COMPREHENSIVE CHIROPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY Volume 2
COMPREHENSIVE CHIROPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY Volume 2
Applications in Stere...
24 downloads
615 Views
16MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
COMPREHENSIVE CHIROPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY Volume 2
COMPREHENSIVE CHIROPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY Volume 2
Applications in Stereochemical Analysis of Synthetic Compounds, Natural Products, and Biomolecules
Edited by Nina Berova Prasad L. Polavarapu Koji Nakanishi Robert W. Woody
A JOHN WILEY & SONS, INC., PUBLICATION
Copyright © 2012 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc. All rights reserved Published by John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken, New Jersey Published simultaneously in Canada No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, scanning, or otherwise, except as permitted under Section 107 or 108 of the 1976 United States Copyright Act, without either the prior written permission of the Publisher, or authorization through payment of the appropriate per-copy fee to the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, (978) 750–8400, fax (978) 750–4470, or on the web at www.copyright.com. Requests to the Publisher for permission should be addressed to the Permissions Department, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 111 River Street, Hoboken, NJ 07030, (201) 748–6011, fax (201) 748–6008, or online at http://www.wiley.com/go/permission. Limit of Liability/Disclaimer of Warranty: While the publisher and author have used their best efforts in preparing this book, they make no representations or warranties with respect to the accuracy or completeness of the contents of this book and specifically disclaim any implied warranties of merchantability or fitness for a particular purpose. No warranty may be created or extended by sales representatives or written sales materials. The advice and strategies contained herein may not be suitable for your situation. You should consult with a professional where appropriate. Neither the publisher nor author shall be liable for any loss of profit or any other commercial damages, including but not limited to special, incidental, consequential, or other damages. For general information on our other products and services or for technical support, please contact our Customer Care Department within the United States at (800) 762–2974, outside the United States at (317) 572–3993 or fax (317) 572–4002. Wiley also publishes its books in a variety of electronic formats. Some content that appears in print may not be available in electronic formats. For more information about Wiley products, visit our web site at www.wiley.com. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data: Advances in chiroptical methods/edited by Nina Berova . . . [et al.]. p. cm. Includes index. ISBN 978-0-470-64135-4 (hardback : set)—ISBN 978-1-118-01293-2 (v. 1)—ISBN 978-1-118-01292-5 (v. 2) 1. Chirality. 2. Spectrum analysis. 3. Circular dichroism. I. Berova, Nina. QP517.C57A384 2012 541.7–dc23 2011021418 Printed in the United States of America 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
IN MEMORY OF CARLO ROSINI (1948–2010)
Carlo Rosini obtained his degree in Chemistry (1973) at the University of Pisa, where he completed his thesis on the stereochemistry of Ni(II) complexes. He entered the Italian CNR by joining the group of Professor Piero Salvadori and the research on determination of absolute configuration by Circular Dichroism. Later on, Carlo Rosini spent two years (1977–1979) at the King’s College in London, under the supervision of Professor Stephen F. Mason. During this period he studied polarized-light-based spectroscopy and its application to structural determinations. He was appointed as associate professor (1992) at the University of Pisa and then as a full professor (1997) at the University of Basilicata, Potenza. The field of chirality was fundamental to the scientific activity of Carlo Rosini. His broad scientific interests included many aspects of organic stereochemistry, like asymmetric organic synthesis, chiral discrimination mechanisms, chiral stationary phases for enantioselective chromatography, and structural characterization of organic molecules by Circular Dichroism. The last research projects of Carlo Rosini were oriented toward chemical/computational approaches for the determination of absolute configuration by linking experimental and theoretical studies. We miss his enthusiasm and his charisma, but we will remember his life and his contributions to the science and the chemical community. Carlo Rosini was one of the first scientists who accepted to contribute a chapter to this volume. Although his premature and tragic death prevented his submission, his spirit never died and is now, not only in the chapter contributed by his co-workers and former students, but also in the minds of all of us who had the privilege to know him and collaborate with him.
CONTENTS
PREFACE CONTRIBUTORS
PART I A HISTORICAL OVERVIEW
1
THE FIRST DECADES AFTER THE DISCOVERY OF CD AND ORD BY AIME´ COTTON IN 1895 Peter Laur
PART II ORGANIC STEREOCHEMISTRY
2
SOME INHERENTLY CHIRAL CHROMOPHORES—EMPIRICAL RULES AND QUANTUM CHEMICAL CALCULATIONS
xi xiii
1 3
37 39
Marcin Kwit, Pawel Skowronek, Jacek Gawronski, Jadwiga Frelek, Magdalena Woznica, and Aleksandra Butkiewicz
3
ELECTRONIC CD OF BENZENE AND OTHER AROMATIC CHROMOPHORES FOR DETERMINATION OF ABSOLUTE CONFIGURATION
73
Tibor Kurt´an, S´andor Antus, and Gennaro Pescitelli
4
ELECTRONIC CD EXCITON CHIRALITY METHOD: PRINCIPLES AND APPLICATIONS
115
Nobuyuki Harada, Koji Nakanishi, and Nina Berova
5
CD SPECTRA OF CHIRAL EXTENDED π -ELECTRON COMPOUNDS: THEORETICAL DETERMINATION OF THE ABSOLUTE STEREOCHEMISTRY AND EXPERIMENTAL VERIFICATION
167
Nobuyuki Harada and Shunsuke Kuwahara
vii
viii
CONTENTS
6
7 8
ASSIGNMENT OF THE ABSOLUTE CONFIGURATIONS OF NATURAL PRODUCTS BY MEANS OF SOLID-STATE ELECTRONIC CIRCULAR DICHROISM AND QUANTUM MECHANICAL CALCULATIONS Gennaro Pescitelli, Tibor Kurt´an, and Karsten Krohn DYNAMIC STEREOCHEMISTRY AND CHIROPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY OF METALLO-ORGANIC COMPOUNDS James W. Canary and Zhaohua Dai CIRCULAR DICHROISM OF DYNAMIC SYSTEMS: SWITCHING MOLECULAR AND SUPRAMOLECULAR CHIRALITY
217
251
289
Angela Mammana, Gregory T. Carroll, and Ben L. Feringa
9 10
11
ELECTRONIC CIRCULAR DICHROISM OF SUPRAMOLECULAR SYSTEMS Cheng Yang and Yoshihisa Inoue
317
THE ONLINE STEREOCHEMICAL ANALYSIS OF CHIRAL COMPOUNDS BY HPLC-ECD COUPLING IN COMBINATION WITH QUANTUM-CHEMICAL CALCULATIONS Gerhard Bringmann, Daniel G¨otz, and Torsten Bruhn
355
DETERMINATION OF THE STRUCTURES OF CHIRAL NATURAL PRODUCTS USING VIBRATIONAL CIRCULAR DICHROISM
387
Prasad L. Polavarapu
12
DETERMINATION OF MOLECULAR ABSOLUTE CONFIGURATION: GUIDELINES FOR SELECTING A SUITABLE CHIROPTICAL APPROACH
421
Stefano Superchi, Carlo Rosini, Giuseppe Mazzeo, and Egidio Giorgio
PART III INORGANIC STEREOCHEMISTRY
13
APPLICATIONS OF ELECTRONIC CIRCULAR DICHROISM TO INORGANIC STEREOCHEMISTRY
449 451
Sumio Kaizaki
PART IV BIOMOLECULES
14
ELECTRONIC CIRCULAR DICHROISM OF PROTEINS Robert W. Woody
473 475
ix
CONTENTS
15
ELECTRONIC CIRCULAR DICHROISM OF PEPTIDES Claudio Toniolo, Fernando Formaggio, and Robert W. Woody
499
16
ELECTRONIC CIRCULAR DICHROISM OF PEPTIDOMIMETICS
545
Claudio Toniolo and Fernando Formaggio
17
CIRCULAR DICHROISM SPECTROSCOPY OF NUCLEIC ACIDS Jaroslav Kypr, Iva Kejnovsk´a, Kl´ara Bedn´arˇ ov´a, and Michaela Vorl´ıcˇ kov´a
18
ELECTRONIC CIRCULAR DICHROISM OF PEPTIDE NUCLEIC ACIDS AND THEIR ANALOGUES
575
587
Roberto Corradini, Tullia Tedeschi, Stefano Sforza, and Rosangela Marchelli
19 20 21 22
23 24
CIRCULAR DICHROISM OF PROTEIN–NUCLEIC ACID INTERACTIONS Donald M. Gray
615
DRUG AND NATURAL PRODUCT BINDING TO NUCLEIC ACIDS ANALYZED BY ELECTRONIC CIRCULAR DICHROISM George A. Ellestad
635
PROBING HSA AND AGP DRUG-BINDING SITES BY ELECTRONIC CIRCULAR DICHROISM Mikl´os Simonyi
665
CONFORMATIONAL STUDIES OF BIOPOLYMERS, PEPTIDES, PROTEINS, AND NUCLEIC ACIDS. A ROLE FOR VIBRATIONAL CIRCULAR DICHROISM Timothy A. Keiderling and Ahmed Lakhani
707
STRUCTURE AND BEHAVIOR OF BIOMOLECULES FROM RAMAN OPTICAL ACTIVITY Laurence D. Barron and Lutz Hecht
759
OPTICAL ROTATION, ELECTRONIC CIRCULAR DICHROISM, AND VIBRATIONAL CIRCULAR DICHROISM OF CARBOHYDRATES AND GLYCOCONJUGATES
795
Tohru Taniguchi and Kenji Monde
25
ELECTRONIC CIRCULAR DICHROISM IN DRUG DISCOVERY Carlo Bertucci and Marco Pistolozzi
INDEX
819
843
PREFACE
Chirality is a phenomenon that is manifested throughout the natural world, ranging from fundamental particles through the realm of molecules and biological organisms to spiral galaxies. Thus, chirality is of interest to physicists, chemists, biologists, and astronomers. Chiroptical spectroscopy utilizes the differential response of chiral objects to circularly polarized electromagnetic radiation. Applications of chiroptical spectroscopy are widespread in chemistry, biochemistry, biology, and physics. It is indispensable for stereochemical elucidation of organic and inorganic molecules. Nearly all biomolecules and natural products are chiral, as are the majority of drugs. This has led to crucial applications of chiroptical spectroscopy ranging from the study of protein folding to characterization of small molecules, pharmaceuticals, and nucleic acids. The first chiroptical phenomenon to be observed was optical rotation (OR) and its wavelength dependence, namely, optical rotatory dispersion (ORD), in the early nineteenth century. Circular dichroism associated with electronic transitions (ECD), currently the most widely used chiroptical method, was discovered in the mid-nineteenth century, and its relationship to ORD and absorption was elucidated at the end of the nineteenth century. Circularly polarized luminescence (CPL) from chiral crystals was observed in the 1940s. The introduction of commercial instrumentation for measuring ORD in the 1950s and ECD in the 1960s led to a rapid expansion of applications of these forms of chiroptical spectroscopy to various branches of science, and especially to organic and inorganic chemistry and to biochemistry. Until the 1970s, chiroptical spectroscopy was confined to the study of electronic transitions, but vibrational transitions became accessible with the development of vibrational circular dichroism (VCD) and Raman optical activity (ROA). Other major extensions of chiroptical spectroscopy include differential ionization of chiral molecules by circularly polarized light (photoelectron CD), measurement of optical activity in the X-ray region, magnetochiral dichroism, and nonlinear forms of chiroptical spectroscopy. The theory of chiroptical spectroscopy also goes back many years, but has recently made spectacular advances. Classical theories of optical activity were formulated in the early twentieth century, and the quantum mechanical theory of optical rotation was described in 1929. Approximate formulations of the quantum mechanical models were developed in the 1930s and more extensively with the growth of experimental ORD and ECD studies, starting in the late 1950s. The quantum mechanical methods for calculations of chiroptical spectroscopic properties reached a mature stage in the 1980s and 1990s. Ab initio calculations of VCD, ECD, ORD, and ROA have proven highly successful and are now widely used for small and medium-sized molecules. Many books have been published on ORD, ECD, and VCD/ROA. The present two volumes are the first comprehensive treatise covering the whole field of chiroptical spectroscopy. Volume 1 covers the instrumentation, methodologies, and theoretical xi
xii
P R E FA C E
simulations for different chiroptical spectroscopic methods. In addition to an extensive treatment of ECD, VCD, and ROA, this volume includes chapters on ORD, CPL, photoelectron CD, X-ray-detected CD, magnetochiral dichroism, and nonlinear chiroptical spectroscopy. Chapters on the related techniques of linear dichroism, chiroptical imaging of crystals and electro-optic absorption, which sometimes supplement chiroptical interpretations, are also included. The coverage of theoretical methods is also extensive, including simulation of ECD, ORD, VCD, and ROA spectra of molecules ranging from small molecules to macromolecules. Volume 2 describes applications of ECD, VCD, and ROA in the stereochemical analysis of organic and inorganic compounds and to biomolecules such as natural products, proteins, and nucleic acids. The roles of chiroptical methods in the study of drug mechanisms and drug discovery are described. Thus, this work is unique in presenting an extensive coverage of the instrumentation and techniques of chiroptical spectroscopy, theoretical methods and simulation of chiroptical spectra, and applications of chiroptical spectroscopy in inorganic and organic chemistry, biochemistry, and drug discovery. In each of these areas, leading experts have provided the background needed for beginners, such as undergraduates and graduate students, and a state-of-the-art treatment for active researchers in academia and industry. We are grateful to the contributors to these two volumes who kindly accepted our invitations to contribute and who have met the challenges of presenting accessible, up-to-date treatments of their assigned topics in a timely fashion. Nina Berova Prasad L. Polavarapu Koji Nakanishi Robert W. Woody
CONTRIBUTORS
S´andor Antus, University of Debrecen, Research Group for Carbohydrates of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Debrecen, Hungary Laurence D. Barron, Department of Chemistry, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, United Kingdom Kl´ara Bedn´arˇ ov´a, Institute of Biophysics, Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic, v.v.i., Brno, Czech Republic Nina Berova, Department Chemistry, Columbia University, New York, New York, USA Carlo Bertucci, Department of Pharmaceutical Sciences, University of Bologna, Bologna, Italy Gerhard Bringmann, Institute of Organic Chemistry, University of W¨urzburg, W¨urzburg, Germany Torsten Bruhn, Institute of Organic Chemistry, University of W¨urzburg, W¨urzburg, Germany Aleksandra Butkiewicz, Polish Academy of Sciences, Institute of Organic Chemistry Warsaw, Poland James W. Canary, Department of Chemistry, New York University, New York, New York, USA Gregory T. Carroll, Chemical Sciences Division, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, California, USA Roberto Corradini, Department of Organic and Industrial Chemistry, University of Parma, Parma, Italy Zhaohua Dai, Department of Chemistry and Physical Sciences, Pace University, New York, New York, USA George A. Ellestad, Department of Chemistry, Columbia University, New York, New York, USA Ben L. Feringa, Stratingh Institute for Chemistry, University of Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands Fernando Formaggio, Department of Chemistry, University of Padova, Padova, Italy Jadwiga Frelek, Polish Academy of Sciences, Institute of Organic Chemistry, Warsaw, Poland Jacek Gawronski, Department of Chemistry, A. Mickiewicz University, Poznan, Poland Egidio Giorgio, Department of Chemistry, University of Basilicata, Potenza, Italy xiii
xiv
CONTRIBUTORS
Daniel G¨otz, Institute of Organic Chemistry, University of W¨urzburg, W¨urzburg, Germany Donald M. Gray, Department of Molecular and Cell Biology, The University of Texas at Dallas, Richardson, Texas, USA Nobuyuki Harada, Institute of Multidisciplinary Research for Advanced Materials, Tohoku University, Sendai, Japan Lutz Hecht, Department of Chemistry, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, United Kingdom Yoshihisa Inoue, Department of Applied Chemistry, Osaka University, Suita, Japan Sumio Kaizaki, Department of Chemistry, Graduate School of Science, Osaka University, Osaka, Japan Timothy A. Keiderling, Department of Chemistry, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, Illinois, USA Iva Kejnovsk´a, Institute of Biophysics, Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic, v.v.i., Brno, Czech Republic Karsten Krohn, Department of Chemistry, University of Paderborn, Paderborn, Germany Tibor Kurt´an, Department of Organic Chemistry, University of Debrecen, Debrecen, Hungary Shunsuke Kuwahara, Department of Chemistry, Toho University, Funabashi, Japan Marcin Kwit, Department of Chemistry, A. Mickiewicz University, Poznan, Poland Jaroslav Kypr, Institute of Biophysics, Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic, v.v.i., Brno, Czech Republic Ahmed Lakhani, Department of Chemistry, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, Illinois, USA Peter Laur, Institute of Inorganic Chemistry, RWTH Aachen University, Aachen, Germany Angela Mammana, Department of Chemistry, University of Dayton, Dayton, Ohio, USA Rosangela Marchelli, Department of Organic and Industrial Chemistry, University of Parma, Parma, Italy Giuseppe Mazzeo, Department of Chemistry, University of Basilicata, Potenza, Italy Kenji Monde, Faculty of Advanced Life Science, Frontier Research Center for Postgenome Science and Technology, Hokkaido University, Sapporo, Japan Koji Nakanishi, Department of Chemistry, Columbia University, New York, New York, USA Gennaro Pescitelli, Department of Chemistry and Industrial Chemistry, University of Pisa, Pisa, Italy Marco Pistolozzi, Department of Pharmaceutical Sciences, University of Bologna, Bologna, Italy
CONTRIBUTORS
Prasad L. Polavarapu, Department of Chemistry, Vanderbilt University, Nashville, Tennessee, USA Carlo Rosini, (deceased) Department of Chemistry, University of Basilicata, Potenza, Italy Stefano Sforza, Department of Organic and Industrial Chemistry, University of Parma, Parma, Italy Mikl´os Simonyi, Chemical Research Center, Department of Molecular Pharmacology, Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Budapest, Hungary Pawel Skowronek, Department of Chemistry, A. Mickiewicz University, Poznan, Poland Stefano Superchi, Department of Chemistry, University of Basilicata, Potenza, Italy Tohru Taniguchi, Faculty of Advanced Life Science, Frontier Research Center for Postgenome Science and Technology, Hokkaido University, Sapporo, Japan Tullia Tedeschi, Department of Organic and Industrial Chemistry, University of Parma, Parma, Italy Claudio Toniolo, Department of Chemistry, University of Padova, Padova, Italy Michaela Vorl´ıcˇ kov´a, Institute of Biophysics, Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic, v.v.i., Brno, Czech Republic Robert W. Woody, Department of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, Colorado, USA Magdalena Woznica, Polish Academy of Sciences, Institute of Organic Chemistry, Warsaw, Poland Cheng Yang, Department of Applied Chemistry, Osaka University, Suita, Japan
xv
a
c
o
Projection along b-axis
Figure 5.38. Absolute stereostructure of the C60 fullerene cis-3 bisadduct (R,R,f,s A)-[CD(+)280]-32 (top) and projection along b-axis (bottom). (Redrawn from reference 54, with permission.)
(a)
(b)
(c)
Figure 8.1. Dynamic chirality at the molecular and supramolecular level detected by CD spectroscopy. (a) A chiral molecule can direct achiral molecules to self-assemble into chiral supramolecular structures. (b) A chiral molecular switch or motor undergoes conformational changes that include inversion of molecular helicity. (c) Chiral molecules can self-assemble into chiral supramolecular structures, the chirality of which is determined by the enantiomer in excess.
S
Rotor Axle Stator O
Legs
O O
O
n
n S
S
Au Surface
2 CD (mdeg)
hν
0 –2
hν
200
240
280
320
λ (nm)
Figure 8.6. Assembly of thiol-terminated light-driven rotary molecular motors on a semitransparent gold film provides a monolayer of chiroptical material that can be analyzed with CD spectroscopy. The CD signals invert between positive and negative bands, corresponding to changes in the helicity of the molecules comprising the monolayer upon the application of photons and thermal energy. The initial spectrum (solid black) inverts (dotted black) after irradiation with UV light (λmax = 365 nm) at room temperature. After heating the surface (70◦ C, 2 h) the spectrum inverts again to restore the original (solid gray). A second dosage of photons inverts the signal (dotted gray). Heating brings the rotors back to the original orientation relative to the substrate [30].
UV O NH N2N
S
S
O
DET-4o
O NH
Vis
HN NH2
H2N
+
S
S
O HN NH2
DET-4c
DET-4o
–
+ –
dG
dC
Figure 8.18. A photoswitchable chiroptical DNA complex. At the top is shown the photoequilibrium between the open (DET-4o) and closed (DET- 4c) forms of a dithienylethene molecular switch that contains pendant ammonium groups to confer water solubility and allow the switches to bind electrostatically to the polyanionic backbone of DNA when the amine is protonated. Photochemical ring closure was accomplished through the use of a UV lamp (λmax = 365 nm) using a 340-nm cutoff filter. Photochemical ring opening was performed with visible light using ® a 520-nm cutoff filter. Molecular models (created using Hyperchem ) show that the distance between the terminal ammonium functionalities closely resembles the distance between the anionic phosphate groups of a guanosine (G)–cytosine (c) base pair [58].
Interface
Interface
Compression
M-Chiral
Compression
Achiral
P-Chiral
Figure 8.24. A supramolecular chiroptical switch composed of achiral amphiphiles. Space-filling structures of achiral amphiphile (TARC18), which forms a Langmuir–Schaefer film at the air–water interface, and chiral supramolecular structures formed upon interface compression. (Reprinted by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc. [66].)
OR
complexation N
I
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
NOH
N OH
N mutarotation of glucose
N
N
42a: R = (C2H4O)8CH3 42b: R = n-C4H9
complexation
N
N
n
42
N
N
N
N
N OH
N N N
OH
left-handed helical complex
right-handed helical complex
Figure 9.24. Chiral self-aggregation of achiral polymer induced by a saccharide. (Reprinted with permission from reference 80. Copyright Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA.)
3 MeOH / water 5:1 6:1 7:1 CD/(mdeg)
CD/(mdeg)
2
1
0
–1 300
8
8:1 9:1 10:1 310
320
330
340
350
360
6 β-glucose +7 +2.4 mdeg 4 (337 nm) 2
time 0h 1h 3h 8h 15 h 24, 48 h 15, 24, 48 h 8h
0
5h 3h α-glucose –2 –3 +2.4 mdeg 1h 0h (337 nm) –4 300 310 320 330 340 350 360
λ (nm)
λ (nm)
(a)
(b)
Figure 9.25. (a) Induced CD spectra of a mixture of 42a (1mM in monomer unit) and D-glucose (0.3M) in 5:1–10:1 MeOH/H2 O at 25◦ C. (b) Time-dependent CD spectra of a mixture of 42a (1mM in monomer unit) and α- or β-D-glucose (0.3M) in 5:1 MeOH/H2 O at 25◦ C. (Reprinted with permission from reference 80. Copyright Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA.)
(a)
(b)
Figure 12.6. Exciton chirality defined by the allowed B naphthalene and S = O transitions in 1
(a) E-conformer of (S)-8 and (b) Z-conformer of (S)-9.
0.05 0
Δε
−0.05 Nd
−0.15
ν −0.25 14.00
(103 cm−1) 16.00
18.00
20.00
0.3 MI
Δε
0 −0.3 −0.6 −0.9 20.00
Ln Ho -SAPR-8-C4(llll)-M[Ln(+)-(hfbc)4] with an encapsulated alkali metal ion
ν (103 cm−1) 21.00
22.00
23.00
24.00
25.00
0.04
Δε
0 −0.04 −0.08 −0.12
ν (103 cm−1)
Er
−0.16 12.00 14.00 16.00 18.00 20.00 22.00 24.00
Figure 13.6. CD spectra in the hypersensitive 4f –4f transitions of Cs[Ln((+)-hfbc)4] in CHCl3 (left) and the proposed structure in solution (right).
200
Δε
100 0 −100 −200 250
300 λ (nm)
350
Figure 13.9. Exciton CD spectra of M[La((+)-hfbc)4 ] in CHCl3 . M: Cs (red), Rb (green), K (blue), Na (black).
Internuclear (net effect) Intranuclear (Ln end) Intranuclear (Cr end)
Δε (M−1cm−1)
50
CrIII
LnIII 0
N
N
−50
N
N
N
N
L2 275
300
375 325 350 Wavelength/nm
400
425
O N
Figure 13.10. Right: Structure of the ligand L2(below) and -[LnIII CrIII (L2)3 ]6+ (above). Left: Schematic vertical lines summering the dominant coupling effects in the CD spectra of -LnIII CrIII (L2)3 ]6+ . The black line corresponds to the CD spectrum of -[GdCr(III)(L2)3 ]6+ in CH3 CN.
10 8 6 4 Ellipticity (mdeg)
2 0 –2 –4 B-DNA hZαADAR1 yabZαE3L IsZαE3L orfZαE3L spZαE3L vZαE3L
–6 –8 –10 –12 –14 –16 230
240
250
260
270
280
290
300
310
320
2800
3200
3600
Wavelength (nm) (a) 6
Ellipticity (mdeg) at 255 nm
4 2 0 hZαADAR1 yabZαE3L IsZαE3L orfZαE3L spZαE3L vZαE3L
–2 –4 –6 –8 –10 0
400
800
1200
1600
2000
2400
Time (sec) (b)
Figure 19.1. (a) CD spectra of poly[d(G–C)] in the B form and in the presence of Zα domains from human ADAR1 editing enzyme (hZα), yaba-like disease virus (yabZα), lumpy skin disease virus (lsZα), orf virus (orfZα), swinepox virus (spZα), and vaccinia virus (vZα), listed in decreasing order of their abilities to convert B-DNA to Z-DNA. CD spectra of the added proteins contributed the negative signals at wavelengths shorter than about 250 nm. (b) Kinetics of the B to Z conversion in the presence of the same domains. Proteins were added to poly[d(G–C)] at a protein to base-pair ratio of 0.4 (with the final protein concentration being 90 μM), in a buffer of 10 mM HEPES, pH 7.4, 10 mM NaCl, and 0.1 mM EDTA, except for yabZα where the buffer included 100 mM NaCl. Spectra were taken at 25◦ C using a 2-mm-pathlength cell. CD values are in mdeg ellipticity. (Reproduced from Quyen et al. [6] by permission of Oxford University Press, copyright 2007.)
θ (mdeg)
5
0
–5
Sp1ZF6 (ER)4 + [2GC (10)] Sp1ZF6 (KE)4 + [2GC (10)] Sp1ZF6 (G4S)4 + [2GC (10)] Free [2GC (10)]
–10 200
220
240
260
280
300
320
Wavelength (nm)
Figure 19.8. CD spectra of a DNA containing two GC-box sequences separated by a 10-bp spacer, 2GC(10), complexed with each of three peptides containing six zinc fingers but with different linkers between zinc fingers 3 and 4: Sp1ZF6(ER)4 with linker (Glu–Ala–Ala–Ala–Arg)4 , Sp1ZF6(KE)4 with linker (Lys–Ala–Ala–Glu–Ala)4 , and Sp1ZF6(G4 S)4 with linker (Gly–Gly–Gly–Gly–Ser)4 . Spectra were taken at 20◦ C using a 1-mm-pathlength cell. Samples contained 4.5 μM peptide–DNA complex in 10 mM Tris–HCl (pH 8.0), 50 mM NaCl, 0.005% Nonidet P-40, and 1 mM dithiothreitol. CD values are mdeg ellipticity. (Reprinted with permission from Yan et al. [42], ©2005, American Chemical Society)
B-DNA
A-DNA
Z-DNA
Binding modes minor groove binding
major groove minor groove
major groove
intercalation
minor groove
Figure 20.1. Representation of the three principal secondary structures of DNA. The right¨ handed A and B form are obtained from standard parameters within the Schrodinger–Maestro graphical interface. The thinner and more elongated Z form is obtained from X-ray parameters of a hexamer as imported from the protein data bank (PDB). In this representation, three units of the hexamer are stacked in order to display the overall left-handed zig-zag helicity. The structure on the far right depicts drug–DNA double-helix interactions with the drug colored black: minor groove binding (top) and intercalation between base pairs (bottom).
Figure 21.1. Binding sites are indicated by specific ligands in white, warfarin (Site I, right-hand side) and diazepam (Site II, left-hand side). (Reprinted with permission from reference 3, copyright 1996, Elsevier.)
Cleft Thyroxine 5 2°: lodipamide
IIIB FA 5 Thyroxine 2,3 2° : Oxyphenbutazone 2° : Propofol
IIIA: Drug Site 2 FA 3, 4 Thyroxine 4 Diflunisal Diazeapam Halothane Ibuprofen Indoxyl sulphate Propofol 2° : CMPF
IB FA 1 Hemin 2° : Azapropazone 2° : Indomethacin 2° : TIB
FA 2 IIA: Drug Site 1 FA 7 Thyroxine 1 Azapropazone CMPF DIS Indomethacin Iodipamide Oxyphenbutazone IIA-IIB Phenylbutazone FA 6 2° : Diflunisal TIB 2° : Halothane Warfarin 2° : Ibuprofen 2° Indoxyl sulphate 3° Diflunisal
Figure 21.2. Ligand-binding capacity of HSA defined by crystallographic studies. (Reprinted with permission from reference 9, copyright 2005, Elsevier.)
Figure 21.16. Mutual positions of quercetin (molecular modeling 48) and warfarin (X ray [8]) in the cavity of Site I subdomain IIA. (Reprinted with permission from reference 48, copyright 2003, Elsevier.)
IB
IA
IIIB
site II IIA site I
IIIA
IIB
Figure 21.21. X-ray crystallographic structure of HSA [8] with curcumin molecules localized by docking. Subdomains are indicated. (Reprinted with permission from reference 55, copyright 2003, Elsevier.)
1 5
7 2 4 3 6 C16:0
Figure 21.37. Structure of HSA complexed with seven palmitic acid molecules. (Reprinted with permission from reference 105, copyright 2000, Elsevier.)
(a)
(b)
Figure 21.38. Conformational changes in warfarin binding (Site I) as a result of fatty acid binding. (a) Helices h2 and h3 are shown by light shades for defatted and by dark shades for myristate bound HSA. (Reprinted with permission from reference 8, copyright 2001, American Society for Biochemistry and Molecular Biology.) (b) The volume of Site I in defatted HSA is depicted by a light brown semitransparent surface that becomes expanded upon myristate binding (blue semitransparent surface), the red arrows point to structural changes associated with fatty acid binding. (Reprinted with permission from reference 9, copyright 2005, Elsevier.)
Figure 21.40. Two crocetin molecules fitted to FA3 and FA4 sites; the negative exciton dictates the horizontal crocetin molecule to be behind the slanting one. (Reprinted with permission from reference 108, copyright 2001, Elsevier.)
(a)
(b)
Figure 21.41. Electrostatic potentials of genetic variants. (a) lysophospholipid ligand binding at the surface of variant F1-S. (b) variant a. (Reprinted with permission from reference 124, copyright 2006, ACS.)
Figure 21.55. Preferred conformer of diazepam docked into the crystal structure of AGP F1. Hydrogen bonds of the carbonyl oxygen to Glu64 and Gln66, as well as contacts of the ring nitrogens with Arg90 and Tyr127, are indicated. (Reprinted with permission from reference 125, copyright 2008, Elsevier.)
HR1-25
40
Millidegrees
20 10
Millidegrees
30
HR2-25
10
0% TFE 2.5% TFE 5% TFE 7.5% TFE 10% TFE 12.5% TFE 15% TFE
0
0 0% TFE 2.5% TFE 5% TFE 7.5% TFE 10% TFE 12.5% TFE 15% TFE
–10
–10 –20
–20
–30 200
210
220 230 240 Wavelength (nm)
250
200
260
210
220
230
240
1:1 Mixture 10
0% TFE 2.5% TFE 5% TFE 7.5% TFE 10% TFE 12.5% TFE 15% TFE
20 5
0 0% TFE 2.5% TFE 5% TFE 7.5% TFE 10% TFE 12.5% TFE 15% TFE
–10 –20 –30 –40 220
230
240
250
260
Millidegrees
Millidegrees
10
210
260
Difference Spectra
30
200
250
Wavelength (nm)
0
–5
–10 200
210
Wavelength (nm)
220 230 240 Wavelength (nm)
250
260
Figure 25.9. CD spectra of HR1–C25, HR2–C25, and their 1:1 mixture: [peptide] 50 μM, PBS, pH7.4, TFE as the co-solvent (0%, 2.5%, 5%, 7.5%, 10%, 12.5%, 15%). Difference CD spectra as a function of TFE concentration (0%, 2.5%, 5%, 7.5%, 10%, 12.5%, 15%) is also depicted. The difference CD spectra are calculated subtracting the two individual peptide spectra from those of the mixture. (Reproduced with permission from reference 69.)
PART I A HISTORICAL OVERVIEW
1 THE FIRST DECADES AFTER THE DISCOVERY OF CD AND ORD BY AIME´ COTTON IN 1895 Peter Laur
1.1. SCOPE: SUBJECTS AND TIME FRAME TO BE REVIEWED The story of the Cotton effect begins with its discovery in 1895. Although the news was hailed by leading physicists and chemists, studies to extend, exploit, and apply Cotton’s findings developed at a slower pace than one might have anticipated. One of the reasons for this delay was simply the necessity of the researchers to construct their own optical apparatus. Gradual technical improvements eventually allowed one, in the 1920s, to take chiroptical measurements in the ultraviolet as well as the visible, thus making accessible in principle a great many Cotton effects in colorless (mostly organic) compounds. Despite the paramount importance of such developments, neither the technical details nor the physics involved will be discussed in the following. Rather, a chemist’s view will prevail, paying attention chiefly to experimental results and the application of chiroptics to chemical problems. Since much of the work during the first 20 or so years after Cotton’s discovery was done by physicists and physicochemists, it is not surprising that many investigations were interconnected with or even motivated by the concomitant progress of the theory of optical activity. But also the discussion of this part of (theoretical) physics will be curtailed in the following. The exclusion in this chapter appears justified, because various comprehensive reviews are readily available, as they are for the field of optical instrumentation. By about 1935, Cotton effect measurements were possible with most organic and inorganic chromophores. It is rather surprising that not much use was made of the chiroptical techniques, especially by organic chemists. On the other hand, physical chemists had demonstrated the feasibility of Cotton effect studies in various classes of chemical compounds, but seemed satisfied with this result. Likewise, the advancement of optical Comprehensive Chiroptical Spectroscopy, Volume 2: Applications in Stereochemical Analysis of Synthetic Compounds, Natural Products, and Biomolecules, First Edition. Edited by N. Berova, P. L. Polavarapu, K. Nakanishi, and R. W. Woody. © 2012 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Published 2012 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
3
4
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
instruments for chiroptical measurements slowed down. All this led to a certain climax of chiroptical studies in the early 1930s, to be followed by a near standstill. It is not unreasonable to symbolically connect this phenomenon with the death in 1936 of T. M. Lowry, one of the most active scholars in the field. Arguably, the death of T. M. Lowry ended the first, pioneering period of chiroptical studies. The present chapter will concentrate on reviewing these first “historical” decades. Some work on the experimental study of the Cotton effect continued after 1936 until World War II on a minor scale, on, for example, organic compounds (S. Mitchell) or platinum complexes (I. Lifschitz). But at exactly the same time, new developments took place in the theory of optical activity and its application to chemical problems: Werner Kuhn’s calculation of the absolute configuration of lactic acid in 1935 rang in a new era. The waning interest of the experimentalists contrasts with the increased activity of theoretical chemists like J. G. Kirkwood, E. U. Condon, H. Eyring, or W. Kauzmann, who in the late 1930s advanced different models of optical activity. Still, chemistry had to wait for the period of 1950–1960 for a revitalization of chiroptics. Some reasons for the animation are: (1) the development of X-ray scattering methods for the determination of the absolute configuration, thus anchoring the stereochemistry unambiguously, following J. M. Bijvoet’s seminal publication of 1951; (2) the advent of new, commercially available measuring devices of ORD and CD; and (3) growing interest in natural products chemistry and, generally, optically active systems. But to discuss these topics would need another chapter.
1.2. EARLY CHIROPTICAL STUDIES The discovery of optical activity is credited to the two distinguished French mathematicians, physicists, astronomers, and geodesists (and more) Dominique-Franc¸ois Jean Arago (1786–1853, of Catalan origin) and Jean-Baptiste Biot (1774–1862) [1]. Arago and Biot had been closely associated at least since 1806 in the pursuit of other scientific subjects, and they sometimes published together. Both investigated the optical activity of quartz, and apparently they also shared their equipment to some extent. If, on the one hand, Arago was the first to go into print, Biot, on the other hand, soon became more active in this field and extended the studies. He undoubtedly observed optical activity for the first time in organic compounds such as natural oils and terpenes, or solutions of camphor [2] and cane sugar [3]. Biot continued his research on optical activity throughout his life, later concentrating particularly on tartaric acid. He noticed the wavelength dependence of the optical rotation even at the very beginning of his studies, albeit in a rather qualitative way. Whereas eventually the rotatory dispersion of quartz could be elucidated satisfactorily (which led to Biot’s law, stating that the rotation is inversely proportional to the square of the wavelength), similar solution studies were seriously impeded by experimental deficiencies, particularly the lack of suitable monochromatic light sources. Genuine chiroptical studies were, therefore, rather infrequent until the end of the nineteenth century. One of the most important papers here is a report by the Norwegian physicist Adam Arndtsen, who discussed his studies of aqueous solutions of (+)-tartaric acid [4]. Using sunlight, he was able to visually determine the angle of rotation at some of the principal Fraunhofer lines, that is, C (656), D (589), E (527), b (517), F (486), and e (438 nm). He could confirm and extend Biot’s earlier finding that the rotation exhibits a maximum in the spectral region studied, with its wavelength shifting from the
T H E F I R S T D E C A D E S A F T E R T H E D I S C O V E RY
blue to the red on increasing concentration. This unexpected and intriguing result led the Swiss chemist Hans Landolt (an important pioneer of the investigation and application of optical activity, as well as one of the “fathers” of Physical Chemistry) in 1877 to introduce the expression “anomale Rotationsdispersion” (anomalous rotation dispersion) [5], which since has become established for the description of such rotatory dispersion curves that run through a maximum or minimum, or show a reversal of sign. It had thus become apparent that spectropolarimetry promised to develop into an interesting field in the future. In his last and comprehensive paper on optical activity, Biot [6] suggested, therefore (translation from the French by the present author): I should like to draw the attention of experimentalists to a class of phenomena which, hitherto, has been little studied but which, nevertheless, for both theoretical and practical purposes, ranks in importance with that of the optical rotatory power itself of which it is a constituent element. I refer to the specific mode of dispersion that each optically active substance or compound imparts to plane polarized light of different wavelengths [literally: refrangibility].
Despite this exhortation, reports on rotatory dispersion remained scarce until the end of the century. This is also evident from the very first book on optical activity, where all data known at that time are summarized, which was published in Germany in 1879 by Landolt [7]. Here, he also describes in detail the optical equipment used by himself and his predecessors. Therefore, it is not necessary to dwell at this point on the measuring devices and optical methods. Although most of the rotations listed (many of which had been determined or redetermined by Landolt himself) refer to the sodium D line only, his book also has short sections on normal and anomalous rotatory dispersion. It is important to realize that so far all reported optically active liquids or solutions were based on organic compounds without absorption bands in the visible. In fact, Landolt emphasized that there is not a single inorganic substance known which shows optical activity in solution (or in the gas phase), from which he tentatively—but incorrectly—concluded that optical activity might be restricted to carbon compounds, except for the solid phase. Surprisingly, he gave no reference to any optically active transition metal complex, although at least Fehling’s solution (a mixture of several Cu(II) tartrate complexes) had been around since 1848 [8]. One might speculate whether such coordination compounds (of a still unknown nature) were ignored as a result of theoretical considerations. It should also be mentioned that measurements in general were limited to practically colorless samples and to merely certain frequencies of the visual solar spectrum. The only other reasonably monochromatic light sources available were based on lithium, sodium, and thallium salts heated in a Bunsen burner (invented in 1866), giving access to the wavelengths 671 nm (Li), 589 nm (Na), and 535 nm (Tl), respectively. It is worthwhile to briefly turn to the “anomalous” refractive dispersion using unpolarized light—that is, the characteristic sigmoidal variation of the index of refraction in the absorption region, running through a maximum and minimum, instead of steadily increasing as the wavelength decreases, as in normal dispersion. This behavior had been discovered in iodine vapor in 1862 by the French physicist F.-P. Leroux [9], and around 1870 it attracted the attention of several investigators, who published independently on anomalous dispersion in the visible, using solutions of organic dyes like fuchsine [10]. There was some dispute as to priority among the Danish physicist Christian Christiansen, the Swiss chemist and physicist Jacques-Louis Soret, and the German physicist August Kundt. While it is clear that Christiansen was the first to publish, the most extensive studies were carried out by Kundt. The relevance of these findings to the present subject
5
6
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
lies in the fact that here was proven the possibility of successfully studying the index of refraction even near absorption bands in the visible. Consequently, a similar anomalous dispersion could be expected to exist for the optical rotation, keeping in mind the relation between the velocity of light, the index of refraction, and the optical rotation. This anomalous dispersion feature of the rotation should have been accessible by existing techniques, if only suitable colored optically active samples had been available. It took more than two decades, however, before this problem was addressed.
1.3. THE DISCOVERY OF THE COTTON EFFECT In 1895, two short papers (“notes”) appeared in the fortnightly journal of the French Academy of Sciences, entitled “Unequal absorption of right and left circularly polarized light by certain optically active substances” [11] and “Anomalous rotatory dispersion of absorbing substances” [12]. The author was the 26-year-old physicist Aim´e Auguste ´ Cotton (Bourg-en-Bresse 1869–S`evres 1951), a PhD student at the prestigious Ecole Normale Sup´erieure in Paris. The first of these papers describes and names the property of “dichro¨ısme circulaire” (what we now call “CD”) associated with an absorption band of an optically active compound in solution, and the second one introduces the corresponding effect in the dispersion mode (now called “ORD”). The full paper of 85 pages, also incorporating studies on magnetic optical activity, was published in 1896 under the heading “Investigations of the absorption and the dispersion of light by optically active media” [13]. It summarizes A. Cotton’s Th`ese de Doctorat, which he prepared from ´ November 1893 to July 1896 at the Physics Laboratory of the Ecole Normale with Professors Marcel Brillouin and Jules Violle as advisors. Based on his important discoveries, Cotton was accorded the degree of Docteur e` s Sciences in 1896. In his thesis, Cotton for the first time reports data of (a) optical rotations close to both sides of an absorption band in the visible, using solutions of Cu(II) and Cr(III) coordination compounds with tartrate or malate ligands, and (b) the associated circular dichroism. It is quite obvious that Cotton was successful to a large degree owing to both the quality of his optical components and the skillful and precise construction of the measuring devices, especially for the determination of very small values of the ellipticity, but also to his power of observation, and—last but not least—to a fortunate choice of optically active samples. In this chapter, however, his technical equipment and the underlying physical principles shall not be discussed in detail, because Cotton himself gives a full description in his major paper, and there are also comprehensive reviews elsewhere as, for example, in the books by Mitchell and Lowry (see below). While Cotton’s expression “dispersion rotatoire anomale” (anomalous rotatory dispersion) is self-explanatory, a comment concerning his novel term “dichro¨ısme circulaire” (circular dichroism) may be appropriate. Cotton did not always measure directly or indirectly the difference in absorption of left- and right-circularly polarized light by his sample [i.e., (εL –εR )], but rather the ellipticity of the emerging elliptically polarized light. In this case, his measuring device included, apart from a Nicol prism to provide plane-polarized light, a “double circular polarizer” consisting of two quarter-waveplates placed side by side in the plane-polarized light beam in such a way that their principal axes are at 90◦ to one another and at 45◦ to the plane of the incident light. This arrangement allowed the observation of left- and right-circularly polarized light beams next to each other. On the introduction of a sample showing circular dichroism, the beams would be differently absorbed, which could be detected visually or photometrically. The field of vision was thus divided into two halves by these λ/4 plates. When
T H E F I R S T D E C A D E S A F T E R T H E D I S C O V E RY
he used white instead of monochromatic light for the examination of his optically active sample solutions, these two halves showed different colors. This reminded him of the dichroism observed with certain doubly refracting crystals, where the ordinary and the extraordinary ray are absorbed unequally, as found by Biot in tourmaline and later by the Austrian mineralogist Haidinger in many other cases [14]. Cotton therefore chose the term “circular dichroism.” In fact, Haidinger had already discovered this phenomenon in amethyst quartz in 1847 [15]. Nowadays, the expression “circular dichroism” probably just awakens vague memories of the original visual observations; this context has been largely forgotten nowadays, with the advent of automated electronic spectropolarimeters. Actually, Cotton himself had already performed some photometric measurements, but had found them inferior to his visual results.
1.4. THE FIRST CD AND ORD CURVES Cotton’s measurements obviously were not only restricted to the visible, but also quite limited as to the wavelengths available. Even under favorable conditions, at most eight spectral lines were at his disposal, namely, 657 (red, near C), 589 (yellow, sodium D line), 581 (orange, near D), 562 (greenish yellow), 522 (green, between E and b), 475 (blue, near F), 459 (blue-violet), and 437 nm (violet, near e) [the letters C, D, E, b, F, and e refer to the Fraunhofer lines so designated]. A comparison with Arndtsen’s paper of 1858 [4] shows that hardly any improvement of the spectral availability had taken place until the end of the nineteenth century. However, on the positive side it can be seen that these lines are spread rather evenly across the whole visual region. Nevertheless, the generation of continuous absorption and rotation curves, as often published, on the basis of observations at some of these individual wavelengths, leaves much to the whim of the draftsman, especially concerning the position and magnitude of any maxima and minima. Such “data” should not be overinterpreted. This situation would prevail in the decades to come. It is not unexpected that, at the onset of his investigations, Cotton chose Fehling’s solution (“liqueur de Fehling”) for his studies. It is, after all, in the direct line of Biot’s research to look at derivatives of active tartaric acid. Secondly, the only area of importance where the application of optical activity had become established was saccharimetry; and thirdly, Fehling’s solution was a proven and powerful reagent in carbohydrate chemistry [16]. It seems that Cotton systematically progressed from the complex and notoriously unstable Fehling’s solution to simpler alkali copper(II) tartrates, the preparation of which he describes in detail. By the way, it is amusing to note that in one case he reports the precipitation of copper tartrate from a copper sulfate solution by adding the aqueous solution of a crystal of Seignette salt (potassium sodium tartrate); this crystal had been prepared by Pasteur himself. Unfortunately, these copper complexes proved to be very unstable; they changed or simply decomposed with time or at elevated temperature and were also light-sensitive. Furthermore, the chemical composition of these aqueous solutions was unknown (and, to some extent, still is), and attempts at isolating any well-defined compound failed. A solution of crystalline copper malate, perhaps more stable, did not show any observable circular dichroism. Despite these drawbacks, Cotton did obtain many ORD and some CD data, but obviously the reproducibility of the experiments remains questionable, and the curves shown in print [13] should be interpreted with caution.
7
8
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
The most convincing chiroptical effects, however, were observed with aqueous solutions of potassium chromium(III) tartrate, prepared in situ. They shall be discussed here in some detail. Figure 1.1 is Cotton’s Figure 18 on page 408 of reference 13, and it shows a complete “Cotton effect” in the ORD and the CD near 570 nm. Because of its seminal importance, this figure has been later reprinted by others a number of times. The actually measured data are given as follows: 657 nm, rotation ρ + 1◦ 26 , ellipse [sic] φ + 32 ; similarly: 589, +2◦ 30 , (−3◦ 40 ); 581, +1◦ 46 , −4◦ 54 ; 562, −1◦ 21 , −4◦ 16 ; 522, −2◦ 50 , −1◦ 25 ; and 475, 1◦ 52 [no sign given in the paper; from the curve it is evident that ρ must be negative], +28 . Data were thus collected at six wavelengths only, because the onset of a second strong absorption band made observations at shorter wavelengths impossible. The parentheses around the ellipticity value at the sodium D line are Cotton’s and indicate that this number results from photometric measurements. Despite its beautiful appearance, there are unfortunately some flaws in this figure and the data as printed. A comparison of the figure with the data listed above makes evident two discrepancies at 562 nm: In the figure, the angle φ is given as −4◦ 46 (not −4◦ 16 ), and the corresponding angle ρ is given as −0◦ 21 (not −1◦ 21 ). On reexamination, the true values were verified to be φ − 4◦ 46 and ρ − 1◦ 21 . The figure should be redrawn, therefore, using this value of ρ. Such a modification would necessarily modify the shape of the ORD curve, while not basically changing it. Cotton gives these corrections in
+3°
+2°
ρ) ons (
Rotati
+1°
0
Elli s pse
–1°
(ϕ)
–2°
–3°
–4°
–5°
Figure 1.1. CD and ORD of potassium chromium(III) 657
589 581562
522
475 459 437
tartrate (solvent H2 O). (From A. Cotton, Ann. Chim. Physique 1896, [7] 8, 347; Figure 18, p. 408.)
T H E F I R S T D E C A D E S A F T E R T H E D I S C O V E RY
a letter to Professor Ladislas Natanson in Cracow, Poland, quoted on pages 33/34 of reference 17. He explains the first error as a misprint, and he states that the second one is a mistake by the “dessinateur” (draftsman). However, the really important disagreement between the ORD and CD, as we can see immediately from the curves—with hindsight—lies in the incompatibility of their signs. If we accept the rotation values as correct, as seems reasonable, the sign of the CD is in error. And so it is! Cotton himself redressed this flaw two years later [18] in a paper, the first sentence of which runs as follows (translated from the French): ‘It is easy to be mistaken as to the sense of a circular vibration.’ Admitting his mistake in the assignment of the direction of the rays circularly polarized by a Fresnel rhomb, he imputed it to his misinterpretation of some of Billet’s tenets in the latter’s “Trait´e ” [19]. Apparently, Billet had used the expression “principal section” of a mica crystal in an unorthodox way and had also treated this crystal as positive, contrary to the common practice. Therefore, all of Cotton’s CD curves, and the sign of all ellipticities published before 1898, ought to be inverted. But not everyone read or responded to this correction; others did so, but without indicating it. The confusion that might have been generated was fortunately curtailed by the fact that very few scientists, apart from Frenchmen, studied the circular dichroism in the following decades. But as late as in 1923, (Ms.) N. Wedeneewa in Moscow (for example) still used the earlier “wrong” sign of the CD, when she reported the ORD and CD of camphor quinone [20]. Similarly, T. M. Lowry just reprinted Cotton’s Figure 18 in his famous classic of 1935 [21] without any comment, whereas S. Mitchell in his treatise on the Cotton effect [22] of 1933 simply shows an inverted CD curve in ostensibly the same figure (see Figure 1.2), also without any further comment. Another point of criticism could be raised because of the all-too-vague identity of the samples investigated. Although Cotton carefully describes the preparation of his samples, as mentioned earlier, their inherent instability cannot preclude changes with time, perhaps also as the result of shifting equilibria between the several complexes present. Indeed, small changes even in the synthesis of the tartrate complexes can lead to the total inversion of the anomalous rotatory dispersion, as has been observed by Wedeneewa [20]. All this calls for caution with respect to the early ORD and CD publications. However, concerning the key compound discussed at length, potassium chromium(III) tartrate, all doubts were finally set to rest by W. Kuhn [23], who much later very carefully repeated Cotton’s work and found it fully correct (Figure 1.3).
1.5. THE REACTION OF THE LEARNED WORLD TO COTTON’S DISCOVERIES Cotton’s papers raised the immediate attention of Wilhelm Ostwald (Nobel Prize 1909), who, one year after the publication of the original notes in the Comptes Rendues [11, 12], wrote two abstracts thereof himself for his journal Zeitschrift f¨ur Physikalische Chemie [24]. This was followed by his six-page review of Cotton’s full paper [13] in the same year [25], with several CD and ORD curves reprinted, including Cotton’s original Figure 18, discussed above. It should be pointed out that the lack of correspondence of the sign of the ORD and the CD could not have been noticed by Ostwald at that time, since the necessary theoretical background had not yet been provided. With these reviews, Ostwald acquainted the chemical world with Cotton’s results, and his name carried much weight. It is certainly unusual that preliminary notes by a foreign physics student and extracts of his
9
10
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
5°
4
3
2
1
0
–1
–2
–3 6600
6200
5800
5400
5000
Wave-length Å.U. Rotations Ellipticities
4600
Figure 1.2. CD and ORD of potassium chromium(III) tartrate (solvent H2 O). (From S. Mitchell, The Cotton Effect, Bell, London, 1933; Figure 12, p. 23; reproduced with permission.)
thesis should induce an already famous physical chemist to such a presentation. Incidentally, already the “sponsoring” of Cotton’s notes by the renowned physicist Gabriel Lippmann from Luxembourg (Nobel Prize 1908)—such notes had to be presented by an academician—attests to the importance attributed to them. One might well say that chiroptics had a splendid start. The speed with which the news was reported and hailed is altogether breathtaking. For example, the physical chemist Landolt referred to Cotton’s studies already in the second edition of his book, published in 1898 [7]. Mention should also be made of the German physicist Paul Drude, who included a treatment of Cotton’s “(anomalous) rotary dispersion” in his famous Lehrbuch der Optik of 1900 [26]. So, by the beginning of the twentieth century, the international world of physics and physical chemistry was well aware of Cotton’s results. It took only a few additional years before a thorough theoretical treatment was provided by L. Natanson, Professor of Theoretical Physics at the Jagiellonian University Krak´ow (Cracow, Poland). The title of his important paper, “On the elliptic polarization of light transmitted through an absorbing naturally-active medium” [27], with a supplementary note [17], needs no further comment. Here, Natanson treated the interdependence of absorption, optical rotation, and circular dichroism. Probably in order to spread his results further, also an amalgamated and shortened French translation of both papers by the Count of Ballehache was published very shortly thereafter [28]. The relations presented here between the sign of the rotation and the circular dichroism have become known as the “R`egle de Natanson” or “Natanson’s Rule” [29]. This finally allowed the
11
xz–xT
log x
[A]–10–3
T H E F I R S T D E C A D E S A F T E R T H E D I S C O V E RY
2,75 7,5 3,5
2,50 5,0 3,0
Z
3
1
2,25 2,5 2,5 + 0 2,0
2,00 −
2
1,75 –2,5 1,5 1 1,50 –5,0 1,0 g –0,10
1,25 –7,5 0,5 4
–0,05
g 1,00 –10,0 0
–0,05 –12,5 –0,5
7000 Å
6000
5000
4000
3000
λ
Figure 1.3. UV, CD, and ORD of potassium chromium(III) tartrate (solvent H2 O). (From W. Kuhn, ¨ A. Szabo, Z. Phys. Chem. 1931, B15, 59; Figure 1, p. 62; Oldenbourg Wissenschaftsverlag Munchen, reproduced with permission.)
prediction of the sign of the circular dichroism associated with a specific absorption band, based on just the anomalous rotation curve, which should not be too difficult to obtain. Natanson’s papers included the following sentences on the first page: “Effects of this kind have been observed and investigated by Monsieur A. Cotton” [27] and “Des ph´enom`enes de ce genre ont e´ t´e observ´e et analys´es par M. Cotton” [28]. Here we find the seed that has developed into the important technical terms “Cotton’s Phenomenon” and “Cotton Effect,” which have been used ever since, with the first one preferred in the early decades of the twentieth century. At this point it may be timely to more formally give a definition of the Cotton effect as we understand it today. It may be interesting to compare the definition given in 1933 by Stotherd Mitchell on page 24 of his book on the Cotton effect (incidentally the first monograph of this kind) [22] with the definition by Werner Kuhn from 1960 [30]. Mitchell wrote: “A maximum ellipticity and zero rotation are found in this region [of the absorption band]. The rotation reaches a maximum value on one side of the band and
12
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
a minimum on the other. This variation of rotation and ellipticity in the neighbourhood of an absorption band has been called the Cotton effect.” [Mitchell’s italics] Kuhn stated: “[Cotton] found that optical rotatory power as a function of the wavelength often shows, in the region where the substances show ordinary absorption, a characteristic anomaly which is associated with a circular dichroism in the absorption region and which after the name of its discoverer is called a Cotton effect.” [Kuhn’s italics] It is satisfactory that both definitions, published some 30 years apart, fully agree with one another; furthermore, we still can subscribe to both of them, even 50 years later. Many similar definitions can be found over the last 80 years, all of them stressing the point that the ensemble of rotatory dispersion and circular dichroism in the absorption region collectively constitute the Cotton effect. Nevertheless, quite commonly the term Cotton effect has loosely been used to characterize merely the “anomalous” rotation features, since in the decades following Cotton’s discoveries the available data were mostly limited to the optical rotation. In fact, in many cases it has been considered sufficient to have reached the first maximum of the rotatory dispersion curve, still outside the absorption band, to apply the term Cotton effect. In recent decades, when ORD effectively disappeared in favor of CD, the term usually means the CD curve only.
1.6. MORE TARTRATES: THE PHYSICIST’S PLAYGROUND Cotton’s discovery of circular dichroism raised so much interest in Brace’s Physics Laboratory at the University of Nebraska that it was decided to construct an improved and more sensitive apparatus for measuring both elliptical polarization and rotation, in order to repeat and extend the French findings. The American physicist DeWitt Bristol Brace was himself active in the field of optical activity and had in 1904 described an elliptical polarizer and compensator that was incorporated not only in the optical system used in Nebraska, but also later in Europe. Brace died in 1905 and had, therefore, no part in the further development. The first results on, for example, complex chromium, copper, cobalt, and nickel tartrates and copper malate were presented by M. F. McDowell in 1905 [31]. The ellipticity had been measured in “all parts of the spectrum,” which means at some 10 different wavelengths of the visual solar spectrum. Unfortunately, the calculation of the ellipticity was found to be incorrect, and some compounds were irreproducible. This was carefully rectified at the same laboratory in 1912 by L. B. Olmstead, who studied tartrates, malates, and lactates of chromium, copper, cobalt, and manganese [32]. Also here, the so-called “monochromatic” light, with a spectral band width of perhaps 20 nm, was obtained from sunlight. Although the optical part of the investigation seems to be impeccable (except that Cotton’s first—incorrect—sign protocol of the circular dichroism was still used), the identity of the compounds studied is uncertain. Olmstead himself points out: “No chemical analyses of the compounds were made; the names assigned being merely for convenience, and not indicating that the chemical formulæ are known.” [Olmstead’s italics]. He observed that Cotton’s results for potassium chromium tartrate could be repeated quantitatively when the sample was prepared from potassium dichromate and potassium tartrate, but an oppositely signed Cotton effect developed when the potassium dichromate was replaced by chromium acetate. Undoubtedly, the samples consisted of a mixture of complexes, as was also indicated by color changes of the solutions, depending on variations of the concentration and with time. As a result, even these carefully collected data are of a qualitative nature only.
T H E F I R S T D E C A D E S A F T E R T H E D I S C O V E RY
The same qualifications pertain to a large number of papers of the early twentieth century on the rotatory dispersion of transition metal complexes with optically active ligands. In addition, the rotatory dispersion data were often collected at only four or five rather ill-defined spectral bands in the visible. Examples are found in the report by H. Grossmann and A. Loeb on copper tartrate and malate coordination compounds [33], as well as in the paper by H. Volk on copper, nickel, and cobalt complexes with lactate ligands [34]. Also these investigations were initiated, by the way, in order to verify and extend Cotton’s findings. Cotton himself did not continue his work on the optically active tartrates, but motivated his student Georges Bruhat to address the problem again [35]. Bruhat tried to synthesize and isolate individual, well-defined compounds, but succeeded with most tartrates and malates in part only, because of the easy decomposition of the respective solutions. He did isolate and investigate uranyl tartrate that seemed to be stable and showed a Cotton effect near 500 nm. His optical equipment limited the quality of his measurements rather severely, however. After a disruption of the research by the First World War, he resumed his studies again in 1919 with a much more advanced apparatus. This allowed him to reduce the spectral band width from 30 nm to 10 nm, which was essential to avoid “flattened-out” dispersion curves. In this way, he obtained splendid CD and ORD data for uranyl tartrate and ammoniacal cobalt tartrate [36], for example. But regrettably, not even the high quality of the physical data allows any better analysis of the compounds responsible. The interest in this topic was not yet put to rest in Cotton’s laboratory. In the earlier work, the copper complexes had been particularly unsatisfactory. Therefore, the study of alkaline copper tartrate solutions was taken up again in order to enhance the quality of the samples [37]. Somewhat later, complex chromium [38] and cobalt tartrates [39] were reinvestigated. Good CD data could be collected, but the chemical identity of the species in solution remained uncertain, despite Mathieu’s extensive experiments. Such tartrate studies were not wholly limited to Paris. Also W. Pfleiderer in Basel, Switzerland, had returned to measuring the optical rotation of aqueous alkaline solutions of copper tartrate, and he found his data to qualitatively agree with Cotton’s of 1895 [40]. The chiroptical instability that Nina Wedeneewa in Moscow, Russia, had encountered with alkaline chromium tartrates in the absorption region has been mentioned already [20]. Last but not least, attention is drawn to W. Kuhn’s reevaluation of the same problem, as outlined earlier [23]. The overview presented here is not exhaustive. Because of the similarity of the problems, the preceding discussion pertains also to, for example, optically active lactates, malates, and “sucrates” of transition metals. The respective chiroptical results are not basically different from those with tartrate ligands. It remains to report that even many years later the chemical identity of these complicated coordination compounds has not been fully understood, with several questions still unsettled even today [41]. While some of the variability observed is certainly caused by the gradual replacement of coordinated water by the organic ligands, condensation processes leading to multinuclear species also seem to be involved. It is intriguing that the chiroptical properties of tartrate complexes dominate the study of circular dichroism for three decades. In fact, during these years very few CD measurements have been carried out outside of this area (see later). One might speculate whether this conservatism would perhaps result from the fact that practically all researchers were physicists, who might have had limited awareness of colored optically
13
14
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
active compounds in other fields of chemistry. After all, with, for example, organic xanthates, such compounds did exist, but their investigation was largely confined to only one chemical research group in Russia, as will be seen. The question might well be asked, What motivated these tenacious tartrate investigations? It is obvious that genuine chemical topics were not addressed, such as the stereochemical correlation and the application of optical activity to the study of reaction mechanisms, or as a tool in the elucidation of the chemical constitution. This contrasts with the aims in connection with the Werner complexes, to be discussed in the following section of this report. But as to tartrates, the investigators were primarily interested in the circular dichroism in its own right. They tried to effect improvements in the optical instrumentation in order to enhance the sensitivity and precision of their measuring devices. For testing the various theories of optical activity and to compare calculated and experimental data, the latter should be measured with a maximum of accuracy and reliability. It might well have been felt that the continuation with “well-known” samples like the complex tartrates would be advantageous, with a host of data already existing for comparison.
1.7. WERNER COMPLEXES: INORGANIC CHEMISTS LEARN TO MAKE USE OF THE COTTON EFFECT According to common practice, the tartrate systems discussed in the previous section can be considered to belong to the realm of inorganic chemistry. But they were chosen for chiroptical research without paying much attention to their chemical nature. Chemists have performed hardly any systematic studies of these compounds and have instead tended to neglect them. The situation was quite different with regard to the chemically and structurally welldefined octahedral transition metal complexes, following the Alsatian Alfred Werner’s (1866–1919) introduction in 1893 of his geometric model for centers with the coordination number six [42]. At that time, Werner worked in the laboratory of his doctoral advisor, Professor Arthur Rudolf Hantzsch, at the University of Zurich, Switzerland. He had obtained his doctoral degree only in 1890, but was quickly promoted to a chair of chemistry at this University in 1895. Although his revolutionary concept eventually secured him the Nobel Prize in 1913, it met much resistance among his chemical colleagues. The opposition diminished, however, after he had achieved the resolution of some of his complexes into enantiomers [43], since the occurrence of optical activity was hard to reconcile with other than the octahedral geometry. The optically active compounds, mostly Co(III) complexes, were of greatly varying chemical and optical stability, often racemizing at room temperature within a few hours. It was found that chelating ligands like oxalate ions (O, O -donor ligands) or 1,2-diamines (N , N -donor ligands) led to increased stability. In the beginning, the optical rotation at only one wavelength was considered sufficient to characterize a specific complex. But it was soon realized that the stereochemical correlation should not be based on such an individual value, since it varied too much in magnitude and even in sign from one complex to the next, notwithstanding a close chemical relationship. Furthermore, as the enantiomeric purity of the compounds was often uncertain, a particular, selected rotation value could be quite misleading. On the other hand, these complexes were well-suited to measurements of the Cotton effect due to their color, which often brought them within the range of visual observation. The sign of this Cotton effect, associated with electron transitions at the coordinating metal
T H E F I R S T D E C A D E S A F T E R T H E D I S C O V E RY
center, was found to be a reliable, characteristic feature. Consequently, measuring the rotatory dispersion including, hopefully, a more or less complete Cotton effect became a common goal. The first Werner complex for which both ORD and CD data through an absorption band were obtained, namely, potassium (trisoxalato)iridate(III) dihydrate, K3 [Ir(C2 O4 )3 ]·2 H2 O, was resolved by M. Del´epine [44], and its chiroptical properties were determined by G. Bruhat [45]. A Cotton effect near 450 nm was found. This is, incidentally, one of the rare instances where the circular dichroism of a Werner complex has been determined in the early part of the twentieth century. In practically all other cases, the term Cotton effect just refers to the rotatory dispersion near or at an absorption band in the visible. Werner himself had already reported similar dissymmetric, optically active complexes with bidentate ligands like [Co(en)3 ]3+ or [Cr(ox)3 ]3 – (en = 1,2-diaminoethane; ox = oxalate ion C2 O4 2− ), but without any further spectropolarimetric data [46]. It is amusing to see that in some other cases the Cotton effect—or, rather, the anomalous rotatory dispersion—rests on measurements at only three different wavelengths as for [Rh(ox)3 ]3− , for example [47]. Werner’s concept achieved its final breakthrough when he published the resolution of the “completely inorganic” complex [Co{Co(NH3 )4 (OH)2 }3 ]Br6 , an octahedral Co(III) complex with bidentate O, O ligands. This complex, without any carbon atom, is sterically related to the simpler [Co(en)3 ]3+ system. It showed a Cotton effect near 600 nm [48]. This finding finally put to rest the long-lived but obsolete theory that the presence of carbon atoms was essential for the unfolding of optical activity. Werner showed no particular interest in the Cotton effect in its own right, however, but rather made use of it for the stereochemical correlation and the characterization of his compounds. A further example which may be mentioned is [Co(NO2 )2 (en)(pn)], with pn = 1,2-diaminopropane, with either rac-pn or l -pn, that had Cotton effects in the 530- to 540-nm range [49]. In general, Werner’s interest in spectropolarimetry remained limited, and usually he left further chiroptical studies to others. Even when he reported Cotton effects, it is not always clear how, where, and by whom the data were obtained. Meanwhile, a new “center of gravity” for the examination of Werner complexes was developing in Groningen in the Netherlands. Here, the stereochemist Franciscus Mauritius Jaeger (1877–1945), Professor of Inorganic and Physical Chemistry at the Rijksuniversiteit Groningen (RUG) from 1908 to 1945, had by 1915 embarked on a program of the comprehensive investigation of these systems [50]. A great many new, and some already known, Werner complexes were synthesized and studied. Jaeger’s interests lay largely in their crystallographic description, but he also included optical activity in his research program. Most of the spectropolarimetric data generated “plain” ORD curves only, because the anticipated Cotton effect was often beyond the wavelength limit of the optical devices or inaccessible because of too strong an absorption. In Jaeger’s extensive paper of 1919 [51], many such plain curves are reported, but only two cases of a bona fide Cotton effect, namely, in K3 [Cr(ox)3 ] (Cotton effect near 565 nm) and K3 [Co(ox)3 ]·H2 O (near 620 nm). The chromium compound had already been synthesized and resolved by Werner in 1912, but had not been investigated by spectropolarimetry, whereas the (trisoxalato)cobaltate(III) was new. It was very advantageous that Jaeger could induce Israel Lifschitz (1888–1953), Private Docent at the University of Zurich, to join his laboratory in 1921. Lifschitz, whose special area of research had been the absorption spectroscopy and photochemistry of organic compounds, now became Private Docent of Electrochemistry and Photochemistry
15
16
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
and tenured staff member at RUG. He turned to the spectroscopic study of transition metal complexes, with particular attention to spectropolarimetry. Largely owing to his efforts, the laboratory developed into a center of chiroptical spectroscopy, of international repute. Lifschitz had taken his doctorate in 1911 with A. Hantzsch in Germany (Hantzsch had changed from Zurich to the University of Leipzig) and had moved to Switzerland in 1914. It is interesting to note that he there worked close to Werner, who also had been a student of Hantzsch. Perhaps the shift of Lifschitz from organic photochemistry to coordination stereochemistry has thereby been influenced, but presently nothing is known of a personal interaction with Werner. It is difficult to assay in detail Lifschitz’s contribution to the Groningen laboratory, except for his own publications, since Jaeger as laboratory head regularly included the research results of his local colleagues in his own publications, without giving any individual credit. This procedure was rather common in those days. Only sometimes is Lifschitz mentioned in a vague way as a “collaborateur” (coworker). In 1923 Lifschitz started a series of papers called “Investigations of Rotatory Dispersion” [translated from the original German]. In the first paper, he presented and discussed ORD data of complexes of Cr(III), Co(III), Ni(II), and UO2 2− ions with optically active camphor derivatives, including nitrocamphor. These compounds exhibited Cotton effects in the visible. The paper is also noteworthy, because here the technical term “Cotton effect” was introduced into the chemical literature; the earlier term had been “Cotton phenomenon” [52]. In the second paper of this series, Lifschitz reported the ORD Cotton effects of Co and Cu complexes with amino acid ligands (alanine, asparagine), and also of the complex [Cu-(l -pn)2 ]SO4 (effect at 510 nm) [53]. Slightly later, Jaeger extended the chiroptical studies to cobalt complexes with 1,2-diamino ligands, and he reported the Cotton effects in [Co(rac-trans-1,2-diaminocyclopentane)3 ]Cl3 · 4H2 O at 470 nm and in [Co(rac-trans-1,2-diaminocyclopentane)(en)2 ]Br3 · 2H2 O at 500 nm [54]. A few years later, some of these Werner complexes were reinvestigated by Werner Kuhn, making use of advanced instrumentation. Measurements had now become possible down to 280 nm. With potassium (trisoxalato)cobaltate(III), for example, the Cotton effect at ∼600 nm was measured both in rotatory dispersion and in circular dichroism [55]. But now the aim had shifted from using the spectropolarimetric data for chemical and stereochemical correlation, as had been the purpose in Zurich and Groningen, to probing the stereochemistry in depth, with the elucidation of the absolute configuration in mind, and to testing new theoretical models of the optical activity. But it would take a few additional decades before eventually another experimental reinvestigation of the circular dichroism of some of these complexes, in connection with an analysis based on an improved theory, led to the desired knowledge of both the structure in solution and the absolute configuration. To this end, once again the circular dichroism of the (trisethylenediamine)cobalt(III) cation [56] and of the (trisoxalato)cobaltate(III) anion [57] was studied. But to trace this development would far exceed the scope of the present overview.
1.8. THE COTTON EFFECT IN ORGANIC CHEMISTRY, A RUSSIAN DOMAIN It would not be correct to claim that organic chemists neglected optical activity in the early twentieth century, except to characterize compounds by their D-line rotation. As an example to the contrary can be cited a series of papers by the Swiss chemist Hans Rupe (1866–1951) on the influence of the constitution on the rotatory power of optically active
T H E F I R S T D E C A D E S A F T E R T H E D I S C O V E RY
compounds, starting in 1903 [58]. However, usually colorless solutions were examined in the visible, as also done by Rupe, and could provide data on “plain” rotatory dispersion only. These investigations are, therefore, outside of the scope of the present overview. However, it must be admitted that, in general, organic chemists seem to have been less interested in chiroptical effects than their inorganic or physicochemical colleagues. Thus the study of organic molecules, as much as there is, had to rest on the “good will” of people from the latter fold. Here, credit is to be given first to the distinguished English physical chemist, Thomas Martin Lowry (1874–1936). Lowry’s interest in optical activity dates back to 1898, when he noted the change of optical rotation on nitrocamphor with time and introduced the term “mutarotation” to characterize this phenomenon [59]. He greatly improved the mathematical treatment and the theoretical understanding of rotatory dispersion and circular dichroism, based in part on the experimental data collected in his own research group in London, and later in Cambridge. It is interesting to see that there was a certain lack of understanding of the theory of optical activity on the part of some organic chemists. Even Rupe himself, for example, maintained as late as in 1921 that there had not been established with certainty any connection between the Cotton effect and the absorption of light [60]. In the earlier period of his career, Lowry dealt mostly with features outside of absorption bands; that is, he did not penetrate by experiment into the Cotton effect region itself. The state of the research on optical activity by the year 1914 has been summarized in the report “Optical Rotatory Power. A general Discussion” [61], and later in Lowry’s classic book [21], and it need not be described further in this paper. Lowry’s work in the early 1930s on the Cotton effect of organic molecules will be discussed later in this section. The most active pioneer in the study of the rotatory dispersion of organic molecules, and the only one who obtained data for the Cotton effect before World War I, is undoubtedly the Russian Leo [Lev] Alexandrovitsch Tschugaev (1873–1922) [62]. Tschugaev was a prolific research worker, who from the beginning of his career engaged in the chemistry of compounds like terpenes and camphor and, secondly, that of transition metal complexes. It was probably the study of optically active natural products that aroused his interest in optical activity generally. Eventually, he turned to a third research topic, after he had become Professor of Inorganic Chemistry at the Imperial University of St. Petersburg, and began in 1909 a series of papers on (anomalous) rotatory dispersion [63]. Tschugaev was fully aware of Cotton’s ground-breaking discoveries, and he was also aware of the problems inherently connected with the samples chosen for this early work. Therefore, he proudly, and correctly, pointed out in his initial papers that he now for the first time employed well-defined compounds for the study of the rotatory dispersion (he himself had no instrument that would allow him to measure the circular dichroism, in addition). But also he was still limited to visual observations at certain spectral lines. He used samples from two different families of sulfur-containing colored derivatives of optically active terpene alcohols like borneol, menthol, or fenchol, namely, xanthates RO–C(S)–SR and related compounds, along with “dithiourethanes” RO–C(S)–NPh–C(S)Ph (with Ph = C6 H5 ) and similar compounds. In all cases he found an anomalous dispersion of the rotation, but for different reasons. The xanthates give colorless or yellowish solutions, because there are no absorption bands in the visible. The anomalous rotatory dispersion detected is, therefore, of the type already observed for tartaric acid by Biot, and it is not caused by a Cotton effect in this spectral region. The red dithiourethanes, however, do show an absorption band at ∼520 nm, and the rotatory dispersion features indeed result from a Cotton effect associated with this absorption.
17
18
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
It must be admitted that Tschugaev was only able to detect the first maximum of the ORD curve, because of the onset of high absorption near 450 nm precluding measurements of the short-wavelength part of the dispersion curve. Therefore, it might be considered stretching a point rather far to speak of his truly having detected Cotton effects, since this depends on quite some interpolation and interpretation. But his contention was much strengthened by G. Bruhat, to whom he had sent samples of both the d - and the l -bornyl dithiourethane mentioned above. Bruhat was able to measure the circular dichroism, both in toluene solution and in the melt [35, 64]. The CD maximum at 520–530 nm coincided with the absorption maximum at 520 nm. Bruhat could confirm, but not extend, Tschugaev’s ORD data, by the way. This then not only proved that Tschugaev’s interpretation of his rotatory dispersion curves had been correct, but also provided the first example of circular dichroism observed in a well-defined (organic) compound. With Tschugaev’s papers at hand, it is interesting to follow the progress of his search for a fitting technical term to describe what he initially calls an anomalous rotatory dispersion “in the sense of Cotton,” until he finally in 1912 arrived at the “Cotton phenomenon.” This then became the internationally accepted term to be used for two decades, until it lost ground against Lifschitz’s “Cotton effect.” T. M. Lowry revisited Tschugaev’s compounds in 1932, confirming the earlier data and extending the wavelength range of the observations, thanks to improvements in the optical instrumentation and the introduction of photography. He also performed calculations on a more advanced basis in order to analyze and simulate the data [65]. Now it had become possible to take photographic readings at many points of the wavelength scale down to 325 nm. Lowry not only supplemented and slightly extended Tschugaev’s earlier ORD results, but now he could additionally make available circular dichroism data for the xanthates. These compounds, with a weak absorption at 360 nm (which Tschugaev had missed) and a strong one at 280 nm, exhibit a CD maximum at ∼355 nm. The steep rise of the absorption toward shorter wavelengths still precluded the precise observation of the second ORD maximum at about 330 nm. It is notable that Lowry found his photographic CD measurements of the dithiourethanes in the year 1932 less exact than Bruhat’s visual measurements of 1911. Colored organic compounds were not unknown apart from the sulfur-containing derivatives discussed above, but were not easily available in optically active form. For chiroptical studies they should advantageously stem from the pool of optically active natural compounds or their derivatives, because the organic chemists of those days seem to have tended to avoid resolutions, contrary to their colleagues in the field of Werner complexes. Therefore, it is not surprising that the yellow camphor quinone attracted the attention of physical chemists and physicists alike. The Russian physicist Nina Wedeneewa detected in this compound a Cotton effect near 490 nm by ellipticity and rotatory dispersion measurements; although the work had been done in 1919, its publication was delayed until 1923 because of the political turmoil in Russia [20]. Her main interest was the analysis of the data in terms of the Drude theory of optical dispersion. Slightly later, in 1925, Israel Lifschitz also had tried to measure the optical rotation of camphor quinone near the absorption region, but could reach the first maximum only [53]. Lowry later repeated, confirmed, and extended Nina Wedeneewa’s findings, thereby tacitly correcting the sign of her circular dichroism data, as he studied camphor quinone both in solution and in the vapor phase [66]. Also this second case, in which the circular dichroism of an organic molecule has been measured successfully, in addition to Tschugaev’s/Bruhat’s dithiourethane,
T H E F I R S T D E C A D E S A F T E R T H E D I S C O V E RY
stems from Russia. Unfortunately, the First World War, the Russian Revolution, and Tschugaev’s premature death interrupted and eventually ended a period of intensive research on chiroptics in that country. Intriguing colored organic compounds are the “nitrosites” (1,2-nitroso-nitrites) and “pseudo-nitrosites” (1,2-nitroso-nitro compounds), which can be made by the addition of (formally) N2 O3 to olefins. These compounds exhibit green or blue colors in solution, provided that the nitroso group is monomeric. E. Deussen, working with the blue optically active caryophyllene nitrosite, had noticed an anomalous rotatory dispersion, minimalistically based on readings at just two wavelengths [67]. The suggestion by Tschugaev, that this might be caused by a Cotton effect in the visible [68], led Stotherd Mitchell in Glasgow in 1928 to check the chiroptical properties of this compound [69], but with readings taken at eight wavelengths between 691 and 436 nm. Indeed, a Cotton effect was found in the CD at ∼680 nm. It might be remarked that the absorption curves were measured separately with right- and left-circularly polarized light, whereas in practically all earlier cases data on ellipticities had been collected. In summary, the circular dichroism of only three (colored) organic compounds had become known by 1928. Although in some cases the claim has been put forward to have seen in such compounds a Cotton effect by rotatory dispersion, this should be taken with a grain of salt, because this cannot normally be substantiated by presenting the whole sigmoidal dispersion curve. Usually one wing of the curve is missing (commonly on the high-energy side of the absorption band), for reasons discussed above. It may come as a surprise, therefore, that as early as 1910, Eug`ene Darmois, one of Cotton’s students, published the ORD Cotton effect of even a colorless organic compound, namely, camphor, at ∼300 nm [70]. It is true that he had not been able to obtain rotation data at the absorption maximum itself, but only on either side of it (with a gap between 313 and 265 nm), but the dispersion curve can be easily completed by interpolation. This finding is all the more remarkable, because it demonstrated for the first time the possibility of taking rotation values down to ∼250 nm in the ultraviolet. Regrettably, the response of the chemical community was slow, probably because of the technical difficulties involved in the construction of a suitable spectropolarimeter. It took some 20 years before Darmois’s work could be taken up again; then, W. Kuhn published ORD, CD, and UV data of camphor, taken right through the absorption band [71], and T. M. Lowry likewise reported data of the related camphor-β-sulfonic acid [72]. It seems rather daring that Darmois [70] also tried to measure the chiroptical properties of olefins like α- and β-pinene or limonene, but—not unexpectedly—without much success. This chromophore still resisted the efforts of R. Servant in 1932, but at least this time some indication of a first ORD maximum seemed to be suggested at around 280 nm in the case of the pinenes [73]. From the foregoing it appears that rather suddenly, by around 1930, many more types of compounds were studied by chiroptical techniques. This resulted from the progress in instrumentation, to be related briefly in the next section. Now, a great many additional chromophores in colorless organic compounds, like nitro, azido, nitrito, and particularly carbonyl groups, opened the way for studies of the circular dichroism and the rotatory dispersion. Nevertheless, just a few typical samples were used to be investigated for physical–chemical purposes. It would take many more years before organic chemists made use of the now accessible optical techniques for stereochemical correlations and the determination of the absolute configuration. But this then is far outside the scope of this overview. These newer developments since the early 1930s will not be treated here, because many summaries are already available. The major source of information
19
20
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
for the organic chemist on these later chiroptical investigations is Carl Djerassi’s book [74], which has become a “classic” in the field to which the reader should turn.
1.9. ADVANCES IN INSTRUMENTATION AND THEORY; THE WAY INTO THE ULTRAVIOLET Very briefly, the technical advances shall be sketched here that, around 1930, led to the (short-lived) upsurge in chiroptical activity mentioned in the foregoing section. Details shall be omitted, because comprehensive reviews are readily available. In addition to Lowry’s encyclopedic monograph of 1935 [21] and Mitchell’s book of 1933 [22], one should pay particular attention to Bruhat’s 1930 treatise on polarimetry, since most of the “newer” development of spectropolarimeters and ellipsometers resulted from the efforts at his laboratory in Paris [75]. Another active center was at the Technische Hochschule (Institute of Technology) Karlsruhe, Germany, where the Swiss physical chemist Werner Kuhn not only worked on theoretical and experimental chiroptics, but also developed his own apparatus [76]. Relevant optical instruments have also been reviewed by R. Descamps in Brussels, Belgium, who had himself constructed and perfected a spectropolarimeter for the UV region [77]. Of course, Lowry’s important contributions from his Laboratory of Physical Chemistry in the University of Cambridge, UK, are by no means to be forgotten. Progress in instrumentation for chiroptical studies meant, besides the obvious improvement of sensitivity and reliability, by and large the extension of the wavelength range into the ultraviolet. It was evident that the absorption bands of the vast majority of chemical compounds are located in the UV. It may come as a surprise that polarimetric measurements in the ultraviolet have been known for a considerable time and can be traced back to the nineteenth century. Various instruments for this purpose are described by Lowry [21], but the operation of the apparatus was laborious, the accuracy of the results questionable, and the accessible wavelength range rather limited. It does not seem, moreover, that these techniques have been applied to the detection of Cotton effects before the exceptional pioneering work of E. Darmois in 1911 [70]. One of the earlier attempts at measuring optical rotations in the UV was by Lowry himself, who in 1908 combined a half-shadow polarimeter with a UV spectrograph [78]. Darmois could collect data to the wavelength limit of 250 nm. But in order to make this wavelength range more generally accessible, and even extend it toward higher energy, three different problems had to be solved: first, with regard to the light sources; second, with the transparency of optical components to the UV light; and third, in connection with the efficiency of detectors. 1. The solar spectrum provided light in the laboratory only down to the limit of 300 nm, because of atmospheric absorption. Mercury vapor lamps allowed readings to be taken for another 50 nm, down to 250 nm. Beyond that wavelength, various other light sources have been used, in all cases providing an array of separate spectral lines—for example, the iron arc to 233 nm, or the cadmium spark to 210 nm. 2. The transparency limits of glass preclude its use in UV instruments for lenses, prisms, or similar optical devices, except for the near-UV range. Materials like Iceland spar (cutoff at 250 nm), fluorspar, or quartz had to be introduced to improve the transmittance of UV radiation. Even the Canada balsam used in
T H E F I R S T D E C A D E S A F T E R T H E D I S C O V E RY
conventional Nicol prisms had to be replaced by, for example, glycerol, in order to allow their utilization below 340 nm. 3. As to the detectors, the fluorescent screens of the early days were soon replaced by photographic implements, but the evaluation of the developed plates posed new problems in its own right. The improvements in all these areas led to the independent construction of two similar recording spectropolarimeters in the year 1926, giving access to UV measurements up to the high energy limit of 250 nm [79]. An important objective in the construction of these instruments was the desire to hold to a minimum the number of optical parts that had to be transparent to UV light. In Cotton’s photographic spectropolarimeter, the optical density of the photographs had to be evaluated by means of a photometer or, better, by a microphotometer. Although the recording was automatic, it was not continuous, but consisted of discrete exposures. Bruhat, on his part, used a photoelectric device. The data analysis could still be cumbersome, but the measurement of rotations in the UV had nevertheless become relatively easy. Bruhat’s polarimeter was perfected still further [80], to the extent that the photoelectric measurements became superior in precision to those obtained by the photographic method applied by Servant [73]. All the instruments mentioned so far are polarimeters. Similar advances had taken place in the construction of ellipsometers. Again, Bruhat was in the forefront with the development of a polarimeter–ellipsometer [81]. This widely used visual instrument consisted of an ordinary polarimeter, fitted with a mica λ/4 plate. Werner Kuhn developed an even more advanced photographic device for use in the ultraviolet [82]. It contained optical parts of quartz and fluorite only, and it allowed measurements to be taken all the way to 190 nm. This apparatus was the preferred instrument for many years to come and was marketed by the well-known makers of optical instruments in Berlin, Schmidt & Haensch. A similar ellipsometer was described by Mathieu in Paris [83]; it was designed particularly for the wavelength range of 450–280 nm. In conclusion, in the beginning of the 1930s, the development of instrumentation to measure the optical rotatory dispersion and the circular dichroism (in terms of ellipticities) had progressed to a state of perfection that was hard to improve upon in the decades to come. But, although it had been convincingly shown now that the Cotton effects of a wealth of optically active (organic) compounds were accessible, the chemical community at large was slow to make use of the chiroptical techniques. This resulted probably in part from the fact that the importance of stereochemistry had not yet been realized widely, especially among organic chemists. Also, the necessary apparatus still had to be built individually, and the measurement of ORD and CD was still far from being routine. Only with the advent of commercial recording instruments for ORD [84] and CD [85] many years later was the field of chiroptical investigations opened to the general chemist. Very few sentences must suffice on the contemporary development of the theory of optical activity, because this topic lies far away from the present overview. Paul Drude’s theory of optical activity in isotropic media, as expanded in his famous book of 1900 [26], has been the standard with which most physical(–chemical) research had to contend for the first three decades of the twentieth century. Many experimental investigations, including Lowry’s, have been motivated by the search for an improved version of the “Drude equation” of optical activity. An important step forward in this line was taken by L. Natanson, who in the year 1909 succeeded in deriving an equation that could approximate the optical dispersion within the absorption band, a problem that Drude’s original equation could not handle [17, 27, 28]. An advanced theory of optical activity
21
22
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
was published by Max Born (1882–1970, Nobel Prize 1954) in 1915 [86] and at about the same time by C. W. Oseen [87] and F. Gray [88]. Although the importance of these papers, especially Born’s, was immediately recognized, practically no direct influence on the study of chiroptical properties was engendered. Likewise, the important paper by the Belgian physicist L´eon Rosenfeld (1904–1974) on the quantum-mechanical theory of optical activity did not affect the chemical community at the time [89]. It took Werner Kuhn’s (1899–1963) simplification of Born’s theory into his coupled-oscillator model to attract the chemists’ attention [76, 90]. Now the application of theoretical methods to actual problems of stereochemistry seemed to become realistic. Even the determination of the absolute configuration of molecules might come into reach. Indeed, Kuhn’s conclusion that (−)-butan-2-ol had the (R) configuration was the culminating point of his theoretical work [91]. A comprehensive overview of these developments in theory is found in Mathieu’s monograph on the molecular theories of natural optical activity [92].
1.10. SOME WORDS ON NOMENCLATURE: COTTON EFFECT, OPTICAL ROTATORY DISPERSION, CD, ORD The expression “Cotton effect” (originally in German) was introduced by Israel Lifschitz in 1922. The earlier technical term, first used by Tschugaev in 1912 (also originally in German), is “Cotton’s phenomenon.” This latter expression developed gradually by the contraction of phrases like “anomale Rotationsdispersion im Sinne A. Cottons” (anomalous rotation dispersion in the sense of A. Cotton) [93] or “la mani`ere de voir de M. Cotton” (literally: Mr. Cotton’s way of viewing) and “ph´enom`ene de la dispersion anormale” (phenomenon of anomalous dispersion) [94]. Tschugaev never used the word “Cotton effect” in whatever language. It is slightly confusing, therefore, to find this term in his Russian collected works [95], but on closer inspection this turns out to appear in a posthumous translation of his German papers into Russian. He himself always wrote ” (i.e., Cotton’s phenomenon). in Russian “ As can be seen from Table 1.1, both expressions were used side by side for a period of 10 years, but eventually “Cotton effect” was victorious. The situation is slightly simpler with “rotatory dispersion.” From the beginning in 1877, this term had become established, with minor variations as shown in Table 1.2. The only point meriting some attention is the question, Why has rotatory dispersion nowadays become “optical rotatory dispersion”? The “optical” was originally added in order to differentiate between the two effects of magnetic and optical rotatory dispersion, both of which were the subject of a series of papers by Lowry, with the first one appearing in 1913. Usually, however, it was considered unnecessary to point to this difference, because magnetic rotatory dispersion rarely plays a role in chemistry. The modern habit of always referring to “optical rotatory dispersion”, which also led to the common abbreviation “ORD,” seems to originate with Carl Djerassi, who used it since 1955 in a great many papers and who publicized it further by his textbook on ORD. The counterpart expression with respect to circular dichroism should be “optical circular dichroism,” in order to likewise differentiate between optical and magnetic circular dichroism. Indeed, the French “fathers” of modern CD instruments and their application in chemistry have used the term “dichro¨ısme circulaire optique” [96], but for reasons unknown, in this case the chemical community has continued to ignore the “optical.” For the first half of the twentieth century, abbreviations were not much used in (physical) chemistry. With fashions changing, this became a craze, however, in the second half, especially in the United States and the Soviet Union. Typical is the general use
23
T H E F I R S T D E C A D E S A F T E R T H E D I S C O V E RY
TAB L E 1.1. The Change from Cotton’s Phenomenon to the Cotton Effect The Cotton Phenomenon 1912 1913 1914
1915 1922 1922 [1925]
1926
1930, 1933
L. Tschugaeff: Cottonsches Ph¨anomena L. Tchougaeff: ph´enom`ene Cottonb L. Tschugaeff: Cotton’s phenomenonc M. Del´epine: les ph´enom`enes d´ecouverts par M. Cottond H. Rupe: Cottonsches Ph¨anomene H. Grossmann: Cotton-Ph¨anomenf F. M. Jaeger: ph´enom`ene de Cottonh
The Cotton Effect
1922
J. Lifschitz: Cottoneffektg
1922 [1925] 1923
F. M. Jaeger: l’effet de M. Cottonh F. M. Jaeger: l’effet Cottoni
1928 1929 1930
S. Mitchell: Cotton Effectk W. Kuhn: COTTON-Effektl G. Bruhat: l’effet Cottonn
1935
T. M. Lowry: Cotton Effecto
W. Pfleiderer: Cottonsches Ph¨anomenj
T. M. Lowry: Cotton phenomenonm
Cotton effect (Engl.); Cottoneffekt (German, Danish); effet Cotton (French); Effeto Cotton (Italian); Efekt Cottona (Polish); (Russian) a L. Tschugaeff, J. Prakt. Chem. 1912, [2] 86 , 545–550; L. Tschugaeff, G. Glinin, Ber. Dtsch. Chem. Ges. 1912, 45 , 2759–2764. b L. Tchougaeff, A. Kirpitcheff, Bull. Soc. Chim. Fr. 1913, [4] 13 , 796–803. c L. Tschugaeff, Trans. Faraday Soc. 1914, 10 , 70–79. d M. Del´ epine, C. R. H. Acad. Sci . 1914, 159 , 239–241. e H. Rupe, Liebigs Ann. Chem. 1915, 409 , 327–357. f H. Grossmann, M. Wreschner, Die anomale Rotationsdispersion, Sammlung chem. u. chem.-techn. Vortr¨ age, W. Herz, ed., Enke, Stuttgart, 1922, 26 , 259–314. g J. Lifschitz, Rec. Trav. Chim. Pays-Bas 1922, 41 , 627–636. h F. M. Jaeger, Rapp. Disc. Inst. Int. Chimie Solvay (Conseil Chim. 1922, Bruxelles), Gauthier-Villars, Paris, 1925, 199–202. i F. M. Jaeger, Bull. Soc. Chim. Fr. 1923, [4] 33 , 853–889. j W. Pfleiderer, Z. Phys. 1926, 39 , 663–685. k S. Mitchell, J. Chem. Soc. London 1928, 3258–3260. l W. Kuhn, Z. Phys. Chem. 1929, B4 , 14–36. m T. M. Lowry, Trans. Faraday Soc. 1930, 26 , 266–271; T. M. Lowry, H. Hudson, Philos. Trans. 1933, A232, 117–154. n G. Bruhat, Trait´e de Polarim´etrie, Editions de la Revue d’Optique, Paris, 1930. o T. M. Lowry, Optical Rotatory Power, Longmans, Green and Co., London, 1935; reprint: Dover Publications, New York, 1964.
of “RD” in C. Djerassi’s book published in 1960, incidentally one of the first major applications of this abbreviation. It is amusing to note that here “RD” still refers to “rotatory dispersion,” of course, while the same author had already adopted “optical rotatory dispersion” for some years. It was consistent with adding “optical” to “rotatory dispersion,” to also add the letter “O” to the abbreviation “RD”: The birth of “ORD” took place in Djerassi’s environment in the early 1960s.
24
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
TAB L E 1.2. From Rotatory Dispersion to Optical Rotatory Dispersion Rotatory Dispersion, Dispersion Rotatoire, Rotationsdispersion
1913 1914 1915 1917 1935
H. Landolta: (anomale) Rotationsdispersion [German] A. Cottonb: dispersion rotatoire (anomale) [French] H. Grossmannc: (anormale) Rotationsdispersion [German] L. Tschugaeffd: anomale Rotationsdispersion im Sinne A. Cottons [German] L. Tschugaeffe: dispersion rotatoire ano(r)male [French] T. M. Lowryf : rotatory dispersion [English] T. S. Pattersong: (normal/abnormal) rotation-dispersion [English] T. M. Lowryh: an exact definition of normal and anomalous rotatory dispersion F. M. Jaegeri : rotatie-dispersie [Dutch] T. M. Lowryj : (normal and anomalous) rotatory dispersion [English]
1913 1926 1955 1959 1960
T. M. Lowryk: magnetic and optical rotatory dispersion [English] W. Pfleidererl : optische/magnetische Rotationsdispersion [German] C. Djerassim: Optical Rotatory Dispersion Studies [1st paper] [English] F. Woldbyen: optical rotatory dispersion [English] C. Djerassi: Optical Rotatory Dispersion, McGraw-Hill, New York [English]
1877 1895 1908 1911
Optical Rotatory Dispersion
a
H. Landolt, Liebigs Ann. Chem. 1877, 189 , 241–337 (p. 274). Cotton, C. R. H. Acad. Sci . 1895, 120 , 989–991. c H. Grossmann, H. Loeb, Z. Ver. Deutsch. Zuckerind., Allg. Teil 1908, 58 , 994–1009. d L. Tschugaeff, Z. Phys. Chem. 1911, 76 , 469–483. e L. Tschugaeff, A. Ogorodnikoff, Ann. Chim. Phys. 1911, [8] 22 , 137–144. f T. M. Lowry, J. Chem. Soc. London 1913, 103 , 1062–1067. g T. S. Patterson, Trans. Faraday Soc. 1914, 10 , 111–117. h T. M. Lowry, J. Chem. Soc. London 1915, 107 , 1195–1202. i F. M. Jaeger, Chem. Weekbl . 1917, 14 , 706–732. j T. M. Lowry, Optical Rotatory Power, Longmans, Green and Co., London, 1935. k T. M. Lowry, T. W. Dickson, J. Chem. Soc. London 1913, 103 , 1067–1075. l W. Pfleiderer, Z. Phys. 1926, 39 , 663–685. m C. Djerassi, E. W. Foltz, A. E. Lippman, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1955, 77 , 4354–4359. n F. Woldbye, Acta Chem. Scand . 1959, 13 , 2137–2139. b A.
The abbreviation “CD” for circular dichroism was introduced at about the same time. Whereas “OCD” has never become popular, “MCD” for magnetic circular dichroism is a logical and accepted abridgment. In the same vein, a reasonable abbreviation for magnetic rotatory dispersion should be “MRD”. The misnomer “MORD” (which in German means “murder,” by the way) should fall into disuse. Details concerning these various abbreviations are collected in Table 1.3. It remains to remind the reader that the terms “rotatory dispersion” and “circular dichroism” as well as their abbreviations might change, if languages other than English are used. Some examples are collated in Table 1.4.
1.11. BIOGRAPHICAL NOTICES: G. BRUHAT, A. COTTON, W. KUHN, I. LIFSCHITZ, T. M. LOWRY, L. NATANSON, AND L. TSCHUGAEV It is a moot question how far a treatise on the history of natural sciences ought to be supplemented by a personalized account. It is the present author’s contention that such an approach is helpful to provide a balanced background for the scientific results
25
T H E F I R S T D E C A D E S A F T E R T H E D I S C O V E RY
TAB L E 1.3. From RD to ORD (but not from CD to OCD) 1960
C. Djerassi,a Optical Rotatory Dispersion: “abbreviated RD (curves)”
1960
W. Klyne, Adv. Org. Chem. 1 , 239–348: “abbreviated R.D. curves”
1965
P. Crabb´e,b Optical Rotatory Dispersion and Circular Dichroism in Organic Chemistry: “circular dichroism, abbreviated CD; rotatory dispersion curves, abbreviated RD”
1965
L. Velluz, M. Legrand, M. Grosjean,c Optical Circular Dichroism: “CD-curves”
1963
D. Lightner,d PhD Thesis: ORD
1966
K. Mislow,e Introduction to Stereochemistry: ORD, CD [preface September 1964, © 1965, published 1966]
1967
G. Snatzke,f ed., Optical Rotatory Dispersion and Circular Dichroism in Organic Chemistry [Summer School, Bonn, 24 September–1 Oct., 1965]: ORD, CD; “MORD”, MCD
1972
P. Crabb´eg, ORD and CD in Chemistry and Biochemistry
a
McGraw-Hill, New York. Holden-Day, San Francisco. c Verlag Chemie, Weinheim/Academic Press, New York. d Stanford, CA. e W. A. Benjamin, New York. f Heyden & Son, London. g Academic Press, New York. b
TAB L E 1.4. ‘CD’’ and ‘‘ORD’’ [and ‘‘CE’’] in English, French, German, and Russian CD RD ORD
DC DR DRO
КД
circular dichroism, Circulardichroismus rotatory dispersion, Rotationsdispersion optical rotatory dispersion, optische Rotationsdispersion Круговой дихроизм
dichro¨ısme circulaire dispersion rotatoire dispersion rotatoire optique
ДОВ
Дисперсия оптического вращения
[CE
Cotton effect, Cotton-Effekt]
[EC
effet Cotton]
discussed in the foregoing sections. After all, the common expression “it was found that” is deceptive insofar as it tends to obscure the fact that these results were not “found” by anonymous agencies, but earned by individual scientists, working at a specific time and under specific circumstances that pertain to both their professional and their private lives. Among the many actors in the first decades after the discovery of the Cotton effect, who could be considered for some biographical notices, here seven scientists are selected, as listed in the section title in alphabetical order. These names may reflect some personal predilection, but it is not too difficult to defend these choices impartially: Cotton is, of course, of outstanding importance. Natanson opened the route to an understanding of the interconnection of CD, ORD, and absorption generally. Tschugaev pioneered the investigation of chiroptical properties of organic molecules, while Lifschitz did the same with coordination compounds and has, moreover, coined the technical term “Cotton effect.” Bruhat was of particular importance for the development of instruments for chiroptical studies, together with Lowry and Kuhn, while the two latter scientists (both of them chemists, by the way) were instrumental also for the progress in the application
26
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
of the theory of optical activity to chemical problems. All of these persons earned universal recognition, and even fame, also in other fields of chemistry or physics. All of them would merit attention, even if their part in the progress of chiroptics were to be neglected. Actually, for some among them, their activity in this field was rather incidental, if seen against their lifetime achievements. In the following, summary biographies of these scholars will be related in sequence according to their date of birth, with Cotton’s biography at the end, however. The theoretical physicist Ladisla(u)s [Władysław] Natanson (1864–1937) was born in Warszawa (Warsaw), Poland, the son of a medical doctor. Warsaw was under Russian rule at the time, and Natanson was a Russian subject. After graduation from a classical school in 1882, he enrolled as a student at the Faculty of Sciences of the University of St. Petersburg, where he became a “Candidate” (Licentiate) in 1886. After a few months at the Cavendish Laboratory at Cambridge, U.K., he returned to Imperial Russia in order to fulfil the requirements necessary for Russian subjects who wanted to embark on an academic career. Therefore, in 1887 he moved to Dorpat, Livonia (now Tartu, Estonia), to work for his doctorate with the physicist Professor A. von Oettingen, which he obtained in 1888. Incidentally, the official language at the University of Dorpat was German. After some postdoctoral studies with L. Boltzmann at the University of Graz, Austria, he returned to Warsaw to write an “Introduction to Theoretical Physics” [97]. This book was met with much acclaim, which helped him to be granted a position at the Jagiellonian University Krak´ow (Cracow), Poland (then under Austrian rule). There he moved up through the academic ranks: 1894 Titular Professor, 1899 Extraordinary Professor, and finally 1902 Professor of Theoretical Physics. Later he was also appointed Dean of the Faculty, and in 1922/23 he became Rector of the University. Elected to the Academy of Sciences in 1893, he became President of the Section of Mathematical and Natural Sciences in 1926, until he resigned from both the Academy and the University in 1935 for health reasons. His professional achievements are expanded upon in the obituary notice by L´eon Klecki, which includes a bibliography [98]. The chemist Lev Aleksandrovi(ts)ch Tschugaev (Chugaev) (1873–1922) was born in Moscow, Russia. After completing his studies at the University of Moscow in 1894, he became Assistant at the Bacteriological Institute of the University, where he started his research on the optical activity of organic compounds. From the beginning, Tschugaev strove to be competent in organic as well as inorganic chemistry. His master’s thesis in 1903 dealt with studies in the terpene and camphor series, while in his doctoral thesis (habilitation) of 1906 he presented results from coordination chemistry. Throughout his life, he successfully followed this dichotomy in his research, with some excursions into physical chemistry. In 1906 he was appointed Professor at the Technical University in Moscow, and in 1908 he was called to the Chair of Inorganic Chemistry at the Imperial University of St. Petersburg (later: University of Petrograd). He held this position at the time of his death. During World War I and the Russian Revolution he was mainly active in the field of technical and applied chemistry. He was one of the founders of the Institute of Applied Chemistry in Petrograd and became its director. In the aftermath of the revolution, he died of typhoid fever at Wologda, Russia, at the age of not yet 50. Obituary notices have appeared in England [62] and in Germany [99], acknowledging his abundant contributions to chemistry. Attention should also be paid to his “Selected Works” [95]. The physical chemist Thomas Martin Lowry (1874–1936) was born at Low Moor, Bradford, Yorks., U.K., the son of a Wesleyan Chaplain. He studied at the Central Technical College, South Kensington, London. From 1896 to 1913 he was assistant to Professor
T H E F I R S T D E C A D E S A F T E R T H E D I S C O V E RY
H. E. Armstrong and from 1904–1913 he was Lecturer in Chemistry at the Westminster Training College. In 1913 he became Head of the Chemical Department in Guy’s Hospital Medical School and Professor of the University of London. In 1920, finally, he was appointed to the newly created Chair of Physical Chemistry at Cambridge University. He continued at Cambridge for the rest of his life. In his extensive obituary notice, W. J. Pope wrote [100]: “[The book] on “Optical Rotatory Power” was issued in 1935 and will long remain a standard work on the subject. The immense amount of accurate experimental work which Lowry has left on record secures him a permanent place in the history of the science to which he was devoted.” But, although chiroptical methods are central to this overview, Lowry’s important contributions to other areas should not be forgotten. Mention may be made of his studies of the polymorphism of inorganic salts, his “Studies of Valency” and of the nitrogen oxide/water system, the nature of the sulfur halides, and the stereochemistry of tellurium compounds. In all cases he tried to apply modern physical concepts to chemical problems. Lowry was a member of the Faraday Society from its beginnings in 1903 and acted as its president in 1928–1930. He became a Fellow of the Royal Society in 1914. The physicist Georges Bruhat (1887–1945) was born in Besanc¸on, France, the ´ son of a civil servant. He was admitted with honors into the renowned Ecole Normale Sup´erieure (ENS) in Paris in 1906. After having obtained his B.Sc. (“licence e` s sciences physiques”) at the University of Paris, he acquired the qualification to teach at secondary schools (as “Professeur agr´eg´e ”) and taught at a high school in Paris for one year. Perhaps this interval in his scientific career awakened his interest in teaching and in writing textbooks for this purpose. He then got a position as laboratory assistant (“pr´eparateur”) at the ENS, which enabled him to work under the guidance of A. Cotton on his doctoral dissertation: “La dispersion anormale du pouvoir rotatoire mol´eculaire” (the anomalous dispersion of the molecular rotatory power). After an interruption by his military service during the First World War, he could continue his academic career in 1919 in Lille, France, where he was Professor of General Physics from 1921 to 1927. His successor was Marcel Pauthenier, by the way, who had been his partner in the construction of UV spectropolarimeters [79]. Bruhat returned to the University of Paris in 1929 as Lecturer and Professor Extraordinary. In 1938 he was promoted to the Chair of Theoretical and Celestial Physics. During this time he published four compendious textbooks on general physics: Electricity (1924), Thermodynamics (1926), Optics (1930), and Mechanics (1934). These books have become standard texts in French universities, with many editions; Optics, for example, has been reedited as recently as 2004. Bruhat also continued his association with the ENS, serving as “Sub-Director” from 1935, and as acting director during World War II. In the beginning of August 1944, he was arrested by the political police (“Gestapo”) of the German occupation powers and held prisoner in lieu of a student accused of activities in the French Resistance Movement. He was taken to Germany into a concentration camp and died there on January 1, 1945, of pneumonia and exhaustion. The chemist Israel Lifschitz (1888–1951) was born in Shklov, Russia (now Belarus) (see Figure 1.4). His family was German and lived in Leipzig, Germany. His mother had moved to Shklov just for her confinement, motivated by family regards. He studied chemistry at the University of Leipzig and worked there for his doctoral degree under the guidance of A. Hantzsch. His dissertation of 1911 dealt with the spectroscopic properties of various organic nitrogen compounds. Faithful to the ideas already developed in this dissertation, his main interest became the correlation of chemical constitution and bonding with electronic absorption. Although by training he was an organic chemist, his research
27
28
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
Figure 1.4. Israel Lifschitz. (Photograph provided by Ms. E. H. Lifschitz, Haifa, and reproduced with her permission.)
led him far into physical chemistry and, later, also inorganic chemistry. Leaving Leipzig in 1911, he moved to the University of Zurich, Switzerland, for his habilitation. To this end, he submitted a second dissertation on the changes of light absorption by organic acids on salt formation. As a result, the title of “Private Docent of Chemistry” was conferred on him in 1914, allowing him to do independent research, but not connected with any paid position. The life of a Private Docent was difficult, unless one was privately affluent. The economic troubles after World War I also forced Lifschitz to interrupt his work at the university in 1920, in order to look for a source of income outside of Academia, to support his growing family. Lifschitz extended his investigations to include the optical rotatory dispersion of transition metal coordination compounds (see, e.g., paper V of a series on the function of chromophores [101]); after 1920 this became his central area of research. From these papers it can be deduced that he had established a cooperative arrangement with the Dutch inorganic stereochemist F. M. Jaeger at the Rijksuniversiteit Groningen (RUG) in the Netherlands, by 1919 at the latest. Jaeger invited Lifschitz to join his laboratory and offered him a tenured staff position as “Conservator”. This induced Lifschitz to move to Groningen, although he had become a Swiss citizen and probably had intended to stay in that country. As a result, in the summer of 1921, Lifschitz became Private Docent
T H E F I R S T D E C A D E S A F T E R T H E D I S C O V E RY
of Electrochemistry and Photochemistry, as well as Conservator at the Laboratory of Inorganic and Physical Chemistry at RUG. He helped to develop the department into a center of chiroptical spectroscopy. RUG became the birthplace of the “Cotton effect,” since Lifschitz coined this technical term there. The relevance of his research was readily acknowledged by stereochemists and physical chemists at other institutions. Already in 1935, J.-P. Mathieu in Paris had pointed out that Lifschitz was the first to systematically investigate the relations between the experimental data on the Cotton effect and the chemical bonds in optically active compounds [83]. Lifschitz held his position at RUG until he was dismissed in November 1940 for political reasons. Under the German occupation of the Netherlands in World War II, the situation of Jewish people deteriorated continually. Since Lifschitz was unable to continue his research at RUG, he turned again to his private studies of the mystical movements in Judaism, of which he was a dedicated and competent scholar. He was a deeply religious person, who had also published on related subjects. Now he became absorbed again in his studies of Chassidism, and he gave even private lessons on the Zohar. All this ended, when he, his wife, and their five children were detained in February 1943. He was eventually deported to the Theresienstadt Concentration Camp in Bohemia in September 1944, separated from his three sons, two of whom did not survive the ordeal. Liberated at the end of the war, he, his wife, and the three children left returned to Groningen, where he was reinstalled at RUG. He died in the Netherlands in 1953 and was buried in Haifa, Israel. The dire story of the family’s fate has been reported by his elder daughter Esther Hadassa Lifschitz [102]. It had proved to be fatal that the Dutch authorities had insisted, shortly before the war, that the family accept Dutch citizenship while relinquishing their Swiss citizenship. An attempt to regain Swiss nationality during World War II failed. It is likely that they could have otherwise left for Switzerland. The present paper may perhaps draw some attention to Lifschitz, who has been undeservedly forgotten. The physical chemist Werner Kuhn (1899–1963) was born at Maur am Greifensee, Switzerland, the son of a pastor. He studied chemistry at the ETH Z¨urich and obtained his doctorate at the University of Zurich in 1923, with a dissertation on a photochemical topic. After working with Niels Bohr in Copenhagen, Denmark, for two years, he returned to Zurich for his habilitation in physical chemistry in 1927. He moved to Germany thereafter. For three years he worked at the University of Heidelberg, where he started his research on optical activity; in 1930–1936 he worked at the Technische Hochschule Karlsruhe, and in 1936 he occupied the Chair of Physical Chemistry at the University of Kiel. In the year 1939 he returned to his home country, when he was called to the Chair of Physical Chemistry at the University of Basel. Later he was also elected rector of the University. He remained there until the end of his life. A report on “Leben und Werk von Werner Kuhn” (life and work of W. K.), including a bibliography, appeared in 1984 in connection with a “Werner Kuhn Symposium” of the Swiss Chemical Society [103]. The physicist Aim´e Auguste Cotton (1869–1951) was born in the French provincial town of Bourg-en-Bresse, where his father taught mathematics (see Figure 1.5). He was ´ a student of physics at the Ecole Normale Sup´erieure (ENS) in Paris from 1890 to 1893. He completed his doctoral studies, in the course of which he discovered the “Cotton effect” at the Laboratory of Physics with M. Brillouin and J. Violle and earned the title “Docteur e` s-sciences physiques” in 1896. It is noteworthy that he included in his thesis his first attempts at measuring magnetic optical activity, since his future scientific career was to be centered on the physics of magnetism and magneto-optics. It would be in these fields, rather than in research on natural optical activity, that he would rise to eminence.
29
30
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
Figure 1.5. Aime´ Auguste Cotton. (From L. de Broglie, Notice sur la vie et l’œvre de Aime´ ´ Cotton, Academie des sciences—Institut de France, Paris, 1953; reproduced with permission.)
After a few years at the Faculty of Sciences of the University of Toulouse as Assistant/Associate Professor (Maˆıtre de Conf´erences, Professeur adjoint), he returned to the ENS in Paris, entrusted with the substitution of the Academician J. Violle, his teacher, for the period of 1900–1904. From 1904 to 1922 he served as Lecturer (Charg´e de cours) at the Faculty of Sciences of the University of Paris, delegated to the ENS. He was promoted to Professeur-adjoint in 1910 and became Professor of Theoretical and Celestial Physics at the Sorbonne in 1920. Finally, he was called to the Chair of General Physics there in 1922, succeeding G. Lippmann (Nobel Prize 1908). In 1923 he was elected a member of the illustrious Academy of Sciences as successor to J. Violle. He even became President of the Academy in 1938. Cotton retired from the Sorbonne in 1941, but continued until his death as Director of the Laboratory for Magneto-Optical Studies that he had founded in 1927. In France, A. Cotton is considered to be one of the eminent physicists of the twentieth century. He himself described his scientific aims and accomplishments in a 1923 pamphlet on the occasion of his election to the Academy [104]. As he pointed out, he had worked extensively on the Zeeman effect, but even more on the magneto-optical properties of colloids and molecular solutions. Many of the latter investigations were performed in
T H E F I R S T D E C A D E S A F T E R T H E D I S C O V E RY
cooperation with the biologist Henri Mouton (1869–1935) of the Institute Pasteur (later Professor of Physical Chemistry at the University of Paris). Together they discovered in 1907 the important “Cotton-Mouton-Effect” (magnetic field induced linear birefringence) [105]. Cotton’s fame in physics rests, arguably, more on this discovery than on the “Cotton effect” in natural optical activity. Detailed information on his life and work is easily available thanks to various obituaries [106] and to a notice published on the occasion of the centenary of his birth [107]. Cotton received many honors and was awarded many prizes. He was nominated for the Physics Nobel Prize in the years 1915, 1916, 1920, 1922, 1925, 1927, 1928, 1929, 1930, 1931, 1932, 1933, 1934, 1944, and 1949, but without success [108]. His memory is kept alive in France with the “Laboratoire Aim´e Cotton,” as his former Laboratory for Magneto-Optical Studies has been renamed. It is now the Atomic and Molecular Physics Laboratory of CNRS, associated with the University Paris XI and situated on its campus in Orsay. Also the “Prix Aim´e Cotton” should be mentioned, which was established by the French Physical Society in 1953 in memory of A. Cotton and is awarded annually. In what esteem he is held by the French physicists is also apparent by the fact that he is one of the twelve “most eminent” physicists chosen by the Academy on the occasion of the World Year of Physics 2005 (WYP2005/UNESCO). Among chemists of countries other than France, and especially among the younger fold, the name “Cotton” rarely brings to their minds memories of a specific person, unfortunately, unless they mistake it for the name of the distinguished American inorganic chemist A. Albert Cotton (1930–2007) of textbook fame. However, whether they know anything about the person or not, for the chemists working in chiroptics or stereochemistry, T. M. Lowry’s words of 1935 still hold true [21]: Cotton’s discovery in absorbing optically-active media of the twin phenomena of circular dichroism and of anomalous rotatory dispersion, which are indissolubly associated with his name, is [. . .] amongst the “classics.”
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS It is a pleasure to acknowledge the kind cooperation of Ms. E. H. Lifschitz in Haifa, Israel, who has provided important information on her father, Israel Lifschitz, and has permitted the publication of his photograph. It is a privilege to acknowledge also the untiring help of Dr. Henry Joshua of New York City, who has overcome many difficulties in his endeavors to establish contacts with Ms. Lifschitz, whose whereabouts had been unknown. The author is also grateful to Professor Jerome Gurst of Pensacola, Florida, for language counseling and for his helpful critique of the manuscript.
REFERENCES 1. D. F. Arago, M´em. Cl. Sci. Math´em. Phys. Inst. France 1811, 12 , I, 1–16, 113–134 (published 1812); [J. B.] Biot, Phys. Inst. France 1812, 13 , I, 1–372 (May 1813). 2. J. B. Biot, Bull. Sci. Soc. Philomath. 1815, [3] 2 , 190–192. 3. J. B. Biot, M´em. Acad. Roy. Sci. Inst. France 1817, [2] 2 , 41–136 (September 1818). 4. A. Arndtsen, Ann. Chim. Phys. 1858, [3] 54 , 403–421; Pogg. Ann. 1858, [2] 105 , 312–317.
31
32
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
5. H. Landolt, Liebigs Ann. Chem. 1877, 189 , 241–337 (p. 274). 6. J. B. Biot, Ann. Chim. Phys. 1860, [3] 59 , 206–326; appendix 326–345 (page 266/7, Section III, 8). In this appendix, by the way, Biot refutes claims that the Baltic-German physicist Thomas Johann Seebeck (1710–1831) might have been the first to observe optical activity in solutions. 7. H. Landolt, Das optische Drehungsverm¨ogen organischer Substanzen und die praktischen Anwendungen desselben, Vieweg und Sohn, Braunschweig, 1879; English translation: Handbook of the Polariscope, D. C. Robb, V. H. Veley, translators, Cambridge, 1882 (reprint: BiblioLife, Charleston, SC, 2009). 2nd ed. Vieweg und Sohn, Braunschweig, 1898; English translation: The Optical Rotating Power of Organic Substances, J. H. Long, translator, Chemical Publishing Co., Easton, PA, 1902. 8. H. Fehling, Arch. Physiol. Heilkunde 1848, 7 , 64–73; Ann. Chem. Pharm. 1849, 72 , 106–113. 9. F. (-)P. Leroux, C. R. H. Acad. Sci . 1862, 55 , 126–128; Pogg. Ann. 1862, [2] 117 , 659–660. 10. C. Christiansen, Pogg. Ann. 1870, [2] 141 , 479–480; Pogg. Ann. 1871, [2] 143 , 250–259. A. Kundt, Pogg. Ann. 1870, [2] 142 , 163–171; Pogg. Ann. 1871, [2] 143 , 149–152; Pogg. Ann. 1871, [2] 143 , 259–269. J.-L. Soret, Arch. Sci. Phys. Natur. 1871, [2] 40 , 280–283. 11. A. Cotton, Absorption in´egale des rayons circulaires droit et gauche dans certain corps actifs, C. R. H. Acad. Sci . 1895, 120 , 989–991. 12. A. Cotton, Dispersion rotatoire anomale des corps absorbants, C. R. H. Acad. Sci . 1895, 120 , 1044–1046. 13. A. Cotton, Recherches sur l’absorption et la dispersion de la lumi`ere par les milieux dou´es du pouvoir rotatoire, Th`ese de Doctorat, Paris, 1896; Ann. Chim. Phys. 1896, [7] 8 , 347–432; summary: J. Phys. Th´eor. Appl . 1896, [3] 5 , 237–244. 14. [J. B.] Biot, Bull. Sci. Soc. Philomath. 1815, [3] 2 , 26–27; W. Haidinger, Pogg. Ann. 1845, [2] 65 , 1–30. 15. W. Haidinger, Pogg. Ann. 1847, [2] 70 , 531–544. 16. It would be interesting to know if Fehling’s solution was indeed Cotton’s very first sample. Apparently his papers, including his laboratory notebooks 1895–1920, are at the Niels Bohr Library, American Center for Physics, College Park, MD. 17. L. Natanson, Bull. Int. Acad. Sci. Cracovie, Cl. Sci. Math. Nat., Jan. 1909, 25–37. 18. A. Cotton, J. Phys. Th´eor. Appl . 1898, [3] 7 , 81–85. 19. F. Billet, Trait´e d’optique physique, Mallet-Bachelier, Paris, 1858/59 (2 vols.). 20. N. Wedeneewa, Ann. Phys. 1923, [4] 72 , 122–140. 21. T. M. Lowry, Optical Rotatory Power, Longmans, Green and Co., London, 1935; reprint: Dover Publications, New York, 1964. 22. S. Mitchell, The Cotton Effect and Related Phenomena, G. Bell & Sons, London, 1933. 23. W. Kuhn, A. Szabo, Z. Phys. Chem. 1931, B15 , 59–73. 24. W. O. [i.e., W. Ostwald], Z. Phys. Chem. 1896, 19 , 383, no. 87 and 88. 25. W. O. [i.e., W. Ostwald], Z. Phys. Chem. 1896, 21 , 158–163. 26. P. Drude, Lehrbuch der Optik , Hirzel, Leipzig, 1900; English translation: The Theory of Optics, C. R. Mann, R. A. Millikan [Nobel Prize 1923], translators, Longmans, Green & Co., London, 1902; reprint: Dover Publications, New York, 1959. 27. L. Natanson, Bull. Int. Acad. Sci. Cracovie, Cl. Sci. Math. Nat., O eliptycznej polaryzacyi s´wiatła, przepuszczonego przez ciało naturalnie , Oct. 1908, 764–783. 28. L. Natanson, J. Phys. Th´eor. Appl . 1909, 8 , 321–347. 29. A. Cotton, C. R. H. Acad. Sci . 1911, 153 , 245–247.
T H E F I R S T D E C A D E S A F T E R T H E D I S C O V E RY
30. W. Kuhn, Proc. [2 nd] Conf. Rotatory Dispersion, Santa Fe, CA, 20–22 Jan., 1960; Tetrah. 1961, 13 , 1–12. 31. M. F. McDowell, Phys. Rev . 1905, 20 , 163–171. 32. L. B. Olmstead, Phys. Rev . 1912, 35 , 31–46. 33. H. Grossmann, A. Loeb, Z. Ver. Deutsch. Zuckerind., Allg. Teil 1908, 58 , 994–1009. 34. H. Volk, Ber. Dtsch. Chem. Ges. 1912, 45 , 3744–3748. 35. G. Bruhat, Th`ese de Doctorat, Paris, June 1914; Ann. Physique 1915, [9] 3 , 232–282, 417–489. 36. G. Bruhat, Ann. Physique 1920, [9] 13 , 25–48. 37. R. de Mallemann, P. Gabiano, C. R. H. Acad. Sci . 1927, 185 , 350–352. 38. J.-P. Mathieu, C. R. H. Acad. Sci . 1931, 193 , 1079–1081; Ann. Physique 1935, [11] 3 , 371–460. 39. J.-P. Mathieu, C. R. H. Acad. Sci . 1932, 194 , 1727–1729. 40. W. Pfleiderer, Z. Phys. 1926, 39 , 663–685. 41. R. D. Gillard, Progr. Inorg. Chem. 1966, 7 , 215–276. Oddly, this author maintains that “Aim´e Cotton (1872–1944) discovered the [Cotton] effect while Professor of Physics at the Sorbonne in Paris.” Both the dates (recte: 1869–1951) and the professorship are erroneous (Cotton became a Professor at the Sorbonne in 1910, but had discovered the effect in 1895). 42. A. Werner, Z. Anorg. Allg. Chem. 1893, 3 , 267–330; see also: Vierteljahresschrift der Z¨urch. Naturf. Ges. 1891, 36 , 129–169. 43. A. Werner, Ber. Dtsch. Chem. Ges. 1911, 44 , 1887–1898. 44. M. Del´epine, C. R. H. Acad. Sci . 1914, 159 , 239–241; Bull. Soc. Chim. Fr. 1917, [4] 21 , 157–172. 45. G. Bruhat, Bull. Soc. Chim. Fr. 1915, [4] 17 , 223–227. 46. A. Werner, Ber. Dtsch. Chem. Ges. 1912, 45 , 121–130; 3061–3070. 47. A. Werner, J. Poupardin, Ber. Dtsch. Chem. Ges. 1914, 47 , 1954–1960. 48. A. Werner, Ber. Dtsch. Chem. Ges. 1914, 47 , 3087–3094. 49. A. Werner, Helv. Chim. Acta 1918, 1 , 5–32. 50. Important reviews of stereochemistry and optical activity at Groningen: F. M. Jaeger, Proc. Akad. Wet. Amsterdam 1915, 17 , 1217–1236; Lectures on the Principle of Symmetry, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1917 (2nd enlarged edition 1920); Bull. Soc. Chim. Fr. 1923, [4] 33 , 853–889; Spatial Arrangements of Atomic Systems and Optical Activity, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1930. 51. F. M. Jaeger, Rec. Trav. Chim. Pays-Bas 1919, 38 , 171–314. 52. J. Lifschitz, Z. Phys. Chem. 1923, 105 , 27–54. It may be pointed out that the author abbreviated his first name, Israel, in print usually by the letter “J”; this was not uncommon in those days. 53. J. Lifschitz, Z. Phys. Chem. 1925, 114 , 485–499. 54. F. M. Jaeger, H. B. Blumendal, Z. Anorg. Allg. Chem. 1928, 175 , 161–230. 55. W. Kuhn, K. Bein, Z. Anorg. Allg. Chem. 1933/34, 216 , 321–348 (ORD); Z. Phys. Chem. 1934, B24 , 335–369 (CD). 56. R. E. Ballard, A. J. McCaffery, S. F. Mason, Proc. Chem. Soc. London 1962, 331–332. 57. A. J. McCaffery, S. F. Mason, Proc. Chem. Soc. London 1962, 388–389. 58. H. Rupe, Zeltner, W. Lotz, M. Silberberg, Liebigs Ann. Chem. 1903, 327 , 157–200 (first paper of the series); H. Rupe, L. Silberstrom, Liebigs Ann. Chem. 1918, 414 , 99–111 (ninth paper). 59. T. M. Lowry, J. Chem. Soc. London 1899, 75 , 211–244.
33
34
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
60. H. Rupe, A. Krethlow, K. Langbein, Liebigs Ann. Chem. 1921, 423 , 324–342 (thirteenth paper of the series [58]). 61. T. M. Lowry, ed., Trans. Faraday Soc. 1914, 10 , 44–138. 62. So transliterated by T. M. Lowry in the obituary note (J. Chem. Soc. London 1923, 123 , himself, who often published in Germany, usually spells his name 956–958). . A. there Tschugaeff, and sometimes Tch´ugaeff or Tschugajew, in France also Tchougaeff. Chemical Abstracts always list him as L[ev] A[leksandrovich] Chugaev. In the references to this overview, the original spelling as given in the papers has been chosen. 63. L. Tschugaeff, Ber. Dtsch. Chem. Ges. 1909, 42 , 2244–2247 (paper I of the series); L. Tschugaeff, A. Ogorodnikoff, Z. Phys. Chem. 1910, 74 , 503–512 (II); L. Tschugaeff, Z. Phys. Chem. 1911, 76 , 469–483 (III); L. Tschugaeff, A. Ogorodnikoff, Z. Phys. Chem. 1912, 79 , 471–480 (IV); L. Tschugaeff, A. Ogorodnikoff, Z. Phys. Chem. 1913, 85 , 481–510 (V); L. Tschugaeff, W. Pastanogoff, Z. Phys. Chem. 1913, 85 , 553–572 (VI). See also: L. Tschugaeff, A. Ogorodnikoff, Ann. Chim. Phys. 1911, [8] 22 , 137–144; L. Tschugaeff, J. Prakt. Chem. 1912, [2] 86 , 545–550; L. Tchougaeff, Bull. Soc. Chim. Fr. 1912, [4] 11 , 718–722; L. Tschugaeff, G. Glinin, Ber. Dtsch. Chem. Ges. 1912, 45 , 2759–2764; L. Tchugaeff, A. Kirpitcheff, Bull. Soc. Chim. Fr. 1913, [4] 13 , 796–803; L. Tschugaeff, , A. A. , , B. [L. Trans. Faraday Soc. 1914, 10 , 70–79; . A. 1915, A. Tschugaev, A. A. Glebko, G. V. Pigulevskii], J. Russ. Phys. Chem. Soc. 47 , 774–775. 64. G. Bruhat, C. R. H. Acad. Sci . 1911, 153 , 248–250. 65. T. M. Lowry, H. Hudson, Philos. Trans. 1933, A232 , 117–154. 66. T. M. Lowry, H. K. Gore, Proc. Roy. Soc. 1932, A135 , 13–22. 67. E. Deussen, J. Prakt. Chem. 1912, [2] 85 , 484–488. 68. L. Tschugaeff, J. Prakt. Chem. 1912, [2] 86 , 545–550. 69. S. Mitchell, J. Chem. Soc. London 1928, 3258–3260. 70. E. Darmois, Ann. Chim. Phys. 1911, [8] 22 , 247–281, 485–590; Th`ese de Doctorat, Paris, 1910. 71. W. Kuhn, H. K. Gore, Z. Phys. Chem. 1931, B12 , 389–397. 72. T. M. Lowry, H. S. French, J. Chem. Soc. London 1932, 2654–2658. 73. R. Servant, C. R. H. Acad. Sci . 1932, 194 , 368–369. 74. C. Djerassi, Optical Rotatory Dispersion. Applications to Organic Chemistry, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1960. ´ 75. G. Bruhat, Trait´e de Polarim´etrie [with a preface by A. Cotton], Editions de la Revue d’Optique th´eorique et instrumentale, Paris, 1930. 76. Review: W. Kuhn, Theorie und Grundgesetze der optischen Aktivit¨at [theory and fundamental principles of optical activity], in Stereochemie, K. Freudenberg, ed., Deuticke, Leipzig, 1933, pp. 317–434. 77. R. Descamps, Trans. Faraday Soc. 1930, 26 , 357–371. 78. T. M. Lowry, Proc. Roy. Soc. 1908, A81 , 472–474; Philos. Trans. 1912, A212 , 261–297; T. M. Lowry, W. H. C. Coode-Adams, Philos. Trans. 1927, A226 , 391–466. 79. A. Cotton, R. Descamps, C. R. H. Acad. Sci . 1926, 182 , 22–26; R. Descamps, Rev. Opt. Th´eor. Instr. 1926, 5 , 481–501; G. Bruhat, M. Pauthenier, C. R. H. Acad. Sci . 1926, 182 , 888–890 (with comments by A. Cotton, C. R. H. Acad. Sci . 1926, 182 , 890–891); G. Bruhat, M. Pauthenier, Rev. Opt. Th´eor. Instr. 1927, 6 , 163–184. 80. G. Bruhat, P. Chatelain, C. R. H. Acad. Sci . 1932, 195 , 462–465; J. Physique 1932, [7] 3 , 501–511; G. Bruhat, A. Guinier, C. R. H. Acad. Sci . 1933, 196 , 762–764; Rev. Opt. Th´eor. Instr. 1933, 12 , 396–416. 81. G. Bruhat, Bull. Soc. Chim. Fr. 1930, [4] 47 , 251–261.
T H E F I R S T D E C A D E S A F T E R T H E D I S C O V E RY
82. W. Kuhn, Ber. Dtsch. Chem. Ges. 1929, 62 , 1727–1731; W. Kuhn, E. Braun, Z. Phys. Chem. 1930, B8 , 445–454. 83. J.-P. Mathieu, Ann. Physique 1935, [11] 3 , 371–460. 84. H. Rudolph, J. Opt. Soc. Am. 1955, 45 , 50–59; Rudolph Photoelectric Spectropolarimeter®, O. C. Rudolph & Sons, Caldwell, NJ. 85. M. Grosjean, M. Legrand, C. R. H. Acad. Sci . 1960, 251 , 2150–2152 (Centre de Recherche Roussel-Uclaf); Dichrograph®, Societ´e Jouan, Paris. 86. M. Born, Phys. Z . 1915, 16 , 251–258; Ann. Phys. 1918, [4] 55 , 177–240. 87. C. W. Oseen, Ann. Phys. 1915, [4] 48 , 1–56. 88. F. Gray, Phys. Rev . 1916, [2] 7 , 472–488. 89. L. Rosenfeld, Z. Phys. 1928/29, 52 , 161–174; Rosenfeld was at that time a postdoctoral associate with M. Born in G¨ottingen, Germany. 90. W. Kuhn, Z. Phys. Chem. 1929, B4 , 14–36. 91. W. Kuhn, Z. Phys. Chem. 1935/36, B31 , 23–57. 92. J.-P. Mathieu, Les Th´eories Mol´eculaires du Pouvoir Rotatoire Naturel , Gauthier-Villars, Paris, 1946. 93. L. Tschugaeff, Z. Phys. Chem. 1911, 76 , 469–483. 94. L. Tschugaeff, A. Ogorodnikoff, Ann. Chim. Phys. 1911, [8] 22 , 137–144. , , Publishing House of the Academy of Sciences of the SSSR, 95. . A. Moscow, 1955. 96. L. Velluz, M. Legrand, M. Grosjean, C. R. H. Acad. Sci . 1963, 256 , 1878–1881. do fizyki teoretycznej , Redakcye “Prac Matematyczno-Fizycznych”, War97. L. Natanson, saw, 1890. 98. L. Klecki, Prace Matematyczno-Fizyczne 1939, 46 , 1–18 (in French). 99. J. Salkind, Ber. Dtsch. Chem. Ges. 1922, 55 , 141A–142A. 100. W. J. Pope: Thomas Martin Lowry, Obituary Notices of Fellows of the Royal Society 1938, 2 , 287–293. 101. J. Lifschitz, E. Rosenbohm, Z. Wiss. Photogr., Photophys. Photochem. 1920, 19 , 198–214. 102. E. H. Lifschitz, Er was weinig begrip voor de joden [there was not much sympathy with the Jews], in Terug van weggeweest, J. van Gelder, ed., Stichting Geldersboek, Groningen, 1993, pp. 141–148 (Chapter 15); also: private communication to the author. 103. H. Kuhn, Chimia 1984, 38 , 191–211. 104. A. Cotton, Notice sur les Travaux Scientifiques, Presses Universitaires de France, Paris, 1923. 105. A. Cotton, H. Mouton, Ann. Chim. Phys. 1907, [8] 11 , 145–203, 289–339. 106. M. Javillier, C. R. H. Acad. Sci . 1951, 232 , 1521–1527; J. Cabannes [Cotton’s successor at the Sorbonne], Ann. Physique 1951, [12] 6 , 895–898; Louis [Prince] de Broglie [Nobel Prize 1929], Notice sur la vie et l’œvre de Aim´e Cotton, Institut de France, Acad´emie des Sciences, Paris, 1953 [30 pages]. 107. A. Kastler, C. R. H. Acad. Sci . 1969, 269 , 70–74. 108. E. Crawford, The Nobel Population 1901–1950: A Census of the Nominators and Nominees for the Prizes in Physics and Chemistry, Universal Academy Press, Tokyo, 2002. (Nomination 1915, page 62 (C. Fabry, nominator). Similarly: 1916, p.64 (M. Brillouin); 1920, p.80 (J. Bordet); 1922, p.84 (J. Bordet); 1925, p.94 (J. Bordet); 1927, p.102 (J. Bordet, C.E. Guillaume, C.E. Guye, A.Schidlof); 1928, p.106 (C.E. Guillaume); 1929 , p.110 (C.E. Guillaume); 1930, p.116 (C.E. Guillaume, H. Villat); 1931, p.120 (C.E. Guillaume, R. de Mallemann); 1932, p.124 (C.E. Guillaume, G. Reboul); 1933, p.128 (C.E. Guillaume); 1934, p.132 (H. Buisson, C.E. Guillaume, C.E. Guye, J. Perrin, V. Posejpal, P. S`eve); 1944, p.170 (H. Beghin); 1949, p.186 (M. Pauthenier)).
35
PART II ORGANIC STEREOCHEMISTRY
2 SOME INHERENTLY CHIRAL CHROMOPHORES—EMPIRICAL RULES AND QUANTUM CHEMICAL CALCULATIONS Marcin Kwit, Pawel Skowronek, Jacek Gawronski, Jadwiga Frelek, Magdalena Woznica, and Aleksandra Butkiewicz
Molecules that do not contain center of chirality can still be chiral if their structure does not contain a plane of symmetry. Typical examples are hexahelicene and biphenyl (Figure 2.1) in which the chromophoric system (in these cases π electron system) is helical due to steric reasons preventing enantiomerization of the molecule at ambient temperature. Examples discussed in this chapter include (a) conjugated chromophoric systems of dienes, (b) enones, (c) helical chalcogenides, and (d) nonplanar amide chromophores. Many molecules of natural origin contain chromophores of either of this type (e.g. steroids, terpenes, amino acids, antibiotics, and metabolites); hence interpretation of their ECD may be useful for their absolute structure elucidation.
2.1. DIENES AND TRANS-ENONES Dienes and enones form a class of chromophores that can be helical due to nonplanarity of the π -bond system. Their chiroptical properties have been a subject of numerous studies over the past 50 years [1], aimed at clarifying the role of twist of the π -bond system and chirality of the molecule on the ECD spectra and optical rotation. There are other types of helical chromophoric systems; among these are dichalogenides (disulfides, diselenides, ditellurides), which are distinctly different due to their non-π -electron chromophore, and these will be discussed in detail in the following section (Figure 2.2). The conformations of these molecules may be conveniently described by considering their helicities. 1,3-Dienes can exist in two planar conformations defined as s-trans and s-cis and an infinite number of nonplanar, skewed forms, traditionally called cisoid or Comprehensive Chiroptical Spectroscopy, Volume 2: Applications in Stereochemical Analysis of Synthetic Compounds, Natural Products, and Biomolecules, First Edition. Edited by N. Berova, P. L. Polavarapu, K. Nakanishi, and R. W. Woody. © 2012 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Published 2012 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
39
40
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
Figure 2.1. Hexahelicene and biphenyl—examples (M)-Hexahelicene
of inherently chiral (helical) chromophores.
(M)-Biphenyl
(a)
(b) C C
C
C
C
C
O
w=C=C−C=C
C
Ch Ch
C
C
C
C
w=O=C−C=C
R
C
w = C − Ch − Ch − C (Ch = S, Se, Te)
t=C−C=C−R
Figure 2.2. Simple helical chromophores and definitions of torsion angles ω (a) and definition of angle τ that describes distortion of the C=C bond from planarity (b).
transoid , depending on the conformation of the nearer planar form. The conformation can otherwise be described by torsion angle ω, which can be either positive (P ) or negative (M ) (see Scheme 2.1). The same is true for enones and dichalcogenides; however, in the last case both planar s-trans and s-cis conformations represent the transition states, not any stable structures. Additional classification of chromophore structures may be accomplished on the basis of molecular symmetry [1b]. Both butadiene and symmetrically disubstituted dichalcogenides in planar forms belong to either C2h or C2v symmetry point group, respectively, for s-trans and s-cis conformers. Rotation around the C–C or Ch–Ch bonds reduces the
(a) X
X S-cis (sp)
X Cisoid
Planar
P-helical
Cisoid
X Transoid
X S-trans (ap)
X Transoid
(b)
M-helical
P-helical
Planar
M-helical
X = CH2 (1,3-dienes) X = O (enones)
Scheme 2.1. (a) Possible planar and nonplanar conformations of 1,3-dienes and enones and (b) definition of M- and P-helicities in the cases of cisoid and transoid 1,3-dienes.
S O M E I N H E R E N T LY C H I R A L C H R O M O P H O R E S
symmetry to C2 in skewed, chiral conformations. Unlike butadiene and dichalcogenides, the simplest enone (acrolein) exhibits only trivial C1 symmetry when skewed and Cs symmetry for both planar forms. The electronic transitions of 1,3-dienes and enones are reflections of their structures. The degree of electron delocalization determines intensity and energy of the low-energy π –π * electronic transition in the diene chromophore. For the most populated s-trans conformation of butadiene, the most intense band is found at 210 nm with εmax > 20,000 [2], whereas for s-cis planar conformation, both the intensity and energy of the π –π * electronic transition is significantly lower. In the case of cyclopentadiene the long-wavelength absorption band appears at 240 nm (εmax = 3500) [2]. The extinction coefficients and energies of the low-energy π –π * electronic transitions for skewed dienes are higher for transoid compared to cisoid structures and reach a minimum (λmax = 190 nm) for perpendicular diene confomation (ω = ±90◦ ) [2, 3]. In the case of 1,3-cyclohexadiene the observed UV maximum appears at 256 nm (εmax = 9000) [4]. The lowest-energy π –π* electronic transition has been used as a diagnostic band for solving stereochemical problems with the use electronic circular dichroism (ECD) spectroscopy. Contrary to dienes, α, β-unsaturated ketones typically exhibit two absorption bands: one very weak near 330 nm (R-band) and the second at around 230 nm (K-band). The lowest-energy band originates from a forbidden transition from nonbonding 2py orbital into antybonding π * orbital; thus this electronic transition is defined as n –π * [5, 6]. In the case of 2-cyclohexenone the lowest-energy n –π * transition is found at 320 nm (ε = 36) [7]. For chiral enones the dissymmetry factor (g) for the lowest-energy n –π * electronic transition is in the range 10−1 to 10−2 . The second UV absorption band in enone chromophore has the character of an intramolecular charge transfer transition from the vinyl to the carbonyl group and exhibits much higher intensity compared to the lowest-energy n –π* electronic transition. Oscillator strengths for transoid enones are usually higher than for cisoid . The dissymmetry factor for π –π * electronic transition is in the range 10−3 to 10−4 . In the case of 2-cyclohexenone, this band appears at 225 nm (εmax = 13800) [7]. Although only two bands are observed in the UV spectra of enones, ECD spectra of α, β-unsaturated ketones exhibit three (sometimes four) Cotton effects between 360 and 185 nm. The weak UV absorption at about 300 nm is responsible for the long-wavelength Cotton effect of moderate intensity. This band is followed by a π –π * transition Cotton effect corresponding to the UV band placed between 220 and 250 nm. Another Cotton effect that does not have the corresponding UV maximum appears at around 200 nm and usually exhibits a high rotatory strength, sometimes even higher than that for the π –π * electronic transition. The origin of this Cotton effect is not clear. Earlier calculations by Liljefors and Allinger suggested that this is another π –π * transition of low intensity in nearly planar enones [8]. Snatzke suggested that this is the second forbidden n –π * electronic transition [1i, 9]. The direction of polarization of this transition has been determined by linear dichroism measurements [10]. The fourth electronic transition is observed between 195 and 185 nm in ECD spectra of some enones having an axial substituent in α or β positions. This transition was considered as n –σ * excitation [1d–1f]. During the last few decades, various empirical rules have been proposed to correlate the signs of the Cotton effects of 1,3-dienes and α, β-unsaturated ketones with their stereochemistry (Table 2.1). Whereas some of the correlation rules are of historical value, two basic stereochemical concepts underlying the development of such correlations are briefly considered below.
41
42
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
TAB L E 2.1. Empirical Rules Correlating Cotton Effect for a Given Electronic Transition with the Chirality of Compounds Containing 1,3-Diene and Enone Chromophores Electronic Transition
Rule
π –π * (dienes) π –π * (dienes) π –π * (dienes) π –π * (dienes) π –π * (planar s-trans dienes) π –π * (enones) n –π * (enones) n –π * and π –π * (enones) n –π * (planar s-trans enones) n –π * and π –π * (enones) 210-nm transition (cyclic enones)
References
Diene Helicity Rule (Moscowitz et al., 1961) Allylic Axial Chirality Rule (Burgstahler and Barkhurst, 1970; Burgstahler et al., 1976) Quadrant Rule (Moriarty et al., 1979) Sector Rule (Weigang, 1979) Planar Diene Rule (Duraisamy and Walborsky, 1983)
11 12, 13
Enone Helicity Rule (Djerasi et al., 1962, Whalley, 1962) Enone Helicity Rule (Snatzke, 1965) Orbital Enone Helicity Rule (Kirk, 1986)
17, 18 19 1e
Sector Rule (Snatzke, 1979; Snatzke, 1965)
1h, 19a
Allylic Axial Chirality Rule (enones) (Burgstahler and Barkhurst, 1970) Carbon–Carbon Bond Chain in Cyclic Enones Rule (Gawronski, 1982)
14 15 16
12 1d
For correlating the chiroptical phenomena with the diene or enone structure, two fundamental effects had to be taken into account: (a) the contribution from the helicity of the chromophore and (b) the effect of extrachromophoric perturbation. Whereas the first of these effects correlates conformation of the chromophore with its spectroscopic properties, the second is related to the configuration at the stereogenic center(s). Both effects may act in the same or in opposite direction, so determining the dominant contribution is an important yet not always easy task. In the case of rigid 1,7,7-trimethyl2,3-dimethylene-bicyclo[2.2.1]heptane (1), chirality originates from the presence of the methyl group connected to C1 carbon atom [20]. As long as the chromophore is planar, the effect of extrachromophoric perturbation dominates. On the other hand, in the case of highly flexible (3S,8S,E,E )-dimethyl-deca-4,6-diene (2), both effects contribute to the π –π * transition Cotton effect [21], whereas in the case of the rigid structure of ergosterol (3) a negative twist of diene moiety is considered as the origin of the long-wavelength Cotton effect [22]. C9H17
H HO 1
2
De = −0.6 (250 nm)
De = +3.0 (230 nm)
3 w = −11° De = −18.0 (269 nm)
According to the Diene Helicity Rule (DHR) [11a], the sign of the long-wavelength Cotton effect reflects directly the sense of helicity of the chromophore; that is, for positive twist of the 1,3-diene system a positive long-wavelength π –π * transition Cotton effect is expected (Figure 2.3a).
43
S O M E I N H E R E N T LY C H I R A L C H R O M O P H O R E S
(a)
(b)
Figure 2.3. Empirical correlating P +C.e. w > 0°
M −C.e. w < 0°
+C.e. for right-handed angle Caxial −Callyl −C = C
−C.e. for left-handed angle Caxial − Callyl −C = C
rules for 1,3-dienes: (a) Diene Helicity Rule and (b) Allylic Axial Chirality Rule.
The validity of DHR has been challenged by calculations at different levels of sophistication [3, 23–31]. Most of them were performed for simple models like 1,3butadiene and generally confirmed the validity of DHR, but it should be noted that some of the calculations gave opposite results [28, 31]. To overcome the inadequacy of the Diene Helicity Rule for certain types of diene structures, the concept of allylic axial substituent contributions to optical activity of conjugated dienes was proposed by Burgstahler and co-workers (Allylic Axial Chirality Rule, hereafter referred to as AACR) [12, 13]. According to this concept, the sign of the long-wavelength Cotton effect of conjugated dienes is primarily due to the contribution of allylic axial substituents, such as alkyl groups. The sign of the contribution is determined by the helicity (+ or −) of the Caxial –Callyl –C=C bond system (Figure 2.3b). Thus, antipodal CD curves of 15-methylene-5α-cholest-8(14)-en-3β-ol acetate (4) and 3-isopropylidene-A-norcholest-5-ene (5) were explained as due to contribution from the allylic axial substituents; these dienes exhibit Cotton effects of opposite signs to those required by the DHR. + AcO
H + + – H H H w = +20° 4 De = +4 (250 nm)
H – H
–
w = +20°
– H
5 De = −5 (250 nm)
A corollary to this rule is a low contribution of the diene chromophore to the rotational strength of the π –π * transition. Certain substituents attached to one of the diene carbon atoms (e.g., the CN group) can cause sign reversal of the long-wavelength Cotton effect, in the absence of any obvious structural change [32], and this is another example of inconsistency with the Diene Helicity Rule. An experimental and theoretical study of α-phellandrene (6) and other 5-alkyl-1,3cyclohexadienes (7, 8) by Lightner et al. [30] for the first time provided a dissection of the contributions of various structural elements to the cyclohexadiene 260 nm Cotton effect. In the case of (5R)-5-methyl-1,3-diene (7), variable-temperature ECD spectra were invariant, due to a low energy difference between equatorial and axial conformers, estimated as 0.05 kcal mol−1 (Figure 2.4a,b), and exhibited a positive long-wavelength Cotton effect ( ε = +5 at 260 nm). A dramatic change of ECD spectra with temperature was observed when a tert-butyl group was attached to the 1,3-cyclohexadiene skeleton. At slightly elevated temperature, the sign of the long-wavelength Cotton effect was positive ( ε = +2.5 at +31◦ C) and stepwise decreased upon lowering the temperature. At −180◦ C the value of the long-wavelength Cotton effect was ε = −3.0, which corresponds to energy difference Gax-eq = 0.4 kcal mol−1 .
44
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
The rotatory strengths estimated from ECD spectra for 8 are positive for axial P helical conformer (R = +55.6 × 10−40 cgs units) and negative for equatorial M -helical conformer (R = −15.0 × 10−40 cgs units). The sign of the contribution due to the s-cisdiene moiety alone is calculated opposite to that predicted by the Diene Helicity Rule for 5-alkyl-1,3-cyclohexadienes, and the sign and magnitude of the Cotton effect are apparently dominated by the contributions of the axial allylic bonds (groups) (Figure 2.4c). Recently, a more advanced ab initio calculation by Hansen and Bak [33] in the random phase approximation (RPA) using Aug-cc-pVTZ atomic basis set provided important confirmation of the earlier findings on the role of allylic substituents. The effects of the allylic methyl groups were found to follow a quadrant rule being almost additive, and the contributions from axial substituents were calculated significantly larger than those from the equatorial groups. Analysis of chiroptical properties of compounds having enone chromophore is usually much more laborious. The first difficulty is due to small energy differences between conformers, and the second is the origin of the electronic transitions. While the n –π * electronic transition has origin similar to that of saturated ketones, higher energy transitions in enones are not pure and involve various types of orbitals. Estimated inversion barrier for 2-cyclohexenone is lower than the inversion barrier experimentally determined for cyclohexene [34]; and full inversion cycle involves a number of structures, each characterized by out-of-plane position of at least one saturated carbon atom. The diversity of possible conformation does not vanish even if a 2-cyclohexenone ring is a part of polycyclic systems, as in steroids and terpenoids. For example, for testosterone (9) molecule in the crystal lattice the dihedral angle ω that characterizes chromophore helicity takes different values, both positive and negative,
(a)
(c)
(b)
Figure 2.4.
Conformational drawings of (R)-α-phellandrene (6) (a) and (5R)-5-alkyl-1,3-
cyclohexadienes 7 and 8 (b) showing the axial or equatorial position of the alkyl group in relation to diene helicity and estimated group contributions to the rotatory strength (R (×10−40 cgs units) for the lowest-energy π −π ∗ electronic transition of (P)-1,3-cyclohexadiene (c).
45
S O M E I N H E R E N T LY C H I R A L C H R O M O P H O R E S
depending on the space group and on the presence or not of other molecules forming hydrogen bonds or complexes [35–38].
Almost 50 years ago, Djerassi et al. [17], Whalley [18], and Snatzke [19] proposed rules for the first two Cotton effects: positive enone helicity was correlated with a negative n –π * and a positive π –π * Cotton effect. This rule was thereafter applied by Kirk to s-cis and s-trans enones unperturbed by polar substituents, and (P ) π orbital helicity at C1 and C2 carbon atoms was correlated with a positive n –π * and a negative π –π * Cotton effect (Figure 2.5a,b) [1e]. These rules worked well for cyclohexenones, but for cyclopentenones inverse rules were proposed [1d, 1f, 19b]. Snatzke proposed a modification of the octant rule that correlates the sign of the n –π * Cotton effects with the stereostructure of planar enones [1h,1i,19c]. The n –π * Cotton effects of steroidal enones in oriented (anisotropic) systems were later studied by Kuball et al. [39]. Their studies demonstrated that sector or helicity rules can be applied, provided that vibronic progressions originating from various conformers are taken into account. On the other hand, Burgstahler and Barkhurst [12] has shown for the first time the importance of allylic axial substituents that led to a breakdown of the enone helicity rule for the π –π * transition of some s-cis steroid enones. The electronic transition observed between 220 and 200 nm in ECD spectra of some enones [9, 40] is characterized by a low oscillator strength, making it difficult to detect in (a)
(b)
O
O
s-cis (P)
O
s-trans (P)
s-cis (P)
−C.e. (n−p*), +C.e. (p−p*) (c)
O
O
s-trans (M )
+C.e. (n−p*), −C.e. (p−p*) (d)
O
R b′ O
O
+C.e. (~220 nm)
−C.e. (~220 nm)
a′ R
b′
b
a′
a O
Figure 2.5. (a) The first Enone Helicity Rule. (b) Kirk’s Enone Orbital Helicity Rule. (c) correlation rule for the third Cotton effect. (d) Correlation rule for the sign of the fourth Cotton effect in 2-cyclohexenones.
46
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
the UV spectra, and a high rotatory strength, resulting in some cases in overlap with the Cotton effect originating from the π –π * electronic transition. Attempts to correlate the sign of the third Cotton effect with structural parameters were met with many difficulties. Burgstahler correlated the sign of the third Cotton effect with the chirality of α carbon atom [12]. In the case of 4 -3-ketosteroids, a positive value of the third Cotton effect is in agreement with the chirality due to an axial 2β-substituent. This relationship can only be treated as tentative due to numerous exceptions. Gawronski suggested that the sign of the third Cotton effect is connected with the presence of saturated carbon–carbon bond chain, especially in polycyclic enones. It shows a clear relation to the absolute configuration at the allylic position (Figure 2.5c) [1d, 1f]. The fourth electronic transition, thought to involve n and σ ∗ orbitals, has been found in enones having α or β substituents in an axial position. The sign of this Cotton effect is dominated by the orientation of substituent, with assumption of a sofa(5) conformation of 2-cyclohexenone skeleton (Figure 2.5d).[1d–1f]. In the light of the above-mentioned facts, proper determination of the nature of electronic transition(s) involved is mandatory for rational stereochemical analysis of compounds containing the enone chromophore. This is of special interest in the case of molecules containing polar groups, which may influence strongly both the sign and the magnitude of the Cotton effects [41]. On the basis of DFT calculation at the B2LYP/6-311 + +(2d,2p) level and with the use of NBO method [42], it was possible to determine the origin of the first three electronic transition for a group of model compounds. For s-trans-acrolein, 2-cyclohexenone, (4S )-4-hydroxy-2-cyclohexenone (10), and (5R)-5-hydroxy-2-cyclohexenone (11), characterized by planar conformation of the chromophore (ω = 180◦ , τ = 0◦ ) and sofa(5) conformation of the cyclohexenone skeleton, the origin of the first two electronic transitions did not raise doubts (Figure 2.6). The long-wavelength electronic transition with a small oscillator strength involves HOMO(−1)–LUMO orbitals (nC=O –πC=C * type), whereas the second electronic transition with the highest oscillator strength is of CT character, involving HOMO and LUMO orbitals (πC=C –πC=O * type). The third electronic transitions, responsible for the third strong Cotton effect observed in the ECD spectra of enones, is characterized by a small oscillator strength. For acrolein the third electronic transition involves both πC=O –πC=O * and nC=O –σ * transitions, while in the case of 2-cyclohexenone it is a mixture of electronic transitions of the πC=C –πC=C * type (HOMO–LUMO(+1), the main contribution) and πC=C –σ * [HOMO–LUMO(+2)]. This supports the earlier suggestion [1d] that the configuration of saturated C–C bond chain in cyclic enones may be, in the absence of polar substituents, the controlling factor of the sign of the short-wavelength Cotton effect. The presence of a hydroxy group in enones 10 and 11 causes a change of the character of the third electronic transition, compared to 2-cyclohexenone. This electronic transition appearing at ∼190 nm involves the lone pairs of the hydroxy group [HOMO(−2)] and LUMO orbitals and thus may be referred to as nOH –πC=O * type. This may suggest that the third, short-wavelength Cotton effect in 2-cyclohexenones having polar substituents at C4 and/or C5 position depends on the helicity of the (H)O–C · · · C=O bond system [41]. In the analysis of the origin of optical activity of cyclic 1,3-dienes and enones the effect of nonplanarity of the C=C bond(s) is usually neglected. Recently, Diedrich and Grimme [43] performed an advanced quantum chemical calculation of the rotatory strength for the electronic transitions of twisted (−10 deg) ethylene. The calculated rotatory strength for the π –π * transition was of the order 75–198 × 10−40 cgs units, depending on the method used. Since nonplanar ethylene generated a high rotatory
47
S O M E I N H E R E N T LY C H I R A L C H R O M O P H O R E S
(a)
(b)
O 10
IIIb
OH 11
IIId
IIIc
LUMO(+1)
LUMO
(d)
O
O
O
LUMO(+2)
OH
(c)
I II IIIa
I II
I II IIIe
I II IIIe
HOMO
HOMO(−1)
HOMO(−2)
Figure 2.6. Molecular orbitals obtained with the use of the NBO method for representative planar enones: (a) Acrolein and (b) I nC=O –πC=O ∗, II πC=C –πC=O *, IIIa πC=O –πC=O *, IIIb nC=O –σC(O) – H *, IIIc πC=C –πC=C ∗, IIId πC=C –σC – C ∗ /σC – H *, IIIe nOH –πC=O *.
strength, neglecting such an effect in the case of π –π * electronic transitions of nonplanar enone and diene seems unjustified. Nonplanar conformations of simple 1,3-butadiene and acrolein may be chiral due to nonplanarity of the C=C bonds, defined as the sign and value of torsion angle τ (Figure 2.2). Thus, nonplanar molecular conformations may be due to nonzero values of either angle ω or angle(s) τ , or both. If both torsion angles ω and τ are considered, chromophore conformation may be defined as homohelical (if the signs of angles ω and τ are the same) or as heterohelical , if the signs of angles ω and τ are opposite [44]. In the case of s-trans acrolein and 2-cyclohexenone, deformation of the C=C bond from planarity results in the appearance of nonzero rotatory strength. Enone Helicity Rule is obeyed as long as the twist of the C=C bond and enone helicity are of opposite sense (heterohelical [41]). We will now discuss the effect of substitution of 1,3-cyclohexadiene and 2-cyclohexenone, which sometimes leads to contrasting effects. (S , S )-trans-1,2-Dihydroxy-3,5-cyclohexadiene (12) in the crystal phase forms an M -helical conformer (ω = −11.5◦ ), with the hydroxy groups occupying equatorial positions. Variable-temperature ECD spectra measured in methanol reveal that the rotatory strengths for both P- and M-helical conformers are positive, in accordance with the helicity of O–Callyl –C=C system, and the rotatory strength for diaxial P -conformer is one order of magnitude higher than that for the diequatorial one (Scheme 2.2) [45]. Significant solvent effect can be observed in the ECD spectra of 12. ECD spectrum in methanol solution at room temperature shows a Cotton effect ( ε = +11.2 at 258 nm),
48
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
w = −11.5° (X-ray)
OH
H
OH O
OH
H
12
O
methanol
H
cyclohexane
H
H
Δep−p* +6 (cyclohexane) +11 (methanol)
H M (more abundant) R p−p* > O
OH P R p−p* >> O
Scheme 2.2. Conformational equilibrium of dihydroxydiene 12.
due to increased population of P -helical conformer, whereas in nonpolar solvent the presence of intramolecular OH· · ·O bond favors the diequatorial M-conformer, with concomitant decrease of the long-wavelength Cotton effect ( ε = +6 at 259 nm). According to recent calculation performed for 12 at the DFT/B3LYP/6-311++G(d,p) level, diaxial P conformer is of 0.7 kcal mol−1 higher energy relative to the diequatorial one. Rotatory strength of the π –π * electronic transition, calculated at the mPW1PW91/6311++G(2d,p) level for P -helical 12 is almost four times higher than that for the lowest-energy diequatorial M conformer [46], consistent with the experimental ECD data. More complex systems are represented by arene metabolites 13–17 [41, 46–48]. These compounds, being valuable chiral building blocks and ligands in organic synthesis [49], are characterized by the presence of a vicinal cis-diol system and a 1,3-diene or enone chromophore. All of them can exist in solution in an equilibrium of diastereoisomeric diene (enone) conformers of P or M helicity with one of the OH group in an axial and the other in an equatorial position.
The main problem with stereochemical analyses of compounds of this type is reliable determination of conformer population. In general, the number of available conformers is not limited to M and P diastereoisomeric structures. Intramolecular hydrogen bond patterns of the hydroxy groups further increase the number of distinct stereoisomeric structures (Scheme 2.3). Thus, either C1(or C4)–OH or C2(or C5)–OH can be a hydrogen bond donor, and the orientation of the O–H bond against the vicinal C–H bond
49
S O M E I N H E R E N T LY C H I R A L C H R O M O P H O R E S
4
R
3
H
R
H O R2
O
3
R4
1
R
R1 2
H
R
4
R
2 1
R
R
4
H
3 R O
H
2
R H
H
R
1
R
4
3 R O
R2
R1
O
H
O
H
H P3
H P1
H M3
H
H a OH
3
R
O H
O
H H M1
R w
R
H
enones, R3
b OH
==O
4
R
R
3
H
O H R2
O
1
R H
H M2
4
R
3
H
R
O
2
R
R H
O H H M4
1
4
R
H 3 O R
R2 H
H H P2
O
1
R
R
4
3 R O
H
H
R2 O
1
R
HH P4
Scheme 2.3. Diastereomeric Pand M conformers of arene metabolites 13–17 and the definition of torsion angles α, β, and ω.
can be either syn or anti . This makes the number of available conformers up to eight (M 1–M 4, P 1–P 4), and the number can still be higher if one includes the rotamers due to the presence of nonspherical substituents in the ring. Contrary to 1,3-cyclohexadiene derivatives, in the case of cis-ketodiols 15–17 the conformational equilibrium is strongly affected by solvent polarity. Calculations performed at MP2/Aug-cc-pVTZ//B3LYP/6-311++G(2d,2p) level and with the use of a PCM model led to a conclusion that in polar surroundings a conformer of type P 4 dominates, in contrast to 1,3-cyclohexadiene derivatives, where conformer P 4 does not participate in conformational equilibrium even to a small extent [46–48]. It should be noted that X-ray diffraction analysis may provide quite different results, since in the crystal lattice the most important structure-determining factor is the possibility of formation of intermolecular hydrogen bonds. Thus, in the case of fluorinated ent-14e the molecular structure found in the crystal corresponds to conformer M 4. In contrast to M 1, M 2, and P 1 are calculated at the B3LYP/6-311++G(d,p) level as the lowest-energy
Figure 2.7. Potential energy surface calculated at the B3LYP/6-311++G(d,p) level for P- and M-helical conformers of fluorinated derivative 14e (a) and X-ray diffraction determined structure of ent-14e (b).
50
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
(a)
(b)
13b 13d
2 OH OH
Dioxygenase TDO-O2
OH
Dioxygenase TDO-O2
OH
0 Δe −2 13c
−4 minor
major
−6
13e 220
13a 13b 13c 13d 13e
13a 240
260
280
300
320 nm
Figure 2.8. (a) Empirical rule correlating the stereochemical course of arene cis-dihydroxylation with the relative size of substituents. (b) ECD spectra of cis-diols 13a-13e measured in cyclohexane solution.
conformers (Figure 2.7) for isolated molecule 14e [47]. The calculated preferred conformations of dihydrodiols substituted at the positions C3 or C6 by trifluoromethyl group are strongly affected by the presence of sequence of hydrogen bonds Oeq H · · · Oax H · · · FCF2 , which may shift the conformer equilibrium into such a conformer. The CD spectra measured in nonpolar solvent for a number of 3-substituted cisdihydrodiols 13a–13e differ markedly in the sign of the diagnostic long-wavelength spectral region (Figure 2.8b). This suggests that either the absolute configuration assigned according to Figure 2.8a is wrong, or the absolute configuration at C1 carbon atom is the same for the whole series and the cis-dihydrodiols 13a–13e differ in chiroptical properties [46]. Extensive computational study on the structure and chiroptical properties of arene metabolites led to a conclusion that the presence of substituents X and/or Y, as well as the hydroxy groups, is the decisive factor in shifting the P ↔ M conformer equilibrium in one or another direction, and this determines the sign and magnitude of the longwavelength diene Cotton effect. The substituent effect on the ECD spectra of cis-diols 13–14 may be ordered as follows: CN > Br > CH3 > CF3 > F = H. This study indicates that no simple empirical model, including the DHR and the AACR, can fully account for the experimental CD data of all cis-dihydrodiols. In relation to the Diene Helicity Rule, rotatory strength contribution from helical cyclohexadiene chromophore is in any case weak and, in certain cases (Br, CN substituents at C3), does not correlate with the sign of diene torsion angle. The failure of the AACR results from mutually canceling contributions due to allylic hydroxy groups, both axial and equatorial, in conformers of P and M helicity. Deceptively simple cis-ketodiols 15–17 are in fact complex systems, due to their conformational equilibria. Circular dichroism spectra measured in acetonitrile solutions and calculated at the PCM/B2LYP/Aug-cc-pVTZ level are quite similar, regardless the enone structure and in the case of cis-ketodiols 15 exhibit a positive/negative/positive sequence of Cotton effects. However, in the case of 16 and 17 the sign of the longwavelength nC=O –πC=O * Cotton effect appears affected by the substituent in C6 position, but the patterns of the second πC=C –πC=O * and the third nOH –πC=O * Cotton effects are similar to that measured and calculated for 15. Surprisingly, detailed inspection of the ECD spectra calculated for individual conformers of 15a shows the same pattern, but not the magnitudes, of Cotton effects [41]. Rotatory strengths calculated for M -helical conformers remain in agreement with DHR and also with the alternative AACR, which
51
S O M E I N H E R E N T LY C H I R A L C H R O M O P H O R E S
assigns a dominant contribution to the axial hydroxy group at the allylic position. On the other hand, ECD spectra calculated for the P conformers, which dominate in the conformational equilibrium, are not in agreement with the empirical rules and show much higher magnitudes than those calculated for their M -helical counterparts. In the case of P -helical conformers a dominant contribution is assigned, rather unexpectedly, to the equatorial hydroxy group [41]. With the use of modern computational approach, Kwit et al. estimated the effect of structural factors on the rotatory strengths of electronic transitions by replacing systematically the hydrogen atoms at C3–C6 in (P )-2-cyclohexenone with either a polar hydroxy group or a nonpolar methyl group. As expected, the dominant role of substituent at C4 over substituents in either C5 or C6 positions is clearly visible, regardless their electronic nature and orientation. For the πC=C –πC=O * transition of monosubstituted (P )2-cyclohexenones the substituent contributions, including signs, are as follows: 4eq-OH (−), 4ax-OH (+), 4ax-Me (+) > 4eq-Me (−), 5ax-OH (−), 6eq-OH (+) > 5ax-Me (+), 6ax-Me (−) > 5eq-OH (+), 5eq-Me (−), 6eq-Me (+), 6ax-OH (+). Another striking result revealed for the first time is that the sign of the principal πC=C –πC=O * transition Cotton effect is less dependent on the enone nonplanarity (angle ω) and more dependent on nonplanarity of the C=C bond [41, 46b]. The models of ECD contributions for arene metabolites of mono-substituted 1,3cyclohexadiene and cis-ketodiol type are proposed shown in Figure 2.9. These models redefine the importance of structural factors previously considered as responsible for chiroptical properties of dienes and enones. Nonplanarity of the C=C bonds, usually neglected, is of equal or even higher importance compared to the distortion of the whole conjugated chromophore from planarity.
2.2. DICHALCOGENIDES: MOLECULES WITH INHERENTLY CHIRAL CHROMOPHORES Dichalcogenides are unique examples of molecules with an inherently chiral chromophore. The dichalcogenide Ch–Ch moiety (Ch = S, Se, or Te) exists in the form of two helical enantiomeric P /M conformations. Both enantiomeric conformers give opposite Cotton effects that cancel in the experiments. When the dichalcogen moiety is placed in a chiral surrounding, the conformers are no longer of equal energy and this (a)
(b)
Figure 2.9. Estimated bond contributions to the rotatory strength R (×10−40 cgs units) of the lowest-energy π − π * electronic transition of arene metabolites of (a) the type (P)-1,3cyclohexadiene derivative (a) and (b) the type (P)-2-cyclohexenone derivative.
52
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
Scheme 2.4. Full interconversion scheme for dichalcogenide R–Ch–Ch–R conformers.
gives rise to the Cotton effects in the CD spectra. The conformer equilibrium involves transition states (TS) of either s-cis or s-trans structure in which the Ch–Ch moiety is planar (Scheme 2.4). C–S–S–C torsion angle (ω) for dimethyl disulfide in the gas phase was reported in the review as 90.44◦ (±0.45◦ ) [50]. Values 85◦ , 82◦ , and 87◦ were found for dimethyl diselenide based on the microwave [51] and vibrational spectra [52] as well as on the electron diffraction data [53]. The data from low temperature X-ray diffraction of dimethyl dichalcogenides are shown in Table 2.2. For benzene solution the values of torsion angle ω calculated from the dipole moment measurements (68.5 ± 2.0◦ for Me2 S2 , 65.4 ± 4.0◦ for Me2 Se2 , 35.9 ± 10.0◦ for Me2 Te2 ) [55] are much smaller than those found in the gas phase. This difference was explained by interactions between the solvent and the solute molecules. Data found for the diphenyl dichalcogenides in the crystal state and for benzene solution are more coherent— that is, 96.2◦ vs. 81.3◦ for Ph2 S2 , 97.1◦ vs. 62.6◦ for Ph2 Se2 , 88.5◦ vs. 84.0◦ for Ph2 Te2 [55]. Skewed structure of dichalcogenides is explained by the gauche effect, which was introduced for disulfides [50] but which can be extended to diselenides and ditellurides. In the dichalcogenide molecule the nonbonding electron pairs that reside on the p orbitals perpendicular to the Ch–Ch bond are partially overlapping. The destabilization due to the lone-pair–lone-pair repulsion in orthogonal position is reduced in nonplanar cisoid and transoid conformations of the dichalcogenide molecule. Hyperconjugation by which the p lone pairs of the chalcogen atoms are overlapping with the σ * molecular orbitals of the R–Ch bonds located in the same plane provides additional stabilizing effect [56]. Rotation barrier for the interconversion between enantiomeric conformers of dichalcogenides is low enough to allow free rotation of the Ch–Ch bond in acyclic molecules at room temperature (Scheme 2.4). Due to the repulsion between substituents on the chalcogen atoms, s-trans transition state is of lower energy. For S–S bond the rotation barrier is estimated in the range 6.8–13.2 kcal mol−1 [57–61]. Calculations (including MP2 method) give the value ca. 5 kcal mol−1 through the s-trans transition TAB L E 2.2. X-ray Data for Dimethyl Dichalcogenides Me2 Ch2
˚ Ch–Ch [A]
˚ C–Ch (A)
ω (degrees)
Me2 S2 Me2 Se2 Me2 Te2
2.03 2.31 2.71
1.80 1.94 2.15
86 85 90
Source: Data taken from reference 54.
53
S O M E I N H E R E N T LY C H I R A L C H R O M O P H O R E S
state and 9 kcal mol−1 through the s-cis transition state. [50, 62, 63]. Calculated rotation barrier for H2 Se2 is lower (4.47 and 6.21 kcal mol−1 , respectively). Substitution with the phenyl group does not change significantly the magnitude of the rotation barrier which was calculated for diphenyl disulfide, diselenide, and ditelluride as 8.6, 8.2, and 5.3 kcal mol−1 through a s-cis transition state and 5.4, 5.2, and 3.7 kcal mol−1 through a s-trans transition state [64]. It is seen that the rotation barrier is lowered with the increase of the length of the Ch–Ch bond (see Table 2.2). A model for interpretation of the CD spectra of disulfide chromophore was proposed by Bergson [65, 66] and later verified by Linderberg and Michl [67] and by Woody [68]. Woody has shown the dependence of the rotation strength on the torsion angle of disulfide chromophore. In this model the sign of the long-wavelength Cotton effect obeys a quadrant rule (Figure 2.10). Bergson’s model due to its simplicity has been very successful. Recent study of the disulfide transitions using advanced computational methods led to similar conclusions [69–71]. As molecular structures of dichalcogenides are similar, this rule can be easily extended to diselenides and ditellurides [70–73]. It has to be noted that the longwavelength Cotton effect is of differing nature at different values of the torsion angle. The two lowest-energy electronic transitions are described as nA –σ * and nB –σ *. In the range 0◦ –90◦ , nA is a HOMO whereas nB is HOMO(−1). The highest energy difference between nA and nB orbitals is calculated for values of the dichalcogenide torsion angle. This difference diminishes at around 90◦ where nA and nB orbitals are almost degenerate. For the torsion angle greater than 90◦ , nB becomes HOMO and this leads to a change of the rotational strength. Similar switch of orbital positions takes place at −90◦ (Figure 2.11) [71, 72]. The first attempt to experimental study of chiroptical properties of dichalcogenide chromophore was made by Djerassi et al. [74], who recorded the ORD spectra for cystine and selenocystine. They observed negative Cotton effects at 250 and 290 nm, respectively. Ringdahl et al. [75] have found a long-wavelength Cotton effect at around 320 nm in the ECD spectra of selenocystine Other examples of CD spectra are provided by 2,2-dithioand 2,2-diseleno derivatives of propionic acid [76, 77]. It was expected that the CD spectroscopy based on the disulfide chromophore will find application in the analysis of protein structure. However disulfide CD bands in proteins are difficult to identify since the average number of disulfide bonds in proteins is low and the CD band originating from
0° −C.e.
+C.e.
180°
90°
+C.e.
Δe 0
−C.e. −90° −180
−90
0
90
180
Torsion angle R-S-S-R
Figure 2.10. Relation between the torsion angle in R–S–S–R disulfides and observed sign of the long-wavelength Cotton effect.
54
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
l [nm] 480
Rotational strength (R)
20
460 10
440 420
0
400
−10
360 340
−20
Figure 2.11. Rotatory strength (R ×10−40 cgs units,
320
solid line) and wavelength (dashed line) of the long-wavelength transition for dimethyldiselenide. (Data from reference 72.)
380
0
30
60
90
120
150
Dihedral angle C-Se-Se-C
180
the disulfide chromophore is often overlapped by the CD bands originating from aromatic residues, as well as from the amide chromophore. Laur [78] presented the CD spectra of rigid cyclic (9S , 10S )-trans-2,3-dithiadecalin (18a) and (9S ,10S )-trans-2,3-diselenadecalin (18b) and open-chain disulfide (19a), diselenide (19b), and ditelluride (19c) substituted by (S )-2-methylbutyl groups (Figure 2.12). For rigid trans-decaline derivatives (18a, 18b) in a chair–chair conformation, C–Ch–Ch–C bond forms a left-handed (M ) helix. The long-wavelength Cotton effects for 18a and 18b are negative, in direct correlation with the twist direction of the helix. Due to distortion of the dichalcogenide chromophore from the optimum 90◦ value to ∼60◦ , the position of the UV absorption bands and consequently of the Cotton effects is red-shifted by around 40 nm. The torsion angle of the open-chain derivatives 19 is not confined to just one value, so it is expected that these compounds exist as a mixture of freely interconverting diastereoisomers with the torsion angle C–Ch–Ch–C around 90◦ or −90◦ . A small energy difference between distereoismers due to steric repulsion between the alkyl chains leads to a small difference in their population and to the rise of small, but nonzero, Cotton effects. Indeed, the observed Cotton effects are about 30–50 times lower than those observed for trans-decalin 18.
0.4
4
0.2
2
H Ch Ch H 18 a, Ch = S b, Ch = Se
Ch Ch
19 a, Ch = S b, Ch = Se c, Ch = Te
0 Δe
Δe 0.0 −0.2
18b 19b
−0.4 250
300
350
400
450
−2 −4
500 l[nm]
Figure 2.12. ECD spectra of the diselenadecalin (18b) (right-hand scale) and diselenide (19b) (left-hand scale) in acetonitrile. (Redrawn using the data from reference 78.)
55
S O M E I N H E R E N T LY C H I R A L C H R O M O P H O R E S
Further examples are the CD spectra of sugar-substituted diselenides and ditellurides [79]. The authors characterize the observed bands but do not consider the effect of chiral substituents on the dichalcogenide conformation. Recently, the CD spectra of diglycosyldisulfides and diselenides were reported, and a good agreement between the experimental and the calculated CD spectra of di(teraacetylated glycosyl)diselenide using the TDDFT method was obtained [71]. The CD spectra of several symmetrical diselenides with chiral alkyl substituents allowed us to determine the effect of chirality of the alkyl groups on the chirality of the diselenide moiety with the aid of TDDFT calculation. Thus, the S configuration of the carbon atom adjacent to the Se atom correlates with positive long-wavelength Cotton effect. This effect was explained by a model based on steric repulsion between bulky substituents [72]. The CD spectra measured for the dichalcogenides substituted with the same chiral alkyl groups show a shift of the position of the long-wavelength n –σ * Cotton effects toward a longer wavelength and a significant reduction of the Cotton effect intensity on going from S to Te. This trend is observed in the CD spectra of di[(S )2-methylbutyl] derivatives of dichalcogenides [78] and also for dineomenthyl derivatives 20 (Figure 2.13). The decrease of the Cotton effect intensity in this series is a result of elongation of the chalcogen–chalcogen and chalcogen–carbon bonds, as shown in Table 2.2, which causes significant reduction of steric repulsion between the substituents and hence lowering of free energy difference between the diastereomeric conformers of dichalcogenides of M and P helicity. Contemporary procedure for the analysis of ECD spectra of chiral dichalcogenides requires computation of conformer distribution and then the average CD spectra [71, 72, 80]. However, from a practical point of view the information about helicity of the dichalcogenide moiety can be obtained directly from the sign of the Cotton effect due to the long-wavelength nA –σ * transition. Higher-energy nB –σ * transition usually overlaps with other transitions and may be not distinguishable in the observed CD spectra. Orbitals nA and σ * involved in the long-wavelength transition are localized on the dichalcogenide moiety and are not affected by alkyl substituents. A further simplification of the analysis of rotational strength of complex chiral dichalcogenides can be based on the data obtained for dimethyl dichalcogenide. Calculation of the whole system seems justified only for structures with the C–Ch–Ch–C torsion angle very close to 90◦ (or −90◦ ) where nA and nB are almost degenerate and their exact energy may depend on the substituents in the molecule.
1.6 Ch Ch
1.2 Δe
20 a, Ch = S b, Ch = Se c, Ch = Te
20a 20b 20c
0.8 0.4 0.0 250
300
350
400
450
500
550 l[nm]
Figure 2.13. ECD spectra of the dineomenthyl disulfide 20a, diselenide 20b, and ditelluride 20c in cyclohexane solution.
56
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
2.3. THE AMIDE CHROMOPHORE IN BI- AND POLICYCLIC β-LACTAM RING SYSTEMS The amide chromophore has been recognized as a basic unit in a variety of bioactive compounds. Among them the β-lactam family of antibiotics represents some of the most clinically relevant antibiotics known [81–84]. This is attributable to their broad spectrum of antibacterial activity and a relatively low level of toxicity [83, 85]. To connect the biological activity with a defined stereochemistry of β-lactams, many research groups were engaged in the analysis of their chiroptical properties [86–99]. In the case of monocyclic β-lactams the planarity of the amide chromophore was demonstrated [90, 96, 99, 100]. The assumption of planarity of this chromophore has allowed to explain many features of protein structure. The (3R, 4S )-3-phenoxy-4-vinylazetidin-2-one presented below is an example of monocyclic β-lactam with a planar β-lactam moiety (Figure 2.14). The O=C2–N1–C4 torsion angle equal to 177.28◦ , derived from its X-ray structure, clearly demonstrates the planarity of amide chromophoric system. According to Moscowitz [101–103], such a planar amide chromophore has to be categorized as inherently achiral but chirally perturbed by its neighborhood. Therefore, one has to take into consideration the chiral perturbation (mainly through space), and this is usually achieved by the help of different sector rules. However, based on both the X-ray and computational studies, it has been demonstrated that in small cyclic peptides and medium-sized lactams the amide chromophore can be slightly nonplanar [94, 97, 104–108]. The skewness of the amide unit causes its inherent chirality, and thus such a nonplanar chromophore now belongs to the Moscowitz inherently chiral class of chromophores [101–103]. These chromophores are characterized by very strong CD effects mainly governed by their chirality. It means that the contributions from all the other atoms and groups may be neglected, so that the rules correlating the stereostructure with CD data can be classified as “chirality rules” or “helicity rules.” As a result of the extensive studies of lactam chromophores, several sector and helicity rules for the correlation between the structure and Cotton effect (CE) signs of n –π* transition have been established. Among them the β-lactam octant rule [90, 97, 109], Weigang’s sector rule [100], a modification of Weigang’s lactam rule [99], and Ogura’s [91] and Wolf’s [96] helicity rules can be mentioned. These empirical rules correlate the sign of the CE designated as the n –π * transition of the β-lactam chromophore with the absolute configuration of monocyclic azetidinones. The 4π electrons and two free electron pairs of the amide chromophore are located on the carbonyl oxygen atom. The molecular orbital (MO) occupied by the highest energy electron pair is largely (80–90%) located on the carbonyl oxygen and is a 2p orbital. Its axis is located in the plane of the amide group and is perpendicular to the direction of the
Figure 2.14. Crystal structure of (3R, 4S)-3-phenoxy-4-vinylazetidin-2-one. Thermal ellipsoids are shown at 50% probability level.
57
S O M E I N H E R E N T LY C H I R A L C H R O M O P H O R E S
C=O bond. The second pair of free electrons, with a much lower energy, occupies orbitals extensively overlapping with d orbitals. This orbital is of both 2s and 2p character, and its axis is directed along the C=O bond (Figure 2.15). Four electronic transitions can theoretically occur within the amide chromophore, namely π0 –π * (around 190 nm), π+ –π * (around 140 nm), n –π * (around 220 nm), and n –π *. The last transition is predicted theoretically but has not been observed experimentally. Amide transition π0 –π * is electrically allowed (εmax ∼ 104 M−1 cm−1 ), and the direction of the electric transition moment μ approximately defines a line connecting the N and O atoms (Figure 2.15). The n –π* transition is electrically forbidden (εmax ∼ 102 M−1 cm−1 ); however, it has a large magnetic transition moment m directed along the line passing through the C=O bond (Figure 2.15). In penicillins and cephalosporins the β-lactam unit is nonplanar and its nitrogen atom is pyramidal. The relationship between an (R) AC at the ring junction carbon atom and the positive sign of the lowest energy CE attributed to the amide n –π * transition which occurs in penicillins and cephalosporins at around 230 nm and 260 nm, respectively, was well-documented [86, 89, 93, 104, 110–112]. There is a nontrivial question whether the same regularity is valid for the oxa- and carbaanalogues of penicillins and cephalosporins. To clarify this, a study was undertaken to establish a correlation of the absolute stereostructure of a variety of β-lactam derivatives with the sign of the amide n –π * transition in their CD spectra. In addition, to rationalize the experimental results and to find out the scope and limitations of observed regularities, the calculation of chiroptical properties of β-lactam antibiotic analogues at B3LYP/TZVP level of theory were performed.
2.3.1. General Structures of Penicillins and Cephalosporins The chiroptical properties of oxacephams have been studied on variety of bi-, tri-, and tetracyclic oxacephams [113, 114]. Some of them, namely oxacephams 21–29, are presented in Chart 2.1 while the CD spectra of representative members of this group are shown in Figure 2.16. As can be seen in Figure 2.16, the investigated compounds exhibit, generally, two CD bands at around 220 and 190 nm. The 220-nm CD band can be assigned to the n –π * electronic transition of β-lactam unit, whereas the band at around 190 nm corresponds (a)
(b) π* O C μπ→π*
mn→π*
π*
π0
n→π* π0→π* n π0 n′
N
C N
n
C N
n′
π+ π+
Figure 2.15. (a) Molecular orbitals and electronic transitions within the amide chromophore. (b) Directions of the magnetic m and electric μ transition moments defining the electronic transitions within the amide system.
58
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
Chart 2.1.
(a)
(b)
Figure 2.16. (a) CD spectra of selected oxacephams 21 (——), 26 (· · ·), and 27 (– – –) recorded in acetonitrile. (b) Crystal structures of compounds 26 and 28 with the crystallographic numbering scheme. Thermal ellipsoids are shown at 50% probability level.
to the π –π * excitation of the same unit. With respect to the sign of band at 220 nm, the oxacephams fall into two different groups. In the first group, consisting of compounds with (6R) absolute configuration, the sign of this CD band is positive, whereas in the second group, represented by compounds with (6S ) absolute configuration, this band is negative [113]. Based on that data, additionally corroborated by the specifics of their synthetic pathway and the X-ray analysis obtained for compounds 26 and 28 [113], it can be unambiguously established that the (6R) AC corresponds to a positive CE at around 220 nm whereas (6S ) AC corresponds to a negative sign of the same CE.[113, 114] The data indicate the nonplanarity of the amide chromophore and the pyramidal configuration of the amide nitrogen in the studied oxacephams. Thus, the β-lactam chromophore is inherently chiral, and the sense of its chirality is expressed as a right or left helicity that correlates well with the AC at C6 carbon atom. The helicity appears to be independent of the kind and the position of other substituents present in the oxacepham moiety [113, 115, 116].
59
S O M E I N H E R E N T LY C H I R A L C H R O M O P H O R E S
The nonplanarity of the chromophore excluded application of the known sector rules for the prediction of the n –π * CE sign, since these rules were developed for the planar amide chromophore only [90, 97, 100]. In such case, the helicity rule should, in principle, be able to correlate the chiroptical properties and structure. However, for the studied oxacephams a breakdown of Ogura’s [91] and Wolf’s [96] helicity rules was found [113]. The spiral rule [107, 108] based mostly on the CD results obtained for the nonplanar α-lactams and monocyclic β-lactams that correlates the positive/negative torsional angle O=C–N–C with a negative/positive n –π * CE, respectively, in general, was valid for oxacephams studied. However, it was found that the absolute configuration of the bridgehead carbon atom determines the sign of the O=C–N–C torsional angle. Therefore, to connect directly the AC of this carbon atom with the sign of the CE due to n –π * transition observed around 220 nm in oxacephams, a simple helicity rule has been proposed [113]. According to this rule, a positive sign of the 220 nm CE corresponds to an (R) AC at the bridgehead carbon atom, whereas a negative sign of the same CE is related to a (6S ) AC. The rule was experimentally demonstrated to be correct for a variety of oxacephams [114–119]. The DFT conformational analysis of oxacepham 21 at B3LYP/TZVP level of theory indicates the skewness of the β-lactam unit by negative O9–C8–N1–C2 and O9–C8–N1–C6 torsion angles of −24.1◦ and −175.7◦ , respectively. The six-membered ring in the computed lowest energy conformer of oxacepham 21 is in a chair conformation with β-lactam ring in energetically favorable equatorial position. Furthermore, it has been found that the positive long-wavelength CE around 220 nm (Figure 2.16) is in an excellent agreement with the TD-DFT simulated positive CD band of 21 (Figure 2.17a) and also follows the helicity rule. The band at 220 nm has mainly the character of an amide n(O)–π * transition. In summary, the agreement between simulated and experimental CD spectra confirms not only the absolute configuration and conformation of 21 but also the validity of helicity rule for this oxacepham. The same helicity rule works very well also for cephams [118], as demonstrated in Figure 2.17b with cepham 30 as representative example of this group of compounds. As expected for the (R) AC at the ring junction, cepham 30 exhibits, similarly to oxacephams, a positive CE at around 220 nm. The six-membered ring of 30 is in a chair conformation, equally as in 21. Similarly to previously described cephams [118], the conformational flexibility in 30 is limited to the side-chain substituent at C7. The simulated CD spectrum (a)
(b)
Figure 2.17. (a) Simulated at B3LYP/TZVP theory level CD spectrum of 21 (– – –) compared with its experimental CD spectrum (——) and calculated structure of the lowest-energy conformer of 21. (b) Simulated at B3LYP/TZVP theory level CD spectrum of 30 (– – –) compared with its experimental CD spectrum (——) and calculated structure of the lowest energy conformer of 30. The vertical bars represent calculated at B3LYP/TZVP level rotatory strengths. Protons are omitted for clarity.
60
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
of lowest energy conformer is in a good agreement with experiment (Figure 2.17b). The positive band at 212 nm is caused by transitions out of the amide n(N) into the amide n(O)π* orbital, as well as by transitions out of the sulfur lone pair into the same acceptor orbitals. The negative excitations at around 235 and 207 nm result mainly from the sulfur lone pair transitions, with some admixture of the amide n(O) as donor orbital. With a torsion angle O=C–N–C6 equal to −175◦ for 30, the helicity rule is satisfied. The applicability of the helicity rule was also tested for carbacephams [118]. Similarly to the earlier discussed cephams and oxacephams, two bands are present in their CD spectra in the 280- to 190-nm spectral range. The long-wavelength band assigned to the n –π * excitation occurs at around 220 nm while the second band, of the π –π * origin, appears at around 200 nm. As shown in Figure 2.18, carbacephams with (6R) configuration possess a positive CE at around 220 nm while carbacephams with an (S ) AC at C6 have a negative CE in the same spectral range. The signs are exactly what one would expect to see applying the helicity rule. Thus, the CD spectra of discussed compounds conform to the rule developed for oxacephams. The presence of isolated double bond in compounds 32 and 33 does not influence their CD spectra, which appear similar to their saturated counterpart 31 (Figure 2.18a). Completely different situation occurs in the case of compounds 34 and 35 where a conjugated double bond is present. The presence of such an α,β-unsaturated amid chromophore, defined also as cephem, causes a red shift (by about 30–40 nm) and the crucial CD band arises, depending on actual substitution, at 250 nm or 260 nm (Figure 2.18b). Except for other differences, compounds with substituents at C2 absorb at longer wavelength when compared to those unsubstituted at this carbon atom. This regularity is independent of the type of heteroatom present at position 5 in a six-membered ring fused with an azetidinone ring. Additional examples, including the 7-aminocephalosporanic acid, the active nucleus for the synthesis of cephalosporins and intermediates, and its derivatives, can be found in the recently published review [119]. The model carbacepham 31 demonstrates the impact of conformational factors on the CD spectra. As predicted by DFT calculations, the six-membered ring of the lowestenergy conformer of this carbacepham exists in a chair conformation [118, 119]. Note also that the only chromophore of 31 that absorbs above 180 nm is the amide group of the azetidin-2-one ring. It is thus very unexpected that despite this apparent structural simplicity, the computed CD spectrum of the lowest-energy conformer of 31 displays little, if any, resemblance with the experimental CD spectrum, shown in Figure 2.19. The computed amide n(O)–π * CD band is considerably blue-shifted, while the amide n(N)–π ∗ band is not only notably shifted to a higher-energy region but even has the wrong sign.
Figure 2.18. (a) CD spectra of carbacephams 31 (——), 32 (– – –), and 33 (· · ·) recorded in acetonitrile. (b) CD spectra of carbacephems 34 (——), 35 (·– · – · –·) and oxacephem 36 (– – –) recorded in acetonitrile.
61
S O M E I N H E R E N T LY C H I R A L C H R O M O P H O R E S
Figure 2.19. Simulated CD spectrum of carbacepham 31 at 0 K (– – –) and
5
OH H H
20
N
10
O
31
0
0 −5
−10
−10
−20 190
Rvel⋅10−40 cgs
Δε (M−1cm−1)
10
350 K (· · ·) compared to experiment (——). The 0 K curve corresponds to the optimized PBE0/SV(P) conformer of 31 shown on the right. (From J. Frelek, P. Kowalska, M. Masnyk, A. ´ Kazimierski, A. Korda, M. Woznica, M. Chmielewski, F. Furche, Circular dichroism and conformational dynamics of cephams and their carba and oxa analogues, Chem. Eur. J. 2007, 13, 6732–6744. Copyright Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA. Reproduced with permission.)
230 210 250 Wavelength (nm)
In order to investigate the impact of thermal effects on the CD spectrum, molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of 31 at 350 K were carried out and demonstrated that the saturated six-membered ring system shows a considerable flexibility. The results of the MD simulations revealed that the CD spectrum is highly dependent on the conformation of both the four- and the six-membered rings, with sign inversions occurring for both bands at various points of the MD simulation [118]. The simulated CD spectrum at 350 K compares much better with the experiment than the 0 K spectrum (Figure 2.19). Both bands are broadened and red-shifted compared to the 0 K spectrum and have the correct sign. This result is not surprising because the experimental CD spectra were measured at room temperature and thus represent a thermal average over the CD spectra of many different conformations. This effect more clearly reflects the spectrum at 350 K, taking into consideration all possible conformations. On the basis of the aforementioned discussion, it can be stated that regardless of the presence of carbon, oxygen, or sulfur atom at 5 position of the six-membered ring, all cepham analogues absorb in the same absorption range. The sign of the decisive CE at around 220 nm depends on the AC at C6 only. Thus, oxacephams, cephams, and carbacephams with (6R) AC display a positive CD band in this spectral region, whereas
(a)
(b)
Figure 2.20. (a) CD spectra of penicillin V (38) (– – –) and penam 39 (——) recorded in water and acetonitrile, respectively. (b) Simulated at B3LYP/TZVP theory level CD spectrum of lowestenergy conformer of 39 (– – –) compared with its experimental CD spectrum (——) and calculated structure of lowest energy conformer. The vertical bars represent calculated at B3LYP/TZVP level rotatory strengths. Protons are omitted for clarity.
62
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
their counterparts with (6S ) AC exhibit a negative sign of the n –π * CE in the same spectral range. Therefore, it can be concluded that all those groups of compounds are subject to the helicity rule. In the case of conformationally flexible compounds, however, the additional theoretical support for the experimental data is recommended. The penams also conform perfectly to the helicity rule. As can be seen in Figure 2.20, the penam representatives 38 (penicillin V) and 39 possess a positive CE in the longwavelength part of the spectrum in accordance with the (R) stereochemistry at the ring junction. The shift of the CD maxima into the lower-energy spectral region by ≈10 nm is related to the penam-constrained backbone. The bicyclic system of penams is relatively rigid, and its conformational lability is largely restricted to the side-chain substituent at C6 carbon atom. Its relatively unrestricted mobility is evident, considering the results of conformational search for penam 39 for which seven conformers in the energy range of 2.8 kcal mol−1 are found. In respect to the five-membered ring conformation space, however, only two conformers exist. In the first one, populated at the conformational equilibrium over 88%, the five-membered ring is in an envelope conformation with C2 carbon atom below the average plane passing through the ring (Figure 2.20). In the second conformer, the five-membered ring adopts again an envelope conformation but with the sulfur atom above the ring plane. Beyond these two, the other individual conformers show differences only in the conformation of substituent at C6 carbon atom which demonstrates its relatively substantial flexibility. The computed O=C–C7–N1–C2 and O=C–C7–N1–C5 torsion angles for all conformers of penam 39 are calculated to be negative, thus providing corroborating evidence for the nonplanarity of amide chromophore. In simulated at B3LYP/TZVP theory level ECD spectra the sign of the lowest-energy excitations is positive for all conformers, as predicted by the helicity rule for (5R) AC. The positive CE at around 240 nm is in accordance with both the helicity rule and the calculations. Based on this we can conclude that for penams the requirements of the helicity rule are met, and therefore the rule can be successfully applied to this group of compounds. Oxaanalogues of penicillins, commonly referred to as clavams, exhibit the same shape of the CD spectra as oxacephams and penams (Figure 2.21). The positive sign of the decisive CD band arising at around 240 nm in clavam 40 corresponds to its (R)configuration at C5, and the negative one corresponds to the (S )-configuration of the ring junction in its local enantiomer 41. This finding validates the proposed rule for clavams too. As can be seen in Figure 2.21a, the shape of CD spectra of clavams corresponds very well with the shape of spectra of natural penicillins. (a)
(b)
Figure 2.21. (a) CD spectra of clavams 40 (——) and 41 (· · ·) recorded in acetonitrile compared with the CD spectrum of penicillin V (38) (– – –). (b) Simulated at B3LYP/TZVP theory level CD spectrum of lowest energy conformer of 42 (– – –) compared with experimental CD spectrum (——) and calculated structures of its two lowest-energy conformers. Protons are omitted for clarity.
S O M E I N H E R E N T LY C H I R A L C H R O M O P H O R E S
A more complex situation is encountered when considering the spectra of clavams with an additional, interfering chromophore in the molecule such as phenyl, which substantially perturbs the electronic structure of the system and therefore significantly influences the CD spectra. However, the recent study on this subject demonstrated that even in the case like that, the requirements of helicity rule have been met and the rule can be successfully applied to correlate the structure and the respective chiroptical properties for unsubstituted and substituted clavams as well [120]. In the ECD spectra of the representative members of carbapenams 43–45, the 240nm ECD band is negative for compounds 43 and 45 with (5S ) AC and positive for 44 with (5R) AC, as predicted by helicity rule (Figure 2.22). Even the presence of interfering chromophores in compound 45 (i.e., phenoxy group and double bond) does not alter the relationship between the sign of 240-nm CD band and absolute configuration of the C5 carbon atom [121]. Similarly to clavams and penams, the bicyclic system of carbapenams is relatively rigid and its conformational lability is largely restricted to substituents at the C6 carbon atom and in the five-membered ring. Although for carbapenam 43 nine conformers were found in the energy range of 2.4 kcal mol−1 , in respect to the five-membered ring conformation space, however, there were only two distinct conformers present. In the first one, populated in the conformational equilibrium over 75%, the five-membered ring is in an envelope conformation with C4 carbon atom below the average plane passing through the ring. In the second conformer the five-membered ring adopts a halfchair conformation with C2 and C3 carbon atoms located above and below the ring plane, respectively (Figure 2.22). Beyond these two, the other individual conformers show differences in the substituent at C6 carbon atom which demonstrates its relatively substantial flexibility. The average ECD spectrum shows very close agreement between experiment and theory, thus providing evidence that these conformers are present in solution under given conditions (Figure 2.22). The negative CE at around 240 nm is in accordance with both the helicity rule and the calculations [121]. In order to show that the nonempirical correlation between chiroptical properties and stereochemistry is not restricted specifically only to very simple cases, more complex
Figure 2.22. CD spectra of carbapenams 43 (——), 44 (·–·–·–), and 45 (– – –) recorded in acetonitrile and simulated at B3LYP/TZVP theory level CD averaged spectrum of 43 (· · ·) as well as lowest-energy envelope (E) and half-chair (H-C) conformers of 43. Protons are omitted for clarity.
63
64
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
compounds such as carbapenam 46 which incorporates a conjugated diene chromophore at C4 in addition to the amide chromophore have been studied. Although the sign of observed at 240-nm CD band in 46 apparently is consistent with the helicity rule, CD contributions to this band of other electronic transitions can play a decisive role (Figure 2.23). In fact, the TDDFT calculations brought some more insight about the complex UV and CD relationship in carbapenam 46. The five-membered ring in this compound is nearly planar with a nitrogen atom slightly deviated from the plane formed by remaining four carbon atoms. The conformational differences in 46 are limited mostly to the conformation of the side chain. In all four conformers calculated for 46, the O8–C7–N1–C2 and O8–C7–N1–C5 torsion angles are negative, and thus helicity rule requirements are met. Consequently, the simulated CD spectrum for these geometries showed an expected positive band at ∼240 nm (Figure 2.23) [121]. The analysis show that the electronic transitions from the amide and diene chromophores are mixed and appear in approximately the same energy range. Thus, the longwavelength CD band is an admixture of the amide n –π * and diene π –π * excitations occurring at 240 nm and 252 nm, respectively (MO49 → MO∗ 52 and MO49 → MO∗ 51, respectively). Regardless of this complexity within the band at 240 nm, the positive sign of its component related to the amide n –π* excitation and its decisiveness in terms of the helicity rule are in accord with the rule. In addition, the agreement between the experimental and Boltzmann-averaged ECD spectra is very accurate and confirms both absolute configuration and conformation of carbapenam 46 [121]. It should be added that very recently the helicity rule was reformulated. The reason for this was the fact that presence of substituents in the vicinity of the ring junction may cause the change of AC descriptors of the bridgehead carbon atom from R to S , and vice versa. According to the CIP priority rules, such a change causes an allyl group at C4 in 46 whereas propionic acid methyl ester substituent attached to the same carbon atom in 45 does not. Therefore, to avoid misunderstandings, after reformulation the rule connects the sign of the n –π * amide transition with the d or l configuration, as defined by Wo´znica et al. [121].
(a)
(b)
Figure 2.23. (a) Simulated ECD and UV spectra of lowest energy conformer of carbapenam 46 (——) and experimental ECD spectrum of 46 (– – –). (b) Dominant contributions of MOs of particular excitations of carbapenam 46 lowest-energy conformer.
S O M E I N H E R E N T LY C H I R A L C H R O M O P H O R E S
As was mentioned before, the molecular dynamics (MD) simulations carried out for some carba- and oxacephams revealed a considerable flexibility of the saturated sixmembered ring and high dependency of the ECD spectra on the conformation of both the four- and the six-membered rings [113, 118]. In some cases this dependency resulted in a breakdown of the helicity rule caused by a change of the conformation of the pyranose ring from a chair to a boat. Therefore, the question arose about scope and limitations of the helicity rule. To answer this question, chiroptical properties of several model compounds with β-lactam ring fused to a seven-member ring were studied. These ringexpanded cephalosporin analogues 47–50 (Figures 2.24 and 2.25) were chosen due to their increased conformational flexibility in comparison with investigated earlier bicyclic β-lactams with six- and four-membered rings condensed together. In addition, a decrease of the skeletal strain energy expected for compounds in question may result in overall flattening of the system. Therefore, a subsequent breakdown of the helicity rule cannot be excluded. Up to four absorption bands are present in the ECD spectra of investigated compounds 47–49 in the spectral range of 185–300 nm (Figure 2.24). The band occurring around 220 nm attributed to the amide n(O)–π ∗ transition is of a particular interest because this band is the subject of the helicity rule. According to the helicity rule for compounds 47–49 belonging to the (7R)configurational series, a positive CD is expected, whereas for β-lactam ent 48 with (7S )-configuration a negative one is expected. In fact, in both cases opposite bands at around 215 nm were observed in disagreement with the helicity rule (Figure 2.24). The question arises whether compounds 47–49 constitute an exception or the rule itself is imperfect. A finding the reasons for this inconsistency appears undoubtedly very important considering the future applicability of the helicity rule. Among the factors that may play a role are the higher conformational flexibility of compounds 47–49 and/or a significant change in the geometry of β-lactam chromophore by adopting a planar conformation that does not obey the rule [113]. In order to throw light into the origin for observed deviations from the rule, TDDFT calculations were carried out for β-lactams 47 and 48 (Figure 2.24). In these cases, depending on the compound, the main ECD band is a composite of excitations out of the amide n –π * transition and transitions out of the sulfur or oxygen lone pairs into the same acceptor orbitals. In addition, the transitions out of the double-bond orbitals mix strongly with the amide n –π * transition. Some of the structures of conformers of (a)
(b)
Figure 2.24. (a) ECD spectra of β-lactams: 47 (· · ·), ent 48 (– – –); and 49 (——) recorded in acetonitrile. (b) Simulated at B3LYP/TZVP theory level average CD spectrum of 47 and 48 compared with experimental spectra (ε is the molar decadic absorption coefficient. Protons are omitted for clarity.
65
66
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
(f)
(g)
(h)
Figure 2.25. (a–g) Computed structures of conformers of β-lactam 50 and their simulated ECD spectra. (h) The Boltzmann-averaged spectrum compared to experiment (ε is the molar decadic absorption coefficient). Protons are omitted for clarity.
S O M E I N H E R E N T LY C H I R A L C H R O M O P H O R E S
β-lactams 47 and 48, calculated within the range of 3 kcal mol−1 , demonstrate presence of a small deviation from planarity of the amide chromophore manifested by a slight pyramidality of the amide nitrogen. Nevertheless, the negative sign of the decisive ECD band in both experimental and Boltzmann-averaged ECD spectra clearly demonstrates the breakdown of the helicity rule for these compounds. For saturated carbaanalogue 50, seven conformers within the energy range of 2.4 kcal mol−1 were found. To simplify and speed up the calculations, the large substituent at C8 carbon atom (OSit BuMe2 ) was substituted by a smaller OSiMe3 group. Both groups have very similar electronic properties, and the change should not significantly influence the electronic spectra. As can be seen in Figure 2.25, two of seven conformers obtained for 50, namely 3 and 4, have slightly skewed amide chromophore, whereas in the remaining five conformers the chromophoric system is planar. The population ratio of conformers with a planar and with a nonplanar chromophore in β-lactam 50 is approximately 4:1. Therefore, because the average ECD spectrum is, by definition, the sum of weighted contributions of all conformers, the negative sign of the decisive band should predominate, which is indeed the case (Figure 2.25h). However, a small positive ECD band at around 240 nm, originating from the twisted conformers 3 and 4, is present in both experimental and simulated spectra. The band at around 220 nm has primarily the character of an amide n –π * transition. The average ECD spectrum shows a very close agreement between experiment and theory, thus providing strong evidence that these conformers are present in solution under given conditions. The seven-membered ring in conformers of 50 is in a chair or a twist–chair conformation, and the azetin-2-one ring is in equatorial position at C7 (Figure 2.25). Beyond that, the individual conformers show conformational differences mostly within the substituent at C8 carbon atom. Independent evidence comes from the X-ray diffraction data for a thioanalogue of β-lactam 50, namely thiolactam 50a, the only one forming crystals suitable for such an analysis. The solid-state structural data clearly demonstrates the planarity of the amide chromophore and the chair form of seven-membered ring. Additionally, the dihedral angle C9–C7–C2–N1 equal to −2.0◦ points to the sp 2 hybridization of the amide nitrogen atom.
50
50a
In conclusion, the combined experimental and theoretical studies have shown that the ring-expanded β-lactam analogues do not follow the helicity rule since they do not belong to β-lactam type with nonplanar amide chromophore, for which the rule is valid. Therefore, these β-lactam analogues belong to the second class of Moskowitz’s chromophores [102, 103]—that is, to locally achiral but chirally perturbed. Thus, depending on the type of chiral perturbation originating from either chiral conformation of the ring incorporating achiral chromophore or from bonds closely connected to the chromophore, the chirality of the second or third sphere, respectively, should govern the CD of these compounds, as proposed by Snatzke [122]. According to this view, chirality or sector rules can correlate the stereochemistry around the chromophore with the sign of respective CD bands.
67
68
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The preparation of this chapter and the work of our research group (JF, AB, MW) described herein has been supported by the Ministry of Science and Higher Education, grants N N204 123507 and N N204 092935.
REFERENCES 1. Reviews and book chapters: (a) J. Gawronski, Houben-Weyl Methods of Organic Chemistry, Vol. E21a, 4th ed., G. Thieme, Stuttgart, 1995, pp. 499–533. (b) P. Salvadori, C. Rosini, L. Di Bari, in The Chemistry of Dienes and Polyenes, Vol. 1, Z. Rapoport, ed., John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1997, pp. 111–147. (c) J. Gawronski, in Circular Dichroism: Principles and Applications, N. Berova, K. Nakanishi, and R. W. Woody, eds., Wiley-VCH, New York, 2000, pp. 305–335. (d) J. K. Gawronski, Tetrahedron 1982, 38 , 3–26. (e) N. Kirk, Tetrahedron 1986, 42 , 777–818. (f) J. Gawronski, Conformations, Chiroptical and Related Spectral Properties of Enones, in The Chemistry of Enones, S. Patai and Z. Rappoport, eds., John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1989, Chapter 3. (g) D. A. Lightner, J. E. Gurst, Organic Conformational Analysis and Stereochemistry from Circular Dichroism Spectroscopy, WileyVCH, New York, 2000, pp. 337–409. (h) G. Snatzke, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed . 1979, 18 , 363–377. (i) G. Snatzke, in Fundamental Aspects and Recent Developments in Optical Rotatory Dispersion and Circular Dichroism, F. Ciardelli and P. Salvadori, eds., Heyden, London, 1973, pp. 109–124. 2. H. Suzuki, Electronic Absorption Spectra and Geometry of Organic Molecules, Methuen, London, 1963. 3. A. Rauk, H. A. Peoples, J. Comput. Chem. 1980, 1 , 240–256. 4. N. J. Bunce, J. P. Bergsma, M. D. Bergsma, W. De Graaf, Y. Kumar, L. Ravanal, J. Org. Chem. 1980, 45 , 3708–3713. 5. L. H. Hall, Group Theory and Symmetry in Chemistry McGraw-Hill, New York, 1969. 6. G. Herzberg, Molecular Spectra and Molecular Structure Van Nostrand, Princeton, NJ, 1966. 7. E. S. Stern, C. J. Timmons, Electronic Absorption Spectra in Organic Chemistry, St. Martin’s Press, New York, 1971. 8. T. Liljefors, N. L. Allinger, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1976, 98 , 2745–2749. 9. H. Ziffer, C. H. Robinson, Tetrahedron 1968, 24 , 5803–5816. 10. J. K. Gawronski, T. Liljefors, B. Nord´en, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1979, 101 , 5515–5522. 11. (a) A. Moscowitz, E. Charney, U. Weiss, H. Ziffer, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1961, 83 , 4661–4663. (b) G. Wagniere, W. Hug, Tetrahedron Lett. 1970, 4765–4768 12. A. W. Burgstahler, R. C. Barkhurst, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1970, 92 , 7601–7603. 13. A. W. Burgstahler, L. O. Weigel, J. K. Gawronski, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1976, 98 , 3015–3016. 14. R. M. Moriarty, H. E. Paaren, U. Weiss, W. B. Whalley, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1979, 101 , 6804–6810. 15. O. E. Weigang, Jr., J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1979, 101 , 1965–1975. 16. M. Duraisamy, H. M. Walborsky, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1983, 105 , 3264–3269. 17. C. Djerassi, R. Records, E. Bunnenberg, K. Mislow, A. Moscowitz, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1962, 84 , 870–872. 18. W. B. Whalley, Chem. Ind . 1962, 1024–1027. 19. (a) G. Snatzke, Tetrahedron 1965, 21 , 413–419. (b) G. Snatzke, Tetrahedron 1965, 21 , 421–438. (c) G. Snatzke, Tetrahedron 1965, 21, 439–448. (d) G. Snatzke, in Optical Rotatory Dispersion and Circular Dichroism in Organic Chemistry, G. Snatzke, ed. Sadtler Research Labs, Philadelphia, 1967, pp. 208–223.
S O M E I N H E R E N T LY C H I R A L C H R O M O P H O R E S
20. A. W. Burgstahler, D. L. Boger, N. C. Naik, Tetrahedron 1976, 32 , 309–315. 21. G. Giacomelli, L. Lardicci, C. Bertucci, A. M. Caporusso, Tetrahedron, 1978, 34 , 2015–2020. 22. H. J. C. Jacobs, E. Havinga, Rec. Trav. Chim. 1965, 84 , 932–941. 23. K. K. Cheong, A. Oshita, D. J. Caldwell, H. Eyring, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 1970, 67 , 1727–1733 24. M. C. A. Donkersloot, H. M. Buck, J. Mol. Struct. 1988, 180 , 389–390. 25. H. Weiss, H. Ziffer, E. Charney, Tetrahedron 1965, 21 , 3105–3120. 26. E. Charney, H. Ziffer, U. Weiss, Tetrahedron 1965, 21 , 3121–3126. 27. W. Hug, G. Wagniere, Helv. Chim. Acta 1971, 54 , 633–649. 28. J. S. Rosenfield, E. Charney, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1977, 99 , 3209–3214. 29. E. Charney, C.-H. Lee, J. S. Rosenfield, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1979, 101 , 6802–6804. 30. D. A. Lightner, T. D. Bouman, J. K. Gawronski, K. Gawronska, J. L. Chappuis, B. V. Crist, A. E. Hansen, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1981, 103 , 5314–5327. 31. A. Rauk, J. O. Jarvie, H. Ichimura, J. M. Barriel, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1975, 97 , 5656–5664. 32. J. Lessard, L. Ruest, Ch. R. Engel, Can. J. Chem. 1972, 50 , 1433–1437. 33. A. E. Hansen, K. L. Bak, J. Phys. Chem. A 2000, 104 , 11362–11370. 34. R. Bucourt, Topics in Stereochemistry N. L. Allinger and E. L. Eliel, eds., 1974, 8 , 159. 35. P. J. Roberts, R. C. Patterson, G. M. Sheldrick, N. W. Isaacs, O. Kennard, J. Chem. Soc. Perkin II , 1973, 1978–1984. 36. B. Busetta, C. Courseille, F. Leroy, M. Hospital, Acta Crystallogr. Sec. B 1972, 28 , 3293–3299. 37. A. Cooper, G. Kartha, E. M. Gopalakrishna, D. A. Norton, Acta. Crystallogr. Sec. B 1969, 25 , 2409–2411. 38. A. Cooper, E. M. Gopalakrishna, D. A. Norton, Acta. Crystallogr. Sec. B 1968, 24 , 935–941. 39. H.-G. Kuball, S. Neubrech, A. Sch¨onhofer, Chem. Phys. 1992, 163 , 115–132. (b) H.-G. Kuball, B. Schultheis, M. Klasen, J. Frelek, A. Sch¨onhofer, Tetrahedron: Asymmetry, 1993, 4 , 517–528. (c) J. Frelek, W. J. Szczepek, H. P. Weiss, G. J. Reiss, W. Frank, J. Brechtel, B. Schultheis, H.-G. Kuball, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1998, 120 , 7010–7019. (d) J. Frelek, W. J. Szczepek, S. Neubrech, B. Schultheis, J. Brechtel, H.-G. Kuball, Chem. Eur. J . 2002, 8 , 1899–1907. 40. L. Velluz, M. Legrand, R. Viennet, C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris. 1965, 261 , 1687–1691. 41. M. Kwit, J. Gawronski, D. R. Boyd, N. D. Sharma, M. Kaik, Org. Biomol. Chem. 2010, 8 , 5635–5645. 42. (a) F. Weinhold, in, Encyclopedia of Computational Chemistry, Vol. 3, P. v. R. Schleyer, N. L. Allinger, T. Clark, J. Gasteiger, P. A. Kollman, H. F. Schaefer III, and P. R. Schreiner, eds., John Wiley & Sons, Chichester, UK, 1998, pp. 1792–1811. (b) A. E. Reed, L. A. Curtiss, F. Weinhold, Chem. Rev . 1988, 88 , 899–926. (c) F. Weinhold, J. E. Carpenter, in, The Structure of Small Molecules and Ions, R. Naaman and Z. Vager, eds., Plenum, New York, 1988, pp. 227–236. (d) F. Weinhold, Computational Methods in Organic Photochemistry: Molecular and Supramolecular Photochemistry, A. G. Kutateladze, ed., Taylor & Francis/CRC Press, Boca Raton FL, 2005, pp. 393–476. 43. C. Diedrich, S. Grimme, J. Phys. Chem. A 2003, 107 , 2524–2539. 44. For the other definition of homo- and heterohelicity see, for example: M. Kwit, U. Rychlewska, J. Gawronski, New J. Chem. 2002, 26 , 1714–1717. 45. J. Gawronski, K. Gawronska, G. Buczak, A. Katrusiak, P. Skowronek, H. Suemune, Tetrahedron: Asymmetry 1996, 7 , 301–306. 46. (a) J. Gawronski, M. Kwit, D. R. Boyd, N. D. Sharma, J. F. Malone, A. F. Drake, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2005, 127 , 4308–4319. (b) M. Kwit, J. Gawronski, Chirality 2011, 23 , 744–751.
69
70
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
47. M. Kwit, N. D. Sharma, D. R. Boyd, J. Gawronski, Chem. Eur. J . 2007, 13 , 5812–5821. 48. M. Kwit, N. D. Sharma, D. R. Boyd, J. Gawronski, Chirality 2008, 20 , 609–620. 49. (a) D. R. Boyd, G. N. Sheldrake, Nat. Prod. Rep. 1998, 15 , 309–324. (b) T. Hudlicky, D. Gonzalez, D. T. Gibson, Aldrichimica Acta 1999, 32 , 35–62. (c) R. A. Johnson, Org. React. 2004, 63 , 117–264. (d) D. R. Boyd, T. D. H. Bugg, Org. Biomol. Chem. 2006, 4 , 181–192. 50. E. Zysman-Colman, D. N. Harpp, J. Sulfur. Chem. 2004, 25 , 291–316. 51. P. Groner, C. W. Gillies, J. Z. Gillies, Y. Zhang, E. Block, J. Mol. Spectrosc. 2004, 226 , 169–181. 52. W. H. Green, A. B. Harvey, J. Chem. Phys. 1968, 49 , 3586–3595. 53. P. D’Antonio, C. George, A. H. Lowrey, J. Karle, J. Chem. Phys. 1971, 55 , 1071–1075. 54. O. Mundt, G. Becker, J. Baumgarten, H. Riffel, A. Simon, Z. Anorg. Allg. Chem. 2006, 632 , 1687–1709. 55. H. Lumbroso, J. M. Catel, G. Le Coustumer, C. G. Andrieu, J. Mol. Struct. 1999, 513 , 201–218. 56. R. Steudel, Y. Drozdova, K. Miaskiewicz, R. H. Hertwig, W. Koch, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1997, 119 , 1990–1996. 57. W. N. Hubbard, D. R. Douslin, J. P. McCullough, D. W. Scott, S. S. Todd, J. F. Messerly, I. A. Hossenlopp, A. George, G. Waddington, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1958, 80 , 3547–3554. 58. D. W. Scott, H. L. Finke, M. E. Gross, G. B. Guthrie, H. M. Huffman, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1950, 72 , 2424–2430. 59. H. A. Khwaja, S. Walker, Can. J. Chem. 1983, 61 , 2107–2111. 60. R. L. Redington, J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1962, 9 , 469–476. 61. J. Hahn, P. Schmidt, K. Reinartz, J. Behrend, G. Winnewisser, K. M. T. Yamada, Z. Naturforsch. 1991, 46 , 1338–1342. 62. V. Aquilanti, M. Ragni, A. C. P. Bitencourt, G. S. Maciel, F. V. Prudente, J. Phys. Chem. A, 2009, 113 , 3804–3813. 63. D. Nori-Shargh, H. Yahyaei, J. E. Boggs, J. Mol. Graphics Modell . 2010, 28 , 807–813. 64. T. Shimizu, H. Isono, M. Yasui, F. Iwasaki, N. Kamigata, Org. Lett. 2001, 3 , 3639–3641. 65. G. Bergson, Ark. Kemi 1958, 12 , 233–237. 66. G. Bergson, Ark. Kemi 1962, 18 , 409–434. 67. J. Linderberg, J. Michl, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1970, 92 , 2619–2625. 68. R. W. Woody, Tetrahedron 1973, 29 , 1273–1283. 69. M. Pericou-Cayere, M. Rerat, A. Dargelos, Chem. Phys. 1998, 226 , 297–306. 70. J. Seino, Y. Honda, M. Hada, H. Nakatsuji, J. Phys. Chem. A 2006, 110 , 10053–10062. ´ Ken´ez, S. Antus, L. Szil´agyi, T. Z. Illy´es, I. Szab´o, 71. T. Kurt´an, G. Pescitelli, P. Salvadori, A. Chirality 2008, 20 , 379–385. ´ 72. P. Skowronek, J. Scianowski, J. Gawronski, Tetrahedron: Asymmetry, 2006, 17 , 2408–2412. ´ 73. P. Skowronek, J. Gawronski, J. Scianowski, 12th International Conference on Circular Dichroism, Brescia 2009. 74. C. Djerassi, A. Fredga, B. Sj¨oberg, Acta Chem. Scand . 1961, 15 , 417–426. 75. B. Ringdahl, J. C. Craig, G. Zdansky, A. Fredga, Acta Chem. Scand . 1980, 34 , 735–738. 76. P. M. Scopes, R. N. Thomas, M. B. Rahman, J. Chem. Soc. C 1971, 1671–1676. 77. B. Ringdahl, J. C. Craig, A. Fredga, W. A. Bonner, Acta Chem. Scand . 1981, 35 , 467–471. 78. P. H. A. Laur, Proceedings of Third International Symposium on Organic Selenium and Tellurium Compounds, 1981, 217–229. 79. M. Michalska, G. Snatzke, Liebigs Ann. Chem. 1987, 179–181. 80. Y. Honda, A. Kurihara, Y. Kenmochi, M. Hada, Molecules 2010, 15 , 2357–2373.
S O M E I N H E R E N T LY C H I R A L C H R O M O P H O R E S
81. J. Mann, M. J. C. Crabbe, Bacteria and Antibacterial Agents, Oxford University Press, New York, 1996. 82. R. D. G. Cooper, Topics in Antibiotics Chemistry, Ellis Horwood, Chichester, 1980. 83. G. I. Georg, Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. (Symposia-in-print No 8) 1993, 3 , 2159. 84. A. G. Brown, D. Butterworth, M. Cole, G. Hanscomb, J. D. Hood, C. Reading, G. N. Rolinson, J. Antibiot. 1976, 29 , 668–669. 85. R. M. Sweet, L. I. Dahl, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1970, 92 , 5489–5507. 86. D. B. Boyd, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1972, 94 , 6513–6519. 87. D. B. Boyd, J. Med. Chem. 1973, 16 , 1195–1199. 88. R. Busson, H. Vanderhaeghe, J. Org. Chem. 1978, 43 , 4438–4441. 89. R. Busson, E. Roets, H. Vanderhaeghe, J. Org. Chem. 1978, 43 , 4434–4437. 90. H. Rehling, H. Jensen, Tetrahedron Lett. 1972, 27 , 2793–2796. 91. H. Ogura, H. Takayanagi, K. Kubo, K. Furuhata, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1973, 95 , 8056–8059. 92. H. Ogura, K. Takeda, H. Takahashi, Chem. Pharm. Bull . 1975, 23 , 2469–2473. 93. V. Toome, B. Wegrzynski, G. Reymond, Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 1976, 69 , 206–211. 94. J. McCann, A. Rauk, G. V. Shustov, H. Wieser, D. Yang, Appl. Spectros. 1996, 50 , 630–641. 95. D. Galle, M. Tolksdorf, M. Braun, Tetrahedron Lett. 1995, 36 , 4217–4720. 96. H. Wolf, Tetrahedron Lett. 1966, 5151–5156. 97. G. Barbaro, A. Battaglia, A. Guerrini, C. Bertucci, S. Geremia, Tetrahedron: Asymmetry 1998, 9 , 3401–3409. 98. Y. Chen, A. G. Petrovic, M. Roje, G. Pescitelli, M. M. Kayser, Y. Yang, N. Berova, G. Proni, Chirality 2010, 22 , 140–152. 99. T. Polonski, M. J. Milewska, Croat. Chim. Acta 1989, 62 , 129–134. 100. E. Ong, L. Cusachs, O. Weigang, J. Chem. Phys. 1977, 67 , 3289–3297. 101. A. Moscowitz, Advan. Chem. Phys. 1962, 4 , 67–112. 102. A. Moscowitz, Dansk Kemi 1962, 43 , 113–117. 103. A. Moscowitz, K. Mislow, M. A. W. Glass, C. Djerassi, J.Am.Chem.Soc. 1962, 84 , 1945–1955. 104. D. B. Boyd, J. P. Rhiel, F. S. Richardson, Tetrahedron 1979, 35 , 1499–1508. 105. I. Fric, P. Malon, M. Tichy, K. Blaha, Collect. Czechoslov. Chem. Comm. 1977, 42 , 678–686. 106. K. Blaha, M. Budesinsky, I. Fric, Z. Koblicova, P. Malon, M. Tichy, Tatrahedron Lett. 1978, 41 , 3449–3452. 107. G. Shustov, A. Kachanov, I. Chervin, R. Kostyanovsky, A. Rauk, Can. J. Chem. 1994, 72 , 279–286. 108. G. V. Shustov, G. K. Kadorkina, S. V. Varlamov, A. V. Kachanov, R. G. Kostyanovsky, A. Rauk, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1992, 114 , 1616–1623. 109. M. Braun, D. Galle, Synthesis 1996, 819–820. 110. D. B. Boyd, C.-Y. Yeh, F. S. Richardson, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1976, 98 , 6100–6106. 111. D. B. Boyd, J. P. Riehl, F. S. Richardson, Tetrahedron 1979, 35 , 1499–1508. 112. J.-C. Mueller, V. Toome, D. L. Pruess, J. Antibiotics 1983, XXXVI , 217–225. 113. R. Łysek, K. Borsuk, M. Chmielewski, Z. Kału˙za, Z. Urba´nczyk-Lipkowska, A. Klimek, J. Frelek, J. Org. Chem. 2002, 67 , 1472–1479. 114. J. Frelek, R. Łysek, K. Borsuk, J. Jagodzi´nski, B. Furman, A. Klimek, M. Chmielewski, Enantiomer 2002, 7 , 107–114. 115. A. Kozioł, J. Frelek, M. Wo´znica, B. Furman, M. Chmielewski, Eur. J. Org. Chem. 2009, 338–341.
71
72
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
116. T. T. Danh, W. Bocian, L. Kozerski, P. Szczukiewicz, J. Frelek, M. Chmielewski, Eur. J. Org. Chem. 2005, 429–440. 117. A. Kozioł, B. Furman, J. Frelek, M. Wo´znica, E. Altieri, M. Chmielewski, J. Org. Chem. 2009, 74 , 5687–5690. 118. J. Frelek, P. Kowalska, M. Masnyk, A. Kazimierski, A. Korda, M. Wo´znica, M. Chmielewski, F. Furche, Chemistry—Eur. J . 2007, 13 , 6732–6744. 119. M. Wo´znica, P. Kowalska, R. Rysek, M. Masnyk, M. G´orecki, M. Kwit, F. Furche, J. Frelek, Curr. Org. Chem. 2010, 14 , 1022–1036. 120. M. Chmielewski, M. Cierpucha, P. Kowalska, M. Kwit, J. Frelek, Chirality 2008, 20 , 621–627. 121. M. Wo´znica, M. Masnyk, S. Stecko, A. Mames, B. Furman, M. Chmielewski, J. Frelek, J. Org. Chem. 2010, 75 , 7219–7226. 122. G. Snatzke, Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. Engl . 1979, 18 , 363–377.
3 ELECTRONIC CD OF BENZENE AND OTHER AROMATIC CHROMOPHORES FOR DETERMINATION OF ABSOLUTE CONFIGURATION ´ Sandor ´ Tibor Kurtan, Antus, and Gennaro Pescitelli
3.1. BENZENE DERIVATIVES WITH CONTIGUOUS CHIRALITY CENTER; SECTOR AND CHIRALITY RULES The benzene chromophore is a common structural feature in numerous optically active synthetic and natural products, and hence Cotton effects (CEs) of the characteristic π –π ∗ electric transitions are regularly utilized for the determination of their absolute configurations. Above 175 nm, benzene shows three π –π ∗ electronic absorption bands, centered at 184, 204, and 254 nm and designated as 1 Ba,b (E1u ), 1 La (B1u ), and 1 Lb (B2u ), respectively [1–3]. Depending on the substitution pattern of the aromatic ring, the position and intensities of these absorption bands can be somewhat altered, but the spectrum is essentially unchanged. It is the longest wavelength CE belonging to the 1 Lb (B2u ) band, which is most often used to determine the absolute configuration of benzene derivatives. The 1 Lb transition is both electronically and magnetically forbidden in benzene, and its electronic absorption intensity derives from vibronic borrowing from the allowed 1 Ba,b transition. The 1 Lb band shows well-defined vibrational fine structure, and its CEs are associated with allowed transitions from the lowest-energy vibrational mode in the ground state to totally symmetric vibrational modes in the lowest-energy electronically excited state, and the lowest-energy CE corresponds to the 0–0 vibrational transition 1 Lb CE. Sometimes two distinct vibrational progressions appear with similar spacing and a small separation. The two progressions may have CEs with opposite signs, and in this situation the CD in the 1 Lb region appears as a succession of a sequence of minima and maxima or of maxima of alternating sign [4–6]. Upon substitution of the benzene ring, an additional intensity is attributed to the induced electric transition moment due to the substituent that destroys the symmetry of benzene [7]. In optically active benzene Comprehensive Chiroptical Spectroscopy, Volume 2: Applications in Stereochemical Analysis of Synthetic Compounds, Natural Products, and Biomolecules, First Edition. Edited by N. Berova, P. L. Polavarapu, K. Nakanishi, and R. W. Woody. © 2012 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Published 2012 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
73
74
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
TAB L E 3.1. 1 Lb Band CEs of (R)-Phenylmethylcarbinols in Methanola H
R C
OH CH3
Compound (R)-1 (R)-2 (R)-3 (R)-4 (R)-5 (R)-6 (R)-7 a Spectroscopic
CD [λ, nm (ε × 102 )
R H p-Cl p-CF3 m-Cl m-CF3 o-Cl o-CF3
268 276 268 274 271 273 270
Reference
(−17) (+2.5) (−12) (−28) (−15) (+6.7) (−13)
9 9 9 10 10 10 11
moments [8]: qCl = +6, q(CF3 ) = −9 [(cm mol)/L]−1/2 .
derivatives, the rotational strength of the 1 Lb CEs is influenced by the 1 Ba,b transitions through vibronic coupling as well as by the induced transition moments of the aromatic substituents. In previous papers [10, 12–16] and a review [17] on the ECD study of phenyl- and benzylcarbinols, phenyl- and benzylcarbinamines, and 1-substituted indans and tetralins, Smith applied an empirical sector rule to describe the vibronic contribution to the 1 Lb CE in monosubstituted benzene derivatives with a contiguous chirality center. This sector rule divides the space around the benzene chromophore into 12 sectors, but it is simplified to a quadrant rule for monosubstituted benzenes, since only sectors surrounding the chirality centers have to be considered (Figure 3.1). In the quadrant rule, the plane of the benzene ring defines a nodal plane, while the other one, perpendicular to the former, is allocated by the attachment bond of the benzylic carbon as shown in Figure 3.1. In substituted benzene derivatives with hydrogen atom at the contiguous chirality center, the benzylic hydrogen eclipses or nearly eclipses the plane of the benzene ring as supported by X-ray [18, 19], 1 H NMR [20, 21], and molecular modeling [22]. Since the observed chiroptical properties are dependent on both the conformation and absolute configuration, the knowledge of the proper conformation regarding the rotation about the benzylic
(a)
(b)
(c)
H C* R1
H
H C*
R2
R1
* R2
R1
R2
Figure 3.1. (a) Sector rule for third sphere contribution to the 1 Lb CE in monosubstituted benzene derivatives with contiguous chirality center. The plane of the benzene ring is also a nodal plane; signs are for the upper sectors. (b) Quadrant sector rule of monosubstituted benzene derivatives with benzylic chirality center. The plane of the benzene ring is also a nodal plane; signs are for the upper sectors. (c) Quadrant sector rule with signs of all the four sectors viewed from the direction of the benzylic carbon. Thick line represents the benzene ring, defining a nodal plane. Benzylic hydrogen eclipces or nearly eclipses the plane of the benzene ring.
E L E C T R O N I C C D O F B E N Z E N E A N D O T H E R A R O M AT I C C H R O M O P H O R E S
attachment bond is crucial for the correct application of the sector rule. If the benzylic hydrogen is not totally eclipsed with the benzene ring as observed by Pescitelli et al. [23] (vide infra) in the ECD analysis of PhCH(Me)t-Bu supported by TDDFT-ECD calculation, and by Butz and co-workers for α-phenylethyl alcohol (1) from gas-phase data [24], the application of the benzene sector rule becomes ambiguous (Table 3.1). If the benzylic hydrogen lies in the plane of the benzene ring (nodal plane), it does not have significant contribution, while the R1 and R2 groups are in front and rear sectors with negative and positive contributions, respectively. Based on experimental ECD data, a sequence of magnitudes of the contribution to the 1 Lb CE of various groups (related to group polarizabilities) has been determined [13]. For example, in (R)-α-phenylethyl alcohol [(R)-1, R1 = Me, R2 = OH, Figure 3.1], the methyl group, located in the negative lower front sector, has larger rotatory contribution than the hydroxyl group, which implies a negative 1 Lb band CE as found experimentally for (R)-1. Similarly, the sector rule can predict the sign of 1 Lb band CE and thus determine the absolute configuration from the experimental 1 Lb band CE for monosubstituted benzene derivatives with benzylic chirality centers if the sequence of rotatory contributions are known for the benzylic substituents R1 and R2 (Figure 3.1). It must, however, be stressed that the relative order of magnitude, for example, the methyl vs. the hydroxyl group contribution in 1 has been disputed [24]. While it is only the vibronic contribution (orientation and sequence of R1 and R2 ) that determines the 1 Lb band CE of monosubstituted benzene derivatives, with additional achiral ring substituents there is an additional induced rotatory contribution to the 1 Lb CE, which may have the same or opposite sign as that of the vibronic contribution. The magnitude of the induced electronic transition moment is related to the spectroscopic moment of the ring substituent, introduced by Platt [25] and Petruska [8]. Depending on the spectroscopic moment and ring position(s) of the substituent(s), the induced rotatory contribution can reinforce, decrease, or even override the vibronic contribution, whose effects are summarized by a chirality rule [17]. When (R)-α-phenylethyl alcohol [(R)1)] is substituted with a chlorine atom, having a negative spectroscopic moment, the induced rotatory contribution overrides the negative vibronic contribution and results in positive 1 Lb CEs for o- and p-substitution [(R)-6 and (R)-2, respectively], while for msubstitution the negative 1 Lb CE is preserved [(R)-4]. In contrast, when the trifluoromethyl group, having a positive spectroscopic moment, is the aromatic substituent, o-, m- and p-substituted derivatives [(R)-3, (R)-5, (R)-7] give equally negative 1 Lb CEs; i .e. the induced rotatory contribution of the trifluoromethyl substituent does not overshadow the negative vibronic contribution of the chirality center. It seems that phenylalkylcarbinols and phenylalkylcarbinamines ortho- or para-substituted by an atom or group with positive spectroscopic moment (Cl, Br, CH3 , OH, OMe) show 1 Lb CEs of opposite sign to that of the unsubstituted parent compound. In contrast, derivatives having a substituent with negative spectroscopic moment (CF3 , CN) in the meta position have the same sign of 1 Lb CEs as that of the unsubstituted parent. As a summary, the unambiguous configurational assignment of benzene derivatives with a benzylic chirality center by semiempirical rules has to meet the following conditions: 1. Benzylic hydrogen is eclipsed with the plane of the benzene ring or else the exact conformation must be known. 2. Reliable priority order for the rotatory contributions of the benzylic R1 and R2 substituents (vibronic contribution to the 1 Lb CE).
75
76
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
3. Clear-cut allocation of the R1 and R2 substituents to sectors. 4. When vibronic and induced contributions have opposite signs, one has to know which is the dominant contribution. Even in the absence of auxochromic substituents on the phenyl ring, the consistency of the sector rule for benzene 1 Lb transition has been recently called into question by different reports having in common the use of high-level quantum-mechanics calculations for predicting ECD spectra. It must be stressed that ECD calculations offer a valuable chance for validating sector rules, the benefit of which the original authors of the rules didn’t have. In fact, provided that a reliable calculation method is chosen, the calculations allow one to observe the chiroptical response of a molecule in a certain specific geometry (that used as an input). Moreover, such a geometry may be manipulated accessing hypothetical conformations which cannot be physically observed. Pescitelli et al. have reported the ECD spectra of a homologous series of simple chiral aliphatic compounds (R)-PhCH(Me)R [(R)-8-11] with R = Et, nPr, i Pr and tBu, respectively [23]. Compound (R)-11 showed a negative 1 Lb CE in agreement with Smith’s rule; however, the lowest-energy conformation for this derivative had the C–H bond not coplanar with the ring as prescribed by the rule, thus the agreement was fortuitous. The lowest-energy conformations of the remaining compounds do have the prescribed conformation. Low-temperature ECD spectra (at 183 K), which should be dominated in all cases by the respective lowest energy conformer, consist of a series of more intense maxima with positive sign alternated by a series of weaker maxima with negative sign (Figure 3.2). The first series is allied with the allowed vibrational progression with spacing 920–1000 cm−1 , and its sign is at odds with that predicted by the 1 Lb CE sector rule. Time-dependent density functional theory (TDDFT) calculations reproduced instead the dominant sign of 1 Lb CE’s, although a more correct treatment would necessarily include vibronic effects [26, 27]. A further exception to the 1 Lb CE sector rule has been reported by Butz et al. [24] concerning (R)-α-phenylethyl alcohol [(R)-1]. According to these authors, the apparent consistency between the negative 1 Lb CE observed for (R)-1 and the sector rule is due to an incorrectly assumed conformation. The correct lowest-energy structure, found by geometry optimizations and gas-phase experiments, has the methyl bond roughly perpendicular to the plane of the phenyl, and the C–H bond is well oustide from the plane. To reconcile such a structure with the observed ECD spectrum, the sector signs for the rule must be reversed. Later, the authors substantiated their conclusions by TDDFT calculations also using a solvent model [28]. In this study, the relevant dihedral angles for 1 (Ph-Cα and Cα-O) were varied systematically and their impact on the sign of calculated 1 Lb CE was ascertained. Moreover, a rigorous theoretical approach was followed by Autschbach and co-workers in their critical evaluation of the same sector rule. The authors generated true nodal surfaces delimiting the sectors by placing a negative charge on a grid set on the top of a benzene ring at a fixed distance and varying its position systematically [29]. Since the benzene ring becomes dissymetrically perturbed by the charge, its transitions acquire non-negligible rotational strengths. In this case too, the signs obtained for the 1 Lb sector rule were opposite to the original ones. The above findings demonstrate that at least for simple benzenes with chiral substituents (i.e., endowed with third-sphere chirality in Snatzke’s terminology) [30, 31], the sector rule for 1 Lb CE is far from being generally valid and should be used with caution. Since in previous papers [13–15, 17], Smith reviewed the application of sector and helicity rules to benzene derivatives with contiguous chirality center in detail, the present chapter focuses mainly on benzene natural products with condensed carbocyclic and especially heterocyclic rings such as in tetralin, dihydrobenzo[b]furan, chroman, isochroman
77
E L E C T R O N I C C D O F B E N Z E N E A N D O T H E R A R O M AT I C C H R O M O P H O R E S
1
1 (a)
×20
×20
(b) 0
0 ×2
293 k 183 k
–1
–1
×2
293 k 183 k
Δε
Δε
–2
–2
nPr
Et
–3
–3 (R)-(1-methylpropyl)-benzene [(R)-8]
(R)-(1-methylbutyl)-benzene [(R)-9]
–4
–4 190 200 210 220 250 260 270 280 λ (nm)
190 200 210 220 250 260 270 280 λ (nm)
1 (c)
0 (d)
×20
0
–1 Δε
–2
×2
293 k 183 k
×20 293 k 173 k
–4 Δε
–2 iPr
–6 tBu
–8
–3
–4
(R)-(1,2,-dimethylpropyl)-benzene [(R)-10] ×.5 190 200 210 220 250 260 270 280 λ (nm)
–10 ×.5 –12
(R)-(1,2,2-trimethylpropyl)benzene [(R)-11]
190 200 210 220 250 260 270 280 λ (nm)
Figure 3.2. Experimental ECD spectra of (R)-PhCH(Me)R derivatives (R)-8-11 at room temperature (solid lines) and at 173–183 K (dashed lines) in hexane or heptane. (Reprinted from reference 23, with permission from Elsevier).
and benzodioxane derivatives. In these derivatives the phenyl chromophore is embedded in a chiral ring, thus they exhibit second-sphere chirality [30, 31]. Some of Smith’s results have been outlined above to underscore the parallelism between the theories describing the two families of benzene derivatives. The major goal of the recent chapter is to provide guidelines for nonspecialists in the determination of absolute configuration of cyclic natural products with fused benzene ring by means of benzene semiempirical helicity rules.
3.2. TETRALIN AND TETRAHYDROISOQUINOLINE DERIVATIVES 3.2.1. Tetralins and Tetrahydroisoquinolines without Aromatic Ring Substituents; P/M Helicity → Positive/Negative 1 Lb CE In terms of chromophoric system, chiral tetralin and 1,2,3,4-tetrahydroisoquinoline derivatives belong to the benzene chromophores with chiral second sphere [30, 31]. In
78
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
(a)
6 X
P helicity
positive
5a
4 3
X
X2 8a 1 8 ωC5a,C4,C3,X < 0 X: CH2 tetralin X: NH tetrahydroisoquinoline negative M helicity sign of the 1Lb-band CE 7
ωC5a,C4,C3,X > 0
5
(b)
X
Figure 3.3. (a) Snatzke’s helicity rule or correlation between the sign of the second sphere contribution of tetralin (tetrahydroisoquinoline) and the 1 Lb band CE [30, 32]. The arrow indicates the direction of the overall spectroscopic moment. P- and M-helicity refer to the absolute conformation of the nonaromatic ring. (b) Sector rules for the third (fourth) sphere contributions to the 1 Lb band CE in tetraline (tetrahydroisquinoline). The plane of the benzene ring is a nodal plane, and signs refer to upper sectors.
these cases, the achiral benzene chromophore (first sphere) is chirally perturbed by the fused chiral ring (second sphere) and the substituents of the heterocyclic ring (third sphere), which gives rise to the observed Cotton effects. In tetralin derivatives having no substituents on the fused aromatic ring, the 1 Lb CE is determined mainly by the absolute conformation [30] of the fused nonaromatic chiral ring adopting usually a half-chair conformation–that is, the P - or M -helicity defined by the ωC5a,C4,C3,X torsional angle, which in turn is directed by the absolute configuration of the fused ring (Figure 3.3). Snatzke and Ho [32] developed a so-called helicity rule for the benzene chromophore of chiral tetralin and tetrahydroisoquinoline derivatives (Figure 3.3) according to which if the benzene ring is not further substituted, P -helicity of the nonaromatic ring leads to a positive CE within the 1 Lb band and, vice versa, M -helicity is manifested in a negative one. Moreover, a sector rule [33–36] was introduced to evaluate the contribution of the third sphere, namely, the presence of substituents attached to the nonaromatic ring. This sector rule is similar to the sector rule of benzene derivatives with benzylic chirality center (Figure 3.1a) except for that an additional plane is added, perpendicular to the benzene ring and coinciding the C2 axis, resulting in 16 sectors (Figure 3.3b). There is a simple relationship between the helicity rule and sector rule of tetralin; the two non-coplanar carbon atoms of tetralin lie in positive sectors with P -helicity affording the same prediction by the two rules. Since it is the chiral sphere nearest to the chromophores that generally determines the sign of the 1 Lb CE, the helicity of the nonaromatic ring has to be considered as the dominant contribution. If the relationship between the helicity of the nonaromatic ring and the sign of 1 Lb band CE is known, the chirality (absolute conformation) of the heterocyclic ring can be deduced from the measured ECD spectrum. Since the relative configuration of the substituents at the chiral centers as well as their equatorial or axial orientation can be obtained from NMR experiments (3 JH,H , 3 JC,H , NOE effects) or X-ray analysis, their absolute configurations can be also assigned. For instance, in the (2S , 3S )-12 tetraline derivative (Table 3.2), the trans-diequatorial arrangement of the C2 and C3 methyl groups and half-chair conformation of the carbocyclic ring can be determined from NMR experiments (e.g., large value of 3 J2H,3H ); and then according to the helicity rule, the measured positive 1 Lb CE suggests that the nonaromatic ring adopts P -helicity [36]. The combination of these two data allows the determination of the absolute configuration as (2S , 3S )-12. Similarly, the positive 1 Lb CEs of (2R)-13, (1R)-14, and (4aS , 9aS )15 derive from P -helicity of the dominant conformer with half-chair conformation. In
E L E C T R O N I C C D O F B E N Z E N E A N D O T H E R A R O M AT I C C H R O M O P H O R E S
order to reduce van der Waals repulsion between the 1-Me and peri 8-H in (1R)-14, the 1-Me group preferably adopts a quasi-axial orientation with a distorted half-chair conformation [36]. The measured positive 1 Lb CE implies P -helicity, which is only feasible with (1R)-14 absolute configuration. With a half-chair conformation of the fused ring B, the benzylic 9-Me group of (4aS , 9S , 9aR)-16 would be in an equatorial orientation, however, C9 moves into the plane of the benzene ring to shift the 9-Me to a quasi-axial position and thus reduces the repulsion with peri 8-H and 1-H, resulting in a twist boat conformation. Since the nonaromatic ring adopts a conformation considerably different from the half-chair one, and other equilibrating conformers may also contribute, the helicity rule fails to determine the right absolute configuration in this case. In contrast, the epimeric (4aS , 9R, 9aR)17 corroborates well the helicity rule, since the fused cyclohexene ring has half-chair conformation with an axial 9-Me as the major conformer. The tetrahydroisoquinoline derivatives 18–21 behave similarly, and M -helicity results in a negative 1 Lb CE and vice versa.
3.2.2. Tetralins with Achiral Ring Substituents Snatzke et al. [31, 39] also showed that achiral substituents of the benzene ring with large spectroscopic moment {e.g., qOMe = +21 [(cm mol)/L]−1/2 } [8] in specific positions inverted the helicity rule. This inversion was attributed to the change of the direction of the sum spectroscopic moment [8, 25, 40, 41] vector which gives the electric transition moment vector (μ)–namely, the translation of the electron charge during the transition. This effect was called the induced rotatory contribution and was described by the chirality rule (vide supra) for benzene derivatives with contiguous chirality center. In Snatzke’s terminology, the achiral ring substituents can induce the inversion of the original helicity rule, which is the consequence of rotating the electric transition moment by approximately 30◦ . Figure 3.4a shows a polarization diagram of the tetralin chromophore, in which the addition of the spectroscopic moments oriented the electric transition moment along the direction of the C2 axis of the chromophore, which gives a positive 1 Lb -band CE for P -helicity of the nonaromatic ring (helicity rule of unsubstituted tetraline). The same helicity rule is valid for 6,7-dimethoxytetralins (Figure 3.4b), since in the presence of the two methoxy substituents at position 6 and 7, the direction of the electric transition moment does not change. In contrast, when tetralin has only one methoxy or hydroxy group at C6, the sum of the spectroscopic moments rotates the electric transition moment by approximately 30◦ , which leads to a sign inversion as shown in Figure 3.4c. Similarly, the inverse helicity rule holds for 5,7-dimethoxytetralins. A systematic study [31, 39] was carried out on substituted tetralin derivatives to reveal the effect of different substitution patterns on the sign of the 1 Lb band. This study clearly demonstrated that 5,8- and 6,7-disubstituted and 5,6,7-trisubstituted tetralins follow the same helicity rule as the unsubstituted tetralin, while 6-monosubstituted and 5,6- and 5,7-disubstituted tetralins obey the inverse one (Figure 3.5). The tetralin chromophore is found in pharmacologically active chiral synthetic derivatives such as melatoninergic ligands 22 [42] and 23 [43], the 5-HT1A receptor antagonist 24 [44], and 2-aminotetralin-2-carboxylic acids 25a,b [45, 46], the absolute configuration of which could have been determined by tetralin helicity rules (Chart 3.1). In 1-aryltetralin lignan natural products such as burseranin (26) [47], the 1-aryl group has exciton coupled interaction with the fused benzene ring [48], which determines the ECD spectrum (Chart 3.1). The absolute configurations of 1-aryltetralines are elucidated
79
80
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
TAB L E 3.2. Helicity and 1 Lb band CE of Tetralin and Tetrahydroisoquinoline Derivatives 8 7
R1 8a 1
6
5
5a
4
R1 3
4a
R2 2
6
1 10 R 4
5
7 8
3 R3
R2
R2
9a
9
R3
2
NH
1
H
R3
12 : R1 = H, R2, R3 = Me
15 : R1 = Me, R2 , R3 = H
18 : R1, R2 = H, R3 = Me
13 : R1, R3 = H, R2 = Me
16 : R1, R3 = H, R2 = Me
19 : R1, R3 = H, R2 = Me
1
2
3
1
14 : R = Me, R , R = H
2
3
17 : R , R = H, R = Me
20 : R1 = H, R2, R3 = Me 21 : R1, R3 = Me, R2 = H
Compound
Helicity of the Low-Energy Conformer H
(2S , 3S )-12
Me
1
Lb band CE [λ, nm (ε)a or [θ]b
Reference
272 (+0.191)a
36
264.5 (+0.248) Me H
(2R)-13
(1R)-14
H Me
H Me Me
(4aS , 9aS )-15 H2C
H
(4aS, 9S, 9aR)-16
H 2C
H
272 (+0.161)a 265 (+0.176)
36
272.5 (+0.226)a 264.5 (+0.233)
36
272.5 (+0.303)a 265 (+0.330)
36
272.5 (-0.058), 270 (+0.012)a 265 (−0.33), 257.5 (−0.027)
36
273 (+0.568)a 266 (+0.558)
36
266 (−290)b 273 (−800)b
37 38
270 (+292)b
37
CH2
CH2 H Me
H
(4aS, 9R, 9aR)-17
Me
H2C
H
H
H N
(1S )-18
H Me
H
(3S )-19 Me
N H
81
E L E C T R O N I C C D O F B E N Z E N E A N D O T H E R A R O M AT I C C H R O M O P H O R E S
TAB L E 3.2. (Continued ) 1
Helicity of the Low-Energy Conformer
Compound
Lb band CE [λ, nm (ε)a or [θ]b
37
265 (+613)b
37
265
H
Reference
(+718)b
H
Me
(1R, 3S )-20 N H Me
H
H
(1R, 3R)-21
N H a CE b CE
Me
Me
reported as ε. reported as θ .
(a)
–
5
+
+
– –
(b)
4
6
3
7
2
+
+
+
MeO
8 1 P-helicity positive1LbCE
– –
+ P-helicity positive1LbCE
(d)
(c) MeO +
–
MeO
–
+
MeO +
MeO –
–
+
–
MeO –
– P-helicity negative1LbCE
+
+ OMe
OMe P-helicity negative1LbCE
Figure 3.4. Polarization diagram of the 1 Lb band, direction of the overall spectroscopic moment, and helicity rule of (a) tetralin (b) 6,7-dimethoxytetralin (c) 6-methoxytetralin, and (d) 5,7dimethoxytetralin.
from the sign of the relatively intense CE in the 270- to 290-nm region, governed by the exciton coupling of the two 1 Lb transitions, and thus the helicity rule cannot be applied for this type of tetralin derivatives [49, 50].
3.3. BENZENE CHROMOPHORES WITH FUSED HETEROCYCLIC RING In the following, the applicability of benzene helicity rules is to be discussed in O-heterocyclic natural products, in which the fused benzene ring is part of a 2,3dihydrobenzo[b]furan, isochroman, chroman, or 1,4-benzodioxane moiety (Chart 3.2). The correlation between the n –π ∗ CE and the absolute geometry will be also
82
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
R1 R2
6
R3 7
R1 4
5
3
P-helicity positive 1Lb CE
2 8
tetralin: R1,R2,R3,R4= H 5,8-dimethoxytetralin: R1,R4= OMe, R2,R3= H 6,7-dimethoxytetralin: R1,R4= H, R2,R3= OMe 5,6,7-trimethoxytetralin:R1= H, R2,R3,R4= OMe
4 3
P-helicity negative1Lb CE
2
R3 7
1
R4
5
R2 6
8
1
6-methoxytetralin: R1,R3= H, R2= OMe 5,6-dimethoxytetralin: R1,R2= OMe, R3= H 5,7-dimethoxytetralin: R1,R3= OMe R2= H
Figure 3.5. Effect of achiral ring substituents of large spectroscopic moment (e.g., OMe) on the tetralin (tetrahydroisoquinoline) helicity rule.
O NHCOEt MeO
OH
NHC
n-Pr N
MeO
22
23
n-Pr
Me 24
O O O
NH2
O
COOH R
O O burseranin (26)
25a: R = H 25b: R = OH
Chart 3.1. Structures of tetralin derivatives 22–26.
R1
6
7 7a 1 O
5 4
4a 3
2 R2
2,3-dihydrobenzo[b]furan
R1
6
5 5a 4
7 8
8a 1 X
3 O2
R1
R2
X: H2 isochroman X: =O dihydroisocoumarin
R1
7 6
7 6
8 8a 1 O 2 R2 3 5 5a 4 X
X: H2 chroman X: =O chroman-4-one
8 8a 1 O 2 R2 3 5 5a O 4
1,4-benzodioxane
Chart 3.2. Chromophores with fused benzene ring.
addressed in some of the related carbonyl derivatives such as dihydroisocoumarins and chromanones. ECD spectroscopy has been often utilized for the elucidation of absolute configuration of these flavonoids by simply comparing the ECD spectra of similar derivatives without a deeper understanding of the factors that determine their chiroptical properties. We aimed to establish helicity rules for unsubstituted chromophores by the synthesis and
E L E C T R O N I C C D O F B E N Z E N E A N D O T H E R A R O M AT I C C H R O M O P H O R E S
ECD study of derivatives with known absolute configurations to see whether the original or inverse tetralin helicity rule is valid for these chromophores. Since the benzene rings are substituted in most of the natural products containing these chromophores, the effect of aromatic ring substituents on the helicity rule has to be studied as well, which will help natural product chemists to choose appropriate ECD reference compound for the unambiguous determination of absolute configuration of novel natural products. The determination of absolute configuration of natural benzene-fused heterocycles has to follow the protocol outlined below: 1. Determination of the relative configuration and axial /equatorial orientation of the ring substituents by NMR methods (3 J H,H , 3 JC,H , NOE effect), X-ray single crystal diffraction, computational conformational analysis or their combinations. These studies also provide information on the conformation of the fused nonaromatic ring whether it has a half-chair, envelope, or boat conformation. 2. Determination of the absolute conformation (helicity) of the fused heterocyclic ring on the basis of benzene ECD helicity rules from the measured 1 Lb band CE. The helicity rule of the unsubstituted chromophore and the effect of ring substituents with large spectroscopic moment have to be known. The helicity of the heterocyclic ring is governed by the absolute configuration of the chirality centers and the preferred equatorial/axial orientation of the substituents. Large substituents prefer equatorial orientation due to 1,3-diaxial interaction, although benzylic substituents sometimes tend to favor axial position in order to reduce van der Waals repulsion with the peri aromatic hydrogen. 3. For a safe configurational assignment, a major conformer with known conformations and high population is required that dominates the ECD parameters. 4. By merging the information on the helicity, relative configuration, and axial/equatorial orientation of the substituents, the absolute configuration can be deduced.
3.3.1. Benzodioxane Chromophore; P/M-Helicity → Positive/Negative 1 Lb CE The benzodioxane chromophore occurs in chiral nonracemic natural flavanolignans [51–53] and neolignans [54–57] as well as in synthetic derivatives of pharmacological interest [58–62]. Antus et al. [51] prepared 1,4-benzodioxane steroid derivatives 27a–c of known absolute configuration and helicity, the ECD study of which showed that the same 1 Lb band helicity rule is valid for unsubstituted 1,4-benzodioxanes as for analogous tetralins; the P /M -helicity of the heteroring leads to a positive/negative 1 Lb band CE, respectively (Chart 3.3, Table 3.3). This result also afforded the configurational assignment of the natural flavanolignan (−)-silandrin and (−)-isosilandrin isolated from Silybum marianum [51, 53]. The unsubstituted 1,4-benzodioxane helicity rule was applied to deduce the absolute configurations of synthetic glycogen phosphorylase inhibitors 28a–b, having a 1,4-benzodioxane moiety connected to a N -(β-D-glucopyranosyl)amide unit (Chart 3.3) [60]. Their opposite 1 Lb band CE is governed by the helicity of the heteroring (Table 3.3), which in turn is dictated by the equatorial orientation of the C2 substituent and then the absolute configuration of the C2 chirality center. The chirality centers of the sugar unit are manifested only in the transitions of the amide chromophore, which are not in a mirror image fashion, but they do not interfere with the characteristic 1 Lb band CE. The ECD data of (2R, 3S )-29a,b, (S)-30a,b, and
83
84
C O M P R E H E N S I V E C H I R O P T I C A L S P E C T R O S C O P Y, V O L U M E 2
1 H O 2 3 O 4 H 2-H 27a β 27b α 27c β
OH
OH HO HO H 3-H β α α
R2 6
O
R1 7
O
1
OH
O
R2 7
O
R1
2 1
O 2-C 28a (R) 28b (S) OH
6
OH
R1 R2 (S)-30a CH2OAc H (S)-30b H CH2OAc
O
OH
5
O
NHCOMe
4
R2 H (2R,3S)-29a (CH2)2NHCOMe H (CH2)2NHCOMe (2R,3S)-29b
OMe
2 3
O
R1
O
1
O
1 2 3
OH R 7
2
H N
O
8
EtO
6
O 1
OH
OMe R (2S, 3S)-31a (CH2)3OH (2S, 3S)-31b CH=CHCH2OH
2
OH
O (S)-32
Chart 3.3. Structures of benzodioxane derivatives.
TAB L E 3.3. Helicity and ECD Data of Benzodioxane Derivatives cpd. 27ac 27bc 27cc (R)-28a (S )-28b (2R, 3S )-29a (2R, 3S )-29b (S )-30a (S )-30b (2S , 3S )-31a (2S , 3S )-31b (S )-32
Helicity
CE {λ, nm (ε)a or [θ]b}
Reference
M M P M P P P M M M M M
285 (−1.49)a 285 (−1.09)a 284 (+1.59)a 279 (−0.09)a,d 278 (0.04)a,d 280 (+389)b 280 (+400)b 284 (−0.18)a 285 (−0.21)a 299 (−1010)b 282 (+2549)b 315sh (−0.41), 289 (−0.58)a
51 51 51 60 60 56 56 61 61 54 54 e
reported as ε. reported as θ . c With cholestane skeleton. d Absolute configurations are erroneously shown in reference