COLD MOLECULES Theory, Experiment, Applications
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
COLD MOLECULES Theory, Experi...
30 downloads
1150 Views
35MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
COLD MOLECULES Theory, Experiment, Applications
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
COLD MOLECULES Theory, Experiment, Applications Edited by
Roman V. Krems William C. Stwalley Bretislav Friedrich
CRC Press Taylor & Francis Croup Boca Raton London New York
CRC Press is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group, an informs business
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
CRC Press Taylor & Francis Group 6000 Broken Sound Parkway NW, Suite 300 Boca Raton, FL 33487-2742 © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC CRC Press is an imprint of Taylor & Francis Group, an Informa business No claim to original U.S. Government works Printed in the United States of America on acid-free paper 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 International Standard Book Number: 978-1-4200-5903-8 (Hardback) This book contains information obtained from authentic and highly regarded sources. Reasonable efforts have been made to publish reliable data and information, but the author and publisher cannot assume responsibility for the validity of all materials or the consequences of their use. The authors and publishers have attempted to trace the copyright holders of all material reproduced in this publication and apologize to copyright holders if permission to publish in this form has not been obtained. If any copyright material has not been acknowledged please write and let us know so we may rectify in any future reprint. Except as permitted under U.S. Copyright Law, no part of this book may be reprinted, reproduced, transmitted, or utilized in any form by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying, microfilming, and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without written permission from the publishers. For permission to photocopy or use material electronically from this work, please access www.copyright. com (http://www.copyright.com/) or contact the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc. (CCC), 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, 978-750-8400. CCC is a not-for-profit organization that provides licenses and registration for a variety of users. For organizations that have been granted a photocopy license by the CCC, a separate system of payment has been arranged. Trademark Notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation without intent to infringe. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Cold molecules: theory, experiment, applications / [edited by] Roman Krems, Bretislav Friedrich, and William C. Stwalley. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-1-4200-5903-8 (hard back: alk. paper) 1. Collisions (Nuclear physics) 2. Low temperatures. 3. Quantum solids. 4. Quantum liquids. 5. Cold gases. 6. Molecular dynamics. I. Krems, Roman. II. Friedrich, Bretislav. III. Stwalley, William C, 1942- IV. Title. QC794.6.C6C635 2009 530.4-dc22 Visit the Taylor & Francis Web site at http://www.taylorandfrancis.com and the CRC Press Web site at http://www.crcpress.com
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
2009015987
Contents Foreword . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ix Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xi A Guided Tour of the Monograph . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xiii Editors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xxvii Contributors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xxix Part I
Cold Collisions
Chapter 1
Theory of Cold Atomic and Molecular Collisions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Jeremy M. Hutson
Chapter 2
Electric Dipoles at Ultralow Temperatures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 39 John L. Bohn
Chapter 3
Inelastic Collisions and Chemical Reactions of Molecules at Ultracold Temperatures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 69 Goulven Quéméner, Naduvalath Balakrishnan, and Alexander Dalgarno
Chapter 4
Effects of External Electromagnetic Fields on Collisions of Molecules at Low Temperatures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 125 Timur V. Tscherbul and Roman V. Krems
Part II
Photoassociation
Chapter 5
Ultracold Molecule Formation by Photoassociation . . . . . . . . . . . . . 169 William C. Stwalley, Phillip L. Gould, and Edward E. Eyler
Chapter 6
Molecular States Near a Collision Threshold . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 221 Paul S. Julienne
Chapter 7
Prospects for Control of Ultracold Molecule Formation via Photoassociation with Chirped Laser Pulses . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 245 Eliane Luc-Koenig and Françoise Masnou-Seeuws
Chapter 8
Adiabatic Raman Photoassociation with Shaped Laser Pulses . . . . 291 Evgeny A. Shapiro and Moshe Shapiro v
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
vi
Contents
Part III
Few- and Many-Body Physics
Chapter 9
Ultracold Feshbach Molecules . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 319 Francesca Ferlaino, Steven Knoop, and Rudolf Grimm
Chapter 10
Molecular Regimes in Ultracold Fermi Gases . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 355 Dmitry S. Petrov, Christophe Salomon, and Georgy V. Shlyapnikov
Chapter 11
Theory of Ultracold Feshbach Molecules . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 399 Thomas M. Hanna, Hugo Martay, and Thorsten Köhler
Chapter 12
Condensed Matter Physics with Cold Polar Molecules . . . . . . . . . 421 Guido Pupillo, Andrea Micheli, Hans-Peter Büchler, and Peter Zoller
Part IV
Cooling and Trapping
Chapter 13
Cooling, Trap Loading, and Beam Production Using a Cryogenic Helium Buffer Gas . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 473 Wesley C. Campbell and John M. Doyle
Chapter 14
Slowing, Trapping, and Storing of Polar Molecules by Means of Electric Fields . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 509 Sebastiaan Y.T. van de Meerakker, Hendrick L. Bethlem, and Gerard Meijer
Part V
Tests of Fundamental Laws
Chapter 15
Preparation and Manipulation of Molecules for Fundamental Physics Tests . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 555 Michael R. Tarbutt, Jony J. Hudson, Ben E. Sauer, and Edward A. Hinds
Chapter 16
Variation of Fundamental Constants as Revealed by Molecules: Astrophysical Observations and Laboratory Experiments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 597 Victor V. Flambaum and Mikhail G. Kozlov
Part VI
Quantum Computing
Chapter 17
Quantum Information Processing with Ultracold Polar Molecules . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 629 Susanne F. Yelin, Dave DeMille, and Robin Côté
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
vii
Contents
Part VII Chapter 18
Cold Molecular Ions Sympathetically Cooled Molecular Ions: From Principles to First Applications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 651 Bernhard Roth and Stephan Schiller
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
Foreword This volume offers an exhilarating journey to a compelling frontier of molecular physics. It is a special pleasure to applaud the authors and editors. Intrepid explorers of the frontier, they are also adept guides for both recruits and curious visitors. The result is a lucid and lively evangelical survey of seminal results, experimental and theoretical methods, prospects and challenges. My benediction will simply touch on some kinships, past or future, with more civilized fields. Any physical chemist of my vintage is delighted to see molecules now ardently embraced by physicists. The oft-quoted dictum: “A diatomic molecule has one atom too many” has been disavowed. The new converts to molecular physics are emulating illustrious ancestors from early decades of the 20th century, who found that molecules presented challenging questions for the then fledgling quantum theory. Today, much of the “hot” appeal of molecules in the “cold” (<1 K) and “ultracold” (<10−3 K) regimes does not stem from attaining low temperatures as such. Rather, a chief aim is to gain access to dramatic quantum phenomena that emerge when de Broglie wavelengths become comparable to or longer than the size or the separation of molecules. This key issue of wavelength versus interaction range was first exemplified over 80 years ago in the celebrated prediction of Bose–Einstein condensation (BEC). However, it soon after also became prominent in nuclear physics. For collisions of protons or neutrons at kinetic energy of ∼1 MeV (equivalent to ∼1010 K), the de Broglie wavelength (∼ 30 × 10−13 cm) is considerably longer than the range of nuclear forces. Consequently, s-wave scattering, resonances, and tunneling became major features in probing nuclear physics. That may soon become so for molecular physics too, although it has proved much more difficult to reach the corresponding long wavelength realm. On entering that realm, molecular physicists will enjoy some great advantages over their nuclear predecessors. Both intramolecular and intermolecular interactions can be strongly influenced by applying external electric or magnetic fields. Also, for molecules, coherent excitation processes induced by laser light provide another particularly powerful tool. Moreover, at least for prototype systems, molecular theory and electronic structure calculations often can offer guidance in design and interpretation of experiments. The “hot” appeal of the cold and ultracold molecular regimes has another fundamental aspect. Attaining these regimes requires liberation from thermodynamics. BEC was long presumed to be attainable only for liquid helium. It was expected that, before the temperature and density required to form a degenerate quantum gas could be reached, thermodynamics would impose the mundane process of ordinary condensation. Now BEC has been obtained at or below 10−6 K for many atomic and a few molecular vapors. That required finding pathways along which the kinetics becomes much too slow to reach equilibrium states. This is the same principle governing much of conventional chemical synthesis. Hordes of organic molecules, many ix © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
x
Foreword
crucial for biology, are thermodynamically unstable but are made by exploiting kinetically dominated pathways. This also must be how sizable organic molecules appear in the interstellar medium, despite the low cosmic abundance of carbon. Viewed in this context, cold molecule research may embolden even pragmatic chemists to seek more extreme means to evade thermodynamics. Many among the wide range of techniques and concepts found in this monograph have roots entwined with the pioneering molecular beam work conducted by Otto Stern. As Einstein’s first postdoctoral fellow, Stern acquired a taste for Gedanken experiments, later fulfilled in his laboratory. In his day, “beams” probably would have seemed a misleadingly robust term. Rather, he spoke of “molecular rays.” That now seems prescient in an era striving for long de Broglie wavelengths. In the preface for a 1931 book by Fraser titled Molecular Rays, Stern emphasized the characteristics of the method as “Its directness and (in principle at least) its primitiveness.” For the present volume, equally apt is his praise of “… that beauty and peculiar charm which so firmly captivates physicists working in this field.” Dudley Herschbach Cambridge, Massachusetts
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
Acknowledgments The editors wish to thank John Doyle, Gerard Meijer, and Françoise Masnou-Seeuws for their help with developing this monograph, and the Institute for Theoretical Atomic, Molecular and Optical Physics at the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics for partial support. The European Union Research Training Network on Cold Molecules, coordinated by Françoise Masnou-Seeuws and Olivier Dulieu, catalyzed much of the research reported in this book.
xi © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
A Guided Tour of the Monograph COLD MOLECULES ARE HOT This monograph was prompted by the need for a comprehensive and comprehensible account of the research that has been amassed on translationally (and otherwise) cold molecules. Having started, in the mid-1990s, as a challenge to a handful of enthusiasts who sought to widen the range of cold-matter research to include gaseous molecules, the venture picked up speed quickly and underwent a strongly nonlinear growth. Today, nearly forty research groups worldwide are engaged in cold molecule research, and produce more than 100 papers annually. The leading protagonists of the field, in the midst of many mutual encounters and interactions, are now meeting on the pages of this monograph to jointly survey the state of the art of their field. It was the task of the coeditors to help to present their material in a consistent and concise manner. The hope of all of us involved in bringing this monograph to life has been that it will serve as a text- or handbook to students entering the field and weathered researchers alike, and will help to foster their identity within academic institutions and the physics and chemistry communities at large. Cold molecule research owes much of its original inspiration to the field of cold atoms. However, it pursued its own aims. Molecules are not only more complicated than atoms, but in some respects also more interesting: apart from possessing vibrational and rotational degrees of freedom, molecules may carry dipole (and higher) electric and magnetic moments. These moments lend properties to molecules on which new operational principles can be based (e.g., quantum computing) or that may allow researchers to investigate novel physics (e.g., quantum degenerate dipolar systems, whose scope is currently limited to the quantum gas of chromium atoms). This introduction is a preview of what the chapters in this monograph have to offer. The methods for producing translationally cold (<1 K) molecules can be generally divided into two categories: direct and indirect ones. The indirect methods rely on linking together ultracold (<1 mK) atoms through magnetically tunable Feshbach resonances (magnetoassociation) or by photoassociation. The molecules that ensue are translationally as ultracold as the atoms they were formed from. The direct methods slow or select preexisting molecules. This is effected either by decelerating a supersonic molecular beam by time-dependent electric, magnetic, or radiative fields or by selecting out a slow fraction of a molecular ensemble. Preexisting molecules can also be sympathetically cooled in a buffer gas of precooled atoms. Once slowed/cooled down to the cold regime, the preexisting molecules can be subject to further sympathetic cooling via a thermal contact with an ultracold gas of atoms or, if the molecules were confined in a trap, to evaporative cooling. xiii © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
xiv
A Guided Tour of the Monograph
We note that, of the above, a phase-space density increase is concomitant only with the processes of sympathetic and evaporative cooling. In all other cases, phase-space density remains at most constant. A drop in phase-space density takes the gaseous sample further away from quantum degeneracy.
COLLISIONS OF COLD AND ULTRACOLD MOLECULES When hot molecules are placed in a bath of cold atoms, their translational energy is quenched by elastic collisions with the buffer-gas atoms. The evaporative cooling is likewise based on elastic collisions leading to energy transport and reequilibration of the translational temperature of a molecular ensemble as the trap depth is gradually reduced. If the molecules are initially prepared in metastable excited states, they may undergo inelastic and reactive as well as elastic collisions. Inelastic and reactive collisions release energy and accelerate the colliding particles. This results in trap loss. Because the density of molecules is usually the largest near the center of a trap, where the temperature is the coldest, collisional trap loss removes some of the coldest atoms and molecules and leads to heating. Ideally, a cooling experiment should begin with an ensemble of molecules prepared in the absolute ground state to avoid inelastic collisions and their deleterious effects. However, this is most often not feasible. Electrostatic and magnetic traps widely used to isolate molecular gases from the thermal environment confine molecules in excited Zeeman and Stark states. Molecules generated by linking ultracold atoms are normally produced in highly excited vibrational states. In order to establish the possibility of cooling specific molecules to ultracold temperatures, it is therefore critically important to understand the efficiency of elastic scattering and inelastic and reactive collisions of these molecules at cold and ultracold temperatures. Theoretical analysis of molecular collisions at low temperatures has played an important role in the development of the research field of cold molecules. In particular, quantum-mechanical calculations carried out in the early days of cold molecule research demonstrated that rovibrationally inelastic collisions and chemical reactions of molecules at ultracold temperatures may be very fast. Theoretical work showed that collision-induced Stark relaxation of molecules confined in an electrostatic trap is prohibitively fast but molecules in magnetic traps may be more stable against collisional trap loss. Quantum-mechanical calculations had elucidated the mechanisms of inelastic collisions of molecules in electrostatic and magnetic traps and demonstrated that collisional properties of cold and ultracold molecules can be effectively tuned by external fields. This work identified a range of molecules that may be amenable to collisional cooling in magnetic traps and stimulated the development of new traps that could confine molecules in the absolute ground state. These and other results of the theoretical work on molecular collisions at cold and ultracold temperatures are described in Chapters 1 to 4 of this monograph. To set the stage for further dispositions, Jeremy Hutson describes in Chapter 1 (entitled “Theory of Cold Atomic and Molecular Collisions”) the basic theory of atomic and molecular scattering at low temperatures. This chapter introduces the concepts of the cross-section, the rate coefficient, and the scattering length, and describes the main ingredients of quantum collision theory. It is shown that the © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
A Guided Tour of the Monograph
xv
scattering wavefunctions and the bound-state wavefunctions can be obtained from the calculations based on the same principles and numerical methods. A particular emphasis is placed on the extension of the collision theory to molecular scattering in the presence of external fields and the discussion of scattering resonances that can be tuned by external fields. These scattering resonances can be used to vary the interaction properties of ultracold molecules, which may be necessary for a number of applications of ultracold molecules discussed in further chapters. A major thrust of recent experimental work has been to create ultracold polar molecules, as ultracold dipolar gases offer exciting opportunities for new fundamental discoveries. More than ten research groups demonstrated the possibility of creating ultracold polar molecules by photoassociation of ultracold alkali-metal atoms. Chapter 2 (“Electric Dipoles at Ultralow Temperatures”), written by John Bohn, presents a comprehensive and rigorous discussion of classical and quantummechanical dipoles. With meticulous attention to detail, this chapter describes the effects of molecular structure such as the presence of the rotational angular momentum, the electron spin, or Λ-doubling on interactions between molecular dipoles. The discussion is conveniently formulated in terms of spherical tensors, which makes the mathematical expressions for the matrix elements of the dipole–dipole interaction operator elegant and transparent. Chapter 3 (“Inelastic Collisions and Chemical Reactions of Molecules at Ultracold Temperatures”), written by Goulven Quéméner, Naduvalath Balakrishnan, and Alexander Dalgarno, is a comprehensive account of recent theoretical work on rovibrationally inelastic and reactive scattering of molecules at cold and ultracold temperatures. The chapter includes a compilation of zero-temperature rate constants for inelastic and reactive collisions of various molecules. The authors describe both neutral and ionic systems and collision processes involving atom–molecule and molecule–molecule scattering. This chapter contains 25 diagrams illustrating various physical phenomena such as near-resonant energy transfer in cold collisions, the effect of near-threshold virtual states on chemical reactivity of ultracold molecules, threshold collision laws, Feshbach and shape resonances, and the effects of rotational degrees of freedom on vibrational relaxation of cold and ultracold molecules. The authors analyze tunneling-dominated chemical reactions and insertion chemical reactions that occur without an activation barrier and discuss the challenges for the theory of ultracold chemical dynamics. Controlling chemical reactions with electromagnetic fields has been a long-sought goal of researchers. External field control of chemical reactions will not only allow chemists to selectively produce desired species, but will also reveal the mechanisms of chemical reactions, yield information on interactions determining chemical reactions, and elucidate the role of nonadiabatic and relativistic effects in chemical dynamics. External control of bimolecular reactions is, however, complicated by thermal motion of molecules, which randomizes molecular encounters and diminishes the effects of external fields on molecular collisions. The effects of the thermal motion can be reduced by cooling molecular gases to low temperatures. Electromagnetic fields may influence molecular collisions significantly only when the translational energy of the molecules is smaller than the perturbations due to interactions with the external fields. Static magnetic and electric fields (up to 5 T and 200 kV/cm, respectively), © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
xvi
A Guided Tour of the Monograph
as well as off-resonant laser fields (1012 W/cm2 ) readily available in the laboratory, shift molecular energy levels by up to a few Kelvin. As a result, external field control of gas-phase molecular dynamics may be most easily achieved at cold and ultracold temperatures less than 1 K. In Chapter 4, entitled “Effects of External Electromagnetic Fields on Collisions of Molecules at Low Temperatures,” Timur Tscherbul and Roman Krems discuss the effects of external fields on the dynamics of molecular collisions at cold and ultracold temperatures and outline the prospects for new discoveries in the research of molecule–field interactions at low temperatures. The first part of Chapter 4 focuses on collision-induced Zeeman and Stark relaxation relevant for molecular cooling experiments, the discussion of tunable shape and Feshbach resonances, and the scattering of molecular dipoles in an electric field. The results presented exemplify what is described in general terms in Chapters 1 and 2. The second part of this chapter describes new mechanisms for external field control of atom–molecule and intermolecular interactions by combined electric and magnetic fields. Here, the authors discuss the effects of electric fields on collisions of magnetically aligned molecules, collisions in nonparallel electric and magnetic fields, and differential scattering of cold molecules in electric fields. In the third part of the chapter, the authors discuss inelastic and chemically reactive collisions of ultracold molecules confined by laser fields to move in quasi-two-dimensional geometry. The experiments with such systems may probe the effects of external space symmetry on binary interactions of molecules and the role of long-range intermolecular interactions in determining chemical reactivity of ultracold molecules. Chapter 4 concludes with a discussion of prospects for cold controlled chemistry.
PHOTOASSOCIATION OF ULTRACOLD ATOMS The formation of ultracold molecules starting with readily produced ultracold atoms is an attractive and relatively simple method for obtaining such molecules. There are two widely employed methods for such formation: photoassociation (discussed in this section) and magnetoassociation by tuning a magnetic field to convert a Feshbach resonance between two colliding atoms into a very weakly bound molecular level (discussed in the next section). Chapter 5 by William Stwalley, Phillip Gould, and Edward Eyler, entitled “Ultracold Molecule Formation by Photoassociation,” provides an overview of experimental results and their theoretical interpretation. After a brief introduction to the various approaches to formation of ultracold molecules, the process of photoassociation itself is introduced as an important component of atomic line broadening, especially on the wings of an atomic line. However, at room temperature and above, a broadened atomic line has relatively little information content because of the wide range of collision energies and angular momenta of collisions contributing to the lineshape. This is in stark contrast to photoassociation of ultracold atoms, typically at 100 μK, where only a few angular momenta of collision lead to penetration to short distances where photoassociation at significant detunings from atomic resonance can occur. This ultracold photoassociation leads to sharp line-like spectra, where the observed lines correspond to transitions from a colliding pair of ground-state atoms © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
A Guided Tour of the Monograph
xvii
to excited molecular rovibronic levels with specific quantum numbers for each line; that is, very nearly a bound–bound molecular electronic spectrum. Photoassociation of like atoms to form homonuclear molecules, emphasizing the widely studied alkali metals, is treated first. The simple one-color experiments are described in detail, including the variety of techniques used for detection: trap loss (decrease in atomic fluoresence), direct detection of excited molecule ionization, detection of fragments by resonance-enhanced multiphoton ionization, and detection of ground or metastable molecules (formed by decay of the upper photoassociation level) by resonance-enhanced multiphoton ionization. Two-color experiments are discussed, both the ladder scheme for reaching highly excited states and the lambda (Raman) scheme for reaching bound molecular levels correlating with two ground-state atoms. The latter scheme is, of course, relevant for forming molecules in the ground or lowest metastable electronic state (the X and the a states for the alkali-metal dimers). Chapters 7 and 8 of this monograph use ultrafast lasers for this lambda scheme, as opposed to the cw lasers used in the experiments described in Chapter 5. Photoassociation of unlike atoms to form heteronuclear molecules (with dipole moments) is treated next, with emphasis on the extensively studied case of KRb. The differences between like and unlike atom photoassociation is then discussed in some detail. Next, the promise of atom–molecule and molecule–molecule photoassociation (not yet experimentally realized) is briefly mentioned. The rapidly expanding fields of photoassociation in a quantum degenerate gas, in an electomagnetic field, and in an optical lattice are briefly discussed as a partial introduction to later chapters. The characterization of the X and a state levels of homonuclear and heteronuclear alkali dimer molecules formed by decay of the upper levels formed by photoassociation is discussed next. Resonance-enhanced multiphoton ionization is shown to be a powerful technique for establishing the population of vibrational levels formed in the X and a states near the dissociation limit. A new ion depletion technique for observing rotational and hyperfine structure as well for these levels near dissociation is also discussed. To reach lower levels, especially in the ground X state, it is useful to select specific photoassociation approaches such as double minimum excited-state potentials, resonant coupling of two (or more) excited state potentials, and stimulated Raman transfer from levels near dissociation to low levels (e.g., the collisionally stable v = 0, J = 0 level). Finally connections to ultracold molecular ions, to tests of fundamental laws, to quantum computing with ultracold polar molecules, to ultracold collisions and chemistry, and to more speculative areas are mentioned. Chapter 6 by Paul Julienne, entitled “Molecular States Near a Collision Threshold,” provides a thorough introduction to the region near dissociation dominated by long-range forces. It provides, on the one hand, a connection to the collision dynamics discussions of Chapters 1–4 and, on the other hand, to the photoassociation of Chapters 5–8 and the magnetoassociation (Feshbach molecules) of Chapters 9–11. Of particular interest is the elegant long-range scaling of properties for both collisions at ultracold energies and of bound vibrational levels just below dissociation (longrange molecules) for the case of a single internuclear potential energy curve. The case © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
xviii
A Guided Tour of the Monograph
of multiple interacting potentials is then introduced and the resulting modifications of the formalism discussed. Chapter 7 by Eliane Luc-Koenig and Francoise Masnou-Seeuws, entitled “Prospects for Control of Ultracold Molecule Formation via Photoassociation with Chirped Laser Pulses,” provides an intriguing set of case studies on the theme “where ultrafast meets ultracold.” A series of calculations are described for two-color lambda ultrafast photoassociation of the cesium dimer into the a state via the long-range well of a double minimum state. With an emphasis on developing some physical intuition concerning ultrafast photoassociation, the authors develop insightful concepts such as resonance window, photoassociation window, dynamical hole, momentum kick, compression effect, and integrated mass current to understand as well as present their interesting results. Chapter 8 by Evgeny Shapiro and Moshe Shapiro, entitled “Adiabatic Raman Photoassociation with Shaped Laser Pulses,” provides an interesting complementary approach to the ultrafast/ultracold two-color photoassociation scheme. They study the Raman adiabatic passage of an incoming wavepacket of two colliding atoms to form a translationally ultracold diatomic molecule. This wavepacket approach provides an interesting alternative to the theory described in the previous chapter. In addition, the authors of Chapter 8 pursue both analytical theory and numerical simulations for KRb and Rb2 , which shows how a photoassociation measurement can be used to probe the wavefunction of the colliding atoms.
FEW- AND MANY-BODY PHYSICS WITH COLD MOLECULES Recent theoretical work has shown that ultracold molecules trapped in optical lattices can be used to simulate condensed-matter systems, engineer novel phases with topological order, and explore many-body interactions. Polar molecules in external field traps may form chains, which can be used to study rheological phenomena with nonclassical behavior. The creation of a Bose–Einstein condensate of molecules may enable the study of Bose-enhanced chemistry and the effects of symmetry breaking on chemical interactions at ultracold temperatures. The realization of these proposals as well as the creation of dense ensembles of ultracold molecules depends critically on the possibility of controlling the scattering length of molecules by external electromagnetic fields. The prediction and observation of magnetic Feshbach resonances in atomic collisions opened the door to many groundbreaking experiments with ultracold gases such as the realization of the BEC–BCS crossover, the observation of quantum phase transitions, and the creation of ultracold molecules using time-varying magnetic fields. Extension of this work to molecular collisions may similarly lead to the development of new research fields such as cold controlled chemistry, quantum coherent control, and quantum condensed-matter physics with molecular condensates. Chapter 9, “Ultracold Feshbach Molecules,” written by Francesca Ferlaino, Steven Knoop, and Rudolf Grimm, introduces the concept of magnetically tunable Feshbach resonances and describes the experimental techniques for the creation of ultracold atomic gases, making ultracold molecules by tuning Feshbach resonances, removing the atoms from ultracold atom–molecule mixtures in order to produce a pure molecular gas, and using avoided crossings induced by magnetic dipole–dipole and © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
A Guided Tour of the Monograph
xix
spin–orbit interactions to prepare molecular samples in specific quantum states. The authors describe the fascinating observation of Stückelberg oscillations in an ultracold gas of molecules and how tuning the scattering length of ultracold atoms via Feshbach resonances can be used to study few- and many-body physics of ultracold systems. In particular, they describe the experimental studies of Efimov trimer states, molecular Bose–Einstein condensates and many-body physics in atomic Fermi gases. A major thrust of recent experimental research has been to produce ultracold molecules in the absolute ground state by combining ultracold atoms. This has been a daunting task. At the end of Chapter 9, the authors describe the results of a successful experiment yielding ultracold molecules in the absolute ground state. The creation and Bose–Einstein condensation of weakly bound diatomic molecules of fermionic atoms is perhaps one of the most important results of cold atom physics. Molecules produced by tuning interatomic interactions using Feshbach resonances are the largest diatomic molecules obtained so far, with a size of the order of thousands of Ångströms. They represent novel composite bosons, which exhibit features of Fermi statistics at short intermolecular distances. While highly excited, these molecules are remarkably stable with respect to collisional relaxation. This is a consequence of the Pauli exclusion principle for identical fermionic atoms. Chapter 10 by Dmitry Petrov, Christophe Salomon, and Georgy Shlyapnikov, entitled “Molecular Regimes in Ultracold Fermi Gases,” introduces theories to describe the physics of molecular regimes in two-component Fermi gases and Fermi–Fermi mixtures. The authors discuss elastic and inelastic collisions of these extended molecules and demonstrate the effects of quantum statistics on interactions of weakly-bound molecules in a molecular Bose–Einstein condensate. For heteronuclear systems, they introduce a model based on the Born–Oppenheimer approximation separating the motion of light and heavy atoms. The model is used for an elegant description of the Efimov states. At the conclusion of the chapter, the authors extend their theory to many-body systems of heavy and light fermions and demonstrate that significant long-range repulsions between weakly-bound molecules may lead to the spontaneous formation of a molecular crystalline phase. Building on the discussion of Chapter 1 and complementing the discussions of Chapters 9 and 10, Chapter 11, “Theory of Ultracold Feshbach Molecules,” written by Thomas Hanna, Hugo Martay and Thorsten Köhler, is a concise description of the microsopic theory of Feshbach molecules. The authors describe the role of atomic hyperfine interactions and the interatomic interactions in determining Feshbach resonances and how Feshbach resonances modify the interaction properties of ultracold atoms. They present the classification of Feshbach resonances and distinguish openchannel-dominated and closed-channel-dominated resonances. As the different types of resonances give rise to different properties of Feshbach molecules, the discussion of this chapter is important for the understanding of how tuning microscopic interaction parameters with magnetic fields modifies the macrosopic properties of an ultracold quantum gas. The creation of low-dimensional quantum gases has opened up exciting possibilities for new research with ultracold atoms and molecules on problems in several different areas of physics. Bose and Fermi gases exhibit unusual properties in two dimensions, and confining ultracold atoms in two-dimensions may result in interesting © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
xx
A Guided Tour of the Monograph
decoherence dynamics of quantum gases. Low-dimensional quantum systems may be used as controllable models for a variety of phenomena in condensed-matter physics. For example, polar molecules confined in two dimensions may repel each other at long range, which leads to the formation of self-organizing crystals at ultracold temperatures and to the possibility of designing various spin lattice models. This is the focus of Chapter 12 by Guido Pupillo, Andrea Micheli, Hans-Peter Büchler, and Peter Zoller, entitled “Condensed Matter Physics with Cold Polar Molecules.” The chapter opens with an overview of many-body systems of strongly interacting polar molecules placed in external microwave and dc electric fields. The authors show that the polarization of laser fields, the strength of dc fields, and the number of laser-field couplings can all be used to tune the long-range interactions between polar molecules and generate purely repulsive, step-like or strongly attractive potentials. This can be used to engineer strongly correlated quantum phases in a two-dimensional crystal of molecules. This system can also be used to realize effective lattice models with interparticle interactions described by exotic Hubbard Hamiltonians. Hubbard Hamiltonians are model Hamiltonians designed to describe low-energy physics of interacting fermions or bosons on a lattice. The authors show that internal degrees of freedom in ultracold molecules combined with the tunability of the many-body system of polar molecules in two dimensions may allow researchers to construct a complete toolbox for the simulation of any permutation-symmetric lattice spin model. At the conclusion of the chapter, the authors describe a setup that allows them to engineer many-body systems of ultracold polar molecules in which the two-body interactions are canceled and the dominant interaction is determined by three-body effects. This exotic system may find intriguing applications in condensed-matter physics.
COOLING AND TRAPPING OF PREEXISTING MOLECULES The workhorse of cold-atom physics, laser cooling, is inapplicable to most molecules (if to any at all). Necessity proved to be a mother of invention: a host of techniques, based on new principles independent of laser cooling, have been developed that make it possible to cool preexisting molecules. The swatch of these direct techniques is variegated and attests to the imagination of their inventors. The direct methods are currently being pursued by about 20 research groups worldwide, and are concerned with the development and applications of buffer-gas cooling, Stark or Zeeman deceleration, deceleration by pulsed optical fields, deceleration via collisions in crossed molecular beams, supersonic expansion from a counter-rotating nozzle, or selection of the low-velocity tail of a Maxwell–Boltzmann distribution of molecules in an effusive beam. All direct methods start with relatively hot molecules (200 to 1000 K), usually in the source of a supersonic molecular beam. Whereas the indirect methods are limited to molecules readily formed by photoassociation or magnetoassociation (e.g., diatomic molecules), the direct methods are versatile, applicable to large classes of molecules (e.g., Stark deceleration to all polar molecules; buffergas cooling coupled with magnetic trapping to all paramagnetic molecules) or to any molecules (all other direct techniques). Buffer-gas cooling and Stark deceleration © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
A Guided Tour of the Monograph
xxi
turned out to be the most effective among the direct techniques; each is described in some detail in a dedicated chapter. Wes Cambell and John Doyle, in Chapter 13, entitled “Cooling, Trap Loading, and Beam Production Using a Cryogenic Helium Buffer Gas,” survey the feats accomplished by thermalizing molecules via elastic collisions with a cryogenic He buffer gas. Buffer-gas cooling makes it possible to attain a temperature of about 0.5 K, which is not ultracold. However, a great advantage of the method (apart from its versatility) is its ability to cool and trap large numbers of molecules. By evaporating a fraction of the trapped molecules, it should be possible to cool the molecular ensemble further down toward the ultracold regime (<1 mK). Nevertheless, so far the initial numbers of trapped molecules and other factors, especially the buffer gas removal, have not made it possible to effectively apply such an evaporative cooling scheme. The number of the magnetically trapped molecules depends critically on the technique of loading the molecules into the buffer gas. Laser ablation can hardly evaporate more than 108 to 1013 atoms or molecules (with a single pulse). Therefore, a considerable effort has recently been put into developing an alternative technique of loading molecules into the cryogenic environment. The new technique is based on the use of a molecular beam made up of the molecules that are to be cooled. The molecular beam is simultaneously employed to transport the molecules into the cryogenic cell. Thus far, it has been possible to thermalize 1012 molecules of the NH radical, obtained by dissociating a pulsed beam of NH3 in an electric discharge. Unlike an conventional supersonic expansion, the authors show that it is possible to precool molecules to temperatures well below their boiling point before they are released through an orifice into a beam. In essence, molecules are cooled inside a cell held at a temperature of about 1 K by high-density helium and come out of an orifice in the cell (into a beam). Thus, molecules come out rotationally cold. If the helium density is high enough, most of the cold molecules inside the cell will exit into the beam with a forward velocity equal to that of the cold helium gas. This has been shown to produce very high fluxes of cold molecules, including cold molecular oxygen injected into a magnetic hexapole guide whose output flux was found to be in excess of 1012 sec−1 . Bas van de Meerakker, Rick Bethlem, and Gerard Meijer in Chapter 14, “Slowing, Trapping and Storing of Polar Molecules by Means of Electric Fields,” describe the techniques of Stark deceleration, dc and ac trapping, and storage of polar molecules using inhomogeneous electric fields. The authors first show that the technique of Stark deceleration (or acceleration) makes it possible not only to arbitrarily vary the velocity of polar molecules but also to select the molecules’ internal state (electronic, vibrational, and rotational) and orientation. The method thus allows for a complete control of molecules. The method makes use of a time-dependent inhomogeneous electric field, by means of which the Stark energy of polar molecules is altered. Stark energy represents the potential energy of molecules in an electric field. Its change is compensated for by a change in the kinetic translational energy of the molecules, as dictated by energy conservation. Depending on whether the Stark energy provided is negative or positive, the field causes either an acceleration or a deceleration along the longitudinal coordinate. In © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
xxii
A Guided Tour of the Monograph
order to be able to accelerate/decelerate a pulse of molecules with a distribution of coordinates and velocities (spatial and velocity spread), the acceleration/deceleration process must be carried out under the conditions of phase stability. This is discussed in some detail in the chapter, along with the transverse focusing needed to maintain the pulse of molecules on course along the longitudinal coordinate. Sufficiently slow polar molecules in a low-field seeking state can be confined in an electrostatic (dc) trap—a minimum of Stark energy in free three-dimensional space. A special case of an electrostatic trap, also discussed in the chapter, is a storage ring, which provides transverse but not longitudinal confinement for low-field seeking molecules. It is most simply implemented by bending a transverse focuser, such as a hexapole, onto itself. The low-field seekers then have a minimum of potential energy on a circle rather than at a single point. Compared with a trap, a storage ring is capable of confining molecules without the need to bring them to a standstill first. The circling packets of molecules can repeatedly interact, at well-defined times and positions, with electromagnetic fields and/or other atoms or molecules. In order to counteract the spreading of the packet in the ring—and thus to restore the ability to define the timing and position of the stored molecules—a storage ring was constructed consisting of two half-rings separated by a gap. Depending on the switching sequence, the gap can act as a time-varying inhomogeneous electric field (similar to a single stage of a Stark decelerator) that accelerates, decelerates, or just transports or bunches the molecular packet under the conditions of phase stability. The split-ring device thus represents a molecular analog of a synchrotron for charged particles. Bunching ensures a high density of the stored molecules and, in addition, enables injecting multiple packets—either copropagating or counterpropagating—into the ring independent of the packet(s) already stored. Trapping of molecules in high-field seeking states is of particular interest, chiefly because ground-state molecules are always high-field seeking. Since a ground state cannot decay, molecules trapped via their ground state cannot be lost from the trap by two-body relaxation processes, which plague trapping via low-field seeking states in electrostatic or magnetic traps. In the absence of a loss mechanism, ground-state molecules are expected to be amenable to evaporative or sympathetic cooling. We note that relaxation losses have been predicted to be particularly severe for polar molecules in excited rovibrational states. Another reason for developing traps for high-field seekers is that heavier molecules have small rotational constants (and, often, large dipole moments) and so become high-field seeking at relatively small field strengths, thereby precluding the application of large-enough forces required to trap or otherwise manipulate them. Since creating a maximum of a static field in free space is prohibited by a consequence of Maxwell’s equations, known as Earnshaw’s theorem, one has to rely on a trick similar to the one used in a Paul trap for ions: one generates a static field that has the shape of a saddle surface. Such a field focuses molecules in one direction and defocuses them in the perpendicular one. By reversing the polarity of the electrodes that generate the field (i.e., ac switching), the focusing and defocusing directions can be interchanged. The ac switching between the two field configurations causes the molecules to undergo an oscillatory micromotion whose frequency tends to get in step with the switching frequency. Since the force acting on the molecules increases with distance from the saddle point, the amplitude and thus © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
A Guided Tour of the Monograph
xxiii
the kinetic energy of the micromotion increases with distance as well. Because the kinetic energy of the micromotion is positive (as kinetic energy always is), it creates in effect a potential energy well, with a minimum at the trap center. The positive kinetic energy of the micromotion is independent of whether the molecules are in a low- or high-field-seeking state, which makes an ac trap work for either. It is noteworthy that electrostatic traps are about 1 K deep (depending on the molecular species and details of the trap design), and have a volume of typically 1 cm3 . An ac electric trap has a depth of about 1 to 10 mK and a volume of about 10−2 cm3 .
TESTS OF FUNDAMENTAL PHYSICS WITH COLD MOLECULES There is a class of experiments in prospect or progress with cold molecules that could answer questions reaching far beyond the scope of traditional molecular science: these experiments test some of the fundamental symmetries in physics, such as the time-reversal symmetry (T), parity (P), and the Pauli principle. These symmetries are a window into the world of the fundamental forces in nature and thus molecular, table-top experiments that test them are complementary to the high-energy collisional experiments. Particularly promising and interesting is the simultaneous testing of the timereversal symmetry and parity in experiments that search for the permanent electric dipole (EDM) of the electron (and of other elementary particles). A nonzero value of EDM implies the breaking of both T and P. Since the Standard Model predicts an unmeasurably small value for the electron EDM, finding a nonzero EDM would amount to the discovery of physics beyond the Standard Model. Such a discovery would revolutionize physics. In Chapter 15, “Preparation and Manipulation of Molecules for Fundamental Physics Tests,” Michael Tarbutt, Jony Hudson, Ben Sauer, and Ed Hinds show what the search for the EDM of the electron has to do with cold molecules. From the experiments carried out so far it is known that the EDM of the electron does not exceed the value of about 5 × 10−19 D. This is an exceedingly small value, one that would be found if an electron were expanded to the size of the Earth and deformed on the poles by a micron! A dipole moment manifests itself through its Stark effect, that is, by a shift of the energy levels of a system carrying the dipole moment when the system is subject to an electric field. In order for the Stark shift to be detectable, the EDM has to be exposed to as large a field as possible. The strongest fields that one can come by are available inside heavy atoms (where they can reach values of 10 GV/cm, thanks to relativistic effects). Atoms are spherically symmetric, however, and so before any EDM measurement they need to be oriented in the laboratory frame (otherwise the dipole moment would average out). But orienting atoms is difficult, because in doing so one has to rely on their polarizability, which is small. Therefore, it is of great advantage to add to a given heavy atom another atom, and to carry out the Stark effect measurement on the polar molecule that thereby ensues! Polar molecules can be easily oriented. In fact, a Stark decelerator and an electric trap are based on the ability to orient polar molecules easily in the laboratory frame. The use of cold polar molecules further enhances the resolution of the measurement. The experiment of the Hinds group with decelerated YbF molecules already comes close to yielding the © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
xxiv
A Guided Tour of the Monograph
most accurate value of the electron‘s EDM. An increase of the experimental accuracy by a single order of magnitude could lead to a rejection or adoption of some of the alternatives to the Standard Model. Molecules are beginning to play a key role in another area of fundamental interest, namely in testing the temporal and spatial variation of the fundamental constants. Molecular vibration, rotation, hyperfine structure, and other features offer combinations of the fundamental constants that are not available with atoms. Chapter 16, “Variation of the Fundamental Constants as Revealed by Molecules: Astrophysical Observations and Laboratory Experiments,” by Victor Flambaum and Mikhail Kozlov, describes the application of precision molecular spectroscopy to the study of a possible variation of the fundamental constants. The authors show that molecular spectra are mostly sensitive to two dimensionless constants, namely the fine-structure constant and the electron-to-proton mass ratio. The chapter discusses the results which follow from the astrophysical observations of the optical and microwave spectra of molecules, as well as possible laboratory experiments with molecules. Although the accuracy of the laboratory results cannot yet compete with that of the astrophysical observations, there are significantly improved experiments in progress that are likely to reverse this situation soon. The ideas behind these experiments and the preliminary experimental results so far obtained are discussed in detail. The authors show that the sensitivity for the variation of the fine-structure constant is particularly large for narrow, quasidegenerate levels of diatomic molecules. Such levels may come about due to a quasidegeneracy of either hyperfine and rotational levels, or between the fine and vibrational levels within the molecular electronic ground state. The transitions between the quasidegenerate levels correspond to microwave frequencies, which are experimentally accessible, and have narrow linewidths, typically ∼10−2 Hz. The sensitivity of the relative variation (frequencyto-frequency variation ratio) can exceed 105 in such cases.
QUANTUM COMPUTING WITH COLD MOLECULES Already atomic systems such as charged ions and neutral atoms have been shown to be attractive candidates for physical realization of quantum computation, in view of their exceptionally long coherence times and well-developed techniques for cooling and trapping. The main conceptual problems are associated with designing fast and robust multiatom operations for quantum entanglement as well as with scaling these systems to large numbers of qubits. Susanne Yelin, Dave DeMille, and Robin Cote show in Chapter 17, entitled “Quantum Information Processing with Ultracold Polar Molecules,” that ultracold polar molecules are a potentially superior candidate for the realization of quantum bits in a scalable quantum computer. Polar molecules combine the key advantages of neutral atoms and ions while featuring similarly long coherence times. In particular, large ensembles of cold molecules can be trapped and cooled similarly to neutral atoms, but they can then be manipulated individually using electric fields in analogy with ions. The first proposed complete scheme for quantum computing with polar molecules took advantage of the first feature, but not the second. It was based on an ensemble of ultracold polar molecules trapped in a one-dimensional optical lattice, combined © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
A Guided Tour of the Monograph
xxv
with an inhomogeneous electric field. The requisite entanglement is achieved via the interaction among the dipoles, each of which represents a qubit. Such qubits are individually addressable, thanks to the Stark effect, which is different for each molecule in the inhomogeneous electric field. A subsequent proposal showed that it may be possible to couple polar molecules into a quantum circuit using superconducting wires. The capacitive, electrodynamic coupling to transmission line resonators was proposed in analogy with coupling to Rydberg atoms and Cooper pair boxes. The key feature of molecules is their RF frequency rotational transitions, nicely compatible with microwave circuitry. Coupling individual molecules to microwave strip-lines is advantageous for several reasons. First, it allows for detection of single molecules by remote sensing of transmission line potentials, as well as for efficient quantum-state readout. Second, the molecules can be further cooled using a novel method involving microwave spontaneous emission into on-chip transmission lines. Finally, remotely separated molecules can be coherently coupled to allow for nonlocal operations. Local gating with electrostatic fields can be used to achieve an exceptional degree of addressability. Single-bit manipulations can be accomplished by using local modulated electric fields. The chapter provides a brief introduction to the field of quantum information processing and computation, discusses various platforms for implementing quantum computers, and makes the case for using permanent molecular dipoles as realizations of individually addressable qubits. A look into the future reveals the contours of a superconducting microwave resonator of an optical quantum computer enmeshed with an ensemble of polar molecules.
MUCH OF THE ABOVE WITH COLD MOLECULAR IONS Chapter 18 by Bernhard Roth and Stephan Schiller, entitled “Sympathetically Cooled Molecular Ions: From Principles to First Applications,” provides a superb introduction to the very different techniques used to study cold molecular ions and of their applications. First the authors provide some background on RF ion traps, ion cooling, and cold molecular ion production. The chapter focuses on the interpretation of images of Coulomb clusters formed by fluorescing atomic ions (e.g., alkaline earth positive ions) interacting with nonfluorescing ions (e.g., HD+ or alkaline earth hydride positive ions, formed by reaction of hydrogen molecules with alkaline earth positive ions). The molecular dynamics simulations of Coulomb clusters are compared with the fluorescent images of these same clusters, which allows for a detailed species and cluster-shape identification as well as for an understanding of the heating effects. Sympathetic cooling thus emerges as a general and well-understood method for producing cold molecular ions. Special topics, such as motional resonance coupling and species-selective ion removal follow, before ion-neutral chemical reactions and polyatomic molecule photofragmentation are discussed. The chapter concludes with a dream-come-true spectroscopy of the HD+ molecular ion. It is clear that the field of cold molecular ions represents an area of great opportunity for the pursuits of the ultracold. © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
xxvi
A Guided Tour of the Monograph
PROSPECTS This monograph reviews the past and surveys the present of cold molecule research, whose spirit, scope and promise all point to a bright future indeed. It is evident already that the experimental and theoretical research on cold and ultracold molecules has irreversibly changed atomic, molecular, and optical physics and quantum information science. Its impact on condensed-matter physics, astrophysics and physical chemistry is becoming apparent as well. It is also evident from the material expounded in this volume that the research field of cold molecules has been marching ahead with big strides. What seemed unfeasible less than ten years ago (e.g., the creation of ultracold polar molecules in the absolute ground state by photoassociation, magnetic trapping of dense molecular gases, and the collision experiments with molecules at ultracold temperatures, among others) has now been realized by multiple research groups. The main goal of the cold molecule experiments over the past five years has been the creation of stable and dense ensembles of ultracold molecules. With this goal accomplished, at least for some molecular systems, a part of the experimental effort is now focusing on applications. Ultracold chemistry, molecular Bose–Einstein condensates, and coherent control of ultracold molecular processes are no longer in the realm of theory only. The close interplay between theory and experiment has been instrumental for the success of cold molecule research. As this research is becoming increasingly multidisciplinary, the role of theory is shifting toward identifying new applications of cold and ultracold molecules in a variety of areas of physics and chemistry. In conclusion, we are pleased to say that the properties of ultracold molecules and the prospects for diverse applications of ultracold molecular gases seem to have captured the imagination of the physics and chemistry communities at large. Cold molecules are enjoying a happy life and their ending is nowhere in sight. Roman V. Krems, Canada William C. Stwalley, USA Bretislav Friedrich, Germany
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
Editors Roman V. Krems is an assistant professor at the University of British Columbia in Vancouver, Canada. He graduated from Moscow State University, Russia, in 1999 and obtained a PhD in physical chemistry from Göteborg University, Sweden, in 2002. He was a Smithsonian Institute predoctoral fellow at the HarvardSmithsonian Center for Astrophysics in 2001–2002 and a postdoctoral fellow at the Harvard-MIT Center for Ultracold Atoms in 2003–2005. His current research focuses on the theoretical study of new methods for the production of ultracold molecules, understanding the effects of external electromagnetic fields on dynamics of molecules at low temperatures and the interaction properties of cold and ultracold molecules, and ultracold chemistry. William C. Stwalley is Board of Trustees Distinguished Professor and Department Head of Physics at the University of Connecticut. He graduated from the California Institute of Technology with a BS in chemistry in 1964 and from Harvard University with a PhD in physical chemistry in 1969. He was a faculty member at the University of Iowa from 1968 to 1993 in chemistry and later in physics as well, serving as director of the Iowa Laser Facility from 1976 to 1993 and George Glockler Professor of Physical Science from 1988–1993. His awards include Fellowship in the American Physical Society, the Optical Society of America, and the American Association for Advancement of Science, an Outstanding Referee award (American Physical Society, APS), the William F. Meggers Award (the Optical Society of America, OSA), and the State of Connecticut Medal of Science (2005). His research has focused on atomic and molecular interactions from collisions, spectroscopy and theory, with particular interest in the interactions of alkali metal (and hydrogen) atoms. Recent work has emphasized such studies at ultracold temperatures using photoassociation and related techniques. Bretislav Friedrich is a research group leader at the Fritz-Haber-Institut der MaxPlanck-Gesellschaft, Berlin, Honorarprofessor at the Technische Universität Berlin, and co-director of the History and Foundations of Quantum Physics Program in Berlin. He graduated from Charles University, Prague, in 1976, and earned his PhD in chemical physics from the Czech Academy of Sciences, in 1981. His awards include an Iberdrola Fellowship (Spain) and an Outstanding Referee award (APS). His experimental and theoretical research at Göttingen (1986–87), Harvard (1987–2003), and Berlin (from 2003) have dealt with interactions of molecules with fields, molecular spectroscopy, molecular collisions, and molecular cooling and trapping. He has taught undergraduate and graduate courses in physical chemistry and molecular physics as well as in the history of science.
xxvii © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
Contributors Naduvalath Balakrishnan Department of Chemistry University of Nevada Las Vegas Las Vegas, Nevada
Dave DeMille Department of Physics Yale University New Haven, Connecticut
Hendrick L. Bethlem Laser Centre Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, Netherlands
John M. Doyle Department of Physics Harvard University Cambridge, Massachusetts
John L. Bohn JILA University of Colorado Boulder, Colorado
Edward E. Eyler Department of Physics University of Connecticut Storrs, Connecticut
Hans-Peter Büchler Institute for Theoretical Physics III University of Stuttgart Stuttgart, Germany
Francesca Ferlaino Institute of Experimental Physics and Center for Quantum Physics University of Innsbruck Innsbruck, Austria
Wesley C. Campbell Department of Physics Harvard University Cambridge, Massachusetts Robin Côté Department of Physics University of Connecticut Storrs, Connecticut Alexander Dalgarno Institute for Theoretical Atomic, Molecular and Optical Physics Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics Cambridge, Massachusetts
and Institute for Quantum Optics and Quantum Information Austrian Academy of Sciences Innsbruck, Austria Victor V. Flambaum School of Physics The University of New South Wales Sydney, Australia Phillip L. Gould Department of Physics University of Connecticut Storrs, Connecticut
xxix © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
xxx
Contributors
Rudolf Grimm Institute of Experimental Physics and Center for Quantum Physics University of Innsbruck Innsbruck, Austria
Steven Knoop Institute of Experimental Physics and Center for Quantum Physics University of Innsbruck Innsbruck, Austria
and
and
Institute for Quantum Optics and Quantum Information Austrian Academy of Sciences Vienna, Austria
Institute for Quantum Optics and Quantum Information Austrian Academy of Sciences Vienna, Austria
Thomas M. Hanna Department of Physics Clarendon Laboratory University of Oxford Oxford, United Kingdom
Thorsten Köhler Department of Physics and Astronomy University College London London, United Kingdom
Edward A. Hinds Centre for Cold Matter The Blackett Laboratory Imperial College London London, United Kingdom Jony J. Hudson Centre for Cold Matter The Blackett Laboratory Imperial College London London, United Kingdom Jeremy M. Hutson Department of Chemistry University of Durham Durham, United Kingdom Paul S. Julienne Joint Quantum Institute National Institute of Standards and Technology and University of Maryland Gaithersburg, Maryland
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
Mikhail G. Kozlov Petersburg Nuclear Physics Institute Gatchina, Russia Roman V. Krems Department of Chemistry University of British Columbia Vancouver, Canada Eliane Luc-Koenig Laboratoire Aimé Cotton, CNRS Université Paris Sud XI Orsay, France Hugo Martay Department of Physics University of Oxford, Clarendon Laboratory Oxford, United Kingdom Françoise Masnou-Seeuws Laboratoire Aimé Cotton, CNRS Université Paris Sud XI Orsay, France
xxxi
Contributors
Gerard Meijer Fritz-Haber-Institut der Max-Planck-Gesellschaft Berlin, Germany Andrea Micheli Institute for Theoretical Physics University of Innsbruck and Institute for Quantum Optics and Quantum Information Innsbruck, Austria Dmitry S. Petrov Laboratoire de Physique Théorique et Modèles Statistiques Université Paris-Sud Orsay, France and Russian Research Center Kurchatov Institute Moscow, Russia Guido Pupillo Institute for Theoretical Physics University of Innsbruck and Institute for Quantum Optics and Quantum Information Innsbruck, Austria Goulven Quéméner Department of Chemistry University of Nevada Las Vegas Las Vegas, Nevada
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
Bernhard Roth Institute of Experimental Physics Heinrich-Heine-University Düsseldorf Düsseldorf, Germany Christophe Salomon Laboratoire Kastler Brossel Ecole Normale Supérieure Paris, France Ben E. Sauer Centre for Cold Matter The Blackett Laboratory Imperial College London London, United Kingdom Stephan Schiller Institute of Experimental Physics Heinrich-Heine-University Düsseldorf Düsseldorf, Germany Evgeny A. Shapiro Departments of Chemistry and Physics University of British Columbia Vancouver, Canada Moshe Shapiro Departments of Chemistry and Physics University of British Columbia Vancouver, Canada and Department of Chemical Physics The Weizmann Institute Rehovot, Israel
xxxii
Georgy V. Shlyapnikov Laboratoire de Physique Théorique et Modèles Statistiques Université Paris-Sud Orsay, France and Van der Waals–Zeeman Institute University of Amsterdam Amsterdam, Netherlands William C. Stwalley Department of Physics University of Connecticut Storrs, Connecticut Michael R. Tarbutt Centre for Cold Matter The Blackett Laboratory Imperial College London London, United Kingdom Timur V. Tscherbul Harvard-MIT Center for Ultracold Atoms and Institute for Theoretical Atomic, Molecular, and Optical Physics
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
Contributors
Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics Cambridge, Massachusetts Sebastiaan Y.T. van de Meerakker Fritz-Haber-Institut der Max-Planck-Gesellschaft Berlin, Germany Susanne F. Yelin Department of Physics University of Connecticut Storrs, Connecticut and Institute for Theoretical Atomic, Molecular and Optical Physics Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics Cambridge, Massachusetts Peter Zoller Institute for Theoretical Physics University of Innsbruck and Institute for Quantum Optics and Quantum Information Innsbruck, Austria
Part I Cold Collisions
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
Theory of Cold Atomic 1 and Molecular Collisions Jeremy M. Hutson CONTENTS 1.1 1.2
Introduction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Classical Collision Theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2.1 Laboratory and Center of Mass Coordinates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2.2 Cross-Sections and Rate Coefficients . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2.3 Elastic, Inelastic, and Reactive Scattering . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2.4 Centrifugal Barriers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2.5 Structured Particles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3 Quantum Collision Theory. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3.1 Single-Channel Scattering (for Unstructured Atoms) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3.1.1 Bound States . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3.1.2 Low-Energy Collisions. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3.1.3 Numerical Methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3.2 Multichannel Scattering . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3.2.1 Atom–Diatom Scattering . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3.2.2 Scattering of Metastable Helium Atoms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3.3 Coupled Equations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3.3.1 Scattering Calculations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3.3.2 Numerical Methods for Scattering . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3.3.3 Decoupling Approximations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3.3.4 Bound States . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3.3.5 Numerical Methods for Bound States . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3.4 Quasibound States and Scattering Resonances . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3.5 Low-Energy Scattering . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3.6 Collisions in External Fields . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3.6.1 Basis Sets without Total Angular Momentum . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3.6.2 Spin Relaxation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3.6.3 Zero-Energy Feshbach Resonances . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.4 Reactive Scattering . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.4.1 Langevin Model for Barrierless Reactions. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
4 4 4 5 6 7 7 7 7 11 11 13 15 15 16 17 19 19 20 21 21 23 25 26 27 28 28 30 32 34 3
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
4
1.1
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
INTRODUCTION
An understanding of atomic and molecular interactions and collisions is essential to the study of cold and ultracold molecules. Collisions govern the lifetime of molecules in traps and determine whether proposed cooling schemes will work. Once atoms and molecules are in the ultracold regime, the extent to which their interactions can be controlled depends on a detailed understanding of their collisional properties. The purpose of this chapter is to outline atomic and molecular collision theory and describe the special features that are important to the study of cold molecules.
1.2
CLASSICAL COLLISION THEORY
Studies of cold molecules focus on behavior at temperatures below 1 K and sometimes as low as 1 nK. At such temperatures the de Broglie wavelengths for translational motion become quite large, and at the lower end of the temperature range it becomes meaningless to consider atoms and molecules as classical particles—a quantum-mechanical treatment is essential. Nevertheless, a classical treatment is relevant at higher temperatures and provides many useful concepts, so we will begin with an outline of classical scattering before proceeding to a more detailed treatment of quantum scattering. More detailed treatments are given in various textbooks, such as those of Child [1] and Levine [2].
1.2.1
LABORATORY AND CENTER OF MASS COORDINATES
Consider two atoms or molecules with masses m1 and m2 with positions r1 (t) and r2 (t) as a function of time t. (Bold type indicates vector quantities.) The initial velocities of the particles are given by v1 and v2 . After an elastic or inelastic collision (in which the chemical identities and masses of the collision partners do not change, see Section 1.2.3) the colliding particles have velocities v1 and v2 . These are the laboratory coordinates of the particles; most experiments provide information about collisions in the laboratory frame. For calculations on atomic and molecular collisions, it is almost always convenient to transform to center of mass coordinates. The centre of mass is at R, where R=
m 1
M
r1 +
m 2
M
r2 .
(1.1)
The center of mass moves like a particle with mass M and velocity V, where M = m1 + m2 m m m m 1 2 1 2 v1 + v2 = v1 + v2 . V= M M M M © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
(1.2)
Theory of Cold Atomic and Molecular Collisions
5
The classical kinetic energy T , linear momentum p, and angular momentum L may be written T=
1 1 1 1 m1 v12 + m1 v12 = MV 2 + μv 2 2 2 2 2
p = m1 v1 + m2 v2 = MV
(1.3)
L = m1 (r1 ∧ v1 ) + m2 (r2 ∧ v2 ) = μ(r ∧ v), where μ is the reduced mass, μ = m1 m2 /(m1 + m2 ), and r and v are the relative position and velocity vectors, r = r1 − r2 and v = v1 − v2 . The motion of the particles is governed by the potential energy U. If U is independent of the position of the center of mass, as is the case in field-free space or in the presence of homogeneous fields, the equations of motion (classical or quantum) factorize into separate equations for the center of mass and for the relative motion. The total linear momentum p is conserved in a collision, so the center of mass moves uniformly (constant velocity V) and is unaffected by the collision. The kinetic energy T is conserved in elastic collisions, and L is conserved if the angular momenta of the particles themselves do not change in magnitude or direction. Collision calculations are almost always carried out in the center of mass frame, which moves with the center of mass. The relative motion of the two particles is described as that of a single particle of mass μ subject to an interaction potential V (which is not the same asV in Equation 1.3). For structureless particles V depends only on the interparticle distance r, but more generally it also depends on internal degrees of freedom such as spins and rotations. Once the equations have been solved for the relative motion, they can, if desired, be transformed back into laboratory coordinates.
1.2.2
CROSS-SECTIONS AND RATE COEFFICIENTS
Consider the collision of two particles initially in internal states described by an index i. To simplify notation, it is convenient to use a single index to specify the states of both particles. The angle between the initial and final relative velocities v and v is given by spherical polar coordinates Θ and Φ, where Θ is the deflection angle in the center of mass frame. We start with a well-defined beam of particles with a flux Ii (number of particles per unit area per unit time). After the collision, the flux Ij (number of particles per unit solid angle per unit time) is a function of the deflection angle Θ and is different for each possible set of final internal states j. We define the differential cross-section as dσij Ij = , dω Ii
(1.4)
where ω is an element of solid angle at deflection angle Θ. The corresponding integral cross-section σij is integrated over all possible final directions, so it contains information about the total probability of the transition i → j, 2π π dσij σij = sin Θ dΘ dΦ. (1.5) dω 0 0 © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
6
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
Under most circumstances the differential cross-section is independent of Φ in the center of mass frame so that the integration over Φ in Equation 1.5 is equivalent to multiplication by 2π. The integral cross-section should not be confused with the total cross-section, which is usually understood to be summed over all possible final states j; thus it is possible to speak of total differential or total integral cross-sections. The differential cross-section has dimensions of area/solid angle, and the integral cross-section has dimensions of area. Cross-sections are functions of collision energy. However, many experiments are not monoenergetic and involve distributions of energy. The overall rate of a process i → j is given by the rate coefficient kij = vσij , where the extra factor v arises because the collision rate is proportional to v. When there is a distribution of relative velocities f (v) this must be further averaged, kij =
∞
vf (v)σij dv.
(1.6)
0
The velocity distribution function is normalized so that gases it is commonly a Maxwell distribution, f (v) =
μ 2πkB T
3/2
∞
0
f (v) dv = 1. For thermal
−μv 2 4πv exp 2kB T 2
,
(1.7)
but other distributions can be important in cold molecule studies.
1.2.3
ELASTIC, INELASTIC, AND REACTIVE SCATTERING
It is useful to classify the possible outcomes of collisions as elastic, inelastic, and reactive: • An elastic collision is one in which the kinetic energy of relative motion of the two particles does not change, though their individual kinetic energies and velocities may change. • An inelastic collision is one in which energy is transferred between internal and relative kinetic energy, but the chemical constitution of the collision partners is unchanged. • A reactive collision is one in which the products are chemically distinct from the reactants, usually also involving a change in relative kinetic energy. These definitions are not quite universal. Collisions in which the internal state of one or both collision partners changes are sometimes considered inelastic even if the total internal energy is unchanged, so that there is no change in relative kinetic energy. Collisions in which the possibility of atom transfer needs to be taken into account in the dynamics are often considered reactive, even if the final products are indistinguishable from the reactants. © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
Theory of Cold Atomic and Molecular Collisions
1.2.4
7
CENTRIFUGAL BARRIERS
It is usually convenient to consider collisions in spherical polar coordinates that describe the relative positions of the particles. In such a coordinate system the equations of motion for the interparticle distance r are governed by a centrifugally corrected effective potential, VL . For structureless particles where V depends only on r, |L|2 , (1.8) VL (r) = V (r) + 2μr 2 where |L| is the magnitude of the relative angular momentum of the two particles about one another. The interaction potential between two atoms or molecules dies off as r −n at long range, where n ≥ 2 except for collisions between two charged particles. Because the potential is attractive at some or all angles, the effective potential for |L| > 0 usually has a maximum. There is therefore a centrifugal barrier in the effective potential. In classical scattering at kinetic energies below the maximum, the particles cannot penetrate the barrier and do not enter the short-range region. In quantum scattering there is the possibility of tunneling into or through the barrier.
1.2.5
STRUCTURED PARTICLES
In practice, most of the collisions of interest in cold molecule studies involve collision partners with internal structure. Many of the atoms and molecules of interest have unpaired spins, and molecules have vibrational and rotational levels. Even nuclear hyperfine splittings, which are small enough to be neglected in many areas of chemistry, are large enough to be important in cold molecule studies. It is thus crucial to be able to handle collisions between atoms and molecules with internal structure. Although methods based on classical trajectories have had considerable success for inelastic and reactive collisions at room temperature or higher [3], for cold atoms and molecules it is almost always necessary to treat the collisions quantum-mechanically.
1.3
QUANTUM COLLISION THEORY
In quantum mechanics, atomic and molecular collisions may be handled using either time-dependent or time-independent approaches. Time-dependent (wavepacket) methods have recently become very popular for handling molecular collisions at temperatures around room temperature and higher [4,5]. However, at very low collision energies the usual time-dependent methods become hard to implement, both because it takes a very long time to complete a collision and because the absorbing potentials that are usually used at long range tend to cause unphysical reflections. It is thus usual to handle the low-energy collisions that are important in cold molecule studies using time-independent methods.
1.3.1
SINGLE-CHANNEL SCATTERING (FOR UNSTRUCTURED ATOMS)
Most of the processes of interest in cold collision studies involve structured particles, but there are some ideas that are most simply introduced for unstructured particles. © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
8
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
We introduce a time-independent wavefunction Ψ that represents the complete two-particle collision system. For unstructured particles this depends only on r, the relative position vector. We represent the wavefunction in the absence of scattering as a plane wave Ψ0 = eik·r , where k is the wavevector describing the relative motion and its magnitude k is the corresponding wavenumber. The relative kinetic energy Ekin is 2 k 2 /2μ. This corresponds to an incoming flux density Ii = k/μ, which corresponds classically to the relative velocity v for a wave with unit particle density. The total wavefunction, including the effects of scattering, behaves asymptotically (at very large r) as r→∞
Ψ(r) ∼ Ψ0 (r) + f (Θ)
eikr , r
(1.9)
where the complex quantity f (Θ) is the scattering amplitude (which is zero in the absence of any collisions). The scattering is cylindrically symmetric about the initial relative velocity vector so it is convenient to expand the scattering amplitude in Legendre polynomials PL (cos Θ), f (Θ) =
∞
fL PL (cos Θ).
(1.10)
L=0
The incoming plane wave may also be expanded in Legendre polynomials using the identity ∞
eik·r = (2L + 1)iL PL (cos Θ)jL (kr), (1.11) L=0
where the functions jL (r) are spherical Bessel functions [6], which have the asymptotic form r→∞
jL (kr) ∼ (kr)−1 sin(kr − Lπ/2).
(1.12)
The quantum number L represents the orbital angular momentum for end-over-end motion of the two particles around one another. L has nothing to do with any electron orbital angular momentum that is present in the system. For single-channel scattering, different values of L are referred to as different partial waves. The Schrödinger equation for relative motion of two unstructured particles in free space is 2 2 (1.13) − ∇ + V (r) Ψ(r) = EΨ(r). 2μ It is usually convenient to take E = 0 to be the energy of the separated particles, so that V (r) → 0 as r → ∞. Ψ(r) may be expanded as
ψL (r)PL (cos Θ), (1.14) Ψ(r) = r −1 L
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
9
Theory of Cold Atomic and Molecular Collisions
and substituting this into Equation 1.13 gives independent equations for the different values of L, 2 d2 − + VL (r) ψL (r) = EψL (r), (1.15) 2μ dr 2 where the centrifugally corrected potential VL (r) is VL (r) = V (r) +
2 L(L + 1) . 2μr 2
(1.16)
This is simply the quantal form of the classical Equation 1.8. Although the wavefunction of Equation 1.9 is complex, it is sufficient to work with real solutions of Equation 1.15 that are regular at the origin (usually ψL → 0 as r → 0 provided VL (r) 0 at r = 0). Typical solutions are shown in Figure 1.1. They have the long-range form r→∞
ψL (r) ∼ krjL (kr + δL ),
(1.17)
Energy
where jL (kr) is a spherical Bessel function [6] and krjL (kr) (sometimes called a Riccati–Bessel function) is the solution of Equation 1.15 with V (r) = 0, i.e., for free
Scattering states
Centrifugal barrier
Dissociation energy
Bound states
r
FIGURE 1.1 Effective potential for single-channel scattering, showing centrifugal barrier and typical wavefunctions for bound and scattering states.
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
10
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
motion of noninteracting particles. At very long range, where the centrifugal potential is negligible, the solutions may be written r→∞
ψL (r) ∼ sin(kr − Lπ/2 + δL ).
(1.18)
The quantity δL is the phase shift for partial wave L and is zero in the absence of interaction, i.e., if V (r) is zero. The scattering amplitude may be written in terms of phase shifts as f (Θ) =
∞ 1
(2L + 1)(e2iδL − 1)PL (cos Θ). 2ik
(1.19)
L=0
The differential cross-section is dσ = | f (Θ)|2 dω
(1.20)
and thus involves a double sum over partial waves. Structure in the differential crosssection arises from interference between the contributions of different partial waves. The total elastic cross-section is ∞
4π
(2L + 1) sin2 δL . σ= 2 k
(1.21)
L=0
The equations above refer to scattering of distinguishable particles. For identical bosons (fermions), only even (odd) values of L are allowed and the prefactors are modified. The expressions for cross-sections involve sums over partial waves L that formally run from zero to infinity. In practice, however, for sufficiently high L the centrifugal barrier in the effective potential VL (r) keeps the particles far enough apart that there is no significant scattering. The usual approach is therefore to begin the summation at low L and keep adding contributions until the sum converges, i.e., until several successive L values make negligible contributions. There is an approximate correspondence between the partial wave quantum number L and the classical impact parameter b, which describes a collision in terms of the closest distance that the two particles would approach one another if they were noninteracting, b2 ∼
L(L + 1) . k2
(1.22)
In general terms, a collision can contribute to cross-sections if b is less than the distance outside which the interaction potential is negligible. For heavy-particle collisions at room temperature or above, it is common to need hundreds or even thousands of partial waves to converge the sums. For cold collisions, however, much smaller numbers of partial waves are needed and ultracold cross-sections are often dominated by a single partial wave: L = 0 for distinguishable particles or indistinguishable bosons and L = 1 for indistinguishable fermions. Low partial waves are sometimes referred to using electronic orbital terminology: s-wave, p-wave, d-wave for L = 0, 1, 2, and so on. © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
11
Theory of Cold Atomic and Molecular Collisions
1.3.1.1
Bound States
When the interaction potential V (r) is attractive, the Schrödinger equation (1.15) may support bound-state solutions at energies E < 0 (below the dissociation energy) as well as scattering solutions at energies E > 0, as shown in Figure 1.1. In practice, almost all systems of interest support many bound states. The boundary conditions for bound states are different from those for scattering states, and in particular ψL (r) → 0
r→∞
as
or
r → 0.
(1.23)
For deep wells the low-lying bound states are often harmonic-oscillator-like, with a spacing that depends mainly on the curvature of the potential near the minimum. Just below dissociation (at E = 0), however, the bound states are densely packed. Numerical methods for finding bound-state solutions of Equation 1.15 are described in Section 1.3.1.3. However, in conceptual terms a considerable amount may be understood in terms of semiclassical arguments [7]. In semiclassical methods, the Schrödinger equation is expanded semiclassically in powers of . The resulting first-order JWKB (Jeffreys–Wentzel–Kramers–Brillouin) quantization condition gives remarkably accurate results for the vibration-rotation energies EvL of diatomic molecules: ΦL (EvL ) = (v + 21 )π,
(1.24)
where v is the vibrational quantum number and the phase integral ΦL (E) is ΦL (E) =
rmax
rmin
2μ[E − VL (r)] 2
1/2 dr.
(1.25)
The integral is taken between the classical turning points rmin and rmax at energy E, such that VL (rmin ) = VL (rmax ) = E. At energies near the potential minimum, where rmin and rmax are (relatively) close together, ΦL (E) increases relatively slowly with energy and the bound states are far apart. Conversely, near dissociation, where rmin and rmax are far apart, ΦL (E) increases quickly with energy and the bound states are close together. 1.3.1.2
Low-Energy Collisions
Collisions at low energy exhibit special behavior. It is useful to define a k-dependent scattering length aL by − tan δL . (1.26) aL (k) = k The s-wave scattering length a0 (k) (or often just a(k)) is particularly important because the s-wave elastic cross-section is given simply by σ(k) =
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
4πa2 . 1 + a2 k 2
(1.27)
12
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
The scattering length becomes constant at very low energy, with leading correction terms given by effective range theory [8], 1 a(k) = a(0) + k 2 r0 a(0)2 + O(k 4 ), 2
(1.28)
where r0 is the effective range. The physical interpretation of the zero-energy scattering length a(0) (or often just a) is that, when E = V (r), the wavefunction ψL=0 (r) has zero curvature. As r → ∞, ψL=0 (r) for zero energy is thus a straight line. The extrapolation of this straight line cuts the distance axis at a separation R = a0 , which may be positive or negative. In the special case where there is a bound state exactly at zero energy, the zeroenergy wavefunction at long range is a straight line with zero slope, and the scattering length a0 is infinite. The quantization condition of Equation 1.24 suggests that for L = 0 there will be a zero-energy vibrational level and thus an infinite scattering length when Φ0 (0) = (v + 21 )π. However, this is not quite correct; Gribakin and Flambaum [9] have shown that, if V (r) behaves at long range as V (r) = −Cn /r n , the zero-energy scattering length is given semiclassically by
a0 = a¯ 1 − tan
π π tan Φ0 (0) − , n−2 2(n − 2)
(1.29)
where Φ0 (0) is evaluated at E = 0. The mean scattering length a¯ is
√ 2/(n−2) Γ n−3 n−2 π 2μCn a¯ = cos n−1 n − 2 (n − 2) Γ n−2
(1.30)
and is a function only of n, Cn , and the reduced mass μ. The scattering length given by Equation 1.29 is infinite when Φ 1 1 =v+ + π 2 2(n − 2)
(1.31)
instead of simply v + 21 . Boisseau and colleagues [10,11] have demonstrated that the semiclassical quantization condition of Equation 1.24 breaks down very close to dissociation and have explored corrections to it consistent with Equation 1.29. The zero-energy scattering length is very sensitive to the details of the interaction potential. If we consider multiplying the (attractive) interaction potential V (r) by a factor λ, the typical behavior of a0 for the single-channel case is shown in Figure 1.2. As the potential depth is reduced it supports fewer and fewer bound states, and every time there is a bound state at exactly zero energy there is a√pole in the scattering length. The quantity Φ0 (0) in Equation 1.29 is proportional to λ. If the potential supports nb bound states, then changing it by 2 parts in nb is enough to take the scattering length a0 through a complete cycle (from one pole to the next). A much smaller change in the potential can cause substantial changes in a0 , especially near poles in Figure 1.2. © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
13
Theory of Cold Atomic and Molecular Collisions 10
a –a
5
0
–5
–10 0.9
0.95
1
1.05
1.1
l
FIGURE 1.2 The s-wave scattering length as a function of potential scaling factor λ: in this case λ = 1 corresponds to a potential with 100 bound states and the potential behaves at long range as V (r) = −C6 r −6 .
For this reason it is very difficult to obtain reliable scattering lengths from ab initio electronic structure calculations, except for systems with quite shallow wells (such as those for collisions with He). When there is a bound state just below dissociation, the scattering length is given by a=
[2 /(2μEbind )]
(1.32)
where Ebind is the binding energy of the highest level. More generally, for collisions of unstructured particles a0 is a function of the fractional part of the noninteger quantum number at dissociation vD ,
π 1 (1.33) tan vD + 2 π . a0 = a¯ 1 − tan n−2 1.3.1.3
Numerical Methods
Single-channel collision problems are usually handled by propagation methods, whereas bound-state problems can be handled either by propagation or by basis set methods. The general strategy in propagation methods is to define a grid of points between a distance rmin at very short range and a distance rmax at long range. It is useful to divide © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
14
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
the integration range into two or more regions. The inner classically forbidden region is the region near the origin where VL (r) > E. Conversely, the classically allowed region is the region where VL (r) < E. The classically allowed region is separated from the inner classically forbidden region by the inner turning point, with VL (r) = E; this is the point at which a classical particle would stop and turn around. For bound-state problems, where VL (r) > E at long range, there is also an outer classically forbidden region at large r where VL (r) > E, which is separated from the classically allowed region by the outer turning point. In general, of course, it is possible for there to be more than one classically allowed region and additional classical turning points. This is particularly common in cold molecule applications when the collision energy is lower than the height of a centrifugal barrier in VL (r). For a scattering calculation, it is sufficient to solve Equation 1.15 numerically by propagating ψL (r) outwards, starting at a point rmin deep in the inner classically forbidden region. In the classically forbidden region, the wavefunction curves away from zero according to Equation 1.15. Thus a solution that starts from zero will increase approximately exponentially until it reaches the inner turning point, then start to oscillate. The usual procedure is to propagate the solution out to a distance rmax and then to match the wavefunction and its derivative to Equation 1.17 to obtain the phase shift δL . This is then repeated for sufficient values of L to obtain convergence of the summations in the expressions for cross-sections. The propagation can be carried out using any of a variety of techniques for solving second-order differential equations, such as the renormalized Numerov method of Johnson [12]. For bound states the problem is a little more difficult, because solutions of Equation 1.15 that satisfy the boundary conditions Equation 1.23 do not exist at all energies. In general, if a solution of the differential equation that satisfies the boundary condition at one end of the range is calculated at an arbitrary energy, it will not satisfy the boundary condition at the other end of the range. Furthermore, propagating a solution of a differential equation into a classically forbidden region is a notoriously unstable procedure, because any exponentially increasing component quickly dominates the (usually desired) exponentially decreasing component, and any information about the exponentially decreasing component becomes lost in the numerical errors. This is not a problem when propagating a solution out of a classically forbidden region, because the exponentially increasing solution is then the one that is wanted. The approach usually adopted is to guess an energy Etrial and propagate a solution ψ+ (r) outwards from rmin to a point rmid in the classically allowed region. A second solution ψ− (r) is then propagated inwards to meet it from a point rmax , far into the outer classically forbidden region. The two solutions are arbitrarily normalized, so their values can always be made to agree at the matching point by renormalizing them. However, for a finite potential VL (r), the derivative ψ (r) of the wavefunction must be continuous, as well as its value ψ(r). The criterion for Etrial to be an eigenvalue is therefore [ψ+ ] (rmid )/ψ+ (rmid ) = [ψ− ] (rmid )/ψ− (rmid ), (1.34) where the superscripts + and − indicate outwards and inwards solutions originating at short and long range, respectively. The matching function [ψ+ ] /ψ+ − [ψ− ] /ψ− is thus a function of energy that is zero when E is an eigenvalue; it would be possible to © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
Theory of Cold Atomic and Molecular Collisions
15
converge on an eigenvalue simply by using one of the standard numerical procedures for finding a zero of a function, such as the secant method, to find a zero of the difference of the normalized derivatives. However, in the one-dimensional case, it is common to use Numerov propagation with an explicit energy correction formula due to Cooley [13], which gives quadratic convergence in the energy. This algorithm usually converges to ±10−6 cm−1 in less than 10 iterations, so that it offers a very efficient method for finding eigenvalues and eigenfunctions of one-dimensional Schrödinger equations.
1.3.2
MULTICHANNEL SCATTERING
The discussion of quantum scattering so far has concentrated on collisions between unstructured particles with only a single internal state. However, most systems of interest involve structured particles. The Hamiltonian for the colliding pair may generally be written 2 (1.35) − ∇ 2 + Hˆ int (τ) + V (r, τ), 2μ where τ denotes all coordinates except the interparticle distance r and Hˆ int (τ) represents the internal Hamiltonians of the two particles. The intermolecular potential V (r, τ) is now a function of τ as well as r. The wavefunction for a pair of colliding particles may be written in the form
Ψ(r, τ) = r −1 φi (τ)ψi (r), (1.36) i
where the channel functions {φi (τ)} form a basis set in the τ coordinates. The total wavefunction Ψ(r, τ) thus has components in each channel i. For both bound states and scattering, the wavefunction must be regular at the origin, and when V (r) 0 as r → 0 the short-range boundary conditions are ψi (r) → 0
as
r → 0.
(1.37)
The particular sets of channel functions needed are different for each type of scattering problem, and it would be quite impossible to enumerate all the possibilities, so just two relatively simple examples will be given here: atom–diatom scattering and collisions of metastable helium atoms. 1.3.2.1 Atom–Diatom Scattering Consider collisions between a structureless atom A and a closed-shell diatomic molecule BC, which is allowed to rotate but not vibrate. Nuclear spins are neglected. The orientation of the diatomic molecule is described by a unit vector rˆBC with spherical polar coordinates (θBC , φBC ). The corresponding rotational wavefunctions are spherical harmonics Yjmj (ˆrBC ) = Yjmj (θBC , φBC ). The position of the atom with respect to the center of mass of the diatom is given by spherical polar coordinates (r, rˆA ) = (r, θA , φA ) with corresponding spherical harmonics YLmL (ˆrA ). © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
16
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
It is possible to expand the total wavefunction as in Equation 1.36 using simple products of spherical harmonics, φi (τ) = Yjmj (ˆrBC )YLmL (ˆrA ).
(1.38)
In this representation, the index i represents the set of quantum numbers { j, mj , L, mL }. This expansion is suitable under some circumstances, such as calculations on collisions in applied electric and magnetic fields. However, for field-free scattering it is inefficient because it fails to take advantage of the fact that the total angular momentum J is a good quantum number. It is therefore usual to use the Arthurs–Dalgarno total angular momentum representation [14], with basis functions that are eigenfunctions of Jˆ 2 and JˆZ as well as ˆj2 and Lˆ 2 . These are formed as linear combinations of the simple product functions,
JMJ φi (τ) = YjL = jmj LmL |JMJ Yjmj (ˆrBC )YLmL (ˆrA ), (1.39) mj mL
where jmj LmL |JMJ is a Clebsch–Gordan vector coupling coefficient. The index i thus represents the set of quantum numbers { j, L, J, MJ }. The Hamiltonian of the colliding pair is diagonal in the quantum numbers J and MJ (and independent of MJ ). It is therefore adequate to solve equations for each value of J separately, which results in very large savings in computer time. The computational efficiency may be further increased by taking advantage of other symmetries such as total parity. For each value of J, the channel basis set contains a set of functions with values of j and L that can couple together to give a resultant J. There are matrix elements involving the anisotropic part of the interaction potential that are off-diagonal in j and L. A common approach is to include all monomer rotational functions with j limited by a maximum value jmax , and for each j to include all allowed values of L of the desired parity (−1) j+L that satisfy the triangle condition | j − L| ≤ J ≤ j + L. Such calculations are often referred to as close-coupling calculations. The value of jmax required depends on the anisotropy of the interaction potential and it is of course always necessary to check convergence of the results with respect to jmax . The total angular momentum J plays the part of a partial wave quantum number. As for collisions of structureless particles, integral cross-sections involve sums over partial waves and differential cross-sections involve double sums, with interference between different partial waves playing an important role. 1.3.2.2
Scattering of Metastable Helium Atoms
States of individual atoms are usually described by quantum numbers L, S, and Ja for the electronic orbital, spin, and total angular momenta, respectively. However, in scattering and bound-state problems involving pairs of atoms or molecules it is common to use lower-case letters for quantum numbers of individual collision partners and reserve capital letters for quantities that refer to the collision system (or complex) as a whole. Thus, in this subsection we will use l and s for the quantum numbers of a single helium atom and reserve L and S for the end-over-end angular momentum of the atomic pair and the total spin, respectively. © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
17
Theory of Cold Atomic and Molecular Collisions
The helium atom has a metastable 3 S1 excited state with quantum numbers a = ja = 1 and a radiative lifetime of 8000 s. To carry out quantum scattering calculations on collisions of two such atoms, we need channel functions to handle the two spin quantum numbers and the mechanical angular momentum L. Once again it would be possible to use simple product functions as channel functions, |s1 ms1 |s2 ms2 |LML ,
(1.40)
but in the absence of external fields it is more efficient to use a total angular momentum representation. There is more than one way to construct such functions from three angular momenta, but the obvious one in this case is to couple s1 and s2 to give a total S and then couple S to L to give a resultant J, |s1 s2 SMS =
s1 ms1 s2 ms2 |SMS |s1 ms1 |s2 ms2 ;
ms1 ms2
|SL JMJ =
SMS LML |JMJ |SMS |LML .
(1.41)
MS ML
Once again, the resulting equations are diagonal in J and independent of MJ . Additional savings may be made by constructing functions that are symmetric with respect to exchange of identical atoms. In the case of metastable 4 He, the functions that are antisymmetric with respect to exchange may be discarded because the atoms are composite bosons.
1.3.3
COUPLED EQUATIONS
Substituting the expansion (1.36) into the total Schrödinger equation and projecting onto a single channel function φj (τ) yields a set of coupled equations,
2 d2 − − E ψ (r) = − Wji (r)ψi (r), j 2μ dr 2
(1.42)
i
where i and j are collective indices that each include all the quantum numbers needed to describe a channel. The coupling matrix W(r) generally contains off-diagonal as well as diagonal terms, Lˆ 2 ∗ Wji (r) = φj (τ) Hint (τ) + V (r, τ) + φi (τ) dτ. (1.43) 2μr 2 The coupling matrix W(r) does not become zero at long range, because different channels correspond to different energies of the separated monomers. Indeed, in some channel basis sets, W(r) may not even be diagonal at long range. However, it is almost always best to transform into a representation in which W(r) is diagonal, r→∞
Wii (r) ∼ wi δij , © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
(1.44)
18
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
before applying scattering boundary conditions. The energies wi , which correspond to levels of (pairs of) free monomers, are often referred to as thresholds because they represent energies at which pairs of monomers can be separated into the states concerned. The channels in a coupled-channel calculation at total energy E are usually divided into open channels, which correspond to energetically accessible monomer levels (E ≥ wi ), and closed channels, which correspond to energetically inaccessible monomer levels (E < wi ). The channel wavenumber ki for channel i is defined through the equation 2 ki2 = |E − wi | = |Ekin,i |, 2μ
(1.45)
where Ekin,i is the kinetic energy for channel i. In quantum scattering, we envisage a situation where there is an incoming wave in a single channel j, corresponding to the incident particles, and outgoing waves in all open channels, corresponding to scattered particles. The corresponding unnormalized wavefunction is asymptotically r→∞ −1
Ψ(r, τ) = r
−1/2 −ikj r+iLj π/2 φj (τ)kj e
+
−1/2 iki r−iLi π/2 Sji φi (τ)ki e
,
i
(1.46) where the sum runs over open channels only. There is a separate solution corresponding to each possible incoming channel, and the solution is characterized at long range by the S-matrix with elements Sji . The S-matrix is an Nopen × Nopen complex symmetric matrix, where Nopen is the number of open channels. It is unitary, that is, SS† = I, where S† indicates the Hermitian conjugate and I is a unit matrix. If the physical problem is factorized into separate sets of coupled equations for different symmetries (such as total angular momentum or parity), there is a separate S-matrix for each symmetry. All properties that correspond to completed collisions, such as elastic and inelastic integral and differential cross-sections, can be written in terms of S-matrices. There are usually several (or many) channels i, with different values of the orbital angular momentum Li , corresponding to each pair of internal states α of the colliding atoms or molecules. We indicate the set of channels corresponding to a particular set of monomer quantum numbers α as i ∈ α. The integral cross-section for molecules to undergo a transition from states α before the collision and to states β after the collision is π
σαβ = 2 gi |δij − Sij |2 , (1.47) kα i∈α j∈β
where the degeneracy factor gi is a function of the channel quantum numbers that depends on the particular channel basis set in use. In practice, the coupled equations usually factorize into sets with different symmetries (such as total angular © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
19
Theory of Cold Atomic and Molecular Collisions
momentum), each with its own S-matrix, so that there is an additional sum over symmetries. 1.3.3.1
Scattering Calculations
If the basis set contains N channel functions of a particular symmetry, a single solution of the coupled equations 1.42 is a vector ψ(r) made up of N radial strength functions ψi (r) for i = 1 to N. However, at any energy there are N linearly independent solution vectors that satisfy the boundary conditions (1.37) at short range, and it is usually not possible to select a single one of them that is physically relevant until longrange boundary conditions are applied. In computational terms it is therefore usually necessary to solve for all N solutions simultaneously to obtain an N × N wavefunction matrix Ψ(r) with elements ψij (r). The radial strength functions ψij (r) are in general complex. However, it is almost always possible to transform the problem to work with real functions and to express the complex solutions, when needed, in terms of these. For both open and closed channels, the boundary conditions require that Ψ(r) → 0 at short range. However, at long range the scattering boundary conditions corresponding to real solutions are r→∞
Ψ(r) = J(r) + N(r)K,
(1.48)
where the S-matrix is related to the open-open part K oo of the real symmetric K-matrix by S = (1 + iK oo )−1 (1 − iK oo ).
(1.49)
The matrices J(r) and N(r) are diagonal matrices with elements for open channels given by [15] 1/2
jLj (kj r)
1/2
nLj (kj r),
[J(r)]ij = δij rkj [N(r)]ij = δij rkj
(1.50)
where jL and nL are spherical Bessel functions, and for closed channels given by [J(r)]ij = δij (kj r)−1/2 ILj +1/2 (kj r) [N(r)]ij = δij (kj r)−1/2 KLj +1/2 (kj r),
(1.51)
where IL and KL are modified spherical Bessel functions of the first and third kinds [6]. (Note that the Riccati–Bessel functions used by Johnson [15] are krjL (kr) and krnL (kr) in the notation of Ref. [6].) The use of Bessel functions in place of sines and cosines takes into account the effect of the centrifugal terms in W(r) and makes it possible to apply the boundary conditions at much shorter range. 1.3.3.2
Numerical Methods for Scattering
As in the single-channel case, the coupled-channel equations are usually solved by numerical propagation. One approach is to start a solution matrix Ψ(r) at a distance © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
20
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
rmin , far enough into the classically forbidden region (in all channels) to assume that Ψ(rmin ) = 0. The solution is propagated outwards to rmax , which is chosen to be at long enough range that the effects of the potential V (r, τ) are negligible outside rmax . The wavefunction matrix and its derivative are then matched to the boundary conditions Equation 1.48 to obtain the real symmetric matrix K. This is then transformed using Equation 1.49 to obtain the physically meaningful S-matrix. There are many different propagators that have been developed to take account of the special properties of Equation 1.42, and a detailed discussion is beyond the scope of this chapter. Among those commonly used in cold molecule collisions are the renormalized Numerov approach [16,17] and several different log-derivative propagators [15,18,19]. The latter actually propagate the log-derivative matrix, defined as Y(r) =
dΨ [Ψ(r)]−1 , dr
(1.52)
in place of the wavefunction itself. The K matrix can be obtained from the logderivative matrix at rmax without requiring the wavefunction matrix explicitly [15]. The log-derivative propagators have good step-size convergence properties and do not suffer from stability problems arising from the presence of deeply closed channels. The airy-based log-derivative propagator of Alexander and Manolopoulos [19] has particular advantages for cold collisions because it allows very large propagation steps at long range. A variety of program packages are available to construct and solve sets of coupled equations for molecular quantum scattering calculations. These include the MOLSCAT package of Hutson and Green [20] and the HIBRIDON package of Alexander et al. [21]. 1.3.3.3
Decoupling Approximations
The computer time taken to solve a set of coupled equations is generally proportional to N 3 , where N is the number of channel basis functions in the expansion of Equation 1.36. Even for atom–diatom scattering, the size of the basis set required for close-coupling calculations can be prohibitively large, especially for systems with small rotational constants or strongly anisotropic potential energy surfaces. For more complicated systems, such as molecule–molecule scattering or for problems involving open-shell or nonlinear molecules, the problem is substantially worse. There are thus a number of decoupling approximations that factorize the coupled equations into smaller sets that can be solved separately. Approaches that have been popular for collisions at higher energies include the CS (coupled states or centrifugal sudden) approximation and the IOS (infinite-order sudden) approximation. A detailed discussion of these is beyond the scope of this chapter, but there is a good (if old) review by Kouri [22]. Decoupling approximations can save enormous amounts of computer time and can often provide approximate solutions for otherwise intractable scattering problems. However, they necessarily involve approximations, and must be treated with great care for cold molecule interactions. In particular, the CS and IOS approximations in their usual form both approximate the end-over-end angular momentum © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
21
Theory of Cold Atomic and Molecular Collisions
operator Lˆ 2 and thus affect centrifugal barriers, which can be extremely important in the ultracold regime. Nevertheless, carefully crafted decoupling approximations can be of great value. 1.3.3.4
Bound States
Provided the interaction potential is sufficiently attractive (which it almost always is), the multichannel Schrödinger equation supports bound states at energies En below the lowest threshold. The corresponding wavefunction for state n is Ψn (r, τ) = r −1
φi (τ)ψin (r).
(1.53)
i
The boundary conditions for bound-state problems are ψin (r) → 0
as
r→0
or
∞
(1.54)
in all channels i. Multichannel bound-state problems are much more complicated than singlechannel problems. Although to a first approximation it may be true that each bound state is supported primarily by a single channel with a well-defined potential well, this is not generally the case. The coupling between channels provided by W(r) mixes and shifts the levels in a nontrivial way that is outside the scope of this chapter but has been explored extensively in the context of the spectroscopy of Van der Waals complexes [23]. 1.3.3.5
Numerical Methods for Bound States
There are two general approaches to the calculation of bound states of multichannel systems: coupled-channel methods and radial basis set methods. Coupled-channel methods [24] operate by direct numerical solution of Equation 1.42, propagating either a wavefunction matrix or a derived quantity such as the log-derivative matrix (Eqution 1.52) across a grid of r values. As in the singlechannel case, the propagation is carried out outwards from a distance rmin at very short range and inwards from a distance rmax at long range to a matching point rmid in the classically allowed region. Solutions that satisfy bound-state boundary conditions (Equation 1.54) exist only for certain values of the energy E, so an extra layer of calculation is needed to locate the energies (eigenvalues). In the multichannel case, the desired wavefunction is a column vector ψn (r) whose elements are the channel wavefunctions ψin (r). In order to start propagating a solution to the coupled equations, it is necessary to know not only the initial values of the functions ψin (r) at rmin and rmax (which are given by the boundary conditions) but also their derivatives (which are not). It is therefore once again necessary to propagate an N × N wavefunction matrix Ψ(r), made up of a complete set of N vectors that spans the space of all possible initial derivatives. The particular wavefunction vector that is continuous (and has a continuous derivative) at the matching point is not identified until after converging on an energy eigenvalue. © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
22
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
Because the columns of Ψ(r) span the space of all possible initial derivatives, any wavefunction that satisfies the boundary conditions can be expressed as a linear combination of them. The true wavefunction vector ψn (r) can thus be expressed as ψn (r) = Ψ+ (r)C + , −
−
ψn (r) = Ψ (r)C ,
R ≤ rmid ; R ≥ rmid ,
(1.55)
where Ψ+ (r) and Ψ− (r) are the wavefunction matrices propagated from short and long range and C + and C − are r-independent column vectors that must be found. For an acceptable wavefunction, both ψn and its derivative must match at R = rmid , ψn (rmid ) = Ψ+ (rmid )C + = Ψ− (rmid )C − ; ψn (rmid ) = [Ψ+ ] (rmid )C + = [Ψ− ] (rmid )C − ,
(1.56)
where the primes indicate radial differentiation. Gordon [25] combined these two equations into the single equation + − + − + Ψ Ψ [Ψ ] [Ψ ] C − C − = 0, (1.57) where the matrix on the left-hand side is evaluated at R = rmid . It is a matrix of order 2N × 2N, and is a function of the energy at which the wavefunctions are calculated. A nontrivial solution of Equation 1.57 exists only if the determinant of the matrix on the left is zero, and this is true only if the energy used is an eigenvalue En of the coupled equations. In Gordon’s method, eigenvalues of the coupled equations are located by solving the coupled equations at a series of trial energies E and searching for energies at which the determinant is zero. It is then straightforward to find the transformation vectors C + and C − . Propagating wavefunctions explicitly in the presence of deeply closed channels is notoriously numerically unstable. It is much more satisfactory to use a propagator that is stable in the presence of closed channels, such as one of the log-derivative propagators described above. The multichannel matching condition can be expressed very simply in terms of the log-derivative matrix Y(r) of Equation 1.52. If E is an eigenvalue of the coupled equations, there must exist a wavefunction vector − ψn (rmid ) = ψ+ n (rmid ) = ψn (rmid ) for which − [ψ+ n ] (rmid ) = [ψn ] (rmid ),
(1.58)
Y + (rmid )ψn (rmid ) = Y − (rmid )ψn (rmid ),
(1.59)
[Y + (rmid ) − Y − (rmid )]ψn (rmid ) = 0.
(1.60)
so that
or equivalently
Thus the wavefunction ψn (rmid ) is an eigenvector of the matching matrix Y + (rmid ) − Y − (rmid ) with eigenvalue zero. Eigenvalues En of the coupled equations can be located © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
Theory of Cold Atomic and Molecular Collisions
23
by searching for energies at which the log-derivative matching matrix has a zero eigenvalue, using standard methods for finding zeroes of a function, such as the secant method. The propagator methods described here are implemented in the widely distributed BOUND package [26]. However, most bound-state problems of interest in cold molecule studies, such as those involving open-shell species and applied magnetic fields [27,28] require extensions to the distributed code. A quite different approach for calculating bound states is to expand the radial functions ψin (r) in a basis set of functions {χj (r)}, so that the full wavefunction is expanded
cijn φi (τ)χj (r). (1.61) Ψn (r, τ) = ij
The approach is then simply to calculate the complete Hamiltonian matrix in the product representation and diagonalize it to find the eigenvalues and eigenvectors. This approach is generally preferred for low-lying (deeply bound) states, because in that case quite compact radial basis sets can be used. Methods of this general type have been extensively reviewed in the context of the vibration-rotation spectroscopy of Van der Waals complexes and other molecules that exhibit wide-amplitude motion [29–31]. General-purpose programs are available for closed-shell triatomic and tetraatomic molecules [32,33]. However, these methods present some difficulties for the near-dissociation states that are important for cold molecule studies. The general problem is that quite large basis sets of radial basis functions {χj (r)} are often needed to describe both the short-range and long-range parts of the potential. For N channels and Nr radial basis functions, the full Hamiltonian matrix is of dimension NNr and the time taken to diagonalize it is proportional to N 3 Nr3 . By contrast, the time taken by propagation methods is proportional to N 3 but is linear in the number of propagation steps. There has nevertheless been a considerable amount of work on methods to calculate near-dissociation bound states using product basis sets [34,35].
1.3.4
QUASIBOUND STATES AND SCATTERING RESONANCES
True bound states can exist only at energies below the lowest threshold of the same symmetry as the state concerned. However, quasibound states can exist at energies above threshold, as shown in Figure 1.3. These are (relatively) long-lived states that can be seen in spectroscopy in much the same way as true bound states, but are coupled to a continuum and decay (dissociate) spontaneously. As a quasibound state has a finite lifetime τ, it has a width in energy ΓE rather than a precisely defined eigenvalue, ΓE = /τ.
(1.62)
Quasibound states also produce sharp features in collision properties as a function of energy, and in this context they are usually referred to as scattering resonances. There are two different types of scattering resonance that can occur, as shown schematically in Figure 1.3. A shape resonance corresponds to a state that is confined © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
Energy
24
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
Quasibound states (Feshbach resonances) Centrifugal barrier Quasibound state (shape resonance) Dissociation energy
Bound states
r
FIGURE 1.3 The different types of bound and quasibound states and scattering resonances. For the purpose of illustration only two potential curves are shown, corresponding to the lowest channel and one excited channel.
behind a barrier in a centrifugally corrected potential (Equation 1.16). A shape resonance can exist even in single-channel scattering and decays by tunneling through the barrier. Conversely, a Feshbach resonance [36] (sometimes called a compound state resonance) corresponds to a state that is supported by an attractive well in channels that are energetically closed at the energy of interest. It decays by curve-crossing to the open channel. If there is only one open channel, a resonance (of either type) is characterized by a sharp change in the phase shift δL , which increases sharply by π across the width of the resonance. The phase shift follows a Breit–Wigner form as a function of energy,
ΓE −1 , (1.63) δL (E) = δbg + tan 2(Eres − E) where δbg is a slowly varying background term, Eres is the resonance position, and ΓE is its width (in energy space). In general the parameters δbg , Eres and ΓE are weak functions of energy, but this is often neglected for reasonably narrow resonances. The 1 × 1 S-matrix for single-channel scattering is given by SL (E) = e2iδL (E) .
(1.64)
As δL (E) is real, SL (E) describes a circle of radius 1 in the complex plane across a resonance. © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
Theory of Cold Atomic and Molecular Collisions
25
When there is more than one open channel, the complex symmetric scattering matrix S has elements Sij . The diagonal S-matrix element in incoming channel i has magnitude |Sii | ≤ 1 and may be written in terms of a complex phase shift δi (E) with a positive imaginary part [37], Sii (E) = e2iδi (E) .
(1.65)
In the multichannel case, the quantity that follows the Breit–Wigner form of Equation 1.63 is the S-matrix eigenphase sum [38,39], which is the sum of the phases obtained from the eigenvalues of the S-matrix. The eigenphases and the eigenphase sum are real, unlike the phases δi obtained from individual diagonal elements, because the S-matrix is unitary, so that all its eigenvalues have modulus 1. Across a resonance, the individual S-matrix elements describe circles in the complex plane [40], Sij (E) = Sbg,ij −
igEi gEj , E − Eres + iΓE /2
(1.66)
where gEi is complex. The radius of the circle in Sij is |gEi gEj |/ΓE , which is usually less than 1. The partial width for channel i is commonly defined as a real quantity, ΓEi = |gEi |2 . For a narrow resonance, the total width is just the sum of the partial widths, ΓE =
ΓEi .
(1.67)
i
The physical interpretation of the partial width is that, when the quasibound state corresponding to the resonance decays, the fractional population produced in product channel i is ΓEi /ΓE .
1.3.5
LOW-ENERGY SCATTERING
At low energies, scattering is commonly dominated by one or a few partial waves and the cross-sections σ(k) may be decomposed into partial wave contributions σL (k) from different incoming partial waves L. The limiting low-energy behavior for different values of L is given by the Wigner threshold laws [41]. For elastic cross-sections, tan δL (k) ∼ k 2L+1
and
σel,L ∼ k 4L ,
(1.68)
where k is the wavenumber in the incoming channel. For a potential that behaves as V (r) = −Cn r −n at long range (with n > 2), there is an additional L-independent term that dominates at high L [42], tan δL (k) ∼ k n−2 © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
and
σel,L ∼ k 2n−6 .
(1.69)
26
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
For inelastic (deexcitation) cross-sections, σinel,L ∼ k 2L−1 .
(1.70)
For the purpose of the Wigner laws, a transition is classed as inelastic if the kinetic energy released is large compared to the centrifugal barrier in the outgoing channels. At low energies, the complex phase shift defined by Equation 1.65 can be expressed in terms of a complex energy-dependent scattering length, a(k) = α(k) − iβ(k) [43], defined by analogy with Equation 1.26 as − tan δi (k) 1 a(k) = = k ik
1 − Sii (k) . 1 + Sii (k)
(1.71)
This expression is to be preferred to the common approximation, a(k) ≈
−Im Sii , ik
(1.72)
because Equation 1.71 remains valid close to resonance when a(k) is large and |1 − Sii | is not close to zero. For an incoming channel with L = 0 (s-wave scattering), the scattering length a(k) becomes constant at limitingly low energy. The elastic and total inelastic cross-sections are exactly [44] σel (k) =
4π|a|2 1 + k 2 |a|2 + 2kβ
(1.73)
and tot σinel (k) =
1.3.6
4πβ . k(1 + k 2 |a|2 + 2kβ)
(1.74)
COLLISIONS IN EXTERNAL FIELDS
Collisions in applied electric and magnetic fields are important for several reasons. Most importantly, applied fields provide ways to control ultracold gases, and for atomic systems this control has already led to the observation of a wide range of new phenomena including molecule formation and transitions to superfluid phases [45]. There is little doubt that applied fields will provide the key to controlling the much richer behavior expected for ultracold molecules. A subsidiary issue is that cold molecules are often manipulated or trapped using applied electric or magnetic fields. Such methods generally rely on the molecules remaining in a particular quantum state, and are disrupted if they undergo transitions to different states. In addition, inelastic collisions that convert internal energy into kinetic energy can eject both collision partners from the trap if the kinetic energy released is greater than the trap depth. The most important effect of an applied electric or magnetic field is that the energy levels of the colliding monomers split and shift by amounts that can be quite large © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
Theory of Cold Atomic and Molecular Collisions
27
compared to the kinetic energy. The shifts in the positions of scattering thresholds have profound effects on collision properties, as will be seen below. Another effect of an applied field is that it breaks the isotropic character of space, so that the total angular momentum is no longer a good quantum number. This presents computational problems because much greater numbers of channels are coupled together. Many problems that are computationally tractable in the absence of fields become intractable when fields are applied. Despite the proliferation of channels and the need for more complicated Hamiltonians, the formal theory of atomic and molecular collisions is not much changed in the presence of fields. Applied fields do reduce symmetry, so that collisions no longer take place in an isotropic environment: total angular momentum is no longer conserved, and differential cross-sections need not be cylindrical symmetrical in the center-of-mass frame. However, in computational terms, it is still necessary to solve sets of coupled differential equations subject to bound-state and scattering boundary conditions. Perhaps the most important effect is that applied fields provide access to resonance phenomena that do not occur in field-free scattering. In particular, they provide access to zero-energy Feshbach resonances, which are at the heart of most approaches to controlling ultracold gases.
1.3.6.1
Basis Sets without Total Angular Momentum
As described in Section 1.3.2 above, field-free scattering calculations are usually carried out in total angular momentum representations. The equations arising from each value of the total angular momentum are independent and may be solved separately. In the presence of an applied field, this symmetry is lost and there is much less advantage in working in a total angular momentum representation. Several cases may be envisaged: • In the presence of a magnetic field with no electric field, the quantities that are conserved are the projection Mtot of the total angular momentum onto the field axis and the total parity [46–48]. • In the presence of an electric field but no magnetic field, Mtot is again preserved but the total parity is lost. Pairs of states with ±|Mtot | are degenerate with one another. States with Mtot = 0 separate into blocks that are even and odd with respect to reflection in a plane containing the field axis. • In the presence of collinear electric and magnetic fields, only Mtot is conserved. • In the presence of electric and magnetic fields that are not collinear, there is no symmetry at all and even Mtot is lost [49]. As in field-free calculations, there are very many basis sets that may be used in different circumstances. A totally uncoupled representation is often convenient because the matrix elements needed are usually quite simple. For example, for collisions of a molecule in a 3 Σ state with an unstructured atom we need basis functions to handle the molecular rotation n, electron spin s, and end-over-end angular momentum © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
28
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
L. In this case the totally uncoupled representation is made up of simple product functions φi (τ) = |nmn |sms |LML .
(1.75)
However, other basis functions sometimes describe the real eigenfunctions more compactly and may be useful in arriving at physical interpretations. In this case the functions that describe the diatomic molecule most efficiently at low fields are obtained by coupling n and s to give a resultant j, which does not appear in the basis set of Equation 1.75. 1.3.6.2
Spin Relaxation
Paramagnetic molecules are often confined in magnetic traps, with a magnetic field that is zero at the center of the trap and increases in all directions away from it. Such an arrangement traps molecules in low-field-seeking states, whose energy increases away from the center, but not those in high-field-seeking states. However, because the lowest-energy state in a field is always high-field-seeking, it is always possible for molecules to be transferred from trapped states to untrapped states by inelastic collisions. The rate of this process limits the time for which molecules can be trapped. Calculations on the collisions of cold molecules in fields are discussed in more detail in this book in the chapter by Tscherbul and Krems (Chapter 4). 1.3.6.3
Zero-Energy Feshbach Resonances
Vibrational energy levels are quite closely packed near thresholds. In cold molecule studies, it is common to have several closely spaced thresholds, corresponding to different nuclear hyperfine states or other small energy splittings of the colliding monomers. Because the bound states of the two-body system usually have different Stark and Zeeman effects from the constituent monomers, near-dissociation bound states may often be tuned across thresholds with applied electric and magnetic fields. An example of this is shown in Figure 1.4. At the point where the bound state and the threshold exactly coincide, there is a zero-energy Feshbach resonance. Consider the case of a zero-energy Feshbach resonance as a function of magnetic field B. At constant Ekin , the phase shift follows a form similar to Equation 1.63,
ΓB , (1.76) δ(B) = δbg + tan−1 2(Bres − B) where Bres is the field at which Eres = E = Ethresh + Ekin . An example of this is shown in Figure 1.5. The width ΓB is a signed quantity given by ΓB = ΓE /Δμ, where the magnetic moment difference Δμ is the rate at which the energy Ethresh of the open-channel threshold tunes with respect to the resonance energy, Δμ =
dEres dEthresh − . dB dB
(1.77)
ΓB is thus negative if the bound state tunes upwards through the energy of interest, as in the case in Figure 1.5. © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
29
Theory of Cold Atomic and Molecular Collisions
0
(1, 1)–1
(mfin1 mfin2) (–1, 1) (0, 0) (0, 1)
(1, 1)–2
Energy/h (GHz)
–1
(1, 2)–4 (1, 2)–4
(1, 1)
–2
–3
(1, 1)–3 (2, 2)–5 (2, 2)–5 (2, 2)–5
–4 (f1, f2) v ¢ 0
200
400 600 Magnetic field (G)
800
1000
1200
FIGURE 1.4 Tuning of molecular levels (solid lines) and atomic thresholds (dashed lines) for 87 Rb as a function of magnetic field. Feshbach resonances occur at the points marked with 2 filled circles, where a molecular state crosses a threshold. (From Marte, A. et al., Phys. Rev. Lett., 89, 283202, 2002. With permission. Copyright 2002, the American Physical Society.)
When there is only one open channel, the S-matrix element S = e2iδ(B) describes a circle of radius 1 in the complex plane. In the ultracold regime, the background phase shift δbg goes to zero as k → 0 according to Equation 1.26 (with aL (k) replaced by abg , which is finite and becomes constant as k → 0). However, the resonant term still exists. The scattering length passes through a pole when δ(B) = n + corresponding to S = −1. The scattering length follows the formula [51],
π,
a(B) = abg
ΔB 1− . B − Bres
1 2
(1.78)
An example of this is shown in Figure 1.6. The elastic cross-section given by Equation 1.73 thus shows a sharp peak of height 4π/k 2 at resonance. The two widths ΓB and ΔB are related by ΓB = −2abg kΔB .
(1.79)
At limitingly low energy, ΓB is proportional to k while ΔB is constant [52]. For multichannel scattering, the situation is more complicated. As a function of magnetic field, the scattering length passes through a pole only if δ0 (B) passes through © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
30
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
10.0
Eigenphase sum/p
9.8
9.6
9.4
9.2
9.0 7168.7553
7168.7550
7168.7556
7168.7559
Magnetic field (G)
FIGURE 1.5 Phase shift for elastic 3 He–NH collisions in the vicinity of an elastic Feshbach resonance at a kinetic energy of 10−6 K. (From González-Martínez, M.L. and Hutson, J.M., Phys. Rev. A, 75, 022702, 2007. With permission. Copyright 2007, the American Physical Society.)
n + 21 π, corresponding to S00 = −1. If there is any inelastic scattering, the radius of the resonant circle in S00 is proportional to k at low energy and this does not occur. The formula followed by the complex scattering length is [53] a(B) = abg +
ares , 2(B − Bres )/Γinel B +i
(1.80)
where ares is a resonant scattering length that characterizes the strength of the resonance. When ares is small, the scattering length shows only small peaks or oscillations across a resonance. Both ares and the background term abg can in general be complex and are independent of kinetic energy at low energy. When ares is complex, the total inelastic cross-section given by Equation 1.74 can show troughs as well as peaks in the vicinity of a resonance.
1.4
REACTIVE SCATTERING
Reactive scattering, in which the products of a collision are chemically different from the reactants, is formally similar to inelastic scattering. However, there are complications that arise from the fact that a basis set that efficiently describes the reactants is usually inefficient to describe the products and vice versa. Even the coordinate system to be used requires some care: for example, Jacobi coordinates © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
31
Theory of Cold Atomic and Molecular Collisions 3 × 104 Ekin = 1.0 mK
Re (scattering length) (Å)
2 × 104
1 × 104
0 × 100
–1 × 104
–2 × 104
–3 × 104 7168.7550
7168.7553
7168.7556
7168.7559
Magnetic field (G)
FIGURE 1.6 Scattering length for elastic 3 He–NH collisions in the vicinity of an elastic Feshbach resonance, from calculations at a kinetic energy of 10−6 K. (From GonzálezMartínez, M.L. and Hutson, J.M., Phys. Rev. A, 75, 022702, 2007. With permission. Copyright 2007, the American Physical Society.)
are usually inappropriate because the reduced mass is different in the reactant and product coordinate systems. The approach most commonly used to circumvent these difficulties, at least for triatomic systems, is to express the problem in hyperspherical coordinates, with the relative positions described by a single radial coordinate ρ (the hyperradius) and two hyperangles. The different atomic arrangements simply correspond to different values (or ranges of values) of the hyperangles, and a single basis set is capable of describing all arrangements. The time-independent scattering problem again reduces to a set of coupled differential equations that can be solved by propagation as in the inelastic case. Several variants of hyperspherical coordinates have been used, and a general comparison has been given by Pack and Parker [54]. There are a variety of channel basis sets that have been used by different authors: in some approaches the basis functions are solutions of a fixed-ρ Schrödinger equation that is solved at each value of the hyperradius [54–56], and in others the basis functions represent the reactants and products [57]. At long range (in the hyperradius ρ), the solutions are transformed back into the basis sets appropriate for the reactants or products individually and matched onto Bessel functions to give the scattering S-matrix as described in Section 1.3.3.1. These methods, together with time-dependent (wavepacket) approaches for reactive scattering, have been recently reviewed by Hu and Schatz [58]. © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
32
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
The time-independent procedure works well for atom–diatom reactions involving light atoms that proceed on a single potential energy surface. A general-purpose program to solve the time-independent scattering problem in this case is available [57]. However, applying the theory outside this narrow range of systems is not yet routine. Low-energy reactive scattering calculations have been carried out for single-surface systems as heavy as K + K2 [59]. Calculations have also been carried out at higher energy for light systems such as F + H2 [60], where the reaction occurs on several surfaces coupled by spin–orbit interactions. However, heavy-atom systems involving multiple surfaces are not yet tractable, even for triatomic systems. Methods for performing full-dimensional quantum scattering calculations on four-atom and larger systems have been developed [61,62], but are mostly based on time-dependent wavepacket approaches that are not easily applicable to ultracold collisions. There has so far been relatively little work on reactive collisions in the presence of external fields, but Tscherbul and Krems [63] have described the general theory required in the presence of an electric field and have carried out pilot calculations on the LiF + H ↔ Li + FH reactions.
1.4.1
LANGEVIN MODEL FOR BARRIERLESS REACTIONS
There is a considerable class of chemical reactions for which the potential energy surfaces are barrierless with deep wells at short range. These include many ion–molecule reactions as well as atom exchange reactions in atom–molecule and molecule– molecule collisions involving alkali metal dimers. In the ultracold domain where only one or a few partial waves contribute to collision cross-sections, such reactions still require a full quantum treatment. However, for strongly exothermic barrierless reactions at slightly higher temperatures (several mK) it is a reasonable approximation that all collisions that sample the short-range region of the potential surface lead to reaction. This is the basis of the Langevin capture model [64]. The effective potential VL (r) for a partial wave with L > 0, Equation 1.16, is governed at long range by the centrifugal and dispersion terms, VL (R) =
2 L(L + 1) C6 − 6, 2μR2 R
(1.81)
where C6 is the atom–molecule or molecule–molecule dispersion coefficient. There is thus a centrifugal barrier at a distance
RLmax with height
VLmax
=
6μC6 = 2 L(L + 1)
2 L(L + 1) μ
1/4 (1.82)
3/2 (54C6 )−1/2 .
(1.83)
At collision energies below the centrifugal barrier in the incoming channel, the partial cross-sections for each L follow Wigner laws given by Equation 1.70. If there are © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
33
Theory of Cold Atomic and Molecular Collisions
many open channels, however, the inelastic probabilities above the centrifugal barrier come close to their maximum possible value of 1. The cross-sections then vary as E −1 because of the k −2 factor in the expression for the cross-section. At collision energies high enough that many partial waves are involved, the total inelastic cross-section and rate coefficient become 1/3 C6 capture σinel (E) = 3π ; 4E (1.84) 1/3 1/2 1/3 3πC6 E 1/6 2E C6 capture = . kinel (E) = 3π 4E μ 21/6 μ1/2 For atom–molecule and molecule–molecule reactions, the centrifugal barriers for low partial waves are typically a few mK or less. For barrierless reactions, therefore, Langevin behavior sets in at temperatures between 1 and 100 mK. Above this temperature, the details of the short-range potential become unimportant. An example of this is shown in Figure 1.7, which shows inelastic collision rates for Li + Li2 for boson and fermion dimers initially in v = 1 and 2 [65]. The full quantum result approaches the Langevin value at collision energies above about 10 mK.
Rate coefficient (cm3/s–1)
10−9
Bosons: vi = 1 Bosons: vi = 2 Fermions: vi = 1 Fermions: vi = 1
10−10
10−6
Langevin model
10−5
10−4
10−3 Collision energy (K)
10−2
10−1
FIGURE 1.7 Total inelastic rate coefficients for collisions of Li with Li2 (v = 1 and 2, with j = 0 for boson dimers and j = 1 for fermion dimers). The dotted line shows the result of Langevin capture theory. (From Critaš, M.T. et al., Phys. Rev. Lett., 94, 033201, 2005. With permission.)
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
34
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
REFERENCES 1. Child, M.S., Molecular Collision Theory, Academic Press, London, 1974. 2. Levine, R.D., Molecular Reaction Dynamics, Cambridge University Press, 2005. 3. Aoiz, F.J., Banares, L., and Herrero, V.J., Recent results from quasiclassical trajectory computations of elementary chemical reactions, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans., 94, 2483–2500, 1998. 4. Althorpe, S.C. and Clary, D.C., Quantum scattering calculations on chemical reactions, Annu. Rev. Phys. Chem., 54, 493–529, 2003. 5. Althorpe, S.C., The plane wave packet approach to quantum scattering theory, Int. Rev. Phys. Chem., 23, 219–251, 2004. 6. Abramowitz, M. and Stegun, I.A., Handbook of Mathematical Functions, 9th edn., Dover, New York, 1964. 7. Child, M.S., Semiclassical Mechanics with Molecular Applications, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1991. 8. Hinckelmann, O. and Spruch, L., Low-energy scattering by long-range potentials, Phys. Rev. A, 3, 642, 1971. 9. Gribakin, G.F. and Flambaum, V.V., Calculation of the scattering length in atomic collisions using the semiclassical approximation, Phys. Rev. A, 48, 546, 1993. 10. Boisseau, C., Audouard, E., and Vigué, J., Quantization of the highest levels in a molecular potential, Europhys. Lett., 41, 349–354, 1998. 11. Boisseau, C., Audouard, E., Vigué, J., and Flambaum, V.V., Analytical correction to the WKB quantization condition for the highest levels in a molecular potential, Eur. Phys. J. D, 12, 199–209, 2000. 12. Johnson, B.R., Renormalized Numerov method applied to calculating bound states of coupled-channel Schrödinger equation, J. Chem. Phys., 69, 4678–4688, 1978. 13. Cooley, J.W., An improved eigenvalue corrector formula for solving the Schrödinger equation for central fields, Math. Comput., 15, 363–374, 1961. 14. Arthurs, A.M. and Dalgarno, A., The theory of scattering by a rigid rotator, Proc. Roy. Soc., Ser. A, 256, 540–551, 1960. 15. Johnson, B.R., Multichannel log-derivative method for scattering calculations, J. Comput. Phys., 13, 445–449, 1973. 16. Johnson, B.R., New numerical methods applied to solving one-dimensional eigenvalue problem, J. Chem. Phys., 67, 4086, 1977. 17. Colavecchia, F.D., Mrugała, F., Parker, G.A., and Pack, R.T, Accurate quantum calculations on three-body collisions in recombination and collision-induced dissociation. II. The smooth-variable discretization-enhanced renormalized Numerov propagator, J. Chem. Phys., 118, 10387–10398, 2003. 18. Manolopoulos, D.E., An improved log-derivative method for inelastic scattering, J. Chem. Phys., 85, 6425–6429, 1986. 19. Alexander, M.H. and Manolopoulos, D.E., A stable linear reference potential algorithm for solution of the quantum close-coupled equations in molecular scattering theory, J. Chem. Phys., 86, 2044, 1987. 20. Hutson, J.M. and Green, S., MOLSCAT computer program, version 14. Distributed by Collaborative Computational Project No. 6, UK Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council, 1994. 21. Alexander, M.H., Manolopoulos, D.E., Werner, H.-J., and Follmeg, B., HIBRIDON computer program, available at http://www.chem.umd.edu/groups/alexander/hibridon/ hib43/, 1987–2008.
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
Theory of Cold Atomic and Molecular Collisions
35
22. Kouri, D.J., Rotational excitation II: Approximate methods, in Bernstein, R.B., ed., Atom–Molecule Collision Theory: A Guide for the Experimentalist, Plenum Press, New York, 1979, p. 301–358. 23. Hutson, J.M., An introduction to the dynamics of Van der Waals molecules, in Advances in Molecular Vibrations and Collision Dynamics, Vol. 1A, JAI Press, Greenwich, Connecticut, 1991, p. 1–45. 24. Hutson, J.M., Coupled-channel methods for solving the bound-state Schrödinger equation, Comput. Phys. Commun., 84, 1–18, 1994. 25. Gordon, R.G., A new method for constructing wavefunctions for bound states and scattering, J. Chem. Phys., 51, 14, 1969. 26. Hutson, J.M., BOUND computer program, version 5. Distributed by Collaborative Computational Project No. 6, UK Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council, 1993. 27. González-Martínez, M.L. and Hutson, J.M., Ultracold atom–molecule collisions and bound states in magnetic fields: zero-energy Feshbach resonances in He–NH (3 Σ− ), Phys. Rev. A, 75, 022702, 2007. 28. Hutson, J.M., Tiesinga, E., and Julienne, P.S., Avoided crossings between bound states of ultracold Cesium dimers, Phys. Rev. A, 78, 052703, 2008. 29. Tennyson, J., The calculation of the vibration-rotation energies of triatomic molecules using scattering coordinates, Comput. Phys. Rep., 4, 1–36, 1986. 30. Baˇci´c, Z. and Light, J.C., Theoretical methods for rovibrational states of floppy molecules, Annu. Rev. Phys. Chem., 40, 469–498, 1989. 31. Carrington, T., Methods for calculating vibrational energy levels, Can. J. Chem.–Rev. Can. Chim., 82, 900–914, 2004. 32. Tennyson, J., Kostin, M.A., Barletta, P., Harris, G.J., Polyansky, O.L., Ramanlal, J., and Zobov, N.F., DVR3D: a program suite for the calculation of rotation-vibration spectra of triatomic molecules, Comput. Phys. Commun., 163, 85–116, 2004. 33. Kozin, I.N., Law, M.M., Tennyson, J., and Hutson, J.M., New vibration-rotation code for tetraatomic molecules exhibiting wide-amplitude motion: WAVR4, Comput. Phys. Commun., 163, 117–131, 2004. 34. Tiesinga, E., Williams, C.J., and Julienne, P.S., Photoassociative spectroscopy of highly excited vibrational levels of alkali-metal dimers: Green-function approach for eigenvalue solvers, Phys. Rev. A, 57, 4257–4267, 1998. 35. Mussa, H.Y. and Tennyson, J., Bound and quasi-bound rotation-vibrational states using massively parallel computers, Comput. Phys. Commun., 128, 434–445, 2000. 36. Feshbach, H., Unified theory of nuclear reactions, Ann. Phys., 5, 357–390, 1958. 37. Mott, N.F. and Massey, H.S.W., The Theory of Atomic Collisions, 3rd edn., Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1965, p. 380. 38. Hazi, A.U., Behavior of the eigenphase sum near a resonance, Phys. Rev. A, 19, 920–922, 1979. 39. Ashton, C.J., Child, M.S., and Hutson, J.M., Rotational predissociation of the Ar–HCl Van der Waals complex—close-coupled scattering calculations, J. Chem. Phys., 78, 4025, 1983. 40. Taylor, J.R., Scattering Theory: The Quantum Theory of Nonrelativistic Collisions, Wiley, New York, 1972, p. 411–412. 41. Wigner, E.P., On the behavior of cross sections near thresholds, Phys. Rev., 73, 1002–1009, 1948. 42. Sadeghpour, H.R., Bohn, J.L., Cavagnero, M.J., Esry, B.D., Fabrikant, I.I., Macek, J.H., and Rau, A.R.P., Collisions near threshold in atomic and molecular physics, J. Phys. B–At. Mol. Opt. Phys., 33, R93–R140, 2000.
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
36
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
43. Balakrishnan, N., Kharchenko, V., Forrey, R.C., and Dalgarno, A., Complex scattering lengths in multi-channel atom–molecule collisions, Chem. Phys. Lett., 280, 5–9, 1997. 44. Cvitaš, M.T., Soldán, P., Hutson, J.M., Honvault, P., and Launay, J.M., Interactions and dynamics in Li + Li2 ultracold collisions, J. Chem. Phys., 127, 074302, 2007. 45. Pethick, C.J. and Smith, H., Bose–Einstein Condensation in Dilute Gases, Cambridge University Press, 2002. 46. Volpi, A. and Bohn, J.L., Magnetic-field effects in ultracold molecular collisions, Phys. Rev. A, 65, 052712, 2002. 47. Krems, R.V. and Dalgarno, A., Quantum-mechanical theory of atom–molecule and molecular collisions in a magnetic field: Spin depolarization, J. Chem. Phys., 120, 2296–2307, 2004. 48. Krems, R.V. and Dalgarno, A., Collisions of atoms and molecules in external magnetic fields, in Fundamental World of Quantum Chemistry, Brändas, E.J., and Kryachko, E.S., Eds, Vol. 3, Kluwer Academic, 2004, p. 273–294. 49. Tscherbul, T.V. and Krems, R.V., Controlling electronic spin relaxation of cold molecules with electric fields, Phys. Rev. Lett., 97, 083201, 2006. 50. Marte, A., Volz, T., Schuster, J., Durr, S., Rempe, G., van Kempen, E.G.M., and Verhaar, B.J., Feshbach resonances in rubidium 87: Precision measurement and analysis, Phys. Rev. Lett., 89, 283202, 2002. 51. Moerdijk, A.J., Verhaar, B.J., and Axelsson, A., Resonances in ultracold collisions of Li-6, Li-7, and Na-23, Phys. Rev. A, 51, 4852–4861, 1995. 52. Timmermans, E., Tommasini, P., Hussein, M., and Kerman, A., Feshbach resonances in atomic Bose–Einstein condensates, Phys. Rep., 315, 199–230, 1999. 53. Hutson, J.M., Feshbach resonances in the presence of inelastic scattering: threshold behavior and suppression of poles in scattering lengths, New J. Phys., 9, 152, 2007. Note that there is a typographical error in Equation 22 of this paper: the last term on the right-hand side should read −βres instead of +βres . 54. Pack, R.T, and Parker, G.A., Quantum reactive scattering in 3 dimensions using hyperspherical (APH) coordinates—theory, J. Chem. Phys., 87, 3888–3921, 1987. 55. Schatz, G.C., Quantum reactive scattering using hyperspherical coordinates: results for H + H2 and Cl + HCl, Chem. Phys. Lett., 150, 92–98, 1988. 56. Launay, J.M. and LeDourneuf, M., Hyperspherical close-coupling calculation of integral, cross-sections for the reaction H + H2 → H2 + H, Chem. Phys. Lett., 163, 178, 1989. 57. Skouteris, D., Castillo, J.F., and Manolopoulos, D.E., ABC: a quantum reactive scattering program, Comput. Phys. Commun., 133, 128–135, 2000. 58. Hu, W. and Schatz, G.C., Theories of reactive scattering, J. Chem. Phys., 125, 132301, 2006. 59. Quéméner, G., Honvault, P., Launay, J.M., Soldán, P., Potter, D.E., and Hutson, J.M., Ultracold quantum dynamics: Spin-polarized k + k2 collisions with three identical bosons or fermions, Phys. Rev. A, 71, 032722, 2005. 60. Alexander, M.H., Manolopoulos, D.E., and Werner, H.-J., An investigation of the F + H2 reaction based on a full ab initio description of the open-shell character of the F(2 P) atom, J. Chem. Phys., 113, 11084–11000, 2000. 61. Zhang, D.H. and Light, J.C., Quantum state-to-state reaction probabilities for the H + H2 O → H2 + OH reaction in six dimensions, J. Chem. Phys., 105, 1291–1294, 1996. 62. Meyer, H.D. and Worth, G.A., Quantum molecular dynamics: propagating wavepackets and density operators using the multiconfiguration time-dependent Hartree method, Theor. Chem. Acc., 109, 251–267, 2003.
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
Theory of Cold Atomic and Molecular Collisions
37
63. Tscherbul, T.V. and Krems, R.V., Quantum theory of chemical reactions in the presence of electromagnetic fields, J. Chem. Phys., 129, 034112, 2008. 64. Levine, R.D. and Bernstein, R.B., Molecular Reaction Dynamics and Chemical Reactivity, Oxford University Press, 1987. 65. Cvitaš, M.T., Soldán, P., Hutson, J.M., Honvault, P., and Launay, J.M., Ultracold Li + Li2 collisions: Bosonic and fermionic cases, Phys. Rev. Lett., 94, 033201, 2005.
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
Electric Dipoles at 2 Ultralow Temperatures John L. Bohn CONTENTS 2.1 2.2 2.3
General Remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Review of Classical Dipoles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Quantum-Mechanical Dipoles in Fields. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3.1 Atoms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3.2 Rotating Molecules . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3.3 Molecules with Lambda-Doubling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4 The Field due to a Dipole . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4.1 Example: j = 1/2 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4.2 Example: j = 1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5 Interaction of Dipoles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.1 Potential Matrix Elements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.2 Adiabatic Potential Energy Surfaces in Two Dimensions . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.3 Example: j = 1/2 Molecules . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.4 Adiabatic Potential Energy Curves in One Dimension: Partial Waves . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.5 Asymptotic Form of the Interaction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
2.1
39 40 42 42 45 48 51 53 55 57 58 61 62 65 66 67 67
GENERAL REMARKS
Any object with a net positive charge on one end and a net negative charge on the other end possesses an electric dipole moment. In ordinary classical electromagnetism this dipole moment is a vector quantity that can point in any direction, and is subject to electrical forces that are fairly straightforward to formulate mathematically. However, for a quantum mechanical object like an atom or molecule, the strength and orientation of the object’s dipole moment can depend strongly on the object’s quantum mechanical state. This is a subject that becomes relevant in low-temperature molecular samples, where an ensemble of molecules can be prepared in a single internal state, as described in Chapters 5, 9, 13, 14, and 15. In such a case, the mathematical description becomes more elaborate, and indeed the dipole–dipole interaction need not take the classical 39 © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
40
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
form given in textbooks. The description of this interaction is the subject of this chapter. We approach this task in three steps: first, we introduce the ideas of how dipoles arise in quantum mechanical objects; second, we present a formalism within which to describe these dipoles; and third, we give examples of the formalism that illustrate some of the basic physics that emerges. The discussion will explore the possible energy states of the dipole, the field generated by the dipole, and the interaction of the dipole with another dipole. We restrict the discussion to a particular “minimal realistic model,” so that the most important physics is incorporated, but the arithmetic is not overwhelming. Although we discuss molecular dipoles in several contexts, our main focus is on polar molecules that possess a Λ doublet in their ground state. These molecules are the most likely, among diatomic molecules at least, to exhibit their dipolar character at moderate laboratory field strengths. Λ-doubled molecules have another peculiar feature, namely, their ground states possess a degeneracy even in an electric field. This means that there is more than one way for such a molecule to align with the field; the two possibilities are characterized by different angular momentum quantum numbers. This degeneracy leads to novel properties of both the orientation of a single molecule’s dipole moment and the interaction between dipoles. In the examples we present, we focus on revealing these novel features. We assume the reader has a good background in undergraduate quantum mechanics and electrostatics. In particular, the ideas of matrix mechanics, Dirac notation, and time-independent perturbation theory are used frequently. In addition, the reader should have a passing familiarity with electric dipoles and their interactions with fields and with each other. Finally, we will draw heavily on the mathematical theory of angular momentum as applied to quantum mechanics in more detail in the classic treatise of Brink and Satchler [1]. When necessary, details of the structure of diatomic molecules have been drawn from Brown and Carrington’s recent authoritative text [2].
2.2
REVIEW OF CLASSICAL DIPOLES
The behavior of a polar molecule is largely determined by its response to electric fields. Classically, an electric dipole appears when a molecule has a little bit of positive charge displaced a distance from a little bit of negative charge. The dipole moment is then a vector quantity that characterizes the direction and magnitude of this displacement: μ =
qξ rξ ,
ξ
where the ξ-th charge qξ is displaced rξ from a particular origin. Because we are interested in forces exerted on molecules, we will take this origin to be the center of mass of the molecule. (Defining μ = 0 would instead identify the center of charge of the molecule—quite a different thing!) By convention, the dipole moment vector points away from the negative charges, and toward the positive charges, inside the molecule. © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
41
Electric Dipoles at Ultralow Temperatures
A molecule has many charges in it, and they are distributed in a complex way, as governed by the quantum-mechanical state of the molecule. In general there is much more information about the electrostatic properties of the molecule than is contained in its dipole moment. However, at distances far from the molecule (as compared to the molecule’s size), these details do not matter. The forces that one molecule exerts on another in this limit are strongly dominated by the dipole moments of the two molecules. In this limit, too, the details of the dipole moment’s origin are irrelevant, and we consider the molecule to be a “point dipole,” with a dipole moment characterized by a magnitude μ and a direction μ. ˆ We consider in this chapter only electrically neutral molecules, so that the Coulomb force between molecules is absent. its energy depends on the relative If a dipole μ is immersed in an electric field E, orientation of the field and the dipole, via Eel = −μ · E. This follows simply from the fact that the positive charges will be pulled in the direction of the field, while the negative charges are pulled the other way. Thus a dipole pointing in the same direction as the field is lower in energy than a dipole pointing in exactly the opposite direction. In classical electrostatics, the energy can continuously vary between these two extreme limits. As an object containing charge, a dipole generates an electric field, which is given, r ). For a point as usual, by the gradient of an electrostatic potential, Emolecule = −∇Φ( dipole the potential Φ is given by Φ(r ) =
μ · rˆ , r2
(2.1)
where r = r rˆ denotes the point in space, relative to the dipole, at which the field is to be evaluated [3]. The dot product in Equation 2.1 gives the field Φ a strong angular dependence. For this reason, it is convenient to use spherical coordinates to describe the physics of dipoles, because they explicitly record directions. Setting rˆ = (θ, φ) and μ ˆ = (α, β) in spherical coordinates, the dipole potential becomes Φ=
μ (cos α cos θ + sin α sin θ cos(β − φ)). r2
(2.2)
For the most familiar case of a dipole aligned along the positive z-axis (α = 0), this yields the familiar result Φ = μ cos θ/r 2 . This potential is maximal along the dipole’s axis (θ = 0 or π), and vanishes in the direction perpendicular to the dipole (θ = π/2). From the results above we can evaluate the interaction potential between two dipoles. One of the dipoles generates an electric field, which acts on the other. Taking the scalar product of one dipole moment with the gradient of the dipole potential Equation 2.2 due to the other, we obtain [3] ) = Vd (R
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
ˆ μ ˆ 2 − 3(μ 1 · R)( 2 · R) μ 1 · μ , 3 R
(2.3)
42
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
= RRˆ is the relative coordinate of the dipoles. This result is general for any where R orientation of each dipole, and for any relative position of the pair of dipoles. In a special case where both dipoles are aligned along the positive z-axis, and where the vector connecting the centers of mass of the two dipoles makes an angle θ with this axis, the dipole–dipole interaction takes a simpler form: 1 − 3 cos2 θ . (2.4) R3 Note that the angle θ as used here has a different meaning from the one in Equation 2.2. We will use θ in both contexts throughout this chapter, hopefully without causing undue confusion. The form 2.4 of the interaction is useful for illustrating the most basic fact of the dipole–dipole interaction: if the two dipoles line up in a head-to-tail orientation (θ = 0 or π), then Vd < 0 and they attract one another; if they lie side by side (θ = π/2), then Vd > 0 and they repel one another. (This expression ignores a contact potential that must be associated to a point dipole to conserve lines of electric flux [3]. However, real molecules are not point dipoles, and the electrostatic potential differs greatly from this dipolar form at length scales inside the molecule, scales that do not concern us here.) Our main goal in this chapter is to investigate how these classical results change when the dipoles belong to molecules that are governed by quantum mechanics. In Section 2.3 we evaluate the energy of a dipole exposed to an external field. In Section 2.4 we consider the field produced by a quantum-mechanical dipole. In Section 2.5 we address the interaction between two dipolar molecules. Vd (r ) = μ1 μ2
2.3
QUANTUM-MECHANICAL DIPOLES IN FIELDS
Whereas the classical energy of a dipole in a field can take a continuum of values between its minimum and maximum, this is no longer the case for a quantummechanical molecule. In this section we will establish the energy spectrum of a polar molecule in an electric field, building from a set of simple examples. To start, we will define the laboratory z-axis to coincide with the direction of an externally applied electric field, so that E = E zˆ . In this case, the projection of the total angular momentum on the z-axis is a conserved quantity.
2.3.1 ATOMS Our main focus in this chapter will be on electrically polarizable dipolar molecules. But before discussing this in detail, we first consider the simpler case of an electrically polarizable atom, namely, hydrogen. This will introduce both the basic physics ideas, and the angular momentum techniques that we will use. In this case a negatively charged electron separated a distance r from a positively charged proton forms a dipole moment μ = −er . Because dipoles require us to consider directions, it is useful to cast the unit vector rˆ into its spherical components [1]: x √ z y ±i = ∓ 2C1±1 (θφ), = C10 (θφ). r r r © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
43
Electric Dipoles at Ultralow Temperatures
Here the C’s are reduced spherical harmonics, related to the usual spherical harmonics by [1] 4π Ckq = Ykq , 2k + 1 and given explicitly for k = 1 by 1 C1±1 (θφ) = ∓ √ sin θe±iφ 2 C10 (θφ) = cos θ.
(2.5)
In general, it is convenient to represent interaction potentials in terms of the functions Ckq (because they do not carry extra factors of 4π), and to use the functions Ykq as wavefunctions in angular degrees of freedom (because they are already properly normalized, by Ylm |Yl m = δll δmm ). Integrals involving the reduced spherical harmonics are conveniently related to the 3-j symbols of angular momentum theory, for example:
d(cos θ) dφCk1 q1 (θφ)Ck2 q2 (θφ)Ck3 q3 (θφ) = 4π
k1 q1
k2 q2
k3 q3
k1 0
k2 0
k3 . 0
The 3-j symbols, in parentheses, are related to the Clebsch–Gordan coefficients. They are widely tabulated and easily computed for applications. In terms of these functions, the Hamiltonian for the atom–field interaction is Hel = −(−er ) · E = ezE = er cos(θ)E = erEC10 (θφ).
(2.6)
The possible energies for a dipole in a field are given by the eigenvalues of the Hamiltonian 2.6. To evaluate these energies in quantum mechanics, we identify the usual basis set of hydrogenic wavefunctions, |nlm, where we ignore spin for this simple illustration: r, θ, φ | nlm = fnl (r)Ylm (θ, φ). The matrix elements between any two hydrogenic states are nlm | −μ · E | n l m = erE
∗ d(cos θ) dφYlm C10 Yl m
= erE(−1)m (2l + 1)(2l + 1) l 1 l l 1 l × . 0 0 0 −m 0 m
(2.7)
Here er = r 2 drfnl (r)rfn l is an effective magnitude of the dipole moment, which can be analytically evaluated for hydrogen [4]. © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
44
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
Some important physics is embodied in Equation 2.7. First, the electric field defines an axis of rotational symmetry (here the z-axis). On general grounds, we therefore expect that the projection of the total angular momentum of the molecule onto this axis is a constant. And indeed, this is built into the 3-j symbols: because the sum of all m quantum numbers in a 3-j symbol should add to zero, Equation 2.7 asserts that m = m , and the electric field cannot couple two different m’s together. A second feature embodied in Equation 2.7 is the action of parity. The hydrogenic wavefunctions have a definite parity, that is, they either change sign, or else remain invariant, upon converting from a coordinate system (x, y, z) to a coordinate system (−x, −y, −z). The sign of the parity-changed wavefunction is given by (−1)l . Thus an s-state (l = 0) has even parity, while a p-state (l = 1) has odd parity. For an electric field pointing in a particular direction, the Hamiltonian 2.6 itself has odd parity, and thus serves to change the parity of the atom. For example, it can couple the s and p states to each other, but not to themselves. This is expressed in Equation 2.7 by the first 3-j symbol, whose symmetry properties require that l + 1 + l = even. This seemingly innocuous statement is the fundamental fact of electric dipole moments of atoms and molecules. It says that, for example the 1s ground state of hydrogen, with l = l = 0, does not, by itself, respond to an electric field at all. Rather, it requires an admixture of a p state to develop a dipole moment. (These remarks are not strictly true. The ground state of hydrogen already has a small admixture of odd-parity states, due to the parity-violating part of the electroweak force. This effect is far too small to concern us here, however.) To evaluate the influence of an electric field on hydrogen, therefore, we must consider at least the nearest state of opposite parity, which is the 2p state. These two states are separated in energy by an amount E1s2p . Considering only these two states, and ignoring any spin structure, the atom-plus-field Hamiltonian is represented by a simple 2 × 2 matrix: −E1s2p /2 μE H= . (2.8) μE E1s2p /2 where the dipole matrix element is given by the convenient shorthand μ = 1s, m = √ 0 | ez | 2p, m = 0 = 128 2ea0 /243 [4]. Of course there are many more p states that the 1s state is coupled to. Plus, all states are further complicated by the spin of the electron and (in hydrogen) the nucleus. Matrix elements for all these can be constructed, and the full matrix diagonalized to approximate the energies to any desired degree of accuracy. However, we are interested here in the qualitative features of dipoles, and so limit ourselves to Equation 2.8. The Stark energies are thus given approximately by E± = ± (μE)2 + (E1s2p /2)2 .
(2.9)
This expression illustrates the basic physics of the quantum mechanical dipole. First, there are necessarily two states (or more) involved. One state decreases in energy as the field is turned on, representing the “normal” case where the electron moves to negative z and the electric dipole moment aligns with the field. The other state, © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
Electric Dipoles at Ultralow Temperatures
45
however, increases in energy with increasing field and represents the dipole moment antialigning with the field. Classically, it is of course possible to align the dipole against the field in a state of unstable equilibrium. Similarly, in quantum mechanics this is a legitimate energy eigenstate, and the dipole will remain antialigned with the field in the absence of perturbations. A second observation about the energies of Equation 2.9 is that the energy is a quadratic function of E at low fields, and only becomes linearly proportional to E at higher fields. Thus the permanent dipole moment of the atom, defined by the zero-field limit ∂E− μpermanent ≡ lim , E →0 ∂E vanishes. The atom, in an energy eigenstate in zero field, has no permanent electric dipole moment. This makes sense because, in zero field, the electron’s position is randomly varied about the atom, lying as much on one side of the nucleus as on the opposite side. The transition from quadratic to linear Stark effect is an example of a competition between two opposing tendencies.At low field, the dominant energy scale is the energy splitting E1s2p between opposite parity states. At higher field values, the interaction energy with the electric field becomes stronger, and the dipole is aligned. The value of the field where this transition occurs is found roughly by setting these energies equal to find a “critical” electric field: Ecritical = E1s2p /2μ. For atomic hydrogen, this field is on the order of 109 V/cm. However, at this field it is already a bad approximation to ignore that fact that there are both 2p1/2 and 2p3/2 states, as well as higher-lying p states, and further coupling between p, d, etc., states. We will not pursue this subject further here.
2.3.2
ROTATING MOLECULES
With these basics in mind, we can move on to molecules. We focus here on diatomic, heteronuclear molecules, although the principles are more general. We will consider only electric fields so small that the electrons cannot be polarized in the sense of the previous section; thus we consider only a single electronic state. However, the charge separation between the two atoms produces an electric dipole moment μ in the rotating frame of the molecule. We assume that the molecule is a rigid rotor and we will not consider explicitly the vibrational motion of the molecule, focusing instead solely on the molecular rotation. (More precisely, we consider μ to incorporate an averaging over the vibrational coordinate of the molecule, much as the electron–proton distance r was averaged over for the hydrogen atom in the previous section.) As a mathematical preliminary, we note the following. To deal with molecules, we are required to transform freely between the laboratory reference frame and the bodyfixed frame that rotates with the molecule. The rotation from the lab frame (x, y, z) © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
46
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
to the body frame (x , y , z ) is governed by a set of Euler angles (α, β, γ). The first two angles α = φ, β = θ coincide with the spherical coordinates (θ, φ) of the body frame’s z axis. By convention, we take the positive z direction to be parallel to the dipole moment μ. The third Euler angle γ serves to orient the x axis in a desired orientation within the body frame; it is thus the azimuthal angle of rotation about the molecular axis. Consider a given angular momentum state | jm referred to the lab frame. This state is only a state of good m in the lab frame, in general. In the body frame, which points in some other direction, the same state will be a linear superposition of different m’s, which we denote in the body frame as ω’s to distinguish them. Moreover, this linear superposition will be a function of the Euler angles, with a transformation that is conventionally denoted by the letter D: D(αβγ) | jω =
| jm jm | D(α, β, γ) | jω
m
≡
j
| jmDmω (α, β, γ).
m
This last line defines the Wigner rotation matrices, whose properties are widely j tabulated. For each j, Dmω is a unitary transformation matrix; note that a rotation can only change m-type quantum numbers, not the total angular momentum j. One of the more useful properties of the D matrices, for us, is dα d cos(β) dγ = 8π2
j1 m1
j
j
j
Dm11 ω1 (αβγ)Dm22 ω2 (αβγ)Dm33 ω3 (αβγ) j2 m2
j3 m3
j1 ω1
j2 ω2
j3 . ω3
(2.10)
Because the dipole is aligned along the molecular axis, and because the molecular axis is tilted at an angle β with respect to the field, and because the field defines the z-axis, the dipole moment is defined by its magnitude μ times a unit vector with polar coordinates (β, α). The Hamiltonian for the molecule–field interaction is given by Hel = −μ · E = −μEC10 (βα) = −μEDq0 (αβγ). j∗
(2.11)
For use below, we have taken the liberty of rewriting C10 as a D-function; since the second index of D is zero, this function does not actually depend on γ, so introducing this variable is not as drastic as it seems. To evaluate energies in quantum mechanics we need to choose a basis set and take matrix elements. The Wigner rotation matrices are the quantum-mechanical eigenfunctions of the rigid rotor. With normalization, these wavefunctions are αβγ | nmn λn =
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
2n + 1 n∗ D . 8π2 mn λn
Electric Dipoles at Ultralow Temperatures
47
As we did for hydrogen, we here ignore spin. Thus n is the quantum number of rotation of the atoms about their center of mass, mn is the projection of this angular momentum in the lab frame, and λn is its projection in the body frame. In this basis, the matrix elements of the Stark interaction are computed using Equation 2.10 to yield · E | n mn λ = −μE(−1)mn −λn (2n + 1)(2n + 1) nmn λn | −μ n 1 n n 1 n × . (2.12) −mn 0 mn −λn 0 λn In an important special case, the molecule is in a Σ state, meaning that the electronic angular momentum projection λn = 0. In this case, Equation 2.12 reduces to the same expression as that for hydrogen, apart from the radial integral. This is as it should be: in both objects, there is simply a positive charge at one end and a negative charge at the other. It does not matter if one of these is an electron, rather than an atom. More generally, however, when λn = 0 there will be a complicating effect of lambda-doubling, which we will discuss in the next section. Thus the physics of the rotating dipole is much the same as that of the hydrogen atom. Equation 2.12 also asserts that, for a Σ state with λn = 0, the electric field interaction vanishes unless n and n have opposite parity. For such a state, the parity is related to the parity of n itself. Thus, for the ground state of a 1 Σ molecule with n = 0, the electric field only has an effect by mixing this state with the next rotational state with n = 1. These states are split by an energy Erot = 2Be , where Be is the rotational constant of the molecule. (In zero field, the state with rotational quantum number n has energy Be n(n + 1).) We can formulate a simple 2 × 2 matrix describing this situation, as we did for hydrogen: −Erot /2 −μE H= , (2.13) −μE +Erot /2 where the dipole matrix element is given by the convenient shorthand notation μ = nmn 0 | μq=0 | n mn 0. There is one such matrix for each value of mn . Of course there are many more rotational states that these states are coupled to. Plus, all states would further be complicated by the spins (if any) of the electrons and nuclei. The matrix 2.13 can be diagonalized just as Equation 2.8 was above, and the same physical conclusions apply. Namely, the molecule in a given rotational state has no permanent electric dipole moment, even though there is a separation of charges in the body frame of the molecule. Second, the Stark effect is quadratic for low fields, and linear only at higher fields, with the transition occurring at a “critical field” Ecrit = Erot /2μ.
(2.14)
To take an example, the NH molecule possesses a 3 Σ ground state. For this state, ignoring spin, the critical field is of the order 7 × 106 V/cm. This is far smaller than the field required to polarize electrons in an atom or molecule, but still large for laboratory-strength electric fields. Diatomic molecules with smaller rotational constants, such as LiF, would have correspondingly smaller critical fields. In any event, by the time the critical field is applied, it is already a bad approximation to © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
48
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
ignore coupling to the other rotational states of the molecule, which must be included for an accurate treatment. We do not consider this topic further here.
2.3.3
MOLECULES WITH LAMBDA-DOUBLING
As we have made clear in the previous two subsections, the effect of an electric field on a quantum-mechanical object is to couple states of opposite parity. For a molecule in a Π or Δ state, there are often two such parity states that are much closer together in energy than the rotational spacing. The two states are said to be the components of a “Λ-doublet.” Because they are close together in energy, these two states can then be mixed at much smaller fields than are required to mix rotational levels. The physics underlying the lambda doublet is rather complex, and we refer the reader to the literature for details [2,5]. However, in broad terms, the argument is something like this: a Π state has an electronic angular momentum projection of magnitude 1 about the molecular axis. This angular momentum comes in two projections, for the two senses of rotation about the axis, and these projections are nominally degenerate in energy. The rotation of the molecule, however, can break the degeneracy between these levels, and (it so happens) the resulting nondegenerate eigenfunctions are also eigenfunctions of parity. The main point is that the resulting energy splitting is usually quite small, and these parity states can be mixed in fields much smaller than those required to mix rotational states. To this end, we modify the rigid-rotor wavefunction of the molecule to incorporate the electronic angular momentum: αβγ | jmω =
2j + 1 j∗ Dmω (αβγ). 8π2
(2.15)
Here j is the total (rotation-plus-electronic) angular momentum of the molecule, and m and ω are the projections of j on the laboratory and body-fixed axes, respectively. Using the total j angular momentum, rather than just the molecular rotation n, marks the use of a “Hund’s case a” representation, rather than the Hund’s case b that was implicit in the previous section [2]. In this basis the matrix element of the electric field Hamiltonian 2.11 becomes jmω | −μ · E | j m ω = −μE(−1)
m−ω
(2j
+ 1)(2j
j + 1) −m
1 0
j m
j −ω
1 0
j . (2.16) ω
In Equation 2.16, the 3-j symbols imply conservation laws. The first asserts that m = m is conserved, as we already knew. The second 3-j symbol adds to this the fact that ω = ω . This is the statement that the electric field cannot exert a torque around the axis of the dipole moment itself. Moreover, in the present model we assert that j = j , because the next higher-lying j level is far away in energy, and only weakly mixes with the ground state j. With this approximation, the 3-j symbols have simple © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
49
Electric Dipoles at Ultralow Temperatures
algebraic expressions, and we can simplify the matrix element: jmω | −μ · E | jmω = −μE
mω . j( j + 1)
The physical content of this expression is illustrated in Figure 2.1. Notice that both m and ω can have a sign, and that whether the energy is positive or negative depends on both signs. An essential point is that there is not a unique state representing the dipole aligned with the field. Rather, there are two such states, distinguished by different angular momentum quantum numbers but possessing the same energy. To distinguish these in the following we will refer to the two states in Figures 2.1a and b as molecules of type | a and type | b, respectively. Likewise, for molecules nominally antialigned with the field, we will refer to types | c and | d, corresponding to the two states in Figures 2.1c and d. The existence of these degeneracies will lead to novel phenomena in these kinds of molecules, as we discuss below. As to the lambda doubling, it is, as we have asserted, diagonal in a basis where parity is a good quantum number. In terms of the basis (Equation 2.15), wavefunctions of well-defined parity are given by the linear combinations 1 | jmω ¯ = √ [| jmω ¯ + | jm − ω]. ¯ 2
(a)
m>0
j
(2.17)
(b) w>0 w>0 m<0
j (c)
m>0
j
(d) w<0 w>0 j
m<0
FIGURE 2.1 Energetics of a polar molecule in an electric field. The molecule’s dipole moment points from the negatively charged atom (large circle) to the positively charged atom (small circle) as indicated by the thick arrow. The dashed line indicates the positive direction of the molecules’ body axis, while the vertical arrow represents the direction of the applied electric field. The dipole aligns with the field, on average, if either (i) the angular momentum j aligns with the field and m > 0, ω > 0 (a), or (ii) j aligns against the field and m < 0, ω < 0 (b). Similar remarks apply to dipoles that antialign with the field (c,d).
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
50
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
Here we define ω ¯ =| ω |, the absolute value of ω. For a given value of m, the linear combinations of ±ω ¯ in Equation 2.17 are distinguished by the parity quantum number = ±1. It is straightforward to show that in the parity basis Equation 2.17 the Λ-doubling is off-diagonal. The net result is that for each value of m, the Hamiltonian for our lambda-doubled molecule can be represented as a 2 × 2 matrix, similar to the ones above: −Q −Δ/2 H= , −Δ/2 Q where Δ is the lambda doubling energy, that is, the energy difference between the two parity states, and |m|ω ¯ Q ≡ μE j( j + 1) is a manifestly positive quantity. This is the Hamiltonian we will treat in the remainder of this chapter. The difference here from the previous subsections is that the basis is now that of Equation 2.15, which diagonalizes the electric field interaction rather than the zero-field Hamiltonian. This change reflects our emphasis on molecules in strong fields where their dipole moments are made manifest. The zero-field Λ-doubling Hamiltonian is considered, for the most part, to be a perturbation. In general, for field interactions that are not infinitely larger than the lambda doublet, the energy eigenstates are superpositions of the strong-field states | jm ± ω. ¯ For each value of m (which, remember, is conserved by the field), the mixing of +ω ¯ and −ω ¯ states is conveniently represented by a mixing angle that we denote by δm : ¯ + sin δm | jm − ω ¯ | jmω ¯ = + = cos δm | jmω ¯ + cos δm | jm − ω. ¯ | jmω ¯ = − = − sin δm | jmω
(2.18)
Explicitly, the mixing angle as a function of field is given by tan δ|m| =
Δ/2 = − tan δ−|m| , Q + Q 1 + η2
in terms of the energy Q and the dimensionless parameter ηm =
Δ . 2Q
Notice that with this definition, δm is positive when m is positive, and δ−m = −δm . The energies of these states are conveniently summarized by the expression Emω ¯
mω ¯ = −μE 1 + η2 , j( j + 1)
m = 0.
This is a very compact way of writing the results that will facilitate writing the expressions below. Notice that the intuition afforded by Figure 2.1 is still intact in © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
51
Electric Dipoles at Ultralow Temperatures
these energies, but by replacing the sign of for the sign of ω. Thus states with m > 0 have negative energy, while states with m < 0 have positive energy. These expressions are somewhat problematic in the limit where the field vanishes, which sets Q = 0. However, this limit exists and it is easily shown that δ| m| = π/4 in this limit, while the energies become −μEsign(m)Δ/2. Likewise, we also have Q = 0 whenever m = 0, for any value of the field strength. Again, we can still write the eigenstates in the form of 2.18, provided that we set δ0 =
π , 4
and understand that the corresponding energies, independent of field, are simply E0ω ¯ = −Δ/2. Like the dipoles considered above, this model has a quadratic Stark effect at low energies, rolling over to linear at electric fields exceeding the critical field given by setting Q = Δ/2. This criterion gives a critical field of Ecrit =
Δj( j + 1) . 2μ| m | ω ¯
(2.19)
To take an example, consider the ground state of OH, which has j = ω ¯ = 3/2, μ = 1.7 Db, and a Λ-doublet splitting of 0.06 cm−1 . In its m = 3/2 ground state, its critical field is ∼1600 V/cm. Again, we have explicitly ignored the spin of the electron. The parity states are therefore easily mixed in fields that are both small enough to easily obtain in the laboratory, and small enough that no second-order coupling to rotational or electronic states needs to be considered. Keeping the relatively small number of molecular states is therefore a reasonable approximation, and highly desirable as it simplifies our discussion. (In OH there is also the ω ¯ = 1/2 state to consider, but it is also far away in energy compared to the Λ-doublet, and we ignore it. It does play a role in the fine structure of OH, however, and this should be included in a quantitative model of OH.)
2.4 THE FIELD DUE TO A DIPOLE Once polarized, each of the Λ-doubled molecules discussed above is itself the source of an electric field. The field due to a molecule is given above by Equation 2.1. In what follows, it is convenient to cast this potential in terms of the spherical tensors defined above: Φ(r ) =
μ · rˆ μ
= 2 (−1)q C1q (αβ)C1−q (θφ). 2 r r q
(2.20)
That this form is correct can be verified by simple substitution, using the definitions of Equation 2.5 and comparing to Equation 2.2. It seems at first unnecessarily complicated to write Equation 2.20 in this way. However, the effort required to do so © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
52
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
will be rewarded when we need to evaluate the potential for quantum-mechanical dipoles below. For a classical dipole, defining the direction (αβ) of its dipole moment would immediately specify the electrostatic potential it generates according to Equation 2.20. However, in quantum mechanics the potential will result from suitably averaging the orientation of μ over the distribution of (αβ), weighted by probabilities that are dictated by the molecule’s wavefunction. To evaluate this, we need to evaluate matrix elements of Equation 2.20 in the basis of energy eigenstates 2.18. This is easily done using Equation 2.10, along with formulas that simplify the 3-j symbols. The result is
jmω | C1q
⎧ ( j + m)( j − m ) ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ , q = +1 − ⎪ ⎨ 2 ω | jm ω = δωω m, q=0 , j( j + 1) ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎩+ ( j − m)( j + m ) , q = −1 2
(2.21)
where the quantum numbers m and ω are signed quantities. Also note that this integration is over the molecular degrees of freedom (αβ) in Equation 2.20. This still leaves the angular dependence on (θφ), which characterizes the field in space around the dipole. From expression 2.21 it is clear that this matrix element changes sign upon either (1) reversing the sign of both m and m or (2) changing the sign of ω. Moreover, jmω | C1q | jm − ω = 0, because ω is conserved by the electric field. Using these observations, we can readily compute the matrix elements of Φ in the dressed basis 2.18. Generally they take the form ¯ = μ jmω ¯ | C1q | jm ω ¯ (−1)q jmω ¯ | Φ(r ) | jm ω
C1−q (θφ) . r2
(2.22)
The matrix elements in front of Equation 2.22 represent the quantum-mechanical manifestation of the dipole’s orientation. These matrix elements follow from the above definition of the eigenstates (Equation 2.18). Explicitly, jmω, ¯ | C1q | jm ω, ¯ = cos(δm + δm ) jmω ¯ | C1q | jm ω ¯ jmω, ¯ −| C1q | jm ω, ¯ + = jmω, ¯ + | C1q | jm ω, ¯ −
(2.23)
= − sin(δm + δm ) jmω ¯ | C1q | jm ω. ¯ In all these expressions, the value of q is set by angular momentum conservation to q = m − m . This description, while complete within our model, nevertheless remains somewhat opaque. Let us therefore specialize it to the case of a particular energy eigenstate | jmω. ¯ In this state, the averaged electrostatic potential of the dipole is cos θ mω . cos 2δm Φ(r ) ≡ jmω ¯ | Φ(r ) | jmω ¯ = μ j( j + 1) r2 © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
(2.24)
Electric Dipoles at Ultralow Temperatures
53
Here the factor in parentheses is a quantum-mechanical correction to the magnitude of the dipole moment. The factor cos 2δm expresses the degree of polarization: in a strong field, δm = 0 and the dipole is at maximum strength, whereas in zero field δm = π/4 and the dipole vanishes. Notice that for a given value of m, the potential generated by the states with = ± differ by a sign. this is appropriate, because these states correspond to dipoles pointing in opposite directions (Figure 2.1). The off-diagonal matrix elements in Equation 2.22 are also important, for two reasons. First, it may be desirable to create superpositions of different energy eigenstates, and computing these matrix elements requires the off-diagonal elements in Equation 2.22, as we will see shortly. Second, when two dipoles interact with each other, one will experience the electric field due to the other, and this field need not lie parallel to the z-axis. Hence, the m quantum number of an individual dipole is no longer conserved, and elements of Equation 2.22 with q = 0 are required.
2.4.1
EXAMPLE: j = 1/2
To illustrate these abstract points, we consider here the simplest molecular state with a Λ doublet: a molecule with j = 1/2, which has ω ¯ = 1/2, and consists of four internal states in our model. Based on the discussion above, we tabulate the matrix elements between these states in Table 2.1. Because we have j = 1/2, we suppress the index j in this section. For concreteness, we focus on a type | a molecule, as defined in Figure 2.1. This molecule aligns with the field and produces an electrostatic potential (Equation 2.24). However, if the molecule is prepared in a state that is a superposition of this state with another, a different electrostatic potential can result. We first note that combining | a with | b produces nothing new, because both states generate the same potential. An alternative superposition combines state | a with state | c. In this case the two states have the same value of m, but are nevertheless nondegenerate. We define iω0 t 1 −iω0 t 1 | ψac = Ae ω, ¯ + + Be ω, ¯ − , 2 2 for arbitrary complex numbers A and B with | A |2 +| B |2 = 1. Because the two states are nondegenerate, it is necessary to include the explicit time-dependent phase factors, where ω0 = | Emω ¯ |/, and 2ω0 is the energy difference between the states. As usual in quantum mechanics, these phases will beat against one another to make the observables time dependent. Now some algebra identifies the mean value of the electrostatic potential, averaged over state | ψac , as μ | A |2 −| B |2 cos 2δ1/2 ψac | Φ(r ) | ψac = 3 cos θ − 2| AB | sin 2δ1/2 cos(2ω0 t − δ) . (2.25) r2 This potential has the usual cos θ angular dependence, meaning that the dipole remains aligned along the field’s axis. However, the magnitude, and even the sign, of the dipole © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
54
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
TABLE 2.1 ¯ | C1q | jm ω ¯ for a j = 1/2 Molecule Matrix Elements jm ω
1 ω+ ¯ 2 1 ω− ¯ 2 1 ¯ − ω+ 2 1 − ω− ¯ 2
1 ω+ ¯ 2
1 ω− ¯ 2
1 cos 2δ1/2 3
1 − sin 2δ1/2 3
1 − sin 2δ1/2 3 √ 2 3
1 − cos 2δ1/2 3
0
2 3
0
1 − cos 2δ1/2 3
1 − sin 2δ1/2 3
1 − sin 2δ1/2 3
1 cos 2δ1/2 3
0
√ −
2 3
1 − ω+ ¯ 2
1 − ω− ¯ 2
√ −
2 3
0 √
To obtain matrix elements of the electrostatic potential Φ(r ), these matrix elements should be multiplied by (−1)q C1−q (θφ)μ/r 2 , where q = m − m .
change over time. The first term in square brackets in Equation 2.25 gives a constant, dc component to the dipole moment, which depends on the population imbalance | A |2 −| B |2 between the two states. The second term adds to this an oscillating component with angular frequency 2ω0 . The leftover phase δ is an irrelevant offset, and comes from the phase of A∗ B, that is, the relative phase of the two components at time t = 0. It is therefore possible to construct a superposition of states of the dipole, such that the effective dipole moment of the molecule bobs up and down in time. The amount that the dipole bobs, relative to the constant component, can be controlled by the relative population in the two states. Moreover, the degree of polarization of the molecule plays a significant role. For a fully polarized molecule, when δ1/2 = 0, only the dc portion of the dipole persists, although even it can vanish if there is equal population in the two states, “dipole up” and “dipole down.” As another example, we consider the superposition of | a with | d. Now the two states have different values of m as well as different energies: iω0 t 1 −iω0 t 1 ¯ + + Be ¯ + . | ψad = Ae 2 ω, − 2 ω, The dipole potential this superposition generates is cos θ μ ψad | Φ(r ) | ψad = cos 2δ1/2 | A |2 −| B |2 3 r2 2μ sin θ + . Re A∗ Be−i(φ+2ω0 t) 3 r2 This expression can be put in a useful and interesting form if we parametrize the coefficients A and B as α α A = cos e−iβ/2 B = sin eiβ/2 . 2 2 © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
Electric Dipoles at Ultralow Temperatures
55
This way of writing A and B seems arbitrary, but it is not. It is the same parametrization that is used in constructing the Bloch sphere, which is a powerful tool in the analysis of any two-level system [6]. This parametrization leads to the following expression for the potential: ψad | Φ(r ) | ψad =
1μ cos 2δ cos α cos θ + sin α sin θ cos((β − 2ω t) − φ) . 1/2 0 3 r2 (2.26)
The interpretation of this result is clear upon comparing it to the classical expression 2.2. First consider that the molecule is perfectly polarized, so that cos 2δ1/2 = 1. Then Equation 2.26 represents the potential due to a dipole whose polar coordinates are (α, β − ωt). That is, this dipole makes (on average) an angle α with respect to the field, and it precesses about the field with an angular frequency 2ω0 . Interestingly, even in this strong field limit where the field nominally aligns the dipole along z, quantum mechanics allows the dipole to point in quite a different direction. As the field relaxes, the z-component reduces, but this dipole still has a component precessing about the field.
2.4.2
EXAMPLE: j = 1
We also consider a molecule with spin j = 1. Here there are in principle three mixing angles, δ1 , δ0 , and δ−1 . However, as noted above we have δ−1 = −δ1 and δ0 = π/4, so that the entire electric field dependence of these matrix elements is incorporated in the single parameter δ1 . In this notation, the matrix elements of the electrostatic potential for a j = 1 molecule are given in Table 2.2. Similar remarks apply to the spin-1 case as applied to the spin-1/2 case. If the molecule is in an eigenstate, say | +1ω, ¯ −, then the expectation value of the dipole points along the field axis, and its distribution has the usual cos θ dependence. In an eigenstate with m = 0, however, the expectation value of the dipole vanishes altogether. As before, the molecule can also be in a superposition state. No matter how complicated this superposition is, the expectation value of the dipole must instantaneously point in some direction, since the only available angular dependence resides in the C1q functions, which yield only dipoles. In other words, no superposition can generate the field pattern of a quadrupole moment, for example. Where this dipole points, and how its orientation evolves with time, however, can be nontrivial. For example, a superposition of | +1ω, ¯ + and | +1ω, ¯ − can bob up and down, just like the analogous superposition for j = 1/2. However, for j = 1 molecules additional superpositions are possible. For example, consider the combination | ψ3 = Aeiω0 t | +1ω, ¯ + + BeiωΔ t | 0ω, ¯ + + Ceiω0 t | −1ω, ¯ −, where ωΔ = Δ/2 is a shorthand notation for half the lambda doubling energy. Let us further assume for convenience that A, B, and C are all real. Then the expectation © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
56
TABLE 2.2
¯ | C1q | jm ω ¯ for a j = 1 Molecule Matrix Elements of jmω ¯ | +1ω−
¯ | 0ω+
¯ | 0ω−
¯ | −1ω+
¯ | −1ω−
+1ω+ ¯ |
1 cos 2δ1 2
1 − sin 2δ1 2
1 − cos(δ1 + π/4) 2
1 sin(δ1 + π/4) 2
0
0
+1ω− ¯ |
1 − sin 2δ1 2
1 − cos 2δ1 2
1 sin(δ1 + π/4) 2
1 cos(δ1 + π/4) 2
0
0
0ω+ ¯ |
1 cos(δ1 + π/4) 2
1 − sin(δ1 + π/4) 2
0
0
1 − cos(−δ1 + π/4) 2
1 sin(−δ1 + π/4) 2
0ω− ¯ |
1 − sin(δ1 + π/4) 2
1 − cos(δ1 + π/4) 2
0
0
1 sin(−δ1 + π/4) 2
1 cos(−δ1 + π/4) 2
0
0
1 cos(−δ1 + π/4) 2
1 − sin(−δ1 + π/4) 2
1 − cos 2δ1 2
1 − sin 2δ1 2
−1ω+ ¯ |
1 1 1 1 − sin(−δ1 + π/4) − cos(−δ1 + π/4) − sin 2δ1 cos 2δ1 2 2 2 2 q 2 To obtain the matrix elements of the electrostatic potential Φ(r ), these matrix elements should be multiplied by (−1) C1−q (θφ)μ/r , where q = m − m . −1ω− ¯ |
0
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
0
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
¯ | +1ω+
57
Electric Dipoles at Ultralow Temperatures
value of the electrostatic potential is ψ3 | Φ(r ) | ψ3 =
cos θ μ μ sin θ cos 2δ1 A2 + C 2 + √ cos(δ1 + π/4)B 2 2 r2 r 2 × [A cos((ωΔ − ω0 )t − φ) − C cos(−(ωΔ − ω0 )t − φ)].
By analogy with remarks in the previous section, this represents a dipole with a constant component along the z-axis, which depends on both the strength of the field and on | A |2 + | C |2 , the total population in the ±m states. It also has a component in the (x–y)-plane (given by the sin θ dependence), orthogonal to the field’s direction. In the case where C = 0, this component would precess around the field axis with a frequency ωΔ − ω0 , in a clockwise direction as viewed from the +z direction. On the other hand, if A = 0, this component would rotate at this frequency but in a counterclockwise direction. If both components are present and A = C, then the result will be, not a rotation, but an oscillation of this component from, say, +x to −x, in much the same way that linearly polarized light in a superposition of left- and right-circularly polarized components. More generally, if A = C, then the tip of the dipole moment will trace out an elliptical path. However, in the limit of zero field, ω0 reduces to ωΔ and these time-dependent effects go away.
2.5
INTERACTION OF DIPOLES
Having thus carefully treated individual dipoles and their quantum-mechanical matrix elements, we are now in a position to do the same for the dipole–dipole interaction between two molecules. This interaction depends on the orientation of each dipole, μ 1 . This interaction has the form (Equation 2.3): and μ 2 , and on their relative location, R ˆ μ ˆ 2 − 3(μ μ 1 · μ 1 · R)( 2 · R) R3 √ 6μ1 μ2
=− (−1)q [μ1 ⊗ μ2 ]2q C2−q (θφ). R3 q
) = Vd (R
(2.27)
In going from the first line to the second, we assume that the intermolecular axis = (R, θ, φ). The makes an angle θ with respect to the laboratory z-axis, so that R angles θ and φ thus stand for something slightly different than in the previous section. The second line in Equation 2.27 also rewrites the interaction in a compact tensor notation that is useful for the calculations we are about to do. Here √
1 1 q 2 [μ1 ⊗ μ2 ]2q = 5 C1q1 (β1 α1 )C1q2 (β2 α2 ) (−1) q −q1 −q2 q1 q2
denotes the second-rank tensor composed of the two first-rank tensors (i.e., vectors) C1q1 (β1 α1 ) and C1q2 (β2 α2 ) that give the orientation of the molecular axes [1]. Equation 2.27 highlights the important point that the orientations of the dipoles are © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
58
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
intimately tied to the relative motion of the dipoles: if a molecule changes its internal state and sheds angular momentum, that angular momentum may appear in the orbital motion of the molecules around each other.
2.5.1
POTENTIAL MATRIX ELEMENTS
Equation 2.27 is a perfectly reasonable way of writing the classical dipole–dipole interaction. Quantum mechanically, however, we are interested in molecules that are in particular quantum states | jmω, ¯ , rather than molecules whose dipoles point in particular directions (α, β). We must therefore construct matrix elements of the interaction potential 2.27 in the basis we have described in Section 2.3.3. Writing the interaction in the form above has the advantage that each term in the sum factors into three pieces: one depending on the coordinates of molecule 1, another depending on the coordinates of molecule 2, and a third depending on the relative coordinates (θ, φ). This makes it easier to evaluate the Hamiltonian in a given basis. For two molecules we consider the basis functions α1 β1 γ1 | jm1 ω, ¯ 1 α2 β2 γ2 | jm2 ω, ¯ 2 ,
(2.28)
as defined above. In this basis, matrix elements of the interaction become jm1 ω, ¯ 1 ; jm2 ω, ¯ 2 | Vd (θφ) | jm1 ω, ¯ 1 ; jm2 ω, ¯ 2 √ 2 1 1 = − 30μ1 μ2 q −q1 −q2 × jm1 ω, ¯ 1 | C1q1 | jm1 ω, ¯ 1 jm2 ω, ¯ 2 | C1q2 | jm2 ω, ¯ 2
C2−q (θφ) (2.29) R3
¯ are evaluated in Equawhere matrix elements of the form jmω, ¯ | C1q | jm ω, tion 2.23. Conservation of angular momentum projection constrains the values of the summation indices, so that q1 = m1 − m1 , q2 = m2 − m2 , and q = q1 + q2 = (m1 + m2 ) − (m1 + m2 ). To make this model concrete, we report here the values of the second-rank reduced spherical harmonics [1]: 1 (3 cos2 θ − 1) 2 1/2 3 =∓ cos θ sin θe±iφ 2 1/2 3 = sin2 θe±2iφ . 8
C20 = C2±1 C2±2
We also tabulate the relevant 3-j symbols in Table 2.3. Viewed roughly as a collision process, we can think of two molecules approaching each other with angular momenta m1 and m2 , scattering, and departing with angular © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
59
Electric Dipoles at Ultralow Temperatures
TABLE 2.3 The 3-j Symbols Needed to Construct the Matrix Elements in Equation 2.29
q
q1
q2
0 0 1 2
0 1 1 1
0 −1 0 1
2 q
1 1 −q1 −q2 √ 2/15 √ 1/ 30 √ −1/ 10 √ 1/ 5
Source: Brink, D.M. and Satchler, G.R., Angular Momentum, 3rd ed., Oxford University Press, 1993. Note that these symbols remain invariant under interchanging the indices q1 and q2 , as well as under simultaneously changing the signs of q1 , q2 , and q.
momenta m1 and m2 , in which case q is the angular momentum transferred to the relative angular momentum of the pair of molecules. Remarkably, apart from a numerical factor that can be easily calculated, the part of the quantum-mechanical dipole–dipole interaction corresponding to angular momentum transfer q has an angular dependence given simply by the multipole term C2−q . Suppose that the molecules, when far apart, are in the well-defined states of 2.28. Then the diagonal matrix element of the dipole–dipole potential evaluates to (1 − 3 cos2 θ) m1 1 ω ¯ m 2 2 ω ¯ μ2 cos 2δm1 cos 2δm2 . (2.30) μ1 j( j + 1) j( j + 1) R3 This has exactly the form of the interaction for classical, polarized dipoles, as in Equation 2.4. The difference is that each dipole μ1 , μ2 , is replaced by a quantumcorrected version (in large parentheses). It is no coincidence that this is the same quantum-corrected dipole moment that appeared in expression 2.24 for the field due to a single dipole. When both dipoles are aligned with the field, we have m1 1 > 0 and m2 2 > 0 (e.g., both molecules are of type | a), and the interaction has the angular dependence ∝ (1 − 3 cos2 θ). On the other hand, when one dipole is aligned with the field and the other is against (e.g., one molecule is of type | a and the other is of type | c), then the opposite sign occurs – just as we would expect from classical intuition. More generally, at finite electric field, or at finite values of R, the molecules do not remain in the separated-molecule eigenstates 2.28, because they exert torques on one another. The interaction among several different internal molecular states makes the scattering of two molecules a “multichannel problem,” the formulation and solution of which is described in Chapters 5, 9, 13, 14, and 15. However, a good way to visualize the action of the dipole–dipole potential on the molecules is to construct an adiabatic , the relative surface. To do so, we diagonalize the interaction at a fixed value of R location of the two molecules. Before doing this, we must consider the quantum statistics of the molecules. If the two molecules under consideration are identical bosons or identical fermions (with © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
60
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
μ1 = μ2 = μ), then the total two-molecule wavefunction must account for this fact. This total wavefunction is α1 β1 γ1 | jm1 ω ¯ 1 α2 β2 γ2 | jm2 ω ¯ 2 Fjω;m ¯ 1 1 m2 2 (R, θ, φ). This wavefunction is either symmetric or antisymmetric under the exchange of the two particles, which is accomplished by swapping the internal states of the molecules, while simultaneously exchanging their center-of-mass coordinates, that to −R : is, by mapping R (α1 β1 γ1 ) ↔ (α2 β2 γ2 ) R→R
(2.31)
θ→π−θ φ → π + φ.
For the molecule’s internal coordinates, a wavefunction with definite exchange symmetry is given by α1 β1 γ1 | jm1 ω ¯ 1 α2 β2 γ2 | jm2 ω ¯ 2 s =
1
2(1 + δm1 m2 δ1 2 ) × α1 β1 γ1 | jm1 ω ¯ 1 α2 β2 γ2 | jm2 ω ¯ 2
+ sα2 β2 γ2 | jm1 ω ¯ 1 α1 β1 γ1 | jm2 ω ¯ 2 . (2.32)
The new index s = ±1 denotes whether the combination 2.32 is even or odd under the → −R interchange. If s = +1, then F must be symmetric under the transformation R for bosons, and odd under this transformation for identical fermions. If s = −1, the reverse must hold. We now have the tools required to consider the form of the dipole–dipole interaction beyond the “pure” dipolar form 2.30. The details of this analysis will depend on the Schrödinger equation to be solved. The Schrödinger equation reads
2 2 − ∇ + Vd + HS Ψ = EΨ. 2mr
Here HS stands for the threshold Hamiltonian that includes Λ-doubling and electric field interactions, and is assumed to be diagonal in the basis 2.32; and mr is the reduced mass of the pair of molecules. In the usual way, we expand the total wavefunction Ψ as 1
Ψ(R, θ, φ) = Fi (R, θ, φ) | i , R i
where the index i stands for the collective set of quantum numbers { jω; ¯ m1 1 m2 2 s}. © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
61
Electric Dipoles at Ultralow Temperatures
Inserting this expansion into the Schrödinger equation and projecting onto the ket i | leads to the following set of coupled equations: 2 ∂ ∂2 ∂ 1 1 ∂2 − Fi sin θ + + 2 2mr ∂R2 ∂θ R sin θ ∂θ R2 sin2 θ ∂φ2
+ i | Vd | i Fi + i | HS | iFi = EFi . i
If we keep N channels i, then this represents a set of N coupled differential equations. We can, in principle, solve these subject to physical boundary conditions for any bound or scattering problem at hand. For visualization, however, we will find it convenient to reduce these equations to fewer than three independent variables. We carry out this task in the following subsections.
2.5.2 ADIABATIC POTENTIAL ENERGY SURFACES IN TWO DIMENSIONS Applying an electric field in the zˆ -direction establishes zˆ as an axis of cylindrical symmetry for the two-body interaction. The angle φ determines the relative orientation of the two molecules about this axis, thus the interaction cannot depend on this angle. To handle this, we include an additional factor in our basis set, 1 | ml = √ exp(iml φ). 2π We then expand the total wavefunction as ΨMtot (R, θ, φ) =
1
F (R, θ)| ml | i . R i ml i ml
In each term of this expression the quantum numbers must satisfy the conservation requirement for fixed total angular momentum projection, Mtot = m1 + m2 + ml . In addition, applying exchange symmetry to each term requires that Fi,ml (R, π − θ) = s(−1)ml Fi,ml (R, θ) for bosons, and s(−1)ml +1 Fi,ml (R, θ) for fermions. Inserting this expansion into the Schrödinger equation yields a slightly different set of coupled equations: 2 − 2mr +
∂2 1 ∂ ∂ + sin θ Fi,ml ∂θ ∂R2 R2 sin2 θ ∂θ
2 ml2 2mr
R2 sin2 θ
Fiml +
i ml
i | Vd2D | i Fi m + i | HS | iFiml = EFiml . (2.33) l
This substitution has the effect of replacing the differential form of the azimuthal kinetic energy, ∝ ∂ 2 /∂φ2 , by an effective centrifugal potential ∝ ml2 /R2 sin2 θ. In © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
62
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
addition, the matrix elements of the dipolar potential Vd2D are slightly different from those of Vd . Recall that the (θ, φ)-dependent part of the matrix element 2.29 is proportional to C2−q (θ, φ), which we will write explicitly as C2−q (θφ) ≡ C2−q (θ) exp(−iqφ). This equation explicitly defines a new function C2−q (θ) that is a function of θ alone, and that is proportional to an associated Legendre polynomial. The matrix element of the potential now includes the following integral:
1 1 dφ √ e−iml φ C2−q (θ)e−iqφ √ eiml φ 2π 2π C2−q (θ) = dφei(Mtot −Mtot )φ 2π
ml | C2−q | ml =
C2−q (θ), = δMtot Mtot
which establishes the conservation of the projection of total angular momentum by the dipole–dipole interaction. Therefore, matrix elements of Vd2D in this representation are identical to those in of Vd in Equation 2.29 except that the factor exp(−iqφ) is . replaced by δMtot Mtot With these matrix elements in hand, we can construct solutions to the coupled differential equations 2.33. However, to understand the character of the potential surface, it is useful to construct adiabatic potential energy surfaces. This means that, for a fixed relative position of the molecules (R, θ), we find the energy spectrum of Equations 2.33 by diagonalizing the Hamiltonian Vc2D + Vd2D + HS , where Vc2D is a short-hand notation for the centrifugal potential discussed above. This approximation is common throughout atomic and molecular physics, and amounts to defining a single surface that comes as close as possible to representing what is, ultimately, multichannel dynamics.
2.5.3
EXAMPLE: j = 1/2 MOLECULES
Analytic results for the adiabatic surfaces are rather difficult to obtain. Consider the simplest realization of our model, a molecule with spin j = 1/2. In this case each molecule has four internal states (two values of m and two values of ), so that the two-molecule basis comprises 16 elements. Dividing these according to exchange symmetry of the molecules’ internal coordinates, there are ten channels within the manifold of s = +1 channels, and six within the s = −1 manifold. These are the cases we will discuss in the following, although the same qualitative features also appear in higher-j molecules. As the simplest illustration of the influence of internal structure on the dipolar interaction, we will focus on the lowest-energy adiabatic surface, and show how it differs from the “pure dipolar” result (Equation 2.30) as the molecules approach one another. The physics underlying this difference arises from the fact that the dipole–dipole interaction becomes stronger as the molecules get closer together, and at some point this © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
63
Electric Dipoles at Ultralow Temperatures
interaction is stronger than the action of the external field that holds their orientation fixed in the lab. The intermolecular distance at which this happens can be approximately calculated by setting the two interactions equal, μ2 /R03 = (μE)2 + (Δ/2)2 , yielding a characteristic distance R0 =
μ2 (μE)2 + (Δ/2)2
1/3 .
When R R0 , the electric field interaction is dominant, the dipoles are aligned, and the interaction is given by Equation 2.30. When R becomes comparable to, or less than, R0 , then the dipoles tend to align in a head-to-tail orientation to minimize their energy, regardless of their relative location. Before proceeding, it is instructive to point out how large the scale R0 can be for realistic molecules. For the OH molecule considered above, with μ = 1.7 D and Δ = 0.06 cm−1 , the molecule can be polarized in a field of E ≈ 1600 V/cm. At this field, the characteristic radius is approximately R0 ≈ 120a0 (where a0 = 0.053 nm is the Bohr radius), far larger than the scale of the molecules themselves. Therefore, while the dipole–dipole interaction is by far the largest interaction energy at large R, over a significant range of R this potential does not take the usual dipolar form. To take an even more extreme case, the molecule NiH has a ground state of 2 Δ symmetry with j = 5/2 [2]. Because it is a Δ, rather than a Π, state, its Λ doublet is far smaller, probably on the order of ∼10−5 cm−1 . This translates into a critical field of E ≈ 0.5 V/cm, and a characteristic radius at this field R0 ≈ 2000a0 ≈ 0.09 μm. This length is approaching a nonnegligible fraction of the interparticle distance in a Bose–Einstein condensed sample of such molecules (assuming a density of 1014 cm−3 , this spacing is of order 0.2 μm). Deviations from the simple dipolar behavior may thus influence the macroscopic properties of a quantum degenerate dipolar gas (see Chapter 12). As an example, we present in Figure 2.2 sections of the lowest-energy adiabatic potential energy surfaces for a fictitious j = 1/2 molecule whose mass, dipole moment, and Λ doublet are equal to those of OH. These were calculated in a strongfield limit with E = 104 V/cm. Each row corresponds to a particular intermolecular separation, which is compared to the characteristic radius R0 . However, as noted above, there are two possible ways for the molecule to have its lowest energy, as illustrated by parts (a) and (b) of Figure 2.1. Interestingly, it turns out that these give rise to rather different adiabatic surfaces. To illustrate this, we show in the left column of Figure 2.2 the surface fora pair of type | a molecules, which corresponds at infinitely large R to the channel 21 +, 21 +; s = 1 ; and in the right column we show combinations of one type | a and one type | b molecule. In the latter case, there are two possible symmetries corresponding to s = ±1, both of which are shown. Finally, for comparison, the unperturbed “pure dipole” result is shown in all panels as a dotted line. Consider first two molecules of type | a (left column of Figure 2.2). For large distances R > R0 (Figure 2.2a), the adiabatic potential deviates only slightly from the pure-state result, reducing the repulsion at θ = π/2. When R approaches the © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
64
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications |aaÒ
(a)
|ab, sÒ
(d)
Energy (K)
0.02 0.00 1.5R0 –0.02
Energy (K)
(b) 0.08
(e)
0.00
R0 s = +1 s = –1
–0.08
(f )
Energy (K)
(c) 0.0
0.5R0 –0.5 –1.0 0
p/2 q
p
0
p/2 q
p
FIGURE 2.2 Angular dependence of adiabatic potential energies for various combinations of molecules at different interparticle spacings R, which are indicated on the right side. Dotted lines: diagonal matrix element of the interaction, assuming both molecules remain strongly aligned with the electric field. Solid and dashed lines: adiabatic surfaces. These surfaces are based on the j = 1/2 model discussed in the text, using μ = 1.68 D, Δ = 0.056 cm−1 , mr = 8.5 amu, and E = 104 V/cm, yielding R0 ∼ 70a0 . The left-hand column presents results for two molecules of type | a, as labeled in Figure 2.1; in the right column are results for one molecule of type | a and one of type | b, which necessitates specifying an exchange symmetry s.
characteristic radius R0 (Figure 2.2b), the effect of mixing in the higher-energy channels becomes apparent. Finally, when R < R0 (Figure 2.2c), the mixing is even more significant. In this case the dipole–dipole interaction is the dominant energy, with the threshold energies serving as a small perturbation. As a consequence, the quan tum numbers 21 +, 21 +; s = 1 can no longer identify the channel. It is beyond the scope of this chapter to discuss the corresponding eigenstates in detail. Nevertheless, we find that for R < R0 the channel | aa (repulsive at θ = π/2) is strongly mixed with the channel | ac (attractive at θ = π/2). The combination is just sufficient that the two channels nearly cancel out one another’s θ-dependence. At the ends of the range, however, the adiabatic curve is contaminated by a small amount of channels containing centrifugal energy ∝ 1/ sin2 θ. The right column of Figure 2.2 shows adiabatic curves for the mixed channels, one molecule of type | a and one of type | b. In this case there are two possible signs of s; © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
65
Electric Dipoles at Ultralow Temperatures
these are distinguished by using solid lines for channel 21 +, − 21 −; s = 1 and dashed lines for channel 21 +, − 21 −; s = −1 . Strikingly, these surfaces are different both from one another, and from the surfaces in the left column of the figure. Ultimately this arises from different kinds of channel couplings in the potentials (Equation 2.29). Note that, while type | a and type | b molecules are identical in their interaction energy with the electric field, they still represent different angular momentum states. Nevertheless, molecules in these channels still closely reflect the pure dipolar potential at large R, and become nearly θ-independent for small R. A further important point is that the potentials described here represent large energies as compared to the mK or μK translational kinetic energies of cold molecules, and will therefore significantly influence their dynamics. Further, the potentials depend strongly on the value of the electric field of the environment, both through the direct effect of polarization on the magnitude of the dipole moments, and through the influence of the field on the characteristic radius R0 . It is this sensitivity to field that opens the possibility of control over interactions in an ultracold dipolar gas (see Chapter 12). Although we have limited the discussion here to the lowest adiabatic state, interesting phenomena are also expected to arise due to avoided crossings in excited states. Notable is a collection of long-range quasibound states, whose intermolecular spacing is roughly centered around R0 [7]. Such states could conceivably be used to associate pairs of molecules into well-characterized transient states, furthering the possibilities of control of molecular interactions.
2.5.4 ADIABATIC POTENTIAL ENERGY CURVES IN ONE DIMENSION: PARTIAL WAVES For many scattering applications, it is not necessarily convenient to express the dipole– dipole interaction as a surface (more properly, a set of surfaces) in the variables (R, θ, φ) describing the relative position and orientation of the molecules. Rather, it is useful to expand the relative angular coordinates (θ, φ) in a basis as well. To do this, the basis set 2.28 is augmented by spherical harmonics describing the relative orientation of the molecules, to become ¯ 1 α2 β2 γ2 | jm2 ω ¯ 2 θφ | lml , α1 β1 γ1 | jm1 ω with
θφ | lml = Ylml (θφ) =
2l + 1 Clml (θφ). 4π
The total wavefunction is therefore described by the superposition ΨMtot (R, θ, φ) =
1
F Y (θφ) | i , R i ,l ,ml l ml i ,l ,ml
which represents a conventional expansion into partial waves. The wavefunction is, as above, restricted by conservation of angular momentum to require Mtot = m1 + © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
66
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
m1 + ml to have a constant value. Moreover, the effect of the symmetry operation 2.31 on | lml is to introduce a phase factor (−1)l . Therefore, the wavefunction is restricted to s(−1)l = 1 for bosons, and s(−1)l = −1 for fermions. The effect of this extra basis function is to replace the C2−q factor in Equation 2.29 by its matrix element C2−q → lml | C2−q | l ml =
l (2l + 1)(2l + 1)(−1)ml 0
2 0
l 0
l −ml
2 −q
l . ml
(2.34)
From this expression it is seen that the angular momentum q, lost to the internal degrees of freedom of the molecules, appears as the change in their relative orbital angular momentum, that is, ml = ml + q. From here, the effects of field dressing are exactly as treated above. The quantum number l, as is usual in quantum mechanics when treated in spherical coordinates, represents the orbital angular momentum of the pair of molecules about their center of mass. Following the usual treatment, this leads to a set of coupled radial Schrödinger Equations for the relative motion of the molecules: −
2 d2 Filml 2 l(l + 1) + Filml + i | Vd1D | i Fi l m + i | HS | iFilml = EFilml . 2 2 l 2mr dR 2mr R i l ml
(2.35) The second term in this expression represents a centrifugal potential ∝1/R2 , which is present for all partial waves l > 0.
2.5.5 ASYMPTOTIC FORM OF THE INTERACTION Casting the Schrödinger equation as an expansion in partial waves, and the interaction as a set of curves in R, rather than as a surface in (R, θ, φ), allows us to explore more readily the long-range behavior of the dipole–dipole interaction. The first 3-j symbol in Equation 2.34 vanishes unless l + 2 + l is an odd number, meaning that even (odd) partial waves are coupled only to even (odd) partial waves. Moreover, the values of l and l can differ by at most two. Thus the dipolar interaction can change the orbital angular momentum state from l = 2 to l = 4, for instance, but not to l = 6. Finally, the interaction vanishes altogether for l = l = 0, meaning that the dipole–dipole interaction nominally vanishes in the s-wave channel. Because all other channels have higher energy, due to their centrifugal potentials, it appears that the lowest adiabatic curve is trivially equal to zero. This is not the case, however, because the s-wave channel is coupled to a nearby d-wave channel with l = 2. Ignoring higher partial waves, the Hamiltonian corresponding to a particular channel i at long range has the form
0 A20 /R3
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
A02 /R3 . 32 /mr R2 + A22 /R3
Electric Dipoles at Ultralow Temperatures
67
Here A02 = A20 and A22 are coupling coefficients that follow from the expressions derived above. Note that all these coefficients are functions of the electric field E. Now, the comparison of dipolar and centrifugal energies defines another typical length scale for the interaction, namely, the one where μ2 /R3 = 2 /mr R2 , defining a “dipole radius” RD = μ2 mr /2 . (More properly, one could define an electric-field-dependent radius by substituting A02 for μ2 .) For OH, this length is ∼6800a0 , while for NiH it is ∼9000a0 . When the molecules are far apart, R > RD , the dipolar interaction is a perturbation. The size of this perturbation on the s-wave interaction is found through second-order perturbation theory to be A202 mr 1 (A02 /R3 )2 − 2 ∼− . 3 /mr R2 32 R4 Therefore, at very large intermolecular distances, the effective potential, as described by the lowest adiabatic curve, carries an attractive 1/R4 dependence on R, rather than the nominal 1/R3 dependence. At closer range, when R < RD , the 1/R3 terms dominate the 1/R2 centrifugal interaction, and the potential reduces again to the expected 1/R3 dependence on R.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Many fruitful discussions of molecular dipoles over the years are acknowledged, notably those with Aleksandr Avdeenkov, Doerte Blume, Daniele Bortolotti, Jeremy Hutson, and Chris Ticknor. This work was supported by the National Science Foundation.
REFERENCES 1. Brink, D.M. and Satchler, G.R., Angular Momentum, 3rd ed., Oxford University Press, 1993. 2. Brown, J. and Carrington, A., Rotational Spectroscopy of Diatomic Molecules, Cambridge University Press, 2003. 3. Jackson, J.D., Classical Electrodynamics, 2nd ed., Wiley, New York, 1975. 4. Bethe, H.A. and Salpeter, E.E., Quantum Mechanics of One- and Two-Electron Atoms, Plenum Press, 1977. 5. Hougen, J.T., The Calculation of Rotational Energy Levels and Rotational Line Intensities in Diatomic Molecules, NBS Monograph 115, available at http://physics.nist.gov/Pubs/Mono115/ 6. Allen, L. and Eberly, J.H., Optical Resonance and Two-Level Atoms, Wiley, New York, 1975. 7. Avdeenkov, A.V., Bortolotti, D.C.E., and Bohn, J.L., Field-linked states of ultracold polar molecules, Phys. Rev. A, 69, 012710, 2004.
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
Inelastic Collisions and 3 Chemical Reactions of Molecules at Ultracold Temperatures Goulven Quéméner, Naduvalath Balakrishnan, and Alexander Dalgarno CONTENTS 3.1 3.2
Introduction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Inelastic Atom–Molecule Collisions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2.1 Vibrational and Rotational Relaxation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2.1.1 Collisions at Cold and Ultracold Temperatures . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2.1.2 Shape Resonances in Molecular Collisions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2.1.3 Feshbach Resonances in Molecular Collisions . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2.2 Quasiresonant Transitions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2.3 Atom–Molecular Ion Collisions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3 Chemical Reactions at Ultracold Temperatures. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3.1 Tunneling-Dominated Reactions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3.1.1 Reactions at Zero Temperature . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3.1.2 Feshbach Resonances in Reactive Scattering . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3.2 Barrierless Reactions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3.2.1 Collision Systems of Three Alkali Metal Atoms . . . . . . . . . . 3.3.2.2 Role of PES in Determining Ultracold Reactions . . . . . . . . 3.3.2.3 Relaxation of Vibrationally Excited Alkali Metal Dimers 3.3.2.4 Reactions of Heteronuclear and Isotopically Substituted Alkali-Metal Dimer Systems. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4 Inelastic Molecule–Molecule Collisions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4.1 Molecules in the Ground Vibrational State . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4.2 Vibrationally Inelastic Transitions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.5 Summary and Outlook . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
70 71 71 71 79 80 82 83 84 86 87 92 95 95 101 104 106 108 108 112 115 116 117
69 © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
70
3.1
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
INTRODUCTION
The development of techniques for cooling and trapping of a wide variety of atomic and molecular species in recent years has created exciting opportunities for probing and controlling atomic and molecular encounters with unprecedented precision [1]. While many of the initial studies of cold atoms and molecules were centered on the creation of dense samples of cold and ultracold matter, more recent work has focused on the manipulation and control of intermolecular interactions, with the ultimate aim of achieving quantum control of atomic and molecular collisions [2]. Although the ideas of quantum control of chemical reactions were proposed many years ago, the ability to create ultracold molecules in specific quantum states has given further stimulus to this field. Its development requires that molecular properties and collisional behavior be well understood at cold and ultracold temperatures where the dynamics of molecules are dramatically different compared to collisions at elevated temperatures. Over the last ten years significant progress has been achieved both in theoretical and experimental works. The experimental methods such as photoassociation spectroscopy, magnetic tuning of Feshbach resonances, buffer-gas cooling, and Stark deceleration [3–6] have been developed and applied to a variety of molecular systems. Novel methods to study ultracold chemical reactions involving ion–molecule systems in a linear Paul trap have been proposed [7]. External control of chemical reactions using electric and magnetic fields is another area of active interest [8]. The aim of this chapter is to provide an overview of recent progress in characterizing molecular processes and chemical reactions at cold and ultracold temperatures, with particular emphasis on theoretical developments in quantum-dynamics simulations of atom–molecule collision systems over the last ten years. In contrast to scattering at thermal energies, ultracold collisions offer fascinating and unique opportunities to study molecular encounters in the extreme quantum regime where the entire collision can be dominated by a single partial wave. One of the main motivations of current experimental efforts to create dense samples of ultracold molecules is to study the possibility of chemical reactions at temperatures close to absolute zero. While Wigner’s law [9,10] predicts that rate coefficients of exothermic processes are finite in the zero-energy limit, it does not say if the rate coefficient will be large enough for reactions to be observable in an experiment. Nor does it say anything about how the rate coefficients at zero temperature depend on the interaction potential. Most chemical reactions between neutral atoms and molecules involve an energy barrier and it is not clear if chemical reactions between them generally occur with measurable rates at ultracold temperatures. Calculations for the F + H2 reaction, which proceeds by tunneling at low energies, have shown that the reaction may occur with a significant rate at ultracold temperatures [11]. There is also experimental and theoretical evidence that chemical reactions involving heavy-atom tunneling of carbon [12] and fluorine [13] atoms can occur with significant rate coefficients at low temperatures. Photoassociation experiments involving alkali-metal systems have stimulated considerable interest in chemical reactivity in alkali-metal dimer–alkali-metal atom collisions at ultracold temperatures [14]. Rearrangement collisions in identical particle alkali-metal trimer systems occur without energy barrier, and recent studies have
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
Inelastic Collisions and Chemical Reactions of Molecules
71
indicated that chemical reactions in alkali-metal atom–alkali-metal dimer collisions may be very fast at ultracold temperatures. Unlike tunneling-dominated reactions, the limiting values of the rate coefficients for alkali-metal systems are less sensitive to vibrational excitation of the dimer. In this chapter, we give an overview of recent studies of ultracold atom–molecule collisions, focusing on nonreactive and reactive systems and the effect of vibrational excitation of the molecule on the collisional outcome. We will discuss both tunneling-dominated and barrierless reactions and examine recent efforts in extending these studies to ionic systems as well as molecule–molecule systems. We consider mostly the novel aspects of collisional dynamics of atom–diatom systems at cold and ultracold temperatures with illustrative results for specific systems. For more comprehensive discussion of cold and ultracold collisions including reactive and nonreactive processes and the effect of external fields we refer the reader to several review articles [6,8,13–15] that have appeared in the last few years. For details of the theoretical formalisms we refer to the chapters by Hutson and by Tscherbul and Krems.
3.2
INELASTIC ATOM–MOLECULE COLLISIONS
Theoretical studies of ultracold molecules received intense interest after the success of ultracold atom photoassociation and buffer-gas-cooling experiments, which demonstrated that a wide array of molecular systems with thermal and nonthermal vibrational energy distributions can be created in ultracold traps. The collisional loss of trapped molecules is an important issue in these experiments. Photoassociation produces molecules in highly excited vibrational levels. Whether the excited molecules decay by vibrational quenching or through chemical reaction is an intriguing question. Although an extensive literature exists on the collisional relaxation of vibrationally excited molecules at elevated temperatures not much was known about the magnitude of the relaxation rate coefficients at temperatures lower than 1 K. A few earlier reports [16–18] on atom–diatom collisions in the Wigner threshold regime had been published, but a detailed investigation of the dependence of the relaxation rate coefficients on the internal energy of molecules and their sensitivity to details of the interaction potential has not been carried out. Here, we give a brief account of recent quantum-dynamics calculations of vibrational and rotational energy transfer in atom–diatom collisions at cold and ultracold temperatures. We focus on a few representative systems to illustrate the main features of energy transfer in nonreactive atom–molecule collisions at ultracold temperatures, and we show how the corresponding rate coefficients are influenced by rotational or vibrational excitation of the molecule.
3.2.1 VIBRATIONAL AND ROTATIONAL RELAXATION 3.2.1.1
Collisions at Cold and Ultracold Temperatures
As discussed in the chapter by Hutson, at very low energies, scattering is dominated by s-waves, and the scattering cross-section can be expressed in terms of a single parameter called the scattering length. For single-channel scattering where only elastic © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
72
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
scattering is possible, the scattering length is a real quantity and the magnitude of the cross-section in the s-wave limit is given by σ = 4πa2 , where a is the scattering length. For multichannel scattering, as in vibrationally or rotationally inelastic collisions of molecules, the scattering length is a complex number and is denoted as avj = αvj − iβvj where v and j are, respectively, the initial vibrational and rotational quantum numbers of the molecule [10,19]. The limiting value of the elastic cross-section in el = 4π|a |2 = 4π(α2 + β2 ). The the presence of inelastic scattering is given by σvj vj vj vj total inelastic quenching cross-section from a given initial rovibrational level of the molecule is related to the imaginary part of the scattering length through the relation in = 4πβ /k where k is the wavevector in the incident channel. The quenching σvj vj vj vj in = rate coefficient becomes constant at ultralow temperatures and is given by kvj 4πβvj /μ at zero temperature, where μ is the reduced mass of the collisional system. Thus, the rovibrational relaxation rate coefficients attain finite values for different initial vibrational and rotational levels of the molecule. The dependence of the rate coefficients on v and j has been an important issue in cold molecule research because exothermic vibrational and rotational relaxation collisions are a major pathway for trap loss in cooling and trapping experiments. Initial studies of rotational and vibrational relaxation of atom–molecule systems at cold and ultracold temperatures have mostly focused on van der Waals systems such as He–H2 [19–22], He–CO [23,24], and He–O2 [25]. Owing to the importance of some of these systems in astrophysical environments, extensive calculations of low-temperature behavior of rate coefficients have been performed for collisions of H2 [19] and CO [23,24] with both 3 He and 4 He. For both systems reasonably accurate intermolecular potentials have been reported. The initial calculations on the He–H2 system employed the potential energy surface (PES) of Muchnick and Russek (MR) [26]. For He–H2 , vibrational excitation of the H2 molecule has a dramatic effect on the zero-temperature quenching rate coefficients. As illustrated in Figure 3.1, the vibrational quenching rate coefficients increase by about three orders of magnitude between v = 1 and v = 10 of the H2 molecule [19]. The quenching rate coefficients exhibit a minimum at around 10 K, which roughly corresponds to the depth of the van der Waals interaction potential. This behavior appears to be a characteristic of vibrational quenching rate coefficients. For incident energies lower than the well depth the rate coefficient exhibits a minimum and with subsequent decrease in temperature the rate coefficient begins to increase before attaining the Wigner limit. For systems with deeper van der Waals wells the minimum is shifted to higher temperatures. Measurements of vibrational relaxation rate coefficients for the H2 −CO system have confirmed this behavior [27]. Balakrishnan, Forrey, and Dalgarno [28] investigated vibrational relaxation of H2 in collisions with H atoms for vibrational quantum numbers v = 1 to 12 of the H2 molecule. They adopted a nonreactive scattering formalism and neglected the rotational motion of the H2 molecule. The calculations showed that vibrational relaxation rate coefficients are strongly dependent on the initial vibrational level of the H2 molecule. The relaxation rate coefficients were found to increase by about seven orders of magnitude between vibrational levels v = 1 and v = 12. The dramatic variation in the rate coefficients with increase in vibrational excitation was explained in terms of the matrix elements of the interaction potential between © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
73
Inelastic Collisions and Chemical Reactions of Molecules
Rate coefficient (cm3/molecule/sec)
10−12
10−14
10−16
u = 10 u=9 u=8 u=7 u=6 u=5 u=4 u=3 u=2 u=1
10−18
10−20 −6 10
10−4
10−2 100 Temperature (K)
102
104
FIGURE 3.1 Rate coefficients for the quenching of H2 (v, j = 0) by collisions with He atoms as functions of the temperature for v = 1 to 10 of the H2 molecule. (From Balakrishnan, N. et al., Phys. Rev. Lett., 80, 3224, 1998. With permission.)
the vibrational wavefunctions as functions of the atom–molecule center-of-mass separation. Vibrational relaxation rate coefficients in atom–molecule systems are often influenced by van der Waals complexes formed during the collision process. Decay of these complexes leads to resonances in the energy dependence of the relaxation crosssections (see Figure 3.2 for Ar–D2 collisions). Applying effective range theory to describe ultracold collisions of the He–H2 system, Balakrishnan and colleagues [19] and Forrey and colleagues [20] demonstrated that vibrational predissociation lifetimes of resonances that lie close to the energy threshold can be derived accurately from the value of the zero-temperature quenching rate coefficient. This formalism was extended to describe vibrational relaxation of trapped molecules and it was shown that the vibrational relaxation rate is controlled by the most weakly bound state of the van der Waals complex [22]. In a related work Dashevskaya and colleagues [29] have shown that vibrational quenching of H2 (v = 1, j = 0) at low temperatures can be described using a two-channel approximation within the quasiclassical method provided appropriate parameters are employed in the calculations. Subsequently, Côté and colleagues [30] generalized this method to predict vibrational relaxation lifetimes of atom–diatom van der Waals complexes with energies near the dissociation threshold. © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
74
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications 10–4
j¢ = 2 j¢ = 4 j¢ = 6 j¢ = 8
Cross-section (10–16 cm2)
10–6
10–8
10–10
10–12 –8 10
10–6
10–4
10–2
Kinetic energy
100
102
104
(cm–1)
FIGURE 3.2 Cross-sections for quenching of the v = 1, j = 0 level of D2 in collisions with Ar atoms resolved into the different rotational levels j in v = 0 as functions of the incident kinetic energy. (From Uudus, N. et al., J. Chem. Phys., 122, 024304, 2005. With permission.)
Unlike in thermal energy collisions, the presence of a weakly bound state in the vicinity of a channel threshold can dramatically influence the cross-sections in the ultracold regime. This is illustrated in Figure 3.2 where the cross-sections for vibrational relaxation of D2 (v = 1, j = 0) in collisions with Ar atoms [31] are presented over an energy range of 10−8 to 103 cm−1 . The cross-sections exhibit a curvature characteristic of a resonant enhancement in the energy range 10−5 to 10−3 cm−1 . Such enhancement of the cross-section can occur when the interaction potential supports a virtual state or a very weakly bound state near the channel threshold leading to a zero-energy resonance. The virtual state is characterized by a large negative scattering length while the bound state is characterized by a large positive scattering length. For the present case the real part of the scattering length is large and positive (α10 = 97.0 Å) and the resonance occurs from the decay of a loosely bound van der Waals complex supported by the entrance channel potential. For energies below 10−2 cm−1 the cross-section is dominated by s-wave scattering in the incident channel, and the zero-energy resonance arises from s-wave scattering in the entrance channel. The resonant enhancement is more clearly seen in the plot of the reaction probability as a function of the kinetic energy, shown in Figure 3.3. The probability peaks at an energy of 6.0 × 10−4 cm−1 , which roughly corresponds to the binding © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
75
Inelastic Collisions and Chemical Reactions of Molecules 1e–11
8e–12
Probability
6e–12
4e–12
2e–12
0e+00 10–6
10–5
10–3
10–4
Incident kinetic energy
10–2
(cm–1)
FIGURE 3.3 Total probability of quenching of the v = 1, j = 0 level of D2 in collisions with Ar atoms as a function of the incident kinetic energy. The peak value of the probability corresponds to a zero energy resonance. (From Uudus, N. et al., J. Chem. Phys., 122, 024304, 2005. With permission.)
energy of the quasibound state. The resonance appears in the scattering calculations at energies above the threshold due to its close proximity to the channel threshold. The binding energy of the quasibound state can be estimated using the scattering length approximation [10,31]. The magnitude of the binding energy is given by |Eb | = 2 cos 2γ10 /(2μ|a10 |2 ) where μ is the reduced mass of the Ar–D2 system, a10 = α10 − iβ10 is the scattering length for the v = 1, j = 0 level, and γ10 = tan−1 (β10 /α10 ). This yields a value of |Eb | = 4.9 × 10−4 cm−1 , in reasonable agreement with the exact value derived from scattering calculations. A more accurate value of the binding energy can be obtained using the effective range formula given by Forrey and colleagues [20]: α10 r0 2 2α10 r0 |Eb | = 1− − 1− |a10 |2 |a10 |2 μr02 where r0 is the effective range of the potential, which may be evaluated by fitting the low-energy behavior of the phase shift for the elastic channel to the standard 2 /2. For Ar–D (v = 1, j = 0) effective range formula, k10 cot δ10 = −1/α10 + r0 k10 2 collisions, the effective range formula yields r0 = 16.32 Å. The resonance position © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
76
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
calculated using the effective range approximation is |Eb | = 5.95 × 10−4 cm−1 , in excellent agreement with the value of 6.0 × 10−4 cm−1 obtained from the scattering calculations. It is generally very difficult to accurately evaluate energies of such weakly bound states using standard bound state codes and the effective range formula provides a convenient and reliable method to calculate binding energies of weakly bound states that lead to zero-energy resonances. One of the challenging aspects of cold and ultracold collisions is the sensitivity to details of the interaction potential. Even the best available methods for the electronic structure calculations of PESs result in errors much larger than the collision energies in the cold and ultracold regime, and the dynamics calculations are often sensitive to small changes in the interaction potential. To explore the sensitivity of cold and ultracold collisions to details of the interaction potential, Lee and colleagues [32] performed a comparative study of the ultracold collision dynamics of the He–H2 system using the MR potential and a more recent ab initio potential developed by Boothroyd, Martin, and Peterson (BMP) [33]. The BMP potential was considered to be an improvement, approaching chemical accuracy, over all conformations compared to the MR potential. However, significant differences were observed for vibrational relaxation of the v = 1, j = 0 state of the H2 molecule in collisions with He computed using the two surfaces. The limiting value of the quenching rate coefficient on the BMP surface was found to be about three orders of magnitude larger than that of the MR surface. The difference was attributed to the more anisotropic nature of the BMP surface leading to larger values of the off-diagonal elements responsible for driving vibrational transitions. Indeed, it was found that the vibrational quenching of the v = 1, j = 0 level was dominated by the transition to the v = 0, j = 8 level, which is driven by the high-order anisotropic terms of the interaction potential. To explore the behavior of inelastic collisions involving polar molecules at ultracold temperatures, Balakrishnan, Forrey and Dalgarno [23] investigated vibrational and rotational relaxation of CO in 4 He–CO collisions. The dynamics of the He–CO system was found to exhibit significantly different features at low temperatures compared to the He–H2 system. Quantum scattering calculations of 4 He and 3 He collisions with the CO molecule revealed that the larger reduced mass and the deeper van der Waals interaction potential of the He–CO system give rise to a number of shape resonances in the energy dependence of vibrational relaxation cross-sections [23,24]. The effect of shape resonances on low-temperature vibrational relaxation rate coefficients will be discussed in the next subsection. The computed values of vibrational relaxation rate coefficients for both 3 He and 4 He collisions with CO(v = 1) have been found to be in good agreement with the experimental data of Reid and colleagues [34] in the temperature range 35 to 100 K. Calculations of vibrational relaxation rate coefficients for the He–CO system in the temperature range 35 to 1500 K have also been reported by Krems [35]. He has shown that inclusion of the centrifugal distortion of the vibrational wavefunction enhances the relaxation process, and that the quenching rate coefficients are sensitive to high-order anisotropic terms in the angular expansion of the interaction potential [36]. Bodo, Gianturco, and Dalgarno [37] have extended the work of Balakrishnan and colleagues [23] to study the vibrational relaxation of excited CO(v = 2, j = 0, 1) molecules in collision with 4 He atoms at ultralow energies. They found that © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
Inelastic Collisions and Chemical Reactions of Molecules
77
vibrational quenching of CO(v = 2, j = 0, 1) in collisions with 4 He is dominated by the v = 2 → v = 1 transition. The cross-sections for the v = 2 → v = 0 transition were found to be about four orders of magnitude smaller than the single quantum transitions for both j = 0 and j = 1 initial rotational levels. Ultracold vibrational relaxation of a number of other molecules in collisions with He atoms has been reported by a number of other investigators in recent years. Stoecklin, Voronin, and Rayez [38] reported the vibrational relaxation of F2 in collisions with 3 He atoms. In this study, they constructed the PES of He–F2 using ab initio points obtained by high-level molecular electronic-structure calculations, and reported the cross-sections for elastic scattering and inelastic relaxation of F2 (v = 0, 1, j = 0) for collision energies in the range 10−6 to 2000 cm−1 . A similar study has been reported by the same authors for the 3 He + HF(v = 0, 1, j = 0, 1) system [39]. The vibrational quenching cross-sections were found to be very small compared to pure rotational quenching, in agreement with the results for the He–CO system. This is due to the weak dependence of the He–HF PES on the HF internuclear distance and the strong anisotropy of the interaction potential. Bodo and Gianturco [40] presented a comparative study of vibrational relaxation of CO(v = 1, 2, j = 0), HF(v = 1, 2, j = 0), and LiH(v = 1, 2, j = 0) in collisions with 3 He and 4 He atoms in the Wigner regime. The quenching rate coefficients were found to depend strongly on the collision partner. They reported rate coefficients in the range 10−21 to 10−19 cm3 /sec for CO, 10−16 to 10−15 cm3 /sec for HF, and 10−14 to 10−11 cm3 /sec for LiH. The differences were attributed to the features of the intermolecular forces between the diatomic molecules and the He atoms. The interaction potential of the He–CO system is almost isotropic and is characterized by small vibrational couplings elements. The He–HF system is more anisotropic and the couplings between vibrational states are more significant. The interaction potential of the He–LiH system is very anisotropic and it exhibits strong vibrational couplings. There is considerable ongoing experimental interest in cooling and trapping NH [41,42] and OH [43,44] molecules using the buffer gas cooling and Stark deceleration methods described in the chapters by Doyle and by Meijer. Krems and colleagues [45] and Cybulski and colleagues [46] reported cross-sections and rate coefficients for elastic scattering and Zeeman relaxation in 3 He–NH collisions from ultralow energies to 10 cm−1 . The calculations were performed using the rigid rotor approximation and an accurate He–NH PES. It was demonstrated that the elastic scattering of NH molecules with He atoms in weak magnetic fields is at least five orders of magnitude faster than the Zeeman relaxation, which suggests that the NH molecule is a good candidate for buffer-gas cooling. In a related study González–Sánchez and colleagues [47] examined rotational relaxation and spin-flipping in collisions of OH with He atoms at ultralow energies. They found that the rotational relaxation processes dominate the elastic process as the collision energy is decreased to zero. While theoretical prediction of rate coefficients for vibrational and rotational relaxation in a number of atom–diatom systems has been made, comparable experimental results are not available for the majority of these systems. The first measurements of vibrational relaxation of molecules at temperatures below 1 K were reported by Weinstein and colleagues [48]. In their study, CaH molecules slowed down by elastic collisions with 3 He buffer gas atoms were trapped in an inhomogeneous magnetic © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
78
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
field. An upper bound of the rate coefficients for spin-flipping transitions in CaH as well as vibrational relaxation of CaH molecules in the v = 1 vibrational level in collisions with 3 He atoms were estimated at a temperature of about 500 mK. Balakrishnan and colleagues [49] presented a theoretical analysis of the vibrational relaxation of CaH in collisions with 3 He atoms based on quantum close-coupling calculations and an ab initio PES for the He−CaH system developed by Groenenboom and Balakrishnan [50]. In a related study, Krems and colleagues [51] reported cross-sections for spin-flipping transitions in CaH induced by collisions with 3 He and obtained results in close agreement with the experimentally derived values of Weinstein and colleagues [48]. Krems and colleagues demonstrated that at low energies, spin-flipping transitions in the N = 0 rotational level of 2 Σ molecules induced by structureless atoms occur through coupling to the rotationally excited N > 0 levels and that the corresponding rate coefficients are determined by the spin–rotation interaction with the transiently rotationally excited molecule. Table 3.1 provides a compilation of zero-temperature quenching rate coefficients for vibrational and rotational relaxation in a number of atom–diatom systems.
TABLE 3.1 Zero-Temperature Inelastic Rate Coefficients for Different Atom–Molecule Systems System
Initial (v, j )
kT =0 (cm3 /sec)
Reference
H + H2
(v = 1, j = 0)
1.0 × 10−17
[28]
(v = 1, j = 0) (v = 10, j = 0)
3 × 10−17 3.6 × 10−14
[19] [19]
4 He + CO
(v = 1, j = 0) (v = 1, j = 1)
6.5 × 10−21 9.0 × 10−19
[23] [23]
3 He + CO
(v = 1, j = 0) (v = 2, j = 0) (v = 1, j = 0) (v = 2, j = 0)
1.3 × 10−19 2.1 × 10−19 5.3 × 10−21 1.3 × 10−20
[40] [40] [40] [40]
3 He + CaH
(v = 0, j = 1) (v = 1, j = 0)
3.5 × 10−12 2.6 × 10−17
[49] [49]
3 He + HF
(v = 1, j = 0) (v = 2, j = 0) (v = 1, j = 0) (v = 2, j = 0)
3.1 × 10−16 2.6 × 10−15 8.1 × 10−16 6.5 × 10−15
[40] [40] [40] [40]
(v = 1, j = 0) (v = 2, j = 0) (v = 1, j = 0) (v = 2, j = 0)
9.0 × 10−14 3.6 × 10−12 3.8 × 10−13 1.5 × 10−11
[40] [40] [40] [40]
3 He + H
2
4 He + CO
4 He + HF
3 He + LiH 4 He + LiH
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
79
Inelastic Collisions and Chemical Reactions of Molecules
3.2.1.2
Shape Resonances in Molecular Collisions
At energies above the onset of the s-wave regime, cross-sections will be dominated by contributions from nonzero angular momentum partial waves. If the interaction potential includes an attractive part, the effective potentials for nonzero angular momentum partial waves may possess centrifugal barriers that introduce shape resonances in the collision energy dependence of the cross-section. This is illustrated in Figure 3.4 for the vibrational relaxation of CO(v = 1, j = 0) in collisions with 4 He atoms. The sharp features in the energy dependence of the cross-section for energies between 0.1 and 10.0 cm−1 arise from shape resonances supported by the van der Waals interaction potential between He and the CO molecule. As shown in Figure 3.5, when integrated over the velocity distribution of the colliding species, the shape resonances lead to significant enhancement of the vibrational relaxation rate coefficient for temperatures between 0.1 and 10.0 K. Similar results have been found for vibrational relaxation of CO [24], O2 [25], and CaH [49] in collisions with 3 He atoms. The sharp features in the energy dependence of the vibrational relaxation cross-sections for the Ar + D2 sytem shown in Figure 3.2 also arises from shape resonances supported by the Ar–D2 van der Waals potential. The effect is generally more pronounced for systems composed of heavier diatomic molecules and
10−5
Cross-section (10−16 cm2)
10−6
10−7
10−8
10−9 10−5
10−3
10−1 Energy (cm−1)
101
103
FIGURE 3.4 Cross-section for the quenching of the v = 1, j = 0 level of CO in collisions with 4 He as a function of the incident kinetic energy. (From Balakrishnan, N. et al., J. Chem. Phys., 113, 621, 2000. With permission.)
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
80
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications 10−18
Rate coefficient (cm3/sec)
u = 1, j = 1
10−19
10−20 u = 1, j = 0
10−21 10−5
10−3
10−1
101
103
T (K)
FIGURE 3.5 Rate coefficients for the quenching of CO(v = 1, j = 0, 1) by collisions with 4 He as functions of the temperature. (From Balakrishnan, N. et al., J. Chem. Phys., 113, 621, 2000. With permission.)
interaction potentials with deep van der Waals wells for which the density of states will be much higher, leading to rich resonance structures in the cross-sections. 3.2.1.3
Feshbach Resonances in Molecular Collisions
Feshbach resonances occur in multichannel scattering in which an unbound (continuum) channel is coupled to a bound state of another channel. If the energy of the interacting system in the unbound channel lies close to that of the bound state and the coupling between the two channels is strong, the cross-section may change dramatically in the vicinity of the resonance. In the Feshbach resonance method for producing ultracold molecules, an external magnetic field is used to tune the energy of the bound pair to that of the separated atoms. In atom–diatom systems, the bound state may correspond to a quasibound state of the atom–diatom van der Waals complex. Channel potentials corresponding to different initial vibrational and rotational levels of the diatom may induce Feshbach resonances. For the He–CO system Feshbach resonances were found to occur near channel thresholds corresponding to the j = 1 rotational level in the v = 0 and v = 1 vibrational levels. Figure 3.6 shows the Feshbach resonance in the elastic scattering cross-sections in the v = 1, j = 0 channel in the vicinity of the v = 1, j = 1 level. The presence of the Feshbach resonance close © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
81
Inelastic Collisions and Chemical Reactions of Molecules
Cross-section (10−16 cm2)
260
240
220
200 3.8080
3.8090
3.8100
3.8110
Energy (cm−1)
FIGURE 3.6 Feshbach resonance in the elastic scattering cross-section of CO(v = 1, j = 0) by 4 He atoms. The resonance occurs just below the opening of the v = 1, j = 1 level shown by the vertical line. The energy is relative to the v = 1, j = 0 level of the CO molecule. (From Balakrishnan, N. et al., J. Chem. Phys., 113, 621, 2000. With permission.)
to the opening of the j = 1 level has a dramatic effect on the vibrational quenching cross-sections from the v = 1, j = 1 level of the CO molecule. Since the Feshbach resonance occurs so close to the threshold of the v = 1, j = 1 channel, its effect on scattering in the v = 1, j = 1 level is similar to that of the zero-energy resonance discussed previously for the Ar + D2 system. This is illustrated in Figure 3.5 (see also Table 3.1) where we compare the rate coefficients for vibrational relaxation from the v = 1, j = 0 and v = 1, j = 1 levels of the CO molecule. The zero-temperature limiting value of the quenching rate coefficient of the v = 1, j = 1 level is about two orders of magnitude larger than for the v = 1, j = 0 level. Similar Feshbach resonances have also been shown to occur in the vibrational and rotational predissociation of He–H2 van der Waals complexes [20]. Forrey and colleagues [20] has successfully used the effective range theory to predict the predissociation lifetimes of these resonances. The Feshbach resonances can be used as a very sensitive probe for the interaction potential and also to selectively break or make bonds in chemical reactions. The coupling between the bound and unbound states can be modified by applying an external electric or magnetic field, and this provides an important mechanism for creating or eliminating Feshbach resonances and thereby controlling the collisional © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
82
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
outcome. Krems have shown that weakly bound van der Waals complexes can be dissociated by tuning a Feshbach resonance using an external magnetic field [52]. In this case the dissociation occurs through coupling between Zeeman levels of the bound and unbound channels and the magnitude of the coupling is varied by changing the external magnetic field.
3.2.2
QUASIRESONANT TRANSITIONS
Although the properties of cold and ultracold collisions are quite different from scattering at thermal energies and quantum effects dominate at low temperatures, a remarkable correlation between classical and quantum-dynamics has been discovered in the relaxation of rovibrationally excited diatomic molecules. Experiments performed nearly two decades ago [53,54] showed that collisions of rotationally excited diatomic molecules with atoms may result in very efficient internal energy transfer between specific rotational and vibrational degrees of freedom. The energy transfer becomes highly efficient when the collision time is longer than the rotational period of the molecule. This effect has since been termed “quasiresonant rotation–vibration energy transfer.” The experimental results revealed that the quasiresonant (QR) transitions satisfy the propensity rule Δj = −4Δv or Δj = −2Δv where Δv = vf − vi and Δj = jf − ji [53,54]. This inelastic channel dominates over all other rovibrational transitions. The QR transfer is generally insensitive to details of the interaction potential. Rather, the QR process involves conservation of the action I = nv v + nj j, where nv and nj are small integers. Forrey and colleagues [21] found that the QR transitions also occur in cold and ultracold collisions of rotationally excited diatomic molecules with atoms and that the process is largely insensitive to the details of the interaction potential even in the ultracold regime. The Δj = −2Δv QR transition in He + H2 collisions [55] is illustrated in Figure 3.7 where the zerotemperature vibrational and rotational transition rate coefficients for different initial vibrational levels of the H2 molecule are plotted as functions of the initial rotational level. For initial rotational levels greater than 12 the QR transition becomes the dominant energy transfer mechanism compared to pure rotational quenching. The gap at j = 22 occurs because the Δj = −2Δv transition is energetically not accessible for this initial state at zero temperature. Forrey and colleagues [21] found that the QR process is even more dominant at low temperatures than at thermal energies. Remarkably, classical trajectory calculations [21] were successful in correctly predicting the correlation between Δj and Δv at ultracold temperatures even though the changes in v and j were fractional. Extensive studies of QR energy transfer in cold and ultracold temperatures have been reported by Forrey and colleagues [56–59]. Ruiz and Heller [60] have recently published a review paper providing a detailed analysis of QR phenomenon using semiclassical techniques. McCaffery and colleagues [61–63] have also reported a number of quasiclassical trajectory calculations of the QR process in thermal energy collisions and successfully interpreted a large body of experimental data based on the QR phenomenon and simple parametric models. © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
83
Inelastic Collisions and Chemical Reactions of Molecules 10−10 Dv = 0, Dj = −2 10−12
Rate coefficient (cm3/sec)
Dv = +1, Dj = −2
10−14 u=0 u=1
10−16
u=2 u=3 u=4
10−18
10−20
Dv = −1, Dj = +2
0
4
8
12
16
20
24
28
j
FIGURE 3.7 Zero-temperature rate coefficients for 4 He + H2 (v, j) collisions as functions of the initial vibrational and rotational quantum numbers. (From Forrey, R.C. et al., Phys. Rev. A, 64, 022706, 2001. With permission.)
3.2.3 ATOM–MOLECULAR ION COLLISIONS Dynamics of ionic systems are different from collisions of neutral species. The shortrange part of the interaction potential for ionic systems is usually more anisotropic and the long-range part has an attractive component that is determined by the polarizability of the atom and it vanishes as 1/R4 where R is the atom–molecule center-of-mass distance [64]. Due to the strong polarizability term, the interaction potential for ionic systems extends to longer range compared to neutral atom–molecule systems. Therefore, it is important to understand the effect of both the short- and long-range part of the interaction potential on the scattering dynamics. For this purpose, several studies have focused on ultracold collisions between molecular ions and neutral atoms as well as neutral molecules and atomic ions. Bodo and colleagues [64] investigated rotational quenching in Ne+ 2 + Ne and + He2 + He collisions at ultralow energies. They found that the Wigner regime begins at a collision energy of 10−4 cm−1 for the He system and 10−6 cm−1 for the Ne system. In general, the s-wave Wigner regime was found to occur at lower energies for ionic systems compared to neutral species. For example, in He + H2 [19] and He + O2 [25] collisions the Wigner regime begins at collision energies of about 10−2 cm−1 . The differences are attributed to the long range of the ion–neutral interaction potential, © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
84
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
which enhances contributions from higher partial waves. The differences between the He and Ne systems can be attributed to the mass difference and to the strength of the long-range interaction potentials. For the heavier Ne system the long-range part is more attractive, which increases the contribution of higher-order partial waves at ultralow energies. The magnitude of the zero-energy rate coefficients for rotational quenching in these molecular ions is on the order of 10−9 cm3 /sec, which is considerably larger than for collisions involving neutral species. Stoecklin and colleagues [65] have performed a comparative study of collisions of 3 4 N+ 2 (v = 1, j = 0) molecular ions with neutral He or He atoms, and the scattering of neutral N2 (v = 1, j = 0) molecules in collisions with 3 He or 4 He atoms. The vibrational quenching cross-sections for these systems are presented in Figure 3.8. While the behavior of the quenching cross-sections of neutral N2 molecules with 3 He and 4 He atoms was found to be similar, they observed a striking difference 3 4 between the quenching cross-sections of N+ 2 in collisions with He and He atoms. In particular, the resonance positions in the quenching cross-sections were significantly 3 shifted and the number of resonances was different. The N+ 2 + He system has a −2 −1 shape resonance at a collision energy of 10 cm , which is absent for the N+ 2 + 4 He system. Furthermore, the zero-energy quenching rate coefficient is an order of 3 4 magnitude larger for collisions of N+ 2 (v = 1, j = 0) with He than with He, whereas 3 it is comparable for collisions of N2 (v = 1, j = 0) with both He and 4 He. The 3 differences may be due to a virtual state in the N+ 2 (v = 1, j = 0) + He collision system. More recently, Guillon and colleagues [66] studied the effect of spin-rotation interaction on vibrational and rotational quenching for the He–N+ 2 system. They found that the vibrational quenching is not modified by the spin–rotation coupling, while rotational transitions are sensitive to the fine-structure interactions. Table 3.2 provides a compilation of zero-temperature quenching rate coefficients for vibrational and rotational relaxation in several ion atom–molecule systems.
3.3
CHEMICAL REACTIONS AT ULTRACOLD TEMPERATURES
The last three decades have seen impressive progress in the experimental and theoretical descriptions of chemical reactions between atoms and small molecular systems. While fully state-resolved experiments have been performed for a large number of collision systems, accurate quantum dynamics calculations have been restricted to systems involving light atoms such as H + H2 , F + H2 , Cl + H2 , C + H2 , N + H2 , O + H2 and some of their isotopic analogs [67,68]. Most experimental studies of small molecular systems focused on reactions at thermal or elevated collision energies, although some recent measurements have been extended to temperatures as low as 10 K for some astrophysically relevant systems [69]. Due to the possibility of achieving coherent chemistry there has been substantial interest in understanding the behavior of chemical reactions at cold and ultracold temperatures. At these temperatures perturbations introduced by external electric and magnetic fields are significant compared to the collision energies involved and external fields can be employed to control and manipulate the reaction outcome. Over the last seven years a number of studies of ultracold atom–diatom chemical reactions have been reported both for © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
85
Inelastic Collisions and Chemical Reactions of Molecules
(a)
103 Isotope 3 Isotope 4
102
s (10–16 cm2 )
101
100
10–1
10–2
10–3
10–4 –8 10
10–6
10–4
10–2 E
(b)
100
102
(cm–1)
10–2
Isotope 3 Isotope 4
s (10–16 cm2)
10–3
10–4
10–5
10–6
10–7
10–6
10–4
10–2
100
102
–1
E (cm ) + 3 FIGURE 3.8 Vibrational quenching cross-sections for N+ 2 (v = 1, j = 0) + He and N2 (v = 1, j = 0) + 4 He (a) and N2 (v = 1, j = 0) + 3 He and N2 (v = 1, j = 0) + 4 He (b) systems. (From Stoecklin, T. and Voronin, A., Phys. Rev. A, 72, 042714, 2005. With permission.)
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
86
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
TABLE 3.2 Zero-Temperature Inelastic Rate Coefficients for Different Ion Atom–Molecule Systems Initial (v, j )
kT =0 (cm3 /sec)
Reference
Ne+ 2 + Ne
(v = 0, j = 2) (v = 0, j = 4) (v = 0, j = 6)
3.3 × 10−10 7.3 × 10−10 7.0 × 10−10
[64] [64] [64]
He+ 2 + He
(v = 0, j = 2) (v = 0, j = 4) (v = 0, j = 6)
6.7 × 10−10 8.4 × 10−10 1.2 × 10−9
(64] [64] [64]
3 N+ 2 + He
(v = 1, j = 0)
4 × 10−14
[65]
4 N+ 2 + He
(v = 1, j = 0)
3 × 10−15
[65]
System
reactions with and without an energy barrier. Chemical reactions at low temperatures often behave quite differently from reactions at elevated temperatures. In particular, the weak van der Waals interaction potential, which does not play any significant role at high temperatures, may have a dramatic effect on the outcome of reactions at low temperatures.
3.3.1 TUNNELING-DOMINATED REACTIONS In the course of the last 10 to 15 years there has been much interest in understanding the role of resonances in chemical reactions that involve an energy barrier for which the reactivity is primarily driven by tunneling at low temperatures. Recent studies on F + H2 /HD/D2 [11,70–80], Cl + HD [81,82], H + HCl/DCl [83], Li + HF/LiF + H [84,85], O + H2 [86,87], and F + HCl/DCl [88] reactions have demonstrated that decay of quasibound states of the van der Waals interaction potential in the entrance and exit channels may give rise to narrow Feshbach resonances in the cross-sections. The reactions of F with H2 and HD have been the subject of numerous quantum scattering calculations over the last two decades. The two reactions have emerged as benchmark systems for experimental and theoretical studies of resonances in chemical reactions. A detailed analysis of the low-energy resonance features in the F + H2 reaction was presented by Castillo and colleagues in 1996 [70]. They demonstrated that several resonances that appear in the energy dependence of the cumulative reaction probability for the F + H2 reaction arise due to the van der Waals interaction potential in the product HF + H channel. In particular, the origin of the resonances has been attributed to the van der Waals potential associated with the HF(v = 3, j = 0 − 3) channels. A large number of experimental and theoretical papers has appeared that examined various aspects of these resonance features [11,70–72,75–80]. Among these studies, the work of Takayanagi and Kurosaki [71] deserves special attention. They showed that for F + H2 , F + HD, and F + D2 reactions, reactive scattering © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
87
Inelastic Collisions and Chemical Reactions of Molecules
resonances occur due to the decay of quasibound states of the van der Waals potential in the entrance channel of the reaction. These Feshbach resonances are associated with the decay of quasibound states of adiabatic potentials corresponding to F· · · H2 (v = 0, j = 0, 1), F· · · HD(v = 0, j = 0 − 2), and F· · · D2 (v = 0, j = 0 − 2) complexes, obtained by diagonalizing the J = 0 Hamiltonian in a basis set of the asymptotic rovibrational states of the reactant molecules. 3.3.1.1
Reactions at Zero Temperature
Balakrishnan and Dalgarno [11] showed that quasibound states of the F + H2 van der Waals complex have a dramatic effect on the reactivity in the Wigner threshold regime. They found that the F + H2 (v = 0, j = 0) reaction has a rate coefficient of 1.25 × 10−12 cm3 /sec in the zero-temperature limit. Their calculation was based on the widely used PES of Stark and Werner [89] for the F + H2 system. The relatively large value of the zero-temperature rate coefficient is due to the presence of a small narrow energy barrier for the reaction so that tunneling of the H atom is efficient. The vibrational level resolved cross-sections for the F + H2 (v = 0, j = 0) reaction are shown in Figure 3.9 for the total angular momentum quantum number J = 0.
102
Cross-section (10−16 cm2)
100
u¢ = 2
10−2
u¢ = 1
u¢ = 0
10−4
10−6 10−7
10−6
10−5
10−4 10−3 Kinetic energy (eV)
10−2
10−1
FIGURE 3.9 J = 0 cross-sections for F + H2 (v = 0, j = 0) → HF(v ) + H reaction for v = 0 − 2 as functions of the incident kinetic energy. (From Balakrishnan, N. and Dalgarno,A., Chem. Phys. Lett., 341, 652, 2001. With permission.)
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
88
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
The v = 2 level is the dominant channel at low energies in agreement with the behavior at higher energies. Subsequent calculations showed that at low energies the F + HD reaction is dominated by the formation of the HF product with an HF/DF branching ratio of about 5.5 [74]. The formation of the DF product is suppressed because tunneling of the heavier D atom is less efficient. In earlier quantum calculations, Baer and colleagues [90, 91] reported HF/DF branching ratios ranging from 1.5 at 450 K to 6.0 at 100 K. Their low-temperature value is in close agreement with the zero-temperature limit obtained by Balakrishnan and Dalgarno [74]. Figure 3.10 compares the J = 0 cross-sections for the F + H2 (v = 0, j = 0) and F + HD(v = 0, j = 0) reactions over a kinetic energy range of 10−7 to 1.0 eV. In the Wigner threshold regime, the reactivity of the F + H2 system is an order of magnitude greater than that of the F + HD reaction. A rigorous analysis of the scattering resonances in the F + HD reaction was recently presented by De Fazio and colleagues [80], who provided a detailed characterization of the resonances supported by the entrance and exit channels of the van der Waals potential and discussed the effect of higher total angular momenta on the position and lifetime of the resonances. Stereodynamical aspects of the F + H2 collision and the effect of polarization of the H2 molecule on the outcome of the reaction at low energies were recently 102
Cross-section (10−16 cm2)
101
100
10−1
10−2
10−3
10−4 10−7
10−6
10−5
10−4 10−3 Kinetic energy (eV)
10−2
10−1
FIGURE 3.10 Comparison of J = 0 cross-sections for F + HD(v = 0, j = 0) → HF + D (solid curve), F + HD(v = 0, j = 0) → DF + H (short-dashed curve) and F + H2 (v = 0, j = 0) → HF + H (long-dashed curve) reactions as functions of the incident kinetic energy. (From Balakrishnan, N. and Dalgarno, A., J. Chem. Phys. A, 107, 7101, 2003. With permission.)
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
89
Inelastic Collisions and Chemical Reactions of Molecules
explored by Aldegunde and colleagues [77]. They argued that a reactant polarization scheme can be exploited to control state-to-state dynamics of the reaction. To explore the role of tunneling in chemical reactions at cold and ultracold temperatures Bodo, Gianturco, and Dalgarno [73] investigated the dynamics of the F + D2 system at low and ultralow energies. They found that compared to the F + H2 reaction, the reactivity of F + D2 is significantly suppressed in the Wigner regime with an HF/DF ratio of about 100. This is illustrated in Figure 3.11 where the J = 0 cumulative
Cumulative reaction probabilities
(a) 0.02
0.015
H2
0.01
D2 (×10)
0.005
0
0
0.0002
0.0004 0.0006 Collision energy (eV)
0.0008
0.001
10–3
10–2
(b) 103
Reaction cross-section (Å2)
102 101 100 10–1 10–2 10–3 10–4 –8 10
10–7
10–6 10–5 10–4 Collision energy (eV)
FIGURE 3.11 Comparison of the J = 0 cumulative reaction probabilities (a) and crosssections (b) of F + H2 and F + D2 reactions as functions of the incident kinetic energy. (From Bodo, E. et al., J. Phys. B: At. Mol. Opt. Phys., 37, 3641, 2004. With permission.)
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
90
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
reaction probability and cross-sections for the F + H2 and F + D2 reactions are plotted as functions of the incident kinetic energy from the Wigner limit to 0.01 eV. The dramatic suppression of the F + D2 reaction in the Wigner regime cannot be explained based on tunneling alone. A closer examination of the reaction probabilities for the F + H2 and F + D2 reaction revealed that an unusual enhancement of the reactivity occurs for the F + H2 reaction at about 3 × 10−5 eV [75] (see Figure 3.11a). This feature was attributed to the presence of a virtual state. The enhancement of the limiting value of the rate coefficient for the F + H2 reaction was also ascribed to the virtual state. Evidence for the virtual state is the presence of a Ramsauer–Townsend minimum in the elastic cross-section at an energy of about 3 × 10−5 eV and a negative value of the real part of the scattering length for the F + H2 reaction [75]. To explore how isotope substitution modifies reactivity at low temperatures Bodo and colleagues [75] artificially varied the mass of the hydrogen atoms in the calculation for the F + H2 reaction from 0.5 to 1.5 amu. As illustrated in Figure 3.12, for an H atom mass of 1.12 amu the virtual state induces a zero energy resonance at which the real part of the scattering length diverged to infinity. For the same value of the H atom mass, the zero-temperature rate coefficient of the reaction attains a value of 1.0 × 10−9 cm3 /sec, which is about three orders of magnitude larger than that of the F + H2 reaction in the Wigner limit. The variation of the scattering length of the F + H2 system as a function of the mass of the pseudo-hydrogen atom is similar to the variation of scattering length as a function of the magnetic field in the vicinity of a Feshbach resonance. Another example of a tunneling-dominated reaction is the Li + HF → LiF + H reaction. At cold and ultracold temperatures the reaction occurs by tunneling of the relatively heavy fluorine atom. The LiH + F channel is energetically not accessible at low energies and tunneling of the H atom is not involved in this reaction at low temperatures. Due to strong electric dipole forces exerted by the HF molecule, the van der Waals interaction potential of the LiHF system is deeper compared to the F + H2 system. The Li· · · HF van der Waals potential well is about 0.24 eV (1936.0 cm−1 ) and the H· · · LiF potential well is about 0.07 eV (565.0 cm−1 ). Quantum scattering calculations for Li + HF and LiF + H reactions by Weck and Balakrishnan [84,85] with the PES of Aguado and colleagues [92] have shown that for incident energies below 10−3 eV the reaction cross-section exhibits a large number of resonances. The energy dependence of the J = 0 cross-section for Li + HF(v = 0, j = 0) collisions is shown in Figure 3.13. Detailed bound-state calculations of the LiHF van der Waals complexes revealed that for the Li + HF(v = 0, j = 0) reaction the resonances correspond to the decay of Li· · · HF(v = 0, j = 1 − 4) van der Waals complexes. Calculations with vibrationally excited HF molecules showed that the reaction becomes about 600 times more efficient in the Wigner regime when HF is excited to the v = 1 vibrational level. As seen in Figure 3.13, a unique feature of the Li + HF(v = 0, j = 0) reaction is the presence of a strong peak at 5.0 × 10−4 eV at which the reaction cross-section is about six orders of magnitude larger than the background cross-section. The results for both Li + HF [84] and LiF + H [85] reactions with thermal and nonthermal vibrational excitation suggest that heavy-atom tunneling may play an important role in chemical reactions at cold and ultracold temperatures. An experimental study [12] of an organic ring expansion reaction at 8 K has © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
91
Inelastic Collisions and Chemical Reactions of Molecules (a)
150 100
a (Å)
50 0 –50 –100 –150 (b) 10–8
R(T = 0) (cm3/sec)
10–9 10–10 10–11 10–12 10–13 10–14
|Re(Ep)| (meV)
(c)
100 10–1 10–2 10–3 10–4 10–5
0.6
0.8
1
1.2 1.4 1.6 Mass of both H atoms
1.8
2
FIGURE 3.12 Real part of the scattering length (a), zero-temperature limiting values of the rate coefficient (b), and positions of quasibound states (c) of the F· · · H2 complex as functions of the mass of a pseudo hydrogen atom. (From Bodo, E. et al., J. Phys. B: At. Mol. Opt. Phys., 37, 3641, 2004. With permission.)
shown that the reaction occurs almost exclusively by carbon tunneling. The tunneling contribution was found to be orders of magnitude greater than over the barrier contribution. In a recent work, Tscherbul and Krems [93] have explored the Li + HF and LiF + H reactions in the presence of an external electric field. They have shown that, for temperatures below 1 K, the reaction probability can be significantly influenced by electric fields. © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
92
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
Cross-section (10−16 cm2)
Cross-section (10−16 cm2)
1 0.1
u=1
0.01 0.001 0.0001 1e–05 1e–06 1 u=0
0.1 0.01 0.001 0.0001 1e–05 1e–06 1e–07 1e–07
1e–06
1e–05
0.0001 0.001 Kinetic energy (eV)
0.01
0.1
FIGURE 3.13 Cross-sections for LiF formation (solid curve) and nonreactive scattering (dashed curve) in Li + HF(v, j = 0) collisions as functions of the incident kinetic energy: results for v = 0 (a); results for v = 1 (b). (From Weck, P.F. and Balakrishnan, N., J. Chem. Phys., 122, 154309, 2005. With permission.)
3.3.1.2
Feshbach Resonances in Reactive Scattering
Van der Waals complexes formed during collisions can either undergo vibrational predissociation or vibrational prereaction leading to sharp features in the energy dependence of the cross-sections. The term “prereaction” refers to the process in which a rotationally or vibrationally excited van der Waals complex decays through chemical reaction rather than by rotational or vibrational predissociation. For reactions with energy barriers the chemical reaction pathway may involve tunneling. The reactions of Cl with H2 and HD are dominated by tunneling at low temperatures [81–83]. Compared to the F + H2 and F + HD reactions, the energy barrier for the Cl + H2 reaction is much larger and the reactivity at low energies is significantly suppressed. Nearly a decade ago, Skouteris and colleagues [81] showed that the van der Waals interaction potential between Cl and HD determines the reaction outcome, despite the fact that the depth of the van der Waals interaction potential for the Cl· · · HD system is less than one-tenth of the height of the reaction barrier. Quantum scattering calculations of the Cl + HD reaction on PESs without the van der Waals interaction potential predict nearly equal probabilities for HCl and DCl products [81]. However, if the potential surface includes the van der Waals interaction a strong preference for the DCl product occurs at thermal energies, in agreement with experimental results. The effect of these weakly bound states on the reactivity at cold and ultracold temperatures has recently been explored by Balakrishnan [82]. © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
93
Inelastic Collisions and Chemical Reactions of Molecules
The cross-sections for HCl and DCl formation and nonreactive rovibrational transitions in Cl + HD(v = 1, j = 0) collisions for total angular momentum quantum number J = 0 are shown in Figure 3.14 as functions of the total energy [82]. The sharp features in the cross-sections correspond to Feshbach resonances arising from the decay of quasibound van der Waals complexes formed in the entrance channel of the reaction. The quasibound states can be identified by examining bound states of adiabatic potentials correlating with the v = 1, j = 0 and v = 1, j = 1 levels of the HD molecule. They are displayed in Figure 3.15 as functions of the atom–molecule separation. The adiabatic potential curves are computed by diagonalizing the diabatic potential energy matrix obtained in a basis set of rovibrational levels of the HD molecule at each value of the atom–molecule separation. The Feshbach resonances labeled B, C, D, and E in Figure 3.14 result from the decay of the corresponding quasibound states shown in Figure 3.15. The cross-sections in Figure 3.14 do not show a peak corresponding to the metastable state A. This is because the state A is too deeply bound and it is not accessible through scattering in the v = 1, j = 0 channel. Figure 3.14 also shows that the quasibound states preferentially undergo prereaction than predissociation. This
102
101
Cross-section (10−16 cm2)
100
10–1
Cl + HD – nonreactive B
C
D
10–2
E
HCl + D – reactive 10–3
10–4
DCl + H – reactive 10–5
10–6 0.685
0.69
0.695
0.7
0.705
Total energy (eV)
FIGURE 3.14 Reactive and nonreactive scattering cross-sections for Cl + HD(v = 1, j = 0) reaction as functions of the incident kinetic energy. (From Balakrishnan, N. J. Chem. Phys., 121, 5563, 2004. With permission.)
© 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
94
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
0.7 E
u = 1, j = 1
D C 0.69
B
Energy (eV)
u = 1, j = 0
A 0.68
0.67
5
10
15
20
R (au)
FIGURE 3.15 Adiabatic potential energy curves of the Cl + HD system correlating with the HD(v = 1, j = 0) and HD(v = 1, j = 1) levels as functions of the atom–molecule separation. Quasibound levels responsible for the resonances in Figure 3.14 are labeled by B, C, D, and E. (From Balakrishnan, N., J. Chem. Phys., 121, 5563, 2004. With permission.)
is due to the enhanced coupling of the resonance states with the reactive channels compared to those with the nonreactive channels. The wavefunctions of quasibound states B and E are shown in Figure 3.16 as functions of the atom–molecule separation. Although the wavefunction of the weakly bound state E extends far beyond the transition state region of the reaction, it preferentially undergoes prereaction rather than predissociation. Thus, regions of the interaction potential far away from the transition state region may have a significant effect on reactivity, especially when part of the wavefunction in that region is sampled by a resonance state that is coupled to the reactive channel. Figure 3.14 also demonstrates that because the reaction is dominated by tunneling at low temperatures, the formation of the DCl + H product, which involves the tunneling of the D atom, is severely suppressed in the threshold regime. This is more clearly illustrated in Figure 4 of Ref. [82] where the reaction cross-section is plotted as a function of the incident kinetic energy. Table 3.3 provides a compilation of zero-temperature quenching rate coefficients for a number of atom–diatom chemical reactions, which are dominated by tunneling at low energies. © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
95
Inelastic Collisions and Chemical Reactions of Molecules 0.02
0.02
B E Adiabatic potential
0
0
–0.01
–0.01
–0.02
0.01 Potential energy (eV)
Wavefunction (arb. units)
0.01
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
–0.02 35
R (au)
FIGURE 3.16 Adiabatic potential and the wavefunctions of the quasibound levels B and E shown in Figure 3.15 as functions of the atom–molecule separation. Amplitudes of the wavefunctions have been reduced by a factor of 10 for the convenience of plotting. (From Balakrishnan, N., J. Chem. Phys., 121, 5563, 2004. With permission.)
3.3.2 3.3.2.1
BARRIERLESS REACTIONS Collision Systems of Three Alkali Metal Atoms
As discussed by Hutson and Soldán in two recent reviews [6,14], progress on the production of ultracold molecules and the creation of molecular Bose–Einstein condensates of alkali-metal systems have motivated theoretical studies on ultracold atom–dimer alkali-metal collisions. Here, we give an overview of recent calculations for spin-polarized triatomic alkali-metal systems, Li + Li2 [94–97], Na + Na2 [98,99], and K + K2 [100]. These results have all been obtained using the reactive scattering code written by Launay and Le Dourneuf [101], based on a time-independent quantum formalism. Refs. [94,95,97] and [100] describe the details of the PESs and dynamics calculations. The quantum dynamics studies of Refs. [98] and [99] have been performed using the Na3 PES reported by Higgins and colleagues [102], while the results of Ref. [96] have been obtained using the Li3 PES calculated by Colavecchia and colleagues [103]. Another PES for Li3 has been constructed by Brue and colleagues [104]. © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
96
Cold Molecules: Theory, Experiment, Applications
TABLE 3.3 Zero-Temperature Quenching Rate Coefficients for Tunneling Dominated Reactions (the Final Arrangement has also been Specified) Initial (v, j )
kT =0 (cm3 /sec)
Reference
F + D2
(v = 0, j = 0) (v = 0, j = 0) (v = 0, j = 0) (v = 0, j = 0)
1.3 × 10−12 (H + HF) 2.8 × 10−14 (D + HF) 0.5 × 10−14 (H + DF) 2.1 × 10−14 (D + DF)
[11] [74] [74] [73]
F + HCl F + HCl
(v = 0, j = 0) (v = 1, j = 0)
F + HCl
(v = 2, j = 0)
F + DCl
(v = 1, j = 0)
1.2 × 10−17 4.0 × 10−15 5.3 × 10−15 5.2 × 10−13 3.3 × 10−13 4.4 × 10−21
(Cl + HF) (Cl + HF) (F + HCl) (Cl + HF) (F + HCl) (Cl + DF)
[88] [88] [88] [88] [88] [88]
H + HCl
(v = 0, j = 0) (v = 1, j = 0) (v = 2, j = 0) (v = 1, j = 0) (v = 2, j = 0)
2.4 × 10−19 (Cl + H2 ) 7.2 × 10−14 (Cl + H2 ) 1.9 × 10−11 (Cl + H2 ) 7.8 × 10−15 (Cl + HD) 1.7 × 10−12 (Cl + HD)
[83] [83] [83] [83] [83]
Cl + HD
(v = 1, j = 0)
1.7 × 10−13 (D + HCl) 7.1 × 10−16 (H + DCl) 7.8 × 10−14 (Cl + HD)
[82] [82] [82]
Li + HF
(v = 0, j = 0) (v = 1, j = 0) (v = 1, j = 0)
4.5 × 10−20 2.8 × 10−17 3.8 × 10−15 1.6 × 10−14 1.7 × 10−14 2.7 × 10−13
[84] [84] [85] [85] [85] [85]
System F + H2 F + HD
H + DCl
H + LiF
(v = 2, j = 0)
(H + LiF) (H + LiF) (Li + HF) (H + LiF) (Li + HF) (H + LiF)
Quantum scattering calculations show that ultracold reactions of alkali metal atoms with alkali metal dimers are much more efficient than tunneling-driven processes. This can be explained based on the following considerations. First, the indistinguishability of the atoms may play a role. For a homonuclear triatomic system, the three possible arrangement channels are the same. Also, the presence of identical two-body potentials in all three arrangement channels may enhance the depth of the three-body interaction potential. Consider the two-body term (additive term) of a homonuclear triatomic system at equilateral geometries. Because the distances between the three identical atoms are the same, the same diatomic potential term is added three times to yield the two-body terms of the triatomic system. If the diatomic potential is deep or repulsive, the two-body term will be three times deeper or repulsive at equilateral geometries. In contrast, for triatomic systems with distinguishable atoms, the diatomic © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
Inelastic Collisions and Chemical Reactions of Molecules
97
pairs are not the same. For example, for the Li + HF system, the three diatomic fragments are distinctly different. They have completely different electronic structures and properties such as minima, equilibrium distances, turning points, and the nature and range of the interaction. Thus, at an equilateral configuration for which the three diatomic distances are the same but the diatomic potential energies are different (one may be attractive while the other two may be repulsive), the overall two-body term can be weaker than the individual two-body interaction potential. This could lead to a triatomic interaction region that is less strong than that of a homonuclear triatomic system. Second, the topology of the PES plays a significant role. For all alkali-metal trimer systems, the minimum energy configurations arise at equilateral and collinear geometries as shown by Soldán and colleagues [105]. Furthermore, the surface is barrierless so that all atom–dimer alkali-metal collisional approaches are energetically possible. In contrast, most of the nonalkali systems discussed above are characterized by a collinear (or bend) atom–diatom approach, and dominated by a repulsive barrier in the triatomic transition-state region. The particular topology of the PES arises from the three-body interaction potential. Also, the couplings between different electronic surfaces of the triatomic system give rise to conical intersections, which create a repulsive barrier in the transition-state region. If the energy barrier is high and its width large, tunneling will be very inefficient, leading to very small values for the reaction rate coefficients in the Wigner regime. Although reactivity can be enhanced when resonances are present, the background scattering in reactive cross-sections is generally quite small. In contrast, for almost all alkali-metal trimer systems, the conical intersections arise at small interatomic distances where the PES is sufficiently repulsive that it plays no significant role at ultralow energy and the reactivity is not influenced by such repulsive barriers. Third, the density of states of the system plays an important role. If the density of states is small as for