Contents 1
Introduction and overview . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.1 The main result and its history . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2 Wave maps to H2 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3 The small data theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.4 The Bahouri–Gérard concentration compactness method 1.5 The Kenig–Merle agument . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.6 An overview of the book . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
2
The spaces S Œk and N Œk . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1 Preliminaries . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2 The null-frame spaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3 The energy estimate . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4 A stronger S Œk-norm, and time localizations . . . . . . . . . . 2.5 Solving the inhomogeneous wave equation in the Coulomb gauge
3
Hodge decomposition and null-structures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 65
4
Bilinear estimates involving S and N spaces . . . . . . . . . . 4.1 Basic L2 -bounds . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2 An algebra estimate for S Œk . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.3 Bilinear estimates involving both S Œk1 and N Œk2 waves 4.4 Null-form bounds in the high-high case . . . . . . . . . 4.5 Null-form bounds in the low-high and high-low cases . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
73 73 90 93 101 111
5
Trilinear estimates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.1 Reduction to the hyperbolic case . . . . . . . . . . 5.2 Trilinear estimates for hyperbolic S-waves . . . . . 5.3 Improved trilinear estimates with angular alignment
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
115 116 148 180
6
Quintilinear and higher nonlinearities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 197 6.1 Error terms of order higher than five . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 217
7
Some basic perturbative results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 223 7.1 A blow-up criterion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 223 7.2 Control of wave maps via a fixed L2 -profile . . . . . . . . . . . 244
8
BMO, Ap , and weighted commutator estimates . . . . . . . . . . . . 277
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. 1 . 1 . 4 . 8 . 11 . 16 . 18 25 25 28 42 57 63
vi
Contents
9
The Bahouri–Gérard concentration compactness method . . 9.1 The precise setup for the Bahouri–Gérard method . . . 9.2 Step 1: Frequency decomposition of initial data . . . . 9.3 Step 2: Frequency localized approximations to the data 9.4 Step 3: Evolving the lowest-frequency nonatomic part . 9.5 Completion of some proofs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.6 Step 4: Adding the first large component . . . . . . . . 9.7 Step 5: Invoking the induction hypothesis . . . . . . . 9.8 Completion of proofs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.9 Step 6 of the Bahouri–Gérard process; adding all atoms
. . . . . . . . . .
293 293 294 302 309 358 358 397 421 422
10
The proof of the main theorem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.1 Some preliminary properties of the limiting profiles . . . . . . . 10.2 Rigidity I: Harmonic maps and reduction to the self-similar case 10.3 Rigidity II: The self-similar case . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
427 429 444 450
11
Appendix . . . . . . . . . 11.1 Completing a proof . 11.2 Completion of proofs 11.3 Completion of a proof 11.4 Completion of a proof 11.5 Competion of proofs
459 459 462 463 467 469
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 477 Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 481
1
Introduction and overview
1.1
The main result and its history
Formally speaking, wave maps are the analogue of harmonic maps where the Minkowski metric is imposed on the independent variables. More precisely, for a smooth u W RnC1 ! M with .M; g/ Riemannian, define the Lagrangian Z L.u/ WD j@ t uj2g jruj2g dt dx: RnC1
Then the critical points are defined as L0 .u/ D 0 which means that u ? Tu M in case M is embedded in some Euclidean space. This is called the extrinsic formulation, which can also be written as u C A.u/.@˛ u; @˛ u/ D 0 where A.u/ is the second fundamental form. In view of this, it is clear that ı is a wave map for any geodesic in M and any free scalar wave . Moreover, any harmonic map is a stationary wave map. The intrinsic formulation is D ˛ @˛ u D 0, where j D˛ X j WD @˛ X j C i k ı u X i @˛ uk is the covariant derivative induced by u on the pull-back bundle of T M under u (with the summation convention in force). Thus, in local coordinates u D .u1 ; : : : ; ud / one has uj C
j ik
ı u @˛ ui @˛ uk D 0:
(1.1)
The central problem for wave maps is to answer the following question: For which M does the Cauchy problem for the wave map u W RnC1 ! M with P t D0 D .u0 ; u1 / have global smooth solutions? smooth data .u; u/j In view of finite propagation speed, one may assume that the data .u0 ; u1 / are trivial outside of some compact set (i.e., u0 is constant outside of some compact set, whereas u1 vanishes outside of that set). Let us briefly describe what is known about this problem.
2
1 Introduction and overview
First, recall that the wave map equation is invariant under the scaling u 7! n u./ which is critical relative to HP 2 .Rn /, whereas the conserved energy n Z 1X E.u/ D j@˛ u.t; x/j2 dx n 2 R ˛D0
is critical relative to HP 1 .Rn /. In the supercritical case n 3 it was observed by Shatah [41] that there are self-similar blow-up solutions of finite energy. In the critical case n D 2, it is known that there can be no self-similar blow-up, see [42]. Moreover, Struwe [50] observed that in the equivariant setting, blow-up in this dimension has to result from a strictly slower than self-similar rescaling of a harmonic sphere of finite energy. His arguments were based on the very detailed well-posedness of equivariant wave maps by Christodoulou, Tavildar-Zadeh [4], [5], and Shatah, Tahvildar-Zadeh [44], [45] in the energy class for equivariant wave maps into manifolds that are invariant under the action of SO.2; R/. Finally, Rodnianski, Sterbenz [38], as well as the authors together with Daniel Tataru [26] exhibited finite energy wave maps from R2C1 ! S 2 that blow up in finite time by suitable rescaling of harmonic maps. Let us now briefly recall some well-posedness results. The nonlinearity in (1.1) displays a null-form structure, which was the essential feature in the subcritical theory of Klainerman–Machedon [16]–[18], and Klainerman–Selberg [20], [21]. These authors proved strong local well-posedness for data in H s .Rn / when s > n2 . The important critical theory s D n2 was begun by Tataru [64], [63]. These seminal papers proved global well-posedness for smooth data satisfying a n n 2 2 1 smallness condition in BP 2;1 .Rn / BP 2;1 .Rn /. In a breakthrough work, Tao [59], n n [58] was able to prove well-posedness for data with small HP 2 HP 2 norm and the sphere as target. For this purpose, he introduced the important microlocal gauge in order to remove some “bad” interaction terms from the nonlinearity. Later results by Klainerman, Rodnianski [19], Nahmod, Stephanov, Uhlenbeck [36], Tataru [61], [60], and Krieger [23], [24], [25] considered other cases of targets by using similar methods as in Tao’s work. Recently, Sterbenz and Tataru [47], [48] have given the following very satisfactory answer1 to the above question: If the energy of the initial data is smaller than the energy of any nontrivial harmonic map Rn ! M, then one has global existence and regularity.
1
The conclusions of our work were reached before the appearance of [47], [53].
1.1 The main result and its history
3
Notice in particular that if there are no harmonic maps other than constants, then one has global existence for all energies. A particular case of this are the hyperbolic spaces Hn for which Tao [57]– [53] has achieved the same result (with some a priori global norm control). The purpose of this book is to apply the method of concentration compactness as in Bahouri, Gérard [1] and Kenig, Merle [14], [15] to the large data wave map problem with the hyperbolic plane H2 as target. We emphasize that this gives more than global existence and regularity as already in the semilinear case considered by the aforementioned authors. The fact that in the critical case the large data problem should be decided by the geometry of the target is a conjecture going back to Sergiu Klainerman. Let us now describe our result in more detail. Let H2 be the upper half-plane 2 y2 model of the hyperbolic plane equipped with the metric ds 2 D d x yCd . Let u W 2 R2 ! H2 be a smooth map. Expanding the derivatives f@˛ ug˛D0;1;2 (with @0 WD @ t ) in the orthonormal frame fe1 ; e2 g D fy@x ; y@y g gives rise to smooth coordinate P j 2 1 functions ˛1 ; ˛2 . In what follows, k@˛ ukX will mean . j2D1 k˛ kX / 2 for any norm k kX on scalar functions. For example, the energy of u is
E.u/ WD
2 X
k@˛ uk22 :
˛D0
Next, suppose W H2 ! M is a covering map with M some hyperbolic Riemann surface with the metric that renders a local isometry. In other words, M D H2 = for some discrete subgroup PSL.2; R/ which operates totally discontinuously on H2 . Now suppose u W R2 ! M is a smooth map which is constant outside of some compact set, say. It lifts to a smooth map uQ W R2 ! H2 uniquely, up to composition with an element of . We now define Q X . In particular, the energy E.u/ WD E.u/. Q Note that due to k@˛ ukX WD k@˛ uk 2 the fact that is a group of isometries of H , these definitions are unambiguous. Our main result is as follows. Theorem 1.1. There exists a function K W .0; 1/ ! .0; 1/ with the following property: Let M be a hyperbolic Riemann surface. Suppose .u0 ; u1 / W R2 ! M TM are smooth and u0 D const, u1 D 0 outside of some compact set. Then the wave map evolution u of these data as a map R1C2 ! M exists globally 1 as a smooth function and, moreover, for any p1 C 2q 41 with 2 q < 1,
4
D1
1 Introduction and overview 1 p
2 q, 2 X
2
k. /
@˛ ukLpt Lqx Cq K.E/:
(1.2)
˛D0
Moreover, in the case when M ,! RN is a compact Riemann surface, one has scattering:
max @˛ u.t / @˛ S.t /.f; g/ L2 ! 0 as t ! ˙1 x
˛D0;1;2
jrj/ where S.t/.f; g/ D cos.t jrj/f C sin.t g and suitable .f; g/ 2 .HP 1 jrj L2 /.R2 I RN /. Alternatively, if M is non-compact, then lifting u to a map j R1C2 ! H2 with derivative components ˛ as defined above, one has
max ˛j .t / @˛ S.t /.f j ; g j / L2 ! 0 as t ! ˙1 x
˛D0;1;2
where .f j ; g j / 2 .HP 1 L2 /.R2 I R/. We emphasize that (1.2) can be strengthened considerably in terms of the type of norm applied to the Coulomb gauged derivative components of the wave map: 2 X
k
2 ˛ kS
C K.E/2
(1.3)
˛D0
The meaning ˛ as well as of the S norm will be explained below. We now turn to describing this result and our methods in more detail. For more background on wave maps see [13], [61], and [42].
1.2
Wave maps to H2
The manifold H2 is the upper half-plane equipped with the metric ds 2 D d x2 Cd y2 . Expanding the derivatives f@˛ ug˛D0;1;2 (with @0 WD @ t ) of a smooth y2 map u W R1C2 ! H2 in the orthonormal frame fe1 ; e2 g D fy@x ; y@y g yields @˛ u D .@˛ x; @˛ y/ D
2 X j D1
˛j ej ;
1.2 Wave maps to H2
whence yDe
P
j D1;2
1@ 2 j j
;
xD
5
X
1
@j .j1 y/;
(1.4)
j D1;2
provided we assume the normalization limjxj!1 j ln yj D limjxj!1 jxj D 0. Energy conservation takes the form Z
Z 2 X 2 X ˇ j ˇ ˇ .t; x/ˇ2 dx D ˛
2 X 2 X ˇ j ˇ ˇ .0; x/ˇ2 dx ˛
(1.5)
R2 ˛D0 j D1
R2 ˛D0 j D1
where x D .x1 ; x2 / and @0 D @ t . If u.t; x/ is a smooth wave map, then the j functions f˛ g for 0 ˛ 2 and j D 1; 2 satisfy the div-curl system @ˇ ˛1
@˛ ˇ1 D ˛1 ˇ2
@ˇ ˛2
@˛ ˇ2 @˛ 1˛ @˛ 2˛
ˇ1 ˛2
(1.6)
D0 D
(1.7) ˛1 2˛
(1.8)
D ˛1 1˛
(1.9)
for all ˛; ˇ D 0; 1; 2. As usual, repeated indices are being summed over, and lowering or raising is done via the Minkowski metric. Clearly, (1.6) and (1.7) are integrability conditions which are an expression of the curvature of H2 . On the other hand, (1.8) and (1.9) are the actual wave map system. Since the choice of frame was arbitrary, one still has gauge freedom for the system (1.6)–(1.9). We shall exclusively rely on the Coulomb gauge which is given in terms of complex notation by the functions 1
P2
1
j D1 @j j : D .˛1 C i ˛2 /e i P If j1 are Schwartz functions , then j2D1 @j j1 has mean zero whence
˛
1
2 X j D1
WD
1 ˛
Ci
2 ˛
1 @j j1 .z/ D 2
Z R2
log jz
j
2 X
@j j1 ./ d ^ d N
(1.10)
(1.11)
j D1
is well-defined and moreover decays like jzj 1 (but in general no faster). The gauged components f ˛ g˛D0;1;2 satisfy the new div-curl system X 2 1 @˛ ˇ @ˇ ˛ D i ˇ 1 @j . ˛1 j2 ˛ j/ j D1;2
i
˛
1
@j .
1 2 ˇ j
2 1 ˇ j/
(1.12)
6
1 Introduction and overview
@
Di
2 X
1
@j .
1 2 j
2 1 j /:
(1.13)
j D1
In particular, one obtains the following system of wave equations for the
˛
D i @ˇ
˛
1
X
@j .
1 2 ˇ j
˛:
2 1 ˇ j/
j D1;2
i @ˇ
ˇ
1
@j .
C i @˛
ˇ
1 2 ˛ j
2 1 ˛ j/
X
1
@j .
1 2 ˇ j
2 1 ˇ j/
(1.14)
j D1;2
Throughout this book we shall only consider admissible wave maps u. These are characterized as smooth wave maps u W I R2 ! H2 on some time interval I so j that the derivative components ˛ are Schwartz functions on fixed time slices. By the method of Hodge decompositions from2 [23]– [25] one exhibits the null-structure present in (1.12)–(1.14). Hodge decomposition here refers to writing 2 X Rk k C ˇ (1.15) ˇ D Rˇ kD1
where Rˇ WD @ˇ jrj 1 are the usual Riesz transform. Inserting the hyperbolic P terms Rˇ 2kD1 Rk k into the right-hand sides of (1.12)–(1.14) leads to trilinear nonlinearities with a null structure. As is well-known, such null structures are amenable to better estimates since they annihilate “self-interactions”, or more precisely, interactions of waves which propagate along the same characteristics, cf. [18]– [17], as well as [20], [21], [11]. Furthermore, inserting at least one “elliptic term” ˇ from (1.15) leads to a higher order nonlinearity, in fact quintic or higher which are easier to estimate (essentially by means of Strichartz norms). To see this, note that 2 X
@j j D 0
j D1
@j ˇ
2
@ˇ j D @j
ˇ
@ˇ
j;
In these papers this decomposition is also referred to as “dynamic decomposition”.
1.2 Wave maps to H2
7
whence ˇ D i
2 X
@j
1
ˇ
1
@k .
1 j
2 k
1 2 k j/
j
1
@k .
1 ˇ
2 k
1 k
2 ˇ/
:
j;kD1
(1.16) j Since we are only going to obtain a priori bounds on ˛ , it will suffice to assume j throughout that the ˛ are Schwartz functions, whence the same holds for ˛ . In what follows, we shall never actually solve the system (1.12)–(1.14). To go further, the wave-equation (1.14) by itself is meaningless without assuming the ˛ to satisfy the compatibility relations (1.12) and (1.13). In fact, it is not even clear that (1.12) and (1.13) will hold for all t 2 . T; T / if they hold at time t D 0 and (1.14) holds for all t 2 . T; T /. Nonetheless, assuming that the ˛ are defined in terms of the derivative components ˛ of a ‘sufficiently nice’ wave map, it is clear that all three of (1.12)–(1.14) will be satisfied. This being said, we will only use the system (1.14) to derive a priori estimates for ˛ , which will j then be shown to lead to suitable bounds on the components ˛ of derivatives of a wave map u. This is done by means of Tao’s device of frequency envelope, see [59] or [23]. This refers to a sequence fck gk2Z of positive reals such that ck 2
jk `j
c` ck 2 jk
`j
(1.17)
where > 0 is a small number. The most relevant example is given by ck WD
X
2
jk `j
kP` .0/k22
21
`2Z
which controls the initial data. While it is of course clear that (1.6)–(1.9) imply the system (1.12)–(1.14), the reverse implication is not such a simple matter since it involves solving an elliptic system with large solutions. On the other hand, transferring estimates on the ˛ in H s .R2 / spaces to similar bounds on j the derivative components ˛ does not require this full implication. Indeed, assume the bound k kL1 .. T0 ;T1 /IH ı1 .R2 // < 1 for some small ı1 > 0 (we will t obtain such bounds via frequency envelopes with 0 < ı1 < ). For any fixed time t 2 . T0 ; T1 / one now has with Pk being the usual Littlewood–Paley projections to frequency 2k , P2
1 1 kP` ˛ kH ı2 D P` Œe i j D1 @j j ˛ H ı2 P2
1 1 P` ŒP<` 10 .e i j D1 @j j /PŒ` 10;`C10 ˛ H ı2 P2
1 1 C P` ŒPŒ` 10;`C10 .e i j D1 @j j /P<`C15 ˛ H ı2
8
1 Introduction and overview
C
P2 X
P` ŒPk .e i j D1
1@ 1 j j
/PkCO.1/
˛ H ı2
k>`C10
. kPŒ`
10;`C10 ˛ kH ı2 P2
1 1 C PŒ` 10;`C10 .e i j D1 @j j / H ı2 kP<`C15 ˛ k1 P2 X
Pk .e i j D1 1 @j j1 / ı kPkCO.1/ ˛ k1 C H 2 k>`C10
Next, one has the bounds
rx e i
1
P2
1 j D1 @j j
kP<`C15
2 L1 t Lx
. 2.1 ˛ kL1 x
. kj1 kL1 L2x ; t
ı1 /`
k
˛ kH ı1
where the first one is admissible due to energy conservation for the derived wave map, see (1.5). In conclusion, kP` ˛ kH ı2 . kP`CO.1/
˛ kH ı2
C 2.ı2
ı1 /`
kkL2x k kH ı1 :
Summing over ` 0 yields kkL1 t
. T0 ;T1 /IH ı2 .R2 /
< 1:
(1.18)
By the subcritical existence theory of Klainerman and Machedon, see [18]– [16] as well as [20], [21], the solution can now be extended smoothly beyond this time interval. More precisely, the device of frequency envelopes allows one to place the Schwartz data in H s .R2 / for all s > 0 initially, and as it turns out, also for all times provided s > 0 is sufficiently small. The latter claim is of course the entire objective of this book. We should also remark that we bring (1.14) into play only because it fits into the framework of the spaces from [59] and [63]. This will allow us to obtain the crucial energy estimate for solutions of (1.14), whereas it is not clear how to do this directly for the system (1.12), (1.13). As already noted in [23], the price one pays for passing to (1.14) lies with the initial conditions, or more precisely, the time derivative @ t ˛ .0; /. While ˛ .0; / only involves one derivative of the wave map u, this time derivative involves two. This will force us to essentially “randomize” the initial time.
1.3
The small data theory
In this section we give a very brief introduction to the spaces which are needed to control the system (1.12), (1.13), and (1.14). A systematic development will
9
1.3 The small data theory
be carried out in Chapter 2 below, largely following [58] (we do need to go beyond both [58] and [23] in some instances such as by adding the sharp Strichartz spaces with the Klainerman–Tataru gain for small scales, and by eventually modifying k kS Œk to the stronger jjj jjjS Œk which allows for a high-high gain in the S S ! L2tx estimate). First note that it is not possible to bound the trilinear nonlinearities in this system in Strichartz spaces due to slow dispersion in dimension two. Moreover, it is not possible to adapt the X s;b -space of the subcritical theory to the scaling invariant case as this runs into logarithmic divergences. For this reason, Tataru [63] devised a class of spaces which resolve these logarithmic divergences. His idea was to allow characteristic frames of reference. More precisely, fix ! 2 S 1 and define p !˙ WD .1; ˙!/= 2; t! WD .t; x/ !C ; x! WD .t; x/ t! !C ; which are the coordinates defined by a generator on the light-cone. Now suppose that i are free waves such that 1 is Fourier supported on 1 jj 2, and both 2 and 3 are Fourier supported on jj 2k where k is large and negative. Finally, we also assume that the three waves are in “generic position”, i.e., that their Fourier supports make an angle of about size one. Clearly, 2 k 1 2 3 is then a representative model for the nonlinearities arising in (1.14). With Z e i ŒtjjCx f ./ d 3 .t; x/ D R2
p R we perform the plane-wave decomposition 3 .t; x/ D ! . 2t! / d! where Z ! .s/ WD e i rs f .r!/ rdr: By inspection, Z k! kL2
k
1 t! L x !
d! . 2 2 k
3 kL1 L2x :
(1.19)
t
Hence, 2
k
Z k!
1
2 kL1
2 t! Lx!
d! . 2 .k
k
Z k! kL2
1 t! Lx!
3 kL1 L2x t
k
d!k
1
2 kL2 L2x t! !
1 kL1 L2x k 2 kL1 L2x t
t
example3
which is an of a trilinear estimate which will be studied systematically in Chapter 5. Here we used both (1.19) and the standard bilinear L2tx bilinear 3
Note that one does not obtain a gain in this case. This fact will be of utmost importance in this book, forcing us to use a “twisted” wave equation resulting from these high-low-low interactions in the linearized trilinear expressions.
10
1 Introduction and overview
L2 -bound for waves with angular separation: k
1
2 kL2 L2x t! !
Dk
1
2 kL2 L2x t
k
. 22 k
2 kL1 L2x k 1 kL1 L2x t
This suggests introducing an atomic space with atoms 1 and satisfying k ! kL1 L2x 1 t!
!
t
of Fourier support jj
!
as part of the space N Œ0 which holds the nonlinearity (the zero here refers to the Littlewood–Paley projection P0 . Below, we refer to this space as NF). In addition, the space defined by (1.19) is also an atomic space and should be incorporated in the space SŒk holding the solution at frequency 2k (we refer to this below as the 2 PW space). By duality to L1t! L2x! in N Œ0, we then expect to see L1 t! Lx! as part of SŒ0. The simple observation here (originating in [63]) is that one can indeed bound the energy along a characteristic frame .t! ; x! / of a free wave as long as its Fourier support makes a positive angle with the direction !. Indeed, recall the local energy conservation identity @ t e div.@ t r / D 0 for a free wave where 1 e D .j@ t j2 C jr j2 / 2 is the energy density, over a region of the form f T t T g \ ft! > ag. From the divergence theorem one obtains that Z Œ T t T j! ? r j2 d L2 . k k2L1 L2 t
t! Da
x
where L2 is the planar Lebesgue measure on ft! D ag. Sending T ! 1 and letting denote the distance between ! and the direction of the Fourier support of j tD0 , one concludes that k kL1 L2x . t!
!
1
k kL1 L2x : t
Hence, we should include a piece sup d.!; /k kL1 2 ! Lx
!622
!
in the norm S Œ0 holding P0 provided is a wave packet oriented along the cone of dimensions 1 2k 22k , projecting onto an angular sector in the -plane associated with the cap S 1 , where is of size 2k (this is called NF below). Recall that we have made a genericity assumption which guaranteed that the Fourier supports were well separated in the angle. In order to relax this condition,
1.4 The Bahouri–Gérard concentration compactness method
11
it is essential to invoke the usual device of null-forms which cancel out parallel interactions. One of the discoveries of [23] is a genuinely trilinear null-form expansion, see (5.44) and (5.45), which exploit the relative position of all three waves simultaneously. It seems impossible to reduce the trilinear nonlinearities of (1.14) exclusively to the easier bilinear ones. It is shown in [63] (and then also in [58] which develops much of the functional framework that we use, as well as [23]) that in low dimensions (especially n D 2 but these spaces are also needed for n D 3), these null-frame spaces are strong enough – in conjunction with more traditional scaling invariant X s;b spaces – to bound the trilinear nonlinearities, as well as weak enough to allow for an energy estimate to hold. This then leads modulo passing to an appropriate gauge to the small energy theory. 12 P 2 The norm k kS in (1.3) is of the form k kS WD where k2Z kPk kS Œk 2 s;b , L4 L1 Strichartz norms, as well as the S Œk is built from L1 t Lx , critical X t x null-frame spaces which we just described.
1.4
The Bahouri–Gérard concentration compactness method
We now come to the core of the argument, namely the Bahouri–Gérard type decomposition and the associated perturbative argument. We remark that independently of and simultaneously with Bahouri, Gérard, Merle and Vega [30] introduced a similar concentration compactness method into the study of nonlinear evolution equations (they considered the L2 -critical nonlinear Schrödinger equation). In [12] P. Gérard considered defocusing semilinear wave equations in R3C1 of the form u C f .u/ D 0 with data given by a sequence .n ; n / of energy data going weakly to zero. Denote the resulting solutions to the nonlinear problem by un , and the free waves with the same data by vn . Gérard proved that provided f .u/ is subcritical relative to energy then kun
vn kL1 .I IE/ ! 0;
as n ! 1
where E is the energy space. In contrast, for this to hold for the energy critical problem he found via the concentrated compactness method of P. L. Lions that it is necessary and sufficient that kvn kL1 .I IL6 .R3 // ! 0. In other words, the critical problem experiences a loss of compactness. The origin of this loss of compactness, as well as the meaning of the L6 condition were later made completely explicit by Bahouri–Gérard [1]. Their result
12
1 Introduction and overview
2 3 P1 reads as follows: Let f.n ; n /g1 nD1 H L .R / be a bounded sequence, and define vn to be a free wave with these initial data. Then there exists a subsequence fvn0 g of fvn g, a finite energy free wave v, as well as free waves V .j / and C .".j / ; x .j / / 2 .RC ; R3 /Z for every j 1 with the property that for all ` 1, ! ` .j / .j / X 1 t t x x n n vn0 .t; x/ D v.t; x/ C V .j / ; C wn.`/ .t; x/ (1.20) q .j / .j / .j / "n "n j D1 "n
where lim sup kwn.`/ kL5 .R;L10 !0 3 x .R // t
n!1
as ` ! 1;
and for any j ¤ k, .j /
"n
.k/
"n
.k/
C
"n
.j /
"n
C
ˇ .j / ˇxn
ˇ .j / .k/ ˇ xn ˇ C ˇtn .j /
"n
.k/ ˇ tn ˇ
! 1;
as n ! 1:
Furthermore, the free energy E0 satisfies the following orthogonality property: E0 .vn0 /
D E0 .v/ C
` X
E0 .V .j / / C E0 .wn.`/ / C o.1/;
as n ! 1:
j D1
Note that this result characterized the loss of compactness in terms of the appearance of concentration profiles V .j / . Moreover, [1] contains an analogue of this result for so-called Shatah–Struwe solutions of the semi-linear problem u C juj4 u D 0 which then leads to another proof of the main result in [12]. One of the main applications of their work was to show the existence of a function A W Œ0; 1/ ! Œ0; 1/ so that every Shatah–Struwe solution satisfies the bound kukL5 RIL10 .R3 / A E.u/ (1.21) t
x
where E.u/ is the energy associated with the semi-linear equation. This is proved by contradiction; indeed, assuming (1.21) fails, one then obtains sequences of bounded energy solutions with uncontrollable Strichartz norm which is then shown to contradict the fact the nonlinear solutions themselves converge weakly to another solution. The decomposition (1.20) compensates for the aforementioned loss of compactness by reducing it precisely to the effect of the symmetries, i.e., dilation and scaling. This is completely analogous to the elliptic (in fact, variational) origins of the method of concentration compactness, see Lions [28] and Struwe [49]. See [1] for more details and other applications.
1.4 The Bahouri–Gérard concentration compactness method
13
The importance of [1] in the context of wave maps is made clear by the argument of Kenig, Merle [14], [15]. This method, which will be described in more detail later in this section, represents a general method for attacking global well-posedness problems for energy critical equations such as the wave map problem. Returning to the Bahouri–Gérard decomposition, we note that any attempt at implementing this technique for wave maps encounters numerous serious difficulties. These are of course all rooted in the difficult nonlinear nature of the system (1.6)–(1.9). Perhaps the most salient feature of our decomposition, performed in detail in Section 9.2, as compared to [1] is that the free wave equation no longer captures the correct asymptotic behavior for large times; rather, the atomic components V .j / are defined as solutions of a covariant (or “twisted”) wave equation of the form C 2iA˛ @˛ (1.22) where the magnetic potential A˛ arises from linearizing the wave map equation in the Coulomb gauge. More precisely, the magnetic term here captures the highlow-low interactions in the trilinear nonlinearities of the wave map system where there is no a priori smallness gain. We shall then obtain the concentration profiles via an inductive procedure over increasing frequency scales; in particular, in (1.22) the Coulomb potential A˛ (this is a slight misnomer, but the “Coulomb” here and in all other instances where we use this phrase is a reference to the gauge) is defined in terms of lower-frequency approximations which are already controlled, see the next subsection for more details. In keeping with the Kenig–Merle method, the Bahouri–Gérard decomposition is used to show the following: assume that a uniform bound of the form k kS C.E/ for some function C.E/ fails for some finite energy levels E. In particular, the set ˚ A WD E 2 RC j sup k kS D 1 ¤ ; k kL2 E x
P 1 where we loosely denote the energy by k kL2x D . 2˛D0 k ˛ k2 2 / 2 , and we can Lx then define a number, denoted throughout the rest of this book by Ecrit , as follows: Ecrit D inf E E 2A
(1.23)
Then there must exist a weak wave map ucritical W . T0 ; T1 / ! S to a compact Riemann surface uniformized by H2 , which enjoys certain compactness properties. In the final part of the argument we then need to rule out the existence of such an object, arriving at an eventual contradiction at the end of the book.
14
1 Introduction and overview
Starting this grand contradiction argument here, we now assume as above that A ¤ ;; this implies that there is a sequence of Schwartz class (on fixed time slices) wave maps un W . T0n ; T1n / R2 ! H2 with the properties that ı k n kL2x ! Ecrit , ı limn!1 k n kS.. T0n ;T1n /R2 / D 1. Thus all these wave maps have t D 0 in their domain of definition. We shall call such a sequence of wave maps essentially singular. Roughly speaking, we shall proceed along the following steps. First, recall that the Bahouri–Gérard theorem is a genuine phase-space result in the sense that it identifies the main asymptotic .`/ carriers of energy which are not pure radiation, which would then sit in wn . This refers to the free waves V .j / above, which are “localized” in frequency (namely at .j / scale ."n / 1 ) as well as in physical spaces (namely around the space-time points .j / .j / .j / .tn ; xn / ). The procedure of filtering out the scales "n is due to Metivier– Schochet, see [33]. (1) Bahouri–Gérard I: Filtering out frequency blocks. If we apply the frequency localization procedure of Metivier–Schochet to the n n derivative components ˛n D . @˛ynx ; @˛yny / of an essentially singular sequence at time t D 0, we run into the problem that the resulting frequency components are not necessarily related to an actual map from R2 ! H2 . We introduce a procedure to obtain a frequency decomposition which is “geometric”, i.e., the frequency localized pieces are themselves derivative components of maps from R2 ! H2 . More specifically, in Section 9.2, we start with decompositions ˛n D
A X
Q ˛na C w˛nA ; ˛ D 0; 1; 2
aD1
where the Q ˛na are “frequency atoms” obtained from the first stage of the standard Bahouri–Gérard process, see [1]. Here it may be assumed that the frequency scales in the cases ˛ D 0; 1; 2 are identical. Since the Q ˛na do not necessarily form the derivative components of admissible maps into H2 , one replaces them by components ˛na which are derivative components of admissible maps, subject to the same frequency scales. (2) Refining the considerations on frequency localization; frequency localized approximative maps. In order to deal with the non-atomic (in the frequency sense) derivative components, which may still have large energy, we need to be able to truncate the derivative components arbitrarily in frequency while still retaining the geometric interpretation. Here we shall use arguments just as in the first step to allow us to “build up” the components ˛n from low fre-
15
1.4 The Bahouri–Gérard concentration compactness method
quency ones. In the end, we of course need to show that for some subsequence of the ˛n , the frequency support is essentially atomic. If this were to fail, we deduce an a priori bound on k ˛n kS.. T0n ;T1n /R2 / . Specifically, we show in Section 9.3 that judicious choice of an interval J , depending on the position of the Fourier support of the frequency atoms ˛na allows us to truncate the components ˛n to PJ ˛n while retaining their “geometric significance”, i.e., the components PJ ˛na , ˛ D 0; 1; 2 are also derivative components of a map up to arbitrarily small errors. (3) Assuming the presence of a lowest energy non-atomic type component, establish an a priori estimate for its nonlinear evolution. More precisely, in nA
.0/
Section 9.4, we replace ˛n by components ˚˛ 0 , which arise by truncating the frequency support of ˛n to sufficiently low frequencies such that all frequency atoms with energy above a certain threshold are eliminated. In order to obtain a priori bounds on the evolution of the associated Coulomb .0/
components
nA ˛ 0
.0/
.0/
P nA0 1 nA D ˚˛ 0 e i kD1;2 4 @k ˚k , .0/ nA0 the ˚˛ by frequency truncated
we use the previous .0/
nA
step to approximate PJj ˚˛ 0 for judiciously chosen increasing intervals Jj , whose number only depends on the energy Ecrit . A finite induction procedure then leads to a priori bounds on nA
.0/
the ˛ 0 , provided n is chosen large enough (only depending on Ecrit ). Here we already encounter the difficulty that the low frequency components appear to interact strongly with the high-frequency components in the nonlinearity, a stark contrast to the defocussing nonlinear critical wave equation. In particular, in order to “bootstrap” the bounds on the differences of the nA
.0/
Coulomb potentials associated with the PJj ˚˛ 0 , we have to invoke energy estimates for covariant wave equations of the form u C 2i @ uA D 0. (4) Bahouri–Gérard II, applied to the first atomic frequency component. In Section 9.6, assuming that we have constructed the first “low frequency ap.0/
nA
proximation” ˚˛ 0 in the previous step, we need to filter out the concentration profiles (analogous to the V .j / at the beginning of this subsection) corresponding to the frequency atoms above the minimum energy threshold and at lowest possible frequency. This is where we have to deviate from Bahouri–Gérard: instead of the free wave operator, we need to use the covariant wave operator An D C 2iAn @ to model the asymptotics as t ! ˙1, where An is the Coulomb potential associated with the low fre.0/
nA0
quency approximation ˚˛
. Thus we obtain the concentration profiles
16
1 Introduction and overview
as weak limits of the data under the covariant wave evolution. Again a lot of effort needs to be expended on showing that the components we obtain are actually the Coulomb derivative components of Schwartz maps from R2 ! H2 , up to arbitrarily small errors in energy. Once we have this, we can then use the result from the stability section in order to construct the time evolution of these pieces and obtain their a priori dispersive behavior. (5) Bahouri–Gérard II; completion. Here we repeat Steps 3 and 4 for the ensuing frequency pieces, to complete the estimate for the ˛n . The conclusion is that upon choosing n large enough, we arrive at a contradiction, unless there is precisely one frequency component and precisely one atomic physical component forming that frequency component. These are the data that then gives rise to the weak wave map with the desired compactness properties.
1.5
The Kenig–Merle agument
In [14], [15], Kenig and Merle developed an approach to the global wellposendess for defocusing energy critical semilinear Schrödinger and wave equations; moreover, their argument yields a blow-up/global existence dichotomy in the focusing case as well, provided the energy of the wave lies beneath a certain threshold. See [7] for an application of these ideas to wave maps. Let us give a brief overview of their argument. Consider u C u5 D 0 in R1C3 with data in HP 1 L2 . It is standard that this equation is well-posed for small data provided we place the solution in the energy space intersected with suitable Strichartz spaces. Moreover, if I is the maximal interval of existence, then necessarily kukL8 .I IL8x .R3 // D 1 and the energy E.u/ is conserved. t Now suppose Ecrit is the maximal energy with the property that all solutions in the above sense with E.u/ < Ecrit exist globally and satisfy kukL8 .RIL8x .R3 // t < 1. Then by means of the Bahouri–Gérard decomposition, as well as the perturbation theory for this equation one concludes that a critical solution uC exists on some interval I and that kuC kL8 .I IL8x .R3 // D 1. Moreover, by similar t arguments one obtains the crucial property that the set n 1 o 3 K WD 2 .t /u .t / x y.t / ; t ; 2 .t /@ t u .t / x y.t / ; t W t 2I
1.5 The Kenig–Merle agument
17
is precompact in HP 1 L2 .R3 / for a suitable path .t /; y.t /. To see this, one applies the Bahouri–Gérard decomposition to a sequence un of solutions with energy E.un / ! Ecrit from above. The logic here is that due to the minimality assumption on Ecrit only a single limiting profile can arise in (1.20) up to errors that go to zero in energy as n ! 1. Indeed, if this were not the case then due to fact that the profiles diverge from each other in physical space as n ! 1 one can then apply the perturbation theory to conclude that each of the individual nonlinear evolutions of the limiting profiles (which exist due to the fact that their energies are strictly below Ecrit ) can be superimposed to form a global nonlinear evolution, contradicting the choice of the sequence un . The fact that ` D 1 allows one to rescale and re-translate the unique limiting profile to a fixed position in phase space (meaning spatial position and spatial frequency) which then gives the desired nonlinear evolution uC . The compactness follows by the same logic: assuming that it does not hold, one then obtains a sequence uC .; tn / evaluated at times tn 2 I converging to an endpoint of I such that for n ¤ n0 , the rescaled and translated versions of uC .; tn / and uC .; tn0 / remain at a minimal positive distance from each other in the energy norm. Again one applies Bahouri–Gérard and finds that ` D 1 by the choice of Ecrit and perturbation theory. This gives the desired contradiction. The compactness property is of course crucial; indeed, for illustrative purposes suppose that uC is of the form 1 uC .t; x/ D .t / 2 U .t / x x.t / where .t/ ! 1 as t ! 1, say. Then uC blows up at time t D 1 (in the sense that the energy concentrates at the tip of a cone) and .t /
1 2
uC .t /
1
x C x.t / D U.x/
is compact for 0 t < 1. Returning to the Kenig–Merle argument, the logic is now to show that uC acts in some sense like a blow-up solution, at least if I is finite in one direction. The second half of the Kenig–Merle approach then consists of a rigidity argument which shows that a uC with the stated properties cannot exist. This is done mainly by means of the conservation laws, such as the Morawetz and energy identities. More precisely, the case where I is finite at one end is reduced to the self-similar blow-up scenario. This, however, is excluded by reducing to the stationary case and an elliptic analysis which proves that the solution would have to vanish. If I is infinite, one basically faces the possibility of stationary solutions which are again shown not to exist.
18
1 Introduction and overview
For the case of wave maps, we follow the same strategy. More precisely, our adaptation of the Bahouri–Gérard decomposition to wave maps into H2 leads to a critical wave map with the desired compactness properties. In the course of our proof, it will be convenient to project the wave map onto a compact Riemann surface S (so that we can avail ourselves of the extrinsic formulation of the wave map equation). However, it will be important to work simultaneously with this object as well as the lifted one which takes its values in H2 (since it is for the latter that we have a meaningful well-posedness theory for maps with energy data). The difference from [14] lies mainly with the rigidity part. In fact, in our context the conservation laws are by themselves not sufficient to yield a contradiction. This is natural, since the geometry of the target will need to play a crucial role. As indicated above, the two scenarios that are lead to a contradiction are the self-similar blow-up supported inside of a light-cone and the stationary weak wave map, which is of course a weakly harmonic map (which cannot exist since the target S is compact with negative curvature). The former is handled as follows: in self-similar coordinates, one obtains a harmonic map defined on the disk with the hyperbolic metric and with finite energy (the stationarity is derived as in [14]). Moreover, there is the added twist that one controls the behavior of this map at the boundary in the trace sense (in fact, one shows that this trace is constant). Therefore, one can apply the boundary regularity version of Helein’s theorem which was obtained by Qing [37]. Lemaire’s theorem [27] then yields the constancy of the harmonic map, whence the contradiction (for a version of this argument under the a priori assumption of regularity all the way to the boundary see Shatah–Struwe [42]).
1.6
An overview of the book
The book is essentially divided into two parts: The modified Bahouri–Gérard method is carried out in its entirety starting with Chapter 2, and ending with Chapter 9. Indeed, all that precedes Chapter 9 leads to this section, which constitutes the core of this book. The Kenig–Merle method adapted to Wave Maps is then performed in the much shorter Chapter 10. We commence by describing in detail the contents of Chapter 2 to Chapter 9.
1.6 An overview of the book
19
1.6.1 Preparations for the Bahouri–Gérard process As explained above, we describe admissible wave maps u W R2C1 ! H2 mostly in terms of the associated Coulomb derivative components ˛ . Our goals then are to (1) Develop a suitable functional framework, in particular a space-time norm k kS.R2C1 / , together with time-localized versions k kS.ŒI R2 / for closed time intervals I , which have the property that lim sup k kS.I R2 / < 1 I IQ
for some open interval IQ implies that the underlying wave map u can be extended smoothly and admissibly beyond any endpoint of IQ, provided such exists. (2) Establish an a priori bound of the form k kS.I R2 / C.E/ for some function C W RC ! RC of the energy E. This latter step will be accomplished by the Bahouri–Gérard procedure, arguing by contradiction. We first describe (1) above in more detail: in Chapter 2, we introduce the norms k kS Œk , k kN Œk , k 2 Z, which are used to control the frequency localized components of and the nonlinear source terms, respectively. The norm k kS is then obtained by square summation over all frequency blocks. The basic paradigm for establishing estimates on then is to formulate a wave equation
DF
or more accurately typically in frequency localized form P0
D P0 F;
and to establish bounds for kP0 F kN Œ0 which may then be fed into an energy inequality, see Section 2.3, which establishes the link between the S and N -spaces. In order to be able to estimate the nonlinear source terms F , we need to manipulate the right-hand side of (1.14), making extensive use of (1.15). The precise description of the actual nonlinear source terms that we will use for F is actually rather involved, and given in Chapter 3. In order to estimate the collection of trilinear as well as higher order terms, we carefully develop the necessary estimates in Chapters 4, 5, as well as 6. We note that the estimates in [23], while similar,
20
1 Introduction and overview
are not quite strong enough for our purposes, since we need to gain in the largest frequency in case of high-high cascades. This requires us to subtly modify the spaces by comparison to loc. cit. Moreover, the fact that we manage here to build in sharp Strichartz estimates allows us to replace several arguments in [23] by more natural ones, and we opted to make our present account as self-contained as possible. With the null-form estimates from Chapters 4, 5, 6 in hand, we establish the role of k kS as a “regularity controlling” device in the sense of (1) above in Chapter 7, see Proposition 7.2. The proof of this reveals a somewhat unfortunate feature of our present setup, namely the fact that working at the level of the differentiated wave map system produces sometimes too many time derivatives, which forces us to use somewhat delicate “randomization” of times arguments. In particular, in the proof of all a priori estimates, we need to distinguish between a “small time” case (typically called Case 1) and a “long time” Case 2, by reference to a fixed frequency scale. In the short time case, one works exclusively in terms of the div-curl system, while in the long-time case, the wave equations start to be essential. Chapter 7 furthermore explains the well-posedness theory at the level of the ˛ , see the most crucial Proposition 7.11. We do not prove this proposition in Chapter 7, as it follows as a byproduct of the core perturbative Proposition 9.12 in Chapter 9. Proposition 7.11 and the technically difficult but fundamental Lemma 7.10 allow us to define the “Coulomb wave maps propagation” for a tuple 2 ˛ , ˛ D 0; 1; 2 which are only L functions at time t D 0, provided the latter are the L2 -limits of the Coulomb components of admissible maps. Indeed, this concept of propagation is independent of the approximating sequence chosen and satisfies the necessary continuity properties. We also formulate the concept of a “wave map at infinity” at the level of the Coulomb components, see Proposition 7.15 and the following Corollary 7.16. Again the proofs of these results will follow as a byproduct of the fundamental Proposition 9.12 and Proposition 9.30 in the core Chapter 9. In Chapter 8, we develop some auxiliary technical tools from harmonic analysis which will allow us to implement the first stage of the Bahouri–Gérard process, namely crystallizing frequency atoms from an “essentially singular” sequence of admissible wave maps. These tools are derived from the embedding 1 BP 2;1 .R2 / ! BMO as well as weighted (relative to Ap ) Coifman–Rochberg– Weiss commutator bounds. As mentioned before, Chapter 9 represents the core of this book. In Section 9.2, starting with an essentially singular sequence un of admissible wave maps with deteriorating bounds, i.e., k ˛n kS ! 1 as n ! 1 but with the
1.6 An overview of the book
21
crucial criticality condition limn!1 E.un / D Ecrit , we show that the derivative components ˛n may be decomposed as a sum ˛n
D
A X
˛na C w˛nA
aD1
where the ˛na are derivative components of admissible wave maps which have frequency supports “drifting apart” as n ! 1, while the error w˛nA satisfies lim sup kw˛nA kBP 0 n!1
2;1
< ı;
provided A A0 .ı/ is large enough. In Section 9.3, we then select a number of “principal” frequency atoms na , a D 1; 2; : : : ; A0 , as well as a (potentially very large) collection of “small atoms” na , a D A0 C 1; : : : ; A. We order these atoms by the frequency scale around which they are supported starting with those of the lowest frequency. The idea now is as follows: under the assumption that there are at least two frequency atoms, or else in case of only one frequency atom that it has energy < Ecrit , we want to obtain a contradiction to the essential criticality of the underlying sequence un . To achieve this, we define in Section 9.3 sequences of approximating wave maps, which are essentially obtained by carefully truncating the initial data sequence na in frequency space. In Section 9.4, we establish an a priori bound for the lowest frequency approximating map which comprises all the minimum frequency small atoms as well as the component of the small Besov error of smallest frequency, see Proposition 9.9. The proof of this follows again by truncating the data suitably in frequency space, and applying an inductive procedure to a sequence of approximating wave maps. This hinges crucially on the core perturbative result Proposition 9.12, which plays a fundamental role in this book. The main technical difficulty encountered in the proof of the latter comes from the issue of divisibility: let us be given a schematically written expression @ A which is linear in the perturbation (so that we cannot perform a bootstrap argument based solely on the smallness on itself), while A denotes some null-form depending on a priori controlled components . “Divisibility” means the property that upon suitably truncating time into finitely many intervals Ij whose number only depends on k kS , one may bound the expression by k@ A kN.Ij R2 / kkS :
22
1 Introduction and overview
In other words, by shrinking the time interval, we ensure that we can iterate the term away. While this would be straightforward provided we had an estimate for kA kL1 L1 (which is possible in space dimensions n 4), in our setting, t x the spaces are much too weak and complicated. Our way out of this impasse is to build those terms for which we have no obvious divisibility into the linear operator, and thereby form a new operator A WD C 2i @ A with a magnetic potential term. Fortunately, it turns out that if A is supported at much lower frequencies than (which is precisely the case where divisibility fails), one can establish an approximate energy conservation result, which in particular gives a priori control over a certain constituent of k kS . With this in hand, one can complete the bootstrap argument, and obtain full control over kkS . Having established control over the lowest-frequency “essentially non-atomic” approximating wave map in Section 9.4, we face the task of “adding the first large atomic component”, n1 . It is here that we have to depart crucially from the original method of Bahouri–Gérard: instead of studying the free wave evolution of the data, we extract concentration cores by applying the “twisted” covariant evolution associated with An u D 0; which is essentially defined as above. The key property that makes everything work is an almost exact energy conservation property associated with its wave flow. This is a rather delicate point, and uses the Hamiltonian structure of the covariant wave flow. It then requires a fair amount of work to show that the profile decomposition at time t D 0 in terms of covariant free waves is “geometric”, in the sense that the concentration profiles can indeed by approximated by the Coulomb components of admissible maps, up to a constant phase shift, see Proposition 9.24. Finally, in Proposition 9.30 we show that we may evolve the data including the first large frequency atom, provided all concentration cores have energy strictly less than Ecrit . As most of the work has been done at this point, adding on the remaining frequency atoms in Section 9.9 does not provide any new difficulties, and can be done by the methods of the preceding sections. In conjunction with the results of Chapter 7, we can then infer that given an essentially singular sequence of wave maps un , we may select a subsequence of them whose Coulomb components ˛n , up to re-scalings and translations, converge to a limiting object ˛1 .t; x/, which is well-defined on some interval I R2
1.6 An overview of the book
23
where I is either a finite time interval or (semi)-infinite, and the limit of the Coulomb components of admissible maps there. Moreover, most crucially for the sequel, ˛1 .t; x/ satisfies a remarkable compactness property, see Proposition 9.36. This sets the stage for the method of Kenig–Merle, which we adapt to the context of wave maps in Chapter 10.
2
The spaces S Œk and N Œk
Chapters 2–5 develop the functional framework needed to prove the energy and dispersive estimates required by the wave map system (1.12)–(1.14). The Banach spaces which appear in this context were introduced by Tataru [63], but were specified in this form by Tao [58], and developed further by Krieger [23]. We will largely follow the latter reference although there is much overlap with [58]. We emphasize that this section is self-contained. The spatial dimension is two throughout.
2.1
Preliminaries
As usual, Pk denotes a Littlewood–Paley projection1 to frequencies of size 2k . More precisely, let m0 be a nonnegative smooth, even, bump function supported in jj < 4 and set m./ WD m0 ./ m0 .2/. Then X m.2k / D 1 8 2 R2 n f0g k2Z
b
and Pk f ./ WD m.2 k /fO./. In the sequel, we shall call a function f adapted to k, provided its Fourier transform is supported at frequency 2k . The operator Qj projects to modulation 2j , i.e., Qj .; / WD m 2 j .j j jj/ b .; /
b
with O referring to the space-time Fourier transform. Similarly, Qj˙ .; / WD m 2 j .j j jj/ Œ˙ >0b .; /:
1
s;p;q Then the relevant XP k spaces here are defined as X q kkXP s;p;q WD 2sk 2jpq kPk Qj k 2 k
1
j
L t L2x
q1
:
Strictly speaking, these are not true projections since Pk2 ¤ Pk , but we shall nevertheless follow the customary abuse of language of referring to them as projections. The same applies to smooth localizers to other regions in Fourier space.
26
2 The spaces S Œk and N Œk A B P6 P5 P4 P3 P2 P1 D C
Figure 2.1. Rectangles
If Pk D , then kkL1 L2x . kk t
1 ;1 0; 2
XP k
as well as kkL1 . kk t;x
1 ;1 1; 2
XP k 1 2`
.
In what follows, C` is a collection of caps S 1 of size C and finite overlap (uniformly bounded in ` and with CPsome large absolute constant). There is an associated smooth partition of unity 2C` a .!/ D 1 for all ! 2 S 1 , as well as projections P f ./ WD a b fO./ where b WD . By construction,
b
Pk; WD Pk ı P is a projection to the “rectangle”
jj
˚ Rk; WD jj 2k ; b 2
(2.1)
in Fourier space. For space-time functions F we shall follow the convention that O Œ >0 FO .; / _ C a . / O Œ <0 FO .; / _ : P F D a ./ We will also encounter other rectangles R which are obtained by dividing Rk; in the radial direction into 2 m many subrectangles of comparable size where m < 0 is some integer parameter (it will suffice for us to consider ` m 0 where 2 C` ). The collection of these Prectangles will be denoted by Rk;;m , and we introduce projections PR so that R2Rk;;m PR D Pk; . Figure 2.1 exhibits
27
2.1 Preliminaries
such a collection of rectangles. The sector ABCD is of length 2k and width 2`Ck , whereas the shorter segments AP1 , P1 P2 etc. are of length 2kCm . O ˝, where We shall frequently use Bernstein’s inequality: if supp./ 1 1 ˝ R2 is measurable, then kkq . j˝j p q kkp for any choice of 1 p q 1. We shall also require the following variant of Bernstein’s L2 ! L1 bound, which is obtained by combining the standard form of this bound with the 1C2 /-Strichartz estimate for the wave equation. This type of estimate L4t L1 x .R appears in [59], but the following formulation is from [23], which involves one further localization on the Fourier side. We present the proof for the sake of completeness. ˚ Lemma 2.1. Let Dk;` be a cover of jj 2k by disks of radius 2kC` . Then for all j k, X c2Dk;`
2 kPc Qj kL 2 1 t Lx
12
`
. 22 2
3k 4
2
j
k 4
kkL2 L2x ; t
(2.2)
for any which is adapted to k. Proof. We follow the argument in [58], but use the small-scale Strichartz estimate of Klainerman–Tataru at a crucial place, see Lemma 2.17 below. First, set j D 0, whence k 1. Construct a Schwartz function a.t / whose Fourier transform is supported in j j 1, and which satisfies 1D
X
a3 .t
s/
s2Z
for all t 2 R. Then
X 3
kPc Q0 kL2 L1 a .t x t
s/Pc Q0 L2 L1 t
s
X
a2 .t . s
.
X
a.t s
s/Pc Q0
x
21
2
2
L t L1 x
21
2 s/Pc Q0 L4 L1 : t
x
Now one notes that the function a.t s/Pc Q0 satisfies almost the same assumptions about modulation ( 1) and frequency localization as Pc Q0 . Therefore,
28
2 The spaces S Œk and N Œk
we can apply the improved Strichartz estimate of Klainerman–Tataru [22] to estimate
`
a.t s/Pc Q0 4 1 . 2 3k 4 2 2 kP c k 0; 1 ;1 : L L XP k
x
t
2
Thus kPc Q0 kL2 L1 .2 x
3k 4
t
`
22
21
2 s/Q0 Pc 0; 1 ;1
X
a.t
XP k
s2Z
.2
3k 4
2
`
2 2 kPc Q0 kL2 L2x : t
The lemma follows via Plancherel’s theorem.
The previous proof was based on the following small-scale version of the usual L4t L1 x -Strichartz estimate. It was obtained by Klainerman and Tataru [22]. Lemma 2.2. With Dk;` as above, one has X
2 kPc e i t jrj f kL 4 1 L t
c2Dk;`
x
12
`
. 22 2
3k 4
kf kL2x
(2.3)
for any k-adapted f . In particular, X
2 kPc kL 4 1 L
c2Dk;`
t
x
12
`
. 2 2 kk
3 ; 1 ;1 2
XP k4
(2.4)
for any Schwartz function which is adapted to k.
2.2
The null-frame spaces
In contrast to sub-critical HP s .R2 / data with s > 1, it is well-known that XP s;b spaces do not suffice in the critical case s D 1. Following the aforementioned references, we now develop Tataru’s null-frame spaces which will provide sufficient control over the nonlinear interactions in the wave map system. For fixed2 ! 2 S 1 define p !˙ WD .1; ˙!/= 2; t! WD .t; x/ !C ; x! WD .t; x/ t! !C ; (2.5) 2
Henceforth, ! will always be a unit vector in the plane.
29
2.2 The null-frame spaces
which are the coordinates defined by a generator on the light-cone. Recall that a plane wave traveling in direction ! 2 S n 1 is a function of the form h.x ! C t / (and h sufficiently smooth). We write a free wave as a superposition of such plane waves: with S 1 and Pk; the projection to jj 2k and b 2 as defined above, Z e i.t jjCx/ Pk; f ./ d Pk; .t; x/ D Œjj2k Z Z D e i r.x!Ct / fO.r!/ r drd! k Œr2 Z D (2.6) k;! .t C x !/ d!;
1
where
Z k;! .s/
The argument of
k;!
WD
in (2.6) is
p
e i rs fO.r!/r dr:
Œr2k
2 t! , whence
Z
k
k;! kL2t L1 ! x!
1
k
d! . jj 2 2 2 kPk; f k2 :
(2.7)
We now define the following pair of norms3 kGkNFAŒ WD inf dist.!; / !622
kkPWAŒ WD inf kkL2
1 t! Lx!
!2
1
kGkL1
2 t! Lx!
(2.8) (2.9)
which are well-defined for general Schwartz functions. The notation here derives from null-frame and plane wave, respectively. The quantities defined in (2.8) and (2.9) are not norms – in fact, not even pseudo-norms – because they violate the triangle inequality due to the infimum. This indicates that we should be using (2.8) and (2.9) to define atomic Banach spaces (which is why we appended “A” in the norms above). First, recall from (2.6) that Z p Pk1 ; .t; x/ D k;! . 2 t! / d!:
3
The dist.!; / 1 factor in the NFAŒ-norm arises because of a geometric property of the cone, see the proof of Lemma 2.4.
30
2 The spaces S Œk and N Œk
Then (2.7) suggests that we define Z kPk1 ; kPWŒ WD k k;! kL2
Z
1 t! Lx!
d! D
k
k;! kPWAŒ d!:
In other words, PWŒ is the completion of the space of all functions which can be written in the form X X D j j ; jj j < 1; k j kPWAŒ 1 (2.10) j
j
where j 2 C and j are Schwartz P functions, say. The norm of any such in PWŒ is then simply the infimum of j jj j over all representations as in (2.10). By Hölder’s inequality we now obtain the simple but crucial estimate kF kNFAŒ dist.; 0 /
1
kkPWAŒ 0 kF kL2 L2x ; t
provided is a PWAŒ-atom. This suggests that we also define NFŒ as the atomic space obtained from NFAŒ as usual: the atoms of NFŒ are functions for which there exists ! 62 2 such that kkL1 L2x dist.!; /. The previous t! ! estimate then implies the bound kF kNFŒ dist.; 0 /
1
kkPWŒ 0 kF kL2 L2x :
(2.11)
t
The dual space NFŒ is characterized by the norm kkNFŒ D sup dist.!; /kkL1 L2x < 1: t!
!622
!
We now turn to defining the spaces which hold the wave maps. O f 2 R2 W jj 2k g. Definition 2.3. Let be a Schwarz function with supp./ Henceforth, we shall call such a adapted to k. Define kkS Œk; WD kkL1 L2x C jj
1 2
t
2
k 2
kkPWŒ C kkNF Œ
(2.12)
kkS Œk WD kkL1 L2x C kQkC2 k P 0; 1 ;1 C kQk k P 1 C";1 ";2 (2.13) t X 2 X 2 21 X 3k . 12 "/` 2 4 C sup sup 2 2 kQ<j Pc kL4 L1 (2.14) j 2Z `0
C sup sup
c2Dk;`
sup
˙ ` 100 `m0
X
X
t
x
˙ kPR QkC2` k2S Œk;
21
:
2C` R2Rk;˙;m
(2.15) Here P and PR are as above, and " > 0 is a small number (" D
1 10
is sufficient).
31
2.2 The null-frame spaces 1
k
The factors jj 2 2 2 in (2.12) are from (2.7). By inspection, the norm of S Œk; is translation invariant, and kkS Œk; : kf kS Œk; kf kL1 tx
(2.16)
One has the following scaling property: kkS Œk D k./kS ŒkCm ;
D 2m ; m 2 Z:
(2.17)
It will be technically convenient to allow noninteger k in Definition 2.3. The only change required for this purpose is to allow j; `; m 2 R in (2.14) and (2.15). In that case one has kkS Œk D k./kS ŒkClog2 ;
8 > 0:
(2.18)
Later we will need to address the question whether kPk kS ŒkCh is continuous in h near h DP 0 for a fixed Schwartz function . Henceforth, we shall use the operator I WD k2Z Pk Qk and I c WD 1 I (we will also use QkCC instead of Qk ). Moreover, we refer to functions which belong to the range of I as “hyperbolic” and to those in the range of I c as “elliptic”. Since kQk Pk k
1 ;1 0; 2
XP k
. kQk Pk k
XP k
1 C";1 ";2 2
;
2 one concludes that the energy norm L1 t Lx in (2.13) as well as the Strichartz norm of (2.14) are controlled by the final norm of (2.13) for the case of elliptic functions (for the Strichartz norm use Lemma 2.2). We first verify that temporally truncated free waves lie in these spaces (with an embedding constant that does not depend on the length of the truncation interval).
Lemma 2.4. Let S 1 be arbitrary. Then kkS Œk; . kPk; k
(2.19)
1
XP 0; 2 ;1
as well as kPk Qk kS Œk . kPk Qk k
1
XP 0; 2 ;1
:
(2.20)
In particular, if f is adapted to k, then k.t =T /e i t
p
f kS Œk C kf kL2
with a constant that depends on the Schwartz function but not on T 2
(2.21) k.
32
2 The spaces S Œk and N Œk
1 Proof. We assume that is an XP 0; 2 ;1 -atom with P0; D . Then from Plancherel’s theorem and Minkowski’s and Hölder’s inequalities, j
O 2 1 . 2 2 kk 2 2 kkL1 L2x . kk L L L Lx t
t
kkL2
1 t! L x !
1 2
1
O 2 . .2j jj/ kk L
2 ! L!
D .2j jj/ 2 kkL2 L2x t
j 2
kkL1 L2x . t!
!
2 kkL2 L2 : ! ! dist.; !/
(2.22)
In the final estimate (2.22) we used that ^.`! ; T! 0 / ^.!; ! 0 /2 where `! is the line oriented along the generator parallel to .1; !/ and T! 0 is the tangent plane to the cone which touches the cone along the generator `! 0 . To establish (2.20) we begin with sup
X
` 100
X
˙ kPR Q2` k2 0; 1 ;1 XP 0
2C` R2Rk;˙;
12
. kk
0; 1 2 ;1
XP 0
2
which is obvious from orthogonality of the P0;˙ . In view of (2.19), this bound yields the square function in (2.15). The energy is controlled via the embedding kkL1 L2 . kk P 0; 1 ;1 , whereas the Strichartz component of S Œk is controlled X 2 by Lemma 2.2. Finally, the statement concerning the free wave reduces to the case k D 0 for which we need to verify the bound X
j 2 2 kT O T j ˙ jk m 2
j
j ˙ jjj fO./kL2 L2 C
j 2Z
C
X
22j kT O T j ˙ jjj m 2
j
21 2 j ˙ jjj fO./kL . kf k2 2 2 L
j 2Z
which are both clear provided T 1 due to the rapid decay of . O
Naturally, S Œk contains more general functions than just free waves. One way of obtaining such functions is to take D 1 F , in other words from the Duhamel formula. We will study this in much greater generality in the context of the energy estimate below, but for now we take F to be a Schwartz function. Remark 2.5. The bounded function defined via its Fourier transform b .; / D 1 ./2 .jj
j j/.jj
jj/
1
33
2.2 The null-frame spaces
belongs to SŒ0 but is not a truncated free wave. Here 1 is a smooth cut-off to jj 1, and 2 .u/ is a smooth cut-off to juj < 1=10. We leave it to the reader to construct other functions which lie in S Œ0 and which are not (truncated) free waves. The following basic estimates will be used repeatedly: ı if is adapted to k, then .j k/. 12 "/
kQj kL2 L2 . min.2 kQj kL2 L1 . 2k 2
j
k 4
^0
min.2
; 1/2 .j
j 2
k/. 12
kkS Œk ; "/
; 1/2
(2.23) j 2
kkS Œk :
(2.24)
This follows from the XP s;b;q components of the S Œk-norms, as well as the improved Bernstein’s inequality of Lemma 2.1. ı The duality between NFŒ and NF Œ implies jh; F ij . kkS Œk; kF kNFŒ :
(2.25)
In what follows, WD sign. /b , and for any ! 2 S 1 , ˘! denotes the orthogonal ? projection onto NP.!/ WD ! (the null-plane of !). Lemma 2.6. The projection ˘! satisfies the following properties: ı Let F C` be a collection of disjoint caps. Suppose that ! 2 S 1 satisfies dist.!; / 2 Œ˛; 2˛ for any 2 F where ˛ > 2` is arbitrary but fixed. Define4 ˚ T;˛ WD .; / W jj 1; 2 ; jjj j jj . ˛2` : (2.26) Then f˘! .T;˛ /g2F NP.!/ have finite overlap, i.e., X ˘! .T;˛ / C 2F
where C is some absolute constant. ı Let ˚ S WD .˙jj; / W 2 R2 ; b 2 ˙ be a sector on the light-cone where S 1 is any cap. Furthermore, let ! 62 2 and e S WD ˘! .S/. Then on e S the Jacobian @@! satisfies ˇ @ ˇ ˇ ˇ (2.27) ˇ ˇ d.!; / 2 : @! 4
An important detail here is that these dimensions deviate from the usual wave-packets of dimension 1 2` 22` .
34
2 The spaces S Œk and N Œk X
Y
Z
C
D0
D
X0 Y0
Z0
C0
A0
P0 Q0 R0
B0 A
P Q R
B Figure 2.2. The projected sectors
The same holds on ˘! .Sa / where ˚ Sa WD ˙ jj C a; W 2 R2 ; jj 1; b 2 ˙ ; provided a is fixed with jaj jjd.!; /. Proof. Denote ˚ S WD s.1; ! 0 / C .1; ! 0 / W ! 0 2 ; 1 s 2; jj < h where h will be determined. Then ˚ ˘! .S /g2F D fs vE C w E W ! 0 2 ; 1 s 2; jj < h where vE WD vE.!; ! 0 / D .1; ! 0 /
.1; !/;
w E WD .1; ! 0 /
.1; !/;
with D 12 .1C!! 0 /, D 12 .1 !! 0 /. Recall that dist.!; / dist.!; 0 / DW ˛ where 2 F is arbitrary. Moreover, diam./ 2` DW ˇ. One checks that q p jE v j D 2.1 2 / ˛:
35
2.2 The null-frame spaces
Furthermore, @E v WD .0; ! 0 ? / 21 ! ! 0 ? .1; !/ denotes the derivative @ 0 vE where 0 we have written ! 0 D e i . Then j@E v j 1 and vE ^ @E v D .; ! 0
?
! C !/ ^ .0; ! 0 /
1 ? ! ! 0 .1; ! 0 / ^ .1; !/ 2
satisfies jE v ^ @E v j ˛ 2 . In conjunction with jE v j ˛ this implies that j^.E v ; @E v /j ˛. Since ˇ ˇ ˇvE.!; ! 0 / vE.!; ! 00 /ˇ & j! 0 ! 00 j 8 ! 0 ; ! 00 2 0 ; it follows that dist .!; ! 0 /; .!; ! 00 / & ˛j! 0
! 00 j
(2.28)
where ˚ .!; ! 0 / WD s vE.!; ! 0 / W 1 s 2 : Therefore, one needs to take h D ˛ˇ to insure the property of finite overlap of the projections. This is optimal, since one can check that vE and w E always satisfy j cos.^.E v ; w/j E 21 . In Figure 2.2 the left-hand side depicts four sectors as they would appear on the light-cone, whereas the right-hand side is the projected configuration in NP.!/ with A0 WD ˘! .A/ etc. Note that the segments A0 B 0 as well as A0 P 0 , P 0 Q0 , Q0 R0 , R0 B 0 have lengths comparable to the corresponding ones on the left, i.e., AB etc., whereas the lengths of A0 D 0 , B 0 C 0 are those of AD and BC contracted by the factor ˛. Finally, we have shown that ^.A0 B 0 C 0 / ˛ (and similarly for the angles at the points P 0 , Q0 , R0 ) so that the height of the parallelogram A0 P 0 X 0 D 0 is proportional to ˛ times the length of A0 P 0 , see (2.28). The second statement of the lemma follows from the consideration of the preceding paragraph. As a consequence of Lemma 2.6, we now show that the square function in (2.15) can always be refined in terms of the angle. 0 0 Lemma 2.7. S Let F 0 C` be a collection of disjoint caps and let 2 C` be a cap with F . Suppose further that for every 2 F there is a Schwartz function adapted to k 2 Z and which is supported on n o 0 T;k WD WD sign. /b 2 ; jjj j jj . 2`C` Ck
with some k 2 Z. Then
X
S Œk; 0
2F
with some absolute constant C .
C
X 2F
k k2S Œk;
21
36
2 The spaces S Œk and N Œk
Proof. First, one may take k D 0 and > 0 (the latter by conjugation symmetry). The L1 L2 -component of (2.12) satisfies the required property due to orthogonality, whereas the PWŒ-component is reduced to Cauchy–Schwarz (via 1 2 the jj 2 -factor). For the final NF Œ (i.e., L1 t! Lx! )-component one exploits orthogonality relative to x! via the preceding lemma. Here ! 2 S 1 n .2 0 / is arbitrary but fixed. Later we will prove bi- and trilinear estimates involving S and N space. The following bilinear bounds will be a basic ingredient in that context. Lemma 2.8. One has the estimates 1
k0
kF kNFŒ
j 0 j 2 2 2 . kkS Œk 0 ; 0 kF kL2 L2x ; t dist.; 0 /
k kL2 L2x
jj 2 2 2 . kkS Œk; k kS Œk 0 ; 0 : dist.; 0 /
1
t
(2.29)
k
(2.30)
For the final two bounds we require that 2 \ 2 0 D ;. Proof. The second one follows from the definition of the spaces, whereas (2.30) follows from (2.29) and the duality bound (2.25). Note that both of these estimates have a dispersive character, as they involve space-time integrals. By applying ideas from the energy estimate, we will improve on (2.30) in the high-high case, see Lemma 4.5. Next, we define the spaces which will hold the nonlinearities. These spaces differ from those used for example in [23] as far as the “elliptic norm” k k 1 C"; 1 ";2 is concerned. Here the extra XP k
2
" ensures that we achieve exponential gains in the maximal frequencies for certain high-high-low interactions. Definition 2.9. N Œk is generated by the following four types of atoms: With F being k-admissible, either ı kF kL1 L2x 2k , t ı FO is supported on jjj jjj 2j 2k and kF k 1; 1 ;1 1, XP k
ı F D Qk F , kF k
XP k
1 C"; 1 ";2 2
2
1 where " > 0 is as in the S Œk spaces,
ı F P is the sum of wave-packets F : there exists ` 100 such that F D c c 2C` F with all supp.F / supported on either > 0 or < 0, with F supported on jj 2k , jjj j jj C 1 2kC2` , WD sign. /b 2 and to
37
2.2 The null-frame spaces
that the bound X
kF k2NFŒ
12
2k
holds. We refer to these types as energy, XP s;b;q , and wave-packet atoms, respectively. In what follows, we refer to functions adapted to some k 2 Z as “elliptic” iff Pk Qk D , whereas those satisfying Pk Qk D as “hyperbolic”. This terminology has to do with the behavior of the wave operator in these respective regimes. We now record a fundamental duality property of N Œk. Lemma 2.10. For any 2 S Œk and F 2 N Œk with F D Pk Qk F jh; F ij . 2k kkS Œk kF kN Œk ; kF k
XP k
1 ;1 2
1;
. kF kN Œk . kF k
XP k
1;
(2.31) 1 ;1 2
:
(2.32)
Proof. The duality relation (2.31) is proved by taking F to be an atom; for the wave-packet atom use (2.25). By definition of N Œk, one has kF kN Œk . kF k 1; 1 ;1 . For the left-hand bound in (2.32) use (2.19) and (2.31). XP k
2
As an application of the geometric considerations of Lemma 2.6 we now show that refining a wave-packet atom yields another wave-packet atom. Lemma 2.11. Let F D Then
sup
sup
`0 ` `0 j 0
P
X X
2C`
F be a wave-packet atom as in Definition 2.9.
X
0 2C`0 R2Rk; 0 ;j 0
kPR P 0 Q<`C`0 Ck F k2NFŒ 0
12
C 2k (2.33)
with some absolute constant C . Proof. By scaling invariance, we can set k D 0. Moreover, fix `0 ` and `0 j 0. Choose ! 0 D !. 0 / 2 S 1 n .2 0 / for each 0 which attain the respective
38
2 The spaces S Œk and N Œk
NFŒ 0 norm. Then one has X X X kPR P 0 Q<`C`0 F k2NFŒ 0 0 2C`0 R2R0; 0 ;j 0
.
X X
X
d.! 0 ; 0 /
0 2C`0 R2R0; 0 ;j 0
.
X
inf
1 !2S n.2/
d.!; /
2
2 kPR P 0 Q<`C`0 F kL 1
2 t! Lx!
X
2
X
2 kPR P 0 Q<`C`0 F kL 2
0 2C`0 R2R0; 0 ;j 0
x!
21 2
1
L t!
(2.34) .
X
inf
1 !2S n.2/
d.!; /
2
2 kF kL 1
2 t! L x !
:
(2.35)
To pass to (2.34) we used the inclusion `2 .L1t! / L1t! .`2 /, whereas orthogonality implies (2.35). Indeed, first note that [ supp ŒPR P 0 Q<`C`0 F /.t! ; /^ ˘! supp F ŒPR P 0 Q<`C`0 F t! 2R
where the Fourier transform on the left-hand side is in x! and on the right-hand side in .t! ; x! /. Second, the sets on the right-hand side enjoy a finite overlap property by Lemma 2.6. In what follows, we will often need to split a wave into C C where O / _; O / _: C WD Œ 0 .; WD Œ <0 .; The question arises whether the spaces S Œk and N Œk are preserved under these operations. Lemma 2.12. For any Schwartz function which is adapted to k, k ˙ kS Œk C kkS Œk ;
kF ˙ kN Œk C kF kN Œk ;
with some absolute constant C . Proof. We set k D 0 and assume that is adapted to k D 0. Let 0 be a bump function on the line with 0 . / D 1 on C 1 and 0 . / D 0 if 2C 1 where C > 1 is some large constant. Then C c .; / D 0 jj Œ 0b .; / C .1 0 / jj Œ 0b .; /:
39
2.2 The null-frame spaces
Denote the two functions on the right-hand side by .C;1/ and .C;2/ , respectively. Then .C;1/ D (2.36) where is a measure of bounded mass. Therefore, k .C;1/ kS Œ0 C kkS Œ0 : Next, k .C;2/ kS Œ0 C k .C;2/ k
1 ;1 0; 2
XP 0
C kkS Œ0
where we used the Plancherel theorem in the final step. For N Œk it will suffice to check the case of L1t L2x -atoms. For these, we write F C D F .C;1/ C F .C;2/ as above. The first term here is fine from (2.36), whereas the second is placed in L2t L2x and bounded by means of (2.32). Another piece of terminology used by Tao is the following: Definition 2.13. We shall say that a family fm˛ g˛ is disposable, if T˛ f WD .m˛ fO/_ D f ˛ where ˛ are measures with uniformly bounded mass: sup k˛ k C < 1 ˛
with some universal constant C . Clearly, disposable multipliers give rise to bounded operators on any translation invariant Banach space. Thus, if X is a Banach space of functions on RnC1 with the property that for all f 2 X one has kf .
y/kX D kf kX ;
8 y 2 RnC1 ;
then sup˛ kT˛ f kX C kf kX . The following observation will be a useful device for removing frequency cut-offs. Lemma 2.14. The families ˚ Pk; k; ;
˚ Pk Qj j k ;
˚ Pk Q<j j k ;
˚ ˙ Pk Q
C k
40
2 The spaces S Œk and N Œk
are disposable. In the first family is any cap, whereas in the last family C > 0 has to be chosen such that the support of the multiplier associated with Pk Q
100
Proof. Without loss of generality one may take k D 0. Then these statements reduce to simple exercises in harmonic analysis. The following fact will serve as a substitute for the previous problem in a non-disposable context. p
Lemma 2.15. Qj , Q<j are bounded on L t L2x for every 1 p 1 with a constant independent of j 2 Z. Proof. The inverse Fourier transform of Q<j with respect to time alone is Z b .; / d e i t m0 2 j . jj/ F Z O ds D 2j m c0 2j .t s/ e i jj.t s/ F .s; / O in the second line denotes the Fourier transform with respect to the where F .s; / second variable. Consequently, kQ<j F kL1 L2x kc m0 k1 kF kL1 L2x t
as claimed.
t
The previous result, combined with Lemma 2.7, implies the following square function bound. Corollary 2.16. For all j; k 2 Z and all k-adapted Schwartz functions one has kQ<j kS Œk C kkS Œk with some absolute constant C . 2 Proof. We may again take k D 0. The L1 t Lx -component of the S Œ0-norm is covered by Lemma 2.15. The XP s;b;q -components are obvious, the Strichartz norms as well by construction, and the square function is a consequence of Lemma 2.7.
41
2.2 The null-frame spaces
We remark that the analogous statement for N Œk holds as well, see Corollary 2.23 below. Next, for the sake of completeness we state the full range of Strichartz estimates that follow from (2.14). Lemma 2.17. For any 4 p 1 and 2 q 1 which satisfy X
2 kPc kL p q L t
12
C 2`.1
x
2 p
2 q
4" p /
1 p
2k.1
2 q/
1 p
C
1 2q
k kS Œk
14 , (2.37)
c2Dk;`
for any k 2 Z, ` 0, and with an absolute constant C . Proof. Assume first that X
2 kPc kL p q L t
x
12
1 p
C
1 2q
D 14 . By interpolation, and with D
X
X
x
t
c2D0;`
c2D0;`
2.1 / 2 L1 t Lx
2 kPc kL 4 1 kPc k L
2 kPc kL 4 1 L x
t
c2D0;`
2 X
4 p,
12
2 kPc kL 1 2 L t
c2D0;`
1 2
x
(2.38) .2
. 12
"/`
k kS Œ0 :
To pass from (2.38) to the last line, one uses (2.14) as well as the energy compo1 2 1 nent of (2.15). For larger q, one gains a factor 22`. 2 p q / by Bernstein’s inequal1 2 ity, and rescaling to frequency 2k yields a factor of 2k.1 p q / as claimed. Finally, we conclude this section with the following useful fact. Lemma 2.18. Let be adapted to 0. Then for any m0 X
kP0; k2L1 L2 t
2Cm0
12
x
10,
. jm0 jkkS Œ0
Proof. First, X 2Cm0
kP0; Q2m0 k2L1 L2 x t
12
.
X
kP0; Q2m0 k2S Œ0;
21
2Cm0
. kkS Œ0
42
2 The spaces S Œk and N Œk
by (2.15). Second, X
X 2m0 `0
kP0; Q` k2L1 L2 t
2Cm0
12
X
X
.
kP0; Q` k2 0; 1 ;1
x
2m0 `0
XP 0
2Cm0
21
2
. jm0 jkkS Œ0 : And third, kP0; Q0 kL1 L2x . kP0; Q0 k
1 ;1 0; 2
XP 0
t
. kP0; Q0 kXP 0;1
";2
;
0
whence X
kP0; Q0 k2L1 L2 t
2Cm0
12
.
X
x
kP0; Q0 k2P 0;1 X0
2Cm0
. kP0 Q0 kXP 0;1 0
";2
12 ";2
. kkS Œ0
as claimed.
The central problems concerning the S Œk and N Œk spaces are how to obtain an energy estimate and how to control the trilinear nonlinearities appearing in the gauged wave map system. We begin with the energy estimate, and then develop bilinear bounds which are preliminary to the central trilinear bounds.
2.3
The energy estimate
The purpose of this section is to prove the energy estimate in the context of the SŒk and N Œk spaces, see Proposition 2.26 below. First, we require some technical lemmas. The first two of these lemmas will arise in the Duhamel integral. Lemma 2.19. For any F which is k-adapted and satisfies F D QkCC F , kRC F kN Œk . kF kN Œk
(2.39)
where RC acts only in time. Proof. We may assume that k D 0. This is clear if F is an energy atom. Next, we 1 consider the XP 0; 2 ;1 -atoms. First, let FO be supported on jj 1; jjj jjj 2j
43
2.3 The energy estimate
with kF kL2 L2x . 2j=2 . Then t
kRC F kN Œ0 . kP<j .RC /F kN Œ0 C kPj .RC /F kN Œ0 .2
j=2
kP<j .RC /F kL2 L2x C kPj .RC /F kL1 L2
.2
j=2
kP<j .RC /k
.2
j=2
t
L1 t
kF kL2 L2x C kPj .RC /kL2 kF kL2 L2 t
t
kF kL2 L2x . 1: t
Now let F be a wave-packet atom, i.e., for some ` 100, X ˚ c / > 0; jj 1; jjj j 22` ; 2 F ; supp.F F D 2C`
and
P
kF k2NFŒ 1. We write, with j D 2`, RC D P<j .RC / C Pj .RC /
as before. Then P<j .RC / does not significantly change the support properties of F . Moreover, since kP<j .RC /k1 . 1, we see that P<j .RC /F is essentially a wave-packet atom. On the other hand, since kF kL2 L2x . 2j=2 from (2.32) t we conclude that kPj .RC /F kL1 L2 . 2
j=2
kF kL2 L2x . 1 t
(2.40)
which proves (2.39).
It is important to note that the previous lemma fails for functions in N Œ0 1 C"; 1 ";2 -norm is finite on functions which which are “elliptic” since the XP k 2 are too singular. But in the elliptic regime, there will be no need for the Duhamel formula and thus for Lemma 2.19. A technical variant of the preceding lemma will be needed in the proof of Proposition 9.14: Lemma 2.20. Let F be as in the preceding lemma, S 1 , and ! … ˙2. Then for any c 2 R we have ˙ kP Q
where the implied constant only depends on C and jj.
44
2 The spaces S Œk and N Œk
Proof. It is essentially identical to the preceding one: one replaces RC by Œt! c and L1t L2x by L1t! L2x! . The Duhamel formula (in other words, 1 ) introduces a Hilbert transform in the normal direction to the light-cone. The following lemma is of this type. Lemma 2.21. Let be a smooth function on R such that 0 1, .u/ D 1 on 1 u 1, supp./ Œ 2; 2, and 0 .u/ 0 on u 0, and 0 .u/ 0 on u 0 0. Define C T .t / WD Œ0;1/ .t =T / for each T 1. Then, with WD Œ0;1/ , 1 b .T / C 1 : i
C c T . / D
(2.41)
c C C In particular, c T . / D a T .a / for all 0 < a < 1 and a
ˇc ˇ ˇC . /ˇ . jj T
1
ˇd c ˇ ˇ C . /ˇ . jj T d
;
2
:
Moreover, let D . / be a smooth function on Œ 1; 1 with .0/ D 1 and 1 on Œ 1; 1. Then ˇ ˇˇ ˇc c C C sup ˇT . / T . / ˇ C k0 k1 j j1
with an absolute constant C . Finally, if T 0 2 ŒT =2; 2T , then
b
ˇc ˇC . /
ˇ ˇ C T 0 . / C T min 1; .T j j/
T
100
with a constant C that only depends on . Proof. Integrating by parts in C c T . / D
Z e
i u C T .u/ du
yields (2.41). In particular, ˇ ˇc ˇC . /ˇ . jj T
1
min.T j j; .T j j/
100
/;
and similarly for the derivatives. Next, write C c T ./
C c T . / D
1 1 b T. / C 1 : b .T / C 1 C i i. /
45
2.3 The energy estimate
In view of our assumptions on , ˇ 1 ˇ .1 . /
1
ˇ /ˇ . k0 k1 ;
and similarly for the terms involving b .T /. The final statement is an immediate consequence of (2.41). The following representation of waves 1 F with F a null-frame atom will be useful in several instances. Hence, we state it as a separate fact. Lemma 2.22. Assume that F 2 N Œ0 is a wave-packet atom, i.e., F D F C D P 2C` F with X kF k2NFŒ 1 2C`
for some `
100, see Definition 2.9. Then Z t sin .t 1 .t / WD F .t / D 0
s/jrj F .s/ ds jrj
admits a decomposition of the form D
1
F1 C
XZ 2C`
1 2 ;a C B;a ;a da
(2.42)
R
where kF1 kL1 L2x . 1 and t
sup kB;a kL1 C; t;x ;a
2 Z X
j k k ;a
j D1
with an absolute constant C , whence XZ j sup k ;a k j D1;2
Finally,5 for j D 1; 2
b
j c ; supp ;a C supp F
0; 1 2 ;1
XP 0
0; 1 ;1 XP 0 2
da
3
da C kF kNFŒ
2
. 1:
2 c supp B;a ;a C supp F
(2.43)
for all a and and some absolute constant C . 5
Here cE denotes the dilation of the convex set E about its center of mass by the constant c.
46
2 The spaces S Œk and N Œk
Proof. As in the proof of Lemma 2.19, we first write RC D P2` .RC / C P<2` .RC / DW 1 C 2 : Then F1 WD 1 F satisfies kF1 kL1 L2x . 1, see (2.40). On the other hand, F2 WD t F is again a wave-packet atom at essentially the same scale as F , i.e., F2 D 2 P e 2C` F with X e k2 kF 1: NFŒ
2C`
Define ˚ WD
1F . 2
Then ˚ D Z
1
˚T; .t / WD
1
P
limT !1 ˚T; with sin .t s/jrj C e .s/ ds: T .t s/F jrj
It suffices to prove that Z ˚T; D
1 2 T;;a C BT;;a T;;a da
where sup sup kBT;;a k1 . 1
T 1 a
and
Z
j
k T;;a k
sup sup
0; 1 2 ;1
XP 0
j D1;2 T 1
da . kFQ kNFŒ
(2.44)
both uniformly in . Fix 2 C` and ! D !./ 2 S 1 n .2/ so that d.!; /
1
e k 1 kF L
2 t! Lx!
e kNFŒ : 2kF
As usual, we foliate relative to t! . More precisely, define e .t; x/.a; x! / fa .x! / D F where t! D a means that .t; x/.a; x! / WD a!C C x! : By Lemma 2.6 supp.fOa / ˘!
˚ .; / W jj 1; b 2 ; j
jjj . 22`
DW R;! : (2.45)
47
2.3 The energy estimate
Let .t! ; x! / denote the null-frame coordinates. Then
jj D
2!1 ! C jj
h.! /
(2.46)
where !1 WD ! ! and, with j! j2 D .!1 /2 C .!2 /2 , one has h.! / WD 2 /2 .! 1 . 2!
Moreover, j!1 j d.!; /2 and j!2 j . d.!; / by elementary geometry (cf. Lemma 2.6). We define P;! f WD F 1 R;! .! /f .! ; ! / ; where R;! is a smooth cut-off adapted to the rectangle R;! in the ! -plane. Furthermore, we set h i C Qj;! f WD F 1 m0 2 j C d 2 .; !/.! h.! // f .! ; ! / : C By construction, P;! Q2`;! is essentially the same as P0; Q2` , see Lemma 2.6. In fact, one has
e D P;! QC e F F 2`;! C and P;! Q2`;! is disposable. Clearly, Z ˚T; D ˚T;;a da
where ˚T;;a .t/ WD
C P;! Q2`;!
Z
1
sin .t
1
s/jrj C T .t jrj
s/ı.s!
a/fa ds:
C Then ˚T;;a D P0;C Q2`CC ˚T;;a and C ˚T;;a D P;! Q2`;! F
1
c .C T .
jj/
C c T .jj C //e
i ! a
fOa .! / : (2.47)
C We claim that the contribution of jc T .jj C /j . 1 to (2.47) can be added 1 to T;;a . In fact,
C
1 i ! a O Q F O.1/e . / f . /
2`CC R;! ! a ! 0; 1 ;1 XP 2
0
(2.48) . 2` m0 2 2` C . jj/ R;! .! /fOa .! / 2 2 L L
. 22` d.!; /
1
kfa kL2 ;
48
2 The spaces S Œk and N Œk
which is better than needed. To pass to the final estimate here we used Lemma 2.6, especially (2.27); the latter estimate can be applied for fixed , since then ! D C .; /. Next, we split the contribution of c .jj / to (2.47) into several !
T
h.! / D 0 implies that p 2jj D C jj D 2 h.! /= 2 C ! e1 DW g.! /
pieces. Since !
where e1 D .1; 0; 0/, one has by Lemma 2.21 C c T .
jj/
1 C 2! c T g. / .! !
1 h.! / D O 1 D O d.!; / !
2
:
(2.49)
In view of (2.48) (which gains a factor of 22` . d.!; /2 ), the contribution 2 1 1 of (2.49) to (2.47) can again be added to T;;a . Set b D b.! / D g.!! / . Fur.0/
.0/
thermore, set b0 WD b.! / where ! Lemma 2.21, C c T
2 1 ! .! g.! / Db
b
h.! / D b
1 C b0 T
!
2 R;! is fixed, cf. (2.45). In view of
b
1 C bT
!
h.! /
h.! / C O T min.1; .T j
jjj/
100
/
(2.50)
where we used that b b0 on R;! . The computation from (2.48) above now 1 shows that the O./ term in (2.50) can be added to T;;a . It therefore remains to analyze the contribution of the first term in (2.50) to (2.47). Define Z BT;a; .t; x/ WD C .t s! /e i a.t! s! / c m0 .s! / ds! b0 T ! where 2j CC d 2 .; !/ DW (recall that m0 is even). On the one hand, kBT;a; k kc m0 k1 and on the other hand, C P;! Q2`;! F
D BT;a;
b
1 C b b0 T .! h.! //e i ! a fOa .! / h i g.! / ih.! /a O F 1 ı ! h.! / R;! .! / e f . / a ! 2!1 1
2 DW BT;a; T;;a : 2 2 By inspection, the Fourier support of T;;a as well as that of BT;a; T;;a are no larger than that of the original wave-packet F (up to a dilation by a constant).
49
2.3 The energy estimate
Finally, by a calculation similar to (2.48), 2 k T;;a k
. F
1 ;1 0; 2
XP 0
1
g.! / h.! / e 2!1
ı !
. d.!; /2
lim sup F
1
ŒM M.
M !1
. d.!; /
1
ih.! /a
R;! .! /fOa .! /
g.! / jj/ e 2!1
ih.! /a
0; 1 2 ;1
XP 0
R;! .! /fOa .! /
0; 1 2 ;1
XP 0
kfa kL2 :
This concludes the proof of the lemma.
In passing, we now prove the analogue of Lemma 2.15 for null-frame coordinates, which then gives Corollary 2.16 for the N Œk spaces. Corollary 2.23. For all F 2 N Œk and all j 2 Z one has kQj F kN Œk C kF kN Œk with some absolute constant C . P s;b Proof. This Pis clear if F is either an energy or a X -atom. Therefore, suppose that F D F is a wave-packet atom with k D 0. It suffices to prove that kQj F kNFŒ C kF kNFŒ : This in turn follows from kQj F kL1
2 t! Lx!
C kF kL1
2 t! Lx!
(2.51)
which holds uniformly in ! 2 S 1 n .2/. Fix such an ! and apply Plancherel’s theorem in x! . By (2.46), F2 Q<j F .t! ; ! / Z 2!1 D m0 2 j ! C jj
h.! / e i ! .t!
s! /
d ! F2 F .s! ; ! / ds!
where for our purposes here F2 refers to a partial Fourier transform relative to the
50
2 The spaces S Œk and N Œk
second variable x! . In view of j!1 j d.!; /2 , ˇZ 1 ˇ ˇ ˇˇ ˇF2 Q<j F .t! ; ! /ˇ ˇ m0 2 j 2! ! ˇ C jj .N 2j d.!; /
2
Z
˝
2j d.!; /
2
.t!
ˇ ˇ ˇ s! / d ! ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇF2 F .s! ; ! /ˇ ds! ˇ ˛ Nˇ ˇF2 F .s! ; ! /ˇ ds! : s! / h.! / e i ! .t!
Performing an L2! estimate followed by an L1t! bound yields (2.51).
Finally, there is the following simple fact that will play a role in the proof of the Strichartz component of k kS Œk . Lemma 2.24. Let akm 0 for all 1 m M and 1 k K. Suppose PK a kD1 km for all m where 0 is arbitrary. Then K X M X kD1
2 akm
12
M
1C 2
K
1 2
;
(2.52)
mD1
for all 0 1. Proof. Denote the sum in (2.52) by S. On the one hand, S
K X M X
akm M:
kD1 mD1
On the other hand, K X M 12 p X p 2 S K akm KM ; kD1 mD1
and the lemma is proved.
Now we can state the main energy bound. We begin with the easier elliptic regime. Lemma 2.25. Let F be a space-time Schwartz function which is adapted to k 2 Z. Assume furthermore that F D I c F and set WD 1 F , which is defined via division by 2 jj2 on the Fourier side. Then kkS Œk . kF kN Œk with an absolute implicit constant.
51
2.3 The energy estimate
Proof. We may again assume that k D 0. We then need to prove that kkXP 0;1 ";2 . min kF kL1 L2x ; kF kXP 0; 1 ";2 ; k
t
(2.53)
0
since, as we observed after Definition 2.3, the norm on the left-hand side dominates the other norms which make up k kS Œk . If we select kF kXP 0; 1 ";2 on the 0 right-hand side of (2.53), then this inequality is obvious. On the other hand, if we select kF kL1 L2x , then one concludes via Bernstein’s inequality in time. t
Next, we deal with the hyperbolic regime. Proposition 2.26. Let k 2 Z and suppose 0 ; 1 are Schwartz functions in R2 which are adapted to k. Further, suppose F is a space-time Schwartz function which is adapted to k, and which is moreover hyperbolic, i.e., F D IF . Then the unique smooth solution of D F; .0/; @ t .0/ D .0 ; 1 / satisfies kkS Œk . k.0 ; 1 /kL2 HP
1
C kF kN Œk
(2.54)
with an absolute implicit constant. Proof. By scaling we may assume that k D 0. We first assume that F D 0. Then
b
.t /./ D cos.t jj/b0 ./ C
sin.tjj/ b 1 ./: jj
Consequently, (2.54) follows from (2.21) upon sending T ! 1. Next, we assume that 0 D 1 D 0. By the Duhamel formula, Z t sin .t s/jj F .s/./ ds: .t / D jj 0
b
b
In other words, we need to show that
Z t sin .t s/jrj
Œ0;1/ .s/F .s/ ds . kF kN Œ0 :
S Œ0 jrj 1 In view of Lemma 2.19, we may remove the indicator function Œ0;1/ .t / D RC .t/ on the left-hand side. This is where we use that F D IF , but after this point we may no longer assume that F D IF since RC F loses this property.
52
2 The spaces S Œk and N Œk
The goal is now to prove uniformly in T 1
Z 1 C
sin .t s/jrj T .t s/F .s/ ds
S Œ0
1
. kF kN Œ0
(2.55)
where C T .u/ WD .u=T /RC .u/ is a bump function as specified in Lemma 2.21. Denote Z 1 .t / D sin .t s/jrj C s/F .s/ ds: (2.56) T .t 1
Then the space-time Fourier transform of equals (up to a multiplicative constant) C C b b .; / D c jj/ c (2.57) T . T . C jj/ F .; /; whence, by Lemma 2.21, ˇ ˇ jb .; /j . ˇjj jjˇ
1
2
Œj j<10 C
b .; /j Œj j10 jF
(2.58)
. kF kN Œ0
(2.59)
and thus also kQ0 k
1 ;1 0; 2
XP 0
C kQ>0 kXP 0;1 0
";2
from (2.32) and Lemma 2.25. By Lemma 2.4 it suffices to assume that F is either 1 an energy or a wave-packet atom. Moreover, in each of these cases the XP 0; 2 ;1 and XP 0;1 ";2 -components of the S Œk norm of can be ignored due to (2.59). Moreover, since the XP 0;1 ";2 -norm controls the entire S Œ0-norm in the elliptic regime, it suffices to consider only Q0 . In case F is an energy atom, i.e., kF kL1 L2 1 standard X s;b and Strichartz norms for the wave equation bound the norms in (2.13) and (2.14), see Lemma 2.2. We are therefore reduced to bounding (2.15), for which it suffices to verify that
C
sup sup sup P0; Q<2` sin.t jrj/C T .t /f S Œ0; . kf kL2x ` 100 T 1 2C`
for any f which is 0-adapted (the case of Q being analogous). We can ignore the further localization to the rectangle R due to orthogonality, cf. (2.15). The Fourier transform of the function inside the norms on the left-hand side is C C O 0 2 2` .jj / c O ./m jj/ c T . T .jj C / f ./ C where is a cut-off adapted to the cap . The contribution by c T .jj C / is c controlled by (2.19). As for C /, one needs to show that T .jj
C
22` m c0 .22` / P0; e i t jrj f S Œ0; . kf kL2x : T
53
2.3 The energy estimate
However, since the term in brackets is a bounded function uniformly in `, one can again apply Lemma 2.4. P Now assume that F is a wave-packet atom, i.e., F D 2C` F with X kF k2NFŒ 1 (2.60) 2C`
where the F have the wave-packet form as specified in Definition 2.9. We need to show that X 21 X ˙ 2 . 1: (2.61) sup sup sup kPR Q2` 0 C kS Œ0; 0 ˙ `0 100 `0 m0
0 2C`0 R2R0;˙ 0 ;m
We first consider the case `0 `. Lemma 2.11 implies that it suffices to assume that `0 D ` and to show that, uniformly in 2 C` , k kS Œ0; C kF kNFŒ with an absolute constant C , where Z 1 WD sin .t 1
s/jrj C T .t
s/F .s/ ds:
However, this follows immediately from Lemma 2.22 applied to , the stability property (2.16), and the imbedding (2.19); note that the term 1 F1 in (2.42) can be ignored as it was dealt with in the beginning of this proof. Finally, the case `0 ` is reduced the to `0 D ` by means of Lemma 2.7 (note that the Fouriersupport of equals that of F ). It remains to control the Strichartz norms (2.14). Due to Corollary 2.23, we may ignore the projection Q<j . We split the argument into two parts: First, we will prove the estimate
2 12 X Z 1 `
e ˙i.t s/jrj F .s/ ds 4 1 (2.62) . 2 2 kF kN Œ0
Pc c2D0;`
L t Lx
1
for any F as in (2.60), cf. Lemma 2.1. Second, we take the C T cut-off as in (2.56) into account which then yields the full result. This second step is done by an adaptation of the Christ–Kiselev argument and will result in the loss of a power 2`ı where ı > 0 can be made arbitrarily small. Lemma 2.2 reduces the proof of (2.62) to the bound
Z 1
i sjrj e F .s/ ds 2 . kF kN Œ0 :
1
Lx
54
2 The spaces S Œk and N Œk
By orthogonality, it suffices to show that uniformly in
Z 1
i sjrj e F .s/ ds 2 . inf d.!; / 1 kF kL1
Lx
1
2 t! L x !
!622
with F as in (2.60). By Plancherel, this is the same as
b F .˙jj; / L2 . d.!; / 1 kF kL1
2 t! Lx!
where we choose an arbitrary ! 62 2. As above, we may set F D ı.t! .0/ .0/ t! /f .x! / where t! 2 R is an arbitrary number and f 2 L2x! is an arbitrary function whose Fourier support is contained in the projection of the Fourier support of F onto the ! -plane. This reduces us further to the bound kfO .! /kL2 . d.!; /
1
kf kL2
!
(2.63)
where on the left-hand ˇ ˇ side we regard ! as a function of . By Lemma 2.6 the ˇ @ ˇ Jacobian obeys ˇ @! ˇ d.!; / 2 which implies (2.63). This concludes the first step, i.e., the proof of (2.62). Note Pthat our proof of (2.62) applies to any F which can be written in the form F D F provided F satisfy b / f 2 R2 W jj 1; b supp.F 2 g: In other words, one does not need any condition on the modulations of F . This fact will be most important for the remainder of the proof (since we will need to multiply F by cutoff functions in time). Our next goal is to establish the estimate, with ı > 0 arbitrarily small,
2 2 X Z 1 1
. 2. 2 ı/` kF kN Œ0 e ˙i.t s/jrj C .t s/F .s/ ds
Pc
T 4 1 c2D0;`
1
L t Lx
(2.64) for any F as in (2.60) but without any restriction on the modulations of each F . For the remainder of the proof we will fix such a Schwartz function F . Moreover, k k2 without any subscripts will mean the sum in (2.60). As mentioned before, we prove (2.64) by an adaptation of the Christ–Kiselev lemma. The latter does not apply directly since the null-frame norm in (2.60) is not of pure Lebesgue type. We make the following preliminary observation. Let E D E .t / act only in the time variable and define the map .E/ WD kE F k2 as a set function on the Borel sets of R. Then one has the following -subadditivity property with fEj g R an
55
2.3 The energy estimate
arbitrary collection of pairwise disjoint Borel sets: X X XX .Ej / D kEj F k2 D inf d.!; / j
j
X
inf d.!; /
j
2
X
!…2
X
D
X
2
!…2
inf d.!; /
2
X
2 t! Lx!
2 t! Lx!
X
2 kEj F kL 2
x!
j
21
2 kL 1
t!
2 kF kL 1
2 t! Lx!
!…2
k
2 kEj F kL 1
2 kEj F kL 1
j
inf d.!; /
D
2
!…2
kF k2NFŒ 1
In view of this property it suffices to prove (2.64) for F which are supported on intervals6 of size T in time and we may also replace C T by the indicator Œs
jIm;n j D jJm;n j D T 2 dist Im;n Jm;n ; fs D tg/ 2 .T 2
n
n
;
=10; 10T 2
n
8 1 m Mn ; n 0 ; 8 1 m Mn ; n 0:
We call any two intervals I; J of length T 2 n related provided I J 2 Q. Note that any I can be related to at most 20 of the J intervals. To each n 0 we now also associate 2n pairwise disjoint intervals fe J m;n g1m2n which partition Œ0; T and with the property that .e J m;n / D .e J m0 ;n / 6
8 1 m; m0 2n :
Strictly speaking, one would need to choose something like 10T here to accommodate the support of C T , but we ignore this issue.
56
2 The spaces S Œk and N Œk
The subadditivity of implies that .e J m;n / 2 n . Finally, we introduce an auxiliary function ˚ which is piece-wise linear, strictly increasing on Œ0; T and which has the property that ˚.Jm;n / D e J m;n . In view of all these properties Z X
Pc
t
c2D0;`
e ˙i.t
2
F .s/ ds 4
s/jrj
L t L1 x
1
Mn 1 X X X
˚.Im;n / .t /Pc .
nD0
c2D0;`
mD1
Z
t
e ˙i.t
s/jrj
2
˚.Jm;n / .s/F .s/ ds
L4t L1 x
1
:
Applying Cauchy–Schwarz to the sum over n allows one to bound this further as .
1 X X
Mn
X
˚.Im;n / .t/Pc .1 C n/2 mD1
c2D0;` nD0
Z
t
e ˙i.t
s/jrj
1 X
2n
Z X X
P
c
.1 C n/2
nD0
c2D0;`
1
2
˚.Jm;n / .s/F .s/ ds 4
L t L1 x
1
.
(2.65)
e ˙i.t
s/jrj
1
mD1
4 21
e .s/F .s/ ds
4 1 : J m;n L L t
x
(2.66) Label the disks c 2 D0;` by fck gK ,K 2 kD1 Z
WD Pck
akm;n
1
e ˙i.t
s/jrj
1
2` ,
and denote for fixed n,
2
e .s/F .s/ ds
4 1: J m;n L L x
t
The previous bound now takes the form Z X
Pc c2D0;`
t
e 1
˙i.t s/jrj
2
F .s/ ds 4
L t L1 x
.
1 X
n
2
.1 C n/
nD0
K X 2 X kD1
2 akm;n
12
:
mD1
In view of (2.62) (and the remark at the end of its proof concerning time cutoffs) K X kD1
2
D 2` .e akm;n . 2` e F J m;n / 2` 2 J m;n
n
:
57
2.4 A stronger S Œk-norm, and time localizations
By Lemma 2.24 with D 2`
n,
M D 2n , K D 2
n
K X 2 X kD1
2 akm;n
21
. 2.1
2` ,
2ı/`
2
ın
mD1
for any 0 ı 1. In view of (2.66), one obtains (2.64).
As a simple corollary, we now obtain the following continuity result. Recall that the norm of S Œk can also be defined for non-integer k, cf. (2.18). The continuity in k is not obvious due to the various Fourier multipliers in (2.14) and (2.15) over infinitely many scales. Corollary 2.27. Let be a Schwartz function in R1C2 which is adapted to k 2 R. Then lim kkS ŒkCh D kkS Œk
h!0
Proof. By (2.18), 1
k.
1
/kS Œk D kkS ŒkClog2
It therefore suffices to note that by the energy estimate ˇ ˇ
1
k.
1
k
ˇ kkS Œk ˇ
/kS Œk
1
.
k.
1
. k.
1
1
/
.
1
.
1
/ /
kS Œk /Œ0kL2 HP /Œ0kL2 HP
1 1
C k.
1
C k.
1
.
1
/
/kN Œk
.
1
/
/kL1 HP
as ! 1.
2.4
t
1
!0
A stronger SŒk-norm, and time localizations
The energy estimate of Proposition 2.26 and Lemma 2.25 can be summarized as the statement that kkS Œk . jjjjjjS Œk where jjjjjjS Œk WD kkL1 L2x C kkN Œk t
(2.67)
58
2 The spaces S Œk and N Œk
for any space-time Schwartz function which is adapted to k 2 Z. To see this, one estimates kkS Œk . kI kS Œk C kI c kS Œk . k .I /.0/; .@ t I /.0/ kL2 HP
1
C kI kN Œk C kI c kN Œk
. kkL1 L2x C kkN Œk D jjjjjjS Œk : t
To remove I from the right-hand side here one uses Corollary 2.23. We shall henceforth use this stronger norm and the resulting smaller S Œkspace. We introduce this norm because it leads to an improvement over the bilinear bound (2.30) in the case of high-high interactions, see Lemma 4.5 below. This improvement reflects a smoothing effect of convolutions of measures supported on the light cone. It thus cannot be obtained using the S Œk; norms alone, since (2.30) is based on Hölder’s inequality 1 2 2 2 L2t! L1 x! L t! Lx! ,! L t Lx
which does not allow for any gain in regularity. It will be essential to note that Corollary 2.16 still applies to the stronger norm jjj jjj: Lemma 2.28. For all which are adapted to k 2 Z and all j 2 Z one has jjjQj jjjS Œk C jjjjjjS Œk with some absolute constant C . Proof. This follows immediately from Lemma 2.15 and Corollary 2.23.
Another property which the stronger norm inherits is that it is finite on free wave, cf. Lemma 2.4. More precisely, for any which is adapted to k and satisfies D Qk , jjjjjjS Œk D kkL1 L2x C kkN Œk t
kkL1 L2x C kk t
0;
XP k
1 ;1 2
. kk
0; 1 2 ;1
XP k
:
As in [23], one needs to allow for time-localized versions of S Œk, both relative to the original k kS Œk , as well as the stronger jjj jjj-norm. This has to do with the fact that the we need to derive a priori bounds in these spaces for Schwartz functions ˛ which satisfy (1.12)–(1.14) on some time interval Œ T; T . Since the norms of the S Œk and N Œk spaces are defined in phase space, one cannot simply define these norms by time truncations. Rather, one proceeds as in [59] and [23]
59
2.4 A stronger S Œk-norm, and time localizations
by means of Schwartz extensions: with T 0, k kS Œk.Œ T;T R2 / WD Q jŒ
jjj jjjS Œk.Œ
T;T R2 /
WD
Q jŒ
and Q both Schwarz functions, and kPk Q kS Œk ;
inf T;T D
jŒ
T;T
T;T D
(2.68)
jjjPk Q jjjS Œk :
inf jŒ
T;T
It is easy to see that the triangle inequality holds for these expressions and that they are actually norms. Moreover, it is clear that these norms are nondecreasing in T . Following [23], we now verify that these norms are continuous in T . Lemma 2.29. Let be the restriction of some Schwartz function the time interval Œ T0 ; T0 where T0 > 0. Then k kS Œk.Œ
and jjj jjjS Œk.Œ
T;T R2 /
0
in R1C2 to
T;T R2 /
are nondecreasing and continuous in 0 T < T0 . Proof. The definition of S Œk with respect to either norm can be extended to noninteger k. Given T > 0, let j"j be very small and set WD TTC" . Then kPk kS Œk.Œ
T ";T C"R2 /
D kPkC
kS ŒkC.Œ T;T R2 /
where WD log2 and .t; x/ WD .t; x/, and similarly for jjj jjj. Clearly, for " > 0, ˇ ˇ ˇkPk kS Œk.Œ T ";T C"R2 / kPk kS Œk.Œ T;T R2 / ˇ ˇ ˇ D ˇkPkC kS ŒkC.Œ T;T R2 / kPk kS Œk.Œ T;T R2 / ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇkPkC kS ŒkC.Œ T;T R2 / kPk kS Œk.Œ T;T R2 / ˇ C kPkC .
/kS ŒkC.Œ T;T R2 / :
By the energy estimate, kPkC .
/kS ŒkC.Œ T;T R2 /
. kPkC . . k.
/kS ŒkC /Œ0kL2 HP
C kPkC . . k.
/kN ŒkC
/Œ0kL2 HP
C kPkC .
1
1
/kL1 HP t
1 .R1C2 /
as ! 1. By Corollary 2.27, lim kPkC
!1
kS ŒkC.Œ T;T R2 /
D kPk kS Œk.Œ
T;T R2 /
!0
60
2 The spaces S Œk and N Œk
which implies that lim kPk kS Œk.Œ
"!0C
T ";T C"R2 /
D kPk kS Œk.Œ
T;T R2 /
as claimed. The case of T D 0 follows directly from the energy estimate. The case of jjj jjj is essentially the same. We define localized N Œk-norms similarly, i.e., k kN Œk.Œ
T;T R2 /
WD
kPk Q kN Œk
inf
Q jŒ
T;T D
jŒ
T;T
for Schwartz functions. In particular, one has a localized version of (2.67) jjjjjjS Œk.Œ
T;T R2 /
WD kkL2
I IL2 .R2 /
C kk
N Œk.Œ T;T R2 / :
Furthermore, later we will also need localized norms on asymmetric time intervals Œ T 0 ; T for which the results here of course continue to hold. Finally, in the perturbative steps to follow, we will need to piece together solutions of time-localized wave equations to solutions on larger time intervals. To justify this procedure we rely on the following lemma. Lemma 2.30. Let I R be a closed interval, with a covering I D [jND1 Ij by closed intervals; assume that the Ij overlap at most two at a time, and that consecutive intervals have intersection with non-empty interior. Then if we are given k-adapted j with k such that
j jIj \Il
D
j kS Œk.Ij R2 / ` jIj \I` ,
cj ;
j D 1; 2; : : : ; N;
then defining
k kS Œk.I R2 / .
N X j D1
k
via
jIj WD
j kS Œk.Ij R2 /
N X
j,
we have
cj
j D1
where the implied constant is universal (independent of the decomposition of I or N ). The same applies to the norms jjj jjjS Œk.Ij R2 / . Proof. Chose a partition of unity fj g subordinate to the cover fIj g, such that suppj Ij . We shall select the j in such fashion that jsuppj0 j jIj \ Ik j, provided the latter is non-zero (which happens only for at most two other k). We
61
2.4 A stronger S Œk-norm, and time localizations
first deal with the kkS Œk -norms. By assumption, we can find Schwartz extensions Qj of j , 8j , such that k Qj kS Œk.R2C1 / 2cj . We now define Q WD
N X
j Qj
j D1
P and verify the desired bound k Q kS Œk.R2C1 / . cj . For simplicity, consider a single interval half-infinite I1 with neighboring half-infinite I2 , and the corresponding expression 1 Q 1 C 2 Q 2 : Note that 01 C 02 D 0 on the overlap of the intervals. It is easy to see that the only potential difficulty in controlling k1 Q 1 C 2 Q 2 kS Œk comes from the “elliptic portion” of k kS Œk , as we have introduced the cutoffs whose derivatives we do not a priori control. By scaling invariance, it suffices to consider k D 0. Hence consider now P0 Qj Œ1 Q 1 C 2 Q 2 for some j 1. We decompose this by applying a frequency trichotmoy P0 Qj Œ1 Q 1 C 2 Q 2 DP0 Qj ŒQŒj
Q 10;j C10 .1 / 1
C P0 Qj ŒQ<j
10 .1 / Q 1
Q 10;j C10 .2 / 2
C QŒj
C Q<j
10 .2 / Q 2
C P0 Qj ŒQ>j C10 .1 / Q 1 C Q>j C10 .2 / Q 2 : (2.69) We start by estimating the last line: We have
P0 Qj ŒQ>j C10 .1 / Q 1 C Q>j C10 .2 / Q 2 2 L
t;x
X
kP0 Qj ŒQr .1 /QŒr
5;rC5
Q 1 C Qr .2 /QŒr
5;rC5
Q 2 k
L2t;x
r>j C10
.
X
X
2
.1 /r
kQŒr
5;rC5
Q `k
`D1;2 r>j C10
From here we easily obtain
X
P0 Qj ŒQ>j C10 .1 / Q 1 C Q>j C10 .2 / Q 2
XP 0
j >O.1/
.
XP 0
1 2 C;1 ;2
:
1 2 C;1 ;2
X `D1;2
k Q `k
XP 0
1 2 C;1 ;2
:
62
2 The spaces S Œk and N Œk
The second line in (2.69) is estimated similarly, and so we reduce to estimating P0 Qj QŒj 10;j C10 .1 / Q 1 C QŒj 10;j C10 .2 / Q 2 : We may assume that F .1;2 / decay rapidly away from frequency scale 2R 1, say. Write
D P0 Qj ŒQŒj
C QŒj 10;j C10 .2 / Q 2 Q Q 10;j C10 @ t .1 / 1 C QŒj 10;j C10 @ t .2 / 2
C P0 Qj ŒQŒj
10;j C10 .1 /@ t
@ t P0 Qj ŒQŒj
Q 10;j C10 .1 / 1
Q 1 C QŒj
10;j C10 .2 /@ t
(2.70)
Q 2 :
We start by estimating the second row: We will consider the case j D R C O.1/, since in the other cases one obtains additional exponential gains from the frequency localization of 1;2 . But then we can write QŒj
10;j C10 @ t .1 /
D Q 1 QŒj
10;j C10 @ t .1 /
N
C OL2 .R t
1 2
where Q localizes to an interval around supp01 of length R for 2 . By picking R large enough, we may assume that
/
, say, and similarly
Q 1 Q 1 D Q 2 Q 2 : Thus we obtain P0 Qj QŒj 10;j C10 @ t .1 / Q 1 C QŒj
Q 10;j C10 @ t .2 / 2 D
X
OL2 .R
N
t
/ Q`
`D1;2
and from here we infer
P0 Qj ŒQŒj 10;j C10 @ t .1 / Q 1 C QŒj
Q 10;j C10 @ t .2 / 2
D O.R
N0
/
XP 0
X
1 2 C;1 ;2
k Q ` kS Œ0.R2C1 /
`D1;2
where we recall the assumption j D R C O.1/. The remaining cases j R, j R are lead to a similar bound. Next, consider the last line of (2.70); here we write P0 Qj ŒQŒj D P0 Qj ŒQŒj
10;j C10 .1 /@ t
Q 1 C QŒj
10;j C10 .1 /@ t Q<j C20
10;j C10 .2 /@ t
Q 1 CQŒj
Q 2
10;j C10 .2 /@ t Q<j C20
Q 2 : (2.71)
2.5 Solving the inhomogeneous wave equation in the Coulomb gauge
63
But this we can estimate by
P0 Qj QŒj 10;j C10 .1 /@ t Q<j C20 Q 1 C QŒj
10;j C10 .2 /@ t Q<j C20
.
X
2
Q2
.1 /j
XP 0
1 C;1 ;2 2
k@ t Q<j C20 Q ` kL2 : (2.72) t;x
`D1;2
One can now perform the square summation over j > O.1/, and as a result obtains the upper bound X . k Q ` k 1 C;1 2 XP 0
`D1;2
2
where the implied constant is universal. The argument for controlling the jjj jjjS Œk -norm is similar. One uses
N X
j Qj D
j D1
N X
j Qj ;
j D1
as well as Lemma 2.19.
Remark 2.31. In the sequel, we shall use the preceding lemma freely without an explicit reference.
2.5
Solving the inhomogeneous wave equation in the Coulomb gauge
Consider the wave equation (1.14), i.e., ˛ D F˛ . Here F˛ is a nonlinear expression in , but we will not pay attention to this now. In the sequel, we shall require a priori bounds on ˛ in the S Œk-space. To do so, we reduce matters to the energy estimates of Section 2.3 as follows: Writing (suppressing ˛ for simplicity) one concludes (with both to frequency 1),
D IF C I c F
and F global space-time Schwartz functions adapted Z
.t/ D S.t
t0 /.I /Œt0 C
t
U.t t0
s/IF .s/ ds C
1 c
I F
(2.73)
64
2 The spaces S Œk and N Œk
where the final term is obtained by division by the symbol7 of , and the first two terms represent the free wave and the Duhamel integral, respectively. Note that the first term here implicitly depends on all of , not just Œt0 , and so in order to actually obtain a bound on k kS , one needs to implement a bootstrap argument. Specifically, assume that we a priori have a bound on k jŒ
T0 ;T0 kS
P for some T0 > 0. Also, assume that we define I D k2Z Pk Q
T0 ;T0 kS
C kF kN
(2.74)
where the implied constant is absolute (the T0 1 here comes from the timederivative in the initial data). Indeed, this follows from .I /Œt0 D I.Œ T0 ;T0 / Œt0 C I.Œ1 Œ T0 ;T0 / Œt0 and min
t0 2Œ T0 ;T0
as well as
I.Œ
T0 ;T0
.I.Œ1
/ Œt0
L2x
Œ
T0 ;T0
D r t;x I.Œ
// Œt0 L2 HP x
T0 ;T0
/
L2x
1
k kS
. T0 1 jŒ
T0 ;T0
S
due to our choice of I . The above energy inequality then follows immediately. It is apparent that in order to use this energy inequality, one needs to establish an a priori bound for on a small time interval Œ T0 ; T0 . In fact, in later applications we will always split the estimates for Pk into the small-time case jt t0 j "1 2 k and the large time case jt t0 j "1 2 k (with a small "1 that is determined by the specific context - this then requires the constant C in the definition of I to be large). In the small time case, the necessary a priori bound is derived from the div-curl system (1.12), (1.13) for the gauged components. This information is then fed into the large-time case as described above.
7
In the sequel, we shall understand the operator otherwise stated.
1
to be division by the symbol unless
3
Hodge decomposition and null-structures
Here we introduce the actual system of wave equations for which our S and N spaces allow us to deduce a priori estimates. From the discussion at the very beginning, we recall that the Coulomb components ˛ satisfy the system (1.14), which has the schematic form
˛
D i @ˇ Œ
i @ˇ Œ
˛ Aˇ
ˇ A˛
ˇ
C i @˛ Œ
Aˇ
(3.1)
where Aˇ denotes the Coulomb gauge potential Aˇ D
X
4
1
@j
1 2 ˇ j
2 1 ˇ j
:
j D1;2
This system in and of itself does not appear to lend itself to good estimates, and to overcome this we have to use a key additional feature, namely the fact that the flow of (1.14) preserves the div-curl system (1.12), (1.13) in the obvious sense: if the ˛ at time t D 0 are the Coulomb derivative components of an actual map, whence (1.12), (1.13) holds at time t D 0, then the corresponding solution of (1.14) satisfies this system on its entire time interval of existence. The div-curl system allows us to decompose the components ˛ as the sum of a gradient term and an error term solving an elliptic equation, see (1.15). Thus we have schematic identities of the form ˛
D R˛
C ˛ :
Substituting the gradient terms introduces the desired null-structure. The present section serves to make this decomposition of the nonlinear source terms precise. We now describe this procedure for each of the three terms on the right-hand side of (3.1). First, define @j 1 WD 1 @j and Qˇj . ; / D Rˇ
1
1 2 j 1 ˇ Rj 2
Qˇj . ; / D Rˇ Qˇj .; / D
Rj
Qˇj .; / D 1ˇ j2
2
Rj
1
1 2 ˇ 1 j Rˇ 2
Rj
j1 2ˇ :
Rˇ
2
66
3 Hodge decomposition and null-structures
Then, adopting the Einstein summation convention, i@ˇ Œ ˛ Aˇ D i @ˇ ˛ I c @j 1 Qˇj . ; / C i @ˇ ˛ I @j 1 Qˇj . ; / C i @ˇ ˛ @j 1 Qˇj . ; / C i @ˇ ˛ @j 1 Qˇj .; / C i @ˇ ˛ @j 1 Qˇj .; / :
(3.2)
The two main terms here are the trilinear ones in . We introduced the modulation cutoff I in front of Qˇj since the two resulting expressions are estimated differently: for the second, one uses a trilinear null-form structure, see (5.44) below, whereas for the first the bilinear null-form Qˇj suffices. Note that the other three terms involving are quintilinear and septilinear in , respectively, due to (1.16). These are discussed in greater detail below, under the heading “higher order errors”. Next, i @ˇ ˇ @j 1 Q˛j . ; / i@ˇ Œ ˇ A˛ D i @ˇ ˇ @j 1 Q˛j . ; / i @ˇ ˇ @j 1 Q˛j .; / i @ˇ ˇ @j 1 Q˛j .; / : The -terms need to be decomposed further, whereas the main term here is again the trilinear one in , which we now rewrite as follows: i@ˇ ˇ @j 1 Q˛j . ; / D i @ˇ ˇ @j 1 I c Q˛j . ; / i @ˇ ˇ @j 1 I Q˛j . ; / (3.3) The first term on the right-hand side will be estimated as is, whereas the second term now needs to be rewritten according to the Littlewood–Paley trichotomy, in order to make it amenable to our estimates: X i@ˇ ˇ @j 1 I Q˛j . ; / D i Pk @ˇ ˇ @j 1 IP
i
X
@j 1 IP
Pk Rˇ
5@
ˇ
Q˛j . ; /
(3.4)
k
i
X
Pk ˇ @j 1 IP
5@
ˇ
Q˛j . ; /
k
i
X
@ˇ Pk P>k Rˇ
@j 1 IP>kC5 Q˛j . ; /
k
i
X
@ˇ Pk P>k ˇ @j 1 IP>kC5 Q˛j . ; /
k
(3.5)
67
3 Hodge decomposition and null-structures
i
X
@ˇ P
@j 1 IPŒk
5;kC5 Q˛j .
; /
k
i
X
@ˇ P
5;kC5 Q˛j .
; / : (3.6)
k
The terms involving are expanded further as explained below. For the first term on the right-hand side of (3.4) one replaces @ˇ ˇ by the right-hand side of (1.13) which leads to a quintilinear term. The second term can be estimated since the @ˇ -term falls on the small frequencies. Finally, the third term in (3.1) is treated as follows:
i @˛ Œ
ˇ
Aˇ D i @˛ Œ
ˇ
I c A ˇ C i @˛ Œ
ˇ
IAˇ
(3.7)
The first term on the right-hand side of (3.7) is estimated as is; in fact, it is essential that one does not perform the Hodge decomposition in the first slot since otherwise ˇ D 0 would create problems if has large modulation. For the second term, one needs to distinguish frequency interactions as before:
i @˛ Œ
ˇ
IAˇ D i
X
P k @˛
ˇ
@j 1 IP
5 Qˇj .
; /
k
Ci
X
Pk
ˇ
@j 1 IP
5 @˛ Qˇj .
; /
(3.8)
k
Ci
X
@˛ Pk P>kC5 Rˇ
@j 1 IP>k Qˇj . ; /
k
Ci
X
@˛ Pk P>kC5 ˇ @j 1 IP>k Qˇj . ; /
(3.9)
k
Ci
X
@˛ P
@j 1 IPŒk
5;kC5 Qˇj .
; /
k
Ci
X
@˛ P
5;kC5 Qˇj .
; / (3.10)
k
The -terms need to be expanded further, see below, whereas the -terms in (3.9) and (3.10) are estimated as they are. The second term on right-hand side of (3.8)
68
3 Hodge decomposition and null-structures
is expanded by means of the Hodge decomposition: X i Pk ˇ @j 1 IP
Di
X
Pk R ˇ
@j 1 IP
5 @˛ Qˇj .
; /
(3.11)
k
Ci
X
Pk ˇ @j 1 IP
5 @˛ Qˇj .
; /
(3.12)
k
The trilinear estimates of Chapter 5 cover (3.11), and (3.12) is handled below, under “higher order errors”. Finally, the first term on the right-hand side of (3.8) is rewritten by means of (1.12): i
X
Pk @˛
ˇ
@j 1 IP
5 Qˇj .
; /
k
Di
X
Pk @ˇ
˛ @j
1
IP
5 Qˇj .
; / C quintilinear terms (3.13)
k
where the quintilinear terms arise by using the curl identity for @˛ ˇ @ˇ ˛ into this expression. Note that we have switched the derivatives @˛ and @ˇ . We still have to explain how to deal with the higher order terms involving at least one factor of . Higher order errors. Note that these arise in two ways: first, we generate errors by replacing the Gauge potential Aˇ in i @ˇ Œ
˛ Aˇ
by a Qˇj . ; / null-form, and similarly for the remaining types of terms i @ˇ Œ
ˇ A˛ ;
i @˛ Œ
ˇ
Aˇ :
We shall call the higher order terms generated by this process (and later further Hodge decompositions applied to them) of the first type or kind. Second, we generate errors of the schematic form r
1
IQˇj . ; /;
and we call these together with all the terms generated by them upon applying further Hodge decompositions of the second type or kind. For simplicity, we omit frequency localizations in the ensuing discussion.
3 Hodge decomposition and null-structures
69
Figure 3.1. An example of an expansion graph
Considering the errors of the first kind, these are of the schematic form rx;t r 1 Œ ; rx;t r 1 Œ where we recall from the very beginning, Section 1, that D r 1 r 1. 2/ ; whence the above terms may be thought of as quintilinear and septilinear. Now as they are written, we cannot yet quite estimate these expressions, and we need to introduce more null-structure, by expanding the r 1 . 2 / in D r 1 r 1. 2/ ; into a Qj -null-form as well as even higher order error terms. To keep track of things we associate an expansion graph, i.e., a simple binary tree with the expressions generated: Represent the original terms rx;t Œ Aˇ by a simple node, and whenever we replace one of the factors in the (schematically written) Aˇ D r 1 . 2 / by the corresponding , we draw a downward edge pointing left or right corresponding to which factor we replace. We can now exactly specify the full expansion of the higher order errors of first type:
70
3 Hodge decomposition and null-structures
Precise description of expansion for errors of first type: Keep applying Hodge decompositions to the inner r 1 . 2 / in all factors 1
Dr
r
1
.
2
/;
generated until the associated expansion graph has a directed subgraph of length four. Then the process stops. Note that formally, the terms with a directed subgraph of length four thereby generated are up to at least the 11th degree in . Next, we apply a similar process to the errors of the second type. We represent the first such error, schematically given by rx;t r
1
IQj . ; /
by a simple node, and whenever we apply a Hodge decomposition to one of the factors of r 1 . 2 / in D r 1 r 1. 2/ we draw a downward edge pointing left or right, thereby generating an associated expansion graph. Then we have: Precise description of expansion for errors of second type: Keep applying Hodge decompositions as above until the associated expansion graph has a directed subgraph of length three. Then the process stops. Again we generated a list of errors of degree of multilinearity up to order 11 and more in . To summarize this discussion, we have now recast our system of equations in the form
˛
D
5 X
F˛2i C1
i D1
where the superscript indicates the minimum degree of multilinearity of the corresponding terms in (i 1 indicates the length of a directed subgraph in the corresponding graph representation), and the leading cubic terms F˛3 can be ex-
71
3 Hodge decomposition and null-structures
pressed as F˛3 D i@ˇ
I c @j 1 Qˇj . ; / C i @ˇ ˛ I @j 1 Qˇj . ; / i @ˇ ˇ @j 1 I c Q˛j . ; / X i Pk Rˇ @j 1 IP
˛
k
i
X
i
X
@ˇ Pk P>k Rˇ
@j 1 IP>kC5 Q˛j . ; /
k
@ˇ Pk P
@j 1 IPŒk
5;kC5 Q˛j .
; /
k
C i @˛ ˇ I c @j 1 Qˇj . ; / X Ci Pk @ˇ ˛ @j 1 IP
Ci
X
Ci
X
Ci
X
Pk Rˇ
@j 1 IP
5 @˛ Qˇj .
; /
k
@˛ Pk P>k Rˇ
@j 1 IP>kC5 Qˇj . ; /
k
@˛ P
@j 1 IPŒk
5;kC5 Qˇj .
; /
(3.14)
k
Here it is very important to note that the second as well as the eighth term on the right contribute a magnetic potential interaction term of the form X 2i Pk @ˇ ˛ @j 1 IP
the idea being that we interpret the low-frequency term @j 1 IP
k Rˇ @j 1 IP>kC5 Q˛j . ; / k
72
3 Hodge decomposition and null-structures
i
X
i
X
Pk Rˇ
@j 1 IP
5@
ˇ
Q˛j . ; /
k
@ˇ P
@j 1 IPŒk
5;kC5 Q˛j .
; / : (3.16)
k
Furthermore, we denote by F˛3k .
1;
2;
3/
the corresponding multilinear expressions. We also introduce frequency localized versions F˛3k . 1 I P<` I 2 ; 3 / in which one includes a cutoff P<` in front of all instances of Q˛j . similarly for other multipliers P` etc.
2;
3 /,
and
4
Bilinear estimates involving S and N spaces
In this section we develop some of the required bilinear bounds. First, we present some bounds from S S into L2tx , in particular one which involves a gain in the high-high case and which does not appear in [59] or [23], see Lemma 4.7 below. This result allows for better control on products 1 2 of S-waves and will be most useful in the trilinear case. In addition, as in the aforementioned references we consider the case of 1 2 S and 2 2 N . This section concludes with bilinear estimates for null-forms.
4.1
Basic L2 -bounds
To begin with, we present the following geometric lemma for cones, see [58] for a similar result. It will be used repeatedly. Lemma 4.1. Suppose 1 ; 2 are such that ˇ ˚ supp.bj / .; / j jj 2kj ; ˇjj
ˇ j jˇ 2`j
for j D 1; 2. Let `0 ; k0 2 Z and assume that there exists j0 2 f0; 1; 2g so that `j0 > `j C C
8 j 2 f0; 1; 2g n fj0 g:
(4.1)
Then there is the following dichotomy: (A) If k0 D kmax C O.1/, then X Pk0 Q`0 1 2 D Pk0 Q`0 Pk1 ;1 1 Pk2 ;2 2 1 ;2
where 1 ; 2 are caps of size C
1r
and separation dist.1 ; 2 / r with
r WD 2.`max In particular, `max kmin C O.1/.
kmin /=2
:
(4.2)
74
4 Bilinear estimates involving S and N spaces
(B) If k0 < kmax Pk0 Q`0
C , then X X ."/ Pk1 ; 1 Pk2 ; 1 2 D Pk0 Q`0 X
(4.3)
"D˙
C
."/
2
Pk0 Q`0
X
."/
Pk1 ;1 1 Pk2 ;
. "/
2 2
(4.4)
1 ;2
"D˙
1r
the sum in (4.4) runs over caps of size C r WD 2k0
with
kmax .`max kmin /=2
2
and with separation dist.1 ; 2 / r, whereas the sum in (4.3) runs over caps of size r 0 where 2k0 kmax r 0 1 is arbitrary but fixed. The sum (4.3) is empty if `max < kmax C and (4.4) is nonzero only if `max kmin C O.1/. Finally, if (4.1) fails, then the same representations hold provided r . 1 and one replaces dist.1 ; 2 / r with dist.1 ; 2 / . r. Proof. We consider first the .CC/ and . / cases, i.e., when 1 ; 2 have the same sign. Then j1 j C j2 j j1 C 2 j 2`max ; (4.5) whence .j1 j C j2 j/2
j1 C 2 j2 2`max Ckmax
and thus ^.1 ; 2 / 2.`max Ckmax
k1 k2 /=2
:
Now assume further that k0 D kmax C O.1/. Then it follows that ^.1 ; 2 / 2.`max
kmin /=2
:
If on the other hand k0 < kmax C , then k1 D k2 C O.1/ D kmax C O.1/ and from (4.5), `max D kmax C O.1/. Furthermore, 2 D 1 C O.2k0 / implies that ˇ ˇ ˇ^.1 ; 2 /ˇ j1 ^ 2 j D O.2k0 j1 jj2 j
kmax
/:
Next, consider the .C / or . C/ cases. Then j1 C 2 j
jj1 j
j2 jj 2`max
(4.6)
which implies that j1 C 2 j2
jj1 j
j2 jj2 2`max j1 C 2 j C jj1 j
j2 jj
4.1 Basic L2 -bounds
75
Figure 4.1. Opposing .CC/ waves
or equivalently, 2k1 Ck2 ^2 .1 ; 2 / 2`max Ck0 :
(4.7)
If k0 D kmax C O.1/, then ^.1 ; 2 / 2.`max If, on the other hand, k0 kmax
kmin /=2
:
C , then
^.1 ; 2 / 2k0
kmax .`max kmin /=2
2
and we are done. While it is clear that `max kmin C O.1/ if k0 D kmax C O.1/, some proof is needed in case k0 < kmax C . Thus, suppose j1 j j2 j whence j1 C 2 j
j1 j C j2 j 2`max
which implies that 2k0 Ck1 ^2 .1 C 2 ; 2 / 2`max Ckmax since 2k0 Ck1 2kmin Ckmax , the claim follows.
76
4 Bilinear estimates involving S and N spaces
Finally, if (4.1) fails, then (4.5) turns into j1 j C j2 j
j1 C 2 j . 2`max
which then leads to the claimed loss of separation between the sectors. However, their maximal distances are controlled by the same quantities as before. The special appearance of (4.3) derives from the contributions of waves which lie on opposing sides of the light-cone. In fact, Figure 4.1 shows two vectors on the same half (i.e., > 0) but opposing sides of the light cone. They add up to produce a wave of small frequency but large modulation, as described by (4.3). This is the mechanism by which nonlinearities can turn free waves into “elliptic objects”. This phrase refers to functions whose Fourier support has large separation from the characteristic variety of . Also, following Tao we refer to (4.1) as the modulation imbalanced case, whereas its opposite is the modulation balanced case. Remark 4.2. Lemma 4.1 is optimal in the following sense: ı Given `0 k0 10 there exist 1 ; 2 2 Rn with 1 j1 j; j2 j 2, ^.1 ; 2 / 2.`0 Ck0 /=2 and such that j1 C 2 j
jj1 j
j2 jj 2`0
j1 C 2 j 2k0 : ı Given `0 k1 10 there exist 1 ; 2 2 Rn with 2k1 1 j1 j; j2 j 2 and ^.1 ; 2 / 2.`0 k1 /=2 and so that j1 j C j2 j
1
j1 j 2k1 ,
j1 C 2 j 2`0 :
Our immediate goal now is the proof of Lemma 4.5. It is important to note that k the improvement of 2 2 over (2.30) which is obtained in Lemma 4.5 coincides with the gain for the case of free waves. In order to accomplish this, we require three preparatory lemmas, all of which are well-known. The first is Mockenhaupt’s “square function estimate” (more precisely, its geometric content), see [34], [35]. O Recall that D sign. /. Lemma 4.3. Let ; Q 2 C` with dist.; / Q jj 1 and suppose that Fi C`i for i D 1; 2 are partitions of and , Q respectively, by pairwise disjoint caps. Further, let r 2 .0; 1/, 2 .1; 2/, and define for any cap 0 S 1 T 0 ;;r WD f.; / W jjj
j r; 2 0 ; jj j
jjj j 0 j2 g:
4.1 Basic L2 -bounds
Set Mi WD #Fi . Then
X X
sup T1 ;1 ;r CT2 ;2 ;r 1 ;2 1
L1 .R3 /
1 2F1 2 2F2
77
C max 1; r.M1 C M2 / (4.8)
where C is some absolute constant. Proof. Fix r 2 .0; 1/, and 1 ; 2 1. Applying a Lorentz transform, one may assume that ` D 10, say. Also, suppose without loss of generality that `1 `2 whence M1 M2 . We first consider the case where rM1 1. Fix .; / 2 R3 such that1 X X 1 .T ; ;r CT ; ;r / .; / 1: 2
1
1
2
2
1 2F1 2 2F2
Suppose T1 ;1 ;r with 1 2 F1 contributes to the sum on the left-hand side. Define a mirror-image T1 ;1 ;r of T1 ;1 ;r by reflecting T1 ;1 ;r about the point .; /. Due to ` D 10 and the dimensions of the tubes T , the mirror images of all fT1 ;1 ;r g1 2F1 have uniformly bounded overlap. The same applies with the role of F1 and F2 reversed. In conclusion, each T1 ;1 ;r can pair up with at most O.1/-many T2 ;2 ;r so as to give a contribution to (4.8), whence the bound of M1 for (4.8). To obtain the factor r improvement, we further note that due to fixed 1 and 2 , only those contributions to (4.8) need to be counted which derive from pairs .T1 ;1 ;r ; T2 ;2 ;r / which lie in fixed cylinders jji j i j < r, i D 1; 2. In terms of equations, we are given .; / 2 R3 and we need to consider the sets of .i ; ri !i /, i D 1; 2 with !i 2 S 1 satisfying the transversality condition 1 1 ^.!1 ; !2 / 2 Œ 100 ; 50 , say, and such that 1 C 2 D ; jr1 jj1 j
1 j < r;
r1 !1 C r2 !2 D jr2
r1 j < 22`1 ;
2 j < r jj2 j
r2 j < 22`2 :
It follows from the second, third, and fourth conditions that 1 !1 C 2 !2 D C O.r/ and since the circular arcs containing !1 and !2 are transverse to each other, they must be of lengths . r. Consequently, we can only count tubes which correspond to an r r disk on the light-cone and of those there are at most rM1 -many. In case 1
The 12 -factor is a convenient modification that can be made due to scaling.
78
4 Bilinear estimates involving S and N spaces
rM1 1, then the number of the allowed pairs is . 1 in light of this construction and we are done. Next, we present a standard bilinear L2 bound for free waves. Lemma 4.4. Let ; Q 2 C` with dist.; / Q jj WD ˇ and suppose 1 , 2 Q are arbitrary caps. Let r 2 .0; 1/ and 1 ; 2 1. Then q ke i t jrj f1 e ˙i t jrj f2 kL2 L2x . ˇ 1 min rˇ; j1 j; j2 j kf1 k2 kf2 k2 ; (4.9) t
provided ˚ b1 / 2 R2 W O 2 1 ; jjj 1 j . r supp.f ˚ b2 / 2 R2 W O 2 ˙2 ; jjj 2 j . r supp.f
and the sign in the last sign is chosen to be the same as in (4.9). Proof. The proof reduces to the following well-known property of convolutions: Suppose ˚ 3 O 1 j . r ; 1 WD .jj; / 2 R W 2 1 ; jjj ˚ 3 O 2 j . r : 2 WD .˙jj; / 2 R W 2 ˙2 ; jjj Note that ^.; ˙/ & ˇ for any .jj; / 2 1 and .˙jj; / 2 2 . Then q 1 kf 1 g 2 kL2 .R3 / . ˇ min rˇ; j1 j; j2 j kf kL2 .d / kgkL2 .d 1
2
/
(4.10) where 1 and 2 are the lifts of the measure in to the sectors 1 ; 2 on the light-cones. To prove (4.10), interpolate between L1 and L1 . On L1 we have the standard fact that k k kkkk for measures and their total variation norms. This fact does not use the angular separation of the supports nor their sizes. On L1 , however, this separation and size are crucial and yield R2
kf
1
g 2 kL1 .R3 / . ˇ
1
min.r; j1 jˇ
1
/kf kL1 .d
1
/ kgkL1 .d
2
/
assuming as we may that j1 j j2 j. To obtain this bound, consider ıneighborhoods of 1 and 2 , respectively. In other words, replace d1 by .ı/
de j
WD ı
1
Œdist..; /;
j /<ı
d d
4.1 Basic L2 -bounds
79
for small ı > 0 and observe that .ı/
.ı/
lim sup kde 1 de 2 kL1 .ˇ ;
1
min.r; j1 jˇ
1
/
(4.11)
ı!0C
by elementary geometry. To pass from (4.10) to estimates for the wave equation use Plancherel’s theorem. We can now state the aforementioned improved bilinear L2 bound. The norm jjj jjj is the one from (2.67). Lemma 4.5. Let i be adapted to ki for i D 1; 2. Assume further that we are in the high-high case k1 D k2 C O.1/ and that i D Qj Ck 2k1 C i for i D 1; 2. Then k1 k j (4.12) kPk Qj .1 2 /kL2 L2x . 2 2 2 4 jjj1 jjjS Œk1 jjj2 jjjS Œk2 t
for any j k k1 C O.1/. Moreover, in the same range of j , kPk Qj .R˛ 1 Rˇ 2
Rˇ 1 R˛ 2 /kL2 L2x . 2 t
k1 2
2
3kCj 4
jjj1 jjjS Œk1 jjj2 jjjS Œk2 (4.13)
for any ˛; ˇ D 0; 1; 2. Proof. We assume that k1 D k2 C O.1/ D 0. At first, we also assume that k C so as to exclude the opposing .CC/ and . / waves in Lemma 4.1. We need to prove that kPk .1 2 /kL2 L2x . 2 t
k j 4
k.f1 ; g1 /kL2 HP
1
C kF1 kN Œk1
k.f2 ; g2 /kL2 HP
1
C kF2 kN Œk2
for any ki -adapted Schwartz functions fi ; gi ; Fi , i D 1; 2 and Z t sin t jrj sin .t s/jrj i .t/ D cos.t jrj/fi C gi C Fi .s/ ds jrj jrj 0 We reduce this to three cases:
k j
Pk Qj .1 2 / 2 2 . 2 4 .f1 ; g1 / 2 P 1 .f2 ; g2 / 2 P L t Lx L H L H
k j
Pk Qj .1 2 / 2 2 . 2 4 .f1 ; g1 / 2 P 1 F2 L t Lx L H N Œk2
k j
Pk Qj .1 2 / 2 2 . 2 4 kF1 kN Œk kF2 kN Œk 1 2 L L t
x
1
(4.14)
(4.15)
(4.16) (4.17) (4.18)
80
4 Bilinear estimates involving S and N spaces
where the absence of terms on the right-hand side implies that the corresponding functions are zero (thus, F1 D F2 D 0 in (4.16) etc.) We begin with (4.16) which follows easily from Lemma 4.4. To see this, we decompose i into caps of size ` D .j C k/=2 as in Lemma 4.1. Adopting the convention that 1 2 means that dist.1 ; 2 / 2` , and setting g1 D g2 D 0 for simplicity, one has2 X
Pk Qj .1 2 / 2 2 .
Pk Qj .Pk ; 1 Pk ; 2 / 2 2 1 1 2 2 L L L L t
x
t
x
1 2 2C`
X
.
X
kPk1 ;1 Pc 1 Pk2 ;2 P
c 2 kL2 L2x t
c2D0;k 1 2 2C`
X
.
X
2
k ` 2
kPk1 ;1 Pc f1 k2 kPk2 ;2 P
c f2 k2
(4.19)
c2D0;k 1 2 2C`
.2
k ` 2
kf1 k2 kf2 k2
as needed. The estimate in (4.19) follows from (4.8) since k `. To prove (4.17) and (4.18) it will suffice as usual to assume that Fi are N Œki atoms for i D 1; 2. In fact, if F2 in (4.17) is either and energy or an XP s;b -atom, then one again reduces matters to the free case. Consequently, we may restrict ourselves to (4.18) when both F1 and F2 are null-frame atoms. Using Lemma 2.11 to refine these null-frame atoms one can thus assume that X X e 00 F (4.20) F1 D F 0 ; F1 D 0 2C`0
00 2C`00
where `0 ; `00 `. Again by Lemma 2.11, we can further assume that there exists a fixed c 2 D0;k so that Pc F1 D F1 and P c F2 D F2 . Applying the same decomposition as in (4.19), fix 1 2 . In view of Lemma 2.22, X Z 1 Pk1 ;1 1 D G1 C 10 ;a C B 0 ;a 20 ;a da (4.21) 0 2C`0 0 1
Pk2 ;2 2 D
1e
G 2 C
R
X Z 00 2C`00 00 2
e 200 da e 100 C B e 00 ;a ;a ;a
(4.22)
R
where the functions on the right-hand side satisfy the bounds specified in that lemma. Moreover, the Fourier supports of the functions appearing inside the integral in (4.21) and (4.22) satisfy (2.43), and they also retain the Pc and P c 2
Recall our convention about Pki ; which takes the sign of into account.
4.1 Basic L2 -bounds
81
localization property, respectively, due to the fact that k `. We can ignore the e 2 as they are reducible to free waves. For simplicity, terms involving G1 and G 1 1 e we also set 0 ;a D 00 ;a D 0. By Plancherel’s theorem and Lemma 4.3, kPk ŒPk1 ;1 1 Pk2 ;2 2 kL2 L2x t q . 1 C 2k .M1 C M2 / ! 12 X c2D0;k
X
X
0 2C
00 2C
`0
2 c 2 kL2 L2 t x
kPk1 ; 0 Pc 1 Pk1 ; 00 P
`00
0 1 00 2
0
00
where M1 D 2` ` ; M2 D 2` ` . On the other hand, applying Lemma 2.22 to Pc 1 , P c 2 and using Lemma 4.4 implies that kPk1 ; 0 Pc 1 Pk1 ; 00 P c 2 kL2 L2x t Z e c e2 c kBc0 ;a 2c . 0 ;a B 00 ;b 00 ;b kL2 L2 dadb t x 2 ZR e2 c . k 2c 0 ;a 00 ;b kL2 L2 dadb t x 2 R Z q 0 00 e2 c . 2 ` min.2kC` ; 2` ; 2` / k 2c 0 ;a k 0; 1 ;1 k 00 ;b k XP 0
R2
.2
`
q
2
0 00 e min.2kC` ; 2` ; 2` /kPc F 0 kNFŒ 0 kP
1 ;1 0; 2
XP 0
dadb
c F 00 kNFŒ 00 :
One checks that q
1C
2k .M1
C M2 / 2
`
q
0
00
min.2kC` ; 2` ; 2` / . 2
k ` 2
;
whence X
kPk1 ;1 Pc 1 Pk2 ;2 P
c 2 kL2 L2x t
.2
k ` 2
c2D0;k
! 12 X c2D0;k
X
X
0 2C
00 2C
`0
`00
0 1 00 2
e kPc F 0 k2NFŒ 0 kP
2 c F 00 kNFŒ 00
:
82
4 Bilinear estimates involving S and N spaces
In conclusion, kPk Qj .1 2 /kL2 L2x t X X kPk1 ;1 Pc 1 Pk2 ;2 P .
c 2 kL2 L2x t
c2D0;k 1 2 2C`
.2
k ` 2
! 21 X
X
c2D0;k 1 2 2C` k `
. 2 2C
X
X
X
e c F 00 k2 00 kPc F 0 k2NFŒ 0 kP NFŒ
0 2C`0 00 2C`00 0 1 00 2
kF 0 k2NFŒ 0
12 X
0 2C`0
e 00 k2 00 kF NFŒ
21
00 2C`00
as desired; in the last step we have also used Lemma 2.11. This concludes the proof of (4.18) for the case of null-frame atoms F1 ; F2 . As indicated, the other cases are easier since they can be reduced to free waves. Finally, if k D O.1/, then the proof is easier. In fact, it follows via a capdecomposition from the basic bilinear bound (2.30). We leave those details to the reader. The second bound (4.13) follows by the same argument. The only difference from (4.12) lies with an additional gain of 2` which is precisely the size of the angle in the above decompositions into caps. Later, we shall require the following technical variant of the previous bound. Corollary 4.6. Under the assumptions of Lemma 4.5, for any j k k1 CO.1/ and any m0 10, X
kPk Qj .Pk1 ;1 1 Pk2 ;2 2 /kL2 L2x . 2
k1 2
t
2
k j 4
jjj1 jjjS Œk1 jjj2 jjjS Œk2 ;
1 ;2 2Cm0 dist.1 ;2 /2m0
(4.23) X 2Cm0
kPk Qj .Pk1 ; 1 2 /k2L2 L2 t
x
12
. jm0 j 2
k1 2
2
k j 4
jjj1 jjjS Œk1 jjj2 jjjS Œk2 : (4.24)
Moreover, analogous bounds hold for the null form in (4.13) with an extra gain j Ck of 2 2 . Finally, the left-hand side in (4.23) vanishes unless j C k 2m0 100.
4.1 Basic L2 -bounds
83
Proof. The final statement here is due to Lemma 4.1. Note that one cannot simply square sumP the bounds of LemmaP 4.5 applied to Pk1 ;1 1 and Pk2 ;2 2 due 2 to the fact that jjjPk; jjjS Œk (or kPk; k2S Œk for that matter) cannot be controlled. However, since we may assume that j Ck 2 m0 , the angular decomposition induced by the frequency and modulation cutoffs Pk Qj is finer than the one superimposed by 1 and 2 . Inspection of the proof now reveals that either by orthogonality or by organizing the finer caps into subsets of the 1 ; 2 2 Cm0 , and applying the Cauchy–Schwarz inequality yields the stated bound. For (4.24) one needs to distinguish two cases: either m0 j Ck 2 or not. In the former case, the decomposition into caps in Cm0 is coarser than the one coming from Lemma 4.1 and one can again argue by means of Cauchy–Schwarz as before. In the latter case, however, we split the modulation of the first input as follows: Q<j Ck
C
D Q<2m0
C
C Q2m0
C <j Ck C
The contribution of Q<2m0 C 1 is handled exactly as in the Lemma 4.5 since one may always refine the null-frame representation, cf. (4.20). On the other hand, Q2m0 C <j Ck C 1 is controlled by means of Lemma 2.4. More precisely, for any 2m0 C ` < j C k C one has Q` 1 D Q` 1 F1 ; see (4.15). Since (2.32) implies that kQ` 1 k
1 ;1 0; 2
XP 0
1
D kQ`
F1 k
1 ;1 0; 2
XP 0
. kQ` F1 k
0;
XP 0
1 2 ;1
. kF1 kN Œ0
one can reduce the contribution of Q` 1 to the case of free waves as in the proof of Lemma 4.5. Summing over all ` in this range loses a factor of at most jm0 j, as claimed. Finally, the claim concerning the null-forms is immediate. Removing the modulation restrictions on the inputs in Lemma 4.5 results in the following estimates. Lemma 4.7. If 1 and 2 are adapted to k1 and k2 , respectively, then for j k k1 C O.1/ D k2 C O.1/, kPk Qj .1 2 /kL2 L2x . 2
k j 4
t
2
k1 2
jjj1 jjjS Œk1 jjj2 jjjS Œk2 ;
(4.25)
whereas for j k2 k D k1 C O.1/, kPk Qj .1 2 /kL2 L2x . 2 t
3k2 4
2
j 4
k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2 :
(4.26)
84
4 Bilinear estimates involving S and N spaces
Proof. Consider the high-high case j k k1 C O.1/ D k2 C O.1/ D 0. On the one hand, there is the bound
k j
Pk Qj .Qj Ck C 1 Qj Ck C 2 / 2 2 . 2 4 jjj1 jjjS Œk jjj2 jjjS Œk (4.27) 1 2 L L x
t
which is given by Lemma 4.5. On the other hand, by the improved Bernstein bound of Lemma 2.1,
j k
Pk Qj .Q>j Ck C 1 2 / 2 2 . 2 4 ^0 2k kQ>j Ck C 1 2 k 2 1 L Lx L L t
x
t
.2 .2
j
k 4
k j 4
2k kQ>j Ck
2 C 1 kL2t L2x k2 kL1 t Lx
k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2 :
(4.28)
In the high-low case j k2 k D k1 C O.1/ D 0 consider the following three subcases. First,
j k k
Pk Qj .Q<j C 1 Q<j C 2 / 2 2 . 2 4 2 2 22 k1 kS Œk k2 kS Œk 1 2 L L t
x j
k2
j
k2 4
by a decomposition into caps of size 2 2 and the L2 -bilinear bound (2.30). Next, by the improved Bernstein estimate Lemma 2.1,
Pk Qj .1 Qj C 2 / 2 2 . k1 kL1 L2 kQj C 2 k 2 1 L Lx L L t
x
t
.2
k2
2 2
j 2
k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2 :
And third, kPk Qj .Qj C 1 Q<j C 2 /kL2 L2x t X
. Pk Qj .Qm 1 Q<j
C 2 / L2 L2x t
mj CO.1/
X
.
X
kPk1 ;1 Qm 1 Pk2 ;2 Q<j
mj CO.1/ 1 ;2
X
.
X
kPk1 ;1 Qm 1 kL2 L2x kPk2 ;2 Q<j t
mj CO.1/ 1 ;2
X
.
2
m 2
C 2 kL2t L2x
2k2 2
m k2 4
C 2 kL1 t;x
k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2
mj CO.1/
.2
3k2 4
2
j 4
k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2
as claimed. The inner sums run over 1 ; 2 2 C m
k2 2
with dist.1 ; 2 / . 2
m k2 2
.
4.1 Basic L2 -bounds
85
Later we shall also need the following technical variants, both of which are in the same spirit as Corollary 4.6. Corollary 4.8. Let be adapted to k1 and suppose for every 2 Cm0 with m0 100 there is a Schwarz function which is adapted to k2 . Then, provided j k2 k D k1 C O.1/, X
kPk Qj .Pk1 ;
/kL2 L2x . jm0 j2
3k2 4
t
2
j 4
kkS Œk1
X
2Cm0
k
2 kS Œk2
12
2Cm0
(4.29) Proof. One uses the argument for the high-low case of Lemma 4.7. In particular, k D k1 C O.1/ D 0. First, with m D j 2k2 , X
Pk Qj .Q<j
C Pk1 ;
Q<j
C
/
2Cm0
D
X
X
Pk Qj .Q<j
C Pk1 ;1 Pk1 ;
Q<j
C Pk2 ;2
/:
2Cm0 1 ;2 2Cm
If m m0 , then by the L2 -bilinear bound (2.30) X
Pk Qj .Q<j
C Pk1 ;
Q<j
C
/ L2 L2 t x
2Cm0
X
.
X
Pk Qj .Q<j
C Pk1 ;1
Q<j
C Pk2 ;2
/ L2 L2 t x
2Cm0 1 ;2 2Cm 1
X
.
X
j
2
k2 4
2
k2 2
2Cm0 1 ;2 2Cm 1
j
.2
k2 4
2
k2 2
kkS Œk1
kQ<j X
C Pk1 ;1 kS Œk1 ;1 kQ<j C Pk2 ;2
k
2 kS Œk2
kS Œk2 ;2
12
2Cm0
where we applied Cauchy–Schwarz twice to pass to the last line. If, on the other hand, m > m0 , then we first consider smaller modulations of . In fact, dropping
:
86
4 Bilinear estimates involving S and N spaces
the Q<j C on as we may one has X
Pk Qj .Q<2m C Pk ; Q<j 0 1
/ L2 L2 t x
C
2Cm0
X
.
X
Pk Qj .Q<2m 0
C Pk1 ;1
Q<j
C Pk2 ;2
/ L2 L2 t x
1 ;2 2Cm 2Cm0 1
X
.
j
X
2
k2 4
2
k2 2
1 ;2 2Cm 2Cm0 1
j
.2
kQ<2m0 X k2 k2 4 2 2 kkS Œk1 k
C Pk1 ; kS Œk1 ; kQ<j C Pk2 ;2 2 kS Œk2
kS Œk2 ;2
12
2Cm0
where we again applied Cauchy–Schwarz twice to pass to the last line. Finally, we need to account for Q2m0 C <j C . Fix ` with 2m0 C ` < j C and repeat the previous estimate. This yields X kPk Qj .Q` Pk1 ; Q<j C /kL2 L2x t
2Cm0 j
.2
k2 4
2
k2 2
kkS Œk1
X
k
2 kS Œk2
21
2Cm0
which, upon summing in ` yields the same bound with the loss of a factor of .j 2m0 /C . Replacing this by the larger jm0 j then implies the bound of the corollary. Next, by the improved Bernstein estimate of Lemma 2.1, and Lemma 2.18, X kPk Qj .Pk1 ; Qj C /kL2 L2x t
2Cm0
.
X
kPk1 ; kL1 L2 kQj
C
kL2 L1 x t
2Cm0 j
. jm0 j 2
k2 4
2 k2 2
j 2
kkS Œk1
X 2Cm0
And third, X kPk Qj .Qj 2Cm0
C Pk1 ;
Q<j
C
/kL2 L2x t
k
2 kS Œk2
12
:
4.1 Basic L2 -bounds
X
.
X
87
kPk Qj .Qm Pk1 ; Q<j
C
/kL2 L2x t
mj CO.1/ 2Cm0
X
.
X
X
kPk1 ;1 Qm Pk1 ; Pk2 ;2 Q<j
C
kL2 L2x t
mj CO.1/ 2Cm0 1 2
X
.
X
X
kPk1 ;1 Qm Pk1 ; kL2 L2x t
mj CO.1/ 2Cm0 1 2
2k2 2
. 2k2 2
j
k2 4
X
X
1 ;
mDj CO.1/
m k2 4
kPk2 ;2 Q<j 12 2 kPk1 ;1 Qm Pk1 ; kL2 L2 kPk2 ;2 Q<j
C
0
3k2 4
2
j 4
kkS Œk1
X
k
2 kS Œk2
t
k2L1 L2
2 ; 0
.2
kL1 L2x
x
t
X
C
t
21
x
12
2Cm0
as claimed. The inner sums run over 1 ; 2 2 C m dist.1 ; 2 / . 2
m k2 2
k2 2
and 1 2 denotes
.
Remark 4.9. We note here that one may also gain in terms of m0 at the expense of some losses in terms of the frequencies/modulations; specifically, using similar reasoning and under the same assumptions as above, one obtains X
kPk Qj .Pk1 ;
/kL2 L2x t
2Cm0
. 2ı1 m0 2ı2 .k1
j/
2
3k2 4
2
j 4
kkS Œk1
X
k
2 kS Œk2
21
(4.30)
2Cm0
for suitable ı1;2 > 0. We shall also require the following estimates which gain something in terms of the small angle. Corollary 4.10. Given ı > 0 small and L 1, there exists m0 .ı; L/ 1 with the following property: let k; k1 ; k2 2 Z so that maxi D1;2 jk ki j L. For any
88
4 Bilinear estimates involving S and N spaces
1 and 2 which are adapted to k1 ; k2 , respectively, and j k C C , X
kPk Qj .Pk1 ;1 1 Pk2 ;2 2 /kL2 L2x ı2
k j 3
2
t
k1 2
jjj1 jjjS Œk1 jjj2 jjjS Œk2 :
1 ;2 2Cm0 dist.1 ;2 /2m0
(4.31) In the high-low case k D k1 C O.1/, k2 k1 X
C,
kPk Qj .Pk1 ;1 1 Pk2 ;2 2 /kL2 L2x ı2
k2 j 3
t
2
k2 2
k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2
1 ;2 2Cm0 dist.1 ;2 /2m0
(4.32) as well as X 1
k j k
Pk Qj .1 Pk ; 2 / 2 2 2 2 ı2 23 2 22 k1 kS Œk k2 kS Œk : 1 2 2 L L t
x
2 2Cm0
(4.33) Proof. Let k1 D 0 whence jkj L and jk2 j 2L. Implicit constants will be allowed to depend on L. By Corollary 4.6 and (4.27), X
Pk Qj .Qj Ck
C Pk1 ;1 1 Qj Ck C Pk2 ;2 2 / L2 L2x t
1 ;2 2Cm0 dist.1 ;2 /2m0
.2
kCj 4
2
j 2
jjj1 jjjS Œk1 jjj2 jjjS Œk2 ı2
j 4
jjj1 jjjS Œk1 jjj2 jjjS Œk2 m0
kCj
which is sufficient. Note that we used interpolation and 2 4 2 2 which gives the desired gain of ı provided m0 is small enough relative to ı and L. For the remaining cases we use a variant of (4.28): with 2 > r > 1, D 2r 1, and 1 1 1 p D r 2,
Pk Qj .Q>j Ck .2 .2
j 4 j 4 j
C Pk1 ;1 1
Pk2 ;2 2 / L2 L2 t
kQ>j Ck
C 1
kQ>j Ck
p C Pk1 ;1 1 kL2t L2x kPk2 ;2 2 kL1 t Lx
. 2 4 .
2/ m0 . 21
2
1 p/
(4.34)
x
Pk2 ;2 2 kL2 Lrx
kPk1 ;1 1 k
t
1 ;1 0; 2
XP 0
kPk2 ;2 2 kL1 L2x : t
(4.35)
4.1 Basic L2 -bounds
89
j
Taking close to 1, one can make this ı2 4 as desired. This bound can be summed over 1 ; 2 by Cauchy–Schwarz and the definition of the S Œk-norm; see also Lemma 2.18. In the high-low case j k2 k D k1 C O.1/ D 0 we proceed as follows. First,
Pk Qj .Q<j C Pk ; 1 Q<j C Pk ; 2 / 2 2 1
j
.2
k2 2
min 2
m0 2
1
2
j
;2
k2 4
2
kPk1 ;1 Q<j j
. ı2
k2 3
2
k2 2
kPk1 ;1 Q<j
L t Lx
2
k2 2
C 1 kS Œk1 kPk2 ;2 Q<j C 2 kS Œk2
C 1 kS Œk1 kPk2 ;2 Q<j C 2 kS Œk2 j
k2
by a decomposition into caps of size 2 2 and the L2 -bilinear bound (2.30). The summation over 1 and 2 can be carried out since it leads to the square function (2.15). Next, by the improved Bernstein estimate, see Lemma 2.1, kPk Qj .Pk1 ;1 1 Qj
C Pk2 ;2 2 /kL2t L2x
. kPk1 ;1 1 kL1 L2 kQj j
. min.2 j
ı2
k2 4
k2 3
2
;2
k2 2
m0 2
/2k2 2
C Pk2 ;2 2 kL2t L1 x j 2
kPk1 ;1 1 kL1 L2x kPk2 ;2 2 k
kPk1 ;1 1 kL1 L2x kPk2 ;2 2 k t
1 ;1 0; 2
XP k
t
2
0; 1 2 ;1
XP k
2
and summation over 1 ; 2 is again admissible. Finally,
Pk Qj .Qj C Pk ; 1 Q<j C Pk ; 2 / 2 2 1 1 2 2 L t Lx X
. Pk Qj .Qm Pk1 ;1 1 Q<j C Pk2 ;2 2 / L2 L2 t
x
mj CO.1/
X
X
mj CO.1/
10 ;20
X
X
mj CO.1/
10 ;20
. .
kPk1 ;1 Qm Pk1 ;10 1 Pk2 ;2 Q<j kQm Pk1 ;1 Pk1 ;10 1 kL2 L2x kQ<j t
X
.
2
m 2
2k2 min.2
m k2 4
;2
m0 2
C Pk2 ;20 2 kL2t L2x C Pk2 ;2 Pk2 ;20 2 kL1 t;x
/kPk1 ;1 1 kS Œk1 kPk2 ;2 2 kS Œk2
mj CO.1/
. ı2
k2 2
j
2
k2 3
kQj CO.1/ Pk1 ;1 1 k
0; 1 2 ;1
XP k
1
kPk2 ;2 2 kL1 L2x t
(4.36)
90
4 Bilinear estimates involving S and N spaces
as claimed. The inner sums run over 10 ; 20 2 C j
with dist.10 ; 20 / . 2
k2 2
j
k2 2
.
The bound in (4.36) can be summed over the caps 1 ; 2 by definition of the S Œk norm. Finally, (4.33) follows from the preceding since the gain of ı was obtained only from the low-frequency function 2 . We can therefore square-sum the final estimate to obtain the desired conclusion.
4.2
An algebra estimate for SŒk
The following bilinear bound expresses something close to an algebra property of the SŒk spaces. It is obtained by removing the restriction on the modulation of the output in Lemma 4.7. Lemma 4.11. For any j; k 2 Z,
Pk Qj . / . 2k1 ^k2 2 provided ; tively.
1
XP 0; 2 ;1
k k1 _k2 4
j
2
k1 ^k2 ^0 4
2.k1 _k2
j /. 21 "/^0
jjjjjjS Œk1 jjj jjjS Œk2 ; (4.37)
are Schwartz functions which are adapted to k1 and k2 , respec-
Proof. We commence with the high-high case k1 D k2 C O.1/ D 0 and k O.1/. We need to prove that
Pk Qj . /
j
k
. 2 4 min 2 4 ; 2
1
XP 0; 2 ;1
To begin with, one has
2j=2 Pk Qj .Q>j k j=2
.2 2
2
. 2k 2j=2 2 . 2k 2
j
k 4
C
j
k 4
j
k 4
^0
^0 ^0
j. 12 "/
jjjjjjS Œk1 jjj jjjS Œk2 :
/ L2 L2 t
x
kPk Qj .Q>j kQ>j
min.1; 2
C
C kL2 L2 k . 12
"/j
/kL2 L1x t
kL1 L2
/kkS Œk1 k kS Œk2
which is admissible. So it suffices to estimate Pk Qj .Qj C Qj C /. As usual, we perform a wave-packet decomposition by means of Lemma 4.1. Note
91
4.2 An algebra estimate for S Œk
that (4.1) holds here. We begin with (4.3) where we choose r 0 WD 2k . Thus, k < C and j D O.1/, and in view of (2.30)
Pk Qj .Qj C C Qj C C / 2 2 L t Lx X kP Qj C C P Qj C C kL2 L2x . t
2Ck
X
.
1
jj 2 kP Qj
C
C
kS Œk1 ; kP
Qj C
C
kS Œk2 ;
2Ck
. 2k=2C kkS Œk1 k kS Œk2 where we invoked Lemma 2.12 in the final step. The same estimate applies to and . It therefore suffices to assume that j k C O.1/; but then Lemma 4.7 applies. Next, we consider the low-high case k D k2 C O.1/ D 0, k1 < C . We need to prove that
j j 2 2 P0 Qj . / L2 L2 . 2k1 2 t
k1 4 ^0
x
min.1; 2
j. 21 "/
/kkS Œk1 k kS Œ0 :
In view of Lemma 4.7 we can assume that j k1 . From the XP s;b;q components of the SŒk norm,
2j=2 P0 Qj .Qj C / L2 L2 . 2j=2 kQj C kL2 L1 k kL1 L2 t
. 2k1 2
j
k1 4 ^0
min.1; 2
. 12
"/j
Finally, it remains to bound
2j=2 P0 Qj .Q<j
x
/kkS Œk1 k kS Œk2 :
C
Qj
C
/ L2 L2 t
x
which will be done using the usual angular decomposition. Lemma 4.1, and provided j C , and with ` D m 2k1 ^ 0,
2j=2 P0 Qj .Q<j X . 2j=2
C
Qj X
mj C
; 0 2C` ; 0
X
X
C
In fact, from
/ L2 L2 t
x
kP0 Qj .Pk1 ; Q<j
C
Pk2 ; 0 Qm /kL2 L2x t
(4.38) .
mj C
2j=2
; 0 2C` ; 0
kPk1 ; Q<j
C kL1 L1 kPk2 ; 0 Qm
kL2 L2x t
92
4 Bilinear estimates involving S and N spaces
X
.
j
2 k1 2
m k1 ^0 4
kPk1 ; kL1 L2 kPk2 ; 0 Qm kL2 L2x t
; 0 2C` ; 0
mj C
. 2 k1 2
X
2j=2 k1 4 ^0
kkS Œk1 k kS Œk2
where we used Corollary 2.16 in the final inequality. If j C , then only m D j C O.1/ contributes to the sum in (4.38). The XP 0;1 ";2 component of the S Œk1 norm then leads to a gain of min.1; 2 . 2 "/j / and we are done. Corollary 4.12. Under the same conditions as in the previous lemma and provided k1 k2 one has
Pk .Q
1
XP 0; 2 ;1
. 2k1 1 C .k2 ^ a
k1 /C kkS Œk1 k kS Œk2
(4.39)
where k D O.1/ C k2 . Proof. Summing (4.37) over j yields (4.39) with a k2 . It thus suffices to consider a k2 . If a k1 we use Q
2j=2 Pk Qj .Q
x
t
j
X
2j=2 kPk Qj .Q
j aC10
X
C
2j=2 kPk Qj .Qj CO.1/ Q
j aC10
X
. 2k1 kkS Œk1 k kS Œk2 C
2j=2 kQj CO.1/ kL2 L1 kQ
j aC10 k1
. 2 kkS Œk1 k kS Œk2 X
C
3
2j=2 2. 2
"/k1
2
j.1 "/
kkS Œk1 kQ
j aC10
. 2k1 kkS Œk1 k kS Œk2 as desired. The sum over j a C 10 was estimated via Lemma 4.11. If k1 < a k2 , one proceeds similarly.
93
4.3 Bilinear estimates involving both S Œk1 and N Œk2 waves
Bilinear estimates involving both SŒk1 and N Œk2 waves
4.3
The following lemma is a crucial tool. In essence, it expresses the property N S ,! N . Lemma 4.13. For and F which are k1 and k2 -adapted, respectively, one has kPk .F /kN Œk . 2k1 ^k2 2
j
k^k1 ^k2 ^0 4
kkS Œk1 kF kN Œk2
(4.40)
provided Pk2 Qj F D F and under the following condition Pk Qj
C .Q<j C
F / D Pk Qj
C .Q<j Ck k1 C
F/
(4.41)
in the case k1 D k2 C O.1/ k C O.1/ j . If (4.41) fails, then one loses a factor of 1 C .k1 k/C on the right-hand side of (4.40); alternatively, one has the following weaker version of (4.40) kPk .F /kN Œk . 2k1 ^k2 2
j
k^k1 ^k2 ^0 4
kk
0; 1 2 ;1
XP k
kF kN Œk2 :
(4.42)
1 1
0; ;1 Proof. We remark beforehand that this proof will only use the XP k1 2 -norm for the elliptic regime D Pk Qk of the S Œk norm. In particular, the embedding kkS Œk1 . kk 0; 1 ;1 holds without any restrictions on the modulation, XP k
2
1
cf. (2.20). We start with the high-high case k1 D k2 C O.1/ D 0. Throughout this proof, we shall freely use Lemma 2.15 in order to remove Q<j C from various estimates. First, we consider the case where D Qj C . If j k, then by Bernstein’s and Hölder’s inequalities
Pk .F / . 2 k kPk .F /kL1 L2 . kF kL1 L1 N Œk . kkL2 L2x kF kL2 L2x . kkS Œk1 2 t
t
j 2
kF kL2 L2x t
. kkS Œk1 kF kN Œk2 which is admissible. If on the other hand j k, then we again have to consider several subcases. If D Qk , then 2
k
kQk F kL1 L2x . kQk F kL1 L1x . kQk kL2 L2x kF kL2 L2x t
t
.2
j
k 2
kkS Œk1 kF kN Œk2
t
t
94
4 Bilinear estimates involving S and N spaces
which is admissible. Hence it suffice to assume that D Qj C k . Furthermore, we can assume that the output is at modulation j . In fact, by the improved Bernstein’s inequality, k
Pk Q>j .F / .2 N Œk
X
` 2
2
kPk Q` .F /kL2 L2x t
`>j
.
X
` 2
2
2
` k 4 ^0
kF kL2 L1
`>j
.
X
2
j
` 2
2
` k 4 ^0
kkL1 L2x 2
j 2
t
kF kL2 L2x t
`>j
.2
j
k 4
kkS Œk1 kF kN Œk2
as desired. Now consider the output of modulation at most j . We also first restrict ourselves to the contributions by Qj C <<j CC . Thus, by Lemma 4.1 and Lemma 2.15,
Pk Qj .Qj C <<j CC F / N Œk X k .2 kPk Qj .Q` F /kL1 L2x t
`Dj CO.1/
.2
k
X
X
`Dj CO.1/ D2Dk
.2
k
X
X
X 0 2C
kPk Qj .PD P Q` P 0 P
D F /kL1t L2x
.`Ck/=2
X
kPD P Q` P 0 P
D F kL1t L2x
`Dj CO.1/ D2Dk 0 2C.`Ck/=2
where 0 means dist.; 0 / . diam./. Moreover, Dk is a cover of fjj 1g by disks of diameter 2k and with overlap uniformly bounded in k; the associated projections are PD . Hence, one can further estimate (recall j k)
Pk Qj . F / N Œk X X k .2 `Dj CO.1/ D2Dk
.2
k
X
X
`Dj CO.1/ D2Dk
. 2.j
k/=4
X
kPD P Q` kL2 L1 kP 0 P x t
0 2C
.`Ck/=2
X 0 2C
D F kL2t L2x
2
`C3k 4
.`Ck/=2
kkS Œk1 kF kN Œk2 :
kPD P Q` kL2 L2x kP 0 P t
D F kL2t L2x
95
4.3 Bilinear estimates involving both S Œk1 and N Œk2 waves
Next, we consider the output of modulation at most j and D Qj CC k . Then we are in the “imbalanced case” of Lemma 4.1, whence X X Pk Qj .F / D Pk; Qj .Pk1 ; 0 Ql Pk2 ; 00 F / k`j CC ; 0 ; 00 ` k
where 2 C ` k , 0 ; 00 2 C.`Ck/=2 and dist.; 0 / 2 2 , dist. 0 ; 00 / 2 2 Using (2.29) one obtains
Pk Qj .F / N Œk X X
k
Pk; Qj .Pk ; 0 Q` Pk ; 00 F / 2 1 2 NFŒ
`Ck 2
.
k`j CC ; 0 ; 00
.
X
2
k`j CC
.
X
2
k
2 2
j
k 4
`Ck 4
X
` k 2 ^0
2
j
` 4
kPk1 ; 0 Q` kS Œk1 ; kPk2 ; 00 F kL2 L2x t
0 ; 00 j 2
kQ` kS Œk1 2
kF kL2 L2x . 2
j
t
k 4
kkS Œk1 kF kN Œk2
k`j CC
as desired. To pass to the final inequality one uses (2.20) as well as kQ` kS Œk1 kQ` k 0; 1 ;1 . XP k
2
1
Now assume Q<j C D . We first dispose of outputs of modulation exceeding j C . If j k, then kPk Q>j .2 .2
C .F /kN Œk j 2 j 2
kPk Q>j
C .F /kL2t L1x
.2
j 2
kkL1 L2 kF kL2 L2
kkS Œk1 kF kL2 L2x . kkS Œk1 kF kN Œk2 t
which is admissible. On the other hand, if j k, then X ` kPk Q>j C .F /kN Œk . 2 k 2 2 kPk Q` .F /kL2 L2x t
`>j C
X
.
2
` 2
2
` k 4
kPk Q` .F /kL2 L1x C 2 t
3k 2
kPk Qk .F /kL2 L2x t
k`>j C
.2
j
k 4
kkS Œk1 kF kN Œk2
as desired. It therefore remains to consider X Pk Qj C .Q<j C F / D Pk Qj ˙
C .Q<j C
˙
F ˙/
96
4 Bilinear estimates involving S and N spaces
where all four possibilities .CC/; .C /; . C/; . / are allowed on the righthand side. We first dispose of the contributions “opposing waves” as described by (4.3). This occurs only if k < C and j D O.1/, in fact, Pk Qj
C .Q<j C
C
F C / D Pk Q
C <
C
F C /;
whence
Pk Qj
C .Q<j C
C
F C / N Œk
. k C F C kL2 L1 . k C kL1 L2 kF C kL2 L2x t
. kkS Œk1 kF kN Œk2 which is admissible. Therefore, we can now ignore the contribution of (4.3). Let us now also assume without loss of generality that D C , see Lemma 2.12. Using duality and Lemma 4.1, one obtains in view of (4.41) Pk Qj
F/ X X ˙ D Pk;˙ Qj
C .Q<j C
C .Pk1 ; 0 Q<j Ck C
Pk2 ; 00 F / (4.43)
˙ ; 0 ; 00
with caps 2 C` , 0 ; 00 2 C` satisfying dist. 0 ; 00 / 2m , dist.; 0 / 2` where ` D .j k/=2, m D .j C k/=2. Note that Lemma 4.1 also implies that j k C O.1/. Since ˙ Pk;˙ Qj
C
˙ D Pk;˙ QkC2`
(4.44)
C
the right-hand side of (4.43) represents a wave-packet decomposition in the sense of Definition 2.9. Moreover, the operators in (4.44) are disposable in the sense of Lemma 2.14. Therefore, kPk Qj
C .Q<j C
F /kN Œk
.2
k
max ˙
X
Pk ; 0 Q<j Ck 1
C
Pk2 ; 00 F kNFŒ :
0 ; 00
We could discard here since the choice of 0 leaves only a finite number of choice of . Invoking (2.29), this can be further estimated by .2
k
. 2.j
max ˙
k/=4
X 2 j Ck 4 0 ; 00
2
j
k
kPk1 ; 0 Q<j Ck
2
kkS Œk1 kF kN Œk2 :
C kS Œk1 ; 0 kPk2 ; 00 F kL2t L2x
97
4.3 Bilinear estimates involving both S Œk1 and N Œk2 waves
To pass to the final inequality here it was essential that (4.41) reduced the modulation of from < j C to < j C k C . Indeed, if (4.41) fails, then we need to write Q<j C D Q<j Ck C C Qj Ck C <j C . For the first summand here one applies the argument we just gave, whereas for the second summand the best one can do is to invoke (2.20) which results in the loss of of factor of k a claimed. This concludes the high-high case. Let us now consider the low-high case k1 < C , k2 D k D O.1/. Since (2.24) implies that kQj
C
F kL1 L2 . kQj j 2
.2 j
.2
C kL2 L1 kF kL2t L2x j
2
k1 4 ^0
2k1 kkS Œk1 kF kL2 L2x t
k1 4 ^0
2k1 kkS Œk1 kF kN Œk2
it will suffice to bound kQj C F kN Œk . Moreover, if j k1 C C , then the modulation of Qj C F is on the order of j , whence kQj
C
F kN Œk . 2 .2 .2
j 2 j 2 j 2
kQj
C
F kL2 L2x
kQj
C kL1 L1 kF kL2t L2x
t
2k1 kkS Œk1 kF kL2 L2x . 2k1 kkS Œk1 kF kN Œk2 t
as desired. We may therefore assume that j k1 C C . We first consider the case where the output has modulation j C . More precisely, let j C m k1 C C , ` D .m k1 /=2, as well as without loss of generality F D F C . Then by the balanced modulation case of Lemma 4.1, X C Qm .Qj C F / D Pk; Qm .Pk1 ; 0 Qj C F / ; 0
where ; 0 are caps of size C kQm .Qj
1 2`
and with dist.; 0 / . 2` . Therefore,
F /kN Œk X C . 2 m=2 k Pk; Qm .Pk1 ; 0 Qj C
C
F /kL2 L2x t
; 0
.2
m=2
X
2 2 kPk1 ; 0 Qj C kL 1 L1 kF k 2 2 L L
21
; 0
.2
m=2
X ; 0
22k1 2` kPk1 ; Qj
2 C kL1 L2
2 kF kL 2 L2
21
98
4 Bilinear estimates involving S and N spaces
.2
m=2
2
.k1 m/=4 k1
.2
m=2
2
.k1 m/=4 k1
2 kQj
C kL1 L2 kF kL2t L2x
2 kkS Œk1 kF kL2 L2x t
where we used Lemma 2.15 in the final step. Summing over m j that kQ>j
C .Qj C
F /kN Œk . 2k1 2
j=2
k1
2
.k1 j /=4
.k1 j /=4
.2 2
C implies
kkS Œk1 kF kL2 L2x t
kkS Œk1 kF kN Œk2
which is admissible. It therefore remains to bound kQ<j C .Qj C F /kN Œk for which we shall again apply a wave-packet decomposition as in Lemma 4.1. Since j k1 C C and k1 1, we can assume that j C in applying Lemma 4.1 (which allows us to ignore the opposing .CC/ or . / contributions in (4.3)). Without loss of generality, we assume further that D C (see Lemma 2.12). Then with caps ; 0 of size C 1 2m and separation 2m where m WD .j k1 /=2, kQ<j
C .Qj C F /kN Œk
X
. Pk; Q<j 0
X
.
Pk; Q<j
C .Pk1 ; 0 Qj C F / N Œk
k1 .Pk1 ; 0 Qj C
0
where we used Corollary 2.23 to dispose of Qj further bounded by .2
k1 2
j
2
k1 4
X 0
. 2.j
C.
21
2
F /
(4.45)
N Œk
In view of (2.29) this is
kPk1 ; 0 Qj C k2S Œk1 ; 0 kF k2L2 L2 t x
21
k1 /=4 k1
2 kkS Œk1 kF kN Œk2
as desired. It remains to consider the high-low case k D k1 CO.1/ D 0, k2 <
C . First,
kQ>j Ck2 F kN Œk . kQ>j Ck2 F kL1 L2 . kQ>j Ck2 kL2 L2 kF kL2 L1 .2
.j Ck2 /=2 k2
.2 2
j
kkS Œk1 2k2 2
k2 4 ^0
kkS Œk1 2
j 2
j
k2 4 ^0
kF kL2 L2x t
2
k2
kF kL2 L2x t
4.3 Bilinear estimates involving both S Œk1 and N Œk2 waves
99
k2
which is acceptable with a factor of 2 2 to spare. The reason for using Q>j Ck2 rather than Q>j will become clear momentarily. Next, kQj Ck2 F kN Œk . kQj Ck2
C ŒQj Ck2
C kQ<j Ck2 As usual, (4.46) is controlled in the XP
C ŒQj Ck2
1 2 ;1
1;
F kN Œk
(4.46)
F kN Œk
(4.47)
norm whence
(4.46) . 2
.j Ck2 /=2
.2
.j Ck2 /=2
kQj Ck2 kL1 L2 kF kL2 L1
.2
.j Ck2 /=2
kQj Ck2 kL1 L2 2k2 2
kQj Ck2 F kL2 L2x t
. 2 k2 2
j
k2 4 ^0
kkS Œk1 2
j 2
2
k2
j
k2 4 ^0
kF kL2 L2x t
kF kL2 L2x t
which is again acceptable. Finally, we perform a wave-packet decomposition on (4.47) via Lemma 4.1 in the imbalanced case and duality. Thus, one has X C Q<j Ck2 C .Qj Ck2 F / D Pk; Q<j .Pk1 ; 0 Qj Ck2 F / Ck2 C ; 0
where the sum runs over pairs of caps ; 0 of size C 1 2` with ` WD .j C k2 /=2 and dist.; 0 / 2` . Moreover, j k2 C O.1/ since the only other possibility j D O.1/ allowed by (4.3) contributes a vanishing term (as does Q<j Ck2 C ). Therefore, with 0 denoting the admissible pairs, X X C
. Pk; Q<j Ck2
.2
` 2
C
.Pk1
; 0
2 21 Qj Ck2 F / N Œ
0
2j=2 2k2 kkS Œk1 kF kN Œk2
. 2k2 2.j
k2 /=4
kkS Œk1 kF kN Œk2
as desired.
There is the following general estimate that does not require (4.41) since we restrict ourselves to k k1 C O.1/. Corollary 4.14. For and F which are k1 and k2 -adapted, respectively, one has kPk .F /kN Œk . 2k1 ^k2 2
j
k^k1 ^k2 ^0 4
kkS Œk1 kF kN Œk2
provided Pk2 Qj F D F and k D k1 _ k2 C O.1/.
(4.48)
100
4 Bilinear estimates involving S and N spaces
Proof. This is an immediate consequence of Lemma 4.13.
Another important technical variant of Lemma 4.13 has to do with an additional angular localization of the inputs. This will be important later in the trilinear section. Its statement is somewhat technically cumbersome, but this is precisely the form in which we shall use it later. Corollary 4.15. Let be k1 -adapted, and assume that for some m0 100, for every 2 Cm0 there is a Schwarz function F which is adapted to k2 and so that Pk2 Qj F D F . Then X
kPk .Pk1 ; F /kN Œk . jm0 j 2
2Cm0
k1
j
2
k1 4 ^0
kkS Œk1
X
kF k2N Œk2
12
2Cm0
(4.49) provided we are in the low-high case k D k2 C O.1/ k1 . The sum here runs over caps with dist.1 ; 2 / . 2m0 . Proof. For this, one simply repeats the P proof of the2 low-high case of Lemma 4.13 with one additional twist: since kPk1 ; kS Œk cannot be controlled by kkS Œk1 , one has to check carefully that the square summation – which (4.49) leads to after Cauchy–Schwarz – is compatible with the estimates we are making (the norm for F is always L2t L2x ). This is the case if we place Pk1 ; 2 P s;b -norm. In the latter case one does not incur any loss in L1 t Lx or an X due to orthogonality, whereas in the former case there is a loss of jm0 j, see Lemma 2.18. The only place where one cannot use either of these norms is (4.45). Indeed, if k1 C 2m0 j C , then the caps of sizes 2m0 are smaller than j
k1
those of size 2` D 2 2 in the wave-packet decomposition of (4.45). In this case, however, one considers a wave-packet decomposition induced by the projections Pk1 ; Q j C , then this issue does not arise at all and the estimate (4.45) is performed essentially as in Lemma 4.13 – the only difference being that the caps in the wave-packet decomposition are grouped together inside the larger Cm0 – caps.
4.4 Null-form bounds in the high-high case
4.4
101
Null-form bounds in the high-high case
Henceforth, k kS Œk will mean the stronger norm jjj jjjS Œk . The following definition introduces the basic null-forms as well as the method of “pulling out a derivative”. Definition 4.16. The null-forms Q˛ˇ for 0 ˛; ˇ 2, ˛ ¤ ˇ, are defined as Q˛ˇ .; / WD R˛ Rˇ
Rˇ R˛
whereas Q0 .; / WD R˛ R˛ : By “pulling out a derivative from” from Q˛ˇ we mean writing Q˛ˇ .; / D @˛ .jrj
1
Rˇ /
or the analogous expression with and
@ˇ .jrj
1
R˛ /
interchanged.
Recall the L2 -bound (4.13) of Lemma 4.5 for Q˛ˇ -null-forms. We separate the null-form bounds according to high-high vs. high-low and low-high interactions. The high-high case is slightly more involved due to the possibility of opposing .CC/ or . / waves with comparable frequencies and very small modulations which produce a wave of small frequency but very large modulation. Lemma 4.17. For any ` k CO.1/, and j adapted to kj with k1 D k2 CO.1/, ` k
k
kPk Q` Q˛ˇ .1 ; 2 /kL2 L2x . 2 4C 2 2 2
k k1 2
t
k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2 :
(4.50)
In particular, k1 2
kPk QkCC Q˛ˇ .1 ; 2 /kL2 L2x . 2k t
Finally, for any m0
k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2 :
(4.51)
10,
X 1
Pk QkCC Q˛ˇ .Pk ; 1 ; 2 / 2 2 2 2 1 L L t
x
2Cm0
. jm0 j 2
k1 2
k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2 : (4.52)
102
4 Bilinear estimates involving S and N spaces
Proof. We can take k1 D k2 C O.1/ D 0. First, by (4.13), kPk Q` Q˛ˇ .QkC`
C 1 ; QkC` C 2 /kL2t L2x
.2
`Ck 4
Second, by an angular decomposition into caps of size 2 X kPk Q` Q˛ˇ .Qm 1 ; Qm 2 /kL2 L2x
k
2 2 k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2 :
`Ck 2
,
t
`Ck C m`
X
.
2
`Ck 2
2
` k 4
2k kQm 1 kL2 L2x kQm 2 kL1 L2x t
(4.53)
t
`Ck C m`
.2
`C3k 4
k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2 :
To pass to (4.53) one uses the improved Bernstein inequality, which yields a factor `Ck ` k of 2k 2 4 , whereas the 2 2 corresponds to the angular gain from the null-form (note that the error coming from the modulation is at most 2m 2` which is less than this gain). And third, by the improved Bernstein inequality and a decompomCk sition into caps of size 2 2 , X kPk Q` Q˛ˇ .Qm 1 ; Qm 2 /kL2 L2x t
`mC
X
.
2
` k 4
2k 2
mCk 2
2k 2
mCk 2
C 2m kQm 1 kL2 L2x kQm 2 kL1 L2x t
t
`mC
X
.
2
` k 4
C 2m 2
m 2
k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2
`mC ` k
. 2 4C 2k k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2 : mCk
The factor 2 2 C 2m here is made up out of the angular gain 2 of 2m in modulation (in case ˇ D 0). And finally, due to " < 21 ,
mCk 2
and the loss
`
kPk Q` Q˛ˇ .QC 1 ; 2 /kL2 L2x . 2k 2 2 kQ˛ˇ .QC 1 ; 2 /kL1 L1x t t X k 2` m . 2 2 2 kQm 1 k 2 2 kQQ m 2 k L t Lx
L2t L2x
mC `
. 2k 2 2
X
2m 2
2m.1 "/
k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2
mC
.2 as desired.
` k 4
2k k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2
103
4.4 Null-form bounds in the high-high case
Next, we consider (4.52). Here one essentially repeats the proof of (4.51) verbatim. The only difference being that instead of Lemma 4.5 one uses Corollary 4.6, in fact the null-form version of (4.24). Note that this loses a factor of jm0 j. To sum over the caps one also needs to invoke Lemma 2.18 in case 2 of a L1 t Lx -norm, which incurs the same loss. We shall also require the following technical variant of the estimate of Lemma 4.17. It obtains an improvement for the case of angular alignment in the Fourier supports of the inputs. Lemma 4.18. Let ı > 0 be small and L > 1 be large. Then there exists m0 D m0 .ı; L/ < 0 large and negative such that for any j adapted to kj for j D 1; 2, X
kPk QkCC Q˛ˇ .Pk1 ;1 1 ; Pk2 ;2 2 /kL2 L2x t
1 ;2 2Cm0 dist.1 ;2 /2m0
ı2
k1 2
k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2 ; (4.54)
provided maxj D1;2 jk kj j L. The constant C is an absolute constant which does not depend on L or ı. Proof. Set k D 0. We first note that summing (4.50) over ` B already yields an improvement over (4.51) provided B is large enough (in relation to ı and L). Hence it suffices to consider the contribution of P0 Q` Q˛ˇ .Pk1 ;1 1 ; Pk2 ;2 2 / with B ` O.1/ fixed. First, if we choose m0 to be a sufficiently large negative integer, then X P0 Q` Q˛ˇ .Q` C Pk1 ;1 1 ; Q` C Pk2 ;2 2 / D 0 1 ;2 2Cm0 dist.1 ;2 /2m0 `
by Lemma 4.1. Second, by an angular decomposition into caps of size 2 2 , X X
P0 Q` Q˛ˇ .Qm Pk ; 1 ; Qm Pk ; 2 / 2 2 1 1 2 2 L L t
x
1 ;2 2Cm0 ` C mC dist.1 ;2 /2m0
C.L; ı/
X
X
1 kQm Pk1 ;1 1 kL2 L2x kQm Pk2 ;2 2 kL1 t Lx t
1 ;2 2Cm0 ` C mC dist.1 ;2 /2m0
C.L; ı/ jm0 j 2
m0 2
k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2 ı k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2 :
104
4 Bilinear estimates involving S and N spaces
To pass to the last line we applied Cauchy–Schwarz to the sum over the caps as well as Lemma 2.18. The case dealing with Qm Pk1 ;1 1 and Qm Pk2 ;2 2 is analogous. And finally, due to " < 21 , X kP0 Q` Q˛ˇ .QC Pk1 ;1 1 ; Pk2 ;2 2 /kL2 L2x t
1 ;2 2Cm0 dist.1 ;2 /2m0
X
.
kP0 Q` Q˛ˇ .QC Pk1 ;1 1 ; Pk2 ;2 2 /kL1 L2x t
1 ;2 2Cm0 dist.1 ;2 /2m0
C.L; ı/
X mC
C.L; ı/2
m0 2
X
2m
kQm Pk1 ;1 1 kL2 L2x kQQ m Pk2 ;2 2 kL2 L1 x t
t
1 ;2 2Cm0 dist.1 ;2 /2m0
X
2m 2
2m.1 "/
k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2 ık1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2
mC
as desired.
In case the output has “elliptic” rather than hyperbolic character, there is the following bound. Lemma 4.19. For any j adapted to kj with k1 D k2 C O.1/, X
k 2 "` Pk Q` Q˛ˇ .1 ; 2 /kL2 L2x . 2 2 2 "k1 hk1 ki2 1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2 : t
`kCC
Furthermore, X kPk Q` Q˛ˇ .Qk1 CC 1 ; Qk2 CC 2 /kL2 L2x t
`kCC k
. 2 2 hk1
ki2 k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2 : (4.55)
Proof. We set k1 D k2 C O.1/ D 0. One has the decomposition kPk Q` Q˛ˇ .1 ; 2 /kL2 L2x t
. kPk Q` Q˛ˇ .Q`
C 1 ; Qk1 CC 2 /kL2t L2x
(4.56)
C kPk Q` Q˛ˇ .Q`
C 1 ; Q>k1 CC 2 /kL2t L2x
(4.57)
C kPk Q` Q˛ˇ .Q<`
C 1 ; Q` C 2 /kL2t L2x
(4.58)
C kPk Q` Q˛ˇ .Q<`
C 1 ; Q<` C 2 /kL2t L2x :
(4.59)
105
4.4 Null-form bounds in the high-high case
We begin with the estimate X 2 "` kPk Q` Q˛ˇ .1 ; 2 /kL2 L2x . 2k k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2 t
`kCC `¤k1 CO.1/
which is stronger than what we claim – this is due to the fact that the the case of opposing .CC/ and . / waves is excluded in this sum. We first consider the case ` k1 C 0 where C 0 is large but still smaller than the constant C in (4.56)–(4.59). Then the term in (4.59) vanishes. On the one hand,
(4.56) . 2k Pk Q` Œ@ˇ .Q` C jrj 1 1 Qk2 CC @˛ jrj 1 2 /
@˛ .Q` C jrj 1 1 Qk CC @ˇ jrj 1 2 / 2 1 L t Lx
2
.2
kC`
kQ`
C 1 kL2t L2x k2 kS Œk2 :
Here we used that kQk2 CC @ˇ jrj
1
2 kL1 L2x . k2 kS Œk2 : t
Furthermore, X
X
2.1
"/` k k1
2
kQm 1 kL2 L2x k2 kS Œk2 t
kCC `k1 C m` C
. 2k k1 kXP 0;1
";2
k1
k2 kS Œk2
. 2k k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2 as desired. The term (4.58) satisfies the same bound, more precisely, it can be reduced to (4.56), (4.57). Next, note that due to ` k1 C 0 it suffices to consider 1 D Qk1 CC 1 in (4.57). Consequently, X 2 "` (4.57) kCC `k1 C
.
X
2
"`
X X kCC `k1 C
x
mk1 CC
2
"`
X
` 2k 2 2 Q˛ˇ .Qm 1 ; QQ m 2 / L1 L1 t
kCC `k1 C
.
Pk Q` Q˛ˇ .Qm 1 ; QQ m 2 / 2 2 L L t
kCC `k1 C
.
X
x
mk1 CC
2
"`
X mk1 CC
. 2k k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2
`
2k 2 2 2m 2
2m.1 "/
k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2
106
4 Bilinear estimates involving S and N spaces
where we used that " < Then X
1 4
in the final step. Second, suppose that ` k1 C C 0 .
"`
Pk Q` Q˛ˇ .1 ; 2 / L2 L2
2
t
`k1 CC 0
X
.
`k1
2
x
"`
Pk Q` Q˛ˇ .QQ ` 1 ; Q`
CC 0
X
C
`k1
`k1
"`
2
"`
Pk Q` Q˛ˇ .Q`
CC 0
Q
(4.60)
5 1 ; Q` 2 / L2 L2x t
(4.61)
X
Pk Q` Q˛ˇ .Qm 1 ; QQ m 2 /
(4.62)
CC 0
X
C
2
5 2 / L2 L2x t
L2t L2x
m` 5
which are in turn estimated as follows: X
(4.60) .
2
"` k
2
"` k `
2
Pk Q` Q˛ˇ .QQ ` 1 ; Q`
`k1 CC 0
X
.
`k1
5 2 / L2 L1x t
2 2 kQQ ` 1 kL2 L2x k2 kL1 L2x t
t
CC 0
. 2k k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2 and similarly for (4.61), whereas (4.62) is bounded by X
.
2
"`
X `k1
CC 0
` 2 2 2k Q˛ˇ .Qm 1 ; QQ m 2 / L1 L1 t
`k1 CC 0
.
X
x
m` 5
2
"`
X
`
2 2 2k 2m 2
2m.1 "/
k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2
m` 5
k
. 2 k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2 as desired. It remains to consider the case j` k1 j D j`j C 0 , which gives us the weaker bound stated in the lemma. We use the decomposition (4.56)–(4.59). The terms (4.56)–(4.58) give a bound of 2k as before. The main difference lies with (4.59) which is nonzero only due to the contribution to opposing .CC/ or . / waves,
107
4.4 Null-form bounds in the high-high case
see Lemma 4.1. In fact, one has with ` D k1 C O.1/ D O.1/,
Pk QO.1/ Q˛ˇ .Q< C 1 ; Q< C 2 / 2 2 L t Lx X X
Pk QO.1/ Q˛ˇ .Q< C P 1˙ ; Q< C P 2˙ / L2 L2 . t
x
˙ 2Ck
.
k
X X
2 2 kQ<
˙ ˙ C P 1 kS Œk1 ; kQ< C P 2 kS Œk2 ;
(4.63)
˙ 2Ck
.2
k 2
X X ˙
kQ< C P 1˙ k2S Œk1 ;
12 X
2Ck
kQ<
CP
˙ 2 2 kS Œk2 ;
21
2Ck
k
. 2 2 k 2 k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2 : To pass to the last line, we wrote X kQ< C P 1˙ k2S Œk1 ; 2Ck
.
X
kQ<2k P 1˙ k2S Œk1 ; C
2Ck
2Ck
.
k1˙ k2S Œk1
X
C jkj
X
X
X
. jkj
2
2kj C
kQj P 1˙ k2 0; 1 ;1 XP k
2kj C 2Ck 2
kQj P 1˙ kS Œk1 ;
(4.64)
2
1
k1˙ k2S Œk1
and the result follows. The second statement (4.55) follows by essentially the same proof.
Remark 4.20. It is important to note that the logarithmic loss of hk1 ki2 in (4.55) only results from the case of opposing waves in the high-high case. Later we will use (4.55) without this loss in those cases where these interactions are excluded. Later, we shall also require the following technical refinement of Lemma 4.19 dealing with a further angular restriction of the first input. Corollary 4.21. Under the assumptions of Lemma 4.19 and for any m0 X X 2 21 2 "` kPk Q` Q˛ˇ .Pk1 ; 1 ; 2 /kL2 L2x
10,
t
2Cm0
`kCC k
. jm0 j 2 2 2
"k1
hk1
ki2 k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2
108
4 Bilinear estimates involving S and N spaces
with an absolute implicit constant. Proof. This can be seen by reviewing the proof3 of Lemma 4.19. Specifically, up 2 until (4.63), one places Pk1 ; 1 either in the XP s;b or L1 t Lx norms. The norms are amenable to square summation, in the latter case at the expense of a factor jm0 j, see Lemma 2.18. However, as far as (4.63) is concerned, we distinguish two cases: k m0 and k > m0 . In the former case, the caps in Ck are smaller than those in Cm0 and (4.63) applies directly (one organizes the caps in Ck into subsets of the larger Cm0 -caps). In the latter case, however, the Cm0 –caps are smaller which forces us to write Q<
C 1
D Q<2m0 1 C Q2m0 <<
C 1 :
The former is subsumed in a square function bound as in (4.63), whereas the latter leads to a loss of jm0 j as in (4.64) and the corollary is proved. Next, we obtain an improvement in case of angular alignment of the inputs. This is analogous the case of low modulations, see Lemma 4.18. Lemma 4.22. Let ı > 0 be small and L > 1 be large. Then there exists m0 D m0 .ı; L/ < 0 large and negative such that for any j adapted to kj for j D 1; 2, X
X
2
1 ;2 2Cm0 `kCC dist.1 ;2 /2m0
"`
kPk Q` Q˛ˇ .Pk1 ;1 1 ; Pk2 ;2 2 /kL2 L2x t
1
ı 2. 2
"/k1
k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2 ; (4.65)
provided maxj D1;2 jk kj j L. The constant C in (4.65) is an absolute constant which does not depend on L or ı. Proof. The proof consists of checking that one can glean a gain from angular alignment by following the proof of Lemma 4.19. In effect, this will always be done by means of Bernstein’s inequality. The only case where this is not possible is (4.63), but that case is excluded by the angular alignment assumption. We set k1 D 0 whence jkj L and jk2 j 2L. Implicit constants here will be allowed to depend on L, but not the constants C appearing in modulation cutoffs.
3
It is important P to observe that one cannot square sum the bound of Lemma 4.19 directly due to the fact that 2Cm kPk1 ; 1 k2S Œk cannot be controlled. 0
109
4.4 Null-form bounds in the high-high case
As before, one has the decomposition kPk Q` Q˛ˇ .Pk1 ;1 1 ; Pk2 ;2 2 /kL2 L2x
(4.66)
. kPk Q` Q˛ˇ .Q`
(4.67)
t
C Pk1 ;1 1 ; Qk1 CC Pk2 ;2 2 /kL2t L2x
C kPk Q` Q˛ˇ .Q`
C Pk1 ;1 1 ; Q>k1 CC Pk2 ;2 2 /kL2t L2x
(4.68)
C kPk Q` Q˛ˇ .Q<`
C Pk1 ;1 1 ; Q` C Pk2 ;2 2 /kL2t L2x
(4.69)
C kPk Q` Q˛ˇ .Q<`
C Pk1 ;1 1 ; Q<` C Pk2 ;2 2 /kL2t L2x :
(4.70)
We first consider the case ` k1 C 0 where C 0 is large but still smaller than the constant C in (4.67)–(4.70). Then the term in (4.70) vanishes by Lemma 4.1. By Bernstein’s inequality, X 2 "` (4.67) kCC `k1 C
X
.
Pk Q` Œ@ˇ
kCC `k1 C
.Q`
C jrj
1
Pk1 ;1 1 Qk2 CC @˛ jrj
1
Pk2 ;2 2 /
1
@˛ .Q` C jrj Pk1 ;1 1 Qk2 CC @ˇ jrj 1 Pk2 ;2 2 / L2 L2 t x X 1 kQ` C Pk1 ;1 1 kL2 L2x kPk2 ;2 2 kL1 t Lx
.
t
kCC `k1 C
.2
m0 2
X
kQ`
2 C Pk1 ;1 1 kL2t L2x kPk2 ;2 2 kL1 t Lx
kCC `k1 C
ıkPk1 ;1 1 k
1 ;1 0; 2
XP 0
kPk2 ;2 2 kL1 L2x : t
Summing over 1 ; 2 now yields the desired bound by the Cauchy–Schwarz inequality (see also Lemma 2.18). The term (4.69) satisfies the same bound. Next, note that due to ` k1 C 0 it suffices to consider 1 D Qk1 CC 1 in (4.68). Consequently, X 2 "` (4.68) kCC `k1 C
.
X
X
Pk Q` Q˛ˇ .Qm Pk
1 ;1
1 ; QQ m Pk2 ;2 2 / L2 L2 t
kCC `k1 C mk1 CC
.
X
X
Q˛ˇ .Qm Pk
kCC `k1 C mk1 CC
1 ;1
1 ; QQ m Pk2 ;2 2 / L1 L2 t
x
x
110
4 Bilinear estimates involving S and N spaces
X
.
X
2m 2
2m.1 "/
kPk1 ;1 Qm 1 kL2 L2x kPk2 ;2 QQ m 2 kL2 L1 x t
t
kCC `k1 C mk1 CC
. ıkPk1 ;1 1 kXP 0;1
";2
0
kPk2 ;2 2 kXP 0;1
";2
:
0
Summing over 1 ; 2 again leads to the desired bound. Second, suppose that ` k1 C C 0 . Then X
2 "` Pk Q` Q˛ˇ .Pk1 ;1 1 ; Pk2 ;2 2 / L2 L2 X
.
2
`k1
CC 0
C
X `k1
"`
Pk Q` Q˛ˇ .QQ ` Pk1 ;1 1 ; Q`
2
"`
2
"`
Pk Q` Q˛ˇ .Q`
CC 0
X
C
x
t
`k1 CC 0
`k1 CC 0
5 Pk2 ;2 2 / L2 L2x t
Q
(4.71)
5 Pk1 ;1 1 ; Q` Pk2 ;2 2 / L2 L2x t
X
Pk Q` Q˛ˇ .Qm Pk
1 ;1
(4.72)
1 ; QQ m Pk2 ;2 2 / L2 L2 t
x
m` 5
(4.73) which are in turn estimated as follows: X (4.71) 1 ;2 2Cm0 dist.1 ;2 /2m0
.
X
X
2
"`
Pk Q` Q˛ˇ .QQ ` Pk1 ;1 1 ; Q`
1 ;2 2Cm0 `k1 CC 0 dist.1 ;2 /2m0
.
X
X
2.1
"/`
5 Pk2 ;2 2 / L2 L2x t
kQQ ` Pk1 ;1 1 kL2 L2x kPk2 ;2 2 kL1 L2x t
t
1 ;2 2Cm0 `k1 CC 0 dist.1 ;2 /2m0
ık1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2 and similarly for (4.72), whereas X
(4.73)
1 ;2 2Cm0 dist.1 ;2 /2m0
.
X
X
1 ;2 2Cm0 `k1 CC 0 dist.1 ;2 /2m0
2
"`
X
` 2 2 Q˛ˇ .Qm Pk1 ;1 1 ; QQ m Pk2 ;2 2 / L1 L2 t
m` 5
x
111
4.5 Null-form bounds in the low-high and high-low cases
.2
m0 2
X
1
X
2. 2
"/` m
2 2
1 ;2 2Cm0 mC5`k1 CC 0 dist.1 ;2 /2m0
2m.1 "/
kPk1 ;1 1 kS Œk1 kPk2 ;2 2 kS Œk2
ık1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2 as desired. It the remaining case j` k1 j D j`j C 0 we use the decomposition (4.67)– (4.70). The terms (4.67)–(4.69) give a bound of ı as before. The main difference lies with (4.70) which is nonzero only due to the contribution to opposing .CC/ or . / waves, see Lemma 4.1. However, this case is excluded due to the angular alignment assumption.
4.5
Null-form bounds in the low-high and high-low cases
We now derive analogues of the previous two lemmas in the high-low case, with the low-high case being completely analogous. Lemma 4.23. For any j adapted to kj with k2 k1 C O.1/ D k one has
Pk QkCC Q˛ˇ .1 ; 2 / 2 2 . 2. 12 L L t
"/k2 "k1
x
2
k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2 :
Proof. We may take k D k1 C O.1/ D 0 and k2 C . Assume first that Q
P0 Qj .R˛ Q<j
j k2 CO.1/
C
X
C 1 Rˇ Q<j C 2
Rˇ Q<j
C 1 R˛ Q<j C 2 / L2 L2x t
P0 Q<j CC .R˛ Qj 1 Rˇ Qj 2
(4.74)
Rˇ Qj 1 R˛ Qj 2 / L2 L2
P0 Q<j CC .R˛ Q<j 1 Rˇ Qj 2
(4.75)
Rˇ Q<j 1 R˛ Qj 2 / L2 L2
t
x
j k2 CO.1/
C
X
t
x
j k2 CO.1/
(4.76) Each of the summands here is bounded by 2.j Ck2 /=4 . For the first, one decom-
112
4 Bilinear estimates involving S and N spaces j
poses into caps of size 2 X (4.74) .
k2 2
: X
P0 Qj .R˛ Q<j
j k2 CO.1/ 0 2C j
Rˇ Q<j X j 2
.
C P 1 Rˇ Q<j C P 0 2
k2 2
C P 1 R˛ Q<j C P 0 2 / L2 L2x t k2 4
2
k2 2
kQ<j
C P 1 kS Œk1 ; kQ<j C P 0 2 kS Œk2 ; 0
j k2 CO.1/
.2
k2 2
k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2
where we applied (2.29) in the last step. Note that the null-form gains a factor of the angle in this bound. As for (4.75), one performs a similar cap decomposition but without the separation between the caps: X X
P0 Q<j CC .R˛ Qj P 1 Rˇ Qj P 0 2 (4.75) . j k2 CO.1/ ; 0 2C j
.
k2 2
Rˇ Qj P 1 R˛ Qj P 0 2 / L2 L2 t x X j k2 1 2 2 kQj P 1 kL2 L2x kQj P 0 2 kL1 t Lx t
j k2 CO.1/
.
X
j
2
k2 2
j 2
2
j
2
k2 4
2k2 kQj P 1 kS Œk1 ; kP 0 2 kL1 L2x t
j k2 CO.1/
.
X
2
j Ck2 4
k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2 . 2
k2 2
k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2
j k2 CO.1/
Finally, (4.76) .
X
X
j k2 CO.1/ ; 0 2C j
.
kP0 Q<j CC .R˛ Q<j P 1 Rˇ Qj P 0 2 k2 2
Rˇ Q<j P 1 R˛ Qj P 0 2 /kL2 L2x t X j k2 2 2 kQ<j P 1 kL1 L2x kQj P 0 2 kL2 L1 x t
t
j k2 CO.1/
.
X
j
2
k2 2
j
2
k2 4
2k2 kQ<j P 1 kS Œk1 ; kQj P 0 2 kL2 L2x t
j k2 CO.1/
.
X j k2 CO.1/
2
j Ck2 4
k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2 . 2
k2 2
k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2
113
4.5 Null-form bounds in the low-high and high-low cases
If Qk2 C 2 D 2 , then we may take 1 D QC 1 , whence
P0 QO.1/ Q˛ˇ .1 ; 2 /
. k1 kL1 L2x kR0 2 kL2 L1 t t x X . k1 kL1 L2x 2j kQj 2 kL2 L2x
L2t L2x
t
t
k2 j C 1
. 2. 2
"/k2
k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2 :
On the other hand, if 2 D QC 2 , then necessarily also 1 D QC 1 so that
P0 QO.1/ Q˛ˇ .1 ; 2 / 2 2 L t Lx
. P0 QO.1/ Q˛ˇ .1 ; 2 / L1 L1 t x X m Q kQm 1 kL2 L2x 2 kQm 2 kL2 L2x . t
t
mC
. k1 kS Œk1
X
2m.1 "/ k2 . 12 "/
2m 2
2
k2 kS Œk2
mC 1
"/k2
. 2. 2
k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2
and the lemma is proved. Next, we deal with the case of outputs with large modulation. Lemma 4.24. For any j adapted to kj with k2 k1 C O.1/ D k one has X
2
1 Pk Q` Q˛ˇ .1 ; 2 / L2 L2 . 2. 2
"`
"/k2
x
t
k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2
`kCC
Proof. Set k D k1 C O.1/ D 0 and k2 X
2
"`
C . Then
P0 Q` Q˛ˇ .1 ; 2 / L2 L2 t
x
`C
.
X
2
"`
P0 Q` Q˛ˇ .QQ ` 1 ; Q<`
C 2 / L2 L2x t
(4.77)
`C
C
X `C
2
"`
P0 Q` Q˛ˇ .Q`
C 1 ; Q` C 2 / L2 L2x t
(4.78)
114
4 Bilinear estimates involving S and N spaces
First, taking ˛ D 0 and ˇ D 1, X
(4.77) . 2 "` P0 Q` .R0 QQ ` 1 R1 Q<`
C 2
`C
R1 QQ ` 1 R0 Q<` X
.
"`
2
C 2 / L2 L2x t
1 .2` kQ` 1 kL2 L2x k2 kL1 t Lx t
`C 1/ C kQQ ` 1 kL2 L2x kR0 Q<` C 2 kL1 t Lx t X 1 1 . k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2 2k2 C kQQ ` 1 kL2 L2x 2. 2 C"/` 2. 2 "/k2 k2 kS Œk2 t
`C 1
"/k2
. 2. 2
k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2 :
To pass to the second to last line we used the estimate kR0 Q<`
1 C 2 kL1 t Lx 3j
X
. 2k2 kQk2 2 kL1 L2x C
2 2 kQj 2 kL2 L2x
t
t
k2 <j <` C 3j
X
. 2k2 kQk2 2 kL1 L2x C
222
t
.1 "/j . 12 "/k2
2
k2 kS Œk2
k2 <j <` C 1
1
X
. 2k2 kQk2 2 kL1 L2x C
2. 2 C"/j 2. 2
t
"/k2
k2 kS Œk2
k2 <j <` C 1
1
. 2k2 kQk2 2 kL1 L2x C 2. 2 C"/` 2. 2 t
"/k2
k2 kS Œk2 :
On (4.78) one has the bound (again for ˛ D 0 and ˇ D 1) X
(4.78) . 2 "` P0 Q` .R0 Qm 1 R1 QQ m 2 R1 Qm 1 R0 QQ m 2 / L2 L2 t
x
m`C
X
.
1
2. 2
"/` m
2 kQm 1 kL2 L2x kQQ m 2 kL2 L2x t
t
m`C
.
X
2
. 21 "/m
1
k1 kS Œk1 2. 2
"/k2
k2 kS Œk2
mC 1
. 2. 2 as claimed.
"/k2
k1 kS Œk1 k2 kS Œk2
5
Trilinear estimates
The purpose of this section is to derive the estimates on the trilinear nonlinearities which govern the wave map system. To clarify the role that these estimates play, we include here a table which explains how these estimates relate to the trilinear terms arising in Chapter 3. Recall that the trilinear null-forms are summarized in the expression (3.14). In the table, we number the terms in this expression 1–11. The gist of the estimates to follow is that whenever one is given a trilinear null-form of the schematic form rx;t P0
1r
1
Œ
2
3
with each i localized to spatial frequency 2ki , i D 1; 2; 3, then one gains exponentially in the difference of the largest to the smallest logarithmic frequency present, unless one is in the situation where k1 D O.1/ and k2;3 1, i.e., the high-low-low case. This latter feature forces us to modify the procedure of Bahouri–Gérard in Chapter 9, and it also informs our choice of the weight w.k1 ; k2 ; k3 / below. In addition to the bilinear estimates of the previous sections, we will also heavily use the Strichartz component of the S Œk-norm, see (2.14). As already
Table 5.1. Relation of trilinear estimates to null-forms Estimate
Trilinear expression
Lemma 5.1 Corollary 5.2 Lemma 5.3 Corollary 5.4 Lemma 5.5 Remark 5.6 Lemma 5.7 Lemma 5.9 Corollary 5.10 Lemma 5.11
1, 2 3, 7 4–6, 8–11 1, 3, 7 2, 5, 6, 8–11 2 4, 9 1, 3, 7 2, 5, 6, 8–11 2, 5, 6, 8–11
116
5 Trilinear estimates
in [23], we will partially rely on Tao’s trilinear estimate from [59] which states that (relative to our norms in the S Œk-spaces)
P0 Œ
ˇ 1R
2 Rˇ
1 .k2 ^k3
3 N Œ0 . 2
k1 /^0 k1
2
3 Y
k
i kS Œki
(5.1)
i D1
for some 1 > 0. To obtain (5.1) from [59], one observes that kr kS Œk (strictly) dominates the S Œk-norms of [59], whereas kP0 kN Œ0 is dominated by the respective N Œ0-norm used in [59]. Because of this property, the trilinear bound from [59] can be adapted to this setting provided the correct scaling is taken into account. Moreover, throughout this section we define, with kmax WD k1 _ k2 _ k3 , kmin WD k1 ^ k2 ^ k3 , and kmed the median of k1 ; k2 ; k3 , 8 < 2 0 kmax 20 kmin ^0 if kmax C w.k1 ; k2 ; k3 / WD 2 0 .kmed kmin / if k1 D kmax D O.1/ : 0 .k1 Ck2 ^k3 / 2 if k1 < kmax D O.1/ where 0 > 0 is some fixed small constant. We split our argument into two cases, depending on whether all inputs are “hyperbolic” or not. This distinction is based on modulation vs. frequency.
5.1
Reduction to the hyperbolic case
The following lemma deals with the case where at least one ofPthe inputs or the interior null-form have “elliptic” character. Recall that I WD k2Z Pk QkCC and I c WD 1 I (here C is an absolute constant, C D 10 will P suffice). ThroughQ out this section, we will write Pk to denote a projection k 0 DkCO.1/ Pk 0 , and similarly with QQ k . Lemma 5.1. Let i be Schwarz functions adapted to ki for i D 0; 1; 2. Then for any ˛ D 0; 1; 2, and j D 1; 2,
P0 @ˇ A0 ŒA1 R˛
1
1
@j AQ1 Qˇj .A2
2 ; A3
3 / N Œ0
. w.k1 ; k2 ; k3 /
3 Y
k
i kS Œki
iD1
where Ai and AQ1 are either I or I c , with at least one being I c . Moreover, we impose the condition that A1 D AQ1 D I c implies ˛ ¤ 0.
117
5.1 Reduction to the hyperbolic case
Proof. Case 1: 0 k1 k2 C O.1/ D k3 C O.1/. We begin with A0 D I c and A1 D I . Then we can drop IR˛ from 1 and estimate1
P0 Q0 @ˇ Œ 1 1 @j Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / N Œ0
ˇ 1 . P0 Q0 @ Œ 1 @j Qk1 CC Qˇj .
C P0 Q0 @ˇ Œ 1 1 @j Qk1 CC Qˇj . By Lemma 4.17, placing (5.2) into XP 00;
1
1
1 ";2
@j Qk1 CC Qˇj .
.k .2
k2 2
1 kL1 L2x 2 t
k2 2
k
3 / N Œ0
(5.2) (5.3)
implies
2;
k
2 ; 3 / N Œ0 : 2;
3 / L2 L1 t x
2 kS Œk2 k 3 kS Œk3
1 kS Œk1 k 2 kS Œk2 k 3 kS Œk3
whereas X
(5.3) .
P0 Qm @ˇ ŒQm
C
1
1
@j QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / N Œ0
(5.4)
mk1 CC
X
C
P0 Q0 @ˇ ŒQm
1
C
1
@j Qm Qˇj .
2;
3 / N Œ0 :
mk1 CC
(5.5) Lemma 4.19 yields the following bound on (5.4): X
P0 Qm @ˇ ŒQm
1
C
1
@j QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / N Œ0
mk1 CC
X
.
P0 Qm @ˇ ŒQm
1
C
1
@j QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / XP 0; 0
mk1 CC
X
.
2
m"
k
1 kL1 L2x 2 t
k1
kPQk1 QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 /kL2 L2x t
mk1 CC
.2
"k2
2
k1 2
hk2
k1 i
2
3 Y
k
i kS Œki :
i D1
1
It is convenient to prove the somewhat stronger bound with A0 D Q0 here.
1 ";2
118
5 Trilinear estimates
The bound on (5.5) proceeds similarly: X
P0 Q0 @ˇ ŒQ>m C 1 (5.5) .
1
@j QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / N Œ0
mk1 CC
.
X
X
P0 Q` @ˇ ŒQ>m
1
C
1
@j QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / N Œ0
mk1 CC 0`mCC
X
C
X
P0 Q` @ˇ ŒQQ `
1
1
@j QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / N Œ0
mk1 CC `mCC
.
X
1
X
"/`
2. 2
Q>m
1 L2 L2 t x
C
mk1 CC 0`mCC 1
PQk 1
@j QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
X
C
mk1 CC
X
"`
2
QQ `
PQk 1 L2 L2
1
1
x
t
@j QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / L1 L2 : x t
`mCC
In the second to last line we applied Bernstein’s inequality in the time variable to switch from L2t to L1t . We now replace the L1 t on the right-hand side of the last m line by an L2t at the expense of a factor of 2 2 . Together with Lemma 4.19 this yields X X 1 (5.5) . 2 k1 C. 2 "/` kQ>m C 1 kL2 L2x t
mk1 CC 0`mCC
PQk QQ m Qˇj . 1
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
X
C
X
2
k1 "`
m
22
mk1 CC `mCC
kQQ ` X
.
Q Q 1 kL2 L2x Pk1 Qm Qˇj . t
2
. 21 C"/k1
1 2m
2
k
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
1 kS Œk1
PQk QQ m Qˇj . 1
m
.1 "/` . 12 "/k1
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
mk1 CC
X
C
X
2
k1 "`
222
2
k
1 kS Œk1
mk1 CC `mCC
PQk QQ m Qˇj . 1 .2
k1 2
2
"k2
hk2
2;
k1 i
3 / L2 L2 t x 2
3 Y
k
i kS Œki :
i D1
Next, we consider the case where both A0 D I c and A1 D I c . If ˛ ¤ 0, then one can drop R˛ altogether so that the previous analysis applies. Otherwise, if ˛ D 0,
119
5.1 Reduction to the hyperbolic case
then by assumption AQ1 D I and
P0 Q0 @ˇ ŒQk CC R˛ 1 1 @j PQk Qk CC Qˇj .A2 2 ; A3 3 / 1 1 1 N Œ0 X
ˇ Q 1
Q P0 Qm @ ŒQm R˛ 1 @j Pk1 Qk1 CC Qˇj .A2 2 ; A3 3 / N Œ0 mk1 C10C
(5.6)
C P0 Q0k
1 C10C
ŒQ0k1 C10C R˛
@
ˇ 1
1
@j PQk1 Qk1 CC Qˇj .A2
2 ; A3
3 / N Œ0 :
(5.7)
By Lemma 4.17, (5.7) is bounded by
P0 Q0k C10C @ˇ ŒQ0k C10C R˛ 1 1
1
1
@j PQk1
Qk1 CC Qˇj .A2
. Q0k
1 C10C
R˛
. kQ0k1 C10C R˛ .2
k2 2
3 Y
k
2 ; A3
3 / XP 0; 0
1
@j PQk1 Qk1 CC Qˇj .A2 2 ; A3
1
Q 1 kL1 L2x @j Pk1 Qk1 CC Qˇj .A2 1
t
1 ";2
3 / L2 L1 t
2 ; A3
x
3 / L2 L2 t x
i kS Œki :
i D1
On the other hand, (5.6) is estimated as follows: X
kP0 Qm @ˇ ŒQQ m R˛
1
1
@j PQk1
mk1 C10C
.
X
2
m"
kQQ m R˛
Qk1 CC Qˇj .A2 2 ; A3 3 /kXP 0; 1 ";2 0
1
Q 1 kL2 L2x @j Pk1 Qk1 CC Qˇj .A2 2 ; A3 3 / L1 L2 t
t
x
mk1
.2 .2
. 12 C"/k1
"k1
k2 2
k
1 kS Œk1 2
3 Y
k
k1 2
kPQk1 Qk1 CC Qˇj .A2
2 ; A3
3 /kL2 L2x t
i kS Œki
i D1
where we applied Bernstein’s inequality relative to t as well as Lemma 4.17 to pass to the last line. Now suppose A0 D I (in fact, A0 D Q0 ), but at least one of A1 or AQ1 equals I c . But then the modulations of 1 and Qˇj essentially agree, whence
120
5 Trilinear estimates
˛ ¤ 0 and X
P0 Q0 @ˇ ŒQm R˛
1
1
@j QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / N Œ0
mk1 CC
X
.
P0 Q0 @ˇ ŒQm R˛
1
1
@j QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / L1 tx
mk1 CC
X
.
kQm
k1
1 kL2 L2x 2 t
PQk1 QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
mk1 CC
X
.
1
2. 2
"/k1
2
m.1 2"/
k
1 kS Œk1 2
k1
2
m"
kPQk1 QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 /kL2 L2x t
mk1 CC
.2
k1 2
"k2
k1 i2
hk2
3 Y
k
i kS Œki :
i D1
The final estimate here uses Lemma 4.24. The last case which we need to consider is A0 D A1 D AQ1 D I and either one of A2 ; A3 equal to I c . But then necessarily A2 D A3 D I c , whence
P0 @ˇ I ŒIR˛ 1 1 @j I Qˇj .Qk CC 2 ; Qk CC 3 / 2 2 N Œ0
1
. IR˛ 1 @j I Qˇj .Qk2 CC 2 ; Qk2 CC 3 / L1 L1 t x X
PQk Qk CC Qˇj .Qm 2 ; QQ m 3 / 1 1 . k 1 kL1 L2x 1 1 L L t
t
x
mk2 CC
.k
1 kL1 L2x
X
t
2m
k2
2
2m.1 "/ .1 2"/k2
2
k
2 kS Œk2 k 3 kS Œk3
mk2 CC
.2
k2
3 Y
k
i kS Œki
i D1
which concludes Case 1. Case 2: 0 k1 D k2 C O.1/; k3 k2 C. We again begin with A0 D I c , A1 D I and the representation (5.2) and (5.3) (dropping IR˛ from 1 as before). By Lemma 4.23, (5.2) is bounded by
1
1
@j Qk1 CC Qˇj . .k
2;
3 / L2 L1 t x
1 kL1 L2x 2 t
. 21 "/k3
2
.1 "/k1
k
2 kS Œk2 k 3 kS Œk3 ;
121
5.1 Reduction to the hyperbolic case
whereas X
(5.3) .
P0 Qm @ˇ ŒQm
1
1
C
@j QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / N Œ0
(5.8)
mk1 CC
X
C
P0 Q0 @ˇ ŒQm
1
1
C
@j Qm Qˇj .
2;
3 / N Œ0 :
mk1 CC
(5.9) Lemma 4.24 yields the following bound on (5.8): X
P0 Qm @ˇ ŒQm
1
1
C
@j QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / N Œ0
k1 CC m
X
.
P0 Qm @ˇ ŒQm
1
1
C
@j QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / XP 0; 0
1 ";2
k1 CC m
X
.
2
m"
2
k1
k
k1
1 kL1 L2x 2 t
PQk1 QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
k1 CC m 1
. 2. 2
"/k3
3 Y
k kS Œki :
i D1
The bound on (5.9) proceeds similarly: X
(5.9) .
P0 Q0 @ˇ ŒQ>m
1
1
C
@j QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / N Œ0
mk1 CC
X
.
X
P0 Q` @ˇ ŒQ>m
C
1
1
@j
mk1 CC 0`mCC
C
QQ m Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / XP 0; 1 ";2 0 X X
P0 Q` @ˇ ŒQQ ` 1
1
@j QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / XP 0; 0
1 ";2
mk1 CC `mCC
X
.
1
X
2. 2
"/`
kQ>m
C
Q
1 kL2 L2x kPk1 t
1
@j
mk1 CC 0`mCC
C
QQ m Qˇj . 2 ; X X 2
3 /kL2 L2x
(5.10)
t
"`
kQQ `
Q 1 kL2 L2x Pk1 t
1
@j
mk1 CC `mCC
QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / L1 L2 : x t
(5.11)
122
5 Trilinear estimates
To pass to (5.10) we used Bernstein’s inequality to switch from L2t to L1t , which ` 2 costs 2 2 . We now replace the L1 t on the right-hand side of the last line by an L t m at the expense of a factor of 2 2 . In view of Lemma 4.24 one concludes that
X
(5.9) .
X
k1 C. 12 "/`
2
kQ>m
C
1 kL2 L2x t
mk1 CC 0`mCC
PQk QQ m Qˇj . 1
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
X
C
X
2
k1 "`
m
22
mk1 CC `mCC
Q Q 1 kL2 L2x Pk1 Qm Qˇj .
kQQ ` X
.
t
. 12 C"/k1
2
1 2m
2
k
1 kS Œk1
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
PQk QQ m Qˇj . 1
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
mk1 CC
C
X
X
k1 "`
2
m
222
.1 "/` . 12 "/k1
2
k
1 kS Œk1
mk1 CC `mCC
kPQk1 QQ m Qˇj . .2
3 Y
k1 . 12 "/k3
2
2;
k
3 /kL2 L2x t
i kS Œki :
i D1
Next, we consider the case where both A0 D I c and A1 D I c . If ˛ ¤ 0, then one can drop R˛ altogether so that the previous analysis applies. Otherwise, if ˛ D 0, then by assumption AQ1 D I and as in Case 1 one obtains (5.6) and (5.7). By Lemma 4.23, (5.7) is bounded by
P0 Q0k C10C @ˇ ŒQ0k C10C R˛ 1 1
1
1
@j PQk1 Qk1 CC Qˇj .A2
. kQ0k1 C10C R˛ . 12
.2 .2
k1 2
"/k1
1
2. 2
1
1
@j PQk1 Qk1 CC Qˇj .A2
kQ0k1 C10C R˛ "/k3
3 Y i D1
1 kL2 L2x t
1
2 ; A3
i kS Œki :
3 / XP 0; 0
3 /kL2 L1x t
@j PQk1 Qk1 CC Qˇj .A2
k
2 ; A3
2 ; A3
3 / L2 L2 t x
1 ";2
123
5.1 Reduction to the hyperbolic case
On the other hand, (5.6) is estimated as follows: X
P0 Qm @ˇ ŒQQ m R˛ 1 1 @j PQk Qk 1
1 CC
mk1 C10C
X
.
2 m" QQ m r t;x jrj
1
Qˇj .A2 2 ; A3 3 / XP 0; 0
k1 Q 2 P Q 2 k k CC
1
L2t Lx
1
1 ";2
1
mk1
Qˇj .A2 .2
. 21 C"/k1
.2
k1 C. 12 "/k3
k
1 kS Œk1 2 3 Y
k
k1 2
2 ; A3
3 / L1 L2 x t
PQk Qk CC Qˇj .A2 1 1
2 ; A3
3 / L2 L2 t x
i kS Œki
i D1
where we applied Bernstein’s inequality relative to t as well as Lemma 4.23. We now turn to the case where A0 D I , but at least one of A1 or AQ1 equals c I . But then the modulations of 1 and Qˇj essentially agree whence ˛ ¤ 0. Bounding N Œ0 by L1t L2x and invoking Lemma 4.24 yields X
P0 Q0 @ˇ ŒQm
1
1
@j QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / N Œ0
mk1 CC
X
.
kQm
1 kL2 L2x t
2
k1
PQk1 QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
mk1 CC 3 Y
. 23 "/k1 C. 12 "/k3
.2
k
i kS Œki
.2
k1 . 12 "/k3
2
iD1
3 Y
k
i kS Œki :
iD1
The last case which we need to consider is A0 D A1 D AQ1 D I and either one of A2 ; A3 equal to I c . We begin with A2 D I c . But then necessarily A2 D A3 D I c , whence
P0 @ˇ I ŒI
. I 1
1
1
@j I Qˇj .Qk2 CC
2 ; Qk2 CC
3 / N Œ0
1
@j I Qˇj .Qk2 CC 2 ; Qk2 CC 3 / L1 L1 t x X k1
Q . k 1 kL1 L2x 2 Pk1 Qk1 CC Qˇj .Qm 2 ; QQ m t
3 / L1 L2 t x
mk2 CC
.k
1 kL1 L2x
X
t
mk2 CC
2m
k2
2
2.1 "/m . 12 "/k2 . 12 "/k3
2
2
k
2 kS Œk2 k 3 kS Œk3
124
5 Trilinear estimates
.2
3 Y
. 32 "/k1 C. 12 "/k3
k
k1 . 12 "/k3
i kS Œki . 2
2
i D1
3 Y
k
i kS Œki :
i D1
It remains to consider the case A2 D I and A3 D I c . We begin by reducing the modulation of the entire output. Indeed, by Lemma 4.23,
P0 @ˇ Q.1 1 2 .1
.2
3"/k3 C ŒQk1 CC
3"/k3 1 2 .1
.2
k1
.2
.1 "/k1
2
k
1 kL1 L2x t
3"/k3
"
2 2 k3
k
3 Y
2
k1
@j Qk1 CC Qˇj .I
kI Qˇj .I
2; I
. 12 "/k3 "k2
1 kL1 L2x
2
t
k
1
1
2
c
k
2; I
c
3 / N Œ0
3 /kL2 L2x t
2 kS Œk2 k 3 kS Œk3
i kS Œki :
iD1
Next, we reduce the modulation of
1:
P0 @ˇ Q.1 3"/k ŒQ.1 3"/k k 3 3 1
ˇ
. P0 @ Q.1 3"/k3 ŒQ.1 3"/k3 Qˇj .I . kQ.1 .2 .2
k1 2
2
1 kL2 L2x
3"/k3 k1 1 2 .1
. 12 "/k1
t
3"/k3 "
2 2 k3
k
3 Y
2
k1 c
2; I
1
@j Qk1 CC Qˇj .I 1
1
2; I
c
3 / N Œ0
@j Qk1 CC
3 /
L1t L1x
k1
I Qˇj .I
1 kS Œk1 2
k
1
2; I
. 21 "/k3 "k2
2
k
c
3 / L2 L2 t x
2 kS Œk2 k 3 kS Œk3
i kS Œki :
i D1
Finally, we reduce the modulation of the interior null-form using Lemma 4.13:
P0 @ˇ Q.1
3"/k3 ŒQ.1 3"/k3 k1
1
1
@j Qk3 k1 CC Qˇj .I
.k
X
1 kS Œk1
` 4
2
2
k1
hk1 i Pk1 Q` Qˇj .I
2; I 2; I
c
c
2 3/
3 / N Œ0 L t L2x
k3 `k1 CC
.2
.1 2"/k1 . 41 "/k3
2
3 Y
k
i kS Œki
i D1
which is again admissible. After these preparations, we are faced with the follow-
125
5.1 Reduction to the hyperbolic case
ing decomposition: P0 @ˇ Q.1
D P0 @ˇ Q.1
Q.1 3"/k3 k1 3"/k3 Q.1 3"/k3
3"/k3
1
1
Qˇj .Qk3 k2 CC X P0; @ˇ Q.1 3"/k3 Pk1 ; 0 Q.1 D ; 0 2C`
3/
2 ; Qk3 CC k2 CC
3/
1
1
k1
c
@j Qk3 Qˇj .I
2; I
@j Qk3
1
@j Qk3 2 ; Qk3 CC k2 CC 3 /
3"/k3 k1
Qˇj .Qk3 k2 CC
1
where ` D 21 .1 3"/k3 and dist.; 0 / . 2` . Placing the entire expression in L1t L2x and using Bernstein’s inequality results in the following estimate: With J WD Qk3 k2 CC ,
P0 @ˇ Q.1
3"/k3 ŒQ.1 3"/k3 k1
1
1
@j Qk3
Qˇj .I
X
P0; ŒPk ; 0 Q.1 1
2; I 1
1
3"/k3 k1
c
@j Qk3
; 0 2C`
Qˇj .J
X `
P0; ŒPk ; 0 Q.1 22 1
3"/k3 k1
3 / L1 L2 t x
2; J
1
1
2 12
2 /
3 L
@j Qk3
; 0 2C`
Qˇj .J
X ` 22 kPk1 ; 0 Q.1 0 2C
2; J
2 1k 2
3"/k3 k1
1
Lx
`
L1t
x
2
3 / L1 x
12
L1t
@j Qk3
2 21
Qˇj .J 2 ; J 3 / L2
L1t
x
` 2
2 kQ.1 .2 .2
1 4 .1 1 4 .1
3"/k3 3"/k3
3"/k3 k1
k k
1 kS Œk1 1 kS Œk1
1 kL1 L2x t
2 2
k1 k1
1 @j Qk3 Qˇj .J 2 ; J 3 / L1 L2
kr t;x jrj 2
k3 2
k
x
t
1
J
2 kL2 L2x kr t;x jrj t
. 12 "/k3 "k2
2 kS Œk2 2
2
k
1
J
3 kL2 L1 x t
3 kS Œk3
which is again admissible for small " > 0. Case 3: 0 k1 D k3 C O.1/; k2 k3 one.
C: This case is symmetric to the previous
126
5 Trilinear estimates
Case 4: O.1/ k2 D k3 C O.1/; k1 C. This case proceeds similarly to Case 1. We again begin with A0 D I c and A1 D I . Then we can drop IR˛ from 1 and estimate
P0 Q0 @ˇ Œ 1 1 @j Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / N Œ0
ˇ 1 e 0 Q
ˇ 1 e
C P0 Q0 @ Œ 1 @j P 0 QC Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / N Œ0 e 0 D PŒ where we write P into XP 00; 1 ";2 implies
1
1
C;C
1 1 kL1 t Lx
. 2k1 2
(5.13)
for simplicity. By Lemma 4.17, placing (5.12)
e 0 Q
.k
(5.12)
k2 2
2
3 Y
k
2;
k2 2
k
3 / L2 L2 t x 2 kS Œk2 k 3 kS Œk3
i kS Œki
i D1
whereas (5.13) .
X
P0 Qm @ˇ ŒQm
1
1
C
e 0 QQ m Qˇj . @j P
2;
3 / N Œ0
(5.14)
mC
C
X
P0 Q0 @ˇ ŒQm
C
1
1
e 0 Qm Qˇj . @j P
2;
3 / N Œ0 :
mC
(5.15) Lemma 4.19 yields the following bound on (5.14): X
P0 Qm @ˇ ŒQm
1
C
1
e 0 QQ m Qˇj . @j P
2;
3 / N Œ0
mC
.
X
P0 Qm @ˇ ŒQm
C
1
1
@j QQ m Qˇj .
2;
mC
.
X
2
m"
k
e Q
1 kP 0 Qm Q 1 kL1 ˇj . 2 ; t Lx
mC k1
.2 2
"k2
hk2
2
k1 i
3 Y i D1
k
i kS Œki
3 /kL2 L2x t
3 / XP 0; 0
1 ";2
127
5.1 Reduction to the hyperbolic case
which is admissible. The bound on (5.15) proceeds similarly: X
P0 Q0 @ˇ ŒQ>m
(5.15) .
C
1
1
@j QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / N Œ0
mC
.
X
X
P0 Q` @ˇ ŒQ>m
C
1
1
X
P0 Q` @ˇ ŒQQ `
1
1
@j QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / XP 0; 0
@j QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / XP 0; 0
mC 0`mCC
C
X
mC `mCC
.
X
1
X
"/`
2. 2
kQ>m
C
1 kL2 L1 x
"`
1 kL2 L1 x
t
1 ";2
e P 0 QQ m Qˇj .
1 ";2
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
mC 0`mCC
C
X
X
2
kQQ `
t
e P 0 QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / L1 L2 : x t
mC `mCC
In the second to last line we applied Bernstein’s inequality in the time variable to switch from L2t to L1t . We now replace the L1 t on the right-hand side of the last m line by an L2t at the expense of a factor of 2 2 . Together with Lemma 4.19 this yields
(5.15) .
X
X
1
2. 2
"/` k1
2 kQ>m
1 kL2 L2x
C
t
e P 0 QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
mC 0`mCC
C
X
X
2
m 2 2 2 kQQ `
"` k1
1 kL2 L2x t
e P 0 QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
mC `mCC
. 2 k1
X
2
1 2m
k
1 kS Œk1
e P 0 QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
mC
C 2k1
X
X
2
"`
m
222
.1 "/`
mC `mCC
k .2
. 23 "/k1
2
"k2
hk2 i
2
3 Y
k
1 kS Œk1
e P 0 QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
i kS Œki
i D1
which is admissible. Next, we consider the case where both A0 D I c and A1 D I c . If ˛ ¤ 0, then one can drop R˛ altogether so that the previous analysis
128
5 Trilinear estimates
applies. Otherwise, if ˛ D 0, then by assumption AQ1 D I and
P0 Q0 @ˇ ŒQC R˛ 1 1 @j P e 0 QC Qˇj .A2 2 ; A3 3 / N Œ0 X
ˇ 1
P0 Qm @ ŒQQ m R˛ 1 @j P e 0 QC Qˇj .A2 2 ; A3 3 / N Œ0 m10C
C P0 Q010C @ˇ ŒQ010C R˛
1
1
e 0 QC Qˇj .A2 @j P
2 ; A3
(5.16)
3 / N Œ0 : (5.17)
By Lemma 4.17, (5.17) is bounded by
P0 Q010C @ˇ ŒQ010C R˛
1
1
@j
e 0 QC Qˇj .A2 P
. Q010C R˛
1
k1
.2 2
3 Y
k2 2
k
3 / XP 0; 0
1 ";2
1
e 0 QC Qˇj .A2 2 ; A3 3 / 2 2 @j P L t Lx
1
e 1 @j P 0 QC Qˇj .A2 2 ; A3 1 kL1 t Lx
. kQ0k1 C10C R˛
2 ; A3
3 / L2 L2 t x
i kS Œki :
i D1
On the other hand, (5.16) is estimated as follows: X
P0 Qm @ˇ ŒQQ m R˛
1
1
e 0 QC Qˇj .A2 @j P
2 ; A3
m10C
.
X
2
m"
QQ m r t;x jrj
1
m0
. 2. 2
1
"/k1
1
"/k1
. 2. 2
k
1 kS Œk1 k2 2
3 Y
k
1 L2 L1 t x
e P 0 Qk1 CC Qˇj .A2
e P 0 QC Qˇj .A2
2 ; A3
3 / XP 0; 0 2 ; A3
1 ";2
3 / L1 L2 x t
3 / L2 L2 t x
i kS Œki
i D1
where we applied Bernstein’s inequality relative to t as well as Lemma 4.17. Now suppose A0 D I (in fact, A0 D Q0 ), but at least one of A1 or AQ1 equals I c . If AQ1 D I c , then the modulations of 1 and Qˇj essentially agree,
129
5.1 Reduction to the hyperbolic case
whence ˛ ¤ 0 and X
P0 Q0 @ˇ ŒQm R˛
1
1
@j QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / N Œ0
mC
X
.
P0 Q0 @ˇ ŒQm R˛
1
1
@j QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / L1 L2 t x
mk1 CC
.
X
kQm
1 kL2 L1 x t
e P 0 QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
mC
.
X
3
"/k1
2. 2
2
m.1 2"/
k
1 kS Œk1 2
m"
e 0 QQ m Qˇj . kP
2;
3 /kL2 L2x t
mC 3
. 2. 2
"/k1 "k2
hk2 i2
3 Y
k
i kS Œki :
i D1
The final estimate here uses Lemma 4.24. Now suppose that AQ1 D I and A1 D I c . Then
P0 Q0 @ˇ ŒI c R˛ 1 1 @j I Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / N Œ0
c 1
e . I R˛ 1 @j P 0 I Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / L1 L2 t x
c
1
e
. I r t;x jrj 1 L2 L1 P 0 QC Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / L2 L2 t
. 21
"/k1
.2
k
1 kL2 L2x 2 t
x
k2 2
t
k
x
2 kS Œk2 k 3 kS Œk3 :
The last case which we need to consider is A0 D A1 D AQ1 D I and either one of A2 ; A3 equal to I c . But then necessarily A2 D A3 D I c whence
P0 @ˇ I ŒI 1 1 @j I Qˇj .Qk CC 2 ; Qk CC 3 / 2 2 N Œ0
. I 1 1 @j I Qˇj .Qk2 CC 2 ; Qk2 CC 3 / L1 L1 t x X
e Q 1 P 0 QC Qˇj .Qm 2 ; Qm 3 / L1 L1 . k 1 kL1 t Lx t
x
mk2 CC
. 2k1 k
1 kL1 L2x
X
t
mk2 CC
. 2k1
k2
3 Y
k
i kS Œki
i D1
which concludes Case 4.
2m
k2
2
2m.1 "/ .1 2"/k2
2
k
2 kS Œk2 k 3 kS Œk3
130
5 Trilinear estimates
Case 5: O.1/ D k1 ; k2 D k3 C O.1/. We begin with A0 D I c and AQ1 D I (in fact, A0 D Q0 suffices here as usual). Moreover, we will drop R˛ from 1 which amounts to excluding the case A1 D I c and ˛ D 0 but nothing else. Then, from Lemma 4.17,
P0 I c @ˇ Œ
1
@j I Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / N Œ0 X
1 1 @j IPk Qˇj .
1
.
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
kk2 ^0CO.1/
X
.
k
1 kL1 L2x
k
1 kL1 L2x 2
t
2
k
IPk Qˇj .
2;
3 / L2 L1 t x
kk2 ^0CO.1/
X
.
k
k2 2
t
k
2 kS Œk2 k 3 kS Œk3
kk2 ^0CO.1/
.2
3 Y
jk2 j 2
k
i kS Œki
i D1
which is better than needed. Now suppose ˛ D 0 and A0 D A1 D I c , which implies that AQ1 D I . Then
P0 I c @ˇ ŒI c R0 X .
1
@j I Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / N Œ0 X
2 "m P0 Qm ŒQQ m R0 1
1
1
@j Pk I Qˇj .
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
kk2 ^0CO.1/ m0
X
.
X
2.1
"/m
kQQ m
1 kL2 L2x 2 t
k
Pk I Qˇj .
2;
kk2 ^0CO.1/ m0
X
.
k
k
1 kS Œk1 2 2
IPk Qˇj .
2;
3 / L1 L1 x t
3 / L2 L2 t x
kk2 ^0CO.1/ k
X
.
22 k
1 kS Œk1 2
k
k2 2
k
2 kS Œk2 k 3 kS Œk3
kk2 ^0CO.1/
.2
jk2 j 2
3 Y
k
i kS Œki :
i D1
Next, consider the case A0 D I c , and AQ1 D I c . Since I c R0
1
is now excluded,
131
5.1 Reduction to the hyperbolic case
we may drop A1 R˛ altogether. Then
P0 I c @ˇ Œ 1 1 @j I c Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / N Œ0 X
1
P0 Q0 Œ 1 @j QkC Pk Qˇj . .
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
(5.18)
kk2 ^0CO.1/
C
X
X
2
"m
kk2 ^0CO.1/ mC
P0 Qm ŒQm C
X
X
P0 Q0 ŒQ>m
1
1
C
@j QQ m Pk Qˇj .
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
(5.19)
1
Q 1 @j Qm Pk Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / L2 L2 :
C
t
x
kk2 ^0CO.1/ mC
(5.20) First, by Lemma 4.19, X (5.18) .
k
kQkC Pk Qˇj .
k
1 kL1 L2x
2
k
1 kL1 L2x
kQkC Pk Qˇj .
k
1 kL1 L2x
22 2
t
2;
3 /kL2 L1 x t
kk2 ^0CO.1/
X
.
t
2;
3 /kL2 L2x t
kk2 ^0CO.1/
X
.
t
k
"k2
hk2
ki2 k
2 kS Œk2 k 3 kS Œk3
kk2 ^0CO.1/
.2
"jk2 j
hk2 i
3 Y
k
i kS Œki :
i D1
Second, again by Lemma 4.19, X X (5.19) . 2
"m
P0 Qm ŒQm
C
1
1
@j QQ m Pk
kk2 ^0CO.1/ mC
Qˇj . X
.
X
2
"m
k
1 kL1 L2x t
QQ m Pk Qˇj .
kk2 ^0CO.1/ mC k 2
X
.
2 2
"k2
hk2
.2
hk2 i
3 Y i D1
ki
3 Y i D1
kk2 ^0CO.1/ "jk2 j
2
k
i kS Œki
k
i kS Œki
2; 2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
3 / L2 L2 t x
132
5 Trilinear estimates
and third, X
(5.20) .
X
kQ>m
kk2 ^0CO.1/ mC
X
.
X
2
X
X
"jk2 j
hk2 i
3 Y
k
2;
2
. 12 2"/m
3 / L1 L1 x t m
k
1 kS Œk1 2 2
QQ m Pk Qˇj .
kk2 ^0CO.1/ mC
.2
.1 "/m
k
t
QQ m Pk Qˇj .
kk2 ^0CO.1/ mC
.
1 kL2 L2x 2
C
k
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
1 kS Œk1 2
QQ m Pk Qˇj .
2;
"m
3 / L2 L2 t x
i kS Œki
i D1
where one argues as in the previous two cases to pass to the last line. Thus, A0 D Q0 for the remainder of Case 5. If A1 D I c , then necessarily AQ1 D I c which implies ˛ ¤ 0. Therefore,
P0 Q0 @ˇ ŒI c X .
@j I c Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / N Œ0 X
Qm 1 1 @j Pk QQ m Qˇj .
1
1
2;
3 / L1 L2 t x
kk2 ^0CO.1/ mC
X
.
X
kQm
1 kL2 L2x t
Pk QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
kk2 ^0CO.1/ mC
X
.
X
2
.1 2"/m
k
1 kS Œk1 2
"m
Pk QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
kk2 ^0CO.1/ mC
X
.
k
1 kS Œk1
k
22 2
"k2
hk2
ki2 k
2 kS Œk2 k 3 kS Œk3
kk2 ^0CO.1/
.2
"jk2 j
hk2 i
3 Y i D1
k
i kS Œki
(5.21) which is again admissible. So we may assume also that A1 D I which means that we can drop R˛ from 1 . First, consider the case AQ1 D I c , whence we now face the expression P0 Q0 @ˇ 1 1 @j I c Qˇj . 2 ; 3 /
133
5.1 Reduction to the hyperbolic case
with the implicit frequency constraints of Case 5. We write this as
P0 Q0 @ˇ Œ 1 1 @j I c Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / X D P0 Q0 @ˇ Œ 1 1 @j Q>kCC Pk Qˇj .
2;
3/
k
D
X
X
P0 Q0 @ˇ ŒQ
1
1
C
@j Ql Pk Qˇj .
2;
3/
kl>kCC
C
X
X
P0 Q0 @ˇ ŒQl
1
C
1
@j Ql Pk Qˇj .
2;
3/
kl>kCC
C
X
X
P0 Q0 @ˇ ŒQl
1
1
C
@j Ql Pk Qˇj .
2;
3 /:
kO.1/
(5.22) To estimate the first term of (5.22), we use
X
X
P0 Q0 @ˇ ŒQ
1
C
1
@j Ql Pk Qˇj .
2;
3 / N Œ0
kl>kCC
X
X
P0 QlCO.1/0 @ˇ ŒQ
1
1
C
@j
kl>kCC
Ql Pk Qˇj . .
X
X
2
. 21 "/l
kQ
C
1 kL1 L2x 2 t
"l
2; 1
3 /
1;
1 2 ;1
@j
kl>kCC
Ql Pk Qˇj .
XP 0
2;
3 / L2 L1 : t x
(5.23) Recalling the assumptions on the frequencies in Case 5, and using Bernstein’s inequality as well as Lemma 4.19, we can further bound the preceding by
.
X
X
2
. 21 "/l
k
22 2
"k2
k
1 kS Œk1
Y
kPkj
j kS Œkj
j D2;3
k<minfO.1/;k2 g O.1/>l>kCC
.2
"k2 _0
3 Y i D1
k
i kS Œki :
(5.24)
134
5 Trilinear estimates
The second term of (5.22) is handled similarly, using
X
X
P0 Q0 @ˇ ŒQl
C
1
1
X
P0 Q0 @ˇ ŒQl
C
1
1
@j Ql Pk Qˇj .
2;
3 / N Œ0
2;
3 / L1 HP t
kl>kCC
X
@j Ql Pk Qˇj .
1
kl>kCC
X
.
X
kQl
C
1 kL2
t;:x
1
@j Ql Pk Qˇj .
2;
3 / L2 L1 t x
kl>kCC
(5.25) and from here the estimate continues as for (5.23). The third term of (5.22) is handled identically, and we note here that one actually gains exponentially in l. Finally, suppose at least one choice of j D 2; 3 satisfies Aj D I c . Then necessarily, A2 D A3 D I c and
P0 I @ˇ ŒI 1 1 @j I Qˇj .I c 2 ; I c 3 / N Œ0 X
1 c
. I 1 @j IPk Qˇj .I 2 ; I c
3 / L1 L2 t x
kk2 ^0CO.1/
X
.
k
kIPk Qˇj .I c
k
1 kL1 L2x
2
k
1 kL1 L2x
2k kIPk Qˇj .I c
t
2; I
c
3 /kL1 L1 x t
(5.26)
kk2 ^0CO.1/
X
.
t
2; I
c
Q
3 /kL1 L1x
3 /kL1 L1x t
kk2 ^0CO.1/
. 2k2 ^0 k
1 kL1 L2x
X
t
kQˇj .Qm
2 ; Qm
t
mk2 CC
. 2k2 ^0 k
1 kL1 L2x
X
t
2m
k2
2
2.1 "/m .1 2"/k2
2
k
2 kS Œk2 k 3 kS Œk3
mk2 CC
.2
k2 _0
3 Y
k
i kS Œki
(5.27)
i D1
as claimed. Case 6: O.1/ D k1 k2 C O.1/ k3 C C. This case proceeds similarly to Case 5. We begin with A0 D I c and AQ1 D I (in fact, A0 D Q0 suffices here as usual). Moreover, we will drop R˛ from 1 which amounts to excluding
135
5.1 Reduction to the hyperbolic case
the case A1 D I c and ˛ D 0 but nothing else. Then, from Lemma 4.23,
P0 I c @ˇ Œ .k
1
1
1 kL1 L2x 2 t
@j I Qˇj . k2
2;
3 / N Œ0
I PQk2 Qˇj .
2;
.
1
1
@j I Qˇj .
.1
3 / L2 L1 . 2 2
2;
"/k3 C"k2
3 / L2 L2 t x
3 Y
x
t
k
i kS Œki
i D1
which is better than needed. Now suppose ˛ D 0 and A0 D A1 D I c , which implies that AQ1 D I . Then
P0 I c @ˇ ŒI c R0 1 1 @j I Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / N Œ0 X
"m 1 . 2 P0 Qm ŒQQ m R0 1 @j PQk2 I Qˇj .
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
m0
.
X
2.1
"/m
kQQ m
1 kL2 L2x 2 t
k2
PQk2 I Qˇj .
m0
.2
k2 2
1
2. 2
"/k3 C"k2
3 Y
k
2;
3 / L1 L1 x t
i kS Œki :
iD1
Next, consider the case A0 D I c , and AQ1 D I c . As before, we can drop A1 R˛ in this case. Then
P0 I c @ˇ Œ 1 1 @j I c Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / N Œ0
1 . P0 Q0 Œ 1 @j QkC PQk2 Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / L2 L2 t x X
"m 1 Q Q C 2 P0 Qm ŒQm C 1 @j Qm Pk2 Qˇj .
(5.28)
2 ; 3 / L2 L2 (5.29) t
x
mC
C
X
P0 Q0 ŒQ>m
C
1
1
@j QQ m PQk2 Qˇj .
2;
3 / L2 L2 : t x
mC
First, by Lemma 4.24,
2 k2 Qk2 O.1/C PQk2 Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / L2 L1 t t x
. k 1 kL1 L2x Qk2 O.1/C PQk2 Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / L2 L2
(5.28) . k
1 kL1 L2x t
1
. 2. 2
"/k3
t
3 Y iD1
k
i kS Œki :
x
(5.30)
136
5 Trilinear estimates
Second, again by Lemma 4.24, (5.29) .
X
2
"m
2
"m
P0 Qm ŒQm
C
1
1
@j QQ m PQk2 Qˇj .
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
mC
.
X
k
1 kL1 L2x t
QQ m PQk Qˇj . 2
2;
3 / L2 L1 t x
mC 3 Y
. 21 "/k3
.2
k
i kS Œki
i D1
and third, (5.30) .
X
kQ>m
1 kL2 L2x 2
C
t
k2
QQ m PQk2 Qˇj .
2;
3 / L1 L1 x t
mC
.
X
2
.1 "/m
m
k
1 kS Œk1 2 2
QQ m PQk Qˇj . 2
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
mC
.
X
2
. 12 2"/m
k
1 kS Œk1 2
"m
QQ m PQk2 Qˇj .
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
mC 1
. 2. 2
"/k3
3 Y
k
i kS Œki
i D1
where one argues as in the previous two cases to pass to the last line. Thus, A0 D Q0 for the remainder of Case 6. If A1 D I c , then necessarily AQ1 D I c which implies ˛ ¤ 0. Therefore,
P0 Q0 @ˇ ŒI c 1 1 @j I c Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / N Œ0 X
1
Q Q . Qm 1 @j Pk2 Qm Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / L1 L2 t
x
mC
.
X
kQm
1 kL2 L2x t
PQk QQ m Qˇj . 2
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
(5.31)
mC
.
X
2
.1 2"/m
k
1 kS Œk1 2
"m
PQk2 QQ m Qˇj .
2 ; 3 / L2 L2 t
x
mC . 21 "/k3
.2
3 Y
k
i kS Œki
i D1
which is again admissible. So we may assume also that A1 D I which means that
137
5.1 Reduction to the hyperbolic case
we can drop R˛ from
1.
Next, assume AQ1 D I c . Then write
P0 Q0 @ˇ 1 1 @j I c Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / X D P0 Q0 @ˇ Q<` C 1 1 @j Pk2 CO.1/ Q` Qˇj .
2;
3/
`>k2 CC
C
X
P0 Q0 @ˇ Q`
C
1
1
@j Pk2 CO.1/ Q` Qˇj .
2;
:
3/
`>k2 CC
(5.32) The first term we estimate by using Lemma 4.24: We obtain
X
P0 Q0 @ˇ ŒQ<`
C
1
1
@j Pk2 CO.1/ Q` Qˇj .
2;
3 / N Œ0
`>k2 CC
X
P0 Q`
C 0 @
ˇ
ŒQ<`
X
.
2
. 12 "/`
kQ<`
C
O.1/>`>k2 CC
1
1
@j Pk2 CO.1/ Q`
Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / N Œ0
1 "` @j Pk2 CO.1/ Q` 1 kL1 L2x 2 t
Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / L2 L1
O.1/>`>k2 CC
C
t
X
.
2
. 21 "/` . 21 "/k3
2
.2
kPkj
x
j kS Œkj
j D1
O.1/>`>k2 CC . 21 "/.k2 k3 /
3 Y
3 Y
kPkj
j kS Œkj :
j D1
The second term in (5.32) is more of the same, and estimated using
P0 Q0 @ˇ ŒQ`
C
1
. kŒQ`
C
1
@j Pk2 CO.1/ Q` Qˇj . 1 kL2
t;x
1
2;
3 / N Œ0
@j Pk2 CO.1/ Q` Qˇj .
2;
3 / L2 L1 t x
from which point the estimate is concluded as in the preceding case. This leaves the cases A2 D I c or A3 D I c to be considered. In the former case, necessarily
138
5 Trilinear estimates
A2 D A3 D I c and
P0 I @ˇ ŒI 1 1 @j I Qˇj .I c 2 ; I c 3 / N Œ0
1 c c
Q . I 1 @j I Pk2 Qˇj .I 2 ; I 3 / L1 L2
x
t
.k
1 kL1 L2x t
k2
2
kI PQk2 Qˇj .I c
2; I
c
3 /kL1 L1 x t
. k 1 kL1 L2x kI PQk2 Qˇj .I c 2 ; I c 3 /kL1 L2x t t X . k 1 kL1 L2x kQˇj .Qm 2 ; QQ m 3 /kL1 L2x t
t
mk2
.k
X
1 kL1 L2x
kr t;x jrj
t
1
Qm
Q
2 kL2 L2x kQm t
3 kL2 L1 x t
mk2
.k
C kQm 2 kL2 L2x kr t;x jrj 1 QQ m 3 kL2 L1 t x t X 1 1 2 .1 2"/m 2. 2 "/k2 2. 2 "/k3 k 2 kS Œk2 k 3 kS Œk3
1 kL1 L2x t
mk2 1
3 Y
"/.k3 k2 /
. 2. 2
k
i kS Œki
i D1
which is acceptable. The one remaining case is A0 D A1 D AQ1 D A2 D I and A3 D I c . Of course one may also assume that 3 D Qk2 CC 3 . Then we write P0 I @ˇ I 1 1 @j I Qˇj .I 2 ; I c 3 / D P0 I @ˇ I 1 PQk2 1 @j I Qˇj .I 2 ; I c 3 / (5.33) 1 ˇ Q c C P0 I I 1 @j @ Pk2 I Qˇj .I 2 ; I 3 / : (5.34) The term on the right-hand side of (5.33) is difficult. More specifically, the methods that we have employed up to this point do not seem to yield the necessary bound. However, Tao’s trilinear estimate (5.1) implies that ˇ
k@ P0
1 Rˇ
3
2 kN Œ0
.2
.k3 k2 / k2
2
3 Y
k
i kS Œki
(5.35)
i D1
for some constant > 0 as well as k@ˇ P0
1 Rˇ
2
k3 3 kN Œ0 . 2
3 Y i D1
k
i kS Œki :
(5.36)
139
5.1 Reduction to the hyperbolic case
Since 2k2 PQk2 1 @j I can be replaced by the convolution by a measure and all norms involved are translation invariant, these estimates imply (5.33). The analysis of (5.34) is easier and similar to the considerations at the end of Case 2. More precisely, we first reduce the modulation of the entire output by means of Lemma 4.23:
P0 Q.1
@j @ˇ PQk2 I Qˇj .I 2 ; I c 3 / N Œ0
3"/k3 k 1 kL1 L2x I Qˇj .I 2 ; I c 3 / L2 L1
3"/k3 C ŒI
.2 .2
1 2 .1
1
1
t
1 2 .1
3"/k3
k
"
. 2.1C"/k2 2 2 k3
1 kS Œk1 2 3 Y
x
t
. 12 "/k3 .1C"/k2
k
2
k
2 kS Œk2 k 3 kS Œk3
i kS Œki :
i D1
Next, we reduce the modulation of
1:
P0 Q.1 3"/k ŒQ.1 3"/k 1 1 @j @ˇ I PQk Qˇj .I 2 ; I c 3 / 2 3 3 N Œ0
1 ˇ . P0 Q.1 3"/k3 ŒQ.1 3"/k3 1 @j @ I PQk2 Qˇj .I 2 ; I c 3 / L1 L2 t
k2
. 2 kQ.1 1 2 .1
.2
Q 1 kL2 L2x kPk2 I Qˇj .I
3"/k3
3"/k3
k
"
. 2 2 k3 C.1C"/k2
t
. 21
1 kS Œk1 2 3 Y
k
"/k3 .1C"/k2
2
2; I
k
c
x
3 /kL2 L2x t
2 kS Œk2 k 3 kS Œk3
i kS Œki :
i D1
Finally, we reduce the modulation of the interior null-form using Corollary 4.14:
P0 Q.1
3"/k3 ŒQ.1 3"/k3
1
1
@j @ˇ PQk2 Qk3 k2 CC Qˇj .I
.k
X
1 kS Œk1
2
` k2 4
2
` 2
PQk Q` Qˇj .I 2
2; I
c
2; I
3 / N Œ0 c
3 / L2 L2 t x
k3 `k2 CC 1
. 2. 4
"/.k3 k2 /
3 Y
k
i kS Œki
i D1
which is again admissible. After these preparations, we are faced with the follow-
140
5 Trilinear estimates
ing decomposition: P0 Q.1
3"/k3
Q.1
D P0 Q.1
3"/k3
3"/k3
1
1
Q.1
@j @ˇ Qk3 Qˇj .I 1
3"/k3
2; I
c
3/
1 ˇ
@ @j Qk3
Qˇj .Qk3 k2 CC 2 ; Qk3 CC k2 CC 3 / X P0; Q.1 3"/k3 Pk1 ; 0 Q.1 3"/k3 1 1 @j @ˇ Qk3 D ; 0 2C` Qˇj .Qk3 k2 CC 2 ; Qk3 CC k2 CC 3 / where ` D 21 Œk2 C .1 3"/k3 and dist.; 0 / . 2` . Placing the entire expression in L1t L2x and using Bernstein’s inequality results in the following estimate: With J WD Qk3 k2 CC ,
P0 Q.1 3"/k Q.1 3"/k k 3 3 1
X
P0; ŒPk ; 0 Q.1 1
1
1
@j @ˇ Qk3 Qˇj .I
3"/k3 k1
1
1
2; I
Qk3 Qˇj .J 3"/k3 k1
; 0 2C`
3/
L1t L2x
@j @ˇ
; 0 2C`
X `
P0; ŒPk ; 0 Q.1 22 1
c
1
1
2 21
2 /
3 L
2; J
L1t
x
@j @ˇ
2 21
Qk3 Qˇj .J 2 ; J 3 / L1
L1t
x
X
Pk ; 0 Q.1 2 1 ` 2
2 1 ˇ 1 kL2 k @j @
3"/k3 k1
x
0 2C`
Qk3 Qˇj .J
2 12
/
3 L2
2; J
x
L1t
` 1 @j @ˇ Qk3 Qˇj .J 2 ; J 3 / L1 L2 2 2 kQ.1 3"/k3 k1 t t x
` 1 1 . 2 2 k 1 kS Œk1 r t;x jrj J 2 kL2 L2x r t;x jrj J 3 L2 L1
1 kL1 L2x
t
.2
1 4 .1
3"/k3 C
k2 4
k
1 kS Œk1
2
k3 2
k
t
. 12 "/k3 "k2
2 kS Œk2 2
2
k
x
3 kS Œk3
which is again admissible for small " > 0. Case 7: k1 D O.1/ k3 C O.1/ k2 C C. This case is symmetric to the previous one. Case 8: k2 D O.1/; max.k1 ; k3 / C. We begin with A0 D Q0 and AQ1 D I , and we drop R˛ from 1 excluding the case A1 D I c and ˛ D 0 but nothing
141
5.1 Reduction to the hyperbolic case
else. Then, from Lemma 4.23,
P0 I c @ˇ Œ 1 1 @j I Qˇj . 2 ;
3 / N Œ0
.
1
1
@j I Qˇj .
k1 . 1
2 ; 3 / L2 L2 . 2 2 2
Q0 Qˇj . 1 I P . k 1 kL1 t Lx
t
"/k3
2; 3 Y
3 / L2 L2 t x
k
x
i kS Œki
i D1
which is better than needed. Now suppose ˛ D 0 and A0 D A1 D I c , which implies that AQ1 D I . Then by Lemma 4.23
P0 I c @ˇ ŒI c R0 1 1 @j I Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / N Œ0 X
"m 1 . 2 P0 Qm ŒQQ m R0 1 @j PQ0 I Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / L2 L2 t
m0
.
X
2
"m
1
QQ m r t;x jrj
1 L2 L1 t x
m0
.
X
2.1
"/m
kQQ m
1 kL2 L2x t
PQ0 I Qˇj .
1
@j PQ0 I Qˇj .
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
m0 . 21 "/.k1 Ck3 /
.2
3 Y
k
2;
x
3 / L1 L2 x t
i kS Œki :
i D1
Next, consider the case A0 D I c , and AQ1 D I c . As before, we can drop A1 R˛ in this case. Then
P0 I c @ˇ Œ 1 1 @j I c Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / N Œ0 X
"m . 2 P0 Qm ŒQm C 1 1 @j QQ m PQ0 Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / L2 L2 (5.37) x
t
mC
C
X
P0 Q0 ŒQ>m
1
1
C
@j QQ m PQ0 Qˇj .
3 / L2 L2 : t x
2;
(5.38)
mC
First, by Lemma 4.24, X
(5.37) . 2 "m P0 Qm ŒQm
C
1
1
@j QQ m PQ0 Qˇj .
2;
mC
.
X
2
"m k1
2 k
1 kL1 L2x t
QQ m PQ0 Qˇj .
mC
.2
k1 C. 21 "/k3
3 Y i D1
k
i kS Œki
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
3 / L2 L2 t x
142
5 Trilinear estimates
and second, (5.38) .
X
2k1 kQ>m
1 kL2 L2x
C
t
QQ m PQ0 Qˇj .
2;
3 / L1 L2 x t
mC
.
3
X
"/k1
2. 2
.1 "/m
2
k
m
1 kS Œk1 2 2
QQ m PQ0 Qˇj .
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
mC
. 2k1
X
2
. 12 2"/m
k
1 kS Œk1 2
"m
QQ m PQ0 Qˇj .
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
mC k1 C. 12 "/k3
.2
3 Y
k
i kS Œki
i D1
where one argues as in the previous two cases to pass to the last line. Thus, A0 D Q0 for the remainder of Case 8. If AQ1 D I c , then necessarily A1 D I c which implies ˛ ¤ 0. Therefore,
P0 Q0 @ˇ ŒI c 1 1 @j I c Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / N Œ0 X
1
Q Q . Qm 1 @j P0 Qm Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / L1 L2 t
x
mC
.
X
2k1 kQQ m
1 kL2 L2x t
PQ0 Qm Qˇj .
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
mC
X
. 2k1
2
.1 2"/m
k
1 kS Œk1 2
"m
PQ0 QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
mC k1 . 12 "/k3
.2 2
3 Y
k
i kS Œki
i D1
which is again admissible. So we may assume also that AQ1 D I . Now suppose that A1 D I c . Then we can take A1 D Qk1 C whence
P0 Q0 @ˇ ŒQk C R˛ 1 1 @j I Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / 1 N Œ0
1
Q . Qk1 C R˛ 1 @j P0 I Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / L1 L2 t x
PQ0 I Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / 2 2 . kQk1 C r t;x jrj 1 1 kL2 L1 L L x t
. 21 "/k1
.2
1
. 2. 2
k
. 12 "/k3
1 kS Œk1 2
"/.k1 Ck3 /
3 Y i D1
k
t
k
i kS Œki :
2 kS Œk2 k 3 kS Œk3
x
143
5.1 Reduction to the hyperbolic case
So we may assume for the remainder of this case that A1 D I which means that we can drop R˛ from 1 . This leaves the cases A2 D I c or A3 D I c to be considered. In the former case, necessarily A2 D A3 D I c and
P0 I @ˇ ŒI 1 1 @j I Qˇj .I c 2 ; I c 3 / N Œ0
1 c c
Q . I 1 @j I P0 Qˇj .I 2 ; I 3 / L1 L2 t x
k1 c c . 2 k 1 kL1 L2x I PQ0 Qˇj .I 2 ; I 3 / L1 L2 x t
t k1 c c
Q . 2 k 1 kL1 L2x I P0 Qˇj .I 2 ; I 3 / L1 L2 t t x X
k1
Q . 2 k 1 kL1 L2x Qˇj .Qm 2 ; Qm 3 / L1 L2 t
t
m0
. 2k1 k
X
1 kL1 L2x
kr t;x jrj
t
1
x
Q
2 kL2 L2x kQm
Qm
t
m0
C kQm . 2 k1 k
X
1 kL1 L2x
2
t
2 kL2 L2x kr t;x jrj t
.1 2"/m . 21 "/k3
2
k
3 kL2 L1 x t
1
QQ m
3 kL2 L1 x
t
2 kS Œk2 k 3 kS Œk3
m0 1
. 2k1 C. 2
"/k3
3 Y
k
i kS Œki
i D1
which is acceptable. The one remaining case is A0 D A1 D AQ1 D A2 D I and A3 D I c . Of course one may also assume that 3 D QC 3 . The analysis in this case is similar to the considerations at the end of Case 2. More precisely, we first reduce the modulation of the entire output by means of Lemma 4.23:
P0 @ˇ Q.1 3"/k C ŒI 1 1 @j PQ0 I Qˇj .I 2 ; I c 3 / 3 N Œ0
1 .1 3"/k c 3
1 IQ .2 2 k 1 kL1 3 / L2 L2 ˇj .I 2 ; I t Lx t
1 2 .1
k1
.2 2 "
. 2k1 2 2 k3
3"/k3
3 Y
k
k
. 21 "/k3
1 kS Œk1 2
k
x
2 kS Œk2 k 3 kS Œk3
i kS Œki
i D1
Next, we reduce the modulation of 1 :
P0 Q.1 3"/k @ˇ ŒQ.1 3"/k 1 1 @j I PQ0 Qˇj .I 2 ; I c 3 / 3 3 N Œ0
ˇ 1
Q . P0 @ Q.1 3"/k3 ŒQ.1 3"/k3 1 @j I P0 Qˇj .I 2 ; I c 3 / L1 L2 t x
. 2k1 kQ.1 3"/k 1 k 2 2 PQ0 I Qˇj .I 2 ; I c 3 / 2 2 3
L t Lx
L t Lx
144
5 Trilinear estimates
. 2k1
1 2 .1
"
3"/k3
. 2 2 k3 Ck1
3 Y
k
k
1 kS Œk1 2
. 21 "/k3
k
2 kS Œk2 k 3 kS Œk3
i kS Œki
i D1
Finally, we reduce the modulation of the interior null-form using Corollary 4.14:
P0 Q.1 3"/k ŒQ.1 3"/k 1 1 @j PQ0 Qk C Qˇj .I 2 ; I c 3 / 3 3 3 N Œ0 . 2k1 k
1 kS Œk1
X
2
` k1 4
2
` 2
PQ0 Q` Qˇj .I
2; I
c
3 / L2 L2 t x
k3 `C
.2
3k1 1 4 C. 4
"/k3
3 Y
k
i kS Œki
i D1
which is again admissible. After these preparations, we are faced with the following decomposition: P0 @ˇ Q.1 3"/k3 Q.1 3"/k3 1 1 @j Qk3 Qˇj .I 2 ; I c 3 / D P0 Q.1 3"/k3 @ˇ Q.1 3"/k3 1 1 @j Qk3 Qˇj .Qk3 k2 CC 2 ; Qk3 CC k2 CC 3 / X P0; Q.1 3"/k3 @ˇ ŒPk1 ; 0 Q.1 3"/k3 1 1 @j Qk3 D ; 0 2C`
Qˇj .Qk3 k2 CC
2 ; Qk3 CC k2 CC
3 /
where ` D 21 Œ.1 3"/k3 k1 ^0 and dist.; 0 / . 2` . Placing the entire expression in L1t L2x and using Bernstein’s inequality results in the following estimate:
P0 Q.1 3"/k ŒQ.1 3"/k 1 1 @j Qk Qˇj .I 2 ; I c 3 / 1 2 3 3 3 L t Lx
X
P0; ŒPk ; 0 Q.1 3"/k 1 1 @j Qk 1 3 3 ; 0 2C`
2 12
Qˇj .Qk3 C 2 ; Qk3 CC C 3 / L2 1 x Lt
X
1
Pk ; 0 Q.1 3"/k 1 @j Qk 1 3 3 0 ; 2C`
2 21
Qˇj .Qk3 C 2 ; Qk3 CC C 3 / L2 1 x Lt
X
2 1 kPk1 ; 0 Q.1 3"/k3 1 kL @j Qk3 1 x 0 2C`
145
5.1 Reduction to the hyperbolic case
Qˇj .Qk3 C `
2 2 2k1 kQ.1
3"/k3
1 kL1 L2x t
`
1 kS Œk1
r t;x jrj .2
3k1 1 4 C 4 .1
3"/k3
1
kr t;x jrj
k
1 kS Œk1
1
1
Qˇj .Qk3 C . 2 k1 C 2 k
2 ; Qk3 CC C
2 ; Qk3 CC C
Qk3 CC C
2
k
L1t
x
@j Qk3
Qk3 C k3 2
2 12
/
3 L2
3 / L1 L2 t x
2 kL2 L2x
t
3
L2t L1 x
. 1 "/k3 k 3 kS Œk3 2 kS Œk2 2 2
which is again admissible for small " > 0. Case 9: k3 D O.1/; max.k1 ; k2 /
C. Symmetric to Case 8.
It is important to realize that Lemma 5.1 yields the following statement, which is really a corollary of its proof rather than its lemma. Corollary 5.2. Let i be Schwarz functions adapted to ki for i D 0; 1; 2. Then for any ˛; ˇ D 0; 1; 2, and j D 1; 2,
P0 r t;x A0 ŒA1 R˛ 1 1 @j AQ1 Qˇj .A2 2 ; A3 3 / N Œ0 . w.k1 ; k2 ; k3 /
3 Y
k
i kS Œki
i D1
where Ai and AQ1 are either I or I c , with at least one being I c . Moreover, we impose the following restrictions: ı If A1 D AQ1 D I c then ˛ D 0 is excluded, ı if k1 D O.1/ > k2 k3 C C , then A0 D A1 D AQ1 D A2 D I , A3 D I c is excluded, ı if k1 D O.1/ > k3 k2 C C , then A0 D A1 D AQ1 D A3 D I , A2 D I c is excluded. In particular, kP0 r t;x Œ
1
1
c
@j I Qˇj .
2;
3 /kN Œ0
. w.k1 ; k2 ; k3 /
3 Y i D1
k
i kS Œki :
(5.39)
Proof. Note that the first exclusion in our list is precisely the exclusion in Lemma 5.1. The only real difference between this statement and that of Lemma 5.1
146
5 Trilinear estimates
lies with the fact that we no longer require the outer most derivative to be @ˇ . But this mattered only in one case, namely when we applied Tao’s bound (5.1) in Cases 6 and 7 above. Moreover, inspection of the argument in those cases reveals that the @ˇ @ˇ null-form was needed only in those instances which are excluded as the second and third conditions of our above list (in fact, the modulations were narrowed down much more before any need for (5.1) arose). The final statement is an immediate consequence of the first one, since we removed R˛ altogether (which eliminates the first exclusion) and since the other two exclusions do not arise due to AQ1 D I c . Therefore, one simply sums over all choices of A0 ; A1 ; A2 and A3 . In fact, the proof of Lemma 5.1 makes no use of the fact that 1 @j contains the same index as the null-form Qˇj . But the strengthening resulting from replacing 1 @j by jrj 1 , say, is of no benefit to us so we do not carry it out. The following variant of Lemma 5.1 covers the other two types of trilinear nonlinearities arising in the Coulomb gauged wave map system. Lemma 5.3. Let i be Schwarz functions adapted to ki for i D 0; 1; 2. Then for any ˛ D 0; 1; 2, j D 1; 2,
P0 @ˇ A0 ŒA1 Rˇ 1 1 @j I Q˛j .A2 2 ; A3 3 / N Œ0
. w.k1 ; k2 ; k3 /
3 Y
k
i kS Œki
(5.40)
i kS Œki
(5.41)
i D1
P0 @˛ A0 ŒA1 Rˇ
1
1
@j I Qˇj .A2
2 ; A3
3 / N Œ0
. w.k1 ; k2 ; k3 /
3 Y
k
i D1
where Ai are either I or I c , with at least one being I c . Proof. Both these bounds follow from Corollary 5.2 provided we are not in those cases described as Items 2 and 3 in the list of exclusions (observe that the first exclusion does not arise due to our limitation to AQ1 D I ). So let us consider the second exclusion k1 D O.1/ > k2 k3 C C and A0 D A1 D AQ1 D A2 D I , A3 D I c (the third one being symmetric to this case). Then (5.41) is an immediate consequence of (5.1), see (5.35) and (5.36) above. As for (5.40), observe that due to the analysis of (5.34) we may assume that the outer @ˇ derivative hits 1 . Hence, it suffices to bound
P0 I ŒI @ˇ Rˇ 1 1 @j I Q˛j .I 2 ; I c 3 / : N Œ0
147
5.1 Reduction to the hyperbolic case
However, due to the property that kIP0 kL2 L2x . kkS Œ0 and @ˇ @ˇ D , this t is easy:
P0 I ŒQC @ˇ Rˇ 1 1 @j I Q˛j .I 2 ; I c 3 / N Œ0
ˇ 1
. P0 I ŒQC @ Rˇ 1 @j I Q˛j .I 2 ; I c 3 / L1 L2 t x
1
c ˇ
Q . kQC @ Rˇ 1 kL2 L2x @j Pk2 I Q˛j .I 2 ; I 3 / L2 L1 t
.k
1 kS Œk1 2
1 2 .1
t
3"/k3 "k2
2
k
x
2 kS Œk2 k 3 kS Œk3
as desired. The following technical corollary will be important later.
Corollary 5.4. For some absolute constant 0 > 0, and arbitrary Schwartz functions i , 2 X
P0 r t;x Œ
1
1
@j I c Qˇj .
2;
3 / N Œ0
j D1
. K 2 sup max 2
0 jkj
k2Z i D1;2;3
kPk
i kS Œk
(5.42)
P provided maxi D1;2;3 k2Z kPk i k2S Œk K 2 and with an absolute implicit constant. Moreover, given any ı > 0 there exists a constant L D L.ı/ 1 such that X0 k1 ;k2 ;k3
2 X
P0 r t;x ŒPk 1
1
1
@j I c Qˇj .Pk2
2 ; Pk3
3 / N Œ0
j D1
ı K 2 sup
max 2
0 jkj
k2Z i D1;2;3
where the sum
P0
k1 ;k2 ;k3
Further, if X00
k1 ;k2 ;k3
k1 ;k2 ;k3
X
i kS Œk
extends over all k1 ; k2 ; k3 outside of the range
jk1 j L; P00
kPk
k2 ; k3 L;
jk2
k3 j L:
(5.43)
denotes the sum over this range, then
2 X
P0 r t;x ŒPk 1
1
1
@j I c Pk Qˇj .Pk2
2 ; Pk3
3 / N Œ0
kk2 L0 j D1
ı K 2 sup max 2 k2Z i D1;2;3
0 jkj
kPk
i kS Œk
148
5 Trilinear estimates
where L0 D L0 .L; ı/ is a large constant. Finally, given ı > 0, there exists C > 1 large enough such that we have X X
P0 r t;x ŒPk 1 1 @j I c P< k Q>kCC Qˇj .Pk 2 ; Pk 3 / 1 2 3 N Œ0 k1 ;2;3 k< C
ı K 2 sup max 2
0 jkj
k2Z i D1;2;3
kPk
i kS Œk :
P Proof. Write i D ki 2Z Pki i for 1 i 3. In view of the definition of the weights w.k1 ; k2 ; k3 /, summing (5.39) over all choices of k1 ; k2 ; k3 yields (5.42). The second statement follows immediately from the fact that the weights w.k1 ; k2 ; k3 / gain some smallness outside of the range (5.43) (namely 2 ıL ). For the third statement one needs to observe that in Case 5 – which is the one specified by (5.43) but of course with a range specified by the constant L – an extra gain can be obtained by restricting k to sufficiently small values compared to k2 ; k3 .
5.2
Trilinear estimates for hyperbolic S-waves
The following lemma finally proves the trilinear estimates in the “hyperbolic” case. The argument will rely on the following trilinear null-form expansion from [23]: 2@ˇ
1
D .
1
@j Qˇj .
1 /jrj
C .
1
2;
2 jrj 1
1 .jrj 1 1 / @j
3/ 1
3
2 /jrj
C
1 jrj
1
2 jrj 1
1
jrj
1
1
@j .Rj
1 jrj
1
C
2 jrj
Rj
as well as its “dual” form 2@ˇ 1 1 @j Qˇj . 2 ; D
.
3/ 1
3
3 1
1
3
1
2 /jrj 1
1
3
@j .Rj 1
1
2 jrj
@j Rj
1
3/ 1
2 jrj
3
(5.44)
C
2 jrj
1
2 jrj
1
1 jrj
3
3/
1
3
.
1 /
C
1
jrj 1
1
@j Rj
1
@j Rj
2 2 jrj 2 jrj
1 1
3
3
: (5.45)
Strictly speaking, we shall want to apply these identities to the trilinear expression @ˇ 1 1 @j IPk Qˇj . 2 ; 3 /
149
5.2 Trilinear estimates for hyperbolic S -waves
for some Pk . In the case of (5.45) the operator IPk can be inserted in front of any product involving 2 and 3 which is the case for all but the second term on the right-hand side of (5.45), i.e., . 1 jrj 1 3 /jrj 1 2 (and similarly for (5.44)). Since IPk is disposable, it takes the form of convolution with a measure k with mass kk k . 1. Thus, the second term needs to be replaced by the convolution Z 1 jrj 1 3 . y/ jrj 1 2 . y/k .dy/: (5.46) The logic will be that any estimate that we make on . 1 jrj 1 3 /jrj 1 2 in the context of the S Œk and N Œk spaces will equally well apply to this convolution since all norms are translation invariant. We shall use this observation repeatedly in what follows without any further comment. Finally, the weights w.k1 ; k2 ; k3 / are those specified at the beginning of this section. Lemma 5.5. Let
j
be adapted to kj , for j D 1; 2; 3. Then
2
X
P0 I @ˇ IR˛
1
1
@j I Qˇj .I
2; I
3/
N Œ0
j D1
. w.k1 ; k2 ; k3 /
3 Y
k
i kS Œki
(5.47)
k
i kS Œki
(5.48)
k
i kS Œki
(5.49)
iD1 2
X
P0 I @˛ IRˇ
1
1
@j I Qˇj .I
2; I
3/
N Œ0
j D1
. w.k1 ; k2 ; k3 /
3 Y iD1
2
X
P0 I @ˇ IRˇ
j D1
1
1
@j I Q˛j .I 2 ; I 3 /
N Œ0
. w.k1 ; k2 ; k3 /
3 Y i D1
for any ˛ D 0; 1; 2. Proof. We begin with (5.47). Due to the I in front of 1 we shall drop the R˛ operator. Also, it will be understood in this proof that i D Qki CC i for 1 i 3 and we will often drop the I -operator in front of the input functions.
150
5 Trilinear estimates
Case 1: 0 k1 k2 C O.1/ D k3 C O.1/. By Lemma 4.17,
ˇ 1
P0 I @ Q0 1 @j I Qˇj .I 2 ; I 3 / N Œ0
. P0 I @ˇ Q0 1 1 @j I Qˇj .I 2 ; I 3 / 1 2 L L
t x
k1 Q . kQ0 1 kL2 L2x 2 Pk1 I Qˇj .I 2 ; I 3 / 2 2 t
(5.50)
L t Lx
.2
k2 2
3 Y
k
i kS Œki :
i D1
So it suffices to consider P0 I @ˇ Q<0
1
1
@j I Qˇj .I
2; I
3/
D P0 QC @ˇ Q<0
1
1
@j QC Qˇj .I
: (5.51)
2; I
3/
One can also limit the modulations of 2 ; 3 further. Indeed, by (4.42) of Lemma 4.13 and Corollary 4.14,
ˇ 1 Q P Q @ Q @ I P Q .Q I ; I /
0 C <0 1 j 2 3 k1 ˇj "k2 N Œ0
. 2 k1 k 1 rx;t jrj 1 I 3 k 0; 1 ;1 Q"k2 rx;t jrj XP k
.2
"k2
hk2
k1 i
3 Y
k
2
1
I
2
3
0;
XP k
2
1 2 ;1
(5.52)
i kS Œki
i D1
which is admissible. Note that we replaced 1 @j PQk1 by 2 k1 as explained in the paragraph preceding this lemma. Thus, assume that 1 D QC 1 , j D Q"kj j for j D 2; 3, apply the identity (5.45), and estimate the six terms on the right-hand side of (5.45) in the order in which they appear. First, by the Strichartz component (2.14),
P0 I 1 jrj 1 2 jrj 1 3
N Œ0
. P0 I 1 jrj 1 2 jrj 1 3 0; 1 ;1 XP 0 2
. 1 jrj 1 2 jrj 1 3 2 2 L t Lx
. k kL1 L2x 2 t
k2
k
2 2 kL4 L1 x t
k3
k
3 kL4 L1 x t
151
5.2 Trilinear estimates for hyperbolic S -waves 3 Y
k2 2
.2
k
i kS Œki :
i D1
Second, by (4.40) of Lemma 4.13 and Lemma 4.11,
P0 I .
1 1 jrj /jrj 1 3 2 N Œ0
Q
. hk3 i Pk3 Q"k3 1 jrj 1 3
0;
XP k
1 2 ;1
kjrj
1
2 kS Œk2
3
. hk3 i PQk3 Q"k3
3
1
1 jrj
0; 1 2 ;1
XP k
k
2 kS Œk2
3
. 2k1
k3
1
2 4 ."k3
k1 /
3 Y
hk3 i
k
i kS Œki :
i D1
Here we use that the restriction on the modulation of the output and the modulation of 2 allow us to restrict the modulation of . 1 jrj 1 3 / to size < 2"k3 . Third, by (4.42) and Lemma 4.11,
P0 I
1 .jrj
1
1
2 /jrj
. PQk3 Q"k3
1 jrj
3 1
N Œ0
3 0; 1 ;1 2 XP k
X
2
1 4 j ^0
3
Qj jrj
1
2
j "k2
. 2k1
k3
1
2 4 .3"k3
k1 /
hk3 i2
3 Y
k
0;
XP k
1 ;1 2
2
i kS Œki :
i D1
Fourth, again by (4.42) and Lemma 4.11,
P0 I .
1 1 / @ .R jrj / 1 j j 2 3 N Œ0
X `
. 2 k1 2 4 kQ` 1 k 0; 1 ;1 PQk1 QC Rj XP k
`C
.2
k1
k2 4
2
k2 4
3 Y i D1
k
2
1
i kS Œki :
2 jrj
1
3
1 ;1 0; 2
XP k
3
152
5 Trilinear estimates
Fifth, with ` D k1 k2 ,
P0 I 1 1 @j .Rj 2 jrj 1 3 / N Œ0
1 1 Q . 1 @j Pk1 Rj 2 jrj 3 2 2 L t Lx X k1
Pc Rj 2 jrj . k 1 kL1 L2x 2 t
1
P
c
3 L2 L1 t x
c2Dk2 ;`
.k
1 kL1 L2x 2
X
k1 k3
2 2 kL4 L1
kPc Rj
t
x
t
c2Dk2 ;`
X
21
kP
c
2 3 kL4 L1
.k
1 kL1 L2x 2
k1 k2 .1 2"/`
2
t
2
3k2 2
k
x
t
c2Dk2 ;`
12
2 kS Œk2 k 3 kS Œk3
which is admissible for small " > 0. The sixth and final term is estimated by means of (4.40) and Lemma 4.11:
P0 I 1 1 @j .Rj 2 jrj 1 3 / N Œ0
Q
1 1 . hk1 ik 1 kS Œk1 Pk1 QC @j Rj 2 jrj 3 0; 1 ;1 2 XP k
1
. hk1 ik 1 kS Œk1 PQk1 QC Rj . hk1 ik
1 kS Œk1 2
5.k1 k2 / 4
2
k2 4
2 jrj
k
1
3
1 ;1 0; 2
XP k
1
2 kS Œk2 k 3 kS Œk3
which concludes Case 1. Case 2: 0 k1 D k3 C O.1/; k2 k3 C. By Lemma 4.23,
ˇ 1 P I @ Q @ I Q .I ; I /
0 0 1 j 2 3 ˇj N Œ0
. P0 I @ˇ Q0 1 1 @j I Qˇj .I 2 ; I 3 / 1 2 L L
t x
k1 Q . kQ0 1 kL2 L2x 2 Pk1 I Qˇj .I 2 ; I 3 / 2 2 t
L t Lx
1
. 2. 2
"/k2
2
.1 "/k1
3 Y i D1
k
i kS Œki :
153
5.2 Trilinear estimates for hyperbolic S -waves
So it suffices to consider P0 I @ˇ Q<0
1
1
@j I Qˇj .I
2; I
D P0 QC @ˇ Q<0
3/
1
1
@j QC Qˇj .I
2; I
: (5.53)
3/
One can also limit the modulation of 3 further. Indeed, by (4.42) of Lemma 4.13 and Corollary 4.14,
ˇ 1 Q
P0 QC @ Q<0 1 @j I Pk1 Qˇj .I 2 ; Q"k3 I 3 / N Œ0
k1 Q 1 1 .2 Pk3 1 rx;t jrj I 2 0; 1 ;1 Q"k3 rx;t jrj I 3 0; 1 ;1 XP k 2 XP k 2 (5.54) 3 3 k2 k1
.2
hk1
k2 i2
3 Y
"k1
k
i kS Œki
i D1
which is admissible. As explained in Case 1, we replaced 1 @j PQk1 by 2 k1 . If 0 k2 , then we can similarly reduce the modulation of the small frequency term, cf. (5.52):
P0 QC @ˇ Q<0 1 1 @j I PQk1 Qˇj .Q"k2 I 2 ; I 3 / N Œ0
. 2 k1 PQk2 .2
k2
k1 4
2
1 1 rx;t jrj I 3
"k2
3 Y
k
0; 1 ;1 Q"k2 rx;t jrj
XP k
2
1
I
2
2
0;
XP k
1 2 ;1
2
i kS Œki
i D1
As a final preparation, we limit the modulation of the output in case k2 0. In fact, by Lemma 4.23,
ˇ 1
P0 Q.1 3"/k2 C @ 1 @j I Qˇj .I 2 ; I 3 / N Œ0
. P0 Q.1 3"/k2 C @ˇ 1 1 @j I Qˇj .I 2 ; I 3 / 0; 1 ;1 2 XP k
1 2 .1
.2 1
. 2 2 "k2 2
3"/k2
k
1 kL1 L2x
.1 "/k1
t
3 Y i D1
k
2
k1
kPQk1 I Qˇj .I
i kS Œki :
2; I
2
3 /kL2 L2x t
154
5 Trilinear estimates
Thus, for the remainder of this case we assume that 1 D QC 1 , 2 D Q"k2 ^k2 2 , and 3 D Q"k3 3 . Moreover, the output is restricted by Q.1 3"/k2 ^C . We now estimate the six terms on the right-hand side of (5.45). First, by the Strichartz component (2.14),
P0 Q.1 3"/k2 ^C 1 jrj 1 2 jrj
. P0 Q.1 3"/k2 ^C 1 jrj 1
. 2 2 .1 1
. 2 2 .1 1
. 2 2 .1
3"/k2 ^0
1 jrj
3"/k2 ^0
k
1 kL1 L2x 2
3"/k2 ^0
1
k1 4
2
2
1
k2
3 Y
k2 4
k
k
N Œ0 1
2 jrj 1
2 jrj
t
3
1
3
0;
XP 0
1 2 ;1
3 L2 L2 t x k3
2 2 kL4 L1 x t
k
3 kL4 L1 x t
i kS Œki
i D1
which is admissible. Second, by (4.40) of Lemma 4.13 and Lemma 4.11,
P0 Q.1 .2
k2 ^0
3"/k2 ^C
.
hk1 i PQk2 _0 Q.1
.2
k2 _0
.2
k2 _0
1
1 jrj
k2 _0 k1 4
1
3"/k2 ^"k2
hk1 i PQk2 _0 Q.1 hk1 i2
3 /jrj
3"/k2 ^"k2
1
2 4 Œ.1
2
N Œ0 1
1 jrj 1 jrj
3"/k2 ^"k2 k1
3
1
3 Y
3
k
1 2 ;1 2 _0
0;
XP k
0; 1 2 ;1 2 _0
XP k
kjrj
k
1
2 kS Œk2
2 kS Œk2
i kS Œki
i D1
which is again admissible. Third, by (4.42) and Lemma 4.11,
P0 Q.1 3"/k2 ^C 1 .jrj 1
. PQk2 _0 Q.1 3"/k2 ^"k2
2 /jrj
1
1 jrj
1
3 N Œ0
3 0; 1 ;1 hk2 _ 0i 2 XP k
jrj . hk2 _ 0i2
k2 _0 k1 4
2
1 4
.1 3"/k2 ^"k2 k1
2
2 _0
1
Q"k2 ^k2
"k2 ^k2 2
3 Y i D1
k
2
0;
XP k
2
i kS Œki :
1 ;1 2
155
5.2 Trilinear estimates for hyperbolic S -waves
Fourth, again by (4.42) and Lemma 4.11,
P0 I . .2
1 / k1
1
X
2 jrj
@j .Rj ` 4
2 kQ`
1k
`C
. 2k2
k1
2
3 Y
k1 4
k
3/
1
N Œ0
PQk QC ŒRj 1
0; 1 ;1 XP k 2 1
1
2 jrj
3
1 ;1 0; 2
XP k
3
i kS Œki :
i D1
Fifth,
P0 I 1 1 @j .Rj 2 jrj 1 3 / N Œ0
1 1
Q . 1 @j Pk1 Rj 2 jrj 3 L2 L2 x
t k1 1
. k 1 kL1 L2x 2 Rj 2 jrj 3 L2 L1 t
2k1
.2 .2
3k2 4
t
k
2
1 kL1 L2x kRj t
5k1 4
3 Y
k
x
k 3 kL4 L1 2 kL4 L1 x x t
t
i kS Œki :
i D1
The sixth and final term is estimated by means of (4.40) and Lemma 4.11:
P0 I
1
1
2 jrj
@j .Rj
/ 3
1
N Œ0 1
. hk1 ik 1 kS Œk1 PQk1 Q"k3
@j Rj
1
2 jrj
3
0;
XP k
1 2 ;1
1
. hk1 ik
1 kS Œk1
. hk1 i2k2
k1
2
PQk Q"k Rj 1 3
1 4 .1
"/k1
3 Y
k
2 jrj
1
3
1 ;1 0; 2
XP k
1
i kS Œki
i D1
which concludes Case 2. Case 3: 0 k1 D k2 C O.1/; k3 k2
C. This is symmetric to the preceding.
Case 4: O.1/ k2 D k3 C O.1/; k1 C. This case proceeds similarly to Case 1. Following (5.52), we begin by limiting the modulations of 2 ; 3 to
156
5 Trilinear estimates
2"k2 . Indeed, by (4.42) of Lemma 4.13 and Corollary 4.14,
P0 QC @ˇ I 1 1 @j I PQ0 Qˇj .Q"k2 I 2 ; I 3 /
N Œ0
. 2 k1 . 22k1
k2
k
k2
1
1 rx;t jrj
1 2 "k2
2
3k
I
hk2
k1 i
1 ;1 0; 2
XP k
3 Y
kQ"k2 rx;t jrj
1
2 k 0; XP k
I
3
1 2 ;1
2
k
i kS Œki
i D1
which is admissible. Next, we limit the modulation of the output: by Lemma 4.17,
ˇ 1
P0 Qk1 C @ 1 @j I Qˇj .I 2 ; I 3 / N Œ0
. P0 Qk1 C @ˇ 1 1 @j I Qˇj .I 2 ; I 3 / 0; 1 ;1 2 XP k
.2 .2
k1 2
k1
Q 1 P k 1 kL1 0 I Qˇj .I L x t
k2 2
3 Y
k
2
2 ; I 3 /
L2t L2x
i kS Œki :
i D1
We now again estimate the six terms on the right-hand side of (5.45). First, by the Strichartz component (2.14),
P0 Qk1 1 jrj 1 2 jrj 1 3 N Œ0
1 1 . P0 Qk1 1 jrj 2 jrj 3 0; 1 ;1 2 XP 0
.2 .2 .2
k1 2 k1 2
1
1 jrj
2 jrj
k kL1 L2x 2 t
k1
k2 2
3 Y
k
k2
1
k
3 L2 L2 t x
2 2 kL4 L1 x
k3
t
k
3 kL4 L1 x t
i kS Œki :
i D1
Second, by (4.40) of Lemma 4.13 and Lemma 4.11,
P0 I . 1 jrj 1 3 /jrj 1 2 N Œ0
Q
1 . hk3 i Pk3 Q"k3 1 jrj 3 / 0; XP k
3
1 ;1 2
jrj
1
2 S Œk2
157
5.2 Trilinear estimates for hyperbolic S -waves
. hk3 i PQk3 Q"k3 . 2k1
1
2 4 ."k3
k3
k1 /
hk3
3
1
1 jrj
k1 i
0; 1 2 ;1
XP k
3 Y
k
2 kS Œk2
3
k
i kS Œki :
i D1
Third, by (4.42) and Lemma 4.11,
P0 I 1 .jrj 1 2 /jrj 1 3 N Œ0
Q
1 . hk2 i Pk3 Q"k3 1 jrj 3
0; 1 ;1 XP k 2 3
. 2k1
k3
1
2 4 .3"k3
k1 /
hk2 i2 hk1 i
3 Y
k
jrj
1
2
0;
XP k
1 2 ;1
2
i kS Œki :
i D1
Fourth, again by (4.42) and Lemma 4.11,
P0 I . 1 / 1 @j .Rj 2 jrj 1 3 / N Œ0
X ` k1
4 . 2 kQ` 1 k 0; 1 ;1 PQ0 QC Rj `k1 CC k2 4
. 2 k1
XP k
2
2 jrj
1
2 jrj
3
1
3 Y
k
1 ;1 0; 2
XP k
1
i kS Œki :
i D1
Fifth, with ` D k2 ,
P0 Qk1 1
. 2k1 1
1
@j .Rj
3/
1
@j PQk1 Rj 2 jrj X
Pc Rj . 2k1 k 1 kL1 L2x t
1
N Œ0
3
L2t L2x
2 jrj
1
P
c
3 L2 L1 t x
c2Dk2 ;`
. 2k1 k
1 kL1 L2x 2
k3
X
kPc Rj
t
2 2 kL4 L1
c2Dk2 ;`
X c2Dk2 ;` k1 k2 .1 2"/`
.2
2
2
3k2 2
3 Y i D1
k
i kS Œki
t
12
x
kP
c
2 3 kL4 L1 t
x
12
3
158
5 Trilinear estimates
which is admissible for small " > 0. The sixth and final term is estimated by means of (4.40) and Lemma 4.11:
P0 I 1 1 @j .Rj 2 jrj 1 3 / N Œ0
. 2k1 k 1 kS Œk1 PQ0 Qk1 1 @j Rj 2 jrj 1 3 0; 1 ;1 XP k
. 22k1 k 1 kS Œk1 PQ0 Rj . 22k1 2
3 Y
k2 4
k
3
1
2 jrj
2
1
1 ;1 0; 2
XP 0
i kS Œki
i D1
which concludes Case 4. Case 5: O.1/ D k1 ; k2 D k3 C O.1/. We start with the decomposition P0 @ˇ
1
1
@j I Qˇj .
2;
3/
X
D
P0 @ˇ
1
1
@j Pk I Qˇj .
: (5.55)
2;
3/
kk2 ^0CO.1/
We first limit the modulation of 1 :
X
P0 @ˇ Q>k I Q>kCC I kk2 ^0CO.1/
.
X
X
1
.Rˇ
P0 @ˇ Q>k I Q>kCC I
kk2 ^0CO.1/
.
1
k 2
2
kQ>kCC
kk2 ^0CO.1/
@j Pk I 2 Rj
1
Œ
Rj
3
2 Rˇ
3/
1 2 @jˇ Pk I.jrj 1
2 Rj
Pk I.jrj 1 2 Rˇ 3 / 0; 1 ;1 2 XP
1 2 1 2 Rj 3 / 1 kL2 L2x @jˇ Pk I.jrj t
Pk I.jrj 1 2 Rˇ 3 / 1 1 L t Lx
.
X
2 k 1 kS Œk1 k
1 2 @jˇ Pk I.jrj 1
2 Rj
3/
2 Rˇ
/ 3
kk2 ^0CO.1/
Pk I.jrj .
X kk2 ^0CO.1/
2k
k2
k
N Œ0
1
1 kS Œk1 k 2 kL1 L2x k 3 kL1 L2x t t
1 L1 t Lx
3/
159
5.2 Trilinear estimates for hyperbolic S -waves
.2
k2 _0
3 Y
k
i kS Œki :
(5.56)
i D1
Hence, if the inner output has frequency 2k then we may assume that 1 has modulation . 2k . As usual, we apply (5.45). First, by the Strichartz component (2.14),
X
P0 I Qk 1 Pk I Œjrj 1 2 jrj 1 3 N Œ0
kk2 ^0CC
X
.
P0 QkCC Qk
1 Pk I Œjrj
k 2 2 Qk
1
1
1
2 jrj
3
kk2 ^0CC
X
.
1 Pk I jrj
1
2 jrj
X
2
k k2 2
L2t L2x
1 2 k2 _0
k
i kS Œki
i D1
kk2 ^0CC
.2
3 Y
1 ;1 2
3
kk2 ^0CC
.
0;
XP 0
3 Y
k
i kS Œki :
i D1
For the second term, we can assume that 1 D Qk2 ^0CC by (4.40) of Lemma 4.13 and Lemma 4.11,
P0 I . 1 jrj 1 3 /jrj 1 2 N Œ0
X j k2 ^0
. 2k2 ^0 2 4 PQk2 _0 Qj 1 jrj
1,
1
see above. Then,
3
j k2 ^0CC
jrj
PQ0 Qk2 ^0CC
.2
k2 _0
.2
2k2 _0
3 Y
k
1
1 jrj
3
i kS Œki :
i D1
Third, by (4.42) and Lemma 4.11,
P0 I Qk2 ^0CC 1 .jrj 1 2 /jrj
1
3
1 ;1 0; 2 2 _0
XP k
N Œ0
k
1
1 2 ;1 2 _0
0;
XP k
2 S Œk2 2 kS Œk2
160
5 Trilinear estimates j
X
.
2
k2 ^0 4
Q
Pk2 _0 Qk2 ^0CC
1 jrj
3
1
Qj jrj k2 _0
.2
3 Y
k
0; 1 2 ;1 2 _0
XP k
j k2 ^0CC
1
2
0;
XP k
1 ;1 2
2
i kS Œki :
iD1
Fourth, again by (4.42) and Lemma 4.11,
X
P0 I .QkCC 1 /
1
@j Pk I.Rj
2 jrj
1
2 jrj
1
3/
kk2 ^0CC
X
.
X
`
2 4 kQ`
1k
kk2 ^0CC `C
1 2 ;1
0;
XP k
1
Q
Pk QkCC Rj X
.
k
1k
kk2 ^0CC
.
3 Y
k
0; 1 ;1 XP k 2 1
2
k k2 2
k
N Œ0
3
0; 1 2 ;1
XP k
1 2 k2 _0
2 kS Œk2 k 3 kS Œk3 2
i kS Œki :
iD1
Fifth, with ` D k k2 ,
X
P0 I QkCC
1
1
@j Pk I.Rj
2 jrj
1
3/
kk2 ^0CC
X
.
k 2 2 QkCC
1
1
2 jrj
@j Pk I Rj
1
N Œ0
3
L2t L2x
kk2 ^0CC
.k
1 kL1 L2x
X
t
2
k 2
1 kL1 L2x
X
t
2 jrj
1
P
c
3 L2 L1 t x
c2Dk2 ;`
kk2 ^0CC
.k
X
Pc Rj
2
k 2
k3
X
kPc Rj
2 2 kL4 L1
X
x
t
c2Dk2 ;`
kk2 ^0CC
kP
c
2 3 kL4 L1
c2Dk2 ;`
.k
1 kL1 L2x
X
t
kk2 ^0CC
1
2. 2
2"/.k k2 /
k
21
2 kS Œk2 k 3 kS Œk3
t
x
21
161
5.2 Trilinear estimates for hyperbolic S -waves
.2
3 Y
. 12 2"/k2 _0
k
i kS Œki
i D1
which is admissible for small " > 0. The sixth and final term is estimated by means of (4.40) and Lemma 4.11:
P0 I QkCC
X
1
1
2 jrj
@j Pk I.Rj
1
/ 3
kk2 ^0CC
.k
2k Pk QkCC
X
1 kS Œk1
1
@j Rj
N Œ0 1
2 jrj
3
kk2 ^0CC
.k
2 Pk QkCC Rj
X
1 kS Œk1
k
2 jrj
1
kk2 ^0CC
.k
X
1 kS Œk1
2k 2
k k2 2
k
3
1 ;1 2
0;
XP k
0; 1 2 ;1
XP k
2 kS Œk2 k 3 kS Œk3
kk2 ^0CC
.2
1 2 k2 _0
3 Y
k
i kS Œki
i D1
which concludes Case 5. Case 6: O.1/ D k1 k2 C O.1/ k3 C C. Since Lemma 4.23 implies that
P0 @ˇ Q>k2 . kQ>k2 1
. 2. 2
@j I Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / 1 2 L t Lx
k2 I Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / L2 L1 1 kL2 L2x 2
1
1
t
"/.k3 k2 /
t
3 Y
k
x
i kSŒki
i D1
we may assume that precisely, P0 I @ˇ
1
D Qk2
1.
Next, we reduce matters to (5.1). More
1
@j I Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / D P0 I @ˇ 1 PQk2 1 @j I PQk2 Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / C P0 I I 1 1 @j @ˇ PQk2 I Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / : 1
(5.57) (5.58)
The term in (5.57) satisfies the bounds (5.35) and (5.36), whereas (5.58) is ex-
162
5 Trilinear estimates
panded further: P0 I I 1
1
@j @ˇ PQk2 I Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / D P0 I I 1 1 @j PQk2 I.jrj 1 C Rˇ
2@
ˇ
Rj
3
@ˇ Rj
2 Rj
2 Rˇ
Rj
3
2 jrj
1
(5.59)
3
3/ :
(5.60)
The two terms in (5.60) are again controlled by (5.1). Consider the first term on the right-hand side of (5.59). Replacing 1 @j PQk2 by 2 k2 as usual, one obtains from Lemmas 4.13 and 4.11,
1 jrj 1 2 Rj 3 N Œ0 X
j k2 . 2k2 2 4 Qj jrj 1 2 0; 1 ;1 k 1 Rj 3 k 0; 1 ;1 XP k
j k2 CC
. 2k2 k
2k
0; 1 2 ;1
XP k
2k3 hk3 ik
2
2
XP 0
2
1 kS Œk1 k 3 kS Œk3
2
which is more than enough. The second term in (5.59) is estimated similarly:
1 jrj 1 3 Rj 2 N Œ0 X
j k3 . 2k3 2 4 Qj jrj 1 3 0; 1 ;1 k 1 Rj 2 k 0; 1 ;1 XP k
j k3 CC
. 2k3 k
2k
0; 1 2 ;1
XP k
2k2 hk2 ik
2
3
XP 0
2
1 kS Œk1 k 2 kS Œk2
2
which concludes Case 6. Case 7: k1 D O.1/ k3 C O.1/ k2 C C. This case is symmetric to the previous one. Case 8: k3 D O.1/; max.k1 ; k2 / C. By Lemma 4.23,
ˇ 1 P I @ Q @ I Q .I ; I /
0 j 2 3 k1 C.1 3"/k2 1 ˇj N Œ0
. P0 I @ˇ Qk1 C.1 3"/k2 1 1 @j I Qˇj .I 2 ; I 3 / 1 2 L L
t x
Q
k1 . 2 kQk1 C.1 3"/k2 1 kL2 L2x P0 I Qˇj .I 2 ; I 3 / 2 2 t L t Lx
1
. 2 2 "k2 2
k1 2
3 Y i D1
k
i kS Œki :
163
5.2 Trilinear estimates for hyperbolic S -waves
A similar calculation shows that one can place Qk1 C.1 entire output. So it suffices to consider P0 Qk1 C.1
in front of the
Q
3"/k2 @
D P0 Qk1 C.1
3"/k2
ˇ
2; I
3/
:
We now stimate the six terms on the right-hand side of (5.45). First, by the Strichartz component (2.14),
P0 Qk C.1 3"/k . 1 jrj 1 2 jrj 1 3 / 1 2 N Œ0
. P0 Qk1 C.1 3"/k2 1 jrj 1 2 jrj 1 3 0; 1 ;1 XP 0
1
. 2 2 Œ.1 1
. 2 2 Œ.1 1
. 2 2 Œ.1
3"/k2 Ck1 3"/k2 C3k1
3"/k2 C3k1
1 jrj
k 2
1
1
2 jrj
3
L2t L2x
2 1 kL1 L2x k 2 kL4 L1 t t x 3 Y
k2 4
k
2
k2 4
k
3 kL4 L1 x t
i kS Œki
i D1
which is sufficient. Second, by (4.40) of Lemma 4.13 and Lemma 4.11,
1 1 P Q . jrj /jrj
0 k1 C.1 3"/k2 1 3 2 N Œ0
. 2k2 PQ0 Q.1 3"/k2 1 jrj 1 3 0; 1 ;1 jrj 1 2 S Œk2 2 XP 0
Q . P0 Q.1 3"/k2 1 jrj 1 3 0; 1 ;1 k 2 kS Œk2 XP 0
k1
.2 2
.1 3"/k2 4
k1
^0
hk1 i
3 Y
k
2
i kS Œki
i D1
which is admissible. Third, by (4.42) and Lemma 4.11,
P0 Qk1 C.1 3"/k2 1 .jrj 1 I 2 /jrj 1 3 N Œ0
Q
1 . P0 Q.1 3"/k2 1 jrj 3 0; 1 ;1 jrj 2 XP 0
k1
.2 2
.1 3"/k2 4
k1
^0
hk1 i
3 Y i D1
k
i kS Œki :
1
I
2
0;
XP k
2
1 2 ;1
164
5 Trilinear estimates
Fourth, again by (4.42) and Lemma 4.11,
P0 Qk1 C.1 3"/k2 .Qk1 C.1 3"/k2 X ` k1 . 2 k1 2 4 kQ`
1
1 /
1 k 0; XP k
`k1 C.1 3"/k2
@j .Rj
2 jrj
1
3/
N Œ0
1 ;1 2
1
Q
P0 Qk1 CC Rj . 22k1 2 4 .1
1
3"/k2 k2
2 hk2 i
3 Y
k
2 jrj
1
3
0; 1 2 ;1
XP k
3
i kS Œki :
i D1
Fifth,
P0 Qk1 C.1 1
. 2 2 Œ.1 1
. 2 2 Œ.1 .2
1 2 Œ.1
1
. 2 2 Œ.1
1 1 @ .R jrj / 1 j j 2 3 N Œ0
3"/k2 Ck1
1 1 @j PQk1 Rj 2 jrj 1 3 2 2 L t Lx
3"/k2 Ck1 1
k 1 kL1 L2x Rj 2 jrj 3 L2 L1 3"/k2
t
3"/k2 Ck1
3"/k2 Ck1
k 2
t
1 kL1 L2x kRj
k 3 kL4 L1 2 kL4 L1 t x t x
t
3 Y
3k2 4
k
x
i kS Œki :
i D1
The sixth and final term is estimated by means of (4.40) and Lemma 4.11:
1 1 P Q Q @ .R jrj /
0 k1 C.1 3"/k2 k1 C.1 3"/k2 1 j j 2 3 N Œ0
. 2k1 k 1 kS Œk1 PQ0 Qk1 CC 1 @j Rj 2 jrj 1 3 0; 1 ;1 2 XP k
. 2k1 k 1 kS Œk1 PQk3 Qk1 Rj . 2k1 Ck2 hk2 i
3 Y
k
2 jrj
1
3
1
0; 1 2 ;1
XP k
3
i kS Œki
i D1
which concludes Case 8. Case 9: k2 D O.1/; max.k1 ; k3 /
C. Symmetric to Case 8.
Hence we are done with (5.47). Next, we turn to (5.48) which is similar; basically, one uses (5.44) instead of (5.45). First, one observes that any reductions
165
5.2 Trilinear estimates for hyperbolic S -waves
in modulation which preceded application of (5.45) to (5.47) can equally well be carried out for (5.48) since these bounds only use Lemmas 4.17 and 4.23. Second, observe that the last four terms of (5.44) reappear as the last four terms of (5.45) up to the order and the choice of signs, both of which are irrelevant. Consequently, one only needs to verify that the first two terms of (5.44) satisfy the desired bounds. Case 1: 0 k1 k2 C O.1/ D k3 C O.1/. In this case the second terms in (5.44) and (5.45) satisfy the same bounds, whence it will suffice to bound the first term in (5.44). However, by (4.42) and Lemma 4.11,
P0 I . 1 /jrj 1 2 jrj X ` 2 4 kQ` 1 k .
.2
N Œ0
0;
XP k
`C k1
k2 4
2
k2 4
3 Y
k
3
1
1 2 ;1
Q
Pk1 QC jrj
1
2 jrj
1
1
3
0; 1 2 ;1
XP k
3
i kS Œki
i D1
which is admissible. Case 2: 0 k1 D k3 C O.1/; k2 k3 C. Using the arguments from Case 2 above, we may assume that 1 D Q.1 3"/k2 ^0 k1 1 . In addition, it was shown there that it suffices to assume that 2 D Q"k2 ^k2 2 , 3 D Q"k2 3 . First,
P0 I Q.1 .2
3"/k2 ^0
.1 3"/k2 ^0 k1 4
k1
1
QC Œjrj
Q.1
1
3"/k2 ^0 k1
2 jrj
1
1
N Œ0
0;
XP k
.2
.1 3"/k2 ^0 k1 4
hk1
k2 i
k
1 ;1 2
1
QC jrj 3 Y
3
1
2 jrj
1
3
1 ;1 0; 2
XP k
1
i kS Œki
i D1
which is admissible. One may also restrict the modulation of the entire output by means of the projection Q.1 3"/k2 ^0 k1 . Applying Lemma 4.13 and
166
5 Trilinear estimates
Lemma 4.11 to the second expression in (5.44) yields
P0 Q.1 3"/k2 ^0 k1 Q.1 3"/k2 ^"k2 . 1 jrj 1 2 /jrj 1 3 N Œ0
.1 3"/k2 ^ .1 "/k2
4 .2
PQk1 Q.1 3"/k2 ^"k2 1 jrj 1 2 0; 1 ;1 XP k
.2
.2
.1 3"/k2 ^ .1 "/k2 4
.1 3"/k2 ^ .1 "/k2 4
Q.1 hk1
1 jrj
3"/k2 ^"k2
k2 i
3 Y
k
1
2
1
jrj 1 3 S Œk3
2 0; 1 ;1 k 3 kS Œk3 2 XP k
1
i kS Œki
i D1
which is admissible provided jk2 j > k1 for some > 0. When this condition is violated, we have to work a little harder. First, since we may choose > 0 arbitrarily small and the ensuing estimates will not be affected by our choice of , we may from now as well assume k2 D O.1/. With the modulation and frequency restrictions from above in place, and going back to the original (un-expanded) version of the term under consideration, write schematically rx;t Œ
1
1
@j I Qˇj .
2;
3 /
D
1 .r
1
3/ 2
where we suppress the action of convolution operators of bounded L1 -mass, as they do not affect our estimates. Then we have (for some ı1 > 0 small)
P0 I 1 Q .1 ı1 /k1 .r 1 3 / 2 N Œ0
.k .2
1
2 k 0; 1 ;1 r
ı 1 k1
XP k
2
1
Q
.1 ı1 /k1
1
3 Y
kPkj
3
0;
XP k
1 2 ;1
3
j kS Œkj :
j D1
In light of the modulation restrictions from earlier, we now reduce to estimating P0 I Q< k1 1 .r 1 Q< .1 ı1 /k1 3 / 2 : Decompose this expression into P0 I Q< k1 1 .r 1 Q< .1 ı1 /k1 3 / 2 D P0 I P< ı2 k1 ŒQ< k1 1 .r 1 Q< .1 ı1 /k1 3 / 2 C P0 I P ı2 k1 Q< ı3 k1 ŒQ< k1 1 .r 1 Q< .1 ı1 /k1 C P0 I P ı2 k1 Q ı3 k1 ŒQ< k1 1 .r 1 Q< .1 ı1 /k1
(5.61) 3 / 2
(5.62)
3 / 2
(5.63)
167
5.2 Trilinear estimates for hyperbolic S -waves
where we pick 0 < ı2 < ı3 1. For the first term on the right, suppressing the action of the convolution operator P< ı2 k1 and reverting to the original form, we have reduced to estimating the term P0 rx;t
1
1
@j I Qˇj . 2 ; X D ; 0 2C
3/
P0; 0 rx;t
ı2 k1 ;
1
1
@j I Qˇj .P0;
;
2;
3/
0
where the point is of course that we can localize the output as well as the smallfrequency input 2 to approximately the same small angular sector. If we then make the null-form expansion as at the beginning of Case 2 above, we reduce to estimating
X ; 0 2C
P0; 0 Q.1
3"/k2 ^0 k1
0 ı2 k1 ;
.Q.1
P0 Q.1
X
.
2C
3"/k2 ^"k2 .
1
1 jrj
1
P0;
2 /jrj
1
P0;
2 /jrj
1
ı4 k1
3 Y
kPkj
/ 3
N Œ0
3"/k2 ^0 k1
ı2 k1
Q.1 .2
1 jrj
3"/k2 ^"k2 .
2 3
12
N Œ0
j kS Œkj
j D1
where we have used (the proof of) Corollary 4.10, which concludes estimating the contribution of (5.61). As for that of (5.62), here we can write P0 I P
ı2 k1 Q< ı3 k1 ŒQ< k1
X
D
; 0 2C .1Cı2
D
ı C 3
1 .r
P0 I P 2
ı2 /k
X O.1/>`> ı2 k1 ; 0 2C
1
Q<
.1 ı1 /k1
1
Pk3 ; 0 Q<
P0 I P` Q< ` k1 2
3 / 2
ı2 k1 Q< ı3 k1 ŒPk1 ; Q< k1
.r
X k1 C`C
1
.r
1
1
.1 ı1 /k1
ı3 k1 ŒPk1 ; Q< k1
Pk3 ; 0 Q<
.1 ı1 /k1
3 / 2
1 3 / 2
168
5 Trilinear estimates
X
D
X
O.1/>`> ı2 k1 ; 0 2C
P0 I P`; 00 Q<
` ı3 k1 2
k1 C`C
ı3 k1 ŒPk1 ; Q< k1
; 0 1 .r
1
Pk3 ; 0 Q<
3 / 2
.1 ı1 /k1
where in the last sum 00 ranges over the O.1/ many caps in C
` ı3 k1 2
such that ei-
` ı3 k1 2
ther one of ˙ 00 is at distance . 2 from . As the operator P`; 00 Q< ı3 k1 is given by convolution with a kernel of bounded L1 -mass, we can then again suppress it and revert to estimating the expression X ; 0 2C
P0 rx;t Pk1 ;
` ı3 k1 2
k1 C`C
1
1
@j I Qˇj .
2 ; Pk3 ; 0
3/
; 0
where we have suppressed the implicit dependence on ` (coming from the suppressed action of P`; 00 Q< ı3 k1 ). Due to the preceding identity, it is easy to see that we may write X ; 0 2C
k1 C`C
` ı3 k1 2
P0 rx;t Pk1 ;
1
1
@j I Qˇj .
3/
; 0
X
D ; 0 2C
2 ; Pk3 ; 0
k1 C`C
X
` ı3 k1 2
; 0 Q 1;2 2C
P0;Q2 rx;t Pk1 ;
1
1
` ı3 k1 2
;Q 1 ˙CQ 2
@j I Qˇj .P0;Q1
2 ; Pk3 ; 0
:
3/
For fixed ; 0 , one can now again expand the null-form as at the beginning of Case 2, and as for (5.61), one then concludes that for fixed ; 0
X Q 1;2 2C
` ı3 k1 2
P0;Q2 rx;t
;Q 1 ˙CQ 2
Pk1 ; .2
ı5 k1
1
kPk1 ;
1
@j I Qˇj .P0;Q1
1 kS Œk1 kP0
2 ; Pk3 ; 0
2 kS Œk2 kPk3 ; 0
/ 3
N Œ0
3 kS Œk3
for some ı5 > 0 depending on ı3 ı2 . One can then perform the summation over ; 0 with the aid of Cauchy–Schwarz, and the summation over ` only costs
169
5.2 Trilinear estimates for hyperbolic S -waves
logarithmically. In conclusion, we obtain
X X
O.1/>`> ı2 k1 ; 0 2C
k1 C`C
P0 rx;t Pk1 ;
` ı3 k1 2
1
1
; 0
@j I Qˇj .
2 ; Pk3 ; 0
.2
3/
ı6 k1
N Œ0
3 Y
kPkj
j kS Œkj
j D1
for some small ı6 > 0, which concludes the contribution of (5.62). Finally, we consider the contribution of (5.63). Here we take advantage of Lemma 4.11, which gives
1 P Q ŒQ .r Q /
` ı3 k1 < k1 1 2 0; 1 ;1 < .1 ı1 /k1 3 2 XP l
.2
` k1 4
kQ<
k1
1 kS Œk1 kQ< .1 ı1 /k1
Then we use Lemma 4.13, which gives
P0 I PO.1/ ı2 k1 Q ı3 k1 ŒQ< k1 1 .r 1 Q< .1 ı1 /k1 3 /
X
.
P` Q ı3 k1 Q< k1 1 .r 1 Q< .1 ı1 /k1
3 kS Œk3 :
N Œ0
3 / 0;
2
k . 2.ı3
1 4 /k1
3 Y
kPkj
1 ;1 2
XP l
O.1/>`> ı2 k1
2 kS Œk2
j kS Œkj :
j D1
Case 3: 0 k1 D k2 C O.1/; k3 k2
C. This is symmetric to Case 2.
Case 4: O.1/ k2 D k3 C O.1/; k1 C. This is similar to Case 1. Indeed, the second terms in (5.44) and (5.45) satisfy the same bounds, whence it will suffice to bound the first term in (5.44). However, by (4.42) and Lemma 4.11,
P0 I .I 1 /jrj 1 2 jrj 1 3 N Œ0
X ` k1
. 2 4 kQ` 1 k 0; 1 ;1 PQ0 QC jrj 1 2 jrj 1 3 0; 1 ;1 2 2 `k1 CC
XP k
1
XP k
2
170
5 Trilinear estimates
. 2 k1
k2
3 Y
k
i kS Œki
i D1
which is admissible. Case 5: O.1/ D k1 ; k2 D k3 C O.1/. Here again it suffices to only consider the first term in (5.44). Moreover, (5.55) and (5.56) apply whence that first term is bounded by the Strichartz component (2.14):
X
1 1
P0 I Qk 1 Pk I Œjrj 2 jrj 3 N Œ0
kk2 ^0CC
X
.
P0 QkCC Qk
1 Pk I Œjrj
1
2 jrj
1
1
3
3
kk2 ^0CC
X
.
kQk
k 2 2 1 L Lx Pk I jrj
1
t
2 jrj
kk2 ^0CC
X
.
kk2 ^0CC
2k
k2 2
3 Y
k
i kS Œki . 2
i D1
k2 _0 2
3 Y
k
L1t L2x
L2t L1 x
i kS Œki :
i D1
Case 6: O.1/ D k1 k2 C O.1/ k3 C C. Here one basically starts from (5.57), which can be handled via (5.1). Case 7: k1 D O.1/ k3 C O.1/ k2 C C. This case is symmetric to the previous one. Case 8: k3 D O.1/; max.k1 ; k2 / C. As in Case 8 above, one first shows that one can place Qk1 C.1 3"/k2 in front of the entire output, as well as in front of 1 . So it suffices to consider P0 Qk1 C.1 D P0 Qk1 C.1
Q
3"/k2
2; I
3/
:
We now stimate the first two terms on the right-hand side of (5.44). First, by the Strichartz component (2.14),
P0 I Qk1 C.1 3"/k2 1 jrj 1 2 jrj 1 3 N Œ0
1 1 . P0 I Qk1 C.1 3"/k2 1 jrj jrj 2 3 1 2 L t Lx
.1 3"/k2 Ck1 1 1
2 1 .2 k 1 k 1 2 jrj 2 jrj 3 L t Lx
L t Lx
171
5.2 Trilinear estimates for hyperbolic S -waves
. 2.1 . 2.1
3"/k2 Ck1
3"/k2 Ck1
k 2
2 1 kL1 L2x k 2 kL4 L1 x t
k2 4
3 Y
t
k
k2 4
k
3 kL4 L1 x t
i kS Œki
i D1
which is sufficient. Second, by (4.40) of Lemma 4.13 and Lemma 4.11, and assuming first that k1 D k2 C O.1/,
P0 Qk1 C.1 3"/k2 .Qk1 C.1 3"/k2 1 jrj 1 2 /jrj 1 3 N Œ0 X
1 1 . /jrj
P0 Qk1 CC Pk .Qk1 C.1 3"/k2 1 jrj 2 3
N Œ0
kk1 CC
.
X
Pk Qk1 CC
1 jrj
1
2k Pk Qk1 CC
1 jrj
1
2
kk1 CC
.
X
2
0; XP k
kk1 CC
.
X
k
2 2
k k1 4
3 Y
k
1 2 ;1
0; 1 2 ;1
XP k
jrj
k
1
3 S Œk3
3 kS Œk3
i kS Œki
i D1
kk1 CC
which is admissible. If k2 < k1 C , then by the same lemmas,
P0 Qk1 C.1 3"/k2 .Qk1 C.1 3"/k2 1 jrj 1 2 /jrj 1 3 N Œ0
1 1 . P0 Q.1 3"/k2 CC PQk1 .Qk1 C.1 3"/k2 1 jrj 2 /jrj
. PQk1 Q.1 3"/k2 CC 1 jrj 1 2 0; 1 ;1 jrj 1 3 S Œk3 2 XP k
. 2k1 PQk1 Q.1 k1
.2 2
.1 3"/k2 4
k1
3"/k2 CC 3 Y
k
1 jrj
1
2
3
N Œ0
1 0; 1 2 ;1
XP k
k
3 kS Œk3
1
i kS Œki
i D1
which is again admissible. Finally, if k1 < k2 C , then arguing analogously yields
P0 Qk1 C.1 3"/k2 .Qk1 C.1 3"/k2 1 jrj 1 2 /jrj 1 3 N Œ0
. P0 Qk2 PQk2 .Qk1 C.1 3"/k2 1 jrj 1 2 /jrj 1 3 N Œ0
172
5 Trilinear estimates
. PQk2 Qk2
. 2k2 PQk2 Qk2 . 2k1
3 Y
k
2
1
1 jrj 1 jrj
1
2
0; 1 ;1 XP k 2 2
1 ;1 0; 2
XP k
1
jrj k
3 S Œk3
3 kS Œk3
2
i kS Œki
i D1
which concludes this case. Case 9: k2 D O.1/; max.k1 ; k3 / analysis of (5.48).
C. Symmetric to Case 8. This concludes the
Neither of the identities (5.44) or (5.45) applies to (5.49). Hence, (5.49) requires somewhat different arguments. Case 1: 0 k1 k2 C O.1/ D k3 C O.1/. As in (5.50) one sees that it suffices to consider 1 D Q0 1 . Then Q˛j D QC Q˛j and we split P0 I @ˇ IRˇ 1 1 @j I Q˛j .I 2 ; I X D P0 Q` C @ˇ Rˇ Q` C
3/
1
1
@j Q` Q˛j .I
2; I
3/
(5.64)
`C
X
C
P0 Q`1 @ˇ Rˇ Q`1
1
1
@j Q` Q˛j .I
2; I
3/
P0 Q<`2 @ˇ Rˇ Q`2
1
1
@j Q` Q˛j .I
2; I
3/
(5.65)
` C `1 C
X
C
: (5.66)
` C `2 C `
Decomposing (5.64) via Lemma 4.1 into caps of size 2 2 yields P0 Q` C @ˇ Rˇ Q` X D P0; Q`
C C@
1 ˇ
1
@j Q` Q˛j .I
Rˇ Q`
C Pk1 ; 0
2; I 1
3/ 1
@j Q` Q˛j .I
2; I
3/
0 2C `
2 `
where 0 denotes that these caps have distance about 2 2 . Hence we gain a factor of 2` from the null-form involving @ˇ and Rˇ . From (2.29) one now obtains X X
k(5.64)kN Œ0 .
P0; Q` C @ˇ `C
0 2C `
2
173
5.2 Trilinear estimates for hyperbolic S -waves
Rˇ Q` X
.
` 4
2` 2
2
C Pk1 ; 0
k1 X 2
1
1
@j Q` Q˛j .I
kPk1 ; Q`
C
2
Q` Q˛j . X
.
3`
242
k1 2
k
1 kS Œk1 2
k
i kS Œki :
k1 4C
2
k2 2
k
NFŒ
2 2k1 1 kS Œ 2
2C `
`C
21
2 / 3
2; I
21
2
2 ; 3 / L2 L2 t
x
2 kS Œk2 k 3 kS Œk3
`C k1
. 24
k2 2
3 Y i D1
Here we also used Lemma 2.7 as well as Lemma 4.17. The expressions in (5.65) `1
are decomposed into caps of size 2 2 but without separation. Therefore, with a gain of 2`1 from the outer null-form, X X
k(5.65)kN Œ0 .
P0; Q`1 @ˇ ` C `1 C
; 0 2C `1 2
Rˇ Q`1 Pk1 ; 0 1 1 @j Q` Q˛j .I X X `1
2 2
P0; Q`1 @ˇ
.
` C `1 C
2
P 0;
3/
2; I
3/
2
2
21
2; I
2 / 3 2
21
X0
1 2 ;1
; 0 2C `1 2
Rˇ Q`1 Pk1 ; 0 1 1 @j Q` Q˛j .I X X
P0; Q`1 @ˇ
.
` C `1 C
12
2; I
L t L2x
; 0 2C `1 2
Rˇ Q`1 Pk1 ; 0
1
1
@j Q` Q˛j .I
L t L1x
:
(5.67) To pass to (5.67) one invokes the improved Bernstein estimate of Lemma 2.1. Hence, this can be further bounded by .
X ` C `1 C
2`1
X 0 2C `1 2
kQ`1 Pk1 ; 0
2 1 kL1 L2 t
x
174
5 Trilinear estimates
21
2 Q` Q˛j .I 2 ; I 3 / L2 L2 t x 21 ` k1 2 2 k1 2 4C 1 kS Œk1 ; 0 2k1
2 X
.
2`1
X 0 2C
` C `1 C
kQ`1 Pk1 ; 0
`1 2
k2 2
2 k1 .2
k1 4
k2 2
3 Y
k
kQ` Q˛j .I
2; I
3 /kL2 L2x t
i kS Œki :
i D1
For (5.66) one proceeds similarly, performing a cap decomposition and placing the entire expression in L1t L2x . We skip the details. Case 2: 0 k1 D k3 C O.1/; k2 k3 C. This is essentially the same as the preceding with Lemma 4.23 replacing Lemma 4.17. Case 3: 0 k1 D k2 C O.1/; k3 k2
C. This is symmetric to the preceding.
Case 4: O.1/ k2 D k3 C O.1/; k1 C. This is very similar to Case 1. First, one checks that the entire output can be restricted by Qk1 . This implies that due to the I -operator in front of 1 , the decomposition (5.64)–(5.66) continues to hold but with ` k1 C C : P0 I @ˇ IRˇ 1 1 @j I Q˛j .I 2 ; I X D P0 Q` C @ˇ Rˇ Q`
3/ C
1
1
@j Q` Q˛j .I
2; I
3/
(5.68)
`k1 CC
C
X
P0 Q`1 @ˇ Rˇ Q`1
1
1
1
1
@j Q` Q˛j .I
2; I
3/
` C `1 k1 CC
C
X
ˇ
P0 Q<`2 @ Rˇ Q`2
(5.69) @j Q` Q˛j .I 2 ; I 3 / :
` C `2 k1 CC
(5.70) One can again decompose (5.68) into caps, but of size 2
X X
k(5.68)kN Œ0 .
P0; Q` C @ˇ `k1 CC
0 2C `
Rˇ Q`
` k1 2
. Therefore,
k1 2
C Pk1 ; 0
1
1
@j Q` PQ0 Q˛j .I
2; I
2
3/
NFŒ
21
175
5.2 Trilinear estimates for hyperbolic S -waves
X
.
2
3.` k1 / 4
k1 2
2
`k1 CC
X
kPk1 ; Q`
C
2
3 / L2 L2 t x
2
Q 1 kSŒ Q` P0 Q˛j . 2 ;
12
2C `
2
X
.
2
3.` k1 / 4
k1 2
2
k
1 kS Œk1 2
k2 2
k
2 kS Œk2 k 3 kS Œk3
`k1 CC
.2
k1 2
k2 2
3 Y
k
i kS Œki
i D1
which is admissible. Furthermore, k(5.69)kN Œ0 is bounded by
X
.
` C `1 k1 CC
; 0 2C `1
Rˇ Q`1 Pk1 ; 0 X `1 2 2
.
P0; Q`1 @ˇ
X 2
k1
1
1
@j Q` Q˛j .I 2 ; I
X
P0; Q`1 @ˇ
; 0 2C `1
` C `1 k1 CC
2
0 2C `1
` C `1 k1 CC
X0
1 2 ;1
12
k1
Rˇ Q`1 Pk1 ; 0 1 1 @j Q` Q˛j .I 2 ; I X X `1 2 2 k1 kQ`1 Pk1 ; 0
.
2 / 3 0; P
2
2 / 3 2
21
L t L2x
2 1 kL1 L1 x t
k1
12
2
2 ; I 3 / L2 L2 t x X `1 `1 k 1 222 4 kQ`1 Pk1 ; 0
Q` PQ0 Q˛j .I X
.
0 2C `1
` C `1 k1 CC
Q` PQ0 Q˛j .I .2
3k1 4C
k2 2
3 Y
k
2 1 kS Œk1 ; 0
21
`
2 4C
k2 2
k1
2
2 ; I 3 / L2 L2 t
x
i kS Œki :
i D1
Finally, (5.70) is similar to the previous estimate and we skip it. Case 5: O.1/ D k1 ; k2 D k3 C O.1/. We apply (5.55) and reduce the modulation
176 of
5 Trilinear estimates 1
via (5.56) to
1
D Qk
1.
Furthermore,
P0 @ˇ I Rˇ Qk 1 1 @j Pk I Q˛j . 2 ; 3 / D P0 I jrj 1 Qk 1 1 @j Pk I Q˛j . 2 ; C P0 I Rˇ Qk 1 1 @j @ˇ Pk I Q˛j . 2 ;
3/
(5.71)
3/ :
(5.72)
Lemmas 4.13 and 4.17 imply the following bound on (5.71):
X
P0 I jrj 1 Qk 1 1 @j Pk I Q˛j . 2 ;
3/
kk2 ^0CC
X
.
X
2
m k 4
jrj
1
Qm
1
kk2 ^0CC mk 1
X
.
2
.2
1 2 k2 _0
k
2;
1 2 ;1
0;
XP 0
3/
0; 1 2 ;1
XP k
i kS Œki
i D1
kk2 ^0CC 3 Y
3 Y
k k2 2
@j Pk I Q˛j .
N Œ0
k
i kS Œki
i D1
which is admissible. The second term (5.72) needs to be expanded as follows: 2Rˇ Qk 1 1 @j @ˇ Pk I Q˛j . 2 ; 3 / D Qk jrj 1 1 1 @j Pk I Q˛j . Qk jrj Qk jrj
1
1
2;
(5.73)
3/
1
1
@j Pk I Q˛j .
2;
3/
(5.74)
1
1
@j Pk I Q˛j .
2;
3 /:
(5.75)
We just dealt with the term (5.74). Since the modulation of the entire output is . 2k , one concludes that
X
(5.73) .
Qk jrj 1 1 1 @j Pk I Q˛j . 2 ; 3 / 0; 21 ;1 XP 0
kk2 ^0CC
.
X
k
22 k
1 kL1 L2x t
1
@j Pk I Q˛j .
2;
3 / L2 L1 t x
kk2 ^0CC
.
X kk2 ^0CC
2
k k2 2
3 Y i D1
k
i kS Œki . 2
1 2 k2 _0
3 Y i D1
k
i kS Œki
177
5.2 Trilinear estimates for hyperbolic S -waves
as well as, from Lemma 4.13, X
(5.75) .
Qk jrj
1
k
1
1
@j Pk I Q˛j .
2;
3 / N Œ0
kk2 ^0CC
X
.
1 kL1 L2x t
1
@j Pk I Q˛j .
2;
3/
X
.
2
3k k2 2
3 Y
k
i kS Œki
1 2 k2 _0
.2
i D1
kk2 ^0CC
3 Y
0;
XP 0
kk2 ^0CC
k
1 ;1 2
i kS Œki
i D1
which is sufficient. Case 6: O.1/ D k1 k2 C O.1/ k3 C C. As before, one reduces the modulation of 1 to 1 D Qk2 1 . Furthermore, P0 @ˇ I ŒRˇ Qk2 1 1 @j PQk2 I Q˛j . 2 ; 3 / D P0 I jrj 1 Qk2 1 1 @j PQk2 I Q˛j . C P0 I Rˇ Qk2 1 1 @j @ˇ PQk2 I Q˛j .
2;
3/
(5.76)
2; 3/ :
(5.77)
Lemmas 4.13 and 4.23 imply the following bound on (5.76):
P0 I jrj 1 Qk2 1 1 @j PQk2 I Q˛j . X m k2
2 4 jrj 1 Qm 1 0; . XP 0
mk2 1
. 2. 2
"/.k3 k2 /
3 Y
k
2; 1 2 ;1
3/
N Œ0
1
@j PQk2 I Q˛j .
2;
3/
1 ;1 0; 2
XP k
2
i kS Œki
i D1
which is admissible. The second term (5.77) needs to be expanded as follows: 1 @j @ˇ PQk2 I Q˛j . 2 ; 3 / D Qk2 jrj 1 1 1 @j PQk2 I Q˛j . 2 ; 3 / Qk2 jrj 1 1 1 @j PQk2 I Q˛j . 2 ; 3 / Qk2 jrj 1 1 1 @j PQk2 I Q˛j . 2 ; 3 /:
2Rˇ Qk2
1
(5.78) (5.79) (5.80)
We just dealt with the term (5.79). Since the modulation of the entire output
178
5 Trilinear estimates
is . 2k2 , one concludes that
(5.78) . Qk2 jrj .2
k2 2
k
1
1 kL1 L2x t
"/.k3 k2 /
. 2. 2
1
1
1 1
3 Y
k
@j PQk2 I Q˛j .
@j PQk2 I Q˛j .
i kS Œki .
i D1
3 Y
0;
XP 0
1 2 ;1
2;
k
/ 3
2;
3 / L2 L1 t x i kS Œki
i D1
as well as, from Lemma 4.13, 1
(5.80) . Qk jrj .k
1 kS Œk1 1
. 2. 2
1 1
"/.k3 k2 / k2
2
1
@j PQk2 I Q˛j .
@j PQk2 I Q˛j .
3 Y
k
2;
2;
3 / N Œ0
3/
1 2 ;1
0;
XP 0
i kS Œki
i D1
which concludes Case 6. Case 7: k1 D O.1/ k3 C O.1/ k2 C C. This case is symmetric to the previous one. Case 8: k3 D O.1/; max.k1 ; k2 / duced to Qk1 :
P0 @ˇ IQk1 Rˇ Qk1 .2 .2
k1 2
k1 2
C. The modulation of the output can be re-
1
1
1 k 1 kL1 t Lx
1
1
2. 2
"/k3
3 Y
k
@j PQ0 I Q˛j .
2;
3/
N Œ0
@j PQ0 I Q˛j . 2 ; 3 / L2 L2 t
x
i kS Œki :
i D1
Similarly, the input
1
can be reduced to Qk1
1.
As in Case 6,
P0 @ˇ Qk1 ŒRˇ Qk1 1 1 @j PQ0 Qk1 Q˛j . 2 ; 3 / D P0 Qk1 jrj 1 Qk1 1 1 @j PQ0 Qk1 Q˛j . C P0 Qk1 Rˇ Qk1 1 1 @j @ˇ PQ0 Qk1 Q˛j .
2;
3/
2; 3/ :
(5.81) (5.82)
179
5.2 Trilinear estimates for hyperbolic S -waves
Lemmas 4.13 and 4.23 imply the following bound on (5.81):
P0 Qk1 jrj 1 Qk1 1 1 @j PQ0 I Q˛j . 2 ; 3 /
N Œ0
.
X
2
m k1 4
1
jrj
Qm
1
mk1
.2
k1 2
1
2. 2
"/k2
3 Y
k
0; 1 ;1 XP k 2 1
PQ0 Qk Q˛j . 1
2;
3/
1 ;1 0; 2
XP 0
i kS Œki
i D1
which is admissible. The second term (5.82) needs to be expanded as follows: 1 @j @ˇ PQ0 I Q˛j . 2 ; 3 / D Qk1 jrj 1 1 1 @j PQ0 I Q˛j . 2 ; 3 / Qk1 jrj 1 1 1 @j PQ0 I Q˛j . 2 ; 3 / Qk1 jrj 1 1 1 @j PQ0 I Q˛j . 2 ; 3 /:
2Rˇ Qk1
1
We just dealt with the term (5.84). Next,
(5.83) . Qk1 Qk1 jrj 1 1 .2 .2
k1 2
k1 2
jrj
1
1
"/k3
2. 2
1 L1 L1 x t 3 Y
k
1
1
@j PQ0 I Q˛j .
@j PQ0 I Q˛j .
2;
2;
3/
(5.83) (5.84) (5.85)
0;
XP 0
1 2 ;1
3 / L2 L2 t x
i kS Œki
i D1
as well as, from Lemma 4.13,
(5.85) . Qk1 jrj 1 1 1 @j PQ0 Qk1 Q˛j . 2 ;
. k 1 kS Œk1 1 @j PQ0 Qk1 Q˛j . 2 ; 3 / .2
. 21 "/k3
2
k1 2
3 Y
k
3 / N Œ0 0;
XP 0
1 2 ;1
i kS Œki
i D1
which concludes Case 8. Case 9: k2 D O.1/; max.k1 ; k3 /
C. Symmetric to Case 8.
180
5 Trilinear estimates
Remark 5.6. It follows from the high-low-low interaction case of the proof of Lemma 5.5 that for some > 0,
ˇ 1 P I P I @ @ P I Q .P ; P /
0 1 j k1 k ˇj k2 2 k3 3 N Œ0
k
.2
w.k1 ; k2 ; k3 /
3 Y
k
i kS Œki
(5.86)
i D1
provided k1 D O.1/, k k2 D k3 C O.1/ O.1/. In effect, for later use, we also mention the following lemma, which is proved using identical reasoning: Lemma 5.7. Assume k1 D O.1/. Then we have the bounds
P0 IRˇ
1 @ˇ P k
1
@j Q˛j . 2 ; 3 /
N Œ0 k
.2
w.k1 ; k2 ; k3 /
3 Y
kPki
i kS Œki ;
i D1
P0 IRˇ
1 @˛ P k
1
@j Qˇj .
2;
3/
N Œ0
. 2 k w.k1 ; k2 ; k3 /
3 Y
kPki
i kS Œki
i D1
for suitable > 0.
5.3
Improved trilinear estimates with angular alignment
We conclude this section on trilinear bounds with a technical result which we shall require in several instances, such as the blow-up criterion of the following section. By Corollary 5.4, one gains extra smallness outside of the parameter range (5.43); note that the latter describes precisely Case 5 in the proof of Lemmas 5.1 and 5.5 which is the high-low-low case of interactions. In fact, the exact same gain as in that corollary can also be obtained for the trilinear expressions of Lemma 5.5. Corollary 5.8. The nonlinearities of Lemma 5.5 satisfy the estimates of Corollary 5.4. I.e., given ı > 0 there exist L; L0 large so that the ı-gains in the sum
181
5.3 Improved trilinear estimates with angular alignment
P P over 0k1 ;k2 ;k3 as well as 00k1 ;k2 ;k3 with k k2 types of trilinear null-forms in Lemma 5.5.
L0 , are obtained for the three
Proof. As in the case of Corollary 5.4, this follows from the form of the weights w.k1 ; k2 ; k3 / as well as from the fact that an extra gain in Case 5 of Lemma 5.5 was obtained when k < k2 L0 . However, one cannot gain smallness in the high-low-low case without further assumptions. In this section we shall prove that angular alignment between the Fourier support of at least two of the inputs implies smallness in this case. We start with the contributions by I c Qˇj . In Corollary 5.4 we isolated one case where smallness P00 cannot be obtained without any further assumptions.0 It was given by the sum k1 ;k2 ;k3 2Z over the range (5.43) together with k2 L k k2 C O.1/. Recall that L and L0 are very large depending on ı. Throughout this section, i will be Schwartz functions satisfying X max kPk i k2S Œk K 2 i D1;2;3
k2Z
for some constant K. We shall use defined earlier.
P00
k1 ;k2 ;k3 2Z
repeatedly in the sense that it was
Lemma 5.9. Given any ı > 0 there exists m0 .ı/ large and negative such that X 2 ;3 2Cm0 dist.2 ;3 /2m0
k2 CO.1/ X
X00 k1 ;k2 ;k3 2Z
2 X
P0 r t;x Pk1
1
kDk2 L0
1
@j I c Pk Qˇj .Pk2 ;2
2 ; Pk3 ;3
j D1
ı K 2 sup max 2 k2Z i D1;2;3
as well as X 1 ;2 2Cm0 dist.1 ;2 /2m0
X00 k1 ;k2 ;k3 2Z
k2 CO.1/ X kDk2 L0
3/
0 jkj
N Œ0
kPk
i kS Œk
182
5 Trilinear estimates 2 X
P0 r t;x Pk1 ;1
1
1
2 ; Pk3
/ 3
2 ; Pk3 ;3
/ 3
@j I c Pk Qˇj .Pk2 ;2
N Œ0
j D1
C
k2 CO.1/ X
X00
X
k1 ;k2 ;k3 2Z
1 ;3 2Cm0 dist.1 ;3 /2m0
2 X
P0 r t;x Pk1 ;1
1
kDk2 L0
1
@j I c Pk Qˇj .Pk2
N Œ0
j D1
ı K 2 sup max 2
0 jkj
k2Z i D1;2;3
kPk
i kS Œk :
Proof. The proof simply consists in verifying that the argument in Case 5 of Lemma 5.1 allows for this extra gain. We first consider angular alignment between 1 and 2 . In this case, we will need to repeat the argument of Case 5, obtaining the gain from Bernstein’s inequality. First, restrict the output by Q0 and assume that 1 D Pk1 ;1 1 and 2 D Pk2 ;2 2 with fixed caps 1 ; 2 . In the end, one verifies that it is possible to sum over these caps. Then
P0 Q0 @ˇ .
k2 CO.1/ X kDk2
C
1
1
@j I c Qˇj .
P0 Q0
1
1
2;
3/
N Œ0
@j QkC Pk Qˇj .
2;
/ 3
L0
k2 CO.1/ X
X
2
P0 Qm Qm
"m
C
1
1
(5.87)
L2t L2x
@j QQ m Pk Qˇj .
2;
kDk2 L0 mC
3/
L2t L2x
(5.88) C
k2 CO.1/ X kDk2
L0
X
P0 Q0 Q>m
C
1
1
@j QQ m Pk Qˇj .
2;
3/
mC
L2t L2x
:
(5.89) First, by Lemma 4.19, and with M large but finite and
(5.87) .
k2 CO.1/ X kDk2 L0
k
p 1 kL1 t Lx
QkC Pk Qˇj .
2;
1 p
C
1 M
D 12 ,
3 / L2 LM t x
183
5.3 Improved trilinear estimates with angular alignment
.
k2 CO.1/ X
1
2m0 . 2
1 p/
k
k
1 kL1 L2x
22 2
t
2 "k2 jk2 j M
2
k
2 kS Œk2 k 3 kS Œk3
kDk2 L0 3 Y
ı
k
i kS Œki :
i D1
Since p > 2 one can take m0 large and negative to obtain the final estimate here. Second, again by Lemma 4.19, (5.88) .
k2 CO.1/ X
X
2
"m
kDk2 L0 mC
P0 Qm Qm .
k2 CO.1/ X
X
2
"m
1
1 p/
k
1
1
C
p 1 kL1 t Lx
@j QQ m Pk Qˇj . 2
k
2;
QQ m Pk Qˇj .
3/
2;
3 / L2 LM t x
kDk2 L0 mC
.
k2 CO.1/ X
2m0 . 2
k
22 2
3 Y
2 "k2 jk2 j M
2
L0
kDk2
k
i kS Œki ı
i D1
L2t L2x
3 Y
k
i kS Œki
i D1
and third, (5.89) .
k2 CO.1/ X
X
kQ>m
C
2 1 kL2 Lp x t
k
QQ m Pk Qˇj .
2;
kDk2 L0 mC 2
. 2jk2 j M
k2 CO.1/ X
1
2m0 . 2
1 p/
kDk2 L0
X
2
.1 "/m
k
m
1 kS Œk1 2 2
mC
QQ m Pk Qˇj . m0 . 12
.2
1 p/
2
2 jk2 j M
3 / L1 LM x t
k2 CO.1/ X
X
2
. 12 2"/m
k
2;
1 kS Œk1 2
3 / L2 LM t x "m
kDk2 L0 mC
QQ m Pk Qˇj . ı
3 Y
k
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
i kS Œki
i D1
where one argues as in the previous two cases to pass to the last line. Next,
184
5 Trilinear estimates
suppose the output is limited by Q0 . Then
P0 Q0 @ˇ I c .
k2 CO.1/ X
1
1
@j I c Qˇj .
X
Qm
1
1
2;
3/
N Œ0
@j Pk QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 / L1 L2 t x
kDk2 L0 mC
.
k2 CO.1/ X L0
kDk2
.2
m0 . 21
X
kQm
1 kL2 Lp x t
k
2
kPk QQ m Qˇj .
2;
3 /kL2 LM x t
mC k2 CO.1/ X
1 p/
X
2
.1 2"/m
k
2 "m jk2 j M
1 kS Œk1 2
2
kDk2 L0 mC
Pk QQ m Qˇj . 1
. 2m0 . 2
k2 CO.1/ X
1 p/
kDk2
ı
3 Y
k
k
1 kS Œk1
k
22 2
2 "k2 jk2 j M
2
k
2;
3 / L2 L2 t x
2 kS Œk2 k 3 kS Œk3
L0
i kS Œki
i D1
which is again admissible. On the other hand, assume now that 1 as we may suppose that k D k2 C O.1/ D k3 C O.1/, we obtain
P0 Q0 @ˇ I 1 1 @j I c Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / N Œ0
ˇ 1 c P0 Q0 @ I 1 @j I Qˇj . 2 ; X
.
2
` 2
2
kQ<`
10
1 kL1 Lx
kQ`
10
1 kL1 L2x
t
/ 3
XP 0
1;
1 2 ;1
(5.90) D I 1 . Then,
CL1t HP
1
1 @j Q` Qˇj . 2 ; 3 / L2 L1 t
x
O.1/>`k2 CC1
X
C
2
` 2
t
1
@j Q` Qˇj .
2;
3 / L2 L1 t x
O.1/>`k2 CC1
C
X k2 CC <`
P0 Q0 @ˇ I
1
1
@j Q` Qˇj .
2;
3/
N Œ0
: (5.91)
Here we have chosen C1 large enough depending on ı, while C is as in the definition of I c . Then using Lemma 4.19, we infer that the first two amongst the last
185
5.3 Improved trilinear estimates with angular alignment
three preceding terms are bounded by .ı
3 Y
kPkj
j kS Œkj
j D1
and summation over the angular sectors/frequencies is straightforward to gi