7) suggests a certain time
801
200
8Ot
\.
1( i\ 80 sot
,
60
I
200
300
Fig. 6. Si-0 diagram (in unit of pM) for the Japan Sea water at Stas. 13, 14 and 15 in Fig. 6a, a t Stas. 19, 22 and 23 in Fig. 6b, and at Stas. 24 and 25 in Fig. 6c.
112
8 " "-" "
Tritium(T.U.) 2
1
3000b
0.5
4000
'
-60 I
1 .o
4
3
-F - l l , ( p M ) , , 1.5
,
,
,
,
.......... c - 1 4 ("00) ' -46 ' -iO ' ( ! I ' 20 ' - - - - - Ra-226 (dpm(m3) 140
120
100
,
, ,
2.0
' 40' 1
80
Fig. 7. Vertical distributions of tritium, CFCs (F-11and F-12), C-14 (A1*C value) and Ra-226 (radioactivity). Their units and scales are given within the figure. The concentrations are in the level of 1/1/1988. necessary for the vertical mixing of water bearing the tritium, but its detection in the water below 1500 or 2000 m depth indicates an active vertical mixing and advection (upwelling and downwelling) as compared to that in the Pacific water. Watanabe et al. (1991) have estimated the turnover time of the Japan Sea deep water below 200 m depth t o be about 100 yrs, based on its vertical distribution and a crude model. The concentrations of CFCs, F-11 (trichlorofluoromethane) arid F-12 (dichlorodifluoromethane) in the Japan Sea water also decreased with depth and the decrease rate is larger than t h a t of tritium. This steeper decreases in F-11 and F-12 is probably due t o the fact that CFCs are released t o the atmosphere more recently with a large increase rate than tritium. Upon examining Fig. 7 closely, we can recognize tha t F-11 decreases more steeply with depth than F-12. This may be caused by the release rate of F-11/F-12 which increased with time until 1975 (Smethie et al., 1988). The A14C value of the Japan Sea deep water was nearly the same as that determined by Gamo and Horibe (1983) in 1977 (-74 ym). The rapid decrease rate in the C-14 values with depth seems to be due to the larger capacity of dissolved inorganic carbon (carbonate) in seawater, which induces the delay in the air-sea exchange equilibrium of the carbon system, as compared to sparingly soluble gases
113 such as CFCs. The concentration of Ra-226 inversely increases with depth. Since the distribution is probably stationary, this is due to its sources at the bottom, the dissolution from biogenic particles which contain Ra-226 removed from the surface water, and from the bottom sediments which contain Ra-226 produced from the decay of Th230. As discussed by Harada and Tsunogai (1986) the Ra-226 concentration in the Japan Sea deep water is large as compared to that in other oceans containing the same amount of C-14 or dissolved oxygen. This niay be due t o the fact the Japan Sea water is vertically well mixed and most of the surface water upwelled in winter does not flow out to the Pacific, but sinks again after dissolving the atmospheric oxygen and some radiocarbon at the surface. We therefore must distinguish the turnover time of the Japan Sea water for the vertical mixing and its residence time
Fig. 8. A box model with three layers and four boxes of the Japan Sea. The solutions for the case of T (the proportion of the cold surface) of 0.5 are also shown. The numerical values given are the bottom area, S , the volume of water, V , the production (or loss) rates of tritium and Ra-226, P , and the observed concentrations of tritium and Ra-226. T h e six unknowns solved for T = 0.5 and the residence times calculated from the solutions are underlined.
114 within the Japan Sea excluding the warm surface water (Tsushima current) flowing in and out like river water.
3.2.
Three layers model
We have calculated the residence time of the Japan Sea water using a box model with three layers and four boxes (Fig. 8), which has been stated in Section 2 for t:-e Si-0 diagram. The model is basically the same as t h a t used by our previous worb (Harada and Tsunogai, 1986; Watanabe et al., 1991) except for the following three points. 1) We add the intermediate water reservoir to the previous model. Then the boxes are the warm surface, the cold surface, the intermediate and the deep reservoirs. It is assumed t h a t the warm surface does not directly exchange water with the intermediate reservoir (Fig. 8). 2) More recent estimate of the hypsometry of the Japan Sea basin (Menard and Smith, 1966) shows somewhat different figures from the older ones used by the previous works. The area, volume, mean depth of the Japan Sea are, respectively, 1 . 0 1 3 ~ 1 0km2, ~ 1 . 6 9 0 ~ 1 0km3 ~ and 1667 m. We have also used the depth zones in the Japan Sea area estimated by them. The area and volume of each box are given in Fig. 8. 3) The particulate flux of Ra-226 (345 dpm/m2/yr) used in this study has been calculated from the observed ratio of excess Ra-226 t o opal in the sediment trap samples collected in the Atlantic (Brewer et al., 1980; Honjo, 1980), and the observed particulate flux of opal in the Japan Sea (Masuzawa et al., 1990). We assume the particulate flux of Ra-226 is proportional t o the surface area and the excess Ra-226 defined by Brewer et al. (1980) is completely dissolved within a few hundred years. We further assume t h a t the benthic flux of Ra-226 is proportional to the bottom area. The time change in the concentration of a tracer element in each box is expresses as follows:
where C , V and P are the concentration of a tracer element, volume of water, production (or loss) rate of C , respectively, and the suffixes, w, c, m and d denote the warm surface, the cold surface, the intermediate and the deep reservoirs. T h e rates of water exchange, K 1 , Kz and K3 are of those between the warm and the cold surface reservoirs, the cold and the intermediate water, and the intermediate and the deep waters, respectively. The proportion of the cold surface t o the whole surface, r , seems to be variable from season to season and we regard the proportion as one of parameters. Then V, = V,r where V, is the volume of the whole surface water. The residence times of the deep water (Td), of the intermediate and deep water (Tmd) and of the whole Japan Sea water excluding the warm surface water (Tcmd) are obtained from the following equations; if we can determine the K values,
115
I
/
_ _ _ _ _ _ _-_ _ _ _ _ k_ _ - - --------,191
m
I
1
‘0.4
/
0.5
0.6
r
0.7
0.8
0.9
Fig. 9. The solutions as a function of r , where T is the residence time of water in the respective reservoirs expressed with suffixes, K is the exchange rate of water, and k is the gas transfer velocity of carbon dioxide at the surface, which is calculated from the K values and the vertical profile of C-14. Tcmd
+ vm + vd)/Kl
= (6
+ [(vm+ vd)/K2][(vm+ v d ) / ( & + v m + v d ) ] + (Vd/K3)[Vd/(T/c+ Vm + %)I.
(6)
We have solved the three K values and other three unknowns (C, and Cd for tritium and C, for Ra-226) by introducing the observed mean concentrations of C, (3.6 T.U. in 1988) and C, (2.6 T.U.) for tritium and C, (81 dpm/m3), C, (134 dpm/m3) and c d (154 dpm/m3) for Ra-226 into Eqs. (1) t o ( 3 ) for tritium and Ra-226, namely six equations. The P value for tritium is the input rate from the atmosphere to the surface and the radioactive decay which is proportional t o its amount in the respective box. The P value for Ra-226 consists of the particulate and benthic fluxes which are assumed to be proportional to the area, and the radioactive decay. The benthic flux of Ra-226 from a unit area is the same as t h a t used by Harada and Tsunogai (1986). A steady state condition ( d C / d t = 0) can be applied for Ra-226, but not for tritium. The details of the calculation are given in Watanabe et al. (1991). The results obtained are expressed as a function of r (Fig. 9). The results do not highly depend on the T value which can be roughly regarded t o be 0.5 according t o H a t a (1962). In Fig. 8, therefore, the K values and other unknowns obtained for the case of T = 0.5 are also shown. The residence times calculated from the above A’ values and Eqs. (4) t o (6) for T = 0.5 are 100, 110 and 990 years for respectively, T d , T m d and Tcmd,which are nearly the same as those obtained by Watanabe et al. (1991). They have reported that the residence times of the deep water below 200 m and t h a t of the cold surface water are, respectively, about 100 and 1000 yrs. The calculated concentration in the deep water, C d = 0.5 T.U., is also reasonable as compared with the observed
116 mean concentration, 0.4 T.U. (Watanabe et al., 1991). Using t h e d a t a observed by Horibe (ed., 1981), we have estimated t h e mean concentrations of dissolved oxygen, which are 242.2 pM for C, and 224.6 pM for Cd. By introducing t h e K3 value obtained here ( 9 . 3 ~ 1 0 ' m3/yr), ~ t h e oxygen consumption rate in t h e deep water below 1000 m depth turns out to be 164 x lo9 moles/yr or 172 pmoles/m3/yr or 3.8 ml/m3/yr. T h e consumption rate in a unit volume is comparable with t h a t in t h e Pacific deep water, 3.1 ml/m3/yr (Tsunogai, 1972). T h e rate in a unit area is 0.26 moles 0 2 / m 2 / y r , which is 43% of t h e organic carbon flux directly observed in September by t h e sediment traps in t h e surface 1000 m, 0.61 moles C/m2/yr (Tsunogai and Noriki, 1987). T h e difference may be d u e to t h e decomposition of organic compounds i n t h e water above 1000 m depth or t h e larger particulate flux in the summer season. At any rate the Japan Sea is not so fertile. T h e mean concentrations of dissolved silica are 49.2 p M for C,, and 73.0 pM for Cd (Horibe, ed., 1981). T h e regeneration rate of silica in the Japan Sea deep water below 1000 m depth is calculated to be 221 x l o 9 moles/yr or 232 pmoles/m3/yr or 0.36 moles/m2/yr. T h e rate in a unit area agrees fairly well with t h e observed flux of opal, 0.33 moles/rn2/yr (Masuzawa et al., 1989). According to Tsunogai et a1.(1990), t h e particulate opal is not substantially dissolved during sinking through t h e water column b u t dissolved on t h e bottom. T h e atomic ratio of Si/O in the regeneration (or loss) term, P, is 0.67 in t h e Japan Sea, whereas t h a t in t h e Pacific deep water is 0.39 (Tsunogai, 1972). This enrichment in silica in t h e J a p a n Sea may be d u e to a larger input from t h e Asian continent via t h e atmosphere and rivers, and may be related to large fragile radiolarians found in t h e sediment traps (Noriki, personal communication). T h e apparent C-14 age of t h e Japan Sea deep water (A14C = -74 %), is 300 yrs, which is larger than t h e turnover time for t h e vertical mixing obtained in this study, Table 1. Concentrations of CFCs in t h e various reservoirs calculated from the estimated water exchange rates(k) for the case of T = 0.5 by assuming t h a t t h e atmospheric input rate is proportional to t h e difference from t h e equilibrium concentration and the C m values are equal to observed ones.
F-11 (pM) Calc. (Obs.) Warm surface Om
Cw
F-12 (pM) Calc. (Obs.1
(2.24) (1.84)
-
-
-
(1.10) (0.95)
1.90
( -)
1.07
( -)
0.72
(0.72)
0.42
(0.42)
0.05
(0.10)
0.03
(0.06)
-
Cold surface
CC Intermediate
cm
Deep
Cd
117 100 yrs, b u t shorter than its residence time within t h e J a p a n Sea, 990 yrs. T h e discrepancy between t h e apparent C-14 age and t h e turnover time is d u e to t h e delay in the gas exchange equilibrium at t h e surface for t h e carbonate system. If t h e li' values obtained here is applied to t h e carbonate system, we get t h e gas exchange rate or t h e gas transfer velocity of carbon dioxide to be 1.5 m/day (Fig. 9) almost regardless of t h e T value. This is about a half of t h e mean value of t h e world oceans, 3.3 m/day (Broecker and Peng, 1982). T h e small gas transfer velocity seems to be caused by the lower sea surface roughness of the northern Japan Sea as observed by t h e GEOSAT altimeter, although t h e coastal region along Japan is fairly rough in winter (Ebuchi e t al., 1992). We have also calculated t h e concentrations of CFCs in t h e cold surface ( C c ) and t h e deep (Cd) reservoirs, using t h e observed concentration of CFCs in t h e intermediate water ( C m ) t,h e estimated zi' values and a n assumption t h a t the input rates of t h e atmospheric CFCs are proportional to their atmospheric concentrations of Smethie et al. (1988). T h e calculation method is similar to t h a t of Watanabe et al. (1991) for tritium except their Eq.(9) mhich should be modified as follows; Cc(t+At)
= CC(t) + at[lil(C,(,)C,,t,,,/~~(,),,- C C ( t ) ) li'2(Cm(t) - G ( t ) ) + k ( C c ( t ) e g- CC(t))SCl/VC,
+
(7)
where C,(t)eqand Cc(t)eq are t h e equilibrium (satura.ted) concentrations at 20°C and 0°C with t h e atmosphere at the time, 1, and k is t h e apparent gas exchange coefficient in this case. T h e calculated concentrations of CFCs in t.he cold surfa.ce, C, (Table 1)) coincide fairly well with those observed in t h e warm surface, C,, including t h e water of 100-200 m depth and 1-2°C. T h e slightly larger observed concentrations in t h e deep reservoir may be d u e to the cont,amination during the sampling and chemical analysis. T h e calculated net input rates in 1987 in t h e Japan Sea are 9 ~ 1 0 - ~ ~ for F-12, which are smaller than rnoles/m2/yr for F-11 and 5 ~ 1 0 -moles/m2/yr 11x10-* moles/m2/yr for F-11 in t h e 1970 level calculated by Liss and Slater (1974). T h e calculated gas exchange coefficients k, are only 20 m/yr for F-11 and 30 m/yr for F-12, which are 20-30 times smaller than t hat estimated from C-14, which is 1.5 m/day. Of course t h e calcula.ted gas exchange coefficient is apparent, because the degree of equilibration of CFCs in t h e surface mixing layer j u s t below the surface film should be larger than t h a t i n t h e bulk surface of 200 m thick for the sparingly soluble CFCs, and t h e gas excha.nge should also occur in t h e warmer seasons a t the Lower solubilities of CFCs (i.e., the concentration difference between the atmosphere and t h e surface wa.ter is small). Indeed t h e concentration of CFCs i n the summer surface water (Table 1) is almost equilibrated with t h e atmosphere at the ambient temperature. Owing to t h e lack of d a t a on CFCs in northern Ja.pan Sea in winter, howeverjt is difficult to explain these differences although t h e smaller input rate may be partly d u e to the small a.ir-sea ga.s exchange coefficient in t h e Japan Sea.
118 Acknowledgement We would like to acknowledge valuable discussion with Dr. Shinichiro Noriki a n d the m e m b e r s of t h e Analytical Chemistry Laboratory, Faculty of Fisheries, Hokkaido University. We also t h a n k Ms. Keiko Moriya for her kind cooperation in making t h e manuscript. References Brewer, P. G., Y. Nozaki, D. W. Spencer, and A. P. Fleer, 1980. Sediment trap experiments in the deep North Atlantic: isotopic and elemental flux. J . Mar. Res., 38, 703-728. Broecker, W. S., and T. -H. Peng, 1982. Tracers in the Sea, Eldigio Press, Columbia Univ., New York, 690 pp. Fukuoka, J., 1965. Hydrography of the adjacent sea (1) - T h e circulation of the Japan Sea. J. Oceanogr. SOC.Japan, 21, 95-102. Ebuchi, N . , H. Kawamura, and Y. Toba, 1992. Growth of wind waves with fetch observed by the GEOSAT altimeter in the Japan Sea under winter monsoon. J . Geophys. Res., 97, 809-819. Gamo, T., and Y. Horibe, 1983. Abyssal circulation in the Japan Sea. J. Oceanogr. Soc. Japan, 39, 220-230. Harada, K., and S. Tsunogai, 1986. "'Ra in the Japan Sea and the residence time of the Japan Sea water. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett., 77, 236-244. Hata, K., 1962. Seasonal variation of the volume transport in the northern part of the Japan Sea. J . Oceanogr. SOC.Japan, 20th Anniversary Volume, 168-179. Honjo, S., 1980. Material fluxes and modes of sedimentation in the mesopelagic and bathypelagic zones. J . Mar. Res., 38, 53-97. Horibe, Y. (ed.), 1981. Preliminary Report of the Hakuho Maru Cruise KH-77-3 (Pegasus Expedition), Ocean Res. Inst., Univ. Tokyo, 55 pp. Liss, P. S., and P. G . Slater, 1974. Flux of gases across the air-sea interface. Nature (London), 247, 181-184. Masuzawa, T., Noriki, S., T . Kurosaki, S. Tsunogai, and M. Koyama, 1989. Compositional change of settling particles with water depth in the Japan Sea. Mar. Chem., 27, 61-78. Menard, H. W., and S. M. Smith, 1966. Hypsometry of ocean basin provinces. J. Geophys. Res., 71, 4305-4325. Smethie, Jr., W. M., D. W. Chipman, J . H. Swift, and K. P. Kolterniann, 1988. Chlorofluoromethanes in the Arctic Mediterranean seas: evidence for formation of bottom water in the Eurasian Basin and deep-water exchange through Fram Strait. Deep-sea Res., 35, 347-369. Tsunogai, S., 1972. An estimate of the rate of decomposition of organic matter in the deep water of the Pacific Ocean. In: Biological Oceanography of the North Pacific Ocean, A. Y. Takenouti (ed.), Idemitsu Shoten, Tokyo, pp. 517-533. Tsunogai, S., 1987. Deep-water circulation in the North Pacific deduced from Si-0 diagrams. J . Oceanogr. SOC.Japan, 43, 77-87. Tsunogai, S., and S. Noriki, 1987. Organic matter fluxes and the sites of oxygen consumption in deep water. Deep-sea Res., 34, 755-767. Tsunogai, S., S. Noriki, K . Harada, and K. Tate, 1990. Vertical-change index for the particulate transport of chemical and isotopic components in the ocean. Geochem. J., 24, 229-243. Uda, M., 1934. Hydrographical studies based on simultaneous oceanographic surveys made in the Japan Sea and in its adjacent waters during May and June, 1932. Rec.
119 Oceanogr. Works Japan., 6, 19--107. Watanabe, S., S. Saito, and S. Tsunogai, 1988. Chlorofluoromethanes in the Japan Sea. Proc. 1988 Fall Meeting of Oceanogr. SOC.Japan, 285. Watanabe, S., M. Nakajima, and S. Tsunogai, 1989. Carbon dioxide exchange rate in the Japan Sea estimated from radiocarbon. Proc. 1989 Annual Meeting of Geochem. SOC. Japan, 47. Watanabe, Y . W . , S. Watanabe, and S. Tsunogai, 1991. Tritium in the Japan Sea and the renewal time of the Japan Sea deep water. Mar. Chem., 34, 97-108.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Deep Ocean Circulation, Physical and Chemical Aspects edited by T. Teramoto 0 1993 Elsevier Science Publishers B.V. All rights reserved
121
Instrumental Development for Measurement of Phosphate in Seawater and Some Discussion of Nutrient Distributions in the North Pacific Kitao FUJIWARA a n d Hiroyuki TSUBOTA*
Abstract
Several methods for the measurement of phosphate in sea water are presented based on the different principles. For classical colorimetry, a rapid automated method based on flow injection analysis is proposed where a mirrorcoated long-path cell was applied. Detection limit, of this system is about 0.05 p M . Conversion of phosphate to phosphine is also developed and coupled with gas-chromatography or ozone gas-phase chemiluiriinescence for total or dissolved total phosphorus measurement. Besides the analytical methods for phosphorus, the relationship between phosphate and nitrate (+ nitrite) in the western north Pacific is discussed.
1. Introduction Nutrients are t h e most important species for describing t h e chemical nature and status of seawater. They link t h e biological environment a n d dynamics of t h e ocean. In another words, t h e measurement of nutrients are indispensable in chemical oceanography. In general, nutrients are measured by colorimetry; however, t h e methods currently adopted d o not necessarily provide sufficient sensitivity for deternlining them accurately in seawater. Accordingly, for describing minute chemical structure in the deep sea, a more precise method is required. Bubble-segmentation system was introduced into t h e majority of t h e commercial autoriiated a n a l y x r s such as Technicon’s. However, t h e bubble-segnientatiori has some disadvantage as a ship-board technique: slow speed of analysis a n d unstableness against t h e niovement of ship. For t h e discussion of minute structure in the nutrient distribution, the present method lacks t h e precision in speed a n d operation of measurement. For overcoming this problem, a n application of flow injection analysis (FIA) may be effective, which is faster in measurement speed a n d of which stability increases during operation compared t o t h e analyzer based on bubble-segmentation. However, the colorimetric detection is made before reaching t h e stationary s t a t e in analytical reactions a n d diffusion of t h e solutions is serious. which means t h a t improvement in the sensitivity is required for colorimetric detector of FIA. Besides t h e colorimetric detection of nutrients by a FIA with enhancing detection power, t h e method based on a completely different chemical principle is *Facultyof Integrated A r t s and Sciences, Hiroshima University, Higashisenda-rnachi, Naka-ku, Hiroshima 730, Japan
122
mirrored kurface
: incident (sour'ce) 1 i g h t - - - - - - - - t ;reflected (transmitted) light
P
Fig. 1. Schematic illustration of the mirror-coated long-path cell with the bifurcated optical guide.
Table 1. Instruments used in this study. Light source Laser diodes
Sharp, type LTD030MD 3 niw (750 nm) 30 mw (830 nm) : Sharp, type 5HD-23 : Machida denshi, type LBS-750 :
LED Power source Detector (silicon photodiode) : Preamplifier : : Electrometer Optical guide : Flow injection system Analyzer : : X-Y Sampler Commercial colorimetric
Hamamatsu, type S780-5BQ-3L N F Electronic, type LI-76 Advantest, type TR-8652 Koyo, type EK-3036
Hitachi, type K-1000 Hitachi, type 105XY detector : Jasco, type 870-UV (for HPLC) Spectrophotometer for reference measurement of absorption : Shimadzu, type UV-120-01 Computer used in the flow injection analysis Computer : NEC, type PC-8801 Printer , : Epson, type FP-80
proposed in this paper because the analytical values obtained by the double or triple independent methods are sometimes indispensable for improving the reliability of the results.
2.
Developments of Analytical Methods for Phosphorus in Seawater
123
LED, LD
m-,v
PHOTO 7 DIODE
1
OPTtCAL
GUIDE
pzinting aluminum powder
N0.5
-20-
Fig. 2. Designs of the mirror-coated long-path cells.
2.1.
Highly sensitive colorimetric detector for flow injection analysis
Nutrient species are generally determined by colorimetric methods. Several automated systems have been developed for routine measurement of nutrients in seawater, and we adopted here a flow injection method. The method has several merits especially in field operations such as on board research vessels, that it is simple and rapid. One of its drawbacks is the low sensitivity because the detection was done before reaching a maximum of color-development. The dilution of the solution is another serious problem here. These weakness may be overcome by the enhancement of detection power of flow injection analysis. In light absorption spectrometry, extension of optical pathlength is one of the effective ways t o increase sensitivity. In our previous papers (Fuwa et al., 1984; Fujiwara and Fuwa, 1985; Fujiwara, 1988), we have discussed how a capillary com-
124
OPTICAL GUlOE
unnin
Fig. 3 . Illustration of flow injection system for phosphate nieasurement with a mirror-coated long-path cell. mercially sold for gas chromatography was transfornied to a colorirnet,ric cell for this purpose. I t was possible t o design cells of as long as 50 m for colorimetry. through which the light is transmitted in any geometric configuration by total reflection a t the inner cell wall. However, this tot>alreflection cell cannot, be applicd t o the nutrient measurements because water has low refractive index. We, therefore, developed a new type of linear long-path cell, in wliich introduction of source light and detection of reflected light in the cell are carried out. in the same direction by using a bifurcated optical guide. The source light is introduced froin one end of the flow cell, transmitted in the sample solution with reflecting a t the outer cell wall, and then collectd a t the same source-light inlet (see Fig. 1). Using this type of cell it is possible t o collect the reflected light passed via various pathways inside the cell. This mirror-coated long-path cell is used as the colorinietric cell in our flow injection system (Fujiwara et al., 1990). T h e instriiinents employed are listed in Table 1. The mirror-coated long-path cells of various designs are shown in Fig. 2. Five types of cells (hereafter referred t o as No. 1-No. 5 according t o the figure) were constructed. Cell No. 1 is a Pyrex tube with i.d. of 3 iiim and 0.d. of 5 mm and its outer cell wall is painted with aluminum powder. T h e outer walls of the other cells (No. 2-No. 5 ) were silver-coated by the ordinary met,liod. For the protection of the silver-coating, a cylindrical glass is placed over tlic cell. No. 2 and 3 cells are the same except for the orientation. Cell No. 3 was originally made for turbidity measurement, in which t,he suspended particles often settle downward, causing a drift of the signal in such a case. T h e leak of solut,ion a t the connection of the light, guide (optical fibers) and the cell was prevented by packing with a black polyethylene tube. T h e aperture of the light guide at the cell side is 3.00 m n ,and at the light source/detector side is 2.16 mm. In this light guide, the bundle of optical fibers (the 0.d. of each fiber is 50 um) from the cell side was divided into two branches, each of which was connected t o either the light source or the detector, thus creating bifurcation. The
125
5 0 " Z
P/rnL
8 rnin.
Fig. 4. Example of flow injection signals for phosphate measurement. The signal as printed through the personal computer is shown. optical fibers from the light source and the detector sides are randomly mixed in the cell side. The detection system is shown in Fig. 3. The flow injection analyzer was connected to the mirror-coated long-path cell. The absorbance of the solution was calculated by a personal computer (instead of by a log amplifier), t o which the signal from an electrometer was sent via GP-IB. Laser diodes a t 750 nm ( 3 mW) and 830 nm (30 mW) operated in a cw mode were used as the light source. When the present mirror-coated long-path cells were used, the sample was introduced into the flow injection analyzer using an X-Y auto-sampler so t h a t u p to 100 samples can be sequentially measured. Since generation of the bubbles in the carrier disturbed the stability in the signal, degassing of the carrier was done for 2 h. For phosphate measurement, the color-developing reagent was made by mixing 14% (v/v) sulfuric acid (150 mL) 0.275% (w/v) antimony potassium tartarate (45 niL) 4% (w/v) ammonium molybdate (45 mL) in this order, with 1.76% (w/v) ascorbic acid (90 mL) and ethanol (50 niL) being added just before measurement. When measurement was made without ethanol, baseline gradually shifted. Ethanol was effective in diminishing this shift. It has been suggested that an addition of some surfactants such as SDS or Triton X-100 is helpful for stabilization of the baseline of the signal in various auto-analyzing systems coupled with CL coloriinetric detector. However, addition of these reagents made no difference in our system. The flow injection analyzer was a sandwich type, where the sample (30 pL) is sandwiched between the color developing agent (100 pL). The flow line of the carrier was heated at about 130 C for 3 m and then introduced into a mixing coil of 2-m length before going t o the detector (mirror-coated long-path cell). The 2-m length coil was also attached t o the outlet of the detector in order to create back pressure which prevent bubble formation. The flow rate of the carrier was about 2.0 mL/min. Absorbance observed by the present long-path cell is compared with that obtained by an ordinary cell of 1-cm length. Using cell No. 4, an enhancement of about 27 times in the absorbance was attained (in the range of less than 0.05 in the ordinary cell although the cell length is only 15 times longer than t h a t of the ordinary cell. Cell No. 5, which has the same cell length as t h a t of cell No. 4, provides poor
+
+
126 enhancement in absorption than did No. 4 cell. Cell No. 2 gave 16 X enhancement in the linear range of the calibration curve. On the other hand, the absorbance obtained by cell No. 1 was in 1 : 1 ratio to that obtained by the ordinary cell. The present system was used as the detector for flow injection analysis of phosphate. The source light used here was a laser diode at 750 nm emission. The laser diode is an effective tool as a light source for detecting molybdenum blue colorimetric detection of phosphate ion from the viewpoint of its stability and intensity. Fig. 4 shows the typical results obtained by the present system with cell No. 4 under the condition that the flow rate of the carrier was 1.53 mL/min. and the solution was heated at once at 130°C. In this case, 1 ng P/mL (about 0.03 pmol/L) can be measurable according to the computation of signal averaging, and 3 ng P/mL (about 0.1 pmol/L) is detectable by the direct reading of the recorder chart of Fig. 4. The detection power of the present system is sufficient for almost all the seawater samples including nutrient-depleted surface waters. Thus, introduction of the present mirror-coated long-path cell in flow injection analysis is quite useful in the field of nutrient geochemistry phytoplankton growth. In practice, the present system was operated during the R.V. Tansei-Maru cruise (KT 88-19, Nov. 8-11, 1988), and its feasibility and handling performance was confirmed. 2.2.
Measurement of phosphate by the methods associated with the phosphine generation technique
Here, the method of phosphate determination using the phosphine generation technique will be discussed. It is possible to apply various spectroscopic methods for measuring phosphine which exists in gas-phase at the room temperature because of the boiling point of -87.7"C. Since the methods for measuring phosphate in water sample are rather limited, the development of the method involving quantitative conversion from phosphate to phosphine may be useful for comparison. However, the major problem is the difficulty in the reduction of phosphate, because the redox potential of phosphate to phosphine is lower than that of water: For the reactions, P 3H20 3e = PH3 3 0 H - and 2Hz0 2e = Hz 20H-, -0.87 and -0.8277 V vs SHE, respectively, are given. This means that the generation of phosphine from phosphate is difficult under the presence of water. We have developed the procedure of quantitative generation of phosphine by the use of sodium tetrahydroborate as the reducing agent, which is popularly utilized in the hydride generation of metalloide elements such as As, Se, Sb, and Sn in atomic spectrometries. The procedure is outlined in Fig. 5 , where the sample phosphate is mixed with aqueous solution of sodium tetrahydroborate in a quartz vessel shown in Fig. 6 and is dried at about 40°C. The quantitative generation of phosphine was possible when this mixture was heated t o 460°C. This phosphine generation method expands the analytical methods available for phosphate. For example, gas-chromatography (Hashimoto et al., 1987), ozone gas-phase chemiluminescence detection (Fujiwara et al., 1989a), and ICP atomic emission spectrometry (Fujiwara et al., 1989b) can be applied to the phosphate analysis in combination with this phosphine generation technique in this report. Fig. 7 shows the distribution of the total and total dissolved phosphorus in the
+
+
+
+
+
Table 2. Determination of Phosphorus in Various Compounds"?*. method KH2P04 DTPS" ADP AMP IMP phytic acid molybdenum blue colorimetry 100f2.2 100f3.1 100f3.3 10052.6 100k3.4 100f3.4 with K2S2O8 digestion present method with 99.7f2.4 98.3f3.4 101.5f2.9 99.4f3.2 99.6f3.3 97.8f3.1 K2S2O8 digestion 101.4f2.3 101.lf2.7 98.6f3.4 98.4f2.6 99.5f3.2 68.9f4.8 present method " Sample amount was 100 ng of P/mL, 100 p L . Average value for five repetitive measurements. trans-1,2-Diphenyl-l,2,3,6-tetrahydro-1,2-diphosphorin 1,2-disulfide.
'
128 samp1e +mixing with NaBI-i4 and drying bmeasurement of TP by hydride-generation method ,digestion
with IC2s208
Leasurement of TP by molybdenum-blue colorimetry
+filtration with 0.2-pm Nuclepore filter
lL
mixing with NaBI14 and drying easurement of TDP by hydride-generation method
digestion with K2S208 Lmeasurement of TDP by molybdenum-blue colorimetry
Fig. 5. Procedure for phosphorus measurement. TP: total phosphorus, TDP: total dissolved phosphorus.
IOcm Fig. 6. Designs of sample container for generation of phosphine from phosphate. a type: half cylindrical, b type: boat. Japan Trench obtained by the phosphine generation-gas chromatography method.
It should be noted that the results obtained by the method correspond t o the concentration of the total phosphorus compounds in the sample, and do not agree with orthophosphate (P043-). The difference between the phosphine generation method and the ordinary molybdenum blue colorimetry can be attributable t o the phosphorus compounds other than orthophosphate. Table 2 shows the recoveries for various phosphorus compounds based on the phosphine generation-gas chromatography and potassium persulfate digestion-molybdenum blue colorimetry. Except for phitic acid, both the results show good agreement with each other. Gas-phase chernallurnanescence detectaon of phosphate
It is well-known that phosphine naturally burns in the atmosphere and emits visible light, which is called igunus flatuus or will’o-the-wisp. However, this luminescence was not well elucidated. Before establishing the gas-phase chemiluminescence measurement of phosphate, chemiluminescence spectra occurring between phosphine and ozone were observed. A silent discharge type ozone generator was used at the applied electric voltage of 100 V with flowing oxygen at the rate of
129 phosphorus (yrnol liter")
hydride-generation method 0: total phosphorus 0: t o t a l d i s s o l v e d phosphorus
90 01
10000~
Fig. 7. Distributions of dissolved total and total phosphorus at at the Japan Trench (29"05'N lat, 142'51'E long). 100 mL/min. The concentration of ozone was 13 g/m3 under this condition. For conversion of phosphate in the sample to phosphine, the sample was taken in a quartz vessel (either boat or half cylindrical types, see Fig. 6). A boat-type container is more convenient for retaining t,he sample and sodium tetrahydroborate solutions than the half cylindrical one. The generated phosphine was mixed with ozone in a chemiluminescence chamber. The chemiluminescence chambers of various design were made and used in this experiment. For quantitative analysis of phosphate, a photon counting system with a cooled photomultiplier was adopted where no spectral separation was carried out due to the small intensity of chemiluminescence emission. The analog output of the photon counter was recorded on a strip chart recorder. The equipments used are listed in Table 3. The recommended procedure for determination of phosphate is as follows: 102000 pL of the sample phosphate solution is placed in the quartz vessel and completely dried. Then, 100 ILLof 6% sodium tetrahydroborate is added t o the residue and dried again a t a temperature below 45°C in an oven for 2 h. This dried mixture is inserted into a phosphine generation tube made of quartz and then heated t o
130
810
650 570 WAVELENGTH, n m
730
490
b
800
700
600 WAVELENGTH
I
500
400
nm
Fig. 8. Chemiluminescence spectra. a: Spectrum for high concentration of phosphine (about 10%). b: Spectrum for low concentration of phosphine (108 ppm).
Fig. 9. Schematic diagram of phosphine generation and chemiluminescence detection systems: 02, oxygen cylinder; He, helium cylinder; (1)gas flow meter, (2) cooling water, (3) ozone generator, (4) chemiluminescence chamber, ( 5 ) aluminum case, (6) slide transformer, (7) phosphine generation tube, (8) digital thermometer, (9) heater, (10) phosphine trap wounded ny a Nichrom wire which heats trap to expel the condensed moisture, (11) photomultiplier housing, (12) cooling unit, (13) photon counter, (14) recorder. 480-500°C by a cylindrical Nichrom heater. The temperature is monitored and controlled by a digital thermometer. Helium is used as a carrier gas of the generated phosphine and continuously circulated
131 Table 3. Instruments used in this work. : Nippon Ozone Co., Type 0-3-2 Ozone generator Spectrometer : Jasco, Type CT-25-C Multichannel detector PC D image sensor : Hamamatsu, Type S2304-512Q Detector Type C2327 Dat a processing unit : Type C2890 DMA interface Type M2891 : NEC, PC9801 VX Personal Computer Printer PC-PR201F2 Scope : Trio, Type CS1577(30 MHz) Fourier transformation and general spectral observation Analyzer(Recorder) : Yokogawa, Type 36553 FFT module : Yokogawa, Model 3659 20A DC amplifier : Kiethley, Type 427 : N F Electronic, Type LI-76 DC(A/V) amplifier Function generator : N F Electronic, Model FG-121B PM power source : HTVC 488R PM(photomultip1ier) : Hamamatsu, R456 Determination of phosphate : Mitamura Riken, 400 W Electric furnace Digital thermometer : Nippo Electric, Type LM499 P M housing with electronic cooler : Hamamatsu, Type C659-A PM Type R649 Photon counter Type (22130 : Hitachi, Model 056 Strip chart recorder
through the phosphine generation tube at a flow rate 600 mL/min. Phosphine is trapped in a U-tube packed with a small amount of quartz wool by cooling it with liquid nitrogen for 2 min. After collecting phosphine, the cold trap is soaked (warmed) in a water bath. The gaseous phosphine is, then, introduced into the chemiluminescence chamber and mixed with ozone supplied from a generator of silent discharge type through which oxygen flows at a rate of 150 mL/min. T h e peak height of chemiluminescence signal fed into a strip chart recorder was read for calculating phosphate concentration. When phosphine at high concentration was exposed t o air, the color of emission changed from white to red and then reversed from red t o white before termination. Occasionally, a greenish emission appeared, which is presumably due to H P O or (PO), . This fact suggests t h a t the chemiluminescence spectrum changes according to the concentration of phosphine. Fig. 8a shows the chemiluminescence spectra given by phosphine at about 1015% (v/v) concentration. A broad peak of emission appeared at 670 nm with
132
Exhaust
N0.3 Exhaust
4
03 10 C r n
Fig. 10. Schematic illustration of the chemiluminescence chambers.
D i o d e
I
I
I
A r r a y
HRlOOO
J-Y
Mono.
H10
I a
V a l v e
# Z
a Col d
R e a c t i o n
r
Tr up
Fig. 11. Schematic diagram of optical system and hydride generation sample introduction system for ICP-AES.
a shoulder at 740 nm. This emission looked orange. Both oxygen and ozone can make luminescence at this concentration of phosphine. Fig. 8b shows the
133
I ~ G O " E
180'
160'W
Fig. 12. Sampling stations in the western North Pacific. Solid circle, open circle and open triangle are for the cruise of KH 80-2 (CY), KH 82-1 (CE) and KH 85-4 (DE), respectively. emission spectrum given by phosphine at the concentration of 103 ppm. Only ozone generated this emission and oxygen did not. The broad spectrum extending from 350-700 nm was obtained. Neither the sharp peaks in the visible region nor those due to P O at around 280 nm were observed. The small peak at 650 nm is the same as the one in Fig. 8a. The system illustrated in Fig. 9 was constructed for phosphate determination. The chemiluminescence chambers of type 1-3 in Fig. 10 were compared in regard t o the quantitativeness of the measurement. In chamber No. 1, phosphine was injected into the ozone flow. In chambers No. 2 and 3, the flows of carrier/phosphine and ozone were merged in each other from the opposite side. The chemiluminescence chamber No. 1 generated slightly stronger emission than chamber No. 3. The shorter chamber (No. 2) gave about 40% weaker chemiluminescence. Both No. 1 and 3 chambers give the same detection limits of 1 ng, and linear dynamic ranges are from 2 t o 5000 ng for chamber No. 1, and from 10 t o 5000 ng for chamber No. 3. Chamber No. 2 gave a detection limit of 2 ng with a linear dynamic range of 5-1000 ng. The narrow dynamic range of chamber No. 2 can be explained by its short length between the entrance and exhaust of gases. Phosphane generataon and ats detectaon by anductavely coupled plasma-atomac emassaon spectroscopy (ICP-AES) The application of ICP-AES will be briefly mentioned for phosphate analysis below. In the system for observing phosphorus atomic emission in the ICP-AES with phosphine generation, helium continuously flows into the I C P for sustaining its operation. Therefore, two lines were constructed:one is the pathway through the hydride generation tube (sample) and another is a bypass.
134
50 -
40
CE-13
-
d P e 0
30-
0 20 -
10-
0
o h
I
1
I
2
I
3
The system is shown in Fig. 11. The phosphiiie generation technique is the same as previously described. The detection limit was the same as one without hydride generation (direct introduction of sample solution into the ICP). This is due to the combined effect of the high efficiency of phosphorus atomization and the about 50% conversion efficiency. Thus, the merit of hydride generation is canceled in this case. The advantage of the hydride generation-ICP method is in the separation of phosphorus from the sample matrix, and hence the huge interference of NaC1, if any, in ICP-AES for phosphorus can be eliminated. Otherwise, seawater sample can not be determined directly by ICP-AES. The detailed results were shown in our paper (Fujiwara et al., 1989b).
135 Table 4 The slopes (dNO3/dPO4) in the whole water column (W), the upper layer (U) and the deeper layer (D) in the North Pacific. Station CY-3 CY-4 CY-5 CY-6 CY-8 CY-9 CY-10 CY-11 CY-13 CE- 1 CE-2 CE-3 CE-4 CE-5 CE-6 CE-8 CE-9 CE-10 CE-11 CE-12 CE- 13 CE-14 CE-15 CE-16 DE-2 DE-4 DE-7 DE-8
3.
The slopes W 14.1 14.8 15.0 14.6 14.9 14.4 14.6 14.5 14.4 13.9 14.2 14.0 14.8 13.0 14.0 14.0 14.1 13.2 13.4 13.5 15.3 14.3 14.9 14.8 23.4 24.2 14.4 14.0
(dN03/dP04) D U 13.6 10.5 13.8 11.8 14.4 12.3 12.2 14.1 14.4 13.2 14.1 12.5 14.4 12.9 12.9 14.0 14.0 13.0 13.6 12.5 13.7 11.5 13.7 12.3 13.8 12.0 12.3 9.4 13.4 12.1 13.5 11.3 13.4 12.4 12.5 10.5 14.2 12.9 6.2 12.2 6.4 14.0 13.8 13.9 11.7 15.4 14.1 11.2 23.0 19.5 23.6 17.1 14.0 11.0 13.4 9.2
Discussion on the Distribution of Nutrients in the Western North Pacific
Phosphate, nitrate, and silicate concentrations have been obtained a t various locations in the North Pacific (Horibe, 1980, 1982). The stations are shown in Fig. 12. The stations CE-5 and CE-15 are located in the mid-North Pacific gyre. The stations DE-4 and CY-5 are located in the subarct,icregion, where the nutrients are not entirely depleted in the surface layer. The slopes of the linear lines are less in the deeper layer than in the upper layer at all the stations in the North Pacific, as is shown in Fig. 13. These features are
136 considered t o be reflected from dissolution and/or adsorption of nutrients from/to settling particles and sea floor. In the dissolution stage in shallower layers, appearance of nitrate exceeds than t h a t of phosphate. In contrast t o the shallower layer, the decreasing trend of phosphate concentration towards the sea floor in the deeper layer is more distinctive than t h a t of nitrate, i.e., in the map presenting the relationship of nitrate and phosphate, d N / d P becomes smaller in the deeper layer below the point t h a t gave the highest concentrations of phosphate and nitrate. Larger and smaller d N 0 3 / d P 0 4 are commonly found for the upper and deeper water columns, respectively, although the degrees in this difference were found t o be variable for the stations. At some stations, the slopes ( d N 0 3 / d P 0 4 ) are rather close t o each other for upper and deeper layers, while clear separations can be found between the upper and deeper layers at other stations. For example, at station CE-13, the deeper layer is clearly separated from t h a t of the upper layer; however, difference of the slopes between them is a little at station DE-4. T h e slopes in the whole water column, the upper and deeper layers are shown in Table 4. I t is evident from the table t h a t at all the stations phosphate is more depleted than nitrate in the deeper layer. In our previous paper (Hayase e t al., 1988), it is stated that phosphate, nitrate, and silicate are more enriched than fluorescent organic matter in the deep layer. Those features may be related t o phosphate-nitrate diagrams with regard t o dissolution of settling particles. Further improvements in regard t o analytical speed and precision would be required for the nutrient measurements. This will help further interpretations regarding the minute structure of the distributions of nutrients in seawater.
References Fujiwara, K., and K. Fuwa, 1985. Liquid core optical fiber total reflection cell as a colorimetric detector for flow injection analysis. Anal. Chem., 57, 1012-1016. Fujiwara, K., 1988. Application of a wave-guide capillary cell in the determination of copper by flow injection analysis. Anal. Chim. Acta, 212, 245--251. Fujiwara, K., T. Kanchi, S. Tsumura, and T. Kumamaru, 1989a. Phosphine-ozone gasphase chemiluminescence for determination of phosphate. Anal. Chem., 61, 26992703. Fujiwara, K., M. A. Mignardi, G. Petrucci, B. W. Smith, J. D. Winefordner, 198913. Determination of phosphorus by ICP-AES using solid-phase hydride generation. Spectrosc. Lett., 22., 1125-1140. Fujiwara, K., T. Nakamura, T. Kashima, H. Tsubota, T. Solin, M. Aihara, and M. Kiboku, 1990. Mirror-coated long-path cells for colorimetry with the use of a bifurcated optical guide. Appl. Spectrosc., 44, 1084-1088. Fuwa, K., L. Wei, and K. Fujiwara, 1984. Colorimetry with a total-reflection long capillary cell. Anal. Chem., 56, 1640-1644. Hashimoto, S., K. Fujiwara, and K. Fuwa, 1987. Determination of phosphorus in natural water using hydride generation and gas chromatography. Limnol. Oceanogr., 32, 729735. Hayase, K., M. Yamamoto, I. Nakazawa, and H. Tsubota, 1987. Behavior of natural fluorescence in Sagami Bay and Tokyo Bay, Japan -- vertical and lateral distributions. Mar. Chem., 20, 265-276. Hayase, K., H. Tubota, I. Sunada, S. Goda, and H. Yamazaki, 1988. Vertical distribution
137
of fluorescent organic matter in the North Pacific. Mar. Chem., 25, 373--381. Horibe, Y. (ed.), 1981, 1982. Preliminary Report of the Hakuho Maru Cruise KH 802 (CYGNUS Expedition) and K H 82-1 (CEPHEUS Expedition). Ocean Research Institute, Univ. of Tokyo.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Deep Ocean Circulation, Physical and Chemical Aspects edited by T. Teramoto 0 1993 Elsevier Science Publishers B.V. All rights reserved.
139
Actinium-2 27: A Steady State Tracer for the Deep-sea Basin-wide Circulation and Mixing Studies Yoshiyuki NOZAKI*
Abstract The presence of excess "'Ac (half-life, 21.8 years) relative to the parent 231Pain deep ocean waters indicates its usefulness as a novel tracer of basin-wide circulation and mixing studies on the time scales of less than 100 years. For this purpose, 227Acis probably best utilized by coupling with "*Ra (half-life, 5.75 years), both of which have their significant source in the bottom sediments. Most important is to develop a new method for simultaneous and accurate determination of 227Acand '"Ra in seawater. This may be achieved by combination of MnO2-fiber extraction and subsequent a-scintillation counting of '"Rn and '19Rn emanated from the fiber. New data on the vertical profiles of 227Acand '"Th (as an indicator of "'Ra) obtained in the deepest part of the Izu-Ogasawara Trench down to 9,700 m suggest that they are predominantly governed by isopycnal mixing. Within the trench, both nuclides are nearly constant with depth, suggesting that the water is uniformly mixed. This view is consistent with the distributions of other chemical species and radioisotopes whose concentrations are almost identical to those of the deep water at 5000-6000 m depths around this region.
1.
Introduction
Among the soluble members of U / T h decay series nuclides, 222Rnand 228Ra, having their significant source in the bottom sediments, have been exploited as tracers for the study of mixing and exchange processes of ocean waters. Because of its short half life of 3.83 days, application of 222Rnis limited to processes occurring on time scales of less than two weeks. Hence, the extensive studies using 222Rn(e.g., Broecker, 1965; Chung and Craig, 1972) have focused on the characterization of bottom boundary layer. By contrast, 228Rawith a. half life of 5.75 years can be used in the study of physical processes of decadal time scales, such as vertical mixing and circulation of ocean basins (e.g., Moore, 1969; Sarmiento et al., 1976). 228Rais particularly important for the deep sea environments into which the anthropogenic tracers such as artificial 3H and chlorofulorocarbons have not penetrated as yet. Recently, Nozaki (1984) has found excess 227Ac over its parent 231Pain North Pacific deep waters, suggesting t h a t it can serve as a deep sea tracer as well. 2 2 7 A ~ *Ocean Research Institute, University of Tokyo, Minarnidai, Nakano-ku, Tokyo 164, J a p a n
140 has a half life of 21.8 years (see Fig. l ) ,approximately four times longer than that of "'Ra and have a merit that its application to oceanographic problems is extended up t o -100 years. The usefulness of this relatively newborn tracer in the study of deep water circulation and mixing is not well explored as yet. In this paper, I describe the present status of knowledge on the oceanic distribution of 227Acand their geochemical and oceanographical significances as well as the development of sampling and analytical techniques.
2.
Background
Because actinium has no stable isotope, its physico-chemical nature is not well understood. Yet limited informations on the characteristics of Ac compounds (Latimer, 1952) and the radiotracer studies (Karalova and Myasoyedov, 1982) suggests that the chemical behavior of Ac resembles that of lanthanum. Until recently, the trivalent lanthanides had been thought t o belong to a group of the least soluble elements in seawater such as Fe, Al, Pa and T h whose concentrations are maintained at extremely low level by scavenging of particulate matter. Thus, if 2 2 7 A and ~ 231 Pa were virtually insoluble and were rapidly scavenged to particles, the oceanic 23sU-231Pa-227Acsystem could be used t o determine the mean residence time of marine particles in analogous t o the fact that the 222Rn-210Pb-210Bisystem in the atmosphere can be used to determine the mean residence time of aerosols (see Turekian et al., 1977). This idea was noted when the first PARFLUX Atlantic sediment trap samples were analysed radiochemically (Spencer et al., 1977). The Pa activity ratios in the Pacific particle unequivocal measurements of 227Ac/231 samples done by Anderson (1979) resulted in the values from less than 0.1 t o 0.6, and appeared to be consistent with the above idea. Unfortunately however, the situation was not so simple. Nozaki (1984) found that 227Acis present in excess over 231Pain Pacific deep waters indicating that 2 2 7 Ais~ supplied from somewhere
3.43 x
J" 3.92s
J Fig. 1.
A portion of decay scheme of 23sU series chain.
141 to the deep water and not effectively removed by particle scavenging as a whole. This clearly means that the analogy of marine 235U-231Pa-227A~ chain to the atmospheric zzzRn-210Pb-210Bisystem does not hold. Instead, investigation on the usefulness of 2 2 7 Aas ~ an oceanographic tracer in the context of physical mixing and circulation has begun. This is an aspect described in more detail below.
3. Methodology Application of 2 2 7 Aas ~ an oceanographic tracer strongly depends upon the availability of t h e conventional method of accurate determination and hence methodological development, is one of the most important topics on this subject. There are several ways of determining 227Acin seawater. Not all methods have been thoroughly tested so that their advantage and disadvantage are, in part only conceptually and theoretically, described. Because 227Acis a weak @-emitter( p energy, 0.0455 MeV) and present at extremely low concentrations of < 3 dpm/1031 in seawater, it is difficult to directly count the low-level activity of 227Ac. Therefore, the methods generally include extraction of 227Acfrom large-volume of seawater ( > l o 0 l), isolation and detection of some of its daughters.
-200
L
seawater
Carriers (Fe,
Be,Pb)
ion exchange column
U
Fig. 2. A diagram showing the analyt,ical procedure for radionuclides in large-volume water samples as currently been used on board R. V. Hakuho-Maru.
142 3.1. Extraction of Ac from large-volume seawater Coprecipitation with iron hydroxide
Here I describe the chemical procedure (Fig. 2), with focus on 2 2 7 A ~which , has currently been used on board of R. V. Hakuho-Maru for simultaneous determination of various radionuclides (Th, Pa, Pu, Am, P b , Be, Sr, Cs and C isotopes) using a -250 1 water samples obtained from various depths with a twin PVC bottle sampler (Horibe and Tsubota, 1977). Soon after sampling, unfiltered seawater of 200-250 1 was placed in a closed container, acidified with 500 g of concentrated H N 0 3 (one bottle of Wako Pure Chemical Industries Ltd.). Then, Np-gas was circulated through the water and a column containing 4 M NaOH solution for several hours t o extract dissolved C o p gas for 14C measurements (Horibe et al., 1986). The remaining water was transfered into a PVC container with a funnel-shape bottom. To the water, various carriers (1 g as Fe (111), 25 mg as P b , 1 mg as BeO, 20 mg as Cs) and yield monitors (appropriate amounts of 233Pa,234Th, 242Pu and 243Am) were added and thoroughly mixed. Then, 500 g of concentrated NH40H (one bottle of Wako Chemical Industries LTD) was added with stirring to precipitate iron hydroxide together with the actinides at pH 7.5. The precipitate was allowed t o settle for more than 24 hours and then separated from most of the water through a valve at the bottom of the container. The supernatant was further treated for "Sr and 137Csaccording t o the method of Nagaya and Nakamura (1981). The iron hydoxide precipitate was further separated from water by decantation and filtration, and then redissolved in ~ 5 ml 0 of 8 M HN03. The solution was allowed to stand for more than a week, meanwhile gelatinous precipitate of amorphous silica was formed. This precipitate which contained most of Pa was separated from the solution by centrifugation and set aside for Pa analysis (Nozaki and Nakanishi, 1985). The 8 M H N 0 3 solution containing 2 2 7 Aand ~ other radionuclides was then passed through a Dowex 1x 8 anion exchange column (12 c m x 1 cm, 100-200 mesh) preconditioned with 8 M HN03. The isotopes of Ac, Be, P b and Am passed through the column, whereas U, Th, P u and Pa were adsorbed on the resin. The column was rinsed twice with 20 ml of 8 M HN03. The time of this ion exchange separation was recorded. The 8 M HN03 effuluent and rinses were combined and the iron content in the solution determined by atomic absorption spectrometry t o determine the recovery of iron hydroxide up t o this step. The solution containing 2 2 7 Awas ~ stored in a polyethylene bottle and was set aside for further treatment. The isotopes on the resin were successively eluted with aliquots (40 ml each) of 10 M HC1 for Th, 10 M HC1 0.13 M H F for Pa, 10 M HC1 NH41 for P u and 0.1 M H N 0 3 for U. These nuclides were then analysed by a and ,B spectroscopy described in Nozaki et al. (1981) for Th, Nozaki and Nakanishi (1985) for Pa and Nagaya and Nakamura (1987) for Pu. N
+
+
MnOp -fiber extration
The acrylic fibers coated with manganese dioxide (called MnOp fiber, hereafter) prepared by the method of Moore (1976) and Nozaki (1983) are very effective for extracting R a from seawater ranging in volume from 20 t o several thousand liters.
143 Reid et al. (1979) demonstrated that the MnO2-fibers are also efficient adsorbers for Ac as well. They found the extraction efficiency of 99*1% for both Ra and Ac under the flow rate of 0.5 l/min using 30 1 of surface seawater. Thus, the use of MnO2-fiber in extracting Ac from seawater greatly reduces the labor needed for sampling large-volume waters and shipboad chemical extraction. Using the submersible pumps with a MnO2-fiber column as described in Krishnaswami et al. (1976), Orr et al. (1984), Nozaki et al. (1987) and Bacon (personal communication), Ac can be extacted from seawater in situ. More convieniently, some specific devices attached t o hydrowire or mooring rope in order for the M n 0 2 fiber t o be exposed t o seawater may also be used as described in Moore and Reid (1973), Moore (1976), Anderson (1979) and Nozaki (1983). In the latter, only the isotopic composition adsorbed on the MnO2 fiber can be determined. The effective volume from which radioisotopes were extracted may be estimated if any one of the isotopes is known for its concentration in the seawater. The equilibrium concentration of 234Thwith respect to 238Ucan be used for a-emitting T h isotopes (Moore, 1981; Nozaki and Horibe, 1983). The 226Raconcentration measured in a separate aliquot of seawater is used for 228Ra (Moore and Reid, 1973). No appropriate isotopes are available for 2 2 7 Aand ~ 231Pafor this purpose. 3.2.
Alpha-spectrometry of 227Th
The Mn02-fibers are leached in hot 6 M HCl for 12 hrs t o dissolve all the nuclides and manganese in the presence of appropriate carrier and spikes (Pb, 233Pa,229Thetc.), depending upon the nuclides of interest. The white fiber was removed from solution after squeezing the solution and washing. The solution was filtered to remove fabric debris using a Millipore HA filter and then evaporated t o dryness. The residue was redissolved in -40 ml 8 M HN03 and loaded on a Dowex 1 x 8 anion exchange column preconditioned with 8 M HN03. The column was washed twice with 20 ml of 8 M HN03. The effluent and rinses were combined and set aside for 227Acanalysis. The T h and Pa isotopes adsorbed on the resin were analyzed according t o the methods given above. 2 2 7 Ain ~ the 8 M HN03 solution obtained by either iron hydroxide or MnO2fiber methods can be determined by a-spectrometry of 227Th which was milked from the 227Acsolution, as follows: The 8 M H N 0 3 containing 227Acsolution was stored for more than 5 months during which 227Th grew into equilibrium with 227Ac. To the solution, an appropriate amount of 230Th(-0.2 dpm) was added as a yield monitor, and the solution was passed through an anion exchange column preconditioned with 8 M HN03. The column was washed twice with 20 ml aliquots of 8 M HN03, and the effluent and rinses were combined and stored. The time of the ion exchange separation between 227Th and 227Acwas recorded. T h on the resin was eluted with 40 ml of 8 M HC1 and the solution was evaporated t o dryness. The T h residue was taken in one drop of 8 M H N 0 3 and a few ml of deionized H 2 0 . The pH of the solution was adjusted t o 1.5-2.0 with dilute NH40H and then T h was extracted from the solution to 3 successive 0.5 ml aliquots of 0.4 M TTA-benzene solution. The T h was plated on a stainless steel disk and counted for its a-activities by a-spectrometry.
144 I
I
(a)
MnO,
150-
100
i
iiber Sample
TA06'82 5370m 919mm Detector N o 2
-
2
In +
5 =
3
0 50 -
0 200
460
mu"--
MnO, fiber sample T A 0 6 ' 8 2 . 4965m 4494min Detector N o 2
(b) 500-
9
400-
6
-
2
r
- 5 2
0
0 200-
4
100-
200 0
250
(C) 150-
300
350
400
Seawater sample Ce-13. 5 8 7 0 m 2873min
9
Fig. 3 . Examples of a-spectrum of T h isotopes, based on Mn02fiber samples (a and b) and a large-volume seawater ( c ) . Fig. 3c was obtained by the second milk of T h fraction grown in the 8 M H N 0 3 solution containing 2 2 7 A(230Th ~ was used as a yield monitor).
145 An example of @-spectrum is shown in Fig. 3. Apparent dual peaks due to 227Thwere registered centering at the energy of -5.7 MeV and -6.0 MeV. T h e count rates from 5.70 t o 5.80 MeV and from 5.95 to 6.05 MeV corresponds t o 39% and 54% of 227Th decay, respectively. It is also clear from Fig. 3b t h a t 224Ra( a energy, 5.686 MeV) and 212Bi (a-energy 6.051 MeV) contribute to the count rate in the same a-energy region of 227Th. The contribution of 224Rais corrected by subtracting the count rate of 220Rn,from a peak around 5.7 MeV, and t h a t of '12Bi is corrected by subtracting 35% of 220Rncount rate (based on a branching ratio) from the peak around 6.0 MeV. These contributions become larger as the activity of '"Th on the counting source is higher and the time elapsed between preparation of T h counting source and counting is longer. Since 228Thwas separated from 2 2 7 A ~ by the first 8 M H N 0 3 anion exchange, the correction is minimized for the second milked T h fraction as shown in Fig. 3c. The activity of 2 2 7 Ain ~ seawater sample ( A ~ + 2 2 7 ) 0 is calculated on the basis of the equation given by AAc)(AT'h-227)meATht2 1 ATh(e-XActl - eAThtl
(ATh (AAc-227)O
=
- (ATh-227)rne-AThtZ (1 - e-AThtl -
1
11
"7
(1)
"7
where tl is the time elapsed from the first to the second anion exchange in nitrate form to separate Ac and T h , t2 is the time between the second anion exchange and measurement of T h , and f is the chemical yield of Ac. Using 227Actracer and 20 1 aliquots of surface seawater, 2 2 7 Awas ~ confirmed t o be coprecipitated with iron hydroxide quantitatively (Nozaki, 1984). I t was also ~ not retain at all on the Dowex 1 x 8 resin in 8 M H N 0 3 form, found t h a t 2 2 7 Adoes and therefore only losses of Ac during processing and recovering of iron hydoxide precipitatc need to be corrected. This correction was made by monitoring the recoveries of iron for each sample (-80%). The only assumption here is that 227Ac is quantitatively coprecipitated with iron hydroxide even in expanded volume of seawater ( ~ 2 5 1). 0 This can be explicitly tested using 227Actracer. Also if 225Ac (half life, 10.0 days) is used as a yield monitor, the assumption is no longer required. These, however, remain t o be done in the future. As an independent check, one can calculate in sitii 227Th concentration as a measure of 2 2 7 Ain ~ seawater when sampled. Based on the studies of 234Th-238U disequilibrium in the ocean (Bhat et al., 1969; Amin et al., 1974), and the 24.1 day half life of 234Th which is longer than that of 227Th,the assumption seems t o be justified for most of the ocean except for the shallow waters ( < l o 0 m). Nozaki (1984) actually took this approach for some of Pacific deep waters. In Fig. 4, the ~ obtained as above. results of in situ 227Th are compared with the 2 2 7 Avalues Although agreement between the two is good, there is a fairly large uncertainty in the value of in situ 227Th. This is because correction for 227Thdecay became large due to the time (-1 month) elapsed from water sampling and measurement of T h activities for these samples. It is a disadvantage for this method t h a t rapid chemical separation and counting of T h are necessary. In practice, this is often difficult when a number of large-volume water samples need t o be processed. It is
146 I
I
/ 0
I
1 2 "'Th (dprn/103kg)
3
Comparison of in situ 227Th activity and 2 2 7 A activity ~ Fig. 4. determined for deep water samples during the Cepheus Expedition of R. V. Hakuho-Maru (KH-82-1).
Drying Agent
Rn Cell
L
a,
z LL I C
2
Fig. 5 . A dual cell counter for simultaneous determination of '"Rn and 220Rn (After Orr, 1988).
also noticed that the presence of 228Thin the sample often requires relatively large correction for the contribution of its daughters, 224Raand 'l'Bi (See Fig. 3b). For this reason, the in situ 227Thmethod was difficult to apply t o shallower waters in which the 228Thconcentration was significantly higher than t h a t of 227 Ac. For MnO2-fiber sample obtained after natural exposure t o seawater, it is difficult t o estimate the effective volume of seawater because of the lack of natural Ac isotope with a n appropriate half-life. Therefore, Nozaki and Yang (1987), in interpreting their radionuclide data, assumed t h a t the extraction efficiency of Ac is equal t o t h a t
147 of Ra. This is based on the laboratory experiment of Reid et al. (1979), but has not been tested in natural condition. Thus, intercomparison of the various methods for "?Ac determination should help confirming the validity of assumptions. 3.3.
Alpha-scintillation counting of 219Rn
An a-scintillation counter for 222Rn,consisting of a-scintillation cell inside of which is coated with ZnS powder and a photomultiplier, has been commonly used to determine 226Rain environmental samples (Lucas, 1957; Broecker, 1965). By coupling the a-scintillation methods and the MnO2 fiber on which R a isotopes were collected, Rama et al. (1987) developed a method of measuring 224Ra(half-life, 3.6 days) via counting "'Rn (half-life, 56 seconds) and its short-lived daughter. They suggested that the system might also be used t o measure 223Ra (half-life, 11 days), a ground-daughter of 227Ac, via counting 'lgRn (half-life, 4 seconds) and its daughters. Orr (1988) further considered the possibility, theoretically, and reached to the conclusion that the two cell counting system (Fig. 5) is necessary t o resolve the activities due t o 'lgR.n and 220Rnif both are present on the M n 0 2 fiber. Upon leaving the MnOz-fiber, the radon must have a short travel time (less than a few seconds) t o reach the first cell and a long travel time (-30 seconds) t o reach the second. In this way, the first cell counts both 219Rn and 220Rn,while the second counts mostly 220Rn,thereby allowing the resolution of individual activities with two simultaneous equations. Once the method is established, the simplicity (no chemistry) and greater sensitivity of supported radon emanation will make "?Ac measurements more practical on seawater samples. There is also an advantage in such a system of measuring 223Ra (as 2 2 7 A ~and ) 224Ra (as 228Th or 228Ra) simultaneously, if the radioactive equiliribria can be assumed in the sample.
4. Marine Geochemistry of 2 2 7 A ~ 4.1. Reactivity of actinium with respect to settling particles In order to use "?Ac as a tracer of physical oceanographic processes, we must understand the extent to which the 227Acconcentration might be affected by interaction with particles. The interactions of natural radionuclides between particles and solution, so called "scavenging" in t,he deep sea is best represented as a reversible process rather than the unidirectional transfer from solution to particles as exemplified by the case of T h isotopes (Nozaki et al., 1981). Thus, the reactivity of nuclides with respect to particles can be evaluated in terms of the equilibrium concept of distribution coefficient, K D defined as, hTD =
paticulate nuclide in dpm/g of dry particles dissolved nuclide in dpm/g of seawater
(2)
For one of the least soluble nuclides, 230Th in deep seawater, approximately 20% of total 230Th is associated with particles and K n is estimated to be 2 ~ 1 0 ~ (GESAMP, 1984). Nozaki and Nakanishi (1985) demonstrated that K D for Pa is -10 times smaller than KD for Th, i.e., KD(Pa) = 2x106 in the North Pacific. This implies that only a few percent of 231Pais in particulate form.
148 The only available d a t a for particulate 227Acare based on the sample collected by sediment traps. Anderson (1980) determined three samples from the PARFLUX Pacific site, southeast of Hawaii (Honjo personal communication). In Fig. 6, the results of the (227Ac/231Pa)activity ratio are compared with those obtained for seawaters of the western North Pacific (Nozaki, 1984). T h e (227Ac/231Pa)activity ratio in particulate matter is one order of magnitude smaller than that in seawater, indicating that KD(Pa)/Ko(Ac) = 10 (or KD(Ac) = 2 ~ 1 0 and ~ ) only a few tenth of percent for Ac is bound with particles. Another way of expressing the elemental reactivity with particles is the scavenging residence time which is inversely related t o KO. Nozaki (1984) has estimated the scavenging residence time of Ac to be ~ 3 0 0 0years which is 100 times longer than that of T h (Nozaki et al., 1981). This implies t h a t since the mean life of 2 2 7 Ais~ only 31 years, the particle scavenging can hardly influence the distribution of 2 2 7 Ain ~ the deep sea, and hence 227Accan be used as a steady-state “conservative” tracer (Craig, 1969).
Comparison of the (227Th/231Pa)activity ratios between Fig. 6. seawater and particulate matter. Data are based on Nozaki (1984) arid Anderson (1979).
149 4.2.
Diffusion of 2 2 7 Afrom ~ deep-sea sediments
The presence of excess 2 2 7 Ain ~ deep waters clearly indicates t h a t there is a n additional source to the water other than 231Padecay. The distribution pattern of 2 2 7 Aincreasing ~ toward (Nozaki, 1984) the bottom and the good correlation between 227Acand 228Ra(Nozaki and Yang, 1987) strongly suggests t h a t excess 227Acmay be derived from underlying sediments through porewater diffusion much like Ra isotopes (Cochran, 1979). This is not quite surprising because the rare earth elements are diagenetically mobilized through porewater of marine sediments (Elderfield and Sholkovitz, 1987). More directly, Nozaki et al. (1990) have measured the pore water profile of 227Acin Northwest Pacific deep-sea sediment (Fig. 7 ) . The station locations where 2 2 7 Ad~a t a are available are shown in Fig. 8. T h e 227Acconcentration decreasing toward the sediment-water interface implies t h a t 227Acis diffusing out of the sediment. The model calculation suggested t h a t the molecular diffusion alone can support only one half of the excess 2 2 7 A standing ~ crop in the water column and the remainder need t o be supplied by the aid of bioturbation. It is also estimated the Langmuir isotherm adsorption coefficient, K for Ac solid/solution interaction, t o be (3&1)x1O3 which is comparable with t h a t Ac-227 (dpm/kg) 0.00
0.05
0.15
0.10
20
0
PzO.30 crn2/s
5
10
0 15 CD
-2 5
h
2 20
I
v
25
30
? N
0 0
35
Fig. 7. The 227Th profile in the pore water of Northwest Pacific deep-sea sediment obtained at the AN-5 site of Fig. 8.
150
N
40
20
a Fig. 8. The station locations where seawater and sediment samples were collected for 227Acanalyses. Those were occupied by two cruises of R. V. Hakuho-Maru (Cepheus and Antares Expeditions in 1982 and 1984, respectively.)
for Ra (1000-5000) reported in Cochran and Krishnaswami (1980). T h e adsorption coefficient K is related to the distribution coefficient K D by the equation (Cochran, 1979) given by
' = 0.83 (Nozaki et al., 1990), h - D becomes -O.4x1O5, a Using ps = 0.35 and 3 somewhat lower value compared with K D = 2x105 in t,he water column. This difference, if significant, may be caused by one or combination of changes in surface properties of sediment particles due to decomposition of organic matter and MnO2 coating, and in solution chemistry of porewater due to complexation, low solution/solid ratio, etc. Noteworthy in the calculation is t h a t the reactivity of 2 2 7 A in ~ sediment porewater is approximately equal t o that of Ra, regardless of difference in the valency state (+3 versus $2) and thereby their different solution chemistry in laboratory experiment. However, this is not surprising because there is a marked resemblance between Ba (as analogue of Ra) and La (as analogue of Ac), whose oceanic distributions are strongly correlated t o that of reactive silica (Chan et al., 1976; Klinkhammer et al., 1983). Thus, so far, we have found any disernible difference between R a and Ac in their geochemical behavior in the deep-sea environment. 4.3.
2 2 7 Ain ~ coastal and surface waters
Little work has been made to establish the 227A~--231Pa disequilibrium relationship in the shallow water environment. This is because both 2 2 7 Aand ~ 231Pa concentrations are extremely low. Yet it is clear from the open ocean d a t a (see below) t h a t there is very little excess 227Acin the surface water in contrast t o
151 Ac-227 (dpm/lOOOL) 0.0
+
0.5
1 .o
1.5
0
)-9(
w
20001
m x m
AN-1
AN-1 mx 4000
P 2 5
3
6000
8000
+ 10000
Fig. 9. Trench.
X X
t--s-+
cw
10000
The vertical profiles of 2 2 7 Aand ~ "'Th
in the Izu-Ogasawara
the presence of large excess 228Ra. The reason for this is that, because of a lack of authigenic 231Pa,production of 227Acin the shallow water sediments is about a factor of 20 smaller than that in deep-sea sediments. This recoil production of 2 2 7 Ain ~ sediments simply depends upon the 231Pacontent which is 2.8f1.4 dpm/g for deep-sea sediments (Yang et al., 1986) and -0.1 dpm/g for shallow water sediments assuming -3 rnuglg of average U content in shallow water sediment and the radioactive equilibrium between 231Paand 235U.In addition, Ac might be more particle-reactive than R a i n the esturine-coastal environment. Li et al. (1975) found that R a is significantly desorbed from river-borne particles in the estuarine mixing zones. On the other hand, Sholkovitz and Elderfield (1987) showed that the rare earth elements are removed from water during estuarine mixing. Further study is clearly needed in these environment.
5.
Simultaneous Use of 2 2 7 Aand ~ 228Raas Tracers of DeepSea Processes
Until now, 227Acd a t a were available only in the western North Pacific (Nozaki, 1984; Nozaki and Yang, 1987). The profiles were obtained t o the bottom of up to 6000 meters. Here I report the first d a t a set reaching a maximum depth of 9750 m in the deepest part of the Izu-Ogasawara Trench (station AN-1 in Fig. 8). At the site, various natural and man-made radionuclides together with nutrients and trace metals were measured, but only the profiles of 2 2 7 A and ~ 228Th are shown in Fig. 9. My fundamental premise to show the 228Th data is t h a t they are presumably in equilibrium with the parent, 228Rain the deep waters below
152 ~ 3 0 0 0meters. The reason for this comes from the box-model type calculation for concordance of (228Th/228Ra) and (230Th/234U)ratio (Nozaki and Yamada, 1987) given by, (ARa-228) = (:Th-230) AU-234 (4)
(
ATh-228
Th-228
)
+
ATh-230
In deriving equation (4), the first-order scavenging rate constant is assumed to be equal for 228Thand 230Th. The measured (234U/230Th)for the deep waters is becomes 0.95 which is indistinguishable from about 2000, and hence (228Th/228Ra) the equilibrium value within the uncertainty of measurement. Thus, I refer "'Th in the deep waters as (228Ra)hereafter.
5.1.
Vertical profiles of 2 2 7 Aand ~ 228Th('"Ra) in the deep trench
The vertical profile of 2 2 7 Ain ~ general is sirnlar to that of (228Ra)except for the top -1000 in where ("'Ra) has a strong surface maximum. The disparity in the shallow water can be ascribed to the difference in the flux from coastal sediments and possibly in the scavenging rates in nearshore/offwhore mixing zone as discussed above. The profiles of 227Acand (228Ra)down t o -6000 m, the bottom depth of eastern abyssal plain, are very similar to those observed in the western North Pacific basin (Nozaki, 1984; Nozaki et al., 1981) showing an increase with depth. Below 6000 meters, both 2 2 7 Aand ~ (228Ra)show some scatter but are relatively constant with depth. The scatter of data within the trench for 2 2 7 Aand ~ (22sRa) is not consistent with any other nuclides and therefore I regard them to be artifact in the analysis rather than real. The vertical profiles obtained here are first interpreted by using a one dimensional steady-state diffusion model given by
where K Z is the vertical eddy diffusion coefficient, Z is the height above the bottom, X is the decay constant, C is the excess activity of radionuclide of interest over the parent. The choice of the model is not based on the reality of physical mixing but purely based on the fact that the available data set is one dimensional. Thus, its application to the d a t a will show the inadequancy rather than successfulness of the model. T h e solution of equation ( 5 ) for the boundary conditions of C = C0 at Z = 0 and C = 0 at Z -+ 00 is given by,
Some example of profiles for given li'z values are shown in Fig. 10, where the excess activity is normalized to 1 a t the bottom interface. Based on the equation (6), K z must be higher than lo4 cm2/s for the nearly constant 2 2 7 Aand ~ (228Ra) profiles within the trench, and 50 and 130 cm2/s, for the 2 2 7 A and ~ 228Radata respectively between 3000 m and 6000 m. The high apparent vertical diffusivity within the trench may be due to the narrow topography which tends to induce
153 rapid boundary mixing (Armi, 1978). It is probable that the water within the trench is very rapidly renewed with the deep water of 5000 to 6000 meters around this region. The inconsistency of the apparent vertical diffusion coefficient derived from the 2 2 7 Aand ~ (228Ra)d a t a suggests that the chemical distributions are largely governed by isopycnal mixing (Sarmiento et al., 1982). This is also supported by the simlarity in the vertical profile down to -6000 meters between the Izu-Ogasawara trench and the western North Pacific regardless of the difference in the bottom depth.
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
Ra-228iAc-227
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
Ra-228
Ac-227
0.0
1.2
1.0
Ac-227
Fig. 10. The calculated profiles of 2 2 7 Aand ~ 228Rabased on a simple diffusion model and given Eiz values. Note t h a t the vertical model 228Ra2 2 7 A plot ~ gives a concave curve which differ from the rapid isopycnal mixing model with negligible radioactive decay (the solid line of Fig. 10d).
154 3
T
0
1
2
3
Ac-227 (dpm/lOOOL) Fig. 11. The correlation diagram between 2 2 7 Aand ~ 228Rain the deep water. The d a t a (squares) deeper than 3000 m at the AN-1 station are plotted. The calculated curve of the simple vertical mixing model is shown by the diamonds which differs from the rapid isopycnal mixing model with (227Ac/228Ra)ratio of 1 and negligible decay (the solid line). One of the interesting outcomes of the simple vertical model is shown in Fig. 10d and 11, where the 22sRavesus 2 2 7 Aplot ~ shows the concave feature regardless of the value of K z . However, if the distribution of the two nuclides is governed by rapid horizontal mixing (hence, negligible decay) with a contstant 22sRa to 227Acsource ratio, it should approach t o the linear line as shown in Fig. 11. Thus, the difference between the vertical and horizontal models suggests t h a t the simultaneous use of 228Raand 227Actracers should, at least in principle, resolve the relative importance of diapycinal and isopycnal mixing in the deep sea. The published d a t a near the slope of Japanese Islands obtained by Nozaki and Yang (1987) appears to follow a linear trend rather than a concave curve, showing their distributions are largely governed by lateral mixing.
Acknowledgements This work was supported by the Ministry of Education, Science and Culture, Japan through the Grant-in-Aid Nos. 63610004 and 01610003 to the University of Tokyo. The manuscript was typed by Ms. K. Hasegawa.
References Amin, B. S., S. Krishnaswami and B. L. K. Somayajulu, 1974. z34Th/238U activity ratios in Pacific Ocean bottom waters, Earth Planet. Sci. Lett., 21, 342. Anderson, R. F., 1981. The Marine Geochemistry of Thorium and Protactinium. Ph. D. Thesis, M.1.T.-W.H.O.I. Joint Program, Woods Hole, Mass., 287 pp.
155 Armi, L., 1978. Some evidence for boundary mixing in the deep ocean. J. Geophys. Res., 83, 1971-1979. Bhat, S. G., S. Krishnaswami, D. Lal, Rama and W. S. Moore, 1969. Th234/U238ratios in the ocean. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett., 4, 483-491. Broecker, W. S., 1965. An application of natural radon to problem in ocean circulation. In: Symposium on Diffusion in Oceans and Fresh Waters, Lamont-Doherty Geological Observatory, Palisades, NY, pp. 116-145. Chan, L. H., J. M. Edmond, R. F. Stallard, W. S. Broecker, Y. C. Chung, R. F. Weiss and T . L. Ku, 1976. Radium and barium at GEOSECS stations in the Atlantic and Pacific. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett., 32, 258-267. Chung, Y., and H. Craig, 1972. Excess radon and temperature profiles from the eastern equatorial Pacific. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett, 14, 55-64. Cochran, J. K., 1979. The Geochemistry of 226Raand 228Rain Marine Deposits. Ph. D. Thesis, Yale University, New Haven, Conn. 260 pp. Cochran, J. K., and S. Krishnaswami, 1980. Radium, thorium, uranium and 'loPb in deep-sea sediments and sediment pore waters from the North Equatorial Pacific. Amer. J. Sci., 280, 849-889. Craig, H., 1969. Abyssal carbon and radiocarbon in the Pacific. J . Geophys. Res., 74, 5491-5506. Elderfield, H., and E. R. Sholkovitz, 1987. Rare earth elements in the pore waters of reducing nearshore sediments. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett., 82, 280-288. GESAMP, 1983. An Oceanographic Model for the Dispersion of Wastes Disposed of in the Deep Sea. IAEA, Vienna, 182 pp. Horibe, Y., and H. Tsubota, 1977. A large-volume water sampler. In: Preservation of the Marine Environment, Report of Co-operative Research, Vol. 1, Y. Horibe (ed.), University of Tokyo Press, 199 pp. Horibe, Y., Y. Takashima,, T . Gamo, Y. Nozaki, M. Sakanoue and Y. Nagaya, 1986. Mixing of seawater studied with chemical tracers. In: Dynamics of the Oceans, K. Kajiura (ed.), Koseikaku-Koseisha, Tokyo, pp. 9-77. Karalova, J . K., and B. F. Myasoyedov, 1982. Actinium, Science Academy, Moscow, USSR. Klinkhammer, G., H. Elderfield and A. Hudson, 1983. Rare earth elements in seawater near hydrothermal vents. Nature, 305, 185-188. Krishnaswami, S., D. Lal, B. L. K. Somayajulu, R. F. Weiss and H. Craig, 1976. Largevolume in-situ filtration of deep Pacific waters: mineralogical and radioisotope studies. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett., 32, 420-429. Latimer, W. M., 1956. Oxidation Potentials, 2nd Edition, Prentice-Hall, Inc., Englewood Cliffs, N. J., 392 pp. Li, Y. H., and L. H. Chan, 1979. Desorption of Ba and 226Rafrom river borne sediments in the Hudson Estuary. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett., 43, 343-350. Lucas, H. F., 1957. Improved low-level alpha-scintillation counter for radon. Rev. Sci. Instrum., 28, 680-683. Moore, W. S., 1969. Oceanic concentrations of "'Ra. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett., 6, 437-446. Moore, W. S., 1976. Sampling "'Ra in the deep ocean. Deep-sea Res., 23, 647-651. Moore, W. S., and D. F. Reid, 1973. Extraction of radium from natural waters using manganese-impregnated acrylic fibers. J. Geophys. Res., 78, 8880-8885. Nagaya, Y., and K. Nakamura, 1981. Artificial radionuclides in the western Northwest Pacific (I); "Sr and 137Csin the deep waters. J. Oceangr. Soc. Japan, 37, 135-144. Nagaya, Y., and K. Nakamura, 1987. Artificial radionuclides in the western Northwest Pacific (11); 137Csand 239,240Pu inventories in water and sediment columns observed
from 1980 to 1986. J. Oceanogr. SOC.Japan, 43, 345-355. Nozaki, Y., 1983. Determination of thorium isotopes in seawater by moored MnOz-fiber method. J . Oceanogr. SOC.Japan, 39, 129-135. Nozaki, Y., 1984. Excess "?Ac in deep ocean water. Nature, 310, 486-488. Nozaki, Y., and T. Nakanishi, 1985. 231Paand 230Thprofiles in the open ocean water column. Deep-sea Res., 32, 1209-1220. Nozaki, Y., and H. Yang, 1987. T h and P a isotopes in the water of the western margin of the Pacific near Japan: Evidence for release of "* Ra and "'Ac from slope sediments. J. Oceanogr. SOC.Japan, 43, 217-227. Nozaki, Y., Y. Horibe and H. Tsubota, 1981. The water column distributions of thorium isotopes in the western North Pacific. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett., 54, 203-216. Nozaki, Y., and Y. Horibe, 1983. Alpha-emitting thorium isotopes in northwest Pacific deep waters. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett., 65, 39-50. Nozaki, Y., H. S. Yang and M. Yamada, 1987. Scavenging of thorium in the ocean. J. Geophys. Res., 92, 772-778. Nozaki, Y., and M. Yamada, 1987. Thorium and Protactinium isotope distributions in waters of the Japan Sea. Deep-sea Res., 34, 1417-1430. Nozaki, Y., M. Yamada and H. Nikaido, 1990. The marine geochemistry of actinium-227: Evidence for its migration through sediment pore water. Geophys. Res. Lett., 17, 1933-1936. Orr, J. C., N. L. Guinasso and D. R. Schink, 1984. Device for Rapid in situ Extraction of Tracers from Large Volumes of Seawater. Tech. Resp. 84-T-1, Dep. of Oceangr., Texas A&M University, College Station, TX, 60 pp. Orr, J. C., 1988. Evaluation of counting methods for oceanic radium-228. J. Geophys. Res., 93, 8265-8278. Rama, J. F. Todd, J. L. Butts and W. S. Moore, 1987. A new methods for the rapid measurement of 224Rain natural waters. Mar. Chem., 22, 43-54. Reid, D. F., R. M. Key and D. R. Schink, 1979. Radium, thorium, and actinium extraction from seawater using an improved manganese-oxide-coated fiber. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett., 43, 223-226. Sarmiento, J. L., C. G. H. Rooth and W. S. Broecker, 1982. Radium 228 as a tracer of basin wide processes in the abyssal ocean. J. Geophys. Res., 87, 9694-9698. Sarmiento, J. L., H. W. Feely, W. S. Moore, A. E. Bainbridge and W. S. Broecker, 1976. The relationship between vertical eddy diffusion and buoyancy gradient in the deep sea. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett., 32, 357-370. Spencer, D. W., P. G. Brewer, A. Fleer, S. Honjo, S. Krishnaswami and Y. Nozaki, 1978. Chemical fluxes from a sediment trap experiment in the deep Sargasso Sea. J. Mar. Res., 36, 493-523. Turekian, K. K., Y. Nozaki and L. K. Benninger, 1977. Geochemistry of atmospheric radon and radon products. Ann. Rev. Earth Planet. Sci., 5, 227-255. Yang, H. S., Y. Nozaki, H. Sakai and A. Masuda, 1986. The distribution of 230Thand 231Pain the deep-sea surface sediments of the Pacific Ocean. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta, 50, 81-89.
Deep Ocean Circulation, Physical and Chemical Aspects edited by T. Teramoto 0 1993 Elsevier Science Publishers B.V. All rights reserved.
157
Distributions and Mass-Balance of 239,240Pu and 137Csin the Northern North Pacific Yutaka NAGAYA and Kiyoshi NAKAMURA*
Abstract 239,240Pu and '37Cs,in t h e water and sediment columns of t h e northern North Pacific (including t h e Bering Sea) were determined in 1988, and their distributions were compared with those in the southern regions. T h e 137Cs water and sediment inventories in t h e area north of t h e Subarctic Convergence are remarkably lower than t h e estimated global fallout inputs. This suggests t h a t 137Cs is effectively transported southward from t h e northern upwelling regions t o the central Pacific gyre. T h e difference between t h e total inventory and t h e atmospheric input of 239,240 P u is relatively smaller than that of 137Cs. This is attributable to t h e fact t h a t P u is more particle reactive than Cs, and hence it is more actively involved in t h e vertical biogeochemical cycling. Penetration of t h e radionuclides into t h e sediment column occurs due mostly t o bioturbation. T h e particle mixing coefficients calculated based on artificial radionuclide distributions are comparable t o those estimated from excess zlOPb.
1.
Introduction
Artificial radionuclides released, largely due to the nuclear weapon testing with a maximum in 1963, into the marine environment have been regarded as useful tracers in the study of various marine processes. Hence their distributions and pathways in the marine environment have been investigated extensively for our understanding of not only the degree of radioactive contaniination but also natural geochemical and oceanographic processes occurring in the ocean (for example, see Pentreath, 1988). The recent studies of 2391240Puand 137Csin the North Pacific by Bowen e t al. (1980) and Nagaya and Nakamura (1981, 1984 and 1987) showed t h a t there is considerable disagreement between the inventories of the radionuclides in the water column and the estimated global fallout inputs t o the surface ocean. In the central North Pacific, the water column inventories were higher than t.he estimat,ed atmospheric inputs, and it was suggested t h a t the discrepancy is attributable t o the contribution of local tropospheric input which presumably occurred near the test site of the equatorial North Pacific and it might also be in part due to the contribution of the remobilized radionuclides from the test sites (Noshikin and Wong, *Division of Marine Radioecology, National Institute of Radiological Sciences, Isozaki, Nakaminato, 311-12 Japan
158 1980; McMurtry et al., 1985). On the other hand, the water column inventories were nearly equal or slightly lower than the fallout inputs in the northern and northwestern North Pacific. In our previous paper (Nagaya and Nakamura, 1987), we suggested that this latitudinal transition in reversing the ratio of standing stock t o fallout or the radionuclides occurs across the Subarctic Convergence around 40°N. However the observed data on the area north of the Subarctic Convergence were sparse for that time, and it was necessary to make further measurements t o confirm this. In this paper, we present the new data on 2393240Puand 137Cs in the northern North Pacific and their geochemical significance is discussed.
2.
Materials and Methods
All sea water and sediment samples were collected during the KH-88-3 cruise (Draco Expedition, 1988) of R/V Hakuho-Maru, the Ocean Research Institute, University of Tokyo. Sampling stations are shown in Fig. 1, together with those occupied by the previous cruises (Nagaya and Nakamura, 1981, 1984, 1987). Surface water samples ( w 100 1 each) were collected by using a pump, and subsurface samples ( w 250 1 each) were collected using a large volume sampler described in Horibe et al. (1977). Sediment samples were collected with a box
Fig. 1. Sampling stations. 0: this work, 0 : previous cruise (CY..1980; DE..1985; B,C..1986). a: surface water and sediment, b: surface water only, c: sediment only.
159
4
-
-
2t
4
0 U
-0-0.
0 CY-6
L
I
+ - u 0
DR-I0 -0-
6
Fig. 2. Vertical distribution of 239,240Pu in north (DR-10) and south (CY-6) of the Subarctic Convergence. corer (50 cm x 50 cm x 50 cm). After recovery a 12 cm x 12 cm square core was subsampled from each sediment, and then extruded and cut at 1 t o 2 cm intervals on board the ship. 2 3 9 , 2 4 0a ~ ~ nd 137Cscontents were determined for all samples, except 2391240Pu contents in subsurface water samples from 2 stations (DR-5 and DR-21). Analytical procedures for the radionuclides were described elsewhere (Nagaya and Nakamura, 1981, 1984, 1986; Nakamura and Nagaya, 1985). The natural radionuclide 210Pb in the sediment samples was determined by gamma-spectrometry, and calculated from its count rate at the gamma energy of 46.5 keV.
3.
Results and Discussion
The analytical data are shown in Tables 1 and 2. All the d a t a are corrected for radioactive decay t o the date of sample collection. The radionuclide inventories calculated from the d a t a are given in Table 3. 3.1.
Vertical profiles of 239,240Pu and 137Csin the water and sediment columns
The vertical profiles of 2393240Pu and 137Csin the water column at 50"N (DR-10) obtained here are compared with those at 40"N (CY-6) reported earlier (Nagaya
160 Table 1. Results of sea water analysis. DEPTH (m) 0
T ("C)
(Ym)
-
-
IJ7 cs (mBq/t) 4.94f0.29
DR- 5
0 103 257 401 598 789 947 2,000 3,486 4,999 6,239
8.2 8.32 6.02 4.59 4.02 3.45 3.40 1.88 1.51 1.57 1.70
33.360 33.048 33.884 33.892 34.100 34.279 34.385 34.599 34.681 34.691 34.689
DR- 7
0
-
DR-10
0 106 279 397 598 799 997 2,003 2,989 4,000 5,615
0 105 204 405 700 1,000 1,499 2,505 3,937
STN Ur- 2
DR-13
DR-18
0
DR-21
0 96 246 402 602 797 1,002 2,003 3,014 4,001 4,850
DR-23
0
S
(mBq/100l) 4.35-
PU/CS x102 (Activity ratio) 0.88fO.09
3.23f0.22 3.43f0.15 3.09f0.15 2.17f0.12 0.70f0.07 0.45f0.07 0.31f0.09 0.04f0.04 0.01f0.03 0.06f0.04 0.02f0.04
1.12f0.26
0.35f0.08
34.483
3.23f0.20
1.45f0.19
0.45f0.07
4.98 2.03 3.24 3.35 3.04 2.77 2.49 1.78 1.55 1.48 1.64
33.142 33.392 34.048 34.170 34.286 34.360 34.434 34.602 34.647 34.669 34.693
2.64f0.18 2.08f0.10 0.80f0.08 0.56f0.07 0.28f0.05 0.17f0.06 0.15f0.07 0.04k0.04 0.09f0.04 0.11f0.04 0.07f0.04
2.02f0.19 0.97f0.05 1.63f0.23
0.77f0.09 0.47f0.03 2.0f0.4
6.11 2.40 3.07 3.55 3.20 2.85 2.28 1.73 1.59
33.191 33.304 34.578 34.031 34.240 34.362 34.500 34.632 34.655
2.82f0.22 1.71f0.11 2.34f0.12 0.88f0.07 0.29f0.06 0.14f0.03 0.08f0.03 0.09f0.03 0.03f0.03
1.85f0.21 0.80f0.07 1.30f0.07 1.63f0.07 1.48f0.08 1.20f0.09 0.90f0.07 0.56f0.05 0.9150.07
0.66f0.09 0.47f0.05 0.56f0.04 1.9f0.02 5.1fl.l 8.6f2.0 11.3414.3 6.5f2.6
-
32.921
2.1150.16
1.23f0.28
0.6f0.1
8.51 4.45 3.96 3.80 3.45 3.13 2.84 1.96 1.57 1.52 1.58
32.763 32.853 33.877 34.049 34.210 34.309 34.383 34.588 34.647 34.681 34.684
2.7960.19 1.94f0.09 1.69f0.10 0.97f0.07 0.41f0.06 0.36f0.05 0.06f0.03 0.04f0.03 0.12f0.04 0.06f0.03 0.03f0.03
0.40f0.09
0.14f0.03
-
32.527
2.63f0.18
0.23f0.07
0.09f0.03
2syJ4uPU
-
-
2.25f0.24 l.ll*0.20 1.14f0.08 0.60f0.05 0.41f0.05 0.57f0.06 1.00f0.07
8.0f1.7 6.5f2.6 1.7f3.6
* Activity ratio is neglected because of large deviation.
*
4.8f2.4 5.2f2.0 14.3f8.2
*
161 Table 2.
(cm) 0- 2 2- 4 4- 6 6- 8 8-10 10-12 12-14 14-16
Water Contents @) 67.9 68.4 65.5 71.2 63.3 62.6 61.6 60.8
0- 3 3- 6 6- 9 9-12 12-15 15-18 18-21
73.1 70.5 67.2 66.6 64.5 63.5 63.7
5.83f0.34 1.63k0.22 0.42f0.15 0.37f0.14 0.15f.O.13 0.08f0.11 0.00f0.12
0.571f0.017 0.271f0.010 0.090f0.006 0.072f0.005 0.027f0.003 0.024f0.003 0.009f0.002
0.098f0.006 0.17f0.0