Commun. Math. Phys. 276, 1–21 (2007) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-007-0338-8
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Constraining the Kähler Moduli in the Heterotic Standard Model Tomás L. Gómez1,3 , Sergio Lukic2 , Ignacio Sols3 1 CSIC Instituto de Matemáticas y Fisica Fundamental, Madrid 28006, Spain.
E-mail:
[email protected]
2 Department of Physics and Astronomy, Rutgers University, Piscataway, NJ 08855-0849, USA.
E-mail:
[email protected]
3 Departamento de Álgebra, Facultad de Matemáticas UCM, Madrid 28040, Spain.
E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 24 December 2005 / Accepted: 11 June 2007 Published online: 19 September 2007 – © Springer-Verlag 2007
Abstract: Phenomenological implications of the volume of the Calabi-Yau threefolds on the hidden and observable M-theory boundaries, together with slope stability of their corresponding vector bundles, constrain the set of Kähler moduli which give rise to realistic compactifications of the strongly coupled heterotic string. When vector bundles are constructed using extensions, we provide simple rules to determine lower and upper bounds to the region of the Kähler moduli space where such compactifications can exist. We show how small these regions can be, working out in full detail the case of the recently proposed Heterotic Standard Model. More explicitly, we exhibit Kähler classes in these regions for which the visible vector bundle is stable. On the other hand, there is no polarization for which the hidden bundle is stable. 1. Introduction Our understanding of Calabi-Yau compactifications of string/M-theory has been increased considerably during the last years. On the one hand, distributions of vacua for type IIB, IIA and type I string theory are much better understood. On the other hand, promising compactifications of the heterotic string have been found at special points of the moduli space. Although a systematic study of distributions of vacua for compactifications of the heterotic string is much harder, because our primitive understanding of their moduli stabilization and the huge amount of vector bundle moduli, we can still find systematic criteria to constrain the regions of the moduli space where realistic vacua should be located. Recently, phenomenologically interesting Calabi-Yau compactifications of the heterotic string have appeared in the literature [2, 5]. Using certain elliptically fibered threefold with fundamental group ZZ3 × ZZ3 , and an SU (4) × ZZ3 × ZZ3 instanton living on the visible E 8 -bundle, give rise to an effective field theory on IR4 which has the particle spectrum of the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (MSSM), with no exotic
2
T. L. Gómez, S. Lukic, I. Sols
matter but an additional pair of Higgs-Higgs conjugate superfields. In these models, vector bundles are constructed using vector bundle extensions, which correspond to Hermitian Yang-Mills connections when they are slope-stable. We use this specific construction to exemplify how a systematic selection of realistic Kähler moduli can be done.1 The organization of the paper is as follows: Sect. 2 contains an outline of the natural criteria for selecting Kähler moduli in realistic Calabi-Yau compactifications of the heterotic string. In Sect. 3, we analyze the case of the Heterotic Standard Model, describe the geometry of the elliptic Calabi-Yau and construct its Kähler cone. Section 4 provides lower and upper bounds to the region of the Kähler cone that makes stable the observable vector bundle of the HSM. In such construction we find a destabilizing sub-line bundle for the hidden vector bundle, and exhibit Kähler classes that make stable the visible one. 2. Picking Kähler Moduli The spacetime in a Calabi-Yau compactification of the strongly coupled heterotic string [15], defined through the direct product eleven-dimensional manifold Y = IR4 × X × [0, 1], with X a Calabi-Yau threefold. N = 1 supersymmetry on the four dimensional Effective Field Theory, requires to fix a G 2 -holonomy metric on X × [0, 1] plus gauge connections at the hidden and visible vector bundles, which satisfy the Hermitian Yang-Mills equations. In order to define a barely G 2 -holonomy metric on X × [0, 1] we introduce a calibration 3-form, according to D. Joyce [16], = (At + B)ω ∧ dt + Re(),
(2.1)
which depends on the differential dt along the interval and the holomorphic 3-form and Kähler class ω of the threefold. Such a calibration defines a barely G 2 -holonomy metric on X × [0, 1], where the Kähler class is linearly dilated along the interval; therefore at the visible and hidden boundaries the Kähler classes are ω0 = Bω and ω1 = (A + B)ω (i = 1 stands for the ‘hidden’ boundary and i = 0 for the ‘visible’ one). The set of Kähler classes on X is usually known as the Kähler cone and denoted by K(X ) ⊂ H 2 (X, ZZ). One approach to model building is to attach a SU (n) × G Hermitian Yang-Mills gauge connection at the boundary, to obtain an Effective Field Theory with the commutant of SU (n) × G ⊂ E 8 as gauge group while the N = 1 supersymmetry of the EFT is preserved. Here G is the non-trivial holonomy group associated to a certain flat line bundle. By the theorem of Donaldson and Uhlenbeck-Yau [9], we know that SU (n)-connections that satisfy the Hermitian Yang-Mills equations and slope-stable rank-n holomorphic vector bundles with vanishing first Chern class are in one-to-one correspondence.
2.1. Constraining angular degrees of freedom. Thus, the holomorphic vector bundles Vi → X that we fix at the hidden and visible sectors, have to be slope stable in order to get a sensible vacuum. Slope stability can impose severe constraints on the Kähler moduli. 1 Recently, Donagi and Bouchard [8] have also proposed an independent CY compactification of the heterotic string with the spectrum of the MSSM and no exotic matter, using a different Calabi-Yau with an explicitly slope-stable vector bundle in the observable sector. It would be also interesting to study in detail these questions with the vector bundle which has just appeared in [4], on the same CY [5].
Constraining the Kähler Moduli in the Heterotic Standard Model
3
If Wi → Vi is a rank-m (with m < n) holomorphic torsion free subsheaf2 , then only the ωi ∈ K(X ) that verify 1 1 ωi2 ∧ c1 (Wi ) < ω2 ∧ c1 (Vi ) = 0, (2.2) m X n X i can make Vi stable. At this point we realize that if ωi is a stablemaker for Vi , then N ωi with N ∈ ZZ+ is also a stablemaker. The stablemakers form a subcone Kis (X ) ⊆ K(X ) within the Kähler moduli, [20]. The physical importance of slope stability is clear, [9]: Non-stablemaker classes at the boundary of Kis (X ) make the vector bundle Vi semistable, i.e. we can only find correspondences to connections with reduced gauge group H ⊂ SU (n), thus the gauge dynamics of the Effective Field Theory would be governed by the commutant of H × G ⊂ E 8 instead of SU (n) × G. Usually, a detailed computation of Kis (X ) is difficult because we need to identify every subsheaf Wi of Vi . Note that if h 0 (Wi∨ ⊗ Vi ) = 0, then Wi cannot be a subsheaf of Vi , but the converse is not necessarily true. If the vector bundle Vi is constructed through a non-trivial extension, defined by a short exact sequence 0 −→ VL −→ Vi −→ V R −→ 0,
(2.3)
with Ext1 (V
s R , VL ) = 0, we can give upper and lower bounds to Ki (X ) in a simple way, looking at subsheaves of VL and V R . On the one hand, the set ULi of subsheaves of VL is a subset of the set of subsheaves of Vi , since VL → Vi is injective. This provides an upper bound for cone Kis (X ) of Kähler classes for which Vi is stable:
Kis (X )>
2 = ωi ∈ K(X ) : ωi ∧ c1 (L i ) < 0, ∀ L i ∈ ULi .
(2.4)
X
On the other hand, a subsheaf of Vi gives an element of ULi × URi , where URi is the subset of subsheaves of V R . Indeed, if Wi is a subsheaf of Vi , there is a commutative diagram 0 −→ VL −→ Vi −→ V R −→ 0 ↑ ↑ ↑ 0 −→ W L −→ Wi −→ W R −→ 0
(2.5)
where the vertical arrows are injective, hence we obtain subsheaves W L and W R of VL and V R . This gives a lower bound s < 2 Ki (X ) = ωi ∈ K(X ) : ωi ∧ (c1 (W L )+c1 (W R )) < 0, ∀ W L ∈ ULi , W R ∈ URi . X
(2.6) Note that the ones belonging to ULi are true subsheaves of Vi , and the ones in URi are possible subsheaves of Vi . Therefore, we can construct two bounds to the stablemaker Kähler subcone Kis (X ), Kis (X )< ⊆ Kis (X ) ⊆ Kis (X )> .
(2.7)
2 It is enough to consider reflexive sheaves, i.e., sheaves with W = W ∨∨ . Furthermore, we can assume i i that Wi is semistable.
4
T. L. Gómez, S. Lukic, I. Sols
Sometimes we can use further information to discard some pairs (W L , W R ) which do not come from subsheaves Wi of Vi , hence obtaining a better lower bound. For instance, the pair (0, V R ) can be discarded, because it would give a splitting of the defining exact sequence (2.3), but we have assumed that the extension is not trivial, hence has no splitting. Other cases that can be discarded are pairs of the form (0, W R ) when h 0 (W R∨ ⊗ Vi ) = 0. We shall apply these ideas in the next sections to the vector bundles constructed in the Heterotic Standard Model, [2]. 2.2. Constraining radial degrees of freedom. In the last subsection we have seen how to choose rays in the Kähler cone that preserve the slope stability of a given vector bundle, and thus define a consistent gauge group in the effective field theory. On the other hand, radial degrees of freedom in Kis (X ) are related with variations of the volume of X , [11]. We are not free to choose arbitrary volumes for the threefolds at the hidden and observable sector, if we want to preserve sensible values for Newton’s constant and the E 8 gauge coupling, [22]. Using Liouville’s measure, we can estimate the volume of the Calabi-Yau threefold at the point ωi ∈ K(X ) as 3 1 Vol(X )i = ω3 , (2.8) 3! X i thus radial dilations in the Kähler cone ωi → N ωi with N ∈ ZZ+ , map the volume as Vol(X )i → N 3 Vol(X )i . The volume of the threefolds at the boundaries of Y , are related through Witten’s formula [22] ρ 1 Vol(X )1 = Vol(X )0 + 2π ω0 ∧ c2 (V0 ) − c2 (T X ) + O(ρ 2 ), (2.9) P X 2 with P the eleven dimensional Planck length and ρ the length of the M-theory interval. This formula (2.9) holds at first order in ρ, which is the limit where we work, as in (2.1). A more accurate relation between the volumes of the CYs at the boundaries, taking into account the non-linear corrections in ρ, was derived in [6] and [7]. Newton’s constant in the effective supergravity theory on the observable IR4 of Y goes as GN ∼
9P , ρVol(X )0
(2.10)
6P . Vol(X )0
(2.11)
and the E 8 gauge coupling as αGU T ∼
Witten observed in [22], that in order to find realistic values for these physical quantities, the volume of the threefold in the visible sector has to be very large. As the integral in the right-hand side of (2.9) is negative due to Chern-Weil theory, and the identity 2 Tr F ∧ ω = − |F|2 ω3 , (2.12) X
X
3 Being rigorous, we should work with the dimensionfull measure (α ω)3 , although this will be irrelevant for our purposes because α factorizes out in the formulae that we use. In the small volume limit this
approximation can fail, and we should use conformal field theory to give a more accurate estimation.
Constraining the Kähler Moduli in the Heterotic Standard Model
5
he deduced that sensible values for G N and αGU T are only possible for very small Vol(X )1 . Summarizing: Let K0s (X ) and K1s (X ) be the set of Kähler classes that make stable V0 → X and V1 → X , respectively. Physically interesting vacua should be located in rays of the Kähler cone lying in the intersection K0s (X ) ∩ K1s (X ) ⊂ K(X ), such that the relative dilating factor ω0 /ω1 is very large, and the Witten’s correlation 1 1 ρ 1 3 3 ω ∼ ω + 2π ω0 ∧ c2 (V0 ) − c2 (T X ) (2.13) 3! X 1 3! X 0 P X 2 is satisfied. Remark 1. Although the study of distributions of vacua for these models is not as developed as for Calabi-Yau compactifications of the type II string theory, the presence of vacua in these regions of the Kähler moduli space should be statistically favorable along the lines of [10], once the vector bundle, dilaton and complex moduli are stabilized. We have shown how to identify these regions explicitly. In the rest of the paper we determine them for the recently proposed Heterotic Standard Model. 3. The Elliptic Calabi-Yau and its Kähler Cone First, we briefly recall the construction of the Calabi-Yau threefold used the Heterotic Standard Model, following the reference [5]. Let X be the fiber product over IP1 of two rational elliptic surfaces X = B1 ×IP1 B2 , as in the diagram: X π1 π2 B1 ↓ π B2 β1 β2 IP1
(3.1)
This kind of Calabi-Yau threefolds was already studied by C. Schoen in S. The geometry of X is basically encoded in the geometry of the rational elliptic surfaces B1 and B2 . Due to the phenomenological interest in finding threefolds which admit certain Wilson lines4 , the aim of [5] was to look for threefolds X such that ZZ3 × ZZ3 ⊆ Aut( X ). This search was achieved thanks to the existence of certain elliptic surfaces that admit an action of ZZ3 × ZZ3 which can be characterized explicitly through a proper understanding of the Mordell-Weil group of B. Following Kodaira’s classification of singular fibers, our elliptic surfaces B1 and B2 are characterized by three I1 and three I3 singular fibers. Such rational elliptic surfaces are described by one-dimensional families that allow us to build fiber products X , corresponding to smooth Calabi-Yau threefolds. Furthermore, X admits a free action of G = ZZ3 × ZZ3 and the quotient X = X /G is also a smooth Calabi-Yau threefold with fundamental group π1 (X ) = ZZ3 × ZZ3 . Let g1 and g2 be generators of this group, g2 acting as translation tη by a section η of the fibration β : B → IP1 , and g1 acting nontrivially on the base. Let ξ = g1 (σ ) and α B = t−ξ ◦ g1 . The threefold used in the description of the Heterotic Standard Model is X = X /G, although we will work with G-equivariant objects on X . In the rest of this section 4 I.e. flat line bundles with non-trivial holonomy.
6
T. L. Gómez, S. Lukic, I. Sols
we describe the G-invariant homology rings of B and X , and their corresponding G-invariant Kähler cones (i.e. their ample cones, or spaces of polarizations). For the homology of a surface B, we choose a set of generators: the 0-section σ , the generic fiber F, the 6 irreducible components of the three I3 singular fibers that do not intersect the 0-section 1,1 , 1,2 , . . . , 3,1 , 3,2 , and the two sections generating the free part of the Mordell-Weil group5 ξ and α B ξ . These generators are a basis for H2 (B, ZZ) ⊗ Q, but adding the torsion generator of the Mordell-Weil group η=σ+F−
1 2
1,1 + 2,1 + 3,1 −
1,2 + 2,2 + 3,2 , 3 3
(3.2)
we generate all H2 (B, ZZ). The intersection matrix of the homology generators is as follows: ⎛ σ ⎞T ⎜ F ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ 1,1 ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ 2,1 ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ 3,1 ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ 1,2 ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ 2,2 ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ 3,2 ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ ξ ⎟ ⎠ ⎝ αB ξ η
⎛ σ ⎞ ⎛ −1 ⎜ F ⎟ ⎜ 1 ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ ⎜ 1,1 ⎟ ⎜ 0 ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ ⎜ 2,1 ⎟ ⎜ 0 ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ ⎜ 3,1 ⎟ ⎜ 0 ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ · ⎜ 1,2 ⎟ = ⎜ 0 ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ ⎜ 2,2 ⎟ ⎜ 0 ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ ⎜ 3,2 ⎟ ⎜ 0 ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ ⎜ ξ ⎟ ⎜ 0 ⎠ ⎝ ⎝ 0 αB ξ 0 η
1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ⎞ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 ⎟ ⎟ 0 −2 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 ⎟ ⎟ 0 0 −2 0 0 1 0 1 0 1 ⎟ ⎟ 0 0 0 −2 0 0 1 0 1 1 ⎟ ⎟ 0 1 0 0 −2 0 0 0 1 0 ⎟ . (3.3) ⎟ 0 0 1 0 0 −2 0 0 0 0 ⎟ ⎟ 0 0 0 1 0 0 −2 1 0 0 ⎟ ⎟ 1 0 1 0 0 0 1 −1 1 0 ⎟ ⎠ 1 0 0 1 1 0 0 1 −1 0 1 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 −1
The invariant homology under the action of G = ZZ3 × ZZ3 , is generated by H2 (B, ZZ)G = spanZZ F, t = −σ + 2,1 + 3,1 + 3,2 + 2ξ + α B ξ + η − F , (3.4) where t can be also expressed as the homological sum of three sections, i.e. t = ξ + αB ξ + η ξ . The cohomology ring of X can be expressed as H ∗ (X, Q) = H ∗ ( X , Q)G ,
(3.5)
using the G-invariant cohomology of X . Hence G 2 H (B1 , Q) ⊕ H 2 (B2 , Q) H 2 (B1 , Q)G ⊕ H 2 (B2 , Q)G G = H ( X , Q) = , (3.6) H 2 (IP1 , Q) H 2 (IP1 , Q) 2
that due to (3.4), is the same as X , Q)G H 2 (X, Q) = H 2 ( = spanQ τ1 = π1∗ (t1 ), τ2 = π2∗ (t2 ), φ = π1∗ (F1 ) = π2∗ (F1 ) ,
(3.7)
where t1 and t2 (respectively, F1 and F2 ) are the t-classes (respectively, F-classes) defined in (3.4), corresponding to each surface B1 and B2 . Using Poincaré duality, we know that H 4 (X, Q) is isomorphic to H 2 (X, Q), also H1 (X, ZZ) π1 (X ) = ZZ3 × ZZ3 because the Hurewicz theorem, thus H 1 (X, Q) = H 1 (X, ZZ) ⊗ Q = 0. 5 See Appendix A, for a complete description of the Mordell-Weil group of the elliptic surface.
Constraining the Kähler Moduli in the Heterotic Standard Model
7
The ring H ev ( X , Q)G is generated through the cup product of the generators (3.7), and is isomorphic to H ev ( X , Q)G = Q[τ1 , τ2 , φ]/φ 2 , φτ1 = 3τ12 , φτ2 = 3τ22 ,
(3.8)
with the top cohomology element being τ12 τ2 = τ1 τ22 = 3{pt.}. 3.1. The ample cone of the elliptic surface. As first step to determine the Kähler cone on the threefold, we build the G-invariant ample cone of the rational elliptic surface through Nakai’s criterion. The set of ample classes is by definition the integral cohomology part of the Kähler moduli. Using Looijenga’s classification of the effective curves in a rational elliptic surface [17], we know that the cone of effective classes in H2 (B, ZZ) is generated by the following classes e ∈ H2 (B, ZZ): 1) The exceptional curves e2 := −1, i.e. every section of the elliptic fibration. 2) The nodal curves e2 := −2, i.e. the irreducible components of the singular fibers. 3) The positive classes, i.e. the classes that live in the “future” side of the cone of e2 > 0. Nakai’s criterion for surfaces says that a class s is ample if and only if s · s > 0 and e · s > 0 for every effective curve e. We will apply this criterion to the invariant classes s = a F + bt. • Intersection of s with the exceptional curves. Although there is an infinite amount of exceptional curves or sections in the elliptic surface, we can characterize them completely thanks to our understanding of the Mordell-Weil group. As it is explained in Appendix A, the representation of the Mordell-Weil group E(K ) ZZ ⊕ ZZ ⊕ ZZ3 in End(H2 (B, ZZ)) has as generators: (tξ )∗ , (tα B ξ )∗ and (tη )∗ . Thus, the homology of an arbitrary section can be expressed as y (3.9) xξ yα B ξ zη = (tξ )∗x (tα B ξ )∗ (tη )∗z σ, where xξ (respectively yα B ξ and zη) means xξ = ξ ξ . . . ξ . x
Finding the Jordan canonical forms associated to (tξ )∗ , (tα B ξ )∗ and (tη )∗ , allows us to expand (3.9), explicitly. We exhibit the list of homology classes associated to the sections in Appendix A. Hence, the intersections of the exceptional curves with the generators of the invariant homology are F · [xξ yα B ξ zη] = 1
(3.10)
t · [xξ yα B ξ zη] = x 2 + y 2 − x y − x.
(3.11)
and
It is easy to check that x 2 + y 2 − x y − x as a function ZZ ⊕ ZZ → ZZ is non-negative and becomes zero for (x = 0, y = 0), (x = 1, y = 0) and (x = 1, y = 1). Therefore a G-invariant ample class s = a F + bt has to verify s · [0ξ 0α B ξ zη] = a > 0,
(3.12)
8
T. L. Gómez, S. Lukic, I. Sols
and s · [∞ξ ∞α B ξ zη] = a + ∞b > 0, ⇒ b > 0.
(3.13)
• Intersection of s with the nodal curves. The nodal curves are identified with the irreducible components i, j of the singular fibers, thus their intersections with the invariant class s = a F + bt give us s · i, j = b > 0,
(3.14)
an identical result to the inequality (3.13), derived above. • Intersection of s with the positive classes. Let K+ (B) be the cone of positive classes in B, i.e. K+ (B) = {e ∈ H2 (B, ZZ)| e · e > 0}. As K+ (B) is a convex set and we have to take intersections of elements in K+ (B) with invariant classes in H2 (B, ZZ)G , only the intersection K+ (B) ∩ H2 (B, ZZ)G matters. From the intersection matrix of the homology generators, we know that the intersection matrix of the invariant homology H2 (B, ZZ)G is
F t
T F 0 3 · = t 3 1
(3.15)
hence, we find K+ (B) ∩ H2 (B, ZZ)G := e = x F + yt| 6x y + y 2 > 0 ,
(3.16)
being the edges of such a “future” cone F and 6t − F. Furthermore, their intersections with our ample candidate s = a F + bt give us the conditions s · F = (a F + bt) · F = 3b > 0, s · (6t − F) = 18a + 6b − 3b = 18a + 3b > 0,
(3.17)
that do not constrain the inequalities (3.12), and (3.13). Finally, as the cone generated by F and t is within K+ (B) ∩ H2 (B, ZZ)G , the last Nakai condition s · s > 0 or positivity of the Liouville measure is verified. Therefore, the G-invariant ample cone associated to the elliptic surface B is simply K(B)G = spanZZ+ {F, t} .
(3.18)
3.2. Ampleness in the threefold. Once we have characterized the G-invariant ample cone on the rational surface, we can construct G-invariant ample classes on the threefold X as a product of ample classes on the surfaces B1 and B2 . In fact, the following proposition shows that the ample classes on X constructed in this way determine explicitly its G-invariant ample cone K( X )G = K(X ). Proposition 3.1. The G-invariant ample cone of X is K( X )G = spanZZ+ {τ1 , τ2 , φ} .
(3.19)
Constraining the Kähler Moduli in the Heterotic Standard Model
9
Proof. If L i is an ample class in Bi , then π1∗ L 1 ⊗ π2∗ L 2 is an ample class in X , hence K( X )G contains the positive linear span of τ1 , τ2 and φ. To show the opposite inclusion, we apply Nakai’s criterion to some effective classes. Let H = aτ1 + bτ2 + cφ be an ample class. If C1 is the class of a fiber of π1 , 0 < H · C1 = 0a + 3b + 0c = 3b. Analogously, if C2 is the class of a fiber of π2 , we obtain a > 0. Let i : B1 ×IP1 B2 → B1 × B2 . Let C be the class of σ1 ×IP1 σ2 , let c1 , c2 be two integers with c = c1 + c2 , and denote [Bi ] (respectively, [pt]) the class of Bi in H 0 (Bi , ZZ) (respectively, of a point in H 4 (Bi , ZZ)), 0 < H · C = i ∗ ((at1 + c1 f 1 ) ⊗ [B2 ] + [B1 ] ⊗ (bt2 + c2 f 2 )) · i ∗ [σ1 ⊗ σ2 ] = i ∗ ((at1 + c1 f 1 )σ1 [pt] ⊗ σ2 + σ1 ⊗ [pt] (bt2 + c2 f 2 )σ2 ) = i ∗ (c1 [pt] ⊗ σ2 + c2 σ1 ⊗ [pt]) (3.20) = c1 + c2 = c. 4. Slope Stability of the Vector Bundles The concept of (slope) stability of a vector bundle depends on the choice of a polarization H ∈ K(X ) ⊂ H 2 (X, ZZ), i.e., we say that a holomorphic vector bundle E → X is stable iff H 2 · det(·) , (4.1) µ(F) < µ(E) ; with µ(·) = rank (·) for every reflexive subsheaf F → E. By det(E) and det(F) we mean the determinant line bundles associated to E and F. There is a natural bijection between vector bundles on X and G-equivariant vector bundles on X . We will recall a few general remarks on G-invariance and G-equivariance, which will be useful in the rest of this section. Let X be a complex projective variety and G a complex algebraic group acting on it. A subvariety X of X is said to be invariant if g X = X for all g in G. A divisor D is said to be invariant if gD = D for all g in G. A divisor class is said invariant to be if for any divisor D in the class and g and in G, the divisor gD is linearly equivalent to D. An equivariant structure on a vector bundle E on X is a lifting by linear maps E(x) −→ E(gx) (for all g ∈ G) between fibers, of the action of G on X . We will widely use this notion, and sometimes also the notion of equivariant coherent sheaf (we will talk about some equivariant ideal sheaf) so it is convenient to generalize it defining an equivariant structure on a coherent sheaf F on X as a family of isomorphisms ϕgF : F∼ = g ∗ F , for each g ∈ G, so that ϕgF g = ϕgF ϕgF . Equivariant morphisms f : F −→ F , between equivariant sheaves are those such that ϕgF F −→ g ∗ F f ↓ g∗ f ↓
F −→ g ∗ F
ϕgF for all g ∈ G.
(4.2)
(4.3)
10
T. L. Gómez, S. Lukic, I. Sols
If two vector bundles have an equivariant structure, obviously their tensor products inherit an equivariant structure. If a vector bundle E has an equivariant structure, all of its exterior powers, and in particular its determinant line bundle, det (E), inherit an equivariant structure, and also its dual E ∗ (pointwise, take the inverse of the transposed action). The trivial bundle L = X × C, or O X as an associated sheaf, admits a trivial equivariant structure. A vector bundle with equivariant structure is always invariant, which means, by definition, that g ∗ E is isomorphic to E for any g in G . In the case E is a vector bundle L of rank 1, this definition means that both g ∗ L and L define the same point of Pic(X ), i.e. that the point corresponding to E in Pic(X ) is fixed by the action of the group, or still, in terms of associated divisors, that the corresponding divisor class is invariant. A vector subbundle E ⊂ E of an equivariantly structured bundle E is called an equivariant vector subbundle when g(E (x)) ⊂ E (x) for all x in X and g in G. This is equivalent to say that, for all g ∈ G, the isomorphism E ∼ = g ∗ E given by the equivariant structure applies E into g ∗ E , so this notion still has a meaning when E is just a coherent subsheaf. An equivariant coherent subsheaf E obviously inherits a structure of the equivariant coherent sheaf, as well as its quotient E
= E/E , and we just say that the extension 0 −→ E −→ E −→ E
−→ 0,
(4.4)
is equivariant. An equivariant vector bundle is said to be equivariantly stable if all its equivariant coherent sheaves (enough to check with reflexive) have smaller slope. A section s of equivariantly structured E is called equivariant when, for all x in X and g in G, it is g(s(x)) = s(gx) . When viewing the section, as usual, as a subbundle O X → E, this amounts to say that the subbundle is equivariant and the inherited equivariant structure on the trivial bundle is the trivial equivariant structure. Clearly, the vanishing locus V (s) of an equivariant section is invariant. If the vector bundle E is a line bundle L of rank one, and s is a meromorphic equivariant section of it, i.e. equivariant section defined on a Zariski open set, the divisor it defines is an invariant divisor (not only a divisor of invariant class). We say L is equivariantly effective if it has a nonzero equivariant global (i.e. holomorphic) section. In a surface X , a line bundle L = O X (D) is equivariantly ample when it is equivariant and has positive selfinterseccion, and its itersection number with all equivariantly effective equivariant line bundles is positive. Therefore, ample and equivariant implies equivariantly ample. 4.1. Conditions on the effective divisors. This is an analysis previous to the solution of both problems. We show now that if there exists an effective divisor in the invariant class O B (at + bF) on the elliptic surface, then a ≥ −3b. We start with the following: Remark 2. Denote a the defect quotient a =
a 3
.
(4.5)
Recall that t is the homology sum of three sections, namely ξ , α B ξ and η ξ , which we denote, respectively, s1 , s2 and s3 . The 3a summands in at = as1 + as2 + as3
(4.6)
Constraining the Kähler Moduli in the Heterotic Standard Model
11
can be ordered
, at = s1 + · · · + s3a
(4.7)
so to fullfill the following three conditions: • For all index i such that si = s1 , {s j | j ≤ i and s j = s2 } − { j | j ≤ i and s j = s1 } ≤ a .
(4.8)
• For all index i such that si = s3 , {s j | j ≤ i and s j = s2 } − { j | j ≤ i and s j = s3 } ≤ a .
(4.9)
• For all index i such that si = s2 , {s j | j ≤ i and s j = s1 or s3 } − { j | j ≤ i and s j = s2 } ≤ a . (4.10) Indeed, the following ordering of the 3a summands satisfies the three conditions: take its first 3a summands to be (s1 + s2 + s3 ) + · · · + (s1 + s2 + s3 ).
(4.11)
Next, add summands of the alternating form (s1 + s2 ) + (s3 + s2 ) + (s1 + s2 ) + (s3 + s2 ) + · · ·
(4.12)
(so s has already ocurred a times) and add finally summands s1 , s3 , in no matter which order, until completing a ocurrences of each. The consequence of this remark is the following Lemma 1. For any direct factor OIP1 (l) occurring in the splitting of β∗ O B (at) it is l ≤ a := a3 , i.e. h 0 (β∗ O B (at)(−a − 1)) = 0. Proof. Recall β∗ O B = OIP1 . Order the 3a summands in
, at = s1 + · · · + s3a
(4.13)
as in the former remark. For some index 1 ≤ i < 3a, assume it is already proved that
)(−a − 1)) = 0. h 0 (β∗ O B (s1 + · · · + si−1
(4.14)
It is then enough to prove that h 0 (β∗ O B (s1 + · · · + si )(−a − 1)) = 0.
(4.15)
From
) −→ O B (s1 +· · · + si ) −→ Os1 (s1 +· · · + si ) −→ 0, (4.16) 0 −→ O B (s1 +· · ·+si−1
we obtain
) −→ β∗ O B (s1 +· · ·+si ) −→ OIP1 ((s1 + · · · + si )s1 ) −→ 0. 0 −→ β∗ O B (s1 + · · · + si−1 (4.17)
12
T. L. Gómez, S. Lukic, I. Sols
Assume first that si = s1 . Recalling that s12 = −1, s1 s3 = 0, s1 s2 = 1, we have (s1 + · · · + si )s1 = { j | j ≤ i and s j = s2 } − { j | j ≤ i and s j = s1 } ≤ a , (4.18) proving, by consulting the former exact sequence, the wanted vanishing. The vanishing is analogously proved in the case si = s3 . Assume now that si = s2 . Recalling that s22 = −1, s2 s1 = s2 s3 = 1, we have (s1 +· · · + si )s2 = { j | j ≤ i and s j = s1 or s3 }−{ j | j ≤ i and s j = s2 } ≤ a , (4.19)
thus proving also the wanted vanishing.
Corollary. If H 0 (B, O B (at + bF)) = 0,
(4.20)
0 = H 0 (B, O B (at + bF)) = H 0 (IP1 , β∗ O B (at + bF)) = H 0 (IP1 , OIP1 (b) ⊗ β∗ O B (at)),
(4.21)
then a ≥ −3b. Proof. We assume
where β∗ O B (at) is a direct sum of factors OIP1 (l) with l ≤ a/3, by the lemma. Therefore, for some of these factors, we obtain a (4.22) 0 ≤ b+l ≤ b+ . 3 Let be the inverse image of Z under the second projection. 1 Lemma 2. a) If H 0 ( X , O X (a1 τ1 + a2 τ2 + bφ)) = 0, then a1 , a2 ≥ 0 and b ≥ − 3 (a1 + a2 ). b) If H 0 ( X , I (a1 τ1 + bφ)) = 0, then a1 ≥ 0, b ≥ − 13 a1 + 3.
Proof. a) If ai were negative, then the restriction of this section to any elliptic fibre E i of π2 would be O Ei −→ O Ei (a1 ( p1 + p2 + p3 )),
(4.23)
and this is impossible. On the other hand, 0 ∗ H 0 O X (a1 τ1 + a2 τ2 + bφ) = H O B1 (a1 t1 + bF1 ) ⊗ π1∗ π2 O B2 (a2 t2 ) = H 0 (O B1 (a1 t1 + bF1 ) ⊗ β1∗ β2∗ O B2 (a2 t2 )) = H 0 (β1∗ O B1 (a1 t1 ) ⊗ OIP1 (b) ⊗ β2∗ O B2 (a2 t2 )) = H 0( OIP1 (l1i ) ⊗ OIP1 (b) ⊗ OIP1 (l2 j )). i
a1
(4.24)
j
In these sums l1i ≤ a1 := 3 and l2 j ≤ a2 := a32 , because of the former lemma, so if this is nonzero, then for some direct factors OIP1 (l1 ) and OIP1 (l2 ) appearing in the decomposition it is a2 a1 0 ≤ l1 + b + l2 ≤ +b+ (4.25) 3 3
Constraining the Kähler Moduli in the Heterotic Standard Model
13
b) Remark that π1∗ π2∗ I = β1∗ β2∗ I = β1∗ OIP1 (−3) = O X (−3φ).
(4.26)
since β2∗ I = OIP1 (− p1 − p2 − p3 ) ∼ = OIP1 (−3) (because Z lies in the fibers of β2 at three different points p1 , p2 , p3 ∈ IP1 ). Therefore X , I (a1 τ1 + bφ)) = H 0 (B1 , π1∗ π2∗ I ⊗ O B1 (a1 τ1 + bφ)) 0 = H 0 ( = H 0 (B1 , O B1 (a1 τ1 + (b − 3)φ)), and we conclude using the previous corollary.
(4.27)
4.2. The hidden bundle. Let H be a rank-2 subbundle of the vector bundle Eh → X , adjoint representation of the hidden E 8 gauge group, defined through the short exact sequence 0 −→ O X (2τ1 + τ2 − φ) −→ H −→ O X (−2τ1 − τ2 + φ) −→ 0.
(4.28)
By construction of the extension, the determinant line bundle associated to H is trivial, thus the slope of the rank-2 vector bundle is µ(H) = 0. On the other hand, O X (2τ1 + τ2 − φ) admits a morphism to H as it is shown in the diagram (4.28), therefore given a polarization H = O Z+ , we have X (xτ1 + yτ2 + zφ) with x, y, z ∈ Z 2 2 2 µ O X (2τ1 +τ2 − φ) = H · O X (2τ1 +τ2 −φ) = 3(x +2y + 6x z +12yz) > 0, (4.29) that is positive for all H ∈ K(X ), thus µ O X (2τ1 + τ2 − φ) > µ(H), which means that O X (2τ1 + τ2 − φ) is a destabilizing line bundle for H. As H is not stable, we cannot integrate the hermitian Yang-Mills equations in order to construct an SU (2)-instanton on H. We must substitute H in order to find a sensible vacuum for the heterotic string. 4.3. The visible bundle. Here we recall the construction of the visible bundle, [2]. First it is defined as an equivariant rank 2 vector bundle V2 on B of trivial determinant given as a nontrivial extension 0 −→ O B (−2F) −→ V2 −→ I Z (2F) −→ 0,
(4.30)
with Z the scheme of 9 points, together with an equivariant structure on V2 so that this extension is equivariant ∗ 0 −→ O X (−2φ) −→ π2 V2 −→ I (2φ) −→ 0.
(4.31)
Recall that is the lifting to X of Z by the second projection. Then the visible rank 4 vector bundle V4 of the trivial determinant is defined through the extension 0 −→ O(−τ1 + τ2 ) ⊕ O(−τ1 + τ2 ) −→ V4 −→ V2 (τ1 − τ2 ) −→ 0,
(4.32)
together with an equivariant structure making this extension equivariant, and general among such extensions. We will show there exists some equivariant line bundle O X (x 1 τ1 + x 2 τ2 + yφ), thus of corresponding class of divisors H being invariant, i.e. H = x1 τ1 + x2 τ2 + yφ, such
14
T. L. Gómez, S. Lukic, I. Sols
that the integers x, y, z are positive (thus O X (x 1 τ1 + x 2 τ2 + yφ) equivariantly ample) and making the equivariant bundle V4 equivariantly stable. The degree of a line bundle O X (a1 τ1 + a2 τ2 + bφ), with respect to the polarization H is H 2 (a1 τ1 + a2 τ2 + b f ) = 3(x1 + x2 + 6y)(a1 x2 + a2 x1 ) + x1 x2 (3a1 + 3a2 + 18b)
(4.33) = 3x2 (2x1 + x2 + 6y)a1 + 3x1 (x1 + 2x2 + 6y)a2 + 6x1 x2 b.
Clearly, this degree function is strictly monotonous with respect to the obvious partial ordering among these line bundles or triples of integers (a1 , a2 , b). Now we will list all possible subsheaves. 1). Possible line subbundles. For this we see the first necessary conditions on a1 , a2 , b for π2∗ V2 to admit O X (a1 τ1 + a2 τ2 + bφ) as an equivariant line subbundle 0 −→ O X (−2φ) −→
π2∗ V2 −→ I (2φ) −→ 0. (4.34) ↑ O (a τ + a τ + bφ) 2 2 X 1 1
If a1 ≤ 0 and a2 ≤ 0 and b ≤ −2 − 13 (a1 + a2 ) is not fulfilled, then the intersection of this subbundle with the one on the left must be null, so O X (a1 τ1 +a2 τ2 + bφ) becomes an equivariant subsheaf of the one on the right, thus giving an equivariant nonzero section of O X (−a1 τ1 − a2 τ2 + bφ) vanishing at . We thus get possibilities 1 i) a1 ≤ 0 and a2 ≤ −1 and b ≤ 2 − (a1 + a2 ), 3 1 ii) a1 ≤ 0 and a2 = 0 and b ≤ −1 − a1 , 3 1 iii) a1 ≤ 0 and a2 ≤ 0 and b ≤ −2 − (a1 + a2 ). 3
(4.35)
For ii) we have used Lemma 2 b). Let us find now necessary conditions for the existence of an equivariant rank 1 reflexive sheaf, i.e. equivariant subbundle O X (a1 τ1 +a2 τ2 +bφ), of V4 : −→ π2∗ V2 (τ1 − τ2 ) −→ 0. 0 −→ O X (−τ1 + τ2 ) ⊕ O X (−τ1 + τ2 ) −→ V4 (4.36) ↑ O X (a1 τ1 + a2 τ2 + bφ) By the same argument as above, combined with our former discusion on equivariant line subbundles of π2∗ V2 , we obtain these possibilities: 1 i.1) a1 ≤ −1 and a2 ≤ 1 and b ≤ − (a1 + a2 ), 3 1 i.2) a1 ≤ 1 and a2 ≤ −2 and b ≤ 2 − (a1 + a2 ), 3 2 1 i.3) a1 ≤ 1 and a2 = −1 and b ≤ − − a1 , 3 3 1 i.4) a1 ≤ 1 and a2 ≤ −1 and b ≤ −2 − (a1 + a2 ). 3 2). Possible reflexive sheaves of rank 2.
(4.37)
Constraining the Kähler Moduli in the Heterotic Standard Model
15
Let us consider now an equivariant reflexive subsheaf of rank 2 ∗ 0 −→ O X (−τ1 + τ2 ) ⊕ O X (−τ1 + τ2 ) −→ V4 −→ π2 V2 (τ1 − τ2 ) −→ 0 (4.38) ↑ R2
having nonnegative degree. Since all of its equivariant line subbundles, as equivariant subbundles of V4 , must have, as seen, negative degree, the reflexive sheaf R2 is equivariantly semistable. If its intersection with the subbundle of V4 in its above presentation were not zero, then there would be a nonzero equivariant morphism R2 −→ O X (−τ1 + τ2 ) ⊕ O X (−τ1 + τ2 ) ,
(4.39)
between both equivariantly semistable sheaves, so that the first should have slope not bigger than the slope of the second, i.e. R2 should have degree not bigger than the degree of the direct sum, which is negative (as seen in the former step). We thus obtain an injection 0 −→ R2 −→ V2 (τ1 − τ2 ) −→ Q −→ 0,
(4.40)
between these equivariant reflexive sheaves of rank 2, thus its quotient Q is a torsion sheaf. We thus obtain a nonzero equivariant morphism O X (a1 τ1 + a2 τ2 + bφ) =
2
R2 −→
2
V2 (τ1 − τ2 ) = O X (2τ1 − 2τ2 ). (4.41)
Therefore, necessarily 1 ii.1) a1 ≤ 2 and a2 ≤ −2 and b ≤ − (a1 + a2 ). (4.42) 3 The top case a1 = 2 and a2 = −2 and b = 0, would give a contradiction to what we want to prove, if it occurred, since no polarization of X giving negative degree to O(−τ1 + τ2 ) ⊕ O(−τ1 + τ2 ) would give negative degree to O X (2τ1 − 2τ2 ), but fortunately it does not occur. Indeed, if this were the case, then the quotient Q would be supported in codimension at least two, but this is incompatible with the kernel R2 of such a quotient being reflexive, unless Q = 0, i.e. R2 ∼ = V2 (τ1 − τ2 ), thus splitting the sequence presenting V4 . This would contradict the genericity of the extension taken in its presentation. Therefore, we get three subcases: 1 ii.1.a) a1 ≤ 1 and a2 ≤ −2 and b ≤ − (a1 + a2 ), 3 1 ii.1.b) a1 ≤ 2 and a2 ≤ −3 and b ≤ − (a1 + a2 ), 3 1 ii.1.c) a1 ≤ 2 and a2 ≤ −2 and b ≤ −1 − (a1 + a2 ). 3
(4.43)
3). Possible rank 3 equivariant reflexive sheaves. We can consider these equivariant subsheaves saturated, i.e. having as a quotient a rank 1 torsion free sheaf, with a line bundle O X (a1 τ1 +a2 τ2 +bφ) as dual. In other words, giving such a subsheaf is equivalent to giving an equivariant line subbundle as in the diagram −→ O 0 −→ π2∗ V2 (−τ1 + τ2 ) −→ V4∨ X (τ1 − τ2 ) ⊕ O X (τ1 − τ2 ) −→ 0. (4.44) ↑ O (a τ + a τ + bφ) 1 1 2 2 X
16
T. L. Gómez, S. Lukic, I. Sols
Here we have used that V2∨ ∼ = V2 , since it is a rank two bundle of trivial determinant. Since V4∨ has zero degree for any polarization, all we must show is that the equivariant line subbundle O X (a1 τ1 + a2 τ2 + bφ) has negative degree for the polarization we are considering. If the compositions O X (a1 τ1 + a2 τ2 + bφ) −→ O X (τ1 − τ2 ),
(4.45)
with each of the two direct factors on the right-hand side were both null, then we would have a nonzero equivariant morphism ∗ O X (a1 τ1 + a2 τ2 + bφ) −→ π2 V2 (−τ1 + τ2 ),
(4.46)
and these morphisms have already been analyzed in step one. Therefore, in our situation we are necessarily in one of the following cases: 1 iii.1) a1 ≤ 1 and a2 ≤ −1 and b ≤ − (a1 + a2 ), 3 1 iii.2) a1 ≤ −1 and a2 ≤ 0 and b ≤ 2 − (a1 + a2 ), 3 (4.47) 4 1 iii.3) a1 ≤ −1 and a2 = 1 and b ≤ − − a1 , 3 3 1 iii.4) a1 ≤ −1 and a2 ≤ 1 and b ≤ −2 − (a1 + a2 ). 3 In case iii.1), the top instance (a1 = 1 and a2 = −1 and b = 0) would provide an essential contradiction to what we want, if it ocurred, since no polarization giving O X (τ1 − τ2 ) negative degree could also give negative degree to the bundle O X (−τ1 + τ2 ) ⊕ O (−τ + τ ) in the presentation of V . Fortunately, this instance does not occur. 1 2 4 X Indeed, in such a case the above morphism O (a τ + a τ + bφ) → O (τ − τ ) would 1 1 2 2 1 2 X X be isomorphic, thus splitting the bottom sequence presenting V3 in the diagram 0 −→ O X (−τ1 + τ2 ) ⊕ O X (−τ1 + τ2 ) −→ V4 −→ V2 (τ1 − τ2 ) −→ 0, (4.48) inclusion ↑ of one summand ↑ ↑ id. 0 −→ O (−τ + τ ) −→ V −→ V (τ − τ ) −→ 0, 1 2 3 2 1 2 X in contradiction with the fact that the extension presenting V4 has been taken to be general, with both of its components in the decomposition Ext 1 (V2 (τ1 − τ2 ), O X (−τ1 + τ2 ) ⊕ O X (−τ1 + τ2 )) 1 1 = Ext (V2 (τ1 − τ2 ), O X (−τ1 + τ2 )) ⊕ Ext (V2 (τ1 − τ2 ), O X (−τ1 + τ2 ))
(4.49)
being nonzero. Therefore, the first case splits into three subcases: 1 iii.1.a) a1 ≤ 0 and a2 ≤ −1 and b ≤ − (a1 + a2 ), 3 1 iii.1.b) a1 ≤ 1 and a2 ≤ −2 and b ≤ − (a1 + a2 ), (4.50) 3 1 iii.1.c) a1 ≤ 1 and a2 ≤ −1 and b ≤ −1 − (a1 + a2 ). 3 Summing up, the vector bundle V4 will then be stable if all the subsheaves that we have listed have negative degree. Recall that the degree d(x1 , x2 , y, a1 , a2 , b) is monotonous in a1 , a2 and b, so in each case it is enough to check that it is negative when these numbers take the maximum possible value. Therefore, we get the following sufficient conditions for a polarization to make V4 stable:
Constraining the Kähler Moduli in the Heterotic Standard Model
17
Fig. 1. Polarizations which make V4 stable
Proposition 1. The vector bundle V4 is equivariantly stable for any polarization O X (x 1 , x 2 , y) admitting equivariant structure (for instance, x 1 , x 2 multiple of 3) and making the number d(x1 , x2 , y, a1 , a2 , b) := 3(x1 + x2 +6y)(a1 x2 + a2 x1 )+x1 x2 (3a1 + 3a2 +18b) (4.51) negative for the following triples (a1 , a2 , b) of integers i.1) (−1, 1, 0), i.2) (1, −2, 7/3), i.3) (1, −1, −1), ii.1.b) (2, −3, 0), ii.1.c) (2, −2, −1), iii.1.a) (0, −1, 0), iii.2) (−1, 0, 5/3).
(4.52)
Remark. We have removed some cases which are redundant. For instance, case i.4) corresponds to the point (1, −1, −2), but this case is automatic once case i.3), corresponding to (1, −1, −1), has been checked, since the degree function is monotonous in a1 , a2 and b. Using the proposition, it is easy to find examples of ample sheaves which make V4 stable. For instance, O X (18τ1 + 21τ2 + 49φ). In Figure 1 we have ploted the region of ample bundles which satisfy the conditions of Proposition 1, and hence make stable the vector bundle V4 . Acknowledgements. We would like to thank E-D. Diaconescu, R. Donagi, A. Krause, G. Moore and G. Torroba for useful discussions and correspondence, specially to M. E. Alolnso for help with computer algebra programs (Maple and Singular) and V. Braun for pointing out a computational mistake in a previous version of this paper; fixing the mistake led us to a more explicit form for Proposition 1. S.L. thanks the UCM Department of Algebra for hospitality during his visit.
18
T. L. Gómez, S. Lukic, I. Sols
Appendix A. Action of the Mordell-Weil Group on the Homology The Mordell-Weil group E(K ), is defined adding sections fiberwise thanks to the group structure of an elliptic curve, once the zero section is fixed. More rigorously, we define E(K ) in terms of the short exact sequence 0 −→ T −→ H2 (B, ZZ) −→ E(K ) −→ 0
(A.1)
for a certain subgroup T in H2 (B, ZZ). For our elliptic surface, we know that the Mordell-Weil group is isomorphic to ZZ ⊕ ZZ ⊕ ZZ3 and is generated by the sections ξ , α B ξ and η, thus we can express every section as xξ yα B ξ zη for x, y ∈ ZZ and z ∈ ZZ3
(A.2)
with xξ (respectively yα B ξ and zη) meaning xξ = ξ ξ . . . ξ . x
Therefore, if ta : B → B is the Mordell-Weil action of translating by the section a, we have to determine the push forwards (tξ )∗ , (tα B ξ )∗ , (tη )∗ as maps H2 (B) → H2 (B), in order to express the homology class of an arbitrary section as y
[xξ yα B ξ zη] = (tξ )∗x · (tα B ξ )∗ · (tη )∗z σ
(A.3)
with σ the zero section. The push forwards (tξ )∗ , (tη )∗ and (α B )∗ were already determined in [5], using the quotient structure of the Mordell-Weil group on H2 (B, ZZ) and computing intersection numbers with sections. Here, we state their result, and derive (tα B ξ )∗ as (α B )∗ (tξ )∗ (α B )−1 ∗ , hence we have ⎛ σ ⎞ ⎛ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 −1 −1 ⎞ ⎛ σ ⎞ ⎜ F ⎟ ⎜0 1 0 0 1 0 1 0 ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ 1,1 ⎟ ⎜ 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ 2,1 ⎟ ⎜ 0 0 0 0 0 0 −1 0 ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ 0 0 0 0 −1 0 0 1 (tξ )∗ · ⎜ 3,1 ⎟ = ⎜ ⎜ 1,2 ⎟ ⎜ 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ 2,2 ⎟ ⎜ 0 0 0 1 0 0 −1 0 ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ 3,2 ⎟ ⎜ 0 0 0 0 −1 0 0 0 ⎝ ⎠ ⎝ 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ξ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 αB ξ
0 0 1 0 0 0 1 2 0
−1 ⎟ ⎜ F ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ 0 ⎟ ⎜ 1,1 ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ 0 ⎟ ⎜ 2,1 ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ 1 ⎟ ⎜ 3,1 ⎟ ⎟·⎜ ⎟, 0 ⎟ ⎜ 1,2 ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ 0 ⎟ ⎜ 2,2 ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ 1 ⎟ ⎜ 3,2 ⎟ ⎠ ⎝ ⎠ 1 ξ 1 αB ξ
⎛ σ ⎞ ⎛ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 −1 −1 ⎞ ⎛ σ ⎞ ⎜ F ⎟ ⎜ 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 1 −1 0 ⎟ ⎜ F ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ 0 0 ⎟ ⎜ 1,1 ⎟ ⎜ 1,1 ⎟ ⎜ 0 0 −1 0 0 1 0 0 ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ 0 0 ⎟ ⎜ 2,1 ⎟ ⎜ 2,1 ⎟ ⎜ 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ 1 ⎟ ⎜ 3,1 ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 −1 1 (tα B ξ )∗ · ⎜ 3,1 ⎟ = ⎜ ⎟·⎜ ⎟, 0 1 ⎟ ⎜ 1,2 ⎟ ⎜ 1,2 ⎟ ⎜ 0 0 −1 0 0 0 0 0 ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ 0 0 ⎟ ⎜ 2,2 ⎟ ⎜ 2,2 ⎟ ⎜ 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ 0 ⎟ ⎜ 3,2 ⎟ ⎜ 3,2 ⎟ ⎜ 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 −1 1 ⎠ ⎝ ⎠ ⎝ ⎠ ⎝ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 ξ ξ 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 2 αB ξ αB ξ
(A.4)
(A.5)
Constraining the Kähler Moduli in the Heterotic Standard Model
⎛ σ ⎞ ⎛ 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 ⎜ F ⎟ ⎜ 1 ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ 1,1 ⎟ ⎜ −2/3 0 0 0 ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ 2,1 ⎟ ⎜ −2/3 0 0 0 ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ −2/3 0 0 0 (tη )∗ · ⎜ 3,1 ⎟ = ⎜ ⎜ 1,2 ⎟ ⎜ −1/3 0 1 0 ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ 2,2 ⎟ ⎜ −1/3 0 0 1 ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ 3,2 ⎟ ⎜ −1/3 0 0 0 ⎝ ⎠ ⎝ 0 0 0 0 ξ 0 0 0 0 αB ξ
19
0 0 0 0 0 0 ⎞ ⎛ σ ⎞ 0 1 1 1 0 0 ⎟ ⎜ F ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ 0 −1 0 0 −2/3 1/3 ⎟ ⎜ 1,1 ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ 0 0 −1 0 1/3 −2/3 ⎟ ⎜ 2,1 ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ 0 0 0 −1 1/3 1/3 ⎟ ⎜ 3,1 ⎟ ⎟·⎜ ⎟. 0 −1 0 0 −1/3 2/3 ⎟ ⎜ 1,2 ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ 0 0 −1 0 −1/3 −1/3 ⎟ ⎜ 2,2 ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ 1 0 0 −1 2/3 −1/3 ⎟ ⎜ 3,2 ⎟ ⎠ ⎝ ⎠ 0 0 0 0 1 0 ξ 0 0 0 0 0 1 αB ξ (A.6)
Another way of looking at these is as generators of the representation of the three matrices Mordell-Weil group in End H2 (B, ZZ) . The commutation relations [(tξ )∗ , (tα B ξ )∗ ] = 0, [(tξ )∗ , (tη )∗ ] = 0, [(tη )∗ , (tα B ξ )∗ ] = 0 are obeyed and the torsion generator (tη )∗ , verifies (tη )3∗ = 1 as expected. Thus, expanding the equation y
[xξ yα B ξ zη] = (tξ )∗x · (tα B ξ )∗ · (tη )∗z σ for the homology classes of the sections, gives us the following list6 : If x 0 2 1 y ≡ 0 (mod 3) or 1 (mod 3) or 2 (mod 3), z 0 1 2
(A.7)
(A.8)
then xξ yα B ξ zη = (1 − x − y)σ + (1/3x 2 + 1/3y 2 − 1/3x y − x − y)F + 1/3y 1,1 + 2/3x 2,1 +(1/3x +2/3y) 3,1 +2/3y 1,2 +1/3x 2,2 +(2/3x +1/3y) 3,2 + xξ + yα B ξ. If x 1 0 2 (A.9) y ≡ 2 (mod 3) or 0 (mod 3) or 1 (mod 3) z 0 1 2 then xξ yα B ξ zη = (1 − x − y)σ + (1/3x 2 + 1/3y 2 − 1/3x y − x − y + 1)F + (1/3y − 2/3) 1,1 + (2/3x − 2/3) 2,1 + (1/3x + 2/3y − 2/3) 3,1 + (2/3y − 1/3) 1,2 + (1/3x − 1/3) 2,2 + (2/3x + 1/3y − 1/3) 3,2 + xξ + yα B ξ. If x 2 1 0 (A.10) y ≡ 1 (mod 3) or 2 (mod 3) or 0 (mod 3) z 0 1 2 then xξ yα B ξ zη = (1 − x − y)σ + (1/3x 2 + 1/3y 2 − 1/3x y − x − y + 1)F + (1/3y − 1/3) 1,1 + (2/3x − 1/3) 2,1 + (1/3x + 2/3y − 1/3) 3,1 + (2/3y − 2/3) 1,2 + (1/3x − 2/3) 2,2 + (2/3x + 1/3y − 2/3) 3,2 + xξ + yα B ξ. If x 0 2 1 (A.11) y ≡ 1 (mod 3) or 2 (mod 3) or 0 (mod 3) z 0 1 2 6 It can be proven to hold by using induction.
20
T. L. Gómez, S. Lukic, I. Sols
then xξ yα B ξ zη = (1−x − y)σ +(1/3x 2 +1/3y 2 −1/3x y −x − y +2/3)F +(1/3y − 1/3) 1,1 + 2/3x 2,1 + (1/3x + 2/3y − 2/3) 3,1 + (2/3y − 2/3) 1,2 + 1/3x 2,2 + (2/3x + 1/3y − 1/3) 3,2 + xξ + yα B ξ.If
x y z
≡
1 0 0
(mod 3) or
0 1 1
(mod 3) or
2 2 2
(mod 3)
(A.12)
then xξ yα B ξ zη = (1 − x − y)σ + (1/3x 2 + 1/3y 2 − 1/3x y − x − y + 2/3)F + 1/3y 1,1 +(2/3x −2/3) 2,1 +(1/3x +2/3y−1/3) 3,1 +2/3y 1,2 +(1/3x −1/3) 2,2 + (2/3x + 1/3y − 2/3) 3,2 + xξ + yα B ξ. If
x y z
≡
2 2 0
(mod 3) or
1 0 1
(mod 3) or
0 1 2
(mod 3)
(A.13)
then xξ yα B ξ zη = (1 − x − y)σ + (1/3x 2 + 1/3y 2 − 1/3x y − x − y + 2/3)F + (1/3y −2/3) 1,1 +(2/3x −1/3) 2,1 +(1/3x +2/3y) 3,1 +(2/3y −1/3) 1,2 +(1/3x − 2/3) 2,2 + (2/3x + 1/3y) 3,2 + xξ + yα B ξ. If
x y z
≡
0 2 0
(mod 3) or
2 0 1
(mod 3) or
1 1 2
(mod 3)
(A.14)
then xξ yα B ξ zη = (1− x − y)σ +(1/3x 2 +1/3y 2 −1/3x y − x − y +2/3)F +(1/3y − 2/3) 1,1 + 2/3x 2,1 + (1/3x + 2/3y − 1/3) 3,1 + (2/3y − 1/3) 1,2 + 1/3x 2,2 + (2/3x + 1/3y − 2/3) 3,2 + xξ + yα B ξ. If
x y z
≡
1 1 0
(mod 3) or
0 2 1
(mod 3) or
2 0 2
(mod 3)
(A.15)
then xξ yα B ξ zη = (1 − x − y)σ + (1/3x 2 + 1/3y 2 − 1/3x y − x − y + 2/3)F + (1/3y −1/3) 1,1 +(2/3x −2/3) 2,1 +(1/3x +2/3y) 3,1 +(2/3y −2/3) 1,2 +(1/3x − 1/3) 2,2 + (2/3x + 1/3y) 3,2 + xξ + yα B ξ. If
x y z
≡
2 0 0
(mod 3) or
1 1 1
(mod 3) or
0 2 2
(mod 3)
(A.16)
then xξ yα B ξ zη = (1 − x − y)σ + (1/3x 2 + 1/3y 2 − 1/3x y − x − y + 2/3)F + 1/3y 1,1 +(2/3x −1/3) 2,1 +(1/3x +2/3y−2/3) 3,1 +2/3y 1,2 +(1/3x −2/3) 2,2 + (2/3x + 1/3y − 1/3) 3,2 + xξ + yα B ξ.
Constraining the Kähler Moduli in the Heterotic Standard Model
21
References 1. Banks, T., Dine, M.: Couplings and Scales in Strongly Coupled Heterotic String Theory. Nucl. Phys. B 479, 173–196 (1996) 2. Braun, V., He, Y-H., Ovrut, B.A., Pantev, T.: Vector Bundle Extensions, Sheaf Cohomology, and the Heterotic Standard Model. Adv. Theor. Math. Phys. 10, 4 (2006) 3. Braun, V., He, Y-H., Ovrut, B.A., Pantev, T.: Heterotic Standard Model Moduli. JHEP 0601, 025 (2006) 4. Braun, V., He, Y-H., Ovrut, B.A., Pantev, T.: The Exact MSSM Spectrum from String Theory. JHEP 0605, 043 (2006) 5. Braun, V., Ovrut, B.A., Pantev, T., Reinbacher, R.: Elliptic Calabi-Yau Threefolds with Z Z3 × ZZ3 Wilson Lines. JHEP 0412, 062 (2004) 6. Curio, G., Krause, A.: Nucl.Phys. B 602, 172–200 (2001) 7. Curio, G., Krause, A.: Nucl.Phys. B 693, 195–222 (2004) 8. Donagi, R., Bouchard, V.: An SU(5) Heterotic Standard Model. Phys. Lett. B 633, 483–791 (2006) 9. Donaldson, S.K., Kronheimer, P.B.: The Geometry of Four-Manifolds. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1990 10. Douglas, M.R.: The Statistics of String/M-Theory Vacua. JHEP 0305, 046 (2003) 11. Douglas, M.R., Fiol, B., Römelsberger, C.: Stability and BPS branes. JHEP 0509, 006 (2005) 12. Grassi, A., Morrison, D.R.: Automorphisms and the Kähler cone of certain Calabi-Yau manifolds. Duke Math. J. 71, 831–838 (1993) 13. Gukov, S., Kachru, S., Liu, X., McAllister, L.: Heterotic Moduli Stabilization with Fractional ChernSimons Invariants. Phys. Rev. D 69, 086008 (2004) 14. Hartshorne, R.: Algebraic Geometry. Graduate Texts in Mathematics, No. 52, New York: Springer-Verlag, 1977 15. Hoˇrava, P., Witten, E.: Eleven-dimensional supergravity on a manifold with boundary. Nucl. Phys. B 475, 94–114 (1996) 16. Joyce, D.D.: Compact Manifolds with Special Holonomy. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000 17. Looijenga, E.: Rational surfaces with an anti-canonical cycle. Ann. of Math. (2) 114, 267–322 (1981) 18. Namikawa, Yo.: On the birational structure of certain Calabi-Yau threefolds. J. Math. Kyoto Univ. 31, 151–164 (1991) 19. Schoen, C.: On the fiber products of rational elliptic surfaces with sections. Math. Ann. 197, 177–199 (1988) 20. Sharpe, E.: Kähler Cone Substructure. Adv. Theor. Math. Phys. 2, 1441 (1998) 21. Wilson, P.M.H.: The Kähler cone on Calabi-Yau threefolds. Invent. Math. 107, 561–583 (1992) 22. Witten, E.: Strong coupling expansion of Calabi-Yau compactification. Nucl. Phys. B 471, 135–158 (1996) Communicated by M.R. Douglas
Commun. Math. Phys. 276, 23–49 (2007) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-007-0339-7
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Large Time Dynamics of a Classical System Subject to a Fast Varying Force F. Castella1 , P. Degond2 , Th. Goudon3 1 IRISA & IRMAR, Université de Rennes 1, Campus de Beaulieu, 35042 Rennes Cedex, France.
E-mail:
[email protected]
2 MIP, UMR 5640 (CNRS-UPS-INSA), Université Paul Sabatier - 118, route de Narbonne,
31062 Toulouse Cedex, France. E-mail:
[email protected]
3 Team SIMPAF - INRIA Futurs & Labo. Paul Painlevé, UMR 8524, Université des Sciences et Technologies
Lille 1, F-59655 Villeneuve d’Ascq Cedex, France. E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 15 February 2006 / Accepted: 9 March 2007 Published online: 15 September 2007 – © Springer-Verlag 2007
Abstract: We investigate the asymptotic behavior of solutions to a kinetic equation describing the evolution of particles subject to the sum of a fixed, confining, Hamiltonian, and a small, time-oscillating, perturbation. The equation also involves an interaction operator which acts as a relaxation in the energy variable. This paper aims at providing a classical counterpart to the derivation of rate equations from the atomic Bloch equations. In the present classical setting, the homogenization procedure leads to a diffusion equation in the energy variable, rather than a rate equation, and the presence of the relaxation operator regularizes the limit process, leading to finite diffusion coefficients. The key assumption is that the time-oscillatory perturbation should have well-defined long time averages: our procedure includes general “ergodic” behaviors, amongst which periodic, or quasi-periodic potentials only are a particular case. 1. Setting of the Problem We consider the asymptotic behavior as ε goes to 0 of the solutions f ε (t, x, v) ≥ 0 to the following kinetic equation with relaxation term: t 2 ε ε ε = γ Q( f ε )(t, x, v), (1) ε ∂t f (t, x, v) + H0 (x, v), f + ε V ,x , f ε2 where Q( f ε )(t, x, v) := P( f ε )(t, x, v) − f ε . (2) Here, the Poisson bracket {·, ·} stands as usual for { f, g} = ∇v f · ∇x g − ∇x f · ∇v g. The position, resp. velocity, variables x, resp. v, both belong to the whole space Rd (d ≥ 1), and we shall often make use of the phase-space variable X = (x, v) ∈ R2d . Throughout this text, the Hamiltonian H0 (X ) ∈ C ∞ (R2d ) is assumed given, and confining, i.e. lim H0 (X ) = +∞.
|X |→∞
(3)
24
F. Castella, P. Degond, Th. Goudon
The right-hand-side of (1)-(2) involves a projection operator P, whose value we define as P f ε (t, X ) := f ε (t, H0 (X )), (4) where the quantity f ε (t, E) is the mean value of f ε over the energy shell S E := {X ∈ R2d s.t. H0 (X ) = E}, namely,
1 f (t, E) := f ε (t, X ) δ(H0 (X ) − E), h 0 (E) S E
δ(H0 (X ) − E) S E = H0 −1 (E) . where h 0 (E) := ε
(5) (6)
SE
Here, the measure δ(H0 (X ) − E) over S E is defined as δ(H0 (X ) − E) :=
dσ E (X ) , |∇ X H0 (X )|
(7)
where dσ E (X ) denotes the induced euclidean surface measure over the energy shell S E . The measure δ(H0 (X ) − E) is the standard micro-canonical (or Liouville) measure of statistical physics. The fact that the above objects P f ε (t, X ) and f ε (t, E) are well defined is proved later, under the main assumption that the measure δ(H0 (X ) − E) δ(H0 (X ) − E) < +∞ for almost every E ∈ H0 (R2d ) (see satisfies h 0 (E) = SE
Hypothesis 1), a requirement which somehow reinforces the fact that H0 is assumed confining. Note that throughout this text, the prototype where H0 is the harmonic oscillator H0 = Hharm = (x 2 + v 2 )/2 is relevant. The kinetic equation (1) is written in dimensionless form. The important dimensionless parameters are ε > 0, which goes to zero, and the relaxation parameter γ > 0, considered fixed. We refer to [CDG] for a thorough discussion and motivation of the scaling. The dynamics induced by Eq. (1) may be described as follows: (a)
At leading order, the evolution is driven by transport along the Hamiltonian flow of H0 , i.e. along the solutions to the Hamiltonian ODE: ∂t x(t, x, v) = ∇v H0 (t, x(t, x, v), v(t, x, v)) , ∂t v(t, x, v) = −∇x H0 (t, x(t, x, v), v(t, x, v)) ,
(b)
x(0, x, v) = x, v(0, x, v) = v.
(8)
We shall often use the phase-space notation X (t, X ) = (x(t, x, v), v(t, x, v)). Due to the scaling in (1), transport occurs at the fast time scale t/ε2 and, since H0 is confining, transport roughly induces “oscillatory” trajectories at the fast scale t/ε2 . The reference Hamiltonian H0 is perturbed by the small and oscillatory potential ε V (t/ε2 ). On the one hand, this perturbation is of size ε > 0 when compared to H0 , and ε perturbations of a Hamiltonian flow are known to modify the dynamics by an O(ε2 ) quantity, on time scales of the order 1. Time being rescaled by a factor 1/ε2 in our case, the perturbing term εV is expected to modify the dynamics by a quantity of the order 1. This is usually called a weak-coupling regime.
Large Time Dynamics
(c)
25
On the other hand, the oscillations carried by the potential V (t/ε2 ) at the fast scale t/ε2 may interact with those induced by the transport term at the same scale. Hence only the average effect – in time – of these combined oscillations is expected to influence the dynamics at dominant order. The relaxation term Q( f ε ) = P( f ε )− f ε , discussed below, models complex interaction phenomena. Since the projection operator P( f ε ) projects f ε onto functions of the energy H0 (X ) only, it is clear that Q( f ε ) redistributes the energy uniformly on each energy shell S E , or, in other words, it relaxes f ε to a solution of P f ε = f ε . Yet the fluctuations P f ε − f ε , small but definitely non-zero in (1), are transported along the Hamiltonian flow, which eventually give rise to diffusion in the energy variable. This is typically what already happens for standard diffusion limits in kinetic theory.
In a previous text [CDG], we studied the asymptotic behavior of (1) under the main assumption that the perturbing potential V (t/ε2 , x) is periodic or quasi-periodic in the fast time variable. Assuming also that the Hamiltonian flow of H0 has some stability property (an assumption that we shall need here as well, see Hypothesis 2 below), we proved that f ε goes, in some weak topology, to a function of the energy only, say F(t, H0 (X )), and that the limiting profile F(t, E) (E ∈ R) satisfies a diffusion equation in energy, of the form ∂t [h 0 (E) F(t, E)] − ∂ E [b(E) h 0 (E) ∂ E F(t, E)] = 0,
(9)
where h 0 (E) is defined in (5). The effective coefficient b(E) obtained in [CDG] is nonnegative. It takes into account the average effect, in time, of the resonant interactions between X (t/ε2 ) and the perturbation V (t/ε2 ). It also is given by an almost explicit formula involving auxiliary profile equations. For several reasons, the periodic or quasi-periodic case is unsatisfactory. Technically speaking, the limit equation is easily guessed in the (quasi-)periodic case, upon simply performing a double scale expansion in the spirit of classical homogenization theory [BLP]. On top of that, the actual proofs given in [CDG] rely on the user-friendly framework of double-scale convergence introduced in [Ng] and [A]. In essence, (quasi-)periodicity turns out to be a strong, and quantitative version of ergodicity, for which the analysis eventually reduces to conveniently adapting the tools of double-scale convergence. (Quasi-)periodicity is also restrictive from the physical viewpoint. As discussed below, Eq. (1) may describe the classical evolution, in phase space, of a collection of atoms undergoing the influence of the atomic Hamiltonian H0 , and weakly coupled to an external laser field through εV (t/ε2 ). The potential V then is roughly the electric field. Hence restricting to (quasi-)periodic V ’s means restricting to (quasi-)periodic fields. Last, the quantum equation analogous to (1) has been previously studied in [BCD, BCDG], and other, more general situations than the mere (quasi-)periodic setting have been analyzed there. The analysis performed in [BCD, BCDG] actually shows the key point is that the perturbing potential V should possess well defined long time averages 1 T of the form lim V (s) ds or so. The existence of such long time averages is T →∞ T 0 certainly implied by the much stronger (quasi-)periodicity assumption, but it definitely includes much more general “ergodic” behaviors. Adopting this point of view, our goal in the present paper is to fill the gap, i.e. to describe the asymptotic ε → 0 for more general oscillating potentials V that are not
26
F. Castella, P. Degond, Th. Goudon
(quasi-)periodic in time. The potentials we are interested in are actually of KBM type (after: Krylov, Bogolioubov, Mitropolski): they are required to possess specific long-time averages (Hypothesis 3 below). We stress that the present extension is by no means trivial. First, the mere formulation of the assumption we need on the potential, though of KBM type, is not immediate. It is an original requirement. Second, the (quasi-)periodic setting essentially requires an adaptation of tools from double-scale analysis, and allows to pass to the limit in the standard two-scale topology directly on f ε . This strategy cannot be extended in any way here. We need a variance to split f ε as P f ε + (Id − P) f ε and to pass to the limit in P f ε , exploiting a specific compactness property inherited from the structure of the equation. From this point of view, our proof shares a lot of features with the derivation of the Kubo-like formula in [GP3]. Last, an important difficulty in the analysis of (1) is created by the fact that the operator f → P f does not preserve the smoothness of f , and P f is not even once differentiable in general. This difficulty is linked with the general lack of smoothness of the energy levels S E as E varies. In the (quasi-)periodic setting, the use of a double-scale analysis allows to circumvent this difficulty, with the mere drawback that our homogenization procedure does not provide a corrector. In the present framework, the lack of smoothness of P f is more problematic, and we do need to deal with this difficulty in order to recover the necessary compactness. Our main result is the following. Theorem 1. Let f 0ε ≥ 0 be the initial data for (1). We assume that f 0ε is bounded in L 2 (R2d ). We also suppose the Hamiltonian has well-defined energy levels with finite measure (Hypothesis 1 below), the Hamiltonian flow of H0 is polynomially stable (Hypothesis 2), and the potential V has some well-defined long-time averages (Hypothesis 3). Then, the following holds: (i) The solution f ε (t, X ) to (1) admits the decomposition f ε (t, X ) = P f ε (t, X ) + εgε (t, X ), where gε is bounded in L 2 ((0, T )×R2d ) and P f ε (t, X ) is bounded in C 0 ([0, T ]; L 2 (R2d )). (ii) Up to subsequences, P f ε (t, X ) converges in C 0 ([0, T ]; L 2 (R2d )−weak) towards a function F(t, H0 (X )). (iii) The limiting function F : R+ × R → R+ satisfies the following diffusion equation in D ([0, ∞) × R): ∂t [h 0 (E) F(t, E)] − ∂ E [h 0 (E) b(E) ∂ E F(t, E)] = 0, F(0, E) = lim f 0ε (E) (the limit is in L 2 (R)-weak). ε→0
Equivalently, F satisfies 2 ∂t [h 0 (E) F(t, E)] − h 0 (E) a(E) ∂ E F(t, E) − h 0 (E) b(E) ∂ E,E F(t, E) = 0,
F(0, E) = lim f 0ε (E). ε→0
Here the coefficient a and b are defined from (20) below through a(E) = A (E), b(E) = B (E). They satisfy h 0 (E) a(E) = ∂ E [h 0 (E) b(E)] , b(E) ≥ 0.
Large Time Dynamics
27
Naturally, the above theorem extends the result obtained in [CDG] to non-periodic V ’s. More importantly, it is worth remarking that the formal structure of the formula which defines the diffusion coefficients a and b coincides with the one of eddy diffusivity in turbulence theory, see [Ta]. Before coming to the formulation of Hypothesis 1, 2, and 3, and to the proof of Theorem 1, we wish to make two comments. Equation (1) is the standard setting for the description of an atom in interaction with a light field, say a laser. This is the prototype situation we have in mind: the unperturbed Hamiltonian H0 is the atomic Hamiltonian, while the perturbation εV (t/ε2 ) is the potential energy induced by light in the vicinity of the atom. Equation (1) adopts a classical mechanics description of such an interaction. If a quantum mechanical setting is retained, the kinetic equation (1) becomes a quantum Liouville equation, also known as an atomic Bloch equation. It reads in our case
t 2 ε ε ε iε ∂t ρ (t) = H0 , ρ (t) + ε V , ρ (t) + γ Q(ρ ε (t)). (10) ε2 The unknown ρ ε (t) now is a time dependent trace class operator, called “density matrix” of the atom, all Poisson brackets in (1) have become commutators between operators in (10), and Q(ρ ε ) is a relaxation operator that plays the same role as Q( f ε ). The factor Q(ρ ε ) describes at a heuristic level the observed trend of various atomic systems to relax towards equilibria of the unperturbed Hamiltonian H0 . The relaxation term Q is well documented in the physics literature (see e.g. [Lo]), while the operator Q we introduced in [CDG] comes up in mere analogy with Q, as a classical counterpart of the quantum operator Q. The quantum setting (10) has been completely analyzed in [BCD], for potentials that are either (quasi-)periodic in time, or more generally of KBM type (with optimal convergence rates in the first situation, and no better error estimate than o(1) in the second). The main convergence result obtained in [BCD] is similar in spirit to what we prove here and in [CDG]: the atom tends to be well described by a function of the energy only, i.e. by a function N (t, n) which describes the occupation probability of the atom’s nth eigenstate at time t. The function N (t, n) plays the role of F(t, E). Yet the main difference with the classical case is that energy levels now are discrete, so that the diffusion process obtained classically for F rather becomes a discrete jump process for N . Our second comment concerns the role of the relaxation term Q. From the modeling point of view, a mathematically rigorous derivation of this term goes far beyond the scope of this paper. We simply use it as a way to take into account observed relaxation phenomena. On the other hand, the asymptotic analysis of (1) or (10) is dominated by the resonant interaction between the oscillations of V (t/ε2 ), and those induced by the transport operator ε2 ∂t + {H0 , .}. Technically, the relaxation operators Q or Q somewhat regularize the situation in this respect: they prevent the possibility of too strong resonances (small denominators), through the introduction of some damping in the model. One may then wonder what happens along the asymptotic process if the relaxation term is set to zero in the original Eqs. (1) or (10). In the quantum case, and for (quasi-)periodic potentials V , it turns out smaller damping rates of order O(εµ ) with µ < 1/2 may be considered (see [BCD, BCDG]). The usual (undamped) formulae for the Einstein rate equations [Lo] have been recovered in [BCD, BCDG]. The analysis heavily relies on small denominator estimates, perturbed Diophantine estimates, and other arguments in the same vein, in the spirit of averaging techniques for ODE’s. Yet the condition µ < 1/2
28
F. Castella, P. Degond, Th. Goudon
still means that damping should not be too small with respect to the other perturbations. In this perspective, a deep gap actually separates the case “with damping” from the case “without damping” (in this article as well as in [CDG] and [BCD, BCDG]). The mathematical and physical situation, as well as the limiting process itself, are completely different when the (possibly small) relaxation term is set to zero from the onset: indeed, the limiting equation (9) is time-irreversible, while the associated scaled Eq. (1) only becomes irreversible through the dissipation term. The route we choose here uses a heuristic, and deterministic, relaxation term. The reader may find in [CD, Ca1, Ca2] a similar model “with relaxations” used to rigorously derive the Pauli master equation from the quantum Liouville equation in a deterministic framework. A second, probably more standard approach is the introduction of stochastic averaging in the model, which gives the necessary “loss of memory” in the analysis: to some extent, deterministic relaxation terms play a similar role as the stochastic averaging process. The deep role played by stochastic averaging in the derivation of irreversible equations is very well explained in [CIP] (see also [Sp]). More recently, we may mention [EY1, EY2, PV, LV], or also [KPR]. There are actually several other examples of such an alternative: homogenization of convection(-diffusion) equations (see [GP1, GP2] and the references therein), Lorentz gas involving a billiard (see [BDG] and [BSC]), quantum scattering limit of the Schrödinger equation ([BPR, EY2, PR, PV]...). For the (space-)homogenization of kinetic equations without dissipative term, we refer e.g. to [Al, FH]. We now state the assumptions we need on the Hamiltonian H0 , and the potential V . We begin with the assumptions on H0 , which are essentially the same as in [CDG]. Hypothesis 1. (Energy levels with finite measure). We assume that the confining Hamiltonian H0 satisfies: (i) For almost all E ∈ H0 (R2d ), the set S E = {X = (x, v) ∈ R2d |H0 (X ) = E}, is a smooth orientable 2d − 1 submanifold of R2d . For any such E, we denote the induced euclidean surface measure by dσ E (X ). We also define the (microcanonical or Liouville) measure δ(H0 (X ) − E) as δ(H0 (X ) − E) =
dσ E (X ) . |∇ X H0 (X )|
(ii) For any E as in (i), the set S E has finite measure with respect to δ(H0 (X ) − E), namely h 0 (E) = δ(H0 (X ) − E) < +∞, a.e. E ∈ H0 (R2d ). SE
Remark. As noticed in [CDG], the Sard theorem asserts that Hypothesis 1-(i) is generically satisfied (see e.g. [Mi]). Hence the truly important assumption is point (ii). Hypothesis 2. (Stability of the Hamiltonian flow). Let X : (s, X ) ∈ R × R2d −→ X (s, X ) ∈ R2d be the Hamiltonian flow of H0 , namely d +∇v H0 X (s, X ) = X (s, X ) , X (0, X ) = X = (x, v). (11) −∇ H x 0 ds
Large Time Dynamics
29
We assume that the linearized flow satisfies, for any s ≥ 0 and X ∈ R2d , DX (s, X ) ≤ C(X ) (1 + s) p , DX D2 X (s, X ) ≤ C(X ) (1 + s) p , 2 DX
(12) (13)
for some C(X ) ≥ 0 which is locally bounded in X , and some exponent p ≥ 0, independently of s. Remark. The analysis provided in [CDG] for (quasi-)periodic potentials only requires the first stability estimate (12). In the present text, estimate (13) is required as well. It may be somewhat relaxed into a locally Lipschitz bound of the form |D X /D X (s, X + Y ) − D X /D X (s, X )| ≤ C(X ) |Y | (1 + s) p . We do not detail this unnecessary technical point. Remark. The crucial assumptions on H0 are Hypothesis 1-(ii) and 2. The former allows to define the relaxation operator Q (see Lemma 1 below), while the latter is a strong stability assumption on the Hamiltonian flow of H0 : according to (12), any two trajectories starting with nearby initial data should diverge at most polynomially with time. For the standard Hamiltonian H0 (X ) = v 2 /2 + V0 (x), with V0 any ‘reasonable’ potential, we recall that the generic divergence of two nearby trajectories is more likely exponential in time. Naturally, Hypotheses 1 and 2 are fulfilled in the prototype case of the harmonic oscillator Hharm (X ) = (x 2 + v 2 )/2. We mention that the stability Hypothesis 2 may be somewhat relaxed, so as to include the case of exponential divergence, i.e. the case when (1+s) p is replaced by exp(C1 s) for some C1 > 0. However, this can only be done at the (unreasonable) price of considering large enough values of the relaxation parameter γ , namely γ > C1 . We do not dwell on this aspect of the analysis. As proved in [CDG], Hypothesis 1 allows to properly define the operators and P, as in (4) and (5). This gives a well-defined relaxation operator Q = Id − P in (1). The basic observation is that the co-area formula reads, with the above notations 1 2d f (X ) d X = f (E) h 0 (E) d E. (14) ∀ f ∈ L (R ), R2d
R
Armed with (14), one may indeed deduce (see [CDG]) the following Lemma 1. The operator P defined in (4) satisfies the following properties: (i)
P is a continuous projection operator on L p spaces: P(P f ) = P f,
P f L p (R2d ) ≤ f L p (R2d ) 1 ≤ p ≤ ∞.
Besides P is conservative: for any integrable function, we have Pf dX = f d X. R2d
R2d
30
(ii)
F. Castella, P. Degond, Th. Goudon
P is self-adjoint with respect to the inner product of L 2 (R2d ) (denoted ·, · throughout the paper): for any function f ∈ L 2 (R2d ) and ϕ : R → R such that ϕ(H0 (X )) ∈ L 2 (R2d ), we have ϕ(H0 (X )), (Id − P) f = 0.
(iii)
P is non negative: if f ≥ 0 a.e. X , then P f ≥ 0 a.e. X as well. Moreover, the stronger relation holds: f ≥ 0 a.e. X, and P f = 0 a.e. X =⇒ f = 0 a.e. X.
(iv) The operators f −→ P f and f −→ {H0 , f } are orthogonal, i.e. the relation P {H0 , f } = 0, holds for any f ∈ L 2 (R2d ) such that {H0 , f ∈ L 2 (R2d ). Consequently, for any f, g ∈ L 2 (R2d ) such that {H0 , f and {H0 , g in L 2 (R2d ), we have P({H0 , f } g) = −P( f {H0 , g}). (v) The operator Q = Id − P is a bounded operator on L 2 (R2d ) and the relation |P f − f |2 d X ≥ 0 − Q( f ) f d X = R2d
R2d
holds for any f ∈ L 2 (R2d ). (vi) Let V : R × R2d → R be a C 1 function. Let ϕ ∈ Cc∞ (R). We have P {V(t), ϕ(H0 )} = 0. Remark. Point (v) asserts that Q relaxes towards solutions to P f = f , and the rate of convergence is unity. The proof of point (vi) relies on the equality P {V, ϕ(H0 )} (X ) = P ({V, H0 }) (X ) ∂ E ϕ(H0 (X )) = 0. There remains to specify the behavior of the perturbing potential V (s, x) in the fast time variable s. This is the main new point in the present paper. To motivate our approach, let us describe the situation in the quantum case, i.e. when analyzing (10) instead of (1). The key point in [BCD, BCDG] is the following: one may transform the original PDE (10) into an infinite dimensional ODE, which in turn very much behaves like a finite dimensional ODE with oscillatory coefficients (up to small remainder terms), of the form d t yε (t) = ψ , yε (t) . (15) dt ε2 As a consequence, the quantum problem (10) reduces, in essence, to performing an averaging procedure on the ODE (15). Now, the basic averaging theorem for ODE’s (see e.g. [SV]) asserts that the solution yε (t) to any oscillatory ODE of the form (15), converges in some topology towards the solution of the averaged ODE d 1 T = lim y(t) = ψ (y(t)) ψ (s, y(t)) ds , (16) T →∞ T 0 dt
Large Time Dynamics
31
provided the function ψ(s, z) has KBM dependence in the time variable s. We recall that a function ψ(s, z) is called a KBM function whenever the limit ψ (z) = lim
T →∞
1 T
T
ψ(s, z) ds
(17)
0
exists, for every z. We refer to e.g. [SV] for the precise statements concerning averaging of ODE’s. Periodic, quasi-periodic, or even almost-periodic functions of time, are obvious examples of KBM functions. In the present paper, the analysis shows that an argument similar to the one used in the quantum context [BCD, BCDG] allows to transform the original PDE (1) into a PDE with oscillatory coefficients, of the form (roughly) ∂ t t 2 yε (t, E) = α 2 , E ∂ E yε (t, E) + β , E ∂ E,E yε (t, E), (18) ∂t ε ε2 for some coefficients α and β. This result is very much in the spirit of observation (15) above. The quantitative statement is Proposition 5 below, where the relevant coefficients are the two functions A(t/ε2 , X ) and B(t/ε2 , X ) entering Hypothesis 3. Keeping in mind the paradigm (15)–(16), the natural assumption is that the time dependent coefficients α(s, E), β(s, E) (or A(s, E), B(s, E)) should have well defined long time averages in s. When V is periodic or quasi-periodic in time, this requirement is easily met, since the relevant coefficients then are (quasi-)periodic in time as well [CDG]. The natural extension, which is the purpose of this paper, is the case when the coefficients α, β (or A, B) are merely KBM. All these considerations motivate our main assumption on V : Hypothesis 3. (Existence of long-time averages of V ). (i) We assume that V ∈ Cb3 (R+ × Rd ) is bounded with bounded derivatives up to third order. (ii) Introduce the family of transport operators associated to the Hamiltonian flow of H0 , Su (ϕ)(X ) := ϕ X (u, X ) . For any t ≥ 0, define the functions
t
A(t, X ) :=
e−γ u {V (t) , Su {V (t + u) , H0 }} du,
0
t
B(t, X ) :=
e−γ u {V (t), H0 } × Su {V (t + u) , H0 } du.
0
We assume that A and B admit long-time averages, in that the following limits 2d exist in L ∞ loc (R )-weak- : A (X ) := lim
T →+∞
1 T
0
T
A(s, X ) ds, B (X ) := lim
T →+∞
1 T
T
B(s, X ) ds.
0
(19)
32
F. Castella, P. Degond, Th. Goudon
(iii) Furthermore, we assume that the following limits hold true: t t A 2 , X A (X ), B , X B (X ), ε ε2 + 2d in L ∞ loc (R × R ) − weak − .
(20)
Remark. Assumption (i) may be somewhat relaxed in that V may be assumed Cb2 , with a Lipschitz second derivative, globally in time, locally in X . We do not detail this technical aspect. The above assumption requires some comments. An important hypothesis is point (i). Indeed, we show below (Proposition 2) that the assumed regularity on V and H0 implies the coefficients A and B are bounded, T globally in time t ≥ 0, and locally in X . Hence the sequences 1/T 0 · · · are bounded 2d in L ∞ loc (R ), and they possess (up to subsequences) weak- limits as T → ∞, limits that are automatically independent of time. This ensures the validity of statement (ii), of KBM type. The same argument shows the sequences A(t/ε2 , X ) and B(t/ε2 , X ) + 2d also are bounded in L ∞ loc (R × R ), hence possess weak- limits as ε → 0. The point is, assertion (iii) requires these limits are independent of t. This in turn implies that A(t/ε2 , X ) automatically goes to A (X ), and similarly for B. In summary, assumption (iii) is considerably stronger than (ii). It should also be noted that, in the context of T ODE’s, the averaging of (15) only requires the long time averages 1/T 0 ψ(s, z)ds converge, while in the present PDE context, we do need the reinforced assumption (iii). The remainder of this paper is devoted to the proof of Theorem 1. 2. Proof of Theorem 1 2.1. Two uniform bounds. Our analysis starts with the Proposition 1. Suppose the initial data f 0ε is bounded in L 2 (R2d ). Then, ∞ (R+ ; L 2 (R2d )). (i) The family ( f ε )ε>0 is bounded in L ε ε f − Pf (ii) The family g ε )ε>0 := is bounded in L 2 (R+ × R2d ). ε ε>0
Proof of Proposition 1. We readily observe γ 1 d ε 2 ε ε | f | dX = γ Q( f ) f d X = − 2 |P f ε − f ε |2 d X ≤ 0, 2 dt R2d ε R2d R2d where Lemma 1-(vi) has been used. For later convenience, we also state and prove the following easy, yet crucial, uniform bound on the coefficients A(t/ε2 , X ) and B(t/ε2 , X ) entering Hypothesis 3. Proposition 2. Suppose Hypotheses 2 and 3 are fulfilled. Let 0 < R < ∞ and set E(R) := {X ∈ R2d , |H0 (X )| ≤ R},
B(R) := {X ∈ R2d , |X | ≤ R}.
(i) There exists 0 < ρ(R) < ∞ such that any X ∈ E(R) belongs to B(ρ(R)) as well. Moreover, for any X ∈ E(R) and u ∈ R, we have X (u, X ) ∈ B(0, ρ(R)) too.
Large Time Dynamics
33
(ii) There exists a function C(R), bounded for bounded values of R > 0, such that sup sup sup V (t/ε2 − u) , H0 Su V (t/ε2 ) , H0 ≤ C(R), ε>0 t≥0 X ∈E (R)
sup sup
sup
ε>0 t≥0 X ∈E (R)
V (t/ε2 − u) , Su V (t/ε2 ) , H0 ≤ C(R) (1 + u) p ,
whenever u ≥ 0. The exponent p is as in Hypothesis 3. (iii) There exists a function C(R), bounded for bounded values of R > 0, such that1 C(R) t sup sup sup A 2 , X ≤ p+1 , ε γ ε>0 t≥0 X ∈E (R) C(R) t sup sup sup B . , X ≤ 2 ε γ ε>0 t≥0 X ∈E (R)
Here, functions A and B are as in Hypothesis 3. Proof of Proposition 2. The fact that H0 is confining (3) readily implies point (i). Next, point (ii) comes as an immediate consequence of the regularity assumptions we have made on H0 and V . Indeed, we may write, whenever ε > 0, t ≥ 0, and X ∈ E(R), V (t/ε2 − u) , H0 Su V (t/ε2 ) , H0 ≤ ∇x V 2L ∞ (R×B(ρ(R))) ∇v H0 2L ∞ (B(ρ(R)) ≤ C(R), where C(R) is a locally bounded function of R. Similarly, we have V (t/ε2 − u) , Su V (t/ε2 ) , H0 D X (u, X ) ≤ ∇x V L ∞ (R×B(ρ(R))) × ∞ DX L (B(ρ(R)))
2 × Dx V L ∞ (R×B(ρ(R))) ∇v H0 L ∞ (B(ρ(R))) 2 + ∇x V L ∞ (R×B(ρ(R))) Dx,v H0 L ∞ (B(ρ(R))) ≤ C(R) × (1 + u) p . The last line uses Hypothesis 3. Point (iii) is easily deduced, since, for any ε > 0, t ≥ 0, and X ∈ E(R), we have the two upper bounds +∞ 2 e−γ u du ≤ C(R) γ −1 , |B(t/ε , X )| ≤ C(R) 0 +∞ 2 |A(t/ε , X )| ≤ C(R) e−γ u (1 + u) p du ≤ C(R) γ − p−1 . 0
1 Note that we implicitly assume here γ < 1 – this is no loss of generality.
34
F. Castella, P. Degond, Th. Goudon
2.2. Obtaining an equation for P f ε . The following result completes the previous Proposition 1, according to which f ε = P f ε + O(ε): we derive here an equation for P f ε . We mention that the splitting f ε = P f ε + ε g ε into a (dominant) function of the energy, and a (smaller) fluctuation term, is partly motivated by a similar decomposition occurring in the quantum context, see [BCD, BCDG]. The crucial point is that the dominant function of the energy turns out to satisfy a closed equation (up to small remainder terms). Note that [CDG] follows a completely different approach, based on a double-scale convergence analysis for f ε itself. Proposition 3. The function P f ε = P f ε (t, X ) satisfies the equation ∂t P f ε (t, X ) = L ε P f ε (t, X ) + ε R ε (t, X ) + I ε (t, X ) .
(1)
The leading term L ε (P f ε ) is a second order, linear operator, with memory term and oscillatory coefficients. It has the value L
ε
Pf
ε
t/ε2
e−γ u P
(t, X ) = 0
V (t/ε2 ) , S−u
V (t/ε2 − u) , P f ε (t − ε2 u)
du.
The remainder and initial terms R ε and I ε are R ε (t, X ) =
t/ε2
e−γ u P
0 ε
I (t, X ) = −ε−1 e−γ t/ε
2
V (t/ε2 ) , S−u V (t/ε2 − u) , g ε (t − ε2 u) du, P V (t/ε2 ) , S−t/ε2 g0ε .
The picture given in Proposition 3 is made complete through the next technical statement, according to which operators L ε , R ε , and I ε are bounded in some weak topology. Proposition 4. Let ϕ : R → R be a C ∞ compactly supported function. Then, there exists a constant C > 0, depending on γ , supp(ϕ), H0 and V , such the following estimates hold true: ε ε sup L P f (t, X ) ϕ(H0 (X )) d X ≤ C ϕ W 2,∞ (R) , (2) t≥0
R2d
2 ∞ ε dt ≤ C ϕ 2 2,∞ , R (t, X ) ϕ(H (X )) d X 0 2d W (R ) 0 R ∞ 2 ε dt ≤ C ϕ 2 1,∞ . I (t, X ) ϕ(H (X )) d X 0 2d W (R )
0
R
(3) (4)
Proof of Proposition 3. Proposition 1 naturally leads to splitting the original kinetic equation (1) on f ε into an equation for P f ε , and an equation on g ε = ( f ε − P f ε )/ε. We have on the one hand 1 1 ∂t P f ε = − P V (t/ε2 ), f ε = − P V (t/ε2 ), P f ε − V (t/ε2 ), g ε ε ε = −P V (t/ε2 ), g ε ,
Large Time Dynamics
35
(Lemma 1 has been used, which allows to cancel the O(1/ε) contribution), while, on the other hand ε2 ∂t g ε + H0 , g ε + γ g ε = − V (t/ε2 ), P f ε − ε (Id − P) V (t/ε2 ), g ε . Hence we arrive at a system with a particular triangular structure, namely, ∂t P f ε = −P V (t/ε2 ), g ε , ε2 ∂t g ε + H0 , g ε + γ g ε = − V (t/ε2 ), P f ε − ε (Id − P) V (t/ε2 ), g ε .
(5) (6)
The similar (and crucial) structure is involved in the quantum case (see [BCD, BCDG]). Exploiting this observation, one may first express g ε as a function of P f ε : the method of characteristics readily gives
t/ε2 2 g ε (t, X ) = e−γ t/ε g0ε X (−t/ε2 , X ) − e−γ u V (·/ε2 ) , P f ε 0
× t − ε2 u, X (−u, X ) du t/ε2
−ε e−γ u (Id − P) V (·/ε2 ) , g ε t − ε2 u, X (−u, X ) du.
(7)
0
Now, inserting (7) into (5) roughly gives a closed equation on P f ε , namely ∂t P f ε = L ε P f ε + ε Rε + ε I ε , t/ε2 with Rε = e−γ u P V (t/ε2 ) , (Id − P) S−u V (t/ε2 −u) , g ε (t − ε2 u) du. 0
There remains to observe that, for any u, we have P
V (t/ε2 ) , P S−u
V (t/ε2 − u) , g ε (t − ε2 u)
= 0,
by virtue of Lemma 1. Hence R ε = R ε , and the proposition is proved.
Proof of Proposition 4. Let us pick some R > 0 such that supp ϕ ⊂ (−R, +R). Proposition 2-(i) implies ϕ(H0 (X )) = 0 whenever |X | ≥ ρ(R). Actually, using the energy conservation, the function Su ϕ(H0 ) ≡ ϕ(H0 ) is supported in B(ρ(R)) for any u ≥ 0. This observation is used repeatedly below. First step: Proof of estimate (2) on L ε . Upon using the definition of L ε , performing the obvious integration by parts, and systematically exploiting the identity {V, ϕ(H0 )} = {V, H0 } ∂ E ϕ(H0 ) and so on, we obtain,
36
F. Castella, P. Degond, Th. Goudon
R2d
L ε (P f ε )(t, X ) ϕ(H0 (X )) d X
=
R2d
=
R2d
=
R2d
=
t/ε2 0
e−γ u P V (t/ε2 ), S−u V (t/ε2 − u), P f ε (t − ε2 u) ϕ(H0 ) du d X
t/ε2 −γ u
P f ε (t − ε2 u) V (t/ε2 − u) , Su V (t/ε2 ) , ϕ(H0 ) du d X
t/ε2 −γ u
P f ε (t − ε2 u) V (t/ε2 − u) , Su V (t/ε2 ) , H0 ∂ E ϕ(H0 ) du d X
e
0
e
0
V (t/ε2 − u) , H0 Su V (t/ε2 ) , H0 ∂ E2 E ϕ(H0 ) ∂ E ϕ(H0 ) du d X. + V (t/ε2 − u) , Su V (t/ε2 ) , H0
t/ε2 −γ u
e
R2d
0
P f ε (t − ε2 u)
This together with Proposition 2-(ii) allows to estimate ε ε 2d L (P f )(t, X ) ϕ(H0 ) d X R t/ε2 ≤ C(R) ϕ W 2,∞ (R) e−γ u P f ε (t − ε2 u) 1 B(ρ(R)) (1 + u p ) du d X 2d R 0 ∞ ε e−γ u (1 + u p ) du ≤ C(R) ϕ W 2,∞ (R) f L ∞ (R+ ;L 2 (R2d )) |B(ρ(R))|1/2 ≤ C(R) γ
−p
0
ϕ W 2,∞ (R) ,
where the indicator function 1 B(ρ(R)) is used to keep track of the compact support of ϕ, while the last estimate uses Proposition 1. Second step: Proof of estimate (3) on R ε . The proof follows the same lines as before. Multiplying R ε by the trial function ϕ(H0 ) and performing the obvious integration by parts, we obtain R ε (t, X ) ϕ(H0 (X )) d X R2d
=
=
R2d
g ε (t − ε2 u) e−γ u
V (t/ε2 − u) , Su V (t/ε2 ) , ϕ(H0 ) du d X.
0
R2d
t/ε2
g ε (t − ε2 u) e−γ u V (t/ε2 − u) , H0 } Su V (t/ε2 ) , H0 ∂ E2 E ϕ(H0 ) 0 ∂ E ϕ(H0 ) du d X. + V (t/ε2 − u) , Su V (t/ε2 ) , H0 t/ε2
As a consequence, using Proposition 2-(ii), we recover 2 ∞ ε R (t, X ) ϕ(H0 ) d X dt 0
R2d
≤ C(R) ϕ 2W 2,∞ (R) ≤ C(R)
ϕ 2W 2,∞ (R)
0
2 t/ε2 |g ε (t − ε2 u)| e−γ u(1 + u p ) 1 B(ρ(R)) du d X dt R2d 0
∞
g ε 2L 2 (R×R2d ) γ −2 p ≤ C(R) γ −2 p ϕ 2W 2,∞ (R) .
Large Time Dynamics
37
The last estimate uses Proposition 1. Third step: Proof of estimate (4) on I ε . We write ε 2d I (t, X ) ϕ(H0 ) d X R −1 −γ t/ε2 ε 2 = ε e g0 (X ) St/ε2 V (t/ε ), H0 ∂ E ϕ(H0 (X )) d X R2d 2 ≤ C(R) ϕ W 1,∞ (R) ε−1 e−γ t/ε |g0ε (X )|1 B(ρ(R)) d X ≤ C(R) ϕ W 1,∞ (R) ε Hence +∞ 0
R2d −1 −γ t/ε2
e
f 0ε L 2 (R2d ) .
2 I (t, X ) ϕ(H0 ) d X dt ≤ C(R) ϕ W 1,∞ (R) ε
R2d
+∞
ε−2 e−2γ t/ε dt 2
0
≤ C(R) γ −1 ϕ 2W 1,∞ (R) .
This ends the proof of Proposition 4.
2.3. Analysis of the memory effect. Proposition 3 establishes the equation ∂t (P f ε ) = L ε (P f ε ) + O(ε), where the operator L ε is a second order differential operator involving both a memory effect (this is the term P f ε (t −ε2 u)) and coefficients that oscillate in time (these are the terms V (t/ε2 ) etc.). The next proposition allows to get rid of the memory effect, and to somewhat put in evidence the true difficulty of the present analysis, namely the presence of time oscillatory terms. Proposition 5. For any smooth test functions ζ (t) ∈ Cc∞ (R+ ) and ϕ(E) ∈ Cc∞ (R), we have ∞ P f 0ε (X ) ϕ(H0 (X )) ζ (0) d X + P f ε (t, X ) ϕ(H0 (X )) ζ (t) dt d X 0 R2d R2d
∞ t t ε 2 P f (t, X ) A 2 , X ∂ E ϕ(H0 ) + B , X ∂ E E ϕ(H0 ) + ε ε2 R2d 0 ×ζ (t) d X dt = O(ε), (8) where O(ε) is estimated by Cε for some C, independent of ε, which depends on the test functions ζ and ϕ. Here, the coefficients A(t/ε2 , X ) and B(t/ε2 , X ) are defined in Hypothesis 3. Proof of Proposition 5. Propositions 3 and 4 readily give, upon testing Eq. (1) against ζ (t) ϕ(H0 (X )), ∞ (P f ε )(0, X ) ϕ(H0 (X )) ζ (0) + (P f ε )(t, X ) ϕ(H0 (X )) ζ (t) 2d 2d R R 0 ∞ ε ε L (P f )(t, X ) ϕ(H0 (X )) ζ (t) dt d X = O(ε). + 0
R2d
38
F. Castella, P. Degond, Th. Goudon
Now, the proof of Proposition 4 (estimate (2)) provides the weak form of the operator L ε , namely ∞ L ε (P f ε )(t, X ) ϕ(H0 (X )) ζ (t) dt d X 0
=
R2d ∞
0
t/ε2
e−γ u P f ε (t, X ) × V (t/ε2 ) , H0 Su V (t/ε2 + u) , H0 ∂ E2 E ϕ(H0 ) ∂ E ϕ(H0 ) ζ (t + ε2 u) du d X dt. (9) + V (t/ε2 ) , Su V (t/ε2 + u) , H0 R2d
0
In order to replace ζ (t + ε2 u) by ζ (t) in (9), we evaluate the difference (here, we do not rewrite the exact value of the term between brackets), 2 ∞ t/ε e−γ u P f ε (t, X ) [· · · ] ζ (t + ε2 u) − ζ (t) du d X dt 0 R2d 0 t/ε2 ≤ ε2 × T ζ L ∞ × u e−γ u P f ε L ∞ (R+ ;L 2 (R2d )) [· · · ] L 2 (R2d ) du 0
≤ ε × T ζ L ∞ × C(R) ϕ W 2,∞ × 2
t/ε2
u (1 + u) p e−γ u du
0
≤ C ε2 , where we used Propositions 1 and 2, and the last constant C depends on T , R, γ , ϕ and ζ . The proposition is proved. 2.4. Compactness properties. According to Proposition 5, the limiting dynamics of P f ε may be obtained upon averaging out the coefficients A(t/ε2 , X ) and B(t/ε2 , X ) in Eq. (8). The averaging procedure naturally needs bounds together with compactness properties. These elements are essentially gathered in Proposition 6. Yet the compactness at hand is not enough to conclude at once, since Eq. (8) involves products of weakly convergent sequences P f ε (t, X )× A(t/ε2 , X ) and P f ε (t, X )× B(t/ε2 , X ). The crucial point, which allows to deal with such products, is that the function P f ε (t, X ) possesses some compactness in the time variable t, while A(t/ε2 , X ) and B(t/ε2 , X ) have some compactness in the phase-space variable X . Based on this observation Proposition 7 shows one can pass to the weak limit in the above products. The idea of exploiting this particular structure in products of weakly convergent sequences is borrowed from a similar observation made in [Li] in a different context. It may also be seen as a version of the compensated-compactness principle. Let us come to the details. We first state Proposition 6. Take any time T > 0. −2,1 (i) The sequence (∂t [h 0 (E) (f ε )(t, E)])ε>0 is bounded in L 2 (0, T ; Wloc (R)). ε As a corollary, the sequence (h 0 (E) (f )(t, E))ε>0 is relatively compact in C 0 ([0, T ]; L 2loc (R) − weak), and the sequence ((P f ε )(t, X ))ε>0 is relatively compact in C 0 ([0, T ]; L 2loc (R2d ) − weak).
Large Time Dynamics
39
(ii) There exists a function F(t, E) ∈ C 0 (R+ ; L 2 (R)) such that, up to extracting subsequences, the family h 0 (E) (f ε )(t, E) converges to h 0 (E) F(t, E) in C 0 ([0, T ]; L 2loc (R) − weak), while the sequence (P f ε )(t, X ) converges to F(t, H0 (X )) in C 0 ([0, T ]; L 2loc (R2d ) − weak). Remark. We draw the reader’s attention to the following important difficulty. Proposition 6 asserts the sequence ((P f ε )(t, X ))ε>0 has some compactness in time. This is due to the fact that, when going to the energy variable E, the associated sequence (h 0 (E) (f ε )(t, E))ε>0 is once differentiable in time, with values lying in the negative Sobolev space W −2,1 (R), uniformly in t and ε. Note however that, though both sequences ((P f ε )(t, X ))ε>0 and (h 0 (E) (f ε )(t, E))ε>0 are roughly the same object, yet the time derivative of the sequence ((P f ε )(t, X ))ε>0 does not belong to a negative Sobolev space in any obvious way. From Proposition 6, we are able to deduce Proposition 7. Take two arbitrary test functions ζ (t) ∈ Cc∞ (R+ ) and ϕ(E) ∈ Cc∞ (R). The following convergence result holds: ∞ t (P f ε )(t, X )A 2 , X ζ (t)ϕ(H0 (X )) dtd X ε R2d 0 ∞ F(t, H0 (X ))A (X )ζ (t)ϕ(H0 (X )) dtd X. → ε→0 0
R2d
Similarly, we have, ∞ 0
t (P f ε )(t, X )B , X ζ (t)ϕ(H0 (X )) dtd X ε2 R2d ∞ F(t, H0 (X ))B (X )ζ (t)ϕ(H0 (X )) dtd X. −→ ε→0
0
R2d
Proof of Proposition 6. The whole proposition is essentially a consequence of Proposition 3 combined with the co-area formula (14). We write, taking a compactly supported test function ϕ ∈ W 2,∞ (R), ∂t h 0 (E) (f ε )(t, E) ϕ(E) d E R = ∂t P f ε (t, X ) ϕ(H0 (X )) d X (using the co-area formula) 2d R ε = L P f ε + ε R ε + ε I ε (t, X ) ϕ(H0 (X )) d X (using Proposition 3). R2d
Hence, using Proposition 4, we may upper-bound, 0
T
R
ε
∂t h 0 (E) (f )(t, E) ϕ(E) d E
2 dt ≤ C ϕ 2W 2,∞ (R) ,
−2,1 and the sequence (∂t [h 0 (E) (f ε )(t, E)])ε>0 is bounded in L 2 (0, T ; Wloc (R)).
40
F. Castella, P. Degond, Th. Goudon
On the other hand, Proposition 1 and the co-area formula allow to similarly establish that the sequence (h 0 (E) (f ε )(t, E))ε>0 is bounded in L ∞ (R+ ; L 2loc (R)). Indeed, taking a compactly supported test function ϕ ∈ L 2 (R), we may write ε h 0 (E) (f ε )(t, E) ϕ(E) d E = P f (t, X ) ϕ(H (X )) d X 0 2d R
R
≤ C ϕ(H0 (X )) L 2 (R2d ) ≤ C ϕ L 2 (R) ,
where the first inequality uses Proposition 1 and the second estimate uses once again that H0 is confining. Therefore, standard compactness results give that the sequence (h 0 (E) (f ε ) (t, E))ε>0 is relatively compact in C 0 ([0, T ]; L 2loc (R) − weak). Hence the existence of F(t, E) ∈ C 0 ([0, T ]; L 2loc (R)) such that h 0 (E) (f ε )(t, E) goes to h 0 (E) F(t, E) in C 0 ([0, T ]; L 2loc (R) − weak), as ε → 0. Besides, using the co-area formula again gives the similar compactness property for the sequence ((P f ε )(t, X ))ε>0 . Indeed, taking a compactly supported test function ψ(X ) ∈ L 2 (R2d ), we may write ε (P f )(t, X ) ψ(X ) d X = h 0 (E) (f ε )(t, E) (ψ)(E) d E R2d R −→ h 0 (E) F(t, E) (ψ)(E)d E = F(t, H0 (X )) ψ(X ) d X, R
R2d
where the convergence is uniform as t varies in compact subsets of R+ (thanks to the previous result). The proposition is now proved. Proof of Proposition 7. We only prove the first convergence result, the other one being completely similar. Our proof closely follows that of a similar statement, given in [Li] (Lemma 5.1, p. 12). We choose two cutoff functions in time, resp. in space, (X ) ∈ Cc∞ (R2d ) and χ (t) ∈ Cc∞ (R+ ), such that ≥ 0, χ ≥ 0, = 1, χ = 1. Associated with these regularizing function, we take a small parameter δ > 0, and set t 1 1 X , δ (X ) := 2d , χδ (t) := χ δ δ δ δ together with (P f ε )δ (t, X ) :=
R+
(P f ε )(t + s, X ) χδ (s) ds,
Fδ (t, X ) := F(t + s, X ) χδ (s) ds, + R t t , X := A 2 , X − Y δ (Y ) dY, Aδ 2d ε2 ε R A δ (X ) := A (X − Y ) δ (Y ) dY. R2d
With these notations, the argument, borrowed from [Li] and developed in the subsequent steps below, is the following. First, standard functional analysis shows that Proposition
Large Time Dynamics
41
7 is true when (P f ε ), A(t/ε2 , X ), F, A are replaced by (P f ε )δ , Aδ (t/ε2 , X ), Fδ and A δ , respectively. Second, the compactness of f ε in time (Proposition 6) turns out to imply some compactness of P f ε in time as well. Similarly, the coefficients A(t/ε2 , X ), B(t/ε2 , X ) are smooth in X , uniformly in t/ε2 , and for this reason they possess some compactness in X . From this it follows that the regularized function (P f ε )δ , Aδ (t/ε2 , X ), Bδ (t/ε2 , X ) go to P f ε , A(t/ε2 , X ), B(t/ε2 , X ) in some strong topology as δ goes to zero. The conclusion follows. First step: Proof of a regularized version of the proposition. We write, for any fixed value of δ > 0, ∞ t (P f ε )δ (t, X ) Aδ , X ζ (t) ϕ(H0 (X )) dt d X ε2 R2d 0 ∞ (P f ε )(s, X ) δ (X − Y ) ϕ(H0 (X )) d X = 2d R2d 0 R ×
∞
A
0
t ,Y ε2
=: pδ,ε (s,Y )
χδ (s − t) ζ (t) dt ds dY,
=:aδ,ε (s,Y )
and all integrals actually carry over compact compact sets, say t ∈ [0, T0 ], s ∈ [0, T0 ], |X | ≤ R0 , |Y | ≤ R0 . Now, given δ > 0, and given arbitrary values of the variables s, Y , we have, using the known weak convergence of P f ε (Proposition 6), F(s, H0 (X )) δ (X − Y ) ϕ(H0 (X )) d X. pδ,ε (s, Y ) −→ pδ (s, Y ) := ε→0
R2d
(We used here that the convergence of P f ε is weak in space but pointwise in time). Besides, we have the uniform bound pδ,ε (s, Y ) ≤ C δ (X − Y ) 2 2d ≤ C δ −d , L (R ) Y
where C is independent of ε and δ, but it does depend on ϕ. As a consequence, the dominated convergence theorem gives F(s, H0 (X )) δ (X − Y ) ∀δ > 0, pδ,ε (s, Y ) −→ ε→0
R2d
×ϕ(H0 (X )) d X strongly in L 2loc (R+ × R2d ). On the other hand, the function aδ,ε (s, Y ) satisfies the uniform bound aδ,ε (s, Y ) ≤ C(R) γ − p−1 χδ (s − t) 1 2d ≤ C, L (R ) t
where C is independent of ε and δ (we used Proposition 2). All this information allows to deduce T0 pδ,ε (s, Y ) − pδ (s, Y ) aδ,ε (s, Y ) ds dY 0
B(R0 )
≤ C pδ,ε − pδ L 2 ([0,T0 ]×B(R0 )) = oδ (1),
42
F. Castella, P. Degond, Th. Goudon
where C is independent of ε and δ, and oδ (1) denotes a term which goes to zero with ε, for any fixed δ > 0. Using these notations, we arrive at ∞ t (P f ε )δ (t, X ) Aδ , X ζ (t) ϕ(H0 (X )) dt d X ε2 R2d 0 T0 = pδ (s, Y ) aδ,ε (s, Y ) ds dY + oδ (1)
0
T0
=
B(R0 )
B(R0 )
0
A
t ,Y ε2
× χδ (s − t) ζ (t) ds d X
T0
= 0
B(R0 )
0
B(R0 )
0
F(s, H0 (X )) δ (X − Y ) ϕ(H0 (X ))
dt dY + oδ (1)
T0
A (Y )
T0
× χδ (s − t) ζ (t) ds d X
B(R0 )
F(s, H0 (X )) δ (X − Y ) ϕ(H0 (X ))
dt dY + oδ (1),
+ where the last equality uses the assumed weak convergence of A(t/ε2 , Y ) in L ∞ loc (R × 2d R )-weak- (Hypothesis 3). Hence, we may conclude ∞ t (P f ε )δ (t, X ) Aδ , X ζ (t) ϕ(H0 (X )) dt d X ε2 R2d 0 ∞ Fδ (t, X ) A δ (X ) ζ (t) ϕ(H0 (X )) dt d X + oδ (1). = 0
R2d
Second step: Estimating the effect of the regularization. The previous step allows to write
∞ t ε (P f )(t, X ) A 2 , X − F(t, H0 (X )) A (X ) ζ (t) ϕ(H0 (X )) dt d X ε R2d 0 ∞ t t ε ε (P f )(t, X ) A 2 , X − (P f )δ (t, X ) Aδ ,X = oδ (1) + ε ε2 0 R2d ∞ ×ζ (t) ϕ(H0 (X )) dt d X + [Fδ (t, H0 (X )) A δ (X ) 0
R2d
−F(t, H0 (X )) A (X ) ] ζ (t) ϕ(H0 (X )) dt d X =: oδ (1) + Iδ,ε + IIδ .
(10)
This serves as a definition of the two terms Iδ,ε and IIδ . We now prove that Iδ,ε and IIδ go to zero with δ, uniformly in ε. We begin with the most difficult term Iδ,ε . We first split in the obvious way ∞ t t (P f ε )δ (t, X ) A 2 , X − Aδ , X ζ (t) ϕ(H0 (X )) dt d X Iδ,ε = ε ε2 0 R2d ∞ t (P f ε )(t, X ) − (P f ε )δ (t, X ) A 2 , X ζ (t) ϕ(H0 (X )) dt d X. + ε 0 R2d
Large Time Dynamics
43
Next, going to the energy variable in order to treat the second term later, we split further ∞ t t ε Iδ,ε = (P f )δ (t, X ) A 2 , X − Aδ ,X ζ (t) ϕ(H0 (X )) dt d X ε ε2 R2d 0 ∞ t ε ε h 0 (E) (f )(t, E)−( f )δ (t, E) (A) 2 , E ζ (t) ϕ(E) dt d E + ε R 0 ∞ t t (P f ε )δ (t, X ) A 2 , X − Aδ ,X ζ (t) ϕ(H0 (X )) dt d X = 2 2d ε ε 0 R ∞ t ε ε h 0 (E) (f )(t, E)−( f )δ (t, E) (A)δ , E ζ (t) ϕ(E) dt d E + ε2 R 0 ∞ h 0 (E) (f ε )(t, E) − (f ε )δ (t, E) + R 0 t t , E ζ (t) ϕ(E) dt d E. × (A) 2 , E − (A)δ ε ε2 Here, we have used a regularization of (A)(t, E) in the energy variable E, namely t t (A)δ , E := (A) 2 , E − E χδ s (E ) d E ε2 ε R t s = (A) 2 , E − δ E χ (E ) d E , (11) ε R and s ∈]0, 1/2[ is a parameter that can be chosen arbitrarily (the need for s ∈]0, 1/2[ becomes clear later). At this point, we have split Iδ,ε into (1) (2) (3) + Iδ,ε + Iδ,ε , Iδ,ε = Iδ,ε (i) with the obvious notations. We prove that each term Iδ,ε , i = 1, 2, 3, goes to zero with δ, independently of ε. (1) The first term Iδ,ε is easily bounded by, say, t t (1) , Iδ,ε ≤ C sup sup sup A 2 , X + Y − A 2 , X ∞ ε ε |Y |≤δ ε>0 0≤t≤T0
L (B(R0 ))
where C is independent of ε and δ. Here, we implicitly assumed that supp ⊂ B(1). We also used the uniform boundedness of P f ε in L 2loc and the fact that ζ and ϕ have compact supports. Now, our assumptions on the potential V , the Hamiltonian H0 , and the flow X , readily imply the following uniform Lipschitz bounds, valid for any compact set K ⊂ R+ × R2d , 2 D V t t D2 V ,X +Y − , X ≤ C δ, sup sup sup 2 2 2 2 Dx ε Dx ε |Y |≤δ ε>0 (t,X )∈K DV t t DV ≤ C δ, sup sup sup , X + Y − , X 2 2 Dx ε Dx ε |Y |≤δ ε>0 (t,X )∈K 2 D H0 D 2 H0 sup sup (X + Y ) − (X ) ≤ C δ, 2 2 DX |Y |≤δ (t,X )∈K D X DX DX sup sup sup (u, X + Y ) − (u, X ) ≤ C δ (1 + u) p , D X D X |Y |≤δ ε>0 (t,X )∈K
44
F. Castella, P. Degond, Th. Goudon
where C is independent of ε, δ, and u ≥ 0, but it does depend on the compact set K . An easy adaptation of the proof of Proposition 2 then allows to deduce from these bounds that the function A(t/ε2 , X ) is Lipschitz, locally in X but uniformly in the first variable, i.e. t t sup sup sup A 2 , X + Y − A 2 , X ≤ C δ, (12) ∞ ε ε |Y |≤δ ε>0 0≤t≤T0 L (B(R0 )) where C is independent of ε and δ (but it does depend on R0 , T0 ). The conclusion is (1) Iδ,ε ≤ C δ, where C is independent of ε and δ. (2) The analysis of Iδ,ε follows roughly the same idea: we write (2) Iδ,ε =
∞ 0
ε
ε
ζ (t) h 0 (E) (f )(t, E)−h 0 (E) (f )δ (t, E) ,(A)δ
t , E ϕ(E) dt, ε2
where . , . denotes the duality bracket in the energy variable E. Hence we may safely estimate t (2) ε , Iδ,ε ≤ C δ sup sup ∂t h 0 (E) (f )(t +θ δ, E) ,(A)δ 2 , E ϕ(E) 2 ε ε>0 0≤θ≤1
L ([0,T0 ])
where C is independent of ε and δ. Using now the uniform boundedness of ∂t [h 0 (E) −2,1 (f ε )] in L 2loc (Wloc ), we recover, for some E 0 > 0 that depends on the support of ϕ, t (2) , E ϕ(E) Iδ,ε ≤ C δ sup (A)δ 2,∞ 2 ε ε>0 W (R ) 0≤t≤T0 t ≤ C δ sup (A)δ ε2 , E 2,∞ ε>0 W (]0,E 0 [) 0≤t≤T0 t ≤ C δ 1−2s sup (A) ε2 , E ∞ ε>0 L (]0,E 0 +1[) 0≤t≤T0 t ≤ C δ 1−2s sup . A ε2 , X ∞ ε>0 L (B(R0 )) 0≤t≤T0
Note that the need for using a regularized version of (A)(t, E), namely (A)δ )(t, E), (1) (2) (3) in the splitting Iδ,ε = Iδ,ε + Iδ,ε + Iδ,ε is clear in this estimate: it is enforced by the low ε regularity of ∂t [h 0 (E) (f )] (t, E) in the E variable. The choice 0 < s < 1/2 also appears clearly now. The conclusion is, using Proposition 2-(iii) (2) Iδ,ε ≤ C δ 1−2s , with C independent of δ and ε.
Large Time Dynamics
45
(3)
Last the term Iδ,ε is obviously bounded by, say, t t sup (A) 2 , E + E −(A) 2 , E 2 ε ε s |E |≤δ ε>0 0≤t≤T0 L ([0,E 0 ],h 0 (E) d E) t t (P A) 2 , E + E − (P A) 2 , E ≤ C sup sup sup , 2 ε ε |E |≤δ s ε>0 0≤t≤T0 L (B(R0 )
(3) Iδ,ε ≤ C sup sup
for some given E 0 > 0 (that depends on R0 ), and C is independent of ε and δ. Here we used the co-area formula. Now, estimate (12) establishes that the functions A(t/ε2 , X ) ∈ L 2 (B(R0 )), parametrized by t ∈ [0, T0 ] and ε > 0, satisfy a uniform equi-integrability criterion, hence belong to a relatively compact set of L 2 (B(R0 )). The continuity of the projection operator P readily implies that the functions (P A)(t/ε2 , X ) ∈ L 2 (B(R0 )) also belong to a relatively compact set of L 2 (B(R0 )). This in turn implies that the functions (P A)(t/ε2 , X ), parametrized by t and ε, satisfy a uniform equi-integrability criterion, namely t t (P A) sup sup sup − (P A) , E + E , E −→ 0. (13) 2 2 2 ε ε |E |≤δ s ε>0 0≤t≤T0 L (B(R0 ) δ→0 The conclusion is (3)
Iδ,ε −→ 0, uniformly with respect to ε. δ→0
(i)
Summarizing, the above estimates on Iδ,ε (i = 1, 2, 3) give Iδ,ε −→ 0, uniformly with respect to ε. δ→0
Let us now come to the easier term IIδ . We write as before ∞ Fδ (t, H0 (X )) [A δ (X ) − A (X )] ζ (t) ϕ(H0 (X )) dt d X IIδ = 0 R2d ∞ h 0 (E) [F(t, E) − Fδ (t, E)] (A )δ (E) ζ (t) ϕ(H0 (X )) dt d E + 0 ∞ R h 0 (E) [F(t, E) − Fδ (t, E)] [(A )(E) − (A )δ (E)] + 0
R
×ζ (t) ϕ(E) dt d E, where we defined the regularization of (A )(E) in the energy variable E, (A )δ (E) := (A )(E − E ) χδ s (E ) d E = (A )(E −δ s E ) χ (E ) d E , R
R
(14) and s ∈]0, 1/2[ is a parameter that can be chosen arbitrarily. At this point, we have split IIδ into (1)
(2)
(3)
IIδ = IIδ + IIδ + IIδ ,
46
F. Castella, P. Degond, Th. Goudon
with the obvious notations. A fairly easy analyzing the term Iδ,ε gives successively (1) IIδ ≤ C δ,
adaptation of the estimates produced while (2) IIδ ≤ C δ,
with C independent of δ, and (3)
IIδ −→ 0. δ→0
The adaptation is obtained upon observing that the various functions A(t/ε2 , X ), etc. entering the analysis of Iδ,ε , and their various weak limits (in the relevant spaces) A (X ), etc. that enter the analysis of IIδ , admit the same boundedness properties (typically, if u n u in L 2 , then u L 2 ≤ inf n u n L 2 ). This is enough to reproduce the arguments given for Iδ,ε . Third step: Conclusion. Summarizing, we have proved up to now that
∞ t (P f ε )(t, X ) A 2 , X − F(t, H0 (X )) A (X ) ε R2d 0 ×ζ (t) ϕ(H0 (X )) dt d X = oδ (1) + O(δ), where oδ (1) goes to zero as ε → 0 for any fixed value of δ > 0, and O(δ) is estimated by C δ with C independent of ε and δ. This proves the proposition.
2.5. The homogenization procedure: Proof of the theorem. We are now in position to end the proof of the main theorem. First step: Homogenization procedure. Take two smooth test functions ζ (t) ∈ Cc∞ (R+ ) and ϕ(E) ∈ Cc∞ (R). Proposition 5 asserts
∞ P f 0ε (t, X ) ϕ(H0 (X )) ζ (0) d X + P f ε (t, X ) ϕ(H0 (X )) ζ (t) dt d X R2d 0 ∞ t ε P f (t, X ) A 2 , X ∂ E ϕ(H0 ) + 2d ε 0
R t , X ∂ E2 E ϕ(H0 ) ζ (t) d X dt = O(ε). +B ε2
Hence, Propositions 6 and 7 allow to pass to the limit and eventually obtain F(0, H0 (X )) ϕ(H0 (X )) ζ (0) d X R2d ∞ F(t, H0 (X )) ϕ(H0 (X )) ζ (t) dt d X + 2d 0 ∞ R F(t, H0 (X )) A (X ) ∂ E ϕ(H0 )+B (X ) ∂ E2 E ϕ(H0 ) ζ (t) d X dt = 0. + 0
R2d
Large Time Dynamics
47
The co-area formula next provides
R
∞
h 0 (E) F(0, E) ϕ(E) ζ (0) d E + h 0 (E) F(t, E) ϕ(E) ζ (t) dt d E 0 R ∞ h 0 (E) F(t, E) a(E)∂ E ϕ(E) + b(E)∂ E2 E ϕ(E) ζ (t) d E dt = 0, (15) + 0
R
where a(E) := A (E), b(E) := B (E). Note that both coefficients a and b are well-defined and belong to L ∞ (R) since the two functions A and B belong to L ∞ (R2d ). Note also that Eq. (15) is the weak formulation of the second order equation 2 ∂t [h 0 (E) F(t, E)] + ∂ E [a(E) h 0 (E) F(t, E)] − ∂ E,E [b(E) h 0 (E) F(t, E)] = 0. (16)
There remains to establish the properties of the coefficients a(E) and b(E). This is done in the next step. Second step: Properties of the effective coefficients. The proof we give now establishes the claimed formula h 0 a = ∂ E (h 0 b). It also sheds some light on the connection between the present setting and the case when the potential V is assumed (quasi-)periodic in time. 2d As a preliminary, let h ∈ L ∞ loc (R × R ). We associate to any such function the quantity
∞
χh (t, X ) :=
h t + s, X (s, X ) e−γ s ds,
0 2d which obviously also belongs to L ∞ loc (R × R ). An immediate computation shows χh satisfies the backward transport equation (or: adjoint equation) −∂t χh − {H0 , χh } + γ χh = h,with vanishing initial datum. With this notation, we may introduce the profile χ = χ (t, X ) given by
χ := χ{V , H0 } . The profile χ allows to express the coefficients a and b in the following way:
∞ a(E) = − {V (τ ) , χ (τ )} dτ (E),
0 ∞ b(E) = − {V (τ ) , H0 } χ (τ ) dτ (E), 0
∞ where − · · ·
1 T ···. T 0 0 This observation allows to both prove the non-negativity of b and the relation h 0 a = stands for the weak limit in L ∞ loc − as T → ∞ of
48
F. Castella, P. Degond, Th. Goudon
∂ E (h 0 b). Indeed, we may write, on the one hand ∞ − {V (τ ) , H0 } χ (τ ) dτ 0
T 1 − (∂τ χ (τ ) + {H0 , χ (τ )} − γ χ (τ )) χ (τ ) dτ = lim T →∞ T 0 2 χ (0) − χ 2 (T ) 1 T γ T 2 − = lim H0 , χ 2 /2 dτ + χ (τ ) dτ T →∞ 2T T 0 T 0 T 1 γ T 2 H0 , χ 2 /2 dτ + χ (τ ) dτ , = lim − T →∞ T 0 T 0
from which it follows, using Lemma 1, that ∞ γ T 2 χ (τ ) dτ ≥ 0. P − {V (τ ) , H0 } χ (τ ) dτ = P lim T →∞ T 0 0 Hence b(E) ≥ 0. On the other hand, using the co-area formula and integration by parts, we have, for any trial function ψ ∈ Cc∞ (R), ∞ h0a ψ d E = − {V, χ } ψ(H0 (X )) d X dτ R R2d 0 ∞ − χ {V, ψ(H0 (X ))} d X dτ =− R2d 0 ∞ − χ {V, H0 (X )} (∂ E ψ)(H0 (X )) d X dτ =− R2d 0 = − h 0 b ∂ E ψ d E, R
which proves h 0 a = ∂ E (h 0 b). This ends the proof of our main theorem.
References [Al] [A] [BPR] [BDG] [BLP] [BCD] [BCDG] [BSC]
Alexandre, R.: Asymptotic behaviour of transport equations. Appl. Anal. 70(3–4), 405–430 (1999) Allaire, G.: Homogenization and two-scale convergence. SIAM J. Math. Anal. 23, 1482–1518 (1992) Bal, G., Papanicolaou, G., Ryzhik, L.: Radiative transport limit for the random schrödinger equation. Nonlinearity 15(2), 513–529 (2002) Bardos, C., Dumas, L., Golse, F.: Diffusion approximation for billiards with totally accommodating scatterers. J. Stat. Phys. 86(1–2), 351–375 (1997) Bensoussan, A., Lions, J.-L., Papanicolaou, G.: Asymptotic analysis for periodic structures. Studies in Mathematics and its Applications, 5, Amsterdam: North-Holland, 1978 Bidégaray, B., Castella, F., Degond, P.: From bloch model to the rate equations. Discrete Contin. Dyn. Syst. 11(1), 1–26 (2004) Bidégaray, B., Castella, F., Dumas, E., Gisclon, M.: From bloch model to the rate equations II: the case of almost degenerate energy levels. Math. Models Methods Appl. Sci. 14(12), 1785–1817 (2004) Bunimovich, L.A., Chernov, N.I., Sinai, Ya.G.: Statistical properties of two-dimensional hyperbolic billiards. Usp. Mat. Nauk 46, no. 4, 43–92, (1991); translation in Russ. Math. Surv. 46(4), 47–106 (1991)
Large Time Dynamics
[Ca1] [Ca2] [CD] [CDG] [CIP] [EY1] [EY2] [FH] [GP1] [GP2] [GP3] [KPR] [Li] [LV] [Lo] [Mi] [Ng] [PR] [PV] [SV] [Sp] [Ta]
49
Castella, F.: From the von Neumann equation to the Quantum Boltzmann equation in a deterministic framework. J. Stat. Phys. 104(1/2), 387–447 (2001) Castella, F.: From the von Neumann equation to the Quantum Boltzmann equation II: identifying the Born series. J. Stat. Phys. 106(5/6), 1197–1220 (2002) Castella, F., Degond, P.: Convergence de l’équation de von Neumann vers l’équation de Boltzmann Quantique dans un cadre déterministe. C. R. Acad. Sci., t. 329, sér. I, 231–236 (1999) Castella, F., Degond, P., Goudon, T.: Diffusion dynamics of classical systems driven by an oscillatory force. J. Stat. Phys. 124(2–4), 913–950 (2006) Cercignani, C., Illner, R., Pulvirenti, M.: The mathematical theory of dilute gases. Applied Mathematical Sciences, 106, New York: Springer-Verlag, 1994 Erdös, L., Yau, H.T.: Linear Boltzmann equation as scaling limit of quantum Lorentz gas, Advances in Differential Equations and Mathematical Physics, Contemporary Mathematics 217, Providence, RI: Amer. Math. Soc., pp.135–155 (1998) Erdös, L., Yau, H.T.: Linear Boltzmann equation as the weak coupling limit of a random Schrödinger equation. Commun. Pure Appl. Math. 53, 667–735 (2000) Frenod, E., Hamdache, K.: Homogenisation of transport kinetic equations with oscillating potentials. Proc. Roy. Soc. Edinburgh Sect. A 126(6), 1247–1275 (1996) Goudon, T., Poupaud, F.: Approximation by homogeneization and diffusion of kinetic equations. Comm. P.D.E. 26, 537–570 (2001) Goudon, T., Poupaud, F.: Homogenization of transport equations: weak mean field approximation. SIAM J. Math Anal. 36, 856–881 (2004) Goudon, T., Poupaud, F.: Homogenization of transport equations: a simple PDE approach to the kubo formula. Bull.Sci. Math. 131, 72–88 (2007) Keller, J.B., Papanicolaou, G., Ryzhik, L.: Transport equations for elastic and other waves in random media. Wave Motion 24(4), 327–370 (1996) Lions, P.-L.: Mathematical topics in fluid mechanics, Vol. 2, Oxford: Oxford univ. Press, Oxford Science Publications 19, 1996–98 Loeper, G., Vasseur, A.: Electric turbulence in a plasma subject to a strong magnetic field. Asymptot. Anal., 40(1), 51–65 (2004) Loudon, R.: The quantum theory of light. Oxford Science Publications, Oxford: Oxford univ. Press, 1983 Milnor, J.W.: Topology from the differentiable viewpoint. The University Press of Virginia, 1963 Nguetseng, G.: A general convergence result for a functional related to the theory of homogenization. SIAM J. Math. Anal. 20, 608–623 (1989) Perthame, B., Ryzhik, L.: The quantum scattering limit for a regularized wigner equation. Math. Appl. Anal. 11, 447–464 (2004) Poupaud, F., Vasseur, A.: Classical and quantum transport in random media. J. de Math. Pures et Appl 82(6), 711–748 (2003) Sanders, J.A., Verhulst, F.: Averaging methods in nonlinear dynamical systems, Applied Mathematical Sciences, Vol. 59, Berlin-Heidelberg-Newyork: Springer-Verlag, 1985 Spohn, H.: Large scale dynamics of interacting particles, Berlin-Heidelberg-Newyork: Springer, 1991 Taylor, G.I.: Diffusion by continuous movements, Proc. London Math. Soc., Ser., 2, 20, 196–211, 1923
Communicated by J.L. Lebowitz
Commun. Math. Phys. 276, 51–91 (2007) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-007-0329-9
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
The Spectral Shift Function and Spectral Flow N. A. Azamov1 , A. L. Carey2 , F. A. Sukochev1 1 School of Informatics and Engineering, Flinders University of South Australia, Bedford Park,
5042, SA, Australia. E-mail: azam0001;
[email protected]
2 Mathematical Sciences Institute, Australian National University, Canberra, ACT 0200, Australia.
E-mail:
[email protected]
Received: 5 May 2006 / Accepted: 7 May 2007 Published online: 28 August 2007 – © Springer-Verlag 2007
Abstract: At the 1974 International Congress, I. M. Singer proposed that eta invariants and hence spectral flow should be thought of as the integral of a one form. In the intervening years this idea has lead to many interesting developments in the study of both eta invariants and spectral flow. Using ideas of [24] Singer’s proposal was brought to an advanced level in [16] where a very general formula for spectral flow as the integral of a one form was produced in the framework of noncommutative geometry. This formula can be used for computing spectral flow in a general semifinite von Neumann algebra as described and reviewed in [5]. In the present paper we take the analytic approach to spectral flow much further by giving a large family of formulae for spectral flow between a pair of unbounded self-adjoint operators D and D + V with D having compact resolvent belonging to a general semifinite von Neumann algebra N and the perturbation V ∈ N . In noncommutative geometry terms we remove summability hypotheses. This level of generality is made possible by introducing a new idea from [3]. There it was observed that M. G. Krein’s spectral shift function (in certain restricted cases with V trace class) computes spectral flow. The present paper extends Krein’s theory to the setting of semifinite spectral triples where D has compact resolvent belonging to N and V is any bounded self-adjoint operator in N . We give a definition of the spectral shift function under these hypotheses and show that it computes spectral flow. This is made possible by the understanding discovered in the present paper of the interplay between spectral shift function theory and the analytic theory of spectral flow. It is this interplay that enables us to take Singer’s idea much further to create a large class of one forms whose integrals calculate spectral flow. These advances depend critically on a new approach to the calculus of functions of non-commuting operators discovered in [3] which generalizes the double operator integral formalism of [8–10]. One surprising conclusion that follows from our results is that the Krein spectral shift function is computed, in certain circumstances, by the Atiyah-Patodi-Singer index theorem [2].
52
N. A. Azamov, A. L. Carey, F. A. Sukochev
Introduction Overview. In [3] we gave an analytic proof that the spectral shift function of M. G. Krein computes the spectral flow under certain restricted circumstances. Spectral flow stems from the work of Atiyah-Patodi-Singer [2] where it is introduced primarily in a topological sense. Subsequently, starting with a suggestion of I. M. Singer at the 1974 Vancouver ICM, the idea that spectral flow could be expressed as the integral of a one form has been extensively studied in the framework of unbounded Fredholm modules (or spectral triples) beginning with [24] and continuing in [15, 16]. The current state of knowledge using an analytic approach due to Phillips [30, 31] is described in detail in [5]. On the other hand the Krein spectral shift function has an extensive history in perturbation theory which may be partly traced from [26, 6, 11, 32]. The spectral shift theory was developed by both physicists and mathematicians in the context of perturbation theory of Schrödinger operators. By the Birman-Krein formula, it is related to the phase of the scattering matrix in the latter’s spectral representation. Krein’s formula for the spectral shift function, which is the motivation for this paper, is restricted to the case where one perturbs an arbitrary unbounded self adjoint operator D0 by a trace class operator. The spectral shift function compares in a sense the relation between the spectrum of D0 and that of its perturbation. In this paper we will extend the theory of the spectral shift function to the situation where we perturb D0 by an arbitrary bounded self adjoint operator but adopt the assumption that D0 has compact resolvent motivated by the notion of spectral triple. One surprising conclusion that follows is that the Atiyah-Patodi-Singer (or APS) index theorem [2] and its generalizations are, in certain instances, computing the spectral shift function. The generalizations of the APS index theorem we are referring to in the previous paragraph have to do with situations where von Neumann algebras other than all the bounded operators on a Hilbert space arise. The standard theory of spectral flow deals with unbounded self adjoint Fredholm operators. Using an approach due to Phillips op cit spectral flow may be defined analytically (but as yet not topologically) for certain operators affiliated to semifinite von Neumann algebras, the so-called Breuer-Fredholm theory, which is reviewed in [5]. In addition the connection between spectral flow in semifinite spectral triples and generalizations of the APS index theorem is explained in [5] with reference to the extensive previous history of the matter. Spectral flow is related to odd degree K -theory and the odd local index theorem in noncommutative geometry [20, 17]. For the purposes of using spectral flow to obtain information about K -theory it is enough to consider unbounded operators D with compact resolvent. However, previous studies of spectral flow formulae have restrictions 2 on D such as theta summability (requiring the heat operator e−t D to be trace class for all t > 0). In this paper we will relax this condition to capture the more general situation where only compact resolvent is needed. By contrast the theory of the spectral shift function was formulated for Schrödinger operators associated to Euclidean spaces and in that setting the assumption of compact resolvent does not generally hold. Thus it is not surprising that the relationship between the Krein spectral shift function and spectral flow should have remained somewhat unexplored until recently. In [3] we noticed that under hypotheses that guaranteed that both the Krein spectral shift function and spectral flow exist then they are essentially the same notion. This led us to the current investigation where we borrow some ideas from spectral flow theory as formulated in a spectral triple to extend the range of situations for which the Krein spectral shift function may be defined. We are then able to obtain new results on the spectral shift function and to prove, by a combination of the methods of [3] and [15, 16]
Spectral Shift Function and Spectral Flow
53
that the spectral shift function gives a wide variety of analytic formulae for spectral flow. In fact it is the interaction between these previously disparate theories that makes these advances possible. An additional very important feature of our analysis is its generality; we are able to study self adjoint operators that are affiliated to a general semifinite von Neumann algebra N in contrast to the classical theory which deals with the special case where N is the algebra of all bounded operators on a Hilbert space H. (Note that there are examples of quantum mechanical Hamiltonians whose resolvent lies in a semifinite von Neumann algebra, see e.g. [14].) Summary of results. In order to keep this paper to a reasonable length we have omitted a detailed discussion of spectral flow in von Neumann algebras referring to the paper [5] for this. On the other hand we include in Sect. 1 preliminary results particularly those from [3] which may be less accessible to the reader. This latter paper is very important for the present investigation because it provides a calculus of functions of operators more effective than has been available in the past. The key technical advance that we exploit is the use of double operator integrals (DOI) not in its original form [8] but in the much more effective form discovered in [3]. In particular it is this latter paper that develops a calculus for functions of operators affiliated to general semifinite von Neumann algebras. This calculus replaces the more elementary perturbation theory techniques in [15, 16] and is more user friendly than that of [27]. The main new results on the Krein spectral shift function are in Sect. 2. Here we show that by starting with self adjoint operators D0 with compact resolvent in a semifinite von Neumann algebra we are able to define the Krein spectral shift function for general bounded self adjoint perturbations V. Section 2 also exhibits some properties of the spectral shift function for operators satisfying these hypotheses mostly in the context of preparing the ground for the subsequent discussion of spectral flow. Specifically D0 D0 +V we observe that the spectral projections E (a,b) and E (a,b) of D0 and D0 + V = D1 respectively are finite in N for bounded intervals (a, b). Using a fixed faithful normal semifinite trace τ on N we define (following [7]) the spectral shift measure for the pair D0 , D1 , by 1 Dr D1 ,D0 () = dr, τ V E 0
where is a bounded Borel subset of the real line and Dr = D0 + r V, r ∈ [0, 1]. We consider this Birman-Solomyak formula (formula (16) in the text) for the spectral shift measure as fundamental. It is this formula which in our opinion must be taken as the definition of the generalized spectral shift function of a pair of operators, whenever this expression makes sense for that pair. We then prove that this measure is absolutely continuous with respect to Lebesgue measure and the resulting Radon-Nikodym derivative we define to be the spectral shift function ξ D1 ,D0 (λ). This function can be related to the original spectral shift function of Krein which was introduced in a completely different fashion. Furthermore, under our assumptions, the spectral shift function ξ D1 ,D0 (λ) is in fact a function of a bounded variation and there is a canonical representative which is an everywhere defined function. We remark that in [33] B. Simon outlined (without proof) some similar results on the spectral shift function. In Sect. 3 we present a series of new analytic formulae for spectral flow. These require the use of the spectral shift function and its properties derived in Sect. 2. The formulae
54
N. A. Azamov, A. L. Carey, F. A. Sukochev
we obtain subsume those of [16]. We are able to provide a variety of analytic formulae whenever D0 has compact resolvent and show how these formulae can be specialized when there are summability hypotheses imposed. For illustrative purposes we describe two of our main theorems here. Suppose that there is a unitary operator u with D1 = u D0 u ∗ and such that V = u[D0 , u ∗ ] ∈ N . That is, for a dense subalgebra of the C ∗ -algebra generated by u we have a semifinite spectral triple. Then spectral flow from D0 − λ to D1 − λ for any real λ is equal to ξ D1 ,D0 (λ). We relate our results to previous formulae for spectral flow via the following result. For any positive integrable function f on the real line with f (D0 + r V ) trace class for r ∈ [0, 1] and r → f (D0 + r V )1 being 1-summable on [0, 1], we find that spectral flow from D0 − λ to D1 − λ for any real λ is given by 1 sf(λ; D0 , D1 ) = C −1 τ (V f (Dr − λ)) dr, ∞
0
where C = −∞ f (x) d x. In fact in this restricted situation of unitarily equivalent endpoints we can prove that the spectral shift function is constant implying that spectral flow occurs uniformly past any point on the real line not just zero. We also obtain analogues of these results when the endpoint operators are not unitarily equivalent. Then the relation between spectral flow and the spectral shift function is modified by the addition of endpoint correction terms (in a fashion analogous to [16]). The key idea we exploit in this part of the paper is the observation [24] that spectral flow can be written as the integral of an exact one form on the affine space of bounded perturbations of a fixed unbounded operator D0 . It eventuates that there is a way to construct a large class of such one forms that will compute spectral flow when the only constraint on D0 is that it have compact resolvent. This advance is made possible by the understanding of the spectral shift measure afforded by Sect. 2. It then follows that the spectral shift function computes spectral flow with the caveat that there are simple correction terms arising from the zero eigenspace of each endpoint of the path. One motivation for this investigation arises from [17] where the odd local index theorem in noncommutative geometry was deduced from the analytic formula for spectral flow in [16] via an intermediate formula in terms of a cyclic cocycle which was called the ‘resolvent cocycle’. The results and viewpoint of this paper may have other applications to noncommutative geometry besides spectral flow. Specifically we have in mind situations where we would like to avoid ‘summability constraints’ on D0 . 1. Notation and Preliminary Results 1.1. Notation. We write H for a fixed separable complex Hilbert space, and by N we denote a semifinite von Neumann algebra acting on H [34, V. 1. 21]. We use the usual notation DηN for operators D affiliated with N [34, IV. 5, Exercise 3]. We let τ be a faithful normal semifinite trace on N [34, V. 2. 1] and by L 1 (N , τ ) we denote the set of τ -trace class operators affiliated with N [34, V.2, p. 320]. Then we use the notation L1 (N , τ ) = L 1 (N , τ ) ∩ N for the (unitarily) invariant operator ideal [16, Appendix A.2] of all bounded τ -trace class operators with norm ·1,∞ = · + ·1 , where · is the usual operator norm and ·1 := τ (|·|) [34, V.2, p. 320]. By B(R) we denote the T be the spectral σ -algebra of all Borel subsets of R. For a self-adjoint operator T let E projection of T corresponding to ∈ B(R), and let E λT be the spectral projection of T corresponding to (−∞, λ]. Write Cc∞ (R) (respectively, Cc∞ ()) for the set of all
Spectral Shift Function and Spectral Flow
55
compactly supported C ∞ -smooth functions on R (respectively, ⊆ R), and B(R) (respectively, Bc (R)) for the set of all bounded Borel functions on R (respectively, compactly supported bounded Borel functions on R). If an operator T affiliated with N is τ -measurable [22, Definition 1.2], then the t th generalized s-number µt (T ) of the operator T is defined by µt (T ) = inf {T E : E is a projection in N with τ (1 − E) t} . If E ∈ N is a τ -finite projection (i.e. τ (E) < ∞), then µt (E) = χ[0,τ (E)) (t), t 0.
(1)
An operator T ∈ N is said to be τ -compact iff lim µt (T ) = 0. The set of all τ -compact t→∞
operators from N forms an ideal in N which is denoted K(N , τ ). The ideal K(N , τ ) coincides with the norm closure of the ideal in N generated by τ -finite projections. Let Rz (D) = (z − D)−1 denote the resolvent of D. If D = D ∗ ηN and Rz (D) ∈ K(N , τ ) for some (and hence for all) z ∈ C \ R, then we say that D has τ -compact resolvent. An operator T ∈ N is called τ -Fredholm [29, Appendix B] if the projections [ker T ], [ker T ∗ ] are τ -finite and there exists a τ -finite projection E ∈ N such that ran(1 − E) ⊆ ran(T ). For a τ -Fredholm operator T one can define its τ -index by τ - ind(T ) = τ ([ker T ]) − τ ([ker T ∗ ]). Definition 1.1. Let N be a semifinite von Neumann algebra and let E, E be two invariant operator ideals over N . We denote the self-adjoint part of E by Esa . Let D0 be a fixed is called self-adjoint operator affiliated with N . A function f : D0 + Esa → f (D0 ) + Esa affinely (E, E )-Fréchet differentiable at D ∈ D0 + Esa , if there exists a (necessarily such that the following equality holds: unique) bounded operator L : Esa → Esa f (D + V ) − f (D) = L(V ) + o(V E ), V ∈ Esa . If E = E then we write L = DE f (D), otherwise we write L = DE ,E f (D). In our case the ideals E and E will be N or L1 (N , τ ). We constantly use some parameters for specific purposes. The parameter r will always be an operator path parameter, i. e. the letter r is used when we consider paths of operators such as Dr = D0 + r V. Very rarely we need another path parameter which we denote by s. We do not use t as a path parameter, since t is used for other purposes later in the paper. The letter λ is always used as a spectral parameter. If we need another spectral parameter we will use µ. We finish this subsection with the following elementary fact which we will use repeatedly. Lemma 1.2. If is an open interval in R and if f ∈ Cck (), then there exist functions √ √ f 1 , f 2 ∈ Cck () such that f 1 , f 2 are non-negative, f = f 1 − f 2 and f 1 , f 2 ∈ Cck (). Proof. Let [a, b] be a closed interval, [a, b] ⊆ and supp( f ) ⊆ (a, b). Take a nonnegative C ∞ -function f 1 f on [a, b] which vanishes at a and b in such a way that √ f 1 is C ∞ -smooth at a and b, and take f 2 = f 1 − f.
56
N. A. Azamov, A. L. Carey, F. A. Sukochev
1.2. Self-adjoint operators with τ -compact resolvent. The remaining subsections in this section are technical and dry. The reader may wish to browse this section then move on to Sects. 2 and 3 which contain the main results referring back to the technicalities of this section when needed. In this current subsection we collect some facts about operators with compact resolvent in a semifinite von Neumann algebra. We do not claim any great originality for these. Lemma 1.3. If D = D ∗ ηN has τ -compact resolvent and V = V ∗ ∈ N , then D + V also has τ -compact resolvent. Proof. This follows from the equality Rz (D +V ) = (Rz (D+V )V +1) Rz (D), z ∈ C\R. Lemma 1.4. If D = D ∗ ηN has τ -compact resolvent, then for all compact sets ⊆ R D is τ -finite. the spectral projection E Proof. If D has τ -compact resolvent then the operator (1+D 2 )−1 = (D+i)−1 (D−i)−1 is τ -compact. Since for every finite interval there exists a constant c > 0, not depending D c(1 + D 2 )−1 , the projection E D is also τ -compact, and hence on D such that E τ -finite. Corollary 1.5. If D = D ∗ ηN has τ -compact resolvent, then for all f ∈ Bc (R) the operator f (D) is τ -trace class. Proof. There exists a finite segment ⊆ R such that | f | const χ , so that | f (D)| D. const E Lemma 1.6. [15, Appendix B, Lemma 6] If D0 is an unbounded self-adjoint operator, A is a bounded self-adjoint operator, and D = D0 + A then (1 + D 2 )−1 f (A)(1 + D02 )−1 , √ where f (a) = 1 + 21 a 2 + 21 a a 2 + 4. Lemma 1.7. Let D0 = D0∗ ηN have τ -compact resolvent, and let B R = {V = V ∗ ∈ N : V R} . Then for any compact subset ⊆ R the function D0 +V V ∈ B R → E
is L1 (N , τ )-bounded. D0 +V c0 (1 + (D0 + V )2 )−1 for some constant c0 = c0 () > 0 and Proof. We have E ∗ for every V = V ∈ N . Now, by Lemma 1.6 there exists a constant c1 = c1 (R) > 0, such that for all V ∈ B R ,
(1 + (D0 + V )2 )−1 c1 (1 + D02 )−1 . D0 +V Hence, since D0 has τ -compact resolvent, all projections E , V ∈ B R , are bounded from above by a single τ -compact operator T = c0 c1 (1 + D02 )−1 . This means, that for t > 0, D0 +V µt (E ) µt (T ). D0 +V ) = χ[0,τ (E D0 +V )) (t) and there exists t0 > 0 such that µt0 (T ) 1. Further, by (1) µt (E
D0 +V ) t0 . This implies that for all V ∈ B R , τ (E
Spectral Shift Function and Spectral Flow
57
Corollary 1.8. If D0 = D0∗ ηN has τ -compact resolvent, then for any function f ∈ Bc (R) the function V ∈ B R → f (D0 + V )1,∞ is bounded. Corollary 1.9. Let D0 = D0∗ ηN have τ -compact resolvent, r = (r1 , . . . , rm ) ∈ [0, 1]m , V1 , . . . , Vm ∈ Nsa and set Dr = D0 + r1 V1 + · · · + rm Vm . Then Dr (i) for any compact subset ⊆ R the function r ∈ [0, 1]m → E is bounded; 1 (ii) for any function f ∈ Bc (R) the function r ∈ [0, 1] → f (Dr )1 is bounded. An elementary proof of the following lemma can also be found in [15]. Lemma 1.10. If D0 = D0∗ ηN and if V = V ∗ ∈ N , then for any t ∈ R, eit (D0 +V ) converges in ·-norm to eit D0 when V → 0. Proof. Follows directly from Duhamel’s formula t eit (D0 +V ) − eit D0 = ei(t−u)(D0 +V ) i V eiu D0 du. 0
If (S, ν) is a finite measure space then we say that a function f : S → B(H) is measurable, if for any η ∈ H the functions f (·)η, f (·)∗ η : S → H are Bochner measurable. We define the integral of a measurable function by the formula f (σ ) dν(σ )η = f (σ )η dν(σ ), η ∈ H, S
S
and call it an so∗ -integral. If f : S → L1 (N , τ ) is an L1 -bounded function then it is measurable if and only if there exists a sequence of simple (finitely-valued) functions f n : S → L1 (N , τ ) such that f n (σ ) → f (σ ) in the so∗ -topology [3, Sect. 3]. Lemma 1.11. [3, Lemma3.10] If a measurable function f : S → L1 (N , τ ) is uniformly L1 (N , τ )-bounded then S f (σ ) dν(σ ) ∈ L1 (N , τ ) and τ f (σ ) dν(σ ) = τ ( f (σ )) dν(σ ). S
S
1.3. Difference quotients and double operator integrals. Originally, multiple operator integrals of the form ϕ(λ0 , . . . , λn ) d E λD00 V1 d E λD11 V2 . . . Vn d E λDnn , (2) TϕD0 ,...,Dn (V1 , . . . , Vn ) = Rn+1
where D0 , . . . , Dn are self-adjoint operators and V1 , . . . , Vn are bounded operators, were defined as repeated operator integrals [21] or as spectral integrals [8–10] in the case of double operator integrals. It was noted in [3] (see also [28]) that one can give another definition of multiple operator integrals (Definition 1.15). The idea of the new definition is that for functions ϕ(λ0 , . . . , λn ) of the form ϕ(λ0 , . . . , λn ) = α0 (λ0 )α1 (λ1 ) . . . αn (λn ) the expression (2) can be interpreted as α0 (D0 )V1 α1 (D1 )V2 . . . Vn αn (Dn ). Hence, for functions ϕ of the form (7) one can try to define the multiple operator integral by the
58
N. A. Azamov, A. L. Carey, F. A. Sukochev
formula (8). Having proved the correctness of this definition (Proposition 1.16), we will be able to work with the usual operator integrals of the form (8), provided that one has a representation of the form of Eq. (7) for the function ϕ. Actually, one has considerable freedom of choice of this representation, and one should try to find that representation of ϕ which is most suitable for the purpose at hand. In our case the function ϕ(λ0 , λ1 ) is the difference quotient f [1] (λ0 , λ1 ) :=
f (λ0 ) − f (λ1 ) λ0 − λ1
(3)
of some function f. We denote by C n,+ (R) the set of functions f ∈ C n (R), such that the j th derivative f ( j) , j = 1, . . . , n, belongs to the space F −1 (L 1 (R)), where F( f ) is the Fourier transform of f. We emphasize that the Fourier transform of a function f ∈ C n,+ (R) need not belong to L 1 (R) (see Lemma 1.12(ii)). Let
:= (s0 , s1 ) ∈ R2 : |s1 | |s0 | , sign(s0 ) = sign(s1 ) , and i dν f (s0 , s1 ) := sgn(s0 ) √ F( f )(s0 ) ds0 ds1 . (4) 2π
If f ∈ C 1,+ (R), then it is not difficult to see that , ν f is a finite measure space [3, Lemma 2.1], so that , ν f can be used for the construction of the double operator integral. The following Birman-Solomyak or BS-representation of f [1] (λ0 , λ1 ) [3, Lemma 2.2] [1] f (λ0 , λ1 ) = α(λ0 , σ )β(λ1 , σ ) dν f (σ ), (5)
where σ = (s0 , s1 ), α(λ0 , σ ) = ei(s0 −s1 )λ0 and β(λ1 , σ ) = eis1 λ1 , is not suitable for our present purposes. Lemma 1.14 provides a modification of this BS-representation for f [1] with which we will constantly work. We include the proof of the following fact for completeness. Lemma 1.12. (i) If f ∈ Cc1 (R), then fˆ ∈ L 1 (R). (ii) the function ϕ(x) = √ x 2 belongs to C 2,+ (R). 1+x
Proof.
(i) Following the proof of [13, Corollary 3.2.33], we have | fˆ|(ξ ) dξ = |ξ + i|−1 |ξ + i|| fˆ|(ξ ) dξ R
R
R
|ξ + i|
−2
1 2
dξ
|ξ + i| | fˆ| (ξ ) dξ 2
R
2
1
2 2
d f (x)
dx
+ f (x) = const < ∞.
dx R (ii) The proof is similar to that of (i).
1 2
Spectral Shift Function and Spectral Flow
59
Applying part (i) of this lemma to the first n derivatives of a function f from Ccn+1 (R), we obtain Corollary 1.13. Ccn+1 (R) ⊆ C n,+ (R), n = 1, 2, . . .. The following lemma provides a BS-representation for f [1] , 0 f ∈ Cc2 (R), which will be used throughout this paper. √ Lemma 1.14. Let f ∈ Cc2 (R) be a non-negative function such that g := f ∈ Cc2 (R). If ⊇ supp( f ), then f [1] (λ0 , λ1 ) = (α1 (λ0 , σ )β1 (λ1 , σ ) + α2 (λ0 , σ )β2 (λ1 , σ )) dνg (σ ),
where σ = (s0 , s1 ) and α1 (λ0 , σ ) = ei(s0 −s1 )λ0 g(λ0 ), α2 (λ0 , σ ) = ei(s0 −s1 )λ0 ,
β1 (λ1 , σ ) = eis1 λ1 ,
β2 (λ1 , σ ) = eis1 λ1 g(λ1 ),
(6)
so that α1 (·, σ ), β2 (·, σ ) ∈ Cc2 () for all σ ∈ , and |α1 (·)| , |β2 (·)| g∞ , while α2 (·, σ ), β1 (·, σ ) ∈ C ∞ (R) for all σ ∈ , and |α2 (·)| , |β1 (·)| 1. Proof. The assumption g ∈ Cc2 (R) implies that g ∈ C 1,+ (R) (see Corollary 1.13). Now, g 2 (λ0 ) − g 2 (λ1 ) λ0 − λ1 g(λ0 ) − g(λ1 ) = (g(λ0 ) + g(λ1 )) = g [1] (λ0 , λ1 ) (g(λ0 ) + g(λ1 )) . λ0 − λ1
f [1] (λ0 , λ1 ) =
Hence, using (5), we have f [1] (λ0 , λ1 ) = (α(λ0 , σ )g(λ0 )β(λ1 , σ ) + α(λ0 , σ )g(λ1 )β(λ1 , σ )) dνg (σ ).
If we set α1 (λ, σ ) = α(λ, σ )g(λ), β1 (λ, σ ) = β(λ, σ ), α2 (λ, σ ) = α(λ, σ ) and β2 (λ, σ ) = g(λ)β(λ, σ ), then we see that all the conditions of the lemma are fulfilled. The next step is to recall the definition of the multiple operator integral as it was given in [3]. Let ϕ ∈ B(Rn+1 ) be a bounded Borel function on Rn+1 which admits a representation of the form ϕ(λ0 , λ1 , . . . , λn ) = α0 (λ0 , σ ) . . . αn (λn , σ ) dν(σ ), (7) S
where (S, ν) is a finite measure space and α0 , . . . , αn are bounded Borel functions on R × S. Definition 1.15. For arbitrary self-adjoint operators D0 , . . . , Dn on the separable Hilbert space H, bounded operators V1 , . . . , Vn on H and any function ϕ ∈ B(Rn+1 ) which admits a representation given by (7), the multiple operator integral TϕD0 ,...,Dn (V1 , . . . , Vn ) is defined as (8) TϕD0 ,...,Dn (V1 , . . . , Vn ) := α0 (D0 , σ )V1 . . . Vn αn (Dn , σ ) dν(σ ), S
where the integral is taken in the so∗ -topology.
60
N. A. Azamov, A. L. Carey, F. A. Sukochev
Proposition 1.16. [3, Lemma 4.3] The multiple operator integral in Definition 1.15 is well-defined in the sense that it does not depend on the representation (7) of ϕ. The following lemma is a corollary of Lemma 1.14 and the definition of the multiple operator integral. Lemma 1.17. If D0 = D0∗ ηN , if D1 = D0 + V, V = V ∗ ∈ N and if f ∈ Cc2 (R) is a √ non-negative function, such that g := f ∈ Cc2 (R), then T fD[1]1 ,D0 (V ) = (α1 (D1 , σ )Vβ1 (D0 , σ ) + α2 (D1 , σ )Vβ2 (D0 , σ )) dνg (σ ),
where α1 , β1 , α2 , β2 are given by (1.14). We need the following weaker version of [3, Theorem 5.3]. See also [10]. Proposition 1.18. [3, Theorem 5.3] Let N be a von Neumann algebra. Suppose that D0 = D0∗ is affiliated with N , that V ∈ N is self-adjoint and set D1 = D0 + V. (i) If f ∈ C 1,+ (R), then f (D1 ) − f (D0 ) = T fD[1]1 ,D0 (V ). (ii) If f ∈ C 2,+ (R), then the function f : D0 + Nsa → f (D0 ) + Nsa is affinely (N , N )Fréchet differentiable, the equality DN f (D) = T fD,D holds and DN f (D) is [1] ·-continuous, where DN is to be understood in the sense of Definition 1.1. 1.4. Some continuity and differentiability properties of operator functions. We are going to consider spectral flow along ‘continuous’ paths of unbounded Fredholm operators. We will make precise what we mean by continuity in this setting later. However our formulae require more than just continuity. They require us to be able to take derivatives with respect to the path parameter. For this to be feasible we need the full force of the double operator integral formalism. We present the results we will need as a sequence of lemmas. Lemma 1.19. Let (S, ν) be a finite measure space and let f : S → L1 (N , τ ) be a L1 (N , τ )-bounded so∗ -measurable function. Then f (σ ) dν(σ ) f (σ )L1 d |ν| (σ ). L1
Proof. By definition for any η ∈ H the function σ → f (σ )η is Bochner measurable. Hence, the function σ → f (σ ) = supη∈H : η1 f (σ )η is also measurable. Similarly, since the function σ → τ ( f (σ )B) is measurable, the function σ → f (σ )1 = sup B∈N : B1 |τ ( f (σ )B)| is also measurable. Hence, the right-hand side of the last equality is well defined. For η ∈ H with η 1 we have by definition of so∗ -integral (see [3, (2)]) f (σ ) dν(σ )η = f (σ )η dν(σ ) (9) f (σ )η d |ν| (σ ) f (σ ) d |ν| (σ ).
Spectral Shift Function and Spectral Flow
61
Hence, the inequality is true for ·-norm. Since A1 = sup B∈N : B1 |τ (AB)| , we have
f (σ ) dν(σ ) =
f (σ ) dν(σ )B
sup
τ 1
B∈N : B1
= sup
τ ( f (σ )B) dν(σ ) B∈N : B1 |τ ( f (σ )B)| dν(σ ) sup B∈N : B1
f (σ )1 d |ν| (σ ),
(10)
where the second equality follows from the definition of so∗ -integral and Lemma 1.11. Combining (9) and (10) completes the proof. In the sequel we will constantly need to take functions of a path of operators. We thus need the following continuity result. For the definition of B R see Lemma 1.7. Proposition 1.20. If D0 = D0∗ ηN has τ -compact resolvent and if f ∈ Cc2 (R) then the operator-valued function A : V ∈ B R → f (D0 + V ) takes values in L1 (N , τ ) and is L1 (N , τ )-continuous. Proof. That A(·) takes values in L1 (N , τ ) follows from Lemma 1.3 and Corollary 1.5. By Lemma 1.2 it is enough to prove continuity for a non-negative function f with √ g = f ∈ Cc2 (R). By Proposition 1.18(i) and Lemma 1.17 we have f (D0 +V )− f (D0 ) = T fD[1]0 +V,D0 (V ) = (α1 (D0 +V, σ )Vβ1 (D0 , σ )+α2 (D0 +V, σ )Vβ2 (D0 , σ )) dνg (σ ).
Hence, by Lemma 1.19, we have f (D0 + V ) − f (D0 )1,∞ α1 (D0 + V, σ )1,∞ V β1 (D0 , σ )
+ α2 (D0 + V, σ ) V β2 (D0 , σ )1,∞ d νg (σ )
g(D0 +V )1,∞ V +V g(D0 )1,∞ d νg (σ )
νg ( ) V (g(D0 + V )1,∞ + g(D0 )1,∞ ). Now, Corollary 1.8 applied to g completes the proof.
Corollary 1.21. If D0 = D0∗ ηN has τ -compact resolvent, r = (r1 , . . . , rm ) ∈ [a, b]m , if V1 , . . . , Vm ∈ Nsa and if Dr = D0 + r V = D0 + r1 V1 + · · · + rm Vm , then for any function f ∈ Cc2 (R) the operator-valued function A : r ∈ [a, b]m → f (D0 + r V ) takes values in L1 (N , τ ) and is L1 (N , τ )-continuous. Next we prove the main lemmas of this section. There are several matters to establish. First we want to be able to differentiate, with respect to the path parameter, certain functions of paths of operators. Then we need to determine formulae for the derivatives and the continuity properties of the derivatives with respect to the path parameter.
62
N. A. Azamov, A. L. Carey, F. A. Sukochev
Lemma 1.22. If D1 and D2 are two self-adjoint operators with τ -compact resolvent affiliated with semifinite von Neumann algebra N , if X ∈ Nsa and if f ∈ Cc3 (R) then T fD[1]1 ,D2 (X ) depends L1 -continuously on · perturbations of D1 and D2 . Proof. As usual, we can assume that f is non-negative and its square root g = C 3 -smooth. Let Y1 , Y2 ∈ Nsa . Then by Lemma 1.17,
√
f is
T fD[1]1 +Y1 ,D2 +Y2 (X ) − T fD[1]1 ,D2 (X ) = [α1 (D1 + Y1 , σ )Xβ1 (D2 + Y2 , σ ) + α2 (D1 + Y1 , σ )Xβ2 (D2 + Y2 , σ )
−α1 (D1 , σ )Xβ1 (D2 , σ ) − α2 (D1 , σ )Xβ2 (D2 , σ )] dνg (σ ) = ([α1 (D1 + Y1 , σ ) − α1 (D1 , σ )] Xβ1 (D2 + Y2 , σ )
+α1 (D1 , σ )X [β1 (D2 + Y2 , σ ) − β1 (D2 , σ )] + [α2 (D1 + Y1 , σ ) − α2 (D1 , σ )] Xβ2 (D2 + Y2 , σ ) +α2 (D1 , σ )X [β2 (D2 + Y2 , σ ) − β2 (D2 , σ )]) dνg (σ ). For every fixed σ ∈ by Lemma 1.10 the norms β1 (D2 + Y2 , σ ) − β1 (D2 , σ ) and α2 (D1 + Y1 , σ ) − α2 (D1 , σ ) converge to zero when Y1 , Y2 → 0, and by Corollary 1.8 the L1 -norms of α1 (D1 , σ ) and β2 (D2 + Y2 , σ ) are bounded when Y1 , Y2 → 0. Hence, for every fixed σ ∈ the L1 -norms of the second and third summands in the last integral converge to zero when Y1 , Y2 → 0. Now we are going to show that the same is true for the first and fourth summands. It is enough to prove that for every fixed σ ∈ , for example, α1 (D1 +Y1 , σ )−α1 (D1 , σ )L1 tends to zero. We have α1 (D1 + Y1 , σ ) − α1 (D1 , σ )L1 = ei(s0 −s1 )(D1 +Y1 ) g(D1 + Y1 ) − ei(s0 −s1 )D1 g(D1 ) 1 L i(s0 −s1 )(D1 +Y1 ) i(s0 −s1 )D1 g(D1 + Y1 ) 1 e −e L i(s0 −s1 )D1 + e (g(D1 + Y1 ) − g(D1 )) 1 L i(s0 −s1 )(D1 +Y1 ) i(s0 −s1 )D1 e −e g(D1 + Y1 )L1 + g(D1 + Y1 ) − g(D1 )L1 . It follows from Lemma 1.10 that the first summand converges to zero when s0 , s1 are fixed and Y1 → 0, and it follows from Proposition 1.20 that the second summand also converges to zero. Since by Corollary 1.8 the trace norm of the expression under the last integral is uniformly L1 (N , τ )-bounded with respect to σ ∈ , it follows from Lemma 1.19 that D1 +Y1 ,D2 +Y2 (X ) − T fD[1]1 ,D2 (X ) 1 → 0, T f [1] L
when Y1 , Y2 → 0.
Spectral Shift Function and Spectral Flow
63
The following theorem is a version of a well-known Daletskii-S. G. Kre˘ın formula [21]. We would like to give a heuristic argument explaining the formula (11). In the resolvent expansion series 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 = + V + V V + ... z−H −V z−H z−H z−H z−H z−H z−H the second summand is a double operator integral TϕH,H (V ) with ϕ(λ, µ) =
1 1 1 · = z−λ z−µ λ−µ
1 1 − . z−λ z−µ
If H and H + V are bounded operators and f is a function analytic in a neighbourhood of the union of the spectra of H and H + V then the Cauchy integral implies f (H + V ) = f (H ) + T fH,H [1] (V ) + terms of second order. Theorem 1.23. If the von Neumann algebra N is semifinite, D0 = D0∗ ηN has τ -compact resolvent and f ∈ Cc3 (R), then the function f : D ∈ D0 + Nsa → f (D) ∈ Nsa takes values in L1 (N , τ )sa . Moreover, it is affinely (N , L1 )-Fréchet differentiable, the equality DN ,L1 f (D) = T fD,D [1] holds, and DN ,L1 f (D) is (N , L1 )-continuous, so that b T fD[1]r ,Dr (V ) dr, f (Db ) − f (Da ) =
(11)
(12)
a
where V ∈ Nsa , Dr = D0 + r V and the integral converges in L1 (N , τ )-norm. Proof. We have by Proposition 1.18(i) and Lemma 1.17, f (D1 ) − f (D0 ) = T fD[1]1 ,D0 (V ) = (α1 (D1 , σ )Vβ1 (D0 , σ ) + α2 (D1 , σ )Vβ2 (D0 , σ )) dνg (σ ), = (α1 (D0 , σ )Vβ1 (D0 , σ ) + α2 (D0 , σ )Vβ2 (D0 , σ )) dνg (σ )
+ [α1 (D1 , σ ) − α1 (D0 , σ )]Vβ1 (D0 , σ ) dνg (σ ) + [α2 (D1 , σ ) − α2 (D0 , σ )]Vβ2 (D0 , σ ) dνg (σ ) =
D0 ,D0 T f [1] (V ) + (I I ) + (I I I ).
Since α2 is just an exponent and since g ∈ C 2,+ (R), (I I I )L1 = O(V 2 ) can be shown by Duhamel’s formula. The argument is as in the proof of [3, Theorem 5.5]. So,
64
N. A. Azamov, A. L. Carey, F. A. Sukochev
it is left to show that (I I )L1 is o(V ). By Lemma 1.19 we have (I I )L1 = [α1 (D1 , σ ) − α1 (D0 , σ )]Vβ1 (D0 , σ ) dνg (σ ) 1 L α1 (D1 , σ ) − α1 (D0 , σ )L1 V β1 (D0 , σ ) dνg (σ )
α1 (D1 , σ ) − α1 (D0 , σ )L1 dνg (σ ). = V
Now, it follows from α1 (·, σ ) ∈ Cc2 (R) (see (1.14)) and Proposition 1.20 that α1 (D1 , σ )− α1 (D0 , σ )L1 → 0, σ ∈ , so that by the Lebesgue dominated convergence theorem we conclude that the last integral converges to 0, and hence (I I )L1 = o(V ). Finally, that DN ,L1 f (D) is (N , L1 )-continuous follows from Lemma 1.22. 1.5. A class F a,b (N , τ ) of τ -Fredholm operators. Our technique for handling spectral flow of paths of unbounded operators is to map them into the space of bounded operators using a particular function. We thus need to discuss some continuity properties of paths of bounded τ -Fredholm operators, analogous to those we described in the unbounded case. Let a < b be two real numbers. Let F a,b (N , τ ) be the set of bounded self-adjoint τ -Fredholm operators F ∈ N such that (F − a)(F − b) ∈ K(N , τ ). For F0 ∈ F a,b (N , τ ) let A F0 = F0 + K(N , τ )sa be the affine space of τ -compact self-adjoint perturbations of F0 . Lemma 1.24. If F0 ∈ F a,b (N , τ ) then A F0 ⊆ F a,b (N , τ ). Proof. If K ∈ K(N , τ )sa then (F0 + K − a)(F0 + K − b) = (F0 − a)(F0 − b) + (F0 − a)K + K (F0 + K − b) ∈ K(N , τ ). Lemma 1.25. If F ∈ F a,b (N , τ ) and h ∈ Bc (a, b) then h(F) ∈ L1 (N , τ ). Proof. The proof is similar to the proof of Lemma 1.4. For any compact subset of (a, b) there exists a constant c0 > 0 such that χ (x) c0 χ[a,b] (x)(b − x)(x − a), so that F F c0 E [a,b] (b − F)(F − a). E
(13)
F ∈ K(N , τ ) and hence E F is Since (b − F)(F − a) ∈ K(N , τ ), it follows that E τ -finite. Now, for any h ∈ Bc (a, b) there exists a compact subset of (a, b) and a F and hence h(F) ∈ L1 (N , τ ). constant c1 such that |h| c1 χ , so that |h(F)| c1 E
Lemma 1.26. If F0 ∈ F a,b (N , τ ), K = K ∗ ∈ K(N , τ ), and if is a compact subset of (a, b), then (i) the function r ∈ [0, 1] L1 (N , τ )-bounded;
→
F0 +r K E takes values in L1 (N , τ ) and is
Spectral Shift Function and Spectral Flow
65
F0 +K (ii) there exists R > 0 such that the function K ∈ B R ∩ K(N , τ ) → E takes 1 1 values in L (N , τ ) and is L (N , τ )-bounded. F0 +r K Fr Proof. (i) That E = E ∈ L1 (N , τ ) follows from Lemmas 1.25 and 1.26. By Fr Fr c0 E [a,b] (b − Fr )(Fr − a) for all r ∈ [0, 1] and hence by [22, (13) we have E Lemma 2.5]
Fr Fr ) c0 µt E [a,b] (b − Fr )(Fr − a) c0 µt [(b − Fr )(Fr − a)] . µt (E Since (b − Fr )(Fr − a) = (b − F0 )(F0 − a) + r L 1 − r 2 L 2 , where L 1 , L 2 ∈ K(N , τ ), we have by [22, Lemma 2.5(v)] Fr µt (E ) c0 µt/3 [(b − F0 )(F0 − a)] + r µt/3 (L 1 ) + r 2 µt/3 (L 2 )
c0 µt/3 [(b − F0 )(F0 − a)] + µt/3 (L 1 ) + µt/3 (L 2 ) , Fr so that µt (E ) = χ
Fr (t) [0,τ E ]
(14)
is majorized for all r ∈ [0, 1] by a single function
decreasing to 0 when t → ∞, since all three operators (b − F0 )(F0 − a), L 1 and L 2 are τ -compact. The same argument as in Lemma 1.7 now completes the proof. (ii) If F = F0 + K then (b − F)(F − a) = (b − F0 )(F0 − a) + L , where L = (b− F0 )K − K (F0 −a)− K 2 ∈ K(N , τ ). Choose the number R > 0 such that K < R F+K ) = χ
F+K (t) will be implies L < 1. Then by (14) the function t → µt (E ] [0,τ E majorized by a single function decreasing to a number <1, so that the same argument as in Lemma 1.7 again completes the proof. Proposition 1.27. Let F0 ∈ F a,b (N , τ ), K = K ∗ ∈ K(N , τ ), and let h ∈ Cc2 (a, b). Then (i) the function r ∈ R → h(F0 + r K ) takes values in L1 (N , τ ) and is L1 (N , τ )continuous; (ii) there exists R > 0 such that the function K ∈ B R ∩ K(N , τ ) → h(F0 + K ) takes values in L1 (N , τ ) and is L1 (N , τ )-continuous. Proof. The proof of this proposition follows verbatim the proof of Proposition 1.20 with references to Lemmas 1.24, 1.25 and 1.26 instead of Lemmas 1.3, 1.5 and Corollary 1.8. Lemma 1.28. If F1 , F2 ∈ F a,b (N , τ ), X ∈ K(N , τ )sa and h ∈ Cc3 (a, b), then the double operator integral ThF[1]1 ,F2 (X ) takes values in L1 (N , τ ) and is L1 (N , τ )-continuous with respect to norm perturbations of F1 and F2 by τ -compact operators. The proof of this lemma is similar to that of Lemma 1.22 with references to Lemma 1.26(ii) and Proposition 1.27(ii) instead of Corollary 1.8 and Proposition 1.20.
66
N. A. Azamov, A. L. Carey, F. A. Sukochev
Theorem 1.29. Let N be a semifinite von Neumann algebra. If F0 ∈ F a,b (N , τ ), h ∈ Cc3 (a, b), then the function h : F ∈ F0 + Ksa (N , τ ) → h(F0 ) + Ksa (N , τ ) takes values in L1 (N , τ )sa . Moreover, it is affinely (K, L1 )-Fréchet differentiable, the equality DK,L1 h(F) = ThF,F [1] holds, and DK,L1 h(F) is (K, L1 ) continuous, so that r0 h(Fr1 ) − h(Fr0 ) = ThF[1]r ,Fr (K ) dr,
r0 , r1 ∈ R,
(15)
r1
where K ∈ Ksa (N , τ ), Fr = F0 + r K and the integral is in L1 (N , τ )-norm. The proof is similar to that of Theorem 1.23 with use of Proposition 1.27(ii) and Lemma 1.28 instead of Proposition 1.20 and Lemma 1.22, and therefore it is omitted. 2. Spectral Shift Function We will take an approach to the notion of spectral shift function suggested by the BirmanSolomyak formula (16). The key point is that once one appreciates that the spectral shift function of M. G. Krein is related to spectral flow in a specific fashion one can reformulate the whole approach to take advantage of what is known about spectral flow as expounded for example in [5]. The theorem in [3] which connects spectral flow and the spectral shift function contains the germ of the idea but one needs the technical machinery of the last section to exploit this. We now explain this different way to approach spectral shift theory which is influenced by ideas from noncommutative geometry. 2.1. The unbounded case. 2.1.1. Spectral shift measure. In order to make our main definition we need to prove a preliminary result which complements [3, Lemma 6.2]. The latter asserts that the Dr function γ (λ, r ) = τ V E λ is measurable for every V ∈ L1 (N , τ ) and D = D ∗ ηN . Lemma 2.1. Let (N , τ ) be a semifinite von Neumann algebra and let D = D ∗ ηN have resolvent. If V = V ∗ ∈ N then the function f : (a, b, r ) ∈ R3 → τ -compact Dr τ V E (a,b) is measurable. Proof. W.l.o.g. we can assume that V 0. It is enough to prove that the function f is measurable with the second variable b and with respect to r. Since √ respect√to Dr Dr τ V E (a,b) = τ V E (a,b) V , we know by [27, Lemma 5.9] that it is enough √ Dr √ to prove that the operator function (r, b) → V E (a,b) V is so∗ -measurable. By [3, 3.2] it is enough to prove that for any ξ, η ∈ H the scalar function √ Proposition Dr √ Dr V E (a,b) V ξ, η = Tr(θ√V ξ,√V η E (a,b) ) is measurable, where θξ,η (ζ ) := ξ, ζ η. √ √ Since the operator θ V ξ, V η is trace class, the measurability of this function follows from [3, Lemma 6.2].
Spectral Shift Function and Spectral Flow
67
Definition 2.2. If D0 = D0∗ ηN has τ -compact resolvent and if D1 = D0 + V, V ∈ Nsa , then the spectral shift measure for the pair (D0 , D1 ) is defined to be the following Borel measure on R: 1 Dr dr, ∈ B(R). (16) D1 ,D0 () = τ V E 0
The generalized function ξ D1 ,D0 (λ) =
d D ,D (a, λ) dλ 1 0
(17)
is called the spectral shift distribution for the pair (D0 , D1 ). Evidently, this definition does not depend on a choice of a. By Lemmas 1.3, 1.4, 2.1 and Corollary 1.9(i) the measure exists and is locally finite. Our task now is to show that the spectral shift distribution is in fact a function of locally bounded variation. 2.1.2. Spectral shift function. The main result we wish to establish next is that the spectral shift measure is absolutely continuous with respect to Lebesgue measure. Moreover its density, which we previously referred to as the spectral shift distribution, is in fact a function of locally bounded variation which we will then refer to as the spectral shift function. It is our extension of M. G. Krein’s function to the setting of this paper. Our method of proof is to first establish some trace formulae. Lemma 2.3. (i) Let D = D ∗ ηN have τ -compact resolvent. A function α ∈ B(R) is D ) ( ∈ B(R)), if and only if α(D) ∈ 1-summable with respect to the measure τ (E L1 (N , τ ) and in this case α(λ) τ d E λD . τ (α(D)) = R
Furthermore, for any V = V ∗ ∈ N the function α is 1-summable with respect to the D ), and measure τ (V E α(λ) τ V d E λD . τ (V α(D)) = R
(ii) Let F ∈ F a,b (N , τ ). A function α ∈ B(a, b) is 1-summable with respect to the F ) ( ∈ B(a, b)), if and only if α(F) ∈ L1 (N , τ ) and in this case measure τ (E τ (α(F)) =
b
a
α(λ) τ d E λF .
Furthermore, for any V = V ∗ ∈ N the function α is 1-summable with respect to the F ), and measure τ (V E τ (V α(F)) = a
b
α(λ) τ V d E λF .
68
N. A. Azamov, A. L. Carey, F. A. Sukochev
Proof. We give only the proof of (i). W.l.o.g. we can assume that α is a non-negative function. If α is a simple function then the first part of the claim follows from Lemma 1.4. Let αn be an increasing sequence of simple non-negative functions, converging pointwise to α. Then for each of the functions αn the first equality is true. The supremum of the increasing sequence of non-negative operators α n (D) is α(D) of and the
supremum the increasing sequence of numbers R αn (λ) τ d E λD is R α(λ) τ d E λD . Hence,
both non-negative numbers R α(λ) τ d E λD and τ (α(D)) are finite or infinite simultaneously, which proves the first part of the lemma. For the second part we can assume w.l.o.g. that V 0. Then again both parts of the second equality make sense and they are for simple functions. √ equal √
D = τ D V , ∈ B(R), is non-negative and Since the measure τ V E V E √ √ √ √ the supremum of V αn (D) V ∈ L1 (N , τ ) is V α(D) V we have that α(λ) τ V d E λD = lim αn (λ) τ V d E λD n→∞ R R √ √ √ √ V αn (D) V = τ V α(D) V , = lim τ n→∞
D
so that R α(λ) τ V d E λ simultaneously.
√
and τ (V α(D)) = τ
√ V α(D) V are finite or infinite
We need the following version of Fubini’s theorem. Lemma 2.4. (i) For any self-adjoint operator DηN with τ -compact resolvent and V =
D . Let D = D ∗ ηN have τ -compact resolvent and V ∗ ∈ N , let m D,V () = τ V E 0 0 let Dr = D0 + r V. If g ∈ Bc (R), then 1 dr g(λ) m Dr ,V (dλ) = g(λ) D1 ,D0 (dλ). (18) 0
R
R
0
a
a
F , ∈ B(a, b). (ii) For any F ∈ F a,b (N , τ ) and V = V ∗ ∈ N , let m F,V () = τ V E Let F ∈ F a,b (N , τ ) and let Fr = F0 + r V. If g ∈ Bc (a, b), then b 1 b dr g(λ) m Fr ,V (dλ) = g(λ) F1 ,F0 (dλ). Proof. (See also [25, VI.2]). We give only the proof of (i). The measurability of the function r → R g(λ) m Dr ,V (dλ) follows from Lemma 2.1. Note that both integrals are repeated ones. Let ⊇ supp(g) be a finite interval.
By Corollary 1.9 (i) there exists M > 0 such that for all r ∈ [0, 1] we have m Dr ,V () M. If g(λ) = χ (λ), ∈ B(), then 1 1 dr χ (λ) m Dr ,V (dλ) = m Dr ,V () dr = () = χ (λ) (dλ). 0
0
So, (18) is true for simple functions. Let now g be an arbitrary function from Bc (), let ε > 0 and let h be a simple function such that g − h∞ < ε. Then the LHS of (18) is equal to 1 1 dr (g − h)(λ) m Dr ,V (dλ) + dr h(λ) m Dr ,V (dλ) = (I ) + (I I ), 0
0
Spectral Shift Function and Spectral Flow
69
and the RHS of (18) is equal to (g − h)(λ) (dλ) + h(λ) (dλ) = (I I I ) + (I V ).
We have (I I ) = (I V ). Further, |(I )| M g − h∞ Mε and |(I I I )| M g − h∞ Mε. The following theorem complements [3, Theorem 6.3]. Theorem 2.5. If D = D ∗ ηN has τ -compact resolvent, if V = V ∗ ∈ N , and if D1 = D0 + V, then the measure D1 ,D0 is absolutely continuous, its density is equal to D0 D1 − τ E (a,λ] + const (19) ξ D1 ,D0 (·) = τ E (a,λ] for almost all λ ∈ R. Moreover, for all f ∈ Cc3 (R) f (D1 ) − f (D0 ) ∈ L1 (N , τ ) and τ ( f (D1 ) − f (D0 )) = f (λ)ξ D1 ,D0 (λ) dλ. (20) R
Proof. By Lemma 1.3 and Corollary 1.5 f (D1 ) − f (D0 ) ∈ L1 (N , τ ). By√Lemma 1.2 we need only consider the case of a non-negative function f with g := f ∈ Cc2 (R). We have by (12), 1 T fD[1]r ,Dr (V ) dr, f (D1 ) − f (D0 ) = 0
where the integral converges in that
L1 (N , τ )-norm.
Hence, it follows from Lemma 1.17
f (D1 ) − f (D0 ) 1 = (α1 (Dr , σ )Vβ1 (Dr , σ ) + α2 (Dr , σ )Vβ2 (Dr , σ )) dνg (σ ) dr. (21)
0
Now, for a fixed σ ∈ , we have τ (α1 (Dr , σ )Vβ1 (Dr , σ ) + α2 (Dr , σ )Vβ2 (Dr , σ )) = τ (V (α1 (Dr , σ )β1 (Dr , σ ) + α2 (Dr , σ )β2 (Dr , σ ))) = (α1 (λ, σ )β1 (λ, σ ) + α2 (λ, σ )β2 (λ, σ )) τ V d E λDr , R
where the last equality uses Lemma 2.3. (That α1 (λ)β1 (λ) + α2 (λ)β2 (λ) belongs to Bc (R) follows from Lemma 1.14.) Hence using (21), and by Lemma 1.11 applied to the finite measure space ([0, 1]× , dr ×νg our previous equality implies that we have: A := τ ( f (D1 ) − f (D0 )) 1 = τ (α1 (Dr , σ )Vβ1 (Dr , σ ) + α2 (Dr , σ )Vβ2 (Dr , σ )) dνg (σ ) dr 0
=
0
1
R
(α1 (λ, σ )β1 (λ, σ ) + α2 (λ, σ )β2 (λ, σ )) τ V d E λDr dνg (σ ) dr.
70
N. A. Azamov, A. L. Carey, F. A. Sukochev
Now, by Lemma 2.3, Fubini’s theorem, and Lemma 1.14 we have 1 A= (α1 (λ, σ )β1 (λ, σ ) + α2 (λ, σ )β2 (λ, σ )) dνg (σ ) τ V d E λDr dr
0
= 0
1
R R
f (λ) τ V d E λDr dr.
Finally, by Lemma 2.4 we have 1 A= f (λ) τ V d E λDr dr = R
R
0
f (λ) d D1 ,D0 (λ).
(22)
Let f ∈ Cc1 (R) and take a point a outside of the support of f. Then we have (see [1, Proposition 8.5.5]) A = τ ( f (D1 ) − f (D0 )) = τ ( f (D1 )) − τ ( f (D0 )) D1 D0 − (integrating by parts) = f (λ)dτ E (a,λ] f (λ)dτ E (a,λ] R R D1 D0 =− − τ E (a,λ] dλ. (23) f (λ) τ E (a,λ] R
Comparing (23) and (22) we see that is absolutely continuous with density equal to D0 D1 − τ E (a,λ] + const . (24) ξ D1 ,D0 (λ) = τ E (a,λ] It is worth noting that the formula (20) does not determine the function ξ uniquely, but only up to an additive constant. Remark 1. This theorem is an analogue of [4, Theorem 3.1], in which the existence and absolute continuity of the spectral shift measure were proved for any self-adjoint operator D affiliated with N and τ -trace class operator V ∈ N . As a result of what we have proved to this point we are now in a position to assert that in fact the spectral shift distribution is an everywhere defined function and hence to change our terminology and refer to ξ as a function. Moreover this last lemma enables one to modify ξ so as to make it a function defined everywhere in a natural way. Definition 2.6. If the expression (24) is continuous at a point λ ∈ R, then we define ξ D1 ,D0 (λ) via formula (24). Otherwise, we define the value of the spectral shift function ξ at a discontinuity point to be the half sum of left and right limits. Corollary 2.7. The spectral shift function ξ is a function of locally bounded variation. Proof. This is immediate because ξ is the difference of two increasing functions by the last formula. Lemma 2.8. Let D0 ηN be a self-adjoint operator with τ -compact resolvent, let V ∈ Nsa and let D1 = D0 + V. If f ∈ Bc (R) then ∞ 1 f (λ)ξ D1 ,D0 (λ) dλ = τ (V f (Dr )) dr. −∞
0
Spectral Shift Function and Spectral Flow
71
Proof. It follows from Lemma 2.3 and Lemma 2.4 that 1 1 ∞ τ (V f (Dr )) dr = f (λ)τ V d E λDr dr 0
0
=
∞
−∞
−∞
f (λ) 0
1
τ V d E λDr dr.
2.1.3. The spectral shift function for unitarily equivalent operators. The situation where the operators D and D + V, are unitarily equivalent arises naturally in noncommutative geometry in the context of spectral triples. One thinks of the unitary implementing the equivalence as a gauge transformation by analogy with the study of gauge transformations of Dirac type operators. It thus warrants special consideration especially in view of our first result below. Theorem 2.9. Let D be a self-adjoint operator affiliated with N having τ -compact resolvent and let V = V ∗ ∈ N be such that the operators D + V and D are unitarily equivalent. Then the spectral shift function ξ D+V,D of the pair (D + V, D) is constant on R. Proof. The operators f (D + V ) and f (D) are unitarily equivalent and for f ∈ Cc∞ (R) they are τ -trace class by Corollary 1.5. Hence, τ ( f (D + V ) − f (D)) = 0, so that by Theorem 2.5 the equality f (λ)ξ D+V,D (λ) dλ = 0 R
holds for any f ∈ Cc∞ (R). Now, integration by parts shows that ξ (λ) is zero as a generalized function on R, which by [23, Ch. I.2.6] implies that ξ is equal to a constant function. Note that function ξ in this theorem is equal to a constant function everywhere, not just almost everywhere. Our second major result on the spectral shift function in this special context is the following theorem. We shall show in Sect. 3 below that this theorem extends one of the main results of [16]. Theorem 2.10. Let D0 be a self-adjoint operator with τ -compact resolvent, affiliated with N . Let V = V ∗ ∈ N be such that the operators D1 = D0 + V and D0 are unitarily equivalent. If f ∈ Cc2 (R) then 1 ξ D1 ,D0 (µ) = C −1 τ (V f (Dr − µ)) dr, ∀ µ ∈ R, (25) 0 where C = R f (λ) dλ.
Proof. For any fixed µ the operator Dr − µ has τ -compact resolvent by Lemma 1.3 and the function r → τ (V f (Dr − µ)) is continuous by Proposition 1.20, so that the integral on the RHS of (25) exists. By Lemma 2.8 and Theorem 2.9 we have 1 τ (V f (Dr − µ)) dr = f (λ − µ)ξ D1 ,D0 (λ) dλ = ξ(0) f (λ) dλ.
0
R
R
72
N. A. Azamov, A. L. Carey, F. A. Sukochev
2.2. The bounded case. As we remarked previously, our technique in the next section for discussing spectral flow in the unbounded case is to map into the space of bounded τ -Fredholm operators. We thus need to develop the theory described in the previous subsections ab initio for the bounded case. Fortunately this is not a difficult task as the proofs are much the same. As we will see, because we are considering bounded perturbations of our unbounded operators, it suffices to consider compact perturbations in the bounded case. Definition 2.11. If F0 ∈ F a,b (N , τ ), K ∈ K(N , τ )sa , F1 = F0 + K and if Fr = F0 + r K , then the spectral shift measure for the pair (F0 , F1 ) is defined to be the following Borel measure on (a, b): 1 Fr F1 ,F0 () = dr, ∈ B(a, b). (26) τ K E 0
The generalized function d F ,F (c, λ), c ∈ (a, b), dλ 1 0 is called the spectral shift distribution for the pair (F0 , F1 ). ξ F1 ,F0 (λ) =
(27)
Evidently, this definition not depend on a choice of c ∈ (a, b). The measurability does Fr may be established following the argument of Lemma of the function r → τ K E 2.1, using Lemma 1.26. It follows that the measure exists and is locally-finite on (a, b). Proposition 2.12. If F0 ∈ F a,b (N , τ ), K ∈ K(N , τ ) and if F1 = F0 + K , then (i) the measure F1 ,F0 is absolutely continuous and its density is equal to F0 F1 + const, λ ∈ (c, b), ξ F1 ,F0 (λ) = τ E (c,λ] − E (c,λ] where c is an arbitrary number from (a, b); (ii) there exists a unique function ξ F1 ,F0 (·) of locally bounded variation on (a, b), such that for any h ∈ Cc2 (a, b) the following equality holds true: b h (λ)ξ F1 ,F0 (λ) dλ. τ (h(F1 ) − h(F0 )) = a
The proof is identical to the proof of Theorem 2.5, with references to 1.24, 1.25, (15) instead of 1.3, 1.5, (12) and hence we omit it. Corollary 2.13. In the setting of Proposition 2.12, if F0 and F1 are unitarily equivalent, then ξ F1 ,F0 is constant on (a, b). The proof is similar to the proof of Theorem 2.9. Definition 2.14. We redefine the function ξ F1 ,F0 at discontinuity points to be half the sum of the left and the right limits of the RHS of the last equality. Thus, the function ξ F1 ,F0 is defined everywhere on (a, b). Lemma 2.15. If F0 ∈ F a,b (N , τ ), K ∈ K(N , τ ), if Fr = F0 + r K , r ∈ [0, 1] and if h ∈ Bc (a, b) then 1 h(λ)ξ F1 ,F0 (λ) dλ = τ (K h(Fr )) dr. R
0
This lemma and its proof are bounded variants of Lemma 2.8, so we omit the details.
Spectral Shift Function and Spectral Flow
73
3. Spectral Flow 3.1. The spectral flow function. We wish to avoid a long excursion into the analytic theory of spectral flow preferring the reader to read the early Sections of [5] for the relevant background and definitions. With those prerequisites it is possible to appreciate that the following notions are well defined. We now introduce the spectral flow function on the real line. As usual we have D0 = D0∗ ηN with τ -compact resolvent and D1 = D0 + V with V bounded. Then we define the spectral flow function to be µ → sf(µ, D0 , D1 ), µ ∈ R, where sf(µ, D0 , D1 ) is spectral flow from D0 − µ to D1 − µ along the path Dr − µ = D0 − µ + r V . We remark that the homotopy invariance of spectral flow means that, in the affine space of bounded perturbations of a fixed operator D0 , spectral flow does not depend on the choice of continuous path but only on the endpoints. However one does need to make precise what one means by continuity in a path parameter in the unbounded case. We define the space of self adjoint, unbounded τ -Fredholm operators to be those operators that under the map D → FD = D(1 + D)−1/2 are sent to bounded τ -Fredholm operators in N . This definition is equivalent to the usual definition for unbounded Fredholm operators in a semifinite von Neumann algebra (more details on this can be found in [18].). A path of unbounded τ -Fredholm operators is said to be continuous if its image under this map is continuous in the norm topology on the bounded τ -Fredholm operators. This topology is usually called the Riesz topology and it is different from the graph norm topology used in [12]. A more detailed discussion of topologies on the set of unbounded self-adjoint Fredholm operators and the relevance of these for spectral flow may be found in [36]. We note that the condition of having compact resolvent implies the τ -Fredholm property for the unbounded operator. We now recall, to provide some motivation for the point of view of this section, some ideas from [16] which is couched in the language of noncommutative geometry [19]. In 2 [16] the condition of theta summability (τ (e−t D0 ) < ∞ for all real t > 0) is imposed and then the main result of [16] is an analytic formula for spectral flow from D0 to D1 = D0 + V . The ideas behind this formula go back to [2] and a more complete history may be found in [5]. The formula of [16] is as follows: 1 ε 2 τ V e−ε Dr dr sf(D0 , D1 ) = π 0 1 1 + (ηε (D1 ) − ηε (D0 )) + τ ([ker(D1 )] − [ker(D0 )]) , (28) 2 2 where ηε is a ‘truncated eta invariant’. For an unbounded self-adjoint operator D for 2 which e−t D is τ -trace class for all t > 0, it is defined in [16, Definition 8.1] following [24] by ∞ 1 2 ηε (D) := √ τ De−t D t −1/2 dt. π ε
74
N. A. Azamov, A. L. Carey, F. A. Sukochev
When the endpoints are unitarily equivalent the two ηε terms and the kernel correction terms in the formula for spectral flow cancel. In [3] we showed that in the theta summable case and for trace class perturbations the spectral shift function and the spectral flow function differ only by kernel correction terms. Our aim in this paper is to show that this is the case more generally and in fact to go further. We will demonstrate that the spectral shift function provides a way to prove more general analytic formulae for spectral flow than is achieved in [16]. The plan of this section is to first establish a geometric framework that is analogous to that of Getzler [24] and [16]. Then we derive analytic formulae for spectral flow in terms of the spectral shift function in both the case of paths of bounded τ -Fredholm operators and for paths of unbounded τ -Fredholm operators. The starting point is basically the same as that of [16] in that we need a formula for the relative index of two projections. This next result is a strengthening of [16, Theorem 4.1]. Lemma 3.1. Let P and Q be two projections in the semifinite von Neumann algebra N and let a < 0 < b be two real numbers. Let κ be a continuous function such that 2 2 for any s ∈ [0, (b−a) 4 ], κ(s(P − Q) ) is τ -trace class. Then F0 = (b − a)P + a and F1 = (b − a)Q + a are self-adjoint τ -Fredholm operators from F a,b (N , τ ) as is the path Fr = F0 + r (F1 − F0 ), and 1
−1 sf({Fr }) = Ca,b τ F˙r κ [(b − Fr )(Fr − a)] dr, 0
1
where Ca,b = 0 (b − a)κ (b − a)2 (r − r 2 ) dr is a constant, and the derivative F˙r is ·-derivative. Proof. We have F˙r = F1 − F0 = (b − a)(Q − P) and (b − Fr )(Fr − a) = (b − a)2 r (1 − r )(Q − P)2 , so that by assumption κ [(b − Fr )(Fr − a)] is τ -trace class for r ∈ [0, 1]. For each r ∈ (0, 1) define fr (x) = (b − a)xκ (b − a)2 (r − r 2 )x 2 . Then
1
0
τ F˙r κ [(b − Fr )(Fr − a)] dr
1
=
τ (b − a)(Q − P)κ (b − a)2 r (1 − r )(Q − P)2 dr,
(29)
0
and by [16, Theorem 3.1] we have 1
τ F˙r κ [(b− Fr )(Fr −a)] dr = 0
1
τ ( fr (Q − P)) dr
0
1 = fr (1) ind(Q P) dr = Ca,b ind(Q P) = Ca,b sf({Fr }), 0
where the last equality follows from a < 0 < b and the definition of spectral flow.
Spectral Shift Function and Spectral Flow
75
Remark 2. In the proof of this lemma we use [16, Theorem 3.1] for functions f without the condition f (1) = 0. But an inspection of the proof of this theorem shows that this condition becomes superfluous, if we rewrite the statement of this theorem as f (1) ind(Q P) = τ [ f (P − Q)], which for functions f with f (1) = 0 becomes just 0 = 0. 3.2. Spectral flow one-forms in the unbounded case. The strategy of [16] is geometric and follows ideas of [24]. The first step in this strategy is summarized in Proposition 3.3 in preparation for which we need an explicit formula for the derivative of a function of a path of operators. The method by which this is achieved in [16] does not apparently generalise sufficiently far to cover the situations considered in this paper. The double operator integral approach of Sect. 2 overcomes this problem. Lemma 3.2. Let D = D ∗ ηN , let X, Y ∈ N and let f ∈ Cc2 (R) be a non-negative √ D,D function such that g := f ∈ Cc2 (R). If Y T fD,D [1] (X ) and X T f [1] (Y ) are both τ -trace class then D,D τ Y T fD,D (X ) = τ X T (Y ) . [1] f [1] Proof. By Lemma 1.17 we have A = τ Y T fD,D [1] (X ) =τ Y (α1 (D, σ )Xβ1 (D, σ ) + α2 (D, σ )Xβ2 (D, σ )) dνg (σ ) i(s1 −s0 )D is1 D i(s1 −s0 )D is1 D e dνg (s0 , s1 ) . g(D)X e +e Xg(D)e =τ Y
Making the change of variables s1 − s0 = t0 , s1 = t1 , and using (4) we have (α1 (D, σ )Xβ1 (D, σ ) + α2 (D, σ )Xβ2 (D, σ )) dνg (σ )
i eit0 D g(D)X eit1 D = sgn(t0 + t1 ) √ 2 2π {(t0 ,t1 )∈R , t0 t1 0} it0 D +e Xg(D)eit1 D F(g)(t0 + t1 ) dt0 dt1 i eit0 D g(D)X eit1 D = sgn(t) √ 2π R t +eit0 D Xg(D)eit1 D dlt F(g)(t) dt, where t = (t0 , t1 ) ∈ R2 : t0 t1 0, t0 + t1 = t and dlt is the Lebesgue measure on t . Thus, by Fubini’s theorem [3, Lemma 3.8] i eit0 D g(D)X eit1 D A = sgn(t) √ τ Y 2π R t it0 D it1 D dlt F(g)(t) dt +e Xg(D)e
76
N. A. Azamov, A. L. Carey, F. A. Sukochev
i = sgn(t) √ τ Y eit0 D g(D)X eit1 D 2π R t +Y eit0 D Xg(D)eit1 D dlt F(g)(t) dt i = sgn(t) √ τ X eit1 D Y g(D)eit0 D 2π R t it1 D +X e g(D)Y eit0 D dlt F(g)(t) dt, where the trace and the integral can be interchanged by Lemma 1.11. The integral above D,D coincides with τ X T f [1] (Y ) . The key geometric idea is to regard the analytic formula for spectral flow of [24] and [16] as expressing it as an integral of a one form. As we are dealing with an affine space, the geometry is easy to invoke as we see in the next result. Proposition 3.3. Let D be a self-adjoint operator affiliated with N , having τ -compact resolvent and let f ∈ Cc3 (R). Let α = α f be a 1-form on the affine space D0 + Nsa defined at the point D ∈ D0 + Nsa by the formula f
α D (X ) = τ (X f (D)) , X ∈ Nsa , D ∈ D0 + Nsa .
(30)
Then α is a closed 1-form, and, hence, also exact by the Poincaré lemma. Proof. The proof follows mainly the lines √ of [15], with necessary adjustments. As usual, we can assume that f 0 and g := f ∈ Cc3 (R). We note that the operator X f (D) is τ -trace class, so that the 1-form α is well-defined. Now, by the definition of the exterior differential, for X, Y ∈ N , we have dα D (X, Y ) = £ X α D (Y ) − £Y α D (X ) − α D ([X, Y ]), where £ X is the Lie derivative along the constant vector field X. Since the space D0 +Nsa is flat, we have [X, Y ] = 0. So, we have to prove that £ X α D (Y ) = £Y α D (X ). It follows from Theorem 1.23 that
d
d
A := £ X α D (Y ) = α (Y ) = τ (Y f (D + s X )) D+s X ds s=0 ds s=0
= τ Y DN ,L1 f (D)(X ) = τ Y T fD,D [1] (X ) . Hence, by Lemma 3.2, D,D £ X α D (Y ) = τ Y T fD,D (X ) = τ X T (Y ) = £Y α D (X ), [1] f [1] which implies that α D is a closed 1-form.
Though closedness of a 1-form already should imply its exactness by the Poincaré lemma and contractibility of the domain we follow [16] and give an independent proof of exactness.
Spectral Shift Function and Spectral Flow
77
Definition 3.4. Let D0 be a fixed self-adjoint operator with τ -compact resolvent affiliated with N , and let f ∈ Cc (R). We define the function θ f on the affine space D0 + N by the formula 1 f τ (V f (Dr )) dr, θD = 0
where D ∈ D0 + Nsa , V = D − D0 and Dr = D0 + r V. Measurability of the function r → τ (V f (Dr )) follows from Lemma 2.1. Proposition 3.5. Let f ∈ Cc3 (R) and let X ∈ N . Then f
f
dθ D (X ) = α D (X ). Proof. W.l.o.g. we can assume that X is self-adjoint. By definitions f
(A) := dθ D (X )
1 d
d
f θ = τ ((V + s X ) f (Dr + sr X )) dr = ds s=0 D+s X ds s=0 0 1 1 = lim τ ((V + s X ) f (Dr + sr X ) − V f (Dr )) dr s→0 s 0 1 1 1 = lim τ (X f (Dr + sr X )) dr + lim τ (V ( f (Dr + sr X ) − f (Dr ))) dr. s→0 0 s→0 s 0 The first summand of this sum by Proposition 1.20 is equal to 1 τ (X f (Dr )) dr. 0
By Proposition 1.18(i) the second summand is equal to 1 1 1 Dr +sr X,Dr τ V T f [1] (sr X ) dr =lim τ V T fD[1]r +sr X,Dr (r X ) dr lim s→0 s 0 s→0 0 1 1 = τ V T fD[1]r ,Dr (r X ) dr = τ X T fD[1]r ,Dr (V ) r dr, 0
0
where the second equality follows from Lemma 1.22 and the last equality follows from Lemma 3.2. Hence, by Lemma 1.11, 1 τ X f (Dr ) + r T fD[1]r ,Dr (V ) dr (A) = 0 1 Dr ,Dr =τ X f (Dr ) + r T f [1] (V ) dr , 0
where the integral on the RHS is a so∗ -integral. By Proposition 1.20 and Lemma 1.22 the function r ∈ [0, 1] → f (Dr ) + r T fD[1]r ,Dr (V ) ∈ L1 (N , τ ) is L1 (N , τ )-continuous, so that the last integral 1 f (Dr ) + r T fD[1]r ,Dr (V ) dr (B) := 0
78
N. A. Azamov, A. L. Carey, F. A. Sukochev
can be considered as Riemann integral. Let 0 = r0 < r1 < · · · < rn = 1 be the partition of [0, 1] into n segments of equal length n1 . By the argument used in the proof of [3, Dr ,Dr j
Theorem 5.8] it can be shown that the L1 (N , τ )-norm of T f [1]j
(V ) − T fD[1]r ,Dr (V ),
r ∈ [r j−1 , r j ], has order n1 . Hence rj n 1 j Dr j ,Dr j Dr ,Dr 1 T L - lim (V ) − j T f [1] (V ) dr n→∞ n n f [1] r j−1 j=1
rj n Dr ,Dr 1 T f [1]j j (V ) − T fD[1]r ,Dr (V ) dr = 0, j n→∞ n r j−1
= L1 - lim
j=1
so that by formula (12) applied to the pair (Dr j−1 , Dr j ) we have n 1 j Dr j ,Dr j 1 f (Dr j−1 ) + T f [1] (B) = L - lim (V ) n→∞ n n j=1
n
1
f (Dr j−1 ) + j f (Dr j ) − f (Dr j−1 ) = L1 - lim n→∞ n j=1 rj n 1 j Dr j ,Dr j Dr ,Dr 1 (V ) − j T f [1] (V ) dr +L - lim T n→∞ n n f [1] r j−1 j=1
n 1
= L1 - lim j f (Dr j ) − ( j − 1) f (Dr j−1 ) = f (D1 ). n→∞ n j=1
The argument before [15, Proposition 1.5] now implies the following corollary. Corollary 3.6. The integral of the 1-form α f along a piecewise continuously differentiable path in D0 + N depends only on the endpoints of the path . Proposition 3.7. If a self-adjoint operator D0 affiliated with N has τ -compact resolvent, D1 , D2 ∈ D0 + Nsa , then for all λ ∈ R, ξ D2 ,D0 (λ) = ξ D2 ,D1 (λ) + ξ D1 ,D0 (λ). Remark. We emphasize that this additivity property is not almost everywhere in the spectral variable but in fact holds everywhere. Proof. It follows from (19) that ξ D2 ,D0 (λ) = ξ D2 ,D1 (λ) + ξ D1 ,D0 (λ) + C, where C is a constant. Multiplying both sides of this equality by a positive Cc2 -function f, and integrating it, by Lemma 2.8 we get αf = αf + αf +C f (λ) dλ, D2 ,D0
D2 ,D1
D1 ,D0
R
where Di ,D j is the straight line path connecting operators Di and D j . The last equality and Corollary 3.6 imply that C = 0.
Spectral Shift Function and Spectral Flow
79
3.3. Spectral flow one-forms in the bounded case. Since we obtain our unbounded spectral flow formula from a bounded one we need to study the map D → FD = D(1+ D 2 )−1/2 which takes the space of unbounded self adjoint operators with τ -compact resolvent to the space F −1,1 (N , τ ) of bounded τ -Fredholm operators F satisfying 1 − F 2 ∈ K(N , τ ). Let F0 ∈ F a,b (N , τ ), let h ∈ Cc2 (a, b) and let K = F − F0 , Fr := F0 + r K . We define a 0-form θ and a 1-form α h on the affine space A F0 by the formulae θ Fh =
1
τ (K h(Fr )) dr,
0
and α hF (X ) = τ (X h(F)) , X ∈ K(N , τ ). By Lemmas 1.24 and 1.25, the operators h(Fr ) and h(F) are τ -trace class, so that the forms θ h and α h are well-defined. Proposition 3.8. If F0 ∈ F a,b (N , τ ) and if h ∈ Cc2 (a, b), then dθ Fh (X ) = α hF (X ), where X ∈ K(N , τ ), so that the 1-form α hF is exact. Proof. The proof follows verbatim the proof of Proposition 3.5, with references to Proposition 1.27 and Lemma 1.28 instead of Proposition 1.20 and Lemma 1.22. As in the unbounded case we get the following Corollary 3.9. The integral of the one-form α h depends only on the end-points. Corollary 3.10. Let F j ∈ F a,b (N , τ ), j = 0, 1, 2, such that F2 − F1 , F1 − F0 ∈ K(N , τ ). Then for any λ ∈ (a, b) the following equality holds true ξ F2 ,F0 (λ) = ξ F2 ,F1 (λ) + ξ F1 ,F0 (λ). We omit the proof as it is similar to that of Proposition 3.7. Let −1/2 ϕ(λ) = λ 1 + λ2 . It is easy to see that if D = D ∗ ηN is an operator with τ -compact resolvent, then the operator FD := ϕ(D) belongs to F −1,1 (N , τ ). Proposition 3.11. If D0 = D0∗ ηN is an operator with τ -compact resolvent, and if V = V ∗ ∈ N , D1 = D0 + V, then the following equality holds: ξ D1 ,D0 (λ) = ξ FD1 ,FD0 (ϕ(λ)).
80
N. A. Azamov, A. L. Carey, F. A. Sukochev
Proof. Let h ∈ Cc3 (−1, 1) and f (λ) = h(ϕ(λ)). Then by Theorem 2.5, A := τ ( f (D1 ) − f (D0 )) =
f (λ)ξ D1 ,D0 (λ) dλ,
R
and since FD1 − FD0 ∈ K(N , τ ) by [15, Lemma 2.7], we can apply Proposition 2.12 to get
A = τ h(FD1 ) − h(FD0 ) = = =
1
−1 ∞
h (t)ξ FD1 ,FD0 (t) dt
−∞ ∞ −∞
h (ϕ(λ))ϕ (λ)ξ FD1 ,FD0 (ϕ(λ)) dλ f (λ)ξ FD1 ,FD0 (ϕ(λ)) dλ.
Since f is an arbitrary C 2 -function with compact support, comparing the last two formulas we get the equality ξ D1 ,D0 (λ) = ξ FD1 ,FD0 (ϕ(λ)) + C.
(31)
It is left to show that the constant C = 0. Let h be a non-negative function from Cc∞ (−1, 1). By Lemma 2.8 we have
R
h(ϕ(λ))ξ D1 ,D0 (λ) dλ =
1
0
τ V h(FDr ) dr.
(32)
Multiplying the first term of the RHS of (31) by h(ϕ(λ)), integrating it and using Lemma 2.15, we get
A := =
h(ϕ(λ))ξ FD1 ,FD0 (ϕ(λ)) dλ =
R 1
1
−1
τ K h(Fr )(ϕ −1 ) (Fr ) dr,
h(µ)ξ FD1 ,FD0 (µ)(ϕ −1 ) (µ) dµ
0
where K = FD1 − FD0 and Fr is the straight line path connecting FD1 and FD0 . Let g(µ) = h(µ)(ϕ −1 ) (µ). By Corollary 3.9 we have
1
A=
1
τ (K g(Fr )) dr =
0
0
τ F˙ Dr g(FDr ) dr.
By Proposition 1.18(ii) we have F˙ Dr = TϕD[1]r ,Dr (V ). Hence, A= 0
1
τ TϕD[1]r ,Dr (V )g(FDr ) dr.
Spectral Shift Function and Spectral Flow
81
Using the BS-representation for ϕ [1] given by (5), it follows from the definition of DOI (8), Lemma 1.12(ii) and Lemma 1.11, that 1 i(s−t)Dr it Dr A= τ e Ve dνϕ (s, t) · g(FDr ) dr
0
= 0
1
τ ei(s−t)Dr V eit Dr g(FDr ) dνϕ (s, t) dr
1 1 = √ τ V eis Dr is ϕ(s)g(F ˆ Dr ) ds dr 2π 0 R 1 1 = √ τ V g(FDr ) eis Dr is ϕ(s) ˆ ds dr 2π 0 R 1 1
= τ V g(FDr )ϕ (Dr ) dr = τ V h(FDr ) dr, 0
(33)
0
since g(ϕ(λ))ϕ (λ) = h(ϕ(λ)). It follows from (31), (32) and (33) that C R h(ϕ(λ)) dλ = 0 and, hence, C = 0. 3.4. The first formula for spectral flow. We establish first a spectral flow formula for bounded τ -Fredholm operators. In this way we avoid a number of difficulties with unbounded operators. Then we make a ‘change of variable’ to get to the unbounded case. First we require some additional notation which is important for establishing a convention for how we handle the situation when the endpoints have a kernel. Let a < 0, b > 0 and let signa,b be the function defined as signa,b (x) = b if x 0, and signa,b (x) = a if x < 0. = signa,b (F), when it is clear from the context what the numbers a We will write F and b are. Definition 3.12. If F ∈ F a,b (N , τ ) and κ is a C 2 -function on [0, ∞) vanishing in a neighbourhood of 0 then for h(λ) = κ ((b − λ)(λ − a)) we define γh (F) as 1 α hFr ( F˙r ) dr, γh (F) = 0
where α h is the closed one-form defined before Proposition 3.8, and {Fr }r ∈[0,1] is the straight line connecting F and F. The following theorem is the analogue in our setting of [16, Theorem 5.7]. It is the fundamental formula that we need as our starting point. Theorem 3.13. Let F0 ∈ F a,b (N , τ ), let K ∈ K(N , τ ) and let F1 = F0 + K . Let κ be a C 2 -function on [0, ∞) vanishing in a neighbourhood of 0, such that the integral of h(λ) = κ ((b − λ)(λ − a)) over (a, b) is equal to 1. Then the spectral flow between F0 and F1 is equal to b sf(F0 , F1 ) = h(λ)ξ F1 ,F0 (λ) dλ + γh (F1 ) − γh (F0 ). a
82
N. A. Azamov, A. L. Carey, F. A. Sukochev
Proof. The proof follows ideas of [16, Theorem 5.7]. First of all by Phillips’ definition of spectral flow [5] we have 0 , F 1 ). sf(F0 , F1 ) = sf( F (Note that, a priori we would expect to write 0 ) + sf( F 0 , F 1 ) + sf( F 1 , F1 ), sf(F0 , F1 ) = sf(F0 , F as noted in the proof however there is no spectral flow along the paths joining F and F of [15, Theorem 1.7].). Now, by Lemma 3.1 we have 0 , F 1 ) = sf( F
1
˙ ) dr, α hF ( F r r
0
r }r ∈[0,1] is the straight line path, connecting F 0 and F 1 . By Corollary 3.9 we where { F can replace this path by the (broken) path given on this diagram FO 0 _ _ _/ F 1 γ (F ) −γh (F0 ) h 1 /F 0 1 F Then we get 1 ) = −γh (F0 ) + 0 , F sf( F
1 0
α hFr ( F˙r ) dr + γh (F1 ),
where {Fr }r ∈[0,1] is the straight line path, connecting F0 and F1 . But, setting F1 − F0 = K , we have by Lemma 2.15, 0
1
α hFr ( F˙r ) dr =
0
1
τ (K h(Fr )) dr =
R
h(λ)ξ F1 ,F0 (λ) dλ.
Theorem 3.14. Let F0 ∈ F −1,1 (N , τ ), let K ∈ K(N , τ ) and let F1 = F0 + K . Let κ be a C 2 -function on [0, ∞) vanishing in a neighbourhood of 0, such that the integral of h(λ) = κ(1 − λ2 ) over (−1, 1) is equal to 1. Then the spectral flow function for the pair F0 and F1 is equal to sf(µ; F0 , F1 ) =
1
−1
where h −µ (λ) = h(λ + µ).
h(λ)ξ F1 ,F0 (λ) dλ + γh −µ (F1 − µ) − γh −µ (F0 − µ),
Spectral Shift Function and Spectral Flow
83
Proof. By definition we have sf(µ; F0 , F1 ) = sf(F0 − µ, F1 − µ). Since F j − µ ∈ F −1−µ,1−µ (N , τ ), by the previous theorem we have sf(F0 − µ, F1 − µ) 1−µ = h −µ (λ)ξ F1 −µ,F0 −µ (λ) dλ + γh −µ (F1 − µ) − γh −µ (F0 − µ). −1−µ
Since ξ F1 −µ,F0 −µ (λ) = ξ F1 ,F0 (λ + µ), we have sf(F0 − µ, F1 − µ) 1−µ h(λ + µ)ξ F1 ,F0 (λ + µ) dλ + γh −µ (F1 − µ) − γh −µ (F0 − µ) = −1−µ 1
=
−1
h(λ)ξ F1 ,F0 (λ) dλ + γh −µ (F1 − µ) − γh −µ (F0 − µ).
Corollary 3.15. If F0 and F1 are unitarily equivalent, then sf(µ; F0 , F1 ) = ξ F1 ,F0 (µ) = const.
Proof. By Corollary 2.13 the function ξ F1 ,F0 (·) is constant on (−1, 1), so that R h(λ) ξ F1 ,F0 (λ) dλ = ξ F1 ,F0 (0). If F0 and F1 are unitarily equivalent, then γh −µ (F1 − µ) = γh −µ (F0 − µ). Hence, for all µ ∈ (−1, 1), sf(µ; F0 , F1 ) = ξ F1 ,F0 (µ) = ξ F1 ,F0 (0). Lemma 3.16. If F ∈ F −1,1 (N , τ ) and if {h ε }ε>0 is an approximate δ function (by compactly supported even functions) then for all µ ∈ (−1, 1) the limit γµ (F) := lim γh ε (F − µ) ε→0
exists and is equal to ξG,G (0), where G = F − µ. Proof. Since h is an even function we have that
0 −∞
h ε (λ)ξG,G (λ) dλ →
1 ξ (0−) 2 G,G
h ε (λ)ξG,G (λ) dλ →
1 ξ (0+), 2 G,G
and
∞ 0
84
N. A. Azamov, A. L. Carey, F. A. Sukochev
then by Lemma as ε → 0. If {G r }r ∈[0,1] is the straight line path connecting G and G, 2.15 we have 1 1
˙ γh ε (G) = αh ε (G r ) dr = τ G˙ r h ε (G r ) dr 0 0 1
= ξG,G h ε (λ)ξG,G (λ) dλ → (0−) + ξG,G (0+) = ξG,G (0) 2 R as ε → 0, by Definition 2.6 of ξ at discontinuity points.
Now we need to handle the situation when the endpoints are not unitarily equivalent. For this we require some additional facts about the ‘end-point correction terms’. The interesting fact which we now establish is that the approach using the spectral shift function differs in a fundamental way from the previous point of view in [16]. The next few results demonstrate this by showing that the spectral shift function absorbs the contribution to the formula due to the spectral asymmetry of the endpoints leaving only kernel correction terms to be handled. Lemma 3.17. If F ∈ F −1,1 (N , τ ) and if µ ∈ (−1, 1), then the following equality holds true 1 γµ (F) = τ [ker(F − µ)]. 2 Proof. Let G = F − µ. We have G G τ [ker G] = τ E (−∞,0] . − E (−∞,0] By Proposition 2.12(ii) and Definition 2.14 the value ξG,G (0) is the half sum of the last expression and G G τ E (−∞,0) = 0. − E (−∞,0) Hence, by Lemma 3.16, γµ (F) = ξG,G (0) =
1 τ ([ker G]) . 2
Theorem 3.18. If F0 , F1 ∈ F −1,1 (N , τ ) such that F1 − F0 ∈ K(N , τ ), then for all µ ∈ (−1, 1), 1 sf(µ; F0 , F1 ) = ξ F1 ,F0 (µ) + (τ [ker(F1 − µ)] − τ [ker(F0 − µ)]). (34) 2 Proof. Replace h in Theorem 3.14 by h ε,µ (thus translate the approximate δ function h ε by µ) and then let ε → 0 using Lemmas 3.16, 3.17. We now see that under hypotheses that guarantee both are defined the spectral flow function and the spectral shift function differ only by kernel corrections terms for the endpoints. We should remark that the occurrence of the correction terms γµ (F j ), j = 1, 2, in the last formula can be explained by the fact that we actually define the spectral flow function and the spectral shift function at discontinuity points in different ways. The spectral shift function is defined as a half-sum of the left and the right limits, while the spectral flow is defined to be left-continuous.
Spectral Shift Function and Spectral Flow
85
3.5. Spectral flow in the unbounded case. The formulae for spectral flow in the bounded case may be now used to establish corresponding results in our original setting of unbounded self adjoint operators with compact resolvent. By Proposition 3.11 ξ D1 ,D0 (0) = ξ FD1 ,FD0 (0) and by definition of spectral flow for unbounded operators [5] sf(D0 , D1 ) = sf(FD1 , FD0 ). Hence, it follows from (34) taken at µ = 0 that sf(D0 , D1 ) = ξ D1 ,D0 (0) + γ0 (F1 ) − γ0 (F0 ). Since ker(D) = ker(FD ), we have the following equality: 1 1 sf(D0 , D1 ) = ξ D1 ,D0 (0) + τ [ker(D1 )] − τ [ker(D0 )]. 2 2 If we replace here the operators D0 and D1 by the operators D0 − λ and D1 − λ respectively then we get 1 1 sf(λ; D0 , D1 ) = ξ D1 −λ,D0 −λ (0) + τ [ker(D1 − λ)] − τ [ker(D0 − λ)]. 2 2 Since ξ D1 −λ,D0 −λ (0) = ξ D1 ,D0 (λ) it follows that 1 1 sf(λ; D0 , D1 ) = ξ D1 ,D0 (λ) + τ [ker(D1 − λ)] − τ [ker(D0 − λ)]. 2 2
(35)
3.6. The spectral flow formula using infinitesimal spectral flow. The results on the spectral shift function that we established in Sect. 2 now suggest a new direction for spectral flow theory. Definition 3.19. Let D0 be a self-adjoint operator affiliated with N having τ -compact resolvent. The infinitesimal spectral flow one-form is a distribution-valued one-form D on the affine space D0 + Nsa , defined by formula D (X ), ϕ = τ (X ϕ(D)) ,
X ∈ Nsa , ϕ ∈ Cc∞ (R).
Formally, D (X ) = τ (X δ(D)) , where δ(D) is the δ-function of D. We believe that the notion of infinitesimal spectral flow will have application to the problem of studying spectral flow when the endpoints differ by a D0 relatively bounded perturbation. To this end we establish that spectral flow may be reformulated in terms of it.
86
N. A. Azamov, A. L. Carey, F. A. Sukochev
Theorem 3.20. Let D1 ∈ D0 + Nsa . Spectral flow between D0 and D1 is equal to the integral of the infinitesimal spectral flow one-form along any piecewise C 1 -path {Dr }r ∈[0,1] in D0 + N connecting D0 and D1 in the sense that for any ϕ ∈ Cc∞ (R) the following equality holds true: 1 sf(λ; D0 , D1 )ϕ(λ) dλ = Dr ( D˙ r ), ϕ dr. R
0
Formally,
1
sf(D0 , D1 ) = 0
Dr ( D˙ r ) dr,
or
sf(λ; D0 , D1 ) = 0
1
Dr −λ ( D˙ r ) dr.
Proof. By Corollary 3.6 we can choose the path {Dr }r ∈[0,1] to be the straight line path Dr = D0 + r V . It follows from Lemmas 1.3 and 1.4 that the functions λ → τ ([ker(D0 − λ)]) and λ → τ ([ker(D1 − λ)]) can be non-zero only on a countable set. Hence, by (35) and Lemma 2.8 we have sf(λ; D0 , D1 )ϕ(λ) dλ = ξ D1 ,D0 (λ)ϕ(λ) dλ R
R 1
=
1
τ (V ϕ(Dr )) dr =
0
0
Dr ( D˙ r ), ϕ dr.
We remark that the infinitesimal spectral flow one-form is exact in the sense that its value on every test function is exact. 3.7. The spectral flow formulae in the I-summable spectral triple case. The original approach of [16] required summability constraints on the operator D0 . We will now see that if indeed D0 satisfies such conditions then we can weaken conditions on the function f in Theorem 2.10. Lemma 3.21. Let D0 be a self-adjoint operator with a τ -compact resolvent affiliated with
N . Let g be an increasing continuous function on [0, +∞), g(0) 0 and
such that g c(1 + D 2 )−1 ∈ L1 (N , τ ) for all c > 0. Let f (x) = g (1 + x 2 )−1 . Then for any R > 0 and for any V = V ∗ ∈ N the operator f (D + V ) is trace class and the function V ∈ B R → f (D + V )1 is bounded. Proof. By [22, Lemma 2.5(iv)] we have for all t > 0, −1 −1 2 2 = g µt 1 + (D + V ) . µt ( f (D + V )) = µt g 1 + (D + V ) By Lemma 1.7 there exists a constant c = c(R) > 0 such that for any V ∈ B R , −1 −1 1 + (D + V )2 c 1 + D)2 .
Spectral Shift Function and Spectral Flow
87
Hence, by [22, Lemma 2.5(iii)] we have −1 −1 2 2 µt ( f (D + V )) g µt c 1 + D = µt g c 1 + D .
Since g c(1 + D 2 )−1 ∈ L1 (N , τ ), the last function belongs to L 1 [0, ∞), which implies that f (D + V ) ∈ L1 (N , τ ). Lemma 3.22. Let D0 , g and f be as in Lemma 3.21. An integral of the one-form f
α D (X ) = τ (X f (D)), X ∈ N , D ∈ D0 + Nsa , along a piecewise smooth path in D0 + Nsa depends only on endpoints of that path. Proof. Let f n be an increasing sequence of compactly supported smooth functions converging pointwise to f and 1 , 2 be two piecewise smooth paths in D0 + Nsa with the same endpoints. Then by Lemma 3.21, Lebesgue dominated convergence theorem and Corollary 3.6 we have αf = lim α fn = lim α fn n→∞ 1 1 n→∞ 1 fn = lim α = lim α fn = αf. n→∞ 2
2 n→∞
2
The condition that g(c(1 + D02 )−1 ) be trace class is a generalised summability constraint. This notion arises naturally for certain ideals I of compact operators (for example for the Schatten ideals I p , p 1, g(x) = x p/2 and we have the notion of p-summability). We have also already remarked on the θ -summable case. Now if there is a unitary u ∈ N with V = u ∗ [D0 , u] bounded then we have, for a dense subalgebra A of the C ∗ -algebra generated by u, a semifinite ‘g-summable’ spectral triple (A, N , D0 ). Moreover D0 + V = u D0 u ∗ so we have unitarily equivalent endpoints. Theorem 3.23. Let f be a non-negative L 1 -function such that f (Dr ) ∈ L1 (N , τ ) for all r ∈ [0, 1], and let r → f (Dr )1 be integrable on [0, 1]. If D0 and D1 are unitarily equivalent then 1 −1 sf(λ; D0 , D1 ) = C τ (V f (Dr − λ)) dr, where C =
∞
−∞
0
f (λ) dλ.
Proof. Unitary equivalence of D0 and D1 implies that two last terms in (35) vanish. In case of f ∈ Bc (R), multiplying (35) by f (λ) and integrating it we get the required equality by Lemma 2.8 and Theorem 2.9. For an arbitrary f ∈ L 1 the claim follows from Lebesgue’s dominated convergence theorem by approximating f by an increasing sequence of step-functions converging a.e. to f. The following corollary recovers two of the main results of [15, 16].
88
N. A. Azamov, A. L. Carey, F. A. Sukochev
Corollary 3.24. (i) If D0 is θ -summable with respect to N and if D0 and D1 are unitarily equivalent then 1 ε 2 sf(D0 , D1 ) = τ V e−ε Dr dr. π 0 (ii) If D0 is p-summable (i.e. (1 + D02 )− p/2 ∈ L1 (N , τ )) with respect to N , where p > 1 and if D0 and D1 are unitarily equivalent then 1 − p 2 2 dr, sf(D0 , D1 ) = C −1 τ V 1 + D p r where C p =
∞
−∞
0
p
(1 + λ2 )− 2
dλ. p
Proof. Put f (λ) = e and f (λ) = (1+λ2 )− 2 for (i) and (ii) respectively in Theorem 3.23. The conditions of that theorem are fulfilled by Lemma 3.21. −ελ2
3.8. Recovering η-invariants. To demonstrate that we have indeed generalized previous analytic approaches to spectral flow formulae we still need some refinements. What is missing is the relationship of the ‘end-point correction terms’ to the truncated eta invariants of [24]. In fact Theorem 3.13 combined with some ideas of [16] will now enable us to give a new proof of the original formula (28) for spectral flow with unitarily inequivalent endpoints. Introduce the function ε −3/2 ε(1−λ−1 ) κε (λ) = λ e , π
and let h ε (λ) = κε (1 − λ2 ), f ε (λ) = κε (1 + λ2 )−1 . Lemma 3.25. Let D0 = D0∗ ηN be θ -summable, let V ∈ Nsa and let D1 = D0 + V. Then 1 1 ε 2 h ε (λ)ξ FD1 ,FD0 (λ) dλ = τ V e−ε Dr dr. π 0 −1 Proof. Since h ε (ϕ(µ)) = f ε (µ), by Proposition 3.11 we have ∞ 1 h ε (λ)ξ FD1 ,FD0 (λ) dλ = h ε (ϕ(µ))ξ FD1 ,FD0 (ϕ(µ))ϕ(µ) dµ (A) := −1 −∞ ∞ = f ε (µ)ϕ (µ)ξ D1 ,D0 (µ) dµ. −∞
Further, by Lemmas 2.4 and 2.3, 1 1 ∞
Dr f ε (µ)ϕ (µ) τ V d E µ dr = τ V f ε (Dr )ϕ (Dr ) dr (A) = −∞ 0 0 1 ε 2 3/2 −ε Dr2 2 −3/2 dr (1+ Dr ) e (1+ Dr ) = τ V π 0 1 ε 2 = τ V e−ε Dr dr. π 0
Spectral Shift Function and Spectral Flow
89
As we have emphasized previously, the strategy of our proof follows that of [16] in that we deduce the unbounded version of the spectral flow formula for the theta summable case from a bounded version. To this end introduce Fs = D(s + D 2 )−1/2 . Lemma 3.26. [16, Lemma 8.8] We have lim α h ε = 0, δ→0 δ
where δ is the straight line connecting F0 and Fδ . Lemma 3.27. If D = D ∗ ηN is θ -summable, then the following equality holds true 1 (ηε (D) + τ [ker D]) . 2 Proof. We note that 1 − Fs2 = s(s + D 2 )−1 and that F˙s = − 21 D(s + D 2 )−3/2 . The path 1 := {Fs }s∈[0,1] connects sgn(FD ) with FD . If we denote by 2 the straight line path = sign(FD ) then the path −1 + 2 connects FD with F, connecting sgn(FD ) with F so that by Lemma 3.22 applied to f = h ε , and by the argument of [16] and Lemma 3.26 dealing with discontinuity of the path 1 at zero, it follows that γh ε (FD ) = − αhε + αhε . γh ε (FD ) =
1
We have for the first summand 1 hε ˙ hε α = α Fs ( Fs ) ds = 1
0
0
1
2
τ F˙s h ε (Fs ) ds
1 1 τ D(s + D 2 )−3/2 κε 1 − Fs2 ds =− 2 0 1 1 =− τ D(s + D 2 )−3/2 κε s(s + D 2 )−1 ds 2 0 ε 2 1 ε 1 =− τ D(s + D 2 )−3/2 s −3/2 (s + D 2 )3/2 e− s D ds 2 π 0 1 ε 1 − ε D 2 −3/2 =− s τ De s ds 2 π 0 ∞ dt 1 ε 1 2 τ De−εt D √ = − ηε (D). =− 2 π 1 2 t
Let E = [ker D] and let G r = sgn(FD ) + r E be the path 2 . Then the second summand is equal to 1 1
hε ˙ α = τ G r h ε (G r ) dr = τ Eκε (1 − G r2 ) dr. 2
Since 1 − 2
G r2
=
0
0
E(1 − r 2 ),
αhε =
so that γh ε (FD ) =
0
it follows that 1 2 τ Eκε (1 − r ) dr = τ (E)
1 2
0
(ηε (D) + τ [ker D]) .
1
κε (1 − r 2 ) dr =
1 τ (E), 2
90
N. A. Azamov, A. L. Carey, F. A. Sukochev
As a direct corollary of these lemmas and Theorem 3.13 we get a new proof of (28). The idea used in the proof of the next theorem, of approximating the exponential function by functions of compact support, has been exploited in the context of the spectral flow formula in [35]. Theorem 3.28. If D0 is θ -summable then the formula (28) holds true. Proof. Let h n be a sequence of smooth non-negative functions, compactly supported on (−1, 1), and converging pointwise to h ε . Recall that Dr = D0 + r V . Then the sequence 1 γh n (FDr ) converges to γh ε (FDr ) and the sequence −1 h n (λ)ξ FD1 ,FD0 (λ) dλ converges 1 to −1 h ε (λ)ξ FD1 ,FD0 (λ) dλ by Lebesgue’s DCT, since θ -summability of D0 implies 1summability of h ε (FDr ). Hence the claim follows from Theorem 3.13, Lemma 3.25 and Lemma 3.27. References 1. Asplund, E., Bungart, L.: A First Course in Integration. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 1966 2. Atiyah, M., Patodi, V., Singer, I.M.: Spectral Asymmetry and Riemannian Geometry. III. Math. Proc. Camb. Phil. Soc. 79, 71–99 (1976) 3. Azamov, N.A., Carey, A.L., Dodds, P.G., Sukochev, F.A.: Operator integrals, spectral shift and spectral flow. to appear in Canad. J. Math, available at http://arxiv.org/list/math/0703442, 2007 4. Azamov, N.A., Dodds, P.G., Sukochev, F.A.: The Krein spectral shift function in semi-finite von Neumann algebras. Integral Equations Operator Theory 55, 347–362 (2006) 5. Benameur, M.-T., Carey, A.L., Phillips, J., Rennie, A., Sukochev, F.A., Wojciechowski, K.P.: An analytic approach to spectral flow in von Neumann algebras. In: Analysis, geometry and topology of elliptic operators, Hackensack, NJ: World Sci. Publ., 2006, pp. 297–352 6. Birman, M.Sh., Pushnitski, A.B.: Spectral shift function, amazing and multifaceted. Dedicated to the memory of Mark Grigorievich Krein (1907–1989). Integral Equations Operator Theory 30, 191–199 (1998) 7. Birman, M.Sh., Solomyak, M.Z.: Remarks on the spectral shift function. J. Soviet Math. 3, 408–419 (1975) 8. Birman, M.Sh., Solomyak, M.Z.: Double Stieltjes operator integrals. I. In: Problems of Mathematical Physics, No. 1, Spectral Theory and Wave Processes, Leningrad: Izdat. Leningrad. Univ., 1966, pp. 33–67 (Russian) 9. Birman, M.Sh., Solomyak, M.Z.: Double Stieltjes operator integrals. II. In: Problems of Mathematical Physics, No. 2, Spectral Theory, Diffraction Problems, Leningrad: Izdat. Leningrad. Univ., 1967, pp. 26–60 (Russian) 10. Birman, M.Sh., Solomyak, M.Z.: Double Stieltjes operator integrals. III, Leningrad: Izdat. Leningrad Univ., 1973, pp. 27–53 (Russian) 11. Birman, M.Sh., Yafaev, D.R.: The spectral shift function, the work of M. G. Krein and its further development. Algebra i Analiz 4, 833–870 (1992) 12. Booβ-Bavnbek, B., Lesch, M., Phillips, J.: Unbounded Fredholm operators and spectral flow. Canad. J. Math. 57, 225–250 (2005) 13. Bratteli, O., Robinson, D.: Operator Algebras and Quantum Statistical Mechanics I. Berlin-HeidelbergNewyork: Springer-Verlag, 1979 14. Carey, A.L., Hannabuss, K.C., Mathai, V., McCann, P.: The quantum hall effect on the hyperbolic plane. Commun. Math. Phys 190, 629–673 (1998) 15. Carey, A.L., Phillips, J.: Unbounded Fredholm modules and spectral flow. Canad. J. Math. 50, 673–718 (1998) 16. Carey, A.L., Phillips, J.: Spectral flow in Fredholm modules, eta invariants and the JLO cocycle. K-Theory 31, 135–194 (2004) 17. Carey, A.L., Phillips, J., Rennie, A., Sukochev, F.A.: The local index formula in semifi- nite von Neumann algebras I: spectral flow. Adv. in Math. 202, 451–516 (2006) 18. Carey, A.L., Phillips, J., Rennie, A., Sukochev, F.A.: The local index formula in semifi- nite von Neumann algebras II: even case. Adv. in Math. 202, 517–554 (2006) 19. Connes, A.: Noncommutative Geometry. San Diego: Academic Press, 1994 20. Connes, A., Moscovici, H.: The local index formula in noncommutative geometry. GAFA 5, 174–243 (1995) 21. Daletski˘ı, Yu.L., Kre˘ın, S.G.: Integration and differentiation of functions of Hermitian operators and applications to the theory of perturbations. Vorone˘z. Gos. Univ., Trudy Sem. Funkcional. Anal. 1, 81–105 (1956) (Russian)
Spectral Shift Function and Spectral Flow
91
22. Fack, T., Kosaki, H.: Generalised s-numbers of τ -measurable operators. Pacific J. Math. 123, 269– 300 (1986) 23. Gelfand, I.M., Shilov, G.E.: Generalized functions, Vol. 1, New York: Academic Press, 1964 24. Getzler, E.: The odd Chern character in cyclic homology and spectral flow. Topology 32, 489–507 (1993) 25. Jacobs, K.: Measure and integral. New York-San Francisco-London: Academic Press, 1978 26. Kre˘ın, M.G.: Some new studies in the theory of perturbations of self-adjoint operators. (Russian) First Math. Summer School (Kanev, 1963), Part I, Kiev: Naukova Dumka, 1964, pp. 103.187; English transl. in M.G. Kre˘ın: Topics in differential and integral equations and operator theory, Basel: Birkhäuser, 1983, pp. 107–172 27. de Pagter, B., Sukochev, F.A.: Differentiation of operator functions in noncommutative Lp-spaces. J. Funct. Anal. 212, 28–75 (2004) 28. Peller, V.V.: Multiple operator integrals and higher operator derivatives. http://arxiv.org/list/math.SP/ 0505555, 2005 29. Phillips, J., Raeburn, I.: An index theorem for Toeplitz operators with noncommutative symbol space. J. Funct. Anal. 120, 239–263 (1994) 30. Phillips, J.: Self-adjoint Fredholm operators and spectral flow. Canad. Math. Bull. 39, 460–467 (1996) 31. Phillips, J.: Spectral flow in type I and type II factors - a new approach. Fields Inst. Comm. 17, 137–153 (1997) 32. Simon, B.: Trace ideals and their applications. London Math. Society Lecture Note Series 35, CambridgeLondon: Cambridge University Press, 1979 33. Simon, B.: Spectral averaging and the Krein spectral shift. Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 126, 1409–1413 (1998) 34. Takesaki, M.: Theory of Operator Algebras. Vol. I, Berlin Heidelberg-Newyork: Springer-Verlag, 2002 35. Wahl, C.: Spectral flow as winding number and integral formulas. http://arxiv.org/list/math/0703287, 2007 36. Wahl, C.: A new topology on the space of unbounded selfadjoint operators and the spectral flow. http://arxiv.org/list/math/0607783, 2006 Communicated by A. Connes
Commun. Math. Phys. 276, 93–115 (2007) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-007-0327-y
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Decay of Weak Solutions to the 2D Dissipative Quasi-Geostrophic Equation César J. Niche, María E. Schonbek Department of Mathematics, UC Santa Cruz, Santa Cruz, CA 95064, USA. E-mail:
[email protected];
[email protected] Received: 15 May 2006 / Accepted: 15 April 2007 Published online: 28 August 2007 – © Springer-Verlag 2007
Abstract: We address the decay of the norm of weak solutions to the 2D dissipative quasi-geostrophic equation. When the initial data θ0 is in L 2 only, we prove that the L 2 norm tends to zero but with no uniform rate, that is, there are solutions with arbitrarily slow decay. For θ0 in L p ∩ L 2 , with 1 ≤ p < 2, we are able to obtain a uniform decay 2 rate in L 2 . We also prove that when the L 2α−1 norm of θ0 is small enough, the L q norms, 2 for q > 2α−1 , have uniform decay rates. This result allows us to prove decay for the L q norms, for q ≥
2 2α−1 ,
2
when θ0 is in L 2 ∩ L 2α−1 .
1. Introduction and Statement of Results We consider the dissipative 2D quasi-geostrophic equation θt + (u · ∇)θ + (−)α θ = 0, θ (x, 0) = θ0 (x),
(1.1)
where x ∈ R2 , t > 0 and subcritical exponent 21 < α ≤ 1. In this equation, θ = θ (x, t) is a real scalar function (the temperature of the fluid), u is an incompressible vector field (the velocity of the fluid) determined by the scalar function ψ (the stream function/pressure) through u = (u 1 , u 2 ) = (−
∂ψ ∂ψ , ). ∂ x2 ∂ x1
The temperature θ and the stream function ψ are related by ψ = −θ, The second author was partially supported by NSF grant DMS-0600692.
94
C. J. Niche, M. E. Schonbek 1
where is the usual operator given by = (−) 2 and defined via the Fourier transform as s 2 f (ξ ) = |ξ |s fˆ(ξ ), s ≥ 0. When α = 21 , “dimensionally, the 2D quasi-geostrophic equation is the analogue of the 3D Navier-Stokes equations” (Constantin and Wu [11]), and the behaviour of solutions to (1.1) is similar to that of the 3D Navier-Stokes equations. For this reason, α = 21 is considered the critical exponent, while α ∈ ( 21 , 1] are the subcritical exponents. Note that when α = 1, (1.1) is the vorticity equation of the 2D Navier-Stokes equations. Besides its intrinsic mathematical interest, the dissipative 2D quasi-geostrophic equation describes models arising in meteorology and oceanography. More specifically, it can be derived from the General Quasi Geostrophic equations by assuming constant potential vorticity and constant buoyancy frequency (see Constantin, Majda and Tabak [10] and Pedlosky [20]). Consider the dissipative quasi-geostrophic equation with subcritical exponent, this is α ∈ ( 21 , 1]. In this article, we address the uniform decay of the L q norm, for q ≥ 2, of weak solutions to (1.1) for the initial data θ0 in different spaces. We first describe results related to the ones obtained here. In his Ph.D. thesis, Resnick [21] proved existence of global solutions to (1.1) for θ0 in L 2 . Moreover, he proved a maximum principle θ (t) L p ≤ θ0 L p , t ≥ 0
(1.2)
for 1 < p ≤ ∞. Constantin and Wu [11] established uniqueness of “strong” solutions (for a precise statement of this and Resnick’s result, see Sect. 2.1) and also showed that for θ0 in L 1 ∩ L 2 , 1
θ (t) L 2 ≤ C(1 + t)− 2α , t ≥ 0.
(1.3)
Their proof relies on an adaptation of the Fourier splitting method developed by Schonbek [22, 23] and on the retarded mollifiers method of Cafarelli, Kohn and Nirenberg [2]. Moreover, they proved that for generic initial data, the decay rate (1.3) is optimal. Using rather general pointwise estimates for the fractional derivative α θ and a positivity lemma, Córdoba and Córdoba [12] gave a new proof of (1.2) and proved decay of solutions when θ0 is in L 1 ∩ L p , for 1 < p < ∞. More specifically, they showed that − p−1 αp
θ (t) L p ≤ C1 (1 + C2 t)
, t ≥ 0,
(1.4)
where C1 and C2 are explicit constants. Working along the same lines, Ju [15] obtained an improved maximum principle of the form θ (t) L p ≤ θ0 L p
1
C p−2 t 1+ p−2
p 2− 2 pα
(1.5)
for θ0 in L 2 ∩ L p , with p ≥ 2 and a constant C = 1. Note that for p = 2, i.e. θ0 in L 2 , this expression reduces to (1.2); this is θ (t) L 2 ≤ θ0 L 2 . We now state the results we prove in this article. As we mentioned in the last paragraph, when θ0 is in L 2 , the decay (1.5) reduces to the maximum principle (1.2) and no decay rate can be deduced. We address this issue in the following theorems, where we prove that the L 2 norm of weak solutions tends to zero but not uniformly, that is, there are solutions with arbitrarily slow decay.
Decay of Solutions to Quasi-Geostrophic Equation
95
Theorem 1.1. Let θ be a solution to (1.1) with θ0 ∈ L 2 . Then lim θ (t) L 2 = 0.
t→∞
Theorem 1.2. Let r > 0, > 0, T > 0 be arbitrary. Then, there exists θ0 in L 2 with θ0 L 2 = r such that if θ (t) is the solution with initial data θ0 , then θ (T ) L 2 ≥ 1 − . θ0 L 2 To prove Theorem 1.1 we adapt an argument used in Ogawa, Rajopadhye and Schonbek [19] to prove decay in the context of the Navier-Stokes equations with slowly varying external forces. It consists in finding estimates for the decay of the norm in the frequency space, studying separately low and high frequencies. The decay of the low frequency part is obtained through generalized energy inequalities, while the Fourier splitting method is used to bound the decay of the high frequency part. To construct the slowly decaying solutions of Theorem 1.2 we follow the ideas used by Schonbek [23] to prove a similar result for the Navier-Stokes equations. Namely, we construct initial data θ0λ whose L 2 norm does not change under an appropiate λ-scaling, such that it gives rise to a slowly decaying solution to the linear part of (1.1). We then impose extra conditions on θ0λ to control the term related to the nonlinear part, making it arbitrarily small for small enough values of λ. The next result concerns the decay of the L 2 norm of solutions when the initial data is in L p ∩ L 2 , with 1 ≤ p < 2. Theorem 1.3. Let θ0 ∈ L p ∩ L 2 , where 1 ≤ p < 2. Then, there is a weak solution such that 1 2 − 2α ( p −1)
θ (t) L 2 ≤ C(1 + t)
.
The proof of Theorem 1.3 has similarities with the one for (1.3) in Constantin and Wu [11]. We remark that the decay rate we obtain is of the same type as in (1.4) and (1.5), where θ0 is in L 1 ∩ L p , with 1 < p < ∞ and in L 2 ∩ L p , with p ≥ 2, as proved in Córdoba and Córdoba [12] and Ju [15] respectively. The next theorem is key for establishing decay of the L q norm of solutions, for large enough q. Theorem 1.4. Let θ0
2
L 2α−1 1
tα Moreover, for
2 2α−1
≤ κ. Then, for m =
( m1 − q1 )
2 2α−1
≤ q < ∞,
θ (t) ∈ BC((0, ∞), L q ).
≤ q < ∞, 1
t 2α
+ α1 ( m1 − q1 )
∇θ (t) ∈ BC((0, ∞), L q ).
The proof of Theorem 1.4 is based on ideas used by Kato [17] for proving a similar result for the Navier-Stokes equations. Namely, we construct (in an appropiate space) a solution to (1.1) by successive approximations θn+1 , whose norms are bounded by that of θ1 , θn and ∇θn . This gives rise to a system of recursive inequalities that can be solved if the norm of the data θ0 is small enough. We can then extract a subsequence converging to a solution with a certain decay rate. This preliminary estimate is then used to obtain the decay rate in Theorem 1.4. Note that when α = 1, we recover the rates obtained by Kato [17].
96
C. J. Niche, M. E. Schonbek
Remark 1.1. A result related to Theorem 1.4 concerning existence of strong solutions in 2 L p for small data in L q , where 2α−1 < q ≤ p and 1p + αq = α − 21 , was proven by Wu [27]. These solutions exist only in an interval [0, T ], where the size of the initial data 2 tends to zero when T goes to infinity. Notice that the special case of θ0 in L 2α−1 is not covered by the hypothesis. Remark 1.2. It is well known that solutions to the 3D Navier-Stokes equations, i.e. (1.1) with α = 1, are smooth when θ0 is small in L 2 and the solution is in H 1 (see Heywood [13], Kato [17] and Serrin [26]). For the quasi-geostrophic equation with critical expo3 nent α = 21 , Córdoba and Córdoba [12] proved that when θ0 is in H 2 and is small in ∞ L , the solution is in fact classical. These results suggest that the solution obtained in Theorem 1.4 might have better regularity than the one obtained. We now state the result concerning decay of L q norms, for large q. 2
Theorem 1.5. Let θ0 ∈ L 2 ∩ L 2α−1 . Then there exists T = T (θ0 ) such that for t ≥ T 2 and 2α−1 ≤ q < ∞, 1
4a−3
θ (t) L q ≤ C t q α(2α−1) 2
1 −1+ 2α
.
2
By (1.5), when θ0 ∈ L 2 ∩ L 2α−1 , the L 2α−1 norm of the solution tends to zero. Then, after a (possibly long) time T = T (θ0 ), the solution enters the ball of radius κ, where κ is as in Theorem 1.4. Interpolation between the decays in (1.5) and Theorem 1.4, for some q in the appropiate range of values, provides us with a first decay rate. This rate, which is a function of q, can then be maximized, leading us to the result in Theorem 1.5. A similar idea was used by Carpio [3] to obtain analogous results for the Navier-Stokes equations. Remark 1.3. After this work was submitted we received preprints of articles by Carrillo and Ferreira [4–6] in which they prove results directly related to the ones obtained here. The proofs by Carrillo and Ferreira are, in general, rather different from ours, as they work in spaces that are related but not identical to the ones we work in. In [5], they prove Theorem 1.4 in the particular case α = 1 and θ0 ∈ L 2 but with no restriction on the size of the initial data θ0 . Moreover, they obtain estimates for the decay of all derivatives of θ in L 2 ∩ L q , thus showing that the solution is smooth (see Remark 1.2). In the forthcoming preprint [6], Carrillo and Ferreira extend their results to 21 < α ≤ 1 2
and θ0 ∈ L 2α−1 and also obtain decays analogous to those of Theorem 1.5, but in the 2 more restrictive case of initial data θ0 ∈ L 1 ∩ L 2α−1 . Recently, many articles concerning different aspects of the dissipative quasigeostrophic equation have been published. Besides the ones we have already referred to, see Berselli [1], Carrillo and Ferreira [4], Chae [7], Chae and Lee [8], Constantin, Córdoba and Wu [9], Ju [14, 16], Schonbek and Schonbek [24, 25], Wu [27–32] and references contained therein. This article is organized as follows. In Sect. 2, we collect the basic results and estimates we need. In Sect. 3 we prove Theorems 1.1 and 1.2, in Sect. 4 we prove Theorem 1.3 and finally in Sect. 5 we prove Theorems 1.4 and 1.5.
Decay of Solutions to Quasi-Geostrophic Equation
97
2. Preliminaries In this section we collect some essential results and estimates concerning solutions to Eq. (1.1).
2.1. Existence and uniqueness of solutions. We first state the existence and uniqueness results we assume througout this article. Theorem 2.1 (Resnick [21]). Let T > 0 be arbitrary. Then, for every θ0 ∈ L 2 and f ∈ L 2 ([0, T ]; H −α ) there exists a weak solution of θt + (u · ∇)θ + (−)α θ = f, θ (x, 0) = θ0 (x), such that θ ∈ L ∞ ([0, T ]; L 2 ) ∩ L 2 ([0, T ]; H α ). Theorem 2.2 (Constantin and Wu [11]). Assume that α ∈ ( 21 , 1], T > 0 and p and q satisfy 1 α 1 + =α− . p q 2
p ≥ 1, q > 0,
Then there is at most one solution θ of (1.1) with initial value θ0 ∈ L 2 such that θ ∈ L ∞ ([0, T ]; L 2 ) ∩ L 2 ([0, T ]; H α ), θ ∈ L q ([0, T ]; L p ). These solutions obey a Maximum Priciple as in (1.2); this is θ (t) L p ≤ θ0 L p , t ≥ 0 for 1 < p ≤ ∞ (see Resnick [21], Córdoba and Córdoba [12] and Ju [15] for proofs). Multiplying (1.1) by θ and integrating in space and time yields s
t
α θ (τ )2L 2 dτ ≤ C, ∀ s, t > 0.
(2.6)
2.2. Estimates. Let θ (x, t) = K α (t, x) ∗ θ0 −
0
t
K α (t − s, x) ∗ u · ∇θ (s) ds
(2.7)
be the integral form of Eq. (1.1), where K α (x, t) is the kernel of the linear part of (1.1), i.e. 1 2α K α (x, t) = ei xξ e−|ξ | t dξ. 2π R2
98
C. J. Niche, M. E. Schonbek
Proposition 2.3 (Wu [27]). Let 1 ≤ p ≤ q ≤ ∞. For any t > 0, the operators K α (t) : L p → L q , K α (t) f = K α (t) ∗ f, ∇ K α (t) : L p → L q , ∇ K α (t) f = ∇ K α (t) ∗ f are bounded and K α (t) f L q ≤ Ct
− α1 ( 1p − q1 )
∇ K α (t) f L q ≤ Ct
f L p ,
1 1 1 1 −( 2α + α ( p − q ))
(2.8)
f L p .
(2.9)
The following estimates for the integral term in the right-hand side of (2.7) are an immediate consequence of Proposition 2.3 and they are key in the proof of Theorem 1.4. Lemma 2.4. Let η ≤ µ + ν < 2. Then t t 1 K α (t − s) ∗ u · ∇θ (s) ds η2 ≤ C (t − s)− 2a (µ+ν−η) θ (s) L
0
0
2
Lµ
∇θ (s)
2
Lν
ds
(2.10) and
t
∇ K α (t − s) ∗ u · ∇θ (s) ds η2 L t 1 1 ≤C (t − s)−( 2α + 2a (µ+ν−η)) θ (s)
0
0
Proof. Use (2.8) and (2.9) with q = η2 , p = u · ∇θ
2
L µ+ν
2 µ+ν
≤ Cθ
2
Lµ
∇θ (s)
2
Lν
ds.
(2.11)
and 2
Lµ
∇θ
2
Lµ
which follows from Hölder’s inequality and boundedness of Riesz transform.
Lemma 2.5 (Schonbek and Schonbek [25]). Let β, γ be multi-indices, |γ | < |β| + 2α max( j, 1), j = 0, 1, 2, · · · , 1 ≤ p ≤ ∞. Then x γ Dt D β K α (t)L p = Ct j
|γ |−|β| p−1 2α − j− pα
for some constant C depending only on α, β, γ , j, p. 3. L 2 Decay for Initial Data in L 2 3.1. Proof of Theorem 1.1. Let θ (t) be a solution to (1.1) with θ0 ∈ L 2 . For φ = φ(ξ, t), 2 2 ˆ ˆ . (3.12) + (1 − φ(t))θ(t) θˆ (t)2L 2 ≤ 2 φ(t)θ(t) L2 L2 2 and (1−φ(t))θ(t) 2 the low and high frequency parts ˆ ˆ We call the terms φ(t)θ(t) L2 L2 of the energy respectively. In Propositions 3.1 and 3.3 and Corollary 3.2, we obtain estimates, for an appropiate class of functions φ, that allow us to prove that the low and high frequency parts of the energy tend to zero. These estimates are of similar character to the ones that Ogawa, Rajophadye and Schonbek obtained for the Navier-Stokes equations in [19].
Decay of Solutions to Quasi-Geostrophic Equation
99
3.1.1. Energy estimates. We first establish some preliminary estimates which will be needed in the proof of Theorem 1.1. Proposition 3.1. Let ψ ∈ C 1 ((0, ∞), C 1 ∩ L 2 ). Then for 0 < s < t, t ˆ ), ψ θˆ (τ ) − |ξ |α θˆ ψ (τ )2 2 | dτ (s)2 2 + 2 θ(τ (t)2 2 ≤ θˆ ψ |ψ θˆ ψ L
L
t
+2
L
s
2 θˆ (τ )| dτ. |ξ · u θ (τ ), ψ
s
Proof. Let θ (t) be a smooth solution to (1.1). Taking the Fourier transform, multiplying 2 θˆ and integrating by parts we obtain the formal estimate by ψ d αˆ 2 ˆ θˆ 2 2 = 2 ψ θ (t), ψ θ(t) ψ ψ θ (t) − |ξ | 2 L L dt 2 θˆ (t). − 2u · ∇θ (t), ψ Integrating between s and t yields
t 2 2 ˆ ), ψ ˆ ˆ θˆ (τ ) − |ξ |α θˆ ψ (τ )2 2 | dτ θ(τ θ ψ (t) L 2 ≤ θ ψ (s) L 2 + 2 |ψ L s t 2 θˆ (τ )| dτ. |ξ · u θ (τ ), ψ +2 s
The retarded mollifiers method (see Lemma 4.3) allows us to extend this estimate to weak solutions. For full details see Ogawa, Rajopadhye and Schonbek [19].
Corollary 3.2. Let φ ∈ C 1 ((0, ∞), L 2 ). Then for 0 < s < t, t 2α 2 −|ξ |2α (t−s) 2 ˆ ˆ )| dτ. ˆ φ(t) L 2 + 2 |ξ · u θ , e−2|ξ | (t−τ ) φ 2 (t)θ(τ θ φ(t) L 2 ≤ θ (s)e s
η (τ ) = Proof. Take ψ
2α e−|ξ | (t+η−τ ) φ(ξ, t)
for η > 0. Then
ˆ ), ψ η θˆ (τ ) = |ξ |2α ψ η θˆ (τ ) = |ξ |α ψ η θˆ (τ ), ψ η θˆ (τ )2 2 , η θ(τ ψ L so the integrand in the second term in Proposition 3.1 vanishes. Taking the limit as η → 0 (t) = φ(ξ, t) and ψ (s) = e−|ξ |2α (t−s) φ(ξ, t), so we see that ψ t 2α 2α ˆ )| dτ, θˆ φ(t)2L 2 ≤ θˆ (s)e−|ξ | (t−s) φ(t)2L 2 + 2 |ξ · u θ , e−2|ξ | (t−τ ) φ 2 (t)θ(τ s
as we wanted to prove.
Proposition 3.3. Let E ∈ C 1 ((0, ∞), R) and ψ ∈ C 1 ((0, ∞), L ∞ ) such that 1 − ψ 2 ∈ L ∞ ((0, ∞), L ∞ ) and ∇(1 − ψ 2 )ˇ ∈ L ∞ ((0, ∞), L 2 ). Then t ˆ )2 2 dτ E(t)ψ θˆ (t)2 2 ≤ E(s)ψ θˆ (s)2 2 + E (τ )ψ θ(τ L
L
t
+2 s
+2
s
t
s
L
E(τ )|ψ θˆ (τ ), ψ θˆ (τ ) − |ξ |α ψ θˆ (τ )2L 2 | dτ ˆ )| dτ. E(τ )|u · ∇θ (τ ), (1 − ψ 2 (τ ))θ(τ
100
C. J. Niche, M. E. Schonbek
Proof. We prove the estimate first for smooth solutions. As in Proposition 3.1, we take the Fourier transform of (1.1) and multiply it by Eψ 2 θˆ . Integrating by parts and then between s and t we obtain the formal estimate t 2 2 ˆ ˆ E(t)ψ θ(t) L 2 ≤ E(s)ψ θ (s) L 2 + E (τ )ψ θˆ (τ )2L 2 dτ s t ˆ )2 2 | dτ E(τ )|ψ θˆ (τ ), ψ θˆ (τ ) − |ξ |α ψ θ(τ +2 L s t E(τ )|u · ∇θ (τ ), (1 − ψ 2 (τ ))θˆ (τ )| dτ. +2 s
Here we used that u · ∇θ, θ = 0. When using the retarded mollifiers method, the conditions 1 − ψ 2 ∈ L ∞ ((0, ∞), L ∞ ) and ∇(1 − ψ 2 )ˇ ∈ L ∞ ((0, ∞), L 2 ) will guarantee the weak convergence of the nonlinear term. For full details see Ogawa, Rajopadhye and Schonbek [19].
3.1.2. Proof of Theorem 1.1. We first prove the following easy estimate. Lemma 3.4. Let m > 0 and
f m (t) =
|ξ |>1
|ξ |2α e−m|ξ |
2α t
dξ.
Then limt→∞ f m (t) = 0. Proof. From the inequality |ξ |2α e−m|ξ |
2α t
e−m|ξ | mt
2α t/2
≤C
it follows that f m (t) =
|ξ |>1
|ξ |2α e−m|ξ |
2α t
dξ ≤ C
Thus, limt→∞ f m (t) = 0.
2α t/2
|ξ |>1 ∞ r e−mtr/2
e−m|ξ |t/2 dξ = C ≤C mt |ξ |>1 1 C 2 e−mtr/2 ≤ 1+ =C . (mt)2 mt (mt)2
e−m|ξ | mt
mt
dξ
dr (3.13)
We choose φ(ξ, t) = e−|ξ | t . Note that φ is the kernel of the solution to the Fourier transform of (1.1). Low frequency energy decay. Using Corollary 3.2 with φ as defined above we obtain 2α
θˆ φ(t)2L 2 ≤ θˆ (s)φ(t − s)φ(t)2L 2 + 2
s
t
ˆ ). |ξ · u θ, φ 2 (t − τ )φ 2 (t)θ(τ
(3.14)
Decay of Solutions to Quasi-Geostrophic Equation
101
A standard application of the Dominated Convergence Theorem proves that the first term in the right-hand side of (3.14) tends to zero when t goes to infinity. Now ˆ ) = ξ α · u ˆ ) ξ · u θ (τ ), φ 2 (t − τ )φ 2 (t)θ(τ θ (τ ), |ξ |1−α φ 2 (t − τ )φ 2 (t)θ(τ α 1−α 2 ˆ ) L 1 . ≤ |ξ | u θ (τ ) L ∞ |ξ | φ (t − τ )φ 2 (t)θ(τ (3.15) As u θ (ξ ) = uˆ ∗ θˆ (ξ ), then
α α
ˆ |ξ | u θ (τ ) L ∞ = sup
|ξ | u(ξ ˆ − η)θ (η) dη
ξ ∈R2
≤C
R2
sup
2
R2
ξ ∈R
+ sup
2 ξ ∈R
|ξ − η|α u(ξ ˆ − η)θˆ (η) dη
ˆ |η| u(ξ ˆ − η)θ(η) dη
α
R2
α )u θ ∞ + u ≤ C ( a θ L ∞ ≤ C (α u)θ L 1 + u α θ L 1 L ≤ Cα θ L 2 . Now ˆ ) L 1 ≤ C|ξ |1−2α φ 2 (t − τ )φ 2 (t) L 2 |ξ |α θˆ (τ ) L 2 . |ξ |1−α φ 2 (t − τ )φ 2 (t)θ(τ (3.16) and
|ξ |1−2α φ 2 (t − τ )φ 2 (t)2L 2 =
R
≤
2
|ξ |2−4α e−4|ξ |
|ξ |≤1
2α (2t−τ )
dξ
|ξ |2−4α dξ + f 4 (2t − τ ).
(3.17)
As 21 < α ≤ 1, the first term in the right-hand side of (3.17) is integrable. By Lemma 3.4 and (3.13) we see that f 4 (2t − τ ) ≤
C ≤C 4(2t − τ )2
(3.18)
for t large enough. Then using (3.15), (3.16), (3.17) and (3.18) we obtain that t t ˆ ) dτ ≤ θ (τ ) L ∞ |ξ |1−α φ 2 (t − τ ) |ξ · u θ , φ 2 (t − τ )φ 2 (t)θ(τ |ξ |α u 2 s
s
ˆ ) L 1 dτ × φ 2 (t)θ(τ t θ (τ ) L ∞ |ξ |1−2α φ 2 (t − τ )φ 2 (t) ≤2 |ξ |α u s
× θˆ (τ ) L 2 |ξ |α θˆ (τ ) L 2 dτ t ≤C α θ (τ )2L 2 dτ. s
102
C. J. Niche, M. E. Schonbek
Taking limits as s and t go to infinity, (2.6) implies that the low frequency part of the energy goes to zero. High energy frequency decay. Let ψ(ξ, t) = 1 − φ(ξ, t). As 1 − ψ 2 (ξ, t) = 2φ(ξ, t) − φ 2 (ξ, t) = 2e−|ξ |
2α t
− e−2|ξ |
2α t
decays exponentially fast, we can apply Proposition 3.3. After rearranging terms, we obtain 2 2 ˆ ˆ (1 − φ(t))θ(t) = ψ(t)θ(t) ≤ I + I I + I I I + I V, L2 L2
where E(s) 2 ˆ ψ θ(s) , L2 E(t) t 1 E (τ )ψ θˆ (τ )2L 2 − 2E(τ )|ξ |α ψ θˆ (τ )2L 2 dτ, II = E(t) s t 2 III = E(τ )ψ θˆ (τ ), ψ(τ )θˆ (τ ) dτ, E(t) s t 2 E(τ )|u · ∇θ (τ ), (1 − ψ 2 (τ ))θˆ (τ )| dτ. IV = E(t) s I =
We choose E(t) = (1 + t)k , where k > 2. Term I. Since |ψ| ≤ C and θ ∈ L 2 , 1+s k 1+s k 2 ˆ ψ(s)θ(s) ≤ C . I = L2 1+t 1+t Thus, lim I (t) = 0.
t→∞
Term II. We use the Fourier splitting method. Let B(t) = {ξ ∈ R2 : |ξ | ≤ G(t)}, where G is to be determined below. Then E (τ )ψ(τ )θˆ (τ )2L 2 − 2E(τ )|ξ |α ψ(τ )θˆ (τ )2L 2 ˆ )|2 dξ − 2E(τ ) = E (τ ) |ψ θ(τ |ξ |2α |ψ θˆ (τ )|2 dξ R2 B(t) R2 B(t) ˆ )|2 dξ − 2E(τ ) ˆ )|2 dξ + E (τ ) |ψ θ(τ |ξ |2α |ψ θ(τ B(t) B(t) ˆ )|2 dξ ≤ E (τ ) − 2E(τ )G 2α (τ ) |ψ θ(τ R2 B(t) ˆ )|2 dξ − 2E(τ ) +E (τ ) |ψ θ(τ |ξ |2α |ψ θˆ (τ )|2 dξ. B(t)
B(t)
(3.19)
Decay of Solutions to Quasi-Geostrophic Equation
103
1 2α k Choosing G(t) = 2(1+t) , we see that E (τ ) − 2E(τ )G 2α (τ ) = 0 so the first term in the right-hand side of (3.19) vanishes. As the last term in (3.19) is negative, it can be dropped, hence t k k−1 ˆ (τ )|2 dξ dτ. II ≤ (1 + τ ) |ψ θ (1 + t)k s B(t) As ψ(ξ, t) = 1 − e−|ξ | t , then |ψ| ≤ |ξ |2α for |ξ | ≤ 1. Then 2 ˆ ˆ )|2 dξ ≤ C G 4α (t) = |ψ θ(τ )| dξ ≤ |ξ |4α |θ(τ 2α
B(t)
B(t)
Then II ≤
k (1 + t)k
t
(1 + τ )k−3 dτ ≤
s
C . (1 + t)2
C , (1 + t)2
so lim I I (t) = 0.
t→∞
2α −|ξ | t = |ξ |2α φ(ξ, t). As Term III. As ψ(ξ, t) = 1 − e−|ξ | t , then ψ = ∂ψ ∂t = |ξ | e E(t) is an increasing function t 2 ˆ ), (1 − φ(τ ))θ(τ ˆ ) dτ III = E(τ )|ξ |2α φ(τ )θ(τ E(t) s t ≤ 2 |ξ |α θˆ (τ ), |ξ |α θˆ (τ ) dτ s t ≤2 α θˆ (τ )2L 2 dτ. (3.20) 2α
2α
s
Taking limits when t and s go to infinity we obtain lim I I I (t) = 0.
t→∞
Term IV. Let ω(ξ, ˆ t) = 1 − ψ 2 (ξ, t). Then ˆ )| ≤ |ξ |α |u |u · ∇θ (τ ), ω(τ ˆ )θ(τ θ (τ )|, |ξ |1−a |ωˆ θˆ (τ )| ˆ ) L 1 . ≤ |ξ |α u θ (τ ) L ∞ |ξ |1−α ωˆ θ(τ
(3.21)
As in (3.16) |ξ |1−α ω(τ ˆ )θˆ (τ ) L 1 ≤ C|ξ |1−2α ω(τ ˆ ) L 2 |ξ |α θˆ (τ ) L 2 . We notice that as 2α − 4 < 0, then |ξ |1−2α ω(τ ˆ )2L 2 = |ξ |2−4α |ω| ˆ 2 dξ R2 2−4α ≤ |ξ | dξ + |ξ |≤1
|ξ |≥1
|ω| ˆ 2 dξ ≤ C.
(3.22)
(3.23)
104
C. J. Niche, M. E. Schonbek
Then by (3.21), (3.22) and (3.23),
t
IV ≤ 2
s
s
t
≤2
t
≤2 s
|u · ∇θ (τ ), ω(τ ˆ )θˆ (τ )| dτ θ (τ ) L ∞ |ξ |1−2α ω(τ |ξ |α u ˆ ) L 2 α θ (τ ) L 2 dτ α θ (τ )2L 2 dτ.
As before, letting s and t go to infinity we obtain lim I V (t) = 0.
t→∞
Thus, the high frequency part of the energy goes to zero, which concludes the proof of Theorem 1.1.
3.2. Proof of Theorem 1.2. We briefly describe the idea of the proof. In order to make the decay of a solution to (1.1) arbitrarily slow, we will construct a set of initial data {θ0λ }λ>0 in L 2 such that θ0λ L 2 = θ0 L 2 . The mild solution to (1.1) with initial data θ0λ , θ λ (x, T ) = K α (T ) ∗ θ0λ (x) −
T 0
K α (T − s) ∗ (u λ · ∇)θ λ (s) ds,
(3.24)
has the following property: given T > 0, we can find λ sufficiently close to zero, so that the L 2 norm of the first term of the right-hand side of (3.24) stays arbitrarily close to that of θ0 . For this to hold, θ0λ must be such that: a) the L 2 norm of θ0λ is invariant under the scaling; b) θ0λ gives rise to a self-similar solution to the linear part of (1.1); and c) θ0 is in L p ∩ L q , for appropiate p and q, so that the integral term will be sufficiently small. We remark that as a result of our choice, the L p and L q norms of θ0λ will not be invariant under scaling. We proceed to the proof now. For θ0 in L 2 , it is easy to see that θ0λ (x) = λθ0 (λx) is such that θ0λ L 2 = θ0 L 2 , λ > 0. Then, for these θ0λ , condition a) holds. Now let θ0 be such that θ0λ gives rise to a selfsimilar solution λ to the linear part of (1.1), that is λ (x, t) = λ(λx, λ2α t) is a solution to t + (−)α = 0, λ0 (x) = θ0λ (x).
Decay of Solutions to Quasi-Geostrophic Equation
105
By uniqueness of the solution to the linear part, we have λ (x, t) = K α (t) ∗ λ0 (x) = K α (t) ∗ θ0λ (x), thus λ (t) L 2 = |λ (x, t)|2 d x = λ2 |(λx, λ2α t)|2 d x R2 R2 2α 2α 2α 2 = |(y, λ t)| dy = e−|ξ | λ t |θˆ0 (ξ )| dξ. R2
R2
As a result of this, given T > 0,
λ (T )2 −|ξ |2α λ2α T |θˆ (ξ )|2 dξ 0 L2 R2 e = 1. lim = lim 2 dξ 0 2 2 λ→0 λ→0 | θ (ξ )| R2 0 L
(3.25)
This shows that choosing λ small enough, we can make the ratio of the norms arbitrarily close to 1 for large enough t. We now address the integral term in (3.24). We first notice that K α (t − s) ∗ (u λ · ∇)θ λ (s) L 2 = ∇ K α (t − s) ∗ (u λ θ λ )(s) L 2 ≤ ∇ K α (t − s) L 1 (u λ θ λ )(s) L 2 1
≤ C(t − s)− 2α u λ (s) L p θ λ (s) L q 1
≤ C(t − s)− 2α θ λ (s) L p θ λ (s) L q , where we have used Lemma 2.5 with γ = 0, p = 1, β = 1, j = 0, Hölder’s inequality with 21 = 1p + q1 and boundedness of the Riesz transform. By the Maximum Principle (1.2), θ λ (s) L m ≤ θ0λ L m and as 2
θ0λ L m = λ1− m θ0 L m
(3.26)
then 1
K α (t − s) ∗ (u λ · ∇)θ λ (s) L 2 ≤ C(t − s)− 2α λ ≤ C(t − s)
1 − 2α
2−( 2p + q2 )
θ0 L p θ0 L q
λθ0 L p θ0 L q .
θ0λ
(3.27)
norm of is invariant only when m = 2. Choosing We remark that by (3.26), the θ0 in L p ∩ L q (condition c)) we obtain T 1 K α (T − s) ∗ (u λ · ∇)θ λ (s) L 2 ds ≤ C T 1− 2α λθ0 L p θ0 L q . (3.28) Lm
0
So given > 0 and T > 0, we can choose λ > 0 such that by (3.25), K α (T ) ∗ θ0λ L 2 θ0λ L 2
and by (3.28)
T 0
≥1− , 2
K α (T − s) ∗ (u λ · ∇)θ λ (s) L 2 ds θ0λ L 2
Then θ λ (T ) L 2 ≥ 1 − . θ0λ L 2 This proves our result.
≤
. 2
106
C. J. Niche, M. E. Schonbek
4. L 2 Decay for Initial Data in L p ∩ L 2 , 1 ≤ p < 2 To prove Theorem 1.3, we follow a modified version of the Fourier splitting method, see Constantin and Wu [11]. Similar ideas in the context of the 2D Navier-Stokes equation can be found in Zhang [33]. In order to compute the actual decay rate of the L 2 norm, we need a preliminary estimate, proven in Lemma 4.3, which we then use to establish the right decay. In both proofs we first obtain formal estimates for smooth solutions through the Fourier splitting method and we then use the method of retarded mollifiers of Cafarelli, Kohn and Nirenberg [2] to extend them to weak solutions. The following auxiliary lemmas will be necessary in the sequel. 1
Lemma 4.1. Let h ∈ L p , 1 ≤ p < 2 and let S(t) = {ξ ∈ R2 : |ξ | ≤ g(t)− 2α }, for a continuous function g : R+ → R+ . Then
ˆ 2 dξ ≤ Cg(t) |h|
− α1 ( 2p −1)
.
S(t)
Proof. By Cauchy-Schwarz
ˆ 2 dξ ≤ |h|
S(t)
ˆ 2r dξ |h|
1
1
r
s
dξ
S(t)
,
S(t)
where r1 + 1s = 1. Setting 2r = q, we obtain
1 r
=
2 q
and
1 s
=
2 p
− 1. By the Riesz-Thorin
→ is bounded for p ∈ [1, 2] and Interpolation Theorem, F : p ˆ q p is in L , then h L ≤ h L and as a result of this Lp
ˆ 2 dξ ≤ C |h| S(t)
Lq
2 −1 p
dξ
2
= C (V ol S(t)) p
1 p
+
1 q
= 1. As h
−1
S(t)
= C r (t)
2( 2p −1)
= Cg(t)
− α1 ( 2p −1)
.
Lemma 4.2. Let θ be a solution to (1.1). Then, |u · ∇θ (ξ )| ≤ C|ξ |θ 2L 2 .
Proof. As u · ∇θ (ξ ) = ∇ · uθ (ξ ) = ξ · u θ (ξ ), boundedness of the Fourier transform and of the Riesz transform imply |u · ∇θ (ξ )| = |ξ ||u θ(ξ )| ≤ |ξ |u θ L ∞ ≤ C|ξ |uθ L 1 ≤ C|ξ |θ 2L 2 .
In the next lemma we establish the preliminary decay rate.
Decay of Solutions to Quasi-Geostrophic Equation
107
Lemma 4.3. Let θ be a solution to (1.1) with initial data θ0 in L p ∩ L 2 , 1 ≤ p < 2. Then 1 ˆ 2 dξ ≤ C ln(e + t)−(1+ α ) . |θ| R2
Proof. The first part of the proof consists of a formal argument that proves the expected decay for smooth solutions. At the end of the proof we sketch how to make the argument rigrous. We use the Fourier splitting method, taking 1
B(t) = {ξ : |ξ | ≤ g − 2α (t)}, 1 where g(t) = ( 21 + 2α )[(e+t) ln(e+t)]. From (1.1), after multiplying by θ and integrating
d |θˆ |2 dξ = −2 |ξ |2α |θˆ |2 dξ. 2 dt R2 R Then, as ˆ 2 dξ ≥ 2 2 |ξ |2α |θ| R2
ˆ 2 dξ + (1 + |ξ |2α |θ| B(t)
1 )[(e + t) ln(e + t)]−1 α
(4.29)
B(t)c
|θˆ |2 dξ,
(4.29) becomes d 1 ˆ 2 dξ + (1 + )[(e + t) ln(e + t)]−1 ˆ 2 dξ |θ| |θ| 2 dt R2 α R 1 −1 ≤ (1 + )[(e + t) ln(e + t)] |θˆ |2 dξ. α B(t) 1
Multiplying on both sides by h(t) = [ln(e + t)]1+ α , writing the left-hand side as a derivative and integrating between 0 and t, 1 ˆ 2 dξ ≤ θ0 2 2 [ln(e + t)]1+ α |θ| L R2 t 1 1 ˆ 2 dξ ds. + (1 + )[(e + s)]−1 ln(e + s) α |θ| α B(s) 0 (4.30) Hence, we need to estimate (1.1),
ˆ 2 dξ . From the solution to the Fourier transform of
B(s) |θ|
2α θˆ (ξ, t) = θ0 (ξ )e−|ξ | t +
t
e−|ξ |
2α (t−s)
u · ∇θ (s)ds.
0
We obtain ˆ t)| ≤ |θ0 (ξ )| + |θ(ξ,
0
t
|u · ∇θ | ds
108
C. J. Niche, M. E. Schonbek
which, by Lemma 4.2 leads to ˆ t)| ≤ 2 |θ0 (ξ )| + |θ(ξ, 2
t
2
0
2 |ξ |θ (τ )2L 2
dτ
t ≤ 2 |θ0 (ξ )|2 + t|ξ |2 θ (τ )4L 2 dτ . 0
Then, passing to polar coordinates
ˆ 2 dξ ≤ 2 |θ| B(s)
|θ0 |2 dξ + B(s)
s|ξ |
2 0
B(s)
s
θ (τ )4L 2
dτ
dξ
− 1 ( 2 −1)
≤ C[(e + s) ln(e + s)] α p s π g(s) −2 α 2 3 4 +C r s θ (τ ) L 2 dτ dr dϕ 0 0 0 2 − 1 ( 2 −1) + Cs 2 g α (s) ≤ 2 C[(e + s) ln(e + s)] α p = C[(e + s) ln(e + s)]
− α1 ( 2p −1)
2
+ Cs 2 [(e + s) ln(e + s)]− α ,
(4.31)
where we have used Lemma 4.1 with g(s) = C[(e + s) ln(e + s)] and the Maximum Principle for the L 2 norm of θ . Substituting (4.31) in (4.30) we see that the integral in the right-hand side of (4.30) is finite, so
ˆ 2 dξ ≤ C [ln(e + t)]−(1+ α ) . |θ| 1
R2
The formal part of the proof is now complete. To extend the estimate to weak solutions, we repeat the argument, applying it to the solutions of the approximate equations ∂θn + u n ∇θn + (−)α θn = 0, ∂t where u n = δn (θn ) is defined by δn (θn ) =
t
φ(τ )R⊥ θn (t − δn τ ) dτ.
0
Here the operator R⊥ is defined on scalar functions as R⊥ f = (−∂x2 −1 f, ∂x1 −1 f )
∞ and φ is a smooth function with support in [1, 2] and such that 0 φ(t) dt = 1. For each n, the values of u n depend only on the values of θn in [t − 2δn , t − δn ]. As stated in Constantin and Wu [11], the functions θn converge to a weak solution θ and strongly in L 2 almost everywhere. Since the estimates obtained do not depend on n, they are valid for the limit function θ . The proof is now complete.
Decay of Solutions to Quasi-Geostrophic Equation
109
4.1. Proof of Theorem 1.3. As before, we prove a formal estimate for smooth solutions, which then can be extended to weak solutions by the method of retarded mollifiers. For the formal estimate, we proceed as in Lemma 4.3, employing the Fourier splitting method with 1
B(t) = {ξ : |ξ | ≤ g(t)− 2α } for g(t) = 2α(t + 1). Thus d 1 1 2 2 ˆ ˆ ˆ 2 dξ, |θ| dξ + |θ| dξ ≤ |θ| dt R2 α(t + 1) R2 α(t + 1) B(t) 1
which after using h(t) = (t + 1) α as an integrating factor leads to t 1 1 1 2 2 −1 2 ˆ ˆ (s + 1) α (t + 1) α |θ | dξ ≤ θ0 L 2 + |θ| dξ ds. 0 α R2 B(s)
(4.32)
Working as in (4.31) in Lemma 4.3, using Lemma 4.1 with g(s) = 2(s + 1) and the preliminary estimate from Lemma 4.3 for making 1
θ (τ )4L 2 ≤ θ (τ )2L 2 [ln(e + τ )]−(1+ α ) , we obtain 1 α (t + 1)
t − 1 ( 2 −1)+ α1 −1 2 2 ˆ |θ| dξ ≤ θ0 L 2 + C (1 + s) α p ds 2 R 0 t s 1 −2 1 + θ (τ )2L 2 [ln(e + τ )]−(1+ α ) sg α (s)(1 + s) α −1 dτ ds 0
0
1 2
1
− ( −1)+ α ≤ θ0 2L 2 + C(1 + s) α p t s 1 1 + θ (τ )2L 2 [ln(e + τ )]−(1+ α ) s(1 + s)−( α +1) dτ ds. 0
0
(4.33) Now I (t) =
t 0
s
0 t
(1 + s)
≤C
1
− a1
0
0
t
ds
(1 + τ )
0 t
≤C
1
θ (τ )2L 2 [ln(e + τ )]−(1+ α ) s(1 + s)−( α +1) dτ ds 1 α
[ln(e θ (τ )2L 2
1
+ τ )]−(1+ α ) 1
(1 + τ ) α
dτ
1
1
(1 + τ ) α θ (τ )2L 2
[ln(e + τ )]−(1+ α ) 1
(1 + τ ) α
dτ,
so taking 1
f (t) = (t + 1)
1 α
θ (t)2L 2 ,
− α1 ( 2p −1)+ α1
a(t) = (1 + t)
, b(t) =
[ln(e + τ )]−(1+ α ) 1
(1 + τ ) α
,
110
C. J. Niche, M. E. Schonbek
Eq. (4.33) becomes
t
f (t) ≤ C + a(t) +
f (τ )b(τ )dτ.
0
By Gronwall’s inequality
t
f (t) ≤ f (0) exp
b(τ ) dτ
0
Notice that as
1 2
t
+
a (τ ) exp
0
< α ≤ 1, t b(τ ) dτ = 0
t 0
τ
t
b(s)ds dτ.
(4.34)
1
[ln(e + τ )]−(1+ α ) 1
(1 + τ ) α
< ∞.
Then (4.34) becomes (t + 1) α θˆ (t)2L 2 ≤ C θ0 2L 2 + (1 + t) 1
− α1 ( 2p −1)+ α1
ds,
hence 1 2 ( p −1)
1
θ (t)2L 2 ≤ (t + 1)− α + C(1 + t) α
1 2 ( p −1)
≤ C(1 + t) α
,
which proves the formal estimate. The retarded mollifiers method allows us to extend it to weak solutions.
2 5. L q Decay, for q ≥ 2α− 1 5.1. Proof of Theorem 1.4. We now describe the main ideas behind the proof of 2 Theorem 1.4. For clarity, we let m = 2α−1 . We first prove preliminary estimates of the form 1 1−δ m )
t α ( t
1 2α
θ (t) mδ ≤ C, t > 0,
(5.35)
∇θ (t) L m ≤ C, t > 0
(5.36)
for fixed 0 < δ < 1. To do so, following Katos’s [17] ideas, we construct a solution in m L δ to the integral equation (2.7) by successive approximations θ1 (t) = K α (t) ∗ θ0 ,
θn+1 (t) = K α (t) ∗ θ0 −
0
t
K α (t − s) ∗ (u n · ∇)θn (s) ds, n ≥ 1.
These approximations are such that 1 1−δ m )
t α (
θn+1 (t)
1
m Lδ
≤ K n+1 , t 2α ∇θn+1 (t) L m ≤ K n+1
(5.37)
are bounded by expressions that depend on K 1 , K n and K n only. If θ0 has small L m norm then these recursive relations are uniformly bounded; this is K n ≤ K , K n ≤ K , n ≥ 1 for some K > 0. A standard argument allows us to show that there is a uniformly m converging subsequence θn whose limit is a solution to (2.7) in L δ that obeys (5.35) and (5.36). These preliminary estimates are used to bootstrap a similar argument which proves the results stated in the theorem.
Decay of Solutions to Quasi-Geostrophic Equation
111
Proof. We begin by proving (5.35) and (5.36). Let δ be fixed, 0 < δ < 1. We note first that by (2.8) in Lemma 2.3, θ1 (t)
1 1−δ m )
≤ Ct − α (
m δ
L
θ0 L m ,
and by (2.9) in Lemma 2.3, 1
∇θ1 (t) L m ≤ Ct − 2α θ0 L m . Let K 1 = K 1 = Cθ0 L m . Now assume 1 1−δ m )
t α (
1 2α
t for t > 0. Then θn+1 (t)
∇θn (t) L m ≤ K n
m Lδ
≤ θ1 (t)
m Lδ
θn (t) mδ ≤ K n ,
t
+
1 1−δ m )
≤ K1 t − α (
0
t
+ 0
1 1−δ m )
≤ K1 t − α (
K α (t − s) ∗ (u n · ∇)θn (s)
L
m δ
K α (t − s) ∗ (u n · ∇)θn (s)
L
t
ds m δ
ds
1
(t − s)− αm θn (s) mδ ∇θn (s) L m ds L 0 t 1 1−δ 1 1−δ 1 ≤ K 1 t − α ( m ) + C K n K n (t − s)− αm s − αm − 2α ds +C
0
1 1−δ m )
≤ K1 t − α (
1 1−δ m )
+ C K n K n t − α (
,
(5.38)
where we used boundedness of the Riesz transform and (2.10) in Lemma 2.4 with 2 η = µ = 2δ m and ν = m . By an analogous method
t
∇θn+1 (t) L m ≤ ∇θ1 (t) L m + ∇ K α (t − s) ∗ (u n · ∇)θn (s) L m ds 0 t 1 ≤ K 1 t − 2α + ∇ K α (t − s) ∗ (u n · ∇)θn (s) L m ds 0 t 1 1 δ m ∇θn (s) L m ds ≤ K 1 t − 2α + C (t − s)−( 2α + mα ) θn (s) delta L 0 t 1 1 δ 1−δ 1 − 2α ≤ K1 t + C Kn Kn (t − s)−( 2α + αm ) s − αm − 2α ds ≤ K1 t
1 − 2α
+C
0 1 − 2α Kn Kn t ,
(5.39)
where we used boundedness of the Riesz transform and (2.11) in Lemma 2.4 with η = ν = m2 , µ = 2δ m . We have then that the norms described in (5.37) are respectively bounded by K n+1 ≤ K 1 + C K n K n , K n+1 ≤ K 1 + C K n K n .
112
If K 1 <
C. J. Niche, M. E. Schonbek 1 4c ,
an induction argument allows us to prove that K n ≤ K
Kn ≤ K , 1 . Note that K 0 < for n ≥ 1, where K = 2c of the initial data has to be small. Then 1 1−δ m )
t α (
t
1 2α
1 4c
θn (t)
implies θ0 L m < L
1 , 4c2
thus the L m norm
≤ K,
m δ
∇θn (t) L m ≤ K ,
for n ≥ 1. By a standard argument (see Kato [17] and Kato and Fujita [18] for full details) we can extract a subsequence that converges uniformly in (0, +∞) to a solution θ . Then 1 1−δ m )
t α(
m
θ ∈ BC((0, +∞), L δ ),
1
t 2α ∇θ ∈ BC((0, +∞), L m ). We now use these preliminary estimates to prove the theorem. As before, we construct a solution by successive approximations. Let m ≤ q < ∞. By (2.8) in Lemma 2.3, θ1 (t) L q ≤ Ct
− α1 ( m1 − q1 )
θ0 L m ,
and by (2.9) in Lemma 2.3, ∇θ1 (t) L q ≤ Ct
1 1 1 −( 2α + α ( m − q1 ))
θ0 L m .
Notice that this estimate holds for q ≥ m. Again, set K 1 = K 1 = Cθ0 L m . We want 1
( 1 −1)
1
+1( 1 −1)
to show inductively that the L q norms of t α m q θn (t) and t 2α α m q ∇n+1 θ (t) are uniformly bounded. Then t −1( 1 −1) θn+1 (t) L q ≤ K 1 t α m q + K α (t − s) ∗ (u n · ∇)θn (s) L q ds 0 t −1( 1 −1) − 1 ( 1+δ − 1 ) ≤ K1t α m q + C (t − s) α m q θn (s) mδ ∇θn (s) L m ds L 0 t 2−δ 1 −1( 1 −1) − 1 ( 1+δ − 1 ) ≤ K 1 t α m q + C K n K n (t − s) α m q s − mα − 2α ds 0
≤ K1 t
− α1 ( m1 − q1 )
1
1
1
− ( − ) + C K n K n t α m q ,
(5.40)
2 where we have used (2.10) in Lemma 2.4 with η = q2 , µ = 2δ m and ν = m and we have used the preliminary estimates obtained for θn (t) mδ and ∇θn (t) L m . Proceeding L analogously for the gradient we obtain t ∇θn+1 (t) L q ≤ ∇θ1 (t) L q + ∇ K α (t − s) ∗ (u n · ∇)θn (s) L q ds 0 t −( 1 + 1 ( 1 − 1 )) ≤ K 1 t 2α α m q + ∇ K α (t − s) ∗ (u n · ∇)θn (s) L q ds 0 t 2−δ 1 −( 1 + 1 ( 1 − 1 )) −( 1 + 1 ( 1+δ − 1 )) ≤ K 1 t 2α α m q + C (t − s) 2α α m q s − mα − 2α ds 0
≤ K1t
1 1 1 −( 2α + α ( m − q1 ))
+ K n K n t
1 1 1 −( 2α + α ( m − q1 ))
,
(5.41)
Decay of Solutions to Quasi-Geostrophic Equation
113
where we used (2.11) in Lemma 2.4 with η = q2 , µ = 1
K n+1 = t α K n+1 = t
( m1 − q1 )
2δ m
and ν =
2 m . As before,
setting
θn+1 (t) L q ,
1 1 1 1 2α + α ( m − q )
∇θn+1 (t) L q ,
(5.42)
we obtain K n+1 ≤ K 1 + C K n K n , K n+1 ≤ K 1 + C K n K n . The same arguments that were used for the preliminary estimates apply here, leading to 1
tα
( m1 − q1 )
θ (t) ∈ BC((0, ∞), L q )
and 1
t 2α for
2 2α−1
+ α1 ( m1 − q1 )
∇θ (t) ∈ BC((0, ∞), L q )
≤ q < ∞, which is the desired result.
2 5.2. Proof of Theorem 1.5. Let m = 2α−1 . By (1.5), the L m norm of θ tends to zero, so for times larger than some T = T (θ0 ), θ (t) L m ≤ κ, for κ as in Theorem 1.4. Let m ≤ q < r . Interpolation yields
θ (t) L q ≤ θ (t)aL m θ (t)1−a Lr for a =
m r −q q r −m
and 1 − a =
r q−m q r −m .
θ (t)
Lq
Then
≤ Ct
(1− α1 ) mq
r −q r −m
− α1 ( m1 − q1 )
.
This holds for any r such that q ≤ r < ∞. The optimal decay rate is given by the minimum of the exponent f (r ) = C1
r −q − C2 , r −m
where C1 = (1 − α1 ) mq and C2 = α1 ( m1 − q1 ). As C1 < 0, this is a non-increasing function, so the optimal decay rate is 1 1 1 1 m − − . lim f (r ) = C1 − C2 = 1 − r →∞ α q α m q Then 1
4a−3
θ (t) L q ≤ C t q α(2α−1) which is the desired result.
1 −1+ 2α
, t ≥ T,
Acknowledgements. The authors would like to thank Helena Nussenzveig-Lopes for calling their attention to the articles by Carrillo and Ferreira; José Carrillo and Lucas C.F. Ferreira for providing us with copies of their preprints and for helpful remarks concerning their work and the anonymous referee for his suggestions and comments.
114
C. J. Niche, M. E. Schonbek
References 1. Berselli, L.C.: Vanishing viscosity limit and long-time behaviour for 2D quasi-geostrophic equations. Indiana Univ. Math. J. 51, 905–930 (2002) 2. Cafarelli, L., Kohn, H., Nirenberg, L.: Partial regularity of suitable weak solutions of the Navier-Stokes equations. Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 35, 771–831 (1982) 3. Carpio, A.: Large-time behaviour in incompressible Navier-Stokes equations. SIAM J. Math. Anal 27, 449–475 (1996) 4. Carrillo, J., Ferreira, L.C.F.: Self-similar solutions and large time asymptotics for the dissipative quasigeostrophic equations. Monatshefte für Math 15, 111–142 (2007) 5. Carrillo, J., Ferreira, L.C.F.: Convergence towards self-similar asymptotic behaviour for the dissipative quasi-geostrophic equations. Banach Center Publ. 74, 95–115 (2006) 6. Carrillo, J., Ferreira, L.C.F.: Asymptotic behaviour for the subcritical dissipative quasi-geostrophic equations. Preprint UAB, 2006 7. Chae, D.: The quasi-geostrophic equation in the Triebel-Lizorkin spaces. Nonlinearity 16(2), 479–495 (2003) 8. Chae, D., Lee, J.: Global well-posedness in the super-critical dissipative quasi-geostrophic equations. Commun. Math. Phys. 233(2), 297–311 (2003) 9. Constantin, P., Cordoba, D., Wu, J.: On the critical dissipative quasi-geostrophic equation. Indiana Univ. Math. J. 50, Special Issue, 97–107 (2001) 10. Constantin, P., Majda, A., Tabak, E.: Formation of strong fronts in the 2-D quasigeostrophic thermal active scalar. Nonlinearity 7, 1495–1533 (1994) 11. Constantin, P., Wu, J.: Behaviour of solutions of 2D Quasi-geostrophic equations. SIAM J. Math. Anal. 30, 937–948 (electronic) (1999) 12. Córdoba, A., Córdoba, D.: A maximum principle applied to quasi-geostrophic equations. Comm. Math. Phys. 249, 511–528 (2004) 13. Heywood, J.: Open problems in the theory of Navier-Stokes equations of viscous incompressible flow. The Navier-Stokes equations (Oberwolfach, 1988), Lecture Notes in Math. 1431, Berlin: Springer, 1990. pp. 1–22 14. Ju, N.: Existence and uniqueness of the solution to the dissipative 2D quasi-geostrophic equations in the Sobolev space. Commun. Math. Phys. 251, 365–376 (2004) 15. Ju, N.: The maximum principle and the global attractor for the 2D dissipative quasi-geostrophic equation. Commun. Math. Phys. 255, 161–182 (2005) 16. Ju, N.: On the two dimensional quasi-geostrophic equations. Indiana Univ. Math. J. 54, 897–926 (2005) 17. Kato, T.: Strong L p solutions of the Navier-Stokes equation in Rm , with applications to weak solutions. Math. Z. 187, 471–480 (1984) 18. Kato, T., Fujita, H.: On the nonstationary Navier-Stokes system. Rend. Sem. Mat. Univ. Padova 32, 243–260 (1962) 19. Ogawa, T., Rajopadhye, S., Schonbek, M.: Energy decay for a weak solution of the Navier-Stokes equation with slowly varying external forces. J. Funct. Anal. 144, 325–358 (1997) 20. Pedloskym, J.: Geophysical Fluid Dynamics. New York: Springer Verlag, 1987 21. Resnick, S.: Dynamical problems in non-linear advective partial differential equarions. Ph. D. Thesis, University of Chicago, 1995 22. Schonbek, M.: L 2 decay for weak solutions of the Navier-Stokes equations. Arch. Rat. Mech. Anal. 88, 209–222 (1985) 23. Schonbek, M.: Large time behaviour of solutions to the Navier-Stokes equations. Comm. Partial Diff. Eqs. 11, 733–763 (1986) 24. Schonbek, M., Schonbek, T.: Asymptotic behavior to dissipative quasi-geostrophic flows. SIAM J. Math. Anal. 35, 357–375 (electronic) (2003) 25. Schonbek, M., Schonbek, T.: Moments and lower bounds in the far-field of solutions to quasi-geostrophic flows. Disc. Contin. Dyn. Syst. 13, 1277–1304 (2005) 26. Serrin, J.: The initial value problem for the Navier-Stokes equations. In: Nonlinear problems (Proc. Sympos., Madison, Wis.), Madison, WI: Oniv. ofvisc. Press, pp. 69–98, 1963 27. Wu, J.: Dissipative quasi-geostrophic equations with L p data. Electron. J. Diff. Eq. (2001), No. 56, 13 pp. (electronic) 28. Wu, J.: The 2D dissipative quasi-geostrophic equation. Appl. Math. Letters 15, 925–930 (2002) 29. Wu, J.: The quasi-geostrophic equation and its two regularizations. Comm. Partial Diff. Eqs. 27(5-6), 1161–1181 (2002) 30. Wu, J.: Global solutions of the 2D dissipative quasi-geostrophic equation in Besov spaces. SIAM J. Math. Anal. 36(3), 1014–1030 (2004/05) (electronic) 31. Wu, J.: Solutions of the 2D quasi-geostrophic equation in Hölder spaces. Nonlinear Anal. 62(4), 579–594 (2005)
Decay of Solutions to Quasi-Geostrophic Equation
115
32. Wu, J.: The two-dimensional quasi-geostrophic equation with critical or supercritical dissipation. Nonlinearity 18(1), 139–154 (2005) 33. Zhang, L.: Sharp rates of decay of solutions to 2-dimensional Navier-Stokes equations. Comm. Partial Diff. Eqs. 20, 119–127 (1995) Communicated by P. Constantin
Commun. Math. Phys. 276, 117–130 (2007) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-007-0328-x
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Regge and Okamoto Symmetries Philip P. Boalch École Normale Supérieure et CNRS, 45 rue d’Ulm, 75005 Paris, France. E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 31 May 2006 / Accepted: 17 April 2007 Published online: 13 September 2007 – © Springer-Verlag 2007
Abstract: We will relate the surprising Regge symmetry of the Racah-Wigner 6 j symbols to the surprising Okamoto symmetry of the Painlevé VI differential equation. This then presents the opportunity to give a conceptual derivation of the Regge symmetry, as the representation theoretic analogue of the derivation in [5, 3] of the Okamoto symmetry.
1. Introduction The 6 j-symbols (or Racah coefficients) are real numbers associated to the choice of six irreducible representations Va , . . . , V f of SU(2). They were first published in work of Racah [16] in 1942, and arise in the addition of three angular momenta, which classically can be viewed as adding three vectors in R3 . Apparently ([15]) “there is hardly any branch of physics involving angular momenta where the use of Racah-coefficients is not needed in order to carry out the simplest computation”. (See the two volumes [1, 2] for many more details or the introduction to the tables [20] for a concise summary.) Wigner [23] used a slightly different normalisation so that they have tetrahedral symmetry, and wrote them in the form: ab e . (1) cd f Here a, b, c should be thought of as the lengths of three vectors a, b, c in R3 so the four points 0, a, a + b, a + b + c are the vertices of a (skew) tetrahedron. Then d, e, f should be the lengths of the other three edges of this tetrahedron, i.e. the lengths of a + b + c, a + b, b + c respectively. (Thus each column of (1) contains the lengths of two opposite edges, and the top row abe is a face. See Fig. 1.) Then the 6 j-symbol is invariant under the possible relabellings of this tetrahedron (preserving the relations so one gets 24 = #Sym4 possibilities).
118
P. P. Boalch
c
e
b d f a
Fig. 1. Labelling of the edges of a skew tetrahedron
Racah established an explicit formula for the 6 j-symbols as a sum, which has since been equated with the value at 1 of certain 4 F3 hypergeometric functions (and are closely related to the Wilson orthogonal polynomials [24]). Using this explicit Racah formula, in 1959 Regge [18] showed the 6 j-symbols also have the following further symmetry, which is more mysterious: p−a p−b e ab e , = p−c p−d f cd f where p = (a + b + c + d)/2. (Combined with the tetrahedral symmetries this generates a symmetry group isomorphic to Sym3 × Sym4 .) For example classically, recalling that a tetrahedron is determined up to isometry by its edge lengths, one may show (cf. Ponzano–Regge [15] and Roberts [19]) that this Regge action on the set of six edge lengths defines a non-trivial automorphism of the set of (skew) Euclidean tetrahedra, taking a generic tetrahedron to a non-congruent tetrahedron. Earlier Regge [17] found similar extra symmetries of the Clebsch-Gordan 3 j-symbols. The 3 j-symbols are in a sense less canonical, but note that Ponzano–Regge [15] p.7 explain how to obtain the 3 j-symbols as an asymptotic limit of 6 j-symbols and that in this limit the 6 j Regge symmetry becomes the 3 j Regge symmetry. They then wrote: The geometrical and physical content of these [Regge] symmetries is still to be understood and they remain a puzzling feature of the theory of angular momenta. Therefore it is a pleasant result to be able to reduce the problem of their interpretation to the Racah [6j] coefficient only. The basic aim of this article is to give a conceptual explanation of the Regge symmetry of the Racah 6 j coefficient. The key idea is to relate the above 6 j-symbols (for the group SU(2)) to certain three-dimensional 6 j-symbols (i.e. for the group SU(3)). The Regge transformation then arises simply from the natural duality between two dual irreducible representations of SU(3). The layout of the remainder of this article is as follows. First we will give the definition of the 6 j-symbols, then we will relate the Regge symmetry to a symmetry of a completely different object, this time a non-linear differential equation, the Okamoto symmetry of the Painlevé VI equation. Then we will “quantise” (that is, give the representation theoretical analogue of) the derivation of the Okamoto symmetry given in [5, 3], and so give a conceptual derivation of the Regge symmetry (i.e. without using the Racah formula).
Regge and Okamoto Symmetries
119
Remark 1. Note that Granovski˘ı and Zhedanov have shown in [8] that the 6 j symbols are determined by a certain noncommutative algebra and so, as they show, finding the Regge symmetry may be reduced to finding the corresponding symmetry of this algebra. 2. Background The 6 j-symbols are real numbers associated to the choice of 6 irreducible representations (irreps) of G := SU(2). We will label irreps Va by positive integers a ≥ 0, so that Va = Syma (V ) is the spin a/2 representation of dimension a + 1, where V is the two-dimensional Hermitian vector space defining G. Given 3 such irreps, with labels a, b, c say, one can form the tensor product Vabc := Va ⊗ Vb ⊗ Vc which again will be a representation of G and will decompose as a direct sum of irreps. Thus given a fourth representation Vd one may consider the multiplicity space Mabcd := HomG (Vd , Vabc ) of G-equivariant maps from Vd into the 3-fold tensor product. Thus Mabcd is a Hermitian vector space with dimension equal to the multiplicity of Vd in Vabc . There are two (almost) canonical unitary bases in Mabcd (‘coupling bases’) and the 6 j-symbols arise as matrix entries of the change of basis matrix between these two bases. The coupling bases arise by decomposing Vabc in the two possible orders: on one hand we may first decompose Vab := Va ⊗ Vb : Ve ⊗ HomG (Ve , Vab ) Vab ∼ = e
which entails the following direct sum decomposition of Mabcd : HomG (Vd , Vec ) ⊗ HomG (Ve , Vab ). Mabcd = HomG (Vd , Vab ⊗ Vc ) ∼ = e
The key point is that each of the terms in this direct sum is either zero or onedimensional (since, for SU(2), any irrep appears at most once in the tensor product of two irreps). Thus choosing a real vector of length one in each one dimensional term yields the 1-2 coupling basis {ve } of Mabcd as e varies, unique up to the sign of each basis vector. (We set ve = 0 if the space HomG (Vd , Vec ) ⊗ HomG (Ve , Vab ) is zero.) Similarly decomposing the 3-fold product in the other order, i.e. first writing V f ⊗ HomG (V f , Vbc ) Vbc ∼ = f
yields a different basis {w f }, the 2-3 coupling basis, adapted to the decomposition HomG (Vd , Va f ) ⊗ HomG (V f , Vbc ). Mabcd = f
Thus given six irreps with labels a, b, c, d, e, f , and a standard sign-convention, one will get two vectors ve , w f in Mabcd and thus a number U (a, b, c, d, e, f ) = ve , w f
120
P. P. Boalch
by pairing them using the Hermitian form. (As e and f vary these will be the matrix entries of the unitary change of basis matrix alluded to above—in fact by reality it is real orthogonal.) The 6 j-symbols were defined by Wigner in terms of U by a minor normalisation: U (a, b, c, d, e, f ) ab e , = (−1) p √ cd f (e + 1)( f + 1)
p := (a + b + c + d)/2.
This normalisation is such that the 6 j-symbols admit tetrahedral symmetry, where the coefficients label the six edges of a tetrahedron (containing for example the quadrilateral abcd and faces abe and bc f ). Note that if U is non-zero then p will be an integer. As mentioned in the introduction using the explicit Racah formula for the 6 j-symbols, Regge [18] showed the 6 j-symbols also have the following symmetry: ab e p−a p−b e = , cd f p−c p−d f where p = (a + b + c + d)/2. (Since e, f are fixed, one may just as well view this as a symmetry of the corresponding function U .) More geometrically one may also view this as a symmetry of the set of tetrahedra in R3 (cf. [15, 19]). First note that if Ve appears in Va ⊗ Vb then the triangle inequalities a − b≤ e ≤ a + b hold; i.e. there exists a Euclidean triangle with sides of lengths a, b, e. (One also has the parity condition that a + b + e be even.) Thus if both vectors ve and w f are non-zero then there are four Euclidean triangles with side lengths abe, cde, ad f, bc f respectively. Now these four triangles may or may not fit together to form the faces of a Euclidean tetrahedron; the condition that they do is given by requiring the determinant of the ‘Cayley-Menger matrix’: ⎛
0 a 2 e2 d 2 1
⎜ ⎜ a2 ⎜ ⎜ ⎜ e2 ⎜ ⎜ ⎜ d2 ⎝ 1
⎞
⎟ 0 b2 f 2 1 ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ 2 2 b 0 c 1⎟ ⎟ ⎟ 2 2 f c 0 1⎟ ⎠ 1 1 1 0
to be positive. It is simple to check the Regge transformation preserves the set of all triangle inequalities (although permuting them in a non-trivial way). Moreover a computation will show that the determinant of the Cayley-Menger matrix is preserved too. Thus one may view the Regge transformation as an automorphism of the set of Euclidean tetrahedra, even if we allow real (not necessarily integral) edge lengths (noting that a tetrahedron with non-zero volume is determined by its edge lengths up to isometry, possibly reversing the orientation). Our first step in deriving the Regge symmetry is to note a remarkably similar symmetry of a completely different object, this time of a certain nonlinear differential equation.
Regge and Okamoto Symmetries
121
The Painlevé VI differential equation (henceforth PVI ) is the following nonlinear ordinary differential equation for a holomorphic function y(t) with t ∈ C \ {0, 1}: 2 1 1 1 dy 1 1 dy 1 + + + + − y y−1 y−t dt t t − 1 y − t dt t y(y − 1)(y − t) (t − 1) t (t − 1) α + β , + + γ + δ t 2 (t − 1)2 y2 (y − 1)2 (y − t)2
1 d2 y = 2 dt 2
where α, β, γ , δ are four complex constants. PVI is usually thought of as controlling the monodromy preserving (isomonodromic) deformations of rank 2 (traceless) Fuchsian systems with 4 poles on P1 (whose monodromy is a representation of the free group on 3 generators into SL2 (C)). Okamoto [14] proved PVI has a quite nontrivial symmetry: Theorem 1. Choose four complex constants θ = (θ1 , . . . θ4 ) and set α = (θ4 − 1)2 /2,
β = −θ12 /2,
γ = θ32 /2,
δ = (1 − θ22 )/2.
If y(t) is a solution of PVI with parameters θ then, if defined, y + φ/x solves PVI with parameters θ = (θ1 − φ, θ2 − φ, θ3 − φ, θ4 − φ), where φ =
4
1 θi /2
and
2x =
t y + θ3 (t − 1) y − θ1 y − 1 − θ2 + − , y y−t y−1
where y is the derivative of y with respect to t. (Observe the striking similarity with the Regge transformation.) In the next section we will describe exactly how the Okamoto and Regge symmetries are related (in effect showing precisely how the complicated Okamoto action on the pair (y, x) relates to the trivial Regge action on the pair (e, f )). Remark 2. Since the parameters appearing in PVI are now quadratic functions of the θ ’s, if y solves PVI with parameters θ then y will also solve PVI for any parameters obtained from θ by negating any combination of θ1 , θ2 , θ3 and possibly replacing θ4 by 2 − θ4 . Together with the Okamoto transformation these four ‘trivial’ transformations generate a group isomorphic to the affine Weyl group of type D4 (see [14]). Further one may add in transformations corresponding to the Sym4 symmetry group of the affine D4 Dynkin diagram and obtain a symmetry group isomorphic to the affine Weyl group of type F4 . The confusing fact to note is that one still does not obtain symmetries corresponding to all the tetrahedral 6 j symmetries, basically because the PVI flows vary y, x and fix the θ ’s.
122
P. P. Boalch
3. Regge and Okamoto We will relate the Regge action on Euclidean tetrahedra to the Okamoto action. Let a1 , a2 , a3 ∈ R3 be three vectors, so that 0, a1 , a1 + a2 , a1 + a2 + a3 are the vertices of a tetrahedron. Denote the other three edge vectors of the tetrahedron by a4 , a5 , a6 so that: a1 + a2 + a3 + a4 = 0, a5 = a1 + a2 ,
a6 = a2 + a3 .
Denote the lengths of these six vectors a1 , . . . , a6 by a, b, c, d, e, f respectively. Now let H be the set of traceless 2 × 2 Hermitian matrices. Thus H is a real threedimensional vector space and we give it a Euclidean inner product by defining A1 , A2 := 2Tr(A1 A2 ). Thus we can view the tetrahedron as living in H by choosing an isometry ϕ : R3 ∼ =H such as ⎛ ⎞ x 1 x y + iz . ϕ ⎝y⎠ = 2 y − i z −x z Then we set A j = ϕ(a j ) ∈ H for j = 1, . . . , 6. Thus the Regge symmetry becomes an action on the set of these 6 Hermitian matrices A j (clearly determined by its action on the first three matrices). Now in the standard isomonodromy interpretation [11] of the Painlevé VI equation the Okamoto symmetry becomes a (birational) action on the set of Fuchsian systems of the form d A1 A2 A3 − A, A := + + , Ai ∈ sl2 (C), (2) dz z z−t z−1 where the coefficients A1 , A2 , A3 are 2×2 traceless complex matrices and t ∈ C\{0, 1} fixed. As above we will set A4 = −(A1 + A2 + A3 ) which is now the residue of Adz at z = ∞. This interpretation comes about by using explicit local coordinates on the space of such systems; up to overall conjugation by SL2 (C), the set of such Fuchsian systems is of complex dimension 6 and local coordinates (near a generic system) are given by θ1 , θ2 , θ3 , θ4 , x, y, where θi is such that Ai has eigenvalues ±θi /2, and where x, y are two explicit algebraic functions of A defined for example in [5] p.199, following [11]. (These are the same x, y appearing in Theorem 1.) Of course one would prefer to view the birational transformation as the intrinsic object, and its explicit coordinate expression as secondary. In particular one might hope for a simpler expression than that given in terms of x, y in Theorem 1. One way to do this, which will be useful here, was observed in [5] Lemma 34. To describe this we should first modify slightly the matrices A1 , A2 , A3 : Let i = Ai + θi /2 A
i = 1, 2, 3
i has eigenvalues 0, θi (i.e. it has rank one and trace θi ). so that A
Regge and Okamoto Symmetries
123
Lemma 3. ([5] Lemma 34) Each of the five expressions 1 A 2 ), Tr( A
2 A 3 ), Tr( A
2 A 3 ), 1 A Tr( A
1 A 3 ), Tr( A
3 A 2 A 1 ) Tr( A
is preserved by the birational Okamoto transformation of Theorem 1. This may be proved by a direct coordinate computation; the geometric origin of it is given in [5] (see especially Lemma 34, Remark 30) and may be thought of as the (complexification of the) classical analogue of the ideas we will use in the next section. Now it is straightforward to prove (see [9]) that generically the first two of these expressions (viewed as functions on the set of Fuchsian systems) together with the 1 A 2 ) and four θ ’s make up a system of local coordinates. Let us write λ12 = Tr( A 2 A 3 ). Thus, in these coordinates the Okamoto transformation acts simply λ23 = Tr( A as (θ, λ12 , λ23 ) → (θ1 − φ, θ2 − φ, θ3 − φ, θ4 − φ, λ12 , λ23 )
with φ = 41 θi /2, which looks even more like the Regge transformation, and easily yields the main result of this section: Theorem 2. Suppose A1 , A2 , A3 are 2 × 2 traceless Hermitian matrices with eigenvalues ±θi /2 with θi > 0 and let a, b, c, d, e, f be the edge lengths of the corresponding tetrahedron in R3 (under the isometry ϕ) i.e. the lengths of the vectors corresponding to the six matrices A1 , A2 , A3 , A1 + A2 + A3 , A1 + A2 , A2 + A3 respectively. Then the Okamoto transformation of (A1 , A2 , A3 ) corresponds to the Regge transformation of the tetrahedron with edge lengths a, b, c, d, e, f . Proof. For the first four edge lengths this is easy since (a, b, c, d) = (θ1 , θ2 , θ3 , θ4 ) (note that the triangle inequalities imply φ − θi ≥ 0). We need to also show that the Okamoto transformation preserves the edge lengths e and f . But this is now a simple computation: First note e2 = 2Tr(A1 + A2 )2 = θ12 + θ22 + 4Tr A1 A2 . 1 − θ1 /2)( A 2 − θ2 /2) = 4Tr A 1 A 2 − 2θ1 θ2 so that Then observe 4TrA1 A2 = 4Tr( A 1 A 2 . e2 = (θ1 − θ2 )2 + 4Tr A The first term on the right here is preserved, as is the second term by the lemma above, and so e is preserved since it is positive. Similarly for f . Remark 4. Returning briefly to the complex (not-necessarily Hermitian) picture, the above argument implies that the Okamoto transformation is also characterised as preserving Tr A25 and TrA26 , where A5 = A1 + A2 and A6 = A2 + A3 (and similarly it preserves Tr(A1 + A3 )2 ).
124
P. P. Boalch
Remark 5. (Spherical tetrahedra, cf. [21].) Consider three elements M1 , M2 , M3 ∈ SU(2) of the 3-sphere S 3 ∼ = SU(2), and the spherical tetrahedron with vertices I, M1 , M1 M2 , M1 M2 M3 . This has edge lengths li , where TrMi = 2 cos(li ) (i = 1, . . . , 6), where M4 = (M1 M2 M3 )−1 , M5 = M1 M2 , M6 = M2 M3 . One may define a Regge symmetry of the set of such tetrahedra, by acting on the edge lengths exactly as before. This action may be complexified in the obvious way (allow Mi ∈ SL2 (C) and li ∈ C). On the other hand the Okamoto action on the Fuchsian systems (2) induces an action on their monodromy data (i.e. essentially on the space of SL2 (C) representations of the fundamental group of the four-punctured sphere). The fact to be noted is that this action coincides with the above spherical Regge action (taking Mi to be the monodromy around the i th puncture for i = 1, 2, 3, 4); in other words the Okamoto action fixes the functions Tr(M1 M2 ) and Tr(M2 M3 ) of the monodromy data—this was the main result of [10], proved differently in Corollary 35 of [5]. 4. Conceptual Regge Symmetry We will give a conceptual derivation of the fact that the Regge symmetry preserves the 6 j-symbols (i.e. without using the Racah formula). There are two basic steps: • Identify the SU(2) 6 j symbols with certain SU(3) 6 j-symbols, • Use a natural symmetry of these SU(3) 6 j-symbols. These are representation theoretic analogues of the derivation given in [5, 3] of the Okamoto symmetry. (The article [22] helped us to understand this—see also [4] where we first realised that [22] describes a representation theoretic analogue of some things the present author had been thinking about.) First we will set up notation for representations of H := SU(3). Let W be the three-dimensional Hermitian vector space defining H . For any integer a ≥ 0 write Wa := Syma (W ) for the a th symmetric power of W ; an irreducible representation of H . Similarly for integers a ≥ b ≥ 0 write W(a,b) for the irrep of H corresponding to the Young diagram with 3 rows of lengths a, b, 0 resp. (cf. [6]). (Thus in particular Wa = W(a,0) .) One would like to define the SU(3) 6 j-symbols using the same framework as described above for SU(2). This is difficult though since SU(3) is not multiplicity-free and in general one will not obtain a decomposition of the multiplicity spaces into onedimensional pieces, but into pieces of higher dimension. (There are numerous articles discussing this multiplicity problem, and methods to circumvent it.) However things are simpler if we take the three initial representations to be symmetric representations (i.e. of the form Wa ). Then the Pieri rules imply one will again get the desired one-dimensional decomposition and we may proceed as before (and this is the only case we will need here). Thus we choose 3 symmetric irreps, with labels a, b, c say, and form the tensor product Wabc := Wa ⊗ Wb ⊗ Wc . Now, given an arbitrary representation Wλ with λ = ( p, q) one obtains a multiplicity space as before Nabcλ := Hom H (Wλ , Wabc ).
Regge and Okamoto Symmetries
125
Similarly to before the two expansions Wa ⊗ Wb ∼ =
W(r,s) ⊗ Hom H (W(r,s) , Wa ⊗ Wb ),
(r,s)
Wb ⊗ Wc ∼ =
W(t,u) ⊗ Hom H (W(t,u) , Wb ⊗ Wc )
(t,u)
yield two decompositions of the multiplicity space: Nabcλ ∼ =
Hom H (Wλ , W(r,s) ⊗ Wc ) ⊗ Hom H (W(r,s) , Wa ⊗ Wb ),
(r,s)
Nabcλ ∼ =
Hom H (Wλ , Wa ⊗ W(t,u) ) ⊗ Hom H (W(t,u) , Wb ⊗ Wc ).
(t,u)
Now the Pieri rules (see [6]) imply that the tensor product of a symmetric representation with any irrep will be multiplicity free (i.e. each irrep that appears in the tensor product will appear exactly once). Thus both of these decompositions of Nabcλ will be into one-dimensional pieces and by choosing real basis vectors of length one vr s , wtu in the corresponding pieces we can define matrix entries as before: U (3) (a, b, c, λ, (r, s), (t, u)) = vr s , wtu . (Again a sign-convention is needed to fix the signs of the basis vectors, but we will not worry about this here—the correct choices will be such that the following result is true.) The basic fact that we will use is that these 3-dimensional 6 j coefficients are equal to 2-dimensional 6 j coefficients: Proposition 6. Choose six integers a, b, c, d, e, f ≥ 0. Then [up to sign] U (a, b, c, d, e, f ) = U (3) (a, b, c, ( p, q), (r, s), (t, u)), where p=
a+b+c+d a+b+e b+c+ f , r= , t= , 2 2 2 q = p − d, s = r − e, u = t − f.
This will be proved below (it is probably quite well-known). First we will describe the desired three-dimensional symmetry and deduce the Regge symmetry: Proposition 7. The three-dimensional 6 j-symbol is symmetric as follows: U (3) (a, b, c, ( p, q), (r, s), (t, u)) = U (3) ( p − a, p − b, p − c, ( p, p − q), ( p − s, p − r ), ( p − u, p − t)).
126
P. P. Boalch
Note that this does indeed project back to give the Regge symmetry1 . Thus our task is reduced to justifying the above two propositions. At first sight it may appear that little progress has been made, replacing the Regge symmetry by the symmetry of Proposition 7. But as we shall see, this symmetry arises simply by pairing two dual representations of SU(3). [It is not however simply a matter of dualising all the representations in sight, since the dual of Wa is not a symmetric representation, for a > 0.] Proof (of Proposition 6). The first step is to identify the corresponding weight spaces Mabcd and Nabcλ . This can be done easily using “Howe duality for GLk -GLn ”, as follows (cf. [25, 22])2 . Choose two positive integers k, n and let V, W be complex vector spaces of dimensions k, n respectively. Then their tensor product V ⊗ W is a representation of GL(V ) × GL(W ) and so its d th symmetric power Symd (V ⊗ W ) is also a GL(V ) × GL(W )-module. This decomposes as a direct sum of irreducible GL(V ) × GL(W )-modules in the following way (see [6] Exercise 6.11; apparently this goes back to Cauchy): Symd (V ⊗ W ) ∼ Vλ ⊗ Wλ , = #λ≤k,n |λ|=d
where the sum is over all Young diagrams λ with d boxes and having no more than k or n rows, and Vλ (resp. Wλ ) is the irreducible GL(V )-module (resp. GL(W )-module) corresponding to λ. Choosing bases of V and W allows us to be more explicit. In particular it identifies GL(V ) ∼ = GLk (C) and so picks out a maximal torus (the diagonal subgroup), as well as a Borel subgroup (the upper triangular subgroup) and so allows us to speak of weights and highest weight vectors of GL(V ) modules (similarly for GL(W )). Also we can now view V ⊗ W as the space of linear functions ψ on the set Mk×n of k × n matrices X = (xi j ) with the following action of GLk (C) × GLn (C): (gk , gn )(ψ)(X ) = ψ(gkT Xgn ). (To avoid confusion below when k = n = 3, we will refer to this GLk (C)-action, respectively GLn (C)-action, as the action on the left, resp. right.) Then Symd (V ⊗ W ) = ∗ ) is the set of such functions which are homogeneous polynomials of degree Symd (Mk×n d, with the same action. Thus as GLk (C) × GLn (C)-modules, (k) (n) ∗ Symd (Mk×n )∼ Vλ ⊗ Vλ , (3) = #λ≤k,n |λ|=d (r )
where Vλ is the GLr (C) irrep. with Young diagram λ. ∗ ) can be viewed as the tensor product of the Now, as a GLk module Sym• (Mk×n n ∗ ) ∼ functions on each of the columns of X , i.e. Sym• (Mk×n = 1 Sym• Ck . Moreover if we choose n positive integers µ = (µ1 , . . . , µn ) then we can consider the subspace: ∗ ) S µ Ck := Symµ1 Ck ⊗ · · · ⊗ Symµn Ck ⊂ Sym• (Mk×n 1 Inverting the equations appearing in Proposition 6 yields d = p − q, e = r − s, f = t − u so that Proposition 6 implies U (3) ( p − a, p − b, p − c, ( p, p − q), ( p − s, p − r ), ( p − u, p − t)) = U ( p − a, p − b, p − c, q, r − s, t − u) and so, since q = p − d, r − s = e, t − u = f we do obtain the Regge symmetry U (a, b, c, d, e, f ) = U ( p − a, p − b, p − c, p − d, e, f ) as desired. 2 To proceed explicitly (using similar ideas) see [13, 7].
Regge and Okamoto Symmetries
127
of functions which are homogeneous of degree µi in the i th column. This is equivalent ∗ ). to saying they are the vectors of weight µ for the GLn action on Sym• (Mk×n Now what we are really interested in are the GLk multiplicity spaces of the form: µ
Mλ := HomGLk (Vλ(k) , S µ Ck ) whose dimension is the multiplicity of Vλ(k) in this n-fold product of symmetric representations. This multiplicity space may be realised explicitly as the subspace of S µ Ck (k) of vectors of highest weight λ for the GLk action (since each copy of Vλ in S µ Ck has a unique highest weight vector, up to scale). On the other hand by the decomposition ∗ ) of vectors of highest weight λ for the GL action is (3) the subspace of Sym• (Mk×n k (n)
a single copy of Vλ . Intersecting this with the subspace S µ Ck (i.e. the vectors with GLn (C) weight µ) yields the basic result we need (cf. [22] Lemma 3.4):
(n) ∼ M µ between the Lemma 8. The above discussion gives an isomorphism Vλ [µ] = λ (n) weight µ subspace of the GLn (C) representation Vλ and the GLk (C) multiplicity µ space Mλ .
In the 6 j-symbol situation, we are interested in three-fold tensor products of symmetric representations, so n = 3, and our Young diagrams always have at most two non-zero rows, so we may take any k ≥ 2. For k = 2, Lemma 8 implies (3) Mabcd ∼ = Vλ [µ],
where µ = (a, b, c) and where λ has at most 2 rows and is such that Vλ(2) ∼ = Vd as SU(2) representations and the number of boxes in λ equals a +b +c. This implies λ = ( p, q, 0), where p + q = a + b + c and p − q = d, i.e. p = (a + b + c + d)/2 and q = p − d as in the statement of Proposition 6. In turn, for k = 3, Lemma 8 implies (3)
Vλ [µ] ∼ = Nabcλ , and so combining the two gives the desired isomorphism of multiplicity spaces. (Explicitly if we view the 2 × 3 matrices as the first two rows of the 3 × 3 matrices, then these multiplicity spaces are actually equal as spaces of polynomial functions on 3×3 matrices since in both cases they do not depend on the variables in the third row, as λ has at most two non-zero rows.) Remark 9. For the reader familiar with Gelfand-Tsetlin tableaux, we should mention that the weight space Vλ(3) [µ] (and thus the common multiplicity space) admits a basis parameterised by tableaux of the form ⎛ ⎞ p q 0 ⎝ α β ⎠, γ where α, β, γ are integers satisfying interlacing inequalities: p ≥ α ≥ q ≥ β ≥ 0, α ≥ γ ≥ β and should be such that the tableau has ‘weight’ µ = (a, b, c)—the weight of a tableau is the differences of the row sums, i.e. we require γ = a, α + β − γ = b, p+q −(α+β) = c. This gives a simple way to compute the dimension of the multiplicity spaces (i.e. count the tableaux) although we will not need to use this Gelfand-Tsetlin basis (in general it does not coincide with any of the coupling bases).
128
P. P. Boalch
To complete the proof of Proposition 6 we need to see the corresponding coupling bases match up under the above isomorphism of multiplicity spaces. (One may use the ∗ ) and so see the Hermitian forms Bargmann-Segal-Fock Hermitian form on Sym• (Mk×n coincide.) One way to do this is to first observe that the 1-2 coupling spaces are the eigenspaces of the GLk (C) quadratic Casimir operator Ck acting on the first two tensor factors of S µ Ck = Syma Ck ⊗ Symb Ck ⊗ Symb Ck , where µ = (a, b, c) and k = 2 or 3. This holds since in general Ck acts (see e.g. [25] p.161) by multiplication by the scalar
m i2 +
mi − m j
(4)
i< j
on the GLk irrep. with Young diagram (m 1 , . . . , m k ). Denote this operation by Ck12 and note it preserves the common multiplicity space Mabcd = Nabcλ ⊂ S µ C2 ⊂ S µ C3 for k = 2, 3. Then we just observe, using (4), that on the multiplicity space the Casimirs differ by a scalar: C312 = C212 + (a + b) and so have the same eigenspaces (and the eigenspace labels match up as stated, that is: r − s = e, r + s = a + b). (Similarly for the 2-3 coupling.) Next we will describe the three-dimensional symmetry which lifts the Regge symmetry: If Vλ(3) is the irrep of GL3 (C) with Young diagram λ = ( p, q, 0) then there is a pairing (3)
(3)
Vλ ⊗ (Vλ )∨ → C, (3)
where (Vλ )∨ is the dual representation. Tensoring this by the p th power D p of the deter(3) (3) minant representation yields a pairing Vλ ⊗ Vλ → D p , where λ = ( p, p − q, 0). (3) (3) This pairs the µ = (a, b, c) weight space of Vλ with the µ weight space of Vλ , where µ = ( p − a, p − b, p − c) and so yields a perfect pairing: (3)
(3)
Vλ [µ] ⊗ Vλ [µ ] → C.
(5)
Now to prove Proposition 7 one just needs to check that the corresponding coupling bases are dual with respect to this pairing. Remark 10. On the level of Gelfand-Tsetlin tableaux the above duality corresponds to negating each tableau element then adding p to each element and finally flipping the tableau about its vertical axis. (Observe that the tableau’s weight has transformed as stated.) Proof (of Proposition 7). We will first describe the above pairing in a different way which will be more convenient. Write G = GL3 (C) and let S a = Syma C3 . By the Pieri rules there is a unique G-equivariant map S a ⊗ S p−a → S p
Regge and Okamoto Symmetries
129
since S p appears precisely once in this tensor product3 . (Similarly replacing a by b or c.) Putting these together there is a G-equivariant map S a S b S c ⊗ S p−a S p−b S p−c → S p S p S p pairing the corresponding factors (and omitting to write several ⊗ symbols). Again by the Pieri rules there is a unique (projection) map S p S p S p → D p to the p th power of the determinant representation. Composing with the above map we get a (degenerate) bilinear form: ν : S a S b S c ⊗ S p−a S p−b S p−c → D p . In terms of pairs of polynomials on M3×3 (viewing S α S β S γ as polynomials homogeneous of degrees α, β, γ in the columns 1, 2, 3 resp. as above) this bilinear form ν amounts to multiplication followed by orthogonal projection onto D p (which is just the line spanned by the p th power of the polynomial det : M3×3 → C). (3) (3) Now we wish to relate ν to the natural pairing Vλ [µ] ⊗ Vλ [µ ] → C of (5). For this we view Vλ(3) as a space of polynomials on the 3 × 3 matrices as in Lemma 8 (as the polynomials with highest weight λ for the GL3 -action on the left), but we view Vλ(3) differently as the space of polynomials with lowest weight (0, p − q, p) for the GL3 -action on the left. Then multiplication of functions followed by orthogonal projection onto D p (3) (3) gives a pairing Vλ ⊗ Vλ → D p which one may check is nonzero directly (observing (3) that a highest weight vector of Vλ pairs non-degenerately with a lowest weight vector (3) of Vλ ). Thus by Schur’s lemma this pairing coincides with the natural one up to scale. Restricting to the µ and µ weight spaces respectively and using Lemma 8 thus yields a non-degenerate pairing Nµλ ⊗ Nµ λ → C
(6)
(3) which is a restriction of ν. (To identify Nµ λ ∼ = Vλ [µ ] we use the analogue of Lemma 8 with “highest weight” replaced by “lowest weight” throughout the proof.) Now we need to show that, with respect to the pairing (6), the 1-2 coupling bases on each side are dual (and similarly for the 2-3 bases). For this it is sufficient to prove the non-corresponding coupling basis vectors are orthogonal; the non-degeneracy of the pairing then forces the corresponding coupling basis vectors to pair up. We will show this for the 1-2 coupling (the other coupling being analogous). Write W(x,y) for the irrep. of G with Young diagram (x, y, 0). By the Pieri rules there is a unique map S p S p → W( p, p) and so we have a G-equivariant map,
S a S b S p−a S p−b → S p S p → W( p, p) .
(7)
This enables us to factor ν as follows: S a S b S c S p−a S p−b S p−c → W( p, p) S c S p−c → W( p, p) S p → D p . To see how the coupling subspaces pair up, first expand both S a S b and S p−a S p−b into sums of irreps, so S a S b S p−a S p−b becomes a sum of tensor products of the form 3 More precisely there is a unique subspace of S a S p−a which is G-equivariantly isomorphic to S p , and thus a (unique) orthogonal projection onto this subspace. To lighten the notation we will call this subspace S p here (and similarly below).
130
P. P. Boalch
W(r,s) ⊗ W(x,y) , where W(r,s) ⊂ S a S b etc., and (7) maps these to W( p, p) . However using the Littlewood–Richardson rule it is easy to see that there is a nonzero map W(r,s) ⊗ W(x,y) → W( p, p) if and only if x = p − s, y = p − r (and if so it is unique up to scale). This gives the stated correspondence between the 1-2 coupling bases (in the fifth slot of U (3) ). Remark 11. Presumably the argument above extends to the Regge symmetry of the q-deformation of the 6 j-coefficients [12]. References 1. Biedenharn, L.C., Louck, J.D.: Angular momentum in quantum physics. In: Encyclopedia of Mathematics and its Applications, Vol. 8, Reading, MA:Addison-Wesley, 1981 2. Biedenharn, L.C., Louck, J.D.: The Racah-Wigner algebra in quantum theory. In: Encyclopedia of Mathematics and its Applications, Vol. 9, Reading, MA:Addison-Wesley, 1981 3. Boalch, P.P.: Six results on Painlevé VI. SMF, Séminaires et congrès, Vol. 14, to appear, available at http://arxiv.org/abs/math/0503043, 2005 4. Boalch, P.P.: G-bundles, isomonodromy and quantum Weyl groups. Int. Math. Res. Not. no. 22, 1129–1166, (2002) 5. Boalch, P.P.: From Klein to Painlevé via Fourier, Laplace and Jimbo. Proc. London Math. Soc. 90(3), 167–208 (2005) 6. Fulton W., Harris J.: Representation theory. GTM, Vol. 129, Berlin Heidelberg-New York:Springer, 1991 7. Gliske, S., Klink, W.H., Ton-That, T.: Algorithms for computing generalized U(N ) Racah coefficients. Acta Appl. Math. 88(2), 229–249 (2005) 8. Granovski˘ı, Ya.A., Zhedanov, A.S.: Nature of the symmetry group of the 6 j-symbol. Sov. Phys. JETP 67(10), 1982–1985 (1988) 9. Hitchin, N.J.: Geometrical aspects of Schlesinger’s equation. J. Geom. Phys. 23(3–4), 287–300 (1997) 10. Inaba, M., Iwasaki, K., Saito, M.-H.: Bäcklund transformations of the sixth Painlevé equation in terms of Riemann-Hilbert correspondence. I. M. R. N. 2004(1), 1–30 (2004) 11. Jimbo, M., Miwa, T.: Monodromy preserving deformations of linear differential equations with rational coefficients II. Physica 2D, 407–448 (1981) 12. Kirillov, A.N., Yu, N.: Reshetikhin Representations of the algebra Uq (sl(2)), q-orthogonal polynomials and invariants of links. In: Adv. Ser. Math. Phys., Vol. 7, V. Kac, ed., reprinted in: Adv. Ser. Math. Phys. Vol. 11, T. Kohno, ed., Singapore:World Scientific, 1989, pp. 285–339, 202–256 resp. 13. Klink, W.H., Ton-That, T.: Calculation of Clebsch-Gordan and Racah coefficients using symbolic manipulation programs. J. Comput. Phys. 80(2), 453–471 (1989) 14. Okamoto, K.: Studies on the Painlevé equations. I. Sixth Painlevé equation PVI . Ann. Mat. Pura Appl. (4) 146, 337–381 (1987) 15. Ponzano, G., Regge, T.: Semiclassical limit of Racah coefficients. In: Spectroscopic and group theoretical methods in physics, Bloch, F. ed., NewYork: John Wiley and Sons, 1968, pp. 1–58 16. Racah, G.: Theory of complex spectra II. Phys. Rev. 62, 438–462 (1942) 17. Regge, T.: Symmetry properties of Clebsch–Gordan coefficients. Il Nuovo Cimento X, 544–545 (1958) 18. Regge, T.: Symmetry properties of Racah’s coefficients. Il Nuovo Cimento XI, 116–117 (1959) 19. Roberts, J.: Classical 6 j-symbols and the tetrahedron. Geom. Topol. 3, 21–66 (1999) (electronic) 20. Rotenberg, M., Bivins, R., Metropolis, N., Wooten, J.K.: The 3-j and 6-j symbols. London: Crosby Lockwood and Son Ltd, 1959 21. Taylor, Y., Woodward, C.: 6 j symbols for Uq (sl2 ) and non-Euclidean tetrahedra. Selecta Math. 11, 539–571 (2005) 22. Toledano Laredo, V.: A Kohno-Drinfeld theorem for quantum Weyl groups. Duke Math. J. 112(3), 421–451 (2002) 23. Wigner, E.P.: On the matrices which reduce the Kronecker products of representations of S.R. groups. (1940). Published in: Quantum theory of angular momentum L.C. Biedenharn, ed., New York: Acad. Press, 1965 24. Wilson, J.A.: Some hypergeometric orthgonal polynomials. SIAM J. Math. Anal. 11(4), 690–701 (1980) 25. Želobenko, D.P.: Compact Lie groups and their representations. A.M.S. Trans. Math. Monog. Vol. 40, Providence, RI: Amer. Math. Soc, 1973 Communicated by A. Connes
Commun. Math. Phys. 276, 131–188 (2007) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-007-0334-z
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
The Newtonian Limit for Perfect Fluids Todd A. Oliynyk Max-Planck-Institut für Gravitationsphysik, Am Mühlenberg 1, D-14476 Golm, Germany. E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 9 June 2006 / Accepted: 12 June 2007 Published online: 13 September 2007 – © Springer-Verlag 2007
Abstract: We prove that there exists a class of non-stationary solutions to the EinsteinEuler equations which have a Newtonian limit. The proof of this result is based on a symmetric hyperbolic formulation of the Einstein-Euler equations which contains a singular parameter = vT /c, where vT is a characteristic velocity scale associated with the fluid and c is the speed of light. The symmetric hyperbolic formulation allows us to derive independent energy estimates on weighted Sobolev spaces. These estimates are the main tool used to analyze the behavior of solutions in the limit 0. 1. Introduction The Einstein-Euler equations or, in other words, the Einstein equations coupled to a simple perfect fluid are given by the following system of equations: 8π G i j T , c4 = 0,
Gi j = ∇i T i j
(1.1) (1.2)
where the stress-energy tensor for the fluid is given by T i j = (ρ + c−2 p)v i v j + pg i j
(1.3)
with ρ the fluid density, p the fluid pressure, and v the fluid four-velocity normalized by v i vi = −c2 , c the speed of light, and G the Newtonian gravitational constant. The study of the behavior of solutions to these equations in the limit that = vT /c 0, where vT is a characteristic velocity scale associated with the fluid matter is known as Present address: School of Mathematical Sciences, Monash University, Clayton, Vic 3800, Australia.
132
T. A. Oliynyk
the Newtonian limit. By suitably rescaling the gravitational and matter variables (see Sect. 2), the Einstein-Euler equations can be written as G i j = 2κ 4 T i j and ∇i T i j = 0,
(1.4)
where κ = 4π GρT /vT2 , vi v i = − −2 , ρT is a characteristic value for the fluid density, and t = x 4 /vT is a “Newtonian” time coordinate. In the limit 0, one expects that there exists a class of solutions to Einstein-Euler equations (1.4) that approach solutions of the Poisson-Euler equations ∂t ρ + ∂ I (ρw I ) = 0, (I, J = 1, 2, 3) J I J J J ρ(∂t w + w ∂ I w ) = −(ρ∂ + ∂ p), (∂ I = δ I J ∂ J ) = ρ, ( = ∂ I ∂ I )
(1.5) (1.6) (1.7)
of Newtonian gravity in some sense. As above, ρ and p are the fluid density and pressure, respectively, while w I is the fluid (three) velocity. This problem has been studied since the discovery of general relativity by many people and there is a large number of results available in the literature. The majority of results are based on formal expansions in the parameter which are used to calculate the (approximate) values of physical quantities and also to investigate the behavior of the gravitational and matter fields in the limit 0. For some classic and recent results of this type see [2,3,6,9,11–13,20–22,31,41] and references cited therein. The main difficulty with the formal expansions is that they leave completely unanswered the question of convergence. In the absence of a precise notion of convergence, it becomes unclear to what extent the formal expansions actually approximate relativistic solutions. In this paper, we go beyond formal considerations and supply a precise notion of convergence for gravitating perfect fluids as 0. This necessitates introducing suitable variables that are compatible with the limit 0. The metric gi j , which defines the gravitational field, turns out to be singular in this limit. To remedy this problem, we introduce a new gravitational density u¯ i j which is related to the metric via the formula gi j = √ where Qi j =
δI J 0
IJ 4¯u 0 + 2 0 0
Qi j , − det(Q)
0 0 + 4 3 J 4 −1 u¯
(1.8)
0 u¯ I 4 + 4 4 0 0
0 . (1.9) u¯ 44
From this, it not difficult to see that the density u¯ i j is equivalent to the metric gi j for > 0 and is well defined at = 0. For the fluid, we also introduce a new velocity variable wi according to v I = w I and v 4 = 1 + w 4 .
(1.10)
For technical reasons, we only consider isentropic flow where the pressure is related to the density by an equation of state of the form p = f (ρ). Moreover, to formulate a symmetric hyperbolic system for the fluid variables {ρ, v}, we need to deal with the well known problem that the system becomes singular when ρ +c−2 p = 0. This is a particular problem for fluid balls having compact support. To get around this problem, we follow Rendall [34] and use a technique of Makino [24] to regularize the fluid equations so that
Newtonian Limit for Perfect Fluids
133
a class of gravitating fluid ball solutions can be constructed. Thus as in [34], we assume an equation of state of the form p = Kρ (n+1)/n ,
(1.11)
where K ∈ R>0 , n ∈ N, and we introduce a new “density” variable α via the formula ρ=
1 α 2n . (4K n(n + 1))n
(1.12)
As discussed by Rendall, the type of fluid solutions obtained by this method have freely falling boundaries and hence do not include static stars of finite radius and so this method is far from ideal. However, in trying to understand the Newtonian limit and post-Newtonian approximations these solutions are almost certainly general enough to obtain a comprehensive understanding of the mathematical issues involved in the Newtonian limit and post-Newtonian approximations. We would also like to remark that the results contained in this article are largely independent of the specific structure of the fluid equations. We therefore expect that the analysis in this paper can be carried over without much difficulty to other matter models whose equations can be formulated as a symmetric hyperbolic system and have a finite propagation speed for the matter density in the limit 0. Our approach to analyze the limit 0 is to use the gravitational and matter variables {¯ui j , wi , α} along with a harmonic gauge to put the Einstein-Euler equations into the following form: b0 (V )∂t V =
1 I 1 c ∂ I V + b I (, V )∂ I V + f (, V )V + g(V )V + h(),
(1.13)
where V comprises both the gravitational and matter variables, and the c I are constant matrices. This system is symmetric hyperbolic and hence by standard theory there exist local solutions. However, the difficulty in analyzing the limit 0 of such solutions is that the equation contains the singular terms −1 c I ∂ I V and −1 g(V )V . Although, singular limits of symmetric hyperbolic equations have been previously analyzed in [5, 19, 37, 38], these results cannot be directly applied to the system (1.13). There are two main difficulties in adapting these results to the Einstein-Euler system. The first is that the Einstein-Euler system (6.1) must be modified by including an elliptic equation, essentially the Newtonian Poisson equation, in order to be of the canonical form required by [5, 19, 37, 38]. This results in a coupled elliptic-hyperbolic system of the form B 0 (W )∂t W =
1 I c ∂ I W + B I (, W )∂ I W + F(, W )W + H (),
(1.14)
where W is related to V via an elliptic equation and F is a non-local functional. The second difficulty is that the initial data which must include a 1/r piece for the metric and hence it cannot lie in the Sobolev space H k . This 1/r type fall-off behavior is crucial for obtaining the correct limit and is intimately tied to the elliptic part of our formulation of the Einstein-Euler system. The standard procedure in general relativity to deal with this type of fall off, at least for elliptic systems, is to replace the spaces H k with the weighted Sobolev spaces Hδk [1, 7]. However, the arguments used in [5, 19, 37, 38] fail for the weighted spaces as the weight used to define the Hδk spaces destroys the integration by parts argument which is used to control the singular term −1 c I ∂ I W in (1.14). Indeed,
134
T. A. Oliynyk
using integration by parts, it follows easily from the definition of the weighted L 2δ innerproduct (see (A.4) with = 1) that 1 − −1 c I ∂ I W |W 2 = − ∂ I (σ −2δ−3 )c I W |W 2 , (1.15) Lδ L 2 where σ (x) = 1 + |x|2 /4. In general, this term will blow up as 0 unless δ = −3/2 which coincides with the standard L 2 norm. However, to include 1/r fall-off, we need to consider −1 < δ < 0 which introduces a singular 1/ term into energy estimates based on the weighted norm Hδk . k (see To overcome this problem, we introduce a sequence of weighted spaces Hδ, Appendix A for a definition) by replacing the weight σ (x) with σ (x) = σ (x). Under this replacement, (1.15) changes to − −1 c I ∂ I W |W 2 ≤ C W |W L 2 , L δ,
δ,
which is no longer singular as 0. This allows us to derive independent energy estimates for solutions to the Einstein-Euler equations. These estimates can then be used to define a precise notion of convergence for gravitating perfect fluids solutions in the limit 0 which is essentially a statement about the validity of the zeroth order expansion in . This is formalized in the following theorem; for a more precise version see Propositions 5.1, 6.1 and 7.8, and Theorems 7.7 and 7.12. k− Theorem 1.1. Suppose −1 < δ < −1/2, k ≥ 3 + s, β j ∈ s =0 C ([0, T ∗ ], Hδ−1 ) is k k+1 I J k I J I a harmonic gauge source function, and α , w ∈ Hδ−1 , z ∈ Hδ , z4 ∈ Hδ−1 is the o
o
free initial data for the Einstein-Euler equations where supp α ⊂ B R∗ for some R ∗ > 0. o
Then for 0 small enough, there exists a T ∈ (0, T ∗ ] independent of ∈ (0, 0 ], and maps u¯ ij (t) − u¯ ij (0), ∂ I u¯ ij (t), ∂t u¯ (t), α (t), wi (t) ∈
s+1
=0
k− C ([0, T ], Hδ−1, ),
∈ C ([0, T ], Hδk+2 ) ∩ C 1 ([0, T ∗ ], Hδk+1 ), k−1 k ) ∩ C 1 ([0, T ∗ ], Hδ−1 ), w I ∈ C 0 ([0, T ∗ ], Hδ−1 k−1 0 ∗ k 1 ∗ ρ ∈ C ([0, T ], Hδ−1 ) ∩ C ([0, T ], Hδ−2 ), 0
∗
such that (i) IJ z wI , wJ φ −∂ K z K I + β I (0) z4I J , (∂t u¯ ij (0)) = −∂ K z K J + β J (0) −∂ K wK + β 4 − g¯ 4J w J − 2 (g¯ 4J w J )2 − g¯ 44 ( 2 g¯ I J w I w J +1) 1 o o o o w4 (0) = − + , g¯ 44 (¯uij (0)) =
Newtonian Limit for Perfect Fluids
135
wI (0) = w I (0) = w , o
α (0) = α , o
ρ(0) = ρ = (4K n(n + 1))−n α 2n , o
o
where φ = φ(, ρ , w I , z4I J , β j (0), z I J ), and w = w(, ρ , w I , z4I J , β j (0), z I J ) o
(ii)
(iii) (iv) (v)
o
o
o
is the initial data determined by the gravitational constraint equations (see ij Proposition 5.1), and g¯ i j is determined from u¯ (0) by the formulas (1.8) and (3.1), ij I {¯u (x , t), α (x I , t), wi (x I , t)} determines, via the formulas (1.8), (1.9), (1.10), and (1.12), a 1-parameter family (0 < ≤ 0 ) of solutions to the Einstein-Euler 4j Ij equations (1.4) in the harmonic gauge ∂t u¯ + ∂ I u¯ = β j on the common spacetime region (x I , t) ∈ D = R3 × [0, T ], {(x I , t), ρ(x I , t), w I (x I , t)} solves the Euler-Poisson equations (1.5)–(1.7) on the spacetime region D, there exists a constant R ∈ (R ∗ , ∞) independent of ∈ (0, 0 ] such that supp α (t), supp ρ(t) ⊂ B R for all (t, ) ∈ [0, T ] × (0, 0 ], and there exists a constant C > 0 independent of ∈ (0, 0 ] such that j
¯uij (t) − δ4i δ4i (t) L 6 + ∂ I u¯ ij (t) − δ4i δ4 ∂ I (t) H k−1 + v I (t) − w I (t) H k−1 + −1 v 4 (t) − 1 H k−1 + ρ (t) − ρ(t) H k−1 + ∂t ρ (t) − ∂t ρ(t) H k−2 ≤ C
for all (t, ) ∈ [0, T ∗ ] × (0, 0 ]. We remark that the techniques of this paper can also be used to derive convergent expansions in of the type considered in Theorems 2 and 3 of [19] and [38], respectively. These convergent expansions in general differ from the formal post-Newtonian expansions. To get post-Newtonian expansion to a certain order in requires that the initial data must be chosen correctly. In the absence of constraints on the initial data, a general procedure for doing this is discussed in [5]. Due to the fact that there are constraints on the initial data in general relativity, this becomes a non-trivial problem called the initialization problem. See [18] for an extended discussion. The proof of convergence and a discussion of the initialization problem will be presented in a separate paper [27]. We note that similar results for the Vlasov-Einstein system have been derived in [36] using a zero shift maximal slicing gauge. However, unlike [36], our approach is able to handle not only higher order expansions in , but also a wide variety of matter models. We also note that in [16,18], there is another interesting proposal for analyzing the limit as 0 which is based on a gauge for which the Einstein equations are again elliptichyperbolic but distinct from [36]. As in this article, the authors of [16, 18] also propose to use the methods of [5,19,37,38]. However, the required estimates are not proven and it is yet to be verified if this approach would be successful. We remark that the results of this and the companion paper [27] are local in time and therefore address the “near zone” problem. In the special case of spherical symmetry, the situation improves and there are some global results available on the Newtonian limit [26,32]. However, because spherically symmetric systems do not generate gravitational radiation, these results do not shed light on the “far zone” problem for post-Newtonian expansions where radiation plays a crucial role and the 0 limit must be analyzed in the region “close” to future null infinity. We plan to investigate the far zone problem in the near future.
136
T. A. Oliynyk
Our paper is organized as follows: in Sect. 2, we define dimensionless variables for the Einstein-Euler system. Sections 3 and 4 are devoted to introducing variables and a gauge condition that cast the Einstein-Euler equations into a form suitable for analyzing the limit 0. Appropriate initial data which is regular in the limit 0 is constructed in Sect. 5 while in Sect. 6 we prove a local existence theorem for the Einstein-Euler system on the weighted spaces. Finally, in Sect. 7, we show that solutions to the Einstein-Euler system converge as 0 to solutions of the Poisson-Euler system of Newtonian gravity. A precise statement of convergence is contained in Theorem 7.12 which is the main result of this paper. 2. Units Our conventions for units are as follows: L3 M M L i , and [G] = , [ p] = , [v ] = [c] = . L3 LT 2 T MT 2 Note that with these choices the stress-energy tensor has units of an energy density, i.e. [T i j ] = LMT 2 . To introduce dimensionless variables, we define
[x i ] = L , [gi j ] = 1, [ρ] =
ˆ v i = vT vˆ i and ρ = ρT ρ, where vT and ρT are “typical” values for the velocity and the density, respectively. The Einstein-Euler equations then can be written as Gˆ i j = 2κ 4 Tˆ i j and ∇ˆ i Tˆ i j = 0, where =
√ vT 4π GρT , κ= , xˆ i = κ x i , gˆ i j = gi j , 2 c vT
pˆ =
p vT2 ρT
,
and Tˆ i j = (ρˆ + 2 p) ˆ vˆ i vˆ j + pˆ gˆ i j . The normalization vi v i = −c2 , implies that vˆ i vˆ i := gˆ i j vˆ i vˆ j = −
1 . 2
Also, we can introduce a time coordinate t via t = x 4 /vT . With these choices, we have 1 L , [t] = [T ], and [κ] = 2 . T L Thus all our dynamical variables and coordinates are dimensionless and the two constants vT and κ can be used to fix the length and time scales by using units so that
[] = [vˆ i ] = [ρ] ˆ = [ p] ˆ = [g] ˆ = [xˆ i ] = 1, [vT ] =
vT = 1 and κ = 1. In this case we can use t and x 4 interchangeably as long as we remember that they carry different units. To simplify notation, we will drop the “hats” from the hatted variables for the remainder of this article.
Newtonian Limit for Perfect Fluids
137
3. Reduced Einstein Equations To aid in deriving the appropriate symmetric hyperbolic system for the gravitational variables, we temporarily introduce a new set of coordinates related to old ones by the simple rescaling x¯ J = x J , x¯ 4 = x 4 / and let ∂i =
∂ ∂ , ∂¯i = i . ∂ xi ∂ x¯
In the new coordinates, the metric g¯ i j and its inverse g¯ i j are given by IJ gI J g I 4 g −1 g I 4 ij ) = (g¯ i j ) = and ( g ¯ . g4J 2 g44 −1 g 4J −2 g 44 Next, consider the metric density ¯ g¯ i j where |g| ¯ = − det(g¯ i j ). g¯ i j = |g|
(3.1)
(3.2)
We note that the metric g¯ i j is related to the density g¯ i j by the following formula: 1 ¯ = − det g¯ i j , g¯ i j = √ g¯ i j where |g| |g| ¯ and hence
IJ 1 g¯ (g ) = √ g¯ 4J |g| ¯ ij
g¯ I 4 . 2 g¯ 44
(3.3)
(3.4)
To obtain a gravitational variable that is regular and non-trivial in the limit 0, we define
1 u¯ i j = 2 g¯ i j − ηi j , (3.5) 4 where
1I 3×3 η = 0 ij
0 −1
is the Minkowski metric density. As stated in the introduction, for > 0, the metric gi j can be recovered from the density u¯ i j via the formulas (1.8)–(1.9). As we shall see, even though the metric gi j is singular in the limit 0, the quantity u¯ i j is well defined at = 0. We note that these variables are closely related to the gravitational variables discovered by Jürgen Ehlers and subsequently used in the papers [17,28,29] to construct stationary/static solutions to the Einstein equations coupled to various matter sources. In the (x¯ i ) coordinate system, the Christofell symbols are given by
¯ ikj = 2 g¯ km (2¯gi g¯ j p − g¯ i j g¯ p )∂¯m u¯ p + 2(¯g p δ(ik ∂¯ j) u¯ p − 2¯g (i ∂¯ j) u¯ k ) . (3.6)
138
T. A. Oliynyk
We note that Christofell symbols in the (x i ) coordinate system are related to the ¯ ikj as follows: A A 4 44 = −2 ¯ 44 , 44 = −1 ¯ 444 , 4A4 = ¯ 4A4 , A A A A = −1 ¯ B4 and BC = ¯ BC . 4AB = 4AB , B4
(3.7) (3.8)
Using (3.6), a straightforward calculation shows that the Einstein tensor G¯ i j is given in terms of the density u¯ i j by
1 2 ij G i j := 2 |g| ¯ G¯ i j = g¯ k ∂¯k (3.9) u¯ + 2 Ai j + B i j + C i j + D i j , 2 where |g| ¯ = − det(¯gi j ),
Ai j = 2 21 g¯ k g¯ mn − g¯ km g¯ n g¯ i p g¯ jq − 21 g¯ i j g¯ pq ∂¯ p u¯ k ∂¯q u¯ mn ,
B i j = 4¯gk 2¯gn(i ∂¯m u¯ j) ∂¯n u¯ km − 21 g¯ i j ∂¯m u¯ kn ∂¯n u¯ m − g¯ mn ∂¯m u¯ ik ∂¯n u¯ j ,
C i j = 4 ∂¯k u¯ i j ∂ u¯ k − ∂¯k u¯ i ∂¯ u¯ jk , 2 k 2 k(i j) D i j := g¯ i j ∂¯k u¯ − 2∂¯k u¯ g¯ .
(3.10) (3.11) (3.12) (3.13) (3.14)
To fix the gauge, we assume that ∂¯i u¯ i j = β j
(3.15)
for prescribed spacetime functions β j = β j (x I , x 4 ). For > 0, ∂¯i u¯ i j = β j implies that ∂¯i g¯ i j = 4 3 β j or equivalently ∂k gk4 = 4 3 β 4 and ∂k gk A = 4 2 β A ,
√ where gi j = − det(gk )g i j is the metric density in the (x k ) coordinates. Thus (3.15) is, for > 0, a generalized harmonic type gauge and is harmonic if the functions β j are chosen to be identically zero. Clearly, if we define E i j := g¯ i j ∂¯k β k − 2∂¯k β (i g¯ j)k , then (3.15) implies that Di j = E i j . Setting
ij 2 ij u¯ + E i j + 2 Ai j + B i j + C i j G R := G i j − D i j + E i j = g¯ k ∂¯k
and T i j := 2 |g| ¯ T¯ i j = |g| ¯
2 IJ T 1 T 4J
1T I 4 T 44
(3.16)
Newtonian Limit for Perfect Fluids
139
the Einstein equations G i j = 2 4 T i j in the gauge (3.15) become ij
GR = T i j ,
(3.17)
which we will refer to as the reduced Einstein equations. To write the reduced Einstein equations in first order form, we introduce the variables
if k = I ∂ I u¯ i j ij . u¯ k := ∂¯k u¯ i j = ∂4 u¯ i j if k = 4 The reduced Einstein equations then become
ij ij ij −¯g44 ∂¯4 u¯ 4 = g¯ 4I ∂¯ I u¯ 4 + g¯ I J ∂¯ I u¯ J + E i j + 2 Ai j + B i j + C i j − T i j , g¯ I J ∂¯4 u¯ J = g¯ I J ∂¯ J u¯ 4 , ij
ij
ij ∂¯4 u¯ i j = u¯ 4 ,
or equivalently
1 1 4I 1 ij ij g¯ ∂ I u¯ 4 + g¯ I J ∂ I u¯ J + E i j + Ai j + B i j + C i j − T i j , 1 IJ ij ij IJ g¯ ∂4 u¯ J = g¯ ∂ J u¯ 4 , 1 ij ∂4 u¯ i j = u¯ 4 . Next, define ij
−¯g44 ∂4 u¯ 4 =
ui j := u¯ i j and let
ij
ij
uk := u¯ k ,
(3.18)
V = (r i j ) ∈ M4×4 | det(ηi j + 4r i j ) > 0 .
Then using vector notation
T ij ij ui j := u4 , u J , ui j , we can write the reduced Einstein equations as A4 (u)∂4 ui j = where
1 I 1 C ∂ I ui j + A I (u)∂ I ui j + F¯ i j (, u) − (T i j , 0, 0)T ,
⎛ 0 1 − 4u44 4 ⎝ A (u) = 0 δ I J + 4u I J 0 0 ⎛ ⎞ I J 0 0 δ C I = ⎝δ I J 0 0⎠ , 0 0 0 ⎛ 4I ⎞ I J 4u 4u 0 A I (u) = ⎝4u I J 0 0⎠ , 0 0 0
⎞ 0 0⎠ , 1
(3.19)
(3.20)
(3.21)
(3.22)
140
T. A. Oliynyk
and ij F¯ i j (, u) = (E i j + f¯i j (u, uk ), 0, u4 )T .
(3.23)
The functions f¯i j (u, uk ) are analytic for u ∈ V and moreover are quadratic in uk . Here we are using the notation ij
u = (ui j ) and uk = (uk ). The stress-energy tensor is given in terms of the u variable by IJ IJ 1 δ p0 4u p 0 +√ (T i j ) = ρ(v i v j ) + √ 0 0 0 0 |g| ¯ |g| ¯ I 4 p 0 4u , + 2 p(v i v j ) + √ |g| ¯ 4u4J −1 + 4u44 and hence
where
1 ij 0 (T ) = 0
0
−1 ρ
(3.24)
+ Si j ,
(3.25)
0 |g|v ¯ I v4 ¯ − 1)(v 4 )2 + ((v 4 )2 − 1) |g|v ¯ J v 4 −1 (|g| (ρ + 2 p)v I v J +|g| ¯ −1/2 p(δ I J +4u I J ) pv I v 4 +4|g| ¯ −1/2 pu I 4 +|g| ¯ . pv J v 4 +4|g| ¯ −1/2 pu4J p(v 4 )2 +|g| ¯ −1/2 p(−1+4u44 ) (3.26)
(S i j ) = ρ
We remark that if v 4 − 1 = O(), then S i j is regular in as is easily seen from the above formula and the expansion |g| ¯ = 1 + 4ηi j ui j + f (u),
(3.27)
where f (u) is analytic for u ∈ V and also satisfies f (y) = O(|y|2 ) as y → 0. 4. Regularized Euler Equations There are various approaches to symmetric hyperbolic formulations of the relativistic Euler equations [4, 14, 15, 34, 40]. We use the approach of [4] which is based on fluid projection and the introduction of a Makino variable. In the coordinates (x¯ i ), the Euler equations are given by ∇¯ i T¯ i j = 0,
(4.1)
where T¯ i j = (ρ + 2 p)v¯ i v¯ j + p g¯ i j and the fluid velocity v¯ i is normalized according to 1 . 2
(4.2)
v¯ i ∇¯ j v¯ i = 0
(4.3)
v¯ i v¯ i = − Differentiating (4.2) yields
Newtonian Limit for Perfect Fluids
141
which implies v¯ j v¯ i ∇¯ j v¯ i = 0.
(4.4)
Writing out (4.1) explicitly, we have (∂¯i ρ + 2 ∂¯i p)v¯ i v¯ j + (ρ + 2 p)(v¯ j ∇¯ i v¯ i + v¯ i ∇¯ i v¯ j ) + g¯ i j ∂¯i p = 0.
(4.5)
The operator j
j
L i = δi + 2 v¯ j v¯ i j
j
j
projects into subspace orthogonal to the fluid velocity v¯ i , i.e. L i L ik = L k and L i v¯ i = 0. j Using L k to project the Euler equations (4.5) into components parallel and orthogonal to v¯ i yields, after using the relations (4.2)–(4.4), the following system: v¯ i ∂¯i ρ + (ρ + 2 p)L ij ∇¯ i v¯ j = 0,
(4.6)
1 L i ∂¯i p = 0, ρ + 2 p j
(4.7)
Mi j v¯ k ∇¯ k v¯ j + where
Mi j = g¯ i j + 2 2 v¯ i v¯ j . As discussed in the introduction, we introduce a new density variable α via the formula (1.12). Multiplying (4.6) by the square of the function 1 h(α) = 1 + (α)2 , 4n(n + 1) gives dα i ¯ j L ∇ i v¯ = 0, dρ j s 2 dp j ¯ L ∂ j α = 0, Mi j v¯ k ∇¯ k v¯ j + ρ + 2 p dα i
h 2 v¯ i ∂¯i α + h 2 (ρ + 2 p)
where s2 =
1 dp = 2 α2 dρ 4n
is the square of the speed of sound. A simple calculation shows that dα s 2 dp = h 2 (ρ + 2 p) = q, 2 ρ + p dα dρ where q = q(, α) =
1 α. 2nh(α)
(4.8) (4.9)
142
T. A. Oliynyk
This shows that the system (4.8)–(4.9) is symmetric, and moreover at a point where α = 0 and hence p = ρ = 0, it is regular unlike (4.6)–(4.7). This is the point of introducing the Makino variable α. Also note that the pressure is given in terms of the Makino variable by p=
K α 2n+2 . (4K n(n + 1))n+1
(4.10)
Define w I := v¯ I , and w 4 := v¯ 4 −
1
so that v I = w I , and v 4 = 1 + w 4 .
(4.11)
Using vector notation w = (α, wi )T , we can write (4.8) and (4.9) as a 4 ∂4 w = a I ∂ I w + b, where
q L 4j h 2 (1 + w 4 ) , q L i4 Mi j (1 + w 4 ) −h 2 w I −q L Ij I a = , −q L Ij −Mi j w I
a4 =
and
(4.12)
(4.13) (4.14)
j −q L ij ¯ i v¯ b= . j −Mi j ¯ v¯ k v¯
(4.15)
k
From (3.3), (3.5), (3.18), and (3.27), we find that g¯ i j = ηi j + f i j (u),
(4.16)
where the f i j (y) are analytic and satisfy f i j (y) = O(|y|) as y → 0. Also, (3.6) shows that
lp
p ¯ ikj = ηkm 2ηi η j p − ηi j η p um + 2 η p δ(ik u j) − 2η (i uk + f ikj (u, um ) j) (4.17) for functions f ikj (u, um ) that are analytic for u ∈ V, linear in the um , and satisfy f ikj (0, y) = 0. So then Mi j = g¯ i j + 2 2 g¯ ik g¯ j v¯ k v¯ = δi j + m i j (u, w k )
(4.18)
Newtonian Limit for Perfect Fluids
143
and j
j
j
j
j
L i = δi + 2 g¯ ik v¯ k v¯ j = δi − δi4 δ4 + i (u, w k ), j
(4.19)
j
where i (u, w k ) and m i j (u, w k ) are analytic for u ∈ V and i (0, 0) = m i j (0, 0) = 0. Using (4.16)–(4.19), the matrices a i and the vector b can be written as 1 0 (4.20) a4 = + aˆ 4 (u, w), 0 δi j α I −w I − 2n δj aI = ˆ w) + α aˆ I (u, w), (4.21) + w I a(u, α I − 2n δi −δi j w I and
0 α bˆ 1 (u, w) · uk
. b= + lp
p −ηim 2η4 η4 p + η p um − 2 η p δ4i u4 − 2η 4 ui bˆ 2 (u, w) · uk 4 (4.22) Note that (i) aˆ 4 , a, ˆ aˆ I , bˆ 1 , and bˆ 2 are analytic in all their variables provided that u ∈ V, 4 I (ii) aˆ , aˆ and aˆ are symmetric, and (iii) aˆ 4 (0, 0) = 0, aˆ I (0, 0) = 0, a(0, ˆ 0) = 0, bˆ 1 (0, 0) = 0, and bˆ 2 (0, 0) = 0. Consequently the system (4.12) is symmetric hyperbolic on a region where (u, w) is small enough to ensure that a 4 is positive definite. This can always be arranged by taking small enough and since we are interested in the limit 0 no generality is lost in assuming this. It is important to realize that the derivation above of (4.12) required that both the Euler equations (4.1) and the fluid velocity normalization (4.2) are satisfied. Alternatively, we can first assume that (4.12) is satisfied and then show that (4.1) and (4.2) are also satisfied. To see this, define N := v¯ i v¯ i + 1/ = g¯ 44 (1/ +w 4 )2 + 1/ +2g¯ 4J (1 + w 4 )w J + g¯ I J w I w J . (4.23) Clearly, N = 0 is equivalent to v¯ i v¯ i = −1/ 2 for > 0. Furthermore, any solution of (4.12) also solves (4.6)–(4.7) for any > 0. So assuming that v¯ is a solution to the system (4.6)–(4.7), contracting (4.7) with v¯ i yields (1 + 2 2 v¯ i v¯ i )v¯ k ∂¯k (v¯ i v¯ i ) = 0. For (2N − 1) = 0, this implies (1 + w 4 )∂4 N = −w I ∂ I N .
(4.24)
Clearly, this is a symmetric hyperbolic equation for N whenever 0 < 1/C ≤ (1+w4 ) ≤ C for some constant C. This can always be arranged at x 4 = 0 by choosing small enough. Therefore, if initially N x 4 =0 = 0, then N = 0 for as long as (1 + w 4 ) stays absolutely bounded and bounded away from zero. Consequently, choosing initial data for the system (4.12) such that N x 4 =0 = 0 will guarantee that the solution will satisfy the full Euler equations (4.5) in an open neighborhood of the hypersurface x 4 = 0. In particular, if {α, wi } is a solution to (4.12) with initial data satisfying N |x 4 =0 , then α is a solution to the equation ∂4 α + X I ∂ I α + Y α = 0,
(4.25)
144
T. A. Oliynyk
where X I :=
wI , 1 + w 4
and
Y :=
∇¯ i v¯ i . 2n(1 + w 4 )h 3 (α)
(4.26)
Observe that Y = Y¯ (w 4 , α)(∂t w 4 + ∂ I w I ) + Yˆ (u, w 4 , uk , w I , ), where Y¯ (0, 0) − 1/(2n) = 0, Yˆ (0, . . . , 0) = 0 and Y¯ (w 4 , α 4 ), Yˆ (u, w 4 , uk , w I , α 4 ) are analytic on the region u ∈ V and 1 + w 4 > 0. 5. Newtonian Initial Data Let S0 ∼ = R3 be the hypersurface defined by S0 := {(x I , 0) | (x I ) ∈ R3 }. The covector 4 n i = δi is conormal to S0 implying that constraint equations for the initial data on S0 are given by n i G i j = 2κ 4 n i T i j . Defining C J := −1 (G 4J − κT 4J ) and C 4 := G 44 − κT 44 , we find that C j = 0 is equivalent to n i G i j = 2κ 4 n i T i j for > 0. Also, by defining H j := ∂¯i u¯ i j − β j ,
(5.1)
= 0. the generalized harmonic gauge (3.15) can be written as As will be seen in the proof of the next proposition the equations C j = 0 are regular at = 0. So to find appropriate initial data that is well defined at = 0, we solve the regularized constraint equations C j = 0. Moreover, we must also ensure that the harmonic gauge condition H j = 0 and the fluid normalization N = 0 are satisfied. To solve the constraints C j = 0, H j = 0, and N = 0, we use a implicit function technique based on the work of Lottermoser [23]. We assume that the fluid velocity can be written as (4.10) which is consistent with the expected behavior of the fluid velocity as 0. We will not assume that the density and pressure are related by the equation of state (1.11). Instead, we will consider them as independent prescribed fields for the purpose of finding solutions to the constraint equations. We do this so that the following proposition remains valid for other equations of state. Hj
Proposition 5.1. Suppose −1 < δ < 0, k > 3/2, R > 0 and (ρ, ˜ p, ˜ w˜ I , z˜4I J , β˜ j , z˜ I J ) ∈ k−2 2 k−1 2 k k (Hδ−2 ) × Hδ−1 × (Hδ−1 ) × B R (Hδ ). Then there exists an 0 > 0, an open neighk : borhood U of (ρ, ˜ p, ˜ w˜ I , z˜4I J , β˜ j , z˜ I J ), and analytic maps (−0 , 0 ) × U → Hδ−1 I J k I J I j I J 4 I j (, ρ, p, w , z4 , β , z )→ w , (−0 , 0 )×U → Hδ : (, ρ, p, w , z4 , β , z I J )→ φ, (−0 , 0 ) × U → Hδk : (, ρ, p, w I , z4I J , β j , z I J ) → w I such that for each ij (ρ, p, w I , z4I J , β j , z I J ) ∈ U , (, ρ, p, w I , w 4 , u¯ 4 , β j , ∂¯4 u¯ i j ) is a solution to the three constraints C j = 0, H j = 0, and where (¯ui j ) = (∂t u¯ i j ) =
IJ z w J
N = 0,
w I , φ
z4I J −∂ K z K J + β J
(5.2)
(5.3) −∂ K z K I + β I −∂ K w K + β 4
(t = x 4 ),
(5.4)
Newtonian Limit for Perfect Fluids
145
and 1 − g¯ 4J w J − w =− + 4
2 (g¯ 4J w J )2 − g¯ 44 ( 2 g¯ I J w I w J + 1) . g¯ 44
(5.5)
Moreover, if we let φ0 = φ|=0 , w0I = w I |=0 , and w04 = w 4 |=0 , then φ0 , w0I , and w04 satisfy the equations φ0 = κρ, w0I = ∂ I β 4 − ∂ L z4L I + κρw I , and w04 = 0, respectively. Proof. Let u¯ 44 = φ, u¯ I J = z I J , u¯ I 4 = w I , and ∂¯4 u¯ I J = z4I J . Solving H j S = 0 0 yields
and ∂¯4 u¯ 4J = (−∂ I z I J + β J ), ∂¯4 u¯ 44 = −∂ I w I + β 4 (5.6) while solving N S = 0 gives 0
1 − g¯ 4J w J − w =− + 4
2 (g¯ 4J w J )2 − g¯ 44 ( 2 g¯ I J w I w J + 1) . g¯ 44
(5.7)
From (3.3) and (3.5), it is not difficult to verify that w 4 = −1 f (w I , 3 z, 3 w, 2 φ), where f (y) (y = (y1 , . . . , y4 )) is analytic in a neighborhood of (0, 0, 0, 0) and moreover f (y) = O(|y|2 ) as y → 0. Using the relation (5.6) to eliminate ∂¯4 u¯ 44 and ∂¯4 u¯ 4J in favour of w I and z I J , we find that 2 44 g¯ k ∂¯k u¯ + D 44 = φ − ∂ K2 L z K L + 4 2 h 4 ,
2 4J g¯ k ∂¯k u¯ + D 4J = w J − ∂ J β 4 + ∂ L z4L J + 4h J ,
where h 4 = z K L ∂ K L φ + φ∂ K2 L z K L − 2 2 w L ∂ K2 L w K , h J = 2 z K L ∂ K2 L w J + 2 w J ∂ K2 L z K L − 2 w L ∂ K2 L z K J − φ∂k z4K J − 2 z J L ∂ L β 4 . Using this and Eqs. (3.9), (3.10)–(3.14), (3.24)–(3.26), and (4.10)–(4.11), we see that C I = w J + ∂ L z4L J + h J + f I ( 3 z, 3 w, 2 φ, Dz, Dw, Dφ, z4 , (−∂k w I + β 4 ), (−∂ K ζ K L + β L )) − κ S 4I ,
(5.8)
and C 4 = φ − κρ − κ(2w 4 + (w 4 )2 )ρ − ∂ K2 L z K L + 4 2 h 4 + 2 f 4 ( 3 z, 3 w, 2 φ, Dz, Dw, Dφ, z4 , (−∂k w I + β 4 ), (−∂ K ζ K L + β L )) − κ S 44 ,
(5.9)
146
T. A. Oliynyk
where the functions f I (y) (y = (y1 , . . . , y9 )) are analytic in a neighborhood of {(0, 0, 0)} × U , where U is any open set and are quadratic in (y4 , . . . , y9 ). Note that S 44 = ρ S14 (, w I , 2 z, 2 w, φ) + pS14 (, w I , 2 z, 2 w, φ) and S 4I = ρw I + ρ S1I (, w I , 2 z, 2 w, φ) + pS2I (, w I , 2 z, 2 w, φ), where the functions S j (y) (y = (y1 , . . . , y7 )) are analytic in a neighborhood of U × {(0, 0, 0)} for any open set U . Using Lemma A.8 and Proposition 3.6 of [17], we see from the above considerations that for any R > 0 there exists an 0 > 0 such that the maps k ) × B R (Hδk )3 −→ Hδk : (, w I , z, w, φ) −→ w4 (−0 , 0 ) × B R (Hδ−1
and k−2 2 k−1 2 k ) × B R (Hδ−1 ) × (Hδ−1 ) × B R (Hδk )3 (−0 , 0 ) × (Hδ−2 k−2 −→ Hδ−2 : (, ρ, p, w I , z4 , β, z, w, φ) −→ C j
are analytic. Since C I |=0 = w I − ∂ I β 4 + ∂ L z4L I − κρw I ,
C 4 |=0 = φ − κρ
(5.10)
k−2 is an isomorphism (see [1], and for −1 < δ < 0 the Laplacian : Hδk → Hδ−2 Proposition 2.2), we can use the analytic version of the implicit function theorem (see [10] Theorem 15.3) to conclude, shrinking 0 if necessary, that there exists an open k−2 2 k ) × (H k−1 )2 × B (H k ) and neighborhood U of any point in (Hδ−2 ) × B R (Hδ−1 R δ δ−1 analytic maps
(−0 , 0 ) × U −→ Hδk : (, ρ, p, w I , z4 , β, z) −→ φ and (−0 , 0 ) × U −→ Hδk : (, ρ, p, w I , z4 , β, z) −→ z such that the constraints are satisfied, i.e. C j (, ρ, p, w I , z4 , β, z, w(, ρ, p, w I , z4 , z), φ(, ρ, p, w I , z4 , z)) = 0 for all (, ρ, p, w I , z4 , β, z) ∈ (−0 , 0 ) × U .
Newtonian Limit for Perfect Fluids
147
6. Local Existence for the Einstein-Euler System The combined systems (3.19) and (4.12) can be written as b0 (U, V )∂t V =
1 I c ∂ I V + b I (, U, V )∂ I V + f (, U, V )V 1 (t = x 4 ), + g(V )V + h
(6.1)
where U := (0, 0, ui j , 0, 0)T , V :=
ui j o o ij ij ij i T (u4 , u J , δu , α, w ) ,
:= ui j |t=0 = u¯ i j |t=0 ,
δui j := ui j − ui j , o 0 , a 4 (u, wi , α)
(6.3)
A4 (u) 0 I C 0 c I := , 0 0 I 0 A (u) , b I (, U, V ) := 0 a I (, u, wi , α) ⎛ ij ⎞ f¯ (u, uk ) − S i j + 4δui j ∂¯k β k − 8 ∂¯k β (i δu j)k ⎜ ⎟ 0 ⎟, f (, U, V )V := ⎜ ij ⎝ ⎠ u4 i b(, u, uk , w , α) b0 (U, V ) :=
j
g(V )V := (−δ4i δ4 ρ(α), 0, . . . , 0)T , and h :=
4ui j ∂¯k β k − 8 ∂¯k β (i u j)k + ηi j ∂¯k β k − 2∂¯k β (i η j)k o
o
0
(6.2)
(6.4) (6.5) (6.6)
(6.7)
(6.8)
.
(6.9)
For initial data, we will use the following notation: given a function z that depends on time t, we define z := z|t=0 . o
To fix a region on which the system (6.1) is well defined, we note from (3.20), (4.20), and the invertibility of the Lorentz metric (ηi j ) that there exists a constant K 0 > 0 such that − det(ηi j + 4ui j ) > 1/16, 1 + w 4 > 1/16, 1 1 A4 (u) ≥ 1I , a 4 (u, w, α) ≥ 1I 16 16
(6.10) (6.11)
and |A4 (u)| ≤ 16, |a 4 (u, w, α)| ≤ 16
(6.12)
for all |u| ≤ 2K 0 , |wi | ≤ 2K 0 , |α| ≤ 2K 0 . The choice of the bounds 1/16 and 16 is somewhat arbitrary and they can be replaced by any number of the form 1/M and M for
148
T. A. Oliynyk
any M > 1 without changing any of the arguments presented in the following sections. However, since we are interested in the limit 0, we lose nothing by assuming M = 16. k , z I J ∈ H k+1 , z I J ∈ Proposition 6.1. Suppose −1 < δ < 0, k ≥ 3 + s, α , w I ∈ Hδ−1 δ 4 o
o
ij
ij
k , β j ∈ C 1 ([−T, T ], H k ). Let u ¯ , ∂t u¯ and w 4 be the initial data constructed in Hδ−1 δ−1 o
o
o
Proposition 5.1 which, by choosing 0 ≤ 1 small enough, satisfies |wi |, |α |, | u¯ ij | ≤ K 0 for all ∈ (0, 0 ]. o
o
o
Then (i) for each ∈ (0, 0 ], there exists T1 (), T2 () > 0 and a unique solution s+1
V ∈
=0
k− C ((−T1 (), T2 ()), Hδ−1 )
to the system (6.1) with initial data V = (∂t u¯ ij , ∂ J u¯ ij , 0, α , wi ). o
o
o
o
o
(ii) The identities ij
∂t u¯ ij =
u4,
ij
, and u J, = ∂ J u¯ ij
hold where by definition u¯ = −1 u , u = u + δu , and u = u¯ . ij
ij
ij
ij
o
o
o
ij
(iii) The triple {¯u , wi , α } determines, via the formulas (1.12), (3.4), (3.5), and (4.11), a solution to the full Einstein-Euler system (1.1)–(1.2) that satisfies the constraints ∂t u¯ 4 j + ∂ I u¯ I j = β j and v i vi = −
1 . 2
(iv) For some constant C > 0 independent of , the initial data V satisfies the estimate o
V − V 0 H k o
o
δ−1,
≤ C V − V 0 H k o
o
δ−1
≤ C
while
∂t V (0) H k−1 ≤ ∂t V (0) H k−1 ≤ C δ−1,
δ−1
for all ∈ (0, 0 ]. (v) If sup0≤t
T2 () such that the solution V can be continued to the interval (−T1 (), T∗ ). Proof.
(i) Follows directly from Theorem B.5, Proposition B.6, and Corollary B.7, where we use the initial data from Proposition 5.1. (ii) This follows from standard arguments on reductions of 2nd order hyperbolic equations to 1st order symmetric hyperbolic systems. See [39], Sect. 16.3 for details.
Newtonian Limit for Perfect Fluids
149 ij
(iii) By part (ii), the triplet {¯u , wi , α } satisfies the reduced Einstein equations (3.17) ij and the fluid equations (4.12). By construction, {¯u |t=0 , wi |t=0 , α |t=0 } satisfies the constraints N |t=0 = 0, H j |t=0 = 0, and (G 4i − T 4i )|t=0 = 0. The reduced Einstein equations (3.17) can be written in terms of the Einstein density G i j as G i j − g¯ i j ∂¯k Hk + 2∂¯k H(i g¯ j)k = T i j . Using (G 4i − T 4i )|t=0 = 0, we see that
−¯g4 j ∂¯k Hk + 2∂¯k H(4 g¯ j)k
t=0
= 0.
(6.13)
A straightforward calculation then shows that this implies that ∂t H j |t=0 = 0. As discussed in Sects. 4 (see (4.24)), N satisfies a linear symmetric hyperbolic system and hence by uniqueness, it follows that N = 0 for all (x I , t) ∈ R3 × (−T1 (), T2 (). Thus {wi , α } determine a solution, via the formulas (4.11), to the Euler equation which are equivalent to ∇¯ i T i j = 0. So taking the divergence of (6.13) while using ∇¯ i T i j = ∇¯ i G i j = 0 shows that H j satisfies an equation of the form g¯ ik ∂¯ik H j + Q q (¯g, ∂¯k g¯ )∂¯ p Hq = 0, j
jp
jp where the Q q are analytic in g¯ and ∂¯k g¯ . Clearly, this is a linear, 2nd order hyperbolic equation for H j . Since H j |t=0 = ∂t H j |t=0 = 0, we must have H j = 0 for all (x I , t) ∈ R3 × (−T1 (), T2 ()). k (iv) We know from Proposition 5.1 that the map (0, 0 ] → V ∈ Hδ−1, is analytic o
which implies the estimate V − V 0 H k ≤ C for some fixed constant C > 0. δ−1 o o So then
V − V 0 H k o
o
≤ V − V 0 H k
δ−1,
o
o
δ−1
≤ C
by Lemma A.11. Since {¯u , wi , α } solves the reduced Einstein equations (3.17), we have that ¯ ¯ I j + 8 2 ∂ L ∂¯4 u¯ I j + g¯ K L ∂ K2 L u¯ I j + 2 f I j ( 2 u¯ , ∂¯4 u¯ , ∂ L u¯ ) g¯ 44 ∂t ∂ 4 u = 2 S I j ( 2 u¯ , α , wi ), where the f I J are analytic and quadratic in ∂4 u¯ and ∂k u¯ while S I J are also analytic and linear in α and wi . Evaluating this equation at t = 0, and using the following facts from Proposition 5.1, ¯ i j H k −1 ¯uI j H k+1 + ¯u44 H k+1 + ∂t u o
δ
o
δ
δ−1
o
+ α H k o
δ−1
+ wi H k o
δ−1
≤ C, (6.14)
we find upon solving for ∂t ∂¯4 u¯ I j that
∂t ∂¯4 u¯ I j (0) H k−1 ≤ C ∀ ∈ (0, 0 ] δ−1
(6.15)
by the calculus inequalities of Appendix A. But from part (iii), we get that ∂¯4 u¯ 44 + ∂ I u¯ I 4 = 0 and hence differentiating this with respect to t and evaluating at t = 0 yields ¯ I 4 H k−1 ≤ C ∀ ∈ (0, 0 ].
∂t ∂¯4 u¯ 44 (0) H k−1 = ∂ I ∂t u δ−1
o
δ−1
(6.16)
150
T. A. Oliynyk
From the estimates (6.14), the fluid equations (4.12) and similar arguments as above show that
∂t α (0) H k−1 ≤ C + ∂t wi (0) H k−1 ≤ C ∀ ∈ (0, 0 ]. δ−1
δ−1
(6.17)
Estimates (6.14)–(6.17) and Lemma A.11 then imply that ∂t V (0) H k−1 ≤ δ−1,
∂t V (0) H k−1 ≤ C for all ∈ (0, 0 ]. δ−1 (v) This is just a statement of the continuation principle of Theorem B.6. 7. The Newtonian Limit Let {V , 0 < ≤ 0 } be the sequence of solutions from Theorem 6.1 where we will always assume that −1 < δ < −1/2 and supp α ⊂ B R for some R > 0. o
If we let Tm () denote the maximal time of existence for the solution V , then V ∈
s+1
=0
k− C ([0, Tm ()), Hδ−1 )⊂
s+1
=0
k− C ([0, Tm ()), Hδ−1, ).
(7.1)
k−
So α ∈ s+1
=0 C ([0, Tm ()), Hδ−1 ) and hence Proposition 3.6 of [17] and Lemma A.8 imply that ρ = ρ(α ) ∈
s+1
=0
k− C ([0, Tm ()), Hδ−2 ).
Using Proposition 2.2 of [1], we can solve the equation = ρ
(7.2)
to find ∈
s+1
=0
C ([0, Tm ()), Hδk+2− ).
To obtain the Newtonian limit, we use to take care of the singular term −1 g(V )V in (6.1) by introducing the new variable ij
ij
ij
ij
j
W := (u4, , u J, , δuij , α , wi ) u J, := u J, − δ4i δ4 ∂ J . Observe that V = W + d , where j
d := (0, δ4i δ4 ∂ J , 0, 0, 0).
(7.3)
Newtonian Limit for Perfect Fluids
151
Noting that b0 (U , V ) = b0 (U , W ) and b I (, U , V ) = b I (, U , W ),
(7.4)
W satisfies the equation b0 (U , W )∂t W =
1 I c ∂ I W + b I (, U , W )∂ I W + f(, U , W + d )W + H , (7.5)
where H := h − b0 (U , W )∂t d + b I (, U , W )∂ I d + f (, U , W + d )d . k as 0. Therefore by Lemma By construction the initial data V is bounded in Hδ−1 o
A.11, there exists a constant K 1 such that
W |t=0 H k
δ−1,
≤ K 1 for all ∈ (0, 0 ].
(7.6)
Also by definition of W and Lemma A.7, max{ δu L ∞ , α L ∞ , wi L ∞ } ≤ W C 1 ≤ CSob W H k
δ−1,
b
,
(7.7)
where CSob is the constant from Lemma A.7 that is independent. Shrinking 0 if necessary, we can always assume that 20 CSob K 1 < K 0 . Define
(7.8)
τ := min sup τ > 0| sup W (t) H k
δ−1,
0≤t≤τ
≤ 2K 1 and
sup V H k
0≤t≤τ
δ−1,
< ∞ ,1 . (7.9)
From the continuation principle in Theorem 6.1, it is clear that τ satisfies 0 < τ ≤ Tm (). k 7.1. Energy estimates. We will now use energy estimates on the Hδ−1, spaces to show that τ is bounded below by a constant independent of . The strategy we use is that k spaces. All of the results below will be derived under the of [5, 19] adapted to the Hδ, assumption that the 1-parameter family V of solutions has the additional regularity
V ∈
s+1
=0
k+1− C ([0, τ ], Hδ−1 ).
It is then not difficult to use a solution of this type to approximate solutions of the regularity type (7.1) and thereby show that all of the following results also hold for solutions with the regularity (7.1). Since these sort of approximation arguments are standard, we will leave the details to the interested reader. The next lemma contains the basic energy estimate which is the key to deriving estimates independent of . We note that this type of estimate has been derived previously for the standard Sobolev spaces in [5,19]. It also makes clear why we need to introduce the variables W and to put the Einstein-Euler equations into the form (7.5).
152
T. A. Oliynyk
Lemma 7.1. Suppose ≥ 0, a 0 ∈ C 1 ([0, τ ], W 1,∞ ), a I ∈ C 0 ([0, τ ], W 1,∞ ), g ∈ 1 ) is a solution to the linear equation C 0 ([0, τ ], L 2λ, ), and that w ∈ C 1 ([0, τ ], Hλ, a 0 ∂t w = a I ∂ I w + g. Then there exists a constant C > 0 independent of such that d w|a 0 w L 2 ≤ C ( div a L ∞ + a L ∞ ) w 2L 2 + g L 2 w L 2 , λ, λ, λ, λ, dt where div a = ∂t a 0 + ∂ I a I and a = (a 1 , a 2 , a 3 ). Proof. Let σ¯ = σ−2λ−3 . Then σ¯ −1 ∂ j σ¯ L ∞ ≤ C for some constant C > 0 that is independent of . Using this, the proof follows by a standard integration by parts argument as in the proof of Lemma B.4. To continue, we estimate, in terms of K 1 , how much the support of α can change as 0. Lemma 7.2. supp α (t) ⊂ B R+32K 1 for all (t, ) ∈ [0, τ ] × (0, 0 ]. Proof. Letting X I , Y¯ and Yˆ be as in Sect. 4 (see (4.26)), we define X I (t) := X I (w4 (t), wJ (t)) and
YI (t) := Y¯ (w4 (t), α (t)) ∂t w4 (t) + ∂ I wI (t) +Yˆ ((u + δu(t)), w 4 (t), uk (t), w J (t), α(t)). o
Using (6.10), (7.7), (7.8), and (7.9), we obtain the bound
X I (t) L ∞ ≤ 32K 1 ∀ (t, ) ∈ [0, τ ] × (0, 0 ].
(7.10)
From Lemmas (A.7) and (A.10), and (7.1), it follows that X I ∈ C 0 ([0, τ ], Cb1 ) and YI ∈ C 0 ([0, τ ], Cb0 ). Therefore the vector field X I can be integrated to get a C 1 flow ψI (t, x) that is well defined for all (t, x) ∈ [0, τ ] × R3 . For each x ∈ R3 , define αx (t) := α (t, ψ (t, x)). Then ∂t ψI (t, x) = X I (t, ψ (t, x)) together with the evolution equation (4.25) implies that d x α (t) + Y (t, ψ (t, x))αx (t) = 0. dt By assumption supp α0 ⊂ B R and hence αx (0) = α (x) = 0 for x ∈ E R := R3 \B R . o Therefore α (t, ψ (t, x)) = 0 all x ∈ E R
(7.11)
Newtonian Limit for Perfect Fluids
153
by the uniqueness of solutions to ODEs. But τ τ |ψ (t, x) − x| ≤ |∂t ψ (t, x)| = |X (t, ψ (t, x))| ≤ 32K 1 τ ≤ 32K 1 0
0
by (7.10) and 0 < τ ≤ 1. From this, (7.11), and the fact that for each t the map R3 x → ψ (t, x) ∈ R3 defines a C 1 diffeomorphism, it follows that supp α (t) ⊂ B R+32K 1 for all (t, ) ∈ [0, τ ] × (0, 0 ]. Next, we estimate H k+2 in terms of W H k δ
δ−1,
.
Lemma 7.3. Let R¯ = R + 32K 1 and
¯ −(δ−2)−3/2 1 + (1 + R) ¯ 2k . C1 = (1 + R)
Then there exists a constant C > 0 such that
(t) H k+2 ≤ CC1 W (t) nH k δ
δ−1,
for all (t, ) ∈ [0, τ ] × (0, 0 ]. Proof. By Lemma 7.2, the supp α (t) ⊂ B R+32K 1 for all (t, ) ∈ [0, τ ]×(0, 0 ]. Letting R¯ = R + 32K 1 , it follows directly from the definition of the weighted norms that ¯ −η−3/2 u L 2
u L 2 ≤ u L 2η, ≤ (1 + R) for all functions u whose support is contained in B R¯ and for any ∈ (0, 1] and −η−3/2 ≥ 0. Therefore
ρ H k
δ−2
≤ CC1 ρ H k
δ−1,
,
where C > 0 is a constant independent of and ¯ −(δ−2)−3/2 1 + (1 + R) ¯ 2k . C1 = (1 + R) k is an isomorphism and = ρ , we have H k+2 ≤ Since : Hδk+2 → Hδ−2 δ C ρ H k , and hence, by Lemma A.8 (see also (1.12) and (7.3)) and the above estimate δ−2 that
H k+2 ≤ CC1 ρ H k δ
δ−2,
≤ CC1 α nH k
δ−1,
≤ CC1 W nH k
δ−1,
.
We note that for the remainder of this section, all of the constants appearing in the estimates may depend on the fixed constant K 1 . We will often use C to denote constants that depend on K 1 and that may change from line to line. Let Wα = D α W (|α| ≥ 0), b0 = b0 (U , W ), bI = b I (, U , V ) and f = f (, U , W + d )W . The evolution equation (7.5) implies that 1 I c + bI ∂ I W + (b0 )−1 f + (b0 )−1 H . (7.12) ∂t W = (b0 )−1
154
T. A. Oliynyk
Differentiating this equation yields 1 I c ∂ I Wα + bI ∂ I Wα + q α |α| ≥ 0,
b0 ∂t Wα =
(7.13)
where q α = b0 [D α , (b0 )−1 ( −1 c I + bI )]∂ I W + b0 D α ((b0 )−1 f ) + b0 D α ((b0 )−1 H ). (7.14) From Lemma A.11, we know, since −1< δ < −1/2, that u¯ H k+1 ≤ |δ+1/2| ¯u H k+1 . δ,
o
o
Since ¯u H k+1 is uniformly bounded in , we get, by Lemmas A.7 and A.11, that
δ
δ
o
U C 1,∞ ≤ CSob U H k+1 ≤ C |δ+1/2|
(7.15)
δ,
b
for some constant C > 0 independent of . So
bi (t) W 1,∞ ≤ C ∀ (t, ) ∈ [0, τ ] × (0, 0 ]
(7.16)
by (7.4), (7.7), (7.9) and (7.15) . Also, note that
d L ∞ + Dd L ∞ ≤ C H k+2 ≤ C and ∂t d L ∞ ≤ C H k+1 δ
δ
by (A.3), (A.24) and Lemmas 7.3 and A.7. The evolution equation (7.12) then implies that
∂t b0 L ∞ = Db0 (U , W ) · ∂t W L ∞ ≤ C(1 + ∂t d H k+1 ). δ
(7.17)
Together (7.16) and (7.17) establish the existence of a constant C > 0 such that
div b (t) L ∞ ≤ C(1 + ∂t (t) H k+1 ) ∀ (t, ) ∈ [0, τ ] × (0, 0 ]. δ
(7.18)
Differentiating (b0 )−1 yields ∂ J (b0 )−1 = −(b0 )−1 (Db0 (U , W ) · (∂ J U , ∂ J W ))(b0 )−1 . This along with (7.15), (7.16), (A.3), (A.24), and Lemmas A.7 and A.9 can be used to control the singular term in (7.14) and results in the following estimate (see also Appendix B.2)
q α (t) L 2
δ−1−|α|,
≤ Pα ( W (t) H k
δ−1,
, (t) H k+2 , ∂t (t) H k+1 ) ∀ t ∈ [0, τ ] δ
δ
(7.19) where Pα (y1 , y2 , y3 ) is a polynomial that is independent of and satisfies P(0) = 0. Note that in deriving this result, we have used the estimate
d H k
δ−1,
+ Dd H k
δ−2,
≤ C H k+2 and ∂t d H k δ
δ−1,
≤ C ∂t H k+1 δ
(7.20) for some C independent of which follows from (A.3), (A.24), and Lemma A.11. Define |||W |||2k,δ−1, := |α|≤k
∂ α W |b0 ∂ α W L 2
δ−|α|,
.
Newtonian Limit for Perfect Fluids
155
Then 1
W (t) H k ≤ |||W (t)|||k,δ−1, ≤ 4 W (t) H k ∀ t ∈ [0, τ ] δ−1, δ−1, 4
(7.21)
by (6.11) and (6.12). Lemma 7.1 combined with the estimates (7.16), (7.18), and (7.19) implies that d |||W |||2k,δ−1, ≤ P(|||W |||k,δ−1, , H k+2 , ∂t H k+1 )|||W |||k,δ−1, δ δ dt or equivalently d |||W (t)|||k,δ−1, ≤ P(|||W (t)|||k,δ−1, , (t) H k+2 , ∂t (t) H k+1 ) ∀ t ∈ [0, τ ] δ δ dt (7.22) for a independent polynomial P(y1 , y2 , y3 ) satisfying P(0) = 0. By Lemma 7.3,
H k+2 can be bounded by a polynomial of W H k that is independent of and δ δ−1, = 0. The differential inequality (7.22) shows that if we can do vanishes for W H k δ−1, the same for ∂t H k+1 then we get an estimate for |||W (t)|||k,δ−1, independent of . δ
Lemma 7.4. There exists a polynomial P(y) with coefficients independent of such that P(0) = 0 and
∂t (t) H k+1 ≤ P( W (t) H k δ
δ−1,
)
for all (t, ) ∈ [0, τ ] × (0, 0 ]. Proof. By (4.12), w := (α , wi )T satisfies an equation of the form a 4 (U , W )∂t w = a I (U , W )∂t w + b1 (U , W )W + b2 (U , W )d and so ∂t w = (a 4 )−1 a I ∂ I w + (a 4 )−1 b1 W + (a 4 )−1 b2 d . Thus
∂t w H k−1 ≤ (a 4 )−1 a I H k−1 DW H k−1 δ−1,
δ−2,
1,
4 −1
+ (a )
b1 H k−1 W H k−1 + (a 4 )−1 b2 H k−1 d H k−1 δ−1,
0,
δ−1,
0,
by Lemma A.8. Also by (7.15), (A.3), (A.24), and Lemmas A.7 and A.9, we have that
(a 4 )−1 a I H k−1 ≤ P( W H k
), DW H k−1 ≤ W H k
(a 4 )−1 b1 H k−1 ≤ P( W H k
), and
δ−1,
1,
δ−1,
0,
δ−1,
δ−2,
,
(a 4 )−1 b2 H k−1 ≤ P( W H k
δ−1,
0,
)
for some polynomial P(y) that is independent of . The above two inequalities along with (7.20) and Lemma 7.3 show that
∂t α H k−1 ≤ ∂t w H k−1 ≤ P( W H k δ−1,
δ−1,
δ−1,
)
156
T. A. Oliynyk
for a polynomial P(y) independent of and satisfying P(0) = 0. Using Lemma A.8, the above estimate implies that
,
∂t ρ H k−1 ≤ P W H k δ−1,
δ−2,
where as above P(y) is a polynomial that is independent of . Since ∂t = ∂t ρ , the same arguments used in the proof of Lemma 7.3 can be used to conclude
.
∂t H k+1 ≤ C ∂t ρ H k−1 ≤ P W H k δ
δ−1,
δ−1,
Lemmas 7.3 and 7.4 combined with the estimate (7.22) yield d |||W (t)|||k,δ−1, ≤ P(|||W (t)|||k,δ−1, )|||W (t)|||k,δ−1, ∀ t ∈ [0, τ ] dt
(7.23)
for a polynomial P(y) that is independent of and whose coefficients depend only on K 1 . By Gronwall’s inequality there exists a time T ∗ ∈ (0, 1), independent of , such that if y(t) ≥ 0 is C 1 and satisfies dy/dt ≤ P(y)y, then y(t) ≤ e K 3 t y(0), where K 3 is a constant that depends on K 1 . Therefore |||W (t)|||k,δ−1, ≤ e K 3 t |||W (0)|||k,δ−1, for all (t, ) ∈ [0, min{T ∗ , τ }]×(0, 0 ]. (7.24) Shrinking T ∗ if necessary, we conclude that |||W (t)|||k,δ−1, ≤
3 K1 2
for all (t, ) ∈ [0, min T ∗ , τ ] × (0, 0 ].
(7.25)
Note also that
V (t) H k δ−1, ≤ C for all (t, ) ∈ [0, min{T ∗ , τ }] × (0, 0 ]
(7.26)
by 7.20, 7.21 and Lemma 7.3. Therefore by the definition of τ , we must have 0 < T ∗ < τ for all 0 < ≤ 0 . ˙ := ∂t d Differentiating (7.12) with respect to t, shows that W˙ := ∂t W and d satisfy the equation 1 b0 (U , W )∂t W˙ = c I ∂ I W˙ + b I (, U , W )∂ I W˙ ˙ )W˙ + f¯1 (, U , W , DW , d , Dd , d ˙ , Dd ˙ , ∂t d ˙ ) + ∂t h + f¯2 (, U , W , d , Dd, d for analytic functions f 1 , f 2 with f 2 linear in the last 3 variables. This equation has the same structure (7.5) and it is not difficult to show that the arguments used to derive (7.24) can also be used to obtain the estimate
W˙ (t) H k−1 ≤ C ∀ (, t) ∈ (0, 0 ] × [0, T ∗ ] δ−1,
(7.27)
under the assumption that W˙ (0) H k−1 is bounded as 0. But this is clear from δ−1, Proposition 6.1 and Lemma 7.3 and so the estimate holds. We have proved the following proposition.
Newtonian Limit for Perfect Fluids
157
Proposition 7.5. For 0 > 0 small enough, there exists a T ∗ > 0 independent of ∈ (0, 0 ] such that the one parameter family of solutions V exists, for all ∈ (0, 0 ], on a common time interval [0, T ∗ ]. Moreover, there exist constants C > 0, R¯ > 0 such that K0
V (t) H k ≤ C, ∂t V (t) H k−1 ≤ C, δ−1, δ−1, 0 ≤ C, ∂t (t) H k+1 ≤ C,
max{ δu L ∞ , α L ∞ , wi L ∞ } ≤
(t) H k+2 δ
δ
and supp α (t) ⊂ B R¯ for all (, t) ∈ (0, 0 ] × [0, T ∗ ]. 7.2. Properties of the limit equations. To fully understand the limit equations of Sect. 7.3, we first need to consider the following system: ∂t αˆ = −wˆ I ∂ I αˆ −
αˆ ∂ I wˆ I , 2n
(7.28)
αˆ J ˆ ∂ αˆ − wˆ I ∂ I wˆ J − ∂ J , 2n ˆ = ρ, ˆ
∂t wˆ J = −
(7.29) (7.30)
with initial data α(0) ˆ = α and wˆ I (0) = w I , o
o
(7.31)
where α and w I are as defined in Proposition 6.1. This system is precisely the Poissono
o
1 Euler equation written using the Makino variable ρˆ = (4K n(n+1)) ˆ 2n . Indeed, a −n α straightforward calculation shows that (ρ, ˆ wˆ I ) satisfy the Poisson-Euler equations of Newtonian gravity
∂t ρˆ + ∂ I (ρˆ wˆ I ) = 0,
(7.32)
ˆ + ∂ J p), ρ(∂ ˆ t wˆ + wˆ ∂ I wˆ ) = −(ρ∂ ˆ ˆ ˆ = ρ, ˆ J
I
J
J
(7.33) (7.34)
where pˆ = K ρˆ (n+1)/n . Proposition 7.6. There exist a T > 0 and a solution k−1 k ) ∩ C 1 ([0, T ], Hδ−1 ), α, ˆ wˆ I ∈ C 0 ([0, T ], Hδ−1
k+1 ˆ ∈ C 0 ([0, T ], Hδk+2 ) ∩ C 1 ([0, T ], Hδk+1 ), ∂t ˆ ∈ C 0 ([0, T ], Hδ−1 )
to the initial value problem (7.28)–(7.31), where α(t) ˆ has compact support for all t ∈ [0, T ]. Moreover (i) this solution is unique in the class ˜ ∈ C 0 ([0, T ], Hδk+2 )∩C 1 (Rn ×[0, T ]), α, ˜ w˜ ∈ C 0 ([0, T ], H k )∩C 1 (Rn ×[0, T ]) where α(t) ˜ has compact support for all t ∈ [0, T ], and
158
T. A. Oliynyk
(ii) the solution also satisfies k−
α, ˆ wˆ I ∈ ∩s+1
=0 C ([0, T ], Hδ−1 ),
k+2−
ˆ ∈ ∩s+1 ˆ ∈ ∩s =0 C ([0, T ], H k+1− ). ), ∂t
=0 C ([0, T ], Hδ δ−1
Proof. Writing the system (7.28)–(7.30) as αˆ I 1 αˆ αˆ 0 −wˆ I − 2n δJ = − ∂t , ∂ I αˆ I J wˆ J wˆ J (4K n(n + 1))n ∂ J ( −1 α 2n ) − 2n δ −wˆ I we see that this system is symmetric hyperbolic with a non-local source term. Since k : Hδk+2 → Hδ−2 is an isomorphism, it is not difficult to adapt the approximation scheme and energy estimates of Appendices B.1 and B.2 to this system. Then as in Appendix B.3, this is enough to produce an existence theorem. Consequently, there exists a T > 0 and a solution k−1 k α, ˆ wˆ I ∈ C 0 ([0, T ], Hδ−1 ) ∩ C 1 ([0, T ], Hδ−1 ).
(7.35)
k−1 k ) ∩ C 1 ([0, T ], Hδ−2 ), ρˆ ∈ C 0 ([0, T ], Hδ−2
(7.36)
Therefore ˜ = −1 ρˆ ∈ C 0 ([0, T ], H k+2 ) ∩ C 1 ([0, T ], H k+1 ). and hence δ δ Differentiating (7.34) with respect to t and using (7.32) yields ˆ = −∂ I (ρˆ wˆ I ). ∂t
(7.37)
k ) and hence −1 (ρˆ w ∈ Hδ−2 ˆ I ) ∈ C 0 ([0, T ], But, (7.35) implies that k+1 ). However, Hδk+2 ). Taking the divergence then gives ∂ I ( −1 ρˆ wˆ I ) ∈ C 0 ([0, T ], Hδ−1 −1 I −1 I ˆ = − ∂ I (ρˆ wˆ ) = −∂ I ( (ρˆ wˆ )) and so ∂t ˆ ∈ C 0 ([0, T ], (7.37) implies that ∂t k+1 Hδ−1 ).
ρˆ wˆ I
C 0 ([0, T ],
The statement about compact support follows from the symmetric hyperbolic equation satisfied by αˆ and the property of finite propagation speed. Uniqueness follows from a slight modification of standard arguments, see [39] Proposition 1.3, Sect. 16.1.
7.3. Convergence as 0. In this section, we identify the limit of the relativistic solutions as 0. To accomplish this, we adapt the arguments of [37], Sect. III. Define ij ij V˜ := (˜u4 , u˜ J , δ u˜ i j , α, ˜ w˜ i )T , α˜ I δj −w˜ I I 2n a˜ := , α˜ I − 2n δi −δi j w I I ij ˜b I := A (δ u˜ ) 0I , 0 a˜ 0 w˜ I ij ˜ S := ρ , w˜ J 4ηi j δ u˜ i j + 2w˜ 4 0
p b˜ := ,
p −ηim 2η4 η4 p + η p u˜ m − 2 η p δ4i u¯ 4 − 2η 4 u¯ i 4 ij ˜ T , f˜(V˜ )V˜ := (−S˜i j , 0, u˜ 4 , b)
Newtonian Limit for Perfect Fluids
159
and h˜ := (ηi j ∂ I β I − 2∂ I β (i η j)I , 0, . . . , 0)T . k+1−r Theorem 7.7. For any r > 0, and V converge in C 0 ([0, T ∗ ], Hloc ) and C 0 k−r k+2 ∗ 1 3 ∗ 0 ∗ ˜ ([0, T ], Hloc ) as 0 to ∈ C (R × [0, T ]) ∩ C ([0, T ], Hδ ) and the unique solution V˜ ∈ C 1 (R3 × [0, T ∗ ]) ∩ C 0 ([0, T ∗ ], H k ) of the system
P ∂t V˜ − b˜ I ∂ I V˜ − f˜(V˜ )V˜ − h˜ = 0,
˜ = 0, c I ∂ I (V˜ − d ) ˜ V (0) = V0 (0), o
˜ = ρ, ˜ where P is the projection onto the L 2 orthogonal complement of { c I ∂ I W = 0 |W ∈ H 1 }. Moreover, (i) there exists a R¯ > 0 such that supp α(t) ˜ ⊂ B R¯ for all t ∈ [0, T ∗ ], k (ii) there exists a ω ∈ C 0 ([0, T ∗ ], Hloc ) such that ∂ I ω ∈ C 0 ([0, T ∗ ], H k−1 ) and ∂t V˜ − b˜ I ∂ I V˜ − f˜(V˜ )V˜ − h˜ − c I ∂ I ω = 0,
(7.38)
(iii) and for δ1 ≥ −1/2, there exists a u˜¯ ∈ C 0 ([0, T ], L 6δ1 ) such that u˜ J = ∂ J u˜¯ i j . ij
Proof. By assumption −1 < δ < −1/2, and so it follows directly from the definition of the weighted norms that for every ≥ 0,
u H ≤ u H
δ−1,
for all u ∈ Hδ−1, .
(7.39)
So by Proposition 7.5, k−1 k V ∈ C 0 ([0, T ∗ ], H k )∩C 1 ([0, T ∗ ], H k−1 ) ⊂ C 0 ([0, T ∗ ], Hδ−1, )∩C 1 ([0, T ∗ ], Hδ−1, )
and ∈ C 0 ([0, T ∗ ], Hδk+2 )∩C 1 ([0, T ∗ ], Hδk+1 ) are uniformly bounded for ∈ (0, 0 ]. Therefore by the Banach-Alaoglu theorem there exists subsequences of and V , ˜ ∈ L 1,∞ ([0, T ∗ ], H k+1 ) ∩ Lip([0, T ∗ ], H k ), which we still denote by and V , and δ δ V˜ ∈ L 1,∞ ([0, T ∗ ], H k ) ∩ Lip([0, T ∗ ], H k−1 ) such that and V converge weakly to ˜ and V˜ , respectively, as 0. By Proposition 7.5, the support of α is uniformly bounded in and hence the support of the weak limit α˜ must also be bounded. From Proposition 6.1, we have that ij ij u J, = ∂ J u¯ . So by Lemmas A.7 and A.11, and (7.15), we find that for δ1 ≥ −1/2 ≥ δ,
ij + uij L 2 ≤ C(1 + V H k )
¯uij L 6 ≤ C ¯uij L 6 ≤ C ¯uij L 6 ≤ C u J, L 2 δ1
δ
δ,
δ−1,
δ,
δ−1,
for a constant C independent of . It follows that u¯ I converges weakly to a u˜¯ i j ∈ L 1,∞ ([0, T ∗ ], L 6δ1 ) for which ∂ J u˜¯ i j = u˜ J .
160
T. A. Oliynyk
Now, V satisfies 1 b0 (U , V )∂t V − c I ∂ I (V − d ) + b I (, U , V )∂ I V − f (, U , V )V − h(U ) = 0,
(7.40)
and hence it follows from the boundedness of and V that
c I ∂ I (V − d ) H k−1 ≤ c I ∂ I (V − d ) H k−1 ≤ C. δ−1,
Letting 0 yields ˜ = 0. c I ∂ I (V˜ − d ) Next, applying the projection P (note that V − d ∈ H 1 ) to (7.40) gives P(b0 (U , V )∂t V − b I (, U , V )∂ I V − f (, U , V )V − h(U )) = 0 or equivalently Pb0 P∂t V + Pb0 (1I − P)∂t V − P(bI ∂ I V − f − h ) = 0, where we set b0 = b0 (U , V ), bI = b I (, U ,!V )∂ I V , f = f (, U , V )V , and h = h(U ). Suppose ψ ∈ C0∞ and let u|v = R3 uv d 3 x be the standard L 2 norm. Then ψ|Pb0 (1I − P)∂t V = (1I − P)b0 Pψ|∂t V
(7.41)
as P is a self-adjoint projection operator. Since the imbedding H k (B R ) → H k−r (B R ) k−r (r > 0) is compact for any ball B R , V and converge in C 0 ([0, T ∗ ], Hloc ) and k+2−r 0 ∗ ˜ respectively, as 0. Using this strong convergence C ([0, T ], Hloc ) to V˜ and , 0 2 and we find that " (7.15), # (1I − P)b Pψ → (1I − P)Pψ = 0 in L as 0 and hence 0 ψ|Pb (1I − P)∂t V → 0 by (7.41) and the fact that ∂t V L 2 is uniformly bounded in . Therefore, we have established that Pb0 (1I − P)∂t V −→ 0 weakly in L 2 as 0. The remainder of the proof follows from a straightforward adaptation of the proof of Theorem 2 in [37]. From the block diagonal form of the matrix c I , it is clear that ω can be written as ij
ij
ω = (ω4 , ω I , 0, . . . , 0)T .
Newtonian Limit for Perfect Fluids
161
Using this, we can write the system (7.38) as ∂t α˜ = −w˜ I ∂ I α˜ −
α˜ ∂ I w˜ I , 2n
(7.42)
α˜ KL ˜ ∂t w˜ J = − ∂ J α˜ − w˜ I ∂ I w˜ J − δ I J u˜ 44 , + δ u K L I I 2n
˜ 4I J , ∂t w˜ 4 = −w˜ I ∂ I w˜ 4 − u˜ 44 4 + δI J u ij ∂t u˜ 4 ij ∂t u˜ I ∂t δ u˜ i j ij ∂ J u˜ 4 ij ∂ J u˜ J
= = =
ij ij 4δ u˜ 4I ∂ I u˜ 4 + 4δ u˜ I J ∂ I u˜ J ij ij 4δ u˜ I J ∂ J u˜ 4 + ∂ I ω4 , ij u˜ 4 ,
(7.43) (7.44)
ij + ηi j ∂ I β I − 2∂ I β (i η j)I − S˜i j + ∂ I ω I ,
(7.46) (7.47)
= 0, =
(7.45)
(7.48)
j ˜ δ4i δ4 ,
(7.49)
˜ = ρ, ˜
(7.50)
with initial conditions −1 ˜ u˜ 4 (0) = 0, u˜ iI J (0) = 0, u˜ 44 I = ∂ I φ (φ := ρ(0)), ij
α(0) ˜ = α , w˜ = w , w˜ = 0. I
I
4
(7.52)
o
o
(7.51)
Equation (7.48) immediately implies that ij
u˜ 4 = 0,
(7.53)
and hence, by uniqueness and the fact that δui j (0) = 0, it follows from (7.47) that δ u˜ i j = 0.
(7.54)
˜ But u˜¯ i j ∈ L 6 and Since u˜ J = ∂ J u˜¯ i j , we get from (7.49) that u˜¯ i j = δ4i δ4 . δ1 2 ˜¯ i j ∈ H k ˜ ∈L and so by Theorem 1.2 and Proposition 1.6 of [1], we find that u δ2 δ−2 for 0 > δ2 > δ1 ≥ −1/2 > δ > −1. Since the Laplacian : Hδk2 → Hδk−2 is injective 2 −1 j ˜ and hence for δ2 < 0 (see [1], Proposition 2.2), we must have u˜¯ i j = δ i δ ij
j
4 4
˜ u˜ J = δ4i δ4 ∂ J . ij
j
(7.55)
Substituting (7.53)–(7.55) into (7.42)–(7.49) yields ∂t α˜ = −w˜ I ∂ I α˜ −
α˜ ∂ I w˜ I , 2n
α˜ J ˜ ∂ α˜ − w˜ I ∂ I w˜ J − ∂ J , 2n ˜ = ρ, ˜
∂t w˜ J = −
(7.56) (7.57) (7.58)
162
T. A. Oliynyk
and ∂t w˜ 4 = −w˜ I ∂ I w˜ 4 , ij ∂ ωI ∂ I ω4J k I
(7.59) (i
= η ∂ I β − 2∂ I β η ij
I
j)I
+ S˜i j ,
(7.60)
= 0, ˜ ∂t ∂ I = ∂ I ω444 .
(7.61) (7.62)
Since w˜ 4 (0) = 0, uniqueness of solutions to hyperbolic equations implies that w˜ 4 = 0.
(7.63)
˜ w˜ I , α} Proposition 7.6 and (7.56)–(7.58) imply that {, ˜ must satisfy
k−1 k ∩ C 1 [0, T ∗ ], Hδ−1 α, ˜ w˜ I ∈ C 0 [0, T ∗ ], Hδ−1
(7.64)
and
˜ ∈ C 0 [0, T ∗ ], Hδk+2 ∩ C 1 [0, T ∗ ], Hδk+1 ,
k+1 k ˜ ∈ C 0 [0, T ∗ ], Hδ−1 ∂t ∩ C 1 [0, T ∗ ], Hδ−1 .
(7.65) (7.66)
We then get from (7.61) and (7.62) that k ˜ ∈ C 1 ([0, T ∗ ], Hδ−1 ω444 = ∂t )
(7.67)
ω44J = 0.
(7.68)
and
(i j)
Equations (7.54) and (7.63) imply that S˜i j can be written as S˜ i j = 2δ I δ4 w˜ I . We then find from (7.60) that ij
ω I = ∂ I i j ,
(7.69)
where (i j)
i j = −1 (ηi j ∂ I β I − 2∂ I β (i η j)I + 2δ I δ4 w˜ I ).
(7.70)
Note that i j ∈ C 1 ([0, T ∗ ], Hδk+1 ), k−1 k−1 ) and S˜ i j ∈ C 1 ([0, T ∗ ], Hδ−2 ) by (7.64). Therefore since ∂ I β j ∈ C 1 ([0, T ∗ ], Hδ−2 k ω I = ∂ I i j ∈ C 1 ([0, T ∗ ], Hδ−1 ). ij
We collect the above results in the following proposition.
(7.71)
Newtonian Limit for Perfect Fluids
163
˜ from Theorem 7.7 satisfies Proposition 7.8. The limit solution {V˜ , } ij
δ u˜ i j = u˜ 4 = w˜ 4 = 0, ˜ ∈ C 0 ([0, T ∗ ], Hδk+2 ) ∩ C 1 ([0, T ∗ ], Hδk+1 ),
k+1 k ∂t ∈ C 0 ([0, T ∗ ], Hδ−1 ) ∩ C 1 ([0, T ∗ ], Hδ−1 ),
ij j k+1 k ˜ ∈ C 1 ([0, T ∗ ], Hδ−1 u˜ J = δ4i δ4 ∂ J ) ∩ C 1 ([0, T ∗ ], Hδ−1 ), k−1 k α, ˜ w˜ I ∈ C 0 ([0, T ∗ ], Hδ−1 ) ∩ C 1 ([0, T ∗ ], Hδ−1 ),
˜ α, while {, ˜ w˜ I } solves Eqs. (7.56)–(7.58). Moreover, the ω from Theorem 7.7 is given by ij
ij
ω = (ω4 , ω I , 0, . . . , 0)T , where ij j k ˜ ∈ C 1 ([0, T ∗ ], Hδ−1 ), ω4 = δ4i δ4 ∂t
ij (i j) k ). ω I = ∂ I −1 ηi j ∂ I β I − 2∂ I β (i η j)I + 2δ I δ4 w˜ I ∈ C 1 ([0, T ∗ ], Hδ−1
7.4. Error estimate. To get an error estimate which measures the difference between the relativistic and Newtonian solutions, we adapt the arguments of [37], Sect. IV. Define ˜ − ω and γ := α − α. ˜ Z := V − V˜ + d − d A simple but useful observation is that
γ H k−1 = α − α ˜ Hk
δ−1,
δ−1,
≤ Z H k−1
δ−1,
and
wi − w˜ i H k−1 ≤ Z H k−1 . (7.72) δ−1,
δ−1,
Lemma 7.9. There exists an independent constant C > 0 such that ˜
d (t) − d(t) H k−1 + Dd (t) − Dd(t) H k−1 ≤ (t) − (t) H k+1 δ−1,
δ
δ−2,
≤ C Z (t) H k−1
δ−1,
˜ ˜
∂t d (t) − ∂t d (t) H k−1 ≤ ∂t (t) − ∂t (t) H k ≤ C Z (t) H k−1 + C δ
δ−1,
δ−1,
and
∂t γ H k−2 ≤ C Z (t) H k−1 + C δ−1,
δ−1,
for all (t, ) ∈ [0, T ∗ ] × (0, 0 ]. ˜ are both bounded for all (t, ) ∈ [0, T ∗ ] × Proof. Since the support of α (t) and α(t) (0, 0 ], there exists a independent constant C > 0 such that ˜ H k−1 ≤ ρ − ρ ˜ H k−2 ≤ C ρ − ρ ˜ H k−1 . C −1 ρ − ρ δ−2
˜ = ρ, Also, = ρ , ˜ and :
Hδk+1
→
δ−1,
δ−2
k−1 Hδ−1
is an isomorphism, and therefore
˜ k+1 ≤ ρ − ρ
− ˜ H k−1 ≤ C ρ − ρ ˜ H k−1 ≤ C γ H k−1 ≤ C Z H k−1 (7.73) H δ
δ−2
δ−1,
δ−1,
δ−1,
164
T. A. Oliynyk
by Proposition 7.5 and Lemma A.10. From (4.25) and (7.56), it follows that γ satisfies ∂ I w˜ I α, ˜ ∂t γ = −X I ∂ I γ − Y γ + X I − w˜ I ∂ I α˜ + Y − 2n
(7.74)
where X I and Y are given by (4.26). But X I = X I (w4 , wI ) and w˜ I = X I (0, w˜ I ), and hence
X I − w˜ I H k−2 ≤ C wI − w˜ I H k−2 ≤ C Z H k−1 δ−1,
δ−1,
δ−1,
(7.75)
by (7.72), (A.24), Lemma A.10 and Proposition 7.5. Next,
1 ∂ I w˜ I 1 ¯ Y− = Y (V ) − ∂t w4 + ∂ I wI + ∂t w4 2n 2n 2n
1 ∂ I wI − ∂ I w˜ I + Yˆ (U , V ), + 2n where Yˆ (0) = 0 and Y¯ (0) − 1/(2n) = 0. Using (7.15), (A.3), (A.24), Proposition 7.5, and Lemmas A.7–A.10, we can estimate each of the above terms as follows: 1 1 4 I ¯ ¯
Y (V ) − (∂t w + ∂ I w ) H k−2 ≤ Y (V ) −
H k−2 δ, δ−1, 2n 2n
4 I × ∂t w H k−2 + w H k−2 δ−1, δ−1,
∂t V H k−1 + V H k ≤ C, ≤ C V H k δ−1,
δ−1,
δ−1,
1
∂t w4 H k−2 ≤ C ∂t V H k−1 ≤ C, δ, δ−1, 2n 1 I I
(∂ I w − ∂ I w˜ ) H k−2 ≤ C Z H k−1 , δ, δ−1, 2n and
Yˆ (U , V ) H k−2 ≤ C U H k + V H k δ,
δ,
δ−1,
≤ C.
Therefore
Y −
∂ I w˜ I
k−2 ≤ C Z H k−1 + C. δ−1, 2n Hδ,
(7.76)
We can also estimate X I and Y as follows:
X I H k−2 ≤ C V H k δ−1,
δ−1,
≤ C,
(7.77)
Y H k−2 ≤ C( U H k + V H k δ,
δ,
δ−1,
+ ∂t V H k−1 ) ≤ C. δ−1,
(7.78)
The estimates (7.72), (7.75), (7.76), (7.77), (7.78) along with Lemma A.8 imply via Eq. (7.74) that
∂t γ H k−2 ≤ C Z H k−1 + C. δ−1,
δ−1,
(7.79)
Newtonian Limit for Perfect Fluids
165
˜ = ∂t ρ, Since ∂t = δρ and ∂t ˜ the same arguments used to establish the estimate (7.73) can be used in conjunction with (7.79) to show ˜ k ≤ C Z k−1 + C.
∂t − ∂t H H δ
(7.80)
δ−1,
Finally from (7.73), (7.80), and Lemma A.11, we get the desired estimates ˜ k+1 ≤ C Z k−1
d − d H k−1 + Dd − Dd H k−1 ≤ − H H δ−1,
δ
δ−2,
δ−1,
and ˜ k ≤ C Z k−1 + C ˜ k−1 ≤ ∂t − ∂t
∂t d − ∂t d H H H δ
δ−1,
for some constant C independent of .
δ−1,
Lemma 7.10. There exists a constant C > 0 such that ˜ H k−2 + V (t) − V˜ (t) H k−1 ≤ C for all (t, ) ∈ [0, T ∗ ] × (0, 0 ].
∂t α − ∂t α δ−1,
δ−1,
Proof. From the evolution equation (6.1), we find that Z satisfies the equation b0 ∂t Z =
1 I c ∂ I Z + bI ∂ I Z + F ,
(7.81)
where b0 = b0 (U , V ), bI = b(, U , V ) and ˜ − d )−b0 ∂t ω + bI (∂ I d ˜ − ∂ I d )+bI ∂ I ω F = −b0 ∂t (d ˜ (7.82) −(b0 − 1I )∂t V˜ +(b˜ I − bI )∂ I V˜ + f (, U , V )V − f˜(V˜ )V˜ + h − h. Using (7.15), (A.3), (A.24), Lemmas 7.9, A.7–A.9, and Propositions 7.5 and 7.8, we get the following estimates:
b0 − 1I H k ≤ C( U H k + V H k δ,
δ,
δ−1,
) ≤ C,
(7.83)
˜ − d ) k−1 ≤ (b0 − 1I )∂t (d ˜ − d ) k−1 + ∂t (d −d ˜
b0 ∂t (d ) H k−1 H H δ−1,
δ−1,
δ−1,
˜ − d ) k−1 ≤ C Z k−1 + C, ≤ C( b0 − 1I H k−1 + 1) ∂t (d H H δ,
δ−1,
δ−1,
b0 ∂t ω H k−1 ≤ C( b0 − 1 H k−1 + 1) ∂t ω H k−1 ≤ C, δ,
δ−1,
(7.85)
δ−1,
bI ∂ I ω H k−1 ≤ C bI H k−1 ∂ I ω H k−1 ≤ C bI H k−1 ω H k δ,
δ−1,
δ,
δ−2,
(7.84)
δ−1,
≤ C, (7.86)
˜ k−1 ≤ C.
h − h H
(7.87)
δ−1,
˜ we first note that To estimate the term bI − b, 0 A I (uiJ ) + A I (δuiJ ) I ˜ o b − b = , ˜ 0 a I (u , wi , α , wI , α ) − a I (0, 0, 0, w˜ i , α) where the map a I is analytic. Next, the estimate (7.15) implies that
uij H k−1 , ≤ uij H k−1 + C δuij H k−1 ≤ C + C Z H k−1 . δ
o
δ,
δ−1,
δ−1,
(7.88)
166
T. A. Oliynyk
From Proposition 5.2 and Lemma A.11, we see that the uiJ can be estimated by o
uiJ H k+1 = u¯ iJ H k+1 ≤ |δ+1/2| ¯uiJ H k+1 ≤ C |δ+1/2|+1 . o
δ,
δ,
o
(7.89)
δ
o
Also, from Proposition 7.8 and Lemma 7.9, we obtain ˜ k−1
∂t α − ∂t α ˜ H k−2 + V − V˜ H k−1 ≤ Z H k−1 + d − d H δ−1,
δ−1,
δ−1,
+ ω H k−1 ≤ C Z H k−1 + C. δ−1,
δ−1,
(7.90)
δ−1,
The three estimates (7.88)–(7.90) along with Lemmas A.9 and A.10, and Propositions 7.5 and 7.8, show that
A I (uiJ ) + A I (δuiJ ) H k−1 ≤ C uiJ H k + C δuiJ H k−1 ≤ C + C Z H k−1 , δ,
o
δ,
o
δ−1,
δ−1,
and
a I (u , wi , α , wI , α ) − a I (0, 0, 0, w˜ i , α) ˜ H k−1 δ,
ij i i ≤ C u H k−1 + α − α ˜ H k−1 + w − w˜ H k−1 ≤ C + C Z H k−1 . δ,
δ−1,
δ−1,
δ−1,
Therefore ˜ k−1 ≤ C + C Z k−1 ,
bI − b H H δ−1,
δ−1,
and hence
(b˜ − bI )∂ I V˜ H k−1 ≤ C b˜ − bI H k−1 D V˜ H k−1 ≤ C + Z H k−1 . (7.91) δ,
δ−1,
δ−2,
δ−1,
Next, we notice that f (, U , V )V − f˜(V˜ )V˜ = −ρ F + fˆ(V )V − fˆ(V˜ )V + f¯(, U , V )V , where j
F := −4ρ (δ4i δ4 η pq u¯ pq , 0, . . . , 0)T o
and fˆ and f¯ are analytic. We obtain
fˆ(V )V − fˆ(V¯ )V + f¯(, U , V )V H k−1 ≤ C Z H k−1 + C δ−1,
(7.92)
δ−1,
by the arguments used above. Also, the boundedness of the support of α (t) implies that
F H k−1 ≤ C ρ ηi j u¯ ij H k−1 ≤ C ρ H k−1 ¯u H k−1 ≤ C ρ H k−1 ¯u H k−1 ≤ C. δ−1,
o
δ
δ
o
δ
δ−1,
o
δ
(7.93) So then
f (, U , V )V − f˜(V˜ )V˜ H k−1 ≤ C Z H k−1 + C δ−1,
δ−1,
(7.94)
Newtonian Limit for Perfect Fluids
167
by (7.92) and (7.93). Combining the estimates (7.83)–(7.87), (7.91), (7.92), and (7.94) yields
F H k−1 ≤ C Z H k−1 + C. δ−1,
(7.95)
δ−1,
Letting Z α = D α Z and differentiating Eq. (7.81) yields b0 ∂t Z α =
1 I c ∂ I Z α + bI ∂ I Z α + q α
0 ≤ |α| ≤ k − 1,
where q α = −[D α , b0 ]∂t Z α + [D α , bI ]∂ I Z α + D α F . Using the estimates above along with Propositions 7.5 and 7.8 and the calculus inequalities from Appendix A, we find
∂t Z H k−1 ≤ C Z H k−1 + C, δ−1,
[D
[D
α
α
, b0 ]∂t Z α L 2 δ−1−|α|,
, bI ]∂ I Z α L 2 δ−1−|α|,
δ−1,
≤
C b0
− 1I H k−1 ∂t Z H k−1 ≤ C Z H k−1 + C,
≤
C bI H k−1 D Z H k−2 δ, δ−2,
δ,
δ−1,
δ−1,
≤ C Z H k−1 , δ−1,
and hence
q α H k−1 ≤ C Z H k−1 + C. δ−1,
δ−1,
Combining this estimate with the estimates
∂t b0 + ∂ I bI L ∞ ≤ C, bI L ∞ ≤ C, and Lemma 7.1 shows that d α 0 α Z |b Z ≤ C( Z H k−1 + ) Z H k−1 0 ≤ |α| ≤ k − 1. δ−1, δ−1, dt L 2δ−1−|α|, Summing over α and using Gronwall’s inequality, we get
Z (t) H k−1 ≤ C Z (0) H k−1 + C for all (t, ) ∈ [0, T ∗ ] × (0, 0 ]. δ−1,
δ−1,
This estimate and (7.90) then prove the proposition since Z (0) H k−1 ≤ C by δ−1, Proposition 6.1. We are now ready to prove a precise error estimate for the difference between the relativistic and Newtonian solutions. Proposition 7.11. Suppose −1 < δ < −1/2 and k ≥ 3. Then there exists a constant C > 0 such that j ˜ I ˜ ¯ ij (t) − δ4i δ4 d (t)
¯uij (t) − δ4i δ4i (t) ˜ I (t) H k−1 L 6 + ∂ I u H k−1 + v (t) − w δ,
+
−1
δ−1,
δ−1,
v (t) − 1 H k−1 + ρ (t) − ρ(t) ˜ ˜ H k−1 + ∂t ρ (t) − ∂t ρ(t) H k−2 ≤ C 4
δ−1,
for all (t, ) ∈ [0, T ∗ ] × (0, 0 ].
δ−1,
δ−1,
168
T. A. Oliynyk
Proof. From the evolution equations and Proposition 7.8, we have
j ˜ ij ij = u4 − ω4 , ∂t u¯ ij − δ4i δ4 and hence integrating yields ˜ ¯uij (t) − δ4i δ4 (t) uij − δ4i δ4 φ L 2 + L 2 ≤ ¯ j
j
δ,
δ,
o
t
ij
ij
u4 (s) − ω4 (s) L 2 ds. δ,
0
(7.96) But t 0
ij ij
u4 (s) − ω4 (s) L 2 ds δ,
t
≤ 0
V (s) − V˜ (s) H k−1 + ωi j (s) H k−1 ds (7.97) δ−1,
δ−1,
and j
¯uij − δ4i δ4 φ L 2 ≤ C 3/2
(7.98)
δ,
o
by the calculus inequalities of Appendix A and Proposition 5.1. Also, by Lemma A.4 and u I, = ∂ I u¯ , we have ˜ 6 ≤ C u − δ4i δ d ˜ 2
¯uij − δ4i δ4 L L 4 I, j
ij
j
δ,
δ−1,
˜ + ¯uij (t) − δ4i δ4 (t) L2 j
δ,
˜ + ¯uij (t) − δ4i δ4 (t) L2 . j
(7.99)
δ,
is Recall that ρ = (4K n(n + 1))−n α2n and ρ˜ = (4K n(n + 1))−n α˜ 2n . Since α H k δ−1, bounded as 0, we obtain ˜ H k−1 ≤ C α − α ˜ H k−1 ≤ C V − V˜ H k−1
ρ − ρ δ−1,
δ−1,
δ−1,
(7.100)
by Lemma A.10. We also have that ∂t α H k−2 is bounded as 0, so the formulas δ−1,
∂t ρ =
2n 2n α 2n−1 ∂t α , ∂t ρ˜ = α˜ 2n−1 ∂t α, ˜ (4K n(n + 1))n (4K n(n + 1))n
and the calculus inequalities of Appendix A imply that ˜ H k−2 ≤ C( α − α ˜ H k−2 + ∂t α − ∂t α ˜ H k−2 )
∂t ρ − ∂t ρ δ−1,
δ−1,
δ−1,
≤ C( V − V˜ H k−1 + ∂t α − ∂t α ˜ H k−2 ). δ−1,
δ−1,
(7.101)
Finally, from the definition of V and V˜ , we have I ˜ ˜ I (t) H k−1 + −1 v 4 (t) − 1 H k−1
∂ I u¯ ij (t) − δ4i δ4 d (t) H k−1 + v (t) − w j
δ−1,
≤ C V − V˜ H k−1 . δ−1,
δ−1,
δ−1,
(7.102)
The proof now follows as a direct consequence of Lemma 7.10 and (7.96)–(7.102).
Newtonian Limit for Perfect Fluids
169
In the above error estimate, the norm itself depends on . We now show how to choose norms independent of which are compatible with the error estimate above. First, for any η ∈ R define a norm by
u
, p,η := |α|≤
D α u L ηp .
Recalling that −1 < δ < −1/2, fix η ∈ [δ, −1/2]. Then from (A.24) and Lemma A.11, we get that
u
,2,η−1 ≤ C η+1/2 u H
δ−1,
and u 0,6,η ≤ C η+1/2 u L 6
δ,
(7.103)
for some constant C > 0 independent of . Combining (7.103) with Corollary 7.11 yields the following theorem which is our main result. Theorem 7.12. Suppose −1 < δ < −1/2, −δ ≤ η ≤ −1/2 and k ≥ 3. Then there exists a constant C > 0 such that j ˜ ˜ ¯ ij (t) − δ4i δ4 ∂ I (t)
¯uij (t) − δ4i δ4i (t) 0,6,η + ∂ I u k−1,2,η−1
+ v I (t) − w˜ I (t) k−1,2,η−1 + −1 v 4 (t) − 1 k−1,2,η−1
η+3/2 + ρ (t) − ρ(t) ˜ ˜ k−1,2,η−1 + ∂t ρ (t) − ∂t ρ(t) k−2,2,η−1 ≤ C
for all (t, ) ∈ [0, T ∗ ] × (0, 0 ]. Note that for η = −1/2, we have
u 0,6,−1/2 = u L 6 and u
,2,−3/2 = u H , where u H is the standard Sobolev norm. So the above theorem shows that the difference between the relativistic and Newtonian solutions is of order with respect to the norms · L 6 and · H k−1 . A. Weighted Calculus Inequalities In this and the following sections C will denote a constant that may change value from line to line but whose exact value is not needed. Let V be a finite dimensional vector space with inner product (·|·) and corresponding p norm | · |. For u ∈ L loc (Rn , V ), 1 ≤ p ≤ ∞, δ ∈ R, and ∈ R≥0 , the weighted L p norm of u is defined by
−δ−n/ p u L p if 1 ≤ p < ∞
σ p , (A.1)
u L := δ,
σ−δ u L ∞ if p = ∞ $ 1 where σ (x) := 1 + |x|2 . The weighted Sobolev norms are then defined by 4 ⎧⎛ ⎞1/ p ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ p ⎪⎝ ⎠
D α u L p if 1 ≤ p < ∞ ⎨ δ−|α|, , (A.2)
u W k, p := |α|≤k ⎪ δ, ⎪ α ⎪
D u L ∞ if p = ∞ ⎪ ⎩ δ−|α|, |α|≤k
170
T. A. Oliynyk
where k ∈ N0 , α = (α1 , . . . , αn ) ∈ Nn0 is a multi-index and D α = ∂1α1 . . . ∂nαn . Here ∂i =
∂ , ∂ xi
where (x 1 , . . . , x n ) are the standard Cartesian coordinates on Rn . The weighted Sobolev spaces are then defined as
) k, p k, p n Wδ, = u ∈ Wloc (R , V ) | u W k, p < ∞ . δ,
Directly from this definition, we observe the simple but useful inequality
∂ j u W k ≤ u W k+1 . δ,
(A.3)
δ+1,
k, p
k, p
We note that Wδ,0 are the standard Sobolev spaces and for > 0, the Wδ, are equivalent to the radially weighted Sobolev spaces [1, 7]. For p = 2, we use the alternate notation k := W k,2 . The spaces L 2 and H k are Hilbert spaces with inner products Hδ, δ, δ, δ, u|v L 2 := (u|v)σ−2δ−n d n x, (A.4) δ,
Rn
and
"
u|v H k := δ,
D α u|D α v
#
|α|≤k
L 2δ−|α|,
,
k, p
(A.5) k, p
k . respectively. When = 1, we will also use the notation Wδ = Wδ,1 and Hδk = Hδ,1 Let B R be the open ball of radius R and a R and A R denote the annuli B2R \ B R and B4R \ B R , respectively. Let {φ j }∞ j=0 be a smooth partition of unity satisfying
supp φ0 ⊂ B2 , supp φ j ⊂ A2 j−1 ( j ≥ 1), and φ j (x) := φ1 (21− j x)( j ≥ 1). Scaling gives a one parmeter family of smooth partitions of unity φ j (x) := φ j (x) ( j ≥ 0) which satisfy supp φ0 ⊂ B2/ , supp φ j ⊂ A2 j−1 / ( j ≥ 1), and φ j (x) := φ1 (21− j x)( j ≥ 1). (A.6) Define a scaling operator by S j u(x) := u(2 j−1 x).
(A.7)
This operator satisfies the following simple, but useful identities: S1 = 1I , S j ◦ Sk = Sk ◦ S j = Sk+ j−1 , S j φ j = φ1 ( j ≥ 1),
S j u L p = 2
n(1− j) p
(A.8) (A.9)
u L p ,
(A.10)
S j ◦ D α = 2(1− j)|α| D α ◦ S j .
(A.11)
and
Newtonian Limit for Perfect Fluids
171
Lemma A.1. For 1 ≤ p < ∞, there exists a constant C > 0 independent of ≥ 0 such that 1 p p
u L p ≤ φ0 u L p + C δ,
∞
S j (φ j u) L p ≤ C u L p . p
p
δ,
j=0
Proof. From the identity p
u L p
∞
=
|u| d x + p
|u| p d n x
n
B4/
j=1 a2 j+1 /
and a simple change of variables, it follows that
u L p = σ−δ−n/ p u L p (B4/ ) + p
p
δ,
∞
2n( j−1) S j (σ−δ−n/ p u) L p (a4/ ) . p
(A.12)
j=1
This identity and max σ (x)
−δp−n
min σ (x)
−δp−n
max (S j σ )(x)
−δp−n
min (S j σ )(x)
−δp−n
x∈B 4/
x∈B 4/
=
=
x∈a 4/
x∈a 4/
= =
2 1
−δp−n 2
if −δp − n ≥ 0 , if −δp − n < 0
1 if −δp − n ≥ 0 −δp−n , if −δp − n < 0 2 2 −δp−n
(1 + 22 j ) 2 if −δp − n ≥ 0 , −δp−n 2( j−1) (1 + 2 ) 2 if −δp − n < 0 −δp−n 2
(1 + 22( j−1) ) −δp−n (1 + 22 j ) 2
if −δp − n ≥ 0 , if −δp − n ≤ 0
show that 1 p p p
u L p (B4/ ) ≤ σ−δ−n/ p u L p (B4/ ) ≤ C u L p (B4/ ) C
(A.13)
and 1 − pδ( j−1) p 2
S j u L p (a4/ ) ≤ 2n( j−1) S j (σ−δ−n/ p u) L p (a4/ ) C p ≤ C2− pδ( j−1) S j u L p (a4/ ) (A.14) for some constant C > 0 which is independent of ≥ 0. Using a change of variable, the inequality (A.14) can be written as 1 − pδ( j−1) (1− j)n p 2 2
u L p (a j+1 ) ≤ 2n( j−1) S j (σ−δ−n/ p u) L p (a4/ ) 2 / C p − pδ( j−1) (1− j)n ≤ C2 2
u L p (a j+1 ) . (A.15) 2
/
172
T. A. Oliynyk
From
φk
2 k=0
φ j+k
2
= 1I B4/ and B4/
a2 j+1 /
k=0
and (A.10), we obtain
p
u L p (B4/ )
≤C
p
φ0 u L p
3
+
= 1I a2 j+1 /
(A.16)
p
Sk (φk u) L p
,
(A.17)
k=1
and 2 p
u L p (a
2 j+1 /
)
2n( j+k) S j+k (φ j+k u) L p . p
≤C
(A.18)
k=0
Combining (A.12) with the inequalities (A.13), (A.15), (A.17) and (A.18) yields ⎛ ⎞
u L p ≤ C ⎝ φ0 u L p + p
p
δ,
∞
2− pδ( j−1) S j (φ j u) L p ⎠ p
(A.19)
j=1
for some constant C > 0 independent of ≥ 0. Since supp φ0 ⊂ B4/ and φ0 L ∞ = φ0 L ∞ , we get from (A.13) that
φ0 u L p ≤ φ0 L ∞ u L p (B4/ ) ≤ C σ−δ−n/ p u L p (B4/ ) p
p
p
p
(A.20)
for some constant C > 0 independent of ≥ 0. Next, 2− pδ( j−1) S j (φ j u) L p p
≤ 2− pδ( j−1) 2n(1− j) φ j u L p (A2 j−1 / )
by (A.10) and (A.6),
≤ 2− pδ( j−1) 2n(1− j) φ1 L ∞ φ j u L p (∪1
k=−1 a2 j−k / )
since φ1 L ∞ = φ j L ∞ .
So there exists a constant C > 0 independent of ≥ 0 such that ⎧
p ⎨ C u p p L (B4/ ) + u L p (a8/ ) p − pδ j−1 * 2
S j (φ j u) L p ≤ ⎩ C2− pδ( j−1) 2n(1− j) 2k=0 u Lp p (a
if j = 1
2 j−1+k /
)
if j ≥ 2
.
(A.21) Therefore
φ0 u L p + p
∞
2− pδ( j−1) S j (φ j u) L p p
j=1
⎛
≤ C ⎝ σ−δ−n/ p u L p (B4/ ) + p
∞
⎞ 2n( j−1) S j (σ−δ−n/ p u) L p (a4/ ) ⎠ p
j=1 p
≤ C u L p
δ,
by (A.15), (A.20), and (A.21) by (A.12),
where C > 0 is a constant independent of ≥ 0. The proof then follows from this inequality and (A.19).
Newtonian Limit for Perfect Fluids
173
The above lemma shows that the norm |||u||| L p := φ0 u L p + p
p
δ,
∞
2− pδ( j−1) S j (φ j u) L p p
j=1
is equivalent for 1 ≤ p < ∞, independent of ≥ 0, to the weighted norm u L p . For δ, p = ∞, the appropriate norm is := sup φ0 u L ∞ , 2−δ( j−1) φ j u L ∞ ( j ≥ 1) |||u||| L ∞ δ, and it is easy to see that there exists a constant C > 0 independent of ≥ 0 such that 1 ≤ |||u||| L ∞ ≤ C u L ∞ .
u L ∞ δ, δ, δ, C The same arguments used in proving the previous lemma can be used to establish the following generalization. Lemma A.2. For 1 ≤ p < ∞, let |||u|||
p
:= φ0 u W k, p + p
k, p
Wδ,
∞
2− pδ( j−1) S j (φ j u) W k, p , p
(A.22)
j=1
and for p = ∞ let |||u|||W k,∞ := sup{ φ0 u W k,∞ , 2−δ( j−1) S j (φ j u) W k,∞ ( j ≥ 1)}. δ,
(A.23)
Then there exists a constant C > 0 independent of ≥ 0 such that 1 p p p
u k, p ≤ |||u||| k, p ≤ C u k, p . Wδ, Wδ, Wδ, C For the remainder of this section, we will use the two equivalent norms · W k, p and δ,
||| · |||W k, p interchangeably and refer to both using the notation · W k, p . From (A.22), it δ,
δ,
follows that there exist a constant C > 0 independent of ≥ 0 such that
u W k2 , p ≤ C u W k1 , p whenever k2 ≤ k1 and δ1 ≤ δ2 . δ2 ,
δ1 ,
k ,p
(A.24)
k ,p
Thus we have the inclusion Wδ11, ⊂ Wδ22, for k2 ≤ k1 and δ1 ≤ δ2 . The representation k, p
(A.22) is particularly useful for extending estimates from the usual Sobolev spaces Wδ k, p to the weighted ones Wδ, ( > 0) as the next lemma shows. It also makes clear the philosophy behind deriving weighted Sobolev inequalities which is to derive global estimates from scaling and local Sobolev inequalities [1]. We remark that the norm ||| · |||W k, p , as an alternate representation for the standard δ,1
weighted norms · W k, p , was introduced by Maxwell in [25]. There he used the norm δ,1
to define the weighted Sobolev spaces for non-integral k (see also [4]). Here we will only be interested in integral k.
174
T. A. Oliynyk
Lemma A.3. Suppose 0 > 0 and for all u ∈ C ∞ (Rn , V ), u → F1 (u) is a map that satisfies φ0 F1 (u) = φ0 F1 ((φ0 + φ1 )u), 1 φ j F1 (u) = φ j F1
φ j+k u
k=−1 −( j−1)λ 2 F1 (S j u)
S j F1 (u) =
( j ≥ 1), ( j ≥ 1),
and Fα (α = 2, 3, 4, 5) are linear operators on V . (i) If there is an estimate of the form
F1 (u) W k1 , p1 ≤ C1 F2 (u) W k2 , p2 , where p1 ≥ p2 , then
F1 (u) W k1 , p1 ≤ C F2 (u) W k2 , p2 δ1 ,
δ2 ,
for some constant C > 0 independent of ∈ [0, 0 ] provided δ1 + λ ≥ δ2 . (i i) If there exists an estimate of the form
F1 (u) W k1 , p1 ≤ C1 F2 (u) W k2 , p2 F3 (u) W k3 , p3 +C2 F2 (u) W k4 , p4 F1 (u) W k5 , p5 , 1 1 1 1 1 = + = + (1 ≤ p1 ≤ pα ≤ ∞ α = 2, 3, 4, 5), then p1 p2 p3 p4 p5
F1 (u) W k1 , p1 ≤ C C1 F2 (u) W k2 , p2 F3 (u) W k3 , p3 +C2 F4 (u) W k4 , p4 F5 (u) where
δ1 ,
δ2 ,
δ3 ,
δ4 ,
k ,p
Wδ 5, 5 5
for some constant C > 0 independent of ∈ [0, 0 ] provided δ1 + λ ≥ max {δ2 + δ3 , δ4 + δ5 }. Proof. We only proof part (ii) for 1 ≤ pα < ∞. Part (i) can be proved in a similar manner using the inequality ⎞1/ p ⎛ ⎞1/q ⎛ aj ⎠
⎝
p
aj ⎠
≤⎝
j
q
for a j ≥ 0 and 0 < q ≤ p
(A.25)
j
instead of Hölder’s and Minkowski’s inequalities. See also the proof of Theorem 1.2 in [1]. Recall Hölder’s and Minkowski’s inequalities which state that for 1 ≤ p ≤ q ≤ r < ∞, 1/ p = 1/q + 1/r and any two sequences a j , b j ≥ 0 that the following holds ⎞1/ p ⎛ ⎞1/q ⎛ ⎞1/r ⎛ aj bj ⎠
⎝
p p
j
and
(a j + b j ) p ⎠
⎝ j
q
⎝
j
⎞1/ p
⎛
aj ⎠
≤⎝
⎛
p aj ⎠ j
(A.26)
j
⎞1/ p
≤⎝
brj ⎠
⎛
⎞1/ p
+⎝
p aj ⎠ j
.
(A.27)
Newtonian Limit for Perfect Fluids
175
Next, suppose j ≥ 2. Then
S j (φ j F1 (u)) W1k1 , p1 + 1 + + p1 + p1 1 + + + + + + + −(1− j) p1 λ + = +φ1 S j F1 φ j+k u) + ≤ C2 S j φ j+k u + + F1 + + + + k1 , p1 k=−1 k=−1 W k1 , p1 ⎛ + W + + + 1 1 + + + + + + + + ≤ C2−( j−1) p1 λ ⎝C1 + F2 S j φ j+k u + S j φ j+k u + + F3 + + + + k=−1 k=−1 W k2 , p2 W k3 , p3 ⎞ p1 + 1 + 1 + + + + + + + + + + ⎠ , +C2 + F4 S j φ j+k u + S j φ j+k u + + F5 + + + + p
W k4 , p4
k=−1
W k5 , p5
k=−1
where C > 0 is a constant independent of ≥ 0. Note that in deriving this, we have used the fact that φ1 W k1 ,∞ is bounded for ∈ [0, 0 ]. From the above inequality, we see that 2−δ1 p1 ( j−1) S j (φ j F1 (u)) W1k1 , p1 1 p
≤ C C1 2
−δ2 ( j−1)
k=−1 1
2−δ3 ( j−1)
F3 (S j+k (φ j+k u)) W k3 , p3
× k=−1
+C2 2−δ4 ( j−1)
F2 (S j+k (φ j+k u)) W k2 , p2
1
F4 (S j+k (φ j+k u)) W k4 , p4
k=−1 1
p1
F5 (S j+k (φ j+k u)) W k5 , p5
×
2−δ5 ( j−1)
,
k=−1
where we have used δ1 + λ ≥ max{δ2 + δ3 , δ4 + δ5 }. The above inequality along with (A.26) and (A.27) imply ⎛ ⎝
∞ j=1
⎞1/ p1 p 2−δ1 p1 ( j−1) S j (φ j F1 (u)) W1k1 , p1 ⎠
⎛
⎛
⎜ ≤ C ⎝C1 ⎝
∞
⎞1/ p2 2−δ2 p2 ( j−1) F2 (S j (φ j u)) W2k2 , p2 ⎠ p
j=1
⎛ ×⎝
∞ j=1
⎞1/ p3 p 2−δ3 p3 ( j−1) F3 (S j (φ j u)) W3k3 , p3 ⎠
176
T. A. Oliynyk
⎛
∞
+C2 ⎝ ⎛ ×⎝
⎞1/ p4 2−δ4 p4 ( j−1) F4 (S j (φ j u)) W4k4 , p4 ⎠ p
j=1 ∞
⎞1/ p5 ⎞ ⎟ p 2−δ5 p5 ( j−1) F5 (S j (φ j u)) W5k5 , p5 ⎠ ⎠,
j=1
and hence ⎛ ⎝
∞
⎞1/ p1 p 2−δ1 p1 ( j−1) S j (φ j F1 (u)) W1k1 , p1⎠
≤ C C1 F2 (u) W p2 ,k2 F3 (u) W p3 ,k3 δ2 ,
j=1
δ3 ,
+C2 F4 (u) W p4 ,k4 F5 (u) δ4 ,
.
p ,k Wδ 5, 5 5
(A.28) Similar arguments show that
φ
1/ p1
p F1 (u) k1 , p1 + S1 (φ1 F1 (u)) 1k1 , p1 Wδ , Wδ , p1
1
≤ C C1 F2 (u) W p2 ,k2 F3 (u) W p3 ,k3 δ2 ,
1
+C2 F4 (u) W p4 ,k4 F5 (u) δ4 ,
δ3 ,
p ,k
Wδ 5, 5
,
5
(A.29) for some constant C > 0 independent of ∈ [0, 0 ]. The proof now follows from the two inequalities (A.28) and (A.29). The next lemma is a variation of the previous one and can be proved in the same fashion. Lemma A.4. Suppose 0 > 0 and for all u ∈ C ∞ (Rn , V ), u → F1 (u) is a map that satisfies φ0 F1 (u) = φ0 F1 ((φ0 + φ1 )u), 1 φ j F1 (u) = φ j F1 S j F1 (u) =
φ j+k u
k=−1 −( j−1)λ 2 F1 (S j u)
( j ≥ 1), ( j ≥ 1),
and F2 = D P2 , F3 = P3 , F4 = D P4 , and F5 = P5 , where Pα (α = 2, 3, 4, 5) are linear operators on V .
Newtonian Limit for Perfect Fluids
177
(i) If there exists an estimate of the form
F1 (u) W k1 , p1 ≤ C1 F2 (u) W k2 , p2 , where p1 ≥ p2 , then there exists a constant C > 0 independent of ∈ [0, 0 ] such that
F1 (u) W k1 , p1 ≤ C F2 (u) W k2 , p2 + P2 u W k2 , p2 δ1 ,
δ2 ,
δ2 −1,
provided δ1 + λ ≥ δ2 . (i i) If there exists an estimate of the form
F1 (u) W k1 , p1 ≤ C1 F2 (u) W k2 , p2 F3 (u) W k3 , p3 +C2 F2 (u) W k4 , p4 F1 (u) W k5 , p5 , 1 1 1 1 1 = + = + (1 ≤ p1 ≤ pα ≤ ∞ α = 2, 3, 4, 5), then p1 p2 p3 p4 p5
F1 (u) W k1 , p1 ≤ C C1 F2 (u) W k2 , p2 + P2 u W k2 , p2 F3 (u) W k3 , p3 δ1 , δ2 , δ3 , δ2 −1, +C2 F4 (u) W k4 , p4 + P4 u W k4 , p4 F5 (u) k5 , p5
where
Wδ
δ4 ,
δ4 −1,
5 ,
for some constant C > 0 independent of ∈ [0, 0 ] provided δ1 + λ ≥ max {δ2 + δ3 , δ4 + δ5 }. Remark A.5. By using the generalized Hölder’s inequality, part (ii) of Lemmas A.3 and A.4 can be extended in the obvious fashion if there exist estimates of the form
F1 (u) W k1 , p1 ≤ C F2 (u) W k2 , p2 F3 (u) W k3 , p3 · · · FN (u) W k N , p N , *N 1 where p11 = i=2 pi (1 ≤ p1 ≤ pi ≤ ∞), F1 is as in Lemma A.3, and Fi (i ≥ 2) are of the form Fi = Pi or Fi = D Pi with Pi a linear operator on V . We will now use these two lemmas to extend various inequalities from the standard Sobolev spaces to the weighted ones. All of these inequalities have been derived before by various authors, see for example [1, 4, 7, 8, 25, 30]. The new aspect here is that we show that the constants in the inequalities are independent of ≥ 0 and hence we find inequalities that interpolate between the weighted ( > 0) and the standard ones ( = 0). We begin with a weighted Hölder inequality. Lemma A.6. Suppose 0 > 0, δ1 = δ1 +δ2 and C > 0 independent of ∈ [0, 0 ] such that
1 1 1 = + . Then there is a constant p1 p2 p3
uv L p1 ≤ C u L p2 v L p3 δ1 ,
p
δ2 ,
δ3 ,
p
for all u ∈ L δ22, and v ∈ L δ33, . Proof. Follows directly from Hölder’s inequality and Lemma A.3. Next, we consider weighted versions of the Sobolev inequalities.
178
T. A. Oliynyk
Lemma A.7. (i) For 0 > 0 and k > n/ p there exists a constant C > 0 independent of ∈ [0, 0 ] such that
u L ∞ ≤ C u W k, p δ, δ,
0 and for > 0, u(x) = o(|x|δ ) as |x| → ∞. for all u ∈ Wδ, . Moreover u ∈ Cδ, (ii) For 0 > 0 and 1 ≤ p < n there exists a constant C > 0 independent of ∈ [0, 0 ] such that k, p
u L np/(n− p) ≤ C Du L p
δ−1,
δ,
+ u L p
δ,
1, p
for all u ∈ Wδ, . Proof. (i) The estimate u L ∞ ≤ C u W k, p for some constant C > 0 independent of ≥ 0 δ, δ,
follows from the usual Sobolev inequality u L ∞ ≤ C u W k, p (k > n/ p) and Lemma A.3. Since · W k, p for > 0 is equivalent to · W k, p , the statement δ,
δ,1
u(x) = o(|x|δ ) as |x| → ∞ for > 0 follows from Theorem 1.2 in [1]. (ii) Follows from Lemma A.4 and the Sobolev inequality u L np/(n− p) ≤ C Du L p which holds for all u ∈ W 1, p where 1 ≤ p < n. In addition to the Sobolev inequalities, we will also require weighted versions of the multiplication and Moser inequalities. We first consider the multiplication inequalities. Lemma A.8. Suppose 0 > 0, 1 ≤ p < ∞, k1 , k2 ≥ k3 , k3 < k1 +k2 −n/ p, δ1 +δ2 ≤ δ3 , and V1 × V2 → V3 : (u, v) → uv is a multiplication. Then there exists a constant C > 0 independent of ∈ [0, 0 ] such that
uv W k3 , p ≤ C u W k1 , p v W k2 , p δ3 ,
k ,p
δ1 ,
δ2 ,
k ,p
for all u ∈ Wδ11, and v ∈ Wδ22, . Proof. This proof does not follow directly from Lemma A.3, but can be proved in a simlar fashion. To see this first recall the Sobolev mlutiplication inequality
uv W k3 , p ≤ C u W k1 , p v W k2 , p
(A.30)
Newtonian Limit for Perfect Fluids
179
which holds for 1 ≤ p < ∞, k1 , k2 ≥ k3 , and k3 < k1 + k2 − n/ p. So ⎛ ⎞1/ p ∞
uv W k3 , p = ⎝ φ0 uv W k3 , p + p
δ3
2− pδ3 ( j−1) S j (φ j uv) W k3 , p ⎠ p
j=1
p ≤ C φ0 u(φ0 + φ1 )v W k1 , p ∞
+
2− pδ3 ( j−1) S j (φ j u)S j
φ j+k v W k1 , p ⎠ p
j=1
k=−1
∞
p/2 ≤ C φ0 u(φ0 + φ1 )v W k3 , p +
⎞2/ p
φ j+k v W k1 , p ⎠ p/2
j=1
+
1
2−( p/2)δ3 ( j−1) S j (φ j u)S j
k=−1
p/2 p/2 ≤ C φ0 u W k1 , p φ0 v W k2 , p ∞
⎞1/ p
1
⎞2/ p
2−( p/2)δ1 ( j−1) S j (φ j u) W k1 , p 2−( p/2)δ2 ( j−1) S j (φ j v) W k2 , p ⎠ p/2
j=1
⎛ ≤C
⎝ φ0 u p k , p W 1
∞
+
⎞1/ p p 2− pδ1 ( j−1) S j (φ j u) W k1 , p ⎠
j=1
⎛ × ⎝ φ0 v W k2 , p + p
∞
⎞1/ p 2− pδ2 ( j−1) S j (φ j v) W k2 , p ⎠ p
j=1
≤ C u W k1 , p v W k2 , p , δ1
δ2
where in deriving the third, fourth, and fifth lines we used (A.25), (A.30), and (A.26), respectively. Lemma A.9. (i) If 0 > 0 and δ1 ≥ max{δ2 + δ3 , δ4 + δ5 }, then there exists a constant C > 0 independent of ∈ [0, 0 ] such that ∞
uv H k ≤ C u H k v L ∞ +
v
u L δ , Hk δ , δ1 ,
δ2 ,
3
δ4 ,
5
k ∞ for all u ∈ Hδk2 , ∩ L ∞ δ5 , and v ∈ Hδ4 , ∩ L δ3 , . (ii) If 0 > 0 and δ1 ≥ max{δ2 + δ3 , δ4 + δ5 }, then there exists a constant C > 0 independent of ∈ [0, 0 ] such that
v L ∞
[D α , u]v L 2 ≤C
Du H k−1 + u L 2 δ3 , δ2 , δ1 −|I |, δ2 −1,
∞
v + Du L ∞ + u k−1 L δ , H δ −1, 4
4
δ5 ,
180
T. A. Oliynyk
for all |α| ≤ k, u ∈ Hδk2 , ∩ Wδ1,∞ and v ∈ Hδk−1 ∩ L∞ δ3 , . 4 , 5 ,
m (iii) Suppose 0 > 0, F ∈ C (V, R ) is a map that satisfies D F ∈ Cbk−1 (V, Rm ), and 1 ≤ |α| ≤ k. Then there exists a C > 0 independent of ∈ [0, 0 ] such that
≤ C D F C k−1 u k−1
D α F(u) L 2 L ∞ Du H k−1 + u L 2 δ−|α|,
δ,
δ−1,
b
k ∩ L ∞. for all u ∈ Hδ, (iv) Suppose 0 > 0 and F ∈ Cbk (V, Rm ). Then there exists a C > 0 independent of ∈ [0, 0 ] such that
F(u) H k ≤ C F C k (1 + u k−1 L ∞ ) u H k δ,
δ,
b
k ∩ L ∞. for all u ∈ Hδ,
Proof. Inequalities (i)–(iv) follow directly from (A.24), Lemmas A.3 and A.4, and the following standard Sobolev inequalities: (i) uv H k ≤ C u H k v L ∞ + v H k u L ∞ for all u ∈ H k ∩ L ∞ and v ∈ H k ∩ L ∞. (ii) [D α , u]v L 2 ≤ C Du H k−1 v L ∞ + Du L ∞ v H k−1 for all |α| ≤ k, u ∈ H k ∩ W 1,∞ and v ∈ H k−1 ∩ L ∞ . (iii) Suppose F ∈ C (V, Rm ) is a map that satisfies D F ∈ Cbk−1 (V, Rm ) and 1 ≤ k |α| ≤ k. Then ∂ α F(u) L 2 ≤ C D F C k−1 u k−1 L ∞ Du H k−1 for all u ∈ H ∩ b L ∞. (iv) Suppose F ∈ Cbk (V, Rm ). Then F(u) H k ≤ C F C k (1 + u k−1 L ∞ ) u H k for all b
u ∈ H k ∩ L ∞.
Note that we have used · L ∞ = · L ∞ . 0,
In addition to the Moser inequalities, we also need to know when the map u → F(u) is locally Lipschitz on Hδk . Lemma A.10. Suppose 0 > 0, F ∈ Cb (V, R), F(0) = 0, δ ≤ 0, and k ≤ , and k > n/2. Then for each R > 0 there exists a C > 0 independent of ∈ [0, 0 ] such that
F(u 1 ) − F(u 2 ) H k ≤ C u 1 − u 2 H k δ,
δ,
Proof. See the proof of Lemma B.6 in [30].
k for all u 1 , u 2 ∈ B R (Hδ, ).
We conclude this section with a lemma comparing the norms · L p and · L p . δ
Lemma A.11. (i) If δ ≤ −n/ p, 1 ≤ p ≤ ∞, and 0 ≤ ≤ 1, then −δ−n/ p u L p ≤ u L p ≤ u L p δ
p
for all u ∈ L δ .
δ,
δ
δ,
Newtonian Limit for Perfect Fluids
181
(ii) If −n/ p < δ, 1 ≤ p < ∞, and 0 < ≤ 1, then
u L p ≤ u L p ≤ −δ−n/ p u L p δ
δ,
δ
p
for all u ∈ L δ . Proof. (i) By assumption 0 ≤ ≤ 1, and so we have σ1 (x) ≤ σ (x) ≤ σ1 (x) −δ−n/ p for all x ∈ Rn . By assumption −δ − n/ p > 0 and so we get −δ−n/ p σ1 ≤ −δ−np −δ−np ≤ σ1 . Therefore, directly from the definition of the weighted norm, we σ find −δ−n/ p u L p ≤ u L p ≤ u L p . Part (ii) is proved in a similar fashion. δ
δ,
δ
B. Quasilinear Symmetric Hyperbolic Systems In this section we establish a local existence and uniqueness theorem for a particular form of the quasilinear symmetric hyperbolic system on the weighted Sobolev spaces Hδk . In [30], we proved a local existence and uniqueness theorem for quasilinear parabolic systems on the Hδk spaces by adapting the approach of Taylor [39] (see Theorem 7.2, p. 330, and Proposition 7.7, p. 334) which is based on using mollifiers to construct a sequence of approximate solutions and then showing that the sequence converges to a true solution. Here, we will again follow the same approach for quasilinear symmetric hyperbolic systems and adapt the local existence and uniqueness theorems of Taylor (see Proposition 2.1, p. 370) to work on the weighted Sobolev spaces. We will only provide a brief sketch of the proof since the proof is very similar to the one in [30] and the details can easily be filled in by the reader. Related existence results have been derived independently in [4] using a different method. The hyperbolic equations that we will consider are of the form b0 (u, v)∂t v = b j (u, v)∂i v + f (u, v)v + h, v|t=0 = v0 ,
(B.1) (B.2)
where (i) the map u = u(t, x) is Rr -valued while the maps v = v(t, x) and h = h(t, x) are Rm -valued, (ii) b0 , b j , f ∈ Cbk (Rr × Rm , Mm×m ) ( j = 1, . . . , n), (iii) b0 and b j ( j = 1, . . . , n) are symmetric, and (iv) there exists a constant ω > 0 such that b0 (ξ1 , ξ2 ) ≥ ω1I m×m for all (ξ1 , ξ2 ) ∈ Rr × Rm .
(B.3)
n B.1. Galerkin method. Let j ∈ C∞ 0 (R ) be any function that satisfies j ≥ 0, j (x) = 0 ! n for |x| ≥ 1, and Rn j (x) d x = 1. Following the standard prescription, we construct from j the mollifier jη (x) := η−n j (x/η) (η > 0) and the smoothing operator
Jη (u)(x) := j ∗ u(x) =
Rn
jη (x − y)u(y) d n y.
182
T. A. Oliynyk
Following Taylor ( [39], Ch. 16, Sects. 1 & 2), we first solve the approximating equation b0 (u, Jη vη )∂t vη = Jη b j (u, Jη vη )∂i Jη vη + Jη f (u, Jη vη )Jη vη + Jη h, vη |t=0 = v0 ,
(B.4) (B.5)
and later show that the solutions v converge to a solution of (B.1)–(B.2) as η → 0. Proposition B.1. Suppose T1 , T2 > 0, η > 0, δ ≤ γ ≤ 0, k > n/2, v0 ∈ Hδk , u ∈ C 0 ([−T1 , T2 ], Hγk ), and h ∈ C 0 ([−T1 , T2 ], Hδk ) for some T > 0. Then there exists a T∗ > 0 (T∗ < T1 , T2 ) and a unique vη ∈ C 1 ((−T∗ , T∗ ), Hδk ) that solves the initial value problem (B.4)–(B.5). Moreover if sup0≤t 0 and define F(t, v) := (b0 (u, Jη v))−1 (Jη b j (u, Jη v)∂i Jη v + Jη f (u, Jη v)Jη v + Jη h). Then the approximating equations (B.4)–(B.5) can be written as the first order differential equation v˙ = F(v) ; v(0) = v0 on Hδk . If we can show that F is continuous and is Lipshitz in a neighborhood of v0 in Hδk , then the proof follows immediately from standard existence, uniqueness, and continuation theorems for ODEs on Banach spaces. To prove that F is locally Lipshitz, we first prove the following lemma. Lemma B.2. Suppose δ ≤ γ ≤ 0, > n/2 and that f ∈ Cb (Rm × Rm , Mm×m ). Then for each u ∈ Hγ and R > 0 there exists a constant C > 0 such that
f (u, v1 )v1 − f (u, v2 )v2 H ≤ C v1 − v2 H δ
δ
for all v1 , v2 ∈ B R (Hδ ). Proof. Let f(0,0) = c and g(x, y) = f (x, y) − c so that g(0, 0) = 0. Then f (u, v1 )v1 − f (u, v2 )v2 = c(v1 − v2 ) + (g(u, v1 ) − g(u, v2 ))v1 + g(u, v2 )(v1 − v2 ). Since γ ≤ 0 and > n/2, we get from Lemma A.8 that
f (u, v1 )v1 − f (u, v2 )v2 H ≤ C 1 + g(u, v2 ) Hγ v1 − v2 H δ
+ v1 H g(u, v1 ) − g(u, v2 ) Hγ .
δ
δ
By Lemma A.10, Lemmas A.7 and A.9, and (A.24), we get from the above inequality that
f (u, v1 )v1 − f (u, v2 )v2 H ≤ C( u Hγ , v1 H , v2 H ) v1 − v2 H , δ
δ
where P(y1 , y2 , y3 ) is a polynomial. This proves the lemma.
δ
δ
Using Lemma A.7 of [30], it is not difficult to prove the following variation of the above lemma.
Newtonian Limit for Perfect Fluids
183
Lemma B.3. Suppose δ ≤ γ ≤ 0, η > 0, > n/2 and that f ∈ Cb (Rm × Rm , Mm×m ). Then for each u ∈ Hγ and R > 0 there exist a constant C > 0 such that
f (u, Jη v1 )D Jη v1 − f (u, Jη v2 )D Jη v2 H ≤ C v1 − v2 H δ
for all v1 , v2 ∈
δ
B R (Hδ ).
The proof now follows easily from the above lemmas, Lemma A.7 of [30], and the estimates of Appendix A, which show that for any R > 0 the map F : ([−T1 , T2 ] × k ) → H k is continuous and moreover there exists a constant C > 0 such that B R (Hδ−1 δ−1
F(t, v1 ) − F(t, v2 ) H k ≤ C v1 − v2 H k for all v1 , v2 ∈ B R (Hδk ). δ
δ
B.2. Energy estimates. Fix k > n/2 + 1. By Proposition B.1, we have a sequence of solutions vη ∈ C 1 ([−T (η), T (η)], Hδk ) (0 < T (η) ≤ T1 , T2 ) to the approximating Eqs. (B.4)–(B.5). The goal is to derive bounds on vη in the Hδk spaces independent of η. To do this, we use energy estimates which we now describe. Lemma B.4. Suppose a 0 ∈ C 1 ([0, τ ], W 1,∞ ), a j ∈ C 0 ([0, τ ], W 1,∞ ), f ∈ C 0 ([0, τ ], L 2λ ) and that w ∈ C 1 ([0, τ ], L 2λ ) satisfies the equation a 0 ∂t w = Jη a j ∂ j Jη w + g. Then there exists a constant C > 0 independent of η > 0 such that d w|a 0 w 2 ≤ C (1 + div a L ∞ + a L ∞ ) w 2L 2 + g L 2 w L 2 , λ λ Lλ λ dt where div a = ∂t a 0 + ∂ j a j and a = (a 1 , . . . , a n ). Proof. First, we have d w|a 0 w 2 = 2 w|a 0 ∂t w 2 + w|∂t a 0 w 2 Lλ Lλ Lλ dt j = 2 w|Jη a ∂ j Jη w 2 + 2 w|g L 2 + w|∂t a 0 w Lλ
λ
L 2λ
.
Letting Jη† denote the adjoint of Jη with respect to the inner-product (A.4), we can write the above expression as d w|a 0 w 2 = 2 Jη† w|a j ∂ j Jη w 2 + 2 w|g L 2 + w|∂t a 0 w 2 . (B.6) λ Lλ Lλ Lλ dt Integration by parts shows that Jη† w|a j ∂ j Jη w 2 = − ∂ j Jη† w|a j Jη w Lλ
L 2λ
− Jη† w|(∂ j a j + a j ρ −1 ∂ j ρ)Jη w
L 2λ
, (B.7)
where ρ = σ1−2λ−n . Since ρ −1 ∂ j ρ L ∞ < ∞, together Lemmas B.7 and B.8 of [30] and (B.7) imply that a L ∞ ) w 2L 2 . (B.8) Jη† w|a j ∂ j Jη w 2 ≤ − ∂ j Jη w|a j Jη w 2 +C(1 + ∂i a i L ∞ + Lλ
Lλ
λ
184
T. A. Oliynyk
Again integrating by parts and using Lemma B.8 of [30], we find that a L ∞ ) w 2L 2 . − ∂ j Jη w|a j Jη w 2 ≤ C(1 + ∂i a i L ∞ + λ
Lλ
(B.9)
The proof now follows from the Cauchy-Schwartz inequality and Eqs. (B.6), (B.8), and (B.9). Let vηα = D α vη , bη0 = b0 (u, Jη vη ), bη = b j (u, Jη vη ) and f η = f (u, Jη vη )Jη vη . The evolution equation (B.4) implies that j
∂t vη = (bη0 )−1 Jη bηj ∂ j Jη vη + (bη0 )−1 f η + (bη0 )−1 h.
(B.10)
Differentiating this equation yields bη0 ∂t vηα = Jη bηj ∂ j Jη vηα + g α ,
(B.11)
where
g α = bη0 [D α , (bη0 )−1 Jη bηj ]∂ j Jη vη + bη0 D α (bη0 )−1 Jη f η +bη0 D α (bη0 )−1 Jη h . (B.12)
To simplify the following estimates, we will assume that b j (0, 0) = 0. It is not difficult to treat the case where b j (0, 0) = 0. Recalling that δ ≤ γ ≤ 0 and k > n/2 + 1, we get from the calculus inequalities of Appendix A and Lemma A.7 of [30] the following estimate
bη0 [D α , (bη0 )−1 Jη bηj ]∂ j Jη vη L 2 ≤ bη0 L ∞ [D α , (bη0 )−1 Jη bηj ]∂ j Jη vη L 2 δ−|α| δ−|α|
0 −1 j 0 −1 j ≤ C (bη ) Jη bη H k ∂ j Jη vη L ∞ + (bη ) Jη bη W 1,∞ ∂ j Jη vη H k−1 δ−1 0 δ−1
≤ C (1 + ( u L ∞ + vη L ∞ )k−1 ) u H k + vη H k vη W 1,∞ 0 0 δ +(1 + u W 1,∞ + vη W 1,∞ ) vη H k , δ
where C is independent of η. By the Sobolev inequality (Lemma A.7) we have
u W 1,∞ ≤ C u Hηk , v W 1,∞ + v W 1,∞ ≤ C vη H k , δ
δ
and hence
bη0 [D α , (bη0 )−1 Jη bηj ]∂ j Jη vη L 2
δ−|α|
≤ P( u Hηk , vη H k ) δ
gα
for a η independent polynomial P(y1 , y2 ) . The other terms in can be estimated in a similar fashion to get
(B.13) ≤ P u Hγk , vη H k , h H k ,
g α L 2 δ−|α|
δ
δ
where as above P(y1 , y2 , y3 ) is an η independent polynomial . It can also be shown using the calculus inequalities and (B.10) that
div b L ∞ ≤ P( u Hγk , vη H k , h H k ). δ
δ
(B.14)
Newtonian Limit for Perfect Fluids
185
Finally, we note that L ∞ ≤ C.
b Next, if we define
|||vη |||2k,δ := |α|≤k
D α vη |bη0 D α vη
(B.15) L 2δ−|α|
,
then by (B.3) and (B.15) there exists a constant C > 0 independent of η such that C −1 vη H k ≤ |||vη |||k,δ ≤ C vη H k . δ
δ
(B.16)
Since sup0≤t≤T u(t) Hγk < ∞ and sup0≤t≤T ] h(t) H k < ∞, Lemma (B.4) and δ (B.13), (B.14), (B.15), and (B.16) imply that d |||vη |||2k,δ ≤ C(|||vη |||k,δ )|||vη |||k,δ dt
(B.17)
or equivalently d |||vη |||k,δ ≤ P(|||vη |||k,δ ) dt for a polynomial P(y) with positive coefficients that are independent of η > 0. By Gronwall’s inequality, (B.17), and Proposition B.1, this implies that there exists constants T∗ , K > 0, both independent of η > 0, such that T (η) ≥ T∗ and sup vη (t) H k ≤ K .
0≤t≤T∗
δ
(B.18)
Using the time reversed version of the equation (i.e. sending t → −t) we also get, shrinking T∗ if necessary, that sup
−T∗ ≤t≤0
vη (t) H k ≤ K . δ
(B.19)
Finally, from (B.10), (B.18), (B.19), Lemma A.7 of [30], Lemmas A.7 and A.9, and (A.24), we see, increasing K if necessary, that sup
−T∗ ≤t≤T∗
∂t vη (t) H k−1 ≤ K . δ
(B.20)
B.3. Local existence and uniqueness. To get local existence following the approach of Taylor (see Theorem 1.2, p. 362 in [39]), we let η 0 and use the bounds (B.18)–(B.20) obtained from the energy estimates to extract a weakly convergent subsequence of vη which has a limit that solves the initial value problem (B.1)–(B.2). Since the proof is very similar to that of Theorem B.2 in [30], we omit the details. Proposition B.5. Suppose T1 , T2 > 0, δ ≤ γ ≤ 0, k > n/2 + 1, v0 ∈ Hδk , u ∈ C 0 ([−T1 , T2 ], Hγk ) and h ∈ C 0 ([−T1 , T2 ], Hδk ). Then there exists a T∗ > 0 T∗ < min{T1 , T2 } and a v ∈ L ∞ ((−T∗ , T∗ ), Hδk ) ∩ Lip((−T∗ , T∗ ), Hδk−1 ) that solves the initial value problem (B.1)–(B.2).
186
T. A. Oliynyk
Using the estimates of Appendix B of [30] and of Appendix A and B.2 of this paper, it is not difficult to adapt the proofs of Propositions 1.3–1.5, pp. 364–365, in [39] to get the following theorem. k )∩ Theorem B.6. The solution v from Proposition B.5 is unique in L ∞ ((−T1 , T2 ), Hloc k−1 Lip((−T1 , T2 ), Hloc ) and satisfies the additional regularity
v ∈ C 0 ((−T∗ , T∗ ), Hδk ) ∩ C 1 ((−T∗ , T∗ ), Hδk−1 ). Moreover, if T∗ < T2 and sup0≤T 0, δ ≤ γ ≤ 0, k > n/2 + 1, v0 ∈ Hδk , u ∈ C 0 ([−T1 , T2 ], Hγk ) and h ∈ C 0 ([−T1 , T2 ], Hδk ). Then the initial value problem b0 (u)∂t v = b j (u)∂i v + f (u)v + h, v|t=0 = v0
(B.21) (B.22)
has a solution v ∈ C 0 ([−T1 , T2 ], Hδk ) ∩ C 1 ([−T1 , T2 ], Hδk−1 )) k ) ∩ Lip((−T , T ), H k−1 ). that is unique in L ∞ ((−T1 , T2 ), Hloc 1 2 loc
Let [n/2] denote the largest integer with [n/2] ≤ n/2 and k0 = [n/2] + 2. Then differentiating the solution from Theorem B.6, with respect to t, and using Proposition B.7 yields the following result. s
k− Corollary B.8. Suppose k = k0 + s, u ∈
=0 C ([−T1 , T2 ], Hγ ) and h ∈ s k−
). Then the solution from B.5 satisfies the additional regu =0 C ([−T1 , T2 ], Hδ larity v∈
s+1
=0
C ((−T∗ , T∗ ), Hδk− ).
References 1. Bartnik, R.: The Mass of an Asymptotically Flat Manifold. Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 39, 661–693 (1986) 2. Blanchet, L., Damour, T.: Radiative gravitational fields in general relativity. I. General structure of the field outside the source. Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. Lond. A 320, 379–430 (1986) 3. Blanchet, L., Faye, G., Nissanke, S.: On the structure of the post-Newtonian expansion in general relativity. Phys. Rev. D 72, 44024 (2005) 4. Brauer, U., Karp, L.: Local existence of classical solutions for the Einstein-Euler system using weighted Sobolev spaces of fractional order. Preprint, available at http://www.math.uni-potsdam.de/prof/ a_partdiff/prep/2006_17.pdf, 2006 5. Browning, G., Kreiss, H.O.: Problems with different time scales for nonlinear partial differential equations. SIAM J. Appl. Math. 42, 704–718 (1982)
Newtonian Limit for Perfect Fluids
187
6. Chandrasekhar, S.: The post-Newtonian equations of hydrodynamics in general relativity. Ap. J. 142, 1488–1512 (1965) 7. Choquet-Bruhat, Y., Christodoulou, D.: Elliptic systems in Hs,δ spaces on manifolds which are Euclidean at infinity. Acta. Math. 146, 129–150 (1981) 8. Chru´sciel, P.T., Delay, E.: On mapping properties of the general relativistic constraints operator in weighted function spaces, with applications. Mem. Soc. Math. France 94, 1–103 (2003) 9. Dautcourt, G.: Die Newtonsche Gravitationstheorie als strenger Grenzfall der Allgemeinen Relativitätstheorie. Acta Phys. Polonica 25, 637–646 (1964) 10. Deimling, K.: Nonlinear functional analysis. Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 1998 11. Duval, C., Burdet, G., Künzle, H.P., Perrin, M.: Bargmann structures and Newton-Cartan theory. Phys. Rev. D. 31, 1841–1853 (1985) 12. Ehlers, J.: On limit relations between, and approximative explanations of, physical theories. In: R. Barcan Marcus, G.J.W. Dorn, P. Weingartner, Logic, methodology and philosophy of science VII, Amsterdam: North Holland, 1986, pp. 387-403 13. Einstein, A., Infeld, L., Hoffmann, B.: The gravitational equations and the problem of motion. Ann. Math. 39, 65–100 (1938) 14. Frauendiener, J.: A note on the relativistic Euler equations. Class. Quantum Grav. 20, L193–196 (2003) 15. Friedrich, H.: Evolution equations for gravitating ideal fluid bodies in general relativity. Phys. Rev. D 57, 2317–2322 (1998) 16. Frittelli, S., Reula, O.: On the Newtonian limit of general relativity. Commun. Math. Phys. 166, 221–235 (1994) 17. Heilig, U.: On the Existence of Rotating Stars in General Relativity. Commun. Math. Phys. 166, 457–493 (1995) 18. Iriondo, M.S., Mirta, S., Leguizamón, E.O., Reula, O.A.: Fast and slow solutions in general relativity: the initialization procedure. J. Math. Phys. 39, 1555–1565 (1998) 19. Klainerman, S., Majda, A.: Compressible and incompressible fluids. Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 35, 629–651 (1982) 20. Künzle, H.P.: Galilei and Lorentz structures on space-time: comparison of the corresponding geometry and physics. Ann. Inst. Henri Poincaré 17, 337–362 (1972) 21. Künzle, H.P.: Covariant Newtonian limit of Lorentz space-times. Gen. Rel. Grav. 7, 445–457 (1976) 22. Künzle, H.P., Duval, C.: Relativistic and non-relativistic classical field theory on five-dimensional spacetime. Class. Quantum Grav. 3, 957–974 (1986) 23. Lottermoser, M.: A convergent post-Newtonian approximation for the constraints in general relativity. Ann. Inst. Henri Poincaré 57, 279–317 (1992) 24. Makino, T.: On a local existence theorem for the evolution equation of gaseous stars. In: Patterns and Waves, edited by T. Nishida, M. Mimura, H. Fujii, Amsterdam: North-Holland, 1986 25. Maxwell, D.: Rough solutions of the Einstein constraint equations. Preprint, available at http://arxiv.org/ list/gr-qc/0405088, 2004 26. Noundjeu, P.: On the non-relativistic limit of the spherically symmetric Einstein-Vlasov-Maxwell system. Preprint available at http://arxiv.org/list/gr-qc/0508078, 2005 27. Oliynyk, T.A.: Post-Newtonian expansions for perfect fluids. In preparation. 28. Oliynyk, T.A.: Newtonian perturbations and the Einstein-Yang-Mills-dilaton equations. Class. Quantum Grav. 22, 2269–2294 (2005) 29. Oliynyk, T.A.: An existence proof for the gravitating BPS monopole. Inst. Henri Poincaré 7, 199–232 (2006) 30. Oliynyk, T.A., Woolgar, E.: Asymptotically flat Ricci flows. Preprint, available at http://arxiv.org/list/ math/0607438, 2006 31. Pati, M.E., Will, C.M.: Post-Newtonian gravitational radiation and equations of motion via direct integration of the relaxed Einstein equations: foundations. Phys. Rev. D 62, 124015 (2000) 32. Rein, G., Rendall, A.D.: The Newtonian limit of the spherically symmetric Vlasov-Einstein system. Commun. Math. Phys. 150, 585–591 (1992) 33. Rendall, A.D.: Convergent and divergent perturbation series and the post-Minkowskian approximation scheme. Class. Quantum Grav. 7, 803–812 (1990) 34. Rendall, A.D.: The initial value problem for a class of general relativistic fluid bodies. J. Math. Phys. 33, 1047–1053 (1992) 35. Rendall, A.D.: On the definition of post-Newtonian approximations. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 438, 341–360 (1992) 36. Rendall, A.D.: The Newtonian limit for asymptotically flat solutions of the Vlasov-Einstein system. Comm. Math. Phys. 163, 89–112 (1994) 37. Schochet, S.: Symmetric hyperbolic systems with a large parameter. Comm. Partial Differential Equations 11, 1627–1651 (1986)
188
T. A. Oliynyk
38. Schochet, S.: Asymptotics for symmetric hyperbolic systems with a large parameter. J. Differential Equations 75, 1–27 (1988) 39. Taylor, M.E.: Partial differential equations III, nonlinear equations. New York: Springer, 1996 40. Walton, R.A.: A symmetric hyperbolic structure for isentropic relativistic perfect fluids. Houston J. Math. 31, 145–160 (2005) 41. Will, C.M.: Post-Newtonian gravitational radiation and equations of motion via direct integration of the relaxed Einstein equations. III. Radiation reaction for binary systems with spinning bodies. Phys. Rev. D 71, 084027 (2005) Communicated by G.W. Gibbons
Commun. Math. Phys. 276, 189–220 (2007) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-007-0333-0
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Simple Systems with Anomalous Dissipation and Energy Cascade Jonathan C. Mattingly1 , Toufic Suidan2 , Eric Vanden-Eijnden3 1 Department of Mathematics and CNCS, Duke University, Durham, NC 27708, USA.
E-mail: [email protected]
2 Mathematics Department, University of California, Santa Cruz, CA 95064, USA. E-mail: [email protected] 3 Courant Institute, New York University, New York, NY 10012, USA. E-mail: [email protected]
Received: 7 July 2006 / Accepted: 11 May 2007 Published online: 14 September 2007 – © Springer-Verlag 2007
Abstract: We analyze a class of dynamical systems of the type a˙ n (t) = cn−1 an−1 (t) − cn an+1 (t) + f n (t), n ∈ N, a0 = 0, where f n (t) is a forcing term with f n (t) = 0 only for n ≤ n < ∞ and the coupling coef ficients cn satisfy a condition ensuring the formal conservation of energy 21 n |an (t)|2 . Despite being formally conservative, we show that these dynamical systems support dissipative solutions (suitably defined) and, as a result, may admit unique (statistical) steady states when the forcing term f n (t) is nonzero. This claim is demonstrated via the complete characterization of the solutions of the system above for specific choices of the coupling coefficients cn . The mechanism of anomalous dissipations is shown to arise via a cascade of the energy towards the modes with higher n; this is responsible for solutions with interesting energy spectra, namely E|an |2 scales as n −α as n → ∞. Here the exponents α depend on the coupling coefficients cn and E denotes expectation with respect to the equilibrium measure. This is reminiscent of the conjectured properties of the solutions of the Navier-Stokes equations in the inviscid limit and their accepted relationship with fully developed turbulence. Hence, these simple models illustrate some of the heuristic ideas that have been advanced to characterize turbulence, similar in that respect to the random passive scalar or random Burgers equation, but even simpler and fully solvable. 1. Introduction and Main Results: Life Starts after Blow-up So little is understood about hydrodynamic turbulence that there is not even consensus on what it is. However, most physicists would agree on the following heuristic picture which has emerged from the works of Kolmogorov, Onsager, Richardson, etc. [Fri95]. In this picture, (fully developed) turbulence refers to the idealized state of an incompressible fluid described by the Navier-Stokes equations in the limit of vanishing molecular viscosity. In this limit, the Navier-Stokes equations formally reduce to the Euler equations,
190
J. C. Mattingly, T. Suidan, E. Vanden-Eijnden
and the turbulent solutions should be the most regular solutions of the Euler equations which dissipate energy. This is referred to as anomalous dissipation and is best visualized in the Fourier representation. There it corresponds to a cascade of energy from the small wavenumbers (large spatial scales) where energy is injected (either via the initial condition or by a forcing term in the equation) towards larger and larger wavenumbers (smaller and smaller scales), up to infinity where energy should eventually be dissipated. It is also believed that the cascade of energy implies that the energy spectrum of the turbulent solutions have a power law decay in the wavenumber whose rate can be deduced by dimensional analysis and is 53 in three-dimension of space. Turbulence theory (as we shall refer to the heuristic picture above) also discusses more advanced and more controversial topics such as intermittency. But, without even going into those, most mathematicians would agree that a rigorous confirmation of the basic predictions of turbulence theory is already a tremendous challenge. The best known results on the Navier-Stokes and Euler equations which corroborate the above were obtained in [CET94, Eyi01, DR00, CR06]. These works only indicate that turbulence theory is not blatantly inconsistent. Simpler models, such as the randomly forced Burgers equation or Kraichnan’s model of passive scalar advection (see e.g. [E01, FGV01] for reviews), have also been used to demonstrate that parts of turbulence theory make sense in terms of anomalous dissipation of the weak solutions of the inviscid Burgers equation and the spectrum of energy of the solutions that this implies. Even these simple models remain surprisingly complicated to analyze and a full characterization of the statistical properties of their solutions is still lacking. One of the purposes of the present paper is to illustrate turbulence theory on even simpler models. Many (if not most) of the realistic features have been neglected in our models. Yet, the models possess a rich range of behaviors which depend on the details of the interactions. They provide a simple class of exactly solvable models which can be useful in understanding the inner workings of some energy transfer mechanisms. The solutions of these models are also consistent with much of the claims of turbulence theory. In a way, they offer a setting for the skeptical mathematician to understand the motivation behind these claims, and if this paper succeeds in doing this, we will have achieved our main goal. Next, we introduce the models that we will investigate and we summarize the principal results of the paper. As we will see, the most interesting and meaningful solutions of these models are solutions which have blown-up, such that they have become infinite in some norm. This justifies our claim that “life starts after blow-up”: Disregarding these solutions as nonsensical, as one may be tempted to do at first sight, would, in fact, completely miss the most interesting phenomena displayed by the models, namely that of anomalous dissipation (see Sect. 2 below). Regarding this last point, we note that the concept of anomalous dissipation developed in the present paper has been recently used and nicely generalized in the context of a nonlinear dyadic shell model in Refs. [CFP06a, CFP06b].
1.1. A linear shell model. Consider the equation a˙ n (t) = c (n − 1)an−1 (t) − nan+1 (t) for n ∈ N with the boundary condition a0 (t) = 0 for all t. If c > 0, we can rescale time to fix c = 1; observe also that if an satisfies the equations with the parameter c < 0 then aˆ n (t) = (−1)n+1 an (t) satisfies the equations with parameter |c|.
Simple Systems with Anomalous Dissipation and Energy Cascade
191
In light of these considerations, we set c = 1 and focus our attention on a˙ n (t) = (n − 1)an−1 (t) − nan+1 (t)
(1)
for n ∈ N with the boundary condition a0 (t) = 0 for all t. Although we will see that this calculation is not always correct, on the formal level one has that ∞ ∞ 1d |an (t)|2 = [(n − 1)an−1 (t)an (t) − nan+1 (t)an (t)] 2 dt n=1
=
n=1 ∞
nan (t)an+1 (t) −
n=1
∞
(2) nan (t)an+1 (t) = 0 .
n=1
The second equality is only formal as it assumes that the sum ∞ n=1 nan (t)an+1 (t) is finite and absolutely convergent. To understand this further, consider the evolution of the partial sum n≤N |an (t)|2 . For N ∈ N, 1d |an (t)|2 = −N a N (t)a N +1 (t). 2 dt
(3)
n≤N
The validity of (2) necessitates lim N a N (t)a N +1 (t) = 0.
N →∞
(4)
If this condition is not satisfied, then the formal manipulation in (2) does not hold and the seemingly conservative coupling term in (1) may become a source of anomalous dissipation. We make the concept of anomalous dissipation precise in Sect. 2. But, roughly speaking, it is when seemingly conservative terms have a dissipative effect on the system. In the context of Eq. (1), anomalous dissipation seems to require that the limit as N → ∞ of the right hand side of (3) be negative. In other words, Eq. (1) is dissipative at time t if lim inf nan (t)an+1 (t) > 0. (5) n→∞
If we make the reasonable assumption that limn an+1 /an ∈ (0, ∞), then from (5) the solution of Eq. (1) will be dissipative with a finite dissipation rate provided that 1 an (t) √ n
as n → ∞.1
(6)
At this point some readers may be skeptical since one typically considers equations like (1) with initial data in 2 , the space of square-summable sequences. However, we will see (Theorem 1 in Sect. 3) that Eq. (1) has solutions which exist for all time provided lim sup |an (0)|1/n ≤ 1 . n→∞
1 We say that f (m) g(m) as m → ∞ if there exists an m and c ≥ 1 so that if m > m then 1 1 1 g(m) ≤ f (m) ≤ cg(m). Similarly, we say that f (m) ∼ g(m) as m → m if lim f (m)/g(m) = 1 as 0 c m → m0.
192
J. C. Mattingly, T. Suidan, E. Vanden-Eijnden
This condition admits a large class of initial conditions including those which scale as (6). In Sect. 3, we will also see that (1) possesses a wide verity of behavior including conservative, dissipative, and explosive solutions. It might be tempting to dismiss these non-conservative solutions as non-physical solutions arising from pathological data. We now discuss why this is not the case. Consider Eq. (1) with a white-noise forcing in the first coordinate: a˙ n (t) = (n − 1)an−1 (t) − nan+1 (t) + 1n=1 W˙ (t),
(7)
where 1n=m is 1 if n = m and 0 otherwise, and W (t) denotes a standard Brownian motion, i.e. Gaussian process with mean zero and covariance EW (t)W (s) = min(t, s). If one were to accept the formal calculations in (2), showing energy conservation, then E
∞ n=1
|an (t)|2 = E
∞
|an (0)|2 + t
n=1
if the energy is initially finite. Hence, in the forced system energy seems to grow linearly with time and at t = ∞ one expects the system to have infinite energy. These solutions which “blow-up” (in the sense that they have infinite energy) are the most interesting and relevant. In light of the discussion above, one might expect that the energy of the system would grow to be infinite and arrange the an so that the calculation in (2) is not valid since the sum is not rearrangeable. Onsager would then predict that the system would evolve to the state in which the an decayed as fast as possible but still dissipated energy in the sense that (5) holds. √ The reasoning which leads to (6) strongly suggests that the |an | should scale as 1/ n. In fact, if the system is to reach some equilibrium the effect of the dissipation must exactly balance that of the forcing. Specifically, in the stochastic setting when the forcing is W˙ (t)1n=1 , limn n E(an (t)an+1 (t)) → 1 as t → ∞. All of these conclusions turn out to be correct. In particular, in Sect. 6 we prove that if n |an (0)|2 < ∞ then the solutions converge to a unique random variable a ∗∗ = (a1∗∗ , a2∗∗ , · · · ) which is Gaussian with mean zero and whose distribution is the unique stationary measure for the system. Furthermore, this equilibrium state has a √ structure which is consistent with the anticipated 1/ n scaling: ∗∗ = lim E an (t)am (t) = E an∗∗ am
t→∞
1 . n+m−1
(8)
We also show that similar behaviors are observed with a different type of forcing. In particular, if the forcing is constant, a˙ n (t) = (n − 1)an−1 (t) − nan+1 (t) + 1n=1 , then the system evolves to a unique steady state an∗ which scales as √ π Γ ( n2 ) π ∗ . ∼ lim an (t) = an = n−1 t→∞ n nΓ ( 2 )
(9)
(10)
In summary, we see that the forced systems’ energy grows linearly with time if the energy is initially finite. Asymptotically, the system rearranges itself so that it reaches a state which dissipates energy at t = ∞. This state is chosen so that the dissipation rate matches the energy flux√into the system from the forcing. Since the energy flux is finite, this leaves |an | 1/ n as the only choice. A slower decay rate would produce an infinite rate of dissipation and a faster decay rate would produce a system which conserved energy since the limit in (5) would be zero.
Simple Systems with Anomalous Dissipation and Energy Cascade
193
1.2. A second linear shell model. We introduce a second model which also exhibits interesting but different “blow-up” behavior. Consider b˙n = (n − 1)(n − 21 )bn−1 − n(n + 21 )bn+1
(11)
for n ∈ N with the boundary condition b0 (t) = 0 for all t. As in the previous subsection, the unforced equation formally conserves energy since ∞ ∞ 1d 2 bn (t) = [(n − 1)(n − 21 )bn−1 (t)bn (t) − n(n + 21 )bn+1 (t)bn (t)] = 0. (12) 2 dt n=1
n=1
This equality (as in the case of Eq. (1)) is only formal since, in general, the sum cannot be rearranged. As before, to gain insight we consider the partial sums. For N ∈ N, 1d 2 bn (t) = −N (N + 21 )b N (t)b N +1 (t). 2 dt n≤N
With this in mind, (11) will be called conservative if lim N (N + 21 )b N (t)b N +1 (t) = 0,
N →∞
and dissipative if
lim inf N (N + 21 )b N (t)b N +1 (t) > 0. N →∞
Unlike the case of Eq. (1), if one assumes that lim N →∞ b N +1 /b N exists and is in (0, ∞), then the solution of Eq. (11) will be dissipative if bn 1/n as n → ∞. 2 A solution satisfying bn (t) 1/n (if one exists) has finite energy: ∞ n=1 bn (t) < ∞. Thus, this model differs from the first example in that the system can dissipate energy even when the total energy is finite. While we do not prove a general existence result as broad as for (1), we do show (in Theorem 16) that the dynamics for (11) are well defined if ∞ (−1)n bn (0)
(13)
n=1
converges. This is sufficient for our needs: In particular, it covers the case when bn 1/n as n → ∞. The differences between the first and second models are greater than simply the scaling. When started with initial conditions having finite energy the first model conserves energy. In fact the regularity at time t is the same as the regularity of the initial condition. In contrast, if we start (11) with initial data satisfying (13) (and hence with finite energy), the energy decays with time. Furthermore, for almost every t > 0 one has that bn (t) 1/n as n → ∞ and there exists T , depending on the initial data, so that if t > s > T then ∞ ∞ ∞ bn2 (t) < bn2 (s) < bn2 (T ) < ∞ and
n=1
bn2 (t)
n=1
n=1
→ 0 and t → ∞. Turning to the forced setting, consider b˙n = (n − 1)(n − 21 )bn−1 − n(n + 21 )bn+1 + f (t)1n=1 .
194
J. C. Mattingly, T. Suidan, E. Vanden-Eijnden
When f (t) = W˙ (t) then ∗∗ Ebn∗∗ bn+m
If f (t) = 1, we have bn∗
1 as n → ∞. n(n + m) 1 as n → ∞. n
1.3. Inviscid limits of the first model. In practice, one is often interested in understanding the limit of equations when the explicit sources of dissipation are removed. To explore this question we investigate Eq. (1) with the addition of an overtly dissipative term and then study the limit as the dissipation is removed. To understand our motivation, recall that we have seen that if the first model is started with finite energy initial data then the formal calculation presented in (2) is valid for all finite times as the energy must be infinity for (2) to fail. Yet, as time tends to infinity, the forced system converges to a steady state with infinite energy for which the calculation presented in (2) fails. In contrast, in the second model the analogous calculation, given in (12), fails at almost every positive time since b(t) 1/n as n → ∞ for almost every t > 0. Since the coupling term produces dissipation at finite times in the second model, it is most interesting to study the effect of extra, explicit dissipation in the first model. To this end, we consider the stochastically forced version of the first model with extra, explicit dissipation sufficient to keep the expected energy of the system finite for all times. In particular, the calculation in (2) is valid in the equilibrium state. We are interested in the structure of this invariant state and how it converges to the steady state without the explicit dissipation (as the dissipation is removed). We will consider two cases, one for which the dissipative term is lower order than the coupling term and one for which it is equal order. Specifically, for p ∈ {0, 1} and any ν > 0, consider the equation α˙ n,ν = −2ν(n − 1) p αn,ν + (n − 1)αn−1,ν − nαn+1,ν + 1n=1 W˙ (t). The case p = 0 corresponds to the uniform damping of all the modes and is analogous to what is called Eckmann damping in the context of fluid mechanics since it is subordinate to the nonlinearity. When p = 1 the intensity of the damping increases with the mode index, and it behaves as a viscous term in the language of fluid mechanics since it is the leading order term. As in the previous2 examples, we force the first coordinate with white noise. Assuming that |αn,ν (0)| < ∞, it is straightforward to see that |αn,ν (t)|2 stays finite and uniformly bounded in time for any ν > 0. Hence, the system remains conservative for all time. Furthermore, as t → ∞ the system converges ∗∗ whose distribution is the unique stationary measure for the to a random variable αn,ν system. Direct calculation in the spirit of (2) shows that E
∞ 1 ∗∗ 2 (n − 1) p |αn,ν | = . ν n=1
Thus, there is no anomalous dissipation in the system: All of the dissipation which balances the forcing comes from the term −2ν(n − 1) p αn (t). In Sect. 8, we will see that for p ∈ {0, 1}, ∗∗ E[αn,ν − an∗∗ ]2 → 0 as ν → 0.
Simple Systems with Anomalous Dissipation and Energy Cascade
195
Both of these steady states are Gaussian with mean zero. The way in which the ∗∗ converges (as ν → 0) to that of the ν = 0 steady state a ∗∗ is different variance of αn,ν n for the two values of p we consider. When p = 0 one has ∗∗ 2 E[αn,ν ] = 21−2ν Γ (1 + 2ν)
1 Γ (2n + 1 − 2ν) 1+2ν . Γ (2n + 2) n
(14)
This shows that variances still decay like a power of n. Notice that for all ν > 0 the total energy is finite. When p = 1 we do not obtain an exact formula but rather that ∗∗ 2 1 1 1 κ2 ≤ E αn,ν , ≤ 2n 2n+2 (κ + ν) 2n + 1 κ 2n + 1
(15)
∗∗ behave as the limiting a ∗∗ for where κ 2 = 1 + ν 2 . Since κ > 1 when ν > 0, the αn,ν n small n but decay exponentially for large n.
1.4. Organization. The remainder of the paper is concerned with proving the statements made in this section. Section 2 contains a precise discussion of the concept of anomalous dissipation. In Sect. 3, we return to the first of the two models introduced in Sect. 1 and illustrate the range of possible dynamics by considering specific initial conditions for which the system can be explicitly solved. In Sects. 4 and 5, we prove the existence of solutions and describe their properties for a wide range of initial data. In Sect. 7, we give the proofs of all of the preceding results. Section 6 discusses the forced setting for the first example and Sect. 8 discusses its inviscid limit. Finally, in Sect. 9 we discuss the second model introduced in Sect. 1: we first describe the qualitative behavior of solutions; then, we prove existence and uniqueness results both in the forced and unforced situations. We note that some of the results about anomalous dissipation and the scaling of the solutions can also be obtained by formally taking the continuous limit in n of (1) and (11). In this limit, these equation formally reduce to hyperbolic conservation laws which were analyzed in [Sri05]. 2. Preliminary: Definition of Anomalous Dissipation The concepts of energy conservation, dissipation, and explosion are straightforward when the total energy of the system is finite. A system is conservative if the energy does not change with time. A system is dissipative (or explosive) if the total energy decreases (or increases) with time. However, as the example in the previous section showed, it is possible to have solutions which one might call dissipative even though the total energy is infinite. We give a definition of the above terms which can be applied to situations where the total energy is infinite. Given a time-dependent sequence, {an (t)}n∈N , define the energy in the block M to N , M < N , by N E M,N (t) = |an (t)|2 . n=M
A given block E M,N is dissipative at time t if E˙M,N (t) < 0. Similarly, we will say it is explosive if E˙M,N (t) > 0. If E˙M,N (t) = 0 then we say the block is conservative at
196
J. C. Mattingly, T. Suidan, E. Vanden-Eijnden
time t. If E˙M,N (t) = 0 for all M, N , and t, then the system is at a fixed point. (Note that this is consistent with Example 4 in the next section.) We will say that the system is locally dissipative (locally explosive, or locally conservative) at time t if every finite block is dissipative (explosive or conservative) at time t. In contrast, we will say that a system with E0,∞ = ∞ is dissipative at time t if the limit d lim sup E0,N (t) < 0. dt N →∞ We say it is explosive at time t if lim inf N →∞
d E0,N (t) > 0. dt
When the limit exists we will refer to its absolute value as the rate of energy dissipation or the rate of energy explosion depending on the inequality which is satisfied. We say that the system with E0,∞ = ∞ is conservative at time t if lim
N →∞
d E0,N (t) = 0. dt
If we do not state time explicitly for any of these properties, we mean that the properties hold for all finite times. As the examples of the next section show, it is possible for lim N E0,N = ∞ while lim N E˙0,N = c < 0. Remark 1. It is important to notice that the above categorizations are not exhaustive. It is possible for a system not to fit into any of the categories. This is only an issue when the energy is infinite as we use the definitions at the start when the energy is finite. 3. The Rich Behavior of the First Model The system given by (1) possesses a number of interesting properties beyond those listed in the introductory section. In this section we explore the behavior through a number of examples. A relatively complete theory of the equation will be given in the two sections which follow. We begin with an existence result which covers all of the examples presented. For an infinite vector a = (a1 , a2 , · · · ) with ai ∈ R, define ρ(a) by 1 = lim sup |an |1/n . ρ(a) n→∞
(16)
(ρ(a) is simply the radius of convergence of the power series n an z n ). The following theorem gives an existence and uniqueness result for (1) sufficient for present needs. In particular, it allows initial data with infinite energy ( |an (0)|2 = ∞). A more complete description will be given in Theorem 4 of Sect. 4, where we describe the methodology for solving (1). Theorem 1. If a(0) = (a1 (0), a2 (0), · · · ) is an infinite vector of initial conditions such that ρ(a(0)) > 0, then there exists a unique solution a(t) to (1) with initial conditions a(0) which exist at least up to the time t∗ = arctanh(ρ(a) ∧ 1).
Simple Systems with Anomalous Dissipation and Energy Cascade
197
This existence result, whose proof is given in Sect. 4, covers a wide class of initial data. The dynamical behavior of (1) is quite rich. We list a number of exact solutions which display the range of possible behaviors. Explanations of how these results are obtained will be given in Sect. 4.1. A general discussion of the qualitative properties of solutions of (1) will be given in Sect. 5. Example 1. An energy conserving pulse heading out to infinity: Fixing a1 (0) = 1 and an (0) = 0 for all n = 2, 3, . . . results in the dynamics an (t) =
tanhn−1 (t) . cosh(t)
Even though the solution ∞ decays2 to zero pointwise in n as t → ∞ it conserves energy: ∞ 2 = |a (t)| n n=1 n=1 |an (0)| = 1 for all t ≥ 0. The fact that it conserves energy is consistent with the observations in Eq. (2) and (4) because 1d N tanh N −1 (t) tanh N (t) |an (t)|2 = −N a N (t)a N +1 (t) = − →0 2 dt cosh2 (t) n≤N
as N → ∞. The dynamics of this solution can be understood as pulse moving out to larger and larger N with time while simultaneously spreading out. A simple calculation shows that a N (t) reaches its maximum at a time asymptotic to 21 log(1+4N ) as N → ∞. Hence, as t → ∞ the n for which an which is cresting at time t scales as 41 exp(2t). Example 2. Dissipative solution with finite dissipation rate: If an+1 (0) =
(2n)! 1 ∼√ for n = 0, 1, . . ., 22n (n!)2 πn
then n e−t/2 (2(n − m))!(2m)! tanhn−m (t) for n = 0, 1, . . .. an+1 (t) = √ cosh(t) m=0 22n ((n − m)!m!)2
For each fixed n, we have an (t) ∼
√
2e−t
as t → ∞,
so that the solution decays to zero pointwise in n as t → ∞. On the other hand, since for any fixed time t,
it follows that
∞
e−t/2 1 an (t) ∼ √ √ cosh t π n
n=1 |an (t)|
2
as n → ∞,
= +∞ for all time t ≥ 0 and
e−t 1d <0 |an (t)|2 = −N a N (t)a N +1 (t) → − 2 dt π cosh t n≤N
as N → ∞. For this solution, the calculation in (2) does not hold and the above inequality can be interpreted as a form of anomalous dissipation with finite dissipation rate.
198
J. C. Mattingly, T. Suidan, E. Vanden-Eijnden
Example 3. Dissipative solution with infinite dissipation rate: If an (0) = 1 for all n = 1, 2, . . .. then an (t) = e−t for all n = 1, 2, . . . . 2 This solution decays to zero pointwise in n as t → ∞ and ∞ n=1 |an (t)| = +∞ for all t ≥ 0. Notice that 1d |an (t)|2 = −N a N (t)a N +1 (t) = −N e−2t → −∞ 2 dt n≤N
as N → ∞. The formal calculation in (2) does not hold for this solution and, in terms of the definitions of Sect. 2, we view this as a form of anomalous dissipation with infinite dissipation rate. Example 4. A fixed point: If a2n (0) = 0 for n = 1, 2, . . . and a2n+1 (0) =
(2n)! 22n (n!)2
1 ∼√ for n = 0, 1, . . ., πn
then an (t) = an (0) for all n = 1, 2, . . .. This solution is a fixed point of (1). Notice that N 1d |an (t)|2 = −N a N (t)a N +1 (t) = 0 2 dt n=1
for all N ∈ N, but
∞
n=1 |an (t)|
2
√ = +∞ since a2n+1 ∼ 1/ π n as n → ∞.
Example 5. Explosive solution with infinite explosion time: If an (0) = (−1)n+1 for n = 1, 2, . . . , then an (t) = (−1)n+1 et for all n = 1, 2, . . .. In this case,
∞
n=1 |an (t)|
2
= +∞ and
N 1d |an (t)|2 = −N a N (t)a N +1 (t) = N e2t → +∞ 2 dt n=1
as N → ∞. Thus, (2) does not hold for this solution and we see that the above limit is consistent with an infinite explosion rate for the solution. This is consistent with Theorem 1 as ρ(a) = 1 and t∗ = arctanh(1) = ∞. Example 6. Explosive solution with finite explosion time: If an (0) = (−1)n+1 α n with α > 1 for n = 1, 2, . . . , then an (t) =
(−1)n+1 α n for t < t∗ = arctanh(1/α) and all n = 1, 2, . . .. cosh(t) − α sinh(t)
Simple Systems with Anomalous Dissipation and Energy Cascade
This solution blows up at t = t∗ . In this case,
199
∞
n=1 |an (t)|
2
= +∞ for all t < t∗ and
1d N α 2N +1 |an (t)|2 = −N a N (t)a N +1 (t) = → +∞ 2 dt (cosh(t) − α sinh(t))2 n≤N as N → ∞ for all t < t∗ . Notice that this example is consistent with Theorem 1 as ρ(a) = 1/α < 1. The above examples demonstrate the rich range of behavior of the model. In particular, some solutions grow coordinate-wise in time while others decay. The following result gives a criteria for the later. Theorem 2. Let (a1 (0), a2 (0), · · · ) be the infinite vector of initial conditions. If the limit lim +
r →−1
∞
an (0)r n
(17)
n=1
exists and is finite, then for all n ∈ N, |an (t)| → 0 as t → ∞. Looking back at the examples, this result correctly separates those which decay to zero pointwise in n and those which do not. Denote by p the p-summable sequences: For p > 0, := (a1 , a2 , . . .) : p
∞
|an | < ∞ . p
(18)
n=1
If a = (a1 , a2 , . . .) ∈ 1 then (17) exists and is finite. For future reference, we recall the p def p norm · p defined by a p = ∞ n=1 |an | . A complimentary question is to understand for which initial data the system conserves energy. Theorem 3. If a(0) = (a1 (0), a2 (0), · · · ) ∈ 2 , then a(0)22 = a(t)22 for all time t ≥ 0. Example 1, 2 and 3 all have nice limits at z = −1 in the sense of (17) and they decay to zero as t → ∞ as dictated by Theorem 2. It is particularly interesting to compare Example 3 and 5. Theorem 2 correctly says that the first decays to zero as time increases while declining to comment on the second. Theorem 3 correctly states that Example 1 conserves energy. However, Theorem 3 is not completely satisfactory in that it only applies to solutions which have finite total energy. A number of our examples have infinite energy. We now turn to understanding in detail the dynamics of (1).
200
J. C. Mattingly, T. Suidan, E. Vanden-Eijnden
4. Solution to the Initial Value Problem In this section we show that the initial value problem associated to Eq. (1) is well-posed and admits solutions for a wide class of initial data. Theorem 1 above is an immediate consequence of Theorem 4 below. After giving a general existence and uniqueness theorem, we present specific initial conditions (covered by the existence theorem) for which Eq. (1) admits solutions which conserve energy, dissipate energy, and blow up in finite time. We begin by formally calculating a representation of the solution given by a generating function. We will verify that the representation is valid in the next section. Given initial conditions {an (0) : an (0) ∈ R, n ∈ N}, we assume that a solution an (t) exists and define the generating function G(z, t) =
∞
an+1 (t)z n .
(19)
n=0
Proceeding formally, it is straightforward to verify that G(z, t) would satisfy the following partial differential equation: ∂G ∂G = (z 2 − 1) + zG ∂t ∂z
(20)
with initial condition G 0 (z) = def
∞
an+1 (0)z n .
(21)
n=0 ∂ The first term on the right hand side of (1) comes from z ∂z (zG) and the second from ∂ − ∂z G.
One obtains an ansatz for the form of the solution by solving Eq. (20) by the method of characteristics. By verifying that this ansatz solves the equation, we obtain the following existence and uniqueness result whose proof is postponed until Sect.7. Theorem 4. Consider (1) with the initial condition an (0) such that G 0 (z) is analytic in a neighborhood of the interval (α, 0]. Then the solution of (1) exists and is unique for all t ∈ [0, t∗ ), where t∗ = arctanh(−α ∧ 1). The unique solution is given by G(z, t) an (t) = dz (22) n Γ 2πi z with G(z, t) = def
where ψt (z) = def
ψt (z) (G 0 ◦ φt )(z), cosh(t)
1 z − tanh(t) def and φt (z) = . 1 − z tanh(t) 1 − z tanh(t)
(23)
(24)
Γ is any simple closed contour around the origin within the region of analyticity of G(z, t) (which is non-empty).
Simple Systems with Anomalous Dissipation and Energy Cascade
201
It is worth noting that G(z, t) solves the PDE given in (20) with G(z, 0) = G 0 (z) as initial condition. Notice that finite time existence of solutions only requires that the initial data an (0) have at most exponential growth in n, i.e. there exists C > 0 and γ > 1 such that for all n ∈ N, |an (0)| ≤ Cγ n . If the an (0) decay exponentially then the solution exists for all times (i.e. t∗ = ∞). In addition, (22) implies that an+1 (t) is the n th term of the Taylor series expansion of G(z, t) about z = 0. It is also straightforward to see that (22) defines a semigroup: for any suitable f (z), let 1 ψt (z) f (φt (z)) . cosh(t)
(St f )(z) :=
(25)
Then (23) can be expressed as G(·, t) = St G 0 and it is easy to check that for any t, s > 0, St ◦ Ss f = Ss ◦ St f = St+s f. Since we are particularly interested in knowing the total energy of the solution, it is useful to notice that if G(x, t) is as in (19) then a(t)22 = def
∞
|an (t)|2 =
n=1
1 2π
2π 0
|G(eiθ , t)|2 dθ = G(eiθ , t)2L 2 (S 1 ,dθ) . def
We shall give more properties of the solutions of Eq. (1) in Sect. 5 after a brief discussion of the examples given in the previous section.
4.1. Analysis of examples. We use Theorem 4 to calculate exact the solutions given in Sect. 3. The initial data in Example 1 translates into G 0 (z) = 1, so that G(z, t) =
1 . cosh(t) − z sinh(t)
Calculating the Taylor series gives the quoted an (t). In Example 2 one obtains G 0 (z) = √ 1/ 1 − z. Hence, 1 e−t/2 , G(z, t) = √ √ cosh(t) (1 − z)(1 − z tanh(t)) whose Taylor expansion produces the quoted an (t). Example 3 yields G 0 (z)√= 1/(1−z), G(z, t) = e−t√/(1 − z) and the desired an . Example 4 gives G 0 (z) = 1/ 1 − z 2 and et . G(z, t) = 1/ 1 − z 2 ≡ G 0 (z). Example 5 gives G 0 (z) = 1/(1 + z) and G(z, t) = 1+z Example 6 gives G 0 (z) = α/(1 + αz) and G(z, t) =
α 1 cosh(t) − α sinh(t) 1 + αz
it blows up at t = t∗ as stated.
for t < t∗ = arctanh(1/α);
202
J. C. Mattingly, T. Suidan, E. Vanden-Eijnden
5. Properties of the Solutions We begin by presenting two results which are more quantitative versions of the results in Theorem 2 and Theorem 3. Together, they highlight the fact that it is possible to have a given coordinate converge to zero while no global energy dissipation is present in the system. This implies that there is a flux of energy out to higher and higher modes. It is also interesting that both of the next two results apply in some situations where the total energy is infinite. Theorem 5. Suppose that G 0 (z) is analytic in a neighborhood of (−1, 0] such that G +0 (−1) = lim + G 0 (x)
(26)
x→−1 x∈R
exists and is finite. Then, an (t) ∼ 2e−t G +0 (−1) as t → ∞. In particular, in a neighborhood of the origin G(z, t) ∼ 2e−t G +0 (−1)/(1−z) as t → ∞. Remark 2. If an = n −α for α < 1, then an (t) ∼ 2e−t Γ (1 − α) as t → ∞. The next result contains Theorem 3 as well as giving control of higher Sobolev-like norms. We recall the Sobolev-like sequence spaces for s ∈ R: def
h s = a = (a1 , a2 , . . .) : ah s < ∞ , where the norm · h s is defined by a2h s = def
∞
n=1 n
2s |a |2 . n
Theorem 6. If a(0)22 = def
∞
|an (0)|2 < ∞,
n=1
then a(0)22 = a(t)22 for all t ≥ 0. Similarly, for any s ∈ N, if a(0)2h s = def
∞
n 2s |an (0)|2 < ∞,
n=1
then for any T < ∞ there exists a constant, C(T ), such that sup a(t)2h s ≤ C(T ).
t∈[0,T ]
Simple Systems with Anomalous Dissipation and Energy Cascade
203
5.1. Finer properties of solutions. We begin by giving conditions guaranteeing that the solution decays exponentially in time. We then turn to the case for which G 0 has singularities on the boundary of the unit circle. We close the section with a result which compares the dynamics obtained by placing a single unit of mass at different locations. Let D(r ) denote the open disk of radius r about the origin. We begin with a simple criteria which guarantees that the an decay exponentially in n. Theorem 7. Suppose G 0 (z) is analytic in the disk D(1 + η) for some η > 0. Then, for each T ≥ 0, there exist constants γ , C > 0 which depend only on η and T such that sup |an (t)| ≤ Cγ n for all n ∈ N.
t∈[0,T ]
In particular, the system conserves energy at all finite times. In order to investigate the behavior of solutions when G 0 (z) is not analytic in D(1+η) for some η > 0, we introduce the following region: ∆(ζ, η, θ ) = {z : |z| ≤ |ζ | + η, | arg(z − ζ ) − arg(ζ )| ≥ θ} . def
(27)
We begin with a careful analysis of the case when there is a single singularity on the unit circle. We contrast the cases for which the singularity is located at ±1 in Theorem 8 and Theorem 9, respectively. The remaining cases are covered by Theorem 10. Theorem 8. Assume that either an (0) ∼ Cn α−1 as n → ∞ for some C = 0 or, more generally, that G 0 (z) satisfies both of the following conditions: i) There exist an A = 0 and α > 0 so that G 0 (z) ∼ A(1 − z)−α
as z → 1.
(28)
ii) G 0 (z) is analytic on ∆(1, η, θ )\{1} for some η > 0 and 0 < θ < π/2. Then, for all time t ≥ 0, an (t) ∼
A (1−2α)t α−1 e n as n → ∞, Γ (α)
(29)
and the solution decays to zero as t → ∞ pointwise in n; more precisely, an (t) ∼ A21−α e−t as t → ∞ . Notice the setting of Theorem 8 the energy of the system is infinite for all that in 2 α > 0: ∞ n=1 an (t) = +∞. However, as a direct consequence of (29) in Theorem 8 and our definition of dissipation in Sect. 2 the following is true: Corollary 1. In the setting of Theorem 8: if 0 < α < 1/2 the system is conservative; if α = 1/2 the system displays a finite dissipation rate; and, if α > 1/2 the system displays an infinite dissipation rate.
204
J. C. Mattingly, T. Suidan, E. Vanden-Eijnden
We now consider a singularity at z = −1. The remaining points on the unit circle behave much like the z = 1 in that the solution decays to zero in time. They are discussed in Theorem 10 later in the section. The next result shows that if there is a singularity at z = −1 then the system can explode in time. Theorem 9. Assume that either an (0) ∼ C(−1)n n α−1 as n → ∞ for some C = 0 or, more generally, that G 0 (z) satisfies both of the following conditions: i) There exist an A = 0 and α > 0 so that G 0 (z) ∼ A(z + 1)−α
as z → −1.
(30)
ii) G 0 (z) is analytic on ∆(−1, η, θ )\{−1} for some η > 0 and 0 < θ < π/2. Then, for all time t ≥ 0, an (t) ∼
A (2α−1)t (−1)n n α−1 as n → ∞, e Γ (α)
while for n fixed α as t → ∞, an (t) ∼ 21−α e(2α−1)t ACn−1
where Cnα is the n th coefficient of the Taylor series expansion at z = 0 of the function
1−z α 1 . 1−z 1+z 2 Notice that the energy of the system is again infinite for all α > 0: ∞ n=1 |an (t)| = +∞. However, we have: Corollary 2. In the setting of Theorem 9: If 0 < α < 1/2, the system is conservative; if α = 1/2, it displays a finite explosion rate; and, if α > 1/2, it displays an infinite explosion rate. Remark 3. One must be careful when interpreting the results in Corollary 2 since the system has infinite energy. For example, when α = 1/2 then at each moment of time the system displays a finite explosion rate since energy is pumped in from infinity into any finite collection of modes. However, the rate must slow, falling to zero at t = ∞, since as t → ∞ the system converges to the fixed point given in Example 4. This follows from the fact discussed in Sect. √ 4.1 that the fixed point in Example 4 corresponds to the initial function G(z) = B/ 1 − z 2 for some B = 0. We now give a more general result covering a singularity on the unit circle at any point other than −1. Theorem 8 is a special case of the following result when ζ = 1. Theorem 10. Let ζ be a point on the unit circle not equal to −1. Assume that G 0 (z) behaves as (31) G 0 (z) ∼ A(ζ − z)−α with A = 0 and α > 0 as z → ζ ,
Simple Systems with Anomalous Dissipation and Energy Cascade
205
and that G 0 (z) is analytic on ∆(ζ, η, θ )\{ζ } for some η > 0 and 0 < θ < π/2. Then, for all time t ≥ 0,
1−2α 1+ζ A 1−ζ et + e−t ζtn n α−1 as n → ∞, an (t) ∼ Γ (α) 2 2 where ζt = φt−1 (ζ ). (Notice that φt−1 (1) = 1 and ζt → 1 as t → ∞.) The solution decays to zero as t → ∞ pointwise in n: an (t) ∼ 2e−t
A as t → ∞ . (1 + ζ )α
From the examples above it is natural to conjecture that any singularity on the unit circle dominated by a polynomial-like singularity of degree less than 1/2 will not destroy energy conservation. It can be shown that this intuition is correct for a wide class of initial conditions. We already know that if the initial conditions have finite energy, then energy is conserved. By the reasoning in the section defining anomalous dissipation, it is enough to have 1 lim n 2 |an | = 0 . (32) n→∞
This is possible even if the total energy is infinite. Using the Tauberian theorems in [Hil01] we can show that the dynamics preserves a subset of sequences satisfying (32). These solutions have infinite energy yet conserve energy in the sense of Sect. 2. As these results are tangential and a bit technical we do not give the details. 5.2. The fixed point. By combining the results of the previous section, one can understand a wide range of behavior. We illustrate this by examining the convergence√to a fix point. In Example 4, we saw that the initial data corresponding to G 0 (z) = 1/ 1 − z 2 was invariant under the dynamics. This function is analytic in the open unit disk and has two square root singularities on the unit circle: one at z = 1 and another at z = −1. Up to a technicality, we show that this is the only fixed point that characterizes the initial data that converges to it. If the solution is to exist for all times the function G 0 (z) must be analytic in a neighborhood of (−1, 0]. From Theorem 5, we see that if the limit as z → −1 of G 0 (z) is finite then the solution converges to zero pointwise in n as t → ∞. Hence, if the system converges to a nontrivial steady state, it must have a singularity at z = −1. We assume that the singularity is power-like (i.e. (z + 1)−α ). One can likely deal with other singularities, however, we choose not to pursue this matter here. Theorem 9 implies that the singularity must be order 1/2 if it is a power; otherwise, the system would blow or decay to zero. The question is: Can one make sense of the dynamics when up |an |2 = ∞? The two facts above imply that any initial condition which has only polynomial singularities at z = −1 (if any) and which converges to a fixed point must be of the form: A G 0 (z) = + G˜ 0 (z), (33) 1 (1 + z) 2 where A = 0 and G˜ 0 is analytic in a neighborhood of (−1, 0] and G˜ 0 (z) → G˜ +0 < ∞ as z → −1 from the right along the real axis. By Theorem 5 the dynamics starting from ∞ pointwise in the sequence space. Theorem 8 says that G˜ 0 converge to zero as t → the first term converges to A 2/(1 − z 2 ) as t → ∞. Hence, all data of the form (33) converge to the fix point from Example 4. We have proved the following result:
206
J. C. Mattingly, T. Suidan, E. Vanden-Eijnden
Theorem 11. Let (a1 (0), a2 (0), . . .) be an initial condition such that the solutions exist for all time and converge coordinate-wise to a fixed vector (a¯ 1 , a¯ 2 , . . .) which is not the zero vector. Assuming that the G 0 (z) associated to this initial condition has only a power-like singularity at z = −1 then G 0 is of the form given in (33) and ∞ 2 n a¯ n+1 z = A . (34) 1 − z2 n=0
In particular, all fixed points of Eq. (1) are given by the Taylor series of (34). Notice that the fixed points have infinite energy and have the property that all of the an , with n odd, are equal to zero. In Sect. 6, we will see that steady states with less degenerate structure are obtained by forcing the system. Remark 4. If one starts with an initial condition which has a polynomial singularity on the unit circle at ζ = −1 and of an order β + 1/2 with β > 0, then for all finite times the norm a(t)h s will be infinite if s ≥ −β. Yet the dynamics still converges to the fixed point given by Theorem 11. Hence, at t = ∞ all · h s norms are finite for s < 0. 5.3. The effect of shifting the initial condition. In Example 1 we described how a unit of mass placed at a1 spreads out. The following theorem states that the solution obtained by placing a unit of mass in a p behaves in the same way as the solution obtained by placing a mass at a1 except that the picture is shifted p units down the chain. Theorem 12. Let G 0 (z) = z p for some p ∈ N, then tanhn+ p (t) tanhn− p+ξ (t) + βn (t) , cosh(t) cosh(t) where ξ = p − p ∧ n and βn (t) satisfies n p 1 − tanh2 p (t) n≥p . |βn (t)| ≤ p−n 2n p n tanh (t) 1 − tanh (t) n < p an (t) = (−1) p
Proof (Theorem 12). First observe that G(z, t) =
z − tanh(t) p cosh−1 (t) . 1 − z tanh(t) 1 − z tanh(t)
Expanding this we find ∞
G(z, t) =
1 z n (−1) p tanhn+ p (t) + βn tanhn− p+ξ (t) , cosh(t) n=0
where βn (t) = tanh
p∧n
p∧n k n −1 p−k p . tanh (t) − tanh(t) [− tanh(t)] (t) k k k=1
So |βn (t)| ≤ n p
p∧n k p . 1 − tanh2 (t) [tanh(t)] p∧n−k [tanh(t)] p−k k k=1
In both cases the quoted estimate follows by using the binomial theorem.
Simple Systems with Anomalous Dissipation and Energy Cascade
207
6. The Forced System Since (1) may display anomalous dissipation, it is not unreasonable to expect that adding a forcing term to this equation may lead to a (statistical) steady state. We now show that this is indeed the case. Specifically, we study the system a˙ n (t) = (n − 1)an−1 (t) − nan+1 (t) + 1n=m f (t),
(35)
where m ∈ N, and f (t) is either a constant forcing term, f (t) = 1, or a white-noise process, f (t) = W˙ (t) (in the second case (35) has to be properly interpreted as an infinite system of coupled Itô stochastic differential equations). As in the unforced setting, we represent the solution to (35) as in (22) for some G(z, t). an (t) is the n th coefficient in the Taylor series expansion of G(z, t). By Duhamel’s principle one sees that G(z, t) must satisfy the generalization of (20) with the effect of f (t)1n=m included: ∂G ∂G = (z 2 − 1) + zG + F(z, t), ∂t ∂z where F(z, t) = z m−1 f (t) and the initial condition is G(z, 0) = G 0 (z). This equation is valid for both f (t) = 1 and f (t) = W˙ (t) and forcing on any m ∈ N. Using the semigroup representation defined in (25), the solution of the equation above can be represented as t G(z, t) = (St G 0 )(z) + (St−s F)(z, s)ds. (36) 0
We have Theorem 13. Consider (35) with m = 1, f (t) = 1, and initial condition an (0) satisfying the assumptions of Theorem 5. Then, ⎧ π ⎪ ⎪ if n = 1 ⎨ √2 n (37) lim an (t) = an∗ = Γ (2) π t→∞ ⎪ ⎪ · if n ≥ 2. ⎩ n − 1 Γ ( n−1 2 ) Remark 5. Notice that an∗
∼
π n
as n → ∞.
∗ 2 This implies that an∗ has infinite energy: ∞ n=1 |an | = +∞. This is consistent with the fact that the steady state must be dissipative to compensate for the effect of the forcing term since dissipative solutions must have infinite energy. In this simple example we can see how the forcing is balanced explicitly. Mirroring the calculation in (3) for any N : If we start the system {an∗ } at time t = 0 we have 1d ∗ 2 |an (t)| = a1∗ − N a ∗N a ∗N +1 = 0. 2 dt n≤N
Hence, every block conserves energy as must happen at a fixed point.
208
J. C. Mattingly, T. Suidan, E. Vanden-Eijnden
Theorem 14. Consider (35) with m = 1, f (t) = W˙ (t), and initial condition an (−T ) satisfying the assumptions of Theorem 5. Then, lim an (t) = an∗∗ (t) ≡
T →∞
t −∞
tanhn−1 (t − s) dW (s) cosh(t − s)
a.s.
(38)
Remark 6. From (38), an∗∗ (t) is a Gaussian process with mean zero and covariance
tanhn+m−2 (t − s) ds cosh2 (t − s) −∞ 1 n, m ∈ N. = n+m−1
∗∗ Ean∗∗ (t)am (t) =
t
(39)
Again, this is consistent with the need for dissipation and implies that the invariant measure for (35) with a white-noise forcing is supported on functions with infinite energy (and, in particular, (39) is not trace-class). In addition, notice that this is consistent with the fact that, at least in expectation, the steady state needs to dissipate precisely the energy pumped into the system. In fact, for any N , 1 d ∗∗ 2 N 1 1 ∗∗ E − =0. |an (t)| = − N E a ∗∗ N (t)a N +1 (t) = 2 dt 2 2 2N n≤N
Proof (Theorem 13). The first term on the right hand-side accounts for the initial condition. Theorem 5 implies that (St G 0 ) → 0 as t → ∞. The second term is given explicitly by t t ψt−s (z) (St−s F)(z, s)ds = (40) (φt−s (z))m−1 f (s)ds. cosh(t − s) 0 0 Letting f (t) = 1 and m = 1, this expression becomes
t
(St−s F)(z, s)ds =
0
t
0
ψt−s (z) ds. cosh(t − s)
It follows that lim
t→∞ 0
t
2
(St−s F)(z, s)ds = √ 1 − z2
z−1 arctan √ 1 − z2
+π .
an∗ is the n th coefficient of the Taylor series expansion at z = 0 of this function. Proof (Theorem 14). Letting f (t) = W˙ (t), m = 1, and considering the initial condition at t = −T , we have
t
−∞
(St−s F)(z, s)ds =
t
−∞
ψt−s (z) dW (s). cosh(t − s)
a ∗∗ (t) is the n th coefficient of the Taylor series expansion at z = 0 of this function.
Simple Systems with Anomalous Dissipation and Energy Cascade
209
7. Proofs of the Main Theorems We begin by making a number of observations which will be used in the proofs. ψt and φt each have a single simple pole at z = 1/ tanh(t). Hence, at any finite time both are analytic in an open disk containing the closed unit disk and the Taylor coefficients of their expansions about zero converge to zero exponentially in n. For any fixed t > 0 the map φt is a fractional linear transformation which bijectively maps the open unit disk onto itself and leaves the unit circle invariant. The points z = 1 and z = −1 are the two fixed points. In addition, for every fixed z ∈ D(1)\{1} and fixed neighborhood N of −1, there exists a time T (z, N ) such that φt (z) ∈ N ∩ D(1) for all t > T (z, N ). The behavior of G 0 ◦ φt in a neighborhood of the origin will be important in the analysis which follows. Observe that φt (0) = − tanh(t) and for sufficiently small r > 0, {ρeiθ : θ ∈ [0, 2π ], ρ ∈ [0, r ]} is mapped approximately to {− tanh(t) + ρ(1 − tanh2 (t))eiθ : θ ∈ [0, 2π ], ρ ∈ [0, r ]} and strictly into the closed disk Er = − tanh(t) + ρ(1 − tanh2 (t))eiθ : θ ∈ [0, 2π ], ρ ∈ [0, r/(1 − r )] . For sufficiently small r > 0, Er is strictly contained in the unit disk for all times t. Furthermore, Er is bounded away from the boundary by two lines emanating from −1 of the form {−1 + ρe±iθ : ρ ≥ 0} for some fixed θ ∈ (0, π/2). We recall a basic fact from complex analysis which will be used repeatedly in the arguments that follow. To show that the Taylor coefficients about zero of G 0 ◦ φt converges to those of F as t → ∞ it is sufficient that for all t ≥ 0, F and G 0 ◦ φt are analytic in a fixed, t independent neighborhood of the origin and that G 0 ◦ φt converges uniformly to F on that neighborhood. Proof (Theorem 4). In order that Eq. (22) be well defined, G(z, t) needs to be analytic in a neighborhood of z = 0. Since ψt is analytic for all z ∈ D(1) and each t > 0, the analyticity of G(z, t) about z = 0 is equivalent to the analyticity of G 0 (z) about φt (0) = − tanh(t). As t increases, φt (0) decreases monotonically along the real axis from 0 to −1. We need only show that G 0 is analytic in an open neighborhood of [− tanh(t), 0] in order to complete the proof that Eq. (22) is well defined for all t < t∗ . G 0 is analytic in a neighborhood of the closed interval [− tanh(t), 0] since [− tanh(t), 0] ⊂ (α, 0]. Appealing to the arguments stated at the beginning of this section we see that the image of a small ball about the origin under the mapping φt lies in a thin strip about [− tanh(t), 0]. Hence, the reconstruction formula of Eq. (22) is well defined because Γ can be deformed to lie in a sufficiently small ball about the origin. If t∗ < ∞, then G(z, tanh(t∗ )) fails to be analytic at z = 0 since G 0 (z) in not analytic at α = − tanh(t∗ ); we cannot continue the solution in this case. To see that the an (t) (defined as in the statement of the theorem) do define a solution, observe that by the definition of G(z, t) and integration by parts ∂t G(z, t) (z 2 − 1)∂z G(z, t) + zG(z, t) a˙ n (t) = dz = dz n 2πi z n Γ 2πi z Γ G(z, t) G(z, t) = (n − 1) dz − n dz = (n − 1)an−1 (t) − nan+1 (t). n−1 n+1 Γ 2πi z Γ 2πi z This shows that an (t) given by (22) is indeed a solution of (1) for the initial condition an (0) as long as G(z, t) is analytic around z = 0.
210
J. C. Mattingly, T. Suidan, E. Vanden-Eijnden
Finally, to show that the an (t) defined by Eq. (22) is the unique solution of (1) for the initial condition an (0), note that if two different solutions exist for the same initial condition, then their associated G(z, t) must both satisfy (20) for the same initial condition G 0 (z). Since the solution of (20) is unique, this leads to a contradiction. Proof (Theorem 5). Appealing to the discussion at the beginning of the section and the fact that cosh(t) ∼ 21 et as t → ∞, it is enough to show that ψt (z)(G 0 ◦ φt )(z) converges uniformly to G + (−1)/(1 − z) on some neighborhood of the origin. First, observe that ψt (z) converges to 1/(1 − z) as t → ∞ uniformly on any disk contained within the unit disk. From the discussion at the beginning of the section we see that for all t > 0 the disk of radius 1/10 is mapped to a disk contained entirely in the open unit disk and bounded away from the unit circle by lines emanating from −1 of a constant angle. Hence, we have lim
sup |G 0 (φt (z)) − G +0 (−1)| = 0 .
t→∞ |z|<1/10
Proof (Theorem 6). Since (a1 (0), a2 (0), . . .) is square summable, g(r, θ ) := G 0 (r eiθ ) is in L 2 (dθ ) of the unit circle for all r ∈ [0, 1]. Hence, by Plancherel’s theorem, ∞
|an (t)|2 =
n=1
1 2π
2π
|G(eiθ , t)|2 dθ =
0
1 2π
2π 0
|ψt (eiθ )|2 |G 0 (φt (eiθ ))|2 dθ. cosh2 (t)
Introducing the change of variable eiη = φt (eiθ ), we see that ∞
|an (t)|2 =
n=1
=
1 2π 1 2π
2π
0
2π
|ψt (φt−1 (eiη ))|2 1 dη |G 0 (eiη )|2 −1 2 cosh (t) |φt (φt (eiη ))| |G 0 (eiη )|2 dη =
0
∞
|an (0)|2 .
n=1
To obtain the bounds on the weighted norms, we notice that for s ∈ N, ∞ n=1
n 2s |an (t)|2 =
1 2π
2π 0
s ∂ G iθ 2 dθ . (e , t) ∂θ s
Using the same change of variable one easily shows that this term can be bounded in ∂s iθ terms of the L 2 norms of ∂θ s G 0 (e ) for r ≤ s. By assumption, these norms are finite. Proof (Theorem 7). Fix T > 0. By the considerations at the beginning of the section, one sees that for t ∈ [0, T ] the map ψt (z)(G 0 ◦ φt )(z) remains analytic in D(1 + η1 ) for a sufficiently small η1 depending only on T and η. More precisely, η1 is picked to ensure that D(1 + η1 ) maps into D(1 + η) for all t ∈ [0, T ]; the only remaining constraint on η1 is that 1 + η1 < tanh1 T so that ψt (z) is also analytic in D(1 + η1 ). Hence, the power series converges absolutely on D(1 + η1 /2) and |an (t)| ≤ C(1 + η1 /2)n for all n ∈ N for some C > 0.
Simple Systems with Anomalous Dissipation and Energy Cascade
211
Proof (Theorem 8, Theorem 10 and Corollary 1). Theorem 8 is a special case of Theorem 10 so we concentrate on the later. By the discussion in the proof of Theorem 5, it is clear that for each moment of time t > 0 there exists a η1 > 0 so that G(z, t) is analytic on ∆(ζt , η1 , θ1 )\{ζt }. η1 may be chosen to be sufficiently small in order to avoid other singularities of G 0 which initially lie outside ∆(ζ, η, θ )\{ζ } and approach D(1) under the dynamics of φt . A similar consideration needs to be taken into account for θ and may result in an increase of θ to a new θ1 . As z → ζt , we see that A [cosh(t) − ζt sinh(t)]α−1 [cosh(t) + ζ sinh(t)]α (ζt − z)α
1−2α A 1+ζ 1−ζ t −t e + e = . 2 2 (ζt − z)α
G(z, t) ∼
The result on the asymptotics in n then follows from Theorem 20 in the Appendix since G(z, t) is analytic on ∆(ζt , η1 , θ1 )\{ζt }. The result for fixed n as t → ∞ is just a restatement of Theorem 5 in this context. The corollary follows directly from the discussion in Section 2. Proof (Theorem 9 and Corollary 2). The proof is similar to that of Theorem 8. Since z = −1 is a fixed point for φt for all t > 0, G(z, t) has a singularity at z = −1 inherited from G 0 (z). Since the circle is invariant under φt , for sufficiently small η1 > 0 and θ1 sufficiently close to π/2 we have that G(z, t) is analytic on ∆(−1, η1 , θ1 ). Direct calculation yields:
1 + tanh(t) α A Ae(2α−1)t 1 = as z → −1 . G(z, t) ∼ α cosh(t) + sinh(t) 1 − tanh(t) (1 + z) (1 + z)α We obtain the quoted result by applying Theorem 20 from the Appendix. The asymptotics in time follow from the fact that Ae(2α−1)t 1 − z α G(z, t) ∼ as t → ∞ 1−z 1+z and direct expression of the right hand side in a Taylor series in z. Corollary 2 follows from the discussion on anomalous dissipation in Sect. 2 and the above results. 8. Inviscid Limits We return to the analysis of the inviscid limits of (1). Fixing p ∈ N and defining Λn =
p
(n − k)
k=1
with the convention that Λn = 1 if p = 0, we consider α˙ n,ν = −2νΛn αn,ν + (n − 1)αn−1,ν − nαn+1,ν + 1n=1 W˙ (t) .
(41)
As mentioned in Sect. 1.1, it is straightforward to see that this system converges to a ∗∗ , α ∗∗ , · · · ). In fact, one has random variable αν∗∗ = (α1,ν 2,ν E
n
∗∗ 2 Λn |αn,ν | =
1 . ν
212
J. C. Mattingly, T. Suidan, E. Vanden-Eijnden
Thus, the system does not display anomalous dissipation; the dissipation which balances the energy injection (due to the forcing) comes from the term −2νn p αn (t). Setting ∞ αn+1,ν (t)z n , Gν (z, t) = n=0
one sees that
∂ p Gν ∂Gν ∂Gν + W˙ (t) . = (z 2 − 1) + zGν − 2νz p ∂t ∂z ∂z p
(42)
Using the variation of constants formula we obtain Gν (·, t) = St,ν Gν (·, 0) +
t
(St−s,ν 1) dWs .
0
We will concentrate on the case p ∈ {0, 1}. By the method of characteristics, we find that ⎧ ⎪ e−2νt ⎪ ⎨ for p = 0 ψt (z) f (φt (z)) (St,ν f )(z) = cosh(t) , 1 ⎪ ⎪ ψκt (z − ν) f (ν + κφκt (z − ν)) for p = 1 ⎩ cosh(κt) where κ 2 = 1 + ν 2 . It is interesting to contrast the regularizing effect of the different terms. When p = 0, St,ν simply dissipates energy at a faster rate than St . When p = 1, St,ν has a stronger regularizing effect than St,ν , in that the characteristics are attracted to the circle (ν − κ)eiθ inside of the unit disk and the singularity of ψκt (z − ν) stays uniformly bounded outside of the unit disk for all times. Hence if f has a radius of convergence greater than ν − κ ∼ −1 + ν, then Stν,1 f is analytic on a disk with radius greater than one for all times uniformly. For fixed t, St,ν f converges to St as ν → 0 uniformly on a neighborhood of the origin. Since one also has that St f , St,ν f all go to zero t uniformly on the open disk as t → ∞ for f bounded on the unit disk, we have that −∞ (St−s,ν )1 dWs converges to t −∞ (St−s 1) dWs in mean squared as ν → 0. As before we are primarily interested in these solutions. In this setting they are given by: ⎧ t tanh(t − s)n−1 ⎪ ⎪ dW (s) p=0 e−2ν(t−s) ⎨ cosh(t − s) ∗∗ αn,ν . (43) (t) = −∞ t κ tanh(κ(t − s))n−1 ⎪ ⎪ ⎩ dW (s) p = 1 n cosh(κ(t − s)) −∞ [κ + ν tanh(κ(t − s))] Theorem 15. For all n ∈ N, t ∈ R, and p = 0, 1, one has ∗∗ 2 lim E αn,ν (t) − an∗∗ (t) = 0.
ν→0
∗∗ (t) converges to a ∗∗ (t) as ν → 0 for p = 0, 1. Furthermore, one has the Hence αn,ν n estimates given in (14) and (15).
Simple Systems with Anomalous Dissipation and Energy Cascade
213
Proof (Theorem 15). Fix any t. Consider αn (t, ν, 0) and an (t) starting from initial condition zero at time T with T < t. As T → −∞, αn (t, ν, 0) and an (t) converge respectively to αn∗∗ (t, ν, 0) and an∗∗ (t). By the same argument as Theorem 14, one see that (43) holds. Subtracting (43) from (38), one obtains 2 E αn∗∗ (t, ν, 0) − an∗∗ (t) = 2
∞
2 u 2(n−1) (1 + u)−ν − 1 du (u + 2)2n 0 ∞ 2 1 4ν 2 , ≤2 du = (1 + u)−ν − 1 (u + 1)2 (1 + ν)(1 + 2ν) 0
which implies that αn∗∗ (t, ν, 0) → an∗∗ (t) almost surely as ν → 0. The convergence in the other cases is similar. Applying the Itô isometry to (43) proves the quoted value of 2 E αn∗∗ (t, ν, p) for p = 0. The other estimates follow from 1 1 1 ≤ ≤ κ +ν κ + ν tanh(t) κ which holds for t ≥ 0. Remark 7. At first glance, it might seem more natural to consider the system α˙˜ n,ν = −2νn p α˜ n,ν + (n − 1)α˜ n−1,ν − n α˜ n+1 + 1n=1 W˙ (t) . This leads to the following equation for the generating function G˜ν : ∂ G˜ν ∂ p G˜ν ∂ G˜ν = (z 2 − 1) + z G˜ν − 2νz p − 2νD p + W˙ (t) , ∂t ∂z ∂z p ∂ where D p is p applications of the operator defined by (D f )(z) = ∂z (z f (z)) and D0 is the identity operator. Hence, we see that the extra dissipative term contains the derivative of all orders less than or equal to p. Not surprisingly, the result is a mixture of the behavior of (41) for all orders less than or equal to p. In particular, when p = 1 the asymptotic (in time) behavior is given by ∗∗ α˜ n,ν (t)
=
t −∞
κe−ν(t−s) tanh(κ(t − s))n−1 dW (s) [κ + ν tanh(κ(t − s))]n cosh(κ(t − s))
and satisfies the following estimate: ∗∗ 2 κ2 1 ∗∗ ∗∗ E[αn,νκ/2 ]2 ≤ E α˜ n,ν ≤ 2n E[αn,νκ/2 ]2 . 2n+2 (κ + ν) κ 9. A Second Linear Shell Model We begin the analysis of the second model (11) by giving general conditions for the existence of a unique solution of the initial value problem. The technique is similar to that used in Sect. 4.
214
J. C. Mattingly, T. Suidan, E. Vanden-Eijnden
Theorem 16. Let {bn (0)} be such that ∞ (−1)n bn (0) < ∞.
(44)
n=1
Then the solution of (11) exists and is unique for all positive times. It can be represented as (−1)n+1 ∂ 2n−1 H bn (t) = (0, t), (45) (2n − 1)! ∂ x 2n−1 where 1 t 2 H (x, t) = Ex H0 (X (t)) exp − X (s)ds , (46) 2 0 and X (t) satisfies the stochastic differential equation 1 d X (t) = −X 3 (t)dt + √ 1 − X 4 (t)dW (t). 2 Ex denotes the expectation conditional on X (0) = x ∈ [−1, 1] and H0 (x) = (−1)n+1 bn (0)x 2n−1 .
(47)
(48)
n∈N
Remark 8. Alternatively, H (x, t) can be expressed as H (x, t) = (−1)n+1 bn (t)x 2n−1 ,
(49)
n∈N
where bn (t) solves (11). Remark 9. If the sequence {bn (0)} is monotone and converges to zero as n → ∞ then the condition in (44) holds. The following theorem summarizes the most interesting properties of solutions of (11). Theorem 17. Suppose that bn (0) satisfies (44). Then, for any positive time t > 0, lim (2n + 1)b2n+1 (t) = C¯ 1 (t) and lim 2nb2n (t) = C¯ 2 (t),
n→∞
n→∞
(50)
where C¯ 1 (t), C¯ 2 (t) ∈ R, C¯ 1 (t), C¯ 2 (t) = 0 for all but finitely many t ∈ [0, ∞). In particular, there exists a T > 0 such that for all t ≥ T , the solution of (11) is dissipative and satisfies ∞ ∞ bn2 (t) < bn2 (T ) < ∞. (51) In fact,
∞
2 n=1 bn (t)
n=1
n=1
→ 0 as t → ∞.
Remark 10. The fact that Eq. (11) dissipates energy at finite times is implicit in the rept resentation (46). As time grows, the factor exp(− 21 0 X 2 (s)ds) converges to zero as exp(−ct) almost surely for some positive deterministic c. (This follows from the law of large numbers and the verifiable assumption that the process is ergodic.) Hence, H (x, t) converges to zero uniformly in x as t → ∞.
Simple Systems with Anomalous Dissipation and Energy Cascade
215
Writing (46) as H (x, t) = (Tt H0 )(x), it is easy to see that Tt defines a (Feller) semigroup with generator L defined by (1 − x 4 ) ∂ 2 f x2 3∂f − x − f 4 ∂x2 ∂x 2 x2 ∂f 1 ∂ (1 − x 4 ) − f = 4 ∂x ∂x 2
(L f )(x) =
for f ∈ C 2 ([−1, 1]). In addition, H (x, t) satisfies x2 ∂H 1 ∂ 4 ∂H (1 − x ) − = H, ∂t 4 ∂x ∂x 2
(52)
(53)
with initial condition H (x, 0) = H0 (x) for x ∈ [−1, 1]. One can check that the boundaries at x = ±1 are entrance boundaries for (53) and H (x, t) satisfies lim (1 − x 4 )
x→±1
∂H = 0. ∂x
(54)
Proof (Theorem 16). Noting that L x 2n−1 = −n(n + 21 )x 2n+1 + (n − 1)(n − 21 )x 2n−3 , we compute ∞
(−1)n+1 b˙n (t)x 2n−1
n=1
=
∞ (−1)n+1 (n − 1)(n − 21 )bn−1 (t) − n(n + 21 )bn+1 (t) x 2n−1 n=1
∞ = (−1)n+1 bn (t) −n(n + 21 )x 2n+1 + (n − 1)(n − 21 )x 2n−3 n=1 ∞ = (−1)n+1 bn (t)L(x 2n−1 ). n=1
Proof (Theorem 17). Associated with (53) we have the eigenvalue problem x2 1 d 4 dφ (1 − x ) − φ, −λφ = 4 dx dx 2
(55)
subject to the boundary conditions lim (1 − x 4 )
x→±1
∂φ = 0. ∂x
It is straightforward to see that the operator in (55) equipped with the boundary condition in (54) is self-adjoint in L 2 [−1, 1]. We now explain why this operator has discrete spectrum. A standard calculation shows that the boundary is an “entrance boundary” in
216
J. C. Mattingly, T. Suidan, E. Vanden-Eijnden
the sense of Feller ([Fel54, McK56]), i.e. the diffusion (47), if started from the boundary, enters (−1, 1) and does not return to the boundary. 2 Define L V = 41 ∂x (1 − x 4 )∂x + V (x), where V (x) = − x2 . By standard PDE theory, ∂t u = L V u, subject to the condition limt→0 u(t, x) = δ y (x), has smooth solution in (−1, 1) for any t > 0. We denote this solution by ptV (x, y). For a fixed t > 0, ptV (x, y) is Lipschitz for x ∈ [−1 + , 1 − ] and y ∈ [−1, 1] with a fixed Lipschitz constant Ct and supx,y∈[−1,1] | ptV (x, y)| < Dt . Consider the solution to the following initial value problem: Let f ∈ L 2 ([−1, 1]) and solve ∂t u = L V u with u(0, x) = f (x). The solution is given by
u(t, x) =
ptV (x, y) f (y)dy.
u(t, x) is Lipschitz for x ∈ [−1 + , 1 − ] as the following simple estimate shows: 1 V V |u(t, x) − u(t, x )| = ( pt (x, y) − pt (x , y)) f (y)dy
≤ ≤
−1 1
−1
| ptV (x, y) − ptV (x , y)|| f (y)|dy
Ct |x
−x |
1
−1
| f (y)|dy ≤
2Ct |x
−x |
1
| f (y)| dy 2
−1
21
.
u(t, x) is also bounded in terms of f 2 as follows: |u(t, x)| =
1
−1
ptV (x,
y) f (y)dy ≤ Dt
1
−1
| f (y)|dy ≤ 2Dt
1 −1
| f (y)|
2
21
.
As one can see by a Cantor diagonalization argument in intervals In = [−1 + n1 , 1 − n1 ], V
Tt = et L is a compact self-adjoint operator. Therefore, the spectrum of L V is discrete. Note that the lowest eigenvalue has the following variational representation: 1 1 λ = inf φ
−1 4 (1 −
x 4 )(φ (x))2 + 21 x 2 φ 2 (x) d x , 1 2 −1 φ (x)d x
where the infimum is taken over L 2 equipped with the boundary conditions (54). This shows that the spectrum is strictly positive. Let {φk (x), λk }k∈N be the pair of eigenfunction and eigenvalues such that each φk (x) is odd in x (the even ones do not matter since the initial condition H0 (x) of (53) is odd from (48)). The solution of (53) can be represented as h k e−λk t φk (x), (56) H (x, t) = k∈N
Simple Systems with Anomalous Dissipation and Energy Cascade
where
hk =
1
−1
In turn, (56) implies that bn (t) =
217
H0 (x)φk (x)d x.
h k e−λk t pnk ,
(57)
(−1)n+1 pnk x 2n−1 .
(58)
k∈N
where pnk is defined by φk (x) =
∞ n=1
The pnk satisfy the following recurrence relation inherited from (11): k k −λk pnk = (n − 1)(n − 21 ) pn−1 − n(n + 21 ) pn+1 ,
n ∈ N, p0k = 0.
(59)
The following lemma describes the asymptotic behavior of npn . Lemma 1. For every λk > 0, the recurrence relation in (59) implies that k k lim (2n + 1) p2n+1 = ck1 and lim (2n) p2n = ck2 ,
n→∞
n→∞
(60)
where ck1 and ck2 are nonzero constants whose sign is the same as that of p1k . Proof. Assume p1 > 0 and write (59) as k pn+1 =
λk n(n + 21 )
pnk +
(n − 1)(n − 21 ) n(n + 21 )
k pn−1
n ∈ N, p0k = 0.
We omit the index k in this proof as it plays no role. For sufficiently large n and C depending only on λ, 2 C pn+1 ≤ 1 − + 2 max{ pn , pn−1 }. n n This implies { pn } is bounded. More is true: ! 21 m 2 C 1− + 2 max{ pn , pn−1 }. pm ≤ l l l=n
This implies that
m 1 2 C mpm ≤ exp log m + log 1 − + 2 max{ pn , pn−1 }, 2 l l l=n
which implies further that lim sup mpm < ∞. On the other hand, 2 pn+1 ≥ 1 − pn−1 , n+1
218
J. C. Mattingly, T. Suidan, E. Vanden-Eijnden
which implies pm ≥
m l=n
This implies that
2 1− l +1
! 21 pn .
m 1 2 mpm ≥ exp log m − log 1 − pn if n-m=0 mod 2. 2 l +1 l=n
Thus, lim inf mpm > 0. To show that the sequences in the theorem are Cauchy simply compute ! λ 1 1 |(n + 1) pn+1 − (n − 1) pn−1 | = (n + 1) pn+1 + (n − 1) pn−1 − . n(n + 1) 2 n(n + 1 ) 2
Using the fact that {npn } is bounded in n and summing over n we see that the sequence is Cauchy and have proved the lemma. Going back to the proof of Theorem 17, using (60) in (57) implies (50) with C¯ 1 (t) = e−λk t h k ck1 and C¯ 2 (t) = e−λk t h k ck2 . k∈N
k∈N
Note that there is a T > 0 so that C¯ 1 (t)C¯ 2 (t) > 0 for all t ≥ T . Finally, (50) implies that ∞ 1 d 2 bn (t) = − lim N (N + 21 )b N (t)b N +1 (t) = −C¯ 1 (t)C¯ 2 (t) < 0 N →∞ 2 dt n=1
for all t ≥ T which proves (51).
We also consider the system of forced equations b˙n = (n − 1)(n − 21 )bn−1 − n(n + 21 )bn+1 + f (t)1n=m ,
(61)
for n = 1, 2, . . . with boundary condition b0 (t) = 0 for all t and f (t) is either a constant forcing term, f (t) = 1, or a white-noise process, f (t) = W˙ (t). We have Theorem 18. Consider (61) with f (t) = 1, and initial condition bn (0) satisfying (44). Then dk p k n lim bn (t) = bn∗ ≡ , t→∞ λk k∈N
where pkn is defined by (58) and
dk =
1
−1
φk (x)x m d x.
In particular, bn∗ satisfies ∗ ∗ lim (2n + 1)b2n+1 = C1∗ > 0 and lim (2n)b2n = C2∗ > 0.
n→∞
n→∞
Simple Systems with Anomalous Dissipation and Energy Cascade
219
Theorem 19. Consider (61) with f (t) = W˙ (t), and initial condition bn (−T ) satisfying (44). Then t lim bn (t) = bn∗∗ (t) ≡ dk pnk e−λk s dW (s), T →∞
−∞
k∈N
where pnk is defined by (58). In particular, b∗∗ (t) is a Gaussian process with mean zero and covariance ∗∗ Ebn∗∗ (t)bm (t) =
dk dk p k p k n m , λ + λk k
k,k ∈N
and we have ∗∗ ∗∗ lim (2n + 1)2 E(b2n+1 (t))2 = C1∗∗ > 0 and lim (2n)2 E(b2n (t))2 = C2∗∗ > 0.
n→∞
n→∞
A. Estimates on Taylor Coefficients For the reader’s convenience, we now state a theorem on the asymptotic of Taylor’s series which can be found in [FO90]. Theorem 20. Let ∆(ζ, η, θ ) be as in (27). Assume that f (z) is analytic in ∆(ζ, η, θ )\{ζ } for some ζ ∈ C, η > 0, and 0 < θ < π/2. If f (z) ∼
K (ζ − z)α
as
z→ζ
for some K > 0 and α ∈ {0, −1, −2, · · · }, then fn ∼
K n α−1 , Γ (α) ζ n+α
where f n is the n th Taylor coefficient of f (z) about z = 0. Acknowledgements. We thank Percy Deift, Charles Fefferman, Stephanos Venakides and Xin Zhou for useful conservations. J. M. is supported in part by the Sloan Foundation and by an NSF CAREER award. T. S is supported in part by NSF grant DMS05-53403. E. V.-E. is supported in part by NSF grants DMS02-09959 and DMS02-39625, and by ONR grant N00014-04-1-0565.
References [CFP06a] [CFP06b] [CET94] [CR06] [DR00]
Cheskidov, A., Friedlander, S., Pavlovi´c, N.: An Inviscid Dyadic Model of Turbulence: The Global Attractor. arXiv:math.AP/06108115 v1, 2006 Cheskidov, A., Friedlander, S., Pavlovi´c, N.: An Inviscid Dyadic Model of Turbulence: The Fixed Point and Onsager’s Conjecture. http://arxiv.org/list/math.AP/0610814, 2006 Constantin, P., E, W., Titi, E.S.: Onsager’s conjecture on the energy conservation for solutions of Euler’s equation. Commun. Math. Phys. 165(1), 207–209 (1994) Constantin, P., Ramos, F.: Inviscid limit for damped and driven incompressible Navier-Stokes equations in R2 . http://arxiv.org/list/math.AP/0611782 v1, 2006 Duchon, J., Robert, R.: Inertial energy dissipation for weak solutions of incompressible euler and Navier-Stokes equations. Nonlinearity 13(1), 249–255 (2000)
220
[E01] [Eyi01] [Fel54] [FGV01] [FO90] [Fri95] [Hil01] [McK56] [Sri05]
J. C. Mattingly, T. Suidan, E. Vanden-Eijnden
E, W.: Stochastic hydrodynamics. In: Current developments in mathematics, 2000, Somerville, MA: Int. Press, 2001, pp. 109–147 Eyink, G.L.: Dissipation in turbulent solutions of 2d euler equations. Nonlinearity 14(4), 787–802 (2001) Feller, W.: The general diffusion operator and positivity preserving semi-groups in one dimension. Ann. of Math. (2) 60, 417–436 (1954) Falkovich, G., Gaw¸edzki, K., Vergassola, M.: Particles and fields in fluid turbulence. Rev. Mod. Phys. 73(4), 913–975 (2001) Flajolet, P., Odlyzko, A.: Singularity analysis of generating functions. SIAM J. Discrete Math. 3(2), 216–240 (1990) Frisch, U.: Turbulence. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995 Hilberdink, T.: A Tauberian theorem for power series. Arch. Math. (Basel) 77(4), 354–359 (2001) McKean, H.P. Jr.: Elementary solutions for certain parabolic partial differential equations. Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 82, 519–548 (1956) Srinivasan, R.: Simple models with cascade of energy and anomalous dissipation. In: Oliver Buhler, Charles Doering, ed. Fast times and fine scales, Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution Technical Reports. Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution, 2005
Communicated by P. Constantin
Commun. Math. Phys. 276, 221–259 (2007) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-007-0332-1
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
On Minimal Affinizations of Representations of Quantum Groups David Hernandez CNRS - UMR 8100, Laboratoire de Mathématiques de Versailles, 45 avenue des Etats-Unis, Bat. Fermat, 78035 Versailles, France. E-mail: [email protected] Received: 21 July 2006 / Accepted: 22 March 2007 Published online: 9 September 2007 – © Springer-Verlag 2007
Abstract: In this paper we study minimal affinizations of representations of quantum groups (generalizations of Kirillov-Reshetikhin modules of quantum affine algebras introduced in [Cha1]). We prove that all minimal affinizations in types A, B, G are special in the sense of monomials. Although this property is not satisfied in general, we also prove an analog property for a large class of minimal affinizations in types C, D, F. As an application, the Frenkel-Mukhin algorithm [FM1] works for these modules. For minimal affinizations of type A, B we prove the thin property (the l-weight spaces are of dimension 1) and a conjecture of [NN1] (already known for type A). The proof of the special property is extended uniformly for more general quantum affinizations of quantum Kac-Moody algebras. Contents 1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. Background . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3. Minimal Affinizations and Main Results . . . . 4. Preliminary Results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5. Proof of the Main Results . . . . . . . . . . . . 6. Applications and Further Possible Developments References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
221 223 230 233 237 249 257
1. Introduction In this paper q ∈ C∗ is fixed and is not a root of unity. Affine Kac-Moody algebras gˆ are infinite dimensional analogs of semi-simple Lie algebras g, and have remarkable applications (see [Ka]). Their quantizations Uq (ˆg), called quantum affine algebras, have a very rich representation theory which has been intensively studied in mathematics and physics (see references in [CP6, DM] and in
222
D. Hernandez
[CP2, FR, Nak1, Nak4] for various approaches). In particular Drinfeld [Dr2] discovered that they can also be realized as quantum affinizations of usual quantum groups Uq (g) ⊂ Uq (ˆg). By using this new realization, Chari-Pressley [CP6] classified their finite dimensional representations. Chari [Cha1] introduced the notion of minimal affinizations of representations of quantum groups: starting from a simple representation V of Uq (ˆg), an affinization of V is a simple representation Vˆ of Uq (ˆg) such that V is the head in the decomposition of Vˆ in simple Uq (g)-representations. Then one can define a partial ordering on the set of affinizations of V and so a notion of minimal affinization for this ordering. For example the minimal affinizations of simple Uq (g)-modules of highest weight a multiple of a fundamental weight are the Kirillov-Reshetikhin modules which have been intensively studied in recent years (for example see [KOS, KNH, Kl, HKOTY, KN, Cha2, Nak4, Nak5, H4, CM3, FL] and references therein). An (almost) complete classification of minimal affinizations was done in [Cha1, CP3, CP4, CP5]. The motivation to study minimal affinizations comes from physics: the affinizations of representations of quantum groups are important objects from the physical point of view, as stressed for example in [FR, Remark 4.2] and in the introduction of [Cha1]. For example in the theory of lattice models in statistical mechanics, they are related to the problem of proving the integrability of the model: the point is to add spectral parameters to a solution of the related quantum Yang-Baxter equation (see [CP6]). A second example is related to the quantum particles of the affine Toda field theory (see [BL, Do]) which correspond to simple finite dimensional representations of quantum affine algebras. In the present paper we prove new results on the structure of minimal affinizations, in particular in the light of recent developments in the representation theory of quantum affine algebras. A particular class of finite dimensional representations, called special modules [Nak4], attracted much attention as Frenkel-Mukhin [FM1] proposed an algorithm which gives their q-character (analog of the usual character adapted to the Drinfeld realization and introduced by Frenkel-Reshetikhin [FR]: they encode a certain decomposition of representations in so called l-weight spaces or pseudo weight spaces). For example the Kirillov-Reshetikhin modules [Nak4, Nak5, H4] are special (this is the crucial point of the proof of the Kirillov-Reshetikhin conjecture). A dual class of modules called antispecial modules is introduced in the present paper (antispecial does not mean the opposite of special), and an analog of the Frenkel-Mukhin algorithm gives their q-character. In the present paper we prove that minimal affinizations in type A, B, G are special and antispecial. We get counterexamples for other types, but we prove in type C, D, F that a large class of minimal affinizations are special or antispecial. In particular the Frenkel-Mukhin algorithm works for these modules. As an application, we prove that minimal affinizations of type A and B are thin (the l-weight spaces are of dimension 1). We also get the special property for analog simple modules of quantum affinizations of some non-necessarily finite quantum Kac-Moody algebras. In the proofs of the present paper, the crucial steps include techniques developed in [H4] to prove the Kirillov-Reshetikhin conjecture and in [H6] to solve the Nakajima’s smallness problem. The general idea is to prove simultaneously the special property and the thin property by induction on the highest weight of the minimal affinizations. This allows to use the elimination theorem [H4] which leads to eliminate some monomials in the q-character of simple modules.
On Minimal Affinizations of Representations of Quantum Groups
223
Nakajima first conjectured the existence of such large classes of special modules for simply-laced cases (see [Nak4]), and the existence of a large class of special minimal affinizations was conjectured by Mukhin in a conversation with the author in the conference “Representations of Kac-Moody Algebras and Combinatorics” at Banff in March 2005. In some situations, the properties are already known or can be proved directly from already known explicit formulas. Indeed, for Kirillov-Reshetikhin modules the special property was proved in [Nak5] (simply-laced case) and in [H4] (non-simply-laced case). So for Kirillov-Reshetikhin modules in classical types, the explicit formulas in [KOS, KNH] are satisfied (the formulas for fundamental representations are given in [KS]) and we can get the properties directly from them. General formulas and the thin properties were proved for irreducible tame modules, which include minimal affinizations, for Yangians of type A [Che1, Che2, NT]. (The author was told by Nakajima that the same results hold for quantum affine algebras of type A by [V].) See also [FM2] for the cases of minimal affinizations, which are evaluation representations in type A. Explicit formulas are also available for twisted yangians in classical types [Mo, Naz1]. But the author did not find in the literature a proof of the correspondence between quantum affine algebras and twisted (or non-simply laced) yangians. In general no explicit formulas for q-characters of quantum affine algebras are available, so our proofs use direct arguments without explicit formulas and are independent of previous results on yangians. In particular this allows to extend uniformly our arguments to previously unknown situations (like type B, C, D, G 2 , F4 ), and to more general quantum affinizations which are not necessarily quantum affine algebras. For quantum affine algebras in classical types, explicit conjectural formulas [NN1, NN2, NN3] are available for a large class of representations including many minimal affinizations (all of them for type A; see [KOS, KNH] for more general formulas). In types A, B, the results proved in the present paper imply [NN1, Conjecture 2.2] for these minimal affinizations. The author did not find in the literature a proof of this result, except for type A as explained above. The main subject of the present paper is minimal affinizations and so we give a proof of [NN1, Conjecture 2.2] in this case. But it is possible to prove [NN1, Conjecture 2.2] for more general representations by using a variation of this proof (this and [NN1, Conjecture 2.2] in types C, D will be discussed in a separate publication). The results of [NT, KS, KOS] and of [NN1, Conjecture 2.2] (and the thin property as their consequence) were explained to the author by Nakajima in an early stage of this research, June 2005. Let us describe the organization of the present paper. In Sect. 2 we give some background on the representation theory of quantum affine algebras. In Sect. 3 we recall the definition of minimal affinizations and state the main results of the paper. In Sect. 4 we give preliminary results, including results from [H6] and discussion about an involution of Uq (ˆg). In Sect. 5 we prove the main result of the paper. In Sect. 6 we explain the proof of [NN1, Conjecture 2.2] for minimal affinizations in types A, B, we state additional results (Theorem 6.6) for more general quantum affinizations, and we discuss possible further developments, in particular on generalized induction systems involving minimal affinizations. 2. Background 2.1. Cartan matrix and quantized Cartan matrix. Let C = (Ci, j )1≤i, j≤n be a Cartan matrix of finite type. We denote I = {1, . . . , n}. C is symmetrizable: there is a matrix
224
D. Hernandez
D = diag(r1 , . . . , rn ) (ri ∈ N∗ ) such that B = DC is symmetric. In particular if C is symmetric then D = In (simply-laced case). We consider a realization (h, , ∨ ) of C (see [B, Ka]): h is a n dimensional Q-vector space, = {α1 , . . . , αn } ⊂ h∗ (set of the simple roots) and ∨ = {α1∨ , . . . , αn∨ } ⊂ h (set of simple coroots) are set such that for 1 ≤ i, j ≤ n, α j (αi∨ ) = Ci, j . Let ∨ 1 , . . . , n ∈ h∗ (resp. ∨ 1 , . . . , n ∈ h) be the fundamental weights (resp. coweights): ∨ ∨ i (α j ) = αi ( j ) = δi, j , where δi, j is 1 if i = j and 0 otherwise. Denote P = {λ ∈ h∗ |∀i ∈ I, λ(αi∨ ) ∈ Z} the set of weights and P + = {λ ∈ P|∀i ∈ I, λ(αi∨ ) ≥ 0} the set of dominant αn ∈ P and weights. For example we have α1 , . . . , 1 , . . . , n ∈ P + . Denote Q = i∈I Zαi ⊂ P the root lattice and Q + = i∈I Nαi ⊂ Q. For λ, µ ∈ h∗ , denote λ ≥ µ if λ − µ ∈ Q + . Let ν : h∗ → h linear such that for all i ∈ I we have ν(αi ) = ri αi∨ . For λ, µ ∈ h∗ , λ(ν(µ)) = µ(ν(λ)). We use the enumeration of vertices of [Ka]. We denote qi = q ri and for l ∈ Z, r ≥ 0, m ≥ m ≥ 0 we define in Z[q ± ]: [m]q ! q l − q −l m . [l]q = , [r ]q ! = [r ]q [r − 1]q · · · [1]q , = −1 m q −q [m − m ]q ![m ]q ! q For a, b ∈ Z, we denote q a+bZ = {q a+br |r ∈ Z} and q a+bN = {q a+br |r ∈ Z, r ≥ 0}. Let C(z) be the quantized Cartan matrix defined by (i = j ∈ I ): Ci,i (z) = z i + z i−1 , Ci, j (z) = [Ci, j ]z . ˜ C(z) is invertible (see [FR]). We denote by C(z) the inverse matrix of C(z) and by D(z) the diagonal matrix such that for i, j ∈ I , Di, j (z) = δi, j [ri ]z . 2.2. Quantum algebras 2.2.1. Quantum groups Definition 2.1. The quantum group Uq (g) is the C-algebra with generators ki±1 , xi± (i ∈ I ) and relations: ±Ci, j ± x j ki ,
ki k j = k j ki , ki x ± j = qi [xi+ , x − j ] = δi, j
ki − ki−1
qi − qi−1
,
1 − Ci, j ± r (−1) (xi± )1−Ci, j −r x ± j (x i ) = 0 (for i = j). r r =0···1−Ci, j q
r
i
This algebra was introduced independently by Drinfeld [Dr1] and Jimbo [J]. It is remarkable that one can define a Hopf algebra structure on Uq (g) by: (ki ) = ki ⊗ ki , (xi+ ) = xi+ ⊗ 1 + ki ⊗ xi+, (xi− ) = xi− ⊗ ki−1 + 1 ⊗ xi− ,
On Minimal Affinizations of Representations of Quantum Groups
225
S(ki ) = ki−1 , S(xi+ ) = −xi+ ki−1, S(xi− ) = −ki xi− , (ki ) = 1, (xi+ ) = (xi− ) = 0. Let Uq (h) be the commutative subalgebra of Uq (g) generated by the ki±1 (i ∈ I ). For V a Uq (h)-module and ω ∈ P we denote by Vω the weight space of weight ω: ω(αi∨ )
Vω = {v ∈ V |∀i ∈ I, ki .v = qi
v}.
In particular we have xi± .Vω ⊂ Vω±αi . We say that V is Uq (h)-diagonalizable if V = ω∈P Vω (in particular V is of type 1). For V a finite dimensional Uq (h)-diagonalizable module we define the usual character dim(Vω )e(ω) ∈ E = Z.e(ω). χ (V ) = ω∈P
ω∈P
2.2.2. Quantum loop algebras. We will use the second realization (Drinfeld realization) of the quantum loop algebra Uq (Lg) (subquotient of the quantum affine algebra Uq (ˆg)): ± (i ∈ I, r ∈ Z), ki±1 (i ∈ I ), Definition 2.2. Uq (Lg) is the algebra with generators xi,r h i,m (i ∈ I, m ∈ Z − {0}) and the following relations (i, j ∈ I, r, r ∈ Z, m, m ∈ Z − {0}):
[ki , k j ] = [ki , h j,m ] = [h i,m , h j,m ] = 0, ±Ci, j ± x j,r ki ,
ki x ± j,r = qi [h i,m , x ± j,r ] = ±
1 [m Bi, j ]q x ± j,m+r , m
+ , x− [xi,r j,r ] = δi, j
− + φi,r +r − φi,r +r
qi − qi−1
,
± ± ± ± ±Bi, j ± ±Bi, j ± ± xi,r x j,r xi,r xi,r x j,r +1 − x ± +1 x j,r − q +1 = q j,r +1 x i,r ,
s ± ± (−1) x± · · · xi,r x± x± · · · xi,r = 0, π(k) j,r i,rπ(k+1) π(s) k q i,rπ(1) k=0···s
π ∈ s
k
i
where the last relation holds for all i = j, s = 1 − Ci, j , all sequences of integers ± ∈ Uq (Lg) r1 , . . . , rs . s is the symmetric group on s letters. For i ∈ I and m ∈ Z, φi,m is determined by the formal power series in Uq (Lg)[[z]] (resp. in Uq (Lg)[[z −1 ]]): ± φi,±m z ±m = ki± exp(±(q − q −1 ) h i,±m z ±m ), m≥0
and
± φi,∓m
= 0 for m > 0.
m ≥1
226
D. Hernandez
Uq (Lg) has a Hopf algebra structure (from the Hopf algebra structure of Uq (ˆg)). ± , For J ⊂ I we denote by Uq (Lg J ) ⊂ Uq (Lg) the subalgebra generated by the xi,m ±1 h i,m , ki for i ∈ J . Uq (Lg J ) is a quantum loop algebra associated to the semi-simple Lie algebra g J of Cartan matrix (Ci, j )i, j∈J . For example for i ∈ I , we denote Uq (Lgi ) = Uq (Lg{i} ) Uqi (Lsl2 ). ± ) is denoted The subalgebra of Uq (Lg) generated by the h i,m , ki±1 (resp. by the xi,r ± by Uq (Lh) (resp. Uq (Lg) ). 2.3. Finite dimensional representations of quantum loop algebras Denote by Rep (Uq (Lg)) the Grothendieck ring of (type 1) finite dimensional representations of Uq (Lg). 2.3.1. Monomials and q-characters. Let V be a representation in Rep(Uq (Lg)). The subalgebra Uq (Lh) ⊂ Uq (Lg) is commutative, so we have: V = Vγ , ± γ =(γi,±m )i∈I,m≥0
± ± where: Vγ = {v ∈ V |∃ p ≥ 0, ∀i ∈ I, m ≥ 0, (φi,±m − γi,±m ) p .v = 0}. ± The γ = (γi,±m )i∈I,m≥0 are called l-weights (or pseudo-weights) and the Vγ = {0} are called l-weight spaces (or pseudo-weight spaces) of V . One can prove [FR] that γ is necessarily of the form:
m≥0
deg(Q i )−deg(Ri )
± γi,±m u ±m = qi
Q i (uqi−1 )Ri (uqi ) Q i (uqi )Ri (uqi−1 )
,
(1)
where Q i , Ri ∈ C(u) satisfy Q i (0) = Ri (0) = 1. The Frenkel-Reshetikhin q-characters morphism χq [FR] encodes the l-weights γ (see also [Kn]). It is an injective ring morphism: ± χq : Rep(Uq (Lg)) → Z[Yi,a ]i∈I,a∈C∗
defined by
χq (V ) = where: mγ = Q i (u) =
a∈C∗
γ
dim(Vγ )m γ ,
q −r Y i,a i,a , i∈I,a∈C∗ i,a
(1 − ua)qi,a , Ri (u) =
a∈C∗
(1 − ua)ri,a .
The m γ are called monomials (they are analogs of weight). We denote by A the set of ± ]i∈I,a∈C∗ . For an l-weight γ , we denote Vγ = Vm γ . We will also monomials of Z[Yi,a p p use the notation ir = Yi,q r for i ∈ I and r, p ∈ Z. For J ⊂ I , χqJ is the morphism of q-characters for Uq (Lg J ) ⊂ Uq (Lg).
On Minimal Affinizations of Representations of Quantum Groups
227
u i,a (m) For a m monomial we denote u i,a (m) ∈ Z such that m = . i∈I,a∈C∗ Yi,a We also denote ω(m) = i∈I,a∈C∗ u i,a (m)i , u i (m) = a∈C∗ u i,a (m) and u(m) = ∗ i∈I u i (m). m is said to be J -dominant if for all j ∈ J, a ∈ C we have u j,a (m) ≥ 0. An I -dominant monomials is said to be dominant. Observe that χq , χqJ can also be defined for finite dimensional Uq (Lh)-modules in the same way. In the following for V a finite dimensional Uq (Lh)-module, we denote by M(V ) the set of monomials occurring in χq (V ). For i ∈ I, a ∈ C∗ we set: −1 Ai,a =Yi,aq −1 Yi,aqi Y j,a i
×
{ j|C j,i =−1}
{ j|C j,i =−2}
−1 −1 Y j,aq −1 Y j,aq
{ j|C j,i =−3}
−1 −1 −1 Y j,aq 2 Y j,a Y j,aq −2 .
(2)
−1 As the Ai,a are algebraically independent [FR] (because C(z) is invertible), for M a −v (m) −1 product of Ai,a we can define vi,a (M) ≥ 0 by M = i∈I,a∈C∗ Ai,a i,a . We put vi (M) = ∨ + a∈C∗ vi,a (M) and v(M) = i∈I vi (M). For λ ∈ −Q we set v(λ) = −λ(1 + · · · + −1 ∨ n ). For M a product of Ai,a , we have v(M) = v(ω(λ)). For m, m two monomials, −1 . we write m ≤ m if m m −1 is product of Ai,a
Definition 2.3. [FM1] A monomial m ∈ A − {1} is said to be right-negative if for all a ∈ C∗ , for L = max{l ∈ Z|∃i ∈ I, u i,aq L (m) = 0} we have ∀ j ∈ I , u j,aq L (m) ≤ 0. Observe that a right-negative monomial is not dominant. We can also define left-negative monomials by replacing max by min in the formula of L in Definition 2.3. Lemma 2.4. [FM1] −1 1) For i ∈ I, a ∈ C∗ , Ai,a is right-negative. 2) A product of right-negative monomials is right-negative. 3) If m is right-negative, then m ≤ m implies that m is right-negative.
We have the same results by replacing right-negative by left-negative. For J ⊂ I and Z ∈ Y, we denote Z →J the element of Y obtained from Z by putting ±1 ± / J . Let β : Z[Y j,b ] j∈I,b∈C∗ → E be the ring morphism such that Y j,a = 1 for j ∈ β(m) = e(ω(m)). Proposition 2.5. [FR, Theorem 3] For V ∈ Rep(Uq (Lg)), let Res(V ) be the restricted Uq (g)-module. We have (β ◦ χq )(V ) = χ (Res(V )). 2.3.2. l-highest weight representations. The irreducible finite dimensional Uq (Lg)-modules have been classified by Chari-Pressley. They are parameterized by dominant monomials: Definition 2.6. A Uq (Lg)-module V is said to be of l-highest weight m ∈ A if there is + .v = 0. v ∈ Vm such that V = Uq (Lg)− .v and ∀i ∈ I, r ∈ Z, xi,r For m ∈ A, there is a unique simple module L(m) of l-highest weight m.
228
D. Hernandez
Theorem 2.7. [CP6, Theorem 12.2.6] The dimension of L(m) is finite if and only if m is dominant. (i) For i ∈ I , a ∈ C∗ , k ≥ 0 we denote X k,a = k ∈{1,...,k} Yi,aq k−2k +1 . i
(i) (i) Definition 2.8. The Kirillov-Reshetikhin modules are the Wk,a = L(X k,a ). (i) We denote by W0,a the trivial representation (it is of dimension 1). For i ∈ I and (i)
a ∈ C∗ , W1,a is called a fundamental representation and is denoted by Vi (a) (in the case g = sl2 we simply write Wk,a and V (a)). For g = sl2 , the monomials m 1 = X k1 ,a1 , m 2 = max(u a (m 1 ),u a (m 2 )) X k2 ,a2 are said to be in special position if the monomial m 3 = a∈C∗ Ya is of the form m 3 = X k3 ,a3 and m 3 = m 1 , m 3 = m 2 . A normal writing of a dominant monomial m is a product decomposition m = i=1,...,L X kl ,al such that for l = l , X kl ,al , X kl ,al are not in special position. Any dominant monomial has a unique normal writing up to permuting the monomials (see [CP6, Sect. 12.2]). It follows from the study of the representations of Uq (Lsl2 ) in [CP1, CP2, FR] that: Proposition 2.9. Suppose that g = sl2 . (1) Wk,a is of dimension k + 1 and: −1 −1 −1 χq (Wk,a ) = X k,a (1 + Aaq k (1 + Aaq k−2 (1 + · · · (1 + Aaq 2−k )) · · · ).
(2) V (aq 1−k ) ⊗ V (aq 3−k ) ⊗ · · · ⊗ V (aq k−1 ) is of q-character: −1 −1 −1 X k,a (1 + Aaq k )(1 + Aaq k−2 ) · · · (1 + Aaq 2−k ).
In particular all l-weight spaces of the tensor product are of dimension 1. (3) For m a dominant monomial and m = X k1 ,a1 · · · X kl ,al a normal writing we have: L(m) Wk1 ,a1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ Wkl ,al . 2.3.3. Special modules and complementary reminders Definition 2.10. For m ∈ A let D(m) be the set of monomials m ∈ A such that there are m 0 = m, m 1 , . . . , m N = m ∈ A satisfying for all j ∈ {1, . . . , N }: (1) m j = m j−1 Ai−1 · · · Ai−1 j ,a1 qi j ,ar j
j qi j
, where i j ∈ I , r j ≥ 1 and a1 , . . . , ar j ∈ C∗ ,
(2) for 1 ≤ r ≤ r j , u i j ,ar (m j−1 ) ≥ |{r ∈ {1, . . . , r j }|ar = ar }|, where r j , i j , ar are as in condition (1). For all m ∈ D(m), m ≤ m. Moreover if m ∈ D(m), then (D(m ) ⊂ D(m)).
Theorem 2.11. [H5, Theorem 5.21] For V ∈ Mod(Uq (ˆg)) a l-highest weight module of highest monomial m, we have M(V ) ⊂ D(m). In particular for all m ∈ M(V ), we have m ≤ m and the vi,a (m m −1 ), v(m m −1 ) ≥ 0 are well-defined. As a direct consequence of Theorem 2.11, we also have: ± Lemma 2.12. For i ∈ I, a ∈ C∗ , we have (χq (Vi (a)) − Yi,a ) ∈ Z[Y j,aq l ] j∈I,l>0 .
On Minimal Affinizations of Representations of Quantum Groups
229
This result was first proved in [FM1, Lemma 6.1, Remark 6.2]. A monomial m is said to be antidominant if for all i ∈ I, a ∈ C∗ , u i,a (m) ≤ 0. Definition 2.13. A Uq (Lg)-module is said to be special (resp. antispecial) if its q-character has a unique dominant (resp. antidominant) monomial. The notion of special module was introduced in [Nak4]. It is of particular importance because an algorithm of Frenkel-Mukhin [FM1] gives the q-character of special modules. It is easy to write a similar algorithm for antispecial modules from the Frenkel-Mukhin algorithm (for example it suffices to use the involution studied in Sect. 4.2). Observe that a special (resp. antispecial) modules is a simple l-highest weight modules. But in general all simple l-highest weight modules are not special. The following result was proved in [Nak4, Nak5] for simply-laced types, and in full generality in [H4] (see [FM1] for previous results). Theorem 2.14. [H4, Theorem 4.1, Lemma 4.4] The Kirillov-Reshetikhin modules are (i) (i) (i) special. Moreover for m ∈ M(Wk,a ), m = X k,a implies m ≤ X k,a A−1 k . i,aqi
Define µ IJ : Z[(A±j,a )→(J ) ] j∈J,a∈C∗ → Z[A±j,a ] j∈J,a∈C∗ , the ring morphism such that µ IJ ((A±j,a )→(J ) ) = A±j,a . For m J -dominant, denote by L J (m →(J ) ) the simple Uq (Lg J )-module of l-highest weight m →(J ) . Define: L J (m) = mµ IJ ((m →(J ) )−1 χqJ (L J (m →(J ) ))). We have: Proposition 2.15. [H6] For a representation V ∈ Rep(Uq (Lg)) and J ⊂ I , there is unique decomposition in a finite sum: χq (V ) = λ J (m )L J (m ). (3) m J -dominant
Moreover for all m J -dominant we have λ J (m ) ≥ 0. Remark 2.16. Let m be a dominant monomial and m ∈ M(L(m)) a J -dominant monomial such that there are no m > m satisfying m ∈ M(m) and m appears in L J (m ). Then from Proposition 2.15 the monomials of L J (m ) are in M(L(m)). It gives inductively from m a set of monomials occurring in χq (L(m)). 2.3.4. Thin modules Definition 2.17. [H6] A Uq (Lg)-module V is said to be thin if its l-weight spaces are of dimension 1. For example for g of type A, B, C, all fundamental representations are thin (it can be established directly from the formulas in [KS]; this thin property was observed and proved with a different method in [H3, Theorem 3.5]; see also [CM2]). Observe that it follows from [H1, Sect. 8.4] that for g of type G 2 , all fundamental representations are thin. For g of type F4 , the fundamental representations corresponding
230
D. Hernandez
to i = 1 and i = 4 are thin, but the fundamental representations corresponding to i = 2 or i = 3 are not thin (see [H3]). For type D, it is known that fundamental representations are not necessarily thin: for example for g of type D4 , the fundamental representations V2 (a) have an l-weight space of dimension 2. Explicit formulas for the q-character of fundamental representation in type D are given in [KS] (the thin fundamental representations of type D are also characterized in [CM2]; see also Remark 2.19 below for a general statement). For m ∈ Z[Yi,a ]i∈I,a∈C∗ a dominant monomial, the standard module M(m) is defined as the tensor product : M(m) =
a∈(C∗ /q Z )
(· · · ⊗ (
Vi (aq)⊗u i,aq (m) ) ⊗ (
i∈I
Vi (aq 2 )
⊗u i,aq 2 (m)
) ⊗ · · · ).
i∈I
It is well-defined as for i, j ∈ I and a ∈ C∗ we have Vi (a) ⊗ V j (a) V j (a) ⊗ Vi (a) and for a ∈ / aq Z , we have Vi (a) ⊗ V j (a ) V j (a ) ⊗ Vi (a). Observe that fundamental representations are particular cases of standard modules. As a direct corollary of a result of Nakajima, there is the following result for simplylaced types: wi ∗ Corollary 2.18. We suppose that g is simply-laced. Let m = i∈I Yi,aq φi where a ∈ C , wi ≥ 0 and φi ∈ Z satisfies (Ci, j < 0 ⇒ |φi − φ j | = 1). Then the standard module M(m) is thin if and only if it is simple as a Uq (g)-module. Proof. It follows from [Nak3, Proposition 3.4] that in this situation the number of monomials inχq (M(m))) is equal to the dimension of the simple Uq (g)-module of highest weight i∈I wi i . Observe that this result is false for not simply-laced g (for example there is a thin fundamental representation for type G 2 which is not simple as a Uq (g)-module, see [H1, Sect. 8.4]). The following remark was communicated to the author by Nakajima: Remark 2.19. In particular for g simply-laced, a fundamental representation is thin if and only if the corresponding coefficient of the highest root is 1 (this point is also a trivial consequence of previously known results, for example the geometric construction [Nak1]). We got also the following example: Proposition 2.20. [H6, Proposition 6.6] Let g = sln+1 and consider a monomial of the form m = Yi1 ,aq l1 Yi2 ,aq l2 · · · Yi R ,aq l R , where R ≥ 0, i 1 , i 2 , . . . , i R ∈ I , l1 , l2 , . . . , l R ∈ Z, satisfying for all 1 ≤ r ≤ R − 1, lr +1 − lr ≥ ir + ir +1 . Then L(m) is thin.
3. Minimal Affinizations and Main Results In this section we recall the definition of minimal affinizations and their classification in regular cases. Then we state the main results which are proved in other sections.
On Minimal Affinizations of Representations of Quantum Groups
231
3.1. Definitions [Cha1] Definition 3.1. For V a simple finite dimensional Uq (g)-module, a simple finite dimensional Uq (Lg)-module L(m) is said to be an affinization of V if ω(m) is the highest weight of V . For V a Uq (g)-module and λ ∈ P + , denote by m λ (V ) the multiplicity in V of the simple Uq (g)-module of highest weight λ. Two affinizations are said to be equivalent if they are isomorphic as Uq (g)-modules. Denote by QV the equivalence classes of affinizations of V and for L an affinization of V denote by [L] ∈ QV its classes. For [L], [L ] ∈ QV , we write [L] ≤ [L ] if and only if for all µ ∈ P + , either (i) m µ (L) ≤ m µ (L ), (ii) ∃ν > µ such that m ν (L) < m µ (L ). Proposition 3.2. ≤ defines a partial ordering on QV . Definition 3.3. A minimal affinization of V is a minimal element of QV for the partial ordering. Remark 3.4. For g = sln+1 , we have evaluation morphisms Uq (Lg) → Uq (g) denoted by eva and ev a (for a ∈ C∗ ) and in particular a minimal affinization L of V is isomorphic to V as a Uq (g)-module. 3.2. Classification The minimal affinizations were classified in [Cha1, CP3, CP4, CP5] for all types, except for type D, E for a weight orthogonal to the special node. For the regular cases (i.e. with a linear Dynkin diagram, that is to say types A, B, C, F4 , G 2 ), the classification is complete: Theorem 3.5. [Cha1, CP3, CP4] Suppose that g is regular and let λ ∈ P + . For i ∈ I let λi = λ(αi∨ ) and for i < n let ci (λ) = q ri λi +ri+1 λi+1 +ri+1 −Ci+1,i −1 and ci (λ) = q ri λi +ri+1 λi+1 +ri −Ci,i+1 −1 . Then a simple Uq (Lg)-module L(m) is a minimal affinization of V (λ) if and only if m (i) is of the form m = i∈I X λi ,ai with (ai )i∈I ∈ (C∗ ) I satisfying one of two conditions: (I) For all i < j ∈ I , ai /a j = i≤s< j cs (λ). (II) For all i < j ∈ I , a j /ai = i≤s< j cs (λ). Observe that we have rewritten the defining formulas of cs , cs [Cha1, CP3, CP4] in a slightly different (more homogeneous) way. Observe that for classical types, minimal affinizations (called generalized Kirillov-Reshetikhin modules) were also studied in [GK]. Remark 3.6. As a consequence of Theorem 3.5, for k ≥ 0 and i ∈ I , the minimal affinizations of V (ki ) are the Kirillov-Reshetikhin modules. For g of type D, and λ ∈ P + , we define with the same formulas ci (λ) for i < n − 1, (i) and we set cn−1 (λ) = q λn−2 +λn +1 . For a monomial m = i∈I X λi ,ai we have analog conditions (I) and (II):
232
D. Hernandez
(I) For all i < j ∈ I , ai /a j = (c j−1 (λ)) j i≤s≤min( j−1,n−3) cs (λ), (II) For all i < j ∈ I , a j /ai = (c j−1 (λ)) j i≤s≤min( j−1,n−3) cs (λ), where j = 0 if j ≤ n − 2 and n−1 = n = 1. It follows from [CP3, Theorem 6.1] that if λn−2 = 0 and m = i∈I X λ(i)i ,ai satisfies (I ) or (I I ), then L(m) is a minimal affinization of V (λ). 3.3. Main results It follows directly from Theorem 2.14 and Remark 3.6 that (see also Proposition 6.8 for an alternative general proof): Corollary 3.7. For i ∈ I and k ≥ 0, the minimal affinizations of V (ki ) are special. In general a minimal affinization is not special. Let us look at some examples. First we consider type C. If m satisfies condition (I I ) of Theorem 3.5, L(m) is not necessarily special. For example consider the case g of type C3 and m = Y2,1 Y2,q 2 Y3,q 7 . L(m) is a minimal affinization of V (22 + 3 ). By the process described in Remark 2.16, −1 −1 −1 −1 −1 −1 2 the monomials 11 13 22−1 24−1 31 33 37 , 1−1 3 15 31 33 37 , 13 15 22 24 35 33 37 , 26 24 33 37 and 33 occur in χq (L(m)) and so L(m) is not special. If m satisfies condition (I ) of Theorem 3.5, L(m) is not necessarily special. For example consider the case g of type C3 and m = Y1,q 3 Y1,q 5 Y1,q 7 Y2,1 . L(m) is a minimal affinization of V (31 + 2 ). By the process described in Remark 2.16, the monomials 11 13 15 17 22−1 31 , 11 13 15 17 24 3−1 5 , −1 2 11 13 15 17 26 , 11 13 15 occur in χq (L(m)) and so L(m) is not special. Eventually, let m = Y1,1 Y1,q 2 Y1,q 4 Y2,q 7 Y2,q 9 Y3,q 14 . We can see as for Y2,1 Y2,q 2 Y3,q 7 that L(m) is not special. Moreover L(m) is antispecial if and only if the module L(Y1,q 14 Y1,q 12 Y1,q 10 Y2,q 7 Y2,q 5 Y3,1 ) is special (see Lemma 4.10 and Corollary 4.11 below). But we can check as for Y1,q 3 Y1,q 5 Y1,q 7 Y2,1 that this module is not special. So L(m) is not special and not antispecial. For types D, there are minimal affinizations which are not special. For example let g of type D4 and m = Y1,q 3 Y1,q 5 Y2,1 . Then L(m) is not special (see [H6, Remark 6.8]). However we prove in this paper: Theorem 3.8. For g of type A, B, G, all minimal affinizations are special and antispecial. Theorem 3.9. For g of type C, F4 and λ ∈ P satisfying λn = 0, all minimal affinizations of V (λ) satisfying (I) (resp. (II)) are antispecial (resp. special). For g of type D and λ ∈ P satisfying λn−1 = λn , all L(m) satisfying (I) (resp. (II)) and an−1 = an are antispecial (resp. special). Note that for type D, the condition an−1 = an is automatically satisfied if λ j = 0 for one j ≤ n − 2. Theorem 3.10. For g of type A, B, all minimal affinizations are thin. Theorems 3.8, 3.9 and 3.10 are proved in Sect. 5. Note for type C, there are minimal affinizations which are not thin: for example consider g of type C4 and m = Y3,1 Y3,q 2 . L(m) is a Kirillov-Reshetikhin and a minimal affinization of V (23 ). By the process described in Remark 2.16, the following −1 −1 −1 −1 monomials occur in χq (L(m)): 31 32 , 21 23 3−1 2 34 41 43 , 21 23 45 43 , 14 21 25 34 45 43 , −1 −1 −1 −1 −1 −1 2 14 21 36 43 , 14 21 34 47 , 16 21 25 34 47 and 16 21 25 36 45 47 . And so by Proposition
On Minimal Affinizations of Representations of Quantum Groups
233
2.15 and Proposition 2.9 the monomial 21 25 27−1 326 45 47−1 occurs in χq (L(m)) with multiplicity larger than 2. For type G 2 , there are minimal affinizations which are not thin: for example let m = Y2,0 Y2,2 . L(m) is a Kirillov-Reshetikhin and a minimal affinization of V (22 ). −1 −1 2 We have 20 22 , 11 13 24−1 22−1 , 1−1 7 19 24 26 28 ∈ M(L(m)), and so Y1,9 Y2,4 Y2,6 occurs in χq (L(m)) with multiplicity larger than 2. 4. Preliminary Results In this section g is an arbitrary semi-simple Lie algebra. We discuss preliminary results which will be used in the proof of Theorem 3.8, 3.9 and 3.10 in the next section. First it is well known that: Lemma 4.1. Let L(m 1 ), L(m 2 ) be two simple modules. Then L(m 1 m 2 ) is a subquotient of L(m 1 ) ⊗ L(m 2 ). In particular M(L(m 1 m 2 )) ⊂ M(L(m 1 ))M(L(m 2 )). 4.1. Results of [H6]
All results of this subsection are preliminary results of [H6].
Lemma 4.2. Let a ∈ C∗ and m be a monomial of Z[Yi,aq r ]i∈I,r ≥0 . Then for m ∈ M(L(m)) and b ∈ C∗ , (vi,b (m m −1 ) = 0 ⇒ b ∈ aq ri +N ). Lemma 4.3. Let V ∈ Rep(Uq (Lg)) be a Uq (Lg)-module and m ∈ M(V ) such that there is i ∈ I satisfying Min{u i,a (m )|a ∈ C∗ } ≤ −2. Then there is m > m in M(V ) i-dominant such that Max{u i,b (m )|b ∈ C∗ } ≥ 2. We recall [H6] that a monomial m is said to be thin if Maxi∈I,a∈C∗ |u i,a (m)| ≤ 1. Proposition 4.4. If V is thin then all m ∈ M(V ) are thin. If V is special and all m ∈ M(V ) are thin, then V is thin. Lemma 4.5. Let m dominant and J ⊂ I . Let v be an highest weight vector of L(m) and L ⊂ L(m) be the Uq (Lg J )-submodule of L(m) generated by v. Then L is an Uq (Lh)-submodule of L(m) and χq (L ) = L J (m). In particular for µ ∈ ω(m) − j∈J Nα j , we have
where µ→(J ) =
dim((L(m))µ ) = dim((L J (m →(J ) ))µ→(J ) ), ∨ j∈J µ(α j )ω j .
Lemma 4.6. Let V = L(m) be a Uq (Lg)-module simple module and consider a monomial m ∈ (M(L(m)) − {m}). Then there is j ∈ I and M ∈ M(V ) j-dominant such that M > m , M ∈ m Z[A j,b ]b∈C∗ and ((Uq (Lg j ).VM ) ∩ (M)m ) = {0}. We have the following elimination theorem: Theorem 4.7. Let V = L(m) be a Uq (Lg)-module simple module. Let m < m and i ∈ I satisfying the following conditions: (i) there is a+ unique i-dominant M ∈ (M(V ) ∩ m Z[Ai,a ]a∈C∗ ) − {m }, (ii) x (V ) = {0}, M r ∈Z i,r
234
D. Hernandez
(iii) m is not a monomial of L i (M), (iv) if m ∈ M(Uq (Lgi ).VM ) is i-dominant, then v(m m −1 ) ≥ v(m m −1 ), (v) for all j = i, {m ∈ M(V )|v(m m −1 ) < v(m m −1 )} ∩ m Z[A±1 j,a ]a∈C∗ = ∅. / M(V ). Then m ∈ Lemma 4.8. Let L(m) be a simple Uq (Lg)-module, and m ∈ M(L(m)) such that all m ∈ M(L(m)) satisfying v(m m −1 ) < v(m m −1 ) is thin. 1) For i ∈ I such that m is not i-dominant, there is a ∈ C∗ such that u i,a (m ) < 0 and m Ai,aq −1 ∈ M(L(m)). i 2) We suppose that g = sln+1 , that there are i ∈ I , a ∈ C∗ satisfying u i,a (m ) = −1 and m Yi,a is dominant. Then there is M ∈ M(L(m)) dominant such that M > m and vn (m M −1 ) ≤ 1, v1 (m M −1 ) ≤ 1. 3) We suppose that g = sln+1 , that there is j ∈ I , such that m is (I − { j})-dominant and if j ≤ n − 1, then for all a ∈ C∗ , (u j,a (m ) < 0 ⇒ u j+1,aq −1 (m ) > 0). Then there is M ∈ M(L(m)) dominant of the form M = m
(A j,aq −1 A j−1,aq −3 · · · Aia ,aq ia − j−1 ),
{a∈C∗ |u j,a (m )<0}
where for a ∈ C∗ , 1 ≤ i a ≤ j. Observe that we can prove in the same way an analogous result where we replace all i ∈ I by i = n − i + 1. 4.2. Involution of Uq (Lg) and simple modules For µ an automorphism of Uq (Lg) and V a Uq (Lg)-module we denote the corresponding twisted module by µ∗ V . The ± ∓ → Yi,a involution of the algebra Y defined by Yi,a −1 is denoted by σ .
± ± → b−m xi,m , For all b ∈ C∗ , let τb be the automorphism of Uq (Lg) defined by xi,m ± ± ∗ −r h i,r → b h i,r , ki → ki . For V a Uq (Lg)-module we have χq (τb V ) = βb (χq (V )), ± ± ) = Yi,ab . So τb∗ L(m) where βb : Y → Y is the ring morphism such that βb (Yi,a L(βb (m)) and χq (τb∗ L(m)) = βb (χq (L(m))).
Lemma 4.9. [Cha1, Proposition 1.6] There is a unique involution σ of the algebra Uq (Lg) such that for all i ∈ I, r ∈ Z, m ∈ Z − {0}: ± ∓ ) = xi,−r , σ (h i,m ) = −h i,−m , σ (ki ) = ki−1 . σ (xi,r ± ∓ Moreover for m ≥ 0, σ (φi,±m ) = φi,∓m . ± ∓ ) = −xi,−r to define an involution of Uq (Lg).) (Observe that we could also use σ (xi,r
Lemma 4.10. We have χq (σ ∗ V ) = σ (χq (V )).
On Minimal Affinizations of Representations of Quantum Groups
235
± ± ∓ Proof. For γ = (γi,±m )i∈I,m≥0 , it follows from the relation σ (φi,±m ) = φi,∓m that ± ∗ q i,a Vγ = (σ V )γ , where γ = (γi,∓m )i∈I,m≥0 . Let Q i (u) = a∈C∗ (1 − ua) and Ri (u) = a∈C∗ (1 − ua)ri,a such that in C[[u ± ]] we have:
deg(Q i )−deg(Ri )
m≥0
± γi,±m u ±m = qi
Q i (uqi−1 )Ri (uqi ) Q i (uqi )Ri (uqi−1 )
.
Then in C[[u ± ]] we have:
deg(Q i )−deg(Ri )
Q i (u −1 qi−1 )Ri (u −1 qi )
deg(Q i )−deg(Ri )
Q i (uqi−1 )Ri (uqi )
∓ γi,∓m u ±m = qi
m≥0
= qi where Q i (u) = identities qi
a∈C∗ (1
Q i (u −1 qi )Ri (u −1 qi−1 ) Q i (uqi )Ri (uqi−1 )
− ua)ri,a−1 and Ri (u) =
a∈C∗ (1
,
− ua)qi,a−1 by using the
−1 −1 1 − au −1 qi−1 1 − a −1 uqi−1 −1 1 − a uqi −1 1 − au qi = q and q = q . i i i 1 − au −1 qi 1 − a −1 uqi 1 − a −1 uqi−1 1 − au −1 qi−1
In particular χ (σ ∗ V ) = σ (χ (V )), where, σ : E → E is defined by σ (e(λ)) = e(−λ). Let w0 be the longest element in the Weyl group of g and i → i be the unique bijection of I such that w0 (αi ) = −αi . Let h ∨ be the dual Coxeter number of g and r ∨ the maximal number of edges connecting two vertices of the Dynkin diagram of g. Corollary 4.11. For m dominant, we have σ ∗ L(m) L(m ), where u i,a (m) m = Y −1 −r ∨ h ∨ . a∈C∗
i,a
q
Proof. A submodule of V is a submodule of σ ∗ V , so V simple implies σ ∗ V simple. As it is proved in [FM1, Corollary 6.9] that the lowest monomial of L(m) is −u i,a (m) , we get the result from Lemma 4.10. i∈I,a∈C∗ Y r ∨ h∨ i,aq
Observe that as a by product we get the following symmetry property: (i) ) is invariant by (τa 2 q r ∨ h ∨ ◦ σ ). Corollary 4.12. If k = k, then χq (Wk,a
For example, this symmetry can be observed on the diagrams of q-characters in [Nak2, Fig. 1] and [H1, Sect. 8]. Let us go back to the main purposes of this paper. First we get a simplification in the proof of Theorem 3.8: Corollary 4.13. In Theorem 3.8, it suffices to prove that all minimal affinizations are special.
236
D. Hernandez
Proof. First suppose that g is of type B or G. Then i = i. If m satisfies condition (I I ) of Theorem 3.5, then m of Corollary 4.11 satisfies condition (I ). Moreover if M is dominant, then σ (M) is antidominant. So we can conclude with Lemma 4.10. If g is of type A, conditions (I) and (II) are the same up to a different numbering. Exactly in the same way we get : Corollary 4.14. In Theorem 3.9, it suffices to prove that the considered simple representations satisfying the condition (II) are special. For V a Uq (Lg)-module, denote by V ∗ the dual module of V . As S(ki ) = ki−1 , we have χ (V ∗ ) = σ (χ (V )). As a direct consequence of [FM1, Corollary 6.9], we have: Lemma 4.15. For m dominant, we have (L(m))∗ L(m ), where m =
u (m) Y i,a ∨ ∨ . i∈I,a∈C∗ i,aq −r h
Note that it was proved in [FM1] that we have the following relation between the ∨ ∨ q-character of (Vi (a))∗ Vi (aq −r h ) and Vi (a): χq ((Vi (a))∗ ) = (τa ◦ σ ◦ τa −1 )(χq (Vi (a))). Proposition 4.16. For m a dominant monomial, we have χ (L(m)) = χ (L((σ (m))−1 )). Proof. From previous results, we have χ (σ ∗ ((L(m))∗ )) = σ (χ ((L(m))∗ )) = χ (L(m)), and σ ∗ ((L(m))∗ ) L(
u i,a (m) i∈I,a∈C∗ Yi,a −1 )
= L((σ (m))−1 ).
u i,a (m) The above proposition can be extended to χ (L(m)) = χ (L( i∈I,a∈C∗ Yi,ba −1 )) for all b ∈ C∗ . Observe that we do not have a direct relation between the monomials of the same weight space: for example for g = sl2 and m = Yq Yq23 , the term of weight in χq (L(m)) 2 −1 is 2Yq Yq 3 Yq−1 5 and the term of weight in χq (L(σ (m))) is Yq −3 + Yq −3 Yq .
4.3. Additional preliminary results (i)
(i)
Lemma 4.17. Let m = X k,a . Let m ∈ M(Wk,a ) and µ ∈ {k, k − 2, . . . , −k + 2}. Then vi,aq µ (m m −1 ) ≥ 1 implies i
vi,aq k (m m −1 ) ≥ 1, vi,aq k−2 (m m −1 ) ≥ 1, . . . , vi,aq µ (m m −1 ) ≥ 1. i
i
i
On Minimal Affinizations of Representations of Quantum Groups
237
Proof. For µ = k the result is clear. We suppose that µ < k and we prove the result by induction on k. For k = 1 the result is clear. For general k ≥ 1 and µ < k, suppose that vi,aq µ (m m −1 ) ≥ 1. So m = m and it follows from Theorem 2.14 that m ≤ m A−1 k . i
By Lemma 4.1,
m
= m 1 m 2 , where m 1 ∈
M(Vi (aqik−1 ))
and m 2 ∈
i,aqi (i) M(W ). k−1,aqi−1
From Lemma 4.2, v j,b (m 1 Y −1 k−1 ) = 0 implies b = aq ri (k−1)+R with R ≥ 1 and so i,aqi µ (i) )−1 ) ≥ 1. So by the induction hypothesis b = aqi . So we have vi,aq µ (m 2 (X k−1,aqi−1 i vi,aq k−2 (m 2 (X i
(i) )−1 ) k−1,aqi−1
≥ 1,vi,aq k−4 (m 2 (X i
(i) )−1 ) k−1,aqi−1
· · · , vi,aq µ (m 2 (X i
≥ 1,
(i) )−1 ) k−1,aqi−1
≥ 1.
We can conclude because it follows from Theorem 2.14 that vi,aq k (m m −1 ) ≥ 1. i
C∗
Lemma 4.18. Let a ∈ and a monomial m ∈ Z[Yi,aq r ]i∈I,r ∈Z . Let m ∈ M(L(m)) and R ∈ Z such that for all i ∈ I , (u i,aq r (m ) < 0 ⇒ r ≤ R). Then there is a dominant monomial M ∈ M(L(m)) ∩ (mZ[Ai,aq r ]{(i,r )|i∈I,r ≤R−ri } ). Proof. From Lemma 2.15 it suffices to prove the result for Uq (slˆ2 ). In this case the result follows from (3) of Proposition 2.9. To conclude this section, let us prove a refined version of Proposition 2.15. For i ∈ I , u i,aq 2r (m) . Define: a ∈ C∗ and m a monomial denote m →(i,a) = r ∈Z Yi,aq 2ri i
L i,a (m) = mµiI ((m →(i,a) )−1 χqi (L i (m →(i,a) ))).
Observe that for a ∈ aqi2Z , m →(i,a) = m →(i,a ) and L i,a (m) = L i,a (m). So the definition can be given for a ∈ (C∗ /qi2Z ). We have: Corollary 4.19. For a representation V ∈ Rep(Uq (Lg)), i ∈ I and a ∈ C∗ , there is a unique decomposition in a finite sum: χq (V ) = λi,a (m )L i,a (m ). →(i,a) {m |(m )
Moreover for all
m
such that
(m )→(i,a)
is dominant}
is dominant, we have λi,a (m ) ≥ 0.
Proof. First we write the decomposition of Lemma 2.15 with J = {i}. Then it follows from Proposition 2.9 that for m an i-dominant monomial we have L i,b ((m )→(i,b) ). L i (m ) = (m )→(I −{i}) b∈(C∗ /qi2Z )
5. Proof of the Main Results In this section we prove Theorems 3.8, 3.9 and 3.10. We study successively the different types.
238
D. Hernandez
5.1. Type A
In this Sect. 5.1, g = sln+1 .
Lemma 5.1. Let λ ∈ P + and L(m) be a minimal affinization of V (λ). Suppose that m satisfies the condition (I I ) (resp. condition (I )) of Theorem 3.5. Let K = max{i ∈ I |λi = 0} (resp. K = min{i ∈ I |λi = 0}). The following properties are satisfied: (1) (2) (3) (4)
For all m ∈ M(L(m)), if v K (m m −1 ) ≥ 1, then v K ,a K q λ K (m m −1 ) ≥ 1. L(m) is special. L(m) is thin. For all m ∈ M(L(m)) we have v j,ak q λk +| j−k| (m m −1 ) = v j,ak q λk +| j−k|−2 (m m −1 ) = · · · = v j,ak q λk +| j−k|−2R (m m −1 ) = 1, where j = max{i|vi (m m −1 ) = 0} (resp. j = min{i|vi (m m −1 ) = 0}), k = max{i ≤ j|λi = 0} (resp. k = min{i ≥ j|λi = 0}), and R = v j (m m −1 ) − 1. Observe that as a consequence of property (4), for b ∈ C∗ , v j,b (m m −1 ) = 0 implies b ∈ {ak q λk +| j−k| , ak q λk +| j−k|−2 , . . . , ak q λk +| j−k|−2R }.
Lemma 5.1 combined with Corollary 4.13 implies Theorem 3.8 and Theorem 3.10 for type A. Proof. We suppose that L(m) satisfies (I I ) (the case (I ) is treated in the same way). We prove by induction on u(m) ≥ 0 simultaneously that (1), (2), (3) and (4) are satisfied. For u(m) = 0 the result is clear. Suppose that u(m) ≥ 1. First we prove (1) by induction on v(m m −1 ) ≥ 0. For v(m m −1 ) = 0 we have m = m and the result is clear. In general suppose that for m such that v(m m −1 ) < v(m m −1 ), the property is satisfied. Suppose that v K (m m −1 ) ≥ 1 and v K ,a K q λ K (m m −1 ) = 0. It suffices to prove that the conditions of Proposition 4.7 with i = K are satisfied. Condition (i) of Proposition 4.7: if M > m and M ∈ M(L(m)), we have v K ,a K q λ K (Mm −1 ) = 0 and so by the induction hypothesis v K (Mm −1 ) = 0. So if we suppose v (m m −1 ) moreover that M ∈ m Z[A K ,a ]a∈C∗ , we have M = m a∈C∗ A KK,a,a , and so we get v (m m −1 ) the uniqueness. For the existence, it suffices to prove that this M = m a∈C∗ A KK,a,a is in M(L(m)). By Lemma 4.6, there is j ∈ I , M ∈ M(L(m)) j-dominant such that M > m and M ∈ m Z[A j,a ]a∈C∗ . By the induction hypothesis on v we have j = K , and so by uniqueness M = M. Condition (ii) of Proposition 4.7: by construction of M we have v K (Mm −1 ) = 0. Condition (iii) of Proposition 4.7: first observe that M ∈ m →(K ) M(L(m(m →(K ) )−1 )). As u(m(m →(K ) )−1 ) < u(m), we have property (4) for L(m(m →(K ) )−1 ) and we get (M)→(K ) = Y K ,a K q λ K −1 Y K ,a K q λ K −3 · · · Y K ,a
Kq
−λ K +1−2R
with R ≥ 0. By Lemma 2.9, m is not a monomial of M(L K (M)).
,
On Minimal Affinizations of Representations of Quantum Groups
239
Condition (iv) of Proposition 4.7: let m ∈ M(Uq (Lg K ).(L(m)) M ) such that →(K ) v(m m −1 ) < v(m m −1 ). Then we have m ∈ M A−1 Z[A−1 K ,b ]b∈C∗ and so (m ) K ,a q λk K
is right negative, so m is not K -dominant. Condition (v) of Proposition 4.7: clear by the induction property on v. Now we prove (2). Let J = {i ∈ I |i < K }. By Lemma 4.1, M(L(m)) ⊂ (m →(J ) M (L(m →(K ) ))) ∪ (M(L(m →(J ) ))m →(K ) ). From Theorem 2.14, all monomials of m →(J ) (χq (L(m →(K ) )) − m →(K ) ) are lower than m A−1 which is right-negative, and K ,a q λ K K
so are not dominant. Let m ∈ (M(L(m →(J ) ))m →(K ) − {m}). If v K (m m −1 ) ≥ 1, it follows from property (1) that m is lower than m A−1 which is right-negative, so m K ,a q λ K K
is not dominant. If v K (m m −1 ) = 0, we have u K ,b (m (m →(K ) )−1 ) ≥ 0 for all b ∈ C∗ . We have m (m →(K ) )−1 ∈ M(L(m →(J ) )) with u(m →(J ) ) < u(m), so by the induction hypothesis on u, m (m →(K ) )−1 is not dominant. So there is i = K , b ∈ C∗ , such that u i,b (m (m →(K ) )−1 ) < 0. As u i,b (m (m →(K ) )−1 ) = u i,b (m ), m is not dominant. So L(m) is special. Now we prove (3). From property (2) and Proposition 4.4, it suffices to prove that all monomials of M(L(m)) are thin. From Lemma 4.3, we can suppose that there is m ∈ M(L(m)) such that there are i ∈ I, a ∈ C∗ satisfying u i,a (m ) = 2 and such that all m satisfying v(m m −1 ) < v(m m −1 ) is thin. Then m is ({1, . . . , i −2}∪{i}∪{i +2, . . . , n})dominant and (u i−1,b (m ) < 0 ⇒ b = aq) and (u i+1,b (m ) < 0 ⇒ b = aq). We can apply (3) of Lemma 4.8 for g{1,...,i−1} and for g{i+1,...,n} . We get M ∈ M(L(m)) dominant satisfying u j1 ,aq j1 −i (M) ≥ 1, u j2 ,aq i− j2 (M) ≥ 1 with j1 < j2 , j1 ≤ i ≤ j2 . From property (2) we have m = M, contradiction with condition (II) of Theorem 3.5. Now we prove (4) by induction on v(m m −1 ) ≥ 0. We can suppose that j = n (Lemma 4.5). So k = K . For v(m m −1 ) = 0 we have m = m and the result is clear. Let be m such that the property is satisfied for m with v(m m −1 ) < v(m m −1 ). Let R ≥ 0 be maximal such that m ≤ m A−1 n,a
λ +n−k kq k
A−1 n,a
λ +n−k−2 kq k
· · · A−1 n,a
λ +n−k−2R+2 kq k
.
We suppose moreover that m ≤ m A−1 n,a
λ +n−k kq k
A−1 n,a
λ +n−k−2 kq k
· · · A−1 n,a
λ +n−k−2R+2 kq k
A−1 n,b
with b = ak q λk +n−k−2R . By the induction property on v, m is (I − {n})-dominant, u n,bq (m ) < 0 and (u n,c (m ) < 0 ⇒ c = bq). By property (3), u n,bq (m ) = −1. m is a monomial of L n (m An,b ). By property (3), we can apply (3) of Lemma 4.8 and we get M ∈ M(L(m)) dominant of the form M = m An,b An−1,bq −1 · · · An−r,bq −r with r ≥ 0. From property (2), we have M = m. So R = 0. So n − r = K , bq −r = a K q λ K, that is to say b = a K q λ K +n−K, contradiction. 5.2. Type B
In this Sect. 5.2, we suppose that g is of type Bn .
5.2.1. Preliminary results for type B. Lemma 5.2. Let a ∈ C∗ , m ∈ Z[Yi,aq r ]i∈I,r ∈Z be a dominant monomial. Consider m ∈ M(L(m)) {1, . . . , n−1}-dominant such that all m ∈ M(L(m)) satisfying v(m m −1 ) <
240
D. Hernandez
v(m m −1 ) is thin. Suppose that m is not dominant and let R = min{r ∈ Z|u n,aq r (m ) < 0}. Then there is M ∈ M(L(m)) {1, . . . , n − 1}-dominant such that m ≥ M > m , m M −1 ∈ Z[Ai,aq R+2(i−n)+4r −1 ]i∈I,r ≤0 , u n,aq R (M) = 0 and for all r ≤ R, u n,aq r (M) ≥ 0 and l≥0 u n,aq R−2−4l (M) > 0. Proof. For shortness of notations, we suppose that m Yn,aq R is dominant (the proof is exactly the same if R = max{r ∈ Z|u n,aq r (m ) < 0}). First there is m 0 = An,aq R−1 An−1,aq R−3 · · · An−α,aq R−1−2α m ∈ M(L(m)), where α ≥ 0 and m 0 is {1, . . . , n − 1}-dominant. If α = 0 we take M = m 0 . Otherwise, u n,aq R−4 (m 0 ) = −1 and u n,b (m 0 ) > 0 implies b = aq R−4 . We continue and we get inductively (at each step the involved monomials are thin by assumption): m r = An,aq R−1−4r An−1,aq R−3−4r · · · An−α+r,aq R−1−2α−2r m r −1 ∈ M(L(m)), where 1 ≤ r ≤ α and m r is {1, . . . , n − 1}-dominant. We take M = m α and the properties are satisfied by construction. Lemma 5.3. Let L(m) be a simple Uq (Lg)-module. Let m ∈ M(L(m)) be such that all m ∈ M(L(m)) satisfying v(m m −1 ) < v(m m −1 ) is thin. Suppose that there are j ∈ (I − {n}) such that u j,b (m ) < 0 and mY j,b is dominant. Moreover we suppose that if j = 1, then u j−1,bq −2 (m ) > 0. Then there is M ∈ M(L(m)) dominant satisfying one of the following conditions: (1) M = m A j,bq −2 A j+1,bq −4 · · · A j+r,bq −2−2r where 0 ≤ r ≤ n − j, (2) M = m (A j,bq −2 A j+1,bq −4 · · · An−1,bq −2n+2 j )An,bq −2n+2 j M where M ∈ Z[Ak,bq −2n+2 j+2(k−n)−4l ]k 0, in case (3), we have u n,bq −3−2n+2 j (M) = u n,bq −1−2n+2 j (M) = 1, in case (4), we have u n−1,bq −2n−4+2 j (M) = 1. Proof. Thanks to the hypothesis u j−1,bq −2 (m ) > 0, we can suppose that j = 1. By using (3) of Lemma 4.8 with g{1,...,n−1} of type An−1 , we get m 1 = m A1,bq −2 A2,bq −4 · · · A1+r,bq −2(r +1) ∈ M(L(m)), {1, . . . , n − 1}-dominant. If m 1 is dominant, then the condition (1) is satisfied, and we set M = m 1 . Otherwise we have r = n − 2, u n−1,bq −2n (m 1 ) = 1, m 1 is not n-dominant and (u n,d (m 1 ) < 0 ⇒ d = bq −2n+3 or d = bq −2n+1 ). If u n,bq −2n+1 (m 1 ) ≥ 0 and u n,bq −2n+3 (m 1 ) = −1, then we can use Lemma 5.2 and so condition (2) is satisfied. If u n,bq −2n+1 (m 1 ) = −1 and u n,bq −2n+3 (m 1 ) ≥ 0, M = m 1 An,bq −2n ∈ M(L(m)) is dominant, so condition (1) is satisfied. If u n,bq −2n+1 (m 1 ) = −1 and u n,bq −2n+3 (m 1 ) = −1, m 2 = m 1 An,bq −2n An,bq −2n+2 ∈ M(L(m)) is n-dominant and (u n−1,d (m 2 ) < 0 ⇒ d = bq −2n+2 ). If m 2 is dominant, condition (3) is satisfied. If u n−1,bq −2n+2 (m 2 ) = −1, M = m 2 An−1,bq −2n ∈ M(L(m)) is dominant as u n,bq −2n+1 (m 2 ) = u n,bq −2n−1 (m 2 ) = 1. So condition (4) is satisfied. The additional properties in the end of the statement are clear by construction of M.
On Minimal Affinizations of Representations of Quantum Groups
241
(n)
5.2.2. Kirillov-Reshetikhin modules Wλ,a . Now we consider the case of a KirillovReshetikhin module in the node n, that is to say a minimal affinization of V (λn ) (observe that in this case condition (I) and condition (II) of Theorem 3.5 are satisfied). (n) . Then Lemma 5.4. Let m = X λ,a
(1) For all m ∈ M(L(m)) and µ ∈ {λ, λ−2, . . . , −λ+2}, vn,aq µ (m m −1 ) ≥ 1 implies vn,aq λ (m m −1 ) ≥ 1, vn,aq λ−2 (m m −1 ) ≥ 1, . . . , vn,aq µ (m m −1 ) ≥ 1. (2) L(m) is special. (3) L(m) is thin. (4) Let m ∈ M(L(m)) satisfying r ∈Z,i
r ∈Z v j,aq λ+2n−2 j+4r (m
m −1 ) − 1.
Proof. (1) follows from Lemma 4.17. (2) follows from Theorem 2.14. Let us prove (3). From property (2) and Proposition 4.4, it suffices to prove that all monomials of M(L(m)) are thin. From Lemma 4.3, we can suppose that there is m ∈ M(L(m)) such that there are l ∈ I, d ∈ C∗ satisfying u l,d (m ) = 2 and such that all m ∈ M(L(m)) satisfying v(m m −1 ) < v(m m −1 ) is thin. We distinguish three cases (α), (β), (γ ). (α) Suppose that there is c ∈ C∗ such that u n,c (m ) ≥ 2. Then one of the two following conditions is satisfied. (α.i): There is b ∈ C∗ such that u n−1,b (m ) = −1, (u n−1,d (m ) < 0 ⇒ d = b), (u n,bq −1 (m ) = 2 or u n,bq −3 (m ) = 2) and (u n,d (m ) = 2 ⇒ (d = bq −1 or d = bq −3 )). (α.ii): There is b ∈ C∗ such that u n−1,b (m ) = u n−1,bq 2 (m ) = −1, u n,bq −1 (m ) = 2, (u n−1,d (m ) < 0 ⇒ (d = b or d = bq 2 )) and (u n,d (m ) = 2 ⇒ d = bq −1 ). Otherwise, by using Proposition 2.15, we would get m ∈ M(L(m)) such that v(m m −1 ) < v(m m −1 ) and m does not satisfy property (3). First suppose that the condition (α.i) is satisfied. We have the following subcases: (α.i.1): u n,bq −1 (m ) ≥ 1 and u n,bq −3 (m ) ≥ 1. Then m An−1,bq −2 ∈ M(L(m)) is (I − {n − 2})-dominant and by (3) of Lemma 4.8 with g{1,...,n−1} we get M ∈ M(L(m)) dominant such that u n−R,bq −2−2R (M) ≥ 1 for an R ≥ 1. By property (2), M = m, contradiction. (α.i.2): u n,bq −3 (m ) = 2 and u n,bq −1 (m ) = 0. Then m = m An−1,bq −2 ∈ M(L(m)) −1 ∈ M(L(m)) such and Yn,bq −3 Yn,bq −1 appears in m . So by Lemma 2.15 there is m that m < m and u n,bq −3 (m ) ≥ 2, contradiction. (α.i.3): u n,bq −1 (m ) = 2 and u n,bq −3 (m ) = 0. Then m = m An−1,bq −2 ∈ M(L(m)) is (I − {n − 2, n})-dominant and ∀ j ∈ I, (u j,bq l (m ) > 0 ⇒ l ≤ −2). So by Lemma 4.18 we get M ∈ M(L(m)) dominant such that vn,bq −4 (m M −1 ) ≥ 1 and m M −1 ∈ Z[A j,bq l ] j∈I,l≤−3 . So u n,bq −1 (M) = u n,bq −1 (m ) = 1. By property (2), M = m. By property (1), we have vn,b (m M −1 ) ≥ 1, contradiction.
242
D. Hernandez
Now we suppose that (α.ii) is satisfied. We have the following subcases: (α.ii.1): u n,bq (m ) = 0. Then m = m An−1,bq −2 An−1,b An,b ∈ M(L(m)) and −1 Yn,bq −1 appears in m . So m = m An−1,bq −2 ∈ M(L(m)) Yn−1,bq −4 Yn−1,bq −2 Yn−1,b and u n−1,bq −4 (m ) = 2, contradiction. (α.ii.2): u n,bq (m ) = u n,bq −3 (m ) = 1. Consider m = m An−1,b An−1,bq −2 . Then m ∈ M(L(m)) is (I − {n − 2})-dominant and by (3) of Lemma 4.8 with g{1,...,n−2} we get M ∈ M(L(m)) dominant such that u n−r1 ,bq −2r1 (M) ≥ 1 and u n−r2 ,bq −2−2r2 (M) ≥ 1 with r1 , r2 ≥ 1. By property (2), M = m, contradiction. (α.ii.3): u n,bq (m ) = 1 and u n,bq −3 (m ) = 0. Then m = m An−1,bq −2 An−1,b An,bq −4 ∈ M(L(m)) is (I − {n − 2})-dominant, Yn−1,bq −2 Yn,bq −5 appears in m and ∀ j ∈ I, (u j,d (m ) = −1 ⇒ (( j, d) = (n − 2, bq −2 ) or ( j, d) = (n − 2, b))). So by (3) of Lemma 4.8, there is m ∈ M(L(m)) of the form m = An−2,bq −2 An−3,bq −4 · · · An−R,bq 2−2R m with R ≥ 1 such that ∀ j ∈ I, (u j,d (m ) = −1 ⇒ ( j, d) = (n − 2, bq −2 )). We have u n,bq −5 (m ) = u n−R,bq −2R (m ) = 1. If m is dominant, we have m = m, contradiction. So u n−2,bq −2 (m ) = −1. As moreover u n,bq −5 (m ) = 1, we have a dominant monomial M ∈ M(L(m)) of the form: M = m (An−2,bq −4 An−1,bq −6 An,bq −8 )(An−3,bq −6 An−2,bq −8 An−1,bq −10 An,bq −12 ) · · · (An−r,bq −2r An−r +1,bq −2−2r · · · An,bq −4r ) ×(An−r −1,bq −2−2r An−r,bq −4−2r · · · An−r −1+r ,bq −2−2r −2r ), where r ≥ 1 and r + 1 ≥ r ≥ 0. By property (1), we have M = m. So we have u n−R,bq −2R (m) = u n−R,bq −2R (m ) = 1, contradiction. (β) Suppose that there is b ∈ C∗ such that u n−1,b (m ) ≥ 2. Then we have (u n−2,d (m ) < 0 ⇒ d = bq 2 ) and (u n,d (m ) < 0 ⇒ d = bq). By (3) of Lemma 4.8 with J = {1, . . . , n − 1} and J = {n}, we get a dominant monomial M ∈ M(L(m)) satisfying one of the two following conditions: (β.1) u j1 ,bq 2 j1 −2n+2 (M) = 1, u n,bq −1 (M) = 1 with j1 ≤ n − 1. (β.2) u j1 ,bq 2 j1 −2n+2 (M) = 1, u n−1,b (M) = 1 with j1 ≤ n − 2. From (2) we have m = M, contradiction. (γ ) Suppose that there is i ≤ n − 2 and b ∈ C∗ such that u i,b (m ) ≥ 2. Then m is ({1, . . . , i − 2} ∪ {i} ∪ {i + 2, . . . , n})-dominant. We have (u i−1,d (m ) < 0 ⇒ d = bq 2 ) and (u i+1,d (m ) < 0 ⇒ d = bq 2 ). By applying (3) of Lemma 4.8 and Lemma 5.3, we get M ∈ M(L(m)) dominant such that (M){1,...,n−2} = 1. From property (2) we have m = M, contradiction. Now we prove property (4) by induction on v(m m −1 ) ≥ 0. Let j be as in property (4). For v(m m −1 ) = 0 we have m = m and the result is clear. We suppose that property (4) is satisfied for m satisfying v(m m −1 ) < v(m m −1 ). Let R ≥ 0 maximal such that A−1 · · · A−1 . We suppose moreover that m m −1 ≤ A−1 j,aq λ+2n−2 j j,aq λ+2n−2 j−4 j,aq λ+2n−2 j+4−4R m m −1 ≤ A−1 A−1 · · · A−1 A−1 , j,aq λ+2n−2 j j,aq λ+2n−2 j−4 j,aq λ+2n−2 j+4−4R j,b
On Minimal Affinizations of Representations of Quantum Groups
243
with b = aq λ+2n−2 j−4µ and µ = R. If j ≥ 2, we have u j−1,b (m ) = 1. By the induction hypothesis on v, m is (I − { j})-dominant, u j,bq 2 (m ) = −1 and (u j,d (m ) < 0 ⇒ d = bq 2 ). By property (3), we can apply Lemma 5.3 and we get a dominant monomial M ∈ M(L(m)). From property (2), we have M = m. As u n−1 (m) = 0, we are in the situation (1) or (3) of Lemma 5.3. So m(m )−1 = A j,b A j+1,bq −2 · · · An−1,bq −2(n−1− j) An,bq −2(n− j) (An,bq 2−2(n− j) ), where ∈ {0, 1}. So b = aq λ+2n−2 j , µ = 0 and R = 0, contradiction. 5.2.3. Condition (I). Now we treat the general case of minimal affinization satisfying (n) condition (I) of Theorem 3.5 (except the Kirillov-Reshetikhin modules Wk,a already studied in Lemma 5.4). Lemma 5.5. Let λ ∈ P + and L(m) be a minimal affinization of V (λ) such that m satisfies condition (I) of Theorem 3.5. Let K = min{i ∈ I |λi = 0}. We suppose that K ≤ n − 1. Then the following conditions are satisfied: (1) For all m ∈ M(L(m)) satisfying r ∈Z v K ,a K q 2λ K +4r (m m −1 ) ≥ 1, we have v K ,a K q 2λ K (m m −1 ) ≥ 1. (2) L(m) is special. (3) L(m) is thin. (4) Let m ∈ M(L(m)) satisfying r ∈Z,i
vi,ai q 2i+4r (m m −1 ) ≥ 1},
r ∈Z
k = min{i ≥ j|λi = 0} and R = (
r ∈Z v j,a j q 2λ j +4r (m
(5) Let m ∈ M(L(m)) such that min{i| λn = 0 and
m −1 )) − 1.
r ∈Z vi,ai q 2λi +4r (m
m −1 )
≥ 1} = n. Then
vn,an q λn (m m −1 ) = vn,an q λn −2 (m m −1 ) where R =
r ∈Z vn,an q 2λn +2r (m
= · · · = vn,an q λn −2R (m m −1 ) = 1, m −1 ) − 1.
Proof. We prove by induction on u(m) ≥ 0 simultaneously that (1), (2), (3), (4) and (5) are satisfied. For u(m) = 0 the result is clear. Suppose that u(m) ≥ 1. First we prove (1) by induction on v(m m −1 ) ≥ 0. For v(m m −1 ) = 0 we have m = m −1 m −1 ) and the result is clear. In general suppose that for m such that v(m m ) < v(m −1 −1 the property is satisfied, that v K ,a K q 2λ K (m m ) = 0 and r ∈Z v K ,a K q 2λ K +4r (m m ) ≥ 1. Observe that it follows from Lemma 2.15 and Corollary 4.19 that m is (I − {K })-dom2λ inant and (m )→(K ,a K q K ) is dominant.
244
D. Hernandez
If m is not dominant, by Corollary 4.19, there is m ∈ M(L(m)) K -dominant such that m is a monomial of L K ,a K q 2λ K −2 (m ). Moreover from Proposition 2.9, there is b∈ a K q 2λ K +4Z such that A K ,b m ∈ M(L(m)). By the induction property on v, we have −1 →(K ) M(L(m r ∈Z v K ,a K q 2λ K +4r (m A K ,b m ) = 0. So m = m A K ,b . But m ∈ m →(K ) −1 →(K ) −1 ) )). As u(m(m ) ) < u(m), we have property (4) for L(m(m →(K ) )−1 ) (m and we get (m )→(K ) ∈ Y K ,a K q 2λ K −2 Y K ,a K q 2λ K −6 · · · Y K ,a
Kq
−2λ K +2−4R
Z[Y K ,a K q 4r +2λ K ]r ∈Z
with R ≥ 0. By Lemma 2.9, m is not a monomial of M(L K (m )), contradiction. So m is dominant. Let us prove that r ∈Z v K ,a K q 2λ K +4r +2 (m m −1 ) = 0. Observe that m Y K−1,a
Kq
2λ K −2
∈ M(L(mY K−1,a
Kq
2λ K −2
)).
Moreover u j,a (m (m →(K ) )−1 ) < 0 implies j = K and a = a K q 2λ K −2 . As we have u(mY K−1,a q 2λ K −2 ) < u(m), properties (2) and (3) are satisfied by L(mY K−1,a q 2λ K −2 ). So K K we can use (2) of Lemma 4.8 for g{1,...,n−1} of type An−1 and we get a monomial m ∈ M(L(mY K−1,a
Kq
2λ K −2
)) ∩ (m Y K−1,a
Kq
2λ K −2
Z[A j,a K q 2λ K +4r +2(K − j) ] j≤n−1,r ∈Z ),
which is {1, . . . , n − 1}-dominant and satisfying vn−1 (m Y K−1,a vn−1 (m Y K−1,a
Kq
2λ K −2
(m )−1 ) = 0, then mY K−1,a
Kq
2λ K −2
Kq
2λ K −2
(m )−1 ) ≤ 1. If
= m and the result is clear.
Otherwise, consider the unique b ∈ a K q 2λ K +2(n−K )+4Z such that vn−1,b (m Y K−1,a
(m )−1 )
(m )
bq −1 ).
(m )
Kq
2λ K −2
= 1. We have u n,d < 0 ⇒ (d = bq or d = If u n,bq = 0 we use Lemma 5.2 and we get the result. If u n,bq (m ) = −1 and u n,bq −1 (m ) = 0, we use Lemma 5.2, and in particular we get a monomial (mY K−1,a
Kq
2λ K −2
−1 )A−1 j,d ∈ M(L(mY K ,a
Kq
2λ K −2
)),
where d ∈ / a K q 2λ K +4Z , contradiction with condition (II). In the same way if we have u n,bq (m ) = −1 and u n,bq −1 (m ) = −1, then we get a contradiction by using Lemma 5.2 twice. Now it suffices to prove that the conditions of Proposition 4.7 with i = K are satisfied. Condition (i) of Proposition 4.7: if M > m is in M(L(m)), we have necessarily v K ,a K q 2λ K (Mm −1 ) = 0. So by induction hypothesis r ∈Z v K ,a K q 2λ K +4r (Mm −1 ) = 0, and so v K (Mm −1 ) = 0. So if we suppose moreover that M ∈ m Z[A K ,a ]a∈C∗ , we v (m m −1 ) have necessarily M = m a∈C∗ A KK,a,a , and so we get the uniqueness. For the v (m m −1 ) is in M(L(m)). existence, it suffices to prove that this M = m a∈C∗ A KK,a,a By Lemma 4.6, there is j ∈ I , M ∈ M(L(m)) j-dominant such that M > m and M ∈ m Z[A j,a ]a∈C∗ . By induction hypothesis on v we have j = K , and so by uniqueness M = M. Condition (ii) of Proposition 4.7: by construction of M we have v K (Mm −1 ) = 0. Condition (iii) of Proposition 4.7: first observe that M ∈ m →(K ) M(L(m(m →(K ) )−1 )).
On Minimal Affinizations of Representations of Quantum Groups
245
As u(m(m →(K ) )−1 ) < u(m), we have property (4) for L(m(m →(K ) )−1 ) and we get (M)→(K ) ∈ Y K ,a K q 2λ K −2 Y K ,a K q 2λ K −6 · · · Y K ,a
Kq
−2λ K +2−4R
Z[Y K ,a K q 4r +2λ K ]r ∈Z
with R ≥ 0. By Lemma 2.9, m is not a monomial of M(L K (M)). Condition (iv) of Proposition 4.7: consider a monomial m ∈ M(Uq (Lg K ).VM ) Z[A−1 such that v(m m −1 ) < v(m m −1 ). We have m ≤ M A−1 K ,d ]d∈C∗ and so K ,a q 2λk K
(m )→(K ,a K q K ) is right negative, so m is not K -dominant. Condition (v) of Proposition 4.7: clear by the induction property on v. Now we prove (2). Let J = {i ∈ I |K < i}. From Lemma 4.1, 2λ
M(L(m)) ⊂ (m →(J ) M(L(m →(K ) ))) ∪ (M(L(m →(J ) ))m →(K ) ). As all monomials of m →(J ) (χq (L(m →(K ) )) − m →(K ) ) are lower than m A−1 K ,a
λ Kq K
(Theorem 2.14) which is right-negative, they are not dominant. Let m be a mono→(J ) ) < u(m), the induction property mial in (M(L(m →(J ) ))m →(K ) − {m}). As u(m →(K ) −1 implies that m (m ) is not dominant. If l∈Z v K ,a K q 2λ K +4l (m m −1 ) ≥ 1, it folwhich is right-negative, so lows from property (1) that m is lower than m A−1 K ,a K q 2λ K m is not dominant. We suppose that l∈Z v K ,a K q 2λ K +4l (m m −1 ) = 0. We have for all l ∈ Z, u K ,q 2K +4l (m (m →(K ) )−1 ) ≥ 0, and so there is (i, a) ∈ I × C∗ not of the form (K , q 2K +4l ) with l ∈ Z such that u i,a (m (m →(K ) )−1 ) < 0. So u i,a (m ) = u i,a (m (m →(K ) )−1 ) < 0 and m is not dominant. So L(m) is special. Now we prove (3). From property (2) and Proposition 4.4, it suffices to prove that all monomials of M(L(m)) are thin. From Lemma 4.3, we can suppose that there is m ∈ M(L(m)) such that there are l ∈ I, d ∈ C∗ satisfying u l,d (m ) = 2 and such that all m ∈ M(L(m)) satisfying v(m m −1 ) < v(m m −1 ) is thin. We consider subcases as in the proof of Lemma 5.4. If (α.i.1) is satisfied, we get u n−R,bq −2−2R (m) ≥ 1 with R ≥ 1 and (u n,bq −1 (m) ≥ 1 or u n,bq −3 (m) ≥ 1). As −2 − 2R < −3, we get a contradiction with condition (I) of Theorem 3.5. If (α.i.2) is satisfied, we get a contradiction for Lemma 5.4. −1 If (α.i.3) is satisfied, for Lemma 4.2 we get m ∈ M(L(m)) ∩ mZ[Ai,bq l ]i∈I,l≤−3 such that u n,bq −1 (m) = u n,bq −1 (m ) = 1, vn,bq −4 (m m −1 ) ≥ 1. From Lemma 4.2 and Lemma 4.1, we have m ∈ m {1,...,n−1} M(L(m →(n) )), and we get a contradiction for Lemma 5.4. If condition (α.ii.1) is satisfied, we get a contradiction for Lemma 5.4. If condition (α.ii.2) is satisfied, we get as in the proof of Lemma 5.4 that u n−r1 ,bq −2r1 (m) ≥ 1 and u n−r2 ,bq −2−2r2 (m) ≥ 1 with r1 , r2 ≥ 1. Contradiction with condition (I) of Theorem 3.5. If condition (α.ii.3) is satisfied: we follow the proof of Lemma 5.4 and we get m . If m is dominant, we have u n,bq −5 (m ) = u n−R,bq −2R (m ) = 1 with −2R − (−5) ≤ 3 < 2(n − (n − R)) + 4, contradiction with condition (I) of Theorem 3.5. So m is not dominant. Let R, r, r and M be dominant as defined in the proof of Lemma 5.4.
246
D. Hernandez
From the property (2) we have m = M. Observe that r ≤ r + 1. We have u n−R,bq −2R (m) = 1. We study two cases: If n −r − 1 +r = n, we have moreover u n,bq −3−2r −2r (m) = 1. But (−3 − 2r − 2r ) − (−2R) ≤ 2R − 4 < 2(n − (n − R)), contradiction with condition (I) of Theorem 3.5. If n − r − 1 + r ≤ n − 1, we have moreover u n−r −1+r ,bq −4−2r −2r (m) = 1. Let d = (n−r −1+r −(n− R)) = −1+(R+r −r ) and D = (−4−2r −2r )+2R = 2d −4r −2. If d < 0, condition (I) implies D ≥ −2d + 4, so 0 ≤ D + 2d − 4 = 4d − 4r − 6 < 0, contradiction. If d = 0, condition (I) implies D ∈ 4Z, contradiction as D = −4r − 2. If d > 0, condition (I) implies D ≤ − 4 − 2d, so 0 ≥ D + 4 + 2d = 4d + 2 − 4r = −2 + 4R − 4r and n −r − 1 < n − R < n − R − 1 +r . So the product An−r −1+r ,bq −2−2r −2r · · · An−r −1,bq −2−2r can not appear in m(m )−1 (for example we may use Theorem 4.7 as in the proof of Lemma 5.1), contradiction. Now we suppose that there is b ∈ C∗ such that u n−1,b (m ) ≥ 2. By property (2), we get as in the proof of Lemma 5.4 that m satisfies property (β.1) or (β.2) of Lemma 5.4. For (β.1), we have (2 j1 − 2n + 2 − (−1)) = 2( j1 − n) + 3 < 2(n − j1 ) + 5, contradiction with condition (I) of Theorem 3.5. For (β.2), we have (2 j1 −2n +2−0) = 2( j1 −n)+2 < 2(n − 1 − j1 ) + 6, contradiction with condition (I) of Theorem 3.5. Finally we suppose that there are i ≤ n −2, b ∈ C∗ such that u i,b (m ) ≥ 2. Then m is ({1, . . . , i − 2} ∪ {i} ∪ {i + 2, . . . , n})-dominant. We have (u i−1,d (m ) < 0 ⇒ d = bq 2 ), and (u i+1,d (m ) < 0 ⇒ d = bq 2 ). By applying (3) of Lemma 4.8 and Lemma 5.3 (with bq 2 instead of b and i + 1 instead of j), we get a dominant monomial M ∈ M(L(m)) satisfying one of the conditions (γ .1) (case (1) of Lemma 5.3): u j1 ,bq 2 j1 −2i (M) ≥ 1, u j ,bq 2i−2 j2 +2−r j2 (M) ≥ 1 with 2 j1 < j2 , j1 ≤ i ≤ j2 ≤ n, (γ .2) (case (2) of Lemma 5.3): u j1 ,bq 2 j1 −2i (M) ≥ 1 and u n−1,bq −2n+2i+2 (M) ≥ 1 with j1 ≤ i, (γ .3) (case (3) of Lemma 5.3): u j1 ,bq 2 j1 −2i (M) ≥ 1 and u n,bq 1−2n+2i (M) ≥ 1, u n,bq 3−2n+2i (M) ≥ 1 with j1 ≤ i, (γ .4) (case (4) of Lemma 5.3): u j1 ,bq 2 j1 −2i (M) ≥ 1 and u n−1,bq −2n+2i (M) ≥ 1 with j1 ≤ i. From property (2) we have m = M. For (γ .1), we have 2 j1 −2i −(2i −2 j2 +2−r j2 ) ≤ 2( j1 + j2 ) − 4i ≤ 2( j2 − j1 ), contradiction with condition (I) of Theorem 3.5. For (γ .2), we have 2 j1 − 2i − (−2n + 2i + 2) ≤ 2(n − 1 − j1 ), contradiction with condition (I) of Theorem 3.5. For (γ .3), we have 2 j1 −2i −(3−2n +2i) ≤ 2(n − j1 ), contradiction with condition (I) of Theorem 3.5. For (γ .4), we have 2 j1 −2i −(2i −2n) < 2(n −1− j1 )+4, contradiction with condition (I) of Theorem 3.5. Now we prove property (4) by induction on v(m m −1 ) ≥ 0. Let j be as in property (4). For v(m m −1 ) = 0 we have m = m and the result is clear. We suppose that property (4) is satisfied for m such that v(m m −1 ) < v(m m −1 ). Let R ≥ 0 maximal such that m m −1 ≤ A−1
j,ak q rk λk +2(k− j)
A−1
j,ak q rk λk +2(k− j)−4
· · · A−1
.
j,ak q rk λk +2(k− j)+4−4R
We suppose moreover that m m −1 ≤ A−1
j,ak q rk λk +2(k− j)
A−1
j,ak q rk λk +2(k− j)−4
· · · A−1
j,ak q rk λk +2(k− j)+4−4R
A−1 j,b
with b = ak q rk λk +2(k− j)−4µ and µ = R. By the induction hypothesis on v, m is (I − { j})-dominant, u j,bq 2 (m ) = −1 and (u j,d (m ) < 0 ⇒ d = bq 2 ). By property (3), we
On Minimal Affinizations of Representations of Quantum Groups
247
can apply Lemma 5.3 and we get a dominant monomial M ∈ M(L(m)). From property (2), we have M = m. So we have one of the following situations: Case (1) of Lemma 5.3: m = m A j,b A j+1,bq −2 · · · A j+r,bq −2r , where 0 ≤ r ≤ n − j, and u j+r,bq −2r −r j+r (M) = 1. So R = 0, j + r = k, b = ak q rk λk +2r = ak q rk λk +2(k− j) , contradiction. Case (2) of Lemma 5.3: m = m (A j,b A j+1,bq −2 · · · An−1,bq 2−2n+2 j )An,bq 2−2n+2 j M , where M ∈ Z[A p,bq 2−2n+2 j+2( p−n)−4l ] p
Let R ≥ 0 be maximal such that m m −1 ≤ A−1 n,a
λ nq n
A−1 n,a
λ −2 nq n
· · · A−1 n,a
λ +2−2R nq n
.
We suppose moreover that m m −1 ≤ A−1 n,a
λ nq n
A−1 n,a
λ −2 nq n
· · · A−1 n,a
λ +2−2R nq n
A−1 n,b
with b = an q λn −2µ and µ = R. By the induction hypothesis on v, m is (I − {n})dominant, u n,bq (m ) = −1 and (u n,d (m ) < 0 ⇒ d = bq). So m = An,b m ∈ M(L(m)) is (I − {n − 1})-dominant and (u n−1,d (m ) < 0 ⇒ d = b). If u n−1,b (m ) ≥ 0, m is dominant equal to m, so R = 0 and b = an q λn , contradiction. So u n−1,b (m ) / an−1 q 2λn−1 +4Z < 0, m An−1,bq −2 ∈ M(L(m)) and vn−1,bq −2 (m m −1 ) ≥ 1. So bq −2 ∈ and b ∈ / an q λn +4Z . By Lemma 5.2 there is l ∈ Z such that bq −1−4l = an q λn −1 , so b ∈ an q λn +4Z , contradiction.
248
D. Hernandez
5.2.4. Condition (II). We study the general case of condition (II) of Theorem 3.5. Lemma 5.6. Let λ ∈ P + and L(m) be a minimal affinization of V (λ) such that m satisfies condition (II) of Theorem 3.5. Let K = max{i ∈ I |λi = 0}. Then (1) For all m ∈ M(L(m)), if v K (m m −1 ) ≥ 1, then v K ,a
λK K qK
(m m −1 ) ≥ 1.
(2) L(m) is special. (3) L(m) is thin. (4) For all m ∈ M(L(m)) such that vn (m m −1 ) = 0 we have v j,ak q 2(λk + j−k) (m m −1 ) = v j,ak q 2(λk + j−k−2) (m m −1 ) = · · · = v j,ak q 2(λk + j−k−2R) (m m −1 ) = 1, where j = max{i|vi (m m −1 ) = 0}, k = max{i ≤ j|λi = 0} and R = v j (m m −1 ) − 1. Observe that Lemma 5.4, Lemma 5.5 and Lemma 5.6 combined with Corollary 4.13 imply Theorem 3.8 and Theorem 3.10 for type B. In this case we do not need to prove simultaneously the different properties. Proof. Property (4): As vn (m m →(−1) ) = 0, it follows from Lemma 4.5 that m appears in L {1,···n−1} (m). As g J is of type An−1 , the result is exactly property (4) of Lemma 5.1. Property (1) and (2): As property (4) is satisfied, we can use the proof of property (1) and (2) of Lemma 5.1. u (m) Property (3): The monomial M = i∈I,a∈C∗ Y i,a−1 −r ∨ h ∨ satisfies (I), and so it foli,a q lows from Lemma 5.4 and Lemma 5.5 that L(M) is thin. But from Corollary 4.11, σ ∗ L(M) L(m), and so we have property (3) (Lemma 4.10). 5.3. Type G 2
In this section we suppose that g is of type G 2 .
Lemma 5.7. Let m be a dominant monomial satisfying condition (I) of Theorem 3.5. Then L(m) is special. Proof. From Lemma 4.1, M(L(m))⊂M(L(m →(1) )M(L(m →(2) )). From Lemma 2.14, if m is in (M(L(m →(1) ) − {m →(1) })M(L(m →(2) )), then m ≤ m A−1 which is 1,a q 3λ1 1
right-negative, and so m is not dominant. Consider m = m →(1) m 2 , where m 2 ∈ (M(L (m →(2) )) − {m →(2) }). It follows from Theorem 2.14 that m 2 is right-negative. Suppose that m is dominant. In particular m 2 is 2-dominant and (u 1,b (m 2 ) < 0 ⇒ (u 1,b (m 2 ) = − 1 and b ∈ {a1 q 3−3λ1 , a1 q 9−3λ1 , . . . , a1 q 3λ1 −3 })). From Lemma 4.1, m 2 ∈ M(V2 (a2 q 1−λ2 ))M(V2 (a2 q 3−λ2 )) · · · M(V2 (a2 q λ2 −1 )). But for b ∈ C∗ , it follows from [H1, Sect. 8.4.1] (with 1 instead of 2 and 2 instead of 1) that
−1 −1 −1 −1 −1 χq (V2 (b)) =Y2,b + Y2,bq 2 Y1,bq + Y1,bq 7 Y2,bq 4 Y2,bq 6 + Y2,bq 4 Y2,bq 8 + Y1,bq 5 Y2,bq 6 Y2,bq 8 −1 −1 + Y1,bq 11 Y2,bq 10 + Y2,bq 12 . −1 can only appear in χq From condition (I), a1 q −3λ1 +3 = q 7 (a2 q λ2 −1 ). So one Y1,b (V2 (a2 q λ2 −1 )), and so (u 1,b (m 2 ) < 0 ⇒ b = a1 q −3λ1 +3 = q 7 (a2 q λ2 −1 )). As a consequence v1,a1 q −3λ1 (m m −1 ) ≥ 1. From the above explicit description of the χq (V2 (b)), for all
m ∈ M(L(m →(1) )(M(L(m →(2) )) − {m →(2) }),
On Minimal Affinizations of Representations of Quantum Groups
249
if v1,a1 q −3λ1 (m m −1 ) = 0 then l≥0
−3λ1 +3+6l (m 1q −3λ 1 −3+6l 1q
u 1,a
Y1,a
)
= Y1,a
1q
−3λ1 −3
Y1,a1 q 3−3λ1 Y1,a1 q 9−3λ1 · · · Y1,a1 q 3λ1 −3 ,
where ∈ {0, 1}. In particular we can prove as for property (2) of Lemma 5.1 that v1,a1 q −3λ1 (m m −1 ) ≥ 1 implies v1,a1 q 3λ1 (m m −1 ) ≥ 1, contradiction. Lemma 5.8. Let m be a dominant monomial satisfying condition (II) of Theorem 3.5. Then L(m) is special. Proof. It follows from Lemma 4.17 that for m ∈ M(L(m)), if v2 (m m −1 ) = 0 then (m )→(2) is of the form (Y2,a2 q λ2 −1 Y2,a2 q λ2 −3 · · · Y2,a2 q 1−λ2 )Y2,a2 q 1−λ2 −2 · · · Y2,a2 q 1−λ2 −2R , where R ≥ 0 (from condition (II) we have a2 q 1−λ2 −2 = q 5 (a1 q 3λ1 −3 )). So we can use the proof of property (2) of Lemma 5.1. Lemma 5.7 and Lemma 5.8 combined with Corollary 4.13 imply Theorem 3.8 for type G. 5.4. Types C, D and F4 In this subsection we prove Theorem 3.9. From Corollary 4.14, it suffices to consider condition (II). Type C: As λn = 0 and g{1,...,n−1} is of type An−1 , it follows from (1) of Lemma 5.1 that the monomials m ∈ M(L(m)) satisfying vn (m m −1 ) > 0 are right-negative and so not dominant. For the monomials m ∈ M(L(m)) satisfying vn (m m −1 ) = 0, we can use (2) of Lemma 5.1 and Lemma 4.5. Type D: as an = an−1 and λn = λn−1 , all monomials in the set m →(I −{n−1,n}) M(L(m →(n) ))M(L(m →(n−1) )) are right-negative. Moreover we can prove as (1) of Lemma 5.1 that for i = n − 1 or i = n, vi (m m −1 ) > 0 implies vi,ai q λi (m m −1 ) > 0, and so m is right-negative. For the monomials m ∈ M(L(m)) satisfying vn−1 (m m −1 ) = vn (m m −1 ) = 0, we can use (2) of Lemma 5.1 and Lemma 4.5. Type F4 : The proof is analogous to type C by using Lemma 5.6 for g{1,2,3} of type B3 . 6. Applications and Further Possible Developments 6.1. Jacobi-Trudi determinants and Nakai-Nakanishi conjecture In [NN1, Conjecture 2.2] Nakai-Nakanishi conjectured for classical types that the Jacobi-Trudi determinant is the q-character of a certain finite dimensional representation of the corresponding quantum affine algebra. This determinant can be expressed in terms of tableaux (see [BR] for type A, [KOS] for type B, and [NN1, NN2, NN3] for general classical type). The cases considered in [NN1] include all minimal affinizations for type A, and for type B many minimal affinizations (but for example not the fundamental representations Vn (a)). As an application of the present paper, we prove this conjecture for minimal affinizations of type A and B considered in [NN1, Conjecture 2.2] (see the introduction for
250
D. Hernandez
previous results). Indeed it can be checked for type A and B that the tableaux expression is special and canceled by screening operators, and so is given by the Frenkel-Mukhin algorithm (see the proofs below; this fact was first announced and observed in some cases in [NN1, Sect. 2.3, Rem. 1]). So from [FM1], Theorem 3.8 proved in the present paper implies that the q-character of a considered minimal affinization is necessarily equal to the corresponding expression. Theorem 6.1. For g of type A, B, the q-character of a minimal affinization considered in [NN1, Conjecture 2.2] is given by the corresponding Jacobi-Trudi determinant. This result is coherent with the thin property proved in this paper. With the same strategy, representations more general than minimal affinizations, and types C, D, will be discussed in a separate publication. Let us recall the tableaux expression of the Jacobi-Trudi determinant and give the proof of Theorem 6.1. We treat the type B (the proof for type A is more simple). We recall that a partition λ = (λ1 , λ2 , · · · ) is a sequence of weakly decreasing non-negative integers with finitely many non-zero terms. The conjugate partition is denoted by λ = (λ 1 , λ 2 , · · · ). For λ, µ two partitions, we say that µ ⊂ λ if for all i ≥ 0, λi ≥ µi . For µ ⊂ λ, the corresponding skew diagram is λ/µ = {(i, j) ∈ N × N|µi + 1 ≤ j ≤ λi } = {(i, j) ∈ N × N|µ j + 1 ≤ i ≤ λ j }. We suppose in the following that d(λ/µ) ≤ n, where d(λ/µ) is the length of the longest column of λ/µ, and that λ/µ is connected (i.e. µi + 1 ≤ λi+1 if λi+1 = 0). Let B = {1, . . . , n, 0, n, . . . , 1}. We give the ordering ≺ on the set B by 1 ≺ 2 ≺ · · · ≺ n ≺ 0 ≺ n ≺ · · · ≺ 2 ≺ 1. As it is a total ordering, we can define the corresponding maps succ and prec. For a ∈ C∗ , let 1 i n 0 n i 1
a
= Y1,a ,
a
−1 = Yi−1,aq 2i Yi,aq 2(i−1)
a
−1 = Yn−1,aq 2n Yn,aq 2n−1 Yn,aq 2n−3 ,
a
−1 = Yn,aq 2n+1 Yn,aq 2n−3 ,
a
−1 −1 = Yn−1,aq 2n−2 Yn,aq 2n+1 Yn,aq 2n−1 ,
a
−1 = Yi−1,aq 4n−2i−2 Yi,aq 4n−2i
a
−1 = Y1,aq 4n−2 .
(2 ≤ i ≤ n − 1),
(2 ≤ i ≤ n − 1),
Observe that we have χq (V1 (a)) =
1
a
+
2
a
+ ··· +
n
a
+
0
a
+
n
a
+ n−1 a + · · · +
1
a.
For T = (Ti, j )(i, j)∈λ/µ a tableaux of shape λ/µ with coefficients in B, let m T,a = Ti, j ∈ Y. 4( j−i) (i, j)∈λ/µ
aq
Let Tab(Bn , λ/µ) be the set of tableaux of shape λ/µ with coefficients in B satisfying the two conditions:
On Minimal Affinizations of Representations of Quantum Groups
251
Ti, j Ti, j+1 and (Ti, j , Ti, j+1 ) = (0, 0), Ti, j ≺ Ti+1, j or (Ti, j , Ti+1, j ) = (0, 0). The tableaux expression of the Jacobi-Trudi determinant [KOS, NN1] is: χλ/µ,a = m T,a ∈ Y. T ∈Tab(Bn ,λ/µ)
u (m) For a monomial m, we denote (m)± = {i∈I,a∈C∗ |±u i,a (m)>0} Yi,ai,a the negative and the positive part of m. We say that (m)− is partly canceled by (m )+ if there is i ∈ I and a ∈ C∗ such that u i,a ((m)− ) = −u i,a ((m)+ ) = 0. Lemma 6.2. Let T ∈ Tab(Bn , λ/µ) and a ∈ C∗ . Let (i, j) = (i , j ) ∈ λ/µ, α = Ti, j − +
and β = Ti , j . If α is partly canceled by β , then (i, j) 4( j −i ) aq 4( j−i) = (i + 1, j ) or ((i, j) = (i + 1, j + 1) and Ti, j = Ti , j = n).
aq
Proof. We study different cases: Case (1): 2 α n and 1 β n − 1. We have α = β + 1 and q 4( j−i)+2α = 4( q j −i )+2(β−1) . So j − i = ( j − i) + 1. If j < j , we have i ≤ i and so Ti, j Ti , j , contradiction. So j ≥ j and i > i . There is ((ir , jr ))1≤r ≤R ∈ (λ/µ) R such that (i 0 , j0 ) = (i , j ) and (i R , j R ) = (i, j) and ((ir +1 , jr +1 ) = (ir + 1, jr ) or (ir +1 , jr +1 ) = (ir , jr + 1)). Let Tr = Tir , jr . As (ir +1 , jr +1 ) = (ir + 1, jr ) implies n Tr +1 Tr , we have TR T1 + (i − i ), and so (i, j) = (i + 1, j ). Case (2): n − 1 α 1 and n β 2. Analog to case (1). Case (3): 2 α n and n β 2. As α
aq 4( j−i)
∈ Z[Yk,aq 2k−2+4r ]k≤n−1,r ∈Z × Z[Yn,aq 2r ]r ∈Z ,
and β
aq 4( j
−i )
∈ Z[Yk,aq 2k+4r ]k≤n−1,r ∈Z × Z[Yn,aq 2r ]r ∈Z ,
we have a contradiction. Case (4): n − 1 α 1 and 1 β n − 1. Analog to case (3). Case (5): α = 0 and β = n. We have q 4( j−i)+2n+1 = q 4( j −i )+2n−3 . So j − i = ( j − i) + 1. As in case (1), we have j ≥ j . So i > i . Consider (ir , jr ), Tr as in case (1). If i ≥ i + 2, there is r1 < r2 such that ir1 +1 = ir1 + 1 and ir2 +1 = ir2 + 1. We have Tr1 = Tr1 +1 = 0 or Tr2 = Tr2 +1 = 0. So there is ( p, q) ∈ λ/µ such that ( p, q + 1), ( p + 1, q + 1) ∈ λ/µ and T p,q+1 = T p+1,q+1 = 0 and T p,q = n. So ( p + 1, q) ∈ λ/µ and T p+1,q = n, contradiction. Case (6): α = 0 and β = 0. We have q 4( j−i)+2n+1 = q 4( j −i )+2n−3 and we can conclude as in case (5). Case (7): α = n and β = 0. We have q 4( j−i)+2n+1 = q 4( j −i )+2n−3 . So j − i = ( j − i) + 1. As in case (1) we have j ≥ j . So i > i . If j > j , as in case (5) we get ( p, q) ∈ λ/µ such that ( p + 1, q), ( p + 1, q + 1) ∈ λ/µ and T p,q = T p+1,q = 0 and T p+1,q+1 = n. So ( p, q + 1) ∈ λ/µ and T p,q+1 = n, contradiction. Case (8): α = n and β = n. We have q 4( j−i)+2n+1 = q 4( j −i )+2n−3 or q 4( j−i)+2n−1 = q 4( j −i )+2n−1 . In the first case j −i = ( j −i)+1. As above we have j ≥ j . So i > i .
252
D. Hernandez
Consider (ir , jr ), Tr as in case (1). If there is r such that ((ir , jr ), (ir +1 , jr +1 ), (ir +2 , jr +2 )) = ((ir , jr ), (ir , jr + 1), (ir + 1, jr + 1)), we have necessarily (Tr , Tr +1 , Tr +2 ) = (n, 0, n). So i = ir and i = ir + 1 = i + 1. We can treat in the same way the situation where there is r such that ((ir , jr ), (ir +1 , jr +1 ), (ir +2 , jr +2 )) = ((ir , jr ), (ir + 1, jr ), (ir + 1, jr + 1)). In the second case j − i = ( j − i). As above we have j > j and i = i + 1. Lemma 6.3. Let T0 = (i − µ j )(i, j)∈λ/µ . Then T0 ∈ Tab(Bn , λ/µ) and m T0 ,a is the unique dominant monomial of χλ/µ,a . Proof. First it is clear that T0 ∈ Tab(Bn , λ/µ) and that m T0 ,a is dominant. Consider T ∈ Tab(Bn , λ/µ) such that T0 = T . So there is (i, j) ∈ λ/µ satisfying the property (i = µ j + 1 and Ti, j = 1) or (i = µ j + 1 and Ti, j = succ(Ti−1, j )).
(4)
From Lemma 6.2 the negative part of the box corresponding to (i, j) is not canceled in m T,a (in case (8) of Lemma 6.2, the negative part of the box can only be partly canceled). Lemma 6.4. For all T ∈ Tab(Bn , λ/µ), a ∈ C∗ , the monomial m T,a is thin. Proof. Let (i, j) = (i , j ) ∈ λ/µ, α = Ti, j and β = Ti , j . We suppose that
+ +
α = β
= 0. We study different cases (by symmetry we 4( j−i) aq aq 4( j −i ) can suppose α β): Case (1): 1 α β n − 1. We have α = β and q 4( j−i)+2(α−1) = q 4( j −i )+2(β−1) . So j −i = ( j −i). If j < j , we have i > i and so Ti, j ≺ Ti , j n −1, contradiction. In the same way we get a contradiction for j > j . Case (2): n α β 2. Analog to case (1). Case (3): 1 α n − 1 and n β 2. Analog to case (3) of Lemma 6.2. Case (4): α = n and β = 0. We have q 4( j−i)+2n−3 = q 4( j −i )+2n−3 . So j −i = j −i. As above, we have j < j . So i < i . We can conclude as in case (5) of Lemma 6.2. Case (5): α = β = 0. We have q 4( j−i)+2n−3 = q 4( j −i )+2n−3 . So j − i = j − i. If j = j , we get ( p, q) ∈ λ/µ such that ( p, q + 1) ∈ λ/µ and T p,q = T p,q+1 = 0, contradiction. Case (6): α = β = n. We have q 4( j−i)+2n−3 = q 4( j −i )+2n−3 or q 4( j−i)+2n−1 = q 4( j −i )+2n−1 . In both cases j − i = j − i and we get a contradiction as in case (1). Finally we can conclude the proof of Theorem 6.1: Lemma 6.5. We have χλ/µ,a ∈ Im(χq ). In the proof we will need the following partial ordering defined on Tab(Bn , λ/µ):for T, T ∈ Tab(Bn , λ/µ) we set: T T ⇔ (∀(i, j) ∈ λ/µ, Ti, j Ti, j ). Also by convention for any α ∈ B, Ti, j = α means ((i, j) ∈ λ/µ ⇒ Ti, j = α). Proof. Let α ∈ I . We want to give a decomposition of χλ/µ as in Proposition 2.15 for J = {α}. From Lemma 6.4, the L α (M) that should appear in this decomposition are thin. It suffices to prove that the set Tab(Bn , λ/µ) is in bijection with a disjoint union of sets M(L α (M)) via T → m T,a .
On Minimal Affinizations of Representations of Quantum Groups
253
First suppose that α ≤ n − 1. Let Mα be the set of tableaux T ∈ Tab(Bn , λ/µ) such that for any (i, j) ∈ λ/µ: Ti, j = α + 1 ⇒ ((i − 1, j) ∈ λ/µ and Ti−1, j = α), Ti, j = α ⇒ ((i − 1, j) ∈ λ/µ and Ti−1, j = α + 1). Then by Lemma 6.2, Mα corresponds to all α-dominant monomials appearing in χλ/µ,a . For T ∈ Mα , let T˜ be the tableaux defined in the following way. For (i, j) ∈ λ/µ: if Ti, j = α and Ti+1, j = α + 1, we set T˜i, j = α + 1, if Ti, j = α + 1 and Ti+1, j = α, we set T˜i, j = α, otherwise we set T˜i, j = Ti, j . Then T˜ ∈ Tab(Bn , λ/µ). For T ∈ Mα , we define: Mα (T ) = {T ∈ Tab(Bn , λ/µ)|T T T˜ }. Then by Lemma 2.9 we have L α (m T,a ) =
m T ,a ,
T ∈Mα (T )
and (Mα (T ))T ∈Mα defines a partition of Tab(Bn , λ/µ). Now we treat the case α = n. Let Mn be the set of tableaux T ∈ Tab(Bn , λ/µ) such that for any (i, j) ∈ λ/µ: Ti, j = 0 ⇒ ((i − 1, j) ∈ λ/µ and Ti−1, j ∈ {0, n}), Ti, j = n ⇒ ((i − 1, j − 1) ∈ λ/µ and Ti−1, j−1 = n). By definition of skew diagram, the last condition implies that (Ti, j = n ⇒ ((i − 1, j), (i, j − 1) ∈ λ/µ and Ti−1, j ∈ {0, n} and Ti, j−1 ∈ {0, n})). This can be rewritten:
n0 nn nn n0 Ti−1, j−1 Ti, j−1 , , , }. ∈{ Ti, j = n ⇒ nn 0n Ti−1, j Ti, j 0n nn Then by Lemma 6.2, Mn corresponds to all n-dominant monomials appearing in χλ/µ,a . For T ∈ Mn , let T˜ be the tableaux defined in the following way. For (i, j) ∈ λ/µ: if Ti, j = n and Ti+1, j+1 = n and Ti+1, j = 0 and Ti+1, j = n, we set T˜i, j = n, if Ti, j = n and Ti+1, j+1 = n and Ti+1, j ∈ {0, n}, we set T˜i, j = 0, if Ti, j = 0 and Ti+1, j = 0 and Ti+1, j = n, we set T˜i, j = n, otherwise we set T˜i, j = Ti, j . Then T˜ ∈ Tab (Bn , λ/µ). For T ∈ Mn , we define: Mα (T ) = {T ∈ Tab(Bn , λ/µ)|T T T˜ }. Then by Lemma 2.9, we have L n (m T,a ) =
m T ,a ,
T ∈Mα (T )
and (Mn (T ))T ∈Mn defines a partition of Tab(Bn , λ/µ).
254
D. Hernandez
6.2. General quantum affinizations The quantum affinization Uq (ˆg) of a quantum KacMoody algebra Uq (g) is defined with the same generators and relations as the Drinfeld realization of quantum affine algebras, but by using the generalized symmetrizable Cartan matrix of g instead of a Cartan matrix of finite type. The quantum affine algebra, quantum affinizations of usual quantum groups, are the simplest examples and have the particular property of being also quantum Kac-Moody algebras. In general these algebras are not a quantum Kac-Moody algebra. In [Mi, Nak1, H2], the category O of integrable representations is studied. For regular quantum affinizations (with a linear Dynkin diagram), one can define analogs of minimal affinizations by using properties (I) and (II) of Theorem 3.5. For example let us consider the type Bn, p (n ≥ 2, p ≥ 2) corresponding to the Cartan matrix (Ci, j )1≤i, j≤n defined as the Cartan matrix of type Bn except that we replace Cn,n−1 = −2 by Cn,n−1 = − p. Then one can prove exactly as for Lemma 5.6 that (an analog of Theorem 4.7 is proved by using [H2, Lemma 5.10]): Theorem 6.6. Let g be of type Bn, p . Then if m satisfies property (I) (resp. (II)), then L(m) is antispecial (resp. special). So the analog of the Frenkel-Mukhin algorithm works for these modules and as an application it should be possible to get additional results for this class of special modules (see also Sect. 6.4 below). 6.3. Multiparameter T -systems The special property of Kirillov-Reshetikhin modules allows to prove a system of induction relations involving q-characters of KirillovReshetikhin modules called T -system (see [Nak5] for the simply-laced cases and [H4] for the general case). Indeed for i ∈ I , k ≥ 1, a ∈ C∗ define the Uq (Lg)-module: ( j) (i) Sr,a =( W −(2k−1)/Ci, j ). {( j,k)|C j,i <0,1≤k≤−Ci, j }
−C j,i +E(ri (r −k)/r j ),aq j
Theorem 6.7 (The T -system). Let a ∈ C∗ , k ≥ 1, i ∈ I . Then we have: (i)
(i)
(i)
(i)
(i)
χq (Wk,a )χq (Wk,aq 2 ) = χq (Wk+1,a )χq (Wk−1,aq 2 ) + χq (Sk,a ). i
i
By analogy, the results of the present paper (special property of minimal affinizations of type A, B, G) should lead to systems of induction relations involving q-characters of minimal affinizations (multiparameter T -systems). Let us look at an example. Let g = sl3 . Then we have the following relation: (1)
(2)
(1)
(2)
χq (L(X 3,q 2 X 2,q 8 ))χq (L(X 3,q 4 X 2,q 10 )) (1)
(2)
(1)
(2)
(2)
(2)
= χq (L(X 4,q 3 X 2,q 10 ))χq (L(X 2,q 3 X 2,q 8 )) + χq (L(X 6,q 6 ))χq (L(X 1,q 9 )). Let us give the idea of the proof for this example: as a q-character is characterized by the multiplicity of his dominant monomials [FM1], it suffices to compare dominant monomials of both sides. By using the process described in Remark 2.16, Theorem 4.7 and arguments of [H4], we get the following results: (1) (2) (1) (2) The dominant monomials of χq (L(X 3,q 2 X 2,q 8 ) ⊗ L(X 3,q 4 X 2,q 10 )) are: 10 122 14 25 27 292 21 1, 10 12 23 25 27 292 21 1, 21 23 25 27 292 21 1, 10 12 124 16 110 27 29 , 10 122 14 110 25 27 29 , 10 12 110 23 25 27 29 , 110 21 23 25 27 29 .
On Minimal Affinizations of Representations of Quantum Groups (1)
(2)
255 (1)
(2)
The dominant monomials of χq (L(X 4,q 3 X 2,q 10 ) ⊗ L(X 2,q 3 X 2,q 8 )) are: 10 122 14 25 27 292 211 , 10 12 23 25 27 292 211 , 10 122 124 16 110 27 29 , 10 122 14 110 25 27 29 , 10 12 110 23 25 27 29 . (1) (2) (1) (2) The dominant monomials of χq (L(X 3,q 2 X 2,q 8 ) ⊗ L(X 3,q 4 X 2,q 10 )) are: 21 23 25 27 292 211 , 110 2, q23 25 27 29 . We can conclude that the multiplicity of all these monomials is 1. 6.4. Alternative method for the classification of minimal affinizations We explain how to prove certain classification results (included in Theorem 3.5). The proofs here are written in the context of the paper and could be a general uniform strategy for other quantum affinizations. Moreover we get some new refined results on the involved q-characters. Proposition 6.8. Let L(m) be a minimal affinization of V (λ). Then for all i ∈ I , there is ai ∈ C∗ such that m →(i) = X a(i) . i ,λi Proof. For λi ≤ 1 it is clear. Suppose that λi ≥ 2 and that m →(i) in not of this form. Note that λ − αi ∈ P + . It follows from Lemma 4.5 with J = {i} and Proposition 2.9 that dim((L(m))λ−αi ) = dim((L i (m →(i) ))(λi −2)i ≥ 2. (i)
Let a ∈ C∗ and M = m((m)→(i) )−1 X λi ,a . L(M) is an affinization of V (λ). It follows from Lemma 4.5 with J = {i} that dim((L(M))λ−αi ) = 1 so m λ−αi (L(M)) −{i}) = (M)→(I −{i}) , it follows from Lemma 4.5 < m λ−αi (L(m)). Moreover as (m)→(I with J = I − {i} that for µ ∈ λ − j =i Nα j we have dim((L(M))µ ) = dim((L I −{i} (m →(I −{i}) ))µ ) = dim((L(m))µ ) and so m µ (L(M)) = m µ (L(m)). As µ ≤ λ implies µ = λ or µ ≤ λ − αi or µ ∈ λ − j =i Nα j , we have [L(M)] < [L(m)], contradiction. In the following for L(m) a minimal affinization and for i ∈ I such that λi = 0, ai ∈ C∗ denotes the complex number introduced in Proposition 6.8. Let g = sln+1 (n ≥ 2) and λ = λ1 1 +λn n (λ1 , λn ≥ 1). For µ = α1 +α2 +· · ·+αn , (1) (n) we have dim((V (λ))λ−µ ) = n. Let m = X λ1 ,a1 X λn ,an . If L(m) is a minimal affinization of V (λ) then dim((L(m))λ−µ ) = n. For 0 ≤ h ≤ n denote −1 −1 Ai,a Ai,a . mh = m q λn +n−i q λ1 +i−1 i=1,...,h
1
n
i=h+1,...,n
We have different cases: (1) a1 /an ∈ / {q ±(λ1 +λn +n−1) , q λn −λ1 +n−1 , q λn −λ1 +n−3 , . . . , q λn −λ1 −n+1 }. From Remark 2.16, the n +1 monomials m h for 0 ≤ h ≤ n appear in χq (L(m)) and are distinct. So dim((L(m))λ−µ ) ≥ n + 1 and L(m) is not a minimal affinization of V (λ). (2) a1 /an = q λn −λ1 +n+1−2H with 1 = H ≤ n. Then m H = m H −1 . From Remark 2.16, the n − 1 distinct monomials m h for h ∈ / {H − 1, H } appear in χq (L(m)) with multiplicity 1 and m H appears in χq (L(m)) with multiplicity 2. So dim((L(m))λ−µ ) ≥ n + 1 and L(m) is not a minimal affinization of V (λ).
256
D. Hernandez
(3) a1 /an = q λ1 +λn +n−1 . (4) an /a1 = q λ1 +λn +n−1 . From Proposition 4.16, the character is the same in cases (3) and (4). So necessarily these two cases give a minimal affinization with χ (L(m)) = χ (V (λ)). So for λ1 , λn > 0, (1) (n) L(m) is a minimal affinization of V (λ1 1 + λn n ) if and only if m = X λ1 ,a1 X λn ,an with a1 /an = q λ1 +λn +n−1 or an /a1 = q λ1 +λn +n−1 . Now we suppose that g is general and consider J ⊂ I such that g J is of type Ar , 2 ≤ r ≤ n. Denote by i, j ∈ J the two extreme nodes of J . We suppose that we can decompose I = Ii J I j such that Ii ∪ {i} and I j ∪ { j} are connected, and ∀k ∈ Ii , k ∈ J − {i}, Ck,k = 0 and ∀k ∈ I j , k ∈ J − { j}, Ck,k = 0. Observe that Ii or I j may be empty and if J is of type A2 there is always such a decomposition. Proposition 6.9. Let L(m) be a minimal affinization of V (λ) such that λi , λ j ≥ 1 and for k ∈ J − {i, j}, λk = 0. Then one of the two following condition holds: aj ai λ +λ +r −1 λ +λ +r −1 = qi i j or = qi i j . aj ai ±(λi +λ j +r +1) . Proof. We can suppose in the proof that qi = q j = q. Suppose that ai /a j = q Note that λ− k∈J αk ∈ P + . It follows from Lemma 4.5 with J and the above discussion that dim((L(m))λ−k∈J αk ) ≥ r + 1. Let us define
M = m →(Ii ∪{i}) τq λi +λ j +m−1 a a −1 (m →({ j}∪I j ) ). i j
L(M) is an affinization of V (λ). Letus prove that [L(M)] < [L(m)] (which is a contradiction). Let ω ≤ λ. If ω ≤ λ − k∈J αk it follows from Lemma 4.5 with J that dim((L(M))λ−k∈J αk ) < dim((L(m))λ−k∈J αk ). As for J ⊂ J , λ − k∈J αk ∈ / P+ except for J =J or J =∅, we get m λ− k∈J αk (L(M)) < m λ− k∈J αk (L(m)). Otherwise it follows from Lemma 4.5 that dim((L(M))µ ) = dim((L(m))µ ) as (M)→((Ii ∪J )−{ j}) = (m)→((Ii ∪J )−{ j}) and (M)→((I j ∪J )−{i}) = τq λi +λ j +m−1 a a −1 (m →((I j ∪J )−{i}) ). So m µ (L i j
(M)) = m µ (L(m)).
Let g of type Bn (n ≥ 2), λ = λ1 ω1 + λn ωn (λ1 , λn ≥ 1) and µ = α1 + α2 + · · · + αn . (1) (n) Let m = X λ1 ,a1 X λn ,an . For 0 ≤ h ≤ n denote
mh = m
i=1,...,h
We have (L(m))λ−µ =
−1 Ai,a q λ1 +i−1 1
0≤h≤n (L(m))m h .
−1 Ai,a . q 2λn +1+n−i n
i=h+1,...,n
Let us study the different cases:
(1) a1 /an ∈ / {q ±(λ1 +2λn +n) , q 2λn −λ1 +n , q 2λn −λ1 +n−2 , . . . , q 2λn −λ1 −n+2 }. From Remark 2.16 the n + 1 monomials m h for 0 ≤ h ≤ n appear in χq (L(m)) and are distinct. So dim((L(m))λ−µ ) ≥ n + 1. (2) a1 /an = q 2λn −λ1 +n+2−2H with 1 = H ≤ n. Then m H = m H −1 . From Remark 2.16, the n − 1 distinct monomials m h for h ∈ / {H − 1, H } appear in χq (L(m)) with multiplicity 1 and m H appears in χq (L(m)) with multiplicity 2. So dim((L(m))λ−µ ) ≥ n + 1.
On Minimal Affinizations of Representations of Quantum Groups
257
(3) a1 /an = q λ1 +2λn +n . Then dim((L(m))λ−µ ) = n. Indeed, we see as for the proof of point (3) of Lemma 5.1 that for m ∈ M(L(m)), if v1 (m m −1 ) ≥ 1 then v1,a1 q λ1 (m m −1 ) ≥ 1. So m 0 ∈ / M(L(m)) and from Remark 2.16 m 1 , . . . , m H appear in χq (L(m)) with multiplicity 1. (4) an /a1 = q λ1 +2λn +n . As in case (3), dim((L(m))λ−µ ) = n. From Proposition 4.16, the character is the same in cases (3) and (4). Proposition 6.10. For g of type Bn with n ≥ 2 and λ1 , λn > 0, L(m) is a minimal aff(1) (n) inization of V (λ1 1 + λn n ) if and only if m = X λ1 ,a1 X λn ,an with a1 /an = q λ1 +2λn +n or an /a1 = q λ1 +2λn +n . Proof. If m satisfies (1) or (2) and m satisfies (3) or (4), then dim((L(m))λ−µ ) < dim((L(m ))λ−µ ) and for λ ≤ λ if there is j ∈ I such that v j (λ − λ) = 0 then dim((L(m))λ ) =dim((L(m ))λ ) (1)
=dim(Wλ1 ,1 )λ1 1 −k< j vk (λ −λ)αk ) × dim(Wλ(n) ) ). n ,1 λn n − k> j vk (λ −λ)αk
As we have the same character in situations (3) and (4), they correspond necessarily to minimal affinizations. Now we suppose that g is general and consider J ⊂ I such that g J is of type Br , 2 ≤ r ≤ n. Denote by i, j ∈ J the two extreme nodes of J . We suppose that we can decompose I = Ii J I j such that Ii ∪ {i} and I j ∪ { j} are connected, and ∀k ∈ Ii , k ∈ J − {i}, Ck,k = 0 and ∀k ∈ I j , k ∈ J − { j}, Ck,k = 0. Observe that Ii or I j may be empty and if J is of type B2 there is always such a decomposition. Proposition 6.11. Let L(m) be a minimal affinization of V (λ) such that λi , λ j ≥ 1 and for k ∈ J − {i, j}, λk = 0. Then one of the two following condition holds: aj ai λ +2λ +r λ +2λ +r = qi i j or = qi i j . aj ai The proof is analogous to proof of Proposition 6.9. Acknowledgments. The author is very grateful to Evgeny Mukhin for encouraging him to study minimal affinizations in the continuation of the proof of the Kirillov-Reshetikhin conjecture, to Hiraku Nakajima for useful comments and references in an early stage of this research, and to Vyjayanthi Chari, Maxim Nazarov, Alexander Molev, Michela Varagnolo for useful comments and references. A part of this paper was written as the author gave lectures in the East China Normal University in Shanghai, he would like to thank Naihong Hu for the invitation.
References [B] [BL] [BR]
Bourbaki, N.: Groupes et algèbres de Lie, Chapitres IV-VI. Paris:Hermann, 1968 Bernard, D., LeClair, A.: Quantum group symmetries and nonlocal currents in 2d qft. Commun. Math. Phys. 142(1), 99–138 (1991) Bazhanov, V.V., Reshetikhin, N.: Restricted solid-on-solid models connected with simply laced algebras and conformal field theory. J. Phys. A 23(9), 1477–1492 (1990)
258
[Cha1] [Cha2] [Che1] [Che2] [CM1] [CM2] [CM3] [CP1] [CP2] [CP3] [CP4] [CP5] [CP6] [CP7] [Do] [Dr1] [Dr2] [DM] [FL] [FM1] [FM2] [FR] [FR] [GK] [H1] [H2] [H3] [H4] [H5] [H6]
D. Hernandez
Chari, V.: Minimal affinizations of representations of quantum groups: the rank 2 case. Publ. Res. Inst. Math. Sci. 31(5), 873–911 (1995) Chari, V.: On the fermionic formula and the kirillov-reshetikhin conjecture. Int. Math. Res. Not. 2001(12), 629–654 (2001) Cherednik, I.: A new interpretation of gelfand-tzetlin bases. Duke Math. J. 54(2), 563–577 (1987) Cherednik, I.: Quantum groups as hidden symmetries of classic representation theory. In: Differential geometric methods in theoretical physics (Chester, 1988), Teaneck, NJ: World Sci. Publishing, 1989, pp. 47–54 Chari, V., Moura, A.: Characters and blocks for finite-dimensional representations of quantum affine algebras. Int. Math. Res. Not. 2005(5), 257–298 (2005) Chari, V., Moura, A.: Characters of fundamental representations of quantum affine algebras. Acta Appl. Math. 90(1–2), 43–63 (2006) Chari, V., Moura, A.: Kirillov–Reshetikhin modules associated to G 2 . math.RT/0604281, 2006 Chari, V., Pressley, A.: Quantum affine algebras. Commun. Math. Phys. 142, 261–283 (1991) Chari, V., Pressley A.: Quantum affine algebras and their representations. In: Representations of groups (Banff, AB, 1994), CMS Conf. Proc, 16, Providence, RI: Amer. Math. Soc., 1995, pp. 59–78 Chari, V., Pressley, A.: Minimal affinizations of representations of quantum groups: the simply laced case, j. Algebra 184(1), 1–30 (1996) Chari, V., Pressley, A.: Minimal affinizations of representations of quantum groups: the nonsimply-laced case. Lett. Math. Phys. 35(2), 99–114 (1995) Chari, V., Pressley, A.: Minimal affinizations of representations of quantum groups: the irregular case. Lett. Math. Phys. 36(3), 247–266 (1996) Chari, V., Pressley, A.: A Guide to Quantum Groups. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1994 Chari, V., Pressley, A.: Integrable and Weyl modules for quantum affine sl2 . In: Quantum groups and Lie theory (Durham, 1999), London Math. Soc. Lecture Note Ser. 290, Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press 2001, pp. 48–62 Dorey, P.: Root systems and purely elastic s-matrices. Nucl. Phys. B 358(3), 654–676 (1991) Drinfeld, V.G.: Quantum groups, In: Proceedings of the International Congress of Mathematicians, Vol. 1, 2 (Berkeley, Calif., 1986), Providence, RI: Amer. Math. Soc. (1987), pp. 798–820 Drinfeld, V.G.: A new realization of yangians and of quantum affine algebras. Sov. Math. Dokl. 36(2), 212–216 (1988) Delius G.W., MacKay N.J. (2006) Affine quantum groups. Encyclopedia of Mathematical Physics, Oxford:Elsevier, 2006 Fourier, G., Littelmann, P.: Weyl modules, Demazure modules, KR-modules, crystals, fusion products and limit constructions. Adv. Math. 211(2):566–593 (2007) Frenkel, E., Mukhin, E.: Combinatorics of q-characters of finite-dimensional representations of quantum affine algebras. Commun. Math. Phys., 216(1), 23–57 (2001) ˆ ∞ . Selecta Math. (N.S.) 8(4), 537–635 Frenkel, E., Mukhin, E.: The hopf algebra r epUq gl (2002) Frenkel, E., Reshetikhin, N.: The q-characters of representations of quantum affine algebras and deformations of w-algebras. In: Recent Developments in Quantum Affine Algebras and Related Topics. Cont. Math. 248, 163–205 (1999) Frenkel, I.B., Reshetikhin, N.: Quantum affine algebras and holonomic difference equations. Commun. Math. Phys. 146(1), 1–60 (1992) Grojnowski, I., Kleber, M.: Generalized Kirillov-Reshetikhin Modules for Quantum Affine Algebras. http://www.msri.org/publications/ln/msri/2002/ssymmetry/grojnowski/1/index.html, 2002 Hernandez, D.: Algebraic approach to q, t-characters. Adv. Math. 187(1), 1–52 (2004) Hernandez, D.: Representations of quantum affinizations and fusion product. Transform. Groups 10(2), 163–200 (2005) Hernandez, D.: Monomials of q and q, t-chraracters for non simply-laced quantum affinizations. Math. Z. 250(2), 443–473 (2005) Hernandez, D.: The kirillov-reshetikhin conjecture and solutions of t-systems. J. Reine Angew. Math. 596, 63–87 (2006) Hernandez, D.: Drinfeld coproduct, quantum fusion tensor category and applications. Proc. London Math. Soc. (to appear) math.QA/0504269, 2005 Hernandez, D.: Smallness problem for quantum affine algebras and quiver varieties. math. QA/0607526, 2006
On Minimal Affinizations of Representations of Quantum Groups
[HKOTT] [HKOTY] [J] [Ka] [Kl] [Kn] [KN] [KNH] [KOS] [KR]
[KS] [Mi] [Mo] [Nak1] [Nak2] [Nak3] [Nak4] [Nak5] [Naz1] [NN1] [NN2] [NN3] [NT] [V]
259
Hatayama, G., Kuniba, A., Okado, M., Takagi, T., Tsuboi, Z.: Paths, crystals and fermionic formulae. In: MathPhys odyssey, 2001, Prog. Math. Phys. 23, Boston, MA, Birkhäuser Boston, 2002, 205–272 Hatayama, G., Kuniba, A., Okado, M., Takagi, T., Yamada, Y.: Remarks on fermionic formula. In: Recent developments in quantum affine algebras and related topics (Raleigh, NC, 1998), Contemp. Math. 248, Providence, RI: Amer. Math. Soc. 1999, pp. 243–291 Jimbo, M.: A q-difference analogue of U (g) and the yang-baxter equation. Lett. Math. Phys. 10(1), 63–69 (1985) Kac V.: (1990) Infinite dimensional Lie algebras. 3rd Edition, Cambridge:Cambridge University Press, 1990 Kleber, M.: Combinatorial structure of finite-dimensional representations of yangians: the simply-laced case. Internat. Math. Res. Notices 1997(4), 187–201 (1997) Knight, H.: Spectra of tensor products of finite-dimensional representations of yangians. J. Alg. 174(1), 187–196 (1995) Kuniba, A., Nakanishi, T.: The bethe equation at q = 0, the möbius inversion formula, and weight multiplicities, II: the X n case. J. Alg. 251(2), 577–618 (2002) Kuniba, A., Nakamura, S., Hirota, R.: Pfaffian and determinant solutions to a discretized toda equation for Br , Cr and Dr . J. Phys. A 29(8), 1759–1766 (1996) (1) Kuniba, A., Ohta, Y., Suzuki, J.: Quantum jacobi-trudi and giambelli formulae for Uq (Br ) from analytic bethe ansatz. J. Phys. A 28(21), 6211–6226 (1995) Kirillov, A.N., Reshetikhin, N.: Representations of Yangians and multiplicities of the inclusion of the irreducible components of the tensor product of representations of simple Lie algebras. J. Sov. Math. 52(3), 3156–3164 (1990); translated from Zap. Nauchn. Sem. Leningrad. Otdel. Mat. Inst. Steklov. (LOMI) 160, Anal. Teor. Chisel i Teor. Funktsii. 8, 211–221, 301 (1987) Kuniba, A., Suzuki, S.: Analytic bethe ansatz for fundamental representations and yangians. Commun. Math. Phys. 173, 225–264 (1995) Miki, K.: Representations of quantum toroidal algebra Uq (sln + 1, tor)(n ≥ 2). J. Math. Phys. 41(10), 7079–7098 (2000) Molev, A.: On Gelfand-Tsetlin bases for representations of classical Lie algebras. In: Formal power series and algebraic combinatorics (Moscow, 2000), Berlin:Springer 2000, pp. 300–308 Nakajima, H.: Quiver varieties and finite-dimensional representations of quantum affine algebras. J. Amer. Math. Soc. 14(1), 145–238 (2001) Nakajima, H.: T -analogue of the q-characters of finite dimensional representations of quantum affine algebras. In: Physics and combinatorics, 2000 (Nagoya), River Edge, NJ:World Sci. Publishing 2001, pp. 196–219 Nakajima, H.: t–analogs of q–characters of quantum affine algebras of type An , Dn . In: Combinatorial and geometric representation theory (Seoul, 2001), Contemp. Math. 325, Providence, RI:Amer. Math. Soc. 2003, pp. 141–160 Nakajima, H.: Quiver varieties and t-analogs of q-characters of quantum affine algebras. Ann. of Math. 160, 1057–1097 (2004) Nakajima, H.: t-analogs of q-characters of Kirillov-Reshetikhin modules of quantum affine algebras. Represent. Theory 7, 259–274 (electronic) (2003) Nazarov, M.: Representations of twisted yangians associated with skew young diagrams. Selecta Math. (N.S.) 10(1), 71–129 (2004) Nakai, W., Nakanishi, T.: Paths, tableaux and q-characters of quantum affine algebras: the Cn case. J. Phys. A 39(9), 2083–2115 (2006) Nakai, W., Nakanishi, T.: Paths, tableaux descriptions of Jacubi-Trudi determinant associated with quantum affine algebra of type Dn . J. Algebraic Combin. (to appear) math.QA/0603160, 2006 Nakai, W., Nakanishi, T.: Paths, tableaux descriptions of Jacubi-Trudi determinant associated with quantum affine algebra of type Cn . SIGMA 3, 078 (2007) Nazarov, M., Tarasov, V.: Representations of yangians with gelfand-zetlin bases. J. Reine Angew. Math. 496, 181–212 (1998) Varagnolo, M.: Quiver varieties and yangians. Lett. Math. Phys. 53(4), 273–283 (2000)
Communicated by A. Connes
Commun. Math. Phys. 276: 261–285 (2007) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-007-0314-3
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Super-Derivations and Associated Standard Super-Potentials Huzihiro Araki Research Institute for Mathematical Sciences, Kyoto University, Sakyoku, Kyoto 606-8502, Japan. E-mail: [email protected] Received: 8 December 2006 / Accepted: 18 January 2007 Published online: 23 August 2007 – © Springer-Verlag 2007
Abstract: Abstractly defined super-derivations on Fermionic systems on a lattice are studied. The existence and uniqueness of the associated standard super-potential are shown for every super-derivation with the subalgebra of all local operators as its domain. The relation between the standard super-potential of a super-derivation and the standard potential for the square of the super-potential (which is shown to be a derivation in the case of finite range super-potentials) is obtained (by use of local super-Hamiltonian for the super-derivation and local Hamiltonian for the square). As a consequence, a necessary and sufficient condition for a super-derivation to be nilpotent is obtained in terms of the corresponding standard super potential. Examples of translation invariant nilpotent super-derivations are given in the case of super-potentials of finite ranges on a one-dimensional lattice. A merit of considering the super-potential associated with a super-derivation is that the former can be used as free parameters for the latter. 1. Introduction We consider a system on a lattice with Fermionic grading, which may describe a finite number of Fermions and finite dimensional bosonic objects (such as Pauli spins) on each lattice site. A super-derivation is defined as a derivation with twist by grading [4–7]. For each such super-derivation with the set of all local operators as its domain, we prove the existence of associated super-potentials, which can be made unique by the standardness requirement (relative to a fixed even product state such as the tracial state or the Fermion vacuum state). The proof is obtained by a suitable adaptation of the method used for standard potentials of ∗-derivations recently studied in [3, 1, 2]. A merit of considering the super-potential associated with a super-derivation is that the former can be used as free parameters for the latter. Namely, super-potentials for each finite subset of the lattice can be written out as a linear combination of a finite number of bases (which can be easily listed) and the coefficients are free parameters, without
262
H. Araki
any condition for finite range cases and with convergence conditions which restrict only the growth of coefficients as the finite subset become infinitely large. Furthermore, if this set of parameters is different, the corresponding super-derivation is different. These points are explained in more detail in Remarks 4.2, 4.3 and 4.4. A brief outline of the content is as follows. The C ∗ -algebra for the description of the system under consideration along with its local and graded structure, graded commutation relations, a self-adjoint unitary implementer of the grading automorphism, and formulae for intersections and commutants of subalgebras will be introduced in Part A of Sect. 2. After introduction of product states, the conditional expectations (relative to a fixed product state), which provide an essential tool for the present analysis, are defined and their main properties are explained in Part B of Sect. 2. After these preliminaries, super-derivations which is the main subject of this work will be discussed in Sect. 3. They are defined in Definition 3.1 with inner super-derivations (3.2) as a motivation. As a technical tool, the graded commutant (relative to the graded commutator (3.1)) of subalgebras are obtained in Lemma 3.2. Then as the main result of this section, a system of local super-Hamiltonians H s (I ) is shown in Theorem 3.3 to be in one-to-one correspondence with a super-derivation under consideration. In Theorem 4.1, which is the main result of Sect. 4, a standard super-potential satisfying the standardness condition (−2) (equivalently (−2 )) and the convergence condition (−3) is shown to be uniquely associated with a super-derivation under consideration and hence can be used for the description of super-derivations. In Sect. 5, finite range super-derivations are considered and its square is shown to be a derivation, for which the corresponding standard local Hamiltonians are expressed in terms of the local super-Hamiltonians of the super-derivation in Theorem 5.5. As a consequence, a necessary and sufficient condition for a super-derivation to be nilpotent is given in terms of its super-Hamiltonians in Theorems 5.6 and 5.7. Some examples of nilpotent super-derivations are given in terms of the associated super-potentials in Sect. 6. 2. Algebra and Conditional Expectations (A) Algebra. We consider a C ∗ algebra A for the description of the physical system on a lattice L = Zν . For a subset I of L, I c denotes the complement of I , |I | denotes the number of lattice sites in I when I is finite and the notation I ⊂⊂ L is used to indicate that I is a finite subset of L. The C ∗ algebra A has the following two structures. (Local Structure) For each lattice site i, there is a subalgebra A(i) of A, isomorphic to the full matrix algebra Md of all d × d matrices. For each subset I of L, there corresponds a C ∗ subalgebra A(I ) which is generated by all A(i) with i ∈ I . In particular, A = A(L). Due to the graded commutation relations below, A(I ) is isomorphic to the full matrix algebra of d |I | × d |I | matrices if I is finite. We use the following dense ∗ subalgebra of A: A0 = A(I ). (2.1) I ⊂⊂L
Elements of this subalgebra will be called local operators. (Graded Structure) We consider an automorphism of the algebra A satisfying 2 = 1 and (A(i)) = A(i) for all i. (By an automorphism of a C ∗ -algebra, we mean an
Super-Derivations and Associated Standard Super-Potentials
263
algebraic automorphism preserving also the adjoint ∗.) Then (A(I )) = A(I ) for all subsets I of L. Since 2 = 1, any A ∈ A can be split as a sum of even and odd elements, called the even and odd parts of A, uniquely: A = A+ + A− ,
A± = (A ± (A))/2 ∈ A± ,
(2.2)
where A± = {B ∈ A | (B) = ±B}.
(2.3)
A = A+ + A− .
(2.4)
Namely, we have
Correspondingly, we have the following splitting of all subalgebras: A(I ) = A(I )+ + A(I )− , A(I )± = A(I ) ∩ A± .
(2.5)
We assume that each A(i)− is non-trivial (i.e. non-zero). (As 1 ∈ A(i), A(i)+ is automatically non-trivial.) A state ϕ is called even if it is invariant under , namely if ϕ((A)) = ϕ(A) for all A. A state ϕ is even if and only if it vanishes on all odd elements. (Graded Commutation Relations) For any two disjoint subsets I and J of L and for any x± ∈ A(I )± and y± ∈ A(J )± , we assume the following graded commutation relations (σ, σ = + or −): xσ yσ = −yσ xσ if σ = σ = −, xσ yσ = yσ xσ otherwise.
(2.6) (2.7)
(Self-adjoint Unitary Implementer of ) Since each A(i) is isomorphic to a full matrix algebra, there exists a self-adjoint unitary v(i) ∈ A(i) satisfying v(i)∗ Av(i) = (A) for all A ∈ A(i). Such v(i) is unique up to ± and is even. Since it commutes with all elements of A(I c ), v(i) (2.8) v(I ) = i∈I
for any finite I is a self-adjoint unitary implementer of on A(I ). (Formulae for Intersections and Commutants of Subalgebras) As a consequence of the Local Structure and the Graded Commutation Relations, the following formulae for the commutant of the subalgebra A(I ) within A and a related formula are known and useful (see [3], Corollary 4.12, Theorems 4.17, 4.19 and [1], Theorems 2.2, 2.4, 2.5). A(I j ) = A( I j ). (2.9) j
j
If I is finite, then A(I ) = A(I c )+ + v(I )A(I c )− , (A(I )+ ) = A(I c ) + v(I )A(I c ).
(2.10)
If I is not finite, then A(I ) = A(I c )+ ,
(A(I )+ ) = A(I c ).
All the commutants in the above formulae are taken within A.
(2.11)
264
H. Araki
(B) Conditional Expectations. (Product states) A state ϕ of A is called a product state if ϕ(x y) = ϕ(x)ϕ(y)
(2.12)
for any x ∈ A(I ) and y ∈ A(J ) for any disjoint subsets I and J . Examples of even product states are the tracial state τ characterized by τ (AB) = τ (B A) for all A, B ∈ A and the vacuum state for Fermions. (Conditional Expectations) Fix an even product state ϕ of A. Then, for any subset I of L, ϕ ϕ there exists a map E I from x ∈ A to E I (x) ∈ A(I ) satisfying and uniquely determined by ϕ
ϕ(a1 xa2 ) = ϕ(a1 E I (x)a2 )
(2.13)
for all a1 and a2 in A(I ). It has the following properties of a conditional expectation: ϕ
(1) E I is linear, positive and unital. (2) For any x ∈ A and b ∈ A(I ), ϕ
ϕ
E I (xb) = E I (x)b,
ϕ
ϕ
E I (bx) = bE I (x).
(2.14)
ϕ
(3) E I is a projection of norm 1 onto A(I ). Furthermore, it has the following properties: (4) For any x ∈ A, ϕ
ϕ
E I ((x)) = (E I (x)),
(2.15)
ϕ
namely, E I commutes with . ϕ (5) E I for different I mutually commute and satisfy the following formula: ϕ
ϕ
ϕ
ϕ
ϕ
E I E J = E J E I = E I ∩J .
(2.16)
ϕ
Here E ∅ is to be interpreted as ϕ. (6) In particular, ϕ
ϕ
E I E I c = ϕ.
(2.17) ϕ
(Continuous Dependence on Subsets) The continuous dependence of E I on the subset I is given by the following formula which converges in the norm topology for any fixed x if K ν → K : ϕ
ϕ
lim E K ν (x) = E K , ν
where K ν → K for a net K ν means K = Kν = Kν , µ
ν≥µ
µ
(2.18)
(2.19)
ν≥µ
in which the second equality is the criterion for convergence of the net K ν . In particular, ϕ
lim E K = 1.
K L
(2.20)
Super-Derivations and Associated Standard Super-Potentials
265
3. Super-derivation For Q ∈ A− and A ∈ A define the graded commutator [Q, A] = Q A − (A)Q.
(3.1)
Lemma 3.1. For Q ∈ A− , define δ sQ (A) = [Q, A]
(3.2)
for all A ∈ A. Then δ sQ has the following properties: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6)
δ sQ is a linear mapping from A into A. δ sQ (AB) = δ sQ (A)B + (A)δ sQ (B). δ sQ = −δ sQ . δ sQ is linear in Q. s s ∗ ∗ δ sQ (A)∗ = δ−Q ∗ ((A )) = (δ Q ∗ (A )). δ sQ (δ sQ (A)) = [Q 2 , A](= Q 2 A − AQ 2 ).
Proof. Immediate by direct computations.
Definition 3.1. Let Dom δ be a invariant subalgebra of A. A mapping δ from Dom δ to A is called a super-derivation if it satisfies the properties (1), (2) and (3) of Lemma 3.1 . Dom δ is called the domain of δ. The δ sQ in Lemma 3.1 is called an inner super-derivation. As a technical preparation for the proof of the main theorem of this section, we first introduce the notion of super-commutant and prove a lemma about it. Note that in the graded commutator defined by (3.1), Q is assumed to be odd. In the following lemma, Q is an arbitrary element (not restricted to odd elements). So the notation for the graded commutator is not used. Definition 3.2. For any I ⊂ L, the set of all Q ∈ A satisfying Q A − (A)Q = 0
(3.3)
for all A ∈ A(I ) is called the super-commutant of A(I ) and denoted by A(I ) . Lemma 3.2. (1) If I is finite, then
A(I ) = v(I )A(I ) = v(I )A(I c )+ + A(I c )− .
(3.4)
(2) If I is infinite, then
A(I ) = A(I c )− .
(3.5)
(3) If Q ∈ A− satisfies (3.3) for all A ∈ A(I ), then
Q ∈ (A(I ) )− = A(I c )− irrespective of whether I is finite or infinite.
(3.6)
266
H. Araki
Proof. (1) Consider a finite I . Eq. (3.3) implies [v(I )Q, A] = v(I )Q A − Av(I )Q = v(I )(Q A − (A)Q) = 0.
(3.7)
Therefore Eq. (2.10) implies v(I )Q ∈ A(I ) = A(I c )+ + v(I )A(I c )− .
(3.8)
Conversely, if this is the case, Eq. (3.3) holds. Hence Lemma 3.2 (1) is proved. (Note that v(I )2 = 1.) (2) Consider an infinite I . Eq. (3.3) with A ∈ A(I )+ and the Eq. (2.11) imply Q ∈ (A(I )+ ) = A(I c )
(3.9)
Let Q = Q + + Q − , Q ± ∈ A(I c )± . Then, Eq. (3.3) with A ∈ A(I )− implies 0 = Q A + AQ = 2Q + A. Since there exist a family of operators Aα ∈ A(I )− such that Remark 3.1 below), we obtain Q+ = (Q + Aα )A∗α = 0.
(3.10)
α
Aα A∗α = 1 (see (3.11)
α
Therefore Q = Q − ∈ A(I c )− . Conversely, if this is the case, Eq. (3.3) holds. Hence Lemma 3.2 (2) is proved. (3) Consider Q ∈ A− , then by proof (1) and (2) above, Q ∈ A(I c )−
(3.12)
is necessary and sufficient for Eq. (3.3) to hold for both finite and infinite I .
Remark 3.1. The family Aα ∈ A in the above proof can be constructed as follows: For a finite I , identify A(I ) with the algebra of all linear operators on C N , N = d |I | . Let {en |n = 1, . . . , N } be an orthonormal basis of C N consisting of eigenvectors of v(I ) and let v(I )en = σn en (σn = + or −).
(3.13)
Let u mn (m, n = 1, . . . , N ) be a self-adjoint system of matrix units satisfying u mn ek = δnk em . They satisfy u kl u mn = δlm u kn ,
N
u kk = 1.
(3.14)
k=1
(They also satisfy u ∗kl = u lk , which we are not going to use.) We now construct Aα for α = n = 1, . . . , N as follows. Fix αe and αo satisfying σαe = + and σαo = −. (Note that A(i)± are non-trivial for each i by our overall assumption.) If σα = +, then set Aα = u ααo . If σα = −, then set Aα = u ααe . Then Aα ∈ A(I )− for all α and α Aα A∗α = 1. We can now state the main theorem of this section.
Super-Derivations and Associated Standard Super-Potentials
267
Theorem 3.3. Let δ be a super-derivation with Dom δ = A0 . Then there exists a unique H (I ) ∈ A− for each I ⊂⊂ L satisfying the following properties: (1) For every I and every A ∈ A(I ), δ(A) = [H (I ), A] . ϕ (2) E I c (H (I )) = 0. ϕ (3) If I ⊂ J , then H (I ) = H (J ) − E I c (H (J )). Conversely, if a function H (I ) of finite sets I of L with values in A satisfies the above properties (2) and (3), then (1) above defines a super-derivation δ with Dom δ = A0 . Proof. Proof will be carried out in 5 steps. First, we give an explicit candidate h for H (I ) and show that it is odd and satisfies the property (1) for H (I ). Second, we modify h to h so that h is odd and satisfies (1) and (2). Then we set H (I ) = h . Third, we show that odd H (I ) satisfying (1) and (2) is unique. Fourth, we show (3) by using the uniqueness just proved. Finally, for any given A− -valued function H (I ) of I ⊂⊂ L, satisfying properties (2) and (3), the δ defined by the property (1) is shown to be a super-derivation with its domain A0 . (Step 1) Existence of odd H (I ) satisfying (1). For a finite I , let u mn (m, n = 1, . . . , N ) be a self-adjoint system of matrix units for A(I ), constructed in Remark 3.1. Define h = −N −1 σk σn u kn δ(u nk ). (3.15) k,n
Then (h) = −h due to (u kn ) = σk σn u kn and δ = −δ. We show the condition (1) for H (I ) = h. It is enough to show it for A = u αβ : [h, u αβ ] = hu αβ − σα σβ u αβ h = −N −1 σk σn u kn δ(u nk )u αβ + N −1 σk σn σα σβ u αβ u kn δ(u nk ) k,n
= −N
−1
k,n
σk σn u kn (δ(u nk u αβ ) − σn σk u nk δ(u αβ )) + N −1
k,n
= −N −1
σα σn u αn δ(u nβ ) + δ(u αβ ) + N −1
n
σα σn u αn δ(u nβ )
n
σα σn u αn δ(u nβ )
n
= δ(u αβ ), where we have used the property (2) of Lemma 3.1 for the super-derivation δ to obtain the third equality and k u kk = 1 to obtain the fourth equality. (Step 2) Existence of odd H (I ) satisfying (1) and (2). By Step 1, we have for each I ⊂⊂ L, [h, A] = δ(A)
(3.16)
for all A ∈ A(I ). Let ϕ
h = h − E I c (h). Since
ϕ E I c (h)
∈
A(I c )
−,
h
(3.17)
is odd and the graded commutation relation implies ϕ
[E I c (h), A] = 0
(3.18)
for all A ∈ A(I ). Therefore, condition (1) satisfied by h is also satisfied by h . Furtherϕ more, condition (2) is satisfied by h because E I c is a projection. So we take H (I ) = h .
268
H. Araki
(Step 3) Uniqueness of H (I ) satisfying (1) and (2). Suppose h 1 and h 2 both satisfy conditions (1) and (2) for H (I ). By property (1), we have [h 1 − h 2 , A] = 0
(3.19)
for all A ∈ A(I ). Due to h 1 − h 2 ∈ A− and Lemma 3.2, this implies h 1 − h 2 ∈ A(I c )− . Hence property (2) implies ϕ
ϕ
ϕ
h 1 − h 2 = E I c (h 1 − h 2 ) = E I c (h 1 ) − E I c (h 2 ) = 0.
(3.20)
Therefore h 1 = h 2 and the uniqueness is proved. (Step 4) Proof of the property (3). Let I ⊂ J and A ∈ A(I ) ⊂ A(J ). By the graded ϕ commutation relation, E I c (H (J )) ∈ A(I c )− implies ϕ
[H (J ) − E I c (H (J )), A] = [H (J ), A] = δ(A). ϕ
(3.21)
ϕ
Furthermore, E I c (H (J ) − E I c (H (J ))) = 0. Hence by the uniqueness proved in Step 3, we obtain property (3). (Step 5) Converse. For a given family of H (I ) we define δ by property (1). Then for each I , it is a super-derivation with domain A(I ) by the proof of Lemma 3.1. If I ⊂ J and A ∈ A(I ), then property (3), of which the second term on the right-hand side has vanishing graded commutators with elements of A(I ), implies [H (I ), A] = [H (J ), A]. For general finite I and J and for A ∈ A(I ) ∩ A(J ) = A(I ∩ J ), we can apply the preceding equality for the pairs I ∩ J ⊂ I and I ∩ J ⊂ J to obtain [H (I ), A] = [H (I ∩ J ), A] = [H (J ), A]. Thus the definitions of δ by different H (I )’s are consistent and altogether define a super-derivation δ on A0 .
Remark 3.2. The existence proof of H (I ) is the super-derivation version of what Sakai ([8]) proved for ∗-derivations. We believe that this is a new result. Remark 3.3. The h given in Step 1 of the above proof can be written as u kl h kl , h=
(3.22)
k,l
where h kl =
σl σm u mk δ(u lm ) − δkl N −1
m
σm σn u mn δ(u nm )
(3.23)
m,n
belongs to v(I )A(I ) and satisfies (h kl ) = −σk σl h kl . This can be shown by the following computation. First, u kl h kl = σl σm u kl u mk δ(u lm ) − N −1 σm σn u kk u mn δ(u nm ) k,l
klm
=
u kk δ(u ll ) − N
k,l
= −N −1
k,n
= h,
−1
kmn
σk σn u kn δ(u nk )
k,n
σk σn u kn δ(u nk )
Super-Derivations and Associated Standard Super-Potentials
where we have used
l
u ll =
k
269
u kk = 1 and δ(1) = 0, the reason for the latter being
δ(1) = δ(12 ) = δ(1)1 + (1)δ(1) = 2δ(1).
(3.24)
Second, we compute the commutator (3.3) for A = u αβ and Q = h kl , irrespective of h kl being even or odd, using again property (2) of Lemma 3.1 for the super-derivation δ. (1) If k = l, h kl u αβ − (u αβ )h kl = σl σm u mk δ(u lm )u αβ − σα σβ u αβ σl σm u mk δ(u lm ) m
=
m
σl σm u mk (δ(u lm u αβ ) − σl σm u lm δ(u αβ )) − σl σα u αk δ(u lβ )
m
= σl σα u αk δ(u lβ ) − σl σα u αk δ(u lβ ) = 0. (2) If k = l, h kk u αβ − (u αβ )h kk = σk σm u mk δ(u km )u αβ − σα σβ u αβ σk σm u mk δ(u km ) m
−N
−1
m
σm σn u mn δ(u nm )u αβ + N
mn
= σk σα u αk δ(u kβ ) − − N −1
−1
σα σβ u αβ σm σn u mn δ(u nm )
mn
u mm δ(u αβ ) − σα σk u αk δ(u kβ )
m
σα σn u αn δ(u nβ ) + δ(u αβ ) + N −1
n
σα σn u αn δ(u nβ )
n
= 0, where for the second equality we have used σk σm u mk δ(u km )u αβ = σk σm u mk (δ(u km u αβ ) − σk σm u km δ(u αβ )) m
m
= σk σα u αk δ(u kβ ) −
u mm δ(u αβ )
m
for the first term on the left-hand side of the equality and the same equation with k replaced by n and summed over n for the third term of the left-hand side of the equality. Hence, by Lemma 3.2(1), h kl is in A(I c )− + v(I )A(I c )+ = v(I )A(I ) .
(3.25)
(h kl ) = −σk σl h kl
(3.26)
Finally we have
due to (u pq ) = σ p σq u pq and δ = −δ. Definition 3.3. A function H (I ) of I ⊂⊂ L satisfying (1), (2) and (3) of Theorem 3.3 is called the family of local super-Hamiltonians for the super-derivation δ.
270
H. Araki
4. Standard Super-Potentials We define ϕ
U (I ) = E I (H (I )), which belongs to A(I )− . (A(I ) because of property (2) of H (I ), we have
ϕ EI
(4.1)
and odd because H (I ) is odd.) By
ϕ
ϕ
ϕ(U (I )) = ϕ(E I (H (I ))) = ϕ(H (I )) = ϕ(E I c (H (I ))) = 0.
(4.2)
For the empty set, we define (∅) = U (∅) = 0. ϕ ϕ ϕ ϕ If I ⊂ J , property (3) of H (I ), when multiplied by E I , implies, due to E I = E I E J , ϕ ϕ E I E I c = ϕ and ϕ(H (J )) = 0, ϕ
ϕ
ϕ
U (I ) = E I E J (H (J )) − ϕ(H (J )) = E I (U (J )).
(4.3)
For a general J , we have ϕ
ϕ
ϕ
ϕ
E I (U (J )) = E I E J (U (J )) = E I ∩J U (I ) = U (I ∩ J ). Furthermore, property (3) of H (I ), when multiplied by ϕ
ϕ EJ ,
(4.4)
implies
ϕ
E J H (I ) = U (J ) − E I c (U (J )).
(4.5)
By taking the limit J L, we obtain an expression of H (I ) in terms of U (J ): ϕ
H (I ) = lim (U (J ) − E I c (U (J ))). J L
We now define the (ϕ-)standard super-potential by (I ) = (−1)|I |−|K | U (K ).
(4.6)
(4.7)
K ⊂I
This set of equations (for all I ⊂⊂ L) is equivalent to U (I ) = (K ).
(4.8)
K ⊂I
For the proof, see for example [3]. We can now state the main theorem of this section. Theorem 4.1. (1) The standard super-potential , which is a function of I ⊂⊂ L and is derived from a super-derivation δ through H (I ) of Theorem 3.3, U(I) of Eq. (4.1) and Eq. (4.7), has the following 3 properties: (-1) (I ) ∈ A(I )− , (∅) = 0 . ϕ
(-2) If J ⊂ I and J = I , then E J ((I )) = 0. (-3) For each I ⊂⊂ L, the net
(K )
K ⊂J,K ∩I =∅
converges as J L. Under property (-1), property (-2) is equivalent to
(4.9)
Super-Derivations and Associated Standard Super-Potentials
271
(-2 ) ϕ E J ((I ))
=
(I ), 0,
I ⊂ J, otherwise.
(4.10)
(2) Conversely, any function of I ⊂⊂ L satisfying the 3 properties (-1), (-2) (equivalently (-2 )) and (-3) defines a super-derivation δ with domain A0 by δ(A) = lim [(K ), A] (4.11) J L
K ⊂J
for A ∈ A0 , where the limit on the right-hand side converges in norm. The H (I ) uniquely associated with this δ by Theorem 3.3 is given by H (I ) = lim (K ). (4.12) J L
K ⊂J,K ∩I =∅
(3) The mappings between δ and , given by (1) and (2) above are the inverse of each other and they give a bijective real linear mapping beween the real linear space of all super-derivations with domain A0 and the real linear space of all functions of I ⊂⊂ L satisfying the 3 properties (-1), (-2) and (-3). Remark 4.1. In Eq. (4.11), the summation over K can be (and usually is) limited to those K having non-empty intersection with I when A ∈ A(I ) because terms for other K vanish. Proof. (1) The first property in (-1) follows from Eq. (4.7) and U (K ) ∈ A(K )− . The second property in (-1) is by definition. As for the equivalence of (-2) and (-2 ) under (-1), (-2) is a part of (-2 ) on one hand. On the other hand, if (-2) holds, then with the help of (-1) we have ϕ
ϕ
ϕ
ϕ
E J (I ) = E J E I (I ) = E J ∩I (I ),
(4.13)
which is (I ) if I ⊂ J ∩ I and 0 otherwise due to (-2). Since I ⊂ J ∩ I is the same as I ⊂ J , (-2 ) follows from (-2) and (-1). Substituting Eq. (4.8) into U in Eq. (4.6), using property (-2 ) in which the pair J, I is replaced by the pair I c , K , and noting that K ⊂ I c is equivalent to K ∩ I = ∅, we obtain Eq. (4.12). (2) Let satisfying 3 properties (-1), (-2 ) and (-3) be given. We define (K ), (4.14) H (I ) = lim J L
K ⊂J,K ∩I =∅
where the limit on the right-hand side converges by property (-3). The H (I ) so defined belongs to A− due to (-1). Due to (-2 ), the above defining equation for H (I ) is the same as ϕ H (I ) = lim ((K ) − E I c ((K ))) (4.15) M L
K ⊂M
272
H. Araki
because in the sum over K the terms with K ⊂ I c vanish while the other terms ϕ are (K ) both due to (-2 ). Since E I c is a projection, H (I ) obviously satisfies property (2) in Theorem 3.3. To show property (3) of H(I) in the same theorem, we ϕ ϕ ϕ note that if I ⊂ J , then J c ⊂ I c and hence E I c E J c = E J c . This implies ϕ
ϕ
ϕ
((K ) − E J c (K )) − E I c ((K ) − E J c (K )) ϕ
= (K ) − E I c (K ). If we substitute the expression of H (J ) given by the formula (4.15) into the righthand side of property (3) for H (I ) in Theorem 3.3 and use the equation just computed, then we get an expression of H (I ) given by the formula (4.15) . Therefore the property (3) of Theorem 3.3 is shown. By Theorem 3.3, a super-derivation δ is defined by H (I ) through the formula δ(A) = [H (I ), A]
(4.16)
for A ∈ A(I ). Substituting the expression (4.15) into H (I ) of the above equation and noting that the second term in the sum on the right-hand side of (4.15) belongs to A(I c )− and hence its graded commutator with A vanishes, we obtain the expression (4.11) which is guaranteed to converge in norm (due to the convergence of (4.15)). The uniqueness of H (I ) in Theorem 3.3 now proves that our H (I ) corresponds to the super-derivation δ defined by Eq. (4.11). We have completed the proof of (2). (3) Since the bijective real linear correspondence between δ and H is already established by Theorem 3.3, we only have to establish the bijective real linear correspondence between H and . Since H is explicitly given in terms of , we have only to prove that if k , k = 1, 2, both satisfy properties (-1), (-2 ) and (-3) and give the same H , then 1 = 2 . However, from the expression of H (I ) in terms of , one obtains the expression (4.8) for U (I ) by the property (-2 ) of . Since the relation between U and can be solved uniquely for , yielding the expression (4.7) for in terms of U , the uniqueness of for a given H (I ) follows.
Definition 4.1. The function of I ⊂⊂ L with values in A in the above theorem is called the standard super-potential of the super-derivation δ. We now make three remarks (with associated theorems) about the significance of this theorem and then a remark illustrating this theorem in a simple case. The main point of the first three remarks is to show that it is easy to exhibit all possible standard super-potentials explicitly and (infinite number of) parameters for them can be chosen arbitrarily without any constraint binding them (mutually) except for convergence conditions. Since a different choice of the parameters corresponds to a different choice of super-derivation, the former plays a role of free parameters for the latter. This viewpoint is likely to be useful in constructing a super-derivation having a specific property. Remark 4.2. For each fixed I ⊂⊂ L, an arbitrary (I ) satisfying the two properties (-1) and (-2) (the latter being equivalent to (-2 )) can be exhibited as an arbitrary linear combination of the following basis. i− i− i+ For each i ∈ L, A(i) is of a finite (d 2 ) dimension. Let 1, u i+ 1 ,. . ., u N+ , and u 1 ,. . ., u N− , be linear bases of A(i)+ and A(i)− , respectively, where 1 ∈ A(i)+ is taken as one of its
Super-Derivations and Associated Standard Super-Potentials
273
linear basis. The product state ϕ which is assumed to be even, vanishes on u i− k which is odd. On the other hand,
i+ i+ u i+ k = u k − ϕ(u k )1,
(4.17)
k = 1, . . . , N+ together with 1 can be taken to be a linear basis of A(i)+ and satisfies i+ ϕ(u i+ k ) = 0. Thus we may assume that u k , k = 1, . . . , N+ already has this property. We set iσ u ki i , (4.18) u({ki , σi ; i ∈ I }) = i∈I
where each σi is either + or −, the order of the product is according to the (any) fixed order of i ∈ I for each I , and the number of i such that σi = − is restricted to be odd. We can now state the following theorem about a basis of the linear space of all possible standard super-potentials. Theorem 4.2. The collection of elements given in (4.18) is a linear basis of standard super-potentials (I ), namely (1) they satisfy the two properties (-1) and (-2), and (2) exhaust all such possibility. Proof. Because of the graded commutation relations among A(i) with different i, products of their linear bases form a linear basis of A(I ). Equation (4.18) selects those, for which (1) the number of odd elements in the product is odd and (2) the product does not contain 1 as a factor for any i ∈ I . The first condition is obviously equivalent to (-1). Thus it is enough to show that, for a general linear combination of products of bases of A(i), i ∈ I , to satisfy the property (-2), the second property, i.e. vanishing of coefficient of all products containing 1 as a factor for at least one i, is necessary and sufficient. ϕ If Ji = I ∩ {i}c for an i ∈ I , then the application of E Ji on a general linear combinai tion annihilates those terms with the i factor, say u , not equal to 1 because it will produce a factor ϕ(u i ) = 0, while those terms with u i = 1 which belongs to A(Ji ), remains ϕ unchanged. Thus the result of the multiplication of E Ji is now a linear combination of a basis of A(Ji ), and the property (-2) requires it to be 0, namely all its coefficients have to vanish. Hence (I ) must be a linear combination of the product not containing 1 as a factor for any i ∈ I . In the converse direction, consider J ⊂ I, J = I . Then there is some i ∈ I not ϕ ϕ ϕ belonging to J . Then J ⊂ Ji and hence E J = E J E Ji . Since (4.18) is annihilated by ϕ ϕ E Ji , it is annihilated by E J and hence it satisfies (-2).
Remark 4.3. The convergence condition (-3) for the standardness of a potential in Theorem 4.1 is required for all finite I . This is more convenient when using this condition, but the same requirement for only one point sets I = {i} for all i ∈ L is already sufficient, i.e. equivalent to the condition (-3) stated in theorem 4.1, as is formulated and proved in the following theorem. Theorem 4.3. Under conditions (-1) and (-2), the condition (-3) holds if (and only if) it holds only for I = {i} for all i ∈ L.
274
H. Araki
Proof. Let I = {i 1 , . . . , i N }, N = |I |. For any integer k ∈ [1, N ], let Ik = {i 1 , i 2 , . . . , i k }. For any finite J ⊂ L containing I , the set of all K ⊂ J with non-empty intersection with I is a disjoint union (over k = 1, 2, . . . , N ) of the set of all K ⊂ J such that i k ∈ K and i 1 , i 2 , . . . , i k−1 ∈ / K . Hence ⎛ ⎞ N ⎝ ⎠. = (4.19) K ⊂J,K ∩I =∅
K i k ,K ⊂J ∩(Ik−1 )c
k=1
Note that i 1 , i 2 , . . . , i k−1 ∈ / K is equivalent to K ⊂ (Ik−1 )c . On the other hand, the condition (-2 ) (which follows from (-1) and (-2)) implies ϕ (K ) = (K ). (4.20) E (Ik−1 )c K i k ,K ⊂J
K i k ,K ⊂J ∩(Ik−1 )c
Hence
(K ) =
K ⊂J,K ∩I =∅
N
⎛ ϕ E (Ik−1 )c
⎝
k=1
⎞ (K )⎠ .
(4.21)
K i k ,K ⊂J
By (-3) for one-point sets I = {i k }, k = 1, . . . , N , the sum in the parentheses ϕ on the right-hand side converges (to H ({i k })) as J L. Due to E (Ik−1 )c = 1, the right-hand side is convergent, which implies (-3) for a general I .
Corollary 4.4. Let I = {i 1 , . . . , i N }, N = |I | and set Ik = {i 1 , i 2 , . . . , i k } (k = 1, . . . , N ). The following identity holds: H (I ) =
N
ϕ
E (Ik−1 )c (H ({i k })),
(4.22)
k=1
where
ϕ E (Ik−1 )c
for k = 1 is taken to be an identity map.
Proof. By taking the limit of (4.21) as J L, we obtain the identity.
Remark 4.4. Suppose that there is a representation of the group of lattice translations i ∈ L −→ i + n ∈ L ,
(4.23)
n ∈ L, by automorphisms τn of A satisfying τn (A(i)) = A(i + n), commuting with , and leaving the product state ϕ invariant. Then the following sense: ϕ
ϕ
τn E I = E I +n τn ,
(4.24) ϕ EI
is covariant in (4.25)
where I + n = {i + n; i ∈ I }. A super-derivation which commutes with τn for all n ∈ L is said to be translation invariant. In this case, the corresponding standard super-potential is shown in the following theorem to be translation covariant (as a function of I under the translation I −→ I + n of its variable I , covariance referring to the change of the value of the
Super-Derivations and Associated Standard Super-Potentials
275
function by the automorphism τn ) and hence the convergence condition for I = {i} for (any) one i only is already sufficient for (-3) (for all I ⊂⊂ L) to hold because the convergence condition for any other j ∈ L follows from the convergence condition for one I = {i} by the translation automorphism τ j−i . Thus the convergence requirement reduces to the convergence of a single summation. Theorem 4.5. Let (I ), H (I ), and U (I ) be the standard super-potential, a system of super-Hamiltnian, and U defined by (4.1), all for a super-derivation δ. The following conditions are equivalent: (1) The super-derivation δ is translation invariant in the sense that δτn = τn δ for all n ∈ L. (2) The standard super-potential is translation covariant in the sense that (I +n) = τn ((I )) for all n ∈ L and for all I ⊂⊂ L. (3) The system of local super-Hamiltonians H are translation covariant in the sense that H (I + n) = τn (H (I )) for all n ∈ L and for all I ⊂⊂ L. (4) U satisfies U (I + n) = τn (U (I )) for all n ∈ L and for all I ⊂⊂ L. Proof. (1)→ (3) Condition (1) implies for any A ∈ A(I ), τn (δ(A)) = δ(τn (A)),
(4.26)
where A = τn (A) exhausts elements of A(I + n) when A runs over A(I ). By the definition of the system of local super-Hamiltonian and τn = τn , we have δ(A ) = τn (δ(A)) = τn ([H (I ), A] ) = [τn (H (I )), A ] . ϕ
(4.27)
ϕ
Due to (I + n)c = I c + n, (4.25) implies E (I +n)c τn = τn E I c and hence ϕ
ϕ
E (I +n)c τn (H (I )) = τn E I c (H (I )) = 0.
(4.28)
By the unique characterization of H (I ) (Theorem 3.3 (1) and (2)), the above two equations imply τn (H (I )) = H (I + n),
(4.29)
which is condition (3). ϕ
ϕ
ϕ
(3) → (4).U (I + n) = E I +n (H (I + n)) = E I +n τn (H (I )) = τn E I (H (I )) = τn (U (I )). (4) → (2). Due to
(4.30) (I ) =
(−1)|I |−|K | U (K ),
(4.31)
K ⊂I
the mapping by τn yields τn ((I )) =
(−1)|I |−|K | U (K + n)
K ⊂I
=
K ⊂I +n
where we set K = K + n.
(−1)|I +n|−|K | U (K ) = (I + n),
(4.32)
276
H. Araki
(2)→ (1). By Theorem 4.1 (2), we have for A ∈ A0 , δ(A) = lim [(K ), A] . J L
(4.33)
K ⊂J
The mapping by τn then yields for A = τn (A) ∈ A(I + n), τn (δ(A)) = lim [τn ((K )), τn (A)] J L
= lim
J L
K ⊂J
[(K ), A ] = δ(A )
K ⊂J
= δ(τn (A)) where we denote K + n = K and J + n = J . Hence we have (1).
Remark 4.5. For illustration of standard super-potentials, we compute here the standard super-potential for an inner derivation δ sQ for any Q ∈ A− . Due to the unique characterization of H (I ) for a given δ in terms of properties (1) and (2) of Theorem 3.3 (see Step 2 of its proof), H (I ) for δ sQ is given by ϕ
H (I ) = Q − E I c (Q).
(4.34)
Then ϕ
ϕ
ϕ
U (I ) = E I (H (I )) = E I (Q) − ϕ(Q) = E I (Q), ϕ
(4.35)
ϕ
where the second equality is due to E I E I c = ϕ and the last because Q is odd and ϕ is even, so that ϕ(Q) = 0. By (4.7), we obtain ϕ (I ) = (−1)|I |−|K | E K (Q). (4.36) K ⊂I
One can easily check ϕ ϕ U (I ) = (J ) = (−1)|J |−|K | E K (Q) = E I (Q), J ⊂I
by using Hence
|I |
j=|K | (−1)
(4.37)
J ⊂I K ⊂J
j−|K | |I |−|K | j−|K |
= 0 for K ⊂ I , K = I to obtain the last equality. ϕ
Q = lim E I (Q) = lim I L
I L
(K ).
(4.38)
K ⊂I
This implies δ sQ (A) = lim
I L
[(K ), A] .
(4.39)
K ⊂I
The decomposition of the above type for an element of A has been used in the proof of Lemma 12.5 of [3](for an even element).
Super-Derivations and Associated Standard Super-Potentials
277
5. Super-Derivation of a Finite Range and Nilpotent Super-Derivation Definition 5.1. A standard super-potential is said to have a finite range r if (I ) = 0 whenever diam(I ) > r , where diam(I ) is the maximum distance between two points in I. Lemma 5.1. If the standard super-potential for a super-derivation δ has a finite range, then δ maps A0 into itself, i.e. the range of δ is contained in A0 . Proof. Assume that the standard super-potential has a finite range r . For any finite subset I of L, let [I ]r denote the set of all points of L whose distance from I does not exceed r . Let A ∈ A(I ) and consider the term on the right-hand side of Eq (4.11) corresponding to a finite subset K of L. If diam(K ) > r or I and K does not intersect, then it vanishes. Otherwise, it belongs to A([I ]r ) ⊂ A0 due to I ∪ K ⊂ [I ]r . Hence δ(A) ⊂ A0 .
Remark 5.1. In general, a super-derivation can map A0 into itself even if the corresponding standard super-potential does not have a finite range. (For example, this is the case when (K ) = 0 holds if and only if diam(K ) > dist(0, K ) + 1.) However the following theorem holds. Theorem 5.2. For a translation invariant super-derivation δ with A0 as its domain, it maps the domain into itself if and only if the corresponding standard super-potential is of a finite range. Proof. Since A({0}) is of a finite linear dimension (d 2 ), the union of δ images of its d 2 linear basis are individually in some local algebra and hence δ(A({0})) is contained in their linear span, and hence in some A(J ), J ⊂⊂ L. We add the point 0 to J if not yet contained in J . Let J0 be the minimal choice of such J (take the intersection of all such J ) and set r = diam(J0 ). The explicit construction of h in (Step 1) of the proof of Theorem 3.3 implies h ∈ A(J0 ) in the case of H ({0}). Due to ϕ
ϕ
ϕ
ϕ
E I c (h) = E I c E J0 (h) = E J0 ∩I c (h) ∈ A(J0 ∩ I c ) ⊂ A(J0 ),
(5.1)
we have ϕ
H ({0}) = h = h − E I c (h) ∈ A(J0 ).
(5.2)
We now substitute the expression (4.12) (the case of I = {0}) into H ({0}) in the following quantity which vanishes as a consequence of the above equation: ϕ
0 = H ({0}) − E J0 (H ({0})) (K ). = lim J L
K ⊂J,K 0,K ⊂ J0
By the subsequent lemma, we conclude that (K ) = 0
(5.3)
for all K in the above summand, namely if K contains the point 0 and is not a subset of J0 . By application of τi , we conclude that if K contains a point i, then (K ) = 0 unless K is contained in J0 + i. Since 0 is in J0 by our choice, this means that any point of K must have a distance from an arbitrary point i in K not exceeding r = diam(J0 ), i.e. diam(K ) should not exceed r in order that (K ) = 0. Thus we have shown that the super-potential has a finite range (not exceeding r ).
278
H. Araki
Lemma 5.3. Let K be any (finite or infinite) collection of non-empty finite subsets of L and suppose that a standard super-potential satisfies (K ) = 0, (5.4) K ∈K
where the sum is to be norm convergent in any fixed way if K is an infinite set. Then (K ) = 0 for all K ∈ K. Proof. By omitting those K for which (K ) = 0 from the set K, we may assume that (K ) = 0 for all K ∈ K. We will obtain a contradiction if such K is not empty. Among the members of K there is a minimal K (it is minimal if it does not contain a proper subset belonging to K) because of the following reason. Start with any K ∈ K and try to find its proper subset, say K 1 , which belongs to K. If there is no such K 1 , then K is already minimal by definition of minimality. Continue this process obtaining a strictly decreasing sequence of K i belonging to K. Obviously this can not continue more than |K | − 1 times. Let K n be the last one in this sequence. Then it is a minimal member of K and it is not an empty set (because it is a member of K). Thus there exists a minimal member, say K n of K. Because of minimality, there is no proper subset K of K n belonging to K. By the ϕ standardness condition (-2 ), E K n (K ) = 0 if K ∈ K and K = K n . Therefore, ϕ by applying E K n on the equation in the statement of the lemma, we obtain (K n ) = 0 which is a contradiction because it is assumed that (K ) = 0 for all K ∈ K.
Remark 5.2. The above argument works with coefficients in front of each (K ). Therefore, non-zero (K ) with distinct K are linearly independent. Lemma 5.4. Let δ be a super-derivation with A0 as its domain and mapping this domain into itself. Then δ 2 is an even derivation. Proof. As a product of two linear mappings, δ 2 is a linear mapping. The following computation shows that it is a derivation. Let A and B be elements of A0 . Then δ 2 (AB) = δ(δ(A)B + (A)δ(B)) = δ(δ(A))B + (δ(A))δ(B) + δ((A))δ(B) + Aδ(δ(B)) = δ 2 (A)B + Aδ 2 (B), where δ = −δ is used in the last equality. Since δ anticommutes with by the definition of a super-derivation, δ 2 commutes with . Hence it is an even derivation.
An even derivation can be associated with a system of a local Hamiltonian and a standard potential in exactly the same way as an even *-derivation (see [3]) except that they are not necessarily self-adjoint. Let H s (I ) be the local super-Hamiltonian (for I ⊂⊂ L) of the super-derivation δ in Definition 3.3 and let H (I ) be the local Hamiltonian (for I ⊂⊂ L) of the even derivation δ 2 . (We adopt a slightly different convention as compared with the case of *-derivations. We will require δ 2 (A) = [H (I ), A],
(5.5)
while, in the case of *-derivation, i is multiplied on the right-hand side in order to obtain self-adjoint H (I ), which is irrelevant in the present case.) The two are related as follows.
Super-Derivations and Associated Standard Super-Potentials
279
Theorem 5.5. If a super-derivation δ with A0 as its domain maps this domain into itself, then for each I ⊂⊂ L there exists [I ] ⊂⊂ L containing I such that δ(A(I )) ⊂ A([I ]),
(5.6)
where we define [I ] to be the minimal such [I ]. The following relations hold. For any J such that [I ] ⊂ J ⊂⊂ L, ϕ
H (I ) = H s (J )2 − E I c (H s (J )2 ).
(5.7)
Proof. (Since each A(I ) is of finite dimension, existence of some [I ] containing I and satisfying Eq. (5.6) follows from the assumption on δ. Then take the intersection of all such sets to be [I ] which is then the minimal such set.) We can now make the following computation. For A ∈ A(I ), δ 2 (A) = [H s (J ), δ(A)] = [H s (J ), [H s (J ), A] ] = [H s (J )2 , A],
(5.8)
where the first equality is due to δ(A) ∈ A([I ]) and [I ] ⊂ J , the second due to A ∈ A(I ) and I ⊂ [I ] ⊂ J , and the last by the same computation as the proof of Lemma 3.1(6). Since H s (J ) is odd, H s (J )2 is even. Now the quantity ϕ
H (I ) = H s (J )2 − E I c (H s (J )2 )
(5.9)
satisfies the following 3 properties which characterize the local Hamiltonian of the derivation δ 2 for a finite set I uniquely (see Lemma 5.3 of [3]) and the theorem is proved. (1) ϕ
(H (I )) = ((H s (J ))2 − E I c ((H s (J ))2 ) = H (I ),
(5.10)
due to (H s (J )) = −H s (J ). (2) δ 2 (A) = [H s (J )2 , A] = [H (I ), A]
(5.11)
for any A ∈ A(I ) because the second term on the right-hand side of Eq. (5.7) is an even element of A(I c ) which commutes with A ∈ A(I ). (3) ϕ
E I c (H (I )) = 0 ϕ
(5.12)
ϕ
due to (E I c )2 = E I c .
Theorem 5.6. Let δ be a super-derivation with domain A0 mapping this domain into itself. Let [I ] for I ⊂⊂ L be as in the preceding theorem and H s (I ) be the local super-Hamiltonian for δ. Then δ is nilpotent if and only if H s (J )2 ∈ A(I c ) for one finite J containing [I ] for each finite I , or equivalently for all such J.
(5.13)
280
H. Araki
Proof. By the preceding theorem, Eq. (5.13) for one J containing [I ] for each I implies H (I ) = 0 for all I ⊂⊂ L because the right-hand side of (5.7) then vanishes. Hence the nilpotency δ 2 = 0 follows. (Note that H (I ) = 0 implies (5.13) for all finite J containing [I ] due to (5.7) and so, if (5.13) holds for one J containing [I ] for an I , then H (I ) = 0 and (5.13) holds for all J containing [I ] for the same I .) Conversely if δ is nilpotent, then [H (I ), A] = δ 2 (A) = 0 for all A ∈ A(I ) and hence H (I ) belongs to (A(I ) )+ = A(I c )+ . Then (5.7) implies (5.13) for all finite J containing [I ].
Theorem 5.7. Let δ be a super-derivation such that the associated standard superpotential has a finite range r . Let U (J ) = (K ). (5.14) K ⊂J
Then δ is nilpotent if and only if for every finite I , U (J )2 ∈ A(I c )
(5.15)
for one finite J containing all points within distance 2r from I or equivalently for all such finite J . Proof. For finite subsets I, K 1 , K 2 of L, [(K 1 ), [(K 2 ), A] ] = 0
(5.16)
for all A ∈ A(I ) unless diam(K 1 ) and diam(K 2 ) do not exceed r , some point in K 2 is in I and some point in K 1 is in K 2 ∪ I . This implies that every point in K 2 must be within distance r from I and every point in K 1 must be within distance 2r from I . By applying this criterion to Eq. (4.11), we obtain δ 2 (A) = [(K 1 ), [(K 2 ), A] ] , (5.17) K 1 ,K 2
where we can restrict the sum to those K 1 and K 2 satisfying the above stated restrictions. Let J be a finite subset of L containing all points within distance 2r from I. Then all sets K 1 satisfying the above restriction are contained in J . Furthermore, if any other subsets of J is substituted to K 1 , it will give vanishing contribution. Therefore, the sum over K 1 can be extended to all subsets of J. Hence [(K 2 ), A] ] . (5.18) δ 2 (A) = [U (J ), K2
By the same argument, we can extend the sum over K 2 in this equation over all subsets of J and we obtain δ 2 (A) = [U (J ), [U (J ), A] ] = [U (J )2 , A],
(5.19)
where the last equality is by the same calculation as the proof of Lemma 3.1(6). (Note that U (J ) is odd because it is a sum of (K ) which is odd.) From the above expression of δ 2 , we conclude that δ is nilpotent if and only if U (J )2 , which is even, is in (A(I ) )+ = A(I c )+ for at least one J for each I or equivalently for all J for every I .
(5.20)
Super-Derivations and Associated Standard Super-Potentials
281
If δ 2 (A) = 0 for all A ∈ A(i) for each i ∈ L, then δ 2 (A) = 0 for all A ∈ A0 because A0 is algebraically generated from the union of A(i), i ∈ L. Therefore, we obtain the following result. Corollary 5.8. In the preceding two theorems, the conditions for all I = {i}, i ∈ L are already sufficient for the nilpotency of δ. Suppose that there is a representation of the group of lattice translations i ∈ L −→ i + n ∈ L ,
(5.21)
n ∈ L, by automorphisms τn of A satisfying τn (A(i)) = A(i + n),
(5.22) ϕ
commuting with , and leaving the product state ϕ invariant. Then E I is covariant in the following sense: ϕ
ϕ
τn E I = E I +n τn ,
(5.23)
where I + n = {i + n; i ∈ I }. Consider a super-derivation which is translation invariant in the sense that it commutes with τn for all n ∈ L. Then the associated standard super-potential is covariant in the following sense: τn ((I )) = (I + n).
(5.24)
The associated quantities also satisfy similar properties: τn (U (I )) = U (I + n), τn (H (I )) = H (I + n).
(5.25)
In this situation, if δ 2 (A) = 0 for all A ∈ A(i) for one i ∈ L, then the application of τn on this equation yields the same equation for i + n instead of i and hence we have δ 2 = 0. Thus we obtain the following result. Corollary 5.9. For a translation invariant super-derivation δ, the conditions in the preceding two theorems for only one I with |I | = 1 is already sufficient for its nilpotency. 6. Examples of Nilpotent Super-Derivations Standard super-potentials can be regarded as free parameters for super-derivations and can be used for a systematic construction of their examples. Here, we limit our attention to the system of one kind of Fermion on a one-dimensional lattice L = Z, described by creation and annihilation operators ai∗ and ai at each i ∈ Z, which are odd and satisfy the following CAR (the canonical anticommutation relations): [ai∗ , a ∗j ] = [ai , a j ] = 0, [ai∗ , a j ] = δi j .
(6.1)
The local algebra A(i) at a lattice site i ∈ Z is the linear span of 1, ai , ai∗ and ai∗ ai which give the values 1,0,0,0 under the vacuum state, which we call ψ0 and use for the ϕ product state ϕ of the conditional expectations E I .
282
H. Araki
First, we give an infinite-dimensional space of examples of translation invariant nilpotent super-derivations. (Example 1). Consider the following standard potentials for odd |I |: (I ) = c(I )
ai ,
(6.2)
i∈I
where we take the order of the product the same as the order of i in Z and c(I ) is a complex number, vanishing for diam(I) > r as well as for |I | even. It is an odd element of A(I ) and satisfies the standardness condition (-2) and (-2 ). Due to CAR, they mutually anticommute and in particular, the square is 0. Therefore U (J )2 = 0. By Corollary 5.9, the corresponding super-derivation is nilpotent. If c(I ) = c(I + n) for any n ∈ Z, this is a translation invariant nilpotent super-derivation. Because of the choice of c(I ), these examples form an infinite dimensional linear space. (Example 2) If we replace ai by ai∗ in Example 1, we obtain another infinite-dimensional example of translation invariant nilpotent super-potentials. They are conjugate to Example 1 through the Bogoliubov automorphism which interchanges ai with ai∗ for all i ∈ L. We now want to examine the case of a finite range r for small r . (Example 3) The case of r = 0 and hence (I ) = 0 unless |I | = 1. The most general standard super-potential is given by (i) = c1 ai + c2 ai∗ ,
(6.3)
where the coefficients c1 and c2 are independent of i for a translation invariant superderivation. We have (i)2 = c1 c2
(6.4)
which is a constant and so belongs to A({i}c ). Hence all of them give translation invariant nilpotent super-derivations. (Example 4) The case of r = 1 and hence (I ) = 0 unless I = {i} or {i, i + 1}, i ∈ Z. The most general translation covariant standard super-potential is of the following form. For |I | = 1, it is the same as Example 3. For |I | = 2, ∗ ∗ ∗ ai+1 + d2 ai∗ ai+1 ai+1 + d3 ai∗ ai ai+1 + d4 ai∗ ai ai+1 , (i, i + 1) = d1 ai ai+1
(6.5)
where the constants d1 , d2 , d3 , d4 are independent of i. The condition for the nilpotency of the corresponding super-derivation is that U ([−2, 2])2 can be written in the form without terms containing a0 or a0∗ by Corollary 5.9. We have U ([−2, 2]) =
2 i=−2
(i) +
1
(i, i + 1).
(6.6)
i=−2
As is shown in the Appendix, it turns out that this condition is satisfied if and only if all di ’s vanish, namely (i, i + 1) = 0. So we do not obtain a new example in this case.
Super-Derivations and Associated Standard Super-Potentials
Appendix A.
283
Computation of Example 4
The conclusion of Example 4 is obtained by the following (straightforward but tedious) computation. First some preliminary computations. Suppose A and B are some (I )’s which are products of several distinct a’s and a ∗ ’s. If they contain only one factor with index i = 0, then that factor can be brought to either the left or right end of the product to obtain A = a0(∗) A = A a0(∗) and B in the same form with A replaced by B , where the superscript (∗) indicates two possibilities ∗ or non-∗, A and B are even elements of A({0}c ), and hence the second equality. If both contain the factor a0 , then AB = B A = 0 due to (a0 )2 = 0 and the same holds if both contain the factor a0∗ . This include the case A = B. Therefore, in such cases, A2 = B 2 = AB = B A = 0. Now consider the case where A and B are of the above form but A contains the factor a0 and B contains the factor a0∗ . Then AB + B A = A a0 a0∗ B + B a0∗ a0 A = A B + a0∗ a0 [B , A ],
(A.1)
where [B , A ] = B A − A B . If A contains a0∗ and B contains a0 , the same computation with A and B interchanged yields AB + B A = B A + a0∗ a0 [A , B ].
(A.2)
Next consider the case A = a0∗ a0 A and B = a0(∗) B , where A is odd and B is even, both in A({0}c ). By the same type of computation as above, we obtain if B contains a0 , AB = 0,
B A = B a0 A = a0 B A .
(A.3)
AB = −a0∗ A B .
(A.4)
If B contains a0∗ , then we obtain B A = 0,
Finally consider the case A = a0∗ a0 A and B = a0∗ a0 B , where A and B are odd elements of A({0}c ). Then AB + B A = a0∗ a0 (A B + B A ).
(A.5)
This includes the case A = B. Terms in U ([−2, 2]) are all odd and hence for each term there are an odd (and hence non-zero) number of indices i such that it contains either ai alone or ai∗ alone as a factor (∗) with that index. Then one can bring that factor ai to the right or left end (as one pleases). Therefore, if two such terms A and B have a common i for which both have ai (or ai∗ ) as the only factor with the index i, then AB = B A = 0. In particular, the square of all terms are 0. This can be used to select those pairs of terms A and B for which AB + B A can be possibly non-vanishing. We are now ready to compute the square of U ([−2, 2]). We have U ([−2, 2]) = c1 a0 + c2 a0∗ + d1 a0 D1 + d1 a0∗ a0 D1 + d2 a0∗ D2 + d2 a0∗ a0 D2 + d3 a0 D3 + d3 a0∗ a0 D3 + d4 a0∗ D4 + d4 a0∗ a0 D4 + U , (A.6)
284
H. Araki
where ∗ , D1 = a1∗ a1 = D2 , D1 = a−1 , D2 = a−1
∗ D3 = a−1 a−1 = D4 , D3 = a1 , D4 = a1∗
(A.7)
and U are the remaining terms which do not contain factors with index 0: ∗ ai + c2 ai∗ + d1 ai ai+1 ai+1 U = c1 i=−2.−1,1,2
+ d2
i=−2,1
i=−2,−1,1.2
∗ ai∗ ai+1 ai+1
+ d3
i=−2,1
ai∗ ai ai+1
i=−2,1
+ d4
∗ ai∗ ai ai+1 .
(A.8)
i=−2,1
Omitting all those terms not containing a0 and a0∗ (which are irrelevant for our purpose), we obtain U ([−2, 2])2 = a0 W1 + a0∗ W2 + a0∗ a0 W3 ,
(A.9)
where W1 = (c1 + d1 D1 + d3 D3 )(d1 D1 + d2 D2 + d3 D3 + d4 D4 ) + [d1 D1 + d3 D3 , U ], (A.10) W2 = −(d1 D1 + d2 D2 + d3 D3 + d4 D4 )(c2 + d2 D2 + d4 D4 ) + [d2 D2 + d4 D4 , U ], (A.11) 2 W3 = (d1 D1 + d2 D2 + d3 D3 + d4 D4 ) + [d2 D2 + d4 D4 , d1 D1 + d3 D3 ] + [d1 D1 + d2 D2 + d3 D3 + d4 D4 , U ]+ , (A.12) where [X, Y ]+ = X Y + Y X denotes the anti-commutator. For the condition U ([−2, 2])2 ∈ A({0}c ) to be satisfied, W1 = W2 = W3 = 0 is necessary and sufficient because 1, a0 , a0∗ , and a0∗ a0 are linearly independent basis of A(0). We obtain our conclusion d1 = d2 = d3 = d4 = 0 already from W3 = 0 alone as follows. By substituting Di and Di , i = 1, 2, 3, 4, we find out that the first term of W3 is d1 d2 + d3 d4 while the second term vanishes (the latter due to D1 = D2 and D3 = D4 ). By substituting U we obtain W3 = (d1 d2 + d3 d4 + d1 c2 + d2 c1 + d3 c2 + d4 c1 ) ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ − d12 a−2 a−1 − d1 d2 a−2 a−1 + d2 d1 a−2 a−1 + d22 a−2 a−1 ∗ ∗ + (d1 d4 + d2 d3 )a−2 a−2 + (d3 d2 + d4 d1 )a2 a2 + d32 a1 a2 + d3 d4 a1 a2∗ − d4 d3 a1∗ a2 − d42 a1∗ a2∗ .
(A.13)
Since all terms are linearly independent, W3 = 0 implies vanishing of all coefficients. In particular, d12 = d22 = d32 = d42 = 0,
(A.14)
which implies vanishing of d1 , d2 , d3 , and d4 . Acknowledgements. This is a result of work carried out during the author’s stays at the Erwin Schrödinger International Institute for Mathematical Physics, Wien in February and March, 2005 and at Institut für Theoretische Physik, ETH, Zürich in April and May, 2006. The author would like to acknowledge the financial support and stimulating atmosphere of both Institutes.
Super-Derivations and Associated Standard Super-Potentials
285
References 1. Araki, H.: Conditional expectations relative to a product state and the corresponding standard potentials. Commun. Math. Phys. 246, 113–132 (2004) 2. Araki, H.: Standard potentials for non-even dynamics. Commun. Math. Phys. 262, 161–176 (2006) 3. Araki, H., Moriya, H.: Equilibrium statistical mechanics of Fermion lattice systems. Rev. Math. Phys. 15, 93–198 (2003) 4. Jaffe, A., Lesniewski, A., Osterwalder, K.: Quantum K-theory. Commun. Math. Phys. 118, 1–14 (1988) 5. Jaffe, A., Lesniewski, A., Osterwalder, K.: On super-KMS functionals and entire cyclic cohomology. K-Theory, 2, 675–682 (1989) 6. Jaffe, A., Lesniewski, A., Wisniowski, M.: Deformation of super-KMS functionals. Commun. Math. Phys. 121, 527–540 (1989) 7. Kishimoto, A., Nakamura, H.: Super-derivations. Commun. Math. Phys. 159, 15–27 (1994) 8. Sakai, S.: On one-parameter subgrouops of *-automorphisms on operator algebras and the corresponding unbounded derivations. Amer. J. Math. 98, 427–440 (1976) Communicated by Y. Kawahigashi
Commun. Math. Phys. 276, 287–314 (2007) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-007-0336-x
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Tanaka Theorem for Inelastic Maxwell Models F. Bolley1, , J. A. Carrillo2 1 Institut de Mathématiques, Université Paul Sabatier, F-31062 Toulouse Cedex 9, France 2 ICREA (Institució Catalana de Recerca i Estudis Avançats) and Departament de Matemàtiques,
Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona, E-08193 Bellaterra, Spain. E-mail: [email protected] Received: 9 April 2006 / Accepted: 20 March 2007 Published online: 21 September 2007 – © Springer-Verlag 2007
Abstract: We show that the Euclidean Wasserstein distance is contractive for inelastic homogeneous Boltzmann kinetic equations in the Maxwellian approximation and its associated Kac-like caricature. This property is as a generalization of the Tanaka theorem to inelastic interactions. Even in the elastic classical Boltzmann equation, we give a simpler proof of the Tanaka theorem than the ones in [29, 31]. Consequences are drawn on the asymptotic behavior of solutions in terms only of the Euclidean Wasserstein distance. 1. Introduction This work is devoted to contraction and asymptotic properties of the homogeneous Boltzmann-type equations for inelastic interactions in the Maxwellian approximation introduced in [5] and further analyzed in [16, 6, 7, 10, 1, 11, 2, 8]. We are basically concerned with the Boltzmann equation ∂f = B θ ( f (t)) Q( f, f ) (1.1) ∂t considered in [5] and its variants. Here, f (t, v) is the density for the velocity v ∈ R3 distribution of the molecules at time t, and Q( f, f ) is the inelastic Boltzmann collision operator defined by 1 (ϕ, Q( f, f )) = f (v) f (w) ϕ(v ) − ϕ(v) dσ dv dw (1.2) 4π R3 R3 S 2 for any test function ϕ, where v =
1−e 1+e 1 (v + w) + (v − w) + |v − w|σ 2 4 4
Current address: Université Paris Dauphine, Ceremade, Place du Maréchal de Lattre de Tassigny, F-75775 Paris Cedex 16, France. E-mail: [email protected]
288
F. Bolley, J. A. Carrillo
is the postcollisional velocity, σ ∈ S 2 , v, w ∈ R3 and 0 < e ≤ 1 is the constant restitution coefficient. Equation (1.1) preserves mass and momentum, but makes the kinetic energy (or temperature) 2 1 θ ( f (t)) = v f (t, v) dv f (t, v) dv v − 3 R3 R3 decrease towards 0. In particular, solutions to (1.1) tend to the Dirac mass at the mean velocity of the particles [5]. We refer to [5, 7, 32] for the discussion about the relation of this model to the inelastic hard-sphere Boltzmann equation and different ways of writing √ the operator. Let us just point out that the factor B θ ( f (t)) in front of the operator in (1.1) is chosen for having the same temperature decay law as its hard-sphere counterpart [5] known as Haff’s law. The convergence towards the monokinetic distribution has been made more precise in [7, 10, 2] by means of homogeneous cooling states. They are self-similar solutions of the homogeneous Boltzmann equation (1.1) describing the long-time asymptotics and presenting power-like tail behavior whose relevance was previously discussed in the physics literature [19, 20]. To avoid the collapse of the solution to the Dirac mass, the authors in [16] suggested the introduction of a stochastic thermostat which, at the kinetic level, is modelled by a linear diffusion term in velocity. In this framework, the density f in the velocity space obeys ∂f = B θ ( f (t)) Q( f, f ) + A θ p ( f (t)) v f ∂t
with
0≤ p<
3 · 2
(1.3)
Existence and uniqueness for given mean velocity of a steady state to (1.3) have been shown in [18, 6, 1]. The convergence of solutions towards this steady state in all Sobolev norms has also been investigated and quantified by means of Fourier-based distances between probability measures [1]. Fourier techniques are a good toolbox and have been extremely fruitful for studying Maxwellian models in kinetic theory since Bobylev observed [3, 4] that such equations have closed forms in Fourier variables. Fourier distances are not only suitable technical tools to study the long-time asymptotics of models (1.1) and (1.3), but also they represent the first Liapunov functionals known for inelastic Boltzmann-type equations [1, 2]. In the case of the classical elastic Boltzmann equation for Maxwellian molecules, there is another known Liapunov functional, namely, the Tanaka functional [29], apart from the H -functional for which no counterpart is known in inelastic models. See also [12] for a discussion of Liapunov functionals for the classical Boltzmann equation and another proof of the Tanaka functional in the elastic case. The Tanaka functional is the Euclidean (or quadratic) Wasserstein distance between measures in the modern jargon of optimal mass transport theory. It is defined on the set P2 (R3 ) of Borel probability measures on R3 with finite second moment or kinetic energy as 1/2
1/2 2 W2 ( f, g) = inf |v − w| dπ(v, w) = inf E |V − W |2 , π
R 3 ×R 3
(V,W )
where π runs over the set of joint probability measures on R3 ×R3 with marginals f and g and (V, W ) are all possible couples of random variables with f and g as respective laws. This functional was proven by Tanaka [29] to be non-increasing for the flow of
Tanaka Theorem for Inelastic Maxwell Models
289
the homogeneous Boltzmann equation in the Maxwellian case, see also [12] for a simplified proof. In fact, the Tanaka functional and Fourier-based distances are related to each other [21, 15, 30], and were used to study the trend to equilibrium for Maxwellian gases. On the other hand, related simplified granular models [17] have been shown to be strict contractions for the Wasserstein distance W2 . Other applications of Wasserstein distances to granular models have been shown in [14, 23]. With this situation, a natural question arose as an open problem in [2, Remark 3.3] and [32, Sect. 2.8]: is the Euclidean Wasserstein distance a contraction for the flow of inelastic Maxwell models? The main results of this work answer this question affirmatively. Moreover, we shall not need to introduce Bobylev’s Fourier representation of the inelastic Maxwell models working only in the physical space. We shall show in Sect. 3 the key idea behind the proof of all results concerning contractions in W2 distance for inelastic Maxwell models, namely, the gain part Q + ( f, f ) of the collision operator verifies 3 + e2 W2 (Q + ( f, f ), Q + (g, g)) ≤ W2 ( f, g) 4 for any f, g in P2 (R3 ) with equal mean velocity and any restitution coefficient 0 < e ≤ 1. Based on this property, we shall derive contraction and asymptotic properties both for (1.1) and (1.3) in Subsects. 4.1 and 4.3; for instance we shall prove that the flow for the diffusive equation (1.3) is a strict contraction for W2 . Moreover, Subsect. 4.2 is devoted to the self-similar scaled equation associated to (1.1): in particular we shall show that solutions converge in W2 to a corresponding homogeneous cooling state, without rate but only assuming that initial data have bounded second moment. More precisely, in original variables, let f (t) be a solution to (1.1) with initial datum in P2 (R3 ) with zero mean velocity. If g∞ is the unique stationary solution of the scaled problem with zero mean velocity and unit temperature, and 3
1
f hc (v, t) = θ − 2 ( f (t)) g∞ (v θ − 2 ( f (t))) is the corresponding homogeneous cooling state, then we prove that lim θ ( f (t))−1/2 W2 ( f (t), f hc (t)) = 0.
t→∞
This improves the Ernst-Brito conjecture [19, 20, 7, 10, 2] since it shows that the basin of attraction of the homogeneous cooling state is larger - on f 0 we require bounded moments of order 2 only and not 2 + ε as in previous works - if we do not ask for a rate better than the one dictated by Haff’s cooling law. Moreover, a generalization for non-constant cross sections, including Tanaka’s theorem as a particular case, will be proven in Subsect. 4.4. Finally, we shall also show this generic property for the inelastic Kac model introduced in [27] as a dissipative version of Kac’s caricature of Maxwellian gases [22, 24]. 2. Basic Properties of the Distance W2 and Inelastic Maxwell Models We start by summarizing the main properties of the Euclidean Wasserstein distance W2 that we shall make use of in the rest, referring to [13, 31] for the proofs.
290
F. Bolley, J. A. Carrillo
Proposition 1. The space (P2 (R3 ), W2 ) is a complete metric space. Moreover, the following properties of the distance W2 hold: i) Convergence of measures: Given { f n }n≥1 and f in P2 (R3 ), the following three assertions are equivalent: a) W2 ( f n , f ) tends to 0 as n goes to infinity. b) f n tends to f weakly-* as measures as n goes to infinity and sup |v|2 f n (v) dv → 0 as R → +∞. n≥1 |v|>R
c)
f n tends to f weakly-* as measures and 2 |v| f n (v) dv → |v|2 f (v) dv as n → +∞. R3
R3
ii) Relation to Temperature: If f belongs to P2 (R3 ) and δa is the Dirac mass at a in R3 , then |v − a|2 d f (v). W22 ( f, δa ) = R3
iii) Scaling: Given f in P2 (R3 ) and θ > 0, let us define Sθ [ f ] = θ 3/2 f (θ 1/2 v) for absolutely continuous measures with respect to Lebesgue measure or its corresponding definition by duality for general measures; then for any f and g in P2 (R3 ), we have W2 (Sθ [ f ], Sθ [g]) = θ −1/2 W2 ( f, g). iv) Convexity: Given f 1 , f 2 , g1 and g2 in P2 (R3 ) and α in [0, 1], then W22 (α f 1 + (1 − α) f 2 , αg1 + (1 − α)g2 ) ≤ αW22 ( f 1 , g1 ) + (1 − α)W22 ( f 2 , g2 ). As a simple consequence, given f, g and h in P2 (R3 ), then W2 (h ∗ f, h ∗ g) ≤ W2 ( f, g), where ∗ stands for the convolution in R3 . Here the convolution of the two measures h and f is defined by duality by ϕ(x + y) dh(x) d f (y) (ϕ, h ∗ f ) = R 3 ×R 3
for any test function ϕ on R3 . If f is a Borel probability measure on R3 we shall let v d f (v) = v f (v) dv < f >= R3
R3
denote its mean velocity. We shall use the same notation for densities and measures expecting that the reader will not get confused. It is also interesting to note the following control of averages implied by W2 . As a consequence, the convergence with rate in W2 implies the convergence with rate for all these averages.
Tanaka Theorem for Inelastic Maxwell Models
291
Proposition 2. Given a Lipschitz map ϕ on R3 with Lipschitz constant L, then we have
R
ϕ(v)( f (v) − g(v)) dv ≤ L W2 ( f, g). 3
Proof. Let π be a joint measure on R3 × R3 with marginals f and g. Then
R3
ϕ(v)( f (v) − g(v)) dv =
R 3 ×R 3
(ϕ(v) − ϕ(w)) dπ(v, w).
Using that ϕ is Lipschitz with constant L and estimating by Hölder’s inequality, we get
R3
ϕ(v)( f (v) − g(v)) dv ≤
R 3 ×R 3
|ϕ(v) − ϕ(w)| dπ(v, w)
≤L
R 3 ×R 3
|v − w| dπ(v, w)
≤L
1/2 |v − w| dπ(v, w) 2
R 3 ×R 3
Minimizing over π concludes the argument.
.
Now, let us start by revising the main asymptotic properties of the solutions of (1.1). First of all the mean velocity of the solution is preserved, i.e.,
R3
v f (t, v) dv =
R3
v f 0 (v) dv = U
if f 0 in P2 (R3 ) is the initial datum. By the translational invariance we may assume without loss of generality that U = 0. Then the evolution of the temperature for all solutions of (1.1) is given by Haff’s law of cooling: 1 − e2 dθ ( f (t)) = − B θ ( f (t))3/2 , dt 4
(2.1)
as proven in [5]. Solving explicitly the ODE (2.1) and using the second property in Proposition 1 ensure the following convergence result towards the Dirac mass at 0: Corollary 1. Given a solution f (t, v) to (1.1) with zero mean velocity and initial kinetic energy θ0 corresponding to an initial datum in P2 (R3 ), then W22 ( f (t), δ0 ) =
1−e2 4
12θ0 2 . √ B θ0 t + 2
(2.2)
By Proposition 2, this implies the convergence as t −1 for the averages with Lipschitz functions. More generally it shows the convergence towards total cooling in infinite time. Then, the question is how this cooling is done and what is the typical cooling profile
292
F. Bolley, J. A. Carrillo
for Eq. (1.1). In [19, 20] the existence of a self-similar solution with power-like tails was conjectured (first part of the Ernst-Brito conjecture) which should be asymptotically stable for a large class of initial data (second part of the Ernst-Brito conjecture). The first part of the Ernst-Brito conjecture was answered in [7]: they proved the existence and uniqueness with given initial temperature of self-similar solutions, called homogeneous cooling states (HCS), of the form 3
1
f hc (v, t) = θ − 2 (t) g∞ (θ − 2 (t) v), where g∞ is a solution to ∇ · (g v) = E Q(g, g) with E = 8/(1 − e2 ) and θ (t) is any solution to the evolution (2.1) of the temperature. The results were actually stated in Fourier variables but they can be rewritten in this way. Later, the convergence towards these HCS was obtained in [10, 2]: solutions of the self-similar scaled equation ∂g + ∇ · (g v) = E Q(g, g) ∂τ converge exponentially fast towards the stationary solution g∞ under the assumption that the initial datum has bounded moments of order 2 + ε. Let us remark that in those results the speed of convergence goes to 0 as ε → 0. Also, let us point out that the convergence towards HCS eventually gives the information we are looking for: as times goes on, the solutions to (1.1) cool down towards the Dirac mass at 0 with the corresponding profile f hc (v, t). To conclude this introduction to the Inelastic Maxwell Models, we should mention that more general models allowing non-constant differential cross sections can be considered, as in [8]. Although these models can be written in any dimension, we will stick to the 3-dimensional setting for physical reasons. In any case, the results will generalize equally well to those cases. The operator Q b with variable differential cross section b is defined by
1 v−w (ϕ, Q b ( f, f )) = · σ dσ dv dw, f (v) f (w) [ϕ(v )−ϕ(v)] b 4π R3 R3 S 2 |v − w| (2.3) where again the post-collisional velocity v is given by v =
1−e 1+e 1 (v + w) + (v − w) + |v − w| σ, 2 4 4
and the cross section b satisfies the normalized cut-off assumption 2π π b(k · σ ) dσ = b(cos θ ) sin θ dθ dφ = 1 S2
0
(2.4)
0
for any k in S 2 . 3. Contraction in W2 of the Gain Operators The plan of this section is to obtain contraction properties in the Euclidean Wasserstein distance W2 of the gain operators Q + and Q +b respectively associated to Q and Q b . Since it will be important for later discussions to clarify the cases of equality, and in order to divide difficulties in the proof, we start by deriving this contraction estimate in the case
Tanaka Theorem for Inelastic Maxwell Models
293
of a constant differential cross section Q + ; then we rather quickly generalize the result to general differential cross sections b with the cut-off assumption (2.4). 3.1. Contraction for Q + . Let us write the collision operator Q given in (1.3) as
where Q + ( f, f ) is defined by (ϕ, Q + ( f, f )) =
Q( f, f ) = Q + ( f, f ) − f,
(3.1)
1 f (v) f (w) ϕ(v ) dσ dv dw 4π R3 R3 S 2
(3.2)
for any test function ϕ, where we recall that v =
1−e 1+e 1 (v + w) + (v − w) + |v − w|σ. 2 4 4
In this section we derive a contraction property in W2 distance of the gain operator Q + . For that purpose, let us note that the previous definition of the gain operator can be regarded as follows: given a probability measure f on R3 , the probability measure Q + ( f, f ) is defined by + (ϕ, Q ( f, f )) = f (v) f (w) (ϕ, v,w ) dv dw, R3 R3
where v,w is the uniform probability distribution on the sphere Sv,w with center cv,w =
1−e 1 (v + w) + (v − w) 2 4
and radius rv,w =
1+e |v − w| (Fig. 1). 4
S v,w
v
r v,w σ w
v+w 2
cv,w
Fig. 1. Geometry of inelastic collisions
v
294
F. Bolley, J. A. Carrillo
In probabilistic terms, the gain operator is defined as an expectation: Q + ( f, f ) = E V,W , where V and W are independent random variables with law f . Then the convexity of W22 in Proposition 1 implies W22 (Q + ( f, f ), Q + (g, g)) = W22 E V,W , E X,Y
≤ E W22 ( V,W , X,Y ) ,
(3.3) (3.4)
where X and Y are independent random variables with law g. This observation leads us to consider the W2 distance between uniform distributions on spheres. To this aim, we have the following general lemma: Lemma 1. The squared Wasserstein distance W22 between the uniform distributions on the sphere with center O and radius r and the sphere with center O and radius r in R3 is bounded by |O − O|2 + (r − r )2 . Proof. We define a map T : R3 −→ R3 transporting the sphere of center O and radius r > 0 onto the sphere with center O and radius r ≥ r in the following way: – – –
If r = r , then we just let T be the translation map with vector O − O, i.e., T (v) = v + O − O. If O = O , then we just let T be the dilation with factor rr centered at O, i.e., T (v) = rr v. If r = r , then we consider the only point Ω ∈ R3 verifying that 1 1 (O − Ω) = (O − Ω), r r that is, Ω=O+
r
r (O − O). −r
Then we let T be the dilation with factor rr centered at Ω, that is, we let T (v) = Ω + rr (v − Ω). Such a construction of the point Ω and the map T is sketched in Fig. 2 in the case of non-interior spheres.
r’ r Ω
O
Oí v T(v)
Fig. 2. Sketch of the computation of the Euclidean cost of transporting spheres to spheres. Transport lines are just rays from the point Ω
Tanaka Theorem for Inelastic Maxwell Models
295
Let U O,r and U O ,r denote the uniform distributions on the corresponding spheres. Then the transport plan π given by η(v, w) dπ(v, w) = η(v, T (v)) dU O,r (v) R 3 ×R 3
R3
for all test functions η(v, w) has U O,r and U O ,r as marginals by construction of T . Using this transference plan in the definition of the Euclidean Wasserstein distance, we finally conclude
W22 (U O,r , U O ,r )
r − r ≤ |v − T (v)| dU O,r (v) = r R3
2
2
R3
|v − Ω|2 dU O,r (v)
that can be computed explicitly, giving W22 (U O,r , U O ,r ) ≤ |O − O|2 + (r − r )2 and finishing the proof.
Remark. The map T being the gradient of a convex function, Brenier’s theorem (see Ref. [31] for instance) ensures that the transport plan π defined above is optimal in the sense that the squared distance between the two distributions is = |O − O|2 + (r − r )2 . This lemma, using the notation a = v − x and b = w − y, for fixed values v, w, x, y in R3 , implies that W22 ( v,w , x,y ) ≤ |cv,w − cx,y |2 + |rv,w − r x,y |2
3 − e 1 + e 2 1+e 2 a+ b + ≤ |a − b|2 4 4 4 =
5 − 2e + e2 2 (1 + e)2 2 1 − e2 |a| + |b| + a · b; 8 8 4
here a · b denotes the scalar product between a and b in R3 and the bound in
2 1 + e 2 2 |v − w| − |x − y| |rv,w − r x,y | = 4
2 1 + e 2 1+e 2 (v − w) − (x − y) = ≤ |a − b|2 4 4 follows from the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality (v − w) · (x − y) ≤ |v − w| |x − y|.
(3.5)
Therefore, by (3.3), W22 (Q + ( f, f ), Q + (g, g)) ≤
(1 + e)2
5 − 2e + e2 E |V − X |2 + E |W − Y |2 8 8 1 − e2 + E [(V − X ) · (W − Y )] . 4
296
F. Bolley, J. A. Carrillo
Let moreover (V, X ) and (W, Y ) be two independent optimal couples in the sense that
W22 ( f, g) = E |V − X |2 = E |W − Y |2 . Then 2 E [(V − X ) · (W − Y )] = E [(V − X )] · E [(W − Y )] = < f > − < g > by independence. Collecting all terms leads to the following key estimate and contraction property: Proposition 3. If f and g belong to P2 (R3 ), then W22 (Q + ( f, f ), Q + (g, g)) ≤
2 3 + e2 2 1 − e2 W2 ( f, g) + < f > − 4 4
for any restitution coefficient 0 < e ≤ 1. As a consequence, given f and g in P2 (R3 ) with equal mean velocity, then 3 + e2 W2 (Q + ( f, f ), Q + (g, g)) ≤ W2 ( f, g). 4 The case of equality is addressed in the following statement: Proposition 4. Let f and g belong to P2 (R3 ) with equal mean velocity and temperature, where g is absolutely continuous with respect to Lebesgue measure with positive density. If 3 + e2 + + W2 (Q ( f, f ), Q (g, g)) = W2 ( f, g) 4 for some restitution coefficient 0 < e ≤ 1, then f = g. Proof. It is necessary that the equality holds at each step of the arguments in Proposition 3. In particular, (3.5) holds as an equality, that is, X −Y V −W = |V − W | |X − Y | almost surely in the above notation. Then, since g is absolutely continuous with respect to Lebesgue measure with positive density, one can proceed as in [29, Lemma 9.1] to show that f = g. We sketch the proof for the sake of the reader. Since g is absolutely continuous with respect to Lebesgue measure, there exists [31] a Borel map u : R3 → R3 such that f is the image measure of g by u, and in probabilistic terms V = u(X ) and W = u(Y ) almost surely. Hence u(x) − u(y) x−y = |u(x) − u(y)| |x − y|
(3.6)
Tanaka Theorem for Inelastic Maxwell Models
297
almost everywhere for Lebesgue measure since X and Y are independent and since their law g has positive density. We leave the reader to check [31, Exercise 7.25] that this implies the existence of constants ω1 and ω2 such that u(x) = ω1 + ω2 x. First of all ω22 = 1 since f and g have the same temperature. Then identity (3.6) forces ω2 = 1, implying ω1 = 0 since < f > = < g >, and finally f = g.
3.2. Contraction for Q +b . In this subsection, we consider the more general case of the operator Q b defined in its weak form in (2.3). We define the gain term Q +b by
1 v−w f (v) f (w) ϕ(v ) b · σ dσ dv dw, 4π R3 R3 S 2 |v − w| (3.7) so that again Q b ( f, f ) = Q +b ( f, f ) − f . We shall prove the following extension of Proposition 3 for non-constant cross sections b. (ϕ, Q +b ( f, f )) =
Theorem 1. If f and g in P2 (R3 ) have equal mean velocity, then W22 (Q +b ( f, f ), Q +b (g, g)) ≤
π 3 + e2 1 − e2 + π b(cos θ ) cos θ sin θ dθ W22 ( f, g). 4 2 0
In the elastic case when e = 1, one recovers Tanaka’s non-strict contraction result [29] for the solutions to the homogeneous elastic Boltzmann equation for Maxwellian molecules, at least under the cut-off assumption, but with a somehow simpler argument than those given in [29, 31]. Proof. By definition (ϕ,
Q +b ( f,
π
f )) = 2π
2π
ϕ(v )
dφ f (v) f (w) dv dw b(cos θ ) sin θ dθ 2π
3 3 0 0 π R R = 2π E (ϕ, UV,W,θ ) b(cos θ ) sin θ dθ,
0
where V and W are independent random variables distributed according to f and, given v, w in R3 , Uv,w,θ is the uniform probability measure on the circle Cv,w,θ with center cv,w,θ
1 = (v + w) + 2
1−e 1+e + cos θ (v − w), 4 4
radius rv,w,θ =
1+e |v − w| sin θ 4
and axis k=
v−w (Fig. 3) · |v − w|
298
F. Bolley, J. A. Carrillo
S v,w
θ
w v+w 2
v cv,w, θ
C v,w, θ
Fig. 3. Definition of circles to be transported
Let also g be a Borel probability measure on R3 and X, Y be independent random variables with law g. Then, by the normalization assumption (2.4), the convexity of the squared Wasserstein distance with respect to both arguments ensures that π
2 + + W2 (Q ( f, f ), Q (g, g)) ≤ 2π E W22 (UV,W,θ , U X,Y,θ ) b(cos θ ) sin θ dθ. (3.8) 0
We now let v, w, x, y and θ be fixed in R3 and [0, π ] respectively, and give an upper bound to W22 (Uv,w,θ , Ux,y,θ ). This consists in estimating the transport cost of a circle in R3 onto another one, for which we have the following general bound: Lemma 2. [31] The squared Wasserstein distance between the uniform distributions on the circles with centers c and c , radii r and r and axes k and k is bounded by |c − c |2 + r 2 + r 2 − rr (1 + |k · k |). Hence, using the notations a = v − x, b = w − y, a˜ = v − w and b˜ = x − y in our case we get 2 3 − e 1 + e 1+e 2 W2 (Uv,w,θ , Ux,y,θ ) ≤ + cos θ a + (1 − cos θ ) b 4 4 4
˜ b 1+e 2 2 a ˜ ˜ 2 − |a|| ˜ 1+ · + sin θ |a| ˜ 2 + |b| ˜ b| ˜ 4 |a| ˜ |b| 2 3−e 1+e 1+e 2 2 + cos θ + sin θ |a|2 ≤ 4 4 4
3−e 1+e 2 + cos θ (1 − cos θ ) − sin2 θ a · b +2 4 1+e
2
1+e + (1 − cos θ )2 + sin2 θ |b|2 , (3.9) 4
Tanaka Theorem for Inelastic Maxwell Models
299
where we have used the bound ˜ 2 − |a|| ˜ − a˜ · b˜ ≤ |a| ˜ 2 − 2 a˜ · b˜ = |a˜ − b| ˜ 2 = |a − b|2 . |a| ˜ 2 + |b| ˜ b| ˜ 2 + |b| Assume now that (V, X ) and (W, Y ) are two independent couples of random variables, optimal in the sense that
W22 ( f, g) = E |V − X |2 = E |W − Y |2 . Note that E [(V − X ) · (W − Y )] = E [V − X ] · E [W − Y ] = 0, since (V, X ) and (W, Y ) are independent and since f and g have same mean velocity. Then from (3.9):
E W22 (UV,W,θ , U X,Y,θ ) ≤ γ (θ ) W22 ( f, g), where
γ (θ ) = =
3−e 1+e + cos θ 4 4
2 +
1+e 4
2
(1 − cos θ )2 + 2 sin2 θ
3 + e2 1 − e2 + cos θ. 4 4
One concludes after averaging over θ as in (3.8).
4. Contractive Estimates for Inelastic Maxwell Models In this section, we shall derive contractive estimates in the Euclidean Wasserstein distance for solutions to the inelastic Maxwell models both in the non-diffusive and the diffusive cases and with constant and variable differential cross sections. 4.1. The non-diffusive case I: Original Variables. We are first concerned with solutions f (t) to the Boltzmann equation (1.1) with 0 < e < 1. After time scaling defined by B t τ= θ ( f (w)) dw E 0 with E = to
8 , 1−e2
as in [2], we get a function denoted again f (τ ) for simplicity, solution ∂f = E Q( f, f ). ∂τ
(4.1)
Theorem 2. If f 1 and f 2 are two solutions to (4.1) with respective initial data f 10 and f 20 in P2 (R3 ), then 2 W22 ( f 1 (τ ), f 2 (τ )) ≤ e−2τ W22 ( f 10 , f 20 ) + (1 − e−2τ ) < f 10 > − < f 20 > (4.2) for all τ ≥ 0.
300
F. Bolley, J. A. Carrillo
Proof. Decomposition (3.1) of the collision operator Q as Q( f, f ) = Q + ( f, f ) − f allows us to represent the solutions to (4.1) by Duhamel’s formula as τ e−E(τ −s) Q + ( f i (s), f i (s)) ds, i = 1, 2. f i (τ ) = e−Eτ f i0 + E 0
Then the convexity of the squared Wasserstein distance in Proposition 1 and Proposition 3 imply W22 ( f 1 (τ ), f 2 (τ ))
≤ e−Eτ
τ
e−E(τ −s) W22 Q + ( f 1 (s), f 1 (s)), Q + ( f 2 (s), f 2 (s)) ds 0
τ 3 + e2 2 W2 ( f 1 (s), f 2 (s)) + X ds; W22 ( f 10 , f 20 ) + E e−E(τ −s) 4 0
≤ e−Eτ W22 ( f 10 , f 20 ) + E
here X=
2 1 − e2 < f 1 (s)> − < f 2 (s)> 4
does not depend on time since the mean velocity is preserved by Eq. (4.1). In other words, the function y(τ ) = e Eτ W22 ( f 1 (τ ), f 2 (τ )) satisfies the inequality
τ
y(τ ) ≤ y(0) + E 0
3 + e2 y(s) + X e Es 4
ds
and then y(τ ) ≤ y(0) eγ Eτ +
X (e Eτ − eγ Eτ ) 1−γ
by Gronwall’s lemma with γ = (3 + e2 )/4. This concludes the argument since (1 − γ )E = 2.
Remark 1. 1. Without further assumptions on the initial data f 10 and f 20 , this result is optimal in the following sense. If f 20 is chosen as the Dirac mass at the mean velocity of f 10 , then inequality (4.2) is actually an equality for all τ ; indeed 2 W2 ( f 1 (τ ), f 2 (τ )) = |v − < f 1 (τ )> |2 f 1 (τ, v) dv = 3 θ ( f 1 (τ )) R3
= 3 e−2τ θ ( f 10 ) = e−2 τ W22 ( f 10 , f 20 ), since
dθ = − 2 θ by Eq. (4.1). dτ
Tanaka Theorem for Inelastic Maxwell Models
301
2. In terms of the original time variable t in (1.1), if f 10 and f 20 are two initial data with the same initial temperature θ0 , then the temperatures of the corresponding solutions f 1 and f 2 to (1.1) follow the law 3 dθ 1 − e2 =− Bθ 2 , dt 4
(4.3)
and hence are both equal to
−2 1 − e2 −1/2 θ (t) = θ0 Bt + . 8 Then estimate (4.2) reads as W22 ( f 1 (t), f 2 (t)) ≤
2 θ (t) 2 0 0 θ (t) < f 10 > − < f 20 > W2 ( f 1 , f 2 ) + 1 − θ0 θ0
for all t ≥ 0, and in the particular case of equal mean velocity we can write it as W22 ( f 1 (t), f 2 (t)) ≤
θ (t) 2 0 0 W2 ( f 1 , f 2 ) θ0
(4.4)
that gives the typical decay towards the delta distribution of all solutions.
4.2. The non-diffusive case II: Self-similar variables. The convergence of the solutions to (1.1) towards the Dirac measure at their mean velocity [5] has been made much more precise in [10, 2] by the introduction of self-similar variables and homogeneous cooling states. There the authors prove that the rescaled solutions g defined by g(τ, v) = θ 3/2 ( f (τ )) f (τ, θ 1/2 ( f (τ )) v)
(4.5)
satisfy the strict contraction property d2+ε (g1 (τ ), g2 (τ )) ≤ e−C(ε)τ d2+ε (g10 , g20 ),
C(ε) > 0
for initial data g10 and g20 in P2 (R3 ) with equal mean velocity and pressure tensor, where ε > 0 and d2+ε is a Fourier-based distance between probability measures. Moreover, for ε = 0 one has C(ε) = 0 giving a non-strict contraction in d2 distance. In fact, by the scaling property in Proposition 1, (4.2) reads as W2 (g1 (τ ), g2 (τ )) ≤ W2 (g10 , g20 )
(4.6)
in the scaled variables. This is consistent with the fact that the distances d2 and W22 are “of the same order” [21, 30, 2] up to moment bounds. In itself this non-strict contraction does not give any information about the convergence towards typical cooling profiles of the system. A measure g(τ, v) defined by (4.5) from a solution f (v, τ ) to (4.1) with initial zero mean velocity has zero mean velocity and unit kinetic energy for all τ , and is a solution to ∂g + ∇ · (g v) = E Q(g, g). (4.7) ∂τ
302
F. Bolley, J. A. Carrillo
Moreover, it is proven in [10, 2] that (4.7) has a unique stationary solution g∞ with zero mean velocity and unit kinetic energy; all measure solutions g(τ, v) to (4.7) with zero mean velocity, unit kinetic energy and bounded moment of order 2 + ε converge to this stationary state g∞ as τ goes to infinity in the d2 sense, that is, in the W2 sense since d2 and W2 metrize the same topology on probability measures [30] up to moment conditions. Moreover, the convergence has exponential rate in the d2 sense, and in the W2 sense if the initial datum has finite fourth order moment as proven in [2]. In turn, this ensures existence and uniqueness of homogeneous cooling states to (1.1) for zero mean velocity and given kinetic energy, by going back to original variables, i.e., 3
1
f hc (v, t) = θ − 2 (t) g∞ (v θ − 2 (t)) with θ (t) any solution to the temperature equation (2.1). Moreover, an algebraic convergence of the solutions f (t) with the same initial kinetic energy towards them in the original variables is obtained in [10, 2]. We conclude this section by proving this convergence result using only the W2 distance, and moreover for initial data which have bounded moments of order 2 only and not 2 + ε as above. This in turn shows that the Euclidean Wasserstein distance W2 between solutions of (4.7) converges to zero as t goes to infinity, improving over (4.6) that does not a priori yield any information on the long-time behavior of the solutions g. As a trade of not assuming more than moments of order two, this argument does not provide any rate of convergence as does the Fourier-based argument in [10, 2]. Theorem 3. Let g10 and g20 be two Borel probability measures on R3 with zero mean velocity and unit kinetic energy, and let g1 (τ ) and g2 (τ ) be the solutions to (4.7) with respective initial data g10 and g20 . Then the map τ → W2 (g1 (τ ), g2 (τ )) is non-increasing and tends to 0 as τ goes to infinity. By taking as one solution, in this theorem, the homogeneous cooling state in scaled variables, i.e., the stationary solution g∞ of (4.7), we improve over the stability part of the Ernst-Brito conjecture shown in [10] and re-addressed in [2]. In terms of the original variables, the scaling properties of W2 given in Proposition 1 and the convergence result lim W2 (g(τ ), g∞ ) = 0
τ →∞
have the following direct consequence, which improves over the decay towards the Dirac mass estimate given in (2.2) and (4.4). Corollary 2. Let f 0 ∈ P2 (R3 ) with zero mean velocity and let f (t) be the solution to (1.1) with initial datum f 0 , then lim θ ( f (t))−1/2 W2 ( f (t), f hc (t)) = 0,
t→∞
where the homogeneous cooling state f hc is given by 3
1
f hc (t) = θ − 2 ( f (t)) g∞ (v θ − 2 ( f (t))).
Tanaka Theorem for Inelastic Maxwell Models
303
Proof of Theorem 3. It is based on the argument in [31] to Tanaka’s theorem. The first statement is a simple consequence of (4.6). Then we turn to the second part of the theorem which by the triangular inequality for the W2 distance is enough to prove when g20 , and hence g2 (τ ), is the unique stationary state g∞ to (4.7) with zero mean velocity and unit kinetic energy. Step 1. Let us first assume that the fourth moment of the initial datum is bounded, i.e., |v|4 g10 (v) dv < ∞. R3
The second step will be devoted to avoid this assumption. Then Proposition 6 in the appendix ensures that sup |v|4 g1 (τ, v) dv < ∞, τ ≥0 R3
so that
sup
τ ≥0 |v|>R
|v|2 g1 (τ, v) dv
tends to 0 as R goes to infinity. Prohorov’s compactness theorem and Proposition 1 imply the existence of a sequence τk → ∞ as k → ∞ and a probability measure µ0 on R3 with zero mean velocity and unit kinetic energy such that W2 (g1 (τk ), µ0 ) → 0 as k → ∞. We want to prove that µ0 = g∞ . Without loss of generality, we can assume that the diverging time sequence satisfies τk + 1 ≤ τk+1 for all k. Now, since g∞ is a stationary solution, it follows from the first part of the theorem that W2 (g1 (τk+1 ), g∞ ) ≤ W2 (g1 (τk + 1), g∞ ) ≤ W2 (g1 (τk ), g∞ ).
(4.8)
On one hand, both W2 (g1 (τk ), g∞ ) and W2 (g1 (τk+1 ), g∞ ) tend to W2 (µ0 , g∞ ) as k goes to infinity by triangular inequality. Then, if µ(τ ) denotes the solution to (4.7) with initial datum µ0 , the first point again ensures that W2 (g1 (τk + 1), µ(1)) ≤ W2 (g1 (τk ), µ0 ) which tends to 0. Hence W2 (g1 (τk +1), g∞ ) tends to W2 (µ(1), g∞ ) by triangular inequality, and finally W2 (µ(1), g∞ ) = W2 (µ0 , g∞ ) by passing to the limit in k in (4.8). By the non-increasing character of W2 along the flow, we deduce that W2 (µ(1), g∞ ) = W2 (µ(τ ), g∞ ) = W2 (µ0 , g∞ ) for all τ ∈ [0, 1]. Consequently µ(τ ) and g∞ are two solutions to (4.7) with zero mean velocity and unit temperature, whose W2 distance is constant on the time interval [0, 1]. This is possible only if equality holds at each step in the proof of Theorem 2 in the original space variables; in particular 3 + e2 W2 (µ(τ ), g∞ ) W2 (Q + (µ(τ ), µ(τ )), Q + (g∞ , g∞ )) = 4
304
F. Bolley, J. A. Carrillo
for all τ , and especially for τ = 0. But µ0 and g∞ have the same mean velocity and temperature, and, according to [7, Theorem 5.3], g∞ is absolutely continuous with respect to Lebesgue measure, with positive density. Hence Proposition 4 ensures that µ0 = g∞ . In particular W2 (g1 (τk ), g∞ ) → 0 as k → ∞, and then W2 (g1 (τ ), g∞ ) → 0 as τ → ∞ since it is a non-increasing function. Step 2. Let us now remove the hypothesis on the boundedness of the initial fourth order moment. Let (g 0n )n be a sequence in P2 (R3 ) with zero mean velocity, unit kinetic energy, finite fourth order moment and converging to g10 in the weak sense of probability measures; in particular it converges to g10 in the W2 distance sense by Proposition 1. Such a g 0n can be obtained by successive truncation of g10 to a ball of radius n in R3 , translation to keep the mean property, and dilation centered at 0 to keep the kinetic energy equal to 1. Then, if g n (τ ) is the solution to (4.7) with initial datum g 0n , the triangular inequality for W2 and (4.6) ensure that W2 (g1 (τ ), g∞ ) ≤ W2 (g1 (τ ), g n (τ )) + W2 (g n (τ ), g∞ ) ≤ W2 (g10 , g 0n ) + W2 (g n (τ ), g∞ ). Given ε > 0, the first term in the right hand side is bounded by ε for some n large enough, and for this now fixed n, the second term is bounded by ε for all τ larger than some constant by the first step. This ensures that W2 (g1 (τ ), g∞ ) tends to 0 as τ goes to infinity.
Let us finally point out that a natural question related to the fact that Eq. (4.7) is a strict contraction with respect to d2+ε is whether a Wassertein distance with larger index, for instance W4 , could be strictly contractive for (4.7). Of course, a similar scheme as above can be performed to verify it, but there is one term we cannot control in the transport of spheres argument and we cannot conclude. It is an open problem to prove or disprove this claim, even for a non-strict contraction in the elastic case.
4.3. The diffusive case. We now turn to the diffusive version (1.3) of (1.1). Again by the change of time τ= with E =
B E
t θ ( f (w)) dw 0
8 we are brought to studying the equation 1 − e2 ∂f = E Q( f, f ) + 2 ( f (τ )) v f, ∂τ
where 2 ( f (τ )) =
EA [θ ( f (τ ))] p−1/2 . B
As in the nonviscous case of (4.1) we shall prove
(4.9)
Tanaka Theorem for Inelastic Maxwell Models
305
Theorem 4. If f 1 and f 2 are two solutions to (4.9) for the respective initial data f 10 and f 20 in P2 (R3 ) with same kinetic energy, then 2 W22 ( f 1 (τ ), f 2 (τ )) ≤ e−2τ W22 ( f 10 , f 20 ) + (1 − e−2τ ) < f 10 > − < f 20 > (4.10) for all τ ≥ 0. Proof. We again start by giving a Duhamel’s representation of the solutions. To this aim we write (4.9) as ∂f = E F − E f + 2 ( f (τ )) v f, ∂τ where F = Q + ( f, f ), that is, ∂ fˆ ˆ + E + |k|2 2 ( f (τ )) fˆ = E F. ∂τ Here, we are using the convention µ(k) ˆ =
R3
e−i k·x dµ(x)
for the Fourier transform of the measure µ on R3 . Hence the solutions satisfy τ 2 ˆ k) e−(( f,τ )−( f,s))|k|2 ds, fˆ(τ, k) = e−E τ fˆ0 (k) e−( f,τ ) |k| + E e−E(τ −s) F(s, where ( f, τ ) =
0 τ
2 ( f (s)) ds, and thus
0
τ f (τ, v) = e−E τ ( f 0 ∗ 2( f,τ ) )(v) + E e−E(τ −s) (F(s) ∗ 2(( f,τ )−( f,s)) )(v) ds 0 τ ˜ s, v) ds. := e−E τ f˜(τ, v) + E e−E(τ −s) F(τ, 0
Here α (v) =
1 2 e−|v| /2α (2π α)3/2
is the centered Maxwellian with temperature α/3 > 0. Moreover f 1 and f 2 have the same temperature at all times, so that ( f 1 , τ ) = ( f 2 , τ ). Then the convexity of the squared Wasserstein distance and its non-increasing character by convolution with a given measure, see Proposition 1, imply that τ W22 ( f 1 (τ ), f 2 (τ )) ≤ e−Eτ W22 ( f˜1 (τ ), f˜2 (τ ))+ E e−E(τ −s) W22 ( F˜1 (τ, s), F˜2 (τ, s))ds τ 0 −Eτ 2 0 0 ≤e W2 ( f 1 , f 2 ) + E e−E(τ −s) W22 (F1 (s), F2 (s)) ds. 0
In other words the squared distance W22 ( f 1 (τ ), f 2 (τ )) satisfies the same bound as in the nonviscous case of Theorem 2, and we can conclude analogously.
306
F. Bolley, J. A. Carrillo
Remark 2. 1. As pointed out to us by C. Villani the result can also be obtained by a splitting argument between the collision term and the diffusion term. 2. As proven in [1], the temperature θ ( f (t)) of the solution f in the original time variable t converges towards
θ∞ =
8A B(1 − e2 )
2 3−2 p
as t goes to infinity, and satisfies θ ( f (t)) ≥ min(θ ( f (0)), θ∞ ). In particular B t C1 t τ= θ ( f (s)) ds ≥ E 0 E if C1 = B min(θ ( f (0)), θ∞ )1/2 . Writing (4.10) in the original variable t for initial data with equal mean velocity and temperature, we recover the contraction property W2 ( f 1 (t), f 2 (t)) ≤ W2 ( f 10 , f 20 ) e−(1−γ )C1 t , that coincides with (3.1) in [1] for the Fourier-based d2 distance exactly with the same rate. For p = 1 one can exactly compute τ and also recover (3.2) in [1] but for the distance W2 . 3. The existence of unique diffusive equilibria for each given value of the initial mean velocity can be obtained from this contraction property of the W2 distance analogously to the arguments done in [1] with the Fourier-based distance d2 . 4.4. General cross section. Let f 1 = f 1 (τ, v) and f 2 = f 2 (τ, v) be two solutions to the Boltzmann equation ∂f = Q b ( f, f ) = Q +b ( f, f ) − f ∂τ with respective initial data f 10 and f 20 in P2 (R3 ), where Q +b is defined in (3.7). Then, as in Subsect. 4.1, Duhamel’s representation formula τ f (τ ) = e−τ f 0 + e−(τ −s) Q + ( f (s), f (s)) ds 0
of the solutions and the convexity of W22 ensure the contraction property W2 ( f 1 (τ ), f 2 (τ )) ≤ e−(1−γb )τ/2 W2 ( f 10 , f 20 ) for all τ , where 3 + e2 1 − e2 + π γb = 4 2 is bounded by 1 by (2.4).
π 0
b(cos θ ) cos θ sin θ dθ
(4.11)
Tanaka Theorem for Inelastic Maxwell Models
307
5. Inelastic Kac Model In this last section we consider a simple one-dimensional model introduced in [27] which can be seen as a dissipative version of the Kac caricature of a Maxwellian gas [22, 24]. Let us remark that the definition and properties of the Euclidean Wasserstein distance W2 discussed above generalize equally well to any dimension. Tanaka himself [28] showed that the Euclidean Wasserstein distance is a non strict contraction for the elastic classical Kac model. In the inelastic Kac model, the evolution of the density function f is governed by the equation ∂f = Q( f, f ) (5.1) ∂t in which the collision term Q( f, f ) is defined by 2π dθ (ϕ, Q( f, f )) = dv dw f (v) f (w) ϕ(v ) − ϕ(v) 2π R R 0 for any test function ϕ, where v = v cos θ | cos θ | p − w sin θ | sin θ | p is the postcollisional velocity and p > 0 measures the inelasticity. Equation (5.1) preserves mass but makes the momentum and kinetic energy decrease to 0 at an exponential rate, θ ( f (t)) = e−2βt θ ( f 0 ) + (e−2βt − e−2t ) < f 0> with β > 0 given below. In particular, solutions to (5.1) tend to the Dirac mass at 0. The asymptotic behavior of the inelastic Kac model was analyzed in [27] by means of Fourier-based distances in interesting cases where the initial data has infinite kinetic energy, i.e., for Fourier distances ds with index 1 < s < 2. The existence of self-similar solutions with only moments of order 1 is obtained, characterizing long time asymptotics of the scaled solutions for solutions with a certain number of moments bounded. Here, we show that for finite kinetic energy solutions the distance W2 verifies a strict contraction property. This property may be used in particular cases of the Kac equation with self-similar solutions of finite kinetic energy to discuss its stability in the spirit of Theorem 3. As in the inelastic Maxwell model discussed above, we start by deriving a contraction property for the gain operator Q + defined by 2π dθ dv dw. (ϕ, Q + ( f, f )) = f (v) f (w) ϕ(v ) 2π R R 0 Proposition 5. If f and g belong to P2 (R), then 2π dθ W22 ( f, g). | cos θ |2( p+1) + | sin θ |2( p+1) W22 (Q + ( f, f ), Q + (g, g)) ≤ 2π 0 In terms of solutions f (t) and g(t) to the modified Kac equation (5.1) with finite initial energy only, the above proposition yields, as in previous sections, the bound W2 ( f (t), g(t)) ≤ e−βt W2 ( f 0 , g 0 ), where
2β = 1− 0
2π
dθ > 0. | cos θ |2( p+1) + | sin θ |2( p+1) 2π
This bound is optimal without further assumptions on the initial data f 0 and g 0 since equality holds in the case when < f 0 > = 0 and g 0 = δ0 analogously to previous cases.
308
F. Bolley, J. A. Carrillo
Proof. Given a vector (v, w) in R2 , let Cv,w denote the curve {(v (θ ), w (θ )), θ ∈ [0, 2 π ]}, where
v (θ ) = v cos θ | cos θ | p − w sin θ | sin θ | p , w (θ ) = v sin θ | sin θ | p + w cos θ | cos θ | p .
(5.2)
Let also Uv,w be the uniform probability distribution on Cv,w . Given V and W two independent random variables distributed according to f , we note that Q + ( f, f ) is the first marginal on R of E UV,W , but also its second marginal by symmetry. Then, we have the following result, which is analogous to Lemmas 1 and 2 for this model: Lemma 3. Given two vectors (v, w) and (x, y) in R2 , the squared Wasserstein distance between the distributions Uv,w and Ux,y is bounded by (1 − 2β) |v − x|2 + |w − y|2 . Proof. One can transport the curve Cv,w onto Cx,y by the linear map (a, b) → T (a, b) =
r (a cos ω − b sin ω, a sin ω + b cos ω), r
√ where r = v 2 + w 2 , r = x 2 + y 2 and ω is the angle between the vectors (v, w) and (x, y) in case they do not vanish. We leave it to the reader to discuss the case when either (x, y) or (v, w) are zero. Then, analogously to the proof of Lemma 1, one can define a transport plan associated to the transport map T to get 2 W2 (Uv,w , Ux,y ) ≤ |T (a, b) − (a, b)|2 dUv,w (a, b). R2
Furthermore, for all (a, b) in R2 , r 2 r 2 |T (a, b) − (a, b)|2 = (a cos ω − b sin ω) − a + (a sin ω + b cos ω) − b r r r 2 r = − 2 cos ω + 1 a 2 + b2 r r 2 |v − x| + |w − y|2 2 2 = a . + b v 2 + w2 Hence, we deduce |v − x|2 + |w − y|2 (a 2 + b2 ) dUv,w (a, b) 2 v 2 + w2 R |v − x|2 + |w − y|2 2π 2 dθ = (v (θ ) + w (θ )2 ) · v 2 + w2 2π 0
W22 (Uv,w , Ux,y ) ≤
But
v (θ )2 + w (θ )2 = | cos θ |2( p+1) + | sin θ |2( p+1) (v 2 + w 2 )
Tanaka Theorem for Inelastic Maxwell Models
309
by (5.2), so that W22 (Uv,w , Ux,y )
≤ 0
2π
2( p+1) 2( p+1) dθ |v − x|2 + |w − y|2 | cos θ | + | sin θ | 2π
which is the bound given by the lemma.
We now continue the proof of Proposition 5. First of all, let (V, X ) and (W, Y ) be two independent couples of random variables, with V and X distributed according to f , W and Y according to g, optimal in the sense that
W22 ( f, g) = E |V − W |2 = E |X − Y |2 . Then, by convexity of the squared Wasserstein distance again, it follows from Lemma 3 that
W22 E UV,W , E U X,Y ≤ E W22 (UV,W , U X,Y )
≤ (1 − 2β) E |V − W |2 + E |X − Y |2 = 2 (1 − 2β) W22 ( f, g).
(5.3)
Next, we remark that the measure UV,W on R2 has first and second marginals equal by symmetry of thecurve CV,W by a π/2 rotation. This implies that the first and second of E UV,W on R2 are equal to Q + ( f, f ), and likewise for the measure marginals E U X,Y with marginals Q + (g, g). We shall conclude the argument of Proposition 5 by using the following general result: Lemma 4. If the Borel probability measures µij on R are the successive one-dimensional marginals of the measure µi on R N , for i = 1, 2 and j = 1, . . . , N , then N
W22 (µ1j , µ2j ) ≤ W22 (µ1 , µ2 ).
j=1 N with marginals µ1 and µ2 . Then its Proof. Let π be any joint measure on RvN × Rw marginal π j on Rv j × Rw j has itself marginals µ1j and µ2j , so 2 1 2 W2 (µ j , µ j ) ≤ |v j − w j |2 dπ j (v j , w j ).
The identity
R ×R
N
j=1 |v j N j=1
− w j |2 = |v − w|2 implies the bound
W22 (µ1j , µ2j ) ≤
R N ×R N
|v − w|2 dπ(v, w).
One concludes the argument by minimizing over π .
In our particular case, Lemma 4 ensures that
2 W22 (Q + ( f, f ), Q + (g, g)) ≤ W22 E UV,W , E U X,Y ,
which concludes the proof of Proposition 5 taking (5.3) into account.
310
F. Bolley, J. A. Carrillo
Appendix: Uniform in Time Propagation of Fourth Order Moments In this appendix we derive a uniform propagation of fourth order moments |v|4 g(τ, v)dv of solutions g to R3
∂g + ∇ · (g v) = E Q(g, g), ∂τ
(5.4)
where the operator Q(g, g) is defined as in (1.2) for 0 < e < 1 and E = This result has been used in the proof of Theorem 3.
8 · 1 − e2
Proposition 6. If g 0 is a Borel probability measure on R3 such that |v|4 g 0 (v) dv < ∞, R3
then the solution g to (5.4) with initial datum g 0 verifies |v|4 g(τ, v) dv < ∞. sup τ ≥0 R3
Proof. Without loss of generality we can assume that g 0 , and hence g(τ ) for all τ ≥ 0, has zero mean velocity. We let m 4 (τ ) = |v|4 g(τ, v) dv R3
denote the fourth order moment of g(τ ). Then, using the weak formulation of the inelastic Boltzmann equation, we have: dm 4 (τ ) 4 = ∇(|v| ) · v g(τ, v) dv + E |v|4 Q(g(τ ), g(τ ))(v) dv. (5.5) dτ R3 R3 While the first term on the right-hand side is simply 4 m 4 (τ ), the second term is computed by Lemma 5. There exist some constants µ1 and µ2 , depending only on e, such that R3
|v|4 Q(g, g)(v) dv = − λ + µ2
R
3
|v|4 g(v) dv + µ1
R 3 ×R 3
2
R3
|v|2 g(v) dv
(v · w)2 g(v) g(w) dv dw
for any probability measure g on R3 with finite moment of order 4 and zero mean velocity, where λ=
1 (1 + 4ε − 7ε2 + 4ε3 − 2ε4 ) 3
and
ε=
1−e · 2
Tanaka Theorem for Inelastic Maxwell Models
311
With this lemma in hand, (5.5) reads dm 4 (τ ) = (4 − E λ) m 4 (τ ) + m(τ ), dτ
(5.6)
where m(τ ) is a combination of second order moments, which are bounded in time since the kinetic energy is preserved by Eq. (5.4). Moreover one can check from the expression of E and λ in terms of ε = (1 − e)/2 that 4 − Eλ =
2 [−1 + 2ε + ε2 − 4ε3 + 2ε4 ] 3ε(1 − ε)
which is negative for any 0 < ε < 1/2, that is, for any 0 < e < 1. By Gronwall’s lemma this ensures that m 4 (τ ) is bounded uniformly in time if initially finite, and concludes the argument to Proposition 6.
Let us remark that identity (5.6) is also useful to understand that moments are not created by this equation in contrast to the hard-spheres case [25, 26]. In fact, if initially moments are infinite, they will remain so. Thus, this is another reason why homogeneous cooling states have only a certain number of moments bounded, see [7]. We now turn to the proof of Lemma 5, whose result is given in [5] and [6, Sect. 4] only in the radial isotropic case, i.e., whenever g(v) depends only on |v|. By symmetry we start by writing 1 4 |v| Q(g, g)(v) dv = g(v)g(w) 4π R3 R3 S 2 R3 1 × [|v |4 + |w |4 − |v|4 − |w|4 ] dσ dv dw, 2 where 1−e 1+e 1 (v + w) + (v − w) + |v − w|σ, 2 4 4 1−e 1+e 1 w = (v + w) − (v − w) − |v − w|σ. 2 4 4 v =
Then we introduce the notation u=
v+w v−w 1−e 1+e , U= , ε= , ε = 1 − ε = 2 2 2 2
in which v = u + ε U + ε |U | σ, v = u − ε U − ε |U | σ, v = u + U, w = u − U. Then |v |2 |w |2 |v|2 |w|2
= |u|2 + (ε2 + ε2 )|U |2 + 2 ε ε |U | (U · σ ) + 2 ε (u · U ) + 2 ε |U | (u · σ ), = |u|2 + (ε2 + ε2 )|U |2 + 2 ε ε |U |(U · σ ) − 2 ε (u · U ) − 2 ε |U | (u · σ ), = |u|2 + |U |2 + 2 (u · U ), = |u|2 + |U |2 − 2 (u · U ),
312
F. Bolley, J. A. Carrillo
and eventually 1 4 [|v | + |w |4 − |v|4 − |w|4 ] 2
= (ε2 + ε2 )2 − 1 |U |4 + 2(ε2 + ε2 − 1)|u|2 |U |2 + 4(ε2 − 1)(u · U )2 + 4 ε2 ε2 |U |2 (U · σ )2 + 4 ε2 |U |2 (u · σ )2
+ 4 ε ε |U | |u|2 + (ε2 + ε2 )|U |2 (U · σ ) + 8 ε ε |U | (u · U ) (u · σ ).
Integrating with respect to σ in S 2 and taking the identities dσ dσ dσ |k|2 1 (k · σ ) (k · σ )2 = 1, = 0, = 4π 4π 3 S 2 4π S2 S2 into account, we obtain 1 4 dσ [|v | + |w |4 − |v|4 − |w|4 ] = α |U |4 + β |u|2 |U |2 + γ (u · U )2 , 2 2 4π S where
4 2 α = (ε2 + ε2 )2 − 1 + ε2 ε2 , β = 2 ε2 + ε2 − 1 + ε2 , γ = 4(ε2 − 1). 3 3 Then, by definition of u and U in terms of v and w, the identities
1 m 4 + m 22 + 2 m 22 , |U |4 g(v) g(w) dv dw = 8 R 3 ×R 3
1 m 4 + m 22 − 2 m 22 |u|2 |U |2 g(v) g(w) dv dw = 8 R 3 ×R 3
and
R 3 ×R 3
hold with
(u · U )2 g(v) g(w) dv dw =
m4 = m 22 =
1 [m 4 − m 22 ] 8
3 R
|v|4 g(v) dv, m 2 =
R 3 ×R 3
R3
|v|2 g(v) dv,
(v · w)2 g(v) g(w) dv dw,
since g has zero mean velocity. Collecting all terms, we obtain |v|4 Q(g, g)(v) dv = −λ m 4 + µ1 m 22 + µ2 m 22 , R3
where 1 1 λ = − (α + β + γ ) = (1 + 4 ε − 7 ε2 + 4 ε3 − 2 ε4 ), 8 3 1 1 µ1 = (α + β − γ ) and µ2 = (α − β) 8 4 depend only on ε, that is, only on e. This concludes the proof of Lemma 5.
Tanaka Theorem for Inelastic Maxwell Models
313
Acknowledgements. The authors are grateful to Laurent Desvillettes, Giuseppe Toscani and Cédric Villani for stimulating discussions and fruitful comments. They thank the referees for their relevant comments which helped improve the presentation of the paper. JAC acknowledges the support from DGI-MEC (Spain) project MTM2005-08024 and 2005SGR00611. We acknowledge partial support of the Acc. Integ. program HF20060198.
References 1. Bisi, M., Carrillo, J.A., Toscani, G.: Contractive Metrics for a Boltzmann equation for granular gases: Diffusive equilibria. J. Stat. Phys. 118, 301–331 (2005) 2. Bisi, M., Carrillo, J.A., Toscani, G.: Decay rates in probability metrics towards homogeneous cooling states for the inelastic Maxwell model. J. Stat. Phys. 124, 625–653 (2006) 3. Bobylev, A.V.: The method of the Fourier transform in the theory of the Boltzmann equation for Maxwell molecules. Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR 225, 1041–1044 (1975) 4. Bobylev, A.V.: The theory of the nonlinear spatially uniform Boltzmann equation for Maxwell molecules. Sov. Sci. Rev. C. Math. Phys. 7, 111–233 (1988) 5. Bobylev, A.V., Carrillo, J.A., Gamba, I.: On some properties of kinetic and hydrodynamic equations for inelastic interactions. J. Stat. Phys. 98, 743–773 (2000) 6. Bobylev, A.V., Cercignani, C.: Moment equations for a Granular Material in a Thermal Bath. J. Stat. Phys. 106, 547–567 (2002) 7. Bobylev, A.V., Cercignani, C.: Self-similar asymptotics for the Boltzmann equation with inelastic and elastic interactions. J. Stat. Phys. 110, 333–375 (2003) 8. Bobylev, A.V., Cercignani, C., Gamba, I.M.: Generalized kinetic Maxwell models of granular gases. In: Mathematical models of granular matter, Lecture Notes in Maths. G. Capriz, P. Giovine, P. M. Mariano, eds, Berlin-New York: Springer, 2006 9. Bobylev, A.V., Cercignani, C., Gamba, I.M.: “On the self-similar asymptotics for generalized non-linear kinetic Maxwell models.” submitted for publication (2006), available at http://www.ma. utexas.edu/users/gamba/papers/maxmol.pdf 10. Bobylev, A.V., Cercignani, C., Toscani, G.: Proof of an asymptotic property of self-similar solutions of the Boltzmann equation for granular materials. J. Stat. Phys. 111, 403–417 (2003) 11. Bobylev, A.V., Gamba, I.: Boltzmann equations for mixtures of Maxwell gases: exact solutions and power-like tails. J. Stat. Phys. 124, 497–516 (2006) 12. Bobylev, A.V., Toscani, G.: On the generalization of the Boltzmann H -theorem for a spatially homogeneous Maxwell gas. J. Math. Phys. 33, 2578–2586 (1992) 13. Bolley, F.: “Separability and completeness for the Wasserstein distance”. To appear in Séminaire de probabilités, Lecture Notes in Math, 2007 14. Caglioti, E., Villani, C.: Homogeneous cooling states are not always good approximations to granular flows. Arch. Rat. Mech. Anal. 163, 329–343 (2002) 15. Carlen, E.A., Gabetta, E., Toscani, G.: Propagation of smoothness and the rate of exponential convergence to equilibrium for a spatially homogeneous Maxwellian gas. Commun. Math. Phys. 305, 521–546 (1999) 16. Carrillo, J.A., Cercignani, C., Gamba, I.: Steady states of a Boltzmann equation for driven granular media. Phys. Rev. E. 62, 7700–7707 (2000) 17. Carrillo, J.A., McCann, R.J., Villani, C.: Contractions in the 2-Wasserstein length space and thermalization of granular media. Arch. Rat. Mech. Anal. 179, 217–263 (2006) 18. Cercignani, C., Illner, R., Stoica, C.: On Diffusive Equilibria in Generalized Kinetic Theory. J. Stat. Phys. 105, 337–352 (2001) 19. Ernst, M.H., Brito, R.: High energy tails for inelastic Maxwell models. Europhys. Lett. 58, 182–187 (2002) 20. Ernst, M.H., Brito, R.: Scaling solutions of inelastic Boltzmann equation with over-populated high energy tails. J. Stat. Phys. 109, 407–432 (2002) 21. Gabetta, E., Toscani, G., Wennberg, B.: Metrics for Probability Distributions and the Trend to Equilibrium for Solutions of the Boltzmann Equation. J. Stat. Phys. 81, 901–934 (1995) 22. Kac, M.: Probability and Related Topics in the Physical Sciences. London-New York: Interscience, 1959 23. Li, H., Toscani, G.: Long-time asymptotics of kinetic models of granular flows. Arch. Rat. Mech. Anal. 172, 407–428 (2004) 24. McKean, H.P. Jr.: Speed of approach to equilibrium for Kac’s caricature of a maxwellian gas. Arch. Rat. Mech. Anal. 21, 343–367 (1966) 25. Mischler, S., Mouhot, C.: Cooling process for inelastic Boltzmann equations for hard spheres, Part I: The Cauchy problem. J. Stat. Phys. 124, 655–702 (2006) 26. Mischler, S., Mouhot, C., Rodriguez-Ricard, M.: Cooling process for inelasic Boltzmann equations for hard spheres, Part II: Self-similar solutions and tail behavior. J. Stat. Phys. 124, 703–746 (2006)
314
F. Bolley, J. A. Carrillo
27. Pulvirenti, A., Toscani, G.: Asymptotic properties of the inelastic Kac model. J. Stat. Phys. 114, 1453–1480 (2004) 28. Tanaka, H.: An inequality for a functional of probability distributions and its applications to Kac’s one-dimensional model of a Maxwellian gas. Z. Wahrsch. Verw. Gebiete 27, 47–52 (1973) 29. Tanaka, H.: Probabilistic treatment of the Boltzmann equation of Maxwellian molecules. Z. Wahrsch. Verw. Gebiete 46, 1, 67–105 (1978/79) 30. Toscani, G., Villani, C.: Probability Metrics and Uniqueness of the Solution to the Boltzmann Equation for a Maxwell Gas. J. Stat. Phys. 94, 619–637 (1999) 31. Villani, C.: Topics in optimal transportation, Graduate Studies in Mathematics, Vol. 58. Providence, RI: Amer. Math. Soc, 2003 32. Villani, C.: Mathematics of granular materials. J. Stat. Phys. 124, 781–822 (2006) Communicated by J.L. Lebowitz
Commun. Math. Phys. 276, 315–339 (2007) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-007-0337-9
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Global Existence and Uniqueness of Solutions to the Maxwell-Schrödinger Equations Makoto Nakamura1, , Takeshi Wada2, 1 Mathematical Institute, Tohoku University, Sendai 980-8578, Japan.
E-mail: [email protected]
2 Department of Mathematics, Faculty of Engineering, Kumamoto University, Kumamoto 860-8555, Japan.
E-mail: [email protected] Received: 16 June 2006 / Accepted: 7 February 2007 Published online: 25 September 2007 – © Springer-Verlag 2007
Dedicated to Professor Hiroki Tanabe on his seventy-fifth birthday Abstract: The time local and global well-posedness for the Maxwell-Schrödinger equations is considered in Sobolev spaces in three spatial dimensions. The Strichartz estimates of Koch and Tzvetkov type are used for obtaining the solutions in the Sobolev spaces of low regularities. One of the main results is that the solutions exist time globally for large data. 1. Introduction The Maxwell-Schrödinger system (MS) in space dimension 3 describes the time evolution of a charged nonrelativistic quantum mechanical particle interacting with the (classical) electro-magnetic field it generates. We can state this system in usual vector notation as follows: i∂t u = (− A + φ)u, −φ − ∂t div A = ρ, A + ∇(∂t φ + div A) = J,
(1.1) (1.2) (1.3)
where (u, φ, A) : R1+3 → C × R × R3 , ∇A = ∇ − iA, A = ∇A 2 , ρ = |u|2 , J = 2 Im u∇ ¯ A u, and ∇, and are the usual gradient, Laplacian and d’Alembertian respectively. Physically, u is the wave function of the particle, (φ, A) is the electromagnetic potential, ρ is the charge density, and J is the current density. The system (MS) formally conserves at least two quantities, namely the total charge Q ≡ u22 and the total energy 1 1 E ≡ ∇A u22 + ∇φ + ∂t A22 + rot A22 . 2 2 Supported by Grant-in-Aid for Young Scientists (B) #16740071 of Japan Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology. Supported by Grant-in-Aid for Young Scientists (B) #16740075 of Japan Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology.
316
M. Nakamura, T. Wada
The system (MS) is invariant under the gauge transform (u , φ , A ) = (exp(iλ)u, φ − ∂t λ, A + ∇λ),
(1.4)
and in this paper we mainly study it in the Coulomb gauge div A = 0,
(1.5)
in which we can treat the system most easily. In this gauge, (1.2) and (1.3) become −φ = ρ, A + ∇∂t φ = J.
(1.6)
The first equation of (1.6) is solved as φ = φ(u) = (−)−1 ρ = (4π |x|)−1 ∗ |u|2 , and the term ∇∂t φ in the second equation is dropped by operating the Helmholtz projection P = 1 − ∇ div −1 to both sides of the equation. Therefore in the Coulomb gauge the system (MS) is rewritten as i∂t u = (−A + φ(u))u, A = PJ,
(1.7) (1.8)
which is referred to as (MS-C). To solve (MS-C) we should give the initial condition (u(0), A(0), ∂t A(0)) = (u 0 , A0 , A1 )
(1.9)
in the direct sum of Sobolev spaces X s,σ = {(u 0 , A0 , A1 ) ∈ H s ⊕ H σ ⊕ H σ −1 ; div A0 = div A1 = 0}. The condition (1.5) is conserved under the consistency conditions div A0 = div A1 = 0 since the equation div A = 0 follows from (1.8). Several authors have studied the Cauchy problem and the scattering theory for (MS-C). Nakamitsu-M. Tsutsumi [16] showed the time local well-posedness for (MS-C) in X s,σ with s = σ = 3, 4, 5, . . . . In fact, they treated the case of Lorentz gauge mentioned below, but the Coulomb gauge case can be treated analogously. We remark that their condition can be refined as s = σ > 5/2 by the use of fractional order Sobolev spaces and the commutator estimate by Kato-Ponce [12]. Recently NakamuraWada [17] showed the time local well-posedness for a wider class of (s, σ ) including the case s = σ ≥ 5/3 (precisely see the remark for Theorem 1.1) by using covariant derivative estimates for the Schrödinger part and the Strichartz estimate for the Maxwell part. On the other hand, Guo-Nakamitsu-Strauss [7] constructed a time global (weak) solution in X 1,1 although they did not show the uniqueness. Indeed, in the Coulomb gauge the energy takes the form 1 1 1 E = ∇A u22 + ∇φ22 + ∂t A22 + ∇A22 , 2 2 2 and hence (u, A, ∂t A); X 1,1 does not blow up. Therefore the global existence is proved by parabolic regularization and the compactness method. For the scattering theory, the existence of modified wave operators was proved by Y. Tsutsumi [21], Shimomura [18], and Ginibre-Velo [5, 6].
Global Existence and Uniqueness of Solutions to the MS Equations
317
As we have summarized above, there are several results for the Cauchy problem both at t = 0 or t = ∞. However there are no results concerning the global existence of strong solutions even for small data; the solutions to (MS-C) obtained in [5, 6, 18, 21] exist only for t ≥ 0 and we do not know whether these solutions globally exist or blow-up at finite negative time. The aim of this paper is to answer this problem. Shortly, we prove the global existence of unique strong solutions. To do this, we would need a priori estimates derived from the conservation laws of charge and energy, and hence it is desirable to show the local well-posedness in lower regularity. Therefore we first refine the local theory. To make the statements of the propositions simple, we introduce the notation R∗ = {(s, σ ) ∈ R2 ; σ ≥ max{1; s − 2; (2s − 1)/4}, (s, σ ) = (7/2, 3/2)}, R ∗ = {(s, σ ) ∈ R2 ; σ ≤ min{s + 1; 3s/2; 2s − 3/4}, (s, σ ) = (2, 3)}, and R = R∗ ∩ R ∗ . Theorem 1.1. Let (s, σ ) ∈ R with s ≥ 11/8, σ > 1. Then for any (u 0 , A0 , A1 ) ∈ X s,σ , there exists T > 0 such that (MS-C) with initial condition (1.9) has a unique solution (u, A) satisfying (u, A, ∂t A) ∈ C([0, T ]; X s,σ ). Moreover if s > 11/8 and (s + 1, σ ) ∈ R∗ , then the mapping (u 0 , A0 , A1 ) → (u, A, ∂t A) is continuous as a mapping from X s,σ to C([0, T ]; X s,σ ). σ
s=
11 8
σ = 2s −
3 4
σ=
3s 2
σ =s+1
6 .. .. ... . . ... .. . . 4 . .. ... . . .. ... ... .. .... 3 . . (2, 3) . . . ... .. ... ... . . . . . . . 3 9 . . (2, 4) ... . . . . 2 .... . . . . . 5 3 . ( 2 , 2 ) ... . . . ... ( 72 , 32 ) . . ...... . . ................................................................ . . .. 1 . . . .. ... ... .. .... . . . . . ... .. ... . 0 2 3 4 5 6 ... 1 5
σ =s−1 σ =s−2 σ=
2s+1 4
σ=
2s−1 4
σ=1 s
Fig. 1. A figure of the range of s and σ
Remark. (1) T depends only on s, σ and (u 0 , A0 , A1 ); X s,σ . (2) For any s and σ satisfying the assumption above for the unique existence of the solution, the mapping (u 0 , A0 , A1 ) → (u, A, ∂t A) is continuous in the w*-sense. Namely if a sequence of initial data strongly converges in X s,σ , then the corresponding sequence of solutions also converges star-weakly in L ∞ (0, T ; X s,σ ).
318
M. Nakamura, T. Wada
(3) In [17], we also assume s ≥ 5/3 and 4/3 ≤ σ ≤ (5s − 2)/3 with (s, σ ) = (5/2, 7/2). Generally, in order to construct solutions of dispersive equations in low regularity function spaces, we usually use smoothing effects such as Strichartz estimates. However, the usual Strichartz estimates for Schrödinger equations do not match Eq. (1.7) since we cannot avoid the loss of derivative coming from the term 2iA · ∇u. This is why the preceding results rely on the L 2 -based energy method. In the present work we use a variation of Strichartz estimates first given by Koch-Tzvetkov [15] and refined by KenigKoenig [14] for Benjamin-Ono type equations, and adapted for Schrödinger equations by J. Kato [8]. In the proof of Theorem 1.1, we slightly refine this estimate and combine it with the covariant derivative estimates developed in our previous work [17]. Our local theory does not cover the result for the energy class H 1 , but it is sufficient for our aim. Indeed, we can show the following global result: Theorem 1.2. The solution obtained in Theorem 1.1 exists time globally. By the use of a Koch-Tzvetkov type estimate, we can show 1/2−δ
u; L 2 (0, T ; H6
) ≤ CT 3 ,
where δ > 0 is sufficiently small and the constant C depends only on (u 0 , A0 , A1 ); X 1,1 and δ. Roughly speaking, we can gain 1/2 regularity by this estimate. Indeed, if we control this norm by the Sobolev inequality, we would need u; H 3/2−δ . This estimate, combined with several a priori estimates obtained in the proof of Theorem 1.1, shows that (u, A, ∂t A); X s,σ does not blow up. Next we consider the Lorentz gauge ∂t φ + div A = 0.
(1.10)
(MS) in the Lorentz gauge, which is referred to as (MS-L), is expressed as i∂t u = (−A + φ)u, φ = ρ, A = J. In this case, we need the initial data (u(0), φ(0), ∂t φ(0), A(0), ∂t A(0)) = (u 0 , φ0 , φ1 , A0 , A1 ) ∈ Y s,σ .
(1.11)
Here Y s,σ = {(u 0 , φ0 , φ1 , A0 , A1 ) ∈ H s ⊕ H σ ⊕ H σ −1 ⊕ H σ ⊕ H σ −1 ; div A0 + φ1 = div A1 + φ0 + |u 0 |2 = 0}. The condition (1.10) is conserved under the consistency condition in the definition of Y s,σ since (∂t φ + div A) = ∂t ρ + div J = 0. The first and the second equations respectively follow from the wave equations both for φ and A, and from the conservation of charge derived from the Schrödinger equation. Our result for (MS-L) is the following. Theorem 1.3. Let (s, σ ) ∈ R ∗ with s ≥ 11/8, σ > 1 and σ ≥ s − 1. Then for any (u 0 , φ0 , φ1 , A0 , A1 ) ∈ Y s,σ , there exists T > 0 such that (MS-L) with initial condition (1.11) has a unique solution (u, φ, A) satisfying (u, φ, ∂t φ, A, ∂t A) ∈ C([0, T ]; Y s,σ ). This solution exists time globally. Moreover, if s > 11/8 and (s + 1, σ ) ∈ R∗ , then the mapping (u 0 , φ0 , φ1 , A0 , A1 ) → (u, φ, ∂t φ, A, ∂t A) is continuous as a mapping from Y s,σ to C([0, T ]; Y s,σ ).
Global Existence and Uniqueness of Solutions to the MS Equations
319
We can also consider the temporal gauge φ = 0.
(1.12)
(MS) in the temporal gauge, which is referred to as (MS-T), is expressed as i∂t u = −A u, A + ∇divA = J(u, A). In this case, we need the initial data (u(0), A(0), ∂t A(0)) = (u 0 , A0 , A1 ) ∈ Z s,σ .
(1.13)
Here Z s,σ = {(u 0 , A0 , A1 ) ∈ H s ⊕ H σ ⊕ H σ −1 ; − div A1 = |u 0 |2 }. Our result for (MS-T) is the following. Theorem 1.4. Let (s, σ ) ∈ R ∗ with s ≥ 11/8, σ > 1 and σ ≥ s − 1. Then for any (u 0 , A0 , A1 ) ∈ Z s,σ , there exists T > 0 such that (MS-T) with initial condition (1.13) has a unique solution (u, A) satisfying (u, A, ∂t A) ∈ C([0, T ]; Z s,σ ). This solution exists time globally. Moreover, if s > 11/8 and (s + 1, σ ) ∈ R∗ , then the mapping (u 0 , A0 , A1 ) → (u, A, ∂t A) is continuous as a mapping from Z s,σ to C([0, T ]; Z s,σ ). This paper is organized as follows: In Sect. 2, we first prepare basic estimates used throughout this paper, namely an estimate of Hartree type nonlinearities (Lemma 2.1) and one for covariant derivatives (Lemma 2.2). Next we introduce Strichartz estimates for Klein-Gordon equations (Lemma 2.3) and Koch-Tzvetkov type Strichartz estimates for Schrödinger equations (Lemma 2.4). We also prepare the estimate of the nonlinear term of the Maxwell part, which is based on the Kato-Ponce commutator estimate (Lemmas 2.5 and 2.6). In Sect. 3, we study the linearized Schrödinger equation associated with (1.7). Applying the Koch-Tzvetkov type estimate, we derive a smoothing property of the Schrödinger equation with electro-magnetic potential (Lemma 3.1). Using this estimate together with covariant derivative estimates, we prove the unique solvability of this equation first in H 2 (Lemma 3.2) and next in H s with s ≥ 0 (Lemmas 3.3 and 3.4). In Sect. 4, we discuss the local solvability. We prove the local well-posedness by the contraction mapping principle (Propositions 4.1 and 4.2). The continuous dependence of the solutions on the data is left to Sect. 6, since it is usually the most delicate part of the theory of well-posedness. In Sect. 5, we derive a priori estimates of solutions (Lemma 5.1) and use them in the proof of global existence. Section 6 is devoted to the proof of the continuous dependence of the solutions on the data. In Sect. 7, we prove Theorems 1.3 and 1.4 by using the gauge transform. We conclude this section by giving the notation used in this paper. L p = L p (R3 ) is the usual Lebesgue space and its norm denoted by · p . p = p/( p−1) is the dual exponent of p. This symbol is used only for Lebesgue exponents. H ps = {φ ∈ S (R3 ); (1 − )s/2 φ p < ∞} is the usual Sobolev space. H˙ ps = {φ ∈ S (R3 ); (−)s/2 φ p < ∞} is the homogeneous Sobolev space. The subscript p is omitted if p = 2. For any interval I ⊂ R and Banach space X , L p (I ; X ) denotes the space of X -valued strongly measurable p functions on I whose X -norm belong to L p (I ). This space is often abbreviated to L T X
320
M. Nakamura, T. Wada m, p
for I = (0, T ). Similarly we use the abbreviation C Tm X = C m ([0, T ]; X ) and WT X = W m, p (0, T ; X ), where W m, p (I ; X ) denotes the space of functions in L p (I ; X ) whose derivatives up to the (m − 1)-times are locally absolutely continuous and the derivatives p up to the m-times belong spaces X i , i = 1, . . . , n, we define n to L (I ; X ). For normed n ·; X so that X is also a normed the norm of X = i=1 X i by ·; X = maxi=1 i j,∞ j,∞ = mj=0 WT H σ − j . The space. We define Tm,s = mj=0 WT H s−2 j and Mm,σ T inequality a b means a ≤ Cb, where C is a positive √ constant that is not essential. We write a b if b a as well as a b. a = 1 + a 2 . a ∨ b and a ∧ b denote the maximum and the minimum of a and b respectively. We use the following unusual but convenient symbol: a+ means a ∨ 0 if a = 0, whereas 0+ means a sufficiently small positive number. Namely b ≥ a+ means b ≥ a ∨ 0 if a = 0, and b > 0 if a = 0. It is useful to express sufficient conditions for Sobolev type embeddings Hrs → L p by the inequality (1/r − s/3)+ ≤ 1/ p ≤ 1/r with 1 ≤ r < ∞. 2. Preliminaries In this section we summarize lemmas used in the proof of Theorems 1.1–1.4. The following two lemmas will be repeatedly used in estimates of nonlinear terms. Lemma 2.1. Let s, s1 , s2 , s3 be nonnegative numbers satisfying s ≤ s3 and s1 ∧s2 ≥ s−2 with s1 + s2 > 0. Let s1 + s2 + s3 ∧ (3/2) ≥ s + 1 and the inequality be strict if (i) s j = 3/2 for some 1 ≤ j ≤ 3 or (ii) s = s3 < 3/2. Then the following estimate holds: (−)−1 (u 1 u 2 )u 3 ; H s
3
u j ; H s j .
(2.1)
j=1
Proof. See Lemma 2.1 in [17].
Lemma 2.2. Let (s, σ ) ∈ R∗ with s ≥ 0. Let A ∈ H σ satisfy div A = 0. (i) Let V1 (A, v) = 2iA·∇v+|A|2 v. Then V1 is a continuous mapping from H σ ×H s−1/2 to H s−2 with the estimate V1 (A, v); H s−2 A; H σ 2 v; H s−1/2 .
(2.2)
(ii) The following estimates hold for any v ∈ H s : v; H s + A; H σ α v2 A v; H s−2 + A; H σ α v2 ,
(2.3)
where α = α(s, σ ) is a positive constant independent of v and A. Especially if s = 2, the estimate v; H 2 + A; H˙ 1 4 v2 A v2 + A; H˙ 1 4 v2
(2.4)
holds valid. Proof. For s ≥ 5/2, we can prove (2.2) by the Leibniz rule and the Sobolev inequality. The case s = 0 is the dual of the case s = 5/2, and hence the case 0 < s < 5/2 is proved by interpolation. The continuity of V1 is proved in the same way. Applying 1/2s the interpolation inequality v; H s−1/2 ≤ v; H s 1−1/2s v2 to the estimate of V1 , we can show (2.3). We can show (2.4) if we use the estimate V1 2 ≤ A6 ∇v3 + A26 v6 instead of (2.2).
Global Existence and Uniqueness of Solutions to the MS Equations
321
Next we introduce Strichartz type estimates for Klein-Gordon equations (see for example [2–4, 19]). Lemma 2.3. Let T > 0, σ ∈ R and let (q j , r j ), j = 0, 1, satisfy 0 ≤ 2/q j = 1−2/r j <
σ −1+2/q1
1. Let (A0 , A1 ) ∈ H σ ⊕H σ −1 and F ∈ L T1 Hr1 q
. Then a solution A to the equation
( + 1)A = F with A(0) = A0 , ∂t A(0) = A1 belongs to C T H σ ∩ C T1 H σ −1 and satisfies the estimate σ −k−2/q0
q
max ∂tk A; L T0 Hr0
k=0,1
σ −1+2/q1
(A0 , A1 ); H σ ⊕ H σ −1 + F; L T1 Hr1 q
.
(2.5)
Lemma 2.4. Let T > 0, s ∈ R, α > 0 and 0 ≤ 2/q = 3/2 − 3/r ≤ 1. Let f ∈ L 2T H s−2α . Then a solution u ∈ T1,s to the equation i∂t u = −u + f belongs to
q LT
Hrs−α
and satisfies the estimate
s 1/2 f ; L 2T H s−2α . u; L T Hrs−α u; L ∞ T H +T q
(2.6)
Remark. This kind of estimate was first given by Koch-Tzvetkov [15] for the Benjamin-Ono equation, and it is Kenig-Koenig [14] who formulated the estimate as above. Kato [8] adapted this estimate for Schrödinger equations. However, in [8, 14], s+ to prove (2.6), with the first term in the they need an extra assumption u ∈ L ∞ T H ∞ s+ right-hand side replaced by u; L T H . ∞ Proof. Without loss of generality we assume s = 0. Let u = j=0 u j be the Littlewood-Paley decomposition of the solution u. Namely we take ψ ∈ S (R3 ) such j ˆ that suppψˆ ⊂ {ξ ; 1/2 ≤ |ξ | ≤ 2} and ∞ j=−∞ ψ(ξ/2 ) = 1 for any ξ = 0, and j )u(t, j )u(t, ˆ ˆ put u j = F −1 (ψ(ξ/2 ˆ ξ )) for j ≥ 1, u 0 = F −1 0j=−∞ ψ(ξ/2 ˆ ξ ). Here u(t, ˆ ξ ) is the Fourier transform with respect to the space variable. Similarly let f = ∞ j=0 f j be the Littlewood-Paley decomposition of f . Then u j satisfy the equation i∂t u j = −u j + f j . (2.7) m
j such that 2−2α j T ≤ |I jk | < We divide the interval [0, T ] into disjoint intervals {I jk }k=1 2−2α j+1 T and take t jk ∈ I¯jk at which u j (t)2 attains its minimum in the interval I¯jk . By the standard Strichartz estimate for Schrödinger equations [11, 13, 19, 22],
u j ; L q (I jk ; L r ) u j (t jk )2 + f j ; L 1 (I jk ; L 2 ). Taking the sum with respect to k, we obtain q
u j ; L T L r = (
mj
u j ; L q (I jk ; L r )q )1/q ≤ (
k=1
(
mj
≤(
k=1
u j ; L q (I jk ; L r )2 )1/2
k=1
u j (t jk )22 )1/2 + (
k=1 mj
mj
mj
f j ; L 1 (I jk ; L 2 )2 )1/2
k=1
T
−1 2α j
2
|I jk |u j (t jk )22 )1/2 +(
mj
2−2α j+1 T f j ; L 2 (I jk ; L 2 )2 )1/2
k=1
≤ T −1/2 2α j u j ; L 2T L 2 + (2T )1/2 2−α j f j ; L 2T L 2 .
322
M. Nakamura, T. Wada
The first term in the right-hand side is obtained from the fact that t jk are the minimum points and the definition of the integral. We have also used the definition of I jk and the Hölder inequality for the time variable. Therefore u; L T Hr−α { q
∞
(2−α j |u j |)2 }1/2 ; L T L r ≤ ( q
j=0
T −1/2 (
∞
u j ; L 2T L 2 2 )1/2 + T
∞
T
q
j=0 ∞ 1/2
(
j=0 −1/2
2−α j |u j |; L T L r 2 )1/2 2−2α j f j ; L 2T L 2 2 )1/2
j=0
u; L 2T L 2 +
T
1/2
f ; L 2T
H
−2α
,
where we have used the equivalent norms between the Sobolev spaces and the TriebelLizorkin spaces (see p. 29 in [20]). Thus the lemma has been proved. Lemma 2.5. Let σ ≥ 0. Let 1 < p, p1 , p4 < ∞ and 1 < p2 , p3 ≤ ∞ satisfy 1/ p = 1/ p1 + 1/ p2 = 1/ p3 + 1/ p4 . Then the following estimate holds valid: P(u¯ 1 ∇u 2 ); H pσ u 1 ; H pσ1 ∇u 2 p2 + ∇u 1 p3 u 2 ; H pσ4 .
(2.8)
Moreover if 0 ≤ σ ≤ 1, we can omit the second term of the right-hand side. Proof. We can prove (2.8) by the use of the Kato-Ponce commutator estimate [12] and the fact that P∇ = 0; see [17] for details. The last assertion can be checked immediately for σ = 0, 1 and generalized for 0 < σ < 1 by interpolation. Lemma 2.6. Let (s, σ ) ∈ R ∗ with s ≥ 5/4 and σ ≥ 1. Then P(u¯ 1 ∇A u 2 ); L 1T
H
σ −1
T
1/4
T
3/4
σ −1/2 A; L ∞ T H
2 s 2 s−1/2 u j ; L ∞ . T H ∩L T H6 j=1
(2.9) Proof. It suffices to show the following inequalities: P(u¯ 1 ∇u 2 ); L 1T H σ −1 T 1−1/q1 −1/q2 (u 1 ; L T1 Hr1 q
+
s−1/q1
q
s−1/q2
u 2 ; L T2 Hr2
q s−1/q2 q s−1/q1 u 1 ; L T2 Hr2 u 2 ; L T1 Hr1 )
(2.10)
for suitable q j , r j satisfying the conditions 0 ≤ 2/q j = 3/2 − 3/r j ≤ 1 and 2/q1 + 2/q2 ≤ 3/2; σ −1/2 Au¯ 1 u 2 ; L 1T H σ −1 T A; L ∞ T H
2
s u j ; L ∞ T H .
(2.11)
j=1
We first prove (2.10). We use Lemma 2.5 and obtain the estimate P(u¯ 1 ∇u 2 ); H σ −1 u 1 ; H pσ1−1 ∇u 2 p2 + ∇u 1 p2 u 2 ; H pσ1−1 , where the choice of p1 , p2 depends on the value of s. Practically, if s > 2 and σ ≤ s + 1, s−3/2 we choose p1 = 2, p2 = ∞ so that H s → H σ −1 and H6 → L ∞ . Then we obtain (2.10) with 2/q1 = 0, 2/q2 = 1. If 3/2 ≤ s < 2, we choose 1/ p1 = s/3 − 1/6,
Global Existence and Uniqueness of Solutions to the MS Equations s−1/q2
1/ p2 = (2 − s)/3 so that Hr2
s−1/2
≡ H6
323
→ H p12 by the Sobolev inequality.
1 → H pσ1−1 and 2/q1 + Putting r1 = p1 and hence 2/q1 = 2 − s, we obtain Hr1 2/q2 = 3 − s ≤ 3/2 under the condition σ ≤ 3s/2. If 5/4 ≤ s < 3/2, we choose s−1/q2 ≡ H p12 . Putting r1 = p1 1/ p1 = 2(s − 1)/3, 1/ p2 = 1/2 − 2(s − 1)/3 so that Hr2
s−1/q
1 and hence 2/q1 = 7/2 − 2s, we obtain Hr1 → H pσ1−1 and 2/q1 + 2/q2 = 3/2 under the condition σ ≤ 2s − 3/4. Therefore we obtain (2.10) by the Hölder inequality for the time variable. The proof for the case s = 2 has been omitted, but this is covered by the case s ≈ 2. Next we prove (2.11). By the Leibniz rule,
s−1/q
Au¯ 1 u 2 ; H σ −1 A; H3σ −1 u 1 12 u 2 12 + A p3 u 1 ; H pσ4−1 u 2 p5 + A p3 u 1 p5 u 2 ; H pσ4−1 , where 2 ≤ p3 , p4 , p5 < ∞ are numbers satisfying 1/ p3 ≥ {(2 − σ )/3}+ , 1/ p4 ≥ {1/2 − (s − σ + 1)/3}+ , 1/ p5 ≥ (1/2 − s/3)+ and 1/ p3 + 1/ p4 + 1/ p5 = 1/2. Such a choice is possible under the assumption. Thus (2.11) follows from the Sobolev inequality. 3. Linearized Schrödinger Equations In this section we prove some existence theorems and a priori estimates for the linear Schrödinger equation associated with (1.7): i∂t v = (−A + φ)v, 0 < t < T, v(t0 ) = v0 .
(3.1) (3.2)
Here φ = φ(u) ≡ (4π |x|)−1 ∗ |u|2 and 0 ≤ t0 ≤ T . In this section we regard A and u as known functions defined on [0, T ]. Here we clarify the notion of solutions to (3.1). Definition 3.1. A function v is called a weak (resp. strong) H s -solution to (3.1) if v belongs to T1,s (resp. C T H s ∩ C T1 H s−2 ) and satisfies (3.1) for almost every (resp. all) 0 < t < T . A function v is called a weak (resp. strong) H s -solution to (3.1)–(3.2) if v is a weak (resp. strong) H s -solution to (3.1) and satisfies (3.2). For given σ > 1, we fix positive numbers δ, q and r as δ = min{(σ − 1)/2, 1/4}, 1/q = 1/2 − 2δ/3, 1/r = 2δ/3.
(3.3)
This notation will be used throughout the paper. 2 ∞ satisfy σ Lemma 3.1. Let s ≥ 0, σ > 1 and σ ≥ s − 1. Let A ∈ L ∞ T H ∩ LT L ∞ 2 (s−1)∨1 s−1 s and f ∈ L T H . Then a weak H -solution v to div A = 0. Let u ∈ L T H
i∂t v = (−A + φ)v + f, 0 < t < T, s−1/2
belongs to L 2T H6 s−1/2
v; L 2T H6
and satisfies the estimate
σ 2 ∞ ∞ (s−1)∨1 m s T m A; L ∞ v; L ∞ T H ∩ L T L ∨ u; L T H T H
+ T 1/2 f ; L 2T H s−1 , where m is a positive number.
(3.4)
324
M. Nakamura, T. Wada
Proof. Applying Lemma 2.4, we obtain s−1/2
v; L 2T H6
s 1/2 v; L ∞ 2iA · ∇v + |A|2 v + φv + f ; L 2T H s−1 . (3.5) T H +T
We shall estimate the second term of the right-hand side. We first estimate 2iA · ∇v. We have ∇vq1 (3.6) A · ∇v; H s−1 A∞ v; H s + A; Hrs−1 1 for 0 < 2/r1 = 1 − 2/q1 ≤ 1, and the second term can be omitted in the case s ≤ 1. Indeed (3.6) without the second term is clearly valid for s = 0 and s = 1, and it is also valid for 0 < s < 1 by interpolation; on the other hand if s > 1, (3.6) is obtained by the Leibniz rule. We define the numbers q1 , r1 as (i) 2/q1 = 1 − 2/r1 = 2 − s if 1 < s < 2; (ii) 2/q1 = 1 − 2/r1 = δ if s = 2; (iii) q1 = ∞, r1 = 2 if s > 2. In any case, by virtue of the Sobolev (Gagliardo-Nirenberg) inequality, there exists an exponent 0 < θ < 1 s−1/2 1−θ with 2/q1 ≤ θ such that ∇vq1 v; H s θ v; H6 . Practically, we can take θ = 2 − s if s < 2, θ = 3δ if s = 2, and θ = 2(s − 2)/(2s − 3) if s > 2. Therefore by the Hölder inequality for the time variable together with the Young inequality, T 1/2 A · ∇v; L 2T H s−1 s 1/2 v; T 1/2 A; L 2T L ∞ v; L ∞ T H +T s−1/2 1−θ
L 2T H6
s θ A; L T Hrs−1 v; L ∞ T H 1 2/θ
s 2 T m {A; L 2T L ∞ + 1−1/θ A; L T1 Hrs−1 1/θ }v; L ∞ T H + v; L T H6 1 q
s−1/2
,
where m is a positive number. We choose > 0 so small that the last term in the right-hand side is absorbed in the left-hand side of (3.5). Next we show the estimate |A|2 v; H s−1 A; H σ A∞ v; H s . If s ≤ 1, this inequality follows from the Sobolev inequality. If s > 1, we use the Leibniz rule to derive A∞ vq2 |A|2 v; H s−1 A3 A∞ v; H6s−1 + A; Hrs−1 2 with 0 < 2/r2 = 1 − 2/q2 ≤ 1. We can choose q2 , r2 such that 1/r2 ≥ (1/2 − (σ − s + 1)/3)+ and 1/q2 ≥ (1/2 − s/3)+ . Therefore we obtain the desired estimate again by the Sobolev inequality. By the Sobolev inequality L 6/(5−2s) → H s−1 for 0 ≤ s ≤ 1, and Lemma 2.1 for s > 1, we have φv; H s−1 u; H (s−1)∨1 2 v; H s . Collecting these estimates, we obtain s−1/2
v; L 2T H6
σ 2 ∞ s−1 ∞ (s−1)∨1 m 1 T m A; L ∞ T H ∩ L T L ∩ L T Hr1 ∨ u; L T H q
s 1/2 × v; L ∞ f ; L 2T H s−1 , T H + T
where m is a positive number, and the third space in the norm of A can be dropped if s ≤ 1. q 2 ∞ σ A; L ∞ To complete the proof, we should show A; L T1 Hrs−1 T H ∩ L T L in the 1 nontrivial case 1 < s ≤ 2. We concentrate on the case 1 < s < 2; we can analogously
Global Existence and Uniqueness of Solutions to the MS Equations
325
treat the case s = 2. Let A = ∞ j=0 A j be the Littlewood-Paley decomposition. Then by the Hölder inequalities both for the sequence and the space variable, A;
Hrs−1 1
{
∞
|2(s−1) j A j |2 }1/2 r1
j=0
{
∞
|2
σj
A j |2 }1/2 s−1 2 {
j=0
∞
|2− 1 j A j |2 }1/2 2−s ∞ ,
j=0
where 1 = (σ −1)(s−1)/(2−s) > 0. We have { since A j ∞ A∞ . Therefore we obtain
∞
j=0 |2
− 1 j A |2 }1/2 j ∞
≤ C 1 A∞
σ s−1 A; L T1 Hrs−1 A; L ∞ A; L 2T L ∞ 2−s T H 1 q
by the Hölder inequality for the time variable.
1 ∩ satisfy div A = 0. Let u ∈ L ∞ Lemma 3.2. Let σ > 1 and let A ∈ T H . Then for any v0 ∈ H 2 , there exists a unique weak solution v to (3.1)–(3.2), and the solution v satisfies the following estimate:
M1,σ T
L 2T L ∞
2 2 ∞ ˙1 4 v; L ∞ T H ≤ Cv0 ; H A; L T H 2 ∞ ∞ 1 l × exp{C T 1/2 T l A; M1,σ T ∩ L T L ∨ u; L T H }. (3.7)
Here l is a positive number. Moreover, if u ∈ C T H 1 , v is a unique strong solution to (3.1)–(3.2). Proof. From Eq. (3.1), we can immediately show the conservation law of the L 2 -norm v(t)2 = v0 2 . The uniqueness of the solution clearly follows from this identity. The existence of the weak solution follows from the a priori estimate (3.7). Indeed the unique existence of the strong solution has already been known for sufficiently smooth u, A and v0 (see for example [9, 10]). Therefore we approximate these functions by a sequence of smooth ones and consider the corresponding sequence of solutions. If we extract a star-weakly converging subsequence, then the star-weak limit is a weak solution to (3.1)-(3.2). Therefore we formally prove (3.7). Taking Lemma 2.2 into account, we estimate v; HA2 ≡ A v2 + R4 v2 ˙1 instead of v; H 2 , where R ≡ A; L ∞ T H . Taking the time derivative of A v and using Eq. (3.1), we find the equation for A v: i∂t A v = (−A + φ)A v + 2∂t A · ∇A v + [A , φ]v.
(3.8)
Therefore the standard energy method shows that v; L ∞ (t0 , t; HA2 ) ≤ v0 ; HA20 + 2∂t A · ∇A v + [A , φ]v; L 1 (t0 , t; L 2 ), where A0 ≡ A(t0 ). By the Sobolev inequality, we have ∇vr v; H 2 4δ v; 3/2 H6 1−4δ . Applying this inequality together with the Young inequality and Lemma 2.2, we obtain 2∂t A · ∇A v2 ≤ ∂t Aq ∇vr + ∂t A2 A∞ v∞ ≤ v; H6 + C{ (4δ−1)/4δ ∂t A; H σ −1 1/4δ + ∂t A2 A∞ }v; HA2 . 3/2
(3.9)
326
M. Nakamura, T. Wada
Here q, r are defined by (3.3) and is a positive number which will be determined later. We can easily handle the term [A , φ]v by Lemma 2.1 or the Hardy-Littlewood-Sobolev inequality; we obtain [A , φ]v2 A; H˙ 1 u; H 1 2 v; H 2 . Therefore v; L ∞ (t0 , t; HA2 ) 3/2
≤ v0 ; HA20 + (t − t0 )1/2 v; L 2 (t0 , t; H6 ) t +C { (4δ−1)/4δ ∂t A; H σ −1 1/4δ + ∂t A2 A∞ t0
+A; H˙ 1 u; H 1 2 }v; HA2 dt .
(3.10)
Taking Lemma 3.1 into account, we choose the positive number so small that the second term in the right-hand side is absorbed in the left-hand side. To this end we 2 ∞ ∞ 1 m σ choose such that T m+1/2 A; L ∞ T H ∩ L T L ∨ u; L T H 1 with m stated in Lemma 3.1. Thus we obtain t ∞ 1 l ∨ u; L H A∞ v; H 2 dt , v; H 2 ≤ CR4 u 0 ; H 2 +CT l A; M1,σ T T t0
where l is some positive number. Applying the Gronwall inequality we obtain (3.7). We proceed to the latter part of the lemma. The weak continuity of A v follows from the construction of v. We shall prove the strong continuity. We take a supreme limit of both sides of (3.10) as t ↓ t0 and obtain lim supt↓t0 A v(t)2 ≤ A0 v0 2 . Therefore s- limt↓t0 A v = A0 v0 in L 2 . This argument shows that A v ∈ C T L 2 ; on the other hand, the fact that v ∈ C T L 2 is similarly proved by the conservation law of the L 2 -norm. 1 Therefore we obtain v ∈ C T H 2 from Lemma 2.2 and the fact A ∈ M1,σ T ⊂ C T H . If 1 2 we also assume u ∈ C T H , we can show ∂t v ∈ C T L taking Eq. (3.1) into account. Definition 3.2. We define the two parameter family of the operator {U (t, τ )}0≤t,τ ≤T as the evolution operator of (3.1). Namely, U (t, t0 )v0 solves (3.1)–(3.2). By the following lemmas, {U (t, τ )} can be extended as a family in H s with s ≥ − 2. We put K s ≡ sup0≤t,τ ≤T U (t, τ ); H s → H s . Remark. In view of Lemma 3.2, we have the estimate 1/2 2 ∞ ∞ 1 l ˙1 4 K 2 ≤ CA; L ∞ T l A; M1,σ T H exp{C T T ∩ L T L ∨ u; L T H }
with some positive numbers C, l. 2 ∞ satisfy div A = 0. Let Lemma 3.3. Let −2 ≤ s ≤ 2, σ > 1 and let A ∈ M1,σ T ∩ LT L ∞ 1 u ∈ L T H . Then we have the following:
(i) {U (t, τ )} can be uniquely extended to a family of operators in H s which solves (3.1), namely U (t, t0 )v0 is a weak H s solution to (3.1)–(3.2), and moreover if s ≥ 0, then U (t, t0 )v0 is a unique weak H s solution; (ii) if u ∈ C T H 1 , U (t, t0 )v0 is a strong H s solution; |s|/2 (iii) 1 ≤ K s ≤ K 2 ;
Global Existence and Uniqueness of Solutions to the MS Equations
327
(iv) if w is a weak L 2 solution to the equation i∂t w = (−A + φ)w + f , where f ∈ L 1T H −2 , then w satisfies the integral form of this equation, namely t w(t) = U (t, t0 )w(t0 ) − i U (t, τ ) f (τ )dτ. t0
Proof. This lemma can be proved in the same way as in Lemmas 3.2 and 3.3 in [17]. 2 ∞ Lemma 3.4. Let (s, σ ) ∈ R∗ with 2 < s < 4 and σ > 1. Let A ∈ M2,σ T ∩ L T L satisfy div A = 0. Let u ∈ T1,s−1 . Then for any v0 ∈ H s , there exists a unique weak solution v to (3.1)–(3.2), and the solution v satisfies the following estimate: 1,σ s s ∞ 1 l