Composit in Infra truCtur Building New Markets
e
ELSEVIER
ADVANCED TECHNOLOGY
UK
Elsevier Science Ltd, The Boulev...
60 downloads
4228 Views
18MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Composit in Infra truCtur Building New Markets
e
ELSEVIER
ADVANCED TECHNOLOGY
UK
Elsevier Science Ltd, The Boulevard, Langford Lane, Kidlington, Oxford OX5 1AS, UK
USA
Elsevier Science Inc, 665 Avenue of the Americas, New York, NY 10010, USA
JAPAN
Elsevier Science Japan, Tsunashima Building Annex, 3-20-12 Yushima, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo 113, Japan
Copyright 9 2000 Elsevier Science Ltd Author: Elizabeth Marsh Project Editor: Jane Gilby All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means: electronic, electrostatic, magnetic tape, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without permission in writing from the publishers. Whilst every care is taken to ensure that the data published in this report is accurate, the publishers cannot accept responsibility for any omissions or inaccuracies appearing or for the consequences arising therefrom. First edition November 2000 ISBN 1 85617 368 2
Elsevier Advanced Technology The Boulevard, Langford Lane, Kidlington, Oxford OX5 1GB, UK Tel: +44 (0)1865 843750 Fax: +44 (0) 1865 843971 Printed in Great Britain by Biddies Ltd, King's Lynn
Contents
Global industry overview Main market areas by region 1.2.1 North America 1.2.2 Western Europe 1.2.3 Japan 1.2.4 Southeast Asia 1.2.5 Eastern Europe 1.2.6 South America 1.2.7 Middle East Challenges and opportunities Recent developments 1.4.1 Regulations and legislation 1.4.2 Developments in materials 1.4.3 Industry moves
19 19 21 21
1.5
Mergers and acquisitions 1999-2000
22
2.1
Roads and bridges 2.1.1 North America 2.1.2 Europe 2.1.3 Southeast Asia including Japan Chemical process plant (including cooling towers) Pipelines and tanks Power supplies Marine (harbours and docks) Offshore Public utilities Mass transit
33 36 38 40 40 42 45 48
1.1 1.2
1.3 1.4
2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.7 2.8
2 4 4 7 9 11 14 15 16 16
49 50 51
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets iii
Contents
3.4
Introduction Resins 3.2.1 Unsaturated polyester (UP) resins 3.2.2 Vinyl ester resins 3.2.3 Phenolic resins 3.2.4 Epoxy resins Reinforcements 3.3.1 Introduction 3.3.2 Glass fibres 3.3.3 Aramid fibres 3.3.4 Carbon fibres Other materials
55 58 58 61 62 63 64 64 64 69 71 74
4.1
Introduction
75
4.2
Hand lay-up and spray-up Pultrusion Filament winding Injection moulding Resin transfer moulding (RTM)
76
3.1 3.2
3.3
4.3 4.4 4.5 4.6 4.7 4.8 4.9
5.1 5.2
5.3 5.4
5.5
5.6
Preforms, fabrics and textiles Other processes Market share and growth per technology
International standards North American standards 5.2.1 Standards from ANSI 5.2.2 Standards from the American Petroleum Institute 5.2.3 ASTM standards 5.2.4 Military standards European standards 5.3.1 UK standards 5.3.2 German standards Asia-Pacific standards 5.4.1 Japan 5.4.2 Taiwan 5.4.3 New Zealand Fire-resistance standards 5.5.1 International fire standards 5.5.2 American fire standards 5.5.3 Underwriters Laboratories 5.5.4 European fire standards Health and safety
77 81 82 83 85 87 89
92 99 101 101 101 106 107 108 115 121 121 127 127 127 129 131 132 132 134
Contents
Manufacturing processes Roads and bridges Power supply systems Marine including docks and harbours Offshore applications Chemical process plant including cooling towers Public utilities Mass transport Other applications
137 138 145 150 152 154 160 164 167
169 171 173 175 177 179 181
7. 13 7. 14 7. 15 7. 16
Accordis Group Applied Advanced Technology Co (ApATech Co Ltd) Ashland Chemical Co Inc Bekaert Composites Brunswick Technologies Inc Creative Pultrusions Inc Denali Inc Devonport Management Ltd (DML) Dow Chemical Co DSM Composite Resins Hamon Thermal Europe SA Hardcore Composites Inc Hexcel Corp Maunsell International Ltd Owens Corning LLC PPG Industries Inc
7. 17 7. 18 7. 19 7. 20 7. 21
Psychrometric Systems Inc Strongwell Inc Toray Industries Vestas Wind Systems AS Zoltek Companies Inc
195 196 200 202 205 207 209 212 216 218
8.1
Companies
223
8.2
Associations and organizations
298
6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5 6.6 6.7 6.8 6.9
7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4 7.5 7.6 7.7 7.8 7.9 7. 10 7. 11 7. 12
183 186 190 192
Composites in Infrastructure - Building New Markets
v
List of tables
Table 1 Table 2 Table 3 Table 4 Table 5 Table 6 Table 7 Table 8 Table 9 Table 10 Table 11 Table 12 Table 13 Table 14 Table 15 Table 16 Table 17 Table 18
Table 19 Table 20 Table 21 Table 22 Table 23 Table 24 Table 25 Table 26
vi
Predicted growth for composites in infrastructure, 1999-2005 (000s tonnes) Predicted growth for composites in infrastructure, 1999-2005 (US$ millions) Glass fibre use in building and construction in Europe (%) Thermoset use in composites by geographical sector, 1999-2005 (000s tonnes) Global use of composite constituents, 1999-2005 (000s tonnes) US composite shipments by market sector, 1995-2005 (000s tonnes) Composites as finished products in Europe, 1999 (000s tonnes) Thermoset use by market segment in Europe for 1999 (%) Composite use by market sector in Japan, 1999-2005 (tonnes) GFRP infrastructure applications in Japan (000s tonnes) Thermoset composite markets in Southeast Asia Thermoset-based composite use in Eastern Europe, 1999-2005 (000s tonnes) Polymer consumption in Eastern Europe, 1999 (000s tonnes) Thermoset demand for South America, 1999-2005 (000s tonnes) Composite demand for infrastructure in South America, 1999-2005 (000s tonnes) Thermoset demand for the Middle East, 1999-2005 (000s tonnes) Relative price index for composites and other materials (per kg) Value of composite developments in roads and bridges (US$ millions) Corrosion-resistant market for composites in the USA, 1999-2005 (000s tonnes) Thermoset pipe market by end-user industry (%) Global use of composites in tanks and pipelines, 1999-2005 (000s tonnes) Projected global growth for wind turbine blades by volume and value, 1999-2005 (000s tonnes and US$ millions) Spending on US ports, 1996-2000 Global use of thermoset composites in rail transport, 1999-2005 (000s tonnes) European growth in composite use for rolling stock, 1999-2005 (tonnes) Unsaturated polyester (UP) resin consumption, 1999-2005 (000s tonnes)
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
xi xii XV
9 11 11 14 15 15 15 16 17 33 41 43 44 45 49 52 52 59
List of tables
Table 27 Table 28 Table 29 Table 30 Table 31 Table 32 Table 33 Table 34 Table 35 Table 36 Table 37 Table 38 Table 39 Table 40 Table 41 Table 42 Table 43 Table 44 Table Table Table Table Table
45 46 47 48 49
Table 50
Table 51 Table 52 Table 53 Table 54 Table 55 Table 56 Table 57 Table 58 Table 59 Table 60
Phenolic use in composites in Europe, 1999-2005 (000s tonnes) Mechanical properties of typical reinforcing fibres Glass reinforcement market by application (%) World market for glass reinforcement in thermosets, 1999-2005 (000s tonnes) The glass fibre market in China, 1999-2005 (O00s tonnes) Growth in glass fibre production in India, 1999-2005 (O00s tonnes) Market for carbon fibres, 1999-2005 (000s tonnes) Material deposition rates for composite manufacturing methods European thermoset use in pultrusion (000s tonnes) Global growth for RTM as a percentage of manufacturing, 1999-2005 World production and growth for materials and fabrics (000s tonnes) Fabrication techniques and growth worldwide (%) Estimated fabrication volumes and growth rates for the USA, Europe and Japan in 2000 (000s tonnes) Manufacturing processes for GFRP composites in Germany and Europe in 1999 (% and 000s tonnes) Financial returns for Accordis (~g millions) Financial results for Ashland Inc (US$ millions except share data and return on capital) Financial results for Bekaert Group, 1998 and 1999 (~ 000s) Financial results for Brunswick Technologies Inc, 1995-1999 (US$ millions except per share data) Financial results for Denali, 1995-1999 (000s) Financial results for DML Ltd, 1995-1998 (s Financial figures for Dow and Union Carbide (US$ billions) Financial results for Dow Chemical, 1995-1999 Comparison by business sector on Dow's sales first quarters, 1999-2000 Sales and earnings before interest and taxes (EBIT) for Dow's Performance Plastics business, 1995-1999 (US$ billions) Sales for DSM Performance Materials Division, 1998 and 1999 (~ millions) Net sales for DSM clusters, 1998 and 1999 (~g millions) DSM financial results for 1998 and 1999 (~g millions) Financial results for Hamon Thermal, 1995-1999 (~g millions) Sales by division for Hamon Thermal, 1999 (~ millions) Financial results for Hexcel, 1995-1999 (US$ millions) Financial results for Maunsell, 1997-1998 and 1998-1999
(us$000s)
Financial results for AeCom, 1998-1999 (US$ millions) Financial results for Owens Coming (US$000 millions except income/loss and share price) Financial results for PPG Industries Inc, 1995-1999 (US $millions except share earnings)
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
63 64 65 65 67 67 71 76 80 84 87 89 90 90 171 175 176 179 183 185 187 188 189
189 191 192 192 194 195 199 201 201 203 206
vii
List of tables
Table 61 Table 62 Table 63 Table 64 Table 65 Table 66 Table 67 Table 68
Revenue growth for Global Water Technologies Inc by quarter, 1997-2000 (US$ millions) Financial results for Global Water Technologies Inc by quarters during 1999 and 2000 (US$ millions) Toray sales to outside customers for fiscal year ended 31 March 2000 Consolidated results for Toray for fiscal year ended 31 March 2000 (~ millions and US$) Toray financial results (unconsolidated) fiscal year ended 31 March 1999, 2000 and 2001 (estimated) (~ millions) Sales of wind turbines by Vestas and subsidiaries, 1997-1999 (in MW) Financial results for Vestas, 1995-1999 (DKr millions) Zoltec financial information (fiscal year ended 30th September) (US$000s)
208 209 215 215 216 218 218 222
Executive summary
The use of composites in infrastructure covers four main areas: 9 Q
9 Q
long-standing applications such as pipes and tanks; well-established, but growing, applications such as wind turbine blades and cooling towers; retrofitting and repair of existing civil infrastructure (development stage); and use in new civil infrastructure (research and development stage).
There is some overlap between the areas, such as the innovative work done by the oil industry using carbon fibre reinforcement for specialized pipes and the traditional area of pipes. The overall global composites industry in 2000 is valued at US$8.5 billion in finished product terms, with a production volume of nearly 5 million tonnes. About 15% of that sum could be assigned to infrastructure - in both volume and value - but the new areas such as roads and bridges, which have excited the composites industry, represent only a small fraction of the market. The US composite industry covering the last two, innovative, areas of infrastructure given above was valued at US$20-30 million in 1999 and, although growth is over 1020% per annum, this is coming from a low base. In addition, much of that market is in rehabilitation and repair rather than in new structures. However, when considering both the long-standing and new developments, infrastructure will grow by 2005 to cover some 20% of the composites market. The bulk of that will be split between traditional markets, as pipes, tanks and corrosion-resistant applications, and the existing, but growing, markets of cooling towers and wind turbine blades. The latter now hold nearly equal amounts to the traditional markets and will show the fastest growth. In determining growth for the composites i n d u s t r y - in all applications- it must be emphasized that traditional materials will not allow their market share to be eroded without fighting back. This may be a matter of technical developments or changes in fashion, but it is a fact that cannot be ignored. Legislation and government policies can develop or destroy new markets. As an example, fibre reinforced plastic (FRP) tank sales in the USA showed very large growth during 1998 as EPA legislation on cathodic testing of petroleum tanks led to the widespread replacement of steel tanks. With the end of the replacement period, in December 1998, the market collapsed and the long life of the new composite tanks means that the market will be depressed for some years. The wind turbine industry has received considerable assistance from favourable pricing regimes for renewable energy systems that has encouraged growth. The disadvantage of this is that if such subsidies are removed, as happened in 1986, the d e m a n d may collapse. US federal regulations are now requiring the paper and pulp industry to replace its use of chlorine with chlorine dioxide and hydrogen peroxide by the end of 2000, which is giving increased sales of corrosion-resistant products. The cycle may follow that for tanks once the replacement is completed.
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
ix
Executive summary
The material costs of fibre and resin in composite structures are always greater than their equivalent in steel and concrete. It is, therefore, important to minimize the quantities of fibre and resin that are used. Straightforward material replacement by conventional steel 'look-alike' sections will rarely optimize material content or achieve cost-effectiveness as this implies new design thinking. Changes in thinking are required for the whole industry and its customers. Ibeams, H-beams, channels and angles are considered the proper shapes for structural elements because those are the shapes traditionally produced in steel rolling mills. However, there are other alternatives in composites and it costs no more to produce a complex shape than an I-beam. This approach to design can reduce the final cost by eliminating parts or work, but it requires new thinking from both the composites industry and from their customers. A Catch-22 problem in designing with composites is that a very complex array of properties can be achieved using composite materials. On the one hand, this gives the designer immense freedom to choose different configurations but that very degree of freedom makes it difficult to provide clear design guidance and makes it harder to transfer experience learned on one project to other projects. There is a need for more design guides that provide the kind of information that engineers are accustomed to obtain for traditional materials. The USA has made a useful start in establishing monitoring programmes for new work, but it will obviously take time to derive case studies that can be fed into the design guides. In addition, it is important for design engineers and commissioning authorities to consider total costs rather than the simple up-front capital expenditure. Design, fabrication, erection and maintenance must be viewed as a whole rather than divided between capital expenditure and operational expenditure. If the commissioning body is not responsible for operating expenditure it is unlikely that they will consider low-cost maintenance to be important w h e n compared with the initial high cost of materials. Company size is also a limitation on the composite manufacturing industry. As an example, in the UK the average size of a company is around 33 staff, rising to about double that figure in the USA. Even the larger pultruders in Europe have only 70-80 staff. This limits the availability of companies to release staff for work in marketing, standards, and research and development (R&D). With the small n u m b e r of employees goes under-capitalization. Money is needed for development and new equipment. There is a heavy dependence on the large material manufacturing companies to provide effort. Companies such as DSM, Dow, Toray and PPG spend sums to the value of 4% of sales on R&D. A notable feature of the industry is the variation in company size between the material manufacturers and the component manufacturers. Most materials companies are large multi-nationals often with turnover measured in billions of dollars. There are some early ventures in which materials companies undertake marketing exercises for the smaller, component manufacturing companies. An example would be the link between Exchem and Fibreforce and Pultrex in the UK. There are also early indications of vertical integration as materials manufacturers such as Zoltek buy c o m p o n e n t manufacturers such as SPS Systems. Hexcel, USA has been unusual in operating such an approach, although it is c o m m o n in Japan. Fabrication investment techniques the highest
x
methods are also an indication of small company size, as the capital is not available for closed mould or continuous production such as resin transfer moulding (RTM) and pultrusion. The USA has pultrusion production, partly related to lower energy costs and partly
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
Executive summary
to a longer history. The origins of the composites industry were in aerospace and boat building with limited production numbers in which hand lay-up and sprayup were suitable. However, the process is labour intensive, gives variable quality control, does not allow cost reductions for quantity and has environmental problems with styrene production. Nonetheless, open mould systems will continue to hold the largest share of manufacturing. Even in developed manufacturing areas, such as North America, Japan and Western Europe (all currently around 30-35%), open mould systems will only see a reduction to around an average of 30% by 2005. One example illustrates the problem faced by the composite industry in substituting for conventional materials. The UK uses approximately 750 000 tonnes per a n n u m of steel reinforcing bars and a similar amount of steel section. Replacing even 1-2% of the steel market would require the entire current pultrusion capacity of the UK. The construction industry would want guaranteed supply before committing to widespread use and the composites industry would need high investment to add capacity before they could supply greater quantities. The levels of demand that reinforcement bars (rebars) could generate shows why the composites industry is interested in infrastructure; even a 5% penetration in the UK would require nearly 5000 tonnes per annum of high technology fibre. A key factor in composite acceptance for the new areas of infrastructure is the lack of standards. Although the industry and the standards organizations are making considerable efforts to establish standards, a realistic assessment by one authority indicated that it would be 5 years before there was a full range of formal standards in place. Given the acceptance time that will follow any standardization, this would indicate a 5-10-year period for new structures. Standards are obviously of concern in upgrading work but are not as critical- structures are already built and the concern is that they may fall down without upgrade rather than suffer failure because of the use of innovative materials. The question of public liability in new structures is a severe constraint on the use of new materials or techniques. The global civil engineering and construction market is estimated at US$800 billion and this must be of interest to the composites industry. The cost of infrastructure rehabilitation work in Europe and the USA is well in excess of US$100 billion, with figures as high as US$300 billion being advanced (Tables 1 and 2). Whatever the actual figure, this is a market with considerable potential for composites and offers more immediate returns than composite use in new structures.
Table 1 Predicted growth for composites in infrastructure, 1 9 9 9 - 2 0 0 5 (O00s tonnes) 1999 Roads, bridges
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
10
11
13
14
16
18
20
Corrosion resistant
250
260
270
280
290
300
310
Pipes and tanks
250
255
260
265
273
281
290
Cooling towers
200
206
213
220
227
234
241
Mass transit a
55
6
78
90
103
115
128
Wind turbine blades
40
48
57.5
70
84
101
121
aAbove- and below-ground rail systems.
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets xi
Executive summary Table 2 Predicted growth for composites in infrastructure, 1999-2005 (US$ millions) 1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
Roads and bridges
70
86
107
124
141
168
190
Corrosion resistant
600
618
636
656
675
695
715
Pipes and tanks
600
610
620
630
645
662
678
Cooling towers
600
618
636
656
675
695
715
56
57
58
1452
1597
1757
Mass transit
50
Wind turbine blades 700
51.5 840
53 1008
54.5 1210
Within the period of this report the main growth areas for infrastructure will be cooling towers and wind turbine blades. Wind turbine blades are dependent on favourable pricing regimes in countries such as the USA, Denmark, Germany and Spain, but these will probably continue given the drive for 'green energy' in the face of concerns about global climate change. There is potential in underdeveloped countries as distributed power sources, but these require investment decisions by national energy companies to move from large-scale power systems. The demand for energy is set to continue and this gives both FRP cooling towers and wind turbine blades, which cover both energy production and efficient production, considerable potential for growth. Corrosion-resistant applications will continue to show modest growth, partly dependent on investment in the petrochemical industry in all geographic areas and the introduction of further environmental legislation. The mass transport industry has seen renewed investment in recent years, but this is easing and growth will slow in the next couple of years. Pipes and tanks will remain largely static until 2002-2003 w h e n there could be more investment by public utilities and the petrochemical industry. The new area of roads and bridges, which has excited the industry, should be approached with caution. There is potential in the market but this will be in repair and rehabilitation rather than in new work for the period of this report. Even in the repair business where growth will be at least 10% per annum, this is coming from a very low base and still relies on p u m p priming by national authorities. When considering growth rates for the sector, it should be remembered that customer willingness to pay is limited. A Californian survey found that 98% of residents thought that infrastructure was important but would not pay 1% more in taxes for upgrades; only a major event such as an earthquake changed those opinions.
xii
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
Methodology
A major concern has been to establish which areas are covered by the term 'infrastructure', balancing the need to avoid covering too general an area whilst still covering those sectors which the industry w o u l d recognize as valid. A further concern was h o w to determine the composite market and its potential growth within infrastructure given the lack of formal statistics. Finally, it was necessary to decide which materials would be considered as 'composites' for these applications. The decision was made to include those structural elements that provide support to m o d e m technological life. This included the provision of such services as water treatment, p o w e r supplies and transport. The chemical/petrochemical industry was included as it has revolutionized life in the last century and is the basis for the manufacture of composites. The aerospace and automotive markets were not included as they have been the subject of several other reports. The electronics and c o n s u m e r goods markets were not included, as they do not feature as structural areas. There is a lack of formal statistics in this area; indeed, in the whole area of composites authoritative figures are often not collected or available. Even national statistical collection is deficient as the European Reinforced Plastics Group (GPRMC) has attempted to persuade EUROSTAT to establish a suitable heading for composites in its statistical series, but without success. It is important to note that figures in this report are estimates as there is no heading for 'infrastructure' in industry or national statistical collections. Problems in statistical definition can be seen in figures for composite use within the construction industry, which might be considered to include infrastructure. The construction industry is the largest single end-use industry for plastics, but most of these applications are not reinforced composites and even w h e n these are used it is in such areas as building panels, b a t h r o o m fittings and w i n d o w profiles with cladding, doors, sills and shutters taking a large part of the remainder. The Japanese are notable for the excellence of their statistical collection over many years through the Japan Reinforced Plastics Society (JRPS). However, the figures that JRPS collect u n d e r 'Building and construction' are largely related to domestic and office building. The building and construction heading presents problems t h r o u g h o u t the world. Some well-established markets such as pipes, tanks and silos can provide reasonable market figures. Many statistical series for composites provide a heading for 'corrosion-resistant' applications and a high percentage of this is considered to be part of infrastructure as defined for this report. Even in these areas there is no clear indication of the division between thermoplastics and thermosets, and estimates have been made for this report. Such organizations as the Market Development Alliance of the FRP Composites Industry are n o w beginning to attempt the collection of statistics for this area but are finding considerable difficulties in achieving reliable figures.
Composites in Infrastructure - Building New Markets
xiii
Methodology The raw material manufacturers are the best source of statistics but are not always certain of the end-use of their materials. Owens Coming estimates that construction consumes about 43% of composites, but this is mostly in the general building area and not infrastructure composites, consumption for transport is 20% but this is mostly in the automotive industry with only a very small amount for mass transit systems such as trains. As the topic of infrastructure is new even the materials manufacturers have no clear statistical information in many areas. The situation in the North America, which had well-established figures under the Composites Institute, has deteriorated. The Market Development Alliance of the FRP Composites Industry (MDA) will collect statistics in the future but these will not necessarily be in the same format as the previous series. MDA feels that merely to quote tonnages is not p r o d u c t i v e - a valid point. The Composites Fabricators Association will be collecting statistics but has so far only issued figures under the old Composites Institute general headings. The Society of Advanced Composite Manufacturers (SACMA) ceased to exist from 1 June 2000 and, consequently, their statistical series covering 80% of the US market for carbon fibre production is no longer available. The situation in Europe is saved by the work of AVK, Germany in producing valid statistics over the years. Some of the professional associations in other geographic areas do attempt statistical collection but this is varied in its results. The major source of statistical information has, therefore, been the industry itself, covering the companies manufacturing basic materials through to the c o m p o n e n t manufacturers and to end-user industries. The raw materials companies, being larger and having more resources, are a helpful source of information. DSM and Reichhold (for unsaturated polyesters), Owens Coming and Vetrotex (for glass fibre), and Zoltek and Toray (for carbon fibre) have all proved most helpful. The main method of information gathering has been by interviews with these companies and organizations. Normally statistics would have also been acquired from formal sources and cross-checked against industry estimates. As this has not been possible the statistical information should be treated with some caution, although every effort has been made to balance figures from a range of sources to achieve a reasonable degree of validity. One problem that the industry faces is the lack of openness in supplying market information. Obviously some figures must be considered confidential and it is understandable why companies should consider that information obtained at considerable cost should not be supplied free. However, information supplied to associations can be gathered together and then made available to the industry in an anonymous form. This was previously done, with some success, in such areas as North America, which as the largest market and a driving force, provided indications for other areas. It would be helpful if companies could supply information on this basis to EPTA and MDA. Although such information is by its nature always out-of-date, its retrospective assessment gives indications of trends that would prove useful to member companies. The following method has been used in assessing the percentage of infrastructure to be derived from the overall composite market. According to the Association of European Glass Fibre Producers (APFE) the market breakdown for glass fibre use in the building and construction markets in Europe is as shown in Table 3.
xiv
Compositesin Infrastructure- Building New Markets
Methodology Table 3 Glass fibre use in building and construction in Europe (%) Electricity
23
Roofing
20
Industrial infrastructure
19
Bathroom fittings
11
Flooring
8
Facades
6
Decoration
4
Others
9
Discussion with the industry indicates that 5-10% of industrial infrastructure is contained within our definition of infrastructure applications - covering corrosion resistance, pipes and tanks. As building and construction generally comprises some 30% of the composite market we have a figure that gives about 3% of the total. Most production assigned to corrosion resistance can be covered in infrastructure as it includes chemical production, water, sewerage and oil/ petroleum distribution. The figure of less than 1% has been taken for composites in the new infrastructure markets of roads, bridges and structural rehabilitation. Overall, the whole infrastructure market (as defined) takes about 15% of the thermoset composite market, even w h e n firmly established markets are included. Building and construction, automotive, electronics and consumer goods all have much larger market shares. The decision on materials was made to cover thermoset matrices based on unsaturated polyester (by far the largest market), vinyl ester, phenolics and epoxy resins. The reinforcements were taken to be glass (the largest market), carbon and aramid fibres. It would not have been possible to cover all materials and the largest market is glass reinforced unsaturated thermoset polyester both now and for the foreseeable future. The information in the report was gathered by telephone and personal interviews with many companies. The time and courtesy that they have afforded is much appreciated and such areas as the corporate profiles and case studies would have been impossible without their assistance. The trade associations have also given me considerable assistance and I would particularly like to thank Jaap Ketel and his staff at European Pultrusion Technology Association (EPTA), John Busel at Market Development Alliance of the Composite Fabricators Association (MDA) and Ursula Zarbock at Arbeitsgemeinschaft Verstarkte Kunstoffe Technische Vereinigung EV (AVK-TV), Germany. These three, in particular, have wrestled with the provision of information and statistics to the composites industry for many years and they were generous in their assistance. Some technical information has obviously been included in Chapters 3 and 4, and this has been obtained from a range of technical publications and from company literature. The aim has been to provide sufficient technical detail to give understanding whilst also keeping a level that is acceptable in a market study. This report does not aim to replace the wide range of books and journals that provide the industry with its technical and manufacturing data.
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets xv
Methodology The standards information in Chapter 5 has been obtained partly from the publications of the standards organizations and partly from discussions with those working on standards committees. The Library of the British Standards Institution was helpful and efficient. This area is still subject to change both in the development of actual standards and in the movement within Europe for the harmonization of standards. The case studies in Chapter 6 have been obtained from the participating organizations and their assistance is gratefully acknowledged. The frankness with which they have covered many details can only assist an industry that is still in a learning phase in many areas. The aim in this section has been to cover as wide a range of markets as possible and to discuss the reasoning behind the projects, problems that occurred with their solution and some indication of the success/ failure of the projects. Where possible, costs or project budgets have been included as it was felt that this was of particular interest to the industry. The companies that have been considered for corporate profiles in Chapter 7 have been chosen as illustrating important aspects of the market both technically and geographically. The profiles were developed from interviews with the companies, supplemented with independent assessment; the aim has not been to present a publicity exercise on behalf of the companies or to make inappropriate criticism. This report is not a financial analysis although, naturally, there has been discussion of company results. Chapter 8 is a directory of companies mentioned in this report with others that illustrate particular areas of the industry. This section does not aim to replace such publications as the Reinforced Plastics Buyers' Guide. The section ends with entries for national and supranational bodies. Many people reading this report will have considerable knowledge of the industry and its manufacturing techniques. The Glossary in Chapter 9 is an introduction for those without this depth of knowledge.
xvi
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
Introduction - market developments
The purpose of a composite is to optimize the properties of materials by the process of combination. It is a c o m m o n principle that two, or more, components may be combined to form a composite material to make the best use of their more favourable properties whilst, hopefully, mitigating some of their less desirable features. Composites, therefore, are a combination of several varieties of materials and exhibit the features of each material, as well as providing special characteristics that no single material can achieve. For the purposes of this report 'infrastructure' is defined as those large-scale civil engineering works that provide services or support for a wide range of people. The definition includes roads, bridges, shore construction, tunnels, docks, harbours, piers, offshore construction, power systems, sewage and water systems, and mass transportation such as railways. It does not include buildings in the conventional sense (composites used for building panels and bathrooms are not included), electronics, marine, consumer goods and appliances, the automotive industry or aerospace. Conventional reinforced concrete is widely used in the infrastructure industries largely because of its easy availability, the low cost of steel and concrete, the design base and experience in use. The deterioration of many structures built 4050 years ago is due to the susceptibility of the steel reinforcement to corrosion, and this is now both a major engineering and a major economic problem. There have been technological developments in structural engineering that require increased design loads and the growth d e m a n d for infrastructure resulting from improved standards of living. The estimated costs of repairing road and bridge decks in the US vary considerably but, if the estimate of 132000 bridges as deficient is correct, the figure will certainly run into billions of dollars. The last decade has seen considerable progress in fibre reinforced plastic (FRP) as reinforcement for concrete, including the replacement of conventional steel reinforcement bars (rebars) with FRP rebars or dowel bars. These have usually been a unidirectional glass fibre-polymer resin composition. However, this application is still in the development stages and, whilst promising, are some years from large-scale use. FRP is also used in those sectors that have aggressive environments - pulp, paper, chemicals, oil and operations taking place offshore, oil and gas wells, harbours and docks. Steel, concrete and timber are the traditional materials in these sectors, often used in a coated or treated form. Even in generally non-aggressive environments such as water supplies, FRP still has a share of the market. In addition to the technical developments, there have been changes in legislation
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
1
1
Introduction - market developments
that have had an impact of market sectors requirements for corrosion resistance and pricing of energy production. The power-generation industries show considerable growth potential in two main areas for composites - wind turbine blades and cooling towers. As the d e m a n d for energy continues to grow environmentally friendly power-generation systems will be critical if the effects of global climate change are not to be increased. Consequently, both 'green' power-generation systems and efficiencies in operation of conventional power systems will be required. The market for fibre-based composites is dominated by glass fibre reinforced plastics (GFRP), which represent approximately 90% of the total market, with the remainder of the reinforcement being carbon, aramid and a small amount of other materials. This applies in the developed markets such as North America, Europe and Japan, and to an even greater extent in less advanced markets. In the period to 2005 this figure will remain largely constant with a small increase in carbon fibre reinforcement if the price of carbon fibre is significantly reduced. On production, environmental concerns mean that there is a trend towards closed mould systems, such as resin transfer moulding (RTM) where styrene emission is greatly reduced. The move to closed mould systems is slow and open mould systems will remain the single largest production method for the period of this report. The current figure of some 35% in Europe will decrease to around 30% by 2005. In the developing countries, which have a higher percentage of open mould, there is a current estimate of 72% for China decreasing by 7% to 2001-2002 and by 10% to 2005. The average price for fibre reinforced composites is falling, mainly as a result of decreases in the price for glass fibre and, to a much lesser degree, carbon fibre and aramid fibre. Another factor that is putting downward pressure on prices is competition from the Far East and Southeast Asia.
Despite fears that North America cannot continue its growth of the last few years, there are no indications of an economic downturn and slow but steady growth in thermoset use is predicted. There is a considerable difference in the estimated global growth rates for thermoplastics and thermosets to 2005 with thermosets making gross domestic product (GDP) figures of 2-3% and many thermoplastics growing at over 7% (Table 4). Thermoset resin d e m a n d in 1999-2000 is some 1 million tonnes, which is a little more than the d e m a n d for glass fibre. In both cases only a percentage of the market is for glass reinforced thermoset composites. Growth in Europe has been somewhat disappointing with falls in the important German market and problems with the high value of the p o u n d sterling affecting the UK market. However, exports have shown good growth and this should continue as the Asian market continues to recover. The Japanese economy has been slow to show signs of recovery and even 1% growth in the early years of this report may be optimistic. There should be some improvement from 2003 onwards, but the steel industry will maintain its grip on the automotive market that has provided much of the growth for composites in North America and Europe. Several Japanese steel companies who had invested
2
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
1
Introduction - market developments
heavily in glass mat thermoplastics (GMT) technology as an alternative to steel pressings have left the market. The Asian crisis resulted in surplus capacity, but this surplus will disappear as the economy recovers and C h i n a - the largest of all markets - shows continued growth. India, the second largest Asian market, has a varied economic history but enormous potential with a large middle class and good educational standards, Many large companies which supply the composites industry have established production units in India to service the Asian market, but there are difficulties in both establishment and operation. Reinforced thermoplastics will expand taking market share from thermosets owing to their ease of processing and recycling ability (Table 5). Owens Coming claims the largest single share (25%) of the global market for glass fibre as reinforcement for composites, with some 650 000 tonnes per annum of the total 3.4 million tonnes. Of this, about 8% is for glass fibre furnace rebuilding. One geographical split gives 44% of the market to North America, 27% to Europe,
Table 4 Thermoset use in composites by geographical sector 1 9 9 9 - 2 0 0 5 (O00s tonnes)
North America
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
750
765
780
795
810
825
840
Western Europe
650
660
670
680
690
700
715
Japan
305
308
311
316
321
325
330
Southeast Asia
320
335
350
370
392
415
440
South America
150
153
156
159
163
167
171
Middle East
131
134
137
140
144
148
153
Eastern Europea
174
179
184
189
195
201
207
Others
<50
<50
<50
<50
51
52
53
2003
2004
2005
alncludes Russia.
Table 5 Global use of composite constituents 1 9 9 9 - 2 0 0 5 (O00s tonnes) 1999 UP resins Vinyl ester Phenolic Epoxy Glass f i b r e a Carbon fibre b Aramid fibre
1700
2000 1780
2001 1810
2002 1840
1875
1915
1950
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
140
140
140
138
138
136
136
15
15
15
15
16
16
16
1955
1995
2035
2075
2115
2160
2200
15
15
15
< 10
< 10
< 10
15.5 < 10
15.5 < 10
16
16
< 10
< 10
aGlass fibre products used in reinforcing thermosets. bThis assumes that there is no dramatic reduction in price. If a major price reduction occurred the percentage increase would be about 5% per annum.
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
3
1
Introduction - market developments
24% to Southeast Asia, 4% to Latin America and a similar sum to Eastern Europe, with 2% to the Middle East and other areas. Another geographical split gives 46% to North America, 3% to South America and other areas, and the same amounts to Western Europe and Southeast Asia. The glass fibre content in most composites is around 55%, with the remaining 45% for resins; the extra price for resins is reflected in the split between the US$8 billion value into US$4 billion each for the glass and resin markets.
1.2.1 North America Production of plastics in North America is 43 million tonnes, with sales and captive use at around 45 million tonnes. However, consumption is dominated by the major thermoplastics such as low-density polyethylene (LDPE), high-density polyethylene (HDPE) and polyvinyl chloride (PVC). Only 9.5-10% of production is for thermosets, giving a figure of 4-4.5 million tonnes, with some 1.2 million tonnes being used in reinforced form. Unsaturated polyester (UP) is the major material but much of this is not used in a reinforced form for composites. The Composites Institute of the Society of Plastics Industries, in its last report before being disbanded, reported that composite shipments in the USA in 1999 would be 1.7 million tonnes including both thermoset and thermoplastics (Table 6). As thermosets are preferred for composite production it has been estimated that production of thermoset composites is 1.1-1.2 million tonnes. Some 65% of all thermoset composites use glass fibre reinforcements in a polyester or vinyl ester resin, with the final components being manufactured using the o p e n mould method. The remaining 35% are produced using a variety of high-volume manufacturing methods or use such advanced materials as carbon or aramid fibres, vinyl ester, phenolic or epoxy resins. Reinforced thermoset d e m a n d (resins, reinforcement, fillers, etc.) in the USA is forecast to increase by 2-3% per annum to nearly 1.4 million tonnes, valued at US$5.8 billion, by 2005. Growth sectors include corrosion-resistant applications (including pipelines), cooling towers and wind turbines, which are all based on an increase based on tighter environmental constraints and the need for greater efficiencies in power generation. Highway, bridge and earthquake protection applications will show higher growth but coming from a low base. One large sector is transport, but most of this is material used in the automotive industry with only small amounts of thermosets being used in rail transport. The use of phenolics in mass transit systems is not as widespread as in Europe where this market has been driven by tighter safety legislation. Materials favoured in North America include Modar and fire-retardant UP which are considered to meet safety requirements and are cheaper. The construction industry is another large sector but most of this material is used in standard building products and bathroom fittings; very small amounts are used in rehabilitation of existing roads, bridges and buildings either for repair or for earthquake strengthening. This sector has potential but is not yet a major user of composites. In addition, whilst the rehabilitation market has potential, the market
4
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
1
Introduction - market developments
Table 6 US composite shipments by market sector 1 9 9 5 - 2 0 0 5 (O00s tonnes) a Market sector
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
Aerospace/defence
10.5
11.0
11.2
11.4
11.7
12.0
12.5
Appliance/business equipment
93.0
95.5
97.5
99.6
101.9
104.0
106.5
Construction
345.5
352.0
359.3
366.4
373.7
381.0
389.0
Consumer goods
110.5
115.0
119.4
124.0
129.0
134.0
139.0
Corrosion
190.0
201.0
211.0
219.4
228.0
237.0
245.0
Electrical/electronic 170.5
177.0
184.3
191.6
198.5
206.0
213.0
Marine
182.0
192.0
199.0
205.0
213.0
218.0
224.5
Transport
548.5
576.5
605.0
635.3
667.0
700.0
735.0
Other Total
55.5
57.0
58.5
60.0
61.5
1706.0
1777.0
1845.2
1912.7
1984.3
63.0 2055
64.5 2129
aThis covers thermosets, thermoplastics, reinforcements and fillers. Thermoset-based composites cover some 1.1-1.2 million tonnes.
for new projects is still driven by initial costs rather than long-term maintenance cost. Some 140 000 tonnes of thermoset composite is used in such corrosion-resistant applications as chemical plants, pulp and paper plant, and cooling towers. About 50 000 tonnes of that figure is used for cooling towers. Within this sector the tank business has stagnated, although there is some growth i n g r a t i n g s - about 3%. There is similar growth in sewerage pipes, although many of these are reinforced thermoplastics such as PVC. The USA has one of the world's major wind turbine companies - part of Enron - and this market is still strong as a result of a favourable pricing regime. In the USA the building and construction sector takes some 32% of GFRP use, but most of this is used in conventional building products rather than infi'astructure applications. There is considerable 'pump priming' by the US state and national governments on the use of innovative materials for infrastructure including plastics, although these are not exclusively composites. The US government has made considerable efforts through the Federal Highway Administration, the departments of transportation of individual states, the US Navy and the US Army to fund research programmes that will encourage the use of new techniques in repair and construction of roads, bridges and buildings. Published reports by the US Department of Transportation have indicated that approximately US$35 billion per a n n u m is spent in the USA to maintain the highway and bridge infrastructure. Conservative estimates indicate that approximately US$53 billion is necessary to maintain the highway and bridge infrastructure in its current condition. An estimated 107 683 (18%) of the nation's 576460 bridges are classified as structurally deficient. The primary concerns are seismic safety of roads, bridges and buildings, and corrosive decay of roads and bridges.
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
5
1
Introduction - market developments
While seismic risk is typically associated with California, it is of concern throughout a considerable area of the USA. In 1990 the American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials adopted seismic design guides specifications for the entire USA, recognizing the vulnerability of the nation's bridge infrastructure to potential seismic activity along the West Coast, the Midwest (New Madrid fault) and the northeastern USA. The seismic risk to bridge structures differs from region to region owing to different probable earthquake magnitudes and recurrence periods, as well as geological conditions. The unpredictable nature of seismic events and the vulnerability of the majority of existing bridges necessitates the development and implementation of innovative, fast, effective and economical retrofitting technologies to ensure the safe and continued use of the nation's bridge infrastructure. Corrosion in roads and bridges is more typically a problem in the northeastern USA and Canada, where harsh winters require the use of salt for de-icing. The area concerned is much larger and the number of structures is much greater than for other regions. The Federal Highway Administration implemented the Innovative Bridge Research and Construction 0BRC) programme under funding from the US Congress for the Transportation Equity Act for the 21st Century (TEA-21) unveiled in July 1998. US state departments of transportation propose demonstrations of new materials and systems through the IBRC programme for funding through partnerships between FHWA, the departments of transportation, industry and academia. Composite structures and materials have been a major area of focus. Total funding of US$102 million has been allocated for the six years 1997-2002, although this could be as high as US$200 billion with matching funding from the states. Road and railway maintenance and enhancement are priorities with safety measures and environmental improvements. Projects must demonstrate improved technologies such as disaster-resistant design, lowered construction downtime, cost savings, powered maintenance, improved capacity, greater durability or increased service life, with an aim for the latter of 75-100 years. Materials can include GFRP, carbon fibre reinforced plastic (CFRP), high-strength steel or high-performance concrete. The TEA-21 programme already has a backlog of work and spending has been raised from 11% of the total fund in the first year to 19% in the last. There is criticism from Europe that the US approach is to put money into action rather than analysis, but the process establishes a body of experience on which manufacturers and customers can build. Non-US companies find it difficult to break into the US market partly because it is necessary to register engineers not in just one state but in all states in which they hope to work. In addition, many states prefer to give business that has state funding to state-based industries. Maunsell, the British consulting engineers, has joined with the US engineering group AeCOM to make a global company with some 11000 employees, which rivals Bechtel and Parsons Brinckerhoff. In January 2000 W S Atldns, another major UK company, bought the Benham Consultancy, Oklahoma for US$88 million. Both companies hope that these ventures will give them improved access to the US market.
6 Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
1
Introduction - market developments
1.2.2 Western Europe The large thermoplastic use in Germany results from the automotive industry (see Table 7). Even the USA cannot be considered as a single m a r k e t - earthquake zones, oil production areas and harsh winters all give differing approaches in what is a single legal entity. Consequently, Europe with different climates, legal systems and industrial bases will show considerable variations in production and consumption. Denmark, with a strong environmental record, has an excellent reputation for its work with wind turbine blades helped by the number of wind turbine companies. Norway has a major offshore oil industrial base in the difficult environment of the North Sea. Italy has a solid market in pultrusion products used in power and telecommunication poles; its position in the repair of ancient buildings, although notable, is not relevant to this report. France has some small-scale use of GFRP and aramid fibre reinforced plastic (AFRP) in infrastructure including pipelines, but most French composite development is found in the aerospace and sports areas. Germany has major thermoplastic use in the automotive industry, considerable composite use in the chemical industry but minimal applications in the roads/bridges infrastructure applications. Switzerland has undertaken several interesting projects including Glulam buildings (composites using w o o d and carbon fibre) and carbon fibre reinforced bridge structures. The UK has a modest programme of repair and rehabilitation of smaller bridges and some wrapping of major road bridges using aramids in epoxy resin for improved impact resistance. The Department of Transport had 80 applications for composite use in repair during 1998 and 6 km of carbon and glass reinforced pultruded plate was used. Some examples, such as the Aberfeldy footbridge, have been in place for a decade giving a reasonable test history. The London Underground has a considerable repair and development programme, and the fires at Kings Cross Underground station and following the Paddington rail crash has lead to tighter safety requirements which have, in turn, lead to increased use of phenolics. Germany represents the largest market for fibre reinforced composites in Europe followed, in order, by Italy, France and the UK, and there will be little change in this situation in the next few years. Overall, the volume of the European market for reinforced composites was nearly 910 000 tonnes, valued at US$4.3 billion, in 1999 and an annual growth rate of 2.4% will be seen reaching US$4.93 billion in 2005. The combination of both established and new aspects of infrastructure will have grown from 15% of the market in 1999, with a value of US$860 million, to occupy about 20% of the market in 2005, with a value of some US$986 million. The figure of 15% for infrastructure is derived from market statistics that indicate the divisions for the European use of thermosets to be as shown in Table 8. About 5% of the category 'Others' could be considered to include cooling towers, pipes, tanks and similar end uses, with a further 5% from the 'Building industry' for other infrastructure applications. A total of 1.68 million tonnes of purified terephthalic acid, a basic material for the composites industry, was produced in Europe in 1998 of which 75% was used in polyester fibre, indicating the minority position of composites in the chemical industry. The German market for GFRP was 218000 tonnes in 1999 with most of the growth coming from the automotive market which is not covered in this report.
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
7
1
Introduction - market developments
Table 7 Composites as finished products in Europe 1999 (O00s tonnes) Country
Total
Thermoset
Germany
387
193
194
Italy
238
168
70
France
185
148
37
Benelux
173
113
60
United Kingdom
143
98
45
Spain/Portugal
100
70
30
Thermoplastic
Scandinavia
72
52
20
Others
95
65
30
1393
907
486
Total
Table 8 Thermoset use by market segment in Europe for 1999 (%) Market segment
% share
Household/sanitary
41
Building industry
21
Electronics
21
Cars/machinery
10
Others
7
The market for pipes and tanks showed virtually no growth as the construction of large chemical and power plants stagnated. France has a large market by value for composites - about 23% of the European total - but much of this is largely attributable to demand from the Airbus consortium, Aerospatiale, and from the automotive and sports goods industries. The UK market for phenolic resins was 73 000 tonnes, and some 10 000 tonnes is used in advanced composites mostly for large panels used in exterior building surfaces and the interiors of trains and aircraft. Less than 1000 tonnes will be for the infrastructure market, mostly resulting from the greater investment in the rail industry and the higher fire safety requirements. Over the next five years there will be a small increase, probably rising to 1250 tonnes by 2005. In the UK, apart from coatings, epoxy resins have their greatest use in printed circuit boards, although there is some use in infrastructure in the rail industry and wind turbines; this latter application has not shown the hoped-for developments which would go with the UK's excellent wind regime. However, there is a healthy export business for wind turbine components and a growing interest in offshore wind farms. A large wind farm is to be built on the Northumbrian coast. Of the 32 000 tonnes of epoxies consumed in the UK market, about 1000 tonnes is used in infrastructure and growth will not exceed 2% per annum.
8
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
1
Introduction - market developments
In the Nordic countries it is estimated that the building and construction market will use some 1800 tonnes of pultruded profile in 2000 (53% of the total) but, as with other areas, only about 10-15% of that will apply to infrastructure. Corrosion-resistant applications should take a further 250 tonnes, which is 9% of the total. In the central areas of northern Europe (Belgium, Germany, UK and The Netherlands) some 2000 tonnes of pultruded profiles (30% of the total) will be produced for the building and construction industry, but only about 12% will be used in infrastructure. Corrosion-resistant applications will take about 1100 tonnes, which is 16% of the total pultrusion product. In the areas of France, Italy and Spain about 4000 tonnes (36%) of pultruded profiles will be used in building and construction, with around 15% of that allocated to infrastructure. The Italian pultruded profile market and the large market for wind turbines in Spain raises the percentage. Corrosion-resistant applications will take about 1200 tonnes, which is some 10% of the total. The large multi-national oil companies have established pipelines and offshore work for the North Sea oil and gas fields. These have required the use of phenolics and fibre reinforced epoxies including carbon fibre reinforced epoxy pipelines.
1.2.3 Japan Japan has traditionally been the driving force in the Asian economy, with such countries as Taiwan, South Korea, Thailand and Indonesia providing manufacturing and export potential. The severe economic downturn in the area has hit both Japan and the supply areas but for different reasons. Japan has been affected by the crisis in banking based on a traditional consensus approach to doing business. The signs from Japan are contradictory and could have serious implications for the infrastructure industry. Japan has a one of the largest gross public debts, at nearly 150% of national output. This approach to deficit spending has been associated with a swollen construction industry whose 570000 member firms employ some 10% of the Japanese workforce. A normal figure amongst developed countries is 6-7%. If Japan cuts public spending this could result in a fall in the number of infrastructure projects that would support the composites industry (Table 9). Table 9 Composite use by market sector in Japan 1 9 9 9 - 2 0 0 5 (000 tonnes) 1999 Construction Bath units
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
50.0
50.0
50.0
51.0
52.0
52.0
53.0
108.0
108.0
108.0
109.0
109.0
110.0
110.0
Sewerage systems
74.0
74.0
75.0
75.0
76.0
77.0
78.0
Marine
20.0
20.0
20.0
21.0
22.0
22.0
22.0
Transport
23.4
23.5
23.5
24.0
25.0
26.0
27.0
Tanks/vessels
37.6
38.0
38.0
39.0
40.0
40.0
41.0
Industrial equipment
51.0
51.0
52.0
53.0
53.0
54.0
55.0
Consumer products
41.0
41.0
42.0
42.0
43.0
43.0
44.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
9.5
9.5
10.0
10.0
414.0
414.5
417.5
423.5
429.5
434.0
440.0
Others Total
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
9
1
Introduction - market developments
Japan is the largest market for FRP shipments in Asia with an annual market of 414 000 tonnes. Recent years have seen negative growth owing to the continuing uncertainty in the Japanese market and the move by industry to low-cost manufacturing countries; there was a collapse of all sectors in 1998. Although it had been h o p e d that 1999 would see some improvement due to g o v e r n m e n t measures to induce c o n s u m e r purchases, this has not h a p p e n e d and the overall market has remained essentially stagnant. The new government is still committed to extensive public spending and this has led, in the past, to some projects that have been criticized as wasteful but which supported areas of Japanese industry. There is hope of improvement in the coming years but high e m p l o y m e n t overheads, the costs of bank restructuring and c o n s u m e r uncertainty remain, and it is unlikely that figures for 2005 will have even returned to the level of 1997. The strong position of the steel industry in Japan has lead to a preference for steel over composites in such markets as automotive, which have shown considerable growth and provided a driving force for composites in Europe and the USA. In other geographic areas the automotive industry is a major c o n s u m e r of composites p r o d u c e d by sheet and bulk moulding c o m p o u n d (SMC and BMC, respectively), but the Japanese automotive industry is still heavily oriented towards metals. In addition, Japan has installed very few composite cooling towers or wind turbines that would have produced greater growth. Infrastructure use in such areas as highways and bridges has been largely for carbon and aramid fibre reinforcement as these are local industries. It is estimated that Japan has about 100 demonstration projects in infrastructure repair and rehabilitation. Almost all reinforced thermosets in Japan are based on unsaturated polyester and the largest single market is for bath units - a position that is unique to Japan. Some innovative infrastructure applications have come from the Japanese carbon fibre industry including road, bridge and tunnel rehabilitation, and corrosionresistant repairs in chemical plants, but these are only a tiny fraction of the market. Such applications also use such materials as epoxies, phenolics and vinyl esters, but the amounts are very small. GFRP applications for infrastructure, which saw a decline in 1999, included tanks and vessels, and sewerage treatment. Although construction saw a small increase - from 11.5 to 12% - most of this market is for conventional building projects (Table 10). Concerns have been raised about the state of concrete used in the tunnel systems for the Shinkansen trains in Japan. Since June 1999 there have been at least 20 cases of concrete falling from tunnel walls onto the tracks. In one instance chunks caused the derailment of a freight train and in another incident falling pieces hit a car beneath an overpass. While inspecting tunnels in December 1999 the private railway company that operates the Shinkansen trains in western Japan found about 40 000 weak sections. Japan has a very large overall construction budget - 15% of GDP compared with 8% for the U S A - but it is estimated that less than 10% is spent on maintenance. The two contributory reasons are historical and political. Japan has traditionally constructed w o o d e n buildings that fell down in earthquakes or were burnt d o w n to be replaced not maintained. In political terms, Japan has a very large and powerful construction industry that finds new building more profitable than maintenance and repair.
10
Composites in Infrastructure - Building New Markets
1
Introduction - market developments
Table 10 GFRP infrastructure applications in Japan (O00s tonnes) 1999 Construction a Sewerage Transportb Tanks/vessels
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
4.0
4.0
4.1
4.1
4.2
4.2
4.3
30.0
30.0
30.0
31.0
31.0
31.0
32.0
8.0
8.0
8.1
8.1
8.1
8.2
8.2
37.5
37.0
37.5
37.5
38.0
38.0
38.5
Other
4.0
4.0
4.2
4.2
4.3
4.3
4.3
Total
83.5
83.0
83.9
83.9
84.6
85.7
87.3
aRepair/rehabilitation and earthquake strengthening. bMass transit.
1.2.4 Southeast Asia Asia has some 24% of the world composites market, with about 30% of that used in building and construction (Table 11). However, most of this o u t p u t is related to standard building materials with a strong emphasis on the b a t h r o o m fittings that are also a major item in Japan. One area of infrastructure use is the chemical plants which have b e e n installed in the area with composite materials used for their corrosion resistance. However, the overenthusiastic building p r o g r a m m e u n d e r t a k e n earlier in the 1990s means that there will be little significant growth in this sector until the excess of c o n s u m p t i o n is absorbed. O u t p u t capacity of synthetic resins was 9 million tonnes in 1998, having grown from 5 million tonnes in 1993. About 50% of the o u t p u t is used in plastic pipes, most of which are not reinforced. There is some potential in the more developed areas of the r e g i o n - South Korea, Singapore and Malaysia - for work to increase the axial load capacity of bridges. Those same areas also have an interest in public utility d e v e l o p m e n t such as the tank cover in Singapore, covered in the case studies in Chapter 6. High p o p u l a t i o n growth means that if land can be released by such developments there is an economic basis for composite use.
Table 11 Thermoset composite markets in Southeast Asia 1 9 9 9 - 2 0 0 5 (000 tonnes)
China
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
350.0
370.0
395.0
420.0
445.0
475.0
505.0
India
40.0
42.0
44.0
46.0
48.0
50.0
53.0
Indonesia
25.0
26.0
27.0
28.0
29.0
30.0
31.0
Malaysia
20.0
21.0
22.0
23.0
24.5
26.0
27.5
South Korea
60.0
63.0
66.0
69.0
72.5
76.0
80.0
Taiwan Total
80.0
85.0
89.5
94.0
99.5
104.5
110.0
575.0
607.0
643.5
680.0
718.5
761.5
806.5
Composites in Infrastructure - Building New Markets
11
1
Introduction - market developments
China China has an annum capacity of some 350000 tonnes of thermosets, mostly unsaturated polyesters (UP), of which about 170 000 tonnes are produced locally by 200 companies and the remainder imported; 80% of the UP resins are reinforced with glass fibre. Less than 50 companies are of a significant size, with only about 10 companies capable of production of over 10 000 tonnes per annum; this also applies to the 100 glass fibre manufacturers. In both cases, only a small number of companies are significant producers of high-quality material. Many of the 3000 moulders are small, low-technology operations, and this low-level technology approach is a problem for Chinese production and manufacturing. About 30% of FRP is used in chemical pipe and tank industry. There is considerable growth potential for SMC water tanks constructed from hot-press moulded c o m p o u n d panels that are found in other geographical areas. A 100 000 tonnes per a n n u m polyester plant began construction in December 1999 at Yizheng Chemical Fibre Corp, but much of the output will be for polyester fibres. About 30% of FRP consumption is construction related, with most of that in standard building products. The automotive industry takes about 8-10% of FRP production, and tanks and pipelines have some 22%. The major infrastructure markets for composites are cooling towers, pipes and tanks, and pultruded components, although much of the latter is for recreational and consumer products such as fishing rods, tent poles and window frames. The increasing power demands of consumers and industrialization have lead to the building of over 2000 cooling towers per annum, and there are over 250 000 FRP cooling towers in use in China with the largest one currently in use cooling over 5000 tonnes of water per hour. This market alone requires some 220 000 tonnes of FRP per year. The market for FRP pipes and tanks used in the chemical, food, water supply and oil industries requires over 58 000 tonnes of composite per year. The newer applications of environmental protection, bridge decks and roads are a growing market and currently take over 22000 tonnes per a n n u m of FRP. Although growing affluence is leading to increasing car production, there is still a heavy dependence on rail transport with 10 000 railway vehicles produced each year. Growth estimates indicate that 4 million cars and 20 000 railway vehicles will be produced each year by 2010 and this will require around 55 000 tonnes per annum of FRP. China's annual consumption of phenolic resins is some 22 000 tonnes, of which about 5% is used in railway vehicle construction and other infrastructure applications. The amount of vinyl ester used in China is very s m a l l - around 2000 tonnes per a n n u m - of which a small percentage is used in corrosion-resistant applications in the chemical industry. There is an over-supply of both phenolic resin and vinyl ester, and growth in these markets is very small. The annual consumption of epoxy resin in China is some 65 000 tonnes, although most of this is used in printed circuit boards with a very small amount used in infrastructure applications. Local production and imports cover about 50% each. A 500 tonnes per a n n u m epoxy resin plant began construction at Yueyang Petrochemical General Plants. Some of the first applications of fibre reinforced plastics for bridge structures were in China, of which the first major bridge was the Miyan Bridge completed in 1982 near Beijing and which carries full highway traffic. There are now eight FRP
12
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
1
Introduction
-
market developments
bridges in China generally constructed by hand lay-up of glass fibres in a polyester resin using a honeycomb form of deck structure. China must overcome considerable cost and quality problems in both the production of materials and of components, and the establishment of companies and joint ventures by major manufacturers will be of assistance, although few of those companies have seen profits from their ventures. The Middle East will supply Asia-Pacific with 5.6 million tonnes of commodity thermoplastics by 2003, rising from virtually nil in 1998
Taiwan Taiwan has some 18% of the Asian composites m a r k e t - second to J a p a n - and the industry originally grew on the availability of cheap labour. As labour costs have risen there is some concern that manufacturing will move to cheaper areas such as other Southeast Asian countries, Eastern Europe and Latin America. Taiwan has announced that it is cutting back on large-scale transport projects that could lead to a decline in spending rather than the previous double-digit increases. The allocation for roads and railways is only 28% of the requested figure and although spending on such projects as the municipal transit system in Kaohsiung will continue this will be at a much slower pace. Of the basic raw materials, there are 14 main Taiwanese companies producing about 130000 tonnes per annum of UP, with about 50% of production being exported. The largest m a n u f a c t u r e r - Eternal Chemical - has a capacity of 60 000 tonnes per annum. Taiwan has capacity of some 150 000 tonnes per annum of epoxy resin, with much of this being used in sports equipment. Vinyl ester is used in corrosion-resistant applications in the tank, pipe and scrubber markets. Four companies in Taiwan produce glass fibre mostly in conjunction with the large m u l t i - n a t i o n a l s - such as Owens Corning and PPG I n d u s t r i e s - either as licensees or as joint ventures. Glass fibre capacity is around 145 000 tonnes per a n n u m and there is high-capacity utilization. Most carbon fibre produced by companies such as Formosa Plastics is used in the sports goods markets, although rising labour costs have meant that much manufacturing has moved to China. Aramid fibres are not a factor in the Taiwan market. Hand lay-up still has just under 40% of the manufacturing market, with a growth in automated processes such as spray-up, pultrusion, filament winding and RTM resulting from the increase in labour costs. Taiwan had shipments of some 80 000 tonnes of composites in 1999, but less than 10% of this is used in such infrastructure applications as pipes, tanks and scrubbers. Even rehabilitation of buildings and other structures following the Ji-Ji earthquake will not make a significant contribution to composite use.
South Korea The production of finished composites in Korea is 60000 tonnes per annum, although much of this is used in the automotive industry with very little directed to infrastructure. However, there are small amounts used in corrosion-resistant applications for chemical plants and for pipelines and tanks - less than 5%.
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
13
1
Introduction - market developments
India India has seen the establishment of a n u m b e r of composite operations by the major Western producers such as Owens Corning, Ashland, Cray Valley and Scott Bader. Indian production of composites is some 46 000 tonnes per annum, but much of this is directed towards electrical/electronics, appliances and standard construction applications. About 5% (around 2300 tonnes) is directed to the infrastructure market mostly in pipelines, tanks and corrosion-resistant applications in chemical plants. The use of FRP for roads, bridges and similar applications has not yet been established. The infrastructure market has e n o r m o u s potential as India seeks to modernize its inadequate facilities, but the higher cost of FRP w h e n compared to reinforced concrete limits the potential. One infrastructure area that has considerable potential is the railway, as India has the largest rail network in the world and Indian Railways is now developing composite products for their weight-saving capability and as a means of saving on the use of timber. Increased car sales are also increasing the d e m a n d for petrol storage tanks. Consumption of glass fibre is some 20 000 tonnes per annum, but only about 5% of this will be directed to the infrastructure market. India is unlikely to sustain high growth rates for composites as the economy has shown considerable swings in the last decade.
1.2.5 Eastern Europe In Eastern Europe, Poland takes some 50% of the plastics market with Hungary taking about 18.6% and the Czech Republic about 17.5% (Tables 12 and 13). Most of this production is non-reinforced polyester used for commodity plastics. The automotive industry is also a heavy user as Western manufacturers take advantage of lower labour costs, but much of this production is for thermoplastics. Although virtually all aspects of the infrastructure are in serious need of upgrading, only limited amounts of GFRP will find application in this area with virtually no advanced materials, such as carbon fibre reinforcements. At some point towards 2005 environmental considerations will lead to investment in the chemical industries. Countries such as Russia and Poland have seen a decrease in life expectancy in recent years due to poor working conditions and pollution.
Table 12 Thermoset-based composite use in Eastern Europe 1 9 9 9 - 2 0 0 5 (O00s tonnes) 1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
Russiaa
106.0
108.0
110.0
112.0
114.0
116.0
118.0
Poland
40.0
41.0
42.5
44.0
45.5
47.0
48.5
i
Hungary
20.0
20.5
21.0
21.5
22.0
22.5
23.0
Czech Republic
20.0
20.5
21.0
21.5
22.0
22.5
23.0
Othersb
20.0
20.0
20.0
20.5
20.5
21.0
21.0
206.0
210.0
214.5
219.5
224.0
229.0
233.5
Total
alt should be noted that figures from Russia are not dependable as there is under-reporting due to tax considerations. blncluding Slovakia, Slovenia and Romania.
14
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
1
Introduction - market developments
Table 13 Polymer consumption in Eastern Europe 1999 (000s tonnes) Poland
1160
50%
Hungary
430
18.5%
Czech Republic
410
17.6%
Slovakia
190
8.1%
Romania
135
5.8%
2325
100%
Total
1.2.6 South America The South American market for composites is dominated by Brazil with Argentina and Chile also providing sizeable markets (Table 14). The size of individual national markets is so small that the area has been treated as one geographical entity, although the oil industry in Venezuela does make some infrastructure demands for pipes and tanks. However, prediction of growth rates is difficult as the South American markets are subject to considerable fluctuations caused by their own economic cycles and the effects of downturns in other areas. Considering the geographical separation, the economic crisis in Southeast Asia had a considerable impact on South America. On the positive side, South America has a rapidly growing population and a need for major developments in its infrastructure, although it is doubtful that composites will make a large contribution. There is some potential for pipes and tanks, but most water supplies will use polyester. The highway systems will not show any use of composites in the period of this report as the technical base and government pump-priming are not in place. However, towards the end of the report period greater sophistication in materials selection will raise the percentage use of composites for infrastructure. The predictions in Table 15 are based on use of thermosets. This area was responsible for the production of 280000 tonnes of purified terephthalic acid, of which 75% was used in the production of polyester fibre.
Table 14 Thermoset demand for South America 1999-2005 (000s tonnes)
Brazil
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
152
156
161
166
171
176
181
Argentina
70
72
74
76
79
82
85
Others
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
255
262
270
278
287
296
305
Total
Table 15 Composite demand for infrastructure in South America 1999-2005 (000s tonnes) 1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
18.0
18.5
19.0
19.5
23.0
24.5
25
Composites in Infrastructure - Building New Markets
15
1
Introduction - market developments
1.2.7 Middle East The Middle East has been taken to include the Gulf States, Saudi Arabia, Iran, Egypt, Israel, Jordan, Syria and Lebanon Having the raw materials for both resin and reinforcement manufacture, the Middle East is now starting to manufacture for export. It is expected that more than 5 million tonnes of commodity thermoplastics will-be supplied to Southeast Asia by 2003. Overall, the market for reinforced plastics in the Middle East countries is 105 000 tonnes (Table 16) with pipes for the petrochemical industry taking about 14 000 tonnes. This heavy dependence on the oil industry, where budgets have been severely cut (by 60% in Saudi Arabia) owing to cutbacks in oil production, means that there will be no growth before 2001-2002 after which growth should be 2-3% per annum. The market for other infrastructure applications such as airport buildings will not be able to compensate for the fall in pipe demand. In corrosionresistant applications, the Gulf States have a higher requirement due to their adverse climatic conditions - high temperatures, humidity and salinity.
Table 16 Thermoset demand for the Middle East 1 9 9 9 - 2 0 0 5 (O00s tonnes) 1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
105
105
107
109
11
113
115
The glass fibre industry in Iran required some 9000 tonnes in 1999 with the chemical industry consuming 38%, mostly in oil and petrochemical applications. The current local capacity for unsaturated polyester resin is 12 000-15 000 tonnes per annum, which should rise to 30 000 tonnes per a n n u m by 2001-2002. Hopes for growth have been seriously affected by the restraint on oil production. In a position on the border between Europe and the Middle East, Turkey has a considerable GFRP industry with several glass fibre manufacturers such as CamElyaf. Glass fibre production is of the order of 8000 tonnes per annum, but there is little or no growth. The exception is the GFRP pipe sector, which will see growth of 2% per a n n u m in the coming years. Whilst the total d e m a n d for UP resins is estimated at 30 000 tonnes per annum, this includes both textiles and casting applications. However, most resins for GFRP pipe applications are imported. The industry is not sophisticated, with open moulding as the most popular processing technique.
1.3 C h a l l e n g e s and o p p o r t u n i t i e s The industry must emphasize the importance of life-cycle costing and the two components: capital expenditure (CAPEX) and operational expenditure (OPEX). CAPEX covers the initial investment for an end-user and includes such items as raw material costs. The aim must be to use a material with an optimal price to performance ratio that meets the requirements of the application and no more. Paying for a higher performance resin that exceeds requirements forces up the
16
Composites in Infrastructure - Building New Markets
1
Introduction - market developments
CAPEX unnecessarily. OPEX includes costs for maintenance, repair, inspection and shutdown over the whole lifecycle of the equipment. The intrinsic chemical resistance of FRP, its long operational life and low maintenance requirements have positive benefits on OPEX costs and must be emphasized. However, w h e n customers are only responsible for CAPEX costs there is no incentive for them to consider OPEX costs as the initial price is higher as a result of using a high-cost material. Customer willingness to pay is limited. A survey in Orange Country, California found that 98% of residents thought infrastructure was important but would not pay 1% more in taxes for upgrades. In the survey it was found that only a major negative event such as an earthquake would result in a change of opinion. Automation of labour-intensive activities can reduce recurring labour costs; this is clearly illustrated in the material deposition rates seen for pultrusion, filament winding and automatic tape lay-up. Therefore, the persistence of manual labour as the dominant m e t h o d for composite fabrication is a strong indicator that automation with composites is difficult. A major challenge in developing costeffective composite manufacturing techniques is to maintain the vast material and shape options in a simplified and automated way. The major challenge that faces the industry is to develop flexible methods of automation that can significantly expand the shape and micro-structure of components available to the designer at reasonable cost. An indication of the relative costs of materials, shown in Table 17, gives some indication of the competition faced by composites. Steel prices obviously vary and there are reports of mild steel from China being sold in the USA for US$0.04-0.05 per kg.
Table 17 Relative price index for composites and other materials (per kg) E-glass chopped mat strand (CSM)/UP
1.6
E-glass-woven UP
2.1
E-glass-CSM/vinyl ester
3.0
Pultrusion (vinyl ester)
2.6
Pultrusion (UP)
1.6
Carbon (O~ Carbon (O~
23.0 ester
Carbon (0.9045 ~) vinyl ester
20.0 40.0
DMC
1.7
SMC
2.O
Mild steel grade 43
0.45
Stainless steel
2.0
Aluminium alloy 6063
1.1
Softwood
0.29
Plywood
0.32
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
17
1
Introduction - market developments
Table 17 gives some support to the perception that composite structures are expensive owing to the relatively high cost of the raw materials. However, this perception is misguided as it ignores the fact that: 9
smaller amounts of material may be required;
9
production costs may be lower; and
9
downtime for installation of the structure can be less.
It must be accepted that increased use of composites in infrastructure wiU not grow at a rate hoped for by the industry until civil engineers are confident of their strength and longevity. Applications using traditional materials have failed due to hitherto u n k n o w n factors and adding a relatively untried material to the equation only compounds the problem. The publicity w h e n large structures fail does not encourage innovative use of 'new' materials. The major challenge on the potentially huge market of roads and bridges is that without projects from which to learn there is no body of experience. Without a body of experience, engineers and clients will be wary of using the new technology. In the case study on Hythe Bridge, Oxford all parties indicated that there had been a considerable learning curve in such areas as cleanliness, heat and humidity. The Great Miami Composite Deck Project, run as an evaluation project by the Ohio Department of Transportation (ODOT), indicates the extent of the problems that faced all parties in applying composites to roads and bridge construction. The project will cost ODOT US$7 million, of which testing alone will cost US$1.3 million, with the Federal Highway Administration contributing US$400000-500000. The significance of this project can be seen in that typical bridge projects for ODOT cost US$50000-400000. The value of the exercise is considerable to all parties. In addition, the industry does not help itself in competition between materials, particularly glass and carbon fibre reinforcements. All matrix and reinforcement materials have their appropriate p l a c e - horses for c o u r s e s - as do manufacturing techniques. Design engineers will use a material that meets specifications and will only move to a higher grade or specification if this is essential to the work. Highergrade materials frequently mean higher cost and there is little point in using a more expensive material if this is not justified. One aspect that will need addressing is cost. This applies to all materials and manufacturing elements, but an example from the advanced end of the market provides an illustration. Reducing the cost of carbon fibre would increase the range/number of applications but Zoltek, who originally set a target cost of US$5/lb (US$11/kg) in 2000, have now allowed that date to slip to 2002. The approach to reducing cost is to develop a new polymer with lower processing costs and higher yields that would serve as a precursor to carbon fibre. It must be stated that other carbon fibre developments have taken a lot of time and money to achieve similar requirements. Important points to be noted are: 9
traditional materials will not allow business to be taken from them;
9
cooperation between all parties in a project is vital;
9
authoritative standards are required; and
9
the drive taken by the national highways authorities in the USA should be followed in Europe.
18
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
1
Introduction - market developments
It must be recognized that steel manufacturers will not aUow the infrastructure market to fall through their hands. The cheapest approach for road/bridge construction is still ferrous reinforced concrete. Steel companies are already introducing rebar, which is carbon steel coated with stainless steel, to achieve many of the advantages of stainless steel at a lower cost than FRP composite bar and dowel. Retrofitting projects such as composite column and beam wraps, and bridge rehabilitation have the advantages of speed, easier installation, use of lighter and less cosily equipment, and lower long-term maintenance. Despite these advantages, acceptance of the technology is slow. Figures for work in California, which has shown considerable interest in strengthening structures against earthquake damage, indicate that the value of the market was below US$20 million, with 50% as bridge and road construction and 50% for buildings. The reinforcement materials were divided 75:25 between glass and carbon fibres. The problem of composite acceptance for the new areas of infrastructure is exacerbated by a lack of standards, particularly for national projects. Although the industry and the standards organizations are making considerable efforts to establish standards, a realistic assessment by one authority indicated that it would be five years before there was a full range of formal standards in place. Given the acceptance time that will follow any standardization, this would indicate a 5-10year period for new structures. Standards are obviously of concern in upgrading work but are not as critical- structures are already built and the concern is that they may fall down without upgrade rather than suffer failure because of the use of innovative materials. The question of public liability in new structures is a severe constraint on the use of new materials or techniques.
1.4.1 Regulations and legislation In both Europe and North America there are increasing requirements for tighter legislation on volatile organic c o m p o u n d (VOC) emission, including styrene. VOCs react with nitrogen oxides in the presence of sunlight, resulting in the formation of ozone at ground level. Although the material has not been shown to have any carcinogenic properties there is a widespread requirement for lower emissions as styrene can cause breathing problems. On 6 November 1996, the EU Council formally adopted a solvent emissions proposal. A study prepared in 1994 predicted that the cost of the implemented legislative measures - as then defined - would be over US$70 billion for Europe alone. The changes introduced into the Directive have reduced the cost to some US$14 billion but some measures still have high marginal costs. The Directive will harmonize regulations across Europe and it could result in some manufacturers facing cuts in their allowable solvent emissions of 60% or more. The Directive requires solvent reduction by 20 October 2007 for existing installations and for new installations by 2004, but Member States must have established the legal compliance framework by 31 December 1999. There is a clear indication of investment in new equipment or process changes to meet the new limits. Guidelines on occupational exposure to styrene vary from country to country with the UK allowing a short-term exposure limit (STEL) of 100 parts per million
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
19
1
Introduction - market developments
(ppm) applied over a 15-min period and a time-weighted average (TWS) of 50 ppm over an 8-h period. In the USA, OSHA has set limits of 50 p p m and Germany's limit is just 20 ppm. Exposure to styrene is not considered to have carcinogenic effects but can cause nausea. EU legislation will cause considerable expenditure for the paints and adhesives industries, whilst the polyester industry is a smaller user. Alternatives to styrene as a m o n o m e r have been evaluated but none offer the same blend of quality, performance, convenience and cost effectiveness, and styrene will remain the predominant m o n o m e r in UP resins for the period of this report. In 1999 the US Environmental Protection Agency proposed new maximum available control technique (MACT) standards. This would require existing manufacturers generating 100 tonnes or more of hazardous air pollution to control at least 95% of those emissions. Styrene is already covered u n d e r the VOC legislation and will also be included as a hazardous air pollutant. The surface coatings industry is most heavily affected, but chemical manufacture and processing (which includes composites) is also concerned. The US industry is concerned that many smaller plants will be closed as the capital investment necessary for them to meet environmental requirements will not be justified. All of the major European resin producers, including DSM, Scott Bader, Cray Valley, Reichhold and Neste, already manufacture low-styrene emission resins for the composite industry. Most Scandinavian companies feel that they have a considerable manufacturing advantage in that they have had to meet the tight Scandinavian regulations for some years and have developed processes and materials that are now being adopted by other countries. The safety requirements should also speed the introduction of closed mould fabrication techniques particularly those such as RTM, which can operate a totally closed-loop system at modest capital investment. The styrene regulations are a matter for international concern but local regulations can have major effects on specific markets. This has been very noticeable in the USA. The requirement for maintenance staff to use non-metal ladders near electricity supplies has driven a considerable market for pultruded composite ladders that has spilled over into the domestic market. Seventy per cent of ladders in the USA are now thought to be composite. EPA regulations on the annual cathodic testing of steel tanks holding petroleum have lead to a widespread changeover to composite tanks as the cost of such testing was realized. Europe has no such regulations and steel tanks are still more common. At I tonne of composite per tank this was a significant market. New regulations in the USA requiring the paper and pulp industry to replace their use of chlorine with chlorine dioxide and hydrogen peroxide by the end of 2000 should give increased sales of corrosion-resistant products. Although not a consideration for this report, German requirements on the recycling of materials in cars and packaging are having an impact on the rest of Europe. Tax credits that give a favourable pricing regime for 'green energy' have lead to the growth of the wind energy industry in both Europe and the USA. The problem with all these changes in regulations is that they can have both positive and negative effects.
20
Composites in Infrastructure - Building New Markets
1
Introduction - market developments
1.4.2 Developments in materials As has been stated, the main materials in composites for infrastructure are based on glass fibre products and Ups, and that will remain the case until 2005. Vinyl esters and phenolics are expected to show very little growth and epoxy is largely used with carbon fibre, which is also a minority interest material. Dow Chemical has introduced the Derakane T M epoxy vinyl ester resins that have considerable potential in corrosive or extreme environments. Fires involving considerable loss of life have introduced tighte~ fire regulations in Europe leading to greater use of phenolics in mass transit systems. All thermoset and thermoplastic materials can be given some degree of fire retardancy either by chemical manipulation or the addition of inert mineral fillers and specific chemical compounds, although sometimes at the expense of producing heavier smoke emissions and increased toxicity. However, this ability to tailor resins over a wide range of chemical, mechanical and physical properties for fire hardness, toxicity levels, speed of combustion and ignition temperature offers design engineers a wider range of resins where fire safety is a prime requirement. Thermoplastics are continuing to take market share from thermosets, although the move is much slower than predicted. The greater ease in processing and the requirements for recycling will continue to encourage a move towards thermoplastics. Within composite manufacturing there is a move towards the use of various forms of fabric reinforcements as one-, two- or three-dimensional materials, braids or non-wovens. The use of these products aUows more accurate and efficient placement of the reinforcement. The purchase of Brunswick by Certainteed is an indication of the greater interest in these products. There is also greater interest in the use of core or sandwich materials for lightness and strength. The continuing discussion on carbon fibre prices has lead Conoco to announce the introduction of a pitch-based fibre and Toray Industries to consider whether changes in manufacturing processes would be justified and lead to lower costs. In the other advanced r e i n f o r c e m e n t - a r a m i d s - both Twaron T M and KevlarT M are being promoted for their impact resistance, a feature that was previously used in body armour. Toray Industries has introduced a new version of its carbon fibres with a special sizing agent for use in vinyl ester and UP resin composites. The level of interfacial strength is stated to be equivalent to that of carbon fibre with epoxy resin systems, and the fibre is soft and easily stitched. The material is currently only produced in Japan in small quantities and is aimed at the marine and similar markets. Although not a new material, GKN have announced the development of a composite disk joint that is a critical c o m p o n e n t in the more efficient generation of wind energy. The joint will allow the construction of wind turbines that are more than 90 m tall and with rotor blades with a length of 70 m.
1.4.3 Industry moves A continuing feature of the industry is the disparity in size between the large chemical companies that supply the composites industry and the small-scale fabricators. Acquisitions and mergers have formed huge, global chemical companies culminating with the merger of Dow Chemical and Union Carbide.
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
21
1
Introduction - market developments
Such companies can make the heavy capital investment needed for new developments and markets, and can afford the high levels of research to produce new products. Downstream from the materials manufacturers the fabricators are small with very modest levels of investment. The world's largest p u l t r u d e r Strongwell, U S A - will have sales of US$85 million from pultruded products in 2000. There are a couple of other US companies with sales of around US$30-40 million and Bekaert, Belgium had sales in 1999 of ~88 million in the entire advanced materials business unit partly as a result of two acquisitions which increased sales by 30%. Most of these companies produce for a mass market that includes ladders, w i n d o w and door lineals, fencing and similar products. However, most fabricators are small and undercapitalized, which restricts their development and their ability to participate in standards, R&D programmes and marketing exercises. In an interesting move, Zoltek, USA has joined Hexcel in vertically integrating its production of materials and components. Zoltek has purchased SPS Systems, which is a well-regarded and profitable UK manufacturer of components such as wind turbine blades, and has taken a percentage of Hardcore Composites, which works in the infrastructure market. Other acquisitions have added composite machinery manufacturers to the corporate structure. Zoltek is keen to develop greater use of carbon fibre and these would be two areas that have potential for growth. In a slightly different move Exchem, UK, who manufacture chemical products including adhesives used in the construction industry, is undertaking marketing for the pultruders, Fibreforce, UK. The two companies had worked together on the Hythe Bridge strengthening project in Oxford. Within the glass fibre manufacturing industry, margins, the four majors - Owens Coming, PPG, hold such a large share of the market that a companies is unlikely. The values involved would the Dow Chemical-Union Carbide or BP-Amoco attention of the regulatory authorities.
which has seen falling profit Vertrotex and Johns Manville merger between any of these put such a move on the level of mergers and would attract the
The 'new industry' status of composites for infrastructure can be measured by the state of flux in company mergers and acquisitions in recent years. An illustration is the dizzying move of Hardcore which began life as part of DuPont, became part of True North (which was later closed), was acquired by Harris Specialty Chemicals, which was itself acquired by SKW Trostberg AG and its SKW-MBT Construction Chemicals Group with Hardcore placed as a unit under Master Builders Inc. Hardcore was then divested in May 2000 to a combination of management buyout and an investment group headed by Zoltek.
22
January 1999
Harris Specialty Chemicals, a construction chemicals manufacturer acquires the Construction Products Division of Hardcore Composites from True North Composites. Hardcore had originally been part of DuPont.
January 1999
True North Partners, the investment company behind moulder TPI Composites, acquires SCRIMP Systems LLC. The patent portfolio for the Seeman Composite Resin Infusion Molding Process (SCRIMP), which contains 11 patents, will be assigned to a new company TPI Technology.
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
1
January 1999
Introduction - market developments
DSM splits the DSM Resins business into two business groups Coating Resins; and Industrial Resins and Compounds, with Radcure Products as a separate business unit.
-
February 1999
GKN-Westland Helicopters acquires Dow-United Technologies, which had become a partnership between Dow and United Technologies in 1990. The company specializes in RTM for the aerospace industry. The purchase price was s million.
March 1999
Harris Specialty Chemicals, which had recently acquired Hardcore Composites, was acquired by SKW Trostberg AG and its SKW-MBT Construction Chemicals Group, which are part of Viag AG, Munich. Hardcore was then placed as a unit under Master Builders Inc.
March 1999
Denali purchased the outstanding stock of Belco Manufacturing Companies, a Belton, Texas-based manufacturer of glass fibre reinforced plastic (GFRP) tanks, vessels and piping system whose products are primarily sold to the water/ waste-water and oil and gas industries. Belco's calendar year 1998 revenues were approximately US$8 million.
March 1999
Aerovac Systems Ltd, a manufacturer of vacuum bagging materials, is bought by UMECO plc for s million. UMECO, which has a turnover of s million, also owns B&K Resins and GRP Material Supplies.
April 1999
Cray Valley acquires the structural resin activities of the Dae Sang Group, South Korea, which manufactures unsaturated polyesters, vinyl esters, gel coats and SMC.
April 1999
Following the merger between Amoco Chemical, USA and BP, the conglomerate acquires Arco Chemical, USA.
May 1999
Composite Materials Inc, GLS Composites Distribution Corp and RP Associates merge to form a new company caUed Composites One.
May 1999
The US company Denali Inc announced that it would acquire Welna NV, Netherlands to create the world's largest engineered fibre reinforced plastic products company. Welna manufactures and installs FRP pipe systems, vessels and equipment for high-corrosion applications. Denali pay ~g37 per Welna share and assume ~ 11.5 million of the company's debt. The new company will have some US4250 million in annual revenues and manufacturing locations in the USA, The Netherlands, Germany, France, Poland, Venezuela, Thailand and the UK.
May 1999
Ferro Corp, USA acquired Advanced Polymer Compounding Co which supplies high-performance thermoplastic elastomers. The acquisition will be integrated into Ferro's Filled and Reinforced Plastics business as the Performance Polymer Compounds unit.
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
23
1
24
Introduction - market developments
May 1999
Yvon Vezine Enterprises Inc, Quebec has acquired the Composites Materials Centre of St Jerome, Quebec. CMC is the first technological transfer centre to be privatized in Quebec.
May 1999
Maunsell, the UK engineering consultancy group, licensed its Advanced Composites Construction System (ACCS) to Strongwell, the US pultruder.
June 1999
StrongweU Corp, Bristol, Virginia and Ebert Composites, San Diego, California formed a partnership company Strongwell Ebert LLC to market composite electricity transmission poles. The company's first order for poles to carry 69- and l l5-kV power lines for Southern Californian Edison was delivered in autumn 1999.
June 1999
Denali completes the acquisition of 100% of the outstanding stock of Plasti-Fab Inc, Tualatin, Oregon. Plasti-Fab makes glass fibre reinforced flumes and metering stations to the water and waste-water industries. The company's revenue for 1998 was US$4.5 million.
June 1999
BASF acquire the Morton Industrial Coatings unit of Rohn & Haas Co for US$175 million.
June 1999
Structural Preservation Systems Inc, Baltimore, Maryland formed an alliance with Master Builders Inc, Cleveland, Ohio and Hardcore Composites.
July 1999
Acordis sells 55% of HIMA, which supplies technical services to industrial companies, to Rheinhold & Mahla AG, Munich.
July 1999
Orica, the Australian chemical company, sells its unsaturated polyester resins business to Nuplex Industries, New Zealand for Aus$13.7 million.
July 1999
Hoechst sold its 45% share in the Swiss-based speciality chemicals business, Clariant, for ~2.8 billion.
July 1999
Cape Composites Inc, San Diego, California acquires 100% of Sierra Materials LLC.
July 1999
Hammond, Kennedy, Whitney & Co, New York acquired 49.9% of the outstanding capital stock of Reinhold Industries Inc, Sante Fe Springs, California from Keene Creditors Trust for US$8.98 million. Reinhold manufactures advanced composite components.
August 1999
Reichhold acquires the Brazilian unsaturated resin business which is a subsidiary of Vianova, Germany.
August 1999
Dow Chemical and Union Carbide announce that they are to merge to form a business with a market capitalization ofUS$35 billion.
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
1
Introduction - market developments
August 1999
True North Composites, part of the original Hardcore DuPont Composites, is closed and the assets sold. The company had used the SCRIMP process to mould 50 freight rail cars for Trinity Industries but the companies have been in dispute.
August 1999
CVC Capital Partners acquired the fibres business of Akzo Nobel for US$875 million. The deal covered the fibre business of Accordis (previously Courtaulds and a major producer of PAN precursor), including Fortaf'fl Fibres in the USA and Accordis European Fibres. Akzo Nobel purchase 20% of the new business.
August 1999
Negotiations fail for the sale of Advanced Technical Products Inc to a third party.
September 1999
Borden Chemical Inc, Columbus Ohio acquires Blagden Chemicals Ltd, UK for s million. Blagden produces formaldehyde and resins, including phenolic resins, at four manufacturing sites in the UK and The Netherlands.
September 1999
Advanced Technical Products Inc (ATP), RosweU, Georgia, USA announced that it had entered into a merger agreement with the Veritas Capital Fund LP to sell the company for US$135 million including debt. ATP has five divisions including Lincoln Composites, Marion Composites, Alcore Inc, Intellitec and Lux Industries. ATP had sales in 1998 of US$165 million. The deal was deferred due to problems with the accounts of the Alcore Division.
September 1999
Teijin Ltd, Tokyo and Nisshinbo Industries announced that Teijin would buy Toho Rayon in which Nisshinbo was the primary shareholder. The price was some US$118 million and Nisshinbo will retain a 10% share. Toho was established in 1934, beginning mass production of acrylic fibres in 1963 and polyacrylonitrile (PAN)-based carbon fibres in 1975.
September 1999
Myers Technologies was closed by its parent C.C. Myers Inc, Rancho Cordova, California. The Snap Tite column jacketing technology license reverted to its owner NCF Industries, Long Beach, California. Myers had just completed a major column wrap project at Yolo Causeway near Sacramento.
September 1999
Dow Chemical, Midland, Missouri acquired Union Carbide for some US$11.6 billion giving a global chemical company with annual sales of over US$24.1 billion, making Dow the second largest chemical company in North America after DuPont.
September 1999
Interplastic Corp acquired M&. Hanna Resin Distribution, a thermoset materials business, and combined it with Interplastic Distibution Group to create a new company.
September 1999
Shakespeare Composites & Electronics acquires Lewtex Inc which makes composite cross arms for utility poles.
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
2S
1
:26
Introduction - market developments
October 1999
Two divisions of the Balmoral Group, Aberdeen, U K Balmoral Composites and Balmoral M o u l d i n g s - merge to form a new operating division to be called Balmoral Tanks.
October 1999
Ube Nitto Kasei Co, Nippon Sheet Glass Co and Idemitsu Kosan Co announce a joint venture to produce stampable thermoplastic sheet composed of acrylic resin and carbon fibre. The new venture will be known as Nippon GMT, with equal ownership between the three companies. The company has a capacity of 10000 tonnes per annum and has sales targets of u billion in the fiscal year commencing April 2000.
October 1999
Norton Co, part of Saint Gobain, purchased the Furon Co, Laguna Niguel, California for US$472 million. Furon manufactures high-performance plastics.
October 1999
Aldila Inc sells half its carbon fibre operation to SGL Carbon Fibers and Composites Inc for US$7 minion. The new partnership will be known as Carbon Fiber Technology LLC. Name plate installed capacity for the single production line is reported as 2.5 million lbs of 45K continuous, standard modulus, large-tow carbon fibre with potential to double this amount.
October 1999
Ashland acquires 50% of the Brazilian unsaturated polyester resin company ARA Quimica SA, Sao Paulo. The deal makes Ashland the fifth largest UP resins manufacturer in South America.
October 1999
Fortum Corp sells Neste Chemicals, including the UP resin division Neste Polyester, to a private equity company Industri Kapital for FIM3 billion.
November 1999
RecycleNet Corp, Guelph, Canada acquires the Internet-based company Fiberglass.com Inc based in Salt Lake City, Utah. Fiberglass.com operates Fiberglass World, which is an Internet portal to the composites industry.
November 1999
Solutia Inc buys Morgan Grenfell's ownership of Vianova Resins, Germany for US$640 million. The company was previously part of Hoechst and is a leading European producer of resins.
November 1999
McWhorter Technologies Inc, which manufactures unsaturated polyester resin, sold its 50% stake in the Hong Kong joint venture Syntech Far East, which owns a manufacturing plant in China.
November 1999
Zoltek acquires Cape Composites, which uses a proprietary technology for high-volume production of prepregs. Cape had reduced the price of unidirectional industrial grade carbon fibre prepreg products to US$11.99/Ib in 1998 and US$7.99/Ib in 1999. The company has also begun a class action suit against competitor carbon fibre producers, particularly those in Japan.
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
.1. Introduction - market developments
November 1999
Zoltek acquires Engineering Technology (Entec) and Composite Machines Co (CMC) and joins them to become Entec Composite Machines Inc.
November 1999
Zoltek acquire SP Systems, Isle of Wight, UK, a manufacturer of carbon and aramid fibre reinforced boats and who also manufactures wind turbine blades. Zoltek paid US$30 million in cash, which was financed through a new bank credit facility.
November 1999
Exxon Corp and Mobil Corp merge their polymer and films business to give a b u s i n e s s - Exxon Mobil Chemical C o which will have annual sales of over US$15 billion based on 1998 figures. The regulatory authorities require that they divest some gasoline, pipeline and lubrication assets.
November 1999
Menzolit-Fibron GmbH, part of Dynamit Nobel AG, Germany acquires DSM Compounds, which has sales of ~g50 million per annum, from DSM NV.
November 1999
Accordis sells its textile polyester yarns business to Textilwerke GmbH, Deggendorf, Germany.
November 1999
Morton Industrials divested Carroll George Inc, a composites structures business, following a loss in the fourth quarter of 1999.
December 1999
McWhorter Technologies buys the coatings resins business in Europe and North America of Dyno ASA, Oslo which has annual sales of US$10 million.
December 1999
Owens Coming and IKO Industries announce the formation of a joint venture for a new glass fibre mat facility to manufacture wet-formed glass fibre mat used mainly in the production of roofing shingles.
December 1999
Ciba Specialty Chemicals and Morgan Grenfell Private Equity (MGPE) announced that MGPE will buy Ciba's Performance Polymers division which supplies high-performance epoxy resins, amongst other products. The purchase price was some US$2.75 billion.
December 1999
Akzo Nobel NV signs a contract to sell its Acordis fibres business to CVC Capital Partners for US$840 million (~825 million). CVC take a 64% stake in the new company with Acordis management holding 15% and the remaining 21% held by Akzo Nobel.
January 2000
Fortum Corp, the new owner of Neste sells Neste Chemicals to Industri Kapital, Stockholm for US$535 million.
January 2000
DSM Industrial Resins & Compounds sells its compounds business to Menolit-Fibron, Bretten, Germany which is part of the Dynamit Nobel Group.
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
27
1
28
Introduction - market developments
January 2000
Ameron International's joint venture company in Saudi Arabia, Bondstrand Ltd, establishes a new joint venture in Kuwait to be known as Bondstrand Kuwait Ltd.
January 2000
Premix Inc, USA and Dainippon Ink & Chemicals Inc, Japan formed a joint approach to service global customers with thermoset composite moulding compounds. The agreement is specifically targeted at the electronics industry in Southeast Asia.
January 2000
Advanced Technical Products Inc (ATP) and The Veritas Capital Fund L.P. announce that due to negative developments in ATP's Alcore Division they will terminate the agreement of September 1999. A new agreement, in which stockholders of ATP-will receive cash of US$12.5 per share without interest, is drawn up.
February 2000
Saint Gobain announces that it will combine the operations of its wholly owned subsidiary Norton Performance Plastics with the Furon Co to create a new business unit Saint Gobain Performance Plastics, which will have its headquarters in Wayne New Jersey. The new company has anticipated annual sales of US$830 million.
February 2000
Cambridge Industries Inc is to be sold either in whole or in part and has retained Morgan Stanley Dean Witter & Co to manage the sale. The company has liquidity problems and needs significant funding to pay for new equipment and facilities for increased business.
February 2000
Ferro Corp and Albemarle Corp reach an agreement in principle for Ferro to sell its flame-retardent business to Albemarle.
February 2000
Courtaulds Engineering Ltd is sold to a management buy-out.
February 2000
AlliedSignal Inc and Honeywell Inc are merged and Allied Signal changes its name to Honeywell Performance Fibres.
March 2000
Composite Solutions, San Diego announce that they are to acquire the privately held Trans-Science Corp. Composite Solutions undertakes retrofitting and repair of bridge and columns structures, and Trans-Science has undertaken ballistic research for the US Army.
March 2000
Alcoa Inc acquires all outstanding shares for Cordant Technologies Inc in a transaction valued at some US$2.9 billion, including the assumption of US$685 million in debt. Cordant is composed of three business groups: Howmet Castlings, Huck Fasteners and Thiokol Propulsion, which includes Thiokol TCR Composites. The Alcoa-Cordant combination will have revenues of US$18.8 billion.
March 2000
Fabric Development Inc (FDI) acquires the Fort Washington division of Lydall Manning, making FDI the largest weaver of high-performance fabrics. FDI weaves E-glass, carbon fibre,
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
1
Introduction
-
market developments
aramid (Kevlar), S-2 glass, Spectra, UHMWPE, quartz, Teflon, Nomex and other fibres. March 2000
Acordis transfers its remaining 45% holding in HIMA to Rheinhold & Mahla AG.
April 2000
Mitsubishi Chemical Corp combines the operations of its Functional Products Division with the operations of its wholly owned subsidiary Mitsubishi Kagaku Sanshi Corp. Products from the Functional Division include resin compound sheets, carbon fibres, carbon fibre sheets and alumina fibres. Construction products include reinforcing rods for concrete, Replark prepregs for concrete repair and seismic wrapping with Dialead pitch-based carbon fibres. The two units in the USA- Grafil Inc and Newport Adhesives & Composites- are part of Mitsubishi Rayon and are not affected.
April 2000
Cray Valley acquires the alkyd and unsaturated polyester business of Borden Chemical, UK. The company had a turnover of s million and the manufacturing will be distributed amongst existing Cray Valley plants.
April 2000
DSM-BASF Structural Resins, with the rest of the DSM Industrial Resins Group, is renamed DSM Composite Resins with the pipes and tanks business moved to a separate group.
April 2000
Composites One, which was been formed in 1999, acquires Lake Erie Fiber Glass Inc.
April 2000
CertainTeed Corp signs a letter of intent to purchase Celotex Roofing, Tampa, Florida in which it also acquires a glass fibre mat production plant in Russellville, Alabama.
May 2000
Eastman Chemical Co announces that it will buy McWhorter Technologies Inc, the specialist resin manufacturer, for US$200 million cash and the assumption of US$155 million debt. Sales revenue for McWhorter in the fiscal year to October 1999 was US$444 million.
May 2000
Concert Industries Ltd announces that it has acquired all outstanding shares of Airformed Composites Inc, Charleston, South Carolina, which produces multi-bond air-laid fabrics.
May 2000
Cambridge Industries enters into an agreement to sell virtually all shares in the company for US$363.1 million in cash to Meridian Automotive Systems Inc, Dearborn, Michigan. Cambridge filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in order to operate without disruption during the period of the sale.
May 2000
CGW Southeast Partners IV, Atlanta, Georgia buys all outstanding shares in Johnston Industries Inc, whose subsidiary Johnston Industries Composite Reinforcements Inc makes Vectorply and other multi-axial reinforcing fabrics used in such applications as the bridge deck panels manufactured by Martin Marietta Composites
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
29
1
30
Introduction - market developments
May 2000
Performance Materials Corp, Camarillo, California acquires the assets of BayComp, a division of Bay Mills Ltd Corp, which is a subsidiary of Saint Gobain, France. BayComp manufactures thermoplastic composite tapes, pellets and sheet materials.
May 2000
An investor group headed by Zoltek Companies Inc acquires a significant stake in Hardcore Composites Operations LLC, which had been part of Master Builders Inc which, in turn, is part of the international SKW-MBT Construction Chemicals Group. The remainder of the equity is owned by a new company under the chairmanship of the former CEO of Harcore Composites Division of Master Builders.
May 2000
Dow Chemical acquires General Latex Inc.
May 2000
BP-Amoco announces that it will divest its high-performance engineering polymer and carbon fibre businesses to focus on its mainstream hydrocarbon business. Engineering polymers include the Udel, Radel, Amodel, Xydar, Torlon and Kadel ranges, whilst carbon fibres are marketed as Thornel.
May 2000
Denali Inc, Houston, Texas which manufactures fluid handling products, including composite tanks and piping, received funding of US$28 million from the William Blair Mezzanine Capital Fund III following losses in the third quarter earnings to March 2000. The sum was reduced to US$23 million in June 2000.
June 2000
Dow Chemical assumes full ownership of Buna Sow Leuna Olefinverbund GmbH. The company was formed in 1995 from Buna GmbH, Sachsusche Olefinwerke GmbH and Leuna Polyolefin GmbH and in the same year Dow took 80% of the shares with an investment of US$2.5 billion. The company will now be known as Dow Central Germany.
June 2000
Vetrotex CertainTeed acquires the shares in Brunswick Technologies Inc for US$8.50 per share after the initial offer in May 2000 is refused.
June 2000
Advanced Technical Products Inc announces that it will sell its troubled Alcore and Alcore Brigantine divisions, although no buyer is yet named. For financial reporting purposes the units will be treated as discontinued operations.
June 2000
Composite Solutions Inc, San Diego announces that it will buy Anchor Reinforcements, Huntingdon Beach, California, which manufactures non-woven unidirectional fabrics in carbon, aramid and/or glass for the civil construction industry.
July 2000
Composite Solutions Inc acquires Karagozian and Case Structural Engineers, which was founded in 1945 and has particular interests in earthquake and explosion engineering.
August 2000
Reichhold is to acquire the resin and gel coat business of Fibercenter Ltda, which is the fourth largest producer of polyesters in Brazil.
Composites in Infrastructure - Building New Markets
1
Introduction - market developments
August 2000
Composite Solutions Inc announces the formation of HBC Composite Solutions LLC, a joint venture with Howard Building Corp, California a building and construction contractor. The new company will develop business in seismic retrofitting of buildings.
August 2000
Norton Co, a subsidiary of St Gobain acquires the outstanding shares of Chemfab Corp through a wholly owned subsidiary, PPLC Acquisition Corp. Chemfab manufactures flexible polymeric composite materials.
Composites in Infrastructure - Building New Markets
31
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Industrial applications
The major infrastructure markets are discussed in the following sections and they divide into the following four main areas: 9 9 9 9
use in n e w civil infrastructure (research and d e v e o p m e n t stage); retrofitting and repair of existing civil infrastructure (development stage); well-established but growing applications such as wind turbines and cooling towers; and long-standing applications such as pipes, tanks and corrosion resistance with low growth.
W h e n considering this sector only estimates can be made of the value of the market as no statistics are collected in any country. Tonnages are not considered to be the important e l e m e n t (and are also not collected) as a small a m o u n t of material can have a major influence on cost. Table 18 gives the estimated value of total road/bridge work a r o u n d the world split into the three main r e g i o n s - North America, Europe and Japan. Roads and bridges are a n e w area for composites having been established little more than a decade - the m u c h - q u o t e d Aberfeldy Bridge dates from the beginning of this period and there are still no major highway applications. Most bridges to date have b e e n relatively short - 8-10 m spans - although there are two footbridges with m u c h longer spans. Aberfeldy, UK, which is about 120 m in
Table 18 Value of composite developments in roads and bridges (US$ millions)
North America
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
30
2004
2005
35
45
50
60
70
80
Europe
10
15
20
25
35
45
55
Japan
25
30
35
40
45
55
60
Others
10
11
12
14
16
18
20
Total
75
91
112
129
156
188
215
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets 33
2
Industrial applications
length, and the Big Sandy River Bridge, Kentucky, which was completed in April 1999, has a length of 130 m. This lack of a long history is a problem for civil engineers in accepting composites as a viable construction material. It should be noted that, for example, some European bridges have a documented life of over 2000 years and even those in more m o d e r n materials, such as the cast iron bridge at Ironbridge, UK, were built in the 18th century. However, the composites industry is placing great hopes on growth of the repair of existing infrastructure and the construction of new initiatives as given in the first two items in the list at the beginning of this chapter. It should be stated that the potential market for new work for the period of this report is very small. The lack of standards and the concerns by commissioning bodies on third-party liability will severely limit the potential in the next five years. There is much better potential for repair/rehabilitation of structures. The sector also suffers from the separation between capital expenditure and maintenance costs. Most of the US road and bridge decks that need rehabilitation and strengthening have been in place for 50 years. This timescale is outside the corporate memory or depreciation times of all commissioning bodies. Where there is a regular, for example annual, maintenance cost following new work there is an incentive for bodies to consider the longer term. This is also the case where major disruption to traffic flows in repair work can be avoided, and this was one of the factors in the Hythe Bridge work described in the Chapter 6 case studies. In politically o p e n societies, such as California, it is also important that work that could save lives in the event of earthquakes is seen to have been undertaken. A survey in Orange Country, California, found that 98% of residents thought infrastructure was important but would not pay 1% more in taxes for upgrades. In the survey it was found that only a major negative event, such as an earthquake, Would result in a change of opinion. Where new work is implemented it requires a leap of faith to use relatively untried materials that have the further disadvantage of apparent higher cost rather than follow the traditional route that will last for the period of civic memory. This simpler traditional route is even more attractive if the alternative requires a more complex path in both engineering and financial terms. A large mileage of road throughout the world is made from reinforced concrete. The limited tensile strength of concrete has resulted in the use of steel reinforcement bars (rebars) to provide the tensile strength. Steel rebars are a cost-efficient reinforcement but are susceptible to oxidation when exposed to chlorides. This occurs in marine areas and in areas where road salts are used for de-icing. When properly protected the steel rebars can last for decades, but insufficient concrete cover, p o o r design or workmanship or large amounts of the salts can lead to premature failure. When corrosion of the rebar occurs, the result is a larger volume for the b a r - this can be as much as from two to five times the original volume. The concrete cannot sustain such growth and cracks and spalls cause the road to break up. In recent years epoxy-coated steel bars have been used to overcome the problem but new studies have indicated that epoxy does not perform consistently. The Florida Department of Transportation has now revoked their use and a report by the Canadian Strategic Highway Research Programme (1992) concluded that epoxy-coated reinforcing steel should not be used as the primary protective system. Fibre reinforced plastic (FRP) has the potential to provide a cost-effective answer to this problem. In addition to being totally resistant to chloride ion attack, FRP has 1.5-2 times the tensile strength of steel at only 25% of the weight.
3,4
Composites in Infrastructure - Building New Markets
2
Industrial applications
Dowel bars which provide transverse joint restraint between the cast concrete slabs are typically made from uncoated steel or steel coated with galvanized zinc or epoxy materials. The bars have a similar problem of corrosion and products such as FiberDowel TM have been introduced to provide a lightweight, corrosionresistant component. One disadvantage is the initial cost, as composites are more expensive than steel. A second problem is that the alkalinity inherent in concrete has been d o c u m e n t e d in laboratory tests to deteriorate the glass fibres in the composite bar if the resin matrix does not properly protect them. It is claimed that the new generation of FRP rebar has solved this problem. Although market growth should be approached with some caution, the potential for repair and rehabilitation is considerable. To replace the 132 000 road decks in the USA which are considered to be deficient would require over 18 000 tonnes of composite if the accepted figure of 91 kg/m 2 is used. In a relatively early demonstration project by the University of Delaware or the Delaware Department of Transportation, Tonen Corporation's Forca TM unidirectional carbon fibre sheet, 20-in wide and 0.025-in thick, was used to strengthen the Foulk Road bridge. Three years later there was no sign of cracks in the bridge road surface. However, some early company entrants in the market have shown caution. Glasforms, one of the early innovators in pultruded road decks, has largely withdrawn from this market. They see little chance of growth u n d e r 5-10 years with acceptance by the civil engineering industry requiring a further 5 years of demonstration. It indicates that, in additional to confidence, cost is a factor. A pultruded deck weighing 19 lb/ft 2 has a cost of US$50/ft 2 and at a reasonable profit margin would sell for US$75/ft2; this compares with reinforced concrete decks at some US$25/ft 2. Glasforms has capacity to manufacture 250000 ft 2 of deck and only a small fraction of that is in demand. However, it should be mentioned that Glasforms has been replaced by Creative Pultrusions as the supplier to Martin Marietta Composites (MMC). MMC is involved in several highway projects but sees most growth in the northeast USA which has corrosion from winter-salted roads. Glasforms is located in California. MMC has recently been successful with bids for FRP bridges in New York, Pennsylvania and Maryland to add to its growing list of completed bridges. Within the bridge and building sector in the USA, a further possibility is column and building retrofitting as earthquake strengthening. About 40 states in the USA are vulnerable to seismic disturbances, with other Pacific Rim countries such as Japan, Taiwan and New Zealand facing similar problems. The main competitor system for composite column retrofitting is the use of steel-welded jackets, a technology introduced from New Zealand via the University of California, San Diego. To date, over 3000 bridges have been retrofitted with glass, KevlarTM, carbon fibre and epoxy or isopolyester composite jackets. California Department of Transportation (CALTRANS) has spent US$55 million over a period of 10 years to enhance column ductility as an aid to displacement during earthquakes; this is considered a more effective solution than enhancing strength. Full-height column jackets also add shear capacity.
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
35
2
Industrial applications
2.1.1 North America The importance of the highway network in the USA can be judged from estimates by the Federal Highway Administration that 91% of miles travelled in the USA are in privately owned vehicles; trucks move nearly three-quarters of the value, half of the weight and nearly a quarter of the tonne:km of all shipments in the USA. Over the next 10 years it is estimated that the vehicle distance travelled will increase by 24%, and that rises to 53% over 20 years. The number of commercial trucks on US highways grew by 76% between 1982 and 1992 while vehicle distance travelled doubled. These factors and the growth of such systems as just-in-time delivery introduce commercial pressures to road and bridge repairs as the closure of roads and bridges over a prolonged period has serious economic effects. If the use of composites can be shown to shorten the repair time and if this is factored into costing the initially higher cost of composites is balanced by the reduced operational cost. Estimates on the percentage of the 587 815 bridges in the USA which can be classified as deficient, that is deteriorated, under strength and/or geometrically obsolete for the demands of current and future traffic volumes and loads, varies between 10 and 30%. Whichever number is used, the problem is severe as bridges and roads that were built 50 years ago in the expansion after World War II are now showing deterioration. Published reports by the US Department of Transportation have indicated that approximately US$35 billion per annum is spent in the USA to maintain the highway and bridge infrastructure. Conservative estimates indicate that approximately US$53 billion is necessary to maintain the highway and bridge infrastructure in its current condition. The primary concerns are seismic safety of roads, bridges and buildings, and corrosive decay of roads and bridges. In June 1998 Congress passed the Transportation Efficiency Act for the 21st Century (TEA-21). This legislation authorizes funds for two major initiatives intended to improve the condition, durability and capacity of bridges. TEA-21 continues the Highway Bridge Rehabilitation and Replacement Programme (HBRRP), which provides US$20.4 billion to rehabilitate or replace deficient bridges. In addition, a new initiative has been l a u n c h e d - the Innovative Bridge Research and Construction Programme 0BRC). IBRC is a 10-year programme with an outlined expenditure of US$2.1 billion for research on the 10 materials industries considered as having future potential for the nation. In the first three years of the IBRC programme, 116 projects using innovative materials were funded and 62 of these involved the use of FRP composites in bridge decks, concrete reinforcement, pre-stressing tendons, column wrapping and b o n d e d sheets. A further 56 composites projects are planned for 2000. Under the IBRC programme, US state departments of transportation propose demonstrations of new materials and systems for funding through partnerships between FHWA, the departments of transportation, industry and academia. Composite structures and materials have been a major area of focus. Total funding of US$102 million has been allocated for the six years 1997-2002, although this could be much higher with matching funding from the states. Under the TEA-21 programme, road and railway maintenance and enhancement are priorities with safety measures and environmental improvements. Projects must demonstrate improved technologies such as disaster-resistant design, lowered construction downtime, cost savings, reduced maintenance requirement, improved capacity, greater durability or increased service life, with an aim for the
36
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
2
Industrial applications
latter of 75-100 years. Materials can include glass fibre reinforced plastic (GFRP), carbon fibre reinforced plastic (CFRP), high-strength steel or high-performance concrete. Aramids have been considered as reinforcement mesh in both road and building structures. The TEA-21 programme already has a backlog of work and spending has been raised from 11% of the total fund in the first year to 19% in the last. There is criticism from Europe that the US approach is to put money into action rather than analysis but the process establishes a body of experience on which manufacturers and customers can build. Bridge goals under the TEA-21 programme include: 9 Q Q Q Q
application of innovative materials; reduced maintenance and life-cycle costs; less traffic delay; development of engineering design criteria; and development of non-destructive methods for monitoring and inspection.
In addition to the general question of deterioration and under-design for m o d e m requirements, certain areas, such as California, have specific problems relating to earthquakes. Following the collapse of numerous bridge structures during the 1971 San Fernando earthquake (magnitude 6.4 on the Richter scale) there has been an increased awareness of the vulnerability of highway bridge support columns to damage from earthquakes. This vulnerability was again demonstrated by the 1989 San Francisco earthquake with the collapse of the Cypress Viaduct of the Nimitz Freeway and highway 1-880 in Oakland. More recently, following the 1994 Los Angeles earthquake, numerous highways collapsed or were badly damaged, including portions of the Santa Monica Freeway. Particularly vulnerable are bridge structures designed and/or built prior to 1971, before the San F e m a n d o earthquake p r o m p t e d drastic revisions in the seismic design code (which is still in use today). While seismic risk is typically associated with California, it is of concern throughout most of the USA. In 1990 the American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials adopted seismic design guide specifications for the entire USA, recognizing the vulnerability of the nation's bridge infrastructure to potential seismic activity along the West Coast, the Midwest (New Madrid fault) and the northeastern USA. The seismic risk to bridge structures differs from region to region due to different probable earthquake magnitudes and recurrence periods, as well as geological conditions, but the unpredictable nature of seismic events and the vulnerability of the majority of existing bridges necessitates the development and implementation of innovative, fast, effective and economical retrofitting technologies to ensure the safe and continued use of the nation's bridge infrastructure. With so much of the nation's commercial production and domestic transport road-based, disruption to traffic is a matter for serious economic concern. Infrastructure engineering is concerned with balancing cost and weight to achieve desired performance. To note that a material is light, strong or cheap is simplistic - the material must have certain properties at an acceptable cost. The most commonly used primary design criteria are: 9 9 9 Q
bending strength; bending stiffness; tensile strength; and tensile stiffness.
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
31'
2
Industrial applications
However, other factors that must be considered are: 9 9 9
disruption; appearance; and life-cycle costs.
The US Federal Highway Bridge Rehabilitation, Replacement and Repair programmes have funding averaging US$3.6 billion per annum, and composites could play a prominent role. By mid-1999 roughly US$250 million worth of research and development ~&D) on new construction materials had been undertaken by the High Performance Construction Materials and Systems (CONMAT) Council within the Civil Engineering Research Foundation (CERF), in the USA. However, despite considerable efforts, an authoritative source indicates that the 1999 value of installed composite bridge and road work in the USA is only of the order of US$20-25 million with 75% using glass fibre reinforcement and 25% using carbon fibre. Growth is of the order of 25% per annum but coming from a very low base. The Federal Highway Administration of the US Department of Transportation has issued funding guides for the years to 2003 to demonstrate innovative material technology (including non-composite materials) and some 60% of projects have involved composites. The funding is: 9 9 9 9 9 9
19981999 2000 2001 2002 2003-
US$10 US$15 US$17 US$20 US$20 US$20
million (funded); million (funded); million (in process); million; million; million.
Canada, which has similar weather conditions to the northeastern USA, has taken an active approach to the composite market for roads and bridges. There is a strong academic influence on developments in Canada with ISIS and the University of Manitoba providing good examples of the efforts being made in this area.
2.1.2 Europe United Kingdom
There has been considerable interest in the use of composites in road and bridge structures in the UK resulting from deterioration from bad weather and changing vehicle patterns and loads. The Aberfeldy Bridge in Scotland, the A19 Teeside bridge at Bonds Mill and Hythe Bridge in Oxford are all interesting applications of the use of composites in bridge structures. However, there have been no new structures on the major highways. All new work, to date, has been for footbridges, and most rehabilitation work has resulted from developments by local authorities. The Highways Agency (responsible for the construction and maintenance of major trunk roads and motorways in the UK) has not commissioned any new work using composites. However, the Highways Agency has undertaken various projects using aramids for strengthening bridge columns on major highways against impact damage by heavy trucks. The longer spans of 30-40 m for trunk road and motorway bridges
38
Composites in Infrastructure - Building New Markets
2
Industrial applications
mean that composites have not been used in bridges; most applications so far have been for local roads with spans up to 10 m. One problem is the lack of standards for the major roads and TRL Ltd, the transport and road research laboratory, are currently preparing a standard on bridge decks. The following have been suggested as relative costs for bridge repair/rehabilitation per m 2 (including traffic management and maintenance costs): 9 replace reinforced concrete b r i d g e - s 9 strengthen existing bridge using tensile steel s t r i p - s 9 strengthen existing bridge using carbon fibre s t r i p - s
There were 80 applications in the UK in 1998 for strengthening bridge structures using composites, and 6 km of carbon fibre and glass fibre plates were used in the same year to strengthen 50 bridges. This is an indication that the most effective commercial future for composites in this area is on repair, rehabilitation and retrofitting, and not on the new, intensely competitive applications. Building a body of experience in the repair area could then provide a basis for new work. Switzerland The 'Storkenbrucke' bridge over the railway line at Winterthur, Switzerland, is a cable-stayed bridge in which two of the 24 steel cable stays have been replaced by carbon fibre in an epoxy matrix as an experiment. Stesalit AG, Zullwil, manufactured the carbon fibre wire, and the CFRP stays were a joint venture between BBR and the Swiss Federal Materials Testing Laboratory, Dubendorf. The Testing Laboratory will monitor the cable stays over several years.
As with the UK, much of the development has resulted from the interest of companies such as Sika, Switzerland, and organizations such as the Swiss Federal Materials Testing Laboratory rather than the federal authorities. France There has been very limited use of composites in road and bridge work, with an application on the bridge of an autoroute near Paris. There have been tunnelstrengthening exercises (by Rocksoil, Italy) at Frejus and in the Tartaiguille tunnel on the Marseille-Lyon TGV line.
Denmark The innovative footbridge over the railway line at Kolding was largely the result of developments by LM Glasfibre, which had undertaken and paid for much of the research. However, there have been few other developments. Much of Denmark's very effective efforts in composites have been commercial operations directed at the wind energy market.
Norway In Spring 1998 Norway acquired its first composite bridge, which was combined with a bearing construction of steel. The bridge, deck, gangway and guardrail are made from glass fibre reinforced polyester and the bridge deck is a sandwich construction with a core of expanded PVC foam and laminated with glass fibre reinforced polyester.
Italy
There has been little road and bridge work in Italy using composites, except for the use of composite poles in street furniture and lighting systems. However, both
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
39
2
Industrial applications
FRP and CFRP have been used for tunnel reinforcement and rehabilitation. The work using glass fibre has been very successful technically and has been established largely through the influence of Professor Pietro Lunardi of Rocksoil S.p.A. The sophisticated technology has been used in those geological areas where tunnelling has failed, including the Santo Stefano tunnel on the GenoaVentimiglia line, the Tasso tunnel on the Rome-Florence line and the Vasto tunnel on the Ancona-Bari line.
2.1.3 Southeast Asia including Japan In much of Southeast Asia (outside Japan) there are few, if any, composite applications for roads and bridges, although this is an area that is in desperate need of both new structures and the repair of existing ones. The one major exception has been the building of several composite footbridges in China where the speed of erection was an advantage. The problem for Southeast Asia is the high initial cost in using composites rather than the cheaper conventional methods. Maintenance is not yet considered within the costing structure, partly due to low labour costs. In addition, although much of the area has a maritime climate, there are no weather conditions that require de-icing salts. The exception in Southeast Asia has been Japan, which has the combination of earthquakes, a maritime climate leading to salt corrosion and a sophisticated industry with several of the world's largest carbon fibre manufacturers. Nippon Steel (formerly Tonen) produces Forca T M carbon fibre sheet, whilst Mitsubishi produces Replark T M sheet and Toray has a wide range of carbon fibre products. One application has been in the strengthening of the tunnels used by the Shinkansen 'Bullet' train, where the concrete had showed serious deterioration. Sumitomo has reinforced concrete bridges with pre-stressed aramid FRP-vinyl ester rods. Following the Kobe earthquake considerable reinforcement was undertaken on the piers of road bridges. Some industry statements indicate that Japan may have the largest number of examples of road and bridge w o r k - about 100 projects. However, construction work in Japan is often politically motivated and projects are rarely awarded to foreign companies.
The corrosion-resistant properties of composites are excellent and they have wide application in such areas as chemical processing, wastewater, power generation, and pulp and paper production. This last market gives some indication of the demand outside the markets in developed countries as it has been estimated that China and Southeast Asia require an extra 22 million tonnes of paper and pulp production a year. The would result in a large n u m b e r of bleaching towers, washer drums and hoods, effluent piping, sack, scrubbers and storage tanks, with a high proportion of components made from corrosion-resistant composites which could be unsaturated polyesters (UP) or vinyl esters. Also in Southeast Asia there is a growing demand for wastewater treatment plants that require covers and linings; an example is given in Chapter 6 in a case study of an application in Singapore.
40
Composites in Infrastructure - Building New Markets
2
Industrial applications
Fibre reinforced thermosets are used particularly in corrosive and acidic environments. They are also used in applications requiring lightweight design, flame resistance and thermal insulation. Corrosion-resistant equipment comprises some 12% of the reinforced composite market, and growth has been stagnant since the end of 1998. However, the US market should show growth to the end of 2000 as US federal regulations are now requiring the paper and pulp industry to replace its use of chlorine with chlorine dioxide and hydrogen peroxide by the end of 2000, which is giving increased sales of corrosion-resistant products. The cycle may follow that for tanks once the replacement process is completed. The corrosion-resistant market for composites is the third largest composite market in the USA, with 180000 tonnes in 1999, and should grow at some 2.5% per annum (Table 19). Within corrosion resistance, about 66% of applications are for moderate requirements and 33% of applications are for high-resistance requirements often found in the pulp and paper industry. When considering all corrosion resistance including pipelines, tanks etc., in the global market the premium corrosion-resistance market is small at about 90 000 tonnes compared with the overall market for UP in this sector which is some 680 000 tonnes. Power generation is also a potential growth market for corrosion-resistant p r o d u c t s as industry deregulation has led to a greater demand for efficiency in power production as companies are required to produce energy in a more costeffective way. Refitting of the stations will require both polyester and vinyl ester systems. Typical applications include stacks, ducts and chimneys, demister blades, scrubber slurry and circulating pipes, handrails, staging and gratings, as well as tanks. Gratings, often made by pultrusion, are a considerable market in the USA. Depending on the degree of corrosion resistance and/or fire resistance required, the resin materials used in ascending order of corrosion resistance are isophthalic polyester, orthophthalic polyester and vinyl ester with phenolic resins used for fire/smoke safety. One area of corrosion resistance that has proved a steady market for FRP is gratings and handrails in chemical industries with increasing use in marine environments subject to saltwater corrosion. Strongwell is a major supplier of FRP gratings for both the chemical industry and offshore applications using the pultruded process, and Composite Structures International, Dallas (formerly Fibergrate Corp) considers the moulding process with 35% glass fibre loading to offer good corrosion resistance. The most commonly used resin is isophthalic polyester, although phenolic resins may be used for fire/smoke resistance. Cooling towers are a major market for fibre reinforced plastics with most of the FRP towers manufactured from GFRP. A major cooling tower such as the Commonwealth Edison Joliet plant in the USA will use over 100 000 linear m of pultruded glass fibre profile. The world's largest company for the FRP business is Global Water Technologies' Psychrometric Systems, USA, followed by Hamon
Table 19 Corrosion-resistant market for composites in the USA 1999-2005 (O00s tonnes) ,
1999 ,,
180
..
,,
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
185
190
194
198
202
206
,,
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
41
2
Industrial applications
Thermal, Belgium, which is also making inroads into the USA market. It is notable that of the lengthy list of cooling towers supplied by Hamon only a few are manufactured from FRP and most of these are in the USA. However, there is increasing interest in Europe, and DSM have replaced some of their cooling towers with FRP products manufactured by Hamon. Bedford Composites, Pennsylvania, has supplied the basis of a cooling tower at Barrick Goldstrike Mines, Nevada, made from pultruded profiles. The water p u m p e d from the mine at 65000 gallons per min is reduced from 60 to 4~ before discharge into the Humbolt River. There are wide variations in the estimates of the world market for FRP cooling towers. US estimates give a figure of some US$250 million, of which between US$100 million and US$125 million is in North America and the rest is divided between Europe and the rest of the industrialized world. However, European estimates are for a global market of US$60 million, which is 10% of the world market for all types of cooling tower. Within that figure of US$60 million some 7% is the European market and 12% is the US market. The greater use of FRP cooling towers in the USA is mostly a reflection of the lower costs of FRP pultruded products due to lower energy costs. In the light of figures for 2000 for composite cooling towers in China, the US figure is probably more accurate but a much higher proportion should be ascribed to Southeast Asia. The total market for UP in China is some 270 000 tonnes per annum, of which about 220000 tonnes is used in FRP cooling towers. Production figures from China should be treated with some caution as there are reported to be a large number of small production plants but only about 20 large companies. However, this would give a market in Asia second only to Japan, where UP use is some 410 000 tonnes and the Chinese market is growing at a faster r a t e - about 8% per annum. In the rest of Southeast Asia the market for UP is some 70 000 tonnes per annum. Large amounts of capacity were being installed before the Asian economic crisis but some of that has n o w been postponed. When the surplus production is absorbed there will be a further increase in the number of chemical manufacturing plants (including polyester) and this will be seen in the increased demand for corrosion-resistant products.
2.3 Pipelines and tanks Composite materials have been used by pipeline industries for several decades both for potable water, sewage treatment, power generation, and oil and chemical transport, and they have a long history of reliability. Extreme soil conditions (pH 1-2 with sulphate softs or pH 9-12 in alkaline conditions) can cause degradation, but polymers show good estimated life in 'normal' conditions. Although pipelines and tanks have a long history of plastics use at present, FRP pipes account for only 2% of the total world pipe market with most pipes constructed in cheaper concrete, steel or non-reinforced polymers. Much of the plastics market is non-reinforced materials for such areas as domestic supplies, and these do not come within the remit of this report. As an example 95% of newly laid pipes in Switzerland are plastic but the majority of these are made from PVC. Steel or stainless steel is still the first choice for industrial reservoirs, tanks and pipelines, and many in the oil and gas industry consider steel the only
42
Composites in Infrastructure - Building New Markets
2
Industrial applications
acceptable and safe transport medium for their flammable and contaminantsusceptible product. However, Engineered Pipe (part of Owens Coming) supplies some 500 km of large-diameter composite pipe in Europe each year, and some of that is used for petroleum deliveries. Hobas, Austria, delivers slightly less, including some 150 km in the USA, usually of a smaller diameter and, again, covering a range of products. Companies such as Future Pipe (formerly Wavin) and Ameron specialize in the supply of heavy-duty pipe, frequently manufactured from epoxy resin and used within the petrochemical industry. The downturn in business in the oil industry has led to a decrease in orders for this area. The Gulf States have a FRP pipe capacity of 70 000 tonnes per annum covering both water and oil products. The world pipe market is estimated at US$600 million and this is rising at about 2% per annum. Within the industry major suppliers such as Engineered Pipe have worldwide sales of US$65 million and the US sales for Hobas are US$45 million (Engineered Pipe does not sell in the USA). The companies have about 35-40% of the combined US and European markets. The US pipe industry required 1300 million m of pipe in 1999, but much of that is for non-reinforced plastic, concrete, copper and steel. Growth for plastic pipe is predicted at 2.9% per annum, but for composite materials this will reduce to around 2% per annum. The US thermoset pipe market is estimated to require 4500 km of pipe in 2005 and this will be divided up as shown in Table 20. The US tank market showed a major fall in 1999 following considerable growth during 1998. The figures for 1998 in the USA were so high because new Environmental Protection Agency legislation required that underground steel petroleum tanks should be cathodic tested each year. The cost of such testing has led to major replacement of steel tanks by composite materials. As each tank requires about 1 tonne of composite this created a large, but short-lived, market which collapsed after the deadline date of 31 December 1998. Once the tanks are in place they will not need replacement for some years and this market in the USA will not show a major recovery in the period of this report. Europe does not have the same test requirement and, consequently, cheaper steel tanks for petroleum storage are more commonly used which indicates the effects of legislation on the composites industry. In tonnage the European market for reinforced polyester in silos, tanks and pipes is some 70 000-80000 tonnes, with about double that figure for the USA. At a loading of around 35% glass fibre this would indicate an overall figure for the USA of 200000 tonnes of composite. China uses some 5 0 0 0 0 - 6 0 0 0 0 tonnes of composites in silos, tanks and pipes (Table 21).
Table 20 Thermoset pipe market by end-user industry Market
%
Structural
10.0
Gas production
5.0
Oil production
12.0
Process industries
54.0
Drains and sewers
19.0
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
43
2
Industrial applications Table 21 Global use of composites in tanks and pipelines 1 9 9 9 - 2 0 0 5 (O00s tonnes) 1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
250
255
260
265
273
281
290
The tank industry has seen considerable numbers of company movements in recent years. Denali Inc, Houston, originally spun-off from Owens Coming, has required a major investment from a capital investment fund following losses in the third quarter earnings to March 2000. Denali's listing also moved from the Nasdaq National Market to the Nasdaq Small Cap Market from 1 May 2000. A.O. Smith has its subsidiary Smith Fiberglass up for sale and it is reported that other pipeline and tank companies such as Ameron have difficulties. It is suggested that non-reinforced products at the lower end of the market, which are used in less demanding applications, are seeing growth but that the reinforced products needed by the oil and chemical companies have declining sales, possibly related to the cyclical decline in oil production as the USA and the Middle East oilproducing states disagree on rates of production. Oil and chemicals are a major application particularly for GFRP and vinyl ester, with the latter used for its corrosion resistance. The oil and chemical industries also make some use of epoxy resin as a matrix. Shell has some 2000 km of onshore composite piping installed which greatly outweighs the volume of offshore material. Onshore, the main application for Shell is pipelines, with some tanks and vessels. The main business driver is reduced life-cycle costs through minimum maintenance. Offshore applications are more diverse including firewater mains systems, water injection systems, access structures and flexible risers. Composites are used for their corrosion resistance and their light weight, which gives greater ease of handling and reduced overall structural weight. Again, the business driver is reduced life-cycle cost. Composite piping systems for fire mains and other applications begin to replace copper-nickel and other alloy materials such as super Duplex T M stainless steel. The system competes well on straight runs but there is little or no saving in complex situations. However, the overall viability is much improved when factors such as weight, life and improved fire performance are taken into account. Consequently, Conoco, British Gas, Amoco, Shell and Philips have installations that are under consideration or under construction. There are early signs of some interest in carbon fibre reinforced materials in the oil industry, which is surprising as carbon fibre is electrically conducting and would normally be avoided. However, CFRP is used in accumulator bottles in the Gulf of Mexico deep-water oil wells and a research project is looking at its use in pipelines to the drill head as a communication capacity can be incorporated for the transmission of data. Shell has also indicated an interest in carbon fibre reinforced pipes as the electrical conductivity would allow static electricity (a possible cause of explosions) to be dissipated on oil figs. The major hydrocarbon use for GFRP pipes is the transmission of wet oil (oilwater mixtures) cross-country, and these are found in all oil-producing areas Middle East, Europe and North America. Composites are attractive for their corrosion resistance and their life-cycle cost compared to carbon steel. Some
44
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
2
Industrial applications
applications call for an internally and/or externally coated carbon steel pipe and polyethylene-lined carbon steel will operate up to 60~ Epoxy matrices will operate over 60~ but there are pressure limitations; a few high-temperature applications use polyamide. In potable water, which is a major use for pipelines, Reichholds's DION VERT M 9102-00 coating system has been certified by NSF International under the stringent NSF-61 for potable water applications, making this the only vinyl ester approved to this standard rather than through the use of special coatings. Most GFRP pipes are filament w o u n d with centrifugal casting used for very small pipes. Engineered Pipe manufactures mostly 900 mm pipe, with Hobas producing a slightly narrower diameter at 400-500 mm. The Canadian company Comptank Corp, Ontario, proved to the authorities responsible for the European Agreement on International Carriage of Dangerous Goods by Road that FRP tanks could out-perform the traditional rubber-lined tankers. Working with Clayton Commercial, UK, a tanker was produced made from Derakane 411 epoxy vinyl ester using hand lay-up and filament winding. The tanker holds 27 000 1, and is used for the transport of chemicals and hazardous materials.
Composites are used in power generation for their corrosion-resistant qualities and that area is covered in Section 2.2. However, an important and rapidly growing market for composites is their use in the manufacture of wind turbine blades (Table 22). The global wind energy market is estimated at US$3 billion with about half that market being held by the Danish wind turbine industry, which has a healthy home market and also exports about 75% of production. The rotor blade accounts for some 20% of the cost of the turbine and thus this market is worth - on a global basis - some US$600 million, growing at 20% per annum until 2002-2003 and possibly at a lower rate in later years as the number of suitable wind sites reduces. The German Federal Association for Wind Energy reports that 1674 new wind turbines were installed in Germany in 1999 with a total output of 1569 MW, almost double the output for 1998. Germany leads the world, followed by Spain with 650 MW and Denmark and the USA joint third with 300 MW each. Germany now has an installed base of nearly 8000 turbines with a total power output around 4450 MW; this gives a growth of over 50% since 1998. Spain has a rapidly growing wind-energy market and the 650 MW installed in 1999 means that the northern province of Navarre obtains 30% of its electricity from wind. Denmark
Table 22 Projected global growth for wind turbine blades by volume and value, 1999-2005 (O00s tonnes and US$ millions) 1999 Volume (tonnes) Value (US$)
2000
40
48
700
840
2001 57.5 1008
2002
2003
2004
2005
70
84
101
121
1210
1452
1597
1757
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
45
2
Industrial applications
has a high ratio of power to population at some 0.3 kW per capita and the building of a large offshore scheme is due to begin during 2000. Studies indicate that the world can supply 53 000 TWh of electricity per year, which is four times larger than the consumption of electricity by the entire world in 1998. However, there are now problems in finding new sites and many new turbines are a replacement for smaller output machines. The German increase is partly based on an increase in turbine output from758 to 937 kW in 1999 as larger turbines replace smaller output devices. On the positive side, the recent decision of the German government to phase out nuclear power may place greater emphasis on 'green' energy generation including wind power. Placement of wind turbines on the landscape has caused problems; the UK with one of the best wind regimes in Europe has only a very small number of installations due to protests by nearby residents of potential sites. The wind industry is increasingly considering the establishment of offshore wind farms as the way forward, and a scheme off the coast of Denmark will begin construction in 2000 with a further one to follow off the Northumberland, UK, coast. Other offshore plants are planned for Germany, T h e Netherlands, Sweden, Ireland and France. Costs for wind-power production are now approaching those for coal-fired power stations w h e n favourable pricing regimes are included. At good wind sites, wind energy is fully competitive with new traditional fossil fuel and nuclear generation. Denmark reports that the cost of wind energy fell by two-thirds between 1981 and 1995 based on increases in production and favourable pricing regimes. Studies indicate that the current cost of wind energy is US$0.047/kWh declining to US$0.3/kWh by 2013 and US$0.25/kWh by 2020, which competes with m o d e m large-scale hydro plants. In developing countries with power shortages it is possible to install wind turbines quicker and to provide a decentralized source of energy. Simple wind turbines can be found at the gers of nomadic herders in Mongolia as movable power supplies. The wind energy associations in Europe and the USA give a figure in excess of 3000 MW of new wind-generating capacity installed in 1999. This represents an increase of 30% over the 1998 figure. A global figure of 23 500 MW predicted for 2005 would equate to a consumption of 121000 tonnes per annum of composites. The USA has continued its revival as a wind-energy market with a surge of development across the country. California has a number of wind farms and the largest wind farm in the world - 193 MW at Storm Lake, Iowa - has been officially opened. The favourable pricing regime with tax credits is legislated to continue to the end of 2002. China and India had some development with about 78 MW installed in China in 1999. Statistics are varied and growth rates are uncertain when one large project gives an annum growth rate of 40-50%. India has a reputation for preferring large-scale energy projects from a central organization. However, there are predictions that wind-generated electricity in India will increase to 1150 MW by 2000. Installed wind-energy capacity has increased by 40% in six years and the installed capacity in Europe now meets the energy needs of 5 million people. The industry aim is 40000 MW of installed capacity by 2010 to meet the energy needs of 50 million people. Denmark currently meets its aim of 10% of electricity production through wind generation and n o w aims for 50% by 2030.
46
Composites in Infrastructure - Building New Markets
2
Industrial applications
The installed capacity in Europe over recent years is: 9 9 9 9 9
19951996199719981999-
2529 3496 4695 6430 8900
MW; MW; MW; MW; MW.
Environmental concerns have provided a considerable impetus to wind-energy developments. Much of the world manufacturing is centred in Denmark with NEG Micron AS holding 16% of global wind turbine production (after a poor year in 1999) and Vestas Wind Systems AS holding 23.4%. Enron Wind Corp (part of the major US energy company Enron) holds 16.3% and Enercon, Germany, has 12.8%. Denmark exports 75% of its wind turbine production and is reported to hold over 50% of the US$3 billion global wind turbine market. One company, LM Glasfiber, has produced more than 36000 wind turbine blades since 1978 and claims 45% of the global market for turbine blades. Blades have grown from a length of 8 m producing 50 kW to 34 m producing 2 MW. A new blade with a length of 38.8 m will shortly be producing 2.5 MW at a site near Dusseldorf. At a typical tip speed of 100 miles/h and with the masts at over 100 m (ground-tovertical tip distance), frequently located in coastal regions subject to high levels of pollution, the performance demands are severe. Rapid temperature changes, even ice build-up, as well as erosion from rain, hail and snow, can exacerbate conditions. Consequently, blade specification continues to undergo radical change from the initial open mould chopped strand mat-woven r o v i n g orthophthalic polyester c o n s t r u c t i o n - which is still used. Later developments use resin injection with more sophisticated glass reinforcements and vinyl ester moving to pre-impregnated epoxy reinforcement with their different fabrication and cure requirements. Stiffer blade designs mean that carbon fibre is now being considered. Vestas originally manufactured blades by hand lay-up but changed to using prepregs and vacuum-assisted resin transfer moulding (RTM) in the 1990s. One driver for the change, in addition to performance, in production process has been the need to reduce styrene emissions. Another Danish manufacturer, LM Glasfiber, uses a vacuum-infusion RTM process. The rotor blade accounts for some 20% of the cost of the turbine. Longer rotor blade length - 50-60 m - will provide a potential market for carbon fibre as the blades need higher stiffness than can be achieved with glass fibre. When looking at the optimum balance between cost-stiffness-weight a heavy-tow carbon fibre is attractive and infusion techniques now make it possible to use heavier fabrics to save production time. The cost of carbon fibre still limits the application but in 2000 SP Systems, now part of Zoltek, demonstrated blades using carbon fibre in structural spars. In 2000 about 13 000 MW of power will be produced from wind turbines and this should rise to 35 000 MW by 2005, which would require nearly 80 000 tonnes of composites. Further growth is limited by site availability and the potential for offshore wind farms. Increasing blade lengths could change the type of materials used. The market for wind turbines can show very large annual variations resulting from a single large contract. As an example India had 2.8% of installations in 1996 but none in subsequent years. The wind turbine market is also heavily influenced by government pricing of power, giving percentage installations in the USA in 1996 and 1997 of 2.4%, which leapt to 13.5% in 1998.
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
47
2
Industrial applications
FRP composite piles offer solutions both to maintenance and to environmental problems. As an example, the US Federal Water Pollution Control Act of 1972 has lead to a rejuvenation of the marine environment in New York Harbor. However, with this has come a return of marine borers such as the Teredo worm. Many of the harbour piers are supported on untreated timber and, in some cases, 90% of untreated wood piling has been consumed in one year. Concrete and steel piles are considered too stiff for fendering operations for boats, making polymer composites an ideal choice. In addition, creosote- and chromated copper arsenate (CCA)-treated timber is considered environmentally damaging and may pose a threat to marine life and to waterside workers. It is estimated that the repair and replacement of concrete, steel and wood piling systems costs the USA US$2 billion per annum. Piling from Hardcore Composites has been used by the US Army Corps of Engineers facility in New Orleans and on the Bay Authority Pier End Project on the Delaware River. Creative Pultrusions, the major US composite manufacturer, has produced a pultruded glass fibre-vinyl ester piling product in such demonstration projects as Berth 7 in Port Newark, New Jersey, and the Tiffany Pier Project, New York. The US Navy has now undertaken three projects on the use of composites to upgrade pier and wharf structures. The latest project is the Naval wharf Bravo 25, Pearl Harbor, which uses pultruded carbon fibre as 1 cm rods applied to the reinforced concrete slabs. The carbon fibre was Toray's T700, pultruded by DFI Composites and covered with MBrace CRFP sheet material from Master Builders. The use of composite materials in piling operations has four main disadvantages: 9 Q 9 9
it is more costly than using creosote-treated wood; it is less efficient to drive than conventional piling materials; the long-term performance is not fully established; and FRP has a low modulus and, consequently, deformations may occur in excess of that permitted by the building regulations.
In line with expenditure on roads and bridges, the USA is also spending a considerable sum on the repair and updating of its port and harbour facilities. The figures for the last five years are given in Table 23. A sum of some US$800 million should be included for other national port facilities. The main participants are Seaward International (responsible for the piling) and, from the composites industry, Hardcore Composites, Tonen (now part of Nippon Steel), which produces carbon fire sheets working with Structural Preservation Systems, and Mitsubishi Chemical which produces the Replark T M carbon fibre sheet-strengthening systems. An unusual composite application, which falls between several categories, was the work that DCN Lorient, France, undertook for Voies Navigable de France, which is restoring the French canal system. France has a very extensive network of canals that were originally built to link the river systems and transport goods. However, as in other countries, the canals are now largely used for tourism. The w o o d e n and steel lock gates have rotted or deformed over the years and DCN Lorient has been replacing them with composite gates that will require little or no maintenance drawing on its experience in waterfront structures. The gates are manufactured from glass reinforced isopolyester and manufactured by hand lay-
48
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
2
Industrial applications
up in open moulds to create a solid un-cored laminate reinforced with woven glass fibre fabric. There is localized special reinforcement to meet extra stress. The composite parts are installed in a stainless steel frame and the total weight reduction is 50% of conventional units, making them easier to ship and handle.
Table 23 Spending on US ports 1996-2000 Port
1996-2000 (US$ billions)
Los Angeles
1.3
Long Beach
1.23
Seattle
0.485
Georgia Ports Authority
0.447
Houston
0.311
New York
0.231
Miami
0.203
Port Everglades
0.197
Tacoma
0.196
New Orleans
0.194
Total
4.794
An early use of composites in an offshore application was the strengthening of grid line 3 on the Mobil Beryl B offshore platform in 1995. The project increased the blast capacity of two walls by threefold. Although the cost of the carbon fibre composites was high, this was offset by the saving in labour costs as the work was achieved in 500 man days compared with 2500 for the next best alternative. Cost savings of over 50% were made using the composite method and, in addition, the work was completed without having to shut down production. A major application for GFRP pipes is in the firewater mains on oil rigs, including the sprinkler heads. Glass reinforced epoxy pipework has been shown to have a lower through-life cost than such competing materials as Duplex stainless steel, cunifer and titanium. Carbon steel is corroded by seawater and this would also clog the heads of the sprinkler systems. Of the materials in general use - epoxy, vinyl ester, Modar TM, polyester and acrylic - e p o x y has the highest mechanical properties, toxicity and cost, whilst phenolics have the lowest mechanical properties, toxicity and cost but the best fire/smoke properties, and the other materials occupy an intermediate position. ABB Offshore Technology uses FRP for sub-sea well protection covers, which protect oil well heads from falling debris. Traditionally, such covers have been made of steel and concrete but both these materials can suffer from corrosion and fatigue due to the arduous conditions found at the seabed. The FRP covers are made in open moulds from isopolyester resins supplied by Reichhold and DSM, and fabric matting from Brunswick Technologies (now renamed Saint GobainBTI). The material costs for the composite covers are higher than for steel but manufacturing costs offset this with a 20-30% saving. As the structures are 40% lighter than steel, transport and installation costs are lower and the light weight
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
49
2
Industrial applications
means that the covers can be positioned using remotely operated vehicles - an important consideration for installations that are as deep as 330 m below the sea surface. Norway's offshore oil industry has been responsible for some innovative approaches to the use of non-traditional materials on oil rigs, including the Anaconda piping system developed for Statoil, Norway, by Halliburton Energy Services (previously Wellstream-Halliburton Subsea Systems) and Fiberspar Spoolable Products. The system uses carbon fibre reinforced epoxy umbilical piping manufactured as a continuous coil with a liner of polyvinylidene difluoride (PVDF) and has e m b e d d e d conductors that relay two-way data between a control centre and the sub-surface assembly.
2.7 Public utilities There is a small market with potential growth opportunities in utility poles. There are currently an estimated 130 million wood poles in use in the USA, of which about 1.5 million are electricity distribution poles. However, of the total number, only 1.5% of all utility poles are made from steel, concrete or composite m a t e r i a l just less 2 million poles. Most of this number is made from steel or concrete with only a few thousand made from composites. Wooden utility poles for electricity, telecommunications and lighting all require maintenance and replacement on a regular basis. Within the UK, telecommunication poles awaiting replacement may be designated as dangerous for service engineers to climb and any work to be done requires the use of lifting hoists, which can delay repairs. In addition, the poles at the sides of roads are a source of death or injury in the event of motor accidents. Several companies have now produced poles which snap-off in such accidents. Wood, steel and concrete poles are all subjected to considerable wear due to adverse weather, fungi, woodpeckers, wind and ice loads, and vehicle accidents. Wood poles have a service life of some 20 years and require continual inspection and maintenance. A Douglas Fir pole weighs 1200 lbs, whereas a composite pole will weigh only about 40 lbs. Concrete poles have lower maintenance but the weight can increase transport and placement costs by as much as 60%. Steel poles cost less in transport and placement but must be painted or galvanized to prevent corrosion. FRP is one-fifth the weight of steel but six times as strong giving a long service life. Most composite poles are made from E-glass unsaturated polyester with a surface veil to protect the material from ultraviolet radiation. Safety is also a favourable consideration in the introduction of composite products. A survey in North America found that the wood preservatives creosote, pentachlorophenol and copper chromium arsenate (CCA) are used to treat w o o d e n utility poles in the USA. The organization Beyond Pesticides considers that a preliminary review obtained from the Environmental Protection Agency indicates that the use of this and similar chemicals has serious effects on children exposed to the chemicals, including risk of cancer. The Italian and North American markets have seen strong interest in the use of composite utility poles, with pultrusion as the favoured manufacturing approach in Italy and filament winding in North America. Experimental investigations have looked at GFRP transmission utility poles, and studied the statistics of thickness, glass percentage, tensile modulus and tensile strength which seem to indicate that
50
Composites in Infrastructure - Building New Markets
2
Industrial applications
it is better to rely upon the effective stiffness in the design of GFRP poles. A further advantage is that the poles can be manufactured with a mechanism that allows the pole to collapse and be reinstated in the event of collision with vehicles. Companies such as Top Glass, Italy, Shakespeare, USA, and ISIS/Faroex, Canada, have entered this market. There are currently several thousand composite utility poles in service worldwide but, despite their advantages, the poles are more expensive than w o o d e n poles and this is still a small market. The US Department of Commerce has funded a project with two electric utilities, Southern California Edison Co and San Diego Gas & Electric Co, in which Ebert Composites Corp has produced a lightweight 2.6 m high-voltage electricity transmission tower. The tower is constructed from glass-vinyl ester and the snaptogether pultruded profile structure, which needs neither adhesives nor mechanical fixtures, has a total weight only one-third that of steel. The installation is on the Pacific coast and is subject to heavy salt contamination.
There is considerable investment taking place and planned for rail transport (including metro systems) in the next few years. The lack of investment in previous decades must now be redressed and this goes with a move towards lightweight, high-strength and comfortable carriages. Polymer Engineering Ltd, UK, has recently completed a contract to supply exterior panels worth s million for the Strasbourg Eurotram - the European light rail vehicle project developed by Adtranz; the panels were made using RTM. Adtranz, a subsidiary of DaimlerChrysler, was formed by Daimler-Benz and ASEA Brown Boveri and has 35 years experience in people-mover systems. The company has some 30 programmes on a global basis, having built six US airport transit programmes with 51 cars during 1997-1998. Adtranz uses composites in exterior end caps that close out aluminium vehicle shells and interior parts such as w i n d o w masks, equipment shells and access panels. The new bridge between Denmark and Sweden has meant that new carriages must be commissioned. Consequently, there will be growth well above the gross domestic product (GDP) growth figures but tailing off towards the end of this report period as the backlog of investment is cleared. The growth of composites in rolling stock varies between the sections of the train. Because of the improved design capability that composites gave to train designers for the shape of the front cab, composite materials were adopted at an early stage. It is n o w considered to be at optimum substitution for other materials and consequently any growth in the use of composites in this area will only come from a growth in rolling stock production. Global increases in rolling stock production are considered to be of the order of 2.5% per annum (Table 24). In other areas of trains there is greater opportunity for substitution, particularly with the second-generation, fire-resistant phenolics following recent train accidents. In the UK and The Netherlands train and metro fittings are required to meet fire and smoke standards equivalent to the M1 and F1 ratings; that is, selfextinguishable without production of toxic smoke. Thus, composite materials will see a greater growth rate of around 6% per annum. However, in addition to the phenolics, there is a growing market for reinforced acrylics such as Modar TM as
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
51
2
Industrial applications Table 24 Global use of thermoset composites in rail transport 1 9 9 9 - 2 0 0 5 (O00s tonnes) 1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
155
166
178
190
203
215
228
they have greater adhesive strength than polyester, which requires less resin, and thus reduces the cost of the final composite. In addition, it is possible to use greater amounts of fire retardant with acrylics without compromising the strength of the final product, but acrylics have the disadvantage of accepting lower levels of reinforcement. Phenolics need special finishing requirements such as paints or gel-coats. Developments in fire-retardant polyesters are still not displacing the phenolics. Most fabrication techniques have potential in this area, including filament winding such as the Schindler Waggon technique for moulding a one-piece railway carriage body shell in nine working days at a lower cost than other fabrication techniques. As the use of double-decker trains increases, lightweight solutions that use sandwich construction of an epoxy prepreg aramid reinforcement over a PVC foam core allow rapid assembly and meet fire regulations. The European market for reinforced plastics in the rail sector is expected to grow by nearly 50% in the next five years to around 10 000 tonnes per annum. The biggest growth is expected to be in glass fibre reinforced polyester, especially for above-ground trains. Table 25 gives estimates for composite use and growth in round figures. A small amount of other thermosets are used but include a significant amount of melamine for interior panels, giving another 300 tonnes to the total figure growing at around 7.5% per annum. The main thermoplastics are polycarbonate and polyamide with similar amounts of each. Some geographical variations are found, for example the UK favours phenolic materials in some applications that would use polyester on mainland Europe. One factor which could improve the growth rate is the increased use of doubledecker trains, which would call for greater use of composites and is predicted for the latter part of the time period with growth in such materials as epoxies with carbon fibre reinforcement used for the flooring.
Table 25 European growth in composite use for rolling stock 1 9 9 9 - 2 0 0 5 (tonnes) 1999
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
Polyester
5850
6150
6450
6750
7020
7300
7520
Phenolics
580
630
680
730
800
840
885
Epoxies
120
130
140
150
160
170
180
Vinyl esters
50
50
55
55
60
65
70
Acrylics
55
60
65
70
75
80
85
Thermoplastics Total
52
2000
700
750
800
860
900
945
995
7355
7770
8190
8615
9015
9400
9735
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
2
Industrial applications
Mektech Composites Inc has developed a polyester gel-coat which is compatible with its Cellobond T M phenolic resins, and its low flame spread and smoke toxicity properties make it attractive for mass transit applications. A major application in mass transport which was not rolling stock was the 400 km of cable trays used in the Channel Tunnel which required some 2000 tonnes of pultruded profiles. However, such major public works are rare. A further non-rolling stock application was the construction of a composite walkway in the Paris Metro so that maintenance personnel and other staff could work or pass near high-voltage rails in a humid atmosphere without danger.
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
53
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Raw materials consumption
3.1 Introduction Composites are largely a function of two materials - the resin matrix and the reinforcing fibre - with a small a m o u n t of fillers, fire retardants, mould release c o m p o u n d s and other additives. Some additives are included to reduce the cost, for example fillers, and some to improve the performance, for example fire retardants, and some to improve the manufacture, for example mould release compounds. Composites may seem to have a higher initial cost than traditional materials and a comparison would be that if steel = I and aluminium = 3 then most commercial composites would be between 2 and 3.5 d e p e n d i n g on the formulation and fabrication technique. However, w h e n considering specific strength, if steel = 1 and aluminium = 1.5 then most composites would be between 1.5 and 5.0 depending on formulation and fabrication technique. If life-cycle costs are considered the balance tips even further in favour of composites. The functions and requirements of the matrix in a composite are to: Q Q Q Q Q
keep the fibres in place in the structure; help to distribute or transfer load; protect the filaments in the structure; control the electrical and chemical properties of the composite; and carry interlaminar shear.
In terms of structural needs the matrix should provide some or all of the following: Q 9 Q Q 9 Q Q 9 9 9 9
minimize moisture absorption; wet and b o n d to fibre; flow to penetrate the fibre bundles and eliminate voids during compacting/curing; transfer loads to fibres; provide strength at high temperatures; provide good chemical resistance; have low shrinkage; have a low coefficient of thermal expansion; have reasonable strength, m o d u l u s and elongation; be easily processed into the final composite shape; and have dimensional stability.
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
55
3
Raw materials consumption
Table 5 in Chapter I gives estimated market figures for the global volumes of resin and fibre in composite materials that are considered in this report. The major resins considered in this report are t h e r m o s e t s - unsaturated polyesters, epoxies, vinyl esters and phenolics. A new generation of thermoplastics such as the Fulcrum T M product from Dow Chemical will find a market in infrastructure but this will still be small in the period of this report. Thermoplastic materials still represent a lesser portion of the total composites market and are also less used in infrastructure applications. The trend towards thermoplastics, as o p p o s e d to thermosets, has not moved as fast as anticipated mostly due to the higher cost of the thermoplastic resin, the cost of the equipment and difficulties with processing. In addition, the easier recycling ability of thermoplastics, which it was felt would encourage their greater use, has not proved as great an advantage as predicted. Thermosets have also fought back with new developments that give improved properties and at lower cost. In comparing thermosets and thermoplastics various factors must be considered, including cost per unit of volume, processing, tooling, assembly, recycling, packaging, handling and functionality. In volume terms the major material used for infrastructure applications is unsaturated thermoset polyesters, largely divided between isophthalic polyester and orthophthalic polyester, and this situation will continue for the period of this report. These resins have the advantages of low cost and provide acceptable properties for most general applications. Polyester resins can be tailored chemically or by the addition of selective fillers to provide materials for specified uses including chemical and corrosion resistance, fire-retardant applications, translucency or low shrinkage. Glass fibre products usually reinforce such composites. The extensive use of polyesters is another example of the fact that industries will use a material that meets the requirements of an application at the lowest possible cost - value engineering. Materials that exceed the specified requirements and at greater cost will not be used - over engineering. Composites are inherently corrosion resistant and can show substantial cost benefits when used in aggressive environments. Glass fibre reinforced plastics (GFRP) are used extensively in chemical plant structures where they can withstand acids, alkalis or sea water. The general guide to corrosion resistance for the commonly used polymers is: Q 9 Q 9 Q 9
orthophthalic polyester (has lower corrosion resistance); isophthalic polyester; terephthalic polyester; vinyl ester; bisphenol (phenolics); and epoxy (high corrosion resistance).
This listing is simplistic as the requirements can vary between acids, alkalis, petroleum at differing temperatures. The order, when considering fire resistance, is: 9 9
polyester (burns readily); vinyl ester;
9 9
epoxy; phenolic (excellent fire resistance).
Q ModarTi;
$6
Composites in Infrastructure - Building New Markets
3
Raw materials consumption
Modar is the trade name for a modified acrylic resin produced by Ashland Chemical Co. However, despite polyester's position at the bottom of the fire-resistance list, the use of fire retardants can raise it to acceptable levels for many applications and its other advantages may outweigh the choice of another material, such as the second-generation phenolics. Fire retardants such as ATH (aluminium trihydroxide or in its commercial form as alumina trihydrate) have achieved considerable improvements in the use of polyester materials in less critical fire and smoke situations. It should be noted that although fire retardancy may be cited as a factor in specification it is often smoke emission that is the danger to life. The percentage of unsaturated polyester resin consumption in Europe is: Q Q Q Q
orthophthalic p o l y e s t e r - 62%; isophthalic resin - 17%; terephthalic polyester - 4%; vinyl e s t e r - 5%.
Italy is the largest resin consumer in Europe with some 23% of the market, followed (in order) by Germany, France and the UK. Although Italy has a flourishing composite use in engineering, much of its use is in domestic items. A wide variety of amorphous and crystalline materials can be used as fibres, with glass fibre as the most commonly used material. Carbon fibre can be used separately or in conjunction with glass fibre as a hybrid to increase the stiffness of a structural m e m b e r or the area within a structure. Aramid fibres can be used instead of glass fibres to give increased stiffness to the composite and can be used in preference to carbon fibres if there is an electrical implication - carbon is electrically conducting making it dangerous in some situations. Hybrid solutions combining dissimilar materials and manufacturing processes can sometimes be the most effective solution for an application. As an example, layers of carbon fibre can be used on the u p p e r and lower surfaces of a glass fibre reinforced structural beam section to improve stiffness and strength. A polyester resin might be used for the matrix of a structural section due to its good mechanical and processing properties; exposed surfaces of the c o m p o n e n t could be over-wrapped with a fibre reinforced phenolic layer for additional fire protection. Where the manufacturing process allows, the over-wrap thickness and stacking sequence can be tailored to suit the needs of the specific application. Although more conventional materials such as metals can be tailored, for example coated, this use of hybrid solutions demonstrates a particular attribute of composites that is beneficial in design but requires greater knowledge on the part of design engineers. The mechanical properties of composites d e p e n d on: 9 9 Q
the relative proportions of fibre to matrix within t h e matrix material; the components used to form the composite; and the method of manufacture of the composite.
Composites formed under pressure will generally have a higher fibre volume fraction than those manufactured by hand. The ratio of fibre to matrix is highly dependent on the method of manufacture and also the fibre orientation within the composite. The mechanical properties of the composite are mainly d e p e n d e n t
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
S'I
3
Raw materials consumption on the value of the fibres' modulus of elasticity and ultimate strength. The properties of the composite in use are mainly dependent on the physical properties of the polymer matrix. Glass fibre laminates have a superior impact resistance and can out-perform steel and aluminium when a blunt missile is used. A range of glass forms is available for reinforcement - rovings, mats, fabrics and fibres - giving the option to tailor the properties of the final product. Unidirectional carbon fibre has only limited ability to absorb impact energy, although adding E-glass or aramid fibres can improve this. Use of multi-axial fabrics in the construction of the composite will improve impact resistance. Aramids have the best ballistic impact performance for minimum weight and, hence, are widely used in the body armour market, and that feature means that they are now under investigation as wrappings for piers on bridges and buildings for impact resistance. General growth for reinforced thermosets in infrastructure will average about 2% per annum, although there are considerable variations between market sectors and geographical areas. Disregarding the increasing use of sheet and bulk moulding compounds (SMC and BMC, respectively) by the automotive industry, much of the previous growth in the area has come from specific and individual applications and markets. As an example considerable growth for underground tanks for petroleum storage in the USA was a result of EPA legislation and this market collapsed at the end of 1998. Major growth markets in wind turbine blades in Denmark, Germany, Spain and the USA result from pricing and tax regimes. Investment in rail transport has been encouraged by heavy traffic density in Europe, and some high-profile accidents causing loss of life have encouraged the use of fire-resistant materials. Power deregulation in the USA has encouraged power supply companies to look at inefficient methods of operation including improvements to cooling towers. The rehabilitation/repair for roads and bridges has resulted from the combination of existing structures reaching the end of their design life in large numbers following a burst of building after the World War II and increasing traffic density. Although growth rates in this last sector are high they come from a low base. Use of composites in new building will show a lower growth rate although there is potential, towards the end of the period, for FRP reinforcement bars (rebars) and dowel bars. Where there are warnings of further earthquake activity in developed areas there will be a demand for strengthening work to buildings, roads and bridges. The overall market for reinforced thermosets in 2005 will be about 2.6 billion tonnes, but only about 20% of this will be for all infrastructure applications both long-standing and innovative.
3.2.1 Unsaturated polyester (UP) resins Unsaturated polyesters can be divided into two main groups: isophthalic acidbased unsaturated polyesters (isopolyesters) and phthalic anhydride-based unsaturated polyesters (orthopolyesters), with terephthalic polyester having a small market for high corrosion resistance. Isopolyesters have better chemical resistance than the basic orthopolyesters and demands for improvements in
58
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
3
Raw materials consumption
finished performance standards are leading to a move towards isopolyesters. Isopolyester has been used in a n u m b e r of bridge structures including the Aberfeldy Bridge in Scotland (113 m long), Olympic Bridge, Olympic National Park, Washington (49.5 m long) and Tech21, Ohio (10 m long). The Snap-Tite T M composite jackets used for strengthening concrete beams are made in isopolyester. Isopolyesters are used in 75% of pultruded products in North America. The basic chemistry offers considerable flexibility covering many h u n d r e d standard or specialized grades. The growing use of dicyclopentadiene (DCPD) as an alternative to phthalic anhydride and moves to reduce the styrene content have contributed to growth which was thought to have reached its maximum. The use of fire retardants in the resin has also made them a competitor for phenolics in special applications. The use of aluminia trihydrate (ATH) as a fire-retardant filler and other changes has enabled a low-smoke product to be developed. The remaining disadvantage in the use of ATH is that, although the aluminium portion of the molecule acts as a heat sink with the hydrate portion releasing water to reduce flammability, their smoke and toxicity levels are still inferior to the phenolics. The growing demand for composites in mass transit applications has lead DSM to work with BYK Chemie and the filler manufacturer Martinswerk to introduce a range of polyester-based SMC with fire properties that are claimed to equate with phenolics. Major manufacturers include AOC and Ashland, both producing some 200 000 tonnes per annum, with AOC having upgraded its CollierviUe plant to over 100000 tonnes per annum. DSM produces 170000 tonnes per annum, whilst Neste produces 60000 tonnes per a n n u m and is to double the polyester resin facility at Porvoo, Finland, to 40 000 tonnes per annum in the summer of 2000 giving a total capacity throughout the world of 80 000 tonnes per annum. Reichhold, part of DIC, Japan, acquired Jotun Polymer, Norway, which had also been an innovator in the use of low styrene products. The unsaturated polyesters can be used in a wide range of both reinforced and non-reinforced products such as polymer concrete and simulated marble; the wider range of applications helps to smooth out the cyclical swings in demand. Most polyester resin is used in fibre production and only about 7% of total thermoset resin consumption in Europe in 1999 was for UP (Table 26).
Table 26 Unsaturated polyester (UP) resin consumption 1999-2005 (O00s tonnes) 1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
North America
680
705
730
760
790
820
850
Western Europe
540
551
565
580
595
615
630
Eastern Europe
155
160
165
170
175
180
187
Southeast Asiaa
500
530
565
600
635
680
720
South America
125
130
135
140
145
150
155
65
68
72
75
78
82
85
2065
2144
2232
2325
2418
2527
2627
Others Total
aSoutheast Asia has high levels of polyester resin consumption but much of this is for polyester fibre and where used for composites this is for standard building and construction components.
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
59
3
Raw materials consumption
Sales of UP increased by 4% in the USA during 1999. The total North America market for reinforced thermosets is about 1.2 million tonnes but not all of this is reinforced. The construction industry was the largest consumer with 275 000 tonnes, but most of this is not for infrastructure but in building panels, bathroom c o m p o n e n t s and similar items. In infrastructure growth is running at about 3% as increases in roads, bridges, wind turbine blades and cooling towers are balanced by the decline in the market for tanks and pipelines. Corrosionresistant applications (thermoplastics and thermosets) took some 170 000 tonnes of composites in 1999 and tighter legislation means that this will continue to be a growth sector. US federal regulations now require the paper and pulp industry to replace their use of chlorine with chlorine dioxide and hydrogen peroxide by the end of 2000. This will result in an increase of shipments in this area. A reasonable estimate of thermoset composite in this market would be about 114 000 tonnes. Subject to major fluctuations in the US e c o n o m y (which are not anticipated) it is predicted that growth in North America will continue to increase at a steady rate for the period of this report. Indications in the short term are that this assessment is realistic and subject only to problems with inflation and labour shortages in the USA. Composites are part of the chemical industry that has a close link to the US economy. Volumes will continue to rise but value will show a somewhat lower increase due to the pressure on prices. This situation does seem to be easing as all the major suppliers have a n n o u n c e d price increases during 2000 that may improve profitability. The pricing pressures on manufacturers have meant that Reichhold a n n o u n c e d a price increase of US$0.03/Ib for UP in May 2000 with a further increase of US$0.03/lb from August 2000. The increased prices result from raw materials costs with crude oil costs having risen to over US$30 per barrel. The UP resin market in Europe is between 500 000 and 540 000 tonnes (probably nearer the u p p e r figure with new installed capacity) and just over 50% of this a m o u n t is used in a reinforced form. Growth in both Western and Eastern Europe is about 2-3% per a n n u m in volume. Predictions that there would be major increases in the European market for UP, after the major falls in 1991-1993, have not been realized and, in addition to modest increases in volume, prices have been squeezed to give lower profit margins with 1998 and 1999 as difficult years for manufacturers. One large market sector in Europe is silos, tanks and pipes, where DSM gives a usage figure of some 8 0 0 0 0 tonnes of UP used in reinforced form, although Reichhold would probably give a figure closer to 85 000 tonnes. Although wind turbine blades are providing attractive growth, mostly for the Danish manufacturers, Europe has not seen the same growth rates in North America and China for cooling towers possibly because the pultruded c o m p o n e n t s are more expensive to manufacture. Because energy costs in Europe are higher than North America (and will remain so) composites and their components, which require energy for their manufacture, will always be more expensive and this will give lower growth levels. In Europe about 60% of the 540 000 tonnes per a n n u m c o n s u m p t i o n of UP resin is of orthopolyester resins; 17% is of corrosion-resistant isopolyester giving a figure of some 83 300 tonnes per annum. Growth rate is just u n d e r 4% per annum. When looking at the c o n s u m p t i o n of UP it must be noted that a high proportion is used for SMC, BMC and d o u g h moulding c o m p o u n d (DMC), which find their
60
Composites in Infrastructure - Building New Markets
3
Raw materials consumption
largest markets in the automotive industry. Some 60 000 tonnes per annum was used in SMC applications in Europe and more than 26 000 tonnes per annum for BMC/DMC with both markets showing considerable growth rates. Of the UK market for UP resins 23.5% is for the building and construction industry with some 10% for pipes and tanks. Southeast Asia is a large part of the world market for UP with China taking the largest share, although the manufacturing companies admit that there is no accurate estimate of sales. However, most production is not reinforced but is directed towards the market for consumer goods and standard building products. Only small quantities of the portion that is reinforced are directed towards the infrastructure market, which is not seen as a priority. There is one e x c e p t i o n China has a considerable market for cooling towers, and tanks and pipelines also have good markets in India and China. Capacity for UPs in Brazil, the largest market in South America, is 8 0 0 0 0 85 000 tonnes per a n n u m but over-capacity is some 35% partly due to currency devaluation. Resin prices and margins are low as there are too many producers. The main market is building and construction but very little is directed to infrastructure. Although there is a considerable potential market for pipelines and for water and sewerage supply, much of this is reinforced PVC, widely used in this application in the rest of the world. Consistent growth of just less than 4% has been shown for South America, but it should be noted that this geographical area has a long history of economic volatility which has proved unpredictable.
39. 2 . 2 Vinyl e s t e r r e s i n s Vinyl esters were originally used in composite manufacture for their corrosion resistance. However, further developments are also growing due to their critical strength, which is two-three times that of standard UP resins. They have greater resistance to premature cracking within the matrix prior to the failure of the reinforcement. This greater strength has meant their use in bridge reinforcement, in marine pilings and, particularly, in wind turbine blades, where they are reinforced with glass fibre. Hybrid resins such as the DSM product Daron XP 45TM and the Derakane 411TM from Dow are being introduced. Daron XP 45 is a hybrid of vinyl ester and urethane to give a low viscous system with excellent adhesion for both glass and carbon fibre reinforcement. Reichhold markets a range of epoxy vinyl ester resins that were originally introduced when the company was Jotun Polymer. The resin, known as Norpol CorVE TM, is used in the chemical, oil and gas industries. The US manufacturers are very secretive about vinyl ester production, with major chemical companies considering the information to be commercially sensitive. However, it would be reasonable to estimate a similar percentage for North A m e r i c a - 5% of unsaturated p o l y e s t e r - as is found in Europe. This would give a market figure of some 35 000 tonnes for the USA and a growth rate of around 2%, with greater growth expected from the new materials. In Europe, vinyl esters hold about 5% of the market for unsaturated polyesters giving a figure of some 25 000 tonnes per annum with a growth rate of under 2% per annum. However, only about 13 500 tonnes of this is used in the composite
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets 61
3
Raw materials consumption industry, partly in the production of tanks and pipes which take about 8700 tonnes. Vinyl esters are mostly used in applications demanding corrosion resistance, such as chemical plants, and the UPs are taking some of this market with improved properties given by additives. The Latin American market for vinyl esters is 3500 tonnes per annum, although very little is used in reinforced form for composites; the growth rate is 2.5-3% per annum. Chile and Brazil take just over half of the output, with Mexico taking 18% and Argentina taking about half that amount. Brazil is considered to have growth potential based on corrosion-resistant applications in the chemical industry.
3.2,3 Phenolic resins Of themselves, UP resins and other thermosets such as epoxies will burn producing large quantities of smoke, carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide, with other toxic emissions. Almost every thermoset and thermoplastic resin can be given some degree of fire retardancy, although frequently at the expense of heavier smoke generation. However, the introduction of a range of new phenolic thermosetting resins in the early 1980s proved a benefit in those areas which had a high demand for fire and smoke safety, such as mass transport and offshore applications. Phenolics have one of the longest resin histories but they had not been suited to the composite fabrication techniques then in use. However, their fire hardness, high ignition temperatures coupled with the production of only clear, light smoke encouraged further development, particularly in the aircraft industry. Allied with the fire retardancy has been work on catalyst systems or phenolics to overcome problems associated with their curing or polymerization from the liquid to the solid state both at room and elevated temperatures. Phenolics cure by a condensation reaction which evolves water, which can prevent a full cure being attained and can cause difficulties in decorating the components. Unlike other thermosets, phenolics cannot use a pigmented gel-coat and have to be painted. The desire to produce fire-retardant products meant that for some time competition was found between phenolics, fire-retardant polyesters and methacrylate-urethanes, but the latter material is now litde used. However, polyesters treated with aluminium trihydroxide as a fire-retardant filler have provided strong competition and meant that the expected growth has not materialized, although phenolics are still preferred in some applications. Phenolics have been widely specified in UK mass transport systems such as the London Underground, which specify materials reaching high M1 and F1 fire and smoke safety standards. It is possible that particularly dreadful accidents (in the UK, the Kings Cross underground fire, despite having taken place over a decade ago, is still remembered) led to stronger demands for safety from all sides customers, design engineers, those responsible for financing, e t c . - to produce the same feeling as Californians have about earthquakes. Similar use of phenolics in the USA has not occurred and flame/smoke retardants are considered satisfactory. It is a depressing thought but one the composites industry might consider, that demands for higher safety and better design tend to follow rather than precede disasters. Although 39% of thermoset consumption in Europe in 1999 was for phenolics, most of this was not used in composites. The composite use of phenolic resins in Europe in 1999 was 55 000 tonnes (Table 27), a decline from the 61000 tonnes of
62
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
3
Raw materials consumption
1998, with almost all of that as glass fibre reinforced. Growth will remain stagnant for the next few years. Most phenolics are used in non-reinforced form and, as an example, reinforced phenolics were only 12% of the UK phenolic market of 73 000 tonnes in 1999, giving a figure of just u n d e r 9000 tonnes, much of this resulting from improved investment in the above- and below-ground rail systems with further applications in the offshore oil industry, which suffered a serious accident at the Piper Alpha rig during the 1980s. A combination of circumstances including declining investment in rail transport once the present levels have been completed and fewer offshore rigs will mean a declining requirement for phenolics. Table 27 Phenolic use in composites in Europe, 1 9 9 9 - 2 0 0 5 (O00s tonnes) 1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
55
55
55
54
54
53
53
3.2.4 Epoxy resins Most epoxy resins are used for adhesives and non-composite applications, and only about 2% of epoxy production in Europe in 1999 - some 4000 tonnes - is destined for composites with much of this being used by the infrastructure industry. Epoxy resins in infrastructure are used in heavy-duty applications such as special pipelines for the oil industry, wind turbine blades and bridge support systems, but their cost will restrict wider application. Composite applications needing these advanced requirements will show only small increases in the next few years, possibly rising to 3500 tonnes per annum by the end of the period of this report. As has been noted, design engineers require materials that meet, not exceed, specifications. An exception to this would be wider use of epoxies in wind turbine blades, particularly if longer blades and a decrease in carbon fibre prices lead to an increase in the amounts of carbon fibre used. The market in the USA is of a similar size to Europe - about 4000 tonnes. The smaller use in the wind turbine blades industry is balanced by the greater size of the oil industry and the number of deep offshore oil platforms that are being established in areas such as the Gulf of Mexico. Until recently, carbon fibre was always used with epoxy resin as no other combination gave the same high performance. However, DSM and others have conducted tests comparing vinyl ester and hybrid resins with epoxy using the Tenax TM carbon fibres. The Daron TM hybrid resins could compete on performance a n d had superior processing properties, but vinyl esters could not match the performance of the epoxies. Dow Chemical Co is studying three locations in China as possible sites for the production of epoxy resin. The proposed plant will become available in 20032004 and will have capacity of 40000 tonnes per a n n u m of liquid epoxy and 20 000 tonnes per annum of special resin. Dow is also increasing capacity for special resin manufacturing from 15 000 to 20 000 tonnes per annum, and in basic resins there is a planned increase of 25% with particular emphasis on brominated epoxy resin. It should be emphasized that much of this increased capacity is intended for the electronics industry.
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
6,.3
3
Raw materials consumption
Epoxy adhesive in on-site building and construction applications should reach 14.5 million tonnes in 2001 with growing use of epoxy to repair cracked concrete. The SE90 heavyweight epoxy prepreg from SP Systems (now part of Zoltek) is used for the manufacture of large structures. Very thick reinforcements can be impregnated yielding prepregs of almost 2000 g/m 2, which can be cured at temperatures as low as 85~ This means that thick lay-ups- used in wind turbine spars - can be rapidly put in position, and Vestas uses the product in single cure applications of up to 100 mm laminate thickness. Using unidirectional glass fibre compressive strengths of 1000 MPa can be achieved; a polyester or vinyl ester unidirectional hand lay-up typically achieves 600 MPa. Although originally developed for wind turbine blades, the SE90 is now also used for mould tools and boat hulls. Almost 2.5 million m 2 of the prepreg are produced annually.
3.3.1 Introduction Glass, aramid and carbon fibre reinforced composites have considerable benefits in use. As an example, fatigue performance of carbon fibre composites particularly unidirectional composites loaded in the fibre d i r e c t i o n - is generally far superior to both metals and other composites. Glass fibre composites can show an impact resistance better than aluminium and mild steel. Aramids have the best ballistic impact performance combined with low weight. E-glass is highly resistant to corrosion by most chemicals (except mild acids and mild alkalis), whilst Technora aramid has very high strength retention in both acids and alkalis (Table 28).
3.3.2 Glass fibres The global market for glass fibre is valued at US$4-6 billion, although much of this is used in glass fibre insulation and other domestic/commercial applications. The ratios in the market can be seen in figures that indicate that the total US market for glass fibre is 2.73 million tonnes, whilst the total US reinforced plastics market is 1.63 million tonnes. About 1.1 million tonnes of glass fibre is used in reinforced plastics with loadings of 60-70% in some thermoset applications.
Table 28 Mechanical properties of typical reinforcing fibres Material
64
Density Fibre diameter Elastic modulus Tensile (g/cm3) (l~m) (GPa) strength (GPa)
Carbon fibre (high modulus)
1.8
400
2-2.8
Mesophase carbon
2.02
10
7-10
300
2-2.4
E-glass
2.5
10
90
4.6
S-glass
2.6
10
90
4.6
Kevlar-29 (aramid)
1.44
12
65
3.6
Kevlar-49 (aramid)
1.45
12
130
3.6
Composites in Infrastructure - Building New Markets
3
Raw materials consumption
Table 29 Glass reinforcement market by application (%) Application
Europe
World
Textiles
17
17
Thermoplastic resins
30
21
Thermoset reinforcement
53
62
The global finished composites market is valued at US$8 billion with nearly 5 million tonnes divided between 1.7 million tonnes in Europe (rising to 1.8 million tonnes in 2005), 1.63 million tonnes in the USA (rising to 1.9 million tonnes in 2005) and 1.28 million tonnes in Southeast Asia. The latter is heavily biased towards Japan, Taiwan and South Korea with growth to 1.4 million tonnes in 2005. Glass fibre is the major reinforcement used in thermosets with about 90-95% of the market reinforcing UP resins, which have 90% of the market. The combination of glass fibres-UP resin and open mould systems holds 65% of the composite market. The glass reinforcement market is divided up as shown in Table 29. Table 30 gives some indication of the market for glass fibres as thermoset reinforcement to the year 2005. Although there is a move towards thermoplastics rather than thermosets, this has not happened as fast as predicted and thermosets hold, and will continue to hold, the larger percentage of the composites market. There is some discrepancy between figures for glass fibre production between the major manufacturers Owens Coming and Vetrotex. Vetrotex considers that glass fibre demand in the USA, the world's largest market, is expected to reach 2.95 million tonnes in 2005 with an annual growth rate of 2.2% per annum. One million tonnes of glass fibre is given for reinforcements. Production for 2005 is predicted to be worth US$5.5 billion. Owens Coming estimates the world market for glass fibre in 1999 at 2.3 m i l l i o n tonnes with an industry capacity of
Table 30 World market for glass reinforcement in thermosets 1 9 9 9 - 2 0 0 5 (O00s tonnes) 1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
North America
330
337
344
351
359
367
375
Western Europea
315
327
340
350
360
370
380
Eastern Europeb
100
104
108
112
117
122
126
Southeast Asiac
300
315
331
348
365
383
402
South America
40
42
44
46
48
50
52
Middle East
40
41.5
43
45
48
50
52
Others Total
30 1155
30.5 1197
31
1.5
32
32.5
33
1241
1283.5
1329
1374.5
1420
aBoth EU and non-EU countries. blncludes Russia. CMostly Africa and Australasia.
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
65
3
Raw materials consumption
2.8 million tonnes rising to 3 million tonnes in 2000. The Composites business unit of Owens Coming records that in 1999 it shipped 25% of the world's glass fibre with a sales value of US$284 million and profits of US$55 million. Although all infrastructure applications are included in the Owens Coming shipments, most material is for conventional construction and the automotive industries, with the latter seeing the greatest potential for growth. Vetrotex sees the division of markets for glass reinforcement as 27% in Europe, 24% in Asia, 3% in South America and Australasia, and 46% in North America. Although Vetrotex gives growth rates of 14.5% per annum for South America this is from a low base and the area is subject to considerable variations due to economic cycles. Europe has growth of 7% per a n n u m and North America 4% per annum. Asia is now seeing a recovery, although the double digit increases of the early 1990s have not returned, and when considering Southeast Asia as a whole the high growth rates in such areas as China have to be balanced by the low growth rates in Japan. Owens Coming divides the global market for glass fibre as 29% for Europe, 23% for Asia and 31% for North America. Although there is a high rate of growth for glass fibre production, much of this growth is not feeding through to FRP where growth is around 2% in Europe and slightly higher in North America. In addition, even though there has been an increase in capacity and production this has not resulted in better profits for the manufacturing companies. Allowing for inflation, the price of glass fibre per kg is virtually half the figure of the mid-1980s. The end-user may find this price level attractive but it does limit the funds available for capital investment. In the developed world it would be reasonable to expect 15% of the figures given in Table 30 to be used for infrastructure and this figure would be slightly l o w e r at about 8% - for Southeast Asia (requirements for China and India would balance lower demand in other countries). Within Eastern Europe and South America the figure will reduce to nearer 5%. The Middle East could see a higher p r o p o r t i o n 15% - as the market for pipes and tanks recovers and industrial applications that require corrosion-resistant materials are brought on-stream. The Middle East also has a considerable history of using composite materials for large-scale building projects in adverse climatic conditions of heat and high humidity. Four suppliers hold nearly 95% of the US glass fibre market - Owens Coming, Vetrotex CertainTeed, PPG and Johns Manville, which manufactures specialist insulating products. A similar situation is found in Europe. Japan accounts for 30 000 tonnes of the world's glass fibre production, which is a low figure but is reflected in the small amounts of GFRP used in the automotive industry. In general, the low growth (if any) in the Japanese economy will be mirrored by glass fibre production. The steel industry in Japan is very strong and is supported in preference to GFRP products. Within infrastructure, applications such as road, bridge, tunnel and chemical plant repair and strengthening will be undertaken with carbon and aramid fibres, which would support the strong position of the local carbon and aramid fibre manufacturers rather than glass. Japan has minimal numbers of wind turbine and cooling towers that could have produced larger market figures. China has a market for about 200 000 tonnes per annum of glass fibre but, as in other areas, Chinese domestic production of glass fibre is dominated by small producers often with an under-utilized capacity of only 5000 tonnes per annum
66
Composites in Infrastructure - Building New Markets
3
Raw materials consumption
Table 31 The glass fibre market in China 1 9 9 9 - 2 0 0 5 (O00s tonnes) 1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
216
233
252
272
294
318
344
per plant. A further difference between Chinese production and developed countries is the extensive use of the lower-quality 'middle alkali' glass made from reheating glass marbles rather than the method used by the major manufacturers of direct melting E-glass. Imported glass is used in products requiring better quality control. The projected growth rate for glass fibre production in China is given in Table 31. India is notable for the difference between capacity, production and consumption of glass fibres. Production in 1999 was 18 000 tonnes but consumption was a little over 10000 tonnes per annum with much of the surplus being exported to Southeast Asia. Capacity is over 60 000-70 000 tonnes per annum, with the major producers Owens Coming with 30 000 tonnes per annum capacity, Binani Glass Fibre, CEAT/FGP and UP-Twiga all with capacities of 10000-12 000 tonnes per annum. The projected glass fibre production growth for India is shown in Table 32. Owens Corning's manufacturing capacity in Asia is now nearly 90 000 tonnes per annum, including glass fibre roving and chopped strand mat in India and chopped strand and chopped strand-mat in South Korea. South America (including Mexico) consumes some 90 000 tonnes of glass fibre, with Brazil (30 000 tonnes) followed by Argentina (9000 tonnes). Consumption will show an increase of 2-3% per annum, mostly in the building, construction, pipeline and tank, and transport industries. The dominant position of glass fibre in unsaturated resin in all sectors including infrastructure will remain for the next decade. Even a major fall in the price of alternative materials such as aramid and carbon fibres will not displace the position of glass fibres. Fibre use is also a reflection of the structural need - if glass fibre meets the technical requirements of an application design engineers will not specify a more expensive, higher-strength material such as carbon fibre. The volumes of fibre reinforcements used are partly a reflection of their prices: 9 Q Q
glass f i b r e - US$2.2-13/kg; carbon fibre - US$19/kg (for 48 K tow fibre)-US$44/kg (for 12 K tow fibre); aramid f i b r e - US$12-50/Ib.
Table 32 Growth in glass fibre production in India 1 9 9 9 - 2 0 0 5 (O00s tonnes) 1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
17.9
22.0
23.5
25.0
27.0
30.0
35.0
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets 67
3
Raw materials consumption
Higher tow carbon fibres can be obtained at lower cost particularly with discounts for quantity. The most commonly used reinforcing fibre in infrastructure applications is Eglass. AR-glass is used in alkali and corrosion-resistant applications, R-glass is used for high mechanical performance and D-glass is used for high dielectric performance. Glass strand is produced in furnaces operating at around 1500~ (E-glass) using finely ground materials. The glass leaving the furnace is fed through bushings (blocks pierced with hundreds of holes) of platinum alloy. E-glass is highly resistant to most chemicals but is attacked by both mild acids and mild alkalis. The extensive use of glass fibre reinforcement in chemical plant is reliant on the corrosion resistance of the polymer matrix and its ability to ensure that the glass fibres do not become exposed to the environment. Other glass fibres such as ECR-glass show an improvement over E-glass in corrosive environments. Bare E-glass in distilled water retains about 65% of its short-term ultimate tensile strength after 100 days. This compares with R-glass, which has a strength retention of 75% after 100 days. Rovings, tows and fabrics are the most commonly supplied forms of fibre for infrastructure applications. Rovings and tows can produce a wide variety of reinforcing materials including mats, woven fabrics, braids, knitted fabrics, preforms and hybrid fabrics. Mats, fabrics and braids keep fibres aligned prior to resin impregnation. The fabrication advantages of fabrics and braids mean that they are moving out of the aerospace industry for which they were largely developed and into the markets held by the traditional chopped strand mats and continuous filament mats. Mats are non-woven fabrics that provide equal strength in all directions and come in two distinct forms: chopped and continuous strand. Chopped mats contain randomly distributed fibres cut to lengths typically ranging from 3.75 to 6.25 cm and held together with a chemical binder. Inherently weaker than continuous strand mats, chopped strand mats provide low-cost reinforcement. Continuous strand mat (CSM) is formed by swirling strands of fibre onto a moving belt and finished with a chemical binder that h o l d s the fibre in place. Owing to its high strength, CSM is primarily used in moulding and pultrusion processes which produce structural elements for construction. Extremely lightweight veils are often used as surfacing veils. They have an open fibre arrangement designed to accept a high ratio of resin to fibre, which produces a thick and smooth resin-rich finish. The veils can provide enhanced weather and ultraviolet (UV) protection in such applications as utility poles. Woven fabrics are made on looms in a wide variety of weights, weaves and widths. Glass and other reinforcements such as carbon can be made into hybrid arrangements combining advantages from both materials. In glass and carbon hybrids, carbon fibre can provide high strength and stiffness in the longitudinal direction, whilst E-glass provides transverse strength. One glass fibre manufacturing technique for strand and surfacing mats and veils is the Modigliani process in which molten glass is drawn from a furnace through a bushing plate and spun onto a revolving drum. Size and binder are applied to the fibres as the furnace traverses the drum. The rate at which the furnace traverses the drum controls the filament diameter and the gear racking on the drum controls the pattern in which the fibres are laid down on the drum. Once the target weight of the mat being produced has been achieved, the condensed mat is cut from the drum ready for expansion and curing in an oven. A condensed mat
68
Composites in Infrastructure - Building New Markets
3
Raw materials consumption
will expand by up to 100 times its original length. In m o d e r n manufacturing technology, computerized process technology ensures the consistent drawing of glass fibres of a known filament diameter in a pre-determined pattern to close weight tolerances.
3.3.3 Aramid fibres Aramid fibres considered in this report are para-linked aromatic polyamides that form rigid molecular chains, although there is a meta-aramid product that is used in products such as Nomex TM. The fibres become highly oriented along the direction of the axis during the spinning process used in fibre production. Fibre properties can be altered through variations in the spinning process and by the use of post-spinning heat treatments. Aramid fibres are highly crystalline and possess a low-density advantage compared to glass or carbon fibre having the highest specific tensile strength of any commercially available high-strength, highstiffness fibres. Unidirectional aramid composites have a high tensile strength of 1200-1400 MPa and a very low density (1.35 g/cm 3) making them particularly suited to use as tension members but not generally suited to bending applications. There are three main brands of para-aramid fibres - Kevlar TM from DuPont, Twaron TM from Accordis (previously Akzo Nobel) and Technora TM from Teijin. DuPont and Akzo Nobel had an expensive patent battle over the material and both companies have seen only disappointing use of a material that was very expensive to develop. The US National Research Council Continuous Fiber Ceramic Composites (CFCC) committee noted that returns on investment by DuPont in development of Kevlar TM would have been better if the money had been left in the bank! Other aramid fibres are the meta-aramids produced by DuPont under the Nomex TM trade name and Teijinconex TM, which is manufactured by Teijin. AlliedSignal manufactures an aramid-type material known as Goldflex TM in which a para-aramid purchased from outside manufacturers is processed using its polyethylene Shield TM process. Aramid fibres have exceptional flexibility and tensile strength, which makes them useful for structures that must withstand high stress and vibration. They have been used for impact barriers on motorway piers and dividers where carbon fibre would be too brittle. The two major manufactures are DuPont with production capacity of some 21000 tonnes per annum and Accordis with about half that amount. There is overcapacity worldwide and the market is divided at some 6000 tonnes per annum in Europe, 8000 tonnes per annum in North America and 30004000 tonnes per annum in Japan. Prices vary between US$12/kg for friction applications and US$ 50/kg for high-technology applications, with an average price of US$33-35/kg, to give a world market of up to US$875 million. Growth rate is only 2-3%, with potential in geotextiles and braking systems as a replacement for asbestos in cars, trucks and trains. The original application envisaged for aramid fibres was as a replacement material for tyres but aramid fibres proved too expensive and technical advances in polyethylene overtook requirements. This is yet another indication that materials will fight back to maintain market share - a point which composite manufacturers
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets 69
3
Raw materials consumption
should r e m e m b e r w h e n predicting the demise of steel and other metals. Aramid tyres are now available at s per tyre. The three Japanese manufacturers - DuPont-Toray, Nippon Aramid and Teijin are marketing aramid fibres as earthquake-proof reinforcing materials. Although demand in this growing area is dominated by carbon fibre reinforced plastic (CFRP), there are specialist structural applications where the electrical resistance of aramid can provide an extra safety margin, for instance in railway applications and other areas close to high-power lines. Aramids are available in a variety of forms including cut tow, flock and braids. Growth is likely to be in the form of hybrids of aramid with glass or carbon fibres. Such hybridization is important in overcoming the two major drawbacks of a r a m i d - high cost and difficult handling. There is growth potential with the material, although glass fibres are now able to offer many of the characteristics of aramids. A major use of aramid fibre is in personal body armour, but the material also has good resistance to crack propagation with good impact and fatigue damage properties. This is combined with high vibration damping characteristics and dimensional stability over a wide temperature range. Para-aramid materials offer good resistance to crack propagation, impact and fatigue damage together with high vibration damping characteristics and good dimensional stability over a wide temperature range. The fibres have good chemical resistance, although they are attacked and degraded by strong acids such as sulphuric, nitric, hydrochloric and phosphoric. The breaking strain for aramid fibres is substantially greater than for carbon fibres and is, in some cases, equal to glass fibre. Aramid fibres fall into two main categories in respect of chemical resistance. Paraaramid fibres, such as Kevlar 49 TM, are chemically quite stable and have a high resistance to neutral chemicals but are susceptible to attack by strong acids and by bases. However, Technora TM has very high strength retention in both acids and alkalis. Tests carried out in 40% aqueous H2SO4 at 95~ for 100 h showed 90% strength retention compared to 20% for the Kevlar materials; however, E-glass fibres would have ceased to exist under these conditions. Problems have been experienced with micro-cracking of aramid materials. Commercial aramid fibres can show moisture uptake as high as 5% u n d e r room temperature conditions, probably due to adsorbed moisture in micro-voids close to the surface of the fibres, but there appears to be little effect on the tensile mechanical properties. A further disadvantage is sensitivity to direct exposure to UV radiation; Kevlar 49 TM fabric with a thickness of 1.1 m m loses 50% of its tensile strength after a five-week exposure to sunlight. This is not a major problem in fibre-resin composite materials as the matrix resin acts as a UV screen for the underlying fibres. These problems have restricted the anticipated growth in the aircraft industry. The problems for aramid fibres have been two-fold: Q 9
70
high manufacturing and development costs including the development of complete new polymer systems and very expensive plants; and anticipated applications that either did not appear or were slow to appear.
Composites in Infrastructure - Building New Markets
3
Raw materials consumption
3.3.4 Carbon fibres There is considerable disagreement on the size and growth of the market for carbon fibres (Table 33) with some companies giving capacity figures rather than production. As many plants are only operating at 50% capacity (or less) this gives a considerable variation in output. In addition, the differences in tow sizes can impact on production figures. Figures from Toray, the largest manufacturer of small tow carbon fibre, indicate world production at around 15 000 tonnes per annum, with Toray's production at about 7000 tonnes per annum. Toray is conservative in its estimates (compared, for example, to Zoltek) but these figures are probably reasonably accurate. In addition to plant in Japan, the company also has a carbon fibre plant in Decatur, Alabama, which opened in April 1999. Mitsubishi's subsidiary Grafil has a manufacturing plant at Sacramento, California, and Toho imports fibre into the USA. The three companies probably meet about 70% of the world demand for standard tow polyacrylonitrile (PAN)-based carbon fibre, which is estimated at 10 000 tonnes per annum. Standard tow carbon fibres are mostly used in the aircraft and sporting goods industries, although there is some use in infrastructure. In predicting growth, company positions are also variable. Zoltek has placed all its efforts in carbon fibre and if the predicted growth (or greater) does not emerge the company will be in considerable difficulties. Conoco has not yet begun production and might find manufacturing difficulties as Zoltek has found with its Hungarian acrylic plant. A considerable portion of Toray's production is from SOFICAR and if aircraft orders for Airbus dry up there will be surplus capacity. The anticipated market for sports goods has not materialized and companies need to find an alternative market. Toray has announced that if it decides there is increased demand for large tow fibres (a view held by Zoltek) it will reorganize production at the plant in Ehime, Japan, to concentrate on 70 K tow fibres. The US plant will concentrate on 48 K320 K tows, with much of this supplied to US electronics manufacturers for reinforcement. Toray considers that the current demand for large tow fibres is about 2000 tonnes per annum but anticipates strong growth. The Suppliers of Advanced Composite Materials Association (SACMA; which is currently in limbo but may be re-instated) had given shipment figures for 1997 of around 13 500 tonnes coveting 85% of shipments, which would indicate an overall total of around 16 000 tonnes. The market collapsed in 1998 to 10 500 tonnes giving an overall total, with growth, for 1999 of about 15 000 tonnes, although this may be a little high. The value of these shipments was given as US$580.2 million producing an average price of US$55.4/kg. In February 2000 Toho Rayon increased the prices for PAN-based carbon fibres. Prices have fallen in the last year mostly as a result of capacity increases. Toho Rayon has responded by cutting capacity by 20% but has found a sharp increase in its costs as a result of higher prices for raw materials.
Table 33 Market for carbon fibres 1 9 9 9 - 2 0 0 5 (O00s tonnes) 1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
15
15.5
16
16.5
18
20
22
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
71
3
Raw materials consumption
The aerospace industry, which had originally been the driver in carbon fibre development, has seen a fall in consumption during 1999 with a further fall predicted for 2000. Sports and leisure use has not produced the hoped-for growth and this is now predicted to come from industrial applications, including rollers used in the print and paper industry and parts for airbags. Carbon fibre is used in infrastructure applications but only represents a very small amount. Based on the weight figures used within the industry there are indications that approximately 6.5 m of pultruded composite would require 1 kg of carbon fibre. This would give a weight of 900 kg for the 6 km of pultruded carbon fibre plates used in the UK bridge repair in 1998. Some carbon fibre has been used in rehabilitation of bridges and building, with small amounts used in specialized pipes (usually for the oil industry). If wind turbine blades continue to grow in length there may be moves towards carbon fibre for its extra stiffness, and it may also be used in some other wind turbine applications. This is presumably one reason why Zoltek bought SP Systems. However, the amounts are small even though this is a growth sector. Carbon fibre is more brittle than glass or aramid fibres and, despite a reputation for being non-corrosive, it can show galvanic corrosion when used next to metal. For this reason epoxy is normally used as the matrix for carbon fibre because it makes a good barrier. Carbon fibre reinforced pultruded profiles are somewhat lighter than the equivalent size of glass reinforced material. The most c o m m o n width for a profile is 80 mm wide by 1.2 mm thick which, at a density of 1.6 g/cm 3, gives a weight of 154 g/m. For glass fibre reinforcement a unidirectional glass would have a density of 1.9 g/cm 3 and mat or tape reinforcement would be 1.7 g/cm 3. CFRP has, in general, a better fatigue performance than both metals and other composites, particularly w h e n considering unidirectional composites loaded in the fibre direction. In such cases CFRP is relatively insensitive to tension fatigue damage even at very high stress levels. Even non-unidirectional lay-ups have better performance than such commonly used metals as aluminium 2024 T3 and 4130 grade steels. Certain unidirectional carbon fibres will give a tensile modulus of about 250 GPa, which compares with steel at about 210 GPa. However, the principle attribute of carbon fibre composites is the very high specific stiffness. A unidirectional composite using a standard product, such as Toray's T300 carbon fibre, has a specific modulus of about 80 Msi, which compares to steel at about 27 Msi. When very high modulus fibre is used a specific modulus of 160 Msi can be achieved. The consequence is that, if tensile stiffness is the design criterion, the carbon fibre composite can be several times lighter. There are other mechanical trade-offs when considering carbon fibre but the main consideration is cost. There is discussion in the industry on the most suitable material/method to be used in infrastructure rehabilitation with some difference of opinion between the use of high modulus fibres or pre-stressed components. The modulus of carbon fibre describes the degree of stiffness and can be given as: 9 Q 9 Q
72
low (or standard) - 33-35 Msi; intermediate - 40-50 Msi; H i g h - 50-70 Msi; Ultrahigh - 70-140 Msi.
Composites in Infrastructure - Building New Markets
3
Raw materials consumption
There have been many notable attempts to reduce the cost of carbon fibre which is seen to limit its industrial/infrastructure applications. The most recent target, set by Zoltek, was aiming for US$ 5/lb (US$11/kg) in 2000. This figure has not been achieved and the prediction has now slipped to 2002. The difficulty in achieving this aim without significant improvements in technology or efficiencies can be seen in the following figures. A reasonable assumption for the cost of a PAN precursor is US$1.35/Ib (US$3/kg) and with a conversion rate of 2.2 for precursor to fibre this gives a starting price of US$3/Ib (US$6.6/kg), in capital cost alone, for PAN-based carbon fibres. In March 2000 the three major Japanese carbon fibre manufacturers were investigated as a result of US complaints of price-rigging. Mitsubishi Rayon, Toho Rayon and Toray Industries with their US affiliates Toray Composites (America), Toho Carbon Fibers Inc and Grafil (part of Mitsubishi) have been under investigation since January 1999. In July 1995 Tonen of Japan announced that they had developed a unidirectional carbon fibre for improving the seismic resistance of concrete bridge structures. The material was known as Tonen Tow Sheet and comprised carbon fibre yams glued to a backing scrim of glass fibre fabric. The material has two weights - 200 and 300 g/m 2 at a thickness of 0.11--0.165 mm per ply layer. Application was by a layer of wet resin painted on the concrete surface to which the tow sheet is applied. Mitsubishi has developed a similar material known as Replark TM, but using 3% resin. In February 2000 Conoco Inc, Houston, Texas, announced that it was building a new plant in Ponca City, Oklahoma, for the production of up to 3.6 million kg of random carbon fibre mat. The pilot plant is based on a pitch by-product and produces monofilament spun mat or wool product about 60 cm wide and with a loft about 7.5 cm, although the aim for the production plant is much greater width and with variable density, thickness and properties. The Conoco material is aimed at industrial applications rather than the conventional aerospace and sporting goods markets covered by most PAN tows. It is interesting that Zoltek originally aimed for the aerospace market but withdrew to other applications. Tensile strengths for PAN-based material can be higher than required in such infrastructure applications as concrete column wrapping or fibre reinforced concrete. In such areas modulus may be more important than tensile strength. Mats also offer good dispersion in a range of matrices including concrete, plastic and asphalt. In concrete, the addition of carbon fibre mat would allow tailoring of flexural strength or ductility in such requirements as seismic or wind loading requirements. Conoco considers that the earliest use will be as chopped mat that can be mixed in a matrix; once put into pellet form it can be mixed in plastic matrices and will compete with chopped and milled continuous carbon fibres used for electrostatic discharge (ESD) and electromagnetic interference (EMI) control in such areas as electronics and computer cases. The mat product has been carded in textile forms. It is anticipated that the tensile strength of the pitch-based fibre will be in the range 250-350 ksi with modulus tailored between 35 and 120 Msi. Controlled coefficient of thermal expansion and coefficient of friction could provide applications in the braking systems of trucks and rail rolling stock. AU of these markets compete with large tow carbon fibres from Zoltek where the production processes are largely in place.
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets ?3
3
Raw materials consumption
Union Carbide developed similar mat or veil monofilament products many years ago but the business was bought by BP (now BP-Amoco) and not pursued, although BP-Amoco does produce small quantities of continuous pitch-based carbon fibre. Other manufacturers were Ashland Carbon Fibers which ceased manufacturing the product and DuPont with Petoca and Kureha in Japan. The Conoco fibre appears to have a higher performance mesophase pitch rather than earlier products that were based on the isotropic pitch. An interesting aspect of the costing of the final product can be seen in the following production figures. The plant will cost US$125 million and is predicted to begin commercial production of 3.64 million kg in the second half of 2001. The simple cost of the fibre, based on plant capacity, would be US$34.36/kg and even amortizing this over seven years still gives a manufacturing cost of US$4.9/kg, which is higher than the lowest PAN-based cost of around US$3/kg. Current output of pitch-based carbon fibres is around 3300 tonnes in Japan and 500 000 kg in the USA.
Other materials which are regularly added to composites but which are not quantified in this report are gel-coats, pigments, fillers and flame retardants. 9
9
Q
9
Q
74
Gel-coats are used as finishing coats to give a better surface finish and because glass fibre laminates do not withstand weathering, fading in UV radiation. Gelcoats cannot be used with phenolics, which must be painted. Pigments can be used as part of the basic resin or gel-coat system to give a desired colour or to block UV radiation. Some metallic salt-based pigments may lower the adhesion between fibre and matrix. Fillers are particulates which may include talc and chalk products which lower the cost of the product but must be used with caution as they may lower the long-term structural properties and durability. Flame retardants can be added in particulate or coating form and may be halogenated or non-halogenated. Their use can cause problems for mechanical properties, especially durability. It is necessary to balance the flammability characteristics, ignition, heat development, smoke production and toxicity with structural integrity. Some fire retardants may improve one fire performance characteristic at the expense of others. Organizations such as the Underwriters Laboratory set widely used tests but there is no ISO standard. The major material used is aluminium trihydroxide, which is known in its synthetic commercial form as alumina trihydrate and acts as both fire and smoke suppressor by releasing water vapour on heating. Adhesives, either as thermosetting resins or in speciality form, offer a more speedy assembly than mechanical fixtures or welding. Liquid thermoset resins used in the creation of a composite laminate can be considered as adhesive bonding. Speciality adhesives are a newer introduction and can contain selective cleaning and priming materials in low-, medium- or high-modulus products.
Composites in Infrastructure - Building New Markets
Manufacturing technologies
Hand lay-up is the dominant method of composite fabrication and will remain so for the period of this report. It is estimated that some 65% of all glass fibre reinforced unsaturated polyester (UP) resin (the dominant material for this report) is fabricated by open mould processes - hand lay-up, non-reinforced castings, continuous impregnation and gel-coat resins. Despite environmental pressures to reduce styrene emissions, the 'clean' resin processes such as resin transfer moulding (RTM) still only account for a very small percentage of consumption. Automation of labour-intensive activities can reduce recurring labour costs; this is clearly illustrated in the material deposition rates seen for pultrusion, filament winding and automatic tape lay-up. Therefore, the persistence of manual labour as the dominant method for composite fabrication is a strong indicator that automation with composites is difficult and there are positive advantages to open mould systems. A major challenge in developing cost-effective composite manufacturing techniques is to maintain the vast material and shape options in a simplified and automated way. Automation can translate into lower manufacturing costs provided that: 9 Q Q
the automated steps dominate the cycle time for the part; the parts are produced in sufficient numbers to offset the capital costs of the equipment; and the automated technique does not require higher-priced materials.
These conditions are generally met for reasonable volumes using pultrusion and filament winding. However, the additional complexity required to produce composite parts places limits on the improvements that c a n b e expected from automated techniques. In spite of the potential for considerable improvement over manual lay-up, it is unlikely that automated composite processes will be simpler and, hence, less expensive than the equivalent 'bulk' metal process, for example those for steel. Guidelines on occupational exposure to styrene vary from country to country with the UK allowing a short-term exposure limit (STEL) of 100 parts per million (ppm) applied over a 15 min period and a time-weighted average (TWA) of 50 p p m over an 8 h period. In the USA, OSHA has set limits of 50 ppm and
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
75
4
Manufacturing technologies Table 34 Material deposition rates for composite manufacturing methods Fabrication method
Rate (k~h)
Hand lay-up
0.5
Pre-plied broadgoods
1.5
Tape-laying machine
4.5
Filament winding
45
Germany's limit is just 20 ppm. Exposure to styrene is not considered to have carcinogenic effects but can cause nausea. EU legislation will cause considerable expenditure for the paints and adhesives industries, whilst the polyester industry is a smaller user. There will be greater use of dicyclopentadiene (DCPD)-based resins and the resin suppliers continue to introduce low-styrene emission products. Alternatives to styrene as a m o n o m e r have been evaluated but none offer the same blend of quality, performance, convenience and cost effectiveness, and styrene will remain the predominant m o n o m e r in UP resins for the period of this report. Of the automated processes, injection moulding is a cost-effective way of producing complex, filled polymeric parts but lacks precise control over fibre orientation. Pultrusion is capable of making advanced composite parts and is potentially the lowest cost process; growth in North America is predicted at 8% per annum to 2002. However, pultrusion is limited on part shape, requiring a constant section and has problems with fibres oriented at 90 ~ to the outside. Filament winding works best for shapes with some axial or rotational symmetry but is generally restricted to geodetic fibre paths. The differing fabrication methods have advantages and disadvantages, some of which are related to cost. Table 34 gives a broad outline of the relative speed of the main material deposition rates.
These open mould fabrication techniques are still the most commonly used production methods throughout the world. Even in Europe and the USA such methods predominate and in less technologically developed areas the percentage is higher. The combination of hand lay-up and spray-up is the single largest manufacturing process in Europe with around 35% of production; the USA has about 30% of open mould processing. The global average for open mould techniques in the production of thermosets is around 45%. This must be a matter for concern for the composite industry given the problems of styrene emission, quality control and reproducibility, and the high levels of automation in competitor industries. With composite fabrication, even automated systems may still have some element of contact moulding often as a finishing process. Automated processes such as RTM, filament winding and pultrusion can remove the variations found in hand lay-up whilst providing higher-quality products and reproducibility of components. The entire process of hand lay-up requires about
76
Compositesin Infrastructure- Building New Markets
4
Manufacturing technologies
50 different processes, making the process slow, cumbersome and difficult to automate. The actual lay-up has seven different processes followed by about 33 actions required for bagging, vacuum and curing. In terms of production time, the actual lay-up time (seven processes) often takes about half the total time for the entire process and typical production rates are of the order of 0.5 kg~. Because the process is slow, tedious and dependent on operator skill, the results can be variable requiring a thorough inspection of all structural parts. On the positive side, the process is suitable for large one-piece items, for prototype work and small batches. However, a disadvantage is that for larger-scale production there are problems with repeatability and quality control. If composites are to move into the large-scale production found with conventional materials it will be necessary to adopt the levels of automation found with those materials. The cost benefit to using hand lay-up is that there are few capital costs with the simpler system, although quality control and speed are improved with automation. This reflects the position of the composite market in two areas: 9 Q
having a preponderance of small companies with limited capital investment; the origins of the composites industry as a supplier to the marine and aerospace industries.
Boats and aircraft are usually made as one-off items having large parts - an ideal arrangement for hand lay-up - and nearly 50% of all aircraft components are still made using this method. Volatile organic c o m p o u n d (VOC) legislation will be tightened throughout Europe and the variable rates currently operating are likely to be rationalized. Scandinavian manufacturers point out that the tighter legislation in Scandinavia gives them a manufacturing advantage. Most resin manufacturers such as Reichhold, Scott Bader and DSM are already producing low-styrene resins. However, styrene is still the predominant m o n o m e r and, with open mould techniques, this will continue for the period of this report. Spray-up is heavily used for the production of composite baths, and the introduction of new technology has increased the element of automation with the additional benefit of reduced styrene levels. Equipment from such companies as Magnum Industries, Florida, USA, and Wolfangel GmbH, Germany, have all introduced developments which give more efficient use of material by reducing waste and lower styrene emission. Companies, which have used legislation as an opportunity to examine fabrication techniques, have often found that economies and greater efficiency have resulted.
The pultrusion process was patented in the USA in 1951 as a method for making fishing rods (still a major use of pultrusion in China) and used glass fibre rovings in a polyester matrix. In 1972 continuous strand mat was introduced, but polyester is still the workhorse of the industry. It was not until the mid-1980s that interest in the process as an industrial process was developed. About 28% of the US pultrusion market goes into corrosion-resistant applications.
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets 77
4
Manufacturing technologies
The potential for developing the infrastructure market may be limited in some countries by the current pultrusion capacity. As an example, the UK currently uses 750000 tonnes of steel reinforcing bars per a n n u m and a similar a m o u n t of structural steel sections. Replacing even 1-2% of the steel market would require the entire current UK pultrusion capacity. Matrix materials are usually thermosets and it was not until the mid-1980s that there was much interest in thermoplastics as matrices. Optimistic annual growth rates for pultrusion are set at 12% per annum for the next five years, but a more realistic figure would be 4% per a n n u m but with lower growth in value terms. North America is predicting 8% per a n n u m growth as the supply of timber becomes more difficult. Most raw material manufacturers sell only small amounts of material to pultruders, varying between 0.2 and 5% with an average of 2.6%. Differences for the higher pultrusion market in the USA over Europe include: 9 9
9
lower energy costs; long-standing history of fabrication method; and bulk markets, such as ladders.
Although there are predictions that the pultrusion market in Europe will show faster growth, there are factors such as the lower energy costs in the USA that will still be in effect in 2005. Consequently, European production will grow as the effectiveness of the product becomes apparent but the growth will not be as high as predicted. The estimated markets for pultruded profiles in Europe in 2000 are: 9
9 9
corrosion-resistant a p p l i c a t i o n s - 2900 tonnes; construction - 8000 tonnes; and t r a n s p o r t - 2200 tonnes.
Around 15% of composite production is used in all infrastructure applications and there are predictions that this could rise to 20% by 2005. This would require considerable increases in the growth of such products as pultruded utility poles, cooling towers and corrosion-resistant applications such as gratings. The small percentage of pultrusion used in infrastructure can be seen in figures which indicate that 50% of the total weight produced is used in the following applications, ladder rafts, sucker rod, tool handles, gratings, cable trays, highway protection posts, solid insulator rod, third-rail coverboard, window lineals, electrical rod and bar, cooling tower profiles and conduit strut. Most of these are not infrastructure related, and the largest single item in this list is window lineals. Within Europe only some 2-3% of UP resin production goes into pultrusion products compared to over 35% for hand lay-up and spray-up. Overall pultrusion takes just under 5% of thermoset compounds in Europe. Pultrusion is still a small-scale operation and the average European pultruder has seven or eight pultrusion machines with two or three separate production lines. The average machine capacity is 100 tonnes per a n n u m with production running at about 56% of capacity. The total ex-works value for European pultruded products is around ~130 million. Europe has around 800 pultrusion profile manufacturers, of which just over half produce building profiles. The largest 50 companies in the building profiles sector account for over 80% of the market. Ten of the leading producers -
18
Composites in Infrastructure - Building New Markets
4
Manufacturing technologies
including Veka, Kommerling and Deceuninck - produce 30% of the building profiles. However, most of this market is standard building products such as window frames, cladding, doors, shutters, guttering and similar products. The amount which can be allocated to the infrastructure sector is indicated by the material used - polyvinyl chloride (PVC), usually in the form of uPVC - accounts for 95% of the market and this is rarely, if ever, used for infrastructure. The remaining 5% includes polypropylene, polyester, polystyrene, engineering plastics and thermoplastic elastomers (TPEs). The polymer demand for 1999 was just less than 2 million tonnes and, in line with the percentage seen in other areas, only a maximum of 1% can be allocated to the infrastructure sector. The major pultruders who cater for the infrastructure industry are Bekaert (Belgium), Bedford Plastics (USA), Creative Pultrusions (USA), Exel (Finland), Fiberline (Denmark), Top Glass (Italy) and Fibreforce/Pultrex (UK). Strongwell, the world's largest pultruder with US$85 million worth of components, produces for infrastructure but has also produced carbon fibre reinforced automotive drive shafts for use in GM trucks. The process originally used 12 K carbon fibre but in 1996 the company changed to using the 48 K and 50 K large-tow materials that are now finding use in infrastructure applications. China has 100 pultrusion lines in operation but pultrusion represents only 1.5% of the composite manufacturing market. Although total capacity is about 30 000 tonnes per annum, production is only about 10% of that amount. One of the major consumer areas for pultruded products in China is fishing rods. Isopolyesters account for 75% of pultrusion demand in North America, with a further 15% using vinyl ester. Dow Plastics has introduced a thermoplastic material for pultrusion based on polyurethane and Dow's Fulcrum technology. In the standard pultrusion process resin-coated fibres are pulled through a heated die to produce parts such as round bar, angles, channels and rectangular hollow sections. As the die is often I m or more in commercial processes, and the resin is cured within the die, high pulling forces may be required in production. These forces can be 5-150 kN depending on the section size and, consequently, the pultrusion machine tends to be large. An example of the pultrusion process is material stored in a creel stand capable of supporting many different material packages, sometimes known as roving cheeses, being guided into a pre-heater to obtain a temperature near the melt temperature of the matrix. The material must contain a very carefully specified mass of wetted-out reinforcement. It then enters the heated die with a cavity of the desired cross-section to shape the composite profile followed by a cooled die to consolidate the components. After further cooling by the surrounding air the composite is pulled forward by a pulling mechanism. Pultrusion is a capital-intensive process that can be used for continuous volume manufacture of closely dimensioned shapes and profiles. The cost of the pultrusion dies - some s 000 each - means that new dies cannot be bought for every application. Pultrusion is considered by many to be the most costeffective process for manufacturing the structural members required for large continuous, commercial structural parts using polymer matrix composites. The products range in size from 3 mm rod to 'H'-section girders of considerable size. Manufacturing technology for pultrusion processing has advanced considerably over the last two decades, but there are still serious restrictions to the process that are limiting market penetration.
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets
79
4
Manufacturing technologies
One such limitation has been the very slow processing speeds for pultrusions of more than 5 cm, although new developments have seen speeds increase to 7 m/min in some circumstances. A further limitation is that profiles can only have a constant cross-section and variations in shape cannot be manufactured. A further problem with the process is the requirement for a very rigid construction to enable the frame to support heavy c o m p o n e n t s and to ensure that the force from the pulling mechanism does not result in significant frame deformation. A typical pultruded sheet has the following layers: 9 9 9 9 9 9 9
surfacing chopped fibre; chopped fibre; chopped surfacing
veil; strand mat; strand mat; strand mat; veil.
The surfacing veil is used to give an acceptable finish and also to protect the surface of the product from ultraviolet (UV) radiation. Extended resin pot life is n o w available to pultruders with new catalyst systems that can bring about cures. Pot life has been extended in temperatures below 150 ~C, with standard imidazole catalysts having a pot life of about 8 h and the new materials giving a pot life of up to 48 h. This allows bigger batches to be m i x e d increasing from 25 l to batches of 110 1 and even 180 1. A disadvantage of the pultrusion process is that it can only p r o d u c e continuous straight profiles. The ability to produce curved sections or sections with c o m e r s w o u l d give pultruded products a larger commercial market (Table 35). Researchers at the Warwick Manufacturing Group, part of the University of Warwick, have developed a three-dimensional pultrusion process in which curing is d o n e using UV light rather than heat and takes place as the profile leaves the die. As the die only has to impart a profile to the fibre-resin bundle, the pulling force is far lower than that required for the standard pultrusion process. Examples given indicate that a square hollow section measuring 12 • 12 m m with a 2 m m wall thickness only requires a load of 10 kN. The process uses a computercontrolled robot arm rather than a large pulling rig and this indicates that it could be possible to produce curves and c o m e r s in the structure. The problem for an under-capitalized industry is that the robot control would improve the efficiency of the operation but increase the capital cost.
Table 35 European thermoset use in pultrusion (O00s tonnes)
80
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
43
45
47
49.5
52
54.5
57
Composites in Infrastructure - Building New Markets
4
Manufacturing technologies
Filament winding is a fabrication process that for some geometric shapes can bridge the gap between slow, labour-intensive fabrication techniques, such as those used in the aerospace industry, and the rapid automated fabrication processes, such as those required by the automotive industry. The process uses a continuous fibre reinforcement to form a shape by winding over some predetermined path. The complexity and accuracy of the winding path are easily controlled with computer-controlled winding machines. Thin, hollow shapes with a high fibre to resin ratio are possible, which makes the process suitable for lightweight, high-performance components. The uniform fibre alignment afforded by the process provides high reliability and repeatability in filament-wound components. For filament winding, glass fibre is purchased in a yarn-like form called roving. This roving is routed through a bath of liquid, catalysed, pigmented polyester resin before it reaches the mandrel. After the glass fibre and resin are in place, a surface of resin-impregnated non-woven polyester fabric is applied. Heat is then applied to initiate cross-linking (hardening) of the resin. After hardening, the tube is removed from the mandrel. In this case, hydraulic cylinders with appropriate attachments push the tube off the mandrel. Thermoset resins used as the binders for the reinforcements can be applied to the dry roving at the time of winding (wet winding) or prior to winding (prepreg). The process can be combined with resin transfer moulding (RTM) so that structures can be made to near net shape. The combination of multi-spindle winders for preforms and RTM can produce finished parts at a relatively low cost per piece. Limitations with respect to filament tension, filament wet-out and the speed at which the wet filament can be pulled through have been largely overcome. Thick sections can be w o u n d and non-geodesic and concave sections can be formed with some difficulty. However, methods for forming complex geometries are still not established. There are still problems with heating control and consolidation of materials that yield less than predicted values for tensile strength and interlaminar shear strength. A further limitation is the inability to integrate box sections with large flat panels in a one-piece structure having complex geometry; this will limit the penetration of filament winding in such growth areas as automotive body structures. The advantages of the process include accurate, repeatable fibre placement, the ability to use continuous fibres over the length of the component, relatively low tooling costs and high fibre volumes. Traditionally, the process has been used for pipes and tanks but glass fibre reinforced composite utility poles are now manufactured using the filament winding process. There are other methods that can be utilized to form a hollow cylindrical structure. However, the Shakespeare Company, South Carolina, USA, which is using the process, considers that filament winding combines an economy of material and flexibility of material placement which make it the clear choice for this type of structure. Increases in the use of such products in Europe could lead to an increase in this fabrication method. However, one problem would be that it could take market share from other methods, such as pultruded products.
Composites in Infrastructure- Building New Markets 81
4
Manufacturing technologies In Europe, some 8% of unsaturated polyester (UP) resin is used in filament winding. Growth rate in filament winding is set at 6% per a n n u m and this is partly dependent on the market for such items as pipes. As the pipe market in Europe has been depressed over the last couple of years, the predicted growth rate could be considered too high. It is interesting that Europe no longer supports a trade association devoted to filament winding, although that for pultrusion (European Pultrusion Technology A s s o c i a t i o n - EPTA) still exists. The dependence of the fabrication method on the market for pipes, which is very competitive, may explain the lack of a trade body. It is difficult to arrive at production figures and other statistics for pultruded products with the large n u m b e r of companies involved and thi