INTERNATIONAL UNION OF CRYSTALLOGRAPHY BOOK SERIES
IUCr BOOK SERIES COMMITTEE E. N. Baker, New Zealand J. Bernstein, I...
43 downloads
1856 Views
17MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
INTERNATIONAL UNION OF CRYSTALLOGRAPHY BOOK SERIES
IUCr BOOK SERIES COMMITTEE E. N. Baker, New Zealand J. Bernstein, Israel P. Coppens, USA G. R. Desiraju, India E. Dodson, UK A. M. Glazer, UK J. R. Helliwell, UK P. Paufler, Germany H. Schenk (Chairman), The Netherlands IUCr Monographs on Crystallography 1 Accurate molecular structures A. Domenicano, I. Hargittai, editors 2 P.P. Ewald and his dynamical theory of X-ray diffraction D.W.J. Cruickshank, H.J. Juretschke, N. Kato, editors 3 Electron diffraction techniques, Vol. 1 J.M. Cowley, editor 4 Electron diffraction techniques, Vol. 2 J.M. Cowley, editor 5 The Rietveld method R.A. Young, editor 6 Introduction to crystallographic statistics U. Shmueli, G.H. Weiss 7 Crystallographic instrumentation L.A. Aslanov, G.V. Fetisov, J.A.K. Howard 8 Direct phasing in crystallography C. Giacovazzo 9 The weak hydrogen bond G.R. Desiraju, T. Steiner 10 Defect and microstructure analysis by diffraction R.L. Snyder, J. Fiala and H.J. Bunge 11 Dynamical theory of X-ray diffraction A. Authier 12 The chemical bond in inorganic chemistry I.D. Brown 13 Structure determination from powder diffraction data W.I.F. David, K. Shankland, L.B. McCusker, Ch. Baerlocher, editors 14 Polymorphism in molecular crystals J. Bernstein
15 16 17 18
Crystallography of modular materials G. Ferraris, E. Makovicky, S. Merlino Diffuse x-ray scattering and models of disorder T.R. Welberry Crystallography of the polymethylene chain: an inquiry into the structure of waxes D.L. Dorset Crystalline molecular complexes and compounds: structures and principles F.H. Herbstein
IUCr Texts on Crystallography 1 The solid state A. Guinier, R. Julien 4 X-ray charge densities and chemical bonding P. Coppens 5 The basics of crystallography and diffraction, second edition C. Hammond 6 Crystal structure analysis: principles and practice W. Clegg, editor 7 Fundamentals of crystallography, second edition C. Giacovazzo, editor
Crystalline Molecular Complexes and Compounds Structures and Principles Volume 1
F RA N K H . H E R B S T E I N Emeritus Professor of Chemistry, Technion-Israel Institute of Technology, Israel
1
1
Great Clarendon Street, Oxford OX2 6DP Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford. It furthers the University’s objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education by publishing worldwide in Oxford New York Auckland Cape Town Dar es Salaam Hong Kong Karachi Kuala Lumpur Madrid Melbourne Mexico City Nairobi New Delhi Shanghai Taipei Toronto With offices in Argentina Austria Brazil Chile Czech Republic France Greece Guatemala Hungary Italy Japan Poland Portugal Singapore South Korea Switzerland Thailand Turkey Ukraine Vietnam Oxford is a registered trade mark of Oxford University Press in the UK and in certain other countries Published in the United States by Oxford University Press Inc., New York # Oxford University Press 2005 The moral rights of the author have been asserted Database right Oxford University Press (maker)
First published 2005 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without the prior permission in writing of Oxford University Press, or as expressly permitted by law, or under terms agreed with the appropriate reprographics rights organization. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside the scope of the above should be sent to the Rights Department, Oxford University Press, at the address above You must not circulate this book in any other binding or cover and you must impose the same condition on any acquirer British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data Data available Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data Data available Typeset by Newgen Imaging Systems (P) Ltd., Chennai, India Printed in Great Britain on acid-free paper by Biddles Ltd., King’s Lynn ISBN 0–19–856893–2 (Vol 1) 978–0–19–856893–3 ISBN 0–19–856894–0 (Vol 2) 978–0–19–856894–0 ISBN 0–19–852660–1 (Set) 978–0–19–852660–5 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
TWENTY: Give up learning and put an end to your troubles. From TAO TE CHING by Lao Tsu (A new translation by Gia-fu Feng and Jane English Wildwood House, London 1973)
OR How charming is divine philosophy, Not harsh and crabbed as dull fools suppose, But musical as Apollo’s lute, And a perpetual feast of nectared sweets, Where no crude surfeit reigns, John Milton (1608–74): Comus, 476.
This book has been written in many places and over too many years. It would never have been completed without the help and support of my wife Any. It is dedicated to her and to four teachers and friends: R. W. James, FRS, formerly Professor of Physics in the University of Cape Town G. M. J. Schmidt, formerly Professor of Chemistry in the Weizmann Institute of Science J. D. Dunitz FRS, emeritus Professor of Chemical Crystallography in the Eidgeno¨ssische Technische Hochschule, Zu¨rich Sir Aaron Klug P-PRS, OM, NL. MRC Laboratory of Molecular Biology, Cambridge, UK
This page intentionally left blank
Preface My intention is to give an account of the structure and properties of crystalline binary adducts, perhaps better known as molecular compounds and complexes, which are a broad group of materials whose several members are of interest to chemists (e.g. separations via crown ethers and identifications via charge transfer compounds), physicists (e.g. high-conductivity organics), biologists (is not DNA an excellent example of a hydrogenbonded molecular compound?) and technologists (zeolites for separations and as catalysts). I have tried to cater to them all; extensive inclusion of chemical formulae (for the nonchemists) and stereodiagrams (for the noncrystallographers) will hopefully make it easier to assimilate some of the unavoidable complexities. Most emphasis will be given to geometrical structures derived from crystal structure analyses for here lies the bulk of the available information. I refer to interactions between the components wherever this is possible, including both thermodynamic and electronic aspects. Consideration of the relation between structure and properties will be principally confined to the solid state and the implications of solid state results for understanding chemical reactivity in other phases will not be pursued. I restrict myself to crystalline materials because the results, and their meanings, are least unequivocal for this state of matter. Interactions between components in the fluid states are undoubtedly important but I leave these aspects to others. The word ‘‘molecular’’ appears in the title because most of the relevant materials are indeed molecular, but many contain charged entities and I have licensed myself to include what seems relevant, regardless of the formal restrictions of the title. Most of the substances considered are organic, some are inorganic and many have both organic and inorganic parts. I discuss representatives of many of the various types of molecular compound and complex, but I early realized that any attempt to cover all examples of all types would be self-defeating. The problems of choice beset us all, at all levels of our lives, and an author, struggling to compress the vast expanses of knowledge into a practical physical confine, is no exception. I have given preference to mature areas, where what is known presents a model for the treatment of those regions as yet unexplored, and I have emphasized the fundamentals – structure and thermodynamics. I guess (no other word seems realistic) that I have managed to include about 20% of what is available in the literature. The series Inclusion Complexes, dealing with less than half the topics covered here runs to five volumes and over two thousand pages. The series Comprehensive Supramolecular Chemistry, again with half the present coverage, stretches to eleven volumes and five thousand pages. Perhaps the most serious of my many acts of omission is exclusion of material on ‘‘Zeolites’’. This is not because of any lack of importance of the subject but because it is adequately covered in a number of books and an on-going journal. There is also little said about complexes between large biomolecules – this would have required a separate book.
viii
PREFACE
An overall theory is hardly possible but some areas have had sophisticated theories applied to them, e.g. the quantum-mechanical treatments of charge transfer interactions and the statistical mechanical treatments of some phase diagrams. In order to provide some unifying factors, I have given special emphasis to structural relationships and the classification scheme used is structural rather than chemical in nature. The classification scheme proposed here should not be regarded as more than a convenient framework – Nature is too complex and subtle for the imposition of straitjackets. Titles of books and review articles have been included in the (close to 4000) references, which are attached to each chapter for the convenience of the reader. Much of the information is conveyed through tables, some 200 in number. The tabulated material shows that considerable systematization is possible, but also that considerable variety remains as exceptions to those rules that I (and many others) have succeeded in developing. Crystal packing and other diagrams (some 600) are a challenge to author and reader alike. Colour would have helped but was ruled out as impractical. I am most grateful to authors, editors and publishers for permission to use published material. Some more detailed acknowledgments are made in the text. My thanks go to many friends and to Caltech, Northwestern, Cambridge (U.K.), The Royal Institution, the Universities of Cape Town and Witwatersrand and, last but not least, Technion for help and facilities. Needless to say, the responsibility for the contents is entirely mine. Haifa, November 2004
Frank H. Herbstein
Contents Volume 1 PART I
SOME PRELIMINARIES
1 Structural principles in the classification of binary adducts 1.1 Introduction 1.2 Structural classification of binary adducts 1.2.1 General considerations 1.2.2 Molecular complexes 1.2.2.1 Inclusion complexes 1.2.2.2 Moieties within molecules 1.2.2.3 Frameworks with guest participation and/or linkage 1.2.2.4 Segregated stack charge transfer complexes 1.2.2.5 Packing complexes 1.2.3 Molecular compounds 1.3 Other classifications 1.4 How many binary adducts are there? 1.5 Organic and inorganic supramolecular chemistry References
3 4 5 5 6 6 9 9 9 10 10 10 11 12 12
2 Historical outline References
15 19
PART II
MOIETIES WITHIN MOLECULES
Introduction to Part II 3 The enclosure species – crown ethers, cryptands and related molecules – as hosts 3.1 Introduction 3.2 Doubly bridged cyclophanes and analogous molecules as hosts for intramolecular guests 3.3 Cleft molecules as hosts 3.3.1 Single-cleft hosts 3.3.2 Double-cleft hosts 3.4 Container molecules as hosts 3.4.1 Introduction
27 28 30 44 44 47 48 48
x
CONT ENTS
3.4.2 Cavitands and caviplexes 3.4.3 Hemispherands and hemispheraplexes 3.4.4 Triply bridged cyclophanes and analogous molecules as three-dimensional hosts for intramolecular guests 3.4.5 Spherands and spheraplexes 3.4.6 Carcerands and carceplexes 3.5 Hemicarcerands and hemicarceplexes 3.5.1 Overview 3.5.2 The taming of cyclobutadiene, and of o-benzyne 3.5.3 Molecular mechanics and dynamics studies on the complexation and decomplexation processes 3.6 Comparisons of concepts References
48 50
4 Cyclodextrins, and some analogs, as hosts 4.1 Introduction 4.2 -Cyclodextrins as host 4.2.1 -Cyclodextrin as host in clathrate inclusion complexes 4.2.2 -Cyclodextrin as host in tunnel inclusion complexes 4.2.3 Chemically modified -cyclodextrins as hosts in inclusion complexes 4.3 -Cyclodextrins as host 4.3.1 -Cyclodextrin as host in clathrate inclusion complexes 4.3.2 -Cyclodextrin as host in tunnel inclusion complexes 4.3.3 Exceptional -cyclodextrin structures 4.3.4 Chemically modified -cyclodextrins as hosts in inclusion complexes 4.4 Rotaxanes and catenanes of cyclodextrins 4.5 -Cyclodextrins as host 4.5.1 -Cyclodextrin as host in clathrate inclusion complexes 4.5.2 -Cyclodextrin as host in tunnel inclusion complexes 4.5.3 Chemically modified -cyclodextrins as hosts in inclusion complexes 4.6 Larger cyclodextrins 4.7 Cyclic oligosaccharides as cyclodextrin analogs References
73 74 79 80 84
5 Crystal chemistry of some DNA oligonucleotides and their complexes 5.1 Introduction 5.2 Fundamentals of oligonucleotide structure 5.2.1 General aspects 5.2.2 Single crystal x-ray diffraction studies of oligonucleotides 5.3 Crystal chemistry of oligonucleotides and oligonucleotide-guest structures 5.3.1 Polymorphism, isomorphism, and heteromorphism
51 59 59 61 61 64 66 67 68
90 95 97 100 114 114 117 118 118 119 122 123 123 124
133 134 136 136 140 142 142
CONTENTS
5.4
5.5 5.6
5.7
5.3.2 Phase rule relationships 5.3.3 Applications of these concepts Intercalated hexanucleotide-drug complexes with B-DNA structures 5.4.1 The anthracycline drugs 5.4.2 Nogalamycin and derivatives 5.4.3 The 9-aminoacridine drugs 5.4.4 Native hexanucleotides and comparison of crystal structures Isomorphism and polymorphism of A-DNA octanucleotides and the binding of spermine 5.5.1 Octameric oligonucleotides Minor groove binders 5.6.1 Drug molecules that enter the minor groove 5.6.2 Decameric oligonucleotides 5.6.3 Polymorphs or intermediate phases? An example from the decanucleotides 5.6.4 Dodecameric oligonucleotides General survey of the crystal chemistry of oligonucleotide and oligonucleotide-drug complexes References
PART III
xi
143 144 145 145 151 154 156 158 158 167 167 171 178 183 187 189
HOST–GUEST INCLUSION COMPLEXES
Introduction to Part III 6 Tunnel inclusion complexes formed by hosts of lesser versatility 6.1 Introduction 6.2 Tunnel inclusion complexes with directionally bonded hosts 6.2.1 Urea, thiourea and selenourea as hosts 6.2.1.1 Introduction 6.2.1.2 Types of guest in hexagonal urea inclusion complexes 6.2.1.3 Guests which give rhombohedral urea inclusion complexes 6.2.1.4 Guests which give rhombohedral thiourea inclusion complexes 6.2.1.5 Hermann’s comprehensive structural model 6.2.1.6 Diffraction patterns from tunnel inclusion complexes 6.2.1.7 Hexagonal urea tunnel inclusion complexes 6.2.1.8 Determination of guest molecule conformation from diffuse x-ray scattering
203 204 206 206 206 207 208 209 210 212 215 218
CONT ENTS
xii
6.2.1.9
Variation of structure with temperature, with particular reference to {3(urea)[1/4(n-hexadecane)]} 6.2.1.10 Interruption of urea framework by host–guest hydrogen bonding 6.2.1.11 Rhombohedral urea, thiourea and selenourea tunnel inclusion complexes 6.2.1.12 Monoclinic complexes derived from the rhombohedral complexes 6.2.1.13 Behavior of some rhombohedral inclusion complexes on cooling 6.2.1.14 The orthorhombic Type 4 urea tunnel inclusion complexes 6.2.1.15 The hypothetical Type 5 orthorhombic tunnel inclusion complexes 6.2.1.16 The crystal structure of selenourea and its relation to the structures of its tunnel inclusion complexes 6.2.1.17 Thermodynamics of the formation of the tunnel inclusion complexes 6.2.2 The Bishop–Dance hosts – exo-2,exo-6-dihydroxy-2,6dimethylbicyclo[3.3.1]nonane and analogs 6.2.2.1 Introduction 6.2.2.2 The helical tubuland structures 6.2.2.3 The ellipsoidal tetragonal clathrate complexes of some Bishop–Dance hosts 6.2.2.4 Derived structures 6.2.3 Ta4P4S29 – an inorganic framework containing sulphur chains 6.2.4 The tunnel hydrates 6.2.4.1 Tunnel hydrates with several water molecules per tunnel cross-section 6.2.4.2 Tunnel hydrates with one water molecule per tunnel cross-section 6.3 Tunnel inclusion complexes with van der Waals bonded hosts 6.3.1 Tunnel inclusion and other complexes of deoxycholic acid and related compounds 6.3.2 Substituted spirocyclophosphazenes as hosts 6.3.3 Tritriptycene – a C62H38 hydrocarbon of D3h symmetry with three U-shaped bays 6.3.4 trans-anti-trans-anti-trans-Perhydrotriphenylene as host 6.3.5 N-(p-tolyl)tetrachloro-phthalimide as host 6.4 Comparison of the various types of tunnel inclusion complexes References 7 Clathrate inclusion complexes formed by hosts of lesser versatility 7.1 Introduction 7.2 Directionally bonded hosts
219 227 231 235 236 245 245 247 247 251 251 251 264 267 268 269 269 271 272 272 291 297 298 307 310 311 321 323 323
CONTENTS
7.2.1 Quinol (hydroquinone, 1,4-dihydroxybenzene) as host 7.2.1.1 Crystal structures of quinol polymorphs and -quinol clathrates 7.2.1.2 Low temperature phase transitions in -quinol clathrates 7.2.1.3 Introduction to statistical thermodynamics of clathrate structures and application to the quinol clathrates 7.2.2 Crystal structure of {(6H2O)[hexamethylene tetramine]} 7.2.3 Clathrates derived from existing structures 7.2.3.1 Helium hexahydrate 7.2.3.2 Cadmium cyanide clathrates 7.2.4 Overview of the polyhedral clathrates (including metalloid structures, clathrasils, gas hydrates, clathrate and semiclathrate hydrates) 7.2.4.1 Historical and general introduction 7.2.4.2 Restrictions on the shapes of the polyhedra 7.2.4.3 Packing of pentagonal dodecahedra 7.2.5 Metalloid structures 7.2.6 Clathrasils 7.2.7 Gas hydrates (structures with pentagonal dodecahedra) 7.2.7.1 Relation between guest type and structure type in the gas hydrates 7.2.7.2 Stoichiometry and thermodynamics of the gas hydrates 7.2.7.3 Prototype CS-I and CS-II crystal structures at low temperatures 7.2.7.4 Br286H2O is the only bromine hydrate, and the implications of this result 7.2.7.5 Gas hydrates with charged frameworks (ionic clathrate hydrates) 7.2.8 Peralkylonium hydrates and related structures 7.2.8.1 Introduction 7.2.8.2 Structures based on the CS-I structure 7.2.8.3 Structures based on the CS-II structure 7.2.8.4 Structures based on the HS-II structure 7.2.8.5 Structures based on the HS-I structure and its superstructure SHS-I 7.2.8.6 Structures based on the OS-I structure 7.2.8.7 Structures based on the TS-I structure 7.2.8.8 The effectiveness of the alkyl substituents in forming hydrates 7.2.9 Varieties of structures formed by a particular guest 7.2.10 The alkylamine hydrates 7.2.11 Structures without pentagonal dodecahedra (some with charged frameworks)
xiii
323 323 331
333 345 346 346 347
348 348 353 355 360 363 370 370 372 379 381 383 383 383 384 385 385 385 387 387 389 389 389 392
xiv
CONT ENTS
7.3 Hosts with a combination of directional bonds and van der Waals interactions 7.3.1 Phenol (and related compounds) as hosts 7.3.1.1 Phenol 7.3.1.2 Guayacanin as host 7.3.2 Dianin’s compound (4-p-hydroxyphenyl-2,2,4trimethylchroman) and related compounds as hosts 7.4 Van der Waals linked hosts 7.4.1 Tetraphenylene as host 7.5 Hexahosts and related compounds 7.6 Conclusions and a perspective view References 8 Inclusion complexes formed by versatile hosts 8.1 Introduction 8.2 Tri-o-thymotide and analogs as hosts 8.2.1 Crystallography of tri-o-thymotide and its complexes 8.2.1.1 The trigonal clathrate inclusion complexes 8.2.1.2 The hexagonal tunnel inclusion complexes 8.2.1.3 Tunnel inclusion complexes with organometallic guests 8.2.1.4 Crossed tunnel triclinic inclusion complexes 8.2.1.5 Miscellaneous inclusion complexes 8.2.2 Analogs of tri-o-thymotide 8.3 Trimesic acid and analogs as hosts 8.3.1 Introduction 8.3.2 Host–guest tunnel inclusion complexes based on noncatenated unary hexagonal networks 8.3.2.1 TMA as host 8.3.2.2 Two coordination complexes as potential hosts 8.3.3 Host–guest tunnel inclusion complexes based on catenated hexagonal unary networks 8.3.4 Host–guest clathrate interstitial inclusion complexes based on catenated hexagonal unary networks 8.3.5 Generalization of the concept of ‘‘interruption’’ to give binary networks 8.3.5.1 TMAH2O networks 8.3.5.2 Catenated neutral binary networks 8.3.5.3 Ionic binary networks 8.3.6 Hydrogen-bonded TMA binary complexes 8.4 The Heilbron complexes 8.5 Gossypol and its inclusion complexes 8.6 Tris(5-acetyl-3-thienyl)methane (TATM) as host 8.6.1 Introduction 8.6.2 Chemistry of TATM and its inclusion complexes 8.6.3 Conformations taken up by the TATM molecule in the various crystallographic structure types 8.6.4 Crystallography of the inclusion complexes of TATM
396 396 396 398 399 406 406 408 410 411 421 423 423 423 425 429 431 433 435 436 437 437 437 437 443 446 448 448 449 450 450 452 456 459 469 469 469 470 474
CONTENTS
8.6.5 Formation of the inclusion complexes 8.6.6 Dynamics of guest molecules in the complexes 8.6.7 Other examples 8.6.8 Summary 8.7 (5,10,15,20)-Tetraphenylmetalloporphyrins and complexes 8.7.1 Introduction 8.7.2 Crystallography of (5,10,15,20)tetraphenylmetalloporphyrin coordination complexes 8.7.2.1 Introduction 8.7.2.2 The four-coordinate coordination complexes 8.7.2.3 The five-coordinate coordination complexes 8.7.2.4 The six-coordinate coordination complexes 8.7.3 Crystallography of (5,10,15,20)tetraphenylmetalloporphyrin inclusion complexes 8.7.3.1 Crystallography of four-coordinate (5,10,15,20)tetraphenylmetalloporphyrin inclusion complexes 8.7.3.2 Crystallography of five-coordinate (5,10,15,20)tetraphenylmetalloporphyrin inclusion complexes 8.7.3.3 Crystallography of six-coordinate (5,10,15,20)tetraphenylmetalloporphyrin inclusion complexes 8.7.4 Comparative crystallography of the (5,10,15,20)tetraphenylmetalloporphyrin coordination and inclusion complexes 8.7.5 Questions of nomenclature and description 8.7.6 Can ‘‘sponge’’ structures be inferred from the chemical nature of the second component? References 9 Intercalation complexes 9.1 Introduction 9.2 Intercalation complexes of graphite (GICs) 9.2.1 Introduction 9.2.2 Alkali metals as guests (preparation at atmospheric pressure) 9.2.3 Alkali metals as guests (preparation at high pressures) 9.2.4 Alkaline earth and lanthanide metals as guests 9.2.5 Halogens as guests 9.2.6 Uses, actual and potential, of GICs 9.2.7 Summary for GICs 9.3 Intercalation complexes of inorganic hosts 9.3.1 Introduction 9.3.2 2H--TaS2 as host 9.3.3 Zirconium phosphates and phosphonates as hosts
xv
476 477 477 477 478 478 480 480 481 483 486 493
493
500
502
505 506 507 508 515 516 517 517 520 532 533 533 539 539 540 540 540 546
CONT ENTS
xvi
9.4 Concluding summary References
PART IV
552 552
PACKING COMPLEXES
Introduction to Part IV 10 Packing complexes 10.1 Introduction 10.2 Components are isomers of various types 10.3 The (stereoisomeric) components are enantiomers 10.3.1 Background 10.3.2 Types of binary phase diagram found with enantiomers as components 10.3.3 Formation of conglomerates 10.3.4 Comparing the stability of enantiomorphs and racemic compounds 10.3.5 The structural chemistry of systems with isolatable enantiomers 10.3.5.1 Components are rigid molecules 10.3.5.2 Complications due to conformational isomerism of component molecules 10.3.6 Enantiomorphs and racemic compounds of nonisolatable conformers 10.3.7 Racemic enantiomorphs 10.3.8 Solid solutions of enantiomers 10.4 The (stereoisomeric) components are diastereoisomers 10.4.1 Background 10.4.2 Diastereoisomers as components 10.4.3 Conformers as components 10.4.4 Cis-trans isomers as components 10.4.5 Cocrystallization of tautomers 10.4.6 Interallogon complexes 10.5 Components are positional isomers 10.6 Components have different chemical compositions 10.6.1 Substitutional solid solutions 10.6.1.1 Conditions for formation 10.6.1.2 The information desired 10.6.2 Systems with complete (or a wide range of ) mutual miscibility 10.6.3 Some binary phase diagrams involving phases (primary and intermediate) with extensive composition ranges 10.6.3.1 Dibenzyl – trans-stilbene 10.6.3.2 Diphenyl sulphoxide–diphenyl sulfone 10.6.3.3 p-Dibromobenzene–p-diiodobenzene 10.6.3.4 p-Dibromobenzene–p-chloronitrobenzene
563 564 565 566 566 568 569 571 574 574 577 582 584 585 590 590 590 592 597 600 603 605 605 605 605 607 608 615 615 615 617 617
CONTENTS
10.6.3.5 Benzoic acid–p-fluorobenzoic acid 10.6.3.6 1,2-4,5-Tetrachlorobenzene–1,2-4,5tetrabromobenzene 10.6.4 Evidence for nonrandom substitution in primary solid solutions 10.6.4.1 (trans-Stilbene)–diphenylmercury and tolane–diphenylmercury 10.6.4.2 2,3-Dimethylnaphthalene–anthracene 10.6.5 Inhomogeneity of some solid solution crystals 10.7 Interblock solid solubility 10.8 Primary interstitial solid solutions 10.9 Ordered packing complexes 10.9.1 Metal coordination complexes 10.9.1.1 Components of different composition and configuration but in the same oxidation state 10.9.1.2 Components with different compositions, configurations and oxidation states 10.9.1.3 The components are oligomers 10.9.2 Complexes in which a moiety plays more than one structural role 10.9.3 Miscellaneous packing complexes 10.9.3.1 Packing complexes without specific interactions 10.9.3.2 Packing complexes with incipient specific interactions 10.9.3.3 Packing complexes of the fullerenes C60-Ih, 6 C70-d5h and C76 References Book index
xvii
617 617 618 618 620 620 622 622 623 623 624 624 624 625 628 628 634 634 667 [1]
Volume 2 PART V
MOLECULAR COMPOUNDS WITH LOCALIZED INTERACTIONS
Introduction to Part V 11 Donor–acceptor molecular compounds (essentially localized interactions) 11.1 Introduction and classification
683 684
Part 1: Pure acceptors 11.2 n-Donors and s-acceptors 11.2.1 N, O, S containing ligands as donors and AgI salts as acceptors
687 687
CONT ENTS
xviii
11.3
11.4 11.5 11.6
11.7
11.8
n-Donors and *-acceptors 11.3.1 N, O, S or Se containing donors and dihalogens or halogenated molecules as acceptors 11.3.2 S containing molecules as donors and iodine molecules as acceptors (the polyiodines) 11.3.3. Physical measurements on molecular compounds of the type discussed above 11.3.4 Halogenated molecules as donors and dihalogens as acceptors 11.3.5 Self-complexes – N, O, S, Se to halogen interactions in one-component systems n-Donors and p-acceptors 11.4.1 N, O or S containing ligands as donors and Group VA metal halides as acceptors n-Donors and *-acceptors -Donors and *-acceptors 11.6.1 Aromatic molecules as donors and dihalogens as acceptors 11.6.2 Aromatic molecules as donors and polyhalogenated methanes as acceptors -Donors and p-acceptors 11.7.1 Aluminum tribromide as an acceptor 11.7.2 Miscellany-mainly MX3 (M ¼ As, Sb; X ¼ Cl, Br) as acceptors and aromatic molecules as donors -Donors and (localized) *-acceptors
688 688 706 708 712 713 717 717 723 727 727 731 733 733 734 736
Part 2: Self-interacting acceptors 11.9
n-Donors and s-acceptors 11.9.1 N, O, S containing ligands as donors and AgI salts as acceptors 11.9.2 N, O, S containing ligands as donors and HgX2 (X ¼ Cl, Br, I) as acceptors 11.10 n-Donors and p-acceptors 11.10.1 N, O, S containing ligands as donors and MX3 (M ¼ As, Sb; X ¼ Cl, I) as acceptors 11.11 -Donors and s-acceptors 11.11.1 Aromatics as donors and Ag(I) salts as acceptors; also {benzene CuAlCl4} 11.11.2 Olefins as donors and Ag(I) salts as acceptors 11.11.3 Some general structural principles emerging from Sections 11.11.1 and 11.11.2 11.11.4 Acetylides as donors and Ag(I) salts as acceptors 11.11.5 Acetylides as donors and Cu(I) salts as acceptors 11.11.6 Aromatics as donors and Hg(II) salts as acceptors 11.12 -Donors and p-acceptors n n n
737 737 739 761 761 764 765 777 783 784 784 786 788
CONTENTS
11.12.1 Aromatics as donors and MX3 (M ¼ Sb, Bi; X ¼ Cl, Br) as acceptors 11.12.2 Aromatics as donors and np3 metal ions (GaI, InI, TlI, SnII, PbII) as acceptors 11.13 Summary References 12 Hydrogen bonded molecular complexes and compounds 12.1 Introductory survey 12.1.1 Introduction 12.1.2 The characteristic features of hydrogen bonds 12.2 Application of graph theory to the description of hydrogen bond patterns 12.3 Statistics of hydrogen bond patterns 12.3.1 Methodology 12.3.2 Statistics of ring formation 12.4 Appendage structures (one component forms a hydrogen bonded framework, to which the second component is appended by hydrogen bonding) 12.5 Alternating framework structures (the components, in hydrogen-bonded alternating array, form a mixed framework) 12.5.1 Zero-dimensional frameworks 12.5.1.1 Structures with discrete pairs (A–B) of components 12.5.1.2 Structures with discrete triples (B–A–B) of components 12.5.1.3 Larger discrete groupings of components 12.5.2 One-dimensional frameworks (linear chains of alternating components) 12.5.2.1 Component A has two donor groups and the single acceptor of component B can accept two hydrogen bonds 12.5.2.2 Component A has two hydrogen bond donor groups and component B two acceptor groups 12.5.2.3 Both components have both hydrogen bond donor and acceptor functions 12.5.3 Two-dimensional frameworks (layer arrangements of alternating components) 12.5.4 Three-dimensional frameworks (arrangements of alternating components in space) 12.5.5 Accounting for formation of a molecular compound 12.6 Crystal engineering with hydrogen bonds 12.7 Charged or neutral moieties – when is there hydrogen transfer between the components? References
xix
788 822 836 836 851 852 852 853 861 862 863 864
864
867 867 867 877 881 884
885 889 893 896 901 904 905 908 911
CONT ENTS
xx
PART VI
MOLECULAR COMPOUNDS WITH DELOCALIZED INTERACTIONS
Introduction to Part VI 13 Charge transfer molecular compounds with delocalized –* interactions – introduction and general survey 13.1 Introduction and historical development 13.2 Classification 13.2.1 General considerations 13.2.2 Intramolecular -compounds and self-complexes 13.3 Chemical nature of donors and acceptors 13.3.1 Introduction 13.3.2 Donors 13.3.3 Acceptors 13.3.4 Quasi-acceptors 13.3.5 Ionization potentials of donors and electron affinities of acceptors 13.3.6 Determination of degree of charge transfer 13.4 Binary and quasi-binary donor–acceptor systems 13.4.1 Phase diagrams 13.4.2 Component ratios in binary donor–acceptor systems 13.5 Ternary -molecular compounds References 14 Layered molecules with intra-molecular donor–acceptor interactions 14.1 Introduction 14.2 Molecules of the paracyclophane type 14.2.1 Molecules derived from [n.n]paracyclophanes 14.2.2 Systems related to [n.n]paracyclophanes 14.2.3 Multi-layered systems 14.3 Molecules of the metaparacyclophane type 14.4 Molecules of the metacyclophane type 14.5 Some other systems 14.6 Concluding summary References 15 Crystal chemistry of mixed-stack –* molecular compounds 15.1 Introduction 15.2 Nonstacked structures containing structural groups of limited size 15.3 The crystallochemical families found for 1:1 –* molecular compounds
925 926 927 927 930 932 932 933 935 939 940 944 948 948 952 953 954
959 959 961 961 972 974 976 980 984 986 986 989 990 993 994
CONTENTS
15.4 Packing arrangements in n : m –* molecular compounds 15.5 Some special features of packing arrangements in –* molecular compounds 15.5.1 Crystals where one of the components is also found in interstitial positions 15.5.2 Noncentrosymmetric crystals of -molecular compounds 15.5.3 Acceptors based on polynitrofluorene 15.5.4 Resolution of helicenes by formation of diastereoisomeric charge transfer molecular compounds with enantiomeric acceptors 15.6 Structurally important interactions between polarizable and polar groups 15.7 Mixed-stack crystals with both charge transfer and hydrogen bonding interactions 15.7.1 The quinhydrones as a crystallochemical family 15.7.2 Molecular compounds of the flavins 15.7.3 Other crystals with both charge transfer and hydrogen bonding interactions 15.8 Mixed-stack crystals with both delocalized and localized charge transfer interactions 15.9 Donors and acceptors with special chemical features 15.9.1 Fluorinated aromatics as quasi-acceptors 15.9.2 1,3,5,7-tetramethyluric acid (TMU) as quasi-acceptor 15.9.3 Acceptor is a metal coordination complex 15.9.4 Donor is a metal coordination complex 15.9.5 Donors based on phenazine 15.10 Mixed-stack donor–acceptor molecular compounds with ionized ground states 15.10.1 Mixed-stack closed-shell charge transfer salts 15.10.2 Ion-radical salts 15.11 Isomeric (polymorphic) molecular compounds 15.11.1 Type 1 – isomerism due to different types of interaction without change of moiety structure 15.11.2 Type 2 – isomerism due to electron transfer 15.11.3 Type 3 – isomerism due to proton transfer or to –* electron transfer 15.11.4 Isomerism stabilized by both charge (–*) and proton transfer (CPT compounds) 15.12 Self-complexes 15.13 Conclusions 15.13.1 Structural variety in –* molecular compounds 15.13.2 How should the packing arrangements in –* molecular compounds be described?
xxi
1001 1005 1005 1007 1009
1010 1011 1013 1013 1022 1026 1030 1032 1032 1040 1040 1042 1044 1047 1047 1048 1052 1052 1054 1055 1058 1059 1064 1064 1065
CONT ENTS
xxii
15.13.3 Structural consequences of –* interactions References (Note. The components in the ground states of these molecular compounds are taken to be neutral unless explicitly stated otherwise). 16 Crystal (structural) physics of mixed stack –* molecular compounds 16.1 Introduction 16.2 Thermodynamic parameters 16.3 Spectroscopic measurements on the excited state 16.4 Crystals with disorder ) order transformations on cooling – modern treatments of second order phase transitions 16.4.1 General introduction 16.4.2 The Ehrenfest order of a phase transition 16.4.3 Landau theory of phase transitions 16.4.4 The critical exponents 16.4.5 The permitted symmetries of a low symmetry phase derived from a particular high symmetry phase 16.4.6 Temperature dependence of the order parameter 16.4.7 Pressure dependence of the critical temperature for ordering 16.5 Thermodynamic, structural and kinetic investigations of various systems showing second order transitions on cooling 16.5.1 The crystal structure of {Pyrene PMDA}(PYRPMA) and evidence for an order , disorder phase transition at 160K 16.5.2 The crystal structure of {Naphthalene TCNB} and evidence for an order , disorder phase transition at 72K 16.5.3 The crystal structure of {Anthracene TCNB} and evidence for an order , disorder phase transition at 213K 16.5.4 Other examples of second order transitions 16.6 Crystals with first order transformations on cooling 16.6.1 {Cycl[3.2.2]azine TNB} 16.6.2 Other examples 16.7 Physical nature of the disordered phase 16.8 Transformation to quasi-plastic phase(s) on heating 16.9 Transformation of the ground state from neutral ) ionic on cooling and/or application of pressure (NI transitions) 16.9.1 Introduction 16.9.2 {TTF chloranil} 16.9.3 {DMTTF chloranil} 16.9.4 Other examples 16.9.5 Concluding summary References
1066 1068
1081 1082 1083 1086 1090 1090 1091 1092 1093 1094 1096 1097 1097
n n n
1097
n n n
1105
n n n
n n n
n n n
n n n
1115 1119 1120 1120 1122 1122 1126 1128 1128 1129 1137 1139 1142 1142
CONTENTS
17 Segregated stack -molecular complexes 17.1 Introduction 17.2 Chemistry of donors and acceptors that participate in segregated stacks 17.2.1 Introduction 17.2.2 Donors 17.2.3 Acceptors 17.2.4 Preparation of crystals 17.3 Structures of cation-radical salts 17.3.1 Introduction 17.3.2 Cations are polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons 17.3.3 TTF and related compounds as cations 17.3.4 TMPD salts containing -dimerized cation radicals 17.4 Structures of TCNQ anion-radical salts 17.4.1 Mutual arrangements of approximately plane-parallel TCNQ moieties 17.4.2 Structures with stacks of limited length 17.4.3 TCNQ anion radical salts in which the cations are metals 17.4.4 Stacked structures with –e average charge on the TCNQ moieties 17.4.5 Stacked structures with –0.8e average charge on the TCNQ moieties 17.4.6 Stacked structures with –2/3e average charge on the TCNQ moieties 17.4.7 Stacked structures with –0.5e average charge on the TCNQ moieties 17.4.8 Stacked structures with –0.4e average charge on the TCNQ moieties 17.4.9 Systems studied over a wide range of temperatures 17.4.10 Conclusions drawn from a survey of structural results for TCNQ anion radical salts 17.5 Other anion-radical salts 17.5.1 Alkali-metal chloranil salts 17.5.2 M(dmit)2 and M(mnt)2 as anion radicals in various guises 17.6 Structures of cation-radical anion-radical salts 17.6.1 General survey 17.6.2 Cation : anion ratio 1 : 1; monad stacks 17.6.3 Cation : anion ratio 1 : 1; diad stacks 17.6.4 Cation : anion ratio 2 : 1 or 1 : 2; monad stacks 17.6.5 Cation : anion ratio 2 : 1 or 1 : 2; diad stacks 17.7 Electron density studies of segregated stack complexes
xxiii
1147 1148 1151 1151 1152 1157 1161 1162 1162 1163 1167 1175 1177 1177 1180 1187 1189 1192 1193 1196 1202 1205 1211 1214 1214 1215 1220 1220 1220 1227 1229 1230 1232
xxiv
CONT ENTS
17.8
Theoretical studies of some segregated stack complexes 17.9 Studies of {[TTF][TCNQ]} and some related materials 17.10 Concluding summary References Appendix Book index
1234 1235 1252 1253 1267 [1]
Acknowledgements The author wishes to thank the following for permission to reproduce published material. Academic Press: Inclusion Compounds. Figs. 6.39, 6.65, 7.1, 7.24(a), 7.24(b), 7.38, 7.39, 7.40, 7.42, 7.43, 9.19, 9.22. Non-Stoichiometric Compounds: Fig. 8.4. American Association for the Advancement of Science Science. Fig. 10.24. American Chemical Society Accts. Chem. Res. Figs. 7.36, 10.15. Biochemistry. Figs. 5.7, 5.8, 5.9, 5.12. Chemistry of Materials: Figs. 6.3(b), 6.14, 6.20, 6.30, 8.6. Cryst. Growth & Design: Figs. 12.35, 12.36. Inorg. Chem. Figs. 9.18, 9.21, 10.19, 11.41, 11.58, 11.59, 11.71, 11.100, 11.119, 15.27, 17.38. J. Am. Chem. Soc. Figs. 3.4(a), (b), 3.8, 3.9, 3.17, 3.19, 3.25, 3.26, 3.28, 4.4, 4.15, 6.55, 6.60, 6.61, 6.62, 6.69, 7.5, 7.6, 7.32, 8.8, 8.53, 10.13, 11.16, 11.31, 11.43, 11.60, 11.63, 11.116, 12.6, 12.12, 12.14, 12.16, 12.18, 12.21, 12.27, 15.13, 15.32, 15.33, 16.43, 16.44, 17.9, 17.15, 17.19, 17.23, 17.42, 17.53. J. Chem. Educ. Figs. 4.1, 7.29. J. Med. Chem. Fig. 5.21. J. Org. Chem. Figs. 11.3, 11.72. J. Phys. Chem. Figs. 6.19, 6.26, 6.27, 6.28, 7.26, 17.22(b), 17.37. Organometallics: Figs.11.113, 11.121. American Crystallographic Association Fig. 3.13. American Institute of Physics J. Chem. Phys. Figs. 6.17, 6.25, 7.7, 7.15, 7.34, 7.35, 7.37, 15.29, 16.5, 16.20, 16.23. Sov. Phys. Crystallogr. Figs. 10.20, 10.22 American Physical Society Phys. Rev. Letts.: Figs. 13.4, 16.36, 17.46. Phys. Rev.: Fig. 16.38. Elsevier Adv. Organometall. Chem.: Fig. 9.6. CALPHAD: Fig. 10.21. Carbohydrate Research: Figs. 4.5(a), 4.11(a).
xxvi
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Carbon: Figs. 9.10, 9.11. Chem. Phys. Letts: Fig. 6.11. Comp. Rend. Acad. Sci. (Paris), Ser. C,: Fig. 17.18. Coord. Chem. Revs. Fig. 10.40. FEBS Letters: Fig. 5.23. Inorg. Chim. Acta: Figs. 11.46, 11.53. J. Chromatography: Fig. 15.9. J. Mol. Biol. Figs. 5.6, 5.11, 5.17, 5.18, 5.20. J. Organometall. Chem.: Figs. 10.34, 11.120. J. Phys. Chem. Solids: Figs. 6.13, 17.52. Mater. Sci.: Fig. 16.14. Sol. State Comm. Fig. 16.39. Synth. Mets. Fig. 16.42. International Union of Crystallography Acta Crystallographica, Figs. 6.31, 6.51, 10.14, 10.16, 11.1, 11.15. Acta Crystallographica, B. Figs. 4.3, 4.16, 4.17, 4.19, 6.1, 6.3(a), 6.8, 6.50, 6.53, 6.58, 7.2, 7.25, 7.31, 7.41,10.7,10.8, 10.26, 11.40, 12.2, 12.5, 12.9, 12.10, 12.30, 12.31, 15.2, 15.3, 15.5, 15.7, 15.15, 15.18, 15.21, 16.4, 16.9, 16.10, 16.11, 16.12, 16.13, 16.22, 16.32, 17.17, 17.20, 17.22(a), 17.24, 17.27, 17.29, 17.32, 17.33, 17.43(a), 17.48, 17.49. Acta Crystallographica, C. Figs. 6.18, 8.7, 8.31, 8.37, 8.38, 10.4, 10.17, 10.17A, 10.32(a), 10.32(b), 12.24, 12.28, 15.6, 17.6, 17.7. Acta Crystallographica, D. Fig. 5.16. IUCr Monographs on Crystallography: Figs. 15.34, 15.35. J. Appl. Cryst. Fig. 7.27. Kluwer Academic Publishers J. Incl. Phenom. Figs. 3.11, 6.43, 7.13, 7.14, 7.24, 9.13. Macmillan Publishers Nature. Figs. 5.15, 7.16, 10.33. National Academy of Sciences U. S. A.: Proceedings. Figs. 5.13, 5.14, 5.22. NRC Research Press (Canada) Can. J. Chem.: Figs. 11.45, 11.52. Oldenbourg Verlag Z. Kristallogr. Fig. 6.21. Pergamon Comprehensive Supramolecular Chemistry. Figs. 4.2, 6.59 (Vol. 6). Tetrahedron Letters: Figs. 3.12, 3.22. Tetrahedron: Fig. 12.13. Plenum Water–a comprehensive treatise. Fig. 7.30. J. Cryst. Spectroscop. Res.: Fig. 10.31.
A C KN O W L E D G E M E NT S
xxvii
Professor M. Le Cointe. Ph.D. thesis, University of Rennes I: Figs. 16.35, 16.37, 16.40. RIA-Novosti, Paris La Recherche: Fig. 7.18 (I am grateful to Professor Rose Marx, Saclay, for her help in obtaining this figure). Springer: Monatshefte Chem.: Fig. 10.10. Springer Series in Materials Science No 18: Figs. 9.7, 9.8, 9.9. Topics in Current Chemistry. Figs. 6.41, 12.26. Taylor and Francis: Adv. Phys.: Fig. 9.2. Contemp. Phys.: Fig. 17.57. Mol. Cryst. Liq. Cryst. Figs. 6.12, 6.22, 6.23, 6.33, 10.2, 10.23, 11.25, 15.30, 16.29, 17.3. The Chemical Society of Japan Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. Figs. 4.5(b), 4.6(a), (b), 4.7, 4.9, 4.10, 4.13, 4.18, 11.42, 13.9, 13.10, 13.11, 16.33, 16.34, 17.10, 17.16. Chem. Letts. Figs. 7.17, 10.46, 14.6, 17.44. The Physical Society of Japan J. Phys. Soc. Jpn.: Figs. 13.7, 17.54, 17.55. The Royal Society of Chemistry Chemical Communications: Figs. 3.3, 3.4(c), 3.5, 3.16, 3.23, 6.47, 6.48, 8.21, 8.22, 10.30, 10.35, 10.41, 12.19. Chem. Soc. Revs.: Fig. 9.17. Chemistry in Britain, Fig. 1.2. J. Chem. Soc. A: Fig. 11.49. J. Chem. Soc. B: Figs. 6.67, 6.68. JCS Dalton. Figs. 8.15, 8.16, 8.17, 8.18, 9.23, 9.24, 11.12, 11.33, 11.39, 11.101, 17.11, 17.36. JCS Perkin II: Figs. 3.15, 6.40, 6.42, 7.3, 12.15, 15.14. JCS Trans. Farad. Soc. Figs. 6.4, 6.5, 6.6. J. Mater. Chem.: Figs. 17.39, 17.40. New J. Chem.: Fig. 12.3. The Royal Society of London: Proceedings, Ser. A: Figs. 8.19, 9.12, 15.4, 16.8, 16.30, 16.31. Verlag Chemie-Wiley Angew. Chem. Intl. Ed.: Figs. 3.27, 5.3, 10.36, 11.115, 14.2. Chem. Ber. Figs. 10.28, 11.35, 14.8, 14.12, 14.13, 14,14, 16.45. Chemistry Eur. J. Fig. 6.56. Prog. Inorg. Chem. Figs. 7.21, 7.23.
xxviii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Verlag Helvetica Chimica Acta: Helvetica Chimica Acta. Figs. 5.19, 7.4, 10.11. Verlag der Zeitschrift fu¨r Naturforschung Z. Naturforsch. (b): Figs. 11.110, 11.114, 11.118. Worth Publishers New York Lehninger Biochemistry, 2nd edition. Figs. 5.1, 5.2. Various Acta Chem. Scand.: Figs. 11.7, 11.8, 11.9, 11.30. Acta Chem. Scand A: Figs. 11.10. 11.11. J. Phys. D: Fig. 9.1. J. Struct. Chem. USSR: Figs. 6.2, 7.33. Liebigs Annalen: Fig. 15.20. Molecular Complexes: Fig. 13.8. Phys. Chem. Low-dimens. Materials: Fig. 9.15. I am grateful to Dr Moshe Kapon and Dr Mark Botoshansky for help of many kinds and to the staff of the Chemistry-Biology Library at Technion for their assistance in tracking down material.
Part I Some preliminaries
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 1 Structural principles in the classification of binary adducts
The author . . . thereby extended an old chemical tradition, of calling complexes all those compounds which are in some way odd or unusual, and which do not readily fit the line-for-every-electron-pair representations that are the hallmark of our language. Very often the term complex persists even after the nature of the species has been elucidated – thus we have the complex inorganic ions, the -complexes, s-complexes, charge-transfer complexes, organo-metallic complexes, clathrate complexes, hydrogen-bonded complexes, and so on. W. J. le Noble (1974). Highlights of Organic Chemistry, An Advanced Textbook, Dekker New York Chapter 23, ‘‘Complexes’’, pp. 841–842
Summary: When the properties of the individual components are largely conserved in the primary or intermediate crystalline phases of a two-component (A and B) system, then these phases are called ‘‘binary adducts’’, which is a more formal name for what are usually called ‘‘molecular compounds and complexes.’’ The various types of binary adduct are classified in terms of those interactions between the components that determine the component arrangement in the crystal. Thus A . . . A interactions dominate in inclusion complexes, A . . . A and B . . . B interactions are equally important in segregated-stack charge transfer complexes, all interactions are of roughly equal importance in packing complexes, and A . . . B interactions dominate in molecular compounds. This classification is compared to other complementary schemes.
1.1 Introduction 1.2 Structural classification of binary adducts 1.2.1 General considerations 1.2.2 Molecular complexes 1.2.2.1 Inclusion complexes 1.2.2.2 Moieties within molecules 1.2.2.3 Frameworks with guest participation and/or linkage 1.2.2.4 Segregated stack charge transfer complexes 1.2.2.5 Packing complexes 1.2.3 Molecular compounds 1.3 Other classifications 1.4 How many binary adducts are there? 1.5 Organic and inorganic supramolecular chemistry References
4 5 5 6 6 9 9 9 10 10 10 11 12 12
4
1.1
PRINCIPLES IN THE CLASSIFICATION OF BINARY ADDUCTS
Introduction
The section at 1 bar through the pressure–temperature–composition (P–T–x) phase diagram of a binary (two component) system shows the conditions of stability of the various crystalline phases of composition AxBy. These phases may be primary solid solutions of B in A (or conversely), or AxBy compounds, with congruent or incongruent melting points, with crystal structures different from those of A and/or B. We define a ‘‘binary adduct’’ as a crystalline two-component phase, relatively easily separated into its components, in which the properties of the individual components are very largely conserved. In this definition, which is based on some comments of Ketelaar (1958), the words ‘‘binary,’’ ‘‘component’’ and ‘‘phase’’ have the meanings of the Phase Rule (Ricci, 1966). The phrase concerning the separation of the components refers to the status of intertwined species (see Chapter 3). The collective term ‘‘binary adduct’’ refers to all those chemical species which are the subject matter of this book. We shall be faithful to this definition after our own fashion for there are occasions when the advantages of a broader treatment justify some straying from the strait and narrow paths of excessive conformity. An immediate consequence of the conservation of the properties of the individual components is that there cannot be covalent bonding between the two components, although ionic and ion–dipole interactions are allowed. The binary adduct may have the same crystal structure as one of the components, when there will be solid solution of the minor (guest) component B in the major (host) component A, or it may have a different crystal structure and thus appear as a compound in the A–B phase diagram. This is an important distinction because the solid solution crystal maintains its structure on decomposition of the adduct into its components, while the phase diagram compound decomposes into separate crystals of one (when one component is a gas or liquid under ambient conditions) or both components. Harris (1997) has suggested that the two types of host should be called ‘‘hard’’ (solid solution) and ‘‘soft’’ (phase diagram compound) respectively. We prefer to keep the connection to well-established phase-diagram principles rather than adapt terms already used in other areas of chemistry. Not all phase diagram compounds are binary adducts in our present sense; for example, the phase KF2Al(C2H5)3 is composed of Kþ cations and [(C2H5)3Al-F-Al(C2H5)3] anions (Allegro and Perego, 1963), the properties of the individual components clearly not being ‘‘very largely conserved.’’ In contrast, the neutral molecule–salt complex [(C2H5)4NþBr]2(succinimide)] (Powell and Wait, 1958) could be included because the moieties1 of the individual components appear also in the complex, although with altered mutual arrangement. The principles governing binary adducts can be carried over without much change to ternary and higher adducts and some of these will also be discussed. There is a considerable resemblance between the phase diagrams and thermodynamics of molecular systems on the one hand and those of metal alloy systems on the other; in both instances the properties of the individual components are largely conserved. This is generally not so in purely inorganic systems, where rearrangement of the ions can occur. But the resemblance between molecular and metallic systems hardly extends to structural features and modes of interaction between the components. Metal atoms are 1 One dictionary defines moiety as a portion of indefinite size; we use it as a convenient term for molecule and/or ion.
STRUCTURAL CLASSIFICATION OF BINARY ADDUCTS
5
approximately spherical while molecules usually have complicated shapes; indeed formation of some binary adducts can be ascribed to particular features of these complicated shapes. Interactions between metal atoms in alloys and intermetallic compounds are approximately isotropic and, at the simplest level, are ascribed to delocalisation of one (or a few) electrons per atom over the volume of the substance; interactions between the entities in binary molecular adducts are usually highly anisotropic and directional and are ascribed, to different extents in different adducts, to hydrogen bonding, to localized or delocalized charge transfer, to ionic and ion–dipole forces and to the ubiquitous dispersion forces, possibly all acting in combination. It will be immediately apparent that we have here formalized the definition of ‘‘molecular complexes and compounds,’’ restricting ourselves to the crystalline state. The interactions between the components of binary adducts that occur in solution (or in the vapor phase) are traditionally considered to be of a transient, contact nature which can affect physical properties but are difficult to define in structural terms. However, over the past thirty years, there have been two important developments, one of which concerns us directly and immediately while the second is likely to be of great importance in the future. The first of these developments is the synthesis of an important new group of adducts in which the propinquity of the components persists in solution; the crown ethers represent the first examples of this type of adduct. We use the overall term ‘‘moieties within molecules’’ to define this group. The second concerns the explosive improvement in techniques of studying the structures of adducts formed in the gas phase. Earlier work had employed spectroscopic methods to infer structures of gas-phase adducts (Tamres and Strong, 1979) but the great advance has come from the use of supersonic beams to cool the adducts formed to very low effective temperatures. Most of this work has so far concerned adducts which exist only in the gas phase (Hutson, 1990) but this will surely be extended to adducts which also exist in the crystalline state, thus permitting inference of the importance of aggregation on structure and properties.
1.2 Structural classification of binary adducts 1.2.1 General considerations The primary level of our classification (Herbstein, 1993) is based on the relative structural importance of the interactions between the components A and B in determining the component arrangement in crystalline AxBy. The various hierarchies possible for A . . . A, B . . . B and A . . . B interactions can be completely listed as shown in Table 1.1. We distinguish between molecular compounds and complexes and define ‘‘molecular compounds’’ as those adducts in which A . . . B interactions determine the structure. The rest are ‘‘molecular complexes,’’ which are further subdivided into a number of groups. We distinguish three different types of molecular complex, in all of which the structural pattern in the crystal is not determined primarily by interactions between the two different components, although these may play some role. Le Noble (see above) has already drawn attention to the ambiguous way in which the term ‘‘complex’’ (from the Latin complectere, to entwine, braid, embrace) is used in chemical nomenclature. A material is first called a complex when its structure is not known, but the term generally persists even
6
PRINCIPLES IN THE CLASSIFICATION OF BINARY ADDUCTS
Table 1.1. The classification of binary adducts into molecular complexes and molecular compounds Molecular complexes A . . . A dominant A . . . A dominant and A . . . B important A . . . A and B . . . B dominant A . . . A, A . . . B and B . . . B about equally important Molecular compounds A . . . B dominant
Inclusion complexes Inclusion complexes Segregated stack complexes Packing complexes Localized interactions Delocalized interactions
after the structure has been clarified. Thus we have such disparate usages as complex inorganic ions, s-complexes, -complexes, organometallic complexes and so on. The word ‘‘complex’’ is so entrenched in the chemical literature that it seems impossible to banish it, but we shall try to use it only in a clearly defined sense. The second level of our classification refers to the type of interaction denoted by the three dots linking the two components in the A . . . A, etc. notation. This interaction can be due to hydrogen bonding, van der Waals forces, ion and ion–dipole interactions, localized or delocalized charge transfer interactions and perhaps other interactions yet to be identified; we shall use the symbol in later chapters to indicate localized or delocalized charge transfer interactions. Such a classification scheme is summarized in Fig. 1.1. Our classification is based on structural features rather than on the chemical nature of the components, because a particular chemical entity can form adducts of different kinds, dependent on the nature of the second component. Urea provides a simple example; hydrogen bonded urea molecules form spirals enclosing paraffin hydrocarbons (and other types of guest) in typical channel2 inclusion complexes, and can also hydrogen bond to other molecules to form hydrogen bonded molecular compounds, such as hyperol (urea . . . H2O2; structure by X-ray diffraction at 295K (Lu, Hughes and Giguere, 1941) and by neutron diffraction at 85K (Fritchie and McMullan, 1981)). The metal coordination complexes of urea are not binary adducts in our present sense. We shall now discuss the various categories in Fig. 1.1, proceeding from top to bottom. n n n
1.2.2 1.2.2.1
Molecular complexes Inclusion complexes
We use the term ‘‘inclusion complex’’ in a similar but somewhat broader sense than has been customary in the past; parenthetically we remark that Powell (1984) used both ‘‘inclusion’’ and ‘‘enclosure’’ in his comprehensive introduction to the multivolume series Inclusion Compounds, but we have resisted the temptation to introduce yet another term into this already confused field. Thus ‘‘inclusion complexes’’ are all those crystalline twocomponent systems in which A . . . A interactions dominate and host (A) and guest (B) 2 Although the word ‘‘channel’’ has wide usage in the literature, ‘‘tunnel’’ is pictorially a far more appropriate term. The latter is beginning to replace the former in the recent literature, and we dare to join this trend.
STRUCTURAL CLASSIFICATION OF BINARY ADDUCTS
7
Binary adducts Moieties within molecules Zeolites
A…A dominant
Inclusion complexes
Clathrates Channel inclusion complexes Lamellar complexes
A … A dominant, A … B important A … A and B … B equally important
Frameworks with guest participation and/or linkage Segregated stack complexes Packing complexes
A…B dominant
Localized interactions
A … A, B … B and A … B all about equally important
H-bonded interactions
Molecular compounds
Charge transfer interactions
Delocalized interactions
Charge transfer interactions
Fig. 1.1. Classification scheme for binary adducts, based on the hierarchy of A . . . A, etc. interactions in determining the arrangement of the A and B components in the crystalline adduct. Some second level aspects are also shown.
components can be distinguished without ambiguity; A . . . B and B . . . B interactions are of lesser importance. We denote the inclusion complexes by the symbolism {host[guest]} or {A[B]}. The terms ‘‘host’’ and ‘‘guest’’ have been used in a wider sense by Cram (see below) but we prefer to apply them only to inclusion complexes. These complexes are further subdivided on the basis of the dimensionality of the inclusion into clathrate (cage), tunnel and intercalation (layer) inclusion complexes. The dimensionality is neatly encapsulated in a diagram first used in an article in Scientific American (Brown, 1962) and now used as the logo of the Journal of Inclusion Phenomena and Molecular Recognition (Davies, Kemula, Powell and Smith, 1983); we use the diagram as presented by Harris (1993). Most inclusion complexes have frameworks in which the host molecules are linked to one another by hydrogen bonds or van der Waals forces. More recent work has shown that it is convenient to add here hosts where primary chemical bonds play an important role.
8
PRINCIPLES IN THE CLASSIFICATION OF BINARY ADDUCTS
This occurs in one of two ways; either the host is an individual molecule that encloses a guest, (host plus guest) then crystallizing as an entity to form the crystal, or the host framework constitutes the whole crystal, the guests being enclosed in interstices. We call the first of these types ‘‘moieties within molecules’’ and discuss them below. Zeolites (Barrer, 1983), in which specific host–guest interactions can be important, are an example of the second type. Usually, however, host–guest and guest–guest interactions are of the van der Waals type; guest–guest interactions are often neglected. The term ‘‘clathrate’’ was introduced by Powell (1948), who defined such complexes as a ‘‘structural combination of two substances which remain associated not through strong attraction between them but because strong mutual binding of the molecules of one sort only makes possible the firm enclosure of the other (‘clathratus’ – enclosed or protected by cross bars of a grating).’’ Zeolites also fit this definition. The guest molecules in clathrate complexes are enclosed by the framework of host molecules and are localized at or about points within the framework – thus these complexes can be assigned a dimensionality of ‘‘zero’’. In the tunnel inclusion complexes the guests are enclosed in (essentially) one-dimensional tunnels in the matrix of host molecules. There are inclusion complexes that cannot be assigned unambiguously between the tunnel and clathrate types because of the occurrence of constrictions in the tunnels. In the intercalation complexes the guest molecules are located between layers of host molecules, and hence are considered ‘‘two-dimensional’’; the complexes of graphite and alkali metals (Dresselhaus and Dresselhaus, 1981) are typical examples. The discerning reader will already have noticed that the graphite intercalation complexes, with covalent bonding within the quasi-infinite graphite sheets, constitute two-dimensional analogs to the zeolites with their quasi-infinite three-dimensional frameworks.
Isolated cages
Linear nonintersecting tunnels (channels)
Interconnected cages
Two-dimensional interlamellar regions
Intersecting tunnels
Fig. 1.2. Some typical topologies of inclusion cavities in crystalline host solids. The smallest dimension of each of these cavities is comparable with molecular dimensions. (Reproduced with permission from Harris (1993)).
STRUCTURAL CLASSIFICATION OF BINARY ADDUCTS
9
1.2.2.2 Moieties within molecules A very important development during the past twenty years, recognised by the award of the 1987 Nobel Prize in Chemistry to Cram (1988), Lehn (1988) and Pedersen (1988), is the purposeful synthesis of molecules designed to enclose (or include) other molecules or ions in which the propinquity of the components persists in solution; the crown ethers (Pedersen, 1988) represent the first examples of this type of adduct and the fullerenes with appropriate guests perhaps the most recent (Shinohara, Sato, Ohkoohchi, Ando, Kodama, Shida, Kato and Saito, 1992). We use the overall term ‘‘moieties within molecules’’ to define this group; in the formal terms of our classification these are molecular complexes because the A . . . A (host–host) interactions predominate, even though here the interactions are by covalent bonding. An additional emphasis stresses the relationship between ‘‘moieties within molecules’’ and ‘‘host–guest inclusion complexes’’ in the spirit of the development of inclusion chemistry, which has been broadly defined as incorporating ‘‘all those chemical species, whether they be continuous solids or discrete molecules, having voids or cavities of molecular dimension, and all of the related chemical association and other reaction chemistry. Implicit in the name is the capability of including some other molecular entities within the cavities’’ (Ramprasad, Lin, Goldsby and Busch, 1988). This point of view is recognized by inserting ‘‘Moieties within molecules’’ and ‘‘Zeolites’’ in Fig. 1.1 together with the now-classical clathrate and tunnel inclusion complexes as parts of the broader category of ‘‘Inclusion Complexes.’’ As the guests are not entirely contained within the hosts in the crystal structures of some members of the ‘‘moieties within molecules’’ group (e.g. in some cyclodextrin inclusion complexes), classification can sometimes be ambiguous. 1.2.2.3 Frameworks with guest participation and/or linkage Atoms or ions of guest moieties forming parts of frameworks, or linked to the framework by hydrogen bonding, were first discovered by Jeffrey (1984) and coworkers when analyzing the crystal structures of the peralkylonium salt hydrates and alkylamine hydrates; the latter were called semiclathrate hydrates. A simpler example is provided by trimesic acid.dimethyl sulphoxide (Herbstein, Kapon and Wasserman 1978), where the oxygen atoms of the dimethyl sulphoxide ‘‘guests’’ are parts of the walls of tunnels formed by the hydrogen bonded trimesic acid molecules, while the methyl groups lie within the tunnels. In these examples A . . . A interactions dominate but A . . . B interactions are important. 1.2.2.4 Segregated stack charge transfer complexes The members of the next group have A . . . A and B . . . B interactions of approximately equal importance, with smaller A . . . B interactions. The only complexes known which fit into this category have the components segregated into separate stacks. Although small in number, the group is of great interest and importance because most of its (organic) members have high electrical conductivities, with tetrathiafulvalene: tetracyanoquinodimethane (TTF–TCNQ) as the most famous example (crystal structure by Kistenmacher, Phillips and Cowan (1974)). There are many chemical and physical resemblances to the (delocalized) –* mixed-stack donor–acceptor molecular
10
PRINCIPLES IN THE CLASSIFICATION OF BINARY ADDUCTS
compounds (see below), and the two groups will be considered together in Part VI (as is usually done), but with retention of the designation ‘‘complexes.’’ 1.2.2.5 Packing complexes Proceeding among the hierarchical possibilities, the next group has A . . . A, A . . . B and B . . . B interactions all of approximately equal importance; in other words, no one of these interactions is dominant in determining the structure. These are known as ‘packing complexes’. A typical example is sym-tetrabromobenzene:hexabromobenzene (Gafner and Herbstein, 1964). 1.2.3
Molecular compounds
Finally we arrive at the ‘‘molecular compounds.’’ Here the dominant A . . . B interactions can be localized in nature (Hassel, 1972), as in the acetone – bromine charge transfer compound where there is an n–s* interaction (Hassel and Strømme, 1972), or as in the hydrogen-bonded purine and pyrimidine bases in the DNA double helix (Watson and Crick, 1953). Alternatively the A . . . B interaction can be delocalized, as in the –* interactions found in anthracene picric acid (Fritzsche, 1858; Herbstein and Kaftory, 1976). n n n
1.3
Other classifications
Many proposals have been made for the classification and nomenclature of molecular compounds and complexes, and there is much confusion, overlapping and redundancy. We note here other approaches that complement the scheme set out above. It is perhaps too much to hope that any classification and nomenclature scheme will be able to match the complexity of reality and undoubtedly many binary adducts will be found to straddle classificatory boundaries. The terms host, guest, complex and their binding forces were defined in 1977 by Cram and coworkers in the following way: ‘‘Complexes are composed of two or more molecules or ions held together in unique structural relationships by electrostatic forces other than those of full covalent bonds . . . molecular complexes are usually held together by hydrogen bonding, by ion pairing, by -acid to -base interactions, by metal to ligand binding, by van der Waals attractive forces, by solvent reorganizing, and by partially made and broken covalent bonds (transition states) . . . high structural organization is usually produced only through multiple binding sites . . . a highly structured molecular complex is composed of at least one host and one guest component . . . a host–guest relationship involves a complementary stereoelectronic arrangement of binding sites in host and guest . . . the host component is defined as an organic molecule or ion whose bonding sites converge in the complex . . . the guest component is defined as any molecule or ion whose binding sites diverge in the complex (Kyba, Helgeson, Madan, Gokel, Tarnowski, Moore and Cram, 1977).’’ To which was added later: ‘‘In these definitions, hosts are synthetic counterparts of the receptor sites of biological chemistry, and guests the counterparts of substrates, inhibitors or co-factors.’’ The principle of complementarity
HOW MANY BINARY ADDUCTS ARE THERE?
11
was also emphasised: [in order] ‘‘to complex, hosts must have binding sites which cooperatively contact and attract binding sites of guests without generating strong nonbonded repulsions.’’ This very broad definition was directed towards complexes in solution but can well be extended towards crystalline complexes. Lehn (1988) has introduced the term ‘‘supramolecular chemistry . . . defined as ‘chemistry beyond the molecule’ bearing on the organized entities of higher complexity that result from the association of two or more chemical species held together by intermolecular forces.’’ The partners of a supramolecular species are called ‘‘molecular receptor’’ and ‘‘substrate,’’ in analogy to Cram’s use of ‘‘host’’ and ‘‘guest.’’ The complementarity of a receptor for a given substrate, leading to molecular recognition, depends on energetic (electronic) as well as geometrical features, and extends the celebrated ‘‘lock and key’’ steric fit concept enunciated by Emil Fischer (1894).3 A rather elaborate proposal for the classification and nomenclature of ‘‘host–guest-type compounds’’ has been made by Weber and Josel (1983), based on criteria of host–guest type and interaction, the topology of the host–guest aggregate and the number of components in the aggregate. The nomenclature used by Weber and Josel is rather different from our present proposal; for example the urea-n-paraffin tunnel inclusion complex is a tubulato-clathrate and the graphite-potassium lamellar intercalate is an intercalatoclathrate. Although we have preferred not to adopt the complete Weber–Josel proposal, we have found it convenient to use some of its parts.
1.4 How many binary adducts are there? What proportion of reported crystal structures can be classified as ‘binary (or higher) adducts’? The available statistics are limited to organic (ORG) and metalloorganic (MORG) structures, and refer to the inclusion of water and solvent molecules in such structures (Go¨rbitz and Hersleth, 2000). Using the October, 1998 release of the Cambridge Structural Database, they found that 8% of the 77 000 (nonduplicated) entries for organic compounds could be classed as ‘hydrates’ and 7% as ‘solvates’; the corresponding figures for the 91 000 metalloorganic structures were 10.5 and 17%. Clathrates and other molecular compounds and complexes were excluded from the survey, which thus somewhat underestimates the proportion of structures relevant in the context of this book. The proportion of published structures containing co-crystallized organic molecules has risen from very low values before 1950 to 11% (ORG) and 23% (MORG) for the three year period 1995–1997. Which molecule is the most prolific former of adducts? The principal contender appears to be sulfathiazole, which forms more than 100 solvates, plus many related two-component systems (Bingham et al., 2001). Two broad classes have been identified – inclusion phases, in which the main function of the guest is cavity filling, and co-crystals in which the partner molecule forms an essential part of the hydrogen-bonded framework. Some 60 crystals structures have been reported. Cyclotetramethylene tetranitramine (HMX) (George et al., 1965; Selig, 1982) has also been reported to form more than 100 solvates. 3 ‘‘The restricted action of the enzymes on glucosides may therefore be explained by the assumption that only in the case of similar geometrical structure can the molecules so closely approach each other as to initiate a chemical action. To use a picture I would like to say that enzyme and glucoside have to fit together like lock and key in order to exert a chemical effect on each other.’’ (quoted from Lichtenthaler, 1994).
12
1.5
PRINCIPLES IN THE CLASSIFICATION OF BINARY ADDUCTS
Organic and inorganic supramolecular chemistry
In this book we have placed more emphasis on organic than on inorganic aspects of our subject, although the latter have not been ignored. Some redress of this imbalance can be obtained from the review article of Mu¨ller, Reuter and Dillinger (1995) that, presumably deliberately, has been placed adjacent to Desiraju’s (1995) classic article on Crystal Engineering. As in most of modern chemistry, the distinction between ‘‘organic’’ and ‘‘inorganic’’ will undoubtedly become more and more blurred in the future. References Allegra, G. and Perego, G. (1963). Acta Cryst., 16, 185–190. Barrer, R. M. (1983). J. Incl. Phenom., 1, 105–123. Bingham, A. L., Hughes, D. S., Hursthouse, M. B., Lancaster, R. W., Taverner, S. and Threfall, T. L. (2001). Chem. Commun., pp. 603–604. Brown, J. F., Jr. (1962). Scientific American, 207, pp. 82–92 (July, 1962). Cram, D. J. (1988). J. Incl. Phenom., 6, 397–413 (Nobel Lecture). Davies, J. E. D., Kemula, W., Powell, H. M. and Smith, N. O. (1983). J. Incl. Phenom., 1, 3–44. Desiraju, G. R. (1995). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 34, 2311–2327. Dresselhaus, M. S. and Dresselhaus, G. (1981). Adv. Phys., 30, 139–326. Fischer, E. (1894). Ber. Deutsch. Chem. Gesell., 27, 2985–2993. Fritchie, C. J., Jr. and McMullan, R. K. (1981). Acta Cryst., B37, 1086–1091. Fritzsche, J. v. (1858). J. prakt. Chem., 73, 282–292. Gafner, G. and Herbstein, F. H. (1964). J. Chem. Soc., pp. 5290–5302. George, R. S., Cady, H. H., Rogers, R. N. and Rohwer, R. K. (1965). Ind. Eng. Chem. Prod. Res. Dev. 4, 209–214. Go¨rbitz, C. H. and Hersleth, H.-P. (2000). Acta Cryst., B56, 526–534. Harris, K. D. M. (1993). Chem. Brit., 29, 132–136. Harris, K. D. M. (1997). Chem. Soc. Rev., 26, 279–290. Hassel, O. (1972). ‘‘Structural aspects of interatomic charge-transfer bonding.’’ Nobel Lectures in Chemistry 1963–1970, Elsevier, Amsterdam (1969 Nobel Lecture published in 1972). Hassel, O. and Strømme, K. O. (1959). Acta Chem. Scand., 13, 275–280. Herbstein, F. H. (1993). Acta Chim. Hung. Models in Chemistry, 130, 377–387. Herbstein, F. H. and Kaftory, M. (1976). Acta Cryst., B32, 387–396. Herbstein, F. H., Kapon, M. and Wasserman, S. (1978). Acta Cryst., B34, 1613–1617. Hutson, J. M. (1990). Ann. Rev. Phys. Chem., 41, 123–154. Jeffrey, G. A. (1984). ‘‘Hydrate inclusion compounds,’’ in Inclusion Compounds, edited by J. L. Atwood, J. E. D. Davies and D. D. MacNicol, Academic Press, London, Vol. 1, pp. 135–190. Ketelaar, J. A. A. (1958). Chemical Constitution. Elsevier, Amsterdam, p. 363. Kistenmacher, T. A., Phillips, T. E. and Cowan, D. O. (1974). Acta Cryst., B30, 763–768. Kyba, E. P., Helgeson, H. C., Madan, K., Gokel, G. W., Tarnowski, T. L., Moore, S. S. and Cram, D. J. (1977). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 99, 2564–2571. Lehn, J. M. (1988). J. Incl. Phenom., 6, 351–396 (Nobel Lecture). Lichtenthaler, F. W. (1994). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 33, 2364–2374. Lu, C.-S., Hughes, E. W. and Giguere, P. A. (1941). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 63, 1507–1513. Mu¨ller, A., Reuter, H. and Dillinger, S. (1995). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 34, 2328–2361. Pedersen, C. J. (1988). J. Incl. Phenom., 6, 337–350 (Nobel Lecture). Powell, H. M. (1948). J. Chem. Soc., pp. 61–73.
REFERENCES
13
Powell, H. M. (1984), ‘‘Introduction,’’ in Inclusion Compounds, edited by J. L. Atwood, J. E. D. Davies, and D. D. MacNicol, Academic Press, London, Vol. 1, pp. 1–28. Powell, H. M. and Wait, E. (1958). J. Chem. Soc., pp. 1866–1872. Ramprasad, D., Lin, W.-K., Goldsby, K. A. and Busch, D. H. (1988). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 110, 1480–1487. Ricci, J. E. (1966). The Phase Rule and Heterogenous Equilibrium. Dover, New York (1951, reprinted 1966), Chapter 1. Selig, W. (1982). Propell. Explos., 7, 70–77. Shinohara, H., Sato, H., Ohkoohchi, M., Ando, Y., Kodama, T., Shida, T., Kato, T. and Saito, Y. (1992). Nature, 357, 52–54. Tamres, M. L. and Strong, R. L. (1979). Mol. Assoc., 2, 331–456. Watson, J. D. and Crick, F. H. C. (1953). Nature, 171, 737–738. Weber, E. and Josel, H.-P. (1983). J. Incl. Phenom., 1, 79–85.
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 2 Historical outline
Fir’d at first sight with what the Muse imparts, In fearless youth we tempt the heights of Arts, While from the bounded level of our mind, Short views we take, nor see the lengths behind; But more advanc’d, behold with strange surprize New distant scenes of endless science rise! So pleas’d at first the tow’ring Alps we try, Mount o’er the vales, and seem to tread the sky, Th’ eternal snows appear already past, And the first clouds and mountains seem the last: But, those attain’d, we tremble to survey The growing labours of the lengthened way, Th’ increasing prospect tries our wand’ring eyes, Hills peep o’er hills, and Alps on Alps arise. Alexander Pope: An Essay on Criticism
Summary: The history of our subject goes back to the beginning of the nineteenth century, although the compounds concerned remained curiosities, outside the main stream of the development of chemistry, until the first structures were determined by X-ray diffraction in the 1940s. We are now immersed in an explosion of interest and application, ranging from condensed-matter physics to structural biology.
Having defined our terms in Chapter 1, we can now sketch out the historical background. The first molecular complexes to be reported had illustrious parentages. The hydrate of sulphur dioxide appears to have been prepared in 1777–1778 by Joseph Priestley, while chlorine hydrate was reported in the following terms by Sir Humphry Davy in 1811 ‘it is generally stated in chemical books, that oxymuriatic gas [the original name of chlorine – F.H.H.] is capable of being condensed and crystallized at low temperature; I have found by several experiments that this is not the case. The solution of oxymuriatic gas in water freezes more readily than pure water, but the pure gas dried by muriate of lime undergoes no change whatever, at a temperature of 40 below 0 of FAHRENHEIT. The mistake seems to have arisen from exposure of the gas to cold in bottles containing moisture’ (Davy, 1811).
The complex was assigned the composition 10H2OCl2 by Michael Faraday (1823); the currently preferred formulation is about 66H2OCl2, the exact composition depending on conditions of preparation (see Chapter 7).
16
HISTORICAL OUTLINE
The first molecular compound to be reported was quinhydrone (hydroquinone: p-benzoquinone) by Wo¨hler (1844), who noted its unexpected colour. Continuation of these studies led Wo¨hler (1848) to the preparation of the first clathrates, with quinol (hydroquinone) as host and H2S as guest; the reported compositions of 4(quinol)H2S and 3(quinol)H2S are close to modern values. The SO2 clathrate was reported 10 years later (Clemm, 1859); Mylius (1886), who prepared the CO, HCN and formic acid clathrates somewhat later, suggested possible enclosure of guests by quinol without chemical combination. The picrates of benzene, naphthalene and anthracene were also prepared in the middle of the nineteenth century (Fritzsche, 1858), at a time when the atomic weight of carbon was still taken as 6. The first tunnel (channel) inclusion complex was perhaps the 2(thiourea)diethyl oxalate complex reported by Nencki (1874), although this would appear to require checking. There followed many disparate observations, unrelated to main currents of contemporary organic chemistry and perplexing from a structural point of view. The classical period of development culminated with the publication of the second edition of Paul Pfeiffer’s Organische Moleku¨lverbindungen (1927, First Edition 1921), which remains a mine of useful factual information although some of the structural ideas are fanciful in terms of current knowledge (Fig. 2.1). The modern period was inaugurated by the application of X-ray diffraction methods to the determination of key crystal structures. The first of these appears to have been Phenochinon OH
O
H
H
H
H5C6O H
H H
H H5C6O
H H OC6H6
OC6H5
H O
OH
Enolformen
H
O
Ketoformen
H
O H
H
H
H
OH H
H
O H
H
H
HO
H
H
H
H
O H
O
H O Chinhydron
H
Bei dem heutigen Stand der Chromophortheorie bleibt aber – entgegen der Ansicht Posners – die tiefe Farbe der Chinhydrone bei dieser Formulierung ganz ra¨tselhaft; auch die leichte Spaltbarkeit der Chinhydrone in ihre Komponenten, schon durch sog. indifferente Lo¨sungsmittel, la¨ßt sich schwer mit der Posnerschen Theorie in Einklang bringen. Fig. 2.1. Pfeiffer’s representation of Posner’s (1904) suggestion for the structures of phenoquinone and quinhydrone. From the short quotation attached, it is clear that Pfeiffer was not an enthusiastic supporter of the proposal. The diagram has been copied from p. 276 of Pfeiffer’s book (1927).
HIS T OR I C AL OUT L IN E
17
{{[(CH3)3AsPdBr2]2}-[dioxane]} (Wells, 1938), which is a tunnel inclusion complex. However, the real breakthrough came during and soon after the end of the Second World War when H. M. Powell and coworkers at Oxford reported the structures of p-iodoaniline 1,3,5-trinitrobenzene (Powell, Huse and Cooke, 1943), and {{3(quinol)}[CH3OH]} (Palin and Powell, 1945; cf. Davies, 1998), representative of charge transfer molecular compounds and clathrate complexes respectively. Other important structural elucidations of about the same time were those of gas hydrates (Stackelberg, 1949a,b; Pauling and Marsh, 1952), urea and thiourea tunnel inclusion complexes (Smith, 1950; Hermann and Lenne, 1952), and n–s* (localized) charge transfer compounds of halogens with donors containing oxygen or nitrogen (Hassel and Rømming, 1962). The important theoretical studies of charge transfer compounds by Mulliken (1952a,b) were complemented by thermodynamic and statistical-mechanical studies of clathrates (van der Waals and Plateeuw, 1959). The current period is distinguished by a number of themes. Firstly, there is extensive activity in the area of crystal structure analysis, which is the major experimental tool. The adducts range in size and complexity from the combination of small organic molecules found in hyperol (urea:hydrogen peroxide) (Lu, Hughes and Giguere, 1941) to complexes of large biomolecules, with the complex of lysozyme and tri(N-acetylglucosamine) (Phillips, 1966) as an early example now far surpassed in complexity. Secondly, there is considerable study of interactions between components using a wide range of spectroscopic techniques. Thirdly, there has been renewed interest in physical properties, especially electrical conductivity, and in theoretical explanations for the various types of physical behaviour that have been found. A major gap in current knowledge, in regard to both theory and experimental data, relates to the energetics and thermodynamics of the interactions between the components. One must also note that an important new direction of investigation has developed with the explosive growth of the branch of host-guest chemistry which we have called ‘‘moieties within molecules,’’ the moieties being ions as well as molecules. As we noted in Chapter 1, the importance of these substances rests on their occurrence in solution as well as in the crystalline state. Perhaps the first examples to be studied structurally as well as chemically were the cyclodextrin inclusion complexes (Cramer, 1954), which can enclose many different types of moiety within the hydrophobic interior of the doughnut-shaped molecule. The antibiotics such as enniatin constitute a somewhat similar group. These two sorts of host compound are natural in origin; the first purely synthetic examples, the macrocyclic ‘‘crown’’ ethers, were reported by Pedersen (1967) and since then this has become one of the most rapidly growing areas in the general field of inclusion complexes. The crown ethers were followed by the cryptands and many other variations on this theme and there seem to be few limits to the ingenuity of the organic chemist in the tailoring of particular hosts for the inclusion of specific guests. There have been many applications in analytical chemistry, synthetic organic chemistry and in biochemistry. The analogies to the behaviour of many biomolecules is striking and the phrases ‘‘molecular recognition’’ and ‘‘supramolecular chemistry’’ have become established in the literature (Lehn, 1995; Desiraju, 1995; Nangia and Desiraju, 1998). An important potential contribution of a study of crystalline supramolecular systems (‘‘binary adducts,’’ in a more old-fashioned language) is to provide detailed structural information, both static and dynamic, leading to an understanding of the interactions which are fundamental to molecular recognition, and n n n
18
HISTORICAL OUTLINE
thus hopefully, to the enhancement of our capabilities as molecular engineers, designing desired structures from first principles. The ability to form binary adducts is not limited to small molecules and considerable progress has been made in preparing adducts of large biomolecules, an early example of which has already been mentioned (Phillips, 1966). An important application is in the area of design of drugs that have a capability of recognising receptors in proteins and DNA. Both small-molecule model compounds and biomolecule complexes are subjects of active study. Biomolecule complexes of various kinds are hardly mentioned in this book – their variety and importance demand a book in its own right. However, there is no reason to believe that the interactions involved are fundamentally different from those described here. Highlights in the historical development of the scientific study of binary adducts are summarized in Table 2.1 (references are given in the body of the text). The task of this book is to weave these varied themes into whole cloth in as coherent and cohesive a manner as possible. Table 2.1. Some highlights in the study of binary adducts. The dates are only approximate and have generally been chosen to indicate publication of a particularly significant paper or book, or to mark some special event. Usually the contributions of the authors cited (and their coworkers) extend over many years Approximate date
Author(s)
Achievement
1777–8 1811 1823 1841 1849 1858
Joseph Priestley Humphry Davy Michael Faraday C. Schaftha¨ult F. Wo¨hler J. von Fritzsche
1891
A. Villiers
1893 1897
H. W. Pickering A. W. Hofmann
1916
H. Wieland and H. Sorge
1926 1927
J. Martinet and L. Bornand P. Pfeiffer
1930
E. Hertel
1938
A. F. Wells
1940
M. F. Bengen
First observation of a gas hydrate (of SO2). Observation of the gas hydrate of Cl2. Analysis of the gas hydrate of Cl2. Preparation of graphite intercalates. Preparation of quinol clathrate of H2S. Preparation of first mixed-stack donor–acceptor compounds (benzene, naphthalene and anthracene with picric acid). Preparation of cyclodextrin inclusion complexes. Preparation of alkylamine hydrates. Preparation of nickel ammonium cyanide inclusion complex of benzene. Preparation of choleic acid inclusion complexes. Qualitative donor–acceptor theory of –* molecular compounds. Second edition of Organische Moleku¨lverbindungen. Early crystallographic studies of molecular compounds. Crystal structure of {{[(CH3)3AsPdBr2]2} [dioxane]} tunnel inclusion complex. Preparation of urea-hydrocarbon tunnel inclusion complexes.
19
REFERENCES
Table 2.1. (Continued) Approximate date
Author(s)
Achievement
1943
H. M. Powell
1945
H. M. Powell
1949 1950–2
1964
G. Briegleb A. E. Smith; C. Herrman and H.-U. Lenne M. von Stackelberg; L. Pauling and R. E. Marsh; W. F. Claussen. G. A. Jeffery, Yu. A. Dyadin, and their schools J. D. Watson and F. H. C. Crick F. Cramer W. Saenger; K. Harata J. H. van der Waals and J. C. Plateeuw L. Mandelcorn (editor)
Crystal structure of p-iodoaniline 1,3,5trinitrobenzene. Crystal structure of quinol clathrate of CH3OH. Spectroscopic studies of binary adducts. Crystal structures of urea-hydrocarbon tunnel inclusion complexes. Crystal structures of gas hydrates.
1966
R. S. Mulliken
1966 1969
D. C. Phillips O. Hassel
1983
J. L. Atwood and J. E. D. Davies (editors) D. J. Cram, J.-M. Lehn, C. J. Pedersen. J.-M. Lehn (chair, editorial board)
1951
1953 1954
1959
1987 1996
n n n
Further development of crystal chemistry of gas hydrates and related complexes. Structure of DNA (purine/pyrimidine hydrogen-bonded molecular compound). Publication of Einschlussverbindungen. Crystallography of cyclodextrin complexes. Statistical mechanics of clathrates. Publication of Non-Stoichiometric Compounds. Nobel Prize in Chemistry (inter alia theory of charge transfer interactions). Crystallography of lysozyme complexes. Nobel Prize in Chemistry (crystal structures of localized donor–acceptor molecular compounds). First issue of J. Inclus. Phenom. Nobel Prize in Chemistry (development of supramolecular chemistry). Publication of Comprehensive Supramolecular Chemistry in 11 volumes.
References Clemm, A. (1859). Ann. Chem., 110, 345–349. Cramer, F. (1954). Einschlussverbindungen. Springer, Heidelberg. Davies, J. E. D. (1998). J. Incl. Phenom. and Mol. Recogn. Chem., 32, 499–504. Davy, H. (1811). Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc., 101, 1–35, (see p. 30). Desiraju. G. R. (1995). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 34, 2311–2327. Faraday, M. (1823). Quart. J. Sci. Lit. and Arts, 15, 71–74. Fritzsche, J. von, (1858). J. prakt. Chem., 73, 282–292.
20
HISTORICAL OUTLINE
Hassel, O. and Rømming, C. (1962). Quart. Rev., 16, 1–18. Hermann, C. and Lenne, H.-U. (1952). Naturwiss., 39, 234–235. Lehn, J.-M. (1995). Supramolecular Chemistry – Concepts and Perspectives, VCH, Weinheim. Lu, C.-S., Hughes, E. W. and Giguere, P. A. (1941). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 63, 1507–1513. Mulliken, R. S. (1952a). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 72, 600–608. Mulliken, R. S. (1952b). J. Phys. Chem., 56, 801–822. Mylius, F. (1886). Chem. Ber., 19, 999–1009. Nangia, A. and Desiraju, G. R. (1998). Acta Cryst., A54, 934–944. Nencki, M. (1874). Ber. Deut. Chem. Gesell., 7, 779–780. Palin, D. E. and Powell, H. M. (1945). Nature, 156, 334–335. Pauling, L. and Marsh, R. E. (1952). Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci., 38, 112–118. Pedersen, C. J. (1967). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 89, 7017–7036. Pfeiffer, P. (1927). Organische Moleku¨lverbindungen. Enke, Stuttgart, 2nd Edition. Phillips, D. C. (1966). Scientific American, pp. 78–90 (November, 1966). Powell, H. M., Huse, G. and Cooke, P. W. (1943). J. Chem. Soc., pp. 153–157. Smith, A. E. (1950). J. Chem. Phys., 18, 150–151. Stackelberg, M. von, (1949a). Naturwiss., 36, 327–333. Stackelberg, M. von, (1949b). Naturwiss., 36, 359–362. Waals, J. H. van der, and Platteeuw, J. C. (1959). Adv. Chem. Phys., 51, 1–59. Wells, A. F. (1938). Proc. Roy. Soc. Lond. A, 167, 169–189. Wo¨hler, F. (1844). Ann. Chem., 51, 145–163. Wo¨hler, F. (1849). Ann. Chem., 69, 294–300.
Part II Moieties within molecules
This page intentionally left blank
Introduction to Part II Moieties within molecules
Chemistry is going to move into bigger molecules and new types of reactions. And the chemist is going to have to pay far more attention than he or she has done in the past to noncovalent bonding. Hitherto the chemist has grown accustomed to hydrogen bonding. But other forces will have to be considered, forces that make these big molecules adopt certain shapes . . . I think there is great hope for the future in work going on in the inclusion of small molecules in big ones. Lord Alexander Todd Chemical and Engineering News October, 1980
The unifying theme of Part II is that the binary adducts considered exist in solution as well as in the crystalline state – the guest moieties are enclosed within the confines of the host molecule and held in tight enough embrace to maintain the integrity of the combination despite the potentially disintegrative buffeting forces of the solvent molecules. Therefore our choice of title – moieties within molecules. Alternative terms, meeting with growing acceptance, are ‘‘supermolecule’’ (noun) and ‘‘supramolecular’’ (adjective). The difference between ‘‘supermolecules’’ and the ‘‘molecular compounds and complexes’’ considered in the later sections of this book is that the latter have at most a transient, if any, existence in solution. The supermolecules can have a variety of chemical forms, with the most useful distinction being made between two major geometrical groups – the rings and the threedimensional cages. However, even rings tend to wrap around guests as much as possible. Guests are chosen to match the geometrical shapes of the cavities of the hosts thus imparting selectivity to the systems. This is one aspect of another theme of currently growing importance – that of molecular recognition, which also finds its expression in the matched hydrogen-bonded systems discussed especially in Chapter 12. Perhaps 90% of the binary adducts described in this book have been obtained by chance rather than deliberate design, and this includes those dealt with in Chapters 4 and 5. Not so for the subjects of Chapter 3 – crown ethers, cryptands and other types of enclosure hosts – for these are adducts where the host molecule has been designed to fulfill the function of enclosing within its boundaries a guest of a particular kind. However, the first steps in this direction taken by C. J. Pedersen in the 1960s were not designed but serendipitous, with chance favoring his prepared mind. Pedersen, investigating the effects of bi- and multidentate phenolic ligands on the catalytic properties of the vanadyl group VO, obtained a small quantity (0.4%) of an unknown material which trapped sodium ions. His conclusion – ‘‘thus did I discover dibenzo-18-crown-6, the first crown ether and the first neutral synthetic compound capable of complexing the alkali metal cations’’ – has an almost Biblical ring of triumph (Pedersen, 1988). This discovery sparked off many
24
MOIETIES WIT HIN MOLECULES
investigations, some deepening our knowledge and understanding of the crown ethers, and others, especially those of Lehn (1988) and Cram (1988), moving off in new directions. Formation of complexes is most efficient if the host has a built-in conformation adapted to enclosure of the guest, but this is not a sine qua non for there are many examples showing considerable differences between the conformation of the neat host and that taken up in the complex. Thermodynamic measurements (generally carried out by NMR techniques) on the host–guest combination in solution provide fundamental information about the stability of the complexes formed, and the energetics of the formation and break-up of the host–guest combinations. Both rings and three-dimensional cages have been synthesized, and the guest species include metallic cations, a few anions, organic cations and anions and neutral molecules. We devote most attention to the latter. An informative survey of synthetic supramolecular chemistry has been given by Fyfe and Stoddart (1997). In Chapter 4 (Cyclodextrins and their complexes) we consider a particular group of host molecules – the , and g cyclodextrins – which have toroidal forms of three different sizes; these are natural products obtained from the degradation of starch. Because the host does not entirely enclose the guest, these complexes are less stable in solution than the enclosure species considered in Chapter 3 and we pay more attention to the varieties of arrangement found in the crystals. Cyclodextrins have found widespread use in the chemical and pharmaceutical industries. In Chapter 5 (DNA and its complexes) we consider a limited group of the inclusion complexes formed by another type of host molecule obtained from a natural product – DNA. The complexes of DNA with other biological molecules such as proteins constitute an area of research which seems at present to have limits neither to its size nor its importance but is too large for discussion in a single chapter of this book. For this reason we have limited ourselves to considering complexes of ‘‘small’’ molecules with DNA oligomers of limited length and various compositions. These complexes are essentially of two different kinds – those formed by intercalation of guests between the base pairs of the double helix, and those formed by inclusion of the guests in the small or large grooves on the periphery of the helical DNA fragment. Maverick and Cram (1996) have made some interesting remarks on the role of crystal structure analysis in the prosecution of the type of research described in these chapters (and elsewhere). We quote (with permission) an abbreviated version: ‘‘The . . . analyses presented many problems . . . the solvents used for isolation and purification . . . tend to disorder in the crystals . . . Almost without exception, crystals of carcerands, empty or complexed, were weak diffracters, resulting in very poor data-to-parameter ratios. Often the symmetry of the host cavity and . . . of the guest were incompatible, resulting in inaccuracies just where the greatest accuracy is required. For these reasons, the structures presented . . . are crude by some crystallographic standards.’’ The reader will find a comparison with the even more severe situation described in Chapter 9 (Intercalation Complexes) instructive. Nevertheless, ‘‘Crystal structure determinations . . . were of great importance [because] (i) . . . they were the . . . final criteria for our success in synthesizing these new types of complexes. (ii) [they] provided a wealth of information about preferred conformations . . . [suggesting] explanations for some of the observed binding phenomena . . . (vi) Crystal structures provide a simple, direct and independent means of convincing yourself and skeptics that ‘you know what you are doing.’’’ Few changes are required to make these remarks applicable to many analogous situations described in this book.
REFERENCES
25
Most of the molecules considered in this section have been described in a review volume edited by Semlyen (1997).
References Cram, D. J. (1988). J. Incl. Phenom., 6, 397–413. Fyfe, M. C. T. and Stoddart, J. F. (1997). Accts. Chem. Res., 30, 393–401. Lehn, J.-M. (1988). J. Incl. Phenom., 6, 351–396. Maverick, E. Cram, D. J. (1996). ‘‘Carcerands and Hemicarcerands: Hosts that imprison molecular guests,’’ in Comprehensive Supramolecular Chemistry, edited by J. L. Atwood, J. E. D. Davies, D. D. MacNicol and F. Vo¨gtle, Pergamon, Oxford, Vol. 2, pp. 367–418. Pedersen, C. J. (1988). J. Incl. Phenom., 6, 337–350. Semlyen, J. A. (Editor) (1997). Large Ring Molecules, Wiley, Bognor Regis.
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 3 The enclosure species – crown ethers, cryptands and related molecules – as hosts
‘‘A gentle guest, a willing host, Affection deeply planted – It’s strange how those we miss the most Are those we take for granted.’’ Sir John Betjeman ‘‘The Hon. Sec.’’ (1986)
Summary: Crown ethers are prototype examples of host molecules of the ring type where small ring sizes interact with metallic cations to form widely studied ion-molecule complexes, dealt with here only in passing, while the larger ring sizes interact with neutral molecules and organic cations of various types to form intramolecular inclusion complexes, rotaxanes and even catenanes. Although formally two-dimensional rings, the actual conformations taken up by the larger crown ethers are more complicated and include the formation of molecular clefts. The overall shapes of threedimensional cage molecules are approximately ellipsoidal; the cages are closed to lesser or greater extents, thus permitting ingress and egress of guest molecules tailored in size and shape to match the available portals and cavities. Thermodynamic measurements in solution, principally using NMR methods, provide insight into the energetics of these processes. Although considerable ingenuity has been expended in the synthesis of the hosts, these are more easily obtainable than might be imagined at first thought, and this holds great promise for their widespread use in the future. A crowning achievement of this type of host–guest chemistry is the synthesis of stable but reactive cyclobutadiene incarcerated within the cavity of a hemicarcerand, followed by the analogous preparation of o-benzyne.
3.1 Introduction 3.2 Doubly bridged cyclophanes and analogous molecules as hosts for intramolecular guests 3.3 Cleft molecules as hosts 3.3.1 Single-cleft hosts 3.3.2 Double-cleft hosts 3.4 Container molecules as hosts 3.4.1 Introduction 3.4.2 Cavitands and caviplexes 3.4.3 Hemispherands and hemispheraplexes 3.4.4 Triply bridged cyclophanes and analogous molecules as three-dimensional hosts for intramolecular guests 3.4.5 Spherands and spheraplexes 3.4.6 Carcerands and carceplexes
28 30 44 44 47 48 48 48 50 51 59 59
28
CROWN ETHERS, CRYPTANDS AND RE LATED MOLECUL ES AS HOST S
3.5
Hemicarcerands and hemicarceplexes 3.5.1 Overview 3.5.2 The taming of cyclobutadiene, and of o-benzyne 3.5.3 Molecular mechanics and dynamics studies on the complexation and decomplexation processes 3.6 Comparisons of concepts References
3.1
61 61 64 66 67 68
Introduction
Intramolecular enclosure of guests by hosts, often specifically and purposefully designed, has progressed remarkably rapidly over the last thirty years, spearheaded by the efforts of Pedersen, Lehn, Cram and their coworkers, and formally recognized by the joint award of the Nobel Prize for Chemistry to the trio in 1987. Many different host systems have been synthesized and the strengths of host–guest interactions in solution have been measured, and an understanding developed of the factors contributing to these interactions. In parallel, the determination of a number of crystal structures has led to establishment of a sounder geometrical foundation for the assessment of the various contributions to host– guest interaction. All this has been accompanied by growth of a nomenclature and jargon, especially as the systematic names of most of the host compounds are very complicated. We first introduce representatives of the main types of host (Fig. 3.1) and then discuss the structures of the complexes formed, emphasizing crystallographic results and noting synthetic methods and studies of solution thermodynamics only peripherally. The hosts are given the suffix ‘‘-and’’ (corand – often still called ‘‘crown ethers’’ – cryptand, . . . etc.) and the corresponding complexes are sometimes given the suffix ‘‘-ate’’ and are coronates, cryptates, . . . etc., or else the suffix ‘‘-plex’’ and become caviplexes, hemispheraplexes, . . . etc.). A distinction has been made between cavitands, which are hosts containing enforced cavities, and speleands, where the host combines the elements of a rigid, lipophilic cavity with polar binding sites. The classical origins of these names is obvious: Latin corona wreath, crown; Greek krupto hide; Greek speliaon cave; Latin cavus hollow; Latin carcer prison. When considering the formation of complexes in solution, two important factors are generally taken into account. These are (i) the principle of stereo-electronic complementarity between host and guest, and (ii) the principle of preorganization of a binding site before complexation. The first is often stated to be a modern formulation of Emil Fischer’s ‘‘lock and key’’ principle (Behr, 1994). It implies that there is some special interaction, perhaps charge transfer or hydrogen bonding, between host and guest, as well as geometrical complementarity. The second has been defined by Cram and coworkers in a long series of elegant investigations which we describe in more detail below. Essentially this principle states that binding sites are best organized to be complementary in a stereoelectronic sense prior to complexation; if not, then reorganization is necessary on complexation and the price paid in free energy may outweigh the gain achieved by complexation. If so, then complexation will not take place. In general, complexation requires replacement of solvent molecules by guest molecules. Preorganization also enhances selectivity by introduction of particular chemical features into an host molecule enhancing
29
I NT RO D UC T I O N
O O
O
O
O
N O
H3C
O
O
H
H
N
O O
O Corand (crown ether; 18-crown-6)
n
O
CH3 Podand
Cryptand
O O O
N
O X
X
O O
X
X
H3C
CH3
X
N X
H3C
CH3
CH3
CH3
Hemispherand (X = OCH3)
Cryptaspherand (X = OCH3) X
(H2C)n
X
(CH2)n
X
Doubly bridged cyclophanes CH3 CH3
O S
CH3
Si O
O Si
O CH3
CH3
CH3
CH3
O
O
O
O Si
S O
O
O
O O
O
S
O
O
CH3
CH3
Cavitand
O
O
O
CH3
O
CH3
O
O CH3 Si
Triply bridged cyclophanes
O
S O
Carcerand
Fig. 3.1. Representatives of the main types of host classified in chemical terms. It is important to note that the types of complex formed depend on the nature of the guest and, most importantly, on the geometry as well as the chemistry of the host. The filled circles in the carcerand represent methyl groups.
its ability to form complexes with special guests. However, as we shall see below, there can often be a considerable change of shape in an host molecule as it changes from uncomplexed to complexed conformation. Such comparisons require crystal structures of the neat host as well as those of the complex, and some are indeed available. In crystalline complexes it is also necessary to consider the possibility of intermolecular complexation of guest and/or solvent as an additional stabilizing factor.
30
CROWN ETHERS, CRYPTANDS AND RE LATED MOLECUL ES AS HOST S
Analysis of a crystal structure shows in detail the host–guest relationship in the solid state but it is often not clear to what extent this geometrical situation persists in long-lived fashion in solution. Thermodynamic and spectroscopic (especially NMR methods) studies of the solutions provide evidence to probe these questions. Here we draw special attention to five massive compilations of solution thermodynamic data, which also provide an exhaustive listing of the structural formulae of macrocyclic hosts. These deal with intramolecular complexation of metallic cations and anions (Christensen, Eatough and Izatt, 1974; 217 references; Izatt, Bradshaw, Nielsen, Lamb, Christensen and Sen, 1985; 340 references), organic cations and anions (Izatt, Pawlak, Bradshaw and Bruening, 1991; 1173 references), and neutral molecules (Izatt, Bradshaw, Pawlak, Bruening and Tarbet, 1992; 307 references); this information has been revised and extended (Izatt, Pawlak, Bradshaw and Bruening, 1995; 478 references). There does not seem to be any comparable material dealing with the thermodynamics of the solid complexes and their components, which would be even more relevant here in the context of our emphasis on the solid state. It will be observed that we pay much more attention in this chapter to thermodynamic parameters derived from measurements in solution than we do in most other chapters, where the emphasis is placed on the thermodynamics of the crystalline complexes. The reason is that the thermodynamic measurements refer to the process of intramolecular complexation and this will, we presume, be little altered if it occurs in solution or in the solid state. We start this chapter by considering intramolecular enclosure systems where the host molecules are perhaps more nearly two- rather than three-dimensional; enclosure is often less complete with two-dimensional hosts. We then proceed to the complete enclosure found with three-dimensional hosts. Our classification is largely based on the shapes taken up by the host molecules and thus crosses boundaries of chemical type. We use a mnemonic nomenclature – the supramolecular macrocyclic complex is denoted by parentheses{M[X]}, with the included guest within square brackets [X]. This hopefully lessens the confusion, especially when counterions and solvent molecules are present in the crystal but not included within the confines of the host. There are a number of excellent reviews (Cram and Cram, 1994; Jasat and Sherman, 1999; Hof, Craig, Nuckolls and Rebek, 2002; Rudkevich, 2002) which describe the historical development of the field, the synthetic aspects and the solution chemistry; these are complementary to the material given in this chapter, where the crystal-chemical aspects are emphasized.
3.2
Doubly bridged cyclophanes and analogous molecules as hosts for intramolecular guests
Background to the use of cyclophanes as hosts for the enclosure of neutral molecules has been given (Diederich, 1988; Odashima and Koga, 1983). The necessary, but not always sufficient, condition for intramolecular inclusion of a guest species within the internal cavity of a suitable host molecule is that the cavity should be large enough to accommodate the guest. The classical studies of crown ether complexes deal mostly with those having inorganic cations as guests (Dobler, 1981; Hilgenfeld and Saenger, 1982; Bradshaw, Izatt, Bordunov, Zhu and Hathaway, 1996); we shall not make more than passing reference to these for
DOUBLY BRIDGED CYCLOPHANES AND ANALOGOUS MOLECULES
31
reasons of space. Many complexes of the smaller crown ethers, especially 18-crown-6, with neutral molecules are known, but crystal structure analysis shows that these are intermolecular complexes with hydrogen bonding between the components and not intramolecular inclusion complexes; many are discussed in Chapter 12. From a consideration of the available crystallographic results, Uiterwijk et al. (1986) concluded that ‘‘urea and urea analogs like uronium and guanidinium cations can only form encapsulated complexes with complementary H-bonding schemes if the crown ether has at least 27 ring atoms. With smaller rings, perching complexes are formed.’’ It may well be posssible to generalize this conclusion to other potential guests. An example of complexation by a derivative of 18-crown-6 (3.1) presents a cautionary tale. This forms a highly stable 1 : 1 complex with nitromethane in which the methyl hydrogens are directed towards the emphasised N and O atoms of 3.1 (Weber, Franken, Puff and Ahrendt, 1986; DIZTIP). The difficulties of definition and interpretation appear when the stereoview of the nitromethane environment (Fig. 3.2) is examined. Firstly, the host molecule is not planar and indeed approximates to the cleft shape discussed in Section 3.3 below; secondly, the guest is not entirely enclosed within the host but rather between a group of four host molecules. One should beware of drawing conclusions from projections onto the mean plane of possibly nonplanar molecules. An interesting feature of {3.1[nitromethane]} is that spontaneous resolution has taken place on crystallization, the space group of the complex being P212121; spontaneous resolution does not occur in the two polymorphs of the neat host (TAFYOO, CARXOI), nor in the complexes with acetonitrile (FUCFOY), phenyl cyanide (YURROS), or in the bis(methanol) monohydrate complex (CARXOU). Chloroacetonitrile forms a 1 : 1 complex while the acetonitrile complex has a 1 : 2 host : guest ratio, both complexes being less stable than the nitromethane complex. Dimethylformamide, dimethyl sulphoxide, acetone, benzene and toluene do not form complexes.
N O
O
O
O O
O
3.1
Fig. 3.2. The formula of 3.1 (the N and two O atoms involved in bonding to the methyl hydrogens are emphasised) is shown, and a stereoview of the surroundings of the nitromethane molecule in the crystal of {3.1[nitromethane]}. The host molecules are shown as line drawings and the guest in space-filling representation. (Adapted from Weber, Franken, Puff and Ahrendt, 1986.)
32
CROWN ETHERS, CRYPTANDS AND RE LATED MOLECUL ES AS HOST S
The larger crown ethers1 can and do act as hosts in intramolecular inclusion complexes; a wide range of host shapes and degrees of flexibility can be attained by choice of suitable compositions. Most of the published results refer to (PF6) salts in which the guests are the dications bipyridinium (3.2), diquat (3.3) and paraquat (3.4). One series of publications carries the intriguing title ‘‘Molecular Meccano’’ (Anelli et al., 1992; Part 2, Amabilino, Ashton et al., 1995) and another invokes the name of ‘‘Molecular Lego’’ (Kohnke, Mathias and Stoddart, 1989), both trade names of children’s toys in which complicated structures are constructed by combination of a limited number of simpler units. We shall summarize some of the structural results, starting with smaller host molecules such as bis-m-phenylene-32-crown-10 (C28H40O10; BMP32C10; 3.5; Allwood, Shahriari-Zavareh, Stoddart and Williams, 1987). Note that we shall often use the acronyms of the original papers instead of systematic names. The neat compound (FIKWAX) crystallizes in space group P21/a (Z ¼ 2) and the molecules are centrosymmetric, with ˚ 2. Minimal an open conformation having a free central passage of dimensions 7.8 4.9 A rotations about four single bonds are required to extend the central passage so that a diquat cation can be complexed intramolecularly; the crystals have composition {C28H40O10[C12H12N22þ]}(PF6)2(CH3)2CO (space group P1, Z ¼ 2; FIKWEB). The conformations of uncomplexed and complexed hosts are compared in Fig. 3.3; the two pyridinium rings of the diquat cation have a twist angle of 22 .
NH+
+HN
Bipyridinium (3.2)
N+
N+
Diquat (3.3)
N+–CH3
H3CN+
Paraquat (3.4)
Scheme 3.1
Bis-p-phenylene-34-crown-10 (BPP34C10; 3.6; the formula is shown in Fig. 3.4(a) below2) also forms intramolecular inclusion complexes (Allwood, Spencer, ShahriariZavareh, Stoddart and Williams, 1987a). The neat compound (FIKVEA) crystallizes in space group P21/c (Z ¼ 4), with two molecules of somewhat different conformation at independent centres of symmetry; both conformations are open rather than self-filling. This is in contrast to the self-filling conformation found in tetramethoxy-BPP34C10 (Owen, 1984; CIDLOQ, C2/c, Z ¼ 4). The second conformation (designated II) of the 1 The crown ethers are named as n-crown-m where ‘n’ is the number of atoms in the macrocycle and ‘m’ is the number of (ether) oxygen atoms. Thus 3.5 is 32-crown-10 (or 32C10 for short), the macrocycle having 22 carbons and 10 oxygens. 3.5 contains two m-phenylenes and thus the overall number of carbons is 22 þ (2 3) giving the composition as C28H40O10. The acronym is BMP32C10 where BMP represents bis(m-phenylene) and 32 is the number of atoms (C þ O) in the macrocycle. 2 Although BMP32C10 and BPP34C10 have the same composition (C28H40O10), their macrocycles have different sizes and connectivities.
DOUBLY BRIDGED CYCLOPHANES AND ANALOGOUS MOLECULES
61 173 173 –174
74 –67 –154
68
N
16 73 167
–63
N
22 –66
77
33
94
–62 –171 164 –168 –67
9
7
175
–154 175 18 –62 64 173
Fig. 3.3. Comparison of the centrosymmetric shape of BMP32C10 (3.5) in its neat crystals (on the right) and in its complex with diquat (on the left); the oxygens are darkened; diquat is twisted by 22 about the central bond. The considerable difference in the two conformations is shown by the torsion angles about the various bonds (only torsion angles differing by >5 from 0, 180 are shown). (Reproduced from Allwood, Shahriari-Zavareh, Stoddart and Williams, 1987.)
neat crystals is unusually open and remains so when it encloses a bipyridinium cation, the terminal N–H groups being hydrogen bonded to opposing oxygens of the crown ether (Ashton, Philp et al., 1991; KOLMAZ). When the para hydrogens of the bipyridinium cation are successively replaced by methyls, n-propyls and n-butyls, then a series of rotaxanes3 is obtained, exemplified by the complex of composition {C28H40O10[C12H14N22þ]}(PF6)22[(CH3)2CO] (Fig. 3.4) in which the BPP34C10 macrocycle is threaded by a paraquat (PQT2þ) cation (P1, Z ¼ 2; Allwood, Spencer et al., 1987a; FIRXOT); the 4,4 0 -bi(2-hydroxyethylpyridinium) complex is KOLMED and the 4,4 0 -bi(2-(2-hydroxyethoxy)ethylpyridinium) complex is KOLMIH. As the conformation of the macrocycle hardly changes from one complex to the next, these macrocycles are examples of almost perfect preorganization. A rather similar arrangement and illustration of preorganization is found in the intramolecular paraquat inclusion complex of 1,5-dinaphtho-38-crown-10, which is stabilized by –* interactions between the electron-rich naphthalene and the electron-poor bipyridinium rings, possibly supplemented by weak electrostatic interactions (Ashton, Chrystal et al., 1987; FUVBAZ; 3 Rotaxanes (rota (L) ¼ wheel, axis (L) ¼ axle) have been defined (Schill, 1971) as molecules in which a cyclic structure is threaded by a chain or other linear subunit having bulky ends that prevent the dissociation (unthreading) of the cyclic and linear components. Pseudorotaxanes (Stoddart, 1991) are supramolecules in which the wheel is free to dissociate from the axle – thus the components are held together by nonbonded interactions rather than the mechanical interference of true rotaxanes. Catenanes (L. catena, chain) are molecules which contain two or more interlocked rings which are inseparable without the breaking of a covalent bond. The number of catenated rings is designated by [n] where n 2. These are all examples of interlocked or intertwined species (Amabalino and Stoddart, 1995). Here we return to a point of nomenclature. In Chapter 1 we required ‘binary adducts’ to be relatively easily separable into their components. In terms of this requirement, pseudorotaxanes are binary adducts while rotaxanes and catenanes are not. However, it is convenient to include here some examples of the latter in order to illustrate particular points.
34
CROWN ETHERS, CRYPTANDS AND RE LATED MOLECUL ES AS HOST S
(a)
O O
O
(b)
O
N
O O
O
N O
N
O
O N
O
O
O
O
O
O
O O
O O (c) N
N
Fig. 3.4. Ball and stick (a) and space-filling representations (b) of the centrosymmetric rotaxane complex {BPP34C10[PQT2þ]}(PF6)22(CH3)2CO; the diagrams show two different orientations. The host crown ether 3.6 has an S-shape when viewed from a direction normal to that of (b); (c) the best least squares fit is shown between conformation II of neat BPP34C10 and that found in the paraquat complex. (Parts (a) and (b) reproduced from Anelli et al. (1992) and part (c) from Allwood, Spencer et al., 1987b.)
{C36H44O10[C12H14N2]2þ2(PF6)-2((CH3)2CO)}). Other rotaxanes and pseudorotaxanes are discussed below. The diquat monohydrate complex of BPP34C10 introduces a new feature, with both cation and water molecule located within the torus of the host molecule (Allwood, Spencer, Shahriari-Zavareh, Stoddart and Williams, 1987b; FIKVIE); thus the composition is best represented as {BPP34C10[diquatH2O]}(PF6)2 and the conformation of the host crown ether is again similar to that of conformation II of neat BPP34C10. The crystal structure of {BPP31C9[diquat]}(PF6)2 also shows intramolecular inclusion of diquat by the crown ether host (Ashton, Slawin, Spencer, Stoddart and Williams, 1987; FIRXUZ). The diquat cations are both twisted, as noted above. The crystal structures of neat crown ethers of general formula BPP(3n þ 4)Cn have been determined (Slawin, Spencer, Stoddart and Williams, 1987) for n ¼ 7, 8, 10 (BPP34C10), 11 and 12, and some edge-on views are shown in Fig. 3.5 (analogous diagrams for BPP34C10 have been shown above). It is clear that considerable reorganization of the ring conformations is needed before complexes can be formed, except for the two conformations of BPP34C10 (especially conformation II). An important interaction in these complexes is the edge-to-face stacking between aromatic rings shown for BPP25C7 (Fig. 3.5(a)) and discussed theoretically by Burley and Pesko (1986). It is inferred that the edge-to-face disposition is a result of an electrostatic attraction between a partial positive charge on the intruding hydrogen and the negatively charged
DOUBLY BRIDGED CYCLOPHANES AND ANALOGOUS MOLECULES
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
35
Fig. 3.5. Edge-on views of the molecules BPP25C7 (FIKTIC), BPP28C8 (FIKTOI), BPP37C11 (FIKTUO) and BPP40C12 (FIKVAW) in their neat crystals. (Reproduced from Slawin, Spencer, Stoddart and Williams, 1987.)
-cloud of the aromatic ring; energies of 4–8 kJ/mol are involved. The molecule of bis(1,5-dihydroxynaphtho)-35-crown-9 in its neat crystals provides another example (Ashton, Chrystal et al., 1987; FUTZUP); the central cavity is filled by a T-disposition of the two naphtho moieties, with one in an edge-to-face relation to the other. Similar dispositions have also been observed in intermolecular arrangements. Another new feature is introduced when the host molecule is 1,5-dinaphtho-44-crown-12; the neat molecule crystallizes in space group P21/a, Z ¼ 2 (KEBLEI). A complex of 1 : 2 composition is formed with paraquat which can be represented as {1,5-DN44C12 [PQT2þ]}(PQT2þ)(PF6) 4 (CH3)2CO (KEBLAE; P1, Z ¼ 1). One of the paraquat cations is included within the macrocycle and the second is stacked between the macrocycles, the whole assembly forming an alternating arrangement of donor and acceptor groups (Fig. 3.6; Ortholand, Slawin, Spencer, Stoddart and Williams, 1989). This is very similar in overall form to the well-known . . . DADADA . . . stacking of alternating -donors and *-acceptors found in molecular compounds of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and a variety of electron acceptor molecules (see Chapter 15). In the double or [3]catenane (Ashton, Brown, Chrystal et al., 1991) described below the donor and acceptor units have a . . . DADDAD . . . sequence. Many related examples are given by Amabilino and Stoddart, (1995). It was noted (Ashton, Reddington et al., 1988; Ashton, Goodnow et al., 1989; Bu¨hner, Geuder, Gries, Hu¨nig, Kock and Poll, 1988) that formation of intramolecular inclusion complexes stabilized by charge transfer interactions from a donor host to an acceptor guest, as in most of the examples described above, implied that the converse situation – acceptor host and donor guest – should also lead to formation of complexes. This is shown schematically in Fig. 3.7 and was realized in practice by using the bis(paraquat) derivative (formula 3.7, also shown on the right hand side of Fig. 3.7), abbreviated as
36
CROWN ETHERS, CRYPTANDS AND RE LATED MOLECUL ES AS HOST S
O B Paraquat within crown ether
N
Paraquat between crown ethers
Naphtho donor
Polyoxomethylene chain
O y z
A
C
x
y
z
Intramolecular paraquat acceptor
Naphtho donor
x
Fig. 3.6. The stacking arrangement of the paraquat moieties within and between the naphtho-crown ether rings in {DN44C12[PQT2þ]}(PQT2þ) (PF6)4(CH3)2CO is shown on the left of the diagram; an edge-on view of the arrangement within the {DN44C12[PQT2þ]} portion is shown on the right. (Data from Ortholand, Slawin, Spencer, Stoddart and Williams, 1989.)
[BBIPYBIXYCY][PF6]4. The systematic name of the cyclobis(paraquat-p-phenylene) tetracation is 5,12,19,26-tetraazoniaheptacyclo-[24.2.2.22,527,10212,15216,19221,24] tetraconta-1(28),2,4,7,9,12,14,16,18,21,23,26,29,31,33,35,-37,39-octadecaene (Odell, Reddington, Slawin, Spencer, Stoddart and Williams, 1988), which illustrates why abbreviations are preferred. 4+ N
N
N
N
[BBIPYBIXYCY] 3.7
Scheme 3.2
The host system is quite rigid and the conformation taken up in the solvated salt of composition (BBIPYBIXYCY)4þ(PF 6 )43CH3CN (VAFRID10) is rather strictly preserved in the 1,2- (Odell, Reddington et al., 1988) and 1,4-dimethoxybenzene inclusion complexes, the compositions of which were given as {BBIPYBIXYCY [C8H10O2]}4þ(PF 6 )43CH3CN (the solvent content can also be 2CH3NO2.H2O) (Ashton, Reddington et al., 1988); the 1,4-dimethoxybenzene inclusion complex is shown schematically on the right hand side of Fig. 3.7 and in space-filling mode on the left side of Fig. 3.8. The 1,2-dimethoxybenzene guest is disordered over two orientations and approximates in appearance in the crystal to 1,5-dimethoxynaphthalene, which also can be
DOUBLY BRIDGED CYCLOPHANES AND ANALOGOUS MOLECULES
O O
O
O
O CH3 N+
N+ CH3 O
37
O N+
O
OMe
O
N+
MeO N+
N+
O
Fig. 3.7. Schematic representation of the donor host–acceptor guest intramolecular inclusion complex dication {BPP34C10[PQT]2þ} on the left and the converse situation on the right with donor and acceptor roles interchanged; here the tetracation is {(BBIPYBIXYCY)4þ [C8H10O2]}, with the host designated 3.7. The donor benzene rings are hatched. Space-filling views of the tetracation are shown in Fig. 3.8. (Adapted from Fig. 1 of Ashton, Goodnow et al., 1989.) ˚ , deg, A ˚ 3) for some intramolecular inclusion complexes of formula Table 3.1. Cell dimensions (A 4þ {BBIPYBIXYCY* [guest]} (PF6 )43(solvent). The su’sy of the cell edges are 1 in 5000, and of 0.03 . The crystals all have space group P21/n, with Z ¼ 2; the host:guest ratios are all 1:1 except for the 1,3-bis(5-hydroxy-1-naphthyloxy)propane guest, where it is 1 : 0.5 Guest and refcode
a
b
c
Cell volume
No guest; MeCN solvate VAFRID10 No guest; monohydrate VAFROJ 1,2-dimethoxybenzene VAFSAW 1,4-dimethoxybenzene VAFRUP 1,5-dimethoxynaphthalene KIRTEK 1,3-bis(5-hydroxy-1-naphthyloxy)propane (1:0.5) KIRTIO
10.805 10.478 11.076 10.948 11.218 10.881
19.819 20.152 19.805 19.869 19.756 20.043
14.027 13.757 13.962 13.886 13.980 14.066
109.36 106.45 111.57 110.55 111.23 110.09
2834 2786 2848 2828 2888 2881
* CSD name cyclobis(paraquat-p-phenylene) y
su is standard uncertainty
included. Furthermore, the longer but analogous guest molecule 1,3-bis(5-hydroxy-1naphthyloxy)propane can also be included, with a host : guest ratio of 1 : 0.5 (Reddington, Slawin, Spencer, Stoddart, Vicent and Williams, 1991). All these crystals are essentially isomorphous, as is shown by their similar cell dimensions and identical space groups (Table 3.1). The conformation of [BBIPYBIXYCY]4þ is also maintained in its other complexes. An inclusion complex is also produced with tetrathiafulvalene, an easily oxidized electron donor (see Chapter 13; oxidation potential 0.4 V); the crystals have composition {BBIPYBIXYCY[C6H4S2]}4þ(PF 6 )44CH3CN but are triclinic (P1, Z ¼ 1; VOLMEO) and hence different from the group listed in Table 3.1. The guest is indeed inserted into the cavity of the host but anions and solvent molecules are differently disposed (Philp, Slawin, Spencer, Stoddart and Williams, 1991). All these crystals have an arrangement of rectangular doughnut (or ‘‘bagel’’) shaped host cations alternating with
38
CROWN ETHERS, CRYPTANDS AND RE LATED MOLECUL ES AS HOST S
OH O O
N O
O
N
N
O
O
O
O
O
N
N
N
OH
O
O
Fig. 3.8. Plan views of space-filling representations of the host–guest arrangement in the 1,4dimethoxybenzene intramolecular inclusion complex {BBIPYBIXYCY[C8H10O2]}(PF6)43CH3CN (on the left), and in the rotaxane {BBIPYBIXYCY[HOC6H4(CH2CH2O)4C6H4(OCH2CH2)4 C6H4OH]}(PF6)42CH3CN (on the right). (Reproduced from Anelli et al., 1992.)
layers of anions plus solvent molecules. The host cavity is empty in the parent structure and filled by the included guests in the supermolecules, with ‘‘threaded’’ as perhaps a more appropriate description for the last, and longest, of the guests. Hu¨bner et al. (1989) have shown that analogous hosts can include a variety of guests, among which are anthracene, phenanthrene, pyrene and a number of substituted naphthalenes; no crystal structures have been reported. The ‘‘threading’’ motif is also maintained in a variety of self-assembling rotaxane and pseudorotaxane complexes of [BBIPYBIXYCY]4þ, such as that illustrated on the right hand side of Fig. 3.8, and found as solvated salts. We give a number of guests with refcodes of the crystal structures (Anelli, Ashton, Spencer, Slawin, Stoddart and Williams, 1991; Anelli, Ashton, Ballardini et al., 1992): R
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
R
VOTPAV, as shown, with R ¼ Si(i-Pr)3 SOVLEU, as shown with R ¼ p-phenol SOVKOD, as shown, with R ¼ 2,5-dimethoxyphenyl VOTNUN, with three oxygens per chain, and R ¼ Si(i-Pr)3 SOVKOJ, with five oxygens per chain and R ¼ p-phenol VOTNEX, with three oxygens per chain and R ¼ H VOTNIB, as shown, and R ¼ H VOTNOH with five oxygens per chain and R ¼ H Scheme 3.3
We reproduce here two other structures, which lie on the borders of the subject matter of this book, but perhaps could be described as the ultimate in ‘‘molecule-within-molecule’’ inclusion complexes – the [2] catenane composed of the two host molecules BPP34C10
39
DOUBLY BRIDGED CYCLOPHANES AND ANALOGOUS MOLECULES
N
N
O
O
O
O O
O
O
N
N
O
O
O
O
O
O O
O
N N
N O
N
O
O
O
Fig. 3.9. The intertwined macrocyclic rings found in the catenane {[2]-[BPP34C10][BBIPYBIXYCY]}[PF6]45CH3CN (KEBKUX10). The ball-and-stick and space-filling views are from somewhat different orientations. The C atoms and rings in the cation have been shaded for clarity. (Reproduced from Anelli et al., 1992.)
Macrocyclic tetracation
Crown ether
Crown ether
y z x
Macrocyclic tetracation
Fig. 3.10. Double interlacing of two crown ether rings with the macrocyclic tetracation as found in the [3]catenane SOVLIY C28H40O10C48H40N44þC28H40O104(PF6). (Data from Ashton, Brown, Chrystal et al., 1991.)
and [BBIPYBIXYCY]4þ (Fig. 3.9) and the double or [3]catenane composed of BPP34C10 and the cation analogous to [BBIPYBIXYCY]4þ but made up of four bipyridyl units (Fig. 3.10). As noted above, in the double or [3]catenane (Ashton, Brown, Chrystal et al., 1991) the donor and acceptor units have a . . . DADDAD . . . sequence. One important crystallographic feature of the above group of complexes, perhaps considered trivial by chemists, is that they are all ternary complexes. In addition to the intramolecular inclusion of guests within the cavities of the host molecules, there is also intermolecular inclusion of solvent molecules in the interstices between the host molecules. These solvent molecules make an essential contribution to the cohesion of the crystals, as do the interactions between the ions. If there is disorder of the
40
CROWN ETHERS, CRYPTANDS AND RE LATED MOLECUL ES AS HOST S
anions, then this will have a stabilizing effect due to the additional configurational entropy. Crystal structures of pseudorotaxanes, rotaxanes and catenanes illustrating and extending the principles described above continue to be reported (e.g. Amabilino and Stoddart 1995; Ashton, Ballardini, Balzani, Be´loradsk’y, Gandolfi, Philp, Prodi, Raymo, Reddington, Spencer, Stoddart, Venturi and Williams, 1996; Asakawa, Brown, Menzer, Raymo, Stoddart and Williams, 1997 (RISSER, RISSIV, RISSOB, RISSUH, RISTAO, RISTES, RISTIW, TEYMAL10); Asakawa, Ashton, Hayes, Janssen, Meijer, Menzer, Pasini, Stoddart, White and Williams, 1998 (PUKNOY, PUKNUE, PUKPAM)). The crystals described above are all of salts but [2]catenanes with both partners neutral are also known (Hamilton, Feeder, Prodi, Teat, Clegg and Sanders, 1998; NIFLAP as the perdeuterodimethylsulfoxide solvate C34H32O7C32H12N4O6C2D6OS). N,N 0 ,N00 -tritosyl-5,8,14,17,23,26-hexamethyl-2,11,20-triaza[3.3.3]paracyclophane (formula not shown) forms a 1 : 1 intermolecular inclusion complex with dichloromethane (Bottino, Finocchiaro, Lipkowski, Mamo and Pappalardo, 1991; SOVKAP), whereas a number of different guests form a series of intramolecular inclusion complexes with 2,11,20,29–tetramethyl–2,11,20,29–tetraaza-[3333]-para-cyclophane (3.8) (Tabushi, Yamamura, Nonoguchi, Horotsu and Higuchi, 1984a, b). 3.8 is enantiomeric with exact or approximate C2-2 symmetry. The enantiomers are rapidly interconverted in solution but appear separately in the crystals, among which both racemates and enantiomorphs are found (Table 3.2). H3C
CH3
N
N
N
N
H3C
CH3 3.8
H2N+
(CH2)4
NH2+
H2N+
(CH2)4
NH2+
3.9
Scheme 3.4
Crystal structures have been reported for the complexes with dioxane (Abbott, Barrett, Godfrey, Kalindjian, Simpson and Williams, 1982), CHCl3, CO2, CH3CN and CH2Cl2, (Tabushi, Yamamura, Nonoguchi, Hirotsu and Higuchi, 1984a, b; Hirotsu, Kamitori, Higuchi, Tabushi, Yamamura and Nonoguchi, 1984) and CH2BrCl (Nonoguchi, Yamamura, Tabushi, Higuchi and Hirotsu, 1992). This information, together with that summarised in Table 3.2, shows some interesting features. The host molecule is found to have C2-2 symmetry in all the complexes (crystallographically imposed for the dioxane, CHCl3, CH3CN and CO2 complexes), and is therefore chiral in the solid state (also, of course, in solution, where racemization will be very rapid). A feature common to the unit cells of the complexes is the similarity of the values of [010]. The structure analyses show
DOUBLY BRIDGED CYCLOPHANES AND ANALOGOUS MOLECULES
41
Table 3.2. Crystal data for 2,11,20,29–tetramethyl–2,11,20,29–tetraaza[3.3.3.3]paracyclophane (3.8) and some of its 1 : 1 intramolecular inclusion complexes with various guests (the compositions were determined directly by NMR and/or GLPC methods for the chloroform, methylene chloride, bromochloromethane and acetonitrile complexes). This table was adapted from a summary of results given by Nonoguchi et al. (1992), and in earlier papers Guest
˚ a/A
˚ b/A
˚ c/A
None DERFIP
21.491
15.123
10.020
12.694 89.86 5.772
13.496 80.30 13.514
5.668
Vol./ asymmetric unit (A˚3)
Vol./ guest (A˚3)*
Space group
Z
807.6
–
P21/a
4
–
893.2
85.6
P1
1
112.41
898.6
91.0
P21
4
13.438
111.31
892.9
85.3
C2
2
5.691
13.440
112.06
889.3
81.7
C2
2
25.544
5.406
26.948
109.90
874.8
67.2
C2/c
4
25.590
5.420
26.900
109.86
877.3
69.7
C2/c
4
25.314
5.536
53.508
111.07
874.6
67.0
C2/c
8
25.373
5.486
53.759
111.00
873.3
65.7
C2/c
8
Enantiomorphs pyridinex 5.712 JOPVOZ 68.16 C6H6 49.846 JOPVIT 25.166 CHCl3 CEYHIX Dioxane 25.091 BIJJOT Racemates CH3CN DERFUB CO2 DERFOV CH2BrCl JOPVEP CH2Cl2 CEYHOD
ß/
97.26
x Reduced cell. ˚ 3 from the volume of the asymmetric unit; these volumes will * Nominal values obtained by subtracting 807.6 A be overestimated because of the difference in the shape of the host in its neat crystals and in those of the ˚ 3 in its crystals so the composition is probably nearer complexes. Note that benzene has a molar volume of 122 A 1:0.5, and this is also likely for the pyridine and dioxane complexes.
that all have stacks of homochiral host molecules along [010]. The structures in Table 3.2 can be divided into two groups (a) those with chiral space groups where spontaneous resolution has occurred on crystallization (the pyridine, CHCl3 and dioxane complexes, and, possibly the benzene complex), and (b) those with racemic space groups. The principal difference between the two groups lies in the mutual arrangements of the stacks, and how adjacent homochiral stacks interact, or stacks of different senses of chirality interact. The interactions within the stacks have been calculated by molecular mechanics (MM2) for the CH2Cl2 complex (Hirotsu et al., 1984); the total interaction energy of a column is 138 kJ/mol, with host–guest interaction amounting to 56 kJ/mol and guest–guest interaction to 4 kJ/mol. A further subdivision can be made in terms of unit cells and space groups: thus the CHCl3 and dioxane complexes belong together, as do the CH3CN and CO2 complexes, and the CH2Cl2 and CH2BrCl complexes. Comparison of the crystal structure of the neat host with those of the complexes shows that the host takes up a
42
CROWN ETHERS, CRYPTANDS AND RE LATED MOLECUL ES AS HOST S
Fig. 3.11. Comparison of the conformations of the macrocycle 3.8 in its complexes (on the left) and in its neat crystals (on the right). (Reproduced from Hirotsu, Kamitori, Higuchi, Tabushi, Yamamura and Nonoguchi, 1984.)
more compact form in its neat crystals than in the complexes, where its shape has to allow for inclusion of guests (Fig. 3.11). Guest exchange experiments show that about 40% of the guest in the CHCl3 complex can be replaced by CH2BrCl before there is a change in crystal structure. Weakness of host-guest binding is shown by the fact that guest exchange occurs. The 1,6,20,25-tetraammonium[6.1.6.1]paracyclophane cation 3.9 forms intra-molecular complexes with 1,3-dihydroxynaphthalene, 2,7-dihydroxynaphthalene, p-xylene and durene when crystallized from aqueous solutions at pH < 2 (Odashima, Itai, Iitaka and Koga, 1980). The crystal structure of the salt {3.9[durene]}4Cl4H2O has been reported ˚ , ¼ 97.23(4) , V ¼ 2360 A ˚ 3, space group (a ¼ 14.552(7), b ¼ 22.58(1), c ¼ 7.238(3) A P21/n, Z ¼ 2; ACPHDR); the durene is included within the torus of the cation while the anions and water molecules are situated between the cations. The cation is centrosymmetric, in contrast to 3.8. An analog to 3.9, 1 0 ,100 -dimethyldispiro-[1,6,20,25tetraoxa[6161]paracyclophane-13,4 0 : 32,400 -bispiperidine] (3.10, formula not shown), forms a complex of composition {3.10[C6H6]}C6H6H2O (DENFOR; P1, Z ¼ 1) in which one of the benzenes is enclosed within the host cavity while the other is located in tunnels between the host molecules. Other complexes of 3.10, with toluene and p-xylene (DENFUR), are intermolecular (Krieger and Diederich, 1985). The macrocyclic tetraimide shown in Fig. 3.12, which is composed of two 1,4,5,8naphthalenetetracarboxylic acid diimide subunits joined by two (CH2)8 chains, forms an ‘‘intercalative molecular cryptate’’ with nitrobenzene as guest (Jaswinski, Blacker, Lehn, Cesario, Guilhem and Pascard, 1987); here the polyether chains of crown ethers are replaced by aliphatic chains of methylene groups. The nitrobenzene takes up two orientations in the cavity 165 apart and the two aliphatic (CH2)8 chains have somewhat different conformations and types of disorder; hence the non-centrosymmetric space group P1 was assigned to the triclinic crystals. An example of the effects of the flexibility of an host molecule is illustrated by a tantalizingly brief report (Itai, Tanaka and Iitaka, 1979) about [26]metacyclophane (3.11) and its intramolecular complexes; a full report appears not to have been published. The diagrams reproduced in Fig. 3.13 show that the host molecule is very flexible; in the neat P 1 polymorph (there is a second polymorph, space group Pbca, about which no
DOUBLY BRIDGED CYCLOPHANES AND ANALOGOUS MOLECULES
O N O A O N O
43
O N O + O N – O O N O
A
Fig. 3.12. Three diagrams showing the host–guest relationship for the macrocyclic tetraimide composed of two 1,4,5,8-naphthalenetetracarboxylic acid diimide subunits joined by two (CH2)8 chains; the chemical formula (with A ¼ (CH2)8) is shown in the lower part of the diagram, a line outline at top left and a space-filling model at top right. Only one of the two orientations found for nitrobenzene is shown. (Reproduced from Jaswinski, Blacker, Lehn, Cesario, Guilhem and Pascard, 1987.)
information is available) the conformer has a squashed shape without an interior cavity (c); the p- and o-xylene inclusion complexes (space group Pnmn) have the guests parallel to the mean plane of the host (a), whereas the guests penetrate the host in the benzene, m-xylene, n-heptane, cyclohexane and geraniol complexes (b; space group I2/a). It is not known whether the crystals of the complexes in these groups are isomorphous.
(CH2)2
(CH2)2
(CH2)2
(CH2)2
(CH2)2
(CH2)2
[26] metacyclophane (3.11)
Scheme 3.5
44
CROWN ETHERS, CRYPTANDS AND RE LATED MOLECUL ES AS HOST S
(a)
(b)
(c)
Fig. 3.13. Mode of inclusion of the guests in (a) the p- and o-xylene inclusion complexes of [26]metacyclophane, and (b) of the benzene, m-xylene, n-heptane, cyclohexane and geraniol complexes; (c) the conformation of the neat host in its triclinic polymorph. (Reproduced from Itai, Tanaka and Iitaka, 1979.)
3.3
Cleft molecules as hosts
3.3.1
Single-cleft hosts
Most of the structures described above have doughnut (or ‘‘bagel’’) molecules as hosts, with the guest filling the central hole. The hosts in the structures to be described in this section have a tweezer (or U, cake-server, hairpin or horseshoe) shape with the guests enclosed between the two arms of the tweezer. Dibenzocrown ethers of the general type DB3nCn (n ¼ 6–12, with the phenyl groups linked 1,2 (ortho) to O) form stable adducts with [Pt(bpy)(NH3)2]2þ (bpy ¼ bipyridyl), [Rh(cod)(NH3)2]þ (cod ¼ 1,5-cyclooctadiene) and [Rh(nbd)(NH3)2]þ (nbd ¼ norbornadiene), the counterion being (PF6). One of the first hosts studied was dibenzo-24-crown-8, which forms adducts with these three metal complexes. The unsymmetrical location of guest in the Pt adduct (Colquhoun, Doughty, Maud, Stoddart, Williams and Wolstenholme, 1985; DATNOB, P1, Z ¼ 24) compared to its symmetrical location in the Rh adducts (Colquhoun, Doughty, Stoddart and Williams, 1984; cod complex COCPEP, P21/c, Z ¼ 4; nbd complex, COCPIT, Pbca, Z ¼ 4) is evidence for different types of host–guest interaction – charge transfer interactions between the benzene ring of the crown ether and the bipyridyl ligand stabilize the adducts with the Pt complex while the Rh complexes interact with the crown ether through a substantial number of weak hydrogen bonds and electrostatic interactions and their additive effect leads to stabilization (cf. caption to Fig. 3.14). The 1 : 1 complexes of the smaller host dibenzo-18-crown (DB18C6) with pyridinium NEXLOR) and 1-aminopyridinium BF4 (NEXLUX) are isostructural (both Cc, Z ¼ 4, with similar cell dimemsions), and have the cations located within the cleft (La¨msa¨, Huuskonen, Rissanen and Pursiainen, 1998). Crystal structures have been reported (Bush and Truter, 1972) for DB30C10 itself (P21/c, Z ¼ 2, hence centrosymmetric; DBTCAD) and DB30C10KI (Pnna, Z ¼ 4, the [host. Kþ] moiety having a twofold axis; KIBDOT10) and for DB30C10 intramolecular inclusion complexes. DB30C10 has an elongated shape in its neat crystals but the host molecules have U-shapes in all the complexes, including that with KI (Fig. 3.15). Thus there is a remarkable conformational change on complexation, indicating considerable 4
There is also (loc. cit.) a [Pt(bpy)(NH3)2]2þ monohydrate complex of DB30C10 (P21/n, Z ¼ 4; BEFHUP10).
45
CLEFT MOLECUL ES AS HOST S
norbornadiene
2,2'bipypridyl
Pt
Rh O
NH3 x
z
y
N
z x
y dibenzo-crown ether
dibenzo-crown ether
Fig. 3.14. The intramolecular complexes of DB24C8 with two metal coordination-complex cations. The unsymmetrical disposition on the left (DATNOB) is indicative of charge transfer interactions between the components while the symmetrical disposition on the right (COCPIT) suggests the combined effect of a large number of weak hydrogen-bonding and electrostatic interactions. (Data from Colquhoun, Doughty, Maud, Stoddart, Williams and Wolstenholme, (1985) and Colquhoun, Doughty, Stoddart and Williams (1984).)
K
Fig. 3.15. Comparison of the centrosymmetric shape of DB30C10 in its neat crystals (on the left) with the shape found in its complex with potassium iodide (on the right); the molecule has a twofold axis, shown by the vertical line. Oxygens are darkened. The U-shaped conformation of DB30C10 in the KI complex is rather similar to those conformations found in the intramolecular inclusion complexes shown in Figs. 3.14 and 3.16. (Reproduced from Bush and Truter, 1972.)
flexibility of DB30C10. The analogous di-(1,2)-benzo-30-crown-10 (Colquhoun, Goodings, Maud, Stoddart, Wolstenholme and Williams, 1985; CAKMEG10) and di-(2,3)-naphtho-30-crown-10 (3.13) hosts both take up a U-shape in their crystals. For example, in {dinaphtho-30-crown-10[diquat]2þ}(PF6)21/2H2O (Fig. 3.16) (Allwood, Colquhoun, Doughty, Kohnke, Slawin, Stoddart, Williams and Zarzycki, 1987; FIKVUG), both host and guest are located on a crystallographic twofold axis. The host-guest complex has much the same shape when diquat2þ is replaced by (Pt(bipyridyl)(NH3)2)2þ (FIKVOK; here the crystallographic results were of poorer quality because of disorder). The differences between the mutual arrangements of host and guest in the two complexes
46
CROWN ETHERS, CRYPTANDS AND RE LATED MOLECUL ES AS HOST S
Fig. 3.16. Edge-on view of space filling diagram of {DN30C10[Diquat]2þ} cation in its hexafluorophosphate hemihydrate salt. The diquat moiety is enclosed by the jaws of the tweezer host 3.12. The arrangement in {dibenzo-30-crown-10[diquat]2þ}[PF6] 21/2H2O is very similar. (Reproduced from Allwood, Colquhoun et al., 1987.)
were ascribed, as above, to maximization of Coulomb interactions in the diquat complex and of overlap of -arene systems in the Pt complex. Structures have also been reported (Kohnke, Stoddart, Allwood and Williams, 1985) for {2,20-bisformyldibenzo-30-crown-10[diquat]2þ}(PF6)2 0.75CH3CN (CULCAN) and {2,20-bismethyldibenzo-30-crown-10[diquat.]2þ}(PF6) 2H2O (CULCIV), with results rather similar to those already described. {2,20-Bishydroxymethyldibenzo-30-crown-10 [diquat]2þ}(PF6) 2 (CULCER) was also prepared but the structure was not determined because of its complexity; the crystals are of interest because it is possible that spontaneous resolution of the crown ether had occurred on crystallization (the space group is P2221, Z ¼ 8). O O
O
O 3.13
Scheme 3.6
Another type of molecular tweezer 3.13 has been synthesized by Harmata and Barnes (1990); this molecule has a U-shape despite its planar representation. Although crystals of the neat compound were not obtained, it could be crystallized together with a molecule of 1,3,5-trinitrobenzene (JESCAL; P21/c, Z ¼ 4) to give a cleft structure analogous to that shown in Fig. 3.16, the TNB molecule being held within the jaws of the host. It was suggested that the face-to-face donor–acceptor interactions (see Chapter 15) were supplemented by a face-to-edge interaction between a positively charged hydrogen of TNB pointing towards the centre of the -system of the central benzene ring; such interactions have been proposed for analogous systems (Burley and Pesko, 1986). 3.13a has a similar behaviour; it could only be crystallized as a 1 : 1 complex with nitrobenzene, ‘‘probably because different conformations precipitated together so that a single crystalline product could not form.’’ The guest molecule was located within the cleft of
47
CLEFT MOLECUL ES AS HOST S
the ‘‘naphthalene-walled clip’’ (Reek, Engelkamp, Rowan, Elemans and Nolte, 1998; BIZRAD, P1, Z ¼ 2; no 3D coordinates), as shown on the right. nitrobenzene guest OMe O MeO N Ph N OMe
N Ph N
O
O
O MeO 3.13a
N1
C1
C21
C1⬘ N1⬘ C21⬘
Scheme 3.7
Related molecules have been used for the synthesis of belt and collar shaped potential hosts for intermolecular complex formation. Crystal structures have been reported for two cylindrical hosts but not, as yet, for any complexes (Ashton, Brown, Isaacs et al., 1992; FUJGOG10; GIJWIF10). 3.3.2 Double-cleft hosts Saddle-shaped hosts, with two approximately mutually perpendicular clefts, have been reported (Schwartz, Knobler and Cram, 1992). As an example we reproduce a stereodiagram (Fig. 3.17) of one of these hosts with two enclosed molecules of benzene (JUSXIE). The
Fig. 3.17. Stereodiagram of a double-cleft host with a benzene guest in each cleft. (Reproduced from Schwartz, Knobler and Cram, 1992.)
48
CROWN ETHERS, CRYPTANDS AND RE LATED MOLECUL ES AS HOST S
crystals are tetragonal, space group I41/a and each molecule has S4 symmetry, the two clefts thus being equivalent. 3.4 3.4.1
Container molecules as hosts Introduction
An appreciable portion of the rest of this chapter is concerned with the work of D. J. Cram and colleagues at the University of California at Los Angeles. This has been described recently (Cram and Cram, 1994) in more detail than we can accommodate here; the series ‘‘Host-Guest Complexation’’ had reached No. 68 by 1997. Cram and coworkers use the following abbreviation (X)G where (X) is the container molecule and G the encapsulated guest, and (X)[G where the guest is perching or accommodated between (rather than within) the host molecules; we shall use our own notation described earlier. We (again) briefly summarise the nomenclature. The container molecule is given the suffix ‘‘-and’’ and the complex the suffix ‘‘-ate’’ or, more usually, ‘‘-plex.’’ Thus, at one extreme of the classification, cavitands are bowl-shaped molecular vessels, essentially closed at one end but open at the other; they contain enforced concave interior surfaces of molecular dimensions (Cram, Karbach et al., 1988). They form caviplexes without steric inhibition to either the complexation or decomplexation processes. At the other extreme one has the carcerands, which entrap guest molecules permanently within their shells by constrictive binding; this implies that the guests are incorporated during synthesis and presumably also have some template role. The hemicarcerands are intermediate, and have portals through which the guest molecules can enter or escape the host cavity, with energy barriers large enough to allow isolation and characterization of the complexes at normal temperatures. Cram has described these quasi-spherical molecules as having polar caps, generally rigid, joined by chains of atoms which can be rigid or flexible, and cover the temperate and equatorial zones. A generalized diagram is given in Fig. 3.20 below, where the polar caps are called ‘‘spacers’’ and the linking chains of atoms ‘‘connectors.’’ 3.4.2
Cavitands and caviplexes
A general formula for cavitands is shown in the insert (3.14, n ¼ 1, 2, 3; R ¼ CH3, Br, I); the overall dimensions can be changed by introducing methylene bridges of varying length while the solubility can be manipulated by replacement of the methyls by suitable groups. The methylene bridges have been replaced by quinoxaline (or analogous) flaps; these can be all axial with respect to the rest of the molecule, giving a vase conformation, or all equatorial, giving a kite conformation (Moran, Ericson, Dalcanale, Bryant, Knobler and Cram, 1991). A remarkable result was obtained for a derivative of host 3.14 in which the methylene bridges were replaced by quinoxalines and the pendant methyl groups by menthoxy (OOC(–)menthyl). Complexes of this host with aromatic guests such as benzene and toluene were shown, by desorption chemical ionization (DCI) mass spectrometry, to exist in the gas phase provided the temperature of the ion source was below 100 C. It was suggested that these complexes were formed by complexation of neutral benzene and neutral cavitand molecules in the gas phase, followed by ionization (Vincenti, Dalcanale, Soncini and Guglielmetti, 1990).
49
C ONT AINE R M OL E C UL E S AS HOSTS
Crystal structures were determined for nine caviplexes with methylene bridges, and seven of these contain uncomplexed, intermolecular, guests in addition to complexed, intramolecular, guests (Cram, Karbach et al., 1988). The space groups of two of the caviplexes show that spontaneous resolution of the enantiomeric host has occurred on crystallization. The conical cavitands are supported on the four methyl groups. The nearly closed bases of the cavities are defined by a 16-membered [1.1.1.1] metacyclophane ˚ , too small to allow passage of guest macroring, with an internal diameter of about 3 A molecules. The open tops are defined by [mmmm] meta-cyclophane macrorings con˚. taining eight oxygens and from 24 to 35 ring atoms, with internal diameters of 9–10 A We note some special features: R ¼ H, n ¼ 1, guest CH2Cl2, C2/c, Z ¼ 8. The guest perches above the open end of the bowl. When the guest is CH3CN, the space group is the noncentrosymmetric P4. An additional CH3CN molecule is located interstitially between the host molecules. R ¼ CH3, n ¼ 1, intramolecular guest cyclohexane, intermolecular guest benzene, P212121, Z ¼ 4; spontaneous resolution (of the enantiomeric host) has occurred on crystallization. The cyclohexane, perched above the open end of the bowl, is said to be in the boat conformation but this requires confirmation, especially as the R factor was 15%. R ¼ Br, n ¼ 1, inner methyls replaced by CH2CH2C6H5 (for solubilization), H2O present both as intramolecular and intermolecular guest, space group Pnma, Z ¼ 4 (the host molecule has a mirror plane) (Sherman, Knobler and Cram, 1991; JILZEJ). This caviplex is important in the synthesis of carceplexes (see Section 3.4.6).
R (CH2)n O
O (CH2)n
O
O CH3
H
H
R O
CH3
CH3 H
H
R
CH3
O
O
N
R'
O
N
R'
O (CH2)n
(CH2)n O R
Substituted quinoxaline
3.14
Scheme 3.8
A particularly rigid host is obtained by replacing the CH2 groups bridging the oxygens by Si(CH3)2 to give C40H48Si4O8 (5,10;12,17;19,24;26,3-tetrakis-(dimethylsiladioxa)1,8,15,22-tetramethyl[14]metacyclophane, the cavitand shown in Fig. 3.1). In the crystal structure of {C40H48Si4O8[CS2]}CS2 (Goldberg, 1986; CUYXEZ10) one guest molecule lies along the central, (approximately) fourfold axis of the host, while the second lies between adjacent host molecules in the [100] direction (Fig. 3.18), illustrating the delicacy of the balance between intra- and intermolecular enclosure. The enclosed guest is in a
50
CROWN ETHERS, CRYPTANDS AND RE LATED MOLECUL ES AS HOST S
x z y
x z
y
Fig. 3.18. Stereoviews, parallel (a) and perpendicular (b) to the cavity surface, of the 1 : 2 molecular inclusion complex of the cavitand C40H48Si4O8 with CS2. There is another CS2 molecule between adjacent hosts. (Data from Goldberg, 1986.)
lipophilic environment composed of phenyl groups within the cavity and methyl groups on and above its surface. The host has a dish-like shape, and is thus representative also of the cavitands described above. 3.4.3
Hemispherands and hemispheraplexes
Hemispherands are receptor molecules in which at least half of the binding sites for intramolecular complexation are pre-organized, and complexes are known with alkali metal and alkylammonium cations and neutral organic molecules. The factors governing the binding of malononitrile (CH2(CN)2) to four hemispherands have been studied by combining the results of crystal structure analyses, molecular mechanics calculations and solution thermodynamic measurements (Grootenhuis, van Eerden, Dijkstra, Harkema and Reinhoudt, 1987). We take one example (3.15, formula with n ¼ 1; C30H36O6). The crystal structures of 3.15 (at 113 K, P21/c, Z ¼ 4; MOMODT, Goldberg, 1980) and {3.15[CH2(CN)2]}0.60 (C2H5)2O (C2/m, Z ¼ 4; Grootenhuis, van Eerden, Dijkstra, Harkema and Reinhoudt, 1987; DUTDOL10) have been reported; the conformations of the host are compared in Fig. 3.19. Molecular mechanics calculations using these conformations give strain energies of 57 and 64 kJ/mol, indicating that the host is more strained when it has the conformation taken up in the complex. NMR measurements (240–320 K; in CDCl3 solution) give the association constant as 28 M1
51
C ONT AINE R M OL E C UL E S AS HOSTS
CH3 CH3
H 3C X
X
O X = OCH3
012
08
X O
01
04
O n
Fig. 3.19. Comparison of the conformations taken up by 3.15 (n ¼ 1) in its neat crystals (centre) and in its complex {3.15[CH2(CN)2]}0.60 (C2H5)2O (right). (Reproduced from Grootenhuis, van Eerden, Dijkstra, Harkema and Reinhoudt, 1987.)
at 298 K, H ¼ 35.1, TS ¼ 26.8 and G ¼ 8.4 kJ/mol. The complex is enthalpy-stabilized in solution and, presumably, also in the solid state. The interaction energy between host and guest must be about 42 kJ/mol (we have ignored any influence of solvent molecules in the crystals of the complex). This will be due to four bifurcated C–H . . . O hydrogen bonds from guest to host (Fig. 3.19), and van der Waals interactions. t-Butylammonium perchlorate ((CH3)3CNH3þClO4) forms a complex with 3.15 (n ¼ 1) in which there are three Nþ–H . . . O hydrogen bonds to the oxygens of the three methoxy groups; there is also a conformational change on complexation but the strain energy of the macrocycle does not seem to have been calculated. The free energy of formation of the complex is 32.1 kJ/mol (in CDCl3 solution) (Koenig, Lein, Stuckler, Kaneda and Cram, 1979), four times greater than that of the malononitrile complex; values of H and TS have not yet been reported.
3.4.4 Triply bridged cyclophanes and analogous molecules as three-dimensional hosts for intramolecular guests The first enclosure (or container) molecule to be purposefully synthesized was that of the [2.2.2] cryptand (Dietrich, Lehn and Sauvage, 1968) shown in Fig. 3.20. For reasons of space, we shall discuss only some aspects of cryptand structural chemistry and refer the reader to the broader account given by Dietrich (1996). A general formulation of an enclosure molecule is shown in Fig. 3.20; the synthetic methods used for translating the schematic into real molecules have been summarised by Seel and Vo¨gtle (1992). A formally simple realization of the schematic of Fig. 3.20 (left) is shown in Fig. 3.20 (right) and has been achieved by O’Krongly, Denmeade, Chiang and Breslow (1985; R ¼ CH3) and Vo¨gtle, Berscheid and Schnick (1991; R ¼ H). We now consider crystallographic data on the modes of enclosure. The crystal structures of {C56H38O6.[CH3CN]} (P21/c, Z ¼ 4; JIHJEP, Vo¨gtle et al.) and {C57H40O6[C6H6]}2C6H6 (triclinic, P1, Z ¼ 2); DECWOX, O’Krongly et al.) have been reported in these two papers; the spacer is RC(p-C6H4O–)3 and the connector –C C–C C–. The shapes taken up by the host molecules are appreciably different in the two crystals; O’Krongly et al. (1985) noted that
52
CROWN ETHERS, CRYPTANDS AND RE LATED MOLECUL ES AS HOST S
O
O O N
O N O
O
[2.2.2]cryptand Spacer R
o
o o Connectors o
o
o
R
Spacer
Fig. 3.20. (above) Line diagram of [2.2.2]cryptand. (Below left) General formulation of an enclosure molecule. The spacers illustrated have three links, as in sym-C6H3(CH2NH2)3, but four and six link spacers have also been used successfully. The chemical nature of the connectors is matched to that of the spacers. The spacers can be different, as can the connectors. (Below right) Example of the translations of the general formulation into practice, as achieved by Breslow (R ¼ CH3) and Vo¨gtle (R ¼ H) and their coworkers. (Adapted from Seel and Vo¨gtle, 1992.)
their compound was ‘‘self-adjusting’’. One of the phenyl groups is twisted so as to interact with the included benzene molecule in a face-to-edge fashion, whereas the -acceptor acetonitrile molecule, disordered over two positions, has its nitrile -orbitals interacting with phenyl groups in both face-to-edge and face-to-face fashion. The spacer of an analogous host is 1,3,5-C6H3(O–)3; in this supramolecule, with acetonitrile as guest, it is the methyl group of the guest which interacts with a phenyl of the host (Berscheid, Nieger and Vo¨gtle, 1991; JODMOE, P21/c, Z ¼ 4). Two triply substituted aromatic rings, linked by poly(methylene ether) chains, form enclosures which can take up guests in intramolecular fashion. One example is 3.16 (shown schematically in the formula of Scheme 3.9 and in its correct shape in Fig. 3.21), which encloses diquat2þ in an hexafluorophosphate salt (Allwood, Kohnke, Stoddart and Williams, 1985); here the two spacers are benzenes linked between 1- and 2- positions by two -O-[(CH2)2-O]- chains and between 5-positions by a -(CH2)-O-(C6H4)-O-(CH2)chain. The crystal structures of the neat neutral host (orthorhombic, Pcab, Z ¼ 8; DAXMOE) and of the salt {3.16[Diquat2þ]}(PF6)2 (triclinic P1, Z ¼ 2; DAXMUK) have been reported. Comparison of the host conformation in the two crystals shows that some reorganization occurs on complexation (Fig. 3.21).
C ONT AINE R M OL E C UL E S AS HOSTS
53
[Diquat]2+
y
x
z
y
z
x
Fig. 3.21. On the right is shown the host-guest arrangement in the salt {3.16[diquat]}(PF6)2 (DAXMUK) and on the left the somewhat different conformations of the host in the neat material. (Data from Allwood, Kohnke, Stoddart and Williams, 1985.)
R2 R1
R1 3.16 R1 = –O–(CH2)2–O-; R2 = –CH2–O–(C6H4)–O–CH2–
Scheme 3.9
The triply linked macrocyclic polyammonium receptor 3.17 binds dicarboxylate substrates (Lehn, Me´ric, Vigneron, Bkouche-Waksman and Pascard, 1991); linear substrates of formula O2C(CH2)nCO 2 (n ¼ 2–8) and fumarate and maleate have stability constants Ks ranging from 1400–4100 M1, while terephthalate has a Ks value more than an order of magnitude greater. Determination of the crystal structure of the terephthalate complex, which has space group Pnna, Z ¼ 4 (SIRZAU) shows that it indeed contains a ‘‘supramolecular species of cryptate nature in which two binding subunits of the ditopic coreceptor molecule cooperate in substrate binding,’’ but is in fact considerably more complicated, as is made clear by Lehn et al. (1991). The asymmetric unit consists of the intramolecular complex shown in Fig. 3.22, made up of the macrocycle and an enclosed terephthalate dianion (T(1)2), the complex having a two fold axis of symmetry normal to the N . . . N axis, a terephthalate dianion on a center of symmetry (T(2)2), another terephthalate dianion disordered over two orientations (T(3)2), five ordered water
54
CROWN ETHERS, CRYPTANDS AND RE LATED MOLECUL ES AS HOST S
Fig. 3.22. The intramolecular complex made up of the macrocycle 3.17 and enclosed terephthalate dianion, viewed from the side in outline (left) and space-filling (right) modes and, in the centre, along the N . . . N axis, which is normal to the complex’s crystallographic twofold axis of symmetry. O and N atoms are shaded. (Reproduced from Lehn, Me´ric, Vigneron, Bkouche-Waksman and Pascard, 1991.)
molecules and two more waters disordered over four sites. The asymmetric unit should thus be formulated as 1=2f3:176þ ½Tð1Þ2 g Tð2Þ2 Tð3Þ2 ð5 þ ð4X1=2ÞÞ H2 O, or 1=2fC57 H78 N8 6þ ½ O2 CðC6 H4 ÞCO2 g ð O2 CðC6 H4 ÞCO2 Þ ð O2 CðC6 H4 Þ CO2 Þ ð5 þ ð4X1=2ÞÞH2 O:
An intricate arrangement of hydrogen bonds links all these units. The four oxygens of the included terephthalate dianion are hydrogen bonded to the four ammonium groups, and also to neighboring water molecules; thus the intramolecular interaction is largely, but not entirely, one-dimensional. The view down the N . . . N axis reinforces the point made previously that it can be misleading to draw inferences about the shape of a complex from projections onto mean planes, as in the left- and right-hand parts of Fig. 3.22. Cavitand hosts capable of complexing small organic molecules have been synthesized using cyclotriveratrylene as spacer and –OCH2CH2CH2O– as connectors; these have been called cryptophanes (Collet, 1987). Cryptophane C (3.18; C54H51O9) has a stability constant Ks5 of 300 M1 for complexation with CH2Cl2 (Canceill, Cesario, Collet, Guilhem and Pascard, 1985) in CDCl3 solution, while that for Cryptophane D (3.19) is about twelve times smaller (both measured by 200 MHz NMR in solution) (Canceill, Cesario, Collet, Guilhem, Riche and Pascard, 1986); the values given in the earlier reports have been corrected by Collet (1987) following Canceill, Lacombe and Collet (1987). The energy barriers for inclusion and extrusion of the CH2Cl2 guest in both hosts were determined from the maximum broadening of the NMR signal (Table 3.3). CH2Cl2 seems 5 * The true stability constant is Ks ¼ Ks0(1 þ KsCDCl3[CDCl3]) where Ks0 is the apparent stability constant and KsCDCl3 is the stability constant of the CDCl3 cavitate ( 0.1 M1 for cryptophane C) and [CDCl3] ¼ 12.4 M. At high temperatures (310–330 K), Ks 2.1 Ks0 .
55
C ONT AINE R M OL E C UL E S AS HOSTS
Table 3.3. Energy barriers (kJ/mol) for inclusion and extrusion of CH2Cl2 guest in Cryptophane C and D hosts in CDCl3 solution Host molecule
G# (inclusion)
G# (extrusion)
Cryptophane C Cryptophane D
45.2 49.5
47.0 46.1
Table 3.4. Thermodynamic parameters for intramolecular complexes of Cryptophane E with various guests. G refers to 300K; units for G and H are kJ/mol and for S J/mol K. The volumes were described as ‘van der Waals’ volumes without further definition Guest
˚ 3) V (A
G
H
CH3I CH2Cl2 CH2Br2 CHCl3 CHCl2Br CH(CH3)3 CHClBr2 CHBr3 CCl4 C(CH3)Cl3 C(CH3)2Cl2 C(CH3)3Cl CH3COCH3
54.5 57.6 65.5 72.2 76.1 79.4 80.1 84.0 86.8 89.2 91.6 93.9 70.0
10.0 11.7 12.6 15.5 14.2 11.7 12.1 9.6 5.0 0.8 0.4 3.3 5.4
S
4.2
25
25.1 21.8 15.9 6.3 5.9
29 25 13 17 17
Type of stabilization entropy enthalpy enthalpy enthalpy enthalpy and entropy enthalpy and entropy
c⬘ b⬘ O O Me
O
O Me
O Me
O
O
O
O
O Me
O O Me
O
O
O
O Me
b
Cl 13 c Cl 23
O
Cryptophane C (3.18) ((–) enantiomer)
O
a⬘ a
Cryptophane D (3.19) ((+) enantiomer)
Fig. 3.23. Left – schematic formulae of 3.18 and 3.19. Right – {Cryptophane D[CH2Cl2]} cavitate, showing the view down the pseudo-C3 axis, with 50% probability anisotropic thermal ellipsoids for the guest molecule (radii of other atoms are fixed arbitrarily). (Reproduced from Canceill, Cesario, Collet, Guilhem and Pascard, 1985.)
56
CROWN ETHERS, CRYPTANDS AND RE LATED MOLECUL ES AS HOST S
to enter the cavity of Cryptophane C more easily than that of Cryptophane D and is retained there more strongly. There is not much difference in the rates of leaving (extrusion). The crystal structures of these two isomeric intramolecular complexes have been reported. The crystals of {Cryptophane C[CH2Cl2]}2CH2Cl2 have two additional CH2Cl2 molecules located between the molecules of the complex and are monoclinic (P21/n, Z ¼ 4; CUSCEY) and racemic. The packing consists of alternate homochiral layers of ( þ ) and ( ) enantiomers of Cryptophane C. The cycloveratrylene spacers are mutually rotated by about 60 so the host has a pseudo-C3 axis (Fig. 3.23). The intermolecular dichloromethanes are accommodated in pairs in relatively large voids between groups of host molecules. The orthorhombic crystals of {( þ )-Cryptophane D[CH2Cl2]}1.25CH2Cl2 (space group P212121, Z ¼ 4; DIJJUB) have two additional dichloromethane sites located between the host molecules with occupation factors of 0.5 and 0.75; the space group shows that the macrocycle has resolved spontaneously on crystallization. The dichloromethane of the ‘‘supermolecule’’ shows no signs of disorder, but the interstitial dichloromethanes are loosely held in the crystal, which is efflorescent. Cryptophane E (three additional methoxy groups compared to C and D) forms a chloroform inclusion complex of composition {C57H60O12[CHCl3]}0.2CHCl30.2H2O (space group P21/n, Z ¼ 4; Canceill, Cesario, Collet, Guilhem, Lacombe, Lozach and Pascard, 1989; SEDPOG); this cryptophane also has a pseudo-C3 axis. Thermodynamic parameters have been measured for complexation of Cryptophane E and various guests (1H NMR measurements at 300 and 330 K, 1,1,2,2-tetrachloro-1,2-deuterioethane solvent); these parameters are listed against molecular volume in Table 3.4. A plot of G against volume for the various substituted methanes has a roughly parabolic shape, with a ˚ 3; the most stable complex is formed by chloroform, presumably minimum at 73 A because it fits most snugly into the cavity. The type of stabilization is also listed for those molecular complexes where separate H and S values are available. The methylene chloride complex is exceptional in that it is entropy stabilized. The acetone complex does not fit into the substituted methane series. Remarkably, Cryptophane E is easily oxidized þ to give a crystalline radical cation salt of composition {C57H60O12 [CHCl3]}PF6, the chloroform remaining included in the host cation (Renault, Talham, Canceill, Batail, Collet and Lajzerowicz, 1989; cf. Chapter 13). An isomeric pair of molecules analogous to the cryptophanes, with similar but not identical spacers and –OCH2–C C–C C–CH2O– connectors, has been synthesized, one of which is racemic (3.20; C66H54O62(CH2Cl2)) and the other (3.21; C66H54O6(CHCl3)) meso (Cram, Tanner, Keipert and Knobler, 1991; JOHGES, P1, Z ¼ 2). The crystal structure of 3.20 (space group Pbca, Z ¼ 8; JOHGAO) shows that the molecule has a compact form and near-spherical cavity capable of enclosing small molecules such as CHCl3, (CH3)3COH, CH2Cl2, cubane, propylene oxide and benzene. The value of Ks for benzene at 20 is 103 M1 and the activation free energy for decomplexation of benzene at 20 is 50 kJ/mol. Meso-3.21, which has an ellipsoidal cavity, does not complex the above guests in (CCl3)2CO solution, possibly because of competition from the solvent. There is also a more compact pair (3.22, 3.23) with shorter connectors (Tanner, Knobler and Cram, 1990; Fig. 3.24). Crystal structures have been determined (Tanner, Knobler and Cram, 1992). for {3.22[CH3CN]}CH3CN (triclinic, P1, Z ¼ 2; JORVER) and the isomorphous crystals of {3.23[CH3OH]}CH3OH (JORVIV) and {3.23[empty]}CH2Cl2 (JORVOB) (both rhombohedral, space group R 3, hexagonal cell dimensions for the
tosylate Ts
Ts
Ts
N
N
N
O
tosylate
S N
• CH3CN CH3CN CH3O
OCH3
methoxy
OCH3
tosylate
enclosed acetonitrile methoxy
acetonitrile of crystallization
methoxy
y
3.22. [CH3CN]·CH3CN (JORVER) z
x N
H
H
H
N
N
N
• CH3Cl2
N
methoxy methoxy
CH3O
OCH3
3.23. [empty]·CH2Cl2 (JORVIV)
methoxy
OCH3
disordered methylene chloride
x
y z
Fig. 3.24. Line formulae and molecular diagrams for the two hemicarceplexes 3.22 and 3.23. The CSD has erroneously interchanged the sets of coordinates given for isomorphous JORVIV and JORVOB. The former, labeled as containing both included methanol and methanol of crystallization, actually lists only methylene chloride of crystallization: the latter does not include coordinates for either type of methanol. (Data from Tanner, Knobler and Cram 1992.)
58
CROWN ETHERS, CRYPTANDS AND RE LATED MOLECUL ES AS HOST S
CH2Cl2 complex and (bracketed) the CH3OH complex: a ¼ 14.301(3) (14.262(2)), ˚ , V ¼ 7950 (7912) A ˚ 3, Z ¼ 6 (1/3 of a molecule in the asymc ¼ 44.65(1) (44.914(6)) A metric unit)). Stereodiagrams of the host – guest complexes are shown in Fig. 3.24. 3.23 in CDCl3 binds O2, N2 and H2O weakly and CH3OH with Ka 47 M1 (G295 ¼ 10 kJ/ mol, H 36 kJ/mol and S 88 J/mol K). Comparison of the two isomorphous rhombohedral structures shows that 3.23 is rigid enough for the presence or absence of a guest not to affect its shape. Very strong binding of p-nitrophenol in CD2Cl2 is shown by the triply linked hosts 3.24 and 3.25; the value of Kassoc is about 3.5 104 mol1 for 3.24 and about 10 104 mol1 for 3.25 (Cochran, Parrott, Whitlock and Whitlock, 1992). The crystal structures of the 1 : 1 intramolecular complexes of 3.24 and 3.25 with p-nitrophenol have been determined (as the bis(1,2-dichloroethane) (SUBZOE; C45H34N2O8C6H5NO32(C2H4Cl2); P21/a, Z ¼ 4) and 1,2-dichloroethane (SUBZIY; C45H34N2O8C6H5NO3(C2H4Cl2); P1, Z ¼ 2) solvates respectively), and show similar dispositions of guest to host (Fig. 3.25). NMR measurements confirm that these dispositions are maintained in solution. Hydrogen bonding ˚ between the hydroxyl of the guest and the pyridinium N of the host (d(O–H . . . N) ¼ 2.69 A ˚ (3.24) and 2.77 A (3.25)), noted in earlier work on analogous compounds (Sheridan and Whitlock, 1986, 1988; Whitlock and Whitlock, 1990), was inexplicably not mentioned in a later claim (Cochran, Parrott, Whitlock and Whitlock, 1992) that the detailed
O
O
O
O
O
O
O N O
O
N O
O
O
O
O
O 3.24
∗
3.25
N N
∗
N
N O
CH3 ∗ N CH3
∗
N N
CH3 N CH3
{3.25·[p-nitrophenol]}
Fig. 3.25. Upper – line formulae of 3.24 and 3.25. Lower – stereodiagram showing the disposition of guest and host in the supramolecular complex of 3.25 with p-nitrophenol; the triple bonds of the host molecule are marked with asterisks and oxygens are shown by hatched circles. In terms of the nomenclature used in Fig. 3.20(a), the substituted naphthalenes are the spacers of the host molecules, which have three different connectors. (Reproduced from Cochran, Parrott, Whitlock and Whitlock, 1992.)
C ONT AINE R M OL E C UL E S AS HOSTS
59
geometry of these complexes is dominated by formation of a hydrogen bond involving the electron-rich p-xylene connector and the acidic o-nitro proton of the guest. As the OH . . . N hydrogen bonding has an energy of 30 kJ/mol, while the hydrogen bond contributes only about one-quarter of this to the intramolecular cohesion, it is clear that the former dominates.
3.4.5 Spherands and spheraplexes Spherands are macrocyclic or macropolycyclic systems where the ligands are organised, during synthesis and prior to complexation, in such a way that the unshared electron pairs of the binding sites line a roughly spherical cavity maintained by auxiliary covalent bonding (Cram, Kaneda et al., 1985; Cram and Trueblood, 1981; Cram, 1986). A comprehensive account, with some forty stereodiagrams of spherands, spheraplexes, hemispherands and hemispheraplexes, has been given by Maverick and Cram (1996a); we are perforce more modest. An essential requirement is that the spherand molecule should be rigid and not turned back on itself, with the interior cavity relatively unsolvated. A test of this concept is provided by comparing the geometrical structures of a neat spherand and those of the corresponding spheraplexes. This has been done for spherand 3.26 (C48H48O6; formula not shown), {3.26[Liþ]}Cl and {3.26[Naþ]}CH3SO4C6H5CH3 (Trueblood, Maverick and Knobler, 1991). The spherand moiety maintains nearly the same shape in all three crystals; the cavity is large enough to enclose only lithium or sodium ions. In one type of chemical modification of the prototype spherand the six methoxy groups of the interior were replaced by fluorines; the structure of an intermolecular complex of composition C42H30F62CH2Cl2, with interstitial disordered methylene chlorides, has been reported (Trueblood, Maverick and Knobler, 1991). In another type of modification, augmented spherands were prepared by replacing two pairs of ‘‘meta’’ methoxy groups by –OXO– bridges, where X ¼ –CH2CH2OCH2CH2–, –CH2CH2CH2– or –CH2CH2CH2CH2–. Crystal structures were reported for C52H52O8 (VOWVOS), C52H52O8LiCl3H2O (CAWRIB20). C50H48O6LiFeCl40.5CH2Cl2 (CAWREX20), C52H52O6LiCl3(C6H6) (VOWWEJ) and C50H48LiOþ 6 Cl 3(toluene) (VOWWIN). (VOWWEJ (reported as C2/c) and VOWWIN (reported as I2/a) are isomorphous (similar reduced triclinic cells). Lithium ions are enclosed in the interiors of all these hosts. These structures are extremely rigid, and the aromatic rings are very deformed; ˚ , 10% less than the sum of some intramolecular oxygen . . . oxygen contacts are about 2.5 A the van der Waals radii (Knobler, Maverick and Trueblood, 1992).
3.4.6 Carcerands and carceplexes Carcerands are noncollapsible molecular cells whose interiors are large enough to contain molecules or ions as guests and whose closed surfaces contain pores that are too small to allow guest molecules to enter or depart from their interiors without making or breaking covalent bonds; the concept was first proposed in 1983 (Cram, 1983) and a general account of the reduction of the idea to practice has been given by Maverick and Cram (1996b). A carceplex is composed of a carcerand containing at least one guest (prisoner)
60
CROWN ETHERS, CRYPTANDS AND RE LATED MOLECUL ES AS HOST S
molecule in its interior. The carceplexes were made by shell-closing two identical bowl-shaped cavitands, each containing on their rims four phenolic hydroxyls (Scheme 3.10; Sherman, Knobler and Cram, 1991). The cavitands also contain pendant functional groups for enhancement of their solubilities. In each synthesis, one molecule of solvent was incarcerated, the shell closure being templated by the guest ultimately enclosed. C4
H
HO O
2X
O
O
OH
O
O
OH
O
O
OH O
H
C CH2 CH2
C
H
CH2
H
C CH2
CH2
CH2
C
CH2 CH2 CH2 CH2 H C C
CH2 H
CH2
CH2
CH2
C
C
H
O O
CH2BrCl
H CH2
O
O C2 O
O
O
O
O
O G
CH2
O
CH2
O
O
CH2
O
O CH2
O O
O
O
CH2
O O
O
σh
O O
H
C CH2 CH2
3.27
C CH2 CH2
H
H
C
C
CH2
CH2
CH2
H
CH2
3.28
Scheme 3.10
Carceplexes containing (CH3)2NCOCH3, (CH3)2NCHO and dimethyl sulphoxide were prepared in solution; in earlier work with a different carcerand, insoluble complexes with (CH3)2NCHO, (CH2)4O, Csþ, argon and ClCF2CF2Cl had been prepared (Cram, Karbach, Kim, Baczynskyj and Kalleymeyn, 1985; Cram, Karbach, Kim, Baczynskyj, Marti, Sampson and Kalleymeyn, 1988). The crystal structure of {3.28.[(CH3)2NCOCH3]}0.5 CHCl3 (additional, but not fully identified, solvent molecules ˚, were present) has been determined (triclinic, a ¼ 16.302(3), b ¼ 18.940(3), c ¼ 23.182(4) A 1; R ¼ 0.184 at time of publication; ¼ 90.22(1), ¼ 93.97(1), g ¼ 102.38(1) , Z ¼ 2, P JILZIN). The {carcerand.[guest]} complex is shown in the stereodiagram of Fig. 3.26. ˚ and The cavity has the shape of a prolate ellipsoid of revolution with long axis 10.9 A ˚ . The upper half of the host is rotated by 15 with respect to the lower short axis 6.2 A half, thus making the molecule chiral. That the guest is well and truly incarcerated was demonstrated by heating the complex in C6D5NO2 solution to 160 , subsequent cooling producing no change in the NMR spectrum. In Cram’s view the interior of the carceplex is a definable mixture of free space and space-filling guests – ‘‘guest plus vacuum in varying proportions’’ – and thus constitutes a new phase of matter (see Cram and Cram (1994), p. 148). The two reacting tetrols (3.27) in Scheme 3.10 can be joined by hydrogen bonds rather than by covalent linkages. This has been done by carrying out the reaction in the presence of 1,8-diazabicyclo[5.4.0]undec-7-ene, which acts as a proton acceptor and forms cations (C9H17N2þ) while the two halves of the anionic carcerand are joined by charged hydrogen bonds (Chapman, Olovsson, Trotter and Sherman, 1998). Pyrazine was found to be the most strongly bound guest of those tried, and its complex (HIMJES; P4cc, Z ¼ 4; {C36H32O12(C36H28O12)4[C4H4N2]4(C9H17Nþ 2 )2(C6H5NO2)4H2O}) was about
HEMICARCERANDS AND HEMICARCEPLEXES
61
{3.28·[(CH3)2NCOCH3]}
Fig. 3.26. Stereoscopic side view of the {carcerand[guest]} complex {3.28[(CH3)2NCOCH3]} (JILZIN); the guest (dark outline) was not well enough defined to allow distinction among C, N and O atoms. Hydrogens have been omitted in this diagram; if included, then it is clear that there is no chance of the guest escaping without breaking bonds. (Reproduced from Sherman, Knobler and Cram, 1991.)
2000 times more stable than that of benzene. Crystal structure analysis showed that the pyrazines (disordered over two orientations) had their nitrogens in the equatorial plane of the host; they were involved in weak hydrogen bonding to half of the hydrogens of the intrabowl methylenes.
3.5 Hemicarcerands and hemicarceplexes 3.5.1 Overview A hemicarcerand is a host molecule that combines an enforced inner cavity large enough to accommodate solvent molecules with a portal which allows guest entry and exit at temperatures above 100 . This definition has a functional rather than a chemical structural basis and two types have so far been synthesized. In the first type, the reacting tetrols of Scheme 3.10 (above) are replaced by triols, with the consequence that the dimer product of the shell-closing reaction will have an opening at one corner of its waistband, the inner space of the cavity no longer being entirely cut off from its surroundings as happens in the carcerands. 3.29 is an example of a Type I hemicarcerand host molecule
62
CROWN ETHERS, CRYPTANDS AND RE LATED MOLECUL ES AS HOST S
(Cram, Tanner and Knobler, 1991). It was suggested that the term constrictive binding be used for the steric repulsions (decomplexation activation energy) that must be overcome in the decomplexation process.
H2C H
O
H2C
H2C CH2 CH2 H C
H
C
O O
O
C
O
CH2 Hb O
O
C H CH2 CH2 H2C H2C H
O O
G
Ha O
O
O
O
O O CH2
H2C CH2 CH2 H C C
O
O
O
O O CH2 O O
C C H CH2 CH2 H2C H2C H
3.29
Scheme 3.11
Type I hemicarceplexes with 3.29 as host and containing (CH3)2NCOCH3, (CH3)2NCHO, dimethyl sulphoxide, (CH3)CN, CH2Cl2, CH2Br2, CS2, Xe (Ks 200 M1) and Ar were prepared in solution, isolated and characterized. The crystal structure of {3.29[(CH3)2NCOCH3]}2CH3CN2CHCl3 was determined (orthorhombic, ˚ , Z ¼ 8, Pbna; R ¼ 0.168 at time of a ¼ 20.455(5), b ¼ 20.773(5), c ¼ 30.307(8) A publication; KEHDAC10; Cram, Tanner and Knobler, 1991). The {hemicarcerand[guest]} complex has an overall shape similar to that shown in the stereodiagram of Fig. 3.26. NMR studies showed the formation in solution of hemicarceplexes with nitrogen (Ks 180 M1), oxygen (Ks 44 M1) and H2O. Type II hemicarcerands have been prepared in which the relatively short equatorial linking –OCH2O– groups were replaced by the longer –CH2SCH2– groups (Bryant, Blanda, Vincenti and Cram, 1991). Enantiomerically pure analogs were made by using (R)- or (S)-2,2’-bis(bromomethyl)-1,10 -binaphthyl as linking groups. In somewhat later work analogs were produced in which the four linking groups were (1,3-CH¼N–C6H4– N¼CH–), which is rigid, and where portals and inner-space volume were large enough to permit entry and occupation by hosts such as [2.2]paracyclophane, ferrocene, adamantane and camphor (Quan and Cram, 1991). Other analogs have the semi-mobile o-xylyl {1,2–OCH2C6H4CH2O–)} as linking group (Cram, Blanda, Paek and Knobler, 1991; VURBUF; Pcan, Z ¼ 4; C160H136O2418(C4H9NO)) (hemicarcerand abbreviated as 3.30, formula not given; C4H9NO is dimethylacetamide); a more recent example encapsulates hydrocarbons with molecular weights greater than 200 (Cram, Jaeger and Deshayes, 1993). The hosts are all tetra-linked and hence are analogous, from the standpoint of chemical structure, to the carcerand 3.28. Nevertheless, they are named as hemicarcerands on the functional ground that entry and exit of the guest occurs without breaking covalent bonds. Qualitative information about structural recognition of guest by host 3.29 is provided by the facile incarceration of p-xylene compared to the nonincarceration of the other two
HEMICARCERANDS AND HEMICARCEPLEXES
63
Table 3.5. Thermodynamic parameters (solution in 1,2(CD3)2C6D4 at 100 ) of the 3.30 hemicarceplexes referred to in the text. The units of G and H are kJ/ mol and of S J/mol K. Data from Cram, Blanda, Paek and Knobler, 1991 Guest
G
H
S
(CH3)2NCOCH3 CH3CH2O2CCH3 CH3COCH2CH3 C6H5CH3
15.5 15.9 22.2 14.2
6.3 13.0 10.5 þ9.2
þ25 þ8 þ31 þ63
xylene isomers. Some interesting thermodynamic parameters have been measured for hemicarceplexes of the 3.30 host (Cram, Blanda, Paek and Knobler, 1991), using 500 Mhz 1 H NMR to measure equilibrium constants for complexation and their temperature dependences, giving free energies, enthalpies and entropies of complexation (Table 3.5). The first three of these hemicarceplexes are both enthalpy and entropy stabilized; the toluene guest is entropy stabilized. The explanation advanced is that the positive carbons of the carbonyl groups of the first three guest molecules are electronically complementary to the 16 inward-turned unshared electron pairs of the oxygens of the eight ArOCH2 groups of the host. The unfavourable enthalpy of the toluene complex was attributed to the lack of complementary binding between the flat surface of the guest and the concave inner surfaces of the host. The positive entropies were attributed to two sources: firstly, solvated guest releases solvent molecules which become dispersed in the solvent, increasing the entropy, and, secondly, there is a contribution from the entropy of dilution of the empty space within the cavity – the large empty space of the cavity is broken up into many smaller empty spaces scattered among the solvent molecules. The kinetics of decomplexation, and their dependence on temperature were also measured by NMR and the free energies, enthalpies and entropies of activation for # ¼ disassociation determined. The constrictive binding free energy was defined as Gassoc # Gdisassoc (G ) and is the free energy of the transition state for association (relative to the uncomplexed state). It appears to depend little on the nature of the guest and derives mostly from the change from the unwrapped state of the empty host to the wrapped state # taken up by the hemicarceplex with included guest. The values found for Gassoc were about 100 kJ/mol, about 3/4 of which could be ascribed to an enthalpic contribution and 1/4 to an entropic contribution. Perhaps the most versatile of the currently available hemicarcerands is 3.31 (formula not shown) which differs from 3.29 in that the equatorial belt has four (instead of one) CH2 groups in each of the four (instead of three) vertical linkages (Robbins, Knobler, Bellew and Cram, 1994); again the term ‘‘hemicarcerand’’ is used here for functional rather than structural reasons. 3.31 is the host used in the work described below on o-benzyne (Warmuth, 1997). Thirty complexes of 3.31 were isolated and characterised, and crystal structures reported for six of these. Five were isomorphous; the general formula was {3.31[guest]}2C6H5NO2, space group P21/c, cell dimensions (for p-I2C6H4 guest at ˚ , ¼ 98.199(4) , Z ¼ 2 (PIHYEK); 156 K) a ¼ 16.777(2), b ¼ 19.795(2), c ¼ 20.327(2) A the other guests in this group were C6H5NO2 (PIHYIO), o-BrC6H4OH (PIHYOU),
64
CROWN ETHERS, CRYPTANDS AND RE LATED MOLECUL ES AS HOST S
p-(CH3)2C6H4(PIHZAH) and (CH3)2NCOCH3(PIHZEL). The 3.31 host is here centrosymmetric, and guests lacking a centre must be disordered. The sixth crystal structure was of {3.31[6H2O]}4(o-xylene); these crystals were triclinic, with two formula units in space group P1 (is this a misprint for P 1?). There are no symmetry requirements on the 3.31 molecule and it was twisted by 15 about its polar axis; the water molecules apparently take up an octahedral arrangement within the cavity. Crystal structures of cavitands, caviplexes and hemicarcerands and hemicarceplexes with a variety of guests continue to be reported in illustration of the principles described above (e.g. Helgeson, Paek, Knobler, Maverick and Cram, 1996 (TENLED, TENLIH, TENLON, TENLUT, TENMAA). For example, TENLED is {C128H168O24[C2H6OS] 2(C6H5NO2)} and is described as a ‘‘dimethyl sulfoxide clathrate nitrobenzene solvate.’’ ˚ , ¼ 69.36, ¼ 88.81, The reduced triclinic cell is a ¼ 12.984, b ¼ 14.664, c ¼ 20.336 A g ¼ 65.18 , P1, Z ¼ 1. The host is centrosymmmetric with partial disorder of some n-pentyl groups; the DMSO is disordered over two sites related by a center. Other examples, given by Helgeson, Knobler, and Cram (1997), are RAGXAY, RAGXEC, RACXIG, and RAGXOM. A general survey of Carceplexes and Hemicarceplexes has been given by Jasat and Sherman (1999). 3.5.2
The taming of cyclobutadiene, and of o-benzyne
Sherman, Knobler and Cram (1991) closed their report on carcerands with the prescient remark that ‘‘the inner phases of carcerands are unusual and interesting places where chemical reactions might be carried out.’’ A sequel was not long delayed – cyclobutadiene (C4H4) was reported as tamed but reactive within the ‘‘inner space’’ of 3.29 (Cram, Tanner and Thomas, 1991). The cyclobutadiene was synthesized in situ (within the inner cavity of the hemicarcerand) by irradiation (75 W xenon lamp, 25 ) of the 1 : 1 hemicarcerplex of 3.29 with -pyrone. O O
O hν
hν O
–CO2
Scheme 3.12
The -pyrone guest decomposes to C4H4 and CO2, the latter escaping from the cavity. The (Z)-OHCCH¼CHCHO was produced by reaction of C4H4 with O2 gas. The reactions were followed by NMR (Fig. 3.27). The sharp singlet in the NMR spectrum at ¼ 2.3 is assigned to singlet state cyclobutadiene on the basis of the following evidence. The host’s inward-pointing Ha and Hb protons give sharp doublets in the NMR spectrum of {3.29[C4H4]} at ¼ 4.27, 4.36, whereas triplet C4H4 would broaden and shift these signals, as does triplet oxygen in the spectrum of {3.29[O2]}. The sharpness of the signals at ¼ 4.27, 4.36 shows that the cyclobutadiene is rotating rapidly on the 1H NMR time scale about all its axes. {3.29[C4H4]} heated in (D8)THF at 220 gave free cyclooctatetraene (identified, inter alia, by its ‘‘pungent and characteristic odor’’), through intermediate formation of the cyclobutadiene dimer.
65
HEMICARCERANDS AND HEMICARCEPLEXES
3.29
C2H2
O
O
H
H
3.29 H
7.0
6.5
6.0
5.5
5.0
H
4.5 d
4.0
3.5
3.0
2.5
2.0
Fig. 3.27. 1H NMR spectra (500 MHz, CDCl3, 60 ) of the hemicarcerplexes of 3.29 with cyclobutadiene (CH)4 and (Z)-OHCCH¼CHCHO. (Reproduced from Cram, Tanner and Thomas, 1991.)
This remarkable achievement has been followed by the synthesis of o-benzyne (C6H4; IUPAC name 1,2-didehydrobenzene) within the inner cavity of a hemicarcerand 3.31. The precursor was benzocyclobutendione, which was complexed with 3.31 through a molten phase and then photolysed ( > 400 nm) at 77K to give {3.31[benzocyclopropenone]} as the only product, the structure being confirmed by (an as-yet unpublished) crystal structure analysis. This intermediate complex was then further photolysed (77K, < 297 nm, 88 hours, 300 W xenon arc lamp) to give incarcerated benzyne, identified by its 1H and 13C NMR spectra. If the {3.31[o-benzyne]} product complex is allowed to warm up above 77K, then a host–guest reaction occurs in which the nominal triple bond of the o-benzyne is added across one of the aryl ether bars of the host cage (Warmuth, 1998). O O O
Scheme 3.13
˚ Singlet cyclobutadiene has a rectangular shape, with bond lengths of 1.34 and 1.60 A (Dunitz et al., 1988). Current very high level calculations of the structure of o-benzyne suggest that there is no bond length alternation, a conclusion in conflict with deductions from the NMR spectra which suggest a cumulene-type structure. These geometrical
66
CROWN ETHERS, CRYPTANDS AND RE LATED MOLECUL ES AS HOST S
details could possibly be identified from diffraction measurements on the hemicarcerplexes at low temperature. Studies of ‘‘chemistry in the inner space’’ continue, e.g. Warmuth, 2001.
3.5.3
Molecular mechanics and dynamics studies on the complexation and decomplexation processes
There is a wealth of information available about which hosts will complex (or not) with which guests, including studies of the chemistry, thermodynamics and kinetics. One would wish to translate these qualitative and quantitative results into molecular R
R
R
R
rigid ‘polar’ region OO
O
O O
O O
O
OO
O
O
O
O
O
O
OO
O
O
R
O
O O O
O
R
O
R
flexible ‘temperate’ and ‘equatorial’ regions
OO
R
1. R = PHCH2CH2 2. R = H
(a)
(b)
(c)
Fig. 3.28. (Above) Schematic diagram of the hemicarcerand; the pendant groups R ¼ PhCH2CH2 act to increase the solubility of the host 3.32 #1 in the experimental studies, while R is set to H in the stripped-down version of the molecule 3.32 #2 used for the calculations. (Below) Side views of three low-energy conformations of a space-filling model of 3.32 #2. (Reproduced from Sheu and Houk, 1996.)
COMPARISONS OF CONCEPTS
67
terms – how do the guests enter the hosts, how are they enabled to remain in the cavities and how can they leave? The hemicarcerands are very suitable substrates for this sort of study – the molecules have both rigid and flexible portions, and the portals have reasonably well defined shapes and sizes. The methods of molecular mechanics and molecular dynamics have been applied by Sheu and Houk (1996) to answer these questions, using the ‘‘stripped down’’ hemicarcerand (3.32 #2) as host (Fig. 3.28). The global minimum conformation of the host (2a in Fig. 3.28) has D2h symmetry; 2b has C2h symmetry and is 31.8 kJ/mol higher in energy than 2a, while 2c has D2h symmetry and is 38.5 kJ/mol higher in energy than 2a. Structure 2b is very similar to the analogous hemicarcerand structures found by X-ray diffraction. Sheu and Houk (1996) quote twelve examples of mono- and bicyclic guests which form isolable complexes with 3.32 #1, and twenty-eight examples of similar molecules which do not; 1,2-dimethoxy-4-bromobenzene is an example from the first group and 1,2-dimethoxybenzene from the second. It is the orientation of the intrahemispheric bridges (–OCH2CH2OCH2CH2O–) which is important in determining how easy it is for guest molecules to pass in and out through the portals of the host. Cram has pointed out that preorganization of the shape of the host and stereo-electronic complementarity between host and guest are the important factors determining the binding power of a particular host-guest combination. 3.32 is highly preorganized with two rigid polar caps, while the flexibility of the four intrahemispheric bridges allows the shape of the portals and cavity to range from square to rhomboid to rectangular (conformers 2a, 2b, 2c). Three processes must be considered. Firstly, can potential guests bind within the cavities? Calculation showed that all 12 guests and 28 nonguests mentioned above could form complexes with binding energies of 50–100 kJ/mol. Thus there must be reasons other than thermodynamics that allow some of these potential guests to form isolable complexes, while others do not. The second factor is whether the potential guest can enter the cavity through the available portals, taking into account the flexibility of the gates formed by the intrahemispheric bridges. For many guests, the barrier to entry is high even with the gates open. The third factor is possible escape of complexed guest during the purification process. This is considered to be the reason why many guests with otherwise favourable properties do not form isolable complexes.
3.6 Comparisons of concepts The different types of enclosure molecules introduced in this chapter, their unfamiliar nomenclature and their resemblances to and differences from established concepts in host–guest solid state chemistry can be somewhat bewildering. We have used the succint comparison of concepts made by Sherman, Knobler and Cram (1991) (see also Cram and Cram (1994; pp. 147–148)) as the basis for a more extended comparison organised in parallel with the treatment of this and subsequent chapters. The crown ethers considered here are single-ring hosts which wrap around cations and form intermolecular hydrogen-bonded complexes with suitably substituted organic guests. True intramolecular enclosure occurs only when the crown ether is large enough to bend back on itself to form a cleft into which the guest enters; a number of hosts (not necessarily crown ethers) of this ‘‘molecular tweezer’’ type have been prepared. Larger crown ethers, particularly benzocrown ethers, can, in addition to the act of enclosure, interact
68
CROWN ETHERS, CRYPTANDS AND RE LATED MOLECUL ES AS HOST S
with suitable guests by charge–transfer forces familiar from the classical chemistry (solution and solid state) of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons. Stoddart’s inception and extension of these ideas may well be leading to a new era of supramolecular chemistry based on manipulation of smaller units. Cryptands have three rings (connectors) joined at two apexes (spacers) and form triangular baskets with open sides; four connectors would give baskets of rectangular cross section. Here entry and exit of guests will be relatively easy, and conformational reorganization can be expected during the complexation process. The especial contribution of the Cram group lies in synthesizing molecular baskets with much more varied shapes and, usually, with restricted possibilities of entry and exit. Spherands are hollow and rigid baskets with pole–dipole interactions with guests; so far only cations or relatively small organic molecules have been enclosed in spherands. Carcerplexes contain guests which cannot escape without breaking covalent bonds of the carcerand host molecule; these baskets have a very tight weave. Hemicarcerands are analogous baskets but contain portals which are flexible enough to allow entry and exit of guests at higher temperatures and thus exchange between interior and exterior occurs without bond cleavage. To quote from Sherman et al. (1991) – ‘‘[The] existence and stability [of carciplexes] do not depend on host–guest attractions . . . other than gross size complementarity, but on physical envelopment of guests during [the] shell closures leading to [the formation] of carciplexes.’’ Cram contends that the interiors of carciplexes constitute a new form of matter. The comparison can be completed by considering the place of other types of enclosure. Clathrates are crystalline compounds where the guests are included in cavities left between host molecules linked by hydrogen bonds or van der Waals forces. Generally the sublattice of host molecules has a structure different from that of the neat host, and hence clathrates are secondary solid solutions of guest in host (if of variable composition), or ‘‘phase rule compounds’’ (if of fixed composition). There are some rare examples of primary solid solution. There is no special interaction between host and guest in solution. Zeolites constitute a special case of clathrates where the host structural units are linked by rigid covalent (or ionic) bonds, leading to the crystal becoming a ‘‘giant molecule’’ with many interstices; the complex is then a primary solid solution of guest in host.
References Abbott, S. J., Barrett, A. G. M., Godfrey, C. R. A., Kalindjian, S. B., Simpson, G. W. and Williams, D. J. (1982). J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun., pp. 796–797. Allwood, B. L., Colquhoun, H. M., Doughty, S. M., Kohnke, F. H., Slawin, A. M. Z., Stoddart, J. F., Williams, D. J. and Zarzycki, R. (1987). J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun., pp. 1054 –1058. Allwood, B. L., Kohnke, F. H., Stoddart, J. F. and Williams, D. J. (1985). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 24, 581–583. Allwood, B. L., Shahriari-Zavareh, H., Stoddart, J. F. and Williams, D. J. (1987). J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun., pp. 1058–1061. Allwood, B. L., Spencer, N., Shahriari-Zavareh, H., Stoddart, J. F. and Williams, D. J. (1987a). J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun., pp. 1064–1067.
REFERENCES
69
Allwood, B. L., Spencer, N., Shahriari-Zavareh, H., Stoddart, J. F. and Williams, D. J. (1987b). J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun., pp. 1061–1064. Amabilino, D. B., Ashton, P. R., Brown, C. L., Co´rdova, E., Godı´nez, L. A., Goodnow, T. T., Kaifer, A. E., Newton, S. P., Pietraszkiewicz, M., Philp, D., Raymo, F. M., Reder, A. S., Rutland, M. T., Slawin, A. M. Z., Spencer, N., Stoddart, J. F. and Williams, D. J. (1995). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 117, 1271–1293. Amabilino, D. B. and Stoddart, J. F. (1995). Chem. Rev., 95, 2725–2828. Anelli, P. L., Ashton, P. R., Ballardini, R., Balzani, V., Delgado, M., Gandolfi, M. T., Goodnow, T. T., Kaifer, A. E., Philp, D., Pietraszkiewicz, M., Prodi, L., Reddington, M. V., Slawin, A. M. Z., Spencer, N., Stoddart, J. F., Vicent, C. and Williams, D. J. (1992). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 114, 193–218. Anelli, P. L., Ashton, P. R., Spencer, N., Slawin, A. M. Z., Stoddart, J. F. and Williams, D. J. (1991). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 30, 1036–1039. Asakawa, M., Ashton, P. R., Hayes, W., Janssen, H. M., Meijer, E. W., Menzer, S., Pasini, D., Stoddart, J. F., White, A. J. P. and Williams, D. J. (1998). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 120, 920–931. Asakawa, M., Brown, C. L., Menzer, S., Raymo, F. M., Stoddart, J. F. and Williams, D. J. (1997). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 119, 2614–2627. Ashton, P. R., Ballardini, R., Balzani, V., Be´loradsk´y, M., Gandolfi, M. T., Philp, D., Prodi, L., Raymo, F. M., Reddington, M. V., Spencer, N., Stoddart, J. F., Venturi, M. and Williams, D. J. (1996). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 118, 4931–4951. Ashton,P.R.,Brown,C.L.,Chrystal,E.J.T.,Goodnow,T.T.,Kaifer,A.E.,Parry,K.P.,Slawin,A.M.Z., Spencer, N., Stoddart, J. F. and Williams, D. J. (1991). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 30, 1039–1042. Ashton, P. R., Brown, G. R., Isaacs, N,. S., Guiffrida, D., Kohnke, F. H., Matthias, J. P., Slawin, A. M. Z., Smith, D. R., Stoddart, J. F. and Williams, D. J. (1992). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 114, 6330–6353. Ashton, P. R., Chrystal, E. J. T., Mathias, J. T., Parry, K. P., Slawin, A. M. Z., Spencer, N., Stoddart, J. F. and Williams, D. J. (1987). Tetr. Letts., 28, 6367–6370. Ashton, P. R., Goodnow, T. T., Kaifer, A. E., Reddington, M. V., Slawin, A. M. Z., Spencer, N., Stoddart, J. F., Vicent, C. and Williams, D. J. (1989). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 28, 1396–1399. Ashton, P. R., Philp, D., Reddington, M. V., Slawin, A. M. Z., Spencer, N., Stoddart, J. F. and Williams, D. J. (1991). J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun., pp. 1680–1683. Ashton, P. R., Reddington, M. V., Slawin, A. M. Z., Stoddart, J. F. and Williams, D. J. (1988). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 27, 1550–1553. Ashton, P. R., Slawin, A. M. Z., Spencer, N., Stoddart, J. F. and Williams, D. J. (1987). J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun., pp. 1066–1069. Behr, J.-P. (1994). Editor, The Lock and Key Principle. The State of the Art – 100 Years On, Wiley, Chichester. Berscheid, B., Nieger, M. and Vo¨gtle, F. (1991). J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun., pp. 1364–1366. Bottino, F., Finocchiaro, P., Lipkowski, J., Mamo, A. and Pappalardo, S. (1991). J. Incl. Phenom. and Recogn. in Chem., 11, 41–48. Bradshaw, J. S., Izatt, R. M., Bordunov, A. V., Zhu, C. Y. and Hathaway, J. K. (1996). ‘‘Crown ethers,’’ in Comprehensive Supramolecular Chemistry, edited by J. L. Atwood, J. E. D. Davies, D. D. MacNicol and F. Vo¨gtle, Pergamon, Oxford, Vol. 1, pp. 35–95. Bryant, J. A., Blanda, M. T., Vincenti, M. and Cram, D. J. (1991). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 113, 2167–2172. Bu¨hner, M., Geuder, W., Gries, W.-K., Hu¨nig, S., Kock, M. and Poll, T. (1988). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 27, 1553–1556. Burley, S. K. and Pesko, G. A. (1986). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 108, 7995–8001. Bush, M. A. and Truter, M. R. (1972). J. Chem. Soc., Perkin II, pp. 345–350.
70
CROWN ETHERS, CRYPTANDS AND RE LATED MOLECUL ES AS HOST S
Canceill, J., Cesario, M., Collet, A., Guilhem, J. and Pascard, C. (1985). J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun., pp. 361–363. Canceill, J., Cesario, M., Collet, A., Guilhem, J. Riche, C. and Pascard, C. (1986). J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun., pp. 339–341. Canceill, J., Cesario, M., Collet, A., Guilhem, J., Lacombe, L., Lozach, B. and Pascard, C. (1989). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 28, 1246–1248. Canceill, J., Lacombe L. and Collet, A. (1987). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 107, 6993–6996. Chapman, R. G., Olovsson, G., Trotter, J. and Sherman, J. C. (1998). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 120, 6252–6260. Christensen, J. J., Eatough, D. J. and Izatt, R. M. (1974). Chem. Rev., 74, 351–384. Cochran, J. E., Parrott, T. J., Whitlock, B. J. and Whitlock, H. W. (1992). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 114, 2269–2270. Collet, A. (1987). Tetrahedron (Report No. 226), 43, 5725–5759. Colquhoun, H. M., Doughty, S. M., Maud, J. M., Stoddart, J. F., Williams, D. J. and Wolstenholme, J. B. (1985). Isr. J. Chem., 25, 15–26. Colquhoun, H. M., Doughty, S. M., Stoddart, J. F. and Williams, D. J. (1984). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 23, 235–236. Colquhoun, H. M., Goodings, E. P., Maud, J. M., Stoddart, J. F., Wolstenholme, J. B. and Williams, D. J. (1985). J. Chem. Soc., Perkin II, pp. 607–624. Cram, D. J. (1983). Science, 219, 1177–1183. Cram, D. J. (1986). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 25, 1039–1057. Cram, D. J. and Cram, J. M. (1994). Container Molecules and their Guests, No. 4 of Monographs in Supramolecular Chemistry, Series Editor, J. Fraser Stoddart, London: The Royal Society of Chemistry. Cram, D. J., Blanda, M. T., Paek, K. and Knobler, C. B. (1992). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 114, 7765–7773. Cram, D. J., Jaeger, R. and Deshayes, K. (1993). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 115, 10111–10116. Cram, D. J., Kaneda, T., Helgeson, R. C., Brown, S. B., Knobler, C. B., Maverick, E. F. and Trueblood, K. N. (1985). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 107, 3645–3657. Cram, D. J., Karbach, S., Kim, Y. H., Baczynskyj, L. and Kalleymeyn, G. W. (1985). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 107, 2575–2576. Cram, D. J., Karbach, S., Kim, Y. H., Baczynskyj, L., Marti, K., Sampson, R. M. and Kalleymeyn, G. W. (1988). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 110, 2554–2560. Cram, D. J., Karbach, S., Kim. H.-E., Knobler, C. B., Maverick, E. M., Ericson, J. L. and Helgeson, R. E. (1988). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 110, 2229–2237. Cram, D. J., Tanner, M. A., Keipert, S. J. and Knobler, C. B. (1991). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 113, 8909–8916. Cram, D. J., Tanner, M. A. and Knobler, C. B. (1991). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 113, 7717–7727. Cram, D. J., Tanner, M. A. and Thomas, R. (1991). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 30, 1024–1027. Cram, D. J. and Trueblood, K. N. (1981). Top. Curr. Chem., 98, 43–106. Diederich, F. (1988). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 27, 362–386. Dietrich, B. (1996). ‘‘Cryptands,’’ in Comprehensive Supramolecular Chemistry, edited by J. L. Atwood, J. E. D. Davies, D. D. MacNicol and F. Vo¨gtle, Pergamon, Oxford, Vol. 1, pp. 153–211. Dietrich, B., Lehn, J. -M. and Sauvage, J. -P. (1968). Tetrahedron Letts, pp. 2885–2888. Dobler, M. (1981). Ionophores and their Structures, Wiley, New York. Dunitz, J. D., Kru¨ger, C., Irngartinger, H., Maverick, E. F., Wang, Y. and Nixdorf, M. (1988). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 27, 387–389. Goldberg, I. (1980). Cryst. Struct. Commun., 9, 1201–1207. Goldberg, I. (1986). J. Incl. Phenom., 4, 191–198.
REFERENCES
71
Grootenhuis, P. D. J., Eerden, van, J., Dijkstra, P. J., Harkema, S. and Reinhoudt, D. N. (1987). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 109, 8044–8051. Hamilton, D. G., Feeder, N., Prodi, L., Teat, S. J., Clegg, W. and Sanders, J. K. M. (1998). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 120, 1096–1097. Harmata, M. and Barnes, C. L. (1990). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 112, 5655–5657. Helgeson, R., Knobler, C. B. and Cram, D. J. (1997). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 119, 3229–3244. Helgeson, R., Paek, K., Knobler, C. B., Maverick, E. F. and Cram, D. J. (1996). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 118, 5590–5604. Hilgenfeld, R. and Saenger, W. (1982). Top. Curr. Chem., 101, 1–82. Hirotsu, K., Kamitori, T., Higuchi, T., Tabushi, I., Yamamura, K. and Nonoguchi, H. (1984). J. Incl. Phenom., 2, 215–222. Hof, F., Craig, S. L., Nuckolls, C. and Rebek, J., Jr. (2002). Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. Eng., 41, 1488–1508. Hu¨bner, M., Geuder, W., Gries, W.-K., Hu¨nig,S., Kock, M. and Pohl, T. (1989). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 27, 1553–1556. Itai, A., Tanaka, Y. and Iitaka, Y. (1979), American Crystallographic Association, Winter Meeting. Abstract PA32. Izatt, R. M., Bradshaw, R. D., Nielsen, S. A., Lamb, J. D., Christensen, J. J. and Sen, D. (1985). Chem. Revs., 85, 271–339. Izatt, R. M., Bradshaw, R. D., Pawlak, K., Bruening, R. L. and Tarbet, B. J. (1992). Chem. Revs., 92, 1261–1354. Izatt, R. M., Pawlak, K., Bradshaw, R. D. and Bruening, R. L. (1991). Chem. Revs., 91, 1721–2085. Izatt, R. M., Pawlak, K., Bradshaw, R. D. and Bruening, R. L. (1995). Chem. Revs., 95, 2529–2586. Jasat, A. and Sherman, J. C. (1999). Chem. Revs., 99, 931–967. Jaswinski, J., Blacker, A. J., Lehn, J.-M., Cesario, M., Guilhem, J. and Pascard, C. (1987). Tetrahedr. Letts., 28, 6057–6060. Knobler, C. B., Maverick, E. F. and Trueblood, K. N. (1992). J. Incl. Phenom., 12, 341–360. Koenig, K. E., Lein, G. M., Stuckler, P., Kaneda, T. and Cram, D. J. (1979). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 101, 3553–3566. Kohnke, F. H., Mathias, J. P. and Stoddart, J. F. (1989). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., Adv. Mat., 28, 1103–1110. Kohnke, F. H., Stoddart, J. F., Allwood, B. L. and Williams, D. J. (1985). Tetr. Letts., 26, 1681–1684. Krieger, C. and Diederich, F. (1985). Chem. Ber., 118, 3620–3631. La¨msa¨, M., Huuskonen, J., Rissanen, K. and Pursiainen, J. (1998). Chem. Eur. J., 4, 84–92. Lehn, J.-M., Me´ric, R., Vigneron, J.-P., Bkouche-Waksman, I. and Pascard, C. (1991). J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun., pp. 62–64. Maverick, E. and Cram, D. J. (1996a). ‘‘Spherands: Hosts preorganized for binding cations,’’ in Comprehensive Supramolecular Chemistry, edited by J. L. Atwood, J. E. D. Davies, D. D. MacNicol and F. Vo¨gtle, Pergamon, Oxford, Vol. 1, pp. 213–244. Maverick, E. and Cram, D. J. (1996b). ‘‘Carcerands and Hemicarcerands: Hosts that imprison molecular guests,’’ in Comprehensive Supramolecular Chemistry, edited by J. L. Atwood, J. E. D. Davies, D. D. MacNicol and F. Vo¨gtle, Pergamon, Oxford, Vol. 2, pp. 367–418. Moran, J. R., Ericson, J. L., Dalcanale, E., Bryant, J. A., Knobler, C. B. and Cram, D. J. (1991). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 113, 5707–5714. Nonoguchi, H., Yamamura, K., Tabushi, I., Higuchi, T. and Hirotsu, K. (1992). Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn., 65, 805–811. Odashima, K. and Koga, K. (1983). ‘‘Cyclophanes in host-guest chemistry’’ in Cyclophanes, Vol. 2, edited by P. M. Keehn and S. M. Rosenfeld, Academic Press, New York etc., (Vol. 45 of Organic Chemistry, edited by H. H. Wasserman), Chapter 11, pp. 629–678.
72
CROWN ETHERS, CRYPTANDS AND RE LATED MOLECUL ES AS HOST S
Odashima, K., Itai, A., Iitaka, Y. and Koga, K. (1980). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 102, 2504–2505. Odell, B., Reddington, M. V., Slawin, A. M. Z., Spencer, N., Stoddart, J. F. and Williams, D. J. (1988). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 27, 1547–1550. O’Krongly, D., Denmeade, S. R., Chiang, M. Y. and Breslow, R. (1985). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 107, 5544–5545. Ortholand, J.-Y., Slawin, A. M. Z., Spencer, N., Stoddart, J. F. and Williams, D. J. (1989). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 28, 1394–1395. Owen, J. D. (1984). Acta Cryst., C40, 951–955. Philp, D., Slawin, A. M. Z., Spencer, N., Stoddart, J. F. and Williams, D. J. (1991). J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun., pp. 1584–1586. Quan, M. L. C. and Cram, D. J. (1991). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 113, 2754. Reddington, M. V., Slawin, A. M. Z., Spencer, N., Stoddart, J. F., Vicent, C. and Williams, D. J. (1991). J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun., pp. 630–634. Reek, J. N. H., Engelkamp, H., Rowan, A. E., Elemans, J. A. A. W. and Nolte, R. J. M. (1998). Chem. Eur. J., 4, 716–722. Renault, A., Talham, D., Conceill, J., Batail, P., Collet, A. and Lajzerowicz, Janine, (1989). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 101, 1251–1252. Robbins, T. A., Knobler, C. B., Bellew, D. R. and Cram, D. J. (1994). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 116, 111–122. Rudkevich, D. M. (2002). Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn., 75, 393–414. Schill, G. (1971). Catenanes, Rotaxanes and Knots, Academic Press, New York. Schwartz, E. B., Knobler, C. B. and Cram. D. J. (1992). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 114, 10775–10784. Seel, C. and Vo¨gtle, F. (1992). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 31, 528–549. Sheridan, R. E. and Whitlock, H. W. (1986). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 108, 7210–7211. Sheridan, R. E. and Whitlock, H. W. (1988). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 110, 4071–4073. Sherman, J. C., Knobler, C. B. and Cram. D. J. (1991). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 113, 2194–2204. Sheu, C. and Houk, K. N. (1996). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 118, 8056–8070. Slawin, A. M. Z., Spencer, N., Stoddart, J. F. and Williams, D. J. (1987). J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun., pp. 1070–1072. Stoddart, J. F. (1991) in Host–Guest Interactions: from Chemistry to Biology, Ciba Foundation Symposium 158, Wiley, Chichester, p. 5. Tabushi, I., Yamamura, K., Nonoguchi, H., Hirotsu, K. and Higuchi, T. (1984a). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 106, 2621–2625. Tabushi, I., Yamamura, K., Nonoguchi, H., Hirotsu, K. and Higuchi, T. (1984b). J. Incl. Phenom., 2, 85–89. Tanner, M. E., Knobler, C. B. and Cram, D. L. (1990). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 112, 1659–1600. Tanner, M. E., Knobler, C. B. and Cram, D. L. (1992). J. Org. Chem., 57, 40–46. Trueblood, K. N., Maverick, E. M. and Knobler, C. B. (1991). Acta Cryst., B47, 389–398. Uiterwijk, J. W. H. M., Staveren, C. J. van, Reinhoudt, D. N., Hertog, H. J. den, Jr., Kruise, L. and Harkema, S. (1986). J. Org. Chem., 51, 1575–1587. Vincenti, M., Dalcanale, E., Soncini, P. and Guigliemetti, G. (1990). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 112, 445–447. Vo¨gtle, F., Berscheid, R. and Schnick, W. (1991). J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun., pp. 414–416. Warmuth, R. (1997). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 36, 1347–1350. Warmuth, R. (1998). J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun., pp. 59–60. Warmuth, R. (2001). Chem. Eur. J., 7, 1209–1220. Weber, E., Franken, S., Puff, H. and Ahrendt, J. (1986). J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun., pp. 467–469. Whitlock, B. J. and Whitlock, H. W. (1990). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 112, 3910–3915.
Chapter 4 Cyclodextrins, and some analogs, as hosts
. . . The Gem, The Diadem, The Ring Enclosing All T.Traherne ((?)1636–1674) Summary: The -, - and -cyclodextrins are oligosaccharides containing respectively six, seven and eight glucose units linked between 1 and 4 positions to form macrocyclic rings of overall toroidal or truncated-cone shape; the secondary hydroxyl side is conventionally defined as the ‘‘head’’ of the cone. The inner and outer surfaces of the toroids are hydrophobic while the upper and lower faces are hydrophilic. When crystallized from aqueous solutions the cyclodextrins form inclusion complexes with a large variety of guest molecules, ranging in type from inert gases through polyiodide salts to aromatics. The crystals contain an appreciable number of water molecules which are hydrogen bonded together and also to the host molecules; the amount of water varies from complex to complex. Two types of general structure can be distinguished – the clathrates and the tunnel inclusion complexes – and each of these types contains a number of isomorphous or isostructural classes; about two-thirds of the complexes of known structure are of the tunnel type. The guest molecules are generally enclosed within the cavities of the toroids in a variety of packings; there are sometimes water molecules within the cavities in addition to those located between the cyclodextrins, and guests are sometimes found between the host molecules. If the guest is a salt, linear anions such as polyiodides are found within the cavities while the counter cations are included in the water network. Formation of hydrogen-bonded cyclodextrin dimers is a feature of the tunnel inclusion complexes and these dimers are mainly head-to-tail in the -cyclodextrin complexes, predominantly head-to-head in the -cyclodextrin complexes and with all three possibilities in the (mostly isomorphous) -cyclodextrin complexes so far studied. The catalytic properties of cyclodextrins in organic reactions and their mimicry of enzyme behavior is ascribed to the manner in which the guest is held in a fixed position and orientation by the host even in solution. Cyclodextrins have found wide use in the pharmaceutical industry because of their water solubility, the innocuous nature of their degradation products and, most importantly, their ability to encapsulate drug molecules and release these slowly. Analogs to the cyclodextrins are currently being developed.
4.1 Introduction 4.2 -Cyclodextrins as host 4.2.1 -Cyclodextrin as host in clathrate inclusion complexes 4.2.2 -Cyclodextrin as host in tunnel inclusion complexes 4.2.3 Chemically modified -cyclodextrins as hosts in inclusion complexes 4.3 -Cyclodextrins as host 4.3.1 -Cyclodextrin as host in clathrate inclusion complexes 4.3.2 -Cyclodextrin as host in tunnel inclusion complexes
74 79 80 84 90 95 97 100
74
C Y C L O D E X T R I NS , A ND S OM E AN A L O G S , A S H O S T S
4.3.3 Exceptional -cyclodextrin structures 4.3.4 Chemically modified -cyclodextrins as hosts in inclusion complexes 4.4 Rotaxanes and catenanes of cyclodextrins 4.5 -Cyclodextrins as host 4.5.1 -Cyclodextrin as host in clathrate inclusion complexes 4.5.2 -Cyclodextrin as host in tunnel inclusion complexes 4.5.3 Chemically modified -cyclodextrins as hosts in inclusion complexes 4.6 Larger cyclodextrins 4.7 Cyclic oligosaccharides as cyclodextrin analogs References
4.1
114 114 117 118 118 119 122 123 123 124
Introduction
Towards the end of the nineteenth century Villiers (1891) reported the isolation (in 3% yield) of a group of unusual nonreducing oligosaccharides from cultures containing Bacillus macerans grown on a medium rich in amylose; the enzymes involved are cyclodextrin glycosyltransferases (CGTases EC 2.4.1.19). The product compounds (now obtained in 25% yield) were shown by Schardinger (1904) to be cyclic oligosaccharides, of toroidal or doughnut shape, containing from six to twelve glucose units. They have been called Schardinger dextrins, cyclo[n]amyloses (CAn), cyclomalto-oligosaccharides and cyclodextrins ( for n ¼ 6, for n ¼ 7 and for n ¼ 8, often abbreviated as -, - and -CD). The enzymatic breakdown of starch to give cyclodextrins is illustrated in Fig. 4.1. We follow Chemical Abstracts in using the -, - and -cyclodextrin (CD) nomenclature, corresponding to cyclomaltohexaose, cyclomaltoheptaose and cyclomalto-octaose respectively. There are also some larger cyclodextrins, whose properties are now being explored (see Section 4.6 below); these are referred to by Greek letters or as CAn, with the latter system to be preferred. However, we have generally retained the CD system because of its familiarity. There is also currently an active development of synthetic cyclic oligosaccharides (Gattuso, Nepogodiev and Stoddart, 1998), which show similarities and differences to the cyclodextrins. The water solubility of the cyclodextrins is an important feature of their properties – 14.5 g/100 ml. water at 25 C, 1.85 and 23.2. All three show increasing solubility with temperature (0–90 C), with solubility at 85 C in the order > > (Diaz, Vargas-Baca and Gracia-Mora, 1994). The solubility is ascribed to dipole interactions between the hydrophilic upper and lower surfaces of the tori and bulk water molecules. Complexes (inclusion complexes of one kind or another, in which molecules of many kinds as well as salts can be found as guests) have been reported for -, - and -cyclodextrins and a considerable amount of structural work has been reported, in addition to much chemical and biochemical study, all of which has been accompanied by important industrial developments. Formation of the complexes is ascribed to replacement of water molecules within the hydrophobic inner surface of the torus by hydrophobic guest molecules. The guests in the cyclodextrin complexes are retained within the rings in the solid state and even in solution (at least on a dynamic basis) and this has made the complexes useful as catalysts in organic chemistry and as model systems for many enzyme reactions. The
I NT RO D UC T I O N
75
14.6 Å 5.3 Å
OH O
O
HO
O HO OH
OH O HO
OH
O OH O
O
HO
OH
7.8 Å
HO O
HO
OH O HO
O
HO OH O
OH
O
O HO
O O O
O
O
O
O O
O
O O O
OH O OH HO
OH O HO
O O
CGTase (Enzyme)
O
O
O HO
OH
O HO
HO O
O
O
OH
O HO
O
O
15.4 Å 6.5 Å
O
O
HO
O
HO
O
OH O
OH O
OH HO O
O
O
7.8 Å
HO OH
O
O
OH
OH
O O O
O
O
O O
O
O
O
OH O
O
O OH HO
O
OOH O
Starch
OH O
O
OH
HO
HO
HO
O OH
O OH
OH
HO
17.5 Å 8.3 Å
OH
HO
HO OH O OH
7.8 Å
O
OH O OH HO O
O
O
OH
HO
α– cyclodextrin (top) Molecular Weight 973 Glucose Units 6 Specific Rotation [a]D25 150.5 Cavity Volume mL/g 0.10 6 H2O molecules included (in solution)
β–cyclodextrin (center) Molecular Weight 1135 Glucose Units 7 Specific Rotation [a]D25 162.5 Cavity Volume mL/g 0.14 11 H2O molecules included (in solution)
γ–cyclodextrin (center) Molecular Weight 1297 Glucose Units 8 Specific Rotation [a]D25 177.8 Cavity Volume mL/g 0.20 17 H2O molecules included (in solution)
Fig. 4.1. Enzymatic breakdown of starch to give -, - and -cyclodextrins, together with a summary of their properties. (Reproduced from Diaz,Vargas-Baca and Gracia-Mora, 1994.)
cyclodextrins have been used as encapsulating agents for slow-release drugs and for other pharmaceutical purposes. Cramer (1954, 1987) played a key role in initiating many of these developments. We shall emphasise the structural chemistry of the crystalline complexes and not attempt to duplicate the coverage of other aspects in the extensive contemporary literature (Senti and Erlander, 1964; Bender and Komiyama, 1978; Saenger, 1980, 1984; Saenger, Jacob, Gessler, Steiner, Hoffmann, Sanbe, Koizumi,
76
C Y C L O D E X T R I NS , A ND S OM E AN A L O G S , A S H O S T S
Smith and Takaha, 1998; Saenger and Steiner, 1998; Szejtli, 1982, 1988, 1998; Duche´ne, 1987; Stoddart and Zarycki, 1989; Harata, 1991, 1998). A whole volume (No. 3) of Comprehensive Supramolecular Chemistry, edited by Szejtli and Osa (1996), deals with ‘cyclodextrins’ in 22 chapters extending over 693 pages; there are 3 700 references. Szejtli (1998) mentions that over 15 000 publications had appeared by the end of 1997 (duplication has not been taken into account). An accompanying development has been the preparation of chemically modified cyclodextrins, generally by methylating or acetylating some or all of the hydroxyl groups (Bender and Komiyama, 1978; Tabushi, 1982); these derivatives also form inclusion complexes, which are discussed together with those of the parent compounds. One fundamental crystallographic aspect must be emphasized at the outset. Apart from a few exceptions among chemically modified cyclodextrins, all the crystals discussed below contain varying amounts of water molecules essential to their existence, and crystals of anhydrous cyclodextrins have not been found. In this sense they resemble most crystalline biomolecules such as proteins. This situation differs from that found in virtually all the other molecular complexes and compounds dealt with here, where anhydrous hosts (for complexes) or parent components (for compounds) are the species of reference. -, - and -cyclodextrins all form both clathrate and tunnel inclusion complexes. Saenger, Jacob et al. (1998) suggest that, for -CD complexes, small guest molecules form clathrates and larger guests tunnel complexes, i.e. there is a size selectivity. There are not yet analogous generalizations for the - and -CD complexes. Cell dimensions have been reported for more than 300 inclusion complexes of the cyclodextrins and their methylated derivatives and the crystal structures of most of these compounds have been determined. These structures are complicated because of the possibilities of conformational differences in the macrocycles due to interactions with the included guests and, especially because of the variety of hydrogen bonding arrangements possible, particularly at room temperature, and the accompanying disorder. Thus nonstoichiometric amounts of water are often found in the structures, with the water molecules distributed over a number of sites with partial occupancies. In structural terms this means that the arrangements in different unit cells are different, the crystal structure analysis giving only a picture averaged over the whole crystal. It would be desirable to determine crystal structures at the lowest possible temperatures (currently 10K) by neutron diffraction, preferably also on deuterated crystals and then study the changes that ensue on heating. Not much attention has yet been paid to possible phase changes. Such a programme has been started but results are available for only a few complexes; some disorder often remains even at 15K. We shall generally describe the room-temperature structures in broad terms and not attempt to enter into all the details of conformational differences and hydrogen bonding; Harata (1996; 1998) covers much the same material from a somewhat different point of view. Thus, in essence, we concentrate on showing how the complexes can be classified into various structural (crystallographic) groups, pointing out both the great similarities within each group and the subtle differences among its members. The variety, in a chemical sense, of guests in particular structural families is quite remarkable. The next stage in an overall structural analysis should be to compare in detail the host–guest–water arrangements and interactions. This vast task is on the verge of practicality (Le Bas, Rysanek et al. (1988)) but we leave its realization to future explorers.
I NT RO D UC T I O N
77
Secondary hydroxy O(2)-H, O(3)-H rim Head
Internal tunnel
Tail Primary hydroxy O(6)-H rim (a)
(c)
o
a
o
c
b b (b)
(d) o
a
c o
b c (e)
c
o
b
a
Fig. 4.2. Schematic diagram showing (above): form of the cyclodextrin truncated cone molecule, with conventional definitions; there are twice as many secondary hydroxyls as primary hydroxyls (below) : the broad ways of describing cyclodextrin inclusion complexes: (a) head-to-head tunnel type, showing dimers found particularly in -CD complexes; (b) head-to-tail tunnel type; (c) cage herringbone type; (d) cage brickwork-like or slipped tunnel type; (e) slipped tunnel type with headto-head dimers. (Adapted from Harata, 1996.)
78
C Y C L O D E X T R I NS , A ND S OM E AN A L O G S , A S H O S T S
Table 4.1. Statistics of reported cyclodextrin inclusion complex structures (as of end 2002). The herringbone type of clathrate is denoted by A1 and the slipped tunnel or brickwork type by A2; the head-to-tail arrangement in the tunnel complexes is denoted by B1 and the head-to-head arrangement by B2 Type of cyclodextrin
Polymethyl- Polymethyl-
Cage structures
Tunnel structures
A1
A2
B1
B2
16 – 18 4 1
10 – 2 –
18 4 1 2
27 – 71 11 12(mixed)
Following Saenger (1984), the crystal structures can be classified, into two broad groups (Fig. 4.2), each of which can be further subdivided: Group A: Clathrate or cage structures, where the arrangement of cyclodextrin molecules is such that the cavities of the macrocyclic hosts are blocked off by neighboring host molecules and the guests are therefore enclosed in these cavities. The two subdivisions are: Group A1: herringbone arrangement of host molecules, Group A2: slipped-tunnel or brickwork-like arrangement of host molecules. This group can formally be considered to derive from the tunnel structures (see below) by mutual displacement of adjacent layers of host molecules. Group B: Tunnel structures, where the arrangement of cyclodextrin molecules is such that the toroidal cavities are lined up through the crystals to form approximately linear tunnels in which the guests are accommodated. The mutual arrangement of cyclodextrin molecules has been found to be either head-to-tail or head-to-head in the - and -cyclodextrin complexes studied, and a combination of both in the (mostly isomorphous) -cyclodextrin complexes studied. These two groups, in turn, can be further subdivided into smaller groups of isomorphous or isostructural complexes as has been illustrated by Caira (2002). Our emphasis in this chapter is on structures of CD complexes determined by single crystal methods but one should remember that many such complexes are only obtainable as microcrystalline powders. Here powder diffraction has an important role to play, especially for identification, and Caira (2002) has collected together typical powder patterns for the various isostructural groups. One should also note progress in the capability to solve crystal structures from powder data alone (Pop, Goubitz et al., 2002), and this will undoubtedly also be a feature of future developments. The November 2002 version of the CSD gives 358 hits for ‘cyclodextrin’, of which 116 refer to ‘alpha-cyclodextrin’, 214 to ‘beta-cyclodextrin’ and 17 to ‘gamma-cyclodextrin’. A statistical breakdown of the isomorphous and isostructural structures (i.e. those in Tables 4.2–4.19) among the various categories is shown in Table 4.1; about two-thirds of these structures are of the tunnel type. A measure of the rate of development of the field can be gleaned from the fact that Saenger listed 37 structures in his 1984 and 1985
-CYCLODEXTRIN AS HOST
79
reviews, while Dodds (1999) found 74 -CD structures in Version 5.12, (October, 1998) of the Cambridge Structural Database and 11 -CD structures. Our list of structures is representative but certainly not complete, nor can it be, with the continuing interest in cyclodextrin structures. 4.2 a-Cyclodextrin as host In -cyclodextrin (C36H60O30) the -D-glucose moieties are all in the pyranose staggered chair form with C1 conformation (1a 2e 3e 4e 5e); the glucose moieties are linked betwen 1- and 4-positions. The important structural features are the toroidal, truncatedcone shape of the macrocyclic molecule, its hydrophobic cavity and curved outer surfaces, and its hydrophilic upper and lower faces. The interior diameter of the cavity ˚ . The (primary) 6-hydroxyl face (defined conventionally as the ‘‘tail’’ of is about 5.2 A the molecule) is somewhat narrower than the 2,3-hydroxyl face (the ‘‘head’’ of the molecule); this is illustrated schematically in Fig. 4.2.1 There are intramolecular hydrogen bonds O(3)H . . . O(2) and O(3) . . . HO(2) between the secondary hydroxyl groups around the macrocyclic ring and these play an important role in its stabilization. X-ray data show that the mean O(2) . . . O(3) distances in -, - and -cyclodextrins are ˚ respectively; the interactions in -CD are weaker and its macrocycle 3.00, 2.86 and 2.81 A is more flexible than those of - and -CD. The C(6)-O(6) bonds are preferentially directed away from the centre of the ring (torsion angle O(5)-C(5)-C(6)-O(6) is ( )gauche; some of these bonds can turn inwards, the torsion angle becoming ( þ )gauche, with formation of hydrogen bonds between the O(6)H group and the guest molecule. These features are illustrated in the diagrams of the various structures given below. The solution thermodynamics of the formation of 1 : 1 inclusion complexes (predominantly in water at 298K) has been extensively studied. Rekharsky and Inoue (1998) have summarised and discussed values for the stability constants, standard free energies, enthalpy and entropy changes, and, for some examples, heat capacities. Some 600 values are given for -CD, 400 for -CD and 50 for -CD complexes. Many multiple values are given (for various temperatures, pHs and so on) so the number of guests involved for each cyclodextrin is about two-thirds of the number of separate values. There are also many values for chemically modified cyclodextrins. Corresponding measurements on crystalline complexes do not appear to have been reported, apart from an adiabatic calorimeter study of {-CD11H2O} over the range 13–300K (Hanabata, Matsuo and Suga, 1987), where a first-order phase change occurs at 226K. The solid-state heat capacities at 298.15K of the three common cyclodextrins and some defined hydrates have also been measured (Briggner and Wadso¨, 1990). 1 The secondary hydroxyls are at the broad end of the truncated cone, and the primary hydroxyls at the narrower end. However, the authorities do not agree on which is ‘‘head’’ and which ‘‘tail.’’ We follow Hamilton (Hamilton and Chen, 1988a), Tsoucaris (Mentzafos et al., 1991) and Harata (1996; see p. 290) in designating the broad end as ‘‘head’’ and the narrower end as ‘‘tail.’’ For example, the first of these references has ‘‘ . . . a head-tohead dimer is formed by means of extensive hydrogen bonding across the secondary hydroxyl ends of two adjacent -CD monomers . . . ’’. We use the same definition for - and -CD. Saenger (e.g. Steiner and Saenger, 1998a; see p. 454) and Kamitori et al (1998) interchange ‘‘head’’ and ‘‘tail.’’
80
4.2.1
C Y C L O D E X T R I NS , A ND S OM E AN A L O G S , A S H O S T S
a-Cyclodextrin as host in clathrate inclusion complexes
The crystalline inclusion complexes of -cyclodextrin (C36H60O30) fall into a number of isomorphous or isostructural groups and it is thus quite a versatile host. The chemical compositions within a group are reasonably similar, but there are differences among groups, especially in regard to degree of hydration, and this may indicate one of the sources of the structural differences. In our classification we largely follow Saenger (1985), discussing first the clathrates (Tables 4.2 and 4.3) and then the tunnel inclusion complexes (Tables 4.4–4.9). References and crystal data for earlier work given in extenso by Saenger are summarised in Tables 4.2 to 4.8, and in the text. We find that about two thirds of the structures reported in the CSD fall into the various isomorphous or isostructural groups detailed in the Tables. -Cyclodextrin forms clathrate inclusion complexes with smaller guests which are grouped together in Table 4.2; the gas molecules Cl2, O2, CO2, C2H4, CH4, propane and butane can be enclosed (Cramer and Henglein, 1957) in addition to the guests listed in Table 4.2. Herringbone arrangement of -CD moieties in clathrate inclusion complexes of -cyclodextrin;. Unit cell dimensions: a 9.5, b 14.3, c 37.5; space group P212121; Z ¼ 4; ˚ 3 ; compositions are given in the form {volume per asymmetric unit 1275 A CD[m(guest)]n(H2O)}, where ‘-CD’ is generally omitted for brevity Guest composition
Refcode; reference
a
b
c
V/FU
[7.6H2O] (form III) 0.48Kr58H2O 0.78Kr53H2O I24H2O n-propanol 48H2O CH3OH57H2O 0.8(CH3CN)57H2O CH3NO25H2O [butyric acid]43H2O; [1-butanol] 55H2O [3-iodopropionic acid]5H2O trans-2-butenoic acid5H2O pyrrole5H2O Acetic acid Propionic acid [60H2O] (form I) DMSO2CH3OH2H2O
BANXUJ; CS81 CYDXKR10; SN76 CDEXKR10; SN76 CDEXTI10; MSFM73b CDXPRO; SMFM74 CDEXME10; HS76 GEVTOQ; AJWH98 GULTUC; NILL00 MSFM73a MSFM73a BUPDEV; HUOH83a JECPEM; TSN90 QOHMEF; SRPG00 S85 S85 CHXAMH; MS74, KHS80* ACDMSM; H78 (P21; Z ¼ 2)*
9.400 9.470 9.446 9.558 9.393 9.465 9.479 9.452 9.45 9.44 9.685 9.43 9.404 9.427 9.46 9.529 9.505
14.356 14.299 14.377 14.240 14.292 14.339 14.323 14.299 14.29 14.382 13.508 14.406 14.293 14.34 14.29 14.858 14.150 102.88
37.536 37.489 37.402 36.014 37.515 37.365 37.397 37.380 38.11 37.99 39.581 38.174 37.265 37.62 38.11 34.038 19.738
1266 1261 1266 1225 1259 1268 1269 1263 1287 1289 1323 1296 1252 1272 1287 1205 1294
* These complexes are structurally related but not isomorphous. References: AJWH98 – Aree, Jacob, Saenger and Hoier, 1998; CS81 – Chacko and Saenger, 1981; H78 – Harata, 1978; HS76 – Hingerty and Saenger, 1976; HUOH83a – Harata, Uekama, Otagiri and Hirayama, 1983a; KSH80 – Klar, Hingerty and Saenger, 1980 (XRD and ND; CHXAMH02); MS74 – Manor and Saenger, 1974; MSFM73b – McMullan, Saenger, Fayos and Mootz, 1973b; NILL00 – Nakagawa et al., 2000; S85 – Saenger, 1985; SMFM74 – Saenger, McMullan, Fayos and Mootz, 1974; SN76 – Saenger and Noltemeyer, 1976; SPRG00 – Storsberg et al., 2000.
-CYCLODEXTRIN AS HOST
81
Table 4.2 but detailed crystallographic information is lacking. The crystal data show that these crystals are all isomorphous, despite small differences in water content. The small differences in cell dimensions depend on the nature of the guest and thus there is a fair degree of adaptability among the complexes of Table 4.2. The guest molecules are contained in the internal tunnels (tori) of the -CD molecules and the packing of the hosts is such that free exit of the guests from the tori is blocked by contiguous host molecules held together by an intricate network of hydrogen bonds between hydroxyl groups; the arrangement is shown rather well in the schematic diagram of Fig. 4.2(c). The water molecules lie between the host molecules and participate in the hydrogen bonding, small differences in water content leading to differences of detail in the hydrogen bonding schemes. In addition to the {-CD[I2]4H2O} clathrate complex, the detailed structure of which has been determined, there is a tunnel complex of composition {-CD0.5[I2]4H2O} (Table 4.6). The ternary complex {-CD[2(CH3)2SO.-(CH3OH)]}(CH3OH)2H2O (ACDMSM) also belongs to this group of slipped-tunnel structures; its monoclinic cell can be transformed to give a pseudo-orthorhombic unit cell with the monoclinic b axis coincident with the b axis of the orthorhombic cell of the other examples in Table 4.2. One methanol lies within the torus and the other outside, together with the water molecules. Perhaps surprisingly, the undecahydrate also belongs to this group of complexes. The complexes in Table 4.3 are clathrates, but derived from tunnels by mutual offset of adjacent layers, giving in Saenger’s phrase a ‘‘brickwork-like’’ layer arrangement (Fig. 4.3) or, in an alternative nomenclature, a ‘‘slipped tunnel’’ structure. In these complexes the rings (or methyl groups, for the dimethylformamide guest) are enclosed within the torus with the amino or hydroxyl group of the guest protruding from the 2,3-dihydroxyl face. The space between the -CD molecules is occupied by water molecules, some of which are disordered. There are four distinct -CD hydrates, two being hexahydrates (Form I (BANXUJ) is related to the group of isomorphous crystals of Table 4.2 while Form II (a ¼ 13.70, ˚ , space group P212121; Z ¼ 4; Lindner and Saenger, 1982a) is on its b ¼ 29.35, c ¼ 11.92 A Table 4.3. Clathrate structures, brickwork-like layers in the (001) plane; space group P212121; ˚ ; volume per formula unit 1280 A ˚3 Z ¼ 4. Unit cell dimensions: a 13.6 b 15.3, c 24.5 A Guest composition
Refcode; reference
a
b
c
V/FU
4-chlorophenol5H2O 4-bromophenol5H2O 4-iodophenol3H2O 4-nitrophenol3H2O 2-fluoro-4-nitrophenol3H2O p-iodoaniline3H2O p-hydroxybenzoic acid3.0H2O N,N-dimethylformamide5H2O 2-pyrrolidone 5H2O 11H2O
WEXKOZ; MMKO99 MESYEO; KTM01 CHAIPL; H76 ACDPNP; H77b ZEJDEX; ShSe94 CDEXIA; SBM76, H75 ACDHBA; H77b ACDMFM; H79 ACDPRO; H79 GOQZUH; PMP98
13.447 13.456 13.477 13.431 13.431 13.681 13.356 13.750 13.852 13.839
15.299 15.317 15.373 15.299 15.299 15.475 15.342 15.318 15.373 15.398
24.795 24.733 24.573 24.788 24.780 24.569 24.896 24.544 24.353 24.209
1275 1274 1273 1273 1273 1300 1275 1293 1297 1290
References: H75 – Harata, 1975; H76a – Harata, 1976a; H77b – Harata, 1977b; H79 – Harata, 1979; H82a – Harata, 1982a; HNI96 – Harata, Nagano, Ikeda et al., 1996; KTM01 – Kamitori, Toyama and Matsuzaka, 2001; MMKO99 – Muraoka et al., 1999; PMP98 – Puliti et al., 1998; SBM76 – Saenger, Beyer and Manor, 1976; ShSe94 – Shibakami and Sekiya, 1994.
82
C Y C L O D E X T R I NS , A ND S OM E AN A L O G S , A S H O S T S
(a)
a
1/4 (b)
1/4
1/4
N
b
N 1/4 N
N
N
1/4 c
N a N
Fig. 4.3. A schematic drawing showing the packing in {-CD[p-iodoaniline]}3H2O, a representative of the slipped tunnel structures of Table 4.3. Two cages, one intra-torus and occupied by guest molecules, and the other intermolecular and occupied by waters of hydration, are indicated by light and dense hatching respectively. In (a) the outer contour circles represent the O(2), O(3) rim (‘‘head’’) of the -CD molecules while the middle circles represent the O(6) rim (‘‘tail’’). Circles and molecules drawn with heavier lines are closer to the observer than those with lighter lines. This is also the structure of {-CD11H2O}. (Reproduced from Saenger, Beyer and Manor, 1976.)
own); Form III, approximately an octahydrate, is a ‘‘full’’ member of the group of isomorphous crystals of Table 4.2, and Form IV (undecahydrate) is classified in Table 4.3. The -CD moieties in both hexahydrates have strained, high-energy conformations, different from those in the other two complexes; two of the primary O(6) hydroxyl groups are in the gauche, trans conformation directed towards the center of the doughnut shaped molecule (Fig. 4.4) and two of the O(2) . . . O(3) hydrogen bonds are broken, leading to a ‘‘dented’’ shape for the macrocycle. In contrast, in both Forms III and IV (and also in the isomorphous I2 complex) all the O(6) hydroxyl groups are in the gauche, gauche conformation directed away from the centre of the macrocyclic ring which has a ‘‘round,’’ unstrained shape. In the octahydrate there are 2.6 water molecules within the cavity disordered over 4 sites while in the undecahydrate five water molecules are disordered. In Form I two ordered water molecules are included within the torus, and one water molecule in Form II. This comparison can be extended beyond the hydrates to a number of other -CD complexes (Saenger, Noltemeyer, Manor, Hingerty and Klar, 1976). Thus Saenger
-CYCLODEXTRIN AS HOST
83
Form III
Form I (b)
(a)
0(4)4
0(4)4
0(4)5
0(4)5
0(4)6
0(4)6
0(4)3
)3
0(4
0(4)2
0(4)1 0(4)2
(d)
(c)
(f)
(e)
0(4)1
Fig. 4.4. PLUTO (Motherwell, 1978) space-filling computer-drawn diagrams showing the conformation of the -CD ring in the Form II hexahydrate on the left and the (so-called ‘‘Form III’’) octahydrate on the right. In (a) and (b) the molecules are viewed, from the head side (O(2) . . . O(3)), normal to the hexagon of O(4) atoms of the various glucose residues; in (c) and (d) from the side and in (e) and (f) from the tail of the molecule. In the octahydrate the molecule has a relaxed, round shape but there are distortions in Forms I and II of the hexahydrate especially in the vicinity of glucoses 1 and 6, where O(2) . . . O(3) hydrogen bonds are broken in Form I. In the hexahydrate Form I two O(6) hydroxyls point into the cavity, but not in the octahydrate. (Reproduced from Chacko and Saenger, 1981.)
(1984) contends that -CD also has the strained conformation in aqueous solution and that adduct formation takes place by displacement of the two intra-torus waters by the guest molecule, accompanied by change of the -CD molecule from a ‘‘tense’’ to a more ‘‘relaxed’’ conformation. This mechanism is similar to the ‘‘induced-fit’’ mechanism
84
C Y C L O D E X T R I NS , A ND S OM E AN A L O G S , A S H O S T S
proposed for the interaction of enzymic proteins with their cofactors and substrates (Koshland, 1970), thus indicating that cyclodextrins and their complexes should provide appropriate models for study of enzyme behaviour. The structures of four 1 : 1 crystalline complexes of -CD with metal coordination complexes (and approximately six associated molecules of water) have been reported. Classification presents problems as only one packing arrangement (as opposed to the host–guest relationships) has been described, and the cell dimensions do not show definite similarities to any of the other groups listed in Table 4.2. There is an isomorphous pair of structures [{-CD[Rh(cod)(NH3)2]-PF66H2O}, a ¼ 14.033(4), b ¼ 19.517(6), ˚ (Alston et al., 1985a; DAXTEB) and {-CD [Co(Hdmg)2 c ¼ 23.803(6) A (n-C4H9)H2O)]7H2O}, where H2dmg ¼ dimethylglyoxime, a ¼ 14.083(3), b ¼ 19.237(4), ˚ (Chen et al., 2000; LOVVAT)] and two individual structures {-CD. c ¼ 24.517(5) A ˚ (Luo [Co(Hdmg)2 (n-C3H7)H2O)]7H2O}, a ¼ 13.440(3), b ¼ 17.593(4), c ¼ 29.009(6) A et al., 1996; RAXPOV) and {-CD[C6H12N2O4Pt)]5.5H2O}, a ¼ 10.102(4), b ¼ 13.526(4), ˚ (Alston et al., 1985b; DEGTEO). All these structures crystallize in space c ¼ 41.971(9) A group P212121 with Z ¼ 4, and this suggests that they may all be clathrates. This has been confirmed for the complex with [Co(Hdmg)2(n-C3H7)H2O)] as guest which is the only complex for which the crystal packing has been described. 4.2.2
a-Cyclodextrin as host in tunnel inclusion complexes
The tunnel inclusion complexes of -CD fall into a number of isomorphous or isostructural classes. An immediate distinction can be made between head-to-tail Table 4.4. Tunnel inclusion complexes of -CD with head-to-tail dimers. The space groups are all P21212; Z ¼ 2, and unit cells have been reoriented so as to make [001] the stack axis. Compositions as in Table 4.2, i.e. in the form {-CD[m(guest)]n(H2O)}, where ‘-CD’ is generally omitted for brevity. The square brackets indicate that the guest is included in the torus Guest composition
Refcode; reference
a
b
c
V/FU
[m-Nitrophenol]m-Nitrophenol6H2O* [Benzyl alcohol]Benzyl alcohol6H2O* Na-1-propanesulfonate97H2O [Methyl orange]Naþ9.8H2O [Methyl orange]Kþ9.8H2O [-aminobutyrate]Kþ10.0H2O] [1.5(acetate)]15Kþ9.8H2O [Benzenesulphonate] Naþ10.0H2O 2,5-dihydroxybenzoic acid3.5H2O [Hexanoate] Naþ11.0H2O (Z ¼ 4; see text)
ACDMNP; HUT78 WILJAC; SG94 ACDPRS; H77a CDXSOM; H76a CDXKOM; H76a CDKABA; TAM81 HRW65 CDXBZS; H76c WIZQEB; MM00 MSFM73a
22.231 22.189 21.608 22.099 22.120 21.861 21.89 21.832 21.939 21.94
16.865 16.602 16.700 16.359 16.419 16.624 16.54 16.529 16.786 16.53
8.152 8.265 8.302 8.296 8.292 8.279 8.30 8.356 8.273 16.56
1528 1527 1498 1500 1506 1504 1506 1508 1523 1503
* One guest within each -CD cavity, and one between the stacks. References: H76a – Harata, 1976a; H76c – Harata, 1976c; H77a – Harata, 1977a; HRW65 – Hybl, Rundle and Williams, 1965; HUT78 – Harata, Uedaira and Tanaka, 1978; MM00 – Mele and Malpezzi, 2000; MSFM73a – McMullan, Saenger, Fayos and Mootz, 1973a; SG94 – Steiner and Gessler, 1994; TAM81 – Tokuoka, Abe, Matsumoto, Shirakawa, Fujiwara and Tomita, 1981.
-CYCLODEXTRIN AS HOST
85
and head-to-head arrangements of the -CD molecules in a stack. The crystals of Table 4.4 are built up of -CD molecules stacked head-to-tail along [001], with the guest anions within the tori and the water molecules and cations outside (Fig. 4.5 (left)). The heads and tails of adjacent -CD molecules are hydrogen bonded together in these tunnel complexes, water molecules being located on the peripheries but not between the -CD’s (Fig. 4.6). The Class IIB structures (Fig. 4.5(right)) are lower symmetry variants of the Class IIA type, with differences of detail rather than of principle. The -CD molecules have exact or approximate C2-2 symmetry and closely similar conformations in all the complexes of Table 4.4, although there is some elliptical distortion in the benzenesulphonate and Methyl Orange complexes because of the flattened cross-sections of these guest molecules. The hydrophobic anions are located within the hydrophobic portions of the cavities but are hydrogen bonded to the host molecule at its 6-hydroxyl end; there is disorder about the two-fold axes. There are some differences among the individual complexes; for example the long Methyl Orange anions extend through two -CD molecules (in a partially disordered arrangement, as can be inferred from diffuse scattering on appropriate diffraction photographs), while the acetate groups of the potassium acetate complex are so small that water molecules are accommodated within as well as outside the cavities (Fig. 4.5). The hexanoate anion also extends through two -CD molecules but here the arrangement must be ordered as ˚ . The m-nitrophenol complex shows one the periodicity along [001] is doubled to 16.5 A striking difference of arrangement from the rest of this group, already hinted at by the compositional difference; one guest molecule is found within the torus while the other is located between the host molecules. There are a few analogous examples among other complexes; one possible consequence is different physico-chemical behavior for the two guest molecules. (a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
O6 H C6 H C5 O4 H C3 O3 H
Fig. 4.5. A comparison of the arrangements of guest molecules in the tunnels of some complexes of Table 4.4. The van der Waals envelopes of the guest molecules are shown; broken lines denote hydrogen bonds. The guests are (a) Methyl Orange (H3C)2NC6H4-N¼N–C6H4SO3; (b) Sodium benzenesulphonate NaC6H5SO3; (c) Sodium propanesulphonate NaC3H7SO3; (d) Potassium acetate KCH3COO. Compare with the schematic arrangement shown on the left side of Fig. 4.6. (Reproduced from Harata, 1976a,b.)
86
C Y C L O D E X T R I NS , A ND S OM E AN A L O G S , A S H O S T S
Table 4.5. Tunnel inclusion complexes of -CD with head-to-tail dimers. Space groups are all P21; Z ¼ 2, with stacks along [100] Guest composition
Refcode/reference
a
[m-Nitroaniline]6H2O
CDNOAN; H80
8.054
[Benzaldehyde]6H2O
BAJJAX; HUO81
7.932
[4-fluorophenol]6H2O
JUMYOF; ShSe92
7.845
[2-fluorophenol]5H2O
JUMYUL; ShSe92
7.842
Hydroquinone. 6H2O
PUPTEZ; StSa94
7.909
[p-cresol]6H2O
WEXLEQ; MMKO99
7.927
3-methyl-1-butanol7.1 H2O
S85
(R,S)-1-phenylethanol4H2O
BIJHOR; H82a
8.176
Mono(3-amino-3-deoxy-) -CD 5.5H2O
TOVLOF; HNI96
7.955
16.64
b/
c
V/FU
13.508 94.58 13.500 90.85 13.587 91.75 13.615 92.27 13.505 90.76 13.568 90.41 13.95 95.0 23.930 106.69 24.989 98.15
24.668
1338
24.704
1323
24.557
1308
24.550
1310
24.706
1319
24.54
1320
23.64
1368
13.853
1298
13.106
1290
Notes: BIJHOR has a head-to-tail arrangement in which -CD moieties are inclined at 17 to stack axis; guests sandwiched between -CD molecules. CSD gives p-benzoquinone diagram and formula for PUPTEZ; this is wrong. TOVLOF is a chemically-modified -CD. References: H80 – Harata, 1980; H82a – 1982a; HNI96 – Harata, Nagano, Ikela et al., 1996; HUO81 – Harata, Uekama, Otagiri, Hirayama and Ogino, 1981; MMKO99 – Muraoka et al., 1999; S85 – Saenger 1985; ShSe92 – Shibakami and Sekiya, 1992; StSa94 – Steiner and Saenger, 1994.
For most tables in this chapter, we have listed the variety of guests found in a particular host framework; a converse approach in used in Table 4.6, where we list the variety of frameworks found for hosts of the same chemical type, here ionic polyiodides of various compositions. The variety is quite surprising. Detailed crystal structures have been reported for ZZZANG10 (Cd pentaiodide) and for CYDXLI (Li pentaiodide), which has been inserted in Table 4.7 rather than in Table 4.6 in order to emphasize structural (unit cell) resemblances. A square arrangement of head-to-head dimers stacked in linear fashion along [001] is found in the tetragonal crystals of composition {2(-CD) 0.5(Cdþþ) I3 I2 27 H2O} ˚ 3; ˚ ; space group P41212; Z ¼ 8; volume per formula unit ¼ 1533 A (a ¼ 19.93, c ¼ 30.88 A Noltemeyer and Saenger, 1980; ZZZANG10). The guest anion is [I5 ] and other examples are found with the cations Kþ, NH4þ, Hþ and some divalent species; this is the stable form for Kþ and NH4þ cations. Isostructural crystals are formed with the neutral guest 4,4 0 -biphenyldicarboxylic acid [{2(-CD) C14H10O4 14H2O} (a ¼ 19.609, ˚ ; space group P41212; Z ¼ 8; volume per formula unit ¼ 1550 A ˚ 3; Kamitori c ¼ 32.257 A 0 et al., 1998; CAQPAL). The 4,4 -biphenyldicarboxylic acid guest is entirely enclosed
-CYCLODEXTRIN AS HOST
b
87
0
b a
c
1/4
1/4
1/4
1/4
1/4
1/4
a
c a
b
0
Fig. 4.6. (Left) General arrangement of -CD molecules in the tunnel inclusion complexes of Table 4.4, illustrated for the [1-propane sulphonate]. Naþ9.7H2O complex. Stack axis [001]. (Right) General arrangement of -CD molecules in the tunnel inclusion complexes of Table 4.5. illustrated for the [benzaldehyde] 6H2O complex. Stack axis [100]. (Adapted from Harata (1977a) and Harata, Uekama, Otagiri, Hirayama and Ogino, 1981.)
Fig. 4.7. A stereoview showing the head-to-tail stacking of –CD molecules in {-CD [benzaldehyde]6.0H2O}, illustrating the arrangement in the tunnel inclusion complexes of Table 4.5. Here water molecules also participate in the intracolumn stacking but in other examples the ˚ interactions are only between -CD molecules. Intermolecular O . . . O contacts of less than 3.1 A are shown by thin lines. The benzaldehyde guests can be seen inside the columns. (Reproduced from Harata, Uekama, Otagiri, Hirayama and Ogino, 1981.)
88
C Y C L O D E X T R I NS , A ND S OM E AN A L O G S , A S H O S T S
Table 4.6. Various crystals with polyiodide anions showing the variety of crystal types obtained. The approximately linear anions are held within the -CD torus, with counterions and water molecules between the stacks of -CD head-to-head dimers. The formulae are based on {2(-CD) – note the change from the standard formulation used elsewhere Overall composition
Refcode/ reference
2(-CD NaI3.I2.)8H2O
CYDXTF; NS80 CYDXTE
2(-CD)[I2]8H2O 2(-CD)CsI3I212H2O Alternatively, hexagonal
CYDXTC; NS80
Other cations
a/
b/
c/
Space group
19.590
NH4þ, Kþ, Rbþ
24.440 15.750 space group 109.30 not given 12.970 12.970 7.910 120 15.8 27.37 40.2 C222 15.8
2(-CD)Ba2(I)I212H2O ZZZAND10; 13.71 NS80 2(-CD)Cd0.5 I3I227H2O ZZZANG10; H3Oþ, NH4þ, 19.90 NS80; Kþ, Rbþ, Mg2 þ , Ca2þ, Sr2 þ , Ba2þ, Zn2 þ , Cd2 þ 2(-CD) CAQPAL; 19.609 KMKO98 [4,4 0 -biphenyldicarboxylic acid]14H2O
15.8 13.71 19.90
40.2 120 17.04 120 30.80 90
P62, P6222, P31 P622 P42212
19.609 32.257 P42212
References: KMKO98 – Kamitori et al., 1998; MSFM73a – McMullan, Saenger, Fayos and Mootz, 1973a; NS80 – Noltemeyer and Saenger, 1980.
within the head-to-head dimer, with carboxyls of succeeding guest molecules linked through a pair of water molecules. When -CD was crystallized from a solution containing 4,4 0 -biphenyldicarboxylic acid and CaCl2, then orthorhombic crystals [{2(-CD) ˚ ; space group P21212; Z ¼ 8; C14H10O414H2O} (a ¼ 35.397, b ¼ 24.577, c ¼ 27.969 A ˚ 3; Kamitori et al., 1998; CAQPEP) were obtained. volume per formula unit ¼ 1550 A Structure analysis showed that there were short columns composed of two head-to-head dimers instead of the continuous one-dimensional stacks; however, the guest molecules were enclosed in much the same pattern in both forms. Are these polymorphs? The word was not mentioned by Kamitori et al. The isomorphous structures of the first group in Table 4.7 (the organometallic guests) have been succinctly described by Klingert and Rihs (1991a) as follows: ‘‘ . . . the -CD molecules are arranged head-to-head to form a dimer, with all secondary hydroxy groups of one macrocycle linked to the adjacent one by direct hydrogen bonds. The dimers are stacked along the crystallographic c axis forming parallel channels in which the guest cations and anions are lined up alternately. The cations are encapsulated within the cavity of the dimers while the PF6 anions . . . are centred between the primary hydroxyl faces of adjacent dimers.’’ This description applies well to the complex with neutral Fe(cp)2 as guest (where the PF6 anion is absent), and also to the crystals with neutral molecular guests. The lithium
-CYCLODEXTRIN AS HOST
89
Table 4.7. Isomorphous triclinic crystals (the unit cells are reduced) with guests of various kinds. The space group is P1, Z ¼ 2 unless stated otherwise. In the first group of complexes there are organometallic cations held within the torus of the -CD head-to-head dimers, the PF6 counterions between the tail ends of adjacent dimers and water molecules between the stacks. The general formula is {2(-CD) [Mþ][PF 6 ]8H2O} (note the change from the standard formulation used elsewhere); (-CD) and PF6 are omitted for brevity, while Mþ represents the organometallic cation. The next group has two molecules and one salt as guest. The 1-octanol and valeric acid complexes have head-to-head dimers and hexagonal packing of stacks. The last two examples are presumably isostructural to the first group Organometallic guest cation
Refcode; reference
a/
b/
c/
Unit cell volume
Rh(cp)2þ8H2O
KIWZEV; KR91a,b KIWZAR; KR91a,b KIWYUK; KR91a,b JEMGUD; OH90 PEPBUH; MS-ES-F93 JEHYIE; KR90 KOGKEW; KR91b XIGBOE; S-RPLB01 ZASYOH; NVCdR94 CYDXLI10; NS80 S85
13.756 91.33 13.810 91.06 13.806 91.43 13.836 92.22 13.768 90.98 13.815 91.41 13.845 91.94 13.83 93.01 13.852 93.01 13.830 91.91 13.86
13.833 93.08 13.833 92.94 13.839 92.77 13.864 92.13 13.911 93.46 13.891 92.85 13.861 91.98 13.88 91.72 13.878 91.98 13.855 92.20 13.86
2565
S85
13.85
13.85
MSFM73a; S85 KR91a
11.911 91.3 13.892 89.63
13.870 93.75 13.926 89.20
15.561 119.67 15.560 119.76 15.520 119.80 15.694 119.76 15.601 119.47 15.639 119.64 15.641 119.85 15.72 119.58 15.719 119.32 15.690 119.82 15.63 120 15.62 120 15.669 115.01 16.585 60.26
Co(cp)2þ8H2O Fe(cp)2þ8H2O Fe(cp)29H2O CpRu(C6H6)þ8H2O Fe(cp)(C6H6)þ8H2O Fe(cp)(C7H8)þ8H2O {2(-CD) [n-butylisothiocyanate]9H2O} {2(-CD) [acetone]9H2O} 2(-CD)LiI3 I28H2O 1-octanol (Laue symmetry 6/mm) Valeric acid (Laue symmetry 6/mm) [Diethyl ether]4.1H2O Fe(cp)(C8H8)þnH2O
2574 2566 2606 2593 2601 2597 2615 2625 2602 1300 1298 2606 2786
Notes: ˚ , 90.02 1. KOGKEW gives a metrically-C-centered monoclinic cell with dimensions 13.884 23.977 15.641 A 93.91 90.08 (Z ¼ 4). Coordinates are available for checking. ˚ , 89.96 2. Fe(cp)(C8H8) gives a metrically-C-centered monoclinic cell with dimensions 13.892 24.183 16.585 A 90.80 90.18 (Z ¼ 4). Coordinates are not available for checking. ˚ , 89.95 94.30 3. JEMGUD gives a metrically C-centered monoclinic cell with dimensions 13.900 23.960 15.694 A 90.13 (Z ¼ 4). Coordinates are available for checking (Odakagi et al., 1990). 4. Na and Tl give crystals isomorphous with 2(-CD)LiI3I28H2O. References: KR90 – Klingert and Rihs, 1990; KR91a – Klingert and Rihs, 1991a; KR91b – Klingert and Rihs, 1991b; MSFM73a – McMullan, Saenger, Fayos and Mootz, 1973a; MS-FS-E93 – Meister, Stoeckli-Evans and Su¨ssFink, 1993; NS80 – Noltemeyer and Saenger, 1980; NVCdR94 – Nicolis, Villain et al., 1995; OH90 – Odagaki et al., 1990; S85 – Saenger 1985; S-RPLB01 – Sicard-Roselli et al., 2001.
90
C Y C L O D E X T R I NS , A ND S OM E AN A L O G S , A S H O S T S
Table 4.8. Trigonal crystals with organometallic cations held within the -CD head-to-head dimers and PF6.counterions held between the dimers; the water molecules lie between the stacks of dimers. The general formula is {2(-CD) [Mþ] PF6nH2O, with n 13} (note the change from the standard formulation used elsewhere). In this table only the organometallic guest cation is listed. The original data come from Klingert and Rihs (1991b; T ¼ 180K) except where noted otherwise Organometallic guest cation
Refcode
a
c
Unit cell volume
Fe(cp)(indan)þ Fe(cp)(cumene)þ Fe-bis(cp)propaneþ Fe(cp)(o-xylene)þ Fe(cp)(anisole)þ Ru(cp)(acetophenone)þ (water content not given)
KOGKIA KOGKOG KOGKUM KOGLAT KOGLEX PEPCAO; MS-ES-F93
13.836 13.846 13.812 13.867 13.907 13.918
50.464 50.272 50.356 50.468 49.700 49.77
8366 8347 8319 8404 8324 8349
pentaiodide complex has the anti-isomorphous structure,2 with the charged species interchanged. The complexes of Table 4.7 provide an excellent illustration of how a particular framework can accommodate a variety of chemically different guests, and this generalization applies not only to cyclodextrin complexes. We have some understanding of the principles governing the construction of the framework but little knowledge of what determines which guests will be accepted. The examples in Table 4.8 (another group of isomorphous crystals) show that small changes in the nature of the organometallic cations can lead to a different type of crystal structure, albeit still based on dimers enclosing cations and anions between stacks. About two-thirds of the -CD structures listed in the CSD can be accommodated in isomorphous or isostructural groups (Tables 4.2 to 4.8, excluding Table 4.7). The others are found in space groups P212121,3 P214 and P21212,5 with a few exceptions. Judging from the cell dimensions, these crystals are all different but we have not made a detailed structural comparison. A ‘‘one-of-a-kind’’ structure that warrants special mention is {-CD(cyclopentanone)4.6 H2O}. This was first studied by XRD at room temperature by Le Bas (see Tsoucaris et al., 1987; FERCIO) and then by neutron dif˚ , space group P6, Z ¼ 6; Le Bas and Mason, 1994; fraction at 20K (a ¼ 23.725, c ¼ 7.935 A KIRJOK10). Diffuse scattering at 300K has also been studied (Le Bas and Doucet, 1997). Although there is static disorder even at 20K, the high symmetry and low temperature reveal features not yet found in other -CD structures. 4.2.3
Chemically modified -cyclodextrins as hosts in inclusion complexes
It has been found that chemical modification of cyclodextrins, primarily by methylation or acetylation of hydroxyl groups, leads to hosts with properties different from those of the 2 ‘‘Two substances are said to be anti-isomorphous when their crystal structure[s] are geometrically identical but with the positions of corresponding atoms or ions interchanged.’’ (Evans, 1966, p. 194). 3 HOGCIP, KOBLOC, MEWFUP, QOYLEV, RAXPOV, ROQVUO, TEVCEC, VEHQAA, ZIBWIQ, ZIBWOW. 4 BOLVUT, CDXNEH, OBUMED, RIQDIE, RIQDOK. 5 HEHQAM, MESYAK.
-CYCLODEXTRIN AS HOST
91
native cyclodextrins. The compounds are shown in the schematic formula, with their trivial names (R00 ¼ CH3 for all formulae). R⬙O6C6H3C O3R⬘ 5 O4
4
1
O5 3
2 O2R
n 6 6 7 7
R R0 CH3 H CH3 CH3 CH3 H CH3 CH3 Scheme 4.1
n
name per-dimethyl--CD per-trimethyl--CD per-dimethyl--CD per-trimethyl--CD
The crystal structure of 6A,6C,6E-tri-O-methyl--CD6.7H2O (i.e. three alternate CH2OH groups methylated) has been reported (Durier, Buisson, Due´e, Driguez and Taravel, 1992; PEZKAG), but not (as yet) of any of its inclusion complexes. Crystal data ˚ , V(asymmetric unit) ¼ 1321.0(2) A ˚ 3, are a ¼ 13.975(1), b ¼ 29.162(2), c ¼ 12.965(1) A space group P212121, Z ¼ 4. The molecules are packed in herringbone fashion and there is some resemblance to -CD7.6H2O (form III). Two water molecules are ordered inside the torus, and one ordered, and 3.7 disordered, outside it. The chemically modified -cyclodextrins whose inclusion complexes have been studied crystallographically are hexakis(2,6-di-O-methyl)--CD (C48H84O30, called per-dimethyl-CD) and hexakis(2,3,6-tri-O-methyl)--CD (C54H96O30, per-trimethyl--CD). In per-dimethyl--CD the O(3) hydroxyl groups form O(3)-H . . . O(2) intramolecular ˚ . The crystal structures of the hydrogen bonds which vary in length from 2.87 to 3.16 A per-dimethyl--CD 1 : 1 complexes with I2, acetone (ROQVOI) and 1–propanol (KAF˚, GAZ10) are isomorphous (for the I2 complex: a ¼ 14.124, b ¼ 10.667, c ¼ 21.443 A ˚ 3; KAFFUS10) ¼ 106.3 , space group P21, Z ¼ 2, volume of the asymmetric unit 1552 A and have been shown to be clathrates, with the guests enclosed within the tori of the host molecules (Harata, 1990b). The 1 : 1 complex of per-dimethyl--CD with 3-iodopropionic ˚ , volume of acid is orthorhombic (VERVET; a ¼ 10,707, b ¼ 14.504, c ¼ 41.448 A ˚ 3, space group P212121) and also has a clathrate structure (Harata, asymmetric unit 1616 A 1989). It is striking that these three complexes are anhydrous although crystallized from water, in contrast to the hydrated complexes generally formed. Per-dimethyl-CDacetonitrile dihydrate (Aree, Hoier, Schulz, Reck and Saenger, 2000a; WEXKIT) is also orthorhombic P212121 but not isomorphous with VERVET. Among the interesting properties of the permethylated cyclodextrins is their solubility behavior, summarized as follows by Aree, Uson et al. (1999): ‘‘ . . . the solubility coefficients in water become negative, i.e. they are better soluble in cold than in hot water, where they precipitate or crystallize (Uekama and Irie, 1987) . . . methylated CDs have been crystallized from hot and cold water at 60–89 C and at 4–18 C . . . The crystals that could be obtained from hot water are anhydrous hexakis(2,6-di-O-methyl)-–CD
C Y C L O D E X T R I NS , A ND S OM E AN A L O G S , A S H O S T S
92
(Harata, 1995; Steiner, Hirayama and Saenger, 1996), anhydrous hexakis(2, 3, 6-tri-Omethyl)-–CD and anhydrous heptakis(2, 6-di-O-methyl)-–CD (Steiner and Saenger, 1995a), heptakis(2, 3, 6-tri-O-methyl)-–CDH2O (Caira, Griffith et al., 1994b) and octakis(2, 3, 6-tri-O-methyl)-–CD 2 H2O (Steiner and Saenger, 1998b),’’ Many of these structures (and others) are noted in the following pages. In per-trimethyl--CD all hydroxyl groups have been methylated and the methoxy oxygens can act only as hydrogen bond acceptors. The methoxy groups extend above and below the mean plane of the macrocyclic ring, thus increasing the height of the ˚ (instead of 8 A ˚ for -CD) and decreasing the cross-section truncated cone to 11 A at the 6-methoxy end (Fig. 4.8); this leads to a vase shape (cf. Section 3.4 on cavitands and caviplexes). There is no intramolecular hydrogen bonding and thus the macrocyclic rings are more flexible than those of -CD, with consequent enhancement of the possibilities for chiral discrimination, as has been demonstrated for the diastereoisomeric complexes of R- and S-mandelic acid [PhCH(OH)COOH] (Harata, Uekama, Otagiri and Hirayama, 1987). The four complexes whose structures have been determined fall into three groups (Table 4.9). The limited number of water molecules present is a striking feature of the compositions compared to those of the -CD complexes. The packing of pertrimethyl--CD molecules in the tunnel complexes is compared in Fig. 4.9. The principal
z y x
Fig. 4.8. Stereoview of hexakis(2,3,6-tri-O-methyl)--CD as found in its per-trimethyl--CD. [ p-iodoaniline]H2O complex (Table 4.9). The bracketed moieties are shown included in the torus. The 2,3-methoxy groups are at the bottom of the diagram (‘head’ of the molecule) and the 6-methoxy groups at the top (‘tail’). (Data from Harata, Uekama, Otagiri and Hirayama, 1984.)
sinb
I
II
III
Fig. 4.9. Schematic diagrams of the stacking arrangements in the tunnel inclusion complexes of pertrimethyl--CD: (I) p-iodoaniline; (II) benzaldehyde; (III) p-nitrophenol. (Reproduced from Harata, Uekama, Otagiri, Hirayama and Sugiyama, 1982.)
-CYCLODEXTRIN AS HOST
93
Table 4.9. Structural classification of the inclusion complexes of hexakis(2,3,6-tri-O-methyl)-˚ , deg. V/FU ¼ volume CD (per-trimethyl--CD); compositions as in Table 4.2; cell dimensions in A ˚ 3) per formula unit. These are all tunnel structures, with head-to-tail packing along [001] and (A reported in space group P21; Z ¼ 2. However, note that CECMAY has been reinterpreted as C2221 (Marsh et al., 2002), and that the space group of the last complex is P212121; Z ¼ 4 Guest and water content
Refcode/reference
a
b
c
V/FU
Class IA:[C6H6NI] H2O [p-iodoaniline] [R-mandelic acid]2H2O
BEYLOG; HUO82a CECMEC10; HUO87 BOHWUQ; HUOHS82 BUPDIZ, JEJWOK; H90a JEJXAX; H90a BUPDIZ; HUOH83a BUDKEQ; HUOH82b CECMAY10; HUO82a CECMAY11; MHKH02 MYM01
11.440
23.674
13.531
91.90
1831
11.624
23.739
13.786
106.56
1823
11.604
23.832
13.593
106.11
1799
11.604
23.669
13.824
106.72
1818
11.586
23.641
13.762
106.45
1808
11.59
23.285
13.901
106.98
1794
11.307
14.578
22.118
96.36
1812
13.123
23.187
13.113
107.19
1906
15.571
21.116
23.187
14.636
21.637
23.45
[benzaldehyde]
[(R)-phenylethanol] [(S)-phenylethanol]H2O Iodoacetic acidH2O Class IB: [p-nitrophenol]H2O Class II: [S-mandelic acid]3H2O Reinterpretation with space group C2221 (R)-1,7-dioxaspiro [5.5]-undecane5.1 H2O
1857
References: H90a – Harata 1990a; HUO82a – Harata, Uekama, Otagiri and Hirayama, 1982a; HUOH82b – Harata, Uekama, Otagiri and Hirayama, 1982b, 1984; HUOH83a – Harata, Uekama, Otagiri and Hirayama, 1983a; HUO87 – Harata, Uekama, Otagiri and Hirayama, 1987; HUOHS82 – Harata, Uekama, Otagiri, Hirayama and Sugiyama, 1982; MHKH02 – Marsh et al., 2002; MYM01 – Makedonopoulou, Yannakopoulou et al., 2001.
interactions between host molecules are of the van der Waals type, in contrast to the other cyclodextrin complexes where the hosts are blanketed by large numbers of water molecules. Here, if present, the few water molecules are hydrogen bonded to guest and host within the host tunnel and do not link host molecules. Despite the overall similarities in molecular arrangement, there are subtle differences of detail which are first revealed by small differences in cell dimensions. There is a considerable measure of adaptability in the per-trimethyl--CD tunnel inclusion complexes. A remarkable enantiospecific separation of the enantiomers of the racemic olive fly pheromone 1,7-dioxaspiro[5.5]undecane [] by complexation of the (R)-enantiomer with hexakis(pertrimethyl)--CD and of the [S]-enantiomer with heptakis(pertrimethyl)-CD has been reported by Mentzafos, Mavridis and Yannakopoulou (1999) and Makedonopoulou, Yannakopoulou et al. (2001). The binding constants of the two complexes determined by NMR in aqueous solution are respectively 6600 M1 for the
C Y C L O D E X T R I NS , A ND S OM E AN A L O G S , A S H O S T S
94
[R]-enantiomer – hexakis(per-trimethyl)--CD complex and 935 M1 for the [S]enantiomer – heptakis(per-trimethyl)--CD complex. These differences can be explained by the details of the interactions between enantiomer and cyclodextrin in the respective pairs. In the complex of the (R)-enantiomer with hexakis(pertrimethyl)--CD the guest interacts not only with the enclosing host but also with other hosts in the crystal lattice; C–H . . . O interactions appear to be particularly important. On the other hand, the diastereomers of hexakis(pertrimethyl)--CD with R-and S-phenylethanol are isomorphous (JEJWOK and JEJXAX in Table 4.9) and enantiomeric separation does not appear feasible. O
O O
O
[S] enantiomer
[R]-enantiomer
Scheme 4.2
The mode of insertion of the same guest molecules in the tunnel inclusion complexes of -CD and per-trimethyl--CD is compared in Fig. 4.10. There are similarities for p-iodoaniline but not for the other two guests; however, it would be premature to generalize on the basis of the meagre available evidence. The conformations of per-trimethyl--CD and per-trimethyl--CD have been discussed in detail together with the host–guest inclusion geometry (Harata, Uekama, Otagiri and Hirayama, 1982b, 1984). W I H H H
C
C
C C
C C O
O
H H
H
C H
H
Benzaldehyde
C
C C
C C
C
H C C C H
H
C
H
H
C H
H
C
C N
H
H
H
p-Iodoaniline
H
I H
C
C
C C
C C H
N
H H
H
W O H H
C
N C
O C C
C C
H H
H C
H
O C C
H C C
O H
H
C H
O N O
A p-Nitrophenol
B
Fig. 4.10. Schematic diagrams of the modes of inclusion of the same guest molecules in -CD tunnel inclusion complexes (on the left) and per-trimethyl--CD tunnel inclusion complexes (on the right). The O(2,3) hydroxyls are at the lower ends of the truncated cones. Note the water molecules included in two of the right hand diagrams. (Reproduced from Harata, Uekama, Otagiri and Hirayama, 1982b.)
-CYCLODEXTRIN AS HOST
95
4.3 b-Cyclodextrin as host The -cyclodextrin molecule (C42H70O35) consists of seven 1,4--linked D-glucose residues in the 4C1 chair conformation (Fig. 4.11). The secondary hydroxyls are hydrogen bonded around the macrocyclic ring, increasing its stability and reducing its flexibility. The primary hydroxyls have conformations which depend on the host–guest relationship; in general these hydroxyls have a gauche–gauche conformation and point away from the centre of the macrocycle. However, in some instances the C(6) hydroxyls of glucose residues G3 and G4 have the gauche–trans conformation and point towards the centre of the macrocycle; {-CD[1,4-diazabicyclo[2.2.2]octane]13H2O} (Table 4.10) is an example. This conformation is maintained by hydrogen bonding linking the hydroxyls through a water molecule.
Fig. 4.11.(a) Stereoview of -CD looking downwards from the tail (O(6) end) of the -CD molecule in its complex with [2,5-diiodobenzoic acid]7H2O. All the primary hydroxyls are shown with gauche–gauche conformations pointing away from the centre of the macrocycle; the intramolecular hydrogen bonding between adjacent secondary hydroxyls is clearly seen at the head of the molecule at the bottom of the diagram. Complex is listed in Table 4.14. (Reproduced from Hamilton, Sabesan and Steinrauf, 1981.)
Fig. 4.11.(b) Side-view of the -CD conformation in -CD[1,4-diazabicyclo[2.2.2]octane]13H2O complex, showing the C(6) hydroxyls of G3 and G4 with gauche–trans conformation, on the right hand side of the molecule, pointing towards the centre of the macrocycle. The 6-hydroxyls (the narrower tail of the molecule) are at the top of the diagram. Complex is listed in Table 4.10; oxygens cross-hatched. (Data from Harata, 1982b.)
96
C Y C L O D E X T R I NS , A ND S OM E AN A L O G S , A S H O S T S
˚ , deg.) Table 4.10. Crystal data for isomorphous -CD clathrate inclusion complexes. Unit cells (A have been reoriented where required to maintain a common pattern. All crystals have space group P21 with Z ¼ 2, except where stated otherwise. Compositions are expressed as {-CD[m(guest)] nH2O} with -CD being omitted for brevity. Measurements by XRD at room temperature (nominal 298K) except where stated otherwise; ND ¼ neutron diffraction. V/FU ¼ volume per formula unit ˚3 in A Guest Group I (a) (clathrates) 11H2O (ND at 298K)* 11H2O (ND at 120K) 1.8 HCl8H2O 2HI8H2O CH3OH6.5H2O C2H5OH8H2O (ND – 298K; deuterated crystal) C2H5OH8H2O (ND – 15K; deuterated crystal) KOH9H2O 0.5(DMSO)7.35 H2O Benzyl alcohol [C6H6N2O]6H2O (nicotinamide) [diethanolamine]6.4H2O [but-2-yne-1,4-diol]6.2H2O [propane-1,3-diol]7H2O [C4H10O2]6H2O (1,4-butanediol) (1,5-pentanediol)6.2H2O [diethylene glycol]6H2O [glycerol]7.2H2O [ethylene glycol]8 H2O (squaric acid)6.65 H2O
Refcode; reference
a
b/
c
V/FU
BUVSEQ02; BSHB84 BUVSEQ03; ZSM86 ZZZBVD; SB77 BOBPEN; LS82b BOBPIR; LS82b SIGHOF01; SMS91 SIGHOF02; SMS91 KOBRIC; CNV91 VACZIJ; AC02 DEBGOG; HUOHO85 CACCOY; HKFO83 YIYSII; SKGS95 ZIGZIY; SKGS95 YIYTAB; SKGS95 KUTKOZ; SKS92 YIYSOO; SKGS95 YIYSUU; SKGS95 PIJGOE; GSKS93 PIJGIY; GSK93 MIFHAK; CFM01
21.26
10.31 112.3 10.03 112.5 10.27 109.0 10.28 113.3 10.11 111.0 10.21 111.472 10.00 109.0 10.58 108.4 10.285 109.86 10.101 112.81 10.37 110.5 9.987 111.85 10.092 111.30 9.976 110.88 9.973 110.87 10.014 111.25 9.969 111.62 9.954 111.20 10.021 111.47 10.068 110.16
15.30
1533
14.89
1491
15.04
1515
15.30
1538
15.33
1521
15.215
1527
15.23
1473
15.22
1544
15.155
1532
15.356
1522
15.37
1525
15.247
1506
15.223
1544
15.274
1503
15.271
1508
15.240
1526
15.276
1507
15.251
1509
15.208
1504
15.231
1520
21.62 20.75 21.25 21.03 21.125 20.46 20.20 20.906 21.287 20.43 21.310 20.988 21.116 21.199 21.451 21.288 21.322 21.212 21.117
-CYCLODEXTRIN AS HOST
97
Table 4.10. (Continued ) 0.3(formic acid)7.7 H2O
ASR03
20.986
0.4(acetic acid)7.7 H2O
ASR03
21.044
DIRVOP; H84 POVSIC; StSa98c
20.12
Group I (b) (clathrates) [C6H12N4]6H2O (hexamethylene-tetramine) Trans-cyclohexane-1,4-diol5.4 H2O Group II (brickwork or slipped-tunnel) [C6H12N2]13H2O (diazabicyclo[2.2.2]octane) [C11H11N3SO2]8.3H2O (sulfathiazole) Miscellaneous: space group P212121, Z ¼ 4 2{(Mg(H2O)6 Cl2}3.5H2O (CaCl2)211H2O
20.042
10.169 110.92 10.157 110.67
15.171
1512
15.263
1526
15.29
1557
15.123
1572
16.60 117.4 16.50 117.3
15.44
1752
15.56
1741
10.35 102.1 10.378 102.30
BISTAY; H82b LILLUN; CGN94c
15.40
ZEZTED; NCCR95 HIDZAV; NCCR96
15.95
18.61
23.36
1734
15.88
17.58
24.27
1694
15.26
* A 12-hydrate has been reported (Lindner and Saenger, 1982b; Hamilton, Steinrauf and Van Etten, 1968 (BCDEXD, 01–05, 10; QQQAEV)) with approximately the same cell dimensions as the 11-hydratePerhaps this is an example of concomitant small compositional and structural variationsThe reversible dehydration has been studied (Steiner and Koellner, 1994)The XRD structure at 300K has been reported (Steiner and Koellner, 1994; BUVSEQ01). References: AC02 – Aree and Chaichit, 2002; ASR03 – Aree, Schulz and Reck, 2003; BSHB84 – Betzel, Saenger, Hingerty and Brown, 1984; CFM01 – Crisma et al., 2001; CGN94c – Caira, Griffith, Nassimbeni and van Oudtshoorn, 1994c; CNV91 – Charpin, Nicolis, Villian, Rango and Coleman, 1991; GSKS93 – Gessler, Steiner, Koellner and Saenger, 1993; H82b – Harata, 1982b; H84 – Harata, 1984; HKFO83 – Harata, Kawano, Fukunaga and Ohtani, 1983; HUOHO85 – Harata, Uekama, Otagiri, Hirayama and Ohtani, 1985; LS82b – Lindner and Saenger, 1982b; NCCR95 – Nicolis, Coleman, Charpin and de Rango, 1995; NCCR96 – Nicolis, Coleman, Charpin and de Rango, 1996; SB77 – Szjetli and Budai, 1977; SKGS95 – Steiner, Koellner, Gessler and Saenger, 1995; SKS92 – Steiner, Koellner and Saenger, 1992; SMS91 – Steiner, Mason and Saenger, 1991; StSa95 – Steiner and Saenger,1995; StSa98c – Steiner and Saenger,1998c; ZSM86 – Zabel, Saenger and Mason, 1986;
4.3.1 -Cyclodextrin as host in clathrate inclusion complexes The crystal data are given in Table 4.10; there are some twenty isomorphous (or nearly so) cage complexes (Class I) and one slipped-tunnel (brickwork) structure (Class II), which are illustrated in Figs. 4.12 and 4.13. The -CD clathrates resemble those of -CD in that both can be divided into similar structural types. The arrangement in Class II is head-totail but the slippage between adjacent planes is such that there is very little overlap between successive -CD molecules and hence only minimal hydrogen bonding between them. The two C(6) hydroxyls, which have gauche–trans conformations, point in towards the centre of the macrocycle in the undecahydrate and in the diazabicyclo[2.2.2]octane complex but without disrupting any of the intramolecular hydrogen bonds made by the secondary hydroxyls and without disturbing the round shape of the
98
C Y C L O D E X T R I NS , A ND S OM E AN A L O G S , A S H O S T S
macrocycle. Gessler, Steiner, Koellner and Saenger (1993) have concluded that ‘‘the general behaviour of the guest molecules is similar for all inclusion complexes of -CD with small hydrophilic molecules studied so far. If the complexed molecule is too small to fill the cavity, several water molecules are also included, thereby forming a cluster of hydrogen-bonded guest molecules. This cluster is dynamically disordered: the molecules are mobile, and perform jumps between different alternative (but discrete) sites. In solution, such rearrangements certainly occur in an even more pronounced way than in the crystalline solid state.’’ One structure that does not fit into any of the tabulated groups is {-CD2,7˚ , ¼ 109.28 , dihydroxynaphthalene4.6 H2O} (a ¼ 14.082. b ¼ 19.079, c ¼ 12.417 A space group P21, Z ¼ 2; Anibarro et al., 2001; CACQED); nevertheless, the packing principles are similar. The 2,7-dihydroxynaphthalene molecule is completely included in the -CD cavity with its long axis along the -CD molecular axis, leading to marked elliptical distortion. These moieties are arranged in herring-bone fashion with the 4.6 water molecules distributed at the narrow (tail) end of the -CD cavity. Another exceptional structure is that of {-CDmefenamic acidxH2O} (a ¼ 15.480. b ¼ 25.589, ˚ , ¼ 98.976 , space group P21, Z ¼ 2; Pop et al., 2001; MUPNEQ) where c ¼ 9.297 A mefenamic acid is 2-[2,3-dimethylphenyl-amino]benzoic acid; the moieties are arranged in herring-bone fashion. This structure is noteworthy because it was solved using highresolution room-temperature synchrotron data from polycrystalline samples; this is the first such structure determination and carries important implications for study of CD complexes unobtainable as single crystals. There is a glass transition at about 150 K and a first-order transition in {-CD11H2O} at 226K, with H ¼ 10.2 kJ/mol and S ¼ 451 J K1 mol1 (Hanabata, Matsuo and Suga, 1987); the first-order nature of the transition is hinted at by the appreciably different cell dimensions at 298 and 120K (Table 4.10). Neutron diffraction (Betzel, Saenger, Hingerty and Brown, 1984; Zabel, Saenger and Mason, 1986) shows that the phase change is due to a cooperative ordering of hydrogen bonds, which are dynamically disordered above 226K; the glass transition is ascribed to freezing of the configuration of protons participating in a four-membered ring of water molecules found only in the low temperature phase. Partially deuterated {-CD[C2H5OH3H2O]5H2O} has also been studied at 15K by neutron diffraction (Steiner, Mason and Saenger, 1989); at room temperature most hydroxyl groups and water molecules, especially those in the cavity region containing [C2H5OH3H2O], are extensively disordered. However, a well ordered network of hydrogen bonds is found at 15K. Later work (Steiner, Mason and Saenger, 1991) used fully deuterated crystals. There are two structures with divalent metal cations which have -CD packings related to the herringbone structure type. These are {-CD2{(Mg(H2O)6Cl2}3.5H2O} (Nicolis, Coleman, Charpin and Rango, 1995; ZEZTED) and {-CD(CaCl2)211H2O} (Nicolis, Coleman, Charpin and Rango, 1996; HIDZAV) (Table 4.10, Miscellaneous). The presence of metal cations (also in the KOH complex) involves new structural considerations. Kþ can be included without much disturbance of the overall structure, as is shown by the resemblance of the cell dimensions and symmetry of the KOH complex to those parameters of the large group of -CD complexes with organic guests. However, divalent cations require more drastic changes for their accommodation. Indeed, Nicolis, Coleman et al. (1995) comment: ‘‘The structure [of the Mg complex] may be considered
-CYCLODEXTRIN AS HOST
99
z y
Fig. 4.12. Diagram of the crystal structure of hexamethylenetetramine (HMT) complex of -CD (DIRVOP) viewed down the [100] axis. This is a representative of the clathrate structures (Table 4.10, Group Ib). The HMT guests (emphasized) are enclosed within the -CD tori, which have a herringbone arrangement. The water molecules have been omitted for clarity and the intermolecular hydrogen bonding is not shown. (Data from Harata, 1984.)
b
b
a
c a
c sin b
Fig. 4.13. The slipped-tunnel or brickwork structure of {-CD[diazabicyclo[2.2.2]-octane] 13H2O}, illustrating structures listed in Table 4.10 (Group II) (cf. Fig. 4.2(c)). (Reproduced from Harata, 1982b.)
in two ways: first, a novel arrangement of –CD monomers into which an inorganic motif is inserted or second, a space-filling arrangement of a –CD assembly within an inorganic matrix . . . The nature of the structure is such that it is difficult to say which substructure, organic or inorganic, determines the overall packing.’’ We add a second quotation about HIDVAZ (Nicolis, Coleman et al. (1996): ‘‘Suitable crystals . . . were obtained after 1 year, by slow evaporation of a highly concentrated CaCl2/–CD aqueous solution.’’ A novel complex of composition {-CD8(pyridine)3H2O}, crystallized from a CD–pyridine–water gel system is noted here because the -CD molecules are present as monomers (Rango, Charpin, Navaza, Keller, Nicolis, Villain and Coleman, 1992;
100
C Y C L O D E X T R I NS , A ND S OM E AN A L O G S , A S H O S T S
˚ , ¼ 101.87 , P21, KUFHOI). The cell dimensions are a ¼ 14.70, b ¼ 14.74, c ¼ 21.78 A Z ¼ 2. One pyridine is enclosed within the -CD cavity, one is at the primary hydroxyl level and six, together with the water molecules, are in tunnels between the host molecules; thus the composition is better expressed as {-CD[2(C5H5N)]6(C5H5N)3H2O}. The crystals contain 40% pyridine by weight in a low density packing of -CD molecules. This has been described as a ‘‘brickwork’’ structure by Dodds (1999). 4.3.2 4.3.2.1
-Cyclodextrin as host in tunnel inclusion complexes Structural data
The tunnel inclusion complexes of -CD are isostructural and can be divided (with perhaps one known exception) into the five isomorphous groups given in Tables 4.11 to 4.15. This classification is due to Mentzafos, Mavridis, Le Bas and Tsoucaris (1991), who have made other important contributions, discussed below, to the systematization of the crystal chemistry of this family of complexes. Perhaps the most striking feature of the tunnel inclusion complexes is the appearance of head-to-head -CD dimers, with direct hydrogen bonding between the O(2,3) ends of the truncated cones (Fig. 4.14). These dimers are the structural units in the -CD tunnel inclusion complexes and are linked to one another in stacks by hydrogen bonds via water molecules. The driving force for dimer formation appears to be the creation of a large apolar environment for enclosing hydrophobic guests. The various complexes are then distinguished by different modes of stacking of the dimers. We shall first give the facts – crystal data and packing arrangements for the five isomorphous groups, and then show how Mentzafos et al. (1991) have accounted for these arrangements in terms of different packings of essentially similar layers. In the first group of tunnel (CH) structures (Table 4.11) adjacent dimers in a stack are slightly laterally displaced but their axes remain parallell. The reduced triclinic unit cells in Table 4.12 fall into two groups when the standard ˚ , 113, 99, 103 ordering a < b < c is used. The first group has 15.2, 15.5, 18 A ˚ , 99, 113, 103 . This presumably and the second group has 15.2, 15.5, 18 A implies that the structural roles of a and b are interchanged between the two groups. The ternary complexes of pyrene with octanol and cyclohexanol (Table 4.14) have particularly interesting structures, illustrated for the octanol complex in Fig. 4.15 (p. 110). The pyrene molecules are enclosed not within the internal tunnels of the -CD molecules but within the hydrogen bonded portion of the dimer, and without appreciably perturbing the structure of the dimer. A tentative generalization was made that, in analogous complexes, other aromatic molecules could occupy the same site as pyrene and that the third component need not be an alcohol. The second group (IM; Table 4.12) has been listed separately because these structures are of the slipped-tunnel (brickwork) type), the two barbital complexes differing in having one-dimer and two-dimer lengths of chain respectively. In the screw tunnel (SC) structures (Table 4.13; Fig. 4.16) the integrity of the dimers is maintained but these are now both mutually displaced and tilted. Further evidence for the importance of the dimers is given by the ternary {-CD[acetylsalicylic acid0.5(salicylic acid)]11.7H2O} complex where the three guest molecules are enclosed within a -CD dimer (DIFHOP, Table 4.12, Group II, Nishioka, Nakanishi, Fujiwara and Tomita, 1984).
-CYCLODEXTRIN AS HOST
101
Fig. 4.14.(a) Stereoview of the stacking of -CD head-to-head dimers in the tunnel inclusion structure of -CD[2,5-diiodobenzoic acid]7H2O; the disordered guest molecule and the water molecules are not shown. This is an example of the second group of isomorphous -CD tunnel inclusion complexes with a tunnel (CH) structure, listed in Table 4.14. The space group for this group is C2, with four formula units in the unit cell. (Reproduced from Hamilton, Sabesan and Steinrauf, 1981.)
Fig. 4.14.(b) Two stereoviews of a space-filling model of the -CD dimer with enclosed guest molecules in the {-CD[1-adamantanecarboxylic acid]16H2O} structure. The upper view is looking down from the tail of the molecule (i.e. the primary hydroxyl end) and the lower view is normal to the sevenfold axis of -CD; water molecules are not shown. The two -CD moieties and the two 1-adamantanecarboxylic acid moieties (almost entirely enclosed in the -CD cavity, with one carboxyl group protruding more than the other) are both crystallographically independent. The interlocking of secondary hydroxyl oxygen atoms which link the -CDs to form hydrogen bonded head-to-head dimers is clearly shown in the lower diagram. This example comes from the group of isomorphous -CD tunnel inclusion complexes with an intermediate (IM) structure listed in Table 4.12. The space group is P1, Z ¼ 2. These are also called slipped tunnel or brickwork structures. (Reproduced from Hamilton and Sabesan, 1982b.)
102
C Y C L O D E X T R I NS , A ND S OM E AN A L O G S , A S H O S T S
Table 4.11. Crystal data for some -CD tunnel inclusion complexes with a tunnel (CH) structure; compositions as in Table 4.5. The space group is P1, Z ¼ 2. The reduced cells are given, with standard orientation (a < b < c); these show that the Group I and Group II structures are isostructural Guest
Refcode/ reference
Group I. [C8H8N2O3]7H2O; ( p-nitro-acetanilide)* [C8H8NOBr]13.5H2O; p-bromoacetanilide (benzoic acid)0.35(ethanol)10.3 H2O Group II. [(n-C3H7OH)]9H2O; n-propanol (metastable phase, at 120K; polymorph II). 1,7-dioxaspiro-5,5-undecane# 0.7(Z-tetradecane-7-en-1-al)11.6 H2Ox
a/
b/
c/
CHANAO; HMP78; XADHIT; CD99 AC03a
15.13 88.65 15.20 87.16 15.210 89.13
15.54 81.84 15.61 81.71 15.678 74.64
15.69 76.86 15.74 76.61 15.687 76.40
BCYDPR; JS79 FERCOU; TLRV87 YRM02 XUBXUN
15.316 104.23 15.60 101.4 15.475 101.856
15.461 103.98 15.72 101.7 15.466 101.909
15.575 100.92 15.93 103.2 15.720 103.769
V/FU
1778 1798 1751
1673 1800 1722
Notes: * Pseudo-monoclinic C2 symmetry; # 1,7-dioxaspiro-5, 5-undecane is the pheromone of the olive fly. x (Z-tetradecane-7-en-1-al) is the sex pheromone of the olive pest Prays olea; one molecule is within the dimer and the other between the dimers. References: AC03a – Aree and Chaichit, 2003; CD99 – Caira and Dodds, 1999; HMP78 – Harding, Mclennan and Paton, 1978; JS79 – Jogun and Stezowski, 1979; TLRV87 – Tsoucaris, Le Bas, Rysanek and Villain, 1987; YRM02 – Yannakopoulou et al., 2002.
Tunnels are no longer evident in the chessboard group (CB; Table 4.14). In flurbiprofen A is:
CH3 A
C
In fenoprofen A is :
H
COOH S-(+) enantiomer
F O
Scheme 4.3
Some indication of the influence of guest on overall structure can be obtained from the -CD complexes with flurbiprofen (2-(2-fluoro-4-biphenylyl)propionic acid) and fenoprofen (2-(3-phenoxyphenyl)propionic acid), where structures have been reported with most of the possible combinations of racemic and enantiomeric guests.
Table 4.12. Crystal data for the second isomorphous group of -CD tunnel inclusion complexes with an intermediate (IM) structure (also called slipped tunnel or brickwork structures); compositions as in Table 4.10. The space group is P1, Z ¼ 2The reduced cells are given, with standard orientation (a < b < c); these show that the Group I structures are isomorphous, as are the Group II structures, but Groups I and II are not isomorphous Guest; water content Group I [C11H16O2]15H2O; 1-adamantanecarboxylic acid at 108K. (Note (a)) [C7H8O].xH2O m-cresol (120K); [()-[C15H13O2F]10H2O; ()-(2-(2-fluoro-4-biphenylyl)-propionic acid; flurbiprofen) [(S)-( þ )-[C15H13O2F]10.5H2O; (S)-( þ )-(2-(2-fluoro-4-biphenylyl)propionic acid) [1.5(p-HOC6H4I)]12H2O; p-iodophenol; 153K
Refcode; reference
a/
b/
c/
V/FU
BOGCAB; HS82
15.255 113.54 15.327 113.07 15.420 113.63
15.491 98.87 15.366 99.68 15.490 99.36
17.747 102.54 17.887 102.64 18.633 103.05
1807
15.446 113.52 15.352 113.10 15.440 113.02 15.389 113.43 15.31 112.66 15.40 112.86 15.446 112.99 15.45 113.1
15.513 99.32 15.363 99.40 15.530 98.99 15.519 99.07 15.50 99.47 15.519 99.07 15.452 99.35 15.47 99.4
18.107 102.89 17.985 102.80 18.060 103.44 17.896 103.01 18.30 103.32 17.896 103.01 18.056 103.16 18.08 103.1
1861
15.45 113.6
15.55 99.4
18.09 103.5
1854
BCDMPH; JMS79 CEDMUT; UHI83
CIGXOF; UIH84 BCDPIH10; SJEB78
N-acetyl-L-phenylalanine]12H2O
AGAZIR; ACBS02
[C12H15NO3]13H2O (110K); N-acetylphenylalanine methyl ester N-acety-p-methoxy-L-phenylalanine11.5 H2O
DOCVUM03; S85 CBS01
N-acetyl-L-phenylalanine amide 13H2O
CS01
0.8(nonanoic acid)12 H2O
TEJHAR; RM96b
[0.5(C20H32O4)]10.3H2O; Iloprost is a 1:1 mixture of 16R and S diastereoisomers 4-biphenylacetic acid.xH2O
SHSH89
HHA92
1814 1843
1827 1863 1836 1879 1836 1854 1860
Table 4.12. (Continued ) Guest; water content
Refcode; reference
Group II 0.5[C11H10O2]9H2O; (ethyl cinnamate
BIDMOQ; HST-PU85
[1.5(n-C3H7OH]12H2O; n-propanol at 153K (note (b)) [(C9H8O4)0.5(C7H6O3)]11.7H2O; (acetylsalicylic acid0.5 (salicylic acid)) (3,4-xylidine complex stated to be isomorphous); note (c). 0.5{[C13H24O2]2(C2H6O]24.5 [H2O]}; 1,13-tridecanedioic acid; 173K 0.5{[C14H26O4]0.2(C2H6O]10.93 [H2O]}; 1,14-tetradecanedioic acid 0.5{[C12H22O4]1.16(C2H6O]13.7 [H2O]}; 1,12-dodecanoic acid; 100K. 0.5{[C12H22O4]0.5 (C2H6O]11.1[H2O]}; 1,12-dodecanedioic acid [1.5(R,S)()-(C8H10OS)]17H2O; (R, S)()-methyl-p-tolylsulphoxide [(C8H12N2O3)15.5H2O; (5,5-diethylbarbituric acid (barbital)), Form I N-acetyl-L-phenylalanine]12H2O
CDEXPR, BCDNPR10; JS79, SJEB78 DIFHOP; NNFT84
LONGIE; MTM99; CACPOM; MM01 WISREV; MM00; WISRIZ; MM00 GESVUV; FTMV88; DEVVAB; NAFT84; AGAZOX; ACBS02
N-acetyl-R-phenylalanine]12H2O
AGAZUD; ACBS02
Tert-butyl benzoic acid
HEGXUM; RMHD94
a/
b/
c/
V/FU
15.392 99.74 15.299 99.40 15.247 99.99
15.486 113.61 15.424 113.50 15.475 112.71
18.186 102.78 17.980 103.00 18.310 102.63
1854
15.280 99.79 15.436 99.78 15.251 99.90 15.409 99.71 15.432 99.25 15.497 99.70 15.390 99.27 15.410 98.74 15.417 99.69
15.510 113.13 15.492 113.01 15.456 113.13 15.488 113.12 15.476 113.29 15.549 112.30 15.390 113.39 15.470 113.72 15.476 113.08
18.207 103.02 18.242 102.75 18.153 102.81 18.220 102.90 17.984 102.96 18.123 103.63 17.890 102.75 18.150 103.53 18.244 102.94
1818 1865
1851 1877 1837 1868 1846 1881 1823 1851 1870
7-hydroxy-4-methylcoumarinxH2O
BAS00
7-hydroxyoumarinxH2O
BAS00
2( p-hydroxybenzaldehyde)4.72 H2O; note (d)
BAI02
[(C8H12N2O3)12.5H2O; (5,5-diethylbarbituric acid (barbital)), Form II (4 formula units per cell); note (d)
DEVVEF; NAFT84
15.37 99.47 15.46 99.22 15.262 92.67 15.529 99.89
18.01 113.21 15.55 113.21 15.728 96.97 15.568 93.47
18.01 103.35 18.16 103.23 16.350 103.31 32.327 103.82
1858
Notes: (a) Two other cells have been given for this complex but their relation to the structure solved is not clear (see QQQAEY). (b) 15.229 is also given. (c) In the (acetylsalicylic acid)2(salicylic acid)) complex, the salicylic acid molecule is in the centre of the -CD dimer. (d) The last two complexes have structure combining features of the tunnel and slipped-tunnel arrangements, and are placed here for convenience. They are not isomorphous with the other entries. References: ACBS02 – Alexander et al., 2002; BAI02 – Braga, Aree, Imamura et al., 2002; BAS00 – Brett, Alexander and Stezowski, 2000; CBS01 – Clark, Booth and Stezowski, 2001; CS01 – Clark and Stezowski, 2001; FTMV88 – Fujiwara, Tomita, Marseigne and Vicens, 1988; Vicens, Fujiwara and Tomita, 1988; HHA92 – Harata, unpublished, noted in Harata, Hirayama, Arima, Uekama and Miyayi, 1992; HS82 – Hamilton and Sabesan, 1982; HST-PU82 – Hursthouse, Smith, Thornton-Petit and Utley, 1982; JMS79 – Jogun, McLennan and Stezowski, 1979; MM00 – Makedonopoulou and Mavridis, 2000; MM01 – Makedonopoulou and Mavridis, 2001; MTM99 – Makedonopoulou, Tulinsky and Mavridis, 1999; NAFT84 – Nakanishi, Arai, Fujiwara and Tomita, 1984; NNFT84 – Nishioka, Nakanishi, Fujiwara and Tomita, 1984; RMHD94 – Rontoyianni, Mavridis, Hadjoudis and Duisenberg, 1994; RM96b – Rontoyianni and Mavridis, 1996; S79 – Stezowski, 1985; SHSH89 – Steiner, Hingrichs, Saenger and Hoyer, 1989; SJEB78 – Stezowski, Jogun, Eckles and Bartels, 1978; UHI83 – Uekama, Hirayama, Imai, Otogiri and Harata, 1983; UIH84 – Uekama, Imai, Hirayama, Otogiri and Harata, 1984.
106
C Y C L O D E X T R I NS , A ND S OM E AN A L O G S , A S H O S T S
Table 4.13. Crystal data for the isomorphous group of -CD tunnel inclusion complexes with a screw tunnel (SC) structure; compositions as in Table 4.5. The space group for this group is P21, with four formula units in the unit cell Guest; water content;
Refcode; reference
a
b/
c
V/FU
[C8H11N]16H2O (p -ethyl-aniline);
CDETAN; TFT81 TFT81
15.30
15.58
1881
15.53
1883
NIZGUY; CGNO96 DUTLIN10; HC88b GETPEA; HC88a GETPAW; HC88a CIVBUE; NFT84 KIFPAQ; S-R99 SAJPIC; HHUT88
15.342
32.31 102.4 32.49 102.6 32.54 102.44 32.23 101.2 32.12 100.8 32.76 101.5 33.189 104.85 32.545 103.56 35.31 102.7
15.324
1868
15.32
1850
15.28
1845
15.35
1880
15.562
1900
15.437
1884
15.50
2069
15.255
1821
15.621
1868
15.47
1902
15.609
1890
[C6H6NI]16H2O (p-iodo-aniline); (L-menthol)14.5H2O [R,S-()-C15H14O3]15H2O; (R,S-()-fenoprofen); at 123K [S-( þ )-C15H14O3]12H2O; (S-( þ )-fenoprofen); at 138K [R-( )-C15H14O3]13H2O; (R-( )-fenoprofen) [phenobarbital]13.5 H2O Adamantone [C11H15O3N3F]9.7H2O; (1-hexylcarbamoyl-5-fluorouracil) (carmofur) C12H10N2O212.7H2O; p-amino-p 0 -nitrophenyl 4,4 0 -diaminobiphenyl9.7H2O [S-( )-(C8H10OS)]17H2O; (S-( )-methyl-p-tolyl-sulphoxide) (Z ¼ 8) [1.5(cyclizine)]12.5H2O; (Z ¼ 8).
QACXEX; BLCS99; GYM03 GESWAC10; VFT88 CDN01
15.29
15.28 15.31 15.26 15.229 15.428 15.51
15.454 15.394 15.495 15.246
31.693 102.92 31.995 103.74 65.04 102.6 65.075 102.6
Note: fenoprofen is (3-phenoxyphenyl)propionic acid. References: BLCS99 – Brett, Liu, Coppens and Stezowski, 1999; CDN01 – Caira, Dodds and Nassimbeni, 2001; CGNO96 – Caira, Griffith, Nassimbeni and Oudtshoorn, 1996; GYM03 – Giastas et al., 2003; HC88a – Hamilton and Chen, 1988a; HC88b – Hamilton and Chen, 1988b; HHUT88 – Harata, Hirayama, Uekama and Tsoucaris, 1988; NFT84 – Nakanishi, Fujiwara and Tomita, 1984; S-R99 – Sanchez-Ruiz et al., 1999; the chemical composition was not given; TFT81 – Tokuoka, Fujiwara and Tomita, 1981; VFT88 – Vicens, Fujiwara and Tomita, 1988.
{-CD[()-flurbiprofen]10H2O} (Uekama, Hirayama, Imai, Otogiri and Harata, 1983) and {-CD[(S)-( þ )-flurbiprofen]10.5H2O} (Uekama, Imai, Hirayama, Otogiri and Harata, 1984) have very similar structures (Table 4.12); in the first of these the R-( ) enantiomer is found in one half of the -CD dimer and the S-( þ ) enantiomer in the other half, with a head-to-head arrangement of the guests in which the carboxyls are hydrogen bonded to a primary hydroxyl of the -CD and to a water molecule. A very similar
Table 4.14. Crystal data for the isomorphous group of -CD tunnel inclusion complexes with a tunnel (CH) structure; compositions as in Table 4.10. The space group for this group is C2, with four formula units in the unit cell Guest and water content
Refcode; reference
a
b/
c
V/FU
0.5(KI79H2O) (actually P21 but pseudo C2)
COCMIQ; BHN83
19.61
15.80
1790
NaI38H2O (details not given)
CYDXTF; NS80
19.58
15.75
1778
0.5{[Fe(cp)(mesitylene)]þPF66H2O}
KOGLIB; KR91
19.241
15.768
1745
0.5{[Fe(cp)(biphenyl)]þP F68H2O}; (actually P21 but pseudo C2) [ethyl p-aminobenzoate]7.5H2O
KOGLOH; KR91
19.206
15.674
1733
BIHJEH; HS82
18.75
15.66
1690
[C8H8O2]11H2O (m-toluic acid)
QQQAFA; HSV68
18.86
15.76
1728
[C7H5O2I]11H2O (m-iodobenzoic acid)
QQQAFG; HSV68
18.88
15.69
1724
[(C7H3I2O2]9H2O (2,5-diiodobenzoic acid)
QQQAFJ; HSS81, HSV68
19.19
15.74
1761
[C8H9NO2]13H2O (acetaminophen)¤
CD00
19.207
15.700
1740
[0.5(cimetidine)]11H2O
D99
19.22
15.75
1757
[C10H13BrO]9H2O (2-bromo-5-t-butylphenol)
QQQAFS; HSS81, HSV68
19.24
16.02
1798
[C10H13BrO]9H2O (2-bromo-4-t-butylphenol);
HSV68, HSS81
19.19
15.97
1779
[C7H5O2Br]13H2O (m-bromobenzoic acid)
QQQAFP; HSV68
19.23
15.80
1760
[3,3-dimethylbutylamine]11H2O
VIJXAN; MHT91
19.19
15.89
1773
[0.94(3,5-dimethylbenzoic acid)]9.1H2O
YOVVIO; RM94
19.37
16.00
1811
[4-t-butyltoluene]8.5H2O
KUTJUE; MH92
19.24
24.51 109.5 24.44 109.3 24.415 109.55 24.334 108.88 24.53 110.2 24.67 109.5 24.77 110.0 24.76 109.6 24.48 109.52 24.57 109.1 24.66 108.9 24.58 109.17 24.58 109.5 24.56 108.8 24.71 108.9 24.47 109.9
15.84
1753
Table 4.14. (Continued ) Guest and water content
Refcode; reference
a
b/
c
V/FU
[0.5(cyclopentadienyl mesitylene iron PF6)] H2O
KOGLIB; KR91
19.24
15.77
1745
[0.5(cyclopentadienyl biphenyl iron PF6)] H2O
KOGLOH; KR91
19.21
15.67
1732
[benzophenone] (water content not given)
DEVTED; LBdE84
19.24
15.94
1775
[biphenyl] (water content not given)
DEVTIH; LBdE84
19.34
15.80
1760
spiroacetal
TEMCIX; RLVT96
19.368
15.940
1787
[0.75(octanol)0.5(pyrene)].7.25H2O;
PUKPIU; UR98
19.326
15.922
1778
[1.5(cyclohexanol)0.5(pyrene)].5.25H2O;
PUKPOA; UR98
19.254
15.914
1767
[0.5 ((Z)-9-dodecen-1-ol)]9.6H2O0.5C2H5OH
ZUZXOH; MMH96
19.238
15.790
1752
0.5[C13H26O2].9.8H2O Tridecanoic acid
SOBHUM, 01, 02; MPAM00
19.363
15.937
1799
0.5[C14H26O2].97.5H2O (Z)-Tetradec-7-enoic acid
SOBJEY, 01, 02; MPAM00
19.316
15.936
1788
0.5(-naphthyloxyacetic acid)
ODEJOW; KYMM01
19.341
15.975
1801
Poly(tris(ethylene glycol))8H2O
BEZLAT; REFER; 173K
18.726
15.398
1653
C42H70O351.625(C3H6O)13H2O Poly(trimethylene oxide)13H2O C42H70O351.625(C3H6O)13H2O Poly(propylene glycol)13H2O 0.3(ethanol)12 H2O
KMK00 110K
19.369
15.983
1796
KMK00 110K
19.332
15.961
1880
AC03b
19.292
15.884
1785
1.5(C9H6O2)12 H2O; coumarin
GOSQOU; BAC99
19.322
24.42 109.6 24.33 108.9 24.56 109.5 24.49 109.8 24.450 108.72 24.441 109.00 24.467 109.47 24.477 109.52 24.597 108.55 24.564 108.98 24.632 108.77 24.475 110.48 24.540 108.92 24.572 109.00 24.691 109.35 24.641 106.76
16.050
1829
6-methylcoumarin
BAS00
19.210
7-methylcoumarin
BAS00
19.348
7-methoxycoumarin
BAS00
20.058
Butyrophenone11.5H2O
DGPOO; BS00
19.352
Valerophenone11H2O
DOGPUU; BS00
19.339
Clofibric acid Trans-cinnamic acid
CBM01 (not seen) XERTET; KMM00
19.422
4,7-dimethylcoumarin. 17H2O#
MASBAJ; BAS00
19.513
1,2-bis(4-aminophenyl)ethane12.35H2O
GYM03
19.319
[C10H11NO3]14.2H2O (diacetamate) (Z ¼ 8)
D99
19.275
[C8H15N7O2S3]10.5H2O (famotidine) (Z ¼ 8)
D99
37.72
¤ #
24.600 109.46 24.582 109.84 24.441 109.84 24.599 109.38 25.581 109.08 24.461 108.65 24.024 104.49 24.19 103.92 24.187 109.12 15.50 102.2
15.726
1752
15.784
1765
15.662
1806
15.916
1787
16.010
1871
15.941
1794
18.414
1862
33.315
1889
34.289
1888
26.91
1922*
The ibuprofen complex is isomorphous (Brown, 1997). Structure not yet determined. cf. MASBIR, MASBOX for other substituted coumarins.
References: BAC99 – Brett, Alexander, Ckark, Ross, Harbison and Stezowski, 1999; BAS00 – Brett, Alexander and Stezowski, 2000; BHN83 – Betzel, Hingerty, Noltemeyer, Weber, Saenger and Hamilton, 1983; BS00 – Brett and Stezowski, 2000; CBM01 – Caira, Bourne and Mvula, 2001 (not seen); CD00 – Caira and Dodds, 2000; D99 – Dodds, 1999; GYM03 – Giastas, Yannakopoulou and Mavridis, 2003; HS82 – Hamilton and Sabesan, 1982; HSS81 – Hamilton, Sabesan and Steinrauf, 1981; HSV68 – Hamilton, Steinrauf and Van Etten, 1968; KR91 – Klingert and Rihs, 1991b; KMM00 – Kokkinou et al., 2000; KYMM01 – Kokkinou, Yannakopoulou, Mavridis and Mentzafo, 2001 LdR84 – Le Bas, de Rango, Ryanek and Tsoucaris, 1984; MPAM00 – Reported as triclinic by Makedenopoulou et al (2000) and corrected to monoclinic by Marsh et al. (2002); MHT91 – Mavridis, Hadjoudis and Tsoucaris, 1991; MMH96 – Mentzafos, Mavridis and Hursthouse, 1996; NS80 – Noltemeyer and Saenger, 1980; RLVT96 – Rysanek et al., 1996; RM94 – originally given as triclinic by Rontoyianni and Mavridis (1994) and corrected to monoclinic by Herbstein and Marsh (1998); UR98 – Udachin and Ripmeester, 1998; UWR00 – Udachin, Wilson and Ripmeester, 2000.
110
C Y C L O D E X T R I NS , A ND S OM E AN A L O G S , A S H O S T S
Octanol
Pyrene
Octanol
Fig. 4.15. The tunnel (CH) structure of {-CD[0.75octanol0.5pyrene]7.25H2O} viewed approximately along [010]. The hydrogen-bonded -CD head-to-head dimers are clearly visible, the pyrene is in a hydrophobic site between the molecules of the dimer, and the octanol molecule, whose OH and methyl ends could not be distinguished, extends between dimers. Note that here, and in Fig. 4.16, the tunnel axis runs horizontally and not, as is more usual in such diagrams, vertically. (Reproduced from Udachin and Ripmeester, 1998.)
w
c sin b
A– b
B A⬘
Fig. 4.16. A schematic representation of the molecular packing of the head-to-head dimers in {-CD[ p-ethylaniline]16H2O} (CDETAN) seen along [100]. A and B represent the crystallographically independent -CD molecules and the solid circles the water molecules. The guest molecules, enclosed within the macrocyclic rings, are not shown explicitly. This is an example of the screw tunnel (SC) structures listed in Table 4.13. (Reproduced from Tokuoka, Fujiwara and Tomita, 1981.)
arrangement is found when the guest is the S-( þ ) enantiomer. The -CD complexes with (R,S)- (Hamilton and Chen, 1988b), R-( )-(Hamilton and Chen, 1988a) or S-( þ )fenoprofen (Hamilton and Chen, 1988a) present a somewhat different picture; although isomorphous (Table 4.13) there are differences in cell dimensions and water content. This is in accord with the fact that these complexes are diastereoisomers. In the R-( ) complex the guests are in a head-to-head arrangement while in the S-( þ ) complex there is a head-to-tail arrangement. The complex with (R,S) guests actually has a S : R ratio of 3 : 1, showing that there has been a pair of S guests in head-to-tail arrangement, or a pair of
-CYCLODEXTRIN AS HOST
111
Table 4.15. Crystal data for the isomorphous group of -CD tunnel inclusion complexes with a chessboard (CB) structure; compositions as in Table 4.10. The space group for this group is C2221, with eight formula units in the unit cell Guest and water content
Refcode/reference
a
b
c
V/FU
[benzil] (water content not specified [phenylethylmalonic acid] (water content not specified) [1-hydroxymethyl-adamantane] 11H2O trans-{Pt(PMe3)Cl2(NH3)] 5.5H2O [C11H16O]10H2O (4-tert-butylbenzyl alcohol) 2-aza-5-hydroxy-adamantane 10.5 H2O [2-methyl-2,4-pentanediol] 11.5H2O [C10H14O]13H2O (m-t-butylphenol), Z ¼ 16; probably a superstructural version. [C8H8O2Hg]12H2O phenylmercuric acetate, space group P22121, Z ¼ 4
DEVTON; MM91
19.58
24.00
32.84
1929
DEVTUT; LBdR84
19.09
24.27
32.58
1887
FASXUS; H85
19.16
24.27
32.58
1894
GIPFEQ; ASS88
19.43
24.08
32.50
1901
KOFJEU; MM91
19.196 24.393 32.808 1920
MECQUK; BGKB00 19.144 23.950 32.670 1872 TECYIJ; ZTK96
19.69
24.13
36.61
2174
QQQAFM; HSV68
19.15
24.33
62.78
1828
QQQAFD; HSV68
17.66
11.45
32.74
1655
References: ASS88 – Alston, Slawin, Stoddart, Williams and Zarycki, 1988; BGKB00 – Bobek et al., 2000; H85 – Hamilton, 1985; HSV68 – Hamilton, Steinrauf and Van Etten, 1968; placed here because of possible relationships with cell dimensions of other complexes in this table. LBdR84 – Le Bas, de Rango, Ryanek and Tsoucaris, 1984; MM91 – Mentzafos, Mavridis, Le Bas and Tsoucaris, 1991; ZTK96 – Zhukhlistova, Tischenko, Kuranova, Vainshtein, Mattson and Korpella, 1996;
R guests in head-to-head arrangement. Thus structural features of the diastereoisomers are copied to the pseudo-racemate. 4.3.2.2 An overall structural description Mentzafos et al. (1991) have shown that it is possible to transform the unit cells of the various groups of isomorphous complexes to a partially common measure. Thus the unit cells of the intermediate group (IM, Table 4.12) transform to a (non-standard) cell ˚ , ¼ 98.7, ¼ 116.3, ¼ 89.8 . The screw tunnel (SC; with a ¼ 19.2, b ¼ 24.2, c ¼ 18.1 A Table 4.13) structures can also be transformed to cells with dimensions approximately ˚ , ¼ 90.6 , space group P21 (here the unique monoclinic a ¼ 19.3, b ¼ 23.9, c ¼ 32.5 A axis is [001]). Similar results can be obtained for the first (triclinic) group of tunnel structures (Table 4.11), and it will immediately be noticed that the orthogonal a and b axes in the C2 (CH; Table 4.14) and C2221 (CB; Table 4.15) groups have similar values. Thus ˚ 2; the invariant packing unit in all these structures is a C-centred layer with an area of 460 A there is a pseudo-close-packed (or hexagonal) arrangement of -CD dimers, with each dimer ˚ and four others at 15.4 A ˚ ( ¼ 0.5 [(192 þ 242)1/2]). surrounded by two others at 19.3 A
112
C Y C L O D E X T R I NS , A ND S OM E AN A L O G S , A S H O S T S
CH mode
SC mode
CB mode IM mode
Fig. 4.17. Schematic view of the packing of -CD dimers. In the upper part of each of the various modes each -CD monomer is represented by a heptagon of O4 atoms. In the lower part the lateral displacement between two consecutive -CD dimers is shown with each heptagon representing a -CD dimer. (Reproduced from Giastas et al. (2003)).
The four packing modes shown in Fig. 4.17 have been clearly described by Giastas et al., (2003; p. 296): ‘‘ . . . All have the common feature that they consist of close-packed layers of -CD dimers and are generated by the two-dimensional invariable layers’ different relative positioning. In the CH mode the dimer’s sevenfold axis forms an angle of approximately 10 with the stacking axis. The two-dimensional layers stack in parallel so that the dimers align almost on top of each other to form channels, slightly deformed in the interface between dimers (interdimer interface). The channels are hydrophobic and the guests inside them are shielded from the water environment. The lateral displacement ˚ . On the contrary, in CB of two consecutive -CD dimers along the channel is 2.7 A ˚ , every dimer mode the lateral distance between two dimers of successive layers is 8.9 A being surrounded by solvent molecules. The primary faces and therefore the guest are exposed to the polar environment of water molecules and neighbouring hydroxy groups. The dimer’s sevenfold axis forms an angle of approximately 10 with the stacking axis, but the two-dimensional layers are related by a twofold screw axis and
-CYCLODEXTRIN AS HOST
113
they are not parallel (dihedral angle of 20 ). In the IM mode, a case between the CH and CB modes, adjacent layers are parallel but the dimer’s sevenfold axis forms an angle of approximately 20 with the stacking axis. Consequently, dimers are far from ˚ (the inner diameter of the primary exactly aligned, their lateral displacement being 6 A face of -CD). Thus, a breaking of the channel is observed that leaves parts of the guests free to interact with hydroxy groups of adjacent hosts, as well as with water molecules. Finally, in the SC mode, although the lateral displacement between two ˚ as in the CH mode, the dimer’s consecutive -CD dimers along a channel is only 2.7 A sevenfold axis forms an approximate angle of 10 with the stacking axis but the two-dimensional layers are related by a twofold screw axis and they are not parallel, therefore the guests interact with water molecules and hydroxy groups of adjacent host channels. The guest(s) emerging from the two primary faces of the dimer, is (are) situated between the previously mentioned practically invariant layers and therefore plays a crucial role in the packing. . . . ’’ The important role of the guests in determining the arrangement of the layers was illustrated (Makedonopoulou and Mavridis, 2000) by comparing the structures of -CD dimer complexes containing long aliphatic monocarboxylic and ,!-dicarboxylic acids with host : guest ratio 2 : 1; one dimer is threaded by one molecule of a long guest. Aliphatic monoacids with 12–16 C atoms induce tunnel packing (CH; Table 4.14) while aliphatic diacids with 10–16 C atoms have an intermediate packing mode (IM; Table 4.12). Their suggestion is that ‘‘ in the case of the aliphatic monoacids the hydrophobic end of the amphiphilic guests influences the packing towards the channel [CH] mode in order to protect that part of the guest from the polar aqueous environment that surrounds the dimers. The carboxyl groups, found entrapped in the hydrophobic channel, self-associate forming carboxylic dimers and thus stabilizing the whole system. In contrast, in the case of the diacids the two polar ends of the guest are free to interact with the solvent environment.’’ The number of water molecules per -CD ranges from 7.5 (biphenyl) to 13.4 (1-adamantanecarboxylic acid), spread over 12–16 sites. Although the water molecules have high displacement factors, indicating disorder and appreciable thermal motion, Tsoucaris and coworkers (Mentzafos et al., 1991) deduced that there does exist a quasiinvariant water network organized in layers. There are two separate subnetworks, in one there is hydrogen bonding of water to primary hydroxyls and in the other to secondary hydroxyls. These networks make an important contribution to the overall cohesion of the crystal because there are few direct hydrogen bonds between dimers. Between one and three waters are linked only to other waters (the so-called secondary hydration sphere). There is evidence from the displacement factors that the waters are more tightly linked than the guest molecules. The disposition of the guest molecules depends on their nature – on their size and where the hydrophobic and hydrophilic groups are located and how these interact with the -CD hosts and water molecules. The overall resemblances between the different structures in this family have been demonstrated; the differences, small and not-so-small, derive from the detailed nature of the host–guest interactions, and those involving water molecules. In contrast to the -CD complexes, where only about two-thirds of the structures fall into isostructural or isomophous groups, most of the -CD complexes fit into one of the categories given in the above Tables.
114
4.3.3
C Y C L O D E X T R I NS , A ND S OM E AN A L O G S , A S H O S T S
Exceptional -cyclodextrin structures
There are, at the time of writing, three other -CD structures that do not fit into the classification scheme described above. The first is {-CD[C14H10Cl2NO2]Naþ 11H2O}, where [C14H10Cl2NO2]Na þ is the sodium salt of the anti-inflammatory agent diclofenac, 2-[(2,6-dichlorophenyl)amino]benzeneacetic acid (Caira, Griffith, Nassimbeni and van Oudtshoorn, 1994a (HEHJEJ); Caira, Griffith and Nassimbeni, 1998; ˚ (this is MANNOE). The space group is P61, with Z ¼ 6, a ¼ 15.956(8) and c ¼ 50.95(1) A the first -CD complex found with a hexagonal space group although there are a number of -CD complexes with hexagonal space groups (Table 4.3)). The units of the complex are arranged in a regular head-to-tail fashion about the 61 axis, which is approximately normal to the mean plane of the -CD ring. The guest molecules are inserted between the hosts; Caira et al. describe this as the formation of ‘‘an endless helical host channel with a ˚ .’’ Formation of -CD dimers is presumably inhibited because the 2,6pitch of 51 A dichlorophenyl groups are too bulky to enter the tori of the -CD molecules. The second is {-CD[C14H10Cl2NO2]Naþ16H2O}, where [C14H10Cl2NO2]Naþ .is the sodium salt of the anti-inflammatory agent meclofenamate, 2-[(3-methyl-2,6dichlorophenyl)amino]benzoic acid; the crystals are orthorhombic, space group P212121, ˚ (Caira, Griffith and Nassimbeni, with Z ¼ 4, a ¼ 15.087(2), b ¼ 17.967(2), c ¼ 20.634(4) A 1998; MANNOE). The crystal structure has some resemblances to those of the complexes of per-trimethyl--CD (next paragraph). The third is {-CD[0.5(C13H22N4O3S)] 12.5H2O}, where the guest is ranitidine; the crystals are orthorhombic, space group P212121, with Z ¼ 4, ˚ (Dodds, 1999). The structure is not known. a ¼ 15.10, b ¼ 15.37, c ¼ 37.03 A
4.3.4
Chemically modified -cyclodextrins as hosts in inclusion complexes
-Cyclodextrins chemically modified by methylation have advantages as pharmaceutical carrier molecules over the parent compound because of higher aqueous solubility and greater protection against hydrolysis both in solution and the solid state. The chemically modified -cyclodextrins whose inclusion complexes have been studied crystallographically are heptakis(2,6-di-O-methyl)--CD (C56H98O35, abbreviated as per-dimethyl--CD) and heptakis(2,3,6-tri-O-methyl)--CD (C63H112O35, abbreviated as per-trimethyl--CD). In per-dimethyl--CD the O(3) hydroxyl groups form O(3)˚ and the H . . . O(2) intramolecular hydrogen bonds with an average length of 2.85(3) A macrocycle has a round and nearly symmetrical structure rather like that of the parent -CD. Five crystal structures have been reported for complexes with per-dimethyl-CD as host; the cell dimensions (Table 4.16) show that there are three different structural arrangements. The conformation of the host molecule in the adamantol complex is reported to be similar to that of -CD in its complexes but the nature of the packing was not described. The isomorphous pair of p-iodophenol and p-nitrophenol complexes have clathrate structures in which, remarkably, the organic guests are located between the host molecules and only the water molecules are included within the tori (Fig. 4.18). The carmofur (1-hexylcarbamoyl-5-fluorouracil) complex has the guest disordered between two sites, with the hexyl group of one guest inserted into the torus from the secondary hydroxyl side, while the other guest is located between host molecules. The only other example of intercalation of a guest between CD hosts is
-CYCLODEXTRIN AS HOST
115
Table 4.16. Crystal data for clathrate inclusion complexes with per-dimethyl--CD as host Guest and water content
Refcode/reference
a
b/
c
V/FU
13.821 13.976 14.163 14.797 14.779 15.463 14.163 24.21 11.080
17.424 20.763 20.828 18.853 18.965 18.922 23.096 19.33 14.932
29.610 28.807 29.261 28.989 28.741 27.852 27.641 18.27 44.906
1783 2090 2158 2022 2014 2037 2260 2138
14.278
15.731
31.149
1749
Group II. Space group P21; Z ¼ 2 [C11H15O3N3F]3H2O; carmofur SAJPOI; HHUET88
15.70
15.95
2014
2H2O
CEQCUW; ASLH99
15.241
23.324
1851
0.5 (acetic acid)1.5 H2O
NITSIS; SN97
15.165
18.53 106.6 10.639 101.80 10.613 102.02
23.188
1825
Group I. Space group P212121 (Z ¼ 4) Anhydride ZULQAY; StSa95a 14.7H2O (at 100K). BOYFOK03; SPHG01. 14.7H2O (at 300K). BOYFOK04; AHSRS00 DEZMOK10; H88 6H5O[IC]2H2O; p-iodophenol DEZMIE10; H88 [ p-nitrophenol]2H2O [C11H8O2]3H2O; 2-naphthoic acid WAGHAN; H93, 99 Prostaglandin PGF2 BOYCAX; SCE81 BEFJOL; CES81 [adamantol]12H2O (at 120K) m-cresol acetate COFLOY; PG84 Clofibric acid CBM01 (not seen) CH3CN2H2O AHSRS00a
References: AHSRS00a – Aree, Hoier, Schultz, Reck and Saenger, 2000a; ASLH99 – Aree, Saenger, Leibnitz and Hoier, 1999; CBM01 – Caira, Bourne and Mvula, 2001 (not seen); CES81 – Czugler, Eckle and Stezowski, 1981; H88 – Harata, 1988; H93 – Harata, 1993; thermal motion of the guest has been analyzed (H99 Harata, 1999); HHUET88 – Harata, Hirayama, Uekama and Tsoucaris, 1988; PG84 – Pohlmann, Gdaniec, Eckle, Geiger and Stezowski, 1984; SCE81 – Stezowski, Czugler and Eckle, 1981; SN77 – Selkti et al., 1997; SPHG01 – Stezowski, Parker, Hilgenkamp and Gdenic, 2001; StSa95a – Steiner and Saenger, 1995a.
o
b
a
Fig. 4.18. A schematic diagram of the crystal structure of the isomorphous complexes of the perdimethylated--CD and p-iodophenol or p-nitrophenol, showing the water molecules included in the tori and the guest molecules located between the hosts. (Reproduced from Harata, 1988.)
{-CD[m-nitrophenol]m-nitrophenol6H2O} (see Table 4.4). No explanation has yet been advanced for these exceptional arrangements. An interesting serendipitous result was obtained when postulated per-dimethyl -CD was complexed with synthetic (hence racemic) 1,7-dioxaspiro-[5.5]undecane, which is the
116
C Y C L O D E X T R I NS , A ND S OM E AN A L O G S , A S H O S T S
Table 4.17. Crystal data for the tunnel inclusion complexes with per-trimethyl--CD as host; space groups P212121 with Z ¼ 4 Guest and water content
Refcode; reference
a
b
c
V/FU
Uncomplexed monohydrate
HEZWAK; CGN94b, SS98 GELKEN10; HHA92 RONWOG; BCNO96 CAMPIP; HUOH83 PAFSOE; HHA92 ZIFQOU; CGN94/5 COYXET20; HUI88 COYXAP10; HUI88 PINMAA; MMS94 QOYLIZ; MYM01 XAQJII; RMIB98, CP01 NIZHAF; CGNO96 MODHUI; CP01 CBM01 (not seen) BEYLOG; HUOH82a
14.823
19.382
26.534
1902
15.67
20.80
25.49
2077
15.232
21.327
27.597
2241
15.00
21.37
28.21
2261
14.890
21.407
28.540
2275
15.18
21.41
27.67
2248
15.271
21.451
27.895
2284
15.092
21.714
28.269
2316
14.796
22.444
27.720
2301
10.936
25.530
29.640
2069
11.149
25.664
29.427
2105
11.060
26.138
29.669
2144
11.190
26.080
29.185
2129
11.440
23.674
13.531
1831
[C6H5IO] m-iodophenol [C13H18O2] (S)-ibuprofen [C6H5OI]4H2O p-iodophenol [C14H12O2]H2O 4-biphenylacetic acid [C14H14O3](S)-naproxen* [C15H13O2F] (S)-( þ )-Flurbiprofen [C15H13O2F]H2O (R)-( )-Flurbiprofen [C14H28O2]2H2O ethyl laurate [S]-1,7-dioxaspiro-[5.5] undecane0.57 H2O methylcyclohexane (L-menthol]2H2O (248K) (R)-5-ethyl-1,3,5-trimethylhydrantoin Clofibric acid p-iodoanilineH2O
* (S)-6-methoxy--methyl-2-naphthaleneacetic acid. References: BCNO96 – Brown, Caira, Nassimbeni and Oudtshoorn, 1996 CBM01 – Caira, Bourne and Mvula, 2001 (not seen); CGN94/5 – Caira, Griffith, Nassimbeni and van Oudtshoorn, 1994/5; CGN94b – Caira, Griffith, Nassimbeni and van Oudtshoorn, 1994b; CP01 – Cardinael et al., 2001; HHA92 – Harata, Hirayama, Arima, Uekama and Miyaji, 1992; HUI88 – Harata, Uekama, Imai, Hirayama and Otagiri, 1988; HUOH82a Harata, Uekama, Otagiri and Hirayama, 1982a; HUOH83 Harata, Uekama, Otagiri and Hirayama, 198a, b; MMS94 – Mentzafos, Mavridis and Schenk, 1994; MYM01 – Makedonopoulou, Yannakopoulou et al., 2001; RMIB98 – Rontoyianni, Mavridis, Israel and Beurskens, 1998; SS98 – Steiner and Saenger, 1998.
major component of the pheromone of the olive fruit fly; the guest is a volatile liquid at room temperature (cf. Table 4.11). Structure analysis of the triclinic crystals (P1, Z ¼ 1; Rysanek, Le Bas, Villain and Tsoucaris, 1992; JOSWOD), which contained also a methanol molecule, showed that the host was in fact 2a,2b,2c,2d,2e,2f,3a,3g,6a,6b,6c,6d,6e,6f,6g-pentadeca-O-methyl--cyclodextrin. Thus
ROTAXANES AND CATENANES OF CYCLODEXTRINS
117
five rings had been 2,6-dimethylated, ring A trimethylated and ring G 3,6-dimethylated; the overall formula of the complex was {C57H100O35[C9H16O2]CH3OH}. The guest was totally enclosed within the macrocycle and resolution had occurred on crystallization, as only the S-enantiomer was found. The uncomplexed per-trimethyl--CD monohydrate and the anhydrous m-iodophenol complex (first two in Table 4.17) have cell dimensions which are related to those of the following six, but nevertheless are significantly different. In the monohydrate, the pertrimethyl--CD macrocycle has six rings in the 4C1 conformation, while G2 is in the unusual 1C4 conformation; in the m-iodophenol complex one trimethylglucose unit adopts the uncommon 0S2 high-energy skew-boat conformation, intermediate between 4C1 and 1 C4. These conformational differences must be taken into account in any assessment of the energetics of complexation. The other fully methylated complexes shown in Table 4.17 are essentially isostructural despite differences in water content, and have a tunnel structure with stacking of head-to-tail host molecules along [010]; however, adjacent molecules in the stack are shifted laterally so that the stack axis is zigzag rather than straight. In all these complexes the host molecule is considerably distorted from the regular, round shape of -CD itself towards an elliptical cross section because intramolecular hydrogen bonds cannot be formed and because of the steric hindrance of the methyl groups; the phenyl ring of the guest is within the cavity, with the phenolic OH protruding and hydrogen bonded to two water molecules. The fully methylated host does not form a complex with racemic flurbiprofen but instead separate complexes are formed with R- and S-flurbiprofen. The flurbiprofen guests in the fully methylated complexes have a head-to-tail arrangement in contrast to the head-to-head arrangement found in their -CD complexes (Section 4.3.2). The enantiospecific separation of the enantiomers of the racemic olive fly pheromone 1,7-dioxaspiro[5.5]undecane [] by complexation of the (R)-enantiomer with hexakis(pertrimethyl)--CD and of the [S]-enantiomer with heptakis(pertrimethyl)--CD has already been noted. The binding constants of the two complexes determined by NMR in aqueous solution are respectively 6600 M-1 for the (R)-enantiomer – hexakis (pertrimethyl)--CD complex and 935 M-1 for the [S]-enantiomer – heptakis (pertrimethyl)--CD complex. These differences can be explained by the details of the interactions between enantiomer and cyclodextrin in the respective pairs.
4.4 Rotaxanes and catenanes of cyclodextrins As noted earlier, these compounds, reviewed by Nepogodiev and Stoddart (1998), straddle the borders of present relevance; we consider only those compounds where crystal structures have been reported. Pseudorotaxanes of composition {2(-CD)[1,12diaminododecane]14 H2O)} (Rontoyianni and Mavridis, 1999; BOLVUT) and {2(CD)[12-diaminododecanoic acid]0.6(ethanol)14.4H2O} (Eliadou et al., 1999; VEHQAA) have the long-chain molecules threaded through the torus of head-to-head -CD dimers; the complexes are not isomorphous. These are true complexes in our present sense. Some other examples are probably out-of-bounds. It has been contended that cyclodextrins require chemical modification by replacement of hydroxyl by bulky substituents
118
C Y C L O D E X T R I NS , A ND S OM E AN A L O G S , A S H O S T S
in order to behave as useful models for enzymes. This has been done for -CD by monosubstitution of an hydroxyl by a bulky hydrophobic group; specifically, among the substituents used have been t-butyl-thio (Hirotsu, Higuchi, Fujita, Ueda, Shinoda, Imoto and Tabushi, 1982), phenylthio (Kamitori, Hirotsu, Higuchi, Fujita, Yamamura, Imoto and Tabushi, 1987) and –CH2NH(CH2)6NH2 (Dimitrius, Terzis, Coleman and de Rango, 1996). Unsymmetrical disubstitution has also been used to give 6A,6D-deoxy-6A-(tbutylthio)--CD (Fujita, Matsunaga, Imoto, Hirotsu, Kamitori and Higuchi, 1987). Crystal structure analysis shows that these are all self complexes, in which the -CD portion of the molecule acts as host and the substituent as guest, the substituent on one host being enclosed within the macrocycle of an adjacent molecule. O
O
O
O
NH O
per-dimethyl-b-CD O O
O
O
O
NH
bislactam
Scheme 4.4
The 2-catenane of heptakis(2,6-di-O-methyl)--CD and a macrocyclic bislactam (Armspach, Ashton, Moore, Spencer, Stoddart, Wear and Williams, 1993; YAPSEN) resembles more the 2-catenane shown in Fig. 3.9 than it does the -CD clathrate and tunnel inclusion complexes described above; thus Fig. 3.9 gives a better impression of the molecular shape than the schematic diagram shown above. Again we have crossed the border.
4.5 4.5.1
-Cyclodextrin as host
-Cyclodextrin as host in clathrate inclusion complexes
The structure of {-cyclodextrin[nH2O]} (-CD is C48H80O40) has been determined in three separate studies and a comparison is illuminating. The reports agree in regard to the overall structure, which is of the cage type and resembles the -CD cage structures; the -CD molecules are stacked along [010]. However, small differences in water content and cell dimensions were reported (Table 4.18), as well as differences in the distribution of water molecules in the unit cell. Another difference is that CYOCAM has one of the glucose residues disordered (even though the measurements were made at 120 K) while the macrocycle is completely ordered in CIWMIE10. Similar minor differences in crystals from different batches have been encountered with -CD complexes (Fujiwara, Yamazaki, Tomizu, Tokuoka, Tomita, Matsuo, Suga and Saenger, 1983; Steiner, 1990) and in
-CYCLODEXTRIN AS HOST
119
Table 4.18. Comparison of crystal data reported in determinations of the crystal structure of hydrated -CD. The complexes crystallize in space group P21 with Z ¼ 2 Water content, and temperature
Refcode; reference
a
b/
c
V/FU
[17 H2O] (at 120K)
CYOCAM; MS80
20.253(8)
16.892(6)
1731
[14 H2O] (at 300K)
CIWMIE10; H87
20.271(2)
16.847(2)
1831
[11 H2O] (at 300K) ND
CIMSAS; HBS84
20.287(10)
10.494(5) 105.32(1) 11.098(2) 104.97(1) 22.079(7) 105.07(4)
16.858(12)
1823
References: HBS84 – Hingerty, Betzel and Saenger, 1984; MS80 – Mclennan and Stezowski, 1980; H87 – Harata, 1987.
{-CD[n-propanol]17H2O} (see below). These differences presumably reflect real differences between the samples used (often in the detailed nature of low-occupancy water sites) and point up the need for caution in discussing the fine details of complicated chemical and crystal structures. 4.5.2 -Cyclodextrin as host in tunnel inclusion complexes In addition to the cage structures (only one example to date) there is a group of almost isomorphous tunnel structures (Table 4.19). The crystal structure of these tetragonal crystals deserves special comment, as has been emphasized by Steiner and Saenger (1998a) who discuss the overall packing and the rarity of space group P4212 especially among organic structures (0.006% of those listed in the Spring 1997 update of the Cambridge Structural Database). The crystal structure of {-CDn-propanol17H2O} (this is the ‘‘formula unit’’) has been described in detail by Ding, Steiner and Saenger (1991), who also compare results obtained for two different crystals of the n-propanol complex (SIBJAO, SIBJES). We describe the family of structures in overall terms, starting with the first four entries in Table 4.19. There are 6 formula units in the unit cell, with three crystallographically-independent -CD molecules stacked one above the other along [001] in Wyckoff positions (c) at 0, 1/2, z etc. (three different values of z). The asymmetric unit consists of three groups of two adjacent (linked) glucose rings, with each -CD molecule being obtained by the operation of the fourfold axis on the appropriate pair of glucose rings. Successive -CD molecules in a stack are hydrogen bonded in a sequence of head-to-head (A–B), tail-to-tail (B–C) and head-to-tail (C–A) interactions (A, B, C refer to succeeding molecules up the [001] axis in Fig. 4.19; this ABC notation is not standardized and we follow Steiner and Saenger (1998) in their Fig. 3, but not in their usage of ‘‘head’’ and ‘‘tail;’’ for our usage see Fig. 4.2 and footnote on p. 79)). The headto-head pair corresponds to the dimer found in some -CD and, particularly, in -CD tunnel inclusion complexes (see, for example, Fig. 4.16). The water and alcohol molecules are contained, in a disordered fashion which varies from crystal to crystal, both within the -CD tori, and in the columnar interstitial spaces between the -CD molecules (Fig. 4.19). Now consider what happens when -CD is crystallized from a solution of 12-crown-4, as
120
C Y C L O D E X T R I NS , A ND S OM E AN A L O G S , A S H O S T S
was first done by Vo¨gtle and Mu¨ller (1979). Crown ether complexes are obtained which are essentially isomorphous with the first group of four (Kamitori, Hirotsu and Higuchi, 1986). The 12-crown-4 (CREt) molecules are enclosed within the heads of the -CD molecules; thus the sequence along [001], shown in the left hand column of Fig. 4.20, has no enclosed CREt when the -CDs are juxtaposed tail-to-tail, single CREt molecules when the contact is tail-to-head, and a pair of CREts when the contact is head-to-head. The crown ether molecules are not disordered because they have intrinsic fourfold symmetry. Successive crown ether molecules in a stack are mutually rotated, with the angles between the pairs A/B, B/C and C/A 9.8, 11.2 and 21.0 (the zero sum is required to maintain translational symmetry). When crystallization is carried out in the presence of the salts LiSCN or KCl (Kamitori, Hirotsu and Higuchi, 1987), the pair of CREts contains the cation as {(CREt)Mþ(CREt)]} and this arrangement is also found with NaCl (Kamitori, Hirotsu and Higuchi, 1988); thus the crown ethers are present as neutral molecules and in (12-crown-4)2Mþ complexes. Rb does not form an analogous complex; NH4þ does not appear to have been tried. The anions are located, together with the waters, in the interstitial tunnels between the columns of -CD molecules. All these complexes, with their wide tunnels, lose solvent very easily.
Table 4.19. Crystal data (at room temperature) for some nearly isomorphous tetragonal tunnel inclusion complexes of -CD; space group P4212; Z ¼ 6. The compositions are given as {-CD[x(guest)nH2O} Guest and water content
Refcode; reference
a
c
V/FU
CH3OH C2H5OH n-C3H7OH17H2O
NUNRIX; SS98
23.808(4) 23.823(9) 23.840(5)
23.140(3) 23.227(5) 23.227(6)
2170(1) 2193(1) 2200(1)
23.805(2) 23.808(2) 23.75(2) 23.842(2) 23.816(4) 23.824(1) 23.77 23.80 23.82 23.37
23.196(7) 23.175(2) 22.92(2) 23.132(2) 23.072(3) 23.083(1) 23.15 23.22 23.21 23.91
2182(1) 2189 2155 2192 2181 2184 2181 2192 2195 2176
C6H5CH2OH C8H16O4*9H2O C8H16O4*1/3(LiSCN)7.7H2O C8H16O4*1/3(KCl)9H2O C8H16O4*1/3(NaCl)7.7H2O [1/3(C18H22N2)16.4H2O (cyclizine)# [2/3(C10H16N6S)14.7H2O (cimetidine) [2/3(C8H15N7O2S3)18.7H2O (famotidine) [2/3(C13H22N4O2S)16.3H2O (ranitidine) Polyethylene glycol Clofibric acid
CYDXPL, LS80; SIBJAO, SIBJES, DSS91 DOCYID; KHH86 FEJFIJ; KHH87 FEJFOP; KHH87 SAJNAS; KHH88 D99 D99 D99 D99 UWR00 CBM01 (not seen)
* 12-crown-4 (CREt) References: CBM01 – Caira, Bourne and Mvula, 2001 (not seen); D99 – Dodds, 1999DSS91 – Ding, Steiner and Saenger, 1991; KHH86 – Kamitori, Hirotsu and Higuchi, 1986; KHH87 – Kamitori, Hirotsu and Higuchi, 1987; KHH88 – Kamitori, Hirotsu and Higuchi, 1988; LS80 – Lindner and Saenger, 1980; SS98 – Steiner and Saenger, 1998; water content not given specifically, but it must be close to 17 H2O; UWR00 – Udachin, Wilson and Ripmeester, 2000.
-CYCLODEXTRIN AS HOST
N
N
121
CH3
Cyclizine
Scheme 4.5
Now consider the tetragonal 3 : 1 -CD cyclizine structure. The guest is incorporated into the space between the molecules of the head-to-head dimer, with one guest molecule for each repeat of three -CD molecules up the [001 axis. The cyclizine is disordered in a number of ways – firstly, the piperazine ring can point either up or down, secondly, the cyclizine molecule as a whole can take up one of the four rotationally equivalent positions. There is not enough room within a stack for incorporation of a second cyclizine. However, the tetragonal complexes of -CD with the smaller cimetidine, famotidine and ranitidine guests have 3 : 2 compositions (Table 4.19). Full structure analyses were not carried out for these complexes but we may surmise that two cimetidines, etc. replace one cyclizine within the head-to-head dimer, with appropriate disorder. The crystal structures of the cimetidine, famotidine, ranitidine and cyclizine complexes are of particular interest – their isomorphism with the other -CD complexes strongly
a b
Fig. 4.19. View of part of the crystal structure of the propanol tunnel inclusion complex of -CD, seen down [001]. The symmetry elements of the space group are shown. For simplicity only the A -CD molecules (defined in Fig. 4.20) are shown but this is adequate to show the arrangement of the stacks. The small circles show the water molecules within the internal tunnels of the -CD molecules, while the larger circles show the water molecules in the interstitial tunnels between the -CD molecules. (Reproduced from Ding, Steiner and Saenger, 1991.)
122
C Y C L O D E X T R I NS , A ND S OM E AN A L O G S , A S H O S T S
HEAD
CREt C
TAIL TAIL HEAD HEAD
B
B CREt C
CREt
C
A
TAIL HEAD
CREt C
TAIL TAIL
A
B
B CREt
HEAD HEAD TAIL
A
CREt 0
A
C
ab
Fig. 4.20. Schematic diagram of the arrangement of the -CD molecules in the stacks in the tunnel inclusion complexes; a slice parallel to the ð110Þ plane is shown. The heads and tails of the -CD molecules in the left-hand column are indicated. The designation ‘CREt’ shows that the 12-crown-4 molecules are included in the heads of the -CD molecule; an isolated ‘CREt’ indicates a neutral crown ether molecule, while a juxtaposed pair shows either a pair of neutral molecules or, when crystallization is carried out in the presence of LiSCN, NaCl or KCl, the cationic species {(CREt)2Mþ}. (Modified from Steiner and Saenger, 1998a.)
suggests that in fact there is only one packing mode for all -CD complexes. This could be tested by checking cell dimensions and symmetry for other -CD complexes already reported. Among these are the 15 different complexes, reported by Vo¨gtle and Mu¨ller (1979); a variety of crown ethers, cryptands, cryptates and coronates were guests, and compositions included 1 : 1, 2 : 1, 1 : 1 : 1, 1 : 1 : 2, 2 : 1 : 1 ratios. Also, crystalline 1 : 1 complexes of -CD with ferrocene, acetylferrocene and 1,1 0 -diacetylferrocene have been reported by Harada, Hu, Yamamoto and Takahashi (1988). Crystal data or structures, apart from those noted above, do not appear to have been reported. Steiner and Saenger (1998) have pointed out that the disorder in the tetragonal -CD complexes makes it difficult to determine the molecular dimensions of -CD with the same precision that has been achieved for - and -CD, nor could the interactions among the moieties be defined in detail. Thus caution is needed before drawing far-reaching conclusions from the limited information currently available. 4.5.3
Chemically modified -cyclodextrins as hosts in inclusion complexes
Following the trend set earlier with chemically-modified - and -cyclodextrins, a number of permethylated -cyclodextrins have been prepared, and three different hydrates studied crystallographically (Table 4.20). Octakis(2,3,6-tri-O-methyl) -cyclodextrin is C72H128O40.
CYCLIC OLIGOSACCHARIDES AS CYCLODEXTRIN ANALOGS
123
Table 4.20. Crystal data for three permethylated -cyclodextrin hydrates. The compositions are given as {(C72H128O40).nH2O}. The last host is (C48H64O32) Composition
Refcode; reference
a
2.5H2O
GIWMAA; StSa98b XERSIW; AHSRS00 BEBJAT; AU99 ZUSYOB; YM96
17.730
4.5H2O 4.8H2O Octakis(3,6-anhydro)-CD14H2O
c
V/FU
Space group; Z
16.875
32.172
2271
P212121; 4
10.788
29.058
32.291
2531
P212121; 4
28.872
18.018 98.15 10.305 123.08
33.170
2209
P21; 8
15.406
1477
C2; 2
22.200
b/
References: AHSRS00b – Aree et al., 2000b AU99 – Aree, Uson et al., 1999; StSa98b – Steiner and Saenger, 1998b; YM96 – Yamamura et al., 1996.
4.6 Larger cyclodextrins Larger cyclodextrins ( for n ¼ 9 glucose units, " for n ¼ 10 and for n ¼ 11), were first isolated by French in 1957 (French, Pulley, Effendberger, Rougvie and Abdullah, 1965) and crystal structures have been reported for the (Fujiwara, Tanaka and Kobayashi, 1990; SIYKOA, 13.75 hydrate), " (Jacob, Gessler, Hoffmann, Sanbe, Koizumi, Smith, Takaha and Saenger, 1998; NOBBOV, 20.7 hydrate), (14; Jacob et al., 1998; NOBBUB, 27.3 hydrate) oligomers and for that with 26 glucose units (Gessler, Uson, Takaha, Krauss, Smith, Okada, Sheldrick and Saenger, 1998). Even larger cyclodextrins with 100 or more glucose units in the ring have been prepared (Takaha, Yanase, Takata, Okada and Smith, 1996). Whether inclusion complexes are formed by the larger cyclodextrins remains an open question at the time of writing (2003). The larger cyclodextrins do not have regular truncated-cone structures but are folded back upon themselves; thus guest inclusion seems unlikely. However, measurement of inclusion complexing capacity by capillary electrophoresis (Larsen, Ueda and Zimmerman, 1997) suggests that complexes may be formed by some guests. For example, the formation constant for the -CD–ibuprofen complex is 2600 M1, while corresponding values for the - and -CD ibuprofen complexes are 1013 and 225 M1 respectively.
4.7 Cyclic oligosaccharides as cyclodextrin analogs A series of novel CD analogs composed of alternating D- and L- rhamnopyranose (R) and mannopyranose (M) residues has been synthesized (Ashton, Cantrill, Gattuso, Menzer, Nepogodiev, Shipway, Stoddart and Williams, 1997), and we give some information about crystal structures that have been published (Table 4.21). 1-MM has a clathrate type structure while the other three molecules have tunnel arrangements. Although it has been mentioned that inclusion complexes are formed by
C Y C L O D E X T R I NS , A ND S OM E AN A L O G S , A S H O S T S
124
Table 4.21. Crystallographic information about cyclic oligosaccharides that may be cyclodextrin analogs n; CD analog
1R
2R
Crystal data
1-MM
3; -CD
CH2OH
CH2OH
2-RM
4; -CD
CH3
CH2OH
2-RR
4; -CD
CH3
CH3
3-RR
5; "-CD
CH3
CH3
C36H42 D18O309D2O; C2/c, Z ¼ 4 (molecules are centrosymmetric); ˚, a ¼ 28.005(2), b ¼ 9.807(2), c ¼ 20.853(2) A ˚ 3. NOHKEA ¼ 117.09(1) , V ¼ 5098.8(9) A (Ashton, Cantrill et al., 1997). 2{(C12H20O9)4}67H2O; P4, Z ¼ 1 (two independent molecules with four fold symmetry in the asymmetric unit); ˚, a ¼ b ¼ 24.200(5), c ¼ 7.918(3) A ˚ 3. TAHREZ V ¼ 4637(2) A (Ashton, Brown et al., 1996). C48H80O326Me2CO13H2O; C2/c, Z ¼ 4 (molecules have two fold axes); a ¼ 34.432(5), ˚ , ¼ 116.981) , b ¼ 7.986(2), c ¼ 31.910(3 A 3 ˚ V ¼ 7820(2) A . NOHKAW (Ashton, Cantrillet al., 1997). C60H100O406Me2CO10H2O; P1, Z ¼ 2 (two independent centrosymmetric molecules); ˚, a ¼ 15.130(6), b ¼ 19.077(5), c ¼ 20.017(5) A ¼ 72.74(2), ¼ 87.60(3), ¼ 88.60(3) , ˚ 3 NIHDIR V ¼ 5513(3) A (Gattuso, Menzer et al., 1997),
these hosts6, details have not yet been published. It does not seem too hazardous to predict that the crystallography of these inclusion complexes will prove as interesting as that of the cyclodextrins. References Alexander, J. M., Clark, J. L., Brett, T. J. and Stegowski, J. J. (2001). Proc. Nat. Acad, Sci., 99, 5115–5120. Alston, D. R., Slawin, A. M. Z., Stoddart, J. F. and Williams, D. J. (1985a). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 24, 786–788. Alston, D. R., Slawin, A. M. Z., Stoddart, J. F. and Williams, D. J. (1985b). J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun., pp. 1602–1604. Alston, D. R., Slawin, A. M. Z., Stoddart, J. F., Williams, D. J. and Zarycki, R. (1988). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 27, 1184–1185. Anibarro, M., Gessler, K., Uson, I., Sheldrick, G. M. and Saenger, W. (2001). Carbohydr. Res., 333, 251–256. 6 ‘‘Given the fact that these compounds share with the naturally-occurring CDs an ability to form inclusion complexes with other molecules, they could find themselves enjoying many biomedically-directed and materialsoriented applications in the future’’ (Gattuso, Menzer, Nepogodiev, Stoddart and Williams, 1997).
REFERENCES
125
Aree, T. and Chaichit, N. (2002). Carbohydr. Res., 337, 2487–2494. Aree, T. and Chaichit, N. (2003a). Carbohydr. Res., 338, 439–446. Aree, T. and Chaichit, N. (2003b). Carbohydr. Res., 338, 1581–1589 Aree, T., Hoier, H., Schulz, B., Reck, G. and Saenger, W. (2000a). Carbohydr. Res., 323, 245–253. Aree, T., Hoier, H., Schulz, B., Reck, G. and Saenger, W. (2000b). Carbohydr. Res., 328, 399–407. Aree, T., Hoier, H., Schulz, B., Reck, G. and Saenger, W. (2000c). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 39, 897–899. Aree, T., Jacob, J., Saenger, W. and Hoier, H. (1998). Carbohydr. Res., 307, 191–197. Aree, T., Saenger, W., Liebnitz, P. and Hoier, H. (1999). Carbohydr. Res., 315, 199–205. Aree, T., Schulz, B. and Reck, G. (2003). J. Incl. Phenom. Macrocyclic Chem., 47, 39–45. Aree, T., Uson, I., Schulz, B., Reck, G, Hoier, H., Sheldrick, G. M. and Saenger, W. (1999). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 121, 3321–3327. Armspach, D., Ashton, P. R., Moore, C. P., Spencer, N., Stoddart, J. F., Wear, T. J. and Williams, D. J. (1993). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 32, 854–858. Ashton, P. R., Brown, C. L., Menzer, S., Nepogodiev, S. A., Shipway, A. N., Stoddart, J. F. and Williams, D. J. (1996). Chem. Eur. J., 2, 580–591. Ashton, P. R., Cantrill, S. J., Gattuso, G., Menzer, S., Nepogodiev, S. A., Stoddart, J. F. and Williams, D. J. (1997). Chem. Eur. J., 3, 1299–1314. Bender, M. L. and Komiyama, M. (1978). Cyclodextrin Chemistry. Springer Verlag, New York. Betzel, C., Hingerty, B., Noltemeyer, M., Weber, G., Saenger, W. and Hamilton, J. A. (1983). J. Incl. Phenom., 1, 181–191. Betzel, C., Saenger, W., Hingerty, B. E. and Brown, G. M. (1984). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 106, 7545–7557. Bobek, M. M., Giester,G., Ka¨hlig, H. and Brinker, U. H. (2000). Tetr. Lett., 41, 5663–5667. Braga, S. S., Aree, T., Imamura, K., Vertut, P., Boal-Palheiros, I., Saenger, W. and Teixeira-Diaz, J. J. C. (2002). J. Incl. Phenom. Macrocyclic Chem., 43, 115–125. Brett, T. J. and Stezowski, J. J. (2000). Chem. Commun., pp. 551–552. Brett, T. J., Alexander, J. M. and Stezowski, J. J. (2000). J. Chem. Soc., Perkin 2, pp. 1095–1103. Brett, T. J., Alexander, J. M., Clark, J. L., Ross, C. R. II, Harbison, G. S. and Stezowski, J. J. (1999). Chem. Commun., pp. 1275–1276. Brett, T. J., Liu, S., Coppens, P. and Stezowski, J. J. (1999). Chem. Commun., pp. 551–552. Briggner, L.-E. and Wadso¨, I. (1990). J. Chem. Thermodyn., 22, 1067–1074. Brown, G. R. (1997). M.Sc. Thesis, Department of Chemistry, University of Cape Town. Brown, G. R., Caira, M. R., Nassimbeni, L. R. and Oudtshoorn, B. van. (1996). J. Incl. Phenom. Molec. Recogn. Chem., 26, 281–294. Caira, M. R. (2002). Rev. Roum. Chim., 46, 3761–386. Caira, M. R. and Dodds, D. R. (1999). J. Incl. Phenom. Molec. Recogn. Chem., 34, 19–29. Caira, M. R. and Dodds, D. R. (2000). J. Incl. Phenom. Molec. Recogn. Chem., 38, 75–84. Caira, M. R., Dodds, D. R. and Nassimbeni, L. R. (2001). Supramol. Chem., 13, 61–70. Caira, M. R., Bourne, S. A. and Mvula, E. (1999). J. Therm. Anal. and Calorimetry, 56, 1329–1334. Caira, M. R., Bourne, S. A. and Mvula, E. (2001). Biol. Zh. Armen., 53, 148–158. Caira, M. R., Griffith, V. J. and Nassimbeni, L. R. (1998). J. Incl. Phenom. Molec. Recogn. Chem., 32, 461–476. Caira, M. R., Griffith, V. J., Nassimbeni, L. R. and Oudtshoorn, B. van (1994a). J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Comm., pp. 1061–1062. Caira, M. R., Griffith, V. J., Nassimbeni, L. R. and Oudtshoorn, B. van (1994b). J. Chem. Soc., Perkin 2, pp. 2071–2072. Caira, M. R., Griffith, V. J., Nassimbeni, L. R. and Oudtshoorn, B. van (1994c). J. Incl. Phenom. Molec. Recogn. Chem., 17, 187–201. Caira, M. R., Griffith, V. J., Nassimbeni, L. R. and Oudtshoorn, B. van (1994/1995). J. Incl. Phenom. Molec. Recogn. Chem., 20, 277–290.
126
C Y C L O D E X T R I NS , A ND S OM E AN A L O G S , A S H O S T S
Caira, M. R., Griffith, V. J., Nassimbeni, L. R. and Oudtshoorn, B. van (1996). Supramol. Chem., 7, 119–124. Cardinael, P., Poulon, V., Perez, G., Coquard, G. and Toupet, L. (2001). J. Incl. Phenom. Molec. Recogn. Chem., 39, 159–167. Chacko, K. K. and Saenger, W. (1981). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 103, 1708–1715. Charpin, P., Nicolis, I., Villian, P., Rango, C. de and Coleman, A. W. (1991). Acta Cryst., C47, 1829–1833. Chen, Y., Luo, L., Chen, H., Hu, C., Chen, J. and Zheng, P. (2000). Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn., 73, 1375–1378. Clark, J. L. and Stezowski, J. J. (2001). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 123, 9880–9888. Clark, J. L., Booth, B. R. and Stezowski, J. J. (2001). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 123, 9889–9895. Cramer, F. (1954). Einschlussverbindungen. Springer Verlag, Berlin. Cramer, F. (1987). In Cyclodextrins and Their Industrial Uses, D. Ducheˆne (editor), Editions de Sante´, Paris, pp. 11–20. Cramer, F. and Henglein, F. M. (1957). Chem. Ber., 90, 2572–2575. Crisma, M., Fomasier, R. and Marcuzzi, F. (2001). Carbohydr. Res., 333, 145–151. Czugler, M., Eckle, E. and Stezowski, J. J. (1981). J. Chem. Soc. Chem. Comm., pp. 1291–1292. Diaz, D., Vargas-Baca, I. and Gracia-Mora, J. (1994). J. Chem. Educ., 71, 708–714. Ding, J., Steiner, T. and Saenger, W. (1991). Acta Cryst., B47, 731–738. Dimitrius, M., Terzis, A., Coleman, A. W. and de Rango, C. (1996). Carbohydr. Res., 282, 125–135. Dodds, D. R. (1999). Ph.D. Thesis, Department of Chemistry, University of Cape Town. Ducheˆne, D. (1987). (Ed.). Cyclodextrins and Their Industrial Uses, Editions de Sante´, Paris. Durier, V., Buisson, G., Due´e, E., Driguez, H. and Taravel, F.-R. (1993). J. Chem. Soc., Perkin 2, pp. 1931–1935. Eliadou, K., Yannakopoulou, K., Rontoyianni, A., Mavridis, I. M. (1999). J. Org. Chem., 64, 6217–6226. Evans, R. C. (1966). An introduction to crystal chemistry, 2nd edition. Cambridge University Press. French, D., Pulley, A. O., Effendberger, J., Rougvie, M. and Abdullah, M. (1965). Arch. Biochem. Biophys., 111, 153–160. Fujita, K., Matsunaga, A., Imoto, T., Hirotsu, K., Kamitori, S. and Higuchi, T. (1987). J. Am. Chem Soc., 107, 1790–1791. Fujiwara, T., Tanaka, N. and Kobayashi, S. (1990). Chem. Letts, pp. 739–742. Fujiwara, T., Tomita, K., Marseigne, I. and Vicens, J. (1988). Mol. Cryst. Liq. Cryst. Inc. Nonlin. Opt., 156, 393–404. Fujiwara, T., Yamazaki, M., Tomizu, Y., Tokuoka, R., Tomita, K., Matsuo, T., Suga, H. and Saenger, W. (1983). Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn., 56, 181–187. Gattuso, G., Nepogodiev, S. A. and Stoddart, J. F. (1998). Chem. Revs., 98, 1919–1958. Gattuso, G., Menzer, S., Nepogodiev, S. A., Stoddart, J. F. and Williams, D. J. (1997). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 36, 1451–1454. Gessler, K., Steiner, T., Koellner, G. and Saenger, W. (1993). Carbohydr. Res., 249, 327–344. Gessler, K., Uson, I., Takaha, T., Krauss, N., Smith, S. M., Okada, S., Sheldrick, G. M. and Saenger, W. (1998). Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci., 37, 605–609. Giastas, P., Yannakopoulou, K. and Mavridis, I. M. (2003). Acta Cryst., B59, 287–299. Hamilton, J. A. (1985). Carbohydr. Res., 142, 21–37. Hamilton, J. A. and Chen, L. (1988a). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 110, 4379–4391. Hamilton, J. A. and Chen, L. (1988b). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 110, 5833–5841. Hamilton, J. A. and Sabesan, M. N. (1982a). Carbohydr. Res., 102, 31–46. Hamilton, J. A. and Sabesan, M. N. (1982b). Acta Cryst., B38, 3063–3069. Hamilton, J. A., Sabesan, M. N. and Steinrauf, L. K. (1981). Carbohydr. Res., 89, 33–53. Hamilton, J. A., Steinrauf, L. K. and Van Etten, R. L. (1968). Acta Cryst., B24, 1560–1562.
REFERENCES
127
Hanabata, H., Matsuo, T. and Suga, H. (1987). J. Incl. Phenom., 5, 325–333. Harada, A., Hu, Y., Yamamoto, S. and Takahishi, S. (1988). J. Chem. Soc., Dalton, pp. 729–732. Harata, K. (1975). Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn., 48, 2409–2413. Harata, K. (1976a). Carbohydr. Res., 48, 265–270. Harata, K. (1976b). Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn., 49, 1493–1501. Harata, K. (1976c). Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn., 49, 2066–2072. Harata, K. (1977a). Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn., 50, 1259–1266. Harata, K. (1977b). Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn., 50, 1416–1423. Harata, K. (1978). Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn., 51, 1644–1648. Harata, K. (1979). Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn., 52, 2451–2459. Harata, K. (1980). Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn., 53, 2782–2786. Harata, K. (1982a). Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn., 55, 1367–1371. Harata, K. (1982b). Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn., 55, 2315–2321. Harata, K. (1984). Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn., 57, 2596–2599. Harata, K. (1987). Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn., 60, 2763–2767. Harata, K. (1988). Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn., 61, 1939–1944. Harata, K. (1989). Carbohydr. Res., 192, 33–42. Harata, K. (1990a). J. Chem. Soc., Perkin 2, pp. 799–804. Harata, K. (1990b). Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn., 63, 2481–2486. Harata, K. (1991). ‘‘Recent advances in the x-ray analysis of cyclodextrin complexes,’’ in Inclusion Compounds, edited by J. L. Atwood, J. E. D. Davies and D. D. MacNicol, Vol. 5 (Inorganic and Physical Aspects of Inclusion), Oxford University Press, Oxford etc., pp. 311–344. Harata, K, (1993). Chem. Commun., pp. 546–547. Harata, K. (1995). Supramol. Chem., 5, 231–236. Harata, K. (1996). ‘‘Crystallographic studies,’’ in Cyclodextrins, Volume 3 of Comprehensive Supramolecular Chemistry, edited by J. L. Atwood, J. E. D. Davies, D. D. MacNicol and F. Vo¨gtle, Pergamon, Oxford, pp. 279–304. Harata, K. (1998). Chem. Revs., 98, 1803–1827. Harata, K. (1999). Chem. Commun., pp. 191–192. Harata, K., Hirayama, F., Uekama, K. and Tsoucaris, G. (1988). Chem. Lett., pp. 1585–1588. Harata, K., Hirayama, F., Arima, H., Uekama, K. and Miyaji, T. (1992). J. Chem. Soc., Perkin 2, pp. 1159–1166. Harata, K., Kawano, K., Fukunaga, K. and Ohtani, Y. (1983). Chem. Pharm. Bull., 31, 1428–1430. Harata, K., Nagano, Y., Ikeda, H., Ikeda, T., Ueno, A. and Toda, F. (1996). Chem. Commun., pp. 2347–2348. Harata, K., Uedaira, H. and Tanaka, J. (1978). Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn., 51, 1627–1634. Harata, K., Uekama, K., Imai, T., Hirayama, F. and Otagiri, M. (1988). J. Incl. Phenom., 6, 443–460. Harata, K., Uekama, K., Otagiri, M. and Hirayama, F. (1982a). Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn., 55, 407–410. Harata, K., Uekama, K. Otagiri, M. and Hirayama, F. (1982b). Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn., 55, 3904– 3910. Harata, K., Uekama, K., Otagiri, M. and Hirayama, F. (1983a). Nippon Kagaku Kaishi, pp. 173–180. Harata, K., Uekama, K., Otagiri, M. and Hirayama, F. (1983b). Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn., 56, 1732–1736 Harata, K., Uekama, K. Otagiri, M. and Hirayama, F. (1984). J. Incl. Phenom., 1, 279–293. Harata, K., Uekama, K., Otagiri, M. and Hirayama, F. (1987). Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn., 60, 497–502. Harata, K., Uekama, K., Otagiri, M., Hirayama, F. and Ogino, H. (1981). Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn., 54, 1954–1959. Harata, K., Uekama, K., Otagiri, M., Hirayama, F. and Ohtani, Y. (1985). Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn., 58, 1234–1238.
128
C Y C L O D E X T R I NS , A ND S OM E AN A L O G S , A S H O S T S
Harata, K., Uekama, K. Otagiri, M., Hirayama, F. and Sugiyama, Y. (1982). Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn., 55, 3386–3389. Harding, M. M., Mclennan, J. M. and Paton, R. M. (1978). Nature, Lond., 274, 621–623. Herbstein, F. H. and Marsh, R. E. (1998). Acta Cryst., B54, 677–686. Hingerty, B. and Saenger, W. (1976). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 98, 3357–3365. Hingerty, B., Betzel, C. and Saenger, W. (1984). American Crystallographic Association Abstracts (Winter), p. 37. Hirotsu, K., Higuchi, T., Fujita, K., Ueda, T., Shinoda, A., Imoto, T. and Tabushi, I. (1982). J. Org. Chem., 47, 1143–1144. Hursthouse, M. B., Smith, C. Z., Thornton-Pett, M. and Utley, J. H. P. (1982). J. Chem. Soc. Chem. Comm., pp. 881–882. Hybl, A., Rundle, R. E. and Williams, D. E. (1965). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 87, 2779–2788. Jacob, J., Gessler, K., Hoffmann, D., Sanbe, H., Koizumi, K., Smith, S. M., Takaha, T. and Saenger, W. (1998). Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. Engl., 37, 606–609. Jogun, K. H. and Stezowski, J. J. (1979). Nature, Lond., 278, 667–668. Jogun, K. H., Mclennan, J. M. and Stezowski, J. J. (1979). Abstracts of 5th European Crystallographic Meeting, Copenhagen, p. 34. Kamitori, S., Hirotsu, K. and Higuchi, T. (1986). J. Chem. Soc. Chem. Comm., pp. 690–691. Kamitori, S., Hirotsu, K. and Higuchi, T. (1987). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 109, 2409–2414. Kamitori, S., Hirotsu, K. and Higuchi, T. (1988). Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn., 61, 3825–3830. Kamitori, S., Hirotsu, K., Higuchi, T., Fujita, K., Yamamura, H., Imoto, T. and Tabushi, I. (1987). J. Chem. Soc. Perkin Trans. II, pp. 7–14. Kamitori, S., Maruoka, S., Kondo, S. and Okuyama, K. (1998). Carbohydr. Res., 312, 177–181. Kamitori, S., Matsuzaka, O., Kondo, S., Maruoka, S., Okuyama, K., Noguchi, K., Okada, M. and Harada, A. (2000). Macromolecules, 33, 1500–1502. Kamitori, S., Toyama, T. and Matsuzaka, O. (2001). Carbohydr. Res., 332, 235–240. Klar, B., Hingerty, B. and Saenger, W. (1980). Acta Cryst., B36, 1154–1165. Klingert, B. and Rihs, G. (1990). Organometallics, 9, 1135–1141. Klingert, B. and Rihs, G. (1991a). J. Incl. Phenom., 10, 255–265. Klingert, B. and Rihs, G. (1991b). J. Chem. Soc., Dalton, pp. 2749–2760. Kokkinou, A., Makedonopoulou, S. and Mavridis, I. M. (2000). Carbohydr. Res., 328, 135–140. Kokkinou, A., Yannakopoulou, K., Mavridis, I. M. and Mentzafos, D. (2001). Carbohydr. Res., 332, 85–94. Koshland, D. E. (1970). ‘‘The molecular basis for enzyme regulation.’’ In The Enzymes, Third Edition, edited by P. D. Boyer, Vol. 1, pp. 342–396. Academic Press, New York and London . Larsen, K. L., Ueda, H. and Zimmerman, W. (1997). 8th European Congress on Biotechnology, Budapest, 17–21 August. Lautsch, W., Weichert, R. and Lehmann, H. (1954). Kolloid-Z., 135, 134–136. Le Bas, G. and Doucel, J. (1997). Acta Cryst., B53, 673–679. Le Bas, G. and Mason, S. A. (1994). Acta Cryst., B50, 717–724. Le Bas, G., Rango, C. de, Ryanek, N. and Tsoucaris, G. (1984). J. Incl. Phenom., 2, 861–867. Le Bas, G., Rysanek, N., Royer, F. and Tsoucaris, G. (1988). Mol. Cryst. Liq. Cryst., 161, 363–372. Lindner, K. and Saenger, W. (1980). Biochem. Biophys. Res. Comm., 92, 933–938. Lindner, K. and Saenger, W. (1982a). Carbohydr. Res., 99, 103–115. Lindner, K. and Saenger, W. (1982b). Carbohydr. Res., 107, 7–16. Lindner, K. and Saenger, W. (1982c). Acta Cryst., B38, 203–210. Luo, L. B., Chen, H. L., Tang, W. X., Zhang, Z. Y. and Mak, T. C. W. (1996). J. Chem. Soc., Dalton, pp. 4425–4430. Makedonopoulou, S. and Mavridis, I. M. (2000). Acta Cryst., B56, 322–331. Makedonopoulou, S. and Mavridis, I. M. (2001). Carbohydr. Res., 335, 213–220.
REFERENCES
129
Makedonopoulou, S., Tulinsky, A. and Mavridis, I. M. (1999). Supramol. Chem., 11, 73–80. Makedonopoulou, S., Papaioannou, J., Argyroglou, I. and Mavridis, I. M. (2000). J. Incl. Phenom., 36, 191–215. Makedonopoulou, S., Yannakopoulou, K., Mentzafos, D., Lamzin, V., Popov, A. and Mavridis, I. M. (2001). Acta Cryst., B57, 399–409. Manor, P. C. and Saenger, W. (1974). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 96, 3630–3639. Mclennan, J. M. and Stezowski, J. J. (1980). Biochem. Biophys. Res. Comm., 92, 926–932. McMullan, R. K., Saenger, W., Fayos, J. and Mootz, D. (1973a). Carbohydr. Res., 31, 37–46. McMullan, R. K., Saenger, W., Fayos, J. and Mootz, D. (1973b). Carbohydr. Res., 31, 211–227. Marsh, R. E., Kapon, M. Hu, S. and Herbstein, F. H. (2002). Acta Cryst., B58, 62–77. Mavridis, I. M. and Hadjoudis, E. (1992). Carbohydr. Res., 229, 1–15. Mavridis, I. M., Hadjoudis, E. and Tsoucaris, G. (1991). Carbohydr. Res., 220, 11–21. Meister, G., Stoeckli-Evans, H. and Su¨ss-Fink, G. (1993). J. Organometall. Chem., 453, 249–253. Mele, A. and Malpezzi, L. (2000). J. Amer. Soc. Mass Spectrom., 11, 228–238. Mentzafos, D., Mavridis, I. M. and Hursthouse, M. B. (1996). Acta Cryst., C52, 1220–1223. Mentzafos, D., Mavridis, I. M. and Schenk, H. (1994). Carbohydr. Res., 253, 39–50. Mentzafos, D., Mavridis, I. M. and Yannakopoulou, K. (1999). J. Incl. Phenom., 33, 321–330. Mentzafos, D., Mavridis, I. M., Le Bas, G. and Tsoucaris, G. (1991). Acta Cryst., B47, 746–757. Motherwell, S. (1978). ‘‘PLUTO, Program for Plotting Molecular and Crystal Structures’’, University Chemical Laboratories, Cambridge, England. Muraoka, S., Matsuzaka, O., Kamitori, S. and Okuyama, K. (1999). Carbohydr. Res., 320, 261–266. Nakagawa, T., Immel, S., Lichtenthaler, F. W. and Lindner, H. J. (2000). Carbohydr. Res., 324, 141–146. Nakanishi, I., Arai, M., Fujiwara, T. and Tomita, K. (1984). J. Incl. Phenom., 2, 689–699. Nakanishi, I., Fujiwara, T. and Tomita, K. (1984). Acta Cryst., A40, C78. Nepogodiev, S. A. and Stoddart, J. F. (1998). Chem. Revs., 98, 1959–1976. Nicolis, I., Coleman, A. W., Charpin, P. and Rango, C. de, (1995). Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. Engl., 34, 2381–2383. Nicolis, I., Coleman, A. W., Charpin, P. and Rango, C. de, (1996). Acta Cryst., B52, 122–130. Nicolis, I., Villain, F., Coleman, A. W., and Rango, C. de, (1995). Supramol. Chem., 3, 251–259. Nishioka, F., Nakanishi, I., Fujiwara, T. and Tomita, K.-I. (1984). J. Incl. Phenom., 2, 701–714. Noltemeyer, M. and Saenger, W. (1980). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 102, 2710–2722. Odagaki, Y., Hirotsu, K., Harada, A. and Takahashi, S. (1990). J. Chem. Soc., Perkin I, pp. 1230–1231. Pohlmann, H., Gdaniec, M., Eckle, E., Geiger, G. and Stezowski, J. J. (1984). Acta Cryst., A40, C276. Pop, M.M., Goubitz, K., Borodi, G., Bogdan, M., De Ridder, D. J. A., Peschar, R. and Schenk, H. (2002). Acta Cryst., B58, 1036–1043. Puliti, R., Mattia, C. A. and Paduano, L. (1998). Carbohydr. Res., 310, 1–8. Rango, C. de, Charpin, C., Navaza, J., Keller, N., Nicolis, I., Villain, F. and Coleman, A. W. (1992). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 114, 5475–5476. Rekharsky, M. V. and Inoue, Y. (1998). Chem. Rev., 98, 1875–1917. Rontoyianni, A. and Mavridis, I. M. (1994). J. Incl. Phenom. Mol. Recogn. Chem., 18, 211–227. Rontoyianni, A. and Mavridis, I. M. (1996b). Acta Cryst., C52, 2277–2281. Rontoyianni, A. and Mavridis, I. M. (1999). Supramol. Chem., 10, 213–218. Rontoyianni, A., Mavridis, I. M., Hadjoudis, E. and Duisenberg, A. J. M. (1994). Carbohydr. Res., 252, 19–32. Rontoyianni, A., Mavridis, I. M., Israel, R. and Beurskens, G. (1998). J. Incl. Phenom. Mol. Recogn. Chem., 32, 415–428. Rysanek, N., Le Bas, G., Villain, F. and Tsoucaris, G. (1992). Acta Cryst., C48, 1466–1471. Rysanek, N., Le Bas, G., Villain, F. and Tsoucaris, G. (1996). Acta Cryst., C52, 2932–2936.
130
C Y C L O D E X T R I NS , A ND S OM E AN A L O G S , A S H O S T S
Saenger, W. (1980). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 19, 344–362. Saenger, W. (1984). ‘‘Structural aspects of cyclodextrins and their inclusion complexes’’ in Inclusion Compounds, edited by J. L. Atwood, J. E. D. Davies and D. D. MacNicol, Vol. 2, pp. 231–259, Academic Press, London etc. Saenger, W. (1985). Isr. J. Chem., 25, 43–50. Saenger, W., Beyer, K. and Manor, P. C. (1976). Acta Cryst., B32, 120–128. Saenger, W., Jacob, J., Gessler, K., Steiner, T., Hoffmann, D., Sanbe, H., Koizumi, K., Smith, S. M. and Takaha, T. (1998). Chem. Rev., 98, 1787–1802. Saenger, W., McMullan, R. K., Fayos, J. and Mootz, D. (1974). Acta Cryst., B30, 2019–2028. Saenger, W. and Noltemeyer, M. (1976). Chem. Ber., 109, 503–517. Saenger, W., Noltemeyer, M., Manor, P. C., Hingerty, B. and Klar, B. (1976). Bioorg. Chem., 5, 187–195. Saenger, W. and Steiner, T. (1998). Acta Cryst., A54, 798–805. Sanchez-Ruiz, X., Alvarez-Larena, A., Jaime, C., Piniella, J. F. Redondo, J., Virgili, A., SanchezFerrando, F., Germain, G. and Baert, F. (1999).Supramol. Chem., 10, 219–223. Schardinger, F. (1904). Wien Klin. Wochenschi, 17, 207. Selkti, M., Navazza, A., Villain, F., Charpin, P. and De Rango, C. (1997). J. Incl. Phenom. Molec. Recogn. Chem., 27, 1–12. Senti, F. R. and Erlander, S. R. (1964). ‘‘Carbohydrates’’ (Chapter 9) in Non-Stoichiometric Compounds, edited by L. Mandelcorn, Academic Press, London and New York. Shibakami, M. and Sekiya, A. (1992). J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Comm., pp. 1742–1743. Shibakami, M. and Sekiya, A. (1994). Carbohydr. Res., 260, 169–179. Sicard-Roselli, C., Perly, B. and Le Bas, G. (2001). J. Incl. Phenom. Molec. Recogn. Chem., 39, 333–337. Steiner, T. (1990). Ph. D. Thesis, Freie Univ. Berlin, Germany. Steiner, T., Hinrichs, W., Saenger, W. and Hoyer, G-A. (1989). Carbohydr. Res., 192, 43–49. Steiner, T., Hirayama, K. and Saenger, W. (1996). Carbohydr. Res., 296, 69–82. Steiner, T. and Gessler, K. (1994). Carbohydr. Res., 260, 27–38. Steiner, T. and Koellner, G. (1994). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 116, 5122–5128. Steiner, T., Koellner, G. and Saenger, W. (1992). Carbohydr. Res., 228, 321–332. Steiner, T., Koellner, G., Ali, S., Zakim, D. and Saenger, W. (1992). Biochem. Biophys. Res. Comm., 188, 1060–1066. Steiner, T., Koellner, G., Gessler, K. and Saenger, W. (1995). J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Comm., pp. 511–512. Steiner, T., Mason, S. A. and Saenger, W. (1989). Z. Krist., 186, 281–282. Steiner, T., Mason, S. A. and Saenger, W. (1991). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 113, 5676–5687. Steiner, T. and Saenger, W. (1994b). Carbohydr. Lett., 1, 143–150. Steiner, T. and Saenger, W. (1995a). Carbohydr. Res., 275, 73–82. Steiner, T. and Saenger, W. (1995b). Chem. Commun., pp. 2087–2088. Steiner, T. and Saenger, W. (1998a). Acta Cryst., B54, 450–455. Steiner, T. and Saenger, W. (1998b). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 37, 3404–3407. Steiner, T. and Saenger, W. (1998c). J. Chem. Soc., Perkin 2, pp. 371–377. Stezowski, J. J. (1985). Trans. Am. Cryst. AsSoc., 20, 73–82. Stezowski, J. J., Czugler, M. and Eckle, E. (1981). Proc. I. S. Cyclodextrins, p. 151. Stezowski, J. J., Jogun, K. H., Eckle, E. and Bartels, K. (1978). Nature, Lond., 274, 617–619. Stezowski, J. J., Parker, W., Hilgenkamp, S. and Gdenic, M. (2001). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 123, 3919–3926. Stoddart, J. F. and Zarycki, R. (1989). Cyclodextrins – Monographs in Supramolecular Chemistry. Royal Society of Chemistry, London. Storsberg, J., Ritter, H., Pielartzik, H. and Groenendaal, L. (2000). Adv. Mater, 12, 567–569.
REFERENCES
131
Szejtli, J. 1982). Cyclodextrins and Their Inclusion Compounds. Akade´miai Kiado´, Budapest. Szejtli, J. (1988). Cyclodextrin Technology, pp. 450. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht. Szetjli, J. (1998). Chem. Rev., 98, 1743–1753. Szetjli, J. and Budai, Zs. (1977). Acta Chim. Acad. Sci. Hung., 94, 383–390. Szetjli, J. and Osa, T. (1996). Editors, Cyclodextrins, Volume 3 of Comprehensive Supramolecular Chemistry, edited by J. L. Atwood, J. E. D. Davies, D. D. MacNicol and F. Vo¨gtle, Pergamon, Oxford. Tabushi, I. (1982). Accts. Chem. Res., 15, 66–72. Takaha, T., Yanase, M., Takata, S., Okada, S. and Smith, S. M. (1996). J. Biol. Chem., 271, 2902–2908. Tanaka, Y., Sakuraba, H. and Nakanishi, H. (1990). J. Org. Chem., 55, 564–567. Tokuoka, R., Fujiwara, T. and Tomita, K. (1981). Acta Cryst., B37, 1158–1160. Tokuoka, R., Abe, M. Fujiwara, T., Tomita, K. and Saenger, W. (1980). Chem. Letts., pp. 491–494. Tsoucaris, G., Le Bas, G., Rysanek, N. and Villain, F. (1987). J. Incl. Phenom., 5, 77–84. Udachin, K. A. and Ripmeester, J. A. (1998). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 120, 1080–1081. Udachin, K. A., Wilson, L. D. and Ripmeester, J. A. (2000). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 122, 12375–12376. Uekama, K. and Irie, T. (1987). In Cyclodextrins and their Industrial Uses, Duchene, D., Ed.; Editions de Sante, Paris, pp. 395–439. Uekama, K., Hirayama, F., Imai, T., Otogiri, M. and Harata, K. (1983). Chem. Pharm. Bull., 31, 3363–3365. Uekama, K., Imai, T., Hirayama, F., Otogiri, M. and Harata, K. (1984). Chem. Pharm. Bull., 32, 1662–1664. Vicens, J., Fujiwara, T. and Tomita, K. (1988). J. Incl. Phenom., 6, 577–581. Villiers, A. (1891). Compt. Rend. Acad. Sci. Paris, 112, 536–538. Vo¨gtle, F. and Mu¨ller, W. M. (1979). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 18, 623–624. Yamamura, H., Masuda, H., Kawase, Y., Kawai, m., Butsugan, Y. and Einaga, H. (1996). Chem. Commun., pp. 1069–1070. Yannakopoulou, K., Ripmeester, J. A. and Mavridis, I. M. (2002). J. Chem. Soc., Perkin 2, pp. 1639–1644. Zabel, V., Saenger, W. and Mason, S. A. (1986). J. Am. Chem. Soc., 108, 3664–3673. Zhukhlistova, N. E., Tischenko, G. N., Kuranova, I. P., Vainshtein, B. K., Mattson, P. and Korpella, T. (1996). Kristallografiya, 41, 97–108.
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 5 Crystal chemistry of some DNA oligonucleotides and their complexes
The interaction between DNA and drugs is of great importance in molecular biology and medicinal chemistry. Drugs that target nucleic acids have wide application in nucleic acid recognition, regulation of biological processes and the development of therapeutic agents against cancers and virus-related diseases. Deng, Pan and Sundaralingam, 2003 . . . and, to crown all, Kinnaird and I had to conduct Sheridan down a damned corkscrew staircase, which had certainly been constructed before the discovery of fermented liquors, and to which no legs, however crooked, could possibly accommodate themselves. Lord Byron 31 October, 1815
Summary: We start with brief introductions to the fundamentals of oligonucleotide structure and to some current aspects of crystal chemistry common to cyclodextrin complexes, tetraphenylporphyrin-metal complexes and oligonucleotides and their complexes. This is followed by an outline of the special features of X-ray crystal structure analysis as applied to oligonucleotides, including the limitations on the resolution attainable. The implicit assumption usually made that native oligonucleotides are unary (single component) phases while their complexes (intercalation and minor groove binders are the two principal types) are binary can be a useful working hypothesis but neglects the important effects of solvent and ion content. In contrast to most of the published work, where priority has been given to features of biological importance, here we stress the crystal chemical aspects of hexamer, octamer, decamer and dodecamer oligonucleotide crystals, covering both native and complexed modifications. Many of the crystal structures are, group wise, isomorphous (same crystal structures despite differences in chemical nature). Differences in base-pair sequence sometimes break the isomorphism but usually not. Other different crystal types are often found in addition to the major isomorphous families. An important problem is that the chemical compositions (solvent content, presence and number of ions) are often not known so it can be difficult to decide whether particular clusters of related crystals are polymorphs (different crystal structures although the chemical compositions are the same) or have different compositions. Comparison of unit cell volumes is a useful but limited tool in making such decisions. Attempts are made to classify particular crystalline complexes in phase rule terms as primary solid solutions or phase rule compounds. There are resemblances in behavior and structural features to the cyclodextrins.
5.1 Introduction 5.2 Fundamentals of oligonucleotide structure 5.2.1 General aspects 5.2.2 Single crystal x-ray diffraction studies of oligonucleotides
134 136 136 140
134
CRYSTAL CHE MISTRY OF SOME DNA OLIGONUCLEOTIDES
5.3
Crystal chemistry of oligonucleotides and oligonucleotide-guest structures 5.3.1 Polymorphism, isomorphism, and heteromorphism 5.3.2 Phase rule relationships 5.3.3 Applications of these concepts 5.4 Intercalated hexanucleotide-drug complexes with B-DNA structures 5.4.1 The anthracycline drugs 5.4.2 Nogalamycin and derivatives 5.4.3 The 9-aminoacridine drugs 5.4.4 Native hexanucleotides and comparison of crystal structures 5.5 Isomorphism and polymorphism of A-DNA octanucleotides and the binding of spermine 5.6 Minor groove binders 5.6.1 Drug molecules that enter the minor groove 5.6.2 Decameric oligonucleotides 5.6.3 Polymorphs or intermediate phases? An example from the decanucleotides 5.6.4 Dodecameric oligonucleotides 5.7 General survey of the crystal chemistry of oligonucleotide and oligonucleotide-guest structures References
5.1
142 142 143 144 145 145 151 154 156 158 167 167 171 178 183 187 189
Introduction
The double-helix structure of deoxyribose nucleic acid (DNA), first reported by Watson and Crick in 1952, has attracted more attention and had more influence on the development of modern molecular biology than any other structure determination. The genetic material is composed of DNA, and the complementary nature of the two sets of base pairs in the two strands of the double helix provide a natural way of transmitting genetic information. DNA itself has only been obtained in the form of well oriented fibres up to some microns in length and so the amount of detail that can be extracted from structure analyses is severely limited. Thus a great advance was made when short sequences of DNA bases (synthetic oligonucleotides, also referred to as ‘‘DNA oligomers’’) were first synthesized in the 1970s and crystallized, thus allowing the execution of crystal structure analyses on fragments of relatively small size. This has shown that the original model of DNA derived from fiber diffraction is, not unexpectedly, somewhat oversimplified and has allowed the acquisition of much more structural detail (Neidle, Schneider and Berman, 2003). Our interest here is in the structures of the molecular complexes formed between drug molecules of various kinds and various DNA oligomers (hexamers, octamers, decamers and dodecamers) and specifically in their crystal chemistry. Thus we first review apposite fundamentals of DNA structure and then introduce those aspects of phase diagrams, isomorphism and polymorphism relevant here. The complexes can be classified in two main groups – the
I NT RO D UC T I O N
135
first has the drug molecules intercalated between two successive base pairs and the second has the drug molecule nestling in the minor groove of the DNA oligomer; we treat these separately, In these complexes the DNA fragment is the ‘‘host’’ and the drug molecule the ‘‘guest;’’ some attention is given to the structures of the native hosts (i.e. without guests) because the variety that is found impinges on the structures of the complexes. There are a number of excellent reviews that give more detail than is possible here. The Oxford Handbook of Nucleic Acid Structures (Neidle, 1999) is one recent compendium; another, edited by Demeunynck, Bailly and Wilson (2003), has 25 chapters by 27 authors; besides its broad coverage of topics relevant to this chapter, and far beyond, it includes an illuminating introductory chapter by Waring and Wakelin (2003) and a very useful collection of some thousands of references with titles. The principal data resource is the Nucleic Acid Database (Berman, Westbrook et al., (2002); there were some 2500 entries by late 2004, not all relevant here. Bloomfield et al. (2000) give an overall survey in their Nucleic Acids. Structures, Properties and Functions. Yang and Wang (1999) give an overview of DNA-drug interactions. A Google search for ‘‘nucleic acid databases’’ gave 240 000 hits. Our coverage is selective rather than comprehensive – we omit many important topics outside the mainstream of past and current activity. Most authors emphasize the effects of base sequence on the detailed structure of the oligonucleotides and how the details of the binding of drug molecules differ from one group of oligonucleotides to the next; thus most structural papers include exhaustive analyses of oligonucleotide structure. Their goal has been to account for the large differences found in drug behavior despite small differences in chemical structure. Packing effects on oligonucleotide structure were once considered to be minimal with only passing attention paid to crystal structures as such. Accumulation of information has led to a change in attitude and most structures show appreciable environmental influence. Readers are directed to the original studies for detailed analyses of the geometries and binding interactions in the native oligonucleotides and their drug complexes, including discussions of water structure and the role of metal ions. This material must eventually find application also in discussions of crystal structure, but that stage of development has not yet been reached. Here we draw attention to an approximation that pervades this whole chapter. It is convenient to refer to the complexes as oligonucleotide-drug complexes, with the subliminal implication that the systems are binary. However, about half (by weight) of the crystals consists of solvent (mainly water, more or less organized) and there are also metal cations and spermine. It is surely correct to assign the major structural significance to the oligonucleotide-drug portion but the residue may not be neglected, as has been pointed out by many authors (e.g. Guerri, Simpson and Neidle, 1998). Also, one should not forget that an extrapolation is involved when making inferences about DNA structure and behavior based on results obtained for DNA oligomers. However, there seem to be good reasons to believe that such extrapolations are generally permissible. There is an important area that impinges on the subject matter of this chapter – the formation of complexes between proteins and DNA. However, this would require a book on its own and we give only a leading reference (Goldman, 1996).
CRYSTAL CHE MISTRY OF SOME DNA OLIGONUCLEOTIDES
136
5.2
Fundamentals of oligonucleotide structure
5.2.1
General aspects
The gross structure of DNA is well known, and the DNA oligomers have structures based on the same general principles. The description is conveniently given in terms of a spiral staircase, where the helical outer frame is composed of deoxyribose phosphate groups, and the treads (steps) of hydrogen-bonded pyrimidine–purine pairs. The sugar phosphate groups are negatively charged and so counterions, generally sodium and/or magnesium (calcium and barium are also possibilities, as is spermine (Scheme 5.4)), must accompany the double helix, and are usually embedded in an (often ill-defined) envelope of water molecules; DNA is usually about 50% water by mass. Thus, in formal terms, the oligonucleotides are salts or salt-molecule complexes, depending on the ionization state of the drug molecules. DNA has been found to occur in three stereochemical forms – in A and B the helices are right-handed while left-handed helices are found in the Z form. In earlier work counterions were only positively identified in the Z-DNA hexamers, the B-DNA decamers and some of the DNA-drug complexes,1 but this situation is changing with the increased resolution being attained in crystal structure analyses. We shall first discuss the individual components of the whole association, and then consider how they are combined into an oligomer of particular conformation. The base pairing has received most attention in the past. Watson and Crick showed that treads of the required dimensions to bridge between the two sugar phosphate spirals were obtained by hydrogen bonding guanine–cytosine (GC) and thymine–adenine (TA) pyrimidine–purine base pairs (Fig. 5.1). These are the complementary Watson–Crick base pairs and the implication is that each C in one strand can only be hydrogen bonded to G in the other strand, and similarly for the TA pair. Thus the two strands of the double helix are antiparallel (Fig. 5.2). Although Watson–Crick base pairing is by far the most common, work during the last forty years has shown that other base pairings do occur and are relevant to the structures of the DNA oligomers. The first of these alternative pairings was encountered by Hoogsteen (1959) in the crystal structure of the 1:1 complex of 1-methylthymine and 9-methyladenine. Among other examples of mismatched pairs (‘‘wobble’’ base pairs) are the pyrimidine–purine pairs CHþG (CHþ symbolizes protonated cytosine), TG (with three bridging water molecules included in the hydrogen bonding scheme), CA (one bridging water) and the purine–purine pair GA, which is found in three variations G(anti)A(syn), G(syn)A(anti) and G(anti)A(anti). The oligonucleotides discussed below are mostly self-complementary and based on Watson–Crick base pairing. However, the strands are not required to be identical – a complementary example with nonidentical strands is (5 0 -CGCAAAAAAGCG-3 0 ) (5 0 -CGCTTTTTTGCG-3 0 ) (Nelson, Finch et al., 1987; Table 5.13) while a noncomplementary example (also with non-identical strands) is {(5 0 -CG[5BrC]ATATTTCGC-3 0 ) þ (5 0 -CGCAAATATGCG-3 0 )}, which has GT and CA non-Watson–Crick base pairs (Aymami, Nunn and Neidle, 1999; Table 5.13).
1
The conformations denoted by Z, A and B will be defined below.
FUNDAMENTALS OF OLIGONUCLEOTIDE STRUCTURE H
H
H
H C C
O
C N 50°
To chain
0.2
8n
C
m
H
T
Thymine
137
N
0n
H
C
H
N
0.3
Adenine
m
C
N
N
C
A
O C
1.1
C C
1 nm H
N
H
N 51° To chain
52 ° H
H
H
C
N
C
C
Cytosine To chain
N 52°
0.2
H
C 0n
N
H 0.2
m
m
N 8n
m
Guanine C
N
9n
H 1.0
m
O
0.3
C O
9n
G C
C C
N
N
C
H
N 54° To chain
H
Fig. 5.1. The complementary T-A and CG hydrogen bonded Watson–Crick pyrimidine-purine base pairs. Line drawings with dimensions are on the left and space-filling models on the right. (Adapted from Fig. 31.3 of Lehninger, 1977.)
3⬘
5⬘
Strand I
Strand II
C
G
G
C
A
T
T
A
C
G
G
C
5⬘
3⬘
Fig. 5.2. A model of the base pairing in a hexameric oligonucleotide; base sequence is listed from 5 0 to 3 0 . The dashed lines joining the base pairs represent the hydrogen bonding schemes shown in more detail in Fig. 5.1. In this example, and in most of the other oligonucleotides discussed here, the two strands are antiparallel and identical, but identity is not required. The hexameric oligomer is designated d(5 0 -GCTAGC-3 0 )2. (Adapted from Fig. 31.4 of Lehninger, 1977.)
CRYSTAL CHE MISTRY OF SOME DNA OLIGONUCLEOTIDES
138
The sugar–phosphate arrangement in a single strand is shown schematically in Fig. 5.3. The bases are linked by 3 0 ,5 0 -phosphodiester bonds; the particular fragment illustrated can be written as d(5 0 -ApGpCpT-3 0 ), where d represents deoxy (RNA fragments, with an hydroxyl on the 2 0 ring carbon, are shown as ‘r’ or by lower case letters (‘c’ instead of ‘C’)), ‘p’ represents phosphate and A etc are abbreviations for the bases; a more usual notation is d(AGCT), with the duplex nature of the oligonucleotides discussed here emphasized by using the notation d(AGCT)2. The chain has a certain amount of conformational flexibility. We quote the concise descriptions of the conformations of A, B and Z forms given by Kennard and Hunter (1991; see also Kennard and Salisbury, 1993): ‘‘The A form has 11
H N
O O
P
n–1
O
X
C H C H H C
O n
C
A
N
H C
H O
C
H
N
C
N
C
N
H
O H C C H
O
H
P
O
O6 N 8 5⬘
H
6
9
4 3
N
N
4⬘
1⬘
H
N
2⬘
3⬘
G
1N 2
O 4⬘
O
5
7
N2 H H
H
C
N
O 1
O
P
n+1
O
N
O
O
O O4 CH3 O
5 4 6 1
O
P
n+ 2
O
N
O
N
H
T
3 2
O2
O
Y
O O
P
O
O
Fig. 5.3. Schematic arrangement of the four Watson–Crick bases and sugar-phosphate groups in a single strand of a fragment of DNA. Y shows the direction of the chain that runs from the 5 0 carbon to the 3 0 carbon. X indicates a nucleotide residue. A full notation for the duplex would be d(5 0 -ApGpCpT-3 0 )2. (Reproduced from Fig. 26 of Kennard and Hunter (1991)).
FUNDAMENTALS OF OLIGONUCLEOTIDE STRUCTURE
139
base pairs per turn of helix with 32.7 twist between adjacent base pairs. The rise per ˚ . The bases are oriented anti about the glycoside bond and the furanose base pair is 2.7 A ring adopts the C3 0 endo conformation. The global helix axis lies in the major groove with the bases displaced some distance away . . . . The B form has 10 base pairs per turn, ˚ . The glycoside orientation is anti a helix twist of 36.0 and a rise per base pair of 3.4 A 0 and the sugar conformation tends to C2 endo. The global helix axis is through the base pairs . . . . The Z form is a left-handed helix with a zigzag sugar–phosphate backbone, hence the name. The Z form is mostly adopted by alternating cytosine/guanine sequences and can be considered as a repeat of d(CpG) steps. There are 12 base pairs per ˚ . The helix twist, glycoside orientation and sugar conformation turn and a rise of 3.7 A depend on whether the pyrimidine or purine is being considered or whether it is the first or second base pair of the dinucleotide step.’’ In fibers, whether the A or B form is obtained depends on environmental conditions and this led to the notion that these conformations represent discontinuous states, only stable in very different environments. This point of view has been revised and it is now accepted that A and B forms have similar energies, and stabilization of one or other depends on sequence as well as on oligomer arrangements in the crystals; thus a continuum of right-handed DNA conformations, spanning the range from A to B, could be expected. An example is given in Fig. 5.9. A rough first approximation to the shape of oligonucleotides describes them as right cylinders; this is shown in some packing diagrams such as Fig. 5.7. A better approximation has the surface of the molecules molded into helical minor and major grooves (Fig. 5.4). The larger oligonucleotides (e.g the dodecanucleotides) are often kinked in the sense that
Minor groove
Major Groove
Fig. 5.4. Schematic representation of the major and minor grooves of a B-oligonucleotide. The helical laths represent the sugar-phosphate periphery and the cross-bars the base pairs. (Diagram kindly supplied by Prof. Noam Adir (Technion, 2004)).
140
CRYSTAL CHE MISTRY OF SOME DNA OLIGONUCLEOTIDES
they can be divided into two quasi-cylindrical units with axes inclined to one another; the d(CGCCCGCGGGCG) dodecamer (Table 5.5; Malinina, Fernandez, Hyunh-Dinh and Subirana, 1999) is an example. We quote from Tidwell and Boykin (2003): ‘‘In principle, molecules can bind to either the major or minor grooves of DNA. Due to the great difference . . . in the dimensions of the two grooves, targeting them requires vastly different shaped molecules. The major groove . . . is much wider than the minor groove; the groove width values for ˚ , respectively . . . the major groove is averaged-sequence B-form DNA are 11.6 and 6.0 A the site of binding of many DNA interacting proteins . . . [with only] limited reports of non-protein molecules that bind to the DNA major groove . . . Minor groove binding usually involves greater binding affinity and higher sequence specificity than that of intercalator binding.’’ 5.2.2
Single crystal x-ray diffraction studies of oligonucleotides
The detail obtainable from the results of crystal structure analyses depends ultimately on the nature of the samples, assuming that instrumentation and computing facilities are ‘‘state of the art.’’ The crystals considered in this book cover a wide spectrum of ‘‘diffraction quality’’ ranging from ‘‘exceptional’’ ({benzeneAgClO4} Section 11.11.1) through ‘‘standard’’ (most of the structures) to ‘‘poor’’ (some of the intercalation complexes of Chapter 9). The crystalline oligonucleotides are usually somewhere between ‘‘standard’’ and ‘‘poor.’’ The unit cells are relatively large (volumes of ˚ 3), the number of reflections some thousands and the R factors around 50 000 A obtained around 15–20%. Some improvement can be obtained by structure determination at low temperatures (typically 100K) but this is still the exception rather than the rule. We also note that the small (or minute) quantities of material available do not facilitate crystallochemical studies. There are indications from cell dimension measurements that not all crystals of some complexes are identical. For example, independently prepared crystals of {d(CGCGAATTCGCG)2-Hoechst 33258} measured ˚ 3 whereas two other at 173, 248 and 273K all have cell volumes close to 61 000 A ˚ 3 (see Table 5.13). A crystals (measured at 288 and 298K) had volumes of 67 000 A difference of 10% is surely to be ascribed to compositional or structural differences rather than experimental error. Similar examples are to be found below in the tables of crystallographic data (e.g. d(CCCGCGGG) in Table 5.7 (Fernandez, Subirana et al., 1997)). In small-molecule crystal structure analysis the usual procedure is to define the unit cell contents by a chemical formula (obtained by chemical analysis) or, at least, a mass content obtained through the measured density. Neither chemical analysis nor measured density is generally reported for biomolecular crystals and we use the cell volume as a designator of content. This is a measurable and useful entity despite its incomplete information tally. The assumption is usually made that equality of cell volumes (or their relationship by a small integer) implies similarity of chemical composition. A landmark review by Dickerson (1992), written when about 100 crystal structures of DNA oligonucleotides and complexes had been reported, contains a treatment of
FUNDAMENTALS OF OLIGONUCLEOTIDE STRUCTURE
141
the structure analysis process and much structural information that is still relevant. Some we shall extract here; that part omitted will repay study. Dickerson’s main classification was in terms of helical configuration (A, B, Z2 and irregular) with a secondary division in terms of space group. As our main interest is in the complexes our first division is between the two main groups of complexes – intercalation complexes and minor groove complexes;3 fortunately there is little overlap. Our next criterion is oligonucleotide length (hexamers, octamers, decamers and dodecamers), with a further subdivision in terms of sequence. We have grouped together isomorphous crystals and attempted to identify polymorphism. Native crystals and complexes are treated together because there is considerable overlap between some of these groups. Other problems of definition stem from the limited resolution of many data sets. This may be a result of inadequate crystal (diffraction) quality or of real disorder effects. One criterion of ‘‘resolution’’ is how far out (in reciprocal space) the measured reflections ˚; 1A ˚ atomic resolution extend. This is usually expressed as the direct space value X A corresponds to a Bragg angle of 60 for Cu K radiation. Other ‘‘diffraction quality’’ criteria are discussed by Dickerson (1992). One consequence of disorder is found among minor groove complexes (see below) that have been divided into two types of model – in Class I models the drug molecule takes up a single position in the minor groove while in Class II models there is apparent end-to-end disorder of the (almost symmetrical) drug molecule that may result from incorrect analysis because of the limited resolution of the data set (Goodsell, Kopka and Dickerson, 1995). Thus reports of Class II structures should be treated with some reserve. An authenticated example is the monoimidazole lexitropsin complex of the dodecamer d(CGCGAATTCGCG) (Goodsell, Ng et al., 1995). The next landmark is surely the establishment of the Nucleic Acid Database (NDB; Berman, Olson et al., 1992) and its subsequent development. The NDB contains detailed experimental and structural information (from crystal growth through diffraction techniques through geometrical results) for more than 2 000 structures (NMR studies are included although not considered here), as well as tools for analyzing this treasure trove. In our Table 5.1 we reproduce the description given in Table 1 of Berman, Westbrook et al. (2002). We have used the NDB to provide data for the limited number of topics covered in this chapter. The NDB does not give information about solvent content of reported structures (perhaps because this may change as analyses improve). The limitations of earlier and current results have been stressed in the paragraphs ˚ are above but the face of the future can also be seen. Resolutions of 0.7 A now being achieved both in protein and nucleic acid crystallography. For example, the B-DNA double helix structure of 5 0 -CCAGTACTGG-3 0 has been ˚ using a combination of liquid nitrogen temdetermined to a resolution of 0.74 A ˚ ) (Kielkopf, Ding, Kuhn and perature and synchrotron radiation (wavelength 0.78 A Rees, 2000). 2 3
We do not discuss Z-DNA because of limitations of space. Sometimes called ‘‘parallel’’ (to the planes of the base pairs) and ‘‘perpendicular’’.
142
CRYSTAL CHE MISTRY OF SOME DNA OLIGONUCLEOTIDES
Table 5.1. The information content of the NDB (reproduced from Berman, Westbrook et al. 2002) with some additions Primary experimental information stored in the NDB Structure summary – descriptor NDB, PDB and CSD names; coordinate availability; modifications, mismatch and drug binding. Stuctural description – sequence; structure type; descriptions about modifications, mismatches and drugs; description of asymmetric and biological units. Citations – authors, title, journal, volume, pages, year. Crystal data – cell dimensions, space group. Data collection description – radiation source and wavelength; data-collection device; temperature; resolution range; total and unique number of reflections. Crystallization description – method; temperature; pH value; solution composition. Refinement information – method; program; number of reflections used for refinement; data cutoff; resolution range; R factor; refinement of temperature factors and occupancies. Coordinate information – atomic coordinates, occupancies and temperature factors for asymmetric unit; coordinates for symmetry-related strands; coordinates for unit cell; symmetry-related coordinates; orthogonal or fractional coordinates. Derivative information stored in the NDB Distances – chemical bond lengths; virtual bonds (involving P atoms) Torsions – backbone and side-chain torion angles; pseudo-rotational parameters. Angles – valence bond angles, virtual angles (involving P atoms) Base morphology – parameters calculated by different algorithms Non-bonded contacts Hydrogen bonding classification Valence geometry RMS deviations from small molecule standards Sequence pattern statistics CIF information – coordinates, structure factors.
5.3 5.3.1
Crystal chemistry of oligonucleotide and oligonucleotide-guest structures Polymorphism, isomorphism, and heteromorphism
There are many striking resemblances, and also some differences, in the crystal chemistries of cyclodextrin inclusion complexes (Chapter 4), tetraphenylporphyrin-MII inclusion complexes (Chapter 8) and oligonucleotide native crystals and complexes. The established concepts of polymorphism and isomorphism are basic to the discussion and we find it convenient to introduce a new term ‘‘heteromorphism.’’ We define these terms immediately below, and then illustrate and compare them for particular examples from the three groups of cyclodextrins, tetraphenylporphyrin-MII moieties and oligonucleotides. Our approach is that terms and definitions currently accepted in small-moiety crystallography should be applied to inclusion complexes and biomolecules with minimal change. 1. Polymorphism. Experience and calculation show that many different packing arrangements have similar lattice energies4 (Lommerse et al., 2000) and this gives rise 4 Free energies rather than enthalpies should be considered but entropy is more difficult to calculate and is often explicitly or implicitly ignored.
OLIGONUCLEOTIDE AND OLIGONUCLEOTIDE-GUEST STRUCTURES
143
to the phenomenon of polymorphism. A formal definition of polymorphism is: when the same chemical compound occurs in two different crystalline forms these are called polymorphs; we use ‘two’ for simplicity but polymorph clusters can be larger than pairs. When a first order phase transformation occurs from one phase to the other between low temperature and the melting point, then the two phases are said to be enantiotropically related. If such a phase transformation does not occur then the two phases are monotropically related. A particular chemical substance can show both enantiotropic and monotropic behavior; quartz is one of many examples. The implication of the word ‘same’ is that there is no difference in chemical formula between the two phases. Should a difference in chemical nature (e.g. diamond Sn and metallic Sn) be allowed? These definitions were developed for small-moiety crystallography (including here inorganic crystals and metals) and not much attention has been given to assessing their applicability to biomolecular crystallography. The matter becomes much more complicated when dealing with biological molecules because of the presence of such large quantities of solvent (generally water) in the crystals, as well as ions. Analogous problems can occur with minerals. Polymorphism seen in the context of classical physical chemistry has been reviewed recently (Herbstein, 2004). 2. Isomorphism. Two crystals are defined as isomorphous5 when they crystallize in the same space group, in very similar unit cells and with very similar atomic coordinates. The term ‘‘very similar’’ has not been defined in quantitative terms, although progress, summarized by Dziubek and Katrusiak (2003), has been made in this direction. When the two structures are similar (without defining ‘‘how similar’’) then the two materials are said to be isostructural. Are Cu, Ni and Au isomorphous or isostructural? This question is discussed in Section 10.6.1. Perhaps the best answer is that latitude and flexibility in applying the definitions are preferable to rigidity. 3. Heteromorphism. This term is introduced to cover the situation where different crystals have formula units of the same volume and but different chemical compositions. These are not polymorphs because the different crystals have different compositions. This concept is found to be useful in the three categories of substance discussed here. ‘‘Hetero’’ refers to the different crystal structures and, for oligonucleotides, to different base pair sequences. In a sentence, polymorphism occurs when different crystal structures are found for the same composition, isomorphism when the same crystal structure is found despite differences in composition, heteromorphism when analogous formula units (of the same volume but different chemical compositions) occur in different crystal structures. The keywords ‘‘same’’ and ‘‘different’’ are open to interpretation. 5.3.2 Phase rule relationships In host–guest inclusion complexes, if the host crystal structure (no guest, native) is isomorphous with that of the inclusion complex then the complex is a primary solid solution phase. It is generally not known whether the host:guest ratio is fixed or variable. One example where the host–guest ratio has been shown to cover a wide range is bromine 5
Our distinction between ‘‘isomorphous’’ and ‘‘isostructural’’ is not used by all authors.
144
CRYSTAL CHE MISTRY OF SOME DNA OLIGONUCLEOTIDES
hydrate (Section 7.2.7.4); this is an intermediate phase rather than a primary solid solution. An example of a true primary solid solution is trimesic acid/bromine (Section 8.3.4), but here the composition range has not been established. If the complex and native host are not isomorphous then the host–guest complex is an intermediate phase in the ‘‘binary’’ phase diagram. For understandable reasons, no one seems as yet to have tried to determine a binary oligonucleotide-second component phase diagram, where ‘‘second component’’ is, for example, a drug molecule. 5.3.3
Applications of these concepts
1. Cyclodextrin complexes. A large amount of information is embedded in the tables of Chapter 4. We take the clathrate inclusion complexes of -cyclodextrin as our illustrative example. A herringbone arrangement is found in 15 complexes of Table 4.2. ˚ , space group These complexes are isomorphous with a 9.5, b 14.3 and c 37.5 A P212121, Z ¼ 4; the guests cover a range of chemical types. There is a second group of ˚ , space 10 isomorphous complexes in Table 4.3, with a 13.6, b 15.3 and c 24.5 A group P212121, Z ¼ 4; the guests cover a range of chemical types. That the two groups have the same space group is coincidental. The two groups are heteromorphic, both unit ˚ 3. There are no polymorphs. Both groups are cell volumes being around 51 000 A different intermediate phases in the hypothetical -cyclodextrin/guest/water phase diagram. In the cyclodextrins the host molecule is invariant while the nature (perhaps number) of guest molecules differs from complex to complex, as does the water content, which is sometimes not well established. 2. {Tetraphenylporphyrin-MII(guest)2} complexes. A large amount of information is embedded in the tables of Chapter 8. In the {tetraphenylporphyrin-MII(guest)2} inclusion complexes, the host molecules differ to a small extent because of differing metal ions while the different guest molecules appear to have a greater influence on crystal structure. The chemical compositions of the tetraphenylporphyrin-MII complexes are generally well established. We take the four-coordinate inclusion complexes listed in Table 8.17 as specific examples. The second to the tenth entry in ˚ , 106, 112, Table 8.17 are all isomorphous (a 10.5, b 11.2, c 12.0 A 103 ; Type II triclinic cell (all angles 90 , space group P1, Z ¼ 1). This group is followed by a group of 20, isostructural rather than isomorphous with the first group. These two groups are followed by a third, smaller, group with a Type I triclinic cell (all angles <90 ). This group is heteromorphic to the first two groups, all the unit cell volumes being in the range 1100–1200 A3. Apart from a few exceptions, the metal ions are all ZnII but the guests cover a wide chemical range. There are no polymorphs. 3. Oligonucleotides. A large amount of information is embedded in the tables of this chapter. We treat hexameric, octameric, decameric and dodecameric complexes separately, using as our specific example the dodecameric complexes and native structures listed in Table 5.13, where some forty native dodecamers with different base pair sequences (except for two pairs discussed immediately after Table 5.13) and dodecamers complexed with different guests all crystallize in space group P212121 ˚ 3; these all have (Z ¼ 4), with cell volumes ranging from 60 000 to 70 000 A
I N T E RC AL AT E D HE XANUC L E OT IDE - DR UG COMPLEXES
145
sequences that can be formulated as d(CGCXGCG)2 as discussed later; X represents various different sequences of six base pairs. These dodecamers are all isomorphous. There are also eight native dodecamers (with sequences different from d(CGCXGCG)2 that crystallize in different unit cells, space groups being P1 (2 examples), R3 (3 examples) and one example each for C2, P212121 and P43 (Table 5.14). The triclinic (56761 A3) and rhombohedral (158819 A3) phases of d(ACCGACGTCGGT)2 may be the one true polymorphic pair among the examples of Table 5.14; the ratio of cell volumes is 2.80, which may, or may not, be a small integer. Structural differences among hexameric, octameric, decameric and dodecameric complexes will be demonstrated in the detailed discussion of each group. Among oligonucleotides of a given number of base pairs it is necessary to assess whether the unit cell volumes of different crystal types are the same (modulo a small integer) because this will show, in the absence of better evidence, similarities or differences of chemical composition. However, it is undesirable to label as ‘polymorphs’ those clusters without significant differences in composition but with different base pair sequences. Such clusters are heteromorphic. For a particular oligonucleotide to show true polymorphism both phases must have the same chemical composition, including the same base pair sequence; cell volumes provide a measure of chemical composition in the absence of more definite information. True polymorphism of oligonucleotides appears to be quite rare. One possible example has been given above; another is native d(CCCGCGGG)2. The two polymorphs crystallize in ˚ 3 (Table 5.5)) and P212121 (Z ¼ 4, cell space group P43212 (Z ¼ 8, cell volume 43 880 A 3 ˚ volume 42 479 A (Table 5.7). The similar cell volumes suggest that the chemical compositions may well be the same. Identification of true polymorphism among the cyclodextrin complexes, the tetraphenylporphyrin-MII complexes and the oligonucleotides (native and complexes) should be based on obtaining different phases of the same composition. No one seems as yet to have searched for phase transformations on heating or cooling (but see the intriguing results shown in Fig. 5.21), or tried to establish whether two (apparent) polymorphs are enantiotropically or monotropically related.
5.4 Intercalated hexanucleotide-drug complexes with B-DNA structure An early suggestion that drug molecules could be accommodated between base pairs came from various physico-chemical measurements on the acrdidine proflavine (Lerman, 1961). Denny (2003) writes ‘‘Intercalation is now understood to be the preferred binding mode of virtually any flat polyaromatic ligand of sufficiently large surface area and suitable steric properties.’’ Currently three broad groups of parallel intercalators – the anthracycline derivatives, the nogalamycin derivatives and the 9-aminoacridine derivatives – are known. 5.4.1 The anthracycline drugs The anthracycline (Scheme 5.1) situation has been summarized by Neidle (1997): ‘‘The anthracyclines, of clinical importance as anticancer agents, have a daunosamine-type
146
CRYSTAL CHE MISTRY OF SOME DNA OLIGONUCLEOTIDES
sugar group appended [to the tetracyclic aglycone chromophore], frequently with a charged amine substituent. . . . Almost all [crystallographic studies . . . on exclusively hexanucleotide duplexes] show two drug molecules bound, one at each terminal base-pair site . . . The sugar group is always positioned in the minor groove, with hydrogen bonding, frequently involving water molecules, to atoms on base-pair edges.’’ O
R3
O C R1
D
C
R2
O
B
A
O
O
OH
H H3C
1⬘
O 4⬘ O
NH+3
R5
Daunomycin (¼ daunorubicin) (C27H30NO10); R1¼CH3; R2¼OCH3; R3¼OH; R4¼NH2 (or NH3þ); R5¼H. Adriamycin (¼ doxorubicin); R1¼CH2OH; R2¼OCH3; R3¼OH; R4¼NH2; R5¼H. 4’-Epiadriamycin has inversion of the stereochemistry at the 4 0 (hydroxyl) position of the amino sugar). Idarubicin (¼4-demethoxy-daunorubicin); R1¼CH3; R2¼H; R3¼OH; R4¼NH2; R5¼H. 4-O-demethyl-11-deoxydoxorubicin R1¼R2¼OH; R3¼H; R4¼NH2; R5¼H. MAR70 R1¼CH3; R5¼4 0 -epi-2 0 -deoxyfucose.
H3C HO
NC
N
O 4⬘
1⬘
HO
R4 for various morpholino derivatives of doxorubicin, and acronyms
O
CN-MDox
N
O
MDox
N
O
OCH3 (R)- or (S)-MMDox; methoxy (R)- or (S)
Scheme 5.1
I N T E RC AL AT E D HE XANUC L E OT IDE - D R UG COMPLEXES
147
Table 5.2. Intercalation of anthracycline derivatives in hexameric oligonucleotides with oligonucleotide : drug ratio ¼ 1 : 2. All crystals have distorted right-handed B-DNA-like duplex structures with Watson–Crick base pairs; the common space group is P41212, Z ¼ 8. Dimensions in ˚, A ˚ 3. NDB entries to October, 2004. Structures at RT unless stated otherwise A Hexanucleotide
Intercalated drug
a
c
Cell Volume
NDB ID and Reference
d(CGTACG)283W
Daunomycin
27.86
52.72
40 920
d(CGTACG)2 d(CGTACG)2
adriamycin M-Dox
28.21 28.12
53.19 53.03
42 329 41 873
d(CGTACG)2 d(CGTACG)2 d(CGTACG)2 d(CGTACG)2 d(CGTACG)2
CN-M-Dox (R)-MM-Dox (S)-MM-Dox 4 0 -epiadriamycin MAR70
28.19 28.21 28.11 28.04 28.01
53.32 53.50 53.47 53.15 53.11
42 372 42 576 42 251 41 789 41 668
d(CGTACG)2
28.04
53.36
41 954
d(CGTACG)2
2 0 -bromo-4 0 epidaunorubicin NH2-CH-daunomycin
28.02
52.47
41 195
d(5 0 -CpGpT(NH2) ApCpG-3 0 )2 d(CGATCG)240W
MAR70 HCHO covalent adduct Daunomycin
28.12
52.98
41 893
27.98
52.87
41 391
d(CGATCG)243W at 113K d(CGATCG)243W
Daunomycin
27.85
52.33
40 588
Daunomycin þ spermine
28.11
53.08
41 942
d(CGATCG)2
28.16
53.40
42 165
d(CGATCG)2 at 113K
N-cyanomethyl-N(methoxyethyl)-daunomycin Adriamycin
27.92
52.39
40 839
d(CGATCG)249W
Adriamycin þ spermine
28.21
53.19
42 329
d(CGATCG)235W
idarubicin
28.13
53.68
42 199
d(CGATCG)238W
28.04
53.15
41 789
d(CGATCG)2
4 0 -epiadriamycin (spermine found in major groove) (R)- MM-Dox
DDF001; WUQR87 GLRW90 DDF053; GW95 GW95 GW95 GW95 WFUR90 DDF026; GLL91 DDF065; GPW96 DDFB24; WGLL91 DDFB25; GLL91 DDF018; MHLK89 DDF045; LPZ94 DDF020; FWU90 DD0017; SDM00 DDF044; LPZ94 DDF019; FWU90 DDF029; GW91 DDF022; WFUR90
28.21
53.50
42 576
d(CGATCG)2
(S)- MM-Dox
28.21
53.65
42 695
d(CGATCG)2
4-O-demethyl-11deoxydoxorubicin CN-M-Dox
28.18
53.14
42 079
28.19
53.35
42 396
4 0 -deoxy-4 0 iododoxorubicin
27.73
52.49
40 362
d(CGATCG)250W
d(CGATCG)2
DDF055; GW95 DDF054; GW95 DDF028; GW91 DDF056; GW95; SDM00 DDF062; BSS95
148
CRYSTAL CHE MISTRY OF SOME DNA OLIGONUCLEOTIDES
Table 5.2. (Continued) Hexanucleotide
Intercalated drug
a
c
Cell Volume
NDB ID and Reference
d(CGATCG)2
2 0 -bromo-4 0 epidaunorubicin N-(2-hydroxyethyl)doxorubicin Daunomycin daunomycin
28.09
53.38
42 119
28.13
53.56
42 382
28.05 27.94
53.16 52.24
41 826 40 781
daunomycin
28.07
53.35
42 036
2 0 -bromo-4 0 epidaunorubicin Adriamycin
28.25
53.67
42 832
28.01
52.99
41 574
daunomycin
28.02
52.71
41 384
d(TGTACA)2
4 0 -epiadriamycin
28.02
52.93
41 556
d(TGTACA)2
27.96
52.57
41 097
d(TGATCA)234W
4-O-demethyl-11deoxydoxorubicin 4 0 -epiadriamycin
28.01
52.95
41 542
d(TGATCA)2
Idarubicin
28.19(3)
52.77(4)
41 935
d(TGATCA)2
daunomycin
28.11
52.88
41 784
DDF066; GPW96 DDF078; ECU98 SPS03 DDF023; WGLL91 DDF039; LHM93 DDF068; GPW96 DDF040; LHM93 DDF031; NvM91 DDF035; LBH92 DDF061; BSS95 DDF036; LGBH92 DDF038; GLBH93 DDF032; NvM91
d(CGATCG)2 (dC)(rG)d(ATCG)240W d(CGCGCG)2 d(CGGCCG)2 C84H100N25O44P549W d(CGGCCG)2 d(TGGCCA)2 C85H101N25O44P549W d(TGTACA)2
Notes: Some idea of the progress in this area can be obtained by comparing Dickerson’s five different structures in his Table IV with the 35 entries here. nW is the number of water molecules identified in the structure analysis; this is not necessarily the total water (solvent) content. Comparison of independent duplicate measurements suggests that precision of cell dimensions is a few hun˚. dredths of an A (nA) is 2-aminoadenine; MAR70 is shown in Scheme 5.1; when MAR70 was crystallized with the DNA hexamer d(CGT(nA)CG)2 a covalent methylene bridge was formed between N(3 0 ) of daunosamine and the N(2) of 2-aminoadenine; this spontaneous reaction occurred through the cross linking action of trace amounts of formaldehyde. x Two other d(CGATCG)-dd-MOX crystals were reported (Gao and Wang, 1991). One was orthorhombic, 37.90 ˚ , ¼ 108.1 , ˚ , V ¼ 87 086 A ˚ 3, space group P212121, and the other monoclinic, 26.56 52.81 36.17 A 63.30 36.30 A ˚ 3, space group P2. Structures were not determined. V ¼ 48 223 A References: BSS95 – Berger, Su, Spitzner et al., 1995; ECU98 – Ettore, Cirilli and Ughetto, 1998; FWU90 – Frederick et al., 1990; GLBH93 – Gallois et al., 1993; GLL91 – Gao, Liaw, Li et al., 1991; GLRW90 – Gao, Liaw, Robinson and Wang, 1990; GPW96 – Gao, Priebe and Wang, 1996; GW91 – Gao and Wang, 1991; GW95 – Gao and Wang, 1995; LBH92 – Leonard, Brown and Hunter, 1992; LGBH92 – Langlois d’Estantoin et al., 1992; LHM93 – Leonard, Hambley et al., 1993; LPZ94 – Lipscomb, Peek, Zhou et al., 1994; MHLK89 – Moore et al., 1989; NvM91 Nunn, van Meervelt et al., 1991; SDM00 – Saminadin, Dautant, Mondon et al. 2000; SPS03 – Shi et al., 2003; SS92 – Schuerman, Smith et al., 1996; WFUR90 – Williams, Frederick et al., 1990; WGLL91 – Wang, Gao, Liaw and Li, 1991; WUQR87 – Wang, Ughetto et al., 1987.
I N T E RC AL AT E D HE XANUC L E OT IDE - DR UG COMPLEXES
5⬘
C1 G12
149
3⬘
14
G2 C11 T3 A10 A4 T9 C5 G8 13 3⬘
G6 C7
5⬘
Fig. 5.5. Schematic side view of the d(CGTACG) complex with intercalated anthracycline drug molecules marked as 13 and 14. The drug molecule is seen down its long axis. The increase in spacing of the upper and lower two base pairs is shown schematically, as are the different hydrogen bonding schemes within the base pairs. The amino sugar portion of the drug is located in the minor groove. This diagram can be considered to be a more detailed version of Fig. 5.2. (Adapted from Wang, Ughetto et al., 1987).
The first structure to be determined was that of the {d(CGTACG)-daunomycin} complex (Quigley, Wang et al., 1980; Wang et al., 1987). 83 water molecules were located and a hydrated sodium ion was found to coordinate with daunomycin and guanine; subsequent structure determinations (Moore, Hunter, Langlois d’Estantoin and Kennard, 1989; Frederick, Williams et al., 1990) were in good agreement. Although spermine is essential for crystallization, no spermine molecule could be located and it is possible that it is disordered in the large solvent channels along [001]; the crystals contain about 40% solvent. Other hexameric oligonucleotides complexed with anthracycline drugs (Scheme 5.1) are isomorphous (Table 5.2). Despite the overall resemblances, there are differences among the various complexes that have been illustrated and discussed in considerable detail (e.g. Moore, Hunter et al., 1989; Frederick, Williams et al., 1990); the reader is referred to the original papers. The asymmetric unit is composed of one hexameric oligonucleotide strand and one drug molecule, together with associated water molecules and metal ions. The helical rise ˚ , compared to 3.5 A ˚ at normal sites. The amino sugar lies at the intercalation sites is 5 A in the minor groove, forming hydrogen bonds to the solvent molecules (Fig. 5.5). Structurally one finds two anthracycline drug molecules bound to each hexameric oligonucleotide duplex, with the three-ring planar chromophore intercalated at the CpG steps at both ends of the duplex; one could call this the structural unit, with a volume of about ˚ 3. Irrespective of the base-pair sequence and the nature of the anthracycline,6 the 10 500 A ˚ 3; the isocomplexes all have unit cell volumes between about 40 000 and 43 000 A morphism holds despite differences in base pair sequence and guest identity. Almost forty tetragonal complexes are listed in Table 5.2; as yet there are few examples of analogous complexes crystallizing in other space groups. One example is {d(CGTACG)– 2[3 0 -desamino-3 0 -(2-methoxy-4-morpholinyl)-doxorubicin]}, which is triclinic (P1, Z ¼ 1, ˚ 3; NDB-ID DDF041; Cirilli, Bachechi et al., 1993). Two other unit cell volume 8878 A examples are given in the Notes to Table 5.2. The differences in structural-unit volumes 6
Within the limits of Table 5.2.
150
CRYSTAL CHE MISTRY OF SOME DNA OLIGONUCLEOTIDES
Fig. 5.6. Stereodiagram of the d(CGATCG)-daunomycin complex viewed along the twofold axis into the minor groove. Open and filled bonds are used for DNA and daunomycin respectively. The atoms are shown as spheres of decreasing radius in the order P > O > N > C. (Reproduced from Moore, Hunter et al., 1989.)
3/8
3/8 1/4
1/4
1/4
1/4 1/8
1/8
1/4
1/4 1/8
1/8 1/4
1/4
1/4 3/8
1/4 3/8
Fig. 5.7. Schematic view down [001] shows the packing arrangement of the DNA-drug complexes in the unit cell with space group P41212. The molecular twofold axis coincides with the crystallographic twofold axis at z ¼ 0, which runs diagonally across the square. The two complexes, stacked end-toend along the two fold screw axis in the [001] direction, are related by the twofold axis at z ¼ 1/4. The solvent channels are in the areas near the 41 axes. The dashed circles represent end views of the elongated hexamer-drug complexes. (Reproduced from Wang, Ughetto et al., 1987.)
I N T E RC AL AT E D HE XANUC L E OT IDE - DR UG COMPLEXES
151
are about 10% and may suggest that the various crystals have different (solvent) compositions rather than being heteromorphs. The {(hexamer duplex)2(daunomycin)} complex is shown as a ball-and-stick stereopair in Fig. 5.6 and as a schematic packing diagram in Fig. 5.7. The molecules ˚ and height 26.5 A ˚. can be roughly represented as cylinders of diameter 20 A These cylinders, whose axes lie along [001], are approximately close packed in two dimensions. 5.4.2 Nogalamycin and derivatives Nogalamycin and derivatives (Scheme 5.2) also belong to the anthracycline family of antibiotics and are active against a number of tumor lines. However, difficulties in administering the drugs have discouraged clinical trials. Nevertheless, interaction of nogalamycins with DNA has remained of interest. Crystal structures of a number of hexanucleotide-nogalamycin complexes have been described (Table 5.3).
R1
R2
Nogalamycin
COOCH3
CH3
Disnogalamycin
H
CH3
U-58872
COOCH3
CHO
H
R2
OH
N+ H3C aminoglucose (positively HO charged) H3C
O
O
O
R1 OH
D
C
R2
O
B
A
O
O
CH3
H H3C
O
H3CO OCH3
Scheme 5.2
nogalose (neutral) OCH3
152
CRYSTAL CHE MISTRY OF SOME DNA OLIGONUCLEOTIDES
Table 5.3. Intercalation of nogalamycin or derivatives in hexameric oligonucleotides (some modified); duplex:nogalamycin ratio is 1 : 2. All crystals have distorted right-handed B-DNA-like ˚, A ˚ 3. Chemical formulae in duplex structures with Watson-Crick base pairs. Dimensions in A Scheme 5.3. (pS) indicates that the phosphate group at the TpA step. has been replaced by phosphorothioate. [m5C] is 5-methylcytosine (5-MeC is also used). Structures at RT unless stated otherwise Hexameric oligonucleotide
Intercalated drug
a
b
c
V
NDB ID; Reference
Tetragonal P41212, Z ¼ 8 d(TGATCA)2 at 150K
nogalamycin 37.29 37.29 71.12
98 895 DDF049, 052, 063; SST96
Orthorhombic P212121; Z ¼ 4 d(TGTACA)2 at 150K
nogalamycin 26.30 51.98 67.08
91 703 DDF064; SBM96
Orthorhombic C2221; Z ¼ 8 d(CGT(pS)ACG)2
nogalamycin 22.98 47.27 64.44
69 999 LGR89
Hexagonal; P61 Z ¼ 6 d([m5C]GT(pS)A[m5C]G)2 d([m5C]GT(pS)A[m5C]G)2
nogalamycin 26.31 26.31 100.26 60 104 GLRW90 U-58872 26.27 26.27 100.23 59 903 GLRW90
Hexagonal; P6122; Z ¼ 6 d([m5C]GT(pS)A[m5C]G)239W nogalamycin 26.30 26.30 100.01 59 908 WEG90 References: GLRW90 – Gao, Liaw, Robinson and Wang, 1990; LGR89 – Liaw, Gao, Robinson, van der Marel, van Boom and Wang, 1989; SBM96 – Smith, Brannigan and Moore, 1996; SST96 – Schuerman, Smith, Turkenburg, Dettmar, Van Meervelt and Moore, 1996; WEG90 – Williams, Egli, Gao, Bash, van der Marel, van Boom, Rich and Frederick, 1990.
The hexamer-duplex/drug ratio is 1 : 2 in all the crystals. The asymmetric units of the orthorhombic and P61 hexagonal modifications contain two hexanucleotides, two nogalamycins, two hydrated magnesium ions and 113 water molecules. The P61 hexagonal modification approximates to P6122 symmetry and, under different crystallization conditions, a higher symmetry modification with this space group is obtained, where one strand of the DNA duplex and one drug molecule form the asymmetric unit. 39 water molecules were located. The DNA-drug interaction in both hexagonal and orthorhombic modifications has been described as follows by Liaw, Gao et al. (1989): ‘‘two nogalamycins bind to the DNA double helix in a 2 : 1 ratio with aglycon chromophore intercalated between the CpG steps at both ends of the helix. The nogalose and aminoglucose sugars lie in the minor and major grooves, respectively, of the distorted B-DNA double helix.’’ The hexagonal structures suggest that the volume per formula unit is about ˚ 3, which does not fit the unit cell volumes obtained for the tetragonal and 10 000 A orthorhombic structures. The packing in the tetragonal [d(TGATCA)–nogalamycin} complex has been shown by Smith, Davies, Dodson and Moore (1995) (Fig. 5.8; a somewhat different view is given by Schuerman et al. (1996); their Fig. 4). In overall terms Fig. 5.8 is remarkably similar to the analogous figure for the d([m5C]GT(pS)A[m5C]G)2 hexagonal P61 modification (Fig. 5.9).
I N T E RC AL AT E D HE XANUC L E OT IDE - DR UG COMPLEXES
153
a
Fig. 5.8. Partial view of the packing diagram of the P41212 crystal form of the nogalamycin/ ˚ ), d(TGATCA) complex, seen approximately along [101]. There are four layers along [001] (¼ 71 A which is horizontal in the diagram. (Reproduced from Smith, Davies, Dodson and Moore (1995).)
A
B
c/6
Fig. 5.9. Packing diagram of the P61 crystal form of the nogalamycin/d([m5C]GT(pS)A[m5C]CG) complex. The complexes are stacked end-over-end along a (and b) axes to form a sheet. One of these ˚ ). The packing of the sheets along the c direction sheets is shown in A, viewed down the c axis (100 A is shown in B; the thiophospho group abuts adjacent complexes. There are six sheets along the c axis. (Reproduced from Gao, Liaw, Robinson and Wang, 1990.)
154
CRYSTAL CHE MISTRY OF SOME DNA OLIGONUCLEOTIDES
In both structures there are layers of hexamer-drug complex moieties in (001) planes, with four layers along [001] in the tetragonal complex and six in the hexagonal complex. However, the hexagonal and orthorhombic phases are not accepted as heteromorphs because they do not have the same chemical composition as inferred from the unit cell volumes. The relation between the P61 and P6122 phases is not entirely clear; perhaps a small composition difference accompanies the small symmetry difference. The distortion of the hexamer duplex consequent on the intercalation is greater than that found in the anthracycline drug complexes – hence, a fortiori, the hexamer-nogalamycin phases are separate phases in the DNA-drug system.
5.4.3
The 9-aminoacridine drugs
The 9-aminoacridine-4-carboxamide class of compounds were originally explored as part of a broad attempt to develop acridune derivatives as anticancer drugs. Because these compounds exist as dications under physiological conditions, they are tight binding DNA intercalating agents. They are also potent cytoxins. This general background comes from Denny (2003). NH2
5
N H2
H
R O
N H
R=
H CH3 N+ CH3
R = HN +
H2
9-amino-[N-(2-methylamino)ethyl]acridine4-carboxamide
Morpholino-9-amino-[N-(2-methylamino)ethyl] acridine-4-carboxamide
Scheme 5.3
The structures listed in Table 5.4 are isomorphous. The asymmetric unit (using the 9-amino-DACA complex as example) consists of a single strand of the hexanucleotide, one intercalated 9-amino-DACA molecule, 27 ordered water molecules and, on a crystallographic two fold axis, an additional ‘end-stacked’ 9-amino-DACA molecule (necessarily disordered) and two water molecules. No metal atoms or spermine appeared. Thus the composition is {(hexamer duplex)3(9-amino-DACA)}. The two strands of DNA
I N T E RC AL AT E D HE XANUC L E OT IDE - DR UG COMPLEXES
155
Table 5.4. Intercalation of 9-aminoacridine derivatives in hexameric oligonucleotides. All crystals have distorted right-handed B-DNA-like duplex structures with Watson-Crick base pairs; the ˚, A ˚3 common space group is P64, Z ¼ 6. Dimensions in A Hexanucleotide
Intercalated drug
a
c
Cell Volume NDB ID; Reference
d(CGTACG)2 at 110K d(CGTACG)2 at 110K d(CGTACG)221W at 110K d(CGTACG)221W at 110K d(CG5-BrUACG)2 at 110K d(CCTAGG)2 at RT
9-amino-DACA
30.16
39.69
34 336
morpholinyl
30.239 39.340 34 214
5-fluoro-9-amino-DACA* 30.14
39.40
34 040
5-bromo-9-amino-DACA* 30.19
39.44
34 188
DD0015; AGCDW99 DD0048; AGDW02 DD0023; AGCDPW00 DD0051; TTT
6-bromo-9-amino-DACA
30.087 39.316 33 848
TATDWC99
cryptolepine
29.96
DD0047; LCP02
39.65
33 848
Notes: 9-amino-DACA is 9-amino[N-(2-dimethylamino)ethyl]acridine-4-carboxamide morpholinyl is 9-amino-N-(2-(4-morpholinyl)ethyl)acridine-4-carboxamide cryptolepine is 5-methyl indolo[2.3b]-quinoline * occupancies of drug molecules appear to be appreciably less than 1. References: AGCDW99 – Adams, Guss, Collyer, Denny and Wakelin, 1999; AGCDPW00 – Adams, Guss, Collyer, Denny, Prakash and Wakelin, 2000; AGDW02 – Adams, Guss, Denny and Wakelin, 2002; LCP02 – Lisgarten, Coll, Portugal et al., 2002; TATDWC99 – Todd, Adams, Thorpe, Denny, Wakelin and Cardin, 1999; TTT – Teixera, Thorpe, Todd et al., to be published (DD0051).
are related by a dyad axis and form a right-handed DNA duplex with Watson–Crick base pairing. The intercalated 9-amino-DACA molecule is located between each of the CpG base pair steps with its side chain in the major groove. The additional 9-aminoDACA molecules on the two fold axis stack at the ends of each DNA helix and link one duplex to the next by hydrogen bonds to form a continuous column of duplexes in the ab plane (Fig. 5.10). Because the 9-aminoacridine complexes have both drug molecules intercalated in the hexameric duplexes and additional drug-molecules between the duplexes, these complexes are separate phases in the hexamer-drug system. ˚ 3, somewhat The volume of the asymmetric unit in these complexes is about 5 700 A larger than the value obtained for the P6122 nogalamycin complex of Table 5.2; in both examples the asymmetric unit contains a single strand of the hexamer – whether these are heteromorphs remains moot. A partial view of the packing arrangement is shown in Fig. 5.10. Layers of molecules are formed, one layer being shown in Fig. 5.10 together with the space group symmetry elements which enable one to complete the packing diagram. Successive layers along [001] are obtained by operation of the 31 screw axis.
156
CRYSTAL CHE MISTRY OF SOME DNA OLIGONUCLEOTIDES
B A
A B
Fig. 5.10. One layer of {d(CG5-BrUACG)2(6-bromo-9-amino-DACA)} projected down the [001] axis, looking directly into the major groove. The space group is P64 and the symmetry elements are shown. The helix axis of the duplex is along [100] and is intersected by a two fold axis along [001]. A and B are the intercalated and ‘‘end stacked’’ DACA molecules respectively. (Adapted from Todd, Adams, Thorpe, Denny, Wakelin and Cardin, 1999.)
5.4.4
Native hexanucleotides and comparison of crystal structures
The B-DNA structure of the native hexanucleotide d(CTCGAC)2 has been reported ˚, (Wahl, Rao and Sundaralingam, 1996; BDF068). The hexagonal crystals (40.14, 44.47 A ˚ 3, P6222, Z ¼ 6) show an A-DNA like conformation at the termini of V ¼ 62052 A the duplex. The volume per asymmetric unit is much the same as for the crystals of the various sequences complexed with a variety of drug molecules (Table 5.2) but the two types of hexanucleotide are not isostructural. A native hexanucleotide derivative Rp-d(Gp(S)CpGp(S)CpGp(S)C), where ‘‘p’’ represents a phosphate group and ‘‘p(S)’’ a phosphorothioate group, crystallizes in a modification not yet encountered ˚ , V ¼ 23201 A ˚ 3, Z ¼ 4, P212121) elsewhere (orthorhombic, 34.90, 39.15, 20.64 A (Cruse, Salisbury et al., 1988). This is more densely packed than d(CTCGAC)2, as is shown in Fig. 5.11. The helical duplexes, considered as quasi-cylinders, are approximately close packed. The principal interactions are between cations and phosphate and phosphorothioate groups. Strand 1 of the duplex interacts mostly with symmetry-related strand 1* and similarly for strand 2. A number of possible hydrogen bonds were located.
I N T E RC AL AT E D HE XANUC L E OT IDE - DR UG COMPLEXES
157
Fig. 5.11. Stereodiagram of the packing arrangement in Rp-d(Gp(S)CpGp(S)CpGp(S)C), viewed down the [001] axis, which coincides with the helix axis. The solvent molecules are shown as open circles. 72 solvent molecules, of the approximately 143 in the asymmetric unit, have been located; some of these may be sodium or magnesium ions. (Reproduced from Cruse, Salisbury et al., 1988.)
Another native hexanucleotide has a Z-configuration – indeed it was the prototype of the Z configuration (Wang, Quigley, et al., 1979); this is not relevant for comparison with the B-DNA hexamers considered here. Would a hypothetical native B-DNA hexamer be expected to be isomorphous with the complexes listed in Table 5.2? Probably not, in view of the large perturbation of the hexameric duplex by the two intercalated drug molecules. If so, then the complexes are not to be classified as solid solutions but rather as separate phases in the binary hexamer– drug phase diagram. The packing arrangements in the anthracycline drug complexes differ from those in the nogalamycin and 9-aminoacridine complexes. In the anthracycline drug complexes the quasi-cylindrical molecules have their long axes along the [001] axis of the space group, leading to approximate close packing of parallel cylinders. In the hexagonal nogalamycin and acridine complexes the quasi-cylindrical molecules are arranged in the basal plane, and the layers of cylinders are arranged along the [001] axis by the operation of 31 and 64 screw axes respectively. The packing in the tetragonal and orthorhombic crystals does not appear to have been described in detail. The versatility of the d(CGATCG)2 base pair sequence should be noted. This forms some 15 isomorphous tetragonal complexes with different daunomycin-type guests (Table 5.2), monoclinic and orthorhombic crystals with dd-MOX as guest (Notes to Table 5.2), a triclinic 1 : 2 complex with 3 0 -desamino-2 0 -(2-methoxy-4-morpholinyl)daunomycin, (NDB-ID DDF041; Cirilli et al., 1993) and isomorphous hexagonal complexes with various 9-amino-DACA derivatives (Table 5.4). It is not known whether other base pair sequences behave similarly.
158
5.5
CRYSTAL CHE MISTRY OF SOME DNA OLIGONUCLEOTIDES
Isomorphism and polymorphism of A-DNA octanucleotides and the binding of spermine
The self-complementary octanucleotide d(ACGTACCG)2, where the asymmetric unit is a single strand of octamer, together with about 20 water molecules, crystallizes in space group P43212 (Table 5.5). The two octamer strands are related by a crystallographic twofold axis to form a right handed duplex. Among other differently sequenced octanucleotide duplexes crystallizing in the same space group are d(GCCCGGGC)2 (Heinemann et al., 1987), d(ATGCGCAT)2 (Clark et al., 1990), d(GTCTAGAC)2 (Cervi et al., 1992) and d(GTGCGCAT)2 (Bingham et al., 1992). The brominated analog d(ACGTACC[5 BrU])2 is isomorphous, as is the spermine complex of the differentlysequenced d(GTGTACAC)2. spermine di[!-aminopropyl]-tetramethylene diamine C10H26N4 H2N–(CH2)3–NH–(CH2)4–NH–(CH2)3NH2 spermidine
!-aminobutyl-!-aminopropylamine C7H19N3 H2N–(CH2)3–NH–(CH2)4–NH2
Scheme 5.4 Formulae of spermine and spermidine
Table 5.5. The group (space group P43212, Z ¼ 8) of isomorphous tetragonal octanucleotides, mostly native but with two examples of spermine complexation. The crystals have distorted right˚, A ˚ 3. Struchanded A-DNA-like duplex structures with Watson-Crick base pairs. Dimensions in A tures at RT unless stated otherwise Octanucleotide
Intercalated molecule
a
c
Cell Volume
NDB ID; Reference
d(CCCCGGGG)2
native
43.36
24.83
46683
d(CCCGCGGG)2 d(GCCCGGGC)2 d(GGCCGGCC)2 d(GGCCGGCC)2 d(GGCCGGCC)2 d(GGGCGCCC)2
265K 288K 255K 293K
native native native native native native
41.77 43.25 42.06 42.04 40.51 43.28
25.15 24.61 25.17 25.09 24.67 24.66
43880 46035 44527 44343 40485 46192
d(GGGCGCCC)2 at 115K
native
42.74
24.57
44882
d(GTGCGTAC)2 d(GTCTAGAC)2 d(GTGTACAC)243W d(CCCTAGGG)2 d(CTCTAGAG)2 d(GTACGTAC)2
native native spermine native native native
42.22 42.56 42.43 42.22 42.52 42.50
25.07 24.41 24.75 24.90 24.33 24.79
44688 44215 44558 44382 43892 44777
ADH012; HSWR87 ADH056; ES90 ADH0106; FSV97 ADH008; HLFB87 ADH013; WFBR82 ADH058; ES95 ADH098; WFBR82 ADH026; RHES88; SGGEFR89 ADH027; ADH057; EHHFSR88; SGGEFR89 ADH047; BLZS92 ADH041; CLH92 ADH014; JZS89 ADH078; TS96 ADH020; HLK89 ADH023; CDH90
at at at at
ISOMORPHISM AND POLYMORPHISM OF A-DNA OCTANUCLEOTIDES
159
Table 5.5. (Continued ) Octanucleotide
Intercalated molecule
a
c
Cell Volume
NDB ID; Reference
d(GTACGTAC)2 at RT d(ACGTACC[5-BrU])283W at 100K; C72H81BrN30O32P7 d(ACGTACGT)2 d(ATGCGCAT)243W d(ATGCGCAT)243W
native native
42.32 43.597
25.04 26.268
44 846 49 927.5
ADH024; T90 TAP99
native native spermine
42.84 42.41 42.53
24.80 24.90 24.92
45 515 44 785 45 075
ADH070; WACW96 ADH033; CBS90 ADH032; CBS90
References: BLZS92 – Bingham, Li, Zon and Sundaralingam, 1992; CBS90 – Clark, Brown, Sanderson, Chwalinski, Neidle, Veal, Jones, Wilson, Garman and Stuart, 1990; CDH90 – Courseille, Dautant, Hospital, Langlois d’Estaintot, Precigoux, Molko and Teoule, 1990; CLH92 – Cervi, Langlois d’Estaintot and Hunter, 1992; EHHFSR88 – Eisenstein, Hope, Haran, Frolow, Shakked and Rabinovich, 1988; ES95 – Eisenstein and Shakked, 1995; FSV97 – Fernandez, Subirana, Verdaguer et al. 1997; HLFB87 – Heinemann, Lauble, Frank and Blo¨cker, 1987; HLK89 – Hunter, Langlois d’Estaintot and Kennard, 1989; HSWR87 – Haran, Shakked, Wang and Rich, 1987; JZS89 – Jain, Zon and Sundarlingam, 1989; RHES88 – Rabinovich, Haran, Eisenstein and Shakked, 1988; SGGEFR89 – Shakked, Guerstein-Guzikevich, Eisenstein, Frolow and Rabinovich,1989; T90 – Tagusagawa, 1990; TAP99 – Todd, Adams, Powell, Wilcock, Thorpe, Lausi, Zanini, Wakelin and Cardin, 1999; WACW96 – Wilcocks, Adams, Cardin and Wakelin, 1996; WFBR82 – Wang, Fujii, van Boom and Rich, 1982.
Both phases of true polymorphs of oligonucleotides must have the same chemical composition, including base pair sequence (known from the method of preparation). True polymorphism of oligonucleotides appears to be quite rare; native d(CCCGCGGG)2 is one of the few examples encountered among the oligonucleotides considered here. The two polymorphs crystallize in space group P43212 (Z ¼ 8, cell volume ˚ 3 (Table 5.7; ˚ 3 (Table 5.5; ADH0106)) and P21212 (Z ¼ 4, cell volume 42 479 A 43 880 A ADH103–5). The similar cell volumes suggest that the chemical compositions may well be the same. The octamer d(CGCTAGCG) crystallizes in two forms – orthorhombic (P212121, 24.77 ˚ , cell volume 119 187 A ˚ 3, 3 duplexes and 34 waters in the asymmetric unit) 41.52 115.89 A ˚ ˚ 3, four duplexes in the asymand hexagonal (P61, 48.7 115.9 A, cell volume 238 052 A metric unit) (Tereshko, Urpi et al., 1996). The structure of the first of these has been reported but not (yet) that of the second, although the comment was made that the packing in the two forms was very similar. As the ratio of the cell volumes is 1 : 2, the two forms could well be polymorphs. We first consider the behaviour of the octanucleotides as a group and then discuss the sub-groups in more detail. Six different groups of isomorphous crystals have been reported: ˚ 3; tetragonal, P43212, 18 examples; unit cell volume 44 000 A 3 ˚ ; hexagonal A, P61, 7 examples, unit cell volume 80 000 A ˚ 3; hexagonal B, P6122, 3 examples, unit cell volume 72 000 A ˚ 3; trigonal, R3, 1 example, unit cell volume (hexagonal cell) 230 000 A orthorhombic A, 4 examples (all with the same base pair sequence) P212121, unit cell ˚3 volume 41 000 A ˚ 3). 6. orthorhombic B, P21212, 1 example, unit cell volume 42 000 A 1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
160
CRYSTAL CHE MISTRY OF SOME DNA OLIGONUCLEOTIDES
Table 5.6. Two different groups of isomorphous hexagonal octanucleotides (space groups P61 and P6122, both Z ¼ 6) and one trigonal group (space group R3), all native. The crystals have distorted right-handed A-DNA-like duplex structures with Watson-Crick base pairs. All of the known P61 structures are of sequence d(GGX4CC) with the four central bases comprising C, G, A, T, U and I. ˚, A ˚ 3. Structures at RT unless stated otherwise. Note that, in contrast to Table 5.3, Dimensions in A the P61 and P6122 structures here are quite different Octanucleotide Hexagonal A P61, Z ¼ 6 d(GGGGCCCC)2 d(GGGATCCC)2 d(GGGTACCC)2 d(GGGTACCC)2 at 100K d(GGGTGCCC)2 d(GGTATACC)2 d(GGCATGCC)2 d(GG[BrU]A[BrU]ACC)2
Intercalated molecule
a
c
Cell Volume
NDB ID; Reference
Native (1) native native native
45.32 46.83 46.80 46.06
42.25 44.49 44.52 44.09
82 530 84 494 84 446 81 006
ADH006; ADH007; ADH030; ADH031;
native native native native
45.62 44.97 46.29 45.05
40.99 41.76 42.97 41.72
81 133 80 056 79 739 73 425
RHES88 ADH010; SRK85 ADH076; NN97 SRC81; SRK85; DB89
32.40 32.18 32.34
79.25 78.51 78.49
72 048 70 409 71 093
ADH078; JS89 ADH038; TLBS93 ADH039; TLBS93
Hexagonal B P6122 Z ¼ 6 d(GTGTACAC)2 Native (2) d(GTGTACAC)2 From spermine (2) d(GTGTACAC)2 From spermidine (2)
MBK85 LFBH88 EFSR90 EFSR90
Notes: 1. 106 ordered solvent molecules were found around each double helix; if a density of 1.5 g cm3 is assumed, then there should be another 260 disordered solvent molecules per asymmetric unit. See Fig. 5.14 for the d(GTGCGCAC)2 packing diagram. 2. These three crystals are essentially identical; neither spermine nor spermidine was detected in the structure analysis. The best results were for the crystal grown in the presence of spermine. References: CLH92 – Cervi, Langlois d’Estantoit and Hunter, 1992; DB89 – Doucet, Benoit, Cruse, Prange and Kennard, 1989; EFSR90 – Eisenstein, Frolow, Shakked and Rabinovich, 1990; JS89 – Jain and Sundaralingam, 1989; LFBH88 – Lauble, Frank, Blo¨cker and Heinemann, 1988; MBK85 – McCall, Brown and Kennard, 1985; NN97 – Nunn and Neidle, 1997; RHES88 – Rabinovich, Haran, Eisenstein and Shakked, 1988; SRC81 – Shakked, Rabinovich, Cruse, Egert, Kennard, Sala, Salisbury and Viswamitra, 1981; SRK85 – Shakked, Rabinovich, Kennard, Cruse, Salisbury and Viswamitra, 1985; TLBS93 – Thota, Li, Bingham and Sundaralingam, 1993; TS96 – Tippin and Sundarlingam, 1996.
The tetragonal, hexagonal A, orthorhombic A and orthorhombic B unit cell volumes ˚ 3; the hexagonal B and trigonal unit cell volumes are are all around 43 000 or 80 000 A related by a factor of 3, but do not fit with the first group. It seems reasonable to infer that there are two separate groups of nominally heteromorphic structures – one comprising tetragonal, hexagonal A, orthorhombic A and orthorhombic B, and the second hexagonal B and trigonal. The orthorhombic A group has been noted by its investigators (Fernandez et al., 1997) as showing an unusual spread in cell dimensions. Also, the same sequence (d(CCCGCGGG)2) crystallizes in tetragonal (ADH0106;
ISOMORPHISM AND POLYMORPHISM OF A-DNA OCTANUCLEOTIDES
161
Table 5.7. Two different groups of isomorphous orthorhombic octanucleotides; the space groups are P212121 and P21212; both Z ¼ 4. All crystals have distorted right-handed A-DNA-like duplex ˚, A ˚ 3. Structures at RT unless stated structures with Watson-Crick base pairs. Dimensions in A otherwise Octanucleotide
Intercalated drug
a
b
c
V
NDB code and Reference
Orthorhombic A P212121; Z ¼ 4 d(CCCGCGGG)2 native d(CCCGCGGG)2 native d(CCCGCGGG)2 native d(CCCGCGGG)2 native
21.84 23.13 23.14 24.63
35.40 40.82 40.12 40.59
41.17 42.52 41.90 42.49
31 830 40 146 38 899 42 479
ADH0102; ADH0103; ADH0104; ADH0105;
Orthorhombic B P21212; Z ¼ 4 native d(GTACGTAC)2
38.60
50.82
21.74
42 227
ADH059; LDCP93
FSV97 FSV97 FSV97 FSV97
References: FSV97 – Fernandez, Subirana, Verdaguer, Pyshnyi, Campos and Malinina, 1997; LDCP93 – Langlois d’Estantoit, Dautant, Courseille and Precigoux, 1993.
A13
A13
T12
T12 T4 A5
T4 A5
Fig. 5.12. Stereopair of the d(GTGTACAC)2spermine complex, viewed into the major groove down the dyad axis. The bonds of the spermine are emphasized. This is hexagonal B structure ADH039 (Table 5.6). (Reproduced from Jain, Zon and Sundaralingam, 1989.)
Table 5.5) and orthorhombic A (ADH0105; Table 5.7) structures with cell volumes of ˚ 3 and 42 479 A ˚ 3 respectively. Here the difference fits the usual behavior of 43 800 A polymorphic phases. Another same-sequence pair (GTACGTAC) crystallizes as tetragonal and orthorhombic B forms; these could also be a pair of polymorphs. The two structures have been compared in detail by Langlois d’Estantoit, Dautant, Courseille and Precigoux (1993). One marked difference is in the bend angle of the duplexes in
162
CRYSTAL CHE MISTRY OF SOME DNA OLIGONUCLEOTIDES
the different environments – this is 69 in the tetragonal form and 39 in the orthorhombic B form. The sequence d(ATGCGCAT)2 forms isomorphous tetragonal native (ADH033) and spermine-complex (ADH032) crystals; tetragonal d(GTGTACAC)2 forms only a spermine complex (ADH014; Table 5.5). The hexagonal B d(GTGTACAC)2 sequence forms isomorphous native, spermine and spermidine complexes (Table 5.6; Fig. 5.12). In all these examples, there is no obvious effect of complexation on cell dimensions; the guests were found by structure analysis. The spermine (spermidine) complexes are isomorphous with the native duplexes and thus should be considered as primary solid solution phases. It is not known whether the (relative) spermine content can range from zero (native duplex) to one (maximum spermine content of isomorphous complex). Some interesting features appeared in the first structure determination in this area – that of tetragonal d(GGCCGGCC)2 by Wang, Fujii et al., 1982; Table 5.5. The detailed conformation of the duplex was temperature dependent, approximating more closely to B-DNA at 265K and to A-DNA at 255K (Fig. 5.13). This is a theme that has resonated since the early papers, and composition (base pairs and formation of complexes), sequence, hydration state and environment are now recognized as important factors in determining the details of oligonucleotide structures (Shakked, 1991). Our discussion uses primarily information from cell dimensions and space groups but much more detailed studies based on information gleaned from crystal structures
Minor groove
Minor groove A–DNA
a
–8°C
–18°C
b
c
8–DNA
d
Fig. 5.13. (upper row) Space filling diagrams of four DNA models, all with the sequence GGCCGGCC; the P and O atoms are emphasized. The helix axis is vertical, and a horizontal twofold axis is located in the plane of the paper; (lower row) skeletal views down the helix axis. The complexes are tetragonal, space group P43212, details in Table 5.5. (Reproduced from Wang, Fujii et al., 1982.)
ISOMORPHISM AND POLYMORPHISM OF A-DNA OCTANUCLEOTIDES
163
is becoming available. An example is the study of hydration patterns and intermolecular interactions in the isomorphous tetragonal octameric A-DNA complexes with sequences GGGCGCCC (at 293 and 115K), GGCCGGCC, CCCCGGGG and GCCCGGGC (Eisenstein and Shakked, 1995). We quote from the Abstract: ‘‘The A-DNA major groove is extensively hydrated and together with the hydration shells of the sugar–phosphate backbone can form an ordered network of fused polygons. The water structure of the phosphate backbone is less conserved than that of the grooves. Characteristic hydration patterns are associated with specific base sequences. The A-DNA minor groove provides sites for intermolecular contacts through hydrophobic and polar interactions. Well-ordered water molecules mediate interduplex interactions that involve either the grooves or the backbone, or both. The direct and water-mediated intermolecular interactions observed in the A-DNA crystal structures are relevant to various recognition motifs between DNA and other molecules.’’
Fig. 5.14. The arrangement of d(GTGCGCAC) duplexes in the tetragonal crystal (space group no. 96, P43212) projected down the [001] axis. The elliptical solvent channels run along the vertical ˚ in cross-section; these are filled with solvent molecules 21 axes and are approximately 20 10 A that are not shown. The only direct interaction between neighboring duplexes involves the abutment of the terminal base pairs of one molecule against the sugar phosphate backbone of symmetry related molecules. Note that ‘‘fourfold axis’’ in the original caption should be replaced by ‘‘twofold axis’’. (Reproduced from Wang, Fujii et al., (1982)).
164
CRYSTAL CHE MISTRY OF SOME DNA OLIGONUCLEOTIDES
c
b
a
Fig. 5.15. Projection of the structure of d(GG(BrU)A(BrU)CC)2 down [001] axis (hexagonal A, Table 5.6). The octamer crystallizes in space group P61 with one double helix in the asymmetric unit. The octamers have the A-DNA conformation with 10.9 base pairs per turn, a mean tilt ˚ . Consideration of the angle of 18 and an average separation between base pairs of 3.4 A diffuse scattering shows that the channels contain a me´lange of water molecules and B-DNA. A companion diagram of the isomorphous d(GGGGCCCC)2 given by McCall, Brown and Kennard (1985) (not reproduced here) shows six octameric molecules in an infinite spiral viewed in projection down the 61 screw axis. (Reproduced from Doucet, Benoit, Cvruse, Prange and Kennard (1989).)
Table 5.8. Two different crystal types of 1:2 octamer–distamycin complexes. All crystals have distorted right-handed B-DNA-like duplex structures with modified Watson-Crick base pairs. Structures at RT unless stated otherwise Octameric oligonucleotide
Intercalated drug
a
c
V
Tetragonal P4122, Z ¼ 8; asymmetric unit contains one DNA strand, one distamycin molecule and one Mg cation d(ICICICIC)2 distamycin 27.93 58.62 45 729 d(ICATATIC)2 distamycin 27.86 58.62 45 500 d(ICITACIC)2 distamycin 28.03 58.04 45 601 d(IcICICIC)2 distamycin 27.92 57.70 44 979 d(IcIcICIC)2 distamycin 27.93 57.47 44 799
NDB code / Reference
GDHB25; CRRS94 GDLB50; CRS97 GDLB51; CRS97 CRS95 CRS95
ISOMORPHISM AND POLYMORPHISM OF A-DNA OCTANUCLEOTIDES
165
Table 5.8. (Continued ) Octameric oligonucleotide
Intercalated drug
a
b/
c
V
Monoclinic I2; Z ¼ 2; asymmetric unit contains one DNA strand and one distamycin molecule d(ITITACAC)236W distamycin 28.30 25.05 29.14 19 509 109.2 distamycin 28.11 25.33 30.88 20 491 d(ICATATIC)2 111.26
NDB code / Reference
DD0043; DPS03 GDLB49; CRS97
Notes: Lower case letters represent RNA residues. The unit cells are given for the two I2 structures; these are isomorphous. The space group used in the original publication was C2.
OH N
N
N
N
CH2OH
O H
H HO
OH
I is inosine (hypoxanthine riboside) References: CRRS94 – Chen, Ramakrishnan, Rao and Sundaralingam, 1997; CRS95 – Chen, Ramakrishnan and Sundaralingam, 1995; CRS97 – Chen, Ramakrishnan and Sundaralingam, 1997; DPS03 – Deng, Pan and Sundaralingam, 2003.
Exceptionally, the packing arrangement has been discussed in some detail for this group of isomorphous tetragonal complexes (Table 5.5). Analogous packing diagrams have been given by Bingham, Li, Zon and Sundaralingam. (1992) and Wang, Fujii et al. (1982; their Fig. 3 reproduced in Fig. 5.14). The packing in the hexagonal A family (Table 5.6) is shown in Fig. 5.15; the arrangement of spirals of octameric duplexes should be compared with the left hand diagram in Fig. 5.20 showing a spiral arrangement of decanucleotides. The synchrotron diffraction patterns from d(GG[BrU]A[BrU]ACC)2 have both a (sharp) Bragg and a diffuse component (Doucet, Benoit, Cruse, Prange and Kennard, 1989); the Bragg pattern gives an arrangement of A-DNA helices isomorphous with the other structures in Table 5.6 while the diffuse pattern was only compatible with a disordered array of B-DNA helices contained in the A-DNA framework These replace about 10%
166
CRYSTAL CHE MISTRY OF SOME DNA OLIGONUCLEOTIDES
of the water molecules found in the other structures. These unusual results were interpreted to show that ‘‘under certain conditions of crystallization the A and B conformations of the same DNA fragments can co-exist in the highly hydrated environment of the crystal lattice.’’ Indeed the arrangement described could be classified as a tunnel inclusion complex (Chapter 6), with some resemblance to neat selenourea. Some octanucleotides form minor-groove binding complexes with the natural antibiotic distamycin (Scheme 5.5). Two different crystal types (tetragonal, and monoclinic) have been found (Table 5.8). The molecular structure of the complex is shown in Fig. 5.16; both phases have essentially the same host-guest structure. The asymmetric unit in the monoclinic crystals consists of one octamer strand and one distamycin molecule; in the tetragonal crystals one double helix and two distamycin molecules. The distamycin complex of d(ICATATIC)2 crystallizes in the two space ˚3 groups P4122 and C2 (Fig. 5.17 a and b), with cell volumes of 45 500 and 20 747 A respectively; the ratio is 2.2 and it is possible (but not certain) that the two phases are heteromorphs.
Fig. 5.16. Stereodiagram of the 1 : 2 d(ITITACAC)2 complex with distamycin, showing the antiparallel side-by-side arrangement of the two distamycin molecules in the minor groove (monoclinic, Table 5.8). Complexed hairpin dimers have been shown by Kielkopf et al. (1998) (see Fig. 5.19). An example of a single propamidine molecule in the minor groove of the dodecameric d(CGCGAATTCGCG)2 duplex is shown in Fig. 5.21. (Reproduced from Deng, Pan and Sundaralingam, 2003.)
MI NOR GR OOVE BI NDE RS
167
(a)
(b)
Fig. 5.17. Stereo diagrams for (a) the tetragonal d(ICITACIC)2 structure (GDLB51) and (b) the monoclinic B d(ICATATIC)2 structure (GDLB49). The tetragonal crystals, viewed down [010] contain Mgþþ(H2O)6 cations, appearing in the form of asterisks. These ions are absent from the monoclinic crystals. This supports the conclusion from comparison of cell volumes that these two modifications are not heteromorphs (see text). The tetragonal crystals have sheets of quasi-cylindrical complex molecules in (004) planes with residual channels containing disordered solvent molecules. In the monoclinic B crystals the molecules are arranged in sheets on (011) planes. (Reproduced from Chen, Ramakrishnan and Sundaralingam, 1997.)
5.6 Minor groove binders 5.6.1 Drug molecules that enter the minor groove The general background has been given by Tidwell and Boykin (2003) and Moravek, Neidle and Schneider (2002); as noted earlier, in principle molecules can bind to either the major or minor grooves of DNA, the major groove being the binding site for many DNA interacting proteins while the minor groove is suited to small molecule binding. The oligonucleotides that complex with minor groove binders are decamers and dodecamers. These are considered separately – the decamers present a rather complex and diffuse
168
CRYSTAL CHE MISTRY OF SOME DNA OLIGONUCLEOTIDES
pattern of structures, while the pattern for dodecamers – native species and complexes alike – is much more compact. We first group together in Scheme 5.5 the minor groove binders that have been reported. The curved profile of these molecules, adapted to the general shape of the Scheme 5.5. Drug molecules that enter the minor groove N N R
N
2O
N
H
OR1
H H3C
N+
R2 =
R1 = H Hoechst 33 258
H
R1 = ethyl
Hoechst 33 342
N R1 = H Compound 16 N H NH2
H
+ H2N
NH2
N 6
4⬘
+ NH2
DAPI 4⬘,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole
CH3
O
N Guanidinium O
amide 2 N
N
CH3
H N H amide 1
N
H
Netropsin
O H
N
Amidinium NH2
H2N
+
+
amide 3 NH2
NH2
MI NOR GR OOVE BI NDE RS
CH3
169
O
N N N
O
CH3
N
H
N O
H N
N NH2 +
+
H2N
H
H Imidazole-Pyrrole Lexitropsin
NH2
NH2 CH3
O
N
amide 3 N
O
CH3
N
H N
amide 2
H H
N
Distamycin O
amide 4 +
amide 1 N
O
NH2
NH2
H H
Naturally occurring netropsin has two pyrrole rings; the guanidinium head at the left and the amidinium tail at the right are both positively charged. Imidazole-pyrrole lexitropsin is identical to netropsin except that the left pyrrole ring has been replaced by imidazole. Distamycin has an uncharged –CHO head on the left and charged amidinium tail on the right. (after Goodsell, Ng et al., 1995).
O
O R
NH2
H2N +
+ NH2
R = trimethylene; propamidine R = pentamethylene; pentamidine H2 C
R = gamma-oxa-pentamidine C H2
H2 C O
C H2
NH2
170
CRYSTAL CHE MISTRY OF SOME DNA OLIGONUCLEOTIDES
H N
N N H2N
NH2
berenil +
+
NH2
NH2
O NH2
H2N +
+ NH R
R = H; furamidine R = ethyl; BEF R = isopropyl; BIPF R = cyclopropyl; BCPF
HN R
N N N H3N+
N H
N H N
TRIBIZ N H
O H3C
minor groove, is quite striking. Aromatic diamidines have broad spectrum effectiveness against a range of microbial species. However, so far only pentamidine, despite some negative features, has found clinical use. For reasons of space we hardly consider situations where the drug is covalently linked to the oligonucleotide (e.g. Kopka, Goodsell, Baikalov et al., 1994).
MI NOR GR OOVE BI NDE RS
imidazole Im1 H N
hydroxy-pyrrole Hp2 pyrrole Py3
O H N
N
171
N H
O
H N
N H
amide Am1
OH
amide Am2
pyrrole Py4 O
H N R
N H amide Am3
O R= N H
O
HN + N H
CH3 CH3
ImHpPyPy Dp The polyamide sequence shown is ImHpPyPy Dp where is -alanine and Dp is dimethylaminopropylamide. The other guest is ImPyPy Dp (i.e. hydroxyl of Hp2 replaced by H).
5.6.2 Decameric oligonucleotides The decameric oligonucleotides present a rather complicated structural picture, summarized some years ago by Dickerson, Goodsell and Kopka (1996) for fourteen examples. At the time of writing (October, 2004) some twenty-odd decameric structures have been reported (including one complex) and they are found in six different groups (Table 5.9). ˚, 1. Nine are in a monoclinic cell, space group C2, Z ¼ 2, a 32.3, b 25.5, c 34.4 A 3 ˚ ¼ 113 , V ¼ 26 000 A , with one strand per asymmetric unit. This has been termed the CG family by Quintana, Grzeskowiak et al. (1992); decamers with the sequence type CCARxxYTGG tend to belong to this group. ˚ , V 54 000 A ˚ 3, 2. Two are in space group P212121, Z ¼ 4, a 36.6, b 42.5, c 34.7 A with one helix per asymmetric unit. The native and drug complex pair are isomorphous so the drug complex is a primary solid solution phase. There are two di-imidazole lexitropsin drug molecules side-by-side in the minor groove. 3. Four are in another orthorhombic cell, space group P212121, Z ¼ 4, a 38.9, b 39.4, ˚ , V ¼ 51 000 A ˚ 3, with one helix per asymmetric unit. This has been termed c 33.3 A the KK family by Quintana, Grzeskowiak et al. (1992); decamers with the sequence type CGAxxxxTCG tend to belong to this group.
˚,A ˚3 Table 5.9. Decameric oligonucleotides; all crystals are distorted right-handed B-DNA-like duplexes with Watson-Crick base pairs. Dimensions in A Decameric Oligonucleotide
Drug in the minor groove
Group I: monoclinic, C2, Z ¼ 2; CQ family Native d(CCAGGCCTGG)2, Native, from d(CCAACITTGG)2, 248K Ca2þ solution native d(CCAAGATTGG)2, d(CCAACGTTGG)2, native native d(CCAACGTTGG)2, native d(CCAGTACTGG)2, d(CCAGCGCTGG)2, native native d(CCAAIATTGG)2, d(CCAGGCCTGG)2, native Group II: orthorhombic, P212121, Z ¼ 4 d(CATGGCCATG)2, native d(CATGGCCATG)2, di-imidazole lexitropsin Group III: orthorhombic, P212121, Z ¼ 4; KK family native d(CGATCGATCG)2, d(CGATTAATCG)2, native
a
b/
c
Cell Volume
NDB ID/Reference
31.25 31.87
25.49 116.7 25.69 114.1
34.82 34.21
24 779 25 833
HA89 LKK93
32.52 32.25 32.00 31.73 32.24 32.21 32.15
26.17 25.53 25.37 25.79 25.35 25.14 25.49
34.30 34.38 33.63 34.22 34.19 34.14 34.82
25 556 25 978 26 737 27 022 26 933 25 116 25 490
PHC87; PYD91 PYD91; YPD91 BD0033; CD00 BD0023; KDKR00 BD0035; CD00 BD0055; LLKKD BDJ017; HA89
36.60 36.65
42.49 42.64
34.69 34.68
53 948 54 196
BDJ051; CKCD93 GDJ054; KGH97
38.93 38.60
39.36 39.10
33.30 33.07
51 025 49 911
BDJ025; GYPD91 BDJ031; QGYD92
118.9 113.4 112.98 116.9 117.17 114.70 116.71
d(CGATATATCG)2, d(CGATATATCG)2,
Native (Ca) Native (Mg)
38.76 38.69
40.06 39.56
33.73 33.64
52 373 51 489
YQD92; BDJ036 BDJ037; YQD92
Group IV: hexagonal, P6, Z ¼ 6 d(CCAGGC[5-MeC]TGG)2 d(CCAAGCTTGG)2
native Native (Ca)
53.77 53.08
53.77 53.08
39.35 34.32
98 527 83 741
HA91, HH92 BDJ052; GGK93
Group V: hexagonal, P61, Z ¼ 6 d(CCAAGCTTGG)2
native
45.32
45.32
42.25
75 151
MBK85
Group VI: trigonal, P3221, Z ¼ 6 d(CGATCG(5-MeA)TCG)2 d(CCATTAATGG)2 d(CCACTAGTGG)2 d(CCAACITTGG)2
native native native Native (Mg)
33.38 33.20 32.90 33.23
33.38 33.20 32.90 33.23
98.3 96.04 95.10 94.77
94 001 91 677 89 146 90 628
BGY93 BDJ055; GKD94 BDJ061; SG-G94 LKK93
References: BGY93 – Baikalov, Grzeskowiak, Yanagi, Quintana and Dickerson, 1993; CD00 – Chiu and Dickerson, 2000; CKCD93 – Goodsell, Kopka, Cascio and Dickerson, 1993; GKD94 – Goodsell, Kaczor-Grzeskowiak and Dickerson, 1994; GYPD91 – Grzeskowiak, Yanagi, Prive´ and Dickerson, 1991; GGK93 – Grzeskowiak, Goodsell, KaczorGrzeskowiak, Cascio and Dickerson, 1993; HA89 – Heinemann and Alings, 1989; HA91 – Heinemann and Alings, 1991; HH92 – Heinemann and Hahn, 1992; KDKR00 – Kielkopf, Ding et al., 2000; KGH97 – Kopka, Goodsell, Han, Chiu, Lown and Dickerson, 1997; LKK93 – Lipanov, Kopka, Kaczor-Grzeskowiak, Quintana and Dickerson, 1993; LLKDD – Lisgarten, Lipanov, Kopka et al., to be published; NDB BD0055; MBK85 – McCall, Brown and Kennard, 1985; PHC87 – Prive´, Heinemann, Chandrasegaran, Kan, Kopka and Dickerson, 1987; PYD91 – Prive´, Yanagi and Dickerson, 1991; QGYD92 – Quintana, Grzeskowiak, Yanagi and Dickerson, 1992; SG-G94 – Shakked, Guzikevich-Guerstein et al., 1994; YPD91 – Yanagi, Prive´ and Dickerson, 1991; YQD92 – Yuan, Quintana and Dickerson, 1992.
174
CRYSTAL CHE MISTRY OF SOME DNA OLI