This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
q zq p
p6=q (1 − q
− q bii zπ(p) ).
(39)
Substituting (38) and (39) into (37) we get: Y
(1 − q
bii zq
zp
p6=q
Q1−aij r=1
P
Fj i ( zwr )
1−aij
Y
)
s=1
Q
p>q
P1−aij
(1 − q bij
zs )Pij = w
(40)
zq 1 bii zq zq (1 − q zp )Fii ( zp )
×
1 − aij × k qi Q l(π) (z bii π(q) − q zπ(p) )× p
k=0
(−1)k
(41)
Now Lemma 11 follows immediately from Theorem 9 with t = qi , m = aij . Proof of the theorem. The conditions of the theorem imply that, as a formal power series, Pij =
1−aij
Y
Y
1
p6=q
1 − q bii zpq
z
s=1
1−aij Y Y 1 zs bii zq (1 − q ) (1 − q bij )Pij . (42) zs b ij zp w 1 − q w p6=q s=1
From Lemma 11 it follows that Y p6=q
(1 − q
bii zq
zp
1−aij
)
Y
(1 − q bij
s=1
zs )Pij = 0. w
t Therefore, Pij = 0. This concludes the proof. u One can formulate several versions of Theorem 10. For instance, the following is true.
16
A. Sevostyanov
Proposition 12. Let Fkl (z), k, l = 1, . . . , l be a solution of system (34). Suppose that for some i and j the product 1−aij
Y
1
p6=q
1 − q bii zpq
z
·
Y 1
w zs 1 − q bij zws
· Pij
(43)
is well-defined as a formal power series. Then, Pij = 0. Proof of the proposition is similar to that of Theorem 10. u t Similar statements exist for |q| > 1. Acknowledgements. The author would like to thank B. Enriquez, G. Felder and V. Tarasov for useful discussions. I am also grateful to A. Alekseev and to M. Golenishcheva-Kutuzova for careful reading of the text.
References 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13.
Bourbaki, N.: Groupes et algebras de Lie. Chap. 4, 5, 6, Paris: Hermann, 1968 Chari, V., Pressley, A.: A guide to quantum groups. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press, 1994 Drinfeld, V.G.: A new realization of Yangians and quantized affine algebras. Sov. Math. Dokl. 36 (1988) Drinfeld, V.G.: Quantum groups. Proc. Int. Congr. Math. Berkley, California, 1986, Am. Math. Soc., Providence, RI: 1987, pp. 718–820 Feigin, B., Frenkel, E.: Affine Lie algebras at the critical level and Gelfand–Dikii algebras. Int. J. Mod. Phys. A7, Suppl. A1, 197–215 (1992); Quantization of the Drinfeld–Sokolov reduction: Phys. Lett. B246, 75–81 (1990) Gasper, G., Rahman, M.: Basic hypergeometric series. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press, 1990 Kac, V.G.: Infinite dimensional Lie algebras. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press, 1990 Khoroshkin, S.M., Tolstoy, V.N.: On Drinfeld’s realization of quantum affine algebras. J. Geom. Phys. 11, 445–452 (1993) Kostant, B.: The principal three-dimensional subgroup and the Betti numbers of a complex simple Lie group. Am. J. Math. 81, 973–1032 (1959) Kostant, B.: On Whittaker vectors and representation theory: Inventiones Math. 48, 101–184 (1978) Kostant, B.: The solution to a generalized Toda lattice and representation theory. Adv. in Math. 34, 195–338 (1979) Jing, N.: Quantum Kac–Moody algebras and vertex representations. q-alg/9802036 Macdonald, I.G.: Symmetric functions and Hall polynomials. 2nd edition, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1995
Communicated by G. Felder
Commun. Math. Phys. 204, 17 – 38 (1999)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
© Springer-Verlag 1999
Separation of Variables in the Elliptic Gaudin Model Evgueni K. Sklyanin1 , Takashi Takebe2,? 1 St. Petersburg Branch of the Steklov Mathematical Institute, Fontanka 27, St. Petersburg 191011, Russia.
E-mail: [email protected]
2 Department of Mathematical Sciences, University of Tokyo, Komaba 3-8-1, Meguro-ku, Tokyo, 153-8914,
Japan. E-mail: [email protected] Received: 21 August 1998 / Accepted: 12 January 1999
Abstract: For the elliptic Gaudin model (a degenerate case of the XYZ integrable spin chain) a separation of variables is constructed in the classical case. The corresponding separated coordinates are obtained as the poles of a suitably normalized Baker-Akhiezer function. The classical results are generalized to the quantum case where the kernel of the separating integral operator is constructed. The simplest one-degree-of-freedom case is studied in detail. 1. Introduction The quantum elliptic (or XYZ) Gaudin model was introduced in [1], see also [2], as a limiting case of the integrable XYZ spin chain [3]. The commuting Hamiltonians Hn of the model are expressed as quadratic combinations of sl2 spin operators. Determining the spectrum of Hn turned out to be a difficult problem like the original XYZ spin chain. Let us list the known facts related to this problem. • A solution by means of the Algebraic Bethe Ansatz has been obtained only recently [4]. See also [5]. • As shown in [6], in the SU(2)-invariant, or XXX, or rational, case the spectrum and the eigenfunctions of the model can be found via an alternative method, Separation of Variables, see also the survey [7]. • In [8] the separation of variables in the rational Gaudin model [6] was interpreted as a geometric Langlands correspondence. • In [9] a separation of variables was constructed for the elliptic Gaudin–Calogero model which is closely related to the XYZ Gaudin model, though the separation of variables for the former one is much simpler. • The results of [8] and [9] are based on the interpretation of the corresponding Gaudin models as conformal field theoretical models (Wess–Zumino–Witten models). The ? Present address: Department of Mathematics, Faculty of Science, Ochanomizu University, Otsuka 2-1-1, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo, 112-8610, Japan. E-mail: [email protected]
18
E. K. Sklyanin, T. Takebe
corresponding interpretation of the XYZ Gaudin model was obtained in [10], but the conformal field theoretical model corresponding to the XYZ Gaudin model turned out to be so complicated that writing down the geometric Langlands correspondence for this system, following [8], is not easy. The main task of the present paper is to present a construction of separated variables for the XYZ Gaudin model both in the classical and quantum cases. The paper is organized as follows. After giving a detailed description of the XYZ Gaudin model in Sect. 2, we proceed, in Sect. 3, with the classical case and, following the general philosophy of [7], construct the separated coordinates as the poles of an appropriately normalized Baker-Akhiezer function. The corresponding eigenvalues of the Lax matrix are then shown to provide the canonically conjugated momenta. The whole construction is a simplified version of the one used in [11]. The quantum case is considered in Sect. 4. The separating classical canonical transformation is replaced by an integral operator K . We write down a system of differential equations for the kernel of K and show that it is integrable. The resulting integral operator K intertwines the original and the separated variables and provides, respectively, a Radon–Penrose transformation of the corresponding D-modules. The quantization constructed is a formal one, since we do not study the transformations of the functional spaces of quantum states, leaving it for a further study. A detailed study of the spectral problem is given in the simplest case only: N = 1 (Sect. 5). We show that the corresponding separated equation is none other than the (generalized) Lamé equation. Two appendices contain, respectively, a list of properties of elliptic functions, and the formulas describing a realization of finite-dimensional representations of sl2 (C) on the elliptic curve which are used throughout the paper. 2. Description of the Model Let us recall the definition of the XYZ Gaudin model, following [4]. The elementary Lax operator L(u) of the model depending on a complex parameter u (spectral parameter) is given by 3 1X A(u) B(u) a a wa (u)S ⊗ σ = . (2.1) L(u) = C(u) −A(u) 2 a=1
Here σ a are the Pauli matrices, w1 (u) =
0 θ11 θ 0 θ00 (u) θ 0 θ01 (u) θ10 (u) , w2 (u) = 11 , w3 (u) = 11 , θ10 θ11 (u) θ00 θ11 (u) θ01 θ11 (u)
(2.2)
0 = d/du(θ (u))| where θαβ (u) = θαβ (u; τ ), θαβ = θαβ (0), θ11 11 u=0 , (see Appendix A) a and S are generators of the Lie algebra sl2 (C):
[S a , S b ] = iS c . Hereafter (a, b, c) denotes a cyclic permutation of (1, 2, 3). Note that A, B, C are holomorphic except at u ∈ Z + τ Z, where these operators have poles of first order. 1
2
Introducing the notation L := L ⊗ 1l2 and L := 1l2 ⊗ L, where 1l2 is the unit operator in C2 , one can establish the commutation relation 1
2
1
2
[L (u), L (v)] = [r(u − v), L (u) + L (v)],
(2.3)
Elliptic Gaudin Model
19
where r(u) is a classical r matrix defined by 1X wa (u)σ a ⊗ σ a . 2 3
r(u) = −
(2.4)
a=1
The r matrix behaves as − u1 (P − 21 ) + O(u−3 ) when u → 0. Here P is the permutation operator: P(x ⊗ y) = y ⊗ x. Explicitly, in the natural basis in C2 ⊗ C2 ,
a(u) 0 0 d(u) 0 0 b(u) c(u) r(u) = , 0 c(u) b(u) 0 d(u) 0 0 a(u)
(2.5)
where a(u) = −b(u) = −
w1 (u) + w2 (u) w1 (u) − w2 (u) w3 (u) , c(u) = − , d(u) = − . 2 2 2
Since wa (u) are quasiperiodic in u because of (A.3): w1 (u + 1) = −w1 (u + τ ), w1 (u) = w2 (u) = −w2 (u + 1) = −w2 (u + τ ), w3 (u + τ ), w3 (u) = −w3 (u + 1) =
(2.6)
the L operator (2.1) has the following quasiperiodicity: L(u + 1) = σ 1 L(u)σ 1 ,
L(u + τ ) = σ 3 L(u)σ 3 .
(2.7)
Let `n (n = 1, . . . , N) be half integers. The total Hilbert space of the model is N (`n ) and V (`) is a spin ` representation space of sl : V = N 2 n=1 Vn , where Vn ' V ρ ` : sl2 (C) → EndC (V (`) ),
V (`) ' C2`+1 .
(2.8)
The generating function of the integrals of motion is τˆ (u) =
1 Tr T 2 (u), 2
(2.9)
where the matrix T (u) is constructed as the sum of elementary Lax operators (2.1), T (u) =
N X n=1
A(u) B(u) Ln (u − zn ) = . C(u) −A(u)
(2.10)
Here zn are mutually distinct complex parameters, 1X wa (u)Sna ⊗ σ a 2 3
Ln (u) =
(2.11)
a=1
Sna = 1lV1 ⊗ . . . ⊗ 1lVn−1 ⊗ ρ `n (S a ) ⊗ 1lVn+1 ⊗ . . . ⊗ 1lVN .
(2.12)
20
E. K. Sklyanin, T. Takebe
By virtue of the commutation relations (2.3) the operator T (u) satisfies the same commutation relations 1
2
1
2
[T (u), T (v)] = [r(u − v), T (u) + T (v)],
(2.13)
which implies the commutativity of τˆ (u): [τˆ (u), τˆ (v)] = 0.
(2.14)
Operator τˆ (u) is explicitly written down as follows: τˆ (u) =
N X
℘11 (u − zn )`n (`n + 1) +
n=1
N X
Hn ζ11 (u − zn ) + H0 .
(2.15)
n=1
Here ℘11 , ζ11 are normalized Weierstraß functions defined by (A.5) and Hn =
3 1 XX a wa (zn − zm )Sna Sm , 2 m6=n a=1
H0 =
N X
3 X
n,m=1 a=1
a Za (zn − zm )Sna Sm
(2.16)
are integrals of motion, where Z1 (t) =
0 θ 0 (t) θ11 10 , 4θ10 θ11 (t)
Z2 (t) =
0 θ 0 (t) θ11 00 , 4θ00 θ11 (t)
Z3 (t) =
0 θ 0 (t) θ11 01 . 4θ01 θ11 (t)
(2.17)
Note that the integrals of motion Hn (n = 0, . . . , N) appear as coefficients of the elliptic Knizhnik-Zamolodchikov equations in [10]. Our expression (2.16) for H0 differs from that given in [4] because of different normalization of the ℘ and ζ functions. The classical Gaudin model is obtained if we replace all the commutators with the Poisson brackets, e.g. 1
2
1
2
{T (u), T (v)} = [r(u − v), T (u) + T (v)],
(2.18)
Sa
satisfy, respectively, the Poisson commutation instead of (2.13). The spin variables P a b c relations [S , S ] = iS and are subject to the constraint 3a=1 (S a )2 = `2 . 3. Classical Separation of Variables According to the recipe in [7], the separated coordinates xn should be constructed as the poles of a suitably normalized Baker-Akhiezer function (eigenvector of Lax matrix T (u)). The corresponding canonically conjugated variables should appear then as the corresponding eigenvalues of T (xn ). Instead of choosing a normalization, we shall rather speak of a choice of a gauge transformation M of T (u). The separated coordinates xn ˜ will be obtained then as the zeros of the off-diagonal element B(u) of the twisted matrix −1 ˜ T = M T M. The classical XYZ Gaudin model is a degenerate case of the classical lattice LandauLifshits equation for which a separation of variables has been constructed in [11], see also a discussion in [7]. Here we use essentially the same gauge transformation M(u) as in [11], and our calculations represent a revised and simplified version of those in [11].
Elliptic Gaudin Model
21
3.1. Gauge transformation. Let M(u; u) ˜ be the following 2 × 2 matrix −θ01 u−2 u˜ ; τ2 −θ01 u+2 u˜ ; τ2 , M(u; u) ˜ := θ00 u+2 u˜ ; τ2 θ00 u−2 u˜ ; τ2
(3.1)
where u and u˜ are (possibly dynamical) parameters. (This matrix appears also in the ˜ context of the algebraic Bethe Ansatz. See [12,4].) A twisted L-operator L(u, v; u) ˜ depending on a parameter u˜ is defined by ˜ v; u) ˜ v; u) A(u, ˜ B(u, ˜ ˜ ˜ − v)M(u; u). ˜ (3.2) L(u, v; u) ˜ = ˜ := M −1 (u; u)L(u ˜ v; u) C(u, v; u) ˜ −A(u, ˜ Likewise we define the twisted Lax matrix by ˜ ˜ A(u; u) ˜ B(u; u) ˜ ˜ ˜ (u)M(u; u). ˜ T (u; u) ˜ = ˜ := M −1 (u; u)T ˜ C(u; u) ˜ −A(u; u) ˜
(3.3)
Note that M(u; u) ˜ has the quasiperiodicity because of (A.3): ˜ M(u + 1; u) ˜ = −σ1 M(u; u), ˜ exp(π i uσ ˜ 3 ). M(u + τ ; u) ˜ = e−πi(u+τ/2) σ3 M(u; u)
(3.4)
˜ These formulae together with (2.7) imply that the function B(u, v; u) ˜ has the following quasiperiodicity properties: ˜ + 1; u) ˜ B(u ˜ = B(u; u), ˜
˜ ˜ + τ ; u) u). ˜ B(u ˜ = e−2π i u˜ B(u;
(3.5)
Hence by a standard argument in the theory of elliptic functions (see [13]), we have X ˜ ˜ y ∈ Z + τ Z, (3.6) deg(div(B(u))) = 0, −u˜ + (mult y div(B(u))) ˜ ˜ is the multiplicity of a divisor [y] in the divisor div(B(u)). By the where mult y div(B(u)) ˜ definition (3.3), operator B(u; u) ˜ is holomorphic except at poles of A(u), B(u), C(u), ˜ i.e., u = 0 modulo Z + τ Z: i.e., u = zn (n = 1, . . . , N), and at zeros of det M(u; u), ! N X ˜ [zn ] + [0] (mod Z + τ Z). (3.7) div(B(u)) ≥− n=1
Thus (3.7) and (3.6) imply that there are (N + 1) points x0 , . . . , xN such that ! N N X X ˜ [xj ] − [zn ] + [0] (mod Z + τ Z), div(B(u)) ≡
(3.8)
n=1
j =0
and N X j =0
xj ≡
N X
zn − u˜
(mod Z + τ Z).
(3.9)
n=1
Let us fix the parameter u˜ by the condition that one of xj , for example x0 , is a constant ξ . Note that u˜ becomes then a dynamical variable. Thus we have ˜ = ξ ; u) ˜ j ; u) ˜ = B(u ˜ = 0. B(x
(3.10)
Dynamical variables x1 , . . . , xN are (classically) separated coordinates of the system as we will see below.
22
E. K. Sklyanin, T. Takebe
3.2. Poisson commutation relations and classical separation of variables. The main purpose of this subsection is to prove the following commutation relations. ˜ j ) have the canonical Theorem 3.1. Generically the dynamical variables xj and −A(x Poisson brackets: (i) {xi , xj } = 0 for all i, j = 1, . . . , N. ˜ j )} = 0 for all i, j = 1, . . . , N. ˜ i ), −A(x (ii) {−A(x ˜ (iii) {−A(xi ), xj } = δi,j for all i, j = 1, . . . , N. To prove the theorem, we follow the argument of [11]. First let us introduce several ˆ B, ˆ C, ˆ Dˆ as notations. Define the matrices A, 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ A := , B := , C := , D := . (3.11) 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 Gauge transformation of them are defined as follows: ˆ ˆ A(u; u) ˜ := M(u; u) ˜ AM(u; u) ˜ −1 , ˆ ˆ C(u; u) ˜ := M(u; u) ˜ CM(u; u) ˜ −1 ,
ˆ ˆ B(u; u) ˜ := M(u; u) ˜ BM(u; u) ˜ −1 , ˆ ˆ D(u; u) ˜ := M(u; u) ˜ DM(u; u) ˜ −1 .
(3.12)
Bracket h, i is the standard inner product of the 2 × 2 matrices: hX, Y i = tr XY.
(3.13)
When X(u) is a variable depending on the spectral parameter u, we will denote X(xi ) by Xi for brevity. For example, ∂ ˆ ˆ tr(C(u; u)T ˜ (u)). (∂u hCT i)i = ∂u u=xi The following statement is proved by the same argument as in the proof of the Theorem in §2 of [11]. Lemma 3.2. For any dynamical variable X, hCˆ 0 {X, T }0 i , h∂u˜ Cˆ 0 T0 i
(3.14)
hCˆ 0 {X, T }0 ih∂u˜ Cˆ j Tj i − hCˆ j {X, T }j ih∂u˜ Cˆ 0 T0 i . ˆ T i)j h∂u˜ Cˆ 0 T0 i (∂u hC,
(3.15)
{X, u} ˜ =− and {X, xj } =
We also need the formula for the twisted r matrix. Lemma 3.3. Define 1
2
1
2
˜ −1 M (v; u) ˜ −1 r(u − v)M (u; u)M ˜ (v; u), ˜ r˜ (u, v; u) ˜ := M (u; u)
(3.16)
Elliptic Gaudin Model
23
which we call the twisted r matrix and let r˜ij (u, v; u) ˜ be its (i, j ) element. Then it has the following form: ˜ = −˜r22 (u, v; u) ˜ = −˜r33 (u, v; u) ˜ = r˜44 (u, v; u) ˜ = r˜11 (u, v; u) 0 0 (u) 0 (v) (u − v) θ11 θ11 1 θ11 = − − + , (3.17) 2 θ11 (u − v) θ11 (u) θ11 (v) ˜ = −˜r13 (v, u; u) ˜ = −˜r21 (u, v; −u) ˜ = r˜31 (v, u; −u) ˜ = r˜12 (u, v; u) ˜ = −˜r34 (u, v; u) ˜ = −˜r42 (v, u; −u) ˜ = r˜43 (u, v; −u) ˜ = = r˜24 (v, u; u) 0 ˜ −θ11 θ11 (v + u) , (3.18) = 2θ11 (u)θ ˜ 11 (v) ˜ = r˜41 (u, v; u) ˜ = 0, (3.19) r˜14 (u, v : u) 0 θ (u − v + u) ˜ −θ11 11 r˜23 (u, v; u) ˜ = r˜32 (u, v; −u) ˜ = . (3.20) θ11 (u − v)θ11 (u) ˜ Proof. The proof is given by a direct computation. For example, we have formulae like 1 ˜ θ10 (u)θ10 (u) ˜ θ11 (u)θ11 (u) ˜ −θ10 θ10 (u − u) 1 θ00 (u)θ00 (u) ˜ ˜ = M(u, u) ˜ −1 (iσ2 )M(u, u) ˜ θ11 (u)θ11 (u) ˜ −θ00 θ00 (u − u) 1 −θ01 (u)θ01 (u) ˜ ˜ = M(u, u) ˜ −1 σ3 M(u, u) ˜ θ01 θ01 (u − u) θ11 (u)θ11 (u) ˜ ˜ = M(u, u) ˜ −1 σ1 M(u, u)
θ10 θ10 (u + u) ˜ , −θ10 (u)θ10 (u) ˜ θ00 θ00 (u + u) ˜ , −θ00 (u)θ00 (u) ˜ −θ01 θ01 (u + u) ˜ , θ01 (u)θ01 (u) ˜
which follow from the addition theorems (cf. [14, pp. 20, 22] ) and the Landen transformation (cf. [13, §21.52]) of theta functions. Substituting them in the definition of r˜ (3.16) and using the addition theorems again, we can prove the lemma. u t Proof of Theorem 3.1. Using the formulae (3.14) and (3.15), we have 1 × ˆ ˆ i)k (∂u hCT i)j (∂u hCT h h∂ Cˆ T ih∂ Cˆ T i 1 2 1 2 h∂u˜ Cˆ k Tk i 1ˆ 2ˆ 1 2 u˜ j j u˜ k k hCˆ 0 Cˆ 0 {T , T }00 i − hC j C 0 {T , T }j 0 i × h∂u˜ Cˆ 0 T0 i2 h∂u˜ Cˆ 0 T0 i 1 2 1 2 i h∂u˜ Cˆ j Tj i 1 2 1 2 (3.21) hCˆ 0 Cˆ k {T , T }0k i + hCˆ j Cˆ k {T , T }j k i . − h∂u˜ Cˆ 0 T0 i
{xj , xk } =
1
2
1
2
Therefore computation of {xj , xk } reduces to computation of hCˆ j Cˆ k {T , T }j k i. As in Appendix B of [11], we have 1
2
1
2
1 2
1
2
ˆ k {T , T }j k i = tr1 tr2 ([8 ˆ , r˜ (xj , xk )](T˜ (xj ; u) ˆ9 ˆ j9 ˜ + T˜ (xk ; u))), ˜ h8
(3.22)
for any 8, 9 = A, B, C, D. Substituting 8 = 9 = C and using (3.19), we have 1
2
1
2
hCˆ j Cˆ k {T , T }j k i = 0. Thus (3.21) implies that {xj , xk } = 0.
24
E. K. Sklyanin, T. Takebe
A direct consequence of this is {xj , u} ˜ = 0, which follows from (3.9). Using these results and Lemma 3.2, we have for j 6 = k, 1
2
1
2
1
2
1
2
h∂ Cˆ T ihAˆ j Cˆ 0 {T , T }j 0 i − h∂u˜ Cˆ 0 T0 ihAˆ j Cˆ k {T , T }j k i ˜ j ), xk } = u˜ k k . {A(x ˆ T i)k h∂u˜ Cˆ 0 T0 i (∂u hC, 1
2
1
(3.23)
2
Hence we need to know hAˆ j Cˆ k {T , T }j k i and h∂u˜ Cˆ k Tk i. The former can be computed by (3.22) and (3.19) and we have 1
2
1
2
˜ A˜ k . hAˆ j Cˆ k {T , T }j k i = −2˜r12 (xj , xk ; u)
(3.24)
The factor h∂u˜ Cˆ k Tk i is computed as follows: ˆ T˜ (xk ; u)i ˜ −1 ∂u˜ M(xk ; u), ˜ C] ˜ = h∂u˜ Cˆ k Tk i = h[M(xk ; u) 0 ˜ θ θ11 (xk + u) A˜ k . = − 11 θ11 (xk )θ11 (u) ˜
(3.25)
˜ j ), xk } = 0 for j 6 = k. Substituting (3.24), (3.25) and (3.18) into (3.23), we have {A(x ˜ k )} = 0 is done in a similar way. In addition to the formulae ˜ j ), A(x The proof of {A(x we have shown above, we need 1
2
1
2
˜ C˜ j + r˜12 (xj , xk ; u) ˜ C˜ k , hAˆ j Aˆ k {T , T }j k i = r˜13 (xj , xk ; u) 0 θ (x + u) ˜ −θ11 11 k C˜ k . h∂u˜ Aˆ k Tk i = 2θ11 (xk )θ11 (u) ˜
(3.26) (3.27)
˜ j ), xj } = −1 requires special care, since the r Proof of the remaining equation {A(x matrix r(u) diverges at u = 0. Instead of (3.24), we use 1
2
1
2
hAˆ j Cˆ j {T , T }jj i = =
˜ − 2˜r12 (xj , xj ; u) ˜ A˜ j − lim r˜32 (u, xj ; u) ˜ B(u; u) ˜ u→xj
˜ j. ˜ A˜ j + (∂u B) − 2˜r12 (xj , xj ; u)
(3.28)
ˆ T i)j = (∂u B) ˜ j and substituting (3.28) and (3.25) into (3.23), we have Noting (∂u hC, ˜ j ), xj } = −1. u {A(x t ˜ j ) is an eigenvalue of Since B˜ is zero at u = xj , the dynamical variable Xj := −A(x T (xj ): 0 0 = Xj , (3.29) T˜ (xj ) 1 1 x +u˜ x +u˜ −θ01 j 2 ; τ2 −θ01 j 2 ; τ2 = Xj . (3.30) T (xj ) x +u˜ x +u˜ θ00 j 2 ; τ2 θ00 j 2 ; τ2 Thus if we define the characteristic polynomial by W (z, u) := det(z − T (u)),
(3.31)
Elliptic Gaudin Model
25
each pair of dynamical variables (xj , Xj ) satisfies an equation W (Xj , xj ) = 0,
(3.32)
for j = 1, . . . , N. Therefore, following the definition in [7], canonical variables (x1 , . . . , xN ; X1 , . . . , XN ) are separated variables of the classical elliptic Gaudin model. 4. Quantum System: General Case We return now to the quantum elliptic Gaudin model and construct the quantum separation of variables. The special case N = 1 is considered in the next section, Sect. 5. 4.1. Kernel function. Suppose that the representation space Vn = V `n (2.8) is realized as a space of functions on a certain space with coordinate yn and that the operators S a are differential operators on, e.g., polynomials or elliptic functions. The separating operator K is expressed as an integral operator Z K f (x1 , . . . , xN ) = dy1 · · · dyN 8(x1 , . . . , xN |y1 , . . . , yN )f (y1 , . . . , yN ), (4.1) which maps a function of (y1 , . . . , yN ) in V1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ VN to a function of N -variables xi on the elliptic curve C/Z + τ Z. Let us define the operator Xi as follows: ∂ − 3(xi ), Xi := ∂xi
3(x) =
N X n=1
`n
0 (x − z ) θ11 n . θ11 (x − zn )
(4.2)
Lemma 4.1. The following system of partial differential equations satisfies the Frobenius integrability condition: ˜ = 0, B˜ ∗ (xi ; u)8 ∗ ˜ ˜ = 0, (Xi + A (xi ; u))8
i = 1, . . . , N, i = 1, . . . , N,
(4.3) (4.4)
where P ∗ is the (formal) adjoint of a differential operator P with respect to (y1 , . . . , yN ) and we set u˜ =
N X n=1
zn −
N X
xj
(4.5)
j =0
for a certain constant x0 = ξ . Proof. This is a consequence of the commutation relation (2.13). By multiplying 1
2
˜ (v; u) ˜ from the right and its inverse from the left, we have M (u; u)M 1
2
1
2
˜ T˜ (v; u)] ˜ = [˜r (u, v; u), ˜ T˜ (u; u) ˜ + T˜ (v; u)]. ˜ [T˜ (u; u), Note that u˜ is not a dynamical variable in contrast to that in Sect. 3.
(4.6)
26
E. K. Sklyanin, T. Takebe
In order to show the consistency of Eqs. (4.3) for i and for j , we prove that [B˜ ∗ (xi ; u), ˜ is expressed as a linear combination of B˜ ∗ (xi ; u) ˜ and B˜ ∗ (xj ; u). ˜ Since the formal adjoint is an algebra anti-isomorphism, (P Q)∗ = Q∗ P ∗ , we have
B˜ ∗ (xj ; u)] ˜
˜ j ; u), ˜ i ; u)] ˜ B˜ ∗ (xj ; u)] ˜ = [B(x ˜ B(x ˜ ∗. [B˜ ∗ (xi ; u),
(4.7)
The (1,4)-element of (4.6) gives ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ B(u) − r˜12 (v, u; u) ˜ B(v)) [B(u; u), ˜ B(v; u)] ˜ = 2(˜r12 (u, v; u)
(4.8)
by virtue of (3.19) and (3.18). Replacing u and v in (4.8) by xi and xj respectively which are not dynamical, we obtain ˜ B˜ ∗ (xj ; u)] ˜ = [B˜ ∗ (xi ; u),
0 θ (x + u) ˜ ∗ ˜ ∗ θ11 θ 0 θ11 (xi + u) 11 j B˜ (xi ) − 11 B˜ (xj ), θ11 (xj )θ11 (u) ˜ θ11 (xi )θ11 (u) ˜
(4.9)
which means that Eq. (4.3) for i and for j are compatible. Next we show the compatibility condition ˜ Xj + A˜ ∗ (xj ; u)] ˜ = 0, [Xi + A˜ ∗ (xi ; u),
(4.10)
which implies the consistency of Eqs. (4.4) for i and for j (i 6= j ). It is obvious from (4.2) that [Xi , Xj ] = 0. Because of (4.5), we have ˜ =− [Xi , A˜ ∗ (xj ; u)]
(4.11)
∗ ∂ ˜ A(xj ; u) ˜ . ∂ u˜
By the same argument as that for (3.27) the right-hand side is rewritten as ˜ =− [Xi , A˜ ∗ (xj ; u)]
0 θ (u θ11 θ 0 θ11 (u˜ − xj ) ∗ 11 ˜ + xj ) ˜ ∗ C (xj ; u) B˜ (xj ; u). ˜ − 11 ˜ (4.12) 2θ11 (u)θ ˜ 11 (xj ) 2θ11 (u)θ ˜ 11 (xj )
Exchanging i and j , we have ˜ =− [Xj , A˜ ∗ (xi ; u)]
0 θ (u θ11 θ 0 θ11 (u˜ − xi ) ∗ 11 ˜ + xi ) ˜ ∗ C (xi ; u) B˜ (xi ; u). ˜ − 11 ˜ 2θ11 (u)θ ˜ 11 (xi ) 2θ11 (u)θ ˜ 11 (xi )
(4.13)
The (1,1)-element of (4.6) means ˜ A˜ ∗ (xj ; u)] ˜ = −˜r13 (xi , xj ; u) ˜ C˜ ∗ (xi ; u) ˜ − r˜12 (xi , xj ; u) ˜ C˜ ∗ (xj ; u) ˜ [A˜ ∗ (xi ; u), ∗ ∗ ˜ ˜ ˜ B (xi ; u) ˜ + r˜21 (xi , xj ; u) ˜ B (xj ; u). ˜ (4.14) +˜r31 (xi , xj ; u) Summing up (4.11), (4.12), (4.13) and (4.14), we have proved (4.10) because of (3.18). The consistency of (4.4) for i and (4.3) for j is shown as follows. First assume i 6 = j . Then the same computation as above gives ∗ ∂ ˜ ∗ ∗ ˜ ˜ B(xj ; u) ˜ B (xj ; u) ˜ = − ˜ + [A˜ ∗ (xi ; u), ˜ B˜ ∗ (xj ; u)] ˜ [Xi + A (xi ; u), ∂ u˜ 0 0 (x ) ˜ ∗ θ 0 θ (xi − xj − u) θ11 (xi − xj ) θ11 i − B˜ ∗ (xj ; u) B˜ (xi ; u). ˜ − 11 ˜ (4.15) = θ11 (xi − xj ) θ11 (xi ) θ11 (xi − xj )θ11 (u) ˜
Elliptic Gaudin Model
27
Thus we have proved the compatibility of (4.4) for i and (4.3) for j . Here we used ˜ θ 0 θ11 (xj + u) θ 0 (xj ) ∂ ˜ ˜ j ; u) ˜ j ; u), B(xj ; u) A(x B(x ˜ = − 11 ˜ + 11 ˜ ∂ u˜ θ11 (xj )θ11 (u) ˜ θ11 (xj )
(4.16)
and the (1,2)-element of (4.6). The case i = j is almost the same, but there is another term coming from ˜ [Xi , B˜ ∗ (xi ; u)]: ˜ B˜ ∗ (xi ; u)] ˜ = [Xi + A˜ ∗ (xi ; u), ∗ ∂ ˜ ∂ ˜ ∗ (u; u) B(x ˜ − ; u) ˜ + [A˜ ∗ (xi ; u), ˜ B˜ ∗ (xi ; u)]. ˜ B = i ∂u u=xi ∂ u˜
(4.17)
By the same computation as (3.28), it follows from the (1,2)-element of (4.6) that ˜ B˜ ∗ (xi ; u)] ˜ = [A˜ ∗ (xi ; u), 0 θ 0 θ11 (xi + u) ˜ ˜ ∗ θ (u) ∂ ˜ − 11 ˜ − ˜ (4.18) B˜ ∗ (u; u). A˜ (xi ; u) = 11 B˜ ∗ (xi ; u) θ11 (u) ˜ θ11 (xi )θ11 (u) ˜ ∂u u=xi Substituting (4.18) and (4.16) for j = i into (4.17), we obtain 0 θ 0 (xi ) ˜ θ11 (u) − 11 B˜ ∗ (xi ; u), ˜ B˜ ∗ (xi ; u)] ˜ = ˜ [Xi + A˜ ∗ (xi ; u), θ11 (u) ˜ θ11 (xi )
(4.19)
which proves the consistency of (4.4) for i and (4.3) for i. u t 4.2. Separating operator. The separating integral operator K is defined by (4.1) with the kernel function 8(x|y) satisfying Eqs. (4.3) and (4.4). Proposition 4.2. (i) For any function f of (y1 , . . . , yN ) in V1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ VN , we have ˜ i ; u)f ˜ ) = 0, K (B(x ˜ i ; u)f ˜ ) = Xi f. K (−A(x
(4.20) (4.21)
(ii) The elliptic Gaudin Hamiltonian τˆ (u) with the spectral parameter fixed to u = xi is transformed as follows. K (τˆ (xi )f )(x) = Xj2 K (f )(x),
(4.22)
where Xi is defined by (4.2). Proof. (i) is a direct consequence of (4.3) and (4.4) respectively. (ii) By Definition (2.9), K (τˆ (xi )f )(x) = Z 1 ˜ i ; u) ˜ i ; u) ˜ i ; u) ˜ i ; u))f ˜ i ; u) ˜ 2 + B(x ˜ C(x ˜ + C(x ˜ B(x ˜ (y) dy 8(x|y) (2A(x 2 Z Z ∗ 2 ˜ ˜ 8(x|y) f (y) dy + C˜ ∗ (xi ; u) ˜ B˜ ∗ (xi ; u)8(x|y) ˜ f (y) dy = (A (xi ; u)) Z 1 ˜ C˜ ∗ (xi ; u)]8(x|y) ˜ f (y) dy. (4.23) [B˜ ∗ (xi ; u), + 2
28
E. K. Sklyanin, T. Takebe
The first term in the right-hand side of (4.23) is rewritten by the following formula: ˜ 2 8(x|y) = −A˜ ∗ (xi )Xi 8(x|y) (A˜ ∗ (xi ; u))
= Xi2 8(x|y) + [Xi , A˜ ∗ (xi )]8(x|y),
(4.24)
where we used (4.4). The last term of (4.24) is ∂ ∂ ˜ ∗ (u; u) ˜ = ˜ − ˜ (4.25) A A˜ ∗ (u; u) [Xi , A˜ ∗ (xi ; u)] ∂u u=xi ∂ u˜ u=xi P P because u˜ = zn − xi . Hence, similarly to the derivation of (4.12), we can prove that θ 0 θ11 (u˜ + xi ) ∗ ∂ ∗ ˜ ˜ = ˜ − 11 ˜ A˜ ∗ (u; u) C˜ (xi ; u) [Xi , A (xi ; u)] ∂u u=xi 2θ11 (u)θ ˜ 11 (xi ) −
0 θ (u θ11 11 ˜ − xi ) ˜ ∗ B (xi ; u). ˜ 2θ11 (u)θ ˜ 11 (xi )
(4.26)
The (2, 3)-element of the commutation relation (4.6) gives 0 θ (u − u) ˜ θ11 11 ˜ B(u; u) ˜ θ11 (u)θ ˜ 11 (u) ˜ θ 0 θ11 (u + u) ˜ − 11 C(u; u) ˜ θ11 (u)θ ˜ 11 (u)
˜ ˜ ˜ − [B(u; u), ˜ C(u; u)] ˜ = 2A˜ 0 (u; u)
(4.27)
in the limit v → u. Substituting (4.24), (4.26) and (4.27) into (4.23) and using (4.3), we obtain (4.22). u t Equation (4.20) is a quantum version of (3.10) and Eq. (4.21) together with the canonical commutation relation [Xi , xj ] = δij means that operators (x1 , . . . , xN ; X1 , . . . , XN ) are the quantization of the classical separated variables in Sect. 3.2. The second statement of Proposition 4.2 provides a formal separation of variables for the quantum elliptic Gaudin model. Using the language of [8] and [9], the kernel 8(x|y) provides a Radon–Penrose transformation of the corresponding D-modules (cf. [15]). In principle, the quantum separation of variables should result in a one dimensional spectral problem for the separated equation (4.22) which is equivalent to the spectral problem for the original Hamiltonians (2.16). To achieve this goal one needs to specify an integration contour in (4.1) to study in detail the action of the integral operator K on the functional space V . Here we examine only the simplest case N = 1, leaving the general case for further study. 5. Quantum System: Case N = 1 In this section we examine the special case of N = 1. In this case, everything can be computed explicitly and we shall see that the separated equation is nothing but the classical Lamé equation and its generalization. We adopt the realization of the representation ρ ` of sl2 on the space of elliptic functions reviewed in Appendix B. We could use the standard realization on the space of sections of a line bundle over P1 , but the result is essentially the same up to coordinate transformation and gauge transformation. We omit the suffix n of zn and Sna for brevity.
Elliptic Gaudin Model
29
˜ u) ˜ 5.1. Separated variables. The quantum twisted B operator B(u; u) ˜ = B(u; ˜ is defined as in the classical case (3.3) or (3.2). Substituting (2.1) we obtain 0 θ11 ˜ θ10 (u − z)θ10 (u + u)S ˜ 1 B(u; u) ˜ = 2θ11 (u)θ11 (u)θ ˜ 11 (u − z) − θ00 (u − z)θ00 (u + u)iS ˜ 2 − θ01 (u − z)θ01 (u + u)S ˜ 3 . (5.1) The realization of the representation (B.2) gives the following expression: d ˜ + B˜ (0) (u; u), ˜ ˜ B(u; u) ˜ = B˜ (1) (u; u) dy
(5.2)
where ˜ = θ11 (u)−1 θ11 (u) ˜ −1 θ11 (u − z)−1 θ11 (2y)−1 B˜ (1) (u; u) z u˜ z u˜ × θ10 y + u − + θ10 y − u + − 2 2 2 2 z u˜ z u˜ θ10 −y + + , × θ10 −y − − 2 2 2 2
(5.3)
0 2`θ11 ˜ 11 (u − z)θ11 (y)2 θ11 (u + u)θ 2θ11 (u)θ11 (u)θ ˜ 11 (u − z)θ11 (y)2 z u˜ z u˜ z u˜ 2 + 2θ10 y + u − + θ10 −y + u − + θ10 − − . (5.4) 2 2 2 2 2 2
˜ = B˜ (0) (u; u)
A special point in the case N = 1 is that we can make use of the freedom of u˜ so that ˜ B(u; u) ˜ is a multiplication operator with the divisor of the form, ˜ div(B(u; u)) ˜ = [x] + [z] − [z] − [0] = [x] − [0]
(mod Z + τ Z),
(5.5)
˜ =0 as in the classical case, (3.8), (3.9). In fact, if we put u˜ = −z ± 2y + 1, B˜ (1) (u; u) by virtue of (5.3), and then (5.4) implies ˜ = B(u; u)| ˜ u=−z±2y+1 ˜
0 θ (u − z ± 2y) 2`θ11 11 . −2θ11 (u)θ11 (−z ± 2y)
(5.6)
(We substitute the variable “from the left”, namely we define d ˜ + B˜ (0) (u; −z ± 2y + 1). = B˜ (1) (u; −z ± 2y + 1) B(u; u)| ˜ u=−z±2y+1 ˜ dy Hereafter we always follow this normal ordering convention.) Therefore we can take x = z ∓ 2y in (5.5). This is the one of the “separated variables” in this case. ˜ In the classical model, Theorem 3.1, −A(x; u) ˜ is a dynamical variable canonically ˜ (3.3), is conjugate to x. This is also the case in the quantum model. The definition of A, rewritten in the form 0 θ11 ˜ ˜ 1 θ −1 θ10 (u − z)θ10 (u)θ10 (u)S A(u; u) ˜ = 2θ11 (u)θ11 (u)θ ˜ 11 (u − z) 10 −1 −1 − θ00 θ00 (u − z)θ00 (u)θ00 (u)iS ˜ 2 − θ01 θ01 (u − z)θ01 (u)θ01 (u)S ˜ 3 (5.7)
30
E. K. Sklyanin, T. Takebe
by (2.1). Substituting u˜ = −z ± 2y + 1 and u = x = z ∓ 2y (from the left), we obtain ˜ = A(u; u)| ˜ u=z∓2y,u=−z±2y+1 ˜ 0 0 θ (2y) 0 θ (2y) θ11 θ10 (2y) θ11 θ11 1 d 00 01 =± + 2` + + 2 dy θ10 θ11 (2y) θ00 θ11 (2y) θ01 θ11 (2y) ℘ 00 (y) 1 d −` 0 . (5.8) =± 2 dy ℘ (y) The last equality can be proved by comparing the poles of both sides. Therefore x = ˜ are the canonical conjugate variables z ∓ 2y and X := −A(u; u)| ˜ u=z∓2y,u=−z±2y+1 ˜ satisfying, [X, x] = 1.
(5.9)
We did not make use of the formulation in the previous sections explicitly. In fact, thanks to the special choice of u, ˜ 8 in (4.1) is a δ-function type kernel, which reduces the integral operator K to a coordinate transformation operator from y to x. 5.2. Solving the spectral problem. For the case N = 1, the generating function of the quantum integrals of motion τˆ (u) (u is the spectral parameter) 1X wa (u)2 (ρ (`) (S a ))2 2 3
τˆ (u) =
(5.10)
a=1
is explicitly written down. Here we shift the spectral parameter in the original definition (2.9) as u 7 → uz and set z = 0 for the sake of simplicity. Using (B.2) or (B.6) and various identities of elliptic functions in [13], we can expand the right hand side of (5.10): 1 d2 ℘ 00 (y) d d d2 , 2;u = + 4`(2` − 1)℘ (y) + 4`(` + 1)℘ (u) − 2` τˆ y, dy dy 4 dy 2 ℘ 0 (y) dy (5.11) or
d d2 ;λ , τˆ η, dη dη2
= (η − e1 )(η − e2 )(η − e3 ) 1 1 − 2` 1 1 d d2 + + + + × 2 dη 2 η − e1 η − e2 η − e3 dη `(2` − 1)η + `(` + 1)λ , (5.12) + (η − e1 )(η − e2 )(η − e3 )
where λ = ℘ (u). As is expected from Proposition 4.2 and the result for the rational Gaudin model in [6], operator τˆ (u) is factorized as follows when the spectral parameter u is fixed to a separated variable x1 = 2y. (We may also take x1 = −2y.): 2 d d2 ˜ = −A(u; u)| ˜ u=2y,u=2y+1 = X2 , (5.13) , 2 ; u τˆ y, ˜ dy dy u=2y
Elliptic Gaudin Model
31
which immediately follows from (5.7). (The operator X is defined before (5.9).) This is consistent with the general result (4.22). Equations (5.11) or (5.12) show that the spectral problem of the elliptic Gaudin model with N = 1 is an ordinary differential equation of second order on the elliptic curve C/Z + τ Z: d d2 (5.14) , 2 ; u ψ(y) = t (u)ψ(y), τˆ y, dy dy or on the projective line P1 (C): d d2 , 2 ; λ ψ(η) = t (λ)ψ(η). τˆ η, dη dη
(5.15)
Here t (u), t (λ) are eigenvalues of τˆ , ψ ∈ V (`) is an eigenvalue corresponding to this eigenvalue. Since operators τˆ (u) and Uα commute with each other by virtue of (B.12, B.13) and (5.10), we can decompose each eigenspace of τˆ (u) into those of Uα . Equation (5.14) has regular singularities: u = 0 (mod 0) with exponents −4`, −2` + 1, and u = ωα (α = 1, 2, 3, ω1 = 1, ω2 = τ , ω3 = 1 + τ ) with exponents 0, 2` + 1. Equation (5.15) has regular singularities: η = eα with exponents 0, (2` + 1)/2, and η = ∞ with 21 − `, −2`. If ` is an integer, these equations are ordinary Lamé equations, while for ` ∈ 21 +Z they are generalized Lamé equations studied by Brioschi, Halphen and Crawford. Following the classical theory of Lamé functions (see [13, Chap. XXIII]), we can solve the spectral problem (5.14), (5.15) in V (`) as follows. 5.2.1. Case ` ∈ Z. We want a solution ψ(η) of (5.15) such that ψ(η) ∈ V (`) . Let us assume that ψ(η) is expanded around the singular point eα as ψ(η) =
∞ X r=0
arα (η − eα )2`−r ,
(5.16)
a0 being 1. The condition ψ(η) ∈ V (`) means that arα = 0 for r > 2`. Substituting (5.16) into (5.15), we obtain the following recursion relation: α `(2` − 1) − 3(r − 1)(2` − r + 1) eα + E ar−1 r(` + 21 − r)arα = 3 α (eα − eβ )(eα − eγ )ar−2 + (2` − r + 2) ` − r + (5.17) 2 for r > 0 where E = `(` + 1)λ − t (λ). (Undefined coefficients arα for r < 0 are 0.) Hence, as a function of E, arα = arα (E) is a polynomial of degree r of the form arα (E) = Ar E r + O(E r−1 ),
Ar = r!
−1 1 `−r − +j . 2
r Y j =1
(5.18)
α (E) = 0 by Eiα (i = 1, . . . , 2` + 1). The recursion Let us denote the roots of a2`+1 α α relation (5.17) implies ar (Ei ) = 0 for r ≥ 2` + 1. Hence we obtain a polynomial
32
E. K. Sklyanin, T. Takebe
solution ψ(η) = ψ(η; Eiα ) of (5.15) of the form (5.16) for each i = 1, . . . , 2` + 1, provided that t (λ) = `(` + 1)λ − Eiα .
(5.19)
Conversely, if ψ(η) ∈ V (`) is a solution of the spectral problem (5.15), then there exists certain i for each α = 1, 2, 3 such that ψ(η) = ψ(η; Eiα ). This is proved by expanding the polynomial ψ(η) as in (5.16) and tracing back the above argument. Proposition 5.1. Assume that ω2 = τ is pure imaginary and that parameters zn are all real numbers. Then all Eiα are real and the spectral problem (5.15) is non-degenerate. Namely Eiα 6 = Ejα for distinct i, j and the solutions ψ(η; Eiα ) span the space V (`) . In 1 particular Eiα (i = 1, . . . , 2` + 1) for α = 1, 2, 3 coincide up to order, and a2`+1 (E) = α α 2 3 a2`+1 (E) = a2`+1 (E). Hence we can omit the index α for Ei and a2`+1 (E). Vector ψ(η; Ei ) is an eigenvector of Uα with eigenvalue (−1)` if a`α (Ei ) 6 = 0 and (−1)`+1 if a`α (Ei ) = 0. Proof. Under the assumption τ ∈ iR, operator τˆ (u) (u ∈ R) is an hermitian operator because of (B.11), and hence it is obvious that Eiα are real and that ψ(η; Eiα ) span V (`) . In order to show non-degeneracy of the spectral problem (5.15) we have only to prove that Ei2 are distinct with each other. Define ar2 (E), r < ` + 1, 2 a˜ r (E) := r−l ` + 1 ≤ r ≤ 2` + 1. (−1) ar2 (E), Then the leading coefficient of a˜ r2 is a˜ r2 (E) = A˜ r E r + O(E r−1 ),
A˜ r = |Ar |.
(5.20)
The recursion relation (5.17) is rewritten as 2 2 (E) − kr−2 a˜ r−2 (E), cr a˜ r2 (E) = qr a˜ r−1
(5.21)
where cr = r|` +
1 2
− r|,
`(2` − 1) − 3(r − 1)(2` − r + 1) eα + E, 3 = ` − r + (2` − r + 2)(e1 − e2 )(e2 − e3 ). 2
qr = kr
(5.22)
Since e1 > e2 > e3 under the assumption of the proposition, we have cr > 0 and kr > 0. This fact together with A˜ r > 0 (see (5.20)) implies that all the roots of a˜ r2 (E) are real and distinct by Sturm’s theorem (see, e.g., Chap. IX, §§4–5, [16]). This proves the first statement of the proposition. The operators Uα and τˆ commute and each eigenspace of τˆ is one-dimensional. Hence ψ(η; Ei ) is an eigenvector of Uα . Recall that Uα has eigenvalues (−1)` with multiplicity ` + 1 and (−1)`+1 with multiplicity `. (See §B.2.) If a`α (Ei ) 6= 0, then Uα ψ(η; Ei ) = (−1)` ψ(η; Ei ) because of (B.15). Hence there are at most ` + 1 of Ei ’s such that a`α (Ei ) 6 = 0. In other words, at least ` of Ei ’s satisfy a`α (Ei ) = 0. Since a`α (E) is a polynomial of degree `, this proves the second statement of the proposition. u t
Elliptic Gaudin Model
33
5.2.2. Case ` ∈ 21 + Z. As in the case ` ∈ Z, we consider an expansion (5.16) of a solution ψ(η) of the spectral problem (5.15), but this time we consider the series which terminate at r = ` − 21 : ψ(η) =
`−1/2 X r=0
arα (η − eα )2`−r .
They are parametrized by zeros of the polynomial a α
`+ 21
(5.23)
(E), {Eiα }i=1,...,`+ 1 as in the 2
previous case: ψ(η) = ψ(η; Eiα ). Another set of solutions are obtained from this set by applying the operator Uα : Uα ψ(η; Eiα )
`− 21
=
X r=0
a α 0r (Eiα )(η − eα )r ,
(5.24)
since Uα and τˆ (u) commute. The following proposition is proved in the same manner as Proposition 5.1. Proposition 5.2. Assume that ω2 = τ is pure imaginary and that parameters zn are all real numbers. Then all Eiα are real and Eiα 6 = Ejα for distinct i, j . The solutions ψ(η; Eiα ) and Uα ψ(η; Eiα ) span the space V (`) . In particular Eiα (i = 1, . . . , `+ 21 ) for α = 1, 2, 3 coincide up to order, and a 1 1 (E) = a 2 1 (E) = a 3 1 (E). Hence we can omit the index α for Eiα and a α
`+ 21
(E).
`+ 2
`+ 2
`+ 2
Vectors ψ(η; Ei ) ± Uα ψ(η; Ei ) are eigenvectors of Uα with eigenvalues ∓i. This proposition means that each eigenvalue Ei degenerates with multiplicity two. It was Crawford [17] who first found the relation of these two solutions (one is obtained from the other by operating U2 ) by the explicit expansions of type (5.23), (5.24). See also p.578 of [13]. A. Notations We use the notation for the theta functions with characteristics as follows (see [14]): for a, b = 0, 1, X 2 eπi(n+a/2) τ +2π i(n+a/2)(u+b/2) . (A.1) θab (u; τ ) = n∈Z
Unless otherwise specified, θab (u) = θab (u; τ ). We also use abbreviations d 0 θab = θab (u). θab = θab (0), du u=0
(A.2)
Quasi-periodicity properties of theta functions: θab (u) = (−1)a θab (u + 1) = eπ iτ +2π iu θab (u + τ ).
(A.3)
Parity of thetas: θ00 (−u) = θ00 (u), θ01 (−u) = θ01 (u), θ10 (−u) = θ10 (u), θ11 (−u) = −θ11 (u).
34
E. K. Sklyanin, T. Takebe
A.1. Weierstrass functions. Below we fix ω1 = 1 and ω2 = τ , " # Y u 2 1 u u + 1− exp σ (u) = u , ωmn ωmn 2 ωmn
(A.4)
m,n6=0
where ωmn = mω1 + nω2 , ζ (u) =
σ 0 (u) , σ (u)
℘ (u) = −ζ 0 (u),
σ (u + ωl ) = −σ (u)eηl (2u+ωl ) , ζ (u + ωl ) = ζ (u) + 2ηl , ℘ (u + ωl ) = ℘ (u), where ηl = ζ (ωl /2) , which satisfy η1 ω2 − η2 ω1 = π i. Sigma function is expressed by theta functions as follows: θ11 (u/ω1 ) 2 , σ (u) = ω1 eη1 u /ω1 0 θ11 σ (−u) = −σ (u), ζ (−u) = −ζ (u), ℘ (−z) = ℘ (u), ζ (u) = u−1 + O(u3 ), ℘ (u) = u−2 + O(u2 ). u∼0: σ (u) = u + O(u5 ), Other sigma functions are defined as follows: ω2 σ u + ω1 + η1 2 θ (u/ω ) 2 u 00 1 = e ω1 , σ00 (u) = e−(η1 +η2 )u + ω ω θ (0) 1 2 00 σ 2 ω 1 σ u+ 2 η1 2 θ (u/ω ) u 10 1 = e ω1 , σ10 (u) = e−η1 u ω θ (0) 10 σ 21 σ u + ω22 η1 2 θ (u/ω ) u 01 1 = e ω1 , σ01 (u) = e−η2 u ω θ (0) 2 01 σ 2 which satisfy σg1 g2 (u + ωl ) = (−1)gl eηl (2u+ωl ) σg1 g2 (u), σg1 g2 (0) = 1. σg1 g2 (−u) = σg1 g2 (u), Defining e1 = ℘ (ω1 /2), e2 = ℘ ((ω1 + ω2 )/2), e3 = ℘ (ω2 /2), we have 2 (u) σ 2 (u) σ 2 (u) σ10 + e1 = 00 + e2 = 01 + e3 = ℘ (u), 2 2 σ (u) σ (u) σ 2 (u) e1 + e2 + e3 = 0, 2 2 2 π π π 4 4 θ01 (0) , e1 − e3 = θ00 (0) , e2 − e3 = θ10 (0)4 . e1 − e2 = ω1 ω1 ω1 We also use normalized Weierstraß functions: d d θ11 (u), ℘11 (u) = − ζ11 (u). (A.5) ζ11 (u) = du du
Elliptic Gaudin Model
35
B. Realization of Spin ` Representations on an Elliptic Curve We recall here the following realization of the spin ` representation of the Lie algebra sl2 (C). Let e, f , h be the Chevalley generators and define S 1 = e+f , S 2 = −ie+if and S 3 = h. They satisfy the relation [S a , S b ] = 2iS c for any cyclic permutation (a, b, c) of (1, 2, 3) and represented by the Pauli matrices σ a . B.1. Spin ` representations. The representation space V (`) is realized by V (`) =
2` M
C℘ (y)k
k=0
= { even elliptic function f (y) | div(f ) ≥ −4`(Z + τ Z)}.
(B.1)
The generators S a act on this space as differential operators of first order: ρ (`) (S 1 ) =
θ10 (y)2 θ10 θ10 (2y) d + 2` , 0 θ11 θ11 (2y) dy θ11 (y)2
θ00 θ00 (2y) d θ00 (y)2 1 (`) 2 , ρ (S ) = 0 + 2` i θ11 θ11 (2y) dy θ11 (y)2 ρ (`) (S 3 ) =
θ01 (y)2 θ01 θ01 (2y) d + 2` , 0 θ11 θ11 (2y) dy θ11 (y)2
or in terms of usual Weierstraß functions, σ10 (2y) d (`) 1 + 2`(℘ (y) − e1 ) , ρ (S ) = a1 σ (2y) dy σ00 (2y) d (`) 2 + 2`(℘ (y) − e2 ) , ρ (S ) = a2 σ (2y) dy σ01 (2y) d (`) 3 + 2`(℘ (y) − e3 ) , ρ (S ) = a3 σ (2y) dy
(B.2)
(B.3)
where ea = ℘ (ωa¯ /2) (a¯ = 1, 3, 2, ω1 = 1, ω2 = τ , ω3 = 1 + τ ) for a = 1, 2, 3 respectively and 1 i 1 , a2 = √ , a3 = √ . a1 = √ √ √ √ e1 − e2 e1 − e3 e1 − e2 e2 − e3 e2 − e3 e1 − e3 (B.4) This realization is equivalent to the realization on the space of polynomials of degree ≤ 2` (or, sections of a line bundle on P1 (C)), e = x2
d − 2`x, dx
f =−
d , dx
h = 2x
d − 2`x, dx
via a coordinate transformation, x = −θ01 (y; τ/2)/θ00 (y; τ/2), and a gauge transformation: θ00 (y; τ/2) n ϕ(x(y)) ∈ V (`) . {polynomials in x} 3 ϕ(x) 7 → θ11 (y; τ )2
36
E. K. Sklyanin, T. Takebe
Note that this is also obtained by a gauge transformation from a quasi-classical limit of the representation of the Sklyanin algebra on theta functions [18]. The following expression is obtained from the coordinate transformation η = ℘ (y): V (`) =
2` M
Cηk ,
(B.5)
k=0
and S α acts on V (`) as d + 2`(η − eα ) . (B.6) ρ (`) (S α ) = aα ((eα − eβ )(eα − eγ ) − (η − eα )2 ) dη Let us assume that τ is a pure imaginary number. Then, as is well known (see, e.g., [13]), ea are real numbers and e1 > e2 > e3 . This implies that a1 and a3 are real, while a2 is purely imaginary. We introduce the following hermitian form in this representation space: for elliptic functions f (y), g(y) belonging to V (`) defined by (B.1), we define Z f (y¯2 ) g(y1 ) µ(y1 , y2 ), (B.7) hf, gi := C
where the 2-cycle C is defined by C := {(y1 , y2 ) ∈ (C/ 0)2 , y2 = y¯1 }, and the 2-form µ(y1 , y2 ) is defined by µ(y1 , y2 ) := (e1 − e2 )2(`+1) (e2 − e3 )2(`+1) σ (2y2 )σ (y2 )4` σ (2y1 )σ (y1 )4` dy2 ∧ dy1 (B.8) × 2(`+1) 2(`+1) 4i σ00 (y2 − y1 ) σ00 (y2 + y1 ) (℘ (y2 ) − e2 )(℘ (y1 ) − e2 ) −2(`+1) ℘ 0 (y2 )℘ 0 (y1 )dy2 ∧ dy1 . = 1+ (e1 − e2 )(e2 − e3 ) 4i This is nothing but a twisted version of the inner product introduced in [18]. If we take the description of V (`) of the form (B.5), this hermitian form is expressed as follows: Z hf, gi := f (η) ¯ g(η) µ(η, η), ¯ (B.9) C
where the 2-form µ(η, η) ¯ is defined by (η¯ − e2 )(η − e2 ) −2(`+1) d η¯ ∧ dη . µ(η, η) ¯ := 1 + (e1 − e2 )(e2 − e3 ) 2i An orthogonal basis with respect to this inner product is given by {(η − e2 )j }j =0,...,2` : h(η − e2 )j , (η − e2 )k i = 2π
(2j )!!(4` − 2j )!! (e1 − e2 )j +1 (e2 − e3 )j +1 δj k . (B.10) (4` + 2)!!
The generators S a of the Lie algebra sl2 act on the space V (`) as self-adjoint operators: hρ (`) (S a )f, gi = hf, ρ (`) (S a )gi.
(B.11)
This was first proved in [18], but we can check it directly by using formula (B.10). Hence, if u and zn are real numbers, the operator τˆ (u) defined by (2.9) and the integrals of motion Hn defined by (2.16) are hermitian operators on the Hilbert space V with respect to h·, ·i.
Elliptic Gaudin Model
37
B.2. Involutions. There are involutive automorphisms of the Lie algebra sl2 defined by Xa (S b ) = (−1)1−δab S b .
(B.12)
These automorphisms are induced on the spin ` representations as Xa (S b ) = Ua−1 S b Ua , where operators Ua : V (`) → V (`) are defined by 2` ω1 ℘ (y) − e1 πi` f y+ , (U1 f )(y) = e √ √ 2 e1 − e2 e1 − e3 2` ω1 + ω2 ℘ (y) − e2 , f y+ (U2 f )(y) = e2πi` √ √ 2 e1 − e2 e2 − e3 2` ω2 ℘ (y) − e3 −πi` f y+ , (U3 f )(y) = e √ √ 2 e1 − e3 e2 − e3
(B.13)
(B.14)
for a elliptic function f (y) ∈ V (`) (cf. [18]). They satisfy commutation relations Uα2 = (−1)2` ,
Uα Uβ = (−1)2` Uβ Uα = Uγ
for any cyclic permutation (α, β, γ ) of (1, 2, 3). The action of these operators on the bases {(η − eα )j }j =0,...,2` is: U1 (η − e1 )j = eπi` (e1 − e2 )j −` (e1 − e3 )j −` (η − e1 )2`−j , U2 (η − e2 )j = eπi(2`−j ) (e1 − e2 )j −` (e2 − e3 )j −` (η − e2 )2`−j , U3 (η − e3 )j = e−πi` (e1 − e3 )j −` (e2 − e3 )j −` (η − e3 )2`−j .
(B.15)
Hence eigenvalues of Ua are (−1)` with multiplicity `+1 and (−1)`+1 with multiplicity ` if ` is an integer, and ±i both with multiplicity ` + 21 if ` is a half of an odd integer. When ω1 = 1 and ω2 is a pure imaginary number, these operators are unitary with respect to the hermitian form (B.7). Acknowledgements. One of the authors (E.S.) is grateful to the Department of Applied Mathematics, University of Leeds, UK, where the main part of the paper was written, for hospitality, and acknowledges the support of EPSRC. The other one (T.T.) is grateful to the Department of Mathematics, University of California at Berkeley, USA, where some part of the work was done, for hospitality. He also acknowledges the support of Postdoctoral Fellowship for Research abroad of JSPS. Special thanks are given to Benjamin Enriquez and Vladimir Rubtsov who gave us their article [9] before publication and explained details.
References 1. 2. 3. 4.
Gaudin, M.: Diagonalisation d’une classe d’hamiltoniens de spin. J. de Physique 37, 1087–1098 (1976) Gaudin, M.: La fonction d’onde de Bethe. Paris: Masson, 1983 Baxter, R. J.: Exactly Solved Models of Statistical Mechanics. New York: Academic Press, 1982 Sklyanin, E.K., Takebe, T.: Algebraic Bethe Ansatz for XYZ Gaudin model. Phys. Lett. A 219, 217–225 (1996) 5. Babujian, H., Lima-Santos, A., Poghossian, R. H.: Knizhnik–Zamolodchikov–Bernard equations connected with the eight-vertex model. Preprint solv-int/9804015 6. Sklyanin, E.K.: Separation of Variables in the Gaudin model. Zapiski Nauchnykh Seminarov LOMI 164, 151–169 (1987) (in Russian); J. Sov. Math. 47, 2473–2488 (1989) (English transl.)
38
E. K. Sklyanin, T. Takebe
7. Sklyanin, E.K.: Separation of variables. New trends. In: Quantum field theory, integrable models and beyond (Kyoto, 1994). Progr. Theoret. Phys. Suppl. 118, 35–60 (1995) 8. Frenkel, E.: Affine algebras, Langlands duality and Bethe ansatz. XIth International Congress of Mathematical Physics (Paris, 1994), Cambridge, MA: Internat. Press, 1995, pp. 606–642 9. Enriquez, B., Feigin, B., Rubtsov, V.: Separation of variables for Gaudin–Calogero systems. Compositio Math. 110, 1–16 (1998) 10. Kuroki, G., Takebe, T.: Twisted Wess–Zumino–Witten models on elliptic curves. Commun. Math. Phys. 190, 1–56 (1997) 11. Sklyanin, E. K.: On Poisson structure of periodic classical XY Z-chain. Zapiski Nauchnykh Seminarov LOMI 150, 154–180 (1986) (in Russian); J. Sov. Math. 46, 1664–1683 (1989) (English transl.). 12. Takhtajan, L.A. and Faddeev, L.D.: The quantum method of the inverse problem and the Heisenberg XYZ Model. Uspekhi Mat. Nauk 34:5, 13–63 (1979) (in Russian); Russian Math. Surveys 34:5, 11–68 (1979) (English transl.) 13. Whittaker, E.T. and Watson, G.N.: A Course of Modern Analysis. 4th ed., Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1927 14. Mumford, D.: Tata Lectures on Theta I. Basel–Boston: Birkhäuser, 1982 15. D’Agnolo, A., Schapira, P.: Radon–Penrose transform for D-modules. J. Funct. Anal. 139, 349–382 (1996) 16. Dickson, L. E.: Elementary theory of equations, New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 1914 17. Crawford, L.: On the solution of Lamé’s equation d 2 U/du2 = U {n(n + 1)pu + B} in finite terms when 2n is an odd number. Quarterly J. Pure and Appl. Math. XXVIII, 93–98 (1895) 18. Sklyanin, E.K.: Some Algebraic Structures Connected with the Yang–Baxter Equation. Representations of Quantum Algebras. Funkts. analiz i ego Prilozh. 17-4, 34–48 (1983) (in Russian); Funct. Anal. Appl. 17, 273–284 (1984) (English transl.) Communicated by G. Felder
Commun. Math. Phys. 204, 39 – 60 (1999)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
© Springer-Verlag 1999
Double Quantization on Some Orbits in the Coadjoint Representations of Simple Lie Groups J. Donin1 , D. Gurevich2 , S. Shnider1 1 Department of Mathematics, Bar-Ilan University, 52900 Ramat-Gan, Israel 2 ISTV, Université de Valenciennes, 59304 Valenciennes, France
Received: 15 August 1998 / Accepted: 13 January 1999
Abstract: Let A be the function algebra on a semisimple orbit, M, in the coadjoint representation of a simple Lie group, G, with the Lie algebra g. We study one and two parameter quantizations Ah and At,h of A such that the multiplication on the quantized algebra is invariant under action of the Drinfeld–Jimbo quantum group, Uh (g). In particular, the algebra At,h specializes at h = 0 to a U (g)-invariant (G-invariant) quantization, At,0 . We prove that the Poisson bracket corresponding to Ah must be the sum of the socalled r-matrix and an invariant bracket. We classify such brackets for all semisimple orbits, M, and show that they form a dim H 2 (M) parameter family, then we construct their quantizations. A two parameter (or double) quantization, At,h , corresponds to a pair of compatible Poisson brackets: the first is as described above and the second is the Kirillov-KostantSouriau bracket on M. Not all semisimple orbits admit a compatible pair of Poisson brackets. We classify the semisimple orbits for which such pairs exist and construct the corresponding two parameter quantization of these pairs in some of the cases.
1. Introduction Passing from classical mechanics to quantum mechanics involves replacing the commutative function algebra, A, of classical observables on the phase space, M, with a noncommutative (deformed, quantized) algebra, At , of quantum observables (see [BFFLS] where the deformation quantization scheme is developed). The algebra A is a Poisson algebra and the product in the quantized algebra At is given by a power series in the formal parameter t with leading term equal to the original commutative product and with infinitesimal generator (the linear term in t, antisymmetrized) equal to the Poisson bracket. If the classical system is invariant under a Lie group of symmetries G, the associated quantum system often retains the same group of symmetries, that is, the product
40
J. Donin, D. Gurevich, S. Shnider
on At is invariant under the action of G, or, equivalently, under the action of the universal enveloping algebra U (g). Some modern field-theories, in particular those attempting to unify gravity and quantum field theory, investigate the possibility of deforming (quantizing) the group symmetry as well as the function algebra of the phase space. This is one of the reasons for the interest in quantum groups. The quantum group, Uh (g), defined by Drinfeld and Jimbo is a deformation of U (g) as a Hopf algebra. The quantization of the symmetry group together with the phase space corresponds to defining a Uh (g) invariant deformation of the algebra At . This leads us to the problem of finding a two parameter (or double) quantization, At,h , of a Poisson algebra with a U (g) invariant Poisson bracket. In other words, the problem of two parameter quantization arises if we want to quantize a Poisson bracket (appearing as the infinitesimal generator in t) in such a way that multiplication in the quantized algebra is invariant under the quantum group action (which depends on a deformation parameter h). In the present paper we investigate the problem of one and two parameter invariant quantizations of the Poisson function algebra on a semisimple orbit in the coadjoint representation of a simple Lie group. In general, if M is a manifold on which a semisimple Lie group G acts transitively, it is not true that there exists even a one parameter Uh (g) invariant quantization of the function algebra. In [DGM] it is proven that such a quantization exists if M = G/H and the Lie algebra of H contains a maximal nilpotent subalgebra. A Uh (g) invariant quantization of the algebra of holomorphic sections of a line bundle over a flag manifold is constructed by similar methods in [DG1]. In all these cases the Poisson bracket which is quantized is the r-matrix bracket, rM , on M. This bracket is determined by the bivector field (ρ ⊗ ρ)(r) for r ∈ ∧2 g, the Drinfeld–Jimbo r-matrix (of the form (3.3)), and ρ : g → Vect(M) is the mapping defined by the action of G on M. The Sklyanin–Drinfeld (SD) bracket on G is determined by the difference of two bivector fields on G which are the right and left invariant extensions of the Drinfeld– Jimbo classical r-matrix. For details see [LW]. In [DG2] it is shown that a one parameter Uh (g) invariant quantization of the SD bracket exists for all semisimple orbits in coadjoint representation of G. In the present paper we show that for the semisimple orbits, M, the SD bracket is one of a dim H 2 M parameter family of Poisson brackets admitting Uh (g) invariant quantization. For symmetric spaces M, the r-matrix bracket satisfies the Jacobi identity and hence defines a Poisson bracket. The existence of a one parameter Uh (g) invariant quantization with the r-matrix Poisson bracket is proven in [DS1]. That paper also proves that when M is a hermitian symmetric space there exists a two parameter Uh (g) invariant quantization. The hermitian symmetric spaces form a subclass of semisimple orbits in g∗ . These orbits have a very interesting property: the one-sided invariant components of the Sklyanin–Drinfeld bracket being reduced on such an orbit become Poisson brackets separately. More precisely, one of these components being reduced on M is the r-matrix bracket and the other one becomes the Kirillov–Kostant–Souriau (KKS) bracket which is roughly speaking the restriction to the orbit of the Lie bracket in g (see [KRR,DG1]). These brackets are obviously compatible (i.e. their Schouten bracket vanishes). So, we get a Poisson pencil which is the set of linear combinations of KKS and r-matrix Poisson brackets. The two parameter quantization, At,h , for hermitian symmetric spaces constructed in [DS1] is just a quantization of such a pencil. In particular, At,0 is a U (g) invariant quantization of the KKS bracket on M.
Double Quantization on Some Orbits of Simple Lie Groups
41
The orbits in g∗ on which the r-matrix bracket is Poisson have been classified in [GP]. In particular, the only such semisimple orbits are symmetric spaces. It turns out that there exist two parameter Uh (g) invariant quantizations on some G-manifolds where the r-matrix bracket is not Poisson (does not satisfy the Jacobi identity) but one can add a G-invariant bracket to the r-matrix bracket and get a Poisson bracket. For example, in [Do] it is shown that for g = sl(n) there is a two parameter Uh (g) invariant family (Sg)t,h , where Sg is the symmetric algebra of g which can be considered as the function (polynomial) algebra on g∗ . It is proven that this family can be restricted to give a two parameter quantization on any semisimple orbit of maximal dimension (on which the r-matrix bracket may not be Poisson). In the present paper we prove the existence of a two parameter Uh (g) invariant quantization of the function algebra for some non-symmetric semisimple orbits in g∗ . Similar to the case of symmetric orbits, the quasiclassical (infinitesimal) term of this quantization is a Poisson pencil generated by the KKS bracket and another Poisson bracket which must be the sum of the r-matrix and an U (g) invariant brackets. In particular, we shall see that such pencils exist for all semisimple orbits in case g = sl(n). Note that for non-symmetric orbits both the r-matrix bracket and the SD Poisson bracket are not compatible with the KKS bracket. We give a complete classification of the orbits admitting such a Poisson pencil. Moreover, we classify all such pencils and construct the deformation quantization of some of them. We now describe the content of the paper in more detail. Let G be a simple, connected, complex Lie group, g its Lie algebra. The Drinfeld–Jimbo quantum group Uh (g) can be considered as the algebra U (g)[[h]] with undeformed multiplication but deformed noncommutative comultiplication 1h . Let M be a G-homogeneous complex manifold. It is easy to show that M is isomorphic to a semisimple orbit of G in the coadjoint representation g∗ if and only if the stabilizer, Go , of a point o ∈ M is a Levi subgroup in G (see Sect. 3 for definition). The G-invariant symplectic structure on M is not unique, but each such symplectic structure on M arises from an isomorphism of M with an orbit, Oλ , for some semisimple element λ ∈ g∗ . On Oλ there is the Kirillov–Kostant–Souriau (KKS) Poisson bracket, vλ , whose action on the restriction of linear functions to the orbit is given by the Lie bracket in g. Each Ginvariant symplectic structure on M is induced from the KKS bracket by an isomorphism of M onto a semisimple orbit (see Sect. 3). The first problem we consider is that of quantizing the algebra A of polynomial (or holomorphic) functions on M, such that the quantized algebra Ah has a Uh (g) invariant multiplication ∞ X h i µi , µh = i=0
where µ0 is the initial multiplication of functions and the µi for i ≥ 1 are bidifferential operators. Invariance means that µh satisfies the property µh 1h (x)(a ⊗ b) = xµh (a ⊗ b)
for x ∈ Uh (g), a, b ∈ A.
The second problem we consider is the existence of a two parameter Uh (g) invariant quantization, At,h , of A such that the one parameter family At,0 is a U (g) invariant quantization of the KKS bracket on M. The infinitesimal of the one parameter quantization Ah is a Poisson bracket, whereas the infinitesimal of the two parameter quantization is a pencil of two compatible Poisson brackets.
42
J. Donin, D. Gurevich, S. Shnider
In Sect. 2 we recall some facts on the Drinfeld monoidal categories of quantum group representations, used in our construction of quantization. In addition, we show that the Poisson bracket, p(a, b) = µ1 (a, b) − µ1 (b, a), corresponding to the Uh (g) invariant quantization Ah must be of a special form. Namely, let r ∈ ∧2 g be the Drinfeld–Jimbo classical r-matrix. The Schouten bracket [[r, r]] ∈ ∧3 g is the invariant element ϕ, which is unique up to a factor. Denote by rM the bracket on M determined by the bivector field (ρ ⊗ ρ)(r) where ρ : g → Vect(M) is the mapping defined by the action of G on M. We call rM an r-matrix bracket. Put also ϕM = ρ ⊗3 ϕ. Then, p(a, b) has the form p(a, b) = rM (a, b) + f (a, b),
a, b ∈ A,
(1.1)
where f (a, b) is a U (g) invariant bracket with the Schouten bracket [[f, f ]] = −ϕM .
(1.2)
Note that the r-matrix bracket is compatible with any invariant bracket, i.e. [[f, rM ]] = 0. Similarly, the two parameter quantization At,h corresponds to a pair of compatible Poisson brackets, (p, vλ ), where p = rM + f of the form (1.1) and vλ is the KKS bracket. Since rM is compatible with the invariant bracket vλ , compatibility of p with vλ is equivalent to the condition [[f, vλ ]] = 0.
(1.3)
In Sect. 3 we give a classification of all invariant brackets f satisfying condition (1.2) for all M isomorphic to semisimple orbits. We show that such brackets form a dim H 2 (M) parameter family. In the same section we show that a semisimple orbit may not have any invariant brackets satisfying conditions (1.2) and (1.3). We call an orbit a “good orbit”, if such a bracket exists and then give a classification of all good orbits. Namely, if g is of type An , all semisimple orbits are good. All orbits which are symmetric spaces are good. In cases Dn , E6 there are good orbits which are not symmetric spaces. Moreover, for the good orbits the brackets satisfying conditions (1.2) and (1.3) form a one parameter family. In fact, the property of an orbit being good depends only on its structure as a homogeneous manifold, not on the symplectic structure. The dependence is on the Lie subalgera of the stabilizer subgroup. So, if an orbit M is good, then any orbit isomorphic to M as a homogeneous manifold will be good. In Sect. 4 we consider cohomologies of the complex of invariant polyvector fields on M with differential given by the Schouten bracket with the bivector f satisfying (1.2). We show that for almost all f these cohomologies coincide with the usual de Rham cohomologies of the manifold M and then use this fact in Sect. 5 to prove the existence of an invariant quantization. In the proof we use methods of [DS1] and [DS2]. Using the same methods, we also construct the two parameter quantization for good orbits in cases Dn , E6 and brackets satisfying (1.2) and (1.3). For the case An some additional arguments are required. (See [Do] where using another method the existence of two parameter quantization for maximal orbits is proven.) In conclusion we make two remarks. Remark 1.1. Throughout this paper G is supposed to be a complex Lie group. However, one can consider the situation when G is a real simple Lie group with Lie algebra gR and M is a semisimple orbit of G in g∗R . In this case we take A = C ∞ (M), the complexvalued smooth functions. Let g be the complexification of gR . It is clear that the Lie algebra g and algebra U (g) act on C ∞ (M). Since all our results are formulated in terms of g action, they are valid in the real case as well (see also [DS1]).
Double Quantization on Some Orbits of Simple Lie Groups
43
Remark 1.2. The deformation quantization can be considered as the first step of a quantization procedure whose second step is a representation of the quantized algebra, At,h , as an operator algebra in a linear space. For some symmetric orbits in sl(n)∗ such a representation has been given in [DGR] and [DGK], but the method of [DGK] can be apparently extended to all symmetric orbits in g∗ for all simple Lie algebras g. These operator algebras have a deformed Uh (g) invariant trace which, however, is not symmetric. 2. Poisson Brackets Associated with Uh (g) Invariant Quantization We recall some facts about Drinfeld algebras and the monoidal categories determined by them. They will be used, in particular, in our construction of the quantization. Let A be a commutative algebra with unit, B a unitary A-algebra. The category of representations of B in A-modules, i.e. the category of B-modules, will be a monoidal category if the algebra B is equipped with an algebra morphism, 1 : B → B ⊗A B, called comultiplication, and an invertible element 8 ∈ B ⊗3 such that 1 and 8 satisfy the conditions (see [Dr1]) (id ⊗2
(id ⊗ 1)(1(b)) · 8 = 8 · (1 ⊗ id)(1(b)), b ∈ B, (2.1) ⊗2 ⊗ 1)(8) · (1 ⊗ id )(8) = (1 ⊗ 8) · (id ⊗ 1 ⊗ id)(8) · (8 ⊗ 1). (2.2)
Define a tensor product functor for C the category of B modules, denoted ⊗C or simply ⊗ when there can be no confusion, in the following way: given B-modules M, N, M ⊗C N = M ⊗A N as an A-module. The action of B is defined by b(m ⊗ n) = (1b)(m ⊗ n) = b1 m ⊗ b2 n,
where 1b = b1 ⊗ b2 ,
using the Sweedler convention of an implicit summation over an index. The element 8 = 81 ⊗ 82 ⊗ 83 defines the associativity constraint, aM,N,P : (M ⊗N)⊗P → M ⊗(N ⊗P ), aM,N,P ((m⊗n)⊗p) = 81 m⊗(82 n⊗83 p). Again the summation in the expression for 8 is understood. By virtue of (2.1) 8 induces an isomorphism of B-modules, and by virtue of (2.2) the pentagon identity for monoidal categories holds. We call the triple (B, 1, 8) a Drinfeld algebra. The definition is somewhat non-standard in that we do not require the existence of an antipode. The category C of B-modules for B a Drinfeld algebra becomes a monoidal category. When it becomes necessary to be more explicit we shall denote C(B, 1, 8). Let (B, 1, 8) be a Drinfeld algebra and F ∈ B ⊗2 an invertible element. Put e (b) = F1(b)F −1 , b ∈ B, 1 e = (1 ⊗ F ) · (id ⊗ 1)(F ) · 8 · (1 ⊗ id)(F −1 ) · (F ⊗ 1)−1 . 8
(2.3) (2.4)
e and 8 e satisfy (2.1) and (2.2), therefore the triple (B, 1 e, 8 e) also becomes a Then 1 e 1 e, 8 e). Drinfeld algebra which has an equivalent monoidal category of modules, C(B, Note that the equivalent categories C and Ce consist of the same objects as B-modules, and the tensor products of two objects are isomorphic as A-modules. The equivalence C → Ce is given by the pair (I d, F ), where I d : C → Ce is the identity functor of the categories (considered without the monoidal structures, but only as categories of B-modules), and F : M ⊗C N → M ⊗Ce N is defined by m ⊗ n 7 → F1 m ⊗ F2 n, where F 1 ⊗ F2 = F .
44
J. Donin, D. Gurevich, S. Shnider
Assume A is a B-module with a multiplication µ : A ⊗A A → A which is a homomorphism of A-modules. We say that µ is 1 invariant if bµ(x ⊗ y) = µ1(b)(x ⊗ y) for b ∈ B, x, y ∈ A,
(2.5)
and 8 associative, if µ(81 x ⊗ µ(82 y ⊗ 83 z))) = µ(µ(x ⊗ y) ⊗ z) for x, y, z ∈ A.
(2.6)
Note that a B-module A equipped with 1 invariant and 8 associative multiplication is an associative algebra in the monoidal category C(B, 1, 8). The multiplication e µ= e e-associative and invariant in the category C. µF −1 : M ⊗A M → M will be 8 We are interested in the case when A = C[[h]], B = U (g)[[h]], where g is a complex simple Lie algebra. In this case, all tensor products over C[[h]] are completed in h-adic topology. Denote by ϕ ∈ ∧⊗3 g an invariant element (unique up to scaling for g simple) and by r ∈ ∧⊗2 g the so-called Drinfeld–Jimbo r-matrix of the form (3.3) such that the Schouten bracket of r with itself is equal to ϕ: [[r, r]] = ϕ.
(2.7)
In [Dr1], Drinfeld proved the following (see also [DS2] for the property c)). Proposition 2.1. 1. There is an invariant element 8 = 8h ∈ U (g)[[h]]⊗3 of the form 8h = 1 ⊗ 1 ⊗ 1 + h2 ϕ + · · · satisfying the following properties: a) it depends on h2 , i.e. 8h = 8−h ; b) it satisfies Eqs. (2.1) (i.e. invariant) and (2.2) with the usual 1 arising from U (g); c) it is invariant under the Cartan involution θ ; 321 321 = 8 ⊗ 8 ⊗ 8 for 8 = 8 ⊗ 8 ⊗ 8 . d) 8−1 3 2 1 1 2 3 h = 8h , where 8 2. There is an element F = Fh ∈ U (g)[[h]]⊗2 of the form Fh = 1 ⊗ 1 + (h/2)r + · · · e = 1 ⊗ 1 ⊗ 1. satisfying Eq. (2.4) with the usual 1 and with 8 This proposition implies that there are two nontrivial Drinfeld algebras: the first, (U (g)[[h]], 1, 8h ) with the usual comultiplication and 8 from Proposition 2.1, and the e , 1), where 1 e (x) = Fh 1(x)F −1 for x ∈ U (g). The pair (I d, Fh ) second, (U (g)[[h]], 1 h defines an equivalence between the corresponding monoidal categories C(U (g)[[h]], e , 1). 1, 8h ) and C(U (g)[[h]], 1 It is clear that reduction modulo h defines a functor from either of these categories to the category of representations of U (g) and the equivalence just described reduces to the identity modulo h. In fact, both categories are C[[h]]-linear extensions of the C-linear category of representations of g. Ignoring the monoidal structure the extension is a trivial e in the second case one, but the associator 8 in the first case and the comultiplication 1 make the extension non-trivial from the point of view of monoidal categories. e is denoted by Uh (g) and is The bialgebra U (g)[[h]] with comultiplication 1h = 1 isomorphic to the Drinfeld–Jimbo quantum group ([Dr1]). Let A be a U (g) invariant commutative algebra, i.e. an algebra with U (g) invariant multiplication µ in the sense of (2.5). A quantization of A is an associative algebra, Ah , which is isomorphic to A[[h]] = A ⊗ C[[h]] (completed tensor product) as a C[[h]]module, with multiplication in Ah having the form µh = µ + hµ1 + o(h). The Poisson bracket corresponding to the quantization is given by {a, b} = µ1 (a, b) − µ1 (b, a), a, b ∈ A.
Double Quantization on Some Orbits of Simple Lie Groups
45
In general, we call a skew-symmetric bilinear form A ⊗ A → A a bracket, if it satisfies the Leibniz rule in either argument when the other is fixed. The term Poisson bracket indicates that the Jacobi identity is also true. A bracket of the form {a, b}r = (r1 a)(r2 b) = µ(r1 a, r2 b)
a, b ∈ A,
(2.8)
where r = r1 ⊗ r2 (summation implicit) is the representation of the r-matrix r will be called an r-matrix bracket. Assume, Ah is a Uh (g) invariant quantization, i.e. the multiplication µh is 1h invariant. We shall show that in this case the Poisson bracket {·, ·} has a special form. Suppose f and g are two brackets on A. Then we define their Schouten bracket [[f, g]] as [[f, g]](a, b, c) = f (g(a, b), c) + g(f (a, b), c) + cyclic permutations of a, b, c.(2.9) Then [[f, g]] is a skew-symmetric map A⊗3 → A. We call f and g compatible, if [[f, g]] = 0. Proposition 2.2. Let A be a U (g) invariant commutative algebra and Ah a Uh (g) invariant quantization. Then the corresponding Poisson bracket has the form {a, b} = f (a, b) − {a, b}r ,
(2.10)
where f (a, b) is a U (g) invariant bracket. The brackets f and {·, ·}r are compatible and [[f, f ]] = −ϕA , where ϕA (a, b, c) = (ϕ1 a)(ϕ2 b)(ϕ3 c) and ϕ1 ⊗ ϕ2 ⊗ ϕ3 = ϕ ∈ ∧3 g is the invariant element given by (2.7). ⊗2 Proof. The permutation σ : A⊗2 h → Ah , a ⊗ b → b ⊗ a, is an equivariant operator in the category C(U (g)[[h]], 1, 8h ), because 1 is a cocommutative comultiplication. e , 1) implies that The equivalence of categories C(U (g)[[h]], 1, 8h ) and C(U (g)[[h]], 1 the operator e σ = F σ F −1 on A⊗2 is equivariant under the action of the quantum group Uh (g). Suppose the multiplication in Ah has the form µh (a, b) = ab + hµ1 (a, b) + o(h). It is easy to calculate that
1 σ )(a ⊗ b) = µ1 (a, b) − µ1 (b, a) + (r1 a)(r2 b) + O(h) µh (I d − e h = {a, b} + {a, b}r + O(h). But this is a Uh (g) equivariant operator A⊗2 h → Ah . Taking h = 0 we obtain that the bracket f (a, b) = {a, b} + {a, b}r must be U (g) invariant. So, we have {a, b} = f (a, b) − {a, b}r , as required. It is easy to check that any bracket of the form {a, b} = (X1 a)(X2 b) = µ(X1 a, X2 b), for X1 ⊗ X2 ∈ g ∧ g, is compatible with any invariant bracket. In particular, an r-matrix bracket is compatible with f . In addition, {·, ·} is a Poisson bracket, so its Schouten bracket with itself is equal to zero. Using this and taking into account that the Schouten bracket of the r-matrix bracket with itself is equal to ϕA , we obtain from (2.10) that t [[f, f ]] = −ϕA . u Remark 2.1. a) It is clear that if r satisfies (2.7), then −r satisfies (2.7), too, and we may fh with leading terms 1 ⊗ 1 − (h/2)r. Then, instead replace Fh in Proposition 2.1 with F (2.10) we can write {a, b} = f (a, b) + {a, b}r .
46
J. Donin, D. Gurevich, S. Shnider
b) Assume that At,h is a two parameter quantization of A, i.e. a topologically free C[[t, h]]-module with a multiplication of the form µt,h (a, b) = ab + hµ1 (a, b) + tµ01 (a, b) + o(t, h). Assume, that At,h is Uh (g) invariant, so that At,0 is U (g) invariant. Then there are two compatible Poisson brackets corresponding to such a quantization: the bracket µ1 (a, b) − µ1 (b, a) of the form (2.10) and the U (g) invariant bracket v(a, b) = µ01 (a, b) − µ01 (b, a). Since v is invariant, the compatibility is equivalent to [[f, v]] = 0. e , 1), c) In view of equivalence of the categories C(U (g)[[h]], 1, 8h ) and C(U (g)[[h]], 1 the problem of quantizing the algebra A may be considered in the first category. If Ah is a Uh (g) invariant quantization with multiplication µh , then the multiplication µ¯ h = µh Fh = µ + hµ¯ 1 + o(h) will be U (g) invariant and 8h associative in the sense of (2.6). We have µ¯ 1 (a, b)− µ¯ 1 (b, a) = f (a, b), where f is from (2.10). So, we see that the invariant bracket f from (2.10) with [[f, f ]] = −ϕA plays the role of Poisson bracket for 8h associative quantization. Similarly, the two parameter quantization At,h corresponds to the U (g) invariant 8h associative quantization in C(U (g)[[h]], 1, 8h ) with a pair of compatible invariant brackets f and v, where [[f, f ]] = −ϕA and [[v, v]] = 0. Working in the category C(U (g)[[h]], 1, 8h ) can simplify the process of quantization (see [DS1] and Sect. 5). In the next section we consider the case when A is a function algebra on a semisimple orbit in the coadjoint representation of g and we give a classification of the invariant brackets f satisfying the property [[f, f ]] = −ϕA . Moreover, among such f we distinguish those which are compatible with the KKS Poisson brackets. 3. Pairs of Brackets on Semisimple Orbits Let g be a simple complex Lie algebra, h a fixed Cartan subalgebra. Let ⊂ h∗ be the system of roots corresponding to h. Select a system of positive roots, + , and denote by 5 ⊂ the subset of simple roots. Fix an element Eα ∈ g of weight α for each α ∈ + and choose E−α such that (Eα , E−α ) = 1 for the Killing form (·, ·) on g. Then, for all pairs of roots α, β such that α + β 6 = 0 we define the numbers Nα,β in the following way: [Eα , Eβ ] = Nα,β Eα+β Nα,β = 0
if α + β ∈ , if α + β ∈ / .
These numbers satisfy the following property, [He]. For the roots α, β, γ such that α + β + γ = 0 one has Nα,β = Nβ,γ = Nγ ,α .
(3.1)
Let 0 be a subset of 5. Denote by h∗0 the subspace in h∗ generated by 0. Note that ∗ h = h∗0 ⊕h∗5\0 , and one can identify h∗5\0 and h∗ /h∗0 via the projection h∗ → h∗ /h∗0 . Let 0 ⊂ h∗0 be the subsystem of roots in generated by 0, i.e. 0 = ∩ h∗0 . Denote by g0 the subalgebra of g generated by the elements {Eα , E−α }, α ∈ 0, and h. Such a subalgebra is called the Levi subalgebra. Let G be a complex connected Lie group with Lie algebra g and G0 a subgroup with Lie algebra g0 . Such a subgroup is called the Levi subgroup. It is known that G0 is a connected subgroup. Let M be a homogeneous space of G and G0 be the stabilizer of a point o ∈ M. We can identify M and the coset space G/G0 . It is known that such M is isomorphic to a semisimple orbit in g∗ . This orbit goes through an element λ ∈ g∗
Double Quantization on Some Orbits of Simple Lie Groups
47
which is just the trivial extension to all of g∗ (identifying g and g∗ via the Killing form) of a map λ : h5\0 → C such that λ(α) 6 = 0 for all α ∈ 5 \ 0. Conversely, it is easy to show that any semisimple orbit in g∗ is isomorphic to the quotient of G by a Levi subgroup. The projection π : G → M induces the map π∗ : g → To , where To is the tangent space to M at the point o. Since the ad-action of g0 on g is semisimple, there exists an ad(g0 )-invariant subspace m = m0 of g complementary to g0 , and one can identify To and m by means of π∗ . It is easy to see that the subspace m is uniquely defined and has a basis formed by the elements Eγ , E−γ , γ ∈ + \ 0 . Let v ∈ g⊗m be a tensor over g. Using the right and the left actions of G on itself, one can associate with v right and left invariant tensor fields on G denoted by v r and v l . We say that a tensor field, t, on G is right G0 invariant, if t is invariant under the right action of G0 . The G equivariant diffeomorphism between M and G/G0 implies that any right G0 invariant tensor field t on G induces a tensor field π∗ (t) on M. The field π∗ (t) will be invariant on M if, in addition, t is left invariant on G, and any invariant tensor field on M can be obtained in such a way. Let v ∈ g⊗m . For v l to be right G0 invariant it is necessary and sufficient that v be ad(g0 ) invariant. Denote π r (v) = π∗ (v r ) for any tensor v on g and π l (v) = π∗ (v l ) for any ad(g0 ) invariant tensor v on g. Note that the tensor π r (v) coincides with the image of v by the map g⊗m → Vect(M)⊗m induced by the action map g → Vect(M). Any G invariant tensor on M has the form π l (v). Moreover, v clearly can be uniquely chosen from m⊗m . Denote by [[v, w]] ∈ ∧k+l−1 g the Schouten bracket of the polyvectors v ∈ ∧k g, w ∈ ∧l g, defined by the formula X (−1)i+j [Xi , Yj ] ∧ X1 ∧ · · · Xˆ i · · · Yˆj · · · ∧ Yl , [[X1 ∧ · · · ∧ Xk , Y1 ∧ · · · ∧ Yl ]] = where [·, ·] is the bracket in g. The Schouten bracket is defined in the same way for polyvector fields on a manifold, but instead of [·, ·] one uses the Lie bracket of vector fields. We will use the same notation for the Schouten bracket on manifolds. It is easy to see that π r ([[v, w]]) = [[π r (v), π r (w)]], and the same relation is valid for π l . Denote by 0 the image of in h∗5\0 without zero. It is clear that 5\0 can be identified with a subset of 0 and each element from 0 is a linear combination of elements from 5\0 with integer coefficients which are all positive or all negative. Thus, + the subset 0 ⊂ 0 of the elements with positive coefficients is exactly the image of + . We call elements of 0 quasiroots and the images of 5 \ 0 simple quasiroots. Proposition 3.1. a) Let β and β 0 be roots from such that they give the same element in 0 . Then there exist roots α1 , . . . , αk ∈ 0 such that β + α1 + · · · + αk = β 0 and all partial sums β + α1 + · · · + αi , i = 1, . . . , k are roots. b) Let β¯1 , . . . , β¯k , β¯ be elements of 0 such that β¯ = β¯1 + · · · + β¯k . Then there exist representatives of these elements in such that β = β1 + · · · + βk . Proof. a) Let β 0 = β + γ1 + · · · + γm , where γi ∈ 0 ∪ −0. If (β 0 , β) > 0, then β 0 − β is a root, and the proposition follows. Proceed by induction on m. Since (β 0 , β 0 ) > 0, if (β 0 , β) ≤ 0, then there exist a γi , say γm , such that (β 0 , γm ) > 0, so β 0 − γm is a root and β 0 − γm = β + γ1 + · · · + γm−1 . By induction, the proposition holds for the pair β 0 − γm and β, i.e. there exist a representation β + α1 + · · · + αk−1 = β 0 − γm satisfying the proposition. Now, putting αk = γm , we obtain the required representation of β 0 . ¯ Then b) Let β10 , . . . , βk0 , β 0 be some representatives of elements β¯1 , . . . , β¯k , β¯ in . we have the equation β10 + · · · + βk0 + γ1 + · · · + γm = β 0 for some γi ∈ 0 ∪ −0,
48
J. Donin, D. Gurevich, S. Shnider
i = 1, . . . , m. If (γi , β 0 ) > 0, then β 0 − γi is a root, and we can take β 0 − γi instead β 0 . After iteration, we can assume that all (γi , β 0 ) ≤ 0. Then, there exists a βi0 , say βk0 , such that (βk0 , β 0 ) > 0, so β 0 − βk0 is a root. Applying induction on k, one can suppose that there are representatives β1 , . . . , βk−1 of β¯1 , . . . , β¯k−1 , such that we have an equation β1 + · · · + βk−1 = β 0 − βk0 + γ1 + · · · + γn for some γi ∈ 0 ∪ −0, i = 1, . . . , n, and ˜ γi ) > 0, then for some βj , say β1 , (β1 , γi ) > 0, β˜ = β1 + · · · + βk−1 is a root. If (β, β1 − γi is a root, and one can replace β1 by β1 − γi . Repeating this argument we can ˜ (β 0 − β 0 )) ≥ 0, so either (β, ˜ β 0 ) > 0, and we set ˜ γi ) ≤ 0. Then (β, assume that all (β, k P P 0 0 0 0 ˜ −β ) > 0, and we set βk = β and β = β 0 + γi . In βk = βk − γi , β = β , or (β, k k ¯ u t any case, we obtain the required representatives of β¯1 , . . . , β¯k , β. Remark 3.1. It is obvious that m considered as a g0 representation space decomposes into the direct sum of subrepresentations mβ¯ , β¯ ∈ 0 , where mβ¯ is generated by all the ¯ Part a) of Proposition 3.1 elements Eβ , β ∈ , such that the projection of β is equal to β. shows that all mβ¯ are irreducible. Part b) together with part a) shows that for β¯1 , β¯2 ∈ 0 such that β¯1 + β¯2 ∈ 0 one has [mβ¯1 , mβ¯2 ] = mβ¯1 +β¯2 . Using the Killing form, it is easy to see that representations mβ¯ and m−β¯ are dual. Question. Is it true that for β¯1 , β¯2 ∈ 0 such that β¯1 + β¯2 ∈ 0 the representation mβ¯1 +β¯2 is contained in mβ¯1 ∧ mβ¯2 ⊂ ∧2 m with multiplicity one? Since g0 contains the Cartan subalgebra h, each g0 invariant tensor over m has to be of weight zero. It follows that there are no invariant vectors in m. Hence, there are no invariant vector fields on M. Consider the invariant bivector fields on M. From the above, such fields correspond from ∧2 m. Note that any h invariant bivector from ∧2 m to the g0 invariant bivectors P has to be of the form c(α)Eα ∧ E−α . Proposition 3.2. A bivector v ∈ ∧2 m is g0 invariant if and only if it has the form P v= c(α)Eα ∧ E−α , where the sum runs over α ∈ + \ 0 , and for two roots α, β which give the same element in h∗ /h∗0 one has c(α) = c(β). Proof. In view of Proposition 3.1 a), we may assume that α = β + γ , where γ ∈ 0 . Then the coefficient before Eβ+γ ∧ E−β in [[Eγ , v]] appears from the terms Eβ ∧ E−β and Eβ+γ ∧ E−β−γ in v, and is equal to Nγ ,β c(β) + Nγ ,−β−γ c(β + γ ). But from (3.1) it follows that Nγ ,β = −Nγ ,−β−γ , so if v is invariant under the action of Eγ , i.e. t [[Eγ , v]] = 0, then c(β) = c(β + γ ). u P This proposition shows that coefficients of an invariant element v = c(α)Eα ∧E−α + depend 0 , denoted α, ¯ so vPcan be written in the form P only on the image of α in c(α)E ¯ α ∧ E−α , where the v= c(α)E ¯ α ∧ E−α .Let v ∈ ∧2 m be of the form v = sum runs over α ∈ + \ 0 . Denote by θ the Cartan automorphism of g. Then, v is θ anti-invariant, i.e. θv = −v. Hence, any g0 invariant bivector is θ anti-invariant. If 2 v, Pw ∈ ∧ m are g0 invariant, then [[v, w]] is θ invariant and is of the form [[v, w]] = ¯ α+β ∧ E−α ∧ E−β , where roots α, β are both negative or both positive and e(α, ¯ β)E ¯ = −e(−α, ¯ Hence, to calculate [[v, w]] for such v and w it is sufficient to e(α, ¯ β) ¯ −β). ¯ for positive α¯ and β. ¯ calculate coefficients e(α, ¯ β)
Double Quantization on Some Orbits of Simple Lie Groups
49
P P Proposition 3.3. Let v = c(α)Eα ∧ E−α , w = d(α)Eα ∧ E−α be elements from g ∧ g. Then for any positive roots α, β, (α + β) the coefficient by the term Eα+β ∧ E−α ∧ E−β in [[v, w]] is equal to Nα,β (c(α)(d(β) − d(α + β)) + c(β)(d(α) − d(α + β)) − c(α + β)(d(α) + d(β))).
(3.2)
Proof. Direct computation, see [KRR]. u t Let r ∈ g ∧ g be the Drinfeld–Jimbo r-matrix: X Eα ∧ E−α . r=
(3.3)
α∈+
Then [[r, r]] = ϕ is an invariant element in ∧3 g. From Proposition 3.2 it follows that r reduced modulo g ∧ g0 is g0 -invariant. Hence, r and ϕ define invariant bivector and three-vector fields on M, π l (r) and π l (ϕ), which we denote by rM and ϕM . Recall, that we identify invariant tensor fields on M with invariant tensors in m. From Propositions that the Schouten bracket P3.3 and 3.1 b) it follow that the condition of the bivector v = c(α)E ¯ α ∧ E−α with itself give K 2 ϕM for a number K is ¯ ¯ = c(α)c( ¯ + K2 c(α¯ + β)(c( α) ¯ + c(β)) ¯ β)
(3.4)
for all the pairs of positive quasiroots α, ¯ β¯ such that α¯ + β¯ is a quasiroot. ¯ and assuming that c(α) ¯ 6= 0 we find that Given c(α) ¯ and c(β) ¯ + c(β) ¯ = c(α¯ + β)
¯ + K2 c(α)c( ¯ β) . ¯ c(α) ¯ + c(β)
(3.5)
¯ γ¯ are positive quasiroots such that α¯ + β, ¯ β¯ + γ¯ , α¯ + β¯ + γ¯ are also Assume α, ¯ β, quasiroots. Then the number c(α¯ + β¯ + γ¯ ) can be calculated formally (ignoring possible division by zero) in two ways, using (3.5) for the pair c(α), ¯ c(β¯ + γ¯ ) on the right-hand ¯ c(γ¯ ). But it is easy to check that these two ways give side and also for the pair c(α¯ + β), the same value of c(α¯ + β¯ + γ¯ ). In this sense the system of equations corresponding to (3.5) for all pairs is consistent. Let us consider this system represented P P more carefully. For any positive quasiroot ¯ = ai . In general the as simple quasiroots α¯ = ai α¯ i , define the height ht(α) coefficient c(α) ¯ for quasiroots of height l can be formally defined by iterating (3.5). Let α¯ = α¯ 1 + · · · + α¯ l with possible repetitions and let ci := c(α¯ i ), then P c1 c2 · · · cl + K 2 ci1 ci2 · · · cil−2 + · · · P . (3.6) c(α) ¯ =P ci1 ci2 · · · cil−1 + K 2 ci1 ci2 · · · cil−3 + · · · For K 6 = 0 the expression in the denominator can be expressed as 1 l 5i=1 (ci + K) − 5li=1 (ci − K) . K
(3.7)
50
J. Donin, D. Gurevich, S. Shnider
Assumption. Let (α¯ 1 , · · · , α¯ k ) be the k-tuple of simple quasiroots. In the following we will assume that the point (c(α¯ 1 ), · · · , c(α¯ k )) ∈ Ck does not lie on any of the subvarieties defined by the expressions in the denominator of (3.6). It will be convenient to include the conditions c(α¯ i ) 6 = 0. Proposition 3.4. a) Given a k-tuple of positive numbers (c1 , . . . , ck ) := (c(α¯ 1 ), . . . , Eq. (3.6) uniquely defines ¯ for all c(α¯ k )) satisfying the Assumption, P numbers c(α) P ¯ α ∧ E−α satisfies positive quasiroots α¯ = α¯ i such that the bivector v = c(α)E the condition [[v, v]] = K 2 ϕM . b) When K = 0, the solution described in part a) defines a Poisson bracket on M and there exists a linear form λ ∈ h∗5\0 such that c(α) ¯ =
1 λ(α) ¯
(3.8)
for all quasiroots α. ¯ Proof. a) Since by assumption the denominator is never zero, Eq. (3.6) defines consis¯ satisfying (3.5) for all positive β. ¯ tently c(β) ¯ ¯ = c(α)c( ¯ and further b) When K = 0 (3.4) becomes c(α¯ + β)(c( α) ¯ + c(β)) ¯ β) Eq. (3.6) implies that c(α) ¯ 6 = 0 for all quasiroots. So setting λ(α) ¯ = 1/c(α), ¯ we find ¯ = λ(α) ¯ Thus λ is a linear that Eq. (3.4) is equivalent to the equation λ(α¯ + β) ¯ + λ(β). functional, i.e., an element of h∗5\0 , which by construction must be nonzero on all quasiroots. u t Remark 3.2. a) This proposition shows that invariant brackets v on M such that [[v, v]] = K 2 ϕM form a k-dimensional manifold, X , which equals Ck minus the subvarieties defined in the Assumption, where k is the number of elements from 5 \ 0. Further, it is known that k = dim H 2 (M), [Bo]. If K is regarded as indeterminate, then v forms a k + 1 dimensional manifold, Y = Ck × C. The submanifold Y0 corresponds to K = 0, i.e. consists of Poisson brackets. It is easy to see that all the Poisson brackets of the type c(α) ¯ = 1/λ(α) ¯ 6 = 0 are nondegenerate. Since Y is connected, it follows that almost all brackets v (except an algebraic subset in Y of lesser dimension) are nondegenerate as well. b) If v defines a Poisson bracket on M, then M is a symplectic manifold and may be realized as an orbit in g∗ passing through the element λ from (3.8) trivially extended to g∗ , with the KKS bracket. P Now we fix a Poisson bracket v = (1/λ( ¯ α ∧E−α , where λ is a fixed linear form P α))E and describe the invariant brackets f = c(α)E ¯ α ∧ E−α which satisfy the conditions for K 6= 0, [[f, f ]] = K 2 ϕM [[f, v]] = 0.
(3.9)
An ordered pair of quasiroots α, ¯ β¯ such that α¯ + β¯ is a quasiroot as well will be called an admissible pair. Substituting in (3.2) instead d(α) the coefficients of v, we obtain that the condition [[f, v]] = 0 is equivalent to the system of equations for the coefficients of f, ¯ β) ¯ 2 = c(α¯ + β)λ( ¯ α¯ + β) ¯ 2 c(α)λ( ¯ α) ¯ 2 + c(β)λ( ¯ for all admissible pairs α, ¯ β.
(3.10)
Double Quantization on Some Orbits of Simple Lie Groups
51
On the other hand, the condition [[f, f ]] = K 2 ϕM is equivalent to the system of Eqs. (3.4) for all admissible pairs of quasiroots. Substituting c(α + β) from (3.10) in (3.4) we obtain ¯ β) ¯ 2 )(c(α) ¯ = c(α)c( ¯ ¯ 2 + K 2 λ(α¯ + β) ¯ 2. ¯ + c(β)) ¯ β)(λ( α) ¯ + λ(β)) (c(α)λ( ¯ α) ¯ 2 + c(β)λ( Cancelling terms and extracting the square root, we obtain the equation ¯ β) ¯ = c(α)λ( ¯ c(β)λ( ¯ α) ¯ ± Kλ(α¯ + β).
(3.11)
¯ β) ¯ from (3.11) in (3.10), we obtain Substituting c(β)λ( ¯ α¯ + β) ¯ = c(α)λ( ¯ c(α¯ + β)λ( ¯ α) ¯ ± Kλ(β).
(3.12)
So, the conditions (3.9) on f are equivalent to the system of Eqs. (3.11, 3.12) with + the same sign before K for all admissible pairs α¯ and β¯ from 0 . ¯ We say that an ordered triple of positive quasiroots (not necessarily different) α, ¯ β, + ¯ ¯ ¯ γ¯ ∈ 0 is an admissible triple, if α¯ + β, β + γ¯ , and α¯ + β + γ¯ are quasiroots, too. ¯ γ¯ be an admissible triple of quasiroots. If c(α¯ + β)λ( ¯ α¯ + β) ¯ = Lemma 3.1. Let α, ¯ β, ¯ then c(β¯ + γ¯ )λ(β¯ + γ¯ ) = c(β)λ( ¯ β) ¯ + Kλ(γ¯ ), that is, the signs c(α)λ( ¯ α) ¯ + Kλ(β), before K in (3.12) for the admissible pairs α, β and β, γ are the same. Proof. The admissible pair α, ¯ β¯ + γ¯ gives the equation c(α)λ( ¯ α) ¯ = c(β¯ + γ¯ )λ(β¯ + γ¯ ) ± Kλ(α¯ + β¯ + γ¯ ). The first equation given in the lemma implies that the + sign appears in Eq. (3.11). These two equations imply ¯ β) ¯ − Kλ(α¯ + β) ¯ = c(β¯ + γ¯ )λ(β¯ + γ¯ ) ± Kλ(α¯ + β¯ + γ¯ ). c(β)λ( Substituting for c(β¯ + γ¯ )λ(β¯ + γ¯ ) using (3.12), we get ¯ β) ¯ − Kλ(α¯ + β) ¯ = c(β)λ( ¯ β) ¯ ± Kλ(γ¯ ) ± Kλ(α¯ + β¯ + γ¯ ), c(β)λ( where the last two ± are independent. However if ¯ β) ¯ − Kλ(γ¯ ), c(β¯ + γ¯ )λ(β¯ + γ¯ ) = c(β)λ( we have a contradiction, since either the sign in front of Kλ(α¯ + β¯ + γ¯ ) is positive and ¯ = +Kλ(α¯ + β), ¯ so 0 = λ(α¯ + β), ¯ or the sign in front of Kλ(α¯ + β¯ + γ¯ ) −Kλ(α¯ + β) is negative, implying 0 = λ(γ¯ ). We conclude that the sign in front of Kλ(γ¯ ) must be positive. u t In the situation of the lemma we can express c(γ¯ ) in terms of c(α) ¯ as ¯ + λ(β¯ + γ¯ )). c(γ¯ )λ(γ¯ ) = c(α)λ( ¯ α) ¯ + K(λ(α¯ + β)
(3.13)
Now, we consider the pair (M, λ) as an orbit in g∗ passing through λ with the KKS Poisson bracket X 1 Eα ∧ E−α . v = vλ = λ(α) ¯ + α∈
52
J. Donin, D. Gurevich, S. Shnider
Definition 3.1. We call M a good orbit, if there exists on M an invariant bracket f = P c(α)E ¯ α ∧ E−α satisfying the conditions (3.9). Recall the discussion in the introduction where we explained that conditions (3.9) are necessary for the existence of a 2-parameter quantization. Proposition 3.5. The good semisimple orbits are as follows: a) For g of type An all semisimple orbits are good. b) For all other g, the orbit M is good if and only if the set 5 \ 0 consists of one or two roots which appear in representation of the maximal root with coefficient 1. Proof. a) In this case the system of quasiroots 0 looks like a system of roots of type Ak for k being equal to the number of elements of 5 \ 0. So, the simple quasiroots can be ordered in a sequence β¯1 , . . . , β¯k in such a way that all subsequences consisting of three adjacent elements are admissible. Pick an arbitrary value for c(β¯1 ) and a sign before K in (3.11) for the pair β¯1 and β¯2 . Then, due to Lemma 3.1, consistency of system (3.11, 3.12) implies that the sign before K is the same for all adjacent pairs β¯i and β¯i+1 . Using Eqs, (3.11) and (3.12) for a fixed sign before K and induction on ht(α), we find all the coefficients c(α) ¯ of f and see that the system (3.11, 3.12) is consistent. b) Let g be of type Bn or Cn . Then the maximal root has the form α1 +2α2 +· · ·+2αn , where αi ∈ 5. Denote β = α2 + · · · + αn which is a root. If 5 \ 0 does not contain α1 , + ¯ β. ¯ So, from (3.11) it follows that i.e. α¯ 1 = 0, then 0 contains the admissible pair β, ¯ ¯ ¯ ¯ ¯ ¯ c(β)λ(β) = c(β)λ(β) ± 2Kλ(β), i.e. λ(β) = 0 which is impossible. Assume that 5 \ 0 contains α1 and some roots αi for i > 1. Then both α¯ 1 and β¯ are + ¯ α¯ 1 , β. ¯ It follows from (3.13) not equal to zero, and 0 contains the admissible triple β, ¯ ¯ ¯ ¯ ¯ ¯ that c(β)λ(β) = c(β)λ(β) + 2Kλ(β + α¯ 1 ), i.e. λ(β + α¯ 1 ) = 0 which is impossible as well, because β¯ + α¯ 1 is a quasiroot. So, for consistency of system (3.11, 3.12) in cases Bn and Cn , the set 0 has to contain all the roots αi , i > 1. But in the latter case the system is trivially consistent, because in that case the set of quasiroots looks like A1 . The homogeneous space G/G0 is a symmetric space. Consider the case Dn . The maximal root has the form α1 + α2 + α3 + 2α4 + · · · + 2αn . Denote β = α4 + · · · + αn , which is a root. Consider several cases. The cases when two of α¯ i , i ≤ 3, are equal to zero and β¯ is not equal to zero lead to an inconsistency in the system (3.11, 3.12) in the same way as in the cases Bn and Cn considered above. Assume that two of α¯ i , i ≤ 3, say α¯ 1 , α¯ 3 , and β¯ are not equal to zero. Then the sequence ¯ α¯ 3 , α¯ 1 + β¯ α¯ 1 , α¯ 2 + β,
(3.14)
is a sequence of four nonzero quasiroots. It is easy to see that the subsequences α¯ 1 , α¯ 2 + ¯ α¯ 3 , α¯ 1 + β¯ form admissible triples in + ¯ α¯ 3 and α¯ 2 + β, β, 0 . From Lemma 3.1 it follows that the sign before K must be the same in (3.11) for all adjacent pairs. Taking, for example, the sign plus and applying (3.13) to the second triple, we obtain the equation ¯ α¯ 1 + β) ¯ = c(α¯ 2 + β)λ( ¯ α¯ 2 + β) ¯ + K(λ(α¯ 2 + β¯ + α¯ 3 ) c(α¯ 1 + β)λ( ¯ + λ(α¯ 3 + α¯ 1 + β)).
(3.15)
Double Quantization on Some Orbits of Simple Lie Groups
53
From (3.11) applied to the pair α¯ 1 , α¯ 2 + β¯ we obtain ¯ α¯ 2 + β) ¯ = c(α¯ 1 )λ(α¯ 1 ) + Kλ(α¯ 1 + α¯ 2 + β). ¯ c(α¯ 2 + β)λ(
(3.16)
Putting c(α¯ 1 ) from (3.16) in (3.15) and taking into account linearity of λ, we obtain the equality ¯ α¯ 1 + β) ¯ = c(α¯ 1 )λ(α¯ 1 ) + 2Kλ(α¯ 1 + α¯ 2 + α¯ 3 + β) ¯ + Kλ(β). ¯ (3.17) c(α¯ 1 + β)λ( ¯ in terms of c(α¯ 1 ) from (3.12), we obtain On the other hand, expressing c(α¯ 1 + β) ¯ α¯ 1 + β) ¯ = c(α¯ 1 )λ(α¯ 1 ) ± Kλ(β). ¯ c(α¯ 1 + β)λ(
(3.18)
Now, comparing (3.17) and (3.18), we see that if we take plus before K in (3.18), then ¯ = 0, if we take minus, then λ(α¯ 1 + α¯ 2 + α¯ 3 + β) ¯ = 0. But both λ(α¯ 1 + α¯ 2 + α¯ 3 + 2β) of the cases are impossible, since λ is not equal to zero on quasiroots. Next, assume that β¯ = 0 but α¯ i 6 = 0 for i = 1, 2, 3. In this case the sequence (3.14) becomes the sequence α¯ 1 , α¯ 2 , α¯ 3 , α¯ 1 . Using the above arguments, we obtain that in this case λ(α¯ 1 + α¯ 2 + α¯ 3 ) = 0 must be true, which is impossible, since α¯ 1 + α¯ 2 + α¯ 3 is a quasiroot. In the case when 5 \ 0 contains only one or two roots of αi , i = 1, 2, 3, system (3.11, 3.12) is consistent, because in these cases the set of quasiroots 0 looks like the system of roots of type A1 or A2 . So, the proposition is proved for the classical g. For the exceptional g and a semisimple orbit which is not a symmetric space the system of quasi-roots reduces to one of the t cases which we have just excluded for g equal to Bn , Cn or Dn . u Remark 3.3. a) Note that Proposition 3.5 may be reformulated in the following way: An orbit M is good if and only if the corresponding system of quasiroots 0 is isomorphic to a system of roots of type Ak . We say in this case that M is of type Ak . Orbits of type A1 are exactly the orbits which are symmetric spaces. For such orbits ϕM = 0, and we may take f = 0. Symmetric orbits exist for all classical g and also for g of types E6 , E7 . Orbits of type A2 exist for g of type An , Dn , and E6 . Orbits of type Ak , k > 2, exist only in case g = sl(n). Moreover, in this case all semisimple orbits have the type Ak for k ≥ 1. b) From the proof of Proposition 3.5 it follows that the bracket f satisfying (3.9) is defined on good orbits by the value of its coefficient c(α) for a fixed simple root and the choice of a sign before K. On the other hand, if a fixed f0 satisfies (3.9), then the family ±f0 + sv for arbitrary numbers s also satisfies these conditions. So, this family consists of all invariant brackets satisfying (3.9). Almost all brackets from this family (except a finite number) are nondegenerate, since v is nondegenerate and, therefore, for large s0 the bracket ±f0 + s0 v is nondegenerate as well. For symmetric orbits 5 \ 0 consists of one element, there is one quasiroot and f0 is a multiple of v. Note that in [GP] a classification of all orbits in coadjoint representation (not necessarily semisimple) is given for which ϕM = 0. In particular, if we take K = 1 and find f0 such that [[f0 , f0 ]] = ϕM , then the family ±if0 + sv gives all the brackets satisfying [[f0 , f0 ]] = −ϕM and compatible with the KKS bracket on M. Note that if f is a bracket satisfying [[f, f ]] = −ϕM and {·, ·}r is the r-matrix bracket (2.8), then f ± {·, ·}r is a Poisson bracket on M compatible with KKS bracket.
54
J. Donin, D. Gurevich, S. Shnider
4. Cohomologies Defined by Invariant Brackets In the next section we prove the existence of a Uh (g) invariant quantization of the Poisson brackets described above using the methods of [DS1]. This requires us to consider the 3-cohomology of the complex (3• (g/g0 ))g0 = (3• m)g0 of g0 invariants with differential given by the Schouten bracket with the bivector v ∈ (32 m)g0 from Proposition 3.4 a), for u ∈ (3• m)g0 . δv : u 7 → [[v, u]] The condition δv2 = 0 follows from the Jacobi identity for the Schouten bracket together with the fact that [[v, v]] = K 2 ϕM . The latter equation is equivalent to [[v, v]] = ϕ modulo g0 ∧ g ∧ g, hence [[v, v]] is invariant modulo g0 ∧ g ∧ g. Denote these cohomologies by H k (M, δv ), whereas the usual de Rham cohomologies are denoted by H k (M). Recall, Remark 3.2 a), that the brackets v satisfying [[v, v]] = K 2 ϕ form a connected manifold Y = X × C. Proposition 4.1. For almost all v ∈ Y (except an algebraic subset of lesser dimension) one has H k (M, δv ) = H k (M) for all k. In particular, H k (M, δv ) = 0 for odd k. Proof. First, let v be a Poisson bracket, i.e. v ∈ Y0 . Then the complex of polyvector fields on M, 2• , with the differential δv is well defined. Denote by • the de Rham complex on M. Since none of the coefficients c(α) ¯ of v are zero, v is a nondegenerate bivector field, and therefore it defines an A-linear isomorphism v˜ : 1 → 21 , ω 7 → v(ω, ·), which can be extended up to the isomorphism v˜ : k → 2k of k-forms onto k-vector fields for all k. Using the Jacobi identity for v and invariance of v, one can show that v˜ gives a G invariant isomorphism of these complexes, so their cohomologies are the same. Since g is simple, the subcomplex of g invariants, (• )g , splits off as a subcomplex of • . In addition, g acts trivially on cohomologies, since for any g ∈ G the map X → X, x 7 → gx, is homotopic to the identity map. (G is assumed connected.) It follows that cohomologies of complexes (• )g and • coincide. But v˜ gives an isomorphism of complexes (• )g and (2• )g = ((3• m)g0 , δv ). So, cohomologies of the latter complex coincide with de Rham cohomologies, which proves the proposition when v is a Poisson brackets. Now, consider the family of complexes ((3• m)g0 , δv ), v ∈ Y. It is clear that δv depends algebraically on v. It follows from the uppersemicontinuity of dim H k (M, δv ) and the fact that H k (M) = 0 for odd k, [Bo], that H k (M, δv ) = 0 for odd k and almost all v ∈ Y. Using the uppersemicontinuity again and the fact that the number P k k k k (−1) dim H (M, δv ) is the same for all v ∈ Y, we conclude that dim H (M, δv ) = k dim H (M) for even k and almost all v. u t Remark 4.1. Call v ∈ Y admissible, if it satisfies Proposition 4.1. From the proof of the proposition it follows that the subset D such that Y \ D consists of admissible brackets does not intersect with the subset Y0 consisting of Poisson brackets. Let M be a good orbit and f0 + sv the family from Remark 3.3 b) satisfying (3.9) for a fixed K. Then for almost all numbers s this bracket is admissible. Indeed, this family is
Double Quantization on Some Orbits of Simple Lie Groups
55
contained in the two parameter family tf0 + sv. For t = 0, s 6 = 0 we obtain admissible brackets. So, there exist t0 6 = 0 and s0 such that the bracket t0 f0 + s0 v is admissible. It follows that the bracket f0 + (s0 /t0 )v is admissible, too. So, in the family f0 + sv there is an admissible bracket, and we conclude that almost all brackets in this family (except a finite number) are admissible. Question. Is it true that the set of admissible brackets contains all the nondegenerate brackets? For the proof of existence of two parameter quantization for the cases Dn and E6 in the next section we will use the following result on invariant three-vector fields. Denote by θ the Cartan automorphism of g. Lemma 4.1. For either Dn or E6 and one of the subsets, 0, of simple roots such that G0 defines a good orbit, any g0 and θ invariant element v in 33 m is a multiple of ϕM , that is, g0 ∼ 33 (m = hϕM i. Proof. Let g be a simple Lie algebra of type Dn or E6 and {α1 , . . . , αn } a system of simple roots. Changing notation slightly from Sect. 3, we assume that for g = Dn , (αi , αi+1 ) = −1 for i = 1, . . . , n − 2, (αn−2 , αn ) = −1 with all other inner products of distinct simple roots are zero, and for g = E6 , the non-zero products are (αi , αi+1 ) = −1 for i = 1, 2, 3, 4 and (α3 , α6 ) = −1. For g = Dn , 0 is one of the subsets of simple roots, 01 = {α1 , . . . , αn−2 }, 02 = {α2 , . . . , αn−1 }, or 03 = {α2 , . . . , αn−2 , αn }. For g = E6 , 0 = {α2 , α3 , α4 , α6 }. The positive quasiroots consist of three elements, α, ¯ α¯ 0 , and α¯ + α¯ 0 . Since a θ invariant element has the form w + θw for w ∈ mα¯ ⊗ mα¯ 0 ⊗ m−(α+ ¯ α¯ 0 ) , it is sufficient to show that the space of invariants in mα¯ ⊗ mα¯ 0 ⊗ m−(α+ ¯ α¯ 0 ) has dimension one. We know from Remark 3.1 that the subspaces mα¯ , mα¯ 0 , mα+ ¯ α¯ 0 are irreducible representations of g0 and that mα¯ and m−α¯ are dual. Therefore the dimension of the space of invariants in mα¯ ⊗ mα¯ 0 ⊗ m−(α+ ¯ α¯ 0 ) is the multiplicity of the representation mα+ ¯ α¯ 0 in the tensor product mα¯ ⊗ mα¯ 0 . For Dn and any of 0i the algebra g0 ∼ = An−2 . For 01 , α = αn−1 and α 0 = αn , the representations mα¯ and mα¯ 0 are both isomorphic to the dual vector representation for An−2 , that is, the contragredient representation to the representation for the fundamental weight λn−2 , mα¯ n−1 ∼ = mα¯ n ∼ = (V λn−2 )∗ ∼ = V λ1 . To see that this is so, note first of all that mα¯ n−1 is a lowest weight representation because it has a cyclic vector Eαn−1 and all negative simple root vectors of g0 annihilate Eαn−1 . The corresponding weight of An−2 is −λn−2 because (αn−1 , αj ) = −(λn−2 , αj ) if 1 ≤ j ≤ n − 2. The irreducible lowest weight representations with lowest weight −λn−2 is (V λn−2 )∗ and An−2 , (V λj )∗ ∼ = V λn−1−j . Since the subspaces mα¯ and mα¯ 0 of g have zero intersection, the wedge product mα¯ ∧ mα¯ 0 projects isomorphically onto the tensor product which contains the representation ∼ 2λn−2 )∗ ∼ mα+ = V 2λ1 ¯ α¯ 0 = (V with multiplicity one. In the cases 02 or 03 the representation mα¯ 1 is the contragredient representation to the vector representation (V λ1 )∗ ∼ = V λn−2 . The representations mα 0 = mαn for the case
56
J. Donin, D. Gurevich, S. Shnider
02 and mα 0 = mαn−1 for 03 are (V λn−3 )∗ ∼ = V λ2 . From the elementary representation theory of the Lie algebra sl(n − 1) (type An−2 ) we see that the tensor product mα¯ ⊗ mα¯ 0 contains mα+ ¯ α¯ 0 with multiplicity one. In the case of E6 , g0 ∼ = D4 ∼ = so(8). The representations mα¯ , mα¯ 0 and m−(α+ ¯ α¯ 0 ) are the three inequivalent irreducible eight dimensional representations, the two spinor representations and the vector representation. It is well known that there is a one diment sional space of invariants in the tensor product mα¯ ⊗ mα¯ 0 ⊗ mα+ ¯ α¯ 0 . u The proof of the lemma gives a positive answer on the Question from Remark 3.1 for the particular case. Note that in case of symmetric orbits the space of invariant three-vector fields is equal to zero. 5. Uh (g) Invariant Quantizations in One and Two Parameters In this section we prove the existence of two types of Uh (g) invariant quantization of the function algebra A on M = G/G0 . The first is a one parameter quantization µh (a, b) =
X n≥0
hn µn (a, b) = ab+
X
hn µn (a, b), µ1 (a, b) =
n≥1
1 (f (a, b)−{a, b}r ), 2
as described in Sect. 2, where f is one of the invariant brackets found above, f ∈ (32 m)g , [[f, f ]] = −ϕM . The second is a two parameter quantization µt,h (a, b) = ab + hµ1 (a, b) + tµ01 (a, b) +
X
hk t l µk,l (a, b).
k,l≥1
Recall that in this case there are two compatible Poisson brackets corresponding to such a quantization: the bracket µ1 (a, b)−µ1 (b, a) is skew-symmetric of the form (2.10) and µ01 (a, b) − µ01 (b, a) is a U (g) invariant bracket v(a, b), which we will assume to be the KKS bracket defined by identifying G/G0 with an orbit of the coadjoint representation. We remind the reader of the method in [DS1]. The first step is to construct a U (g) invariant quantization in the category C(U (g)[[h]], 1, 8h ). Then we use the equivalence given by the pair (I d, Fh ) between the monoidal categories C(U (g)[[h]], 1, 8h ) and e , 1) to define a Uh (g) invariant quantization, either µh F −1 in the one C(U (g)[[h]], 1 h parameter case or µt,h Fh−1 in the two parameter case (see Sect. 2). In the first step we used the fact that (33 m)g0 = 0 for symmetric spaces. In the examples considered in this paper, (33 m)g0 does not necessarily vanish, and we modify the proof using a method from [DS2] (see also [NV]). In the case of An any semisimple orbit is a good orbit and a different method is required (see [Do] where the existence of two parameter quantization for maximal orbits is proven). For the cases Bn and Cn , the only good orbits are symmetric spaces and the quantization was dealt with in [DS1]. In the remaining cases g = Dn or E6 , we proved in Lemma 4.1 that (33 m)g0 ,θ = hϕA i, and a suitable modification of the proof still applies.
Double Quantization on Some Orbits of Simple Lie Groups
57
Theorem 5.1. For almost all (in sense of Proposition 4.1) g invariant brackets satisfying [[f, f ]] = −ϕM , there exists a multiplication µh on A, X hn µn (a, b), µh (a, b) = ab + (h/2)f (a, b) + n≥2
which is g invariant (Eq. 2.5)) and 8 associative (Eq. (2.6)). Proof. To begin, consider the multiplication µ(1) (a, b) = ab + (h/2)f (a, b). The corresponding obstruction cocycle is given by obs2 =
1 (1) (1) (µ (µ ⊗ id) − µ(1) (id ⊗ µ(1) )8) h2
considered modulo terms of order h. No h1 terms appear because f is a biderivation and, therefore, a Hochschild cocycle. The fact that the presence of 8 does not interfere with the cocyle condition and that this equation defines a Hochschild 3-cocycle was demonstrated in the proof of Proposition 4 in [DS1]. It is well known that if we restrict to the subcomplex of cochains given by differential operators, the differential Hochschild cohomology of A in dimension p is the space of polyvector fields on M. Since g is reductive, the subspace of g invariants splits off as a subcomplex and has cohomology given by (3p m)g0 . The complete antisymmetrization of a p-tensor projects the space of invariant differential p-cocycles onto the subspace (3p m)g0 representing the cohomology. The equation [[f, f ]] + ϕM = 0 implies that obstruction cocycle is a coboundary, and we can find a 2-cochain µ2 so that µ(2) = µ(1) + h2 µ2 satisfies µ(2) (µ(2) ⊗ id) − µ(2) (id ⊗ µ(2) )8 = 0 mod h2 . Assume we have defined the deformation µ(n) to order hn such that 8 associativity holds modulo hn , then we define the (n + 1)st obstruction cocycle by obsn+1 =
1 (µ(n) (µ(n) ⊗ id) − µ(n) (id ⊗ µ(n) )8) mod h. hn+1
In [DS1] (Proposition 4) we showed that the usual proof that the obstruction cochain satisfies the cocycle condition carries through to the 8 associative case. The coboundary of obsn+1 appears as the hn+1 coefficient of the signed sum of the compositions of µ(n+1) with obsn+1 . The fact that 8 = 1 mod h2 together with the pentagon identity implies that the sum vanishes identically, and thus all coefficients vanish, including the coboundary 0 ∈ (33 m)g0 be the projection of obsn+1 on the totally skew in question. Let obsn+1 symmetric part, which represents the cohomology class of the obstruction cocycle. The coefficient of hn+2 in the same signed sum, when projected on the skew symmetric part is 0 0 ]] which is the coboundary of obsn+1 in the complex (3• m)g0 , δf = [[f, .]]). [[f, obsn+1 0 Thus obsn+1 is a δf cocycle. We have shown in Sect. 4 that this complex has zero cohomology. Now we modify µ(n+1) by adding a term hn µn with µn ∈ (32 m)g0 and consider the (n + 1)st obstruction cocycle for µ0(n+1) = µ(n+1) + hn µn . Since the term we added at degree hn is a Hochschild cocyle we do not introduce a hn term in the calculation of µ(n) (µ(n) ⊗ id) − µ(n) (id ⊗ µ(n) )8 and the totally skew symmetric projection hn+1 term has been modified by [[f, µn ]]. By choosing µn appropriately we can make the (n + 1)st obstruction cocycle represent the zero cohomology class, and we are able to continue the recursive construction of the desired deformation. u t
58
J. Donin, D. Gurevich, S. Shnider
Now we prove the existence of a two parameter deformation for good orbits in the cases Dn and E6 . Theorem 5.2. Given a pair of g invariant brackets, f, v, on a good orbit in Dn or E6 satisfying [[f, f ]] = −ϕM , [[f, v]] = [[v, v]] = 0, there exists a multiplication µh,t on A, X hk t l µk,l (a, b), µt,h (a, b) = ab + (h/2)f (a, b) + (t/2)v(a, b) + k,l≥1
which is g invariant (Eq. 2.5)) and 8 associative (Eq. (2.6)). Proof. The existence of a multiplication which is 8 associative up to and including h2 terms is nearly identical to the previous proof. Both f and v are anti-invariant under the Cartan involution θ. We shall look for a multiplication µt,h such that µk,l is θ antiinvariant and skew-symmetric for odd k + l and θ invariant and symmetric for even k + 1. So suppose we have a multiplication defined to order n, X hk t l µk,l (a, b), µt,h (a, b) = ab + hµ1 (a, b) + tµ01 (a, b) + k+l≤n
with the above mentioned invariance properties and 8 associative to order hn . Using properties c) and d) for 8 from Proposition 2.1, direct computation shows that the obstruction cochain, X hk t n+1−k βk , obsn+1 = k=0,... ,n+1
has the following properties: obsn+1 is θ invariant and obsn+1 (a, b, c) = −obsn+1 (c, b, a) for odd n, and obsn+1 is θ anti-invariant and obsn+1 (a, b, c) = obsn+1 (c, b, a) for even n. Hence, the projection of obsn+1 on (33 m)g0 is equal to zero for even n. It follows that all the βk are Hochschild coboundaries, and the standard argument implies that the multiplication can be extended up to order n + 1 with the required properties. For odd n, Lemma 4.1 shows that the projection on (33 m)g0 has the form X ak hk t n+1−k ϕM . obsn+1 = k=0,... ,n+1
The KKS bracket is given by the two-vector v=
X α∈+ \0
Setting w=
X
1 Eα ∧ E−α . λ(α) ¯
λ(α)E ¯ α ∧ E−α ,
α∈+ \0
gives [[v, w]] = −3ϕM .
Double Quantization on Some Orbits of Simple Lie Groups
Defining µ0(n) = µ(n) + the new obstruction cohomology class is X 0 =( obsn+1
59
a0 n t w, 3
ak hk t n+1−k )ϕM .
k=1,... ,n+1
Finally we define µ00(n) = µ0(n) +
X
ak hk−1 t n+1−k )f
k=1,... ,n
and get an obstruction cocycle which is zero in cohomology. Now the standard argument implies that the deformation can be extended to give a 8 associative invariant multiplication with the required properties of order n + 1. So, we are able to continue the recursive construction of the desired multiplication. t u Remark 5.1. This theorem is also true for semisimple orbits in An , but the proof, which requires different techniques, will be deferred to a forthcoming paper. Remark 5.2. Using the 8h associative multiplications µh and µt,h from Propositions 5.1 and 5.2 and the equivalence between the monoidal categories C(U (g)[[h]], 1, 8h ) e , 1) given by the pair (I d, Fh ) (see Sect. 2), one can define Uh (g) and C(U (g)[[h]], 1 invariant multiplications, either µh Fh−1 in the one parameter case or µt,h Fh−1 in the two parameter case. Acknowledgements. We thank the referee for bringing to our attention some as yet unpublished work dealing with related topics. In “Manin pairs and moment maps" (Ecole Polytechnique preprint, 1998) A. Alekseev and Y. Kosmann–Schwarzbach consider bivectors with Schouten bracket [[f, f ]] = ϕ in the framework of moment map theory. J.-H. Lu has given a classification of Poisson brackets on G/H which are Poisson-invariant relative to the Poisson–Lie action of G.
Note added in proof. The answer to the question after Remark 3.1 is yes. See Bourbaki: Groupes et algèbres de Lie, Chap. 8, § 9, Ex. 14. References [BFFLS] Bauen, F., Flato, M., Fronsdal, C., Lichnerovicz, A., Sternheimer, D.: Deformation theory and quantization, I. Deformations of symplectic structures. Ann. Physics 111, 61–110 (1978) [Bo] Borel, A.: Sur la cohomologie des espaces fibrés principaux et des espaces homogènes de groupes de Lie compacts. Ann. Math. 57, 115–207 (1953) [Dr1] Drinfeld, V.G.: Quasi-Hopf algebras. Leningrad Math. J. 1, 1419–1457 (1990) [Do] Donin, J.: Double quantization on the coadjoint representation of sl(n)∗ . Czechoslovak J. of Phys. 47 No 11, 1115–1122 (1997), q-alg/9707031 [DG1] Donin, J. and Gurevich, D.: Quasi-Hopf Algebras and R-Matrix Structure in Line Bundles over Flag Manifolds. Selecta Math. Sovietica, 12, No 1, 37–48 (1993) [DG2] Donin, J. and Gurevich, D.: Some Poisson structures associated to Drinfeld–Jimbo R-matrices and their quantization. Israel Math. J. 92, No 1, 23–32 (1995) [DGK] Donin, J., Gurevich, D. and Khoroshkin, S.: Double quantization of CP n type orbits by generalized Verma modules. J. of Geom. and Phys. To appear
60
[DGM] [DGR]
[DS1] [DS2] [GP] [He] [KRR] [LW] [NV]
J. Donin, D. Gurevich, S. Shnider
Donin, J., Gurevich, D. and Majid, S.: R-matrix brackets and their quantization. Ann. de l’Institut d’Henri Poincaré, Phys. Theor. 58, No 2, 235–246 (1993) Donin, J., Gurevich, D., Rubtsov, V.: Quantum hyberboloid and braided modules. In: Algebre non commutative, Groupes Quantiques et Invariants, Societé Mathématique de France, Collection Séminaires et Congres, no. 2, 103–118 (1997) Donin, J. and Shnider, S.: Quantum symmetric spaces. J. of Pure and Appl. Algebra 100, 103–115 (1995) Donin, J. and Shnider, S.: Cohomological construction of quantum groups. To appear Gurevich, D. and Panyushev, D.: On Poisson pairs associated to modified R-matrices. Duke Math. J. 73, n. 1 (1994) Helgason, S.: Differential geometry, Lie groups, and symmetric spaces, London–New York: Academic Press, 1978 Khoroshkin, S., Radul, A. and Rubtsov, V.: A family of Poisson structures on compact Hermitian symmetric spaces. Commun. Math. Phys. 152, 299–316 (1993) Lu, J.H. and Weinstein, A.: Poisson–Lie groups, dressing transformations, and Bruhat decompositions. J. of Diff. Geom. 31, 501–526 (1990) Neroslavsky, O.M. and Vlasov, A.T.: Éxistence de produits * sur une variété. C.R. Acad. Sci. Paris, 292 I, 71–76 (1981)
Communicated by G. Felder
Commun. Math. Phys. 204, 61 – 84 (1999)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
© Springer-Verlag 1999
A Functional-Analytic Theory of Vertex (Operator) Algebras, I Yi-Zhi Huang Department of Mathematics, Rutgers University, 110 Frelinghuysen Rd., Piscataway, NJ 08854-8019, USA. E-mail: [email protected] Received: 15 August 1998 / Accepted: 13 January 1999
Abstract: This paper is the first in a series of papers developing a functional-analytic theory of vertex (operator) algebras and their representations. For an arbitrary Z-graded finitely-generated vertex algebra (V , Y, 1) satisfying the standard grading-restriction axioms, a locally convex topological completion H of V is constructed. By the geometric interpretation of vertex (operator) algebras, there is a canonical linear map from V ⊗ V to V (the algebraic completion of V ) realizing linearly the conformal equivalence class of a genus-zero Riemann surface with analytically parametrized boundary obtained by deleting two ordered disjoint disks from the unit disk and by giving the obvious parametrizations to the boundary components. We extend such a linear map ˜ (⊗ ˜ being the completed tensor product) to H , and prove to a linear map from H ⊗H the continuity of the extension. For any finitely-generated C-graded V -module (W, YW ) satisfying the standard grading-restriction axioms, the same method also gives a topo˜ W to H W logical completion H W of W and gives the continuous extensions from H ⊗H of the linear maps from V ⊗ W to W realizing linearly the above conformal equivalence classes of the genus-zero Riemann surfaces with analytically parametrized boundaries. 0. Introduction We begin a systematic study of the functional-analytic structure of vertex (operator) algebras and their representations in this paper. Vertex (operator) algebras were introduced rigorously in mathematics by Borcherds and by Frenkel, Lepowsky and Meurman (see [B,FLM] and [FHL]). Incorporating modules and intertwining operators, the author introduced intertwining operator algebras in [H5]. The original definition of vertex (operator) algebra is purely algebraic, but a geometric interpretation of vertex operators motivated by the path integral picture in string theory was soon observed mathematically by Frenkel [F]. In [H1]–[H7], the author developed a geometric theory of vertex operator algebras and intertwining operator algebras; the hard parts deal with the Virasoro algebra, the central charge, the interaction
62
Y.-Z. Huang
between the Virasoro algebra and vertex operators (or intertwining operators), and the monodromies. But in this geometric theory, the linear maps associated to elements of certain moduli spaces of punctured spheres with local coordinates (or to elements of the vector bundles forming partial operads called “genus-zero modular functors” over these moduli spaces) are from the tensor powers of a vertex operator algebra (or an intertwining operator algebra) to the algebraic completion of the algebra. To be more specific, let (V , Y, 1) be a Z-graded vertex algebra. For any nonzero complex number z, let P (z) be the the conformal equivalence class of the sphere C∪{∞} with the negatively oriented puncture ∞, the ordered positively oriented punctures z and 0, and with the standard local coordinates. Then associated to P (z) is the linear map Y (·, z)· : V ⊗ V → V given by the vertex operator map. Note that the image is in the algebraic completion V of V , not V itself. One of the main goals of the theory of vertex operator algebras is to construct conformal field theories in the sense of Segal [S1,S2] from vertex operator algebras and their representations, and to study geometry using the theory of vertex operator algebras. It is therefore necessary to construct locally convex topological completions of the underlying vector spaces of vertex (operator) algebras and their modules, such that associated to any Riemann surface with boundary, one can construct continuous linear maps between the tensor powers of these completions. In particular, it is necessary to construct a locally convex completion H of the underlying vector space V of a vertex algebra (V , Y, 1) such that associated to the conformal equivalence class of a disk with two smaller ordered disks deleted and with the obvious boundary parametrization, there ˜ (⊗ ˜ being the completed tensor product) to is a canonical continuous map from H ⊗H H . Though in some algebraic applications of conformal field theories, only the algebraic structure of conformal field theories is needed, in many geometric applications, it is necessary to have a complete locally convex topological space and continuous linear maps, associated to Riemann surfaces with boundaries, between tensor powers of the space. In the present paper (Part I), we construct a locally convex completion H V of an arbitrary finitely-generated Z-graded vertex algebra (V , Y, 1) satisfying the standard grading-restriction axioms. Since V is fixed in the present paper, we shall denote H V simply by H . The completion H is the strict inductive limit of a sequence of complete locally convex spaces constructed from the correlation functions of the generators. The strong topology, rather than the weak-∗ topology, on the topological dual spaces of certain function spaces is needed in the construction. For any positive numbers r1 , r2 and nonzero complex number z satisfying r2 +2r1 < 1 and r2 < |z| < 1, there is a unique genus-zero Riemann surface with analytically parametrized boundary given by deleting two ordered disjoint disks, the first centered at z with radius r1 and the second centered at 0 with radius r2 , from the unit disk and by giving the obvious parametrizations to the boundary components. Associated to this genus-zero Riemann surface with analytically L(0) L(0) parametrized boundary is a linear map Y (r1 ·, z)r2 · : V ⊗ V → V . We extend this ˜ (⊗ ˜ being the completed tensor product) to H , linear map to a linear map from H ⊗H and prove the continuity of the extension. It is clear that H is linearly isomorphic to a L(0) L(0) subspace of V containing both V and the image of Y (r1 ·, z)r2 ·. For any finitely-generated C-graded module (W, YW ) satisfying the standard gradingrestriction axioms for such a finitely-generated vertex algebra, we also construct a locally ˜ W to H W convex completion H W of W , and construct continuous extensions from H ⊗H L(0) L(0) of the linear map YW (r1 ·, z)r2 · : V ⊗ W → W .
Functional-Analytic Theory of Vertex (Operator) Algebras, I
63
Our method depends only on the axiomatic properties or “world-sheet geometry” (mainly the duality properties) of the vertex algebra. Since our construction does not use any additional structure, we expect that the locally convex completions constructed in the present paper will be useful in solving purely algebraic problems in the representation theory of finitely-generated vertex (operator) algebras. This paper is organized as follows: In Sect. 2, we construct a locally convex completion H of a finitely-generated Z-graded vertex algebra (V , Y, 1) satisfying the standard L(0) L(0) grading-restriction axioms. In Sect. 3, we extend Y (r1 ·, z)r2 · : V ⊗ V → V to ˜ continuous linear maps from H ⊗H to H . In Sect. 4, we present the corresponding results for modules. In this paper, we assume that the reader is familiar with the basic definitions and results in the theory of vertex algebras. The material in [B,FLM] and [FHL] should be enough. We also assume that the reader is familiar with the basic definitions, constructions and results in the theory of locally convex topological vector spaces. The reader can find this material in, for example, [K1] and [K2]. We shall denote the set of integers, the set of real numbers and the set of complex numbers by the usual notations Z, R and C, respectively. We shall use i, j, k, l, m, n, p, q to denote integers. In particular, when we write, say, k > 0 (or k ≥ 0), we mean that k is a positive integer (or a nonnegative integer). For a graded vector space V , we use V 0 , V ∗ and V to denote the graded dual space, the dual space and the algebraic completion of V , respectively. For a topological vector space E, we use E ∗ to denote the topological dual space of E. The symbol ⊗ always denotes the vector space tensor product. The bifunctor given by completing the vector space tensor product of two topological vector ˜ spaces with the tensor product topology is denoted by ⊗. 1. A Locally Convex Completion of a Finitely-Generated Vertex Algebra In this section, we use “correlation functions” to construct the locally convex completion of a finitely-generated vertex algebra. For any k ≥ 0, let Rk be the space of rational functions in the complex variables z1 , . . . , zk with the only possible poles zi = zj for i 6= j and zi = 0, ∞ (i, j = 1, . . . , k). Let M k = {(z1 , . . . , zk ) ∈ Ck | zi 6 = zj for i 6 = j ; zi 6= 0 (i, j = 1, . . . , k)} (k)
and let {Kn }n>0 , be a sequence of compact subsets of M k satisfying (k)
Kn(k) ⊂ Kn+1 , n > 0, and
Mk =
[ n>0
Kn(k) .
For any n > 0, we define a map k · kRk ,n : Rk → [0, ∞) by kf kRk ,n =
max
(k)
(z1 ,...,zk )∈Kn
|f (z1 , . . . , zk )|
for f ∈ Rk . Then it is clear that k · kRk ,n is a norm on Rk . Using this sequence of norms, we obtain a locally convex topology on Rk . Note that a sequence in Rk is convergent if
64
Y.-Z. Huang
and only if this sequence of functions is uniformly convergent on any compact subset (k) of M k . Clearly, this topology is independent of the choice of the sequence {Kn }n>0 . Let V be a Z-graded vertex algebra satisfying the standard grading-restriction axioms, that is, a V(n) , V = n∈Z
dim V(n) < ∞ for n ∈ Z and V(n) = 0 for n sufficiently small. By the duality properties of V , for any v 0 ∈ V 0 , any u1 , . . . , uk , v ∈ V, hv 0 , Y (u1 , z1 ) · · · Y (uk , zk )vi is absolutely convergent in the region |z1 | > · · · > |zk | > 0 and can be analytically extended to an element R(hv 0 , Y (u1 , z1 ) · · · Y (uk , zk )vi) of Rk . For any u1 , . . . , uk , v ∈ V and any (z1 , . . . , zk ) ∈ M k , we have an element Q(u1 , . . . , uk , v; z1 , . . . , zk ) ∈ V defined by hv 0 , Q(z1 , . . . , zk , v; z1 , . . . , zk )i = R(hv 0 , Y (u1 , z1 ) · · · Y (uk , zk )vi) ˜ be for v 0 ∈ V 0 . We denote the projections from V to V(n) , n ∈ Z, by Pn . Let G ∗ the subspace of V consisting of linear functionals λ on V such that for any k ≥ 0, u1 , . . . , uk , v ∈ V , X λ(Pn (Q(u1 , . . . , uk , v; z1 , . . . , zk ))) (1.1) n∈Z
is absolutely convergent for any z1 , . . . , zk in the region k = {(z1 , . . . , zk ) ∈ M k | |z1 |, . . . , |zk | < 1}. M<1
The dual pair (V ∗ , V ) of vector spaces gives V ∗ a locally convex topology. With the ˜ is also a locally convex space. Note that V 0 is topology induced from the one on V ∗ , G ˜ a subspace of G. ˜ u1 , . . . , uk , v ∈ V , both (1.1) and For any k ≥ 0, λ ∈ G, X ∂ λ(Pn (Q(u1 , . . . , uk , v; z1 , . . . , zk ))) ∂z1 n∈Z X λ(Pn (Q(L(−1)u1 , . . . , uk , v; z1 , . . . , zk ))) = n∈Z
Functional-Analytic Theory of Vertex (Operator) Algebras, I
65
k . Thus (1.1) is analytic in z when (z , are absolutely convergent in the region M<1 1 1 k . . . , zk ) is in M<1 . Similarly, (1.1) is analytic in zi for i = 2, . . . , k when (z1 , . . . , zk ) k . So (1.1) defines an analytic function on M k and we denote it by is in M<1 <1
gk (λ ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ v) since (1.1) is multilinear in λ, u1 , . . . , uk and v. These functions span a vector space Fk k . So we obtain a linear map of analytic functions on M<1 ˜ ⊗ V ⊗(k+1) → Fk . gk : G (k)
k such that Fix a sequence {Jn }n>0 of compact subsets of M<1 (k)
Jn(k) ⊂ Jn+1 , n > 0, and
[ n>0
k Jn(k) = M<1 .
As in the case of Rk , using these compact subsets, we define a sequence of norms k·kFk ,n on Fk , and these norms give a locally convex topology on Fk . There is also an embedding ιFk from Fk to Fk+1 defined as follows: We use k+1 ˜ . For λ ∈ G, (z0 , . . . , zk ) instead of (z1 , . . . , zk+1 ) to denote the elements of M<1 u1 , . . . , uk , v ∈ V , since Y (1, z) = 1 for any nonzero complex number z, gk+1 (λ ⊗ 1 ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ v) as a function of z0 , . . . , zk is in fact independent of z0 , and is equal to gk (λ ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ v) as a function of z1 , . . . , zk . Thus we obtain a well-defined linear map ιFk : Fk → Fk+1 such that ιFk ◦ gk = gk+1 ◦ φk , where
˜ ⊗ V ⊗(k+1) → G ˜ ⊗ V ⊗(k+2) φk : G
is defined by φk (λ ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ v) = λ ⊗ 1 ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ v ˜ u1 , . . . , uk , v ∈ V . It is clear that ιFk is injective. Thus we can regard Fk as for λ ∈ G, a subspace of Fk+1 . Moreover, we have: Proposition 1.1. For any k ≥ 0, ιFk as a map from Fk to ιFk (Fk ) is continuous and open. In other words, the topology on Fk is induced from that on Fk+1 .
66
Y.-Z. Huang
Proof. We consider the two topologies on Fk , one is the topology defined above for Fk and the other induced from the topology on Fk+1 . We need only prove that for any n > 0, (i) the norm k · kFk ,n is continuous in the topology induced from the one on Fk+1 , and (ii) the restriction of the norm k · kFk+1 ,n to Fk is continuous in the topology on Fk . Let {fα }α∈A be a net in Fk convergent in the topology induced from the one on Fk+1 . Then {fα }α∈A , when viewed as a net of functions in z0 , z1 , . . . , zk , is convergent uniformly on any compact subset of M k+1 . Since fα , α ∈ A, are independent of z0 , {fα }α∈A is in fact convergent uniformly on any compact subset of M k , proving (i). Now let {fα }α∈A be a net in Fk convergent in the topology on Fk . Then {fα }α∈A is convergent uniformly on any compact subset of M k . If we view fα , α ∈ A, as functions on C × M k , then the net {fα }α∈A is convergent uniformly on any subset of M k+1 of the form C × K where K is a compact subset of M k . But any compact subset of M k+1 is contained in a subset of the form C × K. So {fα }α∈A is convergent uniformly on any compact subset t of M k+1 , proving (ii). u We equip the topological dual space Fk∗ , k ≥ 0, of Fk with the strong topology, that is, the topology of uniform convergence on all the weakly bounded subsets of Fk (see p. 256 of [K1]). Then Fk∗ is a locally convex space. In fact, Fk∗ is a (DF)-space (see p. 396 of [K1]). ˜ be defined by ˜ and u ∈ V , let Y−1 (u)λ ∈ G For any λ ∈ G (Y−1 (u)λ)(v) = λ((Resx x −1 Y (u, x))v) for v ∈ V . (Note that Resx x −1 Y (u, x) is u−1 in the usual notation. So we could denote Y−1 (u) by u−1 . Here we use the notation Y−1 (u) to avoid the possible confusion with the notations u0 , u1 , . . . for elements in V used later.) For k ≥ 0, we define a linear map γk : Fk+1 → Fk by γk (gk+1 (λ ⊗ u0 ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ v)) = gk (Y−1 (u0 )λ) ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ v) ˜ u0 , u1 , . . . , ul , v ∈ V . for λ ∈ G, Proposition 1.2. The map γk is continuous and satisfies γk ◦ ιFk = IFk ,
(1.2)
where IFk is the identity map on Fk . k+1 . Proof. We use (z0 , . . . , zk ) instead of (z1 , . . . , zk+1 ) to denote the elements of M<1 From the definition, we see that for any positive number < 1, when |z1 |, . . . , |zk | < ,
γk (gk+1 (λ ⊗ u0 ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ ul ⊗ v)) I 1 z−1 gk+1 (λ ⊗ u0 ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ v)dz0 = √ 2π −1 |z0 |= 0 ˜ u0 , . . . , uk , v ∈ V . Thus for any n > 0, there exist mn > 0 and positive for λ ∈ G, number n such that
Functional-Analytic Theory of Vertex (Operator) Algebras, I
67
kγk (gk+1 (λ ⊗ u0 ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ v))kFk ,n = max |γk (gk+1 (λ ⊗ u0 ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ v))| (k)
(z1 ,...,zk )∈Jn
= ≤ ≤
max
I 1 √ (k) 2π −1
|z0 |=n
(z1 ,...,zk )∈Jn
max
(k)
(z1 ,...,zk )∈Jn ,|z0 |=n
max
(k+1)
(z0 ,...,zk )∈Jmn
z0−1 gk+1 (λ ⊗ u0 ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ v)dz0
|gk+1 (λ ⊗ u0 ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ v)|
|gk+1 (λ ⊗ u0 ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ v)|
= kgk+1 (λ ⊗ u0 ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ v)kFk+1 ,mn . This inequality implies that γk is continuous. ˜ u1 , · · · , uk , v ∈ V , by definition, For λ ∈ G, gk+1 (λ ⊗ 1 ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ v) = ιFk (gk (λ ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ v)). Since Y−1 (1)λ = λ, γk (gk+1 (λ ⊗ 1 ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ v)) = gk ((Y−1 (1)λ) ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ v) = gk (λ ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ v). So we have (1.2). u t Corollary 1.3. The adjoint map γk∗ of γk satisfies ι∗Fk ◦ γk∗ = IFk∗ ,
(1.3)
where ∗ → Fk∗ ι∗Fk : Fk+1
is the adjoint of ιFk and IFk∗ is the identity on Fk∗ . It is injective and continuous. As a map from Fk∗ to γk∗ (Fk∗ ), it is also open. In particular, if we identify Fk∗ with γk∗ (Fk∗ ), ∗ . the topology on Fk∗ is induced from the one on Fk+1 Proof. The identity (1.3) is an immediate consequence of the identity (1.2). By this identity, we see that γk∗ is injective. The continuity of γk∗ is a consequence of the continuity of γk . To show that it is open as a map from Fk∗ to γk∗ (Fk∗ ), we need only show that its inverse is continuous. Let {µα }α∈A be a net in Fk∗ such that {γk∗ (µα )}α∈A is convergent ∗ . Since ι∗ is continuous, {ι∗ (γ ∗ (µ ))} ∗ in Fk+1 α α∈A is convergent in Fk . By the identity Fk Fk k (1.2), µα = ι∗Fk (γk∗ (µα )) for α ∈ A. Thus {µα }α∈A is convergent in Fk∗ , proving that the inverse of γk∗ viewed as t a map from Fk∗ to γk∗ (Fk∗ ) is continuous. u
68
Y.-Z. Huang
˜ and the algebraic dual space G ˜ ∗ of We use h·, ·i to denote the pairing between G 0 ∗ ˜ Since V ⊂ G ˜ and V ⊂ G ˜ , this pairing is an extension of the pairing between V 0 G. ˜ and G ˜ ∗ form a dual pair and V denoted using the same symbol. With this pairing, G ˜ ∗. of vector spaces. This dual pair of vector spaces gives a locally convex topology to G ˜ the dual space G ˜ ∗ can be viewed as a subspace of (V 0 )∗ = V . We define Since V 0 ⊂ G, ˜∗ ⊂ V ek : V ⊗(k+1) ⊗ Fk∗ → G by
hλ, ek (u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ v ⊗ µ)i = µ(gk (λ ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ v))
˜ u1 , . . . , uk , v ∈ V and µ ∈ F ∗ . for λ ∈ G, k We now assume that V is finitely generated. The generators of V span a finitedimensional subspace X of V . We assume that the vacuum vector 1 is in X. Any norm on X induces a Banach space structure on X. Since X is finite-dimensional, all norms on X are equivalent, so that the topology induced by the norm is in fact independent of the norm. Since X is a finite-dimensional Banach space and Fk∗ is a locally convex space, ⊗(k+1) ⊗ Fk∗ is also a locally convex space. We denote the image ek (X ⊗(k+1) ⊗ Fk∗ ) X of X ⊗(k+1) ⊗ Fk∗ ⊂ V ⊗(k+1) ⊗ Fk∗ under ek by Gk . Proposition 1.4. For any k ≥ 0, Gk ⊂ Gk+1 . Proof. By definition, hλ, ek (u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ v ⊗ µ)i = µ(gk (λ ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ v) = µ(γk (gk+1 (λ ⊗ 1 ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ v)) = (γk∗ (µ))(gk+1 (λ ⊗ 1 ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ v)) = hλ, ek (1 ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ v ⊗ γk∗ (µ))i ˜ u1 , . . . , uk , v ∈ V and µ ∈ F ∗ . Thus for λ ∈ G, k ek (u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ v ⊗ µ) = ek (1 ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ ul ⊗ v ⊗ γk∗ (µ)) ∈ Gk+1 ˜ u1 , . . . , uk , v ∈ V and µ ∈ F ∗ . u for λ ∈ G, t k Proposition 1.5. The linear map ˜∗ ek |X⊗(k+1) ⊗F ∗ : X⊗(k+1) ⊗ Fk∗ → G k
is continuous. Proof. By the definition of the locally convex topology on the tensor product X⊗(k+1) ⊗ Fk∗ , we need only prove that ek |X⊗(k+1) ⊗F ∗ as a multilinear map from X⊗(k+1) × Fk∗ to k ˜ ∗ is continuous. G Let {(X α , µα )}α∈A be a net in X⊗(k+1) × Fk∗ convergent to 0. Then the nets {Xα }α∈A ˜ and {µα }α∈A are convergent to 0 in X⊗(k+1) and F ∗ , respectively. For any fixed λ ∈ G, k
since X ⊗(k+1) is a finite-dimensional Banach space, the linear map from X⊗(k+1) to Fk defined by u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ v 7 → gk (λ ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ v)
Functional-Analytic Theory of Vertex (Operator) Algebras, I
69
for u1 , . . . , uk , v ∈ X is continuous. Thus {gk (λ ⊗ Xα )}α∈A is convergent to 0 in Fk . In particular, there exists α0 ∈ A such that {gk (λ ⊗ Xα )}α∈A,α>α0 is weakly bounded. Thus ) ( sup
α 0 ∈A,α 0 >α0
µα (gk (λ ⊗ Xα 0 )) α∈A
is convergent to 0. In particular, {µα (gk (λ ⊗ Xα ))}α∈A,α>α0 or equivalently
{µα (gk (λ ⊗ Xα ))}α∈A
is convergent to 0. Since hλ, ek (Xα ⊗ µα )i = µα (gk (λ ⊗ Xα )), ˜ By the definition of we see that {hλ, ek (Xα ⊗ µα )i}α∈A is convergent to 0 for λ ∈ G. ∗ ∗ ˜ ˜ t the topology on G , {ek (Xα ⊗ µα )}α∈A is convergent to 0 in G . u From Proposition 1.5, we conclude: Corollary 1.6. The quotient space (X ⊗(k+1) ⊗ Fk∗ )/(ek |X⊗(k+1) ⊗F ∗ )−1 (0) k
is a locally convex space. Since Gk is linearly isomorphic to (X⊗(k+1) ⊗ Fk∗ )/(ek |X⊗(k+1) ⊗F ∗ )−1 (0), k
the locally convex space structure on (X ⊗(k+1) ⊗ Fk∗ )/(ek |X⊗(k+1) ⊗F ∗ )−1 (0) k
gives a locally convex space structure on Gk . Let Hk be the completion of Gk . Then Hk is a complete locally convex space. Proposition 1.7. The space Hk can be embedded canonically in Hk+1 . The topology on Hk is the same as the one induced from the topology on Hk+1 . Proof. The first conclusion follows from Proposition 1.4. To prove the second conclusion, we need only prove that the topology on Gk is the same as the one induced from the topology on Gk+1 . We have the following commutative diagram: ψk
∗ X ⊗(k+1) ⊗ Fk∗ −−−−→ X⊗(k+2) ⊗ Fk+1 e ek y y k+1
Gk where
−−−−→
Gk+1
∗ ψk : X⊗(k+1) ⊗ Fk∗ → X⊗(k+2) ⊗ Fk+1
70
Y.-Z. Huang
is defined by ψk (u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ v ⊗ µ) = 1 ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ v ⊗ γk∗ (µ) for u1 , . . . , uk , v ∈ X and µ ∈ Fk∗ . By Corollary 1.3, if we identify Fk∗ with γk∗ (Fk∗ ), ∗ . By the definition of the topologies the topology on Fk∗ is induced from the one on Fk+1 on Gk and Gk+1 and the commutativity of the diagram above, we see that the topology t on Gk is the same as the one induced from the topology on Gk+1 . u By Proposition 1.7, we have a sequence {Hk }k≥0 of strictly increasing complete locally convex spaces. Let [ Hk . H = k≥0
We equip H with the inductive limit topology. Then H is a complete locally convex space. Let [ Gk . G= k≥0
Then G is a dense subspace of H . Note that V ⊂ G ⊂ V . Since elements of V are finite or infinite sums of elements of V , elements of G are also finite or infinite sums of elements of V . Thus infinite sums of elements of V belonging to G must be convergent in the topology on H . So G is in the closure of V . Since G is dense in H , we obtain: Theorem 1.8. The vector space H equipped with the strict inductive limit topology is a locally convex completion of V . 2. The Locally Convex Completion and the Vertex Operator Map In this section we construct continuous linear maps from the topological completion of H ⊗ H to H associated with conformal equivalence classes of closed disks with two ordered open disks inside deleted and with the standard parametrizations at the boundary components. We consider the closed unit disk centered at 0. We delete two ordered open disks inside: the first centered at z with radius r1 and the second centered at 0 with radius r2 . See Fig. 1. The positive numbers r1 , r2 and the nonzero complex number z must satisfy the conditions r2 + 2r1 < 1 and r2 < |z| < 1. The three boundary circles are parametrized by the maps eiθ 7 → eiθ , eiθ 7 → z + r1 eiθ , eiθ 7 → r2 eiθ . We denote the resulting closed disk with two disjoint open disks inside deleted and with ordered boundary components parametrized as above by D(z; r1 , r2 ). Note that any closed disks with two ordered open disks inside deleted and with the standard parametrizations is conformally equivalent to D(z; r1 , r2 ) for some z ∈ C× , and some positive numbers r1 , r2 satisfying r2 + 2r1 < 1 and r2 < |z| < 1.
Functional-Analytic Theory of Vertex (Operator) Algebras, I
71
r1 z r2 0
1
Figure 1.
eH be the topological completion of the vector space tensor product H ⊗ H . Let H ⊗ We would like to construct a continuous linear map eH → H ν Y ([D(z; r1 , r2 )]) : H ⊗ associated with the conformal equivalence class [D(z; r1 , r2 )] of D(z; r1 , r2 ). We know ˆ = C ∪ {∞} with the negatively oriented that D(z; r1 , r2 ) corresponds to the sphere C punctures ∞, the ordered positively oriented puncture z, 0 and with the local coordinates w 7 → 1/w, w 7 → (w − z)/r1 and w/r2 vanishing at ∞, z and 0, respectively. In the notation of [H6], the conformal equivalence class of this sphere with tubes of type (1, 2) is (z; 0, (1/r1 , 0), (1/r2 , 0)) ∈ K(2). Associated with this class, we have a linear map L(0)
νY ((z; 0, (1/r1 , 0), (1/r2 , 0))) = Y (r1
L(0)
·, z)r2
·:V ⊗V →V
eH , that the im(see [H6]). We now show that this linear map can be extended to H ⊗ age of this extension is in H and that this extension is continuous. Then we define ν Y ([D(z; r1 , r2 )]) to be this extension. ˜ and u ∈ V , we define an element u [D(z;r1 ,r2 )] λ ∈ V ∗ by For any λ ∈ G (u [D(z;r1 ,r2 )] λ)(v) =
X
L(0)
λ(Pn (Y (r1
L(0)
u, z)r2
v))
n∈Z
=
X
L(0)
λ(Pn (Q(r1
n∈Z
for v ∈ V . ˜ Proposition 2.1. The element u [D(z;r1 ,r2 )] λ is in G.
L(0)
u, r2
v; z)))
72
Y.-Z. Huang
Proof. For any k ≥ 0, u1 , . . . , uk , v ∈ V , X (u [D(z;r1 ,r2 )] λ)(Pm (Q(u1 , . . . , uk , v; z1 , . . . , zk ))) m∈Z
=
XX
L(0)
u, z)r2
L(0)
u, z) ·
λ(Pn (Y (r1
L(0)
Pm (Q(u1 , . . . , uk , v; z1 , . . . , zk )))
m∈Z n∈Z
=
XX
λ(Pn (Y (r1
m∈Z n∈Z L(0)
·Pm (Q(r2
L(0)
u1 , . . . , r2
L(0)
uk , r2
v; r2 z1 , . . . , r2 zk ))).
(2.1)
Since the Z-grading of V is lower-truncated and since r2 < |z| < 1, for any k , there exists a positive number δ > 1 such that the Laurent series (z1 , . . . , zk ) ∈ M<1 2 X
m∈Z
=
L(0)
L(0)
λ(Pn (Y (r1
u, z)Pm (Q(r2
X
L(0)
λ(Pn (Y (r1
L(0)
u1 , . . . , r2
L(0)
uk , r2
v; r2 z1 , . . . , r2 zk ))))t2m
u, z) ·
m∈Z L(0)
=
X
·Pm (t2
L(0)
L(0)
u1 , . . . , r2
L(0)
v; r2 z1 , . . . , r2 zk )))) L(0) L(0) λ(Pn (Y (r1 u, z)Pm (Q((t2 r2 ) u1 , . . . , (t2 r2 )L(0) uk , (t2 r2 )L(0) v;
m∈Z
Q(r2
uk , r2
t2 r2 z1 , . . . , t2 r2 zk ))))
in t2 has only finitely many negative powers and is absolutely convergent to L(0)
λ(Pn (Q(r1
u, (t2 r2 )L(0) u1 , . . . , (t2 r2 )L(0) uk , (t2 r2 )L(0) v; z, t2 r2 z1 , . . . , t2 r2 zk )))
˜ and |z| < 1, for any (z1 , . . . , zk ) ∈ M k , there when 0 < |t2 | < δ2 . Since λ ∈ G <1 exists a positive number δ1 > 1 such that the Laurent series in t1 X L(0) L(0) L(0) L(0) λ(Pn (Q(r1 u, r2 u1 , . . . , r2 uk , r2 v; z, r2 z1 , . . . , r2 zk )))t1n n∈Z
=
X
L(0)
λ(Pn (t1
L(0)
Q(r1
L(0)
u, r2
L(0)
u1 , . . . , r2
L(0)
uk , r2
v; z, r2 z1 , . . . , r2 zk )))
n∈Z
=
X
n∈Z
λ(Pn (Q((t1 r1 )L(0) u, (t1 r2 )L(0) u1 , . . . , (t1 r2 )L(0) uk , (t1 r2 )L(0) v; t1 z, t1 r2 z1 , . . . , t1 r2 zk )))
k , the iterated is absolutely convergent when 0 < |t1 | < δ1 . Thus for (z1 , . . . , zk ) ∈ M<1 sum XX L(0) L(0) L(0) L(0) λ(Pn (Y (r1 u, z)Pm (Q(r2 u1 , . . . , r2 uk , r2 v; n∈Z m∈Z
r2 z1 , . . . , r2 zk ))))t1n t2m
is absolutely convergent when 0 < |t1 | < δ1 and 0 < |t2 | < δ2 .
(2.2)
Functional-Analytic Theory of Vertex (Operator) Algebras, I
73
The iterated sum (2.2) gives a function of t1 and t2 in the region 0 < |t1 | < δ1 , 0 < |t2 | < δ2 . It is clear that this function is analytic in t1 and t2 . Thus it has a Laurent expansion which must be X L(0) L(0) L(0) L(0) λ(Pn (Y (r1 u, z)Pm (Q(r2 u1 , . . . , r2 uk , r2 v; n,m∈Z
r2 z1 , . . . , r2 zk ))))t1n t2m .
Since this double sum is equal to the Laurent expansion, it is absolutely convergent and thus both iterated sums are absolutely convergent. In particular, when t1 = t2 = 1, we see that the right-hand side of (2.1) and consequently the left-hand side of (2.1) are k , proving that u ˜ absolutely convergent when (z1 , . . . , zk ) ∈ M<1 [D(z;r1 ,r2 )] λ is in G. t u ˜ ⊗ Xl+1 ⊗ F ∗ → V ∗ by For any l ≥ 0, we define a linear map αl : G l (αl (λ ⊗ v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vl ⊗ v ⊗ ν))(u) = hu [D(z;r1 ,r2 )] λ, el (v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vl ⊗ v ⊗ ν)i ˜ v1 , . . . , vl , v ∈ X, ν ∈ F ∗ and u ∈ V . for λ ∈ G, l ˜ Proposition 2.2. The image of αl is in G. ˜ u1 , . . . , uk , u, ∈ V , v1 , . . . , vl , v ∈ X and ν ∈ F ∗ , Proof. For any k ≥ 0, λ ∈ G, l X (αl (λ ⊗ v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vl ⊗ v ⊗ ν))(Pn (Q(u1 , . . . , uk , u; z1 , . . . , zk ))) n∈Z
=
X
h(Pn (Q(u1 , . . . , uk , u; z1 , . . . , zk )) [D(z;r1 ,r2 )] λ),
n∈Z
=
X
el (v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vl ⊗ v ⊗ ν)i ν(gl ((Pn (Q(u1 , . . . , uk , u; z1 , . . . , zk )) [D(z;r1 ,r2 )] λ)
n∈Z
⊗v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ ⊗vl ⊗ v)) X X ν (Pn (Q(u1 , . . . , uk , u; z1 , . . . , zk )) [D(z;r1 ,r2 )] λ) = n∈Z
m∈Z
(Pm (Q(v1 , . . . , vk , v; zk+1 , . . . , zk+l ))) .
By the definition of Pn (Q(u1 , . . . , uk , u; z1 , . . . , zk )) [D(z;r1 ,r2 )] λ, we have (Pn (Q(u1 , . . . , uk , u; z1 , . . . , zk )) [D(z;r1 ,r2 )] λ) (Pm (Q(v1 , . . . , vk , v; zk+1 , . . . , zk+l ))) X L(0) λ(Pp (Y (r1 Pn (Q(u1 , . . . , uk , u; z1 , . . . , zk )), z) · = p∈Z
(2.3)
74
Y.-Z. Huang L(0)
=
·r2
X
Pm (Q(v1 , . . . , vl , v; zk+1 , . . . , zk+l )))) L(0)
λ(Pp (Y (Pn (Q(r1
L(0)
u1 , . . . , r1
L(0)
uk , r1
u; r1 z1 , . . . , r1 zk )), z) ·
p∈Z L(0)
·Pm (Q(r2
L(0)
v1 , . . . , r2
L(0)
vl , r2
v; r2 zk+1 , . . . , r2 zk+l )))). (2.4)
Using the associativity of vertex operators, we know that the element XX L(0) L(0) L(0) Y (Pn (Q(r1 u1 , . . . , r1 uk , r1 u; r1 z1 , . . . , r1 zk )), z)· n∈Z m∈Z L(0)
·Pm (Q(r2
L(0)
v1 , . . . , r2
L(0)
vl , r2
v; r2 zk+1 , . . . , r2 zk+l ))
in V is equal to L(0)
Q(r1
L(0)
L(0)
L(0)
L(0)
L(0)
u1 , . . . , r1 uk , r1 u, r2 v1 , . . . , r2 vl , r2 v; r1 z1 + z, . . . , r1 zk + z, z, r2 zk+1 , . . . , r2 zk+l )
k and (z l when (z1 , . . . , zk ) ∈ M<1 k+1 , . . . , zk+l ) ∈ M<1 . This fact and (2.4) imply that
XX
(Pn (Q(u1 , . . . , uk , u; z1 , . . . , zk )) [D(z;r1 ,r2 )] λ)
n∈Z m∈Z
(Pm (Q(v1 , . . . , vk , v; zk+1 , . . . , zk+l )))
is convergent absolutely to L(0)
λ(Pp (Q(r1
L(0)
L(0)
L(0)
L(0)
L(0)
u1 , . . . , r1 uk , r1 u, r2 v1 , . . . , r2 vl , r2 r1 z1 + z, . . . , r1 zk + z, z, r2 zk+1 , . . . , r2 zk+l )))
v;
k and (z l ˜ when (z1 , . . . , zk ) ∈ M<1 k+1 , . . . , zk+l ) ∈ M<1 . Since λ ∈ G,
X
L(0)
λ(Pp (Q(r1
L(0)
u1 , . . . , r1
L(0)
uk , r1
L(0)
u, r2
L(0)
v1 , . . . , r2
L(0)
vl , r2
v;
p∈Z
r1 z1 + z, . . . , r1 zk + z, z, r2 zk+1 , . . . , r2 zk+l ))) k and (z l is absolutely convergent when (z1 , . . . , zk ) ∈ M<1 k+1 , . . . , zk+l ) ∈ M<1 . The arguments above prove that the iterated sum XXX L(0) L(0) L(0) λ(Pp (Y (Pn (Q(r1 u1 , . . . , r1 uk , r1 u; r1 z1 , . . . , r1 zk )), z)· p∈Z n∈Z m∈Z L(0)
·Pm (Q(r2
L(0)
v1 , . . . , r2
L(0)
vl , r2
v; r2 zk+1 , . . . , r2 zk+l ))))
k and (z l is absolutely convergent when (z1 , . . . , zk ) ∈ M<1 k+1 , . . . , zk+l ) ∈ M<1 . The same method as in the proof of Proposition 2.1 shows that in fact the corresponding triple sum is absolutely convergent and thus all the iterated sums are absolutely convergent k and (z l and are all equal when (z1 , . . . , zk ) ∈ M<1 k+1 , . . . , zk+l ) ∈ M<1 . So
Functional-Analytic Theory of Vertex (Operator) Algebras, I
XXX
L(0)
λ(Pp (Y (Pn (Q(r1
75 L(0)
u1 , . . . , r1
L(0)
uk , r1
u; r1 z1 , . . . , r1 zk )), z)·
n∈Z m∈Z p∈Z L(0)
L(0)
L(0)
·Pm (Q(r2 v1 , . . . , r2 vl , r2 v; r2 zk+1 , . . . , r2 zk+l )))) XX (Pn (Q(u1 , . . . , uk , u; z1 , . . . , zk )) [D(z;r1 ,r2 )] λ) = n∈Z m∈Z
(Pm (Q(v1 , . . . , vk , v; zk+1 , . . . , zk+l )))
k and (z l is absolutely convergent when (z1 , . . . , zk ) ∈ M<1 k+1 , . . . , zk+l ) ∈ M<1 . By (2.3), we see that the left-hand side of (2.3) is also absolutely convergent when k and (z l (z1 , . . . , zk ) ∈ M<1 k+1 , . . . , zk+l ) ∈ M<1 , proving that
αl (λ ⊗ v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vl ⊗ v ⊗ ν) ˜ u is indeed in G. t By Proposition 2.2, X αl (λ ⊗ v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vl ⊗ v ⊗ ν)(Pn (Q(u1 , . . . , uk , u; z1 , . . . , zk ))) n∈Z
is absolutely convergent and the sum is equal to gk (αl (λ ⊗ v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vl ⊗ v ⊗ ν) ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ u) ∈ Fk . We define an linear map
∗ βk,l : Fk∗ ⊗ Fl∗ → Fk+l+1
by (βk,l (µ, ν))(gk+l+1 (λ ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk+1 ⊗ u ⊗ v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vl ⊗ v)) = µ(gk (αl (λ ⊗ v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vl ⊗ v ⊗ ν) ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ u)) ˜ u1 , . . . , uk , u, v1 , . . . , vl , v ∈ V , µ ∈ F ∗ and ν ∈ F ∗ . In fact this formula for λ ∈ G, k l only gives a linear map from Fk∗ ⊗ Fl∗ to the algebraic dual of Fk+l+1 . We have: ∗ and the map βk,l is Proposition 2.3. The image of the map βk,l is indeed in Fk+l+1 continuous. ζ
Proof. To avoid notational confusions in the proof, we use Fk , k ≥ 0, to denote the k . Similarly we space Fk whose elements are viewed as functions of (ζ1 , . . . , ζk ) ∈ M<1 η ˜ u1 , . . . , uk , u, have the notation Fl , l ≥ 0. Let µ ∈ Fk∗ and ν ∈ Fl∗ . For any λ ∈ G, v1 , . . . , vl , v ∈ V , we have an element g(z1 , . . . , zk+l+1 ) = gk+l+1 (λ ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk+1 ⊗ u ⊗ v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vl ⊗ v)
(2.5)
of Fk+l+1 . By definition |(βk,l (µ, ν))(g(z1 , . . . , zk+l+1 ))| = |(βk,l (µ, ν))(gk+l+1 (λ ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk+1 ⊗ u ⊗ v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vl ⊗ v))| (2.6) = |µ(gk (αl (λ ⊗ v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vl ⊗ v ⊗ ν) ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ u))|.
76
Y.-Z. Huang
We now view gk (αl (λ ⊗ v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vl ⊗ v ⊗ ν) ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ u) ζ
as an element of Fk . Then gk (αl (λ ⊗ v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vl ⊗ v ⊗ ν) ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ u) X = (αl (λ ⊗ v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vl ⊗ v ⊗ ν))(Pp (Q(u1 , . . . , uk , u; ζ1 , . . . , ζk ))) p∈Z
=
X
ν(gl ((Pp (Q(u1 , . . . , uk , u; ζ1 , . . . , ζk )) [D(z;r1 ,r2 )] λ)
p∈Z
⊗v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vl ⊗ v)).
(2.7)
For fixed ζ1 , . . . , ζk , we view gl ((Pp (Q(u1 , . . . , uk , u; ζ1 , . . . , ζk1 )) [D(z;r1 ,r2 )] λ) ⊗ v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vl ⊗ v) η
as an element of Fl . Then by definition we have X
p∈Z
=
gl ((Pp (Q(u1 , . . . , uk , u; ζ1 , . . . , ζk1 )) [D(z;r1 ,r2 )] λ) ⊗ v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vl ⊗ v) XX
(Pp (Q(u1 , . . . , uk , u; ζ1 , . . . , ζk1 )) [D(z;r1 ,r2 )] λ)
p∈Z q∈Z
(Pq (Q(v1 , . . . , vl , v; η1 , . . . , ηl ))) XXX L(0) λ(Pj (Y (r1 Pp (Q(u1 , . . . , uk , u; ζ1 , . . . , ζk1 )), z) · = p∈Z q∈Z j ∈Z L(0)
=
·r2 XXX
Pq (Q(v1 , . . . , vl , v; η1 , . . . , ηl )))) L(0)
λ(Pj (Y (Pp (Q(r1
L(0)
u1 , . . . , r1
L(0)
uk , r1
u; r1 ζ1 , . . . , r1 ζk1 )), z) ·
p∈Z q∈Z j ∈Z L(0)
·Pq (Q(r2
L(0)
v1 , . . . , r2
L(0)
vl , r2
v; r2 η1 , . . . , r2 ηl )))).
(2.8)
We now calculate the right-hand side of (2.8). For any nonzero complex numbers t0 , t1 , t2 , X L(0) L(0) L(0) λ(Pj (Y (Pp (Q(r1 u1 , . . . , r1 uk , r1 u; r1 ζ1 , . . . , r1 ζk1 )), z)· p,q,j ∈Z
=
X
L(0)
·Pq (Q(r2 L(0)
λ(Pj (t0
L(0)
v1 , . . . , r2 L(0)
Y (Pp (t1
L(0)
Q(r1
L(0)
vl , r2
j p q
v; r2 η1 , . . . , r2 ηl ))))t0 t1 t2 L(0)
u1 , . . . , r1
L(0)
uk , r1
u;
p,q,j ∈Z L(0)
L(0)
L(0)
L(0)
r1 ζ1 , . . . , r1 ζk1 )), z)Pq (t2 Q(r2 v1 , . . . , r2 vl , r2 v; r2 η1 , . . . , r2 ηl )))) X λ(Pj (Y (Pp (Q((t0 t1 r1 )L(0) u1 , . . . , (t0 t1 r1 )L(0) uk , (t0 t1 r1 )L(0) u; = p,q,j ∈Z
Functional-Analytic Theory of Vertex (Operator) Algebras, I
77
t0 t1 r1 ζ1 , . . . , t0 t1 r1 ζk1 )), t0 z)Pq (Q((t0 t2 r1 )L(0) v1 , . . . , (t0 t2 r1 )L(0) vl , (t0 t2 r1 )L(0) v; (2.9) t0 t2 r2 η1 , . . . , t0 t2 r2 ηl )))). By the associativity of vertex operators and the definition of the map gk+l+1 , there exists real numbers δ0 , δ1 , δ2 > 1 such that the right-hand side of (2.9) is convergent absolutely to gk+l+1 (λ ⊗ (t0 t1 r1 )L(0) u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ (t0 t1 r1 )L(0) uk ⊗ (t0 t1 r1 )L(0) u⊗
(t0 t2 r1 )L(0) v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ (t0 t2 r1 )L(0) vl ⊗ (t0 t2 r1 )L(0) v)|zi =t0 z+t0 t1 r1 ζi ,i=1,...,k,zk+1 =t0 z,zk+1+j =t0 t2 r2 ηj ,j =1,...,l (2.10)
when 0 < t0 < δ0 , 0 < t1 < δ1 and 0 < t1 < δ1 . In particular, when t0 = t1 = t2 = 1, we see that (2.10) is equal to and thus the right-hand side of (2.8) is convergent absolutely to L(0)
gk+l+1 (λ ⊗ r1 L(0) ⊗r2 vl
L(0)
u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ r1
L(0)
uk ⊗ r1
L(0)
u ⊗ r2
v1 ⊗ · · · L(0) ⊗ r2 v)|zi =z+r1 ζi ,i=1,...,k,zk+1 =z,zk+1+j =r2 ηj ,j =1,...,l . (2.11)
k , (2.11) as a function of η , . . . , η is an element of Hence for fixed (ζ1 , . . . , ζk ) ∈ M<1 1 l η Fl . We denote this element by fg;ζ1 ,...,ζk (η1 , . . . , ηl ). η ζ We now view µ and ν as elements of (Fk )∗ and (Fl )∗ , respectively. Since ν is continuous, by the calculations above, we have
ν(fg;ζ1 ,...,ζk (η1 , . . . , ηl )) X gl ((Pp (Q(u1 , . . . , uk , u; ζ1 , . . . , ζk1 )) [D(z;r1 ,r2 )] λ) =ν p∈Z
⊗v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vl ⊗ v)
=
X
ν(gl ((Pp (Q(u1 , . . . , uk , u; ζ1 , . . . , ζk1 )) [D(z;r1 ,r2 )] λ)
p∈Z
⊗v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vl ⊗ v)).
(2.12)
By the calculations from (2.6) to (2.12), we see that ζ
ν(fg;ζ1 ,...,ζk (η1 , . . . , ηl )) ∈ Fk and we obtain
|(βk,l (µ, ν))(g(z1 , . . . , zk+l+1 ))| = |µ(ν(fg;ζ1 ,...,ζk (η1 , . . . , ηl )))|.
(2.13)
For g(z1 , . . . , zk+l+1 ) ∈ Fk+l+1 not of the form (2.5), we use linearity to define the functions fg;ζ1 ,...,ζk (η1 , . . . , ηl ). Then (2.13) holds for any g(z1 , . . . , zk+l+1 ) ∈ Fk+l+1 .
78
Y.-Z. Huang
From the definition of fg;ζ1 ,...,ζk (η1 , . . . , ηl ), we see that for any fixed (ζ1 , . . . , ζk ) ∈ η k , the linear map from F M<1 k+l+1 to Fl given by g 7 → fg;ζ1 ,...,ζk (η1 , . . . , ηl ) η
for g ∈ Fk+l+1 is continuous, and for any fixed ν ∈ (Fl )∗ , the linear map from Fk+l+1 ζ to Fk given by g 7 → ν(fg;ζ1 ,...,ζk (η1 , . . . , ηl )) is also continuous. Thus by (2.13), βk,l (µ, ν) is continuous. So the elements of image ∗ . of βk,l are in Fk+l+1 From the definition of fg;ζ1 ,...,ζk (η1 , . . . , ηl ), we see that given any weakly bounded subset B of Fk+l+1 , the subset η
B 0 = {fg;ζ1 ,...,ζk (η1 , . . . , ηl ) | g ∈ B} ⊂ Fl
k is weakly bounded, and thus for any net {ν } for fixed (ζ1 , . . . , ζk ) ∈ M<1 α α∈A convergent η ∗ to 0 in (Fl ) , there exists α0 ∈ A such that the subset ζ
B 00 ({να }α∈A ) = {να (fg;ζ1 ,...,ζk (η1 , . . . , ηl )) | g ∈ B, α > α0 } ⊂ Fk
is also weakly bounded. η ζ Now let {(µα , να )}α∈A be a net convergent to 0 in (Fk )∗ × (Fl )∗ . Then the nets η ζ {µα }α∈A and {να }α∈A are convergent to 0 in (Fk )∗ and (Fl )∗ , respectively. Thus by (2.13) and the discussion above, supg(z1 ,...,zk+l+1 )∈B |(βk,l (µα , να ))(g(z1 , . . . , zk+l+1 ))| ≤ suph(ζ1 ,...,ζk )∈B 00 ({να }α∈A ) |µα (h(ζ1 , . . . , ζk ))|
(2.14)
when α > α0 . By the definition of the topology on Fk∗ , the net on the right-hand side of (2.14) is convergent to 0. Thus the net on the left-hand side of (2.14) is convergent to 0, t proving the continuity of the map βk1 ,k2 . u Let h1 = ek (u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ u ⊗ µ) ∈ Gk and h2 = el (v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vl ⊗ v ⊗ ν) ∈ Gl , where u1 , . . . , uk , u, v1 , . . . , vl , v ∈ X, µ ∈ Fk∗ and µ ∈ Fl∗ . We define (ν Y ([D(z; r0 , r1 , r2 )]))(h1 ⊗ h2 ) = ek+l+1 (u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ u ⊗ v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vl ⊗ v ⊗ βk,l (µ, ν)). Note that any element of Gk or Gl is a linear combination of elements of the form h1 or h2 , respectively, given above, and that k and l are arbitrary. Thus we obtain a linear map ν Y ([D(z; r0 , r1 , r2 )])|G⊗G : G ⊗ G → G. Proposition 2.4. The map ν Y ([D(z; r1 , r2 )])|G⊗G is continuous.
Functional-Analytic Theory of Vertex (Operator) Algebras, I
79
Proof. From the definition of ν Y ([D(z; r1 , r2 )])|G⊗G , we see that for any k, l ≥ 0, ν Y ([D(z; r1 , r2 )]))(Gk ⊗ Gl ) is in Gk+l+1 . To prove that ν Y ([D(z; r1 , r2 )])|G⊗G is continuous, we need only prove that for any k, l ≥ 0, it is continuous as a map from Gk ⊗ Gl to Gk+l+1 . Since the topology on Gk and Gl are defined to be the quotient topologies on (X⊗(k+1) ⊗ Fk∗ )/(ek |X⊗(k+1) ⊗F ∗ )−1 (0) k
and
(X ⊗(l+1) ⊗ Fl∗ )/(el |X⊗(l+1) ⊗F ∗ )−1 (0), l
respectively, we need only prove that the map (ν Y ([D(z; r1 , r2 )])) ◦ (ek |X⊗(k+1) ⊗F ∗ ⊗ el |X⊗(l+1) ⊗F ∗ ) : k
l
(X ⊗(k+1) ⊗ Fk∗ ) ⊗ (X⊗(l+1) ⊗ Fl∗ ) → Gk+l+1 is continuous. On the other hand, by definition, (ν Y ([D(z; r1 , r2 )])) ◦ (ek |X⊗(k+1) ⊗F ∗ ⊗ el |X⊗(l+1) ⊗F ∗ ) = ek+l+1 |X⊗(k+l+2) ⊗F ∗
k+l+1
k
l
◦ (IX⊗(k+l+1) ⊗ βk,l ) ◦ σ23 ,
where IX⊗(k+l+1) is the identity map on X⊗(k+l+1) and σ23 : (X⊗(k+1) ⊗ Fk∗ ) ⊗ (X⊗(l+1) ⊗ Fl∗ ) → X⊗(k+l+2) ⊗ Fk∗ ⊗ Fl∗ is the map permuting the second and the third tensor factor, that is, σ23 (X1 ⊗ µ ⊗ X2 ⊗ ν) = X1 ⊗ X2 ⊗ µ ⊗ ν for X1 ∈ X⊗(k+1) , µ ∈ Fk∗ , X2 ∈ X ⊗(l+1) and ν ∈ Fl∗ . Since the topology on Gk+l+1 is defined to be the quotient topology on ∗ )/(ek+l+1 |X⊗(k+l+2) ⊗F ∗ (X⊗(k+l+2) ⊗ Fk+l+1
k+l+1
)−1 (0),
we need only prove that the map (IX⊗(k+l+1) ⊗βk,l )◦σ23 is continuous. But IX⊗(k+l+1) and σ23 are obviously continuous and βk,l is continuous by Proposition 2.3. So (IX⊗(k+l+1) ⊗ t βk,l ) ◦ σ23 is indeed continuous. u Since G is dense in H , we can extend (ν Y ([D(z; r1 , r2 )]))|G⊗G to a linear map eH to H . ν Y ([D(z; r1 , r2 )]) from H ⊗ Theorem 2.5. The map ν Y ([D(z; r1 , r2 )]) is a continuous extension of νY ((z; 0, (1/r1 , 0), (1/r2 , 0))) eH. That is, ν Y ([D(z; r1 , r2 )]) is continuous and to H ⊗ ν Y ([D(z; r1 , r2 )])|V ⊗V = νY ((z; 0, (1/r1 , 0), (1/r2 , 0))).
80
Y.-Z. Huang
Proof. The continuity of ν Y ([D(z; r1 , r2 )]) follows from the definition and Proposition 2.4. For any m1 , . . . , mk ∈ Z, let µm1 ,...,mk be an element of Fk∗ defined by µm1 ,...,mk (gk (λ ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ u)) I I 1 1 ··· √ z1m1 · · · zkmk · = √ 2π −1 |z1 |=1 2π −1 |zk |=k ·gk (λ ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ u)dzk · · · dzk ˜ u1 , . . . , uk , u ∈ V , where 1 , . . . , k are arbitrary positive real numbers for λ ∈ G, satisfying 1 > · · · > k . Since V is generated by X, elements of the form ek (u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ u ⊗ µm1 ,...,mk ), k ≥ 0, u1 , . . . , uk , u ∈ X and m1 , . . . , mk ∈ Z, span V . Let h1 = ek (u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ u ⊗ µm1 ,...,mk ) and h2 = el (v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vl ⊗ v ⊗ µn1 ,...,nl ) be two such elements of V . Then hλ, (ν Y ([D(z; r1 , r2 )]))(h1 ⊗ h2 )i = hλ, ek+l+1 (u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ u ⊗v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vl ⊗ v ⊗ βk,l (µm1 ,...,mk , µn1 ,...,nl ))i = βk,l (µm1 ,...,mk , µn1 ,...,nl ) (gk+l+1 (λ ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ u ⊗ v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vl ⊗ v)) = µm1 ,...,mk (gk (αl (λ ⊗ v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vl ⊗ v ⊗ µn1 ,...,nl ) ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ u)). (2.15) As in the proof of Proposition 2.3, to avoid notational confusions, we view gk (αl (λ ⊗ v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vl ⊗ v ⊗ µn1 ,...,nl ) ⊗ u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ u) ζ
as an element of Fk and gl ((Pn (Q(u1 , . . . , uk , v; ζ1 , . . . , ζk )) [D(z;r1 ,r2 )] λ) ⊗ v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vl ⊗ v) η
ζ
as an element of Fl . We also view µm1 ,...,mk and νn1 ,...,nl as elements of (Fk )∗ and η (Fl )∗ , respectively. Then the right-hand side of (2.15) is equal to µm1 ,...,mk
X n∈Z
αl (λ ⊗ v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vl ⊗ v ⊗ µn1 ,...,nl )
(Pn (Q(u1 , . . . , uk , u; ζ1 , . . . , ζk ))))
Functional-Analytic Theory of Vertex (Operator) Algebras, I
= µm1 ,...,mk
X
81
µn1 ,...,nl (gl ((Pn (Q(u1 , . . . , uk , u; ζ1 , . . . , ζk )) [D(z;r1 ,r2 )] λ)
n∈Z
⊗v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vl ⊗ v)) = µm1 ,...,mk
X
µn1 ,...,nl
X
n∈Z
(Pn (Q(u1 , . . . , uk , u; ζ1 , . . . , ζk )) [D(z;r1 ,r2 )] λ)
m∈Z
(Pm (Q(v1 , . . . , vl , v; η1 , . . . , ηl ))) = µm1 ,...,mk
X
µn1 ,...,nl
X X
n∈Z
L(0)
λ(Pp (r1
·
m∈Z p∈Z
·Y (Pn (Q(u1 , . . . , uk , u; ζ1 , . . . , ζk )), z) · L(0) ·r2 Pm (Q(v1 , . . . , vl , v; η1 , . . . , ηl ))) I I 1 1 ··· √ ζ1m1 · · · ζkmk · = √ 2π −1 |ζ1 |=1 2π −1 |ζk |=k I I X 1 1 ··· √ η1n1 · · · ηlnl · · √ 2π −1 |η1 |=δ1 2π −1 |ηl |=δl n∈Z XX L(0) λ(Pp (r1 Y (Pn (Q(u1 , . . . , uk , u; ζ1 , . . . , ζk )), z) · · m∈Z p∈Z L(0)
=
·r2 XXX
Pm (Q(v1 , . . . , vl , v; η1 , . . . , ηl ))) L(0)
λ(Pp (r1
n∈Z m∈Z p∈Z
Y (Pn (Resx1 · · · Resxk x1m1 · · · xkmk · L(0)
·Y (u1 , x1 ) · · · Y (uk , x1 )u), z)r2
=
·
·Pn (Resy1 · · · Resyl y1n1 · · · ylnl Y (v1 , y1 ) · · · Y (vl , yl )v)) X L(0) L(0) λ(Pp (Y (r1 h1 , z)r2 h2 )) p∈Z L(0)
= hλ, Y (r1
L(0)
h1 , z)r2
h2 i.
(2.16)
From (2.15) and (2.16), we get (ν Y ([D(z; r1 , r2 )]))(h1 ⊗ h2 ) L(0)
L(0)
= Y (r1 h1 , z)r2 h2 = (νY ((z; 0, (1/r1 , 0), (1/r2 , 0))))(h1 ⊗ h2 ), proving the theorem. u t 3. A Locally Convex Completion of a Finitely-Generated Module and the Vertex Operator Map In this section, we discuss modules. Since the constructions and proofs are all similar to the case of algebras, we shall only state the results and point out the slight differences
82
Y.-Z. Huang
between the constructions and proofs in the case of modules and those in the case of algebras. Let V be a Z-graded finitely generated vertex algebra satisfying the standard gradingrestriction axioms and W a C-graded finitely-generated V -module satisfying the standard grading-restriction axioms, that is, a W(n) , W = n∈C
dim W(n) < ∞, n ∈ C and
W(n) = 0
for n ∈ C whose real part is sufficiently small. Let M be the finite-dimensional vector space spanned by a set of generators of W . As in Sect. 2, we assume that X is a finitedimensional subspace containing 1 of V spanned by a set of generators of V . ˜ W and F W , k ≥ 0, and their duals in the same way as the We construct spaces G k ˜ constructions of G and Fk , k ≥ 0, and their duals in Sect. 2, except that V ∗ is replaced by W ∗ , v ∈ V is replaced by w ∈ W and the vertex operator map Y for V are replaced by vertex operator map YW for the module W . We also define linear maps gkW , ιF W , γkW , k
ekW , k ≥ 0, and linear maps induced from them in the same way as in the definitions of gk , ιFk , γk , ek , k ≥ 0, and induced linear maps in Sect. 2, except that the spaces are replaced by the corresponding spaces involving W and M. ˜ W )∗ . Let For k ≥ 0, ekW is a linear map from V ⊗k ⊗ W ⊗ (FkW )∗ to (G W ⊗k ⊗ M ⊗ (FkW )∗ ) GW k = ek (X
and
GW =
[ k≥0
GW k .
˜ W )∗ form a dual pair of vector spaces ˜ and H , the spaces and (G As in the case of G ˜ W )∗ . As in Sect. 2, we have: and thus we have a locally convex topology on (G ˜W G
Proposition 3.1. For any k ≥ 0, the linear map ˜ W )∗ ekW |X⊗k ⊗M⊗(F W )∗ : X⊗k ⊗ M ⊗ (FkW )∗ → (G k
is continuous. In particular, X⊗k ⊗ M ⊗ (FkW )∗ /(ekW |X⊗k ⊗M⊗(F W )∗ )−1 (0) k
and GW k is a locally convex space. For k ≥ 0, let HkW be the completion of GW k and [ HkW . HW = k≥0
Then HkW , k ≥ 0, are complete locally convex space.
Functional-Analytic Theory of Vertex (Operator) Algebras, I
83
W and the topology Proposition 3.2. For k ≥ 0, HkW can be embedded canonically in Hk+1 W W on Hk is induced from the topology on Hk+1 .
Theorem 3.3. The vector space H W equipped with the strict inductive limit topology is a locally convex completion of W . In particular, GW is dense in H W . Next we extend the map L(0)
YW (r1
L(0)
·, z)r2
·:V ⊗W →W
eH W to H W . associated to [D(z; r1 , r2 )] to a linear map ν YW ([D(z; r1 , r2 )]) from H ⊗ ∗ W ˜ We define u [D(z;r1 ,r2 )] λ ∈ W for λ ∈ G and u ∈ V , the maps ˜ W ⊗ X l ⊗ W ⊗ (F W )∗ → G, ˜ αlW : G l l ≥ 0, and
W W : Fk∗ ⊗ (FlW )∗ → (Fk+l+1 )∗ , βk,l k, l ≥ 0, in the same way as in the definitions in Sect. 3 of u [D(z;r1 ,r2 )] λ ∈ V ∗ for ˜ and u ∈ V , the maps λ∈G
˜ ⊗ Xl+1 ⊗ Fl∗ → V ∗ , αl : G l ≥ 0, and
∗ , βk,l : Fk∗ ⊗ Fl∗ → Fk+l+1 W ˜ ˜ k, l ≥ 0. (Note that the image of αl is in G, not in GW . This is the reason why the W is F ∗ ⊗ (F W )∗ , not (F W )∗ ⊗ (F W )∗ .) domain of βk,l l k l k Let h1 = ek (u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ u ⊗ µ) ∈ Gk and h2 = elW (v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vl ⊗ w ⊗ ν) ∈ GW l ,
where u1 , . . . , uk , u, v1 , . . . , vl ∈ X, w ∈ M and µ ∈ Fk∗ , ν ∈ (FlW )∗ . Define (ν YW ([D(z; r0 , r1 , r2 )]))(h1 ⊗ h2 )
W W (u1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ uk ⊗ u ⊗ v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vl ⊗ w ⊗ βk,l (µ, ν)). = ek+l+1
Note that any element of Gk or GW l is a linear combination of elements of the form h1 or h2 , respectively, above, and that k and l are arbitrary. Thus we obtain a linear map ν YW ([D(z; r0 , r1 , r2 )])|G⊗GW : G ⊗ GW → GW . Proposition 3.4. The map ν YW ([D(z; r1 , r2 )])|G⊗GW is continuous. By this proposition and the fact that G and GW are dense in H and H W , respectively, we can extend ν YW ([D(z; r1 , r2 )])|G⊗GW to a continuous linear map ν YW ([D(z; r1 , r2 )]) eH W to H W . from H ⊗ Theorem 3.5. The map ν YW ([D(z; r1 , r2 )]) is a continuous extension of L(0)
YW (r1 to
L(0)
·, z)r2
·:V ⊗W →W
eH W . H⊗
Acknowledgement. This research is supported in part by by NSF grant DMS-9622961.
84
Y.-Z. Huang
References [B]
R. E. Borcherds: Vertex algebras, Kac-Moody algebras, and the Monster. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 83, 3068–3071 (1986) [F] Frenkel, I.B.: Talk presented at the Institute for Advanced Study, 1988; and private communications [FHL] Frenkel, I.B., Huang, Y.-Z. and Lepowsky, J.: On axiomatic approaches to vertex operator algebras and modules. Preprint, 1989; Memoirs Am. Math. Soc. 104, 1993 [FLM] Frenkel, I.B., Lepowsky, J. and Meurman, A.: Vertex operator algebras and the Monster. Pure and Appl. Math. 134, New York: Academic Press, 1988 [H1] Huang, Y.-Z.: On the geometric interpretation of vertex operator algebras. Ph.D thesis, Rutgers University, 1990 [H2] Huang, Y.-Z.: Geometric interpretation of vertex operator algebras. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 88, 9964–9968 (1991) [H3] Huang, Y.-Z.: Applications of the geometric interpretation of vertex operator algebras. In: Proc. 20th International Conference on Differential Geometric Methods in Theoretical Physics, New York, 1991, ed. S. Catto and A. Rocha, Singapore: World Scientific, 1992, pp. 333–343 [H4] Huang, Y.-Z.: Vertex operator algebras and conformal field theory. Intl. J. of Mod. Phys. A7, 2109– 2151 (1992) [H5] Huang, Y.-Z.: Intertwining operator algebras, genus-zero modular functors and genus-zero conformal field theories. In: Operads: Proceedings of Renaissance Conferences, ed. J.-L. Loday, J. Stasheff, and A. A. Voronov, Contemporary Math. 202, Providence, RI: Am. Math. Soc. 1997, pp. 335–355 [H6] Huang, Y.-Z.: Two-dimensional conformal geometry and vertex operator algebras. Progress in Mathematics, Vol. 148, Boston: Birkhäuser, 1997 [H7] Huang, Y.-Z.: Genus-zero modular functors and intertwining operator algebras, Internat. J. Math. 9, 845–863 (1998) [K1] Köthe, G.: Topological vector spaces I, Grundlehren der mathematischen Wissenschaften, 159, English Edition, New York: Springer-Verlag, 1969 [K2] Köthe, G.: Topological vector spaces II. Grundlehren der mathematischen Wissenschaften 237, New York: Springer-Verlag, 1979 [S1] Segal, G.B.: The definition of conformal field theory. Preprint, 1988 [S2] Segal, G.B.: Two-dimensional conformal field theories and modular functors. In: Proceedings of the IXth International Congress on Mathematical Physics, Swansea, 1988, Bristol: Hilger, 1989, 22–37 Communicated by G. Felder
Commun. Math. Phys. 204, 85 – 88 (1999)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
© Springer-Verlag 1999
Weakly Mixing Invariant Tori of Hamiltonian Systems Oliver Knill Department of Mathematics, University of Texas, Austin, TX 78712, USA. E-mail: [email protected] Received: 24 April 1998/ Accepted: 14 January 1999
Abstract: We note that every finite or infinite dimensional real-analytic Hamiltonian system with a quasi-periodic invariant KAM torus of finite dimension d ≥ 2 can be perturbed in such a way that the new real-analytic Hamiltonian system has a weakly mixing invariant torus of the same dimension. 1. Introduction By the celebrated Kolmogorov–Arnold–Moser theory, Hamiltonian systems often have invariant tori on which the motion is quasi-periodic. While the dynamics on one-dimensional periodic orbits is always trivial, the Hamiltonian dynamics induced on higherdimensional invariant tori can be interesting. The reason is the nontrivial ergodic theory of the systems dxi = αi F (x)−1 dt
(1)
which are obtained by a change of time from a linear flow x˙ = α and which have the invariant measure µ = F (x)dx (see [1]). The flow φ t can be either weakly mixing or RT can be conjugated to the linear flow x˙ = α. Weak mixing means limT →∞ T −1 0 µ(Y ∩ φ t (Y )) − µ(Y )2 dt = 0 for any measurable set Y and is a weak type of chaos. The question of what kind of dynamics occurs for a given α and F is interesting and has been studied for quite a while. Much is known in the case d = 2, a situation of wider interest because any smooth flow on the two-dimensional torus with no fixed points and some absolutely continuous invariant measure reduces to (1) by a change of coordinates [1]. In two dimensions and for smooth F , no strong mixing µ(Y ∩ φ t (Y )) → µ(Y )2 can happen [4]. While Baire generically weakly mixing occurs [3], one can for almost all α conjugate the system to the quasi-periodic flow with F = 1. While for Diophantine rotation numbers, there is point spectrum by Kolmogorov’s theorem and for Liouville
86
O. Knill
rotation number, there is zero-dimensional but continuous spectrum in general [3], it is not known, if the dimension of spectral measures can become positive. The ergodic theory of (1) is less understood in dimensions d ≥ 3. We will note in Sect. 2 that near F = 1, we have generically weak mixing. Arnold mentioned in an interview [6] that Kolmogorov’s work on KAM theory was motivated by the question of whether mixing invariant tori exist for most Hamiltonian systems. While this question is open, our note shows that in a weak sense, the answer is yes: weakly mixing tori of dimension d ≥ 2 occurs densely in some open sets of Hamiltonian systems. The result does not only apply to finite dimensional systems. KAM theorems for infinite dimensional Hamiltonian systems often lead to the persistence of finite-dimensional invariant tori [5,9]. In such a situation, one can perturb the infinitedimensional Hamiltonian to obtain weakly mixing invariant measures of some PDE’s. 2. A Higher Dimensional Version of Sklover’s Theorem Sklover has shown [10,1] that smooth differential equations on the two torus exist for which the dynamics is weakly mixing. The weak mixing property is even Baire generic [3] for real analytic F ’s. This can be generalized to higher dimensions: Proposition 2.1 (Generalization of Sklover’s theorem). For a Baire generic set of (F, α) near F = 1, the flow x˙i = α/F (x) has purely singular continuous spectrum. Such systems are in general ergodic and weakly mixing. Proof. If the coordinates αi of α are rationally dependent, then every orbit is periodic and Tn is foliated by one-dimensional tori, which are parameterized by Tn−1 . A general measure preserving flow Tt on the torus Tn defines a one parameter family Ut of unitary operators Ut f = f (T−t ) on the Hilbert space L2 (Td , dx). By Stone’s theorem there is an infinitesimal generator L satisfying Ut = exp(iLt) which we call the Liouville operator. There is a continuum of distinct ergodic invariant measures my and the Liouville R operator L is an integral L = Tn−1 L(y) dy, where L(y) = p(y)∂x and p(y) is the period of the flow. L has pure absolutely continuous spectrum on the orthocomplement of constant functions if and only if the measure of all orbits with a given period has measure zero. This condition for F is true for an open dense set of F ’s. If α is Diophantine and the realanalytic F near 1, then the flow is conjugated to the linear flow and has pure point spectrum. This result of Arnold and Moser can also be derived from the fact that every time t map is conjugated to a map x 7 → x + α (see [7, 2]). There is a dense set of Liouville operators with absolutely continuous spectrum and a dense set of Liouville operators with discrete spectrum. By Simon’s theorem [11], L Baire generically has purely singular continuous spectrum. (See [3] for details, like how to deal with the fact that the different Liouville operators are defined on different Hilbert spaces. Simon’s theorem is: Let X be a complete metric space of self-adjoint operators on a separable Hilbert space for which convergence in the metric implies strong resolvent convergence. Suppose the two sets of operators in X that have purely continuous spectrum and purely discrete spectrum are both dense in X . Then there is a t dense Gδ in X of operators that have purely singular continuous spectrum.) u Remark. While the result in two dimensions which we obtained together with A. Hof [3] is global, we don’t know whether Proposition 2.1 can be made global in dimensions d ≥ 3.
Invariant Tori of Hamiltonian Systems
87
3. Weakly Mixing Invariant Tori Consider a Hamiltonian vector field XH with smooth Hamiltonian H on a symplectic manifold M. The function H is an integral of motion and the vector field XH is tangential to any energy surface C = {x | H (x) = c}. If c is not a critical value for H , then C is a smooth submanifold and the vector field XH does not vanish on C. If K is another Hamiltonian for which C is an energy surface, C = {x | H (x) = c} = {x | K(x) = c0 } with dH, dK 6 = 0 on C, then ∇K(x) = F (x)∇H (x) at every point x ∈ C with F (x) 6 = 0 and therefore XK (x) = F (x)XH (x), F (x) 6 = 0 on C. It follows that XH and XK have the same orbits on C although their time parameterization will be changed in general. Especially, any invariant torus of XH which is contained in the energy surface C is an invariant torus of XK and the change of the Hamiltonian produces a time change on this torus. Changing the Hamiltonian is useful for the study of periodic orbits (e.g. [12, Lemma 2.1]). Lemma 3.1 (Poincaré trick). Given a Hamiltonian system with a d-dimensional invariant torus N. For any smooth function F on N , with no roots on N, there exists a new Hamiltonian K which has the same invariant torus on which the dynamics is obtained by a change of time with function F . Proof. An explicit choice for K is F (x)(H − c) which has C = {K = 0}. u t We also need to change the rotation vector on invariant quasi-periodic tori. Lemma 3.2 (Change of the rotation vector). Given a Hamiltonian system with a ddimensional invariant torus N on which the dynamics is a rotation with rotation vector α. For any β near α, there exists a Hamiltonian K near H for which the torus N is still invariant and quasi-periodic with rotation vector β. Proof. A change of variables A : z 7 → (φ, I ) defined near the invariant torus N brings the Hamiltonian into action-angle variables on the invariant torus: φ˙ = α + g(I, φ), I˙ = h(I, φ), where g(I, φ) and h(I, φ) vanish on N = {I = α} (see e.g. [8]). If H˜ (φ, I ) = ˜ I) = H (A−1 (φ, I )) is the Hamiltonian in these new variables, change it to K(φ, ˜ ˜ H (φ, I ) + (β − α)I and define K(x, y) = H (A(x, y)). The flow of XK leaves N invariant and is conjugated there to a quasi-periodic flow with rotation vector β. u t Remark. The invariant torus N obtained like this loses the KAM property during the perturbation. However, by KAM, a different torus with the same rotation vector α will persist and the perturbed system will now have two invariant tori, one with rotation number α and one with rotation vector β. Theorem 3.3. Given a real-analytic Hamiltonian H for which there exists an invariant torus N on which the dynamics is quasi-periodic, there exists a Hamiltonian K arbitrarily close to H for which the same torus N is still invariant and for which the dynamics on N is ergodic and weakly mixing.
88
O. Knill
Proof. Using Proposition 2.1, take (β, F ) with β near α and F near 1 such that the corresponding flow on the torus is weakly mixing. We make now a first change of the Hamiltonian H → K1 such that the rotation vector of N is changed to β. Let c be the energy of an orbit on N. Let K = F (K1 − c) be the Hamiltonian obtained from K1 . The flow of this Hamiltonian induced on the invariant torus N is weakly mixing. u t The result generalizes obviously to infinite-dimensional Hamiltonian systems for which KAM theory assures that finite dimensional tori survive (see [5]). For example, there are perturbations of some nonlinear wave equations which have weakly mixing invariant tori. Acknowledgements. I acknowledge the support of the Swiss National Foundation and thank the Mathematical Physics group at the University of Texas at Austin for hospitality. This note is a spin-off from a collaboration [3] with Bert Hof. A key input came from Maciej Wojtkowski, who suggested to us after our seminar talk in Tucson to use the Poincaré trick to apply the torus results to Hamiltonian systems.
References 1. Cornfeld, I.P., Fomin, S.V. and Sinai, Ya.G. Ergodic Theory. Volume 115 of Grundlehren der mathematischen Wissenschaften in Einzeldarstellungen, Berlin–Heidelberg–New York: Springer Verlag, 1982 2. Herman, M-R.: Sur les courbes invariantes par les difféomorphismes de l’anneau. Vol. 2. Astérisque 144, 1–248 (1986) 3. Hof, A. and Knill, O.: Zero dimensional singular continuous spectrum for smooth differential equations on the torus. Ergod. Th. Dyn. Sys. 18, 879–888 (1998) 4. Katok, A.B.: Spectral properties of dynamical systems with an integral invariant on the torus. Functional Anal. Appl. 1, 296–305 (1967) 5. Kuksin, S.: Nearly integrable infinite-dimensional Hamiltonian systems. Volume 1556 of Lecture notes in mathematics, Berlin–Heidelberg–New York: Springer-Verlag, 1993 6. Lui, S.H.: An interview with Vladimir Arnold. Notices of the AMS, April, 1997 7. Moser, J.: A rapidly convergent iteration method and non-linear differential equations. II. Ann. Scuola Norm. Sup. Pisa (3) 20, 499–535 (1966) 8. Pöschel, J.: Integrability of hamiltonian systems on cantor sets. Commun. Pure Appl. Math. 35, 653–696 (1982) 9. Pöschel, J.: A KAM-theorem for some nonlinear partial differential equations. Ann. Scuola Norm. Sup. Pisa Cl. Sci. (4) 23, 119–148 (1996) 10. Shklover, M.D. On classical dynamical systems on the torus with continuous spectrum. Izv. Vyssh. Uchebn. Zaved. Mat. 10, 113–124 (1967) (In Russian) 11. Simon, B.: Operators with singular continuous spectrum: I. General operators. Annals of Mathematics 141, 131–145 (1995) 12. Weinstein, A.: Periodic orbits for convex Hamiltonian systems. Annals of Mathematics 108, 507–518 (1978) Communicated by Ya. G. Sinai
Commun. Math. Phys. 204, 89 – 114 (1999)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
© Springer-Verlag 1999
Kneading Theory: A Functorial Approach J. F. Alves, J. Sousa Ramos Departamento de Matemática, Instituto Superior Técnico, Av. Rovisco Pais, 1096 Lisboa Cedex, Portugal. E-mail: [email protected]; [email protected] Received: 25 February 1998 / Accepted: 15 January 1999
Abstract: We study the homology theory of ` - modal maps of the interval. We give another proof of the Milnor and Thurston results about zeta-functions and we give a functorial approach to kneading theory. Our results give explicit methods for computing the sequences of lap numbers `(f k ) and the sequences of numbers of periodic points in an arbitrary interval [x, y]. 1. Introduction and Preliminaries Mappings from an interval to itself provide a surprisingly complex behavior, useful to the study of higher dimensional smooth dynamical systems. In this paper we present an explicit method for computing the sequence of lap numbers ` f k and the sequence of numbers of periodic points (of negative and critical type) in arbitrary intervals [a, b]. We obtain the Milnor and Thurston [Mi-Th 88] results using a functorial approach to Kneading theory. See also Mori [Mo 90] and Baladi and Ruelle [Ba-Ru 94]. Let I = [a, b] ⊆ R be a compact interval. By definition, a continuous map f : I → I is piecewise monotone if there are points a < c1 < · · · < c` < b at which f has a local extremum and f is strictly monotone in each of the intervals I1 = [a, c1 ], I2 = [c1 , c2 ], . . . , I`+1 = [c` , b]. In this case, the points c1 , . . . ,c` are called the turning points of f , the intervals I1 , . . . ,I`+1 are called the laps of f and `(f ) is the number of laps of f . The relationship between the sequence of lap numbers ` (f ), ` f 2 , . . . , ` (f n ), . . . and the topological entropy of f is very well known [Me-St 93]: the topological entropy of f is equal to the logarithm of the number s (f ) = lim
n→∞
p p n ` (f n ) = inf n ` (f n ). n
Milnor and Thurston [Mi-Th 88] introduced two basic invariants called the kneading matrix and the kneading determinant of f .
90
J. F. Alves, J. Sousa Ramos
In that paper, they present an explicit method for computing the sequence of lap numbers in terms of the kneading matrix. As an example, if f has only one turning point and f (∂I ) ⊆ ∂I , then we have X ` f n t n−1 = (1 − t)−1 + (1 − t)−2 Df −1 , (1.1) n≥1
where Df is the kneading determinant of f . The main theorem in that paper establishes an important relationship between the kneading determinant of f and the periodic points of f . That result can be stated as follows: X tn 2Nf−n − 1 , (1.2) Df −1 = exp n n≥1
where Nf−n is the number of fixed points of f n of negative type, i.e., fixed points of f n in the interior of some lap of f n , where f n is strictly decreasing. Here in this paper we introduce the correspondences θ0 and θ1 . To each piecewise monotone map f : I → I we associate two linear transformations θ0,f and θ1,f both def
defined in the Q-vector space S0 (I, Q) = S0 (I ) ⊗ Q, where S0 (I ) is the free abelian group with basis the elements of I , and Q is the field of rational numbers. These two correspondences present two fundamental properties, which will play an important role in what follows. The first one concerns iteration. Behind the construction of θ0 and θ1 we find two functors .f#0 and .f#1 . As an immediate consequence of this, we will see that θ0 and θ1 have good behaviour in the presence of iteration. In fact we will show that n n = θ0,f n and θ1,f = θ1,f n , for each n ∈ Z+ . θ0,f
(P1)
The nature of the second property is exclusively algebraic. It is clear that S0 (I, Q) is infinite-dimensional, and we will see that the subspaces Im θ0,f and Im θ1,f are both infinite-dimensional; however we will show that (P2) Im θ1,f − θ0,f is finite-dimensional. This property allows us to define the determinant of the pair, θ0,f , θ1,f . This determinant is an element of Q [[t]], which we call D(θ0,f ,θ1,f ) , and will play a role analogous to the kneading determinant of f . To compute D(θ0,f ,θ1,f ) , we introduce the square matrix M(θ0,f ,θ1,f ) with coefficients in Q [[t]], which have many resemblances with the kneading matrix of f . Let f : I → I be a piecewise monotone map, K = [c, d] ⊆ I (with d > c) and x0 ∈ I . As first application we compute the number of solutions in K of the equation f n (x) = x0 , for each n ∈ N. In fact there is a simple relationship between θ1,f (d − c) and # {x ∈ K : f (x) = x0 } , and applying P1 and P2 we can compute the sequence # x ∈ K : f n (x) = x0 .
Kneading Theory: A Functorial Approach
91
Using this we present an explicit method for computing the sequence of lap numbers, which is a generalization of (1.1). The second application have to do with the number of solutions of the equation f n (x) = x, for each n ∈ Z+ . We shall see that there is an important relationship between the number of fixed points of f and the trace of θ1,f − θ0,f . By P1 we easily obtain a similar version of (1.2): we will show that X tn 2Nf−n − 1 + Nf0 n , (1.3) D(θ0,f ,θ1,f ) −1 = exp n n≥1
points of critical type of f n , i.e., fixed points of f n at where which It is clear that (1.2) and (1.3) have only to do with the number of periodic points of f in I . If we want to know something about the number of periodic points of f in an arbitrary subinterval K ⊆ I , then we have to generalize the previous results. We can regard both equations Nf0 n is the number of fixed f n has a local extremum.
f n (x) = x0 and f n (x) = x, for each n ∈ N, as special cases of the equation f n (x) = h(x), for each n ∈ N,
(1.4)
where h : I → I is a continuous map with constant sign, i.e., h is strictly monotone in I , or h is constant in I . Our main theorem concerns the number of solutions of Eq. (1.4), and using this result we obtain a generalization of (1.3) which is related to the number of periodic points of f in arbitrary subintervals of I . 1.1. The determinant of a pair (ϕ, ψ). Let U be a vector space over Q and ψ : U → U a linear transformation such that Im (ψ) is finite-dimensional. Assume ψ has finite-dimensional image, and let W be any finite-dimensional subspace of U such that Im (ψ) ⊆ W . Then we define the trace of ψ by def T r (ψ) = T r ψ|W (it is easy to see that the definition does not depend on W ). If ψ has finite-dimensional image, then there are vectors u1 , . . . , uk ∈ U and linear forms ω1 , . . . , ωk ∈ U ∗ such that ψ=
k X
ωi ⊗ ui ,
(1.5)
i=1
and we can compute T r (ψ) considering the matrix ω1 (u1 ) . . . ω1 (uk ) def ... : Mψ = . . . ωk (u1 ) . . . ωk (uk )
(1.6)
92
J. F. Alves, J. Sousa Ramos
we have
T r (ψ) = T r Mψ .
More generally, if ψ has finite-dimensional image, then, for each n ∈ Z+ , ψ n has finite-dimensional image, and T r ψ n = T r Mψn . As an immediate consequence of this, we have the following Proposition 1.1. Let ψ be a linear transformation on U having finite-dimensional image, and consider u1 , . . . ,uk ∈ U and ω1 , . . . ,ωk ∈ U ∗ as in (1.5). Then we have X tn −1 T r ψ n = Det id − tMψ exp , n n≥1
where Mψ is the matrix defined in (1.6). Now we generalize this result. Let (ϕ, ψ) be a pair of linear transformations on U such that Im (ψ − ϕ) is finite dimensional. We shall say that the pair (ϕ, ψ) has finite-dimensional image. If the pair (ϕ, ψ) has finite-dimensional image, then we can consider vectors u1 , . . . , uk ∈ U and linear forms ω1 , . . . , ωk ∈ U ∗ such that ψ −ϕ =
k X
ωi ⊗ ui .
(1.7)
i=1
More generally ψ n − ϕn =
n k X X
ωi ◦ ψ n−j ⊗ ϕ j −1 (ui ) , for each n > 0,
(1.8)
i=1 j =1
and we see that (ϕ n , ψ n ) has finite-dimensional image, for each n > 0. Thus we define the determinant of (ϕ, ψ) to be the following element of Q [[t]]: X tn def T r ψ n − ϕn . D(ϕ,ψ) −1 = exp n n≥1
If ϕ and ψ have finite-dimensional images, then by Proposition 1.1, Det id − tMψ . D(ϕ,ψ) = Det id − tMϕ In order to compute D(ϕ,ψ) , in the general case, we consider u1 , . . . ,uk ∈ U and ω1 , . . . ,ωk ∈ U ∗ as in (1.7), and we introduce the matrix P P ω1 (ϕ n (u1 )) t n . . . ω1 (ϕ n (uk )) t n n≥0 n≥0 def , . . . ... (1.9) M(ϕ,ψ) = P P n n n n ωk (ϕ (u1 )) t . . . ωk (ϕ (uk )) t n≥0
with coefficients in Q [[t]].
n≥0
Kneading Theory: A Functorial Approach
93
Proposition 1.2. Let (ϕ, ψ) be a pair of linear transformations on U having finitedimensional image and consider u1 , . . . ,uk ∈ U and ω1 , . . . ,ωk ∈ U ∗ , as in (1.7). Then we have D(ϕ,ψ) = Det id − tM(ϕ,ψ) , where M(ϕ,ψ) is the matrix defined in (1.9). Observe that this proposition is a generalization of Proposition 1.1, when we identify a linear transformation ψ with the pair (0, ψ). In fact, if ϕ = 0, then the matrices defined in (1.6) and (1.9) coincide. Generally, the computation of M(ϕ,ψ) is very difficult. The next proposition, which is an immediate consequence of the definition, may be useful in computing D(ϕ,ψ) . Proposition 1.3. Let φ, ϕ and ψ be linear transformations on U such that (φ, ϕ) and (ϕ, ψ) have finite-dimensional images. Then we have: −1 , 1. D(ϕ,ψ) = D(ψ,ϕ) 2. D(φ,ψ) = D(φ,ϕ) D(ϕ,ψ) .
Later we shall need to solve two problems. The first one can be stated as follows: let ψ be a linear transformation on U , u ∈ U and ω ∈ U ∗ . We want to compute the numbers ω (u) , ω (ψ (u)) , . . . , ω ψ n (u) , . . . .
(1.10)
Considering a pair (ϕ, ψ) with finite-dimensional image; the problem becomes easier, if ϕ has a easier iteration. In fact, if the pair (ϕ, ψ) has finite-dimensional image, then it is possible to express these numbers in terms of ϕ. We begin to observe that the numbers in (1.10) appear naturally, when we consider the determinant of the pair (ψ, ψ + ω ⊗ u); we have (ψ + ω ⊗ u) − ψ = ω ⊗ u, and by Proposition 1.2, D(ψ,ψ+ω⊗u) = 1 −
X
ω ψ n (u) t n+1 .
(1.11)
n≥0
Considering the pairs (ψ, ϕ) and (ϕ, ψ + ω ⊗ u), we apply Proposition 1.3 to decompose the first member of (1.11), and obtain the following Corollary 1.4. Let (ϕ, ψ) be a pair of linear transformations on U having finitedimensional image, u ∈ U and ω ∈ U ∗ . Then we have 1−
X n≥0
−1 ω ψ n (u) t n+1 = D(ϕ,ψ) D(ϕ,ψ+ω⊗u) .
94
J. F. Alves, J. Sousa Ramos
The second problem can be stated as follows: Let φ, ϕ and ψ be linear transformations on U , such that the pair (ϕ, ψ) has finite-dimensional image. We want to compute the numbers T r φ ◦ ψ n − ϕn
, for each n > 0.
In other words, we want to compute the formal power series def
ϒ(φ,ϕ,ψ) =
X
T r φ ◦ ψ n − ϕn
t n−1 .
n≥1
It is clear that if φ = id, then by definition of D(ϕ,ψ) , 0
−1 D(ϕ,ψ) , ϒ(id,ϕ,ψ) = −D(ϕ,ψ)
and we can use Proposition 1.2 to compute ϒ(id,ϕ,ψ) . In order to compute ϒ(φ,ϕ,ψ) , we generalize Proposition 1.2. Let (ϕ, ψ) be a pair with finite-dimensional image, and consider u1 , . . . ,uk ∈ U and ω1 , . . . ,ωk ∈ U ∗ as in (1.7). By (1.8), n
Tr φ ◦ ψ −ϕ
n
=
n k X X
i h ωi ◦ ψ n−j φ ϕ j −1 (ui ) ,
i=1 j =1
for each n > 0. Thus ϒ(φ,ϕ,ψ) =
k X X
t j −1
i=1 j ≥0
=
X
t j −1
X
h
i
ωi ψ n φ ◦ ϕ j (ui )
t n+1
n≥0
X
h
ωi ψ n φ ◦ ϕ j (ui )
i
t n+1 ,
n≥0
(i,j )∈3
where o n 3 = (i, j ) ∈ {1, 2, . . . , k} × N : φ ◦ ϕ j (ui ) 6= 0 , and from Corollary 1.4 we obtain the following Corollary 1.5. Let φ, ϕ, ψ be linear transformations on U , such that the pair (ϕ, ψ) has finite-dimensional image, and consider u1 , . . . ,uk ∈ U and ω1 , . . . ,ωk ∈ U ∗ as in (1.7). Then we have ϒ(φ,ϕ,ψ) =
X h (i,j )∈3
i −1 D(ϕ,ψ+ωi ⊗φ◦ϕ j (ui )) . t j −1 1 − D(ϕ,ψ)
Kneading Theory: A Functorial Approach
95
2. The Correspondences θ0 and θ1 2.1. The functors .#0 and .#1. Let I and J be closed and bounded intervals of R and consider a continuous map f : I → J . This map induces another map f : int (I ) → {−1, 0, 1} , defined as follows: for each x ∈ int (I ), such that f is injective on some neighbourhood of x, we define the sign f (x) to be either ±1 according to whether f is strictly increasing or strictly decreasing on some neighbourhood of x. For the remaining points of int (I ) we define f (x) = 0. We say that f is a piecewise monotone map if the set Cf = x ∈ int (I ) : f (x) = 0 is finite. In this case the elements of Cf are called turning points of f . If f has exactly ` turning points, then we say that f is an `-modal map. Let S∗ (I, Q) and S∗ (J, Q) be the singular chain complexes of I and J with coefficients in Q. A continuous map f : I → J induces a chain map f# from S∗ (I, Q) to S∗ (J, Q); ∂1
. . . S1 (I, Q) −−−−→ S0 (I, Q) −−−−→ 0 f f . y #0 y #1 ∂1
. . . S1 (J, Q) −−−−→ S0 (J, Q) −−−−→ 0 This chain complex gives us the following commutative diagram: ∂1 →
p
∂1
p
0 −→ S˜1 (I, Q) = f y #1
S1 (I,Q) ker(∂1 )
−−−−→ S0 (I, Q) −−−−→ H0 (I, Q) −−−−→ 0 f π , y #0 y
0 −→ S˜1 (J, Q) =
S1 (J,Q) ker(∂1 )
−−−−→ S0 (J, Q) −−−−→ H0 (J, Q) −−−−→ 0
in which the two rows are exact sequences and π is a natural isomorphism. Recall that S0 (I, Q) is the Q-vector space defined by def
S0 (I, Q) = S0 (I ) ⊗ Q, where S0 (I ) is the free abelian group with basis I . Thus I is a basis of S0 (I, Q), and f#0 : S0 (I, Q) → S0 (J, Q) is the unique linear transformation that verifies f#0 (x) = f (x), for all x ∈ I . Using f#0 we define .f#0 . Definition 2.1. Let f : I → J be a piecewise monotone map. We define .f#0 : S0 (int (I ) , Q) → S0 (int (J ) , Q) to be the unique linear transformation such that .f#0 (x) = f (x) .f#0 (x) for all x ∈ int (I ) .
96
J. F. Alves, J. Sousa Ramos
To define the morphism .f#1 , recall that the subspace Im (∂1 ) ⊂ S0 (I, Q) is generated by {u ∈ S0 (I, Q) : u = d − c, with c, d ∈ I } . Since S˜1 (I, Q) ' Im (∂1 ), we see that each interval K = [c, d] ⊆ I , with d > c, can be identified with the unique vector k ∈ S˜1 (I, Q), that verifies ∂1 (k) = d − c. From now on we use the same symbol to denote the interval K and the correspondent vector of S˜1 (I, Q). With this identification we can say that the set def
I = {K = [c, d] ⊆ I : d > c} , generates S˜1 (I, Q), and [f (c) , f (d)] if f (c) < f (d) 0 if f (c) = f (d) , for all [c, d] ∈ I. f#1 ([c, d]) = − [f (d) , f (c)] if f (c) > f (d)
(2.1)
Consider now the subset of I, def
If = {K ∈ I : f is injective on K} . Observe that, since f is piecewise monotone, we see that If generates S˜1 (I, Q). For each K ∈ If , we define the sign f (K) to be 1 (−1) if f is strictly increasing (decreasing) on K, and by (2.1) we see that f#1 : S˜1 (I, Q) → S˜1 (J, Q) is the unique linear transformation that verifies f (K) if f (K) = 1 , for all K ∈ If . f#1 (K) = −f (K) if f (K) = −1
(2.2)
Definition 2.2. Let f : I → J be a piecewise monotone map. We define .f#1 : S˜1 (I, Q) → S˜1 (J, Q) to be the unique linear transformation such that .f#1 (K) = f (K) .f#1 (K) , for all K ∈ If . Observe that, by (2.2) .f#1 : S˜1 (I, Q) → S˜1 (J, Q) is the unique linear transformation that verifies .f#1 (K) = f (K) , for all K ∈ If .
(2.3)
The next proposition is an immediate consequence of the definitions of .f#0 and .f#1 , and will play an important role in what follows. Proposition 2.3. Let £ be the category whose objects are the closed and bounded subintervals of R, and whose morphisms are piecewise monotone maps between intervals. Then the associations I → S0 (int (I ) , Q) I → S˜1 (I, Q) and f → .f#0 f → .f#1 are covariant functors from £ to the category of vector spaces over Q.
Kneading Theory: A Functorial Approach
97
2.2. The equation f n (x) = x0 . We are in position to approach the following problem: let f : I → I be a piecewise monotone map, x0 ∈ I and K ∈ I. We want to compute the numbers # x ∈ K : f n (x) = x0 , where f n is the nth -iterate of f.
Remark 2.4. The reason why we consider this problem will be clear later, in the computation of the numbers ` (f n ). We begin to introduce the following notations. Definition 2.5. Let g : I → I be a piecewise monotone map and x0 ∈ I . 1. We define ν(g,x0 ) (K) = # {x ∈ K : g (x) = x0 }, for all subsets K ⊆ I . 2. We define ν˜ (g,x0 ) to be the unique linear form on S˜1 (I, Q) that verifies 1 ν˜ (g,x0 ) (K) = ν(g,x0 ) (int (K)) + ν(g,x0 ) (∂K) , for all K ∈ I. 2 Let f : I → I be a piecewise monotone map and x0 ∈ I . To compute the numbers ν˜ (f 0 ,x0 ) (K) , ν˜ (f 1 ,x0 ) (K) , . . . , ν˜ (f n ,x0 ) (K) , . . . , with K ∈ I, we introduce ωx0 to be the linear form on S˜1 (I, Q) defined by: 1 if x0 ∈ int (K) ωx0 (K) = 21 if x0 ∈ ∂K , for all K ∈ I, /K 0 if x0 ∈ and we have Proposition 2.6. Let f : I → I be a piecewise monotone map, x0 ∈ I and n ∈ N. Then we have ωx0 ◦ (.f#1 )n = ν˜ (f n ,x0 ) . Let n ∈ N. By Proposition 2.3, we have n , ωx0 ◦ (.f#1 )n = ωx0 ◦ .f#1
therefore, Proposition 2.6 is an immediate consequence of the following Lemma 2.7. Let g : I → I be a piecewise monotone map and x0 ∈ I . Then we have ωx0 ◦ .g#1 = ν˜ (g,x0 ) . Proof. Let K ∈ Ig . Since Ig generates S˜1 (I, Q), we only have to show that ωx0 ◦ .g#1 (K) = ν˜ (g,x0 ) (K) , and this follows from (2.3) because ωx0 ◦ .g#1 (K) = ωx0 (g (K)) = ν˜ (g,x0 ) (K) .
t u
98
J. F. Alves, J. Sousa Ramos
Let K ∈ I. From Proposition 2.6, we have ωx0 (.f#1 )n (K) = ν˜ (f n ,x0 ) (K) . Observe that, only with this result, we can’t compute the numbers ν˜ (f n ,x0 ) (K), because the computation of (.f#1 )n (K) is very complicated. To circumvent this difficulty we must work simultaneously with .f#0 and .f#1 . Since these morphisms are defined in different spaces, we introduce the morphisms θ0,f and θ1,f . Definition 2.8. Let f : I = [a, b] → J be a piecewise monotone map, and for each interval I , denote by i the inclusion int (I ) ,→ I . We define θ0,f to be the unique linear transformation from S0 (I, Q) in to S0 (J, Q) that verifies: 1. The diagram i#0
S0 (int (I ) , Q) −−−−→ S0 (I, Q) θ .f#0 y y 0,f i#0
S0 (int (J ) , Q) −−−−→ S0 (J, Q) is commutative. 2. θ0,f (a) = θ0,f (b) = 0. Definition 2.9. Let f : I = [a, b] → J be a piecewise monotone map, and ∂1 the boundary operator. We define θ1,f to be the unique linear transformation from S0 (I, Q) in to S0 (J, Q) that verifies: 1. The diagram ∂1 S˜1 (I, Q) −−−−→ S0 (I, Q) θ .f#1 y y 1,f ∂1 S˜1 (J, Q) −−−−→ S0 (J, Q)
is commutative. 2. θ1,f (a + b) = 0. From the definitions of θ0,f and θ1,f , we see at once that θ0,id 6 = id and θ1,id 6= id, therefore the associations I → S0 (I ) I → S0 (I ) and f → θ0,f f → θ1,f are not functorial. However, if f : I → J and g : J → K are piecewise monotone maps, then we have from Proposition 2.3 θ0,g◦f = θ0,g ◦ θ0,f and θ1,g◦f = θ1,g ◦ θ1,f , and, as an immediate consequence of this, we obtain the following
Kneading Theory: A Functorial Approach
99
Corollary 2.10. Let f : I → I be a piecewise monotone map. Then we have n n = θ0,f n and θ1,f = θ1,f n , for each n ∈ Z+ . θ0,f
In order to write down θ0,f and θ1,f explicitly, we have to introduce some notation. Definition 2.11. Let f : I → J be a piecewise monotone map. We define the function ¯f : I → {−1, 0, 1} by ¯f (x) =
f (x) if x ∈ int (I ) . 0 if x ∈ ∂I
Proposition 2.12. Let f : I → J be a piecewise monotone map. Then we have θ0,f (x) = ¯f (x) .f#0 (x) for all x ∈ I. Definition 2.13. Let f : I = c0 , c`+1 → J be a piecewise monotone map with turning points c1 < · · · < c` . For each 0 ≤ i ≤ ` + 1, we define ωi to be the unique linear form on S0 (I, Q) such that f (ci −) − f (ci +) if x > ci 2 f (ci −) + f (ci +) ωi (x) = if x = ci for all x ∈ I, 2 +) − −) (c (c f i f i if x < ci 2 defining f (c0 −) = f (c`+1 +) = 0. Now we are in position to write down the morphism θ1,f . The proof of the next proposition is a simple verification. Proposition 2.14. Let f : I = c0 , c`+1 → J be a piecewise monotone map, with turning points c1 < · · · < c` . For each 0 ≤ i ≤ ` + 1, let ωi be the linear form defined above. Then we have θ1,f − θ0,f =
`+1 X
ωi ⊗ f#0 (ci ) .
i=0
Observe that, if I = J , then θ0,f and θ1,f are endomorphisms of S0 (I, Q) and this proposition shows that the pair θ0,f , θ1,f has finite-dimensional image. Thus we may consider the determinant of this pair D(θ0,f ,θ1,f ) −1 = exp def
X tn n≥1
n
n n T r θ1,f − θ0,f ,
and, applying Proposition 1.2 and Proposition 2.14, we obtain D(θ0,f ,θ1,f ) = Det id − tM(θ0,f ,θ1,f ) ,
100
J. F. Alves, J. Sousa Ramos
with n ω0 θ0,f (f#0 (c`+1 )) t n n≥0 n≥0 . . . . . . . P P n n ω`+1 θ0,f ω`+1 θ0,f (f#0 (c0 )) t n . . . (f#0 (c`+1 )) t n
P M(θ0,f ,θ1,f ) =
n ω0 θ0,f (f#0 (c0 )) t n . . .
n≥0
P
n≥0
From Proposition 2.12 we have n n θ0,f (x) = ¯ (x) .¯ (f (x)) . . . ¯ f n−1 (x) .f#0 (x) , for each x ∈ I and n ∈ Z+ .With this, we see that M(θ0,f ,θ1,f ) have many resemblances with the kneading matrix of f (see [Mi-Th 88]). Example 2.15. Let f : [0, 1] → [0, 1] be the unimodal map defined by f (x) = 4bx (1 − x) with b ∼ 0.9900675. We have c0 = 0, c1 = 21 , c2 = 1 and c0 = f (c0 ) = f (c2 ) < f 2 (c1 ) < f 3 (c1 ) < f 4 (c1 ) = c1 < f (c1 ) < c2 . Since
1 if x ∈ ]c0 , c1 [ 0 if x ∈ {c0 , c1 , c2 } , ¯f (x) = −1 if x ∈ ]c , c [ 1 2
we have
1 2
M(θ0,f ,θ1,f ) = −1 1 2
1 2 1 2
−1 + t + t 2 + t 3 21 1 + t + t 2 −1 1 1 − t − t2 − t3 2
and D(θ0,f ,θ1,f ) = 1 − 2t + t 4 . Now we return to Proposition 2.6. We can rewrite this result in terms of θ1,f . Definition 2.16. Let I ⊆ R be a compact interval and x0 ∈ I . We define δx0 to be the unique linear form on S0 (I, Q) that verifies 1 2 if x > x0 0 if x = x0 , for all x ∈ I. δx0 (x) = 1 − 2 if x < x0
Kneading Theory: A Functorial Approach
101
We have ωx0 = δx0 ◦ ∂1 , and from the definition of θ1,f , we have n ◦ ∂1 = ∂1 ◦ (.f#1 )n , for all n ∈ N. θ1,f
Thus, as an immediate consequence of Proposition 2.6, we have Theorem 2.17. Let f : I → I be a piecewise monotone map, x0 ∈ I , n ∈ N, and ∂1 : S˜1 (I, Q) → S0 (I, Q) the boundary operator. Then we have n ◦ ∂1 = ν˜ (f n ,x0 ) . δx0 ◦ θ1,f
Let K = [c, d] ∈ I. We have ∂1 (K) = d − c, and from the previous theorem, we have X X n δx0 θ1,f ν˜ (f n ,x0 ) (K) t n+1 . (2.4) 1− (d − c) t n+1 = 1 − n≥0
n≥0
Since the pair θ0,f , θ1,f has finite-dimensional image, we apply Corollary 1.4, to express the first member of (2.4) in terms of θ0,f , and we obtain X ν˜ (f n ,x0 ) (K) t n+1 = D θ1,f ,θ1,f +δx ⊗(d−c) (2.5) 1− 0
n≥0
= D(θ0,f ,θ1,f ) −1 D
.
θ0,f ,θ1,f +δx0 ⊗(d−c)
Example 2.18. Let f be the map of Example 2.15. Set x0 = c1 and K = [c0 , c2 ]. By Propositions 1.2 and 2.14, we have D θ0,f ,θ1,f +δc ⊗(c2 −c0 ) = Det id − tM θ0,f ,θ1,f +δc ⊗(c2 −c0 ) , 1
1
with M
θ0,f ,θ1,f +δc1 ⊗(c2 −c0 )
M(θ0,f ,θ1,f ) A = , B C
T P n n ω0 θ0,f δc1 θ0,f (c2 − c0 ) t n (f#0 (c0 )) t n n≥0 n≥0 P P n n n ω1 θ0,f (c2 − c0 ) t , B = δc1 θ0,f (f#0 (c1 )) t n A= n≥0 n≥0 P P n n ω2 θ0,f δc1 θ0,f (c2 − c0 ) t n (f#0 (c2 )) t n P
n≥0
n≥0
and C=
X n δc1 θ0,f (c2 − c0 ) t n . n≥0
102
J. F. Alves, J. Sousa Ramos
Since
M
θ0,f ,θ1,f +δc1 ⊗(c2 −c0 )
1 2
−1 = 1 2
− 21
−1 + t + t 2 + t 3 21 −1 1 + t + t 2 −1 2 , 1 1 − t − t 2 −t 3 2 −1 1 1 2 −2 1 2 1+t +t
1 2 1 2
we have D
θ0,f ,θ1,f +δc1 ⊗(c2 −c0 )
= 1 − 3t + t 4 .
By (2.5), we arrive at X
ν˜ (f n ,c1 ) ([c0 , c2 ]) t n+1 = 1 −
n≥0
=
1 − 3t + t 4 1 − 2t + t 4
t , 1 − 2t + t 4
and finally X ν˜ (f n ,c1 ) ([c0 , c2 ]) t n = 1 + 2t + 4t 2 + 8t 3 + 15t 4 + 28t 5 + 52t 6 + o [t]7 . n≥0
With this, we conclude for instance that the equation f 6 (x) = c1 has exactly 52 solutions in [c0 , c2 ]. n . Let f : I → I be a piecewise monotone map with turning 2.2.1. The numbers ` f|K points c1 < · · · < cl , and n ∈ N. Recall that the lap number of f n is defined by def ` f n = # x ∈ int (I ) : f n (x) = 0 + 1, in other words, ` (f n ) is the number of maximal intervals in which f n is strictly monotone. More generally, for each K = [c, d] ∈ I, we define def n = # x ∈ int (K) : f n (x) = 0 + 1. ` f|K If we know the numbers ν(f i ,cj ) (int (K)) , with 0 ≤ i ≤ n − 1 and 1 ≤ j ≤ l, n . then we can easily compute ` f|K Let Cf = {c1 , . . . , c` } be the set of the turning points of f . For each cj ∈ Cf , we define the sequence γn cj by: 0 if f n+1 cj ∈ Cf for all n ≥ 0, γ0 cj = 1; γn+1 cj = γn cj if f n+1 cj ∈ / Cf
Kneading Theory: A Functorial Approach
103
and the correspondent formal power series def X γn cj t n . γ cj = n≥0
Then we have n−1 ` X X n γn−1−i cj ν(f i ,cj ) (int (K)) , for all n ≥ 1, =1+ ` f|K j =1 i=0
or equivalently ` X X X n ` f|K γ cj ν(f n ,cj ) (int (K)) t n+1 . t n = t (1 − t)−1 + n≥1
j =1
n≥0
Thus, if ν(f n ,cj ) (int (K)) = ν˜ (f n ,cj ) (K) , for all 1 ≤ j ≤ ` and n ≥ 0, we have by (2.5), D ` X X θ0,f ,θ1,f +δcj ⊗(d−c) n n −1 . ` f|K t = t (1 − t) + γ cj 1 − D(θ0,f ,θ1,f ) n≥1
(2.6)
j =1
In the particular case K = I , if f (∂I ) ⊆ ∂I , then ν(f n ,cj ) (int (I )) = ν˜ (f n ,cj ) (I ) , for all 1 ≤ j ≤ ` and n ∈ N, and by (2.6) we obtain Corollary 2.19. Let f : I = [a, b] → I be a piecewise monotone map with turning points c1 < · · · < c` . If f (∂I ) ⊆ ∂I , then we have D l X X θ0,f ,θ1,f +δcj ⊗(b−a) n n −1 . ` f t = t (1 − t) + γ cj 1 − D(θ0,f ,θ1,f ) n≥1 j =1 Remark 2.20. If f : I = [a, b] → I has a single turning point c1 and f (∂I ) ⊆ ∂I , then we check easily D(θ0,f ,θ1,f ) − D
θ0,f ,θ1,f +δc1 ⊗(b−a)
= t,
and from the previous corollary X n≥1
` f n t n−1 = (1 − t)−1 + γ (c1 ) D −1 (θ
0,f ,θ1,f
)
.
104
J. F. Alves, J. Sousa Ramos
Example 2.21. Let f be the map of Example 2.15. f has a single turning point at c1 . Since f (c0 ) = f (c2 ) = c0 , f (∂I ) ⊆ ∂I . We have γ (c1 ) = 1 + t + t 2 + t 3 , and by Corollary 2.19 X
` f n tn =
n≥1
t 1 − 3t + t 4 + 1 + t + t2 + t3 . 1 − , 1−t 1 − 2t + t 4
and X n≥1
` f n t n−1 =
1 1 + t + t2 + t3 + 1−t 1 − 2t + t 4
= 2 + 4t + 8t 2 + 16t 3 + 30t 4 + 56t 5 + o [t]6 . 2.3. The equation f n (x) = x. Let g : I → I be a piecewise monotone map. As usual, we say that x ∈ int (I ) is a fixed point of g of negative type (positive type) if g (x) = x and g is strictly decreasing (increasing) in some neighbourhood of x. We say that x ∈ I is a fixed point of g of critical type if g (x) = x and x is a local minimum or local maximum point of g. Using the sign ¯g (see Definition 2.11) we may write F ixg = {x ∈ I : g (x) = x} , F ixg− = x ∈ I : g (x) = x, ¯g (x) = −1 , F ixg+ = x ∈ I : g (x) = x, ¯g (x) = 1 , F ixg0 = x ∈ I : g (x) = x, ¯g (x) = 0 , and the correspondent cardinals Ng = # F ixg , Ng− = # F ixg− , Ng+ = # F ixg+ and Ng0 = # F ixg0 . Observe that, since g is piecewise monotone, the sets F ixg− and F ixg0 are finite, and it is clear that Ng ≥ 2Ng− − 1 + Ng0 . Note also that, in many interesting cases, it is sufficient to know the numbers Ng− and Ng0 for computing Ng . As an example if the piecewise monotone g is expansive (by 0 (x) > 1 and map we mean a continuous map g : I → I such that g+ an0 expansive g (x) > 1 for all x ∈ I ) then − Ng = 2Ng− − 1 + Ng0 . Let f : I → I be a piecewise monotone map. Recall that Milnor and Thurston proved that X tn (2.7) 2Nf−n − 1 = Df−1 , exp n n≥1
Kneading Theory: A Functorial Approach
105
where Df is the kneading determinant of f . Here we easily prove a similar result: exp
X tn n≥1
2Nf−n − 1 + Nf0 n = D −1 . (θ0,f ,θ1,f ) n
(2.8)
From definition of D(θ0,f ,θ1,f ) , Eq. (2.8) is an immediate consequence of the following result. Theorem 2.22. Let f : I → I be a piecewise monotone map and n ∈ Z+ . Then we have n n − θ0,f = 2Nf−n − 1 + Nf0 n . T r θ1,f Let n ∈ Z+ . By Corollary 2.10, we have n n − θ0,f T r θ1,f = T r θ1,f n − θ0,f n , therefore, Theorem 2.22 is an immediate consequence of the following Lemma 2.23. Let g : I = [a, b] → I be a piecewise monotone map. Then we have T r θ1,g − θ0,g = 2Ng− − 1 + Ng0 . Proof. Case 1 (g (a+) > 0 and g (b−) > 0 ). Let c1 < · · · < c` be the turning points of g. By Proposition 2.14, we have `+1 X ωi (g#0 (ci )) , T r θ1,g − θ0,g = i=0
with c0 = a and c`+1 = b. Consider the intervals I1 = [c1 , c2 ] , I3 = [c3 , c4 ] , . . . , I`−1 = c`−1 , c` . In this case, g is strictly decreasing in each of these intervals. Therefore, for each i = 1, 3, . . . , ` − 1, g has at most one fixed point in Ii , and by definition of ωi (see Definition 2.13) we have 2 if Ii ∩ F ixg− 6= ∅ ωi (g#0 (ci )) + ωi+1 (g#0 (ci+1 )) = 1 if Ii ∩ F ixg0 6= ∅ . 0 if Ii ∩ F ixg = ∅ From definition of ω0 and ω`+1 we also have 1 ωi (g#0 (ci )) = # F ixg0 ∩ {ci } − , for each i ∈ {c0 , c`+1 } . 2
106
J. F. Alves, J. Sousa Ramos
Thus `+1 X i=0
ωi (g#0 (ci )) = 2Ng− − 1 + Ng0 ,
and the proof follows. Case 2 (g (a+) < 0 or g (b−) < 0 ). Assume that g (b−) > 0 (in the remaining cases the proof follows in the same way). In this case we consider an interval J = [d, b], with d < a, and h : J → J a piecewise monotone map such that g (x) = h (x), for all x ∈ I , h is strictly increasing in [d, a] and h (d) > d. By definition of h, we have Nh− = Ng− and Nh0 = Ng0 , and by Proposition 2.14, T r θ1,g − θ0,g = T r θ1,h − θ0,h . Since h is in the conditions of the first case the proof follows. u t Remark 2.24. We can see Theorem 2.22 as a corollary of a more general result, which shows that the numbers 2Nf−n − 1 + Nf0 n are, in some sense, intrinsically associated with the morphisms .f#0 and .f#1 . We can state this result as follows: let f : I → I be a piecewise monotone map, and consider morphisms α0 , β0 , α1 and β1 such that, the diagrams i#0
p
S0 (I,Q) S0 (int(I ))
i#0
p
S0 (I,Q) S0 (int(I ))
0 −→ S0 (int (I )) −−−−→ S0 (I, Q) −−−−→ .f α y #0 y 0 0 −→ S0 (int (I )) −−−−→ S0 (I, Q) −−−−→
= Q2 −−−−→ 0 β y 0 = Q2 −−−−→ 0,
and ∂1
p0
0 −→ S˜1 (I, Q) −−−−→ S0 (I, Q) −−−−→ H0 (I, Q) = Q −−−−→ 0 .f α β y #1 y 1 y 1 0
p ∂1 | 0 −→ S˜1 (I, Q) −−−−→ S0 (I, Q) −−−−→ H0 (I, Q) = Q −−−−→ 0
are commutative. Then the pair (α0 , α1 ) has finite-dimensional image and T r α1n − α0n − T r β1n + T r β0n = 2Nf−n − 1 + Nf0 n , for all n ∈ N. To prove this result observe that the diagrams i#0
p
S0 (I,Q) S0 (int(I ))
i#0
p
S0 (I,Q) S0 (int(I ))
0 −→ S0 (int (I )) −−−−→ S0 (I, Q) −−−−→ α n −θ n y0 y 0 0,f 0 −→ S0 (int (I )) −−−−→ S0 (I, Q) −−−−→
= Q2 −−−−→ 0 β n y 0 = Q2 −−−−→ 0,
Kneading Theory: A Functorial Approach
107
and 0
p ∂1 0 −→ S˜1 (I, Q) −−−−→ S0 (I, Q) −−−−→ H0 (I, Q) = Q −−−−→ 0 α n −θ n β n y 1 1,f y 1 y0 0
p ∂1 0 −→ S˜1 (I, Q) −−−−→ S0 (I, Q) −−−−→ H0 (I, Q) = Q −−−−→ 0
are commutative. Therefore we have: n n = T r β0n and T r α1n − θ1,f = T r β1n , T r α0n − θ0,f and from Theorem 2.22,
n n − θ0,f 2Nf−n − 1 + Nf0 n = T r θ1,f i h n n − α1n + α0n − θ0,f = T r α1n − α0n + θ1,f = T r α1n − α0n − T r β1n + T r β0n .
Remark 2.25. We can establish a simple relation between D(θ0,f ,θ1,f ) and Df . In fact, from (2.7) and (2.8), we arrive at Df exp
X n≥1
−
Nf0 n n
t n = D(θ0,f ,θ1,f ) ,
or equivalently Df 5
o∈O0
1 − t p(o) = D(θ0,f ,θ1,f ) ,
where O0 denotes the set of periodic orbits of f of critical type, and p (o) the correspondent period. Example 2.26. Let f be the map of Example 2.15. We have −1 X tn 2Nf−n − 1 + Nf0 n = 1 − 2t + t 4 . exp n n≥1
Thus X n≥1
2Nf−n − 1 + Nf0 n t n−1 =
2 − 4t 3 , 1 − 2t + t 4
and finally X 2Nf−n − 1 + Nf0 n t n−1 = 2 + 4t + 8t 2 + 12t 3 + 22t 4 + 40t 5 + o [t]6 . n≥1
With this, we can conclude for instance that Nf 6 ≥ 2Nf−6 − 1 + Nf0 6 = 40.
108
J. F. Alves, J. Sousa Ramos
2.4. The equation f n (x) = h (x). Let h : I → I be a continuous map. We say that h is a constant signal map, if h is a constant function on int (I ). We define the sign of h by def
(h) = h (x) , for some x ∈ int (I ) . In the previous section we proved independently Theorems 2.17 and 2.22. These results have to do with the number of solutions of the equations f n (x) = x0 and f n (x) = x.
(2.9)
Since the constant map and the identity map are constant signal maps, we may regard the equation f n (x) = h (x) ,
(2.10)
where h is a constant signal map, as a generalization of the equations in (2.9). Our goal now is to show that Theorems 2.17 and 2.22 are particular cases of a more general theorem concerning the number of solutions of Eq. (2.10). As an immediate consequence of this theorem, we shall obtain a stronger version of Theorem 2.22, dealing with the number of periodic points of f in an arbitrary subinterval of I . We begin to generalize ν˜ (g,x0 ) (see Definition 2.5). Let g : I → I be a piecewise monotone map and h : I → I a constant signal map. We define the function ν(g,h) : I → {0, 1, 2} by 1 − ¯g (x) (h) if f (x) = h (x) , for all x ∈ I. ν(g,h) (x) = 0 if f (x) 6 = h (x) Since the set
x ∈ I : ν(g,h) (x) 6 = 0
is finite, we can define Definition 2.27. Let g : I → I be a piecewise monotone map, and h : I → I a constant signal map. P ν(g,h) (x), for all subsets K ⊆ I . 1. We define ν(g,h) (K) = x∈K
2. We define ν˜ (g,h) to be the unique linear form on S˜1 (I, Q) that verifies 1 ν˜ (g,h) (K) = ν(g,h) (int (K)) + ν(g,h) (∂K) , 2 for each K ∈ I. Note that, if h = idI , then (h) = 1 and ν(g,idI ) (I ) = 2Ng− + Ng0 . More generally ν(g,idI ) (K) = 2# F ixg− ∩ K + # F ixg0 ∩ K ,
Kneading Theory: A Functorial Approach
109
and ν˜ (g,idI ) (K) = 2# F ixg− ∩ int (K) + # F ixg− ∩ ∂K 1 +# F ixg0 ∩ int (K) + # F ixg0 ∩ ∂K , 2 for each K ∈ I, and it is clear that # F ixg ∩ K ≥ ν(g,idI ) (K) − 1 ≥ ν˜ (g,idI ) (K) − 1. Let h : I → I be a constant signal map and f : I → I a piecewise monotone map. Consider the linear transformation ηh : S0 (I, Q) → S0 (I, Q) defined as follows: If x ∈ I and there is y ∈ I , such that h (y) = x, then ηh (x) = (h) .y . For the remaining points of I we define ηh (x) = 0. It is clear that, if (h) = 0, then ηh = 0. If h = idI , then ηh = idS0 (I,Q) . Since the pair θ0,f , θ1,f has finite-dimensional image, we see that, def n n − θ0,f , for each n ∈ N, γ(n,f,h) = ηh ◦ θ1,f is a linear transformation on S0 (I, Q), with finite-dimensional image. Therefore we can consider T(n,f,h) to be the linear form on S˜1 (I, Q) defined by T(n,f,h) (K) = T r π˜ K ◦ γ(n,f,h) , for all K ∈ I, where π˜ K : S0 (I, Q) → S0 (I, Q) is the unique linear transformation that verifies x if x ∈ int (K) π˜ K (x) = 21 x if x ∈ ∂K , for all x ∈ I. 0 if x ∈ /K Now we can state our main result, which is a generalization of Theorems 2.17 and 2.22. Theorem 2.28. Let f : I → I be a piecewise monotone map, h : I → I a constant signal map, ∂1 : S˜1 (I, Q) → S0 (I, Q) the boundary operator, n ∈ Z+ and S(n,f,h) the linear form on S0 (I, Q) defined by n n S(n,f,h) (x) = δh(x) θ1,f (x) − (h) .f#0 (x) , for all x ∈ I, where δh(x) is the linear form of Definition 2.16. Then S(n,f,h) ◦ ∂1 + T(n,f,h) = ν˜ (f n ,h) . If h is a homeomorphism, then T r γ(n,f,h) = ν(f n ,h) (I ) − 1.
110
J. F. Alves, J. Sousa Ramos
Observe that, once more by Corollary 2.10, we have γ(n,f,h) = γ(1,f n ,h) , T(n,f,h) = T(1,f n ,h) and S(n,f,h) = S(1,f n ,h) , for each n ∈ Z+ . Thus Theorem 2.28 is an immediate consequence of the following Lemma 2.29. Let g : I → I be a piecewise monotone map, h : I → I a constant signal map, ∂1 : S˜1 (I, Q) → S0 (I, Q) the boundary operator, and S(1,g,h) the linear form on S0 (I, Q) defined by S(1,g,h) (x) = δh(x) θ1,g (x) − (h) .g#0 (x) , for all x ∈ I. Then S(1,g,h) ◦ ∂1 + T(1,g,h) = ν˜ (g,h) . If h is a homeomorphism, then
T r γ(1,g,h) = ν(g,h) (I ) − 1.
Proof. Observe that, if (h) = 0, then the proof follows from Theorem 2.17. We shall prove the lemma for (h) 6 = 0. Let g : I = c0 , c`+1 → I be a piecewise monotone map, with turning points c1 < · · · < c` , and h : I → I a constant signal map, such that (h) 6 = 0. Since Ig generates S˜1 (I, Q), to prove the first part, we only need to show that (2.11) S(1,g,h) (d) − S(1,g,h) (c) + T r π˜ K ◦ γ(1,g,h) = ν˜ (g,h) (K) , for all K = [c, d] ∈ Ig . Let K = [c, d] ∈ Ig , and consider the numbers C and D, defined by: h (c) < g (c) (h) − g (c+) if 1 0 if h (c) = g (c) and ¯g (c) 6 = 0 , C= 2 (h) g (c+) if h (c) = g (c) and ¯g (c) = 0 h (c) > g (c) g (c+) − (h) if and
h (d) < g (d) g (d−) − (h) if 1 0 if h (d) = g (d) and ¯g (d) 6 = 0 . D= 2 (h) g (d−) if h (d) = g (d) and ¯g (d) = 0 h (d) > g (d) (h) − g (d−) if
By definition of Ig , g is injective in K, and we check easily C + D = ν˜ (g,h) (K) . Thus, from (2.11) we have to prove that S(1,g,h) (d) − S(1,g,h) (c) + T r π˜ K ◦ γ(1,g,h) = C + D.
(2.12)
Kneading Theory: A Functorial Approach
111
From Propositions 2.12 and 2.14, we have
S(1,g,h) (x) = ¯g (x) − (h) δh(x) (g#0 (x)) +
`+1 X
(2.13)
ωi (x) δh(x) (g#0 (ci ))
i=0
for all x ∈ I , and `+1 X ωi ((π˜ K ◦ ηh ◦ g#0 ) (ci )) . T r π˜ K ◦ γ(1,g,h) =
(2.14)
i=0
Let U : I → Q be the function defined by: U (x) = ¯g (x) − (h) δh(x) (g#0 (x)) , for all x ∈ I. Let V : I → Q be the function defined by: V (x) = 0 if x ∈ I \ {c0 , . . . , c`+1 } , and V (ci ) = ωi ((π˜ K ◦ ηh ◦ g#0 ) (ci )) +ωi (d) δh(d) (g#0 (ci )) − ωi (c) δh(c) (g#0 (ci )) , for each i = 0, . . . , ` + 1. We have
(π˜ K ◦ ηh ) (x) = (h) δh(c) − δh(d) (x) .ηh (x) , for all x ∈ I,
therefore
ωi ((π˜ K ◦ ηh ◦ g#0 ) (ci )) = ωi (h) δh(c) (g#0 (ci )) ηh (g#0 (ci ))
−ωi (h) δh(d) (g#0 (ci )) ηh (g#0 (ci )) ,
and V (ci ) = δh(c) (g#0 (ci )) ωi ( (h) ηh (g#0 (ci )) − c) +δh(d) (g#0 (ci )) ωi (d − (h) ηh (g#0 (ci ))) .
(2.15)
Since K ∈ Ig , we have {c0 , c1 , . . . , c`+1 } ∩ int (K) = ∅, therefore V (x) = 0, for all x ∈ int (K). From (2.15), we verify easily that V (x) = 0, for all x ∈ / K . Thus {x ∈ I : V (x) 6 = 0} ⊆ {c, d} , and, once more by (2.15), we have −δh(c) (g#0 (c)) g (c+) if g (c) 6= h (c) , if ¯g (c) = 0, V (c) = −δh(d) (g#0 (c)) g (c+) if g (c) = h (c) and
V (d) =
δh(d) (g#0 (d)) g (d−) if g (d) 6 = h (d) , if ¯g (d) = 0. δh(d) (g#0 (d)) g (d−) if g (d) = h (d)
(2.16)
(2.17)
(2.18)
112
J. F. Alves, J. Sousa Ramos
By (2.13) and (2.14), we have
X V (x) , S(1,g,h) (d) − S(1,g,h) (c) + T r π˜ K ◦ γ(1,g,h) = U (d) − U (c) + x∈I
and by (2.16) U (d) − U (c) +
X
V (x) = V (c) − U (c) + V (d) + U (d) .
x∈I
From (2.17) and (2.18) we have V (c) − U (c) = C and V (d) + U (d) = D, and finally we obtain (2.12). Now we prove the second part. Assume that h is an homeomorphism. From the first part, we obtain
S(1,g,h) (c`+1 ) − S(1,g,h) (c0 ) + T r π˜ I ◦ γ(1,g,h) = ν˜ (g,h) (I ) ,
therefore
T r γ(1,g,h) − ν˜ (g,h) (I ) = T r idS0 (I,Q) − π˜ I ◦ γ(1,g,h) −S(1,g,h) (c`+1 ) + S(1,g,h) (c0 ) .
Once more, we use Propositions 2.12 and 2.14, to show that
ν(g,h) (I ) − ν˜ (g,h) (I ) − 1 = T r idS0 (I,Q) − π˜ I ◦ γ(1,g,h) −S(1,g,h) (c`+1 ) + S(1,g,h) (c0 ) ,
and the proof follows. u t Remark 2.30. It is clear that we can prove the second part of this proposition, using Lemma 2.23. In fact, if h is an homeomorphism, then we have by Lemma 2.23, (2.19) T r θ1,h−1 ◦g − θ0,h−1 ◦g = ν(h−1 ◦g,idI ) (I ) − 1. Observe that, if h is an homeomorphism, then we have ηh = (h) h−1 #0 , and it is clear that ηh 6 = θ0,h−1 and ηh 6 = θ1,h−1 . Nevertheless, the diagrams i
∂1 #0 S0 (int (I ) , Q) −→ S0 (I, Q) S˜1 (I, Q) −→ S0 (I, Q) ↓ ηh and .h−1 .h−1 ↓ ηh #0 ↓ #1 ↓ ∂1 i#0 S˜1 (I, Q) −→ S0 (I, Q) S0 (int (I ) , Q) −→ S0 (I, Q)
are commutative. Thus, we have ηh ◦ θ0,g = θ0,h−1 ◦g and ηh ◦ θ1,g = θ1,h−1 ◦g , and by (2.19), T r ηh ◦ θ1,g − θ0,g
= T r θ1,h−1 ◦g − θ0,h−1 ◦g = ν(h−1 ◦g,idI ) (I ) − 1 = ν(g,h) (I ) − 1.
Kneading Theory: A Functorial Approach
113
We return to the case h = idI . In this case we have n n S(n,f,idI ) (x) = δx θ1,f (x) − f#0 (x) , for each x ∈ I, T(n,f,idI ) (K) = T r π˜ K ◦ γ(n,f,idI ) n n − θ0,f , for each K ∈ I. = T r π˜ K ◦ θ1,f If we consider the formal power series def
Sf (x) =
X
S(n,f,idI ) (x) t n−1 , for each x ∈ I,
n≥1
and def
Tf (K) =
X
T(n,f,idI ) (K) t n−1 , for each K ∈ I,
n≥1
then, as an immediate consequence of Theorem 2.28, we have X ν˜ (f n ,idI ) (K) t n+1 , Sf (d) − Sf (c) + Tf (K) =
(2.20)
n≥1
for each K = [c, d] ∈ I. Since Tf (K) = ϒ(π˜ K ,θ0,f ,θ1,f ) , we apply Corollary 1.5 to compute Tf (K). To compute Sf (x) we apply Corollary 1.4 to obtain t 2 Sf (x) = D(f#0 ,f#0 +δx ⊗x) − D −1 (θ
0,f ,θ1,f
D , ) (θ0,f ,θ1,f +δx ⊗x )
(2.21)
for each x ∈ I . Example 2.31. Let f be the map of Example 2.15, and consider K = [c, d], with c = f 3 (c1 ) and d = c1 . We have o n j 3 = (i, j ) ∈ {0, 1, 2} × N : π˜ K ◦ θ0,f (f#0 (ci )) 6 = 0 = {(1, 2) , (1, 3)} , and by Corollary 1.5. Tf (K) = ϒ(π˜ K ,θ0,f ,θ1,f ) X −1 j −1 = t 1 − D θ ,θ D j ( 0,f 1,f ) θ0,f ,θ1,f +ωi ⊗π˜ K ◦θ0,f (f#0 (ci )) (i,j )∈3
=
t2 − t3 . 2 1 − 2t + t 4
114
J. F. Alves, J. Sousa Ramos
By (2.21) we have t 2 Sf (c) =
−2t 3 + t 4 + t 5 t2 + t3 − t4 − , 2 1 − 2t + t 4 2 1 − t4
and t 2 Sf (d) =
t4 + t3 − t2 . 2 1 − t4
Thus by (2.20) we have X
ν˜ (f n ,idI ) (K) t n−1 =
n≥1
and finally X
t t − t2 + , 1 − t4 1 − 2t + t 4
ν˜ (f n ,idI ) (K) t n−1 = 2t + 2t 2 + 3t 3 + 6t 4 + 12t 5 + o [t]6 .
n≥1
With this, we conclude, for instance, that # F ixf 6 ∩ K ≥ ν˜ (f 6 ,idI ) (K) − 1 = 11. References [Ba-Ru 94] Baladi, V. and Ruelle, D.: An extension of the theorem of Milnor and Thurston on the zeta functions of interval maps. Ergod. Th. & Dynam. Sys. 14, 621–632 (1994) [Me-St 93] Melo, W. and van Strein, S.: One-Dimensional Dynamics. Berlin–Heidelberg–New York: Springer-Verlag, 1993 [Mi-Th 88] Milnor, J., Thurston, W.: On Iterated Maps of the Interval. In: Dynamical Sytems: Proceedings 1986–1987, Berlin–Heidelberg–New York: Springer-Verlag, 1988. Lecture Notes in Mathematics, 1342, pp. 465–563 [Mo 90] Mori, M.: Fredholm determinants for piecewise linear transformations. Osaka J. Math. 27, 81– 116 (1990) Communicated by Ya. G. Sinai
Commun. Math. Phys. 204, 115 – 136 (1999)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
© Springer-Verlag 1999
Free Massive Fermions Inside the Quantum Discrete sine-Gordon Model Nadja Kutz? Technische Universität Berlin, Sekr. MA 8-5, Strasse des 17. Juni 136, 10623 Berlin, Germany. E-mail: [email protected] Received: 2 December 1996 / Accepted: 19 January 1999
Abstract: We extend the notion of space shifts introduced in [FV3] for certain quantum light cone lattice equations of sine-Gordon type at root of unity (e.g. [FV1,FV2, BKP,BBR]). As a result, we obtain a compatibility equation for the roots of central elements within the algebra of observables (also called current algebra). The equation, which is obtained by exponentiating these roots, is exactly the evolution equation for the “classical background” as described in [BBR]. As an application for the introduced constructions, we derive a one to one correspondence between a special case of the quantum light cone lattice equations of sine-Gordon type and free massive fermions on a lattice, as a special case of the lattice Thirring model constructed in [DV]. 1. Introduction There is a famous correspondence between the quantum sine-Gordon model and the massive Thirring model (see e.g. [C,KM]). The sine-Gordon model and the massive Thirring model have equivalents which are discrete in space and time – namely the so-called doubly discrete quantum sineGordon model (see e.g. [BRST,NCP,S,V,FV2,CN,EK]) and the doubly discrete massive Thirring model [DV]. One of the main purposes of this paper is to establish a connection between the quantum doubly discrete sine-Gordon model and the doubly discrete model of free massive fermions which appears as a special case of the doubly discrete massive Thirring model. The (classical) doubly discrete sine-Gordon model belongs to a class of lattice systems defined by an evolution equation of the following type: gu = V 0 (gl − gr ) + gd = 0. ? Supported by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft, Sonderforschungsbereich 288
(1)
116
N. Kutz
Equation (1) is a discrete version of the evolution equation 2g = V 0 (g), 2 being the Laplacian on two dimensional Minkowski space time. The real value gu ∈ R is given by the three real values gd , gl , gr ∈ R and by the function V 0 (x), which is the derivative of a real potential V (x) : R → R. The indices u, d, l, r denote up, down, left and right, respectively, and stand for the corresponding vertices in the picture of a two dimensional Minkowski space time lattice shown below. The Minkowski space time (or light cone) lattice is just Z2 with the interpretation that edges point in light cone directions. Clearly, if we start with e.g. space periodic initial data gi along a Cauchy zig zag C on the light cone lattice (Fig. 1) then the local evolution given by (1) will determine the function g : V ertices → R on the whole lattice. gu gr
gl
Cauchy path C
gd
Lattice systems of the above type have been discussed e.g. in [BRST,NCP,S,V, FV2,CN,EK]). In [EK] it was shown that it is possible to derive the above equation as an equation of motion from an explicitly given action. Moreover, using covariant phase space techniques, it is possible to derive the symplectic structure belonging to the above model via a variation of this action. As a consequence, one obtains an unique Poisson bracket for the variables gi (now viewed as functions on covariant phase space with quasiperiodic initial conditions). This bracket was first stated in [FV2]. The above Poisson bracket has the property that the variables gi , which are associated with the vertices of the space time lattice, do not necessarily Poisson commute with variables gk associated with vertices outside the lightcone initiating at the vertex i. For this reason the variables gi , which we call vertex variables are often referred to as “variables with nonlocal Poisson relations”. In contrast to this, the induced Poisson relations for the Poisson subalgebra of difference variables gl − gr (Fig. 1) are local. Therefore the difference variables are viewed as referring to physical observables and consequently they received much attention (see e.g. [BKP,FV1,BBR,CN]). The difference variables gl −gr can be associated with the faces of the space time lattice (Fig. 1) and are therefore sometimes called face variables. Despite their unpleasant Poisson relations; it is worthwhile to study the ”vertex algebra” generated by the vertex variables gi . An important step in this direction was made in the work of Faddeev and Volkov [FV3], where quantized models of the above variables were studied. In particular, the so-called quantum L-operator, which is needed for obtaining quantum integrals of motion can be constructed in terms of the vertex algebra but (so far) not in terms of the face algebra. For the construction of the quantum lattice sine-Gordon/massive Thirring model analogy it is crucial to investigate a subalgebra of the vertex algebra which is generated by variables gd + gl and gr + gd , respectively (Fig. 1). This subalgebra is associated with the edges of the lattice and clearly contains the face algebra generated by the face variables. The induced Poisson relations on this subalgebra (edge algebra) are also
Free Massive Fermions Inside Discrete sine-Gordon Model
117
nonlocal. Nevertheless, it turns out that the edge variables when quantized, may furnish fermionic fields, obeying local anticommutation rules. The evolution in the lattice massive Thirring model (MTM) is given by an inner automorphism involving the (quantum) R-matrix of an integrable generalization of the six vertex model followed as a space-like shift on fermionic fields. The evolution of quantized edge variables in the lattice sine-Gordon model (SGM) case given by the quantized version of (1) can also be constructed as an automorphism involving the “dynamical” sine-Gordon R-matrix and a space-like shift. The corresponding automorphisms in that case are not always inner, in particular in the root of unity case, this automorphism gives rise to a quantum evolution with “classical background” as first noticed in [BBR]. In the work of Faddeev and Volkov [FV3] the above mentioned space-like shift automorphisms for the SGM are constructed as inner automorphisms for a special choice of monodromies. We will show that this shift automorphism together with the evolution automorphism can be generalized in the root of unity case to an “almost” inner automorphism by extending the corresponding algebra with central elements which change nontrivially under the automorphism (so-called “classical phase factors”) (see also [BBR]). As a consequence, we obtain a compatibility equation for these central elements. The equation that is obtained by exponentiating this equation is exactly the evolution equation for the “classical background” as described in [BBR]. The paper is organized as follows: in the first section we define the general classical model, which gives rise to the sine-Gordon model and a careful description of the involved algebras is given. In the second section the corresponding quantized model is described. In the third section we describe the model of sine-Gordon type at root of unity, and derive an evolution equation for the roots of central elements. In the last section we use the prior results to show how the quantized lattice sine-Gordon model can be related to the lattice massive Thirring model constructed by Destri and de Vega [DV] (see also [TS] and its bibliography). In particular, we construct an isomorphism between a representation of the fermionic edge algebra and the “bare” fermion operators in [DV] and hence obtain an isomorphism between a representation of the dynamical sine-Gordon R-matrix and the R-matrix of an integrable generalization of the six vertex model (for ω = 1) in [DV]. Incidentally, this R-matrix is identical to the usual quantum R-matrix (with real spectral parameter) of the sine-Gordon model, which defines the commutation relations of the sine-Gordon L-operator (see e.g. [TF]). This is not only interesting in terms of representation theory, but also because we obtain in this way an immediate connection between the phase space of the quantum lattice sine-Gordon theory and its dynamical aspects. As another result it may be possible to understand more about the true nature of the famous sine-Gordon - massive Thirring model equivalence (see e.g. [C,KM]). 2. The Phase Space 2.1. Vertex variables. A (spatially) periodic light cone lattice L2p (Fig. 1) with period 2p may be viewed as L/Z, where Z acts on the infinite light cone lattice L by shifts of 2p in a space-like direction. A quasi-periodic field is a mapping g:L→R with gt,i+2p − gt,i = gt,i+2p+2 − gt,i+2 ∀i ∈ Z,
118
N. Kutz
g2t+2,−2
g2t+2,0
g2t+1,−1
g2t+2,2 g2t+1,1
g2t+1,2p−1
x2t+1,1 g2t,−2
g2t+2,2p
g2t,0
g2t+1,2p+1 C2t+1
x2t+1,3
g2t,2
g2t,2p
x2t,1 x2t,2 g2t−1,−1 g2t−1,1
C2t
x2t,0
g2t−1,2p−1
g2t−1,2p+1
Figure 1. (1)
(2)
and with two (space independent) monodromies mt , mt
defined by
(i)
(2) mt := gt,2p+2k+1−i − gt,2k+1−i for an arbitrary k ∈ Z. Since the quasiperiodic variables gt,k are associated with the vertices of the Minkowski lattice L we will simply call them vertex variables. The indices t, k are adapted to Fig. 1, i.e. t denotes time and k space. We define an evolution of the following form (Fig. 1): (3) gt+1,k+1 = V 0 (gt,k − gt,k+2 ) + gt−1,k+1 . g g Given a set of initial values I2t = (g2t−1,2k+1 )k∈{−1,...p−1} , (g2t,2k )k∈{0,...p} or I2t+1= (g2t,2k )k∈{0,...p} , (g2t+1,2k−1 )k∈{−1,...p−1} , (t ∈ Z fixed) along an elementary Cauchy zig zag (Fig. 1), the evolution equations (3) define quasiperiodic field values at all other times. A quasiperiodic field g obtained in this way will be called a solution to evolution (3). By virtue of the evolution equations the monodromies are time independent (1)
(2)
m2t := m(1) m2t−1 := m(2) . In Fig. 1 elementary Cauchy zig zags C2t and C2t+1 are visualized by dashed and nondashed lines, the grey area indicates fundamental regions for quasiperiodic initial values g g I2t and I2t+1 . The quasiperiodic initial values It can be interpreted as a (global) coordinate chart gt : P → R2p+2 on the set of all solutions P to Eq. (3) via the identification: gt,i (g) = gt,i ∈ R. The set of all solutions to a given evolution will be called covariant phase space P. It is possible to define a translationally invariant action on the set of quasiperiodic fields whose variation gives the above field equations as well as a time independent, translationally invariant symplectic structure [EK], which in the turn defines the following Poisson relations for the functions gt,i : P → R: {gt,i , gt,k } = 0, if i − k even, {gt,i , gt±1,k } = 1, if i − k odd, i < k, |i − k| < 2p, {gt,i , m(k) } = 0 (i − k odd), , m(k) }
= 2 (i − k even), {gt,i {m(1) , m(2) } = 0.
(4)
Free Massive Fermions Inside Discrete sine-Gordon Model
119
The Poisson algebra generated by the vertex variables gt,i : P → R together with the relations (4) will be called vertex algebra. 2.2. Edge variables. Define the following variables: xt,k : = gt,k + gt−1,k−1 xt,k : = gt−1,k + gt,k−1
for k − t even, for k − t odd.
(5)
With respect to the labeling of the vertex variables, the choice of indices for the edge variables appears to be quite counterintuitive. Nevertheless with this choice the indices t and k still refer to space and time. xt+1,k
xt+1,k−1 gt,k−2
gt,k
xt,k−1
t
xt,k
gt−1,k−1 k
The variables xt,k are associated with the edges of the Minkowski lattice L and we call them edge variables. The corresponding Poisson subalgebra will be called edge algebra. g g x = A set of initial vertex values I2t+1 or I2t defines the initial edge values I2t+1 x (x2t+1,k )k∈{0,...2p} or I2t = (x2t,k )k∈{0,...2p} , respectively. The edge variables are still quasiperiodic. Their monodromy is the sum of the two monodromies of the vertex variables : + m(2)} . xt,k+2p = xt,k + |m(1) {z :=mx
The induced Poisson commutation rules are {xt,k , xt,k+n } = 2 {xt,k , mx } = 4.
n ∈ {1 . . . 2p − 1},
(6) (7)
Using definition (5) and the vertex evolution equations (3), one obtains the following evolution equations for the edge variables: xt+1,k = V 0 (xt,k−1 − xt,k ) + xt,k , xt+1,k−1 = V 0 (xt,k−1 − xt,k ) + xt,k−1 , mx = const. We will call these equations edge evolution equations.
(8) (9) (10)
120
N. Kutz
2.3. Face variables. Define the following fields: pt,k−1 : = gt,k−2 − gt,k
gt,k−2
pt,k−1
gt,k
pt−1,k
The difference variables pt,k are associated with the faces of the Minkowski lattice L. They will be called face variables, and the corresponding Poisson subalgebra face g g algebra. A set of initial vertex values I2t+1 or I2t , respectively defines the initial face valp p ues I2t = {(p2t−1,2k )k∈{0..p−1} , (p2t,2k+1 )k∈{0..p−1} } or I2t+1 = {(p2t,2k+1 )k∈{0..p−1} , (p2t+1,2k )k∈{0..p−1} }. Note that pt,k−1 = xt,k−1 −xt,k = xt+1,k−1 −xt+1,k (k −t even). The above variables are periodic since the monodromies cancel: pt,2p+k−1 = pt,k−1 = gt,k−2 + m(i) − (gt,k + m(i) ). The induced Poisson relations between these variables are ultralocal in space: {pt,j , pt±1,j +1 } = 2, {pt,j , pt±1,j +1+k } = 0 for k ∈ {1 . . . 2p − 3}.
(11) (12)
The evolution equations in terms of the face variables read as pt+1,k = V 0 (pt,k−1 ) − V 0 (pt,k+1 ) + pt−1,k . We will call these equations face evolution equations. The introduction of the above variables refers to a Marsden-Weinstein reduction of phase space as explained in [EK]. 2.4. Relations to the sine-Gordon model. Let the halfperiod p of the lattice be even, i.e. p = 2s. In [EK] it was shown that the action, which describes the above dynamical systems is invariant under a redefinition of g ; −g along every second diagonal of the Minkowski lattice, i.e. all the above structure is preserved under such a redefinition. Choosing V 0 (x) = −i ln(
1 + keix ), k + eix
(13)
projecting the evolution to the torus T 2p+2 : k + ei(gt,k −gt,k+2 ) igt−1,k+1 e , (14) 1 + kei(gt,k −gt,k+2 ) and with the above redefinition the vertex equation (3) we obtain the famous Hirota equation [H], while the face equations are commonly known as doubly discrete sineGordon equations (see e.g.[BKP,BBR,FV2]). Without such a redefinition along the diagonals, but still with the special potential given in (13), the above model is related to the doubly discrete mKdV model [CN]. Due to its relation to the sine-Gordon model (see e.g. [IK]), the torus projected vertex, edge and face equations with the potential (13) will be called of sine-Gordon type. In the next sections we will study evolutions of sine-Gordon type. eigt+1,k+1 =
Free Massive Fermions Inside Discrete sine-Gordon Model
121
3. Quantization of the Models 3.1. General outline. Fix an initial Cauchy path as e.g. C2T (Fig. 1). Our quantization scheme ig follows the commonig procedure to substitute the canonical variables I2T := (e 2T −1,2k+1 )k∈{−1,...p−1} {(e 2T ,2k )k∈{0,...p} as functions on phase space by unitary operators I2T := (G2T −1,2k+1 )k∈{−1,...p−1} ∈ U (H), (G2T ,2k )k∈{0,...p} ∈ U (H) obeying Weyl commutation relations. That is, we search for a bijection Q : F(P) → U (H), Q(eigt,k ) =: Gt,k with the properties Q(const) = const 11, ) = Q(eigt,k )Q(eigτ,j ) ei phase , Q(e e igt,k igτ,j
such that [Gt,i , Gt,k ] = 0, Gt,i Gt±1,k = q [Gt,i
, M (k) ]
Gt,i
M (k)
−m 2
if i − k even, Gt±1,k Gt,i , if i − k odd, i < k, |i − k| < 2p,
=0 =
(i − k odd),
q −m M (k) Gt,i
(15)
(i − k even),
[M (1) , M (2) ] = 0, where the commutator is defined as usual [A, B] := AB − BA, q ∈ S 1 ⊂ C, m ∈ N and M (1) : = G2T ,2p G−1 2T ,0 ,
M (2) : = G2T −1,2p−1 G−1 2T −1,−1 ,
Gt,k+2p : = M (i) Gt,k .
11 = (Gt,k )0 is the identity in U (H) and the product in U (H) is given by the composition 2π i
of operators. For our purpose q will always be chosen as a root of unity, i.e. q = e N ∈ S 1 ⊂ C, N ∈ N. in the generators I2T = Let A(G2T ) be the algebra of Laurent polynomials (G2T −1,2k+1 )k∈{−1,...p−1} , (G2T ,2k )k∈{0,...p} (T ∈ Z fixed). Note that, up until now, the “quantization” map Q was only defined for the initial canonical variables eigt,k , t ∈ {2T − 1, 2T } and, modulo a phase factor, on products of these. It was not specified for other functions on phase space P, such as the time one evolved variables: g2T +1,2k−1 = g2T +1,2k−1 (g2T ,2k−2 , g2T ,2k , g2T −1,2k−1 ). Our goal is to implicitly define a quantization for these functions by defining an automorphism Et,k−1 : A(G2T ) → A(G2T ), such that: Q(eigt+1,k−1 ): = Et,k−1 (Gt−1,k−1 ) = Et,k−1 (Q(eigt−1,k−1 )), where eigt+1,k−1 is given by the classical evolution. The automorphism Et,k−1 will be very adapted to our specific model. We will not discuss whether (or how) it would be possible to find such an automorphism in general nor will we be concerned with a discussion of the above quantization procedure with respect to completeness (when e.g. extending by linearity), uniqueness, connection to other quantizatons, etc.
122
N. Kutz
Let us proceed with an explicit construction of Et,k−1 . In accordance with the classical definition (5) define edge operators (k − t even): Xt,k : = Gt,k Gt−1,k−1 , Xt,k−1 : = Gt−1,k−1 Gt,k−2 ,
(16) (17)
−1 = q −m M (1) M (2) . ⇒ MX : = Xt,2p Xt,0
(18)
Let A(X2T ) be the algebra of Laurent polynomials in the generators X = (X2T ,k )k∈{0..2p} . I2T
Define face operators m
Pt,k−1 := q − 2 G−1 t,k Gt,k−2
(19)
−1 −1 −1 Xt,k−1 = Xt+1,k Xt+1,k−1 . Let A(P2T ) be the algebra of Laurent Note that Pt,k−1 = Xt,k P polynomials in the generators I2T = {(P2T −1,2k )k∈{0..p−1} , (P2T ,2k+1 )k∈{0..p−1} }. Clearly the above construction can also be done for the odd time Cauchy path C2T −1 .
3.2. Almost Hamiltonian quantum evolution. Let Rk (Pt,n−1 ) be a nonvanishing Laurent m polynomial in the face operator Pt,n−1 := q − 2 G−1 t,n Gt,n−2 , i.e. Rk (Pt,n−1 ) ∈ A(Gt ) B
which depends on a parameter k ∈ [0, 1). Let eiξk (Pt,n−1 ) ∈ S 1 ⊂ C be a number B ∈ A(PT ) ⊂ A(GT ) and the same parameter which depends on a central element Pt,n−1 k ∈ [0, 1), and B ∈ N. Define recursively (n − t even) B
Gt+1,n−1 : = Et,n−1 (Gt−1,n−1 ) : = Rk (Pt,n−1 )Gt−1,n−1 Rk (Pt,n−1 )−1 eiξk (Pt,n−1 ) B Rk (Pt,n−1 ) Gt−1,n−1 eiξk (Pt,n−1 ) , = (20) m Rk (q Pt,n−1 ) Et,n−1 (Gt˜,j ): = Gt˜,j for j 6 = n − 1 mod 2p; t˜ ∈ {t, t − 1},
(21)
i.e. the automorphisms Et,n−1 act nontrivially only on operators which are associated to the (t, n − 1)th face of the corresponding Cauchy zig zag Ct . Gt+1,n−1
Gt+1,n+1
Et,n+1
Et,n−1
C Gt−1,n−1
Gt−1,n+1
An automorphism defined by conjugation with an element of the algebra and multiplication with a phase factor will be called almost inner. Define E2t : =
p−1 Y n=0
E2t,2n+1
E2t−1 : =
p−1 Y n=0
E2t−1,2n ,
Free Massive Fermions Inside Discrete sine-Gordon Model
123
which is well defined since the corresponding automorphisms Et,n−1 commute. Et evolves all operators associated with a Cauchy path Ct one time step further and by the definition of the evolution automorphism, Et (Gt−1,n−1 ) = Et,n−1 (Gt−1,n−1 ). Using the commutation relations in (15) and the periodicity of the face operators, it follows immediately that the above automorphisms preserve the monodromies. We will call such automorphisms almost Hamiltonian evolution automorphisms. The induced evolution on the subalgebras A(PT ) ⊂ A(XT ) ⊂ A(GT ) (Fig. 1) reads: B
Xt+1,n : = Gt,n Gt+1,n−1 = Gt,n Rk (Pt,n−1 )Gt−1,n−1 Rk (Pt,n−1 )−1 eiξk (Pt,n−1 ) (22) B B Rk (Pt,n−1 ) Xt,n eiξk (Pt,n−1 ) , = Rk (Pt,n−1 )Xt,n Rk (Pt,n−1 )−1 eiξk (Pt,n−1 ) = m Rk (q Pt,n−1 ) B
Xt+1,n−1: = Gt+1,n−1 Gt,n−2 = Rk (Pt,n−1 )Gt−1,n−1 Rk (Pt,n−1 )−1 Gt,n−2 eiξk (Pt,n−1 ) B
= Rk (Pt,n−1 )Xt,n−1 Rk (Pt,n−1 )−1 eiξk (Pt,n−1 ) B Rk (Pt,n−1 ) Xt,n−1 eiξk (Pt,n−1 ) , = m Rk (q Pt,n−1 ) m
Pt+1,n : = q − 2 G−1 t+1,n+1 Gt+1,n−1 = q
−m 2
(23) B ) −1 −iξk (Pt,n+1
Rk (Pt,n+1 )G−1 t−1,n+1 Rk (Pt,n+1 )
e
(24)
B ) −1 iξk (Pt,n−1
Rk (Pt,n−1 )Gt−1,n−1 Rk (Pt,n−1 ) e B B Rk (Pt,n−1 ) Rk (Pt,n+1 ) = Pt−1,n eiξk (Pt,n−1 ) e−iξk (Pt,n+1 ) Rk (q m Pt,n−1 ) Rk (q −m Pt,n+1 ) =: Et,n+1 Et,n−1 (Pt−1,n ),
(25)
P = {(P Now I2T 2T −1,2k )∈{0..p−1} , (P2T ,2k+1 )k∈{0..p−1} } (of course one could also P take I2T −1 ) is an initial configuration of unitary periodic (face) operators, i.e. Pt,2p+n = Pt,n ∈ A(PT ), n ∈ Z. These operators commute as:
[Pt,n , Pt,j ] = 0 n 6= j, [Pt±1,n , Pt,n+j ] = 0
for j ∈ {2...2p − 2}
mod 2p,
Pt,n Pt±1,n+1 = q −m Pt±1,n+1 Pt,n .
(26)
Consider the automorphism Et,n+1 Et,n−1 : A(PT ) → A(PT ) which was recursively defined by: Et,n+1 Et,n−1 (Pt−1,k ) : = Rk (Pt,n+1 )Rk (Pt,n−1 )Pt−1,n Rk (Pt,n−1 )−1 Rk (Pt,n+1 )−1 e
(27) B iξk (Pt,n−1 )
e
B −iξk (Pt,n+1 )
,
and Et,n+1 Et,n−1 acting trivially on all other faces along the corresponding Cauchy zig zag Ct . Since Pt+1,n = Et,n+1 Et,n−1 (Pt−1,n ),
124
N. Kutz
it follows by Definition (28) that : Rk (Pt+1,n ) B
B
= Rk (R(Pt,n+1 )Rk (Pt,n−1 )Pt−1,n Rk (Pt,n+1 )−1 Rk (Pt,n+1 )−1 eiξk (Pt,n−1 ) e−iξk (Pt,n+1 ) ) B
B
= Rk (Pt,n+1 )Rk (Pt,n−1 )Rk (eiξk (Pt,n−1 ) e−iξk (Pt,n+1 ) Pt−1,n )Rk (Pt,n−1 )−1 Rk (Pt,n+1 )−1 . (28) Define the operators (t ∈ Z) R2t−1 :=
p−1 Y
Rk (P2t−1,2n )
R2t :=
n=0
p−1 Y
Rk (P2t,2n+1 ).
n=0
Proposition 3.1. The operators Rt ∈ A(P ) defined as above evolve as: R2t+1 = R2t
p−1 Y
B
B
−1 Rk (eiξk (P2t,2n−1 ) e−iξk (P2t,2n+1 ) P2t−1,2n )R2t ,
n=0 p−1 Y
R2t = R2t−1
B
B
−1 Rk (eiξk (P2t−1,2n ) e−iξk (P2t−1,2n+2 ) P2t−2,2n+1 )R2t−1 .
n=0
Proof. Using the commutation relations in (26) and (28) and the periodicity of the face operators, the proof is straightforward. u t B
B
Corollary 3.2. If eiξk (Pt,n−1 ) e−iξk (Pt,n+1 ) = 11 for all t, x ∈ Z (k −t even) then Rt+1 Rt = Rt Rt−1 is constant. Since in this case the evolution for the face variables is given by conjugation −1 −1 Rt , Pt+1,n = Rt Rt−1 Pt−1,n Rt−1
the operator Rt Rt−1 can be viewed as the discrete analog of a continuous Hamiltonian time evolution, i.e. 1t0 fixed. Rt Rt−1 ↔ eiH 1t0 This is why we called the automorphism constructed in (20),(21) almost Hamiltonian. 4. The Quantum Discrete sine-Gordon Model 4.1. Constructing the evolution automorphism. Theorem 4.1. Let xˆ be an element of a ∗-algebra over C, such that x −1 = x ∗ and . . · x}ˆ is a multiple of the identity element 11 in the algebra, i.e. xˆ B = x B 11, xˆ B := |xˆ · .{z B times
with x B ∈ S 1 ⊂ C. Let k ∈ C, B = e
iξk
=e
iξk (xˆ B )
:=
N gcd(m,N ) , q
=e
2π i N
. Choose any root
1 + k¯ B x B (−1)B−1 B 11 ∈ S 1 11. k B + x B (−1)B−1 1
(29)
Free Massive Fermions Inside Discrete sine-Gordon Model
Define Rk (x) ˆ :=
PB−1
j =0 lj xˆ
j
125
with lj :=
j Y eiξk q m(n−1) − k¯ , 1 − eiξk kq mn
n=1
ˆ satisfies the equation: then Rk (x) ˆ = Rk (x)
k + xˆ Rk (q m x)e ˆ iξk . 1 + k¯ xˆ
(30)
Proof. By straightforward computation. u t ˆ a “dynamical R-matrix”. The above theorem is a generalization of the We call Rk (x) results found in [V] and [FZ], where it was assumed that xˆ B = 11. As it turns out generalizing to general central elements xˆ B is important for obtaining an evolution with nontrivial classical background as first described in [BBR], where a solution for Eq. (30) was indicated for the case m = 2, N = odd, k ∈ R. Solutions to Eq. (30) when q m is not a root of unity can also be found in [BBR]. For our purpose k ∈ [0, 1) from now on. B Unfortunately, despite the suggestive notation, the numbers eiξk (xˆ ) depend not only on the Casimirs xˆ B and the real constant k ∈ [0, 1), but also on the choice of a B th root. ˆ together Clearly, once a choice is made (for all times t) one can use the operators Rk (x) with the chosen roots (now viewed as functions in the central elements) for defining an almost Hamiltonian quantum evolution for the sine-Gordon model as in (20). B However, fixing the roots eiξk (xˆ ) for all time contradicts the idea of defining an evolution by a local process. In the following, we want to show that given an initial choice of roots, it is possible to define an unique evolution for the above roots. In order to accomplish this task, we will extend the algebra A(XT ) by the central elements B eiξk (PT ) . 4.2. Light cone shifts. The doubly discrete sine-Gordon equation, as well as the above described equations of sine-Gordon type (see e.g. (14)), are, as in the continuous case, invariant under light cone shifts. I.e. if gt,k : Z2 → R parametrizes a solution to (3) then gt±n,k±n gives also a solution. In this sense space time shifts can be lifted to automorphisms on covariant phase space and can be interpreted as symplectomorphisms [EK]. In the previous section, we found a quantization of another (yet trivial) symplectomorphism ([AM,GS]) on phase space, namely time evolution. It is now natural to find quantized analogs of the above mentioned light cone shifts. This will be done by defining quantized space translations for half the lattice spacing distance, and then applying the time automorphism. Since translations of half the lattice spacing distance are hard to define on the vertex operators, as one would have to go over to the dual lattice, we restrict ourself to the edge algebra A(XT ). It will be shown that space translations, or space shifts as automorphisms on the edge algebra A(XT ) are almost inner automorphisms. For constructing the space shifts, we will follow an idea developed in [FV3], where such space shifts were suggested for the case of a special choice of vertex monodromies. It will turn out that the treatment of the more general case gives us a natural way to fix B the roots eiξk (Pt,k−1 ) .
126
N. Kutz
Lemma 4.2. The quotient of the two vertex monodromies −1 −1 −1 P2t,2p−3 . . . P2t,1 M (1) (M (2) )−1 = P2t±1,0 P2t±1,2 . . . P2t±1,2p−2 P2t,2p−1 −2 2 2 2 = q −2mp+m X2t,0 X2t,1 X2t,2 . . . X2t,2p−1 MX −2 2 2 2 = q −2mp+m X2t+1,0 X2t+1,1 X2t+1,2 . . . X2t+1,2p−1 MX
is a central element in A(XT ). Demand 4.3. For establishing quantum space time shifts, demand that a) the central elements −1 −1 −1 P2t,2p−3 . . . P2t,1 M (1) (M (2) )−1 = P2t−1,0 P2t−1,2 . . . P2t−1,2p−2 P2t,2p−1 B and Pt,k−1 (B as in Theorem 4.1) shall be multiples of the identity within A(XT ). B
b) The roots eiξ0 (Pt,k−1 ) = (Pt,k−1 (−1)B−1 )− B (see 29) shall be fixed in such a way that 1
p−1 Y
B (P2t−1,2k (−1)B−1 ) B 1
k=0
p−1 Y
B (P2t,2k−1 (−1)B−1 )− B = 1
k=0
p−1 Y
P2t−1,2k
k=0
p−1 Y
−1 P2t,2k−1 .
k=0
By the definition of an almost Hamiltonian quantum evolution demand a) holds automatically for all times t if it is true at an initial time T . The same is valid for demand b) which will soon become clear. For this reason, the index t in the above demands refers to all times t. We are now in the position to define space shifts via products of dynamical R-matrices. Observe that the product is over 2p −1 faces. Figure 2 shows the involved faces (labeling in accordance with Fig. 1 for t = odd). Define St−1 : =
2p ← Y k=2
−1 R0 (Xt,k Xt,k−1 )
(31)
−1 −1 −1 Xt,2p−1 )R0 (Xt,2p−1 Xt,2p−2 ) . . . R0 (Xt,2 Xt,1 ) = R0 (Xt,2p
Pt,2 Xt,2
Xt,1 Pt−1,1
Pt,4
Xt,2p Pt−1,2p−1
Pt−1,3
Proposition 4.4. For all k ∈ Z, −1
B
St−1 Xt,k St = q −m eiξ0 ((Xt,k Xt,k−1 ) ) Xt,k−1 , where eiξ0 (x
B)
= (x B (−1)B−1 )− B as in (29). 1
Free Massive Fermions Inside Discrete sine-Gordon Model
127
Proof. For the proof, everything will be carried out at a fixed time and therefore we suppress the time index. If n ∈ {2 . . . 2p} then by the commutation rules of the edge variables St−1 Xt,n St = S −1 Xn S = =
2p ← Y
R0 (Xk−1 Xk−1 )Xn
k=n 2p ← Y
k=n+1
=
2p ← Y k=n+1
= q −m
R0 (Xk−1 Xk−1 )
k=n
R0 (Xk−1 Xk−1 )−1
R0 (Xn−1 Xn−1 )
R0 (q m Xn−1 Xn−1 )
R0 (Xk−1 Xk−1 )Xn−1 Xn−1 Xn
2p ← Y k=n+1
=q
2p → Y
R0 (Xk−1 Xk−1 )Xn−1
−m iξ0 ((Xn−1 Xn−1 )B )
e
2p → Y k=n+1
2p → Y k=n+1
2p → Y
Xn
k=n+1
R0 (Xk−1 Xk−1 )−1 −1 X
R0 (Xk−1 Xk−1 )−1 eiξ0 ((Xn
B n−1 ) )
−1 X B n−1 ) )
R0 (Xk−1 Xk−1 )−1 eiξ0 ((Xn
Xn−1 .
Analogously, one obtains S −1 X1 S = = = = =
2p ← Y k=3 2p ← Y
R0 (Xk−1 Xk−1 )X2−1 X12
2p → Y k=3
−1
R0 (Xk−1 Xk−1 )−1 eiξ0 ((X2
X1 )B )
2p → Y −1 R0 (X3−1 X2 ) B −1 2 R0 (Xk−1 Xk−1 ) X R0 (Xk−1 Xk−1 )eiξ0 ((X2 X1 ) ) X 1 2 −1 −m R0 (q X3 X2 ) k=4 k=4 2p → 2p ← Y Y −1 −1 B B R0 (Xk−1 Xk−1 )q 2m X3 X2−2 X12 R0 (Xk−1 Xk−1 )e−iξ0 ((X3 X2 ) )+iξ0 ((X2 X1 ) ) k=4 k=4 2p−1 2p Y 2(−1)k+1 Y −1 −1 k B B −1 q 2m(p−1) X2p Xk e(−1) iξ0 ((Xk Xk−1 ) ) eiξ0 ((X1 X0 ) ) k=1 k=1
b)
−1
= q −m eiξ0 ((X1
X0 )B )
X0 ,
(32)
t if we suppose that demand b) holds. With S −1 MX S = MX the assertion follows. u It is easy to show that (l)
−1
(l)
B
(St )−1 Xt,n St = q −m eiξ0 ((Xt,n Xt,n−1 ) ) Xt,n−1 , where (l)
(St )−1 : =
2p+l Y← k=2+l
−1 R0 (Xt,k Xt,k−1 ).
128
N. Kutz (l)
(0)
Therefore the index l is irrelevant and will be dropped, also if (St )−1 instead of (St )−1 is used. Clearly, one can also define an automorphism of the above kind by redefining Sˆt−1 : =
2p+l Y← k=2+l
−1 R0 (αXt,k Xt,k−1 )
α ∈ S1,
which will act as: −1
B Sˆt−1 Xt,n Sˆt = αq −m eiξ0 ((Xt,n Xt,n−1 ) ) Xt,n−1 ,
a fact we will use later. The automorphism S−1 t : A(XT ) → A(XT ) defined on the operators Xt,n as −1
B
m −iξ0 ((Xt,n Xt,n−1 ) ) −1 St Xt,n St = Xt,n−1 S−1 t (Xt,n ) := q e
can be interpreted as a shift on the edge operators in a space direction. The picture of the action of S−1 t is a little different for an automorphism on A(PT ), we find B
B
St−1 Pt,k−1 St = Pt−1,k−2 e−iξ0 (Pt,k−1 ) + eiξ0 (Pt−1,k−2 ) , B
B
St−1 Pt−1,k−2 St = Pt,k−3 e−iξ0 (Pt−1,k−2 ) + eiξ0 (Pt,k−3 ) . Hence applying St to face operators with the same time index t results in a shift down in the light cone direction and applying St to face operators with time index t − 1 results in a shift up in the lightcone direction. Hence St is rather an up-and-down shift in lightcone directions than rather a shift in space: PT +1,k
PT +1,k ST +1 PT ,k−1 ST
ST +1 PT ,k+1
Et
ST +1 PT ,k+1
ST PT −1,k
S PT −1,kT
Figure 2.1
Figure 2.2
Fix an initial time for example T = odd. Then, by definition, the operators ST−1 = R0 (PT −1,2p−1 )R0 (PT ,2p−2 ) . . . R0 (PT −1,1 ),
ST−1+1 = R0 (PT +1,2p−1 )R0 (PT ,2p−2 ) . . . R0 (PT +1,1 )
are given by the choice of initial operators (PT −1,2k+1 )k∈{0...p−1} , (PT ,2k )k∈{0...p−1} and the time evolved face operators (PT +1,2k+1 )k∈{0...p−1} . The operator PT +1,2k+1 can now be obtained by shifting the operator PT ,2k or by applying the time evolution to PT −1,2k+1 , i.e. the shifts depictured in Fig. 2.2 must commute. By the commutation relations of the face operators, it is a straightforward result that:
Free Massive Fermions Inside Discrete sine-Gordon Model
129
Lemma 4.5. R0 (PT +1,2p−1 )R0 (PT ,2p−2 ) . . . R0 (PT +1,1 ) B
B
= RT R0 (e−iξ0 (PT ,2p )+iξ0 (PT ,2p−2 ) PT −1,2p−1 )R0 (PT ,2p−2 ) B
B
. . . R0 (e−iξ0 (PT ,2 )+iξ0 (PT ,0 ) PT −1,1 )RT−1 . Hence B
!
B
ST−1+1 PT ,2n ST +1 = PT +1,2n−1 e−iξ0 (PT ,2n )+iξ0 (PT +1,2n−1 ) B
B
= RT R0 (e−iξ0 (PT ,2p )+iξ0 (PT ,2p−2 ) PT −1,2p−1 )R0 (PT ,2p−2 )
4.5
B
B
. . . R0 (e−iξ0 (PT ,2 )+iξ0 (PT ,0 ) PT −1,1 )PT ,2k B
B
(RT R0 (e−iξ0 (PT ,2p )+iξ0 (PT ,2p−2 ) PT −1,2p−1 )R0 (PT ,2p−2 ) B
B
. . . R0 (e−iξ0 (PT ,2 )+iξ0 (PT ,0 ) PT −1,1 ))−1 B
= RT PT −1,2n−1 RT−1−1 e−iξ0 (PT ,2n )+iξ0 ((e B
−iξk (PTB,2n )+iξk (PTB,2n−2 )
PT −1,2n−1 )B )
B
e−iξk (PT ,2n )+iξk (PT ,2n−2 ) B
= PT +1,2n−1 e−iξ0 (PT ,2n )+iξ0 ((e
−iξk (PTB,2n )+iξk (PTB,2n−2 )
PT −1,2n−1 )B )
.
Comparing both sides of the equation, one finally obtains the compatibility condition: B
!
B
B
B
eiξ0 (PT +1,2n−1 ) = e−iξk (PT ,2n )+iξk (PT ,2n−2 ) eiξ0 (PT −1,2n−1 ) .
(33)
For defining the evolution, we had already fixed the roots on the right-hand side of Eq. (33), so that Eq. (33) determines the roots at one time step further for k = 0. So B a continuous deformation of k defines the roots eξk (Pt,k−1 ) for all k ∈ [0, 1). Hence, B also the evolution of the roots eiξk (Pt,k−1 ) have been now defined by a local process. A direct consequence of Eq. (33) is that demand b) holds for all time since the classical monodromies are as well as their quantum counterparts integrals of motion [K]. Note that if one takes the B th power of Eq. (33) then one obtains PTB+1,2n−1 =
k B + PTB,2n (−1)B−1 1 + k B PTB,2n−2 (−1)B−1
1 + k B PTB,2n (−1)B−1 k B + PTB,2n−2 (−1)B−1
PTB−1,2n−1 .
B satisfy also an equation of sine-Gordon type. This Hence the “classical” variables Pt,k fact was first noted in [BBR] by using the commutation relations of the face operators and computing PTB+1,2k−1 . It is now straightforward to show that, as an immediate consequence,
ST +1 (XT +1,k ) = ET ◦ ST ◦ ET−1 (XT +1,k ), i.e. shifts in time and space direction commute if (33) is satisfied. The picture of the above developed quantum evolution looks considerably complicated. It simplifies greatly, if one restricts oneself to the case of Corollary (3.2):
130
N. Kutz
Proposition 4.6. Let ST be an automorphism on A(XT ) such that at an initial time T , RT = ST (RT −1 ) = S−1 T (RT −1 ),
(34)
Rt+1 = Rt Rt−1 Rt−1 ,
(35)
where recursively then Rt = RT ST (Rt−1 )RT−1 for all t ∈ Z ≥ T . Proof. By (34) and (35), RT = RT ST (RT −1 )RT−1 ,
(36)
RT +1 =
(37)
RT ST (RT )RT−1 .
For completing the induction argument, assume that the following is true: RT +n = RT ST (RT −1+n )RT−1 ,
RT +1+n = RT ST (RT +n )RT−1 .
(38) (39)
Hence RT +n+2
(35)
=
(38,39)
=
(35)
=
RT +n+1 RT +n RT−1+n+1 , RT ST (RT +n )RT−1 RT ST (RT −1+n )RT−1 (RT ST (RT +n )RT−1 )−1 , RT ST (RT +n+1 )RT−1 ,
and analogously RT +n+3
(39,40)
=
(40)
RT ST (RT +n+2 )RT−1 . u t
Proposition 4.7. If ST is an automorphism such at initial time T , XT ,k = ST (XT ,k−1 ) = S−1 T (XT ,k+1 )
and Xt+1,k = Rt Xt,k Rt−1
for all t ∈ N, and with Rt as in Proposition (4.6), then Xt+1,k = RT ST (Xt,k−1 )RT−1 . Proof. By induction as above and by the use of Proposition (4.6). u t The connection to models of statistical mechanics is now evident. We find −1 −1 Xt+2,k+1 = RT S−1 T (RT ST (Xt,k+1 )RT )RT
−1 −1 −1 = RT S−1 T (RT )Xt,k+1 ST (RT )RT .
(41)
Moreover, RT is a product of “local amplitudes” R(PT ,k−1 ) associated to the faces at time T within the light cone lattice. Hence S−1 T (RT ) is a product of “local amplitudes” R(Pt,k−1 ) associated to faces which are shifted in the lightcone direction. Because of (41), this picture is the same all over the lattice, hence we can interpret RT as a kind of transfer matrix (though with complex weights). Another fortunate consequence is that for investigating the evolution it suffices to control the first time step - everything else is then obtained by applying the light cone shifts ET ◦ ST . This is especially important for the construction of integrals of motion, since finding an operator HT , that commutes with the above light cone shifts automatically yields an integral of motion. In the next section an example of such a “static” quantum field theory will be discussed.
Free Massive Fermions Inside Discrete sine-Gordon Model
131
5. Relations to the Massive Thirring Model Choose an initial time T = odd. Let 1 0 01 10 B= , S= , C= . 0 −1 10 0i
(42)
The notation is adopted from viewing B as a “Boost” and S as a “Shift” operator. Note that CBSC −1 = −iS. CSC −1 = −iBS, B, S, C are operators acting on the Hilbert space H = C2 . Define for any operator A on N2p−1 H an operator Al on a “big” Hilbert space H2p = k=0 C2 by Al =
⊗ 11 . . . |{z} A . . . 11 ⊗ |{z} 11 .
11 |{z} 2p−1th
l th site
site
Let C: =
2p−1 Y
0th site
Cl .
l=0
Define XT ,2k : = S2k
2k−1 Y←
Bl = S2k B2k−1 . . . B0 ,
(43)
l=0
XT ,2k+1 : = −B2k+1 S2k+1
2k ← Y
Bl ,
(44)
l=0
MX : = 11 ⊗ 11 . . . ⊗ 11,
(45)
where XT ,0 = S0 . Denote shortly BS2k+1 : = B2k+1 S2k+1 . The above defined operators satisfy the commutation relations of the edge operators XT ,k XT ,k+1 = q −m XT ,k+1 XT ,k ,
XT ,k MX = q −2m MX XT ,k
for q −m = −1. They are periodic and XT2 ,2k = 11 XT2 ,2k+1 = −11.
(46)
The corresponding face operators are almost all bilocal in terms of the tensor product: PT ,2k := XT−1,2k+1 XT ,2k = BS2k+1 BS2k for k ∈ {0 . . . p − 1},
PT −1,2k+1 := XT−1,2k+2 XT ,2k+1 = −S2k+2 S2k+1 for k ∈ {0 . . . p − 2},
PT −1,2p−1 = BS2p−1
2p−2 Y
Bl BS0 ,
l=1
and
PT2,2k = PT2−1,2k+1 = 11.
132
N. Kutz
The difference of the vertex monodromies is −1 p−1 11. P2T −1,2p−1 . . . PT −1,1 PT−1 ,0 . . . PT ,2p−2 = (−1) B
For defining the shift automorphism ST we fix the roots eiξ0 (iPt,n )) (t ∈ {T , T − 1}, n ∈ {0 . . . 2p − 1}) as: e
iξ0 (iPTB,2n ))
=e
iξk (iPTB,2n ))
1 + k 2 (iPT ,2n )2 (−1) k 2 + (iPt,n )2 (−1)
=
21
:= 11,
n ∈ {0 . . . p − 1}, and analogously B
eiξk (iPT −1,2n+1 )) = 11,
n ∈ {0 . . . p − 1}
for all k ∈ [0, 1). Note that with this definition B
B
−1 p−1 −iξ0 (iPT −1,2p−1 )) e . . . e−iξ0 (iPT −1,0 )) PT −1,2p−1 . . . PT −1,1 PT−1 ,0 . . . PT ,2p−2 = (−1) B
B
eiξ0 (iPT ,0 )) . . . eiξ0 (iPT ,2p−2 )) , and hence we have to be careful when defining the shift automorphism (compare with (32)). Let 1 − k2 2k , b = −i , c: = 1 + k2 1 + k2 then using (4.1) and normalizing, the local amplitudes are a straightforward result: Rk (iPT ,2n ) = √
i (b + (1 − c)PT ,2n ). 2(1 − c)
They obey the functional equations: k + iPT ,2n Rk (iPT ,2n ) . = Rk (−iPT ,2n ) 1 + kiPT ,2n The evolution for the edge operators to the next time step is given by XT +1,n =
RT XT ,n RT−1
where RT =
p−1 Y
Rk (iPT ,2l ).
l=0
The shift matrix shall be given by: ST−1 : = R0 (iPT ,2p−2 )R0 (iPT −1,2p−3 ) . . . R0 (iPT −1,1 )R0 (iP2T ,0 ), which defines the following shift automorphism on the edge algebra: −1 S−1 T (XT ,n ) := iST XT ,n ST = XT ,n−1 ,
S−1 T (XT ,0 )
:=
i(−1)p−1 ST−1 XT ,0 ST
n ∈ {1 . . . 2p − 1},
= XT ,2p−1 .
Free Massive Fermions Inside Discrete sine-Gordon Model
133
Lemma 5.1. The matrices CPT ,2n C−1 and CPT ,2n+1 C−1 (n ∈ {0 . . . p − 1}) commute with all generators ITX = (XT ,n )n∈{0..2p} of A(XT ). Hence RT CRT C−1 ST−1 CST−1 C−1 (XT ,n − iCXT ,n C−1 )CST C−1 ST CRT−1 C−1 RT−1
= RT ST−1 XT ,n ST RT−1 − iCRT ST−1 XT ,n ST RT−1 C−1
−1 −1 −1 −1 = −i(RT S−1 T (XT ,n )RT − iCRT ST (XT ,n )RT C ),
n ∈ {1 . . . p − 1}, analogous for XT ,0 . Clearly this defines lightcone shifts on the operators n−1
ψT ,n+1 : =
Y 1 (XT ,n − iCXT ,n C−1 ) = σn− σlz , 2 l=0
i.e. ˜ T S˜ T (XT ,n )R ˜ −1 ψT +1,n+1 : = R T with n ∈ {0 . . . p − 1}, −1 −1 −1 −1 S˜ −1 T (ψT ,n ): = iST CST C ψT ,n ST CST C ,
˜ T : = RT CRT C−1 , R and σ
−
=
00 10
σ z = B.
The shift matrices ST and ST−1 , as well as the evolution matrix RT , are products of bilocal operators, = 11 ⊗ . . . Rk (iBS ⊗ BS) . . . ⊗ 11, n ∈ {0 . . . p − 1}, Rk (iPT ,2n ) Rk (iPT −1,2n+1 ) = 11 ⊗ . . . Rk (−iS ⊗ S) . . . ⊗ 11, n ∈ {0 . . . p − 2}. ˜ T and S˜T . A straightforward computation gives Hence the same holds for R Rk (iBS ⊗ BS)CRk (iBS ⊗ BS)C−1 = Rk (iBS ⊗ BS)Rk (−iS ⊗ S) 1000 0 c b 0 . . . ⊗ 11 = = 11 ⊗ . . . 0 b c 0 0001 = Rk (−iS ⊗ S)CRk (−iS ⊗ S)C−1 . The shift matrices S˜T−1 = R˜ 0 (iPT ,2p−2 )R˜ 0 (iPT −1,2p−3 )R˜ 0 (iPT ,2p−4 ) . . . R˜ 0 (iPT ,0 )
134
N. Kutz
act on the fermionic operators ψT ,k as S˜T−1 ψT ,2n S˜T = = R˜ 0 (iPT ,2n−2 )ψT ,2n R˜ 0 (iPT ,2n−2 )−1 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 −i 0 − 0 z = (σ ⊗ σ2n−2 ) 0 −i 0 0 2n−1 0 0 0 0 1 0 − = −i(112n−1 ⊗ σ2n−2 )
2n−3 Y l=0
= −iψT ,2n−1 ,
0 0 i 0
0 i 0 0
0 2n−3 0 Y z σl 0 l=0 1
σlz (47)
n ∈ {0 . . . p − 1}. In a similar way we have S˜T−1 ψT ,2n+1 S˜T = −iψT ,2n n ∈ {1 . . . p − 1}, S˜T−1 ψT ,1 S˜T = i(−1)p ψT ,2p , so that finally ˜ −1 ˜ = ψT ,n−1 S˜ −1 T (ψT ,n ) = i ST ψT ,n ST ˜S−1 (ψT ,1 ) = i(−1)p−1 S˜ −1 ψT ,n S˜T = ψT ,2p , T T
n ∈ {2 . . . 2p}
which is identical to the shift automorphism constructed in [DV]. Following (4.6,4.7) we know that the construction of the shift automorphism S˜ and the evolution automorphism given by the conjugation with R˜ is sufficient for constructing a Hamiltonian quantum evolution in the sense of the previous sections. Finally comparing with the construction in [DV] one finds that the fermionic operators obey an evolution of free massive fermions. The evolution equations can be derived easily by considering the evolution for the edge variables. Recalling (46), one finds: Xt+1,2k : = Rt Xt,2k Rt−1 =
−1 −1 Xt,2k 1 − kiXt,2k+1 Xt,2k k + iXt,2k+1
Xt,2k −1 −1 1 − kiXt,2k+1 Xt,2k 1 − kiXt,2k+1 Xt,2k 1 −1 = (2k + i(1 − k 2 )Xt,2k+1 Xt,2k )Xt,2k 1 + k2 = cXt,2k + bXt,2k+1 ,
(48)
and analogously for Xt+1,2k+1 . Since these equations are linear, the evolution equations for the fermionic operators follow immediately: ψt+1,2n−1 = cψt,2n−1 + bψt,2n , ψt+1,2n = cψt,2n + bψt,2n−1 .
(49) (50)
Free Massive Fermions Inside Discrete sine-Gordon Model
135
5.1. Conclusion. In the present paper a generalized model of a lattice field theory of sine Gordon type at root of unity was suggested. One aim was to stress the purely local character of the evolution automorphism and another was to finally derive global features like constant transfer matrices – and hence a connection to models in statistical mechanics by restricting to a special case (Propositions 4.6 and 4.7). Since the classical phase space belonging to the evolution of the face variables (current variables) is a torus T 2p , the corresponding quantum model can be viewed as a type of quantization of this torus. Hence, a future project should be the investigation of the above within the framework of noncommutative geometry