CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
CREOLE LANGUAGE LIBRARY (CLL) A companion series to the "JOURNAL OF PIDGIN & CREOLE LANGU...
14 downloads
876 Views
16MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
CREOLE LANGUAGE LIBRARY (CLL) A companion series to the "JOURNAL OF PIDGIN & CREOLE LANGUAGES"
Editors Pieter Muysken (Amsterdam) John Victor Singler (New York)
Editorial Advisory Board Mervyn Alleyne (Kingston, Jamaica) Norbert Boretzky (Bochum) Lawrence Carrington (Trinidad) Chris Corne (Auckland) Glenn Gilbert (Carbondale, Illinois) John Holm (New York)
George Huttar (Dallas) Salikoko Mufwene (Chicago) Peter Mühlhäusler (Adelaide) Pieter Seuren (Nijmegen) Norval Smith (Amsterdam)
Volume 18
Geneviève Escure Creole and Dialect Continua Standard acquisition processes in Belize and China (PRC)
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA STANDARD ACQUISITION PROCESSES IN BELIZE AND CHINA (PRC)
GENEVIEVE ESCURE University of Minnesota
JOHN BENJAMINS PUBLISHING COMPANY AMSTERDAM/PHILADELPHIA
The paper used in this publication meets the minimum requirements of American National Standard for Information Sciences — Permanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials, ANSI Z39.48-1984.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Escure, Geneviève. Creole and dialect continua : standard acquisition processes in Belize and China (PRC) / Geneviève Escure. p. cm. - (Creole language library, ISSN 0920-9026 ; v. 18) Includes bibliographical references (p. ) and index. 1. Creole dialects. 2. Dialectology. 3. Language acquisition. 4. Sociolinguistics. 5. Gram mar, Comparative and general-Syntax. 6. Pragmatics. 7. English language-Social aspectsBelize. 8. Chinese language-Social aspects. I. Title. II. Series. PM7831.E74 1997 417'.22-dc21 97-4278 ISBN 90 272 5240 8 (Eur.) / 1-55619-173-1 (US) (alk. paper) CIP © Copyright 1997 - John Benjamins B.V. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form, by print, photoprint, microfilm, or any other means, without written permission from the publisher. John Benjamins Publishing Co. • P.O.Box 75577 • 1070 AN Amsterdam • The Netherlands John Benjamins North America • P.O.Box 27519 • Philadelphia PA 19118-0519 • USA
Acknowledgments This book is first a tribute to the people of Belize, and more particularly the Creoles of Placencia and the Garifuna of Seine Bight, who shared with me their joie de vivre, and their love of language. There is no space here to thank all the men and women who opened their doors and inner lives to make me feel wel come. I especially want to acknowledge the warm friendship and support pro vided in Placencia by the Lopez family (Miss Cordelia, Clarence, Therese and Errol), Miss Tila (Athelo) Cabrai, Herbert, Miss Doris, Miss Lucille, Miss Sonia, Miss Tensy, Miss Pearl, Miss Lizzie, Blink, Dudu, Bobo, Captain Morgan, Peter, Karim, Philip, and all the pikni (many of them are now adults) especially Verna, Karen, Dennis, Dean, Edward, Chrissie,and Grayson. Special thanks to Errol who assisted me with the fieldwork in Placencia. This is also a tribute to the Seine Bight Garifuna. It was thanks to Mr. Flores, who has now passed away, that I discovered Seine Bight and, later, Placencia. We became friends during the long bus ride from Punta-Gorda, and he invited me to his distant home across the lagoon from Mango Creek. Had he not extended such warm hospitality, I would probably have bypassed the Placencia peninsula, then totally isolated from the main road from Punta-Gorda to Belmopan and Belize-City. My old friend Roman Zuniga also passed away. He was my Garifuna teacher, and he shared with me his humor and his pride in his people's, traditions and language. Little Mark, who at fourteen spoke Garifuna, Creole, Maya, and Kekchi was my most reliable guide in the bush of Toledo District. I cannot possibly mention the names of all the individuals who befriended me, showed me how to dive for conch and lobster, gut a fish, bake cassava bread, or invited me for fish and fufu. They were Creole, Garifuna, Maya, Kekchi, or Mestizo, in Orange Walk, Dangriga, Hopkins, Georgetown, Punta-Gorda, Barranco, San Antonio, Sartineha, Benque Viejo, Caye Caulker, and Belize-City. They instilled in me a profound love of Belize and its diverse people. In China too, I met warm and friendly people in the rural areas as well as
vi
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
in the crowded cities. I gratefully acknowledge the cooperation and open-mindedness of the officials and professors at Huazhong Central University of Science and Technology in Wuhan, especially Cheng En Hong, Lei Guo Pu, and Mu Li Ya, who invited me to teach a stimulating group of teachers for an entire acad emic year, and at subsequent times, and gave me the opportunity to travel freely and get to know China better than if I had been a mere tourist. I owe a lot to my students, many of whom became my friends. They taught me a great deal about the sociolinguistic situation in China. Particular thanks to Chen Kairong, Cheng Kola, Deng Shan, Guan Xiangyang, Liu Lichun, Peng Yuanchu, Tan Xiangyun, Wan Youzhong, Wang Qunying, Zou Hong, and final ly to Zhang Xianping who gave me the opportunity to give lectures in his dis tant Hubei hometown of Xianfan. I fondly remember the enthusiastic welcome I received at Xianfan University. I also benefitted from a summer teaching at Tsinghua University in Beijing. Thanks to Lu Ci and Wu Guohua for their hos pitality, and mostly to Chun-Jo Liu for her initiative in organizing the summer program. I gained a deep appreciation of the people and linguistic diversity of China mostly through chance encounters. Strangers went out of their way to help me when I got desperately lost in Chengdu—unable to get the right bus because of my difficulties with tonal differences; they bought tickets for me in the crowd ed train stations of Wuhan, Shanghai or Kunming; and they offered me tea on dusty Tibetan roadsides. Those strangers were kind to me; they saw me as a per son, not as an alien (the distrusted waiguoren), and they contributed to human izing the anonymous crowds of the Middle Kingdom. During long train rides across the People's Republic, I pored over my Chinese notebooks, trying to figure out a language survival kit that would enable me to achieve basic communication in diverse linguistic areas. A novice learner relating new knowledge to old knowledge, and looking for shortcuts, it occurred to me that Chinese syntax is very much like Creole syntax. Thus ger minated the idea of a comparison of Chinese and Creole structures. However, bringing the project to completion was as lengthy, hazy, and rocky as a train ride in a smoky "hard seat" compartment. None of this work would have been possible without the steady support of the University of Minnesota Graduate School, that provided leaves, research assistants, and limited but steady financial support. I also acknowledge occa sional contributions from the English Department. I am particularly grateful to J. Lawrence (Larry) Mitchell, for his encouragements to pursue my interest in nonstandard varieties, as well as to Sandy MacLeish for his positive attitude and moral support. All my thanks also to the various students and research assistants who discussed issues with me, and helped me transcribe data: Gail Ostrow, Dennis Dougherty, Chao Shoushing, Mao Luming, Ding Ersu, Guan
vii
Xiangyang, Angela Karstadt, and most of all Anna Fellegy, who provided invaluable scholarly comments and editing help in the final stages of the mansucript. Ï hold a deep appreciation of Pieter Muysken's encouragements and patience. Chris Corne has my special thanks because he gave me the confi dence to push onwards by providing helpful critical comments on the first part of the manuscript. I also acknowledge the help of Chun-Jo Liu in reading and commenting on parts of the Chinese sections. In the last stages, the detailed contributions of the reviewers, Stephen Matthews and Virginia Yip were extremely helpful in sharpening issues in the book and relating my findings to current developments in the field of Chinese sociolinguistics. Finally, many friends and colleagues helped in indirect ways, in particular as contributors to the meetings of the Society for Caribbean Linguistics, the Society for Pidgin and Creole Languages, and the Institut d'Etudes Créoles.
Contents Acknowledgments
v
I.
Introduction: Developmental continua 1. General issues in linguistic change 2. Aspects of acquisitional studies 3. The linguistic analysis of nonstandard dialects 4. Creoles and noncreoles
1 1 3 10 18
II.
The Belizean speech community and the use of English 1. Introduction to the history of Belize 2. Ethnolinguistic composition and census data 3. The language situation 4. Focus on the Stann Creek district 5. Conclusion
25 25 28 36 43 55
III. Creole acroiects as innovations 1. Radical creoles, postcreoles, and decreolization 2. Acroiects and standard dialects: Social aspects 3. Acroiects and standards: Linguistic aspects 4. Conclusion
57 57 65 73 86
IV. The interaction of syntax and pragmatics in acroiects: Topic marking 89 1. Syntax and discourse features 89 2. Types of topic strategies 94 3. Distribution of topic strategies 103 4. Comparison with American English 117 5. Pragmatic aspects of syntax 120 6. Conclusion 122 V.
Sociolinguistic perspectives on Chinese 1. Chinese 2. Aspects of the linguistic history of China 3. Main subgroups of "Chinese" 4. The reform of Mandarin: Guanhua, Guoyu, Putonghua
125 125 130 135 139
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA 5. Varieties of Mandarin outside Beijing: Wuhan 6. Wu varieties and Suzhou Wu 7. Conclusions
ix
144 146 148
VI. Topic mechanisms in Chinese: An overview 1. Introduction 2. Topic fronting 3. Topic repetition 4. Topic presentation 5. Summary of topic strategies
151 151 156 163 166 182
VII. Literary and colloquial Putonghua 1. The Putonghua corpus: Methodology 2. Literature and the Cultural Revolution: Two New Friends 3. Literature after the Cultural Revolution: The Matchmaker 4. Beijing colloquial Putonghua 5. Overview of topic strategies in Beijing Putonghua
185 185 188 202 209 219
VIII.Topic strategies in varieties of Putonghua as second dialects 1. Introduction 2. Putonghua spoken in Wuhan 3. Comparison of Beijing and Wuhan Putonghua 4. Wu Chinese 5. Comparison of native and non-native varieties of Chinese 6. Conclusions: Toward a universal view of topic processes
223 223 224 239 243 258 260
IX. Conclusions: Pragmatic universals in second dialect acquisition 1. Patterns of topic marking: Summary 2. Topic marking in the Belizean continuum 3. Patterns of topic marking in Chinese 4. Dialect versus standard: Sociolinguistic universals 5. Conclusions 6. Postscript: Directions for education
263 263 265 271 273 285 286
Bibliography
289
Index
303
Chapter 1 Introduction: Developmental Continua Abstract The issue of dialect acquisition is compared to other types of linguistic developmental continua, including second language acquisition. The impact of social attitudes on language development is examined in various communities, as such attitudes may affect the acquisition of standard varieties by speakers of nonstandard varieties. Methods and models for the analysis of language in spontaneous discourse are dis cussed, and the linguistic units selected are illustrated. A combination of sociolinguistic methodology and functional grammar appears to be the best suited to this study. Finally, I present a justification of the proposed comparative study of a creole context (Belize) and a noncreole context (China). 1. General issues in linguistic change Language is an essential element of practically every human activity, yet its flexible and adaptive nature in social communication is largely ignored, and even denied, by its users. Despite the advances made in linguistics over the last fifty years, most speech communities cling to general normative attitudes toward language, believing that it is (or at least should be) static, monolithic, homogeneous, and primarily preserved, perhaps further refined, by scholarly experts, academicians, writers, and educators. While linguistic change is rec ognized, it is deplored as contributing to the deterioration of "pure" linguistic norms. Pop grammarians contribute to this prevailing view, claiming to correct the process of disintegration by denouncing the solecisms or barbarisms com monly attributed to the poorly educated and the younger generations. In fact, the popular view that blames change on specific social factors and age groups effectively signals a general awareness that linguistic change is highly depen dent on such factors. Correlating social and linguistic factors for explanations of language
2
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
change is a relatively recent target in linguistics. The search for factors that motivate linguistic change has been applied to many areas of language study. Language change is most evident in such areas as historical linguistics, native language acquisition, second language acquisition, pidginization, and creolization which are all characterized by developmental continua—dynamic levels or stages which are not separated from each other by clear boundaries. In contrast to the early structuralist view that synchronic and diachronic processes were not comparable, there has been increasing awareness of the potential structural sim ilarities existing between different types of developmental continua. Such lin guists as Meillet (1921) and Martinet (1955) already emphasized the regularity of change, commonly referred to by structural linguists as the Uniformitarian Principle. According to that view, the same mechanisms which operated in the past can be observed in contemporary variation,' mostly because integrated rule systems are considered to be stable and to change or borrow only in the direc tion of "linguistic drift" or native tendencies. Sociolinguistic methodologies seem to reflect and endorse this approach in their use of apparent time (gener ational studies) and real time (longitudinal studies) to document linguistic change (Labov 1972a; 1972b). Recently, attempts have been made (Andersen 1983; Muysken & Smith 1986) to compare second language acquisition (SLA) to pidginization, creolization (Valdman 1983), and decreolization (Rickford 1983; Schumann 1978; Stauble 1978; Andersen 1983); first language acquisition, as well, has been compared to creolization/pidginization (Bickerton 1981). Nevertheless, there is still no clear consensus as to the nature of the structural similarities linking those developmental continua and the reasons motivating the use of operating principles in language development. According to Bickerton (1981:238) . . .no real connection exists between SLA and creolization: they differ in almost every particular. SLA is done alone, creolization is done in groups; SLA has a tar get, creolization hasn't; SLA is done mainly by adults, creolization mainly by kids; SLA gives you a second language, creolization gives you a first There is, however, general agreement that the adoption of formal princi ples does not operate in a vacuum but that it is linked to practical aspects of the learning situation, such as available linguistic input, psychosocial motivation, and historical factors. For some linguists, "the history of a language is a func tion of the history of its speakers" (Thomason & Kaufman 1991:4). Proponents of the imperfect second language learning hypothesis as applied to pidgins and creoles say that they display features of "interlanguage systems," such as invari ant verb forms, a lack of determiners, the use of demonstratives as determiners, the invariable placement of the negator in preverbal position, the use of adverbs to express modality, a fixed single word order, a lack of inversion in questions,
INTRODUCTION: DEVELOPMENTAL CONTINUA
3
and a reduced or absent nominal marking (den Besten, Muysken, & Smith 1995:97-98). In the search for a better understanding of the principles instrumental in language development, I will focus on two types of linguistic situations which can be characterized as subtypes of second dialect acquisition. Specifically, I will examine the acquisition of standard varieties of a language by speakers of the nonstandard varieties of that same language, with special attention to 1) a creole continuum (Caribbean) and 2) a non-creole situation involving extensive dialect variation (Chinese). The advantages of comparing similar phenomena in obviously distinct contexts are multifold and can be summarized as presenting the following possibilities: 1. 2.
3.
4.
the formulation of cross-linguistic generalizations in studies of acquisition, particularly as they apply to oral discourse; an inquiry into general social attitudes toward marginalized groups, and how this behavior affects the development and use of language varieties produced by those groups; the observation of the interaction of three primary language components— semantics, syntax, and pragmatics—in spontaneous oral communication; and an evaluation of the putative uniqueness of creole languages.
2. Aspects of acquisitional studies Although a substantial amount of linguistic research has been devoted to code switching phenomena between languages, and to second language acquisition (SLA) primarily by adults, relatively little attention has been given to the mech anisms underlying second dialect acquisition (SDA); yet, this type of acquisi tion is undoubtedly more widespread for the simple reason that dialect variation is universal. Whereas not all individuals find themselves in social situations which require the acquisition of a second language, there is no single human being whose repertoire is limited to only one language variety, style, or dialect. Furthermore, unlike second languages, second dialects are typically acquired earlier in life and continue to be acquired throughout adult life.1 Second dialect (usually standard) acquisition is often perceived to be an ambiguous, undefined linguistic process. In West Indian contexts, such learning situations have been characterized as those in which the standard to be learned is neither a native lan guage nor a foreign language (Craig 1971:376; Stewart 1964). SLA research has primarily focused on the analysis of acquisitional steps, particularly on errors occurring in the course of that process. Various mecha nisms have been hypothesized to account for "imperfect learning" and the mis-
4
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
interpretation of linguistic input, which results in the learner's unstable interlanguage continuum; the mechanisms include language transfer due to native language interference, overgeneralization, simplification, and the operation of universal strategies put into motion when linguistic input is deficient (McLaughlin 1987). Errors are usually traced to conflicts between the phono logical or morphosyntactic systems of the two codes in contact (the native ver sus the target model). The learnability of certain features is accounted for by markedness relations, a theory asserting that a language is easier to learn if it contains more unmarked features than the learner's native language. Jakobson (1940) first introduced this mode of interpretation which points to correlations between the development of phonological features in first language acquisition, aphasic loss, and the patterning of phonological inventories across languages (see also Ellis 1994). Recent attempts to identify types of contact-induced linguistic change distinguish between two main mechanisms of interference, obviously relat ed to acquisitional patterns: "interference that results from imperfect group learning during a process of language shift, and interference that results from borrowing, by native speakers of a language, of features of some other language with whose speak ers they are in contact" (Thomason & Kaufman 1991:212). A more focused group of studies have investigated non-native varieties of English (the New Englishes) examining the relationship between the acquisition of such varieties and claims made by theories of language acquisition and change, such as error analysis, mother tongue interference, and markedness theory (Williams 1987). For example, Platt (1991:376) considers English in Singapore as "a kind of fossilized interlanguage [which] became a lingua franca in the English-medium schools among students whose home language might be one of the Chinese dialects, an Indian language or Malay." He shows that many features of Colloquial Singapore English (articles, copula use, tense and number marking) suggest Chinese influence (Chinese constitutes 76% of the population of Singapore), especially from Hokkien, the dominant Chinese dialect. However, a recent investigation of reported language use and identity in Singapore docu ments the effects of the 1987 compulsory bilingual education policy, which made English the medium of education and required the study of a second "eth nic" language (Mandarin, Malay, or Tamil). At the same time, the Singaporean government discouraged the use of Chinese "dialects," such as Hokkien, enforcing a "Speak Mandarin" policy. Results indicate that English is increas ingly used and that, among the majority Chinese group, there is a generational shift in reported identity from Chinese (especially specific Chinese group iden tity such as Hokkien, Cantonese, or Hakka) to Singaporean (Hvitfeldt & Poedjosoedarmo 1995). One may wonder to what extent these attitudes are affecting Singlish, and more specifically, whether Chinese substratal compo-
INTRODUCTION: DEVELOPMENTAL CONTINUA
5
nents are yielding to other features. Another New English acquired as a second language, Kenyan English is displaying mother tongue interference which reflects the learners' ethnic group. The Kikuyu show evidence of a liquid (1/r) phonological merger in their use of Kenyan English, whereas the Luo use affricates but no alveolar fricatives in their version of English. Both features echo native African features of Kikuyu or Luo (Schmied 1991:429). A similar distinctiveness linked to native language is found in Liberian English, a New English which happens to be integrated into a recognized creole continuum and similar to situations existing in other parts of Africa and in the Caribbean. Singler (1991:558), in his investigation of plur al marking in Liberian English, indicates that plural marking in Kru Pidgin English, whose speakers have Kru as a first language, is neither identical to plural marking in Liberian Interior English, whose speakers have Mande as a first language, nor to plural marking in Settler English, spoken by the descen dants of Black American immigrants to Liberia in the nineteenth century. The traces left by the native or ancestral language in the newly developed, typically contact-induced, variety are commonly referred to as substratai influ ences, which reflect the lower status of the speakers of the new language. On the other hand, any influence of the linguistic component traceable to the social ly dominant group is called superstrata!. Theories of genesis will be briefly dis cussed in chapter two, and a comprehensive presentation of existing approaches appears in Alleyne (1980), Arends et al. (1995:9-10; 99-109), Holm (1988), and Muysken & Smith (1986). Finally, pedagogically-driven research has focused on the identification of strata, or stages in the West Indian learning situation (and more particularly in Jamaica and Trinidad), and the implications for English-teaching methods (Bryan 1996; Christie 1983; Craig 1966; 1980; 1996; Pollard 1996; Roberts 1983; 1988; Shields-Brodber 1989). The important issue of the practical applications of lin guistic research to social change will be discussed in chapter nine. 2.1 Universalist explanations of acquisition One of the major explanatory approaches to issues of acquisition involves uni versalist explanations of the human language learning capacity. Chomsky's Universal Grammar (UG) provides innateness as an explanation for cross-lin guistic similarities. This theory postulates that all humans are biologically equipped with a language faculty that permits the generation of general lin guistic principles. The language faculty is available at birth and becomes acti vated when input is insufficient ¿o provide a full model of the target grammar, which is typically the case in first language acquisition. Grammar development consists of the setting of parameters for the specific language being learned. For
6
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
UG-proponents, the study of a child's language development is a sufficient basis for the research and testing of language universals, and external factors, such as communicative needs and social interaction requirements, are consid ered irrelevant. The "Bioprogram Hypothesis," a version of UG introduced by Bickerton (1981), incorporates special reference to the emergence of language universals in pidgin and creole languages, a case of first language acquisition. The latter develop rapidly in contact situations in which speakers evolve a new system without the benefit of an already existing model, thanks to the resources of their innate linguistic ability. Bickerton's genetic view allows for some social input, since demographic, historical, and sociopolitical elements are necessarily involved in the genesis of pidgins, but he fails to include systematic reference to daily interactive needs. Assuming that Chomsky and Bickerton are right about the existence of a language faculty in the brain, there may be other types of universals dependent on external factors, in addition to the commonalities which depend on the inter nal properties of the language faculty (Butterworth, Comrie, & Dahl 1984). Internal and external explanations can be distinguished as follows: Cognitive and psychological explanations involve formal operations that the human mind can vs. cannot accommodate. . .while pragmatic or sociolinguistic explanations involve (formal?) operations that a human society or individual within a society can vs. cannot accommodate. . . (Hyman 1984:68). Muysken & Veenstra (1995:121-134) summarize universalist models applied to pidgins and creoles, identifying two types of universals: procedural universals (referring to universal properties of processes such as L2 learning, grammaticalization) and constitutive universals which designate the properties resulting from those processes (e.g.,TMA systems or word order). These prin ciples and their applications in acrolects will be further discussed in subsequent chapters. In view of the previous attempts at understanding language acquisition and change in various contexts, the question is open as to whether linguistic com monalities, internal or external, also emerge in the acquisition of second lan guages, such as pidgins and creoles, and second dialects, such as acrolects or standard varieties acquired by native speakers of nonstandard varieties. Clearly, the issue must be differentiated from first language acquisition, as presented by Chomsky and Bickerton, since learners of a second dialect or language already possess a native linguistic system which interacts with the target system (either causing errors, transfers, interferences, markedness patterns, or substratai and superstratal influences, according to existing theories). If there are contactinduced linguistic universals, how can they be differentiated from language-
INTRODUCTION: DEVELOPMENTAL CONTINUA
7
specific influences? In which language components are they more likely to be identified? These questions and their applications in acrolects will be further discussed in subsequent chapters. 2.2 The acquisition of second dialects The interpretations outlined above could conceivably be applied to other types of acquisitional situations of the "dialectal" type, especially in cases of second dialect learning—cases when there is no distinct mother tongue present in the competence of the standard learner. The general lack of interest in second dialect acquisition may be due to the difficulty involved in identifying second dialect situations as linguis tically distinct from first dialect contexts. In spite of the paucity of research on dialect acquisition, or perhaps because of it, there is a popular consensus that stan dard dialect acquisition is less traumatic than SLA. This attitude is obviously reflect ed in the educational establishment: a standard variety is never taught in a formal, organized manner and, in contrast to foreign language learning, is not supported by any language manual or the "bidialectal" equivalent of bilingual programs. The learner is assumed to know the standard before going to school. We can infer from such attitudes that there is a deeply entrenched conviction that the acquisition of dialects involves less distance between the native and the target varieties (D1 and D2) than is the case between L1 and L2. Of course, the nonstandard speaker may have previously acquired a passive or partial competence of the standard model, depending on the degree of exposure and motivation involved in a specific situa tion. Public opinion as well as educational systems assume that a speaker of Geordie, a variety of Newcastle English (Graham 1980), will find it easier to learn RP than to learn French, or that a speaker of American Black English should learn standard English faster than Spanglish, and Spanglish faster than Spanish. On the other hand, there is apparently no clear opinion concerning the relative learnability of nonstandard dialects by standard speakers. Would it be easier for a speaker of standard English to learn Black English2 or Geordie than Spanish? It is unusual, however, for speakers of prestigious dialects to strive to learn stigmatized forms, since there are neither the economic nor educational motivations to do so. Although the possibility is not excluded, SDA is typically a one-way social process. There are no empirical studies of dialect versus language acquisition that prove or disprove the validity of the above intuitive statements. Although some nonstandard varieties such as Black English have become the object of schol arly study (Labov 1972a), the actual process of the acquisition of standard American English by speakers of Black English still remains to be explored. The spontaneous acquisition of a standard code as second variety—whether we call it dialect or language—is highly constrained by social factors, subjective attitudes, and the psychosocial context of learning. It is, therefore, essential to
8
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
distinguish between guided learning, the artificial classroom acquisition of a second language, and unguided learning which includes the acquisition of a standard dialect or language in a real life context. Unguided learning situations create the ideal circumstances for the study of the interaction between syntax and pragmatics, as will be discussed below. 2.3 Social attitudes and language/dialect acquisition An important component of language development lies in the existence of social attitudes toward languages and their speakers; yet, SLA studies general ly do not look at the potential significance of the relative social status of the tar get language and of the learner's native language. They also do not take into account the related but distinct issue of the social status of language learners and of native speakers of the linguistic target. For example, there is obviously a different social dynamics involved when comparing the acquisition of English by a Mexican migrant worker in Minnesota, a Mexican migrant worker in California, a Chinese graduate student in an American university, and a Chinese resident of Singapore. There is more of a group support system for Mexicans, or Chícanos, in California than in Minnesota, which has predominantly German and Scandinavian ethnicity and only a seasonal influx of Chícanos. Whether or not a large Mexican population in California, and the universal presence of Spanish or Spanglish in the streets and on the airwaves, facilitates or impedes the acquisition of English by Mexicans remains to be studied. In the other case, a Chinese graduate student on an American campus has a focused, academic motivation to learn English, and the process of SLA acquisition does not inter fere with his or her sense of Chinese identity, unless of course there are personal motives for rejecting it to embrace an American identity. For the Chinese in Singapore, the local English variety is a lingua franca which now symbolizes their identity as Singaporeans, as seen above. Since Mandarin Chinese is offi cially supported by the Singapore government through the "Speak Mandarin" policy, there is good motivation to preserve a Chinese ethnic identity. Social factors are essential to examine because they determine motivation, the availability of learning tools, and other factors instrumental in the develop mental process of language acquisition. As pointed out by LePage & TabouretKeller (1985:247), "neither 'race' nor 'ethnic group' nor 'language' turns out to be a clearly-definable external object," and linguistic choices are "projections" of identity. The learning of non-native varieties, whether they are better defin able as dialects or languages, is at least partially triggered by psychosocial and economic motives. Language is perceived as a marketable asset, a tool for upward mobility. An individual expects to reap benefits, such as status, "class," distinction, recognition and related economic bonuses from the acquisition of a
INTRÓDUCTION: DEVELOPMENTAL CONTINUA
9
new linguistic code. Thus, subjective attitudes toward languages, accents, dialects, and other perceived linguistic entities are directly derived from social factors, and the speakers' histories (Thomason & Kaufman 1199:4). 2.4 Linguistic bias Although the popular (not the linguistic) view defines a dialect as deviant from the norm, the difference between a language and a dialect may be impossible to determine unambiguously, either linguistically or socially. Bias plays an essential role in our perceptions of language varieties and in their acquisition. Linguistic bias reflects the social stratification present in every community, creating a cir cular pattern of cause and effect: language is a social mirror and, thus, perpetu ates social and ethnic bias because linguistic behavior shapes attitudes and opin ions. The lack of power of a stigmatized group is compounded by the negative values associated with the group's linguistic forms (typically described as incorrect, inadequate, inappropriate, uneducated, illogical, and politically dan gerous). A nonstandard variety is often the subject of denial by its own speak ers and by the society harboring it (Ferguson 1959). If at all recognized, it is assumed to be an immature linguistic habit which will be shed in the course of normal intellectual development. If such "bad" linguistic habits persist, users find it harder to establish their social credibility; they may even be denied access to the powerful world of standard speakers. Such attitudes often apply to foreign accents as well and, therefore, to the SLA process. Native speakers often associate—perhaps unconsciously—unflattering intellectual connotations to non-native renderings of their language. A related attitude is the feeling of embarrassment all language learners experience in the first stages of conscious adult acquisition. Clearly, we are strongly motivated to assess an individual's value as a social human being on the basis of that person's verbal ability and conformity to conventional local linguistic standards in addition to other super ficial factors, such as physical appearance and behavior. A prime example of language-based bias is reflected in the recent cam paign to identify English as the sole official language of the United States. The English Only movement has as its goal to deny official status to Spanish, as well as to other immigrant languages, a position which may partly be derived from the common misconception that language unity promotes political unity and economic development.3 The threatening power of linguistic and ethnic diver sity has long been reflected in the stigma attached to Black English varieties in the United States, as well as to creoles in the Caribbean and elsewhere. As reflected in the case of Spanish in the United States, varieties which are commonly referred to as "languages," and that have official and prestigious sta tus in a given country, may hold low status elsewhere. Castilian Spanish, for
10
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
example, is the official language in Spain and constitutes the prestige form in most of Spain except in Catalonia, the Northeastern province, where it has, for political and historical reasons, a much lower status than the local language Catalan. The use of Catalan was made illegal during General Franco's twentyyear dictatorship. In contrast, Catalan was mostly tolerated in Catalogne, the southern province of France adjoining Spain, and it has fallen out of use there despite the fact that it is actively promoted by cultural organizations. Thus, lan guage differences sometimes disappear in cases of voluntary acculturation but are reinforced in cases of oppression. In Latin America, Spanish has a much higher official status than Indian languages (e.g., Quechua, Aymara) whose speakers are at the bottom of the social scale. In the United States, any variety of Latin American or Caribbean Spanish has low overt social status (which does not exclude high covert prestige) due to widespread negative social attitudes toward minorities, migrant workers, and recent immigrants. The circular pattern inherent in linguistic bias is particularly damaging to speakers of nonstandard or unofficial varieties who need to find creative ways to break the pattern of behavior and judgment. For example, the revalorization of Black English and African-American values through the medium of rap music illustrates the attempt to break the pattern of bias through a linguistic medium. Rap clearly has gone well beyond its original linguistic medium since it has been actively adopted in France with musical lyrics in standard Parisian French by Arab and African "rappeur" groups, as well as in Hong Kong as Canto-rap—rap with Cantonese lyrics by analogy with Canto-pop.4 Studies using the matched guise technique have documented the claim that social judgments are based on linguistic behavior, especially on the vague concept of accent (Giles, Bourhis & Taylor 1977). In England, Standard English (RP) is linked to traditional norms and the "public school" education reserved for the elite. A corpus of listeners found that RP evokes impressions of success, intelligence, and elegance but a certain lack of warmth, especially when used by women. Northern English varieties are associated with warmer but less educated and less successful individuals, which confirms that an official norm derives its prestige from the power of the speech community using it (Elyan et al. 1978). Such normative attitudes pro moting the supremacy of standard dialects or official languages are universally shared, and elementary and secondary education teachers are often encouraged to convey this view to their students. The two case studies to be analyzed in this book will illuminate such attitudes. 3. The linguistic analysis of nonstandard dialects Paradoxically, some of the most striking and productive developments in the
INTRODUCTION: DEVELOPMENTAL CONTINUA
11
field of formal linguistics have been concomitant with a denial of the existence and importance of nonstandard varieties, which indeed runs parallel to public ideology. Transformational Generative Grammar (both in its original form and in its later version as Government and Binding), because of the priority it assigns to the search for an abstract linguistic competence and the identification of the universal linguistic capacity shared by all human beings, has intentionally ignored all references to linguistic variability and to the extralinguistic fac tors—social, cultural, psychological and political—that determine linguistic variability. For formal linguistics, the database consists of the linguists' intu itions. Apparently, those intuitions have not included nonstandard verbal struc tures; thus, omissions of large segments of speakers' repertoires are likely to have contributed to the rejection of nonstandard dialects as a valid field of study and a valuable component of education, and may even have reinforced the non standard bias and the low status assigned to their speakers. Schiffrin (1987b:392) claims that one of the major differences between formal linguistics and sociolinguistics is "a difference in data," adding that "the selection of a data type has a profound influence on the range of phenomena which a model aims to represent and a theory aims to explain." 3.1 Labovian sociolinguistics Until twenty years ago, there had been no large scale study of the dialects of groups with low social status. Labov pioneered the field with his seminal stud ies of the social stratification of English in New York City (Labov 1966) and of Black English (Labov 1972a). Although the study of nonstandard dialects has since greatly expanded in the direction of increased observational adequacy, there is still a glaring absence of data documenting the degree of deviance exist ing between standard dialects as acquired by nonstandard speakers and the ver nacular (native) forms of those standard dialects. Labovian sociolinguistics attempts to deal with speech variability per se, and its relevance to commu nicative competence rather than with the Chomskyan internalized competence of the ideal speaker/hearer. For the first time, questions are raised about the validity of our judgments of standard and nonstandard speech, and full scale scientific descriptions of nonstandard speech varieties are conducted. As issues of descriptive accuracy and observational adequacy are brought to the forefront, it becomes necessary to develop sound methodologies for the collection of lin guistic data. What are the observations that will reliably reveal the mechanisms opera tional in language development? How can we ascertain the difference between linguistic facts and the abstracted interpretation of those facts? Indeed, what theory will provide an explanation of the significant linguistic facts? The intu-
12
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
itions of generativists and the mailed questionnaires of dialect geographers obviously tapped limited, and manifestly selective, segments of the linguistic options open to speakers and are now no longer considered appropriate to sat isfy the sociolinguists' interests in establishing the range and extent of linguis tic variability. Matched guise techniques and laboratory experiments are com monly used to isolate linguistic features or identify subjective judgments in con trolled situations and produce interesting results, as in the case of the evaluation of RP outlined above; however, they have the disadvantage of creating artificial situations which can only remotely match genuine language use and, thus, pri marily define formal situations or tap conscious aspects of linguistic behavior. One of Labov's methodological principles—the Principle of Formality— states appropriately that "any systematic observation defines a formal context in which more than the minimal attention is paid to speech" (Labov 1972c). Labov advocates methods whose goals are to capture an individual's full per forming repertoire, from formal to casual, through elicitation of word lists and text reading (for formal speech) as well as through observations of spontaneous conversations (for careful to casual speech). The latter can only be successful if the fieldworker is a member of the speech community under investigation or has become fully accepted as a participant in the social activities of that com munity. Participation, therefore, helps solve the "Observer's Paradox," as one observes "how people speak when they are not being observed" (Labov 1972c). It has been claimed that sociolinguistics is merely a methodology and has no theoretical import. This is clearly inaccurate since all socially-oriented stud ies of language variation derive their premises from the basic theoretical view point that the social context determines human behavior, language being just one aspect of human behavior. Variation studies emphasize the necessity of quantitative analysis as a research procedure with the hypothesis that variabili ty in performance is predictable in terms of the correlated social and linguistic features of each natural interaction. Such approaches are traceable to a Marxist view of social class based on conflict and power. The issue of nonstandard dialects stands within this perspective because the social evaluation of language is based on power, or the perception of power and conflict, and on the human desire to change the power structure to one's advantage. Guy (1988:41) claims that Western social theories present an alternative definition of class based on social unity and status as opposed to the Marxist notions of power and conflict. He says that sociolinguists such as Labov have primarily been functioning from this "soft" perspective, with resulting gradient linguistic stratification, rather than the sharp stratification which is expected to evolve from violent conflict; however, sharp stratification in linguistic feature distribution or subjective atti tudes toward language types has been found to occur in issues of minority lin-
INTRODUCTION: DEVELOPMENTAL CONTINUA
13
guistic behavior—whether in Black English, creoles, or in politically-motivated language choice (such as the case of Catalan mentioned above). Consequently, it seems pointless to separate or choose between unity-sta tus and conflict-power dichotomies. Both types of social behavior obviously cooccur and contribute to the fashioning and development of linguistic behavior. The approach adopted here assumes that a social dynamic is essential in non standard dialect learning but does not presume to predict the type of trigger involved in the acquisition process. It is, however, hypothesized that nonstan dard native speakers will only effectively learn the standard if they have strong incentives to do so—if they envision a practical positive outcome to the acqui sition of the linguistic code. If they assess the achievement of power as unreal istic, it can be predicted that they will not learn much of the standard. The popular definition of the term dialect—a nonstandard variety which is somewhat "deviant" from the local norm—is a useful heuristic sociolinguistic concept because it is based on social attitudes regarding language varieties and their speakers. The notion will naturally be essential in this investigation of the process of acquisition of standard varieties by speakers of dialects or nonstan dard varieties. 3.2 Language in oral discourse and pragmatics The data base underlying this investigation of second dialect acquisition pri marily consists of spontaneous conversations. It is the most common type of ordinary communication, however, which poses the most serious problems of analysis. The principles underlying oral discourse lie within the overlapping ranges of pragmatics and sociolinguistics, Yet, there is currently no compre hensive theoretical framework which adequately predicts the organization of discourse, "no theory of paragraphs and its parts which is nearly as elaborate as a theory of sentences" (Linde 1981:85). The field of pragmatics encompasses a broad range of perspectives on lan guage in context. Green (1989:2) places it at the intersection of a number of fields within and outside of cognitive science: not only linguistics, cognitive psychology, cultural anthropology, and philosophy (logic, semantics, action theory), but also sociology (interpersonal dynamics and social convention) and rhetoric contribute to its domain. The fuzzy boundaries that pragmatics shares in particular with sociolinguistics and semantics, as well as with other disciplines, make pragmatics hard to define clearly, although vague definitions are not lacking. It is defined broadly as "the study of understanding intentional human action," requiring reference to the central notions of belief, intention, plan and act (Green 1989:3), and narrowly
14
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
as "the interpretation of indexical expressions" (Green 1989:2). Levinson (1983) provides an interesting evaluation of various definitions of pragmatics, from its philosophical foundation to a more empirical data-driven approach, implying the growing importance of observational adequacy. Some of those defi nitions include "meaning minus truth conditions," "the study of the relation between language context that are basic to an account of language understanding," "the study of the ability of language users to pair sentences with the contexts in which they are appropriate." Levinson concludes that "conceptual analyses using introspective data [are] replaced by careful inductive work based on observation" (Levinson 1983:285). The functional approach endorsed by Dik (1980) and Givón (1979a; 1990), among others, also regards pragmatics as the primary framework within which "syntactic and semantic principles are explained in terms of the pragmatic pur poses and requirements of verbal interaction" (Dik 1980:2). The functional view of natural language claims to consider language primarily as an instrument of social interaction but, paradoxically, does not discuss real life contexts and pri marily aims to produce principles on the basis of isolated sentences. The advan tage of this approach is its search for "typological adequacy"; as Givón (1990:vii) notes, "surface diversity of cross-language typological facts masks behind it a great measure of commonality of human languages. Part of that com monality is due to semantic and pragmatic universals." Other linguistic research on language universals recognizes the combination of both formal and function al explanations for the commonalities found in human languages (Comrie 1984). 3.3 Theoretical framework for oral discourse The question remains of what theoretical model would most adequately account for the type of speech data to be considered here: namely, spontaneous dis course in the context of standard acquisition by native speakers of nonstandard varieties. The concept of communicative competence and, furthermore, polylectal competence, must be central to this putative model, since I will have to account for the competence of speakers who shift easily between different language varieties depending on the social context. The principles and methods of quantitative sociolinguistics, as briefly outlined above, are well-suited to the detailed analysis of specific linguistic variables. One major aspect of sociolinguistic analysis is empirical, as it involves close attention to social context and to the collection of reliable speech data, an essential element of any attempt at explanations of linguistic facts. In addition, an emphasis on typological generalizations will be essential in the projected comparison of two apparently unrelated linguistic contexts (Belizean and Chinese). Functional grammar provides that angle, with its spe-
INTRODUCTION: DEVELOPMENTAL CONTINUA
15
cial emphasis on universal pragmatic aspects of human communication, espe cially in areas such as topic and focus. Since I elected to exclusively investigate topic marking in spontaneous verbal interaction, the functional approach pro vides a valuable framework within which to place the Belizean and Chinese facts. The processes involved in topic presentation and topic organization pre sent particularly interesting insights into the ambiguous overlap of syntactic and pragmatic processes. Thus, without committing myself fully to either model, I find it convenient and eminently feasible to combine the sociolinguistic framework with the func tional-typological perspective. Indeed, I find the two perspectives to be comple mentary, in the sense that what is lacking in one is supplied by the other. Whereas sociolinguistics is generally restricted to individual linguistic situations, func tional grammar provides options for cross-linguistic generalizations; while func tional grammar has little to say about specific contexts and speakers, sociolin guistics has a well-developed methodology and theory to identify and control the extralinguistic variables which have significant impact on language choice. Finally, the overlap of semantics, syntax, and pragmatics is an important aspect of the study of discourse, and the fuzziness of boundaries is often invoked in functional approaches. Although an account of the absence of neat ly separated components presents a serious challenge, the issue cannot be skirt ed. The notion of overlap is particularly relevant to the study of marginalized varieties. Since nonstandard varieties are usually highly stigmatized, there is no formal or canonical description of their structure, and they are not subjected to a norm. They are, therefore, relatively free to evolve. It is the intent of this investigation to observe whether and how spontaneous contexts favor the clos er association of semantic, syntactic, and pragmatic processes, as noted in cre le situations. A hypothesis to be considered here is that unguided learners, as well as learners deprived of a stable model, are forced to rely on general prag matic or functional principles rather than on the formal syntactic rules of the tar get language because of the continued inaccessibility of the standard grammar. In other words, speakers may pragmatically rearrange the target syntax. The hypothesis will be advanced that such pragmatic reorganization may derive from universally shared principles, regardless of the specific linguistic situa tion. The issue of the putative overlap of pragmatic and syntactic devices will be investigated here more particularly in the acquisition of Belizean acrolects by native speakers of Creole, and of Chinese standard dialects by native speak ers of nonstandard Chinese varieties. 3.4 Units of analysis An essential prerequisite in the linguistic analysis of discourse involves delim-
16
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
iting the domain of the study. The Chomskyan notion that the domain of lin guistic analysis can and should be the sentence unit constitutes the standard basis for most analyses—but it is easy to demonstrate that investigations limit ed to isolated sentences fail to provide essential information about the broader psychosocial context that generates the parameters within which a sentence occurs. Furthermore, it is often difficult to identify sentence boundaries and, thus, to break discourse into significant sentential units. This structural uncer tainty is represented in the following example, in which a Belizean speaker dis cusses "modernity":5 (1) This thing of modernity sometime, I am skeptical of it myself; I think when you talk of the economics of it you want to bring in some sophisticated system, make them become dependent on it, and, you know, look pan de land, look pan de people, and you just see them as factors of production rather than seeing them for what they really are, what the land can produce and how it will—de people who till it, rather than going into this sophisti cated system, say small is beautiful (Co, 42, 1980, Placencia) The definition of linguistic units in discourse, however, does require some reference to its boundaries and to its internal organization. Wald (1983:104) looks at narratives as "discourse units that are extended, potentially syntactical ly elaborate, commonly spoken, and easy to elicit." Such descriptions capture the complexity of discourse but do not contribute much empirical help to the analyst intent on defining descriptively adequate measurements. A more pro ductive attempt to delimit the "discourse origin" and "the end point" of a nar rative leads Wald to refer to a variety of cues, for example: "a coda such as that's it....or a falling intonation and slowing of the speech tempo finally laps ing into silence. . .[and] the following audience (or addressee) reaction" (Wald 1983:108). Labov and Fanshel (1977), in their study of the language of therapy, iden tify "units of talk" which function as speech actions, and their goal is to formu late the set of principles organizing those units of talk, either as concatenation rules sequéncing information, or mapping procedures which determine the pro duction and interpretation of verbal elements. According to Linde (1981:113), "discourse units have an internal structure that is as regular and accessible as the study of the structure of sentences." She identifies certain internal organizational principles which provide coherence in discourse, such as temporal ordering, relations of dominance and inclusion, and a wide set of social and cultural assumptions and presupposition. Linde defines major linguistic units in terms of genres, such as stories, jokes, recipes, narra tives of activities, and the like, all functioning as social units as well. One
INTRODUCTION: DEVELOPMENTAL CONTINUA
17
advantage of this approach is that it makes sense to speakers, who are far more aware of undertaking to tell a story than they are of undertaking to produce a sentence. A disadvantage of the "genre as unit" interpretation is that it may be too broad. A story is likely to be subdivided into various components, inter rupted by interlocutors' comments, then continued and led to completion; thus, a topic can be maintained over alternating turns of conversation. It may be practically more effective to define linguistic units shorter than the genre, while leaving open the potential of expanding beyond conventional idealized sentential boundaries. Sample (2) shown below illustrates the problem of discourse division. It is excerpted from a conversation taped in Placencia, between Co and his friend Ro. Co and Ro used to be coworkers at the income tax department and the customs office in Belize-City. They recall a common friend Xo. The topic of Xo is introduced by Ro's basilectal question [We he do now?], but Co immediately shifts to an acrolect (more appropriate when dis cussing aspects of their official functions as civil servants in Belize-City) and sometimes to a mesolect (turn 5), although Ro occasionally shifts back to a basilect (turn 4). 6 Beside the issue of lectal shifting, a point relevant to the def inition of discourse units is represented in the fact that the topic is interrupted on turn 6 by Ro's digression into recollections of office relationships, to which Co responds (turn 7); Ro then returns to the topic of Xo (turn 8). Thus, the prob lem is how to break down the following chunk of discourse. Should there be eight discourse units (each turn constituting one discourse unit)? Could it be three, the first discourse unit including turns 1-5 (discussion of Xo), the second (6-7) about office relationships, then the third resuming the topic of Xo (turn 8)? Or could the entire paragraph be considered as one single discourse unit: (2) Ro: We he do now? (what does he do now?) 1. Co: I think he wanted to get into merchandising and maybe in bond stores, duty free shops. 2. Ro: I used to like work with he you know, they gave he lee [little] bad name and so but. 3. Co: I found him alright, boy, I got on pretty well with him, ahm, we were from way back, you and I know him even before being a civil ser vant, and ahm, then I worked with him the first time at income tax, then I worked with him at customs, but, I'm, telling you, I think he was a. . .he had ideas, right. 4. Ro: Dat da we I like with a [that's what I like about him]; and he got good, to me, right, we got good staff relationship, right. 5. Co: He used to fine [He used to be fine] 6. Ro: I know one big place like customs funny for you, because the staff too big, right, but to me, like, I use to like ya [there], they make the staff
18
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA there feel at home, right, for instance da you lee birthday today and things like that. 7. Co: Yah, and I think it was good, right, kinda, you work together you must also fun together, you socialize, you find it makes for better working relationship. 8. Ro: Dat's right, I never find no fault with the man, man. If you m ga wan man de but da Xo de [If you had to pick a man, it would be Xo]; yah, he da something else, he da dead scatterbrains, man. (Placencia 1980)
For the purpose of this investigation, I will opt to take the entire paragraph as a discourse unit of analysis. My definition of "topic units" is centered around the topic: all structures related to the topic make up the topic unit, as will be further illustrated in chapters four and six. In many languages, including English, the basic syntactic structure of the sentence involves an SVO order in which topics do not have an especially high priority; yet, topic mechanisms occur more extensively in contextualized casu al and nonstandard varieties related to English, which then appear to assign topic structures to the pragmatic component. The incidence of topic mecha nisms in creole varieties, especially in acrolects, is of special interest here and is related to the claim that the pragmatic component takes over in spontaneous contexts. On the other hand, some languages clearly assign syntactic status to what is pragmatically constrained elsewhere, a phenomenon akin to grammaticalization. This may be the case in Chinese which displays consistent topiccomment discourse structures. The concept of topic chain (Shi 1989; Tsao 1979), to be also discussed in chapter six, may provide an appropriate framework for the study of creole topic mechanisms because of its flexibility in allowing a definition of the topic unit which combines syntactic and pragmatic elements. According to the theory of topic chains, the topic extends its domain to a sequence of several propositions. The topic chain, or topic unit is thus a dis course level phenomenon that raises the issue of the interaction of syntax and pragmatics, as illustrated in the Belizean examples above. And it thus appears that cross-linguistic observations provide a productive perspective on our understanding of topic mechanisms.
4. Creoles and noncreoles Parallel to the growing interest in Black English evidenced in the last thirty years, and perhaps even more extensive, has been the development of the field of creolistics over the last twenty years. This creole scholarship has endeavored to rehabilitate stigmatized creole languages in their own communities, and else-
INTRODUCTION: DEVELOPMENTAL CONTINUA
19
where, and to delineate a new field where social and linguistic factors are inter locked in language development. As indicated above, however, the attention devoted to the development of pidgin and creole-related continua has been somewhat limited. Several important books providing overviews of creoles, or case studies, have appeared since 1980 (Arends et al. 1995; Alleyne 1980; Bickerton 1975; 1981; Chaudenson 1992; Gilbert 1987; Holm 1988; LePage & Tabouret-Keller 1985; Muysken & Smith 1986; Rickford 1987; Romaine 1988; Thomason & Kaufman 1991). One of the current challenges in the field of creole studies involves pro viding satisfactory accounts and explanations of the linguistic variability inher ent in creole situations. There are apparently conflicting interpretations of vari ability, namely, the "continuum" and the "co-existent systems" perspectives (to be further discussed below). The varieties spanning a creole continuum are often characterized as unidimensional and displaying implicational patterns (Bickerton 1975; Rickford 1987). However, analyses leading to these interpre tations are usually based on phonological or morphological variables, rarely on observations of linguistic features beyond the sentence level. A different view holds that only a multidimensional model can accommodate creole situations. In particular, LePage & Tabouret-Keller (1985:180-185) claim that the linguis tic strategies used in Cayo District, a Western district of Belize with predomi nantly Spanish and Creole ethnicity, are necessarily multidimensional because each linguistic choice is an "act of identity" that implies solidarity with or dis tance from others. This perspective is in keeping with the speech accommoda tion theory, which involves the principles of "convergence" and "divergence" in human psychosocial interaction (Giles, Bourhis, & Taylor 1977). The multidimensional interpretation of linguistic variability need not be restricted to multilingual, multiethnic communities, as will be discussed later. The issue of decreolization is often linked to the continuum phenomenon. Decreolization has been interpreted as a development of the continuum in the direction of the standard model, leading from basilect to mesolect to acrolect, with concomitant loss of the "earlier" forms. The process has often been assumed to be a unidirectional substitution of the standard for the creole.7 Having embraced the decreolization view at early stages of my research (Escure 1981), I have come to the conclusion that the reality of creole continua, even in a relatively homogeneous speech community like Placencia, Belize, (see chap ter two) is more complex than can be accounted for by a unidimensional model. The learning of acrolects does not necessarily imply the loss of native basilectal vernaculars. On the contrary, the acquisition of acrolects involves an exten sion of the repertoire available to speakers rather than a systematic sliding of the continuum toward a more standard set of linguistic segments (Escure 1981;
20
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
1982; Rickford 1987:31). There is a reasonable possibility that the process of change through extension and remodeling may be typical of any acquisitional situation, implying the addition of a second code to a first variety. This is like ly to apply to SLA as well. I firmly believe that the acquisition of a second lan guage does not systematically and irreversibly move forward but is subject to backsliding and the preservation of socially meaningful intermediate forms, not unlike the acquisition of varieties along a creole continuum.8 If this is true, SDA may not be drastically different from SLA, and creole situations may be struc turally similar to other language variability situations, although they may still differ in other respects, perhaps historical or political. For Muysken & Smith (1995:4-5), "creole languages are not in the slightest qualitatively distinguish able from other spoken languages." A comparison of second dialect acquisition in creole and noncreole con texts will help clarify the definition of the concept of "creole." In particular, the following problems will be addressed: are creole languages and their continua structurally different from others? Is the pattern of standard acquisition differ ent for a native creole speaker as opposed to a native speaker of a noncreole, nonstandard dialect? Those questions will be examined in the very limited con text of the discourse variables selected for analysis. There is a strong indication that, even though the term creole is widely used in various types of contact-induced situations, it is not clear that a creole is typologically different from other language types which develop through some type of sociolinguistic contact (Corne 1995a; Escure 1993a). It will be hypothesized here that second dialect acquisition is somewhat analogous, though occurring under apparently less traumatic conditions, to the situations which permitted the genesis of pidgins and creoles. Even though a model exists (the standard is usu ally codified in written form and is also subject to informal standardization), it is never systematically related to the learner's native system; thus, the learner is forced into the same decision making situations—what to select from a variety of options. Furthermore, the same social pressures exist: both the incipient pid gin speaker and the nonstandard learner are in positions to be affected by vary ing degrees of social oppression and made to feel that they cannot meaningfully participate in social life unless they control, among other things, the "proper" code—which nobody is attempting to teach them properly or at all! In the case of nonstandard learners, language universals may have already been actively used in the natural development of their uncodified vernacular. 4.1 Two case studies It is hoped that a detailed analysis of selected aspects of two ethnically differ ent types of second dialect acquisition will contribute to our understanding of
INTRODUCTION: DEVELOPMENTAL CONTINUA
21
cross-linguistic acquisitional mechanisms and of linguistic bias. First, the case of Belize, Central America: in that former British colony, the official language is English, directly inherited from the colonial past of what was previously identified as "British Honduras." English is the medium claimed to be used in all governmental and educational functions, but the reality is far from meeting official expectations. The Creoles (Afro-Europeans) overtly rec ognize the prestige of English, but their vernacular language is an Englishbased creole which has in-group prestige. Other groups manifest equally ambiguous attitudes and behaviors toward the standard acrolect. The acquisi tion of Belizean acrolects occurs in the context of a multilectal creole situation, which is likely to have always been variable, and definitely still is. It is a case of relatively recent language formation through pidginization and creolization. Second, the case of the acquisition of Standard Mandarin by speakers of other varieties of Chinese having local, but not official, status occurs in the more traditional context (noncreole) of dialect acquisition, so far undocumented. The People's Republic of China (PRC) has been actively promoting—through mass media and educational channels—the increased use of the new standard of Mandarin Chinese called Putonghua (the "Common Language"). Beijing natives claim that they cannot understand the provincial dialects spoken all over China, but most of the recent leading political figures of China are not natives of the Beijing province and sport remarkable accents: Mao Tse Tung was born in Changsha, Hunan, in the southern part of PRC, where a distinctive lan guage—Xiang—is spoken; Deng-Xiao-Ping is a native of Chengdu, Sichuan, whose Southwestern Mandarin variety is also very distinctive. Obviously, Belizean English-based creoles and Chinese dialects are genet ically and historically unrelated, and the countries in which those varieties are spoken are maximally different in size and ethnic composition. This apparent lack of connection is one reason why I elected to analyze the linguistic situa tions in those two geographically distant sites. Comparing the two types of acquisition should highlight universal aspects of acquisition, as well as the issue of whether there is any substance to the notion that creoles develop in any dis tinctive way (Escure 1993a; 1994). In addition, it is recognized that creoles constitute the linguistic product of relatively recent colonization and enforced transplantation and subjugation of one group to another region and culture, whereas a general assumption of homogeneity is typically associated with Chinese cultures and languages—a manifestly erroneous assumption. Both situations offer similarities in terms of the general social background underlying their respective developments. Chinese populations have been forever subjected to the constant oppression of various emperors and overlords invading each others' territories, and there has
22
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
been a plethora of successive waves of colonization from the north to the south of China. The most recent invasion was the Manchu takeover which resulted in the domination of one nation by an outsider group. Linguistically, the dominant Manchu are said to have adopted the language of the subjugated nation and, more specifically, the Mandarin variety spoken in Northern China (Beijing vari ety). The Manchu invasion occurred at about the same time as the main slave trade from Africa, which changed the ethnolinguistic map of the New World. It is obvious that, historically, similar types of linguistic contact and ethnic mixing phenomena underlie China and Belize. 4.2 Outline of chapters It is expected that close observations of the standard versions produced by native speakers of nonstandard dialects will provide interesting insights into the universal processes underlying the development of language in society. This volume investigates the development of second dialects in the context of the two distinct sociolinguistic situations outlined above: The first part of this volume, chapters two through four, examines linguis tic variation in the context of English-based creoles and the English acrolectal varieties acquired by native speakers of creole basilects, as spoken in Belize (previously British Honduras) where I have conducted fieldwork from 1978 to 1994. Chapter two provides the demographic, geographical, social, and histori cal background of the speech community of Belize, highlighting some of the conditions under which the creole continuum is currently developing English acrolects and focusing more particularly on the Stann Creek District which is the locus of this research. Chapter three is concerned with the acrolectal seg ment, the product of the acquisition of the standard as second (non-native) dialect. The intent is to identify potential differences between the acrolect and the standard variety, the apparent target in acrolectal development. Chapter four specifically investigates the use of topic strategies in Belizean acrolects, com paring syntactic and pragmatic aspects of standard acquisition to basilectal cre le patterns and casual American English varieties. The second part of this volume, chapters five through eight, investigates similar problems in Chinese dialects spoken in the People's Republic of China, including the native vernacular Mandarin/Putonghua spoken in Beijing, the non-native Putonghua acquired by speakers of the Wuhan varieties (Wuhanhua) in Wuhan (Hubei), and the narrative variety of Wu used for traditional tales in Suzhou (Jiangsu) which is also acquired as a second dialect. Speech data were collected since 1985 (Escure 1987), and vernacular data spanning the period from 1963-1985 are derived from contemporary written texts. As a counterpart to chapter two in the Belizean section, chapter five provides parallel background
INTRODUCTION: DEVELOPMENTAL CONTINUA
23
information on the Chinese dialect situation with special emphasis on Beijing, Wuhan, and Suzhou. Chapter six outlines crucial aspects of Chinese syntax in discourse. Chapter seven looks into the use of various types of topic strategies in several varieties representing Standard Chinese/Putonghua. Chapter eight evaluates similar mechanisms in the context of two acquired dialects and leads to a comparison of first and second dialects in some representative Chinese var ieties. Finally, chapter nine establishes a comparison of the patterns observed in Belizean and Chinese standard acquisition and, more particularly, discusses the interaction of syntax and pragmatics, and the issue of the universality of dialect acquisition. From the above remarks, it follows that, should any structural sim ilarities be observed in the linguistic patterns adopted by learners of second dialects in Belize and in China, language-specific substrate and superstate mechanisms could be ruled out. Such potential findings would warrant careful scrutiny, with the ultimate goal of getting closer to an understanding of univer sal linguistic processes. Endnotes 1. Except in relatively restricted cases of simultaneous bilingual acquisition which does not involve diglossia-some sort of social discrepancy between the two languages. In fact, few, if any, such situations exist. 2. For example, Black English in the United States has become extremely popular among some white teenagers; however, I know of no full-scale study documenting the extent of its acquisi tion by groups other than African-Americans. 3. It has been demonstrated that there is no correlation between multilingualism and low eco nomic development or political instability, as discussed in Fasold (1984:5-9). 4. Thanks to Stephen Matthews and Virginia Yip for the information about Canto-rap. 5. In this excerpt, any representation of the phonological idiosyncracies of Belizean acrolects has been omitted since the point of this example is to discuss the challenge of defining discourse units. The only lexical unit that may be different from English is pan 'on' [look pan the land, pan the people]. 6. Linguistic features characteristic of basilects, mesolects, and acrolects will be discussed in later chapters. 7. A parallel interpretation of the acquisition of second languages assumes a unilateral shift from basilang to mesolang to acrolang (Stauble 1980:47; Schumann & Stauble 1983:263). 8. Although I don't know of any study testing in detail the hypothesis of the nonuniformity of L2 learning, all adult speakers of a second language experience the unreliability of L2 perfor mance which varies in terms of multiple factors in the context of interaction.
Chapter 2 The Belizean Speech Community and the Use of English Abstract This chapter provides general demographic and socioeconomic information on the Belizean community, with special focus on Belize's ethnic and linguistic pluralism. The language situation is briefly placed within the specific context of the Englishbased creole continuum. The locus of the research is Stann Creek district and, in par ticular, the Creole village of Placencia and the neighboring Garifuma community of Seine Bight. The linguistic range, from basilect to acrolect, is illustrated in sample texts, with a brief outline of idiosyncratic features defining each lect. 1. Introduction to the history of Belize Aldous Huxley (1934:32) said: "British Honduras is not on the way from any where to anywhere else, has no strategic value, is all but inhabited; if the world has any ends, British Honduras would be one of them." With due respect to Huxley, nothing could be further from the truth! Far from being the dead end implied by Huxley's quote, Belize is a vibrant land of diversity and paradox, with city slums and unspoiled beaches, lush jungles and deforested land turned into sugar plantations only a few miles apart from each other. In multicultural Belize, ethnic diversity and miscegenation are taken for granted, yet Belizean society has inherited the color-coding system of colonization. Literacy and edu cation are high priorities but educated Belizeans are offered few opportunities at home. Thus, many of them have emigrated to the United States which has a higher Belizean population than Belize itself. Thc young average age of the population confirms the continuing scope of emigration patterns. According to the 1991 population census, 75% of the population is under twenty-one, about the same as in 1980. Belize, which originated in a lively brew of cultures, lan guages, and dialects is still developing in multiple dynamic directions. Steeped in a violent past of invasions, clashes, migrations, exploitation, piracy and slav-
26
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
ery, Belizean society offers fascinating insights into patterns of human adapta tion in the face of adversity and into the creativity of linguistic processes in complex communicative situations. The area was the scene of conflicts which almost eliminated Maya civilization, of clashes between Spanish soldiers and British buccaneers, of pirate landings, slave logging camps, Indian caste wars, Black Carib deportation, and finally Salvadoran refugees' immigration. In order to understand the range and overlap of the linguistic codes used in Belize, their social functions and iconic values, and eventually the nature of the second dialects spoken in the context of the traumatic history of Belize, it is essential to delve briefly into some historical aspects of the country. The name Belize was first applied to the main waterway and later to the principal city which became the capital of the independent territory of British Honduras. The origin of the lexical item Belize is somewhat unclear. It may be derived from the name of the assumed founder of the original settlement which eventually became Belize—a Scottish pirate named Peter Wallace, or Wallis, who was possibly a lieutenant of Sir Walter Raleigh.1 As reported in the 1827 Honduras Almanack,and as Bancroft (1883) and Asturias (1941) claim, the first settlement of British Honduras was founded either in 1617 or in 1638 by some eighty shipwrecked sailors led by Wallace/Wallis. The area settled would then have been named "Wallis" or "Ballis" by the Spaniards, due to some interfer ence of the Spanish bilabial fricative.2 The former British colony of British Honduras, self-governed since 1973, became independent on September 21, 1981, after a long period of negotiations with Guatemala which had long-standing claims to what is still referred to on Guatemalan maps as the Belice province. This 13,000 square kilometer territo ry (260 kms at its longest and 100 kms at its widest) is wedged between Spanish-speaking Central America (Mexico, Guatemala, and Honduras) and the Caribbean Sea. It is bounded on the north by Mexico's Yucatan state of Quintana Roo and on the south and west by Guatemala. Belize has the lowest population density of any Central American country, with an overall population of 189,392 according to the most recent (1991) pop ulation census. More than a quarter of the population is clustered in the capital Belize-City (population 43,710). Because of limited economic opportunities, Belize has been traditionally a land of emigration, and although it is difficult to have accurate figures, it can be assumed that there are at least as many Belizeans living in the United States as there are in Belize. The 1991 census finds that, overall, 3,000 Belizeans emigrated since 1980—over 85% of them to the United States—with a steady flow over the years (although no such data are available to document emigration before 1980). This figure is almost certainly an underrepresentation of the facts of emigration for two primary reasons stated in the
THE BELIZEAN SPEECH COMMUNITY
27
population census report: first, entire households who emigrated are not repre sented, and second, Belizeans residing in Belize may have been reluctant to report family members living abroad who have not yet regularized their resi dence status in their land of emigration. Considering those factors, I believe that a reasonable estimate of emigration since 1980 may be closer to 5,000 and, over thirty years may have reached as much as 150,000, and thus may have matched the current population officially residing in Belize. Such high emigration patterns appear to be confirmed by the relative youth of the Belizean population: 65% is under age twenty-four whereas the most pro ductive segment of the population (ages twenty-five to fifty-four) amounts to only 28%. Individuals over fifty-four constitute only 8% of the population. The 1980 census showed a similar trend in age distribution for the ten previous years. This overall pattern suggests that most of the breadwinners live abroad. Emigration is obviously an important factor likely to influence the lan guage situation, either because this young population is likely to have a power ful impact on language choice or because connections with United States resi dents may affect language development in Belize. Considering the pervading emigration, the population could be expected to show a slow increase or even a decrease. In fact, between 1980 and 1991, the population increased by 44,000, an increase of almost 30% and almost twice as much in real numbers as in the previous intercensal period (1970-1980).3 In comparison, the intercensal growth was less between 1970 and 1980 than in the previous ten years as shown in table 2.1: Table 2.1: Population growth in Belize (Population Census, 1991) Year
Population
1960
90,565
1970
119,645
1980
145,353
1991
189,392
Growth during decade 29,000 25,000 44,000
Why this apparent growth? In spite of regular emigration, increased childbirth is not the explanation. It appears that the traditional, or at least thirty-yearold, emigration channels to the United States have been offset by a strong incoming immigration trend. Over 25,000 people living in Belize in the last ten years reported being born abroad, which neatly accounts for the doubled inter censal growth noted above. Most of those immigrants are from Guatemala and El Salvador (both neighboring countries which suffered high political instabil-
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
28
ity) and, to a lesser extent, Mexico and Honduras. Those four countries, all Spanish-speaking, constitute 85% of the native lands of recent immigrants. This fact is an important factor related to language use. Spanish, one of the languages of Belize, has now gained majority status over English-based varieties. The eth nic composition of the country is also affected. 2. Ethnolinguistic composition and census data The diverse Belizean population results from repeated waves of immigrants usual ly forced upon the land. Settling at different times but adding extraordinary diversi ty to the indigenous Amerindian population have been a range of peoples: shipwrecked British seamen, French and British pirates, African maroons and slaves, Miskito Indians brought from the Miskito Coast (now Nicaragua), Black Caribs (Garifuna) deported from St. Vincent, then Honduras, Spanish and Indian refugees from Mexico, Mennonites fleeing religious persecution, and more recently Salvadorans and Guatemalans fleeing political oppression. The contemporary pop ulation includes four major groups: Amerindians, Creoles, Mestizos, and Black Caribs (Garifuna), and other smaller groups. Escure (1983a:32) attempted to inter pret the 1980 census data (Population Census 1980); the distribution of ethnic groups and the languages spoken is represented in table 2.2: Table 2.2: Ethnic groups, population, and languages of Belize in 1980 ETHNIC GROUP
Creoles Mestizos Garifuna Maya Kekchi Whites East Indians Chinese Other: Lebanese Mennonites Salvadorans
%
SECOND LG.
THIRD LG.
39.7 33.1 7.6 6.8 2.7 4.2 2.1 0.1
Creole Spanish Garifuna Maya Mopan Kekchi English English Creole Cantonese
English Creole Creole English Creole** Creole English Creole
Spanish* English English Creole**
3.6
Creole Low German Spanish
English Creole**
POP.
FIRST LG.
Spanish* English
* in some areas only **rarely
Although each Belizean is quite clear about his or her ethnic and cultural identity, the official classification of ethnic groups offers particular challenges
THE BELIZEAN SPEECH COMMUNITY
29
in Belize. The 1980 census used nine categories, including the labels Negro/Black and Mixed, which drew most votes with 76% and 13% respective ly. There was no reference, however, to the locally used terms of identification: Creole, Black Carib or Garifuna, and Mestizo.4 This classification overlooked the peculiar ethnic configuration of Belize and local attitudes toward identity. At least three of the major groups are mixed (Creoles, Black Caribs, and Mestizos), and the first two can be considered "black." Specifically, the Black Caribs, who are now officially referred to as Garifuna (see below for a more extensive discussion of this term and other alternatives) are indeed mixed (Afro-Indians), although they usu ally have dark skin. Creoles are also by definition mixed (Afro-European), but they range over a broad spectrum of coloring and morphological features. Yet, Creoles and Garifuna are culturally and linguistically very different groups. As to the Mestizos, they are also mixed (Hispanic/Indian), although many members of the group identify themselves as "Spanish," and there was no label indicating a Spanish identity in the 1980 census. Furthermore, no distinction was established between the Maya and the Kekchi, two distinct groups of Amerindians who speak different, though related, varieties of Mayan. The 1991 census is a significant improvement over the previous ethnic census because it used labels popularly used in Belize, twelve altogether as optional responses to the question: "To what ethnic, racial, or national group do you think you belong?" The overwhelming majority fits into the Mestizo (43.6%) and the Creole (29.8%) groups. The foreign-born (14% of the population) account for the shift in the majority groups. This figure, however, does not clearly distinguish between recent arrivals and traditional Belizean Mestizos. It might have been help ful to include national origin such as Guatemalan, or Salvadoran, or the use of the label Spanish/Spaniard/Hispanic besides Mestizo, which would have shed light on the ethnic shift apparently ongoing in Belize. Table 2.3: Ethnic Groups in Belize in 1991 ETHNIC GROUP
Creole Indian Garifuna Maya Mopan Kekchi Maya Other Maya German/Dutch Mennonite Mestizo Chinese Syrian/Lebanese White Other
POPULATION (%)
29.8 3.5 6.6 3.7 4.3 3.1 3.1 43.6 0.4 0.1 0.8 1.0
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
30
The most serious inadequacy of the 1991 census lies in its investigation of languages spoken and the discussion of the results. The census dealt with the language situation through two simple questions (Do you speak English?/Do you speak Spanish?) and three answer options in each case (very well/not so well/not at all). One might argue that subjective responses to fluency are generally unreli able because speakers tend to either overrepresent or underrepresent their lan guage skills, depending on the local or national status of those languages. This is a serious issue in Belize where English has the status of "official language" and serves as the language of education. However, the most serious problem may be that no attention is given to the use of the creole language. Furthermore, there is no attempt to assess the language acquisition and shifting strategies of the population. Indeed, the glaring omission of any reference to Creole confirms the continued presence of bias toward native vernaculars. Such an omission can only produce an inaccurate interpretation of the census data. Census figures indicate that 54.3% of the population believe that they speak English "very well," 22.5% "not so well," and 23.2% "not at all," sug gesting: "that just over half of our population speak the official language very well points to the need for some serious considerations, especially in view of the fact that fluency in an established language is an indispensable tool for the acquisition of any other form of knowledge" (Population Census 1991:8). On the other hand, the stated frequency of good Spanish fluency corre sponds to the percentage of Belizeans who, in 1991, identify themselves as Mestizo (43.6%), as shown in table 2.4: Table 2.4: Stated language fluency (1991 Population Census)
Speak English Speak Spanish
Very well 54% 43.8%
Not so well 22.5% 11.1%
Not at all 23.2% 45.1%
This table reflects a clear and complementary assessment of Spanish flu ency as "very well" and "not at all." The growing impact of Spanish from var ious proveniences suggests that other languages, such as the Mayan varieties spoken in the western and southern districts, may be affected by the develop ment of Spanish.5 In contrast to clear assessments of Spanish fluency, table 2.4 reflects the uncertainty related to what constitutes English fluency. The three major groups (Creole, East-Indian, Garifuna), who natively speak some form of English (assuming the creole is some form of English) constitute about 68% of the overall population, yet only 54% estimate that they speak English very well.
THE BELIZEAN SPEECH COMMUNITY
31
The uncertain piace and status of Creole vis-à-vis English is obviously part of the problem, an issue not addressed by the census. The issue of bilingualism or multilingualism is also not addressed. This official dismissal of Creole points to the necessity of including in census reports findings about the extent of sec ond language acquisition. Finally, it would have been interesting, if not crucial, to investigate which portions of the population estimate that they are fluent in Garifuna and in Mayan/Kekchi. Such figures may have helped assess the vital ity of the languages spoken by these two Belizean minority groups. The differential in language use and language fluency in English and Spanish is quite important and is obviously linked to the differential distribu tion of ethnic groups across the six districts of Belize, as represented in table 2.5. Creoles predominate in the Belize district (around the urban area of BelizeCity)6 and are also widespread in Cayo (west, near Guatemala) and Stann Creek (southern coastal area). Mestizos constitute the majority in Corozal and Orange Walk (both north near Mexico) and Cayo. The Garifuna only have a significant presence in Stann Creek. Finally, the southernmost Toledo district is clearly Maya territory, at least in rural areas, since the main town of Punta Gorda is in majority inhabited by Garifuna. Table 2.5: Ethnic groups in the six districts of Belize (1991) (arranged from northern to southern geographical locations; figures indicate percentages)
Districts COROZAL ORANGE WALK BELIZE CAYO STANN CREEK TOLEDO
Creole
Garifuna
Mestizo
Maya
7.6 7.4 67.9 23.0 25.1 5.7
1.3 1.2 5.3 1.7 36.2 10.0
74.1 71.7 18.7 58.0 23.7 11.9
5.0 9.1 1.2 8.7 8.0 62.8
A brief overview of Belizean ethnicity is outlined below, group by group, and in terms of their chronological presence or arrival on the scene of the territory which now constitutes Belize. 2.1 Amerindians The most ancient ethnic group in Belize is the Amerindian group. Maya civiliza tion flourished primarily in the Yucatan peninsula, extending into Belize and neighboring areas of Honduras and Guatemala, but abruptly declined in the ninth century A.D., possibly because of a violent popular revolt against the religious rulers. There is, however, archaeological evidence of continued occupation of the
32
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
Maya sites (presumably by farmers) well into the fourteenth century and proba bly much later, up to the time when the British began settling in Belize in the early seventeenth century. Ruins of cities and pyramids are scattered and half-buried under the tropical jungles, a silent testimony to the existence of a lost civilization forgotten even by its descendants. Some of the sites that have been excavated or surveyed include Altun Ha, San Jose, La Milpa, Mun Diego and others in northern Belize; Xunantunich, Actun Balam, Caracol, Cahal Pech and Tzimin Kax in the West (Cayo District near the Guatemalan border); and Lubantum and Pusilha in the southern Toledo District. The Mayas in Belize now consist of three groups, each speaking a differ ent language variety and living in separate areas. The Mopan and Kekchi Mayas are the descendants of the original inhabitants of Belize who reentered the area from Guatemala during the end of the nineteenth century; they live pri marily in the Toledo district, in southern and western Belize near the Guatemalan border. On the other hand, Yucatecan Mayas came from Mexico after the 1847-1853 Indian Caste War, and they now live in the northern Corozal and Orange Walk districts, close to the Mexican border. Most of the Mopan and Kekchi-speaking Mayas still live in isolated villages and, until recently, have had little contact with other groups. There is an increasing admixture of the Mopan and Kekchi, but Mopan speakers have a somewhat higher status locally, perhaps due to the fact that the largest village of San Antonio (pop. about 200) is primarily Mopan, with some assimilated Kekchi. The southern Mayas consider themselves to be different from the northern Yucatec Mayas who primarily speak Spanish and have been largely assimilated to Mestizos. Yucatec Mayan is still spoken in some rural areas, though Spanish is now becoming the first language as it is associated with progress and social mobility for members of this group. Northern Mayas and Mestizos, thus, close ly identify with Mexico, and Spanish is the primary marker of ethnicity for them. Creole, however, competes with Spanish as an indicator of youth soli darity and interethnic friendship. Even though Spanish-speaking people demographically dominate the northern Belizean community, the size of the Creole group has increased in the city of Corozal, and the limited Creole/Mestizo inter action allows for some Creole expansion in the community. In the western Cayo District, the Mestizo and Creole populations mostly balance out; thus, Spanish and Creole have roughly equal status in the commu nity at large. Interaction between the two groups is frequent, and intermarriage is more common than in the northern part of the country. Consequently, chil dren in Cayo have a choice of identities, whether Spanish or Creole, as attest ed in Le Page and Tabouret-Keller (1985).
THE BELIZEAN SPEECH COMMUNITY
33
2.2 Creoles (Europeans, Africans, Miskitos) The Spanish colonization of Central America in the sixteenth century was con centrated primarily in the Gulf of Campeche and barely affected the area of the Bay of Honduras; however, French, Dutch, and British buccaneers had occa sional contacts with the Belizean coastline. According to sparse records pre sented by Asturias (1941), Bancroft (1883), and Burdon (1935), British settlers had brought Jamaican lumbermen as early as 1655 for the purpose of logging the swamps along the Belize River. As buccaneers increasingly converted to the lumber business after privateering was outlawed, a larger labor force was need ed and African slaves were imported to the area from other parts of the Caribbean. In a 1724 report, a Spanish missionary referred to "300 English [liv ing in Belize], besides Mosquito Indians and negro slaves, these latter having been introduced but a short time before from Jamaica and Bermuda" (Bancroft 1883, vol.7:626). The Mosquito (now called Miskito) Indians mentioned in the above statement came from the British settlement located on the Pacific Coast area of present-day Nicaragua. The Miskitos had become the allies of the British against the Spaniards and, in exchange, had acquired certain privileges, for example the right to crown their kings in the Cathedral of Belize. British lumbermen moved freely between the two settlements until 1787, when the British had to evacuate the Miskito Coast. At that time, some 2,000 British, their African slaves, and Miskito allies moved to the Bay of Honduras to join the "Old Baymen" as the British Bay settlers called themselves (Escure 1983a:30). Miskito Indians merged with the rest of the population (they have also become Afro-Indians in Nicaragua), although many Belizeans still refer to them by the term Waika (generally as a derogatory term). On September 10, 1798, the Spaniards were defeated by the Old Baymen at the Battle of St. George's Cay, which is commemorated as Belize's National Day. Yet, it was not until 1862 that British Honduras became a colony; it became a Crown colony in 1871. Slavery was abolished in 1838, but freedmen were unable to acquire land because land ownership was monopolized by a very small num ber of absentee corporate landlords. The forests had been practically exhausted in northern Belize, and the country's economy could not be adequately converted to agriculture. Today, agriculture-related occupations involve only 5% of the popu lation now, with 42.4% stating that they have never worked. As indicated in tables 2.2, 2.3, and 2.5, the Creole population, which was a long-time majority group, has now slipped to second place after the Spanish-speaking Mestizo group, great ly expanded by recent Central American immigration.
34
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
2.3 Garifuna (Black Caribs) The ethnolinguistic composition of the Belizean population was further modi fied in the first part of the nineteenth century. The first significant event was the arrival, starting in 1803, of the "Black Caribs," a group of Afro-Indians whose native name is Garinagu, though they are now officially called Garifuna (the Arawakan term for their language). However, the anglicized terms Carib for the language, and Carib or Black Carib for the people, are still used freely and without negative connotations by the Garifuna-speaking Garinagu.7 The Garifuna group arose from the miscegenation of Arawak and Island Carib Indians with some African maroons who had been shipwrecked on the island of St. Vincent in 1635. After a failed uprising, supportėd by the French, the Garifuna were deported by the British in 1797 to the island of Roatan off the coast of Honduras. Most of them then moved to the coastal areas of Honduras (near La Ceiba and Tela), south to Nicaragua (Bluefields area), or north to Guatemala (Livingston) and to the Toledo and Stann Creek districts of Belize. The largest Garifuna town in Belize is Dangriga, the population of which was 6,435 in 1991 out of 18,085 for the entire Stann Creek district. Dangriga (previously called Stann Creek, like the district) was founded in 1823 by a group who had sided with the losing royalist cause against the republican gov ernment of Honduras. In 1939, other Garifuna fled the Honduran village of San Juan, again for political reasons, and founded the village of Hopkins, just south of Dangriga in Belize. There are now six Garifuna communities in Belize: Dangriga, Punta Gorda, Barranco, Seine Bight,8 Hopkins, and Georgetown— the only inland village, founded by Hopkins inhabitants after the destructive hurricane Hattie (Hopkins now has a sparse population). African phenotypical characteristics predominate in the Garifuna, who are physically indistinguish able from the darkest Creoles. Their African heritage is mostly represented in the folklore, whereas the Amerindian component has been preserved primarily in their native language, Garifuna, which is mostly Arawakan in structure (Taylor 1977), and will be briefly outlined at the end of this chapter. 2.4 Mestizos Another significant event leading to greater ethnolinguistic diversity was the Indian Caste War (1847-1853) in Mexico which led to a heavy migration of Yucatecan Mayas and Mestizos (Spanish/Indians) from Yucatan into the north ern (Corozal and Orange Walk) and western (Cayo) districts of Belize. Mexican Mestizos have continuously trickled in, many settling as fishermen on some of the islands off the northern coast of Belize in Ambergris Caye and Caye Caulker, for example.
THE BELIZEAN SPEECH COMMUNITY
35
The most recent wave of Mestizo/Hispanic immigrants consists of Salvadoran and Guatemalan refugees who started moving to Belize in the 1980s in order to escape their country's civil wars and political persecution. They have been greeted by the Belizean government as a welcome substitute for a consis tently depleted Belizean population due to massive economic emigration to the United States. They especially fulfill a dire need for agricultural workers in the banana and citrus plantations of the Stann Creek District, where they have settled in hastily built shantytowns. If not yet into a torrent, the Pania9 trickle has at least turned into a regular ly flowing stream, which is currently changing the ethnic and linguistic composi tion of Belize, turning at least half of the country into a Spanish-speaking nation. The other half—part of which I will be investigating—is still predominantly the domain of English and Creole. 2.5 Other groups Other ethnic groups arrived at different times to fill the need for indentured labor. The Chinese came from the southern Guangdong province of China in the 1860s to find labor; now, most own small businesses in Belize-City (dry goods stores or restaurants). They have preserved close ties with their ancestral coun try, especially with Hong Kong and the Guangdong province of the Peoples' Republic of China and, thus, speak Cantonese even now. Many still bring their wives from China through the age-old tradition of prearranged marriage.10 East Indians came shortly thereafter, in the 1880s, though not by choice. They were Sepoy soldiers, deported to Belize by the British after an aborted revolt against British rule in 1857. The British showed consistency in sending unwanted rebels twice to the backwaters of Belize (first, the Black Caribs, then the Sepoy), an attitude toward the forlorn colony obviously reflected in Huxley's quote which introduced this chapter. The East Indians mostly eked out a meagre living on the southern sugar plantations of the Toledo District which had been offered as land grants by the Belizean government to a small number of Americans planters fleeing the United States after the Civil War. The East Indians are now largely assimilated to the Creoles, both linguistically and eth nically, and are concentrated near the city of Punta Gorda. American plantations generally have been abandoned. Some merchants of Middle-Eastern descent, mostly Lebanese (usually referred to as "Syrians") have settled in Belize, as elsewhere in the Caribbean, at various times during the nineteenth and twentieth centuries and have started small businesses which compete with the Chinese. A more recent wave of immigrants arrived in the 1950s, as German Mennonites from Canada and the United States established farming communities in the western part of Belize.
36
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
They rarely participate in the life of the country, restricting their interactions to market activities and to small businesses such as carpentry; many move on to other communities (in Central or South America) after a few years. As is the case elsewhere, they have preserved their Low German dialect. 3. The language situation Belize is certainly a multiethnic nation and can also be identified, overall, as a multilingual nation; yet, individual Belizeans are at most bilingual and usually monolingual, with superficial, if any, knowledge of some other language, as indicated by the census surveys reported above. Language use and the reasons for selection and code-switching vary from one region to the next and depend on the ethnic composition, the degree of interaction with other groups, the amount of education, and the relative status of each individual. As is usually the case in multiethnic societies, ethnocentricity and ethnic stereotypes exist and reflect the relative socioeconomic status of co-existing groups. Language choice is an accurate indicator of those attitudes. Since Creole is not officially recognized as distinct from English and is still overtly assigned a low value, one may wonder why it has so vigorously survived and is gaining prestige and a wider speakership. This vitality may be partly due to a "double standard" that has always prevailed in Creole societies. Even though the vernacular may be overtly denigrated by its very speakers and avoided for certain outgroup con tacts (see 4.2.3 below), it remains covertly—and sometimes overtly—presti gious and highly valued as a marker of ethnic identity and increasingly as a marker of Belizean national identity. Such a situation entails an almost schizo phrenic mechanism that requires subtle code-shifting based on a precise assess ment of the social situation (Hellinger 1972). 3.1 Language policy and education The official language of Belize is English. English may be unanimously recog nized as the language that one must acquire to participate in official government activities, but it is not commonly used in its external (American or British) stan dard form. This fact is largely ignored or unidentified by both language users and language planners. Although there is a general, informal agreement as far as the creole end of the continuum is concerned, what constitutes the "correct" local norm called English—the acrolect—is realized differently by different people, and they are not necessarily aware of such variations. The official (and unoffi cial) position is that any "non-English" variety is brokop—broken English— which often includes the creole varieties as well as the mesolectal area of the
THE BELIZEAN SPEECH COMMUNITY
37
continuum. Such is the persistent legacy of colonialism. Thus, in spite of the fact that it is gaining speakers and prestige, Belizean Creole is still officially ignored. A typical list of the languages spoken in Belize, as seen on a sign posted at the entrance of Punta Gorda, includes: English, Spanish, Garifuna, Maya, and Kekchi, with the glaring omission of Creole. This is disturbing in view of the facts presented above, and in particular when considering that English is not the Belizeans' first language but a second language or dialect for practically all. The paradoxical coexistence of two varieties, one carrying overt prestige and the other covert prestige, is not an unusual phenomenon. Indeed, this situation occurs wherever a "dialect" competes with a "standard," an issue to be exten sively discussed in the following chapters. Official directives to instruct in the overtly prestigious model are naturally passed on to educators; yet, the overlap of the model and the vernacular predictably accounts for the linguistic complexity encountered by children in the classroom. Teachers are expected to teach English, and are believed to be teaching English, but they are often unsure of the exact nature of English as distinct from Creole; more commonly, they are unaware that there is any difference at all. Furthermore, they frequently control a limited segment of the acrolectal end of the continuum which, ironically, is the only segment that they are instructed to teach. Because of the scarcity of teachers, young teachers and teachers' aides are put to work imme diately after primary school, with little or no teacher training. They admit that they frequently switch to Creole in the classroom for more fluent explanations. Similar problems are involved in teaching basic subjects to non-Creole Belizean children. Because teachers are often recruited from among the Garinagu, the Maya-speaking children of a remote village are likely to be intro duced to reading and writing in English by a native speaker of Garifuna who does not know a word of Maya and who has modeled his or her English on the fluctuating varieties she or he has heard in school, on radio reports which pre sent BBC news and local news in Belizean standard, and on Billy Graham's homilies which reach the most distant villages. The resulting effect can only lead to the maintenance, or even the expansion, of the bewildering array of options which make up the creole continuum. For example, Juan, a sixteenyear-old Maya teacher from the Mopan village of San Antonio who had just started teaching in the Garinagu village of Seine Bight told me that he could not speak either Garifuna or Creole, although he could understand the latter, but felt comfortable with English: "Mos'ly, I fin' it difficult wid der language because dey only speak Carib" (3.2: 3). Dennis, a forty-five-year-old Garifuna teacher in the same village, made the following comments, which illustrate, first, the linguistic confusion that must result from the contradictory messages received by the children, and sec-
38
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
ond, the socio-psychological factors that determine language choice in the com munity at large: You start speaking English to dem [the children], then you give dem de definition in Creole which is much easier to dem because dats what dey hear around dem. Outside you find dat de majority of people, der parents speak Creole, dey speak Carib and Creole. When I first started teaching, while I spoke Creole intermittent, and finally I found out dat I spoke too much Creole, and den I put a stop to it because I had learned English. So I practice my English more. I practice it more even when I speak to my friends. So you would find out when I would stand in front of a class and I speak to dem, I try to speak as fluent as I can. When dey [my friends] speak Carib to me, I speak Carib. When dey speak Creole, I speak English to dem, dats de way I treat dem, right? (3.1: 3). But, later in the conversation, he says: Let's say I go among some friends and, like, we going to have a fine time. Okay, de boys start talking and all everybody just discussing Creole. So instead of trying to make myself feel, or try to show off myself dat I am a better man or I am different dan all o' dem, I associate myself wid dem. So I speak Creole, understan'? So nobody can just say he talk funny, he must be from a different land. Ya understan'? I play when you are in Rome you do like the Romans do. (3.1: 10). Of course, the cost of training teachers to achieve proficiency in English and to acquire a sound methodology for teaching English as a second language or dialect is no small problem, and Belize is still a long way from solving it. It seems, however, that a first significant step would be to recognize the separateness of English and Creole, their distinct linguistic and social values, and in par ticular to recognize the intrinsic value of Creole as a linguistic system in its own right. In the recent past, government policies have acknowledged the existence and cultural heritage of the Maya, Garinagu, and Mestizo communities, thus encouraging the use of Maya, Garifuna, and Spanish in school and in local pub lic events. The traditional November 19 celebration of the first Carib settlement in Belize has become another Belizean national holiday earning full coverage in the local mass media. In 1985, Radio Belize broadcast an average of three to four hours in Spanish out of a total seventeen hours; however, earlier attempts at using Creole on the mass media (short programs, storytelling on Radio
THEBELIZEAN SPEECH COMMUNITY
39
Belize, and brief articles in local press) have been discontinued. 3.2 English and the Creole continuum In spite of the official designation of English as the language of choice, English is not anyone's native language in Belize. Since the goal of this study is to exam ine how English is acquired by speakers of related dialects, in particular by native speakers of the English based creole, an essential prerequisite is to define the patterns which characterize Belizean Creole. Only then will it be possible to interpret potential differences between the target model and the version achieved by its learners. 3.2.1 Putative origins of Creole The variety which is overall the most widely spoken in Belize is, undoubtedly, Belizean Creole, the English-based creole which is the vernacular of the Creole (Afro-European) group. Like other Caribbean creoles, Belizean Creole proba bly developed from contacts between Africans and Europeans who emigrated to the American continent. It also ftmctions as the lingua franca for most Belizeans of various ethnic origins. The sociohistorical outline presented in pre vious sections suggests that the African slaves were imported via the Miskito Coast, Jamaica, or other Caribbean islands such as Barbados, which served as a stepping-stone for British colonization (Alleyne 1980:23). Once in Belize, those slaves either created ab ovo the language which was to become Belizean Creole, or they may have brought with them some form of English-based pid gin or creole. It is also possible that the pidgin developed through earlier con tacts between Africans and Europeans along the West African coast (Hancock 1980 assumes a Proto-Creole originating in the Upper Guinea Coast). However, it is practically impossible to ascertain with any degree of accuracy the under lying components of Belizean Creole, both because of the complex population movements which occurred in the area and because of the absence of historical linguistic and demographic documentation. Such paucity of data is largely due to the traditionally low status assigned to creoles as the vernacular languages of a long oppressed group. It is one of the tantalizing mysteries presented by cre le languages that, even though they are very recent languages, so little is known of their precise origins, and thus, practically any interpretation is specu lative.11 In this respect, Belizean Creole is no different from other creoles; in fact, its origins may be more difficult to trace because so many ethnic groups were involved in its development. Although the focus of this study is on the cur rent status of some selected segments of creole continua rather than on their ori gin, it is useful to briefly review current theories of creole genesis, as they illu-
40
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
minate possibilities in developmental processes (a comprehensive critical overview appears in Arenas et al. 1995:87-134). Proponents of the monogenesis of pidgin and creole formation hold that all creoles have a common origin. The earlier interpretation assumed predomi nantly European (superstrate) linguistic influences, dating back to fifteenth- or sixteenth-century European arrivals. According to this perspective, the ancestor of creoles may have been either a nautical lingua franca or a Portuguese-based version of the Medieval Mediterranean trade language (Sabir), later relexified. The nautical element may have been acquired by slaves in Africa or during their sea voyage between Africa and America, or it may even have been borrowed through contacts with white colonists after their arrival in the Caribbean (den Besten, Muysken & Smith 1995:92-93). Some nautical lexical items are evident in most Belizean lects. Terms now obsolete in Standard English are in common use; in particular, frequent function words are likely to have originated in Scottish or other Northern English dialects, such as yonder 'over there,' pan
THE BELIZEAN SPEECH COMMUNITY
41
contact, as predicted by the bioprogram hypothesis (Bickerton 1981). As briefly outlined in chapter one (2.1), the bioprogram is hypothesized to be an innate set of features which emerge in dramatic contact situations where the learner has no adequate exposure or time to learn a new language and is therefore forced to use his own (biolinguistic) resources. However, most lin guists now seem to adopt mitigated positions which involve recognizing that both superstratal, especially dialectal, and substratai influences contributed to the formation of creoles (Mufwene 1986; Rickford 1987 inter alia). This polygenetic interpretation of pidgin and creole genesis posits a diverse origin, assuming that each of the languages involved in colonizing situations deter mined the development of related pidgins and creoles. For example, on the basis of the study of several morphological and syntactic features, Corne (1995a) argues for the transfer of substratai Melanesian conceptualizations in the build ing of Tayo, a French-lexicon language spoken in St. Louis, New Caledonia, which developed in the last 150 years. Yet, this substrate influence results in an entirely new code: Tayo is "in no way a modification of French, nor a relexification of Melanasian language but. . .it is a new creation which is typologically Melanesian" (Corne 1995a:20), or at least "has been deeply influenced by Melanesian conceptualizations" (Corne, personal communication). This "cre ative" interpretation presents a valid explanation of developmental aspects of pidgins or creoles, one that will prove helpful in explaining the emergence of second dialects, such as acrolects in Belize. 3.2.2 Lectal range Defining what constitutes "the creole," even in the specific context of Belize, is a difficult challenge. The term creole is an abstract construct which has no clearly identifiable boundaries. Creoles are typically embedded within complex language continua. For example, the Belizean continuum consists of overlapping Englishbased varieties ranging over a wide spectrum whose extreme poles can be identi fied as 1) Creole and 2) English.13 As is the case in other parts of the Caribbean, the labels "creole" (or "pidgin") and "English" do not accurately refer to the var ieties involved. They merely indicate some abstract contrast which is part of the competence of the Caribbean speaker. Different individuals may produce quite different linguistic forms that they would refer to as "creole" and "English," depending on 1) sociogeographical factors (exposure to, respectively the local variety and the outside norm), 2) educational factors (the higher the education level reached, the more the likelihood that the English model is known), and 3) psychological factors (language attitudes determine choices among the varieties available). All three types of factors are intimately interrelated. The creole includes various basilects spoken as vernaculars (first dialects)
42
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
and is often unintelligible to speakers of a standard English (American or British). In Belize, it is sometimes referred to as "raw" or "broad" creole, espe cially by the inhabitants of the main city, Belize-City, when referring, somewhat deprecatingly, to the language spoken da bush—in rural areas. These basilectal varieties are overtly characterized by a limited but distinctive morphology, especially involving special preverbal markers of TMA systems, with an emphasis on aspectual categories. The phonological inventory is also signifi cantly different from that of standard English. Furthermore, the syntax presents interesting idiosyncracies in a more covert way, which spread throughout the entire spectrum to the uppermost acrolects, as will be discussed below. The acrolectal end of the spectrum, commonly called "English," also differs in impor tant ways from models external to Belize, such as British or American English var ieties. Hence, the term acrolect, briefly defined in chapter one as a set of local stan dards distinctly different from external models, is fully justified to represent such varieties; although apparently modeled on English, the acrolect displays several non-English features, such as topic structures and serialized verbal forms. A more comprehensive discussion of acrolects is provided in chapter three. Between the basilectal varieties, natively spoken in various degrees by urban and rural Creoles, and the acrolectal end of the spectrum, officially pre sented as the norm or linguistic target but interpreted in widely different ways, there is a vague intermediate area called the mesolect, with linguistic and social characteristics of its own. Linguistically, it is identified by an absence of basilectal and acrolectal markers, or it may show redundancy in the use of both types of markers, although these occurrences may be erratic (Escure 1982; 1983b; 1984). Mesolects, which constitute "deviations" from the basilects and are typi cally marked by morphological substitutions, are not necessarily indicative of the Creole speaker's step toward the acquisition of the correct English or an unsuccessful attempt at mastering the prestigious standard, although it may be either. In most cases, the mesolect has a special and distinctive value which denotes a rejection of the social values associated with either the basilectal or the acrolectal ends of the continuum. In Belizean social contacts, the mesolect constitutes an effective, subtle instrument of communication in non-peer con tacts, whether in in-group or out-group contexts. For example, whereas the "raw" creole is appropriate during informal and spontaneous in-group contacts, and the acrolect reserved for professional situations or very formal speech events, the use of a variety stripped of both creole and standard features is appropriate in semiformal speech events, such as interaction with respected members of the Creole community or with members of another ethnic group, such as the Garifuna (see 4.2.2 below). Thus, the use of the mesolect typically
43
THE BELIZEAN SPEECH COMMUNITY
marks a certain social distance, reflecting either deference, especially with elders, or lack of familiarity, diffidence, even disapproval or dislike, especially with members of a different ethnic group. 4. Focus on the Stann Creek district Since this investigation of Belizean Creole is restricted primarily to the commu nities of Placencia and Seine Bight in the Stann Creek district, a southern section of the country, it is relevant to quote the census figures surveying ethnic group (table 2.6) and language distribution (table 2.7) in the Stann Creek district: Table 2.6: Ethnic distribution in Stann Creek district (Pop: 17,477) Creole 25%
Garifuna 36.2%
Mestizo 23.7%
Maya Mopan 6.8%
Kekchi 1.1%
Indian 3.8%
Table 2.7: Stated language fluency in Stann Creek district
Speak English Speak Spanish
Very well 56.2% 26.0%
Not so well 23.5% 9.3%
Not at all 20.4% 64.7%
Of the six Belizean districts, the Stann Creek district has the most evenly distributed percentages of the major ethnic groups. It also has the highest per centage in the country of Garifuna people (36.2%) and the second highest of Creoles (25.1%).14 As far as the language situation is concerned, the stated flu ency in English is the same in the Stann Creek district as throughout the coun try (table 2.4), despite the different distribution of ethnic groups in all six dis tricts (table 2.5). The combined Creole, Garifuna, and East-Indian population in the Stann Creek district, amounting to almost 70% of the population of the Stann Creek pop ulation, roughly corresponds to the number of individuals claiming excellent or lesser fluency in English (around 80%) and concomitantly lacking fluency in Spanish (65%). The "not so well" category is likely to reflect distinct individual definitions of what constitutes English. Garifuna individuals typically claim that they speak English and not Creole, whereas Creoles are more concerned with the fine distinctions between the different codes in use, as discussed above. On the other hand, the small number of Mestizos in Stann Creek (23.7%), relative to the northern districts, corresponds to the number of people claiming excellent Spanish fluency (with the addition of a few Mayas). Because of the design of the language
44
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
questions, it is, however, impossible to determine the respective roles of English and Creole in daily communication and whether Creole or Garifuna people are most likely to consider themselves fluent in English. 4.1 Placencia and Seine Bight According to the 1991 census, rural Stann Creek has an official population of 11,650, showing an increase of about 4,000 during the last ten years. This pop ulation increase, however, has not visibly affected the two small Stann Creek rural/coastal communities of Placencia and Seine Bight. The overall increase of the Belizean population is due to immigrants from neighboring Spanish-speak ing Central American countries, who usually do not settle on Stann Creek coastal areas. The overall population in Placencia (about 400) and Seine Bight (about 500) has remained remarkably stable, which does not exclude population movement; some individuals emigrate and others return home, thus maintain ing the overall balance. Placencia and Seine Bight are located on sandy, coconut-lined beaches about five miles apart on the Caribbean coast, on a long, narrow strip of land running parallel to the mainland and separated from it by a lagoon. Placencia is built at the very southern tip of the peninsula, around a graceful sheltered bay (said to have been a pirates' refuge) punctuated and protected by Placencia Caye, a small island (called a caye/key, from Spanish cayo). This geographical location caused the two communities to be very isolated, and reachable only by a six-hour trip by bus on a dirt road from Belize-City to Mango Creek, followed by a canoe trip across the lagoon. Since 1993, however, Placencia, and Seine Bight to a lesser extent, have begun giving in to the lucrative mirage of tourism: an airstrip near Placencia has been built and a new dirt road now provides direct (two-hour) access from Dangriga along the peninsula, enabling trucks to bring building materials and food supplies. This easier access is changing the appear ance and economy of the area, especially in Placencia. The airy wooden hous es on stilts, which used to provide safety in times of floods and hurricanes, are now modified to accommodate backpackers. Cubicles for tourists are built on the ground floors of several houses, thus putting an end to a traditional favorite leisure activity of the village, namely, lying in hammocks under the breezy, shady space underneath the house and indulging in gossip with friends and rel atives. Increasingly, men abandon their traditionally prosperous fishing activi ties to launch into what is perceived as the more lucrative occupations of tourist guides or hotel workers. Such changes are on-going, and there is no obvious impact on the language situation yet, as attested to by this study, but the situa tion bears watching. These areas were selected in the late 1970s because of their isolation and the particular dynamics linking Placencia and Seine Bight.
THE BELÍZEAN SPEECH COMMUNITY
45
Placencia has a homogeneous Creole population, which used to function smoothly around a self-contained prosperous economy based on fishing. Men would go away to the cayes along the coral barrier reef for one or two weeks at a time, catching fish or skin diving with special hooks for lobster and returning to the village with a full load, which was then processed and exported through the local fishing cooperative. Women would work at the cooperative and take care of the households and the organization of village life during the men's absence. Seine Bight is ethnically and economically different from Placencia. Its population, one of the original Black Carib settlements from Honduras, is almost exclusively Garifuna, with the exception of two or three Maya families who recently moved there from an inland village. Although fishing and raising some limited crops (in particular cassava) have long been subsistence activities in Seine Bight, they have never been done on a sufficiently organized scale to sustain the local population, as in Placencia. Garifuna men and women either work on neighboring banana or citrus plantations, try their luck in other parts of the country, training as teachers or police officers, or emigrate to the United States, sending paychecks to the older women who typically raise several gen erations of children. Another means of support for Seine Bight inhabitants, especially in the 1980s, involved working for the Creoles in Placencia. To do so, Seine Bight men and women would walk four to five miles to and from Placencia each day. Their work included a variety of menial tasks (cutting bush, cleaning fish, washing clothes) which clearly placed the Garifuna in a lower social position vis-a-vis the Creoles of Placencia. Such interactive patterns between Creoles and Garifuna are particularly interesting as they document the fimction of social factors in the development of language patterns (Escure 1982; 1983b; 1984). In the context of Placencia, where Creoles were always secure in their identity and relative comfort, the local Creole language is strongly associated with friendship, solidarity, and folk culture which are more highly valued than the external values of education and refinement asso ciated with English. This general sense of security is reflected in the graceful hos pitality which I associate with Placencia, and probably explains why the acquain tances and friends I made in Placencia over the years were from the very begin ning readily cooperative and supportive, though often amused, at my efforts to learn about and tape-record their speech. Since they already had an innate sense of pride in their local history, they were delighted to note an outsider's interest in the language which they always valued in reaction to official efforts to put down vernacular forms as "brokop." They assign strong values to their "mixed" genet ics, which they attribute to the hospitality extended by Africans over the years to French and English pirates, then to German, Spanish, and Portuguese expatriates
46
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
among others, often through the conduit of their connections with relatives in Roatan, one of the Bay islands of Honduras, and especially the village of West End in that island. Their "hybrid" awareness and identity is displayed in the var ious shades of skin, eye, and hair color is evident throughout the village, and not uncommonly in members of the very same family.15 The respondents, whose speech samples I have used in previous publica tions and in this work, range across all age groups and types of status. There is no socio-economic discrepancy in Placencia of the type found in urban Western societies (upper, middle, and lower/working classes). There are, however, local status differences linked to history. For example, at least four families hold a certain "status" and most of the land in the village because they were the founders of the community. Yet, a person's family affiliation does not translate visibly into privileged economic or social treatment. Other factors defining local status and respectability include age, leadership in village administration, and personal behavior. Placencia is a tolerant society which accepts personal weaknesses, as long as they do not interfere with the public order. For example, regular drinking is tolerated, but regular unruly behavior linked to intoxication is frowned upon and despised. Similarly, sexual escapades are common and a favorite topic of local gossip. Early pregnancies are not uncommon, and young girls' children are well taken care of by the immediate or extended family; how ever, a girl who leaves her children behind with her mother too often while attending the local drinking holes will acquire a bad reputation and may even tually be forced to leave. Although the village is nominally Anglican, the little circular church by the sea is rarely attended by more than a couple of older women. The Anglican Church even discontinued the appointment of the resident priest who lived in Placencia in the 1980s. There are, however, a few dedicated "Seventh Day Adventists": one of them, T, now in her 80's, is also one of the most interesting characters in the village, who holds a special status in Placencia. Throughout her life, she was the village's sole healer and midwife, providing the only medical care available, delivering most of the current inhabitants of the village, and administering cures to various kinds of physical and psychological illnesses through every possible means, whether antibiotics, herbs, obeah, or prayers. She is highly respected and loved and was awarded a special decoration by the Queen during the monarch's visit to Belize in March 1995. Her most endearing quality is her special gift for telling stories, with a general predilection for mesolectal forms, which seems to reflect her unique mediating role in the village. Seine Bight is still perceived by the Creoles as an immigrant grouping, without community roots and without status. The Creole attitude toward the Garifuna is typically scornful and supercilious; this is not lost on the Garifuna,
THE BELIZEAN SPEECH COMMUNITY
47
who hold in return a certain resentment toward the Creoles. The fact that the Garifuna are often destitute and without stable economic activity, and in part dependent on the Creoles for their survival, has contributed to this stereotype. The situation has somewhat improved for the Garifuna, some of whom now work as employees in the new small hotels. Today, the Garifuna take the bus instead of walking to Placencia, and they no longer wash clothes for Placencia women, pri marily because washing machines have been recently introduced. The last episode in this mutual dependence is linked to the development of tourism. Whereas traditional Carib drums (essentially an African tradition) were previous ly scorned by the Creoles and restricted to the village of Seine Bight as a local form of entertainment, Placencia's new entrepreneurs have discovered that tourists like Carib drums and punta (the Garifuna dance); therefore, they hire Seine Bight drummers and dancers to come and perform in Placencia. Thus, Garifuna life has been, and still is, separate but intermingled with Creole life. The distinctiveness of their language has always been an advantage that the Garifuna have had over the Creoles. They can have verbal exchanges in the presence of the Creoles, often at the latter's expense. On the other hand, they are able to communicate in Creole, which they informally learn through their regular interactions and probably pass on early to their children. Thus, children become fluent in Creole prior to primary education and certainly before they are exposed to English. Creole is established early in life as a functional variety with high local prestige value, at least for younger generations, and perhaps also for others. Most older Garifuna people in Seine Bight appear to embrace the official disparagement of the creole language, perhaps because it is a convenient excuse to assert the superiority of their own "real" language; they overtly claim their respect for English as opposed to Creole, which often results in hypercorrected forms of English, laughed at, in turn, by Placencia Creoles who feel they know better. This clearly shows that the language situation serves as an accurate mir ror of social and economic conflicts. Yet, there are also those who, like Dermis the teacher, are sensitive to the appropriateness of linguistic adjustments: ". . .1 associate myself wid dem; so I speak Creole, understan'? so nobody can just say he talk funny. . . . " The acceptance and increased use of Creole is reinforced by the fact that the Garifuna have traditionally held a social status inferior to that of the Creoles. Such attitudes are still evident in many subtle ways in group interaction despite the recent trend toward the rehabilitation of Garinagu culture and the Garifuna language. Garifuna holds in-group prestige among its members (usually older) who are intent on preserving traditional cultural values (songs, festivities, wakes, etc.) and who use it for daily interaction in the villages. Yet, Creole can
48
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
be heard more than occasionally among Gariftma children, and some young parents encourage them to speak Creole and English rather than Garifuna. Increasingly, Garifuna teenagers seem to favor the creole over their ancestral language, and they may no longer have this unique linguistic advantage. Furthermore, there appears to be a recent, and not altogether positive, link developing between Creole and Garifuna teenagers with the arrival of crack cocaine in the area, the concomitant novel occurrence of crime in a previously peaceful area, and the construction of a drug rehab center north of Seine Bight (which local inhabitants suspect to be in fact a drug distribution center). In 1995, Placencia and Seine Bight have lost their innocence. 4. 2 Samples of Belizean texts The linguistic flexibility available to the Placencia and Seine Bight population in spontaneous situations is illustrated in the following speech samples which represent each of the three general segments of the continuum. Speech data were collected in the context of natural conversations during fieldwork done between 1979 and 1994. The samples provided below are derived from conver sations collected in the 1980s. A longitudinal comparison will be presented in the following chapters. 4.2.1 Text 1: Basilect In the following conversation, a Creole woman (S, 43) talks about the profes sional future of her son (R, 24) to a visiting friend (E, 26). It is an informal inter action, since the participants are long-time acquaintances (R and E are child hood friends): 1. S: 2. 3. 4. E: 5. S: 6. E: 7. 8. S:
R. wan tek wan korespondens cos, i me wan tek it befor i kum out i me ds plan fu tek it dat da ti taim de term don, di kos don. a tink i se i wuda me wan kos ina akountin. dat expensive. i kuda me get wan jab da Big Krik, bot dat agen da wan problem. dat da onli paat taim, do. Grif me de tel mi bout da ting, tu. i soun laik da onli wen de banana sizan de aan. Yes da onli den, bot dat de aan wan gud wail, tu.
Translation 1.S: 2.
R. will take a correspondence course, he will have completed it before school is over. He was planning to take it so that by the time the term is over the course will be over too.
THE BELIZEAN SPEECH COMMUNITY 3. 4. E: 5. S: 6. E: 7. 8. S:
49
I think he said he would have done a course in accounting. That's expensive. He could have got a job at Big Creek, but that again is a problem. That's only part time, though. Grif told me about that, too. It sounds like that's only for the banana season. Yes, it's only then, but that lasts a good while, too.
Linguistic characteristics of the basilect represented in text 1 include: 1.
2. 3. 4.
5.
the use of the creole past or anterior morpheme me, which can also com bine with the continuous aspect marker de for continuous past, as in i de plan (line 2), with the future marker wan (z me wan tek, line 1), or with a modal for irrealis/past conditional (z kuda me get, line 5); the absence of inflectional morphology, e.g., the nonmarking of tense/ per son/number as in i kum out (line 1) 1 6 ; the absence of copula {dat expensive, line 4; da wan problem, line 5); the use of de as locative or existential verb {when de banana sizan de aan, line 8 (literally, 'when the banana season is on' e.g., 'when the bananas are ripe'); and the extensive use of focusing expressions with da/dat, which is used as a deictic pronoun, as in da onli den and bot dat de aan (both on line 8).
4.2.2 Text 2: Mesolect in Creole/Carib interaction In this conversation, a Creole fisherman (R) from the village of Placencia talks with a Garifuna man (A) from the neighboring village of Seine Bight and a Creole/Lebanese man (L) from Belize-City: 1. R: 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. L: 7. A: 8. 9. 10. R: 11. 12. 13. 14.
a se, mai Bobo, we da fran, wen i kom op, i kech some gud, en wen i kom op, en i kom outa di wata ina de bout, di blodi stingre i bring out—gaan, sok it op pa mi breda. di bon went rait in, en i kudn get it. yu no samtaim dey juk yu, i gat it gud. di paizan grupa dey no kom in so kloz, do. yu si, wat ar yu keshin en di lain aal, if yu straik dem wid a haapun put di haapun aal iz, laik, stan op—jos laik bon laik it iz nat di wan dat kal flain fish? di mantare, doz ting ar ogli. Dey hav a saata haan, en dey hav tu red, red blood, red aiz. Bot doz tingz ar ogli. Mi breda se waz daivin out, i de wid iz hukstik, rait, i lukin doun aroun di rak, trai huk op a krefish, rait, en wen i luk op, dis big ting waz rait, rait yu ar fra mi.
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
50 Translation 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14.
I say, my Bobo, in front, when he came up, he had caught something, and when he came up, when he came out of the water into the boat, the bloody stingray that he brought out was attached to my brother. the bone [sting] had gone right in [his foot], and he couldn't get it out. you know, sometimes dey stab you, it was pretty bad. The poison grouper, they don't come so close, though. you see, what you catch with the line and all, if you strike them with a harpoon the way to throw the harpoon is to stand up—just like a spear Isn't it the one they call flying fish? The manta rays, those things are ugly. They have a sort of horn, and they have two red, bloody red, red eyes. Those things are ugly. My brother said that he was diving out there, he had his hookstick, he was looking down around the reef, trying to hook up a lobster, and when he looked up, this big thing was right there, [about as close as] you are from me].
Mesolects are intermediate varieties, linguistically as well as socially (see 2.3). They often constitute a compromise between an overly formal speech and an inappropriately informal or friendly mode, and the linguistic structure of mesolects reflects the delicate nature of such situations. Mesolects can, thus, be divided into three general subtypes: 1.
2.
3.
First, they may include primarily neutral variants, stripped of both acrolectal and basilectal features. This would imply that the mesolect speaker knows of the existence of such features and controls those other marked varieties but has determined not to make full use of them. On the other hand, mesolects sometimes include a combination of basilec tal and acrolectal features, which may be interpreted as a certain hesitancy in the choice of the most appropriate code, as is clearly reflected in text 2. There is another possible combination of acrolectal and basilectal variants which leads to redundancy or hypercorrection rather than to alternation as in the second subtype. This variety of mesolect is more likely to indicate insufficient control of both ends of the continuum, or at least of the acrolectal end, and is more typically found in native speakers of languages other than Creole, as is the case with the Garinagu man in text 2.
Text 2 illustrates such sociolinguistic ambiguities. There is a social dis tance between A, a fífty-fíve-year-old Garinagu man who works menial jobs in
THE BELIZEAN SPEECH COMMUNITY
51
the Creole village of Placencia, and the two young Creole men, both in their mid-twenties, who had been schoolmates in Belize-City. L, who belongs to the middle-class, is visiting his friend R, a fisherman's son in Placencia. On the one hand, age demands respect for the older man, but his ethnic membership, low paying job, and lack of formal education assign him a lower status. On the other hand, L brings with him the relative status of the "city-dweller." The linguistic choices evident in all three participants reflect the ambiguity of the situation and the conflicting power struggle underlying variants of the mesolect. Thus, R, the first Creole speaker, initially produces a primarily unmarked mesolect (lines 1-5) of the first type, with zero marking for past tense (with the exception of went in line 4) and zero copula but also an absence of basilectal morphemes. The second part of his conversation (lines 10-14) belongs to the second mesolectal type, with the coexistence of English copular forms (lines 10, 11,13, 14), the basilectal copula/locative de (i de wid iz hukstik, line 12), and of zero copula combined with progressive -ing for the aspectual form i lukin also in }ine 12. This apparent inconsistency may indicate an attempt at linguistic con vergence, in response to A's language (lines 7-9) which includes three struc turally hypercorrect copular forms, such as the preposing of the auxiliary in a cleft construction in line 7, which, furthermore, uses a progressive English form to refer to a habitual action (wat aryu keshin 'what you catch'). Similarly, the absence of copular contraction on line 9 (it iz nat di wan. . .) indicates a hypercorrect level of formality which often occurs in Garinagu interpretation of English. Garifuna phonological interference is also reflected in the form keshin showing the substitution of the palatal fricative for the affricate, since A has no /č/ in his native system. Throughout this sample, and in spite of the various mesolectal interpreta tions just discussed, the creole syntax is preserved through focusing devices such as left dislocation (e.g., mai Bobo. . i kech some gud. . ., line 1; di paizan grupa dey no kum in. . ., line 6) and clefting (line 7) as well as adverbial fronting (lines 1, 2, 5). 4.2.3 Text 3: Acrolect The acrolect is usually considered to represent the Creole speaker's best approximation of the standard model, in this case English. Since chapter three is primarily dedicated to acrolects, only a short sample is provided here. It is an excerpt from an Anglican service in the Creole village of Placencia, and the speaker is P, the Creole "priest" (as Anglican ministers are called in Belize): P:
1. The Jews were expecting someone to come to redeem them. 2. But because Jesus did not fulfill their requirements,
52
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA 3. in other words, they wanted a military rula 4. like how dey had known it in de days of Salomon and David. 5. Yes, dey were expecting, how do you call it, 6. let's call it someone den who would willing to take up arms. 7. In oda wods, de reason why I believe dat Judas betrayed Jesus, 8. Jesus did not, you see, Judas was trying to push Jesus in da corna, right?
A religious service, and in particular a sermon with biblical references, is a situation that requires the most formal style available. However, this acrolectal sample is different from English and reveals occasional Creole interference, especially when the preacher extrapolates from biblical quotations. For exam ple, note the absence of the auxiliary in who would willing (line 6), the hypercorrect use of progressive aspectual forms such as were expecting (lines 1 & 5) and was trying (line 8), as well as the frequent phonological substitution of the dental stop for the interdental. 4.3 Garifuna A brief overview of Garifuna is included because its speakers constitute an important minority in the area under investigation, interact frequently with the Creoles, and necessarily learn or teach segments of the creole continuum. There are additional reasons why some aspects of Garifuna must be highlighted. For example, differences perceived in the Garifuna people's English-based varieties (from basilects to acrolects), as compared to the Creoles' versions could possi bly be traced back to structural elements of Garifuna; on the other hand, if acrolectal forms produced by the Garifuna are similar to those spoken by native Creoles, they might provide support for a universal interpretation of the pat terning of second dialect/language acquisition. Taylor (1951; 1955; 1956a; 1956b; 1958; 1977) and Stochl (1975) provide extensive descriptions of Garifuna, refering to it as Central American Island Carib. It is an Arawakan language closely related to Arawak (Lokono) which, due to the historical events mentioned earlier, has borrowed lexical forms from Carib (Karina), Spanish, French, and English, in that order of temporal sequence and influence. As indicated above, the key event was the deportation of those AfroIndians from the Lesser Antilles, especially St. Vincent and Dominica to the Bay Islands of Honduras (there are still Carib villages on the north coast of the island of Roatan). Some general characteristics of Garifuna that are likely to surface in its speakers' usage of English or Creole include the following. 4.3.1 Phonological features of Garifuna As far as the phonological inventory is concerned, Garifuna lacks the voiceless
THE BELIZEAN SPEECH COMMUNITY
53
palatal affricate, which leads to frequent interference between /š/ and /č/ throughout the continuum, thus producing [f i č] for fish or [d i š] for ditch. This is perhaps the most noticeable feature identifying a Garifuna native to other members of the Belizean community, even if she or he is a fluent speaker of Creole or English. Garifuna is also characterized by the absence of the velar nasal (but has a palatal nasal as well as the bilabial and the alveolar), and of the lax vowels. The latter features are represented in the Garifuna people's produc tion of the continuum but do not differentiate them from other ethnic groups, since speakers of Creole, Mayan, and Spanish also lack lax vowels, Spanish lacks the velar nasal, and Creole only uses it occasionally in acrolects. Indeed, the West Indian standard does not contrast lax and tense high and mid vowels (Alleyne 1980; Escure 1978). 4.3.2 Morphological features of Garifuna The morphology of Garifuna includes a wide range of affixes: prefixes and suf fixes for personal pronouns, attributive and privative prefixes, plural suffixes for animate beings only, some gender morphemes (see below), and aspect/tense markers that combine similarly with verbs and adjectives. Thus, Garifuna treats verbs and adjectives as a single grammatical class, as illustrated for the adjec tive mani 'quiet' and the verb ariha 'see' and in sentences (1) and (2):
Progressive Future
mani 'quiet' maninau 'she is being quiet' manibaun 'she will be quiet'
ariha 'see' narihinau 'I am seeing her' tarihubaun 'she will see her'
1) Bidiba arabaun haruga? Mafuna. Will you go to the bush tomorrow? Maybe. 2) Nichugubai baun ladega uaraguatibu. I'll give it to you because you are honest.
Like Garifuna, but unlike English, Creole uses adjectives like verbs: there is no copula before adjectives (i sick), including contexts with future and past markers: 3) i wan sick [s/he+ future + sick] 's/he will be sick' 4) i me sick [s/he+ past anterior+ sick] 's/he had been sick'
54
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
In this respect, Garifuna and Creole function similarly, and Garifuna speakers can be expected to have no problem learning those Creole patterns. However, there is a difference involving the progressive aspectual marker which can mod ify adjectives in Garifuna but not in Creole. Possibly related to Garifuna inter ference is the Garifuna (more so than Creole) use of the creole continuative marker de before adjectives as well as before verbs (i de quiet versus native Creole i quiet) and the increasing incidence of de before Stative verbs, as in, for example, young Creoles' and Caribs' usage a de tink for 'I think.' 4.3.3 Carib women's language It has been said that Garifuna is one of few languages illustrating structural dif ferences between men's and women's speech patterns: women's speech would be related to the ancestral language Arawak whereas men's speech would evi dence Karina elements, the language of the warlike Amerindian group who invaded St. Vincent and exterminated the Arawakan men but not the women. Those differences, however, are now minimal and fast disappearing from mod ern Garifuna, according to my own observations and inquiries made in the Seine Bight and Hopkins communities. If differences are maintained, they occur in the first and second singular personal pronouns, and in a very limited number of nouns, as illustrated in table 2.8: Table 2.8: Some male/female differences in Garifuna MALE SPEECH
FEMALE SPEECH
au amuru yagu yudi yaugu yagane wegeri irahu wuri iraha gunubu wayunu gunara
nuguya buguya nunine nui nilegen nugune eyeri irahu hinaru iraha huya here winoga
GLOSS
I you my drink my meat my pet my boat boy girl rain land crab tomorrow
The linguistic forms traditionally used by male speakers are receding and are now only used by the older generation, though there are two exceptions: the male speech pronouns (of Karina origin) au and amuru for T and 'you' seem on the contrary to become unmarked, as they are now being increasingly used by young people of either sex, whereas the female Arawakan forms nuguya and
THE BELIZEAN SPEECH COMMUNITY
55
buguya, also meaning 'I' and 'you,' are predominantly used by most other members of the Garifuna community. This seems to be a case of innovation ini tiated by the younger generation, and it will be interesting to note if this trend continues. Taylor (1977) also claims that there is an unusual type of grammati cal gender marking which depends upon speaker sex: abstract nouns would be masculine in women's speech, and feminine in men's speech. However, Stochl (1975) does not mention this feature, and I have found no evidence of this dis tinction in Seine Bight Garifuna. As far as grammatical gender marking is con cerned, it is still preserved for some concrete items. For example, the feminine gender is assigned to articles of clothing, buildings, instruments, plants as well as to females, whereas the masculine gender is attributed to body parts, tempo ral and seasonal referents (such as 'sun,' 'moon,' 'month') as well as to males. The latter feature obviously accounts for the high incidence of 'he' and 'she' as used for subjects and objects in Garinagu usage of the continuum, in contrast to Creoles who often use 'i' regardless of sex, a reflex of the lack of gender mark ing in the basilectal vernacular. 5. Conclusion Given the remarkable multilingual complexity represented in Belize, it is obvi ous that a lingua franca is needed in interethnic communication. Although English is officially claimed to fill this role, the reality of language use in Belize presents quite a different picture, as indicated earlier. The closest to a Belizean lingua franca turns out to be the English-based creole used as native language by the Creole group which constitutes the majority of the population in the country. Because of its official status, however, English must also be spoken, and when it is, the resulting code is either an acrolect or a mesolect, which are the normal outcomes of second dialect acquisition. The following chapter will investigate the processes underlying acrolectal speech behavior. Endnotes 1. Come (personal communication) suggests this may be an example of folk etymology. 2. The French word balise "beacon" has also been suggested as the etymology of Belize, per haps due to the legendary visits of French pirates. Another possibility is that Belize was derived from Mayan and later hispanicized or anglicized. 3. By comparison, the U. S. population increased by about 10% between 1980 and 1990, (from about 220 to 250 million according to Time 1/30/95:54). 4. Other categories were East-Indian, Chinese, Amerindian, Portuguese, Syrian/Lebanese, White, and Other Races. 5. It would be particularly important to study the current status and usage of Maya and Kekchi
56
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
in Belize; this study, however, is restricted to English-based varieties. 6. The capital city of Belize is Belmopan, which is restricted to a small administrative center. 7. The name change was made official after a campaign in the 1970s, the goal of which was to restore pride in Black Carib culture and, generally, to inform Belize's ethnic groups about their respective traditions in reaction to the destructive effects of British colonization. The term Garinagu is the native Black Carib word referring to Carib ethnicity, and Garifuna refers to the language itself. Both terms are now used in government publications. Because the term Garifuna is most frequently used to refer to both the language and the people, it is also the term commonly used in this text. 8. Seine Bight is the village that I have investigated because of its social and economic relations with the neighboring Creole village of Placencia (see Escure 1979; 1982; 1983a; 1983b) 9. Pania is the term locally used to refer to the Latino/Hispanic population. 10. I was personally able to verify this fact during a 1986 trip in Hong Kong. As I was going through customs before boarding the train for the People's Republic of China, I noticed a young Chinese woman standing just ahead of me and bearing a Belizean passport. She explained that she had recently married in absentia a Belizean Chinese and was on her way to visit relatives in Guangzhou (Canton) before emigrating to Belize to join her unknown husband. 11. Corne (p. c.) believes that this paucity of data is due to a general lack of academic interest in exploring the relevant archives and says that exciting new information regarding Cayennais and Louisianais has been found through archival research. He also points out that the origins of several languages are known, in particular Hiri (Police) Motu, Bislama, Tayo, Mauritian, Isle de France Creole, and Reunionnais. 12. For example, haal
Chapter 3 Creole Acrolects as Innovations Abstract This chapter investigates the nature of the acrolectal set of Belizean English varieties and its place in relation to the overall creole continuum. A dynamic view of lectal development is offered as a substitute for the notions of "radical creole" and "postcreole." Acrolects are defined as innovations and extensions of speakers' repertoires. Both the social functions and linguistic characteristics of acrolects are examined in some detail and clearly differentiated from their standard counterparts. 1. Radical creoles, postcreoles, and decreolization As indicated in the previous chapters, the very notion of acrolect presupposes that the creole continuum cannot be defined strictly in terms of the creolized output of a pidginized variety. I intend to show that regardless of the historical accidents which have determined creole genesis, the resulting linguistic situa tion is just as complex and multifaceted as any other situation. One important aspect of this complexity is that the creole continuum does not eventually dis solve into a standard but develops its own innovative standard, the "acrolect" or set of "acrolects." To demonstrate the independent development of the acrolec tal segment, some important issues must be briefly reviewed in order to high light the current status of knowledge in the field of creole studies and, perhaps, add innovations to the picture. Two hypotheses predicting crucial synchronic and diachronic aspects of creole situations will be reviewed and evaluated. The first is the radical creole hypothesis which claims that certain "conservative" creoles remain close to their genesis and, thus, reveal substratai influences; the second is the postcreole hypothesis which, to the contrary, states that certain "innovative" creoles reflecting superstratal influences have evolved rapidly to the point of extinction—creoles that have disappeared after yielding to stan dardized varieties.
58
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
1.1 The radical creole hypothesis One of the widely held assumptions about pidgin and creole situations has been that creoles constitute entities that can be clearly separated from their superstrates or lexifier languages. True or radical creoles are often claimed to be identifiable primarily in rural areas and in older speakers. For example, Bailey (1966:2-3) who concentrated on "the speech of older people and members of the lower levels of the social scale" in her introduction to Jamaican Creole syntax, says: "There is a hard core [of Creole speakers]—the unschooled, ranging from pre-school children to the elderly, with the concentration at either end of the scale—living in isolated villages removed from the centers of culture." This approach has been embraced by Alleyne (1971; 1980), Byrne (1987), Winford (1993), and others who consider Saramaccan, a Surinamese creole with two European lexifier languages (English and Portuguese) to be one of the most "conservative" creoles and, thus, of particular interest to creolistics: "We can ċonstruct a scale starting with Saramaccan and ending with Barbadian English, and passing by varying degrees of retention or elimination of African speech habits" (Alleyne 1971:181). The scale shows at one end some African languages existing virtually intact, and a number of other languages which. . .reveal a high preponderance of structural forms, and less significantly, of vocabulary that can be rather conclusively derived from West African languages. These are, in descending order, Saramaccan and Sranan. . .Krio and Gullah. In the next position on the scale would be located the speech of rural inhabitants of Jamaica, Antigua and Guyana; toward the end of the scale, the speech of the urban working class of these same areas, followed by the speech of the urban Black working class of the United States, and finally the speech of the Black middle class everywhere (Alleyne 1980:18). The view that rural speakers, such as maroons who escaped to the bush, are more conservative because they are sheltered and isolated from the progressive influence of urban centers appears to have been inherited from the field of dialectology which made similar assumptions. In fact, the term creole has come to refer exclusively to basilects, the set of "conservative" vernacular varieties. They were, and still are, the primary object of study in creolistics because they are claimed to best reveal the process of creolization. Those creoles which are thought to be particularly representative of an early stage of creolization have been labeled "radical creoles." For some, a radical creole is assumed to include a higher inci dence of substratum features (see Alleyne quoted above), whereas for others a "deep creole," such as Saramaccan, is closest to the core grammar and best
CREOLE ACROLECTS AS INNOVATIONS
59
reflects "the essential structures and categories of the creolization process, and by implication, pertinent aspects of our faculté de langage " (Byrne 1987:15), a position in keeping with Bickerton's bioprogram (Bickerton 1981; 1984). The consensus of what constitutes a radical creole is rapidly evolving as more information emerges about potential source languages. The hypothesis of the African substrate is endorsed by McWhorter (1992) who believes in mas sive Kwa/Nigerian influences in the development of Saramaccan serial verbs through gradual creolization as a result of universal principles. On the other hand, Bickerton (1994), a proponent of radical, or rapid, creolization disagrees, arguing that the Bantu population exceeded the Kwa population and, therefore, the substrate hypothesis is not viable (Bantu languages are said to have little evidence of serial verb constructions). Bickerton finds serial verbs in Seselwa (the Seychelles Isle de France dialect with French lexical base), which has developed in the social context of a predominantly Bantu population: If universal principles could bring about serialization in the Indian Ocean, where there was no significant Kwa substrate, then they could well have brought it about in the Caribbean. The substratist explanation for Caribbean serialization becomes superfluous (Bickerton 1989:176). However, Corne et al. (1995) suggests that "the so-called 'serial verbs' in Seselwa are in fact the result of clause reduction in asyndetic coordination." This debate illustrates how data (demographic and linguistic) determine inter pretations: McWhorter and Bickerton rely on different stages and types of Suriname demographics, the former now assuming that Saramaccan was shaped on the West African coast before the establishment of maroon commu nities, and the latter relying on recently published records of slave shipments (Postma 1990). Corne et al. (1995:1) rely on early Isle de France Creole texts to show that "serial verbs appear to be largely unchanged over time. . .in free variation with semantically asyndetic coordinated clauses, and the result of reduction of such clauses by the deletion of recoverable elements." It would appear that anybody's favorite theory can be at least partly sup ported by some segment of the historical and linguistic facts. There is no deny ing the fact, however, that serial verbs (a major aspect of the argument that Saramaccan is a radical creole) are widespread in many world languages, and it is possible to claim that serial constructions develop naturally in the acquisition of contact languages. This claim in itself can lead to different and, indeed, opposite interpretations. Bickerton and Byrne believe that serialization, at least in Saramaccan, generated spontaneously and did not originate through influ ence from other languages. Corne's interpretation is that there is vernacularization, a "transfer of 'substratai' conceptualizations in the building of a creole lan-
60
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
guage" (Corne et al. 1995:23). This approach is appealing because it can explain linguistic similarities which may be evocative of substratai structures (Manessy's (1989) "creole cryptotypes"). Considering that several native African languages were usually represented among speakers creating the creole, the valid scenario presented by Corne et al. (1995:23) is that "only what is in common, a sort of highest common factor, was transferable to the emergent cre le, giving only a pale reflection of the syntactic strategies of any given African language" (see also Corne 1989). Tayo, a French-lexicon creole language spoken in New Caledonia is the prime example of the rapid (fifty years) transfer of substratai (Melanesian) con ceptualizations in the building of a creole language with some French syntactic influence (Corne 1994; 1995b). This scenario is further supported by the fact that constructions akin to serial verb structures occur widely even in the ver nacular, nonstandard, or colloquial forms of many languages in which serial ization is not formally recognized, as shown below from a small set of English and French sentences. In these sentences, it may be difficult to. differentiate parataxis from serialization, or it may be the case that these phenomena coa lesce in the pragmatic context of syntax: (1) English: Come get it; Lemme do it.1 (2) French: Ils sont partis se cacher. (They ran away to hide.) Elle va se faire attraper. (She is going to be chided.) Je me suis fait couper les cheveux. (I had my hair cut.) Il est allé courir acheter du pain. (He ran out to get bread.) Va te faire voir chez les Grecs. (Go to hell.) (3) Belizean acrolect: Dey make a ting call 'em casarina. Another approach to the definition of radical creoles involves surveying a large number of features that may yield deeper insights into possible influences on creolization. For example, although Haitian and Saramaccan were considered to be "on a par as radical creoles," Muysken (1994:305) claims that "Haitian stands much further away from potential African source languages than Saramaccan." This opinion is based on observations that Saramaccan includes African (Fongbe) substrate features that Haitian does not have: pre-nasalized stops, co-articulated stops, incorporated articles, paragoge, or agentive forma tions inter alia. On the other hand, features which may also be traced to African substrate influences, such as serial verbs, predicate clefts, postposed determin ers, and postposed adverbial deictics, are shared by Saramaccan and Haitian. A related hypothesis holds that the separation is so sharp between the creole (radi cal, deep) and its superstate that there is no intermediate set of varieties or mesolects. The hypothesis of distinctive lects appears to be an unwarranted
CREOLE ACROLECTS AS INNOVATIONS
61
extrapolation from the data, which does not stand careful scrutiny and obscures the constantly changing nature of the continuum. The same static perspective is reflected in the common reference to "creole" or "basilectal" speakers versus "standard" or "acrolectal" speakers and the implication that they are mutually exclusive. Bickerton (1975:24) summarizes that view in the following manner: We will begin by assuming that speakers who use features such as the tenseaspect markers bin, a, don, doz etc.—features which are not found in any acrolec tal speaker—may be basilectal speakers, and that the features mentioned may be basilectal markers. If our assumption is correct, we will find that those speakers who use such features most frequently will use acrolectal features seldom, if at all; and that, conversely, those speakers who use acrolectal features with high fre quency will use basilectal features infrequently, if at all. Bailey (1966:1), however, while identifying distinct codes in Jamaica and restricting the tenn creole to the extreme nonstandard end of the spectrum, also demonstrates her awareness of the ambiguous linguistic situation: A given speaker is likely to shift back and forth from Creole to English or some thing closely approximating English within a single utterance, without ever being conscious of this shift. Most observers of language in Jamaica have encountered extreme difficulty in distinguishing between the various layers of the language structure, and indeed the lines of demarcation are very hard to draw. Clearly, Bailey states that Jamaicans can be at the same time basilectal and acrolectal speakers. In spite of her insights, her book focuses exclusively on basilects and outlines a static grammar of Jamaican Creole, which paved the way for the circularity and confusion that has contributed to limitations in the development of the field of creole studies; for the most part, artificial labels have too often been imposed on a continuum that cannot be clearly separated into dis tinctive codes. DeCamp (1971:350) identified the weaknesses of this approach, saying that "there is no sharp cleavage between creoles and the standard." 1.2 The postcreole hypothesis Another assumption related to a unilateral view of creole situations is that many sites where pidgins and creoles had developed, under the impetus of social con flicts such as slavery in the New World, have now reached "the final stages of the creole life cycle," or "postcreole" stage (DeCamp 1971:349). DeCamp was the first to coin the phrase postcreole continuum to identify the range of lin guistic variants he had observed in Jamaica. He defined postcreole communi ties as "communities in which is in the process of merging with a standard" and
62
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
refers to them as "a complex but related set of switching activities, all triggered by the presence of one stylistic feature [+oratorical]" (DeCamp 1971:349, 353). Those valuable insights into the concept of variability have been restricted to imply a linear developmental process of change. By "postcreoleness," later interpreted as "decreolization," the traditional view has assumed that the origi nal creole is in the process of disappearing and is being replaced by the stan dard language holding prestige in the area, the process being facilitated by increased educational opportunities and social integration. The alleged linear progression in the direction of the overtly valued model would lead to the death of the original creole—hence the claim that a radical creole could only exist if kept separate from external sociolinguistic contacts. Decreolization has, thus, come to mean the loss of the creole, as clearly stated in the following: The result of decreolization is to create a continuum of intermediate varieties between creole and superstrate. If the process is sufficiently long and intense, the continuum may be progressively eroded at its creole end. The result may be a syn chronic state in which the most conservative variety recoverable is already con siderably different from (and considerably closer to the superstrate than) the orig inal creole (Bickerton 1981:47). The Trinidadian and the Bajan/Barbadian situations are often cited as prime examples of decreolization. 1.3 Problems with radical creoles and postcreoles The radical creole and postcreole hypotheses appear to be mutually exclusiveor to apply to two mutually exclusive types of communication—because they correspond to two types of assumed creole histories: the former occurring in isolated, usually rural, communities and the latter in integrated, usually urban, communities. Although it is expected that creole societies have been exposed to differing degrees of external influences, it is unlikely that they would be so strikingly contrasted in tenus of their linguistic development. First of all, a prac tically static community preserving a conservative creole would be highly dys functional, and it would be in direct contradiction with what is known of lan guage history. Secondly, it is unrealistic to assume that there ever was a stable creole, considering the highly unstable conditions which gave rise to pidgins and creoles. A more satisfying scenario would posit that the initial stage of creolization operated in terms of a developmental continuum from the very start. The notion of an original creole is a vague concept at best because there is no evidence of earlier stages beyond sparse written fragments. In fact, it is possi ble, and very likely, that there was a wide-ranging continuum from the begin-
CREOLE ACROLECTS AS INNOVATIONS
63
ning of African-European contacts. Alleyne first argued in favor of the position that creoles were only a segment of a continuum of variation, showing evidence of "considerable variation from their inception rather than early and rapid crys tallization (Alleyne 1971:170). These [intermediate] forms existed from the very inception of bilingual con tact they were generated by that contact situation in the same way as the other socalled "pidgin" or "creole" forms. . . .they derive from an underlying protodialect, a proto-mtermediate Afro-American. Hence, they were generated in the contact situation at a very early stage when some segments of the African popu lation began to be assimilated by rigorous acculturative processes (Alleyne 1980:182-3). Regardless of the original departure point of the creole continuum, which is a matter of speculation in the almost total absence of hard evidence,2 the position of mesolects within the continuum has been variously interpreted. The standard view has been to refer to a mesolect as an intermediate or imperfect approximation of the model variety reflecting the overall progression toward the acquisition of the target language. In this sense, mesolects constitute a tem porary stage, not unlike the interlanguage stage typically associated with sec ond language acquisition. The adoption in SLA research of the equivalent terms basilang, mesolang, and acrolang obviously signals the perceived linear simi larities between the two linguistic situations (Stauble 1980:47; Schumann & Stauble 1983:263). This one-way upward shift is interpreted as implying a lin guistic restructuring of the creole system, with the replacement of basilectal morphemes or structures by their standard reflexes. 1.4 A dynamic view of lectal development A differing view, and the one to which I now subscribe, holds that mesolects and acrolects are not temporary stages in the acquisition process but constitute separate, overlapping varieties which are assigned distinctive psychosocial functions in the overall system, display their own linguistic characteristics, and usually co-occur in a single speaker's competence. Rickford (1983:304; 1987) notes that "[i]n the decreohzation process, individuals retain the competence in the basilect (or any other lects) that they had at a previous stage, and add to this their newly acquired competence in a higher lect." I also noted (Escure 1981; 1982:247-252; 260) the extraordinary flexibil ity and code-shifting ability evident in two Belizean villages. I observed that Creole speakers of Placencia moved away from the basilectal values of five diagnostic morphosyntactic features when they found themselves in relatively informal situations, especially in intergroup contexts involving contacts with
64
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
Black Caribs. For example, the same speakers showed evidence of past tense marking 63% of the time in intergroup situations, whereas they produced only traces of past marking in intragroup basilectal contacts. All features examined functioned in similar fashion (marking of third-person singular present mor pheme, use of do in negative forms, copular usage, and plural morpheme). To describe this adaptive process, I used the term synchronic decreoliza tion, which refers to the observed intra-individual variation, with the intent to signal that no definite loss of the creole basilect is implied by the absence of a basilectal feature. In the creole situation, learning the standard does not entail a monolithic progression toward the target language (with the replacement of old, linguistic forms by new forms) but, rather, the development of a broader reper toire, allowing for the co-existence of native and acquired forms in a speaker's competence. Creole speakers have been found to extend their repertoires, at least in English-based creole continua, rather than keep them constant through the sub stitution of mesolects for basilects and acrolects for mesolects. In other words, mesolects do not constitute just a temporary interlanguage stage. This is not to say that all speakers extend their repertoires to the same degree. Only repeated observations of the same speakers in different contexts and with different participants, and an extensive knowledge of the community, can lead to a reasonably accurate assessment of individual and community com petence. Previous claims that decreolization produced postcreole continua were based on isolated and, thus, limited lect observations, which did not permit a full comprehension of the extent of code-switching available to individuals; therefore, a thorough investigation of all linguistic varieties is the first crucial step in any study of creole (and any other) situations. 1.5 Decreolization as acquisition Instead of defining decreolization as the gradual loss of the creole basilect lead ing to a postcreole stage, the term decreolization will be used to refer in its broadest sense to the acquisition of non-creole forms, the learning of linguistic forms which are more closely related to the superstrate. This process, which involves the acquisition of new codes, results in the possibility of extensive code-switching triggered in diglossic situations. This definition allows for the preservation of a (possibly separate) basilectal creole system, although not nec essarily in its original state: (1) Decreolization: the extension of the basilects to include linguistic forms derived from the superstate, and resulting in mesolect or acrolect acquisition. According to the interpretation proposed, decreolization would not be unlike second language acquisition, in which it is generally never claimed that
CREOLE ACROLECTS AS INNOVATIONS
65
L2 replaces L1 unless the L2 learners are displaced, isolated, and never again exposed to L1. It has been said, however, that one important area where creole situations differ from SLA is that SLA implies the replacement of earlier forms by new ones; acrolect acquisition does not and, instead, involves "extensions of one's linguistic repertoire from an earlier stage" (Rickford 1983:304). Selinker (1972), however, mentions "backsliding" phenomena in SLA. There is ample evidence that SLA, if studied in a natural context and not in the lab, is no more irreversible than acrolect acquisition, or for that matter, any second dialect or language acquisition, except in cases of early L2 acquisition leading to com plete bilingualism where there is no clearly dominant language. When assessing the amount of attention paid to the creole continuum, basilects (or whatever variety is assumed to be basilectal) turn out to have been the primary object of study. It is only recently that questions have been raised about mesolects (Rickford 1987), especially in relation to their role as dynam ic elements of the continuum instead of errors of interpretation. As far as acrolects are concerned, however, they have been practically ignored. Consequently, the next section will attempt to identify social and linguistic characteristics that may justify the existence of the specific term acrolect. 2. Acrolects and standard dialects: Social aspects The fact that acrolects have so far raised little interest in creole research is prob ably due to the underlying assumption (though never actually discussed) that acrolects are identical to the standard variety of the lexifier language, and that they are the successful outcome of the acquisition process which is the educa tional target in Creole societies. Yet, the very use of the term acrolect as opposed to merely standard variety would seem to indicate that there is, indeed, a per ceived difference between the higher lect in the continuum and the standard. 2.1 Acrolect and standard defined The assumed equivalence of an "acrolect" and its corresponding "standard" has been largely untested so far. Most observations indicate, to the contrary, that acrolects are not identical to the target language but that native speakers of basilectal creoles produce their own version of the target language. This does not imply that speakers are "unsuccessful" in their attempt at learning the stan dard. Their goals may simply be different and it seems inappropriate to assume that acrolectal patterns are approximations of the target language. It may be more relevant to refer to acrolects as innovations. If the notion of individual or community goals and choices in language acquisition is taken into account as a
66
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
significant aspect of acrolectal development, then the crucial question is why acrolectal speakers would choose, albeit unconsciously, to produce varieties dis tinct from the official standard. Psychosocial aspects of the differentiation are par ticularly relevant here and will be investigated more specifically in the context of Belizean society. As a starting point, it may be helpful to refer to definitions of the terms acrolect and standard before further discussing the situation. The term standard is typically defined in composition manuals or gram mars, and such definitions are likely to influence, more particularly, teachers as well as official language policies. The normative view derives "correctness" from the written and literary "educated" medium and assumes that spoken var ieties should match the written variety; therefore, a grammarian's definition of the standard assimilates spoken and written varieties. Linguistic definitions are careful to separate written and oral varieties and refer to social class as instru mental in the arbitrary determination of the official model. Both types of "stan dard" definition are offered below. (2) Standard: a) written and spoken language of educated people (Leggett, Mead & Kramer 1988:268); b) a dominant or prestige dialect (Fromkin & Rodman 1983:251). On the other hand, the term acrolect has only been used in creolistics but always as an equivalent of the standard target language, although one may won der why a different term would be needed under those circumstances. Bickerton (1975:24) uses the term "acrolect to refer to educated Guyanese English (a variety which differs from other standard varieties of the language only in a few phonological details and a handful of lexical items)." My observations indicate that there are ample reasons to avoid equating "standard" and "acrolect." Acrolects may be defined according to two distinct sets of criteria, either in terms of pragmatic use (and more specifically in relation to the speaker's overall repertoire) or in strictly linguistic terms. First, an acrolect may be assigned a pragmatic, discourse-oriented definition in terms of its speakers' intents and abilities. An acrolect would, thus, be the highest variety an individ ual is able or willing to produce in the relevant formal contexts. This definition implies that an assessment of the whole range of a speaker's competence has been made, and this in turn requires extensive knowledge of the individuals under investigation. It might be more revealing to investigate a few individuals exhaustively in as wide a variety of situations as possible than to acquire single lects from a large number of individuals. This method is likely to provide insights into linguistic processes that would not be possible from a more restricted set of samples. Secondly, an acrolect may also be defined in terms of its strictly linguistic
CREOLE ACROLECTS AS INNOVATIONS
67
characteristics and by comparison to basilects and mesolects within the same continuum. For example, basilects are relatively well differentiated from the other varieties, in terms of the incidence of certain morphemes, such as the use of basilectal de (for copular forms) or ms (for past) versus mesolectal null forms or inflectional past marking on verbs; however, the boundaries, if any, separating mesolects from acrolects are extremely difficult to establish (Escure 1982; 1983a; 1983b). Consequently, the following definition of acrolect is pro posed, which characterizes the resulting effect of the decreolization process as defined in (1) above, but allows for variability in its actualization. (3) Acrolect: A non-native version of the standard language, which is acquired through spontaneous or guided learning, functions in formal contexts, and extends its speaker's repertoire without necessarily leading to the loss of the speaker's vernacular. The acrolect is not necessarily a dominant or prestigious dialect, although it is usually associated with education. The definition of the term acrolect implies that there is an available standard that provides a linguistic model instrumental in the formation of acrolects, even in the absence of any guided learning. In Belize, the official English standard is also the superstrate, the lan guage which has yielded the lexical base of the creolizing varieties. All Belizean citizens know that the official language of Belize is English and that they are "supposed" to speak English, regardless of their ethnic identity as Creole, Garifuna, Mestizo, Maya, or Kekchi (see chapter two). 2.2 The label "English" in Belize It is questionable, however, whether in Belize Standard English is either "dom inant" or "prestigious," as stated in the definition given above. The general label "English" is extremely confusing to Belizeans, primarily because English is an external standard, never physically present, although it is officially proclaimed to be the language of Belize. English is not spoken in Belize by any particular group, excepting a handful of immigrants, including a few American families who emigrated to Belize after the Civil War; there are few British subjects liv ing now in Belize. Due to the recent status of Belize as a British colony (the colony of British Honduras), and because it is still a member of the Commonwealth, it is tempting to assign the official English variety to British English or RP, but the influence of RP seems to have been slight. There were isolated recent contacts with some varieties of British English, when in the late 1970s Britain maintained a defensive force in Belize to prevent a potential Guatemalan invasion. Most British soldiers stationed in Belize happened to be
68
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
speakers 'of northern or Scottish English or were Gurkha soldiers from Nepal and, thus, speakers of a Nepalese L2 version of English. Contacts with those British soldiers were definitely not conducted in RP and, in fact, provided access to other nonstandard varieties of English. Interestingly, this situation may have reenacted the early contacts of the Belize settlement between Africans and nonstandard speakers of European English. The only direct access to native renderings of a standard English variety appears to be through radio programs: BBC news and American evangelical broadcasts. Standard English, then, has practically no spoken presence within the country of Belize, though the written medium is, indeed, standard English. 2.3 British and American values in Belize In spite of the absence of direct access to standard English, there are general ized official and unofficial pressures to learn it, but not all individuals respond to the pressure, or those who do, do it in highly variable ways. It is well under stood that mainstream values or the prestige of a variety external to the com munity do not constitute the only, or even the major motivation, for change through dialect acquisition. First, RP is associated with a remote culture, one which does not have realistic value within the Belizean context. Although most Belizeans do not seem to hold strong negative feelings toward the language of the early colonizers, and even appear to preserve some allegiance to England (many Belizeans still keep in their homes portraits of Queen Elizabeth and of other members of the royal family), English/British values are simply irrelevant to Belizean life, and are as quaint and exotic amidst Central American mangrove as the royal hats, Big Ben, or London smog. In contrast, English/American val ues are much more meaningful, in part because of the geographical proximity and the economic reality of job opportunities in the United States. Belizeans nowadays are more likely to have had contacts with American English since many have spent some time working in the United States or have relatives there. Many Belizean children are supported by the money orders sent home from Houston or New York to hard-working grandmothers who com monly raise three or four generations of Belizean babies. Those generations of Belizeans working in the United States return home sometimes, usually for Christmas or when they retire, and they bring back gifts, including their ren dering of American English. However, American English does not necessarily carry with it the prestige associated with the economic benefits assumed to result from living in the United States (although the reality often falls short of what homecoming emigrants are willing to admit). American accent affecta tions are jokingly disparaged as "taakin amerikaan." In reality, the Belizean emigrants' contacts with American Standard varieties are determined by the
CREOLE ACROLECTS AS INNOVATIONS
69
restricted opportunities available to aliens (often illegal) who also happen to be mostly black. Belizeans have more contacts with speakers of Black American English than with speakers of American standard varieties. Thus, American influences are likely to penetrate creole via the Black English medium, rein forcing nonstandard forms of English such as multiple negation. The real world in Belize is one in which the creole, the mesolect, or some other language is spoken, and the vernacular variety has a high prestige at home, not necessarily of the covert type. Although they are aware of the official condemnation of local varieties, most Belizeans generally feel comfortable with their native basilect and take it for granted. 2.4 Range of linguistic choices and attitudes There is a wide range of attitudes regulating the appropriateness of linguistic codes. For example, Kim L. a twenty-five year old urban Creole man proclaims his preference for what he identifies as an intermediate variety—"de creole and English mix togeda"—which he refers to as "broken English": (4)
. . .I like the broken English, I don't like speaking creole, sound too bad.. .you see, you get people who really speak de creole really really bad, you know. Sometime taakin an you don really unerstan what dey sayin, right?. . . I can speak creole myself, you know, but I don like it. . . When I first staated, staated out creole right? After a while I, now I try get out a it for a while. So keep out a it up to now. [10.1: 2]
Kim's "broken English" may in fact be easily interpreted as an acrolect. Having spent some time in the United States, Kim is probably aware that the variety he favors is not standard English, and he therefore identifies it as a mesolect. His characterization of his own variety highlights the ambiguous, adaptable nature of the Belizean continuum. Also extremely revealing in sever al respects is his friend Rick L.'s insinuation that Kim switched away from the creole solely to appeal to "hoity-toity girls": (5) . . .he use to mess with da kinda girl, dey kinda haity-taity girl, right? You wan taak English, you raas (expletive) exactly we happen to a Carib. [10.1:4] (He used to date, you know, classy girls. If you speak English you'll sound just like the Garifuna people.) The first part of Rick's comment suggests some important social reasons underlying the acquisition of noncreole forms: one of them is impressing edu-
70
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
cated young women. To younger Creole men, in particular, the use of English is a commodity and is portrayed in sample (5) as part of a con act, with the ulte rior purpose to obtain a date with a rich girl. The implication is that the language of education has prestige with wealthy girls whose parents can afford to send them to a private school run by nuns, and that there is an obvious equation between money and English. For that reason, English has no inherently signif icant value for the average Creole individual. The prestige of English in Belize is strictly reserved for a small privileged segment of Belizean society, and thus, it is no more than an occasional commodity, deprived of local identity and like ly to be perceived as an illusion, a parody, and a trap for those who fall for the externally imposed standard. 2.4.1 Language attitudes and gender The claim that women especially value the standard language has been made before in relation to various linguistic communities. In the Gullah-speaking community of South Carolina, women were found to learn English more fre quently than men because the working opportunities for women (as teachers and nurses) require interaction with a standard-speaking environment on the mainland; men get better jobs working in construction or other manual labor on the island where the English-based creole (Gullah) is widely spoken and holds local prestige for them (Nichols 1983). Thus, women, but not men, are moti vated to learn the standard variety. In this situation, the acquisition of the stan dard variety is sex-based because, according to Nichols, men and women are offered different economic opportunities. However, in my opinion, women's choice of standard English varieties does not mean that women abandon their native vernacular as they learn English; in fact, the issue of creole loss is not overtly mentioned in the context of the South Carolina Sea Islands, and it could be implied from the absence of such a discussion that Gullah is lost by women, and that "decreolization," in the traditional sense, is implemented by them. Furthermore, it is assumed throughout the study, though never actually stated or discussed, that those women who learn standard American English actually speak in a manner identical to that of native speakers who are not members of the Gullah community. This, of course, is highly unlikely. On the other hand, Edwards' study of a segment of Detroit's urban Black English community found the opposite: women use more vernacular (Black English) variants than men. For four of the five linguistic variables used in this study (four phonolog ical variables and the copula), females chose more of the BE variants than males. This is attributed to the fact that the women living in that neighborhood are less socially mobile than men (Edwards 1992:104-5). In the Belizean rural context, middle-aged women who are most actively
CREOLE ACROLECTS AS INNOVATIONS
71
involved in village activities were found to be more likely than men and other women to use a wide range of varieties, from basilectal to acrolectal (Escure 1991b). Those older women do not give special preference to the standard vari ety but show flexibility and discrimination in their linguistic selections, which reflects their sensitivity to the needs of the community. There is also some evidence that women in the same Belizean village are directly involved in linguistic diffusion and that they accurately reflect the ten dencies of ongoing linguistic change. For example, in a study of copular varia tion, it appeared that when they use basilects, women preserve more than men the conservative features that are also strong vernacular variants, namely, the pre-verbal de morpheme and the pre-adjectival zero-copula. On the other hand, women also accentuate innovations when they use acrolects, in particular the loss of the locative verb ds and the pre-nominal zero-copula, which is increas ingly replaced by the English be copula (Escure 1993c: 128-9). This study con firms the variability existing in individual repertoires, as discussed above, as well as the multidirectionality of the linguistic development in creole situations. It shows that individuals (especially women) can elect to be more conservative or more innovative depending on their assessment of the situation. In the Detroit black urban community, as well as in the rural context of Belize, age, sex, and participation in community activities, or isolation from external groups, are found to strongly stimulate allegiance to the local basilec tal vernacular. The Sea Islands Gullah women who are now involved in main land activities show growing usage of English. The choice of prestigious (offi cial) or stigmatized (local) varieties may be more related to social variables such as class and status than to gender per se. Such patterns are not unique to postcolonial or immigrant communities. Milroy (1980) has shown that the con cept of "social network" plays an important role among Belfast working class groups in terms of preserving working class varieties of Irish English as opposed to the adoption of Standard English. 2.4.2 Language attitudes and ethnicity Interethnic conflicts are also revealed in the latter part of Rick's statement (5), which can be less literally translated as "You try to speak English, and you end up sounding like a fool, just like the Caribs." The last reference points to con flicts between the Garifuna (Black Caribs) and the Creoles, who live in neigh boring villages in southern Belize (see chapter two). They are traditionally involved in minor bickerings in which language plays a major role. The Garifuna overtly scorn the creole and apply themselves to the acquisition of "good English," although they mostly use the creole in daily activities. On the other hand, the Creoles snicker at the Garifuna's second-language versions of
72
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
both creole and English. The Garifuna people, however, keep a step ahead of the Creoles in the linguistic arena, since they speak a native language that the Creoles do not understand. The Gariftina people's mixed reactions to the creole are often shared by other ethnic groups. Some individuals claim that they do not understand the creole, and others say that they speak it when they have to, such as Martin D., thirty-eight, the Gariftina teacher quoted in chapter two who speaks creole with his friends "so nobody can just say he taaks funny he must be from a different land" (3.1: 10). He mentions that his reason for not liking to use creole (although he does) is that it has no rules, a belief unfortunately shared by many Belizeans: (6) Now the reason why I would say dat because de Creole—de Carib you can follow the trend, right, because looking at it grammatically dere are rules for use of words and so, right?—but I think in Creole, I just cannot under stand, you know. Unless if dey can, but so far I haven't seen, I couldn't write a book in Creole dat's a language book, you know. (3.1: 9) The same view is shared by Peter ., a man of mixed Creole/Hispanic descent with a college education, who works as a civil servant in a ministry in Belmopan, the official capital of Belize. Peter states a strong preference for his "Spanish" roots rather than his Creole origin. He says: (7) Creole is notin to be proud of really, you cannot be, I mean, I grew up in de ting. I be frank wid you, dere is notin to be proud of in creole, I tell you de trut. I am from my moder's side, I'm African descent, right; in my fader's side, I'm Spanish descent. Now, if I was to pick de two evil, I pre fer de Spanish, not because of color but because of de moral fiber of de people. (9.2: 6) This quotation suggests that cultural attitudes may be extremely important in determining allegiance to any given variety. The ethnophobic self-depreca tion evident above reflects the lasting undermining effects of colonization, per haps its most devastating legacy, which still shapes some individuals' attitudes toward their peers and their languages. Although the group of Creoles is, by def inition, mixed with combined African and European ancestry, Belizeans often equate "Creole" with "African," as in the above quotation. They also classify as "Spanish" or "Panya" any Central American Hispanic group (mostly Mexican, Guatemalan, or Honduran) which may have interacted with Belizeans after emancipation; indeed, there is a Spanish/Mestizo majority population in the
CREOLE ACROLECTS AS INNOVATIONS
73
northern and western parts of the country, near the Mexican and Guatemalan borders, as discussed in chapter two. Such statements addressing the putative "no rule" status of creoles capture an awareness of the changing nature of creoles. Colonization has naturally con tributed to the pervading stigma attached to the languages spoken by slaves and their descendants in the Caribbean. Yet, in spite of the overt stigma attached to the basilect and its speakers' apparent denials of its value and existence, creoles are still alive and well and, in fact, gaining popularity with certain groups. Similar attitudes are observed universally as languages and dialects derive their status (high or low) from their speakers' degrees of status; however, the reverse is not necessarily true. A speaker does not automatically gain social status through the use of a high status dialect. It is also crucial to take into account the often subconscious perceptions of individuals who accurately assess their social position and their chances for upward mobility, balancing the potential socioe conomic gain involved in the acquisition of the standard against the learning effort required and the potential loss of identity incurred by estrangement from the native vernacular, albeit temporarily. It would be naive and presumptuous to assume that all members of a given society subscribe to official linguistic policy and agree to embrace mainstream values and adopt the standard variety selected by educators, academicians, or planning authorities. 2.4.3 Acrolects as psychosocial entities The reasons why individuals choose to learn or not learn a variety are complex, as briefly previewed in chapter one, and are documented in an increasing num ber of case studies exploring the complexity of the psychosocial mechanisms involved. Acrolects in creole societies, particularly in Belize, are different from the recommended official standard for two major psychosocial reasons. First, acrolects develop independently because the officially prescribed standard is not present in the country; there is simply no linguistic exposure to a consistent British or American standard of English, either in daily activities or in school contexts, as indicated in chapter two. Secondly, Belizeans are not strongly moti vated to learn that remote standard, precisely because there are no cultural or psychosocial links to standard-speaking groups. Since acrolects do not develop according to a specific model, they are highly variable, reflecting the multidimensionality of human experience. 3. Acrolects and standards: Linguistic aspects The high variability of acrolects is a phenomenon triggered or facilitated by the co-existence and mixing of lects. Individuals may have widely differing reper-
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
74
toires, due to social and psychological factors (actual degree of exposure to the standard, degree of education, type of model presented by teachers, group or individual identity; personal ambitions, inter alia). Indeed, one person's acrolect may be another's mesolect. Lects cannot be neatly separated from their superstrate and from each other, but they are perceived as being different from the codified superstrate, and they are almost certainly intended to sound differ ent, as indicated in statements 4, 5, and 6. Although most Belizeans widely use the word English, this term clearly denotes to them a local standard variety which differs both from American and British varieties. It now remains to iden tify how the distinctions between Belizean acrolects and English superstates can be linguistically characterized, if at all. It is essential to verify whether the superstrate/acrolect difference is real—actually represented in linguistic terms, beyond psychosocial factors. In the following section, some of the most promi nent acrolectal features will be briefly examined without speculating as to the underlying reasons for the putative acrolect/superstrate distinctions. The two texts selected below illustrate some acrolects commonly found in Belize. Both are excerpts from conversations I had with the speakers at an early stage of my fieldwork.3 In the creolistic tradition prevalent in the early 1980s, my first reaction had been to discard the texts as noncreole, too English, and, therefore, uninteresting because they appeared to reflect the creole speakers' "highest" available varieties, produced for my own benefit and as a courtesy to a stranger ignorant of the local creole. I have since come to realize that the "English" versions produced by those speakers of creole offer invaluable insights into the interactions of the creole and the standard varieties and help us understand how acrolects develop. I later found that "foreigner talk" as proffered to a stranger was not truly different from the acrolects that later occurred in for mal situations in intragroup contexts, such as village council meetings or Sunday church sermons and in out-group contexts with other Belizean ethnic groups. 3.1 Acrolectal texts 3.1.1 Text 8: Local food (Peter, 40; Creole, Belize-City) 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9.
I will agree one of the things about a fisherman is that they don't have a very good diet, you know, is one of the things we don't bother about that in Belize, you know, we eat anyting we like. But what happened, we used to have all things that sort of compensate for vegetables, you know, like callalou. Yeah, some kind of cabbage, it look like cabbage, but it doesn't grow like cabbage; I didn't eat it for years, but I saw it, and I think it's in Sartineha a couple months ago, dey grow it up dere, in Sartineha village, in the naat (North),
CREOLE ACROLECTS AS INNOVATIONS 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 13. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30. 31. 32. 33. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40.
yeah, its a green vegetable, right. The Caribs, dey have different kind of cassaba, you know, dere have two different type; you have de type, de Caribs, dey use plenty, which they use it for all different type of things; dey use it for -um-dey make a thing call em "casarina," which is a -it's a dried and process; the cassaba were strain, it comes into a kinda powder like -um-coarse powder; you heat up de water, right, and you put de casarina in dat water and you stir it and it comes like a powder, somting like dat. You know, it's a syrup, it's strain' to be very rich, you know; I tink de Americans dey call it "Farina," I tink. (Indians) dey call it plantations -milpas- These are farms where they cut down the land and they burn it in a dry, see. Den, well, actually dis (e)rode de soil a bit, you know. And after workin dat for tree, for a couple years, dey find dat production taper off badly, you know, bekaas dey destroy de soil dat way. They would come dig up around those old stumps and things and plant their corn diet, and then they plant things like that, rice. Yeah, after a couple of years, de production drops off, dey change again. Dey leave dat an dey go-whole village change, yeah. Well nowadays, government is helping them and they've improving the land. They using a little mechanisations for better results, you know. They use certain additives like, urn, fertilizers, and so on, to the soil. It takes time for dem to really accept, you know, um, de need for change, to different approach, you know. But dey are basically corn, rice, an plantains; an pigs an chickens; yeah ground food, peppers, naturally; bikaa dey make pepper soup; beans; got beans to go wid de corn tortillas.
3.1.2 Text 9: Dugu (a Black Carib variant of voodoo) (Mark, 16; Garifuna, Punta-Gorda) 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
Like in voodoo they have this certain woman that comes in the middle of the hall and starts to hypnotize everybody. If you aren't on guard, they'll come up and slap you right down off your seat. Some of them don't touch the ground at all. You know, just dance, knocking about like they're dying, like when people have fits. The lady hypnotizes them, they no
75
16 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18.
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA know it. . Then afterwards they have some of the men that, like, suddenly, they'd take off their trousers and shirt and they would go up to the beam, with lone -ah- like these shorts, and suddenly they'd come down and tell you all what's wrong with you and your parents. . .They have some woman, like, after the celebration is finished, you go along with which or whatever you call the lady—the bouye—and she takes you to certain part of the burial ground and you have to pray along with her to the dead person you want to pray to. And then, suddenly, like, you take along a person along with you to dig a hole, and put a pig's head in there and chickens.
3.2 Linguistic strategies in acrolects Acrolects present regular idiosyncratic features, and those phonological or grammatical features are the creative results of the late acquisition of standard patterns in contact with creole patterns. I have identified three common strate gies which appear to be particularly involved in the development of acrolectal features, and can be related to procedural universals, referring to universal prop erties of processes in language development (Muysken & Veenstra 1995:120). They include frequency variability, structural hypercorrection and relexification leading to grammaticalization. 1) The frequency variability strategy is commonly associated with the incorporation of a relatively new standard variant into the acquired acrolectal system, typically leading to a variable combination of vernacular and standard variants for the same feature, for example, [d] and [ð] as reflexes of the voiced interdental, in contrast to the categorical use of the vernacular variant [d] in basilects, and the categorical use of the standard variant [b] in the external standard system. 2) Structural hypercorrection is a phenomenon which involves the overgeneralization of a standard rule by introducing new forms. For example, the acrolect may extend pluralization via standard rules to abstract or generic items which are not habitually marked for plural in standard English, as represented in They using a little mechanizations (8:33). 3) Finally, relexification, which often coincides with some type of grammat icalization, is perhaps the most fascinating and creative strategy found in acrolects because it is often concealed under a conventional morphological or lexical item borrowed from the superstate. This phenomenon generally involves the substitu tion of a standard lexical item for a creole item but with the additional dimension of a functional shift that meets the syntactic demands of underlying patterns of the
CREOLE ACROLECTS AS INNOVATIONS
77
native basilectai system, or perhaps universal constraints. For example, the use of were in "the cassaba were strain, it comes into a kinda powder" (8: 14-17) may be the result of the relexification leading to grammaticalization of the creole anteri or past preverbal morpheme mε, which in the sentence quoted above corresponds exactly to the anteriority of cassava straining: "after the cassava has been strained, (as a result) it becomes powder" (Escure forthcoming). The three major acrolectal strategies will be further illustrated below, 3.3 Linguistic features Although the focus of this study is primarily on the discourse component, I will first review some prominent features of the other components—phonological, morphological and syntactic—in order to provide an overview of acrolectal pat terns not found in the lexifier language. 3.3.1 Phonological features One of the most striking phonological characteristics of acrolects is that they contain a statistical combination of standard and creole variants for any given variable, illustrating particularly well the first linguistic strategy identified above as frequency variability. Interdental fricatives constitute a prime example of a diagnostic feature because interdentals are practically absent from creole basilects where they are represented by stop reflexes. They variably occur in fairly high proportions in acrolects, though never as much as in the standard.4 It can be safely assumed that interdentals do not exist in the creole phonemic sys tem but, instead, are acquired and added to the speaker's competence in the process of learning a standard. Given the ethnic differences in Belize, specifi cally at the research site of Placencia and its neighboring Garifuna community, it is particularly interesting to examine how Creole and Garifuna speakers respectively acquire the standard interdentals. The creole basilect and the Garifuna language both lack interdentals, which means that the linguistic base is unified in this respect for both groups of speakers. If they show differential behavior in the acquisition of interdentals, then extralinguistic factors must have played a crucial role in the acquisition. It is possible to gain insights into the potential Creole/Garifuna differences by comparing text 8 produced by Peter, a Creole, and text 9 spoken by a Garifuna man. Although the transcripts are relatively short, the generally high incidence of English interdentals or their reflexes are so widely distributed in normal discourse that even a brief sample includes a sufficient amount of those sounds (seventy-six potential interdental sites in text 8). To illustrate the vari able distribution of phonological features, texts 8 and 9 have been scanned for
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
78
the incidence of two variants of the phonological variables /ð/ and / θ / , respec tively, [d] and [ð] and [t] and [θ], as represented in table 3.1. Table 3.1: Interdental variation in acrolects (Texts 8 and 9)
PETER MARK.
N [61] [30]
[ð] 40.9% (25) 96.6% (29)
[d] 59% (36) 3.3% (1)
— —
N [15] —
[θ] 60 %(9) —
[t] 40 %(6)
In acrolectal text 8, Peter uses almost equivalent amounts of the creole variant [d] (59%) and the superstrate voiced variant [ð] (40.9%). The latter constitutes a very high incidence, considering that Peter's basilect consistently lacks interdentals. He also has an even higher frequency of the voiceless inter dental (60%), although the latter phoneme occurs in much smaller proportions than its voiced counterpart, as is the case in all English varieties. In contrast, in text 9, Mark uses primarily the formal variant in this short excerpt (no voiceless interdental context occurs). The Creole and the Garifuna respondents exhibit highly differentiated linguistic behavior, which is reflected in the Creoles' gen eral opinion that the Garifuna people hypercorrect their speech and the Garifuna's own statements that they value English more than the creole ver nacular (see chapter two). This would confirm that linguistic behavior matches ethnic identity and, more specifically, the different attitudes toward English held by the two ethnic groups. The choice of the variants [ð]/[d] and [θ]/[t] is somewhat difficult to predict., unless one takes into account the psychosocial values they hold for speakers. In addition, the choice of variants is determined by the immediate linguistic environment. Word-internal phoneme position seems to be a relevant factor in these acrolects: interdentals, especially the voiceless, rarely occur in medial or final word positions, except in naat (North) or in quantifiers such as anyting, somting. In fact, the first use of the creole variant occurs in anyting (1.3) after seven consecutive incidences of interdentals, all in word-initial position, including the marked combination [ðəθiηz] the things. However, an interesting pattern of variability emerges in the use of the interdental/stop variants of text 8 when the context is more closely examined. Even in this limited excerpt with a total num ber of seventy-six putativc interdentals, interdentals and stops are clustered dif ferentially in separate paragraphs with a varying interdental frequency which differs from the overall figures shown in table 3.1:
CREOLE ACROLECTS AS INNOVATIONS
79
Table 3.2: Interdental frequency in three segments (Text 8) Segment 1 Segment 2 Segment 3 Overall
(1.1-10) (1.11-21) (1.22-40) (1.1-40)
73.3% (11/15) 23.8.% (5/21) 45.0% (18/40) 44.7% (34/76)
The shifts in the three sections seem to follow naturally from the level of attention paid to speech and the speaker's degree of involvement and familiar ity with his topic. In the first part of the text, he is more formal and self-con scious, basically giving a fairly formal overview of nutrition problems in Belize; this is accompanied by a high incidence of interdentals (73.3%). The second segment is more relaxed because he positively presents a familiar topic ("Carib foods"); this corresponds to a predominantly creole pronunciation and a very low incidence of English variants (23.8%). Finally, the third segment reverts to a degree of formality, as he moves on to Mayan methods of land cultivation and concludes with a critique of those methods (45%). Obviously, the text aver age frequency of 44.7% obscures the text-internal variability which is only matched in the third segment. Such variation illustrates the extreme sensitivity of phonological features to context and mood. Clearly, this limited example demon strates that acrolects are very different from the standard, at least in respect to interdentals and their variants. This is not tantamount to saying that standards are stable, but it is obvious that acrolects are much less stable, showing that the acquisition of interdentals is not a simple, rigid, and unilateral process, but reflects psychological and social variations in discourse processing. An acquired phonological feature is a finely-tuned instrument that helps signal the speaker's intention and evaluation of the topic and/or the audience, and is an important aspect of interpersonal and intergroup mechanisms which must hold an important place in the speakers' communicative competence, as demon strated in Labov (1972) for Black English, for example. 3.3.2 Morphological features Most diagnostic morphological features found in English-based varieties are also distributed in quantitatively variable proportions according to the frequen cy variability strategy. The most common features include postnominal or postverbal markers of tense, aspect, and case in Standard English: plural, thirdperson singular present, past, and possessive. The tense-aspect system in native varieties is represented differently, as well as the marking of number (typical ly postnominal markers, as in da bali dem 'those friends') and of possession (typically simple juxtaposition or the use of pre-possessor morphology as in Jan fren/fi Jan fren "John's friend").
80
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
A quick overview of texts 8 and 9 indicates that the addition of Englishderived morphology occurs in fairly high proportions in plural marking and in equivalent amounts for both speakers (87.9% and 83.3%). Other features (e.g., the third-person singular present morpheme and the past morpheme) occur less frequently in these small texts but indicate the same trend, at least for the Creole speaker (Peter): Table 3.3: Morphological acrolectal features PLURAL N [z] 0 Peter 33 87.9% (29) 12.1% Mark 6 83.3% (5) 16.7%
N 8 4
3S/PRES [z] 0 62.5%(5) 37.5% 100% 0
N 4 0
PAST [d] 75% (3) -
0 25% —
Morphological features occur less frequently than phonological items; thus, a short text is less revealing of morphological frequency patterns of vari ation, and it is not possible to say whether the ethnic difference is represented in morphological variation. Plural marking, however, indicates the same textinternal variability (for text 8) that was observed for interdental variation, indi cating again that the second segment is more informal and more likely to include traces of the native basilectal system. The third segment actually includes hypercorrected plurals, or overpluralization, which reflects structural hypercorrection, the use of the second linguistic strategy, with a 112% rate of plural marking since nineteen nouns are pluralized in the acrolect while only seventeen would be in Standard English: Table 3.4: Plural marking in three segments (Text 8) Segment 1 Segment 2 Segment 3 Overall
(1.1-10) (1.11-21) (1.22-40) (1.1-40)
100% (6/6) 50% (4/8) 112% (19/17) 87.8% (29/33)
A similar variability in number marking occurs more broadly in the com bination of plural and singular coreferents in nouns, pronouns, and verbs, as in "one of the things about a, fisherman is that they don't have a very good diet" (8: 1) and "dey make a thing call 'em casarina, which is -it's -a dried and process"; the cassaba were strain, it comes into a kinda powder" (8: 14-17). These excerpts illustrate the combined effects of the creole system, represent ed here in zero-number marking, number-neutral value of creole 'em function ing as an alternative for a relative pronoun, and the superimposition of the
CREOLE ACROLECTS AS INNOVATIONS
81
English system (an attempt to conjugate the verbal is/were, and the marking of third person singular present). Other features display a similar frequency vari ability of the creole and standard variant of a single linguistic feature: for exam ple, the marking and non-marking of third person singular as in "it look like cabbage, but it doesn 't grow like cabbage" (8: 6-7). The frequency variability strategy can be extended to include standard and creole variants of different variables, a phenomenon which involves feature mixing: one standard feature is marked and another is not, as in the following sentence in which the verb is marked in standard fashion and the negation is nonstandard: "the lady hypnotizes you, they no know it" (9: 6,7). Similarly, there is frequent variation in the use of the V-ing English progressive. In text 8, lines 33 and 34, the same verb form occurs twice in succession, first with a cop ula-less progressive and then with the unmarked form: dey using a little mech anisations. . . dey use certain additives. . .The same combination with the verb say occurs in (8): (8) Sometimes talking, and you don't really understand what they saying, right. You no understand what they say.[K, 10.2:1] Structural hypercorrection, the second acrolectal strategy identified above, is represented in the peculiar use of past marking, with some confusion of pre sent perfect and preterit, as in '7 didn't eat it for years, but I saw it, and I think it's in S. a couple months ago" (8: 7, 8); also in other examples not included in the two sample texts: (9) We have shown we not responded to the opportunities favorable. (Peter T9; 1:20) (10) We were being taught to speak English from grammar school days. (Errol, T.7; 3:1.3). Finally, the third acrolectal strategy, relexification, is commonly used to grammaticalize nonstandard interpretations of standard structures. It was men tioned above that the basilectal past/anterior preverbal morpheme mε may be replaced by the preterite form were/was. Other items, in particular certain adverbials, may function as substitutes for the basilectal marker. This is the case for the adverb just in we just have dat ship illustrated in (11). The cruise ship mentioned had, in fact, discontinued its visit to the village a couple of years before this conversation, thus it is clear that the use of just (and was) must have
82
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
a function distinct from the notion of immediacy which is the usual English gloss of just (11) We just have dat ship comin in here, dat was good because it only spend couple hours; de touris' it just stay couple hours. (That ship had just come in; it's a good thing that it only spent a couple of hours here; the tourists just stayed a couple hours.) [S:11:23; 1989] Additional evidence of the new function of had/was is also clear in the fol lowing excerpt from a conversation with the village midwife. She consistently uses had/was to refer to the setting of the story and to events anterior to the actu al topic (the death of the second baby of a pair of twins she had to deliver dur ing a storm). (12) I had one case, it was twins. Well, one come da Wednesday, and we had bad weda, Placencia was unda wata, no plane can land at di airstrip, no boat come, de road block off, de bridge dey flood. Well data baby neva come. When di wata brok Friday morning, and we had to catch di plane and gone up. Dat baby born on di plane just when di plane pitch into Belize. But di ambulance come wid, it had oxygen, you know, come a help di baby, and di baby died on de way to hospital. [Ti: 12:22-23] Note in (12) the use of neva, which is the negative equivalent of the past/ante rior morpheme me but is easily transferred into acrolectal speech with an equiv alent value. Furthermore, brok (in "di wata brok") is no indication of past tense marking; creole basilects have long reanalyzed certain standard past forms {broke, left, got, gone, born) as regular tenseless creole verbs, as seen in the fol lowing sentences: (13) Di dance had to brok up. (The dance was interrupted.) (14) I had to lef dat one. (I had to leave that one behind.) (15) Everybody use to got baby easy. (Everybody used to deliver their babies without problems.) (16) Dat mos' got cancer. (It must be cancer [that she has].) The various examples provided above clearly indicate that a borrowed
CREOLE ACROLECTS AS INNOVATIONS
83
form may be interpreted differently at separate stages of the continuum: some irregular preterites are interpreted as basic verb forms, and some preverbal aux iliaries (was, were, had, did) are grammaticalized as anterior preverbal mor phemes, as are other preverbal adverbials such as just. Similar adaptation occur in many other areas of the language. Adverbial forms or other categories can be assigned aspectual functions that they do not have in the lexifier language: steady as iterative/habitual (17); suddenly as a combination of inchoative/focus marker (as discussed above; see text 9:10, 16); will/would and contracted forms such as "they'll start cursing in (18) and usta are used to mark habitual/durative aspect (8: 4, 13; 9: 3, 8, 9, 10); start/begin are also often used as what appears to be an iterative rather than an inchoative aspect marker (18): (17) When a mε li bway da Belize wi de sell crab stedi ting. (When I was a lit tle boy in Belize-City, we used to sell crab regularly.) [B. 20:15] (18) They (Mayas) drink that (rum) down and they begin cursing and jumping around like fighting with people. Like they'llstart saying the word "smishna," shi-mi_ah-na. . .your mother is a. . .and they 'll start cursing people like that. The relexification/grammaticalization strategy is a pervasive phenomenon which provides flexible options in acrolectal development and, in effect, blurs the boundaries between morphology, syntax, semantics, and pragmatics. The above discussion of grammaticalization could as easily fit into the following summary of acrolectal syntax, since the syntax of acrolectal discourse is depen dent on the types of relexified morphemes just illustrated. 3.3.3 Syntactic features It is obvious from the acrolectal texts presented in this and previous chapters that acrolectal syntax is different from standard syntax in numerous ways, some more covert than others. This is most clearly represented in high frequencies of salience structures, the presence of resumptive pronouns in relative clauses, ser ial verb-type forms, and special aspectual forms. Those patterns are more fre quent and diversified in creole acrolects than in their superstrates. In syntax the most common strategy is frequency variability, a combination of standard and creole features: 1) The negative construction can be represented both by the use of the doauxiliary and the negative morpheme according to standard patterns, or by reg ular preverbal no or multiple negation widespread in creole syntax. Only the
84
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
standard negation is used (four times) in Peter's text, whereas Mark uses two standard forms and one creole negative constructions. 2) Copular absence or presence in acrolects is another common combina tion found in variable frequencies. Standard copula forms are rarely found in a consistent fashion in acrolects, but the combination copula/zero-copula is typi cal of acrolects, as in "government is helping them. . . .they using a little mech anisations" (8: 32,33). The absence of copula usually entails the absence of the passive voice in acrolects, which, in this respect, matches the creole absence of passive even though an agentive preposition may occur in the acrolect: (19) The school I used to go to used to teach by nuns. (Kim T. 10; 1:1) (20) West Indies, yeah, well, we influenced a lot; we influence by West Indian custom, West Indian music, everyting. (Errol, T.10.6: 3) In addition, copula usage is overextended to fulfill focusing functions which are not common in standard English, especially in presentative positions or cleft/pseudo-cleft constructions, with the frequent use of is/it's before topics, as in: "is one of the things we don't bother about that in Belize" (8:2); "I think it's in Sartineha a couple months ago" (8: 8). 3) Relativization shows interesting patterns in acrolects. Although the reg ular standard relative pronouns "which, that, zero" are commonly used in acrolects instead of creole we, they are often accompanied by resumptive pro nouns such as: (21) Is one of the things we don't bother about that in Belize (8:2-3) (22) They have two different type, you have the type, the Caribs, they use plen ty which they use it for all different type of things. (8:11-13). Resumptive pronouns in relatives are highly related to the focusing/repetition phenomena represented in topic structures (Escure 1988). In (22), the NP the type is fronted and presented by a special topic structure (you have), relativized, and pronominalized in the relative clause. In (23) the NP the woman is fronted and similarly presented, relativized after its preposition, and associated with a paraphrase: (23) They have some woman, like, after the celebration is finished, you go along with which or whatever you call the lady -the bouye-. (9:11-13)
CREOLE ACROLECTS AS INNOVATIONS
85
4) Serialized verbals are often disguised in acrolects as semantically asyn detic coordinated structures similar to those found in Tayo (Corne et al. 1995), as discussed above. Such combined fragments are certainly part of what pro duces idiosyncratic acrolectal structures, more paratactic than syntactic, as illustrated in the following examples: (24) dey use it for-um dey make a thing call em casarina. (8: 14) (25) they cut down the land and they burn it in a dry. (8: 23) (26) they would come dig up around those old stumps. (8: 27) In addition, (27) presents serials in a more meaningful sequence: (27) Sometimes they'll want to kill you, chop you up with a machete. . .This man he was saying that the guy came up to his house that night drunk, raped his wife and chopped 'im up all over 'is head, cut 'im over there. Like last month a guy got drunk around Silk Grass there and he went into this lady-he-used-to-live-with- house, and got a look at her, looked at her and looked at the kids, and just went about mincing them up with his machete. [12:34] The verbals qualify as serials because they do not amount to separate actions but fit together to depict one overall event, some verbals fulfilling the roles of prepositions, providing place, manner, or time information; thus, the sequence kill you chop you up is considered to be a serial structure because it includes the main action verb followed by a secondary verb indicating the man ner of killing. Similarly, the sequence [chopped 'im up over 'is head cut 4m over there] is basically made up of verbals which seem in English to be almost paraphrases of each other; however, there is a subtle, but essential, distinction within a creole context. The first verb chop is more specific as it indicates a rapid, repeated manner of cutting, whereas the verb cut means more generally "attack with a sharp object." Therefore, the creole serial concept of comple mentary verbals is represented in the sentence shown above, even though it seems merely repetitive in English. Most of the syntactic features outlined here tend to overlap with discourse features. This is the case for the extension of the "copula" to topicalization and the use of resumptive pronouns in relative clauses which is related to repetitive patterns represented in creole discourse. Serialization is also related to the flow of pragmatic organization and cohesion represented in creole discourse. Those
86
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
factors will be more closely examined in the following chapter. 3.3.4 Effects of basilectal influence in acrolects This chapter has provided a summary of a few phonological, morphological, and syntactic features felt to be representative of acrolects. The selected features include interdental/stop variation, negation, copular variation, relat vization, verb serialization, and the marking of number, tense, and aspect. Observations of those linguistic phenomena strongly suggest that basilectal substratal pat terns are incorporated into acrolects through various innovative strategies. Those strategies include the combination of creole and standard variants result ing in variable frequencies which reflect the introduction of new variants, struc tural hypercorrection, and relexification. Acrolectal differences from the corresponding "target" language can thus be explained in terms of first language/vernacular input resulting in a new code. In other words, there is evidence of substratal/native vernacular influence on an acquired variety, a strategy no doubt similar to that underlying pidgin genesis as well as second language acquisition. Basilectal/vernacular linguistic behav ior appears to be reinterpreted through superstate or "target" equivalents, although it cannot be viewed merely as a calquing process. It is much more like ly that the acquisition target is to produce a new, creative code that captures contexts and speakers socially different from the standard speakers, contexts, and speakers. It is a set of intended differences representing different identities. The relexification of basilectal morphemes into standard morphemes and the substitution of basilectal phonemes for standard phonemes represent vernacular influence in interdialectal situations, especially when the same speakers control different dialects. 4. Conclusion This chapter has established that acrolects cannot be assimilated to standards. The few features (derived from various linguistic components) that were examined provide evidence of distinctive patterns not found in the standard. Clearly, the acrolectal continuum subset constitutes another language category that differs as much from the external standard as it does from the native basilectal subset (cre les) and the mesolectal subset (semi-formal). Acrolects correspond to the most formal subset of the creole continuum which combines features of the native and acquired language. The evidence presented indicates that the acquisition of acrolects is not a unidirectional development toward an official target but rather a complex, variable, and socially significant process showing the combined effects of basilectal and superstratal influences, as well as the possible emergence of uni-
CREOLE ACROLECTS AS INNOVATIONS
87
versal features, an issue to be discussed in the following chapter. In sum, it is claimed here that when two different but regularly interacting systems, as typically represented in creole continua, conflict in one specific lin guistic area, diverse creative strategies are implemented to produce an ade quately formal style while at the same time meeting the structural needs of the native system. It may well be that the process of piginization and the process of acrolect acquisition, as well as other more traditional cases of second language acquisition, function in similar ways. This view would also lend support to the claim that early stages of pidginization and creolization are not cases of simpli fication but, to the contrary, include extensive variable systems in contact, sim ilar to those we can now observe in real life second dialect/second language or acrolect acquisition situations. Endnotes 1. It is generally said that a serial verb construction is characterized by a single intonational contour. This is the case in all the examples produced here. 2. Currently, there are valuable attempts at documenting the early development of creole through research of eighteenth- and nineteenth-century creole sources, such as Lalla & D'Costa (1991) for Jamaican Creole and Rickford & Handler (1994) for Barbadian. However, written documents can only represent restricted aspects of the varieties used at the time, since written representations of the creole presuppose the author's personal interpretation of an oral variety of which he is usually not a native speaker. 3. Both control repertoires which include basilects, mesolects, and acrolects (see Escure 1982 for samples of those variations and a classification of the contexts and speech acts which trig ger such linguistic variations). 4. This feature is also characteristically variable in Black English and in all second dialects of English; generally, interdentals are universally marked phonemes that are relatively rare in world languages.
Chapter 4 The Interaction of Syntax and Pragmatics in Acrolects: Topic Marking Abstract Topic marking strategies are examined in the context of spontaneous Belizean acrolectal discourse. Three major strategies are identified (fronting, repetition, and presenta tion) in a representative sample. Synchronic and diachronic comparisons are estab lished between basilects and acrolects, with the intent to assess crosslectal variability. Belizean patterns are then compared to an equivalent standard (not creole-related) con trol sample (American English), in order to test the putative distinctiveness of dis course features in creole acrolects as second dialects. The remarkable stability observed in pragmatic structure suggests that paratactic strategies are consistently priv ileged in Belizean varieties and closely linked to topicalization strategies. 1. Syntax and discourse features The previous chapter briefly identified idiosyncratic aspects of Belizean acrolects. Acrolects display a unique set of phonological and morphological features, which distinguish them from their basilectal and lexifier counterparts in corresponding phonological and morphological areas. Acrolectal syntax also appears to be characterized by a high degree of flex ibility, reflecting the three major types of strategies outlined in chapter three: frequency variability combining basilectal and standard forms in varying degrees, hypercorrection of standard forms, and relexification of basilectal ele ments. However, with the possible exception of some limited verb-bound syn tactic rules, such as negation, the scope of syntactic rules is likely to expand beyond simple sentential units, requiring reference to a discourse context, espe cially to a natural discourse context, as previewed in chapter one. There are obvious advantages to be derived from the study of discourse
90
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
produced in natural social situations. The first advantage lies in the presence of an interpretable context, as opposed to working with sentences artificially elicit ed through interviews or lab protocols. Spontaneous communication is undoubt edly the correct setting to evaluate how second dialects, such as acrolects, are acquired. Secondly, this type of context is particularly conducive to an under standing of the articulation of syntax and pragmatics. Furthermore, the investi gation of natural discourse is most likely to offer privileged insights into the dynamics of linguistic change which led to the development of pidgins and cre les, and the concomitant acquisition of acrolects, since all of these are acquired in spontaneous, unmonitored contexts. The analysis of the syntax of discourse, however, poses serious challenges, both theoretical and methodological, as outlined in chapter one. Although the definition of structural units of analysis selected here may be controversial, and the discourse model adopted perhaps not entirely satisfactory, the approach fol lowed here will nevertheless provide crucial insights into rarely investigated areas, and in particular acrolectal performance as representative of second dialect acquisition, and the interaction of syntax and pragmatics in acrolects. The area of discourse selected for analysis involves the typology and distribu tion of topic structures. 1.1 The theoretical interpretation of topics In theoretical analyses of topic structures in English or other Indo-European lan guages, one major concern has been the interpretation of the anaphoric relations which hold between a topic and some other sentence constituent. In the early transformational generative framework (Chomsky 1973; 1977; Ross 1967), top ics are fronted by movement rules, and their pronominal copies may be left in the pre-extraction position in the underlying base sentence. Although I will use in this discussion the terms topicalization, left dislocation, and clefting which were first developed as part of the movement analysis, I assume here no such interpretation. These terms simply constitute convenient ways to identify sepa rate surface structural mechanisms dealing with topic presentation, some accompanied by anaphoric pronouns and others not. Similarly, the term fronting does not necessarily imply that the topic was elsewhere at another level; it mere ly refers to initial placement. In fact, it is possible to assume a basic topic-first structure, instead of a subject-first sequence (for SVO languages). In the later generative framework, and in particular in government and binding (GB) theory (Chomsky 1977; 1981), the process of topicalization is accounted for by two base rules:
INTERACTION OF SYNTAX AND PRAGMATICS IN ACROLECTS
91
a) S" → TOP S' b) S' → COMP S' An OSV structure such as, "My mother, I like" is accounted for by mov ing an underlying WH-phrase in S' into COMP position, then deleting it, leav ing an "empty element." An OSV Pro sentence (left dislocation) such as "My mother, I like her" is explained by assuming that the base contains the pronom inal anaphora co-indexed with TOP, rather than a WH-phrase and, thus, no movement applies. However, the GB framework does not readily account for all topic structures, except perhaps in some restricted styles of English. The scope of topic marking is an issue which conflicts with the GB inter pretation. The traditional sentence-bound interpretation of topics does not ade quately account for the scope of topics in natural discourse contexts such as the ones providing the data in this analysis. This is because, as shown in chapter one, spontaneous conversations can hardly be broken into simple sentences, a fact which led to my choice of the "topic unit" as the unit of analysis. The scope of a topic may extend to several verb units, although in some cases it can natural ly be restricted to one simple verb-phrase. Another problem with the GB framework is its specification that co-indexing must exist between the topic and some other element (empty or lexicalized) in the comment. In fact, there are structures in which the comment or predicate contains elements which are not anaphorically bound to the topic, even though some semantic relation may hold between them, as shown in the following sentence: (1) Citrus dey had a lot of competition « with Argentina, but now de bananas we can't produce enough « bananas to put in de market for Europe.1 (BL=Pom/94.3) In (1), the topic citrus is not linked to any overt constituent anaphor, although it is clear that it is topicalized out of a prepositional phrase [for citrus] with con comitant loss of the preposition, and originating as a complement of competition. In addition to the topicalization of citrus, this sentence also illustrates left disloca tion in bananas, with a full copy in the extraction position. In their fronted posi tion, citrus and bananas are similar to presentative structures with adverbial or prepositional highlighting morphology of the type as far as X is concerned, or as to X in English. A likely standard English version appears in (la): (la) As far as citrus is concerned, they had a lot of competition from Argentina, and as to bananas, we can't produce enough to put on the market.
92
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
Chomsky's GB theory cannot account for the wide use of zero anaphora in creole varieties, as well as in some types of casual English discourse. The prag matic inferences involved in assigning the antecedents for anaphora will also be discussed in the following chapters dealing with Chinese (chapters six, seven, and eight), with reference to a pragmatic theory of anaphora (Huang 1994). 1.2 Topic There is no consensus on the issue of the basic definition of topic, except for the fact that topics have multiple facets. A special issue of Linguistics (1992:30) illustrates some of the perspectives on topic-hood, with special attention to the grammatical, pragmatic, psycholinguistic and crosslinguistic nature of topics in utterances and in discourse. For example, Givón refers to psycholinguistic notions of mental processing derived from artificial intelligence research. "Referents ('topics') serve as file labels in the episodic memory for stored text" (Givón 1992:5). Cadiot refers to topics in French in terms of form-function rela tionships, hypothesizing that "the syntactic devices associated with topic-hood match pragmatic functions and strategies" (Cadiot 1992:57). Schiffrin discuss es the duality of the notion of topic functions at the communicative level, as well as at the linguistic level (Schiffrin 1992:165). Yule and Mathis define speech topics in terms of "'staging', which organizes the various elements of the speaker's contribution into background and foreground positions, and. . .'constructed dialogue', which captures the use of direct speech forms (though not verbatim quotes) within reports of previous conversations" (Yule and Mathis 1992:199). De Beaugrande examines "'topic' in respect to the econ omy of discourse, that is, the active system of values, focuses, and priorities among textual elements, and to the agenda of discourse, that is, the ongoing docket of actions, needs, motives, and goals" (de Beaugrande 1992:243). Not surprisingly, considering the diversity of such definitions or descrip tions, it is stated in the introduction of this series of articles that "Definitions of 'topic' and 'topic-hood' are obviously controversial" (Dittmar 1992:21). Such complexity even leads some authors to a radical disposal of the notion of topic. Schlobinski and Schütze-Coburn (1992:89) show that "problems arise when topic is equated with 'given' or 'known' information, with 'point of departure', with 'what the sentence is about', with 'communicative dynamism." Since a definition of topic is unobtainable, they consequently propose to abandon that cumbersome notion, substituting for it another potentially cumbersome mecha nism, as they propose "the independent treatment of all linguistically relevant categories (at all levels) that are usually factored into the topic equation in one place or another." Notwithstanding disagreements on topics, the following discussion will
INTERACTION OF SYNTAX AND PRAGMATICS IN ACROLECTS
93
rely heavily on realistic data, and especially chunks of spontaneous conversa tions to provide an empirical analysis of topic units in Belizean and Chinese varieties, and perhaps eventually reach an interpretation of its place in human language processing. 1.3 Topic and focus It is often presumed that topic and focus are distinct concepts and there has been various attempts at distinguishing between those two notions. For example, topic is often defined as "the subject about which something is said" or as "given information" (Crystal 1987:421), whereas the focus is "an element in a sentence to which the speaker wishes to draw special attention" (Crystal 1987:432). This presumed contrast may, in fact, lead to confusion since there is no reason why given information may not be that to which a speaker wants to draw attention. Some linguists believe that there is a clear formal distinction between focusing and topicalization, in addition to a "comma intonation" which would occur with topicalization but not with focusing: In topicalization, the topic NP is not coindexed with any null element in an Aposition, but is coindexed with some overt pronominal (or quasi-pronominal) form: "Mary, I saw her yesterday". . .In contrast, focused NPs are always coin dexed with a null element in an A-position, never with any overt element: "It was Mary that I saw" (Bickerton 1993:192). Bickerton thinks that focusing (here, clefting) is the dominant syntactic device to achieve constituent emphasis, in contrast to topicalization mecha nisms, which according to him occur in few creoles. However, spontaneous dis course contexts do not validate a clear distinction between topic and focus. Whether reference is made to presupposition, scope of assertion, assertive ver sus counter-assertive focus, or old/given versus new information, there seems to be no basis for treating topic and focus as separate constituents or as involving different processes. Focus appears to be a mark of salience given indiscrimi nately to old or new topics, and the focusing process can be applied to any kind of constituent, and anywhere in the sentence or proposition, as will be demon strated in various types of Belizean and Chinese discourse. The general associ ation of the topic with the notion of "aboutness" in the sentence or in larger units seems to be satisfactory because of its very generality (Keenan & Schieffelin 1976; Wald 1983:104) . The notion of "aboutness" is also related to that of "firstness" or frontness (initial, pre-clausal position), although it will be shown that focusing can apply almost anywhere in the sentence or utterance. In the fol lowing discussion, the term topic marking will be broadly used to refer to focus ing mechanisms of various types.
94
CREOLE AND DIALECT CONTINUA
2. Types of topic strategies This analysis will refer to three major types of topic structures commonly found in the world languages, although not necessarily with the same degree of fre quency. The aim of this study is to determine which of those common topic strategies regularly occur in acrolects, and whether the relative incidence of such strategies separates acrolects from other lects and from their lexifier languages. The strategies are: 1) fronting of the topic, that is, various types of focused structures, whether nominal or verbal, appear in sentence—or clause-initial position, regardless of logical position, or place of extraction; 2) copying or repetition of the topic within the discourse unit; and 3) the use of specific presentative elements external to the actual sentence as topic markers. Those three categories of topic structures are presented in more detail, then ana lyzed in acrolectal texts. Such topicalization strategies are assumed to be much more frequent and diversified throughout the continuum than in the lexifier lan guage (English), which is not topic prominent (Escure 1988). In order to verify this assumption, a brief control sample of standard English varieties external to Belizean acrolects, American English, will be the subject of analysis for com parative purposes. 2.1 Topic fronting Sentence or clause-initial placement of the topic element takes place in struc tures traditionally referred to as topicalization with simple fronting [citrus in (1), everything in (2)]. It may appear as left dislocation, which involves the nominal or pronominal copying of an initial topic. The topic may be a subject [Carihs in (3)] or a fronted direct object [the second topic of (1) bananas, or de unclean in (4)]. It appears that any constituent, nominal (2, 3, 4), verbal (5), or adverbial (6), may function as topic and may be fronted. (2) Everyting we have to pay for « (Escure 1988:163) (3) The Carihs, « they have different type of cassava (Escure 1988:170) (4) De Bible tell you dat de God made all different animals unclean and de unclean « dey shouldn't eat, right? 'The Bible tells you that God created various unclean animals, and the unclean they shouldn't be eaten, right' (T=Adv/94)
INTERACTION OF SYNTAX AND PRAGMATICS IN ACROLECTS
95
(5) Lock on me, she mε<