Commun. Math. Phys. 191, 1 – 13 (1998)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics c Springer-Verlag 1998
Classification and Construction of Quantum Communication Systems ¨ Bernd Muller Institut f¨ur theoretische Physik, Universit¨at T¨ubingen, Auf der Morgenstelle 14, 72076 T¨ubingen, Germany. E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 5 September 1995 / Accepted: 5 November 1996
Abstract: We consider Quantum Communication Systems (QCS’s), introduced by Davies [10] on trace class operators, on general state spaces. These are different from the usual quantum information theory as they deal with input and output being continuous in time. We introduce the concept of a refinement of a QCS, offering the possibility of distinguishing particles, for instance according to their phase or location, and classify refinements of general QCS. We then introduce the notions of a bounded interaction rate and a bounded modulation and give, in special cases, a classification of QCS’s satisfying both conditions. As this classification shows the existence of a class of QCS’s being completely different from the examples studied by Davies, we are able to discuss the cases of an independent detector and a linear modulation. 1. Introduction In classical communication theory the transmission of information is described by means of a Markov kernel P connecting the input and the output system [2], i.e. the input signal w ∈ X (the set of all input signals) leads to a probability distribution E → P (w, E) on the set of possible outputs. Usually one considers the input as generated randomly, so instead of using one signal w ∈ X one takes a probability distribution µ on X. Then µ is transformed into a probability distribution ν on via the formula Z P (w, E)µ(dw). ν(E) = X
In many cases the set of measures on X or is the dual of the C ∗ -algebra C(X) or C() of the continuous complex valued functions on X or , respectively. Then the above map 3∗ : µ → 3∗ µ := ν is the dual of a (completely) positive map 3 : C() → C(X). This definition in terms of C ∗ -algebras and completely positive maps shows an obvious way to generalize the notion of a communication channel to the non-commutative case.
2
B. M¨uller
The use of general W ∗ - or C ∗ -algebras instead of abelian ones is supposed to take into account the quantum mechanical nature of the physical system which is used for signal transmission. This includes a quantum mechanical formulation of information, (relative) entropy and in particular of the transition kernel P [1, 16, 17, 19–22]. The non-commutative analogue to a message, consisting of the letters a1 , . . . , an then is the transmission of a sequence of states ρ1 , . . . , ρn , which is transformed by the channel into a sequence ω1 , . . . , ωn of output states [13]. The transformation ρi → ωi = 3∗ ρi here is the non-commutative generalization of a Markov kernel. In applications the problem is the identification of the states ωi . This can only be done by means of a measurement, the result of which by definition is classical. So by fixing one type of measurement we still have a classical Markov kernel from input to output, which is also the case in the approach presented below, where the measurement always is a counting experiment. The physical situation we look at in this paper is partly different and not covered by the above considerations. In applications one often wants to transmit a signal function w that is continuous or piecewise continuous in time. This is to be achieved by the modulation of the light beam, which is caused by the input system. The light beam itself is described by a state of the photon system. This implies that a possible input is not a discrete chain of letters or (by use of a quantum code ai → ρi ) states, but a real valued function. However, we emphasize that it is possible to restrict the attention to functions that are constant on the time intervals [nc, (n+1)c) and only take values out of a finite set {a1 , . . . , an }. c represents the time necessary for the transmission of one signal ai , and a1 , . . . , an are the possible letters. This restriction shows that a digital (binary) signal transmission is included in the class of models described below. The way the modulating system influences the state is not specified a priori, yet it is proved in 4.2 that, under some additional assumptions, it can always be formulated as a time dependent perturbation of the interaction free dynamics (cf. Eq. (16)). To give a physical example, we think of a light beam entering a modulating system that influences the light. The modulating system for instance is a semiconductor crystal whose transmission coefficient and refraction index at time t are a function of the value w(t) of the signal w that is to be transmitted. If H is the free Hamiltonian of the photon system, the dynamics of the modulated light might be described by ∂ ρt = −i[H, ρt ] + B(w(t))ρt , (1) ∂t where B(w(t)) contains the influence of the modulating system. The above equation assumes that the state ρ is a trace class operator on some Hilbert space H. We remark that, in the sequel, we use a general state space (for instance a predual space of a W ∗ algebra). That way classical features of the light beam can be described as well [15]. At the other end of the channel the receiver performs a measurement on the state “arriving there”. Usually, one considers a number measurement to count the arriving quanta, though, in general this is not necessary. However, most authors do not take into account that, because of the continuity in time, such a measurement cannot be described by a selfadjoint operator on some Hilbert space, in particular not by only taking the spectral decomposition of the Fock number operator in order to get the relevant observable. In this paper we use the theory of counting experiments developed in [6, 9, 10, 18], where the detecting operation itself is assumed to be a quantum stochastic process. So both input and output are continuous in time, and thus it is not at all clear if the resulting channel is memoryless, which is, though not always physically justified, an assumption made implicitly in many articles by only considering the transmission of one letter. However, it is nevertheless possible in models of the type described below to get a memoryless channel, which will be shown in future work. The main advantage of this
Classification and Construction of Quantum Communication Systems
3
approach is, that it can easily be applied in practice. The use of the powerful theory of open systems [7, 9] reduces very efficiently the set of parameters that have to be taken into account. Though it lacks the generality of the investigations on completely positive channels made for instance in [22], the restriction to the special class of counting experiments allows to get a very concrete meaning of any part of the channel and thus easily shows how to construct physical models. And, we remark that because of the possibility of distinguishing particles according to phase, location, energy, . . . (see 3.1), this restriction is not as strong as one might guess. The paper is organized as follows: In Sect. 2 we give the basic definitions – including the one of a quantum communication system (QCS) – which all go back to Davies [10]. For technical reasons the definition given in [10] differs slightly from Definition 2.1. In particular it is shown how to calculate the transition kernel (Eq. (2)). The connections between systems that can distinguish particles (for instance according to energy, phase or location) and systems that can not are studied in Sect. 3. As for counting processes (CP’s, cf. [18]) we call the corresponding constructions coarse–grainings or refinements. In Theorem 3.1 we give a classification of refinements which generally allows to construct a QCS in two steps: First, one has to construct a one point QCS (i.e. a QCS that cannot distinguish particles) and then it can be refined. In Sect. 4 we introduce the ideas of a bounded interaction rate (for CP’s cf. [6, 8, 9, 18]) and a bounded modulation, and call a QCS bounded if both conditions are fulfilled. For a bounded one point QCS having an interaction free semigroup St (2.2) of type R [18] it is shown in Theorem 4.2 that the QCS always can be formulated via the perturbation theoretic equations (10), (11). This implies that Eq. (1), which so far only seems to be a physically reasonable example, can be derived from rather principal considerations, condensed in Definition 2.1. Conversely Theorem 4.3 implies that (10) and (11) always define a QCS. In particular there is an interaction rate operator J(c) (cf. the results for CP’s [10, 18]). Yet J(c) can depend on a real parameter c. In Proposition 4.4 we show that any decomposition of J(c), i.e. a positive operator valued measure (POVM) J(c, .) on a standard Borel space (X, Σ) with J(c, X) = J(c), defines a refinement of the corresponding QCS. For physical applications this implies that one only has to determine the operators J(c, E) (characterizing the instaneous change of state when a particle of type E is detected) in order to get a refinement of a QCS. Finally in Sect. 5 we introduce two important classes: QCS’s with linear modulation and QCS’s with an independent detector. For the first class it is shown that the modulation operators have to be generators of groups of isometries. Both classes are interesting from the physical point of view and we remark that Davies [10] only studied QCS’s satisfying both conditions. 2. Definition of a QCS The first point we are interested in is the set characterizing the input. As we want to have a model respecting the continuity of time, the messages are supposed to be functions of the time. We thus define Yt to be the set of functions w : [0, t) → R, where w is continuous from the right and has finite limits from the left at any point of the interval. For t = ∞ we additionally require that w is bounded. We consider two topologies on Yt : The first one is the uniform topology, the second one is defined by the Skorohod metric d [23]. Important is that the set of step functions is dense in Yt for both topologies. As one can send one message immediately after another one, we introduce the map v(r), r ∈ [0, t) β s,t : Ys × Yt → Ys+t , β s,t (w, v)(r) = w(r − t), r ∈ [t, t + s).
4
B. M¨uller
Usually the indices s, t are neglected and we use β(w, v) or even w × v instead of β s,t (w, v). In the sequel we often will vary t but have a fixed message w. This means that we use one message w ∈ Y∞ and only consider the restrictions of w to the interval [0, t). The output of the communication system shall be produced by a detection system counting the arriving quanta. Thus we use the following notations, introduced in the theory of counting processes [6, 18]: Atn Cnt
:= :=
{((x1 , t1 ), . . . , (xn , tn ))|0 ≤ t1 < . . . < tn < t, xi ∈ X}, {(t1 , . . . , tn )|0 ≤ t1 < . . . < tn < t},
for n ∈ N. Any point of the measurable space (X, Σ) is characterizing a certain type (energy, location, . . .) of particle. The output ((x1 , t1 ), . . . , (xn , tn )) ∈ Atn therefore means that a particle of type xi has been detected at time ti . The event that no particle has been detected during the time interval [0, t) we denote by zt , which is independent from (X, Σ). Therefore C0t = At0 := {zt } and Xt := Un≥0 Atn is the set of possible outputs. Again the possibility of recording two sequences after each other corresponds to a map λ : Xt × Xs → Xt+s defined by (((x1 , t1 ), . . . , (xn , tn )), ((y1 , s1 ), . . . , (ym , sm ))) → ((y1 , s1 ), . . . , (ym , sm ), (s1 , t1 + s), . . . , (sn , tn + s)). The physical channel (for a mathematical realization see Eq. (2)) connecting Yt and Xt for instance may be the quantized electromagnetic field, described by its state ω. More general the set of states of a physical transmission system forms a state space (V, K, τ ), i.e. V is a base normed space with positive cone K, and τ ∈ V ∗ equals the norm on K [7, 9, 12]. Measurements generally are described by means of an instrument. Given a state space, an instrument by definition is a positive operator valued measure (POVM) E: 0 → B+ (V), where (, 0) is the set of possible measurement outputs, satisfying E()∗ τ = τ (for definitions and the necessity of these notations, see [7, 18]). It is important that the probability of a measurement result in A ∈ is given by hE(A)ω, τ i = ||E(A)ω||. if the system is in the normalized state ω ∈ K = V+ (||ω|| = hω, τ i = 1) at the beginning of the measurement, and afterwards the system is in the state E(A)ω. In the above situation any measurement (and henceforth the corresponding instrument) depends on the message w and the time t up to which it is performed. This leads to the following definition: Definition 2.1. A quantum communication system (QCS)is a family of instruments Et (ω, ·) on Xt such that (i) limt↓0 Et (w, Xt )ω = ω in norm for all ω ∈ V and w ∈ Y∞ . (ii) w → Et (w, E) is weakly measurable and even weakly continuous for E = Xt . (iii) Et (w, E)Es (v, F ) = Et+s (w × v, λ(E × F )) for w ∈ Yt , v ∈ Ys and measurable E ⊆ Xt , F ⊆ Xs . We use the uniform topology in (ii) to define the σ-field on Yt . We could also take the Skorohod metric, but as the uniform continuity in most cases is easier to verify we use the weaker condition. Recall that for hω, τ i = ||ω|| = 1 the probability for having an output in the set E ⊆ Xt , provided that the message w is sent, is given by hEt (w, E)ω, τ i. In
Classification and Construction of Quantum Communication Systems
5
this case the state of the channel directly after the measurement has been transformed into Et (w, E)ω. Therefore (iii) expresses that the time evolution has no memory and is homogeneous. Now for any normalized ω ∈ V+ the map (w, E) → hEt (w, E)ω, τ i =: Pt (w, E)
(2)
is a probability transition kernel from Yt to Xt . Therefore for any choice of ω this map defines a channel in the sense of classical communication theory. Note that the above Markov property (iii) of the time evolution does not imply that this channel is memoryless in the sense of communication theory. Remarks 2.2. (i) If g: R → R is continuous and Et is a QCS, then (E, w) → Et (g ◦ w, E) defines another QCS. (ii) For any constant function, i.e. w(t) ≡ c the family Et (c, .) defines a counting process [6]. w w := Et (w, {zt }) and St+s,s := Et (αs (w), {zt }), (iii) We use the following notations: St,0 w where αs (w)(r) := w(s + r). For 0 ≤ s < t St,s is the interaction free dynamics according to w. For any constant c the family Stc := Et (c, {zt }) is a semigroup. 3. Coarse-Grainings and Refinements If the detector counts the particles without distinguishing them, the space (X, Σ) consists of one point only and Atn is isomorphic to Cnt . In this case we call the corresponding QCS a one point QCS. Let us consider a general QCS Et with measurable (X, Σ). It is obvious that via the projection [ Cnt , ((x1 , t1 ), . . . , (xn , tn )) → (t1 , . . . , tn ) π: Xt → n≥0
the QCS Et is transformed into a one point QCS E˜t , where E˜t is defined by E˜t (w, E) = Et (w, π −1 (E)). Physically this corresponds to the neglection of the possibility of distinguishing particles and we therefore call the resulting one point QCS E˜t the coarsegraining of Et . In most cases the inverse way is more important, as one point QCS can often be constructed by use of semigroup theory (cf. next section). Given a one point QCS E˜t the possibility of distinguishing particles corresponds to a refinement of E˜t . In other words: a refinement of E˜t is another QCS Et with measurable space (X, Σ) whose coarse-graining coincides with E˜t . Let Et be such a refinement of E˜t , then obviously the w of both QCS is the same. Moreover it is interaction free dynamics St,s Et (w, X × [0, t)) = E˜t (w, [0, t))
and
w w Et (w, E × [a, b)) = St,b Eb−a (αa (w), E × [0, b − a))Sa,0
(3) (4)
for all E ∈ Σ and 0 < a < b < t. The subsequent theorem shows that these equations essentially are enough to construct a refinement. In the sequel we will often have to deal with sets of the form A = (E1 × [a1 , b1 )) × · · · × (En × [an , bn )),
(5)
6
B. M¨uller
P where Ei ∈ and 0 ≤ a1 < b1 < · · · < an < bn < t. Obviously A is a measurable t set in An . We call a finite union of sets of this form a standard set. The standard sets are closed under the formation of finite intersections and generate the σ-field on Atn . Note that it is sufficient to give a QCS on At1 (and At0 ) as the Markov property then determines the QCS on standard sets and henceforth on general sets. Theorem 3.1. Let (X, Σ) be a standard Borel space and E˜t a one point QCS. Then there is a 1:1-correspondence between the following classes: (i) Refinements Et of E˜t with measurable space (x, Σ). (ii) POVM’s Gt (w, .) on X × [0, t) = At1 (Gt (w, E) ∈ B+ (V)) such that (a) w → Gt (w, E) is weakly measurable, (b) Gt (w, X × [0, t)) = E˜t (w, [0, t)) . w w Gb−a (αa (w), E × [0, b − a))Sa,0 for E ∈ Σ and (c) Gt (w, E × [a, b)) = St,b 0 < a < b < t. The correspondence is given by Et (w, A) = Gt (w, A) for measurable A ⊆ X × [0, t) . Proof. The main idea of the proof is the same as in the corresponding proof for CP’s [18], but as the situation here is much more complicated the details need a closer look. The formal bijective map between Gt and Et is given by Gt (w, A) := Et (w, A) for measurable A ⊆ X × [0, t), i.e., Gt is the restriction of Et on the measurable subsets of At1 ⊆ Xt . To show the bijectivity of the map it is obviously enough to show that it is possible to construct Et whenever Gt is given. For fixed t we subdivide the interval [0, t) k n in 2n disjoint intervals Ikn := [ k−1 2n t, 2n t) for k = 1, . . . , 2 and restrict our attention to the set 3ln := {x = ((x1 , t1 ), . . . , (xl , tl )) ∈ Atl | xi ∈ X, for each k there is at most one ti ∈ Ikn }. It is easy to verify that 3ln ⊆ 3ln+1 and Un≥0 3ln = Atl . We say a map φ : {1, . . . , 2n } → {0, 1} is in Qln , iff cardφ−1 ({1}) = l. For each φ ∈ Qln we define Pφ := {ψ ∈ Qln+1 | for each k ∈ φ−1 (1) there is one and only one l ∈ {2k − 1, 2k} with ψ(l) = 1}. Obviously the Pφ are pairwise disjoint. Now let M0n := {zt/2n }, M1n := X × [0, t/2n ), and for n n × · · · × λ(Mφ(2n ) × Mφ(1) ) . . .). If X = {1} we use each φ ∈ Qln let Aφ := λ(Mπ(2n) l l ˜ n instead of 3n . It is easy to verify that Aφ = ∪ψ∈Pφ Aψ and Bφ instead of Aφ and 3
3ln = ∪φ∈Qln Aφ , where the Aφ are pairwise disjoint. The σ-algebra on Aφ is generated n by sets of the form E = λ(E2n × · · · × E1 ) with measurable sets Ei ⊆ Mφ(i) . For these sets we define µ˜ φ (w, E) = Gt,(2n −1)t/2n (w, E2n ) · · · Gt/2n ,0 (w, E1 ), w and Gb,a (w, {zr }) = Sb,a . Then where Gb,a (w, E) = Gb−a (αa (w), E) for E ⊆ Ab−a 1 Q2 n using the fact that i=1 Mφ(i) is Borel isomorphic to Aφ it follows by [7, Theorem 2] that E → µ˜ φ (w, E) can be extended to a POVM on Aφ . Now it is a technical but straightforward calculation, that for measurable E ⊆ Aφ holds: X µ˜ φ (w, E) = µ˜ ψ (w, E ∩ Aψ ).
Thus the definition µln (w, E) := erates a POVM on Atl satisfying
P
ψ∈Pφ φ∈Qln
µ˜ φ (w, E ∩ Aφ ) for measurable E ⊆ Atl gen-
Classification and Construction of Quantum Communication Systems
7
(i) µln+1 (w, E) = µln (w, E) for measurable E ⊆ 3ln , (ii) µln (w, Clt ) = µln (w, 3ln ). The last equation holds as 3ln is the disjoint union of the Aφ and µln by definition is concentrated on this union. In particular we have µln+1 (w, E) ≥ µln (w, E) for all measurable E ⊆ Atl . Moreover for a standard set E = (E1 ×[a1 , b1 ))×· · ·×(El ×[al , bl )) a direct calculation shows that E ⊆ 3ln for sufficient large n and then w Gbl −al (αal (w), El ) · · · Gb1 −a1 (αa1 (w), E1 )Saw1 ,0 . µln (E) = St,b l
(6)
Now by definition one calculates X µln (w, Aφ ) = E˜t (w, ∪φ∈Qln Bφ ) ≤ E˜t (w, Clt ). µln (w, Atl ) = l φ∈qn
Monotony and boundedness of this sequence imply that for all measurable E ⊆ Clt and ω ∈ V+ (and therefore all ω ∈ V) limn→∞ µln (w, E)ω =: Etl (w, E)ω exists in norm. By the Vitali–Hahn–Saks Theorem [11] we conclude that E → Etl (w, E) is weakly, hence (because of the positivity and the state space properties) strongly σ-additive. Thus Etl (w, .) is a POVM on Atl with (all limits are in the strong topology) Etl (w, Atl )
= =
lim µln (w, Atl ) n→∞ E˜tl (w, Clt ).
˜ ln ) = lim E˜t (w, ∪φ∈Qln Bφ ) = lim E˜t (w, 3 n→∞
n→∞
P∞ Now we can define Et (w, E)ω := l=0 Etl (w, E ∩Atl )ω. It is straightforward that Etl (w, .) is a POVM with Etl (w, Xt ) = E˜t (w, ∪n=0 Cnt ). By construction w → Et (w, E) is weakly measurable and it remains to show 2.1(iii) for Et being an QCS. But as it suffices to verify this equation on standard sets this follows from Eq. (6). Thus there is a unique QCS Et the restriction to At1 of which is Gt , and the theorem is proven. 4. Classification and Construction of QCS It the sequel V, K, τ is a fixed state space. Let Et be a one point QCS. We say Et has a bounded interaction rate if for all a > 0 there is a K(a) > 0 such that ||Et (w, Xt \{zt })|| 5 K(a)t
(7)
for all w ∈ Y∞ satisfying ||w|| 5 a. The QCS has a bounded modulation if for all a > 0 there is a K(a) > 0 such that for measurable sets E ⊆ C0t ∪ C1t holds ||Et (w, E) − Et (v, E)|| ≤ K(a)||w − v||∞ t
(8)
if ||w||∞ , ||v||∞ , t ≤ a. Finally the QCS is bounded if it has a bounded interaction rate and a bounded modulation. We explain the ideas one has in mind when given these definitions. First, for a bounded interaction rate the probability of detecting one or more particles during a time interval of length t gets (linearly) small with t, which is definitely physically reasonable. The problem is that Eq. (7), being formulated for the instruments, contains a uniform estimation for all states. Comparing with CP’s the “best” physical condition should have the form
8
B. M¨uller
||Et (w, Xt \{zt })ω|| ≤ K(a, ω)t,
(9)
for ω in some dense subset of V. (If (9) is valid for all ω ∈ V the uniform boundedness principle implies that (7) holds.) Besides the fact that it is certainly the appropriate way to investigate first the simpler structure before turning to a more complicated one, there is another argument that justifies to consider bounded interaction rates. For CP’s (always take into account 2.2(ii)) Eq. (7) leads to the theory of unbounded interaction rates for which a main result is [18] that formally the same equations hold as in the bounded case, one only has to replace bounded operators by unbounded ones. The interpretation of the modulation condition (8) is that similar messages should imply similar outputs, at least for small t. Concerning the physical relevance the same considerations can be made as for the IR-condition, and it is reasonable to expect that in general the operators B(c) in Theorem 4.2 just have to be allowed to be unbounded. However, this is not yet proved and this paper deals with the bounded case. As for CP’s [6, 18] we require that the semigroup St := Et (0, {zt }) has additional properties. We say a semigroup St is of type R if its Farvard class, i.e. the set of all ω ∈ V for which the orbit {St ω|t ≥ 0} is Lipschitz continuous [4], equals the domain D(W ) of its generator W . Recall that this is always true for reflexive spaces. Any pure semigroup on the state space of trace class operators of a Hilbert space is of type R [6, 18]. We denote the Farvard class of St by F (W ). Lemma 4.1. Let St be a contraction semigroup of type R on V with generator (W, D(W )). (i) If A ∈ B(V) and Tt := exp[(W + A)t] is contractive, then Tt is of type R. (ii) If Tt is another contraction semigroup satisfying ||Tt − St || ≤ Kt, then Tt is of type R and there is a unique bounded operator A ∈ B(V) such that Tt = exp[(W + A)t]. Rt Proof. (i) If ω ∈ F (W +A) then the perturbation equation Tt ω = St ω + 0 Tt−s ASs ωds implies ||St ω − ω|| ≤ ||(Tt − St )ω|| + ||Tt ω − ω|| ≤ ||A|| ||ω||t + ||Tt ω − ω||, thus ω ∈ F (W ) = D(W ) = D(W + A), hence F (W + A) ⊆ D(W + A). The inverse inclusion is always true so Tt is of type R. (ii) Let (Z, D(Z)) denote the generator of Tt , then ω ∈ D(Z) implies ||St ω − ω|| ≤ ||Tt ω − ω|| + ||(St − Tt )ω|| ≤ ||Zω||t + Kt, thus ω ∈ D(W ). Hence A := Z − W is well defined on D(Z) and ||A|| ≤ K. Therefore Z = W + A, D(Z) = D(W ) and Tt is of type R by (i). We say a QCS is of type R if its interaction free semigroup St := Et (0, {zt }) is of type R. We always use the notation St = exp(W t). Theorem 4.2. Let Et be a bounded one point QCS of type R. Then there is a unique Family (B(c))c∈R in B(V) such that ∞ Z X w St,s = St−tn B(w(tn )) . . . B(w(t1 ))St1 ωdt1 . . . dtn (10) n=0
t−s s+Cn
0 = Et (0, {zt }) = exp(W t)). All the semigroups St1 c = Et (c, {zt }) for all ω ∈ V (St := St,0 are of type R and we have Stc = exp[(W + B(c))t]. Furthermore there is a unique family (J(c))c∈R in B+ (V) such that
Classification and Construction of Quantum Communication Systems
Et (w, E)ω =
∞ Z X n=0
t ∪E Cn
9
w St,t J(w(tn )) . . . J(w(t1 ))Stw1 ,0 ωdt1 . . . dtn . n
(11)
For any a > 0 there is a K(a) > 0 such that for all c, d ∈ R with |c|, |d| ≤ a, ||J(c) − J(d)|| ≤ K(a)|a − d|
and
||B(c) − B(d)|| ≤ K(a)|c − d|.
(12) (13)
Finally we have τ ∈ D(W ∗ ) and for all c ∈ R it holds (W ∗ + B(c)∗ + J(c)∗ )τ = 0.
(14)
Proof. First the modulation equation (8) implies that limt↓0 ||St ω −ω|| = 0 for all ω ∈ V and c ∈ R. Thus Stc is a contractive C0 -semigroup satisfying ||Stc − St || ≤ K(c)t. By Lemma 4.1 Stc is of type R and Stc = exp[(W + B(c))t] with a unique bounded operator B(c). In particular (10) is valid for any constant function w. Because of B(d)ω−B(c)ω = limt→0 1t (Std − Stc )ω the modulation condition implies (13). Thus defining w ω := S˜ t,s
∞ Z X t−s s+Cn
n=0
St−tn B(w(tn )) . . . B(w(t1 ))St1 ωdt1 . . . dtn ,
w one easily verifies that S˜ t,s is a well defined bounded operator satisfying w ˜w w S˜ t,s Ss,r = S˜ t,r
(15)
w w for r < s < t. By perturbation expansion we have S˜ t,s = St,s for constant functions and (15) implies that this is even true for piecewise constant functions. Now by the w is strongly continuous and a direct calculation modulation condition the map w → St,s w . By the density of the piecewise using (13) shows that the same holds for w → S˜ t,s constant functions we have proved (10). The theory of counting processes [18] shows that (11) is true for constant w, if we define J(c) to be the perturbation connecting the two semigroups Stc and Ttc := Et (c, Xt ) (both of type R by Lemma 4.1 and the interaction condition(7)). A similar argument as the above one shows the validity of (12), and (14) follows from [18]. We thus have for any constant c:
Z Et (c, [0, t))ω = 0
t
c c St,s J(c)Ss,0 ωds.
If w is constant on the interval [a, b) ⊆ [0, t), i.e. w(s) = c for s ∈ [a, b), then by (4) Z Et (w, [a, b))ω
=
w w St,b Eb−a (c, [0, b − a))Sa,0 ω=
Z
b
= a
b−a 0
w c c w St,b Sb−a,s J(c)Ss,0 Sa,0 ωds
w w St,b J(w(s))Ss,0 ωds.
Hence, if w is piecewise constant, i.e. w(s) = ci for s ∈ [ai , ai+1 ), where 0 < a = a0 < a1 < . . . < aN +1 = b < t, it follows
10
B. M¨uller
Et (w, [a, b))ω
=
N X i=0 Z b
= a
Et (w, [ai , ai+1 ))ω =
N Z X i=0
ai+1 ai
w w St,b J(w(s))Ss,0 ωds
w w St,b J(w(s))Ss,0 ωds.
As both sides of this equation are continuous in w it holds for general w. Finally one verifies by some easy substitutions that for standard sets E = [a1 , b1 ) × . . . × [an , bn ), 0 ≤ a1 < b1 < . . . an < bn < t: Z w Et (w, E)ω = St,t J(w(tn )) . . . J(w(t1 ))Stw1 ,0 ωdt1 . . . dtn . n E
Both sides of this equation are σ-additive and coincide on the generating system of standard sets, hence we get (11). We now give the converse of the above theorem. Theorem 4.3. Let St = exp(W t) be a C0 -semigroup on V and (B(c))c∈R a strongly continuous family of bounded operators on V with B(0) = 0 such that all the semigroups Stc := exp[(W +B(c))t] are positive and contractive. For each c ∈ R, let J(c) ∈ B+ (V) be w and Et (w, E) a positive operator such that (14) holds. Then defining the operations St,s by (10) and (11) we get a one point QCS Et . Et is bounded iff (12) and (13) are valid. Proof. The uniform boundedness principle and the strong continuity of c → B(c) and c → J(c) imply that for any r > 0 there is a constant Ar > 0 such that supu≤r (||B(u)||+ w is a well ||J(u)||) = Ar < ∞. Then for fixed w ∈ Y∞ , it is easy to verify that St,s P∞ n w n defined operator with ||St,s || ≤ n=0 Ar (t − s) /k!. Using the Lebesgue Theorem and w . By hypothesis and this uniform estimation we get the strong continuity of w → St,s w perturbation theory the operators St,s are positive and contractive for constant functions w w w w Ss,r = St,r for r < s < t, therefore St,s is w. A direct calculation shows that St,s positive and contractive for piecewise constant w and by continuity even for arbitrary w. It now is obvious that each Et (w, E) is a well defined positive bounded operator. The strong σ-additivity of E → Et (w, E) the Markov equation 2.1(iii) and 2.1(i) are straightforward calculations. 2.1(ii) follows similar to the corresponding proof for the w . Equation (14) and perturbation theory show that Et (w, Xt )∗ τ = τ for map w → St,s constant functions. As above we extend this equality to piecewise constant functions and then to arbitrary w ∈ Y∞ . Now if the QCS Et is bounded (12) and (13) follow as in the proof of Theorem 4.2. The converse result can be obtained by using the explicit expressions for Et (w, E). We yet have shown how one point QCS’s should be constructed. Now we will concentrate on refinements of such a QCS. As in the case of CP’s any decomposition [18] of the operators J(c) will determine a refinement of the QCS. Proposition 4.4. Let (X, Σ) be a standard Borel space and let Et be constructed as in Theorem 4.3. For each c ∈ R let J(c, .) : Σ → B+ (V), E → J(c, E) be a strongly σadditive map with J(c, X) = J(c). Furthermore let c → J(c, E) be strongly continuous for all E ∈ Σ. Then there is a unique refinement E˜t of Et with measurable space (X, Σ) such that for all E ∈ Σ holds: Z t w ˜ sSt, sw J(w(t), E)Ss,0 ds. Et (w, E × [0, t))ω = 0
Classification and Construction of Quantum Communication Systems
11
Proof. Uniqueness is obvious. To prove existence we use Theorem 3.1. For measurable A ⊆ X × [0, t) and s ∈ [0, t) define As := {x ∈ X|(x, s) ∈ A} and Z
t
Gt (w, A)ω := 0
w w St,s J(w(s), As )Ss,0 ωds.
As in usual measure theory one verifies that the integral is weakly well defined and σadditive in A. Thus Gt (w, .) is a POVM on X × [0, t) which obviously is measurable in w. By Hypothesis 3.1(ii) (b) holds and 3.1(ii)(c) follows with some easy substitutions. We remark that not all refinements of the QCS E˜t necessarily have this form. The classification theorem for arbitrary CP’s with bounded interaction rate [18] shows that for a general refinement the operators J(c, E) have to be formulated as operators on a -dual space [5]. This theorem can even be used to derive structural results similar to those in Theorem 3.2 for arbitrary bounded QCS’s. We made the additional assumptions in Theorem 4.2 because the existence of the operators B(c) ∈ B(V) could not be proved without assuming that St is of type R. And even then it is not yet shown that an arbitrary non-one point QCS can be formulated on V rather than on some -dual space. However, using the classification of counting processes on Hilbert spaces [6, 18] one can show as in the proof of 4.2, that any refinement of a bounded QCS of type R on the state space of trace class operators must have the form which is given in the above proposition.
5. Special Cases Let us consider the QCS Et constructed in 4.3. There are two different differential w ρ) one equations related to Et . First for the interaction free dynamics (i.e. ρt = St,s formally gets ∂ ρt = (W + B(w(t)))ρt . (16) ∂t For the dynamics characterizing the whole system (ρt = Et (w, Xt )ρ) we have ∂ ρt = (W + B(w(t)) + J(w(t)))ρt . ∂t
(17)
Both equations at least are valid on D(W ) for the dense set of piecewise constant functions at any point where w is continuous. The first one shows that the interaction free dynamics contains some information about the transmitted message via the “modulation” B(w(t)). As W essentially contains the energy of a particle, B(w(t)) may be interpreted as an energy modulation caused by the influence of the input system. It then seems to be physically reasonable – at least for small w(t) – that B(c) has the form B(c) = cB0 ,
(18)
i.e. the modulation is linear. We say the QCS Et has a linear modulation if (18) holds. In order to meet the conditions of Theorem 4.3 the operator B0 must have additional properties. Recall that any norm continuous group of isometries on a state space V is positive.
12
B. M¨uller
Proposition 5.1. If Et is a bounded QCS as constructed in Theorem 4.3 with B(c) = cB0 , then B0 is the generator of a group of isometries, in particular B0∗ τ = 0. Conversely if B0 generates a group of isometries, W is the generator of a positive semigroup St of contractions and c → J(c) ∈ B+ (V) is a strongly continuous map with J(c)∗ τ = −W ∗ τ for all c, then Eq. (10) and (11) define a QCS with linear modulation. Proof. Let Et be a QCS with linear modulation, then all the operators W (c) = W + cB0 are generators of contraction semigroups, hence dissipative. Thus for any ω ∈ D(W ) = D(W (c)) with tangent functional x it is 0 ≥ hW (c)ω, xi = hW ω, xi + chB0 ω, xi. As this inequality is valid for all c ∈ R, we conclude hB0 ω, xi = 0. Therefore the operators (±B0 , D(W )) are dissipative and by [3, Prop. 3.1.15] even ±B0 is dissipative, hence B0 is the generator of a group of isometries (which is positive). By use of the Trotter–Kato formula one easily sees that the operators W (c) = W + cB0 generate positive contraction semigroups Stc with W (c)∗ τ = W ∗ τ . Thus we can apply Theorem 4.3 to get the desired result. We see that for a QCS with linear modulation the functional J(c)∗ τ does not depend on c. In particular ||J(c)|| = ||J(c)∗ τ || = ||W ∗ τ || is independent of c. We call a QCS Et as constructed in Theorem 4.3 a QCS with independent detector if J(c) = J for some fixed J ∈ B+ (V). In this case Eq. (11) suggests that J describes the instantaneous change of the state when a particle is detected. For physical applications the most interesting cases will be QCS’s with linear modulation and an independent detector, though one cannot expect that the operators J and B0 are bounded. To give some ideas on applications, we add a few comments on existing models that are not yet published. A direct generalization of Davies’ model [10] to macroscopic coherent light [14, 15] has to use W ∗ -algebraic methods, as the creation and annihilation operators in the relevant representation of the CCR cannot be formulated on Fock space. However, as the center of this representation is non-trivial, classical structures appear and can be detected. If the transmission uses squeezed light, the modulation operators on Hilbert space may have the form a∗2 − a2 or another quadratic expression in the creation and annihilation operators. On Fock space (resp. the trace class operators on Fock space) the existence of such a model has been proved and additional properties could be derived. Using Theorem 4.3 for a dependent model on the set Tsa (H) of trace class operators on a Hilbert space H with J(c)ρ = a(c)uρu∗ , W ρ = −i[H, ρ] − a(0)ρ, B(c)ρ = −i[8(c), ρ] − (a(c) − a(0))ρ, where ρ ∈ Tsa (H), u ∈ B(H) is unitary and a : R → R+ and φ : R → Bsa (H) are continuous functions, we get a very simple expression for the intensity registered by the detector: I(t) = hEt (w, Xt )ω, J ∗ (w(t))τ i = a(w(t)), which easily allows a numeric calculation of the channel capacity when using for instance a binary signal transmission. It is not always clear how to interpret a dependent detector although some considerations imply that this might be connected with a nontrivial movement of the detecting system. However we want to emphasize that there exist QCS without linear modulation or independent detector.
Classification and Construction of Quantum Communication Systems
13
References 1. Accardi, L.: A new class of quantum states: Examples and applications. In: C. Bendjaballah, O. Hirota, and S., Reynaud, ed., Quantum Aspects of Optical Communications. No. 378, Lecture Notes in Physics. Berlin–Heidelberg–New York: Springer-Verlag, 1991, pp. 138–150 2. Ash, R: Information Theory. New York: Interscience, 1965 3. Bratteli, O. and Robinson, D.W. Operator Algebras and Quantum Statistical Mechanics. Volume 1. New York–Heidelberg–Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 1987 4. Butzer, P.L. and Behrens, H.: Semigroups of Operators and Approximation. New York: Springer-Verlag, 1967 5. Clement, P., Diekmann, O., Gyllenberg, M., Heilmann, H.J.A.M., and Thieme, H.R.: Perturbation theory for dual semigroups, I. The sun-reflexive case. Math. Ann. 277, 709–725 (1987) 6. Davies, E.B.: Quantum stochastic processes. Commun. Math. Phys. 15, 277–304 (1969) 7. Davies, E.B.: An operational approach to quantum probability. Commun. Math. Phys. 17, 239–260 (1970) 8. Davies, E.B.: Quantum stochastic processes III. Commun. Math. Phys. 22, 51–70 (1971) 9. Davies, E.B.: Quantum Theory of Open Systems. London–New York: Academic Press, 1976 10. Davies, E.B.: Quantum communication systems. IEEE Trans. on Inf. Th. 23, 530–534 (1977) 11. Dunford, N., and Schwartz, J.T.: Linear Operators, Volume 1. New York–London: Interscience Publishers, 1958 12. Edwards, C.M.: The operational approach to algebraic quantum theory I. Commun. Math Phys. 16, 207–230 (1970) 13. Hall, M.J.W., and O’Rourke, M.J.: Realistic performance of the maximum information channel. Quantum Opt. 5, 161–180 (1993) 14. Honegger, R., and Rapp, A.: General Glauber coherent states on the Weylalgebra and their phase integrals. Physica A 167 945–961 (1990) 15. Honegger, R., and Rieckers, A.: The general form of non-Fock coherent Boson states. Publ. RIMS Kyoto University 26, 397–417 (1990) 16. Ingarden, R.S.: Quantum information theory. Rep. Math. Phys. 10, 43–73 (1976) 17. Lindblad, G.: Quantum entropy and quantum measurements. In: C. Bendjaballah, O. Hirota, and S. Reynaud, ed. Quantum Aspects of Optical Communications. No. 378, Lecture Notes in Physics. Berlin– Heidelberg–New York: Springer-Verlag, 1991, pp. 71–80 18. M¨uller, B.: On generalized quantum stochastic counting processes. To appear in Commun. Math. Phys. 19. Ohya, M.: On compound state and mutual information in quantum information theory. IEEE Trans. on Inf. Th. 29 (5), 770–774 (1983) 20. Ohya, M.: Some aspects of quantum information theory and their applications to irreversible processes. Rep. Math. Phys. 27 (1), 19–47 (1989) 21. Ohya, M.: Information dynamics and its applications to optical communication processes. In: C. Bendjaballah, O. Hirota, and S. Reynaud, ed. Quantum Aspects of Optical Communications. No. 378, Lecture Notes in Physics. Berlin–Heidelberg–New York: Springer-Verlag, 1991, pp. 81–92 22. Ohya, M.: Rigorous derivation of error probability in coherent optical communication. In: In: C. Bendjaballah, O. Hirota, and S. Reynaud, ed. Quantum Aspects of Optical Communications. No. 378, Lecture Notes in Physics. Berlin–Heidelberg–New York: Springer-Verlag, 1991, pp. 203–212 23. Parthasarathy, K.R.: Probability measures on metric spaces. New York–London: Academic Press, 1967 Communicated by H. Araki
Commun. Math. Phys. 191, 15 – 29 (1998)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics c Springer-Verlag 1998
Quantum Dynamical R-Matrices and Quantum Frobenius Group G.E. Arutyunov, S.A. Frolov Steklov Mathematical Institute, Gubkin str. 8, GSP-1, 117966, Moscow, Russia. E-mail:
[email protected];
[email protected] Received: 24 January 1997 / Accepted: 17 March 1997
Abstract: We propose an algebraic scheme for quantizing the rational RuijsenaarsSchneider model in the R-matrix formalism. We introduce a special parametrization of the cotangent bundle over GL(N, C). In new variables the standard symplectic structure is described by a classical (Frobenius) r-matrix and by a new dynamical r-matrix. ¯ Quantizing both of them we find the quantum L-operator algebra and construct its particular representation corresponding to the rational Ruijsenaars-Schneider system. Using the dual parametrization of the cotangent bundle we also derive the algebra for the L-operator of the hyperbolic Calogero-Moser system. 1. Introduction As soon as the classical dynamical r-matrices first appeared [1] on the scene of integrable many body systems, the problem of their quantization became of real interest. The main hope related to this problem is to find a new algebraic structure that ensures the integrability of the corresponding quantum models. We recall [2] that having a finite-dimensional completely integrable system with the Lax representation dL dt = [M, L] one can always write the Poisson algebra of L-operators in the r-matrix form. However, in general, an r-matrix appears to be a nontrivial function of dynamical variables. At present the classical dynamical r-matrices are known for the rational, trigonometric [1, 3] and elliptic [4, 5] Calogero-Moser (CM) systems, as well as for their relativistic generalizations – rational, trigonometric [6, 7] and elliptic [8, 9] Ruijsenaars-Schneider (RS) systems [10]. The problem of quantizing the dynamical r-matrices is rather nontrivial since, in general, such r-matrices do not satisfy a single closed equation of the Yang-Baxter type, from which they can be uniquely determined. Up to now there exists only one example of a quantum dynamical R-matrix related to the quantum spin CM system [11]. This Rmatrix solves the Gervais-Neveu-Felder equation [12, 13] and has a nice interpretation in terms of quasi-Hopf algebras [14].
16
G.E. Arutyunov, S.A. Frolov
A natural way to understand the origin of dynamical r-matrices is to consider the Hamiltonian reduction procedure [3, 15]. Factorizing a free motion on an initial phase space by the action of some symmetry group, we get nontrivial dynamics on the reduced space. An r-matrix appears in the Dirac bracket, which describes the phase structure of the reduced space. In our recent papers [16, 17] we obtained the elliptic RS model, being the most general one among the integrable systems of the CM and RS types, by using two different reduction schemes. In the first scheme, the affine Heisenberg double was used as the initial phase space and in the second one we considered the cotangent bundle over the centrally extended group of double loops. The aim of this paper is to quantize the reduction scheme leading to the dynamical systems of the RS type. Although the most interesting is the spectral-dependent elliptic case [16, 17], to clarify the general approach in this paper we restrict ourselves to considering the simplest rational model. Our construction is based on a special parametrization of the cotangent bundle over the group GL(N, C). This parametrization is similar to the one considered in [18]. However, instead of Euler angles, we use another system of generators to parametrize the “momentum”. These generators obey a quadratic Poisson algebra described by two r-matrices r and r. ¯ The matrix r solves the N -parametric classical Yang-Baxter equation and is related to the special Frobenius subgroup in GL(N, C). We define a special matrix function L on T ∗ G invariant with respect to the action of this Frobenius subgroup. We call this function the “L-operator” since the Poisson algebra of L literally coincides with the one for the rational RS model [7]. Moreover, performing the Hamiltonian reduction leading to the RS model [19], one can recognize in L the standard L-operator of the rational RS model. Then we pass to the quantization. The quadratic Poisson algebra can be quantized by using the R-matrix approach [20, 21]. The compatibility of the corresponding quantum algebra implies the quantum Yang-Baxter equation for R and some new equations ¯ We solve these equations and get an explicit form for R and R. ¯ involving R and R. Coming back to the original generators of T ∗ G we recover the standard commutation relations of the quantum cotangent bundle. We derive a new quadratic algebra which is satisfied by the “quantum” L-operator: −1 −1 −1 L2 R¯ 12 R12 R¯ 21 = R12 L2 R¯ 12 L1 . L1 R¯ 21
We see that the matrices R and R¯ come in this algebra in a nontrivial way. Thus, the dynamical r-matrices (classical and quantum) appear as the composite objects constructed ¯ from the more elementary blocks R and R. It follows from our construction that the quantum L-operator is factorized in the form L = W P . Here W satisfies the defining relations of the quantum Frobenius group, W1 W2 R12 = R12 W2 W1 , where R, being the quantization of r, is an N -parametric solution to the quantum Yang-Baxter equation. The diagonal matrix P plays the role of a generalized momentum. We find the simplest representation of the L-operator algebra and relate it with the rational RS model. The hyperbolic (trigonometric) CM system is known to be dual to the rational RS model [10]. This duality is explained by the existence of the dual parametrization of T ∗ G. In this parametrization the CM model can be easily quantized and we get the commutation relations satisfied by the corresponding quantum L-operator.
Quantum Dynamical R-Matrices and Quantum Frobenius Group
17
2. Frobenius Algebra and Dynamical r-Matrices In this section we introduce a special parametrization of the cotangent bundle T ∗ G over the matrix group G = GL(N, C). As a manifold the space T ∗ G is naturally isomorphic to G ∗ × G, where G ∗ is dual to the Lie algebra G = Mat(N, C). The standard Poisson structure on T ∗ G can be written in terms of variables (A, g), where A ∈ G ∗ ≈ G and g ∈ G, as follows 1 [C, A1 − A2 ], (2.1) 2 {A1 , g2 } = g2 C, (2.2) (2.3) {g1 , g2 } = 0. P Here we use the standard tensor notation and C = i,j Eij ⊗ Eji is the permutation operator. Any matrix A belonging to an orbit of maximal dimension in G ∗ admits a factorization: (2.4) A = T QT −1 , {A1 , A2 } =
where Q is a diagonal matrix with entries qi , qi 6= qj . We also fix the order of qi by using the action of the Weyl group. It is obvious that the matrix T in Eq. (2.4) is not uniquely defined. Indeed, one can multiply T by an arbitrary diagonal matrix from the right. We remove this ambiguity by imposing the following condition: T e = e,
(2.5)
where e is a column with all ei = 1. The choice of (2.5) is motivated by the study of the reduction procedure leading to the Calogero-type integrable systems [22]. Let us note that the condition (2.5) defines a Lie subgroup F ⊂ G. The corresponding Lie algebra F has a natural basis Fij = Eii − Eij , where Eij are the standard matrix unities. The commutation relations of Fij are [Fij , Fkl ] = δik (Fil − Fij ) + δil (Fkj − Fkl ) + δjk (Fij − Fil ). It is worthwhile to mention that F is not only the Lie algebra but also an associative algebra with respect to the usual matrix multiplication: Fij Fkl = δik Fil + δjk (Fik − Fil ). Let us rewrite the Poisson structure (2.1) in terms of the variables T and Q. It is well known that the center of the Poisson algebra (2.1) is generated by the Casimir elements trAn = trQn . Therefore, the coordinates qi Poisson commute with A, T and Q. The only nontrivial bracket one has to calculate is {T, T }. We have {Tij , Tkl } = To find
δTij δAmn
X
δTij δTkl {Amn , Aps }. δAmn δAps mn,ps
we perform the variation of (2.4): T −1 δT Q − QT −1 δT + δQ = T −1 δAT.
This equation can be easily solved, and we obtain the derivatives
18
G.E. Arutyunov, S.A. Frolov
X 1 δTij −1 −1 = (Tia Tnj Tam + Tij Tna Tjm ) δAmn qja
(2.6)
δqi −1 = Tni Tim , δAmn
(2.7)
{T1 , T2 } = T1 T2 r12 (q),
(2.8)
a6=j
and
where qij ≡ qi − qj . By using (2.6) we get where the r-matrix
r12 (q) =
X 1 Fij ⊗ Fji qij
(2.9)
i6=j
appears. It is clear that r12 (q) should be a skew-symmetric solution of the classical Yang-Baxter equation (CYBE). The origin of this r-matrix can be easily understood if we notice that F is a Frobenius Lie algebra, i.e. there is a nondegenerate 2-cocycle (coboundary) on F: ω(X, Y ) = tr(Q[X, Y ]), X, Y ∈ F .
(2.10)
According to [23], to any Frobenius Lie algebra one can associate a skew-symmetric solution of the CYBE by inverting the corresponding 2-cocycle. One can check that the cocycle (2.10) corresponds to r12 (q) ∈ F ∧ F. Coming back to (2.4), we see that any orbit of maximal dimension in G ∗ can be supplied with the structure of the Frobenius group. It is worthwhile to note that ω is the Kirillov symplectic form on the coadjoint orbit of the maximal dimension parametrized by Q. Now, following [18], we introduce a special parametrization for the group element g. To this end we consider an element A0 = gAg −1 , which Poisson commutes with A and possesses the Poisson bracket 1 {A01 , A02 } = − [C, A01 − A02 ]. 2 Diagonalizing A0 = U QU −1 with the help of the matrix U , U e = e, we find that g = U P T −1 ,
(2.11)
where P is some diagonal matrix. It is obvious that the Poisson bracket for U is given by (2.12) {U1 , U2 } = −U1 U2 r12 (q) and that {T, U } = 0. To proceed with the calculation of the brackets {U, P }, {T, P }, δU {P, P } and {P, Q}, we should use the derivative δA0ij that is given by (2.6) with the mn replacement T → U , A → A0 . Performing simple computations, we get {P1 , P2 } = 0, {Q1 , P2 } = P2
X
Eii ⊗ Eii .
(2.13)
i
Introducing pi = log Pi , we conclude that {qi , pj } = δij . We also find the Poisson brackets:
Quantum Dynamical R-Matrices and Quantum Frobenius Group
{U1 , P2 } = U1 P2 r¯12 (q), {T1 , P2 } = T1 P2 r¯12 (q), where we have introduced a new matrix X 1 Fij ⊗ Ejj . r¯12 (q) = qij
19
(2.14) (2.15)
(2.16)
i6=j
The Jacobi identity leads to a set of equations on the matrices r and r. ¯ However, we postpone the discussion of these equations till the next section, where the quantization of T ∗ G will be given in terms of variables Q, T, P, U . Let us define the L-operator as the following function of phase variables, being invariant under the action of the Frobenius group: L = T −1 gT = T −1 U P.
(2.17)
By using (2.8), (2.12) and (2.13-2.15) one can easily find the Poisson brackets containing L: X Eii ⊗ Eii , (2.18) {Q1 , L2 } = L2 i
{T1 , L2 } = T1 L2 r¯12 (q) − T1 r12 (q)L2 , {L1 , L2 } = r12 (q)L1 L2 + L1 L2 (r¯12 (q) − r¯21 (q) − r12 (q)) + L1 r¯21 (q)L2 − L2 r¯12 (q)L1 .
(2.19) (2.20)
We see that the brackets for L and Q are the ones for the L-operator and coordinates of the rational RS model found in [7]. It is obvious that In = trLn = trg n form a set of mutually commuting functions. Let us note that the L-operator (2.17) has the form L = W P , where W = T −1 U . Since both T and U are elements of the Frobenius group F , the element W also belongs to F . Calculating the Poisson bracket for W , we see that it coincides with the Sklyanin bracket defining on F the structure of a Poisson-Lie group: {W1 , W2 } = [r12 (q), W1 W2 ].
(2.21)
The Poisson relations of W and P are {W1 , P2 } = −P2 [r¯12 (q), W1 ].
(2.22)
A well-known property of the Poisson algebra (2.21) is the existence of a family of mutually commuting functions Jn = trW n . Moreover, it turns out that Jn commute not only with themselves but also with P and Q. In Sect. 3 we show that the same property holds in the quantum case. Now we construct the simplest representation of the Poisson algebra (2.21), (2.22) and (2.13) and relate it with the rational RS model. In fact, this representation corresponds to a zero-dimensional symplectic leaf of the bracket (2.21). To this end we employ the Hamiltonian reduction procedure. The 1-form corresponding to the Poisson structure (2.1-2.3) is α = tr(Ag −1 dg). Recall that G acts on T ∗ G by transformations A → hAh−1 , g → hgh−1 in a Hamiltonian way. By using the 1-form α one can easily get the corresponding moment map µ: µ = gAg −1 − A. Performing the Hamiltonian reduction, we fix its value to be
20
G.E. Arutyunov, S.A. Frolov
gAg −1 − A = −γ(ee+ − 1), where γ is an arbitrary constant and e+ is a row with all e+i = 1. In terms of (T, L, Q) variables this equation acquires the form T (LQL−1 − Q)T −1 = −γ(ee+ − 1).
(2.23)
Since T e = e and L = W P the last equation can be written as W Q − QW − γW = −γee+ U. Equation (2.24) can be elementary solved and one gets X γ ei bj Eij , W = γ + qij i,j
(2.24)
(2.25)
where b = e+ U . If we recall that W should be an element of F , i.e. W e = e, then we find the coefficients bj : Q 1 a (qaj + γ) Q , (2.26) bj = γ a6=j qaj and thereby
Q Wij =
a6=i (qaj
Q
+ γ)
a6=j qaj
.
(2.27)
One can check that W given by (2.27) has the desired Poisson brackets (2.21) and (2.22). We do not give an explicit proof of this statement since in Sect. 3 we show that the same function W realizes a representation for the corresponding quantum algebra. The relation of our L-operator with the standard Ruijsenaars L-operator [10] is given by the following canonical transformation: qi → qi , Pi →
Y (qai − γ)1/2 a6=i
(qai + γ)1/2
Pi .
3. Quantum L-Operator Algebra In this section we quantize T ∗ G in terms of variables Q, T, P, U and obtain the permutation relations for the quantum L-operator. The algebra of functions on T ∗ G can be easily quantized and one gets an associative algebra generated by A and g subject to the standard relations: 1 ~[C, A1 − A2 ], 2 [A1 , g2 ] = ~g2 C, [g1 , g2 ] = 0,
[A1 , A2 ] =
(3.1) (3.2) (3.3)
where ~ is a quantization parameter. The commutation relations for the generators T, Q, U, P can be straightforwardly written by using the ideology of the Quantum Inverse Scattering Method [20, 21] (we present only nontrivial relations):
Quantum Dynamical R-Matrices and Quantum Frobenius Group
21
−1 T1 T2 = T2 T1 R12 (q), U1 U2 = U2 U1 R12 (q), T1 P2 = P2 T1 R¯ 12 (q), U1 P2 = P2 U1 R¯ 12 (q), X Eii ⊗ Eii . [Q1 , P2 ] = ~P2
(3.4) (3.5) (3.6)
i
¯ Here R(q) and R(q) are quantum dynamical R-matrices having the following behavior near ~ = 0: ¯ R(q) = 1 + ~r(q) + o(~), R(q) = 1 + ~r(q) ¯ + o(~). It is worthwhile to mention that the matrix elements of the dynamical R-matrices do not commute only with the momenta pi due to the relations [T1 , Q2 ] = [U1 , Q2 ] = 0. It follows from the compatibility conditions that the R-matrices should satisfy the following set of equations R12 (q)R21 (q) R12 (q)R13 (q)R23 (q) R12 (q)R¯ 13 (q)R¯ 23 (q) R¯ 12 (q)P −1 R¯ 13 (q)P2 2
= = =
1, R23 (q)R13 (q)R12 (q), R¯ 23 (q)R¯ 13 (q)P3−1 R12 (q)P3 , = R¯ 13 (q)P −1 R¯ 12 (q)P3 . 3
(3.7) (3.8) (3.9) (3.10)
Let us demonstrate how to get, for example, Eq. (3.9). This equation follows from (3.5) and the following chain of relations: −1 T1 R12 R¯ 13 R¯ T1 T2 P3 = T1 P3 T2 R¯ 23 = P3 T1 R¯ 13 T2 R¯ 23 = P3 T2 T1 R12 R¯ 13 R¯ 23 = T2 P3 R¯ 23 ¯ = T2 T1 P3 R¯ −1 R¯ −1 R12 R¯ 13 R¯ = T1 T2 R−1 P3 R¯ −1 R¯ −1 R12 R¯ 13 R. 13
23
12
13
23
The solution of the Yang-Baxter Eq. (3.8) can be easily found if one notes that 2 = 0. It is known (see e.g. [24] Prop.6.4.13) that if r ∈ Mat(N, C) ⊗ Mat(N, C) r12 satisfies r3 = 0 and solves the classical Yang-Baxter equation then R = er is a solution of QYBE. Therefore, R12 = e~r12 = 1 + ~r12 is a desired solution of the QYBE. The solution of Eq. (3.9) can be found if one supposes that R¯ has the same matrix structure as r¯ does: X r¯ij (~, q)Fij ⊗ Ejj . (3.11) R¯ 12 (q) = 1 + ~ i6=j
¯ Then the following R-matrix is a solution of Eqs. (3.9) and (3.10): R¯ 12 (q) = 1 +
X i6=j
~ Fij ⊗ Ejj . qij − ~
(3.12)
P −1 (q) = 1 − i6=j q~ij Fij ⊗ Ejj . It is not difficult to verify that R¯ 12 Now we should show that the generators A = T QT −1 and g = U P T −1 satisfy the commutation relations (3.1-3.3). From the relations (3.4-3.6) we get [A1 , A2 ] = T2 T1 (R12 Q1 R21 Q2 − Q2 R12 Q1 R21 )T1−1 T2−1 , X −1 Eii ⊗ Eii )R¯ 12 R12 − R12 Q1 )T2−1 T1−1 , [A1 , g2 ] = g2 T2 T1 (R¯ 12 (Q1 + ~ [g1 , g2 ] =
i −1 −1 −1 ¯ ¯ R12 U2 U1 (R12 P1 R21 P2 R12
−1 −1 − P2 R¯ 12 P1 R¯ 21 )T2−1 T1−1 .
22
G.E. Arutyunov, S.A. Frolov
By using the following identities, which can be checked by direct computation: R12 Q1 R21 Q2 − Q2 R12 Q1 R21 = ~(CQ1 R21 − R12 Q1 C), X −1 Eii ⊗ Eii )R¯ 12 R12 − R12 Q1 = ~C, R¯ 12 (Q1 + ~ i −1 −1 −1 ¯ P2 R¯ 12 R12 R12 P1 R21
−1 −1 − P2 R¯ 12 P1 R¯ 21 = 0,
(3.13)
one derives the desired commutation relations for A and g. Let us finally present the permutation relations for Q, T and L = T −1 U P , which can be easily obtained by using (3.4-3.6) and (3.13): X Eii ⊗ Eii , (3.14) [Q1 , L2 ] = ~L2 i
T1 R12 L2 = L2 T1 R¯ 12 , −1 −1 −1 L2 R¯ 12 R12 R¯ 21 = R12 L2 R¯ 12 L1 . L1 R¯ 21
(3.15) (3.16)
It is clear that just as in the classical case the quantities In = trg n form a set of mutually commuting operators. Let us show that In can be expressed in terms of L and Q solely and thereby they can be interpreted as quantum integrals of motion for the rational RS model. By using the definition of L we rewrite In as t
t2 In = trg n = trT Ln T −1 = tr12 C12 T1 Ln1 T2−1 = tr12 C12 T1 Ln1 T2−1 ,
where t2 denotes the matrix transposition in the second factor of the tensor product. It follows from (3.15) that t
t
t2 t2 L1 R¯ 21 . L1 T2−1 =T2−1 R12
Applying this relation, we derive t
t2 t2 t2 t2 t2 T1 T2−1 R12 L1 R¯ 21 · · · R12 L1 R¯ 21 . In = tr12 C12 t
Exchanging T1 and T2−1 with the help of Eq. (3.4), one gets t
t2 t2 t2 t2 In = tr12 C12 T2−1 T1 L1 R¯ 21 · · · R12 L1 R¯ 21 . t
t2 t2 t2 t2 t2 Since C12 T2−1 T1 = C12 and R¯ 21 C12 = C12 we finally arrive at t2 t2 t 2 t2 t 2 t2 t 2 In = tr12 C12 L1 R¯ 21 R12 L1 R¯ 21 R12 L1 · · · L1 R¯ 21 R12 L1 .
It is natural to regard this expression for In as a “quantum trace” of the operator Ln . Just as in the classical case the quantum L-operator has the form L = W P , where W = T −1 U satisfies the defining relations of the quantum Frobenius group: R12 W2 W1 = W1 W2 R12 .
(3.17)
The algebra (3.14), (3.16) rewritten in terms of Q, P and W is given by (3.6), (3.17) and by the relation
Quantum Dynamical R-Matrices and Quantum Frobenius Group
23
−1 −1 W1 P2 R¯ 12 = P2 R¯ 12 W1 .
(3.18)
This shows that the representation theory for L essentially reduces to the one for the quantum Frobenius group. It is known that the algebra (3.17) admits a family of mutually commuting operators given by [25]: Jn = tr1...n Rˆ 12 Rˆ 23 . . . Rˆ n−1,n W1 . . . Wn , where Rˆ ij = Rij Cij . Now we demonstrate that Jn commutes with P . For the sake of clarity we do it for n = 3. It follows from (3.18) that −1 −1 −1 W1 R¯ 14 R¯ 24 W2 R¯ 24 R¯ 34 W3 R¯ 34 . J3 P4 = Rˆ 12 Rˆ 23 P4 R¯ 14
Equation (3.9) written in terms of Rˆ acquires the form −1 ¯ −1 ˆ P3−1 Rˆ 12 (q)P3 = R¯ 23 R13 R12 R¯ 13 R¯ 23 .
By using this equation we can push P4 on the left. Taking into account that R¯ 12 is diagonal in the second space, we get −1 ¯ −1 ¯ −1 ˆ R24 R34 R12 Rˆ 23 W1 W2 W3 R¯ 34 R¯ 24 R¯ 14 . J3 P4 = P4 R¯ 14
Taking the trace in the first, second and third spaces, one gets the desired property. Now we give an example of the representation of the algebra (3.17), (3.18). Namely, −~
∂
we prove that the W -operator given by Eq. (2.27) realizes this algebra with Pj = e ∂qj . It is obvious that [W1 , W2 ] should be equal to zero since W depends only on the coordinates qi . Thus, the following relation has to be valid: [r12 (q), W1 W2 ] = 0. Substituting the explicit form of r12 (q) we have
1 Wmn qkm qkm qln 1 1 1 − Wml Wmn − Wkn − Wkn qkm qkm qln X 1 (Wkl Wmj − Wkj Wml ). + δln qlj
[r12 (q), W1 W2 ]kl mn = Wkl
1
Wmn −
1
Wkn −
(3.19)
j6=l
First we show that when l 6= n the first line in (3.19) cancels the second one. Since γ bj we get Wij = γ+q ij 1 1 γ γ γ γ 1 − − − γ + qkl qkm γ + qmn qkm γ + qkn qln γ + qmn 1 1 γ γ γ γ 1 = 0. − − γ + qml qkm γ + qmn qkm γ + qkn qln γ + qkn In the case l = n the r.h.s. of (3.19) reduces to
24
G.E. Arutyunov, S.A. Frolov
− −
1 qkm
(Wkl − Wml )2 +
X 1 (Wkl Wmj − Wkj Wml ) = qlj j6=l
X 1 γ qkm γ γ γ γ 2 b + ( − )bj bl l (γ + qkm )2 (γ + qml )2 qlj γ + qkl γ + qmj γ + qkj γ + qml 2
X Wmj qmk = Wkl . γ + qml γ + qkj j
j6=l
P W Thus, one has to show that for m 6= k the series S = j γ+qmj vanishes. To this end we kj 1 consider the following integral Q I 1 dz a6=m (qa − z + γ) Q , I= 2πi qk − z + γ a (qa − z) where the integration contour is taken around infinity. Since the integrand is nonsingular at z → ∞, we get I = 0. On the other hand, summing up the residues one finds Q X 1 a6=m (qaj + γ) Q = S. I= γ + qkj a6=j qaj j Now we turn to Eq. (3.18). Explicitly it reads as ~ ~ ~2 ~ ~2 −1 − W + Wjl [W , P ] = − + Pj kl j kl qlj − ~ qkj qkj (qlj − ~) qkj (qlj − ~) qkj X ~ ~2 ~2 − Wki − Wli (.3.20) + δjl qkj (qij − ~) qij − ~ qkj (qij − ~) i6=j
For the sake of shortness in (3.20) we adopt a convention that if in some denominator qij becomes zero, the corresponding fraction is also regarded as zero. Thus Eq. (3.20) is equivalent to the following system of equations: ~
Pj−1 [Wkl , Pj ] =
(qkl Wkl − qjl Wjl ), for k 6= l 6= j; qkj (qlj − ~) ~ Wjl , for j 6= l; Pj−1 [Wjl , Pj ] = (qlj − ~) X ~ Wki ; Pk−1 [Wkk , Pk ] = − qik − ~
(3.21) (3.22) (3.23)
i6=k
Pj−1 [Wkj , Pj ] =
~ ~(~ − qkj ) X 1 Wki (Wjj − Wkj ) + qkj qkj qij − ~
(3.24)
i6=j
−
~2 X 1 Wji , for k 6= j. qkj qij − ~ i6=j
In the sequel we shall give an explicit proof only for the latter case since the other three cases are treated quite analogously. The l.h.s. of (3.24) is 1
We are grateful to N.A. Slavnov for explaining to us the technique of treating such series.
Quantum Dynamical R-Matrices and Quantum Frobenius Group
Q Pj−1 [Wkj , Pj ]
=
Pj−1
a6=k (qaj
Q
a6=j
+ γ)
qaj
25
Q
a6=j,k (qaj
Q
Pj − Wkj = γ
+ γ − ~)
a6=j (qaj
− ~)
− Wkj .
P As to the r.h.s., one needs to calculate the sum i6=j qij1−~ Wki . For this purpose we evaluate the following integral with the integration contour around infinity: 1 I= 2πi
I
Q
dz z − qj − ~
a6=k (qa
Q
− z + γ)
a (qa
− z)
.
The regularity of the integrand at z → ∞ gives I = 0. On the other hand, summing up the residues one finds 1 I=− ~
Q a6=k Q
(qaj + γ − ~)
−
a6=j (qaj − ~)
X i6=j
1 1 Wki + Wkj . qij − ~ ~
From here one deduces the desired series: X i6=j
1 1 Wki = − qij − ~ ~
and X i6=j
1 1 Wji = − qij − ~ ~
Q a6=k Q
(qaj + γ − ~)
a6=j (qaj − ~)
Q a6=j Q
(qaj + γ − ~)
a6=j (qaj
− ~)
+
1 Wkj ~
(3.25)
+
1 Wjj . ~
(3.26)
Now substituting these sums in the r.h.s. of (3.24) one proves (3.24). It follows from our proof that the L-operator L=
X ij
Q
a6=i (qaj
Q
a6=j
+ γ)
qaj
e
∂ −~ ∂q
j
Eij
realizes the representation of the algebra (3.16). Let us briefly discuss the degeneration of the RS system to the rational CM model. To get the CM model, one should rescale ~ → γ~ and consider the limit γ → 0, L → 1 + γL. Then L is the L-operator of the CM model. From Eqs. 3.14), (3.16) one derives the quantum algebra satisfied by the L-operator of the CM model: [Q1 , L2 ] = ~
X
Eii ⊗ Eii ,
(3.27)
i
[L1 , L2 ] = ~[r12 − r¯12 , L1 ] − ~[r21 − r¯21 , L2 ] + ~2 [r12 − r¯12 , r21 − r¯21 ]. (3.28) The last formula can be written in the following elegant form [L1 + ~(r21 − r¯21 ), L2 + ~(r12 − r¯12 )] = 0.
(3.29)
26
G.E. Arutyunov, S.A. Frolov
4. Quantum R-Matrix for the Hyperbolic CM System In this section we describe a dual parametrization of T ∗ G, which is related to the hyperbolic CM system. We start with diagonalizing the group element g = V DV −1 and δVij δDi impose the constraint V e = e. The derivatives δgkl and δg are obtained in the same kl manner as in Sect. 2. Calculating the Poisson brackets of V , D and A we get {V1 , A2 } = V1 V2 s12 V2−1 , X Eii ⊗ Eii V2−1 , {D1 , A2 } = −D1 V2
(4.1) (4.2)
i
where s12 = −
X i6=j
Di Fij ⊗ Eji . Di − Dj
The L-operator corresponding to the hyperbolic CM system is defined as the following function on the phase space: L = V −1 AV.
(4.3)
Calculation of the Poisson algebra of T ∗ G in terms of L, V, D results in {L1 , L2 } = [r˜12 , L1 ] − [r˜21 , L2 ], {V1 , L2 } = V1 s12 , X {D1 , L2 } = −D1 Eii ⊗ Eii ,
(4.4) (4.5) (4.6)
i
where we have introduced the matrix 1 r˜12 = −s12 + C. 2 The matrix r˜12 can be written in the following form: qij
r˜12
1X qij 1X e 2 1X =− cth Eij ⊗ Eji + Eii ⊗ Eii , (4.7) qij Eii ⊗ Eji + 2 2 2 2 i sinh 2 i6=j
i6=j
where qi = log Di . Now we clarify the connection of r˜12 with the dynamical r-matrix found in [1]. By 1 1 1 conjugating L-operator (4.3) with the matrix D 2 : L˜ = D 2 LD− 2 and calculating the Poisson bracket for L˜ with the help of (4.4) and (4.6), we arrive at {L˜ 1 , L˜ 2 } = [R˜ 12 , L˜ 1 ] − [R˜ 21 , L˜ 2 ],
(4.8)
where 1 1 1X −1 −1 Eii ⊗ Eii R˜ 12 = D12 D22 r˜12 D1 2 D2 2 − 2 i 1X qij 1X 1 =− cth Eij ⊗ Eji + q Eii ⊗ Eji . 2 2 2 sinh 2ij
i6=j
i6=j
(4.9)
Quantum Dynamical R-Matrices and Quantum Frobenius Group
27
It is important to note that R˜ differs from the matrix found in [1] by the term 1X 1 q Eii ⊗ (Eji + Eij ). 2 sinh 2ij i6=j
However, this term does not contribute to the bracket (4.8) if we take into account the ˜ representation of the L-operator of the hyperbolic CM system: L˜ =
X
pi Eii +
i
1X 1 q Eij , 2 sinh 2ij
(4.10)
i6=j
where (p, q) form a pair of canonically conjugated variables. Thus, on the reduced space ˜ these matrices define the same Poisson structure for L. ∗ Now we quantize T G in terms of A, V and D variables. We postulate the following commutation relations: [V1 , A2 ] = ~V1 V2 s12 V2−1 , X Eii ⊗ Eii V2−1 . [D1 , A2 ] = −~D1 V2
(4.11) (4.12)
i
One can verify that the compatibility of these relations with (3.2) follows from the following identity satisfied by s12 : X s12 − D1−1 s12 D1 + Eii ⊗ Eii = C. i
By using Eqs. (3.1), (4.11) and (4.12) one derives the commutation relations for the quantum L-operator: [L1 , L2 ] = ~[r˜12 , L1 ] − ~[r˜21 , L2 ] + ~2 [r˜12 , r˜21 ], X Eii ⊗ Eii , [D1 , L2 ] = −~D1
(4.13) (4.14)
i
[V1 , L2 ] = ~V1 s12 .
(4.15)
The relation (4.13) can be also written in the form (3.29): [L1 + ~r˜21 , L2 + ~r˜12 ] = 0.
(4.16)
One can check without problems that the L-operator (4.10) realizes the representation of the algebra (4.16). To complete our discussion let us show the existence of N mutually commuting operators in the algebra composed by the L-operator and the coordinates D. Obviously, In = trAn mutually commute. Applying the technique used in the previous section to derive the quantum integrals of motion, one can show that In can be expressed as the following function of L and D: t2 (L1 + ~st212 )n . In = trAn = trV Ln V −1 = tr12 C12
In the component form these integrals look as
28
G.E. Arutyunov, S.A. Frolov
In =
X
Lj 1 j 2 δj 1 m 1
j1 ,...,jn+1 m1 ,...,mn
L j2 j3 δm1 m2
δj 1 j 2 − 1 +~ δj 2 m 1 Dj1 Dj−1 −1 2
δ m j − δm j + ~ 1 3 −1 1 2 δj3 m2 D j2 Dj 3 − 1
Ljn jn+1 δmn−1 mn + ~
!
! ···
δmn−1 jn+1 − δmn−1 jn Djn Dj−1 −1 n+1
! δjn+1 mn
δjn+1 mn .
Let us note that In can not be expressed as a linear combination of trLn solely. 5. Conclusion The approach to R-matrix quantization of the RS models proposed in the paper seems to be general. The problem of real interest is to apply it to the trigonometric and elliptic cases. As was recently shown, the trigonometric and elliptic RS models are obtained from the cotangent bundles over the centrally extended loop group [19] and double loop group [17] respectively. A natural suggestion is to use for this purpose the above-mentioned phase spaces. It is known that the Heisenberg double [26] can be regarded as a natural deformation of the cotangent bundle T ∗ G. It seems to be interesting to investigate the Poisson structure of the Heisenberg double in the same parametrization. One could expect the appearance of another Poisson structure on the Frobenius group induced by the one on the dual Poisson-Lie group G∗ . The appearance of the quantum Frobenius group F states the problem of developing the corresponding representation theory. Owing to the method of orbits, one can suggest that irreducible representations of F should be in correspondence with the symplectic leaves of the Poisson-Lie structure. On the other hand, it is known [27] that the symplectic leaves of a Poisson-Lie structure are the orbits of the dressing transformation. Studying the orbits of F ∗ and corresponding representations of F , one can hope to obtain the quantum integrable systems being some “spin” generalizations of the RS model [28]. Another open problem related to the representation theory is to find the universal Frobenius R-matrix. As was shown in [29], the Ruijsenaars Hamiltonians can be related to the special L-operator satisfying the fundamental relation RLL = LLR with Belavin’s elliptic R-matrix. It would be interesting to clarify the relationship of this approach with our construction. Acknowledgement. The authors are grateful to L.O.Chekhov, P.B.Medvedev and N.A.Slavnov for valuable discussions. This work is supported in part by the RFFR grants N96-01-00608 and N96-01-00551 and by the ISF grant a96-1516.
References 1. 2. 3. 4.
Avan, J. and Talon, M.: Phys. Lett. B303, 33–37 (1993) Babelon, O. and Viallet, C.M.: Phys. Lett. B237, 411 (1989) Avan, J., Babelon, O. and Talon, M.. Alg. Anal. 6 (2), 67 (1994) Sklyanin, E.K.: Alg. Anal. 6 (2), 227 (1994)
Quantum Dynamical R-Matrices and Quantum Frobenius Group
29
5. Braden, H.W. and Suzuki, T.: Lett. Math. Phys. 30, 147 (1994) 6. Avan, J. and Rollet, G.: The classical r-matrix for the relativistic Ruijsenaars-Schneider system. preprint BROWN-HET-1014 (1995) 7. Suris, Yu.B.: Why are the rational and hyperbolic Ruijsenaars-Schneider hierarchies governed by the same R-matrix as the Calogero-Moser ones ? hep-th/9602160 8. Nijhoff, F.W., Kuznetsov, V.B., Sklyanin, E.K. and Ragnisco, O.: Dynamical r-matrix for the elliptic Ruijsenaars-Schneider model. solv-int/9603006 9. Suris, Yu.B.: Elliptic Ruijsenaars-Schneider and Calogero-Moser hierarchies are governed by the same r-matrix. solv-int/9603011 10. Ruijsenaars, S.N.: Commun. Math. Phys. 110, 191 (1987) 11. Avan, J., Babelon, O. and Billey, E.: The Gervais-Neveu-Felder equation and the quantum CalogeroMoser systems. Preprint PAR LPTHE 95-25, May 1995; hep-th/9505091 (to appear in Commun. Math. Phys.) 12. Gervais, J.L. and Neveu, A.: Nucl. Phys. B238, 125 (1984) 13. Felder, G.: Conformal field theory and integrable systems associated to elliptic curves. hep-th/9407154 14. Babelon, O., Bernard, D. and Billey, E.: A quasi-Hopf algebra interpretation of quantum 3-j and 6-j symbols and difference equations. Preprint PAR LPTHE 95-51, IHES/P/95/91, q-alg/9511019 15. Arutyunov, G.E. and Medvedev, P.B.: Phys. Lett. A223, 66–74 (1996) 16. Arutyunov, G.E., Frolov, S.A. and Medvedev, P.B.: Elliptic Ruijsenaars-Schneider model via the Poisson reduction of the affine Heisenberg double. hep-th/9607170 17. Arutyunov, G.E., Frolov, S.A. and Medvedev, P.B.: Elliptic Ruijsenaars-Schneider model from the cotangent bundle over the two-dimensional current group hep-th/9608013 18. Alekseev, A. and .Faddeev, L.D: Comm. Math. Phys. 141, 413 (1991) 19. Gorsky, A. and Nekrasov, N.: Nucl. Phys. B414, 213 (1994); Nucl.Phys. B436, 582 (1995); Gorsky,A.: Integrable many body systems in the field theories. Prep. UUITP-16/94, (1994) 20. Faddeev, L.D.: Integrable models in (1+1)-dimensional quantum field theory. In: Recent advances in field theory and statistical mechanics. Eds. Zuber, J.B., Stord, R. (Les Houches Summer School Proc. session XXXiX, 1982), Elsevier Sci.Publ., 1984 p. 561 21. Kulish, P.P., Sklyanin, E.K.: Quantum spectral transform method. Recent developments. In: Integrable quantum field theories. Eds. Hietarinta J., Montonen C., Lect .Not. Phys. 51, 1982 p. 61 22. Olshanetsky, M.A., Perelomov, A.M.: Phys. Reps. 71, 313 (1981) 23. Belavin, A.A. and Drinfel’d, V.G.: Funk. Anal. i ego pril. 16 (3), 1–29 (1982) 24. Chari, V. and Pressley, A.: A Guide to Quantum Groups. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 25. Maillet, J.M.: Phys. Lett. B245, 480 (1990) 26. Semenov-Tian-Shansky, M.A.: Teor. Math. Phys. 93, 302 (1992)(in Russian) 27. Semenov-Tian-Shansky, M.A.: Publ. RIMS Kyoto Univ. 21 (6), 1237–1260 (1985) 28. Krichever, I.: A.Zabrodin, Spin generalizations of the Ruijsenaars-Schneider model, non-abelian 2D Toda chain and representations of Sklyanin algebra. hep-th/9505039 29. Hasegawa, K.: Ruijsenaars’ commuting difference operators as commuting transfer matrices qalg/9512029 Communicated by G. Felder
Commun. Math. Phys. 191, 31 – 60 (1998)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics c Springer-Verlag 1998
Representation Theory of Lattice Current Algebras Anton Yu. Alekseev1,2,? , Ludwig D. Faddeev3 , ¨ Fr¨ohlich2 , Volker Schomerus4,5 Jurg 1 Institute of Theoretical Physics, Uppsala University, Box 803 S-75108, Uppsala, Sweden. E-mail:
[email protected] 2 Institut f¨ ur Theoretische Physik, ETH – H¨onggerberg, CH-8093 Z¨urich, Switzerland 3 Steklov Mathematical Institute, Fontanka 27, St. Petersburg 191011, Russia. E-mail:
[email protected] 4 II. Institut f¨ ur Theoretische Physik, Universit¨at Hamburg, Luruper Chaussee 149, 22761 Hamburg, Germany. E-mail:
[email protected] 5 Research Institute for Mathematical Sciences, Kyoto University, Kyoto 606, Japan
Received: 25 April 1996 / Accepted: 14 April 1997
Abstract: Lattice current algebras were introduced as a regularization of the left- and right moving degrees of freedom in the WZNW model. They provide examples of lattice theories with a local quantum symmetry Uq (G ). Their representation theory is studied in detail. In particular, we construct all irreducible representations along with a lattice analogue of the fusion product for representations of the lattice current algebra. It is shown that for an arbitrary number of lattice sites, the representation categories of the lattice current algebras agree with their continuum counterparts. 1. Introduction Lattice current algebras were introduced and first studied several years ago (see [2, 13] and references therein). They were designed to provide a lattice regularization of the left- and right-moving degrees of freedom of the WZNW model [30] and gave a new appealing view on the quantum group structure of the model. In spite of many similarities between lattice and continuum theory, fundamental relations between them remain to be understood. In this paper we prove the conjecture of [2] that the representation categories of the lattice and continuum model agree. 1.1. Lattice current algebras. Lattice current algebras are defined over a discretized circle, i.e., their fundamental degrees of freedom are assigned to N vertices and N edges of a 1-dimensional periodic lattice. We enumerate vertices by integers n(modN ). Edges are oriented such that the nth edge points from the (n − 1)st to the nth vertex. Being defined over lattices of size N , the lattice current algebras come in families KN , N a positive integer. A precise definition of these (associative *-)algebras KN is given in the next section. We shall see that elements of KN can be assembled into (s × s)− matrices, Jn and Nn , n ∈ ZmodN , with KN -valued matrix elements such that ?
On leave of absence from Steklov Institute, Fontanka 27, St.Petersburg, Russia
32
A. Y. Alekseev, L. D. Faddeev, J. Fr¨ohlich, V. Schomerus 1
2
2
1
1
1
2
2
2
1
R0 Jn Jn =Jn Jn R ,
Jn R Jn+1 =Jn+1 Jn , 2
1
R0 N n R N n = N n R0 N n R, 2
1
1
2
0 N n Jn =Jn R N n R ,
1
2
(1.1) 2
1
0 Jn N n−1 = R N n−1 R Jn .
elements in End(V ) ⊗ KN , where To explain notations we view the matrices Jn , Nn asP V is an s-dimensional vector space. In this way Jn = mn,ς ⊗ln,ς determines elements mn,ς ∈ End(V ) and ln,ς ∈ KN which are used to define X
1
Jn =
2
mn,ς ⊗ e ⊗ ln,ς , Jn =
X
e ⊗ mn,ς ⊗ ln,ς ,
where e is the unit in End(V ). Similar definitions apply to Nn . Throughout the paper we will use the symbol σ for the permutation map σ : End(V ) ⊗ End(V ) → End(V ) ⊗ End(V ), and application of σ to an object X ∈ End(V ) ⊗ End(V ) is usually abbreviated by putting a prime, i.e. X 0 ≡ σ(X). The matrix R = R(h) ∈ End(V ) ⊗ End(V ) which appears in Eqs. (1.1) is a one-parameter solution of the Yang Baxter Equation (YBE). Such solutions can be obtained from arbitrary simple Lie algebras. The lattice Kac-Moody algebra KN depends on a number of parameters, including the “Planck constant” h in the solution R(h) of the YBE and the “lattice spacing” 1 = 1/N . A first, nontrivial test for the algebraic relations (1.1) comes from the classical continuum limit, i.e., from the limit in which h and 1 = 1/N are sent to zero. Using the rules Nn ∼ 1 − 1η(x) , Jn ∼ 1 − 1j(x) , R ∼ 1 + iγhr with x = n/N , γ being a deformation parameter and the standard prescription {., .} = lim i h→0
[., .] h
to recover the Poisson brackets from the commutators, one finds that 1 2 γ [C, j (x)− j (y)]δ(x − y) + γCδ 0 (x − y) , 2 1 2 1 2 γ {η (x), η (y)} = [C, η (x)− η (y)]δ(x − y) , 2 2 1 2 1 γ {η (x), j (y)} = [C, j (x)− j (y)]δ(x − y) + γCδ 0 (x − y) . 2 1
2
{j (x), j (y)} =
Here C is the Casimir element C = r + r0 = r + σ(r). For clarity, let us rewrite these relations in terms of components. When we express C = ta ⊗ ta and j(x) = ja (x)ta in terms of generators ta of the classical Lie algebra, the relations become c jc (x)δ(x − y) + γδab δ 0 (x − y), {ja (x), jb (y)} = γfab c ηc (x)δ(x − y), {ηa (x), ηb (y)} = γfab c jc (x)δ(x − y) + γδab δ 0 (x − y). {ηa (x), jb (y)} = γfab c 0 c c s are the structure constants of the Lie algebra, i.e., [ta , tb ] = fab t . We easily The fab recognize the first equation as the classical Poisson bracket of the left currents in the WZNW model. Furthermore, the quantity j R (x) ≡ j L (x) − η(x) Poisson commutes
Representation Theory of Lattice Current Algebras
33
with j L (x) ≡ j(x) and satisfies the Poisson commutation relations of the right currents, i.e., 1 2 1 2 γ {j R (x), j R (y)} = − [C, j R (x)− j R (y)]δ(x − y) − γCδ 0 (x − y) , 2 1
2
{j R (x), j L (y)} = 0 .
(1.2)
Hence we conclude that the lattice current algebra as described in Eqs. (1.1) is the quantum lattice counterpart of the classical left and right currents. One would like to establish a close relationship between the lattice current algebra and its counterpart in the continuum model. A first step in this direction is described in this paper. We find that the representation categories of the lattice and the continuum theory coincide. For this to work, it is rather crucial to combine left- and right-moving degrees of freedom. For instance, the center of the lattice current algebra with only one chiral sector changes dramatically depending on whether the number of lattice sites is odd or even. The only *-operation known for such algebras [26] is constructed in the case of Uq (sl(2)) and does not admit straightforward generalizations. However, no such difficulties appear in the full theory. It therefore appears to be rather unnatural to constrain the discrete models to one chiral sector. 1.2. Main results. In the next section we use the methods developed in [4] to provide a precise definition of lattice current algebras. In contrast to the heuristic definition we use in this introduction, our precise formulation is applicable to general modular Hopf algebras G, in particular to Uq (G ), for an arbitrary semisimple Lie algebra G . The main result of Sect. 3 provides a complete list of irreducible representations for the lattice current algebras KN . Theorem A. (Representations of KN ) For every semisimple modular Hopf algebra G and every integer N ≥ 1, there exists a lattice current algebra KN which admits a family IJ on Hilbert spaces WNIJ . Here the labels I, J run of irreducible ∗-representations DN through classes of finite-dimensional, irreducible representations of the algebra G. The two labels I, J that are needed to specify a representation of KN correspond to the two chiralities in the theory of current algebras. In fact, the algebra K1 is isomorphic to the quantum double of the algebra G [21] and the pairs I, J label its representations. These results are in agreement with the investigation of related models in [22]. Next, we introduce an inductive limit K∞ of the family of finite dimensional algebras KN . It can be done using the block-spin transformation [13] KN → KN +1 . Under this embedding, every irreducible representation of KN +1 splits into a direct sum of IJ irreducible representations of KN . It appears that the representation DN +1 always splits IJ into several copies of the representation DN . Thus, representations of the inductive limit K∞ are in one to one correspondence with representations of K1 (or KN for arbitrary finite N ). In order to be able to take tensor products of representations of the lattice current algebras, we introduce a family of homomorphisms 3N,M : KN +M −1 → KN ⊗ KM , which satisfy the co-associativity condition
34
A. Y. Alekseev, L. D. Faddeev, J. Fr¨ohlich, V. Schomerus
(id ⊗ 3M,L ) ◦ 3N,L+M −1 = (3N,M ⊗ id) ◦ 3M +N −1,L . Let us notice that the co-product 3N,M is supposed to provide a lattice counterpart of the co-product defined by the structure of superselection sectors in algebraic field theory [9, 10, 27, 28]. By combining the co-product 3N,M with the block-spin transformation we construct a new co-product 1N : KN → KN ⊗ KN which preserves the number of sites in the lattice (see Subsect. 4.3). This co-product is compatible with the block-spin transformation and, hence, it defines a co-product for the inductive limit K∞ : 1∞ : K ∞ → K ∞ ⊗ K ∞ . Our second result concerns tensor products of representations of the lattice current algebra K∞ . Theorem B (Representation category of the lattice current algebra). The braided tensor categories of representations of the lattice current algebra K∞ with the coproduct 1∞ and of the Hopf algebra K1 with the co-product 11 coincide. In principle, our theory must be modified to apply to Uq (G ), q p = 1. It is well known that Uq (G ) at roots of unity is not semi-simple. This can be cured by a process of truncation which retains only the “physical” part of the representation theory of quantized universal enveloping algebras. The algebraic implementation of this idea has been explained in [4] and can be transferred easily to the present situation. We plan to propose an alternative treatment in a forthcoming publication.
2. Definition of the Lattice Current Algebra Our goal is to assign a family of lattice current algebras (parametrized by the number N of lattice sites) to every modular Hopf-*-algebra G. Before we describe the details, we briefly recall some fundamental ingredients from the theory of Hopf algebras. 2.1. Semisimple, modular Hopf-algebras. By definition, a Hopf algebra is a quadruple (G, , 1, S) of an associative algebra G (the “symmetry algebra ”) with unit e ∈ G, a onedimensional representation : G → C (the “co-unit”), a homomorphism 1 : G → G ⊗G ( the “co-product”) and an anti-automorphism S : G → G (the “antipode”). These objects obey a set of basic axioms which can be found e.g. in [1]. The Hopf algebra (G, , 1, S) is called quasitriangular if there is an invertible element R ∈ G ⊗ G such that R 1(ξ) = 10 (ξ) R for all ξ ∈ G , (id ⊗ 1)(R) = R13 R12 ,
(1 ⊗ id)(R) = R13 R23 .
Here 10 = σ ◦ 1, with σ : G ⊗ G → G ⊗ G the permutation map, and we are using the standard notation for the elements Rij ∈ G ⊗ G ⊗ G. For a ribbon Hopf-algebra one postulates, in addition, the existence of a certain invertible central element v ∈ G (the “ribbon element”) which factorizes R0 R ∈ G ⊗ G (here R0 = σ(R)), in the sense that R0 R = (v ⊗ v)1(v −1 )
Representation Theory of Lattice Current Algebras
35
(see [24] for details). The ribbon element v and the element R allow us to construct a distinguished grouplike element g ∈ G by the formula X S(rς2 )rς1 , g −1 = v −1 P 1 rς ⊗ rς2 of R. The element g is where the elements rςi come from the expansion R = important in the definition of q-traces below. We want this structure to be consistent with a *-operation on G. To be more precise, we require that (2.1) R∗ = (R−1 )0 = σ(R−1 ) , 1(ξ)∗ = 10 (ξ ∗ ), and that v, g are unitary 1 . This structure is of particular interest, since it appears in the theory of the quantized universal enveloping algebras Uq (G ) when the complex parameter q has values on the unit circle [18]. At this point we assume that G is semisimple, so that every representation of G can be decomposed into a direct sum of finite-dimensional, irreducible representations. From every equivalence class [I] of irreducible representations of G, we may pick a representative τ I , i.e., an irreducible representation of G on a δI -dimensional Hilbert space V I . The quantum trace trqI is a linear functional acting on elements X ∈ End(V I ) by trqI (X) = T rI (Xτ I (g)) . Here T rI denotes the standard trace on End(V I ) with T rI (eI ) = δI and g ∈ G has been defined above. Evaluation of the unit element eI ∈ End(V I ) with trqI gives the quantum dimension of the representation τ I , dI ≡ trqI (eI ) . Furthermore, we assign a number SIJ to every pair of representations τ I , τ J , SIJ ≡ N (trqI ⊗ trqJ )(R0 R)IJ
with (R0 R)IJ = (τ I ⊗ τ J )(R0 R) ,
for a suitable, real normalization factor N . The numbers SIJ form the so-called S-matrix S. Modular Hopf algebras are ribbon Hopf algebras with an invertible S-matrix 2 . Let us finally recall that the tensor product, τ × τ 0 , of two representations τ, τ 0 of a Hopf algebra is defined by 0 0 (τ × τ )(ξ) = (τ ⊗ τ )1(ξ) for all ξ ∈ G .
In particular, one may construct the tensor product τ I × τ J of two irreducible representations. According to our assumption that G is semisimple, such tensor products of representations can be decomposed into a direct sum of irreducible representations, τ K . IJ in this Clebsch-Gordan decomposition of τ I × The multiplicities NK τ J are called fusion rules. Among all our assumptions on the structure of the Hopf-algebra (G, , 1, S) (quasitriangularity, existence of a ribbon element v, semisimplicity of G and invertibility of S), semisimplicity of G is the most problematic one. In fact it is violated by the algebras 1 Here we have fixed ∗ on G ⊗ G by (ξ ⊗ η)∗ = ξ ∗ ⊗ η ∗ . Following [18], we could define an alternative involution † on G ⊗ G which incorporates a permutation of components, i.e., (ξ ⊗ η)† = η † ⊗ ξ † and ξ † = ξ ∗ for all ξ, η ∈ G. With respect to †, 1 becomes an ordinary ∗ -homomorphism and R is unitary. 2 If a diagonal matrix T is introduced according to T 2 I IJ = $δI,J dI τ (v) (with an appropriate complex factor $), then S and T furnish a projective representation of the modular group SL(2, Z).
36
A. Y. Alekseev, L. D. Faddeev, J. Fr¨ohlich, V. Schomerus
Uq (G ) when q is a root of unity. It is sketched in [4] how “truncation” can cure this problem, once the theory has been extended to weak quasi-Hopf algebras [18]. Example (Hopf-algebra Zq ). We wish to give one fairly trivial example for the algebraic structure discussed so far. Our example comes from the group Zp . To be more precise, we consider the associative algebra G generated by one element g subject to the relation g p = 1. On this algebra, a co-product, co-unit and an antipode can be defined by 1(g) = g ⊗ g , S(g) = g −1 , (g) = 1 . We observe that G is a commutative semisimple algebra. It has p one-dimensional representations τ r (g) = q r , r = 0, . . . , p − 1, where q is a root of unity, q = e2πi/p . We may construct characteristic projectors P r ∈ G for these representations according to Pr =
p−1
1 X −rs s q g for r = 0, . . . , p − 1 . p s=0
r
One can easily check that τ (P s ) = δr,s . The elements P r are employed to obtain a nontrivial R-matrix, X q rs P r ⊗ P s . R= r,s
When evaluated with a pair of representations τ r , τ s we find that (τ r ⊗ τ s )(R) = q rs . The R-matrix satisfies all the axioms stated above and thus turns G into a quasitriangular P −r2 Hopf-algebra. Moreover, a ribbon element is provided by v = q Pr . We can finally introduce a ∗-operation on G such that g ∗ = g −1 . The consistency relations 2.1 follow from the co-commutativity of 1, i.e. 10 = 1, and the property R = R0 . A direct computation shows that the S-matrix is invertible only for odd integers p. Summarizing all this, we have constructed a family of semisimple ribbon Hopf-*-algebras Zq , q = exp(2πi/p). They are modular Hopf-algebras for all odd integers p. 2.2. R-matrix formalism. Before we propose a definition of lattice current algebras, we mention that Hopf algebras G are intimately related to the objects Nn , n ∈ ZmodN, introduced in Eq. (1.1). To understand this relation, let us introduce another (auxiliary) copy, Ga , of G and let us consider the R-matrix as an object in Ga ⊗ G. To distinguish the latter clearly from the usual R, we denote it by N± , N− ≡ R−1 ∈ Ga ⊗ G , N+ ≡ R0 ∈ Ga ⊗ G . Quasi-triangularity of the R-matrix furnishes the relations 2
1
1a (N± ) =N ± N ± , 2
1
2
1
1
2
R N + N − =N − N + R , 1
(2.2)
2
R N ± N ± = N ± N ±R . Here we use the same notations as in the introduction, and 1a (N± ) = (1 ⊗ id)(N± ) ∈ Ga ⊗Ga ⊗G. The subscript a reminds us that 1a acts on the auxiliary (i.e. first) component of N± . To be perfectly consistent, the objects R in the preceding equations should all be equipped with a lower index a to show that R ∈ Ga ⊗ Ga etc. We hope that no confusion will arise from omitting this subscript on R. Equations (2.2) are somewhat redundant:
Representation Theory of Lattice Current Algebras
37
in fact, the exchange relations on the second line follow from the first equation in the first line. This underlines that the formula for 1a (N± ) encodes information about the product in G rather than the co-product 3 . More explanations of this point follow in Subsect. 2.3. Next, we combine N+ and N− into one element N ≡ N+ (N− )−1 = R0 R ∈ Ga ⊗ G . From the properties of N± we obtain an expression for the action of 1a on N , 2
1
1
2
1a (N ) = N + N + (N − )−1 (N − )−1 1
2
1
1
1
2
= R−1 N + N + R(N − )−1 (N − )−1 2
2
= R−1 N + (N − )−1 R N + (N − )−1 1
2
= R−1 N R N . As seen above, the formula for 1a (N ) encodes relations in the algebra G and implies, in particular, the following exchange relations for N : 1
2
R0 N R N = R0 R1a (N ) = R0 10a (N )R 2
1
= N R0 N R . This kind of relations first appeared in [23]. We used them in the introduction when describing the objects Nn assigned to the sites of the lattice. Thus we have shown that, for any modular Hopf-algebra G, one may construct objects N obeying the desired quadratic relations. The other direction, namely the problem of how to construct a modular Hopf-algebra G from an object N satisfying the exchange relations described above, is more subtle. To begin with, one has to choose linear maps π : Ga → C in the dual Ga0 of Ga . When such linear forms π ∈ Ga0 act on the first tensor factor of N ∈ Ga ⊗ G they produce elements in G: π(N ) ≡ (π ⊗ id)(N ) ∈ G for all π ∈ Ga0 . π(N ) ∈ G will be called the π-component of N or just component of N . Under certain technical assumptions it has been shown in [6] that the components of N generate the algebra G. In this sense one can reconstruct the modular Hopf-algebra G from the object N. Lemma 1 ([6]). Let Ga be a finite-dimensional, semisimple modular Hopf algebra and N be the algebra generated by components of N ∈ Ga ⊗ N subject to the relations 1
2
N R N = R1a (N ) , where we use the same notations as above. Then N can be decomposed into a product of elements N± ∈ Ga ⊗ N , 3 The co-product 1 of G acts on N according to 1(N ) = (id ⊗ 1)(N ) = N N ± ± ± ± ˜ ± ∈ Ga ⊗ G ⊗ G. Here N± [N˜ ± ] on the right hand side of the equation have the unit element e ∈ G in the third [second] tensor factor
38
A. Y. Alekseev, L. D. Faddeev, J. Fr¨ohlich, V. Schomerus −1 N = N + N− such that −1 ∈ Ga ⊗ N ⊗ N , 1(N ) ≡ N+ N˜ N− −1 ∈ Ga ⊗ N (N ) ≡ e ∈ Ga , S(N± ) ≡ N±
define a Hopf-algebra structure on N . Here, the action of 1, , S on the second tensor −1 are supposed component of N, N± is understood. In the equation for 1(N ), N+ , N− P to have a trivial entry inPthe third component while N˜ = nς ⊗ e ⊗ Nς with e being the unit in N and N = nς ⊗ Nς ∈ Ga ⊗ N . As a Hopf algebra, N is isomorphic to Ga . Let us remark that the ∗-operation in G induces a ∗-operation in N which looks as follows: (2.3) N+∗ = N− . In our definition of the lattice current algebras below, we shall describe the degrees of freedom at the lattice sites directly in terms of elements ξ ∈ G, instead of working with N (as in the introduction). The δI -dimensional representations τ I of Ga ∼ = G furnish a δI × δI -matrix of linear forms on Ga . When these forms act on the first tensor factor of N , we obtain a matrix N I ∈ End(V I ) ⊗ G of elements in G, N I ≡ τ I (N ) = (τ I ⊗ id)(N ) . These matrices will turn out to be useful. us illustrate all these remarks on the examExample (R-matrix formalism for PZqrs). Let q P r ⊗ P s and that Zp has only one-dimensional ple of G = Zp . Recall that R = representations given by τ r (g) = q r . Evaluation of the objects N± in representations τ r r produces elements N± = (τ r ⊗ id)(N± ) ∈ C ⊗ Zq ∼ = Zq . Explicitly, they are given by X X r q rs Ps = g r and N− = q −rs Ps = g −r . N+r = Together with the property (τ r ⊗ τ s )1 ∼ = τ r+s the relations (2.2) become g ±(r+s) = g ±s g ±r , q rs g s g −r = g −r g s q rs . For N ∈ Zq ⊗ Zq we find N=
X
q 2rs Pr ⊗ Ps and N r = g 2r .
As predicted by the general theory, the elements N r ∈ Zq generate the algebra Zq when p is odd. 2.3. Definition of KN . Next, we turn to the definition of the lattice current algebras KN associated to a fixed modular Hopf algebra. Before entering the abstract formalism, it is useful to analyse the classical geometry of the discrete model. Our classical continuum theory contains two Lie-algebra valued fields, namely η(x) and j(x). To describe a configuration of η, for instance, we have to place a copy of the Lie-algebra at every point x on the circle. On the lattice, there are only N discrete points left and hence configurations of the lattice field η involve only N copies of the Lie algebra. When
Representation Theory of Lattice Current Algebras
39
passing from the continuum to the lattice, we encode the information about the field j(x) in the holonomies along links, Z jn = P exp( j(x)dx) . n
R
th
Here n denotes integration along the n link that connects the (n − 1)st with the nth site. The classical lattice field jn has values in the Lie group. Let us remark that, even at the level of Poisson brackets, the variables jn can not be easily included into the Poisson algebra. The reason is that jn ’s fail to be continuous functions of the currents. Therefore, we should regularize the Poisson brackets (or commutation relations) of the lattice currents. This regularization is done in the most elegant way with the help of Rmatrices. This consideration explains an immediate appearance of the quantum groups in the description of the lattice current algebras. In analogy to the classical description of the lattice field η, the lattice current algebras contain N commuting copies of the algebra G or, more precisely, KN contains an N -fold tensor product G ⊗N of G as a subalgebra. We denote by Gn the subalgebra G n = e ⊗ . . . ⊗ G ⊗ . . . ⊗ e ⊂ G ⊗N , where G appears in the nth position and all other entries in the tensor product are trivial. The canonical isomorphism of G and Gn ⊂ G ⊗N furnishes the homomorphisms ιn : G → G ⊗N for all n = 1, . . . , N. We think of the copies Gn of G as being placed at the N sites of a periodic lattice, with Gn assigned to the nth site. In addition, the definition of KN will involve generators Jn , n = 1, . . . , N . The generator Jn sits on the link connecting the (n − 1)st with the nth site. Definition 1. The lattice current algebra KN is generated by components 4 of Jn ∈ Ga ⊗ KN , n = 1, . . . , N, along with elements in G ⊗N . These generators are subject to three different types of relations. 1. Covariance properties express that the Jn are tensor operators transforming under the action of elements ξm ∈ Gm like holonomies in a gauge theory, i.e., ιn (ξ)Jn = Jn 1n (ξ) for all ξ ∈ G, 1n−1 (ξ)Jn = Jn ιn−1 (ξ), for all ξ ∈ G ιm (ξ)Jn = Jn ιm (ξ) for all ξ ∈ G, m 6= n, n − 1 modN .
(2.4)
The covariance relations (2.4) make sense as relations in Ga ⊗ KN , if ιn (ξ) ∈ Gn ⊂ KN is regarded as an element ιn (ξ) ∈ Ga ⊗ KN with trivial entry in the first tensor factor and 1n (ξ) ≡ (id ⊗ ιn )1(ξ) ∈ Ga ⊗ Gn ⊂ Ga ⊗ KN . 2. Functoriality for elements Jn on a fixed link means that 1
2
Jn Jn = R1a (Jn ).
(2.5)
This is to be understood as a relation in Ga ⊗ Ga ⊗ KN , where 1a : Ga ⊗ KN → Ga ⊗ Ga ⊗ KN acts trivially on the second tensor factor KN and R = R ⊗ e ∈ 4 Recall that a component of J is an element π(J ) ≡ (π ⊗ id)(J ) in the algebra K . Here π runs n n n N through the dual Ga0 of Ga .
40
A. Y. Alekseev, L. D. Faddeev, J. Fr¨ohlich, V. Schomerus
Ga ⊗ Ga ⊗ KN . The other notations were explained in the introduction. We also require that the elements Jn possess an inverse Jn−1 ∈ Ga ⊗ KN such that Jn Jn−1 = e, Jn−1 Jn = e .
(2.6)
3. Braid relations between elements Jn , Jm assigned to different links have to respect the gauge symmetry and locality of the model. These principles require 1
2
2
1
if n 6= m, m ± 1modN,
Jn Jm =Jm Jn 1
2
2
1
Jn R Jn+1 = Jn+1 Jn .
(2.7)
R denotes the element R ⊗ e ∈ Ga ⊗ Ga ⊗ KN as before. The lattice current algebra KN contains a subalgebra JN generated by components of the Jn only. They are subject to functoriality (2) and braid relations (3). The subalgebra JN admits an action of G ⊗N (by generalized derivations) such that the full lattice current algebra KN can be regarded as a semi-direct product of JN and G ⊗N with respect to this action. Our covariance relations (1) give a precise definition of the semi-direct product. Let us briefly explain how Definition 1 is related to the description we used in the introduction. The relation of the Hopf algebras Gn and the objects Nn has already been discussed. Our covariance relations in Eq. (2.4) correspond to the exchange relations between N and J in the third line of Eq. (1.1). They can be related explicitly with the help of the quasi-triangularity of R, using the formula N = R0 R. We have, for instance, 2
1
1
1
0 0 N n Jn = (e ⊗ (R R)n ) Jn =Jn [(id ⊗ 1n )(R R)]213 1
1
2
= Jn R(e ⊗ (R0 R)n )R0 =Jn R N n R0 , where we use the notation (R0 R)n = (id ⊗ ιn )(R0 R) ∈ Ga ⊗ Gn and R = (R ⊗ e) ∈ Ga ⊗ Ga ⊗ KN as usual. [.]213 means that the first and the second tensor factors of the expression inside the brackets are exchanged. For finite-dimensional semisimple modular Hopf algebras G, Lemma 1 implies that one could define KN using the objects Nn ∈ Ga ⊗ Gn ⊂ Ga ⊗ KN instead of elements η ∈ G ⊗N . The generators Nn would have to obey the exchange relations stated in Eq. (1.1) and 1
2
N n R N n = R1a (Nn ) . The functoriality relation for Jn did not appear in the introduction. But we can use it now to derive quadratic relations for the Jn in much the same way as has been done for N , earlier in this section. Indeed we find 1
2
R0 Jn Jn = R0 R1a (Jn ) = R0 10a (Jn )R 2
1
= Jn Jn R . This exchange relation is the one used in the introduction to describe the lattice currents Jn . When the first two tensor factors in this equation are evaluated with representations of Ga ∼ = G one derives quadratic relations for the KN -valued matrices, JnI ≡ (τ I ⊗ id)(Jn ) ∈ End(V I ) ⊗ KN .
Representation Theory of Lattice Current Algebras
41
As we discussed earlier in this section, elements in the algebra KN can be obtained from Jn with the help of linear forms π ∈ Ga0 . To understand functoriality properly one must realize that it describes the “multiplication table” for elements π(Jn ) ∈ KN . If we pick two linear forms π1 , π2 ∈ Ga0 on Ga , the corresponding elements in KN satisfy π1 (Jn )π2 (Jn ) = (π1 ⊗ π2 )(R1(Jn )) . We can rewrite this equation by means of the (twisted) associative product ∗ for elements πi ∈ Ga0 , (π1 ∗ π2 )(ξ) ≡ (π1 ⊗ π2 )(R1(ξ)) . It allows us to express the product π1 (Jn )π2 (Jn ) in terms of the element π1 ∗ π2 ∈ Ga0 , π1 (Jn )π2 (Jn ) = (π1 ∗ π2 )(Jn ) for all π1 , π2 ∈ Ga0 . Remark. It may help here to invoke the analogy with a more familiar situation. In fact, the Hopf algebra structure of G induces the standard (non-twisted) product · on its dual G0, (π1 · π2 )(ξ) ≡ (π1 ⊗ π2 )(1(ξ)) for all ξ ∈ G . Let us identify π ∈ Ga0 with the image π(T ) = (π ⊗ id)(T ) of some universal object T ∈ Ga ⊗ G 0 and insert T into the definition of the product ·, π1 (T )π2 (T ) ≡ (π1 ⊗ π2 )(1a (T )) = (π1 · π2 )(T ) . Here and in the following we omit the · when multiplying elements π(T ). The derived multiplication rules for components of T ∈ Ga ⊗ G 0 are equivalent to the following functoriality: 1
2
T T = 1a (T ) 1
and imply RTT-relations:
2
2
1
R T T =T T R .
Such relations are known to define quantum groups, and hence our variables Jn describe some sort of twisted quantum groups. This fits nicely with the nature of the classical lattice field jn . As we have noted earlier, the latter takes values in a Lie group. We saw above that the definition of a product for components of Jn implies the desired quadratic relations. The converse is not true in general, i.e. functoriality is a stronger requirement than the quadratic relations. In the familiar case of Uq (sl2 ) for example, functoriality furnishes also the standard determinant relations which are usually “added by hand” when algebras are defined in terms of quadratic relations. Due to functoriality we are thus able to develop a universal theory which does not explicitly depend on the specific properties of the Hopf algebra G. We have shown that the mathematical definition of KN represented in this section agrees with the description used in the introduction. The algebra KN now appears as a special example of the “graph algebras” defined and studied in [4] to quantize ChernSimons theories. This observation will enable us to use some of the general properties established there. The most important one among such general properties is the existence of a *operation. On the copies Gn , a *-operation comes from the structure of the modular Hopf-*-algebra G. Its action can be extended to the algebra KN by the formula Jn∗ = Sn−1 Jn−1 Sn−1 ,
(2.8)
42
A. Y. Alekseev, L. D. Faddeev, J. Fr¨ohlich, V. Schomerus
where Sn = (id⊗ιn )[1(κ−1 )(κ⊗κ)R−1 ] ∈ Ga ⊗Gn ⊂ Ga ⊗KN . Here ιn : G → Gn ⊂ KN is the canonical embedding, and the central element κ ∈ G is a certain square root of the ribbon element v, i.e. κ2 = v (cp. [4] for details). Let us note that the formula (2.8) can be rewritten using the elements Nn,± ∈ Ga ⊗ Gn constructed from the R-element according to Nn,+ ≡ (id ⊗ ιn )(R0 ) , Nn,− ≡ (id ⊗ ιn )(R−1 ) . The conjugate current is expressed as −1 −1 Jn Nn−1,− (κn−1 κn ) . Jn∗ = (κn−1 κn )−1 Nn,−
(2.9)
Here κn−1 = ιn−1 (κ), κn = ιn (κ). In order to verify the property (Jn∗ )∗ = Jn , one uses the following identities: −1 −1 vn−1 Jn vn−1 = va Nn−1 Jn , vn−1 Jn vn = va−1 Jn Nn ,
where va is the ribbon element in the auxilary Hopf algebra Ga . The ribbon elements v at different lattice sites generate automorphisms of the lattice current algebra which resemble the evolution automorphism in the quantum top [3]. Example (The U (1)-current algebra on the lattice). It is quite instructive to apply the general definition of lattice current algebras to the case G = Zq . Recall that Zq is generated by one unitary element g which satisfies g p = 1. Representations τ s of G were labeled by an integer s = 1, . . . , p − 1, and τ s (g) = q s with q = exp(2πi/p). We can apply the one-dimensional representations τ s to the current Jn ∈ Ga ⊗ KN to obtain elements Jns = τ s (Jn ) = (τ s ⊗ id)(Jn ) ∈ KN . Functoriality becomes Jns Jnt = q ts Jns+t , where we have used that (τ s ⊗ τ t )1a (ξ) = τ s+t (ξ) and (τ s ⊗ τ t )(R−1 ) = q −st (s + t is to be understood modulo p). The relation allows to generate the elements Jns from Jn1 ∈ KN . Observe that Jn0 is the unit element e in the algebra KN . From the previous equation we deduce that the pth power of the generator Jn1 is proportional to e, (Jn1 )p = q p(p−1)/2 Jnp = q p(p−1)/2 e . This motivates us to introduce the renormalized generators wn = q (1−p)/2 Jn1 ∈ Kn which obey wnp = e. In the following it suffices to specify relations for the generators wn and gn = ιn (g) of KN . The covariance equations (2.4) read gn wn = qwn gn , wn gn−1 = qgn−1 wn , since (τ 1 ⊗ id)1(g) = qg. The exchange relations for currents become wn wn+1 = q −1 wn+1 wn . The identity 1(κ−1 )(κ ⊗ κ)R−1 = e ⊗ e with κ =
P
q −r
2
/2
Pr finally furnishes
wn∗ = wn−1 . At this point one can easily recognize the algebra of wn ’s as the lattice U (1)-current algebra [12].
Representation Theory of Lattice Current Algebras
43
2.4. The right currents. Let us stress that there is a major ideological difference between our discussion of lattice current algebras and the work in [4]. In the context of Chern Simons theories, the graph algebras were introduced as auxiliary objects, and physical variables of the theory were to be constructed from objects assigned to the links, i.e. from the variables Jn . Here the Jn ’s represent only the left-currents, and we expect also right- currents to be present in the theory. They are constructed from the variables Jn and the elements ξn ∈ Gn and hence give a physical meaning to the graph algebras. We define a family of new variables JnR ∈ Ga ⊗ KN on the lattice by setting −1 −1 Jn Nn−1,+ . JnR = Nn,−
The JnR turn out to provide the right currents in our theory. For the rest of this section we will use the symbol JnL to denote the original left currents Jn . Proposition 2 (Right-currents on the lattice). With JnR ∈ Ga ⊗ KN defined as above, one finds that L commute for arbitrary n, m, 1. the elements JnR and Jm 1
2
2
1
R L L R Jn Jm =Jm Jn ;
2. the elements JnR satisfy the following exchange and functoriality relations: 2
1
1
2
R R R R Jn+1 R Jn = Jn Jn+1 , 2
(2.10)
1
R R R Jn Jn = R1a (Jn ) .
(2.11)
(Here we are using the same notations as in the definition of the lattice current algebra above.) If we denote the subalgebra in KN generated by the components of left currents JnL by JNL and, similarly, use JNR to denote the subalgebra generated by components of JnR , the result of this proposition can be summarized in the following statement: JNR and JNL form commuting subalgebras in KN , and JNR is isomorphic to (JNL )op . Here the subscript op means opposite multiplication. Both statements have their obvious counterparts in the continuum theory (cp. Eq. (1.2)). Example (The right U (1)-currents). We continue the discussion of the U (1)-current algebra on the lattice by constructing the right currents. Our general theory teaches us to consider wnR = gn wn−1 gn−1 . 1 1 = ιn (g) and gn−1 = Nn−1,− = ιn−1 (g). The reader is invited to check Here gn = Nn,+ L that these elements commute with wn = wn .
2.5. Monodromies. In the continuum R x theory one is particularly interested in the behavior of the chiral fields g C (x) = P exp( 0 j C (x)dx) under rotations by 2π, i.e. the monodromy of g C . Here and in the following, C stands for either L or R. The monodromy of g C is determined by the expression I C m = P exp( j C (x)dx).
44
A. Y. Alekseev, L. D. Faddeev, J. Fr¨ohlich, V. Schomerus
Due to the regularizing effect of the lattice, left and right monodromies, M L , M R , are relatively easy to construct and control for our discrete current algebra. They are obtained as an ordered product of the chiral lattice holonomies JnL or JnR along the whole circle, i.e. L M L = va1−N J1L J2L · · · JN
and
R M R = va1−N JN · · · J2R J1R .
(2.12) (2.13)
When we derive relations for the monodromies, it is convenient to include the factors involving va = v ⊗ e ∈ Ga ⊗ KN . The definition in terms of left and right currents produces elements M L and M R in Ga ⊗KN . Their algebraic structure differs drastically from the properties of the currents Jn . We encourage the reader to verify the following list of equations: 1
2
L L L M R M = R1a (M ),
10 (ξ)M L = M L 10 (ξ),
2
1
R R R M R M = R1a (M ) ,
100 (ξ)M R = M R 100 (ξ)
for all ξ ∈ G and with 100 (ξ) = (id ⊗ ι0 )(10 (ξ)) = (id ⊗ ι0 )(σ ◦ 1(ξ)). The functoriality relations are familiar from Subsect. 2.2 and imply that the algebra generated by components of the monodromy M L or M R is isomorphic to G or Gop . There are several places throughout the paper where this observation becomes relevant for a better understanding of our results. As usual, we may evaluate the elements M C in irreducible representations of Ga . This results in a set of KN valued matrices M C,I ≡ (τ I ⊗ id)(M C ). Their quantum traces cIC ≡ tr Iq (M C,I ) are elements in the algebra KN which have a number of remarkable properties. First, they are central elements in the lattice current algebra KN , i.e. the cIC commute with all elements A ∈ KN . Even more important is that cIR , cIL ∈ KN generate two commuting copies of the Verlinde algebra [29]. Explicitly this means that X ¯ K IJ K ∗ NK cC and (cK cIC cJC = C ) = cC ¯ denotes the unique label such that N K K¯ = 1, for C = R, L. Here and in the following K 0 and 0 stands for the trivial representation τ 0 = . If the S-matrix SIJ = N (tr Iq ⊗ tr Jq )(R0 R) is invertible, and N is suitably chosen, the linear combinations χIC =
X
N dI SI J¯ cJC
J
provide a set of orthogonal central projectors in KN , for each chirality C = R, L, i.e., χIC χJC = δIJ χIC , (χIC )∗ = χIC . Proofs of all these statements can be found in [4]. We will see in the next section that products χIL χJR provide a complete set of minimal central projectors in the lattice current algebra or, in other words, they furnish a complete set of characteristic projectors for the irreducible representations of KN .
Representation Theory of Lattice Current Algebras
45
Example (The center of the lattice U (1) current algebra). In terms of the variable wn = q (1−p)/2 Jn1 = −q 1/2 Jn1 (cf. Subsect. 2.3 for notations), the definition of the monodromy M L,1 = (τ 1 ⊗ id)(M L ) becomes M L,1 = (−1)N q 3N/2−1 w1 w2 · · · wN ∈ KN . In this particular example, the quantum trace is trivial so that c1L = M L,1 . It is easily checked that c1L commutes with all the generators wn , gn ∈ KN and that it satisfies (c1L )p = c0L = e . Of course, this relation follows also from the formula crL csL = considerations apply to the right currents.
P
Ntrs ctL = cr+s L . Similar
2.6. The inductive limit K∞ . So far, the lattice current algebras KN depend on the number N of lattice sites, and one may ask what happens when N tends to infinity. A mathematically precise meaning to this question is provided by the notion of inductive limit. The latter requires an explicit choice of embeddings of lattice current algebras for different numbers of lattice sites. They will come from some kind of inverse block-spin transformation [13]. Suppose we are given two lattice current algebras KN and KN +1 with generators Jn , n = 1, . . . , N and Jˆm , m = 1, . . . , N + 1 respectively. The embeddings of G into KN or KN +1 will be denoted by ιn or ιˆm . An embedding γN : KN → KN +1 is furnished by γN (Jn ) = Jˆn for all n < N, γN (JN ) = va−1 JˆN JˆN +1 , and γN (ιn (ξ)) = ιˆn (ξ) for all n < N , γN (ιN (ξ)) = ιˆN +1 (ξ) . The intuitive idea behind γN is to pass from KN to KN +1 by dividing the N th link on the lattice of length N into two new links, so that we end up with a lattice of length ˆ ∈ Ga ⊗ KN +1 , and, N + 1. Observe that γN maps the monodromies M ∈ Ga ⊗ KN to M consequently, the same holds for our projectors χIL , χJR ∈ KN and χˆ IL , χˆ JR ∈ KN +1 , γN (χIL ) = χˆ IL , γN (χJR ) = χˆ JR .
(2.14)
Since the set of numbers N is directed, the collection of KN , together with the maps γN , forms a directed system, and we can define the inductive limit K∞ ≡ lim KN . N →∞
S
By definition, K∞ = N KN / ∼, where two elements AN ∈ KN and AN 0 ∈ KN 0 are equivalent, iff AN is mapped to AN 0 by a string of embeddings γM , i.e., AN 0 = γN 0 −1 ◦. . .◦γN +1 ◦γN (AN ). For the lattice U (1)-current algebra, a detailed investigation of this inductive limit was performed in [5]. We have chosen to define the block-spin transformation by dividing the N th link of the lattice. Now we introduce another block spin operation by dividing the 1st link of the lattice:
46
A. Y. Alekseev, L. D. Faddeev, J. Fr¨ohlich, V. Schomerus
γ˜ N (Jn ) = Jˆn+1 for all n > 1, γ˜ N (J1 ) = va−1 Jˆ1 Jˆ2 , and γ˜ N (ιn (ξ)) = ιˆn+1 (ξ) for all n . Notice that the two block-spin operations ‘commute’ with each other: γ˜ N +1 ◦ γN = γN +1 ◦ γ˜ N . While the map γN is used in the definition of the inductive limit, we reserve γ˜ N for the definition of the co-product for lattice current algebras (see Sect. 4). 3. Representations of the Lattice Current Algebra The stage is now set to describe our main result on the representation theory of the lattice current algebras. We will begin with a much simpler problem of representing two important subalgebras of KN . Their representations will serve as building blocks for the representation theory of the lattice current algebra KN . 3.1. The algebra U. The lattice current algebras KN contain N − 1 non-commuting holonomies Uν , ν = 1, . . . , N − 1, Uν ≡ va1−ν J1 · · · Jν ∈ Ga ⊗ KN . The objects Uν commute with all elements in the symmetry algebras Gn , except the ones for n = 0 and n = ν. These properties of Uν remind us of holonomies in a gauge theory, which transform nontrivially only under gauge transformations acting at the endpoints of the paths. Together, the elements in G0 ⊗Gν ⊂ KN and the components of Uν generate a subalgebra, Uν , of the lattice current algebra KN . These subalgebras Uν ⊂ KN are all isomorphic to the algebra U which we investigate in this subsection. We begin with a definition of U . Definition 3. The algebra U is the *-algebra generated by components of elements U, U −1 ∈ Ga ⊗ U together with elements in G0 ⊗ G1 such that 1
2
U U = R1a (U ) , ι1 (ξ)U = U 11 (ξ),
10 (ξ)U = U ι0 (ξ),
and U −1 is the inverse of U . Here we use the same notations as in Subsect. 2.3. In particular, ι0,1 denote the canonical embeddings of G into G0 ⊗ G1 . The ∗-operation on U extends the ∗-operation on G0 ⊗ G1 ⊂ U, so that U ∗ = S1−1 U −1 S0 . Here Si = (id ⊗ ιi )(1(κ−1 )(κ ⊗ κ)R−1 ) ∈ Ga ⊗ U for i = 0, 1, and κ is a certain central square root of the ribbon element, as before. The algebra U admits a very nice irreducible representation, D, which is constructed by acting with elements in U on a “ground state” |0i. The state |0i may be characterized by the following (invariance-) properties: ιi (ξ)|0i = |0i(ξ) for all ξ ∈ G
i = 0, 1,
Representation Theory of Lattice Current Algebras
47
where is the trivial representation (co-unit) of G. Here and in the following we neglect to write the letter D when elements in U act on vectors. Since we are dealing with a unique representation of U, ambiguities are excluded. While the preceding formula means that |0i is invariant under the action of G0 ⊗ G1 , the components of U ∈ Ga ⊗ U create new states in the carrier space, <, of the representation D, |πi ≡ π(U )|0i = (π ⊗ id)(U )|0i ∈ < for all π ∈ Ga0 . In particular, one identifies |i = |0i because (U ) = U 0 = e. We can think of the vectors |πi as coming from a universal object u ∈ Ga ⊗ <, i.e., |πi ≡ π(u) = (π ⊗ id)(u) . In other words, u = U |0i. A complete description of the representation D on < is given in the following proposition. Proposition 4 (Representation of U). There exists an irreducible *-representation D of the algebra U on a carrier space < such that 1
2
U u = R1a (u) , (e ⊗ ι1 (ξ))u = u(ξ ⊗ e),
(e ⊗ ι0 (ξ))u = (S(ξ) ⊗ e)u .
Here u ∈ Ga ⊗ < and 1a (u) = (1 ⊗ id)(u). The representation space < contains a unique invariant vector |0i ∈ <. Proof. The formulas for the action of U on < follow from u = U |0i ∈ Ga ⊗ < by using the invariance of |0i under the action of ι1 (ξ) and ι0 (ξ). In particular, we have that 1
2
1
2
U u = U U |0i = R1a (U )|0i = R1a (u),
and
(e ⊗ ι1 (ξ))u = U 11 (ξ)|0i = U |0i(id ⊗ )(1(ξ)) = u(ξ ⊗ e) . To derive the action of G0 on < we rewrite the equation U ι0 (ξ) = 10 (ξ)U according to ι0 (ξ)U = (S(ξς1 ) ⊗ e)U (e ⊗ ι0 (ξς2 )) . Here we have inserted the expansion 1(ξ) = ξς1 ⊗ ξς2 and used some standard Hopfalgebra properties of the antipode S. Then one proceeds as in the computation of ι1 (ξ)u to obtain the last formula claimed in Proposition 4. Observe that the formulas in the preceding proposition define an action – not a coaction – of the algebra U on the representations space <. Again, it is important to keep in mind that the co-product 1 in the first formula of Proposition 4 acts on the first tensor factor Ga of u ∈ Ga ⊗ <. In terms of the multiplication ∗ in G 0 (cf. Subsect. 2.3) one has that π1 (U )|π2 i = |π1 ∗ π2 i for all π1 , π2 ∈ G 0 . Consequently, the components π(U ) act on < as some kind of (twisted) multiplication operators. Furthermore, the matrix elements of uI = τ I (u) ∈ End(V I ) ⊗ < span a δI2 -dimensional subspace of < which is invariant under the action of G0 ⊗ G1 ⊂ U. With the help of Proposition 4 we deduce
48
A. Y. Alekseev, L. D. Faddeev, J. Fr¨ohlich, V. Schomerus
ι1 (ξ)uI = uI τ I (ξ) , ι0 (ξ)uI = τ I (S(ξ))uI for all ξ ∈ G and with ιi (ξ) = (eI ⊗ ιi (ξ)), where eI is the unit element in End(V I ). The two formulas furnish the following decomposition of < into a direct sum of G0 ⊗ G1 modules, M Vˇ I ⊗ V I , (3.1) <∼ = I
where Vˇ I is dual to V I and the sum extends over the classes of irreducible representations of G. Vˇ 0 ⊗ V 0 ⊂ < coincides with the one-dimensional subspace spanned by |0i. All these features of the representation space < resemble those of the algebra of squareintegrable functions on a Lie-group G with its characteristic action of left and right invariant vector fields. This similarity is not too surprising and can be traced back to the analogy between the objects U and T . In Subsect. 2.3, T was found to satisfy “RT T relations” which are the key ingredient in the deformation theory of groups G. Mainly for technical reasons we finally look at a certain subalgebra D of U and its action on <. Lemma 2. Let D be the subalgebra of U which is generated by elements ξ ∈ G1 and components of U . When the representation D of U is restricted to D ⊂ U it furnishes an irreducible representation D of D on <. Proof. To prove this lemma we show that every vector |πi in the representation space < is cyclic under the action of D. Since < contains the cyclic vector |0i, our task simplifies to the following problem: show that for every |πi ∈ < there is a representation operator Aπ ∈ D(D) such that Aπ |πi = |0i. For the proof it is crucial to find the projector on |0i in D(D). It is constructed from the minimal central projector P 0 ∈ G that corresponds to the trivial representation = τ 0 . By definition, P 0 satisfies τ I (P 0 ) = δI,0 , so that ι1 (P 0 )|π 0 i = |0iπ 0 (P 0 ) holds for all π 0 ∈ G 0 . The other ingredient we need below is a distinguished element µ ∈ G 0 – called the right integral of G – with the properties (µ ⊗ id)1(ξ) = µ(ξ) , µ(P 0 ) = 1 . Now we choose ξπ ∈ G such that π(ξπ ) = 1. A short technical computation shows that (e ⊗ ξ0 )1(P 0 ) = (S(u−1 ξ0 ) ⊗ e)R1(P 0 ) , where u = g −1 v ∈ G and g was introduced in Subsect. 2.1. We abbreviate η0 ≡ S(u−1 ξ0 ) and regard η0 as a map from G to G acting by left multiplication so that µ ◦ η0 makes sense as an element in G 0 . Let us define Aπ ≡ ι1 (P 0 )(µ ◦ η0 )(U ) . The following calculation proves that Aπ |πi = |0i and hence completes the proof of the lemma: Aπ |πi = ι1 (P0 )(µ ◦ η0 )(U )|πi = ι1 (P0 )|(µ ◦ η0 ) ∗ πi = |0i((µ ◦ η0 ) ∗ π)(P0 ) = |0i(µ ⊗ π)((η0 ⊗ e)R1(P0 )) = |0iπ(ξ0 )µ(P 0 ) = |0i .
Representation Theory of Lattice Current Algebras
49
The algebra D is a semidirect product of G and its dual G 0 , the latter being supplied with the twisted product ∗ that we discussed in Subsect. 2.3. In this light, D appears as a close relative of the deformed cotangent bundle Tq∗ G over a group G which differs from the structure of D only through the use of the standard product · in G 0 . Example. Let us continue our tradition and illustrate the theory with the example G = Zq . The algebra U is then generated by the unitary elements g0 , g1 and w satisfying wp = 1 , g1 w = qwg1 , wg0 = qg0 w, and g0 commutes with g1 (cf. Subsect. 2.3 for further details). States in < are created from a ground state |0i with invariance properties g1 |0i = |0i and g0 |0i = |0i. Through iterated application of w on |0i we may produce p linearly independent vectors |ri ≡ wr |0i ∈ < for r = 0, . . . , p − 1 . Specializing the proof of Proposition 4 to our example, we obtain g1 |ri = q r wr g1 |0i = q r |ri and similarly for g0 . This shows that the one-dimensional subspace spanned by |ri corresponds to the summand Vˇ r ⊗ V r in the decomposition (3.1) of <. The subalgebra D of U is generated by g = g1 and w, with Weyl commutation relations wg = qgw and g p = e = wp . It acts irreducibly on the p-dimensional space <. 3.2. The algebra K. Before we deal with the general situation, it is helpful to study the simplest example of a lattice current algebra for which the lattice consists of only one (closed) link and one site, i.e., the case N = 1. Strictly speaking, K1 has not been defined above. So we must first give a definition. Definition 5 (The algebra K). The *-algebra K ≡ K1 is generated by components of M, M −1 ∈ Ga ⊗ K and elements ξ ∈ G with the following relations 1
2
M R M = R1a (M ) , 1(ξ)M = M 1(ξ) for all ξ ∈ G M −1 is the inverse of M , so that M −1 M = e = M M −1 . The action of ∗ is extended from G to K by the formula M ∗ = S −1 M −1 S , where S = 1(κ−1 )(κ ⊗ κ)R−1 , as before.
50
A. Y. Alekseev, L. D. Faddeev, J. Fr¨ohlich, V. Schomerus
Components π(M ) of the monodromy M can be represented on the carrier spaces V I of the representations τ I of G. This is accomplished by the formula DI (π(M )) = (π ⊗ τ I )(R0 R) ∈ End(V I ) for all linear forms π ∈ Ga0 on Ga . An equivalent universal formulation without reference to linear forms π is DI (M ) = (id ⊗ τ I )(R0 R) ∈ Ga ⊗ End(V I ) . Indeed, one may check that such an action on V I is consistent with the functoriality of M , i.e., with the first relation in Definition 5, 1
2
0 0 R13 R12 R23 R23 ] DI (M R M ) = (id ⊗ id ⊗ τ I )[R13 0 0 = (id ⊗ id ⊗ τ I )[R13 R23 R12 R13 R23 ] 0 0 = (id ⊗ id ⊗ τ I )[R12 R23 R13 R13 R23 ]
= (id ⊗ id ⊗ τ I )[R12 (1 ⊗ id)(R0 R)] = R(1a ⊗ id)(DI (M )) . From our discussion in Subsects. 2.4, 2.5 we know already that Ga ⊗ K contains not only the left monodromy M L = M but also the right monodromy −1 M L N+ ∈ G a ⊗ K M R = N−
N+ = R 0 ,
with
N− = R−1 .
Here N± are regarded as elements in Ga ⊗ G ⊂ Ga ⊗ K, as before. Since the components of M L and M R commute, they can be represented on spaces V I ⊗ V J such that the right/left-monodromies act trivially on the first/second tensor factor, respectively. This action of left and right monodromies on W IJ ≡ V I ⊗ V J can be extended to an action of the entire algebra K. Actually, the algebra K is isomorphic to the Drinfeld double of G [23, 21]. Proposition 6 (Representations of K). The algebra K has a series of irreducible *representations, D IJ , defined on the spaces W IJ . Explicitly, the action is given by DIJ (M ) = (id ⊗ τ I )(R0 R) , J I J DIJ (ξ) = (τ I × τ )(ξ) = (τ ⊗ τ )(1(ξ)) .
Here DIJ (M ) ∈ Ga ⊗ End(V I ) is regarded as an element of Ga ⊗ End(W IJ ) with trivial action on the second tensor factor V J in W IJ . Proof. To check the representation property is left as an exercise to the reader. It may be helpful to consult Theorem 12 of [6]. Irreducibility follows from the fact that the action of the monodromies on the spaces V I is irreducible (cf. Lemma 1 of [6]).
Representation Theory of Lattice Current Algebras
51
Example. For G = Zq , the definition of K furnishes an algebra with generators c = c1L and g such that cp = 1 , g p = 1 and cg = gc . Some explanation can be found at the end of Subsect. 2.5. The abelian algebra K has one-dimensional representations, Dst , on spaces W st labeled by two integers s, t = 0, . . . , p − 1, Dst (c) = q s , Dst (g) = q s+t , where q = exp(2πi/p). For comparison with the general formulas in Proposition 6, one should keep in mind that g is a generator of the algebra G while c coincides with the element τ 1 (M ) ∈ K, up to a scalar factor. 3.3. Representations of KN . In representing the full lattice current algebras KN it is convenient to pass to a new set of generators: Let us define elements Uν ∈ Ga ⊗ KN , ν = 1, . . . , N − 1, as above by Uν ≡ va1−ν J1 · · · Jν . Then the Uν , together with M ≡ M L and the elements ξ ∈ Gn , n = 1, . . . , N, generate KN . They obey the following relations: 1
2
U ν U ν = R1a (Uν ) , 1
2
M R M = R1a (M ) , 1
2
2
1
R0 U ν U µ = U µ U ν for 1 ≤ ν < µ ≤ N − 1 , 1
2
2
1
R0 U ν M = M R0 U ν ,
(3.2)
10 (ξ)M = M 10 (ξ) for ξ ∈ G , ιν (ξ)Uν = Uν 1ν (ξ) for ξ ∈ G , 10 (ξ)Uν = Uν ι0 (ξ) for ξ ∈ G . We infer that KN contains (N − 1) copies of the algebra U generated by Uν , Gν , G0 and one copy of the algebra K generated by M ≡ M L and G0 . These subalgebras do not commute, but the non-commutativity is felt only by Uν , M and G0 . In any case, the exchange relations motivate us to look for representations of the lattice current algebra KN on spaces (3.3) WNIJ ≡ <⊗N −1 ⊗ W IJ . To state the formulas we introduce the notation Dν , ν = 1, . . . , N − 1, which stands for the representation D of the algebra Uν on the ν th factor of the tensor product (3.3), i.e., for every X ∈ Uν , Dν (X) = id1 ⊗ . . . ⊗ idν−1 ⊗ D(X) ⊗ idν+1 ⊗ . . . ⊗ idN −1 ⊗ Id , where idµ acts as the identity on the µth factor < in WNIJ , and Id is the identity on W IJ . Similarly, DIJ denotes the action of the subalgebra K ⊂ KN on the last factor W IJ in WNIJ . The map ι0 embeds elements of G into all the subalgebras Uν of the lattice current algebra KN . Hence G acts on each tensor factor < in WNIJ independently with the help
52
A. Y. Alekseev, L. D. Faddeev, J. Fr¨ohlich, V. Schomerus
of representations Dν . We employ the co-product 1 on G to obtain a family ϑν , ν = 1, . . . , N, of G-actions on WNIJ . In the following, ϑ1 is the trivial representation, ϑ1 = , and ϑν (ξ) = (D1 × ... × Dν−1 )(ι0 (ξ)) ⊗ idν ⊗ . . . idN −1 ⊗ Id for all ξ ∈ G. The symbol × denotes the tensor product of representations. With these conventions we are prepared to define representations of KN on WNIJ . The essential idea is borrowed from the well known Jordan-Wigner transformation. In fact, in writing the actions of our generators on WNIJ we have to relate the Uν ’s and M (which obey non-trivial exchange relations among each other) to the operators Dν (Uν ) tensor factors in WNIJ and hence commute. and DIJ (M ). The latter act on different Qn In analogy with the ‘tail’-factors i=0 σi3 of the Jordan-Wigner transformation, we will employ tails of R-matrices to express the Uν in terms of Dν (Uν ) and M in terms of D IJ (M ). Related constructions appear in Majid’s ‘transmutation theory’ (see e.g. [19]). Theorem 7 (Representations of KN ). The algebra KN has a series of irreducible *IJ realized on the spaces WNIJ given in Eq. (3.3). In the representation representations DN IJ DN , the generators of KN act as IJ (Uν ) = (id ⊗ ϑν )(R−1 )Dν (Uν ) , DN IJ DN (M ) = (id ⊗ ϑN )(R−1 )DIJ (M )(id ⊗ ϑN )(R) , IJ DN (ιν (ξ)) = Dν (ιν (ξ)) for ν = 1, . . . , N − 1 , ξ ∈ G , IJ DN (ι0 (ξ)) = (ϑN ⊗ DIJ )(10 (ξ)) for all ξ ∈ G .
Every *-representation of KN can be decomposed into a direct sum of the irreducible IJ . representations DN Proof. The proof is similar to the one of Theorem 15 in [6]. Although we do not present the details, we stress that the factors (id⊗ϑν )(R±1 ) produce “tails of R-elements” which IJ . are responsible for the correct exchange relations of Uν , M in the representations DN From the definition of ϑν and quasitriangularity of R we infer (for ν > 1) −1 −1 −1 R13 . . . R1ν . (id ⊗ ϑν )(R−1 ) = R12
Here it is understood that the second tensor factor of R1µ is represented on the µth factor < in WNIJ with the help of Dν ◦ ι0 . A simple example suffices to illustrate how nontrivial exchange relations between Uν , M arise in our representations 1
2
1
2
−1 IJ 0 0 (R12 DN U 1 U 2 ) = R12 D1 (U 1 )R23 D2 (U 2 ) 1
2
0 0 −1 −1 (R12 ) R23 D1 (U 1 )D2 (U 2 ) = R12 2
1
−1 D2 (U 2 )D1 (U 1 ) = R23 2
1
IJ (U 2 U 1 ) . = DN
These equations are to be understood as equations in Ga ⊗ Ga ⊗ End(WNIJ ). To reach the second line, we insert the exchange relation of U1 with elements ι0 (ξ) and quasitriangularity of R−1 . Then we use that the images of D1 and D2 commute.
Representation Theory of Lattice Current Algebras
53
IJ Irreducibility of the representations DN follows from the case N = 1 which we have treated in Subsect. 3.2, together with Lemma 2 of Subsect. 3.1. L It is quite instructive to evaluate the projectors χK L χR (defined at the end of SubIJ sect. 2.5) in the representations DN . The answer is given by (cf. [6]) IJ L (χK DN L χR ) = δI,K δJ,L . L As we have promised above, the elements χK L χR are characteristic projectors for the irreducible representations of the lattice current algebra KN . The representation theory described here survives the limit in which N tends to infinity. With the help of our embeddings γN : KN → KN +1 (see Sect. 2.6) we can define IJ IJ an action DN +1 ◦γN of the lattice current algebra KN on WN +1 . It is, of course, no longer irreducible, so that WNIJ+1 decomposes into a direct sum of irreducible representations of the algebra KN . The observations made in the preceding paragraph combined with formula (2.14) furnish an isomorphism
WNIJ+1 ∼ = WNIJ ⊗ < of KN modules, with < being a multiplicity space of the reduction. In particular, all the IJ . This irreducible subrepresentations of the KN -action on WNIJ+1 are isomorphic to DN implies that the inductive limit for the directed system (KN , γN ) splits into independent contributions coming from the simple summands of KN . Since inductive limits of simple IJ algebras are simple, we conclude that K∞ possesses irreducible representations D∞ IJ on W∞ . As for the algebras KN , the labels I, J run through the classes of irreducible representations of G. Example (Representations of the U (1)-current algebra). To discuss the representation theory of the U (1)-current algebra, we introduce the generators vν = q (ν−1)/2 w1 · · · wν ∈ KN which agree with Uν1 = (τ 1 ⊗ id)(Uν ), up to a scalar factor. The whole algebra KN is generated from the elements gν ∈ Gν ⊂ KN , the monodromy c ∈ KN and the holonomies vν ∈ KN such that gν vν = qvν gν , v ν vµ = q g0p
=
gνp
p
=c =
−1
vµ vν
vνp
=1
vν g0 = qg0 vν , for ν < µ , for all ν = 1, . . . , N − 1
st are denoted and c commutes with every other element. Vectors in the carrier space of DN by |r1 , r2 , . . . , rN −1 is,t ,
where rν , s, t = 0, . . . , p − 1. We can easily define an action of our generators on such states, vν |r1 , . . . , rν , . . . , rN −1 is,t = q r1 +...+rν−1 |r1 , . . . , rν + 1, . . . , rN −1 is,t , gν |r1 , . . . , rν , . . . , rN −1 is,t = q rν |r1 , . . . , rν , . . . , rN −1 is,t , g0 |r1 , . . . , rN −1 is,t = q r1 +...+rN −1 +s+t |r1 , . . . , rN −1 is,t , c |r1 , . . . , rN −1 is,t = q s |r1 , . . . , rN −1 is,t .
54
A. Y. Alekseev, L. D. Faddeev, J. Fr¨ohlich, V. Schomerus
The numerical factor on the right hand side of the first line is an example of the “tail of Relements” discussed above. A similar term usually appears in the action of monodromies M but is absent here. It can be seen that the contributions from (id ⊗ ϑN )(R−1 ) and IJ st (M ), cancel for DN (c), (id ⊗ ϑN )(R), which occur in the general expression of DN r since all irreducible representations τ of Zq are one-dimensional. From the experience with conformal field theories we expect that the diagonal repL L II ¯ ¯ on the Hilbert space H ≡ I WNII is particularly relevant. Here we resentation DN just wish to remark that this representation can be realized by a very natural construction. Indeed, it was observed (cf. [4]) that algebras such as KN admit a distinguished invariant linear functional ω : KN → C, 1
N
ω(JI11 . . . JINN ξ) = (ξ)δI1 ,0 . . . δIN ,0 for all ξ ∈ Gn , n ∈ ZmodN and JnI = (τ I ⊗ id)(Jn ), as usual. When the quantum dimensions dI are positive, this functional is positive and hence furnishes – by the GNS construction – a Hilbert space Hω together with a representation π of KN on Hω . If |0iω denotes the GNS vacuum, states in Hω are obtained from 1
N
I I J11 . . . JNN |0iω .
L ¯ The formula shows that Hω is isomorphic to the diagonal sum H = I WNII ∼ = <⊗N . I An explicit evaluation of cR,L on Hω establishes an isomorphism of the two spaces as KN modules. Proposition 8. The GNS-representation arising from the state ω : KN → C is unitarily L ¯ equivalent to the diagonal representation I WNII of the lattice current algebra. The quantum lattice analog of the group-valued local fields of the WZNW model act in this diagonal representation [2, 8]. 4. Product of Representations All continuous current algebras are equipped with a trivial co-product which can be written for Fourier modes of currents j(n) as 1(j(n)) = j(n) ⊗ 1 + 1 ⊗ j(n).
(4.1)
From the point of view of CFT this co-product is not satisfactory, because it changes the central charge of representations. In the framework of CFT, the central charge is characteristic of the model, and one must define a new co-product which preserves it. Such a co-product is provided by the structure of CFT [15, 20]: X Ckn z n−k j(k). (4.2) 1zCF T (j(n)) = j(n) ⊗ 1 + 1 ⊗ k≤n
Here Ckn ≡ n!/k!(n − k)! are binomial coefficients. Observe that the co-product 1CF T is not symmetric and explicitly depends on the parameter z. The aim of this section is to introduce a lattice counterpart of 1CF T . 4.1. Co-product for lattice current algebras. Because lattice current algebras are labelled by the number of lattice sites, it is not necessary that both current algebras on the right
Representation Theory of Lattice Current Algebras
55
hand side of the co-product correspond to chains of the same length. We shall define a family of embeddings (4.3) 3M,N : KN +M −1 → KM ⊗ KN for any N and M . The homomorphisms 3M,N determine an action of KN +M −1 on the IJ tensor products WM ⊗ WNKL of representation spaces for KM and KN . Pictorially, 3M,N corresponds to gluing two closed chains of length M and N by identifying some site of the first chain with some site of the second chain. In this way, the co-product 3M,N explicitly depends on the positions of the identified points. This property is similar to the z-dependence of 1zCF T . Below, we always assume that the enumeration starts from the gluing points, so that this extra parameter does not show up in our formulas; in the same fashion one can put e.g. z = 1 in the continuum theory. After gluing we cut the resulting eight-like loop at the middle point and get one connected chain of length N +M −1. Similarly to 1zCF T , the co-product 3M,N depends on the order in which M and N appear. Next, we present the constructive description of 3M,N . α ,m = Let us denote the left currents of KN by Jnβ , n = 1, . . . , N, and similarly by Jm β α 1, . . . , M, the left currents of KM . Jn and Jm are regarded as elements in G ⊗KM ⊗KN with the property 1
2
2
1
α β β α Jm Jn =Jn Jm
for all n, m. In addition to the left currents, we need N + M commuting copies of the symmetry algebra G to generate KM ⊗ KN . With these notations we can define the announced embedding 3M,N : KN +M −1 → KM ⊗ KN . It maps the generators Jρ , ρ = 1, . . . , N + M − 1, of KN +M −1 in the following way to generators of KM ⊗ KN : α Jρ J α N αJ β M − 1 3M,N (Jρ ) = β J +1 ρ−M β α −1 JN (N− )
for ρ = 1, . . . , M − 1 for ρ = M for ρ = M + 1, . . . , N + M − 2
,
(4.4)
for ρ = N + M − 1
α α where N± = N0,± . For elements ξ ∈ G, we define
α for ρ = 1, . . . , M − 1 ιρ (ξ) ⊗ e β 3N,M (ιρ (ξ)) = e ⊗ ιρ−M +1 (ξ) for ρ = M, . . . , N + M − 2 , α (ι0 ⊗ ιβ0 )(1(ξ)) for ρ = N + M − 1
(4.5)
where e means the unit element in KM or KN . Proposition 9. The map 3M,N : KN +M −1 → KM ⊗ KN defined through Eqs. (4.4) and (4.5), is an algebra homomorphism. One can prove this proposition by directly verifying the defining relations for KN +M −1 . In order to justify calling 3M,N a co-product, we need some kind of co-associativity. For lattice current algebras this holds in the following form.
56
A. Y. Alekseev, L. D. Faddeev, J. Fr¨ohlich, V. Schomerus
Proposition 10. The family of homomorphisms 3M,N satisfies the following property (id ⊗ 3N,L ) ◦ 3M,L+N −1 = (3M,N ⊗ id) ◦ 3M +N −1,L .
(4.6)
Applying our formulas for 3M,N twice to the generators of KL+M +N −2 one easily sees that the homomorphisms on the left and on the right hand sides of (4.6) coincide. ˜ Let us notice that along with the co-product 3 one can introduce a co-product 3 defined by β N+ Jρα for ρ = 1 Jα for ρ = 2, . . . , M − 1 ρ ˜ M,N (Jρ ) = (4.7) 3 β −1 β α JM (N+ ) J1 for ρ = M Jβ for ρ = M + 1, . . . , N + M − 1 ρ−M +1 ˜ M,N acts on elements ξ ∈ G according to Eq. (4.5) with the 1 in the last line being and 3 ˜ are ‘intertwined’ by the ∗-operation. replaced by 10 . These two co-products 3 and 3 To make a precise statement we introduce an element K ∈ KM ⊗ KN by the expression β −1 ˜ M,N (ι0 (κ))(ια K=3 0 (κ) ⊗ ι0 (κ)) . With this notation we have ˜ M,N (x∗ ) K 3M,N (x)∗ = K −1 3
(4.8)
for all x ∈ KN +M −1 . This property is similar to (2.1) where the ∗-operation intertwines 1 and 10 and, in fact, it reduces to the latter on elements ξ ∈ Gn ⊂ KN +M −1 . 4.2. Special cases. There are important special cases of the maps 3M,N which we would like to consider in more detail. First, observe that the map 31,1 : K1 → K1 ⊗ K1
(4.9)
satisfies the co-associativity condition (id ⊗ 31,1 ) ◦ 31,1 = (31,1 ⊗ id) ◦ 31,1 .
(4.10)
This is a specification of Eq. (4.6) for the case of L = M = N = 1. We conclude that the map 11 = 31,1 furnishes a co-product for the algebra K1 . It has been recently shown [21] that as a Hopf algebra K1 is isomorphic to the Drinfeld double of G. In particular, this implies existence of an R-matrix for the Hopf-algebra K1 . As we know (see Sect. 3), the algebra K1 is generated by the elements ξ ∈ G and by the universal element M ∈ G ⊗ K1 . Irreducible representations of K1 are labelled by the pairs (I, J) of irreducible representations of G. This implies that as an algebra K1 is isomorphic to G ⊗ G (see also [23] where an isomorphism of quasi-triangular Hopf algebras is described). There is another interesting special choice of chain lengths N and M : 31,N : KN → K1 ⊗ KN .
(4.11)
The co-associativity condition (4.6) adapted to this case reads (id ⊗ 31,N ) ◦ 31,N = (31,1 ⊗ id) ◦ 31,N .
(4.12)
This shows that 31,N also provides a co-action of the Hopf algebra K1 on KN . Such a structure has been noticed already in [2]. We shall see that it permits us to establish a one-to-one correspondence between representations of KN and K1 .
Representation Theory of Lattice Current Algebras
57
Our last remark on the properties of 3M,N concerns the inductive limit K∞ . Using the block-spin embeddings KN → KN +1 , one can construct a commutative diagram: 3M,N : KN +M −1 → KM ⊗ KN ↓ ↓ 3M,N +1 : KN +M → KM ⊗ KN +1
(4.13)
Commutativity (4.13) ensures that the sequence of homomorphisms 3M,N defines homomorphisms (4.14) 3M,∞ : K∞ → KM ⊗ K∞ . Then Eq. (4.6) implies the co-associativity for 3M,∞ : (id ⊗ 3N,∞ ) ◦ 3M ∞ = (3M,N ⊗ id) ◦ 3N +M −1,∞ .
(4.15)
Thus, 3M,∞ provides a co-module structure for K∞ with respect to the family KM . In particular, K∞ is a co-module over K1 . 4.3. Implications for representation theory. The co-product 3M,N yields a notion of tensor product for representations of the algebras KM and KN . Definition 11. The representation D of the algebra KN +M −1 is called a tensor product of the representations DM of KM and DN of KN if it acts on the tensor product of the corresponding vector spaces WM ⊗ WN according to the following formula: D(x) = (DM ⊗ DN )3M,N (x)
(4.16)
for all elements x of the lattice current algebra KN +M −1 . The resulting representation will be denoted by DM × DN . We would like to analyse the structure of this new tensor product. We denote by 0 the trivial representation of the symmetry Hopf algebra. Proposition 12. For any M and N and for arbitrary labels I and J of the representations of the symmetry algebra the following representations of KM +N −1 are isomorphic: IJ IJ 00 00 IJ DM D N ' DN × DM . +N −1 ' DM ×
(4.17)
00 In this sense, tensoring with the vacuum representation DN is trivial. IJ ⊗ WN00 and To prove this proposition one first checks that on the spaces WM the central elements of KM +N −1 have eigenvalues corresponding to the repIJ resentation DM +N −1 . Then one checks that the dimensions of all these spaces coincide IJ with the dimension of WM +N −1 . This completes the proof. Observe that the tensor product of representations that we have introduced, relates representations of different algebras. For instance, if we take N = M , we obtain a representation of the algebra K2N −1 on the tensor product of representation spaces of KN . The idea now is to embed the algebra KN into K2N −1 with the help of the block spin maps γ˜ M , IJ WN00 ⊗WM
γ˜ 2N −1,N := γ˜ 2N −2 ◦ . . . ◦ γ˜ N +1 ◦ γ˜ N : KN → K2N −1 .
58
A. Y. Alekseev, L. D. Faddeev, J. Fr¨ohlich, V. Schomerus
In this way we may represent the algebra KN on tensor products of its own representation spaces. The resulting representation certainly has a huge commutant and is not appropriate to describe the representation theory of KN . We shall define a certain projection α ∈ KN ⊗ KN that projects to a more interesting subrepresentation. operator PN α The construction of PN proceeds as follows. Notice that the lattice current algebra KN contains N − 1 local projectors pi ∈ Gn ⊂ KN where n runs from 1 to N − 1. They are uniquely determined by the property ιi (ξ)pi = (ξ)pi for all ξ ∈ G. An explicit formula for pi in terms of the objects Ni can be obtained along the lines of Subsect. 2.5. When Ni replaces the monodromy M then we obtain pi instead of χ0 . These projectors pi commute with each other, i.e., pi pj = pj pi for all i, j so that their product defines again a projector PN , N −1 Y PN := pi ∈ K N . i=1
From the defining relations of KN it is fairly obvious that PN commutes with N0 and α will denote the projector PN ⊗ e ∈ KN ⊗ KN the monodromy M . In the following, PN β and similarly PN = e ⊗ PN ∈ KN ⊗ KN . With these objects at hand, we are now able to define a new co-product 1N for the algebra KN , a 3N,N (γ˜ 2N −1,N (x)) for all x ∈ KN . 1N (x) := PN
(4.18)
It is easy to check that 1N defines a homomorphism because γ˜ 2N −1,N and 3N,N are α homomorphisms and the projector PN commutes with the image of 3N,N ◦ γ˜ 2N −1,N : β 1N (x) so that the coKN → KN ⊗ KN . Let us also mention that 1N (PN x) = PN associativity of 1N follows from that of 3N,M , (1N ⊗ id)1N (x) = (id ⊗ 1N )1N (x) for all ξ ∈ KN . In deviation from the standard properties of co-products, 1N is not unit preserving, i.e., 1N (e) 6= e ⊗ e ∈ KN ⊗ KN (e ∈ KN denotes the unit element), and there is no one-dimensional trivial representation of KN . The role of the co-unit is actually played 00 of KN . Such algebraic properties are characteristic by the vacuum representation DN for weak Hopf-algebras [7] and the closely related weak quasi-Hopf algebras of [18]. Notice, that the co-product 1N is compatible with the block spin operation: (γN ⊗ γN )1N = 1N +1 γN . This property is ensured by the fact that two block spin operations γN and γ˜ N commute with each other (see Sect. 2). Thus, one can define an operation 1∞ : K∞ → K∞ ⊗ K∞ which provides a co-product for the inductive limit of lattice current algebras. We would finally like to compare the representation category of KN with that of K1 . To this end notice that the formula IJ 00 DN ' D1IJ × DN
(4.19)
provides a one-to-one correspondence between representations of K1 and KN for arbitrary N . In fact, this implies the same kind of correspondence for representations of K1 and K∞ . Because KN is semisimple, for all N , the isomorphism (4.19) induces a map FN (D1 ) = DN
(4.20)
which assigns to each representation D1 of the algebra K1 a representation DN of the algebra KN .
Representation Theory of Lattice Current Algebras
59
To describe the properties of the map F, it is convenient to use the language of the theory of categories (see e.g. [17]). It is clear that the map FN is invertible and that it defines a co-variant tensor functor mapping the category of representations of the Hopf-algebra K1 into the category of representations of the lattice current algebras KN . Actually, on the image of PNα , the tensor product of representations of KN defined through 1N is isomorphic to the representation obtained with the help of the co-action 31,N . Since tensor operators for the latter may be trivially identified with tensor operators of the quasitriangular Hopf-algebra K1 , the functor FN provides an equivalence of braided tensor categories. In the limit N → ∞ we arrive at the following conclusion. Theorem 13. The functor F establishes an isomorphism between representations the Hopf algebra K1 and the lattice current algebra K∞ which is compatible with a coproducts of K1 and K∞ and establishes an equivalence of braided monoidal categories. We can view this fact as the lattice analogue of a theorem in [16, 14] on the equivalence of tensor categories corresponding to quantum groups and current algebras. Here the algebra K∞ replaces the current algebra, and K1 = G ⊗ G is the direct product of two quantum groups corresponding to two chiral sectors. From this point of view, finding an exact relationship between lattice and continuum current algebras emerges as a challenging problem. Acknowledgement. We would like to thank A. Connes and K. Gawedzki, participants and lectures of the 95’ Summer School on Theoretical Physics at Les Houches for an inspiring atmosphere. V.S. would also like to thank T. Miwa and I. Ojima for their hospitality at RIMS. We are grateful to A. Bytsko and F. Nill for their remarks and criticism.
References 1. Abe, E.: Hopf algebras. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1980; M.E. Sweedler, Hopf algebras. New York: Benjamin, 1962 2. Alekseev, A.Yu.: Faddeev, L.D., Semenov-Tian-Shansky, M.A.: Hidden Quantum groups inside KacMoody algebras. Commun. Math. Phys. 149, no.2, 335 (1992) Faddeev, L.D.: Quantum symmetry in conformal field theory by Hamiltonian methods. In: New symmetry principles in quantum field theory, Proceedings Cargese 91, London–NewYork: Plenum Press 3. Alekseev, A.Yu., Faddeev, L.D.: An evolution and dynamics for the q-deformed quantum top. HelsinkiUppsala preprint, December 1994, hep-th/9406196 4. Alekseev, A.Yu., Grosse, H., Schomerus, V.: Combinatorial quantization of the Hamiltonian Chern Simons theory I. hep-th 9403066, Commun. Math. Phys. 172, 317–358 (1995); Alekseev, A.Yu., Grosse, H., Schomerus, V.: Combinatorial quantization of the Hamiltonian Chern Simons theory II. hep-th 9408097, Commun. Math. Phys. 174, 561–604 (1995) 5. Alekseev, A.Yu., Recknagel, A.: The embedding structure and the shift operator of the U (1) lattice current algebra. hep-th/9503107, Lett. Math. Phys. 37. 15–27 (1996) 6. Alekseev, A.Yu., Schomerus, V. Representation theory of Chern Simons Observables. q-alg/9503016, Duke Math. Journal Vol. 85, No. 2, 447 (1996) 7. B¨ohm, G., Szlachanyi, K.: A coassociative C ∗ -quantum group with non-integral dimension. qalg/9509008, Lett. Math. Phys. (to appear) 8. Bytsko, A., Schomerus, V.: Vertex operators - from a toy model to lattice algebras. q-alg/9611010 9. Doplicher, S., Haag, R.,. Roberts, J.E: Fields, observables and gauge transformations I,II. Commun. Math. Phys. 13, 1 (1969) and 15, 173 (1969) 10. Doplicher, S., Haag, R., Roberts, J.E.: Local observables and particle statistics I,II. Commun. Math. Phys. 23, 199 (1971) and 35, 49 (1974) 11. Faddeev, L.D., Reshetikhin, N.Yu., Takhtajan, L.A. Quantization of Lie Groups and Lie Algebras. Algebra and Analysis 1, 178-201 (1989) and Leningrad Math. J. 1, 193–225 (1990)
60
A. Y. Alekseev, L. D. Faddeev, J. Fr¨ohlich, V. Schomerus
12. Faddeev, L.D., Volkov, A.Yu.: Abelian current algebra and the Virasoro algebra on the lattice. Phys. Lett. B315, 311 (1993) 13. Falceto, F., Gawedzki, K.: Lattice Wess-Zumino-Witten model and quantum groups. J. Geom. Phys. 11, 251 (1993) 14. Finkelberg, M.: Fusion Categories. Harvard University thesis, May 1993 15. Fr¨ohlich, J.: In Recent Developments in QFT, Proc. of 24th Intl. Conference on High Energy Physics, Munich 1988. Kotthaus & Kuehn (eds.), Berlin–Heidelberg–New York: Springer 1989. 16. Kazhdan, D., Lusztig, G.: Tensor structures arising from affine Lie algebras I/II. J. Am. Math. Soc. 6, 4, 905 (1993) 17. Kerler, T.: Nontannakian categories in quantum field theory. Cargese 91, Proceedings, New symmetry principles in quantum field theory, p. 492 18. Mack, G., Schomerus, V.: Quasi Hopf quantum symmetry in quantum theory. Nucl. Phys. B370, 185 (1992) 19. Majid, S.: Algebras and Hopf algebras in braided categories. In: Advances in Hopf Algebras, Lecture Notes in Pure and Appl. Math. 158, New York: Dekker, 1994, p. 55 20. Moore, G., Seiberg, N.: Classical and quantum conformal field theory. Commun. Math. Phys. 123, 177 (1989) 21. Nill, F.: On the Structure of Monodromy Algebras and Drinfeld Doubles. q-alg/9609020 22. Nill, F., Szlachanyi, K.: Quantum chains of Hopf algebras with quantum double cosymmetry. Preprint hep-th/9509100, Commun. Math. Phys., to appear 23. Reshetikhin, N., Semenov-Tian-Shansky, M.: Lett. Math. Phys. 19, 133; (1990) Reshetikhin, N.,Semenov-Tian-Shansky, M.: Quantum R-matrices and factorization problems. J. Geom. Phys. 5, 533 (1988) 24. Reshetikhin, N., Turaev, V.G.: Ribbon graphs and their invariants derived from quantum groups. Commun. Math. Phys. 127, (1990); Reshetikhin, N., Turaev, V.G.: Invariants of 3-manifolds via link polynomials and quantum groups. Invent. Math. 103, 547 (1991) 25. Schomerus, V.: Construction of field algebras with quantum symmetry from local observables. Commun. Math. Phys. 169, 193 (1995) 26. Sklyanin, E.,Volkov, A.unpublished 27. Szlachanyi, K., Vecsernyes, P.: Quantum symmetry and braid group statistics in G-spin models. Commun. Math. Phys. 156, (1993) 127 28. Vecsernyes, P.: On the quantum symmetry of the chiral Ising model. Nucl. Phys. B415, 557 (1994) 29. Verlinde, E.: Fusion rules and modular transformations in 2D conformal field theory. Nucl. Phys. B 300, 360 (1988) 30. Wess, J., Zumino, B.: Phys. Rev. B37, 95 (1971); Witten, E.: Commun. Math. Phys. 92, 455 (1984); Novikov, S.: Uspehi Math. Sci. 37, 3 (1982) Communicated by G. Felder
Commun. Math. Phys. 191, 61 – 70 (1998)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics c Springer-Verlag 1998
Collet-Eckmann Maps are Unstable Alexander Blokh1,? , Michał Misiurewicz2 1 Department of Mathematics, University of Alabama in Birmingham, University Station, Birmingham, AL 35294-2060, USA. E-mail:
[email protected] 2 Department of Mathematical Sciences, IUPUI, 402 N. Blackford Street, Indianapolis, IN 46202-3216, USA. E-mail:
[email protected]
Received: 17 October 1996 / Accepted: 16 April 1997
Abstract: We show that a smooth interval map satisfying the Collet-Eckmann condition at some critical point is not structurally stable in C r topology for any r. 1. Introduction We want to address an old problem of structural stability of smooth interval maps. The reader can find a good account of this problem in [MS]. Basically, one expects that the only way an interval map can be structurally stable is that the trajectories of all critical points are attracted to attracting periodic points. However, this is known only for C 1 -stability ([J]). It is widely believed that this problem resembles the Closing Lemma, that is, a perturbation necessary to change the topological type of a map has to be global (or at least a proof is possible only for global perturbations). Here we show that some maps admit the proof of instability in any C r topology with local perturbations. These maps are the ones satisfying the Collet-Eckmann condition at some critical point. Positive Lyapunov exponent at a critical point causes “sensitivity” at this point, so a local perturbation has global effects. There is a slight difficulty when we speak of structural stability of interval maps. Let us illustrate it with an example. Let f : [0, 1] → [0, 1] be a convex C ∞ unimodal map with f (0) = 0 and a = supx∈[0,1] f (x) < 1. Set gε (x) = f (x) + ε for 0 < ε ≤ 1 − a. The maps gε converge to f in C ∞ topology as ε → 0. None of gε is conjugate to f , since for each of them 0 is not a fixed point while for f it is. Yet this is not the kind of instability of f we want. Basically, the change of behavior of the map was achieved by the change of the interval on which it was defined (and rescaling back). In our example the map may have really changed its topological type, but to establish that is much more difficult than to prove the “instability” as above. ?
He was partially supported by NSF grant DMS 9626303.
62
A. Blokh, M. Misiurewicz
To avoid problems like this, let us define the essential interval for a continuous interval map f as the smallest interval containing trajectories of all interior local extrema of f . Clearly, this interval is invariant for f . Now, continuous interval maps are said to be essentially conjugate if they are conjugate when restricted to their essential intervals. Finally, we say that an interval map f of class C r is C r -structurally stable if there exists a neighborhood of f in C r topology such that every map from this neighborhood is essentially conjugate with f . Note that we can also speak of C r -structural stability of f even if f is not of class r C . Namely, we require that there is a C r -neighborhood of the 0 function such that for every h from this neighborhood f + h is essentially conjugate with f . This may be not too interesting for all maps f , but it makes sense for instance if f is piecewise C r . Sometimes we are interested in changing the topological type of a map by introducing a small local perturbation. To describe this phenomenon, we introduce the notion of structural sensitivity at a point. Namely, we say that a map f is C r -structural sensitive at x if for every C r -neighborhood V of the function 0 and for every neighborhood U of x there exists h ∈ V which is 0 outside U and such that f + h is not essentially conjugate to f . We will use the following terminology. Let f be a continuous interval map. A point x is called a periodic sink (from one side) if there exists n > 0 and a (one-sided) neighborhood U of x such that f n (x) = x, f n (U ) ⊂ U andSthe diameter of f k (U ) tends ∞ to 0 as k → ∞. The basin of attraction of x is then the set k=0 f −k (U ). Note that if f n has a (one-sided) derivative at x, its absolute value is less than or equal to 1. It is well known that any point from the boundary of the basin of attraction of a periodic sink is either periodic or preperiodic. An interval J will be called a wanderval if f n |J is a homeomorphism for every n, the images of J are pairwise disjoint, and the orbit of J does not converge to the orbit of a periodic (even one-sided) sink (we can talk about convergence of the orbit of J since by the second condition all points of J have the same ω-limit set). It is easy to see that this is equivalent to f n |J being homeomorphism for every n and the existence of a point x ∈ J whose ω-limit set is not a periodic orbit. Indeed, if the first set of conditions is satisfied then the absence of flat spots (i.e. intervals on which f is a constant) implies that the orbit of no point x ∈ J converges to a periodic orbit. Suppose now that the second set of conditions holds. In that case if some images of J intersect each other then the union of all images of J is an invariant union of finitely many intervals such that the restriction of f on this union is monotone on every component; this implies that all points of J have periodic orbits as their ω-limit sets. The non-existence of wandervals for smooth interval maps was proven in a series of papers with the most general result obtained in [MMS]. The question of their existence in a piecewise-smooth setting remains unsolved in general, however under the assumption of the exponential growth of the derivative at a point we prove that this point is not contained in a wanderval.
2. Main Theorem We look at the class of all continuous maps f : [0, 1] → [0, 1] for which there exist points 0 = a0 < a1 < . . . < as = 1 such that f is of class C 1 on each of the intervals [ai , ai+1 ], with non-zero derivative on each (ai , ai+1 ). We will refer to these maps as piecewise smooth maps. The points a0 , a1 , . . . , as will be called singular points. Points at which f has local extrema (except 0 and 1) will be called turning points.
Collet-Eckmann Maps are Unstable
63
We will say that a piecewise smooth map f satisfies the Collet-Eckmann condition at a turning point c of f if (2.1) |(f n )0 (f (c))| ≥ αλn for all n, where α > 0 and λ > 1 (in other words, if the lower Lyapunov exponent at f (c) is positive). If only one-sided derivatives of f n at f (c) exist, we mean (2.1) for both of them. We introduce a function r : [0, 1]2 → R ∪ {∞} as follows: r(x, y) =
|f (x) − f (y)| |x − y| |f 0 (x)|
if x 6= y, and r(x, x)=1 (if only one-sided derivatives at x exist, we take as f 0 (x) the derivative from the side where y is). We will call this function relative stretching, since it measures how the interval is being stretched relative to the derivative at one of its endpoints. In fact, this makes sense only if x and y belong to the same lap of f (by a lap we mean a maximal interval on which f is monotone; there may be singular points in the interior of a lap). We will call the infimum of r(x, y) over the pairs of points x, y from the same lap the shrinkability of f . Note that if a point x is critical (i.e. the derivative of f at x vanishes) then r(x, y) = ∞ for all y 6= x. If a, b are two consecutive singular points, let us look at r restricted to [a, b]2 . Clearly, r is continuous off the diagonal. If x 6= y and f 0 (x) 6= 0 then r(x, y) = f 0 (z)/f 0 (x) for some z ∈ (x; y) (by (x; y) we mean (x, y) if x < y and (y, x) if y < x). Hence, since f is of class C 1 on [a, b] and f 0 (x) 6= 0 for all x ∈ (a, b) we conclude that r is also continuous on the diagonal, at all points (x, x) such that f 0 (x) 6= 0. Let f be a piecewise smooth map and let c be a turning point of f . For a given ε > 0 and a neighborhood U of c we denote by B(f, ε, U, c) the set of maps g : [0, 1] → [0, 1] such that |g(x)−f (x)| ≤ ε for every x ∈ U , g(x) = f (x) for every x ∈ / U , |g(c)−f (c)| = ε, and c is a local extremum of g. For every point x ∈ [0, 1] its itinerary (for f ) is the sequence (in (x))∞ n=0 , where in (x) is the point f n (x) if this is a turning point and the lap of f to which f n (x) belongs otherwise. Main Theorem. Let f be a piecewise smooth map with non-zero shrinkability, satisfying the Collet-Eckmann condition at a turning point c. Then there is a neighborhood U of c such that for every ε > 0 if g ∈ B(f, ε, U, c) then either g has more local extrema than f , or the g-trajectory of c is attracted to the orbit of a periodic (at least one-sided) sink, or the itineraries of c for f and g are different. Proof. We may assume from the very beginning that we are considering only those g ∈ B(f, ε, U, c) which have c as their only local extremum in U . Indeed, we may choose U such that f has only one local extremum in it. Then, if g has more than one local extremum in U , it has more local extrema than f in the whole interval, and we are done. Since we will often consider behavior of f separately at each side of some point x, we will speak about right and left halves of x. The point 0 has only right half, and the point 1 only left one. Now every half-point has the derivative of f well defined at it. Moreover, we can tell to which half of f (x) a given half of x is mapped by f . Let λ and α be constants from (2.1). We choose η and µ such that η < 1 < µ < ηλ.
(2.2)
64
A. Blokh, M. Misiurewicz
Let p be the number of singular half-points that are not periodic. We choose an integer N > p such that (2.3) αµN ≥ 1 and
µ ηλ
N
<
K η
p ,
(2.4)
where K is the shrinkability of f . For every non-periodic singular half-point we choose its neighborhood (one-sided, of course) such that every piece of trajectory of length N passes through it at most once. Let V be the union of these neighborhoods. Thus, every piece of a trajectory of length N visits V at most p times. For every periodic singular half-point that is a sink we choose its neighborhood (again one-sided) contained in the basin of attraction. Let W be the union of these neighborhoods. Since f satisfies the Collet-Eckmann condition at c, the trajectory of f (c) does not visit W at all. Then we choose δ > 0 such that if x∈ / V ∪ W , |x − y| < δ and x, y do not lie on opposite sides of a periodic singular point then r(x, y) ≥ η. To see that this is possible, notice that for a small δ, if x, y are as above then they belong to some closed interval J on which f 0 is continuous and non-zero. The function r is continuous on J 2 and it is equal to 1 on the diagonal, hence it is larger than η in some neighborhood of the diagonal. We are now ready to choose U required in the theorem. The choice depends on the trajectory of c, so we will consider several cases. In what follows we denote f i (c) by ci . Case 1. The point c is periodic. Then clearly for any g ∈ B(f, ε, U, c) with sufficiently small ε and U the point c will not be periodic of the same period. Therefore the itineraries of c for f and g will be different. Remember that this case is possible, since we allow non-zero one-sided derivatives at the turning points. Case 2. The point c is preperiodic (but not periodic). Then ck is a periodic repelling point for some k > 0. Let us work with the halves of ck and their neighborhoods (i.e. one-sided neighborhoods in the usual sense). Then there are the following two possibilities for the behavior of f . Case 2a. There are no inverse images of turning points in some closed one-sided neighborhood of ck . Then there is an interval (ck ; a) invariant for some iterate of f , and a is a periodic sink from the appropriate side. For sufficiently small ε and U and for any g ∈ B(f, ε, U, c) with g(c) on the appropriate side of c1 the g-trajectory of c will be attracted by the orbit of a which remains a periodic sink from the appropriate side for g. Case 2b. There are inverse images of at least one turning point of f in an arbitrary small one-sided neighborhood of ck . We can choose one of these inverse images sufficiently close to ck , and then we can choose next inverse images by following the periodic orbit of ck backwards. In this way we get inverse images of a turning point arbitrarily close to c with an additional property that their trajectories before hitting a turning point miss some fixed (small) neighborhood U of c. Let us take a sufficiently small ε > 0 and g ∈ B(f, ε, U, c) with g(c) on the appropriate side of c1 . Then there is a / U for i < m. point a ∈ (g k (c); ck ) such that f m (a) is a turning point and f i (a) ∈ Suppose that the itineraries of c for f and g are the same. Then by induction we see that f i (a) ∈ (g k+i (c); ck+i ) for i ≤ m (even if g k+i (c) ∈ U , the induction step works). Since ck+m and g k+m (c) are on the opposite sides of the turning point f k (a), we get a contradiction.
Collet-Eckmann Maps are Unstable
65
We have shown that if c is a periodic or preperiodic point then choosing a neighborhood U of c according to Cases 1, 2a or 2b we can guarantee that for every ε > 0 if g ∈ B(f, ε, U, c) and c is the only local extremum of g in U then the itineraries of c under the maps g and f are different, or c is attracted to an orbit of a periodic sink. Case 3. The point c is neither periodic nor preperiodic. Let us show that there are inverse images of turning points arbitrary close to c1 on both sides of c1 . Indeed, suppose that this is not the case. Then there is an interval J containing c1 such that all iterates of f are monotone on J. The discussion following the definition of a wanderval implies now that if ω(c) is not a periodic orbit then J is a wanderval. However, because of (2.1), c cannot be attracted to a periodic (even one-sided) sink. It cannot be also on the boundary of a basin of attraction of a periodic sink (because then it would be periodic or preperiodic). Piecewise-smoothness of f implies that these are the only two ways the set ω(c) can be a periodic orbit. Hence, ω(c) is not a periodic orbit and thus there exists a point a1 in a small neighborhood of c1 such that (c1 ; a1 ) is a wanderval. We denote f i−1 (a1 ) by ai . We have n Y |cn+1 − an+1 | = r(ck , ak ). |c1 − a1 | |(f n )0 (c1 )| k=1
The numbers r(ck , ak ) are usually greater than or equal to η. There are several cases when they may be smaller than η, and then they are larger than or equal to K. The first case is when ck ∈ V ∪W . This can happen at most p times during each of N consecutive steps. The second case is when |ck − ak | ≥ δ. However, the images of a wanderval are pairwise disjoint, so this can happen at most 1/δ times no matter how big n is. The third case would be when ck and ak lie on the opposite sides of a periodic singular point. Then this periodic point would belong to a wanderval, so this case is impossible. Therefore (we use (2.4)) lim inf n→∞
|cn+1 − an+1 | |c1 − a1 | |(f n )0 (c1 )|
1/n
≥ (η N −p K p )1/N >
µ . λ
Together with (2.1) this proves that |cn+1 − an+1 | grows exponentially (at least as a constant times µn ), a contradiction. Therefore there are inverse images of turning points of f arbitrary close to c1 on both sides of c1 . Clearly the same holds for the point c. If the orbit of such an inverse image x comes closer to c (if coming from the other side, we look at the first image to decide whether it is closer), we replace x by this point of the orbit of x. In such a way we see that there are arbitrarily small neighborhoods (a, b) of c such that f (a) = f (b), some image of a is a turning point d of f , and the orbit of a before getting to d does not pass through (a, b). We will refer to such neighborhoods as very nice. By (2.4), we have p/N ηλ K > 1. µ η Therefore we can choose an integer M ≥ N so large that ηλ µ
K η
p/N !M ≥2
η 2+1/δ . K
(2.5)
66
A. Blokh, M. Misiurewicz
Next we choose a very nice neighborhood U of c, such that f k (U ) ∩ U = ∅ for k = 1, 2, . . . , M − 1. Moreover we choose U so that orbits of periodic singular points are disjoint from U . Take some ε > 0 and g ∈ B(f, ε, U, c). Recall that due to the arguments from the beginning of the proof we may assume that c is the only local extremum of g in U . Set bn = gn (c), αn = |(f n )0 (c1 )| and γn =
|cn+1 − bn+1 | . εαn
Suppose that the itineraries of c for f and g are the same. Then cn+1 and bn+1 are in the same lap of f (the laps of g are the same as for f ) and if a is an endpoint of U and x ∈ U then f (x) and g(x) lie on the same side of f (a) (otherwise g would have extra turning points). We claim that for a given n > 0 either both bn and cn are in U or both are outside U . First observe that the g-orbit of a and the f -orbit of a are the same. Let us now show by induction that if an endpoint a of U belongs to [cn ; bn ], then f i (a) = g i (a) ∈ [cn+i ; bn+i ] for i = 0, 1, . . . , m, where m is the smallest integer such that f m (a) is a turning point. Indeed, if f i (a) = g i (a) ∈ [cn+i ; bn+i ] then applying f and g to this we get f i+1 (a) = g i+1 (a) ∈ f [cn+i ; bn+i ] ∩ g[cn+i ; bn+i ]. Since f and g are either both increasing or both decreasing on [cn+i ; bn+i ], we get f i+1 (a) = g i+1 (a) ∈ [cn+i+1 ; bn+i+1 ], which completes the induction step. Thus, f m (a) = g m (a) ∈ [cn+m ; bn+m ]. This is a contradiction, since by our assumptions there is no turning point in [cn+m ; bn+m ]. This proves the claim. Consider again two cases depending on the behavior of the trajectory of c. Case 3a. The point c is non-recurrent. Choose U so small that no cn is in U for n > 0. / U for Let us show that this U satisfies the requirements of the theorem. Indeed, cn ∈ / U for all n. Hence, the f -orbit and the g-orbit of b1 are the same. all n, thus bn ∈ Therefore if the itineraries of c1 and b1 for f and g respectively are the same then there are no inverse images of turning points of f in a one-sided neighborhood [c1 ; b1 ) of c1 , a contradiction. Case 3b. The point c is recurrent. Let U be the set chosen after formula (2.5). We are going to look at how γn behaves when n grows. More precisely, we call n special if cn ∈ U (this includes n = 0) and prove by induction that if n is special then γn ≥ (µ/λ)n . This is clearly true for n = 0. Now we show how to make an induction step. Note that the situation is very similar to what we encountered when we were proving that c1 is not an endpoint of a wanderval. Assume that n is special and n + m is the next special number. By the definition of U we have m ≥ M . Our goal is to estimate γn+m from below; to this end we estimate from below quotients γn+1+k /γn+k for k = 0, 1, 2, . . . , m − 2. We have γn+1+k /γn+k =
|cn+2+k − bn+2+k | εαn+k , · εαn+1+k |cn+1+k − bn+1+k |
on the other hand we have bn+1+k = f k (bn+1 ), and thus bn+2+j = f (bn+1+j ), so γn+1+k /γn+k =
|f (cn+1+k ) − f (bn+1+k )| = r(cn+1+k , bn+1+k ) . |cn+1+k − bn+1+k ||f 0 (cn+1+k )|
Thus we can estimate γn+k+1 /γn+k from below by η or K. As before, we normally use η, but we have to use K in some cases. The first case is when cn+1+k ∈ V ∪ W . This can happen at most p times during each of N consecutive steps. The second case is
Collet-Eckmann Maps are Unstable
67
when |cn+1+k − bn+1+k | ≥ δ. This can happen at most 1/δ times. The reason is that the intervals (cj ; bj ) for j = n + 1, . . . , n + m − 1 are pairwise disjoint. Indeed, suppose that they are not. Then one of them intersects the interval (cn+m ; bn+m ) (because the images of non-disjoint intervals are non-disjoint). The latter interval is contained in U , while the one intersecting it is disjoint from U , a contradiction. The third case would be when cn+1+k and bn+1+k lie on the opposite sides of a periodic singular point. We claim that this is impossible. Call this periodic point x. By the choice of U the trajectory of x is disjoint from U . On the other hand, we assumed that the itineraries of c1 and b1 for f and g respectively coincide. This together with the fact that f and g coincide outside U implies that f m−k−1 (x) ∈ [cn+m ; bn+m ] ⊂ U , a contradiction. Hence, the estimate of γn+1+k /γn+k from below by K will be used at most 1+ mp/N times when the first case occurs, and at most 1/δ times when the second case occurs. For γn+m /γn+m−1 we have to modify slightly the estimate, since perhaps bn+m+1 is different from f (bn+m ). Since |bn+m+1 − f (bn+m )| ≤ ε, we get γn+m ≥
|f (cn+m ) − f (bn+m )| − ε 1 ≥ γn η m−j K j − , εαn+m−1 |f 0 (cn+m )| αn+m
where j = mp/N + 1/δ + 2. Using (2.5) and (2.1), and since m ≥ M , we get µ m 1 − . γn+m ≥ γn · 2 λ αλn+m Since µ n+m µ n µ m 1 ·2 − ≥ λ λ αλn+m λ (because of (2.3) and since n+m ≥ M ≥ N ), we get γn+m ≥ (µ/λ)n+m . This completes the induction step. For every special n we get |cn+1 − bn+1 | ≥ γn εαn ≥ εαµn , a contradiction since µ > 1. This completes the proof.
Let us make an observation that leads to a result which seems to be of some interest by itself. Namely, in the beginning of the whole proof and in the beginning of Case 3 we did not use the assumption that the point c is a turning point. We used only the fact that the lower Lyapunov exponent at f (c) was positive. We concluded that this point did not belong to a wanderval. Hence, we get the following result. Proposition 2.1. Let f be a piecewise smooth map with non-zero shrinkability. Then at every point contained in a wanderval the lower Lyapunov exponent is non-positive. Some time ago one of the authors (AB) got interested in the question of existence of wandervals under the assumptions less restrictive than those from [MMS]. In particular it would be nice to find out whether a piecewise smooth map with some singular points at which the order of degeneracy is different to the left and to the right may have wandervals (in the unimodal case this question is quoted in [MS], where it is noted that the proof from [MMS] breaks down under new milder assumptions). We would like to point out that Proposition 2.1 answers the question in a rather specific situation. It also shows that it may make sense to consider a question of whether points with specific properties may be contained in a wanderval (one could call this a “pointwise” approach to the problem of existence of wandervals). Note also that we only need C 1 -smoothness while a higher smoothness is necessary for all previous results (see, e.g., [MMS]).
68
A. Blokh, M. Misiurewicz
3. Discussion of Assumptions We made three assumptions in Main Theorem: piecewise smoothness, non-zero shrinkability and the Collet-Eckmann condition at a turning point c. Now we will discuss them. Our definition of piecewise smoothness is as unrestrictive as possible. In particular, it does not prevent existence of wandervals, even ones that do not come close to the turning points. An example of such a map can be easily derived from Denjoy’s example of a circle diffeomorphism with wandervals (see [CN]). We compensate by assuming that a turning point c satisfies the Collet-Eckmann condition. Then the trajectory of this point has nothing to do with wandervals (see Proposition 2.1). The assumption on non-zero shrinkability is in fact a condition on the behavior of the map close to singular points. Let a be a singular half-point. We will say that f is non-flat at a if either f 0 (a) 6= 0 or there exists a neighborhood W (one-sided) of a and a constant L > 0 such that for every t ∈ W \ {a}, L≤
|f (t) − f (a)| ≤ 1. |t − a| |f 0 (t)|
(3.1)
Lemma 3.1. If a is the only singular point in W = [a; b) and (3.1) holds for all t ∈ (a; b), then r(x, y) ≥ L for every x, y ∈ W . Proof. The sign of f 0 on W is constant; we may assume it is positive. We may also assume that a is the left endpoint of W . The proof in the remaining three cases is similar. We have by (3.1), 0 f 0 (t)(t − a) − (f (t) − f (a)) f (t) − f (a) = ≥ 0, t−a (t − a)2 so the function (f (t) − f (a))/(t − a) is non-decreasing. Hence, if a < x < y < b, then (f (y) − f (a))/(y − a) ≥ (f (x) − f (a))/(x − a). Therefore f (y) − f (a) f (x) − f (a) x − a f (y) − f (x) f (y) − f (a) − = − ≥ 0, y−x y−a y−a x−a y−x so we get
f (y) − f (a) f (x) − f (a) f (y) − f (x) ≥ ≥ . y−x y−a x−a
Hence, by (3.1) we get r(x, y) ≥ L and r(y, x) ≥ L. This completes the proof.
Corollary 3.2. If f is smooth on [a, b], non-flat at a and b, and f 0 is non-zero on (a, b) then f has non-zero shrinkability on [a, b]. To justify our use of the term “non-flat”, we prove the following lemma. Lemma 3.3. Let l > 1 be an integer and let f be a function of class C l−1 defined in a (one-sided) neighborhood of a point a. Assume that f (i) (a) = 0 for i = 1, . . . , l − 1, and that f (l) (a) exists and is non-zero. Then f is non-flat at a. In particular, if a is a non-degenerate critical point of f (that is, f 0 (a) = 0 but f 00 (a) 6= 0) then f is non-flat at a.
Collet-Eckmann Maps are Unstable
69
Proof. By the definition of the derivative, we have f (l−1) (t) = f (l) (a). t→a t − a lim
Thus, by l’Hˆopital’s rule, f (l) (a) f 0 (t) = t→a (t − a)l−1 (l − 1)! lim
Therefore lim
t→a
and
f (l) (a) f (t) . = t→a (t − a)l l! lim
1 f (t) = , (t − a)f 0 (t) l
so (3.1) holds in a neighborhood of a with L = 1/(2l). Thus, f is non-flat at a.
On the other hand, assume that (3.1) holds. If t > a and f 0 (t) > 0 (the other three cases are similar) we get from the first inequality of (3.1), [ln(f (t) − f (a))]0 ≤
1 . L(t − a)
Integrating from t (close to a) to some b > a we get ln(f (b) − f (a)) − ln(f (t) − f (a)) ≤ Therefore
1 [ln(b − a) − ln(t − a)]. L
f (t) − f (a) ≥ const.(t − a)1/L .
This means that f really cannot be flat (in the common sense) at a. The assumption on non-zero shrinkability restricts severely possible behaviors near singular points that are not turning points. It is easy to check that if the singularities from both sides of such a point have the same order, shrinkability stays positive. However, if they are of different orders, shrinkability is zero. Thus, our assumptions on the behavior on both sides of a singular point are quite different than the assumptions in [MS]. We don’t care if the orders of the singularities are different if the point is a turning point, but it is important that they are the same if the point is not a turning point. In [MS] this is just the opposite. The third assumption we are making is the Collet-Eckmann condition at one of the turning points. One can ask whether we can replace it by a subexponential expansion. We cannot do it when using our techniques. The trajectory of the turning point may be coming back to U with some fixed frequency, and we have to guarantee sufficient expansion between each two consecutive returns. 4. Corollaries Main Theorem is stated in a rather technical way. However, it has important consequences, that can be stated in more general terms. In order to do it, we need a couple of lemmas. They are very simple, so we state them without proof. Lemma 4.1. If g satisfies one of the conditions from the conclusion of Main Theorem then it is not essentially conjugate to f .
70
A. Blokh, M. Misiurewicz
Lemma 4.2. Let f be a piecewise smooth map and let U be a neighborhood of a turning point c of f . Let h : [0, 1] → [0, 1] be a function of class C ∞ that is 0 outside U and 1 in some neighborhood of c. Then the map εh tends to 0 in the C ∞ topology as ε → 0. Moreover, f + h ∈ B(f, ε, U, c) if (f + h)([0, 1]) ⊂ [0, 1]. Thus, we can always make perturbations of the type described in the Main Theorem. Now, our corollaries are the following. Corollary 4.3. Let f be a piecewise smooth map with non-zero shrinkability, satisfying Collet-Eckmann condition at some turning point. Then f is not C r -structurally stable for any r ≤ ∞. Corollary 4.4. Let f be a piecewise smooth map with non-zero shrinkability, satisfying the Collet-Eckmann condition at a turning point c. Then f is C r -structurally sensitive at c for every r ≤ ∞. Readers for which the term “non-zero shrinkability” is too special, can use the results of the previous section and change the assumptions in the above corollaries from “a piecewise smooth map with non-zero shrinkability” to “a smooth map with non-degenerate critical points”. For unimodal maps the situation is somehow simpler. If a critical point c has different itineraries for f and g, then there is t ∈ (0, 1) such that c is periodic for tf + (1 − t)g. Therefore, in view of Lemma 3.3, we can state another corollary as follows. Corollary 4.5. For any 1 ≤ r ≤ ∞, in the space of C r unimodal interval maps with nondegenerate critical points, the set of Collet-Eckmann maps is nowhere dense and every such map can be approximated by maps with the critical point belonging to a superattracting periodic orbit. References [J]
Jakobson, M.V.: Smooth mappings of the circle into itself. Mat. Sb. (N.S.) 85 (127), 163–188 (1971) (Russian; English translation: Math. USSR - Sbornik 14, 161–185 (1971) [MMS] Martens, M., de Melo, W. and van Strien, S.: Julia-Fatou-Sullivan theory for real one-dimensional dynamics. Acta Math. 168, 273–318 (1992) [MS] de Melo, W. and van Strien, S.: One-Dimensional Dynamics Berlin: Springer Verlag, 1983 [CN] Coven, E. and Nitecki, Z.: Nonwandering sets of the powers of maps of the interval. Ergod. Th. & Dynam. Sys. 1, 9–31 (1981)
Communicated by Ya. G. Sinai
Commun. Math. Phys. 191, 71 – 86 (1998)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics c Springer-Verlag 1998
The Statistics of Burgers Turbulence Initialized with Fractional Brownian Noise Data Reade Ryan Courant Institute of Mathematical Sciences, New York University, New York, N.Y. 10012, USA. E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 27 January 1997 / Accepted: 30 April 1997
Abstract: The statistics of the solution to the inviscid Burgers equation are investigated when the initial velocity potential is fractional Brownian motion. Using the theory of large deviations for Gaussian processes, we characterize the tails of the probability distribution functions (PDFs) of the velocity, the distance between shocks, and the shock strength. These PDFs are shown to decay like “stretched” exponentials of the form log P (θ) ∝ −θ4−2h . Our method of proof can also be used to extend these results to a much larger class of Gaussian potentials. This work generalizes the results of Avellaneda and E [2, 3] on the inviscid Burgers equation with white-noise initial data. 1. Introduction The one-dimensional Burgers turbulence (BT) system, described by the nonlinear wave equation (1.1) ∂t u(x, t) + u(x, t)∂x u(x, t) = µ∂xx u(x, t), µ ≥ 0, initialized at time t = 0 with random data uo (x), has been discussed in various fields in mathematics and physics. The structural similarity between the Burgers equation and the Navier-Stokes equation was an initial motivation behind the study of Eq. 1.1. While it is now clear that the differences between Burgers and Navier-Stokes turbulence are at least as great as the similarities, the study of Burgers systems is still employed as a testing ground for analytical approaches to Navier-Stokes turbulence [5, 8]. The Burgers equation has also been used in the study of shock wave formation in compressible fluids [6], nonlinear waves in long transmission lines, and the formation of large-scale mass clustering in an expanding universe [12, 15]. Researchers in the latter area of study have been interested in the statistics of the solution to the one-dimensional Burgers equation initialized with two general types of Gaussian data. The first type of initial data is a family of Gaussian processes called fractional Brownian motions (FBMs), denoted here as Bh (·), h ∈ (0, 1). The FBMs
72
R. Ryan
are a one-parameter family of continuous, self-similar processes whose increments, Bh (x) − Bh (y), are mean-zero and have the following second-moment power law: E (Bh (x) − Bh (y))2 = |x − y|2h ,
(1.2)
where E[·] denotes expectation.1 R y The second case of interest specifies that the integral of the initial data φo (y), = uo (x)dx, often referred to as the initial potential, is a fractional Brownian motion. 0 Thus, the initial data uo (x) is a generalized Gaussian process, called fractional Brownian noise. Burgers, himself, worked on the case when h = 1/2 (i.e. white noise initial data) [4]. Burgers [4] showed that the solution to the inviscid Burgers equation with random data resolves itself at time t into a “sawtooth” profile with areas of rarefaction, in which u(·, t) ramps up with a slope of 1/t, followed by downward shocks of random size.2 Thus, in order to obtain a complete understanding of the solution statistics for a BT system, one needs to investigate the PDFs of the velocity u(x, t), the strength of a generic shock, and the rarefaction interval size. Recently, work has been done on the Markovian BT cases, i.e. Brownian motion initial data (h = 1/2 for the first type) and white noise data (h = 1/2 for the second type). Sinai, in his 1992 paper [14], looked at the statistical structure of shocks for inviscid BT with Brownian motion data. By looking at the PDF of the shock strength, he proved that at any fixed time t the points at which shocks occur are dense in Eulerian space and the corresponding shock points in Lagrangian space form a random set of Hausdorff dimension 21 almost surely. Avellaneda and E, on the other hand, did an indepth study of the white-noise case [2, 3]. They investigated the shock structure in this BT system, showing that the shock points form a discrete set almost surely. In addition, they looked at the probability distribution functions of the velocity at a point, the size of a shock, and the size of a rarefaction interval. They proved that the tails of these PDFs all decay like cubic exponentials, i.e. log P (θ) ∝ −tr θ3 , where r = 1 in the former cases and r = −2 in the latter. However, very little rigorous work has been done on the non-Markovian cases3 . In their 1994 paper [15], Vergassola et al., based on numerical and heuristic anaylsis, hypothesized that for Burgers systems, initialized with the second data type, the PDF for the strength of a generic shock at time t, denoted |S(t)|, has the following decay law for s 1: log Prob {|S(t)| > s} ∝ −t2−2h s4−2h .
(1.3)
This law agrees with the work of Avellaneda and E on the white-noise case (h = 1/2). With a few technicalities that shall be discussed later, we shall rigorously prove that the above equation holds ∀h ∈ (0, 1) by finding upper and lower bounds on the probability of a generic shock being very large. We shall also find upper and lower bounds on the tail events for the velocity and an upper bound on the tail of the wavelength size distribution, 1 The parameter h is often called the Hurst exponent, due to Hurst’s work on these processes in the field of hydrology. 2 In general, rarefaction intervals and the intervals between shocks are not equivalent for inviscid Burgers systems. However, for the BT systems we shall be studying, these two entities coincide. Rarefaction intervals will be precisely defined later and shown to be equivalent to the intervals between shocks for the cases under consideration. 3 Handa’s work [7] on the Hausdorff dimension of the shock points in BT systems with the first type of Gaussian data is a notable exception.
Statistics of Burgers Turbulence
73
both of which give similar decay laws for the PDFs of these random variables. As of yet, we have not realized a solid lower bound for the wavelength size probabilities. The reason for this has to do with the particular shock structure of these models. This shall be looked at in some depth below. 2. Solution to the Inviscid Burgers Equation Before stating and proving the results of this paper, let us begin by giving a brief description of the solution to the inviscid Burgers equation. In this section, we shall give precise definitions of the velocity u(x, t), the rarefaction intervals, and the velocity shocks in terms of the initial potential φo (y). Given that φo (y) is continuous and that lim|y|→∞ φo (y)/y 2 = 0, it is a standard exercise to show that there exists a unique left-continuous, vanishing-viscosity solution to the inviscid Burgers equation with initial data uo (x) (proof given in [14, Sinai] among others). Note that fractional Brownian motion satisfies the above two conditions. Thus, asking what the solution to the inviscid Burgers equation initialized by fractional Brownian noise, a generalized random process, is a well-posed question. At a fixed time t, this solution is given by u(x, t) =
x − Y (x, t) , t
(2.1)
where
1 x 1 x Y (x, t) = min y : φo (y) + y 2 − y = min φo (z) + z 2 − z . z 2t t 2t t
(2.2)
Given the assumptions on φo (y), the above minimum, taken over z ∈ R, is well-defined and finite ∀x ∈ R, and thus, Y (x, t) is well-defined and finite ∀x ∈ R. It is easy to see that at points x, for which there exists a unique minimum point y ∗ for the function 1 2 y − xt y, Y (x, t) is continuous and non-decreasing in x and is equal to y ∗ . φo (y) + 2t When there exists more than one global minimum point for some x0 (with t fixed), then Y (x, t) is discontinuous at x0 with lim Y (x, t) = Y (x0 , t) = y1 ,
x↑x0
lim Y (x, t) = y2 ,
x↓x0
where y1 is the smallest minimum point and (2.3) where y2 is the largest minimum point.
(2.4)
Thus, u(x, t) has a shock at x0 with the size of the discontinuity = (y2 −y1 )/t. Looking at the definition of Y (x, t), one sees that if a shock exists at x0 in Eulerian space (x-space), then there corresponds in Lagrangian space (y-space) an interval [y1 , y2 ] for which the 0 1 2 function 8(y; t) = φo (y) + 2t y is greater than or equal to the line xt y + C, for some 0 C, with equality holding at the end points and is strictly greater than xt y + C outside this interval. The interval [y1 , y2 ] will be referred to as a Lagrangian shock interval. We shall make much use of this Eulerian/Lagrangian correspondence in what follows. Using a similar Lagrangian-space construction, we can also give a precise definition for rarefaction intervals and, for the systems under consideration, show their equivalence with the intervals between shocks. We define a rarefaction interval as an interval (x1 , x2 ) such that ∀x ∈ (x1 , x2 ), Y (x, t) = yr , for some yr . Such an interval is considered “rarefied” because no Lagrangian points are mapped into (x1 , x2 ) by the function Y −1 (·, t), which is often called the Lagrangian map for obvious reasons.
74
R. Ryan
As we mentioned before, an interval between two shocks in Eulerian space is not necessarily a rarefaction interval. If, however, such an interval I is not rarefied, there must exist at least one subinterval J ⊆ I for which Y (x, t) is continuous and monotonically increasing in x. However, from geometric considerations, one sees that, lim
y↑Y (x)
x 8(Y (x); t) − 8(y; t) ≤ ≤ Y (x) − y t
lim
y↓Y (x)
8(y; t) − 8(Y (x); t) . y − Y (x)
Therefore, if J exists, 8(y; t) must be continuously differentiable in y for the interval 1 2 y , Y −1 (J, t). However, for the initial data under consideration, 8(y; t) = Bh (y) + 2t and so is nowhere differentiable. In this case, any interval between shocks must be a rarefaction interval.
3. Theorems and Proofs With the above definitions of the velocity at a point x, the strength of a generic shock and the distance between two shocks, we are now ready to state and prove our results. Ry Theorem 1. Given that the initial potential in the inviscid Burgers equation 0 u0 (y 0 )dy 0 = Bh (y), where Bh (·) is a fractional Brownian motion with parameter h, the following holds true for the PDF of the velocity, u(x, t): (3.1) exp −Cv 4−2h t2−2h ≤ Prob {u(x, t) > v} ≤ exp −C 0 v 4−2h t2−2h , where v 1, and C, C 0 > 0 are dependent on the paramenter h. Theorem 2. Let δx(t) be the size of a rarefaction interval at time t, which contains some specified point x. Then for some C > 0, which depends on the Hurst exponent h of the initial potential, and with L 1, (3.2) Prob {δx(t) > L} ≤ exp −CL4−2h t−2 . Our last theorem in this section concerns the distribution of SE , the strength of an Eulerian shock. As with the rarefaction interval size, it will not be hard to find the set which dominates the probability of a shock being large. It is the lower bound that shall be a problem. The crux of the dilemma is that we do not know what the structure of the Eulerian shocks is. Are there a finite number of shocks almost surely in any finite Eulerian interval? Are there accumulations of shocks around certain points? Or are there an infinite number of shocks in any interval? Avellaneda and E in their 1995 paper [3] showed that with white-noise initial data, the solution to the inviscid Burgers equation has a discrete shock structure, meaning that at any time t there is only a finite number of shocks in any bounded Eulerian interval with probability one. Sinai [14] proved, however, that with Brownian-motion initial data, there is an infinite number of shocks in any interval on the x-axis. There may be intervals such that the sum of all the jump lengths is very small, but none with no jumps. In the Sinai case, the probability of the jump of any generic Eulerian shock being greater than zero is zero. But this is a misnomer, since there really is no Eulerian probability distribution to speak of. Without a better understanding of the shock structure, it is impossible to say whether or not there exist any rarefaction intervals, let alone ones larger than some number L.
Statistics of Burgers Turbulence
75
For Burgers turbulence initialized with a fractional Brownian motion potential, it is generally believed that the Eulerian shock structure is discrete. Indeed, numerical simulations have given qualitative confirmation of this hypothesis. However, a rigorous proof has yet to be found due to the difficulty in analyzing the almost sure properties of these non-Markovian processes. Getting back to our problem, we see that the best one can do is to look at the distribution of Eulerian shock size, |SE |, conditioned on |SE | > , for some > 0. This distribution exists no matter what the structure of shocks is. Furthermore, with a lower bound on this conditional distribution, proving that the system has discrete shocks would be enough to extend this lower bound to the unconditioned distribution of |SE |. Therefore, our theorem is the following: Theorem 3. Let |SE | be the strength of an Eulerian shock at time t. Then ∃ C, C 0 > 0 such that Prob {|SE | > s} ≤ Prob |SE | > s |SE | > ≤ exp −C 0 s4−2h t2−2h , (3.3) Prob |SE | > s |SE | > ≥ exp −Cs4−2h t2−2h . (3.4)
The basic analytical tool we will use to prove our results is the theory of large deviations for Gaussian processes. In estimating the tails of the PDFs for the velocity, the shock strength, and the distance between shocks, we need to look at the probability of certain rare events for the initial potentials. The decay rates for these PDFs are determined by the probability of the most likely fractional Brownian motion path in each event. Our arguments boil down to estimating for above and below the action of the most likely path in each case. For the upper bounds on the tails (i.e. the lower bounds on the action), we employ the theory of extreme values for Gaussian processes, making use of Adler’s work on this subject [1]. To find the lower bounds, we use the spectral representations of the initial potentials (given below) in conjunction with the Cameron-Martin-Girsanov formula for Brownian motion. The spectral representation of a real Gaussian process G(y) with stationary increments is given by the formula Z∞
Z∞ (1 − cos(yk)) (E [k])
G(y) − G(0) =
1/2
−∞
sin(yk) (E [k])1/2 dZ2 (k),
dZ1 (k) + −∞
(3.5) where the function E [k] is the energy spectrum of G(y) and Z1 (·) and Z2 (·) are independent Brownian motions on R. For stationary processes, the energy spectrum is defined as the Fourier transform of the correlation function. Here, we define the energy spectrum of a real stochastic process with stationary increments in a similar fashion, as the function which satisfies the equation
E (G(y) − G(0))
2
Z∞ = 2
(1 − cos(2yk))E [k] dk.
(3.6)
−∞
For a fractional Brownian motion Bh (y) with Hurst exponent h, it is trivial to show that
76
R. Ryan
E [k] = Ch |k|
−1−2h
, where
Ch−2
Z∞ = 2
(1 − cos(2k))|k|−1−2h dk.
(3.7)
−∞
Combining Eqs. 3.5 and 3.7, we obtain the spectral representation of FBM. It is evident that the determining factor for the decay rate of large-deviation events for FBMs is the behavior of their energy functions in the infra-red part of the spectrum. Thus, the tail probabilities for BT with FBM initial potentials are determined by the exponent −1 − 2h in the power law in this part of the energy spectrum. Due to this fact, Theorems 1, 2 and 3 hold for a broader range of Burgers systems than those initialized with fractional Brownian noise data. With relative ease, we shall extend the proofs of our theorems to include BT systems whose initial velocity potentials have the same infrared behavior in their energy spectra as the FBMs. More specifically, Theorems 1, 2 and 3 hold for stationary-increment Gaussian processes, having energy spectra E [k] which satisfy the following: • E [k] = Ch |k|−1−2h , • ∃A > 0 : e
−Ak2
for k ∈ (−1, 1)
≤ E [k] ≤ Ch |k|
−1−2h
(3.8) ,
for k ∈ / (−1, 1).
3.1. Proof of Theorem 1: Velocity PDF bounds. By the stationarity of the initial data and the translation invariance of the Burgers equation, {u(x, t), x ∈ R} is a stationary process. Thus, we can focus solely on the tail distribution of u(0, t) without loss of generality. 1 2 y first 3.1.1. Proof of velocity upper bound. Let y ∗ ≡ the value at which Bh (y) + 2t ∗ achieves its minimum on R. Since u(0, t) = −y /t, when Bh (y) is the initial potential, and noting that u(0, t) = −u(0, t) in law, we only need to find an upper bound on the 1 2 y = 0 at y = 0, one has that meausre of {y ∗ ≥ vt}. Since Bh (y) + 2t 1 2 1 2 ∗ (3.9) {y ≥ vt} = min Bh (y) + y ≤ min Bh (y) + y y
Using the following result, due to Adler [1], we shall bound the measure of the right-hand side of the above equation by the desired probability. Lemma 3.1 (Adler). Let G(·) be a continuous mean-zero Gaussian process on R. Define a metric on R, p(x, y) = E[G(x) − G(y)]2 . Given some bounded set I ∈ R, we define NI () = the number of -balls needed to cover the set I under the metric p(·, ·). If ∀ > 0, NI () ≤ K−α for some α, K > 0, then with σI2 = supx∈I E[G(x)2 ], 1 2 2 η (3.11) P sup G(x) ≥ m ≤ C(α, K)m exp − m /σI , 2 x∈I where η is any real number > α. This is not the best possible result for the supremum of a Gaussian process, but it is more than sufficient for our purposes. Before we can apply this lemma, there are two problems that must be overcome. The first is the fact that the boundary in the event we are interested in is not a level set. This is rectified by looking at the process Z(y) = y −2 Bh (y)
Statistics of Burgers Turbulence
77
for y ≥ vt. We can now look at the equivalent event, {miny≥vt Z(y) ≤ −1/2t}. The second difficulty is the unboundedness of the interval (vt, ∞) over which the infimum is being taken. To circumvent this technicality we note that Prob
min Z(y) ≤ −
y∈[vt,∞)
1 2t
∞ X
≤
n=0
Prob
min
y∈[vt+n,vt+n+1)
Z(y) ≤ −
1 2t
. (3.12)
In order to apply Lemma 3.1, we need to show that there ∃K and α > 0 such that for every interval In = [vt+n, vt+n+1), NIn () ≤ K−α . Setting g(y, x) = E[Bh (y)−Bh (x)]2 , we have E[Z(y) − Z(x)]2 ( " # ) 2 y 2 x = − 1 g(0, x) + − 1 g(0, y) + g(x, y) /x2 y 2 . x y Assuming that y ≥ x and setting δ = (y/x)2 − 1, 2 δ 2 g(0, y) + g(x, y) /x2 y 2 E[Z(y) − Z(x)] ≤ 1+δ δ2 y 2h−2 + g(x, y)/x2 y 2 x2 (1 + δ) (y − x)2 ≤ 4 6 2−2h + g(x, y)/x2 y 2 . x y ≤
(3.13)
(3.14) (3.15) (3.16)
Thus, ∀x, y > 1 the metric p(x, y) defined by the second moment of Z(x) − Z(y) is dominated by 2 max{4(y − x)2 , g(x, y)}. Since g(x, y) = |x − y|2h , it is clear that ∀n ≥ 0, NIn () ≤ K−1/2h , for some K > 0. With E[Z(y)2 ] = y 2h−4 , Lemma 3.1 yields P
1 min Bh (y) + y 2 ≤ 0 y>vt 2t
−2 ∞ X t C 4−2h (vt + n) ≤ exp − (2t)η 8 n=0 1 4−2h 2−2h C v exp − t . ≤ (2t)η 8
(3.17) (3.18)
This, combined with Eq. 3.10, establishes the upper bound part of Theorem 1. In order to extend this result to any Gaussian process, G(·), with an energy spectrum satisfying Eq. 3.8, one only needs to note that with Z(y) now defined as y −2 G(y), and g(x, y) ≡ E[G(x) − G(y)]2 , the above proof goes through in an identical fashion. 3.1.2. Proof of velocity lower bound. Let us define a set E of FBM paths as follows: E = {Bh (·) : |Bh (y) + φ(y)| < 1, ∀y ∈ (−vt, vt + 1)}, 0
where φ(y) =
for y < 0 + α y 2 /t for y ∈ [0, vt + 1] φ(vt + 1) for y > vt + 1 , 1 2
(3.19)
(3.20)
78
R. Ryan
1 and α = vt . To establish the velocity PDF lower bound, we need to prove two things: one, that the set E ⊂ {|u(0, t)| > v}, and, two, that (3.21) P (E) ≥ exp −Cv 4−2h t2−2h , for some C > 0. 1 2 y > −α(vt)2 − 1, To prove the first, we note that for every path in E, Bh (y) + 2t 1 2 ∀y ∈ (−vt, vt). On the other hand, Bh (vt + 1) + 2t (vt + 1) < −α(vt + 1)2 + 1, which is 1 equal to −α(vt)2 − 1 − vt . Therefore, y ∗ must be outside (−vt, vt), and |u(0, t)| > v.4 To establish Eq. 3.21, we recall the spectral representation of fractional Brownian motion given by Eqs. 3.5 and 3.7, and write Z∞ (cos(yk) − 1)k −h−1/2 d(Z1 (k) + gc (k)) (3.22) Bh (y) + φ(y) = Ch −∞ Z∞
+ Ch
sin(yk)k −h−1/2 d(Z2 (k) + gs (k)),
−∞
where Z1 (·) and Z2 (·) are standard independent Brownian motions, and gc (k) and gs (k) are given by 1 −1 sin[(vt + 1)k] 2t + α (vt + 1) cos[(vt + 1)k] − k g˙c (k) = , (3.23) πCh |k|3/2−h and 1 −1 (1 − cos[(vt + 1)k]) 2t + α (vt + 1) sin[(vt + 1)k] − k . (3.24) g˙s (k) = πCh |k|3/2−h It is a simple exercise in Fourier analysis to show that gc (k) and gs (k) satisfy Eq. (3.22). Setting W1 (k) = Z1 (k) + gc (k), and W2 (k) = Z2 (k) + gs (k), we employ the CameronMartin formula to obtain a measure where W1 (·) and W2 (·) are standard independent eh (y) ≡ Bh (y) + φ(y) is now a Brownian motions. Under this measure, it is clear that B R mean-zero fractional Brownian motion on (−∞, ∞). Setting Z = g˙c (k)dW1 (k) + R R R g˙s (k)dW2 (k), and noting that [g˙c (k)]2 dk + [g˙s (k)]2 dk = Cφ t−2 (vt)4−2h + O(v 3−2h ), we obtain 1 P (E) = exp − Cφ v 4−2h t2−2h + O(v 3−2h ) (3.25) 2 " # e × E(0,0) exp {Z} ; sup |Bh (y)| < 1
y∈[−vt,vt+1]
1 ≥ exp − Cφ v 4−2h t2−2h − O(v 3−2h ) 2 × P(0,0)
|Z| < v 2−h t1−h ,
sup y∈[−vt,vt+1]
(3.26) ! eh (y)| < 1 |B
.
In order to obtain a sufficiently tight lower bound on the second term in line 3.26, we ˇ ak [13], and the need to make use of two technical lemmas. The first is due to Z. Sid´ second is due to Monrad and Rootzin [9]. They are as follows. 4
Note that symmetry implies that P (|u(0, t)| > v) = 2P (u(0, t) > v).
Statistics of Burgers Turbulence
79
ˇ ak). Given any continuous mean-zero Gaussian process X(y), y ∈ R Lemma 3.2 (Sid´ and a correlated mean-zero Gaussian random variable Z, then for any β, η > 0 and some Borel set I ⊂ R ! ! P
sup |X(y)| < β, |Z| < η
≥ P
y∈I
sup |X(y)| < β
· P (|Z| < η).
y∈I
Lemma 3.3 (Monrad and Rootzin). For a fractional Brownian motion Bh (y), with Bh (0) = 0, ! P
sup |Bh (y)| < 1
≥ exp {−C(h)t} .
y∈[0,t]
Applying these two lemmas to the second term in line 3.26, we get ! eh (y)| < 1 sup |B P(0,0) |Z| < v 2−h t1−h , y∈[−vt,vt+1]
≥ P |Z| < v
2−h 1−h
t
,
· P(0,0)
(3.27) !
sup y∈[−vt,vt+1]
eh (y)| < 1 |B
≥ exp {−Cvt} . The last inequality employs the fact Z ∼ N (0, C 0 v 4−2h t2−2h ), which implies that the probability of |Z| < v 2−h t1−h is order one. This completes the proof of Theorem 1. Of some interest is the exponential decay constant, 21 Cφ . The formula for this constant is ∞ 2 Z 1 Ch−2 cos(k) − k −1 sin(k) 1 Cφ = dk 2 8 π2 |k|3/2−h −∞ 2 Z∞ −1 sin(k) − k [1 − cos(k)] dk . + |k|3/2−h −∞
Except in the case where h = 1/2, this is not the best possible constant. With white-noise initial data, 21 Cφ = 1/6, which in a previous paper I have shown to be optimal [11]. We shall discuss further the upper and lower bound constants later in the paper. To extend this result to the more general Gaussian processes referred to earlier, we need only a few minor adjustments. The first problem that arises is the integrability of [g˙c (k)]2 and [g˙s (k)]2 , when the energy spectrum E [k] of our Gaussian process has a very rapid decay as k → ∞. Using the spectral representation of these processes, we see that cos(2vtk) sin(2vtk) Ch 2vt /(E [k])1/2 , − g˙c (k) = 2tπ k2 k3 sin(2vtk) 1 − cos(2vtk) Ch g˙s (k) = 2vt − /(E [k])1/2 . 2tπ k2 k3
80
R. Ryan
For rapidly decaying E [k], it is clear that these functions are not in L2 (R). Therefore, we must alter the set E slightly. The problem is that the curve φ is not smooth enough. So let us smooth it out by convolving it with a heat kernel, i.e. Z 2 1 e−(y−x) /2A φ(x)dx (3.28) φ∗ (y) = √ 2πA 1 for some A > 0. Setting α = 2t in the definition of φ(y) (Eq. 3.20), we redefine the set E = {Bh (·) : |Bh (y) + φ∗ (y)| < v, ∀y ∈ (−vt, 2vt)}. We see that everything goes through as before. For any stationary increment Gaussian process whose energy spectrum satisfies Eq. 3.8, φˆ∗ (k)/(E [k])1/2 is in L2 with its L2 -norm bounded from above by C 00 v 4−2h t2−2h . Geometry, again, implies that E ⊂ {|u(0, t)| > v} for large enough v. Repeating the steps of the FBM proof, one simply needs to show that P(0,0) [supy∈(−vt,2vt) |G(y)| < v] ≥ C > 0 for all v large enough. This inequality comes easily from a direct application of Lemma 3.1.
3.2. Proof of Theorem 2: Rarefaction interval tails. Without loss of generality, we look at the possibility of a large rarefaction interval surrounding the point x = 0. Following the proof of Avellaneda and E [3] for the white-noise case (h = 1/2), if there is such L , or an interval around x = 0 whose length is greater than L, then either u( L2 , t) ≥ 2t L L u(− 2 , t) ≤ − 2t . Therefore, L L L L + Prob u(− , t) ≤ − (3.29) Prob {δx(t) ≥ L} ≤ Prob u( , t) ≥ 2 2t 2 2t 1 L ≤ 2 exp − ( )4−2h t−2 , (3.30) 8 2 ∀L t. This concludes the proof of Proposition 4.2. We note that the result is also true for the more general Gaussian processes that we are interested in. 3.3. Proof of Theorem 3: Shock Strength tails. As was previously mentioned, we do not know the structure of the Eulerian shocks. Thus, we cannot say whether or not an Eulerian-shock probability distribution exists. We must instead look at the distribution of Eulerian shocks conditioned to be greater in size than some > 0. To get estimates on this distribution, we shall use the connection between the Lagrangian shock intervals and Eulerian shocks. Fixing time t, and setting SL (y) ≡ the Lagrangian shock interval which contains the point y, and {Sn }n∈Z ≡ the sequence of Eulerian shocks such that the size of each shock, denoted |Sn |, is > , one has P |SL (0)| ∈ (s, s + ds) |SL (0)| > t = E 1{|SL (0)|∈(s,s+ds)} |SL (0)| > t (3.31) 1 dy {|SL (y)|∈(s,s+ds)} −l = E lim l→∞ Rl 1{|SL (y)|> t} dy
Rl
−l
(3.32)
Statistics of Burgers Turbulence
81 N P
n=−N = E lim N →∞
s t
1{|Sn |∈[s/t,(s+ds)/t]} 2N + 1
2N + 1 N P |Sn |
(3.33)
n=−N N P
E[1{|Sn |∈[s/t,(s+ds)/t]} ] s n=−N lim = t E[|Sn |] N →∞ 2N + 1 s = P |SE | ∈ [s/t, (s + ds)/t] |SE | > . t E[|Sn |]
(3.34) (3.35)
The equality in line 3.32 uses the stationarity of the initial data and the fact that we are only looking at shocks whose size is greater than . In line 3.33, we ignore the end effects of the interval (−l, l), which are negligible as l and, thus, N → ∞. In line 3.34, we employ the stationarity and ergodicity of the sequence {Sn }n∈Z , which follow from the stationarity and ergodicity of the initial data (details given in my doctoral thesis [10]). Thus, P |SL (0)| > s
Z∞ 1 s0 0 |SL | > t = |SE | > ds0 . s P |SE | = t E[|Sn |] t s
(3.36) This implies that, for any K > 1, s t E[|Sn |] P |SL (0)| > s |SL | > t ≥ P |SE | ≥ |SE | > (3.37) s t t E[|Sn |] ≥ P |SL (0)| > s |SL | > t − P |SL (0)| > Ks |SL | > t . Ks This inequality, combined with the following proposition, which gives bounds on the Lagrangian shock interval PDF, establishes Theorem 3. Proposition 1. With initial potential being a fractional Brownian motion of parameter h, the PDF of the Lagrangian shock interval SL (y), around any point y, at a fixed time t, satisfies the following for s 1: exp −C(h)s4−2h t2−2h ≤ P (|SL (y)| > s) ≤ exp −C 0 (h)s4−2h t2−2h , (3.38) for some C(h), C 0 (h) > 0. 3.3.3. Proof of Propostion 1: Upper bound. Let SL be the Lagrangian shock interval which contains the point y = 0. Our method of proof will be to find a large set F , which is a subset of {SL > s}c . We will then obtain a lower bound on the probability of this set, thus, yielding an upper bound on {SL > s}. To this end, we make the following claim: Claim 3.1. Let F be the following set of fractional Brownian motion paths, with Bh (0) = 0 : l2 1 − 2 1 2 l2 1 + 2 + y ≤ Bh (y) + y ≤ + y , F = Bh (·) : − (3.39) 2t 2t 2t 2t 2t
82
R. Ryan
s(1−) where l = √ and is some constant in (0, 1). 4
2 (1+)
Then, F ⊂ {SL > s}c , given that Bh (·) is the initial potential for the inviscid Burgers equation. Furthermore, for some C() > 0, (3.40) P (F ) ≥ 1 − exp −C()s4−2h t−2 . With this claim established, the upper bound on Prob {SL > s} is immediate. Proof of Claim 3.1. Let us first show that F ⊂ {SL > s}c . To do this, we must show that for every path, Bh (·), in F , there can be no interval [y1 , y2 ] 3 y = 0, whose length 1 2 y ≥ βy + C, for any constants β, C, with is greater than s, and for which Bh (y) + 2t equality holding at the endpoints. By the convexity of the quadratic bounds on Bh (y), one sees that if such an interval exists then the line segment z = βy+C, y ∈ [y1 , y2 ] must also be contained in these bounds (see Fig. 1). However, it is an easy task to calculate that the largest interval surrounding the point y = 0, for which √ any such line segment 4
(1+)
2 l, which we have lies entirely between the above quadratic bounds, has length (1−) conveniently set equal to s. Therefore, every path Bh (·) ∈ F also belongs to the set {SL > s}c .
z-axis
z = (1+ε)y2/2t + εl2/2t
z = Bh(y) + y2/2t
z = (1-ε)y2/2t - εl2/2t
y-axis
Shock Interval SL 0
Fig. 1. The Lagrangian picture when Bh (·) ∈ F . The length of SL is less than
1/2 4 2 (1+)
(1−)
l = s
The second part of this proof is a straightforward application of Lemma 3.1. l2 + y 2 , ∀y ∈ R (3.41) P (F ) = P(0,0) |Bh (y)| ≤ 2t 2t 2 l2 = 1 − P(0,0) |Bh (y)| ≥ + y , for some y ∈ R (3.42) 2t 2t
Statistics of Burgers Turbulence
83
≥ 1 − 2P(0,0)
l2 + y 2 , for some y ∈ (0, l) |Bh (y)| ≥ 2t 2t
l2 + y 2 , for some y ∈ (l, ∞) − 2P(0,0) |Bh (y)| ≥ 2t 2t l2 ≥ 1 − 2P(0,0) Bh (y) ≥ , for some y ∈ (0, l) 2t −2 −2P(0,0) y Bh (y) ≥ for some y ∈ (l, ∞). 2t 2 η s exp −C()s4−2h t−2 , ≥ 1−C t h
(3.43)
(3.44)
(3.45)
4−2h
(1−) . The best choice of for each h is ≈ h2 , with “≈” becoming where C() = 29−3h (1+)2−h “=” as h & 0. We note that the only conditions necessary in the above proof were the continuity of fractional Brownian motion, and the fact that E[Bh (x)−Bh (y)]2 ≤ C|x−y|2h , ∀x, y ∈ R. Therefore, this proof holds for Burgers systems initialized with one of the related Gaussian potentials.
3.3.4. Proof of Proposition 1: Lower bound. This proof follows a line of reasoning similar to that of the velocity PDF lower bound proof. Let a set of fractional Brownian motion paths, denoted E, be defined as follows: o s n s (3.46) E = Bh (·) : |Bh (y) + φ(y)| < 1, ∀ ∈ − − 1, + 1 , 2 2
where φ(y) =
1 2t 1 2t 1 2t
2 + ε s2 + 1 for y < − s2 − 1, + ε y2 for y ∈ − s2 − 1, s2 + 1 , s 2 + ε 2 + 1 for y > s + 1,
(3.47)
1 2 and ε = s2 . For any path Bh (·) ∈ E, Bh (y) + 2t y ≥ −ε(s/2)2 − 1, ∀y ∈ (−s/2, s/2). 1 2 2 For y = ±(s + 1), Bh (y) + 2 y ≤ −ε(s/2) − 2 − ε + 1. Thus, there exists a Lagrangian shock interval [y1 , y2 ] 3 y = 0 such that y1 < −s/2 and y2 > s/2 (see Fig. 2), and E ⊂ {SL > s}. To establish the appropriate lower bound on the measure of E, we shall again use the spectral representation for FBMs and the Cameron-Martin-Girsanov formula. From this representation and a little Fourier analysis, we have
Z∞ Bh (y) + φ(y) = Ch
(cos(yk) − 1)k −h−1/2 d(Z1 (k) + g(k))
−∞ Z∞
+Ch
(3.48)
sin(yk)k −h−1/2 dZ2 (k),
−∞
˙ = where Z1 (·) and Z2 (·) are standard independent Brownian motions, and g(k) ˆ φ(k)/E [k]1/2 , i.e.
84
R. Ryan
z = Bh(y)+ 1 y2 2t
z-axis
z = - εy2 + 1
z = - εy2 - 1 y-axis
0
-s/2-1 -s/2
s/2
s/2+1
Fig. 2. The Lagrangian picture when Bh (·) ∈ E, displayed with the bounds of set E. The shock interval around y = 0 is greater than s
g(k) =
2
1 2t
+ε Ch π
"
# [ s2 + 1] cos [ s2 + 1]k − k −1 sin [ s2 + 1]k . |k|3/2−h
(3.49)
Setting W1 (k) = Z1 (k) + g(k), we employ the Cameron-Martin formula to obtain a measure where W1 (·) is a standard Brownian motion. Under this measure, it is clear eh (y) ≡ Bh (y) + φ(y) is now a centered fractional Brownian motion on (−∞, ∞). that B R R 2 ˙ dk = C 0 (h)t−2 s4−2h + O(s3−2h ), Setting Z = g(k)dW ˙ 1 (k) and noting that [g(k)] we get P (E)
"
(3.50) #
1 eh (y)| < 1 = E(0,0) exp − C 0 (h)t−2 s4−2h − O(s3−2h ) + Z ; sup |B 2 y∈(−s/2−1,s/2+1) 1 0 −2 4−2h 3−2h 2−h −1 ≥ exp − C (h)t s (3.51) − O(s )−s t 2 ! eh (y)| < 1, . × P(0,0) |Z| < s2−h t−1 , sup |B y∈(−s/2−1,s/2+1)
Applying Lemmas 3.2 and 3.3 to the second term in the above inequality, we get the desired lower bound on the measure of E and, thus, on the probability of {SL > s}. The formula for the constant in the leading exponential term is 1 1 0 C (h) = 4−2h 2 2 2 2 Ch π
Z∞ −∞
2 cos(k) − k −1 sin(k) dk. |k|3−2h
(3.52)
Statistics of Burgers Turbulence
85
In order to extend this result to general Gaussian initial potentials with the abovestated spectra, one follows the same line of reasoning used in extending Theorem 1 to cover such cases. Without going through the details a second time, it is clear, by comparing the proofs of Theorem 1 and Proposition 1, that this reasoning works here in an identical manner. 4. Discussion Using large-deviation methods, we were able to find bounds on the tail probabilities for BT systems with FBM velocity potentials. The PDFs we studied were found to decay like stretched exponentials, with the rates of decay determined by the infrared power laws in the energy spectra of the velocity potentials. The question of whether the bounds we found are optimal, however, must be answered in the negative. The exponential constants in the upper and lower bounds for the PDFs of the velocity and the shock strength do not match. Looking closely at the the velocity PDF decay rate, one can see, heuristically, where the problem lies. In a heuristic sense, large-deviation theory implies that the probability that a given realization of the velocity potential φo = φ occurs is proportional to Z 1 1 2 ˆ exp − S(φ) , S(φ) = |φ(k)| /E [k] dk. (4.1) 2 2 Here, S(φ) is the classical action associated with the Gaussian process, in our case the velocity potential, whose energy spectrum is E [k]. The probability of u(0, t) > v, for v 1, is, thus, estimated by finding the path φ∗ with the minimum action that satisfies this condition. In other words, log Prob {u(0, t) > v} ≈ −
inf
S(φ).
φ∈{u(0,t)>v}
(4.2)
law
Using the self-similarity of fractional Brownian motion, Bh (·) = ah Bh (·/a), and the initial velocity-potential description of the set {u(0, t) > v}, given by Eq. 3.9, it is not hard to show that 4−2h 2−2h S(φ) = v t S(φ) . (4.3) inf inf φ∈{u(0,t)>v}
φ∈{u(0,1)>1}
Thus, we see that the true constant in the stretched exponential decay of the velocity PDF should be Cu = inf φ∈{u(0,1)>1} S(φ). In essence, we found the velocity-PDF upper bound by minimizing S(φ) over the 1 2 y ≤ 0} ⊃ {u(0, t) < −v}. This minimization problem is much set {miny>vt φ(y) + 2t more tractable and is solved by the path 1 φ(y) = E Bh (y) Bh (0) = 0, Bh (vt) = − (vt)2 , (4.4) 2t whose action is = 18 v 4−2h t2−2h . For the lower bound on the probability of {u(0, t) > v}, we found at the action 21 Cφ of a particular path φ ∈ {u(0, t) < −v} (defined by Eq. 3.20), giving us an upper bound Cu . Thus, we proved that 1 1 ≤ Cu ≤ Cφ . 8 2
(4.5)
86
R. Ryan
We conjecture that for h ≥ 21 , the optimal path for {u(0, 1) > 1} is given by 1 φ∗ (y) = E Bh (y) Bh (z) = − z 2 , ∀z ∈ [0, 1] , (4.6) 2 with S(φ∗ ) = Cu =
( 23 − h)0( 25 − h) 1 1 , 1 2 (4 − 2h)0(h + 2 )0(3 − 2h) 2h(2 − 2h)
(4.7)
where 0(·) is the Gamma function. This conjecture was proved for h = 21 in [11]. However, the non-Markovian nature of fractional Brownian motion (h 6= 21 ) makes analysis of the action operators S(·) of these processes and, thus, the above minimization problems difficult at best. References 1. Adler, R.J.: An Introduction to Continuity, Extrema and Related Topics for General Gaussian Processes. Inst. Math. Statist. Lecture Notes – Monograph Series, Vol. 12, 1990 2. Avellaneda, M.: PDFs for velocity and velocity gradients in Burgers Turbulence. Commun. Math. Phys. 169, 134 (1995) 3. Avellaneda, M. and E, W.: Statistical properties of shocks in Burgers Turbulence. Commun. Math. Phys. 172, 13 (1995) 4. Burgers, J.M.: The nonlinear diffusion equation. Dordrecht: D. Reidel Pulishing Co., 1974 5. Gotoh, T. and Kraichnan, R.: Statistics of decaying Burgers turbulence. Phys. Fluids A 5, 445 (1993) 6. Gurbatov, S., Malakhov, A. and Saichev, A.: Nonlinear random waves and turbulence in nondispersive media: Waves, rays and particles. New York: Manchester Univ. Press, 1991 7. Handa, K.: A remark on shocks in inviscid Burgers turbulence. In: Fitzmaurice, N., Gurarie, D., McCaughan, F., Woyczy´nski, W. (eds.), Nonlinear waves and weak turbulence with applications in oceanography and condensed matter physics. Progress in Nonlinear Differnetial Equations and their applications, Vol. 11, Boston, Berlin: Birkh¨auser, 1993, pp. 339–345 8. Kraichnan, R.: Models of intermittency in hydrodynamic turbulence. Phys. Rev. Lett. 65, 575 (1990) 9. Monrad, D. and Rootzin, H.: Small value of Gaussian processes and functional laws of the iterated logarithm. Probab. Theory Related Fields 101, no. 2, 173–192 (1995) 10. Ryan, R.: Large Deviation Analysis of Gaussian Fields and Statistics of Burgers Turbulence. Doctoral thesis at Courant Institute of Mathematical Sciences at New York University, accepted September 1996 11. Ryan, R.: Large deviation analysis of Burgers turbulence with white-noise initial data. To appear in Commun. Pure Applied Math. 12. Shandarin, S.N. and Zel’dovich, Ya.B.: The large-scale structure of the Universe: Turbulence, intermittency and structures in a self-gravitating medium. Rev. Mod. Phy. 61, 185 (1989) ˇ ak, Z.: Rectangular confidence regions for the means of multivariate normal distributions. J. Am. 13. Sid´ Statist. Assoc. 62, 626–633 (1967) 14. Sinai, Y.: Statistics of shocks in solutions of inviscid Burgers equation. Commun. Math. Phys. 148, 601–622 (1992) 15. Vergassola, M., Dubrulle, B., Frisch, U. and Noullez, A.: Burgers’ Equation, Devil’s Staircases and the Mass Distribution for Large-Scale Structures. Astron. Astrophys. 289, 325–356 (1994) Communicated by Ya. G. Sinai
Commun. Math. Phys. 191, 87 – 136 (1998)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics c Springer-Verlag 1998
Vertex Operators – From a Toy Model to Lattice Algebras Andrei G. Bytsko1,2 , Volker Schomerus3 1 Institut f¨ ur Theoretische Physik, Freie Universit¨at Berlin, Arnimallee 14, 14195 Berlin, Germany. E-mail:
[email protected] 2 Steklov Mathematical Institute, Fontanka 27, St.Petersburg 191011, Russia. E-mail:
[email protected] 3 II. Institut f¨ ur Theoretische Physik, Universit¨at Hamburg, Luruper Chaussee 149, 22761 Hamburg, Germany. E-mail:
[email protected]
Received: 16 December 1996 / Accepted: 5 May 1997
Abstract: Within the framework of the discrete Wess–Zumino–Novikov–Witten theory we analyze the structure of vertex operators on a lattice. In particular, the lattice analogues of operator product expansions and braid relations are discussed. As the main physical application, a rigorous construction for the discrete counterpart gn of the group valued field g(x) is provided. We study several automorphisms of the lattice algebras including discretizations of the evolution in the WZNW model. Our analysis is based on the theory of modular Hopf algebras and its formulation in terms of universal elements. Algebras of vertex operators and their structure constants are obtained for the deformed universal enveloping algebras Uq (G). Throughout the whole paper, the abelian WZNW model is used as a simple example to illustrate the steps of our construction. Contents 1 2 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 3 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 4 4.1
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 88 Hopf Algebras and Vertex Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 92 Semi-simple modular Hopf algebras . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 92 Universal elements and R-matrix formalism . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 94 Vertex operators and their structure data . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 96 Gauge transformations of vertex operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 99 On the construction of vertex operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 99 Vertex operators for Zq . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 101 A Toy Model for the Discrete WZNW Theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 102 Properties of chiral vertex operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 102 Second chirality . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 103 ∗-operation for chiral vertex operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 105 Quantum group valued field g . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 106 Toy model for Zq . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 108 Review on Lattice Current Algebras . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 109 Definition of lattice current algebras . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 110
88
A. G. Bytsko, V. Schomerus
4.2 4.3 4.4 5 5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5 6 6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 A.1 A.2 A.3 A.4 A.5 A.6
Left currents . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111 Holonomies and monodromies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111 Current algebra for Zq . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 113 Vertex Operators on a Lattice . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 114 Definition of WN . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 114 Vertex operators at different sites . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 116 Extension on a covering of the circle . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 117 Construction of the local field gn . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 118 Lattice vertex operators for Zq . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 120 Automorphisms and Discrete Dynamics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 121 Remarks on the classical continuum limit . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 121 Automorphisms induced by the ribbon element . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 122 Discrete dynamics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 124 U (1)-WZNW model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 127 Proof of Proposition 1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 129 Proof of Proposition 3 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 130 Structure data for left chiral vertex operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 132 Properties of the field g . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 132 Properties of lattice vertex operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 133 Properties of lattice field gn . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 134
1. Introduction Quantization of the WZNW model. The Wess–Zumino–Novikov–Witten (WZNW) model [50, 46, 51, 41] is one of the most famous examples of a rational conformal field theory (CFT) [14, 42, 44]. On the classical level it describes some time evolution for a field g(x) mapping points x of the circle S1 into a compact Lie group G. Among the dynamical variables of the theory, the currents j r (x) = g −1 ∂− g, j l = (∂+ g)g −1 are of particular interest. In contrast to the field g, the currents j r and j l are chiral, so that ∂+ j r = 0 and ∂− j l = 0. Moreover, their Poisson structure is well known to give rise to two commuting copies of Kac–Moody (KM) algebras. Even though numerous papers have been devoted to the quantization of the WZNW-model (e.g. [16, 26, 10, 36, 13, 20, 21, 35]), a rigorous construction of the continuum theory (which requires field strength renormalization) is not fully understood. This motivates the search for lattice regularizations of the theory (i.e., the circle S1 is replaced by a periodic lattice with lattice spacing a) which preserve much of the symmetry structure of the continuum WZNW-model. One may construct appropriate discretizations of the classical model (i.e., ~ = 0) first and then quantize the classical lattice theory to obtain a well defined discrete quantum theory (i.e., ~ 6= 0, a 6= 0). Investigation of the latter is expected to provide insights into the structure of the continuum model. A final step would involve performing the limit a → 0 while keeping ~ 6= 0. The realization of this program was started in [4, 5, 27] where a lattice regularization of the Kac–Moody algebra has been proposed. Classical and quantum lattice current algebras were further investigated in [33, 6]. Our aim here is to extend the analysis of [6] by introducing chiral vertex operators. In comparison with the current algebra, the algebras of vertex operators contain (a finite number of) additional generators. Within these larger algebras we will be able to prepare a discrete analogue of the group valued field g(x) by combining left- and right chiral vertex operators.
Vertex Operators – From a Toy Model to Lattice Algebras
89
Quantum symmetry structure of the WZNW model. Let us recall that solutions of the classical Yang–Baxter equation appear already in the Poisson structure of the classical lattice current algebras (see [33] and references therein). After quantization, quantum groups and quantum universal enveloping algebras G 1 are expected to emerge. Throughout this paper we will meet (global and local) objects (the monodromies M α and a discrete field Nn , see below) whose nature reflects a quantum algebraic structure as well as an object (the discrete field gn ) which displays features of a quantum group. The corresponding deformation parameter is of the form q = exp{iγ~} with γ = π/(k + ν) (where k is the level of the KM algebra and ν is the dual Coxeter number of G) and does not depend on the lattice spacing a. Therefore, the quantum group structures of the continuum and lattice WZNW model coincide. It is also worth mentioning that some aspects of the quantum symmetry structure survive reductions to other theories so that part of what we describe below may be compared with studies of the quantum Liouville and Toda models [37, 29, 11, 23]. Remarks on lattice current algebras. Before we summarize our results, let us briefly review the discretization used in [6] for the chiral currents j l (x), j r (x). Recall that the latter are Lie-algebra valued fields which depend periodically on the variable x. Instead of working with these standard variables, we prefer to pass to the fields j r (x) and η(x) = j r (x) − j l (x) and describe their lattice counterparts. Our lattice divides the circle into N links of length a = 2π/N . So there are N vertices at the points x = an which are numbered by n = 0, . . . , N − 1, N ≡ 0 and the nth link runs from the (n − 1)st vertex to the nth . We may discretize the field η(x) by the simple prescription R (n+ 1 )a ηn := (n− 21 )a η(x)dx = aη(na) + O(a2 ) so that the lattice field ηn has values in a tensor 2 product of N copies of the Lie algebra which are assigned to the N vertices on the lattice. For the right chiral current j r (x) the discretization scheme is different. In this case we encode the information about the field in the holonomies along links, i.e., we define the lattice field jnr by Z jnr
j r (x)dx) .
:= P exp( n
R Here n denotes integration along the nth link. By construction, this classical lattice field jnr has values in the Lie group. The rather different treatment of the fields η(x) and j r (x) may be understood from the Poisson structure of the classical theory, which is ultralocal for η(x) but contains terms proportional to δ 0 (x − y) if the field j r (x) is involved (see [4, 33, 6]). When we pass to the quantum theory, the functions on the space of field configurations become operators and generate some non-commutative algebra KN . More concretely, the algebra KN is generated from the quantum lattice fields Jnr , Nn which correspond to the classical fields jnr , ηn described above. We review the explicit definition of lattice current algebras in Sect. 4. Let us only mention here that a very elegant formulation for commutation relations of the quantum operators can be given in the R-matrix language. In mathematical terms, one has to regard the quantum fields Nn and Jn = Jnr as objects in the tensor product Ga ⊗ KN of the deformed universal enveloping algebra Ga = Uq (G) with the lattice current algebra KN . We can understand this by looking at 1
For shortness, we will often refer to G as quantum algebra.
90
A. G. Bytsko, V. Schomerus
the classical lattice field jnr , for instance. It was constructed as the holonomy of the Liealgebra valued field j r (x) and may be evaluated with irreducible representations of the Lie algebra. Let us denote such representations by τ I and introduce the symbols V I , δI for their carrier spaces and dimensions, respectively. Then we see that jn = jnr gives rise to δI × δI -matrices jnI of dynamical variables. Accordingly, the corresponding quantum operators JnI are matrices of generators for KN which is to say that JnI ∈ End(V I )⊗KN . All these objects JnI may be assembled back into one universal element Jn ∈ Ga ⊗ KN . More details will be presented later; we anticipated this heuristic discussion of universal elements only to prepare for some formulae below. One of the main aims in [6] was to develop a complete representation theory for lattice current algebra KN . It turned out that KN possesses a family of irreducible ∗-representations on vector spaces WNIJ with labels I, J running through classes of finite-dimensional, irreducible representations of Uq (G). Two such labels are needed because of the two chiralities in the current algebra. Furthermore, the algebra KN was found to admit two families of local co-actions 3rn , 3ln : KN 7→ Ga ⊗ KN of the Hopf algebra Ga . They may be considered as a special case of the more general lattice fusion products in [6] and give rise to a notion of tensor products for representations of KN (see also [45] for related results). Vertex operators on a lattice. Product structures in the representation theory are precisely what is needed to initiate a theory of vertex operators. More technically, we employ the homomorphisms 3rn , 3ln in extending the lattice current algebra KN by chiral vertex operators 8rn , 8ln so that the following intertwining relations hold for both chiralities α = r, l, α α for all A ∈ KN . (1.1) A 8α n = 8n 3n (A) The elements 8α n generate an extension WN of the lattice current algebra KN ⊂ WN . Since 3α n (A) is an element of Ga ⊗ KN and hence also of the extension Ga ⊗ WN , the product on the r.h.s. of (1.1) is well defined for 8α n ∈ Ga ⊗ WN . On the l.h.s., A = e ⊗ A ∈ Ga ⊗ KN with e ∈ Ga being the unit element. Our vertex operators 8α n on the lattice possess a number of properties which are all closely related to properties of vertex operators in the continuum theory. Let us highlight some of them without going into a detailed discussion.2 1. Lattice vertex operators 8α n at a fixed lattice site obey operator product expansions of the form 2
1
8rn 8rn = Fr 1a (8rn )
1
and
2
8ln 8ln = Fl 1a (8ln ) .
(1.2)
1
α As usual, the notation 8α n means that we regard the vertex operator 8n as an element of Ga ⊗ Ga ⊗ WN with trivial entry in the second tensor factor etc. We have also α used the shorthand 1a (8α n ) = (1 ⊗ id)(8n ) ∈ Ga ⊗ Ga ⊗ WN for the action of the co-product on the first tensor factor of 8α n . The objects Fα are analogues of the fusion matrix in the continuum theory. We describe their general properties and, in particular, their relation with 6j-symbols in Sect. 2. 2 A construction of (non-chiral) vertex operators for infinite open lattices has been suggested in [45]. Some properties of these vertex operators are similar to what we shall consider here. However, these are different structures, in particular, because for a finite lattice the current algebra KN has a non-trivial center C. An action of our vertex operators on elements from C will play a crucial role in the theory.
Vertex Operators – From a Toy Model to Lattice Algebras
91
2. Lattice vertex operators 8α n assigned to different lattice sites obey braid relations 1
2
2
1
8rn 8rm = Rr− 8rm 8rn
2
and
1
1
2
8ln 8lm = Rl+ 8lm 8ln
(1.3)
for all 0 ≤ n < m < N . Here the objects R± play the role of the braiding matrix in the continuum theory. Let us add that lattice vertex operators of different chirality commute for all n, m. Furthermore, 8α n commute with Nm for m 6= n and with Jm for m 6= n, n + 1, that is, the vertex operators have local exchange relations with elements of the current algebra. 3. Lattice vertex operators 8α n , α = r, l, satisfy the following difference equation: α α 8α n+1 = 8n Jn+1 .
(1.4)
In the naive continuum limit, we have Jnα = e ⊗ e − aJ α (x) + O(a2 ) with x = an and the difference equation becomes a differential equation which expresses ∂x 8α (x) as a (normal ordered) product of 8α (x) and J α (x). Such an equation is well known for the quantized continuum theory. As one may infer from the third property in this short list, lattice vertex operators (much like their continuum counterparts) cannot be periodic. Indeed, starting from 8α 0 an iterated application of Eq. (1.4) gives α α 8α N ≡ 80 M
with
α M α = J1α . . . JN .
The objects M α , α = r, l, are called chiral monodromies. Actually, the lattice rotation n 7→ n + N gives rise to an inner automorphism of the algebra of vertex operators which acts trivially on the lattice fields Jnα and Nn . We show in Sect. 6 that this automorphism can be generated by conjugation with a unitary element v. The latter is constant on the irreducible representation spaces WNIJ of the lattice current algebra KN and its value vIJ = e2πi(hJ −hI ) can be expressed in terms of the conformal dimensions hI of the WZNW model. This leads us to identify v with the operator exp{2πi(L0 − L¯ 0 )} which generates rotations by 2π in the continuum theory. In the lattice theory v is obtained from quantum traces of chiral monodromies M α and is related to the ribbon element of Uq (G). It will be shown in Sects. 3 and 5 that the field Sa (8ln )8rn 3 can be restricted to the L ¯ KK . Let us denote this restriction by gn which suggests that diagonal subspace K W N it is a quantum lattice analogue of the group valued field g(x) in the WZNW model. In fact, our analysis will reveal that gn is a local and quantum group valued field, i.e. 1
2
2
1
gn gm = gm gn
(n 6= m)
and
2
1
1
2
R gn gn = gn gn R .
(1.5) α
Moreover, gn turns out to be periodic. In contrast to the chiral currents j (x), the time evolution of the group valued field g(x) is described by a nontrivial second order differential equation. Its discrete analogue is discussed in Sect. 6. Before we address the full lattice theory we explain some basic constructions in a simple toy model (cf. Sect. 3). Here one studies the algebra generated by the monodromies M r , M l instead of the whole (lattice) current algebra and universal (deformed) tensor operators for the quantum algebra G as simple examples of vertex operators 3
l
l
We use the notation Sa (8n ) = (S ⊗ id)(8n ) with S being the antipode of G.
92
A. G. Bytsko, V. Schomerus
[2, 22, 3, 19]. This finite dimensional toy model may be regarded as a special case of the discrete WZNW theory where N = 1 and it describes the non-local degrees of freedom for an arbitrary number N of lattice sites. Objects and relations of the toy model admit for a nice pictorial presentation which, in particular, brings new light into the shadow world [39]. 2. Hopf Algebras and Vertex Operators 2.1. Semi-simple modular Hopf algebras. By definition, a Hopf algebra is a quadruple (G, , 1, S) of an associative algebra G (the “symmetry algebra ”) with unit e ∈ G, a onedimensional representation : G 7→ C (the “co-unit ”), a homomorphism 1 : G 7→ G ⊗G (the “co-product ”) and an anti-automorphism S : G 7→ G (the “antipode ”). These objects obey a set of basic axioms which can be found, e.g., in [1, 49]. The Hopf algebra (G, , 1, S) is called quasi-triangular if there is an invertible element R ∈ G ⊗ G such that R 1(ξ) = 10 (ξ) R for all ξ ∈ G, (id ⊗ 1)(R) = R13 R12 ,
(1 ⊗ id)(R) = R13 R23 .
Here 10 (ξ) = P 1(ξ)P , with P being the permutation, i.e., P (ξ ⊗ η)P = η ⊗ ξ for all ξ, η ∈ G, and we are using the standard notation for the elements Rij ∈ G ⊗ G ⊗ G. For a ribbon Hopf-algebra one postulates, in addition, the existence of a certain invertible central element v ∈ G (the “ribbon element ”) which factorizes R0 R ∈ G ⊗ G ( here R0 = P RP ), in the sense that R0 R = (v ⊗ v) 1(v −1 ) ,
S(v) = v ,
(v) = 1
(2.1)
(see [48, 40] for details). We want this structure to be consistent with a ∗-operation on G. To be more precise, we require that 4 R∗ = (R−1 )0 = P R−1 P , 1(ξ)∗ = 10 (ξ ∗ ) , v ∗ = v −1 .
(2.2)
This structure is of particular interest, since it appears in the theory of the quantized universal enveloping algebras Uq (G) when the complex parameter q has values on the unit circle [43]. At this point we assume that G is semi-simple, so that every finite dimensional representation of G can be decomposed into a direct sum of finite dimensional, irreducible representations. From each equivalence class [I] of irreducible representations of G, we may pick a representative τ I , i.e., an irreducible representation of G on a δI -dimensional Hilbert space V I . The quantum trace tr Iq is a linear functional acting on elements X ∈ End(V I ) by tr Iq (X) = tr I (Xτ I (w)) . Here tr I denotes the standard trace on End(V I ) with tr I (eI ) = δI and w ∈ G is a distinguished group-like element P constructed from the ribbon element v and the element R by the formula w−1 = v −1 S(rς2 )rς1 , where the elements rςi come from the expansion P 1 R= rς ⊗ rς2 . 4 We fix ∗ on G ⊗ G by (ξ ⊗ η)∗ = ξ ∗ ⊗ η ∗ . Following [43], we could define an alternative involution † on G ⊗ G which involves a permutation of components, i.e., (ξ ⊗ η)† = η † ⊗ ξ † and ξ † = ξ ∗ for all ξ, η ∈ G. With respect to †, 1 becomes an ordinary ∗ -homomorphism and R is unitary.
Vertex Operators – From a Toy Model to Lattice Algebras
93
Evaluation of the unit element eI ∈ End(V I ) with tr Iq gives the quantum dimension, dI := tr Iq (eI ), of the representation τ I . Furthermore, we assign a number SIJ to every pair of representations τ I , τ J : SIJ := ϑ(tr Iq ⊗ tr Jq )(R0 R)IJ
with (R0 R)IJ = (τ I ⊗ τ J )(R0 R) ,
with a suitable, real normalization factor ϑ. The numbers SIJ form the so-called S-matrix S. Modular Hopf algebras are ribbon Hopf algebras with an invertible S-matrix.5 ×τ 0 , of two representations τ, τ 0 of a Let us finally recall that the tensor product, τ Hopf algebra is defined by 0 0 ×τ )(ξ) = (τ ⊗ τ )1(ξ) for all ξ ∈ G . (τ
In particular, one may construct the tensor product τ I ×τ J of two irreducible representations. According to our assumption that G be semi-simple, such tensor products of representations can be decomposed into a direct sum of irreducible representations. Among all our assumptions on the structure of the Hopf-algebra (G, , 1, S) (quasitriangularity, existence of a ribbon element v, semi-simplicity of G and invertibility of S-matrix S), semi-simplicity of G is the most problematic one. In fact it is violated by the algebras Uq (G) when q is a root of unity. It is sketched in [7] how “truncation” can cure this problem, once the theory has been extended to weak quasi-Hopf algebras [43].
Example (Modular Hopf-algebra Zq [6]). We wish to give one fairly trivial example for the algebraic structure discussed so far which comes from the group Zp . To be more precise, we consider the associative algebra Zq generated by one element h subject to the relation hp = e. Co-product, co-unit and antipode for this algebra can be defined by 1(h) = h ⊗ h , S(h) = h−1 , (h) = 1 . We observe that Zq is a commutative semi-simple algebra. It has p one-dimensional representations τ t (h) = q t , t = 0, . . . , p − 1, where q is a root of unity, q = e2πi/p . We may construct characteristic projectors P t ∈ Zq for these representations according to 1 X −tm m q h for t = 0, . . . , p − 1 . P = p p−1
t
(2.3)
m=0
One can easily check that τ t (P s ) = δt,s . The elements P t are employed to obtain a nontrivial R-matrix: p−1 X R= q ts P t ⊗ P s . (2.4) t,s=0
It is easy to see that (τ ⊗ τ )R = q . The R-matrix satisfies all the axioms stated above and thus turns Zq into a quasi-triangular Hopf algebra. Moreover, a ribbon element is P 2 given by v = q −t P t . It is natural to introduce a ∗-operation on Zq such that h∗ = h−1 . The relations (2.2) hold due to the co-commutativity of 1, i.e., 10 = 1, and the property R = R0 . A direct t
s
ts
If a diagonal matrix T is introduced according to TIJ = $δI,J d2I τ I (v) (with an appropriate complex factor $), then S and T furnish a projective representation of the modular group SL(2, Z). 5
94
A. G. Bytsko, V. Schomerus
computation shows that the S-matrix S is invertible only for odd integer p. Summarizing all this, the algebra Zq , q = exp(2πi/p) is a semi-simple ribbon Hopf-∗-algebra. It is a modular Hopf algebra for all odd integer p. The reader is invited to check that for Zq the quantum trace trqI coincides with the standard one. 2.2. Universal elements and R-matrix formalism. Modular Hopf algebras admit a very elegant R-matrix description. For its presentation, let us introduce another (auxiliary) copy, Ga , of G and let us consider the R-matrix as an object in Ga ⊗ G. To distinguish the latter clearly from the usual R, we denote it by N− ≡ (R0 )−1 ∈ Ga ⊗ G .
N + ≡ R ∈ Ga ⊗ G ,
At the same time let us introduce the standard symbols R+ = R and R− = (R0 )−1 ∈ Ga ⊗ Ga . Quasi-triangularity of the R-matrix furnishes the relations 1
2
1
1a (N± ) =N ± N ± ; 1
2
2
1
R+ N + N − =N − N + R+ ,
2
2
(2.5)
1
R + N ± N ± = N ± N ± R+ . Here we use the same notations as in the introduction, and 1a (N± ) = (1 ⊗ id)(N± ) ∈ Ga ⊗ Ga ⊗ G. The subscript a reminds us that 1a acts on the auxiliary (i.e., first) component of N± . To be perfectly consistent, the objects R± in the preceding equations should all be equipped with a lower index a to show that R± ∈ Ga ⊗ Ga , etc. We hope that no confusion will arise from omitting this subscript on R± . The Eqs. (2.5) are somewhat redundant: in fact, the exchange relations in the second line follow from the first equation in the first line. This underlines that the formula for 1a (N± ) encodes information about the product in G rather than the co-product.6 Next, we combine N+ and N− into one element N := N+ (N− )−1 ∈ Ga ⊗ G . From the properties of N± we obtain an expression for the action of 1a on N , 1
2
2
1
2
1
2
1
2
1
−1 −1 −1 R+ 1a (N ) = R+ N + N + N −1 − N − =N + N + R+ N − N − = 2
2
1
1
−1 =N + N −1 − R+ N + N − =N R+ N .
(2.6)
As seen above, the formula for 1a (N ) encodes relations in the algebra G and implies, in particular, the following exchange relations for N : 2
1
1
2
−1 −1 −1 0 −1 R− N R+ N = R− R+ 1a (N ) = R− 1a (N )R+ =N R− N R+ .
(2.7)
This kind of relations appeared first in [47] to describe relations in Uq (G). One may in fact also go in the other direction, which means to reconstruct a modular Hopf algebra G from an object N satisfying the above exchange relations. To begin with, one has to choose linear maps π : Ga 7→ C in the dual Ga0 of Ga . When such linear forms π ∈ Ga0 act on the first tensor factor of N ∈ Ga ⊗ G they produce elements in G: π(N ) ≡ (π ⊗ id)(N ) ∈ G for all π ∈ Ga0 . 0 N 00 ∈ G ⊗ G ⊗ G. The co-product 1 of G acts on N± according to 1(N± ) = (id ⊗ 1)(N± ) = N± a ± 0 00 Here N± and N± have the unit element e ∈ G in the third and second tensor factor, respectively. 6
Vertex Operators – From a Toy Model to Lattice Algebras
95
π(N ) ∈ G will be called the π-component of N or just component of N . It has been shown in [9] that the components of N generate the algebra G, that is, one can reconstruct the modular Hopf algebra G from the object N . A more precise formulation is given by the following lemma. Lemma 1 ([9]). Let Ga be a finite-dimensional, semi-simple modular Hopf algebra and N be the algebra generated by components of N ∈ Ga ⊗ N subject to the relations 1
2
N R+ N = R+ 1a (N ) ,
(2.8)
where we use the same notations as above. Then N can be decomposed into a product −1 , such that of elements N± ∈ Ga ⊗ N , N = N+ N− 0 −1 ) 1(N ) ≡ N+0 N 00 (N−
∈ Ga ⊗ N ⊗ N ,
−1 S(N± ) ≡ N± ∈ Ga ⊗ N ,
(N± ) ≡ e ∈ Ga ,
∗ N± ≡ N∓
define a Hopf-algebra structure on N . Here, the action of 1, , S on the second tensor 0 and N 00 are regarded as elements of Ga ⊗ component of N, N± is understood. N+0 , N− G ⊗ G with trivial entry in the third and in the second tensor factors, respectively. As a Hopf algebra, N is isomorphic to Ga . There is another object, similar to N , that is equally natural to consider and that will appear later in the text, e := N+−1 N− ∈ Ga ⊗ G . N Its properties are derived in complete analogy with our treatment of N , 1
2
e ) =N e R− N e, R− 1a (N
1
2
2
1
e R− N e =N e R+−1 N e R− . R+−1 N
(2.9)
e An appropriate version of Lemma 1 establishes an isomorphism between the algebra N e and the algebra Gop . The latter stands for the quantum generated by components of N algebra G with opposite multiplication, i.e., elements ξ, η ∈ Gop are multiplied according to ξ · η := ηξ. e . We wish to rewrite this simple Observe that property (2.2) implies that N ∗ = N formula for the action of ∗ on N in a more sophisticated way which proves to be useful in the sequel. For this purpose, let us introduce an element S ∈ Ga ⊗ G as follows S := N+ 1(κ) (κ ⊗ κ)−1 = N− 1(κ−1 ) (κ ⊗ κ) ,
(2.10)
where κ is some central square root of the ribbon element v ∈ G, i.e., κ2 = v and κ commutes with all ξ ∈ G. The two expressions for S given in (2.10) are equivalent due to (2.1). It is easy to check that S∗ = S ,
S 0 ≡ P SP = S −1 .
(2.11)
e with the help of S: Now we are able to rewrite the ∗-operation on N and N N ∗ = S −1 N −1 S ,
e∗ = S N e −1 S −1 . N
(2.12)
96
A. G. Bytsko, V. Schomerus
Example (The universal elements for Zq ). The notion of universal elements can be illustrated with the example P of Zq . The elements P N± ∈ Ga ⊗ G are constructed P from the R-matrix (2.4): N± = t,s q ±ts P t ⊗P s = s P s ⊗h±s and hence N = s P s ⊗h2s . The functorial (2.5), (2.8) can be verified by using the obvious identity P properties k s−k P ⊗ P . In order to make these properties more transparent, we 1(P s ) = k p introduce an Hermitian operator pb such that h = qb . It follows from the definition of τ s s that τ (b p) = s and that the co-product, antipode and co-unit act on pb according to 1(b p) = pb ⊗ e + e ⊗ pb , S(b p) = −b p , (b p) = 0 . In these notations, the characteristic projector (2.3) acquires the form P p−s) e are given by and the universal elements N± , N, N P s = p1 m q m (b p⊗b p N± = q ± b ,
p⊗b p N = q2 b ,
p⊗b p e = q −2 b N .
(2.13)
These expressions simplify the task of checking the functoriality relations in (2.5), p⊗b p p ⊗ e+e ⊗ b p) ⊗ b p = q ± (b =N ± N ± . 1a (N± ) = q ±(1⊗id) b 1
2
P 2 p2 and hence Observe that the ribbon element v = s q −s P s can be written as v = q −b − 21 b p2 . A simple calculation gives S = e ⊗ e for the element S we may choose κ = q defined in (2.10). Thus, formulae (2.12) simplify for Zq and become N ∗ = N −1 and e∗ = N e −1 . N 2.3. Vertex operators and their structure data. Our next aim is to recall the theory of tensor operators for a semi-simple modular Hopf algebra G. To this end, we combine the carrier spaces V I of its finite dimensional irreducible ∗-representations τ I into the model space M = ⊕I V I . Each subspace V I ⊂ M appears with multiplicity one. The model space M comes equipped with a canonical action of our modular Hopf algebra so that we can think of G as being contained in the associative algebra V = End(M) of endomorphisms on M. Let us also introduce C ⊂ V to denote the center of G ⊂ V and e for the unit element of V. Definition 1 ((Vertex operator)). An invertible element 8 ∈ Ga ⊗ V is called a vertex operator for G, if 1. 8 intertwines the action of G on the model space M in the sense that ξ 8 = 8 10 (ξ) for all ξ ∈ G .
(2.14)
Here ξ = e ⊗ ξ on the l.h.s. and 10 (ξ) = P 1(ξ)P on the r.h.s. are both regarded as elements in Ga ⊗ V. 2. 8 obeys the following generalized unitarity relation 8∗ = S −1 8−1 = κa κN+−1 8−1 κ−1 ,
(2.15)
where S ∈ Ga ⊗ G was defined in (2.10)–(2.11). On the r.h.s., κ±1 = (e ⊗ κ±1 ) and κa = (κ ⊗ e), so that all these factors are elements of Ga ⊗ V. Invertibility of 8 means that there exists an element 8−1 ∈ Ga ⊗ V such that 8 8−1 = e ⊗ e = 8−1 8.
Vertex Operators – From a Toy Model to Lattice Algebras
97
Since Definition 1 is fundamental to what follows below, let us discuss it in more detail. In Eqs. (2.14)–(2.15) it would be possible to replace 10 by 1 and at the same time S by S −1 . We shall meet elements 8 with such properties later and call them vertex operators as well. The relation (2.14) describes the covariance property of 8. It means that 8 is a universal tensor operator for G (see, e.g., [43]). More precisely, we may evaluate the element 8 ∈ Ga ⊗ V with representations τ I of G to obtain matrices 8I = (τ I ⊗ id)(8) ∈ End(V I ) ⊗ V. The rows of these matrices form tensor operators which transform covariantly according to the representation τ I of G. The relation (2.14) may be rewritten in the R-matrix formalism of Subsect. 2.2 (see [6], where a similar calculation was discussed) as follows: 1
2
2
1
N ± 8 =8 R ± N ±
1
or
2
2
1
N 8 R− = 8 R+ N .
(2.16)
These relations are equivalent [17] to the definition of deformed tensor operators in terms of generalized adjoint actions of G which is often used in the theory of (q-deformed) tensor operators (see, e.g., [15]). Our formula (2.15) for the ∗-operation on 8 certainly deserves a more detailed explanation.7 Both expressions we have provided describe 8∗ in terms of 8−1 . Using the intertwining relation (2.14) one concludes that the conjugated vertex operator obeys a transformation law which differs from the covariance properties of the inverse 8−1 : 8−1 ξ = 10 (ξ) 8 while
8∗ ξ = 1(ξ) 8∗ .
The second relation follows from our assumption (2.2) on the behaviour of the co-product under conjugation. Comparison of the two transformation laws motivates to multiply 8−1 with a factor N+−1 so that we obtain two objects with identical covariance properties, namely 8∗ and N+−1 8−1 . In addition, the operation ∗ is supposed to be an involution, i.e., (8∗ )∗ = 8. This requires to dress the operator N+−1 8−1 with factors of κ as we did in the second expression for 8∗ in (2.15). All these factors can be moved to the left of 8−1 with the help of Eq. (2.14), so that 8∗ = S −1 8−1 . The identity (8∗ )∗ = 8 holds then as a consequence of (2.11). Suppose for the moment that we are given a vertex operator 8 in the sense of our Definition 1. Then we can use it to construct the following structure data of 8, 2
1
F := 8 8 1a (8−1 ) ∈ Ga ⊗ Ga ⊗ V, −1
σ(f) := 8 (e ⊗ f) 8
for all f ∈ C ⊂ V ,
D := 8 N 8−1 ∈ Ga ⊗ V.
(2.17) (2.18) (2.19)
As they are defined, the last tensor components of F, D and σ(f) belong to the algebra V. However, with the help of relation (2.14) and standard axioms of Hopf algebra it is easy to see that F, D and σ(f) commute with all elements ξ ∈ G ⊂ V and hence that F ∈ Ga ⊗ Ga ⊗ C while σ(f), D ∈ Ga ⊗ C. Before we give a comprehensive list of properties of the structure data, we introduce some more notations, R± ≡ F 0 R± F −1 ∈ Ga ⊗ Ga ⊗ C and 1F (ξ) ≡ F (1(ξ) ⊗ e) F 7
−1
∈ Ga ⊗ Ga ⊗ C.
∗-operations of a similar form have appeared in [43, 3, 7].
(2.20) (2.21)
98
A. G. Bytsko, V. Schomerus
Here F 0 = (P ⊗ e)F (P ⊗ e). As a consequence of Eqs. (2.17)–(2.18) and our definition (2.20) we obtain the following exchange relations for vertex operators: 2
1
1
2
2
1
1
2
R± 8 8 = 8 8 R± , R± σ σ (f) =σ σ (f) R± .
(2.22)
It is also worth noticing that one may think of R and 1F as being obtained from R and 1 through a twist with F in the sense of Drinfeld [25]. Proposition 1 (Properties of the structure data). Let the structure data be defined as in Eqs. (2.17)–(2.19). Then it follows from Definition 1 that 1. the element D ∈ Ga ⊗ C may be expressed in terms of σ and the ribbon element v so that (2.23) D = va v−1 σ(v) . Here va = (v ⊗ e) ∈ Ga ⊗ C and v = (e ⊗ v) ∈ Ga ⊗ C, that is, we denote the ribbon element by va and v when it is regarded as an element of Ga or C, respectively. 2. The elements F, R± ∈ Ga ⊗Ga ⊗C and D ∈ Ga ⊗C together with the homomorphism σ : C → Ga ⊗ C obey the following set of relations: 3 (2.24) (e ⊗ F ) (id ⊗ 1a )(F ) = σ (F ) (1a ⊗ id)(F ) , 1
2
2
D R− = R+ σ (D), 2
1
σ σ (f) = 1F (σ(f)) 2
1
R− D = σ (D) R+ ,
(2.25)
for all f ∈ C,
(2.26)
1
3
R±,12 σ (R±,13 ) R±,23 = σ (R±,23 ) R±,13 σ (R±,12 ). 2
1
(2.27) 2
The symbol σ (D) denotes (id ⊗ σ)(D) ∈ Ga ⊗ Ga ⊗ C and σ (D) = (P ⊗ e) σ (D) (P ⊗ e) with P being the permutation. Similar conventions apply to Eqs. (2.24), (2.27). 3. The behaviour of the structure data with respect to the ∗-operation is given by F ∗ = Sa F −1 R∗± = R−1 ± , ∗
∗
σ(f) = σ(f ),
with
Sa = (R+ 1(κ) (κ ⊗ κ)−1 ) ⊗ e ∈ Ga ⊗ Ga ⊗ C , D∗ = D−1 , ∗
(2.28) ∗
(1F (ξ)) = 1F (ξ ),
for all ξ ∈ G and f ∈ C. It means, in particular, that D, R± are unitary while σ, 1F act as ∗-homomorphisms. A proof of the main statements can be found in Appendix A.1. It should be mentioned that some of the relations given in Proposition 1 have appeared in the literature before. Equation (2.27) is probably the most characteristic in our list as it generalizes the usual Yang–Baxter equation. It appeared first in connection with the quantum Liouville model [37]; later some universal solution for Eq. (2.27) in the case of G = Uq (sl(2)) has been found [11]. More recently in [12], the elements F and R and their relations were reinterpreted in the language of quasi-Hopf algebras [25]. As we remarked already, F may be regarded as a twist and it follows from Eq. (2.24) that the twisted co-product 3 −1 . The latter can be used to 1F is quasi-coassociative with co-associator φ = σ (F12 ) F12 rewrite Eq. (2.27) as a quasi Yang–Baxter equation (more details are discussed, e.g., in [12, 18]).
Vertex Operators – From a Toy Model to Lattice Algebras
99
Relations (2.19), (2.25) and the first equation in (2.22) have been introduced in [2] in a description of deformed cotangent bundles Tq∗ G. There, an object N was defined in terms of 8 and D through Eq. (2.19). The relation (2.25) allowed to derive exchange relations for N which guaranteed that coordinate functions for the fibers of Tq∗ G could be obtained from N . We shall see later that the equations in Proposition 1 have a number of important implications for the lattice theories. Reversing this logic, many of the relations in Proposition 1 were conjectured as natural properties of a coordinate dependent braiding matrix in the continuum WZNW-model [26, 20, 21]. 2.4. Gauge transformations of vertex operators. There exists a large gauge freedom in the choice of vertex operators 8. In fact, one may replace 8 7→ 38 with 3 ∈ Ga ⊗ C being invertible and unitary. This transformation does not change the general properties (2.14)–(2.15) of vertex operators but certainly effects their structure data. Namely, after the action of 3 on 8 the initial structure data transform into the following ones: 2
F 7→ 3 σ (3) F 1a (3−1 ), 2
D 7→ 3 D 3−1 ,
σ(f) 7→ 3 σ(f) 3−1 for all f ∈ C, 2
where σ (3) = (id ⊗ σ)(3) ∈ Ga ⊗ Ga ⊗ C, as before. One may reduce such a gauge freedom by additional requirements on the structure data or on the vertex operators. For instance, the gauge freedom allows to normalize the vertex operators in the following sense. Consider the element w := a (8) ≡ ( ⊗ id)8 ∈ V, where : G 7→ C stands for the co-unit of G. An application of the Hopf algebra axiom ( ⊗ id)1 = id to (2.14) furnishes the identity ξw = wξ and hence w ∈ C. From this and Eqs. (2.18)–(2.19) we conclude that ( ⊗ id)D = e , ( ⊗ id)σ(f) = f for all f ∈ C . Moreover, (2.15) implies unitarity of w (observe that ( ⊗ id)(S) = e). Therefore, we can perform the gauge transformation 8 7→ (e ⊗ w−1 )8, which does not change σ and D but normalizes F and 8 so that, without loss of generality, we may assume a (8) = e ∈ C ,
(id ⊗ ⊗ id)F = ( ⊗ id ⊗ id)F = e ⊗ e ∈ Ga ⊗ C .
The normalization of F follows from the normalization and operator product expansion of 8 with the help of ( ⊗ id)1 = id = (id ⊗ )1. It also leads to the identities ( ⊗ id)R± = (id ⊗ )R± = e ⊗ e. Finally, let us notice that multiplication of vertex operators 8 by element f ∈ Ga ⊗ G from the right, i.e., 8 7→ 8F, corresponds to twisting the co-product of G. 8 Transformations of this kind relate vertex operators 8q = 81 Fq for the deformed universal enveloping algebras Uq (G) with unitary vertex operators 81 of the undeformed algebras U (G) [25]. 2.5. On the construction of vertex operators. So far, we have considered the vertex operators as given objects. In the spirit of Lemma 1, however, we can reverse our approach and think of them as being defined through Eqs. (2.17)-(2.19) with an appropriate set of structure data. This is made more precise in the following proposition. 8 The object F should not be confused with our F ∈ G ⊗ G ⊗ C. We use similar letters mainly for a a historical reasons.
100
A. G. Bytsko, V. Schomerus
Proposition 2 (Reconstruction of 8 from structure data). For a modular Hopf algebra G ∼ = Ga with center C, let F ∈ Ga ⊗ Ga ⊗ C and a homomorphism σ : C → Ga ⊗ C be given. Define the elements D ∈ Ga ⊗ C, R± ∈ Ga ⊗ Ga ⊗ C through Eqs. (2.23), (2.20), respectively, and suppose that F, σ (together with D, R± ) satisfy the relations (2.24)–(2.28). Then there exists a vertex operator 8 ∈ Ga ⊗ V for G such that 2
1
8 8 = F 1a (8)
,
8 f = σ(f) 8 .
(2.29)
In particular, the invertible element 8 ∈ Ga ⊗ V has the properties (2.14)–(2.15) and the algebra V generated by its components is associative. V may be identified with the L algebra of operators on the model space M = I V I , as before. Proof. Let us only sketch the proof since it is based on the same computations that are involved in the proof of Proposition 1. The construction of 8 starts from Eqs. (2.29). In e which is generated by components fact, one can use them to build an abstract algebra V e of an object 8 ∈ Ga ⊗ V and elements in C such that the two relations (2.29) hold. The properties (2.24), (2.26) ensure this algebra to be well defined and associative. Due e admits a consistent ∗-operation which makes 8 unitary in the sense to Eqs. (2.28), V e is defined by Eq. (2.19). With of Eq. (2.15). In the next step, an element N ∈ Ga ⊗ V the help of Eqs. (2.25) one proves that N obeys the relations (2.8), (2.16) and hence e contains G as a subalgebra. This subalgebra is finally used to analyze a concrete that V e and to show that V e ∼ representation of V = V = End(M); hence, components of 8 become operators on the model space M. Let us apply Proposition 2 to the example of G ∼ = Uq (G). To this end we need to define appropriate candidates for F and σ which is achieved with the help of the Clebsch–Gordan maps C[T L|S] : V T ⊗ V L → V S and the 6j-symbols { .. .. .. } of Uq (G). Within the space V L of highest weight L, we fix a basis of eigenvectors eL λ for the Cartan subalgebra with eigenvalues λ and denote the associated Clebsch–Gordan S ]. Now define F, σ such that coefficients by [ Tϑ L λ ς F T L = (τ T ⊗ τ L )(F )
and
σ L (b p) = (τ L ⊗ id)(σ(b p))
TL Fϑλ,ϑ 0 λ0 =
X
∗ T S { Tpˆ L pˆ +ϑ+λ pˆ +λ } [ ϑ0
have matrix elements
L S ],
λ0 ς
(2.30)
S,ς
σ L (b p)λ,λ0 = (b p + λ) δλ,λ0 .
(2.31)
Here b p is a rank(G)-dimensional vector of elements in C with τ K (b p) = K. Other notations and conventions are explained in Appendix A.2. Proposition 3. (Vertex operators for Uq (G)) There exist vertex operators 8q for the deformed universal enveloping algebras Uq (G) such that 2
1
8q 8q = F 1a (8q )
,
8q f = σ(f) 8q .
Here F is built up from the 6j-symbols and the Clebsch–Gordan maps of Uq (G) as in Eq. (2.30) and σ is given by (2.31).
Vertex Operators – From a Toy Model to Lattice Algebras
101
The statement follows directly from Proposition 2 once the relations (2.24)–(2.28) have been checked to hold for F, σ. The latter is done in Appendix A.2. Let us mention that formulae similar to (2.30) were considered in [12, 18]. 2.6. Vertex operators for Zq . To conclude our discussion of vertex operators, let us provide an explicit formula for 8 in our standard example G = Zq . Let us fix a set of normalized basis vectors |si, s = 0, . . . , p − 1, for the one-dimensional carrierL spaces V s of the representations τ s . They span the p-dimensional model space M = s V s . b ∈ End(M) by On this space one can introduce a unitary operator Q b |p − 1i = |0i Q
and
b |si = |s + 1i Q
for all s = 0, . . . , p − 2. This operator obeys Weyl commutation relations with the b h = h Q. b With the help of Q b and the characteristic projectors generator h ∈ Zq , i.e., q Q s P introduced in Subsect. 2.1 we are able to define 8: X X bs = 1 b s ∈ Ga ⊗ End(M) . 8 := Ps ⊗ Q q −st ht ⊗ Q p s s,t b and the Weyl relations of Q b and h that 8 obeys all the It follows from the unitarity of Q defining properties of a vertex operator (as we explained in Subsect. 2.2, the element S in Eq. (2.15) becomes trivial for G = Zq ). One may then compute the structure data. To this end it is convenient to employ the operator pb introduced in Subsect. 2.2 such that p . Since the commutative algebra Zq is isomorphic to its center C, all elements in h = qb Zq can be regarded as elements of C and we use our standard notational conventions p for h, b whenever we do so, in particular we shall use h = qb p ∈ C. We also introduce b ς b b and h imply an anti-Hermitian operator ςb by Q = e , so that the Weyl relations for Q [b p , ςb] = e. Within these notations our basic objects look as follows: p ∈G, h = qb
p ⊗b ς p 2 ∈ C , 8 = eb v = q −b ∈ Ga ⊗ End(M) .
Now expressions for the structure data may be obtained by short computations, F =e⊗e⊗e,
p ) = h−1 ⊗ qb p = q −b p ⊗ e+e ⊗ b p, σ(qb
p D = q −2 (b
2
⊗ e−b p⊗b p)
p⊗b p⊗e and R± = qb . Let us remark that, although the example of vertex operators for Zq is fairly trivial, it nevertheless shares some features with the case of G = Uq (G). Indeed, the ribbon element p (b p+ρ) [25], where b p ∈ C ⊗r is a r = rank(G)-dimensional of Uq (G) is given by v = q −b K vector such that τ (b p) = K and ρ is the sum of the positive roots. Our above formula (2.31) means that
b b p, b ⊗e+e⊗b σ(b p) = H p , D = (χ ⊗ e) · q −2H⊗ b is a vector of elements in the Cartan subalgebra such that He b L = λeL and where H λ λ the element χ ∈ G = Uq (G) can be worked out easily with the help of Eq. (2.23). Such expressions, or special cases thereof, may be found in [23, 20, 2, 21, 18]). The element F and the vertex operators 8 are certainly quite non-trivial for Uq (G) (for some explicit examples see [33, 22, 19, 18]).
102
A. G. Bytsko, V. Schomerus
3. A Toy Model for the Discrete WZNW Theory In the rest of this paper we shall apply the theory of modular Hopf algebras and their vertex operators to construct and investigate the lattice WZNW-model. We start with a simple toy model for which the lattice consists of only one site and one edge (see Fig. 1). When we discuss the general notion of lattice current algebras in Sect. 4, we shall understand that they contain chiral observables M (the chiral monodromies) being assigned to the edge. r8
M
Fig. 1. Single-vertex lattice. Chiral observables M are assigned to the edge while chiral vertex operators 8 sit on the vertex
3.1. Properties of chiral vertex operators. Later in the text we shall find that the global chiral observable M in the lattice current algebra obeys the following relation 2
1
M R+ M = R− 1a (M ) ,
(3.1)
where R± , 1a are attributes of the modular Hopf algebra G as before. Components of M generate an algebra J with center denoted by C. Equation (3.1) reminds us of the defining relation (2.6) for the universal element N , which contains all the information about the structure of G. Indeed, the only difference is that the R+ on the l.h.s. of Eq. (2.6) has been replaced by R− . A short computation reveals that we can pass from Eq. (3.1) to (2.6) by rescaling M with the ribbon element va = (v ⊗ e) ∈ Ga ⊗ G. This implies that N 7→ va M provides an isomorphism of the algebras G and J . In particular, the commutation relations for M , 2
1
1
2
−1 −1 R± M R+ M = M R− M R∓
(3.2)
coincide with Eqs. (2.7) for the element N . The isomorphism of J and G certainly implies that there is a ∗-operation on J given by the formula (2.12) with N replaced by M (notice that the factor va is unitary). The lattice theories, however, choose a different conjugation which we discuss in Subsect. 3.3 below. Now let us introduce a vertex operator 8 for J ∼ = G. It will be called chiral vertex operator of the toy model and its properties can be copied from the relations (2.14) -(2.19) when we keep in mind to replace N by va M , η 8 = 8 10 (η), 2
1
8 8 = F 1a (8), D 8 = va 8 M,
1
2
2
1
M 8 R− = 8 R+ M , 2
1
1
(3.3)
2
R± 8 8 =8 8 R± ,
(3.4)
8 f = σ(f) 8 for all f ∈ C.
(3.5)
Here η ∈ J , C stands for the center of J , and we used the same notations as in the previous section. The components of 8 ∈ Ga ⊗ V give rise to the algebra V of chiralL vertex operators. Together with components of M , they act on the model space M = I V I.
Vertex Operators – From a Toy Model to Lattice Algebras
103
We refer to the first equation in (3.4) as operator product expansions (OPE) for 8 and call F the universal fusion matrix. The second formula in (3.4) follows from the operator product expansions; it describes braid relations for the chiral vertex operators and hence leads to interpret R± as the braiding matrix of our model. 9 There exists a nice pictorial presentation for the described algebraic structure. Definitions for the basic objects – except from D, M – are given in Fig 2. Pictures for M and D may, in principle, be constructed with the help of Eq. (2.23), Eqs. (3.5) and an appropriate presentation of the ribbon element. From the basic blocks we can built up the equations (3.3)–(3.5) as in Fig 3. All these pictures are separated by a thick solid line into left and right halves with dotted lines appearing on the left side while thin solid lines exist only on the right side. Our graphical rules are the same as in [39], and, in their terminology, the dotted lines may be said to live in the shadow world. ppppp
pppp @
:= 8
ppppp ppppp ppp ppp p p p p p p p p : = R+ ppppp ppppp
ppppp
ppppp
: = 1a (8)
ppppppp p p p p p p p p p ppppfp
ppppp ppppp p p pppppppp : = R− ppppppppppppppppp : = F ppppp pppp pppp pppppppp ppp
η
ppppp
p @ @
:= f
:= η
ppppp
p pppppp p p p p p p p p p p p p p p ppp p p fp p p p p ppp
: = σ(f)
η@
: = 1 (η)
@
0
Fig. 2. Graphical presentation of our basic objects. Pictures for D and M exist as well, but they are more complicated (cf. remarks in the text)
3.2. Second chirality. What we have discussed so far will be relevant for right chiral objects in the discrete WZNW model. Now we have to describe an analogous construction for the left chiral sector of the theory. To distinguish the two chiralities, we mark the objects of the previous subsection by an extra index r so that M r = M, 8r = 8, Fr = F, σr = σ . . . etc. Their left chiral counterparts will have an index l. To introduce left chiral vertex operators 8l we follow the same strategy as in the previous subsection. Namely, we postulate algebraic relations for an object M l (which will be justified in Sect. 4) and use them as the basic input for our left chiral theory. So let us assume that we are given some object M l such that 1
2
l l l M R− M = R+ 1a (M ) .
(3.6)
The algebra generated by components of M l will be denoted by J l and we use the symbol C l for its center. It is easy to see that the properties of va−1 M l coincide with those of the element e introduced in Subsect. 2.2, Eq. (2.9). This holds, in particular, for the commutation N relations, 1 2 2 1 −1 l l l −1 l (3.7) R± M R − M = M R+ M R∓ . 9 This will become clearer in the full lattice theory where braid relations of vertex operators assigned to different sites contain only R± and the factor R± is absent. Observe also that in the quantum non-deformed limit, i.e., γ → 0, ~ 6= 0, q = ei~γ → 1, the R-matrix R± approaches e ⊗ e whereas the limit of R± is non-trivial (cf. also [2, 19]).
104
A. G. Bytsko, V. Schomerus
ppppp ppppp
ppppp
ppppp
p ppp @ @
(3.4)
=
pppp pp p pp pp p p p p pppp p pfp @ @ pppp
pppp
ppppp ppppp ppppppp ppppp p @ @
=
pppp
(3.3)
=
pppp
pp pp pp pp pp pp p
=
8−1 8 = e ⊗ e
pppp p p p p p p p p p p p p p p pfp p p ppp @ @
(3.5)
pp η @@
@ppppp ppppppppp @ ppppp
pp η@ @
=
pppp @ @ppppp pppp @
e⊗e=88
η
p pp pp p p p p p p p p pfp p
ppppp
=
−1
p p ppp p p p p p p p p p p pfp η
Fig. 3. Pictorial presentation of some basic relations. Only the left equations in (33), (34) and the right equation in (35) are depicted. The figure in the lower right corner means that f ∈ C is central in G. More rules are explained in the text.
e , i.e., Thus, the algebra J l is isomorphic to the algebra generated by components of N to Gop ( op means the opposite multiplication, cf. Subsect. 2.2). Since Eqs. (3.6)–(3.7) differ from the properties of M r , the relations for the left chiral vertex operators will differ from those we had in the right chiral sector. The consistent definition of the left vertex operators is provided by the following list of fundamental relations: 1