Constraints on Language: Aging, Grammar, and Memory
This page intentionally left blank.
Constraints on Language: Aging, Grammar, and Memory
edited by
Susan Kemper University of Kansas and
Reinhold Kliegl University of Potsdam
Kluwer Academic Publishers New York/Boston/Dordrecht/London/Moscow
eBook ISBN: Print ISBN:
0-306-46902-2 0-7923-8526-8
©2002 Kluwer Academic Publishers New York, Boston, Dordrecht, London, Moscow All rights reserved No part of this eBook may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, recording, or otherwise, without written consent from the Publisher Created in the United States of America Visit Kluwer Online at: and Kluwer's eBookstore at:
http://www.kluweronline.com http://www.ebooks.kluweronline.com
CONTENTS
List of Contributors
vii
Preface
xi Susan Kemper
Part 1: Constraints on Language: Aging
1
Language Production and Aging
3
1.
Deborah M. Burke
2.
Working Memory and Spoken Language Comprehension: 29 The Case for Age Stability in Conceptual Short-Term Memory Arthur Wingfield and Patricia A. Tun
3.
Discourse Processing and Aging: Resource Allocation As a Limiting Factor
53
Elizabeth A. L. Stine-Morrow and Lisa M. Soederberg Miller
Part 2: Constraints on Language: Memory
77
4.
79
Limitations on Syntactic Processing Susan Kemper and Karen A. Kemtes
v
vi
5.
Verbal Working Memory Capacity and On-Line Sentence Processing Efficiency in the Elderly
107
Gloria Waters and David Caplan
6.
Testing Age Invariance in Language Processes
137
Reinhold Kliegl, Ulrich Mayr, Martina Junker, and Gisbert Fanselow
Part 3: Constraints on Language: Grammar 7.
Processing Difficulty and Principles of Grammar
169 171
Gisbert Fanselow, Reinhold Kliegl, and Matthias Schlesewsky
8.
Parsing and Memory
203
Lyn Frazier
Part 4: Constraints on Language: Neuroscience
225
9.
227
Working with Limited Memory: Sentence Comprehension in Alzheimer's Disease Daniel Kempler, Amit Almor, Maryellen C. MacDonald, and Elaine S. Andersen
10.
Memory or Aging? That's the Question: An Electrophysiological Perspective on Language
249
Thomas C. Gunter, Sandra H. Vos, and Angela D. Friederici
11.
Age Effects on the Functional Neuroanatomy of Syntactic Processing in Sentence Comprehension
283
David Caplan and Gloria Waters
Concluding Observations
299
Reinhold Kliegl and Susan Kemper
Index
309
LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS
Dr. Amit Almor Department of Psychology University of Southern California Los Angeles, Ca 90089
[email protected] Dr. Elaine S. Andersen Department of Linguistics University of Southern California Los Angeles, Ca 90089
[email protected] Dr. Deborah M. Burke Department of Psychology Pomona College Claremont, CA 917 11
[email protected] Dr. David Caplan Neuropsychology Laboratory Department of Neurology Massachusetts General Hospital Boston, MA 021 14
[email protected] Dr. Gisbert Fanselow Department of Linguistics and Innovationskolleg "Formal Models of Cognitive Complexity" University of Potsdam Potsdam D14469 Germany
[email protected] vii
viii
Dr. Angela Friederici Max Planck Institute for Cognitive Neuroscience Stephanstrasse la Leipzig D-04103 Germany
[email protected] Dr. Lyn Frazier Department of Linguistics University of Massachusetts Amherst, MA 01003
[email protected] Dr. Thomas C. Gunter Max Planck Institute for Cognitive Neuroscience Stephanstrasse la Leipzig D-04103 Germany
[email protected] Martina Junker Department of Psychology and Innovationskolleg "Formal Models of Cognitive Complexity" University of Potsdam Potsdam D14469 Germany
[email protected] Dr. Susan Kemper Gerontology Center 4089 Dole University of Kansas Lawrence, KS 66045
[email protected] Dr. Daniel Kempler Department of Otolaryngology School of Medicine and the Leonard Davis School of Gerontology University of Southern California Los Angeles, CA 90089
[email protected]
ix
Dr. Karen Kemtes Volen National Center for Complex Systems Brandeis University Waltham, MA 02254
[email protected] Dr. Reinhold Kliegl Department of Psychology and Innovationskolleg "Formal Models of Cognitive Complexity" University of Potsdam Potsdam D14469 Germany
[email protected] Dr. Maryellen C. MacDonald Departments of Psychology and Linguistics University of Southern California Los Angeles, CA 90089
[email protected] Dr. Ulrich Mayr Department of Psychology and Innovationskolleg "Formal Models of Cognitive Complexity" University of Potsdam Potsdam D14469 Germany
[email protected] Dr. Lisa Soederberg Miller Department of Psychology Brandeis University Waltham, MA 02254
[email protected] Dr. Matthias Schlesewsky Department of Linguistics and Innovationskolleg "Formal Models of Cognitive Complexity" University of Potsdam Potsdam D14469 Germany
[email protected]
x
Dr. Elizabeth Stine-Morrow Department of Psychology University of New Hampshire Durham, NH 03824
[email protected] Dr. Patricia A. Tun Department of Psychology and Volen National Center for Complex Systems Brandeis University Waltham, MA 02454
[email protected] Dr. Sandra H. Vos Max Planck Institute for Cognitive Neuroscience Stephanstrasse la Leipzig D-04103 Germany
[email protected] Dr. Gloria Waters Department of Communication Disorders Boston University 635 Commonwealth Ave. Boston, MA 02215
[email protected] Dr. Arthur Wingfield Department of Psychology and Volen National Center for Complex Systems Brandeis University Waltham, MA 02254
[email protected]
PREFACE Susan Kemper
A debate about the role of working memory in language processing has become center-most in psycholinguistics (Caplan & Waters, in press; Just & Carpenter, 1992; Just, Carpenter, & Keller, 1996; Waters & Caplan, 1996). This debate concerns which aspects of language processing are vulnerable to working memory limitations, how working memory is best measured, and whether compensatory processes can offset working memory limitations. Age-comparative studies are particularly relevant to this debate for several reasons: difficulties with language and communication are frequently mentioned by older adults and signal the onset of Alzheimer's dementia and other pathologies associated with age; older adults commonly experience working memory limitations that affect their ability to perform everyday activities; the rapid aging of the United States population has forced psychologists and gerontologists to examine the effects of aging on cognition, drawing many investigators to the study of cognitive aging. Older adults constitute ideal population for studying how working memory limitations affect cognitive performance, particularly language and communication. Age-comparative studies of cognitive processes have advanced our understanding of the temporal dynamics of cognition as well as the working memory demands of many types of tasks (Kliegl, Mayr, & Krampe, 1994; Mayr & Kliegl, 1993). The research findings reviewed in this volume have clear implications - for addressing the practical problems of older adults as consumers of leisure timereading, radio and television broadcasts, as targets of medical, legal, and financial documents, and as participants in a web of service agencies and volunteer activities. Older adults are often the recipients of "elderspeak," an insulting and patronizing form of address which is intended to enhance older adults' comprehension (Kemper, 1992; Kemper, Finter-Urczyk, Ferrell, Harden, & Billington, in press); yet elderspeak, by conveying a sense of disrespect, may offend older adults, reducing intergenerational contact and thereby indirectly contributing to older adults' cognitive and social decline (Ryan, Giles, Bartolucci, & Henwood, 1986). Effective strategies for enhancing older adults' comprehension must be developed xi
xii
which will minimize processing demands without relying on "baby talk." Broadcasts and texts targeted at older adults must be adapted to slower information processing rates and reduced working memory capacity if older adults are to continue to be informed and engaged. The chapters in this volume examine what is known about memory, aging, and grammar in order to better understand how such constraints affect language and communication. PLAN
OF THE
BOOK
The contributors to this volume fall into three clusters: (1) Leading cognitive aging researchers with special expertise in language production and comprehension (Kemper, Burke, Kliegl, Stine-Morrow, Waters, Wingfield); (2) Syntacticians concerned with developing performance-based models of language (Frazier and Fanselow); (3) Neuroscientists studying language processing (Gunter, Caplan, Kempler). These researchers adopt a variety of methodological approaches to the study of language processing including psycholinguistic investigations of comprehension and production, psychometric studies of the component processes of reading and of individual differences, neuroimaging studies of linguistic function, and neurolinguistic investigations of pathologies of language. Research populations including young and older adults, older adults with dementia and other age-related diseases, and speakers of English and German. The first set of chapters draws upon recent research in cognitive aging to consider how language production and comprehension are constrained by aging. Studies of normal aging adults offer a unique opportunity to study the role of working memory in language processes. Each chapter focuses on a different aspect of language processing and explores how the architecure of cognition affects language processing. In Chapter 1, Burke draws upon Node Structure Theory in order to consider how asymmetries in language production and perception can arise from limitations of phonological access. She presents new evidence from experimental and naturalistic studies of verbal fluency, word finding, name retrieval, and spelling that highlight how constrains on phonological access can affect older adults. In Chapter 2, Wingfield and Tun focus on studies of spoken language perception to consider the role of working memory and the role of compensatory mechanisms in language processing. In Chapter 3, Stine-Morrow and Soederberg Miller consider how time as a limited resource can affect older adults' reading comprehension. They use regression techniques to decompose the reading process, discovering how some components may be disadvantaged by slower processing whereas other components of reading may be advantaged by slower processing. The chapters in Section 2 focus on syntactic processing. Kemper and Kemtes in Chapter 4 review recent research on the effects of working memory limitations on language processing with an emphasis on syntactic processing. In Chapter 5, Waters and Caplan consider whether there are significant individual differences in working memory, how they best might be measured, and the extent to which such individual differences affect on-line language processing. In Chapter 6, Kliegl and his colleagues investigate how syntactic factors interact to affect older adults' processing of complex constructions. Like the other contributors to this section, they argue that
xiii
some aspects of language processing are age-invariant whereas others are agevarying. Kliegl et al. also provide a detailed tutorial on alternative experimental paradigms for investigating age invariance in language processing. The contributors in Section 2 identify a mosaic of age-spared versus age-impaired language processes at lexical - sentence - and discourse levels of analysis; age-spared processes appear to be buffered from working memory whereas age-varying processes are dependent on working memory. The third set of chapters offer insights from contemporary models of syntax. Both contributors seek to define which aspects of language are subject to working memory constraints and which are buffered from working memory limitations. In Chapter 7, Fanselow and his colleagues, working from a Minimalist perspective, consider parallels between formal grammatical theory and the operation of the human syntactic parser. They argue that grammars avoid postulating movement operations in the same way that human parsers do. Drawing upon linguistic arguments as well as experimental studies, they consider the costs of movement operations in both German and English. In Chapter 8, Frazier also draws upon linguistic arguments as well as experimental studies of reading to examine how sentence complexity as well as discourse factors can affect comprehension. The final set of chapters draws on neuroscience studies of language processing to examine how working memory may be affected by aging and, in turn, affect language processing. In Chapter 9, Kempler and his colleagues draw on comparative studies of healthy older adults and adults with probable Alzheimer's dementia. They show how Alzheimer's dementia selectively impairs semantic processes, including word retrieval and word comprehension, while sparing basic syntactic processes. In Chapter 10, Gunter and his colleagues from the MPI in Cognitive Neurosciences present evidence for age-related working memory limitations on syntactic processing from a study of event-related potentials (ERPs) measured during a sentence reading task. The effects of syntactic complexity on the pattern of ERPs varied with age and working memory capacity, providing further insight into the role of working memory in syntactic parsing. In Chapter 11, Caplan and Waters look at how the use of positron emission tomography (PET) can help to resolve questions concerning the neurological localization of language processing. They suggest that aging may affect language processing at the level of neurological organization and localization. Kliegl and Kemper provide a summary discussion of issues raised by these chapters in their Conclusion. ORIGINS
OF THE
BOOK
This book is based on a workshop sponsored by the Merrill Advanced Studies Institute and the Research Training Program in Communication and Aging at the University of Kansas. The workshop was held March 25 - 29, 1998 in Sedona, AZ. Participation was limited to the senior contributing authors (Burke, Wingfield, Waters, Stine-Morrow, Kliegl, Fanselow, Frazier, Gunter, Kempler, and Caplan) plus a small group of students and faculty from the University of Kansas. We thank Mabel Rice, the Director of the Merrill Advanced Studies Institute and University Distinguished Professor, for her support and encouragement, Meredith Porter for her
xiv
excellent arrangements, and Diane Filion, Ruth Herman, Mary Lee Hummert, Karen Kemtes, Joan McDowd, Melanie Morgan, Laureen O’Hanlon, Pam Saunders, Dick Schiefelbusch, Shari Speer, and Steve Schroeder for their spirited participation and assistance with the workshop. The Research Training Program in Communication and Aging is supported by a grant from the National Institute on Aging, T32 AG000226.
xv REFERENCES
Caplan, D., & Waters, G. S. (in press). Verbal working memory and sentence comprehension. Behavioral and Brain Sciences. Just, M. A., & Carpenter, P. A. (1992). A capacity theory of comprehension: Individual differences in working memory. Psychological Review, 99, 122149. Just, M. A., Carpenter, P. A., & Keller, T. A. (1996). The capacity theory of comprehension: New frontiers of evidence and arguments. Psychological Review, 103, 773-780. Kemper, S. (1994). Elderspeak: Speech Accommodations to older adults. Aging and Cognition, 1, 17-28. Kemper, S., Finter-Urczyk, A., Ferrell, P., Harden, T., & Billington, C. (in press). Using Elderspeak with Older Adults. Discourse Processes. Kliegl, R., Mayr, U., & Krampe, R. Th. (1994). Time-accuracy functions for determining process and person differences: An application to cognitive aging. Cognitive Psychology, 26, 134-164. Mayr, U., & Kliegl, R. (1993). Sequential and coordinative complexity: Age-based processing limitations in figural transformations. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 19, 1297-1320. Ryan, E. B., Giles, H., Bartolucci, G., & Henwood, K. (1986). Psycholinguistic and social psychological components of communication by and with the elderly. Language and Communication, 6, 1-24. Waters, G. S., & Caplan, D. (1996). The capacity theory of sentence comprehension: Critique of Just and Carpenter (1992). Psychological Review, 103,761-772.
This page intentionally left blank.
Part 1
CONSTRAINTS ON LANGUAGE: AGING
This page intentionally left blank.
1
LANGUAGE PRODUCTION AND AGING Deborah M. Burke
When older adults are asked to identify problems in their daily cognitive functioning, certain aspects of language production are at the top of their list. They rate word finding failures and tip of the tongue experiences (TOTs) as their most severe cognitive problems, and the ones most affected by aging (Rabbitt, Maylor, McInnes, Bent & Moore, 1995; Ryan, See, Meneer & Trovato, 1994; Sunderland, Watts, Baddeley, & Harris, 1986). Although older adults’ complaints focus on word retrieval failures, younger adults believe that older adults suffer general declines in their ability to produce effective language (Giles, Coupland & Wiemann, 1992; Ryan & Laurie, 1990). In this chapter, we investigate whether aging affects language production in only specific functions, or across the board. This question is important for evaluating two different types of theories of cognitive aging: informationuniversal and information-specific theories. We focus on word retrieval, reviewing empirical evidence that sheds light on the nature of age-related changes in production processes during adulthood. This evidence suggests an asymmetric effect of aging on different aspects of production, and we discuss the implications of this pattern for the two classes of theory. Changes in language production in old age carry practical as well as theoretical significance, because language production is a critical component of interpersonal communication. If aging impairs production, this may disrupt interpersonal communication, contributing to social isolation. Moreover, people use language production in their everyday interactions as an index of intellectual functioning. Impaired word production, for example, may negatively affect both self-evaluation of cognitive ability and evaluation by others (e.g., Ryan et al., 1994). Negative selfappraisal may promote withdrawal from social interaction, and negative appraisal by others may promote the use of simplified speech to older adults, which appears to further erode their self-evaluation of cognitive functioning (Cohen, 1994; Kemper, Othick, Warren, Gubarchuk, & Gerhing, 1996; Hummert, 1994; Ryan et al., 1994). This downward spiral linked to impaired production highlights the practical 3
4
Figure 1. A sample of nodes in the semantic and phonological systems representing the common nouns mausoleum and mortuary. Many nodes have been left out to simplify the figure. The arrows indicate the spread of priming, top-down, when nodes are activated during production. significance of identifying age-related changes in language production and the underlyingmechanisms. MODELS OF WORD PRODUCTION
There is considerable agreement about the production processes that allow us to name an object or produce a word in spontaneous speech. Probably the best specified and most popular production models are interactive activation models, a type of connectionist model with excitatory and inhibitory connections among representational units. A vast network of pathways connecting representational units is organized into a semantic system which represents word meanings and a phonological and orthographic system which represent word sounds and spellings, respectively (e.g., Burke, MacKay, Worthley, & Wade, 1991; Dell, 1986; Dell, Burger & Svec, 1997; Griffin & Bock, 1998; Harley, 1993; Levelt, 1989; MacKay,
5
1987; MacKay & Abrams, 1998; Stemberger, 1985). Production begins with activation of conceptual units and the spread of excitation through the network, priming semantically appropriate lexical representations which prepares them for activation (retrieval). Phonological representations corresponding to a lexical unit are primed, but temporal aspects of this priming are model-dependent. In some models selection of the lexical unit is completed before access to phonology (e.g., Levelt et al., 1991). In other models, phonological priming occurs during lexical selection so that priming from phonological nodes affects lexical selection in an interactive process (e.g., Dell et al., 1997; Harley, 1993; MacKay, 1987). Interactive activation models vary on specific features; we delineate one model which provides a framework for understanding word production in old age. Figure 1 illustrates aspects of the semantic, lexical and phonological representation of two words, mausoleum and mortuary according to MacKay’s (1987) interactive activation model, Node Structure Theory. The organization of representations or nodes is hierarchical with semantic representations connecting to a lexical node for each word, and lexical nodes connecting to phonological nodes. Note that phonological and semantic nodes are also shared with other words with these components. For example, lexical nodes for mausoleum and mortuary connect to some of the same phonological nodes because they share the phonemes /mo/, and to some of the same semantic nodes because they share an association with death. As shown by the arrows in Figure 1, excitation of semantic features of mausoleum would spread to mortuary, and excitation of phonological components of mausoleum would spread to mortuary. This interactive activation process will explain characteristics of word retrieval failures that we take up below. Activation of a node causes retrieval of the information it represents (MacKay, 1982, 1987). A node is activated if its priming level reaches a critical difference above other nodes in the same domain, a selection rule that makes retrieval sensitive to the priming level of competing nodes (e.g., Wheeldon & Monsell, 1994). The strength of connections between nodes determines the rate and amount of priming transmitted between them and is an important determinant of what information in memory becomes available. Recency and frequency of node activation strengthen connections, whereas aging weakens connections, thereby decreasing the transmission of priming (Burke et al., 1991; MacKay & Burke, 1990). WORD PRODUCTION IN OLD AGE
There is considerable empirical evidence that word production processes are impaired for older adults, consistent with their self reports’ of increased word finding failures. In a review of 25 studies of the effects of aging on picture naming, the majority of studies reported that older adults produced fewer correct names than young adults (Goulet, Ska & Kahn, 1994). In their spoken discourse, older adults produced more pronouns and ambiguous references compared to young adults when describing a memorable experience (Ulatowska, Hayashi, Cannito & Fleming, 1986), a picture (Cooper, 1990), a video (Heller & Dobbs, 1993), or retelling a story (Pratt, Boyes, Robins & Manchester, 1989). This age difference reflects the greater
6
difficulty that older adults have in retrieving the appropriate nouns (but see Glosser & Deser, 1992). Speech disfluencies such as filled pauses, repetitions and hesitations increase with age and may indicate word retrieval difficulties (Cooper, 1990; Kemper, 1992a). A clear case of word finding difficulty is the TOT state in which a person is temporarily unable to produce a word although they are absolutely certain that they know it. In the words of William James (1890), a TOT is “... a gap that is intensely active. A sort of wraith of the name is in it...making us at moments tingle with the sense of our closeness” (p.251). The gap does hold the meaning of the word, allowing rejection of wrong words. What is missing from the gap is the complete phonology of the word, although partial phonological information or related words may come to mind. Older adults report more naturally occurring TOTs during everyday life than young adults (Burke et al., 1991) and more TOTs induced in the laboratory using definitions of rare words (e.g., Burke et al., 1991; Rastle & Burke, 1996) or pictures of rare objects (e.g., a bellows, a yoke) (Brown & Nix, 1996) or pictures of famous people (Maylor, 1990b). While filling out a family tree, older adults also reported a greater proportion of TOTs for the names of members of their extended family than young adults (Burke & Austin, 1999). Interestingly, partial information and alternate words occur during a TOT less frequently for older than young adults (Burke et al., 1991; Cohen & Faulkner, 1986; Maylor, 1990a). Older adults’ word retrieval failures do not seem to be caused by a deficit in formulating the idea to be expressed or in activating appropriate semantic information because studies consistently demonstrate age constancy in conceptual knowledge and its retrieval. For example, on the WAIS vocabulary test participants describe the meaning of presented words. Performance shows little change in adulthood, at least into the 70’s (e.g., Salthouse, 1982, 1988). Similarly, young and older adults produce comparable scripts for common activities (e.g., Light & Anderson, 1983), similar responses for word associations (e.g., Burke & Peters, 1986; Howard 1979; Lovelace & Cooley, 1982) and the same properties of nouns whose meaning is biased by sentence context (Burke & Harrold, 1988; Light, Valencia-Laver, & Zavis, 1991). These findings support the conclusion reached in a number of thorough reviews of the literature: Semantic processes are unaffected by aging (Kemper, 1992b; Light, 1991; MacKay & Abrams, 1996; MacKay & Burke, 1990; Tun & Wingfield, 1993). The locus of older adults’ word finding deficits would seem to be in retrieval at the lexical or phonological level. THEORIES OF AGE-RELATED PRODUCTION FAILURES
There are two theories that have been advanced to explain word production failures and their increase in old age. The Transmission Deficit model extends the Node Structure Theory and postulates that TOTs are caused by insufficient transmission of priming from lexical nodes to phonological nodes (Burke & MacKay, 1997; Burke et al., 1991; MacKay & Burke, 1990). A node is activated only if its accumulation of priming reaches a criteria1 level. If connection strength weakens to the point that transmission of priming to a target node is inadequate to raise its priming to this level, a retrieval failure or error will occur. TOTs occur when connections to
7
Figure 2. Lateral inhibition between lexical units is illustrated for mausoleum and mortuary. The broken line indicates lateral inhibition produced by a lexical unit in proportion to its level of excitation. phonological nodes become too weak to transmit adequate priming. Under the Transmission Deficit model, recency and frequency of node activation strengthen connections so that rare words or words not used recently should be most susceptible to TOT, as observed (Burke et al., 1991; Harley & Brown, 1998). Aging weakens connections so that older adults should produce more TOTs than young adults, as observed (e.g., Burke et al., 1991). The Transmission Deficit theory is an information-specific theory because the type or structure of language units determines whether or not there are aging effects. The functional effect of transmission deficits depends on the architecture of the memory system. Transmission deficits are more likely to involve nodes with one-onone connections, such as phonological nodes which have one-to-one connections with lexical nodes (see Figure 1). In contrast, transmission of priming from semantic nodes to lexical nodes is aided by the many connections that Iink related concepts and produce summation of priming at lexical nodes, making transmission deficits unlikely (see Laver & Burke, 1993). An alternative account of TOTs postulates inhibition as the mechanism underlying TOTs, capturing the phenomenology of an alternate word “blocking” access to the target word. Retrieval fails because another word, related to the target word and more available, blocks or inhibits the target word (e.g., Jones, 1989; Reason & Lucas, 1984; Woodworth, 1938). Within a connectionist model, this occurs through lateral inhibitory connections between lexical nodes, as shown in
8
e.g., Harley, 1993; McClelland & Rumelhart, 1981; Stemberger, 1985. For example, excitation of the lexical node for mausoleum would produce inhibition of related but incorrect words such as mortuary. If, however, mortuary had accumulated more priming than mausoleum, its higher levels of excitation would lead to inhibition of the intended word mausoleum. This inhibition explanation is relevant to age differences via the Inhibition Deficit model proposed by Hasher and Zacks (1988). They argued that inhibitory processes become less efficient in old age so that older adults are less able to
Figure 3. An example of the sequence of verbal cues and pictures in the primed competitor paradigm. Participants produced a response to each stimulus.
9
suppress irrelevant information which impedes retrieval of target information. Word retrieval failures occur because, for example, “...older adults might have trouble when trying to remember the names of acquaintances to make introductions, not because of the loss of access to the relevant memories, but because irrelevant ones are likely to be activated as well, which slows retrieval of the target memories” (Zacks & Hasher, 1994, p. 259). In Figure 2, inhibition of mortuary by the intended word mausoleum would be impaired in older adults, increasing the competition from mortuary for retrieval and increasing the probability that a TOT would occur because an alternate word, mortuary, would be produced, blocking retrieval of the target word. The Inhibition Deficit model is an information-universal theory because the mechanism underlying aging effects, namely, inhibition, is independent of the type or structure of language units being processed. Thus, inhibition deficits would have widespread effects on language production, allowing selection of incorrect information at the level of a lexical item, causing TOTs, but also at a higher, semantic level, causing the intrusion of irrelevant thoughts into discourse. For example, older adults are hypothesized to be less able to inhibit irrelevant ideas at a semantic level and this should drive their narratives or conversations off-topic and produce inappropriate comments and anecdotes (Arbuckle & Gold, 1993; Zacks & Hasher, 1994). WORD PRODUCTION, SEMANTIC COMPETITORS AND INHIBITION DEFICITS
Under the Inhibition Deficit model, older adults’ word retrieval deficits reflect their reduced ability to inhibit irrelevant words which compete for retrieval with the correct word, slowing or preventing its production. We tested this explanation in a series of experiments using a primed competitor paradigm in which recent production of a word increases its competition with a correct word in a subsequent picture naming task (Vitkovitch & Humphreys, 1991; Vitkovitch, Humphreys & Lloyd-Jones, 1993; Wheeldon & Monsell, 1994). Words likely to compete with the correct name of a picture are words for objects sharing physical and semantic attributes with the pictured object; such words would be primed along with the correct name in early stages of processing the picture, but additional processing should allow the correct name to be selected over the competitors. Wheeldon and Monsell (1994) demonstrated that prior production of competitors for a picture name made them more available when the picture was presented, slowing production of the correct picture name. This semantic competitor effect on naming latency reflects the interference of the competitors with retrieval of the correct lexical unit. Note that when semantically similar prime words precede a target picture by a brief interval (e.g., about one second), picture naming is speeded, a semantic priming effect attributed to spreading semantic activation from the prime word to the target (e.g., Lupker, 1988). Under conditions, however, where primes and targets are semantically similar and occur at intervals of several seconds, short-lived semantic facilitation has dissipated and naming is slowed (Kroll & Curley, 1988; Wheeldon & Monsell, 1994).
10
Under the Inhibition Deficit hypothesis, older adults are less able to inhibit irrelevant information so their picture naming should be slowed more than young adults’ by competitors. There are no published data on competitor effects on older adults’ production. Interestingly, however, in speech perception, there were no age differences in the effect of a strong competitor on word recognition in sentences (Stine & Wingfield, 1994). Loveless and Burke (1999) reported three experiments in which young and older adults saw a series of alternating verbal cues and pictures and responded to each stimulus as quickly and accurately as possible with the appropriate one word name (see Figure 3). Verbal cues and pictures were selected that elicited correct responses from young and older adults in pilot testing, and thus naming errors were rare. The verbal cues were constructed to elicit an unrelated word or a word that named an object that was semantically and physically similar to a picture, and thus likely to be a competitor for picture naming. The semantic competitor effect is calculated by subtracting naming latency for a target picture (e.g., cake in Figure 3) when a prior trial presented a verbal cue eliciting an unrelated prime word (dice), from target naming latency when a prior trial presented a verbal cue eliciting a semantically similar prime word (pie). In Experiment 1, two filler trials intervened between the verbal cue for a similar or unrelated prime word and the target picture as shown in Figure 3. Naming latency for target pictures was slower after production of semantically similar prime words (e.g., competitors) compared to unrelated words for 20 young and 30 older
Figure 4. The primed competitor effect for young and older adults in Experiments 1-3 (Loveless & Burke, 1999). The competitor effect is the difference (in milleseconds) between picture naming latency in the unrelated prime condition and the primed competitor condition.
11
adults. Figure 4 shows the primed competitor effect for this experiment in the first panel. Although older adults were slower than young adults overall, there was no statistically significant age difference in the slowing produced by the primed competitor. Indeed, the competitor effect was about half as large in absolute terms for old as for young adults. This raised the possibility that the semantic competitor slowed target retrieval through inhibition of the target and this effect was slightly weaker in older adults because of inhibition deficits. This possibility, however, garnered no support in two subsequent experiments. In Experiment 2, we attempted to increase the competitor effect, especially for older adults, by having participants process the competitor twice before picture naming. The logic is that recent processing of a word strengthens its lexical and phonological connections, increasing its availability for production. By creating two opportunities for processing the competitor, we hoped to increase its availability beyond that in the primed competitor condition of Experiment 1, thereby increasing the competitor effect, especially for older adults. Prior to the verbal cue and picture naming tasks, 21 young and 21 older adults rated the pleasantness of half of the semantically similar prime words (competitors) that were then cued in the subsequent naming task. As shown in the middle panel of Figure 4, the competitor effect was greater than in Experiment 1, but this cannot be attributed to the double processing, because the competitor effect was comparable with single and with double processing. Indeed, there was no increase in the competitor effect from the pleasantness rating task, perhaps because it did not require production of the competitor (see Small, Hultsch & Masson, 1995). The competitor effect was statistically significant for both young and older adults and the magnitude of the competitor effect did not differ by age. In Experiment 3, we attempted to strengthen the competitor effect by eliminating some competitor-picture pairs with relatively low physical similarity that had been used in the first experiment. In all other respects the experiment followed Experiment 1. As can be seen in Table 1, the competitor effect was almost double that in Experiment 1 for both young and older adults, suggesting that competition is related to the physical similarity of the competitor and target. Again there was no age interaction with the competitor effect. The results of these experiments are quite clear: There is no evidence that older adults are more disrupted than young adults by competing but incorrect words in word retrieval. Recent production of a competitor slowed naming, but the effect was comparable across age in three experiments. These findings are contrary to the Inhibition Deficit model, because older adults displayed no sign of a deficit or inefficiency in suppressing irrelevant information (competitors) during retrieval. According to this model, inhibition is the process responsible for suppressing competing but incorrect words in naming; the results suggest this process is maintained in old age. When the competitor effect is considered within a connectionist model with lateral inhibition, the prediction for age effects is quite different from that based on the Zacks and Hasher (1994) notion that irrelevant information slows retrieval until it is inhibited. In connectionist models, inhibition causes interference as well as ending interference. That is, inhibition is emitted from a node in proportion to the
12
node’s level of excitation (e.g., McClelland & Rumelhart, 1981; Stemberger, 1985). The primed competitor achieves relatively high levels of excitation early in the processing of the picture, because of its recently strengthened connections, and would emit inhibition that would slow excitation of the target. If inhibition is impaired in old age, older adults would be affected by competitors. This prediction also is inconsistent with the findings. The primed competitor effect can be explained without invoking inhibition. Under the NST, which has no lateral inhibition, a node is activated if its priming level reaches a critical difference above the priming levels of other nodes in the same domain. Thus, a criteria1 difference between the priming level of the lexical node for the target and the priming level of the lexical node for the competitor must be reached before the target lexical node can be activated. The recent production of the competitor will strengthen its connections increasing the transmission of priming to its lexical node during early processing of the picture. The increased level of priming for the competitor increases the amount of priming that the target must accumulate to achieve the critical difference, thereby delaying target activation and production of the correct name (e.g., Vitkovitch, Humphreys, & Lloyd-Jones, 1993; Wheeldon & Monsell, 1994). The literature on repetition priming effects suggests that recent generation of a word increases availability of the word for production to the same extent across age in production tasks such as category exemplar generation (e.g., Light & Albertson, 1989; Maki & Knopman, 1996) or general knowledge questions (e.g., Rastle & Burke, 1996; Small et al., 1995; see Fleischman & Gabrieli, 1998 for a review). Within the NST framework, this suggests that activation strengthens connections for existing representations in a similar way for young and older adults (MacKay & Burke, 1990). Thus, in the competitor priming paradigm, recent production increases transmission of priming to the competitor to the same extent in young and older adults. Why is there no indication of transmission deficits in older adults? For example, a deficit in transmission of priming to the lexical node for the target, but not the recently activated competitor, would increase the competitor effect in older adults. This effect is not predicted because the functional effect of transmission deficits depends on the architecture of the relevant connections and nodes. The competitor effect occurs at a lexical level where converging connections from semantic representations summate at lexical nodes (see Figure 1), compensating for a transmission deficit in any single connection (see Laver & Burke, 1993 for full exposition of this argument). WORD PRODUCTION, PHONOLOGICAL PRIMING AND TRANSMISSION DEFICITS
Under the Transmission Deficit model, TOTs occur when semantic information activates a lexical node but at least some phonological information remains inaccessible because deficits in the transmission of priming prevent activation of relevant phonological nodes. This effect is information specific, localized to phonological nodes because they are connected by single connections making them vulnerable to transmission deficits (see Figure 1). We tested this explanation using priming paradigms to progressively hone in on phonological processes over a series
13
of experiments. The goal was to test the prediction of the Transmission Deficit model that recent activation at a phonological level would improve word retrieval. Rastle & Burke (1996) demonstrated that prior processing of an answer to a general knowledge question increased production of the answer to the question and reduced TOTs. General knowledge questions were selected whose answers were relatively low frequency words that were likely to induce TOTs, e.g., What do you call a word or sentence that reads the same backwards or forwards, such as 'Madam I'm Adam (answer: palindrome). Before presentation of the questions, young and older adults performed the prior processing task, pronouncing aloud and rating the pronunciation difficulty of the words that were answers to half the questions. They then made one of three responses to each question: "Know" and produced the answer; “Don't know” or “TOT”. Performance was strongly influenced by the prior processing. Figure 5 shows that prior processing increased correct answers to the questions, and decreased TOTs by nearly 50% for both young and older adults, although older adults produced more TOTs. These findings are consistent with the hypothesis that TOT states are less likely for words that have been produced recently, and they support the Transmission Deficit model in which recent production of a word strengthens connections among phonological nodes, thus reducing the probability of a TOT. Because, however, this paradigm involved repetition of the same word, connections at a lexical as well as a phonological level may have been involved. In an effort to isolate the effects of priming at a phonological level, Rastle and Burke (1996) manipulated the type of processing of the answer in the prior processing task. Participants rated the pleasantness of the word in a semantic
Figure 5. Percentage of correct responses and TOTs as a function of age and prior processing. Adapted from Rastle and Burke (1996).
14
condition and counted the number of syllables in a phonological condition. They found that phonological processing of the target reduced TOTs, and adding semantic processing did not increase this priming effect. This supports the hypothesis that recency of target processing influences the likelihood of TOTs, and that the retrieval failure occurs at the phonological level, although lexical level effects are also possible here, despite the manipulation of type of prior processing, because the identical word was involved in the prior processing and the main production task. James and Burke (1998) removed lexical level effects by using words in the prior processing task that were phonologically similar (or dissimilar) to the target, but not identical to the target. All the words were semantically unrelated to the target word so there was no overlap of nodes at the semantic or lexical level between
Figure 6. Example of the prior phonological processing task and general knowledge questions in Experiment 1 of James and Burke (1998). The phonological components of related words that overlapped the answer are underlined. They were not underlined in the experiment. For the Unprimed condition, related words were replaced by words phonologically unrelated to the target.
15
prime and target words. The prior processing task occurred before presentation of each general knowledge question and involved 10 words phonologically unrelated to the answer to the question (Unprimed Condition) or 5 phonologically related and 5 unrelated words (Primed Condition). Figure 6 shows an example of this procedure in the Primed Condition. Each of the 10 words was presented one at a time and participants pronounced each word aloud and rated it on pronunciation difficulty. The general knowledge questions followed immediately. The Transmission Deficit model postulates that production of phonologically related words strengthens some connections in the phonological system required for production of the target. Thus, prior processing in the Primed condition should increase correct responses and decrease TOTs. Consistent with this, young and older adults increased correct responses by about 10% in the Primed condition and decreased TOTs about 10%. Both effects were statistically significant and there was no interaction with age. These results confirm the involvement of phonological connections in TOTs, and demonstrate that recent activation of phonological connections can preclude word retrieval failures. In a second experiment, James and Burke (1998) investigated the effect of phonological priming on target retrieval after a TOT had occurred. This experiment is relevant to a common TOT phenomenon: Naturally occurring TOTs are resolved by the target word popping into mind at a time when the person is no longer trying to retrieve the target and has directed their attention elsewhere. What causes these spontaneous word retrievals? This experiment tested the possibility that these "popups" arise when critical phonological components occur during everyday speech, inadvertently boosting phonological priming and enabling the word to pop into mind. For older adults the interval between the onset of a spontaneous TOT and a "pop up" is longer than for young adults (Burke et al., 1991). One interpretation of this is that older adults require more phonological priming and thus longer intervals for more stimulation to occur before a pop up is triggered. In this case, older adults may show smaller effects of phonological priming on retrieval than young adults in this experiment James and Burke (1998) induced TOT states in 18 young and 18 older adults using general knowledge questions as in the first experiment. When the response to a question was TOT or Don't Know, 10 words were presented as in Figure 6: Participants performed the same pronunciation and rating task as in Experiment 1 on 10 words phonologically unrelated to the TOT target or 5 phonologically related and 5 unrelated words. The same question was repeated immediately after presentation of the 10 words. Figure 7 shows the percent of correct responses to repeated questions that on their first presentation elicited a TOT responses. The Primed condition increased correct answers to the repeated question for both young and older adults and there was no age interaction, as can be seen in Figure 7. These results support the hypothesis that TOTs are caused by weak phonological connections that are strengthened by production of the relevant phonology. The only overlap between target and prime words was at the phonological level so lexical level effects can be ruled out. There is no evidence that older adults require more phonological production for resolution than young adults.
16
Figure 7. Percent correct responses to general knowledge questions repeated after an initial TOT response and a prior processing task with phonologically related (Primed condition) or unrelated words (Not Primed condition). What is the solution to the puzzle of why TOT targets come “spontaneously” to mind in everyday life when a person is no longer actively trying to retrieve the target? The results suggest the possibility that phonologically similar words occurring inadvertently in the environment activate phonological components of the target that had been unavailable because of transmission deficits. Activation of these components erases transmission deficits allowing the phonology for the TOT word to be activated, although somewhat belatedly. Why do such “pop ups” take longer in older than young adults (Burke et al., 1991)? In this laboratory study, language input and output during the TOT was held constant, and recovery of the target word occurred as rapidly for old as for young adults. Thus one possibility is that in everyday life there is less language input and output for older than young adults, providing more limited phonological stimulation. Moreover, there is some evidence that production, not just perception, of phonology is necessary for priming effects on older adults’ production (Small et al., 1995). Although this was not investigated in the present experiment because all prime words were spoken aloud, it is possible that older adults require speech output, not just input, to strengthen phonological connections involved in transmission deficits. SUMMARY: GENERAL OR SPECIFIC EFFECTS OF AGING ON WORD PRODUCTION
Impaired word production in old age seems to involve deficits in accessing specific types of information, namely, phonology. Our investigation of semantic competitor effects provided no evidence that older adults’ word finding deficits are caused by generalized inhibition deficits that increase interference with retrieval at a lexical level. Our investigation of priming at a phonological level provided evidence that
17
weak phonological connections caused word finding deficits and that activation of relevant phonology increased correct production of the target word. The pattern of findings in word production is most consistent with an information-specific theory because the age-related decline seems to be confined to one level of the language system, namely, production of phonology. Interestingly, age differences in picture naming increased for names with lower frequency or more syllables (Goulet et al., 1994), variables that affect the difficulty of accessing the phonological representation of the word (Griffin & Bock, 1998; Jescheniak & Levelt, 1994). This age effect, however, has been tested only with French speakers and additional research in English is needed. The Transmission Deficit model predicts age deficits in phonological retrieval, but not in semantic retrieval, because top-down connections for producing phonology are always one-to-one and this diverging characteristic of top-down connections increases their vulnerability to transmission deficits. Is the age-related word production deficit more general than naming and wordfinding? Recently, MacKay and Abrams (1998; MacKay, Abrams & Pedroza, in press) reported an important new age-related word production deficit that is predicted by Transmission Deficit model, but is so unexpected that it had been untested in experimental studies and self-report questionnaires alike: Older adults made more spelling errors than young adults in written production, an orthographic retrieval deficit. This age decline occurred despite age equivalence in the ability to detect spelling errors and despite the higher vocabulary and education levels of older compared to young adults. Older adults were more likely than young adults to misspell irregularly spelled letter combinations by regularizing them, e.g., calendar = > calender, and only the oldest group ( M = 77 years) misspelled regularly spelled combinations more than the young, e.g., calendar = > kalendar. Under the Transmission Deficit hypothesis, declines in producing phonology and orthography in old age are caused by the same mechanism, namely weak connections in the representational systems for phonology and orthography. Because both systems consist of many one-to-one connections, especially for irregularly spelled words, they are more vulnerable to age-related transmission deficits which disrupt retrieval (see MacKay & Abrams, 1998). Under the Transmission Deficit theory, word production deficits are information-specific and we would not expect older adults’ transmission deficits to affect language production at a higher level such as the production of semantically coherent discourse. In contrast, information-general theories such as the Inhibition Deficit theory predict impairments in older adults speech at the discourse level, not just the word level, because impaired inhibition affects information at all levels. Next we examine studies of aging and discourse to evaluate the adequacy of information-specific and information-general accounts. DISCOURSE PRODUCTION
Arbuckle, Gold and colleagues have demonstrated that older adults’ speech during interviews is more likely to lack focus and to stray off-topic (e.g., Arbuckle & Gold, 1993; Gold, Andres, Arbuckle, & Schwartzman, 1988). The explanation offered by
18
the Inhibition Deficit model is that older adults' reduced ability to inhibit irrelevant information makes it difficult or impossible for them to suppress thoughts that digress from the current speech topic, resulting in production of extraneous personal observations and unrelated information in their speech (Arbuckle & Gold, 1993; Zacks & Hasher, 1994). Indeed, off-topic speech in older adults has been attributed to inhibitory deficits caused by impaired frontal lobe function (Arbuckle & Gold, 1993; West, 1996; Zacks & Hasher, 1994). The view that off-topic speech is caused by a general deficit, namely, in inhibition, is inconsistent with findings that age-related increases in off-topic speech are not universal: Age differences are absent for some topics such as descriptions of a picture or a vacation (Cooper, 1990; Gould & Dixon, 1993). Moreover, if off-
Figure 8. Mean ratings on interest, informativeness, and story quality of descriptions about autobiographical topics of young and older speakers (a) and of older speakers in the high off-topic speech and low off-topic speech groups (b).
19
topic speech is the product of an impairment, it is surprising that people rate older adults’ narratives more highly than young adults’ (e.g., Kemper, Rash, Kynette, & Norman, 1990). James, Burke, Austin, & Hulme (1997) proposed that older adults’ off-topic speech results from age-related changes in pragmatic aspects of language, rather than from cognitive deficits. Older adults set different communicative goals than young adults under some conditions because they place greater value on personal narrative, reminiscence and establishing their identity in discourse (e.g., Coupland & Coupland, 1995). James et al. tested this account and the inhibition deficit explanation by examining age differences in off-topic speech for different discourse topics, and by examining ratings of the communicative quality of the discourse. In the first study, 20 young and 20 older adults described their education, their family, a vacation and three pictures. Analysis of verbatim transcriptions of their responses showed that older adults produced significantly more words and more off-topic speech than young adults, but only when describing the autobiographical topics, not the pictures. For the autobiographical topics, the percentage of words that were offtopic was 2.6% and 12.9% for young and older adults, respectively, almost a five fold difference. In a second study, 10 young and 10 older adults read the transcripts of the young and older adults’ autobiographical descriptions and rated them on several qualitative dimensions. As can be seen in Figure Sa, they rated older adults’ descriptions as more interesting and informative, and better stories than those of young adults. Both young and old raters showed this preference for older adults’ descriptions. Older adults were divided into a low off-topic speech group and a high off-topic speech group on the basis of their percentage of off-topic words for personal topics. As can be seen in Figure 8b, descriptions from older adults with high off-topic speech were rated higher on interest and story quality compared to those of older adults with low off-topic speech. These findings point to the limitations of decremental approaches to cognitive aging. The view that off-topic speech is a consequence of a general impairment, e.g., inhibition deficits, precludes the possibility of enhanced communicative value of off-topic speech. Qualitative evaluation of the speech, however, showed just that: more positive ratings for older than young adults’ descriptions and for descriptions of more verbose than less verbose older adults. Age-related increases in off-topic speech were found only for autobiographical topics suggesting that off-topic speech is a feature of a speech style selected under certain conditions to accomplish specific communicative goals. James et al. (1997) suggest a change in pragmatic aspects of language in old age whereby older adults intend to communicate a meaningful description of past life events, rather than a concise description of facts. This goal increases off-topic speech, but also yields a good story and enhances communicative quality. If off-topic speech were a consequence of an impaired ability to inhibit irrelevant information rather than a change in pragmatic goals, then older adult’s communication on other types of discourse should be disrupted by irrelevant information and inappropriate references. Several studies have investigated communication efficiency by comparing young and older adults on referential
20
communication tasks. These tasks require two people to place objects or drawing in the same locations or order, communicating only via verbal descriptions without being able to see each others array. In same or mixed age dyads, there was no age effect on the total time required or the number of questions required to achieve the same locations of objects on a checkerboard (Siegel & Gregora, 1985). Using same age dyads, Hupet, Chantraine and Nef (1993) reported that older adults used more words and more turns to achieve identical sequential orders for ambiguous figures. Older adults also made relatively more requests for repetition (e.g., “What?” “Huh?”) suggesting that their communication may have been impeded by hearing impairment. Kemper and her colleagues asked same and mixed age dyads to reproduce a route, visible only to the speaker, on a map or dot pattern. Both young and old listeners produced more errors in the route when older adults were speakers, but older speakers did not use more words than the young. The communication difficulty with older speakers may reflect inadequate conceptualization of the routes, rather than problems in producing the language, because older listeners expressed confusion more frequently than young listeners, regardless of speaker age (Kemper, Vandeputte, Rice, Cheung, & Gubarchuk, 1995; see also Kemper et al., 1996). Only one study has attempted to link accuracy on a referential communication task with off-topic speech. Older adults’ off-topic speech in conversation was correlated with time to complete a task similar to that of Hupet et al. (1993), but not with accuracy of performance on the task (Arbuckle, Pushkar, Nohara-LeClair, Basevitz, & Peled, 1998). Thus there is no evidence linking off-topic speech to impaired communication. Some studies do show poorer performance on a referential communication task with older rather than young speakers, but the evidence suggests that older adults suffer perceptual and conceptual deficits, rather than deficits in excluding irrelevant information. In more unstructured conversations, for example, a “get acquainted conversation,” older adults display as much social skill as young adults. There were no age differences in indices of the speaker’s responsiveness to a conversational partner, such as use of “you”, continuation of a topic raised by the partner, or asking the partner a question (Vandeputte, Kemper, Hummert, Kemtes, Shaner, & Segrin, in press). Interestingly, age of partner had a strong effect on these indices with both young and older adults producing less responsive speech with older partners. CONCLUSIONS
We have reviewed evidence that deficits in language production in old age are caused by changes in retrieval of certain types of information. The decline in word production occurs in situations where age-related deficits in working memory (Kemper, 1992) or new learning (MacKay & Burke, 1990) seem to have little influence, for example, naming a picture or producing a familiar name or spelling a well known word. Older adults’ deficits in word production have been localized to impairments in retrieval of phonology and orthography, and not to impairments in semantic retrieval. The pattern of results is compatible with an information-specific theory that postulates age-linked deficits in the transmission of priming. This impairs some aspects of language and not others, depending on the architecture and
21
processing components of the system. Language production at the level of discourse also shows changes in old age, namely, increased off-topic speech. These changes appear to be topic-dependent and are associated with increased communicative value. They can be explained by age-related shifts in pragmatic aspects of language, e.g., communicative goals, rather than a cognitive deficit. This asymmetric language change in old age presents a fundamental challenge for cognitive psychology. We must explain why some aspects of language are more vulnerabIe to aging than others. Information-universal theories predict general decrements which affect language across the board, contrary to observed performance (see Burke, 1997). Information-specific theories, however, are more compatible with the highly specific nature of language change in old age, and with positive change in old age. Accounting for positive change in language is as essential for the development of cognitive aging theory as accounting for decrements.
22
REFERENCES
Arbuckle, T.Y., & Gold, D.P. (1993). Aging, inhibition, and verbosity. Journal of Gerontology: Psychological Sciences, 48, P225-P232. Arbuckle, T.Y., Pushkar, D., Nohara-LeClair, M., Basevitz, P., &Peled, M. (1998, April). Variation in off-topic verbosity in relation to conversational context. Paper presented at the Cognitive Aging Conference. Bock, K. (1996). Language production: Methods and methodologies. Psychological Bulletin & Review, 3, 395-421. Brown, A.S., & Nix, L.A. (1996). Age-related changes in the tip-of-the-tongue experience. American Journal of Psychology, 109,79-91. Burke, D.M. (1997). Language, aging and inhibitory deficits: Evaluation of a theory. Journal of Gerontology: Psychological Sciences, 52B, P254-P264. Burke, D.M., & Austin, A. (1999). When are there age differences in producing proper names? Family names versus famous names. Manuscript in preparation. Burke, D.M., & Harrold, R. M. (1988). Automatic and effortful semantic processes in old age: Experimental and naturalistic approaches. In L. L. Light, & D. M. Burke, (Eds.), Language, memory and aging. (pp.100-116). New York: Cambridge University Press. Burke, D.M., & MacKay, D.G. (1997). Memory, language and ageing. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society: Biological Sciences, 352, 1845-1856. Burke, D.M., & Peters, L. (1986). Word associations in old age: Evidence for consistency in semantic encoding during adulthood. Psychology and Aging, 4, 283-292. Burke, D.M., MacKay, D.G., Worthley, J.S., & Wade, E. (1991). On the tip of the tongue: What causes word finding failures in young and older adults. Journal of Memory and Language, 30, 542-579. Cohen, G. (1994). Age-related problems in the use of proper names in communication. In M. L. Hummert, J. M. Wiemann, & J. N. Nussbaum (Eds.), Interpersonal communication in older adulthood, (pp. 40-57). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications. Cohen, G., & Faulkner, D. (1986). Memory for proper names: Age differences in retrieval. British Journal of Developmental Psychology, 4, 187-197. Cooper, P.V. (1990). Discourse production and normal aging: Performance on oral picture description tasks. Journal of Gerontology: Psychological Sciences, 45, P210-214. Coupland, N., & Coupland, J. (1995). Discourse, identity and aging. In J.F. Nussbaum & J. Coupland (Eds.), Handbook of communication and aging research (pp. 79-103). Mahway, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Dell, G.S. (1986). A spreading-activation theory of retrieval in sentence production. Psychological Review, 93, 283-321.
23
Dell, G.S., Burger, L.K., & Svec, W.R. (1997). Language production and serial order: A functional analysis and a model. Psychological Review, 104, 123-147. Fleischman, D.A., & Gabrieli, J.D.E. (1998). Repetition priming in normal aging and Alzheimer's disease: A review of findings and theories. Psychology and Aging, 13, 88-1 19. Giles, H., Coupland, N., & Wiemann, J. (1992). "Talk is cheap..." but "My word is my bond": beliefs about talk. In K. Bolton & H. Kwok (Eds.), Sociolinguistics today: International perspectives (pp. 2 18-243). London: Routledge. Glosser, G., & Deser, T. (1992). A comparison of changes in macrolinguistic and microlinguistic aspects of discourse production in normal aging. Journal of Gerontology: Psychological Sciences, 47, P266-P272. Gold, D., Andres, D., Arbuckle, T., & Schwartzman, A. (1988). Measurements and correlates of verbosity in elderly people. Journal of Gerontology: Psychological Sciences, 43, P27-P33. Gould, O.N., & Dixon, R.A. (1993). How we spent our vacation: Collaborative storytelling by young and older adults. Psychology and Aging, 8, 10-17. Goulet, P., Ska, B., & Kahn, H. J. (1994). Is there a decline in picture naming with advancing age? Journal of Speech and Hearing Research, 37,629-644. Griffin, Z. M., & Bock, K. (1998). Constraint, word frequency, and the relationship between lexical processing levels in spoken word production. Journal of Memory and Learning, 38, 313-338. Harley, T.A. (1993). Phonological activation of semantic competitors during lexical access in speech production. Language and Cognitive Processes, 8,291-309. Harley, T.A., & Brown, H.E. (1998). What causes a tip-of-the-tongue state? Evidence for lexical neighbourhood effects in speech production. British Journal of Psychology, 89, 151-174. Hasher, L., & Zacks, R.T. (1988). Working memory, comprehension, and aging: A review and a new view. In G.H. Bower (Ed.), The psychology of learning and motivation Vol. 22 (pp. 193-225). San Diego, CA: Academic Press. Heller, R.B., & Dobbs, A.R. (1993). Age differences in word finding in discourse and nondiscourse situations. Psychology and Aging, 8, 443-450. Howard, D.V. (1979). Restricted word association norms for adults between the ages of 20 and 80. JSAS Catalog of Selected Documents in Psychology, 10, (Ms. No.1991). Hummert, M.L. (1994). Stereotypes of the elderly and patronizing speech. In M.L. Hummert, J.M. Wiemann, & J.F. Nussbaum (Eds.), Interpersonal communication in older adulthood. (pp. 162-184). London: Sage Publications. Hupet, M., Chantraine, Y., Nef, F. (1993). References in conversation between young and old normal adults. Psychology and Aging, 8, 339-346. James, W. (1890). Principles of Psychology (Vol. 1). New York: Henry Holt and Company. James, L.E., & Burke, D.M. (1998). Phonological priming effects on word retrieval and tip of the tongue experiences in young and older adults. Manuscript submitted for publication.
24
James, L.E., Burke, D.M., Austin, A., & Hulme, E, (1998). Production and perception of verbosity in young and older adults. Psychology and Aging, 13, 355-367. Jescheniak, J.D., & Levelt, W.J.M. (1994). Word frequency effects in speech production: Retrieval of syntactic information and of phonological form. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 20, 824-843. Jones, G.V. (1989). Back to Woodworth: Role of interlopers in the tip of the tongue phenomenon. Memory & Cognition, 17,69-76. Kemper, S. (1992a). Adults' sentence fragments: Who, what, when, where, and why. Communication Research, 19,444-458. Kemper, S. (1992b). Language and aging. In F.I.M. Craik & T.A. Salthouse (Eds.), The handbook of aging and cognition (pp. 213-270). Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Kemper, S., Rash, S., Kynette, D., & Norman, S. (1990). Telling stories: The structure of adults' narratives. European Journal of Cognitive Psychology, 2, 205-228. Kemper, S., Othick, M., Warren, J., Gubarchuk, J., & Gerhing, H. (1996). Facilitating older adults' performance on a referential communication task through speech accommodations. Aging, Neuropsychology and Cognition, 3, 37-55. Kemper, S., Vandeputte, D., Rice, K., Cheung, H., & Gubarchuk, J. (1995). Speech adjustments to aging during a referential communication task. Journal of Language and Social Psychology, 14,40-59. Kroll, J.F.,& Curley, J. (1988). Lexical memory in novice bilinguals: The role of concepts in retrieving second language words. In M.M. Gruneberg, P.E. Morris, & R.N. Sykes (Eds.), Practical aspects of memory: Current research and issues, Vol. 2 (pp. 389-395). New York: John Wiley & Sons. Laver, G.D., & Burke, D.M. (1993). Why do semantic priming effects increase in old age? A meta-analysis. Psychology and Aging, 8,34-43. Levelt, W.J.M. (1989). Speaking: From intention to articulation. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press. Levelt, W.J.M., Schriefers, H., Vorberg, D., Meyer, AS., Pechmann, T., & Havinga, J. (1991). The time course of lexical access in speech production: A study of picture naming. Psychological Review, 98, 122-142. Light, L.L., & Albertson, S.A. (1989). Direct and indirect tests of memory for category exemplars in young and older adults. Psychology and Aging, 4, 487492. Light, L.L. (1991). Memory and aging: Four hypotheses in search of data. In M.R. Rosenzweig & L.W. Porter (Eds.), Annual Review of Psychology. (pp. 333376). Palo Alto: Annual Reviews. Light, L.L., & Anderson, P.A. (1983). Memory for scripts in young and older adults. Memory and Cognition, 11,435-444. Light, L.L., Valencia-Laver, D., & Zavis, D. (1991). Instantiation of general terms in young and older adults. Psychology and Aging, 6, 337-351.
25
Lovelace, E.A., & Cooley, S. (1982). Free associations of older adults to single words and conceptually related word triads. Journal of Gerontology, 37, 432437. Lovelace, E.A., & Cooley, S. 1982 Free associations of older adults to single words and conceptually related word triads. Journal of Gerontology, 37, 432-437. Loveless, M., & Burke, D.M. (1999). Aging and the effects of primed semantic competitors on picture naming. Manuscript in preparation. Lupker, S.J. (1988). Picture naming: An investigation of the nature of categorical priming. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 14, 444-455. MacKay, D.G. (1982). The problems of flexibility, fluency, and speed-accuracy trade-off in skilled behavior. Psychological Review, 89, 483-506. MacKay, D.G. (1987). The organization of perception and action: A theory for language and other cognitive skills. New York: Springer-Verlag. MacKay, D.G., & Abrams, L. (1996). Language, memory and aging: Distributed deficits and the structure of new versus old connections. In J.E. Birren & W.K. Schaie (Eds.), Handbook of the psychology of aging, 4th ed. (pp. 251-265). San Diego: Academic Press. MacKay, D.G., & Abrams, L. (1998). Age-linked declines in retrieving orthographic knowledge: Empirical, practical and theoretical implications. Psychology and Aging, 13, 647-662. MacKay, D.G., Abrams, L., & Pedroza, M.J. (in press). Aging on the input versus output side: Theoretical implications of age-linked asymmetries between detecting versus retrieving orthographic knowledge. Psychology and Aging. MacKay, D.G., & Burke, D.M. (1990). Cognition and aging: New learning and the use of old connections. In T.M. Hess (Ed.), Aging and cognition: Knowledge organization and utilization (pp. 21 3-263). Amsterdam: North Holland. Maki, P.M., & Knopman, D.S. (1996). Limitations of the distinction between conceptual and perceptual implicit memory: A study of Alzheimer's disease. Neuropsychology, 10, 464-474. Maylor, E.A. (1990a). Age, blocking and the tip of the tongue state. British Journal of Psychology, 81, 123-134 Maylor, E.A. (1990b). Recognizing and naming faces: Aging, memory retrieval and the tip of the tongue state. Journal of Gerontology: Psychological Sciences, 45, P215-P225. McClelland, J.L., & Rumelhart, D.E. (1981). An interactive model of context effects in letter perception: Part 1. An account of basic findings. Psychological Review, 88,375-407. Pratt, M.W., Boyes, C., Robins, S., & Manchester, J. (1989). Telling tales: Aging, working memory, and the narrative cohesion of story retellings. Developmental Psychology, 25,628-635. Rabbitt, P., Maylor, E., McInnes, L., Bent, N., & Moore, B. (1995). What goods can self-assessment questionnaires deliver for cognitive gerontology? Applied Cognitive Psychology, 9, S127-S152.
26
Rastle, K.G., & Burke, D.M. (1996). Priming the tip of the tongue: Effects of prior processing on word retrieval in young and older adults. Journal of Memory and Language, 35, 586-605. Reason, J.T., & Lucas, D. (1984). Using cognitive diaries to investigate naturally occurring memory blocks. In J. E. Harris & P. E. Morris (Eds.), Everyday memory actions and absent-mindedness (pp. 53-70). London: Academic Press. Ryan, E.B. & Laurie, S. (1990). Evaluations of older and younger adult speakers: Influence of communication effectiveness and noise. Psychology and Aging, 5, 514-519. Ryan, E.B., See, S.K., Meneer, W.B., & Trovato, D. (1994). Age-based perceptions of conversational skills among younger and older adults. In M.L. Hummert, J.M. Wiemann, & J.N. Nussbaum (Eds.), Interpersonal communication in older adulthood (pp. 15-39). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications. Salthouse, T.A. (1982). Adult cognition: An experimental psychology of human aging. New York: Springer-Verlag. Salthouse, T.A. (1988). Effects of aging on verbal abilities: Examination of the psychometric literature. In L.L. Light & D.M. Burke (Eds.), Language, memory and aging (pp. 17-35). New York: Cambridge University Press. Siegel, G.M. & Gregora, A.W. (1985). Communication skills of elderly adults. Journal of Communication Disorders, 18,485-494. Small, B.J., Hultsch, D.F., & Masson, M.E.J. (1995). Adult age differences in perceptually based, but not conceptually based implicit tests of memory. Journal of Gerontology: Psychological Sciences, 50B, P162-P170. Stemberger, J.P. (1985). An interactive model of language production. In A. W. Ellis (Ed.), Progress in the psychology of language: Vol.1 (pp. 143-186). London: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Stine, E.A.L., & Wingfield, A. (1994). Older adults can inhibit high-probability competitors in speech recognition. Aging and Cognition, 1, 152-157. Sunderland, A., Watts, K., Baddeley, A.D., & Harris, J.E. (1986). Subjective memory assessment and test performance in the elderly. Journal of Gerontology, 41, 376-384. Tun, P.A., & Wingfield, A. (1993). Is speech special? Perception and recall of spoken language in complex environments. In J. Cerella, W. Hoyer, J. Rybash, & M.L. Commons (Eds.) Adult information processing: Limits on loss (pp.425-457). San Diego: Academic Press. Ulatowska, H.K., Hayashi, M.M., Cannito, M.P., & Fleming, S.G. (1986). Disruption of reference in aging. Brain and Language, 28, 24-41. Vandeputte, D.D., Kemper, S., Hummert, M.L., Kemtes, K.A., Shanner, J. & Segrin, C. (in press). Social skills of older people: Conversations in same and mixed age dyads. Discourse Processes. Vitkovitch, M. & Humphreys, G. W. (1991). Perseverant responding in speeded naming of pictures: It's in the links. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 17, 664-680. Vitkovitch, M., Humphreys, G. W., & Lloyd-Jones, T. J. (1993). On naming a giraffe a zebra: Picture naming errors across different object categories.
27
Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 19, 243-259. West, R.L. (1996). An application of prefrontal cortex function theory to cognitive aging. Psychological Bulletin, 120, 272-292. Wheeldon, L. R., & Monsell, S. (1994). Inhibition of spoken word production by priming a semantic competitor. Journal of Memory and Language, 33, 332356. Woodworth, R.S. (1938). Experimental Psychology. New York: Henry Holt & Company. Zacks, R.T., & Hasher, L. (1994). Directed ignoring: Inhibitory regulation of working memory. In D. Dagenbach & T.H. Carr (Eds.), Inhibitory processes in attention, memory, and language (pp. 241-264). San Diego, CA: Academic Press.
28
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
This research was supported in part by grant AG08835 from the National Institute on Aging. The author gratefully acknowledges the assistance of Jennifer Taylor, Ayda Austin and Peggy Christidis in the preparation of this article.
2
WORKING MEMORY AND SPOKEN LANGUAGE COMPREHENSION: THE CASE FOR AGE STABILITY IN CONCEPTUAL SHORT-TERM MEMORY Arthur Wingfield and Patricia A. Tun
Although the languages of the earth show an explosive variety in form and rules, the presence of a structured language system appears in all societies of the world. Indeed, where oral communication is not possible, sign languages have developed, also with a rich structure of lexicon and syntax, but with space and order of manual movements used to express objects, actions and their syntactic relations (Meier, 1991). As our understanding of the brain structures that carry language function has developed over the years, so too has our appreciation of the unique place language holds in human cognition (Goodglass & Wingfield, 1998). Language function may be among the most highly developed of human skills, but there are constraints on language performance dictated by factors such as the speed with which perceptual and cognitive operations can proceed, and the limitations of a finite memory system on how much we can take in and hold at any one time in the course of language comprehension. The ways in which these memory limits have been characterized have changed over the years. The assumption that memory limits constrain language processing, however, has not. EVOLUTION OF VERBAL SHORT-TERM MEMORY AND LIMITED RESOURCE MODELS
The concept of a limited-capacity input memory buffer was discussed in the literature in the 1800s, but we owe our modern understanding of short-term memory (STM) to a number of milestone studies. These include Peterson and Peterson (1959) who defined the duration of STM as 18 seconds without rehearsal, Waugh and Norman (1965) who emphasized the need for a rehearsal loop to keep a trace alive in STM and to transfer it into long-term memory (LTM), and Conrad (1963), who characterized the STM rehearsal loop as articulatory in nature. This was based on his observation that short-term recall errors for visually presented letters show acoustic/articulatory confusions (Q being recalled as U), rather than visual confusions (Q being recalled as O). Miller (1956) declared the capacity of STM as 29
30
7 +/-2 "chunks" of information. This picture of a sequential information flow from STM to LTM, along with several control processes, has sometimes been called the "modal model" of short-term memory (Atkinson & Shiffrin, 1968). If by the 1960s the presumption of a limited capacity short-term buffer memory for holding verbal materials was experimentally established, by the 1970s the literature suggested a role for STM in language comprehension. Gernsbacher (1985) summarizes this early history as a belief that the surface form of an utterance is held in STM "until a meaningful unit has been comprehended; then it is lost" (pg. 342). This meaningful unit was generally presumed to be the linguistic clause (Fodor, Bever, & Garrett, 1974). While some theorists focused on the limited-capacity limited-duration STM store, others stressed that there are also limits on attentional resources. This limitation was exemplified by the difficulty one has in handling more than one task or mental activity at a time. The best known of these limited-resource models was that of Kahneman (1973), who described processing limitations in terms of a central pool of attentional resources that must be allocated among the multiple mental activities needed in the execution of complex cognitive operations. As more effort is expended on one task or processing operation, so fewer resources will be available for other tasks or operations. This general capacity model largely replaced Broadbent's (197 1) earlier notion of time-sharing for access to a single processing channel. Although in somewhat different ways, both models included an important caveat. Some operations might require access to this central processing capacity (Kahneman, 1973), or single channel (Broadbent, 1971), but the drain on resources needed might be so minimal as not to create interference with a concurrent task, which has been held as the traditional evidence that two operations are competing for the same resource pool. Kahneman also added the second caveat that increasing task demands may increase one's level of physiological arousal, with a resulting increase in total resources. That is, resources are limited, but not necessarily fixed (Kahneman, 1973). From almost the first appearance of limited resource models there was controversy over whether different cognitive operations or processing domains compete for a single undifferentiated pool of resources (Kahneman, 1973), or whether some draw on different resource systems (Allport, Antonis, & Reynolds, 1972; Wickens, 1984). Dual-task effects, it was argued, could arise from the effort involved in keeping response streams separate, from response interference, or from other forms of overhead costs. For this reason, evidence for shared resources must not simply rest on reduced performance on one task while concurrently performing a second task. Rather, one would also need to see an incremental drop in performance on one task as one incrementally increased the difficulty of the other task (Kerr, 1973). Interestingly, although reports of dual-task interference are common in the literature, appearance of this full interaction necessary to support a single resource argument is exceedingly rare (see the review by Tun & Wingfield, 1993). Once one admits that the simple presence of dual-task interference does not prove single-resource theory, any more than the absence of behavioral effects in dual task studies disproves it, we can see that a belief in single resource or multiple
31
resource models rested less on hard data than on a given theorist's idea of parsimony and intuition. WHATEVER HAPPENED TO SHORT-TERM MEMORY?
Shiffrin (1993), one of the champions of the early modal model, reported having being asked by a colleague what had happened to short-term memory. In his colleague's words: "Didn't people used to study that?" Shiffrin's answer was that STM became incorporated into broader models, "to become virtually synonymous with cognition in general" (pg. 93). The best known of these broader models is the notion of working memory; a cognitive system that contains a limited computational space in which materials can be temporarily stored, monitored and manipulated (Baddeley, 1986; Just & Carpenter, 1992). In Baddeley's (1986) formulation, working memory has two "slave" systems (a phonological store and a visual-spatial store) and a limited capacity "central executive" that allocates resources to the operations performed by or within the working memory system (Baddeley, 1986). Just and Carpenter (1992) refer to a verbal working memory, with the presumption that all comprehension operations compete for this single computational space, while leaving open the possibility that other processing domains may tap other resources. In one form or another, however, the concept of working memory has come to dominate most contemporary discussions of constraints on language processing and short-term recall. WORKING MEMORY, AGE, AND LANGUAGE PROCESSING
This dominant position holds that working memory is needed to carry, and hence constrains, language comprehension. The most common conception of working memory is seen in terms of a limited capacity central executive that "schedules" and controls processing operations, and temporary storage buffers that hold incoming information for processing and that store the products of this processing for use and/or integration with previous or yet to be received information (Baddeley, 1986). The verbal buffer store, consisting of a phonological store and a subvocal rehearsal process to preserve the representation in the phonological store, has been wellstudied, although its relevance to actual language comprehension has been called into question (Baddeley, Gathercole, & Papagno, 1998). The belief that working memory resources constrain language processing has been kept alive by numerous reports of significant correlations between individuals' working memory spans and their performance on a variety of language tasks (Carpenter, Miyaki, & Just, 1994; Daneman & Merikle, 1996). The relevance of this argument to adult aging relates to the observation of systematic declines in older adults on verbal working memory tests such as the Daneman and Carpenter (1980) span test and other tests that require concurrent maintenance and processing of verbal materials (Wingfield, Stine, Lahar & Aberdeen, 1988). In the Daneman and Carpenter span test, subjects are asked to read or listen to a set of sentences and then to report back to the examiner the last
32
word of each of the sentences. Span is taken as the largest set-size of sentences for which the final words can be correctly recalled. Figure 1 shows data taken from Wingfield et al. (1988) in which the same groups of subjects were tested for simple digit span, simple word span, and working memory span using an auditory version of the Daneman and Carpenter (1980) span test. In the latter case, a true-false judgment was required after each sentence to insure that subjects were attending to the meanings of the sentences as well as attempting to remember their final words. All of the stimuli were presented over earphones at intensity levels set at a comfortable listening level for each of the subjects. The original study by Wingfield et al. contrasted young versus elderly adults. Figure 1 shows results on the three span tests for young adults (mean age = 19 years), and for the older subjects separated into two groups: a young-old group (mean age = 65) and an older-old group (mean age = 75). We can see a significant age difference for word span, but not for digit span, and a differentially larger age susceptibility to the added load of the working memory span test. We can also see
Figure 1.
Number of items recalled from lists of spoken digits, lists of words, and the final words of sets of sentences presented for comprehension (loaded span). (Data from Wingfield, Stine, Lahar & Aberdeen, 1988.)
33
that these differences are exaggerated for the older-old group relative to the youngold group. By contrast to declines in working memory capacity, knowledge of language structure and its procedural use remain stable in normal aging (Kemper, 1992; Light, 1990). Because of this general pattern of loss and sparing, when age differences have appeared in the comprehension of sentences with complex syntactic structures (e.g., left-branching sentences, sentences with embedded clauses, or sentences with a temporary closure ambiguity) it has been presumed that the age differences are not due to the loss of linguistic knowledge, but to an age-related reduction in working memory capacity (Kemper, 1992; Kemtes & Kemper, 1997). However intuitively appealing the working memory and language comprehension relationship, correlations between working memory span scores and performance differences in language comprehension are not always found, and when they are, they are often modest in size (Waters & Caplan, 1996). The inconsistent correlations between working memory spans and performance on language comprehension tasks have led to arguments that echo the earlier debates about single versus multiple resources in general models of attention. Caplan and Waters (in press) argue against the view that sentence comprehension is carried by the same working memory system that is measured by conventional span tests, such as the Daneman and Carpenter (1980) test. When such correlations appear, or when sentence comprehension appears to be affected by concurrent tasks such as having to remember a digit pre-load, it is argued that these are effects on post-interpretive processes that follow initial sentence comprehension. Caplan and Waters argue that sentence comprehension is carried by a separate syntax or sentence-specific resource. This general position has been supported by evidence from neurological populations who show reduced capacities of short-term verbal memory or executive function as measured by conventional span tests, but who nevertheless show good sentence comprehension, even for sentences with quite complex syntactic constructions (Caplan & Waters, in press; Martin & Romani, 1994). Similarly, the literature holds numerous cases of failures to find reliable correlations between working memory span scores and tests of speech comprehension and recall in young and elderly adults (Wingfield, Waters, & Tun, 1998). WHY
THE PROBLEM IS A DIFFICULT ONE
There are at least three reasons why correlations between working momory measures and comprehesion performance might be expected to be weak. (a) One reason is the lack of specificity with which working memory and its proposed components have been defined. This is especially true of central resources, which have been described with a variety of fanciful metaphors. These have ranged from early references to "psychic energy" (Titchener, 1908), to the engineering metaphor of a limited channel capacity (Broadbent, 1971), the abstraction of a limited capacity "resource pool" (Kahneman, 1973), or the homunculus-driven concept of
34
a limited capacity "central executive" (Baddeley, 1986). That is, it is easier to say that humans have difficulty doing more than one thing at a time than to come up with a less than whimsical metaphor to explain why this is so. (b) To the extent that working memory may be a viable construct, the modest and sometimes absent correlations between working memory span scores and performance on language tasks could be due to poor measurement techniques for estimating working memory. The inconsistency with which these correlations appear could suggest, for example, that current span measures may be capturing some elements of a putative working memory function, but with a clearer picture being fogged by flexible performance strategies (Waters & Caplan, 1996). It has also been argued that the standard testing procedure of presenting progressively larger sentence set-sizes can cause a buildup of proactive interference (PI). Age differences on these span tests might thus be caused or inflated by older adults' greater susceptibility to PI than young adults (Zacks, Hasher, & Li, to appear). (c) Finally, correlations between span scores and language performance might be affected by factors such as linguistic knowledge and verbal fluency that could moderate what might otherwise be clearer effects of limitations in raw computing power. In the current literature, these problems are only exacerbated by investigators using such terms as "working memory," "attentional resources," and "memory stores" as if they had commonly accepted meanings. For some, the term working memory has been used simply as a placeholder term for the empirically observed processing bottlenecks encountered in many language tasks. Baddeley argues for the functional utility of the working memory notion although recognizing that the early formulations of memory stores and a central executive are bound to undergo further fractionation into subcomponents as theory develops (Baddeley, 1998). COMPREHENDING SPOKEN LANGUAGE: A COMPONENTIAL ANALYSIS
An essential part of the working memory debate relates to the temporary memory representations that must be involved in sentence comprehension as well as whether any or all of them may be constrained by a single set of resource limitations. We can see this by looking closely at the operations that must be involved in comprehending spoken language. We represent these operations in the form of a flow diagram in Figure 2 to help guide our discussion. Although there is wide moment-to-moment variability, speech rates in ordinary conversation typically average between 140 and 180 words per minute (wpm). This requires that perceptual encoding of the input, identification of its lexical elements and their syntactic relations, and comprehending the speech at the discourse level, must all be carried out with the speech arriving at an average rate of 2 to 3 new
35
words each second. In speech, the sounds travel past the ear at 1,100 feet per second, such that one cannot take a "second look" as one can in reading (Huggins, 1975). Those operations that cannot be conducted instantaneously, as the speech is being heard, must be conducted on some form of memory representation of that input. Speech is thus an intrinsically temporal event in which the auditory input is constantly changing over time, and where no single instant of the speech signal carries sufficient information to be fully discriminating. At the level of phoneme identification, we know that how a phoneme is perceived will be affected by its phonemic context. For this context to operate, both the phoneme in question and its syllable surround must be held together within a single perceptual "window" even though the acoustic information itself has long since moved past the ear. Perceptual analysis at this level has been identified with the existence of a "preperceptual" auditory memory image lasting perhaps 100 to 125 ms (Huggins, 1975; Massaro, 1974; see also Mattys, 1997). There must also be a memory-dependent operation at a somewhat higher level. Unlike written text, in which words are separated by spaces, words in spoken discourse run together, frequently leading to areas in the acoustic stream where word boundaries are ambiguous (e.g., "he saw the cargo " versus "he saw the car go ") (Gow & Gordon, 1995). The size of the perceptual "window" necessary for segregation of the speech stream at this lexical level would thus have to be far larger than the auditory image described by Huggins (1975) or Massaro (1974). In turn, neither the duration, capacity, nor nature of the representation of these brief acoustic stores could be identified with the memory store needed to temporarily hold the products of syntactic analyses as part of discourse comprehension (van Dijk & Figure 2. Operations and processes that must be performed for successful comprehension of spoken language. Presumed short-term memory representations are indicated by horizontal arrows.
36
Kintsch, 1983), to use several words of a following context to perceptually identify a previously heard indistinct word (Grosjean, 1985; Wingfield, Alexander, & Cavigelli, 1994), or to hold enough input to allow resolution of temporary syntactic ambiguities (Frazier, 1987; Kemtes & Kemper, 1997). Indeed, just as one might argue that spoken language comprehension involves a hierarchy of processing units (syllables, morphemes, clauses, etc.), one may also propose sets of memory traces with increasing sizes and durations to support the perceptual and linguistic analyses at each level of processing. Our goal in this presentation is less to offer definitive answers than it is to frame the questions that we believe need to be answered. Only in this way can one correct the premature reification of working memory that has typified much of the language and aging literature. Our first step must be to "unpack" working memory. Of special interest to us is the specification of the memory representations that underlie language comprehension. We will argue in support of a conceptual shortterm memory (CSTM) as proposed by Potter and Lombardi (Lombardi & Potter, 1992; Potter, 1993; Potter & Lombardi, 1990), and what we see as its implications for language comprehension in adult aging. Among the difficulties cited earlier in attempting to specify the sources of memory constraints that underlie language performance are the compensations and repairs made possible by other knowledge that will be bound to cloud any one-toone correlation between a "hardware" decline and observed performance. These interactions, however, are an inherent part of language processing. An additional part of our task will thus be to identify some of these sources of compensation and to show how they interact with age-related changes in rapid perceptual processing and recall for what has been heard. CONCEPTUAL SHORT-TERM TEMPORARY STORES
MEMORY
(CSTM)
AND
ITS RELATION
TO
OTHER
If only the surface form of a sentence existed in short-term memory until the syntactic content of the sentence was recognized and encoded, then the immediate recall of a phrase or sentence would not be expected to show semantically based errors. Rather, acoustic confusions or word omissions would be expected to typify these errors. By contrast, since the time of Bartlett (1932) long-term recall has been thought to rest less on reproduction from a veridical memory trace of a stimulus event than on reconstructions from abstract semantic representations, or "schemata". Reconstructive contributions to immediate sentence recall have historically received less attention. Potter and Lombardi have argued that the appearance of accurate verbatim recall of a sentence need not be the consequence of a word-for-word readout from a buffer store containing the verbal sequence representing that sentence. Rather, recall could just as easily result from an immediately-formed conceptual representation of the sentence, with accurate recall resulting from a reconstruction of the original wording (Lombardi & Potter, 1992; Potter, 1993; Potter & Lombardi, 1990). Potter and Lombardi refer to this immediate conceptual trace as a conceptual short-term memory (CSTM).
37
According to Potter and Lombardi, in language comprehension the surface form of a sentence, although used for comprehension, is itself not represented in memory; only a conceptual representation of the sentence is formed and retained. In recall, the response system reconstructs the sentence from the CSTM representation of the core meaning of the sentence augmented by activation of critical entries in the lexical semantic system such as a head noun or main verb. (Activation of just-heard lexical entries can be contrasted with a verbatim phonological store that would have both the lexical items and their order represented.) Guided by the production rules of the language, the likelihood of the listener reinstantiating the original surface form of the sentence would be quite high (Lombardi & Potter, 1992). It can be argued that a verbatim short-term store of ordered sequences, kept alive by articulatory rehearsal can also exist, and surely does given that people can repeat nonsense sounds or words of a novel foreign language. This short-term phonological store could be formed even when a meaningful sentence of one's language is heard. The argument, however, is that this store is not used to carry sentence comprehension. This would explain the previously cited findings that some brain-injured adults who score poorly on tests of phonological memory, such as recall of word and digit lists, can nevertheless show unexpectedly good levels of sentence comprehension. These arguments are consistent with the postulate that as a sentence is being heard multiple memory traces are laid down. These include both an immediate semantic representation of the sentence and a verbatim phonological trace, with both traces being held concurrently. Evidence for a semantic trace appearing some period after one no longer sees evidence of a verbatim trace of the surface form of a sentence is evidence that these two kinds of traces have different decay rates. This should not, however, be taken as evidence that one form of trace has necessarily replaced the other. In short, the position we wish to advance is that the neural consequences of a single sensory event can result in concurrent memory traces in multiple formats overlapping in time. These multiple representations may differ in their ecological utility and ease of access, as well as in their susceptibility to interference from other activities. How MANY MEMORY TRACES?
The view that a single experience may lay down a number of concurrent traces representing different features of the stimulus has already appeared in the literature from a variety of perspectives. We have questioned the modal model's presumption that sentence comprehension follows a sequence in which the surface form of a sentence forms the initial trace, with this surface form discarded once the meaning has been extracted. At the level of word recognition there is also reason to question the presumption that variations in speakers' voices, speech rate, and other surface features are discarded as part of the normalization process that leads to the abstract phonological code used for determining word identity (Luce & Lyons, 1998). One might ask whether it would not be very inefficient to maintain lower-level stimulus-based representations when they are not needed for identification of the
38
word itself. If one conceptualized a model programmed solely to identify words, a use-and-discard system would certainly be a more efficient one. There is, however, some evidence in the speech perception literature that acoustic features of a word such as the vocal characteristics of the speaker, even though irrelevant to the word's identification, are maintained in memory not only before the abstract phonological features necessary for lexical identification are abstracted but also for some period beyond that (Goldinger, 1996). Our point here is that surface features of the stimulus at a number of levels may co-exist in memory along with higher-level abstract phonological and semantic representations of the lexical input. On the left side of Figure 2 our diagram of the operations and processes that must be performed for successful language comprehension begins with an analysis of the acoustic waveform. As indicated in our discussion, this includes phoneme identification, lexical access, and determination of the syntactic and semantic relations represented by the lexical elements. We have not, in this diagram, indicated whether there is an interaction between the phonological and conceptual traces. Nor does our diagram show the full array of factors operating on language comprehension. For example, it is undoubtedly the case that thematic role assignment may be determined not only by the syntax of the input but also by access to real-world knowledge. These factors would have to be included in any complete processing account. For the purpose of this illustration we have simplified the model presented here. It will be seen in the diagram that we have identified three memory traces, formed at different times, and decaying at different rates, but all being held concurrently for some period. These are a trace of the acoustic input (which would include factors such as voice quality), a phonological trace representing a verbatim surface form of the utterance, and a conceptual (CSTM) trace. Note that, in our diagram, one form of representation is not replaced by the other forms, but that they are held in parallel, albeit with different decay rates symbolized by the different lengths of the horizontal arrows. SPONTANEOUS SEGMENTATION
AND
SPEECH CONTENT
The essence of Potter and Lombardi's CSTM is that speech must be analyzed for structure and semantic content very rapidly as it is being heard. An argument for a sparing of CSTM in adult aging would require a demonstration of a conceptual trace that can still be developed rapidly in older adults in spite of the general slowing that is a virtual hallmark of normal aging (Salthouse, 1996). One of the lines of evidence we can draw on uses a technique we have referred to as "spontaneous segmentation." In this task subjects hear over headphones a prerecorded paragraph-length passage of prose and are told that their task is to recall what they have heard with as close to 100 percent accuracy as possible. Because of the length of the passage, subjects are told that they may press a pause button on the tape recorder and stop the tape at any time for immediate recall. In this way subjects work their way through the passage on a segment-by-segment basis, selecting a segment and recalling it, then selecting another segment and recalling it, and so on.
39
(In this paradigm subjects are instructed not to try to shadow the speech. Rather, they are told to begin their recall only after the tape has been stopped.) When given this task subjects spontaneously interrupt the speech primarily at major linguistic boundaries: The highest frequency of interruptions occurs at sentence and major clause boundaries, with fewer interruptions after noun and prepositional phrases, and still fewer interruptions after non-clausal points such as after nouns, verbs, prepositions, or other elements that could signal the nature of upcoming constituents. A very few interruptions (typically 11% or less) occur at points that do not coincide with recognized constituent boundaries, and still fewer interruptions occur that split a word. This latter point is an important one. Because there is an inherent time element involved in making the decision as to when to press the button to interrupt the speech, and in making the physical motor movement to do so, the decision as to where to interrupt the speech must be made some time before that point where the subject actually stops the tape. We have taken the finding of linguistically guided interruptions that rarely split a word as strong evidence that subjects are processing the input to determine its structure as it is being heard (Wingfield & Butterworth, 1984). We can see that spontaneous segmentation has much in common with the recently developed auditory moving window (AMW) technique, except that in the AMW method the speech is segmented by the experimenter, either word-by-word or sector-by-sector, and one measures the subject's latencies for pressing a key to hear the next segment (e.g., Ferreira, Henderson, Anes, Weeks, & McFarlane, 1996). Previous work using the spontaneous segmentation paradigm has shown that older adults generally select the same points for interruption of speech as do young adults, and that their recall of the selected segments is quite good, although somewhat poorer than the young adults' for longer segment sizes (Wingfield, Lahar, & Stine, 1989). Artificially accelerating the speech rate has little effect on where older adults interrupt speech for recall, demonstrating that older adults can perform these linguistic operations at rates even faster than normally encountered in everyday discourse (Wingfield & Stine, 1986). Subjects' selections of points of interruption reflect syntactic constituent detection at least at the surface level. Of interest in the present context is (a) whether complexity of the speech content affects where subjects choose to segment the input, (b) whether older adults use speech content in a manner similar to young adults, and (c) whether both groups will be sensitive to content even when the speech is accelerated to exceed rates ordinarily encountered in nature. This, we argue, would be a powerful demonstration that older adults have the processing power needed for rapid on-line encoding of speech necessary to form a CSTM. An experiment conducted by Wingfield and Lindfield (1995) has these requisites. This study tested whether subjects' points of spontaneous segmentation would be affected by the content difficulty of the speech passages. The presumption was that an early-stage semantic representation of the input would respect this content complexity, as distinct from a strictly verbatim store that would be immune to variation in content complexity of the speech input. This should be reflected in a decrease in the size of the segments selected by the subjects when the difficulty of the speech materials is increased. One would still expect to see subjects'
40
interruptions occurring at linguistic constituent boundaries. The smaller segment sizes predicted would be expected to be produced by subjects interrupting the input at more frequently occurring constituent boundaries than sentence and major clause boundaries. Speech difficulty was varied by using an empirically derived measure based on the average word predictability of the speech using a "cloze" procedure. The cloze value of a passage is derived from the percentage of subjects who can correctly guess the identity of words periodically deleted from the passage. The justification for using cloze values is based on the presumption that the probability that a subject will think of a particular word deleted from a text serves as a summary statistic that reflects the combined effects of the syntactic, semantic, and pragmatic constraints that operate on word choice. Consistent with this presumption, prior work has shown that average cloze predictability of a passage correlates highly with Figure 3. Percentage of interruptions following sentence and clause boundaries for high, medium and low predictability passages for young and older adults. (Data from Wingfield & Lindfield, 1995).
41
individuals' subjective estimates of passage difficulty and with actual recall scores (Aquino, 1969). In this study, well-educated young (mean age = 19 years) and older (mean age = 70 years) adults with good levels of education and verbal ability heard 150-word prose passages rated for cloze value by Miller and Coleman (1967). The passages were recorded at a comfortable speaking rate of approximately 150 wpm in natural intonation, and then time-compressed to produce mean speaking rates of 180, 230, and 300 wpm. The subjects' task was to listen to a speech passage as it was presented, interrupting the recording at points of their choosing in order to give immediate recall of the words in that segment. Subjects were told to strive for accuracy of recall. No mention was made of the fact that our main interest was in where they chose to interrupt the speech for recall. Although the sizes of the segments selected for recall showed wide variability, an analysis of variance verified an overall decline in average segment sizes selected as mean inter-word predictability of the passages decreased ( p < .001). There was no main effect of age, nor was there a significant age by passage predictability interaction. There was also no effect of speech rate on segment sizes selected, nor did speech rate interact with either age or passage predictability. The wide variability in sizes of segments selected reflected subjects' tendency to interrupt the input for recall not at regular-size segments, but at major linguistic boundaries that naturally vary in size. Figure 3 shows the mean percentage of interruptions that occurred at sentence and clause boundaries for the young and older adults as passage predictability decreased. Because approximately 90% or more of segmentations occurred at commonly defined syntactic boundaries, the decrease in the percentage of interruptions at sentence and major clause boundaries shown in Figure 3 represents a reciprocal increase in the percentage of interruptions that occurred at the previously defined minor constituent boundaries. This resulted in the progressive reduction in segment sizes just described. (The values shown in Figure 3 have been collapsed across the three speech rates.) An analysis of variance conducted on the data shown in Figure 3 confirmed the significant decline in the percentage of interruptions that occurred at sentence and clause boundaries with decreasing passage predictability ( p < .001). Nor did this effect differ for the older and younger adults either in terms of a main effect of age or a significant passage predictability by age interaction. (In this analysis there was a small effect of speech rate, reflecting subjects' tendency to interrupt the speech more frequently at minor constituent boundaries when the speech input became more rapid, but this did not interact with age or predictability. Indeed, as we saw, this speech rate effect was so small as not to appear in the previously cited analysis of variance conducted on mean segment sizes in terms of numbers of words.) The value of this study is two-fold. First, the study confirms previous findings that have demonstrated the similarity in where young and older adults choose to segment speech input for recall in terms of its surface syntactic constituents. Second, this study shows that both young and older subjects' segmentation patterns were sensitive to speech content as measured by average word predictability. Finally, these were segment selection choices that must have been made on-line, as the speech was being heard, an operation that did not show large age differences.
42
meanings of sentences even though those specific words had not actually occurred in the sentences (e.g., Potter & Lombardi, 1990). It could be argued that such findings could result from recall from a decaying verbatim surface trace constrained by linguistic production rules (Lee & Williams, 1997). Our spontaneous segmentation findings, however, clearly favor the Potter and Lombardi position. These findings would suggest that, although age differences do occur in text recall (they also did so in this experiment), the input to the memory system consisted of speech that had already been analyzed at the content level. This is consistent with recall being based on a CSTM. It is inconsistent with immediate recall being limited to reproduction of a verbatim (ordered) phonological store serving as a precursor to the determination of the syntactic structure and the semantic relations represented in the speech. As we saw, such an analysis must already have been conducted as the basis for subjects' points of segmentations. RECONSTRUCTIONS
AS
EVIDENCE
FOR
GENERATION
FROM
CSTM
Is short-term recall as reconstructive as Potter and Lombardi claim? These authors have certainly shown subjects to misidentify "lure" words related to the meanings of sentences even though those specific words had not actually occurred in the sentences (e.g., Potter & Lombardi, 1990). It could be argued that such findings could result from recall from a decaying verbatim surface trace constrained by linguistic production rules (Lee & Williams, 1997). Our spontaneous segmentation findings, however, clearly favor the Potter and Lombardi position. It is well-known that age differences in recall are smaller for sentences than for recall of random word lists of equivalent length (e.g., Wingfield, Poon, Lombardi, & Lowe, 1985). This would be an expected finding if, as we have argued, sentence recall is based on reconstruction from a spared CSTM, while random word list recall must rely on an age-compromised veridical store. We examined this question by looking at immediate recall of speech by younger and older adults when recall processes were challenged both by varying speech rates and by varying the way in which the information was grouped at presentation (Wingfield, Tun, & Rosen, 1995). For this purpose, we employed a variant of the spontaneous segmentation method described previously. In this case, passages were divided into segments by the experimenter, rather than the listener. Like the spontaneous segmentation paradigm, subjects were asked to give verbatim recall after each segment had ended. Half of the passages were segmented at normal syntactic boundaries, such as at the ends of clauses and sentences, while the remaining half of the passages were segmented at random non-syntactic points. The distribution of segment sizes were matched across the two presentation conditions. Thus, in each condition listeners would be required to recall segments of similar length (e.g., eight words), but in the syntactic condition those eight words would comprise a syntactically coherent clause, while in the non-syntactic condition the eight words might begin with the end of one clause and include only part of a subsequent one. In this study, we predicted that because the non-syntactic condition would present segments that did not represent a coherent syntactic or semantic unit, it
43
should produce poorer recall than would be found for the syntactically segmented passages that respected these coherent groupings. We further hypothesized that, if older adults are especially reliant on the naturally occurring structure of language, they should be especially disadvantaged by disruptions of this structure relative to young adults. In fact, this is what we found: Our older participants (mean age = 73 years) showed differentially greater recall declines than the young adults (mean age = 19 years) for the random segmentation condition relative to the syntactic segmentation condition (Wingfield et al., 1995). In addition to manipulating segmentation scheme, we also stressed processing load by artificially accelerating speech rates from an original rate of 155 wpm to 220 and 285 wpm. Consistent with earlier studies (e.g., Wingfield et al., 1985; Tun, Wingfield, Stine, & Mecsas, 1992), we found that faster speech rates were especially damaging to recall performance in older adults. Furthermore, the older adults' recall performance was particularly vulnerable, relative to the young adults, when rapid speech rates were combined with the non-syntactic segmentation scheme, especially for the longer segments. When the speech was presented in syntactically coherent units with a normal speech rate, however, the age difference in recall accuracy was minimal (see Wingfield et al., 1995, for details). Although the subjects were specifically told that their task was to recall each Figure 4. Number of reconstructions per sentence in young and older adults' recall of passages interrupted at random or at syntactically related intervals for recall when passages were presented at 155, 220, and 285 words per minute (Data from Wingfield, Tun & Rosen, 1995).
44
segment as accurately as possible, reconstructions in recall occurred for both the young and the older adults. In some cases the subjects' responses omitted a modifier such as an adjective or adverb that reduced the length of the response but that still left a meaningful utterance. In other cases lost words were replaced by others, or words were moved or added to preserve coherence. In fact, when a segment was not recalled correctly, an average of 97% of all recall responses were grammatically correct and semantically coherent. (The percentages ranged from 94% to 99% across age groups and conditions.) For the purposes of our analysis of subjects' errors we defined a reconstruction as the addition or substitution of a word or phrase that was not contained in the original utterance, but that nevertheless left the reported segment syntactically acceptable and semantically coherent. Figure 4 shows the mean number of reconstructions per segment for segments that were not reported exactly as heard. These data are shown for the young and older adults for syntactic and random segmentations at each of the three speech rates tested. Overall, both groups showed an increase in reconstructions as speech rates increased and with random versus syntactic segmentations. We wish to emphasize two points. The first is that the older adults showed a greater number of reconstructions than the younger adults, particularly at the faster speech rates. Indeed, this finding held even when we statistically controlled for the older adults' lower recall rates by expressing reconstructions as a proportion of correct recall (Wingfield et al., 1995). Second, older adults showed a relatively smaller increase than the young adults in the proportion of reconstructions produced at the fastest speech rate (285 wpm) when the segments were presented in the random segmentation condition. This is a condition where the older adults' recall accuracy was poorest, but that would also offer them the least basis for reasonable reconstructions. We see this as evidence that reconstructions in the older adults' recall were neither haphazard nor maladaptive. Under ordinary listening conditions where the emphasis is on gist, reconstruction from a semantic base is a perfectly adaptive way of functioning. In everyday life, for example, it is more adaptive to remember from a weather report that the day will be warm and sunny for a picnic, than to recall the exact details of temperature and humidity. Potter and Lombardi (1990) demonstrated reconstructions in immediate recall with young adults by testing sentence recall after subjects heard synonyms in an earlier distractor task. We found such semantically constrained intrusions occurring for both young and elderly subjects even without the presence of interpolated distractors. The Potter and Lombardi position echoes Bartlett's (1932) classic pronouncement that (long-term) memory is more reconstructive than reproductive. It would appear that this principle holds for short-term recall for meaningful speech as well as it does for long-term recall. Other evidence that CSTM is relatively well preserved in normal aging can be seen in the demonstration that recall of time-compressed speech is significantly improved when silent periods are inserted into speech passages following salient linguistic points such as sentence and clause boundaries. Adding additional processing time at these points would best serve the organization of the rapid input into the semantically based CSTM. When this is done one can restore both young
45
and older adults' recall close to their levels for normal speech rates (Wingfield, Tun, Koh, & Rosen, in press). Assuming that a system such as the CSTM described by Potter and Lombardi is the memory system that carries ordinary comprehension and recall of speech, then one would predict results reported in the literature that slowing speech by adding processing time at clauses is more beneficial than, for example, adding additional time at intervals that do not respect the natural processing units in spoken language, or uniform time expansion of all speech elements (see Wingfield et al., in press, for a review). The similar benefits shown by both young and older adults further support the contention that CSTM is well preserved in normal aging. VERBATIM
AND
CONCEPTUAL TRACES
IN
LONG-TERM MEMORY
As we have seen, traditional models of STM presumed that while storage in verbal short-term memory was in a verbatim or phonological form, storage in long-term memory was conceptual or semantic in nature. That is, the transfer from short- to long-term memory involved not simply a strengthening of the initial trace, but a transformation of the coding format. This view found support in many early studies that showed confusions in short-term memory for words with similar sounds but confusion in long-term memory for words with similar meanings (e.g., Baddeley, 1966). The fact is, however, that we can often remember a speaker's voice or the presentation modality of visually or auditorily presented items (Hintzman, Block, & Inskeep, 1972). These examples illustrate retention of sensory characteristics that do not fit the traditional STM-LTM transfer models. Other studies have shown listeners can remember the surface forms of sentences for long periods of time, as in the case of jokes, insults, and other cases in which the listener chooses to focus on the surface features of an utterance (Murphy & Shapiro, 1994). The ability to demonstrate knowledge of the sensory or surface features of verbal stimuli need not imply that the initial acoustic and phonological traces are being sustained in that form hours or days after the stimuli are heard. The occurrence of long-term retention of surface information, however, has led some to argue for the existence of multiple traces in long-term memory as well as in shortterm memory. As part of a larger model of cognitive processing, fuzzy trace theory, Brainerd and Reyna (1990) have argued for storage in long-term memory in the form of both verbatim and gist-based modes that function in parallel. Brainerd and Reyna (1993) propose several principles that interestingly parallel our view of storage and access in short-term memory. Most relevant to our present discussion are the presumptions (1) that gist extraction is the driving force behind encoding as the individual seeks the underlying sense of gist from incoming stimuli, (2) that information is stored on a fuzzy-to-verbatim continuum that ranges from the general gist of a message to an exact representations of the data, providing an array of options for retrieval, (3) that across the lifespan there is a fuzzyprocessing preference for reasoning from gist traces near the fuzzy end of the continuum, (4) that short-term memory is also reconstructive, and the degree to which gist traces or verbatim traces are called into play depends on the task
46
demands, and (5) that these various operations are not dependent on a common processing resource. Support for the presence of both fuzzy and verbatim traces comes from studies showing the stochastic independence of reasoning and memory performance, as well as differential decay rates, with verbatim traces typically forgotten more rapidly than fuzzy traces (Brainerd & Reyna, 1990). A number of findings in the current literature fit well with these general principles. These include developmental trends in memory distortions in adult aging (Tun, Wingfield, Rosen, & Blanchard, 1998) and differences in the time courses for true and false memories (Brainerd & Mojardin, in press). We can see a number of similarities between fuzzy trace theory and CSTM. The first of these is the presumption of parallel stores. That is, fuzzy trace theory posits a "network of multiple representations that vary in degree of approximation to background input," and that cognitive tasks can switch among these representations (Brainerd & Reyna, 1993, p. 47). Second, fuzzy trace theory also assumes that gist need not come second to verbatim information in the time course of encoding. This is suggested by studies in which children and adults can be shown to detect narrative gist even before all of the details of background information are presented (Brainerd & Reyna, 1993). Finally, Brainerd and Reyna also conclude that gist-based reconstructions increase with age, although in the case of long-term recall this effect may be the product of both relative availability of traces and age-related preferences for processing modes (Brainerd & Reyna, 1993). In sum, the past several years have seen a questioning of many of the early assumptions underlying the structure of the verbal memory system and its role in supporting and constraining language comprehension. In this presentation we have offered several of our own conclusions in this regard as well as pointing to developing trends we see in theoretical accounts of memory and resource models and language comprehension. QUESTIONS TO BE ANSWERED
We had observed earlier that our goal would be less to supply definitive conclusions than it would be to isolate what we believe to be important questions that need to be answered in regard to language, memory constraints, and adult aging. We have isolated three such question areas: (1) What are the multiple representations laid down when a sentence is heard? What is their nature and what are their relative durations? Of these representations, which actually contribute to language comprehension and which subserve other functions? (2)
Assuming that these multiple representations run in parallel, to what extent do they interact during sentence comprehension and immediate recall by young adults? Is it possible that an older, slower, system would show a greater degree of interaction between traces in recall than a younger, faster, system, or a shift in dependence on one type of trace
47
relative to another, and could this affect the way in which language is processed and recalled? (3)
Do the various levels of language processing draw to greater or lesser extents on a single pool of processing resources, or do different processing operations draw on different cognitive architectures and resource systems?
We suggest that the answers to these questions represent a necessary step to understanding cognitive constraints on language comprehension in young adults, and the increased processing challenges in older adulthood.
48
REFERENCES
Allport, D.A., Antonis, B., & Reynolds, P. (1972). On the division of attention: A disproof of the single channel hypothesis. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, 24, 225-235. Aquino, M.R. (1969). The validity of the Miller-Coleman readability scale. Reading Research Quarterly, 4, 332-357. Atkinson, R.C., & Shiffrin, R.M. (1968). Human memory: A proposed system and its control processes. In K.W. Spence & J.T. Spence (Eds.), The psychology of learning and motivation: Advances in research and theory (Vol. 2, pp. 89195). New York: Academic Press. Baddeley, A.D. (1966). The influence of acoustic and semantic similarity on longterm memory for word sequences. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, 18, 302-309. Baddeley, A.D. (1986). Working memory. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Baddeley, A.D. (1998). The central executive: A concept and some misconceptions. Journal of the International Neuropsychological Society, 4, 523-526. Baddeley, A.D., Gathercole, S., & Papagno, C. (1998). The phonological loop as a language learning device. Psychological Review, 105, 158-173. Bartlett, F.C. (1932). Remembering: A study in experimental and social psychology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Brainerd, C. J., & Mojardin, A. H. (in press). Children's and adults' spontaneous false memories for sentences: Long-term persistence and mere-testing effects. Child Development. Brainerd, C. J., & Reyna, V. F. (1990). Gist is the grist: Fuzzy-trace theory and the new intuitionism. Developmental Review, 10, 3-47. Brainerd, C. J., & Reyna, V. F., (1993). Memory independence and memory interference in cognitive development. Psychological Review, 100,42-67. Brainerd, C. J., & Reyna, V. F. (in press). When things that were not experienced are easier to "remember" than things that were. Psychological Science. Broadbent, D.E. (1971) Decision and stress. New York: Academic Press. Caplan, D., & Waters, G.S. (1990). Short-term memory and language comprehension: A critical review of the neuropsychological literature. In G. Vallar & T. Shallice (Eds.), Neuropsychological impairments of short-term memory (pp. 337-389). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Caplan, D., & Waters, G.S. (in press) Verbal working memory and sentence comprehension. Behavioral and Brain Sciences. Carpenter, P.A., Miyaki, A., & Just, M.A. (1994). Working memory constraints in comprehension: Evidence from individual differences, aphasia, and aging. In M. Gernsbacher (Ed.), Handbook of psycholinguistics (pp. 1075-1 122). San Diego, CA: Academic Press. Conrad, R. (1963). Acoustic confusions and memory span for words. Nature, 197, 1029-1030. Daneman, M., & Carpenter, P.A. (1980). Individual differences in working memory and reading. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 19, 450-466.
49
Daneman, M., & Merikle, P.M. (1996). Working memory and language comprehension: A meta-analysis. Psychonomic Bulletin and Review, 3, 422433. Ferreira, F., Henderson, J.M., Anes, M.D., Weeks, Jr., P.A., & McFarlane, M.D. (1996). Effects of lexical frequency and syntactic complexity in spokenlanguage comprehension: Evidence from the auditory moving-window technique. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 22, 324-335. Fodor, J.A., Bever, T.G., & Garrett, M.F. (1974). The psychology of language. New York: McGraw-Hill. Frazier, L. (1987). Sentence processing: A tutorial review. In M. Coltheart (Ed.), Attention and performance XII (pp. 559-586). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum. Gernsbacher, M.A. (1985). Surface information loss in comprehension. Cognitive Psychology, 17, 324-363. Goldinger, S.D. (1996). Words and voices: Episodic traces in spoken word identification and recognition memory. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory and Cognition, 22, 1166-1183. Goodglass, H., & Wingfield, A. (1998). The changing relationship between anatomic and cognitive explanation in the neuropsychology of language. Journal ofPsycholinguistic Research, 27, 147-165. Gow, D.W., & Gordon, P.C. (1995). Lexical and prelexical influences on word segmentation: Evidence from priming. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance, 21, 344-359. Grosjean, F. (1985). The recognition of words after their acoustic offset: evidence and implications. Perception and Psychophysics, 38, 299-3 10. Hintzman, D.L., Block, R.A., & Inskeep, N.R. (1972). Memory for mode of input. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 11, 741-740. Huggins, A.W.F. (1975). Temporally segmented speech and "echoic" storage. In A. Cohen & S.G. Nooteboom (Eds.), Structure and process in speech perception (pp. 209-225). New York: Springer-Verlag. Just, M.A., & Carpenter, P.A. (1992). A capacity theory of comprehension: Individual differences in working memory. Psychological Review, 99, 122149. Kahneman, D. (1973). Attention and effort. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall. Kemper, S. (1992). Language and aging. In F.I.M. Craik & T.A. Salthouse (Eds.), Handbook of aging and cognition (pp. 213-270). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum. Kemtes, K. A., & Kemper, S. (1997). Younger and older adults' on-line processing of syntactically ambiguous sentences. Psychology and Aging, 12, 362-371. Kerr, B. (1973). Processing demands during mental operations. Memory and Cognition, 1, 401-412. Lee, M-G., & Williams, J.N. (1997). Why is short-term sentence recall verbatim? An evaluation of the role of lexical priming. Memory and Cognition, 25, 156172. Light, L.L. (1990). Interactions between memory and language in old age. In J.E. Birren and K.W. Schaie (Eds.), Handbook of the psychology of aging (3rd Ed., pp. 275-290). San Diego, CA: Academic Press.
50
Lombardi, L., & Potter, M. C. (1992). The regeneration of syntax in short-term memory. Journal of Memory and Language, 31,713-733. Luce, P.A., & Lyons, E.A. (1998). Specificity of memory representations for spoken words. Memory and Cognition, 26,708-715. Martin, R.C., & Romani, C. (1994). Verbal working memory and sentence comprehension: A multiple-components view. Neuropsychology, 8, 506-523. Massaro, D.W. (1974). Perceptual units in speech recognition. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 102, 199-208. Mattys, S.L. (1997). The use of time during lexical processing and segmentation: A review. Psychonomic Bulletin and Review, 4, 310-329. Meier, R.P. (1991). Language acquisition by deaf children. American Scientist, 79, 60-70. Miller, G.A. (1956). The magical number seven, plus or minus two: Some limits on our capacity for processing information. Psychological Review, 63, 8 1-96. Miller, G.R., & Coleman, E.B. (1967). A set of thirty-six prose passages calibrated for complexity. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 6, 851-854. Murphy, G.L., & Shapiro, A.M. (1994). Forgetting of verbatim information in discourse. Memory and Cognition, 22, 85-94. Peterson, L.R., & Peterson, M.J. (1959). Short-term retention of individual verbal items. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 58, 193-198. Potter, M.C. (1993). Very short-term conceptual memory. Memory and Cognition, 21, 156-161. Potter, M. C., & Lombardi, L. (1990). Regeneration in the short-term recall of sentences. Journal of Memory and Language, 29, 633-654. Salthouse, T. A. (1996). The processing-speed theory of adult age differences in cognition. Psychological Review, 103, 403-428. Shiffrin, R.M. (1993). Short-term memory: A brief commentary. Memory and Cognition, 21, 193-197. Titchener, E.B. (1908). Lectures on the elementary psychology of feeling and attention. New York: Macmillan. Tun, P.A., & Wingfield, A. (1993). Is speech special? Perception and recall of spoken language in complex environments. In J. Cerella, J. Rybash, W. Hoyer, & M.L. Commons (Eds.), Adult information processing: Limits on loss (pp. 425-457). San Diego: Academic Press. Tun, P. A. Wingfield, A. Rosen, M. J., & Blanchard, L. (1998). Response latencies for false memories: Gist-based processes in normal aging. Psychology and Aging, 13, 230-241. Tun, P.A., Wingfield, A., Stine, E.A.L., & Mecsas, C. (1992). Rapid speech processing and divided attention: Processing rate versus processing resources as an explanation of age effects. Psychology and Aging, 7, 546-550. van Dijk, T.A., & Kintsch, W. (1983). Strategies of discourse comprehension. New York: Academic Press. Waters, G., & Caplan, D. (1996). The capacity theory of sentence comprehension: Critique of Just and Carpenter (1992). Psychological Review, 103, 761-772. Waugh, N.C., & Norman, D.A. (1965). Primary memory. Psychological Review, 72, 89-104.
51
Wickens, C.D. (1984). Processing resources in attention. In R. Parasuraman & D.R. Davies (Eds.), Varieties of attention (pp. 63-102). New York: Academic Press. Wingfield, A., Alexander, A.H., & Cavigelli, S. (1994). Does memory constrain utilization of top-down information in spoken word recognition? Evidence from normal aging. Language and Speech, 37, 221-235. Wingfield, A., & Butterworth, B. (1984). Running memory for sentences and parts of sentences: Syntactic parsing as a control function in working memory. In H. Bouma & D.G. Bouwhuis (Eds.) Attention and performance X: Control of language processes (pp. 35 1-363). New York: Academic Press. Wingfield, A., Lahar, C.J., & Stine, E.A.L. (1989). Age and decision strategies in running memory for speech: Effects of prosody and linguistic structure. Journal of Gerontology: Psychological Sciences, 44, P106-P113. Wingfield, A. & Lindfield, K.C. (1995). Multiple memory systems in the processing of speech: Evidence from aging. Experimental Aging Research, 21, 101-121. Wingfield, A., Poon, L.W., Lombardi, L., & Lowe, D. (1985). Speed of processing in normal aging: Effects of speech rate, linguistic structure, and processing time. Journal of Gerontology, 40, 579-585. Wingfield, A., & Stine, E.A.L. (1986). Organizational strategies in immediate recall of rapid speech by young and elderly adults. Experimental Aging Research, 12, 79-83. Wingfield, A., Stine, E.A.L., Lahar, C.J., & Aberdeen, J.S. (1988). Does the capacity of working memory change with age? Experimental Aging Research, 14, 103-107. Wingfield, A., Tun, P.A., Koh, C.K., & Rosen, M.J. (in press). Regaining lost time: Adult aging and the effect of time restoration on recall of time-compressed speech. Psychology and Aging. Wingfield, A., Tun, P. A., & Rosen, M. J. (1995). Age differences in veridical and reconstructive recall of syntactically and randomly segmented speech. Journal ofGerontology: Psychological Sciences, SOB, P257-P266. Wingfield, A., Waters, G.S., & Tun, P.A. (1998). Does working memory work in language comprehension?: Evidence from behavioral neuroscsience. In. N. Raz (Ed.), The other side of the error term: Aging and development as model systems in cognitive neuroscience (pp. 3 19-393). Amsterdam: Elsevier. Zacks, R.T., Hasher, L., & Li, K.Z.H. (to appear). Human memory. In F.I.M. Craik & T.A. Salthouse (Eds.), Handbook of aging and cognition (2nd Edition).
52
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors' research is supported by NIH grants AG04517, AG15852 and AG13614 from the National Institute on Aging. We gratefully acknowledge support from the W.M. Keck Foundation. We also thank Jill Garland for her help preparing this manuscript.
3
DISCOURSE PROCESSING AND AGING: RESOURCE ALLOCATION AS A LIMITING FACTOR
Elizabeth A. L. Stine-Morrow and Lisa M. Soederberg Miller
Time is a central construct in current cognitive aging research. A perusal of recent issues of Psychology and Aging, Journals of Gerontology, and Aging, Neuropsychology, and Cognition, and other major journals (Bashore, Ridderinkhof & van der Molen, 1997; Bryan & Luszcz, 1996; Jagacinski, Liao, & Fayyad, 1995; Myerson, Hale, Wagstaff, Poon, & Smith, 1990; Salthouse, 1996; Sommers, 1996) suggests that cognitive slowing is viewed by many researchers as an important contributor to age deficits in a variety of domains of functioning. We measure the processing time of younger and older adults on a wide array of tasks, find that older adults are slower -- particularly as the task becomes more complex -- and take this as evidence of mental decline. To oversimplify a bit, the implication is that to do things fast is efficient and good and to do things slowly is inefficient and bad. This certainly fits with a large number of everyday instances in which we encounter our own processing limits. For example, our lives would be easier if we could clean up the kitchen faster after dinner or respond to the ATM’s queries with faster button presses, or more quickly digest the obtuse instructions of the IRS. On the other hand, there are a number of other activities for which there hardly seems to be any advantage at all to completing things quickly ... reading a child a bedtime story, drinking a glass of Murphy Goode Reserve Chardonnay, or engaging in a kiss. In fact, for these instances, not only does there seem to be no advantage at all to speed, but speed would rather seem to diminish the experience. In a nutshell, the argument we wish to make is that for many goals, reading falls into this latter class of experiences and that there is something to be gained by considering the advantages conferred by the productive allocation of time to text. First we should make some disclaimers: We are not taking the ridiculous position that speed of processing is never advantageous or important in reading. There is certainly evidence that the experience of reading is diminished for readers who are slower in decoding the orthography of written prose into meaningful concepts. (See West, Stanovich, & Cunningham (1995) for a review.) We are also not discounting the utility of the slowing hypothesis in general. The data supporting 53
54
the position that cognitive processes slow with age and that this slowing can account for a wide variety of performance limitations is voluminous, and there is much value in being able to so parsimoniously account for such a pervasive phenomenon (Salthouse, 1988b). Nevertheless, this focus on processing speed in the current zeitgeist of cognitive aging research may be causing us to neglect the role of time well-spent as we meticulously chart the role of time efficiently spent. In other words, time is a resource that we allocate, and the way in which we allocate resources during reading directly influences the nature of the representation of the text, and consequently, our ability to remember and problem-solve using the text. There appear to be independent domain-specific pools of resources, e.g., Shah & Miyake (1996), but Kahneman’s (1973) basic argument that “there is a ... limit on [the] capacity to perform mental work, [and] this limited capacity can be allocated with considerable freedom among concurrent activities” (p. 8) still applies with domain. The activity of language understanding is one that requires cognitive resources to be allocated for the construction of a complex multi-layered representation, which encompasses word-level meaning, text-level meaning, and discourse-level meaning (see Stine, Soederberg, & Morrow, 1996; Wingfield & Stine-Morrow (in press) for reviews). While these layers of representation may complement and reinforce one another once constructed, there is probably competition for resources in the construction process itself, and resource demands among the three components may be differentially met depending upon reader goals (Kintsch, 1994; Kintsch, 1998; Zwann, Magliano, & Graesser, 1995b). Given age-related declines in cognitive mechanics, the strategic management of resource allocation may well be especially important for older readers in maintaining language processing abilities. In the parlance of the framework suggested by Baltes and Baltes (1990), successful older readers might be expected to be selective about their allocation of resources so as to optimize the construction of the text representation within their constraints. THE METHODOLOGICAL APPROACH
The techniques we have been using to measure resource allocation are the gardenvariety computer methods of measuring self-paced reading time, either sentence-bysentence, constituent-by-constituent, or word-by word, using the moving window method (Just, Carpenter, & Wooley, 1982). In most of the research we will discuss, regression is used to decompose the individual reading times into time allocated as a function of different features of the text. This technique, pioneered by Doris Aaronson (1976; 1977) and Just and Carpenter (1980) two decades ago, essentially assumes that reading is a divided attention task. At every point, cognitive resources must be allocated to word-, text-, and discourse-level processes; allocation to these processes can be estimated by the regression coefficients of their associated text features. Table 1 summarizes the cognitive processes modeled with this technique and their associated operationalization, along with an empirical example (this list of references is far from exhaustive).
55
For example, at the word level, the time for orthographic decoding is estimated by regressing word or sentence reading times onto the number of letters (or syllables); the resulting coefficient is a measure of the time allocated per letter (or syllable) in on-line reading. Lexical access is modeled in terms of log word frequency; because less frequently encountered words take longer to read than more frequently encountered words, the facilitation coefficient (longer reading times for low-frequency words) reflects more extensive elaborative encoding of the features of word meaning. The argument is analogous for variables reflecting text-level processes which result in a proposition-based representation of the text content and for those reflecting a discourse-level representation. Text-level processes are fairly uncontroversial, with numerous empirical examples available for each (e.g., Aaronson & Ferres, 1984b; Haberlandt, Graesser, Schneider, & Kiely, 1986; Kintsch & Keenan, 1973). The product of such processes is an integrated conceptual representation of text content (i.e., the “text-base”). The time allotted to process text-based idea units (i.e., propositions representing the minimal conceptual relation) is most easily measured sentence-by-sentence (or constituent-byconstituent) reading time; at this level propositions are fairly reliable predictors of reading time. Word-by-word reading times are most sensitive to variables marking the conceptual organization. Reading times are reliably longer at the ends of sentences and major intra-sentence syntactic constituents. Because this is the point at which readers integrate information, resolve ambiguities, and so forth, this phenomenon has been called “wrap-up” (Just & Carpenter, 1980) and could be thought of as an empirical indicator of the segment-by-segment processing of discourse that Kintsch and van Dijk (1978) has described in terms of “input cycles.” Resources allocated to wrap-up can be estimated simply in terms of a dummy-coded variable for the presence or absence of such boundaries. Interestingly, the time that readers allocate to wrap-up has been found to be linearly related to the number of new concepts introduced up to that point in the sentence (e.g., Haberlandt et al., 1986). So a more finely tuned estimate of conceptual organization can be attained by including the appropriate multiplicative term (i.e., the dummy code for the presence of the relevant boundary times the number of new concepts). The resulting coefficient provides an estimate of the time per new concept allocated at the boundary. The set of discourse-level processes is not as thoroughly established as those used to construct the text-base, though important strides in this domain have been made in the last few years. Some researchers refer to a “schema” that readers build early in the text which then facilitates processing of subsequent text (Haberlandt, 1984); this is operationalized in terms of serial position (which at the discourse level, yields a negative parameter reflecting facilitation). “Story grammars” (Mandler & Johnson, 1977) were early attempts to model the narrative structure that affords readers a strong level of predictability when processing narrative texts. This can be operationalized by first analyzing the node structure of a narrative. Once constructed, a couple of measures can be calculated for each text segment. The depth in the story grammar tree can be calculated in a fashion analogous to Kemper’s technique with Yngve depth (Kemper, 1992). Readers tend to speed up when they are deep into the plot, as indexed by a negative regression coefficient for
56
depth, suggesting that attention to the narrative structure can facilitate processing. Another measure that is predictive of reading time is a dummy-coded variable for whether or not the current text segment is an episode or story ending; consistent with the depth effects, readers are relatively faster when reading endings. Most recently, research characterizing discourse-level processing has hinged on the concept of the “situation model” (van Dijk & Kintsch, 1983), a representation of “what the text is about” (in contrast to information simply given by the text) that integrates elaborations from world knowledge into the representation of text content; such a representation is argued to enable inferential reasoning and problem solving from the text (Kintsch, 1994). Zwann, Langston, and Graesser (1995a) have proposed an “event-indexing model” of text understanding in which events and intentional actions of the characters are the focal points of the situation model. Resources must be expended to monitor and update the situation model when there is a break in temporal, spatial, causal, or goal coherence in the description of events involving the characters. Consistent with this proposal, readers slow down on text segments representing such breaks (Zwann et al., 1995b). The situation model, then, is conceptualized as a multidimensional representation (Zwann & Radvansky, 1998), though perhaps the most well-studied dimension of the situation model is space. One phenomenon that has been used to provide empirical support for the construction of a spatial situation model is the “distance effect,” the fact that during narrative comprehension readers are facilitated in processing information about objects in close proximity to the protagonist’s current location (Morrow, Greenspan,, & Bower, 1987). In the methodological paradigm typically used to demonstrate the distance effect, readers first memorize a map of the setting in which the narratives they will subsequently read take place. The distance effect can then be demonstrated in either on-line reading time (Rinck & Bower, 1995) or verification times to probes which query relative locations of objects (Morrow et al., 1987). In either case, situation model updating is measured in terms of the protagonist’s movement in the narrative relative to the original layout as learned from the map. As the protagonist moves through the spatial array, some features of the layout are foregrounded and relatively accessible while others recede into the background; once backgrounded, resources are required to activate this information. The variables summarized in Table 1 represent a larger set than would be feasible to examine within a single study. The general approach is to select a set of predictors that cover the processes of interest but avoid multicollinearity (Knight, 1984). Individual regression models are constructed for each subject by regressing the text variables of interest onto reading time (Lorch & Myers, 1990) so that resource allocation patterns for each individual are estimated in terms of the set of beta weights from the regression. Hypotheses about group or task differences can be tested by analyzing the beta weights in a repeated measures ANOVA or a MANOVA. Most of the research described in this chapter will rely on this regression technique in which the multiple demands on resources during text processing are modeled simultaneously.
Table 1.
Modeled language processes and associated text variable used in regression analysis.
THEORETICAL PROCESS
TEXT VARIABLE
REFERENCES
# letters (Ltr) # syllables (Syll) log word f
Aaronson & Just & Carpenter,
Decoding idea units for representation of meaning
# propositions (Prop)
Kintsch & Keenan,
Immediate processing of idea units
New concepts (0/1) (NC)
Immediate organization of idea units
Cumulative new concepts (CumNC)
Parsing / Input cycles
Intrasentence boundary (0/1) (IntsB) Sentence boundary (0/1) (SntB)
Aaronson &
Parsing
Yngve depth (YngD)
Stine-Morrow, Soederberg, Haberlandt & Haberlandt, Graesser, & Kiely, 1986)
WORD Orthographic decoding Lexical access
Aaronson & Carpenter & Just & Carpenter,
TEXT-BASE
57
Buffering (orgn/int)
57
CumNC X IntsB (0/n) (ConcIntsB) CumNC X SntB (O/n) (ConcSntB)
58
DISCOURSE / SITUATION MODEL Schema-based processing
Serial position (SP)
Haberlandt, 1984
Temporal coherence breaks
Zwann, Magliano, & Graesser, 1995
Spatial organization
Spatial coherence breaks Target distance from protagonist
Emotional tone
Emotional coherence breaks
Zwann et al., 1995 Morrow, Greenspan, & Bower, 1987 Gernsbacher, Goldsmith, & Robertson, 1992 Stine-Morrow, Miller, & Leno, in preparation
Story grammar processing
Depth (SG Depth) Ending (SG Ending)
58
Temporal organization
59
AGE DIFFERENCES
IN
PATTERNS
OF
RESOURCE ALLOCATION
Over the last several years, the research in our lab has been focused on looking at individual differences in these patterns of resource allocation, particularly at age differences. To this point, this research could be summarized as showing the following: (1) Older readers are often somewhat slower (show a higher intercept), but their reading times are generally sensitive to the same class of text variables as those of younger adults (Miller & Stine-Morrow, 1998; Stine, 1990; Stine, Cheung, & Henderson, 1995; Stine & Hindman, 1994; Stine-Morrow, Loveless, & Soederberg, 1996). (2) One frequent and important exception to this rule is that older adults allocate less time for conceptual processing, especially at sentence boundaries (Stine, 1990; Stine et al., 1995); when they do wrap-up, they appear to allocate relatively more resources for wrap-up after smaller intrasentence constituents rather than after sentences (Miller & Stine-Morrow, 1998). (3) Readers who are above average in subsequent memory performance allocate time differently from the average reader or from below-average readers. For both younger and older readers, successful outcome is related to longer reading time overall, i.e., a higher intercept (e.g., Stine, 1990; Stine et al., 1995) and more thorough processing of complex syntax (Stine et al., 1996). (4) There also appear to be age differences in the reading strategies that engender good memory performance. For younger readers, successful outcome is related to conceptual processing, especially wrap-up at larger constituents like sentences (Stine, 1990; Miller & Stine-Morrow, 1998). For older readers, successful outcome may be less likely to be related to conceptual processing, but relatively more likely to be related to discourse-level processing. For example, successful older readers show a steeper serial position effect (StineMorrow et al., 1996), presumably reflecting more schema based processing (Haberlandt, 1984) and allocate relatively more time to repair spatial coherence breaks (Morrow et al., 1997). Thus, what the reader “does” when reading appears to be related to the nature of the representation when finished. And there are several tantalizing suggestions of ways in which older readers have to do different things from younger adults in order to have a comparable product from reading so as to demonstrate good memory performance. Generally speaking, older adults are more effective when they implement strategies that enable them to circumvent working memory limits, e.g., by wrapping-up more frequently and by taking advantage of discourse-level organization. In particular, these data are consistent with Adams’ (Adams, 1991; Adams, Labouvie-Vief, Hobart, & Dorosz, 1990; Adams, Smith, Nyquist, & Perlmutter, 1997) notion that younger readers are more literal and text-bound in the way in which they approach the text while older adults are more holistic, especially in terms of the strategies that engender good memory performance. This research, however, is limited in several ways -- ways that may well give the appearance of elders being at a disadvantage in conceptual processing. Thus, the thrust of this chapter will be to address these limits, considering some of the recent research from our lab that in some ways challenges our view of the older reader. To summarize (and elaborate on) the argument to this point, our basic premise is that the productive allocation of resources is a necessary condition for the construction
60
of an organized, elaborated and distinctive, meaning-based representation of text. Research from our lab and elsewhere (Hartley, Stojack, Mushaney, Annon, & Lee, 1994; Ratner, Schell, Crimmins, Mittelman, & Baldinelli, 1987; Zabrucky & Moore, 1994) suggests that on average older adults may not allocate resources during online processing so as to create such a representation, particular for the text-base; this may contribute in part to oft-noted age-related declines in discourse memory. The remainder of the chapter is organized around four factors which may encourage the productive allocation of resources among older readers, thus maximizing the utility of the constructed representation. OLDER ADULTS ALLOCATE RESOURCES
TO
NARRATIVE TEXT
Narrative texts are those that tell a story, most typically by focusing on a protagonist that encounters and resolves one or more conflicts through a telling that unfolds in time. Readers generally read narratives more quickly and remember more from them than expository texts. One account of this phenomenon is that narratives consume cognitive capacity. For example, Britton et al. (1983) demonstrated that simple reaction time in a secondary task was longer when the primary task was to read narrative passages than when it was to read expository passages. Much in the way that it is easier to redirect attention (to answer a telephone, for instance) from reading a newspaper account of the latest university funding crisis than it is when reading a Richard Russo narrative on university life, Britton’s subjects were relatively more absorbed in the narratives, taking longer to respond to the secondary task. Such data prompted them to argue that narratives draw cognitive resources because of the "meaning that is produced by the text in the reader's cognitive system" (p. 41). In other words, the narrative structure of a good story creates an obligatory demand for resources that is difficult to ignore. It may not be only the structure that generates differences in resource allocation, however. Zwann (1994) showed that younger adults read identical passages differently depending on whether they were told that the passages were excerpts from news stories or novels. Thus, genre effects on resource allocation may ultimately be due to a combination of text features and expectations about what is typically required in reading in that genre. There is a small literature in cognitive aging that has explored the narrative advantage among elderly readers. Elderly readers appear to be especially efficient at encoding narratives (relative to expository texts) as measured by reading time per proposition recalled (Tun, 1989). With respect to memory organization, older readers do as well as (Tun, 1989) or better than (Stine & Wingfield, 1987; Stine & Wingfield, 1990) young adult readers in using narrative structure in selective memory for gist over detail. Such findings may appear to be paradoxical if we assume that narratives demand processing resources (Britton et al., 1983), but that aging brings a depletion of resources (Salthouse, 1988a). In fact, using Britton’s secondary task approach, Tun (1989) showed that while younger readers demonstrated a genre effect on secondary task performance (replicating the Britton work), older readers did not, even though older adults showed a differential benefit from genre in processing efficiency. Nevertheless, Tun concedes that the secondary task, which generates very small genre effects among the young (30 msec), may
61
Figure 1. Reading time allocation to different text features of narratives by younger and older adults.
have not been sensitive in an older sample. The analysis of resource allocation from reading times allowed us a more direct text of Tun’s hypothesis that older adults rely on the narrative structure to support self-initiated processing (e.g., Craik & Jennings, 1992). Thus, even though narratives are resource-consuming, their well-defined organization (as well as readers’ well-learned skills in how to approach this genre) may provide support that elders use to meet resource demands. In our study (Stine-Morrow, Miller, & Leno, in preparation), 104 younger adults and 100 older adults read two extended and highly engaging “elder tales,” “The Woodcutter” and “The Alchemist” (Chinen, 1989) for subsequent recall. We should point out that our participants read only narrative passages, and our focus was on examining on-line resource allocation to this genre alone. While we cannot draw conclusions about comparisons between genres, we can examine (in a more fine-grained way than has been done before) age differences in processing narratives. In particular, we were interested in finding out whether, under these optimum conditions (i.e., highly schematic narratives expressing themes presumably of especial relevance in late life), older adults would be compelled to engage in conceptual processing. In terms of overall recall, the two groups were quite similar, with older adults recalling 29.7% of the propositions and younger adults recalling
62
31.2%. Figure 1 shows the reading time allocation patterns for these two age groups. What is striking about these data is that that there are negligible age differences in the patterns of resource allocation, multivariate F(10, 188) = 1.59, p > .1. Most importantly, younger and older readers appeared to respond to the demands for conceptual processing and integration in exactly the same way and to the same extent. In particular, older adults appeared to engage in sentence wrap-up in the same way that younger adults did. Neither was there a substantial difference in subsequent recall. Comparing this to the earlier studies, the data suggest that older adults are using the narrative schema of the text to support resource allocation to the text base. This conclusion is bolstered by the fact that those subjects who were most facilitated in their reading by story grammar depth and ending showed larger sentence wrap-up effects ( r = -.19, p < .01 for depth, and r = -.24, p < .001 for ending). Also, an analysis based on a median split of subsequent recall showed that while elders above-average in recall were more facilitated by story grammar ending and serial position than those below-average in recall, p < .05 for both, younger groups did not show this difference. So it appears that in the case of highly engaging narrative texts, older readers can allocate resources to text-base level conceptual integration. This stands in contrast to our results with expository texts and short narratives in which older adults demonstrated reduced wrap-up effects. In addition, such processing contributed to good recall performance. In a hierarchical regression analysis, ability measures and strategy measures independently predicted recall performance, with ability measures carrying about 17% of the variance, and strategy variables (primarily sentence wrap-up) carrying about 9% (this is the case regardless of the order of entry). AGEDIFFERENCESINRESOURCEALLOCATIONCANDEPENDUPONREADER GOALS
The way in which readers allocate resources to the text has been shown to depend on the goal with which they approach the text. For example, Aaronson and Ferres (1984a) showed that readers allocate relatively more time to lexical items conveying structural features of language (e.g., conjunctions and prepositions) when they read for recall, but relatively more time to lexical items conveying content (e.g., adjectives) when reading for comprehension. Similarly, Kintsch (1994) has argued that comprehension and problem-solving goals promote greater processing of the situation model, while recall goals promote relatively greater attention to the text base. Consistent with this position, Zwann, Magliano, and Graesser (1995b) have shown that among college readers, resources are disproportionately allocated to processing the situation model when narratives are read for comprehension, but to the text base for recall. Reader goals are perhaps particularly important in comparing resource allocation strategies of young and old. Younger adults engaged in (or not far from) formal educational experience often find themselves reading in order to be able to recall the information later. In spite of the professor’s overtures to the contrary,
63
students often prepare for retrieval by focusing on constructing the text base representation, giving short shrift to the situation model. Older adults, on the other hand, are not typically in an ecological niche which requires recall. Rather, they are likely to read for comprehension, for example, for entertainment or for learning how to do something. Thus, it might be expected that even though older adults may be less sensitive to text demands when asked to produce subsequent recall, this may not be the case when they are asked to read for comprehension. In our lab, we tested this hypothesis in an experiment in which younger and older adults read single sentences word-by-word either for recall or comprehension. We should begin with the caveat that this is a preliminary study purely examining sensitivity to text features for sentence processing, so we are limited in being able to address only text-based features (and not situation model features, which are certainly of interest in the long run). Figure 2. Reading time allocation to text features as a function of reader goals for younger and older adults.
64
In this study, 52 university undergraduates and 50 community-dwelling elders read a series of sentences (16-18 words in length) dealing with nature, geography, and history (similar to materials used by Stine and Hindman (1994)). Subjects within each age group were randomly assigned to either a read-for-recall or read-forcomprehension group; those in the former condition simply produced immediate recall for each sentence and those in the latter answered a single question after reading each sentence. Questions were designed to test the gist of the sentence and important details. For example, the sentence “The snowshoe rabbit has white fur in the winter which turns brown in the warmer seasons” was followed with the T/F item, “The snowshoe rabbit is brown in the summer”; the sentence “Fossil reefs formed from limestone bedrock give the ground under Chicago the strength to support tall skyscrapers” was tested with the T/F item, “A layer of granite under Chicago supports its buildings.” The patterns of reading time allocation as a function of reader goal and age are presented in Figure 2. When reading for recall (lower panel of Figure 2), older adults allocated less time to conceptual integration than did the young, as has been previously demonstrated in the word-by-word paradigm (Stine, 1990; Stine et al., 1995). Allocation patterns to achieve comprehension were different from those used to achieve recall for both age groups. First, and most obviously, reading times in the comprehension condition were less sensitive to our target text variables (note that in the upper panel of Figure 2, the scale of time allocation is expanded so as to highlight the relative importance of different text features). Second, there were relatively fewer resources allocated to conceptual integration and relatively more on elaborative encoding of new concepts (NewConc) the first time they were introduced and on lexical access (word f). Third, there was no intrasentence wrapup, and in fact, this variable (ContIntS) produced a suppression effect because of its correlation with NewConc ( r = .72) in this stimulus set. Most importantly, in contrast to the recall condition, there were no age differences at all in reading time allocation, F (4,396)=6.69, p <.001, for the Age by Retrieval Condition by Text Variable interaction. Thus, with the more typical and less resource-consuming reading goal, older readers appeared to meet the resource demands of comprehension. In terms of ultimate performance, the age difference in proportion of propositions recalled (MY = .68, se = .03; MO= .72, se = .02) was not significant, t (49) = 1.37, and older readers even outperformed the young on the comprehension task (MY= .80, se = .02; MO= .89, se = .01), t (50) = 3.85, p < .05. The asymmetry in these results (i.e., age differences in resource allocation leading to age similarity in recall, but age similarity in resource allocation leading to an elder-superiority in comprehension) is not easy to explain. It is not uncommon to find older readers – even high-performing ones – allocating relative few resources to conceptual processing under recall instructions, and it may certainly be that elders can achieve high levels of memory performance by allocating resources to text features not measured in the present study. So one explanation is that elderly readers were engaging in some unmeasured discourse-level processes (e.g., Adams; StineMorrow et al., 1996); though it is difficult to postulate what these processes might be for single sentences) that enabled them to equal (in recall) or outperform (in
65
comprehension) the younger readers. Nevertheless, even though earlier research has demonstrated a relationship between wrap-up and subsequent memory for text (e.g., Haberlandt et al., 1986; Stine, 1990; Miller & Stine-Morrow, 1998), this was not the case in the present data set. In fact, none of our allocation variables predicted performance in either goal condition (recall performance was positively related to both WAIS vocabulary, r = .34, p < .02, and to working memory span, r = .33, p < .02, and comprehension performance was positively related to vocabulary alone, r = .43, p < .001). Thus, even though this particular data set does not speak to the issue of the patterns of allocation that engender good memory performance, they are informative with respect to spontaneous change in allocation strategy in response to task demands: while older readers may differ from the young in how they allocate resources to text for a recall task, they may use strategies quite similar to the young when they read for comprehension. OLDER READERS ALLOCATE RESOURCES
TO THE
SITUATION MODEL
Although the text-base representation is often inefficiently (Hartley et al., 1994) and fragilely (Cohen & Faulkner, 1981; Light & Capps, 1986) constructed among older adults, the mental model has been found to be fairly resilient to the effects of aging (Morrow, Stine-Morrow, Leirer, Andrassy, & Kahn, 1997; Radvansky, Gerard, Zacks, & Hasher, 1990; Radvansky & Curiel, 1998; Soederberg & Stine, 1995). The next experiment we present reinforces the point that older readers show preserved situation model processing and demonstrates that they may be particularly dependent on this mode of processing to achieve good memory performance. We focus on spatial aspects of the situation model, and the logic of our argument hinges on the “distance effect” discussed earlier. Even though resources to the spatial situation model can be modeled using the global regression techniques illustrated in the two studies presented so far (Zwann et al., 1995b), in this case, we used an experimental approach in which word- and text-level variables are held constant to isolate the effects of spatial distance. Earlier research has shown that older readers show a distance effect as they read (Morrow et al., 1997), suggesting that they build and update the spatial situation as the character moves through the setting as younger adults do. In our most recent experiment on this topic (Stine-Morrow, Morrow, & O’Brien, 1998), we were interested in comparing how younger and older adults would deal with new information from the text in constructing a situation model. The participants were 49 university students and 53 community dwelling elderly adults. The setting for all of the narratives was a ten-room research center. In each of the six narratives, a plot was developed for a different protagonist which provided some motivation for him/her to move about the center, interacting with other characters and objects. Before reading the narratives, participants memorized a pictorial layout of the setting which included three objects in each room. In the first few paragraphs of the narrative, three new objects were introduced with a modifier and location, mentioned again explicitly, and mentioned implicitly a third time pronominally. Over the course of the rest of the narrative, there were six critical motion sentences which described a protagonist moving from one room (the
66
Figure 3. Sentence reading time as a function of distance and object type for younger and older adults.
“source” room) to another (the “goal” room) through an unmentioned (“path”) room. Following the motion sentence was a target sentence in which the protagonist was described as mentally interacting (e.g., remembering, thinking about, wondering about) with an object in the layout. Half of the objects in the target sentences were from the layout as originally memorized (“original objects”) and half were those introduced in the text (“new objects”). Thus, there were six cells in the withinsubject design created by factorially combining two levels of Object Type (original, new) and three levels of distance from the protagonist (goal, path, source). After reading each narrative, participants answered a series of Y/N comprehension questions which probed understanding of the protagonist’s goals, subgoals organized to achieve goals, emotional tone, location of the protagonist at critical points in the narrative, as well as the location of learned and new objects. Older adults took longer than the young to learn the narrative layout, as measured by both trials-to-criterion (TTC), t (100) = 7.26, p < .001, and total study time, t (100) = 2.05, p < .05, but were similar to the young in terms of overall comprehension accuracy, t (94) = 1.23, ns. Reading time data were analyzed by first calculating distance effects for learned and new objects for each subject as slope values derived from regressing average sentence reading time onto distance (dummy coded as 0, 1, 2), These slope values were analyzed in a 2 (Age) X 2 (Object Type: original, new) repeated measures analysis of variance. There was a marginal trend for the distance effect to be greater for original objects than for new objects, F (1, 100) = 3.31, p < .075, as would be expected if the a priori learning of the spatial layout enhanced organization of the situation model. In other words, subjects read sentences more quickly when they referred to objects close to the protagonist than when they referred to objects farther away, but this effect was more pronounced
67
when the objects were those learned in the original layout. There was no age difference in the distance effect, nor was the Age by Object Type interaction significant, F < 1 for both. In fact, both younger and older readers demonstrated a significant distance effect for both learned and new objects, with the regression slope significantly greater than zero in all four cases, p < .05. These data suggest that, on average, both younger and older adults can integrate new information from the text into the situation model. Furthermore, an examination of correlations between the distance effect and comprehension performance suggested that mental model updating was predictive of comprehension accuracy, with the distance slope showing significant relationship to overall comprehension accuracy, r (96) = .21, p < .03, as well as to memory for the location of the new objects, r (96) = .28, p < .01, and the protagonist, r (96) = .30, p < .01. To further explore the resource allocation patterns that engendered successful comprehension, distance slopes were analyzed for subjects who achieved comprehension accuracy greater than or equal to 80%. As shown in Figure 4, when conditionalized on high levels of subsequent comprehension performance, younger adults showed a reduced distance effect for new objects relative to original objects (this was the Object Type by Distance interaction evident in the first analysis), suggesting that they were less likely to integrate the new information from the text into the situation model. Older adults, on the other hand, showed similarly large distance effects for both types of objects. This Age X Object Type interaction for the distance effect was significant, F (1,76) = 4.21, p < .05. These data suggest that older adults were able to integrate new information into the situation model from text at least as well as younger adults, and that this mode of processing was particularly apparent among those who were successful in answering the comprehension questions. Thus, older adults who are successful comprehenders appear to allocate relatively more resources than do the young to mental model updating for newly learned information. OLDER READERS ALLOCATE RESOURCES WHEN SUPPORTED ALREADY KNOW
BY
WHAT THEY
The final piece of research we describe addresses the extent to which knowledge can guide the allocation of processing resources (Miller, in preparation). The benefits of knowledge on the products of discourse processing, such as recall and comprehension, are well-established. For example, knowledge has been shown to facilitate language processing among younger adults in terms of recall (Spilich, Vesonder, Chiesi, & Voss, 1979), recognition (Chiesi, Spilich, & Voss, 1979), and coherent production (Voss, Vesonder, & Spilich, 1980) of domain-related texts. Recent work on expertise also attests to the merits of an extensive and wellorganized knowledge base (cf. Ericsson & Charness, 1994) that can help the reader form a situation model (Kintsch, 1998). However, we know little about how knowledge influences on-line reading. The work of Sharkey and Sharkey (1987), and more recently Miller and Stine-Morrow (1998), has shown that knowledge can speed processing by making unfamiliar concepts more accessible and by facilitating
68
conceptual integration. But there is something else that knowledge does for us: it structures the text for us so that we can productively allocate resources to it, as is required whenever we encounter conceptually difficult material in our domain. To explain how knowledge promotes processing, Ericsson and Kintsch (1995) proposed the notion of retrieval structures. Retrieval structures are an elaborate system of retrieval cues in short-term memory that provide rapid access to knowledge structures in long-term memory. Because of this, they refer to this system as long-term working memory (LTWM). High-knowledge readers construct retrieval structures in LTWM as they progress through a text which can enable them to more efficiently encode and retrieve material that directly maps onto relationships stored in long-term memory. Empirically, this may correspond to more efficient (i.e., faster) conceptual integration (cf. Sharkey & Sharkey, 1987; Miller & StineMorrow, 1998). When knowledgeable readers read texts in their domain, the retrieval structures that they construct allow a more complex representation to be stored in LTWM relative to that of the novice (who does not have complicated chunks to retrieve). Our argument is that to the extent that information from the text allows the expert to augment the current knowledge base (e.g., by adding new conceptual relations), processing novel information in the domain may actually be resourceconsuming. Thus, when an expert reads highly familiar material, s/he may be facilitated in conceptual integration, but when the expert is building on the extant knowledge base, s/he can use well-developed retrieval structures to productively expend resources toward the expansion of that knowledge base. Under this latter condition, knowledgeable individuals will actually show more extensive resource allocation (cf. Britton & Tesser, 1982; Britton, Holdredge, Curry, & Westbrook, 1979). Figure 4. Reading time allocation to conceptual processing at the immediate boundaries (INTRASNT), and intersentence boundaries (INTERSNT) as a function of passage type among older readers.
69
From an intuitive standpoint, one could image that reading a journal article within one’s domain of expertise might entail a different allotment of cognitive resources, than, say, reading a newspaper article about research aimed at the general public. The newspaper article can be read quickly by the expert because the concepts are already familiar and highly integrated. The journal article, on the other hand, probably contains new concepts that require cognitive resources by the expert to integrate. The novice, however, would be less likely to expend resources since there are no retrieval structures to promote their productive allocation. In everyday reading, we often read to learn more about something we already know about; given the age-related growth in crystallized abilities (e.g., Schaie, 1996), this is probably even more true of older readers, and it may give them an advantage that is not captured by laboratory passages carefully screened so as to be unfamiliar. Thus, we wish to entertain the possibility that, under some circumstances, knowledge may encourage the older reader to allocate processing resources. Assuming that knowledge facilitates processing of the situation model (Kintsch, 1998), that the situation model promotes comprehension/learning rather than simple recall (Kintsch, 1998), that older adults may be more likely to wrap-up when the goal is comprehension (cf. Figure 2), and that older adults may rely more on the situation model in text processing (cf. Figure 3), it may be that highknowledge elders will expend resources for conceptual wrap-up to learn more about something within a domain in which they are already well-versed. In a demonstration of this principle, Miller (in preparation) asked 50 community-dwelling elders varying in background knowledge of cooking to read fairly technical cooking passages as well as control passages unrelated to cooking. Based on scores on a paper-and-pencil measure of cooking knowledge (an instrument developed and validated using professional chefs and chef trainees), a median split was used to divide this group into those above- and below-average in cooking knowledge. The domain-related passages, taken from cooking textbooks, contained concepts and terminology specific to the area of cooking with terms such as glutin, persillade, and rosemary. The control passages were about jumping beans, swordmaking, and whales and contained concepts like baleen, gulpers, and skimmers. The recall data were consistent with past research showing that knowledge facilitated performance (e.g., Spilich et al., 1979). While there was no group difference in recall of the control passages (32.3 vs. 33.6 propositions for low- and high-knowledge groups, respectively), for the cooking passages, high-knowledge readers demonstrated better recall than low-knowledge ones (24.3 vs. 19.4), t (49) = 1.79, p < .05. Figure 4 shows the patterns of resources allocated to conceptual processing (either immediately or for wrap-up) to cooking and control passages (in this case, the dummy-codes for boundaries were entered without being weighted by conceptual load). For sentence wrap-up, the Group by Passage Type interaction was significant, F (1,46) = 5.32, p < .05, showing that high-knowledge readers were differentially more likely to allocate time to wrap-up for passages in their domain of expertise. While there were no group effects on intrasentence wrap-up at minor boundaries, high-knowledge subjects allocated marginally more resources to the
70
immediate processing of new concepts, F (1,46) = 3.55, p < .07. Thus, it seems that because the older high-knowledge readers had the background knowledge needed to form retrieval structures, they were able to allocate the resources needed to comprehend and remember these challenging texts. CONCLUSION
To wrap up, the literature in discourse processing and aging has been somewhat equivocal with respect to the existence of age deficits. Age deficits have been most apparent when texts are expository and demanding in their requirements of text-base integration. The measurement of on-line processing has related memory deficits among the old to their failure to allocate processing resources to the construction of the text-base. Thus, in processing the text-base, older adults are often fast and “efficient.” The consequent representation does not always serve them well in memory performance. The work we have reviewed, while in many ways still only suggestive, shows that there are certain conditions, namely narrative structure, comprehension goals, situation model availability, and knowledge, which can promote the productive allocation of resources to text among older adults. Perhaps the most provocative aspect of this research is that it suggests that it may wind up being an oversimplification to say that elders can maintain their discourse processing ability by focusing on discourse-level features (e.g., Adams et al., 1990; Stine-Morrow et al., 1996). Rather, it may be that their use of discourselevel features, such as the situation model and narrative structure, provides support to enable them to create a distinct and elaborated text-base on par with that of the young.
71
REFERENCES
Aaronson, D., & Ferres, S. (1984a). A structure and meaning based classification of lexical categories. Annals of the NY Academy of Sciences, 43,21-57. Aaronson, D., & Ferres, S. (1984b). The word-by-word reading paradigm: An experimental and theoretical approach. In D. E. Kieras & M. A. Just (Eds.), New methods in reading comprehension research (pp. 31-68). Hillsdale, N. J.: Erlbaum. Aaronson, D., & Scarborough, H. S. (1976). Performance theories for sentence coding: Some qualitative evidence. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance, 2, 56-70. Aaronson, D., & Scarborough, H. S. (1977). Performance theories for sentence coding: Some quantitative models. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 16, 277-303. Adams, C. (1991). Qualitative age differences in memory for text: A life-span developmental perspective. Psychology and Aging, 6, 323-336. Adams, C., Labouvie-Vief, G., Hobart, C. J., & Dorosz, M. (1990). Adult age group differences in story recall style. Journal of Gerontology: Psychological Sciences, 45, P17-27. Adams, C., Smith, M. C., Nyquist, L., & Perlmutter, M. (1997). Adult age-group differences in recall for the literal and interpretive meanings of narrative text. Journal of Gerontology: Psychological Sciences, 52B, P187-P195. Baltes, P. B., & Baltes, M. M. (1990). Psychological perspectives on successful aging: The model of selective optimization with compensation. In P. B. Baltes & M. M. Baltes (Eds.), Successful aging (pp. 1-34). New York: Cambridge University Press. Bashore, T. R., Ridderinkhof, K. R., & van der Molen, M. W. (1997). The decline of cognitive processing speed in old age. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 6, 163-169. Britton, B. K., Graesser, A. C., Glynn, S. M., Hamilton, T., & Penland, M. (1983). Use of cognitive capacity in reading: Effects of some content features of text. Discourse Processes, 6, 39-57. Britton, B. K., Holdredge, T. S., Curry, C., & Westbrook, R. D. (1979). Use of cognitive capacity in reading identical texts with different amounts of discourse level meaning. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Learning and Memory, 5, 262-270. Britton, B., & Tesser, A. (1982). Effects of prior knowledge on use of cognitive capacity in three complex cognitive tasks. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 21, 421-436. Bryan, J., & Luszcz, M. A. (1996). Speed of information processing as a mediator between age and free-recall performance. Psychology and Aging, 11, 3-9. Carpenter, P. A., & Just, M. A. (1989). The role of working memory in language comprehension. In D. Klahr & K. Kotovsky (Eds.), Complex information processing: The impact of Herbert A. Simon (pp. 3 1-68). Hillsdale: Erlbaum.
72
Chiesi, H., Spilich, G., & Voss, J. (1979). Acquisition of domain-related information in relation to high and low domain knowledge. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 18, 257-273 Chinen, A. (1989). In the ever after. Wilmette, IL: Chiron. Cohen, G., & Faulkner, D. (1981). Memory for discourse in old age. Discourse Processes, 4,253-265. Craik, F. I. M., & Jennings, J. M. (1992). Human memory. In F. I. M. Craik & T. A. Salthouse (Eds.), The handbook of aging and cognition (pp. 51-110). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum. Ericsson, K. A., & Charness, N. (1994). Expert performance: Its structure and acquisition. American Psychologist, 49, 725-747. Ericsson, K. A., & Kintsch, W. (1995). Long-term working memory. Psychological Review, 102, 211-245. Gernsbacher, M. A., Goldsmith, H. H., & Robertson, R. R. W. (1992). Do readers mentally represent characters' emotional states? Cognition and Emotion, 6, 89111. Haberlandt, K. (1984). Components of sentence and word reading times. In D. E. Kieras & M. A. Just (Eds.), New methods in reading comprehension research (pp. 219-251). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum. Haberlandt, K., & Graesser, A. C. (1989). Buffering new information during reading. Discourse Processes, 12, 479-494. Haberlandt, K. F., Graesser, A. C., Schneider, N. J., & Kiely, J. (1986). Effects of task and new arguments on word reading times. Journal of Memory and Language, 25, 3 14-322. Hartley, J. T., Stojack, C. C., Mushaney, T. J., Annon, T. A. K., & Lee, D. W. (1994). Reading speed and prose memory in older and younger adults. Psychology and Aging, 9, 216-223. Jagacinski, R. J., Liao, M., & Fayyad, E. A. (1995). Generalized slowing in sidusoidal tracking in older adults. Psychology and Aging, 10, 8-19. Just, M. A., & Carpenter, P. A. (1980). A theory of reading: From eye fixations to comprehension. Psychological Review, 87, 329-354. Just, M. A., Carpenter, P. A., & Wooley, J. D. (1982). Paradigms and processes in reading comprehension. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 111, 228-238. Kahneman, D. (1973). Attention and effort. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, Inc. Kemper, S. (1992). Language and aging. In F. I. M. Craik & T. A. Salthouse (Eds.), The handbook of aging and cognition (pp. 213-270). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum. Kintsch, W. (1994). Text comprehension, memory, and learning. American Psychologist, 49, 294-303. Kintsch, W. (1998). Comprehension: A paradigm for cognition. New York: Cambridge University Press. Kintsch, W., & Keenan, J. M. (1973). Reading rate and retention as a function of the number of propositions in the base structure of sentences. Cognitive Psychology, 5, 257-274.
73
Kintsch, W., & van Dijk, T. A. (1978). Toward a model of text comprehension and production. Psychological Review, 85, 363-394. Knight, G. P. (1984). A survey of some important techniques and issues in multiple regression. In D. E. Kieras & M. A. Just (Eds.), New methods in reading comprehension research. (pp. 13-30). Hillsdale, N. J.: Erlbaum. Light, L. L., & Capps, J. L. (1986). Comprehension of pronouns in younger and older adults. Developmental Psychology, 22, 580-585. Lorch, R. F., & Myers, J. L. (1990). Regression analyses of repeated measures data in cognitive research. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 16, 149-157. Mandler, J. M., & Johnson, N. S. (1977). Remembrance of things parsed: Story structure and recall. Cognitive Psychology, 9, 111-151. Miller, L. M. S. (in preparation). The effects of real-world knowledge on text processing among older adults. Miller, L. M. S., & Stine-Morrow, E. A. L. (1998). Aging and the effects of knowledge on on-line reading strategies. Journal of Gerontology: Psychological Sciences, 53B, P223-P233. Morrow, D. G., Stine-Morrow, E. A. L., Leirer, V. O., Andrassy, J. M., & Kahn, J. (1997). The role of reader age and focus of attention in creating situation models from narratives. Journal of Gerontology: Psychological Sciences, 52B, P73-P80. Morrow, D. G., Greenspan, S. L., & Bower, G. H. (1987). Accessibility and situation models in narrative comprehension. Journal of Memory and Language, 26, 165-187 Myerson, J., Hale, S., Wagstaff, D., Poon, L. W., & Smith, G. A. (1990). The information loss model: A mathematical theory of age-related cognitive slowing. Psychological Review, 97, 475-487. Radvansky, G., Gerard, L., Zacks, R., & Hasher, L. (1990). Younger and older adults' use of mental models as representations for text materials. Psychology and Aging, 5, 209-214. Radvansky, G. A., & Curiel, J. M. (1998). Narrative comprehension and aging: The fact of completed goal information. Psychology and Aging, 13, 69-79. Ratner, H. H., Schell, D., Crimmins, A., Mittelman, D., & Baldinelli, L. (1987). Changes in adults' prose recall: Aging or cognitive demand? Developmental Psychology, 23, 521-525. Rinck, M., & Bower, G. H. (1995). Anaphora resolution and the focus of attention in situation models. Journal of Memory and Language, 34, 110- 131. Salthouse, T. A. (1988a). Resource-reduction interpretations of cognitive aging. Developmental Review, 8, 1-35. Salthouse, T. A. (1988b). The role of processing resources in cognitive aging. In M. L. Howe & C. Brainerd (Eds.), Cognitive development in adulthood (Vol. Springer-Verlag, pp. 185-239): New York. Salthouse, T. A. (1996). The processing-speed theory of adult age differences in cognition. Psychological Review, 103, 403-428.
74
Schaie, K. W. (1996). Intellectual development in adulthood. In J. E. Birren & K. W. Schaie (Eds.), Handbook of the psychology of aging (Fourth edition) (pp. 266-286). Boston: Academic Press. Shah, R., & Miyake, A. (1996). The separability of working memory resources for spatial thinking and language processing: An individual differences approach. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 125,4-27. Sharkey, N., & Sharkey, A. (1987). What is the point of facilitation? The loci of knowledge-based facilitation in sentence processing. Journal of Memory and Language, 26,255-276. Soederberg, L. M., & Stine, E. A. L. (1995). Activation of emotion information in text among younger and older adults. Journal of Adult Development, 2, 253270. Sommers, M. S. (1996). The structural organization of the mental lexicon and its contribution to age-related declines in spoken-word recognition. Psychology and Aging, 11, 333-341. Spilich, G., Vesonder, G., Chiesi, H., & Voss, J. (1979). Text processing of domainrelated information for individuals with high and low domain knowledge. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 18, 275-290. Stine, E. A. L. (1990). On-line processing of written text by younger and older adults. Psychology and Aging, 5,68-78. Stine, E. A. L., Cheung, H., & Henderson, D. T. (1995). Adult age differences in the on-line processing of new concepts in discourse. Aging and Cognition, 2, 1-18. Stine, E. A. L., & Hindman, J. (1994). Age differences in reading time allocation for propositionally dense sentences. Aging and Cognition, 1, 2-16. Stine, E. A. L., Soederberg, L. M., & Morrow, D. G. (1996). Language and discourse processing through adulthood. In F. Blanchard-Fields & T. M. Hess (Eds.), Perspectives on cognition in adulthood and aging (pp. 255-290). New York: McGraw-Hill. Stine, E. A. L., & Wingfield, A. (1987). Levels upon levels: Predicting age differences in text recall. Experimental Aging Research, 13, 179-183. Stine, E. A. L., & Wingfield, A. (1990). The assessment of qualitative age differences in discourse processing. In T. M. Hess (Ed.), Aging and cognition: Knowledge organization and utilization (pp. 33-92). New York: Elsevier. Stine-Morrow, E. A. L., Loveless, M. K., & Soederberg, L. M. (1996). Resource allocation in on-line reading by younger and older adults. Psychology and Aging, 11,475-486. Tun, P. A. (1989). Age differences in processing expository and narrative texts. Journal of Gerontology: Psychological Sciences, 44, P9-P15. van Dijk, T. A., & Kintsch, W. (1983). Strategies of discourse comprehension. New York: Academic Press. Voss, J., Vesonder, G., & Spilich, G. (1980). Text generation and recall by highknowledge and low-knowledge individuals. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 19, 651-667 West, R. F., Stanovich, K. E., & Cunningham, A. E. (1995). Compensatory processes in reading. In R. A. Dixon & L. Bäckman (Eds.), Compensating for
75
psychological deficits and declines: Managing losses and promoting gains (pp. 275-296). Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum. Wingfield, A., & Stine-Morrow, E. A. L. (in press). Language and speech. In F. I. M. Craik & T. A. Salthouse (Eds.), Handbook of aging and cognition (Second edition). Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum. Zabrucky, K., & Moore, D. (1994). Contributions of working memory and evaluation and regulation of understanding to adults' recall of texts. Journal of Gerontology: Psychological Sciences, 49, P201-P212. Zwann, R. A. (1994). Effect of genre expectations on text comprehension. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 20, 920-933. Zwann, R. A., Langston, M. C., & Graesser, A. C. (1995a). The construction of situation models in narrative comprehension: An event-indexing model. Psychological Science, 6, 292-297. Zwann, R. A., Magliano, J. P., & Graesser, A. C. (1995b). Dimensions of situation model construction in narrative comprehension. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 21, 386-397. Zwann, R. A., & Radvansky, G. A. (1998). Situation models in language comprehension and memory. Psychological Bulletin, 123, 162-185.
76
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors’ research described in this chapter was conducted with the support of grants R01 AG13935 and F31 MH10937. We thank Steve Moynihan and Ken Bell for help with data collection. The first author is indebted to the Merrill Advanced Studies Institute and the participants in the Sedona workshop for a unique and stimulating intellectual experience.
Part 2
CONSTRAINTS ON LANGUAGE: MEMORY
This page intentionally left blank.
4L
IMITATIONS ON SYNTACTIC PROCESSING Susan Kemper and Karen A. Kemtes
GENERAL MODELS
OF
PRODUCTION
AND
COMPREHENSION
There has been far too little research on how aging affects many aspects of language production or processing. For instance, little is known about how aging affects speech errors at syntactic, semantic, and phonological levels; how word order variation, quantifier scope, and attachment ambiguities are affected by normal and pathological aging; and how discourse planning may show positive (Burke, 1997; James, Burke, Austin, & Hulme, 1998) as well as negative effects (Arbuckle & Gold, 1993) of normal aging. One of the most well-established age-related changes to cognition is the loss of working memory capacity (Salthouse, 1991). Although exceptions have often been reported, older adults commonly perform less well on tests of digit or word span as well as on more demanding tests of reading or listening span and computational span. It is not surprising, therefore, that age-related changes to working memory have been linked to age-related differences in language processing. A central hypothesis has been that working memory limitations affect older adults' ability to process hierarchically structure, particularly syntactic constructions involving embedded and subordinate clauses (Kemper, 1992). This hypothesis, thus, challenges two issues of central importance to psycholinguistics, the modularity hypothesis and claims about the serial nature of language processing. Psycholinguistic models of language production and comprehension have tended to focus on two issues: (1) the modularity of syntactic, semantic, and/or pragmatic processes and (2) serial versus hierarchical accounts of language production and comprehension (Balota, d’Arcais, & Rayner, 1990; Bock, 1987; Dell, 1986; Frazier & Fodor, 1978; Garrett, 1988; Kintsch, & van Dijk, 1978; MacKay, 1987; McClelland & Rumelhart, 1981; Rayner & Pollatsek, 1989; Seidenberg, 1989; Seidenberg & McClelland, 1989; Trabasso & van den Broek, 1985). Modularity (Fodor, 1982) or autonomy theory holds that message production involves a sequence of comprehension stages or levels. Typically four properties 79
80
are ascribed to this sequence of processing stages: (1) each stage corresponds to a distinct linguistic rule system, (2) each stage involves a discrete representational system; (3) processing flows unidirectionally through the sequence of stages, and (4) each stage may be characterized by independent constraints on the rules, representations, or processing operations at that stage. Although messages are produced “one word at a time” (Bloom, 1975), message structure is inherently hierarchical. A number of phenomena are typically discussed to illustrate this tension between serial and hierarchical aspects of language: (i) in English, datives and objects can alternate in the linear sequence for some verbs such as give (compare Mary gave a cookie to me to Mary gave me a cookie) but not for others such as donate (Mary donated a million dollars to me versus Mary donated me a million dollars); (ii) verbs must agree with their subjects in person and number; this constraint is violated in Efforts to make English the official language is gaining strength throughout the U. S. (The New Yorker, November 17, 1986, p. 94); although the verb "is gaining" agrees with the immediately preceding noun language, the grammatical subject of the sentence is the plural noun "efforts"; (iii) the interpretation of the scope of quantifiers also is influenced by word-order variation and clause embedding. Compare Everyone in this room speaks two languages to Two languages are spoken by everyone in this room. Whereas the first sentence implies only that each individual is fluent in two languages, the second implies that they are fluent in the same two languages; (iv) ambiguities can arise whenever the linear sequence can be assigned to multiple hierarchical structures. The sequence The boy chased the dog with two bones could be interpreted as indicating that the boy had two bones by attaching the prepositional phrase to the verb phrase ([[chased V] [the dog NP] [with two bones PP] VP]) or that the dog had two bones by attaching the prepositional phrase to the object noun phrase ([[chased V] [the dog [with two bones PP] NP] VP]); (v) complexity increases as clauses and phrases are hierarchically embedded in left-branching or center-embedded structures as in The man the woman the boy saw knew died compared to right-branching (The boy saw the woman who knew the man who died) or serially connected (The boy saw the woman, she knew the man, and he died) structures. Processing models have in common the idea that messages are represented at a number of levels. Processing models vary with respect to how these comprehension processes are implemented (cf. Balota, D'Arcais, & Rayner, 1980, or Gernsbacher, 1990, for detailed discussions of processing models). Most models assume that there are a number of autonomous levels of processing including: orthographic or acoustic levels since the individual words must be recognized from the incoming visual or auditory signal; a level at which lexical information (e.g., category, meaning) for each word is accessed; a syntactic level in which individual words are formed into a hierarchy of syntactic constituents; a semantic level at which meaning relations within and between words are determined; and a propositional level of message meaning. Specific models do differ with regards to how these levels are arranged and how information flows between levels. For example, modular models of language comprehension (e.g., Frazier & Fodor, 1978) propose that
81
comprehension involves a series of discrete and sequential stages of processing: signal decoding (auditory or visual), lexical access, syntactic analysis, semantic analysis, and discourse analysis. In contrast, interactive models of language comprehension (e.g., McClelland & Rumelhart, 198 1) posit that the various stages of analysis occur in parallel and are interactive. Processing models of text structure tend to differ from processing models for individual sentences by focusing on the underlying message representation of a discourse or text (cf. Kintsch and van Dijk, 1978; Mandler & Johnson, 1977; Meyer, 1975; Trabasso, & van den Broek, 1985). Central to text structure models is the idea that messages are decomposed into hierarchically ordered propositionbased idea units during processing. These models generally outline methods for determining the microlevel relations between word units within a text and relating the temporal and causal connections between these idea units. For example, Mandler and Johnson's story grammar approach (1977) views message analysis in terms of an underlying story schema which is used to focus information for comprehension or recall. The structure of the story grammar is tree-based with nodes referring to various constituents (states and events) and branches referring to the causal or temporal connections between constituent nodes. The structure also interacts with general world knowledge as to how stories are constructed (the notions of schema or scripts). These transformational rules are generative in nature and are not specific to the semantic content of the text. In Kintsch and van Dijk's model (1978), text comprehension involves several stages: a text is first decomposed into propositions, propositions are arranged into a hierarchy ranging from the most general propositions to the most detailed, and the propositional hierarchy is stored in memory. Meyer's (1985) model of prose analysis focuses on the logical relationships between the 'micropropositional" level of text, which relates information within and between sentences; the "macropropositional" level of text, which focuses on how text is organized (i. e., gist) and relates logical and causal connections within text; and the top-level structure of text which focuses on the global representation of the text. AGING, WORKING MEMORY,
AND
SYNTACTIC PROCESSING
Within cognitive psychology, working memory is viewed as a limited-capacity storage and processing mechanism. Baddeley (1986) conceived of working memory as involving a central executive, which schedules and assigns processing tasks, and two temporary storage buffers -- an articulatory loop which retains phonological information for subsequent processing and a visual scratch pad which preserves visual information. Similar limited capacity components are commonly included in formal models of syntactic parsing mechanisms (Gibson, Pearlmutter, CansecoGonzales, 1996; Gibson, Schultze, & Salomon, 1996; Lewis, 1996); linguistic analyses place great demands on working memory whenever the amount of information to be processed exceeds working memory's capacity, perhaps by overloading the articulatory loop, or whenever the processing operations themselves, such as those required to parse complex syntactic structures, are excessive and thus over-load the central executive.
82
Working memory limitations have been commonly assumed to account for a wide range of age-related linguistic phenomena including age-related changes to spontaneous production. Although sentence length in words remains constant, older adults show a reduction in their use of complex syntactic constructions such as those involving subordinate and embedded clauses. (Benjamin, 1988; Cooper, 1990; Davis, 1984; Kemper, 1992; Kemper, Kynette, Rash, Sprott, & O’Brien, 1989; Kemper, Rash, Kynette, & Norman, 1990; Kynette & Kemper, 1986; Shewan & Henderson, 1988; Ulatowska, Freedman-Stern, Weiss-Doyle, Macaluso-Haynes, & North, 1983; Walker, Roberts, & Hedrick, 1988.) Kemper (1987a) analyzed the incidence of different types of embedded clauses in both a longitudinal sample and a cohort-sequential sample of adults’ writings taken from diary entries. The longitudinal record spanned seven decades; the cohort-sequential sample contrasted adults born in the 1820s with those born in the 1860s for diary entries made when the adults were in their 40s versus in their 80s. The primary finding was the overall complexity of the adults’ writing declined across the life-span; 70 and 80-year olds produce few sentences with embedded clauses, especially left-branching embeddings. In spontaneous speech, older adults favor coordinate or rightbranching constructions, e.g., She’s awfully young to be running a nursery school for our church, over left-branching constructions, e.g., The gal who runs a nursery school for our church is awfully young. During the production of the left-branching constructions (in which the embedded clause occurs to the left of the main clause), the form of the subject “the gal” must be retained and the grammatical form of the main clause verb “is” (which must agree with its subject in person and number) must be anticipated while the embedded clause “who runs a nursery school for our church” is being produced. Each clause is produced sequentially in the rightbranching construction (in which the embedded clause occurs to the right of the main clause). This asymmetry between left- and right-branching constructions has been assumed to reflect working memory limitations on the production of leftbranching constructions. Kemper et al. (1989) reported that the mean number of clauses per utterance (MCU), a general measure of the complexity of adults language, is positively correlated with the adults backward digit span using the WAIS subtest (Wechsler, 1958). Further, Kemper and Rash (1988) calculated Yngve depth (Yngve, 1960), a measure of the working memory demands of sentence production, and found that it was positively correlated with WAIS digit span as well as with MCU. This line of research, therefore, supports the hypothesis that working memory limitations may affect older adults’ production of complex syntactic constructions. Kemper and her colleagues have also investigated the role of working memory in limiting adults’ processing of complex syntactic constructions. Kemper (1987b) tested adults’ ability to imitate sentences containing different kinds of embedded sentences. The embedded clauses varied in length and locus. The sentences also varied in grammaticality. Whereas the elderly adults, 70 to 89 years of age, were able to imitate the short sentences correctly, they were unable to imitate the long sentences or sentences with a left-branching embedding as in Baking ginger cookies tires me out. The older adults tended to recall either the first clause, as in “I was baking ginger cookes” or the second clause “The cookies tired me“ but not both.
83
The young, college-aged adults were able to imitate the sentences correctly regardless of length, embedding, or grammaticality. Kemper suggested that aging impairs adults' syntactic processing by limiting how many different grammatical operations can be simultaneously performed. Kemper and Rash (1988) and Norman, Kemper, and Kynette (1992) have suggested that working memory limitations on syntactic processing also contribute to older adults' text processing problems by increasing processing demands whenever multiple syntactic constituents must be simultaneously analyzed and interrelated. Norman et al. (1992) compared older adults' text processing comprehension and rates for texts which varied in syntactic complexity but not in content. The most complex version of each text was characterized by many embedded clauses that preceded or modified the sentence subject: "By 1888 with the spreading of civilization, coast-to-coast railroad tracks, which had been laid across the country, replaced the wagon trains. The surveyors marked off farmland to discourage freegrazing. Land which had belonged to the frontier was now owned by settlers with families. The Old West was a thing of the past." In contrast, the simplest version was made of one-clause sentences: "By 1888 civilization had spread from coast to coast. Railroad tracks were laid across the country. They replaced the wagon trains. The surveys marked off farmland. This discouraged freegrazing. Land no longer belonged to the frontier. Settlers with families now owned the land. The Old West was a thing of the past." Norman et al.(1992) demonstrated that older adults' text comprehension and reading speed declined as syntactic complexity increased and concluded that the use of embedded clauses, particularly those modifying the sentence subject, impairs older adults' reading comprehension. Other evidence also supported the hypothesis that working memory limitations affect older adults' processing of linguistic information. For example, Light, Capps, Singh, & Albertson Owens (1985), following Light and Capps (1986) and Light and Singh (1987), found that older adults are less likely to establish the referent of a pronoun when linguistic information intervenes between the pronoun and its antecedent as in "John stood watching while Henry jumped across a ravine. The ground was rocky and uneven that only goats used this path. There were no flowers but a few weeds grew here and there. He fell in the river." although they can do so in when little information intervenes, as in "Henry spoke at a meeting while John drove to the beach. He brought along a surfboard." A similar conclusion was drawn by Zurif, Swinney, Prather, Wingfield, and Brownell (1995) from a study of older adults' on-line processing of object-and subject-relative sentences using a cross-modal priming task. In object-relative sentences, the object 'moves' from the object position of the subordinate clause and leaves a 'gap' or trace (e.g., The tailor hemmed the cloaki that the actor from the studio needed (ti) for the performance). In subject-relative sentences, the gap is indexed by the object of the matrix clause (e.g., The gymnast loved the professori from the Northwestern city who (ti) complained about the bad coffee). The focus of their analysis was to determine whether reactivation of the antecedent occurs at the gap during sentence processing. Zurif et al. found that older adults evidenced priming for the subject- but not object-relative sentences (experiment 1). In a
84
second experiment, Zurif et al. reduced the distance between gap and antecedent in object-relativesentences from seven or eight intervening words to five and found a significant priming effect at the gap position. The authors conclude that older adults reactivate the antecedent when the distance between antecedent and gap is short. Zurif et al. do not report a direct comparison of young and old but interpret their results as showing that older adults’ immediate syntactic analysis of a sentence is affected by working memory limitations that affect the retention of antecedents. Working memory limitations also affect adults’ metalinguistic judgments about the grammaticality of sentences. Pye, Cheung, and Kemper (1992) found that adults of all ages are able to detect violations of grammatical rules as in *Whom did you see the woman from the apartment house next door and? or *John is expected the woman from the city treasurer’s office to help. However, older adults, particularly those in their 80s, also rated some grammatical sentences as ungrammatical. For example, You saw the woman from the apartment house next door and whom? and The woman from the city treasurer's office is expected to help John are grammatical although the older adults typically rated these sentences as ungrammatical. Kemper (1997) also examined metalinguistic judgments of older adults as well as adults with Alzheimer’s disease. Two types of sentences were tested: the first type of sentences tested linguistic constraints on phrase structure, such as the contrast in acceptability for Jane gave the library a book versus Jane donated the library a book or The bed was slept on by Washington versus Tuesday was slept on by Washington. Young adults and healthy older adults tended to reject as acceptable the sentences which violated linguistic constraints on phrase structure whereas adults with Alzheimer’s disease tended to find Jane donated the library a book and Tuesday was slept on by Washington to be acceptable. This finding suggests that adults with Alzheimer’s disease are not sensitive to subtle aspects of verb meaning which regulate their use in various phrase structures. The second type of sentence Kemper tested involved linguistic constraints on transformations of linguistic structure. Some alternative forms of sentences can be legitimately derived whereas others are blocked by linguistic constraints. Both The fact is irrelevant that John gave Bill all his old books and The fact that John gave Bill all his old books is irrelevant are permitted whereas The fact that John gave Bill is irrelevant all his old books is blocked by a linguistic constraint. Kemper found that young adults’ metalinguistic judgments match the predictions of linguistic theory whereas older adults and adults with Alzheimer’s disease tend to find all three variants to be acceptable. This pattern was correlated with working memory capacity, suggesting that the older adults and adults with Alzheimer’s disease were unable to fully process the long, multi-clause sentences due to working memory limitations; hence, they were unable to detect the violation of the linguistic constraint. At least part of the observed age-related decrements in language processing and working memory may be due to age-related slowing of phonological or articulatory processes. Kynette, Kemper, Norman, Cheung, and Anagnopoulos (1990) have confirmed a link between adults’ word span and word repetition rates (Hulme, Thomson, Muir, & Lawrence, 1984; Schweickert & Boruff, 1986). Elderly adults are able to recall as much as they can say in approximately 1.2 seconds; thus word span, as well as word repetition rates, for short one-syllable words exceed
85
those for longer two- or three-syllable words. This relationship between word span and word repetition is stable across the life-span and appears to be an accurate index of the capacity/duration of the articulatory loop component of working memory. A similar account of some forms of childhood reading impairments has been recently put forth by Crain and Shankweiler (1988, 1990) and Gathercole and Baddeley (1989, 1990). Crain and Shankweiler (1988, 1990) note that poor readers lag behind good readers in their comprehension of complex syntactic structures such as relative clauses and that poor readers also evidence a variety of working memory limitations, especially those involving phonological analysis. Language processing deficits, including reading disorders in childhood and syntactic processing limitations in late adulthood, may arise whenever sentences impose severe processing demands on working memory. IN SUPPORT
OF
WORKING MEMORY LIMITATIONS
ON
SYNTACTIC PROCESSING
Much of the evidence for attributing age-related differences in language production and comprehension to working memory limitations hinges on a contrast between left-branching and right-branching syntactic constructions. Left-branching constructions are generally assumed to be more difficult to process than rightbranching ones. One classic parsing model, the so-called Sausage Machine, of Frazier and Fodor (1978) involves two parsing stages: a limited-capacity first stage parser and an unlimited second stage parser. The model explains the asymmetry in the processing left- and right-branching clauses as arising from the restriction of the first-stage parser to the analysis of six or so words at a time. The first-stage parser attempts to form meaningful grammatical constituents from each group of six words. These constituents are then assembled into clauses by the second stage parser. Sometimes the first-stage parser is not successful or the constituents it forms are not correct; the second-stage parser must then re-analyze the words into the correct constituents. Left-branching clauses which exceed the capacity of the first-stage parser will trigger such re-analysis. For example, the first-stage parser will initially (incorrectly) analyze the center-embedded left-branching sentence The man the woman the girl knew cursed died as a six-word coordinate noun phrase followed by a six-word coordinate verb phrase. The second stage parser must break up these constituents and re-analyze the input in order to correctly pair each noun phrase with the appropriate verb. No such re-analysis is required for the right-branching sentence The girl knew the woman who cursed the man who died. The first stage parser will supply the correct constituents, segmenting the first group of words into two noun phrases and a verb and the second group of six words into three noun phrases and two verbs. These constituents can then be readily assembled into clauses by the second stage parser. This parsing model can be naturally extended to account for the effects of aging on syntactic processing. Yngve (1960) suggested Miller's (1962) "7+2" as a candidate for the maximum depth of spoken sentences and that "a depth factor in language change should be easily observable..." (p. 452). Aging may provide just such a "depth factor" by imposing a lower limit on the depth of constituent structures which can be produced. Reducing maximum depth to "5+2" would
86
effectively restrict the production of most left-branching constructions as well as limit the production of other constructions involving, e.g., elaborated noun phrases, prepositional phrases, and auxiliary verb sequences. Reducing the capacity of the first stage parser in the Frazier and Fodor model would produce a similar effect on sentence comprehension. If the first stage parser was restricted to operating, not on six words at a time, but on four words at a time, comprehension of most leftbranching constructions would be disrupted. Although more contemporary parsing models are available, constraints and limitations are incorporated in most in an explicit attempt to account for the difficulty of parsing complexity structures such as center-embedded sentences (see Lewis, 1996, for a review) as constituent "look-ahead" buffers holding to-beanalyzed information may be constrained or temporary memory stores or stacks holding partially analyzed constituents. Formal models of the architecture of human cognition such as SOAR (Laird, Newell, & Rosenbloom, 1987; Newell, 1990) and EPIC (Meyer & Kieras, 1997 a, b) are explicitly designed to incorporate working memory limitations on syntactic processing. According to such parsing models, working memory limitations on syntactic processing should affect a variety of different types of constructions. EXTENDING
THE
HYPOTHESIS
Kemtes and Kemper (1997) sought further support for the hypothesis that agerelated working memory limitations affect syntactic processing by examining on-line reading times for wh-questions. Two wh-question types were chosen for testing: argument questions, e.g., Who did John ask how to paint?, and adjunct questions, e.g., When did John ask how to paint? These types of wh-questions raise significant issues for models of syntactic processing that assume working memory limitations constrain the analysis of complex constructions (Gibson et al., 1996 a & b; Lewis, 1996). Like the filler-gap constructions examined by Zurif et al. (1995), processing wh-questions requires the reader to detect and fill-in a gap; the presence of the gap is signaled by the wh-word, e.g., "who" or "when," which also provides semantic information about the missing element. The gaps can occur at multiple sites associated with either the main verb of the sentence, "ask," or the embedded verb, "to paint." The distinction between argument questions and adjunct questions arises from current linguistic theories of verb structure (Grimshaw, 1991): verbs are classified according to how many arguments, or obligatory constituents, they require. Verb arguments include subjects, direct objects, and, for some verbs, indirect objects or other verbal complements. A verb such as ask requires three arguments: the subject who does the asking, the direct object who is asked, and a verbal complement, the question itself. A verb such as see only requires two arguments, a subject and a direct object (DO). Adjuncts are optional constituents usually conveyed by prepositional phrases, that indicate time or manner. Who and what typically query verb arguments, how, when, and where typically query verb adjuncts. Of particular interest is whether there are age differences in the interpretation of argument and adjunct questions. Older adults were predicted to have more difficulty comprehending adjunct questions because older adults'
87
working memory limitations should make processing optional elements such as adjuncts more difficult. A particular type of wh-question is ambiguous. Who did John ask to paint? has two interpretations. In the first, sometimes called the "'upstairs" interpretation, who is interpreted as referring to the DO of the verb ask In the second interpretation, sometimes called the "downstairs" interpretation, who refers to the DO of the verb paint. Although some details remain under dispute, the relevant linguistic theory (Chomsky, 1986) holds that the wh-word originates as the argument to a verb, in this case as the direct object (DO) of either the verb ask or the verb paint. The wh-word is then raised up from the verb to the front of the sentence in a series of steps or cycles. An intervening wh-word will block this process and permit only an "upstairs" interpretation: How did John ask who to paint? is not ambiguous. This question can only be interpreted as a "how" question about John's asking (e.g., the answer might be "by telephone" not "by using a spray gun"). However, the linguistic constraint is more complicated since Who did John ask how to paint? is ambiguous. It can be interpreted as a "who" question referring to the DO of "ask" (the upstairs interpretation) or as a "who" question referring to the DO of "paint" (the downstairs interpretation). The difference lies in the nature of the intervening wh-word: who is an argument, an obligatory complement of the verb, whereas how is an adjunct, an optional complement to the verb. Arguments can be raised up, jumping past adjuncts, as in Who did John ask how to paint? but adjuncts cannot be raised up past arguments, blocking the downstairs interpretation of How did John ask who to paint? Research by de Villiers and her colleagues (de Villiers, 1996) has shown that very young children recognize the ambiguity of Who did John ask to paint? and produce answers consistent with either the upstairs interpretation or the downstairs interpretation and find How did John ask who to paint? to be unambiguous, producing only upstairs answers. Children do, on occasion, produce an interesting error, interpreting a wh-question with an intervening wh-word, as in Who did John ask how to paint? as a "how" question. Thus, for children, Who did John ask how to paint? is three-ways ambiguous, permitting an upstairs interpretation, e.g., who did John ask?, a downstairs interpretation, e.g., who did John paint?, and a second downstairs interpretation, how did John paint? The metalinguistic study of Pye, Cheung, and Kemper (1992) suggested that such knowledge of linguistic constraints may be offset in late adulthood by working memory limitations on the processing of complex sentences. Consequently, older adults were predicted to be unable to derive both interpretations of Who did John ask to paint? or Who did John ask how to paint? and to prefer either an upstairs interpretation or the downstairs interpretation. To validate the questions and answers, a preliminary study was conducted using an answer acceptability ratings task. Young and older adults read the stories and a question about each story. Each question was paired with two answers. Each answer corresponded to a different interpretation of the question. Participants were asked to rate the plausibility of the answer on a Likert-based scale where 1 = Not very plausible and 5 = Very plausible. In agreement with linguistic theory, the argument questions were ambiguous with two plausible answers and an intervening
88
adjunct rendered the argument adjunct questions unambiguous. Adjunct questions were also unambiguously interpreted by both young and older adults. All participants completed four working memory-based measures in the experiment. The first two tasks, the WAIS-R (Wechsler, 1981) forward and backward digit spans, were included as measures of short-term memory processing. Participants also completed a reading span task which was based on the original Daneman and Carpenter (1980) reading span task and is reported in Kemtes and Kemper (1997). In the reading span task, participants are required to read aloud progressively longer sets of sentences without pausing and then recall the sentencefinal word from each sentence in the set. The reading span score was defined as the highest level at which participants correctly recalled all of the words from two of the three sets. Participants received an additional half point if they correctly recalled one of the three sets from the next highest level. Finally, participants completed a listening span task (Salthouse, Babcock, & Shaw, 1991). In the listening span task, individuals were required to listen to progressively longer sets of short sentences and answer a short question after each sentence. At the end of each level, individuals recalled the sentence-final words in their presented order. The listening span score was defined as the highest level (of six) at which participants correctly recalled all of the words from three of the five sets. Participants received an additional half point if they correctly recalled one of the three sets from the next highest level. Composite working memory scores were formed using the four measures described above. In order to form a composite score that accurately reflected the relative contribution of the four measures used, we conducted a confirmatory factor analysis with a single working memory latent variable. The working memory composite weighted each score on the individual measure according to its association with the working memory factor. Based on a medium split of these composite working memory scores, performed separately for each age group, participants were assigned to either a high-span or a low-span group. High span young adults had an average composite score of 28.5 ( SD = 2.9) whereas low span young adults had an average composite score of 23.8 ( SD = 2.7). Composite scores for the older adults were lower: high span older adults had an average composite score of 22.0 ( SD= 4.7) and low span older adults had an average composite score of 15.5 ( SD = 2.5). The high and low span young and older adults were tested on their comprehension of wh-questions using a word-by-word reading time procedure. The wh-questions tested their comprehension of short stories. Each story followed the same sequence: sentence one introduced the main character and a "how to..." verb; the second sentence introduced the day of the event and two additional characters: the individual to whom the question was addressed and the subject of the query; sentence three repeated the "how to..." action; and the final sentence restated the main character's name and the main action. Four wh-questions were prepared for each story. See (1). Two argument questions beginning with who or what and two adjunct questions beginning with when or how were prepared for each story. Argument questions were of the form "Who did PERSON ask to VERB2?," e.g., Who did John ask to paint? There are two possible answers: who can be interpreted as the DO of
89
ask or the DO of VERB2. An adjunct was inserted into the question to create an argument-adjunct question of the form "Who did PERSON ask how to VERB2?," e.g., Who did John ask how to paint? The question is also ambiguous: it can be interpreted as a who question about the DO of ask or as a who question about the DO of VERB2 since the intervening adjunct how does not block the second interpretation. There is also a third possibility, as some children in the deVillers et al. (1990) study interpreted Who did PERSON ask how to VERB2? as a how question. The adjunct questions were of the form "When did PERSON ask ______ to VERB2?" and the blank could be filled by either an argument, e.g., When did John ask who to paint? or by an adjunct, e.g., When did John ask how to paint? In contrast to the argument question, the adjunct questions should be unambiguously interpreted as when questions about ask Linguistic constraints should block the second interpretation of the adjunct-argument questions as a who question about the DO of VERB2. The downstairs reading of the adjunct adjunct questions should also be blocked so that When did John ask how to paint? should be unambiguously interpreted as a when question about ask (1) Example Story and Questions. A Trace, t, is inserted to Indicate where Answers Originate in the Underlying Structure of the Questions. John is a student in a community art program and is learning how to paint by rotating a brush. On Monday, John was eager to start and asked the instructor if he could paint the class model. John then asked the instructor how to rotate the brush. Finally, John was ready to paint. Argument Questions: Who did John ask t1 to paint t2? Upstairs Interpretation: Who refers to t1 such that John asked the person (i.e., the instructor) a question Downstairs Interpretation: Who refers to t2 such that John asked to paint this person (i.e., the model) Argument Adjunct Questions: Who did John ask t1 how to paint t2 t3? Upstairs Interpretation: Who refers to t1 such that John asked the person (i.e., the instructor) a question Downstairs Interpretation: Who refers to t3 such that John asked to paint this person (i.e., the model) *Optional Downstairs Interpretation: How refers to t2 the method (i.e., by rotating brush) by which John executed the painting. Adjunct Argument Questions: When did John ask t1 who to paint t2? Upstairs Interpretation: When refers to t1 the time (i.e., on Monday) at which John asked the question *Blocked Downstairs Interpretation: Who refers to t2 such that John asked to paint this person (i.e., the model)
90
Adjunct Adjunct Questions: When did John ask t1 how to paint t2? Upstairs Interpretation: When refers to t1 the time (i.e., on Monday) at which John asked the question *Blocked Downstairs Interpretation: How refers to t2 the method (i.e., by rotating brush) by which John executed the action. Reading times for the questions were collected on a word-by-word basis but analyzed separately for four critical segments. The critical segments corresponding to the initial wh-word, the main clause subject and verb, the intervening wh-word (except for argument questions lacking a intervening wh-word), and the final infinitive phrase, as indicated in (2). (2) Question Type Argument Argument Adjunct Adjunct Argument Adjunct Adjunct
Segment 1
2
3
4
Who Who When When
did John ask did John ask did John ask did John ask
--how who how
to paint? to paint? to paint? to paint?
Separate analyses were performed on the question reading times for each segment. Young adults read segment 1, the initial wh-word, more rapidly than older adults ( M Y = 374, SD Y = 179; M O = 583, SD O = 385) and high span adults read segment 1 more rapidly than low span adults ( M H = 425, SD H = 252; M L = 533, SD L = 313). Young adults also read segment 2 more rapidly than older adults ( M Y = 309, SD Y = 94; M O = 475, SD O = 163) and high span adults read segment 2 more rapidly than low span adults ( M H = 346, SD H = 141; M L = 454, SD L= 123). More critcially, young adults read segment 3, corresponding to the embedded wh-word, more rapidly than older adults and high span adults read the segment more rapidly than low span adults; however, low span young adults read segment 3 as rapidly has high span young adults ( M H = 318, SD H = 244; M L = 334, SD L = 113) whereas low span older adults read more slowly than high span older adults ( M H = 416, SD H = 244; M L = 606, SD L = 275). See Figure 1. Reading times for segment 3 did not differ for the three types of questions containing intervening wh-words. Low span young adults read segment 4 as rapidly has high span young adults ( M H = 404, SD H = 390; M L = 461, SD L = 304) whereas low span older adults read more slowly than high span older adults ( M H = 577, SD H = 386; M L = 919, SD L = 482). See Figure 2. Reading times for segment 4 differed for the four types of questions. The final infinitive phrase of adjunct argument questions ( M = 735, SD = 601) was read more slowly than the final infinitive phrase of the other three types of questions ( M = 574, SD = 387). Figure 3 presents the difference scores for the acceptance of the alternative answers to each type of wh-question. The difference scores were calculated for each participant such that positive scores represent a bias for the upstairs interpretation and negative scores represent a bias for the downstairs interpretation. For argument questions, young adults preferred the downstairs answer corresponding to the DO of
91
VERB2 whereas older adults had a slight preference for the upstairs answer corresponding to the DO of ask. For argument adjunct questions, young adults preferred either downstairs interpretation over the upstairs interpretation, whereas older adults preferred the upstairs answer corresponding to the DO of ask over either downstairs interpretation. For adjunct argument questions, young adults again preferred the downstairs answer corresponding to the DO of VERB2 and older adults had a slight preference for the upstairs answer corresponding to the DO of ask. Young adults found both answers to adjunct adjunct questions to be equally acceptable; however, older adults had a preference for the upstairs answer corresponding to the DO of ask. These results suggest that answering complex wh-questions is affected by nonlinguistic biases. Neither pattern of answers is consistent with the predictions based on linguistic theory. Young adults appear to have a bias favoring downstairs interpretations. This downstairs bias renders argument questions unambiguous, over-rides the constraint blocking downstairs interpretations of argument adjunct and adjunct adjunct questions, and prevails over the upstairs interpretation of adjunct argument questions. Older adults appear to have a different bias, one favoring upstairs interpretations: this bias renders argument questions nambiguous and coincides with the "correct" upstairs interpretation of adjunct argument, argument adjunct, and adjunct adjunct questions. One reason young and older adults might have preferred different answers to the complex wh-questions was that the requisite information to answer the questions was not as salient to older adults as it was to the other participants. If older adults remembered the contexts differently, then they might be expected to prefer different answers to the questions. Such an explanation might also account for why the preferred answers differ from those predicted by linguistic theory. For example, if older adults, for example, were unable to recall that a model had been mentioned in the story (see Table 1), they might be unable to answer Who did John paint? producing a bias against the downstairs interpretation of Who did John ask to paint? If so, older adults should prefer different answers to simple wh-questions such as Who did John ask? or Who did John paint? after reading these same stories. To investigate this possibility, a second experiment was conducted using only simple wh-questions. Figure 1. Reading times for segment 3.
92
The results of this second experiment were clear-cut: older and young adults agreed on the preferred answers to the simple wh-questions even during on-line processing. The stories provided the appropriate answers and both young and older adults were able to recall this information when asked to verify answers to the simple wh-questions. These results suggest that the different answer preferences of young and older adults to complex wh-questions reflect qualitatively different interpretations of the questions, not age-differences in understanding or remembering the story information. Although young and older adults were able to answer all four types of questions equally accurately in the second experiment, the reading times for the four types of questions did differ. Simple adjunct questions were more difficult to process than simple argument questions, perhaps because adjuncts are optional verb complements whereas arguments are obligatory elements of the verb phrase. In addition, working memory span affected older adults' processing of simple whquestions as it did their processing of complex wh-questions. The increased reading time required by the older adults, particularly the low span older adults, appears to reflect the demands placed on working memory by the immediate syntactic analysis of the questions. Summary. Answering wh-questions, either simple, one-clause questions such as Who did John ask?, or complex questions such as Who did John ask to paint?, imposes demands on working memory for the processing of semantic and pragmatic information as well as the analysis of the syntax of the question itself. Analyzing some types of wh-questions is more demanding than analyzing other types. Experiment 2 showed that simple adjunct questions asking "how" or "when" something occurred are more difficult to process than simple argument questions about "who" or "what" Figure 2. Reading times for segment 4. was involved and Experiment 1 showed that complex adjunct argument questions of the form When did John ask who to paint? are more difficult to process than other types of complex whquestions. Adjunct questions query optional verb phrase complements, whereas argument questions query obligatory verb complements such as subjects and direct objects and this contrast between
93
optional and obligatory complements apparently affects the speed with which the underlying syntax of a question can determined. Older adults with limited working memory spans, as indexed by a composite factor score obtained from multiple tasks, required more time to analyze both simple and complex wh-questions than younger adults with larger working memory spans. Further, low span older adults with severely limited working memories, processed simple and complex wh-questions even more slowly than high span older adults. Working memory span did not appear to affect young adults' processing of either simple or complex wh-questions. Even the low span young adults had sufficient working memory capacity to process the wh-questions, whereas older adults, even those with relatively high working memory spans, did not. This pattern of results suggests that the effects of working memory capacity on language processing may not be evident unless a threshold is crossed; a threshold of working memory capacity may be imposed by processing tasks such that individuals whose working memory exceeds the thresold are able to perform the task whereas those whose working memory capacity falls below the threshold are not. Further processing decrements may also occur, as in the case of low span older adults, if working memory capacity falls very much below this threshold. In the present case, low span young adults ( M = 23.8) had sufficient working memory capacity to analyze complex wh-questions, whereas high span older adults ( M = 22.0) and low span older adults (M = 15.5) did not. During the validation study, both older and young adults were asked to select Figure 3. Answer Biases of Young and Older Adults
94
among two answer alternatives which were presented along with each question. When asked to choose among possible answers, older adults were able to make both interpretations of the argument questions and found both answer alternatives to be acceptable. This forced-choice procedure also caused young adults to ignore or overlook contextually-plausible "downstairs" interpretations of the wh-questions in favor of the "best" answer, namely the one consistent with linguistic theory. Thus, using this forced-choice procedure, young and older adults had the same preference for answers to the four types of wh-questions and their answers were in accord with the predictions based on linguistic theory. The experimental procedure required the participants to accept or reject a single possible answer to the wh-question. In this situation, older adults appear to interpret complex wh-questions qualitatively differently than do young adults, preferring to answer the first or upstairs interpretation. One possibility is that this primacy bias may result from a working memory limitation on their ability to process both clauses, generate multiple interpretations, apply linguistic constraints on wh-raising to block some interpretations, and select an answer from alternatives held in memory. When a representation of the discourse must be held in working memory, the burden on working memory may be such that older adults do not attempt to syntactically process the entire wh-sentences but attend to only the first clause and retrieve an answer alternative based on that partial interpretation. This account is not supported by the pattern of reading times for the critical regions of the wh-questions. These reading times indicate that the older adults, particularly the low span older adults, take more time, not less time, to process critical regions 3 and 4. Hence, it appears that the older adults did attempt to process the entire whquestion. Despite allocating additional processing time to the critical regions of the whquestions, older adults may have attempted to simplify the task by retaining only the first, or upstairs, intepretation of the wh-question. Hence, when presented with a candidate answer, they may only accept it if it is consistent with what they remember from the discourse context and if it is a plausible answer to what they remember from the question - the upstairs interpretation. This bias renders the argument and argument adjunct questions unambiguous in favor of the upstairs interpretation and produces an answer preference in accord with the predictions of linguistic theory for adjunct argument and adjunct adjunct questions. Young adults apparently also relied on a nonlinguistic bias. Young adults appeared to use a recency strategy, answering the most recent, or downstairs, interpretation. Young adults override the linguistic constraints on wh-questions when they are presented with a candidate answer and the the discourse context establishes a plausible "downstairs" intepretation of the argument adjunct and adjunct argument questions. This bias, then, also rendered the argument and argument adjunct questions unambiguous but favored the downstairs interpretation and resulted in a preference for the downstairs intepretations of the adjunct argument and adjunct adjunct questions. Working memory limitations thus affect older adults' processing of complex wh-questions in two ways. First, older adults, particularly those with limited working memories, allocate additional processing time to the analysis of the critical
95
regions of wh-questions. These critical regions include the medial wh-word as well as the final infinitive. Older adults' answers to wh-questions are also apparently affected by working memory limitations. Their preference for the upstairs interpretation of all four types of complex wh-questions implies an additional working memory limitation on question answering. RECONCEPTUALIZING THE RELATIONSHIP LANGUAGE PROCESSING
BETWEEN
AGING, WORKING MEMORY,
AND
The hypothesis that working memory limtations affect syntactic processing has recently come under careful scruitiny by a number of different theorists. Three reconceptualizations of the relationship between aging, working memory, and langauge processing are considered below: threshold models, inhibitory breakdown, and immediate versus post-comprehension processing. Threshold models. One challenge to the hypothesis that working memory limitations cause older adults' language processing problems comes from a series of studies which have failed to find effects of working memory limitations on sentence processing. These studies use on-line sentence processing tasks rather than the production, imitation, and recall tasks reviewed in the second section of this chapter. For example, Kemtes and Kemper (1997) examined the relationship between younger and older adults' working memory and on-line syntactic processing. They used a word-by-word reading paradigm to assess younger and older adults' on-line comprehension of temporarily ambiguous sentences (e.g. Several angry workers warned about low wages...) that were resolved with either a main verb (MV) interpretation (Several angry workers warned about low wages during the holiday season), or a reduced relative (RRC) clause interpretation (Several angry workers warned about low wages decided to file complaints). Reading times for sentences resolved with the MV interpretation were compared to those for sentences that were not temporarily ambiguous such as Several angry workers spoke about low wages which can only be assigned a MV interpretation. MacDonald, Just, and Carpenter (1992) has previously reported differential patterns of word-by-word reading times for young adults as a function of working memory span. Low span young adults showed little effect of ambiguity whereas high span young adults were affected by the temporary ambiguity. High span young adults required more time to process the final region of the sentence, following the temporary ambiguity. MacDonald et al. interpreted this finding as indicating that the high span young adults initially made both interpretations of the initial ambiguous portion of the sentence and retained both interpretations until the disambiguating information was encountered at the end of the sentence. They then required additional processing time to integrate the sentence-final information with the correct interpretation of the initial ambiguous portion of the sentence. Low span readers, they suggested, made only the most plausible interpretation, interpreting the ambiguous portion of the sentence as a RRC. When inconsistent information was later encountered, they were unable to integrate the information with their RRC interpretation and, hence, performed poorly on a comprehension test.
96
The primary finding from Kemtes and Kemper's (1997) replication was that while older adults' on-line reading times were slower than those of younger adults, syntactic ambiguity did not differentially impair older adults' on-line comprehension of the sentences. High span and low span young adults exhibited the same pattern of reading time latencies as did high and low span older adults. In contrast, older adults' off-line question comprehension was influenced by the syntactic ambiguity manipulation in that question comprehension was reliably poorer, relative to young, for the syntactically ambiguous sentences. These findings pose a challenge to the hypothesis that working memory limitations affect syntactic processing; not only did Kemtes and Kemper fail to replicate MacDonald et al. (1992) finding that high and low span young adults allocate reading times differentially but they also failed to link age differences on the comprehension test to on-line processing differences. The on-line processing differences between young adults and high and low span older adults for critical regions of the complex wh-questions (reported in the previous section of this chapter) suggested that a threshold of working memory capacity must be crossed before processing differences will be observed. If a threshold of working memory capacity must be crossed before processing differences can be observed, it may be that the threshold for the effect of temporary syntactic ambiguities on processing falls above the processing threshold for Kemtes and Kemper's (1997) participants. MacDonald et al. (1992) classified their participants based on the Daneman and Carpenter (1980) reading span task; high span participants had reading spans of 3.5 words or higher whereas low span participants had reading spans of 2.5 or lower (no further distributional information is provided). Kemtes and Kemper adopted a different approach; classifying their participants based on a composite measure derived from forward and backward digit spans and reading spans. They report that high span young adults had reading span scores averaging 3.7 words ( SD = 1.4) whereas low span young adults had reading span scores averaging 3.10 words ( SD = 10.) and that high span older adults had reading span scores averaging 3.6 words ( SD = 0.8) and low span older adults had reading span scores averaging 2.5 words ( SD = 0.5). Note that if there is a threshold, in the MacDonald et al. (1992) paradigm, it must be for the end of sentence INCREASE in reading time for high span participants, reflecting extra processing time required to resolve the ambiguity by selecting among alternative interpretations. Thus, Kemtes and Kemper may have failed to find such a sentence-final effect because many of their "high span" participants were misclassifed and failed to meet the processing threshold. Hence, many of these "high span" participants may not have had sufficient working memory capacity to make both interpretations of the temporary ambiguities. Hence, they were not able to maintain both interpretations through to the end of the sentence and so did not to show a sentence-final increase in reading time as they resolved the ambiguity by selecting among the alternative interpretations. Measurement problems, including the selection of critical measures of working memory capacity, as well as methodological considerations in classifying participants as high versus low span, may contribute to the lack of uniformity in research findings regarding the effects of working memory limitations on syntactic processing. Since most researchers have assumed that the effects should be linear,
97
alternative patterns of the effects, such as discontinuous threshold models, have not been considered. Inhibitory breakdown. Another reconceptualization of the relationship between aging, working memory, and language processing has been advanced by Hasher and Zacks (1988). They suggest that the capacity of working memory is not affected by aging; rather, aging weakens inhibitory mechanisms and permits irrelevant thoughts, personal preoccupations, and idiosyncratic associations to intrude during language encoding and retrieval. These irrelevant thoughts compete for processing resources, such as working memory capacity, and so impair older adults' comprehension and recall. Hence, older adults' comprehension may be affected by distractions or intrusive thoughts. For example, when a text contains distracting words printed in a different font, young adults are able to ignore the distracting material, even when it is related to the text, whereas older adults are not able to ignore the distracting material, which slows their reading, impairs their comprehension, and renders them subject to memory distortions (Carlson, Hasher, Connelly, & Zacks, 1995; Connelly, Hasher, & Zacks, 1991; Zacks & Hasher, 1997). Hasher, Zacks, and May (in press) postulate three functions of inhibition: preventing irrelevant information from entering working memory, deleting irrelevant information from working memory, and restraining probable responses until their appropriateness can be assessed. They argue that older adults suffer from a variety of processing impairments that can be attributed to decreased inhibitory mechanisms (but see Burke, 1997 and McDowd, 1977 for alternative views). Hence, older adults' language processing may mirror that of young adults whenever the task requires the active application of processing strategies since excitatory mechanisms are spared, whereas older adults' language processing may be impaired, relative to young adults', whenever inhibitory mechanisms are required to block out distractions, clear way irrelevancies, or switch between activities. Individuals with poor inhibitory mechanisms may not only be more susceptible to distraction, but they may also be less able to switch rapidly from one task to another and they may rely on well-learned "stereotypes, heuristics, and schemas" (p. 123) (Yoon, May, & Hasher, 1998). This reconceptualization of the nature of working memory and how it is affected by aging receives support from a study by Kwong See and Ryan (1995). Kwong See and Ryan examined individual differences in text processing attributable to working memory capacity (Stine, 1990), efficiency of inhibitory processes (Gernsbacher, 1990), and processing speed (Cohen, 1979), estimated by backward digit span, color naming speed, and Stroop interference, respectively. Their analysis suggested that working memory capacity is correlated with processing speed and inhibitory efficiency and that older adults' language processing difficulties can be attributed to slower processing and less efficient inhibition, rather than to working memory limitations. The inhibitory breakdown account of the relationship between aging, language processing, and working memory suggests that many of the age deficits reviewed in the second section of this chapter may be attributable to inhibitory breakdowns that affect older adults' ability to process complex materials. For example, inhibitory
98
mechanisms may be required in order to sustain a high level of performance on the grammaticality judgment tasks of Pye et al. (1992) and Kemper (1997). Distracting thoughts may intrude and affect older adults' ability to fully process a complex sentence such as The woman from the city treasurer's office is expected to help John, particularly as older adults may fail to understand the reasons for evaluating the grammaticality of a long list of sentences whereas college students may be more accustomed to such tasks. Immediate versus Post-comprehension Processing. Other researchers using other paradigms have also failed to find support for the hypothesis that working memory limitations affect syntactic processing. For example, Stine (1990) found that younger and older adults allocated word-by-word reading times similarly for word-level and more global phrase-level features of the text. Younger adults allocated additional reading time to the ends of phrases, clauses, and sentences whereas older adults paused at clause boundaries only. A related study by Stine, Cheung, and Henderson (1995) extended this earlier research by showing that specific word-, phrase-, sentence-, and discourse-level features of text influenced older adults' word-by-word reading times and explicit recall of narrative texts such that overall, older adults tended to allocate less reading time to processing new concepts. Stine, Loveless, and Soderberg (1996) demonstrated that younger and older adults' on-line reading times were qualitatively similar in that both age groups allocated more reading time to text segments with complex syntactic, new concepts, and longer words. However, older adults did allocate less reading time, relative to young, for new concepts. The effects of working memory limitations on syntactic processing were studied by Wingfield and Lindfield (1995) using the spontaneous speech segmentation technique. This technique allows listeners to interrupt the flow of speech at any point in order to recall the preceding portion. Wingfield and Lindfield varied the predictability of the speech by using passages that differed in cloze predictability. They also varied speech rate using passages presented at 180 wpm and ones time-compressed to approximately 230 and 300 wpm. Both young and older adults tended to select smaller segments as passage predictability declines. Most interruptions occurred at sentence boundaries or major clause boundaries and more occurred at minor phrase boundaries as predictability decreased and as speech rate increased. More critically, despite lower working memory scores for the older adults and despite their poor recall of the speech segments, the older adults tended to segment the speech in the same way as the young adults. Hence, the older adults' immediate processing of the speech appeared to be unaffected by working memory limitations although such limitations did affect their recall. Further challenges to the hypothesis linking working memory limitations to language processing problems come from careful studies of the effects of neurological impairments on language processing. Caplan and Waters (1996a; in press) have considered a number of lines of evidence from studies young and older adults as well as individuals with aphasia and dementia. They distinguish between immediate, interpretive syntactic processing and post-interpretative semantic and pragmatic analyses. Caplan and Waters argue that there is little evidence to support the hypothesis that working memory limitations affect immediate syntactic
99
processes; rather, working memory limitations affect post-interpretative processes involved in retaining information in memory in order to recall it or use it, e.g., to answer questions or match sentences against pictures. In a variety of studies comparing adults stratified into groups based on measures of working memory, Caplan and Waters (1996b) note that effects of syntactic complexity do not differentially affect high versus low span readers or listeners. And they report that secondary tasks that impose additional processing demands on working memory do not differentially affect the processing of complex sentences (Waters, Caplan, & Rochon, 1995). Caplan and Waters (in press) consider aphasic patients such as B. 0. (Waters, Caplan, & Hildebrandt, 1991) who had a digit span of only 2 or 3 digits but who was able to perform as well as normal healthy older adults on a wide range of tasks with complex sentences. They also note that patients with Alzheimer's dementia, who also show severely limited working memory capacity, are able to make speeded acceptability judgments of complex sentences as accurately as nondemented controls (Waters & Caplan, 1997). Caplan and Waters (in press) conclude "the working memory system involved in sentence interpretation is separate from that measured by standard tests of working memory" (p. 23) and that the " 'obligatory, on-line psycholinguistic operations'...that transform the acoustic signal into a preferred, discourse-coherent, semantic representation" draw on processing resources that are separate from those used in other 'controlled, verbally mediated tasks' " (1995, p. 770). Kintsch (1998) has offered a similar reconceptualization. Building on the "long-term working memory" model of Ericsson and Kintsch (1995), he suggests that reading span measures the efficiency with which readers can process and store verbal information in working memory. Reading span thus measures language processing skill, not the capacity of working memory. Kintsch also states that "More skilled readers construct better [memory] representations and hence have available more effective retrieval structures" (p. 239). From this point of view, it is a misnomer to label those who do well on reading span tests as "high span" individuals as this implies greater capacity, not greater processing skill. High skill readers may include those who are able to do well on reading span tests and who are able to spot the temporary ambiguity in sentences such as The defendant examined by the lawyer shocked the jury. High and low skill readers may allocate processing times to words and phrases in a similar fashion and adopt speech segmentation strategies that are similar yet form different types of long-term retrieval structures and thus differ in the long term retention, retrieval, and application of linguistic information. Conclusion. The hypothesis that working memory constraints syntactic processing, as it was originally formatted, lies at the heart of contemporary psycholinguistics. Modularity theory makes a strong prediction regarding the relationship between general cognitive limitations and syntactic processing: syntactic processing, particularly that concerned with the analysis of hierarchical or embedded structures, should be autonomous. Hence, working memory limitations, such as those long associated with aging, should not affect individuals' ability to analyze complex sentences. Whether working memory limitations are considered to be linear or to conform to a threshold model, or whether they are viewed as arising
100
from capacity limitations or a breakdown of inhibitory processes, syntactic processing should be, according to modularity theory, buffered from the effects of aging. Reconceptualizing working memory limitations as affecting postcomprehension processes, not immediate syntactic processing, preserves modularity theory yet recognizes that aging imposes severe constraints on language production andcomprehension.
101
REFERENCES
Arbuckle, T., & Gold, D. P. (1993). Aging, inhibition, and verbosity. Journal of Gerontology: Psychological Sciences, 48, P225-P232. Baddeley, A. (1986). Working memory. Oxford: Clarendon Press. Balota, D. A., Flores D'Arcais, G. B., & Rayner, K. (1990). Comprehension processes in reading. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum. Benjamin, B. J. (1988). Changes in speech production and linguistic behavior with aging. In B. Shadden (Ed.), Communication behavior and aging (pp. 163181). Boston: Williams & Wilkins. Bloom, L. (1975). One word at a time. The Hague: Mouton. Bock, J. K. (1987). Coordinating words and syntax in speech plans. In A. Ellis (Ed.), Progress in the psychology of language (pp. 337-390). London: Erlbaum Associates. Burke, D. (1997). Language, aging, and inhibitory deficits: Evaluation of a theory. Journal of Gerontology: Psychological Sciences, 52B, P254-P264. Caplan, D., & Waters, G. (in press). Verbal working memory and sentence comprehension. Behavioral and Brain Sciences. Carlson, M. C., Hasher, L., Connelly, S. L., & Zacks, R. T. (1995). Aging, distraction, and the benefits of predictable location. Psychology and Aging, 10, 427-436. Chomsky, N. (1986). Barriers. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Cohen, G. (1979). Language comprehension in old age. Cognitive Psychology, 11, 412-429. Connelly, S. L., Hasher, L., & Zacks, R. T. (1991). Age and reading: The impact of distraction. Psychology and Aging, 6, 533-541. Cooper, P. V. (1990). Discourse production and normal aging: Performance on oral picture description tasks. Journal of Gerontology: Psychological Sciences, 45, P210-214. Crain, S., & Shankweiler, D. (1988). Syntactic complexity and reading acquisition. In A. Davison & G. Green (Eds.), Critical approaches to readability (pp. 167192). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum. Crain, S., & Shankweiler, D. (1990). Explaining failures in spoken language comprehension by children with reading disability. In D. A. Balota, G. B. Flores d'Arcais, & K. Rayner (Eds.), Comprehension processes in reading (pp. 529-556). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum. Daneman, M., & Carpenter, P. A. (1980). Individual differences in working memory and reading. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Ability, 19, 450-466. Davis, G. A. (1984). Effects of aging on normal language. In A. Holland (Ed.), Language Disorders in adults. San Diego: College-Hill Press. de Villiers, J. (1996). Defining the open and closed program for acquisition: The case for Wh questions. In M. L. Rice (Ed.), Toward a genetics of language. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum. Dell, G. S. (1986). A spreading-activation theory of retrieval in sentence production. Psychological Review, 93, 283-321.
102
Ericsson, K. A., & Kintsch, W. (1995). Long-term working memory. Psychological Review, 102, 211-245. Fodor, J. A. (1982). Modularity of mind. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Frazier, L., & Fodor, J. D. (1978). The sausage machine: A new two-stage parsing model. Cognition, 6, 291-325. Garrett, M. F. (1988). Processes in language production. In F. J. Newmeyer (Ed.), Linguistics: The Cambridge survey, Ill: Language: Psychological and biological aspects (pp. 69-96). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Gathercole, S. E., & Baddeley, A. D. (1989). Evaluation of the role of phonological STM in the development of vocabulary in children: A longitudinal study. Journal of Memory and Language, 28, 200-213. Gathercole, S. E., & Baddeley, A. D. (1990). Phonological memory deficits in language disordered children: Is there a causal connection? Journal of Memory and Language, 29, 336-360. Gernsbacher, M. A. (1990). Language comprehension as structure building. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum. Gibson, E., Pearlmutter, N., Canseco-Gonzalez, E., & Hickok, G. (1996a). Recency preference in the human sentence processing mechanism. Cognition, 59, 23-59. Gibson, E., Schutze, C., & Salomon, C. (1996b). The relationship between the frequency and the processing of complex linguistic structures. Journal of Psycholinguistic Research, 25,59-92. Hasher, L., & Zacks, R. T. (1988). Working memory, comprehension, and aging: A review and a new view. In G. H. Bower (Ed.), The Psychology of Learning and Motivation (Vol. 22, pp. 193-226). New York: Academic. Hasher, L., Zacks, R. T., & May, C. P. (in press). Inhibitory control, circadian arousal, and age. In D. Gopher & A. Koriat (Eds.), Attention and performance XVII: Cognitive regulation of performance: Interaction of theory and application. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Hulme, C., Thomson, N., Muir, C., & Lawrence, A. (1984). Speech rate and the development of short-term memory span. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 38,241-253. Grimshaw, J. (199 1). Argument structure. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. James, L. E., Burke, D. M., Austin, A.., & Hulme, E. (1998). Production and perception of "verbosity" in younger and older adults. Psychology and Aging, 13, 355-368. Kemper, S. (1987a). Life-span changes in syntactic complexity. Journal of Gerontology, 42, 323-328. Kemper, S. (1987b). Syntactic complexity and the recall of prose by middle-aged and elderly adults. Experimental Aging Research, 13,47-52. Kemper, S. (1992). Language and aging. In F. I. M. Craik & T. A. Salthouse (Eds.), Handbook of aging and cognition (pp. 2 13-270). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum. Kemper, S. (1997). Metalinguistic judgments in normal aging and Alzheimer's disease. Journal of Gerontology: Psychological Sciences, 52, P147-PI55. Kemper, S., Kynette, D., Rash, S., Sprott, R., & O'Brien, K. (1989). Life-span changes to adults' language: Effects of memory and genre. Applied Psycholinguistics, 10, 49-66.
103
Kemper, S., & Rash, S. (1988). Speech and writing across the life-span. In M. M. Gruneberg, P. E. Morris, & R. N. Sykes (Eds.), Practical aspects of memory: Current research and issues (pp. 107-1 12). Chichester: John Wiley & Sons. Kemper, S., Rash, S. R., Kynette, D., & Norman, S. (1990). Telling stories: The structure of adults' narratives. European Journal of Cognitive Psychology, 2, 205-228. Kemtes, K. A., & Kemper, S. (1997). Younger and older adults' on-line processing of syntactic ambiguities. Psychology and Aging, 12, 362-371. Kintsch, W. (1 988). Comprehension: A paradigm for cognition. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Kintsch, W., & van Dijk, T. A. (1978). Toward a model of text comprehension and production. Psychological Review, 85, 363-393. Kwong See, S. T., & Ryan, E. B. (1995). Cognitive mediation of adult age differences in language performance. Psychology and Aging, 10, 458-468. Kynette, D., & Kemper, S. (1986). Aging and the loss of grammatical forms: A cross-sectional study of language performance. Language and Communication, 6, 65-72. Kynette, D., Kemper, S., Norman, S., Cheung, H., & Anagnopoulos, C. (1990). Adults' word recall and word repetition. Experimental Aging Research, 15, 117-121. Laird, J. E., Newell, A., & Rosenbloom, P. S. (1987). SOAR: An architecture for general intelligence. Artificial Intelligence, 33, 1-64. Lewis, R. I. (1996). Interference in short-term memory: The magical number two (or three) in sentence processing. Journal of Psycholinguistic Research, 25, 93-115. Light, L., & Capps, J. L. (1986). Comprehension of pronouns in younger and older adults. Developmental Psychology, 22, 580-585. Light, L. L., & Singh, A. (1987). Implicit and explicit memory in young and older adults. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory and Cognition, 13, 531-541. Light, L. L., Capps, J. L., Singh, A., & Albertson Owens, S. A. (1994). Comprehension and use of anaphoric devices in younger and older adults. Discourse Processes, 18, 77-103. MacDonald, M., Just, M. A., & Carpenter, P. A. (1992). Working memory constraints on the processing of syntactic ambiguity. Cognitive Psychology, 24, 56-98. MacKay, D. G. (1987). The organization of perception and action. New York: Springer-Verlag. Mandler, J. M., & Johnson, N. S. (1977). Remembrance of things parsed: Story structures and recall. Cognitive Psychology, 9, 111-151. McClelIand, J. L., & Rumelhart, D. E. (1981). An interactive activation model of context effects in letter perception: Part 1: An account of basic findings. Psychological Review, 88, 375-407. McDowd, D. (1987). Inhibition in attention and aging. Journal of Gerontology: Psychological Sciences, 52B, P265-P274.
104
Meyer, B. J. F. (1975). The organization of text and its effect on memory. Amsterdam: North-Holland. Meyer, D. E., & Kieras, D. E. (1997). A computational theory of executive cognitive processes in multiple task performance: Part 1 Basic Mechanisms. Psychological Review, 104,3-65. Meyer, D. E., & Kieras, D. E. (1997). A computational theory of executive cognitive processes in multiple task performance: Part 2 Accounts of psychological refractory period phenomena. Psychological Review, 104, 749800. Miller, G. (1962). Some psychological studies of grammar. American Psychologist, 17, 748-762. Newell, A. (1990). Unified theories of cognition. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University. Norman, S., Kemper, S., & Kynette, D. (1992). Adults' reading comprehension: Effects of syntactic complexity and working memory. Journal of Gerontology: Psychological Sciences, 47, P258-265. Pye, C., Cheung, H., & Kemper, S. (1992). Islands at eighty. In H. Goodluck & M. Rochemont (Eds.), Island constraints: Theory, acquisition, and processing (pp. 351-372). Dordrecht: D. Reidel. Rayner, K., & Pollatsek, A. (1989). The psychology of reading. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall. Salthouse, T. A. (1991). Mediation of adult age differences in cognition by reductions in working memory and speed of processing. Psychological Science, 2, 179-183. Salthouse, T. A., Babcock, R. L., & Shaw, R. J. (1991). Effects of adult age on structural and operational capacities in working memory. Psychology and Aging, 6, 118-127. Schweickert, R., & Boruff, B. (1986). Short-term memory capacity: Magic number or magic stuff? Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, & Cognition, 12, 419-425. Seidenberg, M. S. (1989). Visual word recognition and naming: A computational model and its implications. In W. D. Marslen-Wilson (Ed.), Lexical representation and process (pp. 25-74). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Seidenberg, M. S., & McClelland, J. L. (1989). A distributed, developmental model of word recognition and naming. Psychological Review, 96, 523-568. Shewan, C. M., & Henderson, V. L. (1988). Analysis of spontaneous language in the older normal population. Journal of Communication Disorders, 21, 139-154. Stine, E. A. L. (1990). On-Line processing of written text by younger and older adults. Psychology and Aging, 5, 68-78. Stine, E. A. L., Chueng, H., & Henderson, D. (1995). Adult age differences in the on-line processing of new concepts in discourse. Aging and Cogntion, 2, 1-18. Stine-Morrow, E. A. L., Loveless, M. K., & Soederberg, L. M. (1996). Resourse allocation in on-line reading by younger and older adults. Psychology and Aging, 11,475-486. Trabasso, T., & van den Broek, P. (1985). Causal thinking and the representation of narrative events. Journal of Memory and Language, 24, 612-630.
105
Ulatowska, H. K., Freedman-Stern, R., Weiss-Doyle, A., Macaluso-Haynes, S., & North, A. J. (1983). Production of narrative discourse in aphasia. Brain and Language, 19, 317-334. Walker, V. G., Roberts, P. M., & Hedrick, D. L. (1988). Linguistic analyses of the discourse narratives of young and aged women. Folia Phoniatica, 40, 58-64. Waters, G. S., & Caplan, D. (1996a). The capacity theory of sentence comprehension: Critique of Just and Carpenter (1992). Psychological Review, 103, 761-772. Waters, G. S., & Caplan, D. (1996b). Processing resource capacity and the comprehension of garden path sentences. Memory and Cognition, 24, 342-355. Waters, G. S., & Caplan, D. (1997). Working memory and on-line sentence comprehension in patients with Alzheimer's disease. Journal of Psycholinguistic Research, 26, 337-400. Waters, G. S., Caplan, D., & Rochon, E. (1995). Processing capacity and sentence comprehension in patients with Alzheimer's disease. Cognitive Neuropsychology, 12, 1-30. Wechsler, D. (198 1). WAIS-R Manual. New York: Psychological Corporation. Wingfield, A., & Lindfield, K. C. (1995). Multiple memory systems in the processing of speech: Evidence from aging. Experimental Aging Research, 21, 101-121. Wingfield, A., Tun, P. A., & Rosen, M. J. (1995). Age differences in veridical and reconstructive recall of syntactically and randomly segmented speech. Journal of Gerontology: Psychological Sciences, 50B, P257-266. Yngve, V. (1960). A model and a hypothesis for language structure. Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society, 104, 444-466. Yoon, C., May, C. P., & Hasher, L. (1988). Aging, circadian arousal patterns, and cognition. Philadelphia, PA: Psychology Press. Zacks, R., & Hasher, L. (1997). Cognitive gerontology and attentional inhibition: A reply to Burke and McDowd. Journal of Gerontology: Psychological Sciences, 52B, P274-P283. Zurif, E., Swinney, D., Prather, P., Wingfield, A., & Brownell, H. (1995). The allocation of memory resources during sentence comprehension: Evidence from the elderly. Journal of Psycholinguistic Research, 24, 165-182.
106
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Preparation of this chapter was supported by grant RO1 AG0092 from the National Institute on Aging as well as by the Research Training Program in Communication and Aging, supported by NIA grant T32 AG00226. We thank Tamara Harden for her assistance with this research. Kemtes is now a Postdoctoral Fellow at the Volen National Center for Complex Systems, Brandeis University.
5V
WORKING MEMORY CAPACITY ON-LINE SENTENCE PROCESSING EFFICIENCY IN THE ELDERLY
ERBAL
AND
Gloria Waters and David Caplan
In the past decade there has been a proliferation of research addressing the question of the effects of aging on language processing efficiency. Much of this research has focused on the ability of elderly individuals to process and remember information presented in texts (e.g., Tun et al., 1991). Several researchers have investigated sentence processing abilities in aging (Kemper, 1986; 1987a, b; 1992; Kemper & Rash, 1988; Kemper et al., 1989, Kemper et al., 1990). However, much of this work has centered on sentence production. The focus of this chapter is on the effects of aging on sentence comprehension in the elderly. The effects of aging on sentence comprehension abilities have been examined using a variety of tasks, such as object manipulation (Feier & Gertsman, 1980), question answering (Emery, 1985; Davis & Ball, 1989), acceptability judgment (Kemper, 1988; Obler et al., 1991), and sentence recall (Norman et al., 1991). Some studies have found that elderly subjects perform more poorly overall, but that they are not differentially impaired on syntactically more complex sentences (e.g., Feier & Gerstman, 1980). Other studies claim to have found decreased comprehension of more complex syntactic structures in the elderly (e.g., Obler et al., 1991; Davis & Ball, 1989). However, a review of these studies suggests that the effect of age on syntactic comprehension seen in many studies may not be directly attributable to difficulties subjects have in constructing syntactic structures but rather to difficulties in performing operations on the meaning that has been extracted. The tasks on which elderly subjects have shown effects of syntactic complexity have tended to be ones that require them to perform some sort of operation on the material that they have interpreted. This includes tasks which require the subject to retain and re-order large amounts of material in memory (Kemper, 1986; Light, 1990) or to interpret implausible sentences (Davis & Ball, 1989; Obler et al., 1991). This observation has led us to argue that a distinction should be made between the processes that are used to extract the meaning of a sentence from the signal, which we refer to as interpretive processing, and the process of using the meaning that has been extracted to perform other tasks, which we refer to as post-interpretive processing 107
108
(Waters & Caplan, 1996c; Caplan & Waters, 1998). We have argued that elderly individuals are more likely to have impairments in post-interpretive than in interpretive processing. One limitation of many of the studies examining sentence interpretation in the elderly is that they use what has been referred to as “off-line” measures of sentence processing. The term off-line is used to refer to experiments in which subjects must perform a task after the sentence has been understood (e.g., match a spoken sentence to one of several pictures). In contrast, on-line tasks are sensitive to the time-course of the largely unconscious, obligatory, processing that occurs as the words in a sentence are attended to (Marslen-Wilson, 1987). Self-paced word-by-word reading, word or phoneme monitoring, and cross-modal naming or lexical decision are examples of on-line tasks (see Ferreira & Anes, 1994, for a review). The basic rationale of these tasks is that, when other factors are held constant or partialed out, the measurement of reaction times can be interpreted as reflecting the demands of processing of words and phrases as they are perceived and integrated into the developing representation of the sentence. It is possible that if sentence interpretation were measured on-line, differences between younger and older subjects would emerge. Baum (1991) and Waldstein and Baum (1992) used the word monitoring paradigm to investigate the on-line sensitivity of younger and older adults to local and long distance ungrammaticalities. Although processing times and error rates of the elderly were higher overall than those of the younger subjects, there was no evidence that elderly subjects were more reliant on sentential context or that they were less sensitive to ungrammaticalities. Kemtes and Kemper (1996) also found that older and younger subjects did not differ in the effect of syntactic ambiguity on word-by-word reading times, although the older subjects were more affected on an off-line measure of accuracy in responding to questions. Zurif et al. (1995) did find that older subjects were delayed at establishing the connection between a gap in a relative clause and the head of the clause (e.g., determining that it is the man who is kissed in a sentence such as The man who the woman kissed was embarrassed ) using a cross-modal naming paradigm. However, Zurif et al.’s data are difficult to interpret, since a comparison group of younger subjects was not tested on the same materials. Thus, the existing data are at best equivocal as to whether there is a decrease with age in the ability to structure sentences syntactically. It is generally believed that if sentence comprehension abilities do decline with age, that this decline is related to a reduction in working memory capacity or processing resources (Just & Carpenter, 1952; Carpenter et al., 1994). This suggestion stems from work with younger subjects that claims that individual differences in the ability to structure sentences syntactically are related to individual differences in performance on a task that was designed to measure verbal working memory capacity -- the Daneman and Carpenter (1980) reading span task. On this task, subjects are required to read aloud increasingly longer sequences of sentences and to recall the final word of all of the sentences in each sequence. A subject’s working memory span is defined as the longest list length at which they are able to recall the sentence-final words on the majority of trials. Daneman and Carpenter showed that this reading span measure is a better predictor of language
109
comprehension abilities than measures such as digit span. A widespread view is that this is because complex or operation span tasks, such as reading span, involve both a processing and a storage component, and therefore are a better approximation of the working memory requirements of language processing tasks than simple span, which has only a storage component. The results of a variety of experiments have been interpreted as showing that individuals with lower reading spans are less efficient at structuring sentences syntactically than are subjects with higher spans. This in turn, has led to the claim that the working memory system that is measured by the reading span task is involved in syntactic processing during sentence comprehension. However, there is considerable debate about whether subjects with lower reading spans are less efficient at structuring sentences syntactically. We have argued that there are numerous methodological and interpretive problems with many of the studies claiming that there is a significant relationship between reading span and the ability to structure sentences syntactically (Waters & Caplan, 1996c; Caplan & Waters, a & b, in press). In addition, there is considerable controversy about the use of the Daneman and Carpenter task as a measure of verbal working memory capacity. One problem with the Daneman and Carpenter task is that the measure of a subject’s working memory span does not take into account the efficiency with which psycholinguistic computations are carried out, as it is based solely on the storage component of the task. Good performance may reflect a shift of attention away from the sentence aspect of the task, rather than a high level of a central processing resource (Turner & Engle, 1989). As has been recognized by many researchers, subjects may be trading off between components in many ways, making a measure based only on the storage component difficult to interpret (Baddeley, Logie, & Nimmo-Smith, 1985; Daneman & Tardiff, 1987; Turner & Engle, 1986; Tirre & Pena, 1992; Turner & Engle, 1989). In summary, it is commonly believed that working memory capacity declines with age and that this decline is captured by performance on the Daneman and Carpenter task. This reduction in working memory capacity is thought to be associated with reduced syntactic comprehension abilities. However, there is considerable debate about the adequacy of the Daneman and Carpenter task as a measure of verbal working memory capacity. In addition, relatively few studies have examined on-line sentence comprehension abilities in the elderly and the results of those that have are equivocal. In the experiment reported here we studied sentence comprehension in elderly subjects who differ in working memory capacity using a recently developed on-line method -- the auditory moving windows paradigm. The auditory moving windows paradigm provides a measure of processing at each word in a sentence and has been shown to be sensitive to local increases in processing load (Fereirra et al., 1996). Subjects were tested on two different comparisons of sentence types that differ in terms of syntactic structure, cleft-subject versus cleft-object sentences and objectsubject versus subject-object sentences, as seen in Table 1. Numerous linguistic theories and computer-based parsing models maintain that cleft-subject and object-subject sentences are syntactically simpler than cleft-object and subject-object sentences. According to Chomsky’s theory (1981, 1986, 1993), the second of each of these pairs of sentences contain a noun phrase that has been
110
moved to the left of another noun phrase, leaving a Wh-trace. This trace must be related (co-indexed) to its antecedent in order for the thematic roles assigned to the grammatical position that it occupies to be assigned. The memory storage and computational requirements of this operation make the processing load greater in these sentences than in the first members of the pairs (Berwick & Weinberg, 1984; Haarmann et al., 1997). Consistent with this hypothesis, our work with college students has shown that there is an increase in listening time at the embedded verb (V) in cleft-object sentences and at V1 and V2 in subject-object sentences (Waters & Caplan, submitted).
Table 1. Sample stimuli used in the auditory moving windows study.
In the present study, verbal working memory capacity was measured in several ways. Subjects were tested on a variant of the Daneman and Carpenter reading span task in which they were asked to make acceptability judgments about increasingly longer sequences of sentences and to recall the final word of all of the sentences in each sequence (Waters & Caplan, 1996b). Reaction times and errors in making the acceptability judgment were measured. Working memory capacity was tested using five additional operation span tasks -- alphabet span (Craik, 1986), backward digit span (Botwinick & Storandt, 1974), missing digit span (Talland, 1965), subtract 2 span (Salthouse, 1988), and running item span (Talland, 1965).
111
The data from the reading span task were examined to determine whether the traditional reading span measure (performance on the sentence-final word recall component of the task) provides an adequate measure of a subjects’ working memory capacity. If it is a reliable and valid measure of verbal working memory capacity, subjects should not trade-off on the various components of the task and the various components of the task should result in subjects being assigned to the same working memory span group. Moreover, performance on the reading span task should be related to that on other operation span tasks which are claimed to measure verbal working memory capacity. In addition, if on-line sentence processing efficiency is related to verbal working memory capacity as measured by the reading span task, elderly subjects with reduced working memory capacity would be expected to have longer listening times compared to subjects with less reduced capacity, particularly at the verb in acceptable cleft-object compared to cleft-subject sentences and at V1 and V2 in acceptable subject-object compared to object-subject sentences. METHODS
Subjects. Seventy individuals who ranged from 60 to 88 years of age participated in the study. They were recruited through ads posted in churches, synagogues, and newsletter