ected Topics in Electronics and Systei
OS RF MODELING, CHARACTERIZATION AND APPLICATIONS
CMOS RF MODELING, CHARACTERIZATION AND APPLICATIONS
SELECTED TOPICS IN ELECTRONICS AND SYSTEMS Editor-in-Chief:
M. S. Shur
Published Vol. 6: Low Power VLSI Design and Technology eds. G. Yeap and F. Najm Vol. 7:
Current Trends in Optical Amplifiers and Their Applications ed. T. P. Lee
Vol. 8:
Current Research and Developments in Optical Fiber Communications in China eds. Q.-M. Wang and T. P. Lee
Vol. 9:
Signal Compression: Coding of Speech, Audio, Text, Image and Video ed. N. Jayant
Vol. 10: Emerging Optoelectronic Technologies and Applications ed. Y.-H. Lo Vol. 11: High Speed Semiconductor Lasers ed. S. A. Gurevich Vol. 12: Current Research on Optical Materials, Devices and Systems in Taiwan eds. S. Chi and T. P. Lee Vol. 13: High Speed Circuits for Lightwave Communications ed. K.-C. Wang Vol. 14: Quantum-Based Electronics and Devices eds. M. Dutta and M. A. Stroscio Vol. 15: Silicon and Beyond eds. M. S. Shur and T. A. Fjeldly Vol. 16: Advances in Semiconductor Lasers and Applications to Optoelectronics eds. M. Dutta and M. A. Stroscio Vol. 17: Frontiers in Electronics: From Materials to Systems eds. Y. S. Park, S. Luryi, M. S. Shur, J. M. Xu and A. Zaslavsky Vol. 18: Sensitive Skin eds. V. Lumelsky, Michael S. Shur and S. Wagner Vol. 19: Advances in Surface Acoustic Wave Technology, Systems and Applications (Two volumes), volume 1 eds. C. C. W. Ruppel and T. A. Fjeldly Vol. 20: Advances in Surface Acoustic Wave Technology, Systems and Applications (Two volumes), volume 2 eds. C. C. W. Ruppel and T. A. Fjeldly Vol. 21: High Speed Integrated Circuit Technology, Towards 100 GHz Logic ed. M. Rodwell Vol. 22: Topics in High Field Transport in Semiconductors eds. K. F. Brennan and P. P. Ruden Vol. 23: Oxide Reliability: A Summary of Silicon Oxide Wearout, Breakdown, and Reliability ed. D. J. Dumin
Selected Topics in Electronics and Systems - Vol. 24
CMOS RF MODELING, CHARACTERIZATION AND APPLICATIONS
Editors
M. Jamal Deen McMaster University, Canada
Tor A. Fjeldly Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Norway
, © World Scientific !•
New Jersey • London • Singapore • Hong Kong
Published by World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd. P O Box 128, Farrer Road, Singapore 912805 USA office: Suite IB, 1060 Main Street, River Edge, NJ 07661 UK office: 57 Shelton Street, Covent Garden, London WC2H 9HE
British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library.
CMOS RF MODELING, CHARACTERIZATION AND APPLICATIONS Copyright © 2002 by World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd. All rights reserved. This book or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in anyform or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or any information storage and retrieval system now known or to be invented, without written permission from the Publisher.
For photocopying of material in this volume, please pay a copying fee through the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, USA. In this case permission to photocopy is not required from the publisher.
ISBN 981-02-4905-5
Printed in Singapore by Mainland Press
PREFACE CMOS RF MODELING, CHARACTERIZATION AND APPLICATIONS M.JAMALDEEN Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada L8S 4K1
TOR A. FJELDLY UniK - Center for Technology at Kjeller, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, N-2027 Kjeller, Norway
The rapid evolution of semiconductor electronics technology is fueled by a never-ending demand for better performance at reduced cost, combined with a fierce global competition. For CMOS technology, this evolution is often measured in generations of three years, the time it takes for manufactured memory capacity to be increased by a factor of four and for logic circuit density to increase by a factor of between two and three. Technologically, this trend is made possible by a downscaling of transistor feature size (i.e., gate length) by a factor of two per two generations. Traditionally, the highfrequency properties of silicon MOSFETs have been considered inferior to other technologies, including silicon bipolar transistors and transistors based on III-V materials such as gallium arsenide. However, the CMOS technology has now reached a state of evolution, in terms of both frequency and noise, where it is becoming a serious contender for radio frequency (RF) applications in the GHz range. Cut-off frequencies of about 50 GHz have been reported for 0.18 urn CMOS technology, and are expected to reach about 100 GHz when the feature size shrinks to 100 nm within a few years. This translates into CMOS circuit operating frequencies well into the GHz range, which covers the frequency range of many of the popular wireless products today, such as cell phones, GPS (Global Positioning System), and Bluetooth. Of course, the great interest in RF CMOS comes the obvious advantages of CMOS technology in terms of production cost, high-level integration, and the ability to combine digital, analog and RF circuits on the same chip. Circuit design is an integral part of electronics technology, as important as the fabrication itself. Advances in the fabrication process always pose new challenges to the circuit designers. In order to be able to take full advantage of the new technology, the designers need to update their CAD (Computer Aided Design) tools with precise
V
vi
Preface
descriptions of the new devices in terms of models that can be implemented into circuit simulators. To be able to scale the devices for different operations, the models must be physics based to account for the complex dependence of the device properties on dimensions and other processing variables. The model parameters are derived from measurements and characterization of the devices. For RF CMOS, both the modeling and the characterization are challenging tasks that will be especially emphasized in this volume. Next follows a survey of the six contributions included in the first issue. Reliable measurements are a prerequisite for any sensible work on device modeling, especially so for high frequencies where the subtleties of the device behavior are plentiful. In the first chapter of this volume, F. Sischka and T. Gneiting discuss a wide range of issues related to RF MOSFET measurements, most of which also apply to RF device characterization in general. A thorough discussion of S-parameters, Smith charts, polar plots, network analyzer measurements, de-embedding techniques, and MOSFET test structures are included, and may serve as a valuable high-level tutorial on the subject of RF measurements. In the second chapter, M. Je, I. Kwon, H. Shin, and K. Lee discuss MOSFET modeling and parameter extraction for RF applications. They review several existing techniques, many of which are based on earlier work on three-terminal III-V devices, and examine the problems and shortcomings encountered in adapting these techniques to RF MOSFETs. The fact that the MOSFET is a four-terminal device and that the silicon substrate is lossy represent major challenges. The authors emphasize the importance of using charge conserving models, especially in conjunction with parameter extraction. They also present a new four-terminal modeling approach for handling RF MOSFETs. Finally, many of the remaining challenges in RF CMOS modeling and parameter extraction are discussed. RF MOSFET modeling is also the topic of the third chapter by Y. Cheng. Equivalent circuits representing both intrinsic and extrinsic components in a MOSFET are analyzed to obtain physics-based RF models. Procedures for parameter extraction are also discussed. The analysis emphasizes the importance of certain capacitive and resistive components at high frequencies, in particular, the polysilicon gate resistance, the distributed channel resistance, and the components associated with the lossy substrate. An RF MOSFET model based on BSIM3v3 is presented, and good correspondence is obtained with experimental data obtained for different device geometries. Non-quasistatic effects are discussed in conjunction with this model. The modeling of flicker noise and thermal noise, and existing challenges in this area, are also discussed as part of this presentation. The fourth chapter by C.-C. Chen and M. J. Deen is dedicated to RF CMOS noise characterization and modeling. From small-signal models, such as some of those discussed above, it may be difficult to find analytical expressions for the fundamental noise parameters. As an alternative, the authors present techniques for calculating the noise parameters numerically. De-embedding techniques for extraction of RF MOSFET noise parameters and scattering parameters from experiments are also presented in detail, along with procedures for obtaining the frequency and bias dependencies of the extracted
Preface
vii
noise sources. Finally, this chapter includes some considerations for design of low-noise circuits, and a comparison of different noise models reported in the literature. Silicon-on-insulator (SOI) CMOS technology offers exceptional advantages in terms of low-power/low-voltage applications in digital as well as in RF and microwave circuits. In the fifth chapter, D. Flandre, J.-P. Raskin, and D. Vanhoenacker-Janvier present many aspects of the SOI CMOS technology, including SOI materials, devices and circuits, MOSFET properties, passive elements, and last but not least, the RF and microwave modeling and characterization of SOI MOSFETs. A fully developed SOI MOSFET macro model valid from DC to RF is presented, which includes transmission line effects related to both the gate and the channel. Comparisons with experiments show that this model is accurate up to 40 GHz for feature sizes down to 0.16 urn. Some examples of RF SOI CMOS applications are also presented. CMOS operating frequencies in the GHz range have been achieved through the down-scaling of device feature sizes into deep sub-micrometer dimensions. However, this has not come without penalties. Among these are the deleterious effects of hot carrier transport, brought on by a concomitant increase in the MOSFET channel electric field. The high field problem is, of course, rooted in the need for keeping the supply voltages relatively high to maintain high speed and reduce the subthreshold leakage current. Basically, the hot-electron effects lead to device degradation and, hence, represent a serious reliability problem. In the sixth chapter on RF CMOS reliability, S. Naseh and M. J. Deen consider the important issues of hot-carrier effects, and illustrate them by experimental results and simulations.
viii
Preface
M. Jamal Deen is professor of Electrical and Computer Engineering at McMaster University. He also holds the Canada Research Chair in ? •tSU't' Information Technology. He has also been professor of Engineering ; 'N ', Science at Simon Fraser University since 1993. Previously, he was "" ""* & with the CNRS Laboratory of Physics of Semiconductors Devices (LPCS), Grenoble (Visiting Scientist, summer 1998), faculty of Elec* trical Engineering (ECTM Lab), Delft University of Technology (Visiting Professor, summer 1997); Herzberg Institute of Astrophysics, National Research Council, Ottawa (Visiting Scientist, summer 1986); and Lehigh University, Bethlehem, Pennsylvania (Assistant Professor, 1985-86). His industrial experience includes a one-year visiting scientist position (1992-93) with the Device Technology Group, Northern Telecom, Ottawa, and several years of consulting and joint research with Northern Telecom, Bell Northern Research, Conexant, D&V Electronics, IBM, Mitel, National Semiconductor and Rockwell Semiconductor Systems. Dr. Deen holds the Ph.D. and M.S. degrees from Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, Ohio, U.S.A. in Electrical Engineering and Applied Physics, and the B.Sc. degree from the University of Guyana, Guyana, S. America in Physics/Mathematics. As an undergraduate student, he won the Dr. Irving Adler's Prize for the best graduating mathematics student, and the Chancellor's Medal for the second best graduating student in the University in 1978. He was also a Fulbright Scholar from 1980 to 1982, an American Vacuum Society Scholar from 1983 to 1984, an NSERC Senior Industrial Fellow in 1993. He was given a Reward of Recognition Award, Silicon Technology Division, Northern Telecom in 1993, and won the IEEE 1993 Outstanding Branch Councillor and Advisor Award for Canada. Most recently, he was awarded a Canada Research Chair in Information Technology at McMaster University. Dr. Deen is a member of Eta Kappa Nu (the Electrical Engineering Honor Society, U.S.A) and the Electrochemical Society, a life member of die American Physical Society, and a Senior Member of the IEEE. Dr. Deen is also Editor, IEEE Transactions on Electron Devices; Executive Editor, Fluctuation and Noise Letters; and Member, Editorial Board, Interface — An Electrochemical Society Publication. Dr. Deen is the co-editor of six books or conference proceedings and the co-author of thirteen book chapters and one encyclopedia article. He has authored or co-authored more than 220 peer-reviewed scientific papers, 68 conference abstracts and extended abstracts, and 48 commissioned technical reports. He is also named an inventor in five patents.
Preface
ix
Tor A. Fjeldly received the M. Sc. degree in physics from the Norwegian Institute of Technology, 1967, and the Ph.D. degree from Brown University, Providence, RI, in 1972. From 1972 to 1994, he was with Max-Planck-Institute for Solid State Physics in Stuttgart, Germany. From 1974 to 1983, he worked as a Senior Scientist at the SINTEF research organization in Norway. Since 1983, he has been on the faculty of the Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU), where he is a Professor of Electrical Engineering. He is presently with NTNU's Center for Technology at Kjeller, Norway. He was Head of the Department of Physical Electronics at NTNU, and he also served as an Associate Dean of the Faculty of Electrical Engineering and Telecommunication. From 1990 to 1997, he held the position of Visiting Professor at the Department of Electrical Engineering, University of Virginia, Charlottesville, VA, and from 1997 he has been Visiting Professor at the Electrical, Computer and Systems Engineering Department, Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, Troy, NY. His research interests have included fundamental studies of semiconductors and other solids, development of solid-state chemical sensors, electron transport in semiconductors, modeling and simulation of semiconductor devices, and circuit simulation. He has written about 150 scientific papers, several book chapters, and is a co-author of the books Semiconductor Device Modeling for VLSI (Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall, 1993) and Introduction to Device Modeling and Circuit Simulation (New York, NY: Wiley & Sons, 1998). He is also a co-developer of the circuit simulator AIM-Spice. Since 1998, he has been a Co-Editor-in-Chief of the International Journal of High Speed Electronics and Systems, Singapore. Dr. Fjeldly is a Fellow of IEEE and a member of the Norwegian Academy of Technical Sciences, the American Physical Society, the European Physical Society and the Norwegian Society of Chartered Engineers.
This page is intentionally left blank
CONTENTS
Preface M. J. Deen and T. A. Fjeldly
v
RF MOS Measurements F. Sischka and T. Gneiting
1
MOSFET Modeling and Parameter Extraction for RF IC's M. Je, I. Kwon, H. Shin, and K. Lee
67
MOSFET Modeling for RF IC Design Y. Cheng
121
RF CMOS Noise Characterization and Modeling C.-H. Chen and M. J. Deen
199
SOI CMOS Transistors for RF and Microwave Applications D. Flandre, J.-P. Raskin, and D. Vanhoenacker-Janvier
273
RF CMOS Reliability S. Naseh and M. J. Deen
363
International Journal of High Speed Electronics and Systems, Vol. 11, No. 4 (2001) 887-951 © World Scientific Publishing Company
RF MOS MEASUREMENTS FRANZ SISCHKA Agilent Technologies GmbH, Munich, Germany THOMAS GNEITING admos, Frickenhausen, Germany
The trend to higher integration and higher transmission speed challenges modeling engineers to develop accurate device models up to the Gigahertz range. An absolute prerequisite for achieving this goal are reliable measurements, which have to be checked for data consistency and plausibility. This is especially true for RF data, and also for checking and verifying the applied de-embedding techniques. If this is not the case, RF modeling can become quite time consuming, with a lot of guesswork and ad-hoc judgements, and, basically, frustrating and not correct. If, however, the underlying measurements are flawless and consistent, and provided the applied the models are understood well, RF modeling becomes very effective and provides accurate design kits which will satisfy the chip designer's main goal: right the fist time.
1
Characterizing Devices From D C To High Frequencies
While the characterization of electronic components in the DC domain is relatively simple and only requires a voltmeter and an amperemeter, the frequency performance of the device is affected by magnitude dependence and phase shift of the currents and voltages. Furthermore, nonlinearities will lead to a spectrum of frequencies, although the device is only stimulated with a single, sine frequency. Last not least, inevitable capacitive and inductive parasitics, with values close to those of the very device under test (DUT), will contribute to the measurements and degrade the measured performance of the 'inner' DUT. [1,2]
In this paper, we will go step by step through the individual characterization issues and develop measurement strategies which will provide the base of accurate device modeling.
2
DC Measurements As A Prerequisite For RF Setups
Large signal modeling of a nonlinear component always begins with the characterization of its DC performance. Instead of power supplies, DC parametric analyzers with sourcemonitor-unit plugins (SMU) are applied. This allows to fully characterize the DUT (device under test) from fempto-Ampere up to its maximum current, and in all four i-v quadrants. I.e. forward and reverse currents and voltages, are measured with the same SMU unit. l
888
F. Sischka & T.
Gneiting
Usually, in case of a transistor, all 4 terminals (including substrate) are connected to individual SMUs in order to avoid recabling during the forward and reverse measurements.
SMUs apply a Kelvin measurement to avoid parasitic series resistances. This measurement procedure, also known as the four-wire method, consists of a stimulating line (Force) with a second one in parallel (Sense) for every pin of the DUT. Fig. 1 illustrates this. Ohmic losses on the Force line are eliminated by the main operational amplifier (OpAmpl) in voltage follower mode. This means this OpAmpl output will exhibit a somewhat higher voltage than the desired test voltage at the DUT, because the test current generates some ohmic losses along the Force line. The Sense line, connected to the minus input of the OpAmpl, assures that the DUT is biased with exactly the desired test voltage.
SMU
OpAmp2 External Shielding
* L
Ohmic Losses
±
d
OpAmpl
r
•AM/v^-
-r
Dielectric Losses
I desired I voltage
Measurement Instrument
F
Inner Shielding Force
Sense Test Potential
Metering Lines
Fig. 1: The principle of Kelvin measurements (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
While this method compensates the DC errors, it does not cover dynamic measurement problems. For example, to avoid external electro-magnetic influences, both the Force and Sense cables are shielded. Such cable shieldings exhibit parasitic capacitances. Due to charging problems, these capacitances will affect the measurement speed and accuracy of our Kelvin measurement. As a simple example: assume we want to measure the reverse characteristics of a semiconductor diode. This means we need measure very low currents. Before the voltage steps to, e.g. -20 V, the quiescent voltage at the diode is zero. That is, the cable capacitors are not charged. When the negative voltage step occurs, these capacitances have to be charged, and the required current is provided by the OpAmpl. This could lead to either a mis-measurement (DUT current plus charging current) or a delay in the triggering of the actual current measurement (by some intelligent firmware in our measurement). To solve this problem, an extra inner shielding is applied between the hot metering lines and the outer cable shielding, called 'Guard'. This extra shielding is connected to a separate,
2
RF MOS Measurements
889
second 0pAmp2 which follows exactly the value of the desired test voltage. Now it is this auxiliary OpAmp2 which supplies the charging current for the test cables, while the main Op Amp 1 can start current measurements independently of this charging problem. That is, the inner measurement loop does not see the charging problem any more. Of course the point where Force and Sense are tied together must be as close as possible to the DUT. In case they aren't connected, an internal lOkOhm resistor at the . of the SMU acts as the Kelvin point. Another important fact is that the Guard comae i should never be connected to Force or Sense. Otherwise, the inner loop OpAmpl of the SMU would measure the DUT current plus the charging current of the auxiliary, second OpAmp2! In order to maintain the DC measurement accuracy, SMUs perform periodically an autocalibration. This means that the SMU disconnects its outputs from the DUT, measures possible offset voltages and currents and corrects it. This type of calibration does not require any action from the user. See publications [3] and [4] for details.
3
Capacitance Measurements At 1MHz
As discussed in the previous chapter, the DC voltages and currents can be measured directly. The calibration is periodically auto-executed by the instrument. After such a DC characterization, modeling engineers usually perform a so-called CV (capacitance versus voltage) measurement in order to characterize the device capacitances at a standard frequency of 1MHz. This frequency is high enough to allow a resolution down to a few fempto-Ampere (provided shielded probes are applied for e.g. on-wafer measurements), yet still low enough to neglect second order parasitics like resistors in series with the capacitors, or like inductances. For such CV measurements, the DC-bias is swept, a test frequency (1MHz) is applied to the DUT, and the instrument calculates the capacitance between the 2 pins of the DUT from the magnitude and phase of the device voltage and current. For CV meters, an auto-balancing method is typically applied. Fig. 2 depicts the simplified measurement scheme. The DUT is inserted in the feedback loop of an operational amplifier, and the system is stimulated with a 1MHz sine signal plus a DC bias. The feedback resistor R is precisely known, and the complex voltages VI and Vdut are measured. From the formula given in Fig. 2, the capacitance of the DUT can be calculated, assuming an equivalent schematic of either a resistor in series with the capacitor, or, commonly for modeling, a capacitor in parallel with a resistor (which is the bias-dependent diode resistance for example).
3
890
F. Sischka & T.
Gneiting
CV meter applying the auto-balancing method DUT
V
V
Zx
sine frequency + DC bias
R
Hint: LOW potential is virtual ground !
Fig.2: schematic measurement principle of a CV meter (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
Again, test cables and fixtures contribute and affect the device characterization. Here, the measurement calibration consists of unconnecting the DUT, assuming an ideal OPEN condition and measuring the cables and their OPEN parasitics. The corresponding capacitance is then automatically subtracted from the subsequent DUT measurement. Note: If we are interested in the inner DUT's CV curves, i.e. without its surrounding test pads capacitances, we need to connect to an OPEN dummy structure during CV meter calibration. Such an OPEN dummy consists of all connection pads, lines to the DUT etc, but without the inner DUT itself. See Figures 34 and 46 for examples. When characterizing the capacitances of transistors, the open 3rd transistor terminal can be connected to the shielding potential, eliminating the effect of the unwanted capacitor. See Fig. 3, and also publication [5] for details.
taffies
w ©53®
QOSH
Measurement of CDG With the auto-balancing method, connecting the Source to the cable shielding potential, eliminates the effect of CGS
Fig. 3: measuring transistor capacitances with a CV meter (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
4
RF MOS Measurements
4
891
From Y-, Z-, And H-Parameters To S-Parameters
While the CV measurement is considered as a specific two-pin test condition, the situation changes for frequencies above 100MHz. The modeling device is now operated under its originally intended environment conditions: DC bias is applied to all the pins, and an additional small-signal RF excitation is applied. Now, the sine currents and voltages at all pins of the DUT are to be measured, with magnitude and phase. A natural choice for such characterizations would be Z-, Y- or H-parameters from linear two-port theory. These two-port parameters can be used to completely describe the electrical behavior of our device (or network), including any source and load conditions. For such parameters, we have to measure the voltage or current as a function of frequency and bias at the ports of the device. At high frequencies, however, it is very hard to measure voltage and current at the device ports. One cannot simply connect a voltmeter or current probe and get accurate measurements due to the impedance of the probes themselves and the difficulty to place the probes at the desired positions. Furthermore we have to apply either (AC-wise) OPEN or SHORT circuits as part of the Z-, Y- or H-parameter measurement. Active devices may oscillate or self-destruct with such terminations.
4.1
Introducing S-Parameters
Clearly, some other way of characterizing high-frequency networks is required that doesn't have these drawbacks. That is why scattering or S-parameters were developed. These parameters relate to familiar measurements such as gain, loss, and reflection coefficient. They are relatively simple to measure, and do not require connection of undesirable loads to the DUT. Different to Y and Z, however, they relate to the traveling waves that are scattered or reflected when a network is inserted into a transmission line of a certain characteristic impedance ZO. The measured S-parameters of multiple devices can be cascaded to predict overall system performance. S-parameters are readily used in both linear and nonlinear CAE circuit simulation tools, and Z-, Y- or H-parameters can be derived from S-parameters when necessary. To help with becoming familiar with linear S-parameters, we want to give a short example on characterizing components using power measurements, the lightwave analogy for Transmission and Reflection. Since a circuit described by S-parameters can be thought of like inserted into a uniform characteristic impedance (ZO) environment, we can compare Sparameters to reflection and transmission of an optical lens, surrounded at both sides by air. When light interacts with a lens, as in the photograph of Fig. 4, part of the light incident on the eyeglasses is reflected while the rest is transmitted. The amounts reflected and transmitted are characterized by optical reflection and transmission coefficients. By performing such a measurement, your optician is able to characterize your eyeglasses completely.
5
892
F. Sischka
& T.
Gneiting
Fig. 4: reflection and transmission with eyeglasses (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
Similarly, scattering parameters are measures of reflection and transmission of voltage waves through a two-port electrical network, inserted into a uniform characteristic impedance environment. Definition of S-parameters Referring once again to the spectacles examples from above, i.e. power-wise, the S-parameters are defined as: 2\
Pi I
I
2
i
I ajl 2 ibjl
|2 §2 I
i2
I—22 I
with
f
*
,
J
power wave traveling towards the two-port gate
2
power wave reflected back from the two-port gate
and I SnI2
power reflected from portl
ISi2l2
power transmitted from portl to port2
2
power transmitted from port2 to portl
IS.21I
IS22I2
power reflected from port2
This means that S-parameters relate traveling waves (power) to a two-port's (DUT) reflection and transmission behavior. Since the two-port is imbedded in a characteristic impedance of ZO, these 'waves' can be interpreted in terms of normalized voltage or current amplitudes. This is sketched below.
6
RF MOS Measurements
la,!2
893
-
lb, I2 « Zh
tWt*[
._ , f iiin'niiii
Starting with power
normalized toZo V*V
P=v*i
gives normalized amplitudes for voltage and current V
- VP =
3)
a,
^
•*
1-7
-o = I JZc
In other words, we can convert the power towards the two-port into a normalized voltage amplitude of towards _ twoport
VZo"
(1)
and the power away from the two-port can be interpreted in terms of voltages like L.
away _ from _ twoport
(2) See Fig. 5 for details.
Fig. 5: S-parameter definition (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
7
894
F. Sischka & T.
Gneiting
Looking at the S-parameter coefficients individually, we have: v
_ b1
0
reflected at portl
211 £1
_ b2 _
Q
Vtowards portl
v
o u t of port2
—21 ^1
^towards portl
(3) S l l and S21 are determined by measuring the magnitude and phase of the incident, reflected and transmitted signals when the output is terminated in a perfect ZO load. This condition guarantees that a2 is zero. Sll is equivalent to the input complex reflection coefficient or impedance of the DUT, and S21 is the forward complex transmission coefficient. Likewise, by placing the source at port 2 and terminating port 1 in a perfect load (making al zero), S22 and S12 measurements can be made. S22 is equivalent to the output complex reflection coefficient or output impedance of the DUT, and S12 is the reverse complex transmission coefficient. The accuracy of S-parameter measurements depends greatly on how good a termination we apply to the port not being stimulated. Anything other than a perfect load will result in al or a2 not being zero (which violates the definition for S-parameters). When the DUT is connected to the test ports of a network analyzer and we don't account for imperfect test port match, we have not done a very good job satisfying the condition of a perfect termination. For this reason, two-port calibration, which corrects for source and load match, is very important for accurate S-parameter measurements. In order to become more familiar with S-parameters, we will now discuss some specific Sparameter values.
SllandS22 value -1 0 +1
interpretation all voltage amplitudes towards the twoport are inverted and reflected (Oil) impedance matching, no reflections at all (50 Q) voltage amplitudes are reflected (infinite Q.)
The magnitude of Sll and S22 is always less than 1. Otherwise, it would represent a negative ohmic resistor (!). On the other hand, the magnitude of S21 (transfer characteristics) respectively S12 (reverse) can exceed the value of 1 in the case of active amplification. Also, the starting
RF MOS Measurements
895
points of S21 and S12 can be positive or negative. If they are negative, there is a phase inversion. As an example, S21 of a transistor starts usually at about S21 = -2 ...-10. This means signal amplification within the ZO environment and phase inversion.
S21andS12 magnitude 0 0...+1 +1 >+1
interpretation no signal transmission at all input signal is damped in the Z0 environment unity gain signal transmission in the ZO environment input signal is amplified in the ZO environment
The numbering convention for S-parameters is that the first number following the S is the port at which energy emerges, and the second number is the port at which energy enters. So S21 is a measure of power emerging from Port 2 as a result of applying an RF stimulus to Port 1.
4.2
Smith Chart And Polar Plot
The Smith chart for Sxx What makes Sxx-parameters especially interesting for modeling, is that S11 and S22 can be interpreted as complex input or output resistances of the two-port. That's why they are usually plotted in a Smith chart. NOTE: do not forget that included in Sxx is the termination at the opposite side of the twoport, usually ZO !! The Smith chart is a transformation of the complex impedance plane R into the complex reflection coefficient T (rho) , following the formula:
^R-Z0 ~ R + zo r
(1)
with the system's characteristic impedance ZO = 50 Q. This means that the right half of the complex impedance plane circle in the r-domain. The circle radius is '1' (see Fig. 6).
9
R
is transformed into a
896
F. Sischka & T.
Gneiting
R-50 R
r=
R + 50
j50 Ohm
50 Ohm
Fig. 6: the relationship between Sxx and the complex impedance of a two-port. (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
On the other hand, using a network analyzer with a characteristic system impedance of ZO, the parameter S11 is equal to
S„=2.^-1 v01
(2)
where vl is the complex voltage at port 1 and vOl the stimulating AC source voltage (which is typically normalized to 'I'). Fig. 7 depicts the corresponding circuit schematic. twoport ZO
ZO
V01
Fig. 7: about the definition of SI 1
V1
(S22 is analogous) (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
Under the assumption that R is the complex input resistance at port 1 and ZO is the system impedance, we get using eq.(2) and the resistive divider formula for Fig. 7:
R-ZO S»11 n = 2--=— -1 = = R + ZO R + ZO And this is the reflection coefficient T from(l)!!
10
RF MOS Measurements
897
NOTE: see also the chapter called 'Calculating S-Parameters From Complex Voltages' further down. After all, if the reflection coefficient T resp. Sj j or S22 is known, we get for the complex
i+r 1+s-n R = ZO • —-=• = ZO • — 1-T 1-S1 11
resistor R:
, with usually ZO = 50 Q
This explains how we can get the complex input/output resistance of a two-port directly from S11 or S22, if we plot these S-parameters in a Smith chart. Let's go back to Fig. 6 and consolidate this context a little further: it shows a square with the corners (0/0)Q, (50/0)Q, (50/j50)Q and (0/j50)ii in the complex impedance plane and its equivalent in the Smith chart with ZO=50£2. Please watch the angel-preserving property of this transform (rectangles stay rectangles close to their origins). Also watch how the positive and negative imaginary axis of the R plane is transformed into the Smith chart domain ( T ), and where (50/j50)Q is located in the Smith chart. Also verify that the center of the Smith chart represents ZO, i.e. for ZO = 50Q, the center of the Smith chart is (50/j0)Q. This allows us to make the following statements: > Sxx on the real axis represent ohmic resistors > Sxx above the real axis represent inductive impedances > Sxx below the real axis represent capacitive impedances > Sxx curves in the Smith chart turn clock-wise with increasing frequency. Fig. 8 depicts this graphically.
<*»**&tt0>
— K>
CD ED
Fig. 8: Location of ohmic, inductive and capacitive components in the Smith chart (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
11
898
F. Sischka
& T.
Gneiting
As an example for interpreting Smith charts, Fig. 9a shows the S l l plot of a bipolar transistor. In this case, the locus curve stars with S l l = 1 = ° ° * Z Q at low frequencies corresponding to R g g ' + R^j 0( j e + beta*Rr£. For increasing frequencies, the curves then turn into the lower half-plane of the Smith chart, the capacitive region. Here, the C g g shorts R(jiode' anc* beta = 1- F ° r infinite frequency, when the capacitors represent ideal shorts, the end point of S] j lies on the middle axis, i.e. the input impedance is completely ohmic, representing Rgg> + Rr£- Since Rgg> is bias dependent, and decreasing with increasing iB, the end points of the curves represent this bias-dependency. NOTE: For incrementing frequency, the Sxx locus curves turn always clockwise! Fig. 9b shows the S l l curve of a capacitor located between the two ports of the network analyzer (NWA). The capacitor represents an OPEN for DC, thus S11 = 1 = °°*Z0. For highest frequencies, it behaves like a SHORT, and we see the 50 Q of the opposite port2 (!). The transition between the DC point and infinite frequency follows a circle, and the increasing frequency turns the curve again clockwise.
S11
Fig. 9a: Si i of a transistor with increasing Base current iB. (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
12
RF MOS Measurements
899
-F i™ e CI
Fig. 9b: Si ^ of a capacitor between port 1 and port 2
7%e PoZar diagram for Sxy
Fig.10: The polar diagram for S12 and S21 (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
The S21 parameter represents the power transmission from port 1 to port 2, if the two-port is inserted into a matching network with characteristic impedance Z0 of e.g. 50 Q. This means, if no signal is transmitted, then S21=0 (located in the center of the polar plot). If the signal is transmitted, then MAG(S21)>0. The magnitude of the S21 curve will be below T for damping between the port 1 and port 2, and above 1' for amplification. If the phase is inverted, we are basically in the left half-plane of the polar plot (REAL[S21]<0). Like with the Smith chart, all S21 and S12 curves turn clock-wise with increasing frequency. As an example, Fig. 11a shows the S21 plot of a bipolar transistor, and Fig. l i b of a capacitor between port 1 and port 2. While the transistor starts with REAL(S21) < -1 at low frequencies (voltage amplification in a 50 £2 system, plus phase inversion), its curves tend towards S 2 1 = 0 for highest frequencies (no voltage transmission, the transistor capacitances short all voltage transmission). Since the current amplification 6 is bias
13
900
F. Sischka & T.
Gneiting
depending, the start point of the S21 curve at lowest frequencies reflects this 6(iB) dependency: more 6 for higher iB, i.e. more amplification magnitude with S21 for higher iB too. For the capacitor in Fig. l i b , it's just the opposite: no power transmission for lowest frequencies, but an ideal short (S21=l) for highest frequencies. T—i—i—I—r
0
-6.0
-4.0
RERL
-2.0
0.0
2.0
CE+0]
Fig. 11a: S21 of a transistor with varying Base current iB. (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
Ld
m
•;,
-0.5
RECRU
CEC+-0D
Fig. 1 lb: S21 of a capacitor between port 1 and port 2 (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
14
RF MOS Measurements 901
4.3
Useful Notes On S-Parameter Properties
S12 = S21for linear, passive circuits As can be derived from the theory, the Sxy-parameters for passive circuits are equal. MAG(Sxy) <1 for passive circuits. If an active device exhibits power then MAG(Sxy) > 1
amplification
in
the
Z0
environment,
Simple R-L-C circuits have S-parameter curves following half-circles An L-C resonator is an overlay of two half-circles, i.e. represents a full circle. Delay lines appear like phase shifters. All S-parameter curves turn clock-wise with increasing frequency. Because the Sxx parameters, displayed in a Smith chart, can be linked to a locus curve in the complex impedance plane, the Smith chart curve index increment can be related to frequency. It is clear that in the impedance plane, the locus curve for an inductor follows jcoL, i.e. the locus curve starts at '0' and then goes upward. Referring to the Smith chart transformation, this upgoing refers to following a circle, starting at T = -l, and ending at r = +1. I.e. this curve turns clockwise with increasing frequency. For a capacitor, it is just similar: in the impedance plane, a 1/jcoC comes from minus infinity towards '0' for highest frequency. In the Smith chart, this corresponds to a halfcircle, starting at T = +1, and ending at T = -1, again turning clock-wise. Similar considerations can be applied to prove that also for the Sxy paramters, the locus curves in a polar diagram also turn clockwise. Generally speaking, if a measured curve turns counter-clockwise, even only for a frequency sub-range, we have a underlying measurement problem, most possibly a calibration problem. On the other hand, if such a counter-clockwise turning happens for a deembedded curve, and the not de-embedded curve looked ok (all clock-wise), we have a over-de-embedding problem.
4.4
Multiport S-Parameters
The number of multiport parameters for a given device is equal to the square of the number of ports. For example, a two-port device has four S-parameters. Like with Z-, Y- or Hparameters , multiport S-parameters can be obtained by overlying two-port measurements with the not used ports terminated accordingly. For S-parameters, this means a termination by the characteristic impedance Z0. In order to transform e.g. Common-Emitter S-Parameters to Common-Base, we will now consider 3-Port S-Parameters. Provided a certain port is connected to ground, we are then able to evaluate the conversion formulas.
15
902 F. Sischka & T. Gneiting
Converting from 3-PORT to 2-PORT Provided that the device under test is connected with Z0 (e.g. 50 Q) to all its 3 ports, the 3pole network S-parameters are defined as:
b 1 =S 1 1 a, + S12 a 2 +S 1 3 a3 b2 = o 21 a t + o 22 a2 + o 23 a3
^3
=
S31 * a, + S32 * a2 + S 33 a3
^
If port 3 is connected to ground, we get for the corresponding reflection coefficient F^
|\=^2. = -1 (2)
Thus we get the 2-port network parameters from the 3-port ones as:
s„
s13
S 21
- s31
°31
1+ S33
S'12 19
°23
°13 —
O'n2o 2 —
1+S 33
°32
"
I + S33 O' 29 o3
O 32
1+S 33
'O V " J
(3)
Converting from 2-PORT to 1-PORT Such a conversion is required if a component has been measured in two-port mode, and some of its components characteristics might be affected by the characteristic impedance of the opposite VNA port. An example is the calculation of the quality factor of a spiral inductor directly out of S-parameters. In this case, we refer to equation. (3) from above and obtain: S12 ^11
1port
—
^11
S21
1 + S22
From that, we apply the basic S,, 0 R conversion, mentioned in the above chapter on Smith charts,
R = Z0-
1 + S11 1-S 11
and obtain for the input impedance at Port 1
16
RF MOS Measurements 903 *'+Sn_iport
_y
7
^-11_1port ~ *-0
1-Sn. 1port
From this, we can obtain the requested 1-Port characteristic like the Q factor of a spiral inductor QJMAG(Z111port)
REAL(Z111port) Converting from 2-PORT to 3-PORT Using the matrix in (3), we can also calculate the 3-port S-parameters out of 2-port parameters. We know that: 3 2-Sjj=1 i=1 and 3 £^=1
for i=i,2,3
j=i23
for
i=1
So we can calculate the 3-port S-parameters out of the 2-port ones, with Index T (Two-port Measurement):
ssijT C _ °33~
i=1,2 J=1.2
4 - 1 S ijT 1=1.2 1=1,2
^32 -
p
U~S 1 2 T ~"S 2 2 T )
=
z
U-S21T -S22T)
^23 O ^22
—
^>31
=
O
, ^23
^ZZl
^
' ~~ S 3 3
+
^32
1+S33 ~~ S32
S13 = 1 - S 2 3 ~~ S33 S12 = 1 - S 2 2 _ 3 2 S11 = 1 _ S 2 i ~ ^ 3 1
s
S2i = 1 - S 2 2 _ ^ 2 3
17
904
F. Sischka & T.
Gneiting
Once these 3-port S-parameters are known, they can be used to calculate the common-Base or common-Collector 2-port S-parameters of a bipolar transistor etc.
4.5
Calculating S-Parameters From Complex Voltages
Measurementwise, S-parameters refer to the backreflected and transmitted RF power of a component under RF excitation. Most SPICE simulators, however, do not feature Sparameter simulations. But they can simulate complex voltages/currents vs. fireq. Therefore, instead of the missing feature, a method to calculate S-parameters from complex voltages can be applied. As it was mentioned before, S-parameters can be interpreted in terms of voltage at the DUT in a Z0 environment. The following sketch gives an explanation about how to calculate them for a given two-port (DUT), imbedded in an external circuit, which itself represents the characteristic impedance. In order to get the required complex forward and reverse voltages Vi, V0i, V2, V02 (to satisfy the equations (1) .. (4) of Fig. 12), a single SPICE simulation containing twice the embedded DUT is performed. Zl = Z2 = Z0, e.g.ZO = 5012
twoport
Z1
V01
V2
S11=2*-l--1 v 01 §21=2*
(1)
^2_ V01
(2)
Zl = Z2 = Z0, e.g.ZO = 50 Q
twoport
Zl
yo
VQ2
VI
18
RF MOS Measurements
S
-
12
905
-2*-^-
~ V^
(3)
v
V0 ,2
S22=2*^--1 v
02
(4)
Fig. 12: calculating S-parameters out of SPICE simulations (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
For details please refer to publications [6] to [8].
5
Network Analyzer Measurements
After the introduction to the S-parameters, it is time to consider how to measure them. A network analyzer (NWA), also called vector network analyzer (VNA), is applied. This instrument measures S-parameter vectors, i.e. the magnitude and phase, of all four Sparameters of a two-port. This is particularly important for device modeling, because there are also instruments available, which are called network analyzers, but rather are impedance analyzers, and which allow only to perform so-called 1-port measurements. However, a full two-port measurement is the important feature, because only in this case are we able to convert the measured S-parameters to Y- and Z-parameters etc., what is a requirement for de-embedding. When applying network analyzers for S-parameter measurements, it is important to remember that we measure linear circuit performance and circuit performance for a given frequency, ignoring harmonics. On the other hand, network analyzers can also be applied to specific non-linear measurements, e.g. sweeping the RF power, measuring the transfer characteristics and evaluating for example the ldB compression point of amplifiers. In this case, however, signal distortion happens and harmonic frequencies show up. On the other hand, when using a NWA, always the base frequency and its transfer compression are measured. Therefore, if we are interested in the modeling of device nonlinearities, we should apply a spectrum analyzer after the conventional DC-CV-NWA modeling, and use harmonic balance simulation to model the RF-power dependent spectrum. Alternatively, one of the currently introduced commercial nonlinear NWAs can be used as well. In the following, we will refer to linear network analyzers.
5.1
Network Analyzer Measurement Principle
A two-port network analyzer measures the power transmission and reflection in magnitude and phase at two locations, port 1 and port 2.
19
906 F. Sischka & T. Gneiting
It basically consists of a wobbled, high frequency signal generator (RF synthesizer), an S-parameter test set to acquire the input and reflected power at the DUT for both ports, and a control and display unit (mainframe), see Fig. 13 below.
K
signal flow
hpib
Network Analyzer Mainframe RF Synthesizer
© portl
©
s-Parameter Testset port2
test device DUT Fig. 13: vector network analyzer components (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
For the measurement, the DUT is connected between the two ports. The RF synthesizer signal is fed into the S-parameter testset and applied alternately to port 1 and port 2. Measured is the signal of that specific frequency reflected back from the DUT to port 1, the signal transmitted from port 1 to port 2, and then, when the RF signal is applied to port 2, the reverse behavior.
The S-parameter testset. The block diagram of Fig. 14 shows the core of this meter combination, the S-parameter testset. The RF Input source at the top, connected to the RF synthesizer, provides the stimulus power. The PIN switch directs the signal to either a forward or a reverse Sparameter measurement. Directional couplers then detect the injected and reflected power of the DUT. The detected signals are downcoverted into IF signals for further analysis in the NWA mainframe, where all the 4 signals are digitized and signal processed in order to give the S-parameters. Note the signal naming: R: reference signal, A: reflected signal at port 1, B: transmitted signal from port 1 to port 2
20
RF MOS Measurements
907
5o
in
i is tl in
I
o
LO.V7
PIN SWITCH
99V9
IF.
2 X
o X
H h
AAAA
A R
0-90dB
^ ^
^ J"h <^)-^^A^
20dB 20dB
X
I
6dB 0-90dB
0-90dB
V^ PIN SWITCH
2MB 20dB
6dB
A B PIN SWITCH
J
PUT
Fig. 14: Block diagram of the S-parameter testset (4-sampler). R: reference signal A: reflected signal at port 1 B: transmitted signal from port 1 to port 2 (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
4-sampler vs. 3-sampler network analyzers There are two main S-parameter testset principles: 3-sampler and 4-sampler, see Fig. 15. In case of a 3-sampler, the reference signal is coupled-out before the PIN switch. Therefore, the switching errors are not included in the calibration. For a 4-sampler VNA, however, where the reference signals are detected after the switch to the two ports, a better calibration can be performed, including all error terms. Usually, this is important for frequencies above ~20GHz. Also, with the 4-sampler VNA, the user has complete freedom with regard to his own calibration techniques and does not need to use simplified procedures.
21
908
F. Sischka & T.
Source
Gneiting
I . >
fe
A n— Portl
Transfer switcn
3Vfc
-cr Port2
Fig. 15: principle of a 3-sampler and a 4-sampler VNA. (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
Note: in both cases, the signal power at the reference port R should not be too small. Otherwise, the downconverter might have phase locking problems. The NWA error message reads in this case: "phase lock lost".
5.2
Network Analyzer With DC Bias
In order to measure S-parameter of active components, the operating point (DC bias) must be set. This is performed with AC/DC bias TEEs. Such components consist basically of a big inductor (to feed the DC bias) and a big capacitor (to feed the HF signal), see Fig. 16. DC IN coax toSMU
DC & HF OUT
Fig. 16: bias TEE to couple DC bias and HF signal (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
22
RF MOS Measurements
909
Since the applied DC bias inductor is not ideal, but also exhibits some ohmic DC losses, the voltage at the DUT (transistor, diode etc.) will not be identical to the one set up at the DC supply, i.e. the SMU. In order to compensate these DC bias losses, the ohmic loss must be carefully characterized by a separated measurement with the bias TEE's output shorted, and must be added as auxiliary test circuit to the model circuit of the DUT. As a rule of thumb, the ohmic losses are about ~2Q. For a SPICE simulator, the additional circuit is:
.SUBCKT bsim_n_DC_bias 1=G 2=D Rbiasl 1 11 2 Cbiasl 1 11 1 Rbias2 2 22 2 Cbias2 2 22 1 Xtransistor 22 11 0 0 bsim *this is a subcircuit call .ENDS Please note that in order to not affect the high frequency simulations, shunt capacitors Cbiasx are added to short the Rbiasx effects for the S-parameter simulations. With this additional circuit, the modeling simulation will perform corresponding to the measurement environment. Otherwise, if these resistors are not taken into account with the simulation, the simulated DC bias conditions will be different from the ones measured during the Sparameter measurements, what is best seen if the S21 simulations do not match the measurement data at lowest frequencies. Please note that these DC bias losses are not included in any NWA calibration. A NWA calibration refers to the NWA frequency range of e.g. 50MHz .. 50GHz and not to the DC ! In most network analyzers, these bias-TEEs are included in the the S-parameter testset, and the DC_IN is accessible by a coax connector at the rear panel. Fig. 17 sketches the required connections for this case. Note: In order to connect the DC-Analyzer Triax cables to the Coax inputs of the NWA's S-parameter testset, Triax-to-Coax converters have to be applied. Make sure these converters leave the middle shield of the Triax cable open, i.e. unconnected !
23
910
F. Sischka & T.
Gneiting
DC Source/ |ojrj Monitor 113 sU DC bias
Vector Network Analyzer
Synthesized Sweeper ® RF ® " » » » « •
control software 1C-CAP
S-parameter Test Set with internal bias TEEs
OUT
i_r Fig. 17: VNA measurements using the internal DC bias feedthrough of the S-parameter testset.
(C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
If we want to avoid the ohmic losses of the NWA's internal bias TEE, we can also apply the previously mentioned force-sense DC biasing externally (Kelvin measurements), and include a voltage sense line up to the very DUT. As a consequence, this means using double bias-TEE for each port of the NWA. Such a commercial external bias TEE is depicted in Fig. 18.
FORCE
2xtriax toSMU SENSE
DC & HF_OUT
Fig. 18: using external bias TEEs allows to apply Kelvin DC biasing also with network analyzer measurements
(C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
24
RF MOS Measurements 911 The corresponding measurement setup is shown in Fig. 19. Two external bias TEEs are applied between the two DUT connections and the network analyzer ports. This setup then allows to get rid of possible ESD (electrostatic discharge) protection shunt resistors at the NWA ports (typically 1MQ), and, of course, of the internal bias TEE inductor choke resistor. With such a measurement setup, keep in mind to not connect the guard shield of the triax Kelvin cables. Also, these Kelvin bias TEEs should be placed as close as possible to the DUT. Vector Network Analyzer Synthesized Sweeper | S-parameter I Test Set External Bias TEEs
DC Source/ Monitor
Force
DC bias
Fig. 19: VNA measurements with external force-sense DC bias supply (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
5.3
Network Analyzer Calibration
A considerable challenge in S-parameter VNA measurements is to define exactly where the measurement system ends and the DUT begins. This location is called 'reference plane'. This means, all error contributions, inside the VNA and in the cables up to this reference plane, have to be calibrated out. The point is, especially compared to CV measurements, that the calibration standards are no longer ideal, and also contribute themselves to the total calibration process.
What is a 12-term error correction As can be seen in Fig. 20, there are 6 error contribution terms in forward direction, related to the characterizing signals R, A and B of the NWA: Directivity: cross-talk of the power splitter in the NWA testset Crosstalk: cross-talk inside the S-parameter test set, overlying the DUT Source Mismatch: multiple reflections due to impedance mismatch of cables and connectors Load Mismatch: the same for the opposite port
25
912
F. Sischka & T.
Gneiting
Reflection Tracking A/R: Transmission Tracking A/R:
frequency dependence of signal path R->A same for signal path R->B
For the reverse calibration, another 6 error terms add up to a total of 12 terms. The procedure to get rid of these 12 terms is called the 12-term error correction.
power splitter
AC source
H(f)'
5
V
5
'f
frequency res|
source mimmatch
reflection tracking (A/R) transiuis* ion tracking (BM)
load mismatch
Fig. 20: the 12 error contributions for S-parameter measurements with a VNA (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
Network analyzer calibration with standards like SOLT, TRL, LRM etc. There are many different calibration techniques for network analyzers. Such are ShortOpen-Load-Thru (SOLT), Thru-Reflection-Load (TRL) or Load-Refection-Match (LRM) and the associated error correction calculations. For the different calibration procedures, specific known standard terminations have to be measured. Note: for 3-sampler NWAs, specific simplified TRL and LRM calibrations have to be applied. They are called TLR* and LRM*. Although there are many publications on the pros and contras of the different calibration methods, the SOLT is most commonly used for on-wafer measurements of silicon devices. One of the reasons is that due to the electrical losses of silicon, microstrip standards as required for LRM and TRL are difficult to manufacture on the wafer. Another reason for using SOLT is that this calibration is a wide-band calibration and not limited to a frequency band. In case of a SOLT calibration, and for on-wafer measurements using Ground-SignalGround (GSG) coplanar probes, Figures 21 and 22 depict the corresponding test structures,
26
RF MOS Measurements
913
which are usually available on a RF-high-performance ceramic substrate, including accurate description of the non-idealities of these standards.
Fig. 21: calibration substrates (C) Copyright Cascade Microtech
OPEN
IB
V , — if
:
^
-At
Probes in the air
THRU
SHORT
Fig. 22: details of SOLT calibration structures for on-wafer measurements (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
Some notes about these calibration standards: While in the case of the CV meter, the calibration corrects for a single, ideal offset capacitor, a NWA calibration relates to cal standards (OPEN, SHORT, LOAD, THRU etc.) from a calkit. These cal standards do not represent ideal standards. They represent the real, existing standard, including its nonidealities! It means that a SHORT is not an ideal SHORT, but instead represents rather a small inductance. The same applies to the THRU, which has a non-ideal delay time. The OPEN corresponds rather to a capacitor than to an ideal OPEN. Therefore, these non-idealities of the G-S-G probes have to be entered into the NWA before calibration. This is called 'entering' or 'modifying the calkit'.
27
914 F. Sischka & T. Gneiting
While this procedure refers to the non-idealities of the calibration standards, i.e. the termination of the NWA cables during calibration, the subsequent calibration is based on this information and then related to the selected frequency range, the RF power, the averaging of the NWA etc. After it has been performed, the correction terms are stored in the calset of the NWA. In other words, the 12-term error vectors are 'filled up'. Afterwards, when the measurement is performed, the raw measured data arrays will be corrected inside the NWA, using a correction technique related to the selected calibration method, and referring to the specified calset. Finally, this corrected measurement result is transferred into the modeling software and displayed there. Therefore, after the calibration, a re-measurement of the OPEN will not represent an ideal open, but instead exactly those parasitic components as described in the documentation of the OPEN. In the same way, a THRU shows up after calibration with its real delay time, and a SHORT represents its inductive behavior! This fact leads to a simple calibration verification procedure:
5.4
NWA Calibration Verification
Of course, the best calibration verification is to measure a golden device. However, this is not available for on-wafer device modeling. Otherwise, if we remeasure all the calibration standards, i.e. the OPEN, SHORT, LOAD and THRU on the ISS ceramic calibration substrate, and check the result against SPICE simulations of the calibration standard specification netlists, we obtain a very clear picture of the calibration quality. This is because these standards of the ISS substrate are carefully specified by the manufacturer (calkit data!).
CalKit data for Cascade G-S-G probes: Pitch C-Open/fF L-Short/pH 100 -9.3 2.4 125 -9.5 3.6 150 -9.7 4.8 The THRU delay time is always lps.
L-Termination/pH -3.5 -2.6 -1.7
When all 4 standards exhibit an excellent fit between measurement and simulated model, we can assume a correct calibration of the NWA. Note: This calibration verification can also be applied to check the quality of an older calibration.
28
RF MOS Measurements
5.5
915
Conditions For Efficient NWA Measurements
In order to make efficient network analyzer measurements, it is recommendable to perform log sweeps instead of linear ones. Usually, 10 data points per frequency decade are fully sufficient for obtaining clean S-parameter plots. Also, use the same frequencies for all measurements. This simplifies de-embedding later. Last not least, to avoid non-linearities during the measurements, keep the RF power levels smaller compared to the DC bias power level. For transistor modeling, measure S-parameters for all DC bias conditions, perform just one single de-embedding to these data (see further below) and then store them into a data file. Then, by individually reading sub-data out of this file related to e.g. transistor input resistor modeling (frequency sweep for specific DC bias conditions) or transit time modeling (one fixed frequency at the -20dB/dec slope of MAG(H21)), we do not need to re-measure, but simple read from that data file. This saves a lot of calibration time and de-embedding manipulations. Last not least, after the model parameter set has been finally obtained, we can read back all the de-embedded data for all DC bias conditions and compare these curves with the simulation result of the final parameter set. A plot showing the relative vector errors between measured and simulated data allows then to clearly identify the quality of the model fit and to identify operating conditions with best and worst fit.
5.6
Linear Versus Non-Linear RF Performance
So far, we introduced the S-parameters and compared them to the other two-port parameters like Y or Z, into which they also can be converted. This means, S-parameters are small signal parameters by definition. In other words, for a transistor as an example, the S-parameters do not reflect non-linear amplification phenomena like compression etc. In general, two-port parameters of non-linear components like transistors or diodes vary as a function of input power. However, for RF signal powers which are small compared to the DC bias power, this non-linearity can be neglected, and linear operation can be assumed. In the case of a bipolar or MOS transistor, this is generally true for RF input signals at the Base or Gate lower than -30dBm, and Collector or Drain DC currents above 1mA. NOTE: a smart way to check the max. tolerable RF signal power is explained further down in this chapter.
Applying too high RF signals leads to signal distortion and thus to harmonics. When applying a too high RF signal during S-parameter measurements of a network analyzer (NWA), the Kirchhoff law is affected. Since the NWA only measures the base frequencies and ignores the harmonics, the Kirchhoff statement that 'the sum of all currents, at all frequencies, into a node is zero' is violated ! Therefore, it is absolutely important to verify small-signal conditions for the diodes and transistors during NWA measurements.
29
916
F. Sischka & T. Gneiting
Again, keep in mind that when the S-parameters become RF-power dependent, harmonics occur, see Fig. 23. In order to characterize these harmonic frequencies, a spectrum analyzer or a non-linear network analyzer should be applied! Simulation-wise, SPlCE simulators have to be replaced by harmonic balance simulators. And your modeling software, as the interface between measurements and simulator, should support this ! large signal, non-linear RF: voltage/current vectors for each harmonic frequency :
If 5.
8v i
I .a,
c small signal: S-parameters
tf
<0
1 :
f
1
L
t /^^----^^'^freq
freq / DC bias
DC bias
Fig. 23: Applying too much RF power to non-linear devices like transistors generates harmonics
(C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
An absolute prerequisite for using two-port matrices is the linear, time invariant behavior of the circuit. Only in this case, matrix conversions like for example for de-embedding, are possible! Nonlinear high-frequency measurements cannot be de-embedded by Y- and Zmatrix subtractions!
Selecting the right RF power for nonlinear devices before starting calibration When measuring S-parameters of nonlinear devices with a network analyzer, it must be assured that these devices operate in small-signal, linear mode. Otherwise, the high frequency test signals will no longer be sinusoidal, and the occurrence of harmonics will lead to wrong S-parameter measurements and shifted DC bias conditions. A smart method to check the correct port power settings is like this: When measuring a DC output characteristics and calculating the output resistor 'Rout' from of it, the resulting curve is very sensitive. Therefore, we can use this plot to identify possible effects of too big an AC power applied to the transistor. This means, we measure the DC output characteristics, and let the NWA perform measurements untriggered, in continuous mode, i.e. unsynchronized to the DC measurement. Then, we increase the Port power manually (decrease port attenuations) until we see an effect on the next 'Rout' measurement. We then know the maximum allowed RF power for the S-parameter measurements of this device! The plot in Fig. 24 reflects such a test. The disturbed curve happens when tpo much RF power is applied to the transistor.
30
RF MOS Measurements
917
Rout M2
Vd/V
Fig. 24: Measuring the DC Rout resistance of a MOS transistor: with an accurate RF power level and with a too big RF power level. (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
What if: characterizing a transistor at higher RF signal levels where it behaves nonlinear If you need to characterize e.g. a power RF transistor at signal levels where distortion occurs, and where the Kirchhoff law is not fulfilled for the data measured by the NWA, it is absolutely mandatory to replace the linear SPICE S-parameter simulation by a nonlinear harmonic balance simulation. Only with this kind of simulation, we can emulate the conditions of the power RF transistor measurement. From the simulation data of harmonic balance, we then calculate the S-parameters of the base frequency and compare these Sparameters with those obtained from the NWA measurements. Only in this case the obtained model parameters will be correct for the power RF transistor !
Conclusions: If the DUT behaves non-linearly: - signal compression occurs - harmonics show up - the DC operating point may be shifted - loadlines and transfer curves become dynamic, i.e. RF-power dependent - matrix conversions are no longer possible - de-embedding (see further below) is no longer valid. For further details related to the topics of this chapter see publications [9] to [18].
31
918
5.7
F. Sischka & T.
Gneiting
Pulsed S-Parameter Measurements
When measuring a transistor, the DC measurements are usually performed in fast sweep mode, i.e. pretty fast in time. On the other hand, when performing the biased RF measurements (network analyzer), the underlying DC bias has to be kept constant during the whole frequency sweep, incremented and again kept constant for the next frequency sweep. Therefore, due to self-heating of the transistor, the RF measurements may have been performed at completely different chip temperatures than the DC measurements. And while the possibly cooler DC measurement curves served to extract the DC model parameters, we may run into problems when extracting the remaining RF parameters, which may refer to hotter measurement conditions. And this can be one of the explanations if the measured and simulated S21 curves do not match at lowest frequencies. To avoid this, isothermal measurements have to be performed. There are fully configured pulsed network analyzer systems available on the market, like the Agilent 85124A. Such systems allow lus pulsed measurements from DC up to 40GHz. Fig. 25 gives an overview of the system, and Fig. 26 depicts the applied pulse scheme.
IC-CAP control software RF synthesizer network analyzer
LO synthesizer
bias pulser 1
O Pulse Generator, acting as a trigger for the whole system
Fig. 25: block diagram of the Agilent 85124A pulsed measurement system from DC to microwaves
(C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Siscbka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
In this case, the modeling procedure is as follows: > perform a full device measurement characterization at e.g. 25'C in pulsed mode, DC and S-parameters. > extract all temperature-independent model parameters (conventionally) > perform another pulsed measurement for DC and S-parameters at the other
32
RF MOS Measurements
919
temperatures, e.g. -25'C and +75'C and extract the temperature parameters (e.g. XTI and XTB for the Gummel-Poon model) perform a conventional, non-pulsed measurement. The deviation from the pulsed measurement of above is then due to self-heating, modeled by an extra thermal pin of the model. This pin is connected to an equivalent schematic consisting of a thermal resistor (radiation) and a thermal capacitor (self-heating), which is fed by a 'thermal' current. This current is proportional to the dissipated power in the device. The modeling is then performed by tuning the thermal network model parameters Rth and Cth.
Gate/Base DC bias
Drain/Collector DC bias
Gate pulse width = HFpulsewidth + 2T1 + 2T2 Drain pulse width = HFpulsewidth + 2T2
Fig. 26: Pulse timing of the measurement system in Fig. 25 (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
33
920
6
F. Sischka & T.
Gneiting
Extending The embedding
Measurement
Plane
To
The
Transistor:
De-
After having performed a network analyzer calibration, the calibration plane is located at the ends of the NWA cables. The device itself, however, needs to be connected to this calibration plane. In the case of a packaged device, S-parameter measurements would now include the test fixture, the package and the very inner DUT. For on-wafer device characterization, using e.g. ground-signal-ground probes (GSG), the test pads (where the probes touch down) degrade the performance of the very inner DUT by their layout specific capacitive and inductive pad parasitics. In order to extend the calibration plane to either the beginning of the package, or the inner DUT, these outer parasitic effects have to be stripped off. This is called de-embedding. A brief example on how de-embedding returns the real, inner DUT perfonnance without its degradation due to the measurement environment is given in Fig. 27. We can clearly see how the transistor cutoff frequency fT is degraded due to these parasitics. CE+a:
inner transistor performance. > : i i i i.
degraded transit frequency due to package effects J I G50.0
700.0
750.0
1 1 1 I—! 1 1 !_ 800.0 850.0
vBE
900.0
CE:-3 J
Fig. 27: f-p of a transistor before and after de-embedding (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
6.1
A De-Embedding tutorial
If we are going to model a transistor mounted to a chip carrier, this carrier will distort the performance of the inner transistor. Yet, the chip carrier can be described widi series inductors of the bond wires and the parallel capacitors of the pads (Fig. 28).
34
RF MOS
Measurements
921
via
via Fig. 28: chip carrier of a bipolar transistor case and its parasitic components (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
By rearranging the schematic components of Fig. 28, we obtain a simplified equivalent schematic as given in Fig. 29.
•C12
pinl
pin2
C13 S ° total
— —
V
° 11 total
s
s
lj
^ 12 total
21total ° 22 total J
I
C23 L3 pin3
I
Fig. 29: The equivalent schematic of the chip carrier for high frequencies. (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
In order to strip off the parasitic components from the outside towards the inner DUT, Fig. 30 depicts the corresponding de-embedding procedure.
35
922
F. Sischka
& T.
Gneiting
HP 5 i
^TJ
Jc2:
r T
subtract the Y matrix of parallel capacitances
J _ pin3 _ ^
pinl
subtract the Z matrix of the series inductors
ET
pinl
pin2
T
Fig.30: Stripping off the chip carrier parasitics in order to obtain the performance of the inner t r a n s i s t o r
(C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
The step-by-step procedure for this de-embedding: We have measured the S-parameters Sj ota i of the transistor and its carrier. We assume that the carrier has been modeled already. Following our assumption of having parallel capacitors as 'outer' parasitic components, we transform the S-parameters to Y, because a Y matrix represents a PI structure of components. A simple subtraction will de-embed the parasitic capacitor effects, see Fig. 31.
Y=
(Yn-jn(C13+C12) Y 21 +jQC 12
Y 1 2 +jQC I 2 Y 2 2 - j ^ ( C 2 3 + C 12 ) y
c
pinl
pin2
L1 !
L3 pin3 Fig. 31: The remaining equivalent schematic of fig. 30 after the de-embedding of the Capacitors
(C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
36
RF MOS Measurements
923
Now, the new 'outer' parasitic components are the two inductors, which are in series with the chip connections. Series parasitics can be easily eliminated by subtracting a Z matrix. Therefore, we transform the resulting Y-parameters from above into Z-parameters and subtract the inductors, see Fig. 32.
(Zu-\Cl(L,+L3) Z 21 - jftl_ 3
z=
pinl
Z12-jQL3 Z 22 - jQL 3 B
pin2
pin3 Fig. 32: The remaining equivalent schematic of Fig. 31 after the de-embedding of the series inductors
(C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
These Z-parameters are finally transformed back into S-parameters which now describe exclusively the performance of the 'inner' chip. ° 1 letup chip ^°21chip
°12chip Q
lJ
22chipy
Note: de-embedding by complete Y matrix (OPEN) and Z matrix (SHORT) subtractions can be applied as well, provided it has been assured that there are no hidden series components present for Y-matrix subtractions (mixed cross-talk represented by chains of C-L-C-L etc.). there are no hidden parallel components present for Z-matrix subtractions related to a two-step de-embedding: for on-wafer measurements (OPEN -> SHORT sequence): the SHORT has been de-embedded from the OPEN dummy for packaged measurements (SHORT -> OPEN sequence): the OPEN has been de-embedded from the SHORT dummy there are no hidden delay line effects present when subtracting Y- or Z-matrices
37
924
F. Sischka & T.
6.2
Gneiting
Two-Port Matrix Properties And Manipulations For DeEmbedding
Before we begin, first some terms and definitions on serial and parallel circuits: Series circuit
Parallel circuit
.
Impedance Z = ylR2 +X2 Admittance Y -1/Z-jG +B Resistance R Conductance G=l/R Reactance X Susceptance B=l/X Immittance: A general term for both impedance and admittance, used when the distinction is irrelevant.
With this in mind, we are now ready for the two-port matrix signal flow definitions: 1. H matrix relating voltages and currents of a two-port
(vA
'hll h l 2 \ h21 h22
on
2. Z matrix relating voltages and currents of a two-port
(vn
(zll z21
zl2^ (iH z22
38
RF MOS
3. Y matrix relating voltages and currents of a two-port
i2
lJ
fy11 y 1 2 \ (v\\ y21 y22 12
4. A matrix relating voltages and currents of a two-port
(\\\ il V
fall al2^ fv2^ a21 a22 J
V
J
12
5. S matrix relating to traveling waves at a two-port
fb2bI )
l J
fsll
sl2^
(dl\
s21 s22
39
926
6.
F. Sischka & T.
Gneiting
K matrix relating to traveling waves at a two-port
fkll
|blj
Matrix
\L\2\ (bl\ *
k22 v k21
Conversions
Since all these matrices refer to linear, small-signal signal theory, they can be converted into each other. Here some useful examples: H to Y conversion To convert a H matrix into its Y equivalent, we just have to rearrange the matrix equations. The H matrix has the form
^vH fhll vi2y
hl2^ * f i O
h21 h22
v
K"h
j
and the target Y matrix
'iO fyll v i2 y
yl2Y/vn
y21 y22
v-
j
vv2y
The vl dependency, i.e. the first line in the H matrix, can be solved for il:
il =
1
, vl
"•*• *
hl2 „ v2 "I i
, what is already the first line of the Y matrix.
We insert this result into the second line of the H matrix in order to replace the il dependency •o
i2 =
h 2 1
h11
H v1 + h 2 2 - ^ l h 1 2 \i2 h11
40
RF MOS Measurements
927
With
det(h)=h11h22-h12h21 we can rearrange and yield .„ h 2 1 , det(h) . i2 = vl + — — v 2
hll
hll
what finally gives the relationship between the y and h parameters:
( y i i y 12> l y21 y22
•hl2 1 h l l h21 det(h)
Y to Z and ZtoY conversions: The conversion of the Y to the Z parameters is, related to the special definition of these two matrices, very simple. Starting with the resistance matrix form (v) = ( z ) * ( i ) » we can solve it for ( i ) by multiplying to the left side with ( z )
or
, the inverse matrix of ( z ).
(z)-(v)=(zr(z)*(i) (zr(v)=(i)
Comparing this result with the definition of the y matrix, we get finally
(z)-=(y) and correspondingly
(y)-'=(z) Note: remember the matrix inversion scheme:
fa bV1 c d with
-b\
1 ( d ad - cb - c
ad - cb = det( matrix)
41
928
F. Sischka & T.
Gneiting
StoH conversion Important note: S-parameter conversion into other matrices by simply multiplying with e.g. ZO = 50 Q are only o.k. if the characteristic impedance ZO is *not* frequency dependent! This is important for low-impedance silicon substrates !!! _ ( 1 + S 1 1 )-(1 + S 2 2 ) - S 1 2 S 2 1
h 11 „ =
h12 = h
6.3
2s12 (1-S11)-(1 + S22)+S12S21
~2s2i
21
22
* ZO
( 1 - S 1 I ) ( 1 + S22)+S12S21
(1-Sn)-(1 + S 2 2 )+S 1 2 s 2 1 _ (1~ S 11JV~ S 22/~ S 12 S 21 / ZO ( 1 - S H ) ( 1 + S22)+S12S21
De-embedding Techniques
In this chapter, we discuss the matrix properties and manipulation schemes relevant for deembedding. De-embedding
of serial parasitics
(Z-matrix)
Adding of Z-matrices corresponds to adding of serial impedances to a DUT. On the other hand, provided these parasitic matrices are known, we can calculate the Z-matrix of the inner DUT by subtracting them from the Z-matrix of the total measurement. Adding of Z-matrices:
o— "parasl
hiUT
"paras2
42
RF MOS Measurements
929
Ztotal = ZParasl + ZDUT + ZParas2 The individual Z-matrices of the series parasitic components are:
Z_paras1
Z_paras2
J
Paras1
fA B°1
Paras2
(c c l
1°
J
lc cj
Adding these matrices of parasitic components gives: Zparas = ZParasl + ZParas2 or:
Z_paras
(A + C Paras
V
C
C } B+C
= zTEE
what is the matrix of a TEE structure (!!). How to proceed with the de-embedding of series parasitics: Once the parasitic components A, B and C are known, they can be stripped-off by subtracting the Z-matrix Z ^ ^ = ZTEE of a TEE structure from the measured data Ztotal. We obtain: ZDUT = Ztotal - ZParasl - ZParas2 = Ztotal - Zparas
43
930
F. Sischka & T.
Gneiting
De-embedding of parallel parasitics (Y-matrix) Inversely to the adding of Z-matrices above, the adding of Y-matrices corresponds to adding of parallel admittances to a DUT. Again, provided this parasitic Y-matrix is know, we can calculate the Y-matrix of the inner DUT by subtracting Yparas from Y ^ , i.e. the Ymatrix of the total measurement. Adding of Y-matrices: Y
DUT
Y paras
Ytotal = YDUT + YParas The Y-matrix of the parallel parasitics is:
r
Y paras
A +B
-B
-B
C+B
= Y, PI
please watch the signs ! How to proceed with the de-embedding ofparallel parasitics: Once the parallel parasitic components A, B and C are known, they can be stripped-off by simply subtracting the Y matrix Yparas = Yw of a PI structure from the measured data Y ^ and we obtain: YDUT = Ytotal - YParas
44
RF MOS Measurements
931
De-embedding of lossless delay lines (S-matrix)
&"
,"
coplanar
* )
s+
microstrip
Assumption: we are in the S-parameter domain and have the device-under-test (DUT) imbedded between two lossless delay lines: with
a: forward wave b: reflected wave
Then, the S-parameter matrix is valid and it is W = si l t o t a l * a l + 8 1 ^ ^ * 8 2 b2 = s21 t o t a l *al+s22 t o t a l *a2
a1 b1
Delay TD1
Delay TD2
lossless
lossless
a2 b2
The delay matrices are represented by the S-parameter matrices:
f ° T D 1 ~~
0
e(-j»2W*f*TDl)^
f °TD2
(-j*2PI*f*TDl)
—
0
e (-j*2PI«fTD2)
,(-j*2PI»f*TD2)
Q
>
\
How to proceed with the de-embedding of lossless delay lines: Provided we know the delay times TDl and TD2, we can use the 'port shift' properties of Sparameter multiplications (shift of reference planes), and obtain:
45
932
F. Sischka & T.
'S11'DUT n,rr S21,DUT
Gneiting
S12-DUT ^ S22,DUT
f
01 -i
0 1
'total
* p j-2Plf 2TD1 e
S21total expj2Plf
(TD1+TD2)
S12total*exp j2Plf 99? * °"total
(TD1+TD2)\
J-2PI-«-2TD2 pvn e x P
f : frequency TD1: delay time at port 1, TD2: delay time at port 2
with:
De-embedding
applying the
ABC-matrix
By definition, ABC matrices are best suited to describe a chain of two-ports. This feature makes them an ideal starting point for parasitics de-embedding related to measurement conditions where we have considerably long connection lines to the device, and a separation into parallel and serial parasitics cannot be achieved. I.e. situations where the parasitic components are more distributed than lumped. ABC matrix de-embedding can be applied for example to packaged or insertable devices like a connector etc.. It can also be applied to special on-wafer components line spiral inductors, which occupy a large area on the chip and whose parasitics are therefore distributed. For a classical ABC matrix de-embedding, let's start with an example of a packaged device. Besides the test fixture for the DUT, which consists basically of a substrate with a strip line for each port of the DUT, we also need a special test structure to characterize these strip lines. This means we need another strip line on the same substrate like the test fixture, and this strip line is exactly as long as the strip lines of the test fixture. See the sketch below.
(L - AL)/2 —location 7 of the DUT AJine
Ajine
AL test fixture to measure the DUT
auxiliary fixture to characterize AJine
With the assumption that the A j m e ABC matrix is identical to the connection strip lines of the test fixture, the total performance of the device-under-test (DUT) including the test fixture can be expressed in A matrices as:
46
RF MOS Measurements A
933
total = A line * A DUT * A line
or solved for the DUT ABC matrix AQJJT; : A _ A - l * A * A _1 • ^ DUT ~ " • line ** total ^ line
How to proceed: The measured S-parameters S. ^ i are converted to A t
taj
. The same applies to the
measured S j m parameters. Then the matrix calculation from above is applied in order to obtain the de-embedded
AQTJX-
As a special case, the ABC matrix can be applied to de-embedding from lossy delay lines. First, we have to define the ABC matrix A j m e of a strip line, with: ZO y ct B or TD
characteristic impedance of the strip line propagation coefficient of the line loss phase shift resp. delay time of the strip line,
r , lossless line Y (freq)- L = |a( fre q) + j • B(f re q) J • L ~
j • B(f) • L = j • 2PI • freq • T D
Note: roughly TD=10ps per mm strip line can be assumed on a ceramic substrate. In case of a lossy line, we calculate first for every frequency point [i] the auxiliary term: aux[i] = (j2 * PI * freqlij * oc + j * 2 * P I * f req[i] * p)* L
and in case of a lossless line (ct=0), we calculate first:
aux[i]=j*2*PI*freq[i]*p*L or aux[i]=j*2*PI*freq[i]*TD which gives for the ABC matrix of the delay line (per frequency point index i): Aline 10 =
cosh(aux[i]) ZO*sinh(aux[i]p —-sinh(aux[i]) cosh(aux)[i]
This matrix is then introduced in the ACB matrix de-embedding formula A
DUT
=
A|j"ne * A t o t a | * AjTne, and we can calculate the de-embed matrix ArjTjj.
47
934
F. Sischka
& T.
Gneiting
Note: in case of a lossless delay line, the formula simplifies to
Mine lossless [i]
( cos(p*l_) = -^sin(p*L)
and
ZO*sin(P*L)^ cos(p*L)
with
p = coVCL
ZO = J —
6.4
De-Embedding The OPEN Dummy Device
The most simple, but very often used de-embedding method is the simple de-embedding from an OPEN device. The underlying prerequisite for this method is, however, that all the circuit components of the OPEN dummy structure can be represented exclusively by lumped circuit components only which are altogether in parallel with the DUT. Only in this case, the well-known Y-matrix subtraction method Y_DUT = Yjxrtal - Y_OPEN can be applied. Fig. 33 depicts this condition. Y DUT
^^•^rDUT^^H infflHHn,t.,.-'M~ ilHIMiiij L"
•••••
- parallel-v. / parasitic;: Y_parallel Fig. 33: For OPEN dummy device de-embedding using Y-matrix subtraction, the OPEN subcircuit has to be completely in parallel with the DUT. (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
In order to successfully applying this Y-matrix subtraction, this prerequisite condition of parallel parasitics has to be verified. Otherwise, the de-embedded curves of the inner DUT may look ok, but they may be wrong. The best way to check this is to model the open. If we are able to achieve a fit with a subcircuit consisting of lumped devices which can be interpreted as being completely in
48
RF MOS Measurements
935
parallel with the DUT, (independent of how complex the inner structure of this sub-circuit is !), we can be sure to perform a correct OPEN de-embedding. Fig. 34 shows an OPEN dummy layout, and its S-parameter performance. Referring to the physical layout given in Fig. 35, we can assume a simple RC TEE structure for low frequencies. For higher frequencies, also crosstalk between the ground-signal-ground GSG contact pads of the dummy and coupling across the pads from port 1 to port 2 comes into play. See Fig. 34 and components CIO, RIO, C12, C20 and R20, where the resirtors again represent the losses of the silicon substrate. This effect happens usually for frequencies above -10 GHz, and can be seen in the S-parameter measurements as a deviation from the low-frequency half-circles. See the typical measured S-parameters in Fig. 34. Of course, this 2nd order high-frequency dependency varies with the layout of the OPEN and also with the wafer process. OPEN DUMMY
R£«»
CE-33
Fig. 34: Modeling the OPEN dummy device (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
49
936
F. Sischka
& T.
Gneiting
Fig. 35: physical representation of the OPEN dummy structure for low frequencies (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
If we did not require e.g. inductors to model the OPEN dummy, or other components which can be assumed to be in series with the inner DUT, we can now perform the de-embedding. The measured S-parameters of the OPEN and the total DUT are transformed to Yparameters and then, the Y-parameters from the OPEN are subtracted from the total DUT's Y-parameters. De-embed from Open: •DUT
=
^Total - Y 0 p w i
Convert to S: SDUT
6.5
~
S(YQUT)
De-embedding The OPEN And The SHORT Dummy Device
A method to also strip off the series parasitic influence from the measured data is to deembed the inner DUT from both the OPEN and SHORT dummy device. The idea behind this method is, that the electrical behavior of the pads around the DUT can be described by a combination of exclusively parallel (OPEN) and exclusively serial (SHORT) circuit elements as described in Fig. 36.
50
RF MOS Measurements
937
SERIAL PARASITICA
; i Di
•
,_
i -'
r
i
;
)
:
. ' •-* t
V*y"' : *
—c
c i..
••- , 7 ^ - ^
isf-M1*)
I'AHALLEL PARAS!TICS • r-i'Hi'u!
Fig. 36: For OPEN and SHORT dummy device de-embedding using Y- and Z-matrix subtraction, the OPEN subcircuit has to be completely in parallel with the DUT, and the SHORT subcircuit completely in series with the DUT. (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
Once the two-port matrices of the serial and parallel parasitic elements are known, they can be subtracted very easily from the total measurement data set. To determine these matrices, the S-parameters of the OPEN and the SHORT dummy test structure are used.
51
938
F. Sischka
& T.
Gneiting
OPEN DUMMY: o
1
o
o-
PARALIEL PAOASITICS Y pu*!let
SHORT
i—ID-
DUMMY: SERIAL PARASITICS ;
._—o-
'^T*•••»"^•i,
--«•?! "••J1."" v i » i l -• rv-1
. o
{seies i;
•O
<
I
SHORT
^feaih 1 o
• Z i w i ' s t 2\
! PARALLEL PARASITICS i
"j . . . .
Fig. 37:
-
.
. •
Y parftUet
Y- and Z-matrix components of me OPEN and the SHORT dummy device (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
Looking at Fig. 37, the schematic of the SHORT dummy device, it is clear, how the matrices of the serial and parallel parasitic elements can be determined:
52
RF MOS Measurements
939
parallel elements: the S-to-Y converted S-parameters of the OPEN dummy give the Y-parameters of the parallel elements. serial elements: the Z-parameters of the serial elements can be determined from the SHORT dummy when the Y-parameters of the parallel elements are known and de-embedded. SHORT DUMMY layout
1
.J ZJ Z]
Sxx
equivalent circuit R1
L1
L2
R2
°-W—MYT*—|—rrrrrr •AAA-o Rp1
Sxy
Rp2 R3 . fWCF*„
' L3
CE—33
Fig. 38: Modeling the SHORT dummy device, de-embedded from the OPEN (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
53
940
F. Sischka & T. Gneiting
With this pre-assumption, the de-embedding can be performed following these matrix operations:
De-embed from Open: • Short/Open "
'Short " 'Open
Convert fo Zs ^Short/Open ~ MT$|,ort/0|Mit}
De-embed from Short: Zour
= Z D U T / 0 p o n - Zshoit/Op»n
Convert fo S: SDUT
= S(ZDUT)
In a first step, the influence of the parallel parasitic elements is removed from both the SHORT and the device under test (DUT). This is done by subtracting the Y-parameters of the OPEN from the Y-parameters of the SHORT and DUT. In the following step, the resulting Y-parameters are converted to Z-parameters and in this representation, the influence of the serial parasitic elements is removed by subtracting the de-embedded Zparameters of die SHORT from the de-embedded Z-parameters of the DUT. The resulting Z-parameters of the DUT are then finally converted back to S-parameters.
6.6
Verifying The De-Embedding
Verifying the de-embedding procedure is very important before applying it to the very DUT, i.e. die transistor etc. Wimout this step, errors or problems with the de-embedding will result in distortions of the inner, de-embedded device, and, thus, to a wrong device model. This is especially true when de-embedding the complete Y and Z matrices of the OPEN and SHORT dummy. Therefore, it is suggested to - model every dummy structure in order to verify its de-embedding prerequisites and to - verify the de-embedding witii a well-known 'golden device' before applying it to the modeling DUT. This means: - After the OPEN and (if available/required) SHORT dummy measurements have been modeled,
54
RF MOS Measurements
941
- and it is assured that circuit components of the OPEN are all in parallel with the DUT, - and the circuit components of the SHORT can be interpreted as being completely in series with the DUT, we can check the de-embedding procedure with a known 'golden device'. In practice, however, the problem is the availability of such a 'golden device'. Provided we have a THRU dummy, we can use this device for a verification of the de-embedding procedure. The idea is that the THRU should look like a simple delay line, with a certain characteristic impedance ZO, and a delay time TD. Additionally, the delay line can be lossy. In any case, the model parameters must represent physical meaningful values, and the deembedded trace must be simple without resonances etc. Just a simple delay line! Fig. 39 depicts such a dummy device layout, the measurement and the simple model.
THRU DUMMY
Fig. 39: measurement result and model of a THRU dummy, de-embedded from both, the OPEN and SHORT (with the SHORT itself de-embeded from the OPEN). (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
6.7
Over- And Under-De-Embedding
If under-de-embedding occurred, i.e. we de-embed 'not enough parasitics', the traces of the de-embedded device will not be 'turned back' sufficiently, se Fig. 40. The de-embedding error will add up to the inner device and make its model useless. Unfortunately, this effect is usually not directly visible from inspections of the data.
55
942
F. Sischka & T. Gneiting
The better recognizable effect, however, is over-de-embedding. If this happens, the deembedded DUT curves will 'turn backwards' for higher frequencies or show some other non-physical effects. They may even turn outside the Smith chart!
un-deembedded DUT
deembedded DUT
under deembedded
correctly deembedded
over deembedded Fig. 40: under and over de-embedding effect (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
7
Checking RF Measurement Data Consistency
For a successful device modeling, it is very important to check the RF measurement results before proceeding with the parameter extraction. Without going into the details, here some checkpoints: > > > >
> > >
Check for the DC bias losses due to the resistors in the bias TEEs. check the contact resistance of the RF probes to the aluminum pads on the wafer. check the RF-signal power if it is low enough for measuring linear S-parameters. DC bias currents from S-parameters measurements must match the DC curves, otherwise either self-heating, too much RF-signal, or oscillation etc. may have occurred. compare S-parameters (by Y-matrix conversion) against the CV curves. every de-embedding step must make the signal look more ideal. check if there are enough DC bias conditions available for transit time modeling.
56
RF MOS Measurements
8
943
Test Structures For MOS Transistors
This paragraph gives some information about the physical layout of: • • •
8.1
high frequency transistors as used in integrated CMOS circuits test structures to measure these transistors dummy structures to eliminate the influence of the parasitic pads from the real transistor behavior
Pad Layout Suggestions For A Uniform Test Stucture
DC And
S-Parameter
Fig. 41 gives and idea, how a uniform transistor layout could look like to cover both, highresolution DC current and also S-parameter measurements. Source and Bulk are shorted by the probes!
S-par Fig. 41: Uniform layout suggestion for DC and S-parameter measurements of transistors (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
For DC measurements, a low-current resolution is required down to sub-pico-Amperes. This can best be achieved using special shielded DC needles, and connecting these needles directly to the DC analyzer. It is not recommended to measure DC through the S-parameter testset of the network analyzer. For S-parameter measurements, a good grounding is essential, and ground loops must be avoided. Therefore, the Bulk and Substrate contacts are reliably connected to Ground when the GSG probes (Ground-Signal-Ground) are connected to the above layout.
57
944
F. Sischka & T.
Gneiting
If an individual DC bias is required for the Bulk or Substrate contact, it is recommended to use GS probes (Ground-Signal), and to use a 3rd GS probe to bias the 3rd DC contact. Using a 3rd GS probe for the DC contact and not a DC needle reduces possible device oscillation considerably. to Bulk SMU
S-par with individual DC bias Fig. 42: Layout suggestion for S-parameter measurements and individual DC bias for Bulk or Substrate, using Ground-Signal probes. (C) Copyright 2001 by Franz Sischka, Agilent Technologies, Munich
NOTE: the distance between the centers of the pads is called pitch. Typical pitches for onwafer transistor modeling is about or below lOOum.
8.2
Layout For High Frequency MOS Transistors
Depending on the target application, there are different layout schemes possible for RF MOS transistors [20]. These layouts depend on the application in RF circuits. Fig. 43 depicts three basic possibilities for a layout of such devices.
58
RF MOS Measurements
RF transistorl design
one single
Top view
Device geometry
drain
gate
1 Gate 1 Drain 1 Source
transistor source
3 drain I gate,
945
p-Si
0
via
metal
n parallel transistors
gate
3 Gates 3 Drains 3 Sources idrain
H
• gate, p-Si
CZ~~J> metal
source
multi finger
O via
o o
transistors
6 Gates 3 Drains 4 Sources
^1
gate
^^^Bmm •2 drain I gate, p-Si
I source „
Q
via
metal
Fig. 43: Test structures for S-parameter measurements. (C) Copyright 2001 Thomas Gneiting, admos, Frickenhausen, Germany
The use of one of these designs depends on the functionality of the transistor in the designed circuit. However, most designs are using the multi finger transistor approach. It is very compact and because of a minimization of parasitic capacitance due to shared drain/source regions, it provides the best RF performance (e.g. cut-off frequency fT). A detailed layout of such a multi finger transistor is given in Fig. 44 below. The gate fingers are contacted from both sides to minimize the gate resistance which results in a better high frequency noise behavior.
59
946
F. Sischka & T.
Gneiting
M drain §§ g a t e , p - S i
c;
H source — metal
Q
via
Fig. 44: Layout of a multi finger transistor. (C) Copyright 2001 ThomasGneiting, admos, Frickenhausen, Germany
Test devices should be designed so that they can drive enough current to get a reasonable gain for the measurement with the network analyzer. E.g. using a 'normal' short device with W/L = 10um/0.5um would result in a small starting value of IS21I = 0.2. Such small RF signal levels can be affected by the measurement noise and therefore become distorted. A multi-finger device with 6 gates, 3 drain and 4 source areas would exhibit a higher gain of about IS21I = 1.0 with much less measurement resolution problems. Fig. 45 finally depicts a three-dimensional representation of such a multi-finger MOS transistor. It is interesting to note how 'high' the metal planes are relative to the active silicon area and that the size of the transistor itself is very small compared to the size of the pads.
60
RF MOS Measurements
947
Fig. 45: High frequency MOS transistor layout. (C) Copyright 2001 ThomasGneiting, admos, Frickenhausen, Germany
For more information see publication [20].
8.3
Additional dummy structures for de-embedding
The pre requisite for a correct de-embedding is that certain test structures are available on a wafer together with the device under test (DUT) itself. Depending on the selected deembedding method, an OPEN and SHORT dummy structure is required and must be measured. For the proposed de-embedding verification from above, also a THROUGH dummy structure is necessary. The principle layouts of these structures are given in Figures 46 - 48. These layouts are for Ground-Signal-Ground Probes (GSG).
61
948 F. Sisckka & T. Gneiting
cal.plane after de-embedding
OPEN DUMMY
Fig. 46:
Layout of an OPEN dummy structure. (C) Copyright 2001 Thomas Gneiting, admos, Frickenhausen, Germany
cal.plane after de-embedding
SHORT DUMMY Fig. 47: Layout of a SHORT dummy structure. (C) Copyright 2001 Thomas Gneiting, admos, Frickenhausen, Germany
62
RF MOS Measurements
949
THRU DUMMY cal.plane after de-embedding
strip line of the THRU which has to be modeled and what must be representable by a simple SPICE stripline !! Fig.48:
Layout of a THRU dummy structure. (C) Copyright 2001 Thomas Gneiting, admos, Frickenhausen, Germany
9
Conclusions
"The modeling of electronic devices in the Gigahertz range can be troublesome, requiring a lot of guesswork and ad-hoc judgements..." These statements are certainly true if the device engineer does not have a thorough knowledge about the models he is applying, the effects involved in the RF characterization measurements and if he has not tested and verified the RF measurement conditions. On the other hand, if he is well aware of - the features of his measurement equipment (e.g. specifications and instrument calibration), - the limitations of the applied measurements (e.g. device self-heating due to the applied DC power levels), - the boundary conditions during characterization (e.g. small RF power levels for network analyzer measurements) - the performance of the RF test fixture or the on-wafer RF probes (e.g. contact resistance, ground loops etc.)
63
950 F. Sischka & T. Gneiting
- the quality of his RF dummy structures (e.g. verification using a THRU dummy on the wafer), - and permanent checking of data consistency (e.g. bias conditions for S-parameter measurements identical to the DC only measurements), RF device modeling is a very clean and reproducible science.
This chapter attempted to illustrate the main issues of these modeling pre-considerations. During the daily RF modeling work, it was found that once these issues are satisfyingly resolved and the data are consistent and o.k., reliable and accurate device models can be obtained. In order to make a thorough modeling job, it is clear that the modeling engineer has to know the selected device models. But without a clear picture of the basics, i.e. the underlying measurements and their quality, he might easily end up with phrases like the ones above! However, and underlining once again, this can be avoided when giving some extra thoughts to the measurement and characterization of the modeling devices.
References [1] F.Sischka, "Device Modeling and Measurement for RF Systems", VLSI conference proceedings 1999, Lisbon, Kluwer Academics. [2] F.Sischka, "RF Measurements And Modeling with Special Emphasis on Test Structures", Tutorial Short Course at the ICMTS 2000 Conference, Monterey, CA. [3] Agilent 4155B/4156B Product Note No. 3: "Prober Connection Guide", Agilent Technologies Literature Number 5966-4185E, 1998 [4] "Ultra Low Current dc Characterization of MOSFETs at the Wafer Level", Agilent Technologies Application Note 4156-1, 1/1998, Lit.Nr. 5963-2014E [5]..Hiroshi Haruta, "Agilent Technologies Impedance Measurement 2nd edition, Agilent Technologies product number 5950-3000
Handbook",
[6] R.W.Anderson, "S-Parameter Techniques for Faster, More Accurate Network Design", Agilent Technologies Application Note 95-1, PN 5952-1130. This is a reprint of the article in the Feb, 1967 Hewlett-Packard Journal, vol.18, no.6 [7] _Understanding the Fundamental Principles of Vector Network Analysis, Agilent Technologies Application Note 1287-1
64
RF MOS Measurements
951
[8] P. van Wijnen, "On the Characterization and Optimization of High-Speed Silicon Bipolar Transistors", PhD Thesis University of Delft, 1992, published 1995 by Cascade Microtech, Inc., Beaverton, Oregon [9] Paul Schmitz, "Vector Measurements of Hewlett-Packard, Publication HP5958-0387, April 1989
High
Frequency
Networks",
[10] Agilent Technologies Application Notes 1287-1: "Understanding the Fundamental Principles of Vector Network Analyzers", Pub.No. 5965-7710E, 1997 [11] Agilent Technologies Application Notes 1287-2: "Exploring the Architectures of Network Analyzers", Pub.No 5965-7708E, 1997 [12] Agilent Technologies Application Notes 1287-4: "Network Analyzer Measurements: Filter and Amplifier Examples", Pub.No5965-7710E, 1997 [13] "Hewlett-Packard 1997 Back to Basics Seminar", D.Ballo, Network Analyzer Basics, Pub.No. 5965-7917E [14] Hewlett-Packard Application Note 8510-5A: "Specifying Calibration Standards for the HP8510 Network Analyzer", Publication HP5956-4352, February 1997 [15] Cascade Microtech, "Microwave Wafer Probe HP8510 Network Analyzer Input Instruction Manual, 1990
Calibration
Constants",
[16] Cascade Microtech Application Note: "On Wafer Vector Network Analyzer Calibration and Measurements", 1997, Pub Name PYRPROBE-0597 [17] Cascade Microtech Application Note: "Layout Rules for GHz Probing", 1992, Pub.Name LAYOUT19 [18] CascadeMicrotech Technical Brief: "A Guide to Better Vector Network Analyzer Calibrations for Probe-Tip Measurements" [19] F.Sischka, "IC-CAP Modeling Reference", Agilent Technologies publ.no.8519090109, May 2000 [20] T. Gneiting, "Documentation of the BSIM3v3 Modeling Package", HP Part No. 85190-90082, October 1998, included in: IC-CAP Modeling Software Documentation, Agilent Technologies Prod.Nr. 85199D
65
This page is intentionally left blank
International Journal of High Speed Electronics and Systems, Vol. 11, No. 4 (2001) 953-1006 © World Scientific Publishing Company
MOSFET MODELING AND PARAMETER EXTRACTION FORRFIC'S MINKYU JE, ICKJIN KWON, HYUNGCHEOL SHIN, AND KWYRO LEE Dept. ofEECS, KAIST Also with MICROS Research Center, KAIST 373-1 Kusong, Yusung, Taejon, 305-701, Korea E-mail:krlee@ee. kaist. ac. kr After reviewing the basic concept and general strategies, we have examined a variety of examples of modeling and parameter extraction methods for RF MOSFET's. Modeling and parameter extraction techniques popular in III-V FET modeling were reviewed and recent efforts to model the RF MOSFET and extract the model parameters were examined in light of the differences between the MOSFET and the III-V FET. A very simple and accurate parameter extraction method studied in our laboratory for three-terminal modeling considering charge conservation is also introduced. Our works have two important implications. One is that the consideration for charge conservation is important not only for accurate device modeling and circuit simulation but even more for proper parameter extraction. Another is that one accurate large-signal /- V model is enough to be used for DC, low-frequency analog, as well as RF circuit simulation. Four-terminal modeling based on new equivalent circuits to address the high-frequency effects arising in a MOSFET is very complicated and not practical for CAD applications, even without considering the substrate coupling terms. As a temporary alternative, the macro-modeling approach is examined with various examples.
1. Introduction Until recently, most RF circuits and systems have been implemented with either compound semiconductor transistors, such as GaAs MESFETs, HEMTs, HBTs, or silicon BJTs. The microwave properties of silicon MOSFET's were inferior to those of other high-frequency transistors. However, over time the continuous down-scaling of the CMOS technology has made it a candidate for RF applications." As shown in Table 1, the 0.\&-/jm CMOS technology easily available today exhibits nearly 50 GHz offT (cut-off frequency) and fmax (maximum oscillation frequency), and 0.35 dB of NFml„ (minimum noise figure) at 2-GHz operation frequency.5 These figures indicate excellent potential of the current CMOS technology for RF applications operating at several GHz. As the channel length of a MOSFET shrinks to 100 nm, the/?- of the device comes to about 100 GHz.
67
954 M. Je, I. Kwon, H. Shin & K. Lee Table 1. RF characteristics of n-MOSFET's with decreasing channel lengths.5
Gate Length, L [nm]
250
180
140
120
100
MGHz]
33
49
70
84
112
fmox [GHZ]
41
47
51
52
60
NFmin [dB] @ 2 GHz
0.5
0.35
0.23
0.2
0.15
In addition to its sufficient potential, the CMOS technology is very attractive as an RF technology because CMOS provides such advantages as low cost, high-level integration, and easy access over other technologies. Above all, using the CMOS technology it becomes possible to integrate RF circuits, low-frequency analog circuits, and digital circuits in a single chip, which makes an ultimate one-chip system. This strength of the CMOS technology has resulted in a large amount of research directed toward replacing the conventional highfrequency transistors in RF circuits with RF MOSFET's and integrating the RF front-ends into a single chip.6* However, differences between the RF MOSFET and conventional high-frequency transistors make the proper modeling of RF MOSFET complicated and difficult and, in turn, prevent the successful development of robust commercial RF circuits using CMOS technology. There are two major differences: one is related to the substrate material and the other arises from the device structure of the MOSFET's. These differences complicate not only the device modeling but also the implementation of the integrated RF CMOS circuits. 1.1. Large and lossy parasitic components due to the semi-conducting rather than semi-insulating nature of the silicon substrate The MOSFET's are fabricated on a silicon substrate. Silicon is a semi-conducting material rather than a semi-insulating material like gallium-arsenide. As shown in Table 2, the resistivity of silicon is much lower than that of gallium-arsenide, especially for the practical case. Essentially, the intrinsic resistivity of silicon is smaller than that of gallium-arsenide due to more plentiful carriers in the intrinsic condition. Adding to this, in a practical CMOS process, the silicon substrate is typically doped to have the carrier concentration ranging from about 1015 cm3 to about 1018 cm3, which corresponds to the resistivity of 0.01 ~ 10 ohm-cm. The resistivity value of the silicon substrate is closely related to the ease of device fabrication. In the CMOS process, it is not easy to maintain either p-type or n-type substrate in a high resistivity condition.
68
MOSFET Modeling and Parameter Extraction for RF IC's
955
Table 2. Electrical properties of Si and GaAs at 300 °K.
Properties
Si
GaAs
11.7
13.1
• Ultimate intrinsic resistivity
2.3 x 105ohmcm
108 ohmcm
• Practical resistivity range
0.01 ~ 10 ohmcm
108 ohm-cm
\.SW/cm-°C
0.46 W/cm-°C
Dielectric constant Substrate resistivity
Thermal conductivity
The lower resistivity of the silicon substrate results in larger and lossier parasitics related to the substrate. The performance of the integrated CMOS RF circuits is often dominated by these parasitics, not by intrinsic MOSFET's. The substrate parasitics have an important effect on the characteristics and performance of RF CMOS circuits in several aspects, which can be summarized as follow: A. On MOSFET's In RF MOSFET's, the influence of the distributed substrate resistance becomes significant as the operation frequency increases.815 At low frequencies, the impedance of the junction capacitance is so large that the substrate resistance may not be seen from the drain terminal. However, with increasing frequency, the impedance of the junction capacitance reduces and the effects of the substrate resistance start to be seen. At high frequencies, combined with the fact that the MOSFET is a four-terminal device, the signals in RF MOSFET's are coupled through the substrate R-C network in a complex way. The substrate signal coupling mainly affects the small-signal output characteristics, which are important for RF design. This will be discussed in detail in section 3.2. B. On passive circuit elements The semi-conducting substrate also affects the performance of the passive circuit elements such as inductors and capacitors, and makes the modeling of the passive elements complicated.1'1-21 Above all, the energy dissipation through the ohmic loss of the silicon substrate significantly degrades the performance of the on-chip inductors, which is one of the most important components for RF IC's."" The lack of an accurate model for on-chip inductors presents one of the most challenging problems for silicon RF IC designers."" C. On interconnection elements On lossy substrates, complex signal propagation characteristics are exhibited along the interconnection lines and thus it is much harder to model the interconnection lines on the silicon
69
956
M. Je, I. Kwon, H. Shin & K. Lee
substrate."24 For the typical resistivity of the silicon substrate, as the operation frequency increases, a transition from the "slow-wave" propagation mode (no electric field in the substrate) to the "dielectric quasi-TEM" propagation mode (electric field in the substrate) occurs. Furthermore, a longitudinal current component is induced in the silicon substrate by the magnetic field. D. On bonding/probing pads The bonding/probing pads on the silicon substrate constitute considerable parasitics. Most of the loss is associated with the coupling from the signal pads to ground pads that originates from the pad-to-substrate capacitance and the semi-conducting nature of the silicon substrate.25 The S-parameters of the pads have a strong dependence on the substrate resistivity.26 Besides, the substrate carried coupling between the input pad/lead and the output pad/lead is significant.27 All of these parasitics should be carefully considered not only for the actual circuit but also for de-embedding to obtain the accurate characteristics of the intrinsic MOSFET. E. On signal/noise coupling in mixed-signal IC's As various kinds of circuit blocks are integrated on a single-chip, such as digital, analog, and RF circuitry, the signal and noise coupling between blocks through the semi-conducting substrate becomes an important issue for successful system design.18" For example, the great amount of harmonics in the switching noise generated from the digital block may be coupled to the adjacent RF block whose signal level is very weak, to significantly degrade the signal-tonoise ratio of the system. Thus, an efficient isolation technique preventing the substrate coupling should be devised. Also, accurate substrate coupling models that can be incorporated into the circuit simulator are required for the accurate simulation of the designed circuits. 2.2. Three-port/four-terminal rather than a two-port/three-terminal
device
The conventional high-frequency FET's have three terminals: a gate, a source, and a drain. Bipolar transistors are also three-terminal devices, having an emitter, a base, and a collector as their terminals. However, the MOSFET has a fourth terminal, the "body", as shown in Fig. 1. The body is doped opposite to the source/drain regions to isolate these two regions by reversebiased p-n junctions. For reliable operation of a MOSFET, the body terminal should be connected to a certain terminal with a fixed potential. It is typically connected to ground (the lowest potential used in the circuit) for an n-MOSFET and Vdd (the highest potential used in the circuit) for a p-MOSFET to prevent the source/drain junctions from being forward-biased in any case.
70
MOSFET
Modeling and Parameter
Extraction for RF IC's
957
Fig. 1. Simplified cross-section of a MOSFET.
The basic concept of FET operation is to control the current flow between the source and the drain by adjusting the voltage applied to the gate terminal. The carriers - electrons for an nMOSFET and holes for a p-MOSFET - start from the source where they have a higher potential energy and move through the channel region below the gate and sink into the drain where they have a lower potential energy. The number of carriers participating in a current flow is controlled by the field induced from the gate voltage. In a MOSFET, the change in the body potential can also cause the change in the number of channel carriers. This control mechanism by body voltage is very similar to that by gate voltage, although the body voltage is much less efficient than the gate voltage in controlling the current flow. Thus the MOSFET is essentially a four-terminal device. In many cases, the source and the body of the MOSFET are tied together. Even for this configuration, however, a MOSFET cannot be treated as a three-terminal device because the potential of the intrinsic body node (Fig. 1), which can affect the device operation, is neither the same as the (extrinsic) body terminal nor as the source. With DC excitations, the intrinsic body potential is the same as the extrinsic one, which is also identical to the source terminal. However, with AC excitations, the AC body current becomes significant as the excitation frequency increases. The distributed R-C network composed of the depletion capacitances and the substrate resistances, and the AC current flowing through this R-C network directly coupled from gate, drain, and source terminals make the potentials of the extrinsic body and the intrinsic body different. It is much more difficult to explain and predict the behavior of the four-terminal device than that of the three-terminal device. A three-terminal device can be treated as a two-port network, where four complex numbers (eight real numbers) are enough to characterize the device. However, nine complex numbers (eighteen real numbers) are required to characterize a fourterminal device. The complexity increase due to this difference is significant. The highfrequency modeling and parameter extraction is even more difficult considering the signal coupling between various terminals through the substrate. In addition, the measurement of the four-terminal device is harder to perform and more time-consuming. Additional DC /-K curves are needed to characterize the effects of the body terminal in DC operation, and, ideally a threeport S-parameter measurement is needed to fully characterize the small-signal behaviors of the four-terminal device at high frequencies in AC operation. However, there is no established
71
958
M. Je, I. Kwon, H. Shin & K. Lee
measurement technique to perform an on-wafer three-port ^-parameter measurement. Even if three-port measurement is possible, the number of measurement ports is increased and there are many more bias combinations for the AC characteristics to consider; thus the measurement becomes much more time-consuming. As a result, the data handling and the parameter extraction procedure become very complicated. 1.3. Difficulties in CMOS RF modeling/parameter extraction As discussed above, the modeling and the parameter extraction of RF MOSFET's are different from and more difficult than those of conventional high frequency transistors mainly due to the lossy silicon substrate and the four-terminal device structure of MOSFET's. The difficulties can be summarized as follows: • A more complicated model with a larger number of parameters is required to describe the behavior of the four-terminal MOSFET. • The parasitic components for both active and passive devices as well as for pads and interconnection lines, originating from the semi-conducting substrate, should be included and the effects of signal coupling through the substrate parasitics should be considered properly. • The lossy silicon substrate causes large parasitics of the probing pads and interconnection lines. Accurate measurement and careful de-embedding of these parasitics should be performed using well-designed de-embedding fixtures to obtain the real characteristics of intrinsic MOSFET's. • An on-wafer three-port S-parameter measurement technique has not yet been wellestablished, although it is needed to obtain full small-signal characteristics of four-terminal MOSFET's. Until now, the well-established two-port measurement has been used to characterize MOSFET's, which gives insufficient information to model the four-terminal device. • The measurement of three-port/four-terminal devices requires more measurement points and longer time, and produces a large amount of data. • The manipulation of the large amount of data and the extraction of a large number of model parameters are difficult and time-consuming. Despite these problems, intensive efforts have been spent in the field of MOSFET modeling and parameter extraction, and partial solutions have been exhibited. In the next section, we will introduce basic strategies for RF modeling and parameter extraction of two-port networks. Then, in section 3, various three-terminal models and parameter extraction methods for conventional high-frequency transistors and RF MOSFET's, including the work we performed recently, are extensively described. We briefly comment on four-terminal MOSFET modeling and parameter extraction in section 4, followed by conclusion.
72
MOSFET Modeling and Parameter Extraction for RF IG's
959
2. RF Modeling Approaches and Parameter Extraction Strategies for Two-Port Network At high frequencies above about 1 GHz, S-parameter measurement is the easiest and the most reliable way to measure the network characteristics of a certain functional block. A great number of models and corresponding parameter extraction methods from S-parameter measurement data have been proposed for various kinds of two-port networks such as passive devices20 and transistors.™1 In this section, we will discuss the concept and useful interpretations of S-parameters in section 2.1; the basics of modeling and parameter extraction in section 2.2; adequate modeling and parameter extraction strategies for linear/reciprocal and nonlinear/nonreciprocal two-port networks in sections 2.3 and 2.4, respectively; and, finally, requirements for RF FET modeling in section 2.5. 2.2. Physical, mathematical, and engineering interpretations circuit design and measurement
of S-parameters for
An Alport device can be represented in many ways. At low frequency, this is usually done by Z, Y, or H matrices. This is because it is easier to force or measure terminal voltage (or current) with open (or short) circuit. However, there are many problems with this at high frequency. Firstly, accurate high frequency measuring of voltage or current is very hard. In addition, an active device may oscillate or self-destruct with open or shorted connections. Secondly, the voltage or current depends on the cable length, which is always needed to connect a DUT (device under test) and a measurement system. This is equivalent to saying that they are position dependent along the cable. Thirdly, it is not easy to achieve truly open/short termination at high frequency. On the other hand, terminating the port with a cable of characteristic impedance ZQ is much easier. Instead of voltage or current, it is physically and mathematically much easier to work with power (or equivalent voltage) waves propagating into and being reflected from or transmitted through the device. Note that this propagating equivalent voltage wave is position invariant along the cable. Moreover, incident power is fully absorbed, or equivalently there is no reflected power, when the cable corresponding to the force/measure port is terminated by Z0. S-parameters, or scattering parameters in an Alport network are defined as the complex reflection coefficients at each port and complex transmission coefficients of the equivalent voltage wave between each pair of ports. An Alport network has A/2 S-parameters, among which N parameters indicate the reflection coefficients and the remaining N2-N parameters, the transmission coefficients." The S-parameter measurement technique overcomes all of the above drawbacks in characterizing high-frequency networks." The S-parameters relate to familiar measurements such as gain, loss, and the reflection coefficient. The measured S-parameters of multiple devices can be cascaded to predict overall system performance. They are analytically convenient for CAD programs and flow-graph analysis, and mathematically, H, Y, and Z- parameters can be derived from S-parameters when necessary. It should be noted, however, that S-parameters are measured with a particular Z0-system, i.e., 50 O. For example, S2| is the forward gain when terminal 2 is terminated by Z0. This gives insight for a hybrid circuit but not for an integrated
73
960 M. Je, I. Kwon, H. Shin & K. Lee circuit, because usually the output impedance for the former is matched to Z0, while it is very far from Z0 for the latter. Thus S2\ can be interpreted as the rough gain of the device only when its input/output impedance level is around ZQ. 2.2. Basic concepts of modeling and parameter extraction Only when both a proper model and a good set of model parameters are used together, can we obtain accurate and meaningful circuit simulation results. Thus, it is important to develop both a mathematically well-conditioned model to effectively describe the device characteristics and its associated parameter extraction method to find the correct parameter set. The model and the extracted parameter set should be able not only to fit the measured data well but also to predict the correct device behavior under conditions where no measurement is made. Because a correct and efficient parameter extraction is as important as the model itself, we should carefully consider the parameter extraction strategy and method at the same time as when the model is developed. Prior to discussion of the practical modeling and parameter extraction strategies, we should explain modeling and parameter extraction. Most of the device models have their own equivalent circuits, which consist of resistances, capacitances, inductances, voltage-controlled current sources, and so on. This equivalent circuit, having the proper values for each circuit element, generates the device characteristics, or predictions. The value of each element in the equivalent circuit is determined either by examining the data table for table models or by solving the physical or empirical equations for physical models. The model parameters indicate either the values of elements themselves for the table model or the physical and empirical constants and coefficients that appear in the equations describing the behavior of elements for the physical model. In the case of the table model, developing the model of a certain device means that we construct the equivalent circuit that can explain the device behavior in the operation region of interest and devise an appropriate interpolation scheme that can give values of elements when the device does not operate at measurement points. Sometimes, the equivalent circuit of the table model may not be physical, but just mathematical and the element values may be just measured 5-parameter values themselves like the Root model.,4*' The set of measurement conditions should be carefully designed to efficiently cover the whole range in which the device operates. On the other hand, in the case of the physical model, modeling implies constructing the equivalent circuit and formulating the suitable equations that are solved for the element values when the device operating conditions are given. When we extract the model parameters of the physical model, we first extract the element values that fit the measurement data under various conditions, and then find the best values of the constants and coefficients in the equations that describe the characteristics of elements in the operation range of interest. Parameter extraction is not needed for some simple physical models because all of the element values can be calculated from the physical equations without extracting the constants and coefficients experimentally if the process parameters and the device geometries are given. With a physical understanding of the device operation, we can construct the equivalent
74
MOSFET Modeling and Parameter Extraction for RF IC's
961
circuit by choosing and arranging the proper elements. We may further develop the set of equations, each of which describes the behavior of each element. All of the elements and all of the constants and coefficients in the equations must ideally have the corresponding physical origins. However, some of them may be added by empirical experience to enhance the model accuracy. Note that with increasing the number of elements (and/or constants and coefficients), the model accuracy may be improved, but it scarifies the computational efficiency and complicates the parameter extraction. A good model should give satisfactory predictions within the target error tolerance with a minimum number of elements, constants, and coefficients. If the model is physically correct and the model parameters are extracted well, the values of the elements such as resistances, capacitances, and inductances should usually be frequencyindependent by definition. However, like the current source, transconductance and conductance with non-quasi-static"M orfrequency-dispersion40-"characteristics, some elements may be frequency dependent. We assume that the S-parameter measurement is made to extract the model parameters and the measurement at one discrete bias-frequency generates A" independent S-parameters. Since Sparameters are complex numbers, each S-parameter has a real part and an imaginary part, or magnitude and phase, ^measurement data is obtained for one set of S-parameter measurement. If we make measurements at / discrete frequency points without changing bias voltages, 1XY measurement data are generated. The parameter extraction is simply the procedure to find the best set of model parameters fitting the measurement data set. In principle, 1XY data points can be exactly fitted using 1XY independent elements. However, the number of the elements in the practical equivalent circuit is usually and should be much less than 2XY, and it is impossible to model all of the detailed physical phenomena. Besides, there always exist measurement errors. Due to these reasons, the model predictions cannot fit the measurement data perfectly. Thus, the best set of parameters does not give an exact fitting of the measurement data but best approximates it with minimum error under certain criteria. There are various methods to obtain the best set of model parameters and the methods can be classified into three categories: optimization-based approach,'2-" decomposition-based approach,4'-" and direct extraction:4"50 A. Optimization-based approach We assume that the properties of the model are accurately represented with its K characteristics. Let p = [Pi,P2,- • ;PN]Z RN be the vector of model parameters to be extracted, y' =LVj'>J;2'''"'>.>v']e RM > ' = 1,2,- -.AT , the vector of model performance of the i-th characteristics, and zl =[zt',z2',--,zM']e RM , i = \,2,---,K , the vector of measured performance of the »'-th characteristics. A general device model of the i-th characteristic can be written as y' = y'{p). Given the known device model y' = y'{p) for all i"s, pointwise error of the model can be defined as ej'(p) = y]'(p)-zj'{p), M
i = \,2,---,K, j = \,2,---,M . Given
a set of weights W = [w, vv2>- • -,wM]e R , i = 1,2,- • ,K, a scalar measure of partial model
75
962 M. Je, I. Kwon, H. Shin & K. Lee accuracy is assumed as
under the well-known least squares criterion. The global optimization is to find the parameter vectors p^ e R" that minimize the total error function e(p) given as
e(p) = ie'(p).
(2)
Various optimization techniques, such as a gradient-based Levenberg-Marquardt algorithm," a simulated annealing algorithm," and a simulated diffusion algorithm," are used to solve the given optimization problem, like (2). It is generally believed that global optimization is needed to extract the "best" set of parameters to fit the measured performances. However, it is also the most problematic one. The false convergence to a local minimum is frequent if the initial approximations to model parameters are not sufficiently accurate, and substantial computing resources might be needed. This approach cannot provide any intuition to model users. B. Decomposition-based approach Detailed knowledge of model functions is used to design measurements and transform data in such a way as to make the error functions e'(p) in (1) dependent only on a small subset of model parameters. If the parameter subset for different characteristics were disjoint, K independent regressions could be used instead of the global optimization problem or minimization of (2). Furthermore, simplifications of the model in properly selected parts of the characteristics are typically employed, resulting in reduction of the extraction problem to a sequence of some simple curve fittings. The advantage is a simple and fast extraction (with model simplification). Model users can also get some sense of the relationships between parameter values and generated model characteristics. However, because interactions between characteristics are ignored, quality of total fit suffers. Additional model simplifications reduce accuracy even further. C. Direct parameter extraction For some simple models with a relatively small number of parameters, an adequate set of parameters can be solved analytically. In many cases, like the decomposition-based approach, the model is simplified and solved to obtain the model parameters in the selected parts of the characteristics. Direct parameter extraction requires that the analytical expressions are formulated for a particular model based on the separation of model parameters and a few selected parts of the characteristics. The extracted results from direct parameter extraction are sensitive to the device models. Obviously, the measurement accuracy of the selected data points must be very high to reduce the extraction errors. The accuracy of the model with directly extracted parameters may not be the "best." In addition, the development cost involved in such an approach is high. However, the extraction procedure is very straightforward and needs very short computation time. The greatest virtue of this approach is to give users a useful intuition
76
MOSFET Modeling and Parameter Extraction for RF IC's
963
during the parameter extraction. In practice, the above three approaches are properly combined according to the features of the model. We can easily find cases where the decomposition-based successive curve fitting method and the direct extraction method are used together. Even if the decomposition-based method and/or direct extraction method are sufficient to extract the parameters, often the global optimization step is followed to enhance the model accuracy. 2.3. Modeling and parameter extraction strategies for a linear/reciprocal network
two-port
We will focus on the modeling and parameter extraction strategies for linear/reciprocal two-port networks in this section. Most of the passive devices can be treated as linear networks under normal conditions, or when too high voltage is not applied and too large current doesn't flow through the devices. A linear network doesn't have dependence on the applied bias voltages. On the other hand, a passive device is a reciprocal network because no amplifying activity takes place. Thus, most passive devices are modeled as linear and reciprocal networks in practice. The equivalent circuit of the linear/reciprocal device consists of linear/reciprocal passive elements, such as resistances, inductances, and capacitances. There is no transconductance and no transcapacitance because of the reciprocal characteristics and the passive elements in the equivalent circuit have no or negligible bias dependence because of the linear characteristics. For the linear network, there is no distinction between a small-signal model and a large-signal model. If the model is physically correct and the model parameters are extracted well, the values of the elements should usually be frequency-independent and bias-independent as the ideal resistances, inductances, and capacitances show neither frequency dependence nor bias dependence. In the physical model, the equations should not be functions of bias voltages or operation frequencies but of process parameters and geometric parameters of the passive devices only. The operation of passive devices is relatively simple although some parasitic components must be considered adequately. In addition, the number of significant technology parameters for passive devices is smaller than those of transistors and technology parameters, including the substrate doping concentration, are much simpler for passive devices than for transistors. As a result, there are only a few elements in the equivalent circuit, and the physical modeling based on equations is relatively easy. In most cases, parameters can be extracted directly or by using very simple curve fitting such as linear regression. For convenience, a simple optimization technique might be used without severe convergence problems. To characterize a passive device, S-parameter measurements are also made to extract the model parameters and evaluate the model accuracy. Due to the linear characteristics, however, the 5-parameter measurements at only one bias point sweeping the frequency is sufficient. The measurements generate four J-parameters - Sn, Sn, S2\, and S22 - as functions of frequency. Making a distinction between the real part and the imaginary part of each S-parameter, or the magnitude and the phase of each J-parameter, results in eight measured characteristics.
77
964
M. Je, I. Kwon,
H. Shin & K. Lee
However, considering that 5, 2 and S2i of the reciprocal network have the same value due to reciprocity," the number of independent measurement characteristics reduces to six. These characteristics, or the converted characteristics in the form of//, Y, or Z-parameters, are used to evaluate the model performance and extract parameters. As an example of passive device modeling and parameter extraction, we will briefly review the model and parameter extraction method for silicon on-chip spiral inductors presented in a paper by Yue and Wong:'8 Example.
Modeling and parameter extraction for a silicon on-chip spiral inductor."
4"Bfc:
(a) Layout of a square-type spiral inductor. MSM4-¥2 • M2
:S m m m ; L
i-V3
Oxide
Silicon substrate
B
(b) Cross-section along A-B. Fig. 2. Layout and cross-section of a typical on-chip spiral inductor. The on-chip inductors are fabricated using a microstrip transmission line wound in a spiral. In addition to the rectangular geometry as shown in Fig. 2, octagonal and circular geometries are also widely used to implement microstrip spiral inductors. Figure 2(b) shows a crosssectional view of the square-type spiral inductor. Multiple metal layers are often stacked and connected together through via to reduce the ohmic loss resulting from the resistivity of the metal line. A metal layer passing under the spiral is used to access the inner port (point B in Fig. 2(a)) of the inductor. Note that a lower-level metal (Ml) is not used in Fig. 2. By including Ml,
78
MOSFET
Modeling and Parameter
Extraction for RF IC's
965
we can decrease the coupling to the lossy substrate, which significantly degrades the inductor performance at high frequencies. Although the inductor is a device intended for storing magnetic field energy, inevitably parasitic resistances dissipate energy through ohmic loss, lowering the inductor quality factor Q appreciably. In addition, the parasitic capacitance limits the operating frequency of the integrated inductor drastically. Since these counter-productive parasitics limit the inductor performance, it is very important to include and model them accurately, as well as to predict the inductance value correctly. The physical model of a spiral inductor on silicon is v ~g. 3. The inductance and resistance of the spiral and underpass are represented oy aie series inductance, Ls, and the series resistance, Rs, respectively. The overlap between the spiral and the underpass allows direct capacitive coupling between the two terminals of the inductor. This feed-through path is modeled by the series capacitance, Cs. The oxide capacitance between the spiral and the silicon substrate is modeled by COT. The capacitance and resistance of the silicon substrate are modeled by C$i and Rsi-
1c
c£
..
Fig. 3. The lumped physical model of a spiral inductor on silicon."
Ls can be calculated as a sum of all the self and mutual inductances. The self inductance of a line with a rectangular cross-section and the mutual inductance between two parallel lines can be calculated from geometric parameters of lines using adequate formulas summarized by Graver." Based on Graver's formulas, Greenhouse developed an algorithm for computing the inductance of planar rectangular spirals." The Greenhouse method states that the overall inductance of a spiral can be computed by summing the self inductance of each wire segment and the positive and negative mutual inductance between all possible line segment pairs. When a conductor is subjected to a time-varying magnetic field, the eddy current effect occurs. Eddy currents manifest themselves as skin and proximity effects. In the case of the skin effect, the time-varying field due to the current flow in a conductor induces eddy currents in the conductor itself. The proximity effect takes place when a conductor is under the influence of a time-varying field produced by a nearby conductor carrying a time-varying current. The skineffect eddy current and the proximity-effect eddy current superimpose to form the total eddy current distribution. Regardless of the induction mechanism, eddy currents reduce the net current flow in the conductor and hence increase the AC resistance. The series resistance of each line segment caused by the skin effect can be expressed as
79
966
M. Je, I. Kwon, H. Shin & K. Lee
(3)
W-ttf
where p, /, and w represent the resistivity, the length, and the width of the line, respectively, t^ denotes the effective thickness of the line and is defined as 5 (4) teff=S-(\-e-" ) where t is the thickness of the line and 5 is the skin depth, which is a function of frequency. Thus, in fact, Rs depends upon frequency. Despite that the skin effect is more severe than the proximity effect in typical cases, if we want to include the resistance resulting from the proximity effect, it can be computed using a numerical electromagnetic field solver and added XoRs. Based on the inductor's structure, both the crosstalk between adjacent turns and the overlap between the spiral and underpass contribute to Cs. However, since the adjacent turns are almost equipotential, the effect of the crosstalk capacitance is negligible. Therefore, for most practical inductors, it is sufficient to model Cs as the sum of all overlap capacitances, which is equal to S„
..2
Cs=n-w<
^ —
(5)
t0x,M2-M3
where n is the number of overlaps and taxMi-Mi is the oxide thickness between the spiral and the underpass. eox denotes the oxide permittivity. In this model, a MOS microstrip structure is modeled by a three-element network comprised of CM, Rs,, and CSi. Cox represents the oxide capacitance, whereas RSi and Q, represent the silicon substrate resistance and capacitance, respectively. The physical origin of RSi is the silicon conductivity, which is predominately determined by the majority carrier concentration. CSi models the high-frequency capacitive effects occurring in the semiconductor and its value increases with frequency. The substrate capacitance and resistance are approximately proportional to the area occupied by the inductor and can be approximated by Cox=yl-W^,
(6)
CSi=\-l-wCsub,
(7)
and Rsi=,
2 r
'•W-Gsub
(8)
where Csub and Gsub are capacitance and conductance per unit area for the silicon substrate. The factor of two accounts for the fact that the substrate parasitics are assumed to be distributed equally at the two ends of the inductor. Csub and Gsub are functions of the substrate doping and are extracted from measurement results using a simple optimization technique. With all the extracted parameter values, the small-signal characteristics of the equivalent circuit can be simulated using a CAD tool such as SPICE, and then compared to the measured results. For inductors, the quality factor calculated from the 5-parameters should also be
80
MOSFET Modeling and Parameter Extraction for RF IC's
967
verified to validate the developed model and parameter extraction procedure. The on-chip spiral inductor on the silicon substrate is one of the most complicated passive devices. We should consider and model the electromagnetic phenomena dominating the device operation correctly. We have reviewed an example" for this topic. The equivalent circuit composed of elements having their own physical origins was developed and the parameter values were extracted using several equations, a simple optimization, and a numerical solver, if it were needed. 2.4. Modeling and parameter extraction strategies for a nonlinear/nonreciprocal twoport FET Conventional RF FET's have been modeled as nonlinear/nonreciprocal two-port networks. The characteristics of FETs exhibit strong dependence on bias as it is intended to: for example, as the gate voltage increases and comes to exceed a certain threshold value, significant current starts to run through the channel. Thus, a FET is a nonlinear network and both a small-signal model and a large-signal model are needed to completely describe the device operation. The most important aspects of the FET features are amplification and switching operation. The amplification occurring in the FET implies that the FET must be a nonreciprocal network and thus needs transconductances and transcapacitances in its small-signal equivalent circuit. The transconductance represents the amplifying activity itself and the transcapacitance represents the phenomenon where the charge between two given nodes in the active device is controlled not only by the voltages across the two nodes but also by the voltages applied at other nodes, which is unlike the operation of a passive capacitor such as a simple parallel plate capacitor. The transcapacitance is indispensable in guaranteeing charge conservation, especially when the transient behavior of the FET is simulated.57*0 More about this will be discussed in 3-1. The device physics of FETs is not simple and a large number of process parameters and geometric parameters affect the operation. The equivalent circuit requires numeruous elements to describe the device behavior accurately and it is hard to develop equation-based physical models that provide sufficiently accurate predictions. Usually, the equations are augmented by several empirical constants or functional terms. Furthermore, for high-frequency application of the FET model, phenomena such as non-quasi-static effects and frequency dispersion effects must be modeled correctly. The modeling of these effects results in frequency-dependent elements" "•" in the frequency domain description, or equivalently, elements with delayed response in the time domain description. The amount of the delay is often represented by a time constant"" or numerically determined by solving partial differential equations." For most of the conventional RF FET models, the S-parameters are measured sweeping frequency and used to extract small-signal parameters. Since the FET has bias dependence, the S-parameter measurements are made at a set of bias points that effectively covers the operation region of interest and parameters are extracted at each bias point. The S-parameter measurements at each bias point generate four S-parameter characteristics - S,u S\2, S2I, and S22 - varying with frequency. No pair of these characteristics is identical when the device is on and operates in an active mode, while S,2 and S2, coincides when the device is off and passive. The elements in the equivalent circuit can be divided into two groups: the extrinsic parasitic
81
968 M. Je, I. Kwon, H. Shin & K. Lee elements and the intrinsic ones. The extrinsic elements are not related to the intrinsic FET operation, whereas the intrinsic elements represent the active operation of the intrinsic FET. For example, the interconnection parasitics and overlap capacitances are the extrinsic elements and the transconductance and gate capacitances are intrinsic ones. The different nature of the extrinsic elements and the intrinsic elements is often used to extract parameters more easily. The extrinsic elements have no or negligible bias dependence while the intrinsic elements have strong bias dependence. Taking advantage of this difference, it is common practice to apply zero drain bias to the FET,6' where the behavior of the intrinsic FET is much simpler. This coldFET method reduces the number of elements and the values of the remaining extrinsic elements can be extracted without difficulties. With the values of the extrinsic elements determined, then parameters related to the intrinsic FET are extracted to complete the parameter extraction. When the parameter values at an arbitrary bias point are needed during a simulation, the values are obtained using proper interpolation functions such as a polynomial function or a spline function. Also an interpolation function connecting the small-signal measurement data points is integrated to generate the large-signal parameters." Although a lot of parameters are extracted from the S-parameters, sometimes DC I-V characteristics are also measured to extract the DCrelated parameters." Until recently, somewhat different approaches have been applied to model MOSFET's and to extract MOSFET parameters until recently. This is because the MOSFET is a four-terminal, or three-port device and thus the approach used for the III-V FET could not be effective, on one hand, and because the high-frequency characteristics have not been as important for MOSFET's as for III-V FET's, on the other hand. It was only a few years ago that the high-frequency modeling of the MOSFET began to generate extensive interest. The modeling of MOSFET's has been mainly focused on the DC I-V and low-frequency C-V characteristics, and thus most MOSFET models are based on complicated large-signal equations describing the drain current and charge at each terminal - gate, drain, source, and body - as functions of terminal voltages.63 While the equations stem from the MOSFET device physics basically, many empirical constants, coefficients, and functional terms enhance the performance of the model equations. Typically, the DC I-V and low-frequency C-V characteristics are measured and a fairly complex extraction sequence follows to obtain reasonably good fitting to the measurement data. The extraction routine consists of decomposition-based extraction steps followed by global optimization steps with multiple targets to refine the model performance.6* Recently, as the high-frequency modeling of MOSFET's attracts growing interest, new approaches are being applied to MOSFET modeling and parameter extraction. In this section we have discussed the basic strategies of modeling and parameter extraction for FET's. We will review actual examples to make the concepts more tangible in sections 3 and 4, with emphasis on the modeling and parameter extraction of RF MOSFET's, or new approaches. Before examining the modeling examples, the requirements for successful RF FET modeling will be discussed to elucidate RF FET modeling.
82
MOSFET Modeling and Parameter Extraction for RF IC's
969
2.5. Requirements for RF FET modeling The requirements for RF FET modeling should be considered from several points of view: Which measurement method is the most reliable at high frequencies? What performances are important and should be predicted accurately in RF circuit and system design? What conditions should be satisfied to guarantee a robust and efficient circuit simulation? As mentioned previously, S-parameter measurements are the only practical method to characterize the high-frequency performance of devices, circuits, and systems. Thus a RF model and its parameter extraction scheme had better be based on a small-signal model because the Sparameter measurement is a small-signal measurement. Note that by the S-parameter measurement one obtains / ' (= dl/dV) and C (= dQ/dV) at the frequencies of interest. Making an accurate measurement and using the results for parameter extraction is desirable for successful modeling without doubt. Table 3. Required quantities for RF circuit design.
LNA • Bias ( / ) • Gain(/', C) • Linearity
(I",I'",C) • Thermal noise
Mixer
Oscillator
• Bias(/) • Conversion gain (7",C) • Linearity (/"",C)
• Bias (7) • Oscillation frequency (/\C) • Oscillation amplitude (/",/"',£) • Phase noise (///"noise)
Power Amp.
• Bias (I) • Gain(/', C) • Linearity
(I'",C)
Table 3 shows the list of quantities that a successful RF FET model must predict accurately for the important building blocks of RF systems, which indicates that RF models should be able to simulate /, /', /", and /'" very accurately. This is an extremely challenging task. Compared with low frequency analog circuits, a RF system requires much better accuracy of higher harmonics. Besides, the most efficient RF simulation is based on harmonic balance. Thus RF circuit simulation needs much higher-order continuity to improve numerical accuracy as well as simulation convergence speed. It can be easily inferred that starting from / ' modeling/extraction with the help of S-parameter measurement and then constructing /, /", and /'" is a more efficient way than starting from modeling and extraction of / itself. Because / should be uniquely determined for a given Vgs, Vds bias condition, where Vgs is the gate-to-source voltage and V& is the drain-to-source voltage, respectively, all of the / ' are not independent. Similarly, we measure C (=Q") first then extract parameters and construct Q. As all / ' are not independent, so are Q', such that Q is uniquely determined at a given bias condition. This is needed for charge conservation. One of the very important requirements for FET modeling and parameter extraction is that charge conservation is absolutely required for accuracy and simulation convergence. To accomplish this, we should model the current and charge of FET's as path-independent
83
970 M. Je, I. Kwon, H. Shin & K. Lee
quantities.57 In other words, after controlling voltages are allowed to vary and then return to their original values, the values of the current and charge should remain unchanged regardless of the variation history. Details on the charge conservation will be discussed in the next section. 3. Three-Terminal RF MOSFET Modeling and Parameter Extraction Examples As mentioned in 1.2, a MOSFET is a four-terminal device rather than a three-terminal device, unlike other RF FET's. In spite of this fact, in many works, the MOSFET has been modeled as a three-terminal device in the RF range. A three-terminal modeling approach makes the problem quite simple and there are good solutions to this simplified problem devised for conventional III-V FET's already. One wants to use the well-established RF modeling and parameter extraction methods for the conventional III-V FET's. The source and the body terminals of a MOSFET are tied together in many applications, and the MOSFET configured in this way can be handled as a three-terminal device without large errors. In this section, we will examine and discuss the three-terminal modeling approach of RF MOSFET's after the III-V FET modeling/parameter extraction techniques are introduced. 3.1. Brief review of small- and large-signal modeling and parameter techniques for III-V FET's
extraction
The differences between III-V FET models and MOSFET models result from the fact that III-V FET's were originally modeled for high-frequency applications whereas in the past MOSFET models were intended to simulate digital circuits and low-frequency analog circuits. Thus, in studies on III-V FET modeling/parameter extraction, high-frequency modeling issues such as de-embedding of pads and interconnection parasitics, non-quasi-static effects, and nonlinear characteristics including high-order harmonics have been intensively addressed for a long time. Many techniques were developed to address the high-frequency modeling and parameter extraction problems efficiently, and unique features of III-V models were formed during the process. For MOSFET's, physical models that describe the device behavior with a set of equations have mostly been based on large-signal model. This is because it provides the necessary accuracy as well as computation efficiency required by the digital and low-frequency analog VLSI. In contrast to this, it is not difficult to find table models for III-V FET's containing a collection of small-signal measurement data for later retrieval. Actually, the Root model, one of the most widely accepted III-V FET models, is a table-model. There are several reasons why the table models have been applied to III-V FET circuit simulation extensively. The table model can provide quite accurate predictions required for high frequency circuit design without a complete understanding of the physical mechanisms of problematic issues such as non-quasi-static effect, nonlinear characteristics, and frequency dispersion effect, especially for III-V FET's. This is possible because the table model is basically based on measurement; thus, if measurements are made carefully and proper data handling is guaranteed, relatively accurate modeling results can be obtained.
84
MOSFET Modeling and Parameter Extraction for RF IC's 971 Another reason to use table models for III-V FET's is that in many cases, the simulation of RF circuits with III-V FET's has been performed using a harmonic balance simulator, which simulates the circuit performance in the frequency-domain. This harmonic balance simulation is most efficient in simulating circuits including components that have frequency-dependent characteristics. The modeling approach using a set of data measured varying frequency is a very natural one considering the harmonic balance simulation. The other type of circuit simulators are time-domain circuit simulation programs such as SPICE, which has been very popular for MOSFET circuit simulations. For this type of simulation, equation-based physical modeling is a natural approach because the equations can give the current value at each branch as a function of node voltages varying with times. There also exist several III-V FET models for the timedomain simulation such as the Curtice model," the Staz model,66 the Materka model,6' and TriQuint's own model (TOM),68 all of which are based on physical and empirical equations. Popular models for MOSFET's include the BSIM3v3 model,6' the MOS Model 9,6' and the EnzKrummenacher-Vittoz (EKV) model.™ Although table models can provide accurate results for high-frequency circuit simulation, they have problems and shortcomings. In table models, interpolation functions are used to generate continuous data at points between measurement data points. The continuity of the measured characteristics is guaranteed by using interpolation, but the first-order and higherorder derivatives of the characteristics might not be continuous if a proper interpolation function is not chosen. Discontinuities increase the time to converge and even make the simulation fail to converge. Furthermore, because the measurements always contain some errors, the numerical integration of the measured data to find the current or charge values might cause a charge non-conservation problem. However, the most important disadvantage of the table model is that the model is not predictive. This is simply because the table model is not based on device physics. The table model is only valid for devices under the same conditions as the device on which actual measurements were made. Performance of devices with different dimensions or technology parameters cannot be predicted effectively. Thus, all devices with different dimensions used in the circuit should be measured and it is practically impossible to analyze the yield of IC's accounting for process variations. We will now examine examples of RF III-V FET models and parameter extraction methods. The conventional small-signal equivalent circuit for III-V FET and its well-known parameterextraction method will be introduced, and the principles of nonlinear active device modeling studied by Root and Hughes will be reviewed with a resulting physical/empirical model topology.
85
972
M. Je, I. Kwon, H. Shin & K. Lee
6o-'rn
Fig. 4. Conventional small-signal equivalent circuit of a 1H-V FET.
The conventional small-signal equivalent circuit of a III-V FET is shown in Fig. 4. Dambrine, Cappy, Heliodore, and Playez have suggested an efficient method to determine the parameters of this equivalent circuit directly from the measured 5-parameters." Basically, this equivalent circuit can be divided into two parts: • the intrinsic elements, gm, gjs, Cgs, Cg
86
MOSFET Modeling and Parameter Extraction for RF IC's 973 current. In addition, the influence of the CK and Cpd parasitic capacitances is negligible and consequently the extrinsic Z-parameters are simply determined by adding the parasitic resistances Rs, Rg, Rd and inductances Lg, Ls, Ld to the intrinsic Z-parameters. In this bias condition, the Z-parameters of a cold FET are expressed as Zu=R,+Rt+^.
+
^ . +
j<0(L,+Lg)
Rr nkT . . Z12 =Z 2I =RS + -*+ —+ JQ>LS 2 ql, Z22=Rs+Rd+Rc+ja)(Ls+Ld)
(10) (ID (12)
|- r,nr >-^vw-r
Fig. 5. Small-signal equivalent circuit of a cold FET.71 The series parasitic elements can be extracted using these expressions. Ls can be extracted from Im(Zl2), Lg from Im(Zn), and Ld from In^Z^). In addition, the linear extrapolation of the plot Re(Zn) versus \llg to the ordinate gives the value of Rs + Rg + RJ3. Therefore the Zparameters' real parts provide three relations between the four unknowns, R„ Rg, Rd, and Rc. At this step, an additional relation is needed to separate the four unknowns. This additional relation can be the value of the sum Rs + Rd determined by the conventional method using the real part of Z22 and the concept of channel opening factor," the value of Rg provided from the resistance measurement, the values of Rs and Rd provided by DC measurement, or the value of Rc if the channel technological parameters are known. Therefore, the determination of the four parameters, Rs, Rg, Rd, and Rc, does not constitute a real problem since some redundant relations are available in most cases.
87
974
M. Je, I. Kwon, Hr Shin & K. Lee
B. Determination of the shunt parasitic elements Intrinsic device
Fig. 6. Small-signal equivalent circuit of a cold FET at gate voltage lower than the pinch off voltage.71
At zero drain bias and for a gate voltage lower than the pinch-off voltage Vp, the intrinsic capacitance (i.e., under the gate) cancels, as does the channel conductance. Under these biasing conditions, the FET equivalent circuit is shown in Fig. 6. In this figure, Cb represents the fringing capacitance due to the depleted layer extension at each side of the gate. For frequencies up to a few giga-hertz, the resistances and inductances have no influence on the imaginary part of the /-parameters, which can be written lm{Yu) = MCpg+2Cb)
(13)
Im(yI2) = Im(y2I) = -yfflCA
(14)
Im(y22) = yo»(C /x/ +C A ).
(15)
Thus, the three unknowns, Ch, Cpg, and C^, can be calculated using (13)—(15). C. Determination of the intrinsic Y-matrix The remaining problem is to determine the y-matrix of the intrinsic device from experimental data. When all the extrinsic elements are known through the previous steps A and B, the following procedure can be used to solve this problem: (a) transformation of the as-measured S-parameters to impedance (Z) parameters and subtraction of Lg and L,t that are series elements; (b) transformation of Z to /-parameters and subtraction of Cpg and C^ that are in parallel; (c) transformation of Yto Z-parameters and subtraction of Rg, Rs, Ls, Rd that are in series; (d) transformation of Zto y-parameters that correspond to the desired matrix. Therefore, the determination of the intrinsic admittance matrix can be carried out using some simple matrix manipulations with the known values of extrinsic elements.
88
MOSFET Modeling and Parameter Extraction for RF IC's 975 D. Extraction of the intrinsic elements Since the intrinsic device exhibits a n topology, it is convenient to use the admittance (Y) parameters to characterize its electrical properties. These parameters are Yu= 11
a>2R
V
• r
u
'
\ J
Yl2=-jcoCgd X21=
(16) (17)
-J(oC*d
i+mcgs
Y22=gds+J<»(Cds+Cgd)
(18)
(19)
with D = l + a>2Cgs2/?,2. For a typical device, the term o^C^R? is less than 0.01 at low frequency (< 5 GHz) and D = 1 constitutes a good approximation. In addition, assuming CDT« 1, we have rn=«2*,.CgJ2+MCgs+Cgrf) (20) Yl2=-jwCgd
(21)
>2i = *« - M e * + g,„ (*,Cgs + r))
(22)
1'!!=?.+>(CA+Cjl/).
(23)
Expressions (20)-(23) show that the intrinsic small-signal elements can be deduced from the Yparameters as follows: Cgli from Yn, Cgs and /J, from Yu,gm and rfrom Y2X, and lastly, gds and Crfs from y22Through steps A to A all the elements of the FET shown in Fig. 4 are extracted in a direct manner. This method is now well known and has been widely used to extract small-signal parameters of III-V FET's with or without modifications. The extraction of small-signal model parameters is used in the generation and verification of large signal models. The equivalent circuit and parameter extraction procedure introduced above are only for small-signal modeling. For obtaining the corresponding large-signal model, additional large-signal model construction method should be devised. However, as the equivalent circuit in Fig. 4 does not contain a complete set of intrinsic capacitances for charge conservation, we cannot build a successful large-signal model guaranteeing the charge conservation from this small-signal model. Note that in this work, all the parasitics including C w and Cpj are extracted without using separate test fixtures. However, it is also common practice to determine and de-embed pad parasitic elements using separate patterns: open and short patterns for the two-step method," and open, short, and thru patterns for the three-step method." Root and Hughes are the pioneers who addressed the possible problems of equivalent circuits such as that shown in Fig. 4 and presented the principles of nonlinear active device modeling for circuit simulation in SPICE and harmonic balance programs, motivated by an examination of three common problems of standard nonlinear GaAs MESFET models." Here
89
976
M. Je, I. Kwon, H. Shin & K. Lee
we will focus on the first and second problems and their solutions, which introduce the concepts of a voltage controlled charge source (VCQS) and a transcapacitance. These concepts are so important that we review the original ideas of Root and Hughes here. The first problem is that simulations done in large-signal analysis don't fit the measured imaginary parts of the v-parameters versus bias. On the other hand, good fits to the measurements can be obtained in linear (small-signal) analysis. The solution is to use nonlinear VCQS elements in place of two-terminal capacitors in the nonlinear model. A VCQS is a reactive analogue of the familiar voltage controlled current source. This improves the accuracy and convergence properties of the large signal reactive FET model. Linearizing the resulting equations produces an accurate small-signal model, consistent with the large-signal simulations in the appropriate limit. Linearizing a VCQS element produces another unfamiliar quantity, the transcapacitance. A transcapacitance is a reactive analogue of a transconductance. G O
SO
( ^
OD
I* Fig. 7. Voltage controlled current source element.
The nodal equations solved by SPICE in transient (large-signal) analysis are given in (24). There are similar equations, written in the frequency domain, which characterize the harmonic balance based circuit simulators." It is possible in principle to formulate active device models starting directly from the quantities of (24). However, it is often much easier to begin from basic nonlinear elements, and use them as building blocks to construct full models.76 Ii{V\{t\--;VN{t)) + ^-Qi{V,(t),--;VN{t)) = Q, i = \,--,N where N = number of nodes. (24) at Corresponding to each of the terms of the left hand side of (24), there is a nonlinear branch element which we consider. The first is a familiar element, the voltage controlled current source (VCCS). It defines a branch current as a nonlinear function of one or more controlling voltages. A schematic of a three-terminal VCCS element is given in Fig. 7. This example can be considered the most elementary nonlinear model of a FET. The model drain-source current Ids depends on the gate-source voltage Vgs as well as the drain-source voltage Vds. Ifi'UiVr'V*) (25) A nonlinear element related to the second term on the left hand side of (24) is the VCQS. It is a multi-terminal reactive analogue of a VCCS. The VCQS defines a branch charge as a nonlinear function of one or more controlling voltages. The branch current is defined to be the total time derivative of the charge. A schematic of a three-terminal VCQS element is given in Fig. 8. The charge associated with the gate-source branch Qgs depends on the gate-source voltage Vgs and also on the drain-source voltage V^ as given in (26). This is a generalization of
90
MOSFET
Modeling and Parameter
Extraction for RF IC's
977
the familiar two-terminal capacitor, where the charge associated with a branch depends only on the single voltage difference across the element. The branch current of a VCQS element is defined, in (27), by the total time derivative of the charge. The associated reference direction for current to flow is chosen to be from the positive to the negative sign of the symbol in Fig. 8. Notice that the gate-source branch current of this element has a term proportional to the time derivative of the drain-source voltage. The coefficient of proportionality cQsJdVds is a 'so a function of Vgs and Vds. This is called a transcapacitance Cm, which is a reactive analogue of the transconductance. (26) Qgs=Qgs(vgs,vds) jVCQS ' gs
=
-
d_Q
_
i. « g s
df
= c„
dt
dQgs dVgs dv„gs dt •+c„
d
Qg* dVds
dvH, dt
dKis dt
(27)
G Q
o„© SO
OD
Fig. 8. Voltage controlled charge source element.
The model current /rfs of the VCCS nonlinear element of Fig. 7 is plotted versus the two controlling bias voltages Vgs and Vds in Fig. 9. Ids describes a two-dimensional surface. The slope of the Ids surface in the direction parallel to the Vgs axis defines the model transconductance gm(Vgs, V&). The slope of this surface in the direction parallel to the V^ axis defines the model conductance gds(Vgs> V
Yds) = -dI"s BV. gs gds(Vgs,V*)
91
=
2Lt dV,ds
(28) (29)
978 M. Je, I. Kwon, H. Shin & K. Lee
Fig. 9. Model current /* vs. two controlling bias voltages V& and V&. 2 Taking the partial derivative of (28) with respect to Vds, and noting 8 L
dlL
ur dVgs 0,dV, ds we obtain a relationship between the model conductance and model transconductance given in (30). A mathematically equivalent statement (derived using Stokes's Theorem) is given by (31). The indicated contour is any closed loop on the surface defining the model current Jds.
w*wv
5K„,
dV„
< j k Wv. V* )dVgs + gds (Vgs, Vds )dVds ]= 0
(30)
(31)
A key consequence of (30) and (31) is that the model conductance gaJi,Vgs, Vds) and the model transconductance gm(Vg$, Krfs) are not independent functions of bias! Extraction of model gm and gds separately versus bias, which is standard practice in linear analysis, can result in a path-dependent model Ids. That is, the right hand side of (31) may be different from zero. A nonzero result for the right hand side of (31) represents the net (positive or negative) current supplied by the VCCS to the circuit after its controlling voltages are allowed to vary and then return to their original values. This is not a problem in small-signal analysis, where the bias point remains fixed, but it is extremely dangerous in large-signal analysis. Disaster can result in large-signal simulations even if the right hand side of (31) is only slightly different from zero. Under the conditions of large signal periodic input waveforms, the FET model controlling voltages can traverse closed loops in voltage space at the rate of billions of times a second (at microwave frequencies). The error (excess current) generated with each loop traversal accumulates, ultimately becoming large enough to cause the simulation to crash, or else cause a spurious result, such as a runaway voltage on a capacitor plate elsewhere in the circuit. The two properties of path independence and time (frequency) independence of current modeled by VCCS element are hallmarks of a network variable. Exactly the same considerations apply to the network variable charge as applied to the network variable current. The model charge Qgs of the VCQS nonlinear element of Fig. 8 is
92
MOSFET Modeling and Parameter Extraction for RF IC's 979 plotted versus the two controlling bias voltages Vgs and Vj, in Fig. 10. Qgs describes a twodimensional surface. The slope of this surface in the direction parallel to the Vgs axis defines the model capacitance Cgs(Vgs, Vds). The slope of the Qgs surface in the direction parallel to the V& axis defines the model transcapacitance Cm(Vgs, Vds). This is precisely the quantity we met in (27).
Fig. 10. Model charge Q^ vs. two controlling bias voltages VJS and V&. The statement of path independence of the model charge is given in (32). An equivalent statement is given by (33). Mathematically, (32) and (33) show that Cgs(Vgs, Vds) and Cm(Vgs, Vds) are components of a conservative vector field. #
h* (Vs. • V * )dVss + Cm (Vgs, Vds )dVds ] = 0 8Ces
dC„
(32) (33)
dV„ dV„ ds "• gs Again the important point is that the model capacitance and model transcapacitance are not independent functions of bias! Specifying the model capacitances and transcapacitances separately versus bias can result in a path-dependent model Qgs. That is, the right hand side of (32) may be different from zero. Such a situation can result in the same fatal errors as described for the VCCS case. The transient (large-signal) analysis simulations don't fit the ^-parameters versus bias data well. On the other hand, good fits to the measurements can be obtained by using a simple AC (small-signal) model. However, the poor fit to the data in the transient analysis (TA) mode means the TA and AC simulations are inconsistent. Such inconsistencies mean AC simulations over a wide range of bias, no matter how accurate, cannot be used to reliably extrapolate the true large signal model performance. The solution to this problem is to start directly from three-terminal VCQS elements such as Qgs(Vg$, Vds) and QgdiVg,, Vds). Despite the innocent appearance of capacitor symbols in the equivalent circuit of the FET model, the intrinsic capacitors are not two-terminal capacitors. A two-terminal capacitor has a capacitance (and also a charge) that depends only on the single
93
980
M. Je, I. Kwon, H. Shin & K. Lee
voltage difference between the terminals. However, the intrinsic capacitors and charges in
FET's depend on two voltage differences. The consistency between TA and AC modes can now be guaranteed by taking the AC admittance matrix to be given by the linearized TA equations. G
o
G O
9ds -JvW-
9ds SO-
•©•
-OD
9m
(b)
(a)
Fig. 11. Time delay implementation in linear analysis: (a) using a frequency dependent element (b) using a transcapacitance.
The second problem is that large-signal FET models do not simulate time delays of the FET. In linear analysis, time delays are typically introduced via the multiplicative frequency dependent factor gme~J°". In a linear FET model, this factor often appears with the transconductance element at the output. The key point is that in linear analysis only, quantities such as conductances and transconductances can be assigned arbitrary frequency dependences. The objective is to try to represent time delays, at least approximately, using the nonlinear elements. We can start from the standard expression gme'i
~ Sm COSCOT - jgm sin cor
= gm + JeoCT w h e r e Q =-gmT. (34) Under these conditions, we may redraw the linear equivalent circuit of Fig 11(a) as shown in Fig. 11(b). The transcapacitance is the coefficient of proportionality between the out-of-phase current in the drain-source branch and the applied gate-source voltages. The value of the transcapacitance Cr is just -g„ r. This expression is independent of frequency, but it does depend on bias. However, the situation illustrated in Fig. 11(b) is not acceptable for nonlinear analysis as it now stands. The existence of a bias dependent transcapacitance without a corresponding parallel capacitance will generally violate the path independence of the network variable charge. The solution of the problem is again obtained by using a VCQS element in the drain-source branch. This is shown in Fig. 12. The functional form of the charge associated with the
94
MOSFET
Modeling and Parameter
Extraction for RF IC's
981
nonlinear VCQS element can be obtained, starting from the transcapacitance C£Vgs, V^), by solving an "exact" ordinary differential equation. Then, the transcapacitance associated with a VCQS element between the source and the drain provides a reactive output current proportional to the time derivative of the gate voltage. This current approximates the effect of the delay. G 0
delay
Fig. 12. Time delay implementation using VCQS for large-signal analysis.
Figure 13 show the large-signal equivalent circuit used for physical or empirical FET models." As Root and Hughes stressed, the circuit includes nonlinear VCQS elements to guarantee charge conservation, give a good fit to the measured /-parameters, and properly model the effects of time delay. The VCCS elements and VCQS elements represent the active operation of the intrinsic device and the extrinsic series parasitics are accounted for using linear resistances and inductances. This equivalent circuit can be used with physical equations or empirical equations describing the nonlinear active element values.
So—r*"rv-vw-
A/W-' v,r *—OD
Fig. 13. Large-signal equivalent circuit for physical and empirical FET models.77
We believe that there is no question that RF MOSFET modeling should be based on the
95
982
M. Je, I. Kwon, H. Shin & K.
lee
large signal model as shown in Fig. 13. As discussed earlier, current MOSFET models such as BSIM3v363 is basically large signal one. Therefore, we do not have to worry about conservation laws shown in (30) and (33), as far as circuit simulation is concerned. However, these conditions, i.e., the concept of transcapacitance, should still be carefully considered in parameter extraction. This is the focus of this section and will be extensively discussed in 3.3. 3.2. Parameter extraction using conventional three-terminal RF MOSFET models without intrinsic body terminal
Intrinsic device •VW>-
t=kft»e*"v©
9d,
-OD
-rc'
r is
Fig. 14. Conventional small-signal equivalent circuit m o d e l for a silicon MOSFET. 78
Figure 14 shows one of the most popular MOSFET equivalent circuit used to extract smallsignal parameters of a RF MOSFET.'8 It is very similar to the schematic for III-V FET's shown in Fig. 4. The distributed channel resistance /?, was omitted and the MOSFET was regarded as a simple three-terminal device. As previously mentioned, the cold-FET method with forwardbiased gate has been widely used to extract the series extrinsic elements for III-V FET's. However, this cold-FET method cannot be applicable to silicon MOSFET's, because the gate is DC-isolated from the remainder of the device. As a modified approach for silicon MOSFET's, Lovelace, Costa, and Camilleri extracted the parasitic resistances from 5-parameters at Vgs = Vds = 0 V.n This bias condition causes the contribution of the transconductance gm and the output conductance gds to become zero. Conversion of the measured zero-bias 5-parameters into real components of an equivalent Z-parameter network yields the parasitic resistance values as follow: MZu) = Rg+Rs (35) Re(Z12) = Re(Z21) = * s (36) Re(Z22 ) = Rd+Rs. (37) With knowledge of the parasitic resistance parameters, the intrinsic Z-parameters can be
96
MOSFET Modeling and Parameter Extraction for RF IC's
983
obtained by subtracting the series resistances from the measured Z-parameters and then, converted to the intrinsic y-parameters. The intrinsic model elements can be extracted directly using a procedure very similar to that suggested in Ref. 71. Parameters for the intrinsic smallsignal model as a function of the intrinsic y-parameters are shown below: Im(y,2) (38) d -• c
g
Cgs
CO
_lm(Yu) + lm(Yn) CO
_lm(y 22 ) + Im(y,2)
(39) (40)
CO
gds=Re(Y22) 8,
= |V tan"
T = -
(41) (42)
im(y 2 ,-y l2 ) Re(y 2l -y 12 )
(43)
Based on this parameter extraction approach, Biber, et al. constructed a nonlinear largesignal model for RF MOSFET's.7' They proposed new equations for the nonlinear capacitances. To simplify the implementation, the DC drain current equation of the EKV model was used while accuracy for RF simulation was achieved by adding new capacitance equations with the model program code. The combination of the DC and RF parts of the model predicts the nonlinear high-frequency performance over a wide range of the operating bias points.
Fig. 15. Small-signal equivalent circuit used for the extraction of the linear intrinsic elements."
Small-signal on-wafer 5-parameters are measured for a MOSFET at various bias points. The extrinsic elements from probing pads are de-embedded using the three-step method.74 The small-sipal elements including intrinsic ones are determined by direct extraction from this de-
97
984 M. Je, I. Kwon, H. Shin & K. Lee
embedded data.'8 The small-signal equivalent circuit used is shown in Fig. 15. The output conductance is modeled in two parts: \/Rds and the \IZdsoul. The MRds models the low-frequency output conductance while the high-frequency output impedance is dominated by CdsU C^, and R
98
MOSFET
Modeling and Parameter
Extraction for RF IC's
985
expressed as -j<°Tokt
gm*
y*
(46)
\+j(OT0k2
As pointed out above in this section,7"-7'^ and R/Rdg used for considering time delay effects are useful only for small-signal analysis. Intrinsic device C
R
9d
60— rrrt —VW-
dg
-\\—-VW^
•vw—f*^—OD
v
m\^
-1- c,,
•©
Fig. 16. Small-signal equivalent circuit.80
The drain and source series resistances are determined from the extrapolation of equivalent channel resistance to zero channel length using an array of devices with varying channel lengths, whereas the gate series resistance is calculated from the polysilicon sheet resistance. The series inductances are determined by fitting the imaginary parts of Zit, Zn, and Z^x. The Cds is measured on a dummy device structure using only contact pads and is de-embedded from the measured data. After de-embedding the extrinsic elements, the intrinsic ^-parameters can be written as follow:
^_/g£L_
*ii ="
g
\+jcoCgiRi
r>2=-
^21 =
'22
J(0cdg \ + jwCdgRdg
(47) (48)
\ + jaCgdRdg 8n 1 + jaCglRi
-JO>TJ<-\
J
1 + j(0Tok2
(49)
1 + jwCd dg R,dg
\+a>2Cd2Rsub(Rsub+Rds)+ja)CdRds Rds+a)2c/R sub *Vs
99
,
jccCgd \ + jwCgdrdg
(50)
986
M. Je, I. Kwon, H. Shin & K. Lee
Note that Cdg was distinguished from Cgd according to the difference in signal excitation. Cgd * Cdg because the intrinsic capacitances in the active device are not reciprocal. The use of nonreciprocal capacitances is theoretically equivalent to the use of transcapacitances (i.e., Cm = Cdg - Cgd)-W Although the equivalent circuit in Fig. 16 doesn't seem to implement a complete set of capacitances, the charge conservation can be guaranteed by using non-reciprocal capacitances in linear equations when the resulting small-signal model is used to build a large-signal model. However, the above equations are too complex to be useful for direct extraction of parameters, and thus a curve fitting approach was used."0 In practice, the simulated output characteristics using this model show fairly good agreement with the measured ones. However, there is no intrinsic body node in Fig. 16. In the source-body tied MOSFET, the node that is tied with the source is not the intrinsic body, but the extrinsic body. Thus, even for the source-body tied configuration, the circuit elements associated with the body, such as body small signal transconductance gmb and gate-body intrinsic capacitance Cgby do not really disappear. Strictly speaking, without these elements and the intrinsic body node, various substrate-related signal coupling that becomes more important at higher frequencies (> 10 GHz) cannot be explained.'-'2 On the other hand, without the intrinsic body node, the substrate parasitics cannot be modeled physically. The Rsub connected in series with the drain junction capacitance in Fig. 16 may be just enough to fit the measured K22 or S22 up to about 10 GHz, but its location in the equivalent circuit is not physically correct.81-82 As a result, it is difficult to make the value of Rsub in this model be scalable and predictable from the technology parameters. Above all, all the models examined in this section are three-terminal models, and thus their application is limited to a specific circuit configuration. 3.3. KAIST three-terminal model with simple and accurate parameter extraction technique
Drain
6 Source Fig. 17. Small-signal equivalent circuit of a three-terminal MOSFET model without an intrinsic body node.
We have proposed a simple and accurate parameter extraction method for a small-signal MOSFET model including the substrate-related parameters and a complete set of non-reciprocal capacitors.83 This work focuses on a charge-conserving and physical small signal equivalent
100
MOSFET Modeling and Parameter Extraction for RF IC's
987
circuit of the RF MOSFET and an accurate parameter extraction approach by K-parameter analysis from measured S-parameters. The small signal equivalent circuit of a three-terminal MOSFET model is shown in Fig. 17. Non-reciprocal capacitance and substrate-related parameters are included in the model. In a three-terminal configuration, the source-to-body junction capacitance Cjs and the source-tobody spreading resistance Rsubs can be excluded if the intrinsic body node is assumed to be short-circuited to the source directly. This approximation makes a simple direct extraction of all the elements possible. However, Cjd and Rsubd extracted with this assumption do not provide physically correct values, although they provide excellent fit of Y-n up to 10 GHz, as pointed out in 3.2.80 Four intrinsic capacitances, Cgs, Cgd, Cdg and Csd, are required for the three-terminal model. The overlap capacitances are merged with the correspondent intrinsic capacitances. Cgd and Cdg are the two non-reciprocal capacitance components for the three-terminal model.57*0 The capacitive effect of the drain voltage on the gate charge is represented by Cgd, and the capacitive effect of the gate voltage on the drain charge is represented by Cdg. In general, Cdg is different from Cgd. C„ = Cdg - Cgd is a transcapacitance representing the different effect of the gate and the drain on each other in terms of charging currents, just as gm is a transconductance representing the different effect of these two terminals on each other in terms of transport currents. If Cgd and Cdg are set to be equal, as in most conventional models, large error can be introduced since charge conservation does not hold. In the AC simulation, the transcapacitance has to be included for accurate prediction of the transadmittances v 2 i and Yn. Without the nonreciprocal gate-drain capacitance, it is impossible to model I m ^ i ) and I m ^ u ) accurately at the same time. In the case of a four-terminal model with a separate substrate terminal, a similar approach can be extended by including other non-reciprocal capacitances. The resistance Rg represents the effective gate resistance that consists of the distributed channel resistance and the gate electrode resistance." These effects are approximated by a single effective lumped gate resistance, as shown in the equivalent circuit of the MOSFET shown in Fig. 17. Direct extraction using a linear regression approach is performed by K-parameter analysis on the equivalent circuit of the MOSFET for high frequency operation. In our approach, an optimization process, which may have uncertainties in obtaining physical parameters, is not required. The small-signal equivalent circuit shown in Fig. 17 can be analyzed in terms of Yparameters as follow: ja>(Cgs + Cgd) a>2 (Cgs + Cgd )2 Rg + ja>(Cgs + Cgd) "
\+
\+MCgs+Cgd)Rg
_ - a>2Cgd (Cgs + Cgd )Rg - jwCgd
- jwCgd
y 12
Yix
\+a>2{Cgs+Cgd)2Rg2
\+jco{Cgs+Cgd)Rg 1 + MCgs 2
+ Cgd )Rg
8 m -°> Cdg(Cgs
1 + ja(Cgs
+Cgd)Rg l+
+ Cgd )Rg -jccCdg-jcogmRg{Cgs+Cgd)
2
a, (Cgs+Cgd?Rg2
101
988
M. Je, I. Kwon, H. Shin & K. Lee
y22 -_gds
2
*** \+jojCjdRsubd
+
+j(oCsd
**» \ + jcoCjdRsubd
= gdj +
**
, <°2cjd2Rsubd 8ds
+j(oCsd
+gd
+jwCgd
+jaCgd gd + "'
.2/"
D
2
* C **«+**•<**« \ + joj{Cgs+Cgd)Rg
\+co2{Cgs+Cgd)2Rg2 . J<»gmRgCgd -ja>3CgdCdg(Cgs
_, • s* ^ • ^ 2
C
, ^ 2 c g d c d g R g + o>2gmR2gcgd (cgs + c g d )
\+OJ2CJd2Rsubd2 J^Jd
CMCgd+Cm) + jagmCgdRg l+jo>(Cgs+Cgd)Rg
s
"
«
a
u^.,^r
j.r
+Cgd)R2g
2
\ i
(54) For operation frequency up to 10 GHz, by using the assumption that a2 (Cgs + Cgd)2 Rg2 « 1, the K-parameters can be approximated as follows: y,, * w2 (Cgs +Cgd)2Rg+ jo>(Cgs + Cgd)
(55)
2
Yl2 * -w Cgd(Cgs + Cgd)Rg - jcoCgd
(56)
»2i * 8m ~0}2Cdg{Cgs +Cgd)Rg -jwCdg -jojgmRg(Cgs+Cgd)
(57)
2 >-22 * * * +,°)C2*2S:bd 1^ CgdCdgRg \+a> Cjd Rsuhd JWCjd
i ,
l + O) 2C^Jd 2 DRsubd2
+
a>2gmR2gCgd(Cgs +Cgd)
+ jaCsd + jcoCgd + jcogmRgCgd - ja>>CgdCdg(Cgs + Cgd)R2g.
(58) The validity of the assumption that a} (Cgs + Cgd)2 Rg2 « 1 will be checked after each parameter is extracted. All the components of the equivalent circuit are extracted by the Yparameter analysis and analytical equations are derived from real and imaginary parts of the Yparameters. gm is obtained from the ^-intercept of Re(K21) versus of and gds is extracted from the ^-intercept of Re(y22) versus of, at the low frequency range. Rg, Cgd, Cgs and Cdg can be obtained by (61H74).
< 59 >
gm=Re(r2.)Uo /? g =Re(y n )/(Im(K n )) 2
(61)
Cgd=-\miXxl)loj
(62)
Cgs=(lm(Yn)
(63)
+ lm(Yn))/co
Cdg =-lm(Y2l)/o>-gmRg(Cgs+Cgd)
(64)
For the extraction of substrate components Rsuhd and Cjd, Ysub is first defined as follows: ysub = hi ~gds ~
102
+Cgd)
MOSFET Modeling and Parameter Extraction for RF IC's
-jaC*
-ja>Cgd
+ ja>3CgdCdg(Cgs
-jagmRgCgd
°>1Cid2Rsubd _ + _ \ + a>2Cjd2Rsubd2
989
+Cgd)R2g
JaCjd
(65)
\+m2CjdlRsubd
Kubd »s obtained from the slope of the relationship for a2/Re(Ysub) vs. a? by (66). CO R*dU)
• = co2Rsubd +
(66)
2D
Cjd is obtained from the following. 03
Cjd
-1/2
R
subd
-o>2Rsubd2
[Mrsub)
Finally, Csrf is obtained from (58) as as C _ im(y22) c-yrf , r 'grf 2
1.4-
r
-s-V*
s
0.6 J
^V*^
+c
**)**
(68)
W/L = 100 / 0.35 1V,V„ =2V
Sl rn
(67)
°Pe
: R
X
.u.»d=191n
1
»
1 —
103
990
M. Je, I. Kwon, H. Shin & K. Lee
intercept of Re(y22) versus or, at the low frequency range. a?/Re(Ysub) is linearly proportional to of and Rsubd of 191 i2 was determined from the slope, as shown in Fig. 18. 70
W/L= 100/0.35 . V = 1V,V » 2 V
140
60
120
50
100 o o c 8 5
40„
80
a
60
&
40
O
20
30 —
a? 20
0
a n - i c o o o ^
4
6
8
10
'
10 12
Frequency [GHz]
Fig. 19. Frequency dependence of the extracted parameters for an n-MOSFET having 100 fan width and biased to Vg, = 1 V and Vis -2V. In Fig. 19, the frequency dependence of extracted parameters such as Rg, Cgd, Cgs, Cdg> CJd and Cjrf at Vgs = 1 Kand Vds =2 Fare shown. The results show that the extracted parameters remain almost constant with frequency. This verifies that those components are frequencyindependent and the proposed extraction method is accurate and reliable. Due to the nonreciprocity, Qg is larger than Cgd as it should be. For the extracted parameter values, o? (Cgs + Cgd)2 Rg2 is calculated to be 0.055 even at 10 GHz, which is much smaller than one. This verifies the validity of using the assumption in simplifying (51)—(54) to (55H58). 0.0-
ImfY,,]
^A „ A 0
n_a_i"
o
" • * - « - « * _
•0.5 •
R
"
Y
J
"
^ ^ ^ ^ ^ o ^ ^
^>
-1.0-
E > •
-2.5-
-
V
-1.5-
^^ - 2 . 0 -
"
o
Maasurod Propoaad Modal lm Y
I J
W / L - 100/0.35 V • 1 V, V, • 2 V
. •
-3.0-
0
2
4
6
8
2
10
4
6
t
Frequency [GHz]
Frequency [GHz]
(b)
(a)
104
10
MOSFET
Modeling and Parameter
1
T
" " " n 1 ~ |J y ^ o
1
o o o o
Manured Proposed Modal
1
1
1
I
1
r'-'
Measured Proposed Model
•
0
Extraction for RF IC's
W / L * 100/0.35 V = 1 V, V„ = 2 V
991
—i— • j
'"[YJp^
^
OT
E
»
/
Re[YJ
""[*„]
2
4
6
8
10
2
Frequency [GHz]
4
6
8
Frequency [GHz] (d)
(c)
Fig. 20. The measured(symbol) and modeled(line) results of Y-parameters for the n-MOSFET biased to Vg,= 1 Vand VV• 2 V: (a) Yn, (b) YI2/ (c) Yn, (d) Y22. The frequency range is from 0.5 GHz to 10.5 GHz.
In Fig. 20, the calculated results for y-parameters obtained by using the equivalent circuit shown in Fig. 17 with extracted values are compared with the measured data for Vgs = 1 V and Vds = 2 V. It shows that the simulation result matched well with the measurement without any optimization after parameter extraction. The non-reciprocal capacitances Cgd and Cdg contribute to match the imaginary parts of YX2 and Y2\. Excluding transcapacitance could result in a significant error on the imaginary part of Y:, at high frequencies. The substrate coupling significantly contributes to the real part of the output admittance Y22 at high frequency. The total error" between measured and simulated /-parameters of the proposed model is only 0.4 %. 160 v
120
g
100
3
80
2. 40
3
_
__
-.
0
• -
„ - »
.
^ ° —0-****
c
V
'
*
:
.c-
;
:
^X .
^
—-a-^*"
0—D
20 1
1.5
r——
•—•
c_ I — —t
2.0
<W
"
10'-
•—
.
*"
2V
•-•
——0—
^
••
W/L-100/0.35 c
••—
* ** --O
2 «H o .
r
'
W / L * 1 0 0 / 0.35
140
10'-
1
—
1
1
• —
'
1
1.5
2.5
—«— 1
1
2.0
V„[V]
V„[V]
(a)
(b)
•
R
—. • 1
'
2.5
1
1
3.5
Fig. 21. The gate-bias dependence of small signal parameters for an n-MOSFET having 100 ftm width and biased to ]/&= 2 V: (a) capacitances, (b) R8 and Ru,u-
In Fig. 21, gate bias dependence of the extracted small-signal parameters for the nMOSFET biased to Vds = 2 V is shown. The gate bias dependence of extracted capacitances is
105
992
M. Je, I. Kwon, H. Shin & K, Lee
shown in Fig. 21(a). Cgs and Cgd are composed of the intrinsic components Cgsi and Cgdi and the overlap components Cgso and Cgd0. In the saturation region, the intrinsic capacitances Cgdi and Csd are almost zero because the drain voltage does not influence the device charges. The total gate-to-drain capacitance Cgd is dominated by the overlap capacitance Cgdo. As the gate bias increases for constant Vds, Cgd and Cdg increase due to increase of the intrinsic capacitance. Cgs and Cm increase with Vgs near the threshold voltage at the onset of the strong inversion region and are almost constant in the strong inversion saturation region. The extracted Rg and Rsubd with gate bias are shown in Fig. 21(b) and they are almost constant with gate bias in the strong inversion region. i
r
r
.
140- W / L - 1 0 0 i 0.35 V » 2 V^ ^ 120- t» 100 £
•c
~"~-~^
80 <^-—°^
~—-o
—O
•—a
—B
~ ~
3 60e § n
8
> « ;
4020-
° /
^
•40— '
1
r
c
* ,
•
m
;
DC
*
.^-
-20-
0.0
D
o
—c
*
c
W/L -100/0.35 V = 2V
•• .
•
T—
n
,
2.0
m
-
^.
R
>-.—
«i
101-
1.S
-.
102-
A,..
subd fl
-»
—I
'
1
1.0
2.5
(a)
—•
—•
B-
r~
(
•—
a
r-
1.5
2.0
(b)
Fig. 22. The drain-bias dependence of small signal parameters for an n-MOSFET having 100 fan width and biased to Vjs= 2 V: (a) capacitances, (b) Rs and /?»«. In Fig. 22, drain-bias dependence of the extracted small-signal parameters for the nMOSFET biased to Vgs= 2V\s shown. The drain-bias dependence of the extracted capacitances are shown in Fig. 22(a). The vertical line at Vds = 0.81 Kis the boundary between the linear and saturation regions. When the transistor is biased in the linear region with low Vds, the intrinsic behavior of the transistor becomes symmetric in terms of drain and source. Thus the intrinsic capacitances Cgsi and Cgdi are almost the same at V^ = 0 V. In Fig. 22(a), the difference between Cgs and Cgd at Vds = 0 Vis due to the parasitic Cgb which is included in the Cgs. Cgb of the gate contact pad component and the poly-to-well capacitance in the field oxide become the major parts of the parasitic capacitance. At V& = 0 V, Cdg is the same as Cgd and Cm = 0. Cm increases with J ^ in the linear region and is almost constant for high Vds in the saturation region. Csd becomes negative in the linear region because the raising the drain voltage will increase the effective reverse bias at the drain end and will cause the magnitude of the inversion layer charges to decrease. In the saturation region for higher Vds, the gate-to-drain capacitance Cgd is almost the same as Cgdo. The extracted capacitance parameters correctly model the bias dependence of intrinsic capacitance. Because the conventional C-V measurements using large C-V test structure are less sensitive to extraction of small capacitance values in short-channel
106
MOSFET
Modeling and Parameter
Extraction for RF IC's
993
RF MOSFET's, measuring S-parameters of the RF MOSFET in the high frequency GHz range is a better alternative. The proposed parameter extraction method can be applied to accurate intrinsic capacitance modeling at GHz operation. The extracted Rg and RsuM with drain bias are shown in Fig. 22(b) and they are almost constant with drain bias.
20 -
W / L * 100/0.35 V*-2V ———_
W/Ls 100/0.35 V. - 2 V • On,
/
(0
•
-
Extraction rwult DC inm urwmnt
Extraction raault DC measurement
E _? 20
/ 8*. \
i . .a <* —t
—.
*—' 1 2
*•" '
i
•>
(a) Fig. 23. gm and g& extracted from the S-parameter measurement and those obtained from DC measurement: (a) varying the gate bias for Vis = 2V, (b) varying the drain bias for Vg, = 2 V.
In Fig. 23, gm and gds extracted from the S-parameter measurement and those obtained from DC measurement are compared. Extracted gm and gds as a function of Vgs with gate bias for Vds -2 V are shown in Fig. 23(a), and extracted gm and g* as a function of Vj, with drain bias for Vgs = 2 V are shown in Fig. 23(b). They match very well with each other, verifying the validity of the equivalent circuit and the extraction method. The extraction results correctly modeled the bias dependence of gm and && in the linear and saturation regions. Figure 23 shows that RF conductance data agree well with those from derivatives of measured DC I-V characteristics. This has very important implications, that a large-signal model for I-V characteristics is accurate enough to be used for DC, low-frequency analog, as well as RF circuit simulations. 4. Four-Terminal RF MOSFET Modeling and Parameter Extraction We have examined several trials to model the RF MOSFET as a three-terminal device. As mentioned previously, the three-terminal models are only valid for devices with source-body tied configuration and the complex signal coupling through the intrinsic body node cannot be described. To overcome these important limitations, four-terminal modeling of the RF MOSFET is required as essentially it is a four-terminal device. In this chapter, four-terminal modeling examples will be reviewed.
107
994
M. Je, I. Kwon, H. Shin & K. Lee
4.1. Equivalent-circuit-based
modeling approaches
1
OB
Fig. 24. Complete small-signal model for a four-terminal intrinsic MOSFET proposed by Bagheri and Tsividis.37
In Ref. 37, Bagheri and Tsividis presented a four-terminal physical model of a MOSFET with the equivalent circuit shown in Fig. 24. It includes a "transmission-line effect" which is another name for the non-quasi-static effect, and its parameters are given by functions of terminal voltages, process parameters, and device geometry. The parameters vary continuously in value with bias from strong, through moderate to weak inversion. The equations were derived for the long-channel device using a charge-sheet approximation. Two differential equations the current transport and charge continuity equations -with appropriate boundary conditions were solved using iterative methods for obtaining the small-signal terminal currents. In general, each terminal current has the form of a power series numerator over a common denominator series. From this result, the small-signal /-parameters can be calculated using the definition Y
»P =
L
(69)
v
fr
K=O,y*0
where the subscripts a, fl, and y can stand for drain (d), gate (g), and substrate (b). The Yparameters that were evaluated and truncated to second order in Ref. 37 are shown below. 1 + jcoa{ Y (70) gs = -J®0* D(ja>) 1 + jcoa2 Y (71) gd = -JvCgd D(jco) 1 + j coai (72) hs = -JoCbs D{ja>) 1 + jcoa2 Y 0 (73)
M = -J*" ,bd'
108
MOSFET Modeling and Parameter Extraction for RF IC's
-JoC.«*"
igb
*m
Sti
(74) D(jo>)
\-jcoa4-U<») D(jco)
as
(75)
\-jcM6-U'a>)2a7 'mb
&mb
995
(76)
D(Ja) 1
(77)
Ysd = Sd
(78)
^ = 0 1
D(jco) = 1 + jabx + (ja)
b2
(79)
The quantities ah i = 1,2, •••, 7 and b},j = 1, 2 are calculated from terminal voltages, process parameters, and device geometry. As one can see from the detailed description of the quantities," the formulations are very complex. This complexity prohibits intuitive insight into the non-quasi-static effect and makes the model unattractive for CAD application. Note that this physical model is valid only for long-channel MOSFET's and appropriate parasitic elements should be added to be accurate in RF circuit simulations. D O ^gb
Go-
"jb
HI
HI
i/W-
i^i
Y v
>?
=F C ^
m © .
&bd
Cbd
-VvV
1|-
-OB
'mh^at
4=°. 6 S
Fig. 25. Second-order high frequency equivalent circuit for the intrinsic MOSFET proposed by Vandeloo and Sansen.s5 Figure 25 shows another four-terminal high frequency equivalent circuit for the intrinsic MOSFET. Starting from the solution of a set of differential equations, which describe the channel current, Vandeloo and Sansen proposed this model." This model is a special case of the general model obtained by Bagheri and Tsividis shown in Fig. 24. The resistances in series with the capacitances in Fig. 25 represent the inertia of the charge configuration, which produces
109
996
M. Je, I. Kwon, H. Shin & K. Lee
time delay for the charges to reach their steady-state values when the applied voltages vary. In Ref. 85, the circuit elements were extracted by fitting the measured /-parameters rather than calculated using physical equations. For extraction, the theoretical expressions of the sixteen /parameters - Ytj, i = 1, 2, 3, 4, j = 1, 2, 3, 4 - were derived from the equivalent circuit. The numbers in the subscripts refer to the terminals of the MOSFET: 1 denotes the gate, 2 the drain, 3 the bulk, and 4 the source. For example, Y\ \ is written as Y
=
Ja>(Cgsl + Cgs2) + (ja>)2 Cg5lCgs2Rgs2 1 + jo(RgslCgsi
+
+ RgsiCgs2 + Rgs2Cgs2) + (jco)2 Cgs]Cg52RgslRgs2
jccCgd jcoCgd + 1 + jeoRgdCgd 1 + jcoRgdCgd
m
Then, the S-parameter measurement was made to obtain the real /-parameters obtained through a conversion process. The transistor was connected to a two-port S-parameter test set and the transistor configuration was changed during the measurement to fully characterize the fourterminal characteristics in terms of sixteen S-parameters. In the first measurement, the gate was defined as port 1 and the drain as port 2. Four S-parameters were measured at a given DC bias point. Next, the measurement configuration was changed: the bulk was connected to port 1, while the source was connected to port 2. A second set of four S-parameters was measured at the same DC bias. The eight measured S-parameters were converted mathematically to Yparameters. The eight /-parameters, obtained as a function of the frequency, are thus: /,,, Yi2, Yiu Yii< /»» Zj4» ^43. Y**- The missing /-parameters were calculated. It is obvious from the network theorem that six independent linear relations exist between all the /-parameters. To find the eight missing parameters, two extra equations are thus needed. The first relation used is the measurement of the admittance parameter /42, which is equal to the output impedance. For the second relation, a special property of the MOSFET was used. Considering the model of Fig. 25, it is obvious that Y]} equals K31. This relationship was used as the last equation. The missing /-parameters were then calculated by using the relations: X ^/ = 0 • The final result of the measurement and calculation is thus a three-dimensional matrix of N by 4 by 4 elements {N is the number of frequency points). This three-dimensional matrix of measured data was fitted against the theoretical model. The fitting process is built up of two parts: (1) The measured data are fitted against a general transfer function with p poles and z zeros (p and z ranges from 1 to 3). (2) The poles and zeros from the theoretical expression are fitted against the poles and zeros extracted at step (1) by adjusting values of the equivalent circuit elements. Through this process the optimum set of parameter values was obtained, resulting in a very good match between the measured and modeled /-parameters. Although this work proposed a small-signal measurement process for the four-terminal MOSFET and a parameter extraction procedure using the measured data, the measurement requires much effort and the extraction procedure is too complicated due to the complicated theoretical /-parameter expressions of the four-terminal equivalent circuit. In addition, the model did not account for the effects of substrate coupling and thus some of the extracted parameter values are physically incorrect. If
110
MOSFET Modeling and Parameter Extraction for RF IC's
997
the substrate parasitics were also included in the equivalent circuit and their effects were properly considered, the formulations and extraction procedure would become even more complicated. 4.Z Macro-modeling approaches The complexity of high-frequency four-terminal MOSFET modeling, as examined in the previous section, led to the macro-modeling approach. This approach makes use of a commercially available MOSFET model core such as the BSIM3v3, MOS model 9, or the EKV model with lumped-element equivalent circuit extensions. The model core and lumpedelements compose a sub-circuit representing a RF MOSFET. Several works adopting the macro-modeling approach have been reported.10"'3 Most of them commonly use a gate resistance. The non-quasi-static effect and the distributed gate electrode resistance are modeled as this lumped gate resistance. This solution is attractive since this resistance also models the gateinduced thermal noise efficiently." Recent lumped-element extensions for RF have incorporated the effect of the substrate as an external network with the commercial model core. These network approaches are summarized in Fig. 26. Note that the models shown in Fig. 26 represent the intrinsic part of the MOSFET excluding extrinsic series elements in the source and the drain. The substrate models of Refs. 11 and 13 are similar with the exception of additional capacitance in parallel with substrateresistancesfor the model of Ref. 13. The substrate model of Ref. 10 is more complicated than those of Refs. 11 and 12 and requires a complex parameter extraction procedure. If Rsub2 = RSttbi = oo in the network of Fig. 26(a), then this model reduces to that of Fig. 26(b). In a similar way, if Rsubl = R,ubi = 0 in Fig. 26(a), the model of Ref. 12 reduces to that of Ref. II with the junction capacitances enclosed in the model core. One common feature in the models of Refs. 10 and 11 is the use of extrinsic capacitances to account for the drain-tobody/source-to-body junction capacitances. They did this because the body-side ends of the two junction capacitances implemented in the core are hard-wired. Note that the model of Ref. 11 does not allow coupling of the signals through the gmb and Cgb due to the absence of the intrinsic body node. This coupling is important for both Y12 and Y2\ at high frequencies.12 D
O
HI*»
G
o-
E "/•»
(a)
111
-^W—I
998
M. Je, I. Kwon, H. Shin & K. Lee D Q
€
-OB
HI—vw— 6 S (b) D Q
G.rtO
«W-
s -o-
i- t
->W——OB.
6 S (c)
Fig. 26. (a) Sub-circuit model of Ref. 10, (b) sub-circuit model of Ref. 11, (c) sub-circuit model of Ref. 12.
Usually, model parameters of the core in sub-circuit models are extracted with DC /-Kand low-frequency C-V measurement data using the same procedure used in commercial models. Then the extraction of the lumped-elements is executed using measured S-parameters at a given DC bias condition. The Rg has a great influence on the real part of Yu or the phase of Yu and the substrate network affects the real part of Y22 or the phase of Y22 most significantly. Thus the Rg is extracted from Re(yn) or P h a s e d ) and the substrate-related elements are determined from Re(y22) or Phase(v22) directly or using a curve fitting technique. When the used model core does not provide the bias-dependent overlap capacitances, external Cgs0 and Cgd0 can be added between the gate and source/drain terminals of the core to describe the bias dependence of the overlap capacitance, which is especially important in a short-channel LDD MOSFET."2 These external capacitances also allow one to correct for the inaccuracies of the intrinsic capacitances appearing for short-channel devices. The best values of the additional capacitances are found in fitting the modeled Im(v,i) and Im(y12) against the measured ones. Note that the
112
MOSFET
Modeling and Parameter
Extraction for RF IC's
999
accuracy of lm(Yl2) generated from the sub-circuit model mainly relies on the transcapacitance value modeled in the core and cannot be adjusted by just adding external passive components. The sub-circuit models that we have reviewed seem to be a successful compromise between accuracy and model complexity or computational efficiency. These models, accompanied by an appropriate parameter extraction process, show fairly good agreement with the measured smallsignal parameters. However, these sub-circuit models cannot overcome some limitations inherent in the MOSFET model used as a core. The accuracy of g„ and g^ predicted by commercial models has improved significantly, but is not yet sufficient, especially for RF circuit simulation where the higher order derivatives of the current should be smooth and correct. How accurately the commercial MOSFET models simulate the nonlinear characteristics of the RF circuits has not been verified. There also remain errors in predicting the intrinsic C-V characteristics of short-channel devices. These intrinsic problems cannot be cured using extrinsic sub-circuit extensions. Also, note that scalable physical modeling of the added extrinsic elements is required for the sub-circuit model to be scalable and predictive as a whole. 5. Conclusions We have examined a variety of examples of modeling and parameter extraction methods for RF MOSFET's after reviewing the basic concept and general strategies. Modeling and parameter extraction techniques popular in III-V FET modeling were reviewed and recent efforts to model the RF MOSFET and extract the model parameters were examined in light of the differences between the MOSFET and the III-V FET. We have found that the differences - the lossy silicon substrate and the four-terminal properties of a MOSFET - resulted in major difficulties of RF MOSFET modeling and parameter extraction. We have also discussed several works which attempt to successfully apply the established methodology for III-V FET's to MOSFET's with proper modifications, along with the shortcomings and limitations of this three-terminal modeling approach. A very simple and accurate parameter extraction method studied in our laboratory for three-terminal modeling considering charge conservation was also introduced. Our works have two important implications. One is that the consideration for charge conservation is important not only for accurate device modeling and circuit simulation but even more for proper parameter extraction. Another is that one accurate large-signal l-V model is enough to be used for DC, low-frequency analog, as well as RF circuit simulation. Fourterminal modeling based on new equivalent circuits to address the high-frequency effects arising in a MOSFET was found to be very complicated and not practical for CAD applications, even without considering the substrate coupling terms. As a temporary alternative, the macromodeling approach has been examined with various examples. There still remain many challenges in RF MOSFET modeling and parameter extraction, especially to satisfy the tough requirements in the coming future concerning applications at higher frequencies: The Q-V model accuracy for the short-channel device should be enhanced and more precise modeling of l-V, especially in the moderate inversion region is required. Furthermore, the model accuracy of the high-order derivatives of currents and charges should be improved because it is critical for correct nonlinear simulation of RF circuits as well as
113
1000
M. Je, I. Kwon, H. Shin & K. Lee
computational efficiency. More careful implementation of the non-quasi-static effect is also needed. Scalable and physical model development for the substrate network is necessary to keep the virtue of scalable and predictive nature of the MOSFET model at the RF range. There has been much effort to overcome these challenges. With a continuous effort, more successful modeling schemes and parameter extraction strategies will appear in the near future and they will greatly accelerate the growth of the RF CMOS market. As a final comment, it should be emphasized that the challenges mentioned cannot be solved only in terms of modeling itself. As the operation frequency increases, the parameter extraction technique becomes more important. Even with the same modeling scheme, significant improvements can be achieved by developing a better parameter extraction procedure or more accurate measurement techniques. Acknowledgements This work was supported by MICROS research center, Silvaco International, and the National Program for Tera-Level Nano-Devices through MOST. The authors also would like to appreciate useful comments by Prof. Tor Fjeldly at Norwegian Univ. of Science and Technology.
References 1. J. N. Burghartz, M. Hargrove, C. S. Webster, R. A. Groves, M. Keene, K. A. Jenkins, R. Logan, and E. Nowak, "RF potential of a 0.18-um CMOS logic device technology," IEEE Trans. Electron Devices, vol. 47, no. 4, Apr. 2000,864—870. 2. T. Manku, "Microwave CMOS - device physics and design," IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits, vol. 34, no. 3, Mar. 1999,277—285. 3. Q. Huang, F. Piazza, P. Orsatti, and T. Ohguro, "The impact of scaling down to deep submicron on CMOS RF circuits," IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits, vol. 33, no. 7, July 1998, 1023-1036. 4. B. Razavi, "CMOS technology characterization for analog and RF design," IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits, vol. 34, no. 3, Mar. 1999,268—276. 5. E. Morifuji, H. S. Momose, T. Ohguro, T. Yoshitomi, and H. Kimijima, "Future perspective and scaling down roadmap for RF CMOS," Symp. VLSI Technology, 1999,163-164. 6. T. Cho, E. Dukatz, M. Mack, D. MacNally, M. Marringa, S. Mehta, C. Nilson, L. Plouvier, and S. Rabii, "A single-chip CMOS direct-conversion transceiver for 900 MHz spread-spectrum digital cordless phones," Int. Solid-State Circuits Conf., 1999,228-229. 7. J. Rudell, J. Ou, T. Cho, G Chien, F. Brianti, J. Weldon, and P. Gray, "A 1.9 GHz wide-band IF double conversion CMOS integrated receiver for cordless telephone applications," Int. Solid-State Circuits Conf., 1997,304-305.
114
MOSFET Modeling and Parameter Extraction for RF IC's
1001
8. A. Rofougaran, J. Y-C. Chang, M. Rofougaran, and A. Abidi, "A 1 GHz CMOS RF front-end IC for a direct-conversion wireless receiver," IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits, vol. 31, July 1996,880-889. 9. M. B. Das, "High frequency network properties of MOS transistors including the substrate resistivity effects," IEEE Trans. Electron Devices, vol. ED-16, no. 12, Dec. 1969,1049-1069. 10. W. Liu, R. Gharpurey, M. C. Chang, U.Erdogan, R. Aggarwal, and J. P. Mattia, "R.F. MOSFET modeling accounting for distributed substrate and channel resistances with emphasis on the BSIM3v3 SPICE model," Int. Electron Devices Meeting, 1997,309-312. 11. J-J. Ou, X. Jin, I. Ma, C. Hu, and P. R. Gray, "CMOS RF modeling for GHz communication IC's," Int. Electron Devices Meeting, 1998,94-95. 12. S. F. Tin, A. A. Osman, K. Mayaram, and C. Hu, "A simple subcircuit extension of the BSIM3v3 model for CMOS RF design," IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits, vol. 35, no. 4, Apr. 2000,612-624. 13. D. R. Pehlke, M. Schroter, A. Burstein, M. Matloubian, and M. F. Chang, "High-frequency application of MOS compact models and their development for scalable RF model libraries," Custom Integrated Circuits Conf., 1998, 219-222. 14. B-K. Kim, B-K. Ko, K. Lee, J-W. Jeong, K-S. Lee, and S-C. Kim, "Monolithic planar RF inductor and waveguide structures on silicon with performance comparable to those in GaAs MMIC," Int. Electron Devices Meeting, 1995,717-720. 15. J. M. Lopez-Villegas, J. Samitier, C. Cane, P. Losantos, "Improvement of the quality factor of RF integrated inductors by layout optimization," IEEE Radio Frequency Integrated Circuits Symp., 1998, 169-172. 16. C. P. Yue and S. S. Wong, "On-chip spiral inductors with patterned ground shields for Si-based RF IC's," IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits, vol. 33, no. 5, May 1998, 743-752. 17. S. S. Mohan, M. Hershenson, S. P. Boyd, and T. H. Lee, "Simple accurate expressions for planar spiral inductances," IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits, vol. 34, no. 10, Oct. 1999,1419-1424. 18. C. P. Yue and S. S. Wong, "Physical modeling of spiral inductors on silicon," IEEE Trans. Electron Devices, vol. 47, no. 3, Mar. 2000,560-568. 19. R. D. Lutz, Y. Hahm, A. Weisshaar, V. K. Tripathi, A. Grzegorek, W. McFarland, and J. Meyer, "Modeling of spiral inductors on lossy silicon substrates for RFIC applications," IEEE Radio Frequency Integrated Circuits Symp., 1998,313-316. 20. D. C. Benson, Y. Xuan, J. He, C-M. Lin, C. R. Hodges, and E. A. Logan, "Integrated passive
115
1002 M. Je, I. Kwon, H. Shin & K. Lee components for RF applications," IEEE Wireless Communications Conf., 1997, 175-180. 21. A-S. Porret, T. Melly, C. C. Enz, and E. A. Vittoz, "Design of high-Q varactors for low-power wireless applications using a standard CMOS process," IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits, vol. 35, no. 3, Mar. 2000,337-345. 22. H. Hasegawa, M. Furukawa, and H. Yanai, "Properties of microstrip line on Si-Si02 system," IEEE Trans. Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol. MTT-19, no. 11, Nov. 1971, 869-881. 23. S. Zaage and E. Grotheluschen, "Characterization of the broadband transmission behavior of interconnections on silicon substrates," Int. Conf. Wafer Scale Integration, 1993,268—277. 24. J-S. Ko, B-K. Kim, and K. Lee, "Simple modeling of coplanar waveguide on thick dielectric over lossy substrate," IEEE Trans. Electron Devices, vol. 44, no. 5, May 1997, 856-861. 25. T. E. Kolding, "On-wafer calibration techniques for giga-hertz CMOS measurements," IEEE Int. Conf. Microelectronic Test Structures, vol. 12,1999,105-110. 26. L. P. Chen, Y. P. Ho, D. C. Lin, B. M. Tseng, H. Y. Lee, R. F. Guan, G W. Huang, Y. C. Chen, W Y. Wen, and C. L. Chen, "Extraction of parasitic parameters of dummy devices on different silicon substrates," IEEE Radio Frequency Integrated Circuits Symp., 1998,321-324. 27. T. E. Kolding, "Impact of test-fixture forward coupling on on-wafer silicon device measurements," IEEE Trans. Microwave and Guided Wave Lett., vol. 10, no. 2, Feb. 2000,73-74. 28. A. Samavedam, A. Sadate, K. Mayaram, and T. S. Fiez, "A scalable substrate noise coupling model for design of mixed-signal IC's," IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits, vol. 35, no. 6, June 2000,895-904. 29. R. Gharpurey and R. G Meyer, "Modeling and analysis of substrate coupling in integrated circuits," IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits, vol. 31, Mar. 1996,344-352. 30. J. P. Costa, M. Chou, and L. M. Silveira, "Efficient techniques for accurate modeling and simulation of substrate coupling in mixed-signal IC's," IEEE Trans. Computer-Aided Design, vol. 18, May 1999, 597607. 31. L. Forbes, B. Ficq, and S. Savage, "Resonant forward-biased guard-ring diodes for suppression of substrate noise in mixed-mode CMOS circuits," Electronics Lett. vol. 31, no. 9, Apr. 1995, 720-721. 32. G Gonzalez, Microwave Transistor Amplifiers - Analysis and Design, 2nd ed., New Jersey: Prentice Hall, 1997. 33. Understanding the Fundamental Principles of Vector Network Analysis, Hewlett-Packard Application
116
MOSFET Modeling and Parameter Extraction for RF IC's
1003
Note 1287-1. 34. D. E. Root, "Measurement-based active device modeling for circuit modeling for circuit simulation," Advanced Microwave Devices, Characterization and Modeling Workshop, 1993. 35. D. E. Root and S. Fan, "Experimental evaluation of large-signal modeling assumptions based on vector analysis of bias-dependent S-parameter data from MESFETs and HEMTs," IEEE Microwave Theory and Techniques Symp., 1992,255-258. 36. D. E. Root, S. Fan, and J. Meyer, "Technology independent large-signal nonquasi-static FET models by direct construction from automatically characterized device data," European Microwave Conf., 1991, 927-932. 37. M. Bagheri and Y. Tsividis, "A small signal dc-to-high-frequency nonquasistatic model for the fourterminal MOSFET valid in all regions of operation," IEEE Trans. Electron Devices, vol. ED-32, no. 11, Nov. 1985,2383-2391. 38. W. K. Lee, M. Chan, and P. K. Ko, "A physical approach to enhance BSIM3 NQS model for fast transient simulation," IEEE Hong Kong Electron Devices Meeting, 1999, 114-117. 39. W. Liu, C. Bowen, and M-C. Chang, "A CAD-compatible non-quasi-static MOSFET model," Int. Electron Devices Meeting, 1996, 151 — 154. 40. S. Bosch and L. Martens, "Investigation of the frequency dispersion effect in the Root-model applied to conventional and floating-gate MESFET's," IEEE Trans. Electron Devices, vol. 44, no. 12, Dec. 1997, 2311-2313. 41. N. Scheinberg, R. Bayruns, and R. Goyal, "A low-frequency GaAs MESFET circuit model," IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits, vol. 23, no. 2, Apr. 1988. 42. P. Yang and P. Chatterjee, "An optimal parameter extraction program for MOSFET models," IEEE Trans. Electron Devices, vol. ED-30, Sep. 1983,1214-1219. 43. T. Sakurai, B. Lin, and A. R. Newton, "Fast simulated diffusion: an optimization algorithm for multiminimum problems and its application to MOSFET model parameter extraction," IEEE Trans. Computer-Aided Design, vol. 11, no. 2, Feb. 1992,228-234. 44. Y H. Hu and S. W. Pan, "SaPOSM: an optimization method applied to parameter extraction of MOSFET models," IEEE Trans. Computer-Aided Design, vol. 12, no. 10, Oct. 1993,1481-1487. 45. C. van Niekerk and P. Meyer, "A new approach for the extraction of an FET equivalent circuit from measured S-parameters," Microwave and Optical Technology Lett., vol. 11, no. 5, Apr. 1996,281 —284.
117
1004 M. Je, I. Kwon, H. Shin & K. Lee 46. H. Kondoh, "An accurate FET modeling from measured S-parameters," IEEE Microwave Theory and Technique Symp., 1986,377-380. 47. J. W. Bandler, S. H. Chen, S. Ye, and Q-J. Zhang, "Integrated model parameter extraction using largescale optimization concepts," IEEE Trans. Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol. 36, no. 12, Dec. 1988, 1626--1638. 48. H. P. Tuinhout, S. Swaving, J. J. M. Joosten, "A fully analytical MOSFET model parameter extraction approach," IEEE Int. Conf. Microelectronic Test Structures, vol. 1, no. 1, 1988, 79-84. 49. P. R. Karlsson and K. O. Jeppson, "A direct extraction algorithm for a submicron MOS transistor mode," IEEE Int. Conf. Microelectronic Test Structures, vol. 6, 1993, 157-162. 50. S. Minehane, S. Healy, P. O'Sillivan, K. McCarthy, A. Mathewson, and B. Mason, "Direct BSIM3v3 parameter extraction for hot-carrier reliability simulation of n-channel LDD MOSFETs," IEEE Int. Symp. Physical and Failure Analysis of Integrated Circuits, 1997, 133-139. 51. D. W. Marquardt, "An algorithm for least squares estimation of nonlinear parameters," J. SIAM, vol. 11, 1963,431-441. 52. S. Kirkpatrick, C. D. Gelatt, Jr. and M. P. Vecchi, "Optimization by simulated annealing," Science, vol. 220, May 1983,671-680. 53. S. Geman and C-R. Hwang, "Diffusions for global optimization," SIAM J. Control and Optimization, vol. 24, no. 5, Sep. 1986,1031 -1043. 54. D. M. Pozar, Microwave Engineering, 2nd ed., John Willey & Sons, 1998. 55. F. W. Grover, Inductance Calculations, New York, NY: Van Nostrand, 1962. 56. H. M. Greenhouse, "Design of planar rectangular microelectronic inductors," IEEE Trans. Parts, Hybrids, and Packaging, vol. PHP-10, June 1974, 101-109. 57. D. E. Root and B. Hughes, "Principles of nonlinear active device modeling for circuit simulation," ARFTG Conf., 1988,3-26. 58. D. E. Ward and R. W. Dutton, "A charge-oriented model for MOS transistor capacitances," IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits, vol. SC-13, no. 5, Oct. 1978, 703-707. 59. P. Yang, B. D. Epler, and P. K. Chatterjee, "An investigation of the charge conservation problem for MOSFET circuit simulation," IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits, vol. SC-18, no. 1, Feb. 1983.
118
MOSFET Modeling and Parameter Extraction for RF IC's
1005
60. Y. Tsividis, The operation and Modeling of the MOS Transistor, 2nd ed., McGraw-Hill, 1999. 61. F. Diamant and M. Laviron, "Measurement of the extrinsic series elements of a microwave MESFET under zero current condition," European Microwave Conf., 1982,451 —456. 62. R. R. Daniels, A. T. Yang, and J. P. Harrang, "A universal large/small signal 3-terminal FET model using a nonquasi-static charge-based approach," IEEE Trans. Electron Devices, vol. 40. . ;i. 1993, 1723-1729. 63. BSIM3v3.2 MOSFET Model User's Manual, Department of Electrical Engineering and Computer Sciences, University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720. 64. UTMOST HI Extractions Manual, Vol. 1, Silvaco International, CA 94054. 65. W. R. Curtice, "A MESFET model for use in the design of GaAs integrated circuits," IEEE Trans. Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol. MTT-28, no. 5, May 1980,448—456. 66. H. Staz, P. Newman, I. W. Smith, R. A. Pucel, and H. A. Haus, "GaAs FET device and circuit simulation in SPICE," IEEE Trans. Electron Devices, vol. ED-34, no. 2, 1987,160-169. 67. T. Kacprzak and A. Materka, "Compact dc model of GaAs FET's for large-signal computer calculation," IEEE J. Solic-State Circuits, vol. SC-18, no. 2, Apr. 1983,211-213. 68. A. J. McCamant, G. D. McCormack, and D. H. Smith, "An improved GaAs MESFET model for Spice," IEEE Trans. Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol. MTT-38, no. 6, June 1990, 822-824. 69. Sematech "Compact model workshop", Austin, Texas, Mar. 1995. 70. C. C. Enz, F. Krummenacher, and E. A. Vittoz, "An analytical MOS transistor model valid in all regions of operation and dedicated to low-voltage and low-current applications," Analog Integrated Circuits and Systems Processing Journal, vol. 8, 1995, 83—114. 71. G. Dambrine, A. Cappy, F. Heliodore, and E. Playez, "A new method for determining the FET smallsignal equivalent circuit," IEEE Trans. Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol. 36, no. 7, July 1988, 1151-1159. 72. P. L. Hower and N. G Bechtel, "Current saturation and small-signal characteristics of GaAs field effect transistors," IEEE Trans. Electron Devices, vol. ED-20, Mar. 1973,213-220. 73. M. C. A. M. Koolen, J. A. M. Geelen and M. P. J. G Versleijen, "An improved de-embedding techniques for on-wafer high-frequency characterization," IEEE Bipolar Circuits and Technology Meeting,
119
1006
M. Je, I. Kwon, H. Shin & K. Lee
1991,188-191. 74. H. Cho and D. E. Burk, "A three-step method for the de-embedding of high-frequency S-parameter measurements," IEEE Trans. Electron Devices, vol. 38, no. 6, June 1991,1371-1375. 75. K. Kundert and A. Sangiovanni-Vincentelli, "Simulation of nonlinear circuits in the frequency domain," IEEE Trans. Computer-Aided Design, vol. CAD-5, no. 4, Oct. 1986. 76. L. Chua, "Device modeling via basic nonlinear circuit elements," IEEE Trans. Circuits and Systems, vol. CAS-27, no. 11, Nov. 1980. 77. Advanced Design System 1.5 User's Manual - Circuit Components: Nonlinear Devices, Agilent Technologies, Dec. 2000. 78. D. Lovelace, J. Costa, and N. Camilleri, "Extracting small-signal model parameters of silicon MOSFET transistors," IEEE Microwave Theory and Techniques Symp., 1994, 865-868. 79. C. E. Biber, M. L. Schmatz, T. Morf, U. Lott, and W. Bachtold, "A nonlinear microwave MOSFET model for Spice simulators," IEEE Trans. Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol. 46, no. 5, May 1998, 604-610. 80. R. Sung, P. Bendix, and M. B. Das, "Extraction of high-frequency equivalent circuit parameters of submicron gate-length MOSFET's," IEEE Trans. Electron Devices, vol. 45, no. 8, Aug. 1998,1769-1775. 81. S. H-M. Jen, C. C. Enz, D. R. Pehlke, Schroter, and B. J. Sheu, "Accurate modeling and parameter extraction for MOS transistors valid up to 10 GHz," IEEE Trans. Electron Devices, vol. 46, no. 11, Nov. 1999,2217-2227. 82. C. C. Enz and Y. Cheng, "MOS transistor modeling for RF IC design," IEEE Trans. Solid-State Circuits, vol. 35, no. 2, Feb. 2000, 186-201. 83. Ickjin Kwon, Minkyu Je, Kwyro Lee, and Hyungcheol Shin, "A new small signal modeling of RF MOSFETs including charge conservation capacitances," European Solid-State Circuit Conf., 2000, 296— 299. 84. X. Jin, J-J Ou, C-H. Chen, W. Liu, J. Deen, P. R. Gray, and C. Hu, "An effective gate resistance model for CMOS RF and noise modeling," Int. Electron Devices Meeting, 1998,961-964. 85. P. J. V. Vandeloo and W. M. C. Sansen, "Modeling of the MOS transistor for high frequency analog design," IEEE Trans. Computer-Aided-Design, vol. 8, no. 7, July 1989,713-723.
120
International Journal of High Speed Electronics and Systems, Vol. 11, No. 4 (2001) 1007-1084 © World Scientific Publishing Company
MOSFET MODELING FOR RF IC DESIGN YUHUA CHENG Conexant Systems, Newport Beach, CA 92660, USA
High frequency (HF) AC and noise modeling of MOSFETs for radio frequency (RF) integrated circuit (IC) design is discussed. Equivalent circuits representing both intrinsic and extrinsic components in a MOSFET are analyzed to obtain a physics-based RF model. Modeling of the intrinsic device and the extrinsic components is discussed by accounting for the important physical effects at both DC and HF. Based m the Y-parameter analysis of the equivalent circuit model, procedures of the HF model parameter extraction are also developed. With the discussed approaches, a sub-circuit RF model incorporating the modeling of parasitics is presented. This model is compared with the measured data for both y parameter and fT characteristics. Good model accuracy is achieved against the measurements for a 0.25um RF CMOS technology. The non-quasi-static (NQS) modeling issue has also been discussed by using the BSlM3v3 based RF model to predict the HF characteristics of devices with serious NQS effects. Further, noise modeling issues are discussed by analyzing the theoretical and experimental results in both the flicker noise and thermal noise modeling. Modeling efforts to incorporate new physical effects are needed to predict better the flicker noise characteristics in today's MOSFETs. A detailed analysis of the HF noise parameters has been conducted to establish the relationship between the noise parameters preferred by circuit designers and obtained by HF noise measurement. Analytical calculation of the noise parameters has also been discussed to understand the noise characteristics with/without some parasitic components such as gate and substrate resistances as well as the influence of the induced gate noise. The HF noise predictivities of several HF noise models are also examined with the measured data. The results show that the BSIM3v3 based RF model can predict the channel thermal noise better than the other models.
1. Introduction 1.1. General review of the RF performance of MOSFETs With fast growth in the radio-frequency (RF) wireless communications market, the demand for high performance but low cost RF solutions is rising. The common perception is that silicon CMOS is suitable for digital applications while other technologies such as silicon bipolar and III-V material based processes are suitable for high frequency (HF) applications. However, advances in CMOS fabrications have resulted in deep submicron transistors with higher transit frequencies and lower noise figures. RF designers have already started to explore the use of CMOS technology in RF circuits. In Table 1, the RF performance of several generation of CMOS technologies are listed,' where, for a 0.25|im technology^- is around 30GHz, and is in the 50GHz range for a 0.18pm process and even higher for a more advanced technology. Actually, literature on more attractive device performance to RF applications than those listed in Table 1.1 has been reported recently.2 This advanced performance of MOSFETs is attractive for HF circuit design in view of a
121
1008
Y. Cheng
system-on-a-chip realization, where digital, mixed-signal base-band and HF transceiver blocks would be integrated on a single chip. Besides the ability to integrate RF circuits with other analog and logic circuits with the intention to reduce cost by eliminating the sometimes expensive packaging, other advantages offered by silicon CMOS technologies are also interesting, such as the low cost due to the volume of wafers processed and low power consumption feature of MOSFETs, which makes it suitable for portable applications. For example, silicon MOSFET circuit can operate at voltages as low as IV, and still have room to improve. Table 1 RF performances of MOSFETs in different technology generations. Year
1995
1997
1999
2001
2003
L (um)
0.25
0.18
0.14
0.12
49 47
70 51
0.1 112 60
0.35
0.23
84 52 0.2
/T-(GHZ)
/„,,(GHz) NFmi„ (dB)
33 41 0.5
0.15
Although the above picture might change in the future with decreasing MCM packaging cost and due to many still existing problems of a single-chip solution, such as substrate high frequency coupling, synchronized design cycle time for digital and HF blocks as well as increased cost for RF-suitable deep-submicron processes, exploration of the suitability of CMOS for RF application is a very useful task,3 as further development such as silicon-on-insulator and other novel structures will improve the performance of silicon-based CMOS devices in general compared to III-V material based solutions. 4 1.2. The importance of the modeling at HF Time to market is one of the key factors for a product to have profit margin and market shares. For RF products, time to market and design cycle reduction depend greatly on the capability of the design environment to predict circuit performance accurately using simulation. To have an efficient design environment, design tools with accurate models for devices and interconnect parasitics are essential. It has been known that for analog and RF applications the accuracy of circuit simulation is strongly determined by device models. Accurate device models become crucial to predict the circuit performance correctly. In most of the commercially available circuit simulators, MOS transistor models have been originally developed for digital and low frequency analog circuit design,5,6 which focus on the dc drain current, conductances, and intrinsic charge/capacitance behavior up to the megahertz range. However, as the operating frequency increases to the gigahertz range, the importance of the extrinsic components rivals that of the intrinsic counter-parts. Therefore, a RF model with the consideration of the HF behavior of both intrinsic and extrinsic components in MOSFETs is extremely important to achieve accurate
122
MOSFET
Modeling for RF IC Design
1009
and predictive results in simulation of a designed circuit. Next we discuss some examples to show the necessity of the MOSFET HF modeling for RF applications. So far, most compact MOSFET models do not include the gate resistance RG. However, the thermal noise contributed by the gate resistance should be considered as MOS transistors approach gigahertz frequencies, and the RC effect at the gate should be well modeled since both of these effects are important in designing radio frequency CMOS circuits. As shown in Fig. 1, the gate resistance component will significantly affect the input admittance at RF so the model without including RG cannot accurately predict the HF characteristics of the device. It is very crucial because one may use this resistance for impedance matching to achieve maximum power transfer. Also, The thermal noise introduced by the gate resistance increases the noise figure of the transistor. It is an important noise source to be considered when optimizing the noise performance of a RF circuit. Furthermore, The gate resistance also reduces fmax (the frequency at which the maximum available power gain of the device equals to 1), which is an important device parameter in RF circuit design in addition tofT, the frequency at which the current gain of the device equals to 1. It has been known that two additional physical effects at HF will affect the value of the effective gate resistance obtained at DC and low frequency, one is the distributed transmission line effect on the gate, and another one is the distributed effect or NQS effect in the channel.7,8 Therefore, detailed theoretical analysis with the consideration of these two HF effects is needed to obtain an accurate and physical gate resistance model, which is critical in predicting the HF behavior of the MOSFETs in designing a RF circuit.
0.014 0.012
55"
°°1°
>F
0.008
~ c
0.006
CD -~.
0.004
"5*
0.002 0.000 •0.002 0
2
4
6
8
10
12
Frequency (GHz) Fig. 1 The model without the gate resistance cannot predict the measured Yu characteristics.
123
1010
Y. Cheng
•
i
0
1 2
•
1 4
•
1 6
'
1 8
>
r10
Frequency (GHz)
Fig. 2 The model without the substrate resistances cannot predict the measured Yu characteristics.
Another important component that almost all of the compact models implemented in commercial circuit simulators did not account for is the substrate resistance. Actually, substrate-coupling effects through the drain and source junctions and these substrate resistance components play an important role in the contribution to the output admittance so the inclusion of these substrate components in a RF model is needed. This effective admittance of the substrate network can contribute 50% of the total output admittance.9 As shown in Fig. 2, a MOSFET model without the substrate resistance components cannot predict the frequency dependency of the output admittance of the device so the simulation with such a model will give misleading simulation results of the output admittance when the device operation frequency is in gigaherze range. 1.3. The status of the RF MOSFET modeling Compared with the MOSFET models for both digital and analog application at low frequency, compact models for HF applications are more difficult to develop due to the additional requirements of bias-dependence and geometry scaling of the parasitic components as well as the requirements of accurate prediction of the distortion and noise behavior. A common modeling approach for RF applications is to build sub-circuits based on the intrinsic MOSFET that has been modeled well for analog applications.,0, "' 2 The accuracy of such a model depends on how to establish sub-circuits with the correct understanding of the device physics in HF operation, how to model the HF behavior of intrinsic devices and extrinsic parasitics, and how to extract parameters appropriately for the elements of the sub-circuit. A reliable and physics-based parameter extraction methodology based on the appropriate characterization techniques is another important
124
MOSFET Modeling for RF IC Design 1011 portion of the RF modeling to determine the model parameters and generate scaleable models for circuit optimization. Currently, most RF modeling activities focus on the above subcircuit approach based on different compact MOSFET models developed for digital and low frequency analog applications, such as EKV, 13 MOS9, 6 and BSIM3v3.5 Several MOSFET models for RF applications have been reported.11,12'1415 With added parasitic components at the gate, at the source, at the drain and at the substrate, these models can reasonably well predict theHF AC small signal characteristics of short channel (<0.5nm) devices up to 10GHz.11'15 However the RF MOSFET modeling is still at a preliminary stage compared with the modeling work for dgital and low frequency analog applications. Efforts from both industry and universities are needed to bring RF MOSFET models to a mature level in further improving the RF models in describing the AC characteristics more accurately, and in improving the prediction of noise characteristics, distortion behavior, and NQS behavior. 2. AC Small Signal Modeling 2.1. MOSFET structure and components As shown in Fig. 3, a four terminal MOSFET can be divided into two portions: intrinsic part and extrinsic part. The extrinsic part consists of all the parasitic components, such as the gate resistance RG, gate/source overlap capacitance Caso, gate/drain overlap capacitance CGDO, gate/bulk overlap capacitance CGBO, source series resistance Rs, drain series resistance RD, source/bulk junction diode DSB, drain/bulk junction diode DDB, and substrate resistances RSB, RDB and RDSB. The intrinsic part is the core of the device without including those parasitics. Even though it would be desirable to design and fabricate MOSFETs without those parasitics, they cannot be avoided in reality. Some of them may be not noticeable in DC and low frequency operation. However, they will influence significantly the device performance at HF. 2.2. Discussion of equivalent circuits of a RF MOSFET Equivalent circuits have been an effective approach to analyze the electrical behavior of a device by representing the above components. In this section, we discuss the equivalent circuits for both the intrinsic device without the parasitics and the extrinsic device with different parasitic components. 2.2.1 Equivalent circuit for an intrinsic device For an intrinsic device, AC small signal currents referring to the source of the device can be calculated by the following:
125
1012
Y. Cheng
jCCCoGi
— jCOCcDl
—jCOCaBi
vast
Gm— jCOCoGi GDS+jCOCDDi Gmb~ JCCCDBI
VDSi
— JCOCBGI
VBSI
—JOCBDI
JCOCBBI
(1)
Where vG5,-, vDSi, and vBSi are the A C voltages at the intrinsic gate, at the intrinsic drain, and at the intrinsic bulk (all referring to the intrinsic source); J'G„ iDil and iBt are the A C currents through the intrinsic gate, through the intrinsic drain and through the intrinsic bulk; Gm, GDS, and Gmb are the transconductance, channel conductance, and bulk transconductance of the device respectively; Cxyl are intrinsic capacitances between the terminals with the following definitions:
Gv =
when X & y
(2a)
when X = y
(2b)
dVy
Cxy = — ^
RSB
P-3™
RDB
Fig. 3 A MOSFET schematic cross-section with the parasitic components.
Eq. (1) can be rewritten as the following id = JCOCcCiVCSi - jOOCGDiVDSi- j(l)CGB,VBSi
(3a)
im = GmVOSi + GDSVDSi + GmbVBSi — jCOCodVaSi + jCOCDDiVDSi — J0)CDBiVBSi
(3b) IBi = -jCOCBGVGSi-
JQ}CBD!VDSi+ JQ)CBB!VBSi
126
(3c)
MOSFET Modeling for RF IC Design 1013 In Eq. (1), we assume that the components between the gate and other terminals can be considered as pure capacitive ones with infinite resistance so the gate current in Eq. (3a) does not contain any conductive current component. Similarly, the components between the bulk and other terminals can be also considered as pure capacitive ones with infinite resistance so the bulk current in Eq. (3c) does not contain any conductive current component. Those assumptions can usually hold for an intrinsic MOSFET because of the very low leakage currents through the gate to other terminals and through the bulk to other terminals in a MOSFET with current advanced technology. To derive an equivalent circuit from the above equations, we rearrange the above equations in the following forms: ia = j(oCasiVasi + jaCGDivoDi + J(£CGB
(4a)
IDl = {Gm— JG)Cm)VGSi + JWCGDIVDGI + (Gmb — JCOCmb)vSSi + J0>CaDiVDBi + (Gds + J0)CsDi)VDSi
(4b) Ui = j(X)CmgbVGBi + j(0 CBSiVBSi + j(OCGBiVBGi + J0i)CBDiVBDi
(4c)
where C„, Cmb and Cmgb are the differences of the transcapacitances between the drain and the gate, between the drain and the bulk, and between the gate and the bulk, and given by Cm = CoGi— CGDi
(5a)
Cmb = CDBi— CBDi
(5b)
Cmgb = CGBi — CBGI
(5C)
CSDI and Cfls,are intrinsic trancapacitances between the source and the drain, and between the bulk and the source and have the following relationships with other capacitances CsDi= CDDI— CBDI— CGDJ
Cssi = CBBI—CBGI— CBDI
(6a)
(6b)
According to the equations given in Eq. (4), an equivalent circuit (EC) referring to the source can be derived as shown in Fig. 4. Different from the low frequency AC small signal EC, several current components contributed by the transcapacitances cannot be ignored at HF and they are included in the EC in Fig. 4.
127
1014
Y. Cheng
Gi
CGB
_
:r:
-,- CGD
CGS
(Gn-jwCm)vCS/
-e—
(GDS+j WCSDi)vDSi
-©
Di -0
(Gmb-JHCmb )vBSi
• e — CBS
T
O jwCmgbvflSi
-T- CBD
O Bi
Fig. 4 /4n equivalent circuit for an intrinsic MOSFET. 2.2.2. Equivalent
circuit for the device with extrinsic
capacitances
As shown in Fig. 3, parasitic capacitances such as the overlaps of gate-tosource/drain/bulk and the junction capacitances from the source/bulk and drain/bulk diodes are not negligible in a MOSFET and must be included in the EC to describe the device behavior at HF. With the inclusion of those extrinsic capacitances, the EC for a MOSFET can be given in Fig. 5. The EC in Fig. 5 can be further simplified to that in Fig. 6 by merging the intrinsic and extrinsic capacitances together, that is, CGSI+CGSO
(7a)
CGD = CGDI+ CGDO
(7b)
CGB=
(7c)
CGS=
CGBI+CGBO
CBS — CBSI + CJBS
(7d)
CBD = CBDI + CJBD
(7e)
128
MOSFET
CGBo
Modeling for RF IC Design
__
CGBi
_ _ COD.
(Gm-jnGn)vGS
-e-
(CPS+jWCSDj)VDSi
-e-— -e—
I
(Qnb-j^CmbJvMi
I jHCmgbl'flS;
T T O
Bi
Fig. 5 Equivalent circuit of an intrinsic MOSFET plus extrinsic capacitances. „ Gi
CGB
CGS
~_
COD
(Gm-j wCm)vOSi
-© -e— -e— (G>S+jwCSDi)vDS
Di -O
(Gmb-jwCmb)v»-n
CBS
T
O
jwCmgbvBSi
ZZ
CBD
6 Bi
Fig. 6 Another simplified representation of equivalent circuit in Fig. 5.
129
1015
1016
Y. Cheng
2.2.3. Equivalent circuit for the device with parasitic
resistances
In a MOSFET model for DC and low frequency applications, the parasitic resistances at the gate and substrate can be ignored with little influence on the simulation accuracy. Usually, the parasitic resistances at the source and drain can be treated as "virtual" components by incorporating them in the /-Kequation to account for the influence of the voltage drops at those resistances. 5, 6 At HF, however, these parasitic resistances will influence the device performance significantly and they all should be modeled and included in the equivalent circuit for the device. The gate resistance is in principle a bias-independent component at DC and low frequency, but may contain the contribution of an additional component with bias dependence at HF.8 The parasitic resistances at the source and drain consists of several parts as we will discuss later and can be also treated as a bias-independent component even though they do have some bias dependence depending on the device structure and process conditions. The resistances in the substrate can be modeled by different EC networks, such as 5-resistor network, 4resistor network,' 2 3-resistor network,11,16 2resistor network,13 and 1-resistor network,17 as shown in Fig. 7. The 4 and 5 resistor networks are more accurate and can be valid up to higher frequency, but the analysis and parameter extraction of the components are very complex. The 1- and 2-resistor networks introduce fewer components and are easier for the analysis and parameter extraction. However, they may be less accurate when the operating frequency goes to higher frequency.18 The 3-resistor network is a compromise among these substrate networks. It can ensure the accuracy up to 10GHz while maintaining a simple analysis and parameter extraction. However, it should be pointed out that the intrinsic bulk has been shifted to the end of RDSB, as shown in Fig. 7 (c), instead of located somewhere along the resistor RDSB. It has been concluded that this approximation does not influence much the simulation accuracy.11,14 With further consideration of parasitic resistances at the drain, at the gate, at the source, and at the substrate, a complete lumped equivalent circuit for a MOSFET at HF can be given in Fig. 8.
(Intrinsic source)
(Intrinsic source)
Si, Su
o Di
r-^VvV-L-^VVV—i-^Wv—L-WV-| RSB
RDSB1
L
RDSB2
RDB
S RDSB3
Fig. 7 (a) Five-resistor substrate network.
130
MOSFET
(Intrinsic Drain)
(Intrinsic source)
a.
Di
I
I
r ^AAAr-J-^VVVRSB
Modeling for RF IC Design
£
W\Ar--^\AA^-i
RDSBI
RDSB2
RDB
Fig. 7 (b) Four-resistor substrate network.12
(Intrinsic drain)
(Intrinsic source) Si
•
OB
1
r^WV —I RSB
Bi
1
Di
V\A. RUSH
C°B
.
1—ww-i RDB
Fig. 7 (c) Three resistor substrate network."
(Intrinsic source)
CSB
(Intrinsic drain) p Di
1
CDB
RSB i
RDB
B Fig. 7 (d) Two-resistor substrate network."
131
1017
1018
Y. Cheng
(Intrinsic source)
(Intrinsic drain)
Q)B
>SB
RSI:UB
B Fig. 7 (e) One resistor substrate network.1
(Gm-j>*Cm)K»
r~
-e— -e— -e-
(QK+j»CsDi)vas/ ^/W
O
v
(Gmb-j»Cmb) s#
RDSB
Fig. 8 An equivalent circuit with both intrinsic and extrinsic components.
132
MOSFET
Modeling for RF IC Design
1019
2.2.4. Implementation ofa subcircuit RF model in circuit simulators The equivalent circuit shown in Fig. 8 can be used to understand and analyze the HF behavior of a MOSFET. In order to implement this equivalent circuit in a Spice simulator, a subcircuit approach has to be used. In the subcircuit, the characteristics of the intrinsic device is described by a MOS transistor compact model implemented in the circuit simulator, and all the extrinsic components have to be located outside the intrinsic device, so that the MOS transistor symbol in the subcircuit only represents the intrinsic part of the device \ For example, (1) the source and drain series resistors have been added outside the MOS intrinsic device to make them visible in AC simulation (in most compact models, since the internal series resistances are only "virtual" resistances embedded in the I-Vmodel to account for the dc voltage drop across the source and drain resistances in calculating the drain current, they do not add any poles and are therefore invisible for AC simulation); (2) The gate resistance should be added to the subcircuit model (usually RG is not part of the MOS compact model, but plays a fundamental role in RF circuits as we discussed in Section 1); (3) The substrate resistors should be added to account for the signal coupling through the substrate; (4) Two external diodes should be added in order to account for the influence of the substrate resistance at HF (the source-to-bulk and drain-to-bulk diodes are part of the compact model but their anodes are connected to the same substrate node, which will short the AC signal at HF12 so the diodes internal to the compact model should be turned off). With the above considerations, a subcircuit that represents a RF MOSFET in a circuit simulator can be given in Fig. 9. Note that the intrinsic substrate node should be connected at some point along the resistor RDSB, but simulations have shown that connecting the intrinsic substrate to the source or the drain side has little influence on the simulated AC parameters. In some RF models,9-" the intrinsic substrate has been connected to the source side of in order to save one node and one component for the subcircuit model. Two external overlap capacitances, CGSP and CGDP as shown in Fig. 9, with bias dependence can be added but this is not always required, depending on the compact model used. For example, BSIM3v3 accounts for bias dependent overlap capacitances that, if extracted correctly, have shown a sufficient accuracy. However, by adding these external capacitances, the inaccuracies of the intrinsic capacitance model appearing for short-channel devices can be corrected. In the next section, we will discuss the modeling of these intrinsic and extrinsic components shown in Fig. 8. 2.3. Modeling of the intrinsic MOSFET Compared with the MOSFET modeling for digital and low frequency analog applications, the HF modeling of MOSFETs is more challenging. All of the requirements for a MOSFET model in low frequency application, such as continuity, accuracy and scaleability of the
It may include the overlap capacitances at the source, at the drain and at the bulk, depending on the intrinsic compact MOSFET model used in the implementation.
133
1020
Y. Cheng
DC and capacitance models should be maintained in a RF model." In addition, there are further important requirements to the RF models: (1) The model should accurately predict bias dependence of small signal parameters at HF operation; (2) The model should correctly describe the nonlinear behavior of the devices in order to permit accurate simulation of inter-modulation distortion and high-speed large-signal operation; (3) The model should correctly and accurately predict HF noise which is important for the design of, e.g., low noise amplifiers (LNA); (4) The model should include the NQS effect so it can describe the device behavior at very high frequency range in which NQS effect cannot be ignored for a model to behave correctly and will degrade the device performance significantly; (5) The components in the developed equivalent circuit model should be physics-based and geometrically scaleable so that the model can be used in predictive and statistical modeling for RF applications.
Core/Intrinsic MOSFET • Ro
CGSPJ_ • Rs
J:
-AA/V
_iL.
• .I^J_CGDP
JV CSB
l—AA/V RSB
' Substrate Network /
W\r RDSB
B
AAAr-i RDB
B
fig. 9 A subcircuil that can be implemented in a circuit simulator.
To achieve the above, the model for the intrinsic device should be derived with the inclusions of most (if not all) important physical effects in a modern MOSFET, such as normal and reverse short-channel and narrow width effects, channel length modulation, drain induced barrier lowering (DIBL), velocity saturation, mobility degradation due to vertical electric field, impact ionization, band-to-band tunneling, polysilicon depletion, velocity overshoot, self-heating, channel quantization." Also, the continuities of small signal parameters such as transconductance Gm, channel conductance G&, and the intrinsic trancapacitances must be modeled properly. Many MOSFET models, including MOS9,6 EKV,20 and BSIM3v35 have been developed for digital, analog and mixed signal
134
MOSFET
Modeling for RF IC Design
1021
applications. Recently, they all are extended for use in RF applications. We do not present any new models in this work. Instead, in the following, we give a brief discussion on the concept of deriving a compact model of the intrinsic device for RF applications. A compact model includes many mathematical equations for different physical mechanisms. The most important and essential parts are DC and capacitance models. It has been found that the model accuracy in fittings of HF small signal parameters and large signal distortion of a RF MOSFET is basically determined by the DC and capacitance models.21 2.3.1, DC model In general, a DC MOSFET model is derived based on the following Jn = qiimE + qDn V«
(8)
JP = q^pE-qDpVp
(9)
where J„ and Jp are the current density for electrons and holes respectively; q is the electron charge; n, and /j, are the mobilities for electrons and holes, respectively;« is the electron concentration in the channel; p is the hole concentration in the channel; £ is the electric field; D„ and Dp are the diffusion coefficients for electrons and holes, respectively. D„ and .Dp link tojn and y, with the following equations: Dn = V,Hn
(10)
Dp = viflP
(11)
where v, is the thermal voltage. The first terms in Eqs. (8) and (9) describe the drift current components due to the electric filed E. The second terms describe the diffusion current component due to the carrier concentration gradient. In the strong inversion region, the total current is dominated by the drift current. In the subthreshold region, the diffusion current component dominates. However, in the transition region (moderate inversion region) from subthreshold to strong inversion, both drift and diffusion currents are important, and need to be included in the model. As shown in (8) and (9), the electric field E, carrier density, and mobility are the basic factors determining the current characteristics. The electric field E can be obtained by solving the Poisson equation V>=—£-
135
(12)
1022
Y. Cheng
where 0is the electrostatic potential; p i s the charge density including electron, holes, and other charges in the interesting region of the device. However, to get analytical solutions for I-V models, simplified approaches are needed to consider the influence of the electric field in compact modeling." Besides the proper consideration of the electric field, the channel charge and mobility need to be modeled carefully to describe the current characteristics accurately and physically, based on which, different physical effects can be added in the I-V model. In modeling the channel charge, physical effects such as short channel effect, narrow width effect, non-uniform doping effect, and quantization effect etc. should be accounted for in order to describe the charge characteristics accurately in today's devices. There are two types of charge models, one can be called threshold-voltage (Vlh)based models, another can be called surface-potential (y*)-based models, yf-based charge models are based on the analysis of the surface potential that will appear in the I-V model to describe charge characteristics with the influence of many physical effects.22 F,A-based charge models are derived also by solving the surface potential with the consideration of those physical effects, but finally V,h is used instead of 1/4 in the charge (and hence I-V) model to account for the influence of some process parameters such as oxide thickness and doping and device parameters such as channel length and width.5'6,20 In both models, the continuities of the charge and its derivatives should be modeled carefully for the I-V model to have good continuity and to predict correct distortion behavior of the devices. A F,A-based charge model used in BSIM3v3 is given in Eq. (13) as an example. As shown in Fig. 10, the model fits the measured data of the channel charge and ensures the continuity of the channel charge from strong inversion to the subthreshold regions.23 Fig. 11 shows the continuity of the ^ ^ ( a n d hence the charge model as given in Eq. (13) and its first and second derivatives.19
Qchs o = Cox Vpieff
(13a)
VGS-V,H,
VgsKff =
2nv/ln l+exp(— ) 2nvi 1 + 2nCox l„CoX\^.I—-—exp( ^ qe,iN ^iNd, 2nvi
(13b) —)
Here Cox is the unit area oxide capacitance; n is the subthreshold swing factor; Nch is the doping concentration in the channel; Voff\s a fitting parameter; " Vas is the gate voltage; V,h is the threshold voltage; vt is the thermal voltage; q is the electron charge; £,, is the dielectric permittivity of the semiconductor; and $ i s the surface potential when Vgs=Vlh, and is given by 0s=2v,ln(-^-)
where Nch is the doping concentration in the channel;«, is the intrinsic carrier density.
136
(13c)
MOSFET Modeling for RF IC Design 1023
l O itt
N =axiaie
10-"•
.2 o o
GJ
io- 1 3 ;
10-
10-'
OS
OO
OS
1.0
1-5
2X1
3 0
2.5
35
V G S (V) Fig. 10. The charge model covers the weak, moderate, and strong inversion regions of MOSFETs.23
The second derivative of VgsUff vs. VGS
The first derivative of Vgsiaff vs. VGS
Vgstsff .
ft********
•1.0
-0.5
0.0
0.5 1.0 yos(V)
*****
1.5
2.0
2.5
Fig. 11. The continuities of the charge model and its derivatives are needed in different operation regimes." Mobility is another key parameter in MOSFET modeling. It will influence the accuracy and distortion behavior of the model significantly.19,24 The relationship between the carrier mobility and the electric field in MOSFETs has been well studied.25,26 Three
137
1024
Y. Cheng
scattering mechanisms have been proposed to describe the dependence of mobility on the electric field.27 Each mechanism may be dominant under specific conditions of doping concentration, temperature and biases as shown in Fig. 12.
Effective Field Eeff
Fig. 12 Mobility behavior influenced by different scattering mechanisms, depending on the bias and temperature conditions.27
In strong inversion, mobility depends on the gate oxide thickness, doping concentration, threshold voltage, gate and substrate biases. In weak inversion, it is usually modeled as a constant. Thus, continuity of the mobility model is also required to ensure the continuity of the /-K model. In BSIM3v3, a mobility expression based on the V^eff given in Eq. (13) is used, fJ, 1+(U.+UCVBSX
(14) ) + Ub{
J ox
) I ox
where ^& Um Ub and Uc are fitting parameters extracted from measured data; V,h is the threshold voltage; Tox is the gate oxide thickness." With Vg5leff\n Eq. (13), the mobility model given in Eq. (14) is continuous from strong inversion to weak inversion. It has been known that the I-Vmodel based on Eq. (14) can predict the distortion behavior of the devices.21 Recently, other detailed analysis of the influence of the mobility model on the distortion behavior of the 7-Kmodel has also been reported.24 In Fig. 13, is shown the comparison of characteristics of Gm and its derivatives versus gate bias between the model and measured data for a device of 5fim
138
MOSFET
Modeling for RF IC Design
1025
channel length, with the consideration of the distortion behavior of the mobility model.24 It has been realized that an accurate and physical description of a mobility model in compact MOSFET RF models for circuit simulation is essential for distortion analysis. It is also suggested that different models for electron and hole mobilities should be developed because of the difference in quantum-mechanical behavior of electrons and holes in the inversion layer in today's MOSFETs.24
*
6*
%. "
l«
•90 r " " • " • ^ «•»»•.-<«».i
S S n i ^ i ^ ^ • .•i
-ISO
-1
*
- H O »!»««» -120
m
***
-130
,rf-r -t»'--V/---f---
lOB
2.50
,:-***•'•rnxs*******
; -i-%>/}----
3.00
--:•
3.30
.if *M
4.50
5.00
5.50
6.00
VcsCV) Fig. 13 Measured (symbols) and modeled (lines) behavior of Gm and its first and second derivatives as a function of VGS for an n-channel MOSFET with a width of lOum and length of 5\im at fis=0V.24
Based on the charge and mobility models, complete I-V equations can be developed with further inclusions of many important physical effects such as short channel and narrow width effects, velocity saturation and overshoot, poly-depletion effect, quantization effect, and so on. In order to meet the requirements for both AC small signal and larger signal applications, the continuity and distortion behavior of the I-V model should be ensured in deriving the equations when including these physical effects. 2.3.2. Capacitance model In real circuit operation, the device operates under time-varying terminal voltages. Depending on the magnitude of the time-varying signals, the dynamic operation can be classified as large signal operation and small signal operation. Both types of dynamic operation are influenced by the capacitive effects of the device. Thus, a capacitance model is another essential part of a compact MOSFET model for circuit simulation.
139
1026
Y. Cheng
Many MOSFET intrinsic capacitance models have been developed. Basically, they can be categorized into two groups. (1) Meyer and Meyer-like capacitance models and (2) charge based capacitance models.28,29 The advantages and shortcomings of the two groups of model have been well discussed and both of them have been implemented in circuit simulators. The Meyer and Meyer-like models are simpler than charge-based models so they are efficient and faster in computations. But they assume that the capacitances in the intrinsic MOSFET are reciprocal, which is not the case in real device,"and earlier models based on this assumption cannot ensure the charge conservation.19'30 Charge-based models ensure the charge conservation and consider the non-reciprocal property of the capacitances in a MOSEFT. These features are required to describe the capacitive effects in a MOSFET, especially for RF applications where the influence of trans-capacitances are critical and should be considered in the model. But usually the charge-based capacitance models require complex equations to describe all of the 16 capacitances in a MOSFET with four terminal, as given in the following, Q=^SL d/,j
i*j,ij=G,D,S,B
(15)
Cj = - ^ L
i=j
(16)
The development of an intrinsic capacitance model of modern MOSFETs is another challenging issue in RF modeling. To meet the needs in RF applications, besides ensuring charge conservation and non-reciprocity, an intrinsic MOSFET capacitance model should at least have the following features such as (1) guaranteeing model continuity and smoothness in all the bias regions, (2) providing model accuracy for devices with different geometry and different bias conditions, and (3) ensuring model symmetry at the bias of VDs=(N. Some comparisons between the MOSFET capacitance models and the measured data have been reported.31 However, a complete verification of the bias and geometry dependencies of those capacitance models has not been seen. It has been found that some engineering approaches have to be used to improve the accuracy of the capacitance model if the intrinsic capacitance model cannot describe the device behavior accurately.32 Recently, the model continuity has been improved greatly. Many discontinuity issues in earlier capacitance models have been fixed.33 However, most capacitance models still cannot ensure the model symmetry when VDs=0. In Fig. 14 and 15, the asymmetries of the capacitance model in BSIM3v3 are shown for CGs=CGD, Q>0 and C^, and for CBD and CBS.i9 It has been known that a MOSFET should be symmetric for some capacitances at VDs=0, i.e. CDD=Css and CBD=CBS. The asymmetric issue in the capacitance model is apparently non-physical and may cause convergence and accuracy problem in the simulation. This issue may become more critical in the model for RF applications because the devices are often biased in the region of KDS=0V in some applications such as switching. Efforts have been made based on the source-referenced approach, the bulkreferenced approach and surface potential oriented approaches to improve the symmetry property of the models.34 The development of advanced capacitance models with good
140
MOSFET
Modeling for RF IC Design
1027
continuity, symmetry, accuracy and scalebility is still a challenge for the model developers.
V D S (V)
Fig. 14 Simulated Css and CDD as a function of VDS- Css *€DD when VDS-0. "
0.2 0.1 -
^
8 O
• \T \
0.0 -
1
y
-0.1 "
£
'a
-0.2-
o B o
-0.3-0.4-0.5-
Oss
....
f
W/L=10/0.5 1
t/SD
1 0.0
VBS=OV
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
V D S (V) Fig. 15 Simulated Css and CDD as a function of VDS. CBS ^BD when VDS~0.'9
141
1028
Y. Cheng
2.4. Modeling of the extrinsic
MOSFET
For an AC small signal model at RF, the modeling of parasitics is very important. The models for these parasitic components should be physics-based and linked to process and geometry information to ensure the scalability and prediction capabilities of the model. Also, simple sub-circuits are preferred to reduce the simulation time and to make parameter extraction easier. Besides a development of a physical and accurate intrinsic model discussed above, the following issues should be considered in developing a MOSFET model for deep submicron RF applications: 1) The gate resistance should be modeled and included in the simulation. 2) The extrinsic source and drain resistances should be modeled as real external resistors, instead of only a correction to the drain current with a virtual component. 3) Substrate coupling in a MOSFET, that is, the contribution of substrate resistance, needs to be modeled physically and accurately using approriate substrate network for the model to be used in RF applications. 4) A bias dependent overlap capacitance model, which accurately describes the parasitic capacitive contributions between the gate and drain/source, needs to be included. 2.4.1. Modeling of gate resistance At DC and low frequency, the gate resistance consists mainly of the poly-silicon sheet resistance. The typical sheet resistance for a polysilicon gate ranges between 20-40 £2/square, and can be reduced by a factor of 10 with a silicide process, and even more with a metal stack process. At HF, however, two additional physical effects appear, which will affect the value of the effective gate resistance. One is the distributed transmission line effect on the gate, and another one is the distributed effect or NQS effect in the channel.8,35 The distributed transmission line effect on the gate at HF has been studied.7 It will become more severe as the gate width becomes wider at higher operation frequency. So multi-finger devices are used in the circuit design with narrow gate width for each finger to reduce the influence of this effect. A simple expression of gate resistance, R0, based on that in DC or low frequency has been used to calculate the value of gate resistance with the influence of the distributed gate effect (DGE) at HF. However, a factor of a is introduced, which is 1/3 or 1/12 depending on the layout structures of the gate connection to account for the distributed RC effects at RF, as given in the following,
Rc.^^XZL^+Ot) N/Lf
(17)
a
where RGsh is the gate sheet resistance, ffyis the channel width per finger, Lf is the channel length, and A^is the number of fingers, Wex, is the extension of the poly-silicon gate over the active region.
142
MOSFET
Modeling for RF IC Design
1029
Complex numerical models for the gate delay have been proposed. However, the simple gate resistance model with the a factor for the distributed effect has been found accurate up to VfTfov a MOSFET without significant NQS effects." The NQS effect or the distributed RC effect in the channel is another effect that should be accounted for in modeling the HF behavior of a MOSFET. For the devices with NQS effects, additional bias and geometry dependences of the gate resistance are needed to account for the NQS effect.8,35 It has been proposed that an additional resistive component in the gate should be added to represent the channel distributed RC effect.8 As discussed above, when a MOSFET operates at high frequencies, the contribution to the effective gate resistance is not only from the physical gate electrode resistance but also from the distributed channel resistance, which can be "seen" by the signal applied to the gate, as shown in Fig. 16. Thus, the effective gate resistance RG consists of two parts: Ra
=Ra.
poly +Ra,
mis
(18)
where Ra.poiy is the distributed gate electrode resistance from the poly-silicon gate material and is given by Eq. (17), RG.^ is the NQS distributed channel resistance seen from the gate and is a function of both biases and geometry.8,35
Fig. 16 Equivalent gate resistance consists of the contributions from the distributed gate poly resistance and distributed channel resistance.S3S
The HF characteristics of the gate resistance have been studied.35 In Fig. 17, it is shown that RG decreases first as Lf increases while showing a weak bias dependence in this region, then starts to increase with £/as Lf continue to increase above 0.4um while showing a strong bias dependence. The Lf dependence of Ra varies for different VGS. At lower VGS, the Lf dependence of Ra is stronger. Also, RG for the devices with longer Lf increases significantly and has stronger VGs dependence. Fig. 18 shows the Wf dependence of RG. It demonstrates that Ra increases as W^-decreases when Wf<6\\m, and the device with the same Wf has higher RG at lower VGS, which becomes more obvious when Wf narrows. Figs. 19 and 20 give RG for devices with various geometries at several VDS, from which we observe similar Lf and Wf dependencies of RG as what we found in
143
1030
Y. Cheng
Figs. 17 and 18. However, the VDS dependence of RG becomes very weak when VDS is larger than IV.
50 VGS=0.