Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 1
10/23/07 10:21:49 AM...
58 downloads
2103 Views
21MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 1
10/23/07 10:21:49 AM
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
Edited by David Tolfree and Mark J. Jackson
Boca Raton London New York
CRC Press is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group, an informa business
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 3
10/23/07 10:21:50 AM
CRC Press Taylor & Francis Group 6000 Broken Sound Parkway NW, Suite 300 Boca Raton, FL 33487‑2742 © 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC CRC Press is an imprint of Taylor & Francis Group, an Informa business No claim to original U.S. Government works Printed in the United States of America on acid‑free paper 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 International Standard Book Number‑13: 978‑0‑8493‑8315‑1 (Hardcover) This book contains information obtained from authentic and highly regarded sources. Reprinted material is quoted with permission, and sources are indicated. A wide variety of references are listed. Reasonable efforts have been made to publish reliable data and information, but the author and the publisher cannot assume responsibility for the validity of all materials or for the conse‑ quences of their use. No part of this book may be reprinted, reproduced, transmitted, or utilized in any form by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying, microfilming, and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without written permission from the publishers. For permission to photocopy or use material electronically from this work, please access www. copyright.com (http://www.copyright.com/) or contact the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc. (CCC) 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, 978‑750‑8400. CCC is a not‑for‑profit organization that provides licenses and registration for a variety of users. For organizations that have been granted a photocopy license by the CCC, a separate system of payment has been arranged. Trademark Notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation without intent to infringe. Library of Congress Cataloging‑in‑Publication Data Tolfree, David, 1938‑ Commercializing micro‑nanotechnology products / David Tolfree and Mark J. Jackson. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978‑0‑8493‑8315‑1 (alk. paper) 1. Nanotechnology. 2. Microtechnology. 3. Nanotechnology‑‑Economic aspects. 4. Microtechnology‑‑Economic aspects. I. Jackson, Mark J. II. Title. T174.7.T65 2007 620’.50688‑‑dc22
2007025686
Visit the Taylor & Francis Web site at http://www.taylorandfrancis.com and the CRC Press Web site at http://www.crcpress.com
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 4
10/23/07 10:21:50 AM
Contents Preface......................................................................................................................vii Editors.......................................................................................................................xi Contributors.............................................................................................................. xv Chapter 1 The Path to Commercialization............................................................ 1 David Tolfree and Robert Mehalso Chapter 2 Entrepreneurship’s Role in Commercializing MicroNanotechnology Products................................................................... 29 Bruce A. Kirchhoff and Steven T. Walsh Chapter 3 Roadmapping Nanotechnology........................................................... 51 Steven T. Walsh, Bruce A. Kirchhoff, and David Tolfree Chapter 4 Technology Transfer of Nanotechnology Products from . U. S. Universities................................................................................. 71 Mark J. Jackson, G. M. Robinson, and M. D. Whitfield Chapter 5 Commercialization Strategies for Public Research Organizations: How to Move from Public Research into the Market by a Leading Dutch Institute.................................................. 81 Kees Eijkel and Arend Zomer Chapter 6 Market Analysis and Growth for Micro-Nano Products................... 105 Jean-Christophe Eloy Chapter 7 Oxonica Plc: A Leading U.K. Nanotechnology Business................. 143 Kevin Matthews Chapter 8 Zyvex Corporation: Providing Nanotechnology . Solutions — Today™........................................................................ 167 James R. Von Ehr II © 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 5
10/23/07 10:21:50 AM
vi
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
Chapter 9 microParts GmbH: The History of the Development of a Successful German Microsystems-Based Business.......................... 189 Reiner Wechsung Chapter 10 Shaping the Future............................................................................ 229 David Tolfree Chapter 11 Glossary............................................................................................. 253
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 6
10/23/07 10:21:51 AM
Preface Now, in the first decade of the twenty-first century, we are witnessing a quiet manufacturing revolution resulting from the rapid advances made in science and technology in the twentieth century. We are now in the information age and the third industrial revolution based on a knowledge-driven economy. Small technologies, led by micro-nanotechnology, the products of physics, chemistry and engineering and more recently biology, are key drivers of this economy. They are already impacting industries and are having a profound effect on the way people live and work. The ubiquitous use of computers and mobile telephones in industry and commerce, satellite links for communication, improved protective sunscreens, cosmetics, stain-resistant fabrics, composite materials for vehicles and sports equipment, portable diagnostic medical devices, targeted drug delivery systems, fire and water resistant coatings and materials for fuel cells are among some of the products currently on the market or are near-market. There is the promise of many more products in the foreseeable future. The further application of these technologies to manufacture new products and systems is well underway in the US, Asia and Europe but their potential disruptive nature, coupled with public concerns about some aspects of nanotechnology, have raised possible health issues that need to be examined. The emergence of the global market is producing unparalleled opportunities but is also forcing up the pace of international competition. Nations that have a strategy for economic development based on innovation and the exploitation of science and technology, since they are the key to wealth creation and prosperity, will become leaders in this market. We can expect a high demand for new products, systems and services to meet the growing needs of the new economies of Europe and Asia. It is predicted that the global market for micro-nanoproducts and systems will exceed $1 trillion in the next decade. Companies create wealth from the commercial exploitation of their intellectual property. Taking the results of research to full commercialization requires experience in design, manufacturing and marketing and a suitable infrastructure that encourages innovation and the training of technologists and engineers with an understanding of business. Competitive advantage is gained by deploying such a workforce for the development and realization of low cost, high quality products and services that offer at the right time unique advantages to the buyer. Failure to do this will put delays in the full commercialization cycle. Most Governments in the industrialized world are funding micro-nanotechnology research and development because of the economic benefits they will bring to their countries. At present the number of companies that have been successful in markets for micro-nanoproducts is relatively small but this is expected to grow significantly in the coming years. There is an urgent need to: raise awareness, encourage private investment, establish reliable manufacturing processes and agree on standards for design.
vii © 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 7
10/23/07 10:21:51 AM
viii
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
The manufacturing of micro-nanotechnology products raises particular challenges and important fundamental issues related to costs, yields and reproducible quality and acceptability. It is clear that new manufacturing methodologies and processes will have to be developed together with metrology systems, particularly for nanomanufacturing. These will need to extend across multi-disciplinary domains (mechanical, electrical, optical, chemical and biological etc.) if a wide range of new products and systems are to be realized. The challenge facing nations, regions and companies who embrace micro-nanotechnologies is to understand how to manage the economic and social changes they will bring about. The chapters in this book have been written by some of the world’s leading academics and practitioners. Chapter 1 sets the scene by taking the reader along the path to product commercialization, detailing the steps that are needed to convert an idea into a marketable product. Examples are given of products that have successfully entered the market. The authors relate their own experiences in developing and bringing micro-nanoproducts to the market. Chapter 2 is about the importance of entrepreneurship, what is needed to build a successful start-up business and the steps that need to be taken to finance and develop a marketing strategy. Roadmaps are essential tools for planning a future business or helping decision-makers to develop future strategies. Roadmapping nanotechnology is relatively new, so in Chapter 3 the authors discuss the various definitions of nanotechnology and how the issues they raise relate to the production of roadmaps. The various types of roadmaps and the methods used to collect information and produce them are described. In Chapter 4, the role of government agencies, private investors and corporations in expediting technology transfer from universities is covered with particular reference to the US National Nanotechnology Initiative. Public research organizations carry out much of the research and development in micro-nanotechnology. This can raise problems when reaching out into the commercial market place. In Chapter 5, the authors describe their experiences on how the Dutch Institute of Nanotechnology known as Mesa +, located within the University of Twente, developed a commercialization strategy based on a partnership with government and industry by applying the Triple Helix concept which is described in the text. The roles of the partners and the collaboration process at three levels, the conceptual level, the procedural level and the operational or practical level are described. Commercialization is about making products that sell in the market place. First, there has to be a market and then a knowledge of how to access it. In Chapter 6, Jean-Christophe Eloy, the Director of Yole Développement, a market research and strategy consulting company and world leader in the analysis and evaluation of the MEMS markets, explains how such markets are developed and analyzed. Examples are given with illustrations of a number of products such as ink-jets and pressure sensors and the markets they supply. In. the. remaining. Chapters,. 7,. 8. and. 9,. three. leading. micro-nanotechnology. development and manufacturing companies in the UK, US and Germany describe how their businesses started and progressed to become market leaders. They provide a valuable insight into how they overcame the difficulties of raising finance and finding the right product to develop for the growing market for micro-nanoproducts.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 8
10/23/07 10:21:51 AM
Preface
ix
Their experiences will be a valuable aid to anybody or any company wishing to follow a similar path to commercialization. In the concluding Chapter 10, the author takes an optimistic but realistic view of how the new technologies will shape the future. Based on current developments, he makes some guarded predictions up to 2030. Beyond that although predictions are tainted with speculation they can help readers visualize the shape of things to come. The book gives an appraisal of the current status of small technologies and their ability to produce and commercialize new products and systems. An outlook and future perspective of how micro-nanotechnologies will change the future is given to help those concerned about economic and social change. It will be of specific interest to people, companies, and governments wishing to invest in these new technologies and find out about more about the path to commercialization. The editors wish to thank all the chapter authors for their valued contributions to this book and to the many other professionals from whom we sought knowledge and assistance. We particularly acknowledge the proofreading skills of Valerie Tolfree, the wife of the lead editor, whose patience and encouragement helped in the writing of this book. David Tolfree and Mark J. Jackson Editors
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 9
10/23/07 10:21:51 AM
Editors David Tolfree, MSc., F.Inst.P., CPhys., F.IoN. is the co-founder and Executive Director of Technopreneur Ltd, a consultancy company for the exploitation of micro-nanotechnology, established at Daresbury in Cheshire, England. He is one of the founders of MANCEF (Micro and Nanotechnology Commercialization Educational Foundation), an international body dedicated to commercialization and education, and is currently its European Vice-President. David is also one of the founders of the UK Institute of Nanotechnology and is a member of its Advisory Board. He is a Chartered Physicist, a Fellow of the Institute of Physics and the Institute of Nanotechnology and has published over 130 papers, including news articles, chapters for books and conference papers, and has given interviews on television and radio. He is internationally recognized as an authority on the exploitation of micro-nanotechnology and co-authored chapters in the MANCEF International Microsystems and Top-Down Nanotechnology Roadmap. He is currently the guest editor and contributor to the International Journal of Nanomanufacturing; and is also on the advisory boards of a number of international conferences. David gained over 40 years’ experience in research, project management and the marketing of research facilities while employed by the Council for the Central Laboratory of the Research Councils (CCLRC) at Daresbury in the UK. His earlier career was spent doing basic research in nuclear particle and accelerator physics, reactor instrumentation, and nuclear weapons development. In 1994, whilst working at the Daresbury Laboratory, he was the first to establish non-silicon microfabrication technology in the UK, transferring much of it from Germany. At that time he was appointed to be the UK coordinator of the first European R&D Network in Microtechnology involving nine countries. He established the first industry-led UK network in LIGA technology, known as the LIGA Club, and acquired over £300K of industry funding for prototype microstructure development using deep X-ray lithography. Afterwards, he created the SMIDGEN (Small Microengineering Intelligence Design Generation Exploitation Network), a consortium of companies and universities, to drive the commercial exploitation of microsystems technologies. xi © 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 11
10/23/07 10:21:52 AM
xii
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
Acknowledged by the UK Government’s Foresight Directorate as an example of best practice, it laid the early foundations to the UK MNT Network, part of Government’s £92 million Micro and Nanotechnology Manufacturing Initiative established in 2003. In 2004 David originated a successful proposal to the UK Northwest Development Agency to create a National Microsystems Packaging Centre in the North West of England. Since that time he has been proactive in the exploitation of micronanotechnology, working with Government Departments, Regional Development Agencies, companies, research institutes and universities worldwide. In 2005 he was the co-director of the COMS2005 international conference at Baden-Baden in Germany and a session chair at the COMS2006 conference in St Petersburg, Florida. He was on the Joint Organizing Committee of the COMS2007 conference held in Melbourne, Australia and is currently co-chair of the International HARMST-LIGA Commercialization Group. Mark J. Jackson, Ph.D., M.A., C.Eng., M.Eng. is Professor of Mechanical Engineering at The College of Technology, Purdue University. He began his engineering career in 1983 when he studied for his O.N.C. part I examinations and his first-year apprenticeship-training course in mechanical engineering. After gaining his Ordinary National Diploma in Engineering with distinctions and I.C.I. prize for achievement, he read for a degree in mechanical and manufacturing engineering at Liverpool Polytechnic and spent periods in industry working for I.C.I. Pharmaceuticals, Unilever Industries, and Anglo Blackwells. After graduating with a Master of Engineering (M.Eng.) degree with Distinction under the supervision of Professor Jack Schofield, M.B.E., Dr Jackson subsequently read for a Doctor of Philosophy (Ph.D.) degree at Liverpool in the field of materials engineering focusing primarily on microstructure-property relationships in vitreous-bonded abrasive materials under the supervision of Professor Benjamin Mills. He was subsequently employed by Unicorn Abrasives’ Central Research & Development Laboratory (Saint-Gobain Abrasives’ Group) as materials technologist, then technical manager, responsible for product and new business development in Europe, and university liaison projects concerned with abrasive process development. Mark Jackson then became a research fellow. In 2004 he moved to Purdue University as Associate Professor of Mechanical Engineering in the Department of Mechanical Engineering Technology. Mark is
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 12
10/23/07 10:21:52 AM
Editors
xiii
active in research work concerned with understanding the properties of materials in the field of micro scale metal cutting, micro and nano abrasive machining, and laser micro machining. He is also involved in developing next generation manufacturing processes and biomedical engineering. Mark Jackson has directed, co-directed, and managed research grants funded by the Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council, The Royal Society of London, The Royal Academy of Engineering (London), European Union, Ministry of Defense (London), Atomic Weapons Research Establishment, National Science Foundation, N.A.S.A., U. S. Department of Energy (through Oak Ridge National Laboratory), Y12 National Security Complex at Oak Ridge, Tennessee, and Industrial Companies, which has generated research income in excess of $15 million. Mark has organized many conferences and served as the General Chair of the International Surface Engineering Congress. He has authored and co-authored over 150 publications in archived journals and refereed conference proceedings, has edited a book on ‘microfabrication and nanomanufacturing,’ is guest editor to a number of refereed journals, and has edited a book on ‘surgical tools and medical devices’. He is the editor of the ‘International Journal of Nanomanufacturing,’ ‘International Journal of Molecular Engineering,’ International ‘Journal of Nanoparticles,’ ‘International Journal of Nano and Biomaterials,’ and is on the editorial board of the ‘International Journal of Machining and Machinability of Materials’ and ‘International Journal of Computational Materials Science and Surface Engineering.’
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 13
10/23/07 10:21:53 AM
Contributors Kees Eijkel Kennispark Twente Netherlands
David Tolfree Technopreneur Ltd Denton, Manchester, United Kingdom
Jean-Christophe Eloy Yole Développement Lyon, France
James R. Von Ehr II Zyvex Corporation Richardson, Texas USA
Mark J. Jackson Birk Nanotechnology Centre and College of Technology Purdue University West Lafayette, Indiana USA Bruce A. Kirchhoff Professor of Entrepreneurship School of Management New Jersey Institute of Technology Newark, New Jersey USA Kevin Matthews Oxonica Yarnton, Oxfordshire, United Kingdom Robert Mehalso Microtec Associates Fairport, New York USA Grant M. Robinson Micromachinists LLC Purdue University West Lafayette, Indiana USA
Steven T. Walsh Alfred Black Professor of Entrepreneurship and Co-Director of the Technology Management Center Anderson School of Management University of New Mexico Albuquerque, New Mexico USA Reiner Wechsung microParts GmbH Dortmund, Germany Michael D. Whitfield Micromachinists LLC Purdue University West Lafayette, Indiana USA Arend Zomer Centre for Higher Education Policy Studies University of Twente Netherlands
xv © 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 15
10/23/07 10:21:53 AM
1
The Path to Commercialization David Tolfree and Robert Mehalso
Contents Introduction................................................................................................................. 2 Infrastructure for Commercialization......................................................................... 4 Basic Requirements......................................................................................... 4 Disruptive Technologies..................................................................................4 Government Infrastructure Programs............................................................. 5 Clusters and Supply Chain Networks..............................................................6 Intellectual Property and Patents.................................................................... 7 Summary.........................................................................................................8 Steps to Commercialization........................................................................................ 9 Meeting the Challenge.....................................................................................9 Ideas and Concepts........................................................................................ 10 Design, Modeling, and Simulation................................................................ 10 Integration...................................................................................................... 11 Standardization.............................................................................................. 12 Manufacturing............................................................................................... 13 Prototyping.................................................................................................... 13 Packaging....................................................................................................... 14 Testing and Reliability................................................................................... 15 Final-Product Realization and Marketing..................................................... 15 Examples of Products that have taken the Commercialization Path........................ 17 The Ink-Jet Printer......................................................................................... 17 A Brief History of the Ink-Jet Printer................................................. 17 Nano Coatings on Textiles............................................................................. 18 A Portable Blood Analyzer............................................................................ 19 Practical Experiences in Commercializing Micro/Nano-Based Products...............20 References................................................................................................................. 27
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 1
10/23/07 10:21:53 AM
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
Introduction The ultimate value of any technology to society is its ability to generate useful and marketable products and systems using available practical knowledge and skills. Unlike curiosity-driven scientific research, the purpose of technology is to apply knowledge to facilitate design and manufacture. New products result from years of research and development. Research generates new knowledge and therefore intellectual property (IP). Real wealth derives from the commercialization of that IP. Possession of intellectual property is a necessary beginning of the commercialization process. Creating profit from commercialization is industry’s main interest and purpose. This is not the main purpose or first interest of academia since it derives most of its funding support from government. Universities are, however, under increasing pressure to raise revenue by exploiting their IP. Most have set up commercial offices that operate knowledge and technology transfer schemes to expedite revenue. This difference of purpose identifies the fundamental cultural gap between industry and academia. Most government bodies (national and regional) now recognize this cultural gap and are directing their funding strategies more towards projects that are likely to generate economic value and produce a return on the investment. Research and development programs are more likely to be funded if there is a clear path to commercialization and hence wealth generation. Funding bodies now look for a closer link with industrial priorities than to academic vision. The latter is, and will always remain, the source from which ideas and new initiatives emerge. Miniaturization technologies encompassing micro and nanotechnologies are current leaders in the industrial revolution that is driving the new economy. These technologies have the potential to provide an unlimited range of new products by leveraging skills from across many domains. They can be disruptive and thus create new product-market paradigms. Disruptive technologies lead to innovations that have a discontinuous rather than evolutionary nature.1 These discontinuous innovations can create unique products, processes, and services that provide exponential improvements in value for the customer or end user. But disruptive technologies are unstructured and have uncertain technological outcomes, making commercialization difficult to quantify and justify financially.2 They attract risks that have to be balanced against benefits when planning a development and marketing strategy. Many products have evolved over the last ten years using established manufacturing methodologies developed for the semiconductor industry. These microcomponents and microsystems are embedded in products and systems that are now part of everyday life. Some examples are mobile telephones, laptop computers, digital cameras, ink-jet printers, and a huge range of medical diagnostics. However, new products being produced using nanotechnologies largely depend on an advanced understanding of the behavior of materials and processes at the molecular level, where properties are different from operation at the more familiar macroscopic level. For example, there may be some toxicity issues associated with nanoparticles used in the formulation of a range of chemicals for consumer products, like sunscreens and cosmetics. Here, governments generally agree there is a need for further research
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 2
10/23/07 10:21:53 AM
The Path to Commercialization
Cash-flow Benefits Income
Reduction
Market Launch Time: years
Expenditure
Figure 1.1 Time-to-market reduction.
linked to new materials development to determine whether existing regulations for handling and manufacturing toxic chemicals need to be augmented when particles reach nano-dimensions.3 The inevitable convergence of bio- and nanotechnologies will produce unlimited opportunities for manufacturing new materials and products. In the pharmaceutical and biomedical industries, such products will have to undergo stringent tests and evaluation before they are accepted. This delays production and raises costs. The challenge facing researchers, technologists, and manufacturers is whether the same well-trodden path taken to commercialize macroproducts can be used for products based on a combination of micro- and nanotechnologies. This challenge will be greatest in the life sciences, which include medical diagnostics and surgical techniques. These new devices and techniques will revolutionize medical practices and health care. The challenge for companies is to reduce the time to market for new products as illustrated in Figure 1.1. This is particularly relevant for small companies where cash flow dominates profitability and survival of the business. In this chapter, we set out to describe the steps on the ladder that define the commercialization path for new micro-nanoproducts and systems. The complex, multidisciplinary and potentially disruptive nature of the processes used to manufacture micro-nanoproducts and systems makes advances along the path interactive. This path leads to the market but does not guarantee the product will be globally competitive and create a sustainable business. The issues that need to be addressed and the pitfalls and barriers that need to be overcome to achieve full commercialization of an end product from concept to final market penetration will be described. Some examples of products that have been successfully commercialized will be discussed at the end of this chapter.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 3
10/23/07 10:21:54 AM
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
Infrastructure for Commercialization Basic Requirements The absence of a suitable infrastructure that supports research, product development, and manufacturing of an end product is the main barrier to developing any commercialization strategy. Ideally, an infrastructure must support and incorporate a seamless path from concept to end-product realization for the market. The prerequisite for the government of a nation is to understand that success in the global market will bring economic benefits that surpass its capital investment. The challenge facing both public and private investors is to ensure the quality of the management, particularly relevant to emerging technologies, where there is a greater risk element. Technology alone will not ensure that products can be manufactured in volume, at costs a customer is willing to pay, and then delivered to the customers at the right time. Good management of the technological exploitation process is therefore an essential element for success. It is necessary for a nation to link its world-class research with a supporting exploitation path if it is to succeed in the global economy. Industry can no longer compete by selling products made with standard processes that can be applied anywhere in the world, particularly with countries with low-cost economies. Traditional manufacturing is now moving to Asia where labor costs and hence manufacturing costs are lower, and therefore profitability is higher for those who own the IP. Businesses must constantly innovate to raise the quality of production, introduce new product lines or services, and add greater value to their outputs. Those that embrace the new technologies will survive and prosper. Micro-nanotechnologies (MNTs) are among those enablers that will lead to the evolution of new products and new industries. Some of these will be different because they can have a “disruptive” technology base. That may create problems for those unprepared for the changes that such technologies will bring about. For example, ink-jet revolutionized printing in a very short time, causing difficulties for manufacturers of typewriters and more conventional forms of printing that had been unaware of the technological developments. Even if they had been aware, they did not have the technical knowledge or manufacturing infrastructure to support this new printing technology.
Disruptive Technologies A more detailed text on disruptive technologies can be found in Chapter 2, so here we shall just give a brief summary of what they are, since they influence the type of infrastructure required to enable companies to maximize commercial benefits. Disruptive technologies are those that do not support the existing product manufacturing linkages within the industries that embrace them. Thus, the companies that adopt these technologies must essentially revolutionize their manufacturing practices. This is nearly impossible for small companies as they lack the technology infrastructure or resources to dedicate to this task. It is also difficult for large companies to make changes and divert resources from what may currently be profitable endeavors. The innovation process that results from disruptive technologies is called “discontinuous,” where progress is made not through the conventional incremental,
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 4
10/23/07 10:21:55 AM
The Path to Commercialization Technology Push Basic Research
State of Industrial Manufacturing
Force Fit Prototypes Nonexistent Market Channels (primarily developed for Internal customers)
Bottlenecks Technological Development
Modifications to Existing Processes Initial Market Market Acceptance (one market accepts device technology then industry specific vehicles emerge)
Stable New Technology Robust Infrastructure
Market New Augmentation Markets New markets utilise e.g Inertial sensing existing productdevices for multiple technology, paradigm applications forming product platforms
Market Pull
Figure 1.2 Infrastructure model for discontinuous innovations.
continuous, or generational evolutionary processes, but rather through breakthroughs and significant modifications among a wide array of technologies. For this reason, to succeed with these technologies, governments must create an environment that supports discontinuous innovation. An infrastructure model is shown in Figure 1.2. This often requires investment in cutting-edge research, facilities, and equipment. Many large companies invest in their own research and development because it is critical for them in order to maintain their economic competitiveness. However, smaller enterprises need help. It is here where government investment has a pivotal role to play.
Government Infrastructure Programs A number of government-supported infrastructure programs now exist in many countries in Europe, Asia-Pacific, and in the U.S.A. Details of most of these programs can be found on appropriate Web sites. We shall outline a recent program established in the United Kingdom. After accepting a report by the U.K. Advisory Group on Nanotechnology Applications4 in 2003, the government sanctioned an investment of about £90 million for a micro-nanotechnology infrastructure development program. This leveraged an additional £300 million from development agencies and industry, thus encouraging a wider industrial interest, largely absent before 2003. Funds were provided to enhance some recognized centers of excellence and create new ones and also to support new industry-related projects. A key element of the infrastructural program was the formation of a national MNT network5 to bring together all the centers and the 12 regional development agencies into a working partnership. The object of this was to provide a market-orientated focus for facilities, people, and organizations engaged in MNT in the U.K.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 5
10/23/07 10:21:55 AM
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
Table 1.1 Global Funding for Nanotechnology R&D Programs Total World Funding on R&D Region U.S. European Union (FP6 + NGovs) Asia-Pacific Japan
> $10 Billion in 2005. (since 1997 $18 billion) ~$2.56 billion ($435 million VC funding) ~$2.37 billion ~$4.5 billion ~$2.28 billion
In the continental U.S., a vast infrastructure connects federal government funding programs initiated by DARPA (Defence Advanced Research Agency) or NASA (National Aeronautics and Space Administration) with the private sector. It is worth noting that the semiconductor industry spawned MEMS (microelectromechanical systems) technologies. It started as a segment of the semiconductor industry back in the 1960s, utilizing sensor technologies and later developing its own technology platforms. In the 1980s, MEMS became a fully established nomenclature. In Europe the term “microsystems technology” (MST) was the nomenclature used. MST was based on a wider and more descriptive definition embracing non-electronics components like mechanical, optical, and fluidics systems. Nanotechnology started to be used in nomenclature in the early 1990s. Today the more comprehensive terms “small technologies” or “miniaturized systems” are used. They embrace micro- and nanotechnologies. The interpretation of these technologies underpins the type of commercial infrastructure needed to exploit them. Hence a difference in approach exists between Europe and the U.S. Governments in all the major industrialized countries are now adapting their infrastructures to include R&D support for nanotechnologies. The current level of such support is shown in Table 1.1 above. The U.S. and some European infrastructure strengths are linked to the development of “clusters.” These are geographically close groups of interconnected companies and associated institutions in a particular field, linked by common technologies and skills. Most states have one or more clusters focused on various technology or product areas.
Clusters and Supply Chain Networks Clusters significantly enhance the ability of state and local economies to create wealth and build prosperity because they can act as the incubators of innovation. The primary elements they possess needed to transform ideas into inventions are summarized as follows: • • • •
Universities or research centers that generate new knowledge Companies that transform knowledge into products or new services Suppliers that provide critical components or equipment Marketing and distribution firms to deliver the product to customers
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 6
10/23/07 10:21:55 AM
The Path to Commercialization
Companies in strong industry clusters can innovate more rapidly because they can draw on the local networks that link technology, resources, information, and talent. Successful clusters are usually centered on a world-renowned research university. This model for a cluster has been adapted and used successfully in many regions and countries for progressing commercialization of MNT-based industries, notably in Germany and the U.S. According to Grace,6 on a global scale, more than 100 microsystems companies have been created in clusters. No fewer than 35 MEMS, microsystems, and nano clusters have been formed since the first one was created in Dortmund, Germany, in 1986. Further examples of industry MNT clusters will be given in later chapters of this book. Key elements in building commercialization infrastructures are the establishment of supply chain networks. These provide the support needed to ensure industrial sustainability in particular sectors. It is rare for companies, particularly small ones, to have all or even some of the experience or expertise required to design, develop, manufacture, and market products. An MNT-based industry, like any other, will not mature unless effective supply chains exist. Companies in supply chains do not necessarily have to be located in the same region but can be outside the country or region where the manufacturing is taking place. Where this applies, then, wellstructured communication networks are imperative. Having good Internet or personalized computer-based communications support is essential to any global business development. Supply chains give opportunities for growth to very small companies or start-ups. Being part of a supply chain gives visibility and accessibility to potential customers. It also reduces risk to the company and increases customer confidence. Micro-nanotechnology is already stimulating new business opportunities. Estimating the number of companies that are involved in product development and manufacturing worldwide is difficult. Kaiser7 estimates that currently worldwide there are more than 4000 companies and research institutes involved in nanotechnology, with about 2000 focused on services, 1000 focused on products, and 1000 on research; these contribute to the global network of suppliers. The leading countries are the U.S., Japan, China, and Germany. China is growing fastest with more than 600 nanotechnology companies currently registered. The inclusion of product manufacturers that make use of nanomaterials has increased in applications areas and redefined the classifications used to describe such companies.
Intellectual Property and Patents A MEMS patent review has been given in the latest edition of the Micro and Nano Technology Commercialization Education Foundation (MANCEF) Roadmap.8 Here the authors produce an analysis of patents and patent applications based on data from the U.S. Patent Office. Some of the key issues associated with intellectual property (IP) protection and patents are given below. The creation of intellectual property occurs at universities and research institutes that are generally funded by public monies; acknowledgment usually occurs through patent filings. Due to financial constraints, universities often do not file patents but publish papers instead, thus putting information into the public domain and reducing
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 7
10/23/07 10:21:56 AM
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
the commercial value of the IP. In the U.S., however, there is a 12-month allowance after publishing to file a patent. Publishing by academics often brings earlier awards and is part of their cultural infrastructure. Patenting is a mechanism that allows individuals as well as small and large companies to protect their valuable IP. It is the only form of legal protection for assets from which income or wealth can be derived. A plethora of help exists for those wishing to patent. It is available through government agencies, private companies, and consultants. The process of patenting is expensive and takes a significant portion of budgets, particularly from small companies. Each country has its own system, so multiple patents are needed to protect IP internationally. Patents and agreements made in Europe and the U.S. are not always honored in Asia, so at times other protective measures have to be taken. Patents only deal with processes or products, not with conceptual ideas. They can also include modifications to materials and new design software. Multiple ownership of software can give problems when modifications made by one owner have not been agreed to or registered by the others. Nanotechnology is raising many issues, particularly in the biomedical field in areas like genetic modification and drug development. There are three types of patents: utility, design, and plant. The utility patent covers any new invention or discovery of a useful machine, process, manufacture, or composition of matter. These are recommended for new small companies like startups owing to their extensive coverage of new products. The design patent covers any new or nonfunctional design but not structural features. Plant patents are issued for asexually reproducing plants. The pathway to commercialization does not stop with the patent filing. Generally, patents from a number of sources must be compiled and integrated to build a portfolio to protect the new product or company that may be formed to produce the product. The new product is then developed around the portfolio of patents, and the final product will use the patents as protection to maintain a position in the marketplace. IP can be expensive to protect and can be a deterrent to investors. However, if a technological-based company has no IP, it is unlikely that an investor will invest without some form of asset to protect that investment. Micro-nanotechnology companies benefit from licensing patents if they have an inherent value to the company, since they constitute part of its asset portfolio. Sublicensing to manufacturers is often done to build up specific relationships with them and give protection from competitors.
Summary We can summarize the basic requirements and key elements for a working commercialization infrastructure as follows: • Commercialization strategy with market foresight and awareness • Appropriate level of investment in facilities for research and development • Appropriate level of investment in design and manufacturing facilities (including prototyping and end-product development)
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 8
10/23/07 10:21:56 AM
The Path to Commercialization
• • • • •
Trained personnel in MNT design manufacturing technologies and marketing Knowledge of existing and potential customer base for MNT products Engagement of stakeholders and society interest to allay fears and concerns Suitable environment for collaboration, partnerships and network clusters Appropriate protection for intellectual property
Steps To Commercialization Meeting the Challenge The ten major steps in the ladder to take an idea for a new product to the market are shown in Figure 1.3. Each step can be subdivided into smaller sets of tasks depending on the nature of the product and state of knowledge that exists. It is not a linear path, because of the disruptive nature of the technology and because we live in a world where change, challenge, and risk will always offer barriers to progress. It is not a path for the faint-hearted or for those without determination, knowledge, and experience. Experience shows that unless a suitable infrastructure, as described above, is in place, then it will be difficult, if not impossible, to take the steps on the path to commercialization. If the required infrastructure does not exist, then companies have to seek prototyping or manufacturing facilities outside their immediate location or country, Micro-NanoSystem End Product Realisation concept -design – prototype – End product manufacture-market Markets Final Product Pilot Production Process Steps
Reliability Verification Pre-production Prototype Manufacture Inspection and Testing Integration & Assembly of Micro Components
Microcomponent Fabrication Modeling-simulation Design for Manufacture Concept-idea-foresight
Package Design Interface Electronics
Product Development
Test Support Functions
Figure 1.3 Steps to commercialization.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 9
10/23/07 10:21:57 AM
10
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
which can substantially add to the development and production costs. Large-scale production is another hurdle that needs to be considered early on if the product falls into that category. Increasingly, such production can be done more economically in countries with low labor costs. Such countries do not always have the sufficient knowledge required to meet the stringent demands of manufacturing the product. It is essential to have an understanding of the viability of the market for the final product. With the rapid increase in technological development and the shorter lifetimes of products, the reduction in the time to market has become an important factor.9 Globalization has generated the need for global networks and supply chains. Manufacturing companies need to be part of these if they wish to have access to services and markets that may not be attainable in their own countries at competitive rates. There are many examples of innovative companies in the U.K. that, because of the lack of local facilities, have had to seek such assistance in Asia, the U.S., and Europe to manufacture their products.
Ideas and Concepts Every new product or system, innovation or invention is born from an idea or a concept produced by an individual or a group of individuals. These are sometimes driven by need, sometimes by inspiration, sometimes by a desire to make money — but more often by chance. The latter usually results from an association or interconnection between existing products or systems. There is a large gap between an idea and a proven concept. It may be termed a “chasm of death.” Most ideas do not make it across this gap. Advancing even to a point where an idea is conceptually viable takes both research and focused determination. It follows basically the path of any invention. In the multidisciplinary, multidimensional fields of MNT, specialized technology knowledge is essential. The field is relatively new, so there are unlimited applications and opportunities, but the problem facing the idealist or company who might see such opportunities is that to realize that vision, enthusiasm is not enough. It has to be backed up with knowing the best way to proceed, even to advance to the proof-of-concept stage. Most researchers applying for research grants for development projects are judged on their ability to make reasoned cases for success, usually based on the production of demonstrators to prove that the idea or principles used can actually realize a marketable product. Private investors also require individuals or companies to make convincing arguments or demonstrators to back up their claims. A demonstrator is still a long way from the manufacture of a reliable end product. Our model for successfully producing a product is to be sure that each step along the path shown in Figure 1.1 can be taken. We shall outline what is required to take these steps.
Design, Modeling, and Simulation Once a proof-of-principle has been carried out to test that the science is sound, then a design study is the next step. With miniaturized components, devices, and systems, an integrated approach must be taken. The design must satisfy a number of criteria. The knowledge and tools must be available. Gone are the days of a draftsman’s
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 10
10/23/07 10:21:57 AM
The Path to Commercialization
11
sketch design on a drawing board. Microengineering requires a different skill set and software tools. Computer-aided design (CAD), modeling, and simulation tools are vital for finding the best solution to a product development, particularly when many components have to be integrated on a single microchip or substrate. Computer simulations shorten development cycle times, lower costs, and enhance final product performance. This enables optimization of assembly and component integration, thus reducing the probability of failure at the prototype stage. Sometimes the first prototype can be used as a demonstrator to test out the product specification. Many companies now provide software packages for MEMS-based devices, but gaps exist down at the nanoscale. Some customized software for drawing nanoscale patterns for nanolithography is now available. Good design has to take into account all stages of manufacture and include all aspects of packaging to achieve a successful end product. Commercially available software products available from a variety of companies like ANSYS Inc. and Coventor are written for the microsystems environment. In order to simulate complex 3-D geometries, either the Finite Element Method (FEM) or the Element Boundary Method (EBM) needs to be used. The accuracy of simulation and modeling is dictated by a knowledge of the material properties and its behavior at small scale where large surface-to-volume ratios dominate. At these levels, surface forces such as adhesion, stiction, friction, wear, surface tension, viscosity and electrostatic charge have to be considered. Reliability becomes a major problem because the lack of understanding of how material properties age, or the rate at which they change from the original design point when in different operating environments, is one of the many challenges facing designers. In aerospace, automotive, and medical applications, reliability and longevity are of utmost importance. Here, a zero tolerance to failure is required. As we move into the nanotechnology domain, quantum effects become important. New sets of modeling software and design methodologies are required for atomic and molecular scale processes before any realistic advances can be taken. Although much progress has been made in modeling and simulation, software for use at the micro-nanoscale needs more development for accurate simulation.
Integration The rapid growth of microchip and microsytems technology has led the electronics industry toward integration of more functionality onto a single chip. This decreases costs and gives increased reliability to products since they contain fewer discreet components. A number of review articles in a dedicated edition of the International Newsletter on Micro-Nano Integration (MSTnews)10 outline the importance of the subject to manufacturers. In particular, the European INTEGRAMplus project11 has successfully demonstrated the value of integrating micromechnical and microfluidic systems based on silicon chips. This is predicated on the adoption of a multitechnology and multidomain approach with a focus on integrating silicon-based components with other materials such as polymers as platforms for packaging and interfacing to the macro-world. It also provides a design methodology in the CAD environment for the design of components and associate electronics.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 11
10/23/07 10:21:57 AM
12
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
The systems integration approach is now being adopted by most designers and manufacturers and provides a low-cost option for companies, particularly small- to medium-sized companies that do not have the necessary in-house experience or resources to do it alone. The U.S. National Nanotechnology Initiative (NNI)12 has identified manufacturing technology as one of its “grand challenges,” a key area for investment. It has a target to establish ten R&D integration facilities or centers for nanoscale and microscale testing and manufacturing before the end of 2007. Other countries are pursuing similar initiatives. Micro-nano integration has been slow owing to different levels of maturity on the two technologies. Microsystems technology is more mature and serves many mass markets. In comparison, nanotechnology is still mainly embedded in the research base of many countries. Most of the current work integrates low-dimensional materials in microsystem components. The IBM Millipede Project13 is an example of micro-nano integration. Millipede is an atomic force microscope (AFM)-based data storage concept. Thousands of nano-sharp tips punch indentations representing individual bits into a thin plastic film; a data storage density of a trillion bits per square inch, 20 times higher than the densest magnetic storage currently available, is achievable. It opens up new horizons in high density data storage. Other applications that can be envisioned are in large-area, high-speed imaging and high-throughput nanoscale-lithography as well as atomic and molecular manipulation/modification. Another example of micro-nano integration is the development of single molecule biosensors that have microelectronic interfaces. These are packaged to be available as handheld instruments and give rise to a whole range of portable biomedical devices.
Standardization Industry needs agreement on standards before any new manufacturing methodology can progress. Manufacturing standards are a continuing issue for the MEMS/ MST/NEMS industries, but progress is being made. Unlike the mass production associated with the semiconductor industry, where standards for processing are generally accepted, MEMS and NEMS products do not have the same magnitude of volume production. It is too early for the adoption of standards in nano-manufacturing except in materials production. Additionally, each product is unique, requiring different manufacturing approaches to produce the product. Here health and safety rules will have to be adopted as more manufacturers come into business. The setting of internationally acceptable standards is one of the many challenges to be faced. Setting and agreeing on standards is now a serious issue for manufacturers of products based on the use of micro-nanotechnologies. Nanotechnology poses special problems that relate to whether top-down or bottom-up manufacturing methodologies are required. There are many standard development organizations worldwide. Inside Europe, the Network of Excellence in Multifunctional Microsystems (NEXUS) is a leading body. In America, the Institute of Electrical and Electronic Engineers (IEEE) and the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) and, in Japan, the Micromachine Centre (MMC) are key players. The main international bodies are the
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 12
10/23/07 10:21:57 AM
The Path to Commercialization
13
Semiconductor Equipment and Materials International (SEMI) and the International Organization for Standardisation (ISO). International Organization for Standardization (ISO). The latter facilitates the development and communication of standards for the semiconductor industry. It has been the leading organization in setting standards for MEMS and nanotechnology. In 2005, an agreement was reached between the American IEEE and SEMI to foster MEMS and nanotechnology standards.14-15 This underpins the importance given to the establishment of standards for the new emergent manufacturing industry. In addition to acceptance by the world’s leading countries, the global community must also agree. Each of the organizations above has produced or participated in surveys and reports representing the views of their own members. The European project MEMSTAND16 (standardization for microsystems technology) established a roadmap to forecast the future trends of standardization.
Manufacturing Acronyms: MEMS (Microelectricalmechanical Systems) MST (Microsystems Technology) NEMS (Nano-Electrical-Mechanical-Systems) RF (Radio Frequency) CAD (Computer-Aided Design)
Prototyping There is prototyping, rapid prototyping, and preproduction prototyping. All are essential prerequisites for volume manufacturing. Modeling and simulation tools theoretically can make it possible to take the design directly to the preproduction prototyping stage. In practice, the tools are not mature enough for this to happen. For this, there has to be integration of these tools with the fabrication processes; they need to operate across many technology domains to enable designers to produce systems-based products and services. The manufacturing of micro-nano structured devices raises challenges. Few companies currently have the experience or expertise to carry out prototyping without assistance. Companies often form partnerships or strategic alliances with foundries or specialist providers for this purpose. As more and more companies are realizing the importance of the need for integrated solutions, the need for engineering simulation becomes a major factor to ensure company success. The fundamental physics and engineering that govern the behavior of micronanoproducts differ from their counterparts in the macro world. Conventional scaling down from the macro level to the micro level and beyond usually does not work. Prototyping places demands on design and modeling tools. There is an urgent need for improved tools for specific needs. At the nano level, molecular modeling exists, but for practical purposes of manufacturing, very few useful packages are available. A working knowledge of CAD is essential. The type of simulation software used will depend upon the application and the operational environment. As microsystems increasingly have to work in complex domains, such as RF, optics, and harsh
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 13
10/23/07 10:21:58 AM
14
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
environments, many different software suites may be needed to integrate the application with a specific functionality. These enable the design engineer to predict the behavior of microstructures and microsystems under a multitude of physical effects such as electrostatic loads, stress, heat, and electromagnetism. These CAD products can, as they mature, replace hardware prototyping and enable the testing of designs, thus providing an engineering simulation solution that is fast, efficient, and more cost effective.
Packaging Packaging is fundamental to product functionality and is required to interconnect, protect, and provide an interface to the macroworld to facilitate human interaction. It is the most costly part of the process cycle and can represent up to 80% of the total product development costs. Packaging is central to the design process and must be considered at that stage, often beginning at the wafer level. Critical features include cost, reliability, and accuracy. Most microproduct failures have resulted from designs that have failed when packaging solutions are added late in the product development. The same applies for products that have embedded nanocomponents, nanomaterials, and nanosystems. Packaging design must relate to the operational environment. In sensor and actuator applications, it must protect and interact with the environment. For other applications, it may be isolated as in accelerometers or gyroscopes. For medical in vivo systems, complex packaging is required and can be the most important and most costly part of the device or product. Good interference-free RF or optical connectivity is placing increasing demands on packaging when the device or component has to operate in a harsh chemical or biochemical environment. Packaging also has to be reliable to work in multidomain technologies that include structural, mechanical, electrical, optical, thermal, chemical, and radiation environments. A series of connections and interconnections is required in moving from the nano-size domain to the micro-size domain where humans communicate with products. Whether it is for optics, fluidics, thermal, mechanical, or electronics, combining functions in a micro- or nanosystem complicates the interconnection schemes and will sometimes require a new fabrication and packaging approach. The packaging of MEMS/MST devices and systems ultimately determines their commercial success. Each product has its own specific requirements related to the environment in which it has to operate. MEMS packaging is more challenging than IC packaging due to the diversity of MEMS devices and the requirement that many of these devices be in contact with their environment. MEMS devices are more complex, having 3D geometries, often with moving parts that are vulnerable to dust and moisture, mechanical stress, and vibration; therefore, greater protection is required. Packaging materials are critical to obtaining the correct protection in a particular environment. Sealing and bonding of these materials sometimes require special techniques, particularly for operation at high temperatures. Most companies find that packaging is the single most expensive and timeconsuming part of the manufacturing process. As for the components themselves, numerical modeling and simulation tools for MEMS/NEMS packaging are virtually
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 14
10/23/07 10:21:58 AM
The Path to Commercialization
15
nonexistent. Approaches that allow designers to select from a catalog of existing standardized packages for a new device without compromising performance would be beneficial. This is essential if large-scale manufacturing is to develop across the wide product domains.
Testing and Reliability Long-term reliability is essential for all miniaturized components if they are to be incorporated or embedded into products. Failure usually means replacement of the whole product. Production and assembly methods for integrated circuits and MEMS systems make replacement of individual components or maintenance schemes too costly. No product will retain its market credibility without total product reliability assurance. Design for reliability must understand, identify, and prevent failures before the manufacturing stage is reached. All possible failure modes in different environments must be vigorously tested to ensure that failure model predictions are verified. Lack of knowledge between material properties and process parameters could lead to failure after manufacture, resulting in expensive recall for the product and loss of manufacturer and market credibility. Some industries are more sensitive to this than others, notably the automotive and aerospace industries, which are among the large-scale volume manufacturers. PATENT-DfMM17 (The European Network of Excellence) provides European industry with support for integration and reliability issues. This ensures that problems affecting the manufacturing and reliability of micro-nano products can be addressed before prototyping and manufacture starts. Members of this network engage with the European Aerospace community to support manufacturers. Failure modes need to be programmed into the test procedure. Procedures will vary for different types of devices.
Final-Product Realization and Marketing The reader is referred to Chapter 6 on “Market Analysis and Markets” in this book, but we will outline here some of the fundamental issues because they constitute the most important step that needs to be considered on the path to commercialization. Fundamentally, buyers or customers probably do not care how the product was made or have any interest in the technology used to produce it. Their interest in the product is based on its performance and cost advantage. Therefore, normal marketing practices are the same as for any other product. Companies are cautious about this because of any adverse publicity that may have resulted from other products using the same technology where problems have arisen. This is particularly the case for nanotechnology. For example, new sunscreen product manufacturers often refer only to the advantages not the technology that gave the advantages. The problems experienced by Monsanto over genetically modified plants are often related to nanotechnology. Initially this deters manufacturers of food or healthcare products from using the term. Success in achieving a marketable final product means the journey is nearly over, but the final destination of penetration into a competitive market is still to be reached. In a changing global market where market forces operate and demand can fluctuate, the ogre of risk lurks. There are no certainties, and success or failure
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 15
10/23/07 10:21:58 AM
16
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
hangs on the marketing skills of the company and its agents. Prior to reaching the end-product stage, the diligent company would have already put in place a marketing strategy based on all available market intelligence. This will take into account the sales impact that the new product will have on the competition, if any exists. Companies often do not pay enough attention to product promotion and publicity, although it should be inherent in their marketing strategies. This can result in a lack of awareness of the prospective buyer, thus delaying early sales. Increasingly, buyers scan the Internet for new products or updates of existing products. This is now an attractive and cost-effective medium for promotion since changes and updates can readily be made, particularly for high-tech products. But expectation and demand must be met; otherwise credibility is quickly lost. This can be a major problem with high-volume Internet-based sales when demand can exceed availability. Some examples of new products now on the market are listed below. These were taken from the Forbes.com website.18 • • • • • • •
Apple IPod with sub 100 nm elements in its memory chips Choleterol-reducing nanoencapsulated oil, Shemen Industries Canola Active Nanocrystals that improve the consistency of chocolate Zelen Fullerene C-60 Day Cream Easton Stealth CNT baseball bat Nanotex textiles ArcticShield polyester socks from ARC Outdoors with 19 nm silver particles that kill fungus to reduce odor • NanoGuard developed by Behr Process for improved paint hardness • Pilkington’s self-cleaning Activ Glass • NanoBreeze Air Purifier from NanoTwin Technologies, where the UV light from a fluorescent tube cleans the air by photochemical reactions with nanoparticles Between 2006 and 2008, the following key products will be available on the market: • Intel products with 45 nm linewidth transistors (available from 2008)19 • Batteries that are increasingly incorporating nanostructures • Flexible, cheaper, or more luminous flat-screen displays In addition to the products listed above and many others that are likely to be available in the coming years, we will outline below three product areas that are having a profound impact on society: ink-jet printers, coated textiles (clothing), and portable blood analyzers.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 16
10/23/07 10:21:59 AM
FIgurE . I-stat blood analyzer and cartridge.
IXH O FH OOV 5) 0(06
0LFURIOXLGLFV 02(06 LQFO '0' *\URVFRSH V
0DUNHW LQ 0
$FFH OH URP H WH UV 6LOLFRQ 0LFURSKRQH V 3UH VVXUH VH QVRUV ,QNMH W +H D G
FIgurE . Value of the MEMS markets.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
FIgurE . Airbag module (Bosch) source.
FIgurE . Gyro sensor (Bosch source). © 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
FIgurE . Zyvex nProber with positioners aligned 250 microns apart from each other, just a few millimeters above the center stage.
FIgurE . This Easton road bike, created using Zyvex’s NanoSolve materials, was given to President George W. Bush in June 2006.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
FIgurE . Four NanoEffector® Probes in a Zyvex nanomanipulator.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
FIgurE . Schematic diagram Respimat brochure.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
FIgurE . (d) Robotic system for mounting and assembling Respimat.
FIgurE . Respimat production line.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
The Path to Commercialization
17
Figure 1.4 Ink-jet printers.
Examples of Products that have taken the Commercialization Path The Ink-Jet Printer A Brief History of the Ink-Jet Printer Some of the following information has been obtained from the Castleink website.20 The four companies that are market leaders in the supply of ink-jet printers are Hewlett Packard, Epson, Canon, Brother, and Lexmark (see Figure 1.4). In the mid-1970s, printer companies realized the potential of ink-jet technology that would make dot matrix printers obsolete. The challenge, however, was to develop a way to create an affordable ink-jet printer that would reliably create high-quality prints and work with desktop computers. It was the need for a portable, easy-to-use printer to use with desktop and laptop computers that produced the customer demand. The quality of the printed page depends largely on the relationship between the ink, the print head, and the paper. Researchers had to find a way of creating a controlled flow of ink from the print head onto the page and preventing the print head from becoming clogged with dried ink. In 1976, the ink-jet printer was invented, but it took until 1988 for it to become a home consumer item with Hewlett-Packard’s release of the DeskJet. Liquid ink-jet printers generally fall into one of two classes — continuous and drop-on-demand. In a continuous ink-jet printer, a continuous spray of ink droplets is produced, and the unneeded droplets are deflected before they reach the paper and recirculated for reuse. This technique permits very high-speed drop generation, one million drops per second or faster, but is expensive to manufacture. The drop-on-demand ink-jet printers produce ink droplets only when needed. The two most common technologies to drive the droplets out of the print head are thermal (used by Hewlett Packard, Lexmark, Canon, Olivetti, and others) and the piezo-electric effect (used by Epson). The thermal technique has been by far the most successful because printers can be produced inexpensively.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 17
10/23/07 10:21:59 AM
18
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
The biggest challenge for piezo-electric ink-jet technology is the cost and difficulty of producing print heads. Today Epson has a very successful line of piezoelectric color printers, namely the Stylus color and Stylus photo family of printers, offering photographic quality.
Nano Coatings on Textiles Numerous fabrics based on nanocoated fibers are now becoming available on the market. Based on the lotus-leaf principle, whose fine surface structure makes it impossible for water molecules to stick to its surface, nanoparticles dispersed in a solvent can be coated onto fabrics. During volatilization, the nanoparticles independently start to affix themselves to the substrate surface, align themselves, and eventually form a network-like structure. This self-structuring process works downwards, sideways, and upwards, resulting in a three-dimensionally linked network. The U.S. company Nano-Tex LLC has developed and licensed a range of fabrics under the labels Nano-Care,® Nano-Dry,® Nano-Pel,™ and Nano-Touch.™ The fibers of these fabrics have been enhanced to make them behave like the lotus leaf with stain-resistant properties but with their initial material properties remaining unchanged, i.e., they are machine washable and can be tumbled dried; and they feel, look, and possess breathability qualities like the original fabric, so they remain totally unaffected by the treatment. In the nano-enhanced clothing, the fibers have tiny whiskers aligned by spines to repel liquids, reduce static, and resist stains. The properties can be summarized as follows: • Water droplets simply pearl off the fabric • Dirt, grease, and oil spots can be easily removed using a little water • The impregnation is very durable and remains virtually unaffected by wear and tear or washing • The impregnation can be reactivated at any time by the application of heat (e.g., from a dryer or iron) The treatment keeps wearers dry and comfortable by taking moisture away from the body at least ten times faster than most resin-treated cotton fabrics available today. A report published in Innovative Products Based on High-Tech Textiles21 states that “the future of the textile and clothing sector lies not in price reduction but in more intelligent products with additional functionality.” It classified intelligent clothing into five major areas: transfer systems; adaptive systems; smart clothing; transponder systems; and microtechnology and nanotechnology. The textile industry is vital to health and competitiveness of many countries’ economies. Many U.S. and European companies outsource manufacturing to Asia, but they retain much of the IP. Nanotechnology offers solutions for keeping the textile industry competitive through the use of nanotechnology. The wider availability of Nano-Tex stain-resistant clothing and fabrics is starting to revolutionize the textile industry. Europe (EU) has identified the use of nanotechnology as the key to the future competitiveness of its textile industry.22
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 18
10/23/07 10:21:59 AM
The Path to Commercialization
19
Figure 1.5 Nano-Tex shirt showing coffee stain removed.
Nano-Tex shirts are some of the early products that are finding their place in retail outlets. The authors possess products like the ones shown and can verify that they repel most materials that stain, such as red wine, coffee, blackberry jam, tomato ketchup, and mustard (see Figure 1.5).
A Portable Blood Analyzer The i-STAT Corporation’s handheld blood analyzer system, the i-STAT System23 (see Figure 1.6), has the potential to revolutionize the way healthcare is administered. It developed a low-cost blood analysis instrument that fits in the palm of the hand. The device is used with one of many different test cartridges to produce accurate results from just a few drops of blood in about 2 min. The tests include electrolytes, blood gases, immunoassays, and coagulation measurements. The instrument is completely
Figure 1.6 (See.color.insert.following.page.16.).I-stat.blood.analyzer.and.cartridge.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 19
10/23/07 10:22:00 AM
20
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
automated and requires no medical specialist to operate it. Each cartridge is capable of performing up to eight tests. The portable blood analysis system eliminates the traditional process of sending a blood sample to a central laboratory for analysis then waiting for some time before the results come back to the patient. Adopting this device means major changes to the way hospitals do blood tests. This initially did raise, and still does, problems of acceptance by the professionals, as it is seen as an example of a disruptive technology that threatens jobs and traditional practices. This is a common problem with new medicine and healthcare diagnostics when the limitations are not due to the technology or public acceptance but to hospital laboratory management adapting to change. Over the last 5 years, the acceptance problem has been largely overcome, and iSTAT has doubled its revenues. It hopes to increase its growth rate significantly over the coming years. Currently 15 million cartridges are being manufactured each year, but the company has the capacity to produce 40 or 50 million units.
Practical Experiences in Commercializing Micro/Nano-Based Products The methodology of commercializing products has remained fundamentally unchanged since the first Industrial Revolution. Design, prototyping, piloting, and production processes have become more efficient through new techniques such as lean manufacturing, as well as computerization and automation. However, most of this knowledge and commercialization infrastructure is optimized for products at the macroscale, not the micro- and nanoscale. In practice, every step in the commercialization pathway for micro- and nanobased products requires significant new knowledge and new approaches. In this section, the commercialization pathway will be viewed from the perspectives of conceptualizing, designing, prototyping, piloting, and manufacturing micro- and nanosystem-based products in 15 different companies, all of which had manufactured products as a basis for their business model. These companies were focused on automotive, aerospace, medical, military, telecommunications, or consumer markets. Each company faced challenges at every step on the commercialization pathway when trying to adapt an infrastructure based on commercializing macro-based products to build a micro- or nano-based product. Many micro- and nano-based products travel the commercialization pathway toward the marketplace, but few are able to overcome the challenges. Actual company names have not been used to preserve confidentiality. As with most new technologies, micro- and nanotechnology-based product concepts are primarily developed in research environments at universities and research institutions. Fundamental intellectual property is developed from that beginning. Because micro- and nanotechnology are in their infancy, most original patents are still in effect and must be licensed for product companies to have freedom to operate. This creates a significant burden, particularly for start-up companies that must negotiate numerous licenses to insure freedom to operate and produce a product. It is difficult for a start-up company to know what intellectual property it may need when the product has not yet been designed. From our sample of start-up companies, each
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 20
10/23/07 10:22:00 AM
The Path to Commercialization
21
had to license intellectual property from more than one source. This is understandable since most research in micro- and nanotechnology areas is funded by governments. Many funded programs focus on similar areas at different universities and in various countries. Principal university investigators collaborate with one another on a global basis and move from university to university. This results in a dispersion of intellectual property that is difficult to aggregate to form the basis for a company. In one example, at a major United States university, more than 25 microtechnology-based patents were accumulated in the university portfolio. When the patents were analyzed for commercial opportunity, there was not enough intellectual property for a start-up company to have freedom to operate. However, after extensive searches to explore the aggregation of patents from other universities, three companies were formed. Standing alone, none of the universities had hope for a return on their research investment when considering their individual patent portfolios. However, the aggregation of patents resulted in all institutions having a return on their investment. Many of the micro- and nano-based start-up companies considered here did very little intellectual property analysis — some did none at all, even with significant committed venture funding. When considering a start-up company or a product in the micro/nanotechnology space, it is important to do an extensive intellectual property analysis in the specific area to determine the landscape of the intellectual property. As the design matures, the intellectual property landscape should be constantly reviewed to ensure that paths are taken that allow freedom to operate and to generate new intellectual property. As the product concept is developed and as design begins, significant challenges arise when attempting to use conventional macro-based product design methodologies. One of the first challenges is human resource related — the availability of engineers who think and design at the micro- and nanoscales. Challenges begin with universities where researchers and scientists are educated in micro- and nanoscale domains, each in a very specific area. However, researchers and scientists are not product design engineers. In developing a product concept, researchers and scientists address only about 10% of the total pathway to commercialization. Product design engineers provide a unique capability to successfully move along that pathway to commercializing a product. They start where the scientist leaves off and take the concept all the way to the finished product. For the most part, universities teach design at the macroscale, with little if any education at the micro- and nanoscale. The typical design engineer develops a specification for a product, deriving its expected performance, shape and size constraints, electrical requirements, etc. A design engineer in the conventional macroworld uses known standards and metrics for piece parts and processes. He would use supplier catalogs to find components that meet the product requirements. If he needed to fabricate parts, he would use readily available materials with properties that are understood. He would use manufacturing processes that are standardized and well understood, such as machining and injection molding. If the engineer needed a piece of equipment for manufacture or assembly, he would select a supplier who manufactured the equipment as a standard catalog item. It would be delivered to the expected specification and perform in an expected manner. The design engineer would not risk selecting components or equipment that were unproven.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 21
10/23/07 10:22:01 AM
22
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
At one company that had especially elegant micro/nano product designs, the design engineer was asked how he developed such elegant designs. He responded, “I go into a trance and shrink myself down (as he contorted himself in his chair and began to slide under the table) and put myself inside the device I am working on. I visualize the inside connections and interfaces and design the device from the inside to the outside.” How does one transfer this capability to a university professor teaching design engineering, who most likely has never commercialized a macroproduct and probably has no idea about micro and Nan design? Companies that are successful in designing micro- and nano-based products do not rely on the experienced macrodesigners. They bring baggage from the macroworld that does not lend itself to success in designing micro- and nano-based products. The successful companies hire recent college graduates who are open-minded, very bright, creative mechanical engineers who are not indoctrinated in traditional methods. These engineers have no preconceived ideas of what the limits are. Understanding materials is also important. The industrial designer (even one experienced at the macroscale) who is creative, excellent at visualization, and more of an artist than an engineer can also be very successful at micro- and nanoproduct design. In micro- and nano-commercialization, there are few simulation and design tools and standard manufacturing processes, as well as a lack of metrics, standards, and specifications. There is no repository of knowledge for the design engineer to reference. A great deal of knowledge has been generated by companies that have commercialized, or attempted to commercialize, micro- and nano-based products. Since that knowledge was generated in an industrial environment, most of it has not been published or disseminated to the public. At one company, nearly $50 million was spent developing interfaces, packaging, and manufacturing and assembly processes to produce an ink-jet print head. The processes developed could be applied to other microfluidic products; however, they were never published and only disseminated as those who were involved moved into new jobs at other companies and shared their knowledge. Progress has been made in simulation and modelling software at the microscale, but there are significant challenges at the nanoscale. For example, modeling of injection molding processes at the microscale with nano-tolerances is not possible. One company making a microfluidic medical diagnostic device had to resort to trial and error to mold a precision part to nano-tolerances. In developing the tooling to produce the part to specification, 55 modifications were made to the mold, requiring a significant amount of time and money. For silicon-based MEMS devices, reasonable simulation and modelling software exists to support commercialization. The same is true for microfluidics. The difficulty in modelling and simulation comes at the interfaces and connections between the micro- or nanoscale and the human interface at the macroscale where the products are used. As design progresses, the engineer has to consider how he will build the device to make the first prototype. Engineers, particularly those with experience in macroengineering, would design the prototype to be made in a model or machine shop using traditional machining and forming equipment. This approach will surely result in failure of the product to be optimized. It will not meet performance, size, functionality, and cost requirements, if it functions at all.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 22
10/23/07 10:22:01 AM
The Path to Commercialization
23
A company building an imaging device that was embedded into its customer’s imaging product exemplifies the importance of starting out on the right footing to build the first prototype. Because of time and cost considerations, the company decided to build the prototype using conventional macro approaches. The imager was far larger than originally envisioned, its performance was lower than expected, and the cost was significantly higher. The customer was no longer interested in embedding the imager into the product; the cost to redesign it to accept the imager was no longer justifiable considering the now fewer advantages. The imaging device company could not change its design to reflect the advantages of microtechnology because it had built an infrastructure of people and equipment from the macroculture. This company is no longer in business. The micro/nano product design engineer must work closely with process, equipment, manufacturing, assembly, and facilities engineers. This team approach is necessary to design an optimized product. There is a lack of standard, off-the-shelf fabrication and measurement equipment, parts, connections, packaging, processes, and micro-assemblies. Therefore, product design, process development, manufacturing, assembly, and unique facility requirements must be considered together when designing micro-nanoproducts. All of the companies that produced a successful product had to practice the integrated team approach, mainly to develop processes and equipment for manufacturing, assembly, and measurement. One example was a company developing a page-width (300 mm), ink-jet print head for precision, high-speed printing. At that time, the semiconductor industry had developed processes and equipment for 200 mm wafers. To achieve precision and diameter in the ink-jet nozzle position, submicron lithography was necessary. However, at the time, no equipment existed that could handle parts that were 300 mm in length, and no equipment existed that was able to handle geometries different from a silicon wafer. In addition to designing lithography equipment (which included designing unique energy sources), a totally new process and new equipment were needed to coat a resist to the thickness specification. No measurement equipment existed for submicron measurements over a length of 300 mm. This equipment had to be designed and built. The process to fabricate the ink-jet nozzle structure consisted of 54 variables that had to be precisely controlled. The world’s top statisticians said it was not possible to control the process and produce a consistent product. Dr. Taguchi became involved, applied the Taguchi Method for Robust Design (a revolutionary approach at the time), and within 30 days a predictable, consistent, and repeatable product was delivered. In another example at a different company producing a thermal ink-jet print head with a silicon print element, similar experiences with a team approach were necessary. The print element was made by bonding two silicon wafers together — one a fluidic structure for delivering the ink and the other the substrate for the drive electronics and heating element. After bonding (equipment, process, and adhesive for bonding had to be developed), the wafer stack was diced to separate the print elements. Dicing through the wafers to expose the nozzles had to produce a mirror finish with no chipped edges, as illustrated in Figure 1.7. A chip on the nozzle edge would change the surface energy condition, causing the ink-jet drop to stray off course. This would reduce the sharpness of the printed image.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
24
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
Silicon Wafer Microfluidic Nozzle Structure
Heater and Electronics Layer
Silicon Wafer Electronics
FIGURE 1.7 Microfluidic nozzle on silicon wafer.
Each year, millions of wafers are diced for the electronics industry by specialty dicing suppliers in the Far East. There were many suppliers who claimed they could meet the dicing requirements for the ink-jet nozzles. Even when they tried to improve their processes, they could not come close to meeting the quality requirements necessary for dicing ink-jet nozzle structures. Because the ink-jet print head performance was dependent upon a chip-free nozzle edge, the company undertook developing the dicing process. A high-performance dicing saw was purchased and modified by dynamic balancing and precision temperature control of the cutting fluid, as well as other modifications. This achieved a significant improvement — but it was not good enough. Then dicing blade performance was investigated with suppliers who thought their experience and expertise produced the best blade possible — but it was not good enough. The company undertook a development effort to select the appropriate material and develop a dicing blade to meet the ink-jet requirements. When the dicing blade was developed, the process was offered to dicing blade suppliers to produce dicing blades to meet ink-jet requirements. None of the suppliers were able to expand their vision and change their manufacturing processes to make blades to address new markets. It was necessary for the company to build a dicing blade manufacturing operation to meet its quality needs. The new dicing process was able to produce a high-quality mirror finish, with no chips at the nozzle edges. This dicing process was accomplished at speeds considerably faster than the speeds at traditional suppliers and was achieved with a much higher quality output. With nearly every micro-nanosystem product, suppliers who were considered to be top quality could not meet the requirements of micro- and nano-based products. They were boxed in by their past and believed, from their experience and years of process improvements, that their processes were optimized to be as good as they could be. A new view from outside the box (a disruptive approach) can produce significant improvement to meet the unique requirements of micro- and nanosystems and is generally necessary for successful product commercialization.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
The Path to Commercialization
25
Companies that were successful in high-volume manufacturing of micro- and nano-based products integrated fabrication and assembly under one roof. Micronanoproducts require environmentally controlled conditions, are sensitive to rough handling, and generally require additive processing of one process step onto another. Success generally requires an integrated approach. For example, a coating on a substrate, followed by a screen-printed layer, followed by an adhesive layer, etc., is an integrated approach as compared to the conventional macro-approach of piece parts that arrive at the assembly line individually and are then assembled. The conventional wisdom of a supply-chain approach is not effective in the manufacture and assembly of micro- and nano-based products. One company used the conventional supply-chain approach to attempt to build an ink-jet print head. Because of the nature of additive processes, the print head traveled more than 1000 miles from supplier to supplier for the fabrication steps to occur. Packaging and shipping costs were high. Cleanliness requirements were impossible to maintain. When the print head did not function, it was difficult to find the cause of the problem. This type of supply chain approach is akin to each process step in a CMOS (complimentary metal oxide semiconductors) semiconductor fab being performed at a different fab in a different location. The company ultimately integrated manufacturing under one roof. This resulted in significant quality and yield improvement and a large cost reduction. Most importantly, manufacturing issues were observed and addressed quickly, and the product was a market success. Figures 1.8a and 1.8b illustrate the traditional and the integrated approach to manufacturing. The supply-chain approach cannot be successfully applied to micro/nano-based products if the full performance, size, and cost advantages of these products are to
FIGURE 1.8A Traditional manufacturing equipment. Layout considering a piece-part philosophy.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
26
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
FIGURE 1.8B Integrated, automated manufacturing layout of equipment for each step in a process to build and/or assemble a complete ink-jet print head.
be realized. The integrated approach was used in all of the companies that successfully commercialized a high-volume micro/nanoproduct. For low-volume products, the cost for equipment and facilities may not warrant the integrated approach. However, performance, size, and cost of these products will not be optimized. Customers may also have great difficulty moving out of their paradigm to envision new market opportunities with micro- and nano-based products. They often have trouble communicating in the language of micro- and nanotechnology. Lack of understanding makes customers reluctant to accept these new technologies as part of their product offering because they are steeped in traditional engineering and manufacturing methodologies. A nano-based process was developed to make fuel injection nozzle structures for a large automotive company. The vice president of manufacturing, with decades of traditional manufacturing experience, became increasingly frustrated even as the program exceeded performance and cost expectations. He retired, abruptly, because he had no frame of reference at the nanoscale. He could not make decisions on something he could not see. At the same company, internal political and organizational issues began to surface. After millions of fuel injection structures had been delivered defect free, one of the most powerful groups responsible for the product delivery process, the Quality Department, began to feel threatened. As it became evident that this group was no longer influential and jobs would be eliminated, roadblocks were put in place attempting to limit the program’s effectiveness. When jobs are threatened, defence mechanisms are often put in place by both engineers and managers. Successfully selling a micro/nano-based development or product program to a traditional customer is a significant challenge. In working with customers,
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
The Path to Commercialization
27
particularly those with traditional products and infrastructures, one must be sure that senior management supports micro/nanotechnology-based products. Generally, senior management is very interested in high-performance products at a lower cost. This is not necessarily true for all those in the organization below the senior management level, where significant change in infrastructure may have to occur to deliver disruptive new products. To ensure that customer requirements are understood, it is necessary to find a champion below the senior management level. This person should know the company’s product infrastructure and organization structure. He should be a maverick who does not play by the corporation’s book of rules and is not afraid to bypass all intermediate management and go directly to senior management to get roadblocks quickly removed. Each organization has a few of these types; they are the “change makers” that force a company to consider new products. These general comments and specific examples and recommendations are the summation of experience from companies that were commercializing micro-nanointegrated products. Those products include a variety of ink-jet print heads, optical switching devices, medical laparoscopes and endoscopes, implantable medical sensors, medical diagnostic point-of-use microfluidic sensors, automotive fuel injection systems, infrared imagers, vehicle stability management control systems, and energy power devices. As time moves on, universities continue to provide excellent research and intellectual property for future micro- and nano-based products. Education for design engineers continues to be lacking. Simulation and modelling software continues to evolve, particularly for microsystems and microfluidic systems. Some dedicated equipment is available for micro- and nanofabrication with continued evolution. Building prototype, pilot, and production quantities continues to be very difficult. The micro-nano model shop or machine shop does not exist. Germany, specifically the Dortmund Cluster, which includes the Microfactory concept, is building a micro-nano commercialization infrastructure. In Melbourne, Australia, MiniFab is beginning to evolve to provide a commercialization infrastructure. However, in general, governments are lacking vision by not investing in and developing a commercialization infrastructure, thus not taking advantage of what will be considered the greatest economic development opportunity in history.
REFERENCES 1. Walsh, S. and Suleiman, M; Models for the commercialisation of disruptive technologies, International Journal of Technology Transfer and Commercialisation, 3, 187– 198, 2004. 2. Walsh, S, MANCEF Roadmap, Sept. 2002. ISBN:0–9727333–0–2 3. Royal Society Policy Document, Nanoscience and nanotechnologies:opportunities and uncertainties, July 2004, ISBN 0-85403-604-0. 5. The U.K. MNT Network, http://www.mntnetwork.com/. 4. Taylor, J.M., Report New Dimensions for Manufacturing — A UK Strategy for Nanotechnology; DTI pub 6182, June 2002. 6. Grace, R., Technology cluster development: the MEMS industry report card 2006, Small Times, January 2007.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
28
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
7. Kaiser, H., Report: Summary about the State of Nanotechnology Industry Worldwide 2003–2015, www.hkc.com/nanomarkets, 2006. 8. The MANCEF Roadmap (2nd edition) ISBN: 0–9727333–0–2; Chapter 4, 2004. 9. Tolfree, D. and Eijkel, K., Reducing time-to-market for nicrotechnology produced products, presented at the World-Nano-Economic Congress — Europe, London, 6 November 2003. Talk only reference on www.world-nano.com/WNEL-London. 10. Micro-Nan Integration; MST News, No. 4, August 2006. 11. Richardson, A. and Pickering, C., The INTERGRAMplus Access Service, MST News, No. 4, August 2006. 12. The U.S. National Nanotechnology Initiative, http://www.nano.gov. 13. Eleftheriou et al., Millipede – a MEMS-based scanning-probe data-storage system, IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, 39, 928, 2003. 14. SEMI Standards, www.semi.org/standards, 2004. 15. IEEE Standards, www.ieee.org/standards, 2004. 16. Standardization of microsystems technology — European Commission Project July 2002. 17. Richardson, A., Design for Micro-Nano Manufacture, PATENT-(DfMM), 2003, www. patent-dfmm.org. 18. http://www.forbes.com in 2005. 19. http://www.castleink.com/a-inkjet-printer-history. 20. NewScientist.com, news service, 27 January 2007. 21. Innovative Products Based on High-Tech Textiles, 57, 2004.
22. EuroFutureTex Conference. November 8–9, 2005, Padua, Italy. 23. http://www.abbottpointofcare.com/istat/products/analzsers.htm.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
10
Shaping the Future David Tolfree
Contents Introduction............................................................................................................. 229 From the Past to the Future......................................................................... 229 The Future of Health and Medicine....................................................................... 232 Nanomedicine.............................................................................................. 233 Current Developments................................................................................. 234 Future Developments................................................................................... 235 Stem Cells for the Future14.......................................................................... 236 Materials — Products — Applications................................................................... 236 Nanoparticles, Nanomaterials, and Nanomanufacturing............................ 236 Carbon Nanotube Composites..................................................................... 238 Microchips and Nanoelectronics................................................................. 239 Biochips.......................................................................................................240 Supplier Companies.....................................................................................240 Existing MNT Products and Components.............................................................. 241 Emerging New Products and Systems.................................................................... 242 Nano Food Products.................................................................................... 243 Smart Packaging for Food...........................................................................244 Fuel and Transportation Systems................................................................ 245 Detection and Analysis................................................................................246 2030 and Beyond.................................................................................................... 247 References............................................................................................................... 251
Introduction From the Past to the Future The nineteenth century heralded the first industrial revolution based on steam power. It created a manufacturing industry that provided new wealth and social change. The twentieth century was the age of scientific discovery: electrical power replaced steam; and new disciplines such as electronic engineering, nuclear physics, genomics, and computer technology were born. The atom was split, nuclear power became a reality, transistors and microchips were developed, computers were built, and the DNA molecule was decoded, leading to the map of the human genome. Governments 229 © 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 229
10/23/07 10:23:43 AM
230
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
funded research, and the stock of human knowledge rapidly exceeded the ability to exploit it. At the dawn of the twenty-first century, the World Wide Web (the Internet) came into common use for the communication and exchange of information. The twenty-first century is the age of knowledge and communication; intellectual capital is its currency. Now in the first decade of the new century, we look out onto an ocean of unparalleled opportunities when, for the first time, we can begin to see how to manipulate matter at the molecular level. The capability of manipulating atoms and molecules was first hypothesized by Richard Feynman and others in the late 1950s. In his lecture to the American Physical Society, “There’s Plenty of Room at the Bottom,”1 in 1959, American Nobelist Richard P. Feynman presented his audience with a vision of what could be done with extreme miniaturization. He proved simply that the entire 24 volumes of the Encyclopædia Britannica could be written digitally on the head of a pin. That well-quoted statement started people thinking about how nanoscale science could become nanotechnology. In his books Engines of Creation,2 first published in 1986, and Nanosystems: Molecular Machinery, Manufacturing, and Computation,3 published in 1992, Eric Drexler examined the enormous implications of developments in nanotechnology for medicine, the economy, and the environment and made astounding yet well-founded projections for the future. We are now able to understand the possible realities of those predictions. Zyvex, one of the first U.S. nanomanufacturing companies (see Chapter 8), has developed Atomically Precise Manufacturing (APM) to make the tools to manufacture objects — potentially very large objects — with atomic precision. Using chemistry and advanced engineering, this technique will enable advanced materials with unique properties to be made and used in the manufacture of many new products. For example, low-cost, lightweight golf clubs, baseball bats, and tennis rackets have been manufactured with increased strength using carbon nanotubes. The next leap forward may not be from scientific or technological breakthroughs but from unifying science and the convergence of technologies. Success in achieving this will initiate a new renaissance in manufacturing. This has already started with many new products becoming available in sectors such as communications, textiles, and medicine. The establishment of high bandwidth carrier technology means that voice, data, picture, and other interactive multimedia can be transported together over fiber-optic cables or satellites. This is an example of an innovation that has advanced communications technology. The satellite helps facilitate communication irrespective of geographic location. Any person can communicate with anyone at any time, anywhere on earth, if the right equipment is available. The economic and social power of mobile telephones and personal handheld computers is already having an impact on the way people live and work. Converging information technologies with computer technologies, the Internet being an example, has already brought benefits that were not conceived of two decades ago. Communication media are combined into one service and available on a computer screen. At the touch of a key, people and companies can trade goods and services. It brings buyers and sellers together, allowing the rapid transfer of information and finance. This can be carried out at any time and at any place convenient to
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 230
10/23/07 10:23:44 AM
Shaping the Future
231
the user. Google, the most used software search engine, is replacing reference libraries to give users almost instant access to unlimited information. The convergence of nanoscience and nanotechnology; biotechnology, biomedicine, and genetics; information technology, computing, and communications; and cognitive science and neuroscience will facilitate advances in science and technology, improve human abilities, and enhance human performance. The synergistic combination of these sciences and technologies is referred to as NBIC.4 Geographic boundaries are no longer barriers to communication. Nations are coming together into regional groups, creating the “global village” concept. The technological and economic developments that took place in the latter part of the twentieth century and led to the concept of the global economy are now a reality. This will inevitably lead toward a globalized society and eventually political convergence. If this can be achieved, then most of the world’s current problems would be solvable. The future destiny of nations, governments, companies, and individuals is inextricably linked to decisions made today. Such decisions have to be based on available information and a reliable prediction of the future. An accurate prediction of the future enables governments to produce economic strategies and policies, companies to make meaningful business plans, and individuals to plan their lives. Sometimes roadmaps or foresight documents are available to forecast trends in technological development, economic progress, and market intelligence. Predictions based on extrapolation from current trends can be made with a high degree of accuracy, but the rapid pace of innovation makes long-term forecasting beyond 25 years much more difficult. As can be seen from the earlier chapters in this book, disruptive technologies can produce discontinuous innovations that lead to unexpected changes and new areas of development. Any futurist must consider such possibilities when predicting the future. Predicting the future has become a business. Governments and companies often have their own foresight programs and “think-tanks” with specialist staff to advise on future developments and trends. A number of specialist companies and institutes have been set up to trade advice, carry out vision surveys, and write reports on areas of topical interest. Their names can be found by searching the Internet. Some examples of the more prominent ones are listed later. Ian Pearson, a futurist at British Telecom’s Research labs, in his book Business 2010: Mapping the New Commerical Landscape5 states that “within a generation, we will grow computers from biological cultures that are faster than those we use today.” The ability one day to make conscious computers with an intelligence that exceeds humans will provide a challenge to our present society. The development and consequences of artificial intelligence were explored by futurist Ray Kurzweil in his book The Age of Spiritual Machines.6 This was followed by The Singularity is Near,7 which explores the evolution of the union of humans and intelligent machines. In his book The Extreme Future,8 James Canton, who runs the Institute for Global Futures in the U.S., gives a compelling extrapolation from our current knowledge to the next 40 years. He outlines eight fundamental innovations that will shape the future taken from an American perspective: biomimetrics, photonics, nano-biotech, targeted genomics, bio-detection, neuro-devices, nano-energy, and quantum encryption.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 231
10/23/07 10:23:44 AM
232
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
Perhaps the most compelling is biomimetrics — mimicking nature’s mechanisms to make new products. The living world is a manifest of innovative design. It has evolved over the Earth’s history to adapt to its particular environment. We can understand such designs only by examining them at the micro and nanoscale, i.e., at the cell biology level. The natural world uses bio-nanotechnology to create nanostructures and nanomachines. Studying these structures and analyzing the materials from which they are made gives insight about the processes used. Some of these processes are explored in Richard Jones’ book Soft Machines.9 Intense studies are being made of plants and insects to understand how they produce the materials that give them unique abilities to develop and survive in their environment. Accurate and sensitive analytical instruments are now available to make observations and measurements at the nanoscale. Many natural phenomena exist that require explaining — why is the inner shell of the abalone twice as tough as modern high-tech ceramics? why can spiders spin a flexible web five times stronger than steel? why can adhesive mussels stick to rocks, ships, etc., under salt water quite efficiently? why can certain bacterial cells utilize sunlight at 95% efficiency? and why can many insects regenerate lost limbs? Attempts to copy these natural phenomena have so far not succeeded, but studies continue. The results of the studies should help technologists in their quest for making new materials. Our ability to design molecules and biological systems will be dependent on advanced computer modelling that has yet to fully develop. The complex biochemical processes that take place in living cells are being actively studied. This is a priority area for research and development because of its huge importance to medicine and the understanding of life and its origins.
The Future of Health and Medicine Expenditure on world healthcare is now over $3 trillion, which makes it the world’s largest industry. The governments of most countries give health and medicine a high priority. Actual statistics relating to what each nation spends on these can be found on the Internet. With increasing world population, and in some countries a larger aging population, the demand for healthcare is placing impossible burdens on governments. Technological advances in every field of medicine are raising expectations and pushing up demand for services. In democratic countries, politicians and governments have to respond positively to this demand to secure support of the people they represent. They are turning increasingly to science and technology for solutions. The areas where nanotechnology is most likely to enhance the quality of life for human beings will be in the fields of medical diagnostics, drug delivery, and customized therapy. The availability of low-cost, easy-to-use, portable devices and measurement systems will empower people to make their own decisions and plan their own treatment schedules. The Institute for Alternative Futures (IFAF)10 sees in the next 25 years the development of a Health Advocate Avatar. This is a knowledge interface that can mediate interactions between individuals and medical knowledge. It would provide an information platform for organizing and integrating personal medical information to the newest advances in biomedical developments, thus enabling individuals to make
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 232
10/23/07 10:23:44 AM
Shaping the Future
233
informed choices about their own healthcare. It is predicted that before 2030 this will become an accepted practice, making healthcare fully personalized. In the next decade, medical practitioners and health specialists will have enough data on genetics and proteomics from patient records to replace diagnostics with prognostic systems. The mapping of an individual’s DNA and linking that knowledge to his or her health profile will determine vulnerability to a wide range of diseases. This will advance predictive medicine and will enable drugs to be targeted to an individual’s specific needs. Wearable computers will record and analyze data from body monitors containing biomarkers that track disease in people at risk. These computers can be securely connected to health monitoring centers. In this way, the human population would contribute data directly to a central database for storage and analysis. Clinical diagnosis can then be validated by accessing a central library of biomarkers, thus identifying disease at its early onset. The continuing development of imaging systems permits visualization of internal organs and body processes, including brain functions. Within the next two decades, this will advance our understanding of the relationship between body and mind and lead to a “predict and prevent” approach to medicine. Eventually these health measures will result in life extension. Antioxidant and hormone replacement therapies will further aid reduction of the aging process. Future markets will be shaped by anti-ageing and health-enhancement products. Longevity medicine will become an established practice. It is estimated that within the next two decades human life expectancy for healthy people could approach 100 years. Longevity medicine will retard the aging process and promote better health and quality of life; but it will have profound political, economic, and cultural consequences for society. Here we can see how.bio-nanotechnology.through.advances.in.medicine.and.medical.practice.will. change society beyond anything that has gone before. This leads us to the field of nanomedicine.
Nanomedicine Biomedicine and biology are currently undergoing an information revolution. Huge amounts of data are being generated from DNA sequencing, molecular structures, and macromolecular structures (proteins, RNA, DNA); and from modelling and visualizing biological pathways (metabolic, signalling, genetic control). Nanomedicine is a subset of biomedicine. It can be loosely defined as the preservation and improvement of human health using molecular tools and knowledge of the human body’s biochemistry. Nano-sized tools are used for the diagnosis, prevention, and treatment of disease. They help to gain increased understanding of the complex underlying physiology of disease. Nanomedicine will shape the future direction of medicine. For a complete coverage of the subject, the reader is referred to Robert Freitas’s excellent Nanomedicine Book Site.11 On this site, which is exclusively devoted to nanomedicine, can be found four volumes of information covering all aspects of the field. Each volume is available as a hardback book. With the author’s permission, I have taken the following definition from the Nanomedicine Book Web Site.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 233
10/23/07 10:23:45 AM
234
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
Molecular nanotechnology has been defined as the three-dimensional positional control of molecular structure to create materials and devices to molecular precision. The human body is comprised of molecules; hence the availability of molecular nanotechnology will permit dramatic progress in human medical services. More than just an extension of ‘molecular medicine,’ nanomedicine will employ molecular machine systems to address medical problems, and will use molecular knowledge to maintain and improve human health at the molecular scale. Nanomedicine will have extraordinary and far-reaching implications for the medical profession, for the definition of disease, for the diagnosis and treatment of medical conditions including ageing, and ultimately for the improvement and extension of natural human biologica.
In 2005, the European Science Foundation produced a report looking at the future of nanomedicine12 and identifying Europe’s strengths and weaknesses. The work for this foresight study report was carried out by a group of 35 experts from academia and industry at workshops held in Amsterdam in 2004. One of the main conclusions was the urgent need to raise awareness and improve communication of the economic and social benefits of nanomedicine to stakeholders and to the wider public.
Current Developments According to the findings of the IFAF 2029 Project,10 work is in progress in the following six areas as outlined on the Web Site. These will provide the foundations for the future of nanomedicine. • Antimicrobial Properties: An investigation is being carried out on nanomaterials with strong antimicrobial properties such as nanocrystalline silver. This is already being used by some medical centers for wound treatment by coating bandages. • Biopharmaceutics: Efforts are focused on drug delivery applications using nanomaterial coatings to encapsulate drugs and to serve as functional carriers. Nanomaterial encapsulation could improve the diffusion, degradation, and targeting of a drug. • Implantable Materials: Work is centered on using nanomaterials to repair and replace damaged or diseased tissues. Nanomaterial implant coatings could increase the adhesion, durability, and lifespan of implants, and nanostructure scaffolds could provide a framework for improved tissue regeneration. • Implantable Devices: Efforts are concentrated on implanting small devices to serve as sensors, fluid injection systems, drug dispensers, pumps and reservoirs, and aids to restore vision and hearing functions. Devices with nanoscale components could monitor environmental conditions, detect specific properties, and deliver appropriate physical, chemical, or pharmaceutical responses. In the longer term, the development of nanoelectronic systems that can detect and process information could lead to nanodevices that serve as retina implants by acting as photoreceptors, and cochlear implants by improving nerve stimulation. • Diagnostic Tools: Lab-on-a-chip devices are being used to perform DNA analysis and drug discovery research by reducing the required sample
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 234
10/23/07 10:23:45 AM
Shaping the Future
235
sizes and accelerating the chemical reaction process. Devices could promote early detection and diagnosis of disease. Research is in progress using nanoscale devices and materials to learn more about how biological systems self-assemble, self-regulate, and self-destroy at the molecular level. Wyeth and Merck, Pfizer, GSK, Astra Zeneca, and Genentech are using nanotechnologies for drug formulation and drug screening, employing the technique of quantum dot analysis.13 • Molecular Imaging Systems: Advances in nanomedicine will depend on developments in molecular imaging systems. Molecular imaging is the noninvasive visualization in space and time of normal as well as abnormal cellular processes at a molecular or genetic level of function. It is used to provide characterization and measurement of biological processes in humans (in vivo). Current noninvasive imaging developments fall into three categories: • Radionuclide Imaging Devices visualize very low concentrations of radionuclide probes in real time and provide quantitative information but with low image resolution. They can be used for whole body imaging. − The PET (Positron Emission Tomography) scan visualizes probes labelled with positron emitting radioisotopes; it is increasingly popular for both research and clinical medicine. It can reveal the presence of lymphoma cancer cells in specific areas of the body earlier and more accurately than previous diagnostic methods. − The SPECT (Single Photon Emission Computed Tomography) uses probes labelled with radioactive isotopes, which emit gamma rays detected by a gamma camera to create the scan. − Quantitative Autoradiography is a technique used in the laboratory to visualize radioactively labelled molecules in substances. − Radionucleotide Imaging combined with a computed tomography (CT) or a nuclear resonance imaging (NRI) scan provides high anatomic definition along with functional imaging for precise location of the selected molecular activity. • Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) uses paramagnetic-labelled probes and produces high imaging resolution, but a large concentration of the probe must be given, which can overwhelm the system being investigated. • Optical Imaging uses fluorescent and bioluminescent probes that emit radiation in the visible or near-infrared wavelengths, which can be scanned by optical cameras. Since light can travel only a few millimeters through tissue, it is limited to skin, breast, small animals, and endoscopic procedures — not deep tissues.
Future Developments In the future, scanners will become so small and inexpensive that they could be used directly by people in their own homes. They will be able to illuminate a large number of biomarkers that identify disease processes. Beyond disease, some experts see that molecular imaging could prove even more important for revealing healthy biological processes as well. Brain scans already show neurological changes that energize
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 235
10/23/07 10:23:45 AM
236
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
areas of the brain associated with human emotions. Molecular markers can be used to highlight other parameters such as stress levels, immune function, balance, and energy flow. Molecular imaging will become more important as genomics and proteomics expand the number of relevant molecules to visualize human behavior.
Stem Cells for the Future14 In the coming decades, adult stem cells, if taken from a patient’s own body, could hold the key to a renewable source of replacement cells and tissues to treat diseases like Parkinson’s and Alzheimer’s, spinal cord injury, stroke, burns, heart disease, diabetes, osteoarthritis, and rheumatoid arthritis. They could even be used to grow entire organs such as hearts, livers, and kidneys. Although much work has to be done, it is likely that the promise of novel cell-based therapies for such pervasive and debilitating diseases will be realized in the future. One of the hurdles to overcome is the need to be able to easily and reproducibly manipulate stem cells so that they possess the necessary characteristics for successful differentiation and transplantation. It is expected that within the coming decade research will produce a better understanding of how genetic and molecular controls operate within cells, such as the signals that turn specific genes on and off to influence the differentiation of the stem cell. This is important in the use of human stem cells to test new drugs.
Materials — Products — Applications Nanoparticles, Nanomaterials, and Nanomanufacturing Many future products will be manufactured from nanomaterials or composites of such materials. Nanomaterials15 (nanocrystalline materials) are materials possessing grain sizes on the order of a billionth of a meter (10 -9) m. A nanocrystalline material has grains on the order of 1–100 nm. Depending on atomic radii and others parameters, about 5 atoms would occupy a space of about 1 nm. Nanocrystalline materials are exceptionally strong, hard, ductile at high temperatures, wear resistant, erosion resistant, corrosion resistant, and chemically very active. They have unique properties that can be exploited for a variety of structural and nonstructural applications. In the future, the industries where most applications will occur are chemicals, textiles, and electronics. Nanoparticles can be defined as free particles with diameters less than 100 nm. They have different properties compared with larger particles of the same material and exist naturally as products of combustion and photochemical activity. For example, titanium oxide and zinc oxide at the nanoscale are able to absorb and reflect ultraviolet light but are transparent to visible light, which makes them ideal for use as sunscreens. Many such products are now available on the market. Nanoparticles of certain semiconductors have optical properties that enable them to change color with size; these are known as quantum dots. They are used as fluorescent biomarkers in medicine and in solar cells, but many other potential applications exist. At present there are wide public concerns about nanoparticles that need to be addressed. Fortunately, most scientists and governments agree on the issues that relate to the different properties of matter in the form of free nanoparticles to matter
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 236
10/23/07 10:23:46 AM
Shaping the Future
237
where nanoparticles are chemically locked into the material. Nanoparticles already exist in the environment as products of combustion. They are small enough to pass directly into the body through the skin and the cell walls, being less than 100 nm wide, less than the size of a virus. This is of particular concern to manufacturers of nutraceuticals who use them as food supplements. It is claimed they will enter directly into tissues and cells. Other examples of food products that carry a nanoparticle label are nano-tea that is claimed to increase the amount of selenium that can be absorbed from green tea through capsules that bypass the stomach and enter the lower gut directly, and cooking oil that will stop cholesterol entering the blood stream. In the U.S., there are more than 30 food products listed with nanoparticle ingredients. The effect of nanoparticles on health is a subject of study in many countries. Much of the fear is engendered by the known toxicological effects of asbestos. This is a naturally occurring nanoscale material extensively used in the twentieth century because it was a cheap building material. Its use was banned in Europe in 1998. The danger came from dust liberated during manufacture, resulting in many deaths from lung cancer. This was largely due to ignorance about the structure and nature of the material at a time when coal was also burnt on fires. The smoke from these produced even worse pollution and deaths from respiratory diseases. Carbon nanotubes resemble asbestos in structure, but little is known about whether they constitute a similar health hazard. Therefore, there is an understandable public concern about new materials of which little was known. Some similarities in the structure of asbestos fibers to carbon nanotubes have been noted by the public. In 2004 the U.K. government set up an expert committee to review the toxicology and other safety issues associated with nanotechnology and after extensive consultations with people from industry and academia produced a comprehensive report.16 The report concluded that the very small quantities of nanoparticles being manufactured in uncontrolled environments compared with the natural release of such particles did not constitute a serious risk to health. Humans inhale millions of pollutant nanoparticles per breath produced as products of combustion. Nanoparticles of chemicals like titanium dioxide, used in cosmetics and sunscreens, show no evidence of harm to the skin or the organs beneath it. In fact, their enhanced protective properties have proved to be very beneficial to health and may substantially reduce skin cancers by reducing exposure to harmful solar ultraviolet radiation. The need for more toxicological research on nanoparticles was emphasized in the report. This report has helped to reestablish public confidence and give manufacturers guidance on what measures should be taken in nanomanufacturing. The public concern about nanomanufactured products and the health issues associated with genetically modified organisms resulted from a lack of knowledge, misunderstanding, and misinformation put out by the media. However, the scientific community must share some of the responsibility for not explaining the issues in an understandable way to the lay public. The need for better public understanding was also highlighted in the report. Nanomanufacturing based on nanoparticulate technology has created improvements to many existing products. These include improved cosmetics, stain-resistant fabrics, composite materials for vehicles and sports equipment, medical devices and diagnostics, drug delivery systems, and fire and water resistant coatings and materials for fuel cells. These products and others are currently being developed and in
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 237
10/23/07 10:23:46 AM
238
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
some cases are already on the market. In the foreseeable future, there is the promise of many more products. It is only when such products can be purchased by the public in high street shops at affordable prices that the full commercial cycle is complete. There are five widely known methods to produce nanomaterials: • • • • •
Sol-gel synthesis Inert gas condensation Mechanical alloying or high-energy ball milling Plasma synthesis Electrodeposition
All these processes synthesize nanomaterials to varying degrees of commercially viable quantities. Very few companies have the expertise and equipment needed for processing. As the demand for new nano-based products increases and new industries develop, process equipment suppliers will rise to meet that demand. This is likely to accelerate in the next decade. The issues of future nanomanufacturing are outlined by Jackson,17 who concludes that nanomanufacturing processes need to be applied to known engineering materials such as metal alloys and ceramics. Public acceptance of nano-based products is pivotal for many of the issues that have been discussed and highlighted in this book. Any strategy for commercializing micro-nanotechnology products must take into account the public acceptance of the technology and the end product. Customers determine the level of sales and ultimately the market success. Any scares brought about by news that a product is harmful immediately destroy its market credibility. This is particularly so for food or health products.
Carbon Nanotube Composites Carbon nanotubes (CNTs), approximately 10,000 times thinner than human hair, are examples of a new nanomaterial that is already starting to replace or complement carbon fibers in a range of sports equipment such as tennis rackets and golf clubs. They offer stronger, lighter alternatives at potentially lower cost. If proven to give a real competitive advantage to sportsmen, as did lightweight composites for racing cycles, then such materials will be universally adopted. The exceptional high-tensile strength and the physical, mechanical, and electronic properties of CNTs make them potentially suitable for use as sensors, probes, actuators, nanoelectronic devices, and drug delivery systems within biomedical applications. A comprehensive review study has been carried out by Sinha and Yeow,18 who concluded that it is only the unknown toxicology issues and acceptance by the human immune system that at present prevent their use as implants. Carbon nanotubes are being mass produced by the Mitsubishi Chemical Corp. of Japan at an annual rate of 300 tons. In 2007, a larger commercial plant currently under construction will have an annual production capacity of 1500 tons. This indicates the expected market growth for a very successful nanomanufactured product.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 238
10/23/07 10:23:46 AM
Shaping the Future
239
Microchips and Nanoelectronics Nanotechnology has generated the subfield of nanoelectronics. Like its predecessor, microelectronics, it will revolutionize the electronics industry. We are entering a new era when miniaturization is taking a giant leap forward. In fact, personal computers made in the past few years have microchips manufactured with nanometer-scale features so they could be considered to be nanochips. For example, it is now possible to accommodate 800 million transistors on a chip the size of a postage stamp (the transistor is the basic electronic switch). Within the next decade, silicon chip features will shrink down to the molecular scale. The operating limit of the transistor will be reached at about 10 nm or about 30 atoms long. Molecular electronics will then be needed to take us further down in size. New handling techniques adapted from the semiconductor industry are enabling nanomanufacturing processes to be applied to the production of the new microchips and biochips. There is an urgent need to increase the storage capacity and functionality of memory chips for the next generation of computers and consumer products. In addition, the huge demand for devices such as cell phones, smart cards, ID cards, bank cards and sensors, etc., adds to the growing market. Memory chips based on nanotechnology processes will lead the next generation of nanoelectronics with multibillion dollar markets. Murawski19 foresees that current computer disk storage will increase from 80 GB to 1600 GB in the first generation of nanoelectronics and to 80,00 GB in the second generation. This advance will take us into molecular and quantum computing — a distant shore on the horizon. The urgency in moving to molecular electronics is partly driven by the recognition that conventional technologies, despite significant advances, will not be able to sustain Moore’s Law,20 which projects a doubling of computing power about every 2 years. According to the International Technology Roadmap for Semiconductors (ITRS),21 EUV lithography (wavelength 13.5 nm), which is a projection optical lithographic process, will start displacing existing 193 nm lithography techniques before the end of the decade for production of leading-edge semiconductor chips with critical dimensions of 32 nm or smaller. A significant milestone in developing next-generation chip manufacturing technology has been achieved by the silicon chip maker Intel, which has announced that it will start manufacturing processors using transistors just 45 nm wide on 300 mm silicon wafers. Shrinking the basic building blocks of microchips will make them faster and more efficient. The transistors are small enough to fit 100 inside the diameter of a human red blood cell, or 400 million transistors will fit onto a chip half the size of a postage stamp. The Intel dual-core processors have more than 400 million transistors. In addition, the technology includes several innovative performance-enhancing and power-saving features that will provide a basis for future developments. Tze-chiang Chen of IBM22 has also signalled that IBM will start production of these new microchips. He quotes: “The development means the fundamental ‘law’ that underpins the development of all microchips, known as Moore’s Law, remains intact. After more than 10 years of effort, we now have a way forward.”
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 239
10/23/07 10:23:46 AM
240
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
New products that will use these chips are already at the design stage. For example, a new handheld computer with integrated wireless connectivity that will have more computing power than current desktop models could be on the market within a few years. The manufacturers claim that they will be able to run all day on battery power. The complete transition to nanotechnology techniques could occur by 2015, when chip makers will have exhausted their ability to shrink further the wires and switches that make up the modern processors and memory storage devices, central to computers, communications, and consumer electronics. Manufacturers are looking to the future when they can make electronic switches from single molecules. Molecular electronics is an emerging field that will soon be out of the laboratory and into manufacturing. The development of miniaturized scanning tunneling microscopes (STMs) and atomic force microscopes (AFM) that facilitate the manipulation of single molecules has brought the realization of constructing bottom-up structures. Initial products in molecular electronics will be hybrid silicon-molecular devices. Combined with nanotubes, the possibilities of making very sensitive biological and chemical sensors for use in medical diagnostics and environmental monitoring are unlimited. Chemists at Liverpool University in the U.K. recently reported success in forming a bond between a gold atom and a single organic molecule called a Pentacine.23 This bond between a metal atom and an organic molecule is a step toward connecting electronic components to organic molecules, essential for progressing molecular electronics.
Biochips The big development within the next decade will be smart biochips, i.e., molecularscale devices with intelligent multifunctionality. A biochip is a collection of miniaturized test sites (microarrays) arranged on a solid substrate that permits many tests to be performed in parallel in order to achieve faster and higher throughput. Typically, a biochip’s surface area is about the size of a key on a computer keyboard. Biochips will revolutionize medicine in the same way that microchips revolutionized electronic devices. A biochip can perform thousands of biological reactions, such as decoding genes, in a few seconds. It enabled the rapid identification of the estimated 80,000 genes in human DNA. One important application area is in the detection of biomolecules in samples, thus allowing inexpensive rapid detection of toxins and viruses such as avian flu. Pharma companies are particularly interested in using biochips and microfluidic devices to screen tissues for genetic differences so that they can design genetically targeted drugs. This will greatly improve treatment and reduce drug costs by removing the “try and see if it works” principle that dominates current practice. Targeted drug delivery will be the future.
Supplier Companies Biochips are complex devices requiring many different technologies for their construction. The first commercial biochips were introduced by the U.S. company Affymetrix,24 the world’s leading manufacturer of DNA microarrays, in 1994. Since
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 240
10/23/07 10:23:47 AM
Shaping the Future
241
then, Affymetrix GeneChip (R) technology has become the industry standard in molecular biology research and is pointing the way to the future. The German company Siemens is planning to use the “laboratory on a chip” concept in a smart card similar to conventional check cards. The aim is to provide a low-cost, easy-to-use general-purpose, mass-market analytical product similar to existing smart cards. These could be used in doctors’ surgeries and clinical laboratories. The card would be inserted into a desktop or laptop computer where data would be analysed and a readout of results provided. This instant analysis will reduce patient waiting times and reduce the burdens on hospital laboratories. In a similar way to Siemens, the company Infineon is also working on a system to incorporate electronic DNA biochips in powerful desktop devices for diagnostics applications. This will enable complex DNA analyses to be carried out in medical practices, hospitals, and other medical institutions faster and more cost effectively than can be done at present. Impressive work is in progress at many research centers around the world. For example, the Optical Biochip Project at Cardiff University25 aims to develop more sophisticated analytical methodologies that will increase the success rate of drug discovery, in genomics research, in the routine diagnosis of disease. These companies and institutes are pioneering the future direction of analytical diagnostics, which eventually will have a beneficial effect on our lives. Biochips that can perform the basic bio-analysis functions (genomic, proteomic, biosimulation, and microfluidics) at a low cost will transform biological analysis and production in a very similar fashion as the microprocessor did for data. Implanted biochips and microchips can be used for a variety of applications, including identification and tracking of individuals and continuous monitoring of body functions and behaviour. This subject has been featured in many science fiction books and films and has become very controversial. A number of people working in the field have tested the viability of such implants in their bodies. On 24 August 1998, Professor Kevin Warwick,26 director of cybernetics at the University of Reading in the U.K., became the first human to have a microchip implanted in his body. During a 20-min medical procedure described as “a routine silicon-chip implant” by Dr. George Boulos, who led the operation, doctors inserted into Warwick’s arm a glass capsule not much bigger than a pearl. The capsule held several microprocessors that were able to transmit to the outside world. He was able to demonstrate the ease of the operation and its potential value in medical applications, particularly for paraplegics where embedded chips could be used to control motor-drive systems to move limbs. The implant was removed from his arm after nine days without any problems. In response, Charles Ostman, a senior fellow at the Institute for Global Futures, says that “Neuroprosthetics are inevitable” and that “biochip implants may eventually become part of a routine medical procedure.” There is still much work to be done, but the possibilities are unlimited.
Existing MNT Products and Components During the last decade, there has been an upsurge in new applications for miniaturized products, some with nano-sized components and features. Today, these are dominated by the following sectors: IT peripherals, biomedical, automotive, household,
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 241
10/23/07 10:23:47 AM
242
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
and telecommunications. The products manufactured for these were microsystem devices operating with integration of optics, fluidics, thermal, mechanical, and electronic functions. Because many of these and the processes used to develop and manufacture them have already been covered in previous chapters, I have listed some of the more recognizable products and components under the sector headings: • Industrial: Industrial pressure sensors, injection nozzles, flow sensors, industrial micromotors, microbolometers, thermopile, automotive • Automotive: HVAC suspension, airbag accelerometers, fuel injectors, satellite navigators (GPS), rollover, gearbox, fuel monitoring, ABS, tire pressure • Communications: Integrated optics, RF switches, high resolution display panels, resonators, optical attenuators • Chemical Analysis: Gas sensors, microspectrometers, electronic noses, lab-on-a-chip, chemical sensors, valves and pumps • Biomedical Technology: Heart pacemakers, blood pressure monitors, blood analyzers, glucose monitors, nebulizers, tunable hearing aids, spray injectors, biochips (genechips), DNA analyzers • Information Technology: Hard disk drive heads (HDD), large format print heads, magneto optical heads, consumer print heads, digital mirror devices
Emerging New Products and Systems Micro-nanotechnologies are enabling the production of new products and systems and enhancing many of the existing ones listed above. In the near future, these will include RF switches, fuel cells, RF ID tags, and drug delivery systems. The unique properties of nanomaterials will produce new manufacturing paradigms. Nanomaterials like carbon nanotubes could be significant in the development of new hydrogen storage fuel cells to provide automotive power. Advances in optics and magnetics may give rise to new sources of power. Computers and communication systems will make huge advances as new nanochips and biochips become available. Computing technology will enable DNA sequencing to be performed more rapidly and will advance nanomedicine and bionanotechnology into new domains of knowledge beyond anything we can imagine, greatly enhancing human capabilities. Quantum computers could become a reality in the next decade. Research on these is being supported by a number of governments and agencies owing to their potential for civilian and military use. Ultrasensitive 3D motion sensors are being used to detect and measure minute vibrations and movement, including freefall and high-g motion. They will find applications in everything that is capable of movement and can be used to protect sensitive objects that are disturbed by motion. Chemical analysis will become ultraprecision and even more sensitive, able to detect, mix, and separate individual molecules using labelling and lab-on-the chip techniques. The following are some of the application areas where the greatest impact is most likely to be seen.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 242
10/23/07 10:23:47 AM
Shaping the Future
243
Nano Food Products Food is the most important product for humans. According to Helmut Kaiser,27 “Designing and producing food by shaping molecules and atoms is the future of the food industries worldwide.” Their latest study report shows that more than 400 companies worldwide are active in research and development and production using nanotechnologies and molecular science in food, food processing, and packaging. The U.S. is the leader, followed by Japan and China. The nanofood market, currently valued at about $5 billion, is expected to reach about $20 billion in 2010, with packaging being $3.7 billion. There are now more than 300 nanofood products available on the market worldwide. This is expected to grow as more knowledge is gained when the health and safety issues are resolved. Many countries in the European Union (EU) have strict regulations in place for nanofood products and are examining new materials and processes to determine if new rules are required. The U.K. government is working closely with its Institute of Food Science and Technology (IFST) and has agreed to consult with its EU partners on regulatory issues as they arise. This provides a healthy situation and gives confidence to consumers. In contrast, the U.S. Food and Drug Adminstration (FDA) takes a slightly different approach, stressing that new materials and products are within its area of regulation rather than food processing. In a recent scientific status summary report by the IFST and by Weiss et al.28 on the application of nanotechnology in the food industry, it was stated that the most cost-effective development areas for the industry were development of functional materials, micro- and nanoscale processing, product development methods, and instrumentation to improve food safety and biosecurity. The areas of commercial importance would be functional ingredients, drugs, vitamins, antimicrobials, antioxidants, flavorings, colorants, and preservatives. These are also of great interest to pharmaceutical and cosmetic companies. But such companies are very aware of the public concern issues and carefully study government guidelines and regulations. Nanotechnology is linked to genetics, and the deep public concern and controversy over genetically modified (GM) food crops has led to many scientists and politicians calling for a moratorium on the development of the technology. It is being cast alongside similar issues raised by nuclear power and nuclear weapons in the 1960s. Public opinion is easily turned toward negatives, particularly when misinformation is given out by the media and vested interests. “Frankenstein Food” and “Nanbots” are terms being used to describe the consequences of nanotechnology. It is generally accepted that we are entering areas where new knowledge is required, so European governments took the cautionary approach and banned the use of GM crops, while other countries, notably the U.S., continue to apply the technology. It accounts for more than two thirds of all the crops grown worldwide. In addition, South America, Canada, and China are among other leading countries growing crops because they need to produce food economically. In the U.S., the three main GM crops under cultivation are varieties of corn, soya beans, and cotton. These vital foods are exported to underdeveloped countries where they provide huge benefits. The “genie is out of the bottle,” and technology has altered the natural gene pool in a very short time compared to the time it would have taken the natural
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 243
10/23/07 10:23:48 AM
244
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
selection process. So far no observable deleterious effects or problems have been observed, but a deep-rooted concern still exists. The technology, however, has radically changed the way food can be grown. By the middle of the century, it is likely that all food will be produced artificially in controlled conditions with less reliance on pesticides and climate. GM foods are a fact, and more types of plants will be treated in the same way. The use of nanotechnology on future food production, processing, and intelligent packaging will dominate all other methods. This will be of huge value in feeding populations of the underdeveloped world where poor climate and other factors make sustainable food production impossible. Estimates vary, but it can be expected that by 2020 more than 50% of the food industry worldwide will turn to nanotechnology, with thousands of companies benefiting. This is an example of an incremental change rather than a disruptive change, but it will happen.
Smart Packaging for Food The word “smart” is used to convey an intelligent function of the containment or packaging of a product or component. Packaging is an essential stage in the manufacture and commercialization of micro-nanoproducts and can represent 80% of the production cost. It is fundamental to product functionality. Serving the purpose of interconnection and product protection, it provides an interface to the macro world and effectively facilitates human interaction in the working environment. Smart packaging can provide many different functions. They can be mechanically, chemically, electrically, or electronically driven functions that enhance the usability or effectiveness of the product in some way. For example, in food this might in the wrapping or labelling that tracks condition or quality against temperature and time. One such indicator available on the market employs enzymatic color indicators to show the amount of temperature exposure of a stored or shipped temperaturesensitive commodity such as a perishable food product. The indicator is activated at the beginning of the monitoring period by pressure on the plastic bubble strip, which allows the two initial liquids to mix and form the indicating solution. Electronic noses sense the odor-causing chemicals that are emitted when food starts to deteriorate and bacteria produces gases; they provide signals to color change indicators. These will be standard on all food packaging in the future when international agreements are reached on standards. Antimicrobial agents coated on the inside layer of the package, which is in contact with the surface of the food, can release an agent to keep food fresh for longer periods. As the technology develops, less emphasis will need to be placed on freezing, thus reducing costs and easing transportation. It was recently reported that in Denmark and in the U.S., low-cost, battery-free Radio Frequency Identification Device (RFID) tags are being developed to become integrated into packaging.29 They consist of a silicon microprocessor, and some form of radio antenna-conductive carbon ink is replacing the more expensive metal coils used on current tags. This radio antenna functions as both input/output channel and power source. Electricity is generated in the antenna by either a magnetic field or a radio signal; the tag responds by sending out a radio signal. This reply signal
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 244
10/23/07 10:23:48 AM
Shaping the Future
245
contains data stored on the chip, typically an ID number. With the help of RFID readers in our cell phones, in supermarket freezers and check-outs, in our private refrigerators, etc., we will be able to retrieve information about a particular item based on its ID number. RFID is not a new technology, but advances in micro-nanotechnology will empower the consumer over the product supplier, thus improving safety and reliability. We have entered the age of biohazards that could come from the natural spread of disease through contaminated food or induced by bioterrorism. Smart tagging will provide a greater protection to consumers. Smart packaging is estimated to be a $100 billion plus business in the United States. More people work in packaging and packaging operations than any other business area in that country. Although exact figures are not available, it must be an important growth area worldwide.
Fuel and Transportation Systems Our civilization is built on the need for abundant and accessible sources of energy for transportation and driving machinery. I am not going to dwell here on the impending crisis of climate change associated with the burning of carbon-based fossil fuels, since many articles, reports, and books have been written on that subject (and as we move into the future, no doubt the number will increase). Miniaturization technologies have an important role to play in the future as we accelerate the need to find alternative fuels and means of transport. Hydrogen is the most likely power source for transport systems of the future and is providing the greatest challenge to the automotive industry. The global economy is exerting pressure on developing nations and increasing their demands for cheaper and more readily available sources of energy. Energy is at the core of tensions between nations that have sources and ones that do not. Every scientifically advanced nation is investing in research and development in this area. Energy is the defining issue of the twenty-first century. Many studies and surveys have been carried out, and all conclude that by 2050 there will not be enough economically accessible fossil fuel sources to supply the world’s needs. So a crisis is looming that may be much greater than climate change. This makes the assumption that all the renewable energy sources — nuclear, solar, hydroelectric, wind, and wave power — taken together and based on current known technology will not be able to meet that demand. The basic problem is the world needs about 20 terawatts of energy to solve all its needs. Constantly about 165,000 terawatts of solar energy from the sun hit the Earth, but most of it cannot be collected instantly, only indirectly over a period of time from biosources. Richard Smalley30 suggested that the problem could be solved if sufficient energy storage cells for electricity could be made. Then, instead of transporting energy sources like fossil fuels around the world, a global network of interconnected electrical grids could supply those who need it on demand. Local storage sources could be used to provide energy when it was needed. All renewable power sources — solar, wind, hydroelectric, and wave power — could be fed into the grid. Lead-acid storage batteries are commonly used for cars and in houses for shortterm energy supply, but they cannot store enough power unless they are very large,
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 245
10/23/07 10:23:48 AM
246
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
which makes them uneconomical. Through revolutionary advances in nanotechnology, it may be possible to make efficient storage systems the size of a washing machine and drop the cost to less than $1000. Most importantly, it permits some or all of the primary electrical power on the grid to come from variable renewable sources like solar and wind. The key is not only an energy source but also energy storage and energy transport. Storing energy in batteries, capacitors, fuel cells, and some chemical systems like hydrogen depends on nanoscale interactions. The next generation of storage devices will be optimized by nanoengineered advances and the use of nanoscale catalyst particles. Fuel cells are most likely to be the energy sources of the future for vehicles, local off-grid power supply, and power sources for small and handheld electronic devices. Nanomaterials will be important as catalysts and key components of hydrogen storage systems. The use of carbon nanotubes for hydrogen storage is the subject of research at many centers as the mechanism for adsorption is not understood, but it is likely that in the future these structures will have a significant role to play. In the transitional period, hydrogen-powered fuel cell vehicles will be hybrids that also have batteries and electric motors. The immediate challenge is to develop a battery that can store enough energy for a long-range drive and have a short recharging time. Future transport scenarios are being studied, but they tend to be based on social and economic needs, with the environment and carbon pollution now at the top of the agenda.
Detection and Analysis Government agencies worldwide are increasingly looking at miniaturization technologies to provide solutions to combat crime and give their citizens a greater sense of security. Fast DNA analysis is now an established practice and will continue to develop as equipment becomes more portable and analysis faster. Microspectrometry and microfluidic systems enable even smaller samples to be analyzed. The growing threat of global terrorism has accelerated the need for improved detection and surveillance methods. The greatly improved optical resolution of space-orbiting satellites and airborne cameras on pilotless drones are examples of some of these developments. Recently the Japanese company Hitachi announced its latest development in RFID tags: smart dust or powder. It is to date the world’s smallest and thinnest tag, measuring 0.05 × 0.05 millimeters, many times smaller than a human hair.31 The chips have a 128-bit ROM for storing a unique 38-digit number. Data can be written on the chip substrate with an electron beam. There are many applications for such devices in detecting people or objects at short range. They can be embedded in paper bank notes or documents for identification and tracking purposes. Future developments will be made to increase their operational range. This is approaching the ultimate bug, and maybe in the far future they could become intelligent bugs.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 246
10/23/07 10:23:49 AM
Shaping the Future
247
2030 and Beyond The future belongs to new products, new processes, and new systems. These will result from continuing innovation and the exploitation of knowledge. They will radically change our way of life and fuel the global economy. The world in 2030 and beyond will be united by a common purpose: all nations will want to have a safer, healthier, and more prosperous world for their citizens. National, ideological, and religious differences will remain, but overriding these will be a common need to achieve these goals. It was the overwhelming desire of people to reach these goals that was mainly responsible for the collapse of Communism in Europe and the break up of the Soviet Union in the 1990s. They are now the goals driving the emerging giant economies of Asia and India. The new technologies of the twenty-first century are playing a pivotal role in helping all nations to develop their economies and hence improve the standard of living for their people. Predicting the future with any degree of accuracy beyond 2030 will be informed speculation. It is the realm of the science fiction writers and filmmakers; they can produce a whole range of plausible entertaining scenarios without being seriously challenged. However, there is value in speculation when it is based on observable data. Climate change is an example where improved methods of data collection and analysis have enabled predictive modelling to be more accurate and credible. Observations and measurements of changes in the atmosphere have been taken around the world for many years. They have shown an upward trend in average temperatures of about 0.4oC during the last 20 years. The average global temperature is predicted to rise between 0.5–1.00C in the next 20 years. Beyond 2030 and toward 2100, models become less accurate as they predict an average temperature rise in the range 1.4–5.80C. Despite these uncertainties, models show that a warming of the Earth is taking place. It is concluded that human industrial activity since the Industrial Revolution has contributed significantly to this through the release of carbon dioxide and other pollutants into the atmosphere. In the various predictive models used, assumptions were made about possible future scenarios. These had to include natural processes such as the effect of solar disturbances, volcanic eruptions, earthquakes, flooding, and even large meteorite collisions. In addition to these are the economic and social factors. The uncertainty of their severity and therefore their contribution to atmospheric pollution and global warming makes predictive modelling very difficult. Natural processes have shaped the Earth’s geological history and have always had a dominant effect on its climate; this will continue in an unpredictable way in the future. The sun, the origin of all energy sources, is the most dominant force for climate change. Observations made of solar activity such as magnetic storms or solar flares over a long time show a close correlation with severe changes in the Earth’s climate. The reason why the most recent predictions on climate change have been given greater credibility and are now on the agenda of many international conferences is because powerful computers with massive parallel processing capability have been available and have been used to analyze data and test the models. Predicting the future is therefore inextricably linked to utilising such computers. Natural occurrences can be disruptive, and therefore their outcomes cannot be accurately
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 247
10/23/07 10:23:49 AM
248
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
modelled. Like all disruptive technologies, expected paths and directions can be instantaneously changed. The current concern about global warming and how science might deal with it has spurned many innovative ideas and extreme solutions; and even created the foundation for new industries. It would have been difficult, if not impossible, for any futurist living in the eighteenth or nineteenth centuries to have predicted life in the twenty-first century because of the lack of available knowledge at those times. Today our knowledge is increasing rapidly, although our ability to use it effectively lags behind. The Internet has given free access to almost all knowledge. Eventually, search engines like Google will supersede libraries as a place for seeking information. Innovation is the driver of change and gives companies a competitive advantage. Nations that develop an innovation-based economy will be winners, but their governments have to create the right environment for it to flourish. This enevitably means change, and people are generally averse to change and react to it naively, thus slowing down technological advance and delaying the social and economic benefits it could bring. This is reflected in government planning and decision making when a cautionary approach is taken. Sometimes this is necessary, but it can produce a state of unpreparedness when a dire threat emerges. For example, the threat of a bird flu pandemic or a massive earthquake on an unprepared world could be disastrous. The problems facing humans are therefore more associated with acceptance of social change than technological change, although the latter produces the need for that change. Nanotechnology has faced unfavorable reactions from people who are traditionally ignorant of the science and its opportunities. Education and greater awareness is the key to the understanding and public acceptance of such technologies. Earlier in the chapter, the future benefits of nanomedicine to healthcare were outlined. A sensible balance between risk and benefit will always have to be made. In the future, risks will be minimized by improved diagnostics and monitoring of patients. The ability to manipulate and control the genetics of humans, animals, and plants, the availability of new drugs to target disease, the growth and regeneration of human organs from stems cells, the application of remotely controlled robotic operators, continuous body monitoring with internal and external sensors, and the complete understanding of the functions of the human brain are some of the developments that will be realized. In 2030 most food production and its distribution to the consumer is likely to be automated and not involve humans. Animal products will be treated differently from vegetables and fruit owing to the methods of production. Battery farming and hothouse products are already highly automated and involve less human intervention. Arrays of sensors connected to machines and computers will continuously monitor and check all parts of the production process to ensure that quality is maintained. At the retail end of the chain, shops will become distribution centers, allowing customers to freely choose and take what they need without going through timeconsuming checkouts. Individuals and the products will be identified and monitored with payment being automatically debited from their online accounts. This will not necessarily prevent or change some forms of shopping where people like to browse, but it will alter the nature of traditional shopping.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 248
10/23/07 10:23:49 AM
Shaping the Future
249
As stated earlier, breakthroughs in NBIC-related areas will drive developments for the next 50 years and beyond. These will undoubtedly include transport systems (aeronautics and space flight), intelligent environments — (robotics and smart buildings), food, and farming (monitoring and genetic modification). However, biomedicine (nanomedicine and implant surgery) is likely to have the greatest impact on society. Computer technology, both hardware and software, is advancing so rapidly that making predictions on how this will develop beyond 2030 will be speculation. Even before that time, computers will become virtually invisible — woven into clothing, embedded into homes, controlling every household function, and implanted in the body to aid dysfunction. Blindness, deafness, and probably memory loss will be eradicated along with many diseases that inflict the human condition. Developments in computers have depended on making smaller, faster, and highcapacity microchips to move and store data. Nanochips (i.e., molecular electronics) will replace microchips, and quantum computers will most likely be established. One aspect of these is based on the principle of electron spin. Unlike charge, the spin can change without an electron moving. It can flip and change direction. Also unlike charge, once flipped it stays in that state. This quantum spin, as it is known, can therefore be used to store and move data. It is this spin property of electrons that is responsible for magnetism, the property currently exploited in magnetic data storage as used by tapes. Interest in the spin properties of nuclei rather than electrons would open up greater opportunities to design super quantum computers that could carry out very complex calculations currently impossible to do with existing machines. In 2030 computers will control every aspect of life. Intelligent homes will have built-in computer control systems carrying out every function, with robots doing the more arduous tasks. In home entertainment, computerized television with 3-D flat panel sets may be replaced with holographic moving image projectors. Personal micro cameras and microphones will enable images to be projected onto eyeglasses and sounds into the ear from signals received from satellite communicators. People will be able to observe objects and scenes remote from their positions — like seeing around corners or inside buildings. Satellite navigation has been established for many years, but it will become more powerful and sophisticated. Examples of the smart and intelligent systems that integrate with humans in the second half of the twenty-first century were shown in Steven Spielberg’s science fiction films Minority Report and AI. These could possibly become a reality after 2030. New revolutionary technologies-based scientific discoveries yet to be made could radically change transport systems. Japan and Germany are developing train systems based on electromagnetic levitation, known as Maglev. These trains are not in contact with the rails, so with the absence of friction, they can achieve speeds of more than 550 km/h. Their operational costs will be high, so their use could be limited. However, cheap electromagnetic propulsion systems could be developed if superconductivity could be realized at normal temperatures. A superconductor is a material that has no resistance to electric current flow below a certain critical temperature. In a closed circuit with a perfect superconductor, current will flow forever. This would mean no energy loss, hence low power costs. Could nanotechnology solve the problem by making new superconducting materials that would operate at
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 249
10/23/07 10:23:49 AM
250
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
room temperature? Most of the chemical compounds used so far only superconduct at liquid gas temperatures, which limits their use owing to the practicalities and economics of employing cryogenic systems. Molecular superconductors, including carbon nanotubes, are being studied, but at present they also only work at cryogenic temperatures. This single development would revolutionize transportation. Instead of highways filled with cars, silent, levitated hover-trains would glide around cities, and electrically driven personal carriers and walkways would transport people and goods economically anywhere. It would alter the design and landscape of cities and communities, making them look more like how science fiction has always portrayed the future. Similarly, aerospace will benefit from new discoveries as new propulsion systems and materials are developed. Nanotechnology will have to be used in the development of materials for body and engine parts and for fuels. NASA, the U.S. National Aeronautics and Space Administration, is currently developing a reusable replacement for the Space Shuttle. By 2030 this new space vehicle would have been in operation for some years, along with other commercial designs. A new type of space station will probably be in orbit to accommodate both scientific personnel and tourists. This station will also be needed to construct new space vehicles for deeper space exploration as the existing International Space Station (ISS) is not suitable for this purpose. Space exploration and space tourism will become a commercial business. An example where science fiction could become a reality is in the construction of a space elevator. A space elevator is essentially a long cable or tower extending from the Earth’s surface into space with its center of mass at geostationary Earth orbit (GEO), at an altitude of 35,000 km directly above the equator. Electromagnetic vehicles travelling along the cable could serve as a mass transportation system for moving people, payloads, and power between Earth and space. This concept was highlighted by Arthur C. Clark in 1978 in his book The Fountains of Paradise.32 At the time, this idea was dismissed as there was no technology available that could make the engineering possible. Now in the twenty-first century, developments in nanomaterials, like carbon nanotubes, increase the possibility of making such a project a reality. Robert Cassanova, director of the NASA Institute for Advanced Concepts, stated that “it’s scientifically sound and technically feasible.32” A conceptual design has been done by NASA, which is now seriously considering space elevators as a mass-transit system in the late twenty-first century or before. It will be a major international undertaking, perhaps surpassing anything that has gone before. Developments in aerospace will make “Space Planes” a reality; they will be able to take people to the space station or fly around the Earth in hours rather than days. If, as is planned by 2020, a permanent base on the moon is established, then later, maybe by 2030, travel to Mars could become a reality. Space projects such as these will advance all types of transportation systems, and a giant leap forward will be made, fulfilling many human desires and aspirations. Kurzwell6-7 believes that within the next 50 years humans and computers will combine to produce superintelligent entities. These machine-enhanced humans could be a million times more intelligent and operate a million times faster than we can today, so the unimaginable could be achieved. Alternatively, the rate of development of computer technology will produce interacting robots with high levels of artificial
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 250
10/23/07 10:23:50 AM
Shaping the Future
251
intelligence (AI). These could develop a level of human consciousness — thinking robots — that could exceed the abilities of their creators. In his science fiction story Prey,34 Michael Crichton further opened up the debate about manmade nanoparticles becoming an uncontrollable lifeforce that preys on their human creators. He uses the power of the convergence of nanotechnologhy, biotechnology, and computer technology to produce the story’s scenario. In the twenty-first century, it is just possible that artificial self-reproducing life will be created. Then we enter a new world with unknown horizons. New knowledge is helping us to understand more about life and its origins. Nanoscience is unravelling the complexity of the molecular machines that control cell division. We are close to being able to develop the technology to mimic this process then create life artificially. Before 2030 we shall be able to make new organs and repair damaged ones using stem cells and genetic engineering techniques. But the basic questions still remain to be answered. Where did we come from? Did life result from intelligent design or from the pure chance coming together of organic molecules to form molecular machines, which then replicated themselves with great precision and evolved to larger more complex machines? Will we be able to create artificial intelligence and self-replication organisms? We continue to search for the truth. Meanwhile, there is an urgent need to harness and use our knowledge to deliver a new world where everyone has hope for a better future. In this last chapter of the book, I have tried to give a realistic perspective of the near future and have taken a visionary look at some of the developments that might take place after 2030. As I stated earlier, prediction beyond 2030 becomes tainted with speculation, but it is intellectually and spiritually rewarding to speculate. If it stimulates my readers to think more about the future and what they can do to help make the good things happen, then I would have succeeded.
References
1. Feynman, R.P., There is plenty of room at the bottom, in The Pleasure of Finding Things Out, Helix Books, Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1999, pp. 117–140. 2. Drexler, E., Engines of Creation, Anchor Books, New York, 1986 and website: www. e-drexler.com. 3. Drexler, E., Nanosystems: Molecular Machinery, Manufacturing, and Computation, John Wiley & Sons, 1992, 4. Bainbridge, W.S. and Roco, M.C., Reality of Rapid Convergence, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 1093 (1), ix–xiv, 2006. 5. Pearson, I., Business 2010: Mapping the New Commercial Landscape, Spiro Press, 24 Aug 2005. 6. Kurzweil, Ray, The Age of Intelligent Machines, Viking, Penguin, 2004. 7. Kurzweil, Ray, The Singularity is Near, Viking, Penguin, 2005. 8. Canton, James, The Extreme Future, Penguin Books, 2006. 9. Jones, R. Soft Machines, Oxford University Press, 2004. 10. Institute of Alternative Futures (www.altfutures.com), The 2029 Project: Achieving an Ethical Future for Biomedical R&D, 2005. 11. Freitas, R., Nanomedicine Book Site, 2003, http://www.nanomedicine.com/. 12. European Science Foundation Report, Scientific Forward Look at Nanomedicine, February 2005, www.esf.org/publication/196/ESPB23.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 251
10/23/07 10:23:50 AM
252
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
13. Nanotechnology — Product News, Country Doctor, July 19, 2004, http://www.countrydoctor.co.uk/education/. 14. Stem Cell Research, http://stemcells.nih.gov/info/basics/. 15. Nanomaterials, http://www.nanomat.com. 16. UK Royal Society and Royal Academy of Engineering, Report on nanoscience and nanotechnologies: opportunities and uncertainties, 2004. 17. Jackson, Mark, "The future of micro- and nanomanufacturing," in Microfabrication and Nanomanufacturing, Jackson, Mark, Ed., CRC Press, Boca Raton, pp. 367–387, 2006. 18. Sinha, N., Carbon nanotubes for biomedical applications, IEEE Trans on Nanobioscience 4 (2), June 2005, www.nanotec.org.uk. 19. Murawski, F., The market for nanoelectronics, Nanotechnology Law & Business, 1 (4), 2004. 20. Moore, G., Cramming more components onto integrated circuits, Electronics Magazine, 19 April 1965. (Moore’s Law is the empirical observation made in 1965 that the number of transistors on an integrated circuit for minimum component cost doubles every 24 months.) 21. International Technology Roadmap for Semiconductors (ITRS), 2005, provided by Semiconductor Industry Association. 22. Tze-chiang Chen, Message from the vice president, science and technology, IBM research division, IBM Journal of Research and Development, Advanced Silicon Technology, 50 (4/5), 2006. 23. Research Intelligence, University of Liverpool, Business Gateway, Issue 29, August 2006, www.liverpool.ac.uk/research intelligence. 24. http://www.affymetrix.com/index.affx. 25. Smith, P., The Optical Biochip Project, Pathology Basic Technology Research Programme, Cardiff University, 2003-2007. 26. http://www.cnn.com (widely publized in the press), Jan. 1999. 27. Helmert Kaiser Consulting; Nanotechnology in Food and Food Processing Industry Worldwide, 2003–2006–2010–2015, http://www.hkc22.com/nanofood.htm. 28. IFST Report on Food Nanotechnology, 60 (11), November, 2006. 29. Weiss, J., Takhistove, P. and McClements, D., Scientific Status Summary — Materials in food nanotechnology, Journal of Food Science 71, 2006. 30. Future Global Propserity — The Terrawatt Challenge, Richard Smalley, www.mrs. org/publications/bulletin. 31. http://www.technovelgy.com/ct/science-fiction-news. 32. Clark, Arthur C., The Fountains of Paradise, Ballantine, 1978. 33. http://science.nasa.gov/headlines/y2000/ast 07sep_1.htm. 34. Crichton, M., Prey, Harper Collins, New York, 2002.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 252
10/23/07 10:23:50 AM
2
Entrepreneurship’s Role in Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products Bruce A. Kirchhoff and Steven T. Walsh
Contents Introduction............................................................................................................... 30 Folklore.......................................................................................................... 30 Two Classes of Technologies.................................................................................... 31 Evolutionary Technologies............................................................................ 31 Disruptive Technologies................................................................................ 32 Demand Pull and Technology Push Marketing Strategies....................................... 33 Technology Class Matched to Market Strategy........................................................34 Market Strategies for Evolutionary Technologies.........................................34 Market Strategies for Disruptive Technology................................................ 35 Silicon Pulling Industry: Evolutionary Technology...................................... 36 Silicon Pulling Industry: Disruptive Start-Ups............................................. 37 Examples of Disruptive Micro and Nanotechnologies............................................. 38 Micro Technology: Semiconductor Technology22......................................... 38 Nanotechnology: Gene Splicing24................................................................. 39 Sources of Disruptive Technology............................................................................40 Recommendations for Starting a New Technology Business................................... 41 Determining the Nature of Your Technology................................................ 41 Financing Technology Start-Ups................................................................... 41 Selling Your Second First Product................................................................ 43 Distribution is Frequently Complex..............................................................44 Do not Give up Your Original Product Idea.................................................. 45 Create a Team................................................................................................ 45 Do not Write a Business Plan........................................................................ 47 Summary and Conclusions....................................................................................... 48 References................................................................................................................. 48 29 © 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 29
10/23/07 10:22:05 AM
30
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
Introduction The purpose of this chapter is to examine the role of technology in new micro and nanotechnology business formations so as to debunk some misperceptions in current folklore and to suggest guidelines for starting a new technology-intensive firm. The widely believed folklore is that newly formed technology-intensive firms succeed using radically new technologies to commercialize disruptive innovations. It is argued that new technology-intensive firms are best at doing this because they have no existing customer base to please and no internal bureaucratic organization to resist change. Much credit for popularizing this concept goes to Christensen in his book The Innovators’ Dilemma.1 Although not a new concept in the academic literature, Christensen successfully brought this information to a much wider audience. We begin by discussing the current widely believed folklore and demonstrating why it is an oversimplification of reality. Next we provide descriptions of the two classes of new technologies and how these should dictate start-up market strategies. This is followed by a description of two well-known examples of disruptive technologies, one micro and one nano, that have entered world markets in the last 50 years. We use this background information to offer some guidelines for starting a micro or nanotechnology business in today’s markets.
Folklore Christensen’s hypothesis does not agree with actual experiences. The precise operating pattern that the vast majority of new technology firms use to accomplish technology commercialization is not uniform from business to business, and no clear patterns exist because each technology firm’s commercialization effort is unique; no two are exactly alike. Christensen offers this hypothesis as though most newly formed technology firms succeed using disruptive innovations. However, this is a role rarely played by the new firm. More often the invention is based upon a unique use of existing technology, and entry occurs when new firms create substitute or replacement products for the established competitive firms’ existing products/customers. This provides a quick way for the new firms to enter existing markets and achieve relatively quick profitability. Second, contrary to Christensen’s general hypothesis, major established firms’ competitive responses to new high-tech entries have historically protected the major established firms while harming the new firms that threatened existing markets. Often, some established firms respond by simply copying the new technology and forcing the new firms to sue to enforce patent rights, a procedure that often causes new firms to fail. In other situations, established firms will defensively guard existing distribution systems to constrain the new firms’ access to markets. A new paradigm has emerged in the last 20 years reducing the economically vicious competition between large established technology firms and new start-up firms as envisioned in Christensen’s hypothesis. Many major corporations are now acquiring or licensing the intellectual property of new technology firms that have developed products based on radically different technologies than those possessed by the major firms.2 This acquisition process appeals to these acquiring firms because it may be a less expensive way to acquire new technology or simply a speedy way
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 30
10/23/07 10:22:05 AM
Entrepreneurship in Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
31
to enter new markets — or both. This seems to indicate a growing awareness of the value of innovations brought to the market by new technology firms. This has been true in the micro and nanotechnology fields. Thus, new technology firms have discovered new operating procedures that promise better results. Rather than threatening the existing major firms in a given market, the ambitious firms seek to partner with or become a part of a major firm that takes on the marketing of the product. Still, some new firms continue to independently struggle and achieve success. Behind this complex appearance of new technology firm behavior lay some fundamental principles based upon technology management theory developed over the last 30 years that not only describes the role of new technology firms but also prescribes the appropriate methods that lead to their success. The following sections begin by summarizing the theory of technological inventions as developed by academic authors over the last 30 years. Two classes of inventions have evolved from this theory based primarily on two different science sources. In addition, we provide an example of successful micro and nanotechnology firms in both classes. Then, we describe the two major methods of marketing matching the two classes of technology where each method offers different opportunities and threats. Lastly, we provide some guidelines for high-tech start-ups that emerge from an analysis of how these theories can be implemented for survival and profitability.
Two Classes Of Technologies Herein we use the term innovation as has been widely used in management of technology literature. An innovation is the commercialization of an invention. An invention is a new idea or a new combination of existing ideas. In high-tech companies, the invention embodies one of two classes of technology defined in the last 20 years. The academic research literature has agreed that there are two classes of technology: (1) evolutionary, sustaining, incremental or “nuts and bolts” technologies; or alternatively (2) disruptive, radical, emergent or step-function technologies. For simplicity in this chapter, we use the terms evolutionary and disruptive.
Evolutionary Technologies Evolutionary technologies might be described as “business as usual” with a continuous flow of technical inventions emerging from R&D based upon the supplier’s core technical competencies and/or from customers’ suggestions or requests. Evolutionary technologies, also referred to as incremental, sustaining, competence enhancing or “nuts and bolts” technologies, build off of the existing body of knowledge with respect to production capabilities and manufacturing or processing practices and as such have known performance levels and forms of application.3,4 Technologies can originate either inside or outside an industry. Those that originate inside are said to be based upon “core competencies” of corporations in the industry as defined by Prahalad and Hamel.5 The basis for technology is the organizations’ core competencies that evolve into a stream of “continuous innovations” that are delivered to customers as either replacements or substitutes for existing products or as new
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 31
10/23/07 10:22:05 AM
32
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
or greatly improved products. These two product categories are driven by different customer interests and different marketing strategies as discussed below. Replacement or substitute products are those that customers knowingly request to meet their needs, improve their operations, reduce costs, increase the quality of their product, or to produce a competitive advantage in their markets. Major new or greatly improved products are not knowingly requested by customers and do not meet needs that are known to the customers. Thus, although one dominant technology underlies the inventions, the technology’s evolution over time offers the opportunity to invent products for which there are ready buyers or create new inventions that satisfy customer needs that are not apparent to the buyer.
Disruptive Technologies Disruptive technologies frequently find their origins in new science, most of which emerges from academic or corporate R&D or independent scientific research. Schumpeter6 observed that innovations with major impact upon economic activity originate from outside the industry that they affect. Schumpeter also argues that these innovations emerge from and become the reason for the formation of new independent firms, i.e., entrepreneurship. To the extent that Schumpeterian product innovations are technology based, he argues that new independent firms are well suited to bring innovations from outside the existing industry structure and creatively destroy the market structure therein.7 Schumpeter’s observations agree with those of more recent theorists. Abernathy and Utterbach8 state that such technologies are built upon new knowledge and/or new manufacturing practices and are applied to create entirely new product-market paradigms that are often opaque to potential buyers. Further, Anderson, and Tushman,9 evolve from Abernathy and Clark10 and others discussing an “era of ferment” when new technology product paradigms are vying to become the industry dominant design. Bohn11 notes that measuring and managing these technologies is difficult. Bower and Christensen12 further expand this definition with the statement that technology is considered disruptive when its utility generates service products or physical products with different performance attributes that may not be valued by existing customers. Such technologies are applied to create entirely new productmarket paradigms that are often opaque to potential buyers.13 Commercialization products derived from disruptive technologies are frequently referred to as “radical or discontinuous innovations.” Academic research that develops new science sometimes results in the academic researchers starting new companies to invent and commercialize new products and services. And some new science originates in the R&D departments of major corporations. These are sometimes not wanted by the founding corporation and are rejected for development within the major firms and frequently are either licensed or spun off to new technology firms. The technology founders are sometimes encouraged to or willingly leave their employers to pursue their new science into a product invention. As with evolutionary technologies, disruptive technologies can create innovations that provide two categories of products: replacement or substitute. However, neither category of these is fully recognized by buyers as beneficial to their interests.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 32
10/23/07 10:22:06 AM
Entrepreneurship in Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
33
Moore14 states that this customer negative evaluation aspect of disruptive technologies by noting that these technologies generate discontinuous innovations that require users/adopters to change their behavior in order to make use of the innovation. As such, disruptive technologies often require that buyers change their behavior or thinking so to be able to use the products to which the innovations are applied effectively. Inventions that are entirely new products requiring user change behavior are not initially recognized by buyers as being beneficial at all. Commercializing these inventions can be very difficult due to this buyer change behavior no matter how strong the new value proposition is either in a personal or an organizational setting. To overcome buyer/user resistance to adopting disruptive technologies, producers of such innovations must demonstrate that such technologies provide significant cost reductions and/or performance improvements. In this way, customers are found who are willing to take the risks of newness. These totally new inventions based on new science and disruptive technologies are what Schumpeter calls “creative destroyers.” By his definition, such innovations are so radical that they destroy existing markets and the dominant firms that supply these markets, replacing them with entirely new markets and firms based on new technology.15
Demand Pull and Technology Push Marketing Strategies Along with two classes of technology, there are also two types of marketing strategies for new technology products as frequently noted in the academic literature. Demand pull marketing is widely recognized and finds its theoretical underpinnings in the writings of economists over many years. Most recently, economic researchers have described this type of marketing as “opportunity recognition.” One definition of opportunity recognition is that entrepreneurs earn profits as a result of success in finding and exploiting perceived opportunities in the market.16 This definition has found reinforcement in the work of Kirzner,17 who suggests that alertness to opportunities in the marketplace and acting quickly to exploit the void in buyers’ needs is the entrepreneur’s chance to earn temporary excess profits. Kirzner’s theory basically argues that entrepreneurs must discover opportunities where demand exists for the technological innovations they have. In other words, it is demand by an existing unsatisfied buyer that creates the opportunity in the market. Technology push marketing finds its origin in Schumpeter,18 who argues that the primary driver of the economy is innovation. Innovation comes from an entrepreneur’s intrinsic drive to innovate. This intrinsic drive results in the introduction of new products and services different from those in the marketplace. He argues that unique new products are often created without a well-defined market. Thus, contrary to demand pull theory, technology push market strategy emerges from the technology itself. This dichotomy of demand pull/technology push is frequently found in the academic literature. However, few entrepreneurs use purely one or the other. Thus, although described here as a dichotomy, they are really two ends of a continuum where reality is somewhere in between. Nonetheless, we will argue herein that a
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 33
10/23/07 10:22:06 AM
34
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
technology entrepreneur’s choice of market strategy along the continuum should depend on the type of technology that underlies the product or service invention.
Technology Class Matched to Market Strategy Market strategies need to be matched to the class of technology present in a product invention. This matching is shown diagrammatically in Figures 2.1 and 2.2. First is evolutionary technology; second is disruptive technology.
Market Strategies for Evolutionary Technologies Putting the technology class together with market strategy yields an interesting set of relationships. Beginning with evolutionary technology, Figure 2.1 shows how this technology based on known science produces a continuous flow of innovations that can either be buyer pulled or technology pushed. Core competencies are a foundation for developing evolutionary technologies. Evolutionary technologies are used to create continuous innovations that are then used for replacement/substitute products or alternatively new or major improvement products. Notice that when buyers’ needs are well known, an appropriate technology invention can be created with evolving technology that can meet the known demand. Thus, the invention can be targeted to specific buyers and can be “buyer pulled” into the customer’s hands. However, when the buyer’s needs are identified by the supplier but not well known by the buyer, it will be necessary to technology push the invention by offering it as a major improvement or a new product that can produce a competitive advantage for the customer, such as increased quality or decreased costs. The definition of the uniqueness of the evolutionary technology is essential but usually easy to determine. Typically, for buyer pull market strategy, the potential buyer is a well-known customer and approaches a firm’s sales department requesting some kind of new product of major improvement associated with an existing product or service the firm previously provided. Your response is to apply your core competence technology to produce the desired invention, which the customer then buys. Identifying an invention that is truly unique will involve somewhat greater difficulty. Typically, this invention emerges from R&D based on an evolution in the firm’s core competency technology. While it shows potential for application to Technology Source
Firm Core Competencies
Technology Focus
Evolutionary
Innovation Type
Continuous
Market Strategies
User Application Type
Market Pull
Replacement or Substitute
Technology Push
New or Major Improvement
Figure 2.1 Evolutionary technology commercialization model.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 34
10/23/07 10:22:07 AM
Entrepreneurship in Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
35
existing customers, some market research by your sales personnel will be required to learn more about your customers and identify their existing need that is not currently in the forefront of their thinking. Then your sales force is challenged to make the customers desire to add this invention to his current list of needs and eventually buy the invention. This invention can be sold on the basis of major improvements in quality or significant reductions in costs. Either of these results will give your customer a strategic advantage in competitive markets. This is the essence of technology push market strategy and should be the major work of well-trained sales professionals. In the section above, we provide an example of a start-up business that used well-known science to create a new unique product that potential buyers needed. Dialogic Corporation started with one scientist and two experienced technical marketing/managing professionals. The two industry-experienced team members saw the potential need for a unique invention derived from known technology, and they teamed with the scientist to create the invention that became their first product. Subsequently, they were able to create a major company in their chosen field with significant financial success for all three founders.
Market Strategies for Disruptive Technology Selecting a radical innovation product and matching it with the appropriate marketing strategy requires more serious thought. As shown in Figure 2.2, much like evolutionary technology, the market strategies are technology push and market pull. However, whenever possible, it is desirable to choose inventions that can appeal to the potential customers so that buyer pull marketing can be used. The reason is that technology push for radical innovations is far more complex and time consuming than for continuous innovations. Typically the start-up does not have the established customer relationships, and the potential customers will recognize that the innovation will require major behavioral change. And behavioral change of this type is commonly traumatic and undesirable. Thus, it may take years before the first sale is achieved. Many start-up technology firms begin with a new technology that will create radical innovations that will be a hard sell to potential buyers. Unless such firms have major financial investments or are personally wealthy, they are at great risk of business failure. For example, Genentech formed the first gene splicing pharmaceutical company by embracing a new science. Genentech attempted to find buyer Technology Source
Technology Focus
Innovation Type
New Science
Disruptive
Radical
Market Strategies
User Application Type
Technology Push
Creative Destroying
Market Pull
Replacement or Substitute
Figure 2.2 Disruptive technology commercialization model.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 35
10/23/07 10:22:07 AM
36
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
acceptance of substitute and replacement products with only modest success. Since Genentech had raised $35 million with the public sale of stock in 1980, it persevered and eventually after 12 years finally scored with a truly new innovation that provided the basis for major growth in its revenues and profits.19 In today’s economic environment, it may be possible to identify other suppliers that already provide products to those buyers who are likely candidates for your disruptive technology products. One or more of these suppliers may be willing to form an agreement with a start-up firm that is pursuing a disruptive technology that is interesting. This has become especially common in the biopharmaceutical industry where technology sharing among established industry members and new firms is becoming very common. This is a possible way of gaining financial assistance that will allow a long-term project to commercialize a disruptive technology. On the other hand, if you have start-up team members who have established customer relationships with potential buyers, then you have an advantage to use your technology with a buyer pull strategy. The team members with customer contacts become the major mechanism to identify buyer needs for products that can be substitutes or replacements for products that these potential buyers already own. Substitutes and replacements have to demonstrate significant quality improvements or cost reductions to close the sale. This is the quickest way to assure survival and become profitable. However, no doubt you would prefer to see a more unique invention that will take advantage of your technology’s major advantages for applications that seemingly need major improvements. It is a long hard pull, however, to bring a disruptive technology into successful products that provide profitable operations. It is better to take the quick route to survival and profitability before switching your attention to your “dream product.” But keep your dream, for you may be able to afford the challenge of creating profitable operations with the dream product in the future. It will take years to bring the dream invention into a profitable product and creatively destroy the established market structure. It took Intel 10 years from the development of the 4004 microprocessor in 1971 to the 8086 that became the big product in 1981. It took another 13 to 14 years for the microprocessor to creatively destroy the established computer industry. And this happened only because a large number of other technologies interacted with the microprocessor — software and hardware — as it evolved into a creative destroying product.
Silicon Pulling Industry: Evolutionary Technology Our research has developed a major example drawn from research on the silicon pulling industry. Newbert, Kirchhoff, and Walsh completed a study of the independent new firms formed in the semiconductor silicon pulling industry worldwide from 1953 through 1989. Semiconductor silicon is well known as a major microtechnology raw material.20 Our research looks solely at the newly formed independent firms. Six of the thirty-two start-up firms in our study of semiconductor silicon pulling were first to adopt newly marketed technologies and successfully beat the major suppliers to the market with the new technology. In all cases, these firms were started by individuals who had existing contacts with one or more of the current buyers in the industry. In
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 36
10/23/07 10:22:08 AM
Entrepreneurship in Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
37
addition, the newest technology was recently introduced in the industry, and their entry can be described as “early followers.” Since these firms knew the industry buyers, and buyers knew the new technology, they used buyer pull with minor technology push market strategy. This worked well as they acquired market share quickly before major firms entered this market. This combination of new technology with demand pull and minor technology push strategic marketing used by these six startup firms resulted in four of them becoming very successful and the other two modestly successful. All survived or were acquired by larger firms at a profit.
Silicon Pulling Industry: Disruptive Start-Ups On the other hand, firms that introduced the radically new inventions had little knowledge of the current buyers. Lack of knowledge of the market required that these companies emphasize technology push with minor buyer pull marketing strategy. Of the seven firms that used this strategy to sell radically new technologies, one failed with losses after 12 years, another performed poorly and failed after nine years, three performed modestly, and two performed very well and survive today. One of these successes remains independent, and one was acquired by a larger corporation. Three of the seven firms initiated the “float zone process,” a major radical technology change that received weak acceptance in the market. One of these was the poor performer that eventually failed, and the two others are still alive and profitable but with specialized, niche market products. The experience of the seven creative, very early entry firms are typical of those start-ups that bring disruptive technologies into existing industries. On the other hand, these seven firms entered the market by introducing new evolutionary technologies that they developed through research and development. They based their effort on the supposition that the buyers in the industry would want to buy this new technology. However, new, radical innovations were not widely accepted by the buyers who resisted the turmoil of adopting a new technology that would require major new investment and operating changes. Thus, these very early entry suppliers found considerable resistance to their product offerings for several years and were not as financially successful as the early followers of this new technology. In other words, these seven firms that created and introduced radical inventions drawn from disruptive technologies were not the major benefactors of the new technologies’ commercialization. The early followers with the stronger marketing knowledge achieved the greater benefits. It appears from this information that the market pull strategy augmented with a technology push component was more successful than technology push strategy augmented with only a minor market pull emphasis. This finding is true for new, independent firm entries into the silicon pulling industry prior to 1990.21 It is important to note that these findings are presented to make our point about market strategies and may not apply to other industries in other time periods. Next, we focus on both evolutionary and disruptive technologies as we look at the past and future of micro and nanotechnologies.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 37
10/23/07 10:22:08 AM
38
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
Examples of Disruptive Micro and Nanotechnologies It is relatively easy to identify micro and nanotechnologies that fit the definitions of disruptive and evolutionary — historically they are defined in terms of subsequent events. Forecasting which technologies will qualify as disruptive with radical innovations is very difficult since the definitions themselves are presented in the form of an examination of the technology’s impact on the buyers and the markets. For example, in hindsight, the invention of the transistor and its disruptive nature is clearly evident now, almost 60 years later. However, it seems obvious that this was not recognized until after the invention of the integrated circuit and then the programmable microprocessor. Also, one can say that the nanotechnology discovery of the makeup of the human genetic code is a disruptive technology. But, this did not become a reality until the early 1990s and has not reached its full potential for disrupting the pharmaceutical industry even today. In the following two sections, we explore the transistor and the human genetic code as two examples of disruptive technology.
Micro Technology: Semiconductor Technology22 Semiconductor technology was invented in 1947 at Bell Laboratories. The fundamental technology was a new understanding of the physical properties of silicon — quantum physics. This new science had all the characteristics to become a disruptive innovation. As time passed, its disruptive characteristics became apparent. The transistor became a production product in 1949 and was used solely for telephone switching, the purpose for which it was invented. Gradually, the transistor evolved into a substitute for vacuum tubes in electronic equipment — pull out a vacuum tube and put in a transistor. Radios were first. In 1958, Texas Instruments invented and patented the integrated circuit, a major improvement on the transistor but still relying on the physical properties of semiconductor silicon. In 1968, a newly formed firm — Intel Corporation — began to manufacture memory chips (integrated circuits). In 1969, Intel received an order from a Japanese company, Busicom, to make an integrated circuit chip that could be programmed to do many, many different math functions. Ted Hoff realized that it would be more interesting and efficient to do this with a programmable microprocessor. Hoff completed the semiconductor chip in 1971, but Busicom lost interest. Still, the first microprocessor, the Intel 4004, was made available for sale. Programmable processors found a small market in mainframe computers that used them to operate peripheral equipment commanded by the mainframe. Hobbyists also found them interesting. There was no big profitable business. Still, the microprocessor technology spread among several new start-up companies, including Zilog. Then in 1977 (30 years after the invention of the transistor), Apple Computer (a newly formed independent firm) introduced the mass market to these devices by adding a keyboard and some additional components to a Zilog Z-80 processor. Most important of all, Apple established a retail distribution system to sell these computers. Evolution has taken this science of quantum physics and created the microcomputer that has changed the lives of people everywhere and creatively destroyed all but one of the major computer manufacturers that dominated the computer manufacturing industry through the 1990s.23 However it took 40 years for this “quantum
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 38
10/23/07 10:22:08 AM
Entrepreneurship in Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
39
physics, semiconductor technology” to be identified as a truly disruptive technology. And a great deal of evolutionary technology was added over the 40 years to achieve this. But note the important key roles played by newly formed technology firms: Fairchild, Intel, Zilog, Apple, Osborne, Compaq, and Gateway, Dell, Microsoft, Lotus, Novel, etc. Not all survived, but each added a component to the technology evolutionary process. Some of these were marketing and distribution innovations, but each was built upon inventions of other start-up technologies developed by firms that created hard drives, component designs, software, etc. So we can credit major industry and market changes on the science of quantum physics that made silicon a special material in 1947. Still, this technology would have been nothing without the evolutionary technologies — most of which originated from newly formed technology firms.
Nanotechnology: Gene Splicing24 Currently, the healthcare industry is undergoing an explosion of new treatments, products, and processes based upon gene splicing (now termed biotechnology). This began with the discovery of the science of gene splicing technology in 1974. A twoyear-old start-up company named Genentech decided to be the first to enter this area of technology in 1976. With much fanfare, in 1980, it was able to obtain considerable investment capital based primarily on the development of one biological compound (with no real market) and speculation about the promise of gene splicing technology. However, the technology did not produce products that created the majority of its revenues until 1987. As early as 1980, Genentech’s technology yielded products that were as good as existing products (for example, its first human growth hormone), but these products did not have the improvement in quality or reduction in price that made them attractive to the majority of buyers. Genentech relied upon licensing fees for its first two products and did not begin marketing its own product until 1985. In 1988, Genentech for the first time reported more revenues from product sales than from contract research and returns on invested capital. Commercialization of gene splicing became the major contributor to sales in Genetech’s 12th year and 14 years after discovery of gene splicing science. By the late 1990s, a host of newly founded gene splicing companies appeared. All of these took advantage of the fundamental research discoveries that evolved the technology. But interestingly, the major pharmaceutical companies continued to focus on chemistry and made little attempt to enter the biological field until after 2000. This allowed the gene splicing companies to gain an advantage, especially in oncology (cancer treatment). So, by 1996, 22 years after the discovery of gene splicing, the industry begins to produce products that are superior to those offered by the chemistry-based pharmaceutical companies. And the path to technology adoption has included and still does include many newly formed firms. Currently, the new firm phenomenon continues but now in the form of research organizations with alliances to the major firms that have established the market distribution systems. Alternatively, new firms are formed with plans to create a product that will make the firm attractive for acqui-
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 39
10/23/07 10:22:08 AM
40
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
sition by a major firm. Now, the chemical pharmaceutical companies are buying some of these new firms.
Sources of Disruptive Technology Not all disruptive technologies originate in new start-up firms. Bell Labs and the transistor is an example of a large firm producing and profiting from a disruptive technology. Keep in mind that the transistor was invented after 13 years of Bell Laboratories’ research for a reliable replacement for the mechanical switching system, a system that was widely used to replace telephone operators. Its nearly instant commercialization is attributed to the anxiously waiting AT&T telephone market.25 New firms have a vital role in the evolution of disruptive technologies into major markets. Newly formed firms carry out much of the technological evolution from the transistor to microprocessor. Many of these grew up in Silicon Valley, and many were at least partially financed by NASA R&D in its effort to find reliable, lightweight electronics equipment for space travel. Few commercial products emerged directly from the NASA research, but the research advanced the technology that became staples of the commercial products a few years later.26 Customer resistance to radical innovations based on new science means that the sales effort needed to launch a truly disruptive innovation can be very expensive and time consuming. Genentech, based upon belief of the radical new technology of gene splicing, raised $35 million in investor capital in 1980. Such large sums early in the life of a start-up can easily carry a firm through the early product development process. If you have this kind of venture capital backing, you can also do this with a disruptive technology. However, few new technology ventures are able to obtain capital of this magnitude. That is why evolutionary technology is the mainstay of new technology firms. This approach needs to be emphasized when searching for venture financing. New science directed into replacement or substitute products that do not involve major customer behavior changes are much easier and less costly to sell. Intel did not capitalize on the microprocessor it invented until Apple demonstrated the value of the microcomputer. Then, Intel entered with the microprocessor as a better processor in response to IBM’s defined need for building and selling microcomputers in a market that was five years into its expansion phase. By then, Intel had the advantage of 11 years of technology evolution to respond to this buyer’s needs. Genentech’s survival for 11 years without a major successful product is indicative of what a relatively new firm can do with a disruptive technology when it has plenty of venture capital. However, it did take 12 years for its gene-spliced products to become its major income generator. Disruptive technologies take time to develop profitable markets if they are used to market radical innovations using technology push market strategies.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 40
10/23/07 10:22:09 AM
Entrepreneurship in Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
41
Recommendations for Starting a New Technology Business There are many books and magazines in libraries and elsewhere that explain how to start a business. Not many are directed to the technology entrepreneur. Here are some differences that set the high-tech start-up apart from all those books and magazines. These recommendations emerge directly from the technology discussion above. And each of these is discussed in the following sections. First, when starting a new firm, make an effort to determine if your technology is evolutionary or disruptive. Second, do not expect major financing from outside investors. Third, do not be dismayed if your first product does not receive acceptance from your first few potential customers. Fourth, find out how similar products are distributed to customers. Fifth, do not discard your ideas for the eventual use of your disruptive technology. Sixth, create an entrepreneurial team early in the development of your start-up. Last, do not bother spending a lot of time writing and rewriting a business plan; this may work for a coffee shop or a package express company, but it is not for new high-tech businesses — unless you really need someone else’s money to begin the business.
Determining the Nature of Your Technology As evident above, there are significant differences in new firm success determined by the nature of the technology. Disruptive technologies based on new science meet substantial customer resistance and require considerable time, effort, and money to obtain the first sale and enough sales revenue to survive long enough to become profitable. Evolutionary products are usually easy to identify since these are built upon a known technology, not new science. Often, the evolutionary aspect will be obvious if you can clearly identify potential customers who will need your product. Self-assessment of a technology is unlikely to be done without prejudice in favor of the scientist’s views of the technology. Technologies become the favorite subject of the inventor and bias every discussion. It is best to try the invention on some knowledgeable persons. One way is to find a no-cost source of an assessment of the invention. Many universities or incubators have technology assessment procedures. Also, ask technology-savvy friends, relatives, or colleagues. Ideally, you know someone who works for one or more potential buyers, and a properly directed inquiry will gain useful information.
Financing Technology Start-Ups Obtaining borrowed money from a bank or other lending institutions is impossible unless (1) personal assets (house, paid-up insurance policy, etc.) can be pledged as collateral or (2) until the business has at least three to five years of profitable operation. Many entrepreneurs do not know this when they start. They usually try to obtain loans from banks and are depressed when they learn that they cannot. The rejection that is received is not because of the invention idea or the character of the individual(s) involved in the start-up. The lender simply is a risk-adverse institution that is lending someone else’s (depositors) money in the face of strict government regulations. And that collateral mentioned above—that borrowed money obtained as
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 41
10/23/07 10:22:09 AM
42
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
proceeds from a second mortgage or other personal assets—is personally borrowed money. The borrower must repay this money, and the firm has no obligation to pay. Firm failure or bankruptcy means the borrower must repay the debt. Contrary to what some law firms advertise, forming a corporation is no protection from this personal liability to repay borrowed money. Lenders will always require entrepreneurs to sign personally for borrowed money. Ask an accountant about this. Although not as risk adverse, venture capitalists in all but Silicon Valley and, more recently, Boston are very, very reluctant to invest in a technology start-up that has no cash sales booked.27 Real booked sales confirm the value of the product and company. And, few venture capitalists have the enthusiasm for the invented product until it has passed the test of actually being sold. Applying for and receiving competitively determined government research funding can generate interest among venture capitalists. Sometimes, but not often, investors will carefully examine start-ups that have received research money from a government agency because the funding suggests that outside experts consider the technology to be valuable. The primary source of research money from the U.S. government is the Small Business Innovation Research Program (SBIR).28 The SBIR program is federal legislation that requires 13 agencies of the U.S. government to spend 3% of their extramural R&D budget with small businesses. Each agency issues requests for proposals (RFP) for research that are competitively evaluated on technological quality. The funding, when received, allows all rights to the intellectual property to remain with the small business. In other words, this is investment capital for which you never issue shares of your firm or pay back. In addition, venture capitalists prefer to see a firm receive both first- and second-stage SBIR grants for research on a specific technology. Venture capitalists evaluate this as stronger evidence of the value of the technology. Other countries in the European Union have similar programs modeled, to a degree, upon the SBIR program in the U.S. It is worthwhile to check on the availability of such programs. Given the risk associated with new technology, start-up financing is rare for new technology firms. Without major outside financing, personal resources and those of the start-up team members, friends, or family will be necessary to start the business. A stream of cash income flow from product sales will not develop for at least 12 months. Even if the first sales are made quickly, they are likely to be made on a “pay later if you are satisfied with it” basis. This can delay the receipt of cash for as much as 4 or 5 months. In addition, few technology startups develop a product that sells within 6 to 12 months. Many steps are required to generate the first sale. Starting a technology firm is an expensive experience. Most successful technology entrepreneurs develop the technology, obtain an assessment of the technology, file a patent application, and create a prototype before they leave their paying jobs. When the firm is first started, examine the cash that is available to the business and determine how long it will last. If it is not enough to last at least 12 months, find more cash investment. Frequently, neither you nor members of your start-up team will draw a salary from this business until many sales begin and collections are made.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 42
10/23/07 10:22:09 AM
Entrepreneurship in Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
43
Selling Your Second First Product Market research is much more complex than it may appear. As suggested above, potential customers are contacted, the technology is described, and drawings, sketches, or definitions of the product and its actions will be presented to seek the potential customers’ approval of the new venture. The meeting will likely go well, but little useful information on the potential customer’s real interest will be obtained. It is very difficult to obtain accurate information in an interview when the presenter is enthusiastic about the invention. If the entrepreneur presents a persuasive argument, the potential customer will undoubtedly agree that this is a great product idea that should be pursued and offered in finished form when the first product is produced. What this means is that few people will argue with anyone who persuasively argues an issue. Most of us are socially conditioned to avoid arguments with other people of casual acquaintance. Pushing the other person to agree causes agreement simply to avoid arguing. Furthermore, the potential buyer probably does not fully understand the technology since it exists as a real, understandable thing only in the mind of the entrepreneur. Diagrams, equations, sample computer code, and other technological information will not adequately convey the technology. To understand a real technological concept, most of us need to see the product that has the technology imbedded in it. So a prototype is necessary. Do not underestimate the complexity of your technology and its inclusion in a new product. Market research done without a prototype is unlikely to solicit meaningful information. No matter how much market research is conducted, only the presentation of a prototype will elicit meaningful responses. The prototype gives the viewer understanding of exactly what the technology is. So with a prototype, approach one or more potential customers. If the potential customer simple agrees with your presentation and promises to look into your technology at another undefined time, the customer does not understand your technology and does not want to understand. If the potential customers begin to debate about the claims for the product, it means they are interested. The lack of the potential customers’ agreement combined with responses stating that this is not a product they can use may well lead to their suggestion that this technology could create a different product that they could use. The reason for this is that the prototype gives them understanding about the technology and stimulates their thinking about how it might meet their needs. Thus, if the prototype is successful in demonstrating the technology and if the potential customers understand and are interested, they can creatively imagine another, different product built from this technology that could solve some problem they have today. If three or more potential customers suggest the same product idea, they have defined your saleable product. That is a good job of market research. Pause and think, but build a new prototype that meets the specifications that they have described. This “second product experience” is so common among the technology start-up firms we have known that we always discuss it with neophyte technology start-up firms. This extends to software development firms — perhaps more to them than product firms. We refer to it as “How to achieve success with your second first product.” We have never found a way to avoid the second first product problem (or opportunity).
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 43
10/23/07 10:22:10 AM
44
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
One way to avoid the second first product problem is to acquire a team member that has been selling similar products to the same customers you are targeting. Even though this is one possible way, it does not always work; however, it is worth a try. For example, in 1983 a Ph.D. physicist joined with two salesmen to form Dialogic, Inc. The salesmen worked for two different suppliers selling equipment and parts to telephone switching equipment manufacturers. Telephone answering systems were becoming more popular and doing more complex functions. The salesmen thought they knew a major problem with the existing answering systems. The scientist recognized that a piece of sophisticated hardware could replace some complex software and provide a faster more responsive answering system. Since they knew the customers and knew their needs, this should be a snap. They began product development using existing technology and completed a finished model in one year. But, when they approached customers, they received the response that this was not exactly what was wanted. Instead of a single-line answering system, customers wanted a multi-line system. After 6 more months of R&D, Dialogic introduced its second first product, and sales took off. It seems that sometimes even the most experienced and knowledgeable persons still need a second first product. However, they would have been successful earlier if they had taken a prototype around to their customers first. Dialogic went public in 1994 and was wholly acquired by Intel in 1999. Needless to say, the founders benefited financially.
Distribution is Frequently Complex One question that should be asked of potential customers in early discussions is how similar products are distributed to the potential customers. Distribution is often more complex than most technology entrepreneurs are able to imagine. Typically, technology products are not sold to consumers. They are sold to other manufacturers who sell to consumers. For example, computer hard drives are not sold directly to the vast majority of consumers; instead, they are sold to computer manufacturers. Thus, all the knowledge you may have acquired about selling consumer products is useless. We have experience with several medical device manufactures. The industry is characterized by devices that are installed by doctors in hospitals or outpatient clinics run like hospitals. One entrepreneur assumed he would be successful by having salespersons call directly on the doctors, similar to Avon or other house-to-house sales techniques. But there are thousands of doctors. Think of the cost of creating such a massive sales force. The entrepreneur thought it would be possible to reach these doctors by advertising on TV. This is very expensive advertising that is trying to reach a small and unique population of doctors who watch relatively little TV. The largest pharmaceutical firms have large sales forces, but these firms are selling multiple products that only doctors can prescribe. This type of technology marketing to other firms is quite common, and distribution systems exist. It is desirable to define the distribution system by which products similar to yours are delivered to buyers. For this inventor’s product, a team of our students began by contacting the purchasing manager of the university’s hospital. By questioning hospital purchasing personnel and a few doctors, the team discovered a very complex system involving
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 44
10/23/07 10:22:10 AM
Entrepreneurship in Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
45
individual doctor evaluation and approval, hospital committee evaluation and approval, and then a purchasing organization that buys this type of product only from a cooperative distribution organization that services many hospitals. And, the cooperative distributor buys individual products from other distributors. In other words, the medical devices these companies made are not bought directly by doctors. Normally, doctors and hospital staffs make the purchase decision, but actual hospital purchases are made through 2 or 3 levels of distributors. This complex distribution system is a major barrier (or opportunity) for selling medical devices to the healthcare industry. In our experience, few medical device start-ups know this complexity exists. And many of these start-ups have products that are practical, evolutionary technology inventions that could save lives or improve the quality of life of patients. Other industries have similar complexities. Knowing the name, telephone number, and location of the individual who makes the buying decision is very important. And if that individual is in a large corporation, it can take years of sales visits to identify the proper processes and people that will buy this type of new product. Any salesperson who has gone through this process knows the difficulty of finding the buyer in a large firm. With new products, the common way to obtain sales is to identify a firm that already distributes products to those whom you believe will be buyers of your product. Then find a salesperson in that distributor’s organization that knows who, where, and how your potential customers buy your kind of product. Then negotiate and sign an agreement with the distributor to handle your product for a percentage of the sales price. The names of distributors can usually be found in trade journals. Personal relationships are vital in selling new products. Knowing who, what, where, and when is of great value. This is why venture capitalists prefer to invest in companies that can list probable buyers of an entrepreneur’s product, including names, titles, and telephone numbers of these probable buyers. The venture capitalist makes a few telephone calls to some of these names and determines if you really know these people. If you do, your firm’s stock value is pushed higher.
Do not Give up Your Original Product Idea These same personal relationships can be used to launch the product of your dreams. Somewhere after sales of the second first product are progressing well, congenial, collegial relationships have been established with many customers. Now is the time to rethink the original radical innovation and build the first prototype updated over time by the evolution of the technology. Now, since the customers have confidence in the products and personnel of the firm, one or more may be willing to give the radical innovation a try — especially if it will provide a competitive advantage for their business. Then your dream product will become a major factor in creatively destroying the established market structure.
Create a Team A one-person start-up technology company is a rarity in today’s world. Realistically, starting and managing a technology business is far more complex than a new retail
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 45
10/23/07 10:22:10 AM
46
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
store, restaurant, auto repair shop, or a consulting business. It is the rare individual who has all the specialized knowledge and skills that are required to start a technology business. And, money is harder to attain since there are only a limited number of people who will believe in your technology’s promise of future success and profits. The head entrepreneur must assess his/her knowledge, skills, and experience to determine what specializations are missing. Then, the entrepreneur must find persons who possess those missing specializations. Below is a list of the key people that should be in the start up team. R&D: A strong technical specialist who can carry on the R&D work of converting technology into saleable products is essential. Marketing: At first glance, distribution systems can appear to be very complex, but in reality they are not complex if you have a team member who knows the market and the potential buyers you are targeting. Try to obtain an experienced marketing professional with knowledge of the industries that you believe are most likely to contain potential customers. Manufacturing: Manufacturing a prototype and bringing it to actual production-level manufacturing requires special skills, so an experienced manufacturing manager makes a useful addition to your team. Human resources: The process of hiring, firing, and compensating employees is fraught with major issues such as taxes, social security, healthcare benefits, and antidiscrimination and handicap access laws. And the process of selecting employees can be very challenging. A team member with experience in human resources can be worth a lot in avoiding the sinkholes in employee regulations and laws and selecting the proper employees. Finance: Private accountants can be hired by the hour, but the complexity of guiding and operating a business requires much more than an accountant. A financial specialist is the person who plans and executes the steps necessary for survival and eventually profitability. You need a team of 3 to 6 competent people to start a new technology firm. Chief executive officer/manager: Management is an important skill. A professional experienced manager is valuable. This is why most venture capitalists install their own experienced CEO when they invest in a technology firm. This is a very important part of the team. In fact, the initial team may consist of fewer specialists by using outside organizations. Human resources can be acquired by using an employee leasing firm. Rather than hiring employees (non-ownership participants are employees), you lease them from the leasing firm. This gives you a zero employee firm since owners are not employees under U.S. law. This is different in some European Union nations. In addition, you need a certified public accountant, a patent attorney, and a business attorney. Also, there are many accounting firms that will not only keep your books but also provide management information reports (different than the accounting data routinely provided by accountants) and consult about the firm’s finances. A manufacturing manager need not be hired if you sub-contract all manufacturing to a reliable manufacturing company. The choice of this manufacturer is critical, and it may be desirable to hire an experienced manufacturing specialist to assist in choosing a firm to do your manufacturing.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 46
10/23/07 10:22:10 AM
Entrepreneurship in Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
47
That leaves the founding team as three persons: a CEO, a technical R&D expert, and a marketing specialist. The technical expert frequently is the lead entrepreneur and takes the CEO role. You will notice that Dialogic began with two technical sales engineers and a Ph.D. physicist. The Ph.D. shared the CEO responsibilities with the two technical marketing experts. After 3 years of profitability, the team hired an experienced CEO.
Do not Write a Business Plan Every book, radio and TV program, and magazine on entrepreneurship states emphatically that an entrepreneur begins a new business by writing a business plan. However what is the purpose of a business plan? Most planners will tell you it is important for a business organization to have clear goals and objectives to know where it is going and to communicate this to the employees. Only in this way can the firm be sure that all members of the organization are working toward the same goals and objectives. Thus, experts conclude that business plans are a necessary part of starting a business. This seems logical, but it takes a lot of time and money to create a business plan. And in the early months, the firm probably does not have employees. Banks and venture capitalists are not interested in funding the firm, so a plan serves no purpose in the early development of the business. It is not obvious who will benefit from the business plan. Some say the entrepreneur will benefit by thinking through the directions the new firm will take in the future. It is unlikely, however, that a small technology start-up firm of two or three team members has communication difficulties experienced by large corporations. Moreover, during the early stages of developing a new technology business and a saleable product, it is not definite that the first invented product will be saleable. And the type of product, proposed market for it, cost of producing it, and price may change quickly as market research reveals a different product and perhaps a different market. Also, technology may evolve that suggests a better product. A written business plan becomes obsolete every month, perhaps every week. With only a few people involved in the start-up, it is easy to express and agree on a long-term direction for the firm without having a formal written business plan. Communication can be achieved by informal conferences with all old and new team members. These conferences can be “spur of the moment” with a loose agenda. The major purpose is to interact to discuss and decide what the company is doing and what it wants to do as a business. The basic topics are how to survive, generate revenues, and eventually generate profit. Somewhere along the way, the discussion includes the subjects of how the shares of founder stock will be distributed and how all shares of stock will eventually become cash income for the holders. The technology should not be a major topic since only one or two of the team members are interested in the details about the state of and future potential of the technology. A business plan can require a large amount of team members’ time. Alternatively, the firm can spend a large amount of its limited cash to buy someone to write the plan. So, when the decision is made to find an outside investor to put money into
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 47
10/23/07 10:22:11 AM
48
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
the firm, the time has come to write the business plan. The plan’s value is to persuasively explain the future of the firm to someone outside of the founding team. Hopefully, a well-developed team exists and sales have been made. Team quality and sales revenue are the strengths that need to be presented to potential investors through the business plan. This is the firm’s plan for the future, including the opportunity for all investors to take their original investment and profits out of the company as cash payments when it becomes successful. It is a fact of new businesses that no investor, nor team member, wants to leave all the hard-earned profit tied up in the business forever.
Summary and Conclusions Starting a high-tech company is an exhilarating experience. However, technology dominates the form and process of technology entrepreneurship. The two types of technology, evolutionary and disruptive, require that the firm market strategy be created to accommodate the technologies’ unique character. Evolutionary technology offers the faster route to sales revenue. Disruptive technology offers more long-term opportunity for profitability but also requires a long time before revenues are seen. Obviously, the latter also requires much more invested money up front. Both of these can create products that can be sold with technology push or buyer pull marketing strategies. The real challenge is to correctly assess the technology so that a saleable product can be put on the market in the shortest time period. The sooner sales revenues are collected, the less up-front capital investment will be required. And, contrary to recent popular theory, it is not a requirement that a disruptive innovation must be produced. We have provided 7 guides to follow when starting a high-tech business. Most of this comes from our own experiences, especially with fellow university colleagues, clients of our incubators, entrepreneurs that sought us out, those we met at professional meetings, and businesses we have started ourselves. As you contemplate starting your own technology businesses, keep in mind that the first step is to obtain an assessment of your technology. Search for a university or government organization that provides assessment of new technologies. The assessment may not be the final word on your intentions, but it should give you some additional information to think about.
References
1. Christensen, Clayton M., The Innovator’s Dilemma, Harvard Business School Press, Boston, 1997. 2. McHugh, J., Forget old-school R&D. These companies purchase their ideas one startup at a time, Wired, July 6, 2006. 3. Foster, Richard N., Timing technological transitions, in Technology in the Modern Corporation: A Strategic Perspective, M. Horwitch, Ed., Pergammon, New York, 1986. 4. Bower, Joseph L. and Christensen, Clayton M., Disruptive technologies: catching the wave, Harvard Business Review, 73, 1995. 5. Prahalad, C.K. and Hamel, G., Corporate imagination and expeditionary marketing, Harvard Business Review, 69, 81–92, 1991.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 48
10/23/07 10:22:11 AM
Entrepreneurship in Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
49
6. Schumpeter, Joseph A., Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy, Harper and Brothers, New York, 1942. 7. Schumpeter, Joseph A., The Theory of Economic Development, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, 1934. 8. Abernathy, William J. and Utterback, James M., Patterns of industrial innovation, in Readings in the Management of Innovation, 2nd ed., Tushman, M.L. and Moore, W., Eds., Harper Collins, New York, 1988. 9. Anderson, P. and Tushman, M., Technological discontinuities and dominant designs: a cyclical model of technological change, Administrative Science Quarterly, 35, 604–633, 1990. 10. Abernathy, W.J. and Clark, K.B., Innovation: mapping the winds of creative destruction, Research Policy, 14, 3–22. 11. Bohn, R.E., Measuring and managing technological knowledge, Sloan Management Review 36:3, 61–73. 12. Bower, Joseph L. and Christensen, Clayton M., Disruptive technologies: catching the wave, Harvard Business Review, 73, 43–53, 1995. 13. Bower, Joseph L. and Christensen, Clayton M., Disruptive technologies: catching the wave, Harvard Business Review, 73, 43–53, 1995. 14. Moore, Geoffrey A., Crossing the Chasm: Marketing and Selling Technology Products to Mainstream Customers, Harper Business, New York, 1991. 15. Schumpeter, Joseph A., The Theory of Economic Development, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, 1934, p. 75. 16. Schmookler, J., The Theory of Economic Development, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, 1966. 17. Kirzher, Israel M., Perception, Opportunity, and Profit: Studies in the Theory of Entrepreneurship, Chicago University Press, 1979. 18. Schumpeter, Joseph A., The Theory of Economic Development, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, 1934. 19. Barker, R., Taking stock of Genentech: are investors overestimating its promise?, Barron’s National Business and Financial Weekly, March 4, 1985, p. 6–7. 20. Newbert, Scott L., Kirchhoff, Bruce A. and Walsh, Steven T., Defining the relationship among founding resources, strategies, and performance in technology intensive new ventures: evidence from the semiconductor silicon industry, Journal of Small Business Management, in press, July, 2006. 21. The cost of a manufacturing plant exceeded $500 million by 1990, and no new firms were founded thereafter. 22. The information in this section has been taken from various parts of two sources:. Chandler, Alfred D., Inventing the Electronic Century, The Free Press, 2001.. Kaplan, David A., The Silicon Boys, William Morrow and Company, New York, 1999. 23. IBM is the only major producer of mainframe and minicomputers that survived the microcomputer revolution. 24. The information in this section was taken from two sources: Barker, R., Taking stock of Genentech: are investors overestimating its promise?, Barron’s National Business and Financial Weekly, March 4, 1985, p. 6–7. www.gene.com – Genentech’s website last accessed March, 2000. 25. Chandler, Alfred D., Inventing the Electronic Century, The Free Press, 2001. 26. Zhang Junfu, High Tech Start-Ups and Industry Dynamics in Silicon Valley, mimeo, Public Policy Institute of California, 2003. 27. Junfu Zhang, Easier Access to Venture Capital in Silicon Valley: Some Empirical Evidence, mimeo, Public Policy Institute of California, 2006. 28. Full information can be found at: http://www.sba.gov/sbir/indexsbir-sttr.html.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 49
10/23/07 10:22:11 AM
3
Roadmapping Nanotechnology Steven T. Walsh, Bruce A. Kirchhoff, and David Tolfree
Contents Introduction............................................................................................................... 51 What is the Nature of Nanotechnology?........................................................ 53 But what is Nanotechnology?........................................................................ 53 It is often easier to relate the nature of nanotechnology than attempt to define it................................................................................................ 53 What is Roadmapping?.................................................................................. 54 Background............................................................................................................... 55 The First Law of Small Technology.............................................................. 57 The Second Law of Small Technology.......................................................... 57 The Third Law of Small Technology............................................................ 58 The Fourth Law of Small Technology........................................................... 59 Methodology and Information Gathering................................................................. 61 Background.................................................................................................... 61 Methodology.................................................................................................. 62 Data Collection.............................................................................................. 63 Discussion................................................................................................................. 63 Conclusions...............................................................................................................66 References.................................................................................................................66
Introduction Technology roadmaps are a type of strategic plan that attempts to align the research, development, and application of technology with business goals. Unlike strategic plans, however, technology roadmaps often integrate the talents of diverse stakeholders to solve current problems. They help industry, its supply chains, academic and research groups, and governments come together to jointly identify and prioritize the technologies needed to support strategic R&D, marketing, and investment decisions. The various definitions of roadmapping that are used will be discussed with the special issues of roadmapping disruptive technologies. Microsystems and nanosystems are potentially disruptive technologies, so roadmapping them is of special significance. Disruptive technologies can redefine the competitive landscape in traditional 51 © 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 51
10/23/07 10:22:12 AM
52
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
industries and create new ones. Companies and governments that ignore the impact of such technologies do so at their peril. Strategic roadmapping for any technology is an enormous task. This task is made all the more daunting by the newness of a technology, the extent of its useful industrial breadth, the choice of a firm, industry, or region perspective, and finally the degree to which the technology either supports or tries to expunge a current industry technology product paradigm. In this chapter, we will examine the nearly 100 years of efforts that have gone into making technology roadmaps of all types. We recognize that roadmaps have, over this span, been a primary tool to establish new technology into companies, nations, and regions. They have helped to give a focus to strategic vision and policy-making for companies and governments. Numerous elements comprise a roadmap, including the work of many individuals needed to carry out the task of completing it. As a rule of thumb, the larger the audience and size of the stakeholder group, the greater the number of participants required to cover all interests. Furthermore, the nature of the technology under review can add much complexity to the process.1 Nanotechnology2 is vastly different from semiconductor technology.3 Semiconductor microfabrication technology is a fast-paced high technology base that has enjoyed the same technology lifecycle curve for nearly 60 years. Nanotechnology, on the other hand, is an emergent and often disruptive technology that has the potential to redefine the product technology paradigm in several industries, thus making the nanotechnology roadmapping task all that more difficult. Nanotechnology is one of the reasons why the pace of technological change in the world is increasing exponentially,4 making it difficult for strategists and policy makers to fully utilize technologies for competitive advantage. In this introduction, we provide a view of the nature of nanotechnologies and some useful definitions and a discussion on the formational issues of roadmaps. Roadmapping is now an established tool. Over a number of years, many different types of roadmaps have been produced covering almost every sector of technology. Until the publication of the first MANCEF International Roadmap (IMR) in 2002, there were none that specifically covered the special issues associated with the roadmapping of disruptive technologies. This roadmap was the result of 4 years’ work of more than 325 companies and 400 people from 4 continents, including most of the major companies that are involved in the development and production of miniaturized components and products. Many useful lessons were learned during the production of this roadmap, from the process of compiling it, to the differing views and approaches made to the understanding of the technologies. In this chapter, we shall use the MANCEF roadmap as our example since it will help the reader understand the nature of miniaturized technologies and how the roadmapping process can bring opportunities and benefits to companies and nations that want to take the path to commercialization.
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 52
10/23/07 10:22:12 AM
Roadmapping Nanotechnology
53
What is the Nature of Nanotechnology? Nanotechnology is enabling technology5 in many commercial fields. It is disruptive to the technical skill base that it requires to produce products. Nanotechnology can be bifurcated into “Top-down” and “Bottom-up” technologies.
But what is Nanotechnology? It is often easier to relate the nature of nanotechnology than attempt to define it.
There are actually a number of different definitions of nanotechnology. Those who work in the field will be reminded of the old adage “I will know it when I see it.” Any unifying definition is further complicated by the hype associated with nanotechnology since that has created different visions in the minds of non-scientists and technologists. We will discuss the origins of nanotechnologies and the usage terms. The definition of nanotechnology has migrated and expanded over time due to a widening of scientific and public interest in research in this field dating back even further than Richard P. Feynman’s classic presentation, “There is Plenty of Room on the Bottom.” 6 The technical definition of nanotechnology is generally attributed to Taniguchi.7 Initially the field was defined in a purely technological realm, but new definitions are being produced to include the concerns and interests of wider technical and social communities. We start our discussion with Taniguchi’s definition, which states that nanotechnology is “the production technology to get extra high accuracy and ultra fine dimensions, i.e., the preciseness and fineness on the order of 1 nm (nanometer, 10 -9 meter in length).” The term “nano” comes from the Greek word meaning “dwarf.” The name of nanotechnology originates from the nanometer. In the processing of materials, the smallest bit size of stock removal, accretion or flow of materials is probably one atom or one molecule, namely 0.1 ~ 0.2 nm in length. Therefore, the expected limit size of fineness would be of the order of 1 nm. Accordingly, nanotechnology mainly consists of the processing of separation, consolidation, and deformation of materials by one atom or one molecule. The definition used by the United States Group, Nanoscale Science, Engineering and Technology Sub-Committee (NSET) in 2000 states that nanotechnology is research and technology development at the atomic, molecular, or macromolecular levels, in the length scale of approximately 1–100 nanometer range, to provide a fundamental understanding of phenomena and materials at the nanoscale and to create and use structures, devices, and systems that have novel properties and functions because of their small and/or intermediate size. The novel and differentiating properties and functions are developed at a critical length scale of matter, typically under 100 nm. Nanotechnology research and development includes manipulation under control of the nanoscale structures and their integration into larger material components, systems, and architectures. Within these large-scale assemblies, the control and construction of their structures and components remain at the nanometer scale. In some particular cases, the critical length scale for novel properties and phenomena may be under 1 nm (e.g., manipulation of atoms at ~ 0.1 nm) or be larger
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 53
10/23/07 10:22:12 AM
54
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
than 100 nm (e.g., nanoparticle reinforced polymers have the unique feature at ~ 200–300 nm as a function of the local bridges or bonds between the nanoparticles and the polymer).8 There are many other definitions that are influenced by the geographical region or technological environment in which they are derived, the community that is presenting the concept, or other factors. The U.S. National Nanotechnology Initiative definition is one of the most useful and explicative and can be directly related to that used by NSET. They suggest that a certain technology can be considered a nanotechnology only if it involves all of the following three attributes: • Research and technology development at the atomic, molecular, or macromolecular levels, in the length scale of approximately 1–100 nanometer range • Creation and use of structures, devices, and systems that have novel properties and functions because of their small or intermediate size • An ability to control or manipulate on the atomic scale However, for the purposes of roadmap discussion, it is important to understand the basis for the definitions used. Nanotechnology is the practical application of nanoscale science. The British Royal Society has made a clear distinction between these: Nanoscience is concerned with the study of novel phenomena and properties of materials that occur at extremely small length scales — “on the scale of atoms and molecules.” Nanotechnology is “the application of Nanoscale science, engineering, and technology to produce novel materials and devices, including materials for biological and medical applications.”
What is Roadmapping? There is no definitive definition of technology roadmaps. A number of people have expressed their views. Robert Galvin9 states that a roadmap “is an extended look at the future of a chosen field of inquiry composed from the collective knowledge and imagination of the brightest drivers of change in that field.” Others emphasize the ability of roadmapping to provide a vision of the future.10-15 Distilling from these, the most useful working definition of technology roadmapping is “a needs-driven technology planning process to help identify, select, and develop technology alternatives to satisfy a set of product needs.” Expanding this, it brings together a team of experts to develop a framework for organizing and presenting the critical technology-planning information to make the appropriate technology investment decisions and to leverage those investments. Given a set of needs, technology roadmapping process provides a way to develop, organize, and present information about the critical system requirements and performance targets that must be satisfied by certain timeframes. It also identifies technologies that need to be developed to meet those targets. Finally, it provides the information needed to make trade-offs among different technology alternatives.16 Roadmapping is gaining in popularity and importance as academics and practitioners are aware of the increasing importance of technology in the strategic process.17
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 54
10/23/07 10:22:13 AM
Roadmapping Nanotechnology
55
Some strategic theories like competency-based strategies place technology and technology management as the foundation of a company’s search for competitive advantage. They claim unique technologies are a necessary, if not a sufficient, condition for long-term success.18-19 Yet even as technology is recognized as critical and interdependent in a company’s strategic process, this focus on technology makes the strategic process more complex. Technology was once thought by strategists as one dimensional and easy to embody in the strategic process.20 It is now recognized as multidimensional and having primal influence on the strategic process. Further, some of the important managerial aspects of technology, trends in technology development, and sourcing are changing. For example, embodied technology capital and expense costs, the importance of technology at the interface of disciplines, technology complexity, the rate of technology change, global technology sourcing, and many more strategic aspects of technology are more dynamic than ever. Moreover, the importance of long waves and disruptive technology to regions and firms is more understood.21-23
Background Whatever definition of nanotechnology is adopted, technology roadmapping has become an important tool for placing technology in the management process. Today corporations like Motorola, Corning, Phillips, and ALCOA24-27 use roadmaps as part of their strategic process, product development process, R&D efforts, etc. Technology roadmapping is a powerful process for supporting strategic and tactical management decisions.28 Governments, companies, and industrial consortia utilize technology roadmapping to explore and communicate the dynamic linkages between technological resources, organizational strategies, and the changing environment.29-30 Two aspects define the task of a technology roadmap:31 (1) the nature of the technology under question and (2) the audience for the intended roadmap. In our discussion, we will cover the nature of technology, utilizing terms such as enabling or industry specific technology, disruptive or sustaining.32 Until recently almost all roadmap studies were performed on sustaining (established) technologies that are characterized by rapidly changing (high technology) industries such as those involved in semiconductor microfabrication or aluminum production. Indeed, semiconductor technology invented in 1947 was disruptive. It was not until late in the 1970s that an industry roadmap was undertaken.33 Further, nanotechnology is such a broadly defined technology base that it has expressions, which in some industries are disruptive, while in others are sustaining in nature. The roadmap selection process is driven by the commercial nature of the technology under consideration and modified by the strategic nature and scope of the roadmap project. The roadmap selection processes that have embraced enabling technologies logically follow a series of questions that help to bind and define the task. Questions are: • enabling versus product- or industry-specific technology base?34 • potentially disruptive versus sustaining technology?35
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 55
10/23/07 10:22:13 AM
56
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
Technology bases are said to be enabling when they form the basis for solutions that address many product technology paradigms in separate industry settings. The semiconductor-based transistor is such a solution set. This means that the roadmapping professional will have a variety of competing technologies that are specific to the application space under investigation. The terms disruptive and sustaining technologies are ubiquitous in the literature.36 Here, we see an example of a definition that emphasizes their utility as a construct central to the issue of nanotechnology roadmapping. Disruptive or potentially disruptive technologies can set up production platforms based on new sets of technological competencies. They create product technology paradigms that challenge and, if successful, render useless the currently utilized manufacturing competency base or the sustaining technology base. A disruptive technology base usually provides a substantially better value proposition along at least two critical dimensions to be considered commercially viable. When a disruptive technology becomes an industry standard, it becomes sustaining in nature. Sustaining technologies are those that underpin industry standard technology-product platforms. Improvements to these technologies are focused on making expensive changes. The roadmap selection process defines the parameters for the roadmap under question. However, when you have a dichotomy that works, this is exceptionally useful as described in the MANCEF Roadmap by Elders and Walsh.37 The problem with nanotechnology is that it is enabling and simultaneously sustaining in some industries while disruptive in others.38 The nature of a roadmap is further modified and bounded by its strategic purpose. The following sets of constructs help to define those bounds. These constructs include the following bifurcations: • Corporate versus industrial in nature • Market versus technologically concentric • Regional versus international in scope Perhaps the biggest strategic modifier of a roadmapping exercise is the purpose of the roadmap itself.39 The stakeholder group who is developing the roadmap will determine its strategic focus. An industry-based roadmap, for example, will be different from one carried out by a company. National or regional roadmaps for international markets have not had a history of success; however, limiting the geographic scope often provides a focus to a dominant technological pathway for a particular region. Similarly, a concentric market focus or a concentric technological focus either by a company or an industry will determine its boundary. Technological roadmaps are now used for tactical as well as strategic purposes.40 Roadmaps differ between physical and service product planning,41-42 product family tree development versus single product development, and service and product technology process planning. Further, technological roadmaps, in practice, are strongly linked to market forecasting efforts sharing many of the same tools, such as the Delphi method and others. Some authors of roadmaps suggest that roadmapping can be performed on two levels, industry or corporate. Further, these levels necessitate a differing scope of
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 56
10/23/07 10:22:13 AM
Roadmapping Nanotechnology
57
efforts in terms of time, cost, level of effort, and complexity. Moreover, they provide an overall differing process between a company and an industrial process. Finally, we suggest that roadmapping processes for disruptive technologies may need to be different in scope. In many ways, the roadmapping process has become a victim of its own success. The process provides such value to the strategic planning of companies and regions that many have sought to apply it to technology foresight, technology forecasting, data scanning, etc. We now consider nanotechnology-based roadmaps. They inherently differ from the sustaining technology-based roadmaps. Such technologies are the basis for specific technology product paradigms that set the path for major industries. The Semiconductor Microfabrication Roadmap (SMR) benefited greatly by the success of the semiconductor industry that had a single technology focus. Let us consider some of the differences between nanotechnology and semiconductor microfabrication. The following questions raise interesting problems: Why was it so hard for “Small Tech” based solution suppliers to use Moore’s Law43 in the same way that semiconductor fabricators do? What does that suggest for the “Small Tech” based solutions communities? Semiconductor microfabrication benefits from Moore’s Law. Does nanotechnology have a Moore’s Law equivalent? These problems may result from the lack of a unit cell for nanotechnology, unlike all electronically driven microsystems that have transistors as units. If it is true that “Small Tech” has no transistor-like unit cell, then this leads to a series of laws that might suggest production space and standardization strategies.
The First Law Of Small Technology There is no unit cell. The suggestion that no unit cell exists when considering nanotechnologies presents a manufacturing production problem. This law eliminates much of the promise of cross-industrial learning and acts as the basis for many of the next three “Small Tech” laws. While the semiconductor industry focuses on the furthering of MOS technology and, to a smaller extent, bipolar technology, this lack of similar process technologies simply does not exist in the newer small technology paradigms. Where it is true that there are groupings of MEMS production processes, which share many process steps, it is more true to say that there are at least 40 varied routes for manufacturing processes in the MEMS industries. The emerging and encompassing nature of nanotechnology-based applications provides for even more varied based production pathways. This means that the transference of learning in production of micro and nano devices will not keep pace with the learning achieved by their semiconductor cousins in the near future. This leads to the “Second Small Tech Law.”
The Second Law of Small Technology Application, One Process. This law was first presented by Eloy at a meeting in 200444 of “Small Tech.” Designers choose production pathways that are application specific. It suggests serious implications for the roadmapping process. Companies that embrace new nanotechnology-based products will most likely have to modify an existing process
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 57
10/23/07 10:22:13 AM
58
Commercializing Micro-Nanotechnology Products
radically in order to produce it. Further, even though there exists many ways to produce a given product, some of these will be much less cost effective and efficient. In the MANCEF International Roadmap,45 examples are given of many process variants for top-down and bottom-up nanotechnologies that are often specific to a certain application area or group of applications. For example, the top 10 to 15 MEMS companies use many similar process steps but very dissimilar processes. Texas Instruments, Analog Devices, and Sandia National Laboratories are three leaders in surface MEMS technologies and have been integrating MEMS and semiconductor microfabrication for years. Yet the complexity and typology of these processes are very different. They are different since different end users and product applications drive them. Other industry leaders, Hewlett Packard, Honeywell, and Kulite’s, for example, use other MEMS and NEMS technologies to meet their customer needs and have not only varied processes from each other but from many of the other top ten producers.46 Again, technology choices are driven by applications rather than any unit cell considerations. One implication of this reality is that MEMS or NEMS based foundries, whether commercial or captive, have a difficult time following the semiconductor foundry model.47 Micro and nanotechnologies currently do not have a dominant manufacturing technology as does the semiconductor microfabrication industry’s bipolar or CMOS, ensuring processes in that industry have much more in common than MEMS and NEMS. Nano-based foundries face many more problems than their semiconductor-based cousins. Some foundries trying to provide solutions to a wide variety of applications have had exceptionally high development costs. Many NEMS foundries have learned to tailor the projects they accept to meet their existing or planned capabilities. This strategy has been used with success by such firms as Dalsha and Colybris. Minfab in Australia has taken an islands of competence approach that has been successful for them. This describes only the front-end manufacturing reality of “Small Tech.” There are also back-end issues for “Small Tech” commercial solutions. Nano and microbased devices interact with the macro world by communicating, sensing, or actuating along many different paths. Many applications require pathways to sense or actuate in a wide variety of mediums. The importance, cost, value, and problems of nano- and micro-based packaging are well known. Micro and nano applications that sense differing properties have radically differing packaging requirements. This is the base for the second law of “Small Tech.”
The Third Law of Small Technology One Application, One Process, One package. The success of small technologies and their increasing importance over the last decade have become evident. Yet many of the applications share technologies in both the front-end and back-end process have little in common except that they are small. Companies with the highest volume productions enjoy process standardization that derives from high-volume processes. However, the lack of a unit cell does not allow the multiplication effect that comes from the acceptance of common processes across applications. Testing is application specific, leading to the Fourth Law of “Small Tech.”
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8315.indb 58
10/23/07 10:22:14 AM
59
Roadmapping Nanotechnology
The Fourth Law of Small Technology One Application, One Process, One package, One Testing Procedure. The Fourth Law was derived from MANCEF’s First International Top Down Nanotechnology Roadmap produced in the late 1990s.48 The Fourth Law suggests that alternatives to the semiconductor foundry model might be necessary. This law drives many to think that where some applications might follow a semiconductorlike model, more seem to follow the precision machining, islands of competence, or shared facilities model. These four laws provide a basis to understand “Small Tech” and how it should be treated in a roadmapping process. These laws suggest that successful technology product packages and test paradigms will be modified and shifted to other application spaces as is being done by Olivetti ink-jet to microfluidics, Bosch bulk automotive sensors to the commercial sensors, and many others. These laws modify greatly any nanotechnology-based roadmapping. Nanotechnology-based process then differs greatly from a traditional roadmapping process in many ways: • The breadth of the technology and the types of technologies in its base are exceptionally varied. • This requires a roadmapper to be selective. For example, the MANCEF process49 focuses on a subset of nanotechnology. Another roadmapping study focused on Atomically Precise Manufacturing (APM). This roadmapping requires a focus on a new, emerging, enabling and disruptive technology base, which does not have, for the most part, dominant technology product architectures within solution sets they provide. The MANCEF roadmapping process utilized these constraints in order to deal with: • the enabling or meta-systemic nature of the markets that nanotechnology addresses • the flexibility required of firm-based nanotechnology product platform that companies need to develop in order to be robust and address the uncertainties of different markets • The MANCEF roadmap process, unlike traditional ones, did not focus solely on current or future nanotechnology but applied to a