c o g n it ive-b e ha v i o r a I
t h e r a p y FOR SPECIFIC PROBLEMS A N D POPULATIONS
Edited by John R. White and A...
202 downloads
2456 Views
24MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
c o g n it ive-b e ha v i o r a I
t h e r a p y FOR SPECIFIC PROBLEMS A N D POPULATIONS
Edited by John R. White and Arthur S. Freeman
American Psychological Association Washington, DC
CONTENTS
..................................................
ix
.......................................................
xi
.....................................
3
Contributors Preface
Chapter 1.
Introduction
John R. White
I. Cognitive-Behavioral Group Therapy for Specific Problems Chapter 2. Chapter 3.
......................................
29
...............................
63
..........................................
99
Depression
John R. White
Panic and Phobia..
Ariel 1. Lang and Michelle G . Craske
Chapter 4.
Obesity
Chapter 5.
Eating Disorders
Robert R. Radomile
..................................
127
Wayne A. Bowers
Chapter 6.
Dual Diagnoses .................................. Tom Greanias and Sandra Siegel
149
Chapter 7.
Dissociative Disorders
.............................
175
Chapter 8.
Ailu Jesse McCutchen Adult Attention Deficit Disorder .................. 2 11
William D. Morgan vii
11. Cognitive-Behavioral Group Therapy for Specific Populations or Settings
Older Adults .................................... 235 Larry W. Thompson, David V. Powers, David W. Coon, KeUie Takagi, Christine McKibbin, and Dolores Gallagher-Thompson
Chapter 9.
Chapter 10. Medical Patients ................................. Paul G. Ritvo, M. Jane Irvine, Joel Katz, and Brian F. Shaw
263
Chapter 11. Latinos ......................................... Kurt C. Organism
281
Chapter 12. Women’s Sexuality. ............................... Susan Walen andJanet L. Wolfe
305
Chapter 13. Parent Training ..................................
331
Jonathan Stern
Chapter 14. Clients in Partial Hospitalization Settings Amy S. Witt-Browder
.......... 361
Author Index
.................................................
385
Subject Index
.................................................
397
.............................................
405
About the Editors
...
0111
CONTENTS
CONTRIBUTORS
Wayne A. Bowers, PhD, Department of Psychiatry, University of Iowa, Iowa City, Iowa
David W. Coon, PhD, Goldman Institute on Aging, San Fransisco, CA Michelle G. Craske, PhD, Department of Psychology, University of California, Los Angeles
Arthur S. Freeman, EdD, Department of Psychology, Philadelphia College of Osteopathic Medicine
Dolores Gallagher-Thompson, PhD, ABPP, Older Adult Center, VA Palo Alto Health Care System, Menlo Park, CA and Department of Psychiatry, Stanford University School of Medicine, Standford, CA Tom Greanias, LCSW, CADC, Behavioral and Mental Health Services, DuPage County Health Department, Wheaton, IL M. Jane Irvine, D. Phil., York University, Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto, and University Health Network Joel Katz, PhD, Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto General Hospital, and Mt. Sinai Hospital Ariel J. Lang, PhD, Department of Psychiatry, University of California, San Diego and San Diego VA Healthcare System Aila Jesse McCutchen, PsyD, Department of Psychiatry, Massachusetts General Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston Christine McKibbin, PhD, Department of Psychiatry, VA Medical Center and University of California, San Diego, CA William D. Morgan, PsyD, Life Counseling Services, Paoli, PA Kurt C. Organista, PhD, School of Social Welfare, University of California, Berkeley David V. Powers, PhD, Department of Psychology, Loyola College, Baltimore, MD
ix
Robert R. Radomile, M. Ed., Jerry Kear, PhD and Associates, Philadelphia, PA Paul G. Ritvo, PhD, Ontario Cancer Institute, University Health Network, and Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto
Brian F. Shaw, PhD, Community Healthmental Health and
Professional Services, Hospital for Sick Children, and Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto Sandra Siegel, MA, RN, Adler School of Professional Psychology, Chicago Medical School, Chicago, IL Jonathan Stern, PhD, Cognitive Psychotherapy Services, New York, NY Kellie Takagi, PhD, Older Adult Center, VA Palo Alto Health Care System, and Department of Psychiatry, Stanford University, Stanford, CA Larry W. Thompson, PhD, Pacific Graduate School of Psychology and VA Palo Alto Health Care System, Palo Alto, CA Susan Walen, PhD, private practice and Department of Psychiatry, Johns Hopkins School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD John R. White, PhD, California School of Professional PsychologyAlameda and Department of Education, Stanford University, Stanford, CA Amy S. Witt-Browder, MA, The Reading Hospital and Medical Center, Reading, PA Janet L. Wolfe, PhD, Albert Ellis Institute for Rational-Emotive Behavior Therapy, New York, NY
X
CONTRlBUTORS
PREFACE
As psychologists working in graduate and hospital training settings, we have observed a growing demand for qualified therapists skillful in conducting group therapy. Drawing on the existing cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) group literature, we have supervised doctoral and postdoctoral students in various CBT group therapy programs. This approach seems to have produced a consistently positive response from the clients served and offered particular advantages for applying the CBT model. In these group therapy settings, conditional beliefs naturally rose to the surface, providing multiple opportunities to identify, test, and revise those underlying rules that govern social behavior. There was immediate activation of automatic thoughts without having to resort to “out of group experience’’ to find clinically relevant material. The single best advantage of CBT delivered in group settings seems to be the fundamental fact that it is the group itself that generates its own adaptive response. Members gain immeasurably in acquiring this skill through social modeling with each other. First they learn to make a n adaptive response together, and then they are prepared to apply the same process on their own. We have seen over and over that a group’s capacity for adaptive response usually exceeds the ability of those same individuals to undertake adaptation while by themselves. Through our contact with colleagues at other training centers, we became aware that a number of them were also developing and implementing group therapy programs based on principles similar to ours. What was notable was the remarkable range of clinical populations being treated in these various settings using group CBT methods. Of necessity, then, these colleagues have refined specialty techniques for working within this diagnostic diversity. This has led to a significant extension beyond the existing CBT literature, resulting in a second generation of group techniques and methods. Our recognition of these developments became the origin of the present volume as we have attempted to shed light on this xi
advancement as it is occurring. Because these approaches are neither monolithic nor monochromatic, we selected the title Cognitive-Behviord Group Therapy for Specifi Probkrns and Populations to reflect their true plurality. We have endeavored to produce a practical text that will assist clinicians in developing and providing CBT group therapy. It has been our good fortune to obtain the support and authorship of many of the leading CBT group therapists across North America. Because of the practical emphasis of this text as well as the stature of the contributing authors, we offer this collected work as “best practices” of contemporary group CBT. Obviously, this is not an exhaustive list of the prominent CBT therapists who are developing group therapy models. One of our hopes with the publication of the present work is to extend this clinical dialogue to include other accomplished therapists who are working with their own specific populations while refining relevant innovations in group CBT methods. An unexpected outcome of this process was the “group” that was formed by the group therapists who contributed. We would now like to extend those membership boundaries. We asked each of the authors to prepare a detailed description of their work that would serve for all practical purposes as a flexible protocol, enabling another clinician to implement similar methods. Protocol, in this sense, is interpreted in light of its Greek origin proto kollon, which means “a table of contents crafted from sheets of papyrus glued together.” These chapters provide essentially a table of contents of the substance and sequence of the best practices in group CBT. The resulting protocols are deemed flexible in acknowledging the complex demands when offering a simultaneous treatment experience to a variety of separate human beings. Accordingly, each protocol must be able to adjust to individual differences within a common syndrome, including diverse symptom profiles and ideographic problem lists. Flexibility also means that in dealing within clinical populations there should be due recognition of the different stages of development as each individual works through his or her adaptation to the syndrome. For example, within a CBT group therapy for depression, there may be clients for whom this is a first episode, others who have had a longterm low-grade depression with recent exacerbation, and others who present a chronic course of repeated major episodes. No rigid or lock-step protocol will come close to accommodating the needs of these individuals. It is precisely this complex clinical thought process that the authors in this book seek to illuminate, in essence providing a series of detailed clinical algorithms as to how these expert therapists arrive at their decisions in the various phases of group therapy. These chapters are offered to the reader in the time-honored mode of clinical supervision. We all recognize from our therapy training that a good clinical supervisor puts forward plenty of practical advice, especially xii
PREFACE
in forecasting those common problems that arise in therapy and helping to figure the best ways out. Because modeling is one of the most effective methods of learning, a clinical supervisor will typically teach by example and show what he or she really does in session. For example, in the text several authors address the specifics of what they actually say and do when dealing with potential dropouts, always a thorny issue for group therapists. And a good supervisor starts at the skill level the clinician possesses and builds from there. Accordingly, these chapters assume that some readers will come to the present discussion with a background in CBT, others may originate from their work in group therapy, whereas others begin at their specialty knowledge of the clinical population discussed in any particular chapter. Acknowledging this range of backgrounds, the authors, as good clinical supervisors, endeavor to develop each reader’s own knowledge and proficiency to conduct group therapy according that individual’s distinctive style. In composing these chapters, the authors were asked to address what we considered the two defining variables of CBT group therapy. There is nothing more important in an ongoing group therapy than cohesiveness, defined as the degree of personal interest of the members for each other. Cohesiveness is high when people want to attend the group and look forward to relating to each other. They spontaneously think about each other between sessions. When there exists compassion and members feel concern for the suffering of other members, the group has achieved cohesiveness. It is this social force within a group that permits members to tolerate differences and disagreements. When there exists sufficient cohesiveness, these differences do not threaten the basic integrity of the group. There is opportunity to express diversity of experience and opinion with the confidence that the group will not fall apart and individuals will not be harmed. For example, members will typically not begin to engage in a process of constructive conflict until there first exists a feeling of safety that originates from cohesiveness. We asked our authors to address the many ways that they facilitate a sense of cohesiveness in the group and how they intervene when inevitable forces within the group seek to overturn cohesiveness. The other essential variable in CBT group therapy is task focus. CBT is a focused therapy that seeks problem resolution. Each member usually has goals that he or she wants to attain over the course of treatment. This often involves learning and practicing specific skills that help the client to better deal with the issues at hand. If clients were to experience this focus on task as controlling or impersonal, it would certainly fail and probably bring the entire group down with it. Each CBT therapist must determine his or her own best methods of achieving task focus that convey a full sense of empathy and concern. For example, the process of checking in with homework is a good gauge of the therapist’s skills in task focus. Does PREFACE
...
XI11
the therapist follow up on homework every time it is agreed to? When clients do not do homework, is there a discussion that brings the opposing factors to light (without dissolving to a power struggle or exercise in shame)? Are clients able to regard unexpected outcomes not as failures but as opportunities to learn? Is follow-up homework composed with input from all members? Do clients really feel that the homework they have agreed to do can actually help them?When there is sufficient task focus, the therapist is facilitating the group to make optimal use of its constructive energy. In some clinical circles, the variables of cohesiveness and task focus are seen to be at odds. These critics would argue that when a group maintains high cohesiveness, it necessarily diverts from a specific task focus. “The group is too soft to work hard.’’ Alternatively, if the group were to operate with high task focus, it could do so only at the expense of strong positive feelings between members. No real cohesiveness would exist. Sadly, there is no way to succeed on behalf of patients in this either-or dilemma. By virtue of assuming an inverse relationship, cohesiveness must be sacrificed to task focus, or vice versa. These chapters dispute the entire notion of sacrifice and argue a fundamental premise that cohesiveness and task focus are actually orthogonal (see Figure A.l). Consider cohesiveness as presented on an x-axis and task focus appearing on a y-axis. The best “BEST PRACTICES”
COHESIVENESS
TASK FOCUS figure A. 7. Best practices in cognitive-behavioral group therapy.
Xiv
PREFACE
practices of this text advocate clinical work that is experienced by the group as both highly cohesive and highly task focused. Indeed, if a problem arises in the group, these authors propose a clinical algorithm that seeks to reinforce both cohesiveness and task focus. For example, the therapist’s skill in guiding the group to generate a meaningful agenda not only identifies a topic that everyone can personally relate to, but over the course of the session leads to sufficient resolution to arrive at an adaptive response satisfactory to all. How much stronger is this process than if a topic were to be pushed by the therapist or arose randomly from the first member who happens to speak up? Obviously this approach is fundamentally different from clinicians who assume that cohesiveness and task focus are diametrically opposite, and then practice in such a way that substantiates the assumption. Although it is not always easy for a therapist to conduct therapy in ways that support cohesiveness and task focus, we think that it is unfair and unnecessary to ask our clients to settle for less. Because of the practical emphasis of this project, we specifically asked authors to limit their theoretical references and discussions. This does not mean there is neither a theoretical basis to the work nor theoretical implications to the ideas discussed. A downstream consequence of this project has been the early emergence of new thought regarding a model of CBT group therapy. Because of the practical nature of this project, the emerging theory is built inductively from the data of actual day-to-day clinical practice rather than derived deductively from a set of general principles. From these inductive origins, there seem to be promising implications for a CBT group theory that would draw on the burgeoning fields of cognitive psychology and general systems. To name a few, such features of this dual citizenship would include feedback and feed-forward loops, nonlinear and reciprocal cause-and-effect, and complex processes of change and homeostasis. The group, from a slightly surreal perspective, could be viewed as containing the distributed intelligence of the members-not unlike an outof-skull brain with each of the participants as a distinct lobe. Down the road there might also be interesting theoretical applications of such work to nonclinical groups as well, such as in employment, family, politics, and community. Just as the text itself is deliberately integrative, so we specified to our authors that its clinical orientation would take precedence over a research perspective. Yet the majority of these same authors are also clinical researchers, and this collective background is unmistakable in the manner these chapters are presented. T h e authors naturally incorporate a writing style significantly influenced by their research methodology, often including outcome measures as well as operationally defined treatment conditions. The research mindset of this project reinforces the clinical intent of a CBT treatment modality. Clients learn to test their hypotheses about themselves and the world while making behavioral experiments to gather fresh data PREFACE
xv
from their own life. It is hoped that the present work will serve as a catalyst for related clinical research. Not only can these flexible protocols be tested in various clinical settings, but also they can be revised with alternative methods and populations. Research methods from a group tradition would be welcomed to better capture the complex phenomenon of evaluating a CBT treatment experience shared by some number of people simultaneously rather than one person at a time. The interest in CBT group therapies demonstrated by the chapter authors and readers reflects a much larger tidal shift under way in the field of mental health treatment. Nick Cummings, long a respected source forecasting the emerging trends in our profession, has observed, The therapy of the future will be characterized by time-limited empirically derived, condition specific protocols. Of these, only 25% will involve patients in individual psychotherapy, another 25% will involve patients in group therapy, while 50% of our patients will receive psychoeductional group therapy (Cummings, as cited in White, 1995, p. 3).
If these predictions are as accurate as the others in Cummings’s long and distinguished career, the therapy methods discussed in this text will be directly in line with half to as much as three quarters of mental health treatment of the future. The therapist with interest and skills in CBT group therapy will likely find opportunity and growth as these transitions unfold. We feel honored to be able to assist in the development of those therapists and look forward to all they will teach us in the years to come. REFERENCE White, J. (1995). Overcoming depression and loss: A personal workbook for cognitioe group therapy. Palo Alto, CA: Mind Garden.
xvi
PREFACE
cognitive-behavioral
t h e r a p y F O R S P E CIFIC PROBLEMS A N D POPULATIONS
INTRODUCTION JERRY M. SULS, ABRAHAM TESSER, RICHARD B. FELSON
In a recent review of the literature, Banaji and Prentice (1994) counted more than 5,000 publications on phenomena related to the self, spanning a wide variety of journals, monographs, and books. As the size and scope of this literature attests, the self is a well-established research area in a variety of disciplines including clinical psychology, communication, developmental psychology, social psychology, and sociology. The purpose of this volume is to provide an overview of recent and emerging empirical work in this field, as well as its philosophical and scientific origins. The book should be useful to established scholars and students alike. In order to put contributions to this volume into context for the reader, we first present a brief history of the social psychology of self. The history of thought on the self dates from the ancient Greeks. Aristotle emphasized the difference between physical and nonphysical aspects of being human. He referred to the soul as the nonphysical or psychic core of each human being that was essential to mental functioning. Much later this concept was labeled as the self. The shift in terminology is important because, with the rise of Christianity, the concept of soul became the domain of theology. The distinction between physical and nonphysical was maintained and subsequently elaborated by Ren6 Descartes, the French philosopher. (His famous dictum, “I think, therefore I am,” asserts that because thinking is undeniable, so is the existence of the thinker.) The I, a thinking, knowing entity was recognized as a key aspect of the self. The nature of experiencing oneself became a major preoccupation of subsequent philosophers such as George Berkeley, David Hume, James Mill, and John Stuart Mill. A point of debate was whether the self represents the process of
3
experiencing or the content of what is known. The ensuing philosophical debate set the stage for the development of psychology in the later part of the 19th century. Wilhelm Wundt (1897/1902) argued that the sense of self really represents the individual’s experiences of his or her own body, particularly muscle tension and other internal states. This view seemed too narrow, however, to the American psychologist William James (l890), who offered a more complex perspective on the self and, in a real sense, created the agenda for future (social) psychological inquiry about self and identity. James made a distinction between the self as knower or I (process) and known or me (content). According to James, the known self consisted of three domains of selfexperience: the material me, which included one’s body and material possessions, as well as family members and things connected to the self; the social self, which involves the recognition one obtains from friends and significant others, and the spiritual self, which refers to the psychic faculties or dispositions. Thus, the me is the aggregate of things known about self. The I is the stream of consciousness that creates this knowing. Because it is a relatively continuous stream, James thought each thought can remember what went before, which was responsible for people’s feeling of continuity across time. James had hoped he had (by integrating the known and knower aspects of the self) settled classic philosophical disputes about whether the self was a process or a content. For James, the self was both. These ideas became influential in contemporary theories and research on the self. Discussion of the content and structure of the self figures prominently in chapters by Baumeister, Vallacher and Nowak, and Campbell, Assanand, and Di Paula in this volume. James contributed many other ideas about the self, but two were especially important. Because the social self relies on what we think other people think or expect of us, James (1890) argued that “a man has as many social selves as there are individuals who recognize him and carry an image of him in their mind” (p. 190). These comments anticipate the importance of self-presentation and social roles in contemporary research. Another of James’s ideas was that self-esteem is determined by the ratio of one’s successes to one’s pretensions or goals. This means that people’s objective level of success, wealth, or attractiveness, and so forth, is less important than how well they perceive meeting their strivings. The emphasis on self-esteem and strivings leads directly to consideration of self-motives and self-regulation in contemporary research. The work described by Sedikides and Skowronski and Harmon-Jones are manifestations of this tradition in the social psychology of the self. George Herbert Mead (1934) was the father of symbolic interactionism, a theory that has had great influence on social psychologists trained in sociology departments. The theory emphasizes the role of symbols and the individual’s “definition of the situation.” Through symbols, people create a
4
P S Y C H O L O G K A L PERSPECTWES ON SELF AND IDENTEY
to thoughts. Or, behaviors may engender whole sets of feelings and thoughts, which subsequently influence each other (Lazarus, 1997). Some CBT therapists prefer a more linear approach that focuses first on thoughts, which are then seen as causing feelings, which in turn determine behaviors. I have seen good clinical results obtained both ways. The reader is encouraged to explore in his or her own clinical experience which approach (i.e., multidirectional or linear) has worked better and to experiment in various therapeutic situations to see what he or she prefers. A significant implication of the cognitive model is that CBT is a fundamentally phenomenological approach (Mahoney, 1991). Clients and therapist are seeking to track the moment-by-moment personal experience of each individual. Phenomenological refers to how the phenomena of an experience register with an individual, rather an approach that would try to see the universal nature of an event as it would be agreed upon by most or all people. By mutual understanding, there is a steady focus on the unfolding present. Does this mean that past and future are somehow deemed unimportant? Hardly. But the past and future are seen to be constantly filtered through the present moment. So, with appropriate clinical timing, the CBT therapist might say, “What immediate thoughts were triggered when you just touched on that memory o f . . . [an old trauma]?” or “Tell me all your feelings when you became aware right now of. . . [a threat in the future]?”The essence of this phenomenological approach of the CBT therapist is captured in A. T. Beck’s (1976) favorite clinical question, which he called the cognitive probe: “What is going through your mind right now?” Underlying the immediate thoughts, feelings, and behaviors are the individual’s conditional beliefs (J. S. Beck, 1995). These are the if-then statements by which a person makes sense of cause-and-effect relations in the world. Some conditional beliefs are obvious. “If I walk out in the street without looking, then I may get hit by a car.” Such are the basic conditions of people’s lives. Other conditional beliefs are more distinctive of each individual. For example, one person may have learned, “If I speak up for myself, then my ideas will usually be listened to.” Another person may have developed the expectation that “If I take a stand for something that matters to me, then I will be criticized or humiliated.” Obviously, the conditional beliefs of the first individual would lead him or her to be assertive and confident; those of the latter person would influence him or her to be meek and passive. The cognitive model holds that everyone has an array of conditional beliefs that have been learned and accumulated over a lifetime. These beliefs constitute essentially a program for living or a set of rules attempting to make sense of the world. Group therapy is a superb setting to explore conditional beliefs because multiple people are working together to reveal the underlying rules of each person’s life. I explain to clients, INTRODUCTION
5
You are likely to be aware of some of your conditional beliefs and where you learned them. Others probably operate outside your awareness. You assume them to be true, but you don’t really know for sure. In therapy we’re looking for the kinds of conditional beliefs that cause you trouble. Maybe they are negative statements about yourself that are not helpful or true. Or perhaps they are your rules for surviving a difficult past that no longer apply in your current life. Or you may keep yourself from changing or growing because you assume that bad things will happen when there is no real basis for that kind of prediction.
Over the course of group therapy, CBT attempts to bring these conditional beliefs into the light of day and help clients test the hypotheses to determine which are valid and worth keeping versus which should be modified or dumped altogether (Clark, 1989). All those small predictions that clients make on a day-to-day basis are referred to by CBT as hypotheses. Group therapy seeks to help clients be aware of hypotheses they are forming and then determining which are true according to how accurately they predict future events. A client can test a hypothesis by deliberately setting up a situation to determine whether the hypothesis is proved to be valid. For example, a shy client believed that if he opened up he would be ignored by the people around him. With the support of the other clients he decided to test that hypothesis in group by speaking up and assessing the reactions he received. Contrary to his expectation, he found that people were interested in what he had to say and demonstrated their warmth and concern. Thus by testing the hypothesis that opening up would result in his being ignored, he was able to make an alternate hypothesis that in certain supportive settings (such as the therapy group) he could hope for a more positive response. Still in place, however, was the expectation that outside the therapy group nobody would really listen to him. This became his next area of testing the hypothesis by selecting situations and relationships in his day-to-day life where he could experiment with opening up as he had initiated in the group. He then discovered that there were two acquaintances who were more interested in him than he had predicted and their positive reactions opened the possibility of developing actual friendships with them. In this step-by-step process, the client identified his old hypotheses, put them to test, recognized what was proved false, and modified his subsequent predictions according to the new information. The resulting hypotheses led to more fulfilling experiences for him and a more adaptive approach to his interpersonal world. Beneath these conditional beliefs, the cognitive model locates what are called the core beliefs. These are the fundamental ways that an individual regards himself or herself. They are seen to cluster in two areas: “To what extent is the individual capable of being loved?” and “How competent is the individual in facing the challenges of life?“ These core beliefs derive from the accumulation of life experience and how each individual makes
6
JOHN R. WHITE
sense of what has happened. For example, a depressed client’s core beliefs may indicate ‘‘I am not lovable because I have always been abandoned.” Naturally this belief would darken the client’s day-to-day experience as well as strain his or her current relationships. An anxious client may have a core belief that “I can’t deal with threats in the future,” reinforcing the pattern of avoidance commonly seen in anxiety (Burns, 1980). Individuals usually hold a combination of positive and negative core beliefs as to their lovability and competence. If consistent with the goals of treatment, CBT explores the core beliefs as they are influential in each client’s current life. This follows the downward arrow from immediate thoughts, feelings, and behaviors to conditional beliefs to core beliefs (J. S. Beck, 1995). In following the downward arrow method, the CBT therapist helps to explore the assumptions underlying a given belief. For example, a client found herself paralyzed with anxiety about making a presentation to an audience at work and the downward arrow method revealed her conditional belief “If I make a mistake in front of people, then they will think I am stupid.” Then it came to light that she believed if one person in her audience had a single impression that she might have said something wrong, the thought would completely overrule all the positive reactions from everyone else. Exploring still further brought to the surface her own core beliefs about her incompetence that had developed in childhood and persisted despite her highly successful professional career. By using the downward arrow to illuminate the linkages of these beliefs, therapy could integrate methods to help her immediately with feeling more comfortable with her presentation while at the same time addressing her deep feelings of incompetence. It is usually not possible to completely remove negative beliefs. They likely had their origins in key events of the individual’s life and show an indelible mark on the person’s current identity. Contributing significantly to the distinctive qualities of the individual, these core beliefs ought not be eliminated, even if that were possible. However, therapy can assist with cognitive restructuring (Meichenbaum, 1974). This involves helping a client to modify the constellation of beliefs that define her and her world to herself. In the process the individual typically leaves behind certain old beliefs that prove to be no longer valid or useful. There is more flexibility in being able to hold a variety of different beliefs about oneself in different situations, rather than adhering to certain rigid (and usually negative) beliefs that narrowly define the person. For example, a rigid belief that “I never know what to say to people” might be restructured to say “I may be quiet until I get to know somebody, but when I am comfortable I have a pretty good sense of humor.” The therapeutic process of restructuring beliefs gives the client a firsthand experience of the positive results so that she learns to sustain this on her own after the therapy is finished. The process of examining and modifying beliefs is ongoing. A person can exercise choice over which beliefs are fNTRODUCTION
7
strongest and those that support the kinds of feelings and behaviors he or she desires. Psychological distress and symptoms almost always mean that negative core beliefs have gained ascendancy. Group CBT helps the members reduce the impact of the negative beliefs and develop current life experiences that are more rewarding. In the process, there can be creation of positive beliefs based on actual experiences of feeling loved and being competent.
TEN COMMONLY USED METHODS Following are 10 methods commonly used in group CBT. This is not intended to be an exhaustive list but is offered instead as a serviceable introduction. For greater depth, readers are strongly encouraged to go to original source material in the CBT literature as well as to learn from practitioners who regularly use these methods. I engage in both pursuits myself. Automatic Thought Record The automatic thought record refers to a written exercise that guides clients in a process identifying thoughts, feelings, and behaviors* at a given moment, usually when they are experiencing some distress. Sometimes called a dysfunctional thought record or simply a thought record, this is one of the most frequently used clinical tools in CBT. It begins by providing clients the means of gaining awareness to see specifically what is being triggered in an immediate situation. Because awareness properly focused tends to lead to adaptive response,* the automatic thought record itself becomes a method of clinical intervention of focusing and refocusing. By gaining greater ability to focus and refocus, clients generally experience an enhanced sense of self-regulation, compared to when troubling situations and disturbing thoughts seemed to dominate their focus allowing no personal influence upon their own minds. In focusing, clients learn to gain perspective when viewing what is happening in their personal experience. From this vantage point, in refocusing, they are better able to see constructive responses to their triggering situations, as well as to begin modifying the dysfunctional thoughts themselves. The group therapist typically teaches clients to complete the automatic thought record during session. This is an exercise of skills building and reflects the psychoeducational nature of CBT. I explain to clients, The thought record is something akin to a photograph of your mind at a moment in time. I t helps us capture your immediate thoughts, feelings, and behaviors as relate to a given situation. There is not a right or wrong way to complete a thought record. But the more practice
8
JOHN R. WHZTE
you have, you will likely notice a greater understanding of your own reactions and you can see how to guide the experience in a favorable direction. Members typically use thought records to deal with their day-to-day issues as well as to record new experiences during homework* between sessions. In group therapy, thought records offer certain unique advantages. When checking in at the beginning of the group session, members can share selectively from their thought records as a vivid means to relate an experience from outside of the group. I find that these reports are typically fresh and immediate, and lead to lively group exchange. Also, the thought record teaches members a common clinical language that facilitates their understanding and communication (especially valuable when time in the group may be limited). The thought record originated in the work of Aaron Beck (A. T. Beck, Rush, Shaw, & Emery, 1979) and remains a hallmark of his approach. One of the best sources of teaching a client how to complete a thought record is provided by Greenberger and Padesky (1999, who explain the process step by step with plenty of clinical examples. Their client manual can be used as a workbook in therapy for clients to record their automatic thought process and work toward alternative or balanced thinking. Challenging the Thoughts
CBT guides clients in a process of Challenging their thoughts, particularly those that are associated with clinical symptoms and maladaptive behaviors. I will tell clients in a group, Once we have identified what you think or believe, now we get to see how true it is. What is the evidence* for and against?Are there other ways of looking at the same situation?Is this the only conclusion that can be drawn?By challenging your thoughts, you get to see those that may be outdated and need to be replaced. You can also see what thoughts and beliefs of yours stand up to challenge and consequently where you have a stronger and more confident sense of yourself. This method of challenging one’s own thinking harkens back to Socratic questioning* in which inductive analysis brings to the surface underlying assumptions and tests them against competing assumptions. The process of challenging thoughts usually brings to awareness various cognitive distortions that have been supporting the maladaptive beliefs. These distortions are persistent patterns of thought containing idiosyncratic meanings and faulty rules of logic. For example, dichotomous thinking produces a narrow range of conclusions, typically at total odds with each other and expressed only in the most extreme terms: “Regardless of how she tries to explain her feelings about me, I know that she either comINTRODUCTION
9
pletely loves me or totally hates me-those are the only two possibilities.” CBT challenges these extremes to alter the cognitive structure and produce a balanced perspective that flexibly integrates a range of strong opinions with a more objective view of the evidence (A. T. Beck, Freeman, 6r Associates, 1990). Obviously, the therapist needs to have a sufficient collaborative relationship* with clients so that the challenges are not taken to be critical or negating. Empathy is crucial, both to know when and when not to challenge. At the early stages of therapy, the therapist takes the lead in challenging, but over the course of treatment clients learn more and more how to do it on their own-in and out of session. J. S. Beck (1995) provided a detailed explanation of this process in her chapter 8, titled “Evaluating Automatic Thoughts.” Albert Ellis described a similar method as disputation, in which he teaches the client to challenge his or her irrational thinking (see Walen, DiGiuseppe, & Dryden, 1992). As opposed to identifying thoughts as good or bad (and falling into the trap of dichotomous thinking), CBT challenges group members to reflect on the advantages and disadvantages of particular assumptions compared with others.
Mood Monitoring This a simple behavioral method in which clients are asked to regularly rate their moods (sometimes called a mood check). Most often this is used with clients who are experiencing depression, although it can also be used for clients with anxious and manic moods (McKay, Davis, & Fanning, 1997). I explain to clients, Each day I would like you to rate your mood on a scale of 0 to 100: 100 is the most intense depression you’ve ever experienced, and 0 is the complete absence of depression. Give one score that would be your overall impression of the day. Write down the scores each day and bring the results to therapy with you.
This method gives clients and therapist alike an overview of the client’s moods and longer term trends. It also helps to identify anomalous events that stand out from the general pattern. Because clients with a mood disorder tend to be both global and negative about their moods, the formal act of mood monitoring can help them see subtle changes and points of progress. Small improvements are brought into view. Results of mood monitoring can contribute to the process of outcome studies as measures of preand postfunctioning to determine therapeutic effect. Clients learn to assess their continuum of experience, noting slight shifts of day-to-day mood compared with dichotomous thinking* characterized by only a crude sense that “I feel good” or “I feel bad.” After the termination of therapy, continued
10
JOHN R. WHITE
mood monitoring provides early warning signs of potential danger and reinforces relapse prevention.* The most complete means of mood monitoring in CBT is the Beck Depression Inventory (BDI; A. T. Beck & Steer, 1987).’ The BDI permits clients to compare their scores with extensive normative samples as well as to assess their depression by multiple assessments over the course of therapy. Letting clients have direct access to actual research measures of their moods reinforces the sense of shared empiricism in the collaborative relationship of therapy. BDI scores, reviewed by the members of the group, encourage the group as a whole to reckon with how it is doing in reducing the depression of everyone involved. To think empirically means to approach a situation as though it were an experiment. Members of the group learn to collaborate as though they are scientists who are interested in setting up favorable circumstances to experiment with their own therapeutic growth.
Arousal Hierarchy This is a core CBT method in treating anxiety. In my opinion, the principle of an arousal hierarchy has been more broadly applied in general therapeutic work than any other CBT technique. Clients are guided to identify the various stimuli that cause them to feel anxious and to rank them from least to most threatening. I explain to clients,
I want to you to think about all the different situations that cause you anxiety. Be as specific as possible. We will ask each other questions to clarify the exact nature of the threat. Clients in group write their own description of anxious triaears. They then read this material to each other not only to share their personal fears with the other members but also to refine and specify exactly the nature of each trigger. The more explicit the better (Barlow, 1993). Once the anxious items are recorded, I say to clients, Now, for each item I want you to write down the amount of anxiety you think you would experience when directly confronting that trigger. Use a scale of 0 to 100. I suggest you go with your first impression and not worry how that relates to any other scores you’ve given.
I urge clients to remain aware of their physical reactions during this exercise as an additional means to gauge their anxiety. If clients start to obsess about this number or that, I tell them that the ratings are only their impression at the moment, and they may be different 5 minutes in the past or 5 minutes in the future. If so, we can adjust the ratings then. When the triggers and the anxiety ratings are complete, I ask the ‘The BDI can be ordered from the Psychological Corporation, San Antonio, Texas.
INTROD UCTlON
II
clients to list the items from most to least threatening. A rich clinical picture of each individual’s experience of perceived threat begins to emerge in hierarchical form. I suggest clients see what they can observe from their process of ordering. What is surprising? What would they choose to change? This may constitute a small breakthrough for clients, especially those who experience chronic anxiety. There can actually be a “more” and “less” to what troubles them. Prior to the beginning of treatment, clients probably felt their anxiety to be not only uniformly overwhelming but also capricious and unpredictable. With the hierarchy, we are beginning to introduce order. And with order, graded exposure can begin. This is where clients determine which items in the lower regions of the hierarchy they are willing to confront, for the purpose of overriding their characteristically anxious reactions. Prolonged contact with the trigger brings a gradual lessening of the anxious reaction by systematic desensitizution. Clients learn to tolerate being present in the situation to decondition their learned anxiety. As they gain confidence at the lower levels of the hierarchy, they can use the same skills to move higher. The group itself can be an excellent setting by which to experiment with exposure to anxiety-provoking situations. For example, clients may experience strong anxiety in response to speaking up, or intermember conflict, or hearing about the anxiety of other people. Successfully managing these stimuli in the group environment then sets the stage for in vivo exposure in real-life situations. By consciously exposing themselves to these anxiety triggers and not letting themselves run away or be overwhelmed, therapy group members are developing the early stages of mastery.* Adaptation at the higher reaches of the arousal hierarchy eventually include preventing safety behaviors and thought stopping (Barlow, 1988). Anxiety is usually reinforced by a number of safety behaviors that give the client the impression of relieving anxiety, such as checking to make sure things are okay or steering clear of situations that might be threatening. Unfortunately, these safety behaviors usually serve to reinforce anxiety because by depending upon them the client manages to avoid dealing with the anxiety directly. The sense of threat, then, remains high. Therapy urges the client to prevent the safety behavior and use more productive means of confronting and reducing the anxiety. CBT teaches clients to stop their repetitive thoughts associated with their anxiety and redirect to a more pleasant thought content. Activity Monitoring
In active monitoring, clients write down the activities of a given period of time, often a week. I explain to them,
12
JOHN R. WHfTE
We want to get a sense how your time is spent. I’d like you to jot down in a few words the main activities you’ve done on an hour-byhour basis. It’s best to do this ongoing throughout the day so your recall is fresh rather than waiting too long. Almost always, there are some surprises on the part of clients as to where their time actually goes (Bourne, 1995). Not only is this a tool to bring greater awareness on a day-by-day basis, but it serves as a baseline for each member to determine where and how to make changes. Activity monitoring naturally leads to activity planning, in which the client can make goals for himself or herself to spend time in ways that are more beneficial. Progress is not immediate and usually involves a process of shaping and successive approximation. When helping a client develop a therapeutic response, shaping refers to the response profile drawn on a graph that progressively takes the configuration of the desired outcome. A client rareIy learns this response all at once, but more likely by successive approximation where each trial builds upon what has worked before and adds a new attempt to solve what has not yet worked. I find the most value in this exercise comes from asking clients to make assessments of their mastery and pleasure in the hour-to-hour activities during the day. I explain to clients, On the same sheet of paper where you have described your activities, I’d like you to make a quick judgment of how much mastery you experienced during that hour and how much pleasure. Mastery is the sense that you knew what you were doing and felt competent to deal with the situation. Pleasure is how much you enjoyed a given activity. Use a scale of 0 ro 10 ro make a mastery rating and a pleasure rating for each hour during the day. This record can be fascinating to examine during therapy. What exactly are clients’ experiences of high pleasure and mastery? How effective are members at planning the kinds of activities likely to lead to a sense of mastery and pleasure? As an extension of this exercise, I will sometimes suggest that clients start each day by making a goal” for a high-mastery experience and a highpleasure experience. There may be initial disappointment and frustration as clients fall short of their expectations, but the therapist can be helpful by continuing to support small and attainable goals. Therapy can be used to better understand what interferes with these goals (both internal and external factors) and planning how to get positive results. Group provides learning by means of modeling, in which members view the mastery and pleasure experiences of each other to reduce the trial and error of each individual figuring this out on his or her own. Persons (1989) described in further depth the methods of activity monitoring. Of particular interest, she addressed a complaint sometimes expressed by clients or therapists that this exercise may appear “trivial.” If INTRODUCTION
13
there is concern that the activities of daily life are somehow superficial, I think it is by understanding the actual experience of these familiar activities that serves as the pathways to true psychological depth. I find that dealing with the real events of clients’ lives through activity monitoring brings a quality of richness and nuance that these same clients had not realized when they were simply talking about their problems in stereotyped or redundant ways. Before a therapist can effectively urge a client to try activity monitoring, the therapist might consider engaging in the same in his or her day-to-day life. I would be surprised if some unexpected results do not occur. I would recommend putting forth the extra effort to make hourly assessments of mastery and pleasure. Does this lead to reassessment of how these judgments are made? What about modifying those activities that are low pleasure or low mastery so they yield better results? If the therapist experiences personal benefit from these exercises, the therapist will feel better about urging that his or her clients can gain from doing the same.
Problem Solving Clients are likely to believe that their own capacity for problem solving is defective, whether this is actually true or not. Such a belief seems especially entrenched among anxious individuals. Group CBT wants to give clients a constructive experience in addressing problems in their dayto-day lives and figuring out solutions. I explain to clients, As part of the agenda for today I suggest we identify the kinds of problems that members are facing in their daily experience. We’ll determine which problems seem to be strongest for the greatest number of people and that’s where we’ll start.
. In the initial stages of the group, members tend to assume that their problems are somehow different from those of other people in the group. The development of cohesiveness signals the recognition that members struggle with many of the same issues. The therapist facilitates a process whereby the group generates &ptiwe responses to the problems at hand. To adapt means “to gain a better fit with the environment” (Bandura, 1997, p. 24). The group seeks to revise those old behaviors of its members that are no longer working and determine what responses would achieve a better fit. Although the goal* of problem solving also applies in individual treatment, I think that group CBT is unusually well suited to generate adaptive responses. The interaction of group members is more likely to stir the consideration of alternatives, whereas the lone individual in one-to-one treatment probably takes more time to reach this stage. Members model for each other how to generate possible solutions and take steps to see what works. Drawing on 14
I O H N R WHITE
role play and rehearsal, the group can generate experiential learning rather than simply talking about ideas. I usually give a cautionary note as the group begins problem solving: The point here is not to find the right answer, because human problems rarely have one and only one ultimate solution. When you first try something, don’t expect i t to work perfectly. Instead, see what you can learn from these new experiences. You often gain the most from what didn’t work out just the way you expected. Take what you figure out, plan a follow-up solution, and see how it goes.
DZurilla and Goldfried ( 1971) developed a problem-solving approach that is easy to teach group clients. It provides five steps that members can practice together. I find a side benefit accrues from group problem solving. After a little practice, clients usually realize that they possess more natural problem-solving ability than they initially gave themselves credit for. These new successes in therapy provide an opportunity to reexamine their old core beliefs” about incompetence. Rather than now letting their prevailing anxiety dictate their feeling somehow insecure about taking care of problems, they are better able to accept new evidence* that they actually manage these matters fairly well. Group members usually graduate beyond the structured problem-solving methods and engage more liberally in adaptive responses in group. Therapy achieves its purpose when members generalize* these practices in their individual lives. Relaxation
A basic assumption of CBT is that therapy would be overly limited if it stayed only in the realm of talking. Because many clients experience physical tension as a component of their psychological distress, CBT therapists teach relaxation as a clinical skill. In my own practice with groups I explain to clients, As part of therapy, you will learn the ability to relax yourself and reduce the stress in your body. We will start by doing this in session, and then you will practice on your own.
Many clients have preconceived ideas about relaxation, sometimes negative in nature, and these need to be addressed. They may think that relaxation is simply “doing nothing,’’ but it is useful to know that it is actually a learned skill to override the physical stress that has taken hold of their bodies. Or, because their tension may act as a long-standing barrier against the world, there needs to be a gradual development of safety in the therapeutic milieu so these clients can tolerate turning loose of their tension and experiencing more contact with other people. For this reason, before I introduce relaxation, I usually have several sessions for members to develop comfort with the group and for me to assess who might have strong resistance to relaxation. INTRODUCTION
15
The classic work in relaxation has been done by Benson (1975) with development of a broad range of techniques. I believe in the value of relaxation for my clients as a direct means for them to reduce their physical stress. It takes practice, but almost everyone can make progress if they want to. A more subtle benefit of relaxation is its positive effect on the therapy itself. Time and again I have observed that clients are more open to therapeutic work as they make progress in physical relaxation. It does not seem a radical notion that rigidity of the body is accompanied by rigidity in psychological realms. I find that the verbal part of therapy often moves ahead when the individual experiences greater physical relaxation. Recognizing that relaxation is an integral aspect of CBT establishes a clinical rationale for related physical interventions as well. Various group CBT treatments use meditation, hypnosis, exercise, and biofeedback. Of particular interest, in my opinion, is the application of these principles with imagery (Lazarus, 1981). Only a portion of an individual’s mental processes are encoded via language. Much of the content of perception and memory are stored in visual form. CBT brings this material into therapy by questions such as, “What imagery is associated with that memory?” or “Are you aware of any pictures in your mind immediately before you had that feeling of hopelessness?” Therapeutic use of imagery allows the client to gain access to relevant mental experience not available through language alone.
Risk Assessment At any moment, an individual is making a whole series of determinations about the relative threat or safety that he or she is facing at that time. During anxiety or panic, an individual has a tendency to catastrophize and see immediate danger in extreme terms (A. T. Beck, 1976). Often these assessments of risk occur outside the awareness of the individual. I explain to group members, You may sometimes find that you feel threatened but are not be able to identify the source of risk. This can be upsetting, especially if you feel threatened much of the time while there seems to be no good reason for such a reaction on your part. In risk assessment, we want to do the detective work to figure out where the actual threat is coming from.
The therapist can provide important reassurance to clients by undertaking this risk assessment with the certainty that there exists some definable trigger, Clients have often been told in their past, “Oh, it’s nothing -don’t worry,” and they probably try to make themselves believe this dismissal. It does not work, of course, because there remains the unrecog-
16
JOHN R . WHITE
nized source of threat that has not been properly dealt with. So clients do not really feel better in the process, and they judge themselves harshly because they are having a reaction that does not make sense to them or to anyone else. Risk assessment helps group clients and the therapist to see what the origins of threat really are. It also provides a reading of the clients' resources to deal with the risks, producing a risk-to-resources ratio (A. T. Beck, Emery, & Greenberg, 1985). Risk is defined as a threat subjectively perceived by the individual. In the eyes of that person, she experiences some type of danger, such as to her self-esteem, her physical well being, or her relationships with loved ones. Other people may assess her risk differently, and this can make for useful discussion in a therapy group; ultimately it is the individual's sense of her own risk that matters. Resources refer to the psychological qualities that a person uses to deal with the risk. For example, this might include her self-confidence, her communication skills in conflictual situations, or her optimistic outlook. In many clinical situations, the clients' sense of risk is high, whereas their assessment of their own resources to deal with it is low. This formula of high risk/low resource is a cornerstone of the cognitive model" of anxiety. Over the course of therapy, clients examine the actual evidence of their lives to gain a truer sense of risk and resources. They gain in their appraisal of personal resources while reducing their assessment of current risk. Thereafter, when considering the odds for future challenges, they are more likely to arrive at a favorable (and more accurate) risk-to-resource ratio. For example, a client who is a very capable and assertive manager always felt intimidated in the presence of her mother and was not able to use the assertive skills that she had mastered in other areas of her life. Her therapy involved restructuring" her beliefs so that she could say no to her mother when appropriate. As this began to happen, there was a positive shift in her risk-to-resource ratio in the direction of being better able to handle the threats that she felt with her mother. Assessment of risk and resources can be an illuminating method applied in CBT group therapy. When self-defeating views are expressed to the group by an individual, other members can share alternative views of the risks and resources based upon their more balanced view of the individual. It becomes evident that there are a number of ways of looking at a given situation. Care is taken, obviously, that the member does not feel invalidated or overruled by the group. There is a psychological reality to even the most negative of risk-to-resource ratios, and this needs to be respectfully acknowledged. Besides, it is ultimately up to the individual what, if any, alternative views to take in, so a CBT group supports the exploration of different perspectives about risk and resources with responsibility residing with each individual what to do about it. INTRODUCTION
17
Treatment Protocols
Given the empirical basis of CBT, there is an ongoing interest to find the clinical methods that produce the best results. Therapists are testing their approaches to determine what is most helpful to clients. Over time certain methods have demonstrated themselves to produce consistently positive results in dealing with specific problems. This primer chapter of CBT discusses a number of these empirically validated methods, including automatic thought records,* arousal hierarchy,* and relaxation.* The next logical step from these empirically validated methods is an integrated therapeutic approach that includes all the key elements proven to be useful. Building from parts to the whole, this approach is called a treatment protocol. It typically draws together a core set of clinical skills that guides the therapist and clients in developing these abilities. There is typically a progression of the treatment, and the protocol addresses separate issues associated with the beginning, the middle, and the ending of therapy. In recognition of its empirical origins, the protocol usually provides ongoing measurement of group clients to focus the work as well as to determine progress. The protocol may be a guide designed for the therapist’s use or a workbook that clients use as homework* and then bring to session for review. For a treatment protocol to be genuinely useful, there must still be a collaborative relationship* between client and therapist-which is fundamental to any CBT work. The protocol does not substitute for the fact that clients need to feel that the therapist is empathic and genuinely cares about positive results for the client. In some quarters, there is concern that a protocol would lead to a rigid or impersonal therapy. Obviously if this were true it would be counterproductive and a misuse of the therapeutic relationship. One of the earliest protocols was Beck’s seminal work (see A. T. Beck et al., 1979) on CBT treatment of depression. There have been subsequent developments for special techniques for various populations. Linehan (1993) developed a workbook and protocol for treatment of clients with borderline personality disorder that uses both group and individual treatment. For treatment of anxiety, protocols are available from White (1999) that incorporates the State-Trait Anxiety Inventory (Spielberger, 1983) and from Craske, Barlow, and O’Leary (1992). The use of protocols in treatment derives from a tradition in CBT drawing on a wide range of written materials to assist clients outside of session in the form of bibliotherapy. Bibliotherapy integrates the therapeutic work done in session with related reading undertaken by the client. This practice can deepen the experience of therapy, help the client be more involved with the therapeutic process outside of session, and bring in ideas that were discovered
18
JOHNR. WHJTE
in the outside reading. Of course not all clients are inclined to read as part of their therapy and this must be assessed on a case-by-case basis. Relapse Prevention
CBT recognizes that many of the problems treated in therapy have a tendency to recur over the course of a person’s life. Based partly on physiological predisposition as well as deeply ingrained patterns of old learning, symptoms of anxiety and depression show a higher likelihood to returnparticularly at times of crisis. Accordingly, the CBT therapist approaches these problems with intent to give clients a robust set of life skills to manage them rather than to aim for cure (which I do not think is feasible or practical). I explain to group clients, By learning these therapeutic skills you will have greater ability to deal with the triggers and the patterns that have caused you problems. Part of treatment, particularly in the final stages, is reinforcing these skills so the members will continue to use them on their own and stay on top of the old tendencies.
This is called relapse prevention and is an essential part of terminating therapy (J. S. Beck, 1995). Clients successfully finishing CBT group can be seen to have achieved recovery from the problems that initiated treatment in the first place. I t is in their best interest to establish a strong program for themselves that carries forward what they learned during group. I explain, When group is finished, you should be alert to old patterns and triggers that may signal your tendency to relapse. If this occurs, don’t think of it as a failure of yourself or treatment. Instead, focus your efforts on doing everything necessary to regain the upper hand on the problem. You can steer yourself back into a solid recovery from the problems.
By initiating their own interventions early in the cycle, clients are able to avoid full relapse (A. T. Beck, Wright, Newman, & Liese, 1993). Relapse prevention can be further reinforced by scheduling booster sessions in which the group meets for occasional sessions in the future. This often gives clients a target date so they will keep up on their therapeutic focus even when not meeting regularly. Obviously, the enjoyment of reconnecting with members is also a positive reinforcement to stay on track. For these reasons, booster sessions are seen as a good use of therapeutic resources in a time-limited treatment model (Cummings, 1995).
ELEMENTS OF A COLLABORATIVE RELATIONSHIP A collaborative relationship means that the therapist and group clients are working together to get the best possible results (J. S. Beck, 1995). The INTRODUCTION
19
word collaborate derives from the Latin word meaning “to labor together.” This is CBT’s means of achieving a therapeutic alliance. Clients need to feel heard and understood and must be able to believe that their therapist is genuinely interested in helping. Because this is a partnership, clients should feel free to ask wide-ranging questions about the treatment. These methods are useful only to the extent that clients fully understand what is intended. In issues of disagreement it is vital that group members feel comfortable to speak up. Following are what I call the elements of the collaborative relationship. These are the practices of the CBT therapist that promote the development of collaboration. The therapist who is truly comfortable with the CBT approach draws together these elements in a flexible and even creative manner. Practice is required, as with anything else, but the reader is advised to picture this as a smoothly integrated approach that conveys the therapist’s interest and ability to help.
Agenda Most CBT treatment, either group or individual, involves the setting of an agenda for the session (Wright, Thase, Beck, & Ludgate, 1993). Typically, this is a consensus process including the clients and therapist, and so it hinges on the collaboration of everyone involved. Certain benefits of agenda are obvious. It permits a more effective use of time and helps assure that everyone in the group receives adequate attention. Additional advantages result from an agenda process because members often have not had the experience of cooperating with others to plan the use of shared time. To do so in a group setting requires skills of being assertive, listening, waiting one’s turn, and seeking what is best for everyone. These are valuable qualities to learn and generalize* to everyday life.
Feedback CBT is a feedback-rich therapeutic approach. The therapist actively encourages direct feedback from members, through verbal communication and sometimes by writing as well. This enables the therapist to adjust his or her methods and approach according to what is working best for clients. It also models ways of accepting feedback that have a constructive outcome (J. S. Beck, 1995). Feedback between clients is generally guided by what is relevant according to each member’s treatment goals.* For example, a timid individual in an anxiety group could benefit from constructive feedback about how her reticence comes across to other members. This would be particularly important if she is attempting to use the group experience to try being more assertive or open. Because most CBT groups are goal specific and time
20
JOHN R. WHITE
limited, there is usually not encouragement of feedback between clients that is open ended and personally based. For example, most CBT group cultures would not promote feedback such as “I hate you,” “You remind me of my mother,” or “I wonder if you are sexually attracted to me?”
Goal Setting Most CBT group therapies involve the setting of goals to determine the direction of therapeutic movement. Clients often feel themselves to be stuck at first and have difficulty determining specific ways that they want to change. It becomes important to plan positive contingencies of change. For example, if a group member is depressed and has trouble getting to work on time, he might plan that five punctual arrivals means that he can go to a concert on the weekend. Change is more likely to be successful if it results in a reward for the individual. When therapeutic change involves adjustments that are necessary but intrinsically rewarding] such as getting to work on time, it helps to introduce extrinsic rewards like going to the concert. The client learns to motivate himself by establishing his own reward system. One of the initial steps of individuals coming together as a therapy group involves the members putting into words what they hope to get from the therapeutic experience. These individual goals then set the direction for the group as a whole. Clarity about goals proves crucial in determining in later sessions what is relevant for discussion in group and what is not. If potential issues do not relate to the goals set by members, then there is probably more useful material to be dealt with. Naturally goals are reviewed and modified over the course of therapy. Rehearsal reinforces the strength of the goals. An important aspect of terminating the group is assessing how individuals did with their goals and what issues remain after therapy is over (A. T. Beck et al., 1990). The therapist guides the discussion of goals, but the goals originate from the group members themselves. That the therapist takes seriously the goals of the members, reinforces the nature of the therapeutic relationship. Depending on the group environment, I will sometimes voice my own goals, partly to clarify my position as well as to model the goal-setting process for members. In various groups, I have identified the following goals for myself:
= “I want m
to learn something new in each session.”
“I would like everyone to speak up at least at some point in
the course of our therapy.”
= “I hope that everyone feels they are better off than when m
they started.” “Whatever differences arise, I hope we can deal with them so that no one feels they have to drop out.” INTRODUCTION
21
Homework Most CBT involves homework of some sort. Although there is an unlimited range of what CBT therapists use for homework experiences, what the homework has in common is a sense of behawiorul experimentation. Clients are generating new hypotheses, putting them to test in real-life experiences, and determining the outcome of what proves helpful and true (Persons, 1989). I think homework is one of the reasons for the favorable outcomes of CBT treatment. The more frequently a person practices a musical instrument, or rehearses a new physical skill, or speaks a different language, the more that person will gain mastery of the skill. But if group members feel that in therapy they are forced to do homework, the homework will fail, and they may break off therapy altogether. One of the arts of CBT is guiding people to find homework they feel good about doing. In group, CBT members are typically encouraged, but not required, to do homework. Because everyone can learn from the homework experiences of each other, the more members who participate the better. There is usually not much tolerance among group members for repeated excuses, because other members somehow managed to do the work. The group therapist needs to follow up on homework with each individual because this conveys the therapist’s priorities that homework is important. If members cannot or will not do the homework, it is important to explore the real reasons why-without making it a matter of shame or blame. I let it be known that I have had members in my group who, for a variety of different reasons, did not do any homework and still benefited from the group and made a contribution to other people. But on the whole, the people who get the most out of group are the ones who put the most into it-and that includes homework. Socratic Questioning Socratic questioning seeks to illuminate an individual’s underlying assumptions. For example, a woman who is afraid of experiencing panic at work reveals that she has always felt like an outsider there and a panic attack would be the final humiliation. Therapy needs to address both her panic disorder and her feelings of alienation at work (and perhaps in other settings). Over the course of therapy a client learns how to initiate this type of Socratic questioning herself and determine the assumptions and beliefs that underlie her immediate experience. The CBT therapist guides the group members in a process to become aware of underlying assumptions and implicit predictions of how future events will unfold. By this inductive method, clients begin to discover the origins of their thinking and how they reach their conclusions. Over time, group members learn to inquire
22
JOHN K . WHITE
of each other with these open-ended and probing questions. If there is to be lasting benefit to group CBT treatment, individuals will have acquired the practice of self-questioning to be aware of the assumptions that affect mood and behavior (Young, 1990). I t is in the context of a collaborative therapeutic relationship that the CBT techniques and methods reviewed in this chapter can be effective. CONCLUSION Having gained a preliminary grasp of these CBT terms, the reader is now ready to move forward to the chapters describing CBT group therapy. It will be evident that the authors have taken these basic CBT principles and techniques, and applied them in distinctive manner. Chapter topics were selected to address a range of clinical problems that are effectively treated in group venue. Further attention was directed to treatment in a variety of settings, such as outpatient, partial hospital, and inpatient. Benefit from group intervention was recognized to extend beyond traditional diagnostic categories, to also include groups for women’s sexuality and parent training. Application to diverse populations is reflected in particular group approaches for Latinos and older adults. In the process of surveying the range of CBT group therapy, this book provides description of some treatment applications not frequently addressed in CBT texts-such as obesity, parenting, and partial hospitalization. I t is the intent of this approach to promote the effective use of CBT group therapy and to support clinicians in a process of developing and testing further application of CBT in group settings.
REFERENCES Bandura, A. (1997). Self-efficacy: The exercise of control. New York: Freeman. Barlow, D. H. (1988). Anxiety and its disorders: The nature and treatment of anxiety and panic. New York: Guilford Press. Barlow, D. H. (Ed.). (1993). Clinical handbook of psychological disorders: A step-bystep treatment m n u a l (2nd ed.). New York: Guilford Press. Beck, A. T. (1976). Cognitive therapy and the emotional disorders. New York: International Universities Press. Beck, A. T., Emery, G., & Greenberg, R. (1985). Anxiety disorders and phobias. New York: Basic Books.
T.,Freeman, A., & Associates. (1990). Cognitive therapy of personality disorders. New York: Guilford Press. Beck, A. T., Rush, A. J., Shaw, B. F., & Emery, G. (1979). Cognitive therapy of depression. New York: Guilford Press. Beck, A.
INTRODUCTION
23
Beck, A. T., & Steer, R. A. (1987). Manual for the Revised Beck Depression Inventory. San Antonio, TX: Psychological Corporation. Beck, A. T., Wright, E W., Newman, C. E, & Liese, B. (1993). Cognitive therapy of substance abuse. New York: Guilford Press. Beck, J. S. (1995). Cognitive therapy: Basics and beyond. New York: Guilford Press. Benson, H. (1975). The relaxation response. New York: Morrow. Bourne, E. J. (1995). The anxiety and phobia workbook (2nd ed.). Oakland, CA: New Harbinger. Burns, D. D. (1980). Feeling good: The new mood therapy. New York: William Morrow. Clark, D. (1989). Anxiety states. In K. Hawton, P. M. Salkovskis, J. Kirk, & D. Clark (Eds.), Cognitive behavior therapy for psychiatric problems (pp. 52-96). Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.
M. G., Barlow, D. H., & O’Leary, T. A. (1992). Mastery of your anxiety and worry: Client workbook. San Antonio, TX: Graywind.
Craske,
Cummings, N. (1995). Focused psychotherapy. New York: Brunner/Mazel. DZurilla, T. I., &a Goldfried, M. R. (1971). Problem solving and behavior modification. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 78, 107-126. Greenberger, D., & Padesky, C. (1995). Mind over mood: Change how you feel by changing the way you think. New York: Guilford Press. Lazarus, A. A. (1981). The pactice of multimodal therapy: Systematic, comprehensive, and effective therapy. New York: McGraw-Hill. Lazarus, A. A. ( 1997). Brief but comprehensive psychotherapy: The multimodal way. New York: Springer. Linehan, M. M. (1993). Skills training manual for treatment of borderline personality disorder. New York: Guilford Press. Mahoney, M. (1991). Human change processes: The scientific foundations of psychotherapy. New York: Basic Books. Fanning, P. (1997). Thoughts and feelings: Taking control McKay, M., Davis, M., of your moods and your life. Oakland, CA: New Harbinger. Meichenbaum, D. ( 1974). Cognitive-behavior modification: An integrative approach. New York: Plenum Press. Persons, J. (1989). Cognitive therapy in practice: A case formulation approach. New York: Norton. Spielberger, C. D. (1983). State-Trait Anxiety Inventory. Palo Alto, CA: Mind Garden. Walen, S. R., DiGiuseppe, R., & Dryden, W. (1992). A practitioner’s guide to rational-emotive therapy (2nd ed.). New York: Oxford University Press.
24
l O H N R . WHITE
White, J. ( 1999). Overcoming generalized anxiety disorder: Therapist potocol. Oakland, CA: New Harbinger. Wright, J. H., Thase, M. E., Beck, A. T., & Ludgate, J. W. (Eds.). (1993). Cognitive therapy with inpatients: Developing a cognitive milieu. New York: Guilford. Young, J. (1990). Cognitive therapy for personality disorders: A schema-focused approach. Sarasota, FL: Professional Resource Exchange.
INTRODUCTION
25
DEPRESSION JOHN R. WHITE
Psychological depression is the most prevalent problem addressed by psychological treatment. The National Comorbidity Survey determined a prevalence estimate of 17.1% for lifetime major depression (Blazer, Kessler, McConagle, & Swartz, 1994). According to the National Institute of Mental Health, an estimated 17.4 million adult Americans experience some form of depression (major depression, bipolar disorder, or dysthymia) during any 1-year period (M. Strock, personal communication, April 17, 1998; see also American Psychological Association, 1996). O n the basis of his early research predicting suicidal risk, Aaron Beck (1964) developed cognitive therapy for treatment of depression as a structured, short-term, present-oriented method, directed toward solving current problems by means of modifying dysfunctional thinking and behavior. The key to Beck’s understanding of depression was his focus on the prevailing experiences of helplessness and hopelessness-cognitive belief structures that are quite responsive to the cognitive therapy proposed by A. Beck, Rush, Shaw, and Emery (1979). Controlled studies have consistently demonstrated its efficacy in the treatment of major depressive disorder (see Dobson, 1989, for a meta-analysis). Cognitive therapy as developed by Beck has become one of the major contemporary approaches to psychotherapy and has broadened to include cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) 29
with the contributions of Albert Ellis’s ( 1962) rational-emotive therapy, Donald Meichenbaum’s ( 1977) cognitive-behavioral modification, and Arnold Lazarus’s ( 1976) multimodal therapy. The first published report of group desensitization appeared in Lazarus (1961), who also authored a chapter on group behavioral therapy (Lazarus, 1968). The earliest description of cognitive group therapy was provided by Hollon and Shaw (1979). Freeman (1983) edited the first CBT text that dealt exclusively with treatment of couples and groups, an extension of theory and practice from CBT’s origins working in individual therapy. Lewinsohn, Munoz, Youngren, and Zeiss (1986) developed a treatment protocol specifically for group treatment of depression that included teaching members specific skills, such as relaxation, planning pleasant activities, and social assertiveness. Miranda, Schreckengost, and Heine ( 1992) created a structured week-by-week group treatment for outpatients with depression in a hospital setting. Freeman, Schrodt, Gilson, and Ludgate (1993) provided an overview of the variety of CBT group therapy approaches in inpatient settings, and Brabender and Fallon (1993) compared an inpatient CBT group method with other models. Contemporary group therapy literature demonstrates the utility of group therapy in current mental health settings (Cummings & Sayama, 1995). Addressing issues of time-managed group work (MacKenzie, 1997) and effective use of groups in managed care (MacKenzie, 1995), MacKenzie found that there is greater common ground with topics that have been the traditional domain of CBT, such as relapse prevention and goal setting. It is recognized that with certain populations the therapist’s role and the group structure are adjusted significantly, again consistent with CBT’s empirical orientation to modify clinical technique according to the specific needs of the people to be served. A seminal contribution to the development of this CBT group method for treatment of depression was provided in the work of Yalom (1983), in which he addressed the unique requirements of deIivering group therapy in inpatient settings. Given the shortening of hospital stays that was under way at the time and has continued since, Yalom (1983) observed that patient turnover demanded a fundamental shift in the group treatment. Inpatient group therapists cannot work within a longitudinal time frame; instead, they must consider the life of the group to last a single session. [italics added] This necessity suggests that they must attempt to do as much effective work as possible for as many patients as possible during each group session. The single-session time frame dictates that inpatient group therapists strive for efficiency. They have no time to build the group, no time to let things develop, no time for gradual working through. Whatever they are going to do, they must do in one session, and they must do it quickly. These considerations demand a high level of activity [italics added]-far higher than is common or ap-
30
JOHN R . WHITE
propriate in long-term outpatient group psychotherapy. Inpatient group therapists must structure and activate the group; they must call on members; they must actively support members; they must interact personally with patients. There is no place in inpatient group therapy for the passive, inactive therapist. (p. 84) What Yalom was describing in inpatient settings in 1983 has become endemic in mental health treatment in the 2 1st century, particularly for group therapy. Most settings do not provide the opportunity for a completely intact group of people to work together for an extended period of time. It is far more common that there will be treatment of shorter duration and that people will be joining and leaving the group on an ongoing basis. Therefore, this approach to CBT group therapy strongly endorses Yalom’s principle of the single-session time frame. Make the session complete unto itself, including the resolution of problem to the extent possible, because there can be no assumption that the same group of people will ever meet together again. Obviously, there will be cumulative benefit from session to session for certain members who have continuity with each other, but that does not alter the fact that the therapist operates for maximum effect in the single session at hand. With this in mind, the present method has been used (and adapted) effectively in settings in which a cohort of patients begins and finishes therapy together, usually 8- 16 sessions altogether, or in which patients join an ongoing group with a minimum commitment of attendance, commonly 8 consecutive sessions. A separate influence in the development of this model of CBT group therapy derives from organizational literature and the healthy functioning of a working team. To the extent that people join together to form an effective therapy group, they are also succeeding as a work team whose purpose is to reduce the depression of all the people involved. Senge (1990), in his influential text in organizational development, used general systems theory to develop a model for what he called the learning organization, which paralleled the higher goals of the therapy group. I t is “where people continually expand their capacity to create the results they truly desire, where new and expansive patterns of thinking are nurtured, where collective aspiration is set free, and where people are continually learning how to learn to together” (Senge, 1990, p. 3). Bennis and Biederman (1997), eschewing the antiquated “great man” theory of leadership, provided a case study method of six “great groups” that changed the course of 20th-century life by virtue of their creative collaboration. “None of us is as smart as all of us” (Bennis & Biederman, 1997, p. 1). In a lyrical treatment of leadership, DePree (1989) described the optimal bond between people at work, but much the same could be said to apply within the therapy group, when he stated, “covenantal relationships fill deep needs, enable work to have meaning and to be fulfilling. They make possible relationships that can manage conflict and change” (p. 15). DEPRESSION
31
The present model for CBT group therapy of depression was developed in association with Dr. Aaron T. Beck. I was retained by a national psychiatric hospital system to design and implement a unified group treatment for depression in inpatient, partial hospital, and outpatient settings. Beck served as consultant to the project and provided onsite training. The method presented here is fundamentally consistent with Beck’s formulation of cognitive therapy and would not have been possible without his generous support. For the sake of consistency in this chapter, all of the applications and clinical examples focus on outpatient group therapy for depression, although with slight modifications the approach can also be used in inpatient and partial hospital settings.
CBT GROUP PRINCIPLES Cohesiveness Cohesiveness is a central focus of the group therapy literature; it reflects the degree of personal interest of the group members for each other. Cohesiveness is high when people want to attend the group and look forward to relating to each other. They spontaneously think about each other between sessions. It is the social force in a group that permits members to tolerate differences and disagreements. When there exists sufficient cohesiveness, these differences do not threaten the basic integrity of the group. There is the opportunity to express diversity of experience and opinion with the confidence that the group will not fall apart and individuals will not be harmed. When there exists compassion and members feel concern for the suffering of other members, the group has achieved cohesiveness. Unless there is cohesiveness, there is not a group that has formed, only a collection of people who happen to occupy the same time and space. The group therapist’s fundamental task is to build cohesiveness in the therapy group. It serves to guide the therapist in selecting prospective members who are capable of developing cohesive relations with other people. The therapist will explicitly describe and reinforce cohesiveness as a vital component of the therapy group as it is forming. When inevitable challenges and obstacles to cohesiveness arise, the therapist will provide guidance to the group so it can work through the issues and develop greater strength of connection between members. Because cohesiveness defines a fluid and complex set of relationships between a number of people, it exists in no permanent or perfect state. Rather, it is a matter of balance. The therapist is mindful when a group tips in the direction of too much cohesiveness-recognizable when the group becomes overbearing, does not tolerate individual differences, or undercuts autonomy and independence.
32
JOHN R. WHITE
By the same token, the therapist becomes aware if there is too little cohesiveness and members feel lonely, isolated, or cold. It is not long before poor attendance and dropouts develop. A skillful group therapist, in addition to managing all of his or her other therapy work, will always keep a finger on the pulse of the group’s cohesiveness and be ready to gently steer as adjustments need to be made.
Task Focus
CBT is a focused therapy that seeks problem resolution. The group CBT therapist seeks to bring to the group therapy a strategy that builds cohesiveness and task focus. In the minds of some people, these would appear to be contradictory goals. They would argue that for members to maintain a good feeling of connection with others would push resolution of problems out of the way, or that to focus on the work of cognitive therapy would mean no group feeling has developed and “it’s every man for himself.” To assume that cohesiveness and task focus are antagonistic manifests the cognitive distortion of dichotomous thinking and would lead to an unbalanced and incomplete approach to leading a CBT group. In fact, cohesiveness and task focus can be mutually enhancing, and the therapist seeks to facilitate movement from one to the other. When, for example, there has been an emotional group experience that reinforces the empathic connection between members, the therapist might ask, “How does this closer feeling help people make progress in dealing with your depression and moving ahead with your therapeutic goals?” Or, when a group has developed a new stage of task focus and achieved an important piece of problem resolution, the therapist might ask at time of wrap up to that session, “If this is a new level of group mastery, does it lead to a closer feeling between members ?” The therapist is also monitoring when the group gets sidetracked and stuck on issues of cohesiveness or task focus. Oftentimes the means to help the group get unstuck is to turn attention to the underrepresented goal. For example, a group that is struggling to develop its group focus may be assisted by the therapist redirecting and asking, “What feelings are members getting from each other in this group?” There are likely to be undiscovered tasks that are overshadowed by the emotional tone being expressed. The therapist remains attuned when certain members find themselves in rigid roles, representing only task focus or only cohesiveness, and attempts to facilitate a more integrated participation for those people. If a member spends disproportionate time trying to smooth conflicts and make people happy, hoping for absolute cohesiveness, the therapist might ask, “How do you feel about your own progress in the group and what you are getting from it?” DEPRESSlON
33
THERAPIST ROLE AND SELECTION OF MEMBERS Therapist Role
By his or her conduct in the group, the therapist models active participation and collaboration. The therapist is involved with members in building agenda, generating adaptive responses, designing homework, and teaching skills. He or she seeks a high level of involvement of all members, and it is the unusual session when everyone does not speak up in some significant way. The therapist helps to establish a group atmosphere that tolerates individual differences and encourages people to speak openly. By personal example, the therapist takes responsibility for his or her own experience and likewise urges members to do the same. The therapist’s primary mode of communication is Socratic inquiry, which draws people into group discussion by asking probing questions that attempt to stimulate thinking in new ways (see chapter 1). For example, questions to a depressed man recently unemployed might ask, “In what ways do you see yourself differently now that you’ve been laid off from your job?” or “What are your best and worst views of your personal future?” More often than not the answers to Socratic questions lead to new levels of questioning, a process that becomes an important skill for members to acquire in their own selfexploration outside of the group. As the exploration of automatic thoughts (see chapter 1) moves into the deeper levels of belief, usually common themes emerge that approach the scope of universal experience. Who could not, for instance, acknowledge feelings related to core beliefs of being unloved or identify with the sense of feeling incompetent? In this process, the CBT group therapist is more likely to refer “us” and “our” issues rather than to “you” members with “your” problems. Whereas obviously the therapist does not disclose personal history inappropriately, the therapist is willing to convey his or her familiarity with the therapeutic struggle and personal knowledge of dealing with depression. Such is the true nature of the collaborative relationship that is central to CBT, It is not uncommon for members to wonder aloud whether the therapist uses CBT methods in his or her personal life. After all, because the therapist is urging members to do thought records (discussed in chapter 1) on a regular basis to deal with triggering events, would it not be sensible for the therapist to make use of the same? Any therapist gains solid credibility when it is evident the therapist lives the way that he or she practices. I have chosen to think of the role of CBT therapist as akin to the director of a film or the conductor of an orchestra. Similar to the director and the conductor in these artistic venues, the therapist guides a creative process produced by other people. In these roles, the therapist seeks to elicit from the actors or the musicians their best performances, but with
34
JOHN R . WHITE
the notable paradox that the film director appears exclusively off camera and the orchestra director is the only one on stage who does not play a note. The therapist’s best contribution occurs when members are creating their own therapy. I t is usually not the words of the therapist that are the most memorable over the course of a group treatment. The role of director can be enhanced in the therapy group if the therapist chooses to do the group from a standing position. Although entirely optional, there is the obvious benefit to the therapist in being able to write group notes on an upright board (the joke about the cognitive therapist who could not talk if he could not write seems to be true). There is a more subtle advantage owing to the fact that a roomful of people with depression tends to be low in energy. The therapist who stands and moves can bring physical activity into the group milieu that encourages members to expand their own energy level. As the therapist steps forward to elicit a statement from an individual in the group, then turns to write those comments on the board, then moves laterally to talk with another individual, he or she can better guide the pace and direction of dialogue (again, as a director might). Not all therapists would be comfortable standing and moving during therapy group, but it might be worth experimenting with this limited aspect of charismatic leadership. Selection In selecting people to join a CBT group therapy, the therapist’s intent is to bring in those who would benefit from this mode of treatment and who would make a contribution to the experience of other members in the group. It is recommended that there be at least one evaluation session in which the prospective member meets individually with a clinician to determine if group therapy would be a good fit. This evaluation would assess the extent of clinical depression and, most importantly, determine if there is active suicidal ideation. If present, that individual would need to be treated on an urgent basis, with evaluation for crisis intervention, medication, or psychiatric hospitalization. It would obviously be inappropriate to refer an actively suicidal person to an outpatient group therapy. This is a crucial determination for the safety of all individuals involved and so requires one-on-one evaluation with a clinician prior to referring to group. Clinical systems that perform only a telephone screening to refer to a depression group or simply publicize the beginning of a group and have people present themselves are failing this clinical and legal responsibility. It is debatable whether these alternative referral practices would be suitable for diagnostic categories other than depression, but it is certainly not for this population given that suicidal potential is a perennial danger. Active suicidal ideation is the primary exclusion criterion of CBT outpatient group therapy. Others include current and untreated chemical DEPRESSlON
35
dependency or current psychosis. Given the nature of these clinical problems, they require immediate attention before treatment of depression can begin. It would be a disservice to the individual to confound his or her treatment by beginning group therapy for depression without first addressing the more urgent needs. It would be an equal disservice to the members of a depression group to admit a member whose active chemical dependency or active psychosis was going to disrupt the cohesiveness or the task focus of the group. Depending on the skill level of the therapist and the nature of the how the group is composed, it is possible to consider inclusion of members who have past suicidal ideation, chemical dependency, or psychosis, as long as these issues have been properly treated and do not constitute a current problem. There can be good value and positive mutual influence, for example, for a member who is participating in the CBT group treatment for depression who is also active in his or her recovery from substance abuse. There are a number of parallels between CBT and treatment of addictions, including identifying triggers, determining the chain of thought that permits impulsive action, and taking active steps for relapse prevention (Beck, Wright, Newman, & Liese, 1993). The process of determining who will be given the opportunity to join CBT group therapy for depression comprises only half of the selection process. No less important is whether the appropriate individuals elect to join group treatment once it has been offered to them. When the clinician makes a determination that an individual would be a good fit for group, a prime factor determining whether that person elects to join the group depends on the influence of the clinician. Can the clinician speak with firsthand knowledge about the effectiveness of group therapy? Can the clinician knowledgeably address questions or concerns about group treatment that might be raised by a prospective member? Does the clinician actually lead groups himself or herself and convey a positive belief in this work? These are all factors that influence whether the person who could benefit from group therapy actually chooses to be in group therapy. It is obviously preferred if a prospective member is not “forced” into group therapy as the only treatment available. Otherwise there would be referrals of inappropriate cases (such as people who are actively suicidal, chemically dependent, or psychotic). And people who might be appropriate could rightfully resent that they are given no choice as to the type of treatment they receive, thereby undercutting the benefit they would accept from therapy. While the referring clinician may recommend group treatment (perhaps, even strongly), the final decision ought to remain with the individual client. It is on this basis that a solid group therapy program can be built that works hard to maintain the voluntary participation of all individuals involved. When members drop out of group, it usually results from a failure of selection, or treatment, or both. This approach to CBT group therapy for
36
JOHN R . WHfTE
depression seeks to reduce dropouts to a minimum. When even one member drops out of group, that individual probably had a negative therapeutic experience and will be less likely to seek alternative treatment for his or her depression. The group suffers, too, when cohesiveness is broken with the member’s departure and there is no opportunity to resolve the rupture. This is why a ground rule for CBT group therapy asks any member to speak up when he or she is not satisfied with the group or is thinking of dropping out. I t is hoped that such a discussion could resolve the individual’s difficulties with the group, which likely mirror the dissatisfactions experienced by other members that have not yet been voiced. If a member misses a session without prior notification, the therapist makes a policy to contact the individual. Although it remains that person’s choice whether to drop out, the therapist would prefer to discuss the issues to see if they can be settled in the group or at least to determine whether alternative treatments would be more appropriate. If the decision is to drop out, and with that individual’s permission, the therapist conveys to the group at the next session the reasons for the dropout because this is rightly a group issue and should be open to discussion, usually brief. The members typically want to know if the person who dropped out is okay and whether he or she is in some other type of therapy. Responding to these questions helps the remaining members gain closure with the individual who has left the group and reestablish a sense of cohesiveness. STRUCTURE AND CONTENT OF GROUP SESSIONS Session Part 1 : Check-In
At the beginning of each session, group members check in by sharing significant developments of the week, reporting on changes in their depression and recovery, and relating what was interesting from their homework experiences (see chapter 1). Members are typically pleased to see each other, and this segment serves to reestablish cohesiveness of the group as carried forward from the previous week. Homework design will be described in detail below, but this check-in is essential in making sure that homework experience on one’s own is brought back to the members and becomes part of the ongoing group discussion. The check-in occupies about 20 minutes, and the therapist monitors the session to ensure that everyone has an opportunity to speak. Session Part 2: Agenda The practice of CBT recognizes that wise use of time is vital in therapy as well as in life. Most individual CBT treatment protocols involve DEPRESSION
37
the patient and the therapist collaborating to establish a flexible agenda for each session (see chapter 1). The same is true for group CBT treatment of depression as the therapist guides members to determine for themselves what is going to be the best use of available time. Skillful development of agenda facilitates the feeling of cohesiveness as members collaborate to determine what is most important to talk about. As much as possible, these decisions are made by consensus. Members gain in a sense of power as they determine the content of their group and learn skills of setting an agenda in their own lives and joining with other people to do the same. The agenda process, as detailed in the example below, occupies approximately 20 minutes, but it typically takes less time over the course of treatment as members become familiar with each other and the process itself.
Clinical Vignette: Generating the Agenda In an early session of group therapy, members were guided in their first experie:nce developing an agenda to determine what they were going to work on that day. The therapist explained, “I’d like to begin by getting a sense of the kinds of automatic thoughts that are troubling to the people here. Let’s build a list of at least one automatic thought for each person, and then we’ll determine which one is strongest for the greatest number of people, and that will be the focus of our therapy today.’’ The therapist then asked the members to review aloud what they had learned about automatic thoughts. Various members responded: “They are statements we make to ourselves about ourselves, our world, or our future.” “Strong automatic thoughts go with strong feelings.” “They tend to be outside our awareness, like hiding in the shadows or behind the curtain.” “Automatic thoughts just seem to pop into my head.” “They go really fast, more than 90 miles an hour.” “Once you recognize it, you realize you’ve had that thought ten thousand times before.” Periodic rehearsal of CBT terms helps reinforce these ideas in the minds of members and puts the material in the domain of group experience and language more effectively than would a therapist’s lecture on the same topic. The therapist initiated the agenda process by saying, “We are going to use a democratic vote to determine which of these thoughts we will work with today. In a moment we will go around the room for each automatic thought, and I’ll ask people to raise their hands if they can personally relate to it. You may vote for one of the thoughts, or some of them, or all of them.” The therapist recorded the vote count beside each written thought. The minimum was two votes (in fact, it is rare for a thought to have fewer than two votes). The highest vote count was an item that was endorsed by all members of the group: “I will never be normal.” This became the target thought of the group’s focus for the remainder of the session. Every member had a strong personal stake in working through this
38
JOHN R. WHITE
thought; no one was an outsider. A n agenda properly generated by the members transcends a group model of serial individual therapy with spectators, which is not group therapy in the true sense. From this point forward in the session, there was a discernible increase in cohesiveness because the members were joined together by what they experienced in common. Although each individual obviously carried personal history and meaning to “I will never be normal,” the group could now focus on a target thought that belonged to everyone. The next stage of the clinical narrative is presented below, after discussion of the adaptive response. Session Part 3: Adaptive Response
Generating the adaptive response is the primary therapeutic mechanism of CBT (see chapter 1). It is a psychological process by which an individual who has been trapped in a pattern of one’s own thoughts and feelings begins to sense that there are real choices and opportunities. The individual starts to feel able to take action when none seemed possible before. This therapeutic process is particularly important in depression because it is a condition that seems to dictate that there are no options at all. The combination of helplessness and hopelessness, which characterize depression, paralyzes a person from making an adaptive response. The more protracted the failure of adaptive response, the worse the sense of helplessness and hopelessness. It is the immediate experience of adaptive response in taking small tangible steps that begins the process of recovery from depression. There is a natural tendency for a depressed individual to say, “If I were able to feel less depressed, then I would be able to make the adaptive response.’’ A CBT therapist would answer, “As long as you are not able to make adaptive response, you are likely to go on feeling depressed. It is the responsibility of this therapy to help you first make changes in how you act and adapt, with the reasonable expectation that you will then begin to feel better.” There seems to be less of a tendency in a CBT group setting for members to rely on the therapist to be the one who is responsible for making the adaptive response happen. It has been observed repeatedly that, when participating in CBT group therapy for their depression, the same individuals who in one-on-one treatment felt themselves unable to generate an adaptive response and took a passive role in their treatment became more active and involved in generating the adaptive response. There seems to be reduced tendency in the CBT group setting for the illusion that an authority figure will step in to make the necessary changes. Given CBT’s emphasis on adaptive response, it is then recognized that asking for or giving advice in the group setting is generally countertherapeutic. To do so would undermine individual responsibility and predispose a person to a group role of “the help-rejecting complainer” (Frank, DEPRESSION
39
1992). The CBT group therapist models the practice of not giving advice and addresses the issue when it arises between members as follows: “We’re not really here to be in the business of giving advice to each other. It is far more important for us to support each person in determining what he or she needs to do. After all, we’re all grown ups here, and it’s not going to be terribly useful for people to be trying to tell other people how to live their lives, even with the best of intentions.” It usually makes sense to members why individual responsibility is preferred over advice giving, although at certain stressful times in the group when feelings of helplessness are freshly triggered, the therapist can be most effective by identifying the negative thoughts that are coming to the surface in the form of asking for or offering advice. The therapist can keep the group on track by helping members generate adaptive responses to that immediate sense of helplessness. “What do individuals need to do right now in this session to address their own sense of being helpless?” “What is getting in the way of people being able to take responsibility for themselves?” “HOWdoes what is being triggered right now relate to your general sense of depression?” The ability to generate an adaptive response in the session is the best way for an individual to gain confidence in being able to do the same in his or her day-to-day life. Clinical Vignette: Progressing Toward the Adaptioe Response After developing the agenda as described in the previous narrative, the therapist asked the group what were the consequences of believing the target thought “I will never be normal.” Members responded variously, “Sometimes I quit trying to get better.” “I feel hopeless.” “I don’t tell regular people anything personal about me.” “I look for others to take care of me.” “I feel sorry for myself.” “I compare myself with other people.” “I become critical of myself.” Members saw firsthand that the target thought, which they all had in common, led to a broad range of thoughts, feelings, and actions. To recognize that there are multiple pathways leading from a single target thought suggests the possibility that members are not forced to be trapped in the one habitual pathway they experience, but could perhaps guide the alternative pathways they prefer to follow. CBT group therapy tries to show its members that practically any thought has consequences, and to gain awareness of this ongoing process is also to gain influence on it. The therapist then asked group members what would be useful in their feeling less troubled by the automatic thought. This was the quiet beginning of generating the adaptive response. The therapist’s remarks were deliberately low key as he or she guided members to draw on their previous life experiences. There is an implicit assumption in CBT that members possess in their repertoire of behaviors much of what they need to know
40
JOHN R. WHITE
to help themselves. Therapy enables the individual to connect the right response to the right situation while feeling ready to give it an honest try. If the group therapist were to approach the adaptive response as a “big deal,” it would probably intimidate members and mislead them to think the process was more complicated than it really needs to be. The therapist made clear that members were not expected to perform the items that they suggested, nor would the group critique whether or not the response would work. No one was asking for or receiving advice. Instead, it was a process that generated possibilities, and then it was the responsibility of each individual to determine which to apply in one’s own personal situation. In the present clinical narrative, the group generated the following adaptive responses and the therapist wrote verbatim on the board: “I remind myself that many other people struggle with depression. I am not alone.” “Feeling better is a whole lot more important than being normal.” “My worry about whether I’ll ever be normal originates from my fear that I’ll relapse to depression. While that would not make me happy, 1 could deal with it. Relapse doesn’t mean failure.” “Who wants to be normal? I’ve never been completely mainstream, anyway.” “I’ve found people I feel close to. They’re probably not normal either.” When there is a proper climate for members to expect that collectively they can begin to make an adaptive response in the face of the depression, their efforts are often remarkable in their simplicity and good sense. In concluding this therapy session by collaborative design of personal homework, the therapist asked if members would be willing to select one of these adaptive responses and practice it during the week. Whenever the thought occurs, “I will never be normal,” the member would put into action the adaptive response he or she had selected. The therapist explained that the point of this homework was to learn what works and does not work while in the process of responding to automatic thoughts. It is not expected that anyone would achieve a complete resolution. The benefit of the experience for the group is for members to generate a number of the possibilities, test them in real-life situations, and share the results with each other in the next session. From this discussion, members can gain a deeper understanding of adaptive responses and refine their methods for subsequent weeks. By the time members had progressed from generating adaptive responses to designing homework, the mood of the group had shifted from somber to feeling hopeful as it faced a challenge that now seemed manageable. Session Part
4: Homework
Therapeutic homework attempts to put into action what was discussed in session. It seeks to integrate therapy and regular life, thereby making therapy more practical and one’s life more amenable to the positive DEPRESSlON
41
influences of treatment. CBT recognizes that therapeutic progress requires both talking and doing. Each member in the group designs homework that will be relevant to his or her progress in therapy and what needs to be practiced and learned next. Most frequently, homework arises from an individual selecting some aspect of adaptive response generated by the group and deciding how to apply it in his or her personal life in the ensuing week. The therapist and the other members can provide feedback when homework is initially discussed, but the final design and follow-through for homework rests fundamentally with the individual. The group is a good place to explore “negatives” that might emerge in the midst of homework and problem solve ahead of time during session so these factors do not undermine or derail the work. Homework is particularly valuable in a group setting because of the opportunity to learn from the experience of a variety of people. Sometimes it seems that members learn as much, if not more so, from the homework experience of other people than with their own. If homework is to be used in CBT, it is crucial to check up on the homework in the next session. By this method, the results of homework are integrated back into the group experience and signals to each individual that the homework is sufficiently important to follow up on it. The discussion of homework usually involves what worked, what did not, what can be learned from the experience, and what could be done next. The purpose of homework is to learn from new experience, not to perform any given task “correctly.” One probably learns more from what turns out in unexpected fashion. If all homework turns out exactly as planned, it probably means that the homework was too easy or too safe. Homework in CBT group therapy for depression is encouraged but not required. Because homework is successful to the extent that it is designed and carried out by the individual, to make it an issue of control or compliance would violate the principle of autonomy. Homework is encouraged on the basis that it helps people get better sooner and because members often learn a considerable amount from the homework experiences of other people. A certain positive momentum develops in a group when members generate homework at the end of one session, encourage each other to follow through during the week, and then check in on the experience in the following session. Homework models a self-initiative and healthy discipline, both of which are often lacking in the midst of a clinical depression. Part of the reason for the favorable outcome measures of CBT may derive from the simple fact that in doing homework individuals are putting more effort into their therapy, and, as in most endeavors, harder work usually yields better results. Practically all CBT therapies teach individuals how to complete an automatic thought record, a one-page structured inquiry to determine the key elements of the thoughts, feelings, and actions at a given moment in
42
JOHN R. WHITE
time. I t is the written equivalent of what Beck called the cognitive probe (Beck, 1976): “What is going through your mind right now?” (see chapter 1). This approach to CBT group therapy teaches members the automatic thought record in the second session and uses it regularly in homework for the duration of treatment. It proves to be helpful when members are facing troubling thoughts or feelings during the week and want to gain a greater understanding of what has been triggered. It becomes a written record that can be useful in reconstructing the internal details of what happened, such as during check-in of the next session. The other application of the thought record in group therapy is for members to use it while attempting new adaptive responses in order to pay close attention to one’s cognitive process while putting into action this different experience. Practicing self-reflection during the process of change deepens what one can learn about the adaptive response. This approach to CBT group also suggests as part of homework that members use a mastery and pleasure record (see chapter 1). In this onepage sheet, the individual is asked to generate a 1-day mastery goal, a pleasure goal, and then to evaluate what has been the high and low experiences of mastery and pleasure during that day. There is obvious value in members planning such activities on a daily basis and then paying close attention to what happens with their experience of mastery and pleasure. Not surprisingly, depression often undermines the sense of mastery, pleasure, or both regardless of what the individual has done. The more this tendency to undermine oneself is brought into plain view, as recorded in daily mastery and pleasure records, the more negative effects of the depression can begin to be challenged and turned aside. There could hardly be a better predictor of long-term mental health than a rich ongoing experience of mastery and pleasure, as defined on one’s own terms. Clinical Vignette: “Resisting” Homework
In the fourth session of the group, while checking in on homework completed from the week before, two members indicated they had not done the homework. Each person was willing to discuss and explore the reasons, understanding they would not be grilled. The therapist asked, “At one of the moments when you considered doing the homework and decided not to, what were your underlying thoughts at the time?” The first member, Mike, responded, “I didn’t feel it would do any good.’’ Asked for his definition of good, he answered, “To feel good, significantly better than when I started.” The therapist then asked Mike to explore the downstream consequences in his thoughts and actions for the pattern he had described. “Well, I didn’t do the homework, and I felt the same, not better and not worse. Being in the session now and listening to other people talk about what they learned from their homework experience, I get the DEPRESSION
43
feeling that I’m being left behind. They’re getting ahead and I’m not. I feel a little out of it.” Mike was then asked what would happen if this trend continued. “I’d probably drop out. I’d feel I failed and I had lost an opportunity.” The therapist addressed the other group members to determine who else could relate to the automatic thought, “The homework won’t do any good.” The majority of members indicated that they, too, had experienced the same thought at some point during the week. Asked how they responded to it at the time, they provided various answers: “I figured I’d try it anyway, I didn’t have anything to lose.” “Because the therapist said it would be helpful to me, I would do it and see how I felt later on.” “I know that my depression makes me negative to practically everything. If I don’t do something different, I’ll stay depressed.” Once the topic had been broached, most of the members experienced at least transient doubts whether homework would make them feel better. Those who were able to complete the homework found ways not to be immobilized by their doubts. The doubts themselves were not the problem, rather how one responded to the doubts. Mike concluded, “I’m not as weird as I thought I was. Other people can relate to my negative thoughts, and I don’t feel as left behind as I did at first.” The group was asked to generate adaptive responses for occasions when members of the group may experience significant doubts about future homework. “I’ll try to do a thought record when I find myself thinking, ‘the homework won’t do any good.”’ “I’ll focus on alternative beliefs that I can get something valuable from the homework. It helps if I review the evidence of what I’ve learned in the past.” “I’ll adjust my homework to smaller and more manageable tasks. I don’t have to accomplish everything all at once.” “I’ll downsize how much improvement I expect. It will take a while before I’m well.” “I’ll call other members of the group during the week when I feel doubts to get support and encouragement in attempting my homework.” The group members wrote down these adaptive responses and agreed to try them when they encountered doubts about the homework. Members also agreed to remain honest in being candid about their doubts rather than keeping quiet and giving the false illusion that nobody had any such questions. Mike responded that he felt more positive about trying homework as well as being reconnected with people in the group. The second member who had not completed homework, Diane, was asked about her underlying thoughts at one of the moments when she considered giving it a try. She responded, “I don’t like the therapist telling me what to do. The therapist is trying to make me do homework. I t feels demeaning, I resent it. I am not a child.” She said that the consequences of these beliefs were that she did not attempt the homework, and she dreaded coming to the session. “I’m going to get called on. The therapist
44
JOHN R. WHITE
is going to try to criticize me and guilt trip me.” Further consequences would be, “I would probably drop out of the group and avoid future therapy. I’m not to that point yet, but I can feel it coming on if things don’t change. ” No members experienced those exact thoughts about the homework during this group, but they agreed with having similar reactions in situations in which they felt forced to do things against their wills. The therapist responded to Diane, “I’m sorry if I gave you the impression that I was forcing you to do homework, or anything else for that matter. I would certainly not want to be treated that way. My approach is that we’re all fundamentally responsible for ourselves in here, and people need to decide on their own terms what they will do and what they won’t do. As your therapist, I think it is my job to try to work with each of you to help create homework that feels useful to you and that you want to do. But the decision is ultimately yours. Please tell me when I seem to be forcing or controlling, OK?”Diane indicated she felt better about the issue and would tell the therapist if she felt forced. The group was asked about adaptive responses in this situation. “In the future I won’t do homework I don’t want to do.” “I’ll confront the issue if I feel I’m being controlled.” “I’ll check out with other members how they would feel if I don’t do homework.” “I’ll remind myself there is no right answer when it comes to homework, and nobody does it perfectly.” ‘‘I’m willing to say what I learn from other people’s homework and will welcome hearing what they learn from mine.” Diane seemed to have deeper issues about feeling controlled and expressed a distinct sense of resentment in declaring “I’m not a child.” During this session, Diane took no initiative to discuss the personal nature of her reactions to the homework, and the therapist chose not to explore these issues at this time. There needed to be first a clarification that Diane’s concerns were legitimate and no one would be forced to do homework. To have tried to sidestep this issue and move into discussing her individual history would be ill timed and perhaps be seen as manipulative. Cohesiveness suffers when a valid group concern is neglected. As long as the first priority of proper group culture is developed and maintained, individuals will then bring up their personal issues and benefit from the therapeutic influence of the group. The therapist made a silent mental note of Diane’s issues of control and feelings of resentment and looked for opportunities to advance this work in subsequent sessions. Throughout the Phases of Therapy: Goal Setting People who are experiencing depression typically do not feel that goal setting is a pleasant or productive activity. Either they cannot generate goals and so have a difficult time initiating action or they tend to create DEPRESSION
45
goals that are so overwhelming that there is no chance of being able to satisfy them. They fall short in one of the fundamental aspects of psychological health-the ability to generate goals and build hope. This CBT group for treatment of depression seeks to guide the members in the experience of successful goal setting. This is a deficit skill for most people with depression, and group is an especially good venue to practice the new approach and put it to use. In the early stages of forming a group, the therapist explains how each individual can develop goals that are specific, observable, and lead to completed action. Members who feel more confident to discuss goals provide a good model for others who are frightened. In the group discussion about goals, there is a combination of encouragement and constructive suggestions about how to make the goals more attainable. As the cohesiveness of the group grows, the personal goals of individual members develop into the goals for the group. At mid-course in therapy, it is important for each member to assess progress toward goals. Is the therapy on course for reaching one’s goals? Is it off course? Do goals need to be adjusted or added? Members can provide a useful perspective in observing how they each stand in relation to each one’s goals. This view of each other is one of the benefits of group treatment, especially for individuals with depression who are likely to have distortions or blind spots in how they assess themselves. When the conclusion of therapy has been reached, it is important to determine which goals were fulfilled and what new feelings and behaviors developed as a result. I t is equally important to determine which goals were not fulfilled and to reckon with feelings of disappointment and discouragement. How did the members, the therapist, and the group fall short of the goals, and what can be learned from the experience? O n what goals should members keep trying, and which goals should be let go? When the members of the group have a good sense of their own goals, group sessions are more likely to remain focused on the necessary therapeutic work that will attain the goals. There is less likelihood of incidental and unnecessary conflict that does not bear directly on members attaining their goals. There is less small talk or social discourse because to do so would be a distraction. When there is a clear sense of individual goals in the group, there is a stronger basis for the therapist to address and confront an individual who insists on dominating the sessions. All members need the opportunity to participate in each session in support of everyone making headway on their goals. This method of confronting does not need to be used often, but is usually effective because goal setting has been established as such a strong priority in the CBT therapy group. The group’s skillful use of goals reinforces not only the task focus but also the cohesiveness.
46
JOHN R. WHITE
Weekly: Outcomes Measures Because CBT is an empirical method (see chapter I), it involves regular clinical measurement in the form of therapeutic outcome measures. This model of CBT group therapy for depression uses the Beck Depression Inventory, or BDI (Beck & Steer, 1987) as described in chapter 1, although there are other good assessment tools available. Members are asked to complete a BDI each week prior to attending the session. The BDI is usually provided in the waiting room. In the initial group meeting, the therapist discusses the BDI results in some detail so members know what their scores mean and understand the various symptoms that compose a diagnosis of depression. In subsequent weeks, members may elect to mention notable BDI responses, particularly if there have been significant changes from the previous session. Members are provided with a graph to chart their weekly scores to show trends over the course of therapy. Because of its normative sampling, the BDI provides an objective measure of severity of depression that the individual can compare with his or her subjective sense of his or her condition. Weekly assessment can reveal subtle improvements, which can be encouraging for this population because people with depression tend to underestimate their progress in therapy unless they have some objective comparison of where they started. A BDI item specifically inquires about suicidal intent, and another item regarding hopelessness also correlates positively with suicidal risk. These data sources, in addition to verbal statements in group, provide another means to assess suicidal risk (always an issue with a population with depression) and provide the therapist with some peace of mind that each member has answered this vital query each week. BDI results, with the permission of members, provide a good means to summarize treatment status to referral sources, to assess the ongoing effectiveness of the group, and to conduct outcome research.
COMMON THEMES IN GROUP TREATMENT OF DEPRESSION Certain themes emerge regularly in CBT group treatment for depression: loss, anger, suicidal ideation, and guilt. The following is a discussion how CBT conceptualizes each problem and provides group methods for treatment, as illustrated by selected case narratives.
Loss Personal loss is a prominent feature of depression. There are, of course, numerous losses experienced by a person with depression, including loss of energy, of appetite for food, of social contact, of interest in sex, and
DEPRESSION
47
of concentration. These losses are seen as a consequence of the depression and constitute several of the items on the BDI. Equally important are the types of personal losses that cause or lead to the development of depression. These are vital resources of the self that are missing, and, in this frame of mind, there seems to be no way to make up the loss. It is a state of protracted grief in which the individual is not able to properly mourn or to recover. A first step in the therapeutic process is to determine specifically per each individual what exactly has been lost. For example, three people might have experienced the death of their spouses, but the precise meaning of that loss would be different for each individual. For one, it might be the loss of love and no longer feeling deeply connected with anyone else. For another, it might be the loss of personal support and feeling that there is no one to call on in time of crisis. For a third, the death could mean the loss of companionship and missing shared experiences of pleasure. Obviously these categories are not mutually exclusive, but the losses will take on separate and distinct qualities for each individual. Consider, with the loss of a job, one person experiences the loss of financial security, another the loss of friendship at work, and a third might be the loss of opportunity to learn new things. When a depressed person gains sufficient clarity to know exactly what has been lost according to his or her terms, the depression becomes less confusing and more comprehensible. A CBT therapist would say, “We now understand what the loss has meant to you and how your reactions make sense.” As the cognitive aspects of the loss are clarified, this becomes a starting point for change. When the experience of loss has developed into depression, there is commonly a suppression of feeling. People with depression often describe their emotional reactions to the loss as being characterized as empty, numb, dead, or feeling nothing at all. If depression is regarded as the absence of feeling, recovery involves the return of feeling. Group therapy for depression provides an optimal means to bring about the restoration of affect. Consider that funeral customs in most cultures involve a group of people who come together to mourn, to remember, to share feelings, and to prepare to move on. There seems to be a similar emotional passage for people with depression in a therapy group. In the process of mourning, remembering, and sharing, they are enacting a social ritual that addresses loss. Members make personal gains as they offer empathy to other members of the group regarding their various losses. Recovery from depression means being able to care again, not infrequently directed toward other members of the group before one is ready to care for oneself again. If the group has not spontaneously introduced loss as an agenda item by the halfway point in the course of group treatment, it is advised that the therapist raise the topic for discussion. To wait longer would likely confound the working
48
JOHN R . WHITE
through of loss with the termination of the group (see chapter I), itself a significant loss. Clinical Vignette: Loss Following a session in which members discussed at length their various types of loss, the therapist posed the following question: “What automatic thoughts surface when you feel depressed and unable to move ahead in you life beyond the loss?” Members generated a list of the following thoughts: “My feelings are overwhelming to me.” “That relationship was my best chance for happiness; now it’s over.” “I’m too old.” “Circumstances are out of my control.” “Other people don’t understand what I’ve lost.” “I don’t know what to do next.” “I’m scared to try again.” “It feels that a part of me is gone.” Hopelessness was a pervasive theme, demonstrating why the compounding effects of loss eventually lead to the loss of hope. Members were then guided in a democratic agenda process to determine which of the negative thoughts about loss was the strongest for the group. There were equal votes for “Other people don’t understand what I’ve lost” and “It feels that a part of me is gone,” and so the consensus decision was made to work with both. The therapist asked the group to examine advantages and disadvantages for holding these beliefs. The disadvantages were readily apparent: “I stay depressed and alone” and “I’m unable to do anything.” The advantages required more uncovering: “I don’t have to try to get better,” “I won’t let people forget what I have lost,” “If I hoped for more I might fail or be disappointed; I couldn’t handle it,” and “I might look foolish.” If people are having a difficult time getting over loss, it only stands to reason there are strong underlying beliefs and predictions that compel them not to change. Members were asked to identify which one of these underlying beliefs they wanted to change, and they selected “Better able to deal with disappointment.” The therapist explained that one of the reasons a person with depression has trouble generating hope is that the person fears that he or she could not handle the feelings of disappointment if he or she failed to get what is hoped for. The therapist probed the group to generate adaptive responses to disappointment and recorded the following thoughts from the members: “If I try lots of little things, one disappointment is going to be less overwhelming to me.” “I’m better able to get over disappointment if I share it with other people.” “I try to figure out why my attempt was worthwhile even if it didn’t turn out the way I had hoped.” “If I can learn from a disappointment it feels less likely that I’ll have to repeat it.” “Feelings of disappointment are natural. They don’t last forever.” For the following week’s homework, members were asked to plan one new activity that related to their recovery from their loss. For example, one member who was depressed having lost a job and feeling too demoralized to start looking for a new DEPRESSION
49
position stated that she would try to spend an hour reading a technical magazine in her field. As were the other members, she was then asked to select from the list generated by the group the adaptive response that she would use to deal with feelings of disappointment that might arise in this exposure to her field of work. She chose “I’m better able to get over disappointment if I share it with other people,” and she planned to contact her best friend if her feelings became overwhelming. When members feel more confident that they can deal with disappointment, they will be more willing to undertake risk to make life changes following loss. Each member described to the group his or her plan for taking an attainable risk, members offered each other constructive feedback, and a master list was prepared by which to check in on results of the homework in the subsequent session. Anger Most people who are depressed experience problems dealing with anger. They may be anger phobic and feel afraid or guilty that people will get hurt, they may lose control and go into rages followed by contrition, or they may experience a low-grade irritability most of the time. CBT attempts to help people with depression distinguish between constructive and destructive anger. Most anger problems are manifestations of what would be considered destructive anger: fighting to hurt each other, overpowering, blaming, holding a grudge, and never really settling the issue. By contrast, constructive anger is defined as providing the strength to stand one’s ground for the people and principles one cares about, and it is hoped that includes oneself. Constructive anger is a key feature of many adaptive responses when the individual refuses to accept the status quo and resolves to make serious changes in old patterns. The therapist might ask when the group is stuck, “How would you respond to this situation if you had the skills and confidence to use your constructive anger for the good of the people involved?” These strategies could include increasing one’s power, establishing level footing with someone who has been overbearing, or verbalizing one’s resistance to inappropriate use of force. I t is the means by which people establish and maintain limits, and disengage from destructive relationships and reengage when they improve. As constructive anger starts to emerge, it is wise for the therapist to explore among members any negative reactions. There is often a backlash of guilt or anxiety, which can be explored and challenged by using CBT methods. This model of CBT group therapy for depression is designed to keep interpersonal conflict inside the group to a minimum. Because it is a timelimited treatment, there is usually not sufficient opportunity to work through conflicts that might arise between members. A group atmosphere that is rife with conflict is likely to feel unsafe to individuals who are fragile
50
JOHN R. WHITE
by reason of their depression. Conflict, particularly in a depression group, generally does not further the goals that drew people into therapy in the first place. Working on a consensus model reduces the incidence of conflict. Members determine agenda by democratic vote that makes for a decision process everyone can understand and support. Because the giving or the receiving of advice is discouraged, it is less likely that members will feel controlled or criticized-two of the biggest triggers for conflict in a therapy group. In this model of group treatment, a conflict that does occur may be directed toward the therapist. Members sometimes object that CBT uses an agenda (rather than being free flowing), moves toward adaptive response each session (rather than waiting for problems to be fixed), and urges homework (rather than expecting nothing of members outside of group). These are legitimate issues to discuss in the group, and the therapist can demonstrate good methods of conflict resolution to settle the issue in the group and to provide a model for dealing with conflict outside of group in everyday life. When significant anger mixes with depression, suicidal risk needs to be assessed. Anger brings psychological energy to perhaps act upon self-destructive tendencies. Risk increases to the extent that an individual uses suicidal means to express her anger or she becomes so angry that she doesn’t care about the consequences of her destructive actions. When these developments are evident, the therapist must determine the relative safety and danger of the individual, and consider steps to de-escalate the anger.
Clinical Vignette: Suicidal Ideation I t seems inevitable that the issue of suicidal thoughts will surface at
some point in a group therapy for people dealing with depression. One indication of the felt level of safety and honesty in the group is whether members take the opportunity to discuss suicide. A typical clinical exchange occurred when an individual indicated that her troubling automatic thought was “There’s no point to living. I feel like ending it now.” She understood the ground rule regarding no self-harm and was bringing this thought to the attention of the group and therapist so as not to act on it. Once she had broken the ice with this candid statement, enough other members could relate to suicidal thoughts that the group determined to make it the agenda topic for that session. The therapist called on an underlying principle of cognitive therapy that there are at least two sides to virtually any issue, including suicide. She proposed that members examine the advantages and disadvantages of suicide and encouraged persona1 reactions from the members (see chapter 1). Several expressed they were rather shocked and dismayed that the group would explore the apparent advantages of suicide. “Wouldn’t that make it more likely that people would do it?” Others responded that a discussion DEPRESSION
51
alone would be unlikely to trigger suicidal actions. The therapist added that if at some point in the discussion individuals needed take a time-out, they could do so. I t proved unnecessary. As for advantages to suicide, members variously stated the following: “It is an end to pain.” “Sometimes the world doesn’t feel worth continuing to live for.” “If things are never going to get better, why not end it now!” “It will teach a lesson to all those people in my life who didn’t believe how bad it really was.” “I don’t deserve to live.” “I’ve been a burden to loved ones around me.” There was a nervous energy in the group as members shared these opinions. They were taking permission to voice a taboo and breaking through traditional shame and phobic avoidance about suicide. The stated disadvantages regarding suicide were recorded, too, but had less emotional power (such as, “I wouldn’t want to hurt my family,” which is not a reason to live, simply a reason not to die). Each member of the group was asked to select one of the advantages of suicide and explore another way of satisfying that advantage without killing oneself. For example, one member addressed “If things are never going to get better, why not end it now?” in the following manner: “How is it possible to predict that things will never get better? When have I been that completely accurate in my predictions? Furthermore, I know when I’m depressed I have a negative view of the future, which ignores or distorts anything positive. Because I can’t be sure that things will not get better, it makes sense for me to keep trying and see what happens.” As these responses to the suicide advantages accumulated in the group, the nervous energy shifted to a more relaxed and confident feeling. Not only were they breaking through a significant taboo, but also they were finding effective ways to respond that showed that the suicidal thoughts were neither overpowering to individuals nor contagious in the group. A n empathic openness to these vulnerable topics strengthens the cohesiveness of the group and its confidence in being able to handle the challenge. It was significant in this exchange that the therapist did not take a position of trying to urge members away from suicidal thoughts or actions. To do so would have been counterproductive, for it would have communicated her doubts about the group’s capacity to handle this material as a group and eventually make an adaptive response. Instead, she was more effective using Socratic questioning to uncover hidden strengths of the group to address difficult topics and work through them. Her approach of active probing is not to be confused with a passive or laissez-faire style, which would have not served the group in reaching a good resolution. Thus, she needed to actively assess whether all members were prepared to keep discussing this topic. She pressed for the adaptive response in the same session in which the issues surfaced and achieved closure rather than letting the issue drift unfinished into the future. The therapist will have a stronger confidence for favorable outcome when prospective members have been initially
52
JOHN R . WHITE
screened for suicidal potential and found to be safe, and when group members support the ground rule of no self-harm.
Guilt Guilt originates from standards and beliefs individuals hold for themselves as to what they are responsible for, what they should attain, what they are deserve, and what they must do. When individuals conclude that they are falling short of these standards, there is commonly an affective experience of guilt. This feeling state is accompanied by selfcondemnations of being wrong, bad, dirty, or a failure. When the guilt cycle continues unabated, it leads to a widening circle of clinical depression. CBT, which can be viewed as a psychology of belief, provides a foundation with which to analyze the standards and beliefs underlying guilt. These standards maintain power, as well as the capacity to perpetuate depression, by remaining in the cognitive shadows. They are cloaked in authority and tradition, thereby resisting direct examination by those identified as guilty. In a group setting, there is both recognition and relief in hearing other members divulge their own expectations for themselves and how they feel they are falling short. The depressed individual usually thinks he or she is quite alone in his or her guilt, when actually there is notable commonality with other members. Simply bringing these judgments out into the light of day makes them less overwhelming, and sharing them with other people breaks the loneliness. Guilty self-judgments associated with depression usually derive from distorted views of the evidence of one’s life. The negative is inadvertently magnified, whereas anything positive is diminished, often colored by unresolved guilt and punishment from the past. Other members can help the individual begin to challenge the guilty judgments (to determine what is distorted and what is not) as well as contribute their own views of the individual, which are probably more balanced and complete (challenge and distortions are both described in chapter 1). The longer term recovery from depression involves a restructuring of one’s standards and beliefs to ones more congruent with what is currently meaningful and fulfilling in one’s life.
Clinical Vignette: Guilt When members were checking in with homework and discussing mastery and pleasure experiences, the therapist asked an open-ended question whether anyone experienced guilt in these situations. The majority of members answered yes, although they were rather sheepish and puzzled by their reaction. One member said, “I haven’t done anything wrong. Why should I be feeling guilty?” Others added that guilt seemed to lessen their DEPRESSION
53
experience of mastery and pleasure and sometimes eliminated it altogether. The therapist suggested the group pursue this topic during the agenda portion of the session. The group identified feelings of guilt as a common experience shared by all members and set out to identify the automatic thoughts that accompanied them. At first members felt stymied, but there were nods of agreement when an individual said, “I feel I don’t deserve the mastery or pleasure.” Other automatic thoughts followed. “I’ve made other people suffer, why should I feel good?” “I’m only being self-centered and that’s bad.” “I’m not supposed to be happy.” ‘‘I should be punished.” “It’s my fault.” These judgments are typically harsh, uncompromising, and quite effective in making the individual suffer. The therapist directed the group toward adaptive response by asking, “What kind of challenge can you make to these old voices of guilt? Is it possible to stand your ground and not cave in to the negative judgment?” The therapist suggested that to facilitate a dialogue the group divide itself in half; one side was asked to forcefully present the guilty automatic thoughts, whereas the other half was asked to speak with equal force on behalf of the adaptive response of challenge and standing one’s ground. The therapist asked someone to volunteer a personal experience of pleasure and the resulting guilt as the focus for an internal dialogue between the guilty voice and the adaptive response. The exchange was lively with a good deal of laughter and mock vehemence, both favorable antidotes to the guilt-laden affect experienced earlier in the session. Those arguing for the adaptive response stated, “My feeling good doesn’t hurt other people.” “I do deserve to have nice things happen.” “Punishment doesn’t do anything any good.” “Yes, I’ll accept part responsibility for what goes wrong. But I won’t feel guilty for the whole thing.” “My pleasure is good for the people I care about.” “Strange as it sounds, I’ve worked hard to have this pleasure, and I won’t let anyone take it away from me.” After a discussion of approximately 10 minutes, the therapist reversed the roles of the two groups and suggested a dialogue about an example of personal mastery experience and resulting guilt. In the discussion following this exercise] members shared how good it felt to hear a strong challenge to judgments of self-guilt. It was quite a contrast to feeling powerless and helpless in the face of negative judgments. And when the guilty judgments are pulled out in the light of day for discussion, their harshness and distortions become more apparent. One member raised concern that this approach was a “new age racket to eliminate any feelings of guilt and let people off the hook no matter what they did. That would be dangerous and self-deceptive.” The therapist asked the other members if they agreed. A member responded, “This is about challenging guiIt and telling the difference between reasonable and unreasonable guilt.” There followed a discussion that people needed to learn from
54
JOHN R. WHITE
reasonable guilt to stop doing what they are doing. But the guilt that stops people from feeling mastery or pleasure is unreasonable and leads to depression. The member who raised the initial objection agreed with this distinction. The therapist suggested that members analyze their cumulative thought records and mastery and pleasure records to determine to what extent guilt was present. Most people with depression seem to find a considerable amount of guilty content in these written records. Members were then asked to determine how their standards had influenced the development of guilt. “When you challenge your own guilty judgments, do you reexamine your beliefs about yourself? When you have a more balanced view of the evidence, do you feel less guilty?” Members were encouraged to share these insights in the subsequent session. One of the distinctive benefits of a group treatment is the opportunity for members to weigh the evidence (see chapter 1) of what they perceive, believe, and feel. When a number of people share the effort to analyze the assumptions underlying how they relate to the world, there can be a multifaceted discussion. Members gain in their ability to incorporate various points of view and develop a more sophisticated perspective that builds on the additional ways of looking. To be able to incorporate various vantage points is an important skill in general, but particularly so when making adaptive response to guilt. With support provided by the group, members can get beyond acting guilty or punishing themselves.
CONCLUDING TREATMENT Drawing a time-limited group therapy (see chapter I ) to a good conclusion is arguably the most multifaceted skill of the therapist. In the metaphor of therapist as director or conductor, this constitutes the final act of therapy. The therapist seeks to assist members to consolidate their learning and gains in the group. Recurrent themes are brought forward for a final review, especially helplessness and hopelessness- twin towers of depression (Beck, Rush, Shaw, & Emery, 1979) twin towers of depression), as will be addressed below. Members assess themselves in the status of their depression and determine where they stand relative to their goals and expectations from the beginning of the group. For the majority of members, this will be the conclusion of treatment and they will be saying goodbye to other members, the therapist, and this regular venue to join with other people. There is the hope that the cohesiveness that developed in the group can be transferred and developed in other areas of life. Some members may elect to pursue additional treatment after the conclusion of the depression group therapy, and the therapist needs to orchestrate this process as well. DEPRESSZON
55
Sometimes the conclusion of group therapy for depression means that, although the depression has resolved, other areas of psychological distress seem to emerge in stronger manner. Depression, with its decrease of energy, inhibition of feeling, and social withdrawal, can mask the presence of other types of problems. In such cases, successful treatment of the depression brings a return of energy and feeling and reengagement in relationships that can lift heretofore masked problems into plain view. Anxiety is the most frequent condition that exists cornorbidly with depression and, once the depression is treated, anxiety may emerge as a more prominent issue (Clark, 1989). For example, a member who successfully completed the depression group feeling more active and hopeful found herself also worrying anew about recent opportunities she was undertaking. As long as her depression had restricted what she felt she could take on, there was not much to feel anxious about. This member recognized her lifelong tendency toward anxiety and elected to join a CBT group for anxiety on completion of her work with depression. In similar fashion, there will likely be a subset of members who complete treatment for their depression and would benefit then from group therapy for their comorbid anxiety. Given the fact that these members know the CBT methodology and have already experienced therapeutic gains in their depression, they are good candidates to take a strong and successful role in anxiety group. It is useful for the therapist to facilitate discussion about the emergence of these other psychological issues over the course of the depression group therapy so members do not feel completely strange if this occurs to them. If evaluation and referral to another group therapy is to occur after the depression group is finished, the therapist should arrange individual contact with the member outside of group. Another type of follow-up group therapy is for treatment of schema issues (Young, 1990). These are the deepest patterns in a person’s life, integrating one’s history, family of origin, beliefs about oneself, and one’s most powerful emotions (both expressed and unexpressed). Young’s work has identified approximately 18 schemas, such as self-sacrifice or unrelenting standards, and has developed CBT treatment modalities that address the recurrent and dysfunctional nature of these recurrent patterns. Related to the development of group CBT for depression, comparable methods have been adapted for group treatment of schema issues. These include members identifying their own and each other’s schema, determining schema triggers and alternative responses, understanding the adaptive intent in early schema experience, reducing the damage and duration of schema activation, and finding life circumstances and relationships that cultivate the more functional aspects of the schema. Members who have completed CBT depression group and are feeling better may use these psychological gains to address their deeper life patterns in a CBT schema group. These possibilities may be mentioned in the CBT depression group,
56
JOHN R . WHITE
but if members are to engage in a serious evaluation and referral, this should happen outside of group time. Helplessness
It is the pervasive sense of helplessness that was likely to have been one of the stronger motivations for members to seek treatment for their depression. Because their attempts to improve their situation on their own have likely failed, they decided that it was time to seek professional help. CBT group treatment is generally regarded as a practical approach that offers tangible help, and the discussion in this chapter demonstrates that the help comes in the form of members generating their own agenda, developing their own adaptive response, and designing and checking in with their own homework. In other words, the help is produced by the very people who feel helpless. The explanation for this paradox lies in the nature of the group process itself. By establishing a genuine cohesiveness with each other and maintaining a reliable task focus, members create what could be thought of as a “group mind.” This mind is the cumulative product of all the agendas, adaptive responses, and homework experiences that have transpired over the life of the group. Members sometimes verbalize that they can find the inner resources to cope during their day-to-day life by “listening” to the voice of the group that they carry inside them. Bringing a good conclusion to therapy means consolidating the gains experienced by each individual. When confidence that one can reasonably adapt to future life changes outweighs the sense of helplessness, the depression has been largely resolved. Hopelessness
If CBT has truly helped members over the course of group treatment, they are departing group with a greater sense of hope than when they entered. This would suggest that they had resolved issues of loss sufficiently that they could generate a sense of positive expectation for their lives. Treatment gains resulted when members supported each other in generating goals, assessing their progress, and redirecting as necessary. In preparing for life after therapy, members are urged to continue the practice of making goals. This is one of the primary means to avert hopelessness, because the formations of goals and of hope are fundamentally related. An optimal plan for relapse prevention would include the consolidation of therapeutic learning (as described above) while at the same time the individual directs himself or herself in ongoing goals of his or her choosing. The CBT group, which sought to organize the best adaptive efforts of the constituent members, fulfills that purpose when people have learned how to do the same on their own. DEPRESSION
57
Clinical Vignette: Termination In the next to the final session of a group, the therapist suggested members discuss their reactions to finishing therapy. The majority of comments were favorable, and people felt that they had made good gains. These comments were consistent with members’ BDI scores, which reflected a general decrease in depressive symptoms over the course of the treatment. The therapist wanted to provide the opportunity to discuss those negative reactions that individuals might experience but perhaps would find difficult to verbalize in the face of upbeat statements from the other members. She asked, “Does anyone find themselves having a negative reaction as this therapy comes to an end? Are there doubts or concerns that need to be addressed before we finish?” Socratic questioning provides a good method to explore what may be unexpressed and underneath the surface of a group. Because CBT acknowledges one can hold simultaneously a variety of thoughts, each possessing some partial truth, there can be greater freedom to explore the negative because it does not automatically cancel the positive. Taking the therapist’s questions as permission to provide feedback (see chapter 1) about less favorable reactions to termination, members shared the following automatic thoughts: “Part of me worries that I’m not any better.” “Other people in the group seem to have improved more than me.” “I worry that I’m going to relapse and get depressed again.” “Sometimes I think I didn’t learn anything.” “Cognitive therapy doesn’t help.” “I won’t remember anything I learned.” “This group is concluding before I’m ready.” ‘‘I didn’t make serious changes in myself.” “I wish I’d been in individual therapy.” The mood of the group shifted during this discussion and became noticeably gloomy and anxious. The therapist discussed these concerns as a natural part of concluding group therapy and expressed confidence that this process would have a favorable outcome. Even more significant than the content of her words was her positive demeanor and affect, which conveyed she was not personally daunted by discussing these doubts. The therapist used a democratic agenda process to determine which of these negative reactions was strongest for the greatest number of members. The vote revealed that everyone could personally relate to the fear of relapsing to depression. The therapist proposed to explore this thought by eliciting advantages and disadvantages of believing it. The disadvantages were voiced first: “It makes me feel like a failure.” “I would stop thinking about what I had learned.’’ “My view of the future would be pessimistic.” “I’d give up and let the relapse happen, maybe even help it along.” The advantages took longer to come to the surface: “Keeping some skepticism protects against complacency.” “I’m more likely to keep using what I learned in this group.” “It’s more realistic. I do have a higher chance to
58
JOHN R. WHITE
relapse to depression. As long as I’m smart, it doesn’t need to get out of control.” Once again, dialogue on both sides of a difficult issue yielded a more comfortable feeling in the group. As homework for the next session, which would be the final meeting of the group, the therapist suggested that members determine at least one thing they had learned over the course of the group. They were asked in particular to think how that discovery had helped them deal with their personal sense of depression. The ensuing discussion turned into a review of the best parts of the group and provided members a tangible way to consolidate what they had learned. The therapist suggested that members consider taking notes, and most people did so. At the conclusion of this review, the therapist again raised the group’s concern about relapse as first voiced the previous week. It seemed that the worry was less strong this session and that the discussion of the advantages and disadvantages had less emotional charge. Moreover, the consolidation of what had been learned over the course of the group helped members prepare for relapse prevention. CBT group treatment for depression seeks to enhance the sense of cohesiveness among group members as well as increase their task focus in practical ways of overcoming their problems. By developing cohesiveness members experience a therapeutic environment where they can share and identify with each other, enjoy the favorable effects of being cared for, and develop a general sense of belonging. The therapist reinforces group behaviors that favor cohesiveness, such as finding themes and agenda that the majority of members can relate to and encouraging regular participation from everyone. Task focus involves members taking specific steps for therapeutic gains, such as using thought records to identify triggers for depressive reactions and goal-setting to initiate regular activity. This chapter has demonstrated that effective CBT therapy needs to be flexible in developing cohesiveness and task focus. In this therapeutic process, depressed people learn what it feels like to work together for the mutual improvement of each other.
REFERENCES American Psychological Association. ( 1996). How therapy helps people recover from depression. Available: http://www.helping.apa.org/depress.html Beck, A. (1964). Thinking and depression: 11. Theory and therapy. Archives of General Psychiatry, i 0, 561-571. Beck, A. T. (1976). Cognitive therapy and the emotional disorders. New York: International Universities Press. Beck, A., Rush, A., Shaw, B., & Emery, G. (1979). Cognitive therapy of depression. New York: Guilford Press. DEPRESSlON
59
Beck, A., & Steer, R. (1987). Manual for the Revised Beck Depression Inventory. San Antonio, TX: Psychological Corporation. Beck, A., Wright, E,Newman, C., & Liese, B. (1993). Cognitive therapy ofsubstance abuse. New York: Guilford Press. Bennis, W., & Biederman, P. (1997). Organizing genius: The secrets of creative collaboration. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley. Blazer, D., Kessler, R., McConagle, K., & Swartz, M. (1994). The prevalence and distribution of major depression in a national community sample: The National Comorbidity Survey. American]ouml of Psychiatry, 151, 979-986. Brabender, V., & Fallon, A. (1993). Models of inpatient group psychotherapy. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association. Clark, D. (1989). Anxiety states: Panic and generalized anxiety. In K. Hawton, P. Salkovskis, J. Kirk, & D. Clark (Eds.), Cognitive-behavior therapy for psychiatric problems: A practical guide (pp. 52-96). New York: Oxford University Press. Cummings, N., & Sayama, M. (1995). Focused psychotherapy: A casebook of bnef, intermittent psychotherapy throughout the life cyck. New York: Brunnermazel. DePree, M. (1989). Leadership is an art. New York: Dell. Dobson, K. (1989). A meta-analysis of the efficacy of cognitive therapy for depression. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 57, 414-419. Ellis, A. (1962). Reason and emotion in psychotherapy. New York: Lyle Stuart. Hollon, S., & Shaw, B. (1979). Group cognitive therapy for depressed patients. In A. Beck, A. Rush, B. Shaw, &a G. Emery (Eds.), Cognitive therapy of depression (pp. 328-353). New York: Guilford Press. Frank, J. (1992). Some determinants, manifestations, and effects of cohesiveness in therapy groups. In R. MacKenzie (Ed.), Classics in group psychotherapy (pp. 154-165). New York: Guilford Press. Freeman, A. (1983). (Ed.). Cognitive therapy with couples and groups. New York: Plenum Press. Freeman, A., Schrodt, R., Gilson, M., & Ludgate, J. (1993). Group cognitive therapy with inpatients. In J. Wright, M. Thase, A. Beck, & J. Ludgate (Eds.), Cognitive therapy with inpatients (pp. 121-153). New York: Guilford Press. Lazarus, A. (1961). Group therapy of phobic disorders by systematic densensitization. Iournal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 63, 505-510. Lazarus, A. (1968). Behavioral group therapy. In G. Gazda (Ed.), Basic approaches to group psychotherapy and group counseling (pp. 124-155). New York: Charles C. Thomas. Lazarus, A. (1976). Multimodal behavioral therapy. New York: Springer. Lewinsohn, P., Munoz, R., Youngren, M., & Zeiss, A. (1986). Control your depression. New York: Simon & Schuster. MacKenzie, R. (Ed.). (1995). Effective use of group therapy in managed care. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press.
60
JOHN R. WHITE
MacKenzie, R. ( 1997). Time-managed group psychotherapy: Effective clinical applications. Washington, DC:American Psychiatric Press.
Meichenbaum, D. ( 1977). Cognitive-behavioral modification: An integrative approach. New York: Plenum Press.
Miranda, J., Schreckengost, J., & Heine, L. (1992). Cognitive-behavioral group treatment for depression. In M. McKay & K. Peleg ( a s . ) , Focal group psychotherapy (pp. 135-162). Oakland, CA: New Harbinger. Senge, P. (1990). The fifth discipline: The art and practice of the learning organization. New York: Doubleday. Yalom, I. (1983). Inpatient group psychotherapy. New York: Basic Books. Young, J. (1990). Cognitive therapy for personality disorders: A schema focused approach. Sarasota, FL: Professional Resources Exchange.
DEPRESSlON
61
3
PANIC AND PHOBIA ARIEL J. LANG A N D MICHELLE G. CRASKE
Significant advances have been made in recent years with respect to cognitive-behavioral treatment of anxiety disorders, including panic disorder with and without agoraphobia. Twenty independently conducted and controlled studies of treatment for panic that reported rates of zero panic attacks suggest that after 11 sessions of treatment, an average of 76% of treatment completers are free of panic, as are 78% at follow-up (up to 2 years).' The more stringent criteria of being free of panic and excessive anxiety were met by 52% at posttreatment and 66% at follow-up. Two points are noteworthy from these data. First, more success is achieved initially in terms of panic than anxiety about panic. Second, status maintains or continues to improve over the follow-up interval, after active treatment
'These 20 studies are as follows: Arntz and van den Hout (1996); Barlow, Craske, Cerny, and Klosko (1989); Beck, Sokol, Clark, Berchick, and Wright (1992); Beck, Stanley, Baldwin, Deagle, and Averill (1994); Black, Wesner, Bowers, and Gabel (1993); Bouchard et al. (1996); Clark et al. (1994); Cote, Gauthier, Laberge, Cormier, and Plamondon (1994); Craske, Maidenberg, and Bystritsky (1995); Gould and Clum (1995); Could, Clurn, and Shapiro (1993); Hecker, Losee, Fritzler, and Fink (1996); Klosko, Barlow, Tassinari, and Cerny (1990); Laberge, Gauthier, Cote, Plamondon, and Cormier (1993); Lidren et al. (1994); Margraf, Gobel, and Schneider (1989); Ost (1988); Ost and Westling (1995); Shear, Pilkonis, Cloitre, and Leon (1994); Williams and Falbo (1996).
63
is terminated. Thirteen studies that targeted agoraphobia and panic with agoraphobia and reported responder rates indicate that after 12 sessions 50% show substantial improvement (i.e., achieving normative levels of functioning or mild or less distress across a variety of measures), as do 59% at follow-up.z Comparison with the former data set suggests that panic attacks are alleviated sooner, whereas agoraphobia and its pervasive effects may require longer treatment. Ongoing research is addressing the best way to combine panic control and agoraphobia treatments. These treatment developments are particularly important given the frequency with which anxiety and phobias are experienced. The most recent epidemiological data show that almost 17% of the U.S. population is currently experiencing an anxiety disorder, and that figure excludes obsessive-compulsive disorder and posttraumatic stress disorder (Kessler et al., 1994). Furthermore, untreated anxiety disorders tend to be chronic, with relatively low rates of remission (e.g., Goisman et al., 1994; Wittchen, 1988). Untreated anxiety results in serious medical, social, and financial repercussions and is associated with additional psychiatric disorders, including substance abuse, depression, and suicidality (e.g., Markowitz, Weissman, Ouellette, Lish, & Klerman, 1989; Rice & Miller, 1993; Wittchen, 1988; Zaubler & Katon, 1996). Despite the serious consequences of untreated anxiety, between 60% and 92% of afflicted individuals (Angst & Dobler-Mikola, 1985; Pollard, Henderson, Frank, & Margolis, 1989; Thompson et al., 1988) do not receive treatment, perhaps as a result of the high financial cost of psychological intervention. Furthermore, treatment that is obtained is not necessarily effective. For example, of 562 clients with panic or agoraphobia, or both, followed for 1 year, only 15% received behavior therapy, and 16% received cognitive therapy (both of which have demonstrated efficacy for panic disorder), whereas 33% received psychodynamic therapy (a therapy with little demonstrated efficacy for panic disorder; Goisman et al., 1994). This may reflect limited availability of mental health professionals trained specifically in psychological treatments shown to be effective for anxiety disorders, such as cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT). Group treatments are generally less costly and enable the dissemination of empirically supported treatments to a larger number of clients. This chapter describes the cognitive-behavioral approach to the group treatment of anxiety and phobias, with emphasis on panic disorder and agoraphobia. 'Thebe 13 studies are as follows: Cerny, Barlow, Craske, and Himadi (1987); Craske, Rowe, Lewin, and Noriega-Dimitri (1997); Craske, Street, and Barlow (1989); Evans, Holt, and Oei (1991); Feigenbaum (1988); Hoffart (1995); Jansson, Jerremdlm, and Ost (1986); Marks et al. (1993); Mavissakalian and Michelson (1986); Michelson, Mavissakalian, and Marchione (1985); Michelson, Marchione, Marchione, Testa, and Mavissakalian ( 1988); Schulte, Kuenzel, Pepping, and Schulte-Bahrenherg (1992); Telch er al. (1993).
64
LANG AND CRASKE
COGNITIVE-BEHAVIORAL MODEL OF PANIC DISORDER AND AGORAPHOBIA Originally, panic attacks were viewed as occurring without specific triggering cues. Consequently, most theoretical and treatment attention was directed toward agoraphobic symptoms. However, a specific conceptualization now exists for panic attacks and panic disorder that emphasizes fears of bodily sensations (Barlow, 1988; Clark et al., 1988; Ehlers & Margraf, 1989). The treatment described in this chapter is based on this conceptualization, and thus we begin with a brief description of this theory. Panic disorder is thought to be driven by a cycle of “fear of fear,” which is hypothesized to develop in psychologically and biologically vulnerable individuals (Barlow, 1988). Psychological vulnerability is hypothesized to include danger-laden beliefs about bodily sensations such as “I feel out of control when my heart races” (e.g., Reiss, Peterson, Gursky, & McNally, 1986) and about uncontrollability of events and emotions in general (Barlow, 1988). Biological vulnerability is the topic of much research and probably accounts for the strong familial concordance for panic disorder (e.g., Moran & Andrews, 1985). The cycle begins with an initial event in which the body’s autonomic fear response is triggered in a situation that does not represent actual danger to the individual. Often, such an event happens at a time of stress or under circumstances that intensify arousal or are perceived as threatening (Craske & Rowe, 1997). As a result of this initial episode, the individual develops fear of the associated bodily sensations (e.g., racing heart, dizziness, and parasthesias). Fear of sensations is believed to develop as a result of misappraisals of bodily sensations as signs of imminent death, loss of control, and so on and of interoceptive conditioning (Barlow, 1988; Clark et al., 1988; Ehlers 6r Margraf, 1989). Interoceptive conditioning (Razran, 1961) refers to learned fear of internal states as a result of aversive associations. In this case, panic attacks create an aversive association between certain bodily sensations and feelings of terror, resulting in subsequent fear of sensations that signal the possibility of another panic attack. For this reason, activities that produce bodily sensations similar to the sensations of panic sometimes trigger panic attacks. Such activities include exercise, sexual arousal, anger, humidity, and caffeine ingestion. Several features distinguish fear of bodily sensations from fears of external stimuli. First, autonomic arousal generated by fear of sensations in turn intensifies the sensations that are feared, thus creating a vicious circle. The cycle is sustained until the physiological arousal is exhausted or perceptions of safety are achieved. In contrast, fears of external stimuli do not intensify the object of fear. For example, fears of dogs do not make dogs grow larger. Second, cues that trigger panic attacks (i.e., internal bodily sensations) are not always immediately obvious to the individual, thus genPANIC AND PHOBIA
65
erating the perception of being unexpected or “out of the blue” (Barlow, 1988). In this model, all panic attacks are triggered by specific, although sometimes subtle, stimuli, despite their apparent spontaneous nature on occasion. A third feature that distinguishes fear of fear from fear of external stimuli is that bodily sensations that cue panic attacks tend to be less predictable than external stimuli. Fourth, bodily sensations generally are more difficult to control than external objects; that is, sensations are relatively uncontrollable. Unpredictability and uncontrollability have been shown to elevate general anxiety about upcoming aversive events (e.g., DeCola & Rosellini, 1990; Maier, Laudenslager, & Ryan, 1985; Weinberg & Levine, 1980) and panic attacks (Craske, Glover, & DeCola, 1994). Consequently, the unpredictable or uncontrollable nature of panic is believed to contribute to high levels of chronic anxious apprehension (Barlow, 1988) and to maintain anticipatory anxiety about the recurrence of panic (Rachman & Levitt, 1985). In turn, anxious apprehension increases the likelihood of panic by increasing physical tension and, therefore, the availability of sensations that have become triggers for panic, as well as by increasing attentional vigilance for these bodily cues. Thus, a continual cycle of panic and anxious apprehension develops. Finally, agoraphobic avoidance is viewed as one method of coping with the anticipation of panic. Individuals with agoraphobia who seek treatment almost always report a history of panic that preceded the development of their avoidance (e.g., Noyes et al., 1986; Pollard, Bronson, & Kenney, 1989). Not all people who panic, however, develop agoraphobic avoidance, and the extent of avoidance that does emerge is highly variable. The reasons for these individual differences are not clear; agoraphobic avoidance is not related to age of onset, panic symptom profiles, different types of attacks, or frequency of panic (Craske & Barlow, 1988). Gender, however, is significantly related to agoraphobia, with women increasingly predominating as avoidance becomes more severe (e.g., Thyer, Himle, Curtis, Cameron, & Nesse, 1985). Low masculinity scores are even more predictive of agoraphobia (Chambless & Mason, 1986). In contrast, men are more likely to use alcohol or drugs in anticipation of panic (Barlow, 1988). Thus, agoraphobic avoidance is viewed as one style of coping with the anticipation of panic that may be influenced by gender roles and expectations. The cognitive-behavioral model of panic disorder is depicted in Figure 3.1. Evidence for this model is accruing. For example, individuals with panic disorder have strong beliefs and fears of physical or mental harm arising from bodily sensations that are associated with panic attacks (Chambless, Caputo, Bright, & Gallagher, 1984; Clark et al., 1988; van den Hout, Van der Molen, Griez, & Lousberg, 1987). In addition, such individuals fear procedures that induce bodily sensations similar to the ones 66
LANG AND CRASKE
I
I
Precipitants stimulants stress-induced arousal fear-provoking thoughtslimages fluctuations in physiologicalstate
A
I
I
I
I
Perceptionof change in bodily state
I
I
1 I
Fear response mediated by misappraisal and/or interoceptive conditioning
Intensificationof
, Anxious apprehension Hyperarousal Hypervigilance
I
Agoraphobic avoidance
Figure 3.1. Cognitive-behavioral model of panic disorder. Reprinted from “An Integrated Treatment Approach to Panic Disorder” by M. G. Craske, 1996, in Bulletin of the Menninger Clinic, 60 (Suppl. A), A87-AI04. Copyright 1996 by the Menninger Clinic. Reprinted with permission.
experienced during panic attacks (Barlow, 1988), including benign cardiovascular, respiratory, and audiovestibular exercises (Zarate, Rapee, Craske, & Barlow, 1988). Not only is misappraisal associated with fearfulness, but reappraisal has been found to lessen fear. For example, people with panic disorder report significantly less fear and panic during laboratory-based panic provocation procedures when they perceive the procedure as safe and controllable (Craske, 1998; Rapee, Mattick, & Murrell, 1986; Sanderson, Rapee, & Barlow, 1989). Furthermore, there is some evidence for heightened awareness of or ability to detect bodily sensations of arousal in these individuals (Ehlers & Breuer, 1995; Ehlers & Margraf, 1989). Given this conceptualization, cognitive-behavioral treatment targets fear of bodily sensations, anxious apprehension over the recurrence of panic, and agoraphobic avoidance. This contrasts with earlier behavioral treatments that targeted avoidance of agoraphobic situations and either ignored panic or assumed that panic would diminish as agoraphobia reduced. Before detailing the treatment procedures, their efficacy is briefly reviewed.
EFFICACY OF GROUP TREATMENTS FOR PANIC DISORDER AND AGORAPHOBIA Several of the studies described in the introduction to this chapter used group treatments (Cemy et al., 1987; Craske et al., 1989, 1997; Evans
Pmrc AND PHOBIA
67
et al., 1991; Feigenbaum, 1988; Hoffart, 1995; Lidren et al., 1994; Telch et al., 1993). The fact that their outcomes were generally consistent with the summary statistics obtained from mostly individual treatments suggests that group treatment is as effective as individual therapy. Only one study has directly compared the efficacy of group versus individual treatments with respect to panic disorder and agoraphobia. Neron, Lacroix, and Chaput (1995) compared 12-14 weekly sessions of individual or group CBT (N = ZO), although the group condition received two additional 1-hour individual sessions. The two conditions were equally effective for panic and agoraphobia measures at posttreatment and 6-month follow-up. However, the individual format resulted in superior alleviation of generalized anxiety and depressive symptoms by the follow-up point. Another study (Lidren et al., 1994) found that group treatment and individually conducted self-help treatment were equally effective. Obviously, there is need for more investigation of the efficacy of group treatments relative to individual therapy, but extant data suggest that the groups are generally effective for targeted symptoms of panic and agoraphobia. Various other features of group treatments have been examined. Barlow, O’Brien, and Last ( 1984) compared group treatments for agoraphobia that either fully incorporated partners in every treatment session or excluded partners from treatment. Although it is obvious that these findings are limited to clients with partners who are willing to be involved in treatment, groups that incorporated partners achieved superior outcomes. This finding was even stronger 2 years after treatment completion (Cerny et al., 1987). Carter, Turovsky, Sbrocco, and Meadows (1995) examined predictors of attrition from group treatment for panic disorder and agoraphobia that included partners. Completers and noncompleters did not differ in terms of pretreatment severity, although it is interesting to note that partners of noncompleters rated themselves as less communicative about panicrelated issues. This suggests that communication between couples facilitates couples group treatments. Finally, Bowen, South, Fischer, and Looman (1994) found that depression and mastery, as well as number of group sessions attended, predicted outcome from group treatment that combined behavioral and medication approaches within a community treatment setting. GROUP TREATMENT FOR PANIC AND AGORAPHOBIA Described herein is our most recent group treatment approach for panic disorder with agoraphobia (Craske & Lewin, 1994). The treatment incorporates panic control treatment and an additional component specifically targeting agoraphobic avoidance. These are available in detailed manuals for clients and therapists, including Mastery of Your Anxiety and
68
LANG AND CRASKE
TABLE 3.1 Brief Outline of Session Content Session
Topics
1 2 3
Education about anxiety Model of panic, hyperventilation, and breathing retraining Breathing retraining, cognitive restructuring I-overestimates of danger Breathing retraining, cognitive restructuring Il-evaluation of consequences Symptom induction testing, interoceptive exposure Hypothesis testing, interoceptive exposure Causal analysis, interoceptive exposure to activities Management of intense anxiety, processing of worst panic, interoceptive exposure to activities Introduction-concept of agoraphobia Identificationand challenging of thoughts in agoraphobic situations Introduction to in vivo exposure Review of in vivo exposure and common procedural difficulties Review of in vivo practices, design of new practices I Review of in vivo practices, design of new practices II Review of in vivo practices, design of new practices Ill Review of in vivo practices, maintenance of treatment gains
4
5
6 7
8 9
10 11 12
13
14 15 16
Note. From Panic Disorder and Agoraphobia Treatment,by M. G . Craske a n d M. Lewin, 1994 [unpublished treatment manual].
Panic (3rd ed.; Barlow & Craske, 1999), Agoraphobia Supplement to Mastery of Your Anxiety and Panic (3rd ed.; Craske & Barlow, 1999a), and Therapists Guide to Mastery of Your Anxiety and Panic (3rd ed.; Craske & Barlow, 1999b). Treatment normally takes place over 16 weekly sessions, each lasting 1.5-2 hours. The treatment is manualized to ensure adherence by therapists and maximal delivery to clients. A brief outline of session content is presented in Table 3.1. Issues specific to group formats are mentioned throughout the following description and are revisited following the treatment description. The first phase of treatment, or the first 8 weeks, targets panic attacks. The goal of this phase is to influence directly the cognitive and misinterpretational aspect of panic attacks and anxiety, the hyperventilatory response, and conditioned reactions to physical cues. Panic control incorporates four components: (a) education about the fear response, (b) cognitive restructuring, (c) breathing retraining, and (d) interoceptive exposure (i.e., exposure to internal sensations). Education
The first two sessions of treatment are dedicated to education about anxiety, fear, and panic. As described previously, panic disorder is conceptualized as fear of fear, particularly fear of the bodily sensations that are PANIC AND PHOBIA
69
characteristic of panic. These include accelerated heart rate, shortness of breath, chest pain or discomfort, feeling of choking, sweating, trembling, numbness, abdominal distress, dizziness, and feelings of unreality. Steve, age 43, developed panic disorder shortly after a friend died of a heart attack. The death of this friend, who was Steve’s age, left him feeling that anyone could die very suddenly. Steve began making repeated visits to the emergency room and medical specialists on noticing inexplicable accelerations in his heart rate. No problems with his heart were detected. Nonetheless, Steve continued to fear that he was having a heart attack whenever he noticed symptoms of racing heart, chest tightness, and numbness in the hands.
Steve was clearly focused on the cardiovascular changes that he experienced during panic. Although this is a common presentation, individuals differ in which symptom is the most noticeable or distressing. Stephanie, age 20 and a college junior, described her first panic attack as occurring in the classroom. She had been late that day, so she ran to get to class on time. It was the first meeting of the class, so students were asked to introduce themselves. Stephanie was still out of breath when the instructor asked her to introduce herself. She felt herself blush, became worried about how she looked to the rest of the class, and experienced a panic attack. After that, she became very concerned about feeling warm or flushed. She began to avoid crowded situations and was careful to dress in layers that could be easily removed to prevent sensations of overheating and flushing.
Like Steve, Stephanie became very fearful about experiencing bodily sensations. Her fear, however, focused on feeling warm and flushed.
The Nature of Fear Fear is described as a natural and protective emotion, elicited by perceptions of imminent threat. Anxiety is conceptualized as the preparatory state when danger is expected to occur sometime in the future, whereas fear or panic represents the escape or alarm state when danger appears imminent. Observed across a wide variety of species from humans to sea slugs, the fear response activates the organism to deal with threat. As such, the goal of treatment is not to remove all fear and anxiety but to control its inappropriate expression. We emphasize that fear and panic are reactions to stimuli that are perceived as threatening, despite the common misperception that panic occurs from out of the blue. First, clients are taught to describe their emotions in terms of three major components: physiology, cognitions, and behaviors. In other words, each panic attack and episode of heightened anxiety is described in terms of what a person thinks, does, and feels. The following example illustrates the therapist’s role in this task.
70
LANC AND CRASKE
Therapist:
Tell me about your most recent panic attack and see if you can identify what you thought, felt, and did.
Client:
Well, it hit me very suddenly as I was driving to work this morning.
Therapist:
What was the panic attack like?What were the sensations that you noticed?
Client:
I felt like I was going to crawl out of my skin. My heart was racing, and I was sweating. I felt like I had to get out of there.
Therapist:
OK, so let’s put that in terms of “think, feel, and do.” You described a couple of physical sensations, a racing heart and sweating. There was also a thought-that you had to get out of there. What did you do?
Client:
I couldn’t do anything. I just had to sit there because I was stuck in the traffic. But I remember rolling down the window and turning up the music very loud, trying to distract myself. I was also watching for openings in the traffic so that I could get off the road.
Therapist:
So you did do something; you tried to distract yourself, and you started looking for exits. So in this example, we can isolate all three systems.
Not only does this approach begin to engender a personal scientist model, it fits nicely with the treatment rationale, given that treatment incorporates strategies to deal with each component: the thoughts, physical feelings, and behaviors. Next, we give special emphasis to the way in which those three systems interact with each other. For example, when sensations are cognitively misinterpreted as dangerous, they may intensify (because fearful arousal elicits stronger sensations), which in turn provides further confirmation for the perception of danger and an urgency to escape the situation. Urgency to escape a situation is likely to contribute to accelerating arousal, and so on. In addition, we help clients identify the various triggers to their panic and anxiety. We call this causal analysis. Causal analysis is helpful because understanding precipitants removes anxiety associated with uncertainty and helps to decrease the tendency to search for irrational reasons (e.g., “I must be going to have a heart attack”). Also, causal analysis contributes to a sense of personal control. Application of causal analysis is illustrated in the following example. Client:
I was doing very well on my trip. I made it through the flight, and I was having a great time. Then, all of a sudden on the third day I had a panic attack for no reason. After PANIC AND PHOBfA
71
that, I panicked a couple more times. I feel like I’m not any better after all. Therapist:
So you felt like the panic happened for no reason. Let’s see if we can figure out what might have led to a panic in that situation. Tell me what was going on at the time.
Client:
That’s the thing; I was just walking around a museum, looking at the paintings.
Therapist: Client: Therapist: Client: Therapist: Client:
Therapist:
What were your thoughts? Nothing really, we were just talking about the art. How long had you been there? Oh, just a few minutes. We had just walked in. What did you do just before coming into the museum? We had taken a bus from our hotel. We got off in front of the museum and walked up the stairs and into the museum. How many stairs were there?
Client:
I don’t know. There’s a big staircase both outside and inside.
Therapist:
So, I bet we have found the trigger. What do you think of this scenario? You walked up all of those stairs without really thinking about it because you and your friend were talking. Next thing, you were in the museum, and you noticed some sensations from the climb. Not thinking about the stairs, you didn’t come up with a good explanation for the feelings, and your immediate association was panic.
Physiology The second segment of the educational component explains the physiology of fear and anxiety. The goals are to normalize fear and anxiety, provide a realistic explanation for physiological sensations of panic, and recognize the time-limited nature of the response. Fear triggers the “fightor-flight” response, which is the body’s reaction to impending threat. The changes that take place during this response serve the goal of harm avoidance. The body prepares itself to be able to move quickly, to use brain resources, and to minimize the immediate impact of wounds. A listing of fear-related somatic changes is presented in Table 3.2. The fear response is controlled by the autonomic nervous system (ANS). The ANS has two branches: the sympathetic nervous system (SNS) and the parasympathetic nervous system (PNS). The SNS is a catabolic system; that is, it is re-
72
LANG AND CRASKE
TABLE 3.2 Physiological Changes During t h e Fear Response Change
Increased rate and strength of the heart beat Contraction of the spleen Release of stored sugar from the liver Redistribution of blood to the brain and muscles from the skin and viscera Deepening of respiration and dilation of bronchi Dilation of the pupils Release of coagulants and lymphocytes
Result
Rapid mobilization of oxygen Release of red blood cells to carry oxygen Provides energy for muscles Readies the body for action Increases oxygen intake Increases visual efficiency Readies the body to seal wounds and repair tissue damage
Nofe. From The Psychology of Fear and Stress, by J. A. Gray, 1988, pp. 55-56. Copyright 1988 by Cambridge University Press. Adapted with permission.
sponsible for expending energy. The PNS, on the other hand, is anabolic, or responsible for energy storage (e.g., digestion and rest). The fear response primarily is controlled by the SNS and release of adrenaline and noradrenaline (also known as epinephrine and norepinephrine) by the adrenal gland (Gray, 1988). Because threat (e.g., attack by a predator) is normally short-lived, activation of the SNS typically is short-lived. Adrenaline and noradrenaline break down over time, and the body returns to a parasympathetically controlled state of energy storage and rest. Thus, although clients often fee1 that their panic could go on forever, this is actually not the case. A main premise of this educational component is that sensations experienced during panic attacks are based on protective physiological mechanisms. That is, the physiological changes that occur during panic attacks all have an adaptive value (a concept that is obviously in direct contrast with the panic client’s misinterpretations of symptoms as dangerous). For example, heart rate and breathing acceleration speed the flow of oxygen to the muscles that are gearing up to run or fight. Blood flow is redirected away from the periphery and toward the central organs, resulting in cooling of temperature in the extremities. The digestive system is suppressed, often resulting in diarrhea as the body attempts to rid itself of all matter that may absorb energy. Pupils dilate to allow more sensitivity of vision (i.e., to detect signs of danger), resulting in various visual symptoms. Thus, panic attack symptoms represent “side effects” of these protective physiological changes.
Model of Panic The theoretical model of panic, as described previously, is presented to clients. There are two parts to the model: (a) fear of sensations and (b) PANIC AND PHOBIA
73
Scenario 1 Notices some tightness in the chest
Thinks: ”I am going to have a heart attack
1
:
i
t 1
including increased heart rate
I
Scenario 2 Fear reaction leads
of his friends heart attack
rate and shortness
t
evidence of a heart problem
Panic Attack
Figure 3.2. Panic attack cycle for Steve.
awareness or occurrence of sensations. Panic is rooted in fear of physical sensations, caused by misinterpretations of sensations as dangerous and conditioned fear from repeated pairings between sensations and the feelings of panic. Figure 3.2 presents two possible scenarios for Steve’s panic attacks. As these scenarios demonstrate, the initial trigger for a panic attack may be a sensation or a thought. Once the cycle of panic begins, however, thoughts and sensations interact to escalate fear and arousal. Several factors increase the likelihood of the occurrence of such bodily sensations. First, clients tend to be hypervigilant for bodily sensations, which increases the likelihood of noticing changes. Also, many sensations occur because of natural fluctuations in physiology. In addition, sensations may be increased by activity (e.g., exercise and moving quickly), environmental factors (e.g., humidity and bright lights), substances (e.g., caffeine, alcohol, and medications), and irregular breathing patterns.
Myths The final goal of the educational component is to address some commonly held myths about panic. Here are some examples.
Myth 1: “These panic attacks mean I am going crazy.” Many clients fear that panic attacks are an early sign of a major mental disorder, such as schizophrenia. We explain the different symptoms and pattern of onset associated with the two.
Myth 2: “I am going to lose control of myself when I have a panic attack.” Although panic produces very strong feelings, it is
74
LANG AND CRASKE
very unlikely that someone will either be unable to control himself or herself or be totally paralyzed by panic. The purpose of the fight-or-flight response is self-protection, and losing control works against that aim. We ask group members to think about their own experience with panic attacks. Even though they fear losing control and may even interpret past behaviors as indicative of loss of control, closer examination usually reveals that they have maintained goal directedness and functioning.
Myth 3: “Panic attacks must be bad for me” or “My nerves may wear out.” The fear response is not harmful and has a shutoff system to protect the body. Whereas sustained stress has been shown to have long-term negative consequences, the same has not been shown for panic attacks.
Myth 4: “I’m going to have a heart attack.” The most common symptoms of heart disease are chest pain and breathlessness, and the symptoms are most often directly related to effort. Panic attacks, on the other hand, can occur during exercise or rest and normally include many more symptoms. Heart disease also generally produces cardiac changes, which are detectable by an EKG. We certainly encourage consultation with a physician if a client is concerned about heart disease and has not had a recent medical evaluation. Most often, however, clients have been to the medical emergency room, to specialists, or both, all of whom have been unable to detect any problem. If this is the case, we ask clients to hypothesize that their cardiac symptoms are related to anxiety and to test this hypothesis over the course of treatment.
Myth 5: “I am going to pass out.” Fainting is highly unlikely during a panic attack because panic is associated with accelerated sympathetic nervous system activity, which is physiologically incompatible with fainting. Previous fainting tends to be a good predictor of future fainting.
As mentioned, this educational component generally takes two treatment sessions, involving much didactic presentation by therapists as well as encouragement for group members to relate the information to their own experiences. Thus, group members are asked for personal examples for each major discussion point. The group format enables comparison between group members regarding their thoughts, sensations, and behaviors. Most often, awareness of similarities serves to provide reassurance and to reduce fears of being different. Sometimes the group is the first place in which clients learn that others experience the same feelings. Therefore, the sharing of information during the early sessions helps to build group cohesion. PANIC AND PHOBIA
75
Occasionally, group members express fear over “contagion”-that they will acquire specific fears expressed by other group members. In our experience, this type of contagion effect is rare, and when it does occur, is short-lived, dissipating as soon as active skill instruction begins. Notably, the same effect sometimes occurs with self-monitoring. That is, clients are asked to log their daily experiences with panic, anxiety, and other relevant variables, throughout the entire treatment. (Examples of these monitoring forms are provided in Exhibits 3.1 and 3.2.) On occasion, such monitoring initially elicits more anxiety, particularly for individuals whose major coping strategy is distraction. Self-monitoring becomes less anxiety provoking over time, as with exposure procedures in general. Given the amount of information to be presented in the first two sessions, it is important to keep group discussions focused. In fact, group focus is essential throughout the entire treatment. Members who raise issues not directly relevant to the ongoing discussion are invited to speak with the therapist about those issues outside of group time. Therapists attempt to redirect discussion that goes off task in session, particularly in light of evidence for stronger efficacy from focused versus nonfocused treatments (e.g., Schulte et al., 1992). Furthermore, therapists make an effort to equalize group participation by soliciting involvement from the more reticent group members.
EXHIBIT 3.1 Panic Attack Record Panic Attack Record Date:
Time:
With: Partner ___
Duration:
Friend
Stranger
~
Stressful situation: YesINo Maximum Anxiety (Circle):
(minutes) ~
Alone
~
Expected: YesINo
_____ 1_____ 2_____ 3_____4_____ 5_____ 6_____ 7_____8
0
none
moderate
extreme
Sensation (Rate 0-8) Pounding heart TighVpainful chest Breathlessness Dizziness Trembling
~
~
~
~
~
I
Sweatinq HoVcold flashes Choking Fear of dying Nausea __ Fear of going crazy Unreality Fear of losing control Numbnessltingling
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
Note. From Mastery of Your Anxiety and Panic I / , by M. G. Craske, E. Meadows, and D. H. Barlow. 1994, Figure 6.3.Copyright 1994 by Graywind Publications, Inc. Reprinted with permission of publisher, The Psychological Corporation.
76
LANG AND CRASKE
EXHIBIT 3.2 Weekly Record of Anxiety and Depression Each evening before you go to bed, please rate your average level of anxiety (taking all things into consideration) throughout the day, the maximum level of anxiety that you experienced that day, your average level of depression throughout the day, and your average feeling of pleasantness throughout the day. Use the scale below. Next, please list the dosages and amounts of any medication you took. Finally, please rate, using the scale below, how worried or frightened you were, on the average, about the possibility of having a panic attack throughout the day.
0----------1----------2----------3----------4----------5----------6-------none
slight
moderate
a lot
extreme
i dote. From Mastery of Your Anxiety and Panic 11, by M. G. Craske, E. Meadows, and
D. H. Barlow,
Cognitive Restructuring
At Session 3, we introduce cognitive restructuring, beginning with a description of cognitive principles along the lines described by Beck and Emery (1985). The main point is that the way events are interpreted determines the nature of ensuing emotional reactions. Frequently, anxious individuals misattribute their anxiety to external factors, for example, “The shopping mall made me anxious’’or “The humid weather makes me panic.” We stress interpretations: “Your interpretation of being trapped and suffnr-tinn in ‘\,ruc‘L‘6 11.
the .-ALL
mall l e w l c L l l Y L l
L L U U “
v7”n r l tn c v
feel
lrrl
anuinirc” nr “YnrIr fear “L U l l l l L V U “
l V Y l
I r Y I
nf feplina hnt 6 V I
L L I l l l l
LLv-
and suffocated leads you to panic.” According to Beck and Emery, maladaptive cognitions are automatic and involve specific predictions about or PANIC AND PHOBIA
77
interpretations of a given situation. Thus, the first step is to help clients identify specific, maladaptive cognitions. Errors in thinking are divided into two types: (a) overestimation of probability and (b) catastrophic estimation of consequence. Anxious individuals tend to overestimate the likelihood that an aversive event will occur, particularly to themselves (Butler 6r Mathews, 1983). Clients are taught to question and challenge their assumptions and beliefs by looking at realistic probabilities, gathering evidence, exploring alternative interpretations, and considering realistic consequences and ways of managing events should they occur. The cognitive monitoring homework form, which is presented in Exhibit 3.3, is used for at-home practice of identifying and challenging faulty cognitions. The following example demonstrates a discussion that occurred in group after a client recorded panicking while in traffic the week before. Client: Therapist:
. . . and if I hadn’t taken my medication, I don’t know what would have happened. What possibilities did you imagine?
Client:
I don’t know. I don’t think that I could have stayed in control of the car. I might have caused an accident.
Therapist:
What do you think is the likelihood of losing control and causing an accident?
Client:
I don’t know. It felt pretty likely at the time. Maybe 50/ 50.
Therapist:
So you think that there was a 50% chance that you would lose control of the car and cause an accident. Let’s think about that. How many times have you had panic attacks in the car?
Client: Therapist: Client: Therapist: Client: Therapist:
Oh, hundreds, I’m sure. And of those, let’s say, 200 panics, how many times have you felt like you would lose control of the car?
All of them. And how many times have you actually lost control of the car? Well, never. But based on your estimate, you should have lost control
of the car and caused an accident 100 times. So, it sounds like your estimate is an overestimate. In fact, you are probably more careful and pay more attention to your driving when you feel anxious in comparison with when you feel relaxed.
LANG AND CRASKE
EXHIBIT 3.3
An Example of Cognitive Monitoring Homework Triggering Situation
Initial Thought
Realistic Probability
Alternative Thought
Going to work, driving on freeway
I thought that I might get a panic attack and worried that I would not be able to breathe.
8011
I have felt like this, and I have panicked before, but I have never not been able to breathe.
Came home to an empty house
I might lose control, and no one could help me.
0
I have never actually lost control, and even if I did someone wouh probably help me.
In a movie theater
There will be a fire or something, and I won't be able to get to an exit in this crowd.
2
I have gone to th movies many times, and nott ing has ever happened to r Fires in theatei are rare.
PANIC AND PHOBlA
79
As can be seen in this example, it is important to differentiate how likely something feels at the time from realistic likelihood. It is the nature of panic that doom nearly always feels imminent. The second type of error, catastrophization (Craske, Meadows, & Barlow, 1994), involves expecting the worst possible outcome of an event. To decatastrophize, clients learn that worst outcomes are usually relatively unlikely, anxiety and its effects are time limited and manageable, and even the worst outcomes are manageable. Client 1: Therapist:
I don’t like to be in a crowd because if I panic I might faint, and I don’t know what would happen to me then. What do you imagine?
Client 1:
I’d pass out and fall. I can see my body lying there, and nobody would help me.
Therapist:
Wow. That does sound pretty bad. [To other group members]: Has anyone ever seen someone pass out or fall in a crowd?
Client 2: Therapist:
I did one time. What did the people in the area do?
Client 2:
Someone called 91 1, the paramedics came, and they took the guy to the hospital.
Therapist:
So, does it seem pretty catastrophic to think that you’d fall, and people would just step over you and leave you there?
The questioning and challenging techniques are extended through hypothesis testing, which refers to behavioral experiments designed to test predictions and gather more data to disconfirm fearful predictions. For example, an individual may predict falling in the absence of a wall to rest against when feeling anxious. The hypothesis-testing experiment would involve standing away from walls the next time they felt anxious to test whether falling is a true outcome. Similarly, for fears of being ridiculed, clients may test the reactions of others by disclosing their feelings of panic and anxiety. Doubts commonly arise as fearful assumptions are being challenged, and each doubt is based on another cognitive distortion. For example, “Even though I have never fainted before, it could still happen” (which reflects distorted possibilities), or “Even though I’ve never fainted before, it’s only because I’ve managed to get to safety in time” (which reflects false attribution of safety to escape behavior), or “Even though I’ve never fainted before, the next time the sensations could become worse than ever and then I will faint” (which reflects false association between intensity of sensations and risk level). Also, doubts arise from reliance on selective
80
LANG AND CRASKE
information to support fearful appraisals. A typical example is history of psychosis in the extended family (e.g., second cousin), which is used as evidence for the likelihood of going crazy if panic attacks continue. Sometimes fears are couched within the context of perceived consequences of avoidance behavior. For example, “I am most afraid of becoming so anxious that I’d leave the classroom and never return.” In this case, it is helpful to identify and challenge thoughts that generate the motivation to leave (e.g., “I’ll go crazy and scream if I don’t escape”). Finally, individuals often report that they do not have specific thoughts, but rather that they “can’t stand the feelings” of panic. In most cases, careful questioning identifies specific thoughts, such as “I cannot function if I have these feelings” or “These feelings will get progressively worse.” Cognitive restructuring is continued throughout the remainder of the treatment program. Several issues are relevant to group implementation of cognitive restructuring. First, although group members are asked to keep records of all panic episodes, we usually take just one example from each member’s cognitive monitoring forms, for the purpose of reviewing their efforts at cognitive restructuring over the previous week. In contrast, an individual therapist may review the entire form. Second, observing others identify and restructure cognitions obviously provides excellent opportunities for learning vicariously. After the group is fully familiar with the cognitive approach (perhaps by Session 6), we encourage them to help each other identify and challenge anxious cognitions. Sometimes the challenging and restructuring offered by other group members is more effective than by the therapist, given the tendency for group members to affiliate more with people who have experienced similar feelings. In addition, helping other group members with restructuring contributes to the development of an objective perspective, or a personal scientist model. Finally, the group can be a great resource for hypothesis testing or gathering of evidence. For example, the group draws on collective experience or role plays fearful scenarios, such as one client laying on the floor, as if he or she had fainted, and other group members respond to this event in the same way that they would respond if it occurred naturally. This becomes valuable for purposes of decatastrophizing, because by acting out a feared event, clients learn that it is not as bad as they first thought and that there are ways of coping.
Breathing Retraining Also at Session 3, we introduce breathing retraining. Several researchers have examined the efficacy of breathing retraining for panic disorder, given that 50% to 60% of clients describe hyperventilatory symptoms as being very similar to their panic attack symptoms (e.g., Holt & Andrews, 1989). However, it is noteworthy that recent research indicates that hyperventilatory symptoms do not necessarily represent actual hyperPANIC
AND PHOBiA
81
ventilatory physiology (Holt & Andrews, 1989). Nevertheless, breathing retraining has been shown to be helpful, even if it does not correct habitual breathing patterns. The purposes of breathing retraining are to decrease symptoms of acute hyperventilation that sometimes occur during panic, reduce vulnerability to such symptoms, and develop a self-control technique. Breathing retraining begins with a demonstration hyperventilation exercise, in which clients are asked to stand and breath deeply and fast for up to 90 seconds. We usually have the entire group, including therapists, do this exercise together. We emphasize that individuals differ in their response to this exercise to minimize group pressure for each member to continue as long as other members. Obviously, this exercise requires medical clearance from conditions such as pregnancy, neurological disorder, and some cardiovascular disorders. Most often, clients do not endure for the 90 seconds because they become fearful of the sensations produced by hyperventilation. Following this demonstration exercise and an assessment of the degree of similarity between induced sensations and those experienced during panic attacks, education is provided about the nature of hyperventilation. The educational information serves to correct fear-based interpretations (e.g., “I cannot breathe” or “I will suffocate”). The main points conveyed are as follows:
=
=
=
It is natural to overbreathe when one is anxious or panicky as the body searches for more energy in the form of oxygen in preparation for dealing with danger. If the oxygen is not used at the rate at which its consumed, a state of hyperventilation can ensue. Hyperventilation refers to a lowering of the proportion of carbon dioxide to oxygen in the blood, which in turn increases alkalinity of the blood, oxygen stickiness of hemoglobin, and constriction of the blood vessels. All of these changes lead to slightly less oxygen getting to the tissues and the resultant sensations of lightheadedness, dizziness, depersonalization, and parasthesias. These effects are not dangerous.
The next step is to teach “correct” breathing. Clients are taught to breathe from the diaphragm as opposed to the chest, because chest breathing is believed to contribute to hyperventilation. In addition, they are instructed to concentrate by counting during inhalation (e.g., “one, two . . .”) and thinking the word relax during exhalation, proceeding up to 10 and back down to 1 in a continuous cycle. The group practices this form of breathing in session, and then practices at least two times a day, approximately 10 minutes each time, for the next week. There is no attempt to slow the breathing at this point. Sometimes individuals encounter
82
LANG AND CRASKE
difficulties breathing diaphragmatically. One aid to diaphragmatic breathing is to lie on one’s back on the floor with one hand on the sternum and the other under the ribcage. The hand below the ribcage will move more if the person is breathing from the diaphragm. Once the “feeling” of diaphragmatic breathing is experienced in this position, practice can continue in a sitting position, concentrating on filling the lower part of the lungs as if slowly filling a balloon. After 1 week of practice, slowed breathing is approximated, by gradually reaching a 6-second cycle (3 seconds inhalation, 3 seconds exhalation). After another week of slow diaphragmatic breathing practice, practice takes place in distracting environments, such as at work or in the car. The last step is to apply slow breathing as a coping strategy at times of anxiety or panic, which is usually achieved by around Session 6. One difficulty that can arise with breathing retraining is an overreliance on breathing exercises. The provision of a concrete exercise, particularly one that slows symptoms of arousal, is particularly appealing. Frustration and “desperation” can arise from drastic attempts to use the breathing exercise “at all costs” for fear that if breathing is not slowed, then dreaded events such as fainting or death would actually occur. The most effective use of breathing retraining is in combination with cognitive restructuring principles. Another problem is the experience of dizziness or other feared symptoms during slowed breathing exercises. Diane paged her therapist a couple of days after the breathing retraining exercise had first been introduced. She complained that she had been trying the exercise and that she was now unable to breathe normally. She felt that she was not getting enough air. She said that her chest hurt from the effort of breathing and that she was exhausted from being unable to sleep. Therapist:
It does sound like you are expending a lot of effort breathing. It sounds also like you are feeling very anxious about this.
Diane:
Well, yes. I’m not getting enough air.
Therapist:
That’s a scary thought. Let’s test it out as a hypothesis. What evidence do you have for that idea?
Diane:
I don’t know, it really feels like I can’t get enough air. And my chest really hurts.
Therapist:
So, they are some feelings that you have. What about objective evidence? For example, a good sign that you are actually not getting enough air is passing out or turning blue. Have either of those happened?
Diane:
No. PANIC AND PHOBIA
83
Therapist: So, can you think of another possible explanation for those sensations? Diane: Well, I guess anxiety. Thus, symptoms can arise from fear caused by misappraisals of danger. In addition, chronic hyperventilation may render individuals vulnerable to exacerbation of symptomatology when breathing patterns are disrupted, even though the disruption is in the form of breathing retraining exercises. However, symptoms are likely to subside with practice. Others have used applied relaxation in place of breathing retraining. This involves training in progressive muscle relaxation and cue-controlled relaxation that is applied to practice items from a hierarchy of anxietyprovoking tasks (Ost, 1988). Interoceptive Exposure
The purpose of interoceptive exposure (as in the case of exposure to external phobic stimuli) is to disrupt or weaken associations between specific bodily cues and panic reactions. The theoretical basis for interoceptive exposure is fear extinction, given the conceptualization of panic attacks as conditioned or learned alarm reactions to salient bodily cues. Interoceptive exposure is conducted through procedures that induce paniclike sensations reliably, such as cardiovascular exercise. The exposure is conducted using a graduated format and proceeds from simulated exercises in the clinic setting to more naturalistic activities in the home environment. Provision of a credible rationale for interoceptive exposure is essential, given the apparent conflict between earlier strategies that emphasized decreasing sensations (through cognitive restructuring and breathing control) and this more confrontational procedure. In addition, a rationale is important for clients who fear inducing the sensations of panic. We emphasize the value of exposure by eliciting examples of situations or objects that clients themselves learned to become less fearful of as a result of practice and experience (e.g., bike riding, skiing, and public speaking). Clients sometimes express doubts because their fear of sensations has not reduced despite their daily occurrence. We emphasize that in contrast to their current experience of sensations, this exposure entails systematic and controlled exposures to sensations and, in contrast to their current attempts to eliminate the sensations as soon as they arise, this exposure entails progressive toleration of sensations. We begin this segment of treatment at Session 5 with a series of exercises that produce sensations similar to the ones that occur during panic (these are listed in Table 3.3). Over the next several sessions, exposure to individually relevant sensation-induction exercises is repeated, for clients to learn that feared aversive consequences do not occur. A
84
LANG
AND CRASKE
TABLE 3.3 Induction Exercises for lnteroceptive Exposure
Exercise
Sensations
Intensity of Sensation
(0-8)
Intensity
of
Anxiety (0-8)
Similarity to Panic (0-8)
Shake head side to side (30 seconds) Head between legs (30 seconds), sit up quickly Run in place (1 minute) Hold breath Muscle tension (1 minute) Spin (1 minute) Hyperventilation (1 minute) Breathe through a straw (2 minutes) Stare at a light (1 minute) then read
hierarchy is established in order of anxiety level associated with each exercise. Repeated exposure begins with lower anxiety level items. Each item is practiced enough times until the maximum amount of anxiety during the exercise is no more than mild. With each practice, clients are instructed to experience the sensations as fully as possible and to tolerate them for a period of time before terminating the exercise. For example, they may be asked to hyperventilate until they feel sensations of light headedness or dizziness and then to continue to hyperventilate for at least 30 seconds longer. By so doing, they have an opportunity to correct their natural tendencies to avert the sensations as soon as possible and also to learn that feared outcomes do not occur. With each repetition, clients are encouraged to apply cognitive and breathing strategies after inducing and tolerating the sensations. In addition to within-session practices, the exercises are practiced between sessions. Not only does homework practice consolidate learning, but it also facilitates generalizations to conditions in which the therapist is not present as a safety signal. After completing the simulated exercises, PANIC AND PHOBlA
85
the clients identify naturalistic exposure activities, listed in a hierarchy and practiced in the same way. Naturalistic interoceptive exercises include activities such as aerobic exercise or running up flights of stairs, taking steamy showers or saunas, watching suspenseful movies, and drinking caffeine. These are activities that inherently generate sensations. Although interoceptive exposure is the major treatment focus for Sessions 5 through 8, it is continued when necessary throughout the remainder of treatment. Interoceptive exposure works well within a group setting, partly because of the camaraderie and group support offered for each member to confront his or her most feared sensations. We conduct the initial symptom induction exercises as a group, but, as with the hyperventilation demonstration, emphasize individual differences in tolerability of each exercise. Individual members use their own ratings of each exercise to generate their own hierarchy. For the purposes of repeated exposure to each interoceptive exercise, group members form pairs. One member of the pair completes the exercise, whereas the other rates levels of anxiety, informs the first person when to stop the exercise, and prompts the use of breathing and cognitive strategies when the induction is over. Then, they switch roles. Therapists spend some time with each pair, giving feedback when necessary. We have found this type of pairing to be very effective. Furthermore, we often incorporate naturalistic interoceptive exposure exercises for the entire group, such as by providing coffee and chocolate (i.e., stimulants that produce sensations) for all group members to partake in throughout a group session.
In Vivo Exposure The second 8 weeks of treatment incorporate panic control into in vivo exposure, or confrontation with agoraphobic situations. We begin by having each group member list a number of situations that he or she fears or avoids, which are ranked from the least to the most anxiety provoking. We explain that agoraphobia is maintained by fears of panicking or experiencing certain bodily sensations. Therefore, learning that took place in the first phase of treatment-that bodily sensations of panic are not actually dangerous- is central to overcoming agoraphobia. However, direct confrontation with agoraphobic situations is equally important. First, this is achieved by identifying and challenging the thoughts that maintain fear about certain situations. Second, by repeated confrontation with each item from their hierarchy, clients learn that the situations are manageable and the expected catastrophic consequences do not occur. For the duration of the second phase of treatment, clients are asked to practice in vivo exposure at least three times per week, starting with the least anxiety-provoking item on their hierarchy. Included among the more challenging items should be situations associated with the very first panic or a very bad panic attack. The difficulty of exposure can be further
86
LANG AND CRASKE
increased by including exercises to elicit feared sensations, and we generally encourage clients to combine interoceptive exercises with their in vivo exposure to feared agoraphobic situations. As an example of this, Christie had her first panic attack at the track at her school. Bolstered by her ability to manage other situations, she decided that she wanted to return to the track, where she had not been in over a year. She began by simply going to the track and watching people. The next step was to begin walking and then to jog. Finally, she jogged around the track while intentionally looking down to elicit a dizzy sensation that was similar to the sensations that she experienced during her first panic attack.
During every exposure exercise, clients are asked to identify and challenge negative cognitions and to apply breathing retraining when appropriate. In addition, we attempt to correct commonly used but maladaptive methods of coping with agoraphobic situations. The first is the use of safety signals, such as other people (who would help in the event of a panic) or objects (e.g., telephones or phone numbers, money, medications). Safety signals result in maintenance of the erroneous belief of danger (e.g., “I would have gone crazy if my husband had not been there to help me” or “I might have fainted if it hadn’t been for the knowledge that the medication was in my pocket”). Thus, safety signals are gradually weaned. A second negative coping strategy is “holding on for dear life coping,” which refers to taking unnecessary precautions (e.g., sitting in the aisle in a movie theater so faster escape is possible, tightly gripping the steering wheel to prevent losing control of the car). Mastery behavior is encouraged in place of these unnecessary precautions (e.g., sitting in the middle of the row at a movie theater, loosening the grip on the steering wheel). A third strategy is distraction (e.g., pretending to be elsewhere, using music or games to keep one’s mind occupied), which tends to alleviate anxiety in the short term but may not be effective in the long term. Thus, clients are encouraged to maintain an objective focus on the situation and their feelings (e.g., “OK, I am in the elevator, the doors are closing and I can feel it moving, my hands are sweaty, and I would judge my anxiety to be about 3 on the 0-8 scale”). Note that an objective focus is very different from subjective focus, which tends to be negative and fear provoking (e.g., “OK, I am in the elevator and it feels as if I can’t breathe-the doors may get jammed shut, and I would be stuck in here forever.”). In vivo exposure can be challenging. To maximize the benefit of exposure, we plan and rehearse practices within the group setting. That is, each session is devoted to reviewing exposure practices over the preceding week for each group member, learning from those experiences, and planning new exposures for the coming week. Group members are encouraged to become fully involved in evaluation of past and planning of future exPANIC AND PHOBIA
87
posure for themselves as well as for others in the group. For example, planning involves consideration of situational factors (e.g., how many people are likely to be there, how much traffic will there be), and sensations that are likely to occur and how they will be managed. Also, rehearsal is given to the negative cognitions that are likely to occur and how they can be countered. The group setting provides an excellent opportunity for input from everyone regarding management of anxiety in an upcoming exposure task. In addition, the group provides reinforcement for each other’s accomplishments, offsetting the tendencies for clients to minimize their successes and magnify their failures. We encourage reinforcement of behavioral accomplishments regardless of level of anxiety experienced. In addition, the group can be incorporated directly into in vivo exposures by conducting exercises within sessions. These might include role plays of situations, much in the same way that was described previously for hypothesis testing. For example, the group may be arranged in seating positions that simulate a flight, with one group member expressing and managing fear and other members responding as if in the real situation, and also responding by providing examples of cognitive restructuring for the fearful person. In addition, certain exposures can be practiced in vivo as a group, such as exposure to elevators, heights, stores, walking, and other situations that are in close proximity of the clinical setting. Obviously, when conducting group exposures, some members will be more anxious than others. The less fearful members provide excellent models for the more fearful members. Problems with compliance with in vivo exposure are addressed directly in the group. From the start, we attempt to avoid such problems by selecting exercises that are feasible (e.g., not costly, not requiring a good deal of travel). Sometimes, there are complaints about finding the time to complete the homework. Throughout treatment, we emphasize the importance of homework. In regard to the in vivo exposures, we remind group members that the treatment is time limited and explain the importance of practicing while they have the opportunity to come back to the group with any difficulties that they encounter. In many cases, noncompletion of exposure exercises is a function of fear. Thus, therapists and other group members elicit thoughts about the avoided task and help the client through cognitive restructuring. Finally, it may be necessary to work up to a given task gradually, as described below. Jessica wanted to have her eyelashes dyed. She began by covering her eyes and sitting in the dark for 30 seconds and worked up to the 5 minutes required for the dyeing process. She scheduled her appointment but found herself unable to stay. With some discussion, it was established that she felt that when she covered her own eyes she could always uncover them but felt that she would be too embarrassed to ask someone else to uncover her eyes, meaning that she would be trapped.
88
LANG AND CRASKE
We completed cognitive restructuring around the embarrassed and trapped feelings. We also added new exercises by involving her roommate in blindfolding and locking her in a dark room to give her practice with being in someone else’s control.
GROUP STRUCTURE AND SELECTION Our groups normally have 3-5 members. The group size is small to allow for sufficient individual attention. We believe that whereas didactic presentation is feasible in larger groups (e.g., 10-12 clients), cognitive restructuring and exposure exercises are most effective when they are tailored to each individual, in which case a smaller group is necessary. This is consistent with a finding in the area of social phobia treatment: the results from one study that did not achieve the usual rate of effectiveness of CBT (Gelernter et al., 1991) were attributed to large group sizes (Hope, Heimberg, & Bruch, 1995). In addition, we have two therapists per group, ideally one female and one male. The availability of two therapists enhances role plays, demonstration exercises and division of responsibility for different components of the treatment. We require that group members have a principal diagnosis of panic disorder, that is, panic disorders is currently the most disturbing or most disabling condition. The diagnosis is established by use of a semistructured interview (e.g., Anxiety Disorders Interview Schedule for the 4th edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders; Brown, Di Nardo, 6r Barlow, 1994). To increase objectivity in the assessment, the interview is not conducted by the treating clinician, but this is not always feasible in clinical settings. This is a demanding treatment. In addition to attending weekly meetings, group members are expected to complete daily homework. Motivation to engage in treatment is therefore important, and motivation may be diminished if panic disorder is not the primary concern. Furthermore, as seen from the above description, the treatment is not a general anxiety management program but instead is focused on fears of bodily sensations and agoraphobic situations. Thus, it would not adequately address the primary concerns of individuals for whom panic disorder is not the principal diagnosis. It is interesting, however, that our research shows that additional diagnoses tend to diminish substantially after treatment for panic disorder. For example, in addition to a principal diagnosis of panic disorder, the majority of clients have additional diagnoses of generalized anxiety, social phobia, specific phobia, and depression. After treatment, those additional diagnoses commonly subside in intensity, even to the point of being no longer diagnosable (e.g., Tsao, Lewin, & Craske, 1998). Although the majority of clients have additional diagnoses that do not exclude them from group participation, there are some additional diPANIC
AND PHOBIA
89
agnoses that are reason for exclusion. These include current psychosis, suicidality, and substance abuse or dependence, given their likely interruption of the group process and of engagement in the treatment. In addition, we require a medical examination before beginning treatment to ensure that there is no medical contraindication to interoceptive symptom induction or fearful arousal in general (e.g., cardiovascular disease, respiratory conditions, and pregnancy). In the case of medical comorbidity, the treatment can be conducted with the supervision of a physician and with modifications to lessen the intensity of symptom induction and fear arousal, perhaps in combination with ongoing monitoring of certain physiological parameters (such as by using ambulatory blood pressure cuffs). Medication status is another important issue. As many as 50% of our clients take anxiolytic or antidepressant medication or both when they first enter our clinic. The interaction between medications and CBT for panic and agoraphobia is a complicated issue and is in need of further investigation (see Craske, 1996, for a review). For those who come to us on medication, we work with them and their physicians either to stabilize medications at a regular dosage during treatment or to withdraw medications. We generally discourage use of medication on an as-needed basis (most commonly benzodiazepines). We believe that use of as-needed medications works against the principles of treatment. We teach that the fear response is harmless, manageable, and time limited and that bodily sensations will come and go and need not be avoided. As-needed medications deprive the individual of learning these principles. Furthermore, as-needed medications lead to attributions of control and safety to medications as opposed to oneself. Attributions of improvements to medications predict relapse (e.g., Basoglu, Marks, Kilic, Brewin, & Swinson, 1994). O n the other hand, cognitive-behavioral treatments for panic improve the rate of successful withdrawal from medications (e.g., Otto, Pollack, Meltzer-Brody, & Rosenbaum, 1992) and, thus, clients who use medications throughout our treatment frequently successfully discontinue their medications once the treatment is complete.
SUMMARY In summary, it appears that group treatments for anxiety disorders are strongly justified for several reasons. First, their cost-effectiveness results in increased availability of treatment to individuals experiencing anxiety disorders who would not otherwise receive treatment because of financial limitations or availability of therapists. Second, group formats may be conducive to the development of anxiety management skills and overcoming fears of particular situations, given the modeling, reinforcement, and opportunities for simulated or in vivo exposure provided by group members.
90
LANG A N D CRASKE
Third, the data, albeit limited, suggest that on average, group treatments are as effective as individual therapies in the case of cognitive-behavioral approaches for anxiety disorders. It is hoped that future investigation will elucidate the optimal parameters under which group treatment should take place (e.g., frequency and schedule of meetings, number of members) as well as characteristics of individuals who are better suited for group as opposed to individual treatment.
REFERENCES Angst, J., & Dobler-Mikola, A. (1985). The Zurich Study: V. Anxiety and phobia in young adults. European Archives of Psychiatry and Neurological Sciences, 235, 171- 178. Arntz, A., & van den Hout, M. (1996). Psychological treatments of panic disorder without agoraphobia: Cognitive therapy versus applied relaxation. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 34, 113- 12 1. Barlow, D. H. (1988). Anxiety and its disorders: The nature and treatment of anxiety and panic. New York: Guilford Press. Barlow, D. H., & Craske, M. G. (1999). Mastery of your anxiety and panic (3rd ed.). San Antonio, TX: Harcourt Brace. Barlow, D. H., Craske, M. G., Cerny, J. A., & Klosko, J. S. (1989). Behavioral treatment of panic disorder. Behavior Therapy, 20, 261 -282. Barlow, D. H., O’Brien, G. T., & Last, C. G. (1984). Couples treatment of agoraphobia. Behavior Therapy, 15, 41 -58. Basoglu, M., Marks, I. M., Kilic, C., Brewin, C. R., & Swinson, R. P. (1994). Alprazolam and exposure for panic disorder with agoraphobia attribution of improvement to medication predicts subsequent relapse. British Journal of Psychiatry, 164, 652-659. Beck, A. T., & Emery, G. (1985). Anxiety disorders and phobias: A cognitive perspective. New York: Basic Books. Beck, A. T., Sokol, L., Clark, D. A,, Berchick, R., 6,Wright, F. (1992). A crossover study of focused cognitive therapy for panic disorder. American Journal of Psychiatry, 149, 778-783. Beck, J. G., Stanley, M. A., Baldwin, L. E., Deagle, E. A., & Averill, P. M. (1994). Comparison of cognitive therapy and relaxation training for panic disorder. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 62, 818-826. Black, D. W., Wesner, R., Bowers, W., & Gabel, J. (1993). A comparison of fluvoxamine, cognitive therapy, and placebo in the treatment of panic disorder. Archives of General Psychiatry, 50, 44-50. Bouchard, S., Gauthier, I., Laberge, B., French, D., Pelletier, M.-H., & Godbout, C. (1996). Exposure versus cognitive restructuring in the treatment of panic disorder with agoraphobia. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 34, 213 -224. Bowen, R., South, M., Fischer, D., & Looman, T. (1994). Depression, mastery, PANIC AND PHOBIA
91
and number of group sessions attended predict outcome of patients with panic and agoraphobia in a behavioral/medication program. CanadianJournal of Psychiatry, 39, 283-288. Brown, T. A., Di Nardo, P. A., & Barlow, D. H. (1994). Anxiety Disorders Interwiew Schedule for DSM-IV. San Antonio, TX: Psychological Corporation. Butler, G., & Mathews, A. (1983). Cognitive processes in anxiety. Adwances in Behawiour Research and Therapy, 5, 51-62. Carter, M. M., Turovsky, J., Sbrocco, T., & Meadows, E. A. (1995). Patient dropout from a couples’ group treatment for panic disorder with agoraphobia. Projessionui Psychology: Research and Practice, 26, 626-628. Cerny, J. A., Barlow, D. H., Craske, M. G., & Himadi, W. G. (1987). Couples treatment of agoraphobia: A two-year follow-up. Behawior Therapy, 18, 401 415. Chambless, D. L., Caputo, G., Bright, P., & Gallagher, R. (1984). Assessment of fear in agoraphobics: The Body Sensations Questionnaire and the Agoraphobic Cognitions Questionnaire. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 52, 1090-1097. Chambless, D. L., & Mason, J. (1986). Sex, sex-role stereotyping and agoraphobia. Behawiour Research and Therapy, 24, 231-235. Clark, D. M., Salkovskis, P.,Gelder, M., Koehler, C., Martin, M., Anastasiades, P., Hackmann, A., Middleton, H., & Jeavons, A. (1988). Tests of a cognitive theory of panic. In I. Hand & H. Wittchen (Eds.), Panic and phobias: Treatments and variables affecting course and outcome (pp. 71-90). Berlin: SpringerVerlag. Clark, D. M., Salkovskis, P. M., Hackmann, A., Middleton, H., Anastasiades, P., & Gelder, M. (1994). A comparison of cognitive therapy, applied relaxation and imipramine in the treatment of panic disorder. British Journal of Psychiatry, 164, 759-769. Cote, G., Gauthier, J. G., Laberge, B., Cormier, H., & Plamondon, J. (1994). Reduced therapist contact in the cognitive-behavioral treatment of panic disorder. Behawior Therapy, 25, 123- 145. Craske, M. G. (1996). An integrated treatment approach to panic disorder. Bulletin of the Menninger Clinic, 6O(Suppl. A), A87-A104. Craske, M. G. (1998). Anxiety disorders: Psychological approaches to theory and treatment. Boulder, CO: Westview Press/Harper Collins. Craske, M. G., & Barlow, D. H. (1988). A review of the relationship between panic and avoidance. Clinical Psychology Rewiew, 8, 667-685. Craske, M. G., & Barlow, D. H. (1999a). Agoraphobia supplement to mastery of your anxiety and panic (3rd ed.). New York: Graywind. Craske, M. G., & Barlow, D. H. (1999b). Therapists guide to mastery of your anxiety and panic. (3rd ed.). New York: Graywind. Craske, M. G., Glover, D., & DeCola, J. (1994). Predicted versus unpredicted panic attacks: Acute versus general distress. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 104, 214-223.
92
LANG AND CRASKE
Craske, M. G., & Lewin, M, (1994). Panic disorder and agoraphobia treatment. Unpublished treatment manual. Craske, M. G., Maidenberg, E., & Bystritsky, A. (1995). Brief cognitivebehavioral versus nondirective therapy for panic disorder. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry, 26, 113- 120. Craske, M. G., Meadows, E., & Barlow, D. H. (1994). Mastery of your anxiety and panic (11): Therapist guide. New York: Graywind. Craske, M. G., & Rowe, M. (1997). Nocturnal panic. Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice, 4, 153-174. Craske, M. G., Rowe, M., Lewin, M., & Noriega-Dimitri, R. (1997). Interoceptive exposure versus breathing retraining within cognitive-behavioural therapy for panic disorder with agoraphobia. British Journal of Clinical Psychology, 36, 8599. Craske, M. G., Street, L., & Barlow, D. H. (1989). Instructions to focus upon or distract from internal cues during exposure treatment for agoraphobic avoidance. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 27, 663-672. DeCola, J. P., & Rosellini, R. A. (1990). Unpredictable/uncontrollable stress proactively interferes with appetitive Pavlovian conditioning. Learning and Motivation, 21, 137-152. Ehlers, A., & Breuer, P. (1995). Selective attention to physical threat in subjects with panic attacks and specific phobias. Journal of Anxiety Disorders, 9, 1131. Ehlers, A., & Margraf, J. (1989). The psychophysiological model of panic attacks. In I? M. G. Emmelkamp, W. T. Everaerd, E W. Kraaimaat, & M. J. Van Son (Eds.), Fresh perspectives on anxiety disorders (pp. 1-29). Lisse, The Netherlands: Swets & Zeitlinger. Evans, L., Holt, C., & Oei, T. (1991). Long term follow-up of agoraphobics treated by brief intensive group cognitive behavioural therapy. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, 25, 343-349. Feigenbaum, W. (1988). Long-term efficacy of ungraded versus graded massed exposure in agoraphobics. In I. Hand & H. Wittchen (Eds.), Panic and phobias: Treatments and variables affecting course and outcome (pp. 149-158). Berlin: Springer-Verlag. Gelernter, C. S., Uhde, T. W., Cimbolic, P., Amkoff, D. B., Vittone, B. J., Tancer, M. E., & Bartko, J. 1. (1991). Cognitive-behavioral and pharmacological treatments of social phobia: A controlled study. Archives of General Psychiatry, 48, 938-945. Goisman, R. M., Warshaw, M. G., Peterson, L. G., Rogers, M. P.,Cuneo, P., Hunt, M. F., Tomlin-Albanese, J. M., Kazim, A., Gollan, J. K., Epstein-Kaye, T., Reich, J. H., & Keller, M. B. (1994). Panic, agoraphobia, and panic disorder with agoraphobia: Data from a 4 percent multicenter anxiety disorders study. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 182, 72-79. Gould, R. A., & Clum, G. A. (1995). Self-help plus minimal therapist contact in PANIC AND PHOBIA
93
the treatment of panic disorder: A replication and extension. Behavior Therapy, 26, 533-546. Gould, R. A., Clum, G. A., & Shapiro, D. (1993). The use of bibliotherapy in the treatment of panic: A preliminary investigation. Behavior Therapy, 24, 241-252. Gray, J. A. (1988). The psychology offear and stress. New York: Cambridge University Press. Hecker, J. E., Losee, M. C., Friztler, B. K., & Fink, C. M. (1996). Self-directed versus therapist-directed cognitive behavioral treatment for panic disorder. Journal of Anxiety Disorders, 10, 253-265. Hoffart, A. (1995). A comparison of cognitive and guided mastery therapy of agoraphobia. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 33, 423-434. Holt, P., & Andrews, G. (1989). Hyperventilation and anxiety in panic disorder, agoraphobia, and generalized anxiety disorder. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 27, 453-460. Hope, D. A., Heimberg, R. G., & Bruch, M. A. (1995). Dismantling cognitivebehavioral group therapy for social phobia. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 33, 637-650. Jansson, L., Jerremalm, A., & Ost, L.-G. (1986). Follow-up of agoraphobic patients treated with exposure in vivo or applied relaxation. British Journal of Psychiatry, 149, 486-490. Kessler, R. C., McGonagle, K. A., Zhao, S., Nelson, C. B., Hughes, M., Eshleman, S., Wittchen, H.-U., 61 Kendler, K. S.(1994). Lifetime and 12-month prevalence of DSM-III-R psychiatric disorders in the United States: Results from the National Comorbidity Survey. Archives of General Psychiatry, 51, 8- 19. Klosko, J. S., Barlow, D. H., Tassinari, R., & Cerny, J. A. (1990). A comparison of alprazolam and behavior therapy in treatment of panic disorder. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 58, 77-84. Laberge, B., Gauthier, J. G., Cote, G., Plamondon, J., & Cormier, H. J. (1993). Cognitive-behavioral therapy of panic disorder with secondary major depression: A preliminary investigation. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 61, 1028- 1037. Lidren, D., Watkins, P., Gould, R., Clum, G., Asterino, M., & Tulloch, H. L. (1994). A comparison of bibliotherapy and group therapy in the treatment of panic disorder. journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 62, 865-869. Maier, S. F., Laudenslager, M. L., & Ryan, S. M. (1985). Stressor controllability, immune function and endogenous opiates. In F. R. Brush & J. B. Overmeier (Eds.), Affect, conditioning and cognition: Essays on the determinants of behavior (pp. 183-201). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum. Margraf, J., Gobel, M., & Schneider, S. ( 1989). Cognitive-behavioral treatments for panic disorder. In H. Zapotoczsky & T. Wenzel (Eds.), The scientific dialogue: From basic research to clinical intervention. Annual series of European research in behavior therapy (Vol. 5, pp. 149-155). Lisse, The Netherlands: Swets & Zeitlinger.
94
LANG AND CRASKE
Markowitz, J. S., Weissman, M. M., Ouellette, R., Lish, J. D., & Klerman, G. L. (1989). Quality of life in panic disorder. Archives of General Psychiatry, 46, 984-992. Marks, 1. M., Swinson, R. P., Basoglu, M., Kuch, K., Noshirvani, H., O’Sullivan, G., Lelliot, P. T., Kirby, M., McNamee, G., Sengun, S., & Wickwire, K. (1993). Alprazolam and exposure alone and combined in panic disorder with agoraphobia: A controlled study in London and Toronto. British Journal of Psychiatry, 162, 776-787. Mavissakalian, M., & Michelson, L. (1986). Two-year follow-up of exposure and imipramine treatment of agoraphobia. American Journal of Psychiatry, 143, 1106-1 112. Michelson, L., Marchione, K., Marchione, N., Testa, S., & Mavissakalian, M. (1988). Cognitive correlates and outcome of cognitive, behavioral and physiological treatments of agoraphobia. Psychological Reports, 63, 999- 1004. Michelson, L., Mavissakalian, M. Y., & Marchione, K. (1985). Cognitive and behavioral treatments of agoraphobia: Clinical, behavioral, and psychophysiological outcomes. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 53,913-925. Moran, C., & Andrews, G. (1985). The familial occurrence of agoraphobia. British Journal of Psychiatry, 146, 262-267. Neron, S., Lacroix, D., & Chaput, Y. (1995). Group vs. individual cognitive behavior therapy in panic disorder: An open clinical trial with a six month follow-up. Canadian Journal of Behavioural Science, 27, 379-392. Noyes, R., Crowe, R. R., Harris, E. L., Hamra, B. J., McChesney, C. M., & Chaudry, D. R. (1986). Relationship between panic disorder and agoraphobia: A family study. Archives of General Psychiatry, 43, 227-232. Ost, L.-G. (1988). Applied relaxation vs. progressive relaxation in the treatment of panic disorder. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 26, 13-22. Ost, L.-G., & Westling, B. E. (1995). Applied relaxation vs. cognitive-behavior therapy in the treatment of panic disorder. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 33, 145-158. Otto, M. W., Pollack, M. H., Meltzer-Brody, S., & Rosenbaum, J. (1992). Cognitive-behavioral therapy for benzodiazepine discontinuation in panic disorder patients. Psychophamology Bulletin, 28, 123- 130. Pollard, C. A., Bronson, S. S., & Kenney, M. R. (1989). Prevalence of agoraphobia without panic in clinical settings. American Journal of Psychiatry, 146, 559. Pollard, C. A., Henderson, J. G., Frank, M., & Margolis, R. B. (1989). Helpseeking patterns of anxiety-disordered individuals in the general population. Journal of Anxiety Disorders, 3, 131-138. Rachman, S., & Levitt, K. (1985). Panics and their consequences. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 23, 585-600. Rapee, R. M., Mattick, R., & Murrell, E. (1986). Cognitive mediation in the affective component of spontaneous panic attacks. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry, 17, 245-253. Razran, G. ( 1961). The observable unconscious and the inferable conscious in PANIC AND PHOBIA
95
current soviet psychophysiology: Interoceptive conditioning, semantic conditioning, and the orienting reflex. Psychological Review, 68, 81-147. Reiss, S., Peterson, R., Gursky, D., & McNally, R. (1986). Anxiety sensitivity, anxiety frequency, and the prediction of fearfulness. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 24, 1-8. Rice, D. P., & Miller, L. S. (1993). The economic burden of mental disorders. Advances in Health Economics and Health Services Research, 14, 37-53. Sanderson, W. S., Rapee, R. M., & Barlow, D. H. (1989). The influence of an illusion of control on panic attacks induced via inhalation of 5.5 percent carbon dioxide enriched air. Archives of General Psychiatry, 48, 157- 162. Schulte, D., Kuenzel, R., Pepping, G., & Schulte-Bahrenberg, T. (1992). Tailormade versus standardized therapy of phobic patients. Adwances in Behaviour Research and Therapy, 14(2), 67-92. Shear, M. K., Pilkonis, P. A., Cloitre, M., & Leon, A. C. (1994). Cognitivebehavioral treatment compared with nonprescriptive treatment of panic disorder. Archives of General Psychiatry, 51, 395-401. Telch, M. J., Lucas, J. A., Schmidt, N. B., Hanna, H. H., LaNae Jaimez, T., & Lucas, R. A. (1993). Group cognitive-behavioral treatment of panic disorder. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 31, 279-287. Thompson, J. W., Burns, B. J., Bartko, J. J., Boyd, J. H., Taube, C. A., & Bourdon, K. H. (1988). The use of ambulatory services by persons with and without phobia. Medical Care, 26, 183-198. Thyer, B. A., Himle, J., Curtis, G. C., Cameron, 0. G., & Nesse, R. M. (1985). A comparison of panic disorder and agoraphobia with panic attacks. Comprehensive Psychiatry, 26, 208-214. Tsao, J. C. I., Lewin, M. R., & Craske, M. G. (1998). The effects of cognitivebehavior therapy for panic disorder on comorbid conditions. Journal of Anxiety Disorders, 12, 357-371. Van den Hout, M., Van der Molen, G. M., Griez, E., & Lousberg, G. (1987). Specificity of interoceptive fear to panic disorders. Journal of Psychopathology and Behavioral Assessment, 9, 99-109. Weinberg, J., & Levine, S. (1980). Psychobiology of coping in animals: The effect of predictability. In S. Levine & H. Ursin (Eds.), Coping and health (pp. 3959). New York: Plenum Press. Williams, S. L., & Falbo, J. (1996) Cognitive and performance-based treatments for panic attacks in people with varying degrees of agoraphobic disability. Behaviour Research Therapy, 34, 253-264. Wittchen, H.-U. ( 1988). Natural course and spontaneous remissions of untreated anxiety disorder: Results of the Munich Follow-Up Study (MFS). In H. Hand & H. Wittchen (Eds.), Panic and phobias: Treatments and variables affecting course and outcome (pp. 3- 17). Berlin: Springer-Verlag.
96
LANG AND CRASKE
Zarate, R., Rapee, R. M., Craske, M. G., & Barlow, D. H. (1988, November). Response norms for symptom induction procedures. Poster presented at 22nd Annual Convention of the Association for the Advancement of Behavior Therapy, New York, NY. Zaubler, T. S., & Katon, W. (1996). Panic disorder and medical comorbidity: A review of the medical and psychiatric literature. Bulletin of the Menninger Clinic, 60(2, Suppl. A), A12-A38.
PANIC AND PHOBIA
97
OBESITY ROBERT R. RADOMILE
Americans today are obsessed with weight loss. Commercial and medical approaches are ubiquitous, many promising easy, rapid, permanent weight loss that will turn one’s life around. Yet, despite this preoccupation with weight loss and the preponderance of weight-loss programs, 24% of men and 27% of women are obese, that is, 20% or more above ideal weight (Kuczmarski, 1992). Moreover, despite all the dieting and weight-loss programs, the incidence of obesity remains on the rise, having doubled since the early 1900s despite stable or even declining caloric intake (Marston & Raper, 1987). Decreased physical activity, diets high in fat, and changed eating patterns (specifically increased snacking and eating out) would seem to explain the dramatic increase. Although many would seem motivated to lose weight for cosmetic reasons, the serious health implications of obesity cannot be denied. Increased risk of hypertension, diabetes, and cardiovascular disease has been associated with obesity (Bray, 1986; Pi-Snyder, 1991), and higher levels of fat intake have been related to greater risk for cardiovascular disease and cancer (National Academy of Sciences, 1989; U.S. Department of Heath and Human Services, 1988). Despite the contribution of diet and lifestyle changes to the increased incidence of obesity, it should not be assumed that all obesity is caused by
99
diet and lack of exercise and that an altered lifestyle can always correct obesity. Researchers have determined conclusively that genetics play a substantial role in obesity (Bouchard et al., 1990; Price, 1987; Stunkard et al., 1986), and numerous studies have found no significant difference in the caloric intake of obese and nonobese participants (Garrow, 1974; Klesges, Hanson, Eck, & Duff, 1988; Liebel & Hirsch, 1984; Wooley, Wooley, & Dyrenforth, 1979). It should be noted, however, that the accuracy of these and similar studies has come into question as more recent studies have demonstrated that obese participants significantly underreport caloric intake in such studies compared with nonobese participants (Mertz et al., 1991; Schoeller, 1988). The implications of these findings are significant for weight-loss programs, especially as they relate to the self-monitoring of food intake. Pursuit of the “ideal body” or “ideal weight” in the treatment of obesity has been widely condemned by both researchers and practitioners. In addition to the significant role genetics play in both body weight and shape, there is also ample evidence that dieting to achieve the ideal weight simply does not work. In fact, it has been determined that as high as 95% of people who achieve significant weight loss fail to keep the weight off and return to or near their starting weight (Garner & Wooley, 1991). It is not actually known, in other words, whether there are in fact long-term health and psychological benefits from losing and sustaining significant weight loss over a long period of time. What is also not known and probably impossible to single out is the negative psychological effect that repeated failure to lose and sustain significant weight loss has on obese individuals. Weight-loss programs by their very nature reinforce the stereotype that an individual’s weight is in fact under his or her control. Failure to achieve and maintain “goal weight” carries with it the full burden of shame and guilt associated with presumed traits of laziness, lack of pride, and lack of discipline commonly attributed to obese people. It is critical, therefore, that any weight-loss program be particularly sensitive to the potentially damaging effects that failure may have on its participants and be especially cautious when it comes to setting treatment and weight-loss goals. Although there is significant evidence that striving for the ideal weight when working with people who are obese is doomed to failure, much evidence exists supporting the feasibility and benefits of more modest weight loss. I t was found, for example, that the blood pressure of participants with obesity and hypertension could be normalized with weight losses of as little as 10% of body weight (Blackburn & Kanders, 1987). Most losses were found to have long-term benefits for people with Type I1 diabetes (Wing, Marcus, Epstein, & Jawad, 1991). Other studies also support the significant positive effects of modest weight loss on blood pressure and cardiovascular risk factors ( Brownell & Wadden, 1991).
100
ROBERT R. RADOMlLE
The psychological benefits of modest weight loss have been less extensively studied, but what research exists suggests that improved selfimage, improved body image, and decreased depression are associated with modest weight loss (Prochaska, DiClemente, & Norcross, 1992; Wadden & Stunkard, 1985). This chapter describes a time-limited cognitive-behavioral group treatment for obesity that works through education, targeted behavioral change, and cognitive restructuring, with a goal of modest, attainable, and sustainable weight loss. Each of these components is present throughout the 20-week treatment, with education stressed more in the earlier group sessions and behavior change and cognitive restructuring being predominant in the middle and later group sessions. Research has shown that a number of characteristics are common to effective weight-loss programs, and these are emphasized throughout the group sessions. The chapter begins with a review of these characteristics and then proceeds to describe the group’s structure and process and the cognitive-behavioral techniques that are used.
TEN CHARACTERISTICS OF AN EFFECTIVE WEIGHT-LOSS PROGRAM 1. Set Modest Goals As previously stated, clients should be encouraged to set modest weight-loss goals (around 10% of body weight). Clients may be resistant to a low target at first, especially because of the great emphasis placed on thinness and ideal weight in American society. However, through education and cognitive restructuring, clients should be able to accept the more modest weight-loss goal as positive rather than negative, beneficial both physically and psychologically, realistic to achieve, and potentially a first step toward greater weight loss if desired.
2. Understand Eating Behavior
A client should have an increased awareness of and ability to understand his or her own eating behavior (Kirschenbaum, 1987). As noted earlier, obese individuals tend to significantly underestimate and underreport food intake. This is undoubtedly a result of the shame that they feel about themselves, their weight, and their eating behavior. This shame can be identified and its effects brought to light through guided discovery and Socratic questioning. Through cognitive restructuring, clients can become aware that honest, accurate record-keeping is the cornerstone of successful OBESITY
I01
behavior change, the starting point of success rather than a cause for shame.
3. Use Stimulus Control Stimulus control (Schacter & Rodin, 1974) refers to minimizing or eliminating the cues that can lead to overeating and unhealthy eating. This includes practices such as keeping only low-fat snacks in the house or, if that is not possible, making sure any high-fat snacks are out of sight and making sure that all food is wrapped and put away. Some amount of assertiveness training may be necessary to help clients effectively communicate their need for cooperation in this area to family and friends.
4. Exercise Numerous studies have demonstrated that regular aerobic exercise contributes to initial weight loss and the successful maintenance of weight loss (Pavlou, Krey, Steffee, 1989; Racette, Schoeller, Kushner, & Neil, 1995). These and other studies have found that sustained regular exercise contributes to long-term weight loss in a variety of ways. Long-term aerobic exercise raises the metabolic rate, an essential element of weight loss. Furthermore, it encourages the body to burn fat, builds muscle, and reduces the appetite. Participants committed to regular aerobic exercise during weight loss tend to be more successful at losing weight initially, more likely to maintain weight loss over the long term, and more compliant with treatment than those who do not. Positive psychological effects have also been noted even when the level of exercise is below that which would have a physiological impact (Brownell & Wadden, 1992). This points to the value not only of programmed exercise (e.g., aerobics, racquetball, and treadmill) but also lifestyle exercises (e.g., gardening and walking the dog) in a weight-loss program.
5. Practice Cognitive Restructuring Obese individuals exhibit cognitive distortions, including overgeneralization and arbitrary inference (Kramer & Stalker, 1989). Overgenerulizution refers to extrapolating an all-encompassing rule about life from one or a few incidents. For example, a participant who fails to lose any weight after 1 week of following a weight-loss program might conclude “I’ll never lose any weight. I’m just meant to be fat.” Arbimury inference refers to coming to a conclusion-usually an extreme, negative conclusion-de-
I02
ROBERT R. RADOMILE
spite the absence of any supporting evidence. For example, despite being enthusiastically welcomed at a social gathering, an overweight person might conclude “They think I’m lazy and fat and obnoxious, and they really don’t want me here.” Other cognitive distortions include catastrophizing and dichotomous thinking. In catastrophizing, a negative occurrence is projected in a given situation, the damaging impact of which is thought of as insurmountable. For example, an individual trying to lose weight looks ahead to an upcoming holiday meal, imagines himself not being able to exercise any selfcontrol, and concludes that his weight-loss efforts will be irreversibly destroyed, rather than at worse temporarily sidetracked. Dichotomous thinking is all-or-nothing thinking in which there is only absolute success or total failure, no in-between. For example, a program participant might consider weight loss hopeless and herself a complete failure after one “slip” in the program. Identifying and correcting such self-defeating cognitive distortions is critical to successful treatment. The ability to reframe past and present setbacks as a normal part of the change process and valuable as learning opportunities can be the difference between an individual continuing to work at weight loss or one giving up in frustration and disgust. Cognitivebehavior therapy (CBT) has been found to be effective in treating all aspects of eating disorders, including correcting abnormal attitudes about weight and body shape and promoting normal cognitive and behavioral coping skills to resist the urge to binge (Wilson & Fairburn, 1993).
6. Reduce or Eliminate Binge Eating Binge eating, as defined in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (4th ed.; American Psychiatric Association, 1994), involves the consumption of a large amount of food in a discrete period of time (e.g., 1 hour, 2 hours) and a feeling of being out of control over what is eaten during the episode. Binge eating has been found to be a problem for nearly half of the participants studied in hospital and university-based weight-control programs (Marcus, Wing, & Hopkins, 1988; Marcus, Wing, & Lamparski, 1985;’Spitzer et al., 1991; Telch, Agras, & Rossiter, 1988). Binges and the out-of-control feeling experienced during binges reinforce for the individual the familiar feelings of hopelessness and worthlessness. Binges can prompt people to purge, try starving themselves, or give up altogether. The reduction of binge eating has been shown to correlate to both decreased depression (Telch, Agras, Rossiter, Wilfley, & Kenardy, 1990) and greater weight loss (Agras et al., 1994; Smith, Marcus, & Kaye, 1992). CBT has been shown to be effective in reducing the frequency of binge eating (Smith, Marcus, & Kaye, 1992