CLIMATE CHANGERESEARCH
EVALUATIONAND POLICYIMPLICATIONS
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Studies in Environmental Science 65 B
CLIMATE CHANGERESEARCH
EVALUATIONAND POLICY IMPLICATIONS
Proceedings of the International Climate Change Research Conference, Maastricht, The Netherlands, 6-9 December 1994 Editors:
S. Zwerver, R.S.A.R. van Rompaey, M.T.J. Kok and M.M. Berk Programme Office "Dutch National Research Programme on Global Air Pollution and Climate Change" at the National Institute of Public Health and the Environment, P.O. Box 1, 3720 BA Bilthoven, The Netherlands
1995 ELSEVIER Amsterdam
-
Lausanne
-
New
York
-
Oxford
-
Shannon
-
Tokyo
ELSEVIER SCIENCE B.V. Sara Burgerhartstraat 25 P.O. Box 211,1000 AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands
ISBN 0-444-82143-0 91995 ELSEVIER SCIENCE B.V. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the publisher, Elsevier Science B.V., Copyright & Permissions Department, P.O. Box 521, 1000 AM Amsterdam, The Netherlands. Special regulations for readers in the U.S.A. - This publication has been registered with the Copyright Clearance Center Inc. (CCC), 222 Rosewood Drive Danvers, Ma 01923. Information can be obtained from the CCC about conditions under which photocopies of parts of this publication may be made in the U.S.A. All other copyright questions, including photocopying outside of the U.S.A., should be referred to the publisher. No responsibility is assumed by the publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. This book is printed on acid-free paper. Printed in The Netherlands
CONTENTS
Page a t .
VOLUME A Abstract Preface
vii
Editorial
ix
OPENING SESSION
Opening address by the Minister of Housing, Spatial Planning and the Environment M. de Boer P A R T ONE: K E Y N O T E A D D R E S S E S
Current progress in the study of global biogeochemical cycles M.H. Unsworth and G. Wolfe The potential effects of climate change in a riverine hydrological system in northwestern Canada S.J. Cohen
27
Assessing the impacts of climate: the issue of winners and losers in a global climate change context M.H. Glantz
41
Sustainable development and climate change R.I~ Turner
55
Global climate change: social and institutional options M. Redclift
67
National and international economic instruments for climate change policy J.B. Opschoor
77
vi Integrated models for estimating regional climate change in response to anthropogenic emissions: MAGICC and SCENGEN T.M.L. Wigley
93
The process of developing policy based on global environmental risk assessment D.J. Fisk
95
Communication among scientists, decision makers and society: developing policy-relevant global climate change research J. C. Bernabo
103
Climate change, policy options and research implications P. Vellinga
119
Stabilizing Greenhouse gases: global and regional consequences J. Alcamo, M. Krol and R. Leemans
135
PART TWO: N R P A S S E S S M E N T REPORTS AND SHORT P A P E R S T h e m e "the c l i m a t e system" A s s e s s m e n t r e p o r t on N R P s u b t h e m e "Atmospheric p r o c e s s e s a n d UV-B R a d i a t i o n " R. Guicherit
155
Short papers within NRP subtheme "Atmospheric processes and UV-B Radiation" Ultraviolet radiation and photochemistry in clouds: observations and modelling J. Vil&-Guerau de Arellano, P.G. Duynkerke and M. van Weele
237
The marine sulfur-cycle: importance of Phaeocystis SP in DMSproduction during a nearshore springbloom J. Stefels, L. Dijkhuizen and W. W.C. Gieskes
241
Clouds-radiation-hydrologic interactions in a limited-area model A.C.A.P. van Lammeren, A.J. Feijt, R. van Dorland, E. van Meijgaard, P. Stammes and A.P. van Ulden
245
The reduction of solar radiation by anthropogenic aerosol in The Netherlands H.M. ten Brink, A. Khlystov, J.P. Veefkind, C. Kruisz and A. Berner
251
Global modelling of atmospheric trace gases: application of a global three dimensional model T.H.P. The, D.L. Veenstra and J.P. Beck
255
vii Spectral ultraviolet radiation measurements and correlation with atmospheric p a r a m e t e r s F. Kuik and H. Kelder
261
Continental ozone issues; monitoring of trace gases, data analysis and modelling of ozone over Europe J.P. Beck, W.A.J. van Pul, P.J.H. Builtjes, M.G.M. Roemer, R. Bosman, P. Esser, M.E.J.P. Vosbeek and W. Ruijgrok
265
K-Gill propeller vane observations for the Cabauw parametrization experiment M. Bottema and J. W. Verkaik
269
Empirical Orthogonal Function (EOF) analysis of ozone variability F.J.M. Alkemade
275
Total ozone trend analysis from the TOMS data R. de Winter-Sorkina
279
A s s e s s m e n t r e p o r t on N R P s u b t h e m e "Oceans a n d the c l i m a t e system" L. Otto
283
Short papers within NRP subtheme "Oceans and the climate system" Global Emiliania Modeling initiative (GEM) P. Westbroek
325
Evaluating the role of the biological pump in the Northeast Atlantic through paleo primary productivity reconstruction J. Ottens, S. van Kreveld, G. Ganssen and J.E. van Hinte
331
Surface water fCO2 in the Equatorial Atlantic ocean D.C.E. Bakker, H.J.W. de Baar and E. de Jong
339
On the importance of surface mixing in an OGCM A. Sterl
343
Oceans and climate: circulation and interbasin exchanges in the Southern ocean W.P.M. de Ruijter, F.H. Walsteijn and R. C.V. Feron
347
Determination of the NE. Atlantic current field with ARGOS drifters L. Otto, H.M. van Aken and R.X. de Koster
357
Repeated XTB sections in the framework of WOCE T.F. de Bruin, L. Otto, S. Ober, R.X. de Koster and H.M. van Aken
361
viii The ASGASEX programme W.A. Oost
365
E1 Nifio and mixed-layer processes M. van Eijk and G. Burgers
369
.Short papers within NRP subtheme "Palaeo climate" Land ice and sea level change J. Oerlemans and L.A. Conrads
375
Stresses in the lithosphere caused by glacial loads P. Johnston and S. Cloetingh
381
The response of permafrost ecosystems to climate change E.A. Koster
385
Short papers within NRP subtheme "Diagnostics of the climate system" Climate change scenarios for impact studies in the Netherlands A.M.G. Klein Tank, T.A. Buishand, J.J. Beersma and G.P. KSnnen
391
Climate scenarios for Great Britain and Europe M. Hulme, E.M. Barrow, O. Brown, D. Conway, T. Jiang, P.D. Jones and C. Turney
397
The Rossby soliton: a robust non-linear structure in the equatorial ocean T.R.F. Feitsrna and H.A. Dijkstra
401
A nonlinear stability analysis of the coupled equatorial oceanatmosphere system P. C.F. van der Vaart
405
Short papers within NRP subtheme , L a n d - atmosphere interactions" Surface fluxes of water vapour, heat, momentum and CO2 over a savannah in Niger: a contribution to HAPEX-SAHEL A. Verhoef, H.A.R. de Bruin and R. Krikke
411
Climate change and deforestation in West Africa: a space-time trend analysis of rainfall series from CSte d'Ivoire and Liberia R.S.A.R. van Rompaey
417
Regionalization and parametrization of exchange processes at the land surface-atmosphere interface P. Kabat, A.J. Dolman, W.G.M. Bastiaanssen, M.J. Ogink-Hendriks and J.A. Elbers
421
ix
Fourier analysis of time series of NOAA-AVHRR NDVI composites to map isogrowth zones M. Menenti, S. Azzali and W. Verhoef
425
Fluxes over non-uniform vegetation: a numerical study C.M.J. Jacobs, J.P. Nieveen and A.F.G. Jacobs
431
Sensible and latent heat flux over natural bog vegetation R.S. Singh, J.P. Nieveen, C.M.J. Jacobs and A.F. G. Jacobs
437
SLIMM-PROJECT H. Vugts, A.F.G. Jacobs and W. Klaassen
441
Exchange processes of a natural bog vegetation; SLIMM measurements J.P. Nieveen, C.M.J. Jacobs and A.F.G. Jacobs
445
T H E M E " G R E E N H O U S E GASES"
A s s e s s m e n t r e p o r t on N R P t h e m e "Greenhouse gases" J.J.M. Berdowski, A.F. Bouwman, W.M. Kieskamp, J. Slanina
453
Discussion on the NRP assessment report "Greenhouses gases" J. Goudriaan (chairman) and A.F. Bouwman (rapporteur)
535
Short papers within NRP subtheme "Carbon dioxide" Modelling of C O 2 exchange between grassland ecosystems and the atmospheric boundary layer B.O.M. Dirks and J. Goudriaan
543
A simplified model for evaluating the response of the climate system to the increase of greenhouse gases including the simulation of the global carbon cycle M. Mazzini and F. Vantaggiatio
547
Carbon relations of Dutch forests G.J. Nabuurs and G.M.J. Mohren
553
Effects of climate change on the decomposition of soil organic matter in a boreal ecosystem P. Verburg and N. van Breemen
557
Soil carbon turnover in subalpine systems and its dependence on climate M. I~eber and I~ Stahr
561
Remote sensing based modelling of the terrestrial carbon cycle of Europe G.W. Heil, J.C.J.H. Aerts, A.M.J.V. van Boxtel, W.P.A. van Deursen, R. Leemans and J.G. van Minnen
567
Short papers within. NRP subtheme "Methane" The integrated CH4 grassland project: aims, coherence and site description R. Segers and A. van Dasselaar
573
Effects of grassland management on the emission of methane from grassland on peat soils A. van Dasselaar and O. Oenema
577
The integrated CH4 grassland project: methane consumption by indigenous grassland microflora H.J. Heipieper and J.A.M. de Bont
581
Methane fluxes from and to a drained grassland on a peat soil: modelling methane production R. Segers and P.A. Leffelaar
587
Quantification of methane emissions in the exploration and production of natural gas and petroleum in The Netherlands H. Oonk and M. Vosbeek
591
Validation of landfill gas formation models H. Oonk and T. Boom
597
Methane emission from the Amsterdam urban area D. Veenhuysen and P. Hofschreuder
603
Soil parameters controlling methane emission from rice paddies H.A.C. Denier van der Gon and N. van Breemen
607
Short papers within NRP subtheme "Nitrous oxide" Testing high resolution nitrous oxide emission estimates against observations using an atmospheric transport model A.F. B o u w m a n and J.A. Taylor
613
Modelling nitrous oxide emission from soils: a tool for exploring emission reduction strategies C.A. Langeveld, P.A. Leffelaar and J. Goudriaan
619
Measurements of the atmospheric emission of N20 from biogenic sources in general and by grassland ecosystems in particular J.H. Duyzer
623
xi Effects of nitrogen fertilization and grazing on the emission of nitrous oxide from grassland G.L. Velthof, A.B. Brader and O. Oenema
627
Modelling the emission of dinitrogen oxide from mown and from grazed grassland J. Bril, H.G.van Faassen and H. Klein Gunnewiek
631
Emission of greenhouse gases from ~wastewater treatment processes J.G. Bruins, H.D. Oostergoo & M.A. Brinkhorst
635
N20 emissions from combustion processes H. Spoelstra
639
Short papers within NRP subtheme "Emission databases" World Inventory of Soil Emission potentials (WISE): geographic quantification of soil factors that control fluxes of greenhouse gases N.H. Batjes and E. M. Bridges
645
Emission Database for Global Atmospheric Research (EDGAR): version 2.0 J.G.J. Olivier, A.F. B o u w m a n and C.W.M. van der Maas
651
Short papers within NRP subtheme "Socio-economic causes" Emissions inventories and options for control R.J. Swart, A.R. van Amstel, G.J. van den Born and C. Kroeze
663
The role of population growth in global CO 2 emissions J.P. van Ypersele and F. Bartiaux
669
VOLUME B THEME '[IMPACTS AND C O N S E Q U E N C E S OF CLIMATE CHANGE" A s s e s s m e n t r e p o r t on N R P s u b t h e m e "Effects o f c l i m a t e c h a n g e on t e r r e s t r i a l ecosystems" S.C. van de Geijn
677
Short papers within NRP subtheme "Effects of climate change on terrestrial ecosystems" Climate change and agricultural productivity 709 A.H.C.M. Schapendonk, P. Dijkstra, M.J.H. Jansen, C.S. Pot, S.C. van de Geijn, A. Visser and J. Rozema Integrating the effects of climate change on terrestrial ecosystems C.G.F. de Kovel and Y.J.O. Wilms
715
xii Selection of bio-indicators to assess the possible landscape ecological effects of climate change R.S. de Groot, P. Ketner and A.H. Ovaa
719
Phenological reactions of Dutch tree species to climate change described by a simulation model of the annual cycle I~ Kramer and G.M.J. Mohren
725
The role of organic soil profiles on water availability in forests: sensitivity analysis M.G. Schaap, W. Bouten and L.C. Kuiper
729
Carbon allocation in mature grass (Lolium perenne) under elevated CO2 at two soil nitrogen levels A. Gorissen, J.H. van Ginkel and H. van de Beek
735
Wheat and maize production in Hungary under doubled atmospheric CO2 concentration M. Hunkdr Zemankovics and ZS. Bacsi
741
Effects of climate change on yield potential of wheat and maize crops in the European Union J. Wolf and C.A. van Diepen
745
Mediterranean soilscapes and climatic change. An overview J.J. Ibd~tez, A. Garcia-Alvarez, J.L. Gonzdlez-Rebollar and A. C. Imeson
751
A mathematical model for predicting the impact of climate changes on Mediterranean plant landscapes J.L. Gonzdlez-Rebollar, A. Garcfa-Alvarez and J.J. Ibd~tez
757
Vulnerability of Mediterranean ecosystems to climatic change, study of soil degradation under different climatological conditions in an altitudinal transect in the south east of Spain C. Boix, A. Calvo, A. Cerdd, A.C. Imeson, M.D. Soriano and I.R. Tiemessen
763
The impact of climatic change and land use on the hydrological response of Mediterranean soils; a study along a climatological gradient in Crete (Greece) C. Boix, A. Calvo, A.C. Imeson, J.M. Schoorl, M.D. Soriano and I.R. Tiemessen
767
Climate change and malaria risk W.J.M. Martens
771
Will malaria return to Europe under the greenhouse effect? W. Takken, J. van de Wege and Th.H. Jetten
775
o . .
Xlll
A s s e s s m e n t report on N R P subtheme ''Impact o f c l i m a t e change on the Wadden Sea" W.J. Wolff
781
Discussion on the NRP assessment report "Impact of climate change on the Wadden Sea" R.S.A.R. van Rompaey
819
Short papers within NRP subtheme "Impact of climate change on the Wadden Sea" Salt marshes and sea level rise: marsh dynamics in relation to accretion processes and accretion enhancement techniques E.J. Houwing and J.H.J. Terwindt
823
The effect of sea level rise on a migratory wader B.J. Ens and J.D. Goss-Custard
827
Winter temperature and reproductive success in shell-fish in the Dutch Wadden Sea P.J.C. Honkoop, J.J. Beukema and D. Kwast
831
A s s e s s m e n t report on N R P subtheme "Impact o f c l i m a t e c h a n g e on regional hydrology" J. Dronkers
835
Short papers within NRP subtheme "Impact of climate change on regional hydrology" Impact of climate change on the discharge of the river Rhine B. Parmet, J. Kwadijk and M. Raak
911
The effects of an increase in CO2 on the hydrology of forests H.J.M. Lankreijer
919
The effect of t e m p e r a t u r e change on soil structure stability J.W.M. van der Drift
923
The impact of climate change on the sedimentation rates on the embanked floodplains in the Netherlands H. Middelkoop
931
The impact of climate change on suspended sediment transport by the river Rhine N.E.M. Asselman
937
Effect of sea-level rise and climate change on groundwater salinity and agro-hydrology in a low coastal region of the Netherlands L.C.P.M. Stuyt, P. Kabat, J. Postma and A.B. Pomper
943
xiv Impacts of changes in climate change and socio-economic factors on land use in the Rhine basin: projections for decade 2040-49 R.P. RStter, F.R. Veeneklaas and C.A. van Diepen
947
Assessment report on N R P subtheme "Effects o f enhanced UV-B r a d i a t i o n " J.C. van der Leun
951
Short papers within NRP subtheme "Effects of enhanced UV-B radiation" Effects of enhanced UV-B radiation on structure and function of phytoplankton communities A. Veen and A. G.J. Buma
993
Impact of enhanced solar I,W-B radiation on plants from terrestrial ecosystems J. Rozema, M. Tosserams and E. Magendans
997
UVB can affect the immune system resulting in decreased resistance to infections and tumors J. Garssen, W. Goettsch, Y. Sonntag, F. de Gruijl and H. van Loveren
1005
T H E M E " S U S T A I N A B L E SOLUTIONS"
Assessment report on N R P subtheme "Energy d e m a n d a n d s u p p l y options to mitigate greenhouse gas emissions" W. C. Turkenburg
1013
Discussion on the NRP asssessment report "Energy demand and supply options to mitigate greenhouse gas emissions" K. Blok
1055
Short papers within NRP subtheme "Energy demand and supply options to mitigate greenhouse gas emissions" Long-term energy and materials strategies for C02 reduction D.J. Gielen, T. Kram, P. Lako and J.R. Ybema
1061
Energy conservation and investment behaviour of firms M. Gillissen and H. Opschoor
1075
Long term energy efficiency improvement J. de Beer, E. Worrell and K. Blok
1081
Energy efficiency improvement in industrial sectors: international comparisons G.J.M. Phylipsen, E. WorreU and K. Blok
1087
XV
Carbon dioxide removal studies in The Netherlands K. Blok
1093
Storage of carbon dioxide in aquifers in the Netherlands L.G.H. van der Meer, R. van der Straaten and J. Grif-fioen
1099
Waste reduction and the structure of the Dutch waste sector P. de Jong and M. Wolsink
1105
Institutional barriers to waste reduction in Finland J. Hukkinen
1109
Energy production on farms - sustainability of energy crops H. van Zeijts
1113
A simple method to estimate regional yields of biomass crops S. Nonhebel, J. Goudriaan and R. Rabbinge
1117
Energy accounting on farms J.A.M. van Bergen
1123
Space for biomass I. Steetskamp, A. Faaij and A. van Wijk
1127
Conversion routes for energy crops; integrating agricultural and environmental opportunities in Europe E.J.M.T. van den Heuvel
1133
Forests and wood consumption on the carbon balance R. Sikkema and G.J. Nabuurs
1137
Potential of controlled anaerobic wastewater treatment in order to reduce the global emissions of methane and carbon dioxide M.J. Lexmond and G. Zeeman
1143
A s s e s s m e n t r e p o r t on "NRP's" s u b t h e m e "Mobility a n d m o t o r i s e d t r a n s p o r t in r e l a t i o n to s u s t a i n a b l e d e v e l o p m e n t " C.A.J. Viek
1147
Discussion on the NRP assessment reports "Mobility and motorised transport in relation to sustainable development" and "Culture, consumption and lifestyles" M.M. Berk
1165
xvi Short papers within NRP subtheme "Mobility and motorised transport in relation to sustainable development" Private car mobility. Problem awareness, willingness to change, and policy evaluation: a national interview study among Dutch car users L. Steg, C. Vlek and T. Rooijers
1173
A behavioral analysis of private car use by households J. Rouwendal, L. van Staalduinen and P. Kooreman
1177
Differences among car user groups regarding CO2 emissions and sensitivity to policy measures P.M. Cavalini, L. Hendrickx and A.J. Rooijers
1181
Choosing a means of transportation: two inquiries into situational and personal determinants of moving behaviour I.M. de Boer, D. van Kreveld and P.G. Swanborn
1185
Changing attitudes and behaviour by means of providing information; a study on private car use G. Tertoolen and E.C.H. Verstraten
1189
Energy and environmental issues as choosing elements for selecting options in the transportation sector aimed at reducing CO2 emissions: on application to the Italian case D. Barbieri, A. Nucara, M. Pietrafesa and G. Rizzo
1193
Comparative analysis of options for sustainable transport and traffic systems in the 21st century P. Nijkamp, S. Rienstra and J. Vleugel
1197
A s s e s s m e n t r e p o r t on N R P s u b t h e m e "Culture, c o n s u m p t i o n a n d lifestyles in r e l a t i o n to s u s t a i n a b l e d e v e l o p m e n t " C.A.J. Vlek
1201
Short papers within NRP subtheme "Culture, consumption and lifestyles in relation to sustainable development" Reduction of C02 emissions by lifestyle changes K. Vringer, H.C. Wilting, W. Biesiot, K. Blok and H.C. Moll
1229
Life styles and domestic energy consumption: a pilot study B. Breemhaar, W. van Gool, P. Ester and C. Midden
1235
SCAN: SCenario ANalysis Analysis of the social significance, acceptability and feasibility of long-term low energy/low CO2 scenarios for The Netherlands K.J. Kamminga, G. Slotegraaf, H.C.J. van der Veen and H.C. Moll
1241
xvii
Toward a morality of increasing moderation W. Aarts, C. Schmidt and F. Spier
1247
Climate Change, living environment and ways of life M. Jiirvelii and M. Wilenius
1251
Welfare and its relation to the environmental question M.A. Mentzel
1255
A s s e s s m e n t r e p o r t on N R P s u b t h e m e "National i n s t r u m e n t s for c l i m a t e c h a n g e policy" H. Verbruggen
1261
Discussion on the NRP assessment report "International and national instruments for climate change policy" B. Geurts
1271
Short papers within NRP subtheme "National instruments for climate change policy" Tradeable carbon permits P.R. Koutstaal
1275
The feasibility of ecological taxation A. T. G. Paulus
1279
Socio-economic aspects of the greenhouse effect: climate fund R.S.J. Tol, T. van der Burg, H.M.A. Jansen and H. Verbruggen
1283
Socio-economic aspects of the greenhouse effect: applied general equilibrium model R. DeUink, F. Groot, H. Jansen and H. Verbruggen
1289
Assessment report on NRP subtheme "International instruments for climate change policy" J.J. C. Bruggink
1293
Short papers within NRP subtheme "International instruments for climate change policy" Tropical forest policies for the global climate W.T. de Groot and E.M. Kamminga
1317
International policies to address the greenhouse effect: encouraging developing country participation in global greenhouse control strategies J. Gupta, R. van de Wurf~, M. HisschenmoUer, G. Junne and P. VeUinga
1323
xviii Practical aspects of Joint Implementation A. Michaelowa
1327
Industrial energy efficiency in developing countries; present situation and scope for new initiatives J.L. de Ara~tjo, S. Barathan, S. Diallo, F.M.J.A. Diepstraten, J.C. Jansen and A.D Kant
1331
Macroeconomic analysis of C O 2 emission limits for China Z.X. Zhang, H. Folmer and P. van Beek
1345
THEME '~NTEGRATION OF CLIMATE CHANGE RESEARCH" A s s e s s m e n t r e p o r t on N R P s u b t h e m e "Risk a n a l y s i s "
1351
W. Biesiot and L. Hendrickx
Discussion on the NRP asssessment report "Risk analysis" W. Biesiot (chairman) and J. van Lenthe (rapporteur)
1363
Short papers within NRP subtheme "Risk analysis" Integrated assessment of the global warming problem, a decisionanalytical approach J. van Lenthe, L. Hendrickx and C.A.J. Vlek
1367
Clouds, aerosols and biogeochemical cycles: risks of non-linear climate change J. van Ham, R.J. van Beers, P.J.H. Builtjes, G.P. KSnnen, J. Oerlemans, M.G.M. Roemer
1371
Socio-economic and policy aspects of changes in incidence and intensity of extreme weather events. Preliminary results C. Dorland, W.J. Maunder, A.A. Olsthoorn, R.S.J. Tol, P.E. van der Werff and P. Vellinga
1377
Probability of climatic change; identification of key questions W. Fransen
1381
The role of fear and threat in communicating risk scenarios and the need for actions: effect of fear on information processing A.L. Meijnders, C.J.H. Midden and H A . M . Wilke
1387
Short papers within NRP subtheme "Integrated modelling" Overview of IMAGE 2.0: An integrated model of climate change and the global environment J. Alcamo et al.
1395
xix IMAGE 2.0: Uncertainty management in integrated modelling, the IMAGE case J.P. van der Sluijs
1401
Linking IMAGE 2.0 and WORLD SCAN G. Gelauff, B. Geurts, A.M. Gielen, A. den Ouden, J. Alcamo and R. Gerlagh
1407
Modelling land use dynamics by integrating biophysical and human dimensions (CLUE) Costa Rica 1973-1984 A. Veldkamp and L.O. Fresco
1413
Short papers on climate change research in Europe presented during the entire conference The Finish research programme on climate change SILMU P. Heikinheimo and M. Kanninen
1419
Climate change research in Bulgaria A. Iotova and E. Koleva
1423
ANNEXES 1.
List of participants
1427
2.
Acronyms
1461
3.
Units
1463
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
T H E M E "IMPACTS A N D C O N S E Q U E N C E S OF C L I M A T E CHANGE"
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Climate Change Research: Evaluation and Policy Implications S. Zwerver, R.S.A.R. van Rompaey, M.T.J. Kok and M.M. Berk, (Eds.) 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
677
A S S E S S M E N T R E P O R T ON N R P SUBTHEME
'rEFFECTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE TERRESTRIAL ECOSYSTEMS"
ON
S.C. van de Geijn DLO-Research Institute for Agrobiology and Soil Fertility, (AB-DLO) P.O.Box 14 6700 AA Wageningen The Netherlands
With contributions by: P. Dijkstra, A. Gorissen, A.H.C.M. Schapendonk K. Kramer, G.M.J. Mohren
AB-DLO, Research Institute for Agrobiology and Soil Fertility, Wageningen IBN-DLO, Institute for Forestry and Nature Research, Wageningen
F. Berendse, Th. Jetten, C. de Kovel, W. Takken
LUW, Agricultural University of Wageningen
H. Lankreijer, A.W.L. Veen
RUG, University of Groningen
W. Bouten, M. Schaap J. Rozema, A.Visser
UvA, University of Amsterdam VUA, Free University Amsterdam
678 Contents Abstract 0
Introduction 1.1 General outline 1.2 Ecosystem interactions 1.3 Types of ecosystems considered 1.4 Ecosystem stability 1.5 Ecosystem evolution and succession P l a n t g r o w t h and carbon allocation in a soil-plant s y s t e m 2.1 Introduction 2.2 Primary production 2.3 Effects on transpiration at the level of stomata and canopy 2.4 Carbon partitioning and soil organic matter dynamics
0
I m p a c t s on forest e c o s y s t e m s 3.1 Introduction 3.2 Growth of Douglas fir trees 3.3 Changes in organic matter profiles and availability of water in forest soils 3.4 Water balance of a forested area 3.5 Phenological reactions of Dutch tree species and frost sensitivity
0
0
0
0
0
8.
Carbon e c o n o m y of grasses 4.1 Introduction 4.2 Primary production 4.3 Water use 4.4 Degradation of organic matter grown in elevated CO2 P h y s i o l o g y and productivity of arable crops 5.1 General 5.2 Basic plant physiological studies 5.3 Effects of the OTC's 5.4 Biomass formation and yield I n t e g r a t i o n of effects of climate c h a n g e on terrestrial e c o s y s t e m s 6.1 Introduction 6.2 The model 6.3 Progress and plans I m p a c t on ecology and distribution of malaria vectors 7.1 Introduction 7.2 Simulation models 7.3 Distribution of the malaria vector 7.4 Concluding remarks Closing remarks
679 9.
References
ABSTRACT In the projects fostered by the NRP the effects of changed climate (atmospheric CO2 concentration, temperature) on different terrestrial ecosystems were studied. For forests it was concluded that the initial stimulation of tree growth in general did not persist after two years, and therefore care must be taken not to overestimate the potential contribution of increased carbon sequestration by forests. On the other hand, shifted patterns of carbon distribution in the tree-soil system may lead to a higher soil organic matter content, which will contribute to an improved soil structure and availability of soil moisture. A sensitivity analysis revealed that, for the poor sandy forest soils, improved rooting depth is however more effective for drought prevention than higher soil organic matter. From the model exercises it was also inferred that with increased precipitation, as predicted u n d er the projected future climate, runoff and recharge of the groundwater will be increased, especially in winter and for deciduous forest stands. Changed seasonal temperatures will change the timing of phenology but will, in Dutch conditions, not lead to a higher risk for spring frost damage in the period of bud burst. However, competition between tree species may change as the duration of the closed and functional canopy is differentially influenced. For instance for Larix and oak the effective growing season is extended, whereas beech and Tilia cordata will have a shortened leaf area duration. Mechanistic forestry production models, adapted to include also the changes in [CO2], (e.g. in a transient climate scenario), showed that after a transient increase in production, a double-CO2 climate from GCM calculations caused a subsequent decline in productivity. A high variability of the growth and production enhancement by rising [CO2] was also detected in the OTC (Open Top Chambers) and Rhizolab experiments for the crop species studied (potato, wheat, faba bean). The physiological parameters (photosynthesis and respiration) and full season canopy and soil gas exchange m e a s u r e m e n t s showed no growth stage or light and t em perat ure dependent CO2-enhancement effect. An analysis using crop growth models produced clues as to the origin of the existing confusion about the v a r i a b i l i t y of the CO2-enhancement factor for biomass production and yield. Using the growth and weather data of different years it could be shown that interactions between growth stage, light and especially temperature in the early growth stages could explain a large p ar t of the variation. Also about half of the differences in growth enhancement between e.g. (winter) wheat (16 - 34%) and faba bean (35 - 56%) could, according to the model outcome, be ascribed to temperature differences in the early (spring) growth stages. An important and for the carbon cycle very significant finding was that the roots of grass, grown at 700 ppm CO2 were degraded much slower by the soil organisms
680 t h a n reference root material. It was shown that this change in properties m a y fully offset the stimulation of the decomposition of soil organic m a t t e r by the projected temperature rise. In a pilot study the potential distribution within Europe of mosquitoes that can act as a vector for malaria transfer was investigated. The combined effects in the various growth stages of the mosquito, as brought together in a simulation model, indeed point to a highly increased risk for infectious individuals. The probability of an epidemic is considered low, as the European health care system is expected to be sufficiently effective in picking up disease incidence. The concept of "infection potential", developed in this project, offers excellent possibilities to quantify risks also for other, more vulnerable, areas or world wide studies. The methodology developed in this project can be used for other (also agricultural) pests and diseases. 1.
INTRODUCTION
1.1 General outline In the Dutch National Research Programme on Global Air Pollution and Climate Change NRP several aspects of the functioning of widely differing t e r r e s t r i a l ecosystems are considered, varying from physiology, development and productivity of agricultural crops, input and turnover of soil organic matter, characteristics of forest soils and impacts on trees, to the risk of changes in d i s t r i b u t i o n of mosquitoes as vectors for the spreading of malaria. A project aiming at the integration of knowledge at the level of semi-natural ecosystems and thereby to estimate the possible disturbance of the natural succession in such systems was only recently started. In this assessment a selection of processes, tools and (sub-)systems is considered, and results are discussed t h a t may contribute to a further development of our understanding. Each of the contributions has a merit in its own right, but its added value is realised by linking to the knowledge base of the international scientific community. After an introduction this report loosely follows the projects within the subtheme "Effects of climate change on terrestrial ecosystems" and discusses the findings in the general context outlined below. 1.2 E c o s y s t e m i n t e r a c t i o n s Terrestrial managed- or n a t u r a l ecosystems are by definition functioning and developing in a p e r m a n e n t interaction with external environmental conditions. During their course of development they loose or acquire minerals and organic matter, and thereby modify their internal regulation of the structure and further characteristics. As such they are never in a condition of a stable equilibrium, but e s s e n t i a l l y in a dynamic and t r a n s i e n t state, moving from one stage of development to another. From this general notion it follows that changes in the environment, be it natural or man-made, may perturb or disrupt the development path, destabilize the system or affect the rate of development. Changes m a y be g r a d u a l and difficult to assess, or sudden and s u b s t a n t i a l when related to
681 instabilities in the system. Transitions to a new quasi-stationary state may be triggered by incidents like storms, droughts, fires or pests. Also socio-economic conditions may be of great influence. Climate change in that respect adds to the environmental factors that determine and change the variability and predictability of ecosystem functioning and stability. Table 1.1 List of projects in the NRP Subtheme "Effects of climate change on terrestrial ecosystems" Title
Project leader
Number
The role of organic matter profiles in the effects of climatic changes on the availability of water in forests
W. Bouten
850010
Phenological reactions of the main Dutch tree species to climate change described by a simulation model of the annual cycle
G.M.J. Mohren 850014
Interactions between atmospheric CO2-concentration, A.H.C.M. temperature and environmental factors with respect Schapendonk to photosynthesis, assimilate distribution and development rhythm of three agricultural crops
850020
Distribution of carbon over plant and soil compartments during the growth of perennial plants under increased CO2 concentrations
A. Gorissen
850029
Potential impact of climatic changes on the ecology and distribution of malaria vectors
W. Takken
851057
Integration of effects of climate change on terrestrial ecosystems
F. Berendse
853126
Effect of an increase of greenhouse gases on the water balance of the forested land surface
A.W.L. Veen
850015
Not only the intrinsic value of (natural) ecosystems to mankind (although poorly defined like beauty, ecosystem function) is relevant to the issue of climate change. Changes in ecosystem composition or activity will inevitably have an impact on the pools and fluxes of water and carbon dioxide in the environment. Such changes also may modify greenhouse gas fluxes (N20, CH4, water), production as well as absorption, may be influenced, as the magnitude of the fluxes varies between ecosystem types and with ecosystem functioning. Moreover, characteristics like surface roughness and albedo are of direct relevance to the climatologists. The information on the impact of climate change on terrestrial ecosystems is therefore
682 also of direct relevance for the estimation of feed-backs in the global climate system (see Theme " The climate system").
1.3 Types of ecosystems considered It may be clear that an assessment of the impacts of climate change on terrestrial ecosystems requires differentiation, depending on the type of system considered. Intensively managed systems like agricultural production systems may require a change in choice of crop type or crop cultivars and a modification of the cropping system, management and market structure. Agricultural systems may also change in productivity and (economic) viability, especially in marginal production areas. Although impacts of climate change on agriculture in the highly developed technologically advanced Western economies possibly can be absorbed without major risk for food security or shortage, the situation on local and regional markets and with respect to international and intercontinental trade and transportation of food and feed may be affected substantially. A more dramatic situation may arise in regions where local economies do not have access to the economical and technological means to counteract or reduce the threats posed by climate change. Food shortage may lead to starvation or trigger the migration of whole populations. Similarly, measures to protect extensively or unmanaged ecosystems or to counteract unintended developments may also require a substantial economic basis. However, to judge the risks for the various ecosystems properly, we have to look primarily for the changes in driving forces determining functioning, growth and production potential of e.g. various plant types, crop species, vegetations and forests. Physiological processes, water relations, soil organic matter dynamics and competitive relationships are altered by elevated atmospheric CO2 concentrations, modified (seasonal) temperatures and precipitation patterns.
1.4 Ecosystem stability At the next higher integration level from physiological processes in plants and soil, the impact at the level of ecosystem processes should also be taken into account. Forests and semi-natural ecosystems have to be considered as being largely dependent on their internal coherence and consequent resilience to perturbations. As stated, climate change as such is superimposed on top of the existing natural and manmade environmental changes, be it variability or trendwise developments. A proper estimation of the impact therefore requires a complete and coherent picture at a system level and a quantitative description of the selected systems in their present state, their dominant processes and relationships. The projects on plant- and crop physiology, soil science and soil organic matter dynamics find their application in estimating agricultural and forest productivity, ecosystem functioning and hydrological relationships. Another basis for the estimation of changes in forest ecosystem development is provided by the study of tree phenology in a changed climate.
683
1.5 E c o s y s t e m e v o l u t i o n and s u c c e s s i o n Apart from short term changes and risks, a long term perturbation may happen. Pools and fluxes of carbon and mineral nutrients in nutrient poor systems largely determine the dynamics of vegetation succession. The understanding of the effect of climate change on such ecosystem processes, or ecosystem physiology, is r e q u i r e d to e s t i m a t e the i n t e g r a t e d effect on the stability or the r a t e of development. A s e p a r a t e study has addressed the potential change in the distribution of the mosquitoes t h a t can act as a vector for malaria. Interpretation of results of the population ecology and other ecological interactions still has to be combined with socio-economic scenarios to estimate the relevance in terms of health risks. As such this type of studies clearly shows the complexity of long-term interactions and the need for caution when interpreting the outcome of sectorial and specialised studies. 2.
PLANT G R O W T H AND CARBON ALLOCATION IN A S O I L - P L k N T SYSTEM
2.1 I n t r o d u c t i o n P r i m a r y photosynthesis globally takes up as much as 60 - 70 Pg carbon per a n n u m . In addition the oceans have a yearly exchange of the same order of magnitude. Above ground standing biomass is estimated to contain about 500 Pg C, whereas the atmosphere contains about 700 Pg C. These n u m b e r s compare with a yearly emission of 6 Pg C from fossil fuel burning. It m e a n s t h a t the equivalent of the total carbon content of the standing biomass is t u r n e d over by these processes every 8 - 10 years, and of the atmosphere every 6 - 7 years. The total carbon storage in soil organic m a t t e r amounts to approximately 1500 Pg C, of which about half is almost inert. Residence times in various compartments of soil organic m a t t e r m a y range from very short (days to weeks) to extremely long (thousands of years). At the estimated input into the soil the m e a n turnover time in the active part would be of the order of 30-50 years, but this n u m b e r has only limited value, given the range of residence times. Although the dimensions of these numbers give a fair idea about the magnitude of the interactions, the net fluxes are much smaller. Most ecosystems are in a type of steady state, where m e a n losses of carbon by respiration and decay of organic m a t t e r are roughly in equilibrium with C-gains through photosynthesis or other inputs. Even small changes in the balance between C-fixation and release from the storage pools of a system may however have i m p o r t a n t consequences for the long-year cumulative outcome. Especially the pools in the soil t h a t have long residence times are of interest. Pools and fluxes differ between various ecosystems, and depend on activity and structure of communities. Inputs consist of litter accumulating on the soil surface and in the surface layers and of root material derived from living and dead root systems.
684
2.2 P r i m a r y p r o d u c t i o n The changed composition of the atmosphere will have a direct effect on plant processes. The most significant impact will be on photosynthesis. As carbon dioxide is the p r i m a r y s u b s t r a t e for the p h o t o s y n t h e t i c process a r i s i n g concentration in general will enhance the production of assimilates, although not proportional. This is true for plants with the so-called ca pathway, where the concentration of carbon dioxide at the site of photosynthesis inside the leaf at present ambient concentrations is limiting. The enhancement is small or absent for C4 plants. At present most plant species in t e m p e r a t e areas have a c a p a t h w a y , whereas C4 plants are predominantly found in w a r m e r climates and tropical areas. For the Dutch and West-European situation the most prominent exception to the general dominance of ca plants is maize. 2.3 Effects on transpiration at the level of stomata and c a n o p y E l e v a t e d levels of CO2 not only enhance the supply of CO2 as s u b s t r a t e for photosynthesis, but also modify the gas exchange properties of leaves in a canopy in a different way. The opening status of the stomates is a compromise between water loss and uptake of CO2 from air. The increased levels of carbon dioxide cause a partial closure of stomates, and consequently reduce water loss by transpiration. This is also reflected at a leaf level (30 - 60% lower water loss). However, results at a canopy level are not always clear as m a n y other processes interfere. Because of a r e d u c e d t r a n s p i r a t i o n the e v a p o r a t i v e cooling is reduced, a n d canopy t e m p e r a t u r e s rise. Also, the growth e n h a n c e m e n t by elevated CO2 leads to a larger standing biomass, and an increased evaporating surface. As a result various outcomes are possible, and very much depend on periods of water shortage and the timing thereof. 2.4 Carbon partitioning and soil organic matter d y n a m i c s An increased uptake of CO2 by the plant biomass may result in a changed supply of root derived products to the soil microbial biomass. The proper quantification of the g r a d u a l changes in pools and fluxes of soil organic carbon requires special techniques, as only minor changes may occur, t h a t can accumulate however to significant levels over the years. Q u a n t i t a t i v e l y , up to 40% of the gross a m o u n t of carbon assimilated in the photosynthetic process is allocated directly to the root system and rhizosphere during the season. Root respiration and breakdown of easily decomposable organic compounds in the root rhizosphere r e t u r n the carbon almost i n s t a n t l y as CO2. Also p a r t of the biomass built from assimilates produced by photosynthesis is r e t u r n e d in a r a t h e r short cycle. In forest systems e.g. the equivalent of the complete fine root system is t u r n e d over within one y e a r (Olsthoorn 1991, Olsthoorn & T i k t a k 1991). With m a n y annual species of arable crops the full non-harvested biomass is r e t u r n e d as crop residue, and together with the root mass (2 to 4 tons of dry m a t t e r per ha), is subject to decay. Up to 60% is easily decomposable, and returns within one year to the atmosphere as CO2. P a r t of the r e m a i n i n g material is more resistant to degradation, or is converted into partly humified m a t e r i a l by soil organisms, thereby entering the pool with longer residence times in the soil.
685 It is of great importance to assess the direction and magnitude of changes in the different types of pool sizes and fluxes as a consequence of changed atmospheric CO2 concentrations and induced by a change in the climate (temperature, moisture). Such changes may be triggered not only through a direct effect on primary productivity, but also through changes in the quality (composition) of the plant material. This quality, reflected e.g. in carbon to nitrogen ratio (C/N) or lignin content of the material, determines the degree of resistance to decomposition by soil fauna and flora (meso-fauna, bacteria, fungi). The quality of the plant material is also of importance for animals (herbivorous macro-fauna) feeding on the plants. The relationship is even more intricate, as the below-ground processes like mineralization re-supply plants with mineral nutrients, thereby closing the nutrient cycle. These pools and fluxes determine to a large extent the productivity and the composition of the vegetation. The complex interactions with moisture, temperature and mineral nutrient availability require a cautious and multi-faceted approach. 3.
I M P A C T S ON F O R E S T E C O S Y S T E M S
3.1 I n t r o d u c t i o n Because of the importance of forest ecosystems a major question in the framework of climate change research within the NRP has been the estimation of the sensitivity of these systems. This applies to growth of individual trees, species composition and stability of the forest ecosystem.
Climate change may affect forests in a complex way (Figure 3.1). Both direct and indirect effects can be envisaged. As stated above, rising CO2 concentrations will enhance primary production while simultaneously improving water use efficiency. Moreover, rising temperatures may alter phenological development and changing precipitation patterns will also affect growth and hydrological relations. Changes in growth strategy may affect carbon allocation and litter production and distribution as well as litter quality, resulting in modifications of the soil organic matter content, quality and distribution over the soil profile. It is virtually impossible to create a comprehensive picture of all interactions and processes, and answer in general terms to the questions at hand. Therefore efforts have been concentrated on some major issues. In the sub-theme "Effects of climate change on terrestrial ecosystems" following aspects of impacts on forests have been specifically studied: * Douglas fir growth and organic matter dynamics: productivity, quality, conversion rates and pools of organic matter; * hydrological aspects of changes in organic matter content in forest floors; * atmospheric exchange and hydrological relations for a forested land surface; * Phenological development and forest productivity.
686
CLIMATIC
Soil ~ 0rg.
Water/
CHANGE Figure 3.1 Schematic interactions between climate change and forest characteristics
3.2 G r o w t h of D o u g l a s fir trees
P r o d u c t i v i t y a n d carbon allocation To contribute to an improved interpretation of the highly variable results reported in l i t e r a t u r e concerning persistence of the e n h a n c e m e n t of photosynthesis, Douglas fir trees Pseudotsuga menziesii were grown at ambient and elevated (double present) CO2 concentrations. The long term growth enhancement and the partitioning and utilisation of assimilates was followed in time. Using special equipment allowing periodic labelling of the atmosphere with 14CO2 at different CO2 concentrations short t e r m fluxes from the plant to the root and root r h i z o s p h e r e were studied. The hypothesis was tested t h a t the s u p p l y of a s s i m i l a t e s to the root and root environment is stimulated at elevated CO2 concentrations. To ascertain t h a t the effects studied were not (only) t r a n s i e n t p h e n o m e n a , trees and grasses were p r e - t r e a t e d for 14 m o n t h s at the two experimental CO2 concentrations. Subsequently, the plants were exposed for a 4-week period to the 14C-CO2 labelled atmosphere, to trace the fluxes of assimilates. In the experiments with Douglas fir the initial CO2 uptake, expressed in biomass gain was stimulated by about 25%, but this stimulation fell to lower levels with time. Exposure to elevated CO2 for 14 months resulted in 12% more needle biomass and 16% more roots. Root biomass gain is therefore stimulated more t h a n t h a t of branches or needles. Three year old trees appear to have a relatively higher root biomass gain than four year old trees. However, d u r i n g the 4 weeks of exposure to a 14C-labelled a t m o s p h e r e , m e a s u r e m e n t s showed t h a t the total CO2 uptake of the trees p r e - t r e a t e d and
687 treated at 700 ppm was higher than that at 350 ppm, but t h a t the stimulation of photosynthesis of trees pre-treated at 350 ppm exposed to 700 ppm during the m e a s u r e m e n t was higher. This was true in both absolute uptake and the more so w h e n expressed per unit needle biomass. When expressed in this w a y the photosynthesis was reduced by 14% after a p r e t r e a t m e n t at 700 ppm CO2. The reduced photosynthetic activity per unit needle biomass is also found w h e n switching trees from 700 to 350 ppm. Such changes m a y have i m p o r t a n t consequences for the potential for carbon storage to be expected in forests. Q u a n t i t a t i v e conclusions have to wait for the results of additional studies and integration thereof.
Soil a n d root respiration In the high-CO2 t r e a t m e n t at both age classes a higher specific activity was m e a s u r e d in the respiration fluxes from the soil compartment. This m a y be explained postulating t h a t the soil and rhizosphere organisms in this situation have a preference for the (increased) direct supply of energy rich assimilates from the roots, as compared to the older non-labelled organic material in the soil. It would also m e a n t h a t the microbial biomass and the organic m a t t e r fraction involved in this rapid turnover is not subjected to effects of changes in C/N ratios in the material, or lack of mineral nutrients due to enhanced growth of the trees. W a t e r use a t e l e v a t e d C02 Cumulative w a t e r use is changed hardly or not at all, but is lower per unit needle biomass (14-16% lower). Water used for the production of a unit new biomass is also reduced (32% lower). Consequently in unchanged precipitation conditions more biomass can be formed and supported in situations where w a t e r poses a serious limitation, or otherwise more water is becoming available to recharge groundwater reserves or contribute to run-off and surface water storage. Coneluding remarks The general picture can be summarised concluding that initial growth stimulation of Douglas firs does not persist over longer periods. The larger biomass built up initially does not result in a continued higher specific growth rate. It is not realistic to assume t h a t the larger biomass would require proportionally more energy for maintenance, or t h a t tree architecture would lead to a substantial reduction in light interception per unit needle biomass. The latter fact may be at the basis of the high variability of the growth enhancement factor often reported for seedlings in small scale and short duration experiments. From the detailed results of the present experiments it has been concluded t h a t a limited sink strength of the root system, as proposed in literature, does not play a role. A similar conclusion was also drawn from experiments with crop plants (see Section 5.2). Physiological and morphological adaptations and effects of changes in the nutrient requirements and n u t r i e n t availability have not been considered here, but may have consequences t h a t modify p r e s e n t results, but are difficult to assess systematically.
688
3.3 Changes in organic matter profiles and availability of w a t e r in forest soils Introduction Because of the importance of forest ecosystems a major question in the framework of climate change research is the estimation of the sensitivity of these systems. This applies to growth of individual trees, species composition and stability of the forest ecosystem. The question arises also what would be consequences of changes in content and type of soil organic matter due to changed growth characteristics and biomass quality of the trees and of altered organic matter decay rates under climate change (temperature, moisture). The above discussed potential changes in soil organic matter (Section 2.4) therefore are not only relevant for the global carbon cycle and an improved estimation of the projected changes in carbon storage in terrestrial ecosystems. The organic matter in (forest) soils is also very important for the general soil characteristics, especially for structural properties, fertility and water holding capacity. In other words, changes in the amount and quality of the organic matter deposited on and in the soil have an effect on the quality of the soil for various uses. Higher organic matter content will lead to better hydrological properties. Depending on the soil type (particle size and size distribution) the effective water storage capacity e.g. is increased. This is especially true for sandy soils with a deep water table, where most of the Dutch forests are located. For most of these forest soils, where the organic matter content is below 2 to 3% the effect of increases in organic matter can be substantial. Organic matter also lowers the bulk density, and enhances possibilities for deep penetration of roots. Again, this helps to supply trees with water in dry periods.
Role o f organic m a t t e r in sandy forest soils The organic matter in forest soils is distributed over the profile, and varies in properties from barely decomposed leaf litter and branches, decaying roots and partly decomposed material on and in the forest floor to roots and partly or completely humified organic matter in the mineral soil. Soil organic matter influences forest hydrology by affecting evaporation from the forest floor, but also by enhancing soil water retention in the root zone. For most conditions on Dutch sandy soils with a deep water table, the amount of required water for evapotranspiration (ca. 400 mm/year) is not available from storage plus summer precipitation, although the year-total of precipitation may be around 800 mm. This water shortage periodically leads to water stress and thus limited growth. The present project aimed at combining the general understanding of soil physical properties and collecting data in such a way as to allow the evaluation of the sensitivity of the forest hydrological system to climate change. The evaluation itself is not part of this project.
689 From the soil physical characterisation of a range (8 types) of forest soil profiles q u a n t i t a t i v e r e l a t i o n s have been derived t h a t allow a classification a n d quantitative description of most Dutch sandy soils. Organic m a t t e r lowers the bulk density, and thereby enhances the development of soil structure and its stability. As a consequence the shape of the water retention curve is changed. Dependent on the soil particle characteristics the effective water storage capacity is increased. The effect is stronger for former drift sand soils with uniform particle size distributions t h a n in soils with a non-uniform distribution. This difference is brought about by a better pore size distribution in the latter. For mineral soils with organic m a t t e r content below 2 or 3 volume percent the effect is substantial. An additional effect of soil organic matter is its influence on soil wetting and drying characteristics: the hysteresis gap becomes larger with higher soil organic m a t t e r content. The consequences for water availability of this phenomenon still have to be evaluated.
Forest floor evaporation Direct evaporation from the forest floor can constitute a substantial fraction of the available water. Contrary to expectations, the formation of a dry top layer of the organic forest floor does not limit evaporation losses. Apparently the low-density organic material forming the forest floor acts as a (dense and inverted) canopy, where evaporation takes place at all depths. Moreover water movement from the mineral soil to the organic cover by capillary rise can not be neglected. The thickness of the forest floor is found to be an important factor for forest floor hydrology. The supply of w a t e r down to the mineral soil does not depend on the drainage rate of the forest floor, probably because of the widely diverging time constants. The e s t i m a t e d evaporation in a dense Douglas fir forest was 85 mm/y, but is expected to be higher in more open forests where both mean radiation level and wind speed at soil level may be higher. Water availability for evapotranspiration depends not only on water storage, rainfall and retention characteristics (3.2), but also on rooting patterns and root growth strategies. An evaluation of the results in an extended and coupled version of a model for forest hydrology (FORHYD) indicated that the sensitivity of forests for differences in w a t e r availability caused by organic m a t t e r dynamics is small. Probably trees mostly escape conditions of water shortage by extending roots to greater depths. However, also here organic m a t t e r makes a positive contribution, as root growth is enhanced by a lower soil bulk density down the profile. Ongoing sensitivity analysis, still to be completed, concerning forest floor hydrological dynamics related to future climate scenarios will help to estimate better impacts on forests.
690 Rainfall 750 m m / y
Transpiration
:~.I'~!:~200
- 400 m m / y
....: ,,~ ~:~,
Interception 100-350 m m / y
Evaporation ;0 - 150 m m / y
Storage 50 - 300 mm Drainage 50 - 200 m m / y
Figure 3.2 Generalised forest hydrological cycle for the Dutch situation
3.4 W a t e r b a l a n c e
of a forested area
The w a t e r balance of a forested a r e a very m u c h depends on the s t r u c t u r e of a forest, forest canopy and the availability of soil water. A study at a l a r g e r spatial scale was also conducted, using a one dimensional computer simulation model. The results are primarily reported in the sub-theme "Regional Hydrology". F o r t h e s t u d y at a l a r g e r s p a t i a l scale a physiologically b a s e d model w a s i n c o r p o r a t e d to e v a l u a t e the direct effect of elevated CO2 c o n c e n t r a t i o n s on photosynthesis, s t o m a t a l conductance and w a t e r use. To e v a l u a t e the i m p a c t of a climate change, a sensitivity analysis and a climate scenario according to the KNMI-2 scenario (with a relatively strong increase in precipitation, especially in winter) were applied. In a g r e e m e n t w i t h the r e s u l t s from other studies in this subtheme, a low increase of productivity was applied by i n c r e a s i n g t h e leaf a r e a index by 5%. The r e s u l t s show a s e n s i t i v i t y to t h e availability of soil water. Total seasonal w a t e r use of forests m a y change relative to p r e s e n t conditions w i t h b e t w e e n -20% and +10%. Forests suffering w a t e r l i m i t a t i o n show an increase in w a t e r consumption. This m a y even be s t r o n g e r w h e n soil w a t e r storage is increased as concluded by the s t u d y on soil organic m a t t e r . Forests with no w a t e r limitation consume less w a t e r in a changed climate. In general w a t e r shortage is reduced, and more of the excess w a t e r in the w i n t e r period is available to recharge the groundwater.
691
3.5 P h e n o l o g i c a l r e a c t i o n s of D u t c h tree s p e c i e s in r e l a t i o n to frost sensitivity, growing season and primary productivity Introduction Trees are suggested to be in particular vulnerable to climate change because of their long life span and the period of several decades to reach the reproductive stage. Genetic adaptation is therefore too slow and much depends on the plasticity of i n d i v i d u a l trees and tree species to respond physiologically a n d / o r morphologically to changed local conditions. Important phenomena in the annual life-cycle of deciduous trees are bud burst and leaf area development, and the date of leaf fall or preceding senescence. To study the sensitivity to climate of these events for different species, data were collected and used to develop a phenological model. A differential response of trees of different species will not only have a direct effect, but may also, or even more importantly, result in changed competitive relations in a mixed stand. This aspect would need further attention as a follow-up of the present study, which has been concentrated on phenology and productivity changes of individual species.
A n n u a l life-cycle o f deciduous trees Important phenomena in the annual life-cycle of deciduous trees are the moment of bud burst and leaf area development, and the date of leaf fall or preceding senescence. These define the physiologically active period, where light intercepted by the foliage is converted into biomass. This period is for deciduous trees also coinciding with a high water demand. The timing of leaf unfolding is mainly regulated by temperature. For temperate tree species chilling and forcing temperatures are both required to induce leaf unfolding. In other words, a minimum low-temperature exposure and a m i n i m u m h i g h - t e m p e r a t u r e exposure are both required. It is not a priori clear w h e t h e r w a r m e r winters will advance or delay the date of leaf unfolding: the chilling requirement may be attained later, while the critical t e m p e r a t u r e sum for leaf unfolding is likely to be reached earlier in spring. Such shifts m a y have consequences for the occurrence of frost damage. To test the sensitivity of the timing of bud burst to climate several types of models were developed or improved and tested.
Phenology models The phenology models were calibrated and tested using long-year records of phenological development of beech Fagus sylvaticus in the N e t h e r l a n d s and adjacent parts of Germany. Additional data sets of 13 other species but with a shorter record were obtained from phenological gardens in Europe. The models with the best prediction (modified "sequential" and "alternating" model) were used to test the probability of spring frost damage in the bud burst period under various climate change scenarios. Results were compared with similar studies in the UK and Finland.
692
Bud burst and frost damage Based on an analysis of tree clones transferred over Europe, it is argued t h a t the survival of trees is curtailed by spring frosts, and t h u s t h a t the lowest t e m p e r a t u r e occurring around leaf unfolding may be a sensitive indication for the geographical distribution of species. Furthermore it is found that trees possess a considerable plasticity, which enables them to accommodate by phenological adaptation a significant change in climate. With respect to climate warming, in general the probability of frost damage is predicted to be reduced in Dutch, German and UK conditions, for the scenarios and models used (temperature rise uniform throughout the season or temperature rise season dependent). In Finnish conditions however probability of frost damage is found to be increasing. This disparity is due to local climatic conditions, causing predicted bud burst in Finland to be advanced much more than at the other locations. The response of bud break of the earlier tree species to temperature is higher t h a n of those which unfold their leaves in the first weeks of May. This enhanced separation in timing may have consequences for the competitive relationships, as competition for light in early spring is changed.
Length of the growing season As stated, not only bud break but also date of leaf fall is of high significance in tree species performance. Some species (Larix decidua, Quercus robur) are found to end up with a shortened growing season, while others (Fagus sylvatica, Tilia cordata) extend it at higher temperatures as a result of an earlier leaf unfolding without concomitant early leaf fall. Such effects may also have consequences for the competitive relationships.
P r i m a r y productivity models Using a mechanistic model, the combined effect of elevated atmospheric C02, temperature and water shortage was explored for Norway spruce. Results showed t h a t the CO2 response is enhanced in conditions of water shortage. This is due to the fact t h a t water shortage is partly alleviated by the effect of CO2 on stomatal closure. Similarly, the larger increase of respiration of the standing biomass with rising t e m p e r a t u r e s as compared to photosynthesis results in a reduced productivity of cool t e m p e r a t e species when temperatures increase. (6% resp. 2% for potential growth, but 14% resp. 6% in water limited conditions at 350 and 700 ppm CO2 respectively). Climate change scenarios were used to evaluate the sensitivity of three tree species (birch, beech and oak) as predicted by process-based tree growth models. Modified current weather data as well as synthetic weather data, modified using GCM output, were used. A transient climate scenario was constructed using a 100 year r a m p to the 2 x CO2 temperature level (mean GCM outcome). Rainfall was
693 modified according to temperature relations, keeping the number of rainy days constant. In these conditions forest productivity was found to increase initially in the transient scenarios, but was reduced at the 2 x CO2 level, because of an increasing negative effect of temperature on productivity (Figure 3.3).
Net Primary Production 15
B. pubescens
F. sylvatica
Q. robur
o~,~,,.,, v--? QFDL
,!-.-
'~,10
'7"
N5
!
I transient I 2 x CO 2
OI86
NN
OSU
UKMO
transient 2 x CO 2
I transient I 2 x CO 2
Figure 3.3 Model prediction of productivity of birch, beech and oak forest under various (GCM-)climate change scenarios
Concluding remarks Primary productivity models, largely based on correlative relationships, can be used to estimate forest ecosystem productivity in present conditions. More complex mechanistic models of forest growth may also be used to explore the range of effects of climate change on biomass production and carbon storage to be expected. Validation of such models is only partly possible as very few time series of sufficiently detailed forest growth data have been collected. Such more physiological models are however extremely useful tools to explore the possible outcome of the complex reaction of a forest ecosystem to atmospheric [C02] and temperature changes. Basic relations derived in this way may subsequently be simplified in summary functions and included in primary production models like the model FORGRO. Some points should be taken into consideration with respect to these findings. The outcome of these physiological-based models should be interpreted cautiously. A serious drawback is t hat data to calibrate and validate the forest productivity models are very scarce. Moreover, dry matter partitioning, nutrient relationships and water use are only incorporated in a descriptive way, and the quantitative relationships may itself be modified by climatic conditions. The impact of temperature on respiration is important when considering long-term effects. Temperatures could deviate considerably from present patterns. It is however still unclear if the short term response of respiration to higher temperature, as used in the model, is also applicable after long-term exposure to higher temperatures. The sensitivity determined in short term experiments
694 amounts to about 7% per ~ and therefore lower values, (e.g. 3% as suggested by Gifford, 1994) might change the picture importantly. Nevertheless the model exercise and literature study has revealed t h a t i m p o r t a n t changes in forest ecosystem productivity may occur, although the probability of spring frost damage (in Dutch and UK conditions) is decreased.
4.
C A R B O N ECONOMY OF G R A S S E S
4.1 I n t r o d u c t i o n Grasslands dominate an important part of the terrestrial ecosystems, and do play an important role in carbon storage, in some respects with a potential comparable to forests (Goudriaan 1993a, b; Fischer et al, 1994). Especially the below-ground storage of carbon is quantitatively of great importance. Experiments similar in setup to t h a t with Douglas fir (Section 3.2) were also done with different species of grasses (Lolium perenne and Festuca arundinacea). In these experiments the effect of nitrogen supply was studied using two rates of fertiliser application. Plants were grown in a pretreatment for 14 months at 350 resp. 700 ppm CO2 in a greenhouse. After acclimation in a special growth cabinet groups of plants were exposed for 24 hours to a 14C-C02 labelled atmosphere. During the 24 hour t r e a t m e n t and the succeeding 3 weeks of the experiment the plants were hermetically sealed at the base, to allow the determination of (combined) root and soil respiration separate from CO2 exchange of the plant tops. Carbon dioxide produced in the soil c o m p a r t m e n t was trapped in sodium hydroxide, and both absolute a m o u n t and specific activity were determined. This allowed the separation of the contribution of different sources of carbon: respiration of labelled recent assimilates from the root and associated soil biomass, and combined non-labelled material from the root and from native soil organic matter. 4.2 P r i m a r y p r o d u c t i o n Elevated C02 does stimulate the growth of grasses, but similar to what was found with Douglas fir, the effect is falling over the period of a prolonged exposure. The initial growth enhancement was about 25%, but it dropped to about 16% over a period of 66 weeks. At the final harvest yield differences were almost absent. Both grass species behaved similarly, although the yield response of F. arundinacea was somewhat higher. As the effect was similar at both nitrogen levels (135 and 400 kg N/ha) N-limitation as a cause for the falling growth enhancement does not seem likely. At the highest N - t r e a t m e n t root biomass at final harvest was still strongly stimulated by CO2, in contrast to the low-N application, where CO2-enhancement of both root and shoot growth disappeared over time. The 14C label was used to discriminate between biomass g r o w t h d u r i n g pretreatment, and during and after the labelling period. The results show that most of the larger root systems of the 700 ppm-400 kgN-plants had been formed prior to the labelling. However, as the labelling took place in September an interaction with the season can not be excluded. The analysis of the respiration data showed t h a t
695 the percent distribution of assimilates over the compartments did not change with CO2 concentration. The higher application of N-fertilisers however reduced root respiration with 29%. Also the percent 14C in the microbial biomass dropped (from 2 to 1% at 350 ppm CO2). Also at 700 ppm CO2 the 14C labelled fraction dropped (by 20%). Residual labelled organic material increased by about 100% in the 700 ppm treatment. 4.3 W a t e r u s e The p r e t r e a t m e n t had an effect on the w a t e r use t h a t persisted during the t r e a t m e n t . Grass grown at 700 ppm CO2 used less water: both total (-16%) and per unit leaf mass (-25%) when exposed to 350 ppm CO2. At 700 ppm CO2 the w a t e r use was reduced by as much as 35%, independent of p r e t r e a t m e n t . F. a r u n d i n a c e a was more sensitive, reducing water loss per unit leaf area with 47%, compared to 21% for L. perenne. A first extrapolation could be t h a t F. a r u n d i n a c e a is capable of taking better advantage of the conditions with higher CO2 and the more so during periods of water stress. 4.4 D e g r a d a t i o n of o r g a n i c m a t t e r g r o w n in e l e v a t e d CO2 The above discussed experimental results are obtained with organic m a t t e r derived from plants while growing in ambient or double-present CO2 concentrations. The carbon sequestered or released is newly fixed, and only within growing season effects are considered. This might give results t h a t differ in some respects from a normal, more representative growing cycle, where plant residues are left behind at the end of a growth cycle. To test the effects of potential differences in quality of the plant material grown at both CO2 concentrations, the rate of decay of such material has been analysed. The 14C-labelled plant material therefore has been incorporated into the soil to determine the effect of changes in the composition (quality) of the m a t e r i a l caused by growth conditions at elevated CO2. Two t e m p e r a t u r e s (14 and 20oC) and soil moisture levels were used. Roots were t a k e n from L o l i u m p e r e n n e grown and uniformly labelled with 14C for 4 weeks. The different growing conditions were clearly reflected in the C/N ratio. Roots of L. p e r e n n e grown at 700 ppm CO2 had a C/N ratio of 32, whereas for the control plants C/N was 18.
The total production of C02 at 2 ~ consistently exceeded t h a t at 14 ~ accumulating to 30% difference after 64 days. Root derived respiration increased by 26%. The two levels of soil moisture imposed in the e x p e r i m e n t s had no significant effect. The decomposition of roots grown at 700 ppm CO2 was accelerated during the first two days, but the r a t e decreased m a r k e d l y after 8 days. At the end of the incubation high-CO2 roots had released 24% less 14C-CO2. The decomposition of the high C02 roots at 20 ~ essentially paralleled t h a t of 350ppm root material at 14 ~ The rate of decomposition of the root material had no effect on the decomposition of the native soil-organic matter.
696 These results show that the change in quality of the plant material as shown here, can h a m p e r decomposition, and possibly partly negate or even a n n u l the accelerating effect of a temperature rise as induced by greenhouse gases. 5.
P H Y S I O L O G Y AND P R O D U C T I V I T Y OF ARABLE C R O P S
5.1 General Introduction The persistence of the growth enhancement of plants at elevated concentrations of atmospheric CO2 is still under debate. Although mechanisms have been studied and clarified, the transient nature of the growth enhancement and the variable nature are much less understood. Part of the problems in the experimental studies can be related to experimental conditions, where growth environments have to be created to allow controlled exposure to elevated CO2 concentrations. In such e n v i r o n m e n t s plant characteristics m a y be modified, leading to c h a n g e d sensitivity. One aim of the experimental work therefore was to determine the changes in growth characteristics and yield of crop plants in near-field conditions. Therefore three selected arable crops were exposed during the entire growing season to ambient and double-present CO2 concentrations in OTC's (Open Top Chambers). The research was aimed at answering such questions as the nature of species differences and seasonal variations in plant, crop and vegetation response to climate change conditions ([CO2], temperature). Detailed studies of source-sink relations, daily and seasonal variations in assimilation, assimilate distribution and total biomass production have been done. The more detailed studies with individual plants and different growth stages and growing conditions were used to support the seasonal studies. The results of the experiments were combined and mechanistic simulation models were used to evaluate the various findings and extrapolations.
S e l e c t e d crop species and e x p e r i m e n t a l facilities Rising CO2 concentrations enhance photosynthesis and thereby the availability of assimilates for various plant processes. Three crop types differing in assimilate utilisation were selected: * wheat was selected as small grain crop, being a type of "reference crop" used in much of the international climate change research; * faba beans can develop a symbiosis with nitrogen fixing bacteria which convert atmospheric nitrogen to a plant-available form. To s u s t a i n this process the plants have to supply the bacteria in the root nodules with energy in the form of carbohydrates. As such the nitrogen fixation is a drain on the assimilates of the plant; * potato plants can be characterised as strong starch accumulators during tuber bulking, and were expected to profit specifically from the enhanced assimilate availability. The effects of elevated [CO2] were studied experimentally in Open Top Chambers, greenhouses and a Rhizolab facility.
697
5.2 Basic plant p h y s i o l o g i c a l studies P o t size To elucidate some aspects of the effect of smaller pot sizes as reported in literature, special tests were set up aiming specifically to avoid shortage of minerals and water. Although for winter wheat a strong reduction in growth was seen for smaller pot sizes (range used: 0.8 to 10L), CO2-enhancement of growth was not affected. In experiments with faba bean results were more variable, but the general conclusion is t h a t at optimal supply of water and nutrients pot size effects can be avoided. I n t e r a c t i o n w i t h UV-B Special attention was given to the effect of the presence of UV-B in the solar radiation reaching the plants. To this end OTC's were constructed from special material t r a n s m i t t i n g UV-B. Results point to an interaction between UV-B and CO2. Also some effects on plant morphology were detected. Assimilate distribution and photosynthesis In the detailed experiments the distribution of sugars over various parts of wheat plants was studied. No differences could be detected in assimilate and nitrogen distribution, apart from an increased carbohydrate content in the wheat leaves in March. Crop a r c h i t e c t u r e was also u n c h a n g e d . Detailed p h o t o s y n t h e s i s m e a s u r e m e n t s at the leaf level with wheat and faba beans grown in OTC's and greenhouses as used in Amsterdam (and Wageningen at the canopy level) did not show the occurrence of photosynthetic acclimation.
5.3 Effects of t h e OTC's The temperature inside Open Top Chambers is higher than in open field conditions, a l t h o u g h this varies over the day. These higher t e m p e r a t u r e s do have an accelerating effect on plant development, and in general lead to an earlier harvest (about 2 weeks earlier for wheat). The chamber effect on biomass production is however very much influenced by the weather conditions of the specific season. For instance early (or late) high temperatures or drought will affect the crop inside the chamber in a different way, as the development stage or standing biomass is different. For wheat this resulted in 1993 in a clear chamber effect for both winter wheat and faba bean, but in 1994 only for faba bean. A full analysis of the data with crop growth simulation models may reveal whether plants differ in various growth stages regarding their sensitivity to weather conditions. An unexpected r e s u l t was the striking effect of the OTC's on the quality (composition) of the plant material. The carbon content was lower (37% as compared to 38.5%), but the effect on nitrogen content was even more prominent. For wheat N-levels at harvest dropped for stems from 8 to 4 mg/g, for leaves from 10 to 6.4 mg/g but for grain it went up from 21 to 23.3 mg/g. Such differences are very important when using plant material for decomposition studies (see above), and may result in misleading outcomes. In general there was also a slight increase of the harvest index (fraction of the total dry m a t t e r in the harvested product). For wheat the effect was stronger t h a n for
698
faba bean. In 1993 there was no significant effect for faba bean. Differences in harvest index may for faba bean also be influenced by the stage of maturation. It was observed that both with potato and faba bean maturation of the plants tended to be delayed, whereas the faba bean seeds and pods ripened at the same time. Slight differences in moisture content, combined with differences in remaining leaves (including shed leaves) may influence the outcome. A special aspect of the use of OTC's is the existence of (micro meteorological) gradients within the OTC. In pot experiments, as done in Amsterdam, regular rotation of plants can compensate for non-uniform conditions. However, for field grown plants especially the light gradient causes growth differences that put limits to sampling of plants within the chamber. As general conclusion it can be stated that although OTC's can be a helpful (and necessary) tool for experimentation in elevated CO2 conditions, changes in plant growth and development can not be avoided, requiring a cautious interpretation of the magnitude and type of results. In most situations OTC use should be combined with verification experiments at different scales.
5.4 B i o m a s s formation and yield
Growth o f w i n t e r wheat in winter The hypothesis was tested that the higher photosynthesis at double-present C02 concentrations will result in enhanced growth in autumn, or in higher accumulation of reserve carbohydrates in the plant material. Both from detailed carbohydrate analysis and from biomass determinations it appeared that during the winter period no CO2-enhancement of growth occurred. Apparently temperatures from late October till early April are prohibitive. This was corroborated by the results with winter rye grown in the Rhizolab. The rye was sown late August, and grown till April. In the winter period no significant differences in growth or rate of photosynthesis could be observed. However, a stepwise increase in temperature in February resulted in a 21% higher biomass in April. In parallel experiments with grasses it appeared t h a t also there no CO2-enhancement of growth could be detected, and only in May a clear growth stimulation was found. From switching experiments (between CO2-1evels) it appeared that the higher accumulation of carbohydrates during winter did not result in a clear advantage.
Differences in response between species Comparing ambient and double-present CO2 concentrations with wheat, potato and faba bean (Vicia faba) it appeared that the increase in biomass productivity between species and years varied from 16 to 55% (Table 5.1). In general faba bean showed the highest effect, and potato and wheat reacted about equal. Growth enhancements for OTC-grown potato plants were low, and rather variable. In some years no statistically significant differences could be shown.
699 An analysis of the data using simulation models showed that variations in the weather pattern, but also effects related to light and temperature conditions in the period following emergence could explain a significant part of the year to year variability and also of between-species differences. Model performance for potato crops was rather poor. Although models could not explain all results, they clearly helped to show the great importance of the timing of local weather (temperature levels, drought) relative to the development stage of the crop. The generally observed reduction of nitrogen concentrations in the plant biomass was confirmed in our experiments. Therefore the nitrogen harvest (per land area) increased less than the biomass did. Water use
efficiency
In the experimental conditions (optimal water and nutrients) water use efficiency (biomass produced per unit water transpired) was enhanced, but total seasonal water use (per square meter) did not significantly change because of a larger (transpiring) biomass. More detailed analysis showed that nitrogen content in the biomass dropped, but that the harvest index did not change. Full details on the growth of roots and production of CO2 by respiration of the roots and soil throughout the season can not yet be given. Table 5.1A Biomass and yield (g.m-2 dry matter) of crops grown in near field conditions in Open Top Chambers, exposed to ambient and double presen [CO2] in 1994 Crop Winter Wheat total biomass grain yield Potato total biomass yield (dm) tuber fresh wht F a b a bean total biomass seed yield
ambient [CO2]
double [CO2]
statist. signif,
ratio
2302 1009
2709 1206
p
1.18 1.20
1202 1036 5011
1499 1284 5725
p<0.001 p<0.05 p<0.1
1.25 1.24 1.14
1116 614
1641 733
p<0.001 p<0.05
1.47 1.20
700
Table 5.1B [C02] response of biomass production for various years and crops as compared with simulated yield response experiental year ratio spring wheat winter wheat faba bean
1991 1993 1992
simulated year ratio
1.35 1.19 1.58
1975-1987 1993 1975-1987
1.42 1.35 1.52
Canopy gas exchange For the crops grown in the Rhizolab facility gas exchange has been followed throughout the season, allowing the detailed analysis of various interactions with environmental factors. At the canopy level the often reported down-regulation of photosynthesis after prolonged exposure to elevated CO2 was not detected. The growth enhancement due to CO2 did not or very little depend on the development stage of the crop. An interaction with light level or temperature during the growing season could not be detected (Figure 5.1). The absence of a growth enhancement at low (winter) t e m p e r a t u r e s could not be proved, as the photosynthetically active biomass (winter wheat) was too small at that stage. More detailed analysis of data from grass swards and winter rye canopies may shed some light on this point. CCER (750) 100 A o
/
8o
o
o Io.,"=~"
60
~
o
--:
4O
S
0
(
i
0
....
i
,
20
i
40
,
i
. . . . .
60
CCER (350)
Figure 5.1 Scatter plot of canopy photosynthesis of spring wheat and the season at 350 and 700 ppm C02
faba bean throughout
701 6.
INTEGRATION OF EFFECTS TERRESTRIAL ECOSYSTEMS
OF
CLIMATE
CHANGE
ON
6.1 I n t r o d u c t i o n Changes in soil acidity and nitrogen supply are held responsible for the strong decline in species diversity in Europe over the past 40 years. Succession of vegetation types is intimately related to changes in nitrogen mineralization, soil acidity and plant biomass production levels, that are a result of soil organic m a t t e r accumulation. It is to be expected t h a t changes in CO2 concentration in the a t m o s p h e r e will have i m p o r t a n t effects on the rate of soil organic m a t t e r accumulation and nitrogen turn-over. To study the effects on succession in ecosystems, a simulation model is being developed that will help to evaluate effects of changes in [CO2] and temperature on the succession and biological diversity in nutrient poor ecosystems.
Data for the calibration and validation of the model are collected in an existing chronosequence (0 to 120 years) on a nutrient-poor sandy soil. 6.2 T h e m o d e l The model simulates carbon and nitrogen flow through plant biomass and soil. It consists of three main modules: a water balance, a soil module, and a plant module. Decomposition and mineralization are calculated in the soil module. In the model species compete for light, water and nitrogen.
The plant model is still under development. Because species will show different responses to climate change because of specific plant traits, "competition m a y change and lead to a modified development course for the ecosystem. 6.3 P r o g r e s s a n d p l a n s The project was started only in late 1993. Although progress is along expected lines, as yet no results are available. Model outcome will be related to biodiversity using the correlation between species diversity and variables like soil moisture content, nitrogen content, pH, vegetation height and vegetation structure. The duration of the development stages of the succession series of the ecosystem will be used as an indication for the potential for maintaining biodiversity during the succession.
P a r a m e t e r values are obtained from field experiments in five stages in the chronosequence. Among others biomass quantities and decomposition rates are measured for different sources of organic matter. 7.
IMPACT ON VECTORS
ECOLOGY
AND
DISTRIBUTION
OF
MALARIA
7.1 I n t r o d u c t i o n This project was started as a pilot study for vector borne diseases. Specifically it aimed at evaluating the effects of climate change on the complex ecology of
702 mosquitoes and, from there, estimate the risk of a future spread of diseases. In itself it is not directly linked to the other terrestrial ecosystem studies. The main goal of the project was to use detailed information on the habitat and bionics of the relevant Anopheles species to develop a simulation model for the population dynamics of malaria vectors in Europe, allowing the estimation of potential changes in location and size of areas with a health risk. 7.2 S i m u l a t i o n m o d e l s
The model MOSQSIM, describing the population dynamics of vector species, is linked to a model simulating water availability including changed patterns in precipitation. The consequent changes in habitat (moisture, temperature) favouring or hampering the successive stages of mosquito development are calculated. Critical conditions for population development like availability of fresh water pools, and of humans or other blood sources for the blood meal prior to hatching are also quantified in the model. Cur.
Cli,
>1E+8 m >IE+7 [] >1E+6
~
>lE+5 [E >lE+4 []
'
'
'~
'
i
. . . . .
,
'
'
'1
'
'
|
'
i
'
'
U |
'
'
'
............
yl
>1E+3 I~1 >IE+Z ffl >1E+1 [ ] >IE+9 V]
v1ND
El
Figure 7.1 Simulated distribution of Plasmodium vivax infectious mosquitoes under the current temperature (+ 2 ~ climate scenario
703 C.C. >IE+8 >IE+7 >IE+6 >IE+5 >IE+4 >IE+3 >IE+Z >IE+I >IE+8
I'-
+ZK.
.
.
.
.
LA'
'
9
[]
[]
[~]
FU C]
EI
[
Figure 7.2 Simulated distribution of Plasmodium vivax infectious mosquitoes under increased temperature (+ 2 ~ climate scenario 7.3 D i s t r i b u t i o n of t h e m a l a r i a v e c t o r On basis of a climatological database the model correctly generates the vector distribution and malaria incidence in Europe before World War II. Also, realistic values for the vector distribution were found for the last decade. W h e n applied to climate change scenarios the validated model predicts a significant change in the vector distribution. Not only present mosquito species will extend in distribution area, but also more dangerous species will move to higher latitudes over Europe. A s u m m e r t e m p e r a t u r e increase of 2 ~ may result in a h u n d r e d fold or more increase in the number of infected mosquitoes in Southern Europe. The epidemic potential of vectors already present in an area thus may rise drastically. The techniques developed are suitable for estimating the regionalised malaria risk. As an index the vectorial capacity has been defined, being the n u m b e r of potentially infective contacts made by a mosquito population per infectious person per day. This index is a powerful tool, as it may also be used to express the regionalised malaria risk at a world-wide scale. 7.4 C o n c l u d i n g r e m a r k s In the project models have been developed for the distribution of mosquitoes as a vector of malaria. The models from this pilot study can be adapted to assess the impact of climate change on other harmful as well as beneficial insects, provided the proper technical coefficients describing critical stages and processes are
704 available. Evaluation of changes in biodiversity as well as questions related to integrated pest management in crop protection could be studied in this way. 8.
CLOSING REMARKS
The projects summarised above have not yet been completed at this stage. The project on integration of effects in fact has only started a year ago. As a consequence an assessment can only be preliminary. Further interactions and progress in the analysis and interpretation of the results will help to complete the contribution to the scientific basis for the estimation of the impact of global climate change on terrestrial ecosystems. Although the subjects and objects under study were different in many respects, the knowledge developed under the programme has made a significant contribution to improve the understanding of the complex terrestrial ecosystems, and has been instrumental for the development of new tools. It has also helped to establish excellent networks with the international scientific community, and to provide policy makers both nationally and internationally with the latest results. However, the full value of the effort will only be achieved in a follow-up of the programme, where missing information can be added, but certainly a transfer and further integration of knowledge based on the expertise built up in the NRP, and in International Programmes (like IGBP-GCTE, IGBP-BAHC, HDP-LUCC) should take place. 9.
REFERENCES
Arp, W. and F. Berendse, 1993. Plant growth and nutrient cycling in nutrient-poor ecosystems. In: Van de Geijn, S.C., J. Goudriaan and F. Berendse, (eds.). Climate Change: crops and terrestrial ecosystems Agrobiologische Thema's 9: 109-123. Berendse, F., 1993. Ecosystem stability, competition and nutrient cycling. In: Schulze, E.D. and Mooney, H.A. (eds.). Biodiversity and Ecosystem Function Ecological Studies 99: 409-431. Springer Verlag, Heidelberg. Bouten, W. and J. Goudriaan, 1995. Effects of CO2 fertilisation on evapotranspiration. In: Oliver H.R. (ed.). The role of water and the hydrological cycle in global change. ASI NATO. (In press). Dijkstra, P., A.H.C.M. Schapendonk and S.C.van de Geijn, 1994. Response of spring wheat canopy photosynthesis to CO2 concentration throughout the growing season: effect of development stage and light intensity. In: Veroustraete, F. and R. Ceulemans (eds). Proceedings of the Workshop "Modelling and climate change". SPB Academic Publishing bv, The Hague, p. 53-62. Fisher, M.J., I.M. Rao, M.A. Ayarza, C.E. Lascano, J.I. Sanz, R.J. Thomas and R.R. Vera, 1994. Carbon storage by introduced deep-rooted grasses in the South American savannas. Nature 371: 236-238.
705 Gorissen, A, P.J. Kuikman and H .van de Beek, 1995. Carbon allocation and water use in juvenile Douglas fir under elevated CO2. New Phytol. 129: 275-282. Gorissen, A., J.H. van Ginkel, J.J.B. Keurentjes and J.A. van Veen, 1995. Grass root decomposition is retarded when grass has been grown under elevated CO2. Soil Biol. Biochem. 27: 117-120. Goudriaan, J., 1993a. Interaction of ocean and biosphere in their transient responses to increasing atmospheric CO2. Vegetatio 104/105: 329-337. Goudriaan, J. 1993b. Carbon cycle and ecosystem productivity on a global scale. In: Van de Geijn, S.C., J.Goudriaan and F. Berendse (eds). Climate change; crops and terrestrial ecosystems. Agrobiologische thema's no 9. CABO-DLO, Wageningen, p. 125-138. IGBP, 1993. Biospheric Aspects of the Hydrological Cycle: The operational Plan, IGBP-report No. 27. Jetten, T.H., and W. Takken, 1994. Anophelism without malaria in Europe. A review of the ecology and distribution of the genus Anopheles in Europe. Wageningen Agricultural Papers 94-5, 69 pp. Kramer K., 1995. Phenotypic plasticity of the phenology of seven European tree species in relation to climatic warming. Plant Cell and Environment 18: 93-104. Kramer K., 1995. Modelling comparison to evaluate the importance of phenology for the effects of climate change on growth of temperate-zone deciduous trees. Climate Research, in press. Kramer K., 1994. A modelling analysis of the effects of climatic warming on the probability of spring frost damage to tree species in The Netherlands and Germany. Plant Cell and Environment 17: 367-377. Lankreijer, H.J.M., The effects of an increase in CO2 on the hydrology of forests. Thesis in prep., Department of Physical Geography, University of Groningen. Lankreijer, H.J.M., 1994. The effects of an increase in CO2 on the hydrology of forests. Interim report, Department of Physical Geography, University of Groningen. M.G. Schaap, 1995. The role of soil organic matter in forest hydrology. Thesis: Landscape and environmental research group, University of Amsterdam. (In prep.) Martens, W.J.M., L.W. Niessen, J. Rotmans, T.H. Jetten and A.J. McMichael, 1995. Potential impact of global climate change on m a l a r i a risk. Environmental health perspectives 103: 458-464. Olsthoorn, A.F.M., 1991. Fine root biomass of two Douglas-fir stands on sandy soils in the Netherlands. 1. Root biomass in early summer. Neth.J.Agric.Sci. 39: 49-60. Olsthoorn, A.F.M. and A. Tiktak, 1991. Fine root biomass of two Douglas-fir stands on sandy soils in the Netherlands. 2. Periodicity of fine root growth and estimation of below-ground carbon allocation. Neth.J.Agric.Sci. 39: 61-77. Reilly, J., S.C. Van de Geijn, R. Rogasik, C. Rosenzweig, and S.K. Sinha, (Lead Authors) 1995. (In review). Climate change and agriculture: Contribution of IPCC WGII Subgroup Agriculture II.B.5. 1994 to the IPCC Scientific Assessment Report 1995. Steffen, W., B.H. Walker, J.S.I. Ingram and G.W. Koch (eds), 1992. Global Change and Terrestrial Ecosystems: The Operational Plan. IGBP-report No. 21.
706 Tosserams, M., A.J. Visser, M. Groen, E. Magendans and J. Rozema, 1995. The combined effect of CO2 and solar UV-B radiation on faba bean. II. Effect on physiology.Submitted to Plant Cell & Environment. Turner II, B.L., R.M. Moss and D.L. Scole (eds), 1993. Relating Land Use and Global Land-Cover Change. IGBP-report 24 (published jointly with HDP). Van de Geijn, S.C., and J. Goudriaan, 1994. (In press). The effects of elevated CO2 and temperature change on transpiration and crop water use. Proc. FAO Expert Consultation, Rome, 10-14 December 1993. Van de Geijn, S.C., P. Dijkstra, J. van Kleef, K.Groenwold and J.Goudriaan. 1993. An experimental facility to study effects of CO2 enrichment on the daily and long-term carbon exchange of a crop/soil system. In: Schultze, E.D. and H.A. Mooney (eds). Design and execution of experiments on CO2 enrichment. Ecosystems reports 6, Commission of the European Communities, p. 167-174. Van de Geijn, S.C., J. Vos, J. Groenwold, J. Goudriaan and P.A. Leffelaar, 1994. The Wageningen Rhizolab - a facility to study soil-root-shoot-atmosphere interactions in crops. Plant Soil 161: 275-287. Visser, A.J., M. Tosserams, M. Groen, E. Magendans and J. Rozema, 1995. The combined effect of CO2 and solar UV-B radiation on faba b e a n . I.Growth and allocation. Plant Cell & Environment (submitted). Visser, A.J., H. Bleeksma and J. Rozema, 1995.Growth and physiology of spring wheat and faba bean. Effects of differing rooting volumes. Submitted to New Phytol.
Short papers within NRP subtheme "Effects o f c l i m a t e change on terrestrial ecosystems"
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Climate Change Research: Evaluation and Policy Implications S. Zwerver, R.S.A.R. van Rompaey, M.T.J. Kok and M.M. Berk, (Eds.) 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
709
CLIMATE C H A N G E AND A G R I C U L T U R A L P R O D U C T I V I T Y A.H.C.M. Schapendonka, P. Dijkstraa, M.J.H. J a n s e n a , C.S. Pota, S.C. van de Geijna, A. Visserb and J. Rozemab a Research Institute for Agrobiology and Soil Fertility (AB-DLO), P.O. Box 14, 6700 AA Wageningen, The Netherlands b D e p a r t m e n t of Ecology and Ecotoxicology, Free University of Amsterdam, de Boelelaan 1087, 1081 HV Amsterdam, The Netherlands 1. A B S T R A C T Research performed at the AB-DLO and the Free University was intended to quantify the effects of a doubled CO2 concentration on some key agronomic species and grasslands. A set of physiological and morphological processes was studied and related to above- and below ground cycling of carbon. The research was based on experiments and simulation studies at the level of plant, crop and soil in laboratory facilities and semi-field conditions with controlled CO2 supply. A g r i c u l t u r a l crops were grown in "Open Top C h a m b e r s " or greenhouses and grasses in transparent tunnels made of Lexan. Soil processes and root respiration were studied in the Wageningen Rhizolab. Photosynthesis and assimilate partitioning were m e a s u r e d simultaneously in the photosynthesis laboratory. S i m u l a t i o n models a p p e a r e d to be useful tools to quantify the consequences of elevated CO2 and climate change on the productivity of grasses and crops with different growth strategies.
2. R E S U L T S 2.1 P h o t o s y n t h e s i s and p r o d u c t i v i t y In general, a doubled CO2 concentration enhanced photosynthetic rates of leaves by 25-50%. This stimulated the development of leaves and therefore the amount of interecepted light increased. The combined effect of CO2 on photosynthesis and the increased light interception was an improvement of the yield by 30-60%. It was established t h a t the stimulation was not a temporary one. Results from experiments with s u m m e r wheat and faba bean, showed that the CO2 response of wheat remained equal over the season and for faba it even increased towards the end of the season. A remarkable observation was the decreased respiration of soil and roots for grasses under elevated CO2. The consequence of this might be a net positive effect on productivity. The r a n k i n g for the CO2 effect was: faba bean, spring wheat, grass, potato and winter wheat, in a decreasing order. The increase of the harvested products, pods, grain etc. was equal to the total dry m a t t e r increases, which m e a n s t h a t the
710 h a r v e s t index was unaltered by C02. The CO2-driven increase in production, however differed over seasons and between years. The positive effects on grasses and w i n t e r w h e a t were much smaller during w i n t e r t h a n d u r i n g s u m m e r . Differences between years and species were explained in terms of differences in timing on which developmental stages were reached until h a r v e s t [1,2]. Thus environment interacted differently for the respective crops.
2.2 Simulation models Simulation studies were of great help to resolve these interactions. A simulation model for potato production predicted a significant interaction between the CO2 effect and a specific cultivar property, called earliness. In comparison with an early cultivar a late cultivar is characterised by later tuber filling and later leaf senescence. A v e r a g e d over the y e a r s 1988-1991, a s i m u l a t e d i n c r e a s e of the CO2 concentration from 350 vpm to 700 vpm increased tuber dry m a t t e r production by 22% for late cultivars and 29% for early cultivars. The effects were smaller for late cultivars, irrespective of the occurrence of a drought period. The higher benefit for early cultivars compared with late cultivars is due to their relatively low Leaf Area Index (LAI) and the concomitant higher positive effect of CO2 on the l i g h t utilization efficiency [2]. This effect is enhanced by a relatively higher positive effect CO2 on of the Leaf Area Duration (LAD) for early cultivars. 2.3 R e g r o w t h from storage P a s t u r e s are regularly defoliated by grazing or mowing. As a consequence of the removal of photosynthetic tissue, the plants have to remobilize carbon from reserves t h a t were stored in the stubble. These reserves consists mainly of sugars t h a t were obtained from photosynthesis prior to the defoliation. It was found t h a t elevated CO2 increased the amount of reserves. Strong interactions exist between the a m o u n t of biomass harvested and the CO2 effect on the biomass produced in the next cut. There is an optimum for the cutting height to gain the largest effect for double CO2. In the first days after cutting, growth of grasses is mainly sink limited. The a m o u n t of stored carbohydrates in the stubble only set the lower limits for potential regrowth. After about one week of regrowth, the supply of assimilates for regrowth becomes limiting due to photosynthetic restrictions. Doubled CO2 h a d a strong positive effect both on tillering and the rate of refilling the storage pools to be used aider a next defoliation. 2.4 Effect of t e m p e r a t u r e Higher t e m p e r a t u r e s were synergistic with elevated CO2 on photosynthetic rates of leaves. Doubled CO2 stimulated photosynthesis of grasses and w i n t e r w h e a t much more in s u m m e r t h a n in winter, partly due to the temperature- and partly due to light interactions. This tentatively would lead to the conclusion t h a t elevated t e m p e r a t u r e would enlarge the beneficial effect of doubled CO2 on plant productivity. This however appeared not to be the case. Simulation models of grasses and potato, predicted a shorter growing period at higher temperatures due to an accelerated senescence of the leaves. The a d v a n t a g e of a f a s t e r leaf
711 appearance rate and leaf elongation rates in spring were adversely affected by a faster senescence of the leaves. In addition annual crops developed faster, which shortened the time between emergence and harvest and therefore decreased the amount of intercepted radiation and thus the amount of accumulated biomass. 2.5 N i t r o g e n i n t e r a c t i o n As an overal response, high C02 leads to a decrease of the nitrogen content in the biomass m a i n l y due to an increase in the a m o u n t of s t a r c h a n d o t h e r carbohydrates. This effect however is relatively small and in most cases it is of minor importance compared with the effect of other environmental p a r a m e t e r s (Figure 1).
3
N (g rn -2 )
A
2.5 2 1.5 1 0.5 0
Top 0
3
0.2
0.4 0.6 0.8 relative height
1
N (g m - 2 )
B
2.5 2 1.5 1 0.5 0
Top ,
0
0.2
|
=
0.4 0.6 0.8 relative height
,
1
Figure 1: Nitrogen concentration (g m-2 leaf area) of leaves of faba bean against relative plant height as affected by CO2 concentration (LCO2 squares, HCO2 triangles) at low (A) and high (B) plant density.
712 A shortage of nutrients reduces the positive effect of elevated C02. Because large areas in the world are characterised by low amounts of available nitrogen, the expected positive effects on plant production on a global scale have to be considered in this respect. We found t h a t part of the CO2 stimulation might be retained under low nitrogen because the plant seemed to require less nitrogen in the tissue. This was concluded from the findings t h a t the nitrogen contents of wheat and faba bean were reduced under doubled CO2 and optimal nitrogen supply. However, the total amount of nitrogen t h a t was taken up on a surface area basis was higher under double CO2. This can be explained by the bigger root system of those plants with which a larger volume of soil could be explored for nutrients. Obviously, this can only be the case when the soil volume t h a t is concerned contains any nitrogen. In other cases nitrogen becomes limiting even sooner. 2.6 UV-B e f f e c t s F a b a bean was shown to be very sensitive for I_W-B radiation (280-320 nm). C u r r e n t outdoor I_W-B levels already had an effect on the growth of this p l a n t , although UV-B levels in t h a t open top chamber experiment were very low. Both CO2 and UV-B had a significant effect on biomass at all three harvests [3]. The highest UV-B level decreased biomass with 44% in ambient CO2 and 55% in elevated CO2 at the final harvest (41 days). Without UV-B total biomass was s t i m u l a t e d 34% by elevated CO2. This stimulation was only 7% at the highest UV-B level. The 10 k J t r e a t m e n t already decreased total biomass at the final h a r v e s t of ambient grown plants whereas this t r e a t m e n t had no effect on total biomass of plants grown under double CO2. At the highest UV-B t r e a t m e n t total biomass of elevated grown plants was less than the biomass in the ambient grown plants in the 0,6 and 10 k J treatments. 2.7 U n c e r t a i n t i e s While plant growth is stimulated under elevated C02, not all species react in the same way. Interactions between developmental stages of different species and e n v i r o n m e n t a l factors are involved such as light, t e m p e r a t u r e and n u t r i e n t supply. The background of this is not known with sufficient certainty. This aspect is of major importance for plants which grow in competition with each other especially in natural vegetations. A project for further research is in preparation, involving simulation models and "Open Top" experiments. E l e v a t e d CO2 m a y lead to more carbon stored in the vegetation. T h r o u g h an increased root growth it may lead to an elevated carbon pool in the soil, too. The consequences for the total carbon balance may be considerable. The question remains w h e t h e r carbon or nitrogen is the controlling factor in this process. This will be the challenge and the subject of forthcoming projects. 3. G E N E R A L C O N C L U S I O N S 3.1 A b o v e g r o u n d We conclude that the response to doubling the CO 2 concentration varies to a great e x t e n t and t h a t this v a r i a t i o n can p a r t l y be explained by differences in
713 development of specific crop species during the season and interactions with weather conditions. Apart from the uncertainties given above, it is expected that a doubling of the CO2 concentration will result in an increase in production of 15-50 %. An increase in temperature will partly neutralise the effect of CO2 because it decreases the length of the period for growth of annual crops and it increased the turn-over of life leaves into dead litter for grasses. In order to achieve an increase in production, increased input of nutrients is required.
3.2 Below ground When nitrogen is not limiting, a doubling of the C O 2 concentration stimulates the allocation of carbon to the roots and the soil. This may increase the storage capacity of the soil for carbon. The ultimate effect for the carbon cycle will depend on the stimulation in the long term, the availability of nutrients, the effects of higher temperature and the decomposition rates of soil organic matter. References 1 Dijkstra, P., Schapendonk, A.H.C.M. and S.C.van de Geijn, S.C. 1994. Response of spring wheat canopy photosynthesis to CO2 concentration throughout the growing season: effect of developmental stage and light intensity. In: Vegetation, Modelling and Climatic Change Effects. (Eds. P. Veroustraete, R. Ceulemans, I. Impens & J. Van Rensbergen.) SPB Academic Publishing. The Hague, ISBN 90-5103-090-8. pp 53-62. 2 Schapendonk, A.H.C.M., Pot, C.S. and J. Goudriaan, (1995) Simulated Effects of Elevated Carbon Dioxide Concentration and Temperature on the Productivity of Potato. Interaction with Maturity Classes. In: Ecology and Modelling of Potato Crops under Conditions Limiting Growth. (Eds. A. Haverkort & D.K.L. MacKerron). Series Current Issues in Production Ecology. Kluwer Scientific Publishers, Dordrecht. pp 101-114. 3 Visser, A.J., Tosserams, M., Groen, M.W., Kalis, G., Kwant, R. and J. Rozema, 1994. Simultaneous application of CO2 and UV-B radiation (280-320 nm) to Vicia faba: I. CO2 effects on growth and physiology. Proceedings of the 9th Congress of the Federation of European Societies of Plant Physiology. 3-8 july 1994, in press.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Climate Change Research: Evaluation and Policy Implications S. Zwerver, R.S.A.R. van Rompaey, M.T.J. Kok and M.M. Berk, (Eds.) 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
715
Integrating the effects of climate change on terrestrial ecosystems C.G.F. de Kovel a and Y.J.O Wilms a aDepartment of Terrestrial Ecology and Nature Conservation, Wageningen Agricultural University, Bornsesteeg 69, 6708 PD Wageningen, The Netherlands
Abstract
A model of carbon, nitrogen and water flows within an ecosystem in relation to changes in species composition is nearing completion. This model, which applies to succession on sandy soils, will be used to investigate the effects of temperature, nitrogen deposition and CO2 concentration in the atmosphere on vegetation succession. The model applies to primary succession on sandy soils. Parameters are being collected in a Dutch drift sand area (Hulshorsterzand). Preliminary simulation show strong interactions between the effects nitrogen deposition and CO2 concentration: The rate nitrogen is supplied to the ecosystem influences whether species replacement is accelerated, not affected or delayed by increasing CO2 concentrations. This implies that relative abundances of species may change in response to climate change.
1. INTRODUCTION One important component of vegetation succession is the modification of the environment brought about by the plants themselves. This modification encompasses changes in the availability of nutrients, light and water for the different plant species. These changes alter the competitive balance between species, which can lead to shifts in their relative abundances. The carbon, water and nutrient flows in ecosystems can be seriously affected by the various aspects of climate change: rising CO2, changing precipitation patterns and changing temperatures as well as by the changing amounts of nitrogen deposition. This can have pronounced consequences for species composition and biodiversity in natural ecosystems (Pastor & Post, 1986). Short term experiments with one or a few species are insufficient to enable the eventual effects of climate change on plant communities and biodiversity to be predicted with confidence. The solution is to integrate knowledge acquired in these experiments into models. We are therefore in the process of developing a dynamic simulation model to investigate the effects of climate change on succession, which calculates how dominant plant species in a primary succession mediate carbon and nitrogen flows. The final model furthermore will include a water balance. Species diversity is often found to be correlated with ecosystem parameters such as primary production, vegetation structure, nitrogen mineralization and soil pH (Pausas, 1994). Other variables might be identified as being relevant in this context too. These ecosystem parameters are mainly determined by the external environmental conditions, the successional
716 age of the ecosystem and the dominant plant species. The aim of the model presented is to calculate effect of climate change on the mentioned ecosystem parameters and on the biomass of the dominant plant species. Based on the changes in these variables probable consequences for biological diversity will computed using descriptive models.
2. M O D E L DESCRIPTION
The succession model simulates the dynamics of populations of dominant plant species at a certain site through time. In the model plant populations compete for light and nitrogen (Figure 1). A water module will enable competition for water to be investigated too. The model has been specially designed to study the effects of different scenarios of atmospheric nitrogen deposition, CO2 concentration and temperature on succession. The driving variables of the main model are temperature, CO2 concentration in the atmosphere and nitrogen deposition. The water module will use additional weather data, such as rainfall and irradiation as driving variables. The time step of the model is one year and the run time is about 150 years.
FI
mortality
r .....
:
::
E'~ 0
,~
,~,~,~,~
7~
~
ar~
i
" .....
.-i
,~
~
:
9~
.~ ~
..........
~'
-q'~
~
v
---
,,::-.. oo
d'~/l~l
I,,,
,~,
_l
I
/.=--I
~ / ~. \
I!
11
~'~--
--II
~
I~~K
I
L . . . . . .
~
~'I~1
.....
!
"---"~L% ~'~
/~\
assil'nilation
. . . . . . . . . . . .
.~ ! ,.
'~
:
! ~=.- In-',. . . .~. . .t. . . . i:,: E
~/L~
:
i
Fig. 1. General structure of a succession model simulating competition for light and nitrogen as influenced by cBmate change. SoBd Bnes: carbon /nitrogenflow, dotted Bnes: information flow, grey circles: driving variables.
The model computes at each time step the amounts of carbon and nitrogen in the plant parts of the different species. Furthermore, the amounts of carbon and nitrogen contained in litter and soil organic matter and the amount of mineral nitrogen in the soil are calculated. The latter information is useful because on sandy soils with high rainfall the amount of mineral nitrogen in the soil is a measure of the leaching of nitrogen. Vegetation height, light at soil surface and several other derived values can be produced by the model.
717 The model parameters are currently being measured in a chronosequence in a Dutch drift sand area (Hulshorsterzand, 52020 ' N, 5044 ' E). Validation data are being collected in independent measuring campaigns.
3. RESULTS TO DATE As the model is still being developed, the results reported here are preliminary. Parameters were tuned in such a way that a doubling of the CO2 concentration would under optimal conditions result in a 30% increase of production for all species. At intermediate levels of nitrogen input, simulations with a high CO2 concentration (of 560 ppm) showed lower N to C ratios in living tissue and in fresh litter. This in turn resulted in lower decomposition and mineralization rates (Figure 2). Due to reduced N availability, in these cases CO2 enrichment did not lead to increased production, compared to simulations with present-day CO2 concentrations (of 350 ppm). At low N input, little changed; at high N input simulations showed increased total production. Simulations with parameters for Calluna vulgaris (L.) Hull and Deschampsia flexuosa (L.) Trin. (from Bakema et al. 1994) showed that the relative abundances of species may be influenced by increased CO2 concentrations (Figure 3).
kg N ha 4 y e a r ~ 450
20 _
t
kg C / h a
II ~,,, ,,
350
/
350 ppm 250 ,/ 150
560 ppm..--"
t
/
/
/
/
{-
/
/
CV +
15
/
/..,. 9
5 50
-50
i
/
J"
,/
/ ,
I
/ .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
i .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Df .
.
.
~., I - -
.
."
25
I
I
I
50
75
100
,,,I 125
~"..~
/ ~
CV
Df+ /
\
0 0
25
50
75
1 oo
year
Fig 2. N mineralization rates under a Calluna Deschampsia vegetation at two C 0 2 concentrations and 30 kg N / h a / y e a r as atmospheric deposition.
Fig 3. Biomass development o f C. vulgaris and D. flexuosa at two C 0 2 concentrations and 30 kg N ~ha~year as atmospheric deposition.
4. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS So far, we have only investigated the effects of nitrogen deposition and CO2 concentration on vegetation and soil processes. However, the water balance module has not yet been used, so simulations have not included competition for water. The effects of changes in temperature have not yet been studied either. The simulations to date have shown that enhanced CO2 concentration results in a lower nitrogen supply if one of the species is light-limited. This light-
125
718 limited species will produce lower quality litter than under present-day CO2 levels and this will slow down mineralization. Decreased nitrogen availability will limit the production of species that are nutrient-limited. Although the production of the light-limited species usually increased, in most simulations total production did not increase. In some cases increased CO2 concentration led to a shift in dominance if a light-limited species were suppressed by a nutrient-limited species. However, the light-limited species profited most from the increase in CO2 concentration. This effect is largely opposite to the effect of increasing N deposition. In heather ecosystems heavy atmospheric N deposition has been shown to benefit the nutrient-limited grasses more than the more light-limited heather species, which may lead to an accelerated expansion of grasses (Berendse & Elberse, 1990). Clearly, there are strong interactions between the effects of CO2 enrichment and nitrogen deposition. In a dry, nutrient-poor ecosystem, like that of our study site on drift sand, the impact of CO2 on plant water use efficiency may be a very important effect of climate change (Arp, 1991). This aspect of CO2 enrichment will have strong interactions with temperature. During succession nitrogen availability often increases, and concomitantly the competition for light becomes more important. Often early species in the succession suffer from light shortage more than later species. An increase in CO2 concentration might slow down succession in some stages by benefiting early species more than late species. However, an increase in total production might accelerate succession, for example canopy closure may be attained sooner. Our preliminary conclusions are that increasing CO2 concentration may seriously affect succession patterns in poor ecosystems, but probably to a lesser extent in extremely nutrientpoor ecosystems. The direction and magnitude of the changes will differ between ecosystems and successional stages. CO2 enrichment and nitrogen deposition operate antagonistically in some aspects, though both may increase production and both may accelerate succession. The relations between different ecosystem parameters and species richness vary between vegetation types and between successional stages. These relations will have to be established for actual situations. However, it seems probable that a faster disappearance of early successional stages will reduce total species richness on a landscape scale. REFERENCES Arp, W.J. (1991). Plant water relations in elevated atmospheric CO2. Vegetation of a North American Salt Marsh and Elevated Atmospheric Carbon Dioxide. Ph.D. thesis. Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam. Bakema, A.H., Meijers, R. Aerts, R. Berendse, F. & Heil, G.W. (1994). HEATHSOL: a Heathland Competition Model. RIVM, Bilthoven. Berendse, F. & Elberse, W.T. (1990). Competition and nutrient availability in heathland and grassland ecosystems. Perspectives on Plant Competition (Ed. Grace, J.B. & Tilman, D.) Academic Press, Inc., San Diego. Pastor, J. & Post, W.M. (1986). Influence of climate, soil moisture, and succession on forest carbon and nitrogen cycles. Biogeochemistry, 2, 3-27. Pausas, J.G. (1994). Species richness patterns in the understorey of Pyrenean Pinus sylvestris forest. Journal of Vegetation Science, 5, 517-524.
Climate Change Research: Evaluation and Policy Implications S. Zwerver, R.S.A.R. van Rompaey, M.T.J. Kok and M.M. Berk, (Eds.) 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
719
Selection of bio-indicators to assess the possible landscape ecological effects of climate change Rudolf S. de Groot a, Pieter Ketner b and Arjan H. Ovaa a
aWageningen Institute for Environment & Climate Studies, Wageningen Agricultural University, P.O. Box 9101, NL-6700 HB Wageningen, The Netherlands
bDepartment of Terrestrial Ecology and Nature Conservation, Wageningen Agricultural University, P.O. Box 9101, NL-6700 HB Wageningen, The Netherlands
Abstract Past climate changes have led to considerable changes in the species composition of ecosystems. The recent increase in average global temperature is rather strong compared to previous warming periods and, if climate models are correct, future warming will be even stronger. Especially in Europe where the landscape has been greatly fragmented by human activities, the ongoing and projected changes in climate will pose an additional stress on the natural biodiversity. This paper will discuss a method for the selection of bio-indicators to assess the possible landscape-ecological effects of climate change, and presents some preliminary results of the selection of indicator species for the Netherlands.
1. INTRODUCTION
In this paper, some results are presented of a short pilot-study to find suitable bioindicators to assess effects of climate change on biodiversity in Europe. Since species determine the structure and functioning of ecosystems, these bio-indicators can be used to assess the climate-sensitivity of natural end semi-natural ecosystems and landscapes. The main purpose of the study is to develop criteria for the selection of species (bioindicators) that are suitable for assessing the (potential) response of natural ecosystems to climate change "in the field". The complexity of the potential effects of climate change on species as well as on landscape-ecological processes, together with the simultaneous occurrence of many other influences on the landscape (e.g. land use, eutrophication, acid precipitation) [1], makes it essential, but at the same time quite difficult, to select appropriate indicator-species.
720 2. S O M E CRITERIA FOR SELECTING INDICATOR SPECIES
In order to select potential indicator-species, they must be screened on a number of criteria based on the response features and practical constraints. As a start a few criteria are listed in table 1 , but future research will probably refine these further and may add more.
Table 1" Some criteria for selecting bio-indicators for climate change Climate sensitivity Habitat constraints Position within distribution range Presence and abundance Dispersal capacity Functional position in the ecosystem Suitability for monitoring
Depending on the aim for which indicator species are to be used, i.e the responsefeature to be monitored, which m a y be physiology, phenology, inter-specific interactions or abundance/distribution or a combination of these features, a selection of criteria should be used. These criteria could then serve as a type of "filter" to reduce the available species-list in a given region to a few suitable indicator-species.
J i
(1) Climate s e n s i t i v i t y
i
(2) Habitat c o n s t r a i n t s i
i
(3) Position in distr, range i
(4) Dispersal c a p a c i t y i ( ) etc. I
i i
'
I
Bioindicator(s) Figure 1" "Filter" showing the succesive application of criteria to select indicator species for climate change
721 3. SELECTION OF POSSIBLE INDICATOR SPECIES FOR CLIMATE CHANGE IN THE NETHERLANDS The expected climate change in the Netherlands will probably result in winters that are more atlantic (higher temperatures and wetter), while the summer-period will be more continental (higher temperatures and drier). Changes in climate and weather will particularly influence plant and animal species which: (a) occur at the border of their geographical distribution, (b) do not occur in their preferemial habitat (marginal habitats), and (c) are able to adjust rapidly by changing their distribution area or which are just not able to do so and thus will be threatened by extinction. Various studies have been carried out in the Netherlands on the possible effects of global (esp. climate) change on ecosystems and species to various degrees of detail, including on terrestrial plants [3-5], aquatic plants [6], mammals [7-8], birds [9-10], butterflies [11-12] and dragonflies [13]. Most of these studies were carried out within the framework of a project initiated and sponsored by the Dutch Ministry of Housing, Physical Planning and Environment under the title Flora and Fauna 2030 [14] and the socalled LICC project [1]. Using the above mentioned publications and applying some of the criteria described in section 2 of this paper, a preliminary list of indicator species was prepared for herbaceous plants, butterflies, breeding birds and mammals. Only species that are considered as native or well established in the Netherlands have been used. Method of selection For the four groups, all species found in the Netherlands were used as a starting point: 1,253 higher plants, 71 butterflies, 179 breeding birds, and 49 mammals. The selection took place in four steps"
Step (1)" climate sensitivity In the first step, a survey based on expert judgements reveiled that 175 of the 1,253 selected plant species in the Netherlands are expected to respond mainly to climate change and much less to other global changes, whereby 165 plants are expected to benefit from climate-warming and 10 are expected to decline [4]. This list was narrowed down further by using the "Ellenberg-value" for temperature and only those species were selected which have a low value (1-3 = plants which indicate cold growing conditions) or high value (7-9 = plants which indicate warm habitats) [ 15-16]. For animals, such indicator values do not exist and here the climate-sensitivity of the species was qualitatively assessed on the basis of known ecological relations between the species performance and/or distribution and climate factor(s).
Step (2)" habitat constraints Only those species were selected for which adequate habitats can be found at all latitudes in The Netherlands.
722
Step (3): dispersal capacity During step 3, only those species which have a good dispersal capacity or of which (local) expansion is already taking place were selected.
Step (4): suitability for monitoring Finally, the number of suitable indicators was narrowed down further by leaving out those species which may be difficult to monitor, for example because they are too small to recognize, because they lead a "hidden life" or because of taxonomical difficulties or other reasons. Table 2 shows the results of this selection-procedure for the Netherlands for the four species-groups.
Table 2 Selection of bio-indicators for detecting climate change in the Netherlands
Number: Criterion (1) (*) (2) (3) (4)
Number:
Vascular plants 1253 100% + 165 31 18 18 13
14.0% 2.6% 1.4% 1.4% 1.4%
71
9 3 3 3
-
1 0 0 0
-
4
0
5.6%
2
0 0 0
2.8% 2.8% 2.8%
2 2
Mammals 49 100% +
5.6% 1.7% 1.7% 1.7%
*) based on Ellenberg-values (see text)
100%
+
Breeding birds 179 100% +
Criterion (1) (2) (3) (4)
10 1 0 0 0
Butterflies
0 0 0 0
-
0 0 0 0
0% 0% 0% 0%
+ = increase, - = decrease
Table 3 gives a preliminary list of species which could be used as climate indicator species in the Netherlands. All are species which are expected to increase in abundance and/or expand their distribution range. It should be emphasised that possible changes in phenology were not considered in the selection procedure.
723 Table 3 Examples of possible indicator species for climate change in the Netherlands
Vascular plants Ca species:
C__4species:
Anchusa officinalis (Alkanet) Hordeum murinum (Mouse barley) Medicago minima (Bar medick) Poa bulbosa (Bulbous meadow-grass) Sagina apetala Senecio vernalis Trifolium scabrum Trifolium striatum (Knotted Clover)
Abutilon theophrasti (Velvetleaf) Cynodon dactylon (Bermuda grass) Eragrostis minor (Little lovegrass) Eragrostis pilosa (Indian lovegrass) Portulaca oleracea (Purslane)
Butterflies Papilio machaon (Swallowtail) Nymphalis antiopa (Morning cloak)
Breeding birds Asio otus (Long-eared Owl) Cettia cettia (Cetti's Warbler) Cisticola juncidis (Fan-tailed Warbler)
When research and monitoring proceed, species may be added or deleted on the basis of difficulties encountered or based on new insights in the ecology of the species. No mammals were selected as bio-indicators, because most potential indicator-species in this group do not only react strongly to climate change, but also to other environmental changes. However, some species such as the Common Hamster (Cricetus cricetus) or Common Rabbit (Oryctolagus cuniculus) may be added to the list later on. 4. PRELIMINARY CONCLUSIONS A first application of the proposed method for the selection of bio-indicators showed that only 0-3 % of the species within the investigated taxonomic groups (vascular plants, breeding birds, butterflies and mammals) are potentially suitable as indicators for climate change in the Netherlands. All the selected indicator-species are expected to increase in abundance or expand their distribution range. It must be investigated further if this is a bias in the selection method or wether it is an indication of the possibly predominant positive effects of climate change for the investigated species groups in this part of Europe.
REFERENCES 1 M.M. Boer & R.S. de Groot (eds.), Landscape-ecolgical Impact of Climatic change, Proceedings of a European Conference, 429 pp. IOS Press, Amsterdam, Washington, Tokyo, 1990. 2 R.S. de Groot, Biodiversity as indicator for measuring sustainability: A case study on the use of indicator species. In: RMNO (Advisory Council for Nature and
724
3
4 5 6 7
8
9
10
11 12
13
14
15 16
Environment) Towards environmental performance indicators based on the notion of environmental space. 113-131 (1994) P. Ketner, P., Impact of climate change on flora and vegetation inWestern Europe with special emphasis on The Netherlands. In: J.I. Holten (ed), Effects of climate change on terrestrial ecosystems. Report from a seminar in Trondheim, 47-60 (1990). R. van der Meijden, Flora en Fauna 2030: Hogere planten, een geannoteerde soortenlijst. FLORON, 1993 F. Mohren & K. Kramer, Reactions of trees and forests to climate change. Change 9: 14-15, 1992 Th.C.M. Brock & W. van Viersen, Climatic change and hydrophytic-dominated communities in inland wetland ecosystems, Wetl. Ecol. and Man. 2 (1/2) 37-49, 1992 C.P.M. Zoon, Flora en Fauna 2030: Nederlandse zoogdieren in 2010: aantalsontwikkelingen tot 2010 van Nederlandse zoogieren (excl. vleermuizen) op grond van de gevoeligheid voor milieuthema's, 125 pp. Report Vereniging voor Zoogdierkunde en Zoogdierbescherming, Netherlands, report no. 8, 1993. V. Martens, Flora en Fauna 2030: Een studie naar het populatieverloop van vleermuizen in Nederland aan de hand van aantalsontwikkelingen in winterverblijven over de periode 1943-1992. Vleermuizen, 54 pp. Stichting Vleermuiswerkgroep Nederland, 1993 H.T.H.M. Meekes & S.C.V. Geelhoed, Climatic change: The possible consequences for migratory birds. A case study contribution to the LICC-Conference, December 1989. Lunteren, The Netherlands. Nature Conservation Department, Agricultural University Wageningen, 1989. H.P. van der Jeugd, Flora en Fauna 2030: Toekomstperspectief van de Nederlandse Broedvogels. Een extrapolatie van aantallen naar het jaar 2010, 74 pp. SOVON, Netherlands, 1993. Vlinderstichting, Flora en Fauna 2030, Achtergrondreeks, deel 4: Dagvlinders, 38 pp., Vlinderstichting, Wageningen, 1993 C.A.M. van Swaay, The Changing Climate: possible effects on butterflies.A case study contribution to the LICC-Conference, 2-7 December 1989. Lunteren, The Netherlands. Nature Conservation Department, Agricultural University Wageningen, 1991. M.T. Wasscher &J. van Tol, Flora en Fauna 2030: Veranderingen in het voorkomen van libellen (Odonata) in relatie tot geselecteerde milieuparameters, 40 pp. Stichting European Invertebrate Survey, Leiden, Netherlands, 1993 A.H. Ovaa, J. Latour & R. Reiling, Flora and Fauna 2030, Hoofdrapport: Lange termijn effecten van milieubeleid op flora en fauna: schattingen door middel van expert judgement, 31 pp. Wageningen Agricultural University & National Institute of Public Health and Environmental Protection, 1993. H. Ellenberg, Zeigerwerte der Gef~isspflanzen Mitteleuropas, 2nd edition. 122 pp. Scripta Geobotanica IX, G6ttingen, 1979. H. Ellenberg, H.E. Weber, R. Drill, V. Wirth, W. Werner & D. Paulissen Zeigerwerte von Pflanzen in Mitteleuropa, Scripta Geobotanica XVIII, 258 pp., Goltze Verlag, G6ttingen, 1992
Climate Change Research: Evaluation and Policy Implications S. Zwerver, R.S.A.R. van Rompaey, M.T.J. Kok and M.M. Berk, (Eds.) 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
725
Phenological reactions of D u t c h tree species to climate change described by a simulation model of the annual cycle
K. Kramer and G.M.J. Mohren
Institute for Forestry and Nature Research (IBN-DLO), P.O. Box 23, 6700 AA Wageningen, The Netherlands
Introduction
The relationships between climate and both phenology and growth of Dutch tree species were studied to evaluate the potential impacts of climate change on trees and forests in the Netherlands. In order to make such assessments, insight is required on the mechanisms how climatic variables interact with plant processes. The topics addressed in this study are: (1) the modelling of phenology; (2) the consequences of climate change on spring frost damage; (3) the importance of phenotypic plasticity; and (4) the impacts of climate change on growth.
1. MODELLING PHENOLOGY To evaluate the impacts of climate change on growth of temperate deciduous tree species, the onset and cessation of the growth must be accurately described. It was concluded that the timing of leaf unfolding could best be described by a model in which the effects of chilling temperatures (-5 to + 10~ and forcing temperatures (>0~ operate sequentially in time, according to a triangular and logistic function, respectively (Kramer 1994a).
2. SPRING FROST DAMAGE The effects of climatic warming to the probability of spring frost damage of Larix decidua, Betula pubescens, Tilia platyphylla, Fagus sylvatica, Tilia cordata, Quercus rubra, Quercus robur, Fraxinus excelsior, Quercus petraea, Picea abies and Pinus sylvestris in the Netherlands and in Germany were studied. It was concluded that for these species the probability of spring frost damage will decrease, provided the variability in temperature does not change (Figure 1, Kramer 1994b).
726
P(T< O ~ 0.6-
I
l e sequential 1 o alternating ]
0.4-
0.2-
I
-2
I
I
0
/~ T (~
I
I
*2
1
U
*4
Figure 1. Shift of the probability of sub-zero temperatures around the date of leaf unfolding of Fagus sylvatica on uniform temperature increase according to the sequential and alternating model.
3. PLASTICITY
To evaluate the potential response of individual trees to climatic warming, phenological observations of clones of Larix decidua, Betula pubescens, Tilia cordata, Populus canescens, Quercus robur, Fagus sylvatica and Picea abies transferred over a large latitudinal range in Europe were analyzed (Figure 2). It was found that these tree species possess a considerable plasticity and are able to respond phenotypically to a major change in their local climate. For the clones of Larix decidua and Quercus robur the growing season may shorten with increasing temperature, because leaf fall is advanced more than leaf unfolding. In Betula pubescens and Populus canescens, leaf unfolding and leaf fall are advanced equally, whereas in Tilia cordata and Fagus sylvatica the date of leaf fall seems to be unaltered but leaf unfolding advances with increasing temperature (Table 1). These differences in the duration of the growing season in response to increasing temperature may alter the competitive balance between the species in mixed stands (Kramer, in press).
727 Table 1 Shift of leaf unfolding (U) on mean winter temperature (Tw) and leaf fall (F) on mean summer temperature (Ts)
sty/sr,,
sF/sr=
d:
9~J
S
s"
9
t/~ .j"
Larix decidua Betula pubescens Tilia cordata Populus canescens Quercus robur Fagus sylvatica Picea abies
-2.8 -3.7 -2.8 -3.0 -1.7 -2.4 -3.5
-8.5 -3.0 -1.4 -3.8 -5.6 0.0
~,_.~
~ .i'
_
.~_.o
<~ ~'
._ ~ - % - - ~ ~ " ~i~.ill
~.,_.......~...-~ 9
oo
9 Oo
llll-
"~~ /
. . . ~ . ~ ',
~
.~_,
9
~
,"
~ ~0
;'
9 ollll . ~ -,,,O
....~'--------------~' '~
9
9
9
L"\ ~ .';~~II
9
9
9
9
9 ,~
"-', ~ ~ ~,~,
, .>~.'-..
<~
('/f
Figure 2. Location of the International Phenological Gardens.
4. GROWTH
The direct effects of increased atmospheric CO2, together with indirect effects,/.e. water relations, on growth of Picea abies were quantified, using a process-based forest growth model (FORGRO). The results indicated an increased response on growth of Picea abies to increasing CO2 under conditions of water shortage compared to the response in a potential growth situation. This effect is enhanced when the CO 2 increase is combined with a temperature rise possibly associated with the CO 2 induced climate change. These results were qualitatively confirmed by a similar study on Betula pubescens, Fagus sylvatica and Quercus robur, using several mechanistic models of photosynthesis and allocation with different levels of detail, and four climate change scenarios. However, quantitatively large differences were found between both the species, the scenarios and the models. The importance of phenology on the effects of climate change on growth of deciduous temperate-zone tree species was evaluated by a model comparison. The photosynthesis models used diverge in their response of annual gross photosynthesis the CO 2 concentration doubles, and the temperature increases by 2~ to 7~ they agree of differences caused by phenology ranging from 5% if the temperature rises 2~ to 20% if it rises 7~ (Figure 3). The corresponding figures are 5% and 13% when a mechanistic model for allocation of assimilates over the plant organs is used.
728
FORGRO
2.0
OSUM
GISS GFDL
1.5-
UKMO
1.0-
0.5-
0.0
I
0
I
1
rq Betula
I
2
I
3
8T (~
I
4
A Fagus
I
5
I
6
I
7
9 Quercus
Figure 3. Change in NPP relative to the current climate, given a 2x [CO2] and a range of temperature increases 5. REFERENCES
Kramer K., 1994a. Selecting a model to predict the onset of growth of Fagus sylvatica. Journal of Applied Ecology 31: 172-181. Kramer K., 1994b. A modelling analysis of the effects of climatic warming on the probability of spring frost damage to tree species in The Netherlands and Germany. Plant, Cell and Environment 17: 367-377. Mohren G.M.J., 1994. Modelling Norway spruce growth in relation to site conditions and atmospheric CO 2. In: Vegetation, Modelling and Climate Change Effects, F. Veroustraete & R. Ceulemans (eds.) SPB Academic Publishing bv. The Hague, The Netherlands. Kramer K., (in press). Phenotypic plasticity of seven European tree species, in relation to climatic warming. Plant, Cell and Environment. Kramer K. & Mohren G.M.J., (submitted). Sensitivity of FORGRO to climatic change scenarios. A case study on Betula pubescens, Fagus sylvatica and Quercus robur.
Climatic Change. Kramer K., (submitted). A modelling comparison to evaluate the importance of phenology on the effects of climate change on growth of temperate-zone deciduous trees. Climate Research.
Climate Change Research: Evaluation and Policy Implications S. Zwerver, R.S.A.R. van Rompaey, M.T.J. Kok and M.M. Berk, (Eds.) 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
729
The Role of Organic Soil Profiles on Water Availability in Forests: Sensitivity Analyses M.G. Schaap, W. Bouten and L.C. Kuiper Landscape and Environmental Research Group, University of Amsterdam, Nieuwe Prinsengracht 130, 1018VZ Amsterdam, The Netherlands
Abstract This research concerns the soil organic matter linked availability of water in forests on dry, sandy soils. Results show that changes in soil organic matter (SOM) storage influences soil water retention, especially at low SOM contents. Further the organic forest floor allows a significant evaporation flux from the forest floor (yearly max. 30% of the evapotranspiration). Sensitivity analyses show that forest transpiration is only indirectly affected by SOM. A change in water retention does hardly change the transpiration but can alter the strategies of water uptake by roots. Global changes can thus indirectly affect the vitality of forests although the effects may vary with soil type.
CLIMATIC
1. Introduction Forest growth and development is related to soil organic matter (SOM) dynamics and water supply. In order to estimate the sensitivity of forest development to climatic change, it is necessary to have the relations in figure 1 quantified. As a part of this research effort, we study organic matter linked water availability in forests on sandy soils. We presume that these forests are sensitive to climate change because 1) changing meteorological conditions may alter the supply of water and the transpiration demand, and 2) altered primary production and decomposition may change the accumulation of soil organic matter in the mineral soil and organic debris on the forest floor, both changing the water availability in the soil profile.
f
Forest
Development Soi~l
org. matter
~
"~
~ W'~ater availabilit!
CHANGE Figure 1. The relations between forest development, soil organic matter and water availability. Our project is represented by a black arrow.
730 In this project we focused only on the effects of different SOM levels on soil water availability. A high water availability leads to optimal transpiration and carbon assimilation. Soil organic matter influences forest hydrology in three ways"
A~
Changes in hydraulic functions of the mineral soil Changes in the amount of dead organic debris on the forest floor Adaption of the root system
B.
C.
Input nodes
Hidden nodes
Output nodes
1..J
1..K
1..L
x,
Wik
_
Wkl
Y2
X2--~
_
-
1.0
.........
Bias
Figure 2. General structure of the neural network as used in this project. Model input is represented with X, model output with Y. Using selected examples an optimizing algorithm takes care that the neural network 'learns' to predict Y from X without the need for an a-priory model.
2. Results We used a neural network to link soil water characteristics to organic matter contents, the density and textural properties of the soil. The new technique of neural networks allowed us to establish a more reliable model for the retention characteristic than with other methods. Retention characteristics were predicted for two soils of existing Douglas fir sites in the central part of the Netherlands. Both soils mainly differ in soil texture, resulting in a lower water retention in site 1 than in site 2 (figure 3). The organic matter contents were changed from 0 to 200 % of the present level. Water availability appears to increase with SOM, especially at low content. Figure 3 shows that the
731 difference between field capacity (0Fc) or the point of water uptake reduction (0R~D) and the wilting point (0w) is higher on site 2. The forest floor (FF) can be significant in water supply to trees because it can store large amounts of water (up to 20 mm) which can either be discharged to the root system or evaporated. With a two year monitoring program of FF water contents and evaporation we estimated a FF evaporation of 85 mm per year in a dense Douglas fir forest (site 2). Higher amounts are expected for forests with a lower canopy density. Root development is linked to soil organic matter because of the supply of water and nutrients and because of the mechanical limitations for root penetration at low porosities which only occur at very low SOM.
W a t e r retention c u r v e s
site 1
site 2
4.0
4.0 0% SOM
\
100% SOM 3.0
|
,--m
1i
200% SOM
3.0
\
c-
,2.'. o m ,..._,
2.0
9
2.0
E)RED
u_
|
o.
1.0
0,0 0.00
1.0
0.10
0.20
0.30
Water content [cma/cm 3]
0.40
0.0 0.00
0.10
0.20
0.30
0.40
Water content [cm3/cm 31
Figure 3A and B. Modeled water retention characteristics for site 1 and 2 as well as hydrologically relevant water contents. 0Fc: field capacity water content after free drainage in winter, 0RED point of reduced water uptake, 0w: wilting point.
3. Sensitivity analyses It is difficult to predict a-priory what the integrated effects SOM on the water availability will be because root water uptake is a process with many feedbacks. Answers can only be obtained with dynamic models calculating forest transpiration from altered soil properties and meteorological variables. We used the FORest HYDrological package (FORHYD) to perform sensitivity analyses of the transpiration of two Douglas fir forests
732 while varying the amount of soil organic matter, using the meteorological conditions of the past 30 years. Water availability was evaluated as the transpiration reduction (RED), calculated from the potential Makkink-transpiration (PT) and the actual transpiration (AT):
RED
:
I00
PT
- AT
PT
Figures 4A and B show the transpiration reduction as influenced by hydraulic properties which change with organic matter content. To produce these figures, only one property was varied at the time while the others were kept constant. It appears that the point of root water uptake reduction is the dominating factor. Further, the transpiration reduction increases with lower SOM. An increase of SOM above the present level hardly affects the reduction. The impact of SOM is greatest in site 2 which has a higher water availability. This is confirmed in the three dimensional diagrams which show the transpiration reduction when SOM is varied simultaneously with forest floor thickness or with root depth. A decrease in SOM increases the reduction more in site 2. This can be explained by the difference in effective storage: in figure 3A and B the mineral soil water content difference between field capacity and the wilting point is far greater in site 2 than in site 1. Therefore, the thickness of the forest floor is more important in site 1 than site 2 (fig. 5A and 5B) because this layer can supply a part of the desired water uptake. For the same reason the transpiration reduction decreases much more in site 1 than in site 2 if the rooting depth is varied (fig. 5C and 5D). A deeper extending root system allows more water uptake from the mineral soil. Due to the better water retention, site 2 has already sufficient water storage with a limited rooting depth, an increase of roots beyond 50 cm decreases the reduction less than site 1. Whether trees can extend roots to deeper soil layers depends mainly on penetration resistance or soil chemical limitations. The penetration resistance is determined by bulk density and organic matter content and to a lesser extent the soil texture. In fact, the rooting depth in site 1 was only 30 cm due to mechanical resistance and 200 cm in site 2, which leads to large differences in present transpiration reduction between the sites.
4. Conclusions Our research lead to quantification of the relation ships between soil water retention characteristics, soil organic matter content and soil texture. Soil texture was the main determining factor in the water retention characteristic, while SOM increases effective water storage, especially at low SOM contents (fig. 3A and B). However, sensitivity analyses show that forest transpiration is linked to SOM due to alteration of root water uptake effectiveness rather than altered soil water retention. Measurements showed that forest floor evaporation is higher than previously estimated. Yearly amounts may be as high as 30% of the evapotranspiration or 80-150 mm per year. Forest floor transpiration can thus cause a significant decrease in water
733 availability, especially in more open types of forest where wind speeds and radiation levels at the forest floor are high. Concluding it is expected that forests on uniformly textured poor (drift sand) soils are sensitive to forest floor thickness and root depth. Forests or, broadly textured (fiver or glacial) soils are more dependent on the amount of SOM in the mineral soil but have a high water holding capacity. Possible future changes in meteorological circumstances (rainfall and evaporation patterns) would therefore have a larger impact in the water availability of forests on uniformly textured soils. Changes in accumulation and decomposition of SOM would have a larger effect of forests with soils having broader textures. The research results still need to be integrated with predictions of SOM accumulation or decomposition dynamics and altered meteorological conditions due to climatic change.
Transpiration reduction Site 1
Site 2
60
~
35
'
'
BD
55
--e- -
pF
--e--
K(h)
\ \
30 X 25
~~
rr
~
45
40 .0.00
"~
~.~'
20
15 0.50
1.00 SOM amount
1.50 [%]
2.00
0
50
' 100 SOM amount
"
" 150
207.
[%]
Figure 4A,B. Transpiration reduction as affected by soil hydraulic properties varying with soil organic matter content. One property is varied at the time while the rest is kept constant, pF: water retention characteristic, K(h) hydraulic conductivity, BD: soil bulk density, 0RED point of water uptake reduction, All: all properties varied.
734
Site 1 .
.
.
Site 2 .
.
.
g
o
,'.._
,'
', ,'
',
'
'__
o
o ',
,
,
'',
,
,
"'
'
g
o m
.
',
',
~
o
o
7
m
o
"~
~
u3
~
m
[~o1 uop,0nP ~
o
mo
m
"
o
'
g
,,
)
.~>~
o
mm m ~ [%] uop,0npaEI
o
:
,
, K~ l
,i
,~
~ g
'<
o
,
00 ~o [%] uo!10npal::l
g
.~
o
~
o
~
"*
"~
[%] uo!10npeEI
o
'
/
o
g
o
o9
~o
Figure 5A-D. Transpiration reduction dependent on the simultaneous variation of mineral soil SOM and forest floor thickness (5A and B) and mineral soil SOM and root depth (5C and D).
Climate Change Research: Evaluation and Policy Implications S. Zwerver, R.S.A.R. van Rompaey, M.T.J. Kok and M.M. Berk, (Eds.) 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
735
Carbon allocation in mature grass ( L o f i u m p e r e n n e ) under elevated CO2 at two soil nitrogen levels. A. Gorissen, J.H. van Ginkel and H. van de Beek DLO-Research Institute for Agrobiology and Soil Fertility, P.O. Box 14, 6700 AA Wageningen, The Netherlands
Abstract The uptake of atmospheric carbon by terrestrial ecosystems may play an important role in the global carbon cycle since every 6-7 years the whole atmospheric carbon content passes through the plant biomass. Major uncertainties in this area concern the persistency of growth stimulation by elevated CO/and effects on carbon allocation to the soil compartment. In this study the effect of elevated C O / o n growth and carbon allocation of Lolium perenne was investigated. Plants were pretreated at 350 and 700/~L L ~ at two nitrogen levels (135 and 400 kg N ha -~yr -~) for 14 months and subsequently crosswise transferred to ESPAS-phytotrons for a short-term treatment at 350 and 700 ~L L -~ CO: for three weeks. The pretreatment stimulated total shoot growth until the end of the experiment, although no CO: pretreatment effects were observed in the yields of the last cut. The higher nitrogen level almost doubled shoot yield throughout the experiment. The fact that nitrogen stimulated shoot growth until the end of the experiment suggests that the disappearance of the growth stimulation of shoots by elevated CO/was not primarily caused by exhaustion of nitrogen or other nutrients in soil. The nitrogen effect on root growth showed an interaction with the CO2 pretreatment. At the lower nitrogen level root dry weight was not increased at 700/zL L -1 CO:, whereas at the higher nitrogen level a strong increase was observed. This interaction indicates that nitrogen may have important implications for stimulating effects of elevated CO: on root growth on the long-term and thus on carbon allocation to the soil.
1. INTRODUCTION The concentration of CO2 has steadily increased since the Industrial Revolution from 270 ttL L -I to the present value of about 355 #L L -1. The effects on crop yield have been surveyed by Kimball (1983), Cure & Acock (1986) and several others, who concluded that a doubling of the CO: concentration will probably result in an average increase of 30% in crop yield under optimal conditions. Bazzaz (1990) questioned whether such a stimulation would be prolonged in time, since plants adapt to changing circumstances and soil nutrients may be exhausted on the long-term. Although numerous studies have investigated the effects of elevated CO2 on plants, only few have also focussed on roots (Rogers et al., 1994). They described plant reactions on elevated CO2 with emphasis on the soil compartment and concluded that exploration of CO: effects on roots and soil needed strong attention since many uncertainties still have to be solved. The objectives of this study were i) to study the effect of elevated CO: on biomass production and carbon allocation in a perennial species exposed to elevated CO/for a long period, ii) to determine how the effects of elevated CO2 are affected by different nitrogen application rates.
736 2. MATERIALS AND METHODS
2.1. CO, treatments Lolium perenne cv 'Barlet' plants were cultivated from seed in 2-L columns. The columns were filled with Ede loamy sand with a bulk density of 1.2 kg 1-1 (dry weight) and soil moisture was adjusted to about 14% (w/w). All columns received 100 mg N (KNO3) at the start of the experiment. The plants were grown in two adjacent greenhouse compartments with ambient (about 350/zL L -~) and elevated (700 #L L ~) CO2 levels for 14 months (June 1992 September 1993) without additional light. During this pre-incubation period, in the following referred to as pretreatment, the CO2 levels were measured by an Ari-P analyzer (Siemens). The columns were watered weekly and at several dates readjusted to their initial weight with de-ionized water. In spring 1993 the nitrogen treatment was started, the lower nitrogen treatment receiving an amount of nitrogen corresponding with 135 kg N ha-~ yr-~ and the higher treatment corresponding with 400 kg N ha-1 yr-~. After the pretreatment 24 Lolium perenne plants were randomly selected and transferred to the ESPAS growth chambers (Experimental Soil Plant Atmosphere System. Half of the plants from each greenhouse compartment were placed in one ESPAS chamber and vice versa to distinguish between pretreatment and treatment effects. After three days of acclimatization, the plants were pulselabelled for one day with 14CO2. Due to a technical flaw the specific activities in the growth chambers are unknown. For this reason, the effects of the CO2 treatment on the total net CO2 uptake could not be measured. Nitrogen effect and CO2 pretreatment effect on total net uptake were not affected by this flaw, since these treatments were equally distributed among the systems. After the 1-day pulse-labelling the growth cabinets were flushed with fresh air and the plants were further treated with 350 or 700 ~L L -~ CO2 for three weeks. The preset atmospheric CO2 levels were maintained either by injecting CO2 or by removing it by carbosorb filters (Sodasorb, Grace). CO2 was supplied from gas cylinders (100% CO2) and the inflows were controlled automatically by means of Brooks flow controllers. CO2 levels were measured by an URAS 10E infrared analyzer (Hartmann & Braun). Temperatures in the growth chambers (shoot 20~ at day; 15~ at night; roots 16~ at day; 11~ at night) were measured by a platinum resistance thermometer Ptl00, relative humidity (70% at day; 80% at night) using a capacitive humidity sensor and irradiation (300 #mol m-2 s-~ at plant level) by means of a PAR-meter. Wind velocity was set at 0.1 m s-1. All environmental variables were checked with a third independent meter to assure identical conditions. Day/night rhythm was 16/8 h. Prior to CO2 treatment, the column lids were sealed with a silicon rubber (Q3-3481, Dow Chemical) to prevent exchange of x4CO2between growth chamber and soil columns. During the experiment, columns were flushed every 6 hours with CO2-free air at a flow rate of about 40 L h -a for 15 minutes, to prevent O2 deficiency and to remove CO2 from the soil. Root/soilrespired CO2 was trapped by conducting the air through a 300 mL 2 N NaOH solution. 2.2. Analyses Root/soil respiration was measured every third day by taking an aliquot of 1 mL of the NaOH solution and precipitating the HCO3-and CO32-ions with excess BaCI2. Total CO2 was determined by titrating the remaining NaOH with 0.2 N HCI. 1'CO2 was determined in a subsample by liquid scintillation counting using Ultima Gold (Packard). The plants were harvested after 21 growth days in the ESPAS growth chambers. Dry
737 weights of shoots and roots were determined after drying at 80~ for 24 hours. Dried plant material was ground and homogenized and a wet combustion procedure was used to determine total C and 14C. Plant material (30 mg) and soil (1 g) were digested with a 5 ml solution of 2.0 g K2Cr207 in 25 ml H2SO4 and H3PO4 (3/2 v/v) at 160~ for 2 hours. Released CO2 was trapped in 10 ml 1.0 N NaOH, and processed as described above.
3. RESULTS Figure 1 shows the cumulative shoot yields of Lolium perenne during the pretreatment. The first cut after sowing showed that the CO2 pretreatment had increased shoot growth by about 20% (P < 0.04). In the second season, after the N treatment started, this CO2 pretreatment effect could be observed until the end of the experiment, although the increase in total yield reduced to about 16% (P<0.01). The last cut before the treatment in the ESPAS growth chambers revealed no differences in yield anymore. From the very start of the nitrogen application in the second season, the 400 N treatment increased the shoot yield of the first cut by about 18% (P<0.01), independent of the CO2 pretreatment. The average increase amounted to about 65 % (P < 0.001) at the end of the experiment. The results after the CO2 treatment in the ESPAS growth chambers are shown in table 1. During this treatment the 400 N treatment increased shoot yield by about 91% compared with the 135 N treatment. The CO2 pretreatment strongly increased dry root weight at the end of
Lolium perenne
Yield (g) 30 f 25
.................................................................
20
............................................................
4~.....:... ~.. . . . .
f .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
6,*
0
10 135N-350C
20
.
'
30 40 Plant age (weeks) 135N-700C
s
.
........... : 0"-
o~
f ":.':: ..... /..'" .&
r 15 !- ...................................................... .
*
"/~o""
J
400N-350C
.
50
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
I
60
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
70
400N-700C
Figure 1. Yield of Lolium perenne during the pretreatment at 350 and 700 #L L -1 CO2 at two nitrogen levels (135 kg N ha-1 yr-1).
738 Table 1 Biomass (g) and shoot/root ratio after treatment of Lolium perenne with two nitrogen levels (135 and 400 kg N ha -1 yr -~) and with 350 #L L -1 CO2 and 700 #L L -1 CO2 for three weeks after applying a 14C-pulse-label at day 1 (n=3). Nitrogen level 135 350 350
Leaves Roots Shoot/root ratio
Statistics'
Leaves Roots Shoot/root ratio
5.4 4.5 1.2
700
4.9 4.5 1.1
N
< 0.001 < 0.001 ns
400 Pretreatment 700 350 700 Treatment 350 700 350 700 350 700
Plant biomass 5.5 10.5 4.6 7.5 1.2 1.4
6.8 4.5 1.5
P
11.2 10.2 1.1
10.4 14.9 0.7
T
interactions
ns 0.02
ns ns
N* P
ns
ns
10.9 18.2 0.6
1 N = Nitrogen; P-- Pretreatment; T = Treatment; ns---not significant.
the experiment, dependent on the nitrogen level. At 135 N no increase was observed at 700 CO2, whereas at 400 N dry root weight was strongly increased. The percent distribution of 14C among the different compartments is shown in table 2. The percentage recovered in the shoots and roots was not affected by any of the treatments. The percentage in the root/soil respiration decreased in the 400 N treatment by 29% compared with the 135 N treatment, but was unaffected by the other treatments. Also the percentage 14C recovered in the microbial biomass decreased from about 2 % to 1% in the 400 N treatment compared with the 135 N treatment. The residual I'C in soil was also decreased in the 400 N treatment compared to the 135 N treatment, whereas it was increased by 95 % in the 700 CO2 treatment compared with the 350 CO2 treatment. Although the main effect of the CO2 treatment can not be estimated (see above), the main effect of nitrogen showed a 150% increase at 400 N compared with 135 N. The CO2 pretreatment had no effect on total net CO2 uptake.
739 Table 2 Distribution of 14C (% of net total uptake) among different plant/soil compartments after treatment of Lolium perenne with two nitrogen levels (135 and 400 kg N ha -1 yr -1) and with 350/zL L -~ CO2 and 700/zL L -I CO2 for three weeks after applying a ~'C-pulse-label at day 1 (n-3). Nitrogen level 135
400 Pretreatment
350
Leaves Roots Root/soil respiration Microbial biomass Soil residue Shoot/root ratio 1'C Total net uptake (kBq)
700
350
700
350
700
350
Treatment 700 350
47.0 27.8 21.5
47.1 21.5 24.8
48.6 18.4 29.0
% distribution 48.4 56.1 12.9 24.4 33.6 16.9
1.9 1.8
2.1 4.5
2.3 1.7
2.7 2.5
1.2 1.4
1.2 2.4
1.5 0.7
0.5 1.5
1.9 178
2.4 94
2.7 160
3.7 92
2.5 435
3.0 171
3.2 362
1.6 327
Statistics 1
N
P
T
Leaves Roots Root/soil respiration Microbial biomass Soil residue
ns ns 0.03
ns ns ns
ns ns ns
< 0.001 ns
ns ns
ns ns
14C shoot/root ratio Total net uptake (kBq)
0.07 < 0.001
ns ns
ns nr
700
350
700
54.0 20.2 22.2
55.7 22.0 20.1
48.6 31.1 18.2
interactions
1 N = Nitrogen; P = Pretreatment; T = Treatment; ns = not significant; n r - not relevant
4. D I S C U S S I O N
Stimulating effects of CO2 have often been reported, but frequently doubts have been raised about the persistency on the long-term. Adaptation of the plants or exhaustion of soil nutrients could eventually reduce the initial stimulation. In this study some evidence was found that an initial stimulation of shoot growth was reduced during the second season. After 66 weeks the
740 cumulative shoot yield was still increased by 16% after an initial increase of about 20%. However, the last cut before the treatment in the ESPAS growth chambers revealed no differences in yield indicating that the growth stimulation, due to the pretreatment, had disappeared. The slopes in figure 1 support this conclusion since the rates of shoot biomass production are almost equal at the end of the experiment. It seems not plausible that nitrogen plays an important role in this reduction in growth stimulation, since it occurred at both nitrogen levels almost at the same time. Exhaustion of other soil nutrients or morphological/physiological adaptations of the plants are more likely explanations. The 400 N treatment stimulated shoot growth throughout the pretreatment and treatment. Although the amount applied was three times higher than in the 135 N treatment, the yield was almost doubled. The fact that nitrogen stimulated plant growth until the end of the experiment suggests that serious exhaustion of other nutrients did not occur. This implies that, with regard to the disappearance of the growth stimulation by elevated CO2, probably other mechanisms play a role than exhaustion of soil nutrients. In contrast to shoot yield, a strong interaction between nitrogen and CO2 pretreatment was observed for root dry weights. In the 400 N treatment root dry weight strongly increased by 46 % at 700 CO2, whereas no increase was found at 135 N. Summarizing, at the low nitrogen level growth stimulation by CO2 disappeared both in shoots and roots, whereas at the high nitrogen level only the root growth was still stimulated by elevated CO2. This was also expressed in the s/r ratio (Table 1) which was lowest in the 400 N/700 CO2 pretreatment. The interactions with the CO2 treatments indicate that nutrients such as nitrogen, apart from acclimation, may have important implications for stimulating effects of CO2 on the longer term especially with regard to the carbon storage capacity of terrestrial ecosystems. Also with regard to a possible decrease in decomposition rates of litter (CoOteaux et al., 1991; Cotrufo et al., 1994) and roots (Gorissen et al., 1994) the availability of nitrogen may play a key role in the sequestration capacities of natural ecosystems.
5. REFERENCES
Bazzaz FA. 1990. The response of natural ecosystems to the rising global CO2 levels. Annual Review of Ecological Systems, 21, 167-196. Cotrufo MF, Ineson P. and Rowland AP. 1994. Decomposition of tree leaf litters grown under elevated CO2: Effects of litter quality. Plant and Soil, 163, 121-130. Co0teaux MM, Mousseau M, C616rier ML and Bottner P. 1991. Increased atmospheric CO2 and litter quality: decomposition of sweet chestnut leaf litter with animal food webs of different complexities. Oikos 61, 54-64. Cure JD and Acock B. 1986. Crop responses to carbon dioxide doubling: A literature survey. Agriculture and Forest Meteorology, 38, 127-145. Gorissen A, Van Ginkel HJ, Keurentjes JJB and Van Veen JA. 1994. Grass root decomposition is retarded when grass has been grown under elevated CO2. Soil Biology & Biochemistry (in press). Kimball BA. 1983. Carbon dioxide and agricultural yield. An assemblage and analysis of 430 prior observations. Agronomy Journal, 75, 779-788. Rogers HH and Runion GB. 1994. Plant responses to atmospheric CO2 enrichment with emphasis on roots and the rhizosphere. Environmental Pollution, 83, 155-189.
Climate Change Research: Evaluation and Policy Implications S. Zwerver, R.S.A.R. van Rompaey, M.T.J. Kok and M.M. Berk, (Eds.) 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
741
WHEAT AND MAIZE PRODUCTION IN HUNGARY UNDER DOUBLED ATMOSPHERIC CO2 CONCENTRATION M. Hunk~ Zemankovics a and ZS. Bacsi b a Agrometeorological Research Station of the Hungarian Meteorological Service, Keszthely, P.O.Box. 80. H-8361, Hungary b Pannon Agricultural University, Keszthely, P.O.Box.71. H-8361 ,Hungary Abstract
The present investigation aims at asseseing the impacts of three well known climate change scenarios - the carbon dioxide doubling scenarios from the GISS, GFDL and UKMO general circulation models - on wheat and maize yields in Hungary. For this purpose the monthly outputs for global radiation, temperature and precipitation of the above three GCMs were used to create daily weather time series for Hungary. Climatic data scenarios were chosen from the gridbox which covers the location of Keszthely. Historical weather data of 16 years from Keszthely were used as baseline. These were used together with the CERES-Wheat and CERES-Maize crop growth simulation models. The validation of crop models is based on field experiment data from Keszthely. Statistical analysis of simulated crop data is presented. Comparing to the baseline the average wheat yield shows 13-25 % decrease in spite of the slightly increase of total biomass production according to different GCM scenarios. In case of maize the GISS scenario resulted in a small 8 % yield increase on the average, while the GFDL and UKMO resulted in 7% and 14 % yield decrease respectively. Yield decreasing mainly due to the shortened length of growing period. 1.THE CREATION OF THE CLIMATE CHANGE SCENARIOS Outputs from three General Circulation Models were used to create climate change weather scenarios. These are: -GISS (Goddard Institute for Space Studies, New York,U.S.A. [ 1], -GFDL (Geophysical and Fluid Dynamics Laboratory, Princeton, U.S.A. [2], - UKMO ( United Kingdom Meteorological Office, Bracknell, U.K. [3]. All the three applied GCM are so called equilibrum models and they have their limitations regarding spatial resolution. The GISS handles the earth's surface as gridboxes of the size 10 ~ latidude x 7.9 ~ longitude. The climate of each gridbox is considered to be homogeneous, and the climate characteristics are allocated to the gridbox centre. The GFDL works similarly with gridboxes of 4.5~ x 7.5~ and the UKMO with gridboxes of 5~ x 7.5~ In the present study the gridbox covering the location of Keszthely (46.4~ 17.3~ was used with each
742 GCM, thus for GISS the gridbox with the centre 50~176 for GFDL the gridbox with the centre 46.7~176 for UKMO the gridbox with the centre 47.5~176 Regarding temporal resolution, the three GCMs are capable of calculating the weather of a year as monthly average values at most detail. Since the GCMs are inaccurate in simulation of the present climate, so the climate charactherstics simulated under changed greenhouse gas concentrations are also rather unreliable. Therefore we used the rate of changes instead of the absolut values of predicted climatic variables. The "baseline" weather was taken from the location of Keszthely from the period 1975-1990. The change factor was calculated as the difference between the 'future' and 'present' values for temperature, and as the ratio for radiation and precipitation, in agreement with the recommended methodology of many similar impact assesment studies [4],[5],[6]. As the crop growth simulation models require daily weather data and the climate model outputs present the results only in monthly resolutions, the baseline daily weather data were modified by the change factor of the corresponding month to create climate change scenarios with daily resolutions. 2. CROP GROWTH SIMULATION MODELS
The growth and development of the winter wheat and maize crop were assesed using the CERES Wheat and CERES Maize models [7],[8]. Soil and plant characteristics required as input data were chosen according to typical ones for the location of Keszthely as well as the agrotechnology data like the date of sowing. Before starting the climate change experiment the validation of the models had been carried out. In the case of CERES Maize the average differences between the predicted and observed plant variables were less than 4 % [9] and for CERES Wheat the average difference is about 6 % [ 10]. In order to compare the impact of the changed weather on the crops the agrotechnology was assumed constant for all simulation experiments. In the simulation runs the following agrotechnology parameters were used" sowing on 10 October with MV-4 winter wheat variety for the wheat model, and sowing on 20 April with Pioneer 3901 variety for the maize model. For both crops optimal nitrogen supply was assumed, and no irrigation was applied. 3. RESULTS The outputs from the CERES crop models were used for the impact assessments, that is, for both wheat and maize the simulated values of resultant variables under the baseline weather were compared to the simulated values of the same variables under the climate change weather scenarios generated from the three ~ s . The following resultant variables
743 were considered in the assessment: the grain yield (t/ha), the amount of above ground biomass (t/ha), maturity date. 3.1 MAIZE
In the maize experiments altogether 16 baseline weather years were available together with 16 GISS-years, 16 GFDL-years and 16 UKMO-years. The climate change scenarios resulted in maturity occuring much earlier, and thus the growing season became significantly shorter for all the three different ~ s . Biomass and grain yield show somewhat less unanimous results. The GISS scenario resulted in a small, 8% yield increase on the average, while the GFDL resulted 7%, and the UKMO in a 14 % yield decrease. In biomass production the GISS and the GFDL scenarios resulted small increase while the UKMO scenario resulted small decrease. For all the three GCM scenarios the standard deviations of the yield are somewhat smaller than for the baseline weather (table 1.). Table 1 The averages and the standard deviations of the simulated resultant variables of maize for different scenarios Maturity date (day of the year) avg. Base GISS GFDL UKMO
248 225 212 207
Grain yield (t/ha)
Biomass (t/ha)
std.
avg.
std.
avg.
std.
18.0 5.3 3.8 7.0
8.57 9.29 7.96 7.35
3.35 1.07 0.90 2.20
15.95 17.29 16.10 15.25
3.89 1.20 1.16 3.25
3.2 WINTER WHEAT In the wheat experiments altogether 15 baseline weather years were available together with 15 GISS-years, 15 GFDL-years and 15 UKMO-years. Results showed that similar to maize the maturity dates occured earlier and the growing season became significantly shorter for all of the climate change scenarios. The fastest crop development occured in the case of the UKMO scenario, with an average of 42 clays shorter period from sowing to maturity in comparison to the baseline, while under the GFDL scenario maturity occured 25 days earlier on the average, and under GISS scenario 22 days earlier in average than under the baseline weather. The average biomass production slightly increased for all the three climate change
744 scenarios, and the standard deviation decreased. In the case of grain yield the GISS scenario resulted in a yield decrease of 13 %, the GISS scenario resulted 28 % decrease and the UKMO scenario 25 % decrease. Standard deviation of crop variables decreased for all the three GCM scenarios comparing to the baseline. (see table 2.) Summarizing that equilibrium GCM scenarios give a significant warmer climate with moderately higher precipitation amounts. These conditions seem to be favourable for total biomass production but unfavourable for grain filling processes. Table 2 The averages and standard deviations of the simulated resultant variables of winter wheat for different scenarios Maturity date (day of the year)
Base GISS GFDL UKMO
Grain yield (t/ha)
Biomass (t/ha)
avg.
std.
avg.
std.
avg.
std.
193 171 169 151
5.5 5.5 5.1 5.3
6.28 5.44 4.49 4.73
0.85 0.62 0.50 0.68
17.45 18.34 17.75 18.58
2.02 1.47 1.82 1.21
4. REFERENCES
9 10
J.Hansen, I. Fung, A. Laces, S. Lebedeff, D. Rind, R. Ruedy and G. Russet, J.Geophysic. Res., 93 (1988) 9341. R.T. Wetherald, and S. Manabe, Climatic Change, 8 (1986) 5. C.A. Wilson and J.F.B. Mitchell, J. Geophysic. Res. 92 (1987) 13315. M.L. Parry, T.R. Carter and N.T. Konijn (eds.), The Impact of Climatic Variations on Agriculture. Vol. 1. Kluwer Academic Press, 1988. J.B. Smith and J.A. Tirpak (eds.), The Potential Effects of Global Climate Change on the United States. EPA, Washington, DC., 1989. R.M. Adams, C.Rosenzweig, R.M. Peart, J.T.Ritchie, B.A. McCarl, J.D. Glyer, R.B. Curry, J.W. Jones, K.J. Boote and L.H.Jr. Allen, Nature, 345 (1990) 219. D.C. Godwin, J.T. Ritchie, U. Singh and L. Hunt, A User's Guide to CERES Wheat-V2.10. Muscle Shoals, Alabama: International Fertilizer Development Centre, 1989. S.A. Jones and J.R. Kiniry, CERES Maize: A Simulation Model of the Growth and Development of Maize. Texas A&M University Press, College Station, Texas, 1986. M. Hunk~,Id6j~is, 98 (1994)37. ZS. Bacsi and M. Hunker,, Id6j~is, 98 (1994) 119.
Climate Change Research: Evaluation and Policy Implications S. Zwerver, R.S.A.R. van Rompaey, M.T.J. Kok and M.M. Berk, (Eds.) 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
745
Effects of climate change on yield potential of wheat and maize crops in the European Union J. Wolf a and C.A. van Diepen b a Department of Theoretical Production Ecology, Wageningen Agricultural University, Bornse steeg 65, P.O. Box 430, 6700 AK Wageningen, the Netherlands b
DLO the Winand Staring Centre, P.O. Box 125, 6700 AC Wageningen, the Netherlands
Abstract Yields of winter wheat, silage maize and grain maize in the main arable areas of the European Union (E.U.) were calculated with a simulation model, WOFOST, using historical weather data and average soil characteristics. The sensitivity of the model to individual weather variables was determined.Subsequent analyses were made using climate change scenarios with and without the direct effects of increased atmospheric CO 2. The impact of crop management in a changed climate was also assessed. The various climate change scenarios used appear to yield considerably different changes in yield, both for each location and for the E.U. as a whole.
1. Introduction Any changes in climate which may result from increasing concentration of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere could have dramatic consequences for the agricultural yield potential. In this study that formed a part of the E.U. funded EPOCH project, the effects of climate change on the yields of winterwheat, silage maize and grain maize were analysed. In the EPOCH project as a whole the effects of climate change on agriculture and horticulture in the E.U. have been investigated by scientists from nine research institutes in the E.U. The main tasks in this project were: 1. construction of scenarios of climate change; 2. broadscale analysis of the effects of climate change on selected crops; 3. site-specific analysis of the effects of climate change on crop phenology and yields with crop growth simulation models; 4. experimental investigation of the effects of CO 2 enrichment and temperature on crop growth.
2. Model and input data A dynamic crop growth model, WOFOST, developed for calculating agricultural yield potential [ 1] was used. In the model, crop growth is simulated from sowing to maturity on the basis of physiological processes as determined by the crop's response to environmental conditions. The simulation is carried in time steps of one day. The major processes considered are CO 2 assimilation, respiration, partitioning of assimilates to various plant organs, transpiration and phenological development. Two levels of crop yield are calculated: the water limited yield which can be realized in situations where the supply of plant nutrients and crop management are optimum and secondly the potential yield which can be realized if also the water supply is optimum. In order to apply the model data that specify crop growth and phenological development are required including information on properties that determine assimilation and respiration processes and response to moisture stress, partitioning of assimilates to plant organs, life span of leaves and death rates of plant organs. This information is
746 derived from the literature and field experiments. Calculations of crop growth were made for historical sets of daily weather data from 20 meteorological stations. For each of the stations that are representative of the main arable land areas in all E.U. countries, the weather data set covered generally the period 1966-1985. In order to calculate the soil water balance, the soil's physical characteristics such as effective soil depth, soil moisture characteristics and hydraulic conductivity must be known. For each meteorological station the main soil types that occur on arable land areas within a radius of 100 to 150 km around the station, were obtained from the soil map of the European Communities. By interpreting the information per soil type quantitative terms for use in the simulation model could be obtained.
3. S c e n a r i o data In order to calculate crop growth in future the historical weather data were changed on the basis of climate change scenarios. Two different types of scenarios have been applied. Firstly, the composite time-dependent scenarios that were based on the average standardized output of seven equilibrium GCM's.This output resulted in a regional pattern of climate change. By using estimates of global mean warming for the various IPCC emission scenarios (in this study scenario A (i.e. business-as-usual emission scenario) for the years 2010, 2030 and 2050 and scenario A High (high estimate of climate change for scenario A) for year 2050 [2] ) which were calculated with a simple climate model, the GCM-derived regional patterns could be scaled up to obtain the time-dependent changes in climate [3]. Secondly, the individual scenarios that were based on output from three equilibrium 2"CO2 GCM's, i.e. GFDL, GISS and UKMO-L models. 4. R e s u l t s Variables that determine crop yield directly, are atmospheric CO 2 concentration, solar radiation and temperature and those that affect the water balance and hence the degree of drought stress are rainfall, windspeed, vapour pressure and again the other three variables. These variables were adjusted separately, in a stepwise manner, in order to gauge the sensitivity of crop yields to changing values of each. This sensitivity analysis was carried out for winter wheat on three locations, i.e. Kinloss, Orleans and Brindisi that cover the main differences in climate in the E.U. (Table 1). Table 1 Sensitivity of potential (POT) and water-limited (WAT) grain yields of winterwheat in Kinloss, U.K., Orleans, France and Brindisi, Italy to increasing values for atmospheric CO 2 concentration (C), temperature (T), rainfall (R), solar radiation (S), windspeed (W) and vapour pressure (V) 1 (Source = [4]).
POT WAT
C
T
R
S
W
V
++ ++
--,02 __,+3
0 ++
+,++ _
0 __
0 ++
1 0, +, ++ : no, moderate, strong increase in grain yield; - -- : moderate, strong decrease in grain yield. 2 Temperature effect varies from about zero in Kinloss to strongly negative in Brindisi. 3 Temperature effect varies from strongly and moderately negative in Kinloss and Orleans, respectively to moderately positive in Brindisi.
747
10000
]
.oooi 6000 r
4000 2000
0
|
Present
|
A2010
A2030
A2050 Ahigh2050
Figure 1. Average potential (Pot.) and water limited (Wat.) grain yields of winter wheat cultivated at current and at future climate conditions (based on composite scenarios A and A High) in Kinloss, U.K., Orleans, France and Brindisi, Italy, taking into account the direct effect of increasing atmospheric CO 2 in future (Source = [4]).
<-1500
-1500<
<-500
<.v) -500<
500<
<500
<1500
> 1500
o-
. . . . . F------. .~
lc,
__/
?.
Figure 2. Changes in water limited grain yield (kg ha "l dry matter) of winter wheat in the main arable land areas in the E.U. if the weather is changed on the basis of the GISS equilibrium 2'CO 2 scenario and the direct effect of increased CO2 is taken into account (Source = [4]).
748 Potential and water limited grain yields of winter wheat were calculated for historical weather data that were changed on the basis of composite scenarios A and A High (Fig. 1), taking also into account the direct effect of increasing atmospheric CO 2 concentration. Both potential and water-limited yield levels appear to increase greatly over time, mainly as a result of increasing CO 2. For scenario A High that gives the largest increase in temperature, the yield increase is somewhat less than that for scenario A for the same year. If water limited grain yields were calculated for the individual scenarios and the direct effect of increased CO 2 (from 353 to 560 ppm) was taken into account, the GISS scenario gave major yield increases for most locations in the E.U., mainly as a result of CO 2 enrichment (Fig. 2). The GFDL scenario on the other hand, gave yield decreases for the western part of the E.U. (Fig. 3).
<-1500
9 - 1500<
-500<
t-<..../
500<
<500
< 1500
> 1500
9 "--~....,.//
!
<-500
--,. ...... /
/
/
o~o_%_ ~oo .~oo 400 ~~o ~r, 110'
15" L
Figure 3. Changes in water limited grain yield (kg ha -1 dry matter) of winter wheat in the main arable land areas in the E.U. if the weather is changed on the basis of the GFDL equilibrium 2'CO 2 scenario and the direct effect of increased CO 2 is taken into account (Source = [4]). If climate changes, present crop management may be inadequate for the new climate conditions. A number of management responses and their potential usefulness in adapting to the adverse effects of climate change were evaluated. Firstly, yields were calculated for crop varieties that differ with respect to their temperature sum requirements for phenological development. Secondly, amounts of irrigation water required to attain the potential yield level were determined (Table 2). They increase with climate change but decrease if also the direct effect of increased atmospheric CO 2 is taken into account. Finally, the impact of changes in sowing date on the yield level of for example silage maize
749 were determined (Fig. 4). In a changed climate the optimum day for sowing appears to move to an earlier date. Table 2 Required amounts of irrigation water (mm) for attaining the potential yield level of grain maize on three locations in the E.U., both for historical climate and for scenario climate with and without direct CO 2 effect (Source = [5]). Location
Hist. climate
Brindisi, Italy Mannheim, Germany Orleans, France
Scen. A 2050
382 92 157
Scen. A 2050 + CO 2
400 109 211
326 66 147
24000
22000
20000
18000 Orleans Hist.
---o----
Orleans A
16000
14000
Orleans A
40
.
. 6'0
.
8'0
.
High . 1;0
.
120
140
160
Sowing date
Figure 4. Sensitivity to changes in sowing date of the average potential total yield of silage maize cultivated in Orleans, France. Yields have been established for historical weather data (Hist.) and for composite scenarios A and A High for the year 2050 (A and A High) (Source = [6]). 5. C o n c l u s i o n s - Various climate change scenarios appear to yield considerable different changes in yield both for each location and for the E.U. as a whole; - The direct effect of increasing atmospheric CO 2 on wheat grain yield appears to be much greater than the effect of climate change; The average water limited grain yield of winter wheat in the E.U. increases by 1000, 1300 and 2300 kg ha -1 dry matter for the UKMO-L, GFDL and GISS scenarios respectively (based on calculated yield changes and the present area distribution in the E.U.) if the direct effect of increased CO 2 is taken into account; - The average potential grain yield of maize in the E.U. decreases by 2000, 2800 and 2800 kg ha -1 dry matter for the GISS, GFDL and UKMO-L scenarios respectively; -
750 -
The average water limited total yield of silage maize in the E.U. decreases by 600, 2500 and 6300 kg ha -1 dry matter for the GISS, UKMO-L and GFDL scenarios respectively if the direct effect of increased CO 2 is taken into account.
For more information on this study it is referred to [4], [5] and [6]. Complete reports on this study can be obtained from the first author. Results from the EPOCH project are given in a special issue of the European Journal of Agronomy (1993-2(4) ). 6.
References
1 Diepen C.A. van, WolfJ., Keulen H. van and Rappoldt C., 1989. WOFOST: a simulation model of crop production. Soil Use and Management 5:16-24. 2 Houghton J.T., Jenkins G.J. and Ephraums J.J. (Eds.), 1990. Climate change: the IPCC scientific assessment. Report of working group I of the intergovernmental panel on climate change. Cambridge university press, Cambridge. 3 Barrow E.M., 1993. Scenarios of climate change for the European Community. European Journal of Agronomy 2: 247-260. 4 Wolf J., 1993. Effects of climate change on wheat production potential in the European Community. European Journal of Agronomy 2:281-292. 5 Wolf J. and Diepen C.A. van, 1994. Effects of climate change on grain maize yield potential in the European Community. Climatic Change, in press. 6 Wolf J. and Diepen C.A. van, 1994. Effects of climate change on silage maize production potential in the E.C. Agricultural and Forest Meteorology 71: 33-60.
Climate Change Research: Evaluation and Policy Implications S. Zwerver, R.S.A.R. van Rompaey, M.T.J. Kok and M.M. Berk, (Eds.) 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
751
Mediterranean soilscapes and climatic change. An overview J.J. Ib~ifieza, A. Garcia-Alvarez a, J.L. Gonz~ilez Rebollar a and A.C. Imeson b aCentro de Ciencias Medioambientales (CSIC), Serrano 115 bis, 28006 Madrid, Spain. bFysisch Geografisch Bodemkunding Laboratorium, Universiteit van Am~erdam, Nieuwe Prinsengracht 130, 1018 VZ Amsterdam, The Netherlands
Abstract Despite the reduced extension and spatial fragmentations of the Mediterranean region, its biogeodiversity (biologic, edaphic, geomorphic, climatic and hydrologic) is among the highest of the planet. Quantitative data published recently show great links between arid and Mediterranean soilscapes. Mediterranean soilscapes are extremely fragile and therefore potential changes due to climatic and anthropic causes may lead to desertification. Thus, future CO2 warming will increase current desertization processes. Land degradation in arid and semiarid Mediterranean regions (rainfall less than 600 ram) is highly analogous to desertification. 1. GENERAL CHARACTERISTICS: MEDITERRANEAN LANDSCAPES AND CLIMATE CHANGE
The Mediterranean climate currently affects approximately 9,000,000 km 2 (4.6% of the continental lithosphere or 3.3% of the global pedosphere). Mediterranean ecosystems are distributed over Mediterranean Basin, California, Chile, South Africa and Australia. About 3/4 of Meditarreanean basin area enjoys a Mediterranean climate whilst 1/4 suffers greater aridity. The Mediterranean camlot be regarded as a homogeneous morphoclimatic region. A relatively wide range of marked climatic zones exist between wet and arid. In general, the Mediterranean region is characterized by generally warm temperatures, winter or spring and autumn-dominated rainfall, dry and hot summers (of at least two or three months and up to 11 months) and a profusion of microclimates due to local terrain. Mean annual rainfall can vary from 20-25 mm in the "Mediterranean deserts" to 2000-2500 mm on mountain slopes or local maritime areas exposed to rain-bearing winds. Temperature varies widely with latitude, altitude and continentality: the annual mean may drop below 10 C or rise above 25 C. In parallel with these mean conditions the intra-annual and inter-annual climatic variability is very high, with sudden and high intensity rainfall. According to the World Bioclimatic Classification System proposed by Rivas-Martinez [1], the Mediterranean climate has the highest diversity of bioclimatic belts in the world. The Mediterranean area is especially vulnerable to climatic change. The impact of CO 2induced climatic change is potentially serious because of the aridity, the low rates of primary production in the drier areas, the sensitivity of the soils to degradation and erosion, and the high risk of drought and fire. The increase in aridity however is not necessarily caused by decreases in annual precipitation. Increasing aridity can be due to: (a) higher
752 evapotranspiration; (b) a change in the frequency and magnitude of rainfall events; (c) processes of soil degradation that decrease the ability of soil to retain water [2]. Simulation models of the atmosphere's general flow predict that a doubling of the greenhouse gas concentration compared to pre-industrial periods would bring a mean worldwide temperature increase between 3 and 5.5 C [2]. Precipitation predictions are different for different GMC models. The GISS model indicates an increase in general precipitation for the Mediterranean Basin. The BMO model predicts a decrease in precipitation. Both models suggest an increment in potential evapotranspiration of 200 mm~ which may cause an extension of the period with a rainfall deficit and a very large increase in soil moisture deficit [2]. 2. M E D I T E R R A N E A N SOILSCAPES AND SOIL GENESIS 2.1. Mediterranean soils and climate
Duchaufour [3] distinguishes two types of soil characteristic in Mediterranean regions. Thus, when phytoclimatic conditions are relatively moist, the development of Alfisols [4] is common. On the other hand, hi arid and semiarid Mediterranean environments, the most representative soils are Haploxeroll, Argixeroll and Calcixeroll [4]. In view of the large variety of subclimates that can be included within the Mediterranean climate, it is not surprising that pedoclimates and, more specifically, humidity regimes, may be aridic, xeric and even udic in the high mountahls. The dry period causes characteristic rubification of many Mediterranean soils. Incomplete profile leaclfing also allows frequent horizon genesis with accumulation of carbonates raider the Bt horizons [3]. More acidic, weathered profiles develop on the oldest, most stable geomorphological Palaeosurfaces. These are or the Xerult and Ultic Xeralf [3, 4]. In these circumstances, the base of the Bt horizons has become silted up with clay. Impenneabilization induced by this process has the genesis ofhydromorphic features and aquic regimes as a corollary. In arid and semiarid Mediterranean subclimates highly developed, shallow calcic horizons are also characteristic. Likewise, wetting-drying cycles encourage hardening of the horizons with accumulation of carbonates, giving rise to the formation of petrocalcic horizons or calcretes [3]. In the most arid subclimates, caliche accumulation can resuk from the deposition of dust material. Under special conditions a distinct caliche layer can develop within several months. Where petrocalcic horizons are situated at or near the soil surface they can have serious implications for hydrology. Salt accumulation is most severe in arid and semi-arid subclimates (receiving between 300 and 600 mm of rainfall). However, this salt accumulation becomes less impoltant in areas where precipitation drops below this level [5]. Another typical characteristic of Mediterranean environments is the low organic matter content of surface horizons, so they rarely overcome the state of ochric epipedon. This is why unevolved soils conserve a large part of the properties of their original material. In some cases, the effects of small changes in the supply and mineralization of organic matter could have a large impact on soil structure and greatly influence soil and hillslope hydrology. Soils having low organic matter contents are less stable and therefore have a lower infiltration capacity. Soils that contain low amounts of organic matter can respond by slaking, swelling, dispersion, cracking and mellowing, when they are wetted, and because of this can develop surface seals or crust. Ill dispersive soils, physico-chemical characteristics may trigger piping erosion which creates a positive feedback of pipe collapse producing rill and gully incision [6]. Finally, undeveloped shallow soils (Entisols with umbric epipedons, adjacent to Inceptisols
753 and Histosols) predominate in Mediterranean mountain climates. [7].
2.2. Quantitative analysis of Mediterranean soilscapes Ib~iiiez et al. [8], have studied the Mediterranean soil landscapes, on a global level using the data compiled by the FAO [9, 10]. This information served to draw up a matrix on which Minimum Spanning Tree and cluster analysis were performed (Figs. 1 and 2). Close connections between soilscapes of arid and Mediterranean environments become apparent [8]. There are marked, though lesser, sinailarities between Mediterranean and other bordering climate zones. Moreover, a common trait of Mediterranean and arid climate zones is that they both present intermediate evolution soils (Calcisols and Cambisols). These latter two climate types however, are identified by the greater abundance of shallow and saline soils in arid environments and by that of other more developed ones in Mediterranean environments (Luvisols and Planosols) [8]. Results of Minimum Spanning Tree for climate zones (Fig. 2), clearly reflect how soilscapes link in a very well defined latitudinal gradient. References are frequently found in the literature to most characteristic pedogenetic processes of certain environments [3], [11]. However, these canonic types of pedogenesis are not necessarily those underlying soil typological units of greatest land representation. Soilscapes of Meditenanean climates are usually associated to the presence of Luvisols and Vertisols [3], [9]. Cambisols are also frequent [11]. However, Mediterranean soilscapes are very rich and quite diverse for the small surface area covered by this type of climate [8]. Likewise, if the Soil Map of the World at 1:25,000,000 scale [9] is analyzed, different Mediterranean regions in the world can be seen to have quite different soilscapes. They are products of their respective geological and palaeo-environmental histories [8]. In fact, Ve~isols (3.5%) and Luvisols (15.6%) otfly occupy a small area of these territories, with Calcisols (20.3%) and Cambisols (16.2%) being the dominant soil types. Thus, when analyzing global soil patterns, the concept of canonic soil types and/or canonic pedogenetic processes should be supplemented with that of territorially canonic soils types (those with greater territorial representation) [8]. On a World level, despite the small area of the Mediterranean landscapes, their pedodiversity or richness (number of soil typological units -STU- according a FAO keys of 1989) is outstanding. Moreover, after tile mountain soilscapes, the STU density (richness/area unit) of the Mediterranean pedosphere is the greatest [8]. In other words, Mediterranean and mountain climates have a STU density far higher than that of the climatic types of the rest of the world considered by these authors [8]. Therefore these two climatic types, at global level, have a diversity which is not in consonance with the area they occupy. Ibfifiez eta/. [12] also show that soil richness of countries in the Mediterranean Basin are higher than those in temperate and cold environments in central and northern EU countries (Fig. 3). 2.3. Soils and greenhouse effect Climatic changes associated with all increase in CO 2 are comparable to differences in climate that occur locally as a result, for example, of relief and exposure. Unless threshold factors are involved, it is not thought likely that CO2-induced climatic changes will result in a major shift ill the boundalies between soil types. Tile soil contains elements which vary in age from a few weeks (e.g. nutrient concentrations) to tens of thousands of years (e.g. oxic horizons). Many soil characteristics, therefore, reflect the operations of soil-forming processes under a wide range of former
754 climatic conditions; because these conditions differed much more t~om the present climate than the climate predicted for a doubling of CO 2 concentration, these characteristics are not expected to be influenced to a degree that requires consideration [2]. The envisaged changes in climate are likely to have the greatest short-term (50 years) impact through the effect they have on: (a) the salt balance and salt composition of the soil; (b) the chemical precipitation of Ca/Mg carbonates in soil; (c) processes associated with the supply and breakdown of orgalfiC matter [2]. The changes in these processes might not be very significant for the long-term morphological evolution of the soil, but they are undoubtedly important with respect to soil ecology, soil hydrology, soil erosion and land uses. For example, the response of soil aggregates to wetting by rainfall is extremely sensitive to the chemistry of the soil solution and to microbial activity [5]. Slight changes brought about, for example, by longer dry seasons or changing atmospheric deposition may lead to changes in the soil structure which dramatically alter the hydrology and nutrient balance of the soil. For instance, destabilized soil aggregates break down to form surface seals or crusts. When soil surfaces are sealed by chests, the infiltration capacity becomes reduced and overland flow occurs at lower threshold amounts of rainfall. Thus, all increase in aridity would increase the area of soils having unfavourable infiltration characteristics and higher soil erodibility values. In sub-humid and semi-arid climatic zones, a general decrease in precipitation or increase ill evapotranspiration will cause an increase in the area of soils affected by saline or sodic conditions. These changes in salt accumulation could lead to an increase in the area of soils affected by vertic conditions and physical deterioration. 2.4. Soil erosion in the Mediterranean Basin and greenhouse effects In the past, the Mediterranean environment has proved to be sensitive and vulnerable to environmental change, and consequently the landscape in many places has been irreversibly degraded. Currently in tile Mediterranean region, bedrock is exposed over very large areas and most soils are stony. Maximum rates of denudation concur in those semi-arid areas where it rains sufficiently to develop surthce runoff but not to maintain plant cover sufficiently dense to protect the soil [13]. This is the case of semi-arid and arid Mediterranean regions. Erosion is highest in areas receiving between 200-600 mm rainfall per year or with great importance of extreme precipitation events [2, 14, 15]. In sub-humid and semi-arid Mediterranean environments, erosion appears to be closely correlated with rainfall within each area [6], whereas runoff is not significantly correlated with erosion [ 14, 15]. This means that the response of the soil surface to rainfall is of greater importance for achieving erosion than is nmoff alone, suggesting a marked influence of extreme rainthll events again [14]. According to hneson and Emmer [2], an increase in the temperature of 3 to 4 C is argued to have the following impacts on erosion process in the Mediterranean environments: (a) higher rates of erosion on slopes and either relative or absolute increase of overland flow during extreme rainfall events; (b) higher sediment concentration in water runoff; (c) higher sediment and solute supply fiom badlands and/or marl areas; (d) an increase in the risk of rill and gully erosion, (e) an increase in the discontinuity of runoff and sediment transport in drainage basins; (f) lower rates of sediment transport in the major rivers; (g) adjustment of river channels, especially those canting coarse load (braiding will increase and fans will grow); (11) A shift fiom certain perennial streams to ephemeral streams); (i) An increase in wind
755 erosion. 2.5. Desertification and climatic change
At the present time, it would appear that there is a consensus with respect to the fact that the Meditenanean region is the most sensitive in Europe to the climate change which appears to be drawing near [2]. Although the cause of desertification of Mediterranean environments is a debatable matter. Nevertheless, all the evidence seems to point to natural processes strengthening the trend of human ones. Likewise, this region has undergone the most intense, prolonged exploitation known over the whole planet. Simulation models of the atmosphere's general flow predict that a doubling of the greenhouse gas concentration compared to pre-hldustrial periods would bring a mean worldwide temperature increase between 3 and 5.5 C. Current calculations would seem to indicate that this event could occur half way through the twenty-first century. A global change of this magnitude would increase aridity and desertification in the Mediterranean Basin. 3. R E F E R E N C E S 1 S. Rivas-Martinez, Bioclimatic Classification System of the World, 21 a Aproximation,
(lnanusclipt), 1993. 2 A.C. Imeson and I.M. Emmer, Implications of climatic change on land degradation in the Meditenanean. In: L.Jefiic, J.D.Milliman and G.Sestini, Climatic Change and the Mediterranean. E.Amold, 1992. 3 Ph. Duchaufour, Pedologie, 1. Pddogenrse et Classificattion, Masson, Paris, 1977. 4 Soil Suvvey Staff, Soil Taxonomy. A Basic System of Soil Classification for Making and Interpreting Soil Surveys, USDA-SCS Agric. Handbook n ~ 436, Washington, D.C., 1975. 5 A.C.lmeson and R.S. De-Groot, Landscape-Ecological Impact of Climatic Change; Discussion Repport on Meditenanean Region. LICC, VROM-DGMH, Amsterdam, 1989. 6 G. Benito, M. Gutirnez and C. Sancho, Z.Geomorph., 37 (1993) 199. 7 J.J. Ibafiez and R. Jimdnez-Ballesta, An. Edafol. Agrobiol., 45 (1986) 961. 8 J.J. Ib~ifiez, V. Zucarrello, S. De-Alba and A. Garcia-,~dvarez, Catena (Submitted). 9 FAO-UNESCO, World Soil Resources. An Explanatory Note on the FAO World Soil Resources Map at 1:25.000.000 Scale, FAO World Soil Resources Reports 66, Rome, 1991. 10 FAO-UNESCO, Mapa Mundial de Suelos. Leyenda Revisada, FAO, Roma, 1989. 11 E.M. Bridges,World Soils. (2nd edition), Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge, 1978. 12 J.J.lbafiez, S. De-Alba and J. Boixadera, The pedodiversity and its measurement: Aplications to soil information system. In: D. Khlg, R.A.J. Jones and A.J. Thomasson (eds), The Development of an EU Land Information System for Agro-Environmental Monitoring. EU, Bnlssels, (in press), 1994. 13 W.B. Langbein and S.A. Schumm, Transactions of the America Geophysicial Union, 39 (1958) 1076. 14 M. Sala, Hillslope nmoff and sediment production in two Mediterranean mountain environments. In: A.C. hneson and M. Sala (eds.), Geomorphology in Enviroments with Strong Seasonal Contrast. Catena Supplement, 12, (1988). 15 H.N. Le-Houdrou, Vegetation and land-use in the Mediterranean Basin by the year 2050: A prospective study. In: L. Jefiic, J.D. Milliman and G. Sestini, Climatic Change and the Mediterranean, E. Arnold. 1992.
756 European Union m e m b e r countries (E: 1/1000000) (Drawn up from INRA & Joint Res. Center, 1992) BB Mediterranean area
10
5
F
SP
I
D
ENG
GR
P
SCOS-IRL DK
NL
B
N-IRL
L
Figure 1. Richness in Major Soils Groups (FAD &UNESCO; 1974) for the soil map of EU countries
MOUNTAINOUS
HUMID TROPICS AND TROPICS
BOREAL
'~ SEASONALLY DRY TROPICS AND SUBTROPICS
COLD
TEMPLATE
~
MEDITERRANEAN
ARID
Figure 2. Minimum spanning tree analysis for climatic zones
ARID
a ,= ,:, , - r ,= ,=, ,=, ,=, , ~ N ,= A ,,,
,
I
TEMPERATE COLD BOREAL MOU SEASONALLY DRY AND SUBTROPICS
NTAI
NOUS
TROPICS
HUMID TROPICS SUBTROPICS
AND
Figure 3. Dendrograms grouping climatic zones with respect to the number of their Major Soils Groups (FAD & UNESCO, 1989)
Climate Change Research: Evaluation and Policy Implications S. Zwerver, R.S.A.R. van Rompaey, M.T.J. Kok and M.M. Berk, (Eds.) 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
757
A mathematical model for predicting the impact of climate changes on Mediterranean plant landscapes J.L. Gonzfilez-Rebollar, A. Garcia-Alvarez and J.J. Ib~,fiez Centro de Ciencias Medioambientales, CSIC, Serrano 115 bis, 28006 Madrid, Spain
Abstract
The main properties of a phytoclimatic model are explained. It is a technique for theoretic simulation but a field work verification is essential. The methodology involves the transformation of a territory's general phytoclimate data into particular phytoclimate estimates. We are dealing with a simple mathematical climate-soil-relief-vegetation model offering the possibility of predicting changes in vegetation liable to occur at any point in the Iberian peninsula's territory, when the climate data values of a site change as compared with data currently estimated. It consequently enables both alterations and sensitivity of potential plant communities to possible climate changes to be detected and predicted at a certain point in the territory. Using this methodology, it is possible to analyze the repercussions which it is assumed the green house effect would cause according to General Circulation Models (GMCs). A representative case for Le6n province in the NW of the Iberian peninsula is analyzed. 1. INTRODUCTION In addition to the direct influence of the climate on vegetation (the macroclimate) it also exerts an indirect influence via the soil and other environmental factors (the meso/microclimates). The vegetation in the Mediterranean region results from the complex interaction between the climate and other environmental factors. Mathematical models however, cannot accurately represent these interactions and can only identify and simulate general patterns of behaviour. The model presented here has been used in a number of studies to interpret Mediterranean vegetation of the Iberian peninsula [ 1-4]. This study focuses on the variation in vegetation resulting from temperature increases of 1 and 2.5 degrees, guided by predictions resulting from the application of General Circulation Models (GMCs). One must bear in mind however, that edapho-topo-climatic variations in the Mediterranean region are based on a wide range of situations that reflect great diversity and complexity. This study was carried out in Leon province in the NW of the Iberian peninsula. This province is situated on the border between the temperate regions of West Europe (in the N and NW of Spain) and the Mediterranean region. In this study we collected mean monthly precipitation and temperature data from 47 sampling sites distributed over the whole province. This model enabled us to work with different hypotheses that attempt to reproduce distinct geomorphological and edaphic situations. In this case however we have only considered the effects of an increase in temperature.
758 2. M E T H O D O L O G Y The mathematical model used for prediction was described some years ago by one of our team [1] and used to model phytoclimatic-vegetation relationships. The methodology consists of different stages (Fig. 1): 2.1. Phase 1.
The climatic data (precipitation, temperature and evapotranspiration) are transformed to: A)postdictive estimates, B)predictive estimates or C) remain unchanged. This phase allows us to simulate macroclimatic modifications in time in the fight ofpaleoclimatic territorial studies, predictive models or using current data. 2.2. Phase 2.
Transformation of climatic data to phytoclimatic estimates by means of a theoretical simulation of the conditions of the biotope. These are simulations of A) exposure (N or S), B) water loss due to drainage and C) hydric retention in soil. Variations in exposure affect the temperature (T) and the evapotranspiration data; lateral drainage is estimated by means of a runoff coefficient (W), and hydric retention by means of the retention capacity (CR). Monthly precipitation (P), evapotranspiration, runoff" and retention capacity are integrated into the water balance in each location, which allows us to evaluate the monthly availability of water in the soil (D). This evaluation is carried out for each CR,W hypothesis. Data P from each location "i" are thus transformed to estimates D. But D is a parameter that depends on which hypothesis (CK, W) is being considered, there is therefore the same number of monthly estimates of D as there are formulated hypotheses CR, W (Fig. 2). D = DO + P - W P - E
where:
D = Available water P - Precipitation W = Rate of runoff DO = Available water retained CR = Retention capacity E = Evapotranspiration After the water balance, the direct bioclimatic repercussion of the temperature will be evaluated: IBP = f (T - t) where: IBP-- Potential Bioclimatic Intensity T = Temperature t = Minimum vegetative temperature
759
[
DATA BASE
DISCIIIMINANT SIMULATION ANALYSIS ~ DATA " ~ TRANSFORMATION
]
MeteorologicalH ~ ! Potential Variables ] [ ~ '1 'h~l-;-cl)m"-lir
CLIMATE
j[
~_~ 1~ - - ~
~.~
eo,..,,.,
,
~
Figure 1. General scheme of the model
i
I
":
,"~ I
t .,
'.
'>
I '~
:.,
1 i '
~o=
,:,(c r)
D=
Do+P--coP--E
[ w~.TER8ALA.cE!
Biologically
,,.m
15o
o p e n A v a i l a f h a s eIb tDe ~>~ EE> ~> ~E~ >e e water
.
_
2>~E"' r
~
/
~
/Rechargephase
Percolation
/ 1 sO i e c h a Soil moisture storage
cr ] F M A M ]
]
" ~ o A S 0 N D
Figure 2. Basis of the model
rge
Deficit of water
760 Attempts to measure the degree of vegetative activity/inactivity taking into account the double concept of temperature and hydric availability: IBR = Cp * IBP
where:
IBR = Real Bioclimatic Intensity Cp = f (D - e / E - e) e = Minimum vegetative evapotranspiration The general formulas of this hygro-thermic process of bioclimatic estimation can be found in [ 1]. For each hypothesis CR, W, the data P, T and E of a site are transformed into a phytoclimatic vector (F). The vector F obtained from the climatic data of a location "i", using the hypothesis CR = "J" and W - "K", will be called F (i,[J,K]). Likewise we can assume the hypothesis CR, W (eg. CR = Maximum and W = 0) and modify the T values as we have shown here. In this case an increase or decrease in temperature will change the phytoclimatic vector F (in this case F [i, Max CR/W=0]). 2.3. Phase 3. This analyzes the answers of the test. We try to identify the sequential phytoclimatic answers in different temperature hypotheses ( F [i, Max CR/W=0], by means of its degree of similarity (probability) to reference phytoclimatic types: F (Tactual), which are correlated with the potential vegetation Vp. As a consequence, this phase includes two different aspects: - The obtention of reference phytoclimatic types - Identification/classification of hypothetical F (i, Max CRAV=0). We consider that both aspects can be solved using Discriminant Analysis. By means of this analysis, we can establish the zonal phytoclimatic typology in the territory and its Discriminant Functions, and we can refer the rest of the simulated phytoclimates to this typology (mathematically represented by the centroids of the zonalphytoclimatic group). In conclusion: - The methodology involves the transformation of a territory's general phytoclimatic estimates (in time and in space). The transformation is carried out by means of a theoretical simulation of site conditions (precipitation, temperature, geomorphology, soil, etc.) For each location, one must differentiate the theoretical phytoclimatic environment, which is similar to the zonal conditions, from the other estimates, obtained by nonzonal simulation (eg. increase in temperature, from the perspective of climatic change) - The vectors F (i, Max CRJW=0) are grouped according to the type of zonal vegetation to which the location '~ belong. Each group configures a numerical environment "type" (Discriminant analysis). - The intrazonal phytoclimates F (T1, T2 .... Tn) are classified/identified by their similarity to the zonal phytoclimatic typology which is discriminated numerically in the last phase. -
-
Actual phytoclimatic map
Predictive phytoclimatic maps
Figure 3. Location of study area and phytoclimatic maps
762 3. TEMPERATURE INCREASE AND CLIMATIC CHANGE MEDITERRANEAN REGION. AN ASSAY IN LEON PROVINCE
IN
THE
According to current General Circulation Models (GMCs), predictions of climatic change are expressed as an increase in mean temperature. On a planetary scale this implies a significant change from the present conditions in large areas of the biosphere. Our study however also enables prediction of changes on a regional scale or more detailled level. The vegetation in Leon province has been divided into four phytoclimatic units, each one representing the presence of a characteristic tree species. Two of these are representative of temperate regions (Quercus robur and Fagus sylvatica) and two of Submediterranean and Mediterranean environments (Quercus pyrenaica and Q. rotundifolia respectively). The model can be calibrated by using observations of current vegetation in the feld. Each site can be allotted to one of the previously cited units according to its discriminant fimction obtained from phytoclimatic estimations determined from precipitation (P), temperature (T) and evapotranspiration (E) data. This therefore enabled us to reconstruct a current phytoclimatic map (Fig. 3) representing the phytoclimatic units of the region. This model has been used to predict changes occurring in compliance with hypotheses of temperature increases as a consequence of climatic change. Here, predictive phytoclimatic maps (Fig. 4) have been obtained for a mean temperature increase of 1 or 2.5 C. In the former case, 11 of 47 sites, 23% of the total, experienced an increase in aridity of their phytoclimatic environment. The mean temperature increase of 2.5 C caused an increase in aridity of the phytoclimatic environment in 21 sites (45% of total). This percentage of change is within the range obtained from several general circulation models (eg. Geophysical Fluid Dynamics Lab. (GFDL) or Goddard Institute of Space Studies (GlSS) [5]. 6. REFERENCES 1 J.L. Montero de Burgos and J.L. Gonzfilez-Rebollar, Diagramas Bioclimfiticos, Madrid 1983. 2 J.L. Gonzfilez-Rebollar, Estudios Geogrfificos, 177 (1984) 401 3 J.L. Gonzfilez-Rebollar and J.L. Montero de Burgos, E1 paisaje vegetal a la luz de los modelos fitoclimfiticos. M6todos nuevos para viejas cuestiones, Jaca, Huesca, 1988 4 J.L. Gonzfilez-Rebollar, Monograf. Europ. Cofer. LICC, Lauteren, Holland, 1989 5 D.L. Urban, A.J. Hansen, D. O. Wallin and P.N. Halpin, in Biodiversity and Global Change, Wallinford, UK, 1994
Climate Change Research: Evaluation and Policy Implications S. Zwerver, R.S.A.R. van Rompaey, M.T.J. Kok and M.M. Berk, (Eds.) 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
763
Vulnerability of Mediterranean ecosystems to Climatic Change, study of soil degradation under different climatological conditions in an altitudinal transect in the south east of Spain C. Boix a, A. Calvob, A. Cerdfi a, A.C. Imesona, M.D.Soriano b and I.R. Tiemessen a aFysisch Geografisch en Bodemkundig Laboratorium. Landscape and Environmental Research Group. Universiteit van Amsterdam. Nieuwe Prinsengracht 130. 1018 VZ. Amsterdam. The Netherlands. bDepartamento de Geografia. Universidad de Valencia. Avenida Blasco Ibafiez 28. 46010 Valencia. Espafia. Abstract To investigate the potential response of soils to climatic change, measurements of soil physical and chemical properties were carried out during a year in a mountain zone in Alicante (Spain), along an altitudinal and climatological gradient. Hydrological properties (infiltration runoff and sediment concentration) were measured under winter and summer conditions. Chemical and physical soil properties were analyzed for reference soil profiles along the transect. The erosional response of the soils as well as soil properties like organic matter and CEC are found to be under the direct influence of the climate, and as a result they have to be considered as important factors in the desertification processes.
I. INTRODUCTION To investigate the relationship of climate to the erosion hazard and soil degradation in the Mediterranean area, a climatological and altitudinal gradient in Alicante (Spain) was selected as a study zone. The criteria for the selection of the zone follow the approach used already by some authors [ 1-3 ] performing soil studies and experiments along climatological and altitudinal gradients, trying to isolate the impact of the Climatic Change on soil erosion. Two slopes (south and north facing) were selected at three sites situated within a zone of only 30 km and showing a high variation in the range of precipitation (Table 1). The lithology is uniform for the three sites: Upper Cretaceous limestone. The study slopes have had an intensive land use in the past: abandoned agricultural terraces appear in Benidorm (BE) and Callosa (CS) (the lowest and intermediate site, respectively) and signs of grazing and forest fires appear in Cocoll (CC) (the highest site in the gradient). The objective of this work is to determine the changes in properties and erosional response of the soil caused by climate. The experimental design of the field work, extensively explained in other papers [3,4], was as follows: Rainfall simulation experiments were carried out on the six slopes in winter and in summer using a rainfall simulator producing rain at 55 mmh-1 of intensity and during one hour. Several soil profiles were taken along each slope and described in the field. Texture, organic matter, the EC and CEC were sampled and analyzed in the
764 laboratory. This paper summarizes some of the findings of this research, that will be described in detail elsewhere. Table 1 Main characteristics of the study zones Location
Lithology
Vegetation series
Aspect Altitude Slope Average (degrees) (meters)(degrees) precipitation
Benidorm
Upper Cretaceous limestone Upper Cretaceous limestone
ChamaeropoRhamnetum lyciodes QuercococciferaePistacietum lentisci Rubiolongifoliae quercetum
N 75 S 210
74-90 74-106
15 20
350 mm
N 10 S 240
280-360 25 282-344 30
550 mm
N 10 S 120
99420 1026 18 850-910
850 mm
Callosa
CocoU
Upper Cretaceous limestone
2. SOIL HYDROLOGICAL PROPERTIES In general, runoff production in summer shows an inverse trend with increasing altitude, a higher runoff is found at the lowest site and a lower runoff at the highest one (Figure 1). 0,60 -
-
0,50 e--
o r
0,30-
'tY
0,20-
O
-- 0,90
~Rcw
-- 0,80
--a-- S c w
," o "t~ L_
0,60
*"
-- 0,50
o tO
_ _
.-+.....= .::: . . . . . . . . . .... . . . . . . . . .
...........
iiiiiiiiii'iii
0,10 -
!~
0,00 BEs
BEn
CSs
CSn
Fi!iiiiiiiiiiiiiiii
CCs
.
= c~
0 , 70
--o- S c s
~9 0 , 4 0 r
1,00
~Rcs
- 0,40
l.==
o
- 0,30
a~"
-
0,20
.E_ "a
-
0,10
09
-
0,00
cD
CCn
Figure 1 Runoff coefficients and sediment concentration in summer (s) and winter (w) (BE: Benidorm, CS: Callosa, CC: Cocoll, n: north slope, s: south slope)
765 In the case of Benidorm, the infiltration capacity is limited by the presence of a crust which generates more runoff and. However, the runoff production in winter does not follow clearly the altitudinal and climatological gradient, as shown also in Figure 1. Callosa, the intermediate site, shows the most runoff in winter due probably to the combined effect of a high soil moisture content at the time of the experiments and a high percentage of stones at soil surface. Looking at the slope aspect, the runoff coefficients and the sediment concentration (understood as an indicators of the soil erosion), were found always to be higher at the south facing slopes, in summer and in winter (Figure 1). South slopes present, in general, more degraded soil conditions and lower values of soil moisture content.
3. CHEMICAL AND PHYSICAL SOIL PROPERTIES The results obtained demonstrate that there are several soil parameters which show a trend following the climatological gradient. At the most arid site (Benidorm) the soils are shallow and poorly developed (lithic Leptosol) while in the more humid areas (Callosa and Cocoll, respectively) better developed soils can be found (lithic Leptosol, haplic Calcisol and chromic Luvisol). The maximum contents in organic matter, clay percentage and CEC values occur at the highest site: upwards along the transect. Considering aspect, the maximum values are always found on the north facing slopes. 40 35 30 25
45
~OM % .002 mm -=-- CEC
40 35 30 25
20
20
15
15
10
"7, O
E
O
10
5
5
0
0 BEn
BEs
CSs
CSn
CCs
CCn
Figure 2. Organic matter, clay content and CEC (BE: Benidorm, CS CaUosa, CC CocoU, n: north slope, s: south slope)
4. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS The runoff and the sediment concentration values obtained from the rainfall simulation experiments are, in general, very low. But, paying attention to the differences between the three zones, the hazard of erosion of the soils is found to be higher when the climatological conditions become more arid and under dry soil conditions (summer). Under wet soil
766 conditions (winter) the runoff coefficients and the sediment concentration are higher in the intermediate site (Callosa), but this result coincides with the high soil moisture conditions in the soil at the moment of the winter experiments. For the south facing slopes the sediment concentrations and the runoff coefficients decrease upwards along the transect. Among the studied soil properties only the organic matter content, the clay content, and as a consequence of that the CEC, increases upwards along the transect while the electrical conductivity decreases. When the climatological conditions are less favourable (more dry) and the soils less well developed, the rate and the spatial variability, of parameters such as the runoff coefficient, sediment concentration and erosion rate, increases. With more favourable climatological conditions (in the case of Cocoll) the soils show better physical and chemical characteristics, with very low runoff coefficients and sediment concentrations. In the case of Callosa (an intermediate situation), the soils can have high runoff coefficients and sediment concentrations when they are very wet, but lower values when they are dry. In general the soils are more fertile and less erodible when the climatological conditions become more humid. Even on the smaller scale of the difference in micro climate between south and north slope there is found in general a better developed vegetation cover and soil properties as well as less erodible soils on the north slopes. 4. ACKNOWLEDGMENT This work was financially supported by the Commission of the European Communities in the Climatology and Natural Hazards program, EV5V-CT91-0023 ERMES project. Thanks very much to J.M. Schoorl for his valuable help reviewing the English manuscript.
5. REFERENCES
1 Lavee, H., Imeson, A.C., Pariente, S., Benyamini, Y., 1991. The response of soils to simulated rainfall along a climatological gradient in an arid and semi-arid region. Catena 19,1937. 2 Imeson, A.C., Calvo, A., Lavee, H., Perez-Trejo, F., 1993. Modelling and exploring the impact of Climatic change on ecoystem degradation, hydrology and land use along a transect across the Mediterranean. Paper presented in the EC Meeting in Copenhagen, to be published in the Proceedings in 1994. 3 Calvo, A., Soriano Soto, M.D., Boix Fayos, C., Tiemessen, I., 1994: Suelos y procesos geomrrficos en un gradiente climatico altitudinal (Alicante). Actas de la III Reunirn Nacional de Geomorfologia, Logrofio. 4 Soriano, M.D.; Boix, C.; Calvo, A.; Imeson, A.; Cerd~i, A.; Perez-Trejo, F., 1993. Metodologia y disefio del campo experimental en ecosistemas degradados en un transecto altitudinal en la provincia de Alicante, Cuadernos de Geografia, 54, 268-284.
Climate Change Research: Evaluation and Policy Implications S. Zwerver, R.S.A.R. van Rompaey, M.T.J. Kok and M.M. Berk, (Eds.) 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
767
The impact of Climatic Change and land use on the hydrological response of Mediterranean soils; a study along a climatological gradient in Crete (Greece) C. Boix a, A. Calvob, A.C. Imeson a, J.M. Schoorl a, M.D. Soriano b and I.R. Tiemessen a aFysisch Geografisch en Bodemkunding Laboratorium. Landscape and Environmental Research Group. Universiteit van Amsterdam. Nieuwe Prinsengracht 130. 1018 VZ. Amsterdam. The Netherlands. bDepartamento de Geografia. Universidad de Valencia. Avenida Blasco Ibafiez 28. 46010 Valencia. Espafia.
Abstract
To help understand the impact of Climatic Change on the soils of the Mediterranean area, measurements of physical soil properties were carried out in a mountain zone in Crete (Greece), following a climatological gradient. Four experimental slopes were chosen, south facing and situated on limestone lithology. Soil hydrological properties including infiltration, runoff and sediment concentration, were measured and the percentage of waterstable microaggregation in the soil was calculated and used as an indicator of soil degradation. It was found that as well as climate, soil properties were highly affected by the extensive land use of the area, intensive grazing by goats and small scale wildfires.
1. INTRODUCTION One of the approaches proposed by some authors [ 1-4] to evaluate the effects of Climatic Change on soil processes and erosion is to study soil properties and the erosion response of soils along climatological gradients. These climatological gradients have to be carefully selected, joining areas of comparable geology, soils, and vegetation characteristics but having different ranges of precipitation. In this way, it is possible to evaluate the effect of climate on the water-soil-vegetation system. The effect of land use is also important affecting the erosional behaviour of an ecosystem. Following this approach, a climatological and altitudinal gradient was selected in Crete (Greece). This gradient was chosen to study the potential changes generated by changes in climate on soil properties like hydrological and erosional response as well as physical properties. This gradient was one of three gradients selected for study in a transect across the Mediterranean. The Crete transect differed from those in Alicante and Israel with respect to the high density of grazing. Four sites on Upper Cretaceous limestone were selected along this gradient (Table 1). The slopes are used as grazing land for goats, with the more intensive
768 grazing at the highest site (Omalos) and the less intensive grazing at the lowest site (Afrata). The farmers frequently burn patches of shrub vegetation on the slopes to improve the pasture for grazing. In the whole area, old agricultural terraces at the foot slope positions have been abandoned. Rainfall simulation experiments were carried out on the south facing slope of each site using a portable sprinkling rainfall simulator [6]. Rain was applied at an 55 mm h-1 during 55 minutes. At each slope a total of eight simulations on different soil surfaces and land uses categories were carried out. Soil samples were collected from comparable situations to analyze the water stable microaggregation. The waterstable microaggregation and the clay and silt proportion in the fraction <0.105 mm were determined. The methods used are described fully in the cited literature [4]. Table 1 Main characteristics of the four selected slopes (RFS: Rainfall simulation experiments) Location
Altitude Aspect Slope Precipitation (m) (degrees) (degrees) mm 1100 200 25 1000 800 180 35 800 400 175 18 350 100 165 12 200
OMALOS LAKI RODOUPOS AFRATA
Number of RFS 6 8 6 8
2. RESULTS 2.1. Soil hydrological and erosional response A clear decrease in soil erosion and other related parameters, such as the sediment concentration and the sediment yield, with the decreasing altitude and thus a more dry climate was found.
Table 2 Average values of the hydrological response of soils (OM: Omalos; LA: Laki; RO: Rodoupos; AF: Afrata)
OM LA RO AF
Runoff coefficient
Sediment concentra, (gr 1-1)
Sediment yield (gr)
0.66 0.68 0.69 0.37
9.26 1.95 1.72 1.40
61.41 15.74 12.53 6.00
Soil Erosion Bulk Porosity moisture rate density (%) (grm-2h "1) (gr cm -3) content (%) 356.19 97.59 70.99 33.40
0.94 0.90 0.95 0.91
64.45 65.70 64.35 65.80
15.43 17.69 22.41 10.04
Considering the average values for each slope (Table 2), Omalos, the highest and most humid site, shows the highest values of erosion rate, sediment concentration and sediment yield
769 as well as a quite high bulk density. However, the highest runoff coefficient appears in Rodoupos, an intermediate site. In this case the runoff production was clearly influenced by the high soil moisture content at the moment of the experiments (Table 2), also Rodoupos shows the highest bulk density among the studied sites. The lowest and most arid site, Afrata, shows the lowest value of runoff coefficient, erosion rate and sediment yield and concentration. Analyzing the values independently, according to the specific characteristics of the soil surface and land use, bare and burnt plots show the highest runoff coefficients, with the highest erosion rates in bare plots. Abandoned terraces also present high values of runoff and erosion, but taking into account that the gradient of the slope at the terraces is very low, these values are always lower than in bare patches on the slope itself but higher than the vegetated patches on the same slope. 2.2. Soil aggregation
A positive influence of the clay content on the waterstable microaggregation, already pointed out by some authors has been found. Afrata, the lowest site, seems to have the best soil aggregation among the studied soils. The soils in Affata present a more uniform aggregate size distribution for all the measured fractions and the highest value of waterstable microaggregation, besides the highest clay content in the soil. The lowest clay content is found in the Laki soils, an intermediate site, together with a lower value of waterstable microaggregation. Figure 1 shows how the waterstable microaggregation and the clay content follow parallel trends while that in the runoff coefficient is the opposite direction. The waterstable microaggregation is higher in the plots with the highest clay content and the runoff coefficient is higher in plots with lower waterstable microaggregation and clay content. ~,
7O
tO "10
6O
~
50
o
40
N ~
30
~
20
2 tO E
10
t-
O
.0
t--
0,9 0,8
0,7 E .m
O 0,6 iE 0,5 o O
0,4
O
0,3 ,-~
0,2 rv 0,1 0
0 t-~
O
>
O
t-~
~ o
E] Clay %
-,--
0
t'~
>
.s
t'~
>
5 3 5 3
-,--,
t'~
0
.,.,
m Waterstable
>
0
t'~
"0
o
microaggregation %
.t)
> o <
~
0
.Q
u_
.," , <
>
u_
9Runoff coefficient
Figure 1. Clay content, waterstable microaggregation and runoff coefficients under different plot conditions (OM: Omalos; LA: Laki; RO: Rodoupos; AF: Afrata; b: bare patch; v: vegetated patch; bb: bare and burnt patch; vb: burnt patch with new vegetation; t: abandoned terrace).
770 3. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS Soil structure and erosion rates seem to be the result of the combination of two main factors in this case: the climatological conditions and the land use. Omalos, the highest site, has nowadays more biomass production due to the very humid climatological conditions. As a consequence of that, the grazing is more intensive and the erosion rates higher. Due to the grazing the soil is trampled and this produces an increase of the bulk density of the top layer. The goats produce also a displacement of material that remains on the soil surface and this material is easily transported by the runoff water and so increasing the erosion rates. Afrata, the most arid site with less biomass production, less grazing, lower values of soil moisture and a high clay content and waterstable microaggregation shows the lowest erosion rate. Specific soil surface conditions produce a different erosional response. Vegetated patches always show lower runoff coefficients and higher values of waterstable microaggregation than burnt and bare patches. Abandoned terraces at the medium sites have erosion rates higher than vegetated patches, but lower than expected, probably due to a high clay content and a low gradient. In some cases, along studied gradients in Spain and Israel [2-4] high values of erosion have been found when the conditions become more arid, but in the case of Crete, the behaviour of the water-soil-vegetation system is clearly dependent on factors derived from the land use.
4. ACKNOWLEDGMENT This work was financially supported by the Commission of the European Communities in the Climatology and Natural Hazards program, EV5V-CT91-0023 ERMES project.
5. REFERENCES
1 Eybergen, F.A. and Imeson, A.C., 1989. Geomorphological processes and climatic change. Catena 16, 306-319. 2 Lavee, H., Imeson, A.C., Pariente, S., Benyamini, Y., 1991. The response of soils to simulated rainfall along a climatological gradient in an arid and semi-arid region. CATENA 19, 19-37. 3 Imeson, A.C., Calvo, A., Lavee, H., Perez-Trejo, F., 1993. Modelling and exploring the impact of Climatic change on ecoystem degradation, hydrology and land use along a transect across the Mediterranean. Paper presented in the EC Meeting in Copenhagen, to be published in the Proceedings in 1994. 4 Calvo, A., Soriano Soto, M.D., Boix Fayos, C., Tiemessen, I., 1994: Suelos y procesos geom6rficos en un gradiente climatico altitudinal (Alicante). Actas de la III Reuni6n Nacional de Geomorfologia, Logrofio. 6 Calvo, A., 1988. Un simulador de lluvia portatil de fiicil construccirn. In: M. Sala & F. Gallart (eds.),. Mrtodos y Trcnicas para la medicirn en el campo de procesos geomorfolrgicos. Monografia n~ 1, Sociedad Espafiola de Geomorfologia. Zaragoza.
Climate Change Research: Evaluation and Policy Implications S. Zwerver, R.S.A.R. van Rompaey, M.T.J. Kok and M.M. Berk, (Eds.) 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
771
Climate change and malaria risk W.J.M. Martens University of Limburg, Department of Mathematics, P.O. Box 616, 6200 MD Maastricht, The Netherlands / National Institute of Public Health and Environmental Protection (RIVM), P.O. Box 1, 3720 BA Bilthoven, The Netherlands Abstract The biological activity and geographic distribution of the malarial parasite and its vector are sensitive to climate influences, especially temperature and precipitation. In this paper the effects of an increase in temperature on the epidemic potential of malaria are explored. Assessment of the potential impact of global climate change on malaria risk suggests a widespread increases of risk due to an expansion of areas suitable for malaria transmission. The health impact will be most pronounced in populations living in the less economically-developed temperate areas in which endemicity is low or absent. 1.
THE ISSUE
The occurrence of vector-borne diseases ranges from the tropics and subtropics to the temperate climate zones. With a few exceptions, vector-borne diseases do not occur in the cold climates of the world. In Table 1 some of the world's most important vector-borne diseases are listed. Table 1:
Global status of the mqjor vector-borne diseases in 1990. ~
disease
vector
populations at risk (millions)
prevalence of infection (millions)
malaria schistosomiasis lymphatic filariasis onchocerciasis
mosquito snail mosquito blackfly
22(X) 600 900 90
270 2(X) 90.2 17.8
The extent to which vector-borne disease transmission occurs in a specific area is determined by two factors: first, the presence of (an abundance of) vectors capable of transmitting the disease, and second the presence of the relevant parasite. Any factor influencing these two determinants hence influences disease transmission. Direct effects of the anticipated changes in global and regional temperature, precipitation, humidity and wind patterns rcsulting from anthropogenic climate change are the factors which have an impact on the vectors' reproduction habits and on their longevity, and are thus associated with changes in annual vector density. In general, the rate of development of a parasite accelerates as the temperature rises. An increase in temperaturc may therefore result in the completion of the life cycle of a parasite in areas in which previous temperatures were too low for the parasite to reach maturity. Indirect effects of climate change include changes in vegetation and agricultural practices which are mainly caused by temperaturc changes and trends in rainfall patterns. Another indirect effect of climate change is associated with the rise in sea level and the resulting coastal flooding. The proliferation of brackish water lagunae influences the availability of habitat and either encourages or discourages vector species depending on whether they prefer brackish water. Generally speaking, drought and dcsertification, including a migration or extension of global desert belts, could be expected to decrease vector-borne disease transmission. It is thus evident that major changes in the incidence of vector-borne diseases associated with a climate change might be expected, and that the manifestation of these changes is closely related to socioeconomic developmcnt and the provision of health services.
772
2.
MALARIA: A GLOBAL PROBLEM
One of the world's most important vector-borne diseases is malaria, and there are few infectious diseases which have as great an impact on the social and economic development of societies. Out of a world population of approximately 5,300 million people in 1990, some 2,200 million are regarded as being at risk of contracting malaria. Roughly 270 million people are actually infected with the malaria parasite. At present, the distribution of malaria is mainly restricted to the tropics and sub-tropics, although before the Second World War malaria was a common disease in many temperate areas of the world. Malaria eradication campaigns and socio-economic development caused malaria to disappear from areas in which it had previously been endemic, although mosquito densities still allow transmission in these areas. 2 The incidence of malaria is determined by various factors: the abundance of Anopheline species, the propensity of the mosquitoes to bite human beings, the longevity of the mosquitoes and the rate at which the Plasmodium parasite in the mosquito develops. 3.
T E M P E R A T U R E AND E P I D E M I C P O T E N T I A L
A unit of measurement which encapsulates many of the important processes in the transmission of infectious diseases is the basic reproduction rate (Ro), defined as the average number of secondary infections produced when a single infected individual is introduced into a potential host population in which each member is susceptible. 3 The basic reproduction rate allows us to calculate the critical density threshold of host populations necessary to maintain parasite transmission. The critical density for malaria transmission can be expressed as:
Nz=k 1 9 -log____~)
(1)
N,
where Nz/N1 is the number of malarial mosquitoes (N2) per human (N1); p the survival probability of the mosquito; a the frequency of taking human blood meals; n the incubation period of the parasite in the vector. The term kl is a constant, incorporating variables assumed to be temperature independent (including the efficiency with which an infective mosquito infects a susceptible human and an infected human infects a susceptible mosquito, the number of blood meals a mosquito takes from man, and the recovery rate in man). The epidemic potential of malaria is defined as the reciprocal of the host density threshold. This epidemic potential can be used as a comparative index in estimating the effect on the risk of malaria represented by a change in ambient temperature. In Table 2, a number of temperatures which are critical to malarial transmission are set out.
Table 2:
Crucial temperatures in malarial transmission. extrinsic incubation cycle Plasmodium species
digestion of blood-meal Anopheline species
vivax
falciparum
maculipennis
culicifacies
stephensi
degree-days (*C day)
105
111
36.5
29.7
43.4
threshold temperature (*C)
14.5-15 16-19
9.9
12.6
8.9
The most direct effect of temperature is on n. The incubation period of the parasite in the malarial mosquito must have elapsed before the infected vector can transmit the parasite. The relation
773
between ambient temperature and latent period is calculated using a temperature sum as described by MacDonald. a The frequency of feeding depends mainly on the rapidity with which a blood meal is digested, which increases as temperature rises, and can be calculated by means of a thermal temperature sum. 5 The female mosquito has to live long enough for the parasite to complete its development if transmission is to occur. Between certain temperature thresholds, the longevity of a mosquito decreases with rising temperature. The optimal temperature for mosquito survival lies in the 20-25~ range. Temperatures in excess of these will increase mortality and there is a threshold temperature above which death is inevitable. By the same token, there is a minimum temperature below which the mosquito cannot become active. Relying upon data reported by Boyd 6 and Horsfall 7, we assume a daily survival probability of 0.82, 0.90 and 0.04 at temperatures of 9~ , 20 ~ and 40 ~ C, respectively. The epidemic potential is most sensitive to changes in host mortality rates and development time of the parasite. In Figure 1 the influence of increasing temperature on the epidemic potential and the effects of different values of mosquito longevity and minimum temperature requirements for parasite development on the epidemic potential are illustrated. 1.0 reciprocal critical mosquito density
reciprocal critical mosquito density
centralestimate
,," " / / ~ " ' ~ ' ,
,,/,'
,,,/,,,
--
,,\,
,,,\,,
,/,,
0.8-
t
A
15
17
19
21
23
27
29
31
/
,' / ,',,/ ,, ,' / ,' ,,/ ,, . ' Y
/
......
"~" ~
i
,",\,, ~
~
I
\
\
,
\~ ~ \l
,'
-,\,
',~, ',~,
',~,
,,\ ',~
,, ,- .. ,. st
-
13
33 35 37 39 temperature (~
/ /
o.,o.~-
/
tt~ ' ~" "
/ ~ "
I
,'/
,,\ 25
/
t
0,,
13
,
i"
0.6-
,,\,,
,< ,."
t
,
,,\',
,'/,,
,,, " * - - ."."~ " -
centralestimate
15
17
19
21
23
25
27
29
31
33 35 37 39 temperature (~
B
Figure 1: Epidemic potential (valued as 1 as a maximum) for A) P. vivax (left-hand curve p(20~ = 0.8 and Tmin = 14.5~ central estimate p(20~ = 0.9 and Tmin = 14.5~ fight-hand curve p(20~ = 0.95 and Tmin = 15~ B) P. falciparum (left-hand curve p(20~ = 0.8 and Tmin = 16~ central estimate p(20~ = 0.9 and Tmin = 16~ fight hand curve p(20~ = 0.95 and Tmin = 19~
A high epidemic potential indicates that despite a smaller vector population, or alternatively, a less potent vector population, a given degree of endemicity may be maintained. As temperature increases, epidemic malarial potential increases until a maximum is reached. At high temperatures, the accelerated development of the parasite and the increased biting rate can no longer compensate for the decreasing mean life expectancy among the mosquitoes. The distributions shown in Figure 1 indicate that, in temperate climates, small increases in temperature can result in large increases in epidemic potential, irrespective of the values chosen for the survival probability or minimum temperatures assumed for parasite development. The effect of an increase in temperature will be more pronounced on the epidemic potential of less potent mosquito populations. It should be noted that, although the maximum values for epidemic potential are found in the ranges 29-33~ for malaria, the actual transmission intensity also depends on vector abundance. The optimal temperature for the rapid expansion of a population of malarial mosquitoes is found to lie in the range 20-30~ 8 Therefore, within this range, an increase in mosquito numbers may cause an additional increase of the epidemic potential.
774
4. MALARIA RISK DUE TO CLIMATE CHANGE The concept of the basic reproduction rate, discussed in the previous section, is used in an integrated linked-system model to study the effects of projected changes in temperature and precipitation on malaria epidemic potential next century. 9 Here, some major conclusions of this study are presented. With a global mean temperature increase of approximately 3~ the simulation runs on the model show a projected worldwide increase in transmission potential of the mosquito population and an extension of the areas conducive for malaria transmission. The risk of introduction of malaria transmission in non-malarious areas, including large parts of Australia, the United States, and Southern and Central Europe, associated with imported cases of malaria is a real one, since the former breeding sites of several Anopheles species are still available. Given the fact that in the most developed countries, effective control measures are economically feasible, it is not to be expected that human-induced climate changes would lead to a return of a state of endemicity in these areas. A different situation can be expected in currently endemic areas and areas bordering on them, especially in the subtropics. In the highly endemic malarious areas of tropical Africa, the malaria prevalence may increase. In the malarious areas of lower endemicity, however, the prevalence of infection is far more sensitive to climate changes. Therefore, a human induced climate change may have profound effects on numbers of people suffering from malaria in such areas. In this study, the direct effects of a changing temperature and precipitation on malaria transmission were considered. Additional research on the biological, ecological and socio-economic factors important in malaria transmission will be required for a more complete analysis of the impact of a human-induced climate change on this vector-borne disease. 5.
REFERENCES
1. World Health Organization, Potential Health Effects of Climatic Change, Geneva, Switzerland, 1990. 2. World Health Organization, 'World malaria situation in 1990', World Health Statistics Quarterly, Vol 45, 1992, pp 257-266. 3. R.M. Anderson and R.M. May, Infectious Diseases of Humans: Dynamics and Control, Oxford University Press, New York, USA, 1991. 4. G. MacDonald, The epidemiology and control of malaria, London, Oxford University Press, 1957. 5. T.S. Detinova, Age-Grouping Methods in Diptera of Medical Importance, World Health Organization, Monograph 47, Geneva, Switzerland, 1962. 6. M.F. Boyd (ed.), Malariology, Vol 1, W.B. Saunders Company, Philadelphia, USA, 1949. 7. W.R. Horsfall, Mosquitoes: Their Bionomics and Relation to Disease, Hafner Publishing Company, New York, USA, 1955. 8. L. Molineaux, 'The epidemiology of human malaria as an explanation of its distribution, including some implications for its control', in: W.H. Wernsdorfer and I. McGregor (eds.), Malaria, Principles and Practice of Malariology (volume 2), Churchill Livingstone, New York, USA, 1988, pp 913-998. 9. W.J.M. Martens, J. Rotmans and L.W. Niessen, Climate Change and Malaria Risk: An Integrated Modelling Approach, GLOBO Report Series no. 3, RIVM Report no. 461502003, Bilthoven, The Netherlands, 1994.
Climate Change Research: Evaluation and Policy Implications S. Zwerver, R.S.A.R. van Rompaey, M.T.J. Kok and M.M. Berk, (Eds.) 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
775
Will malaria return to Europe under the greenhouse effect? W. Takken', J. van de Wege' and Th.H. Jetten" "Department of Entomology, Wageningen Agricultural University, P.O. Box 8031, 6700 EH Wageningen, The Netherlands
Abstract Malaria risk is determined by environmental and socio-economic factors. The predicted climate change under the greenhouse effect is likely to affect the epidemic potential of malaria due to a change in vector mosquito phenology and distribution. This effect was simulated using a computer model incorporating mosquito life stages and parasite infections in the mosquito and human host. It was found that both air and water temperature are the most important factors determining mosquito phenology and density. A temperature rise of +4~ shows major changes in mosquito distributions and densities at a worldwide scale, but more so in temperature regions than near the equator. The European situation was taken as an example to study epidemic potential under climate change. Malaria risk, in particular that of P l a s m o d i urn vivax, would increase under climate change. There is little risk for transmission of P. f a l c i p a r u m in currently temperate areas because the local anophelines are refractory to this parasite. In areas adjacent to malaria endemic regions, however, climate change may cause a dramatic shift in P. falciparum risk.
1. INTRODUCTION The predicted climate change as a result of the greenhouse effect is expected to cause major shifts in the distribution and epidemiological risk of vector-borne diseases (1), of which malaria is undoubtedly the most important. At present, some 400 million new cases of malaria appear each year with an estimated one million deaths (2). The world distribution of malaria is to a large extent determined by the geographical distribution of the anopheline vectors. In temperate regions malaria was eradicated due to a judicious use of control methods, which was made possible because of the absence of transmission in the winter months (3). Malaria eradication has failed in the tropics because of technical failures and inadequacies, environmental factors, and low level of socio-economic development. It is feared that under the predicted climate change the risk of malaria might return to areas where it was formerly endemic, as well as to areas adjacent to currently endemic regions. In the present study we investigated the risk of malaria transmission in Europe under climate change, using a simulation model for mosquito population dynamics and vectorial capacity.
776 2. THE MODEL A weather driven, stochastic life-table simulation model (MOSQSIM) was developed to simulate the phenology and population dynamics of mosquito species. The core of the program is the so-called fractional boxcar train. This numerical scheme simulates the development cycle of an entire population during one or more stages. Both development rate as well as dispersion of development rate can be changed during the simulation (4). The model calculates the development of the mosquito population with a daily output of all life stages. Water temperature, affecting development of the aquatic mosquito stages, is calculated via an energy exchange model. Malaria transmission is simulated by allowing fractions of mosquitoes to feed on malaria infectious hosts. 2.1 Meteorology Daily weather data on temperature, humidity and sunshine duration used for case studies were obtained from routine meteorological measurements for locations studied. Monthly averaged minimum, maximum and mean temperature, mean relative humidity, wind speed and sunshine duration were derived from a global climatological database (5). The database is used to define the various climate scenarios due to the greenhouse effect. Temperatures during the day have been simulated using the maximum and minimum air temperature. The temperature in the aquatic habitat is determined by the meteorological conditions (temperature, humidity, radiation, wind) and the characteristics of the habitat itself (depth, horizontal water flow, radiation absorption, vegetation). Estimated surface water temperatures were calculated using a mathematical model based on a model described by Losordo and Piedrahita (6). This model calculates temperature variation and thermal stratification in shallow aquaculture ponds.
3. RESULTS 3.1 Case study From a sensitivity analysis it was found that the temperature of the aquatic habitat plays an important role in larval development and survival. As far as we have been able to ascertain, only one reliable data set of both aquatic and terrestrial stages is available, namely from Aguas de Moura in Portugal (7). The larval and pupal countings reported by these authors were used to verify model computations for An.
777 1000000000
-=.
100000000
~
. . . . . . . . . . . . ..... ..... cocoa cmoom
F
I0 0 0 0 0 0 0
~-
1000000
= = k_
100000
S a m p l e s 1939 S a m p l e s 1940 S i m u l a f e d air f e m p e r a t u r e Simulated air+water femperature
-1
L
10000
7. I
~
-i
1000 ~
''
~!
,,,(/i
' ,/
E
~,,i\%
!
I00~_ F-
i~ ~
-I
/ v ~ "
"/
x~ ,~
!
--]
]
P '
120
1o Aguas
10000000 1000000
de
~
"
!
Time
I
"
i
'
I
'
!
~
:
'
i
I
240
(days)
Moura"
"
Larval
IV
~. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ~ ........... lF c o c o a S i m u l a f e d a i r t e m p e r a f u r e CC ff . . . . . Sim~lo,ed water+air temperature CC
100 } F-
rii~) . . . .
-= -~
j _--
c~
I 0000 F=_-
\
I
i~ ~
I
:
'
'
~ b
Aguas
~]
.560
stage
ooooo!
'
i
I
120
, '
I
Time
'
!
I
' ~_
(days)
de M o u r a "
40
',
l
I
i
I
I
I
560
Adulfs
Fig. 1 - Comparison of simulated and field collected data in Aguas de Moura, Portugal, of (A) larval populations of Anopheles atroparvus and of adult populations. Simulations are shown for air temperature only and air and water temperature combined.
778
atroparvus. Mean monthly maximum temperatures, minimum temperatures and relative humidities for Aguas de Moura during the period 1937-1940 were derived from (8). The simulations have the same pattern as the observations (Fig. 1). After two generations the number of emerging adults starts to decrease due to an increased mortality of the aquatic stages. At the same time adult mortality increases due to higher vapour pressure deficits. At the end of August the number of female adults reaches a minimum value and starts to increase again till November. A first peak of adults in May-June and a second peak in September-November was typical for southern Europe. 3.2 Distribution of malaria vectors in Europe
The distribution limits of the various species of the An. maculipennis complex are determined by environmental conditions. Mortality is closely related to aquatic and ambient temperatures. The model parameters found in literature have been used to calculate the population dynamics of members of the An. maculipennis complex over Europe using climate data. Incorporation of the water surface model (see above) enabled us to simulate the distribution of the various species. Results from simulations, using the weather data of the various stations in the Miiller climate-database, predicted where in Europe malaria was endemic. The model had a good fit with historic data from malaria endemic areas in Europe. Based on these simulations it is possible to use the MOSQSIM model to predict the effect of climate change on malaria. 3.3 European distribution An. atroparvus
An. atroparvus is the most widespread malaria vector in Europe. Under increasing temperatures (+4~ the model predicts an increase in adult mosquito densities in northern Europe but a decrease in southern Europe. At the southern distribution limit of An. atroparvus the number of adults sharply decreased. The highest densities were calculated for central Europe. Under increasing temperatures the model predicts an 100 fold or more increase in infectious mosquito densities in central Europe but a decrease in south-eastern Europe. 3.4 Epidemic potential
A comparative index to estimate malaria risk was derived from the vectorial capacity and is expressed as epidemic potential. This is defined as the reciproke of the critical density threshold of mosquitoes resulting in more than one new potentially infective contact per infectious person per unit time. Simulated global changes of yearly mean epidemic potential for Plasmodium falciparum caused by a temperature increase of 4~ show a projected worldwide increase and an extension of the areas conducive for malaria transmission as climate changes. The highest changes are seen at the northern and southern distribution limits of P. falciparum and at higher altitudes within malarious areas (9). Particularly in temperate zones where malaria was once widespread, epidemic potential is likely to increase due to a increase of
779
Cur. C l i . .
9
-." . "
. ..." 9-.. +ZK:
i
X
.x
< .00111 < .0111
x
<
.01
x
<
.1
>----
.1
i II
~
x~ x,x xx X X
~x
X
9
..L
I
Fig. 2 - The impact of a temperature increase on the simulated epidemic potential of P. vivax malaria in Europe for September. Cur.Cli. = Current Climate; +2K = temperature increase of 2~ +4K = temperature increase of 4~
parasite development rate in the mosquito, mosquito longevity and biting rate. This concerns large parts of the world including Europe, the Asiatic part of Russia and the continental USA. In these regions potential malaria transmission will largely be due to P. vivax because many anopheline species of these regions are refractory to P. falciparum. The model predicts that under a temperature rise of +4~ epidemic potential of P. vivax malaria increases 10 fold in southern Europe and 100 fold further north (Fig. 2).
4. DISCUSSION In the present study it is shown that the population dynamics and distribution of European malaria vectors can be simulated accurately provided the models incorporate environmental data from a large number of geographical locations. The significant difference between surface water temperature and ambient temperature as derived from this study, shows that the impact of climate change can affect insect populations in two ways. First, higher temperatures may cause increased mortality of aquatic stages in species adapted to the Mediterranean climate and second, higher temperatures lead to accelerated development and extra generations in the more northern vector species without the observed mortality in the aquatic stages. The study clearly
780 shows that the winter temperatures in Europe were the limiting factors for malaria transmission of the past. Under the predicted climate change, with higher annual temperatures, there will probably be a shift of anopheline distribution in Europe, with the southern species moving further north, and the northern species extending their phenological duration and density. For these reasons the risk of malaria transmission will increase provided infectious individuals are present in the human population. Endemic malaria has been eradicated from Europe since the nineteen seventies, and in the absence of a Plasmodium reservoir, we do not expect a return to a state of endemic malaria due to an increasing potential transmission intensity caused by climate change. The high level of socio-economic development in Europe, in particular the health care system and current animal husbandry, will prevent a reintroduction of endemic malaria. However, large numbers of imported cases of malaria are being registered in Europe each year due to the increased travel to and from endemic countries. Therefore, with the densities and distribution of European anopheline species increasing, there is an increased risk of incidental P. vivax cases, especially in those areas in south-eastern Europe where socio-economic conditions have deteriorated. The present study focused on the impact of climate change on malaria vectors in Europe. Preliminary investigations on a global level demonstrated that the models can be used to predict malaria risk and vector distribution on a larger scale (9; 10). Such studies will be especially useful to assess the risk of malaria (and other vector borne diseases) under climate change in areas that are bordering endemic regions and to predict the potential shift in transmission risk in endemic areas. Such studies are needed in order to prepare for the consequences of climate change at the socioeconomic level, particularly in developing countries.
5. REFERENCES
1
World Health Organization, Potential health effects of climatic change, report of a WHO task group. Geneva, 1990. 2 G.T. Strickland and S.L. Hoffman, Sci. Am. (Science and Medicine) 1 (1994) 24. 3 L.J. Bruce-Chwatt and J. de Zulueta. The rise and fall of malaria in europe. Butler and Tanner Ltd., London, 1980. 4 J. Goudriaan, pp 453-473 in J.A.J. Metz and O. Diekman (eds.), The dynamics of physiologically structured populations 68 (1986). 5 M.J. Miiller, Selected climatic data for a global set of standard stations for vegetation science, W. Junk Publishers, The Hague, 1982. 6 T.M. Losordo and R.H. Piedrahita, Ecol. Mod. 54 (1991) 189. 7 F.J.C. Cambournac and J.M. Simoes, Separata dos Anais do Instituto de Medicine Tropical (Lisbon) 1 (1944) 229. 8 F.J.C. Cambournac, Sobre a epidemiologia do sezonismo en Portugal. Sociedade Industrial de Tipografia, Lisboa, 1942. 9 Th.H. Jetten and W. Takken, Change 18 (1993) 10. 10 Th.H. Jetten, W.J.M. Martens and W. Takken, J. Med. Entomol. (submitted).
Climate Change Research: Evaluation and Policy Implications S. Zwerver, R.S.A.R. van Rompaey, M.T.J. Kok and M.M. Berk, (Eds.) 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
781
A S S E S S M E N T R E P O R T ON N R P S U B T H E M E
"IMPACT OF C L I M A T E C H A N G E ON T H E W A D D E N SEA"
W.J. Wolff Institute of Forestry and Nature Research (IBN-DLO) P.O.Box 23 6700 AA Wageningen The Netherlands
With contributions by: A.G. Brinkman, K.S. Dijkema, B.J. Ens C.J. Smit, G. Wintermans E.J. Houwing, N. Dankers J.A.J. Terwindt
J.J. Beukema, P.J.C. Honkoop
IBN/DLO, Institute of Forestry and Nature Research, Texel IMAU/UU, Institute for Marine and Atmospheric Research/ University of Utrecht NIOZ, Netherlands Institute for Sea Research, Texel
F. Gerritsen, T. Louters, J.P.M. Mulder
RIKZ, National Institute for Coastal and Marine Management, The Hague
G.M. Lenssen, J. Rozema
VUA, Free University of Amsterdam
782
Contents Abstract 1.
Introduction
2.
S h o r t description of the Wadden Sea
E x p e c t e d effects of climate c h a n g e on the Wadden Sea and c h o i c e of r e s e a r c h subjects
0
3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 0
Impact of increased CO2 concentrations 4.1 4.2
0
5.3 5.4
Impact of sealevel rise on the morphology of tidal fiat environments Impact of sealevel rise on erosion, sedimentation and plant dynamics in salt m a r s h e s Impact of sealevel rise on benthic animals of tidal fiats Impact of sealevel rise on shorebirds
Impact of c h a n g i n g water t e m p e r a t u r e s 6.1 6.2 6.3
0
Impact on s a l t m a r s h plants Evaluation
Impact of sealevel rise 5.1 5.2
0
Expected effects of an increase of C02 Effects of changes in t e m p e r a t u r e and other meteorological factors Effects of an increase rate of sealevel rise Effects of increased UV-B radiation Integration of effects
The effects of winter t e m p e r a t u r e on the reproductive success on some bivalves in the Dutch Wadden Sea Experimental tests of the effects of winter t e m p e r a t u r e on reproductive success of bivalves Evaluation
Integration 7.1 7.2 7.3
Integration of effects of climate changes on estuarine ecosystems Results of some scenario studies Evaluation
8.
Evaluation of the Wadden Sea studies of N R P I
9.
References
783 ABSTRACT This section summarizes studies on the effect of climate change on the estuarine Dutch Wadden Sea. Increased concentration of carbon dioxide is expected to have a r a t h e r small effect on s a l t m a r s h vegetation and a negligible effect on the functioning of the Wadden Sea ecosystem. Rates of sealevel rise of 60 and 85 cm per century are not expected to have a major impact on the geomorphology of tidal basins because of increased sedimentation. Also saltmarsh accretion may be able to keep pace with rates of sealevel rise of this magnitude, if erosion at the seaward edge can be controlled. Shorebird population sizes, which appear related to the area of tidal flats in their winter quarters, are not expected to decline because of change in the area of tidal flats in the Wadden Sea. However, because reproduction of several species of bivalve shellfish m a y be i m p a i r e d by h i g h e r w i n t e r temperatures, recruitment of these species may strongly decrease and this m a y affect shorebird populations. Model calculations do not show a major effect of higher winter temperatures on ecosystem functioning, however.
1.
INTRODUCTION
The Wadden Sea is a shallow tidal sea of about 8 000 km2 situated along the coasts of The Netherlands, Germany and Denmark. The Dutch part of the Wadden Sea is considered to be the most important nature area of The Netherlands. It has received recognization as such in the Physical Planning Decision (PKB) for the Waddenzee, about 2 000 km2 of it are protected under the N a t u r e Conservation Act, together with the Danish and German parts it has been given the status of 'Wetland of international importance' under the Convention of Ramsar, and it is recognized as a Biosphere Reserve by UNESCO. The Wadden Sea is one of the best studied wetlands of the world. Boekschoten (1973) estimated that, at that time, already 4,150 scientific publications described this area. This number has increased considerably since then. Hence the structure and functioning of the 'normal' Wadden Sea system are well known. Beukema et al. (1990) arrived at some preliminary conclusions about the possible effects of climate change on the Wadden Sea and other coastal areas. Table 1.1 lists the studies commissioned by the Dutch National Research P r o g r a m m e on Global Air Pollution and Climate Change (NRP I) on the effects of climate change on the Wadden Sea as well as some other relevant studies. In addition research on the effects of climate change has been carried out in the German Wadden Sea. This report aims at an assessment of the results of studies on the Wadden Sea commissioned by NRP I, taking in account any other relevant study.
784 Table 1.1 List of projects in the NRP subtheme "impact of climate change on the Wadden Sea" Title
Project leader
Number
Effects of an increased sealevel rise on geomorphology and ecological functioning of the Wadden Sea
T. Louters
850011
Salt marshes and sealevel rise: plant dynamics in relation to accretion processes and accretion enhancement techniques
J.H.J. Terwindt
850033
Effects of climate change on bird migration strategies
C.J. Smit
850034
Winter temperature and reproductive succes in bivalves living on tidal flats in Western Europe
J.J. Beukema
851053
Integration of effects of climate change on estuarine ecosystem communities
A.G. Brinkman
853127
Non-NRP funding Effects of atmospheric CO 2 enrichment, salinity and flooding on the ecology of C3 and C4 saltmarsh plants
J. Rozema/ G.M. Lenssen
Subsidence of a coastal area due to gas extraction as a model for sealevel rise
N. Dankers/ K.S. Dijkema
2.
S H O R T D E S C R I P T I O N OF T H E W A D D E N S E A
The Wadden Sea is a shallow estuarine area situated along the North Sea coasts of Denmark, Germany and The Netherlands. Average tidal ranges vary between 1.4 and 3.4 m. The Wadden Sea occupies about 8,000 km2 and about half of this area consists of bare tidal flats. Salt marshes occur only above mean high w a t e r m a r k and cover about 300 km2. The Dutch part of the Wadden Sea covers about 2500 km2. The Wadden Sea is considered to be one of the major n a t u r e areas of w e s t e r n Europe. Its tidal landscapes where n a t u r a l processes such as erosion and accretion are visibly active, seem relatively unaffected by humans. The extensive tidal flats contain extremely large numbers of benthic invertebrates and are characterized by high biomasses. Also the subtidal areas are rich in individuals and biomass. On this invertebrate biomass fish and birds feed in very large numbers. Many North Sea fish and crustacean species use the Wadden Sea as a nursery.
785 The bird population includes both breeding birds, such as gulls, terns, and several species of shorebirds, and non-breeding migratory species. The l a t t e r species mainly breed in the Arctic and visit the Wadden Sea as a stopover site during migration or as a wintering site. Non-breeding migratory species include geese, ducks, m a n y species of limicoles, and several other species. It is estimated t h a t altogether about 7 million shorebirds visit the Wadden Sea annually. Wolff (1983) gives an extensive description of the ecology of the Wadden Sea. The past ecological development of the Wadden Sea has been summarized in two review papers by Wolff (1992a) and Wolff et al. (1994). His conclusions are summarized below. In a completely n a t u r a l situation a Wadden Sea landscape would show the following sequence of belts of different landscape types when going from the North Sea to the higher inland areas (Figure 2.1): beaches, dunes and salt marshes on barrier islands tidal flats and channels salt and brackish marshes freshwater marshes, swamps, and peat bogs high-lying soils with forests and other dry vegetation types. It may be assumed t h a t these belts have moved shoreward under the influence of the rising sealevel in the geological past (Zagwijn, 1986). An increased r a t e of sealevel rise due to climate change would in principle have the same effect. Until about 1000 years ago m a n hardly interfered with the geomorphological development of the Wadden Sea. At t h a t time, however, the invention of dikebuilding introduced a major change (Wolff, 1992b). At the end of the 12th century the larger part of the vegetated landscape was separated from the tidal Wadden Sea by a contiguous system of dikes. Thus the connection between the Wadden Sea and the adjacent belt of brackish and fresh wetlands was broken. The result of all embankments and reclamations is a very marked and firm separation between the tidal Wadden Sea on the one hand and the non-tidal land and freshwater areas on the other hand. This hard boundary will prevent further shoreward movement of the coastal ecosystems e n u m e r a t e d above, which leads to the question w h e t h e r these systems can survive in their present position. FLATS .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
,:,:,:-.,:.- . . . .
I BARRIER ISLAND .
.
.
.
.
.
SALT MARSH FRESH PEAT HILLSI
DIKE .
.
.
.
TIDAL FLATS
POLDERS
HILLSI
.
............................................................................................. ~:................................. ~ ~i~i~i~
Figure
DIKE
~i~~i:i:i
Lw
9,.1
Cross-section t h r o u g h the Wadden Sea landscape in the Middle Ages and at present
786 Many species are known to have been introduced from abroad into the Wadden Sea area by h u m a n intervention. Most species were inadvertently introduced; some like the cord grass Spartina townsendii and the Japanese oyster Crassostrea gigas deliberately for, respectively, stimulation of accretion and oyster farming. Other new species were able to colonize the Wadden Sea because their habitat was introduced there. The best example is the construction of artificial rocky shores in the form of b r e a k w a t e r s , moles, and stone-covered dike slopes. It m a y be concluded that the Wadden Sea nowadays lodges quite a number of species of algae and invertebrates which did not occur there before. Most of these species have in common t h a t they are relatively small and short-living and that they have short reproduction cycles. They did not change the ecosystems very much. With respect to climate change it may be wondered whether any further immigrations due to an amelioration of the climate will have equally little effect. On the other hand, h u m a n activities have had such a strong impact on the Wadden Sea ecosystem, that several species have become extinct. Wolff (1992a) lists three species of marine mammals, six species of birds, seven species of fish, and three species of molluscs. Climate change might lead to f u r t h e r local extinctions because species cannot cope with the changed conditions. The following general conclusions may be drawn on the past changes of the Wadden Sea (see also Wolff 1992a; Wolff et al., 1994): in a seemingly natural area h u m a n s appear to have had a very strong impact on the ecosystems; already in the Middle Ages about half of the ecosystems had been destroyed; m a n y large, long-living and slowly reproducing species (K-selected species) have disappeared from the Wadden Sea, whereas many small, short-living and rapidly reproducing species (r-selected species) have colonized the area or increased in numbers. At present the Wadden Sea is managed as a nature reserve or national park, but at the same time several h u m a n activities are still possible. Among these are fisheries for fish, shrimps, and shellfish, mussel culture, extraction of shells, sand, and n a t u r a l gas, sailing and other forms of water sport, military exercises, and grazing of the salt marshes. Moreover, the Wadden Sea is strongly influenced by land drainage containing nutrients and toxic substances. Especially the influence of the river Rhine is quite important in the Dutch part of the Wadden Sea.
0
E X P E C T E D E F F E C T S OF CLIMATE C H A N G E O N T H E W A D D E N S E A AND C H O I C E OF R E S E A R C H S U B J E C T S
In November 1988 a workshop on the expected effects of climate change on marine coastal ecosystems was held at the island of Texel (Beukema et al., 1990). In several contributions the Wadden Sea served as a case study and m a n y of the conclusions of the workshop are applicable to the Wadden Sea. 3.1 E x p e c t e d effects of an i n c r e a s e of CO2 In the workshop cited above Long (1990) and Rozema et al. (1990) showed t h a t elevated CO2-concentrations have a clear impact on s a l t m a r s h plants. This observation has since been studied in the project 'Effects of atmospheric CO2 enrichment, salinity and flooding on the ecology of C3 and C 4 salt m a r s h plants' by
787 J. Rozema and G.M. Lenssen (Table 1.1). CO2-effects on the aquatic ecosystems were considered to be less important (Brouns, 1988) and consequently have not been a subject for further study. 3.2 E f f e c t s of c h a n g e s in t e m p e r a t u r e a n d o t h e r m e t e o r o l o g i c a l f a c t o r s In the 1988 workshop t e m p e r a t u r e and related climate factors were clearly identified as a factor which might strongly influence the distribution of plant and animal species (Van den Hoek et al., 1990; Breeman, 1990; De Vooys, 1990; Beukema, 1990; Wilson, 1990; Costa, 1990). Changed meteorological conditions on one hand will lead to the local extinction of species for which the habitat conditions become unsuitable, and on the other hand will enable other species to colonize new areas because the conditions have become suitable for them. These conclusions have not been followed up by detailed studies since it was reasoned that comparison of the Wadden Sea with estuarine areas more southerly would give enough information on the expected changes of occurrence of plant and animal species (De Vooys, 1990; Costa, 1990). Less attention was paid to shifts in the abundance of species due to changed conditions. However, one possible shift was singled out because of its possible importance for the Dutch shellfish cultures. This concerns the possibility t h a t a relatively small change of w a t e r t e m p e r a t u r e s might negatively affect the reproduction and subsequent survival of the larvae of a n u m b e r of shellfish species. This has been studied in greater detail in the project 'Winter temperature and reproductive succes in bivalves living on tidal fiats in Western Europe' by J.J. Beukema and P.J.C. Honkoop (Table 1.1). However, this study will continue for at least a year after the conclusion of NRP I, so definite conclusions are not yet possible. 3.3 E f f e c t s of an i n c r e a s e d r a t e of s e a l e v e l rise In the 1988 workshop an increased rate of sealevel rise was recognized as a factor with potentially great effects on the geomorphology and the ecology of the Wadden Sea and similar areas (Siefert, 1990; Misdorp et al., 1990; Westerhoff and Cleveringa, 1990; Lefeuvre, 1990; Huiskes, 1990; Dijkema et al., 1990; GossCustard et al., 1990). Salt marshes and tidal fiats could be inundated and this in turn could lead to impacts on the plant and animal species occurring. Consequently several projects addressed this possible problem (Table 1.1). The potential effects on the geomorphology and benthic fauna of tidal fiats were studied in the project 'Effects of an increased sealevel rise on geomorphology and ecological functioning of the Wadden Sea' by J.P.M. Mulder and T. Louters. The possible effects on the geomorphology and vegetation of salt marshes were investigated in the study 'Salt marshes and sealevel rise: plant dynamics in relation to accretion processes and accretion e n h a n c e m e n t techniques' by J.H.J. Terwindt, K.S. Dijkema and E.J. Houwing. The consequences of the possible inundation of tidal flats for shorebird populations were the subject of the study 'Effects of climate change on bird migration strategies' by C.J. Stair, B.J. Ens and G. Wintermans. In addition a non-NRP study on 'Subsidence of a coastal area due to gas extraction as a model for sealevel rise' by N. Dankers and K.S. Dijkema could be used as an experimental analogue of an increased rate of sealevel rise.
788 3.4 Effects of i n c r e a s e d UV-B radiation At the 1988 workshop UV-B was identified as another factor which might have consequences on the Wadden Sea ecosystem (Kramer, 1990; Van de Staay et al., 1990). In the latter study effects on saltmarsh plants were clearly demonstrated. The former study, however, concluded that increased UV-B radiation would have little effect on the biota of the turbid and turbulent Dutch coastal waters. An exception was made, however, for the organisms of tidal flats and shallow pools in the tidal zone during low tide. In view of this conclusion no further studies were commissioned. However, Peletier et al. (submitted) have shown since that benthic diatoms occurring on the Wadden Sea tidal flats show marked changes of abundance under the influence of increased UV-B. 3.5 I n t e g r a t i o n of effects Already in the 1988 workshop it became clear that many biota could become subject to the influence of several aspects of climate change at the same time (e.g. Van de Staay et al., 1990). To address this aspect of the impact of climate change the study 'Integration of effects of climate change on estuarine ecosystem communities' was started by A.G. Brinkman. Based on an already developed simulation model of the ecosystem of the Wadden Sea the various aspects of climate change had to be investigated simultaneously. 4.
IMPACT OF INCREASED CO2 CONCENTRATIONS
4.1 I m p a c t on s a l t m a r s h plants CO2 is essential for the growth of terrestrial and some aquatic plants. Other aquatic plant species are dependent on ions derived from dissolved carbon dioxide. In the photosynthetic process CO2 is chemically reduced to carbohydrates and part of these become plant material. How plants respond to increased CO2 concentrations depends on the photosynthetic pathway of the plant in question. In so-called C3 plants the C3 photosynthetic pathway will result in an increased photosynthetic rate and higher biomass production under higher levels of carbon dioxide. In C4 plants these effects are small or absent (Strain and Cure, 1985; Rozema et al., 1993). In Wadden Sea salt marshes both C3 and C4 plants occur. Increasing CO2 concentrations therefore may result in different rates of biomass production and, hence, in changed competitive abilities. This could lead to changes in the composition of saltmarsh vegetation. An effect on the amount of dead plant material exported from the marsh is also possible.
Experimental CO2 enrichment studies in salt marshes with C3 and C4 species in the Chesapeake Bay, USA, analysed the competitive relationships between the two types of plants (Arp, 1991). The CO2 experiments were done in the field for five continuous years. The C3 species Scirpus olneyi showed increased biomass under elevated atmospheric CO2, in contrast with the C4 grass Spartina patens. This long-term field research was one of the first experimental studies providing evidence that the competitive balance between C3 and C4 plants will shift in favour of the former ones. At the end of the five-year research period the C3 plants
789 demonstrated the same increased rates of growth and photosynthesis as at the start. This implies t h a t under field conditions these plant species do not show photosynthetic acclimation, that is a down regulation of the rate of photosynthesis as a result of end product negative feedback. In The Netherlands Lenssen (1993) investigated the response of three C3 species (Aster tripolium, Elymus athericus, Puccinellia maritima) and one C4 species (Spartina anglica)to CO2 enrichment in the project 'Effects of atmospheric CO2 enrichment, salinity and flooding on the ecology of C3 and C4 salt m a r s h plants' (Table 1.1). In addition he investigated whether the response to CO2 enrichment was modified by other environmental factors, viz. light, t e m p e r a t u r e , UV-B radiation, salinity, and flooding. In his experiments Lenssen (1993) found t h a t at a CO2 concentration of 720 ~tmol.mol-1 the C3 plants showed an increase of plant biomass of 19-33% relative to the ambient CO2 concentration. The only C 4 plant, however, was not stimulated by an higher concentration. These results confirm the earlier results of Curtis et al. (1990) and Arp (1991) for American salt marshes. However, the outcome of the experiments appears to be dependent on the other environmental factors studied. Higher temperatures as a result of climate change probably will favour the C4 species more. Also the other environmental factors influence the effect of increased CO2, but not in correlation with the C3- C4 separation. It may be concluded that higher atmospheric CO2 concentrations will result in higher biomass production of the C3 species and a loss of competitive ability of the C4 species. 4.2 E v a l u a t i o n Changes in competitive ability of saltmarsh plants will probably be reflected in a changed composition of the vegetation on Wadden Sea salt marshes. The higher biomass production probably will have an effect on the exchange of plant organic m a t t e r between saltmarsh and adjacent estuary, but in view of the magnitude of this exchange (Dankers et al., 1984) and the relatively small area of Wadden Sea salt marshes (see section 2) the effect on the Wadden Sea system will be negligible. In view of the conclusion drawn in Section 3.1 about the relative unimportance of CO2-effects below high-tide level, it is concluded here that no further studies on carbon dioxide effects are needed for the Wadden Sea. 5.
I M P A C T OF S E A L E V E L RISE
5.1 I m p a c t of s e a l e v e l r i s e o n t h e m o r p h o l o g y of tidal fiat e n v i r o n m e n t s
A geological evolutionary model of tidal basin development Van der Spek and Beets (1992) studied the evolution of a Wadden-Sea like tidal basin, the so-called Holland tidal basin, between 7000 BP and 3500 BP. Their results have been used to derive a geological model for tidal basin evolution under the influence of a rise in sealevel. The model emphasizes the balance between the extra storage capacity of the basin created by a sealevel rise, and the amount of sediment available for a geomorphological response. The model shows t h a t if the rate of sealevel rise exceeds the rate of sediment supply, the innermost parts of the basin will not receive sufficient sediment for an intertidal morphology to be
790 preserved. Eventually, sand will be deposited only in tidal channels and in the flood tidal delta through which the sediment is supplied; mud deposition will occur in the interchannel areas, and salt marshes will disappear.
An e m p i r i c a l model of the morphological behaviour a n d s t a b i l i t y of channels and fiats in tidal basins D e p a r t i n g from the geological model Eysink (1992) has defined an empirical morphological model MORRES (acronym for MORphological RESponse model) which is b a s e d on a set of empirical equilibrium r e l a t i o n s h i p s b e t w e e n hydrodynamic and geomorphological characteristics of tidal basins. This model is a sediment balance model describing the long-term geomorphological development of the Wadden Sea as a result of increased sealevel rise on the scale of a tidal basin. It covers the geographical units outer delta, inlet and basin. The outer delta is characterized by its sand volume. The inlet is characterized by a cross-sectional area and its length. The tidal basin is characterized by the curve representing the hypsometry. The area and elevation of the tidal flats, defined as the area between m e a n high w a t e r (MHW) and mean low water (MLW), and the depth of the basin are derived from the hypsometric curve. The basin is defined as the surface area at high water. Furthermore, the water motion in the basin is characterized by the tidal prism of the basin. The tidal range in the basin is assumed to remain constant during the morphological adaptation process. The exchange of sediment between the tidal basin and the adjacent sea is based on the principle of a sand trap. An (accelerated) rise in sealevel will cause a regional rise of the average water level in the Wadden Sea. In other words, the depth of the Wadden Sea will increase somewhat. Hence, the dynamic equilibrium will be slightly disturbed. This slight depth increase will cause a slight deceleration of the average current speeds in the channels and over the flats. Since the capacity for sediment transport is a power function of the current speed, the sediment t r a n s p o r t capacity will drop much more as the current speed slows. The flood stream carrying sediment will continue to deposit sediment in the basin. However, the ebb current does not have enough force to lift and remove the total quantity brought in. Thus, over a longer period, this creates a net sand t r a n s p o r t towards the tidal basin. This p r o p e r t y of deepened tidal basins to demand large quantities of sand is termed sand demand or 'sand hunger'. The total quantity of sand required to restore dynamic equilibrium is directly proportional to the depth increase. Hence, sealevel rise will result in filling in of the tidal basin until a new equilibrium is reached. The sand will be derived from the outer deltas of the inlets and eventually from the coasts of the barrier islands. Other changes in the morphology of a tidal basin, e.g. sand extraction, subsidence of the seafloor due to gas extraction, reduction of the tidal basin due to engineering works or accretion of salt marshes, will cause similar reactions of the tidal basin. To predict the behaviour of the Wadden Sea under conditions of sealevel rise on the basis of the empirical r e l a t i o n s h i p s b e t w e e n a n u m b e r of morphological characteristics, it has been assumed t h a t the system will strive for equilibrium. This assumption can be validated by the observations made after two tidal inlets have been changed drastically by reducing their tidal area through the building of dams (1932: Zuiderzee; 1969: Lauwerszee). In both cases the system shows a development towards a new equilibrium.
791 The knowledge of the processes governing the morphology of the tidal flats is rather limited. Observations have shown that, generally speaking, the present rate of flat growth can keep up with the current rise in sealevel of about 20 cm per century. The m a x i m u m r a t e s of increase of tidal flat level derived from measurements in the period 1925-1987, appear to be around 8-13 mm annually. It seems t h a t the tidal flat system has the capacity to compensate for a wide range of rates of rise in sealevel by raising its level. It remains to be seen whether the flats can keep up this growth rate in an increasingly rough wave climate at an accelerated rise in sealevel. This requires more knowledge of the process. To make a prediction of the effects of sealevel rise on the Wadden Sea tidal flats, Louters and Gerritsen (1994)used three different rates of sealevel rise: (1)present rate of 20 cm per century, (2) a predicted rate of 60 cm per century, and (3) a worst-case scenario of 85 cm per century. In addition the effects of other h u m a n interventions, such as sand and shell extraction, and subsidence due to gas extraction, are taken into account.
Consequences o f some likely scenarios o f sealevel rise for the t i d a l fiats and channels of the Wadden Sea The Wadden Sea was created by the rising sealevel. Should this rise slow down or cease in combination with inflow of sediment, the Wadden Sea will silt up. If, on the other hand, the sealevel rises too fast, or too fast in proportion to the inflow of sediment, the tidal flats will become inundated. The future of the Wadden Sea depends on the balance between the supply and the demand of sediment, both of which nowadays are largely under the influence of mankind. On a regional and local scale, the d e m a n d for sediment is partly determined by the effects of mineral extraction (gas, sand and shells) and by the size reduction of the basin caused by e m b a n k m e n t and reclamation projects. Table 5.1 shows t h a t under rates of sealevel rise of 60 and 85 cm per century the Wadden Sea system is still able to track sealevel (nearly) without any time lag. Under this assumption the consequences of these rates of sealevel rise for the Dutch Wadden Sea system have been analyzed (Louters and Gerritsen, 1994). Huge quantities of sediment are transported by the tides between North Sea and Wadden Sea. The flood transports annually about 40-60 million m3 of sand and 100-200 million m3 of silt and clay through the tidal inlets of the Wadden Sea. The ebb carries quantities of the same order of magnitude, but the variance of the data is such t h a t no conclusions can be drawn from the flood and ebb transports about any net transport. It is clear, however, that the quantities transported are much larger t h a n those required to explain sedimentation and/or erosion rates observed in the area.
792 Table 5.1 Amounts of sediment required annually (in million m3 per year) to compensate for changes in the morphology of the tidal basins of the Dutch Wadden Sea Sediment demand (106 m3 per year) 1990 - Present rate of sealevel rise (20 cm/100 year) - Past engineering works Extraction of sand and shells Extraction of natural gas Accretion of salt marshes - Total sediment requirement at present rate of rise -
-
-
- Extra required at sealevel rise of 60 cm/100 yrs - Extra required at sealevel rise of 85 cm/100 yrs
2040
2090
4-5
4-5
4-5
2-3 8-9 0.3 0-9
1-2 6 1-2 0-9
1-2 6 0 0-9
14-26
12-24
11-22
4-5
6-7
6-7
9-10
Louters and Gerritsen (1994) attempt to quantify the amounts of sand needed for the various changes in basin morphology in the Dutch Wadden Sea with use of the empirical model MORRES (Table 5.1).
Effects of engineering works. To restore the disturbed dynamic equilibrium caused by the damming of the Zuiderzee (1932) and Lauwerszee (1969) a long term supply of sand is needed. In the remaining Zuiderzee basin (= the westernmost part of the Wadden Sea) about 100-200 million mS sediment have been deposited in the past 60 years. Louters and Gerritsen (1994) estimated that the total restoration of the basin morphology will require another 700-900 million mS, of which about 70% will be needed in the first 300 years. Therefore the westernmost part of the Wadden Sea will continue to require 1-2 million m3 annually. The much smaller Lauwerszee basin requires about 50 million m3 of sediment of which about 60% had been deposited up to 1987. It is expected t h a t about 1 million mS will be deposited annually in the next 30 years. Altogether the compensation required because of past engineering works will demand 2-3 million m3 annually; at a later stage this will become less.
Extraction of sand and shells. Louters and Gerritsen (1994) report t h a t in the period 1960-1990 annually about 8-9 million m3 of sand have been derived from the Wadden Sea. They expect, based on present government policy, t h a t in the future this amount will consist of about 6 million m 3 of sand and 0.14 million m3 of shells. About 75% of this will be derived from the Ems estuary by dredging in relation to shipping.
793
Extraction of gas. Especially in the e a s t e r n p a r t of the Dutch W a d d e n Sea subsidence of the seafloor due to extraction of n a t u r a l gas will require some 1 million m3 per year for the coming decennia.
Accretion of salt marshes. N a t u r a l accretion of salt m a r s h e s occurred in the past centuries. Although the exact rates of horizontal accretion are not known, an indication m a y be derived from the rate of reclamations, since reclamation of salt m a r s h e s m a y be assumed to have kept pace with horizontal accretion of marshes. Hence, in the past the rate of accretion m a y have been 1.5 km2 per year (Dijkema, 1987). This rate will have required a compensatory sand supply to the tidal basin of about 7-9 million m3 annually. Nowadays, however, the salt m a r s h e s do not show horizontal accretion any longer; in fact the s a l t m a r s h area has been stable since about 1970. Consequently the sand demand of the W a d d e n Sea caused by salt m a r s h accretion m a y be expected to be much less or even nil nowadays. This situation is dependent on h u m a n m a n a g e m e n t of the marshes. For the long t e r m the value of 7-9 million m3 per year may be considered as a ceiling.
Sealevel rise. The present rate of sealevel rise in the Wadden Sea (about 20 cm per century) requires 4-5 million m3 of sand per year for compensation of the depth changes in the tidal basin. An increased rate of sealevel rise of 60 cm per century will require an additional 6-7 million m3 per year in 2090, and a rate of 85 cm per century will need 9-10 million m3 extra per year. The r a t e s of s e d i m e n t a t i o n predicted are much smaller t h a n the a m o u n t s of s e d i m e n t transported. Hence, it is expected t h a t the tidal basins of the Dutch Wadden Sea can keep up with rates of sealevel rise of 60 and 85 cm per century, respectively. Thus it becomes possible to predict the change in the area of tidal flats in the next 50-100 years. It is concluded t h a t a rate of sealevel rise of 60 cm per century will result in a loss of about 0.5% of the area of tidal flats, provided t h a t the supply of sand r e m a i n s constant; a rate of 85 cm will result in a loss of about 1%. These insignificant changes are more t h a n compensated by the expected development of new tidal flats in those tidal basins which still are restoring from the effects of engineering works in the past. For the Marsdiep basin a development of new flats of about 30-50 km2 is possible (2.5-4% of the Wadden Sea total). However, for the individual tidal basins of the Marsdiep and the Ems-Dollard the total a m o u n t of sediment required at rates of sealevel rise of 60 cm and more per century, m a y come very close to the potential supply. Evaluation The study about the effect of accelerated sealevel rise on the flats in tidal basins has a n u m b e r of aspects which require attention. In the first place the model MORRES has been based on empirical relationships determined under the present rate of sealevel rise. It can not be verified w h e t h e r these relationships, such as the assumption of a dynamic equilibrium, will also hold at much higher rates of sealevel rise. Secondly, the results have been based on the assumption of a sediment supply larger t h a n the sediment demand. Above it was already indicated t h a t this is not necessarily true.
794 Thirdly, the model operates at the scale of the tidal basin, which makes translation of the result to ecologically meaningful scales difficult. On the other hand the study provides insight in one of the probably major impacts on the present Wadden Sea system by climate change. Hence, it will be useful to continue the studies on the future development of tidal flat morphology, especially at smaller scales.
5.2 I m p a c t of sealevel rise on erosion, s e d i m e n t a t i o n and plant d y n a m i c s in salt m a r s h e s S a l t m a r s h e s , s a l t m a r s h w o r k s a n d sealevel rise Salt marshes are areas covered with terrestrial vegetation under the influence of seawater. In the Wadden Sea these marshes are found at levels above about mean high tide level at neap tides. Originally salt marshes occurred up to the highest level of regular saltwater flooding. This is still the case on parts of the barrier islands, but elsewhere, especially along the mainland coast, salt m a r s h e s are bounded by the seawall. Moreover the salt marshes along the larger part of the m a i n l a n d coast have been created by h u m a n intervention t h r o u g h m e a s u r e s stimulating accretion (Figure 5.1). This activity, originally aimed at gaining new land for agriculture, has been abandoned in 1980; nowadays the status quo is maintained for these marshes in order to preserve them as nature reserves. Hence, the former 'land reclamation works' have been coined now ' s a l t m a r s h works'. The present area of salt marshes, including the saltmarsh works, in the Dutch part of the Wadden Sea is 73 km2 (Dijkema et al., 1990). The vertical growth of the marsh is determined by the rates of minerogenic and organogenic sedimentation, the frequency and period of tidal flooding and the overall compaction of the sediment (Allen, 1990; Craft et al., 1992). The s e d i m e n t a t i o n rate on the m a r s h is controlled by the m e a n tidal amplitude (Stevenson et al., 1986) and is a function of the height of the saltmarsh in relation to mean high water level (Dijkema et al., 1990). For partly or wholly minerogenic marshes the transport of fine sediment to the marsh surface is mainly dominated by the flood tidal currents (Allen, 1990; Postma, 1967). In addition, the sedimentation rate on flats and marshes is high in those areas which are sheltered, frequently overflooded and where the sediment supply is high.
795
3 rd
field
sedimentation field
....
'---4
.....
I i
2 nd
~
......
i
!
field
!
1 ......
'
, i
-----II IlIHIHi
"
subfield (|OOxlOOm)
....... ~l]HlnT]n Ii
IIIIIIIIIIIIIi_ ....._______,
(400xqOOm)
.~e~ ,n~ ,o~
measurements of elevation
. .......
~u~,.~o ~o,n. earth groyne ~main
....
1st
.
"
.......
: nnnnH
field
I
i.......nlnHIl
[...... 7nIH ll ~
ditch
ditch , open field drain
o
,oo
2.__~.__==oo
m
IIIIIIIIIIIII
Figure 5.1. Scheme of the s a l t m a r s h works along the m a i n l a n d coast of the Dutch W a d d e n Sea. The Wadden Sea is at the top of the figure, the land at the bottom W a d d e n Sea salt m a r s h e s grow t h r o u g h deposition of s e d i m e n t which leads to relatively slow (mm's - cm's per y e a r ) v e r t i c a l growth of the m a r s h a n d at the s a m e t i m e relatively rapid (dm's - m's per year) horizontal growth at the s e a w a r d edge. W a d d e n Sea salt m a r s h e s decrease t h r o u g h erosion, vertically all over the m a r s h as well as horizontally, often in the form of cliffs, m a i n l y at the s e a w a r d side. An horizontally eroding m a r s h can be growing vertically at the same time. On the m a r s h the balance between sedimentation and erosion is usually positive. The balance b e t w e e n erosion and accretion at the s e a w a r d edge of the m a r s h , w h e r e pioneer v e g e t a t i o n e s t a b l i s h e s i t s e l f d u r i n g accretion, b u t w h e r e t h e s a m e vegetation is destroyed during erosion, is m u c h more unstable. This s e a w a r d edge or pioneer zone, apparently is the most vulnerable zone of the marsh. Most s a l t m a r s h e s along the m a i n l a n d coast h a v e a static b o u n d a r y at t h e l a n d w a r d side in the form of a huge seawall; the s e a w a r d b o u n d a r y of m a n y W a d d e n Sea m a r s h e s is fixed by m e a n s of the construction of brushwood groynes. Because of the seawall the m a r s h e s cannot shift their position l a n d w a r d during an increase in sealevel rise. Their only way to survive is to h e i g t h e n up the bed level and so keep pace w i t h the increase in sealevel. It depends on the outcome of the change in processes and s e d i m e n t t r a n s p o r t on and towards the salt m a r s h e s , if these m a r s h e s eventually will submerge or keep pace with an increase in sealevel rise. Since the salt m a r s h e s in the Netherlands Wadden Sea are a result of the dynamic equilibrium between the sedimentation and the erosion processes, changes in the
796 hydrodynamic parameters which might be changed by sealevel rise and climate change, like tidal amplitude, mean high water and wave height distribution, are expected to change the sediment transport pattern in the Wadden Sea and the net result of the processes on the salt marshes. In order to predict the effect of sealevel rise on s a l t m a r s h development, the hydrodynamics and the sedimentation and erosion processes have been studied during NRP I at three locations in the saltmarsh works along the mainland coast. At the same places the adaptation of the vegetation cover to changes in the hydrodynamic parameters has been investigated.
H i s t o r i c a l development o f Wadden Sea salt marshes In the mediaeval Wadden Sea large areas of salt m a r s h e s occurred. H u m a n impact was negligible and probably consisted mainly of building artificial mounds for building houses and of grazing cattle. E m b a n k m e n t of m a r s h e s probably started in the 10th century and by 1300 large areas had been surrounded by dikes. After this time saltmarsh reclamation continued and more or less kept pace with the accretion of new m a r s h e s (Dijkema, 1987). On average about 1.5 kin2 of m a r s h was reclaimed annually. From the 17th century onwards man started to build sand dikes on the barrier islands. In the lee of the dune-like constructions new salt marshes developed. Some of these areas have been reclaimed since, but on several areas large areas of saltmarsh still occur. Along the mainland coast reclamations gradually overtook the natural accretion. One reaction of the coastal population was to stimulate drainage by digging ditches. Thus the marsh area was better drained which enabled the establishment and development of vegetation which again stimulated accretion and growth of the marsh. Subsequently the new marshes could be embanked. From 1930 onwards, brushwood groynes have been build along the mainland coast of the Dutch Wadden Sea to stimulate accretion even more. The construction of the brushwood groynes significantly increased the rate of sedimentation in the areas in between (Dijkema et al., 1988, 1990). Digging of ditches occurred already before 1930. Through the combination of brushwood groynes and ditches the m a r s h area expanded seaward with 8.2 m yr-1 for the Friesland coastal area and 4.7 m yr-1 for the Groningen area during the period 1960-1985 (Bakker et al., 1993). The sedimentation rate and seaward expansion of the saltmarsh was higher during the first years of the construction of the brushwood groynes (1960-1978). Later saltmarsh expansion arrested and erosion occurred from 1978 to present. In 1980 the Netherlands government decided that the existing salt marshes would not be embanked and instead managed as nature reserves. The s a l t m a r s h works had to be aimed at maintaining the status quo. Since, hardly any further accretion of the m a r s h e s has occurred. Partly this can be ascribed to a reduction of the m a n a g e m e n t effort, but other factors have to play a part as well. Van Malde (1992) found for different gauge stations in the Netherlands part of the Wadden Sea an increase in mean sealevel, according to the trend line computed for the period from 1900 till 1960, of about 0.18 cm yr-1. Recent years have shown an accelerated increase in mean high water level of 0.44 cm yr-1 from 1961 to 1983
797 (Dijkema et al., 1990). It has been suggested that this recent rapid rise of m e a n high-tide level could be responsible for the present standstill of the m a r s h growth thus illustrating the vulnerability of the m a r s h for increased rates of sealevel rise (Bossinade et al., 1993). The present m a n a g e m e n t of the man-made marshes or saltmarsh works along the mainland aims in the first place at a reduction of turbulence on and in front of the salt marshes. This is done by the construction of the brushwood groynes. The result is twofold: reduction of the near-bed turbulence leads to less erosion of the bed and it leads to possible increase in sedimentation of mud in and in front of the m a r s h zone. Secondly, m a n a g e m e n t of the m a r s h area aims at protection and improvement of the cover of the vegetation. This results partly from the construction of the groynes: protection of the vegetation against waves and currents, and partly from digging ditches. This ensures a good drainage of the bed which reduces sediment mobility and improves the growth of the vegetation (Reed and Cahoon, 1992).
Transport of sediment and sedimentation The sediment dynamics on and in front of the salt-marshes are determined by the tidal current and the waves. Waves determine the amount of (re)suspended matter and currents will transport the sediment in suspension. The sedimentation on the salt m a r s h e s is d e p e n d e n t on the near-bed turbulence and the grain-size distribution of the transported sediment. Suspended sediment concentrations have been measured during the NRP I study s i m u l t a n e o u s l y with hydrodynamic m e a s u r e m e n t s . The s u s p e n d e d sediment consists of the mud fraction (<50 ~m) only. It is concluded that mud is transported as suspended load throughout the entire water column. Sand, on the contrary, is resuspended by wave action and transported close to the bed as bed load. The data show a decline in the sediment concentration from flood towards ebb. Thus it seems that suspended sediment is transported into m a r s h area. However, the amount of transported sediment is a function of the concentration times the current velocity and the net transport is also dependent on the current direction. It is to be expected that the vegetated parts will show less turbulence in the near-bed water column and most sediment will be deposited here. Advective t r a n s p o r t of suspended sediment into the s a l t m a r s h works has been found during moderate weather conditions as well as just before storms and shortly after a storm period. During storm conditions sediment in the s a l t m a r s h works is r e s u s p e n d e d by wave action and t r a n s p o r t e d from the m a r s h by the strong currents. In this case, the brushwood groynes prevent the loss of large quantities of sand out of the sedimentation fields. These data confirm the earlier results of Dankers et al. (1984) and Asjes et al. (1992) who found a net transport of sediment to Wadden Sea salt marshes on an annual basis. These authors also report that transport towards the m a r s h occurs during quiet weather, whereas seaward transport may occur during storms. Net sedimentation rates have been reported by Dijkema et al. (1990). They vary in time and space and range from about - 1 cm per year to + 3 cm per year. Most marshes show positive vertical accretion rates.
798
Erosion A recent loss in saltmarsh area in the Wadden Sea might be due to an accelerated increase in mean high water level of 0.44 cm yr-1 from 1961 to 1983 (Dijkema et al., 1990), of which between 1976 and 1983 about 75% is calculated to be due to an increase in average windspeed (Bossinade et al., 1993). During the NRP I study much attention has been given to erosion processes. It is concluded from field m e a s u r e m e n t s t h a t the tidal c u r r e n t velocity perpendicular to the shore during moderate (summer) weather conditions never exceeds 10 cm per second inside the brushwood groynes. During storm conditions the waterdepth increases significantly due to wind set up and the current velocity can reach up to 20 cm per second. The ebb current is stronger t h a n the flood current. The alongshore tidal current velocity is extremely low during moderate (summer) conditions. However, wind induced alongshore current velocities can range up to 40 cm per second (as much as 10 times the tidal current component). Wind waves grow during an increase in windspeed and fetch length. It is concluded t h a t the w a t e r d e p t h is the limiting factor for wind induced wave growth at the m a r s h sites. The construction of brushwood groynes, in this situation, does not have any effect on wind wave growth at the m e a s u r e m e n t location some 200 m e t e r distance from the groynes. This conclusion is confirmed by model calculations showing that the growth of wind waves is completed within 30 meters distance from the groynes (Elfrink and Houwing, in prep). A new in-situ erosion meter has been developed to measure the in-situ bed-shear strength of cohesive beds. This in-situ erosion flume (ISEF) is a circulating flow system in the vertical plane. The bottom part of the horizontal test-section is open over a length of 0.9 meter. Current velocity and sediment concentration sensors are fixed in the flume. The shear stress, exerted on the bed by the unidirectional current in the ISEF, causes an erosion of the bed. This erosion is measured by the concentration sensor. It is assumed t h a t the current velocity, at initiation of motion of the top layer of the bed, can be used to compute the critical bed-shear stress. This critical shear stress is assumed to be the characteristic p a r a m e t e r which defines the different types of sediment beds. The results from the ISEF m e a s u r e m e n t s show only small differences in the erosion resistance of the bed within the s a l t m a r s h works. This m e a n s that, theoretically, the bed strength does not differ spatially within the fields and erosion of the bed will start, if the shear-stress is high enough, simultaneously at different places. However, visual observations at low tide show that erosion of the bed is very local. It starts at specific locations only, for instance where the structure of the bed is disturbed by bioturbation. These small-scale erosion p a t t e r n s can generate larger scale erosion forms.
Vegetation and climate change Sea-level rise could become a t h r e a t to coastal marshes by affecting the m a r s h vegetation through an increase of the frequency of tidal flooding and wave energy. If the accretion of sediment on the marsh is less than the increase in sea-level, the m a r s h will be flooded more frequently and vegetation deterioration will increase (Reed and Cahoon, 1992). Similarly, erosion of the marsh will also result in a loss of vegetation and subsequently in a loss of saltmarsh area. Salicornia dolichostachya is the most i m p o r t a n t pioneer species found in the foreland salt marshes of the Wadden Sea. The first important and perhaps most critical phase in the life cycle of Salicornia is the germination and survival of the
799 seedlings (Ungar, 1978). It determines, in combination with growth, the plant density at the end of the growing season and biomass of the fully grown Salicornia population. The second important phase in the life cycle is the seed production. If the a m o u n t of seeds remaining in the pioneer zone after the winter is too low, the size of the Salicornia population will decline which might have a great influence on the development of the saltmarsh as a whole. Although S. dolichostachya is able to reduce wave energy and thus create suitable circumstances for sediment to settle, this annual species is not able to fix mud and therefore does not seem to be of great value for accretion on salt m a r s h e s . However, Salicornia fulfils an i m p o r t a n t role in the spreading and s e a w a r d expanding of Puccinellia maritima. This very important species for silting up is spread mainly by vegetative parts torn from the parent plant. P a r t of these tillers get caught behind living, or in winter dead, Salicornia plants and can establish themselves especially on the higher parts of the pioneer zone (Kamps, 1962). Hence, the presence of Salicornia in the pioneer zone is very i m p o r t a n t for the expansion of salt marshes. The size of the glasswort dominated pioneer zone might be an indication of the quality of the saltmarsh. Therefore, more information has been collected about the life cycle and boundary conditions for establishment of this species. Like Jeffries et al. (1981) no seed bank was found in October before seedfall. Like Beeftink (1985) found for Salicornia procumbens, the population of Salicornia dolichostachya is thinned especially during the seed phase in winter time (99% of the produced seeds was removed from the pioneer zone) and during the growth from established seedlings to fully grown plants (65 % of the seedlings did not survive). Nevertheless, on both sites the development of the Salicornia population does not seem to be limited by a lack of seeds. In contrast to Joenje (1978), it was found in this study t h a t seeds do not act as in water suspended sediment, but are transported as bed load like sand grains (6072~). Finally, m a n y seeds will end up in creeks bottoms where they cannot germinate because of lack of oxygen and a high salt concentration. Evaluation
At the time of writing of this assessment report the s a l t m a r s h study was not yet completed. Especially the relationships between the different parts of the study had not yet been sufficiently developed. Nevertheless the study m a k e s clear t h a t s a l t m a r s h erosion is a complicated process and that further research is required on this subject. The s a l t m a r s h study under NRP I considered processes at the scale of the m2. This makes comparison with the results of the other studies a difficult task. A very detailed in-depth study of some important processes in the saltmarsh, necessarily leads to a lack of overview. On the basis of the results it is not yet possible to make predictions about the impact of sealevel rise on the entire s a l t m a r s h area of the Dutch Wadden Sea. On the other hand some conclusions on the effectivity of the brushwood groynes in stimulating s a l t m a r s h accretion emerged. These conclusions may be incorporated in the m a n a g e m e n t plans for these areas. As a preliminary conclusion from the NRP I study emerges t h a t Wadden Sea salt marshes may survive an increased rate of sealevel rise if erosion processes can be
800 controlled. Sediment supply and accretion rates seem to be sufficient for higher rates of increase of sealevel than at present. This conclusion is in line with a recent study (Oost and Dijkema, 1993) on the possible effects of soil subsidence due to gas extraction on W a d d e n Sea salt m a r s h e s . They concluded t h a t the salt m a r s h e s at the b a r r i e r islands could accomodate a soil subsidence (= equivalent to a sealevel rise) of 0.5 cm per year (= 50 cm per century), whereas the mainland marshes could survive a rate of 1.0 cm per year. However, they drew attention to the vulnerability of the pioneer zone of the m a r s h e s with respect to erosion processes. The conclusions reached above might be tested by the large-scale field study of the effects of soil subsidence due to extraction of n a t u r a l gas (see Table 1.1). This 'experiment' gives information on the behaviour of several km2 of salt marshes in a 'simulated' rapid rise of sealevel. Unfortunately the results of this study have not yet been completely analyzed. 5.3 I m p a c t of s e a l e v e l r i s e o n b e n t h i c a n i m a l s of tidal fiats
Results of a literature study Louters and Gerritsen (1994) report the results of a literature study on the impact of sealevel rise on benthic animals of tidal flats. They conclude t h a t most of the tidal flat species are characterized by a broad ecological amplitude with regard to salinity, w a t e r movements, sediment characteristics, and period of emergence of the tidal flats. Hence, they conclude t h a t sealevel rise as such will not have an i m p o r t a n t ecological effect on tidal flat organisms as long as the present a r e a of tidal flats does not change very much. F r a g m e n t a t i o n of large tidal flat areas because of sealevel rise might result in a situation with more smaller tidal flats, each with an low-tide edge relatively poor in benthic animals. This might have consequences for the food supply for birds and fish.
Evaluation This literature study lacks experimental verification, but there is little to indicate t h a t e x p e r i m e n t s on the effects of higher w a t e r levels would result in other conclusions for the individual species. Also the study did not address the impact of sealevel rise on new species which might colonize the Wadden Sea because of higher temperatures. 5.4 I m p a c t of s e a l e v e l rise on s h o r e b i r d s
Defining the problem of sealevel rise for shorebirds Along coasts m a n y bird species can be seen feeding on the tidal flats. In the Dutch W a d d e n Sea this includes 15-20 a b u n d a n t species from different taxonomic groups: geese, ducks, waders, and gulls. The various species breed in an area ranging from N.E. Canada through Greenland, Iceland, Spitsbergen, and Europe to n o r t h e r n Russia and Siberia. After the breeding season these birds migrate to the Wadden Sea either to stay there all winter or to remain there for a shorter period to feed and to moult, after which the birds fly on to wintering areas further South, e.g. in western Africa. Next spring these populations return to the breeding areas, often after another stopover in the Wadden Sea.
801 D u r i n g t h e i r life cycle these shorebirds are dependent on two very different habitats. They breed in terrestrial environments which differ according to the species concerned. Some species breed in salt m a r s h e s or dune areas, other in agricultural landscapes, still others in heathlands or forests, and several species have their breeding habitat in the Arctic tundra. At first sight it seems t h a t many, if not all species occupy huge areas as breeding ranges. Outside the breeding season, however, all these birds concentrate in a r a t h e r small n u m b e r of tidal flat areas where most of them feed on benthic animals such as shellfish and worms, and some graze algae and seagrasses. The total area of tidal flats along the flyway these bird populations use is small, only about 7,000 km2 of which about 50% are situated in the Wadden Sea. Hence, it has been suggested t h a t the numbers of these birds are primarily governed by competition for food present in their tidal flat habitat in winter. If so, disappearance of tidal flats due to sealevel rise could have a very large effect on these bird populations. When density-dependent processes operate on both the wintering grounds and the breeding grounds of shorebird populations a reduction of either habitat will lead to a decrease in population size (Fretwell, 1972; Goss-Custard, 1980). This implies t h a t when sealevel rise will cause a change in the area of tidal flats available as feeding grounds, population size of shorebirds may be changing too. Furthermore, m a n y species of shorebirds are concentrated in only a few widely separated estuaries during w i n t e r and migration. It is thought t h a t this makes these species especially vulnerable to h a b i t a t loss, as this distribution p a t t e r n breaks the normal link between the a b u n d a n c e of a species and its i m m u n i t y to extinction (Myers et al., 1987; Davidson and Piersma, 1992). Among the bird species dependent on tidal flats limicoles or w a d e r s keep a prominent position. Most wader species breed in arctic or subarctic environments and spend the time outside the breeding season on tidal flats south of their breeding areas. The are several indications t h a t competition in the w i n t e r q u a r t e r s does occur. Several species exhibit leapfrog migration, whereby more northerly breeding populations w i n t e r south of more southerly breeding populations, which is generally attributed to the avoidance of competition (Greenberg, 1986). There is also direct evidence for both competition for food on the wintering grounds, through interference and prey depletion, and for competition for territorial space on the breeding grounds (Goss-Custard, 1986). Several studies exist t h a t report on the effects of loss of tidal flats due to h u m a n interventions. Evans (1978) reports t h a t following a reclamation of 60 % of the intertidal flats of the Tees estuary in north-east England, the wintering numbers of the majority of wader species decreased by a similar percentage or more in the year following the reclamation. Similar results are reported for reclamation of intertidal areas of the Forth estuary in eastern Scotland (McLusky et al., 1992). The construction of a dam across the entrance of the Grevelingen estuary in The N e t h e r l a n d s ended tidal movements in the e s t u a r y and resulted in complete disappearance of the tidal flats. Consequently, nearly all waders disappeared from the a r e a (Wolff et al., 1975); for at least two species it could be proven t h a t n u m b e r s in the n e a r b y Oosterschelde estuary had increased at the same time (Van Latesteijn and Lambeck, 1986; Lambeck et al., 1989). The former studies show t h a t local occurrence of waders is influenced by loss of tidal flats, but they do not show any population effects. Meire (1991), however,
802 reports that after a 30% decrease of intertidal area in the same Oosterschelde estuary due to the building of a storm-surge barrier and secondary dams about 15 years later, the total number of Oystercatchers in the unaffected parts of the estuary did not increase. Moreover, a temporary reduction of the tidal range in the estuary caused by partly closure of the storm-surge barrier in combination with extensive fisheries for shellfish, led to strongly increased m o r t a l i t y of oystercatchers in winter. In the face of the strong fidelity of adult waders to their wintering grounds (Myers, 1984) it is actually surprising t hat the wintering numbers so often quickly readjusted to a reduction in feeding area. Thus, the results of the 'field experiments' corroborate the expectations derived from the studies on competition that reduction of tidal flat habitat will lead to reduction of wader population size. Because bird populations are subject to processes both in the breeding areas and in the winter quarters it is hard to predict the effect of sealevel rise on wader populations. Moreover, the various species and populations normally use several estuaries along their flyway during the non-breeding period and will be influenced by changes in all of these estuaries. There is no shortage of speculations on the possible consequences of climate change. Although not all possible effects are considered, -apparently nobody seriously suspects an effect of increased levels of UV-B on migratory birds for instance-, the diversity of hypotheses is nonetheless bewildering. Therefore, instead of formulating complex scenarios we must seek to answer a set of interrelated precise questions. At least three questions can be distinguished: Which aspects of the climate change or secondary effects will have the greatest impact: global warming, storms, rainfall patterns, sealevel rise? At wh at stage of the life cycle of the birds does the climate change or climate-induced effect operate: breeding season, autumn migration, spring migration, nonbreeding season? Which processes must be considered: vagaries during the migratory flight, interspecific competition between resident and non-resident species, intraspecific competition on the breeding grounds, intraspecific competition on the wintering grounds, phenology of the food supply, evolution of the migration schedule? Second, a formal structure must be devised that will allow us to find an answer to these questions. This formal structure includes mathematical models and a methodology to assess important parameter values. Hence, it was decided to study the effect of sealevel rise by building mathematical models of the population dynamics and the migratory behaviour of two well-studied species: the Oystercatcher Haematopus ostralegus and the Knot Calidris canutus. The Oystercatcher serves as a model for a short-distance migrant, whereas the Knot is a clear example of a long-distance migrant. In the short-distance migrant the migratory phase itself is insignificant in time, and attention focusses on how processes on the wintering and breeding grounds affect the population. In contrast, the long-distance migrant spends a significant amount of time preparing for migration and the model specifically focusses on this part of the annual cycle. The next step is to use the models to investigate the consequences of various climate scenarios.
803
Model development The basic idea of the model is that both the rate of reproduction in summer and the rate of mortality during winter are dependent on the number of individuals in the population, i.e. the population density. The p r i m a r y source of density-dependence in s u m m e r is assumed to result from territorial exclusion, i.e. relatively fewer birds breed when the density of potential breeding birds increases. The proportion excluded is expressed as a k-value: k - aT + bTlogl0N where N is the n u m b e r of potential breeding birds and the slope bT measures the compressibility of the territories. W h e n bT = 1, the territories cannot be compressed any further so that, above the numbers set by the intercept aT, a constant n u m b e r of pairs breed, irrespective of the numbers a t t e m p t i n g to do so. Thus, bT = 0 implies no density dependence and bT = 1 implies perfect 'contest' density dependence. It is not allowed that bT < 0. The primary source of density dependence in winter is decreased survival chances due to competition for food. At low densities, there is no competition, but only a d e n s i t y - i n d e p e n d e n t proportion (mw) starving. When bird density increases, eventually a point, Cw, is reached at which mortality begins to increase and so becomes density-dependent. From then on, mortality increases by bw for every unit increase uin bird density. For the Oystercatcher four sub-populations have been distinguished: Continental coastal, Continental inland, Atlantic coastal, and Atlantic inland. The p a r a m e t e r s defined above have been estimated for each sub-population and, where necessary, age class. F u r t h e r m o r e the size is known of each of the four sub-populations. Within the Continental and Atlantic regions, inland-breeding and coastal-breeding sub-populations use the same coastal areas in winter. Finally, the sometimes quite substantial annual fluctuations in the main production and mortality p a r a m e t e r s were generally not correlated across sites within a sub-population. This allows the s t a n d a r d deviations of the annual variations in these parameters to be estimated for both sub-populations in each region, so t h a t realistic annual variations could also be included in the model. More details are to be found in Goss-Custard et al. (1994). During their m i g r a t o r y journeys, birds m a y cover distances of up to several thousand kilometers in a non-stop flight. The migration of m a n y species, especially waders, consists of a series of such non-stop flights i n t e r r u p t e d by stopovers at tidal flat areas during which large quantities of fat are deposited. This fat serves as fuel for the next leg of the journey. It seems likely t h a t waders migrating between their widely separated wintering and breeding grounds can choose among a number of potential stopover sites using different itineraries. However, the factors determining stopover site choice and departure fuel loads from the stopover sites are not well understood. It has been argued t h a t waders sometimes store more fat t h a n is necessary to fuel the flight to the next site, a phenomenon known as overloading, and t h a t suitable sites are skipped. When only energetic flight costs are considered neither the
804 skipping of potential sites should occur nor overloads be deposited, because flight costs increase rapidly with increasing body mass. Using the equations of Alerstam and LindstrSm (1990) and Weber et al. (1994) developed optimality models of d e p a r t u r e fat loads and stopover site use with time spent m i g r a t i n g as the currency to be minimised. Under this assumption the only cost is the reduction of marginal rate of gain of flight range with increasing body mass. The models identify conditions under which potential stopover sites are skipped or overloads occur. In these models the conditions leading to a storage of overloads are very restrictive but skipping can occur over a wide range of parameters. However, several potentially important factors shaping migration schedules and fuel loads cannot be addressed using the aforementioned models. These factors are: 1.
2.
.
At stopover sites or on the wintering grounds birds m a y face a trade-off between gaining energy for fat deposition and avoiding predation. Predation risk is likely to be influenced by several factors, including flock size, high body mass impairing flight kinematics and consequently the escape response when attacked and the time exposed to predation risk while foraging. Time of arrival in the breeding area and the subsequent timing of the breeding a t t e m p t have a strong effect on breeding success. F u r t h e r m o r e , extra body stores at arrival may guard against adverse conditions or pay some of the costs of producing eggs. The rewards associated with time of arrival m u s t not necessarily be always decreasing with later arrival; arriving on the breeding grounds too early could also be disadvantagous, for instance due to snow cover. Foraging at a stopover site and d e p a r t u r e decisions are also likely to be influenced by s t o c h a s t i c i t y of the e n v i r o n m e n t , including the social e n v i r o n m e n t . Stochasticity in food supply and abiotic conditions, like t e m p e r a t u r e and wind speed and direction affect energy intake and energy expenditure and may therefore lead to unpredictable daily fat deposition rates or even to the risk of starvation. Unpredictable wind conditions during flight m a y cause uncertainty in expenditure when flying from one stopover site to the next.
The model describes the behavioural decisions of a bird having to migrate from its breeding grounds to its wintering grounds, or vice versa. It is a s s u m e d t h a t decisions are made in such a way t h a t fitness upon arrival at the destination is maximised. Fitness expectations upon arrival may depend on both the state of the individual and the time of arrival. Fitness is defined as the life-time contribution of the individual to the next generation. The environment the bird has to migrate through consists of N sites, i.e. the initial site (e.g. the wintering ground), N-2 discrete stopover sites and the final site (e.g. the breeding ground). For simplicity, it is assumed t h a t these sites are a r r a n g e d linearly, so t h a t the distances between the sites are additive. The complete migration period is divided into T time units; one time unit corresponds to one day. The state of a bird is characterised by its reserve level and its location. Location is referred to as a state variable, because it is affected by the decisions of the bird. The reserve level can take any integer value from 0 up to a m a x i m u m reserve level. If the reserves fall to 0 it is assumed t h a t the birds i m m e d i a t e l y die of starvation.
805 At the s t a r t of each time unit the bird m u s t decide on the best possible course of action, given its location and reserves. It can either decide to stay in the site and feed, or to fly to another site in the direction of the final destination. If it decides to feed, it also h a s to decide on its foraging i n t e n s i t y u, which can t a k e a n y value between 0 and 1. W h e n feeding there is also a risk of predation. This risk can be influenced by two variables: the mass of the individual, which is a linear function of reserves, and the foraging intensity u. If the bird decides to depart it m u s t decide on the site w h e r e it will land. It is a s s u m e d t h a t no m o r t a l i t y occurs d u r i n g flight, while flight costs are modelled according to the e q u a t i o n s of A l e r s t a m a n d L i n d s t r 6 m (1990). E x p e n d i t u r e during flight can be stochastic due to influence of unpredictable wind conditions. To find the optimal behaviour, the method of dynamic p r o g r a m m i n g (Mangel and Clark 1988) h a s been applied. For each combination of reserves, site and time, the optimal decision and expected future success is found using b a c k w a r d iteration. Forward iteration then allows to simulate the fate of individual birds, as well as to find population m e a n s and standard deviations. To investigate the effects of h a b i t a t change, e.g. because of sealevel rise, a simple s i t u a t i o n is c o n s i d e r e d w h e r e the fitness consequences of c h a n g e s in t h e environment are determined. These changes could take place at two different time scales: if changes are slow the migrating birds are allowed to adjust their behaviour to the new circumstances, i.e. the birds behave optimally in an e n v i r o n m e n t t h a t deteriorated as compared to an earlier reference situation. Alternatively changes could h a p p e n m u c h faster and the birds do not have the chance to a d j u s t t h e i r b e h a v i o u r to the new e n v i r o n m e n t . Birds t h e n use the b e h a v i o u r which w a s o p t i m a l u n d e r b e t t e r c i r c u m s t a n c e s , i.e. t h e i r m i g r a t o r y b e h a v i o u r is now s u b o p t i m a l in the new environment. In both scenarios fitness can be affected in several ways: either by changes in m o r t a l i t y en route or by delayed arrival at the breeding site. The birds can also be forced to stay at an i n t e r m e d i a t e site. Evans et al. (1992) discuss the consequences h a b i t a t loss at s t a g i n g posts can h a v e for m i g r a t o r y w a d e r s . H a b i t a t loss is modelled by decreasing the m a x i m u m fuel deposition the birds can achieve at a site. D e p e n d i n g on t h e s i t u a t i o n e n v i s a g e d h a b i t a t c h a n g e can h a v e d i f f e r e n t consequences. If the birds can adjust their behaviour to the new conditions h a b i t a t destruction at the wintering grounds are most severe. If the birds use a suboptimal policy fitness losses are more pronounced the closer the affected site is to t h e breeding site. Fitness losses are also more severe when the reward at the breeding site is decreasing over the whole time interval under consideration. The results show clearly t h a t predation is a potentially i m p o r t a n t factor s h a p i n g m i g r a t o r y s t r a t e g i e s . The r a t e s of m a s s gain are also strongly influenced by predation risk. Overloads are deposited w h e n the e n v i r o n m e n t is stochastic. U n c e r t a i n t y in e x p e n d i t u r e leads to a level of overloads which are able to deal w i t h the worst possible case of h e a d w i n d s independent of its probability of occurrence, because if such a s i t u a t i o n arises d e a t h is certain. The model does not allow to m a k e departure decisions like fuel load and the choice of the target site to depend directly on a p a r t i c u l a r wind condition; this would m a k e the inclusion of a n o t h e r s t a t e variable necessary. Intraspecific differences in site use b e t w e e n years m a y t h u s be a consequence of unpredictable meteorological circumstances.
806
Results of model calculations Since the final model calculations will be carried out after this assessment report has been finished, only some examples of calculations will be given. Figure 5.2 gives the r e s u l t s of model calculations for the N.W. E u r o p e a n population of the Oystercatcher. Four subpopulations are distinguished: coastal breeders of the British Isles and those of the continent, and inland breeders of the British Isles and of the continent. The simulations show t h a t most populations decrease with reduction of their wintering area, but t h a t the size of the reduction is strongly dependent. Especially the density dependence of winter mortality (bW) is a very i m p o r t a n t parameter. Fig. 4 gives the results of calculations with the dynamic version of the migration model. Loss of tidal flats has been modelled as decrease of fattening rates. In the top panel it has been assumed that habitat loss is a slow process and t h a t the bird populations can adapt. In the bottom panel h a b i t a t loss is rapid and the populations cannot adapt. The simulations show that under the former scenario only changes in the wintering area have an important effect. The latter scenario shows t h a t changes in any site have an effect, although the most severe effect result from changes in the last stopover area before the breeding area is reached. Hence, also for the long-distance migrants habitat loss appears to have negative consequences for population size. The d e t e r m i n a t i o n o f the a r e a o f suitable h a b i t a t The bird study started under the assumption t h a t the area of suitable h a b i t a t after a rise of sealevel could be predicted from the present topography of tidal flat areas. The basic idea was t h a t future tidal flat areas could be derived from the height distribution of the present fiats, because by higher sealevels lower areas would be drowned. This scenario could be elaborated with the data available. However, the studies on the morphology of the Wadden Sea (Sections 5.1 and 5.2) have shown t h a t tidal fiats and salt marshes are able to accomodate an increased rate of sealevel rise. For the most likely scenarios even no i m p o r t a n t change in tidal fiat area is predicted for the first 100 years. On the other hand the quality of the tidal fiats as a feeding area for shorebirds might change with sealevel rise. Hence, predictions on the area of tidal flats available as feeding areas along the flyways have become very difficult. For the Wadden Sea this is possible, but not for the other areas. Evaluation The model of the short-distance m i g r a n t , even though it was tied to the Oystercatcher, can easily be applied to other species when relevant p a r a m e t e r s are known. Habitat loss due to sealevel rise is predicted to be small (see 5.1), hence effects on wader populations are predicted to be small too, even though the exact magnitude of the effect is hard to predict for such small changes. Other effects are likely to be more important, like shell-fisheries and t e m p e r a t u r e effects on dynamics of the prey (see Section 6). The current model cannot cope with these effects. The model of the long-distance migrant, even though the model was constructed with the Knot in mind, is couched in sufficiently general terms, to be applied to other species for which the relevant p a r a m e t e r s are known. The model can be incorporated as a migration module for the population dynamics model (i.e. the model for the short-distance migrant), but this was not done, since nothing is
807 c u r r e n t l y k n o w n on density-dependent processes on wintering and breeding grounds in the case of Knots. If it is known how habitat loss will affect fattening rates on the stopover sites, the present model can predict the effect on survival rate and reproductive success. The prediction depends on the time scale: if sufficient time has elapsed for adaptation to the new circumstances, habitat loss on the first stopover site on spring m i g r a t i o n will have the most serious consequences, otherwise, habitat loss on the last stopover site will have the most serious consequences During the study it became clear that two basic assumptions were not valid. In a earlier section was already discussed t h a t tidal flat areas do not simply drown during sealevel rise, but t h a t they may be expected to restructure or even to keep pace with moderate levels of sealevel rise. Secondly the developments in the breeding areas cannot be left out of consideration. Especially the Arctic breeding species will face huge changes in their breeding quarters in the case of climate change. These changes should be taken into account if meaningful conclusions are to be drawn about the future of our wader populations.
808
CONTINENTAL
CONTINENTAL
COASTAL
,+0 t . . . . . . . . . . . . o 160 o
. "~
. . . . . .~1~.r r t. :..'vl" . . ~. .
~ . ~ '
..~ ~. . "" ,.. o~.
~1~0
~\
.
250
""-
"X
o
-
i
!
"
.,.
-'" ~ . } . . : ~ : . .
. 200
z 120
INLAND
-",',
i 150
~80o
.
_,am~" 60 -
:.
~ 4o-
i
200
t
I
-
:11 i *'~
~
"-...~.
~,. ,,,.
,
I
_
100
li
k '
i
I
i
5O
9
i.. %
~ ~ ~ .. .. . .
~,
.
0
t
!
t
I
t
,
,
,
I
I
,
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % REDUCTION IN OVERWINTERING AREA % REDUCTION IN OVERWINTERING AREA
ATI_ANTIC
COASTAL
ATLANTIC
INLAND
100 dfl 250 O O
t',]
200 _
Z 0 <150
'~1
\\
~
-
~
:
'.,\
\\
,.A
o 100
80
~.~g~~*"':'~ . . ' . . , , ...:'t: \ : " l : . .':l". " + \ . -,,..,, -.-,,
_
am,,.-.,.,
le
.,.
IP
,
..
60
x :\ kx
40
~
-
i
~ 5o [.., k t
f
I
I
t
~
t
~_" '
9, ._t .
0 I0 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % REDUCTION IN OVERWINTERING AREA BW.~0.10
0
I
I
!
t
t
t
t
t
t
t
.
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % REDUCTION IN OVERWINTERING AREA
BW = 0.05 BW = 0.01 ,11~
BW =_0.005 BW = 0.002 BW = 0.001 ,40 F i g u r e 5.2 S i z e o f t h e e q u i l i b r i u m p o p u l a t i o n for f o u r s u b p o p u l a t i o n s of t h e O y s t e r c a t c h e r a s a f u n c t i o n o f h a b i t a t l o s s a t d i f f e r e n t i n t e n s i t i e s of d e n s i t y - d e p e n d e n t winter mortality (bW)
809 1.01
1-
o = t:
0.99 -
o.i e~ 0.98 -
0.97 -
0.96 0.75
i
I
i
I
I
1.00
1.25
1.50
1.75
2.00
2.25
1.05 tel. fitness site 1 ..... 0 ....
tel. fitness site 2
.... 0----
tel. fitness site 3
1..~~176
/
s o,~
.~
0.95 -
0.9$
,,
//
9s a
/
0.85 -
6 l o,
6
0.8
,o~
-
0.75 0.75
I
I
I
I
I
1
1.25
1.5
1.75
2
2.25
maximum gain
Figure 5.3 The effect of habitat loss (expressed as maximum possible gain of body fat load) on production of young (expressed as relative fitness) by a long-distance migrant. Site I is the wintering area, 2 and 3 are stopover sites (3 is the last site before the breeding area is reached). In the simulation one site has been changed whereas the other ones remained the same. In the top panel it has been assumed that changes occurred slowly (e.g. sealevel rise) and that the bird population was able to adapt. In the bottom panel the change occurred quickly (e.g. reclamation) so that the bird population could not adapt
810 6.
IMPACT OF CHANGING WATER TEMPERATURES
6.1 T h e e f f e c t s o f w i n t e r t e m p e r a t u r e o n t h e r e p r o d u c t i v e s u c c e s s o n s o m e b i v a l v e s in the D u t c h W a d d e n Sea Since 1969 the numbers and biomass of several species of benthic invertebrates are monitored on tidal flats in the westernmost part of the Wadden Sea (Balgzand). The common mussel (Mytilus edulis), the Baltic tellin (Macoma balthica) and the cockle (Cerastoderma edule) are among the most important species. These three species account for a high proportion of the total biomass. Their lifecycle starts with eggs from which planktonic larvae hatch. These larvae spend a period in the water column after which they settle on the tidal flats. The young individuals which thus recruit to the parent population often settle first in a habitat different from t h a t of their parents. At a later stage they move again to settle finally in the habitat of their parents. Winter t e m p e r a t u r e appears to be a factor diminishing recruitment. The data series of the Netherlands Institute for Sea Research (NIOZ) show t h a t after mild winters with a mean water temperature in the period J a n u a r y - M a r c h of about 6 ~ the r e c r u i t m e n t was lower t h a n after cold winters with a m e a n w a t e r t e m p e r a t u r e of about 1 ~ This results in high recruitment and abundance after cold winters, but relatively low abundance after mild winters, and particularly after a series of mild winters.
Two hypotheses may be formulated to account for this diminished recruitment. The first hypothesis assumes predation of just-settled larvae of these bivalves by brown shrimps (Crangon crangon) and shorecrabs (Carcinus maenas) resulting in a diminished recruitment. During a cold winter a large proportion of the predators die, whereas they do not in mild winters. This means t h a t after a mild winter the predators arrive early and they are already on the tidal flats at the moment the larvae of the bivalves settle, resulting in heavy mortality of these newly settled larvae. After a cold winter the larvae are ahead of the predators and have grown to a less vulnerable size at the time the predators appear. The second hypothesis states t h a t the metabolic rate of adult bivalves is on a higher level at higher water temperatures in winter. Since food is scarce in this period, this goes at the expense of stored reserves. As a consequence less energy is available for gametogenesis. As a result the eggs could be smaller, or the n u m b e r of eggs could be lower, or both. The first hypothesis is studied by Beukema at NIOZ. This study is dependent on field observations after mild and cold winters and is necessarily long-term. The NRP-I-period has been too short to come up with meaningful results. The second hypothesis has been studied, mainly experimentally, during NRP I. Four questions have been asked: 1. Are t h e r e differences in g o n a d a l d e v e l o p m e n t at different w i n t e r temperatures? 2. Are eggs after a mild winter smaller than after a cold winter? 3. Is the amount of eggs dependent on the winter temperature? 4. Is the survival of the larvae different at different winter temperatures?
811 6.2 E x p e r i m e n t a l tests of the effects of winter temperature on r e p r o d u c t i v e s u c c e s of b i v a l v e s So far successful experiments have only been carried out with Macoma balthica a n d Cerastoderma edule. Three groups of M a c o m a have been kept in an experimental set-up during the winter months of 1993. One group was kept at ambient temperatures, the second at t e m p e r a t u r e s about 2 ~ higher, and the third group at temperatures 2 ~ lower. The first experiment was not completely successful due to the development of an early plankton bloom in the basins, but it nevertheless d e m o n s t r a t e d a significant correlation between condition of the animals (expressed as ~g ash-free dry weight / (mm shell length)3 ) and egg size in ~lm. A second group of experiments was run in the winter of 1994. Two t e m p e r a t u r e s were used: cold (3.0 ~ and mild (5.6 ~ in combination with two periods of submergence: continuous (24 h per day) and periodically (16 h per day). The length of the period of submergence determines the possibilities for food consumption in the experimental set-up. Longer submergence should mean more food and a higher condition index. Indeed, the condition index of the group permanently submerged was higher t h a n t h a t of the group submerged for 16 h a day (Table 6.1). In accordance with the hypothesis formulated the condition index of the cold winter groups was higher t h a n t h a t of the mild winter groups (Table 6.1). Also the number of eggs varied in accordance with the hypothesis (Table 6.1). The same experiment was run for Cerastoderma edule with similar results (Table 6.1).
Table 6.1 Condition index (mg ash-free dry weight cm-3), mean egg number, and mean egg size (~t) of Macoma balthica and Cerastoderma edule after a winter and spring at cold and mild w a t e r t e m p e r a t u r e s . P a r t of the animals lived p e r m a n e n t l y submerged (sub), whereas the other group was submerged for 16 h and dry for the remaining 8 h per day (int)
Cerastoderma edule cold/int cold/sub mild/int mild/sub
Macoma balthica cold/int cold/sub mild/int mild/sub
Condition index
egg number
egg size
8.7 + 0.1 11.4 + 0.2 7.8 + 0.7
214,892 201,083 65,212
78.2 + 0.3 79.3 + 0.2 76.7 + 0.8
I0.0 + 0.I
9.5 13.8 8.1 9.8
+ + + +
0.3 1.3 0.4 0.4
9,876
29,743 63,561 19,182 20,330
75.3 + 0.i
106.9 104.6 104.1 106.8
+ + + +
1.0 1.0 0.2 0.8
812 6.3 E v a l u a t i o n As already indicated in Section 3.2 this study is not finished at the end of NRP I, so this evaluation is based on a limited amount of information. The hypothesis tested so far is confirmed by the data obtained. Whether the same conclusions can be drawn for populations in the field remains to be seen. In the meantime, nature carried out its own experiment by providing a series of very mild winters on a row. This led to unprecedented low levels of cockles and mussels in the Wadden Sea, thus confirming once more the basic hypothesis t h a t w i n t e r t e m p e r a t u r e s influence the r e c r u i t m e n t of bivalve populations (Stair, 1994). Two conclusions can be drawn from the present data. In the first place the relationship between t e m p e r a t u r e and ecological function is not a simple one. Through the interaction with food, predators, or competitors the abundance of species can change in unexpected ways. For those species which are a b u n d a n t in the Wadden Sea nowadays, we can try to investigate in well-planned studies if their n u m b e r s might be influenced strongly by some interaction of different factors. However, the reverse is also possible. For rare species, or even species which do not yet occur in the Wadden Sea, it is possible t h a t they become very numerous because of similar interactions. Such cases will be very hard to predict. The second preliminary conclusion concerns the Wadden Sea shellfish cultures. These might face a bleak future if the conclusions obtained for Macoma and Cerastoderma hold also for Mytilus. On the other hand it is also possible t h a t other ecotypes of these species develop or are introduced from more southern latitudes which might thrive in a warmer Wadden Sea.
7.
INTEGRATION
7.1 I n t e g r a t i o n of e f f e c t s of c l i m a t e c h a n g e s o n e s t u a r i n e e c o s y s t e m s All aspects of climate change have a larger or smaller impact on the Wadden Sea at the same time. In this Wadden Sea m a n y different processes interact, as do populations of plants and animals. Other h u m a n impacts also play their part. The studies under NRP I, however, are mostly concerned with only one aspect of climate change and one or a few processes or species. Although the subjects under investigation have been chosen carefully, taking into account the importance of the expected effect and the position of the process or species investigated in the total Wadden Sea system, it will be difficult to generalize the results to the entire system. For t h a t reason it has been a t t e m p t e d to bring together all studies in the ecosystem model ECOWASP developed by the DLO-Institute for Forestry and N a t u r e Research and the Netherlands Institute for Sea Research. ECOWASP is a formal description of the relations between a n u m b e r of abiotic factors (light, t e m p e r a t u r e , n u t r i e n t s etc.) and a n u m b e r of species groups (micro-algae, zooplankton, benthic filterfeeders etc.). It covers the western part of the Dutch Wadden Sea; it takes relations with the North Sea and the hinterland into account. U n f o r t u n a t e l y the ECOWASP study was commissioned long after the other studies had s t a r t e d and it will continue to March 1995. So there were few opportunities to steer the other studies, and at the moment of this assesment not all results are available. Especially the integration of the various NRP I studies is not yet completed.
813 7.2 R e s u l t s o f s o m e s c e n a r i o s t u d i e s
Scenario studies have been carried out with the original configuration of the E C O W A S P model, i.e. a model without salt m a r s h e s and birds. Scenarios computed concern addition and reduction of nutrients, changes in turbidity of the water, and increase of the w a t e r temperatures. Especially the later scenario is useful for this a s s e s m e n t , but the other ones m a y serve as i n t e r e s t i n g comparisons. The water t e m p e r a t u r e scenario was computed for both the normal annual course of t e m p e r a t u r e and for a temperature which was increased 20% (based on degrees Celsius). R e m a r k a b l e enough, this r a t h e r drastic increase of t e m p e r a t u r e had relatively little effect on the results of the model computations. Only slight changes occurred. The n u t r i e n t scenarios had much stronger effects, suggesting t h a t the effects of climate change for the Wadden Sea might be less important t h a n the effects of direct h u m a n interventions. The turbidity scenarios gave contradictory results. 7.3 E v a l u a t i o n
Evaluation of the integration of the studies by means of the ECOWASP model is hardly possible at this stage. A general r e m a r k is that this kind of simulations of ecosystem behaviour should be verified by experiments with ecosystems. For the Wadden Sea opportunities to do so exist. 8.
E V A L U A T I O N OF THE W A D D E N SEA S T U D I E S OF N R P I
Did the NRP I studies address the right questions? This question may be answered starting from the different aspects of climate change, but also starting from those aspects of the Wadden Sea considered to be important, either because of their key position in the system, or because of the values society attaches to them. With the present knowledge it seems that the effects of the increase of CO2 have been covered sufficiently. With respect to t e m p e r a t u r e it seems t h a t more a t t e n t i o n to the effects of t e m p e r a t u r e and other meteorological factors on key species might have been useful. For example, t e m p e r a t u r e effects on the eider duck, the most i m p o r t a n t avian predator on the benthic fauna, may be important, because in the Wadden Sea the species is n e a r the southern limit of its distribution. Also the effects on various fish species might be important, both for n o r t h e r n and for s o u t h e r n species. From the viewpoint of sealevel rise the right aspects of the Wadden Sea system seem to have been covered. Finally, it is believed t h a t UV-B increase should have had more attention, especially with regard to the organisms living on the tidal flats. From the viewpoint of key elements in the system it may be concluded t h a t tidal flat benthic microalgae and fish have received insufficient attention. Do the NRP I studies provide a coherent answer to the question of the effects of climate change? The answer is no, chiefly because the studies were conceived as separate research projects by different research groups. Hence, the studies have been carried out using very different spatial scales, respectively of the size of tidal basins, m2 's, entire Wadden Sea, entire flyway population, and again entire
814 Wadden Sea. Also the temporal scales varied widely from single tide events to centuries. Nevertheless it is possible to integrate them to some extent by using the extensive background information. Doing this it becomes possible to draw a few preliminary conclusions. The effects of increase of atmosferic CO2 are expecteded to be slight. Some changes may occur in the salt marshes, but on the scale of the Wadden Sea no important effects are expected. Changes in temperature and other meteorological factors are expected to lead to considerable changes in the species composition of the ecosystem with northern species disappearing and (more) southern species colonizing the area. No important changes are expected in ecosystem functioning, unless one or more key species change drastically in abundance. The NRP I study on bivalve molluscs provides an example of this. It is expected that the most likely scenarios for sealevel rise will not result in disappearance of tidal flats and saltmarshes within the first 100 years. Consequently the plants and animal species depending on tidal flats will not experience large changes. An exception has to be made for the migratory shorebirds which not only will undergo the influence of sealevel rise in their tidal flat habitat in winter, but also the effects of climate change in their arctic and subarctic breeding areas. UV-B increase may lead to changes in the biota of the tidal flat areas and in the saltmarshes but it is expected that this will mainly affect balances between species. It has to be stressed that the expectations summarized above are based on assumptions which could not always be verified and on the study of a limited part of a large and complicated ecosystem. In many respects further study is needed to underscore the present conclusions. The results for the Wadden Sea in general will be applicable to other European estuaries. Only sealevel rise may have very different consequences in some estuaries because of differences in the hydrography and the sedimentology. 9.
REFERENCES
Alerstam, T. and LindstrSm, A., 1990. Optimal bird migration: the relative importance of time, energy, and safety. In: Gwinner, E. (ed.). Bird Migration, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, p. 331-351. Allen, J.R.L., 1990. Salt-marsh growth and stratification: a numerical model with special reference to the Severn Estuary, SW Britain. Mar. Geol. 95: 77-96. Arp, W.J., 1991. Vegetation of a North American saltmarsh and elevated atmospheric carbon dioxide. Thesis, Free Univ. Amsterdam, 181 pp. Asjes, J., K. Zegers, P.W. van Leeuwen, A. Sleutel, M. Binsbergen, F. Biliam, E. Wagenaar, B. Brinkman, N. Dankers and K.S. Dijkema, 1992. Comparative studies on saltmarsh processes, The Netherlands. Rep. to the European Commission, 40 pp. Bakker, J.P., J. de Leeuw, K.S. Dijkema, P.C. Leendertse, H.H.T. Prins and J. Rozema, 1993. Saltmarshes along the coast of The Netherlands. Hydrobiologica 265: 73-95. Beukema, J.J., W.J. Wolff and J.J.W.M. Brouns (eds.), 1990. Expected effects of climatic change on marine coastal ecosystems. Kluwer Acad. Publ., Dordrecht, 221 pp.
815 Beukema, J.J., 1990. Expected effects of changes in winter temperatures on benthic animals living in soft sediments in coastal North Sea areas. In: Beukema, J.J., W.J. Wolff and J.J.W.M. Brouns (eds.). Expected effects of climatic change on marine coastal ecosystems. Kluwer Academic Publ., Dordrecht, p. 83-92. Boekschoten, M., 1973. Lijst van publikaties over het Waddengebied. Report Rijksinstituut voor Natuurbeheer, Leersum, 191 pp. Bossinade, J.H., J. van den Bergs and K.S. Dijkema, 1993. De invloed van de wind op het jaargemiddelde hoogwater langs de Friese en Groninger waddenkust. Rijkswaterstaat, Directie Groningen, Nota Gran 1993-2009, 22 pp. Breeman, A.M., 1990. Expected effects of changing seawater temperatures on the geographic distribution of seaweed species. In: Beukema, J.J., W.J. Wolff and J.J.W.M Brouns (eds.), 1990. Expected effects of climatic change on marine coastal ecosystems. Kluwer Academic Publ., Dordrecht, p. 69-76. Brouns, J.J.W.M., 1988. The impact of elevated carbon dioxide levels on marine and coastal ecosystems. Report Rijksinstituut voor Natuurbeheer, Texel. RIN-rapport 88/58, 101 pp. Costa, M.J., 1990. Expected effects of temperature changes on estuarine fish populations. In: Beukema, J.J., W.J. Wolff and J.J.W.M. Brouns (eds.), 1990. Expected effects of climatic change on marine coastal ecosystems. Kluwer Academic Publ., Dordrecht, p. 99-104. Craft, C.B., E.D. Seneca and S.W. Broome, 1993. Vertical accretion in microtidal regularly and irregularly flooded estuarine marshes. Estuarine Coastal and Shelf Science 37: 371-386. Curtis, P.S., B.G. Drake, P.W. Leadley, W.J. Arp and D.F. Whigham, 1989. Growth and senescence in plant communities exposed to elevated CO2 concentrations on an estuarine marsh. Oecologia 78: 20-26. Dankers, N., M. Binsbergen, K. Zegers, R. Laane and M. Rutgers van der Loeff, 1984. Transportation of water, particulate and dissolved organic and inorganic matter between a salt-marsh and the Ems-Dollard estuary, The Netherlands. Estuarine, Coastal and Shelf Science 19: 143-165. Davidson, N. and T. Piersma, 1992. The migration of Knots: conservation needs and implications. Wader Study Bull. 64 Suppl.: 198-209. Dijkema, K.S., 1987. Changes in salt-marsh area in the Netherlands Wadden Sea after 1600. In: Huiskes, A.H.L., C.W.P.M. Blom and J. Rozema (eds.)Vegetation between land and sea. Junk, Dordrecht. p. 42-49. Dijkema, K.S., J.H. Bossinade, P. Bouwsema and R.J. de Glopper, 1990. Saltmarshes in The Netherlands Wadden Sea: rising high-tide levels and accretion enhancement. In: Beukema, J.J., W.J. Wolff and J.J.W.M. Brouns (eds.), 1990. Expected effects of climatic change on marine coastal ecosystems. Kluwer Academic Publ., Dordrecht, p. 173-188. Dijkema, K.S., J. van den Bergs, J.H. Bossinade, P. Bouwsema, R.J. De Glopper and J.W.Th.M. van Meegen, 1988. Effecten van rijzendammen op de opslibbing en de omvang van de vegetatiezones in de Friese en Groninger landaanwinningswerken, (in Dutch). Rijkswaterstaat, Directie Groningen, Nota Gran 1988-2010, 130 pp. Evans, P.R., 1978. Reclamation of intertidal land: some effects on shelduck and wader populations in the Tees estuary. Verh. orn. Ges. Bayern 23: 147-168.
816 Eysink, W.D., 1992. Impact of sealevel rise on the morphology of the Wadden Sea in the scope of its ecological function - Proposed set-up of a dynamic morphological model for Wadden Sea basins and estuaries based on empirical relations. Rep. H1300, vol. 1, ISOS*2project, phase 3, Delft Hydraulics, Delft. Fretwell, S., 1972. Populations in a seasonal environment. Princeton Univ. Press, Princeton. Goss-Custard, J.D., 1988. Foraging behaviour of wading birds and the carrying capacity of estuaries. In: Sibly, R.M. and R.H. Smith (eds.). Behavioural Ecology: ecological consequences of adaptive behaviour. Blackwell, Oxford, p. 169-188. Goss-Custard, J.D., S. McGrorty and R. Kirby, 1990. Inshore birds of the soft coasts and sealevel rise. In: Beukema, J.J., W.J. Wolff and J.J.W.M Brouns (eds.). Expected effects of climatic change on marine coastal ecosystems. Kluwer Academic Publ., Dordrecht, p. 189-194. Goss-Custard, J.D., R.T. Clarke, K.B. Briggs, B.J. Ens, K.-M. Exo, C.J. Smit, A.J. Beintema, R.W.G. Caldow, D.C. Catt, N. Clark, S.E.A. le V. dit Durrell, M.P. Harris, J.B. Hulscher, P.L. meininger, N. Picozzi, R. Prys-Jones, U.N. Safriel and A.D. West, 1994. Population consequences of habitat loss in a migratory shorebird. I. Estimating model parameters. J. appl. Ecol. (in press). Greenberg, R., 1986. Competition in migrant birds in the non-breeding season. Current Ornithol. 3: 281-307. Huiskes, A.H.L., 1990. Possible effects of sealevel changes on salt-marsh vegetation. In: Beukema, J.J., W.J. Wolff and J.J.W.M. Brouns (eds.). Expected effects of climatic change on marine coastal ecosystems. Kluwer Academic Publ., Dordrecht, p. 167-172. Kamps, L.F., 1962. Mud distribution and land reclamation in the eastern Wadden shallows, Rijkswaterstaat communications nr. 4. Kramer, K.J.M., 1990. Effects of increased solar UV-B radiation on coastal marine ecosystems: an overview. In: Beukema, J.J., W.J. Wolff and J.J.W.M. Brouns (eds.). Expected effects of climatic change on marine coastal ecosystems. Kluwer Academic Publ., Dordrecht, p. 195-210. Lambeck, R.H.D., A.J.J. Sandee and L. de Wolf, 1989. Long-term patterns in the waderusage of an intertidal flat in the Oosterschelde (SW Netherlands) and the impact of the closure of an adjacent estuary. J. appl. Ecol. 26: 419-431. Louters, T. and F. Gerritsen, 1994. Het mysterie van de Wadden. Hoe een getijdesysteem inspeelt op de zeespiegelstijging. Report Rijksinstituut voor Kust en Zee (in Dutch). Lefeuvre, J.C., 1990. Ecological impact of sealevel rise on coastal ecosystems of Mont-Saint-Michel Bay (France). In: Beukema, J.J., W.J. Wolff and J.J.W.M. Brouns (eds.). Expected effects of climatic change on marine coastal ecosystems. Kluwer Academic Publ., Dordrecht, p. 139-154. Lenssen, G.(M.), 1993. Responses of C3 and C4 species from Dutch saltmarshes to atmospheric CO2 enrichment. Thesis, Vrije Universiteit, Amsterdam, 113 p. Long, S.P., 1990. The primary productivity of Puccinellia maritima and Spartina anglica: a simple predictive model of response to climatic change. In: Beukema, J.J., W.J. Wolff and J.J.W.M Brouns (eds.). Expected effects of climatic change on marine coastal ecosystems. Kluwer Academic Publ., Dordrecht, p. 33-40. Mangel, M. and Clark, C.W. 1988. Dynamic modelling in behavioral ecology. Princeton University Press, Princeton, New Jersey.
817 McLusky, D.S., D.M. Bryant and M. Elliott, 1992. The impact of land-claim on macrobenthos, fish, and shorebirds on the Forth estuary, eastern Scotland. Aquatic Conservation 2" 212-222. Meire, P.M., 1991. Effects of a substantial reduction in intertidal area on numbers and densities of waders. Acta XX Congr. Internat. Ornithol. p. 2219-2227. Misdorp, R., F. Steyaert, F. Hallie and J. de Ronde, 1990. Climate change, sealevel rise and morphological developments in the Dutch Wadden Sea, a marine wetland. In: Beukema, J.J., W.J. Wolff and J.J.W.M Brouns (eds.). Expected effects of climatic change on marine coastal ecosystems. Kluwer Academic Publ., Dordrecht, p. 123-132. Myers, J.P., 1984. Spacing behaviour of nonbreeding shorebirds. Behavior of Marine Animals 6: 271-321. Myers, J.P., R.I.G. Morrison, P.Z. Antas, B.A. Harrington, T.E. Lovejoy, M. Sallaberry, S.B. Sennar and A. Tarak, 1987. Conservation strategy for migratory species. Amer. Scientist 75: 19-26. Oost, A.P. and K.S. Dijkema, 1993. Effecten van bodemdaling door gaswinning in de Waddenzee. DLO-Instituut voor Bos- en Natuuronderzoek, Texel. IBN-rapport 025, 133 pp. (in Dutch). Peletier, H., W.W.C. Gieskes and A. Buma, submitted. Paper on UV-B effects on benthic diatoms on tidal flats. Postma, H., 1967. Sediment t r a n s p o r t and s e d i m e n t a t i o n in e s t u a r i n e environments. In: G.H. Lauff (ed), Estuaries, Am. Ass. Adv. Sci., Washington, 83: 158-179. Reed, D.J. and D.R. Cahoon, 1992. The relationship between m a r s h surface topography, hydroperiod and growth of Spartina alterniflora in a deteriorating Louisiana saltmarsh. J. Coastal Res. 8: 77-87. Rozema, J., H. Lambers, S.C. van de Geijn and M.L. Cambridge (eds.) 1993. CO2 and biosphere. Kluwer, Dordrecht, 484 pp. Rozema, J., G.M. Lenssen, R.A. Broekman and W.P. Arp, 1990. Effects of atmospheric carbon dioxide enrichment on salt-marsh plants. In: Beukema, J.J., W.J. Wolff and J.J.W.M. Brouns (eds.). Expected effects of climatic change on marine coastal ecosystems. Kluwer Academic Publ., Dordrecht, p. 49-54. Siefert, W., 1990. Sea-level changes and tidal-flat characteristics. In: Beukema, J.J., W.J. Wolff and J.J.W.M. Brouns (eds.). Expected effects of climatic change on marine coastal ecosystems. Kluwer Academic Publ., Dordrecht, p. 105-112. Smit, C.J., 1994. Alternatieve voedselbronnen voor schelpdier-etende vogels in Nederlandse getijdewateren. DLO-Instituut voor Bos- en Natuuronderzoek, Texel. IBN-rapport 077, 80 pp. (in Dutch). Stevenson, J.C., L.G. Ward and M.S. Kearney, 1986. Vertical accretion in marshes with varying rates of sealevel rise. In: Wolfe, D.A. (ed.). Estuarine variability. Acad. Press, San Diego, p. 241-259. Strain, B.R. and J. Cure (eds.), 1985. Direct effects of increasing carbon dioxide on vegetation. US Dept. of Energy, Washington DC, 287 pp. Ungar, I.A., 1978. Halophyte seed germination. Botanical Review 44: 233-264. Van Latesteijn, H.C. and R.H.D. Lambeck, 1986. The analysis of monitoring data with the aid of time-series analysis. Environm. Monit. Assess. 7: 287-297.
818 Van den Hoek, C., A.M. Breeman and W.T. Stam, 1990. The geographic distribution of seaweed species in relation to temperature: present and past. In: Beukema, J.J., W.J. Wolff and J.J.W.M. Brouns (eds.). Expected effects of climatic change on marine coastal ecosystems. Kluwer Academic Publ., Dordrecht, p. 55-68. Van Malde, J., 1992. Relative rise of mean sea-levels in The Netherlands in recent times. In: Tooley, M.J. and S. Jelgersma (eds.), Impact of sea-level rise on European Coastal Lowlands, Blackwell Publishers, Oxford, UK, p. 36-55. Van der Spek, A.J.F. and D.J. Beets, 1992. Mid-Holocene evolution of a tidal basin in the western Netherlands. Sediment. Geol. 80: 185-197. Van de Staay, J., J. Rozema and M. Stroetenga, 1990. Expected changes in Dutch coastal vegetation resulting from enhanced levels of solar UV-B. In: Beukema, J.J., W.J. Wolff and J.J.W.M. Brouns (eds.). Expected effects of climatic change on marine coastal ecosystems. Kluwer Academic Publ., Dordrecht, p. 211-218. Vooys, C.G.N. de, 1990. Expected biological effects of long-term changes in t e m p e r a t u r e s on benthic ecosystems in coastal w a t e r s a r o u n d The Netherlands. In: Beukema, J.J., W.J. Wolff and J.J.W.M. Brouns (eds.), 1990. Expected effects of climatic change on marine coastal ecosystems. Kluwer Academic Publ., Dordrecht, p. 77-82. Weber, T., Houston, A.I. and B.J. Ens. in press. Optimal departure fat loads. Proceedings of the Royal Society. Westerhoff, W.E. and P. Cleveringa, 1990. Sea-level rise and coastal sedimentation in central Noord-Holland (The Netherlands) around 5000 BP: a case study of changes in sedimentation dynamics and sediment distribution patterns. In: Beukema, J.J., W.J. Wolff and J.J.W.M. Brouns (eds.). Expected effects of climatic change on marine coastal ecosystems. Kluwer Academic Publ., Dordrecht, p. 133-138. Wilson, J.G., 1990. Effects of temperature changes on infaunal circalittoral bivalves, particularly Tellina tenuis and T. fabula. In: Beukema, J.J., W.J. Wolff and J.J.W.M Brouns (eds.), 1990. Expected effects of climatic change on marine coastal ecosystems. Kluwer Academic Publ., Dordrecht, p. 93-98. Wolff, W.J. (ed.), 1983. Ecology of the Wadden Sea. Balkema, Rotterdam, c. 2000 pp. Wolff, W.J., 1992a. Ecological developments in the Wadden Sea until 1990. In: Dankers, N., C.J. Smit and M. Scholl (eds.) - Proceedings 7th International Wadden Sea Symposium, Ameland, 1990. Net. Inst. Sea Res. Publ. Ser. 20: 23-32. Wolff, W.J., 1992b. The end of a tradition: 1000 years of reclamation of wetlands in The Netherlands. Ambio 21: 287-291. Wolff, W.J., N. Dankers, K.S. Dijkema, P.J.H. Reijnders and C.J. Smit, 1994. Biodiversity of the Wadden Sea (Denmark, Germany, The Netherlands): recent changes and future projections. In: Boyle, T.J.B. and C.E.B. Boyle (eds.) Biodiversity, temperate ecosystems and Global change. NATO Advanced Research Workshop. Springer, Berlin, p. 337-356. Wolff, W.J., A.M.M. van Haperen, A.J.J. Sandee, H.J.M. Baptist and H.L.F. Saeijs, 1975. The trophic role of birds in the Grevelingen estuary, as compared to e their role in the saline Lake Grevelingen. In: Persoone, G. et al. (eds.). Proc. 10th Eur. Symp. Mar. Biol., Ostend, Belgium, Sept. 17-23, 1975, vol. 2: 673689.
819
Discussion on the NRP assessment report "Impact of climate change on the Wadden Sea" R.S.A.R. van Rompaey Programme Office of the Dutch National Research Programme on Global Air Pollution and Climate Change NOP, c/o RIVM (pb 59), Postbus 1, NL-3720 BA Bilthoven, The Netherlands, tel: +31-30-743781; fax: +31-30-25 19 32; e-mail:
[email protected] After the clear presentation by W. Wolff (IBN-DLO), coordinator of the 'Wadden' project cluster, a short discussion took place. W. Roeleveld (Free University Amsterdam) commented that the geological sedimentation record in the Wadden Sea is worth studying from the palaeo-ecological point of view. J. Terwindt (Utrecht University) commented that further research from his team will focus on fine elements deposition and on spatial analysis of vegetation gradients. Van Rompaey asked whether climate change may cause loss of biodiversity in the Wadden Sea. Wolff answered that changes in species composition are likely to occur, but that the system does not have as high biodiversity as, e.g. dune ecosystems, and that great losses are not to be expected. However, there may occur important shifts in population size of a number of species, like mussels, which do change the appearance and functioning of the system considerably. De Boer (DGM) asked whether temperature changes on the breeding grounds in the Arctic may also have consequences for nature values in the Wadden Sea. Wolff affirmed that this certainly will be the case and that the interrelations of the Wadden Sea with the global system are part of the research questions of the NRPII project, especially considering birds.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Short papers within NRP subtheme "Impact o f c l i m a t e c h a n g e on the W a d d e n Sea"
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Climate Change Research: Evaluation and Policy Implications S. Zwerver, R.S.A.R. van Rompaey, M.T.J. Kok and M.M. Berk, (Eds.) 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
823
Salt M a r s h e s and sea level rise: m a r s h d y n a m i c s in relation to accretion p r o c e s s e s and accretion e n h a n c e m e n t techniques Erik-Jan Houwing and Joost H.J. Terwindt Institute for Marine and Atmospheric Research Utrecht, dept. Physical Geography, Utrecht University, P.O. Box 80115, 3508 TC Utrecht, The Netherlands
Abstract Sea-level rise will become a worldwide threat to coastal marshes by affecting the marsh vegetation through an increase in number of tidal flooding and an increase in wave energy. The survival of the salt marshes depends on the accretionary-erosional balances in both the marsh zone itself and in the pioneer zone in front of the marsh. The salt marshes along the main coast of the Netherlands Wadden Sea are stimulated by human intervention (siltation constructions) in the natural processes. Evaluation of the effects of climatic change in this area is necessary not only for predictions of future situations but also for the active management and the elaboration of mitigating measures in order to prevent salt marsh erosion.
1.
INTRODUCTION
The Wadden Sea is a shallow tidal sea of about 8,000 km 2 situated along the coast of the Netherlands, Germany and Denmark. An essential characteristic of the Wadden Sea system is the emergence of large tidal flats at low water. A part of special interest are those higher flats along the mainland and the Wadden Sea face of the barrier islands, because on these parts salt marshes are found. Much research has been done concerning the conditions of growth, accretion and erosion processes and vegetational succession in the salt marsh area. Accordingly, the vertical growth of the mudflat-marsh is determined by the rates of minerogenic and organogenic sedimentation, the frequency and period of tidal flooding and the overall compaction of the sediment (Allen, 1990; Craft et al., 1992). The sedimentation rate on the marsh is controlled by the mean tidal amplitude and is a function of the height of the mud flat and salt marsh to mean high water level (Dijkema et al., 1990). In addition, the sedimentation rate on mud flats is high in those areas which are sheltered, frequently overflooded and where the sediment supply is high. The zonation (succession) of the vegetation on the salt marsh is dependent on the surface elevation, the tidal amplitude and the drainage of the area (Armstrong et al., 1985). If the accretion of sediment on the marsh itself remains behind an increase in sea-level rise the marsh will be more frequent overflooded and the vegetation detoriation will increase (Reed and Cahoon, 1992). The Wadden Sea is a unique nature area with wildlife of many different species containing fishes, birds and mammals. The tidal flats and salt marshes act as nursery grounds for
824 migrating birds and contain extremely large numbers of benthic invertebrates and are characterized by high biomass. Most of the salt marsh area in the Wadden Sea can be found attached to the main coast. Here, the marshes stabilize the shoreline and afford protection to developed areas during storms by absorbing and dissipating wave energy, and by storage of water. A rapid increase in mean high water levels might lead to severe erosion of salt marshes and tidal fiats. A loss in the marsh area will affect the coastal protection to storm surges and will have major consequences for migratory birds and for the estuarine ecosystem in the Wadden Sea. The effects of sea level rise on the development of salt marshes can be described in a general manner as follows. The higher mean sea level causes an increase in the tidal storage volume of the flat and marsh area resulting in an extended drainage and associated outbuilding (erosion) of the gully system. In addition the distribution of wave heights over time may shift towards the higher wave domain because the increase in water depth allows higher waves to penetrate towards the fiat-marsh area. The higher wave attack normally will result in flatter profiles. Furthermore the seaward boundary of the pioneer vegetation may shift landward. In the other hand the increased frequency of tidal flooding of the marshes will result possibly in larger sedimentation rates and thus a vertical upbuilding of the salt marsh. Hence the heightening of mean sea level is expected to be associated with an erosional tendency of the fiats and the transition zone of the pioneer vegetation and with an accretional tendency of the higher marsh area. Small changes in the boundary condition for the development of tidal fiats (hydrodynamic parameters like mean sea level, wind induced wave heights and tidal currents) will have consequences for the sedimentation- and erosion-processes on the tidal fiats and in the salt marshes. The pioneerzone, in this respect, is of major importance for the salt marsh. It is transitional to the tidal fiats and it is situated on a level which is most affected by wave action. Erosion of the pioneerzone during an increase in rising high-tide levels will lead to cliff formation and marsh erosion from the seaward edge. The pioneer zone contains the pioneer vegetation Salicornia dolichostachya and an erosional tendency of this zone will be indicated by a landward retreat of this species. The present research addresses the hydrodynamic processes and expected changes in the fiat-salt marsh area in order to develop management strategies and mitigating measures.
2.
RESEARCH AREA
As early as 1930, brushwood groynes have been build along the mainland coast of the Netherlands Wadden sea to stimulate accretion of sediment. The construction of the brushwood groynes significantly increased the rate of sedimentation in the areas in between (Dijkema et al., 1990). The excavation of ditches in the sedimentation area ensured an increase in dewatering in such a way that the succession of pioneer vegetation towards higher order vegetation originated. The sedimentation rate and seaward expansion of the salt marsh area was higher during the first years of the construction of the brushwood groynes (1960-1978). After this period the salt marsh expansion arrested and even erosion within the sedimentation fields occurred. Partly this can be ascribed to a reduction of the management effort, but other factors have to play a part as well. Recent loss in salt marsh area in the Wadden sea might be due to an accelerated increase in mean high water to 0.44 cm yr -1 from 1961 to 1983 (Dijkema et al., 1990), from which about 75 % is calculated to be due to an increase in wind
825 speed between 1976 and 1983 (Bossinade et al., 1993). It is expected that changes in the hydrodynamic boundary conditions will first be noticeable in the pioneer zone. The research, therefore, is focused on the hydrodynamic processes in the pioneer zone and investigates the boundary conditions for the growth and survival of the pioneer vegetation.
3.
MEASUREMENTS
The sediment bed in the pioneer zone consists of mud and fine sand and can be classified as a cohesive bed. Erosion of a cohesive bed or deposition of cohesive material will be confined to a near bed layer and will be hard to measure in situ. Both erosion- and sedimentation- processes are controlled by the near-bed hydrodynamic processes as represented by the bed-shear stress (Partheniades, 1986). The net result of erosion- and sedimentation-processes is determined on one hand by the exerted shear stress (induced by waves and currents) and on the other hand by the strength of the bed. An intensive field campaign was started in April 1993. During this field campaign the shear stress and shear strength determining hydrodynamic parameters were measured in the pioneer zone. Two field sides have been chosen along the Dutch Wadden Sea coast which show a difference in the development of the pioneer zone and in the expansion of the salt marsh. One area is characterized by a salt marsh retreat in the last ten years whereas the other area shows a steady sedimentation in the same period. Simultaneous experiments in both areas will characterize the differences between the repetition and magnitude of the hydrodynamic processes that take place in both salt marsh areas. The hydrodynamic measurements in the pioneer zone includes the determination of wave height distribution throughout the year, tidal current velocities, wave induced current velocities, related erosion- and deposition processes and sediment transport. The germination and growth of the pioneer vegetation is monitored in both areas. Field experiments as well as laboratory experiments were carried out in order to determine the boundary conditions for the establishment of the pioneer vegetation, for the effects of future changes in hydrodynamic processes on the vegetation and the effect of pioneer vegetation on sedimentation- and erosion-processes in the salt marshes. The results are used to draw up and calibrate a Salicornia computer simulation model which describes the life cycle of this pioneer vegetation species.
4.
RESULTS
The results from this research show that sand is transported as bed load in the pioneer zone whereas mud is transported in suspension. In this respect, it is important for the salt marsh as well as for the pioneer zone how much sand or mud is available in front of the flatmarsh zone for the transportation into the salt marsh works. The Wadden morphology in front of the salt marshes partly determines the rate of sedimentation in the pioneer zone. Differences in the Wadden morphology consequently will lead to spatial differences in salt marsh development along the Wadden Coast. It was assumed that the construction of the brushwood groynes would limit wind wave growth in the pioneer zone and thereby decrease the turbulence in the near bed region and as a result decrease erosion of the sediment bed. However, measurements have shown that this
826 is not the case. Wind waves are fully developed within a distance of thirty meters from the groynes. The distance between the groynes measures at present 400 meter. The construction of groynes, however, significantly increased sedimentation. It seems likely that the groynes reduce the current induced turbulence and thus increase the deposition of suspended sediments. The germination, growth and survival of the pioneer vegetation is determined in great extend by the hydrodynamic parameters. For instance the wash away of seeds and seedlings during the first week of gemination is a function of the mobility of the top layer of the bed. This means that the seaward expansion of the pioneer vegetation is determined not only by the frequency and duration of overflooding but also by the composition (mud/sand ratio, shear strength) of the bed. This research is carried out in order to investigate the effects of the present management techniques on erosion- and sedimentation-processes during an increase in sea level rise. The results of the present investigations indicate that variable arrangements and outlines of the brushwood groynes may be applied in order to stimulate the deposition in the area. As such it may combat the negative effects of sea level rise in these areas.
5.
REFERENCES
Allen, J.R.L., 1990. Salt-marsh growth and stratification: A numerical model with special reference to the Severn Estuary, Southwest Britain. Marine Geology, vol 95, pp 77-96. Armstrong, W., E.J. Wright, S. Lythe and J.T. Gaynard, 1985. Plant zonation and the effects of the spring-neap tidal cycle on soil aeration in a Humber salt marsh. Journal of Ecology, vol 73, pp 323-339. Bossinade, J.H., J. van den Bergs and K.S. Dijkema, 1993. The influence of the wind on the annual mean high water along the Frisian and Groninger Wadden Sea coast (in Dutch). Rijkswaterstaat, Directie Groningen, Nota Gran 1993-2009, 22 p. Craft, C.B., E.D. Seneca and S.W. Broome, 1993. Vertical accretion in microtidal regularly and irregularly flooded estuarine marshes. Estuarine Coastal and Shelf Science, vol 37, pp 371-386. Dijkema, K.S., J.H. Bossinade, P. Bouwsema and R.J. de Glopper, 1990. Salt marshes in the Netherlands Wadden Sea: rising high tide levels and accretion enhancement. In:J.J. Beukema, W.J. Wolff and J.J.W.M. Brouns (eds.). Expected effects of climatic change on marine Coastal ecosystems, Kluwer, Dordrecht, pp 173-188. Partheniades, E., 1986. The present state of knowledge and needs for future research on cohesive sediment dynamics. Proceedings, 3rd International Symposium on River Sedimentation, vol III, University of Mississippi, pp 3-25. Reed, D.J. and D.R. Cahoon, 1992. The relationship between marsh surface topography, hydroperiod and growth of Spartina alterniflora in a deteriorating Louisiana Salt Marsh. Journal of Coastal Research,vol 8 ,no 1 , pp 77-87.
Climate Change Research: Evaluation and Policy Implications S. Zwerver, R.S.A.R. van Rompaey, M.T.J. Kok and M.M. Berk, (Eds.) 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
827
The effect of sea level rise on a migratory wader B.J. Ens a and J.D. Goss-Custard b aInstitute for Forestry and Nature Research (IBN-DLO), P.O. Box 167, 1790 AD Den Burg, The Netherlands blnstitute for Terrestrial Ecology (ITE), Furzebrook Research Station, Wareham, Dorset BH20 5AS, United Kingdom
Abstract To investigate the possible effects of sea level rise on the migratory waders that depend on the Wadden Sea for their survival, we chose the well-studied Oystercatcher (Haematopus ostralegus) as a representative of a short-distance migrant. The total population size is modelled as an equilibrium between density-dependent mortality during winter and density-dependent reproduction during summer. Loss of winter habitat will increase mortality in winter and reduce population size. Even under extreme current scenarios of sea level rise, the negative effects on population size seem small. However, the current model ignores effects of temperature, which may affect winter habitat quality through its known effects on the population dynamics of the prey, and the possible effects of changes in breeding habitat.
1. INTRODUCTION The Wadden Sea is renowned worldwide for its importance as a breeding, wintering, and, especially, staging area for migratory waterbirds. A significant proportion of at least 52 distinct populations of 41 species of waterbirds utilize the Wadden Sea at some stage in their annual cycle and in 8 cases this involves no less than the entire world population [1]. For these birds the Wadden Sea is a vital link in their migrations along what is generally referred to as the East Atlantic Flyway. To conserve this rich nature area, the three Wadden Sea countries Denmark, Germany and the Netherlands have taken many protection measures over the last two decades. For instance, the Wadden Sea is recognized as the most important nature area of the Netherlands in the Physical Planning Decision (PKB) for the "Waddenzee" and 2000 km 2 are protected under the Nature Conservation Act. Internationally, it has been given the status of "Wetland of international importance" under the Convention of Ramsar, and it is recognized as a Biosphere Reserve by UNESCO. Very recently, a new potential threat to the system has appeared that might have disastrous consequences: global climate change. Due to the magnitude of its effects, global climate change could easily wipe out all progress that has been made so far in conserving the Wadden Sea. As formulated by Peters [2] " What is clear .. is that the climatological changes would have tremendous impact on communities and populations isolated by development and, by the middle of the next century,
828 may dwarf any other consideration in planning for reserve management." In an early appraisal of the problem for marine coastal ecosystems, Beukema et al. [3] took the necessary first steps of making an inventory of present knowledge, identifying uncertainties and formulating research needs. Although apparently nobody seriously suspects an effect of heightened levels of UV-B on migratory birds, the diversity of hypotheses on the effects of climate change on bird migration is nonetheless bewildering [4-6]. To fight this chaos we need a conceptual framework that allows us to answer a set of interrelated but precise questions, like: 1. Which aspects of the climate change or secondary effects will have the greatest impact: global warming, storms, rainfall patterns, sea level rise? 2. At what stage of the life cycle of the birds does the climate change or climate-induced effect operate: breeding season, autumn migration, spring migration, nonbreeding season? 3. Which processes must be considered: vagaries during the migratory flight, interspecific competition between resident and non-resident species, intraspecific competition on the breeding grounds, intraspecific competition on the wintering grounds, phenology of the food supply, evolution of the migration schedule? We apply the conceptual framework described by e.g. Goss-Custard [7] and Ens et al. [8], which emphasises the importance of individual-based concepts for understanding population processes, to construct mathematical models with a strong empirical basis. Ideally, the models allow us to calculate the effect on the population for a given climate scenario. Space limitations do not permit us more than a brief description of one example: the potential effect of sea level rise on the population dynamics of the oystercatcher Haematopus ostralegus, i.e. we do not report on our work on the long-distance migrants.
2. MODEL DESCRIPTION The basic idea of the model is that both reproduction in summer and mortality during winter are density-dependent. The primary source of density-dependence in summer is assumed to result from territorial exclusion, i.e. relatively fewer birds breed when the density of potential breeding birds increases. We express the proportion excluded as a k-value: k = aT + bTlog~oN, where N is the number of potential breeding birds and the slope bT measures the compressibility of the territories. When bT = 1, the territories cannot be compressed any further so that, above the number set by the intercept aT, a constant number of pairs breed, irrespective of the numbers attempting to do so. Thus, bT = 0 implies no density dependence and bT = 1 implies perfect 'contest' density dependence. We do not allow bT < 0. The primary source of density-dependence in winter is decreased survival chances due to competition for food. At low densities, there is no competition, but only a densityindependent proportion (mw) starving. When bird density increases, eventually a point, Cw, is reached at which mortality begins to increase and so becomes density-dependent. From then on, mortality increases by bw for every unit increase in bird density. We estimated these parameters for each sub-population and, where necessary, age class. Furthermore, we knew the size for each of the four sub-populations that we distinguished: Continental coastal, Continental inland, Atlantic coastal and Atlantic inland. Within the Continental and Atlantic regions, inland-breeding and coastal-breeding subpopulations use the same coastal areas in winter. Finally, the sometimes quite substantial
829 annual fluctuations in the main production and mortality parameters were generally not correlated across sites within a sub-population. This allowed the standard deviations of the annual variations in these parameters to be estimated for both sub-populations in each region so that realistic annual variations could also be included in the model. For more details we refer to [9].
3. MODEL SIMULATIONS In the model the effect of loss of winter habitat is simulated by removing an increasing proportion of the winter habitat and thus, initially, increasing the density of birds on the wintering grounds. Simulations over a range of probable parameter values show that the density at which winter mortality becomes density dependent, Cw, simply determines the point at which population size is affected as habitat is gradually removed. The population is affected sooner in the more widely fluctuating Continental sub-populations than in the less variable Atlantic sub-populations. Once winter density reaches Cw, the consequences depend on the slope, bw, of the density-dependent winter mortality function. In all sub-populations, the reduction in population size increases sharply as bw increases, but only at low values; above a certain level, further increases in bw make less difference. Because of their higher reproductive rate, inland sub-populations are initially less affected by winter habitat loss than coastal sub-populations. These conclusions are robust over a range of assumptions about competition for territories in summer and age differences in mortality in winter [10]. However, the conclusion that inland sub-populations are initially less affected by winter habitat loss depends very much on the assumption that coastal and inland birds compete on equal terms on the wintering grounds. Work is in progress to test the hypothesis that coastal birds may actually be at an advantage, because, as residents, they are likely to dominate their migratory conspecifics. It is unlikely though that our conclusions on the effects of winter habitat loss on the total population size would be greatly altered if this hypothesis was found to be true.
4. THE EFFECT OF SEA LEVEL RISE Given these and other uncertainties in parameter values it is not possible to arrive at a precise prediction of the change in population size under different climate scenarios. However, within the large range of parameter values assessed, there were no cases where population size increased following loss of winter habitat, a theoretical possibility according to Fretwell [11]. Furthermore, it was generally true that the equilibrium population size decreased by a smaller percentage than the reduction in surface of winter habitat. This was especially true for small reductions of winter habitat. Thus, if habitat loss is small, reduction in population size will be even smaller. Under the most extreme scenario of a sea level rise of 85 cm during the next century, the calculations of Louters and Gerritsen [12] indicate that the overall surface area of the Dutch Wadden Sea fiats will not change significantly in the next fifty to a hundred years; in the order of 1% of the intertidal area will be lost. Even if this estimate is out by a factor of 10 it seems unlikely on the basis of the above that the equilibrium population size would be reduced by more than 5 %.
830 5. CONCLUSION Although we think it unlikely that oystercatchers will suffer much from sea level rise, it would be premature to conclude that they are not affected by climate change. The model is able to handle changes in breeding habitat, but we did not include such changes in the scenario calculations. More importantly, we did not allow for possible changes in the quality of the remaining habitat. Simulations with an individual-based physiologically-structured game theoretic model show that deteriorating habitat quality can greatly reduce population size [13]. Thus, our current model cannot handle changes in the population dynamics of the bivalve prey. Recruitment in these prey species depends strongly on temperature [14]. We are currently extending the oystercatcher population model to include the dynamics of the prey. The extended oystercatcher population model will also allow evaluation of the effects of other man-induced habitat changes, like shellfisheries.
6. REFERENCES
10 11 12 13 14
H. Meltofte, J. Blew, J. Frikke, H.-U. R6sner, and C.J. Smit, Wader Study Group Bulletin, 74 (1994) 1. R.L. Peters, pp. 99-118 in R.L. Wyman (ed.), Global Climate Change and Life on Earth, Chapman and Hall, New York, 1991. J.J. Beukema, J.J. 1990. pp. 83-92 in J.J. Beukema et al. (Ms.), Expected Effects of Climatic Change on Marine Coastal Ecosystems, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, 1990. J.D. Goss-Custard, S. McGrorty and R. Kirby, pp. 189-193 in J.J. Beukema et al. (eds.), Expected Effects of Climate Change on Marine Coastal Ecosystems, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, 1990. R.T. Lester, and J.P. Myers, J.P., pp. 119-133 in R.L. Wyman (ed.), Chapman and Hall, New York, 1991. P. Berthold, Bird Migration: a general survey, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1993. J.D. Goss-Custard, Bird Study 40 (1993) 81. B.J. Ens, T. Piersma and R.H. Drent, Ophelia Suppl. 6, (1994) 127. J.D. Goss-Custard, R.T. Clarke, K.B. Briggs, B.J. Ens, K.-M. Exo, C.J. Smit, A.J. Beintema, R.W.G. Caldow, D.C. Catt, N Clark, S.E.A. le V. dit Durell, M.P. Harris, J.B. Hulscher, P.L. Meininger, N. Picozzi, R. Prys-Jones, U.N. Safriel and A.D. West, J. appl. Ecol. 32 (1995) in press. J. D. Goss-Custard, R. T. Clarke, S.E.A. le V. dit Durell, R.W.G. Caldow and B.J. Ens, J. appl. Ecol. 32 (1995) in press. S.D. Fretwell, Populations in a seasonal environment, Princeton University Press, Princeton, 1972. T. Louters and F. Gerritsen, report RIKZ-94.040. J.D. Goss-Custard, R.W.G. Caldow, R.T. Clarke, S.E A. le V. dit Durell and W.J. Sutherland, J. Anim. Ecol., 64 (1995) in press c. J.J. Beukema, K. Essink, H. Michaelis and L. Zwarts, Neth. J. Sea Res. 31 (1993) 319.
Climate Change Research: Evaluation and Policy Implications S. Zwerver, R.S.A.R. van Rompaey, M.T.J. Kok and M.M. Berk, (Eds.) 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
831
Winter temperature and reproductive success in shell-fish in the Dutch Wadden Sea P.J.C. Honkoop, J.J. Beukema and D. Kwast Netherlands Institute for Sea Research, P.O. Box 59, 1790 AB Den Burg, The Netherlands
Abstract Effects of mild and cold winters on the reproductive success of some species of bivalves were studied under experimental conditions. Egg production in the Balthic clam M a c o m a balthica and the cockle Cerastoderma edule was smaller after high than after low winter temperatures. Egg production in M. balthica was positively correlated with their body weight and they lost a higher proportion of their weight during mild than during cold winters. The eggs of the cockle were smaller after a mild than after a cold winter, giving rise to smaller Dlarvae. The lower quantity and quality of eggs after mild as opposed to cold winters can explain why reproductive success in bivalves is generally higher after cold than after mild winters.
1. I N T R O D U C T I O N Ever since 1970, numbers and biomass of bottom animals are recorded annually on the Balgzand, a tidal-flat area in the westernmost part of the Dutch Wadden Sea. Strong year-toyear fluctuations in biomass were observed in most bivalve species, resulting in a low stock size in some years, which then creates a conflict between fishery and nature conservancy. Fluctuations were synchronised for several species and failure of recruitment occurred in particular after mild winter in the cockle, the mussel, the Balthic clam and the gaper clam. In these species reproduction is usually highly successful after cold winters [ 1]. Two factors can be responsible for these fluctuations: 1. Due to an early appearance of predators (shrimps, shore crabs) after mild winters on the tidal flats, the predation pressure on juvenile bivalves will be higher after mild winters than after cold winters [2,3], 2. At high winter temperatures metabolic processes in bivalves proceed at a relatively high rate. As a consequence, weight loss is high during mild winters and energy available for gametogenesis is lower after mild than after cold winters. Higher weight losses during mild winters have been found in mussels and other species of bivalves [4,5]. Low adult weights may affect viability of their offspring by the reduction of size of eggs and larvae[6]. Egg size appears to be important for the survival of bivalve larvae [7]. Our aim is to find out whether such processes can be observed also in Wadden Sea bivalves. By simulation of mild and cold winters, the influence of winter temperature on quantity and quality of eggs is being studied in bivalves such as the Balthic clam, the cockle and the mussel.
832
2. MATERIAL AND METHODS To study effects of winter temperature on bivalves, we kept groups of mussels, cockles and Balthic clams at different levels of water temperature during the winter months until spawning. One group followed the water temperature in the field, the other was kept at a 2.5~ lower level. At each of the two temperature treatments, an intertidal (intermittently immersed) and a subtidal (permanently immersed) group was run. Longer immersion times result in longer daily feeding periods and less weight loss. We used the animals of the four different groups for the determination of body weights prior to spawning, egg production, egg size and size of the larvae.
3. RESULTS The results of measurements of condition index and egg production are shown in Table 1. Egg size and shell length of D-larvae are shown in Table 2. Combined results of body weights and egg production from the years 1993 and 1994 are shown in Figure 1 Table 1 Weight (standardised for animals of exactly 10 mm shell length) and egg production (means _+ SE) after four treatments. Experiments of 1994. Balthic clam cockle
weight
warm tidal cold tidal warm subtidal cold subtidal
egg no.(* 104)
8.1 _ 0.4 9.5 _+0.3 9.8 _+0.4 13.8 _+ 1.3
1.9 3.0 2.0 6.4
_+0.4 + 0.5 + 0.6 + 0.8
weight
7.8 _+0.7 8.7 _ O. 1 10.0 +_0.3 11.4 _+0.2
egg no.(* 105)
0.7 __ O. 1 2.2 _+0.8 O. 1 2.0 _+0.3
Table 2 Egg size of the Balthic clam and egg size and larval shell length of the cockle after four treatments. Experiments of 1994. Balthic clam cockle
warm tidal cold tidal warm subtidal cold subtidal
egg size (~tm)
egg size ( ~ t m )
D-larvae shell length (tam)
104.1 106.9 106.5 104.6
76.7 78.2 75.3 79.3
106.0 + 0.7 122.4 + 0.7
_+0.2 _+ 1.3 + 0.7 + 1.4
+ + + +
0.8 0.4 0.1 0.3
123.0 _+3.3
833
EGG
NUMBER
7,
xl0
4 1993
[]
6
9
1994
5 4 3-J 2
o
1 0
9
[] |
7
9
!
8
9
i
9
BODY
9
|
9
i
9
I
9
i
9
|
10 11 12 13 14 WEIGHT
9
(mg)
Figure 1 Egg production in the Balthic clam as a function of body weight (at standard shell length) just before spawning. Data from experiments in two winters combined. Body weights varied in the expected way, the higher temperatures and shorter feeding time resulted in lower body weights. Egg production was in both species higher at the lower than at the higher winter temperatures (Table 1). Egg size of the Balthic clam was not influenced by winter temperature. In the cockle the eggs of the groups kept at higher winter temperatures were somewhat smaller. The shell lengths of the D-larvae were much smaller after mild than after cold winters (Table 2). The plot of egg numbers against body weights (Figure 1) showed a similar correlation as reported by others [4,5]. High body weights resulted from either good feeding conditions or low winter temperatures (compare Table 1).
4. CONCLUSIONS Apart from diminishing predation pressure, cold winters are beneficial to reproductive success in bivalves by the production of higher numbers of larger eggs, giving rise to more and bigger larvae (which are expected to be more viable than small ones).
5. REFERENCES 1 J.J. Beukema, Neth. J. Sea Res., 30 (1992) 73-79 2 J.J. Beukema, J. Exp. Mar. Biol. Ecol., 153 (1991) 97-113
834 3 4 5 6
J.J. Beukema, Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser., 83 (1992) 157-165 U. Maung Myint and P.A. Tyler, Mar. Biol., 67 (1982) 209-223 L. Zwarts, Neth. J. Sea Res., 28(3) (1991) 231-245 B.L. Bayne, D.L. Holland, M.N. Moore, D.M. Lowe and J. Widdows, J. Mar. Biol. Ass. UK, 58 (1987) 825-841 7 J.N. Kraeuter, M. Castagna, R. van Dessel, J. Exp. Mar. Biol. Ecol., 56 (1982) 3-8
Climate Change Research: Evaluation and Policy Implications S. Zwerver, R.S.A.R. van Rompaey, M.T.J. Kok and M.M. Berk, (Eds.) 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
835
A S S E S S M E N T R E P O R T ON N R P S U B T H E M E
' ~ R E G I O N A L H Y D R O L O G Y ~'
J. Dronkers Rijkswaterstaat, National Institute for Coastal and Marine Management, RIKZ P.O. Box 20907 2500 EX The Hague The Netherlands
With contributions by: G.P. KSnnen F.R. Rijsberman B. Parmet, M. Raak
H.J.M. Lankreij er N.E.M. Asselman, H.J.A. Berendsen, J. Kwadijk and H. Middelkoop J. Postma, L.C.P.M. Stuyt and P. Kabat M. van der Drii~
KNMI, Royal Netherlands Meterological Institute, De Bilt Resource Analysis, Delft RIZA, Institute of Inland Water Management and Waste Water Treatment, Arnhem RUG, University of Groningen RUU,University of Utrecht SC-DLO, Research Institute,The Winand Staring Center, Wageningen UvA, University of Amsterdam
836
Contents Abstract 1.
Introduction
2.
Climate Scenarios 2.1 Introduction 2.2 The need for standardization of scenarios within NRP 2.3 The KNMI approach to precipitation scenarios 2.4 Conclusions
3.
L a n d use scenarios 3.1 Introduction 3.2 Method 3.3 Results 3.4 Implications
4.
Forests 4.1 Introduction 4.2 Method 4.3 Sensitivity and climatic scenario analysis 4.4 Results and conclusions
5.
Lowland hydrology 5.1 Introduction 5.2 Method 5.3 Results of simulations 5.4 Implications
6.
River d i s c h a r g e 6.1 Introduction 6.2 Method 5.3 Results 6.4 Implications
7.
Erosion 7.1 Introduction 7.2 Method 7.3 Results of simulations
8.
T r a n s p o r t and s e d i m e n t a t i o n 8.1 Introduction 8.2 Method 8.3 Results 8.4 Implications
837
0
Economy, safety, environment 9.1 9.2 9.3 9.4 9.5
Introduction Climate scenarios Impacts on safety against flooding Economic impacts Conclusions
10. References
ABSTRACT The major part of the Netherlands consists of a low-lying river delta which is very sensitive to hydrological conditions in the North-Western part of the European continent. The rivers Rhine, Meuse and Scheldt carry through this delta to the North Sea annually nearly 100 km3 of fresh water. This water originates from a drainage basin of about 185 000 km2, which is 6 times the country area. The present geography of the Netherlands has largely been shaped by this river inflow and by the sediments which are carried along. Interaction of these fluxes with North Sea hydrodynamics in a period of rising sea level has produced large lowlands, which in the past millennium have been reclaimed for agricultural, urban and industrial purposes. At present an extended hydrological infrastructure is required to contain high waters and to keep ground water and surface water tables permanently under control. Otherwise more than half of the Netherlands would be permanently or frequently flooded. In the Netherlands water management is a matter of permanent concern. The abundance of water is at the same time source of prosperity and source of vulnerability. Waterways for shipping and water supply for agriculture, industry and domestic use are essential resources for economy. The Dutch wetlands also represent a great environmental value. Changes in water supply and river discharge therefore have important impacts. More frequent occurrence of low discharge is detrimental to fluvial transport and agriculture. More frequent occurrence of high river discharge affects the safety of population against flooding and causes economical damage. Additional sedimentation raises the river beds with respect to the surrounding lowlands with possible consequences for safety and river management. The previous considerations form the basis for the sub-theme "REGIONAL HYDROLOGY" of the Dutch climate change research programme NRP. Seven research projects dealing with different aspects of the hydrological system have been selected in order to study the vulnerability of the Netherlands to climate related hydrological change. Although not all components of the hydrological system could be studied, the most important processes and relationships in the hydrological system have been addressed (see Figure 1). In the present phase of research most of the results still have an indicative character. Some projects have been completed, but others have started only recently. Nevertheless several important conclusions already emerge, which are summarized below:
838 Recent scenarios indicate greater regional climate changes t h a n a s s u m e d in the past. Most r e m a r k a b l e are the strong expected increase in w i n t e r precipitation and the increased drought in summer. With increasing CO2 concentrations forests will become more r e s i s t a n t to droughts. If biomass does not increase, the evapotranspiration will decrease, causing an increase in drainage to ground water and run-off. Drought damage to crop production will increase. Agriculture will be less affected in the low lying river delta t h a n in neighbouring regions. This m a y yield a comparative advantage for the Dutch economy. In coastal lowlands no substantial increase in saline seepage is expected, even if the sea level rises more than one meter. The discharge regime of the Rhine will change drastically. The a n n u a l variability of the discharge will strongly increase; w i n t e r discharges will increase and summer discharges will decrease. Periods of low river discharge will become more frequent and more prolonged. This will diminish the transport function of the Rhine, with serious economic consequences. The availability of cooling water for power plants will also be affected. A shortage of Rhine water will cause further intrusion of saline water in the lower river delta. The frequency of high discharges will increase. This causes more frequent inundation of the embanked floodplains in the Netherlands. It is not yet clear to what extent this will change safety from flooding. Sensitivity of soils to erosion is more affected by the expected changes in land use t h a n by climate change. The production of sediment by soil erosion may be substantially increased by changes in precipitation. Sedimentation rates on the embanked floodplains in the N e t h e r l a n d s will increase. As a consequence, polluted sediments will become an increasing environmental concern. Pollution in the catchment basins of Rhine, Meuse and Scheldt has to be kept under control. A general conclusion from the different sub-theme studies is t h a t the most serious impacts of climate change result from a shift in extreme conditions more t h a n from a shift in average climate conditions. At present no reliable indications can be given regarding changes in frequency of extreme conditions. This question should be addressed with priority in the future NRP. It appears that, in particular, a more f r e q u e n t occurrence of periods of drought will have significant economical consequences.
839
I
....
~' '"
!
I 1" sCENARIOs CLIMATE CHANGE temperature - precipitation - sea level ~9
-
i
["
3 . FORESTS
watera'nci
NARIOS ,,
cachm as'n" t
5 RIVER DISCHARGE
!cl
7. SEDIMENTATION I lowland rivers I I
~
8.
NOMY, SAFETY, ENVIRONMENT
Figure 1.1 Structure of NRP subtheme Regional Hydrology and flow-chart of climate change impacts through Regional Hydrology 1.
INTRODUCTION
Climate change is the driving force in a chain of processes which by altering the hydrology of the Netherlands affect important economical and social values. Changes in temperature and precipitation/evapotranspiration in the catchment basin of the rivers Rhine, Meuse and Scheldt and changes in sea level will affect the water and sediment balances of the Dutch coastal lowlands. Change in land use should also be taken into account. Change in land use may occur in response to climatic factors, but also in response to social or economic factors. Changes in climate and land use both affect the retention capacity and evapotranspiration of the catchment basins and by this the variability of water supply and river discharge. There is also an impact on soil erosion and sediment loading of the rivers with possible consequences for river management. Climate related change of regional hydrology therefore has an important impact on The Netherlands, physically, economically, socially and environmentally. This leads to the questions:
Are the hydrological infrastructure and water management practices in the Netherlands adequate for coping with climate change? Which adaptation measures could be considered? The chain of hydrological processes by which climate change affects socioeconomic and environmental values is depicted in the scheme. This scheme forms the structure of the sub-theme Regional Hydrology. Each process in the chain has been addressed by a specific NRP-project. Starting point are scenarios for relevant climate related variables. Different scenarios are considered, each representing an internally consistent set of projections of global climate change at the regional
840 scale. They form basic input for the different research projects within the subtheme. Much attention has been paid to the consistency of scenario assumptions used in the different projects. To the climate change scenarios are added scenarios for change in land use. Changes in soil erosion and river discharge are studied as p r i m a r y consequences of the climate and land use scenarios. A special underlying study is devoted to the water balance of forest areas. Another special study deals with the water balance of lowlands which are affected by salt w a t e r seepage and sea level rise. As a secondary consequence of climate and land use change the sedimentation in the lowland river system is investigated. C h a n g e in river morphology lags behind the aforementioned processes and therefore is a concern for the longer term. In a final chapter some indications are presented with respect to the economic, social and environmental consequences of the impacts of climate change through the hydrological system. The results obtained sofar in the sub-theme Regional Hydrology do not yet cover the complete hydrological system of the Netherlands including all its catchment basins. Ground w a t e r has not been dealt with in a general way; only for a p a r t i c u l a r type of lowland areas the ground w a t e r balance has been studied. Impacts of climate change on the coastal marine system are not considered in the sub-theme. Table 1.1 List of projects in the subtheme "Regional Hydrology" Title
Project leader
Number
Impact of climate change on the discharge of the river Rhine
B.W.A.H. P a r m e t
850001
H.J.A. Berendsen Influence of climate change on the sedimentation of the rivers Rhine and Meuse (embanked floodplains)
850002
A.W.L. Veen
850015 9
Effect of climate change on groundwater and surface hydrology in the low-cosastal regions of The Netherlands
P. Kabat/ L.C.P.M. Stuyt
851041
The effects of climate change on transport and sedimentation of suspended load of Rhine/Meuse
H.J.A. Berendsen
851059
The impact of temperature and rainfall changes on land degradation in source areas of the suspended sediment load of the Rhine
F.J.P.M. Kwaad/ A.C. Imeson
852089
Effect of increase of C O forested landsurface
2 on
the balance of the
841 2.
CLIMATE SCENARIOS
G.P. KSnnen Royal Netherlands Meterological Institute, KNMI P.O.Box 201, 3730 AE De Bilt,The Netherlands
2.1 I n t r o d u c t i o n Climate impact studies require knowledge of the evolution of climate variables on scales ranging from local to global. Of particular importance in m a n y studies are variables like mean precipitation and its variability, sometimes down to timescales of one day or less. The present-day GCM simulations are still unable to produce reliable predictions for these. One reason for this is the coarse spatial resolution of the models in comparison which the typical size of precipitation areas, which prevents the inclusion of a physically correct description of precipitation; another reason is the present incapability to represent the large-scale atmospheric flow correctly enough to estimate from it even the large-scale precipitation, which depends essentially on the first derivative of the gradient in the flow pattern. To fill this gap, climate scenarios can be constructed. They can be defined as follows (Viner and Hulme 1993) : " A climate scenario is an internally consistent r e p r e s e n t a t i o n of a possible future climate [...], t h a t can be used to get a better understanding of the consequences of climate change [...]". 2.2 The n e e d for s t a n d a r d i z a t i o n of scenarios w i t h i n N R P Integration of results of impact studies requires a certain level of standardization of climate scenarios, particularly because different effects m a y be sensitive to different climate variables, or even to a combination of such variables. Among such variables are means, variances, autocorrelations and extremes of elements like temperature, precipitation, radiation, evaporation and so on. For hydrological studies, precipitation is a key variable. Due to the reasons mentioned before, direct GCM-prediction can not be used. A common approach to obtain absolute values of monthly means is to apply the relative change in precipitation, as obtained from GCMs for a future climate to the observed monthly means (Bultot 1988, Kwadijk 1993); an evolution in time is then obtained by scaling of the change with the GCM-predicted global temperature change. This procedure preserves in first order the internal consistency of the precipitation-global temperature relation. To obtain a scenario on e.g. daily time scale, an observed daily time series m i g h t be transformed into a time series for a future climate, just by scaling all daily values with the relative difference in monthly means. However, it is not a priori g u a r a n t e e d t h a t such a procedure results in a scenario t h a t is meteorologically consistent and hence in e.g. realistic extremes. 2.3 The KNMI a p p r o a c h to p r e c i p i t a t i o n scenarios In the KNMI method, it was attempted to produce precipitation scenarios in the form of daily time series t h a t can be considered to be representative for a future climate. These time series are obtained by transformation of an observed daily time series of t e m p e r a t u r e (T) and precipitation (RR). If required, a scenario for monthly m e a n s follows immediately from the averages of the transformed time series.
{]42 The t r a n s f o r m a t i o n is done as follows. First, a s e a s o n - d e p e n d e n t c h a n g e in t e m p e r a t u r e is applied to all observed daily t e m p e r a t u r e s T in the series. The m a g n i t u d e of the change is based on GCM information. This leads to a new series of t e m p e r a t u r e T*. Then, the daily precipitation a m o u n t s RR are changed. This is done on the bases of the observed relation b e t w e e n RR a n d T in t h e p r e s e n t climate (Figure 2.1) on wet days (threshold 0.1 mm/day), r a t h e r t h a n on bases of GCM-information. The d a t a were fitted by the following piecewise polynomical function R(T) with Temperature in Celsius degrees and daily Rainfall in mm). R(T) = exp [ 0.76 + 0.083 T ] T < 7~ R(T) = exp [ 0.76+0.083 T-0.014 (T-7)2+ 0.0007 (T-7)3 ] T > 7 ~ and T < 21 ~ R(T) = exp [-0.47+0.103 T] T > 21~
Eg. 1.
a n d the t r a n s f o r m e d precipitation RR* in the series were obtained by applying to the observed amounts each day a factor F t h a t depends on T and T* : RR* = JR(T*) / R(T)] RR = F . RR(2) This scenario, referred to as KNMI-1, a s s u m e s implicitly t h a t the m e a n T-RR relation r e m a i n s in first approximation preserved in a changing climate. Table 2.1 shows the dependence of F on T and T* for T* - T= 3~ We note t h a t the coefficient of v a r i a t i o n ( s t a n d a r d deviation divided by the mean) of the original series a n d the t r a n s f o r m e d one is the same. The plausibility of such a r e s u l t is s u p p o r t e d by t h e fact t h a t the coefficient of v a r i a t i o n of RR shows no clear dependence on temperature.
Table 2.1 Multiplying factor F for various values of t e m p e r a t u r e T w h e n there is a c o n s t a n t increase in t e m p e r a t u r e of 3~ on every day (T*=T+3~ The s t a n d a r d error of F is given in parentheses T
T*
F
-12
-9
1.28
:
:
:
:
4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24
7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27
1.28 1.21 1.08 .98 .95 .96 1.02 1.14 1.26 1.28 1.28
(.02) (.01) (.01) (.01) (.01) (.02) (.03) (.06) (.09) (.10) (.10)
(.02)
843 A second scenario, KNMI-2, a s s u m e s t h a t the R-P-T r e l a t i o n is in first a p p r o x i m a t i o n constant, where P is surface air pressure. This leads to the application of a R-T relation t h a t is explicitly pressure dependent. An additional assumption of KNMI-2 is that the difference in pressure is taken to be zero. This is analogous to the assumption t h a t in first approximation the circulation remains unchanged in a future climate. We note, t h a t this assumption does not apply to KNMI-1, as there is an implicit variation of P with T present in Figure 2.1 according to the present-day climatology. Table 2.2 compares the KNMI scenarios for seasonal means with other sources. The T* - T are taken from the Canadian Climate Centre GCM-model. The Bultot and Kwadijk scenario are based on direct model output of GCMs. In general, there is agreement between the various methods, apart from the summer. The latter is probably r e l a t e d to the absence of an accurate description of convective precipitation in the GCMs, which in our method is described by the right hand part in Figure 2.1. The scenarios can be based on the R - Tmax relation too, in which Tmax is the daily m a x i m u m temperature. This leads to other constants in Eq. 1. For further details of he various scenarios we refer to Klein Tank and Buishand (1993a; 1993b; 1994) and Buishand and Klein Tank (1994). Although the KNMI scenarios can give a plausible description of the variability of rain and t e m p e r a t u r e down to very short time scales, its spatial validity is restricted. Over an area of the Netherlands inland the R - T relations are similar, so t h a t a de Bilt-based scenario can be applied in that region. It is presumely also valid in the German lowlands. Extension to other areas like the middle and south basin of the Rhine requires analysis of the R - T relation in those regions.
844
Table 2.2 Mean seasonal changes (2* CO2-1" CO2) in t e m p e r a t u r e T (~ and precipitation R (%) in 2 KNMI climate scenarios for the Netherlands. The values are compared to model predictions of the C a n a d i a n Climate C e n t r e GCM (Boer et al., 1992; McFarlane et al., 1992) and the scenarios used by Bultot et al. (1988) and Kwadijk (1993) Season
Year
DJF
MAM
JJA
SON
KNMI-1,2 1)
+ 3.0
+ 2.3
+ 3.7
+ 3.4
+ 3.7
CCC-GCM 2) Bultot 3) Kwadijk 4) High Best Low
+ + + + +
3.0 3.2 5.7 4.3 3.2
+ 2.3 + 3.1
+ + + + +
3.7 2.5 4.3 2.7 1.7
+ 3.4 + 2.7
+ + + + +
KNMI-1,5) KNMI-25)
+ 20 + 19
+ 8 + 10
+ 6 + 10
+ 5 + 10
+ 10 + 12
CCC-GCM2) Bultot 3) Kwadijk4) High Best Low
+ + + + +
28 15 34 19 4
+ 21 + 11
+ + -
- 11 + 6
+ 2 + 7 + 32 + 11 - 10
AT (~
3.7 2.9 5.0 3.5 2.5
~WR (%)
26 10 25 4 20
1) T a k e n from the CCC-GCM. (see 2) 2) C h a n g e s predicted by the CCC-GCM; T values are for 16 l a n d g r i d p o i n t s s u r r o u n d i n g the N e t h e r l a n d s w h e r e a s R values are for 2 l a n d g r i d p o i n t s covering the Netherlands; two other high resolution GCMs (Geophysical Fluids Dynamics Laboratory GFHI and United Kingdom Meteorological Office UKHI) show s o m e w h a t higher t e m p e r a t u r e increases: about +5~ (Houghton et al., 1992). 3) Three monthly values of the Bultot scenario are averaged. The scenario is valid for Belgium and compiled from various early-GCM sources ( M a n a b e a n d Stouffer, 1980; Manabe et al., 1981; Washington and Meehl, 1983). 4) Scenario based on monthly m e a n changes predicted by the ESCAPE model for gridpoints covering the northern part of the Rhine-basin (using the IMAGE and STAGGER climate modules in ESCAPE; Rotmans, 1990; Wigley et al., 1991). The values presented are for the IPCC Business-as-Usual emission scenario (BaU). High, Best and Low denote upper 90% confidence limit, m e a n and lower
845
90% confidence limit of temperature and precipitation changes obtained with 6 different GCMs. 5) A t e m p e r a t u r e - d e p e n d e n t multiplying factor is applied to each individual rainday in the record at De Bilt (1961-1990). For KNMI-1 this factor is derived from the observed precipitation-temperature relation on wet days at De Bilt (1906-1981) as presented in Figure 2.1. The factor represents the relative change in the mean daily precipitation a m o u n t given a certain t e m p e r a t u r e perturbation AT; it ranges from 0.9 for days with T--12~ to 1.3 for days with T below 4~ and T above 21~ KNMI-1 implicitly assumes t h a t the surface air pressure P changes according to the present-day relation between P and T. For KNMI-2 this factor is derived from the observed p r e c i p i t a t i o n temperature/surface air pressure relation on wet days at De Bilt (1906-1981). The factor r e p r e s e n t s the relative change in the m e a n daily precipitation a m o u n t at distinct v a l u e s of surface air p r e s s u r e P given a c e r t a i n t e m p e r a t u r e p e r t u r b a t i o n AT; it ranges from 0.7 for days with T--17~ and P-1000 h P a to values > 2 at low and high temperatures. KNMI-2 explicitly keeps the daily surface air pressure P unchanged.
0
I
I I
9
I
i
-20
i
-10
i
I
i
0
I
10
i
i
20
i
30
T (~ Figure 2.1 Mean precipitation amounts at t e m p e r a t u r e T class intervals of 2~ for wet days (threshold 0.1 ram) at De Bilt (1906-1981). The figure is based on 15897 wet days (57% of the total n u m b e r of days). The n u m b e r of wet days in a t e m p e r a t u r e interval is 2104 for the T= 6~ class and decreases to about 10 at the extreme t e m p e r a t u r e s . The error bars indicate the estimated s t a n d a r d deviations of the means. The smooth curve represents the fitted regression relation (Equation 1)
846 2.4 C o n c l u s i o n s Precipitation scenarios with a time resolution of one day can be obtained from the empirical relation between observed precipitation amounts and temperature. The corresponding change in seasonal precipitation compares well with GCM-based scenarios, apart from the summer. The scenario can be refined by taking pressure into account as predictor, to account for systematic changes in circulation in case there are clear indications of these in GCM output. The scenarios obtained in these ways are meteorological consistent and provide a plausible description of extremes. Extension to other regions in Europe requires study of the local time series to find the geographical dependence in the results of Eq. 1.
3.
LAND USE SCENARIOS
B. P a r m e t R i j k s w a t e r s t a a t , I n s t i t u t e of I n l a n d W a t e r M a n a g e m e n t and W a s t e W a t e r T r e a t m e n t , RIZA P.O.Box 9072, 6800 ET Arnhem, The Netherlands Abstract Land use is an important p a r a m e t e r in hydrological and morphological processes. Climate change can induce changes in land use because the production and w a t e r use of crops is influenced. In the framework of a project of the I n t e r n a t i o n a l Commission for the Hydrology of the Rhine Basin, land use scenarios have been developed for the Rhine area. Besides climate change, autonomous developments were t a k e n into account, since these determine for a major p a r t the land use changes. A biophysical classification system has been designed and in combination with a crop simulation model geo-referenced information on land use potentials under present and possible future conditions is generated. The influence of climate change is mainly positive, the production increases. Autonomous developments were expressed in a Central Projection with a Plus and a Minus variant. In the Central Projection about one million hectare (10%) is vacated and comes available for other purposes t h a n agriculture or urban land. In the Minus v a r i a n t this is 3 million and in the Plus variant zero. Changed climate adds 0.2 million hectare to this, because less land is required due to the higher production. 3.1 I n t r o d u c t i o n Land use determines interception of precipitation, influences the ratio between i n f i l t r a t i o n a n d surface r u n o f f and d e t e r m i n e s to a l a r g e e x t e n t t h e evapotranspiration. It is therefore an important p a r a m e t e r in hydrological and morphological processes. An increased CO2-content and associated climate change might induce changes in land use, since growth and evapotranspiration of plants are influenced, see also Section 4 and 5. For n a t u r a l vegetation this could m e a n t h a t existing ecosystems move, alter in t h e i r species composition or even completely disappear. For agricultural crops the most i m p o r t a n t aspect is t h a t crop production may increase. Furthermore cropping patterns can change and new v a r i e t i e s can be introduced, t h a t cannot be grown u n d e r p r e s e n t climate
847 conditions. W h e t h e r changed climate conditions lead to changes in land use as described above, depends for a major part on economic, political, demographic and technical, socalled autonomous developments. As there are large uncertainties, both with respect to climate change and to autonomous developments, possible changes in land use have to be expressed in alternative scenarios. In the project 'Influence of climate change on the discharge of the river Rhine', that is coordinated by the International Commission for the Hydrology of the Rhine Basin (CHR), also the effects of land use changes are considered. Land use scenarios taking into account the effects of climate change in combination with autonomous developments were not available and have been developed as part of the CHR-project. The study has been carried out by the Winand Staring Centre at the request of The I n s t i t u t e of Inland Water M a n a g e m e n t and Waste W a t e r Treatment. In this chapter the methodology and the results of the study are presented. 3.2 M e t h o d To d e t e r m i n e the possible impacts of climate change on crop production a preliminary study was carried out (Wolf en van Diepen, 1991). The study showed t h a t the effects of a doubling of the CO2-concentration and an increase in temperature are mainly positive. Most crops grown in Western Europe are of the socalled C3 type, for which the CO2-concentration is sub-optimal. An increase in CO2 acts as a fertilizer and the assimilation rate increases. For socalled C4 crops, of which maize is the only important representative, the CO2-concentration is optimal and the increase in assimilation rate does not occur. An increase in t e m p e r a t u r e enhances the CO2 growth stimulation and increases production where temperature conditions are sub-optimal. Besides production, CO2 influences the water use efficiency. With higher CO2-concentrations, the s t o m a t a of crops have to be opened less to take up the same ammount of CO2. The water loss per s t o m a t a is less. For the overall water use of crops the increase in production counterbalances for a part the increase in water use efficiency, because the leaf surface increases.
An important conclusion of the preliminary study is that m o r e CO2, an increase in temperature and a small change in precipitation during the growing season, does not bring about limitations and even improves the circumstances for the cultivation of presently grown crops. Moreover possibilities for other crops arise. Climate change itself will however not directly generate changes in land use in the Rhine Basin. Although the changed climate boundary conditions will play a role, land use changes will be determined by autonomous developments. A farmer will only grow another crop if it is economically more profitable. It follows t h a t the autonomous developments are very important with respect to changes in land use. The study to land use scenarios for the Rhine basin was therefore divided in two parts. A biophysical and a socio-economic part. The target period is around the mid of next century when, according to the Business as Usual emission scenario of IPCC, the CO2-concentration has doubled. A best guess climate scenario for this period was derived from Kwadijk (1993). The scenario assumes an increase in t e m p e r a t u r e of 1.5~ in s u m m e r and 2~ in winter. Precipitation r e m a i n s unchanged during summer and increases with 10% during winter.
848 The biophysical part is aimed at assessing the effects of a doubling of the CO2concentration and a changed climate on crop production, crop w a t e r use and cropping calendar (Roetter, 1994; Roetter en van Diepen, 1994). The specific aim is to give geo-referenced information on land use potentials under present and possible future conditions. To cover the regional differences in climate and soil in the Rhine basin, a biophysical classification system has been developed. The changes in potential (optimal supply of water, nutrients and pesticides) and water limited yields (optimal use of nutrients and pesticides) and water use of agricultural crops have been investigated using a crop growth simulation model. Simulation results for present and possible future climate were combined into changes in land suitability and attainable yields in the Rhine Basin. The socio-economic part examines the influence of autonomous developments on land use and combines this with the results from the biophysical p a r t into scenarios or projections (Veeneklaas et al, 1994). A Central Projection describes the long-term tendency in land use and is based on secular historic trends, f u n d a m e n t a l scientific and technical principles and basic assumptions. Secular t r e n d s have been used to u n d e r p i n q u a n t i t a t i v e s t a t e m e n t s about f u t u r e developments. Scientific and technical restrictions refer mainly to a t t a i n a b l e agricultural production levels and land suitability and follow from the biophysical part. The basic assumptions are the most controversial. By referring to other studies on future developments they can be made plausible to a greater or lesser degree. In case of great u n c e r t a i n t y a Plus v a r i a n t and a Minus v a r i a n t is constructed. For the Plus variant maximum, and for the Minus variant m i n i m u m u r b a n and agricultural claims on land are assumed. The socio-economic part results in two types of land use projections. For unchanged and changed conditions a Central Projection is constructed with, if necessary a Plus and a Minus variant. 3.3 R e s u l t s
B i o p h y s i c a l p a r t ; changes in l a n d use p o t e n t i a l s A biophysical classification system containing the elements climate and soils and adapted for present and possible future conditions was not available for the Rhine basin and had to be developed. First a bioclimatic classification was designed, which was combined with a soil classification and integrated in a Geographical Information System (GIS) (Roetter, 1994). Climatic, agroclimatic and agroecological m a p s show t h a t a n n u a l m e a n t e m p e r a t u r e , precipitation and annual t e m p e r a t u r e amplitude are the m a i n factors to describe the regional differentiation of agricultural crops and n a t u r a l vegetation. The bioclimatic classification system was based on meteorological data for 53 stations and a digitized altitude map. Regression equations were derived between meteorological variables as dependent variables and combinations of altitude, longitude and latitude as independent variables. Based on the regression analysis and known classification systems the set-up of the bioclimatic system for the Rhine basin is based on: 1) annual mean temperature (seven classes); 2) annual mean temperature amplitude (four classes); 3) a n n u a l mean temperature of the coldest month (five classes); 4) annual mean precipitation (five classes).
849 The first three levels are based on regression equations and the fourth level is based on a digitized precipitation map. The equations have been derived both for p r e s e n t and possible future conditions. They are i m p l e m e n t e d in a GIS and consequently bioclimatic d a t a surfaces can be easily obtained. In total 700 combinations are possible, but only 90 occur at present in the Rhine Basin of which 25 have a surface area larger t h a n 1%. With the a s s u m e d scenario, the climate becomes more maritime/less continental and warmer. The soil suitability classification was based on a digitized soil map. Soil mapping units were clustered in four soil suitability groups based among others on slope class, soil texture, depth, moisture retention characteristics and soil genesis. Biophysical types were generated with the GIS by combining the bioclimatic types with soil suitability groups. This was done for present and possible f u t u r e conditions. It has been assumed that a change in climate does not affect the soil characteristics used in defining suitability groups. With the crop growth model WOFOST, potential and water-limited yields have been computed for seven major crops in the Rhine basin; w i n t e r wheat, silage maize, barley, oil seed, potato, sugar beet and rye grass, for present and possible future conditions (Roetter en van Diepen, 1994). Computations were carried out with meteorological data from 18 weather stations, representing the predominant base-line climatic types, and for two soil types representing the soil moisture and retention characteristics of the soil suitability groups. The crop characteristics were adapted for future conditions according to state of the art knowledge. In line with the preliminary study, the simulations with WOFOST showed that, in general, production increases. U n d e r water-limited situations, besides the CO2-fertilizer effect, the increased w a t e r use efficiency causes the production to increase. For the group of soils with an available w a t e r capacity of 70 mm, the average production for the Rhine area increased for winter wheat with 40%, of rye-grass with 33%, of sugar beets with 25% and of silage maize with 12%. It can be derived from the simulations t h a t soil and t e r r a i n characteristics in combination with a change in mean annual temperature are the main determining factors with respect to land suitability. Based on these criteria, five land suitability classes were defined: Very high, high, moderate, m a r g i n a l and unsuitable. If climate changes according to the described best guess scenario, the a r e a l percentages of land suitability classes change as described in table 3.1. The class "very high" increases from 1.3 to 38.6%. The percentages of the other classes decrease. The a s s u m e d climate change has a positive effect on the overall suitability of land for cultivation of current crops and tree species. S o c i o - e c o n o m i c p a r t ; l a n d use p r o j e c t i o n s Starting point for the land use projections is the present land use in the Rhine basin. The Rhine basin has been divided into 13 regions based on the NUTS-1 division of the European Union (EU). Land use was derived from statistics. Half of the total area of the Rhine basin is used for agriculture and about one third is covered with forest. The basin is densely populated with about 55 million people, consequently a relatively large share, 11%, is built-up land. The Central Projection is based on secular trends in the past, other surveys of the future and basic a s s u m p t i o n s including technical and scientific restrictions
850
(Veeneklaas et al., 1994). Looking at past secular trends in land use, it seems t h a t we enter a period of contraction of the agricultural area. This is founded on the ongoing productivity increases and s t a g n a t i n g demand following from the low expected population growth. Furthermore, there are m a n y parallels with other historic periods of contraction. A decline in agricultural area is also the outcome of other surveys of future land use. The rate of decline in these surveys depends on the scenario assumptions, for example free trade versus protected markets. Table 3.1 Areal percentages of land suitability classes for unchanged and changed climate conditions (Roetter en van Diepen, 1994) Land suitability class
Percentage of total area (%) Unchanged climate
Very high High Moderate Marginal Unsuitable
1.3 28.1 41.8 8.8 20.0
Change (%)
Changed climate 38.6 3.7 37.3 0.7 19.7
+ 37.3 - 24.4 - 4.5 - 8.1 - 0.3
Basic assumptions in the Central Projection for urban land use are that population growth is marginal, but the amount of urban land per i n h a b i t a n t will increase, although at a slower rate t h a n during the last 40 years. For agriculture it is a s s u m e d t h a t technical progress will go on and t h a t regional differences in ratio between actual and water limited production will level out. Around the mid of next century yield levels will have reached 90% of the water limited yield in all regions. The common m a r k e t of agricultural products within the EU will remain. Because food r e m a i n s a strategic good a completely free m a r k e t will not develop. Consequently, world trade in agricultural products will not expand dramatically and protection of own markets for food will not disappear. For agricultural production stricter environmental regulations are expected, which will however not prevent approaching the water-limited yields. F u r t h e r m o r e it is assumed t h a t in the long r u n there will be a tendency to grow crops in those parts of the Rhine Basin t h a t have the highest yields. A certain degree of diversification within the regions will however remain. To construct the projections a hierarchical scheme is applied. U r b a n land needs and n a t u r e claims as defined in national policy plans have the highest priority. Second in line are agricultural land requirements and the lowest priority is given to forest and other land use. This hierarchy is based on the price of land paid by the different categories. For agriculture a second hierarchical scheme is nested, based on the profitability and the required quality of land; Horticulture and p e r m a n e n t crops, root crops, cereals and, with the lowest priority, grassland and fodder crops. For the Rhine basin as a whole the changes are listed in table 3.2. The basic assumptions of the Central Projection result in an increase in urban land use. The
851 Plus v a r i a n t assumes an increased population growth and more u r b a n sprawl and results in a larger increase of u r b a n land use. In the Minus v a r i a n t it decreases because of a decrease in population and lower land claims per i n h a b i t a n t . N a t u r e conservation claimed by policy plans has the same position in the h i e r a r c h y as u r b a n land use. In the N e t h e r l a n d s explicit claims have been f o r m u l a t e d in the N a t u r e Policy Plan of about 10% of the agricultural area. The a r e a used for agriculture decreases in all projections. With changed climate conditions this decrease is even larger, because production levels increase a n d hence, less land is needed. The m a i n decrease is found for cereals. Outside the E U production costs are lower and f u r t h e r m o r e the physical production conditions of the R h i n e b a s i n w i t h i n t h e E U are not optimal for cereal production. The production will therefore partly shift to outside the Rhine Basin. Next in line are potatoes. For this crop strong competition is expected with E a s t e r n Europe. Only for beets a small increase in area is expected for the Central Projection and the Plus Variant, for u n c h a n g e d climate. This is mainly caused by an increase in the production of fodder beets, t h a t will be used in cattle feed in line with a development of more self-sufficiency in dairy farming. The changes in a r e a of u r b a n and a g r i c u l t u r a l land use can differ for the 13 d i s t i n g u i s h e d regions. For the region N e d e r l a n d - O o s t ( N e t h e r l a n d s - E a s t ) for example u r b a n land use increases with 37% in the Central Projection. If n a t u r e reserves are included the increase is 72%. Agriculture decreases w i t h 16% for unchanged and with 21% for changed climate conditions. In the Minus v a r i a n t the agricultural land use decreases with 35%. Besides grassland, the acreage of cereals and potato decreases.
Table 3.2 Changes in areas of u r b a n and agricultural land use for u n c h a n g e d and changed climate conditions, for three v a r i a n t s with respect to the basic a s s u m p t i o n s , for the decade 2040-2050, in million ha and percentages (Veeneklaas et al., 1994) Central Projection Land use
unchanged
Agriculture -
Urban
Urban+ agriculture
Plus v a r i a n t
Minus variant
changed unchanged
changed unchanged
1.57
-
1.83
- 2.67
- 2.84
- 1.26
-
20%
-
24%
-
-
-
-
34%
37%
16%
changed
1.52 20%
+ 0.68 32%
+ 0.68 + 32%
- 0.18 - 9%
- 0.18 - 9%
+ 1.39 +66%
+ 1.39 + 66%
-
-
1.15
-
-
-
0.13
-
-
12%
- 29%
+ 1%
-
-
0.89
9%
2.85
3.02
-31%
0.13 1%
In the C e n t r a l Projection about one million hectare would become available for other use, in the Minus v a r i a n t this is 3 million hectare and in the Plus v a r i a n t no s u b s t a n t i a l s u r p l u s w o u l d be available. C h a n g e d c l i m a t e conditions add
852 approximately 0.2 million hectare. In Germany and the French part of the Rhine basin large parts will be vacated, mainly the areas were presently cereals are grown. The vacated areas could be used for afforestation, especially if different functions like timber production, recreation and nature can be combined. Other plausible possibilities are nature reserves or mixed designation, like dispersed housing, hobby farming, etc. The production of industrial crops does not require large amounts of land and biofuel production is economically not viable. These are therefore less realistic options for the vacated land. 3.4 I m p l i c a t i o n s A doubling of the CO2-content and an increase in t e m p e r a t u r e seem to have a positive influence on crop production. The implications of a climate change as assumed in this study are however small for land use, compared to the influence of autonomous changes. In general, also without climate change, it may be expected that the area built-up land will increase but the agricultural area will decrease at a faster rate. This may offer possibilities for nature development and afforestation. Possible implications for morphological processes in the Rhine basin are briefly discussed in Sections 7 and 8 and for hydrological processes in 6.
It should be noted t h a t in this study only average changes in climate were considered. Changes in for example frost risk or extreme events such as hail storms have probably a larger influence on average yields and yield variability and consequently on land use. However, due to lack of information on changes in these phenomena, they were not taken into account. 4.
FORESTS
H.J.M. Lankreijer Department of Physical Geography, University of Groningen Kerklaan 30, 9651 NN Haren, The Netherlands Abstract The possible impact of an increase in CO2 on the hydrology of forests is evaluated using sensitivity analysis and a climate scenario on an one-dimensional model of forest hydrology. Water use of forests is affected by plant physiological and meteorological variables. Doubling of CO2 leads to a decrease of s t o m a t a l conductance, resulting in a decrease in transpiration of 10 to 30%. The evaporation of rainfall interception by the canopy is increased due to a higher leaf area index and higher temperatures. Total interception increases, but the ratio between interception and precipitation decreases. Simulating a small increase in forest canopy increases the evapotranspiration only weakly and the higher precipitation in the scenario is mainly passed on to drainage. Drought damage in summer should reduce, but winter discharge may strongly increase. 4.1 I n t r o d u c t i o n A change in the concentration of C 0 2 as well as a possible climate change will have direct and indirect effects on the water use of plants, including trees. The changing
853 concentration of ambient CO2 directly effects physiological processes in the plant. The indirect effect results from the change in meteorological variables. Forests are aerodynamically rough and are therefore strongly coupled to atmospheric conditions. As a result, changes in the atmosphere might affect forests stronger than other vegetation types. The aim of this study is to estimate the consequences of a climatic change associated with a doubling of the atmospheric CO2 concentration, for the water balance of forests. The results may be used in other studies in the subtheme Regional Hydrology. Given the direct effect of CO2 on plant physiology, the project is also part of subtheme Terrestrial Ecosystems. The water flow in forests can be divided into interception of rainfall, transpiration by the canopy and drainage to groundwater. Interception and transpiration depend on meteorological variables and characteristics of the canopy. Transpiration is regulated by the stomatal conductance. Because of the turbulent flow of air in the canopy the dependency of interception and transpiration on meteorological conditions is much stronger for forests than for low vegetation. Soil characteristics determine in general the availability of water and the rate of drainage. A simultaneous change in atmospheric CO2 concentration and in climate influences the forest ecosystem in a complex way. Photosynthesis, water use efficiency, growth, canopy structure, nutrient circulation, species composition and phenology are all affected by a climate change. The interrelated and partly unknown processes involved make an analysis of the effects difficult and the results uncertain. Also the different reactions per species makes it difficult to generalize results. Some species, like several coniferous trees, show no reaction of s t o m a t a l conductance to changed CO2 concentrations. In general, pl ant physiological studies show that an increase in CO2 results in higher growth rates, lower stomatal conductance and increased water use efficiency. To simulate the water use of a forest, a realistic model of stomatal conductance (Gs) is needed. However, the exact relation between stomatal regulation, plant physiological processes and environmental variables is not fully known. This has resulted in a variety of empirical models simulating Gs. In this study a well known empirical parameterization of Gs is applied. Given the available data and the existing uncertainties in stomatal behaviour this parameterization is believed to be adequate. However, it is expected that in the near future the stomatal regulation will be simulated more realistically. 4.2 M e t h o d
Model A one-dimensional model is developed to simulate the water balance of a forest on an one hour time scale. The model is based on the model used by Dolman (1988) to simulate the water balance of a coniferous forest and is devided into three main submodels. Transpiration is simulated using the Penman-Monteith equation. The Gash-Rutter (Gash,1979) approach is applied to simulate the interception of rainfall. The soil water balance is simulated on a daily time scale by a simple
854 bucket type model. The amount of water exceeding field capacity is considered as precipitation excess and drained. Actual s t o m a t a l conductance is calculated from solar radiation, a t m o s p h e r i c humidity, air t e m p e r a t u r e and soil w a t e r deficit using the regression equation according to Jarvis (1976) and Stewart (1988). Data Five data sets of different forests in Europe were available to calibrate the model. These have been analyzed for their potential use in this study. The data sets of the Thetford forest (1976) in England and Ede (1988/1989) in The N e t h e r l a n d s are used. The calibration of the coniferous forest in Thetford is described by S t e w a r t (1988), and the calibration of the deciduous forest in Ede is derived from Hendriks et al. (1990) and Ogink-Hendriks (1994). The datasets of Ede did not include winter measurements. As water use during winter is limited due to low t e m p e r a t u r e s and low irradiation, this restriction of data is permissible to calibrate the model. The w a t e r balance is simulated over 5 years using the KNMI-data set of'De Bilt'. This d a t a set covering 1974 - 1978, consists of hourly values of air t e m p e r a t u r e , air h u m i d i t y , global radiation, windspeed and precipitation. The totals of precipitation of these years were 992, 635, 536, 813 and 643 mm respectively; on average 724 mm. The average over 1961- 1990 is 802 mm. The period of 5 y e a r was r e l a t i v e l y dry, with 1974 a wet y e a r and 1976 a very dry one. The meteorological variables of the KNMI data set were measured above grass and are transformed to above forest conditions according to Nonhebel (1987). The forest c h a r a c t e r i s t i c s are described by the calibrated p a r a m e t e r s of the 'Ede' and Tnetford' forests.
4.3 Sensitivity and climatic scenario analysis The influence of the main model p a r a m e t e r s on interception and t r a n s p i r a t i o n were analyzed by sensitivity analysis. To integrate the results with the results of other impact research groups within the National Research Program, the scenario KNMI-2 as described in Section 2 is applied to the 'De Bilt' data. In this study this scenario is n a m e d scenario-2. The changes in t e m p e r a t u r e and precipitation are given in table 4.1. In the scenario the relative humidity is held identical to the relative humidity of the unchanged climate. Other meteorological variables are not changed. The amount of precipitation in the scenario increases strongly compared to climate scenarios described by IPCC or Kwadijk (1993). The increase in precipitation in the scenario is regarded as an increase in precipitation intensity, and not as an increase in duration. In order to apply the scenario an e s t i m a t i o n m u s t be m a d e of the forest p a r a m e t e r s in a changed climate. In particular the leaf are index (LAI) is an i m p o r t a n t parameter. According to the review by Idso and Idso (1994), doubling CO2 increases dry weight by 24% when water is not limiting, and by 58% w h e n w a t e r is limiting. Trees may even be more responsive to a CO2 increase t h a n herbaceous plants, although most experiments are done on seedlings, leafs or small trees. According to the same authors, average increase in dry weight w h e n nutrients are limiting, still amounts to 48%. With limited nutrients and high CO2 the increase will be concentrated in the roots. It is unclear whether the increase in growth is sustainable. Due to the use of unacclimated plants and leaves in most experiments, and the short periods over which m e a s u r e m e n t s are made, it is h a z a r d o u s to transfer the results of these studies to forest (Eamus and Jarvis,
855 1989). For instance, the response of the assimilation rate of acclimated plants seems to be 50% lower than of unacclimated plants due to the lack of active sinks for the assimilation products (Cure and Acock, 1986). In the scenario a modest increase of 5% in LAI and storage capacity is applied. It is expected that growth of the canopy will be limited by low nutrient availability and the maximum LAI possible considering the radiation in the canopy. The direct effect of increased CO2 is simulated by a decrease in stomatal conductance of 30%. Based on present knowledge, these changes are regarded as realistic, though variations due to varying species composition and forest site may be large. Table 4.1 Scenario use as input in model simulations. Change of actual temperature per hour in ~ and hourly precipitation in %. Number of precipitation days is unchanged
Temperature change Precipitation change scenario 2
Winter
Spring
Summer Autumn Year
3.0 19.2
2.3 9.5
3.7 16.2
3.4 10.4
3.1 13.8
4.4 R e s u l t s a n d c o n c l u s i o n s
Interception The interception of rainfall is especially sensitive to changes in evaporation rate, leaf area and related storage capacity of the canopy. Changes in temperature, air humidity and windspeed strongly affect interception. A change in air humidity of 20% results in a change in average air humidity deficit from 0.6 g/kg to 1.8 g/kg. Interception changes by about 50% for coniferous forest and by 60% for deciduous forests. An increase in storage capacity of 20% results in an increase in interception of 10% for coniferous forest and 7% for deciduous forests. In applying the scenario, the small increase in interception for both forest types (Figure 4.1) is mainly caused by the increase in storage capacity. Relative humidity is unchanged and evaporative demand of the air is hardly increasing. Although precipitation increases strongly, it hardly affects interception because the increase is concentrated in winter, when evaporation is low. As a result both forest types show a small decrease in the ratio of interception and total precipitation.
856 Precipitation
4
I
,
1974
el
;.
I
1975
1976
i
1
i
1978
Deciduous forest
Avg
Coniferous forest
Interception
E 50
I
1974
I
I
I
--
I
i
I
l
I
197s
197e
1977
197s
Avg
1974
I~7s
197e
197r
lgTe
Aw
1975
1976
1977
1978
Avg
1974
1975
1976
1977
1978
Avg
Transpiration
1974
Precipitation excess E~ 35o
Normal
~
Scenario2
Figure 4.1 Yearly totals of precipitation, interception transpiration and excess simulated with normal climate and scenario 2
Transpiration Using the P e n m a n - M o n t e i t h equation, t r a n s p i r a t i o n of forests is sensitive to changes in m a x i m u m stomatal conductance, temperature, air humidity and soil water availability. The sensitivity of transpiration is caused by soil water. Due to limited soil water availability, transpiration is reduced after some time. So in most years, when transpiration is enhanced during winter and spring, water shortage occurs and reduces the t r a n s p i r a t i o n in summer. On the other hand, w h e n t r a n s p i r a t i o n is decreased, more water is available and t r a n s p i r a t i o n during s u m m e r is not so often limited. For some years, this results in a higher total transpiration when transpiration enhancing parameters have lower values. This includes interception. When interception is increased, less water is available for transpiration. Application of the scenario shows a small decrease in transpiration over the five year period. In dry years transpiration is limited due to low soil water content during summer. The strong increase in precipitation with a climate change leads to a higher availability of soil water, so transpiration in those years increases. But
857
due to the lower stomatal conductance, transpiration decreases by 10-30% most of the time when water availability is not limiting (Figure 4.1). Forest water balance
The annual water use of forest is simulated to change between -20% and +10 % depending on water availability. The average change over the 5 years is close to zero. Water use is increased when the forest stands on soil with low water availability. The increase in precipitation results in large precipitation excesses and a reduction in the number of days with water shortage (Table 4.2 and 4.3). In winter, when the evapotranspiration of the forest is low, the large increase in precipitation will drain almost completely to the groundwater. Large discharges can be expected, especially in deciduous forests. Figure 4.2 shows a total increase in precipitation excess of 60%, with high peaks during winter. Thetford/coniferous
5oo--
"~2oo o_
loo
... 9 9
o
Uljllllll,ll~'l 1
5
....
.
...
.
I r I I ' l I' I ~'11 I I ' l ' l ' l " l I"1 ~ 9
13
17
21
25
29
33
lll]r'll 37
41
45
It 49
53
Week
Ede/deciduous 4oo
t
350
.9. .
..
.
~ loo1 5O o -T-~ I i l l 1
5
I I 1 ] I 1 1 1 1 F7 i ~ |--I I l-I I ~ t I t .I..I.(1 9
13
17
21
25
29
33
I I vil 37
it 41
I"l
I1,
I 45
I ~.1.
II
49
53
Week 9
Scenario
2
Normal
Figure 4.2 Cumulative precipitation excess per week for Thetford and Ede forests Table 4.2 Number of days with soil water deficit above maximum for Ede deciduous forest
Normal Scenario 2
1974
1975
1976
1977
1978
Avg
0 0
39 18
46 31
13 0
22 0
24 9.8
858 Table 4.3 N u m b e r of days with soil w a t e r deficit above m a x i m u m for Thetford coniferous forest
Normal Scenario 2
1974
1975
1976
1977
1978
Avg
7 0
42 18
91 59
15 10
46 17
40.2 20.8
Implications According to the simulation study winter discharge will increase strongly and s u m m e r droughts will decrease. The increase in winter discharge results from the strong increase in precipitation and not from the decrease in transpiration, which is low in winter. Compared to deciduous forests, coniferous forests diminish winter discharge. It should be noted t h a t the results of the study are strongly dependent on the expected increase of precipitation, the decrease in stomatal conductance, the small increase in leaf area and the assumed constant relative humidity. On the short t e r m the s t o m a t a l conductance of most C3 species at elevated CO2 levels decreases, but long t e r m effects are h a r d l y known at present. Given the uncertainties in these parameters, the limits of confidence of the present study are very wide. The p r e s e n t policy to replace coniferous forest by deciduous forest to limit evaporation, will further increase drainage in a greenhouse climate. This m e a n s that frequent flooding can be expected in winter when the soil is already saturated. Like the prediction of future climate, the prediction of the impacts of climate change on w a t e r use of forest systems is hazardous. An important reason is t h a t data to validate the model are scarce. The response of trees to elevated CO2 levels might mirror t h a t of other C3-plants, but may also differ because trees are woody and perennial. Experiments with increased CO2 concentration on fully grown forest trees are recommended to improve the confidence level of the present studies. 5. L O W L A N D H Y D R O L O G Y J. Postma, L.C.P.M. Stuyt and P. Kabat Research Institute: DLO-The Winand Staring Center (SC-DLO) P.O.Box 125, 6700 AC Wageningen, The Netherlands
Abstract Dynamic computer simulation models were used to carry out scenario studies, forecasting the possible effects of sea level rise and climate change on physical processes which are crucial in regional- and agro-hydrology. These effects call for w a t e r m a n a g e m e n t m e a s u r e s on a regional scale. Attention was focused on changes in hydrology in the upper soil layers where these effects interfere with soil
859 water dynamics. A modified version of the two-dimensional groundwater flow model MOC of Konikow & Bredehoeft was used to simulate density-dependent deep groundwater flow and salt transport. Soil water dynamics and salt transport in the u n s a t u r a t e d zone were simulated with the one-dimensional model SWAP. A sea level rise of 1.2 m (worst-case scenario of IPCC, 1990), gradually imposed during a century, affects the seepage rate into polders in the studied area almost instantaneously but at a negligible rate. During the simulated period, the salinity of the seepage w a t e r r e m a i n s unaffected due to the low flow velocities of the g r o u n d w a t e r and the great path lengths to be travelled by the g r o u n d w a t e r between the coastal area and the polders. In contrast, climate change significantly affects crop production, viz. potential and actual transpiration. 5.1 I n t r o d u c t i o n
Climate change will interfere with low-coastal hydrology int two different ways, namely sea level rise and altered meteorological conditions near the land surface. Sea level rise will probably cause increased seepage rates in low-coastal regions, leading to s a l i n i z a t i o n of (shallow) ground- and surface waters. Altered meteorological conditions will affect the exchange of water and energy at the soil surface, and t h u s soil w a t e r dynamics in the u n s a t u r a t e d zone and crop production. In low-coastal regions of The Netherlands, integral water management influences the open water and the shallow groundwater systems. Agriculture, horticulture, n a t u r e conservation, domestic and industrial w a t e r supply are involved on a regional scale. As climatic change is likely to interfere with integral water supply and demand, an investigation of its possible consequences is called for. The climatic change was simulated using meteorological relationships from the KNMI (see Section 2), based upon a temperature rise of 1 ~ Simulations of the proposed t e m p e r a t u r e rise of 3 ~ (IPCC, 1990) was abandoned, because of sensitivity of the available crop varieties to the changes in t e m p e r a t u r e sums. Adapting these and other physiological plant parameters to such comparatively extreme conditions was considered to be unreliable at this time. It is to be expected t h a t varieties suited to changed conditions will be available when they become necessary. The consequences were assessed through a series of scenario studies, made with dynamic computer simulation models which were modified for this study. These studies were made in a vertical cross-section through the island of Voorne-Putten in the SW-Netherlands. This island was selected because it lies below sea level, and there is a certain amount of saline seepage there already. Also, investigations were made here earlier, providing essential data. The effect of sea level rise on saline seepage was simulated with the 2-D groundwater flow model MOC (Konikow & Bredehoeft, 1978) in cooperation with G. Oude Essink of the Technical University of Delft. Soil water dynamics and crop production were s i m u l a t e d using the SWAP model. SWAP is an i n t e g r a t e d s i m u l a t i o n tool consisting of SWACROP, a quasi 2-D model of the water (plus soluble salt) balance of a cropped soil including drainage and irrigation (Feddes et al., 1994), and WOFOST: a water-limited crop production model (van Diepen et al., 1988) made at the DLO-Centre for Agrobiological Research (CABO-DLO).
860 5.2
Methods
C l i m a t e scenarios To create a climate scenario, the methods were used t h a t are discussed in Section 2. Radiation, humidity and wind and the pattern of rainfall are assumed to r e m a i n unchanged. The increase in t e m p e r a t u r e used in the scenarios is 1 ~ resulting in a change to a n n u a l precipitation of-2% to +9%, depending on the temperature. The meteorological files of the years 1966, 1976, 1979, 1985 and 1986, r a n g i n g from very dry to very wet, were selected as input for the changed climate. Crop production and water use were calculated for these years, first without, then with the climate scenarios. The differences in production show the effect of climate change.
C a l c u l a t i n g crop p r o d u c t i o n with SWAP The island of Voorne-Putten, surface area 19025 ha., was divided into 761 subareas. Soil physical properties, open water levels, drainage properties, salinity and seepage rates, and land-use were collected for each subarea, 461 of which are cultivated. Production of the most frequently grown crops, potatoes, sugarbeets, w i n t e r w h e a t and grass, was calculated of the 461 subareas, for the five selected years, and calibrated with estimated actual harvests. Production and water use for the changed climate was then calculated by using the same years, changed by the climatic change. Higher temperatures will cause: maintenance respiration to increase; - plant organs to age faster, inhibiting daily increase and harvest total of dry matter; - t e m p e r a t u r e sums to increase faster, causing the crop to flower, m a t u r e and/or ripen (too) early. Higher atmospheric CO2 affects the crops (of the C3 plant type) by 4 i m p o r t a n t mechanisms (Wolf & van Diepen, 1993): - Leaf thickness increases, meaning specific leaf area decreases, - Light-use efficiency (crop production per unit radiation) increases, - Maximal assimilation rate increases, - The crop can absorb sufficient quantities of CO2 in a shorter time, keeping the s t o m a t a open for a shorter time, and so reducing transpiration. W a t e r use efficiency is increased this way. The simulations were done with the same crops, but with different crop-varieties assessed to give a realistic yield under the associated climatic conditions, by changing the physiological p a r a m e t e r s of the crop models, cf. Table 5.1 (BoonsPrins et al., 1993).
861 Table 5.1 C h a n g e s in p l a n t physiological p a r a m e t e r s to a d a p t to h i g h e r t e m p e r a t u r e s a n d raised CO2-1evels (from Wolf & van Diepen, 1993) specific leaf
light-use maximal temp. sum area efficiency assimilation (m 2.kg-1) (kg.ha-l.h-1 rate /J.m-2.s-1) (kg.ha-l.h-1)
temp.sum before flowering (~
surface until maturity (~
resistance (s m-l)
Winter wheat l'CO 2 2"CO 2
18.0 14.4
0.45 0.55
40 80
1048 1290
1258 1171
40
Potatoes 1"CO2 2"CO2
18.0 14.4
0.45 0.55
40 80
150 150
1550 1800
30
Grass l'CO 2 2"CO2
25.0 20.0
0.45 0.55
40 80
-
-
65
Sugarbeets 1"CO2 2"CO2
18.0 14.4
0.45 0.55
40 80
573 483
1909 2194
30
Groundwater flow modelling with MOC After several experiments, 3-D simulation of g r o u n d w a t e r flow was discontinued due to severe limitations of the available models. Instead, g r o u n d w a t e r flow was s i m u l a t e d in a v e r t i c a l l y oriented, 2-D cross-section t h r o u g h V o o r n e - P u t t e n , r u n n i n g w e s t to east, w i t h dimensions 200 m (depth) by 25 k m (length). The g r o u n d w a t e r flow model used was MOC (='Method Of Characteristics'), version 3.0 of 1989, w h i c h w a s developed by the US Geological S u r v e y (Konikow a n d Bredehoeft, 1978) as a t r a n s i e n t solute t r a n s p o r t model, including h y d r o d y n a m i c dispersion, t h r o u g h the horizontal plane. In order to suit the model for application in v e r t i c a l l y oriented cross-sections, it was a d a p t e d for d e n s i t y differences of g r o u n d w a t e r (Oude E s s i n k , 1993). In the model, the chloride c o n c e n t r a t i o n d e t e r m i n e s g r o u n d w a t e r density. The n u m b e r of grid cells is 100 (horizontal direction) by 20 (vertical direction); all cells are 250 m long by 10 m high. The g e o m e t r y of the geohydrological s y s t e m at the cross-section t h r o u g h VoorneP u t t e n is depicted in Figure 5.1. Geohydrological p a r a m e t e r s of the subsoil, initial salinities and b o u n d a r y conditions for g r o u n d w a t e r flow were derived from Wit (1987), DGV-TNO (1984), Oude E s s i n k (1993) and P o m p e r (1983). MOC requires the ratios t r a n s v e r s a l to longitudinal conductivity and dispersivity to be constant in the entire modelling domain; these were set to 0.1. Initial salinities following are shown in Figure 5.2. The following boundary conditions were imposed. The base is a no flow b o u n d a r y . Along the seaside and inland b o u n d a r i e s w h e r e h y d r o s t a t i c conditions are assumed, constant piezometric levels and salinities are m a i n t a i n e d , determined by m e a n sea level, w a t e r levels in bordering channels and the density of the water. Along the upper boundary, constant phreatic levels are m a i n t a i n e d in polder areas. These levels are determined by the w a t e r levels in open channels and
862 collector drains. At the sand dune areas a constant rate of groundwater recharge is maintained ( 180 mm.yr- 1).
C a l i b r a t i o n o f MOC The geometry of the island of Voorne-Putten imposes restrictions to the modelling of groundwater flow. Simulation accuracy in a 2-D vertical cross-sectional area is hampered by the fact that important boundary conditions to groundwater flow, i.e. pressure heads at the nearby n o r t h e r n and southern shorelines of the island cannot be incorporated in the model. Hence, calculated seepage rates will be lower t h a n observed ones, particularly in the central area of the domain where the effect of the inland and seaside boundary conditions of the groundwater velocity field are c o m p a r a t i v e l y insignificant. It was therefore decided to concentrate model calibration in the area bordering the seaside boundary where the effect of sea level rise was to be simulated. In addition, the area used for calibration was confined to the bottom layer of the upper aquitard and the first aquifer because of the high r e s i s t a n c e to flow of the lower a q u i t a r d (10000 d.; P o m p e r , p e r s o n a l communication). The calibration was made for seepage rates through the upper a q u i t a r d for the reference case, using the rates established by Wit (1987), by varying the kSAT of (groups of) model cells within ranges, derived from existing information (Figure 5.3). All seepage rates are averaged for specific subareas, mainly polders, with uniform open water levels. j -." / / ,~: ~ / y . .......... Northsea ..... i"
dikes
dunes / '\ "~ / \ \ polders 9t ~ ~ - . . . , - . - - , - ~ ~J//////////J//'///////J
(0.0 to -2.0 m) b e l o w s e a level ,___ \ 9 .... - .... ~,.......-;~,---,,---.................. = , , - ~ ~ ~ - ~ - ~ Spul uu_inK er_K e__ P_:_ ! _m_ult i p l e k's!j ~/~/z'/7-/7-/z~'/z/~/7"/7~,/7~/z/~, .........
~ X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X ~ - : I i f f I f l I ! [ I I ! : : , C a l agl s ( t ~])
>.
Kreftenheye
,
C :D
;
4--'
....:i: ...'.:"
m/d)!fi!:~///X/////y//J/J///'///'///'///'SJJ~J~
F. ( 2 0
'-
m/d)
~J 4_.,
~/////////////////////////////~/, Kedichem
F. ( 0 . 0 0 2
m/d)
m
o
,5 ""-7- c
d)
,. 9
.
.
..~ MOC cells (200~ 10
m)
<
25
~:'.~:f.~.'
SWAP
-.:! ,.~'. "" ....X :::::::::::::::::
prescribed
flux
prescribed
pressure
marine
Maassluis
profiles
F. ( 1 0
for
crop
production
and
salt
boundary
and
salt
m/d):
of
> ~2.ZZ~.ZT/7".~.~ " aquitard
(MOC)
boundaries
name
km
(MOC)
formation
---------(with
no--flow
boundary
hydrobia
layer
(0.01
m/d)
permeability)
Figure 5.1 The sub-soil of Voorne-Putten partitioned into aquifers and aquitards. The h y d r a u l i c conductivities were found after calibration. Vertical scale = 100*horizontal scale
863
5.3 R e s u l t s of s i m u l a t i o n s
Results of simulations of g r o u n d w a t e r flow and solute transport with MOC The effect of sea level rise on saline seepage was assessed by c o m p a r i n g the modelling results of two scenarios. Both simulations r u n for 100 years, from 1994 onward, one with a gradual sea level rise of 1.2 m, and one without sea level rise. Of these simulations, the differences in velocity and salinity of the g r o u n d w a t e r are compared in the upper soil s t r a t a where the effect on land use is most pronounced. Figure 5.4 shows the differences in g r o u n d w a t e r velocities between the two 100 y e a r s i m u l a t i o n s in mg/1. Velocities below 1.10-4 m d-1 are indicated by dots. Seepage i n t e n s i t y does increase, but r e m a i n s of m i n o r i m p o r t a n c e in the total w a t e r balance compared to the a m o u n t of fresh w a t e r deliberately let in to flush saline surface water. It was decided not to incorporate any changes in seepage rate a n d g r o u n d w a t e r salinity in the associated b o u n d a r y conditions for the crop production scenario studies.
Results of Crop Production Simulation Climatic change appears to have two opposite effects on crop production: while it tends to decrease due to higher respiration at higher temperatures, it increases due a longer growing season and to higher water-use efficiency at higher CO2 levels. The net result is increased crop production, as shown in table 5.2. Table 5.2 Crop production (tons (dm) ha-l) for 4 crops in 5 years, w i t h and w i t h o u t 1 ~ climate change, calculated with SWAP. (din = dry m a t t e r , min = m i n i m u m , m a x = m a x i m u m , avg = average, w a r m e r = with w a r m e r climate) Sugarbeets (t.ha-1 dm) year & climate
Potatoes (t.ha-1 dm)
Wheat (t.ha-1 dm)
min m a x
avg
min
max
avg
1966 11.1 15.4 w a r m e r 11.6 20.0
13.8 15.8
11.2 11.6
14.4 20.0
14.4 15.8
5.4 7.4
7.1 7.1 9.7 9.4
1.5 11.9 10.3 4.8 15.3 13.5
8.2 8.2
4.0 5.1
1.7 2.5
6.0 8.2
3.4 5.1
0.3 0.1
4.1 2.1 6.1 3.2
7.4 11.5 10.0 10.2 15.4 12.8
1979 7.7 14.6 w a r m e r 10.4 17.4
12.4 14.7
9.7 9.7
15.0 20.8
13.0 14.7
4.7 6.9 6.8 8.1 10.410.1
1.0 10.8 9.8 3.8 13.3 12.0
1985 7.9 14.5 w a r m e r 10.0 15.8
12.2 13.7
9.0 10.2
15.0 21.0
11.8 13.9
6.5 7.3 7.3 5.3 10.910.1
1.6 11.0 10.0 4.1 14.6 12.6
1986 warmer
9.8 12.3
4.4 4.5
12.2 14.3
6.9 7.4
2.8 7.3 6.3 2.3 10.0 7.2
3.2 11.2 10.0 7.5 15.3 13.4
1976 warmer
1.2 2.5
7.1 14.5 9.9 15.1
min m a x avg
Grass (t.ha-1 dm) min m a x
avg
864 ~lti~ti!i[:::~iiiiiii!;i!iL ~~~:.:~ -,~..-.-.._~/
...~:.::.:~.:~ . . . . . . . . . ~:~;;;- ::;
r'd " . . . . . . . . . . . . .
........
~ ~ e
.~~_
~o~~
............................... ..... . . .
~,,
..
:..
:!ii!::ii:i:!ii:!:!!i":::i::!:!::::!:::i:!- ::::!.i.:::::i:: :.::!:!:::: !:i:::":: . : i ::i : !::: .: ::":": ':.: " '::"::.":i:::::i: i:i:i:ii: ::::::""~_....'"":":' : :: mo.o
.-.
-
:::::::::::::::::::::::::ii.::i:i:iii!iii:.ii:i:!:~i!.:::.:.':::..:.i:i .: ..i:: :: i:..i ~!i::.: i: " : .::::i. .:..i::ii: .i::-:~i :ii!::i:i..i:!'::: :i.i.:i:i::... : ~-~".:::: ii:.
ii~i:i~;~i:i:~;:i:i.~:::~i.i.!~i i~:ii;!:.ii::~i .:. ~.~!:i:i :i~ i:::. :::~! i:i :~ .rT: ; :: :r:~..: ~.
!iiiiii"i
i!ili
:: .:ii:i :.:r%:i:!. Maa:sMs:-i
::!:'.~!:.
;i !:..::~::i.. :.:i!::. ::
i:ii ii:.::i::ii.:..i:ii
i.i:
i !:!:i:i ! ii !ii!!'li! !.i!~~~~,iil~i!i ii i':~1
',ii i!!i!ii!i!iii ii !~'
:::::::::::::::::::::::: :::::::::::::::::::::: :i.i:i:i: :..i:i:::::: :i.i-.:i:.:i..:i..:::i ::::::::::::::::::::::: :::::::::::::::::::::-:-:::~,~: :i.i: .i: :i:i:.:i:i.:.i:'.:i:i-'.:':i-i-i-:-...::'::::i:i:.-:: ::.. :i!!!iii!!:i!ili!!!i!il !! ! !:::!i!iiii!!i!i!iiiii!iii i:: i :ii :!iii!i!iiiii!:ii:i!.il :!! i i:i!!iii!i-iiiiii:iiiii:iii:i i:iil !ii: ii:!iii::!i:ii:ii!ii: iii:i !: .!!i :i!:i:!ii:ii:iiii:ii:i :::~i ii::!i!ii:iiiii:ii!:i[ ii !!! i~.:..!:!.'~i~~i.:i:.::iii..:!! I :: ! i: i: :~"~ i:!::ii::ii!i:il i~:~ iii:[ o.o
~.~
~.o
~.s
m.o
~2.~
Distance from Coastline (Kin)
is.o
i~.~
~o.o
~2.~
:,~.o
Figure 5.2 Isohalines of the groundwater (initial conditions) in the model MOC (mgfl)
2-
dunes
polders
1.5-
1 -
0.5-
(D 03 0Q_ (D r,P) -0.5 qD (_ 0 -lQ_
c~176
1............. : :............: i
[ Lt ........................ ................... i ............... ! '----:
-1 .5 0.0
21
.5
I
5.0
I
7.5
OLstonce
I
10.0
I
to
12.5
I
]5.0
CoostLLne
I
17.5
(km)
I
20.0
I
22.5
I
25.0
Figure 5.3 MOC-simulated seepage is compared to the seepage computed by Wit (1988) from field data. Calibration was only done for the polders close to the sea, to minimize the influence of the ignored raised open water to the north and south
865
:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::
:-:.:: :-:-].:!:!:!:i:i:!:!:i:!:i:i:!:?.iiiili!
-\
::~!~ii!ii~::~i~":i::~i~!ii;ii i ili::i~i!~ .i ;i~!!;~;i!~i~!i!!!:i:i:i:!:i:i:!:!
--/ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
:!:!:!:!:!:!:]:!~i:::'::!~!~i#~!~#:
' .........
. .9. .
[
I ........
~!:!:i:!:i:"i.-..!iii!~ii !:i:i:i:!:!:i:i:i
~ ....
'"
............
.9. . . . . . .
I" . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
........
......
[
.,.
.......
[ ......... ~.-
:.!.[:.[:t.[!.::[...~::.[,.i::;~i:.:!..:"t.;.
-. ".. i.:y "..=.11"...* .r,:-).~..:...::.::::..;
9 .
.
.
.
.
.
.
9
.
.
.......
::.~ .... :
:.;::.s~ : ..... >.:-.
.... ....
.....
.....
. 9. . . . . .
...
.
.
9
._~....._~..
:...:;; .......:
..
..
.
.
.
.
..
.
.
.
..
:= ....
. ...........
__~
9
.
.
"
......
I.
:....................
.
..'
:.
.....
.9. . . . . .
". . . . .
i..-
.............
~-,.._.
......
.
"
"
"
"
..............
. . :
-_ .....
- .......
i .....
". . . . . . . . . . . .
i!i ;i:iii!i. iii:i.li!ii.i.i.li:iii,!i.iil.i:;ii;:il i;iiiiill iiiiiiiil iiiii?ili .!.i.iii!ii! i;i.iiiiii ii.iiiil.i 9 _ _ _
9 . . . . . . . . .
......
.. . . .
. - ! _ . ! . - :
. . . . . . . . . . . .
,9 .....--.. ~.. ~ , ~ , . . . . . .
.9 . . . .
.........
- _ . _ :
_..-!
_-~ [. r--.-. [...~, [ i . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.....
.
.
:
.
~i . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
9
:.
..
...
'..
..
.
.
_}
200.0-' 2.5
6.0
~
.
" 7.5
"
~176 ~
12.6
20.0
~
~
i
~oo~__.
~__. 6 o o o
i.:.::'::~
.
~ooo.... . . . . .
i~o
. . . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
. . . . . . ..
.
::;..:.~ ~.~:~.::.
. .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
after
......
.
.
9
.
9
9 . .
.
: ...... "
i......
.
-
..
~
o
::.:: ~9 .
~I,--~
~
"
"
~
o
~
O
~0 -::---: :
'"
" .
......
:.
\
9
9
~
o
~:~:: . . . . . . : ~i ,=
with
and
"
'..
i
:
\
..
".':: . " "
'-.
9'
. . . .
'
9
~------,:.-:-,::-:-:~:.,---:.:--.--:--:::--.--,---: .... %--:.
....:..k.. ":
:.....~......:
:: ~
'.:.'..:i:.
:"?:.:.:::...:i::..
:
......,ed~.
~..:
.
::"..
~,
%.
[ . ..-,,:....
--,---:
.:.. :
:ii:i.: ~:..i....:?< '
....,
.,......:
9
.-.
.
,... .
\
9 >-,
::.%
9 : ......~::.. ~:.....i. :"ii.. ;i:
. .:... \
"
"
~
" ..".".i '.".
.
~ -, ~-7%=/-~
.'~:::~:~""::f":".~~'~".--"";, ,~.... 9
~.-: 9 .- .~.~: ,- ''~- .: ~ i.
I
~
o
"
...9
.
9
" "
.
%
.. "-,.,.,~ " " .'"i-4,
. . . . . .
"
9
'
~ ' %...k~.
'
.
9
.:
i".
9
" . ..
:
'
'
9 Maa,,
"
sluis
.
'
"'"%,
"
.~,~
.
..
.
"
"
~"
"
~,,,,,
...
"
"m_..~L... "--~oo_
.
. " % o 4 ~ . ~
...
.
,~,,,,~
.
~ooo <
"
"~
..
~oo
..~ ~ - - L _ _ = _
.
~
..
"
"
--~
-'~......
'
. "
9 :.
"',%o.._ .
.
"b%.
"~.
~ -
;
: " "
\%,
X.~
.. '
9 :.. .
9 9
. .
..:
.
" "
"
.
.
\"~.
9 ..
_~.~ "
.
--%
-~\
"
::.
.
k9
..
9
'
9
leO
',~.~ :. ":
7
'
9
~_~ i::
~i~...... :...."?.'~ :~.~4sooo
.~ :: ~
9.
..:
. i...
. .
. . .
......
..
.
.
.
[..
9.
9
9 9
..
. . . .
"
"
..
.
9 140.0
100 years,
.
.
:
1~o.o
26.0
.
.
..
.
o
22.,5
. 9
9
lOO
20.0
simulating
.. ~=J
~s
.
. .
9
17.6
(Km)
: ':
.
....~
.
.
.
9
~
i 9 e o . o .
,.......... 4 ~
- - - - - - - ~ ' ~ - ~ o o ~
:~:~'~!:.i~.~:
:.:::".:".:.:..::r;i.L[k!...v';:i:[.::[:~;.:.:::::::i~.:~i;:;.i : i:.:!.!; 9..i.::. :...~::..t:.:.:.~..~ i"[:.[i...:..:". . .
eo.o
Coastline
velocity-fields
~
....................................................................................
16.0
MOC
ll~~~':iiI"~::::, :~:.~...:., ~:::~".i"":~:.... i: ~ ~ . ~.~...'... ~ ' "
~
..~
......
from
~ ~: :.... , . ~ - ~ - ~ _ ~ ~ ~ , 9 ...
..
" "
10.0 Distance
Figure 5.4 Differences in groundwater without sea-level rise, with
L 9
..
" 0.0
..
..
.
.
. .9. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
:
__ 9
9
.
9
Figure 5.5 Groundwater salinity differences (%) after simulating 100 years, with and without sea-level rise, with MOC
866 5.4 I m p l i c a t i o n s A sea level rise of 1.2 m during the next century does not bring about a significant increase of saline seepage in the polders of Voorne-Putten. Instead, h u m a n intervention, i.e. m a i n t a i n i n g deep phreatic levels in these polders, and the associated land subsidence, are decisive in this respect. A temperature increase of 1~ and increased precipitation are favourable conditions for increased crop production rates, probably with only an occasional need of additional fresh water supply. If the increase of average temperature is greater than the assumed I~ it is likely that additional fresh water will be needed to balance increased evapotranspiration. Possibly the climate induced changes in the discharge regimes of the rivers Rhine and Meus will make it necessary to increase fresh water storage capacity. See also Section 6. Effects of changes of land use on agricultural water demands have been studied in Section 3. 6.
RIVER DISCHARGE
B. ParmetD, M. Raakl) and J. Kwadijk2) 1) 2)
Institute of Inland Water Management and Waste Water Treatment RIZA P.O.Box 9072, 6800 ET Arnhem, The Netherlands University of Utrecht P.O.Box 80.115, 3508 TC Utrecht, The Netherlands
Abstract Climate change influences the water balance of drainage basins in several ways. In a project of the International Commission for the Hydrology of the Rhine basin the possible consequences for the discharge regime of the Rhine are investigated. In the first phase of this project detailed models have been developed and applied for selected sub-basins and a rough water balance model has been developed for the whole Rhine basin. In this study results are presented for climate scenarios a s s u m i n g an increase in t e m p e r a t u r e of about 3~ and an increase in a n n u a l precipitation. The consequences of such a climate change are largest in the Alpine part of the Rhine basin, but are also considerable for the basin as a whole. In general the Rhine changes towards a rain-fed river. The winter discharge increases, which can have consequences for safety, and s u m m e r discharge decreases with consequences for shipping, industry, agriculture and nature. 6.1 I n t r o d u c t i o n Climate change influences the components of the water balance of drainage basins in several ways. Precipitation patterns may change and because of a higher t e m p e r a t u r e also the accumulation and melt pattern of snow. Evapotranspiration is directly influenced by an increase in temperature. In this respect also adaptions of the physiological behaviour of plants to an increased CO2-concentration are important. Changes in these water balance components will of course affect the discharge. Furthermore climate change may induce changes in land use, which is an important factor in evapotranspiration and runoff processes.
867 The river Rhine is economically the most important river of Western-Europe. Its drainage basin, see figure 6.1, covers from the source in Switzerland to the mouth in the North sea, an area of 185.000 km2 and is habitat to over 50 million people. The river is one of the most intensively navigated inland waterways in the world and is of major importance for the supply of w a t e r to large socio-economically i m p o r t a n t areas. Changes in the discharge regime can have consequences for safety and for the w a t e r availability for shipping, i n d u s t r y , domestic use, agriculture, the n a t u r a l e n v i r o n m e n t and recreational purposes. If possible changes are known, counter measures can be formulated to minimize negative effects. Against this background, the International Commission for the Hydrology of the Rhine basin (CHR) initiated in 1989 a project to assess the consequences of climate and land use changes for the discharge regime of the river Rhine. Since a proper tool for this was lacking, the main purpose of the project was to develop a water m a n a g e m e n t model for the whole Rhine basin. This model should be suitable to analyze the changes of total discharge and its distribution over the year as well as changes in height and frequency of discharge peaks. At the same time it should also be used to examine the effectiveness of counter measures. Several institutes from the Rhine r i p a r i a n states cooperate in the project (Parmet, 1993a). The Netherlands contribution is incorporated in the NRP. 6.2 M e t h o d The w a t e r m a n a g e m e n t model for the Rhine basin h a s to m e e t several requirements. To have a certain g u a r a n t e e it is also valid u n d e r the changed conditions it will be used for, the model m u s t have a physical basis. This is especially true for those processes t h a t are directly influenced by changes in climate and land use. This implies that the spatial variability within a basin must be t a k e n into account. To be able to simulate peak flows, a m i n i m u m temporal resolution of one day is required. In mountainous areas this has to be even smaller. In view of the complexity of the area and consequently of the model, it has been decided to phase the project. In the first phase different models for representative drainage basins of characteristic parts of the Rhine basin m u s t be developed. The Rhine basin has therefore been divided in three more or less distinct areas, the "alpine", the "middle mountains" and the "lowland" area. The relevant hydrological processes differ within these areas, for example snowmelt in mountainous areas versus g r o u n d w a t e r flow in the lowland. To give in short t e r m p r e l i m i n a r y estimations on the effects of climate change, in the first phase also a rough model for the whole Rhine basin m u s t be developed. In a second phase the models it is planned to improve, extend and combine the models.
Since reliable information on climate change is not yet available, climate scenarios have to be used (see Section 2). Developments in land use are, if possible, even more uncertain t h a n changes in climate. Hence also for this p a r a m e t e r scenarios have to be used, which are described in Section 3. The first phase of the CHR project is almost finalized. Several hydrological models have and are being developed but also existing models have been applied for relatively small representative basins. For the alpine area an existing hydrological model, the IRMB model, was applied for several small drainage basins (Bultot,
868 1992, Sch~idler 1992). This model computes the evapotranspiration, snow cover and melt and discharge on a daily basis. Because of the temporal resolution, it is not suited to simulate peak flows in mountainous areas. Therefore a w a t e r m a n a g e m e n t model is being developed with a time step of one hour, based on a hydrological forecasting model for the Swiss part of the Rhine basin. In the middle mountains area, a hydrological model is being developed for S a u e r basin, a sub-basin of the Mosel. This model has a very detailed spatial resolution and can operate on hourly and daily basis. The model is not yet operational. For another sub-basin, the Saar, in the near future an existing model will be applied. The lowland model is being developed for the drainage basin of the Overijsselsche Vecht ( P a r m e t , 1993b). The hydrological component of the model is used to compute the daily evapotranspiration and discharge for sub-basins. It consists of a g r o u n d w a t e r model, an u n s a t u r a t e d zone model and a rainfall-runoff model. The flow-routing component of the model combines the sub-basins and routes their discharges towards the mouth of the Overijsselsche Vecht. For the Rhine basin as a whole the w a t e r b a l a n c e model R H I N E F L O W was developed (Kwadijk, 1993). This model is designed to study the sensitivity of the discharge of the Rhine and its main tributaries for a climate change. It is a simple w a t e r balance model based on a Geographical Information System. Computations of evapotranspiration, snow melt and discharge are carried out for grid cells of 3*3 km on a monthly basis. 6.3 R e s u l t s
Effects of climate change, representative basins; Alpine area With the IRMB model the effects of a climate change for several components of the w a t e r balance were simulated for three drainage basins, Murg, Ergolz and Broye. A climate scenario as defined by Bultot was applied (Bultot, 1988). The m o n t h l y t e m p e r a t u r e and precipitation changes are given in table 6.1. The average t e m p e r a t u r e increases with 2.8~ and the annual precipitation with 54 mm (5%). Also changes in net terrestrial and global solar radiation and cloudiness are assumed. Changes in physiological behaviour of plants were not t a k e n into account. Computations were carried out for the period 1981 to 1988. Table 6.1 Monthly t e m p e r a t u r e (T) and precipitation (P) according to the Bultot scenario, used for representative alpine basins and a scenario based on the method developed by the KNMI, used for the representative lowland basin Month
J
F
M
A
M
J
J
A
S
O
N
D
TBultot, ~ 3.1 PBultot, % 1) 10 TNRP, ~ 3.0 PNRP, % 21
3.4 14 3.0 20
3.4 11 2.3 15
3.1 10 2.3 13
2.8 -1 2.3 5
2.7 -2 3.7 12
2.5 -2 3.7 11
2.3 -2 3.7 9
2.3 0 3.4 3
2.7 6 3.4 8
2.8 10 3.4 19
3.2 10 3.0 18
1) The percentual change is an average for the three basins Murg, Ergolz and Broye
869 According to the computations annual potential evapotranspiration increases with about 10%. Actual evapotranspiration increases somewhat less because during the s u m m e r period there is a slight decrease in soil moisture. Discharge increases during the winter period with about 10%. This is due to the fact that the amount of precipitation increases and less precipitation is stored as snow. F u r t h e r m o r e the a c c u m u l a t e d snow melts faster. The duration of the snow cover decreases considerably, especially below an altitude of 1500 m. Discharge in spring decreases slightly with 1%, and in summer discharge decreases with about 15%. This follows from less snowmelt, a larger e v a p o t r a n s p i r a t i o n and a slight decrease in precipitation. The total annual discharge hardly changes. The daily m a x i m u m discharge increases and the daily minimum discharge decreases.
Effects of climate change, representative basins; lowland area For the lowland area, climate scenarios were generated with the method developed by the KNMI within the NRP (see Section 2). In the same way as for the study to the water balance of forest (Section 4), a precipitation scenario was constructed based on the KNMI-2 method, with a t e m p e r a t u r e increase of about 3~ and unchanged air pressure. This resulted in an increase in annual precipitation of 13%. The monthly changes in precipitation and temperature are given in table 6.1. Compared to the other scenarios used in this study, this scenario is r a t h e r wet. Computations were carried out for a sub-basin of the Overijsselsche vecht basin, the Radewijkerbeek, for the period 1965-1990. On the one hand to stay in line with the results of other CHR-studies presented here, and on the other h a n d to illustrate its possible effects, computations have been carried out without and with taking into account changes in plant physiological characteristics. Without considering adaptions of plant physiological properties, referred to as scenario 1, the increase in t e m p e r a t u r e results in an increase of the actual evapotranspiration with 11% (55 mm). The annual increase in precipitation of 13% (102 mm) exceeds the increase in evapotranspiration, hence the precipitation excess increases. Consequently the annual discharge increases. From 6.1 it can be seen t h a t this increase is 16% (scenario 1). The winter discharge increases with 21% and the summer discharge increases too, with 9%. Although the effect of the increase in evapotranspiration is largest during summer, it does not exceed the increase in precipitation. As in the alpine areas the annual amplitude of the discharge regime increases. With this wet climate scenario no increase of problems with water shortages is expected. However the maximum discharge for the period 1965-1990 increases considerably with 29%. With this scenario problems with water surpluses could therefore be expected. As an example the daily discharge is given in figure 6.2 for present and for scenario 1 for the year 1981. The figure clearly shows the increase in the peak flow in March.
870 40 35 3O e- 25
.,.."~i .i
r (3
~-9 20 .__ "0
(D
c~ 15 E
r-
o
10
year
winter
summer
maximum
III scenario 1 ~ scenario 2 9scenario 3 t Figure 6.1 Changes in discharge characteristics for the Radewijkerbeek, for computations with changed climate, NRP scenario (scenario 1), with changed climate and adapted plant physiology (scenario 2) and with changed climate and changed land use (scenario 3), for the period 1965-1990 12 10
-
"0
E E
6
133 L_
-f•
4
0
I
9
I
Ib
__
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
Month
I-------Reference
situation "
"
" Scenario 1 I
Figure 6.2 Daily discharge of the Radewijkerbeek for the reference situation and for computations with changed climate, NRP scenario (scenario 1), for 1981
871 An increased CO2-concentration influences plant physiology. For most plants the w a t e r use efficiency increases and the biomass production increases. An increase in t e m p e r a t u r e for the t e m p e r a t e zones generally leads to an increase in production too (see also Sections 3, 4 and 5). Whether the increase in production exceeds t h e i n c r e a s e in w a t e r use efficiency a n d c o n s e q u e n t l y how e v a p o t r a n s p i r a t i o n changes, is not yet clear. Present knowledge indicates, for doubled CO2-concentrations and an increase in t e m p e r a t u r e of about 1.5 ~ C, a small decrease in evapotranspiration for most crops and forests (Roetter en van Diepen, 1994; Hendriks, 1994). For forests, even with a t e m p e r a t u r e increase of 3~ e v a p o t r a n s p i r a t i o n m a y decrease, as shown in Section 4. Based on this knowledge, plant physiological p a r a m e t e r s were provisionally a d a p t e d in the lowland model. Computations with the same climate scenario as used for scenario 1 (see table 6.1), but with adapted plant physiological characteristics, were carried out for the period 1965-1990. These computations are referred to as scenario 2. The actual evapotranspiration increased with 7%. This increase is 4% less t h a n for scenario 1, which can be explained from the increased water use efficiency of crops. Consequently the increase of the net precipitation excess is larger. The a n n u a l discharge increases therefore more, instead of 16, with 23%. The differences between scenario 1 and 2 with respect to the winter discharge are relatively small, as can be seen from figure 6.1. During this season evapotranspiration plays a minor role (see also Section 4). The increase of 25% is somewhat larger. The effects of a smaller increase in evapotranspiration strongly affect the s u m m e r discharge. Compared to scenario 1 this increases considerably more, 21% instead of 9%. The influence on the m a x i m u m discharge is small, since in such s i t u a t i o n s evapotranspiration plays a minor role.
Effects of climate change, Rhine basin C o n s e q u e n c e s for the whole Rhine b a s i n have been c o m p u t e d w i t h the R H I N E F L O W model. The sensitivity of the discharge regime was examined with a wide range of climate scenarios for the period 1956 to 1980 (Kwadijk, 1993). Here the results of computations with one scenario, the socalled BAU-best scenario, are presented. As already indicated in Section 2, this scenario in general agrees with the scenarios used for the representative basins in the alpine and lowland area. It a s s u m e s an a v e r a g e rise in t e m p e r a t u r e of 3.5~ and a small change in precipitation in s u m m e r and an increase of winter precipitation (see table 6.2). Changes in the physiological characteristics of plants were not taken into account.
872 Table 6.2 BAU-BEST scenario for t e m p e r a t u r e (T) and precipitation (P), for different areas in the Rhine basin (Kwadijk, 1993) P a r t of Rhine basin
North Middle South
Year
Summer
Winter
T,~
P, %
T,~
P, %
T,~
P, %
3.5 3.5 3.5
11 8 7
2.9 2.9 2.9
4 -1 -4
4.3 4.2 4.1
19 19 19
For the alpine part of the Rhine basin, the changes as computed with R H I N F L O W have the same direction as the results for the representative alpine basins. As can be seen from figure 6.3, the discharge during winter increases. This is caused by increased precipitation and snow melt. During s u m m e r the discharge decreases due to a smaller contribution of melt water, increased evapotranspiration and a slight decrease in precipitation. The increase in winter discharge is much larger t h a n for the representative basins, up to 100% with an average of 60%. This can be explained partly from the used scenarios. Both the increase in t e m p e r a t u r e and in precipitation is smaller for the Bultot scenario compared with the BAU-best scenario. F u r t h e r m o r e it can be explained by differences in model components, especially the snow component, and off course the considered area is not the same. The changes during s u m m e r are comparable, both for the alpine area as a whole and for the representative basins in the alpine area, a decrease of about 15% was computed. The changes for the area downstream, the middle and lowland part, are much less pronounced. The discharge increases during winter and spring and decreases during s u m m e r and a u t u m n , as can be derived from figure 6.3. The i n c r e a s e in evapotranspiration causes the soil water deficit to increase. As a result, s u m m e r d i s c h a r g e decreases, but because p a r t of the w i n t e r s u r p l u s is stored as groundwater, not until July. The water surplus during a u t u m n is partly used to replenish soil water, which explains the decrease of discharge during a u t u m n . Because the scenario used for the representative basin for the lowland is wetter, especially for the s u m m e r period, t h a n the BAU-best scenario, the changes in discharge are not directly comparable.
873
100 80 g
60
o
40
~
20
c
~
0
-20
-40
t
11
t
I
t
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
12
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Month Alpine part
-
-
-
Middle part & lowland - ' -
-
Rhine basin outlet I
Figure 6.3 Changes in monthly discharge for the alpine part, the middle and lowland part and the outlet of the Rhine Basin, for computations with the BAU-best scenario, for the period 1956-1980 Where the Rhine enters The Netherlands, near the basin outlet, the changes in the alpine, middle and lowland part are combined. The annual changes are small, the discharge increases with 2%. However, winter and spring discharge increase with about 15%, and s u m m e r and a u t u m n discharge decrease with about 10%. Due to the changes in the alpine area the character of the river Rhine changes from a combined rain-fed/snow-fed into a rain-fed river. The discharge pattern will become less smooth and the difference between m a x i m u m and m i n i m u m flows will increase. The n u m b e r of months with low flows will increase. For example the n u m b e r of months with an average discharge below 1000 m3/s increases for the period 1956 to 1980 with 13, which is about 60%. To make an assessment about peak flows with the monthly discharges computed by R H I N E F L O W , a relation b e t w e e n a v e r a g e m o n t h l y flows and peak flows was derived (Kwadijk en Middelkoop,1994). This relation can be applied with a sufficiently small reliability interval for discharge peaks up to 7000 m3/s. Therefore the relation can be applied for the s t u d y to s e d i m e n t a t i o n processes in the river and floodplains (see Section 8). The considered period is however too short to give fundated results for the design discharge, and hence about consequences for safety. However, model results indicate t h a t the critical discharge (recurrence time of 1250 years) related to the safety s t a n d a r d of the river dikes may increase, with a m a x i m u m of 1500 m3/sec (Kwadijk en Middelkoop, 1994).
Effects o f l a n d use change The effects of changes in land use on discharge characteristics have been studied only very roughly. A first assessment showed t h a t for the entire Rhine basin the impact of land use changes on the river Rhine discharge were smaller t h a n climate
874 changes according to the Business as Usual scenario (Kwadijk,1993). The land use schematization of the model RHINEFLOW is very coarse, and in its present form it is not very suitable to study the effects of land use changes. F u r t h e r m o r e the land use scenarios for the Rhine basin as described in Section 3, were developed only very recently. Computations have therefore just been carried for the lowland area, for the sub-basin of the Radewijkerbeek. A land use scenario was generated based on the "Minus" projection for the region Netherlands- East. In this scenario in total 35% of the agricultural land is vacated. This is divided over potatoes (75%), s u g a r beets (-60%), cereals (-35%), maize (-50%) and grass (-30%). In total 10% of the agricultural area is changed into nature, the remaining 25% into forest, equally divided over coniferous and deciduous forest. The urban area, which is very small in the Radewijkerbeek sub-basin remains constant. Computations with this land use scenario were carried out for the period 1965-1990. Climate conditions w e r e a d a p t e d according to the KNMI-2 scenario. P l a n t physiological characteristics were not adapted. The c o m p u t a t i o n results, referred to as scenario 3, show an i n c r e a s e in e v a p o t r a n s p i r a t i o n of 15%. Compared to scenario 1 this is 4% larger, which is m a i n l y caused by the increase of the area coniferous forest. In Figure 6.2 the changes in discharge characteristics are given for scenario 3. Not surprisingly the increase in a n n u a l discharge is smaller t h a n in scenario 1. The increase is 9% compared to 16% for scenario 1. The effect of the increased evapotranspiration is of course largest during summer. Although the increase in precipitation still exceeds the increase in evapotranspiration, the increase in s u m m e r discharge is only 3% for scenario 3, compared to 9% for scenario 1. The effect of the increased a r e a of coniferous forest is also visible during winter. The total a m o u n t of interception of precipitation increases, and therefore the increase in discharge for scenario 3 is smaller t h a n for scenario 1, 15 respectively 21%. For the flat lowland area changes in land use mainly influence evapotranspiration. Since the extreme discharges are mainly determined by precipitation, the increase in m a x i m u m discharge for scenario 3 is comparable with scenario 1. The effects of the land use scenario are smaller t h a n those resulting from the climate scenario, but are still considerable, especially for total discharges.
6.4 Implications I n t e r i m r e s u l t s of the CHR project show t h a t climate change can h a v e considerable effects for the discharge regime of the Rhine. With the a s s u m e d scenario for the Rhine basin, the winter discharge increases considerably. This could have consequences for safety, but the models are not yet suitable to assess consequences for maximum peakflows. The contribution of water originating from snow melt from the Alps during the s u m m e r period decreases, which is an i m p o r t a n t r e a s o n for a d e c r e a s e in s u m m e r d i s c h a r g e . F u r t h e r m o r e evapotranspiration is expected to increase, which contributes also to a decrease in s u m m e r discharge. Consequently the frequency of periods with low flows increases. It should be noted that in the RHINEFLOW study the effects of increased CO2 on w a t e r use have not yet been taken into account. This would probably result in a reduced increase in evapotranspiration of agricultural crops and for forests even in a decrease as concluded by Lankreijer (1994). However this is not expected to have a large influence on the conclusions with respect to low flows, since the w a t e r originating from snow melt is dominant in such periods and Lankreijer (1994)
875 shows t h a t for dry years even for forests evapotranspiration increases. For water m a n a g e m e n t in The Netherlands an increased frequency of low flows implies increasing costs for shipping. Ships can be loaded less and have to wait longer for sluices and bridges. Costs of electricity production will increase too. To avoid e n v i r o n m e n t a l problems with the t e m p e r a t u r e of cooling water, other more expensive, production units have to be brought into operation. More frequent intrusion of salt water can cause problems for intake of water of certain polders. This m a y cause damage to agriculture. In general the changed discharge regime will also influence river morphology (see Section 8). The effects of land use changes have not yet been studied in detail. From first computations it can be concluded that for lowland areas the total discharge rather than peak discharges will be affected. For the alpine and middle mountains area it is expected that also the peak flows are influenced. Further study is required. The model R H I N E F L O W in its present form is a useful tool for sensitivity analysis. However, the simple process descriptions and the poor quality of the underlying database, limit its applicability. On the other hand the detailed models are only available for a relatively small part of the Rhine basin. To extend these models for the whole basin is a time consuming task. Therefore a promising direction is to couple the rough and the detailed models, for example with transfer functions. RHINEFLOW has to be refined in time and space for this. Furthermore the detailed models have to be applied also in other characteristic areas, to cover the variability within the Rhine basin in a better way. It is recommended to investigate the possible effects of climate change also for other i m p o r t a n t river systems, like the Meuse. A similar approach as in the CHR project can be applied. The largest u n c e r t a i n t y in climate change impact studies has to do with the climate scenarios. For decision makers the u n c e r t a i n t y interval of possible impacts should be as small as possible. It is therefore very i m p o r t a n t t h a t the development of consistent and plausible climate scenarios continues. 7.
EROSION Catchment basin
M. van der Drift and F.J.P.M. Kwaad Laboratory of Physical Geography and Soil Science, University of Amsterdam. Nieuwe Prinsengracht 130, 1018 VZ Amsterdam, The Netherlands Abstract Major source areas of the suspended sediment load of the river Rhine have been identified and the relationship between soil structure stability and climate in selected s e d i m e n t source areas has been studied. The location of the m a i n sediment source areas has been assessed with a mass balance method. Important source areas appeared to be the Aare basin and the Neckar basin. The influence of temperature on soil erodibility was investigated by comparing relevant properties of the same loess derived soil types under different meso-climatological and land
876 use conditions. No correlation of soil structural stability with climate could be established. 7.1 I n t r o d u c t i o n Each y e a r on average 3.1 million tons of suspended s e d i m e n t e n t e r The Netherlands via the Rhine. About two thirds of this sediment is deposited in The Netherlands. The other one-third reaches the North Sea, part of which moves along the Dutch coast to the Wadden Sea. This suspended sediment has important consequences for management and policy development which relate to: - the sediment budget of the lower courses of the Rhine, including the embanked floodplains ('uiterwaarden'), - the sediment budget of the Delta waters, the Dutch part of the North Sea and the Wadden Sea, - the scale of m u d dredging works in the Rhine, including the R o t t e r d a m harbours, - problems of water quality and pollution caused by chemicals (heavy metals, toxic organic compounds, nutrients) adsorbed to suspended sediment particles and present in recent mud deposits.
The suspended sediment load of the Rhine derives from erosion of the beds and banks of the river and its tributaries, but mostly from the valley side slopes and the sloping interfluve areas between the numerous first and second order branches of the Rhine system. The sediment from the valley side slopes and the interfluve areas is t r a n s f e r r e d to the river channels by a set of processes, collectively referred to as the 'slope forming processes'. These include processes of slope wash under n a t u r a l vegetation and processes of accelerated soil erosion (sheet and rill erosion) on agricultural land. The occurrence and rate of soil erosion is controlled by a number of factors, viz. ability of rainfall to cause erosion (erosivity), resistance of the soil to erosion (erodibility), length and steepness of slopes and land use. Climate change may, directly or indirectly, affect all of these factors. For this study the impact of climate change on soil erodibility was selected, because this is an under-developed research area. Soil erodibility is primarily controlled by soil structural stability. Climate affects soil structure through its influence on the organic m a t t e r status of the soil, which depends on biomass production and soil (micro)biological activity. Soil structure is characterized by the presence of soil aggregates, clusters of soil particles which m u t u a l l y adhere by chemical and physical binding forces. In surface soils, these forces are mainly controlled by organic matter. Macroaggregates (>250 ~m) are mainly stabilized by plant roots and larger fungi. Microaggregates (20-250 ~m) are bound together by decomposed organic substances. Micro-aggregation in the size class 2-22 ~m is mainly caused by clay particles, and to a lesser extent by organic materials. The rate of structure development and structure breakdown is dependent on the dynamics of soil organic matter, which, in turn, is controlled by soil moisture and soil temperature regime. The impact of climate change on soil erosion will be largest where soils are most susceptible to erosion. A class of soils that are highly sensitive to erosion, are loess soils, which are wide-spread in the Rhine basin. Objectives of research were: (a) to identify the main source areas of the suspended s e d i m e n t load of the Rhine under present-day climatic conditions, and (b) to
877 analyze the influence of t e m p e r a t u r e on soil erodibility in selected source areas of suspended sediment. The approach was a comparative study of soil erodibility in different parts of the Rhine basin with different temperature conditions under the current climate. Existing differences in erodibility between areas with different t e m p e r a t u r e regimes are an indication of the change in soil erodibility t h a t will possibly occur as a consequence of climate change. Starting date of the research project was 1st J a n u a r y 1993. Duration is two years. In this report results of the first year of study are summarized. On the global level the research project is related to three IGBP core projects which deal with the hydrological and geomorphological study of soil erosion and river basin dynamics: - L a n d - O c e a n I n t e r a c t i o n s in the Coastal Zone (activity: c a t c h m e n t basin dynamics and delivery), - Biospheric Aspects of the Hydrological Cycle (activity: biospheric control of waterborne transport, and integrating waterborne transport at the river-basin scale), - Past Global Changes (effects of climate and h u m a n impacts on the biosphere). On the national level there is a strong relationship with the research projects carried out at the State University of Utrecht and Rijkswaterstaat/RIZA. This concerns the study of the w a t e r balance and water discharge of the Rhine basin, the movement of sediment in the Rhine, the sedimentation rate of suspended solids on the e m b a n k e d floodplain of the Rhine and Meuse, and their sensitivity to climate change (Asselman and Middelkoop; Parmet et al., this volume). 7.2 M e t h o d s
Location o f s u s p e n d e d sediment sources The suspended sediment t h a t enters The Netherlands at Lobith originates from the part of the Rhine basin between the Bodensee and Lobith (see figure 7.1). This part of the Rhine basin has a surface area of roughly 159,000 kin2 which shows a wide range of climatic, geologic, geomorphologic and pedologic conditions. The river itself is regulated by man. Sediment is trapped by weirs and in n a t u r a l and manmade lakes. In some cases sediment is removed from the river system by dredging. It was outside the scope of the project to locate the origin of the suspended s e d i m e n t w i t h the aid of t r a c i n g or f i n g e r - p r i n t i n g t e c h n i q u e s involving mineralogical or chemical analyses. Instead, a mass balance approach was followed. The basis of such an approach is given by long-term m e a s u r e m e n t s of daily w a t e r discharge and suspended sediment concentration at a n u m b e r of stations along the Rhine and its main tributaries. The differences in sediment load between m e a s u r e m e n t points are due to contributions from sediment sources between m e a s u r e m e n t points or to losses due to sedimentation (and dredging) between points. This method does not differentiate between n a t u r a l and h u m a n sources of sediment. Therefore, additional data of the suspended sediment output of the w a s t e w a t e r s of the F r e n c h P o t a s s i u m Mining (MdPA) were used to complete the balance.
878 t"~
I 120 km
THE
/ NETHERLANDS ~'" LO61TH~." 9
N
Laco~
Neuchatel
9
SWITZERLAND
Figure 7.1 -~-~" The Rhine basin u p s t r e a m of Lobith (The Netherlands). Figure adapted from Kwadijk and Middelkoop (1994)
I d e n t i f i c a t i o n o f c l i m a t e effects on soil s t r u c t u r e s t a b i l i t y The effect of climate on soil structure was studied on a meso-scale by comparing loess soils on north and south-facing slopes and on a macro scale by comparing loess soils from a part of the Rhine basin with a more continental climate (Kraichgau) to a part with a more maritime climate (Nordrhein-Westfalen), while keeping other environmental factors, such as geology and topography, constant. Besides climatologically induced variations, also differences in soil s t r u c t u r e between land use types (arable land and forest) and between topsoil and subsoil were investigated (see figure 7.2). Soil samples were tested on presence of lime, organic carbon content, aggregate stability (drop test), soil texture and micro-aggregation (Microscan). With statistical methods of data analysis (cluster analysis, Analysis of Variance, MannWhitney U-test) differences between groups of samples were evaluated (Van der Drift, 1994).
879
Continental climate loess soils
Different aspect and altitude [arable soils
forest soils I
> Isubsoilsl
Maritime climate loess soils
Different aspect and altitude l arable soils
forest soils I
> Isubsoils]
Figure 7.2 Schematic representation of field sampling strategy 7.3 R e s u l t s a n d c o n c l u s i o n s Sediment
sources
The major sources of suspended sediment in the Rhine have been identified from the s h a r e of the s e d i m e n t a m o u n t at Lobith in table 7.1. Rate of erosion (ton/ha/year) is calculated by dividing this share by the area of the river basin. This is an indication of the severity of erosion in the catchment. The sediment loads of the sources u p s t r e a m of Iffezheim (km.334) are reduced with 40% for sediment retention upstream of the dams in the Rhine. Of the h u m a n sediment sources, the industrial waste-waters from the French potassium mining and G e r m a n soda industries contribute to nearly 0.5 Mton suspended sediment/year at Lobith, or 15% (corrected for sedimentation). The n a t u r a l sediment sources in the Rhine basin are characterized by a yearly cycle: in s u m m e r the Aare is the main contributing river; in winter and spring the Neckar, Main and Mosel have a strong influence. If we look at the annual totals of table 7.1, the Swiss Aare system is an important source of suspended sediment, with a corrected mean annual contribution of 0.55 Mton/year, which is equal to an average soil loss of 0.3 ton/ha/year. The Main has the second-highest sediment contribution (0.5 Mton/year), but a slightly lower erosion figure t h a n the Neckar, which delivers a mean annual sediment output of 0.45 Mton, or 15% of the load at Lobith. This m e a n s a soil loss of 0.3 ton/ha/year. No data were available for a separate calculation of the contribution of the Mosel and the Lahn.
880 Table 7.1 Major sources of suspended sediment in the Rhine
Source
Sediment load Mt/y
A m o u n t at Lobith* Mt/y
erosion+ %
Bodensee Thur Aare,Reuss,Limmat Trib. Basel-Maxau Neckar Main Mosel and L a h n Trib. Maxau-Rees MdPA Other industries Households Algae
0 0.2 0.91 0.16 0.45 0.50 0.70 0.17 0.65 0.09 0.02 0.01
0 0.12 0.55 0.096 0.45 0.50 0.70 0.17 0.39 0.09 0.02 0.01
0 3.9 18 3.1 15 16 23 5.5 13 2.9 0.65 0.32
Total
4.32
3.1
100
ton/ha/year
0 0.7 0.3 9 0.3 0.2 0.2 9 n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a.
*: corrected for sedimentation u p s t r e a m of dams (40%) .: unknown +: calculated from 'amount at Lobith' n.a.: does not apply D a t a w e r e received from t h e B u n d e s a n s t a l t ffir Gew~isserkunde, Koblenz, Germany
Soil s t r u c t u r a l stability a n d soil erodibility S u m m a r i e s of aggregate stability analyses with the drop test m e t h o d are given in tables 7.2 - 7.5. No statistically significant difference in aggregate stability w a s found b e t w e e n two climatologically different p a r t s of the Rhine b a s i n (Van der Drift, 1994), a l t h o u g h the d a t a s u g g e s t t h a t soils in a n a r e a w i t h a m o r e continental climate have more stable aggregates t h a n soils under a more m a r i t i m e climate. The t e s t s give an indication of the p r e s e n t state of soil s t r u c t u r e . This does not exclude a difference between the development of aggregate.
881 Table 7.2 S u m m a r y of drop-test data for Kraichgau and NRW topsoil samples, May-June 1993. Statistics are listed for all samples, and arable land only Region Average AS St. dev. AS St. skewness AS Number of samples
Kraichgau
arable
NRW
arable
1.08 0.873 3.39 25
1.27 0.557 - 0.0867 15
1.55 1.02 0.630 14
1.75 0.961 -0.135 4
Table 7.3 Summary of drop-test data for topsoil samples from arable and forest soils, MayJune 1993 Land use Average AS St. dev. AS St. skewness AS Number of samples
Arable
Forest
1.46 0.874 2.65 25
0.850 0.943 2.64 14
Table 7.4 Summary of drop-test data for topsoil and subsoil samples, May-June 1993 Soil horizon Average AS St. dev. AS St. skewness AS Number of samples
Topsoil
T-arable
Subsoil
S-arable
1.011 0.690 1.68 34
1.37 0.661 0.657 19
2.49 1.22 -0.405 6
2.65 1.58 -0.607 3
882 Table 7.5 S u m m a r y of drop-test data for topsoil samples from North- and South-facing slopes, May-June 1993 Aspect
South
S-arable
North
N-arable
Average AS St. dev. AS St. skewness AS N u m b e r of samples
0.771 0.543 0.612 12
1.16 0.593 -0.142 9
1.05 0.556 0.942 12
1.47 0.725 1.07 8
AS = index of aggregate stability; NRW = Nordrhein-Westfalen (Source of tables 7.2 - 7.5: Van der Drift, 1994)
Stability, due to differences in climate On a micro scale, aggregates are slightly more stable on south- and southwestfacing slopes (warm, dry) compared with northerly- and n o r t h e a s t e r l y exposed slopes (cold, moist). However, this difference was not large enough to become s t a t i s t i c a l l y significant. If soils with different land use are compared, the conclusion d r a w n from the M a n n - W h i t n e y test (Van der Drift, 1994) is t h a t aggregate stability is highly influenced by differences in land use. Soils with agricultural land use have a less stable structure t h a n forest soils. Forests are different from arable fields: they have a more shady, constant, t e m p e r a t e and moist climate, which results in more organic matter, with a different composition. Not only the amounts of organic matter, but also the composition and dynamics of organic materials, including soil biologic activity are important controlling factors of soil structure. This is in agreement with the fact that the topsoils have a more stable s t r u c t u r e t h a n subsoils. The soil processes which are responsible for soil structure formation and stabilization, are strongly dependent on fluctuations and range of soil temperature and soil moisture.
I m p l i c a t i o n s a n d recommendations From the results of the first year of study it can be concluded, t h a t a t e m p e r a t u r e change of 3~ in the Rhine basin probably will have no profound effect on soil structural stability and soil erodibility. This does no exclude an impact of climate change on soil erosion and sediment production in the Rhine basin. Sediment production on agricultural land will increase in s u m m e r due to higher rainfall intensities which strongly control the rate of soil erosion (Kwaad, 1991). For instance, a 40% increase of m e a n hourly rainfall intensity will occur, when mean day t e m p e r a t u r e rises from 20 to 23~ (Klein T a n k and KSnnen, 1993). Runoff and soil loss from agricultural land will increase in w i n t e r due to an increased probability of occurrence of s a t u r a t i o n overland flow (Kwaad, 1991), caused by a 19-20% increase of w i n t e r rainfall (KSnnen, this volume). Land use changes, such as foreseen for the decade 2040-2050 by P a r m e t (this volume), viz. a 20-24% decrease in area of agricultural land, will lead to a decrease of sediment production in the Rhine basin, if this 20-24% surface area is forested
883 and if the reduction of the area of crop land is not counteracted by an increased rate of soil loss per ha of remaining crop land. Increased winter discharge volumes and increased daily m a x i m u m discharges of the Rhine, such as mentioned by P a r m e t et al. (this volume), m a y lead to accelerated remobilization of sediment stored as alluvium along the Rhine and its tributaries, e.g. the so called 'Auelehm'. On the other hand, decreased s u m m e r discharges and decreased daily m i n i m u m discharges m a y lead to increased s e d i m e n t a t i o n in the channels of the Rhine system, because these decreased discharges coincide with increased sediment production on the slopes of the Rhine basin due to more intense and more frequent local summer thunderstorms under a warmer climate. A first s e m i - q u a n t i t a t i v e approximation of the impact of climate change on sediment production in the Rhine basin has been made by Van der Drift et al. (1994). From this it appears that sediment production is very sensitive to climate warming. It is therefore recommended to investigate more quantitatively the effect of climate change on the processes, factors and rate of soil erosion in the sediment contributing landscape units of the Rhine basin. 8.
T R A N S P O R T AND S E D I M E N T A T I O N
N.E.M. Asselman, H. Middelkoop and H.J.A. Berendsen Department of Physical Geography, University of Utrecht Heidelberglaan 2, 3508 TC Utrecht, The Netherlands Abstract Erosion, transport and deposition of fine suspended sediments are both directly and indirectly influenced by changed climate conditions. Changes in sediment transport rates were studied using sediment rating curves in combination with flow duration curves, developed using the BaU-climate scenario and four sediment t r a n s p o r t scenarios. All sediment transport scenarios show t h a t an increasing part of the yearly sediment load will be transported at discharges over 4000 m3/s: about 20% under present climate conditions increasing to about 40% when climate changes in accordance with the BaU-scenario. Three aspects of floodplain sedimentation have been studied: (1) past and present sedimentation rates, (2) the impact of climate change on future sedimentation rates and (3) heavy metal pollution of sediment. Floodplain sedimentation shows a high variability in time and space. Depending on site characteristics, present sedimentation rates range between 0.5 and 15 m m per year. At the beginning of floodplain formation, sedimentation rates probably were 3 to 4 times as high as at present. A climate change according to the BaU scenario will lead to a considerable increase in floodplain sedimentation rates in The Netherlands. Depending on the floodplain morphology, however, local changes in sedimentation rates will vary strongly; the expected increase will therefore range between 1% and >100%. The quality of the sediment is still a m a t t e r of concern. Although the heavy metal contamination has considerably decreased since 1970,
884 accelerated future sedimentation will accumulate considerable a m o u n t s of pollutants on the floodplains in The Netherlands. 8.1 I n t r o d u c t i o n The expected climatic change will affect erosion, transport and deposition of suspended sediments of the river Rhine. Concerns are not only related to the impact of environmental and climatic changes on transport and sedimentation of suspended sediments, but also to transport and deposition of sediment associated pollutants. Within the scope of the National Research Program (NRP 1) the impact of climate change on discharge, production, transport and sedimentation of suspended sediment by the river Rhine have been studied. The BaU-best scenario as given by Kwadijk (1993) was used to represent future climate conditions. The impact of climate change on the hydrology of the river Rhine was studied by Kwadijk (1993) and Parmet et al. (Section 6). The study on the effects of climate change on the suspended sediment budget of the river Rhine can be subdivided in three stages. (1) Erosion or production of sediment, that can subsequently be transported into the river. Van der Drift identified the major source areas of the suspended sediment transported by the river Rhine. He also studied the effect of climate and land use change on soil erodibility. (2) A sediment transport stage, d u r i n g which the s e d i m e n t particles are t r a n s p o r t e d d o w n s t r e a m . (3) Sedimentation in the lower course of the river and the delta area and, during high discharge periods, on the embanked floodplains along the river.
A rough estimate of changes in sediment production by soil erosion was obtained by using the USLE rain erosivity factor in combination with the BaU climate scenario (Section 2) and land use scenario (Section 3). This study was carried out by Van der Drift, Middelkoop and Asselman (1994). Transport and deposition of suspended sediment were investigated in two separate NRP studies which are reported here. In the first project, carried out by Asselman, the relation between suspended sediment transport rates and discharge is investigated. The objectives of this study are: to investigate the processes of sediment transport through the river Rhine, to assess the effect of climate change on suspended sediment transport rates, depending on changes in discharge and sediment supply to the rivers. In de second project, carried out by Middelkoop, the sedimentation on the embanked floodplains is investigated. Past and present sedimentation rates are reconstructed using various methods, and the possible effects of climate change on future floodplain sedimentation are assessed. The objectives of this study can be summarized as follows: Assessment of the rate of sedimentation on the embanked floodplains in The Netherlands in relation to flood-frequencies during the past decennia, and centuries. Assessment of quantitative relationships between (1) floodplain morphology, (2) the characteristics of flood periods and (3) sedimentation rates. E valu atio n of possible effects of climate change on future floodplain sedimentation.
885 8.2 M e t h o d s
Transport of suspended sediment The amount of fine suspended sediment (wash load) transported by the river Rhine depends on the availability of loose material and to a lesser extent on the capability of the river to transport this material. Unlike bed material load, wash load is a non-capacity load, which implies that sediment transport rates cannot be calculated using stream power related transport formulas. Instead, the so-called rating curve technique was used to study the effect of changes in discharge on the amount of suspended sediment transported through the river. A sediment rating curve describes the average relation between discharge and suspended sediment concentration. This relation is often described by a power function. In this study a power function with additive constant term was used: C=P+a*Qb where c is suspended sediment concentration (mg/1), Q is river discharge (m3/s) and a, b and p are regression coefficients. The sediment rating curves can be used to obtain information on the availability of sediment in a certain area in combination with the erosive power of the river itself. Steep rating curves (low a- and high b-values) are characteristic for river sections with little sediment transport taking place at low discharge. An increase in discharge results in a large increment of suspended sediment concentrations, indicating that either the power of the river to erode material during high discharge periods is great, or that important sediment sources become available when the water level rises. Flat rating curves are characteristic for river sections with intensively weathered materials or loose sedimentary deposits, which can be transported at relatively low discharges. The constant p-coefficient can be seen as a background concentration, a minimum concentration of suspended sediment occurring at very low discharges. In this study, sediment rating curves were developed for various locations along the river Rhine, using the daily measurements of water discharge and suspended sediment concentrations, measured by the Bundesanstalt fiir Gewasserkunde (BfG), Germany. The sediment rating curves were combined with flow duration curves to obtain sediment discharge curves, showing the effectiveness of different discharge intervals in transporting suspended sediment. Changes in the sediment discharge regime were studied using the changes in monthly discharges of the river Rhine given by Kwadijk (1993) and Parmet et al (Section 6). A relationship between monthly and daily water discharges was obtained following the method used by Kwadijk and Middelkoop (1994). The newly obtained flow duration curve was combined with different sediment rating curves to obtain the sediment discharge curves. Different sediment rating curves were used, corresponding to assumed changes in sediment production in the Rhine basin. A rough estimate of long term average changes in suspended sediment production by soil erosion in the Rhine basin under BaU climate and land use conditions was made using the Universal Soil Loss Equation (USLE), developed by Wischmeier and Smith (1978). It was assumed that only arable land substantially contributes to the production of fine sediment by soil erosion. The effect of climate change is calculated from changes in the rain erosivity factor (R) in the USLE. The
886 estimations of future soil erosion under changed rain erosivity are therefore assessed by changes in both the total amount and intensity of rainfall under the BaU climate scenario. F u t u r e rainfall intensities are calculated from changes in t e m p e r a t u r e s according to Klein T a n k & KSnnen (1993). The effect of changes in land use (Veeneklaas et al., 1994; Section 6) on soil erosion is calculated from the expected changes in the total area of arable land. The results are described in Van der Drift et al. (1994); the changes in annual suspended sediment load t h a t are used for the sediment rating curves are shown in table 8.1. For Rees, n e a r the D u t c h - G e r m a n border (figure 8.1), the following s e d i m e n t transport scenarios were used: 1) Sediment loads are determined by hydraulic properties of the river, sediment production in u p s t r e a m areas has no direct effect, la) The p r e s e n t r a t i n g curve remains valid under changed climate conditions; total yearly sediment load will change, lb) Background concentrations will change u n d e r changed climate conditions; total yearly sediment load remains constant. 2) Sediment loads are determined by the erosion rates in u p s t r e a m parts of the river basin. Changes in erosion rates are influenced only by changes in precipitation and temperature, no land use scenario is used. 3) Sediment loads are determined by the erosion rates in u p s t r e a m parts of the river basin. Differences in precipitation, temperature, and land use are t a k e n into account. 4) Sediment loads are determined by the erosion rates in u p s t r e a m parts of the river basin. Changes in erosion rates are the result of changes in land use. No climate change is t a k e n into account. This scenario is used as a reference scenario to evaluate the effect of climate change under changed land use conditions. In this case land use changes are assumed to be independent from climate change. THE
Figure 8.1 v Location of the gauging stations
"~ '' /
~
I~O krn
887
Analysis o f s e d i m e n t from dike-breach p o n d s For the reconstruction of temporal variations in sedimentation rate during the past 200 300 years, sediment accumulated in dike-breach ponds was analyzed. These sediments can have a thickness of more t h a n 5 m. They often show a lamination of light and dark coloured humic clay. These laminations are believed to represent (yearly) floods. In order to correlate these laminae to floods and minor climate changes in the past, they were dated using the Pb-210 method. Analysis of the h e a v y m e t a l contamination of samples from the dated sediment profiles allowed to make a reconstruction of the pollution history of the river Rhine. -
Floodplain s e d i m e n t a t i o n rates on various time scales For a better interpretation of expected future changes in floodplain sedimentation rates, the spatial and temporal variability of the present and past sedimentation rates were investigated first (figure 8.2).
zwo,,e
.
E
9 e o ~'
O
m
. .
=
~
.E_
X
X ,,
X
X
X
X
X
X X
~~" ~ Gorkum
. , ~ , ~ ~ , , ~ ~ ~ ~"
O ~ .~ " .-.
Lobith .."....
,
X
X = method applied at floodplain section
floodplains
Figure 8.2 Study area and location of investigated floodplains A. Present sedimentation rates. Present floodplain sedimentation rates and their spatial variability were m e a s u r e d after the two floods of 1993 and one in 1994 using about 800 sediment traps made of artificial grass. In the laboratory, the (dry) sediment from the traps was weighed, and the grain size distribution and organic m a t t e r content were determined. The results from the individual traps were interpolated to create r a s t e r maps of sediment accumulation, sand content and organic m a t t e r content. The patterns shown on the maps were correlated with floodplain morphology and sedimentation mechanisms (Asselman & Middelkoop, 1993). B. Sedimentation rates during the past decennia. In several floodplain sections with different elevations and distances to the main channel, soil samples from vertical profiles were collected and their heavy metal content was measured. The heavy metal content of floodplain soils was related to floodplain morphology and flood frequency. The sedimentation rates during the past 50 - 100 years were
888 reconstructed by comparing the heavy metal profiles in the floodplain soils with the pollution history of the Rhine (determined from the dike-breach ponds). In addition, the sedimentation rates of several profiles were assessed using the Pb210 method.
C. Sedimentation rates since the formation of the embanked floodplains. Old river maps provide a rough indication of the beginning of sedimentation on the enclosed floodplains. The total amount of accumulated sediment can be assessed by means of corings. Flood durations can be calculated from records of historic water levels. Using this information a simple model was made to estimate the average yearly sedimentation on several floodplains (Middelkoop & van der Perk, 1991).
A s s e s s m e n t o f the i m p a c t o f c l i m a t e change on f l o o d p l a i n s e d i m e n t a t i o n rates A. Assessment of the impact on floodplain inundation times. U s i n g the R H I N E F L O W model, the changes in monthly Rhine discharges were assessed for the BaU scenario (Kwadijk, 1993; Parmet et al., Section 6). From the relationship between monthly discharges and daily discharges, changes in peak discharge probabilities and exceedance times were calculated (Kwadijk & Middelkoop, 1994). These were used to assess future floodplain inundation times. B. Assessment of local sedimentation rates using a sedimentation model. The effect of climate change on the s e d i m e n t a t i o n rate on one floodplain was i n v e s t i g a t e d u s i n g the ( 2 - d i m e n s i o n a l ) W A Q U A - D E L W A Q m o d e l of R i j k s w a t e r s t a a t (Dutch M i n i s t r y of T r a n s p o r t , Public Works and W a t e r Management). Calibration of the model was carried out by simulating the flood of J a n u a r y 1993 of which the sedimentation rates were measured using the sediment traps. Also, the average sedimentation rates over the past 50 years reconstructed from heavy metal profiles of the floodplain soil were used to calibrate the model. The sedimentation rates under changed climate conditions were assessed by using the sediment discharge curves in correspondence with the BaU climate scenario. C. Sensitivity of large scale potential sedimentation rates.Complementary to the detailed model study for a small area using WAQUA-DELWAQ it was tried to estimate the sensitivity of floodplain sedimentation rates for the Rhine (Waalbranch) embanked floodplains as a whole. At this scale it is not possible to take physical flow and sedimentation processes into account. Instead, two estimators for potential floodplain sedimentation were introduced. The term potential s e d i m e n t a t i o n is used because the estimators do not calculate real sediment deposition, but they are a measure of the a m o u n t of sediment available for deposition. The first estimator calculates for each discharge interval the product of the corresponding (1) total floodplain area over which sediment flows, (2) the suspended sediment concentration and (3) the relative frequency of occurrence. The summed totals for all discharges gives the average yearly figure, expressed in km2*kg/m3/yr. The second estimator uses total volumes of water over floodplain areas and calculates the total average yearly load of suspended sediment present over floodplains, expressed in tons/yr.
889 The effect of the BaU discharge scenario and four sediment rating scenarios on the estimators has been calculated to investigate the possible impact on floodplain sedimentation. 8.3 R e s u l t s
Transport of suspended sediment The relationship between discharge and suspended sediment concentration shows considerable scatter. Some of this scatter can be the result of inaccuracies in the field or in the laboratory, seasonal effects, antecedent conditions in the river basin and differences between falling and rising stages. To reduce the scatter separate rating curves were developed after subdividing the data according to season, stage and wet or dry years. However, since this hardly improved the rating relationship, rating curves were developed using all data. The sediment rating curves developed for various gauging stations are shown in figure 8.3. It can be seen that the steepness of the rating curve decreases in downstream direction, indicating that near the Dutch-German border large quantities of fine material are available for transport at relatively low discharge. The importance of high discharge on suspended sediment transport decreases in downstream direction.
250
-
/ / ."
/" /
2O0
,"
,"
/,."
/,'"
E ,27" ,~"
150
///
_
100
-
I -o
/
/
..,.:'"
/
l.l : " Rhelnfelden (kin 145)
.)" .
/"
.
, . ' / ' / "/
///
i
. . . . .
Maxau (krn 362)
.........
BacharacWKaub (kin 545)
. . . . . . .
Welssenthurrn/Andernach
. . . . . . .
Rees/Emmedch (kin 837)
(kin 607)
.'/"
/ ." / 5O
I
0 o
~ .
I
.
oo
I
.
.,..-
oo
.
,,.-
I
oo
~
I
~
~
I
oo
o
o~
I
oo
~
o3
I
oo
o
,,r
I
oo ~
dlscharge
II
oo o
o
o
~
u3
I
oo o
co
I
oo ~
I
oo o
I
oo ~
r-.
I
oo o
co
I
oo
~
I
~ 2
I
oo
~
o~
oo
o o P
(m3/s)
Figure 8.3 Sediment rating curves developed for various gauging stations along the River Rhine
890 Sediment discharge curves for the river Rhine near Rees were developed using the flow duration curves in combination with the sediment rating curves developed for present and future climate conditions. The sediment discharge curves are shown in figure 8.4. The results of the different sediment transport scenarios are also given in table 8.1. Table 8.1 Sediment transport rates using four sediment transport scenarios scenario
P
Present la lb 2 3 4
29 29 24 32 15 18
p total load >4000 >6000
= = = =
Total load % and (Mt/yr) 100 115 100 122 78 71
>4000 % and (Mt/yr)
(3.09) (3.55) (3.09) (3.77) (2.41) (2.20)
20 35 37 35 42 22
>6000 % and (Mt/yr)
(0.62) (1.24) (1.14) (1.32) (1.01) (0.48)
5 (0.15) 17 (0.60) lS (0.56) 16 (0.60) 20 (0.48) 6 (0.13)
background concentration (mg/l) % of present total yearly sediment transport percentage of total sediment load transported at Q>4000 m3/s percentage of total sediment load transported at Q>6000 m3/s
Steepness of the rating curve is kept constant with a = 1.96"10-5 and b = 1.93 500000000
T
450000000 ~L
/ / ~
/,~" ~ ' \ . X
"c" 400000000 T
~ ~ooooooo~ om ~oooooooo~
/'<" ~'-'A .'\ li"/ .--"'--.. "%.,
2sooooooo t
,I,'/
/
-o
c
~oooooooo Jr
. ooooooo
oooooooo +
,//,' /
#.'/,-"
, ,
\
\
-\\'\
.... - \
-,~<\
\:,.~ -.
"
1.'
,,,,,/," /!//
.
" \\
\
h',~ ,~
5ooooooo +A~S//
\ : " ~-'~-~.~. ~
~
~ -':- L:"":~
- :2..: .'~. ~____:.~_..,._,.~:~
o in Discharge
..................... present
. . . . .
scenario la
.......
~
scenario 4
scenario 3
(m3/s)
.........
scenario lb
.......
scenario 2
Figure 8.4 S e d i m e n t discharge curves developed for Rees according to t h r e e s e d i m e n t transport scenario's
891 Scenario 1. According to the first sediment transport scenario, suspended sediment concentrations only depend on hydraulic properties of the river and t h u s on discharge. The effect of climate change can therefore be s i m u l a t e d using the sediment rating curve based on measurements of the last 15 years in combination with the flow duration curve according to the BaU scenario. The resulting sediment discharge curve shows t h a t more suspended sediment will be transported both at very low discharge (Q < 1500 m3/s) and at high discharge when inundation of low lying floodplains occurs (Q > 4000 m3/s). If the present sediment rating curve is used (scenario la), total suspended sediment load will increase by 15%. If the total load r e m a i n s the same (scenario lb), background concentrations will decrease from 29 to about 24 mg/1. Scenario 2. When changes in soil loss due to climate change are investigated using the BaU scenario for changes in rainfall amounts and rainfall intensities while land use is assumed to r e m a i n unchanged, sediment production will increase by 22% (van der Drift et al., 1994). The increased sediment load can result in h i g h e r background concentrations, occurring at low discharges. If the steepness of the sediment rating curve remains the same, background concentrations will increase from 29 to about 32 mg/1. Scenario 3. W h e n changes in soil loss u n d e r the BaU climate scenario are combined with a land use scenario with a 23 to 48% decrease in area of arable land, sediment production will decrease by 22%. This means t h a t even if the steepness of the rating curve changes, the background concentration will decrease. This can be explained by the trapping of sediment behind weirs. During s u m m e r discharge will decrease, which might result in increased sedimentation behind weirs during s u m m e r time and lower base flow concentrations near Rees. During the winter, more high discharge periods will occur and much of the sediments deposited behind weirs will be flushed out, leading to higher concentrations in the river during high discharge events, as shown by the increased value of the b-coefficient. If the steepness of the rating curve changes, background concentrations will decrease to 18 mgfl or less. If the steepness of the rating curve remains the same, expressed by the unaltered values of a and b, the background concentration (p) will decrease to 15 mg/1. Scenario 4. In scenario 4 the effect of changes in land use without a climatic change is studied. As a result of a 25 to 42% decrease in arable land, the total suspended sediment load will decrease by about 29%. If the steepness of the rating curve r e m a i n s the same, background concentrations will be about 18 mgfl. A similar background concentration was found for scenario 3. The most i m p o r t a n t difference occurs in the sediment discharge curve. According to scenario 4 only 22% of the total sediment load (0.48 Mt/yr) is transported at discharges over 4000 m3/s. When changes in land use occur in combination with changes in climate (scenario 3) about 42% of the total yearly load (1.02 Mt/yr) is t r a n s p o r t e d at discharges of 4000 m 3]s or more. This difference is mainly the result of changes in the flow duration curve. High discharges will occur more often under BaU climate conditions t h a n under present climate conditions.
From the scenarios is can be concluded t h a t the expected change in land use has a stronger impact on the yearly production of suspended sediment t h a n the BaU
892 climate scenario. However, due to the changes in the flow duration curve, a climate change will have a much stronger effect on possible floodplain sedimentation. The effect of climate change under changed land use scenario will be about the same as under present land use conditions.
A n a l y s i s o f sediment f r o m d i k e - b r e a c h p o n d s Although the sediment shows a clear lamination, it is difficult to correlate this to individual floods and hence to fluctuations in flood frequencies. This is because local sedimentation rates are the results of a combination of flood duration, inundation depth, sediment concentration and local flow patterns. It is virtually impossible to reconstruct these in detail for historic times. Using historic dates, Pb-210 dates, palynological information and variations in sediment compaction a time/depth curve of the sediment could be made. Using this as time control the heavy metal pollution of the Rhine sediment during the last 200 years was reconstructed (figure 8.5). This diagram shows t h a t the heavy metal pollution strongly increased during the first half of this century; maximum pollution occurred between 1960 and 1970, since 1970 the heavy metal pollution has strongly decreased. Cd,
~ 50
0
Cu,
Pb (mg/kg)
100
200
. . . .
!
F; .... i ..... i--,::]-"-,~,-:~
100
~!~~1,
150
:
',
k..- ,'~
,,
,
!:',.-r, ~ i
200
,, j
~. . . . . 4. . . . . 4-%,.-; . . . . . ',
. . . . ; . . . . . ~ : , . - - ~. . . . . . r - - - r ,, ~ , ;-~ : . : E'q l I * ',m l :
~~
..... i ..... i ..... ! ..... ! ..... 1 1980
---~ . . . . . ~. . . . . 4. . . . . . 14
13
300
....
', ....
',
.;-"
.--; ..... ,, : l l :
,
,
i
i
l l
',
1960 I
~. . . . . ~. . . . . . ,, ,, : : : :
i
i
i
h~ 1940
102o
..... !......i ..... i..... I-.+-::ti ..... t
400
450
Ii_IIilii i i . . . .
i . . . . . i . . . . . . ',:-. . . . . i . . . . .
............................
--"--
z.
i ....................
i iI
""" .....
500 0
Figure
8.5
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
zn (mg/kg)
Heavy metal pollution history of the river Rhine reconstructed from a dike-breach pond near Wamel
F l o o d p l a i n sedimentation rates on various time scales A. Present sedimentation rates. The sediment accumulation maps show clear patterns in spatial variability (figure 8.6). During a flood, large amounts of sandy s e d i m e n t with low organic m a t t e r content are deposited on the levees. The sediment accumulation decreases exponentially with distance from the river. This
,,,iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii ,,
893
::! 9 if:: iiii!iiiiiiiii!!i!
iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii ii!iiiiiii!ii~ii!!i
:!:!:~',!:!:~: :.:..,:.:.:,.,:.:.: ::::::::::::::::::: .........
> 0.8 kg/m2 0.80 0.70 0.60 0.50 0.40 0.30 0.20 0.00
,.::::~
Study
m~t
'Keenf
a. Keent.
iiii!iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiimiiiiiiiiii ::
ii!i!i?!!iii!iii!i;iii)iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii?iiii.;ii:: :
2.26 kg/m2 1.99 1.73 1.46 1.20 0.93 0.67 0.40 0.14
. . . . . . .
Study
area
~ili~: i:i=:i;:ii
'V'triksche Plaat'
b. Variksche Plaat. floodplain
~
former floodplain protected by river dike
{...........'".. escarpment
major river dike
~
......
minor river dike
.
.--
woe
groyne
_
_ V
a
r
i
~
Figure 8.6 E s t i m a t e d s e d i m e n t a c c u m u l a t i o n after block kriging. Grid cell size = 10 x 10 m2
b''h
894 gradient is mainly caused by the amounts of deposited sand; no gradient was found in the amounts of silt and clay. The amounts of sand deposited j u s t behind the levee show a high spatial variability. If a floodplain has been completely s u b m e r g e d for several days, local depressions have almost no effect on the sediment deposition. The amounts of sediment deposited on different floodplains can vary considerably. Observed average values after the flood of december 1993 range between 1.0 and 6.6 kg/m2, equivalent to 0.8 respectively 5.4 mm. These differences between floodplains seem mainly related to the flow pattern of the water during inundation. During minor floods, when a floodplain is inundated only during a few days, the p a t t e r n of sediment accumulation is much more related to local differences in elevation and inundation times than during large floods. The amount of deposited sediment is far less than proportional to the magnitude of the flood. This implies t h a t minor floods contribute considerably to the yearly floodplain sedimentation rate. From the results of the individual floods, the present average yearly sedimentation rates will be estimated for different floodplain sections. This part of the study is still in progress.
B. Sedimentation rates during the past decennia. The heavy metal profiles obtained from the floodplain soils generally have the same shape as the pollution curve reconstructed from the dike-breach pond sediments. Profiles from floodplains with high sedimentation rates have a higher pollution in the upper 10 cm and have a higher total pollution. Also the maximum concentration is greater and is found at greater depth. The results show that the total soil pollution can be very different from the pollution in the upper 10 cm. A one-dimensional sedimentation model is being developed that simulates the floodplain sedimentation with contaminated sediments. Using this model the sedimentation rates will be reconstructed. The average sedimentation rates during the past decades obtained from the Pb-210 samples range between 1.6 and 0.1 cm/yr. C. Sedimentation rates since the floodplain formation. This method applies to lateral bars and can be used in a limited number of undisturbed floodplains. At the beginning of the floodplain formation the sedimentation rates varied between 1 and 3 cm/year, which is 3 to 4 times as great as at present. Two examples are shown in table 8.2.
895 A. Klompenwaard: 1800 - 1990
B. Variksche Plaat: 1860 - 1990
year
elev. (m a.s'l.)
sed. rate (mm/yr)
year
1800 1850 1900 1950 1990
10.6 11.2 11.7 12.0 12.3
16.0 11.0 7.6 6.2 4.8
1860 1900 1950 1990
N
i
elev. (m a.s.I.)
sed. rate (mm/yr)
4.5 5.4 6.1 6.5
30.0 18.0 11.0 8.5
Ame.m 2 KL'*I~ ~
~ .....~::
~iTme~e'/
.::~-".....
Lobith ,,........
[iiiiiiiiii
i] floodplains
KL = Klompenwaard VP = Variksche Plaat
Table 8.2 Reconstruction of average yearly sedimentation rates using historic data; two examples
A s s e s s m e n t o f the i m p a c t o f c l i m a t e change on f l o o d p l a i n s e d i m e n t a t i o n rates A. Assessment of impact on floodplain inundation times. The effects of climate changes on the Rhine peak discharge frequencies and exceedance times according to the AP and BaU scenarios are given in Section 6. The BaU scenario causes a significant increase in inundation times of floodplains. B. Assessment of local sedimentation rates using a sedimentation model. A proper calibration of the WAQUA/DELWAQ model requires more d a t a on actual sedimentation than those obtained of the flood of J a n u a r y 1993, and preferably for l a r g e r a r e a s t h a n the V a r i k s c h e Plaat. Therefore, also the s e d i m e n t measurements of the December 1993 flood will be used for calibration. Preliminary results of the model indicate that the sedimentation rates on the Variksche Plaat under the BaU climate scenario increase by only 1% if the sediment concentration of the Rhine only depends on hydraulic conditions. Sedimentation rates increase by almost 20% when increased sediment production is taken into account. The effect of climate change for this particular floodplain seems to be insignificant. The main reason for this is that in floodplains directly bordering the main channel only minor amounts of sediment are deposited during high discharges since the flow velocities are then too high for sedimentation. The increase in sedimentation rates will be
896 larger on floodplains t h a t are separated from the main channel by a s u m m e r dike and w h e r e relatively large a m o u n t s of sediment are deposited d u r i n g high discharges.
C. Sensitivity of large scale potential sedimentation rates. The BaU scenario has a strong impact on the potential floodplain sedimentation (figure 8.7 and 8.8). According to the estimator using sedimentation areas, potential sedimentation rates will increase by a factor 1.5 to 2, depending on the sediment rating scenario. The effect on the estimator using sediment volumes is even larger: potential sedimentation rates will increase by a factor 1.7 to 3. When scenario 4 (only land use change) is t a k e n as a reference, potential sedimentation m a y increase by a factor 2.5 respectively 4.5. As demonstrated by the WAQUA/DELWAQ model study of the Variksche Plaat, the increase in the amounts of sediment t h a t really will be deposited may be less large. This strongly depends on the morphological properties of the floodplain sections. For a proper estimate a further analysis of t h e s e d i m e n t a t i o n process u s i n g s e d i m e n t t r a p s and models such as WAQUA/DELWAQ is required in different types of floodplains. 25
:i~~... ~:-i ::-!--!-i-::,/], ~. ~-~;i~i
20
:
:
:
:
! ..........
=--~176176 " =~
:',:ILII~,:"~-~L!"::"',
. .:_ .:- - :. - -:- - :- - -:- - : - i ~ )
\-:
- ~ ~ , ~ \ -
.~
9
'~ ' ~' ~ - ~ ~ -~
,. - -:- - : - -:- - :- -
=
=~
--!--:--;--:--:---:-';A;~~-i--~--:-:--<~!--:--:--i ! i . ---i _i._:_ ii_.',. .... _::__ .::__::__....
i_
5
i_
0
o
~
~
o
o
o
o
o
o
o ,~
o
~
o ,o ~~
o ,~
o
o
o
discharge at Lobith
Rhine
o ,o
o
o
o
o
o ,o
o
o
o
o
o
(m31s)
Figure 8.7 Expected yearly area of sediment influx * sediment concentration as a function of discharge for different scenario's - river Waal 0.05
.
.
v~
o.o,
0o,
8.8
.
.
.
i
:: ~ ! :: :: :: ::
.
.
. '.
- , - - . - - : ~ - : - - : - - , . ...... ? ~ / : - ,'~<~ - : - -
oo o ~ Figure
.
I~'esen!
.
~::::
.
.
.
. . ' .
:_. i.: :..i__ : ' :~~i--:--~--:' "u
: .
.
.'
---
,
~:~~~
.
.
:::::= Rhine discharge
.
.
.
'
.
:!
1
'
- "'" : - - : -
.
.
~ ! ~ ~
: ~ : at Lobith
'
.
.
9 '
:
.
~~.
~ - : ~
(m3/s)
Expected yearly sediment load present above inundated floodplains as a function of discharge for different scenario's - river Waal
897
8.4 Implications According to all sediment transport scenarios a larger part of the yearly sediment load will be transported at discharges over 4000 m3/s, when inundation of low lying floodplains occurs. Under present climate conditions about 20% of the yearly sediment load is transported at discharges over 4000 m3/s, this will be about 40% when climate changes according to the BaU scenario. Under present climate conditions about 5% of the total sediment load is transported when all floodplains bordering the Dutch part of the river are inundated (Q>6000 m3/s); this will be over 15% when climate changes. If no measures against soil erosion are taken by reducing the area of arable land or by soil conservation programmes, the production of sediment will increase. Increased, sediment production will lead to about 20% higher concentrations of suspended sediment at low discharges. When the area of arable land decreases, background suspended sediment concentrations will decrease by some 40%. The amounts of suspended sediment transported at discharges when all floodplains are inundated is hardly affected by the expected changes in land use. The increase in sediment load, transported at high discharge is mainly the result of changes in the discharge regime. Floodplain s ed iment at i on is a complex process. It depends on floodplain characteristics, discharge frequency distributions and sediment concentrations, and therefore shows a high variability in time and space. Depending on site characteristics, present sedimentation rates range between 0.5 and 15 mm per year. Present sedimentation rates are 3 to 4 times as low as they were in the past when the floodplain surface was 1 to 2 m lower and flooding occurred more frequently. This implies that removal of summer dikes and lowering of floodplain surfaces as proposed in nature rehabilitation plans will strongly increase sedimentation rates. The effects of climate change on floodplain sedimentation, as evaluated using the BaU scenario can be considerable. This is mainly caused by an increased frequency of high discharges. As the relationship between effective discharge and the area of inundated floodplains is non-linear, even minor changes in discharge and sediment concentrations will have a strong effect. As a result, the potential floodplain sedimentation is very sensitive for the BaU discharge and sediment rating scenario conditions. The effective sedimentation rates may be different, depending on the morphology and type of floodplain. On floodplain sections directly bordering the main channel and without a summer dike, changes in sedimentation rates are relatively unimportant. However, the effect on floodplains t h a t are situated behind a summer dike, is expected to be relatively high. As it was found that floodplain sedimentation is highly variable in space and during individual floods, predictions on future sedimentation rates cannot yet be done with high accuracy. Further analysis on the effective sedimentation on different types of floodplain sections is therefore required. A p a r t from the sediment quantities, sediment quality is a matter of concern. A reconstruction of the heavy metal pollution of the river Rhine during the past century shows that maximum pollution occurred between 1960 and 1970. The present distribution of heavy metals in floodplain soils is related to this pollution history and the floodplain sedimentation in the past. At many locations the soil
898 quality of the upper 10 cm gives an underestimation of the total pollution of the whole profile. Although the heavy metal content has considerably decreased since 1970, an accelerated sedimentation will still accumulate large amounts of heavy metals on the floodplains in The Netherlands. As average sedimentation rates on most floodplains are in the order of 1 mm/yr, the quality of the upper 50 cm of the floodplain soils will only little improve by the accumulation of sediment of improving quality during the forthcoming century. 9. ECONOMY, SAFETY, ENVIRONMENT F.R. Rijsberman Resource Analysis Zuiderstraat 110, 2624 SJ Delft, The Netherlands 9.1 I n t r o d u c t i o n
In the following pages the results of the hydrology-related projects in the NRP, and their implications for economy, safety and environment, are compared with the results and conclusions of earlier studies. The objective of this comparison is to evaluate whether the NRP-sponsored research has led to changed insights into the impacts of hydrology-related impacts of climate change on the economy, safety and environment in The Netherlands. During the period when IPCC produced its First Assessment Report a comprehensive study was undertaken in The Netherlands to assess the Impacts of Sea Level Rise on Society (ISOS). The ISOS study (Peerbolte et al., 1991) focused largely on sea level rise, but attempted to assess the impacts of changes in hydrology on various aspects of the economy, safety against flooding and the environment as well. The study attempted to integrate data, knowledge and modelling results available in 1988-1991 to produce an assessment of the impacts of climate change for The Netherlands that can be considered as a state-of-the-art review at that point in time; as such it is used in the following pages as a baseline against which the progress made through the NRP programme can be evaluated. It has to be noted at the outset that the approach adopted in the ISOS and NRP studies is quite fundamentally different. The former study made relatively quick and dirty scenario-assumptions for local changes in climate and for a series of physical (intermediate) effects of such changes, e.g. on discharge of the River Rhine, and subsequently attempted to estimate socio-economic impacts resulting from these changes. Impacts were expressed, where possible, in monetary terms for damages such as production losses in agriculture, flooding damages for industry, additional costs of provision of cooling for power plants, and increased costs of water management measures such as pumping drainage water. The hydrology related NRP studies focus largely on the development of regional climate change scenarios (Section 2) and the direct physical effects of these changes in terms of soil erosion, river discharge, sediment transport, sediment deposition, saline seepage and the hydrology of forests. The hydrology-related NRP studies do not assess the socio-economic impacts of these physical effects directly,
899 w i t h the exception of the analysis of changes in agricultural production caused by changes in t e m p e r a t u r e , evaporation, precipitation and CO2-concentrations. 9.2 C l i m a t e s c e n a r i o s One of the more i m p o r t a n t steps forward in the last few y e a r s is the improved regionalization of the climate change scenarios. Both earlier studies as well as the N R P studies are based on the IPCC Business as U s u a l (BaU) scenario, b u t the regionalization of the hydrology-related climate variables is quite different. For c o m p a r i s o n t h e scenarios u s e d in the I S O S - s t u d y are p r e s e n t e d h e r e a f t e r , t o g e t h e r w i t h the scenarios on which the N R P studies are based. One ISOSscenario is the so-called Average (AV) scenario in which all variables, including hydrology-related variables, have their expected values. Another scenario, in which the e s t i m a t e d s t a n d a r d deviations were deducted from the expected values for all variables, is referred to as the Unfavourable (UNF.ALL) scenario. The hydrology related NRP-studies refer to either the regional climate scenarios for The N e t h e r l a n d s developed in NRP (Section 2) or the scenarios for the Rhine Basin developed by Kwadijk (1993). These are also expected values and should therefore be compared with the AV scenario in ISOS. Both scenarios are presented in Table 9.1, together with the two earlier scenarios. Table 9.1 Comparison of regionalized climate change scenarios used in the hydrology related NRP studies as well as in earlier studies Variables Ta Tw Ts Pa Pw Ps Qw Qs Ea=Ew=Es SLR
ISOS AV
ISOS UNF.ALL
NRP
Kwadijk
+3 +3 +3 + 10% + 10% + 10% + 5% -5% + 10% 0.6
+3 +3 +3 +15% + 5% + 10% - 10% + 15% 0.85
+3 * 2.3-3.7 * 2.3-3.7 + 13% * 3%-21% * 3%-21% ** + 15% * * - 10%
+3.5 + 4.3 + 2.9 + 11% + 19% +4%
* m o n t h l y values ** computed values from N R P studies ( P a r m e t et al., 1994) Where: Ta = average a n n u a l T e m p e r a t u r e increase in degrees C Ts = s u m m e r T increase in degrees C Tw = winter T increase in degrees C Pa = average precipitation change in % Ps = s u m m e r precipitation change in % Pw = winter precipitation change in % Qs = s u m m e r river discharge change in % Qw = winter river discharge change SLR = sea level rise in m Ea = average a n n u a l evaporation change in %
900 As can be seen from Table 9.1, the changes in precipitation assumed in the recent scenarios (Section 2) are considerably greater than in the earlier (ISOS-AV) scenario; even greater than in the scenario that was considered "extreme" a few years ago (UNF.ALL). Similarly, the expected changes in river Rhine discharge resulting from the recent NRP RHINEFLOW study considerably exceed the average changes expected earlier (AV scenario). In addition, the NRP studies (Section 6) conclude that the frequency of low flow months (Q< 1000 m3/s) increases with 60%. The conclusion can be drawn from the scenarios presented above that the regional climate change studies undertaken in recent years have shown that the hydrological changes associated with the IPCC-BAU scenario are considerably greater than expected before. Consequently, the hydrology-related impacts of climate change on the economy, safety and the environment can also be expected to be relatively more important than estimated before.
9.3
Impacts on safety against flooding
In the ISOS study it was assumed that the design discharge used for flood protection infrastructure (a discharge of 16,500 m3/s at Lobith, with a recurrence interval of 1250 years) would increase 10%. This resulted in increased design dike crest levels for the river dikes that varied between 0.1 and 0.5 m for different dike sections to maintain the same safety against flooding. The cost of raising river dikes in the non-tidal part of the country (necessitated both by sea level rise and increased river discharges) was estimated to be in the order of 2,500 million guilders over a 100 year period. The cost of raising sea and river dikes was the largest direct economic impact of sea level rise determined in the ISOS-study. The NRP RHINEFLOW study concludes that the average winter discharge increases 15% (Qw= +15%), but u since only a 25 years period was simulated does not allow conclusions to be drawn concerning changes in discharges at frequencies relevant for flood analyses, e.g. discharges with a recurrence interval of 1250 years (Section 6). In a related study, Kwadijk and Middelkoop (1994) used the RHINEFLOW model to assess the probability of exceedance for discharge peaks under possible future climate conditions. For peak discharges relevant for flooding of floodplains (up to Q= 6.500 m3/s) they found that a precipitation increase of 20% leads to a 30% higher two-year peak discharge. For larger design discharges, used for the design of flood protection structures, reliable results could not be obtained because the length of the discharge record was too short. This implies that the hydrology-related NRP studies have not, so far, improved the assessment of floodsafety related impacts. Further analyses of the changes in the peak discharges of the River Rhine are therefore recommended.
9.4
Economic impacts
I m p a c t s on a g r i c u l t u r a l p r o d u c t i o n a n d l a n d use The NRP study (Section 3) analyzed changes in crop yield potential for a time horizon of 2040-2050 with a biophysical simulation model (WOFOST) for Ps=0% en PW=+10%, Ts=l.5, Tw=2, double CO2 concentrations, and computed (Penman) evaporation rates (Ea= +15%). It concludes that the changes would result in average increases in yields of wheat, grass, sugarbeets and corn on sandy soils in the Rhine river basin of 40, 33, 25 and 12 %, respectively. Based on analysis of autonomous developments such as population growth, agricultural production
901 levels and developments in the world and EU market, land use patterns have been simulated, with and without climate change. Without climate change, the range of land use scenarios for the Rhine Basin in the decade 2040-2050 shows that the land used for agriculture will decrease by 0 to 3 million hectares. With climate change, land used for agriculture decreases an additional 0.2 million hectares. Both earlier studies and analysis carried out in the NRP (Section 5) conclude that possible increases in saline seepage through the groundwater due to sea level rise are negligible. Parmet et al. (Section 6) conclude that the summer discharge of the River Rhine would decrease by about 10% and the number of low flow months (Q< 1000 m3/s) increases with about 60%. It has not been analyzed in the NRP what the surface water related implications of these drier summer conditions are, but these could be considerable. The analyses of earlier studies concerning climate change impacts on agricultural production focused on surface water management related issues, including agriculture drought damage, agriculture salinity damage, sprinkler irrigation cost; (discharge) pumping capacity and cost. Conclusions were, for instance, that hydrological dryness influences drought damage substantially, e.g., Ps=-7% (and assumed Es=+15%) resulted in 38% increase of drought damage cost from about 350 to about 500 million guilders per year (Peerbolte et al., 1991). It was also concluded that reductions in average summer discharge of the River Rhine, e.g., Qs=-7%, had only minor impacts on agricultural production. Summarizing, the NRP studies have concluded that there is a potential for significant increases in agricultural production as well as a potential of significant increases in drought damage. From a perspective of the socio-economic impacts on agriculture, the forecasted increase in productivity could increase the comparative advantage of agriculture in The Netherlands, but this will depend on a host of other factors as well (e.g., surface water related drought damages, and w a t e r management costs). The surface water related impacts of the considerably lower summer discharges of the Rhine have not been investigated in the NRP studies, but based on earlier studies it is expected that these could be quite significant for The Netherlands.
Increased costs o f electricity p r o d u c t i o n The ISOS study concluded that the additional costs of electricity production of a decrease in summer discharge of the River Rhine (Qs=-7%) would be in the order of 6 million guilders per year. In Section 6 it is concluded that the average reduction in summer discharges could be higher (Qs=-10%) and that the frequency of low flow months, which can be critical for design of the cooling system, increases considerably. The additional costs of electricity production are therefore likely to be significantly higher than estimated in the earlier studies. Water m a n a g e m e n t costs The larger decrease in average summer Rhine discharges, and increased frequency of low flow months, can also be expected to impact several surface water management factors, particularly the effort required to control the salinity intrusion through the Nieuwe Waterweg (harbour of Rotterdam), navigation, and flushing of polder areas. Increased costs for shipping have not been analyzed in the
902 climate change impact studies to date. Through other studies it is known, however, that the costs for navigation increase rapidly when discharges decrease. Shipping costs in The Netherlands increase from 85 million guilders per week to 130 million guilders per week as the discharge decreases from 1600 to 1000 m3/s (Anonymous, 1990).
F l o o d i n g in f l o o d p l a i n s Earlier studies by Licht (1990) estimated t hat for SLR= 0.85, Qs=-10%, en Qw=+10%, the expected annual economic losses for the brick industry are in the order of 2 million guilders per year due to increased flooding, whereas for dairy farming the increased flooding in winter is more or less compensated by decreased flooding in summer. The NRP study results (Section 6) of Qs=-10% and Qw=+15% would probably result in somewhat higher losses for both the brick industry and dairy farming, but these impacts are still quite small. I m p a c t s on the environment The NRP studies evaluated changes in the following variables that may, in turn, cause environmental impacts" sediment production (Section 7) and suspended sediment t r a n s p o r t and suspended sediment deposition on embanked river floodplains (Section 8); - hydrology of forests (Section 4). -
Earlier studies for The Netherlands evaluated a number of climate change impacts on the environment, but most of these related to coastal environmental aspects. Where, for instance, the ISOS study did look at environmental impacts (impact of flooding on natural areas in river floodplains; decreased biomass phytoplankton and chlorophyll in fresh water ecosystems), the assumed changes in hydrology were too small to determine significant impacts on the environment. The NRP studies showed that sediment production in the River Rhine catchment area may increase by about 20% due to climate change (Section 8), but this increase will be more than balanced by autonomous land use changes that cause a decrease in sediment production. The NRP studies also show that a much higher part of the suspended sediment will be transported at higher discharges, which will lead to a considerably higher deposition of suspended sediment on the embanked floodplains (Section 8). If this sediment remains as polluted as it has been during the last decades than this would lead to a buildup of pollutants on the floodplains which will have serious consequences for the environment. Fortunately, there is a trend towards improving sediment quality in the River Rhine that may mitigate this potential impact. The studies on the hydrology of forests shows t h a t increasing CO2 concentrations may lead to lower evapotranspiration and hence reduced drought damages in summer. Generally speaking, the value of the conclusions of these studies would increase if they were integrated into a common framework for analysis. The changes in the hydrology-related climate variables that follow from the scenarios discussed above, as well as the computed changes in river discharge, are likely to have significant consequences for natural ecosystems, such as desiccation of floodplains in summer. Such ecosystem related consequences have not been looked at in the hydrology-related NRP studies, however.
903 9.5 C o n c l u s i o n s
The changes in hydrology-related climate variables t h a t follow from NRP regionalized climate scenarios are significantly greater those assumed in earlier studies. NRP studies have analyzed the changes in average summer and winter discharges of the River Rhine, as well as the changes in the 2-year peak discharges and frequency of low flow months. The results of these studies show that the discharges of the River Rhine change considerably more than assumed earlier. Peak discharges at recurrence intervals relevant for analysis of impacts on flood safety have not yet been analyzed. Further research in this area is recommended. NRP studies have shown that the expected changes in temperature, precipitation and CO2-concentration have the potential for increased agricultural productivity in The Netherlands. The economic consequences of such changes also depend on changes in drought damages and water management costs. The hydrology related NRP studies have forecasted relatively greater decreases in average summer discharges of the River Rhine than assumed earlier, and significantly increased frequencies of low flow months. This is likely to have considerable impacts on drought damages in agriculture, water management costs, costs of navigation, and costs of electricity production. These surface-water related drought effects may well be the most important economic impacts caused by changes in hydrological climate variables. Several NRP studies have assessed physical effects due to changes in hydrologic variables, such as sediment production, sediment transport and deposition, and hydrology of forests. The expected change in hydrology is likely to lead to increased sediment production, a larger deposition of sediment on the embanked floodplains, and a decrease in the evapotranspiration of forests. These physical effects are likely to have impacts on the environment, but these have not been estimated directly. It is recommended that the analysis of impacts of the various physical effects studied in the future hydrology-related NRP projects is conducted in an integrated framework. 10. R E F E R E N C E S
Anonymous. 1990. Beleidsanalyse waterhuishouding scheepvaart, bevindingen van de werkgroep scheepvaart (in Dutch). RIZA-report 90.005. Asselman, N.E.M. and H. Middelkoop, 1993. Floodplain sedimentation; quantities, patterns and processes. Geopro-93.09. Dept. of Physical Geography, Utrecht University. Accepted for publication in E a r t h Surface Processes and Landforms. Boer, G.J., N.A. McFarlane and M. Lazare, 1992. Greenhouse gas-induced climate change simulated with the CCC second-generation general circulation model. J. Climate, 5: 1045-1077. Boons-Prins, E.R., G.H.J. de Koning, C.A. van Diepen and F.W.T. Penning de Vries, 1993. Crop specific simulation parameters for yield forecasting across the European Community. Simulation reports CABO-TT, no. 32, CABO-DLO. Wageningen, The Netherlands.
904 Buishand, T.A. and A.M.G. Klein Tank, 1994. Regression model for generating time series of daily precipitation amounts for climate change impact studies (submitted to Stochastic Hydrology and Hydraulics). Bultot, F., Coppens, A., Dupriez, G.L., Gellens, D. and F. Meulenberghs, 1988. Repercussions of a CO2 doubling on the water cycle and on the water balance, A case study for Belgium. Journal of Hydrology 99: 219-347. Bultot, F., Gellens, D., Spreafico, M. and B. Sch~idler, 1992. Repercussions of a CO2 doubling on the water balance - a case study in Switzerland. Journal of Hydrology, 137: 199-208. Cure, J.D. and B. Acock, 1986. Crob responces to CO2 doubling: a literature survey. Agri. For. Meteor., 38" 127-145. DGV-TNO, 1984. Grondwaterkaart van Nederland, (Groundwater map of The Netherlands), Rotterdam 37 oost, 37 west). (In Dutch). Rapport GWK 35, Dienst Grondwater-verkenningen TNO, Delft-Oosterwolde. Dolman, A.J., Stewart, J.B. and Cooper, J.D., 1988. Predicting forest transpiration from climatological data. Agri. For. Meteor., 42: 339-353. Drift, J.M.W., H. Middelkoop & N.E.M. Asselman, 1994. Estimation of the effects of climate and land use change on the production of fine sediment by soil erosion in the catchment area of the river Rhine. Internal report, Laboratory of Physical Geography and Soil Sciences, University of Amsterdam; Department of Physical Geography, University of Utrecht, 12 pp. Eamus, D. and Jarvis, P.G., 1989. The direct effects of increase in global atmospheric CO2 concentration on natural and commercial temperate trees and forests. Adv. Ecol. Res., 19: 1-55. Feddes, R.A. and P. Kabat, (eds.) In prep. 1994. SWAP. A model to simulate the Soil Water Atmosphere Plant interactions. Part I. Theory and model description. Simulation Monograph, Pudoc, Wageningen. Hendriks, C.M.A., 1994. Biophysically-based, spatial analysis of possible climate change impacts on forest yield potentials and water use in the Rhine basin, volume 3. (In press). Hendriks, C.M.A., 1994. Biophysically-based analysis of possible climate change impacts on forest yield potentials and water use in the Rhine basin. Volume 3 of Land use projections for the Rhine basin based on biophysical and socioeconomic analysis. Winand Staring Centre-RIZA report 85.3. Hendriks, M.J., Kabat, P., Homma, F. and Postma, J. 1990. Research into the evaporation of a deciduous forest. Measurements and simulations. Report 90, Staring Centrum, Wageningen, The Netherlands, 95 pp, (in Dutch). Houghton, J.T., Callender, B.A. and Varney, S.K. (eds.), 1992. Climate Change 1992, The Supplementary Report to the IPCC Scientific Assessment. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Idso, K.E. and Idso, S.B., 1994. Plant responces to atmospheric CO2 enrichment in the face of environmental constraints: a review of the past 10 years' research. Agri. For. Meteor., 69: 153-203. IPCC, 1990. 'First Assessment Report'. In: Land and Water International no. 69. Isarin, R.F.B. & H.H.A. Berendsen, 1992. Morfodynamiek van de rivierduinen langs de Waal en de Lek. Rapport GEOPRO-92.08. Vakgroep Fysische Geografie Universiteit Utrecht. Jarvis, P.G., 1976. The interpretation of variations in leaf water potential and stomatal conductance found in canopies in the field. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lon. B., 273: 593-610.
905 Klein Tank, A.M.G. and T.A. Buishand, 1993. Modelling daily precipitation as a function of temperature for climate change impact studies. Scientific Reports WR 93-02, KNMI. De Bilt, The Netherlands. Klein Tank, A.M.G. and T.A. Buishand, 1993b. The occurrence of rain in a changing climate. KNMI Memorandum 93-04. Klein Tank, A.M.G. and T.A. Buishand, 1994. Daily precipitation amounts in a future climate derived from temperature and surface air pressure. KNMI Memorandum 94-03. Klein Tank, A.M.G. & G.P. KSnnen, 1993. The dependence of daily precipitation on t e m p e r a t u r e . In: Proceedings of the 18th annual climate diagnostics workshop, Bolder, Colorado. US Dept. of Commerce. KNMI, De Bilt, The Netherlands. Konikow, L.F. and J.D. Bredehoeft, 1978. Computer model of two-dimensional solute transport and dispersion in ground water. U.S. Geol. Surv. Techn. of Water Resour. Investigat., Book 7, Ch C2, 90. Kwaad, F.J.P.M., 1991. Summer and winter regimes of runoff generation and soil erosion on cultivated loess soils (The Netherlands). Earth Surface Processes and Landforms, Vol. 16, 653-662. Kwadijk, J.C.J., 1993. The impact of climate change on the discharge of the river Rhine. Thesis, University of Utrecht. Kwadijk, J. and H. Middelkoop. 1994. Estimation of the impact of climate change on the peak discharge probability of the River Rhine. Climatic Change. 27: 199-224. Licht, P.M., 1990. Beleidseffecten evaluatie binnen rivierbeheer (in Dutch). Thesis, University of Twente. Delft Hydraulics report Q1065/H472. Manabe, S. and Stouffer, R.J., 1980. Sensitivity of a global climate model to an increase of CO2 concentration in the atmosphere. J. Geophys. Res., 85: (C10), 5529-5554. Manabe, S., Wetherald, R.T. and Stouffer, R.J., 1981. Summer dryness due to an increase of atmospheric CO2 concentration. Climatic Change, 3: 347-385. McFarlane, N.A., G.J. Boer, J.P. Blanchet and M. Lazare, 1992. The Canadian Climate Centre second-generation general circulation model and its equilibrium climate. J. Climate, 5: 1013-1044. Middelkoop. H, 1991. Impact of climatic change on sedimentation on the bottomlands ("uiterwaarden") in The Netherlands. Progress-report GEOPRO91.023. Vakgroep Fysische Geografie Universiteit Utrecht. Middelkoop, H. & N.E.M. Asselman, 1993. Assessment of sedimentation rates on floodplains, a case study in The Netherlands. Poster presentation at the 5th International Conference on Fluvial Sedimentology, July 1993, Brisbane, Australia. Middelkoop, H., E.L.J.H. Faessen & H.J. Huizinga, 1992a. Historische morfologie, hydrologie en ecologie van de Waal tussen Pannerden en Nijmegen. Inundatie en landgebruik van de uiterwaarden en morfologie van het zomerbed tussen 1770 en 1830. Rapport GEOPRO-92.06. Vakgroep Fysische Geografie Universiteit Utrecht, (in Dutch). Middelkoop, H., N.J. van den Berg, E.L.J.H. Faessen & H.J.A. Berendsen, 1992b, Morfodynamiek van nevengeulen van de Waal: een historisch overzicht. Rapport GEOPRO-92.07. Vakgroep Fysische Geografie Universiteit Utrecht.
906 Middelkoop, H. & M. Deurloo, 1993. Geomorfologische en Historisch geografische waardering van het uiterwaardengebied rond Sint Andries. Toetsing van een inrichtingsschets. Rapport GEOPRO-93.13. Vakgroep Fysische Geografie Universiteit Utrecht, (in Dutch). Middelkoop, H., & W.P.A. van Deursen, 1993. Modellering inundaties uiterwaarden Case study Gelderse Poort. Rapport GEOPRO-93.01. Vakgroep Fysische Geografie Universiteit Utrecht, (in Dutch). Middelkoop, H. & H.J. Huizinga, 1992. Assessment of suspended sediment concentrations in the rivers Rhine and Waal during the high water period on April 2nd, 1988 using LANDSAT TM data. Rapport GEOPRO-92.01, Vakgroep Fysische Geografie Universiteit Utrecht. Middelkoop, H. & M. van der Perk, 1991. Een reconstructie van de opslibbing van uiterwaarden. Rapport GEOPRO-91.06. Vakgroep Fysische Geografie Universiteit Utrecht. Middelkoop, H., E.L.J.H. Faessen & H.J. Huizinga, 1992a. Historische morfologie, hydrologie en ecologie van de Waal tussen Pannerden en Nijmegen. Inundatie en landgebruik van de uiterwaarden en morfologie van het zomerbed tussen 1770 en 1830. Rapport GEOPRO-92.06. Vakgroep Fysische Geografie Universiteit Utrecht, (in Dutch). Nonhebel, S., 1987. Water use of Dutch forests: a simulation study. Report 7G, Studiecommissie Waterbeheer Natuur, Bos en Landschap, (in Dutch). Ogink-Hendriks, M.J., 1994. Modelling surface conductance and transpiration of a oak forest in The Netherlands. Agri. For. Meteor., (Submitted). Oude Essink, G.H.P., 1993. Effect of Sea Level Rise on the Groundwater Flow System through Amsterdam Waterworks and Haarlemmermeer polder, The Netherlands. Proc. UNESCO Conf. on Sea Level Changes and their Consequences for Hydrology and Water Management, Noordwijkerhout, The Netherlands. Parmet, B., 1993a. Impact of climate change on the discharge of the Rhine. Change 15: 1-3. Parmet, B. and M. Mann, 1993b. Influence of climate change on the discharge of the River Rhine - a model for the lowland area. IAHS publication 212: 469477. Peerbolte, E.B., J.G. de Ronde, L.P.M. de Vrees, M. Mann, G. Baarse, 1991. Impact of Sea Level Rise on Society. A case study of The Netherlands. Report GWAO 90-016. Rijkswaterstaat, Den Haag. Pomper, A.B., 1983. Geohydrological situation and observations on the hydrochemical groundwater situation of the western Netherlands. Geologie en Mijnbouw 62: 3/4. Roetter, R., 1994. Biophysical classification of the Rhine basin as a frame for land use projections. Volume 1 of Land use projections for the Rhine basin based on biophysical and socio-economic analysis. Winand Staring Centre-RIZA report 85.1. Roetter, R. and C.A. van Diepen, 1994. Biophysically-based analysis of possible climate change impacts on crop yield potentials and water use in the Rhine basin. Volume 2 of Land use projections for the Rhine basin based on biophysical and socio-economic analysis. Winand Staring Centre-RIZA report 85.2.
907 Roetter, R. and C.A. van Diepen, 1994. Biophysically-based, spatial analysis of possible climate change impacts on crop yield potentials and water use in the Rhine basin, volume 2. In press. Rotmans, J., 1990. IMAGE: An integrated model to assess the greenhouse effect. PhD Thesis, Kluwer, Dordrecht. Sch~idler, B., Spreafico, M., Bultot, F. and D. Gellens, 1992. Evaluation Wasserhaushaltmodelle. Vorstudie Nationales Forschungsprogramm 31: "Klima~inderungen und Naturkatastrophen". Stewart, J.B., 1988. Modelling dependence of surface conductance on environmental conditions. Agri. For. Meteor., 43" 19-35. Van Diepen, C.A., C. Rappoldt, J. Wolf and H. van Keulen, 1988. Crop growth simulation model WOFOST version 4.1, documentation. SOW-88-01. Center for World Food Studies, Wageningen, The Netherlands. Van Dijck, S.J.E., 1993. Palaeomagnetic research of the sediments from the dike burst pond in the river foreland of the Waal at Wamel (The Netherlands). Student report, Vakgroep Fysische Geografie Universiteit Utrecht. Van Dinter, M., 1993. Palynologisch onderzoek naar wielopvullingen in het Nederlandse rivierengebied. Student report, Vakgroep Fysische Geografie Universiteit Utrecht, (in Dutch). Van Dinter, M., H. Middelkoop, & B. Derks, 1992. Pollen analysis of dike burst ponds near Nijmegen, The Netherlands. Poster presentation at the 8th International Palynological Congress, Aix-en-Provence, 1992. Van der Drift, J.W.M., 1994. The impact of temperature and rainfall changes (climate change) on land degradation in source areas of the suspended sediment load of the Rhine. NRP Project no. 852089, Interim report no.l, Laboratory of Physical Geography and Soil Science, University of Amsterdam, 33 pp. Van der Drift, J.W.M., Middelkoop, H. and N.E.M. Asselman, 1994. Estimation of the effects of climate and land use change on the production of fine sediment by soil erosion in the catchment area of the river Rhine. Internal report, Laboratory of Physical Geography and Soil Science, University of Amsterdam, Department of Physical Geography, University of Utrecht, 12 pp. Veen, A.W.L. and Dolman, A.J., 1989. Water dynamics of forests: one-dimensional modelling. Progress in Physical Geography, 13: 19-35. Veeneklaas, F.R., L.M. van de Berg, D. Slothouwer and G.F.P. IJkelenstam, 1994. Rhine Basin study: Land use projections based on biophysical and socioeconomic analyses. Volume 4, Land use: past, present and future. Report 85.4, Winand Staring Centre (SC-DLO), Wageningen, The Netherlands. Viner, D. and M. Hulme, 1993. Climate change scenarios for impact studies in the UK: General circulation methods and applications for impact assessment. Climatic Research Unit, University of East Anglia, Norwich. Washington, W.M. and Meehl, G.A., 1983. General circulation model experiments on the climatic effects due to a doubling and quadrupling of carbon dioxide concentration. J. Geophys. Res., 88 (Cll): 6600-6610. Wateren-de Hoog, B. van der, & H. Middelkoop, 1992. Floods in the River Rhine and atmospheric circulation patterns. Rapport GEOPRO-92.02. Vakgroep Fysische Geografie Universiteit Utrecht. Wigley, T.M.L., T. Holt and S.C.B. Raper, 1991. STUGE, an interactive greenhouse model: Users manual, Climate Research Unit, Norwich.
908 Wischmeijer, W.H. and D.D. Smith, 1978. Predicting rainfall erosion losses - a guide to conservation planning. US Dept. of Agriculture, Agriculture Handbook No. 537. Wit, K, 1987. Wateraanvoerbehoefte Zuidhollandse Eilanden en Waarden (Fresh water requirements of the south-western island and polders of Zuid Holland), I.C.W. Nota nr. 1801, Winand Staring Centre, RIZA., Wageningen (in Dutch). Wolf, J, and Diepen, van, C.A., 1993. Effects of climate change on crop production and land use in the Rhine basin. In: Geijn, S.C., Goudriaan, and Berendse, F., editors. Climate change; crops and terrestrial ecosystems. Agrobiologische Thema's 9. 1993, CABO-DLO, Wageningen, The Netherlands. Wolf, J. and van Diepen, C.A., 1991. Effects of climate change on crop production in the Rhine basin. Report 52, Winand Staring Centre, RIZA, Wageningen.
S h o r t p a p e r s within N R P subtheme "Impact o f climate change on regional hydrology"
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Climate Change Research: Evaluation and Policy Implications S. Zwerver, R.S.A.R. van Rompaey, M.T.J. Kok and M.M. Berk, (Eds.) 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
911
IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON THE DISCHARGE OF THE RIVER RHINE
B. Parmet "), J. Kwadijkb) and M. Raak a) a)
RIZA, Institute of Inland Water Management and Waste Water Treatment Section Rivers, P.O. Box 9072, 6800 ED Arnhem, the Netherlands
b)
University of Utrecht, Department of Physical Geography P.O. Box 80115, 3508 TC Utrecht, the Netherlands
Abstract Climate change influences the water balance of drainage basins in several ways. In a project of the International Commission for the Hydrology of the Rhine basin the possible consequences for the discharge regime of the Rhine are investigated. In the first phase of this project detailed models have been developed and applied for selected sub-basins and a simple water balance model has been developed for the whole Rhine basin. Results are presented for climate scenarios assuming an increase in temperature of about 3~ and an increase in annual precipitation. The consequences of such a climate change are largest in the Alpine part of the Rhine basin, and are also considerable in other parts of the basin and for the basin as a whole. In general the Rhine changes towards a rain-fed river. The winter discharge increases, which can have consequences for safety, and summer discharge decreases with consequences for shipping, industry, agriculture and ecology.
1. Introduction
Climate change influences the components of the water balance of drainage basins in several ways. Precipitation patterns may change and because of a higher temperature also the timing and amount of snow fall and snow melt. Evapotranspiration is directly influenced by an increase in temperature. An increased CO2-concentration affects plant physiology and may lead to changes in water use too. Furthermore climate change may induce changes in land use, which is an important factor in evapotranspiration and runoff processes. Changes in these water balance components will of course affect the discharge. The River Rhine is economically the most important river of Western-Europe. Its drainage basin, see figure 1, stretches from the source in Switzerland to the mouth in the North sea, covering an area of 185.000 k n l 2 and is habitat to about 55 million people. The river is one of the most intensively navigated inland waterways in the world and is of major importance for the supply of water to large economically important areas. Changes in its discharge regime can have consequences for safety and for the water availability for shipping, industry, domestic use, agriculture, the natural environment and recreational purposes.
912 Against this background, the International Commission for the Hydrology of the Rhine basin (CHR) initiated a project to assess the consequences of climate and land use changes for the discharge regime of the River Rhine. Since a proper tool for this was lacking, the main purpose of the project was to develop a water management model for the whole Rhine basin. This model should be used to analyze the changes in average and extreme discharges and the effectiveness of mitigating measures. Several institutes from the Rhine riparian states cooperate in the project (Parmet, 1993). The Netherlands contribution to this project is incorporated in the Dutch National Research Program on Global Change (NRP).
0# \
120 km
o
\
........--"
,..,
,,) ,J
~~176 \
.J
-\(y :_ )
( "",3
Figure 1. Drainage basin of the River Rhine
2. Method
The model will be developed in two phases. In the first phase model development takes place along a bottom-up and a top-down approach. In the second phase both approaches will be combined. Along the bottom-up approach hydrological models are developed for selected sub-basins. These models are detailed in time and space and can be used to simulate the effects of climate and land use changes on average and peak flows. Sub-basins were selected in three distinct areas; the Alpine area, the Middle Mountains and the Lowland area. Different model concepts are used because the relevant hydrological
913 processes differ. Snow accumulation and melt, for example, is very important in the Alpine area and groundwater flow for the Lowland. Along the top-down approach a GIS-based water balance model is developed with a course resolution in time and space. This model can be used to study the sensitivity of the average discharge regime of the river Rhine and its main tributaries for climate change. The first phase of the CHR project is almost finalized. Along the bottom-up line, several detailed models are developed and also existing models are applied for representative subbasins. For the Alpine area an existing hydrological model, the IRMB model, was applied for several small drainage basins (Bultot, 1992, Sch/idler 1992). In the Middle Mountains area, a model will be developed for the Saar basin, a sub-basin of the Mosel. Results are not yet available. The Lowland model is developed for the drainage basin of the Overijsselsche Vecht (Parmet and Mann, 1993, Parmet and Raak, in prep). This model consists of a hydrological component, that is used to compute the daily evapotranspiration and discharge for sub-basins, and a flow-routing component, that combines the sub-basins and routes their discharges towards the mouth of the Overijsselsche Vecht. For the Rhine basin as a whole the water balance model RHINEFLOW was developed (Kwadijk, 1993). It is a simple water balance model based on a Geographical Information System.
3. Results 3.1. Effects of climate change in representative basins in the Alpine area With the IRMB model the effects of a climate change for several components of the water balance were simulated for three drainage basins, Murg, Ergolz and Broye. A climate scenario as defined by Bultot was applied (Bultot, 1988). The monthly temperature and precipitation changes are given in table 1. Changes in physiological behavior of plants were not taken into account. Simulations with changed climate were carried out for the period 1981 to 1988. The simulations showed an increase of annual potential evapotranspiration of 10%. Actual evapotranspiration increased somewhat less because during the summer period there is a slight decrease in soil moisture. Discharge increased during the winter period with 10%. This is due to the fact that the amount of winter precipitation increases and less precipitation is stored as snow. Furthermore the accumulated snow melts faster. The duration of the snow cover decreases considerably, especially below an altitude of 1500 m. Discharge in summer decreased with about 15%. This follows from a reduced contribution of melt water, a larger evapotranspiration and a slight decrease in precipitation. The total annual discharge hardly changes. The daily maximum discharge increases and the daily minimum discharge decreases. 3.2 Effects of climate change in representative basins in the Lowland area The climate scenario that was used for the Lowland area was based on a method developed in the framework of the NRP (Klein Tank and Buishand, 1995). The monthly changes in temperature and precipitation are given in table 1. Compared to the other scenarios used in this study, this scenario is rather wet. Computations were carried out for the basin of the Overijsselsche Vecht for the period 1965-1990. Changes in plant physiological characteristics were taken into account.
914 An increased CO2-concentration influences plant physiology. For most plants the water use efficiency increases and the biomass production increases. An increase in temperature for the temperate zones generally leads to an increase in production too. Present knowledge indicates, for doubled CO2-concentrations and an increase in temperature of about 1.5~ a small decrease in evapotranspiration for most crops and forests (Roetter en van Diepen, 1994; Hendriks, 1994). Based on this knowledge, plant physiological parameters were provisionally adapted in the Lowland model (Parmet and Raak, in prep).
Table 1 Monthly temperature (T) and precipitation (P), used for representative Alpine basins and for the representative Lowland basin Month
J
F
M
A
M
J
J
A
S
O
N
D
Talpine, ~ Palpine, % 1)
3.1 10
3.4 14
3.4 11
3.1 10
2.8 -1
2.7 -2
2.5 -2
2.3 -2
2.3 0
2.7 6
2.8 10
3.2 10
Tlowland, ~ Plowland, %
3.0 21
3.0 20
2.3 15
2.3 13
2.3 5
3.7 12
3.7 11
3.7 9
3.4 3
3.4 8
3.4 19
3.0 18
1) The percentual change is an average for the three basins Murg, Ergolz and Broye (Sch~idler, 1992)
700
E d L.. ~m tU
.-
6oo 500
400
E m E
300
E
2oo
r-
100
r
<
f
f
f
~
Reference --
0
2
i
I
i
I
I
I
5
1o
.50
1 oo
200
500
Reccurence
- Scenario
1250
period, [years]
Figure 2. Discharges for different recurrence periods for reference and scenario conditions, as computed with the lowland model for the drainage basin of the Overijsselsche Vecht.
915
Simulations for the lowland showed an increase in actual evapotranspiration of about 7%. The CO2 effect on water use does not compensate for the increase in temperature of 3 ~ The annual discharge increased with 22%. Winter discharge increased with 25%. The increase in evapotranspiration in summer does not exceed the increase in precipitation. Discharge in summer increased with 19%. The maximum discharge increased considerably. The distribution of annual maxima can be described using a Gumbel distribution (Mendel, 1993). According to fitted Gumbel functions for the reference (r 2 = 0.98) and scenario (r 2 = 0.97) simulations, peak flows with different recurrence periods change as indicated in figure 2. River dikes in the Netherlands are designed for a discharge with a recurrence period of 1250 years. The figure shows an strong increase of 26% in this design discharge for the river Vecht. 3.3 Effects of climate change, Rhine basin Consequences for the whole Rhine basin have been computed with the RHINEFLOW model. The sensitivity of the discharge regime was examined with a wide range of climate scenarios for the period 1956 to 1980 (Kwadijk, 1993). Here the results of computations with one scenario, the so-called BAU-best scenario, are presented. The scenario is based on the IPCC Business as Usual scenario (IPCC, 1991). It is given in table 2. Changes in land use and physiological characteristics of plants were not taken into account.
Table 2 BAU-BEST scenario for temperature (T) and precipitation (P), for different parts of the Rhine basin (Kwadijk, 1993) Year
Summer
Winter
Part of Rhine basin
T, ~
P, %
T, ~
P, %
T, ~
P, %
North Middle South
3.5 3.5 3.5
11 8 7
2.9 2.9 2.9
4 -1 -4
4.3 4.2 4.1
19 19 19
For the Alpine part of the Rhine basin, the changes as computed with RHINFLOW have the same direction as the results for the representative Alpine basins. As can be seen from figure 3, winter discharge increases. This is caused by increased precipitation and snow melt. During summer the discharge decreases due to a smaller contribution of melt water, increased evapotranspration and a slight decrease in precipitation. The increase in winter discharge is much larger than for the representative basins, upto 100% with an average of 60%. This can be explained partly from the used scenarios. Both the increase in temperature and in precipitation is smaller for the Bultot scenario compared with the BAUbest scenario. Furthermore it can be explained by differences in model components, especially the snow component, and off course the considered area is not the same. The changes during summer are comparable, both for the alpine area as a whole and for the
916 representative basins in the alpine area, a decrease of about 15% was computed. The changes for the area downstream, the Middle and Lowland part, are much less pronounced. The discharge increases during winter and spring and decreases during summer and autumn, as can be derived from figure 3. The increase in evapotranspiration causes the soil water deficit to increase. As a result, summer discharge decreases, but because part of the winter surplus is stored as groundwater, not untill July. The water surplus during autumn is partly used to replenish soil water, which explains the decrease of discharge during autumn. Because the scenario used for the representative basin for the lowland is wetter, especially for the summer period, than the BAU-best scenario, the changes in discharge are not directly comparable. 120
100
o~~ 80 ,.._,
Alpine part -- - Middle & lowland part
40
- - - Outlet basin l--
20 9
.c
0
~
R li"~
~
~
~
0 -20 -40
o>
Z
~
O
~
~
~
LL
~
~
~_
<:
~=-
:~
==
"~
~
==
<
~
CO
O
Month
Figure 3. Changes in monthly discharge for different parts of the Rhine basin and near the basin outlet, for simulations with the BAU-BEST climate scenario, for the period 19651980.
Where the River Rhine enters the Netherlands, near the basin outlet, the changes in the Alpine, Middle and Lowland part are combined. The annual changes are small, the discharge increases with 2%. However, winter and spring discharge increase with about 15%, and summer and autumn discharge decrease with about 10%, see figure 3. Due to the changes in the alpine area the regime of the River Rhine changes from a combined rainfed/snow-fed into a rain-fed river. The discharge pattern will become less smooth and the difference between maximum and minimum flows will increase. The number of months with low flows will increase. For example, the results indicate that the number of months with an average discharge below 1000 m3/s increases for the period 1956 to 1980 with 13, which is about 60%. To make an assessment about peak flows with the monthly discharges computed by RHINEFLOW, a relation between average monthly flows and peak flows was derived. Using this relation it was shown that the probability of discharge peaks upto 7000
917
m3/s increases significantly. This is important in respect to sedimentation on floodplains, because these are inundated for such discharges. The relation does not give well-founded results for the design discharge, and hence about consequences for safety.
4. Implications Interim results of the CHR project show that climate change can have considerable effects for the discharge regime of the Rhine. With the assumed scenario for the Rhine basin, the winter discharge increases considerably. This could have consequences for safety, but the models are not yet suitable to assess consequences for design discharges. The contribution of melt water originating from the Alps during the summer period decreases, which is an important reason for a decrease in summer discharge. Furthermore evapotranspiration is expected to increase, which contributes also to a decrease in summer discharge. Consequently the frequency of periods with low flows increases. For water management in the Netherlands an increased frequency of low flows implies increasing costs for shipping. Ships can be loaded less and have to wait longer for sluices and bridges. Costs of electricity production will increase too. To avoid environmental problems with the temperature of cooling water, other more expensive, production units have to be brought into operation. Other industries that use water for cooling purposes may have to limit production or built cooling towers. Lower water levels will also have undesirable effects on ecological development in floodplains, dessication problems are expected to increase. Furtermore the increased frequency in low flows wil result in a more frequent intrusion of salt water. This can cause problems for intake of water of certain polders and may cause damage to agriculture. In general the changed discharge regime will also influence river morphology. For the Rhine basin land use scenarios have been developed in the framework of the CHR project (Roetter, 1994; Roetter and v. Diepen, 1994; Hendriks, 1994; Veeneklaas et al, 1994). The effects of land use changes have not yet been studied in detail. From first computations it can be concluded that for Lowland areas the total discharge rather than peak discharges will be affected. For the Alpine and Middle Mountains area it is expected that also the peak flows are influenced. First estimates show that land use changes are very important for the production of suspended sediment, sediment transport and sedimentation processes (Asselman, 1994; Middelkoop, 1994). Further study is required. The model RHINEFLOW in its present form is a usefull tool for sensitivity analysis. However, the simple process descriptions and the poor quality of the underlying database, limit its applicability. On the other hand the detailed models are only available for a relatively small part of the Rhine basin. To extend these models for the whole basin is a time consuming task. Therefore a promissing direction is to couple the rough and the detailed models, for example with transfer functions. RHINEFLOW has to be refined in time and space for this. Furthermore the detailed models have to be applied also in other characteristic areas, to cover the variability within the Rhine basin in a better way. It is recommended to investigate the possible effects of climate change also for other important river systems, like the Meuse. A similar approach as in the CHR project can be applied.
918 5. References
Asselman, N., 1994. The impact of climate change on suspended sediment transport in the river Rhine. Report University Utrecht, Department of Physical Geography. Bultot, F., Coppens, A., Dupriez, G.L., Gellens, D. and Meulenberghs, F., 1988. Repercussions of a CO2 doubling on the water cycle and on the water balance - A case study for Belgium. Journal of Hydrology 99, p. 219-347. Bultot, F., Gellens, D., Spreafico, M. and B. Sch~idler, 1992. Repercussions of a CO 2 doubling on the water balance - a case study in Switzerland. Journal of Hydrology, 137, p. 199-208. Hendriks, C.M.A., 1994. Biophysically-based analysis of possible climate change impacts on forest yield potentials and water use in the Rhine basin. Volume 3 of Land use projections for the Rhine basin based on biophysical and socio-economic analysis. Winand Staring Centre-RIZA report 85.3. IPCC, 1991. Climate Change: The IPCC Response Strategies. Cambridge. University Press. Klein Tank, A.M.G. and Buishand, T.A., 1995. Transformation of precipitation time series for climate change impact studies. KNMI report WR 95.01. De Bilt. Kwadijk, J., 1993. The impact of climate change on the discharge of the River Rhine. PhD Thesis. Netherlands Geographical Studies no. 171. Utrecht. Kwadijk, J.C.J. and Middelkoop, H., 1994. Estimation of impact of climate change on the peak discharge probability of the river Rhine. Climatic Change 27, p. 199-224. Mendl, H.-G., 1993. Verteilungsfunctionen in der Hydrologie. CHR/KHR report II-8. Middelkoop, H., 1994. The impact of climate change on the sedimentation rates on the embanked floodplains in the Netherlands. Report University Utrecht. Department of Physical Geography Parmet, B., 1993. Impact of climate change on the discharge of the Rhine. CHANGE 15, p. 1-3. Parmet, B. and M. Mann, 1993. Influence of climate change on the discharge of the River Rhine - a model for the lowland area. IAHS publication 212, p. 469-477. Parmet, B. and Raak, M. In prep. Impact of climate change on the discharge of the river Rhine - A case study for the lowland drainage basin of the Overijsselsche Vecht. Rijkswaterstaat RIZA report. Roetter, R., 1994. Biophysical classification of the Rhine basin as a frame for land use projections. Volume 1 of Land use projections for the Rhine basin based on biophysical and socio-economic analysis. Winand Staring Centre-RIZA report 85.1. Roetter, R. en C.A. van Diepen, 1994. Biophysically-based analysis of possible climate change impacts on crop yield potentials and water use in the Rhine basin. Volume 2 of Land use projections for the Rhine basin based on biophysical and socio-economic analysis. Winand Staring Centre-RIZA report 85.2. Schfidler, B., Spreafico, M., Bultot, F. and D. Gellens, 1992. Evaluation Wasserhaushaltmodelle. Vorstudie Nationales Forschungsprogramm 31: "Klima~.nderungen und Naturkatastrophen". Veeneklaas, F.R, van den Berg, L.M., Slothouwer, D. en G.F.P. IJkelenstam, 1994. Land use: Past, present and future. Volume 4 of Land use projections for the Rhine basin based on biophysical and socio-economic analysis. Winand Staring Centre-RIZA report 85.4.
Climate Change Research: Evaluation and Policy Implications S. Zwerver, R.S.A.R. van Rompaey, M.T.J. Kok and M.M. Berk, (Eds.) 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
919
The effects of an increase in CO2 on the hydrology of forests H.J.M. Lankreijer Department of Physical Geography, University of Groningen, Kerklaan 30, 9751 NN Haren, The Netherlands
Abstract The possible impacts of a climatic change associated with an increase in CO2 on the hydrology of forests is evaluated by applying sensitivity analysis and a climatic scenario to a one-dimensional model. Water consumption of forests is affected by changes in plant physiology and meteorological environment. Changes in species composition are not taken into account. Increase in CO2 leads to a decrease of stomatal conductance, resulting in a decrease in transpiration of 10-30%. The evaporation of rainfall interception by the canopy is increased due to a higher leaf area index and higher temperatures. Application of a wet scenario shows an increase in total interception, but the ratio between interception and precipitation decreases. Simulating a small increase in leaf area increases the evapotranspiration only weakly and the higher precipitation in the scenario is mainly passed on to drainage. Drought damage in summer should reduce, but winter discharge may strongly increase.
1. INTRODUCTION Forests are not only important in the global carbon balance but have also a relevant influence on local and regional hydrology. A change in the concentration of CO2 as well as a possible climatic change will have direct and indirect effects on the water use of plants, including trees. The direct effect of CO2 increase will be most significant on the photosynthesis. Besides, forest are strongly coupled to the atmospheric conditions because of their roughness. Changes in the atmosphere will affect forests stronger than other vegetation types. The aim of this study is to estimate the consequences of a climate change with an increase of atmospheric CO2 concentration for the water balance of forests.
2. SIMULATION OF THE FOREST WATER BALANCE A one dimensional model was developed to simulate the water balance. The model, derived from the model by Dolman et al. [1], is devided in three main parts. Transpiration
920 through the leaves is simulated using the Penman-Monteith equation, which contains the stomatal conductance. Interception and evaporation of rainfall by the canopy is modelled according to the Gash-Rutter [2] approach. And thirdly, the soil is considered as a simple bucket and water exceeding the field capacity is drained. Transpiration is calculated on a hourly time basis, whereas interception and soil water content are calculated with a daily time step. Transpiration of forests is strongly determined by the stomatal conductance. As stomata are sensitive to changes in the CO2 concentration, a model simulating the responses of stomata is essential [3]. The correlation between stomata, meteorological variables and plant physiological processes is evident, but the exact mechanistic process of stomatal functioning is still unknown. This situation has resulted in several possible empirical simulation models. In this study the model developed by Leuning [4] was chosen. To incorporate the effect of soil moisture deficit on the stomatal conductance, the soil moisture function of Stewart [5] is used in combination with the Leuning model. The model describes a relation of stomatal conductance with the assimilation rate and air humidity deficit. To simulate the assimilation rate the biochemical model of Farquhar et al. [6] is used. 2.1 Climate scenario The influence of the main model parameters on interception and transpiration were analyzed by sensitivity analysis. To integrate the results with results of other groups with in the National Research Program, the scenario KNMI-2 as described by K6nnen [7] was applied. The amount of precipitation increases strongly (with a yearly of average 13 %) as compared to climate scenarios described by IPCC. In order to apply the scenario, an estimation must be made of the forest parameters in a changed climate. Changes in the parameters are derived from studies to responses of trees in a changed climate. An excellent review is given by Ceulemans and Mousseau [8]. The reaction of trees depends on species and nutrient environment with the possibility of the tree to develop sinks for the extra carbon. A general trend is the increase of growth and, with some exceptions, of the water use efficiency, but the increase is limited when no sinks are available. With limited nutrients, which is the case for many forests on sandy soils, the increase of biomass will be concentrated in the roots. Therefore, in the scenario a modest increase of 5 % in leaf area index (LAI) of the canopy is applied. The onset of leaf growth and leaf fall are not changed. Also the nitrogen content is not changed to keep the approach simple. Most species show a decrease in stomatal conductance caused by both smaller stomatal opening and lower stomatal density. In this study doubling of CO2 resulted in a decrease of stomatal conductance of 31%. Based on Morison [9], who compared the stomatal conductance of various species under ambient and double CO2 concentrations, these changes are regarded as realistic. Although, variations due to varying species composition and forest site may be large. 2.2 Data The model was calibrated on data of a decidiuos forest (Quercus rubra ) located near Erie in the Netherlands and of the coniferous forest (Pinus sylvestris) of Thetford in England. The model had to be fitted on measured transpiration fluxes and soil moisture content because assimilation data were not available. The simulated variation in the
921 Precipitation
1000
--
i
i
i
1974
1975
1976
1
1977
1978
avg
Year
Decidious
i Normal
1961-1990
Coniferous
Interception 250 -
501974
1975
1976
1977
1978
avg
1974
1975
1976
1977
1978
avg
1975
1976
1977
1978
avg
Transpiration 500 45O 400
..........................
T
...........
300 250 1974 Precipitation
650
1975
1976
1977
1978
avg
1974
excess
i
-
l
~ 350
.
1974
1975
1976
'
1977
1978
avg
t
1974
.
1975
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1976
.
.
.
.
1977
1978
avg
Year
D
Normal climate
I~
Scenario
Figure 1. Yearly totals of precipitation, interception, transpiration and precipitation excess simulated with normal climate and scenario for both forest types.
assimilation rate with the Farquhar model was judged to be realistic. To simulate the water balance over longer periods, the climate scenario study was conducted with a data covering the years 1974-1978, including dry and wet years. The variables were measured above grass and transformed to above forest conditions. The characteristics of Ede and Thetford forests were used to describe the modelled forests.
922 4. RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS Interception of rainfall is especially sensitive to changes in temperature, air humidity, windspeed and leaf area. With no change in the relative humidity when temperature increases, the small increase in leaf area index raises the interception with a small amount (see figure 1). Although precipitation increases strongly, the effect on interception is low. The ratio of interception and total precipitation is decreasing. This means that a larger part of the gross precipitation reaches the soil. Using the physiological based model for stomatal conductance, transpiration appears to be sensitive not only to changes in temperature, air humidity and soil water availability but also the nitrogen availability and the photosynthetic capacity have a strong influence. The available soil water determines the change in transpiration compared to the actual climate. Lower transpiration during winter and spring due to decreasing stomatal conductance, diminish water shortage during summer and the total yearly transpiration may increase. When water is not limiting transpiration decreases with 10-30%. Taking the uncertainties of the applied scenario and used model into consideration, the results must be used with care. The increase in precipitation, especially high during winter, will drain almost completely to the groundwater. This means that frequent flooding can be expected in winter when evapotranspiration is low and the soil is already saturated. Summer droughts will decrease. The present policy to replace coniferous forests with deciduous forests to limit evapotranspiration, will further increase discharge in a greenhouse climate.
5. REFERENCES
1 Dolman, A.J., Stewart, J.B. and Cooper, J.D., 1988. Predicting forest transpiration from climatological data. Agri. For. Meteor., 42: 339-353. 2 Gash, J.H.C., 1979. An analytical model of rainfall interception by forests. Q.J.R. Meteorol. Soc., 105:43-55. 3 Lankreijer, H.J.M. and Veen, A.W.L., 1989. Possible changes in forest hydrology following a global climatic change. Proc. WMO Conf. Climate and Water, Publ. Acad. Finland, Helsinki, 1989; vol. I, pp. 187-196. 4 Leuning, R., 1994. A critical appraisel of a combined stomatal-photosynthesis model for C3 plants. Submitted to Plant, Cell and Environment. 5 Stewart, J.B. 1988. Modelling dependence of surface conductance on environmental conditions. Agri. For. Meteor., 43: 19-35. 6 Farquhar, G.D., von Caemmerer, S., and Berry, J.A., 1980. A biochemical model of photosynthetic CO2 assimilation in leaves of C3 species. Planta 149: 78-90. 7 K6nnen, G.P., 1994. Scenarios climate change. Assessement Report NRP, sub theme Regional Hydrology, pp 9-13. 8 Ceulemans, R. and Mousseau, M., 1994. Tansley review No. 71. Effects of elevated atmospheric CO2 on woody plants. New Phytol., 127: 425-446. 9 Morison, J.I.L., 1987. Stomatal responses to CO2. In: E. Zeiger, G.D. Farquhar and I.R. Cowan (Eds), Stomatal Function. Stanford University Press, Stanford California, 229-251.
Climate Change Research: Evaluation and Policy Implications S. Zwerver, R.S.A.R. van Rompaey, M.T.J. Kok and M.M. Berk, (Eds.) 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
923
The effect of temperature change on soil structure stability Drs. J.W.M. van der Drift
University of Amsterdam, Landscape and Environmental Research Group, Nieuwe Prinsengracht 130, 1018 VZ Amsterdam, The Netherlands
Abstract The influence of variations of temperature, organic carbon content and land use on soil structure stability was investigated by statistical analysis of field and soil data of two loess covered areas in the German part of the Rhine Basin. Aggregate stability as an indicator of structure stability was determined and related to land use, slope aspect and soil organic carbon content. Because aggregate stability showed no relation with aspect, there is little evidence t h a t soil structure stability is related to temperature. Relations between aggregate stability and soil organic carbon content and between aggregate stability and land use were found to be significant.
1. I N T R O D U C T I O N
The occurrence and rate of soil erosion is controlled by a n u m b e r of causes and factors, viz. ability of precipitation to cause erosion (erosivity), length and steepness of slopes, resistance of the soil to erosion (erodibility), and land use (Wischmeier and Smith, 1978; Dikau, 1986). Climate change may, directly or indirectly, affect some of these causes and factors. This study concentrates on the impact of climate change on soil structure stability, because structure stability controls the rate of soil structure degradation, and it is still in an under-developed research area. Climate affects soil structure stability through its influence on the organic m a t t e r status of the soil, which depends on biomass production and decomposition
924 of organic materials by soil (micro)biological activity (Tate, 1987). Soil structure is characterized by the presence of soil aggregates, clusters of soil particles which mutually adhere by chemical and physical binding forces. In surface soils, these forces are mainly controlled by organic matter. Macro-aggregates (>2501~m) are mainly stabilized by plant roots and larger fungi (Tisdall and Oades, 1982). Microaggregates (20-2501~m) are bound together by decomposed organic substances and bacteri. Micro-aggregation in the size class 2-22~m is mainly caused by clay particles, and to a lesser extent by organic materials (Oades, 1993; Tisdall and Oades, 1982). The rate of structure development and structure breakdown is dependent on the dynamics of soil organic matter, which, in turn, is controlled by soil moisture and soil temperature regime (Chaney and Swift, 1984; Tate, 1987; Jenkinson and Ayanaba, 1977). The study of the impact of climate change on soil structure stability is carried out in two areas covered with loess in the catchment of the River Rhine (Dikau, 1986; Clemens and Stahr, 1994; Schalich, 1981). Objective of research is: to analyze the influence of temperature variation on soil structure stability by establishing relationships between aggregate stability and environmental factors like land use and temperature, and soil properties like soil organic matter content and particle size distribution for loess soils in the German part of the Rhine Basin. Based on a comparative study of aggregate stability in different parts of the Rhine basin with different temperature conditions under the current climate, existing differences in structure stability between areas with different temperature regimes might be an indication of the change in soil structure stability that will possibly occur as a consequence of climate change.
2. STUDY AREA AND METHODS
In the German part of the Rhine basin areas covered with loess were selected to compare the structure stability of the soils and analyze the relationship with environmental factors and soil properties: "the Kraichgau" in the federal state Baden Wiirttemberg in the drainage basin of the river Neckar and the "Jfilicher B5rde" in the federal state Nordrhein Westfalen, stretching from the drainage area of the Lippe to the west bank of the Rhine into the basin of the Meuse. These areas differ amongst others with respect to climate, relief and mean elevation. The soil types present in these areas are Braunerden grown with forest, Parabraunerden (agriculture use or forest) and Pararendzina's (agricultural use). The climate of the Kraichgau is warm and dry (semi-continental). Mean annual precipitation as displayed in table 1 is 806 mm. The precipitation of the period June till August is dominated by high-energy storms. Snow cover and soil frost
925 m a y occur from December till March.
Table 1 Climatological
data for station H e i d e l b e r g
Month
J
F
M
A
M
J
J
A
S
0
N
D
YEAR
Tmean Tmax Tmin Prec
1.3 3.6 -1.4 66
2.4 5.3 -0.8 52
6.7 10.9 2.6 45
10.7 15.6 6.1 61
15.0 20.4 9.9 73
18.1 23.4 12.9 90
19.8 25.1 14.8 87
19.0 24.4 14.8 90
15.8 20.8 11.6 65
10.6 14.5 7.2 62
6.1 8.5 3.6 60
2.4 4.5 0.0 55
10.7 14.8 6.7 806
~ ~ ~ mm
Source: Mfiller (1979)
T e m p e r a t u r e d a t a from table 1 are t a k e n from Mfiller (1979). M e a n a n n u a l t e m p e r a t u r e for station Heidelberg is 10.7 ~ The w a r m e s t m o n t h is July, average t e m p e r a t u r e 19.8 ~ the coldest m o n t h is J a n u a r y , average t e m p e r a t u r e 1.3 ~ The a n n u a l m e a n m i n i m u m t e m p e r a t u r e is 6.7 ~ the a n n u a l m e a n m a x i m u m t e m p e r a t u r e is 14.8 ~ Climatic d a t a of the Jfilicher BSrde are t a k e n from Mfiller (1979) as displayed in table 2.
Table 2.2 Climatological
data of station Aachen.
Month
J
F
M
A
M
J
J
A
S
0
N
D
YEAR
Tmean Tmax Tmin Prec
1.8 4.2 -0.9 72
2.2 5.1 -0.7 59
5.6 9.9 2.0 49
8.9 13.5 4.8 63
12.9 17.8 8.1 67
16.0 20.8 11.4 77
17.6 22.3 13.3 75
17.2 22.2 13.3 82
14.5 19.5 10.9 68
i0.i 14.0 6.9 64
6.0 8.6 3.6 67
3.1 5.2 0.7 62
9.7 13.6 6.1 805
Source: Mfiller (1979)
The m e a n a n n u a l precipitation is 805 mm, with a m a x i m u m m e a n in A u g u s t of 82 m m , and the driest m o n t h is March with 49 mm. The period from J u n e to August is dominated by high-intensity storms, with a m o n t h l y m a x i m u m total of 82 m m in August. The a n n u a l m e a n t e m p e r a t u r e is 9.7 ~ the m e a n t e m p e r a t u r e of the w a r m e s t m o n t h (July) is 17.6 ~ the coldest m o n t h is J a n u a r y with a m o n t h l y m e a n t e m p e r a t u r e of 1.8 ~ The effect of climate on soil s t r u c t u r e was studied on a meso-scale by comparing loess soils on north- and south-facing slopes with m i n i m u m variation of geology and topography. Besides climatologically induced variations, also differences in soil s t r u c t u r e between land use types (arable land and forest) and between surface soil and subsoil were investigated.
926 Soil samples were tested on presence of lime, organic carbon content (Allison, 1935), aggregate stability (Low, 1954; Grieve, 1979; Imeson and Vis, 1984), soil texture and micro-aggregation (Edwards and Bremner, 1967; Imeson and Vis, 1984). Results of the drop test of Low were transformed to the AS-index of aggregate stability (Hollemans and Van Dijk, 1988). Aggregate stability can be expressed as the reciprocal of AS. With statistical methods of data analysis (cluster analysis, Analysis of Variance, Mann-Whitney U-test; see Davis 1986) differences between groups of samples were evaluated.
3. R E S U L T S
The statistical analysis of the relations between environmental factors and soil structure stability of loess soils shows that the direct and indirect effects of temperature on
20 o~
16
.~-
12
_.< o ~
,. ................................................................
,<>..............
9
8
~
4
~'
,s
,,
;,'.~ ............................... o
I--A-ARABLE I .................................. -*-FOREST ....... .',, .............................................................................................
o
',,
,
............... i:: ........................................................................................................
........................ i ............ ;:;" .......
.i
,"
<
;- ........................
_
9. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
, ...........................
9...........................
:
:
}
~.
k,
.,,
North Northeast
; ...........................
~
~
"'--~'"
1 ......................................................
.~
East Southeast South Southwest West Northwest Slope aspect
Figure 1 Aggregate stability of agricultural soils and forest soils grouped to aspect
927 aggregate stability is difficult to recognize in the field 9 The mean values of aggregate stability of arable surface soils do not vary for slopes having different aspects (figure 1). For forest topsoils the values of aggregate stability vary widely with aspect. The results as displayed in figure i suggest that forest soils are stable on south-east facing slopes, and have minimum stability on north facing slopes. There is no clear recognizable pattern of variation of aggregate stability with slope aspect. There is a strong and significant relationship (R = -0.82) between the index of aggregate stability (AS) and soil organic carbon content. After log-transforming the data to stabilize the variances of both variables (Davis, 1986), the regression equation is: (1)
LOG(AS) = 0.099 - 1.138 LOG(%C)
AS decreases with increasing carbon content, which means that aggregates become more stable with increasing carbon content of the soil (figure 3).
9 8
o~
7
9o
6
>,, .m
...................
! ..........................................................................
I ......................................
1 ......................................
( ..................
i ......................................
i~ ...................
iiii!iiill............. iiiiiiiii ii i
5 4 3
,L
2
<
1 0
..................
i
arable Topsoils
............
forest
pasture LAN DUSE
Figure 2 Aggregate stability grouped to land use
sub arable
sub forest Subsoils
928 From figure 2 the influence on aggregate stability of land use is obvious: forest surface soils are most stable, while arable surface soils have more stable aggregates t h a n subsoils. The aggregate stability of surface soils under pasture is between t h a t of forest and arable soils. The variation of temperature and soil moisture due to different aspect of valley slopes showed no good correlation with aggregate stability.
3
~ , I Q I
2 ........... ;"-""~~ o-=.--.~, .... i" ~ ' ~o'~" ~..i
1 ~
~"
0
~
,
i
Oo, :
:
0i
....
i ....
i ....
i ....
i ....
i ....
o~{,~ ............. i ................. } ................ + ................ i ................. {.................
""-.".
i
-..~...,ooo o
i
i
i
,
....... o ~ ~
i
,
,
.................~.................~.................
................. } ................ !---:-: ......... !.........
............
.................
.................................................................................................~ ' ~ ]
~-1 ___0
'
]
i
L
i
'
~9"oi
-2
...................................................g ................................................................... o ....... i....."-:.7
-3
.................................................... ].................................................................... ~.o.............~................
ooo
o
-4 ............................................ -2.5 -2 -1.5 -1 -0.5 log(organic
.....
i
o
0
0.5
carbon)
%
1
~
1.5
2
Regression 95%confid.
Figure 3 Relation between organic carbon content and aggregate stability index Table 1 Index land use
l a n d use Arable Forest Pasture subsoil arable subsoil forest all s a m p l e s
of aggregate
stability
of soils
JQlicher B~rde
Kraichgau
AS
AS
1.56 0.43 0.57 4.58 6.60 2.75
1.61 0.29 0.61 5.41 6.61 2.91
from
two
sample
areas
grouped
to
929 The aggregate stability of soils of two different areas is listed in table 1. The difference of means of aggregate stability calculated for 5 groups of land use was not significantly different for areas under different climate. The mean of aggregate stability for all groups indicated that soils in the Kraichgau area (with w a r m e r and drier climate) are somewhat less stable than in the Jtilicher BSrde, but this difference was not significant on the a=0.05 level. However, as the tests give an indication of the present state, there still can be a difference between the development of aggregate stability, due to differences in climate. The present study of the effect of temperature variations on aggregate stability of loess soils shows that temperature does not have a significant influence on the structure stability of soils. Soil structure stability is strongly correlated with the soil organic carbon content, which is determined by the land use. According to the study of Veeneklaas et al (1994), climate change may have a profound effect on land use, thereby implicitly influencing soil properties as well.
4.
R
E
F
E
R
E
N
C
E
S
Allison, L.E. (1935): Organic carbon by reduction of chromic acid. Soil Sci. 40:pp.311-320 - Chaney, K. and R.S. Swift (1984): The influence of organic matter on aggregate stability in some British soils. Journal of Soil Science, 35, pp.223-230 - Clemens, G. and K. Stahr (1994): Present and past soil erosion rates in catchments of the Kraichgau area (SW-Germany). In: Catena 22 (1994) pp.153-168 - Davis, J.C. (1986): Statistics and data analysis in geology. 2nd edition. John Wiley & Sons, New York Chichester - Dikau, R. (1986): Experimentelle Untersuchungen zu Oberfl~ichenabfluss and Bodenabtrag von Messparzellen und landwirtschaftlichen Nutzfl~ichen. Heidelberger Geographischen Arbeiten Heft 81. Heidelberg, Germany - Edwards, A.P. and J.M. Bremner (1967): Dispersion of soil particles by sonic vibration. J. Soil Sc.18:47-63 - Grieve, I.C. (1979): -
930 Soil aggregate stability tests for the geomorphologist. Technical Bulletin 25. British Geomorphological Research Group Hollemans, W. and P. van Dijk (1988): Faktoren van invloed op infiltratie en bodemerosie. Regionale vergelijking tussen drie gebieden in zuid-limburg. Fysisch Geografisch & bodemkundig laboratorium, Universiteit van Amsterdam (In Dutch) Imeson, A.C. and M. Vis (1984): Assessing soil aggregate stability by water-drop impact and ultrasonic dispersion. Geoderma, 34:85-100 - Jenkinson, D.S. and A. Ayanaba (1977): Decomposition of Carbon-14 Labeled plant material under tropical conditions. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J., Vol 41, pp912-915 - Low, A.J. (1954): The study of soil structure in the field and in the laboratory. Journal of Soil Science, 5, pp57-74 Mfiller, M.J. (1979): Handbuch ausgewahlter Klimastationen der Erde. Forschungsstelle Bodenerosion der Universit~it Trier Mertesdorf (Ruwertal) Oades, J.M. (1993): The role of biology in the formation, stabilization and degradation of soil structure. Geoderma 56, pp 377-400 - Schalich, J. (1981): Boden- und Landschaftsgeschichte in der westlichen Niederrheinischen Bucht. In: Fortschr. Geol. Rheinld. u. Westf. 29, pp 505-518 Tate III, R.L. (1987): Soil organic Matter. Biological and ecological effects. J. Wiley & sons Tisdall, J.M. and J.M. Oades (1982): Organic matter and water-stable aggregates in soils. Journal of soil science 33 pp 141-163 Veeneklaas, F.R., L.M. van den Berg, D. Slothouwer and G.F.P. IJkelenstam (1994): Rhine Basin study: Land use projections based on biophysical and socio-economic analyses. Volume 4, Land use: past, present and future. Report 85.4, Winand Staring Centre (SC-DLO), Wageningen, the Netherlands - Wischmeier, W.H. and D.D. Smith (1978): Predicting rainfall erosion losses - a guide to conservation planning. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Agriculture Handbook No. 537
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Climate Change Research: Evaluation and Policy Implications S. Zwerver, R.S.A.R. van Rompaey, M.T.J. Kok and M.M. Berk, (Eds.) 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
931
T h e i m p a c t o f c l i m a t e c h a n g e on the s e d i m e n t a t i o n rates on the e m b a n k e d floodplains in the Netherlands H. Middelkoop Department of Physical Geography, Utrecht University, P.O. Box 80.115, 3508 TC Utrecht, The Netherlands
Abstract
Sedimentation on the embanked floodplains in the Netherlands was studied on different time scales. Many sections of the embanked floodplain along the river Waal were formed only during the past centuries. Spatial differences in floodplain sedimentation rates were investigated using heavy metals as a tracer. Average sedimentation rates during the past decennia range between 2 and >15 mm/yr, depending on the floodplain topography. Present sedimentation rates were measured using sediment traps. Sediment accumulation decreases exponentially with distance from the river channel; relatively large amounts of sediment are deposited in depressions. The effects of the IPCC BaU climate scenario on floodplain sedimentation were evaluated in detail for a small floodplain section, and for the entire Waal floodplain. The results indicate that a climate change alone will increase floodplain sedimentation by at least 50%; the yearly average sediment load transported over the entire Waal floodplain becomes more than three times as large as at present.
1. INTRODUCTION The increased emission of CO2 and other greenhouse gases into the lower atmosphere is expected to lead to a warming of the earth's surface. This greenhouse effect may cause a world-wide climate change in the forthcoming decades, resulting in a.o. changes in temperature, precipitation and evaporation. A climate change will affect the river Rhine discharge regime and the suspended sediment load transported into the Netherlands. As a result, the sedimentation rates on the embanked floodplains in the Netherlands may change. For the assessment of the impact of climate change the IPCC scenario BaU-best (Kwadijk, 1993) is used. Kwadijk (1993) investigated the expected changes in the discharge of the river Rhine and its tributaries using the RHINEFLOW model. Asselman (1994) described the relation between discharge and suspended sediment load by a sediment rating curve. Changes in sediment production may change the present Sediment rating curves. Asselman (1994) defined four sediment rating scenarios associated with different combinations of the BaU climate scenario and land use changes, resulting in different sediment rating curves for the Rhine at the Dutch-German border. In this project the sedimentation on the embanked floodplains is investigated. Past and present sedimentation rates are reconstructed using various methods, and the possible effects of climate change on future floodplain sedimentation are investigated (Middelkoop, 1994). The objectives of this study were to assess: - the sedimentation rate on the embanked floodplains in the Netherlands in relation to flooding-frequencies during the past decennia, and centuries,
932 the spatial variability of floodplain sedimentation, quantitative relationships between sedimentation rates and (1) floodplain morphology and (2) the characteristics of flood periods, and - possible effects of climate change on future floodplain sedimentation. -
-
The sedimentation on the embanked floodplains was studied from different points of view and on various temporal and spatial scales. The investigated floodplain sections are shown in figure 1. The effects of the BaU climate scenario were investigated for a small floodplain section using the WAQUA-DELWAQ model, and for the entire Waal floodplain using the average sediment discharge as an estimator for potential sedimentation.
0
100km
... ~
~" ~
Z voile E
":~:~:~:~:~:~:~:::
~:
N
:
::::i~:::::: ........ ::::::::::::::::::::::
::iii.i:...
.=
~> ,
.E "1o
X
X
X
X
X
' ~.-
:i:~i:iJ:i::~
~..
X Arnhem
Variksche Plaat ' ~ I ~ ~ r
~
~
~
~
~
"
f
9
~se
. -
.... K e e n t /
J~::.-|~
o_
Lobith
.......
o .....!..
Nijmdt]en
..~_~ --
X
.:::, o
~o ~m
~''";~':=
x = method applied at floodplain section [ ij~iii~i~i~i~!~i] floodplains
Figure 1. Study area and location of investigated floodplain sections. 2. FLOODPLAIN
GEOMORPHOLOGY
AND
GENESIS
The genesis and geomorphology of the embanked floodplains were investigated by geomorphologic mapping and corings, and by analysis of old river maps and historic records of water levels. Old river maps provide a rough indication of the beginning of sedimentation on the enclosed floodplains. The present embanked floodplains along the rivers Rhine and Meuse consist of point bars of meandering rivers as well as lateral bars separated by side channels. Many lateral bars were formed only during the last two to three centuries. Lateral bars are mainly found along the river Waal. The development of lateral bars is related to land reclamation from the river bed. Using old maps, a succession scheme was developed showing the stages of development of lateral bars, side channels and vegetation (Middelkoop et al., 1992). Assuming that the yearly sedimentation rate is proportional to the product of inundation time and suspended sediment concentration it was found that at the beginning of the floodplain formation the sedimentation rates were 3 to 4 times as great as at present, and varied between 1 and 3 cngyear.
933 3. R E C O N S T R U C T I O N OF F L O O D P L A I N S E D I M E N T A T I O N RATES USING HEAVY METALS AS A T R A C E R The river Rhine sediments that are deposited on the embanked floodplains in the Netherlands are contaminated with pollutants, including heavy metals. The heavy metals in the floodplain soil profiles were used as a tracer to calculate floodplain sedimentation rates. Sediment accumulated in dike-breach ponds was analysed to reconstruct changes in heavy metal pollution of the river Rhine sediment during the past 200 - 300 years. From historic dates, Pb-210 dates, palynological information and variations in sediment compaction, a timedepth control of the sediment fill of the dike-breach ponds was obtained. The reconstructed changes in the heavy metal pollution of the Rhine sediment are shown in figure 2. The heavy metal pollution increased during the first half of this century; maximum pollution occurred around 1960; since 1970 the heavy metal pollution has strongly decreased. From various sections of the embanked floodplains, samples from vertical soil profiles were collected and their heavy metal content was measured. The samples were taken from sites with different inundation frequencies, local elevations, and distances to the main channel. The heavy metal content of floodplain soils was related to these factors. Average sedimentation rates during the past decades were reconstructed by comparing the heavy metal profiles in the floodplain soils with the pollution history of the Rhine. The heavy metal profiles obtained from the floodplain soils generally have the same shape as the pollution curve reconstructed from the dike-breach pond sediment. Depending on the sedimentation rate, the vertical profile is more or less stretched, and the total heavy metal content varies (figure 3). The total soil pollution can be very different from the pollution in the upper 10 cm. The sedimentation rates for the past decennia that were estimated from the heavy metal profiles range between 2 and > 15 mm/yr.
(Jrl 0 0
0 0 0
._L 01 0 0
I~ 0 0 0
tO 0 0
0 1980 1
1960 1940
2
I
...... ,~-;~- ....... ..i-:........... J,........... 4............ 1920 1900
3
average sedimentation rates (mm/yr):
,50
4
o "13 :3"
2-4 -
s
~s
v3
o 0
o 0
o 0
200
9
15-18
i
Cd, Cu, Pb (mg /kg )
Figure 2. Heavy metal pollution history of the river Rhine reconstructed from a dike-breach pond along the river Waal.
Figure 3. Zinc profiles of floodplain soils as a result of different sedimentation rates.
934
4. PRESENT FLOODPLAIN SEDIMENTATION RATES Present floodplain sedimentation rates and their spatial variability were measured after the two floods of 1993 and one flood in 1994 using a total of about 800 sediment traps of artificial grass. Measurements from the individual traps were interpolated using block-kriging to create raster maps of sediment accumulation (figure 4). The patterns shown on the maps were correlated with floodplain morphology and sedimentation mechanisms (Asselman & Middelkoop, in press.).
0,
....
>1.0 kg/m 2 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 500 m
....~:~;!!!!!!i!i;ii~.:.. ===================================== 9. ~ .-.
>9.0 k g / m 2 8.0 7.0 6.0 5.0 4.0 3.0 2.0 1.0
sand sheet
B. K e e n t - D e c e m b e r 1993.
A. K e e n t - J a n u a r y 1 9 9 3 .
5.5 k g / m 2
2.4 kg/m 2
i
1.8
.... ~9 i 'iiii!ili%~.iiiiiiiiii!iiii!:'
1.5
4.5 5.0 4.0 3.5 3.0
.......-:i:i:i" "
1.2 0.9 0.6 0.3 0.0
i
C. VarikschePlaat- January1993.
2.5
:.:.!
, iiiiiil}iiP"i iiiiiiiIiiii} 500 m
:.
..-.-.:,-.:.:.:.-.'..-,:.-. D. V a r i k s c h e P l a a t - D e c e m b e r
1993.
Figure 4. Sediment accumulation after a single flood, measured by sediment traps. January 1993: minor flood; December 1993: extreme flood.
During the flood, sand is locally deposited directly behind a levee. The amount of deposited (fine) sand decreases exponentially with distance from the levee. This pattern agrees well with existing diffusion models. At distances larger than 50 to 100 m from the river channel the accumulated sediment consists mainly of material < 53~. Here, differences in sediment accumulation are determined by the local topography, which causes differences in inundation times and ponding (figure 4c). The total amounts of suspended sediment < 531.t deposited in the investigated floodplain sections during the high flood of December 1993 ranged between 1.20 and 3.98 kg/m 2 along the river Waal, and between 1.0 and 2.0 kg/m 2 in the study areas along the river Meuse. Equivalent thicknesses of sediment accumulation during the flood ranged between 0.8 mm and 3.2 mm in the central parts of the floodplain sections. The estimated total amount of suspended sediment deposited during the flood on the entire river Waal floodplain was 0.24 Mton. This is about 19% of the total suspended sediment load transported through the river Waal in the same period. It is 7.7% of the average yearly load of suspended sediment transported by the river Rhine into the Netherlands. Comparison of sediment accumulation of different floods shows that the amount of sediment deposited on a floodplain increases less than proportionally with the flood magnitude.
935 5. I M P A C T OF C L I M A T E CHANGE ON FLOODPLAIN SEDIMENTATION RATES 5.1 L o c a l s e d i m e n t a t i o n rates
Sedimentation on a small floodplain section was simulated using the 2-dimensional WAQUA-DEWAQ model (Ubels, 1986). For a series of stationary discharge stages, the average yearly sediment accumulation was calculated by multiplying the sedimentation rates by the associated frequency of occurrence and suspended sediment concentration. The total yearly sedimentation is the summed total of the products. Sedimentation rates under changed climate conditions were calculated by using the BaU flow duration curve (Kwadijk & Middelkoop, 1994) and using the sediment rating curves provided by Asselman (1994). The WAQUA-DELWAQ model demonstrates that sedimentation becomes very ineffective at high discharges (figure 5). Preliminary results indicate that under the BaU climate scenario the sedimentation rate in the test area increases by only 3% if both climate and land use change. A climate change alone, however, increases the sedimentation rates by about 50%. Sedimentation rates will increase much more on floodplain sections behind a minor dike and where sedimentation only occurs during relatively high discharges.
tonh
kg/m2/yr
reference scenario 8.00
present
6.00
auton, land use change only
4.00
climate scenario
2.00
=
BaU-climate
.t
BaU-climate + land use
0.00 3500
i i [ [ i ........i - - - - ~ ..................................
4500
5500
6500
7500
.
o o
8500
discharge (m3/s)
Figure 5. Effective sedimentation on a low floodplain section for different discharges.
.
o o
.
o o
.
.o o
.
o o
o o
~
~
o o o
o o o
Rhine discharge (m3/s)
Figure 6. Sediment load transported over the embanked floodplains for different scenarios.
5.2 Sensitivity of large scale potential s e d i m e n t a t i o n rates
The potential sensitivity of the sedimentation rate on the entire embanked Waal floodplain for a climate change was investigated from changes in the annual amount of river sediment load that is transported over the embanked floodplain. The 1-dimensional SOBEK model (Huyskens & Barneveld, 1994) was used to calculate for a series of discharge stages the percentage of the river discharge transported over the embanked Waal floodplain. At each stage, the sediment load transported over the floodplain was calculated from the product of (1) the discharge, (2) the suspended sediment concentration and (3) the relative frequency of occurrence. The summed totals of the product for all discharges gives the average yearly load,
936 expressed in Mton/yr. This is the amount of sediment is potentially available for deposition. The effect of the BaU discharge scenario and four sediment rating scenarios on this sediment load was calculated to investigate the possible impact on floodplain sedimentation. The BaU climate scenario will increase the average sediment load transported across the floodplains by a factor 3.5 compared to the present situation and by a factor 3.2 compared to the situation with autonomous land use changes (figure 6). The changes in effective sediment deposition will be smaller than the changes in the sediment load. 6. CONCLUSIONS The present floodplain geomorphology comprises both pointbars of meandering rivers and lateral bars that have been formed during the past centuries. Floodplain sedimentation depends on floodplain characteristics, discharge frequency distributions and sediment concentrations, and therefore shows a high variability in time and space. Present floodplain sedimentation rates range between 0.5 and 15 mm per year. The effect of the BaU climate change on floodplain sedimentation are considerable. High discharges will occur more frequently and sediment concentrations are expected to increase as a result of climate change. Under the BaU climate scenario, the yearly amount of sediment transported over the embanked Waal floodplain is more than three times as large as under present climate conditions. The increase of the effective sedimentation rates will be smaller, depending on the type of floodplain section. Sedimentation rates are expected to increase at least by about 50% on floodplain sections directly bordering the main channel and without a summer dike. The sedimentation rate on floodplains that are situated behind a summer dike is expected to increase more than 50%. If also the effect of changes in land use are taking into account, changes for low lying floodplains are insignificant. Nevertheless, the average sediment load transported over the entire floodplain increases still by a factor 2.8.
REFERENCES
Asselman, N.E.M., 1994: The impact of climate change on suspended sediment transport in the river Rhine. Department of Physical Geography, Universiteit Utrecht. Asselman, N.E.M. & H. Middelkoop, in press.: Floodplain sedimentation: Quantities, patterns and processes. Accepted for publication in: Earth Surface Processes and Landforms. Huyskens, R.B.H. & H.J. Barneveld, 1994: Sobek-model voor de Nederlandse Rijntakken. Rapport Q 1895, WL. Kwadijk, J.C.J., 1993: The impact of climate change on the discharge of the River Rhine, Thesis. Universiteit Utrecht. Kwadijk, J.C.J. & H. Middelkoop, 1994: Estimation of the impact of climate change on the peak discharge probability of the River Rhine. Climatic Change, Vol.27, issue 2, pp. 199-224. Middelkoop, H., N.J. van den Berg, E.L.J.H. Faessen & H.J.A. Berendsen, 1992: Morfodynamiek van nevengeulen van de Waal: een historisch overzicht. Vakgroep Fysische Geografie, Universiteit Utrecht, Rapport GEOPRO 1992.07. Middelkoop, H., 1994: The impact of climate change on the sedimentation rates on the embanked floodplains in the Netherlands. Report of the NRP-project NOLK/002/90. Department of Physical Geography, Universiteit Utrecht. Ubels, J.W., 1986: Verantwoording van het hoogwateronderzoek op de Boven-Rijn, de Waal, het Pannerdensch Kanaal, de Neder-Rijn, de Lek en de IJssel. Nota nr. 86.035. DBW/RIZA, Arnhem.
Climate Change Research: Evaluation and Policy Implications S. Zwerver, R.S.A.R. van Rompaey, M.T.J. Kok and M.M. Berk, (Eds.) 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
937
The impact of climate change on suspended sediment transport in the river Rhine Nathalie E.M. Asselman Department of Physical Geography, Utrecht University, PO Box 80.115, 3508 TC Utrecht, The Netherlands
Abstract Erosion, transport and deposition of fine suspended sediments are both directly and indirectly influenced by climate conditions. In this study, the suspended sediment transport regime of the river Rhine under present and future climate conditions was assessed. The impact of climate change on the sediment transport regime was investigated using sediment rating curves in combination with flow duration curves, developed using the BaU-climate scenario, and three sediment production scenarios. The results indicate that a climate change under changed land use conditions will result in a 14% increase in total annual suspended sediment load. A larger part of the yearly sediment load will be transported at discharges over 4000 m3/s. This probably results in increased floodplain sedimentation rates.
1. INTRODUCTION The increased emission of C O 2 and other greenhouse gases during the 20th century, is expected to enhance the greenhouse warming of the lower atmosphere. This may cause a world-wide climate change in the forthcoming decades, resulting in changes in temperature and precipitation. The climate induced changes in vegetation cover and water discharge in turn will affect erosion, transport and deposition of suspended sediments in the river Rhine. Within the scope of the National Research Program (NRP 1) the impact of climate change on discharge, and the suspended sediment transport regime of the river Rhine was studied. The IPCC "Business as Usual" (BaU) scenario projected on the Rhine catchment, was used as climate change scenario (Kwadijk, 1993). The aim of this study is to investigate the processes of sediment transport through the river Rhine under actual climate conditions, and to assess the effect of climate change on the suspended sediment transport regime, depending on changes in discharge and sediment supply to the rivers.
938 2. M E T H O D S
Since wash load is a non capacity load, the amount of fine suspended sediment transported by the river Rhine depends on the availability of loose material and to a lesser extent on the capability of the river to transport this material. Therefore, sediment transport rates cannot be calculated using stream power related transport formulas. Instead, the so-called rating curve technique can be used. A sediment rating curve describes the average relation between discharge and suspended sediment concentration. The most commonly used relationship between discharge and suspended sediment concentration is a rating curve in the form of a power function (a.o. Walling, 1974). In this study a power function with additive constant term was used: c = /9 + a . Q b where c is suspended sediment concentration (mg/1), Q is river discharge (m3/s) and a, b and p are regression coefficients. Sediment rating curves were developed for five gauging stations along the river Rhine (figure 1), using daily discharge and suspended sediment concentration data, measured by the Bundesanstalt fir Gewisserkunde (BfG), Germany.
iiiiiii iiii!iiii \
o
,00k=
t...i,
ERMANY ~ / /
o
..
N .
ANDERNACH-WEISSEI~THURM~ ~ k~.,/..~-"'--" ,J 2'/"
KAuB
~
....I,..'
i
< ~ , < ~ '-7/ "t. <. III
,.~,,.~.,,'~
....
",-..,,,,,. .........-.,t',~.
777 J
~.. L|
7/
~.., ........
Figure 1. Location of the gauging stations.
""
~'~.'\.,.~
.,
,
"'"-/)' \
"',,~n
"
939 The amount of sediment transported at a certain discharge is given by the sediment rating curve. The frequency of occurrence of a certain discharge is given by the discharge frequency distribution. Both curves were combined to obtain the sediment discharge curve. This curve shows at which discharges most suspended sediment transport takes place. Changes in the sediment discharge regime were studied using the flow duration curve and sediment rating curves, developed in accordance with the BaU climate scenario. Monthly scenario discharges were calculated by Kwadijk (1993). The monthly average discharge values were converted into daily discharges using statistical methods based on the method described by Kwadijk and Middelkoop (1994). Changes in suspended sediment production by soil erosion in the Rhine basin under BaU climate and land use conditions were assessed using the Universal Soil Loss Equation (USLE) (Wischmeier and Smith, 1978). Three sediment production scenarios were used, each resulting in a different sediment rating curve. These sediment rating curves were combined with the BaU flow duration curve to obtain sediment discharge curves. The sediment discharge curves show the changes that are expected to occur in the sediment transport regime of the Rhine, when climate changes in accordance with the BaU scenario. For Rees, near the Dutch-German border (figure 1), the following sediment transport scenarios were used: 1) Sediment loads are determined by hydraulic properties of the river, as shown by the sediment rating curve developed for present climate conditions. This rating curve remains valid under changed climate conditions. Changes in sediment production in upstream areas have no direct effect on the sediment load near Rees. 2) Sediment loads are determined by the erosion rates in upstream parts of the river basin under BaU climate, and present land use conditions. 3) Sediment loads are determined by erosion rates in upstream parts of the river basin, as expected for the BaU climate and land use scenario. 4) Sediment loads are determined by changes in sediment production due to autonomous changes in land use, no climate change is taken into account. This scenario is used as a reference scenario to evaluate the effect of climate change under changed land use conditions.
3. RESULTS The sediment rating curves developed for the selected gauging stations are shown in figure 2. The sediment rating curves can be used to obtain information on the availability of sediment in a certain area in combination with the erosive power of the river itself. Steep rating curves, as observed near Rheinfelden, are characteristic for river sections with little sediment transport taking place at low discharge. An increase in discharge results in a large increment of suspended sediment concentrations, indicating that the power of the river to erode material during high discharge periods is great, or that important sediment sources become available when the water level rises. Flat rating curves, as found near Rees, are characteristic for river sections with intensively weathered materials or loose sedimentary deposits, which can be transported at all discharges. The constant p-coefficient can be seen as a background concentration, a minimum concentration of suspended sediment occurring at very low discharges. Since the
940
steepness of the rating curve decreases in a downstream direction, it can be concluded that (1) the importance of high discharge events in transporting suspended sediment decreases in a downstream direction, and that (2) near the Dutch-German border large quantities of fine material are available for transport at all discharges.
250
%
............ Rheinf. (km 145) ...... Maxau (km 362) - - - Bach./Kaub (km 545) -- -- Weiss./And. (km 607) Rees/Emm. (km 837)
/ 200
-
...
.,I
i
-
= 150
,4 4"
r
o ,~..~
"~ 100
.." .."
r
. O
," ~
,"
sj
s"/
~.f
50
0
2000
Figure 2.
4000 6000 Discharge (m3/s)
8000
10000
Sediment rating curves developed for several gauging stations along the river Rhine, under actual climate conditions.
C (mg/1) & f(Q) (d/yr) 160 C
*s S . S
120
""A
T (Mt/yr) Suspended sediment transport (Mt/yr) - 0.5 0.5 present scen. 1 ........ - 0.4 0.4 f~ scen. 2 -- __.. ,,~ scen. 3 - scen4
80 -
0.2 0.2
-
0.1 0.1
4O i
0 mo
,
,
,
i
|
2000 4000 6000 8000 1000012000 Discharge (m3/s)
Figure 3.
0
/i,;
-
-2-
"
....."\
".....~
"'.
~ :""'~ " -- ......
.~--~.~..
0 '~,'r . . . . . -. . . . 0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000 12()00 B. Discharge (m3/s)
Sediment discharge curves developed for Rees under present and BaU climate conditions. a) present climate conditions (n: suspended sediment concentrations (mg/1); B: frequency of occurrence of daily discharges (d/yr); c: suspended sediment transport (Mt/yr)). b) according to several sediment transport scenarios.
941 Figure 3a shows the sediment rating curve (A), the discharge frequency distribution (B), and the sediment discharge curve (C), developed for Rees under present climate conditions. The sediment discharge curve shows that under present climate conditions, most suspended sediment is transported at moderate discharges, with a high frequency of occurrence. The sediment discharge curves developed for the different sediment transport scenarios are shown in figure 3b. The results are summarized in table 1. According to all scenarios, the importance of high discharge events in transporting suspended sediment will increase. This is mainly related to the expected changes in the discharge frequency distribution. The total annual sediment loads are different for each scenario. The impact of climate change on sediment transport rates under future land use conditions can best be assessed by comparing scenarios 3 and 4. This comparison shows that a climate change as assumed in the BaU climate scenario, will result in a 14% increase in the total annual suspended sediment load near Rees. The suspended sediment load transported at discharges over 4000 m3/s, when several floodplains along the Dutch part of the river Rhine are inundated, will increase by about 47% from 0.66 to 0.97 Mt/yr.
Table 1 Sediment transport rates using four sediment transport scenarios Scenario
present la lb 2 3 4
p
29 29 27 38 15 14
Total load
Q > 4000
Q > 6000
%
Mt/yr
%
Mt/yr
%
Mt/yr
100 106 100 125 72 64
3.04 3.21 3.04 3.81 2.20 1.93
28 38 38 36 44 34
0.85 1.22 1.16 1.37 0.97 0.66
12 17 18 16 21 16
0.36 0.55 0.55 0.61 0.46 0.31
p = background concentration (mg/1) total load = annual suspended sediment load in % of present transport and Mt/yr Q > 4000 = percentage of average annual sediment load transported at Q > 4000 m3/s Q > 6000 = percentage of average annual sediment load transported at Q > 6000 m3/s Steepness of the rating curve is kept constant with a = 1.96"10 -6 and b = 1.93
4. CONCLUSIONS When climate changes in accordance with the BaU scenario, the annual suspended sediment load near Rees is expected to decrease by about 28% compared to the present load. However, the impact of climate change on the suspended sediment loads is best assessed by comparison of scenarios 3 and 4. This comparison shows that a climate change in addition to autonomous changes in land use will result in a 14% higher annual suspended sediment load near Rees.
942 According to all sediment transport scenarios a larger part of the yearly suspended sediment load will be transported at discharges over 4000 m3/s, when inundation of low lying floodplains occurs. Under present climate conditions about 28% of the yearly sediment load is transported at discharges over 4000 ma/s, this will be over 40% when land use and climate change in accordance with the BaU scenario.
5. REFERENCES Asselman, N.E.M. (1994): The impact of climate change on suspended sediment transport in the river Rhine. Dept. of Physical Geography, Utrecht University. Kwadijk, J.C.J. (1993): The impact of climate change on the discharge of the River Rhine. Thesis, Utrecht University, 201 pp. Kwadijk, J.C.J. and H. Middelkoop (1994): Estimation of the impact of climate change on the peak discharge probability of the River Rhine. Climatic change, Vol. 27, 2, 199-224. Walling, D.E. (1974): Suspended sediment and solute yields from a small catchment prior to urbanization. In: K.J. Gregory and D.E. Walling (Ed.), Fluvial processes in instrumented watersheds, Institute of British Geographers special publication no. 6, London. Wischmeier, W.H. and D.D. Smith (1978): Predicting rainfall erosion losses - a guide to conservation planning. US Dept. of Agriculture, Agriculture Handbook No. 537.
Climate Change Research: Evaluation and Policy Implications S. Zwerver, R.S.A.R. van Rompaey, M.T.J. Kok and M.M. Berk, (Eds.) 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
943
Effect of sea-level rise and climate change on groundwater salinity and agro-hydrology in a low coastal region of the Netherlands L.C.P.M. Stuyt, P. Kabat, J. Postma and A.B. Pomper DLO Winand Staring Center for Integrated Land, Soil and Water Research, P.O. Box 125, 6700 AC Wageningen, The Netherlands.
Abstract Scenario studies to predict the effects of doubled CO 2 levels, a 1 ~ temperature increase and a 1.2 m sea-level rise on seepage, groundwater and crop production were carded out. Climatic change was simulated, showing increased precipitation. Simulation of effects of sea-level rise on groundwater flow and salt transport showed changes in seepage to be negligible. Simulated crop growth was increased significantly by temperature and CO 2 increase, without increased demand for irrigation.
1. INTRODUCTION Climate change will affect open water and groundwater levels and quality in coastal lowlying regions through sea-level rise and precipitation, and through changes in crop wateruse, enhanced by doubled CO 2 . These changes may cause changes in water management. Climate change was simulated using statistical weather relationships from the KNMI (3). Sea-level rise was simulated with the 2-D transient density-driven model MOC (4,5). Soil water dynamics and crop production were simulated using SWAP (2, 6).
2. METHODS 2.1. Climate Scenarios A climate scenario 1 ~ warmer then present was created with the climatic relationships from the KNMI, using data from the years 1966, 1976, 1979, 1985 and 1986, and called scenario(W). Radiation, humidity and wind and the pattern of rainfall are assumed to remain unchanged, CO 2 levels doubled. The present climate is scenario(P).
2.2. Groundwater Flow Modelling with MOC Voorne-Putten, in the SW of the Netherlands, was selected for modelling as it lies at the coast, below sea level, with saline seepage. Dunes form the Western end. Groundwater flow was simulated with MOC 3.0 of 1989, a transient solute transport model. To suit the model for vertical application, density driven groundwater flow was added. The grid used is 100 by 20, west-to-east, 200 m deep and 25 km long. transversal to longitudinal conductivity and dispersivity ratios were set to 0.1. The boundary conditions imposed were:
944 -
The vertical boundaries have constant piezometric levels. The upper boundary has constant phreatic levels in the polders, in the dunes there is a constant groundwater recharge (180 mm.yr-1). The geometry of the cross-section is shown below. -
/// dunes / f ~
Northsea
}
KrefteN~ye F. (20 m/d)
"
~/////////////////////////////~ Kedichem F. (0.002 m/d)
8 to
dikes
I ~ l ~ r s (0.0 to - 2 . 0 m) below ~ea level Dumkerke F (multtple ks)
i~lll
Spui
8
rr~ine Me~ssluis F. 110 m/d)
AI[NIIIIII
MOC
(200--x- 10 rrO
25
<
SWAP profiles for e r ~
km
......... >
I~eX:lu~tlon
~".~/z~
E
1
aqud:ard
boundary . . . . . . . . . prescribed pressure and salt b o ~ r t e s (MOC) . . . . . . . hyclrobia layer (0.01 m/d} marine Maassluts F, (10 m/d): name of forrnatton (wtth 10ermeablltty)
Fig. 1 The sub-soil of Voorne-Putten partitioned into aquifers and aquitards. Calibration was done for seepage with measured rates (7) by varying ksAT.
2.3. Calculating Crop Production with S W A P
Voorne-Putten was divided into 761 subareas, 461 of which are cultivated. Soil physical properties, open water levels, hydrological properties and land-use were established for each. Different crop-varieties chosen for scenario(W) to give a realistic yield, by adapting some of the physiological parameters of the crop models. An example is Table 1 for wheat. Table 1. Plant physiological parameters for scenario(W) in winter wheat (8,1). spec. light-use eft. max. assim pre-anthesis temp. sum surface leaf area (kg.ha-l.h -1 rate temp. sum until maturity resisi)(s (m2.kg-1) /J.m-2.s -1) (kg.ha-l.h -1) (~ (~ mScen.(P) Scen.(W)
18.0 14.4
0.45 0.55
40 80
1048 1290
1258 1171
40 44
Production of important crops was calculated, with scenario(P), calibrated with estimated
945
actual harvests and then calculated again with scenario(W).
3. RESULTS OF SIMULATIONS The effect of sea-level rise on seepage was assessed by comparing the results of two simulations. Both ran for 100 years, one with and one without sea-level rise. Figure 2 shows the resulting differences in groundwater salinity (mg/1). Seepage intensity increases, but is unimportant compared to the fresh water let in to maintain water quality. On crop growth, climatic change has opposing effects: higher respiration, a longer growing season and higher water-use efficiency. The net result is increased crop production, as an example shows in Table 2. Table 2. Average crop production (tons (dm) ha-l), for 1979, for scenario's (P)&(W), calculated with SWAP. sugarbeets potatoes scen.(P) scen.(W)
12.4 14.7
13.0 1.4.7
wheat
grass
6.8 10.1
9.8 12.0
REFERENCES
1. Boons-Prins, E.R., G.H.J. de Koning, C.A. van Diepen and F.W.T. Penning de Vries. 1993. Crop specific simulation parameters for yield forecasting across the European Community. Simulation reports CABO-TT, no. 32, CABO-DLO. Wageningen. 2. Feddes, R.A. and P. Kabat, (eds.) 1994. SWAP: a model to simulate the Soil_Water_Atmosphere_Plant interactions. Part I: Theory and model description. Simulation Monograph, Pudoc, Wageningen. (in prep). 3. Klein Tank, A.M.G. and T.A. Buishand. 1993. Modelling daily precipitation as a function of temperature for climate change impact studies. Scient. Rep. WR 93-02, KNMI. De Bilt. 4. Konikow, L.F. and J.D. Bredehoeft. 1978. Computer model of two-dimensional solute transport and dispersion in ground water. U.S. Geol. Surv. Techn. of Water Resour. Investigat., Book 7, Ch C2, 90 pp. 5. Oude Essink, G.H.P. 1993. Effect of Sea Level Rise on the Groundwater Flow System through Amsterdam Waterworks and Haarlemmemleer polder, The Netherlands. Proc. UNESCO Conf. on Sea Level Changes and their Consequences for Hydrology and Water Management, Noordwijkerhout, The Netherlands. 6. Supit, I., Hooijer, A.A., van Diepen, C.A. (Eds.), 1994. System description of the WOFOST 6.0 crop simulation model. SC-DLO, Wageningen (in prep). 7. Wit, K., 1987. Wateraanvoerbehoefte Zuidhollandse Eilanden en Waarden (Fresh water requirements of the south-western island and polders of Zuid Holland). I.C.W. Nota nr. 1801. SC-DLO, Wageningen. 8. Wolf, J., and Diepen, van, C.A. Effects of climate change on crop production and land use in the Rhine basin. In: Geijn, S.C., Goudriaan, J. and Berendse, F., editors. Climate change; crops and terrestrial ecosystems. Agrobiologische Thema's 9. 1993, CABO-DLO, Wageningen.
946
9
9
d "t:
0 ~
i:
o~.~
0
0 0
0 b~
0
~
.~-~
o~..~
6. ~
~q
~,~~,~,~ ,~,~,~,~
.....
...
.
",
..,
-..
9
.,
'
9
.....
,
.,,,
",
,
"
,,
"...
. -...
.
.
9 .
'
9
9
.
.
..
9
.
9
.
,..
-...
.
.-.
.
.
9
.
..
......
.
..
i.. . .
.
.
...
"...,..
.
.'.-I
. . .
i
.
9
.
i
..
.
,...,
.
..
....
.
i
9
.
.
.
,
- . . . "
,
,
1!!iiiii!ii!'
. /
.
~
I<
d
~i~ii~i~l!,iii ~I ~
:.:i-::.: :-i:.::-: ...:-::.: :.:::i ,:ij:::.:i::
'~:~', .... ~ ......... I
::::::::: -:::::I "
.......... ~.......... : .
'
i
~...... i).~ : ! : : . . . " . I " " . " ,
0
9
.
"
i
I , , , . ,
,
".
i
~!::::~i, :. i0,
~
~!:.
.:..
~ii
I ".
::!i;
{:. ':
.
"........ " 9
9
......
'
~,,~'!!,,,~,~i,~'~!i,~~ i li~i ! !!i!! t~
i!:..
...
:i::?
1.......,-::....-
:
"7..:::
'.
~ ~ .... :-""
0
o
~.~0i-~ ,~-i~-~:~.::~,., .!::iiii!ii:.i:.-. .
(!)
(I0-~
~
c~
i -~~
.7X ~ -
::::"'::::%L~,
lliiii-i<......
9
9
i:ii:i.)i:.. 2... i:i:}::}: "
"" '
....":.....': . . . 9
6:)
d
0 ~
d
~ 11)
d
Q
@ ~=
d
0
~~
d
0
~ i=~ x~
d
0
r~==
d
r
~ ~:=
d
9
0
d
<)
.............ii')~'~,),~il,i ~ ~ ~ I~:~~ i ~~~~ ~: ~:I~ ~~ =
<S) ~
UI)
d
~#l|
<~I
~@IiI U ~ |
d
I[
~-~
~=~
Climate Change Research: Evaluation and Policy Implications S. Zwerver, R.S.A.R. van Rompaey, M.T.J. Kok and M.M. Berk, (Eds.) 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
947
Impacts of changes in climate and socio-economic factors on land use in the Rhine basin" projections for the decade 2040-49 R.P. R6tter, F.R. Veeneklaas and C.A. van Diepen DLO, Winand Staring Centre, P.O. Box 125, 6700 AC Wageningen, NL
Abstract
The purpose of this study was to develop land use projections for the middle of the next century. To separate the influence of climate change from other factors on land use, projections (a Central Projection and two variants) were made under both unchanged and changed climate. They cover the plausible range of alternative land claims of agriculture and urbanization. Impacts of climate change on land suitability as well as overall changes in the acreages of several land use categories are presented.
1. BACKGROUND
AND
OBJECTIVES
Expected climate change might have a great impact on the discharge pattern of the river Rhine with consequences for agriculture, fresh-water supply, shipping, etc [1]. In addition to the direct effects of changes in temperature and precipitation, changes in land use may also affect the discharge regime through, for instance, changes in water extraction patterns over the season and shifts in the area of arable land. The current study is a contribution to the Climate Project of the International Commission for the Hydrology of the Rhine (CHR). At the request of of the Institute for Inland Water Management and Waste Water Treatment (RIZA), land use projections for the middle of the next century based on biophysical and socio-economic analyses were developed. Several projections were constructed for both unchanged and changed climate. Results will be used by hydrologists examining the possible consequences of changes in climate and land use for the discharge regime of the river Rhine. This paper presents some of the results from the Rhine basin study on land use projections, prepared by the DLO Winand Staring Centre [2-5]. The specific objectives of the Rhine basin study were: - to subdivide the Rhine basin into biophysically differentiated land types (current and future climate/soil/terrain combinations); - to calculate production potentials and associated water use of major crops (and forest types) for the predominant biophysical land types; - to assess actual land use; - to construct different projections of land use for the decade 2040-49: (a) without climate change, i.e. driven by socio-economic factors only, and (b) with climate change, i.e. driven by both climate change and socio-economic factors.
948 2. A P P R O A C H
The impact assessment approach combines results from biophysical and socio-economic analyses at various stages of constructing the projections. 2.1 Land suitability, crop yields and water use First, a biophysical classification system for the Rhine basin was designed, combining a bioclimatic classification adapted for present and possible future climates and a soil/terrain suitability grouping integrated in a geographical information system [2]. Subsequently, potential yields and water use were simulated for both unchanged and changed climate for the predominant biophysical land types and crops [3,4]. Under changed climate we refer to Table 1 and a CO2 concentration of 560 ppmv, based on a Business-as-Usual emission scenario [6], best estimate (BaU-best) as interpreted by [7] for the decade 2040-49.
Table 1 Expected changes in temperature and precipitation applied to the entire Rhine basin
Temperature (~ Precipitation (%)
Spring
Summer
Autumn
Winter
+1.75 0.00
+1.50 0.00
+1.75 0.00
+ 2.00 +10.00
2.2 Construction of land use projections For thirteen administrative regions, actual land use data were obtained from the latest land use statistics [5]. Based on analysis of technical restrictions, historical-trend analysis and basic assumptions regarding technical, political, demographic and political factors, a trend projection was carried out, the Central Projection of land use for both unchanged and changed climate. As much uncertainty occurred with respect to the basic assumptions, two variants to the Central Projection were constructed. The Plus Variant combines the highest claims of urbanization and agriculture, and the Minus Variant represents the lowest claims [5]. In constructing the projections it was assumed, that land use in the long run is demand-induced, and that claims on land of the various demand categories follow an explicit hierarchy: 1. Urban land needs (including nature claims formulated in official policy plans) 2. Agriculture - 2.1 Outdoor horticulture, permanent crops - 2.2 Root crops - 2.3 Cereals and oil-seeds. - 2.4 Grassland and fodder crops 3. Forestry & nature
The rationale behind this 'hierachy' is to be found in the price of land paid by these different land use categories and, for agriculture, in the profitability (per ha) of the various crops and in their land quality requirements.
949 3. RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS An increase in CO2 concentration to 560 ppmv combined with increased temperature and little change in precipitation (Table 1) does not curb crop yields, but improves the conditions for cultivating crops and tree species presently grown. Under baseline climate some ninety biophysical land types have been distinguished in the Rhine basin. Each of them is characterized by soil and terrain characteristics, three temperature characteristics and precipitation [2]. Shifts in their compositions, locations and acreages are considerable under changed climate. One illustrative example is type C2, L-mc/c4, characterized by soil/ terrain group C2 and bioclimatic type L-mc/c4. In soil group C2, orthic Luvisols and eutric Cambisols are clearly predominant and the average slope of land is less than 25 %. The bioclimatic type is characterized by 9.0-9.9 ~ annual mean temperature (L-), a mean annual temperature amplitude of 16.0-17.9 ~ (mc), January mean temperature of 0.0-1.4 ~ (c) and 600 - 799 mm mean annual precipitation (4). Under baseline climate, this biophysical land type covers 6426 km 2, i.e. about 3% of the total Rhine basin area, mainly found in France-Est, the Neckar region, Hessen and Nordrhein-Westfalen. Under changed climate (BaU-best), its area is reduced to 45 km 2, as soil group C2 located in France-Est, etc. then combines with warmer and less continental climates. In other areas with soil group C2 occurring (e.g. Alpenvorland), future temperature and/or precipitation conditions do not meet the criteria (L-mc/c4). Table 2 illustrates changes in average rainfed potential yields and water use of winter wheat for predominant soil/terrain/climate combinations.
Table 2 Selected biophysical land types (as defined in [2]) and associated simulated yields (rainfed potential yields) and crop evapotranspiration of winter wheat under baseline and changed climate (scenario BaU-best, 2040-2049) Biophysical land type
Grain yield (t/ha DM)
Evapotranspiration (mm)
baseline
changed c.
baseline
changed c.
baseline
changed c.
C1, Umc/d2 C2, L-mc/d2 C2, L-mc/c4 B, L-m/c4 B, Umc/d3 B, Mmc/c3 B , L-mc/c4 B, Mcm/d4 C2, L-m/b4
C1, Mmc/d2 C2, L*mc/c2 C2, L+m/b4 B, L+m/b3 B, Mmc/d3 B, L*mc/b3 B, L+m/b3 B, L*cm/c4 C2, L+m/a4
8.7 8.0 7.0 5.8 7.5 6.2 5.5 5.0 7.7
11.1 10.1 10.0 8.3 10.0 8.7 8.2 9.6 10.6
391 398 386 328 361 343 319 320 368
346 343 341 291 334 309 287 294 320
Table 3 summarizes the overall land use changes in the Rhine basin. It is mainly the acreage of cereals (including oil-seeds) leading to decreases in agricultural area: in the
950 Central Projection (CP) and the Plus Variant areas under these crops will be halved. In the Minus Variant the decrease ranges from 62% (unchanged climate) to 66% (changed climate). Climate change according to the BaU-best scenario adds a surplus (some 0.2 * 106 ha) in comparison with unchanged climate, thanks to higher agricultural yields.
Table 3 Projected changes in urban and agricultural land u s e ( 1 0 6 ha), decade 2040-49, under baseline and changed climate (scenario BaU-best) in the CP and two variants (Source: [5])
agric urban total
Central Proj. basel, ch.cl,
Minus Variant basel, ch.cl,
Plus Variant basel, ch.cl.
-1.57 -1.83 +0.68 +0.68 -0.89 -1.15
-2.67 -0.18 -2.85
-1.26 +1.39 +0.13
-2.84 -0.18 -3.02
-1.52 +1.39 -0.13
The given explorations of future land use are largely "status quo-oriented". No surprising dynamics in climate, economic conditions or consumption patterns, to name a few, are taken into account. Therefore, we may conclude that changes in the order of-0.18 to +1.39 * 10 6 ha for urban land use and -2.84 to -1.26 * 10 6 ha for agricultural land use can be expected, if climate change, biophysical impacts and socio-economic factors develop as described by [2-5]. Projected conversions of agricultural land into built-up area on the one hand and into secondary forest, grassland or a mix of the two on the other would have distinct impacts on the discharge regime of the river Rhine. Most favourable in hydrological terms (reduced run-off) appears to be the Minus Variant. 4. R E F E R E N C E S
1 2
3 4 5 6 7
Parmet, B. (1993): Impact of climate change on the discharge of the Rhine.- Change 15: 1-3. R6tter, R.P. (1994): Rhine basin Study: Land Use Projections based on biophysical and socio-economic analysis. Vol.1, Biophysical classifcation as a general framework.- SCDLO Report 85.1, Wageningen and Lelystad, 104 pp. R6tter, R.P. and C.A. van Diepen (1994): Rhine basin Study. Vol.2, Climate change impact on crop yield potentials and water use.- SC-DLO Report 85.2, 145 pp. Hendriks, C.M.A. (1994): Rhine basin study. Vol.3, Climate change impact on forest yield potentials and water use.- SC-DLO Report 85.3, 40 pp. Veeneklaas, F.R., Van den Berg, L.M., Slothouwer, D. and G.F.P. Ijkelenstam (1994): Vol.4, Land use: Past, present and future.- SC-DLO Report 85.4, 155 pp. Houghton, J.T., Jenkins, G.J. and J.J. Ephraums, eds. (1990): Climate Change: The IPCC Scientific Assessment.- Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 365 pp. Kwadijk, J. (1993): The impact of climatic change on the discharge of the river Rhine.- PhD Thesis, University of Utrecht, 172 pp.
Climate Change Research: Evaluation and Policy Implications S. Zwerver, R.S.A.R. van Rompaey, M.T.J. Kok and M.M. Berk, (Eds.) 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
951
ASSESSMENT REPORT ON NRP SUBTHEME "EFFECTS
OF INCREASING
UV-B RADIATION"'
J.C. van der Leun University Hospital Utrecht, Institute of Dermatology Heidelberglaan 100 3584 CX Utrecht The Netherlands
With contributions by: L. van Liere, H. van Loveren
A. Buma,W.W.C. Gieskes F.R. de Gruijl E. Magendans, J. Rozema, M. Tosserams
RIVM, National Institute of Public Health and Environment, Bilthoven RUG, University of Groningen RUU, University of Utrecht VUA, Free University of Amsterdam
952 Contents Abstract 0
0
0
0
Introduction 1.1 Why research on UV-B effects? 1.2 Selection of projects I n v e s t i g a t i o n of t h e effects of UV-B on t h e i m m u n o l o g i c a l r e s i s t a n c e to tumours and infections 2.1 Introduction 2.2 Basic interspecies comparisons 2.3 Infection models in rodents 2.4 Immunological changes in relation to uv-induced skin cancer 2.5 Basic mechanisms 2.6 Conclusions 2.7 Scientific cooperation 2.8 Effects of UV-B on the immunological resistance to t u m o u r s and infections I m p a c t o f e n h a n c e d s o l a r UV-B r a d i a t i o n on p l a n t s f r o m t e r r e s t r i a l ecosystems 3.1 Introduction 3.2 Methodology of UV-B experiments in terrestrial ecosystems 3.3 Responses of terrestrial plants to enhanced solar UV-B-radiation 3.4 Ecological effects of ozone depletion; implications for e n v i r o n m e n t a l policy 3.5 National and international cooperation 3.6 Impact of enhanced solar UV-B irradiation on plants from t e r r e s t r i a l ecosystems E f f e c t s o f i n c r e a s e d UV-B r a d i a t i o n on s t r u c t u r e a n d f u n c t i o n i n g o f a l g a l c o m m u n i t i e s in d i f f e r e n t c l i m a t i c z o n e s : r i s k s o f a g l o b a l d e c r e a s e in s t r a t o s p h e r i c o n z o n e 4.1 S u m m a r y 4.2 Introduction and problem definition 4.3 Aim of the project 4.4 Results 4.5 Conclusion and perspectives of results obtained during NRP I 4.6 Cooperation with other research groups within/outside NRP 4.7 Effects of increased UV-B radiation on structure and functioning of algal communities in different climatic zones: risk of a global decrease in stratospheric ozone
5.
Integration
6.
R e l e v a n c e for p o l i c y m a k i n g
7.
Outlook: f u t u r e w o r k
953 8.
Conclusions
9.
References
ABSTRACT Solar UV-B radiation has profound effects on many organisms. Increases in this type of radiation may, therefore, be expected to have impacts. In this NRP-theme, investigations were carried out on effects of increased UV-B radiation on the immune system, plants from terrestrial ecosystems and algal communities. These three topics were selected on the basis of expertise available in The Netherlands; the topics chosen ranked high in several i n t e r n a t i o n a l priority listings. The projects are described, and the results assessed. Each of the projects produced new knowledge on the effects studied. Several results were taken up in the 1994 UNEP-Assessment of Environmental Effects of Ozone Depletion. Reasons for continuing and intensifying this type of research are given. Other reasonings, implying that such research would not be necessary, are weighed and found wanting. Effects of increasing LW-B radiation rank high among the impacts of global atmospheric change on organisms. 1.
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Why r e s e a r c h o n UV-B effects? Changes in the atmosphere become relevant to society only if they have effects. This places attention for effects in a crucial position in a research programme on atmospheric change. The present assessment deals with effects of increased penetration of solar UV-B radiation to the earth's surface, as a consequence of decreasing total-column ozone. UV-B radiation is the most energetic component of the sunlight reaching the surface. Even without change it has profound influences on humans, animals, plants, microorganisms, materials, and on the chemistry of the atmosphere. A possible increase of this type of radiation demands careful attention. 1.2 S e l e c t i o n of p r o j e c t s Effects of sunlight on organisms are studied in the science called photobiology. The Netherlands have a strong tradition in photobiology. The emphasis has been on h u m a n health from the time between the two world wars. Interest in effects on plants and aquatic organisms developed especially in connection with the problem of depletion of the ozone layer.
954 Selection of topics for NRP-I was guided by the expertise available in the country. This occurred in a spontaneous way, because it was in these areas t h a t project proposals were submitted. This led to the three projects listed in Table 1.1. Table 1.1 List of projects in NRP Subtheme "Effects of increasing UV-B radiation" Title
Project leader
Number
Effects of UV-B on the immunological resistance to tumours and infections
H. van Loveren
850017
Impact of enhanced solar UV-B radiation on plants from terrestrial ecosystems
J. Rozema
850022
Effects of increased UV-B radiation on structure L. van Liere and functioning of algal communities in different climatic zones: risk of a global decrease in stratospheric ozone
851054
The Netherlands provide about I percent of the research efforts in the world, and in some areas where it is relatively active a few percent. It was not considered necessary, therefore, t h a t the NRP-projects would provide complete coverage of this worldwide problem. Important areas, such as effects of UV radiation on the eyes, and on materials, were lacking. On the other hand, the topics t h a t were covered belonged without exception to the "key areas of uncertainty" defined by the U n i t e d Nations E n v i r o n m e n t Programme, and the priorities defined by SCOPE, the Scientific Committee on Problems of the Environment, formed by the International Council of Scientific Unions. 2.
I N V E S T I G A T I O N OF T H E E F F E C T S OF UV-B ON T H E I M M U N O L O G I C A L R E S I S T A N C E TO T U M O I g ~ S AND I N F E C T I O N S
H. van Loveren RIVM, N a t i o n a l I n s t i t u t e of Public H e a l t h and E n v i r o n m e n t a l Protection, Laboratory of Pathology, P.O.Box 1, 3720 BA Bilthoven 2.1 I n t r o d u c t i o n Scientific tools to perform investigations on the health effects of increased UV-B exposure are available. From experimental studies it can be concluded t h a t UV-B causes an increased incidence of tumours by at least two separate mechanisms: 1) by genotoxic activity of UV-B and 2) by affecting the immunologically mediated resistance to tumours. In laboratory animals and also in h u m a n s evidence has
955 been provided of UV-B induced damage of the immune system. For this reason it is reasonable to expect t h a t also immunological resistance to infections may be at risk after UV-B-exposure. It is known that resistance against infectious agents t h a t enter the body via the skin, such as Leishmania, and Herpes simplex, is affected by UV-B irradiation. Whether resistance to infectious agents that enter the body via other routes t h a n the skin is affected is as yet not known. Because UV-B can induce systemic immunosuppression, also suppression of i m m u n i t y against non-skin associated infections (diseases), may be suspected. The main goal of this project was to study/analyze the effects of UV-B on the immune system and resistance to tumours and infections. In these studies dependency of UW-B induced alterations of the i m m u n e system on UV-B dose, UV-B wavelength (spectrum) and species (rat, mice, man) were investigated. This information can serve as a basis for estimation of the health risk of UW-B exposed population groups.
2.2 Basic interspecies comparisons Experiments have been performed in which mice and rats are exposed to UV-B using the newly developed and standerized equipment (FS40 UV-B sunbanks). The MED (minimal erythema, or edema, dose) values were determined for mice and rats. A quantitative scoring method for the determination of UV-B effects on the skin was developed. Using this method it was possible to q u a n t i t a t e edema, redness and swelling reactions after UV-B exposure. In addition to these macroscopical studies also histological studies were performed. Pathological effects such as acanthosis, hyperkeratosis, parakeratosis, and inflammation were induced by UV-B irradiation. These pathological parameters were UV-B dose and time dependent. Similar experiments were performed with a Kromayer lamp as an UVB source. This lamp was used for local/acute UV-B irradiation. Results obtained with this equipment are compared with results obtained with the FS40 lamps (total body/semi-chronic). K r o m a y e r lamps are widely used in clinics for UV-exposure of h u m a n s because it is easily to expose h u m a n s with this lamp. Results obtained with the Kromayer lamp in animal species and humans are being compared in order to be better able to extrapolation animal data. Parameters that are being analysed are: acanthosis, parakeratosis, hyperkeratosis, inflammation and macroscopic changes due to UV-B exposure. Based on these initial studies (characterization of primary skin effects due to UVB exposure in m a n and different animal species), the effects of UW-B exposure on several basal specific and non-specific i m m u n e p a r a m e t e r s were tested. Investigations with respect to changes in the number and subtype of i m m u n e competent cells in the skin as well as in lymphoid organs are being carried out. In addition to these descriptive studies also immune function studies are being carried out. Because the mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR), which is a general parameter for T cell immunity, is often used in studies that deal with UV-B induced changes of the immune system (in rodents and man) we developed the MLR technique at the RIVM. This model is now operable in rats, mice and man. UV-B exposure (in vivo) of mice and r a t s inhibited the MLR significantly, d e p e n d e n t upon UV-B irradiation-dose and irradiation-time. The MLR will be one of the parameters to be used for the comparison of UV-B effects on T cell i m m u n i t y between different species (mice, rats, man). For this purpose MLR experiments with h u m a n cells were carried out. The effect of in vitro UW-B irradiation of rodent and h u m a n blood
956 cells was also studied. UV-B suppressed significantly MLR responsiveness of blood cells in h u m a n s and rodents after in vitro UV-B exposure of lymphocytes. Recently we developed (in collaboration with dr. M. Mommaas, AZL), a method in order to investigate the capacity of skin cells to induce MLR responses of allogenic blood lymphocytes. This assay is called the Mixed Skin Lymphocyte Reaction (MSLR). In vivo, in vitro, as well as in situ UV-B exposure of skin cells from different species including m a n are being carried out. The in vitro irradiation experiments have recently been finished and the comparison of UV-B sensitivity with respect to this i m m u n e p a r a m e t e r for the capacity to induce a lymphocytic reaction was analysed, and accepted for publication in "Photochemistry and Photobiology". Histological parameters, obtained in the same species, will be added to these MLR and MSLR results for a better comparison of UV-B sensitivity/susceptibility, between the different species. Other immune function tests such as n a t u r a l killer cell function and mitogenic responses to several different mitogens were also significantly altered in rats after in vivo UV-B exposure. Mice and h u m a n studies are p l a n n e d with respect to these p a r a m e t e r s . In vitro UV-B exposure of lymphocytes from rodents and man inhibited mitogenic responses significantly. 2.3 I n f e c t i o n m o d e l s in r o d e n t s The effects of UV-B exposure on (immunological) resistance against infectious diseases (bacteria,parasites and viruses) is studied in rats and mice. For this goal several infection models in rodents are available at the RIVM. At this moment a Listeria model (bacteria) and a Trichinella model (parasite) and a Cytomegalo virus infection model are operational. In collaboration with the EPA (Selgrade; Environmental Protection Agency, Health Effects Research Laboratory, section of Immunotoxicology, Research Triangle Parc, NC, USA) an additional virus model is used. U s i n g this collaborative s t u d y the effect of UV-B exposure on the immunological resistance to Influenza infections in the rat will be investigated. Recently experiments were performed in order to test the effect of I.rV-B on the resistance to malaria infections in the rat. This part of the resistance study is done in collaboration with Dr. Luebke from EPA, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA. All infection models that are used are in principle suitable to test immunosuppression, and hence are also suitable to test possible immunosuppression induced by UV-B. If all the available infection models are used almost all the different aspects of immunological resistance against infective agents are investigated.
We d e m o n s t r a t e d t h a t UV-B exposure (suberythemal doses) can inhibit the immunological resistance against Trichinella spiralis infections in rat. Especially UV-B exposure during the second week after Trichinella infection inhibits r e s i s t a n c e a g a i n s t this pathogen indicating t h a t T cell d e p e n d e n t i m m u n e responses are probably altered. In addition, specific IgE titers in serum of UV-B exposed animals are decreased if the animals were i r r a d i a t e d 3 weeks after Trichinella infection Additionally, we demonstrated t h a t suberythemal doses of UV-B inhibited the resistance a g a i n s t a Listeria monocytogenes infection. Especially the specific T cell response to this pathogen was inhibited by UV-B exposure. A manuscript describing these results is now accepted for publication in "Environmental Health Perspectives". As was found for the parasitic and bacterial infection models also resistance to cytomegalovirus was inhibited by UV-B exposure of rats.
957
Therefore, the important new finding is that resistance against several non-skin-associated infectious diseases can be inhibited by UV-B exposure. 2.4 I m m u n o l o g i c a l c h a n g e s in r e l a t i o n to U V - i n d u c e d s k i n c a n c e r Extensive experimental studies on UV-induced skin carcinomas have been carried out with albino hairless mice (SKH:HR1) in order to extract basic quantitative dose-response relationships for modelling of h u m a n skin cancer risk. From other animal models it was known t h a t UV tumours are highly antigenic, i.e., these t u m o u r s are rejected by a strong i m m u n e reaction when t r a n s p l a n t e d into a genetically identical animal. Somehow the UV-exposed animals loose this ability. In the p r e s e n t project lymphoid organs and skin of the hairless mice were i n v e s t i g a t e d in the course of chronic UV-B exposures, leading up to skin carcinomas. I m p o r t a n t shifts in subpopulations of lymphoid cells were found very early in the experiment in the spleens and especially in the lymph nodes of the animals. CD8-positive cells migrated into the superficial layers of skin in the course of the experiment. By challenging the mice after different times and levels of UV exposure it was ascertained how the observed shifts in subpopulations of lymphoid cells correlated to the failure to reject UV turnout cells. This failure sets in long before the occurrence of macroscopically observable, UV-induced primary tumours, it gradually develops aider the initial shifts in subpopulations of lymphoid cells. The relatively rapid suppression of the immunity against the UV carcinomas m a y suggest t h a t this is not a serious rate-limiting step in the genesis of these cancers (and thus difficult to prevent in high risk individuals). Papers on this subject are in p r e p a r a t i o n and will be submitted this year. E a r l y detection of corresponding immunological changes in humans could serve to identify individuals t h a t r u n a high risk for UV-related skin cancers and perhaps also for decreased immunity against certain infections. 2.5 B a s i c m e c h a n i s m s Besides the aforementioned interspecies comparisons of UV sensitivities, a basic u n d e r s t a n d i n g of the mechanisms involved in UV-induced immunosuppression is likely to further a well-directed research on UV-related immunological risks in man. Although fundamental research on mechanisms is carried out by several groups, this research has not yet yielded data t h a t provide good answers on how the results obtained in animals translate to humans. Hence, experiments were carried out to contribute to this animal-to-human extrapolation. We did this by exploring the in vivo murine model for fundamental immune parameters that would directly signify a high sensitivity to UV-suppression, or a state of UV-induced i m m u n e suppression, and that would also be measurable in man.
To capitalize on a well-established assay at the RIVM on the delayed type of hypersensitivity (dth), we studied the effect of [ W irradiation on the sensitization for the e a r l y (initiation) p h a s e of the h y p e r s e n s i t i v i t y r e a c t i o n a g a i n s t picrylchloride applied to the skin. Besides the already-known suppression of the classical dth reaction (swelling at 24 h after the application), we found a suppression by UV radiation of the early phase of dth (swelling at 2 h). Both phases in the dth reaction are mediated through T cells, and we found - contrary to our expectation - t h a t suppression of the late phase did not fully correspond with the suppression of the early phase (the early phase could be made to occur in conjunction with an LW-suppressed late phase dth reaction; see Y. Suntag et al.,
958 1994). An antigen-specific factor (in this case picrylchloride-specific) 'arms' mast cells in the skin for the induction of increased permeability of bloodvessels, causing the edema of the early phase dth reaction. Such a factor should in principle also be m e a s u r a b l e in humans, and might be used to measure a person's UV suppressibility. A very interesting finding stemmed from the combination of the present research on UV immunological effects with a parallel running research project on DNA damage induced by UV radiation. UV-specific DNA damage can be detected through the binding of a monoclonal antibody (H3, supplied by Dr. L. Roza at TNO in Rijswijk) to UV-induced thymine dimers in the DNA. Upon UV irradiation the DNA damage is normally confined to the most superficial layers of skin (the damaging UV radiation does not penetrate any deeper), but UV-damaged DNA was also detected in some cells the draining lymph nodes, already 1 hour after I_W exposure. By a cumbersome combination of techniques, it was ultimately established t h a t these UV-damaged cells from the skin were in fact antigen-presenting cells (APCs). UV-damaged APCs are known to be (partially) dysfunctional, which can result in unbalanced, aberrant immune reactions (no stimulation of Thl cells, but only of Th2 cells exerting suppressive action). It is now of great importance to establish whether UV-damaged APCs (more particularly, Langerhans cells) migrate from the human skin upon I.W irradiation. Such a follow up study is currently pursued with a high priority. Enhanced migration of UV-damaged APCs in some individuals (e.g. people who had skin cancers removed) could signify an increased risk for UV-induced immune suppression. 2.6 C o n c l u s i o n s
The present NRP-I project has been extremely rewarding in that it produced a good many new data on which to base an animal-to-man extrapolation of UV-induced suppression of immune reactions, such as involved in combating infections and skin cancers. Animal experiments widened the spectrum of infections that could be adversely affected by UV radiation, by including infections not entering through the skin. Thus, the possible impact of an increase in UV-B radiation has been importantly broadened. The well-directed study has identified some promising immunological parameters by which to establish an individual's UV-immunosuppressibility, or a state of immunosuppression against certain (infectious) agents. Further studies are needed to establish the feasibility of measuring these parameters in humans for the proposed diagnostic purposes. Clearly, this research has not yet fully evolved to the point t h a t quantitative assessments of UV immunosuppression, and especially the repercussions on infections and vaccinations can be reliably made. The mathematical centre of the RIVM is, however, carrying out preliminary studies on developing a suitable risk model based on the data generated in the present project. In conjunction with this study, the centre of epidemiology at the RIVM is exploring the possibilities of providing epidemiological data (e.g. influenza data in relation to sun hours during summer) to support assessments of UV effects on infections or vaccinations. As such epidemiological data may not be available in a suitable form, plans are also being made for dedicated surveys in which people will be interviewed to investigate a possible relationship between
959 (solar) UV exposure (during vacations) and subsequent risk or severity of infectious diseases. Although it is not part of our daily experience, animal experiments show that UV radiation from the sun may interfere with our immunity against infections. The relevancy of this UV-immunosuppression for infections and vaccinations in a human population still remains to be established: it is unknown whether we are all indiscriminantely at risk of l.W-immunosuppression, or whether the risk pertains solely to high risk individuals (e.g. people already immunocompromised in some way), or whether the risk is nonexistent. Judging by the available experimental data, also supplied by the present project, the latter alternative does not appear to be the most plausible one. Hence, a continuation of this line of research is well warranted, because our ignorance on the subject hampers a good appreciation of health effects of UV radiation, and of increases in I.W radiation due to an depletion of the ozone layer.
2.7 Scientific cooperation In this NRP project the research groups of Dr. F. de Gruijl (RUU, laboratory for dermatology) and of Dr. H van Loveren (RIVM, laboratory for pathology, section of immunobiology) have been and still are collaborating intensively. Knowledge with respect to Ultraviolet radiation and the immune system are connected due to this collaboration. In addition to this formal collaboration five times a year a scientific meetings among researchers in The Netherlands, concerned with UV-B effects on the immune system are organized. During these meetings plans/results from the participants with respect to research concerning UV-B induced alterations of the immune system are discussed. The participants of this national UV-B network are: 1. RUU, Laboratory for Dermatology, Utrecht. 2. RIVM, Laboratory for Pathology, section Immunobiology. 3. LU, Laboratory for Dermatology, Leiden. 4. UvA (AMC), Laboratory for Dermatology, Amsterdam. In addition to these meetings regarding health effects of UV-B two times a year a meeting is arranged in which the other UV effects projects, financed by NRP, participate (Free University, Amsterdam; RIVM, Bilthoven; State University, Groningen; State University, Utrecht). The first of these meetings was in November last year at the Free University in Amsterdam. The second UVB-effects cluster meeting was at the RIVM in April 1993. This meeting was very successful with respect to the integration of the different UV-B "effects studies". The third and fourth meeting were held in Utrecht respectively Groningen (November 1993 and june 1994). In addition to the national collaborations as mentioned above, the RIVM is coordinating a project sponsored by the EC, entitled: "A basis for better evaluation of risk of increasing UV-B exposure for public health". For this purpose collaboration with several groups in Europe is established: Dr. Dall'acqua, Padua, Italy; Dr. Cerimele, Rome, Italy; Dr. Norval, Edinburgh, Scotland; Dr. Gibbs, Dundee, U.K.; Dr. de Gruijl, Utrecht, The Netherlands. The knowledge/expertises of
960 these different labs will serve to further evaluate the risk of increasing UV-B exposure on public health. The accessibility to h u m a n data with respect to UV-B induced effects obtained by several of the participants is now possible. 2.8 E f f e c t s o f U V - B o n t h e i m m u n o l o g i c a l infections
resistance
to t u m o u r s
and
Assessment It was known from experimental work by other groups t h a t UV radiation could influence the course of certain infections. That were infections where the skin was involved, either as the site where the infection entered the body, such as in Leishmania, or where the infection came to expression, such as in Herpes simplex. In the p r e s e n t project it was shown t h a t UV-B i r r a d i a t i o n of the skin of e x p e r i m e n t a l animals can also aggravate the course of an infection t h a t has nothing to do with the skin, for instance, a worm infection t h a t enters the body with the food and has its damaging effects deep inside the body. This surprising finding broadens the range of infectious diseases that require attention as diseases possibly to be influenced by increasing solar UV-B radiation. The result is being included in the U N E P Assessment on Environmental Effects of Ozone Depletion (1994), as has been the case with several experimental results from this group in the earlier U N E P assessments. Another valuable result obtained in this project was the finding of cells with I_W-B induced damage to their DNA in the deep lymph nodes of mice. Because of the limited penetration of UV-B radiation in animal tissues, this damage m u s t have been inflicted while the cells were in the skin. This finding confirms an important p a r t of the theoretical model on how the i m m u n e system is influenced by UV radiation, and strengthens the basis for the prediction of the ultimate effects. : 3.
I M P A C T O F E N H A N C E D S O L A R UV-B R A D I A T I O N O N P L A N T S FROM TERRESTRIAL ECOSYSTEMS
J. Rozema, M. Tosserams and E. Magendans Free University Amsterdam, Department of Ecology and Ecotoxicology, Faculty of Biology, De Boelelaan 1087, 1081 HV Amsterdam
3.1 I n t r o d u c t i o n
Background Decrease in stratospheric ozone over the last decade has been revealed by satellite m e a s u r e m e n t s . As a result a gradual increase in solar ultraviolet-B radiation occurs. M e a s u r e m e n t s of UV-B radiation in the Swiss Alps indicate an a n n u a l increase of UV-B-radiation of 1% since 1981 (Blumthaler and Ambach, 1990).
S o l a r UV-B a n d terrestrial ecosystems Solar UV-B radiation has important biological and ecological effects. Many crops and n a t u r a l plant species demonstrate reduced growth, under enhanced UV-B
961 radiation but there is a wide range of sensitivity to UV-B radiation between plant species and cultivars. A major part of research of UV-B effects relates to crop species and only a few UV-B effect studies are known of plant species of n a t u r a l ecosystems (SCOPE 1992). Most studies of UV-B effects on plants have been conducted in greenhouse or in controlled e n v i r o n m e n t cabinets with UV-B lamps. Relatively low levels of Photosynthetic Active Radiation (PAR), in controlled environment studies m a y prevent induction of photo-repair of UV-damage. This has led to an overestimation of growth reduction of plants exposed to enhanced levels of UV-B. Outdoor experimental UV-B supplementation systems, with natural levels of PAR provide more realistic responses of plants to enhanced UV-B.
Scientific aims O u r r e s e a r c h a i m e d at d e v e l o p m e n t and a p p l i c a t i o n of outdoor UV-B supplementation and UV-B filtrations systems and to assess effects of solar UV-B radiation to plant species of terrestrial ecosystems.
3.2 Methodology UV-lamp systems In experimental studies with enhanced levels of UV-B irradiance UV-lamps are used t h a t are pre-burnt and filtered with cellulose acetate as a cut off filter of wavelengths smaller t h a n 280 nm. The Cellulose Acetate filters are renewed twice a week to avoid reduced transmission of UV-B related to ageing of the cellulose acetate. Mylar polyester filters absorb UV-B and are used to cover UV-B lamps over control t r e a t m e n t t h a t receive no UV-B irradiance, but where the UV-B levels are the same as in the t r e a t m e n t t h a t receive no with enhanced UV-B (see Figure 3.1).
Figure 3.1 Philips TL12/40 lamps are applied both in indoor and outdoor studies of UV-B effects on plants. The plots shown in the photograph, which are exposed to solar UV-B + UV-B supplied by the lamps, refer to monocultures and mixed cultures of the dune grassland species Calamagrostis epigejos and Holcus lanatus. Thus the effect of enhanced UV-B on competitive relationships between plant species is analysed
962 We use Philips TL12/40 lamps both in indoor controlled environment studies and in outdoor studies in an experimental field and in natural ecosystems. Two outdoor unenclosed systems are applied: A. U~-B Supplementation system and B. UV-B filtration systems.
UV-B Supplementation system. A lamp system to supplement ambient solar UV-B over experimental plots and over natural vegetation has been developed and applied (Figure 3.1). At present this outdoor UV-B supplementation system is applied in a "square wave" mode of enhanced UV-B radiation. This implies switching UV-B lamps on for a fixed period around midday, when natural solar UV-B is greatest. Currently an outdoor solar tracking UV-B supplementation is developed and installed. This involves continuous m eas ur em e n t of solar UV-B levels using appropriate UV-B sensors (Yu et al. 1991). This allows accurate simulation of enhanced UV-B throughout the day. There is evidence that plant responses to enhanced UV-B supplied in the solar tracking modulated mode differs both qualitatively and quantitatively from responses to UV-B supplied in the square wave mode. The development and testing of this solar tracking UV-B supplementation is in close cooperation with Dr. Andy McLeod, Institute of Terrestrial Ecology, Huntingdon, United Kingdom and Dr. Gaetano Zipoli, IATA-CNR, Florence, Italy. UV-B lamps are mounted above the vegetation and are maintained at a constant height above the canopy. UV-B sensors will measure and track ambient solar UV-B radiation. Dual UV-B sensors are used beneath both treatment and control racks with UV-lamps, spaced such that one is unshaded from direct sunlight by lamps or frame. The unshaded sensor is selected by the control system preventing shading effects from interfering with feedback control of output of UV-lamps. The lamp output is adjusted to give a constant multiple of UV-B radiation above ambient UV-B radiation. Increases of UV-B radiation relative to ambient UV-B irradiance relating to 20% ozone depletion under clear sky are realized. UV-filtration system. Various types of solid plastic filters are installed above precultured plants in pots or above natural vegetation. These filters absorb either (a) little solar UW-B (and UV-A) (Acrylate filter), (b) all UV-B (Mylar polyester film on top of acrylate filters) and (c) all UV-A + UV-B (Lexan filter). The transmission spectra of these three filter types are given in Figure 3.2.
963
1.0
' ~ii':ii,,e, 0.8 .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
[
=:=
I
0.6
8
0.4
|
.-,
....,
-~
o.2
0.0
-0.2 280
,
,
300
,
320
!
340
,
,
360
380
400
Wavelen~th ( n m )
Figure 3.2 Solar UV-irradiance (August 1992, 13.00 h), on a clear sky day, beneath the various filter types (A = acrylate, L = Lexan, M = Mylar), compared to full sunlight (no filter). Measurement with a Optronic spectroradiometer (OL 752, Optronics Laboratories, Florida, USA) The development and testing of low-cost solid plastic UV-B filters allow outdoor and ecosystem studies of reduction of ambient levels of solar UV-B radiation. In practice it will allow research of responses of plant from nat ural terrestrial ecosystems (Figure 3.3).
3.3 Responses of terrestrial plants to enhanced solar UV-B irradiation Solar UV-B effect studies have been performed on a number of crop and native plant species both in controlled environment (greenhouse), unenclosed outdoor (experimental garden) and field studies in a dune grassland ecosystem (Tables 3.1 and 3.2). A wide range of sensitivity to enhanced UV-B measured in indoor controlled environment experiments, exists among crop species. Cultivars of crops such as soybean (G[ycine max) vary greatly in sensitivity to UV-B. Of the n a t u r a l plant species from Dutch coastal ecosystems: the salt m a r s h ecosystem and dune grassland ecosystem, no apparent sensitive plant species were found both in indoor and outdoor studies. It should be noticed that no natural plant species of the Leguminosae (a plant group with many plant species sensitive to UV-B) have been subjected to enhanced UV-B radiation levels in outdoor experiments. The woodland understorey species Alliaria petiolata indicates to be sensitive to enhanced UV-B. It may be that plant species occurring in open habitats (Calamagrostis epigejos, Spartina anglica) and being exposed to relatively high levels of ambient solar UV-B have evolved UV-B adaptation mechanisms. Other species occurring in the woodland understorey with reduced PAR and reduced ambient UV-B, seem to be relatively UV-B sensitive. This hypothesis is studied in current research.
964
Figure 3.3 Application of solid plastic UV-B filters in the study of reduction of ambient solar UV-B radiation on plant species of a dune grassland ecosystem. The height of the plastic UV-B filters can be adjusted according to seasonal development of the vegetation. At the background a rack of UV-lamps over the dune grassland vegetation is shown as a UV-B supplementation system
3.4 Ecological effects of ozone depletion; implications for e n v i r o n m e n t a l policy 1. Responses of terrestrial plant species to enhanced UV-B range from very sensitive to tolerant or even a positive response. This broad range type of response possibly reflects the intrinsic heterogeneity of the various terrestric ecosystems. Grassland ecosystems are much more exposed to full solar UV-B than under storey plants from forest ecosystems. .
.
Adaptation to enhanced UV-B may consist of two types of mechanisms. a. UV-B tolerant plant species avoid enhanced UV-B radiation flux at sensitive metabolic sites by absorption of UV-B by epidermal structures and dissolved, UV-B absorbing compounds such as flavonoids. b. UV-B tolerant plant species have effective UV-B repair mechanisms, in contrast with UV-B sensitive plant species. The n a t u r e and occurrence of these adaptation mechanisms has been analysed only for a few plant species. Understanding of UV-B responses of all groups of terrestrial plant species needs research priority. Crop plant species tend to be more sensitive to enhanced UV-B than wild plant species. This may indicate that during the breeding procedure domesticating wild species to crop plants adaptation to (high) UV-B has been lost. Maybe a trade off exists between high productivity and sensitivity to UV-B. This is an intriguing hypothesis. It might indicate that plant species may loose (genetically determined) adaptations to solar UV-B. This implies that certain crops or certain cultivars of crops will be less productive with increasing solar UV-B. It is unknown whether selection for
965 increased tolerance to enhanced UV-B will be successful and over w h a t time period. .
.
There are m a n y uncertainties in the knowledge of UV-B effects on plant life in terrestrial ecosystems: effects of UV-B on reproductive biology are largely unknown, some of the reproductive features will be vulnerable to enhanced UV-B; little is known of UV-B effects on "lower plants" like mosses ferns, fungi and algae; the effect of an enhanced UV-B flux is unknown in a "multiple stress" environment such as UV-B air pollution; UV-B x n u t r i e n t and w a t e r deficiency. T h e r e are some indications t h a t enhanced UV-B will cause i n c r e a s e d occurrence of plant diseases by fungi, bacteria and viruses. Consequences of enhanced solar UV-B to terrestrial ecosystems are expected to be substantial. There will be a shift to dominace of UV-B resistant plant species. The altered biochemistry of plant species exposed to high UV-B fluxes may not only affect plant-herbivore relationships but also change the process of decomposition of leaf litter (see Figure 3.4).
3.5. National and international cooperation N a t i o n a l a n d I n t e r n a t i o n a l contacts. Between the different national UV-B research
groups exchange of experimental results and methods occurs. Every six months a meeting is organized by one of the participating groups. D u r i n g these meetings results are presented and discussed. Close collaboration between different groups exists on a s s e s s i n g the impact of UV-B on DNA Damage. Immunological techniques used in skin cancer research are now also applied to assess DNA damage in marine algae and terrestrial plants. Contacts exist with research groups in Germany (prof. M. Tevini, Karlsruhe) and the United States (prof. A.H. T e r a m u r a and Dr. J. Sullivan, Univ. of Maryland, Washington), who are well known for their work on UV-B effects on terrestrial plants. Results were presented and discussed during visits to these research groups in 1992, 1993, 1994.
National cooperation 1. Dr. L. van Liere, Dr. A. Veen, RIVM, UV-B and aquatic Ecosystems. 2. Dr. W. Gieskes, Dr. A. Buma, RUG, DNA-UV-B-damage, UV-B dosimetrie.
International cooperation 3. Dr. A. McLeod, ITE, Huntingdon, U.K., UV-B experimental set-up. 4. Prof.Dr. M. Tevini, Dr. J. Ros, TU, Karlsruhe, UV-B spectroradiometrie. 5. Prof.Dr. A.H. Teramura, Un. Maryland & Hawaii, Dr. J. Sullivan, USA, advanced cooperation and interchange.
International workshop UV-B and Biosphere The groups involved in this project and in the project on UV-B and algal communities (nr. 851054) will organize an i n t e r n a t i o n a l workshop on the influences of UV-B radiation on terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems. T h a t will be held towards the end of 1995.
966
Sponsors: the Dutch Ministry of Housing, Physical Planning and the Environment, The Dutch Organisation for Scientific Research, the Royal dutch Academy of Sciences and the European Community.
TERRESTRIAL ECOSYSTEMS PAR
UV-B
PAR INTERCEPTION
PLANT
1
!
-~r
LEAF ANGLE CANOPY ARCHIITECTURE LA!
NUTRIENTS
y 2 2
HERBIVORY GRAZING
UV-B ABSORBING COMPOUNDS SECUNDARY METABOLITES
RGR BIOMASS PROD. PRIM. PROD.
UV-B DAMAGE PHOTOREPAIR
/
[DEFENSE AGAINST
SEC. PROD. DECOMPOSITION
3
LEAF LONGEVITY SPROUTING BUDBURST
COMPETITIVE ABILITY
Figure 3.4 Conceptual model structure Impact of Enhanced Solar UV-B on Terrestrial Ecosystems: Physiology, Functioning and Dynamics. Ecosystem Functions: 1. Prim. Prod. = Primary productivity; 2. Sec. Prod. = Secondary Productivity; 3. Decomposition. Ecosystem structure: 4. Competitive ability. PAR = Photosynthetic Active Radiation; Pn = Net Photosynthesis; RGR = Relative Growth Rate; LAI = Leaf Earea Index
967 Table 3.1. Survey of qualitative plant responses to enhanced UV-B in controlled environment studies. Daily biologically effective dose of UV-B relating to 20-50% ozone depletion under clear sky. Response to enhanced UV-B negative very sensitive
response sensitive
no significant response
positive
Crop species Pisum sativum Phaseolus vulgaris Vicia faba Lycopersicon esculentum Cucumis sativus Triticum aestivum Zea mays
X X
X X
X X X
Natural plant species Verbascum thapsus Calamagrostis epigejos Plantago lanceolata Alliaria petiolata Aster tripolium Elymus athericus Spartina anglica Holcus lanatus Silene vulgaris
X X X X X X X X X
The reader is referred to Rozema (1993) for more detailed information
968 Table 3.2 Survey of qualitative plant responses to enhanced UV-B in controlled environment studies. Daily biologically effective dose of UV-B relating to 20-50% ozone depletion under clear sky Response to enhanced UV-B negative very sensitive
Crop species Vicia faba Triticum aestivum
response sensitive
positive
X X
Zea mays Natural plant species Calamagrostis epigejos Plantago lanceolata Urtica dioica Holcus lanatus Verbascum thapsus Silene vulgaris
no significant response
X X X X X X X
The reader is referred to Rozema (1993) for more detailed information.
3.6 Impact of enhanced solar UV-B irradiation on plants from terrestrial ecosystems Assessment The project gives valuable additions to the international efforts in this field: the inclusion of plants from n a t u r a l ecosystems, and the investigation of mixed cultures of these plants. These are necessary steps towards the difficult analysis of the influence of increased UV-B irradiance on natural terrestrial ecosystems, a priority topic in several international listings.
The r e s e a r c h e r s in this project are m a k i n g progress in identifying those ecosystems, or sub-ecosystems, for which the UV-B irradiance is an i m p o r t a n t factor. Cultured crops tend to be more sensitive to enhanced UV-B radiation t h a n wild plants, and plants occurring in woodland understoreys more sensitive t h a n plants occurring in open habitats.
969
0
E F F E C T S OF I N C R E A S E D UV-B R A D I A T I O N ON S T R U C T U R E A N D FUNCTIONING OF ALGAL COMMUNITIES IN DIFFERENT C L I M A T I C ZONES: R I S K S OF A G L O B A L D E C R E A S E IN STRATOSPHERIC ONZONE
L. van Lierel and W.W.C. Gieskes2 1 RIVM, Department of Water and Drinking Water Research, National Institute of Public Health and Environmental Protection, P.O.Box 1, 3720 BA Bilthoven 2 RUG, D e p a r t m e n t of Marine Biology, University of Groningen, P.O Box 14, 9750 AA H a r e n
4.1 S u m m a r y During NRP-I new insights were gained with respect to UV penetration in the aquatic e n v i r o n m e n t and UV stress p h e n o m e n a in microalgae after chronic exposure to realistic levels of UV-B. UV-B radiation and penetration modelling has revealed t h a t UV-B penetration can be high in natural waters, particularly in the open ocean where the concentration of humic acids is low. Here, the UV-B attenuation coefficient approaches that of pure water. Large differences in UV-B sensitivity were found when microalgae were subjected to chronic UV-B exposure. Especially the growth of species occurring in offshore waters, such as the important bloom forming alga Emiliania huxleyi was already inhibited at ambient UV-B levels: for Emiliania huxleyi growth inhibition was found to occur at least up to a depth of 15 m, as calculated for 52~ in the Atlantic Ocean. This indicates t h a t UV-B is a n a t u r a l selective factor in plankton assemblages and t h a t an increase in incident UV-B levels will strongly affect the performance of m a n y organisms in the field. Furthermore, thanks to our approach of measuring chronic UV-B effects over several generations, we can now present convincing evidence t h a t L ~ - B effects are underestimated when only short term effects are t a k e n into account, as done so far in UV-B effect studies. This means t h a t the observed 12% decrease in phytoplankton production in Antarctic waters, t h a t is used often for risk evaluation of ozone depletion, strongly needs to be reevaluated, because this study was based on short term photosynthesis measurements. Moreover, growth r a t e reduction was found to be a more reliable and realistic p a r a m e t e r to be considered t h a n the production m e a s u r e m e n t s done so far, because growth is a resultant of all metabolic processes under UV-B stress, including DNA damage, i.e. not only the photosynthetic process. Therefore chronic UV-B mediated growth inhibition phenomena urgently need to be included in future UV-B effect studies and modelhng. The results obtained during NRP-I have indicated t h a t DNA damage and its subsequent effect on the cell cycle play a major role in UV-B mediated growth rate reduction. This approach is new in aquatic UV-B effect studies and f u r t h e r underlines the importance of studying UV-B effects over several generation times. DNA damage occurs at realistic UV-B levels in most species tested so far, and the ability to overcome DNA damage is now thought to be a p r i m a r y factor causing difference in UV-B sensitivity in microalgae. The UV-B induced cell cycle arrest, t h a t we observed, causes shifts in mean cell volume and the contents of structural compounds (protein) and storage products. This will definitely result in changes in the food web through altered grazing activities by herbivores with specific food size
970 requirements, as well as altered sinking rates, resulting in a proportional increase in vertical carbon fluxes out of the euphotic zone. The experimental results have provided basic insight into the key parameters to be included in effect models, that are designed for risk assessment in specific marine habitats. First modelling on large scale can be realised within the coming years if funding is obtained through NRP-II. The simulation model that we developed recently is focussed on the vulnerability of the Atlantic Ocean ecosystem for integrated climate change factors, including UV-B, temperature and carbon dioxide, and is so far unique within the international scientific community. 4.2 I n t r o d u c t i o n and p r o b l e m definition At present no conclusive picture exists on the impact of enhanced UV-B radiation on the structure and functioning of aquatic ecosystems. The limited knowledge on UV-B leaves enough room for speculation on dramatic effects but also trivialization of the problem. During the past few years evidence for both can easily be found in the media and official reports. It is naive to consider the UV-B problem a passed station following the Copenhagen amendments, first of all because observed ozone depletion levels do not always fit the predicted ozone scenarios and secondly because the effects on ecosystems are still poorly quantified. Therefore, a scientifically sound picture of the effects of UV-B enhancement on ecosystems is required. In aquatic ecosystems microalgae form the first trophic level. Since microalgae are known to be sensitive to UV radiation, and since UV penetrates to ecologically significant depths in aquatic environments, effects on global primary production upon ozone depletion are likely to occur. Moreover, UV induced changes in primary production will affect the functioning and structure of aquatic food webs. Laboratory experiments have shown that UV-B affects almost all metabolic processes. This is not surprising: microalgae are unicellular, so the complete organism is subjected to UV radiation. However, as laboratory light conditions usually deviate from the underwater light environment with respect to applied radiation levels and spectral conditions, extrapolation of laboratory findings to the actual field situation is extremely difficult. Therefore, it is crucial for effect studies to assess first of all the primary targets which determine the net result in situ, i.e. the changes in primary production. Available experimental data refer almost exclusively to short term effects. Natural phytoplankton assemblages or species isolated for laboratory experiments are generally exposed to UV-B radiation for only a few hours, while mechanisms operating on a time scale of more than several hours, such as repair of DNA damage and adaptation are not accounted for in such experiments. Nevertheless, these mechanisms may well determine the sensitivity of an organism to chronic enhancement of UV-B radiation. Therefore, experimental data reported so far were not adequate to support a realistic risk analysis. Obtaining such risk analysis was the ultimate goal of our research effort. Collection of experimental data for the purpose of assessing the quantitative impact of UV-B radiation on natural microalgal assemblages is obstructed by several other problems. UV-B effect studies are complicated by spatial and temporal variations in damaging radiation as well as its interaction with UV-A and
971 visible light, as occurring in the field. Therefore, natural daily courses of UV-B radiation are generally significantly different from experimental exposure regimes. Because several UV induced biological effects appear to be nonreciprocal between dose rate and exposure time, an accurate dosimetry is essential for mimicking natural UV conditions. Furthermore, the spectral distribution of solar light differs significantly from that of most artificial light sources. Since biological effects are known to be strongly dependent on wavelength, biological weighting functions are required for the conversion of radiation spectra to biological effective radiation. So far, no specific "microalgae" action spectrum had been d e t e r m i n e d for the inhibition of chronic UV-B radiation on algal production. Finally, only few data are available on the penetration of UV (especially UV-B) in seas and oceans under different hydrographical and climatological conditions. Spectral data are needed for the estimation of attenuation coefficients in the ultraviolet range, the assessment of biological effective dose rates at different water depths in the euphotic zone and a realistic assessment of in situ UV responses. This type of data should also form basic knowledge to be used in the establishment of an appropriate dosimetry in laboratory experiments. Summarizing, at the start of the project no quantitative data were available to assess the effects on aquatic ecosystems. Additionally, the high accuracy necessary for the quantification of UV-B effects made traditional culture methods only poorly applicable. So the generation of accurate and relevant quantitative data required both adequate infrastructure and method development. 4.3 Aim of the project Considering the above mentioned uncertainties, this project was directed towards the study of long-term effects (several generation times) of enhanced UV-B radiation on algal production. To this end knowledge on the most relevant UV-sensitive metabolic processes had to be gained. This information would then be essential for selecting the most appropriate biological weighting functions (action spectra) for translation of experimental results to field conditions. Furthermore, dose effect relationships had to be established for different species. Also, field measurements of the underwater UV-B light regime were needed to gain knowledge of the vertical extinction of UV-B in various natural waters. The results of both experimental and field m e a s u r e m e n t s would supply basic information to be incorporated in exposure models to assess the effects of various scenarios of UV-B irradiance on specific habitats. Two main lines of research were pursued: A. Analysis of in situ UV-B light regimes of different water types (both freshwater and marine). This included: development of a radiation model to calculate surface UV-B irradiation and daily doses; verification of the radiation model by field m e a s u r e m e n t s and by measurements performed by the Laboratory of Radiation Research of the RIVM; field m e a s u r e m e n t s of solar irradiation and spectral a t t e n u a t i o n coefficients using an Optronic OL 752 spectroradiometer equipped with a submersible enclosure; m e a s u r e m e n t of intrinsic optical properties (absorption, scattering coefficients) of suspended material (algae and detritus) and dissolved organic m a t t e r for estimation of u n d e r w a t e r t r a n s m i s s i o n of UV-B radiation, development of a penetration model to estimate UV-B exposure of algae in different water types and to determine potentially sensitive water types.
972 B. Experimental studies of sensitivity and protection to natural ranges of UV-B radiation in natural phytoplankton assemblages and unialgal cultures. This included: assessment of dose-response relationships for representative marine and freshwater algae; analysis of reciprocity between dose rate and exposure time; experimental studies on causal relationships between algal sensitivity and relevant physiological mechanisms; development of a computer controlled dynamic light system (DLCS) to simulate natural light regimes in laboratory cultures; development of a special culture system for the assessment of action spectra and analysis of physiological reactions; assessment of a "general" action spectrum for the long-term effect of UV-B radiation on algal growth; integration of effect and exposure data into a general risk assessment of UV-B effects on algal production. 4.4
Results
Infrastructure and methodology built up during the project -
-
-
-
A spectrophotoradiometer (Optronics OL 752), purchased at the beginning of the project, was equipped with a submersible enclosure to allow for spectral u n d e r w a t e r m e a s u r e m e n t s to a depth of 12 meters. Expertise was accumulated using this equipment during several cruises (Dutch estuarine waters, open Atlantic waters). The spectroradiometer measurements also provided the possibility to establish an accurate dosimetry in experimental systems. Two specialised culturing facilities were developed and made operative: a computer controlled dynamic light system (see below) and a culturing device for measuring wavelength dependent biological effects (action spectra, see below). Special temperature controlled culture rooms were made operative for UV experiments. Detailed information was collected on changes in transmission of materials (perspex, cellulose acetate, polystyrene, glass filters) to be used in UV experiments, as a prerequisite for the establishment of an accurate dosimetry during long-term experiments. A method was developed to study in vivo DNA damage in individual phytoplankton cells, using immunofluorescent labelling. This has resulted in long-term cooperation projects with other research groups (see 4.7). An Image Analysis System was purchased to study DNA damage in natural p h y to p lan k to n assemblages. This system was also made operative for accurate cell size measurements. A Coulter Counter Multisizer system was purchased eventually to study in detail the UV-B induced changes in cell size and volume.
Radiation and penetration models A UV radiation model has been developed to estimate natural light regimes as a function of meteorological conditions, season and latitude. Verification of the radiation model was done using measurements performed by the Laboratory of Radiation Research of the RIVM as well as field data obtained with the Optronics OL 752 during several cruises. To allow analysis of under water UV exposure a separate model was developed to calculate the transmission of I . ~ under water. This model relates spectral transmission with intrinsic optical properties: absorption and scattering characteristics of suspended and dissolved substances
973 in various water types. Laboratory and field data on absorption properties of algal cells, detritus and humic acids were collected and included in the model. Through application of the model mean UV exposure levels could be calculated for Dutch aquatic systems. It was found that dissolved organic m a t t e r (humic acids) causes most of the a t t e n u a t i o n in freshwater and coastal regions. Here the UV-B attenuation coefficient is up to 20 times higher than the attenuation coefficient for visible light. Due to the very low levels of humic acids the attenuation of LW-B r a d i a t i o n in the ocean is relatively low. In clear ocean w a t e r s the UV-B a t t e n u a t i o n coefficient approaches the theoretical value for pure water i.e. two times the attenuation of visible light.
Dose-effect studies: interspecific differences in UV sensitivity Various marine and freshwater algae were tested for their sensitivity to chronic UV-B exposure using growth rate reduction as an overall indicator of UV-stress. Large differences in sensitivity were found between species. A comparison of a n u m b e r of freshwater species demonstrated a generally higher UV sensitivity of desmids and diatoms as compared to green algae. The prymnesiophyte Emiliania huxleyi, thought to be an important bloom forming alga in temperate and boreal marine waters, was found to be very sensitive to UV-B, more t h a n any other marine alga tested. Although marine pelagic diatoms differed considerably in their UV-sensitivity, a comparison with benthic diatoms, isolated from the Dutch Wadden Sea, revealed a significantly higher tolerance of the latter group. No general difference between pelagic diatoms and toxic dinoflagellates was found. Remarkably, a freshly isolated strain of a benthic diatom species did not have a higher UV-B tolerance t h a n a strain that had been cultured in the lab for several years. Reciprocity between UV dose rate and exposure time was tested in several algal species. The inhibition of growth rate was stronger at shorter exposure times (high dose rate) t h a n at long exposure times (low dose rate). In other words, damage of chronic UV exposures was not only a function of dose. These results further stress the importance of applying accurate dosimetry and careful experimental setup.
Studies of mechanisms behind growth inhibition In preliminary experiments photoinhibition did not explain the observed UV induced growth inhibition. Upon UV-B exposure, increases in cell dry weight were observed, while the light capturing capacity remained unchanged. This indicated t h a t the photosynthetic apparatus is not the primary target under chronic UV exposure. Also the effect of low UV-B levels on pigment content, cell size, protein and carbohydrate content, and u l t r a s t r u c t u r e were investigated. UV induced growth rate reduction was typically accompanied by increases in protein content, pigment content and mean cell volume. These trends were stronger at higher UV-B radiation levels. However, at very high UV-B doses, when complete growth inhibition occurred, no increase in cell components were measured. These results were found to be very consistent when testing different species and various UV culture systems (see also below). The increases in cell dry weight, protein and carbohydrate content, pigment content and mean cell size hint at a UV mediated delay in cell division. In this view, low UV-B levels would arrest DNA synthesis t h r o u g h the occurrence of DNA damage, but not the biosynthesis of cell components, thereby arresting the cell cycle at the end of the G1 phase. This was
974 later on confirmed by DNA content and DNA damage m e a s u r e m e n t s in the marine diatom CycloteUa sp. (see above).
UV-B Effect studies using computer controlled Dynamic Light Regime To realize an accurate and realistic dosimetry, a continuous culture systems with steering software was developed to simulate natural photosynthetic light and UV-B regimes simultaneously. The culture system was designed to allow exact quantification of UV-B exposures. High intensity light sources (PAR up to 2000 ~mol.m-2.s-1) provide a realistic UV/PAR ratio. By computer controlled angular slat displacement of Venetian blinds natural sine-curve-like intensity courses for both UV and the visible part can be simulated, as well as the light regime for a superimposed vertical mixing. The combination of rectangular algal cultures and light sources allows accurate dosimetry. In this culture system the effect of LW-B on g r o w t h rate and other physiological p a r a m e t e r s of the common green f r e s h w a t e r alga Selenastrum capricornutum was studied. During short term exposure experiments (transition from no UV-B to UV-B) only significant damage to the photosynthetic system could be detected. A reversed transition to no UV-B d e m o n s t r a t e d recovery of the system. However, although with a lower midday level, a more balanced photosynthetic activity, comparable with the conditions in the absence of I_W-B radiation, was observed after a prolonged exposure to UV-B radiation. The m e a s u r e d daily photosynthetic activity u n d e r chronic UV-B exposure poorly reflected the overall growth conditions. As shown in Figure 4.1, chronic UV-B exposure caused significant increases in mean cell dry weight. Also, mean cell volume and pigment and carbohydrate content increased as a result of UV-B exposure. These results, in combination with the p h o t o s y n t h e s i s m e a s u r e m e n t s , once more hint at UV-B induced cell cycle arrest due to DNA damage rather than inhibition of the photosynthetic apparatus. These results also e m p h a s i z e the incompatibility of acute and chronic UV effects" acute UV responses, such as those m e a s u r e d in short term oxygen evolution or 14C incorporation experiments, might well underestimate chronic effects m e a s u r e d after several generation times.
975
35-
30-
25Cn N (D C3 c- 2 0
I
--
._~
15-
I
10-
I P-sat No UV-B
I P-sat
I Posat
Low UV-B High UV-B
I P-lim No UV-B
I P-lim Low UV-B
treatment
Figure 4.1 Steady State levels of Selenastrum capricornutum cell dry weight as a result of UV-B exposure. P-sat = P-saturated; P-lim = P-limited. Open circles: start of light period; closed circles: end of light period; Vertical lines through data points: standard deviations
DNA damage and repair Very little is known about UV-B induced effects on microalgal DNA. This lack in knowledge is surprising, since l_~ effect studies on higher organised eukaryotic organisms, including man, are mainly focussed on structural changes in DNA. Different lesions can be induced by UV, of which thymine dimers are not only the most abundant photoproducts, but also typically formed as a result of UV-B exposure. A method was developed to detect this kind of cyclobutane dimer in single microalgal cells with a monoclonal antibody, following recent developments in skin cancer research. Detection and quantification of DNA damage is possible after fluorochrome labelling in combination with epifluorescence microscopy and flow-cytometry. A linear relationship was found between the applied UV-B dose and the amount of thymine dimers found in nuclear Cyclotella sp. D N A (Figure 4.2). Within a population of cells the amount of damaged cells, as well as the mean damage level in damaged cells increased with increasing UV-B dose. Kinetics of damage and repair have been studied at various low levels of UV radiation.
976 Simultaneous measurements of cellular DNA content showed a decrease in DNA synthesis during and after several hours of UV exposure. These results, in combination with the observed increases in cell size and cellular protein and pigment levels, indicate that the cell cycle is arrested at the end of the G1 phase. It was also found that the cell cycle can be resumed only after the damage is repaired. Additionally, a shift was observed towards G2 cells in populations of Cyclotella which had been exposed to I_W-B for several days. This seems to be due to the fact that cells with a higher DNA content contain more thymine dimers, requiring more time and energy for repair processes. Determination of species-specific differences in the induction of damage and repair may explain differences in UV-B tolerance and therefore be useful for UV risk assessment studies with respect to shifts in natural populations exposed to a structural increase in incident UV radiation.
Action spectra Action spectra determined so far were either based on the study of higher eukaryotic organisms or isolated cell organelles. Mostly monochromatic light instead of polychromatic light was used to establish these action spectra. For phytoplankton one general action spectrum has been described, based on short term photosynthetic rate measurements. Internationally, very little attention has been payed to the establishment of action spectra, probably because the description of an action spectrum is difficult and time consuming. A special culturing system was developed to study wavelength dependent chronic biological effects using whole organisms and polychromatic light. Using the marine diatom Cyclotella sp. as the test organism, tentative action spectra have been constructed for growth inhibition and DNA damage. Simultaneously wavelength dependent changes in physiological parameters were studied, such as protein and photosynthetic pigment content, and cell size. Both the DNA and growth inhibition action spectrum are very steep in the UV-B region of the spectrum and very much alike. Also, protein, pigment and cell size patterns showed high correlations with the action spectra. The results indicate that wavelength dependent UV-B effects on growth rate are strongly determined by DNA damage and thereby by changes in the cell cycle.
977 20
~n
z
UV-B intensity: I W/mZ 1
15
0
10 ~0
x~ z c~
0
I
I
2
UV-B dosis (KJ/m z)
I
3
Figure 4.2 The formation of thymine-dimers in Cyclotella sp. as a function of UV-B dose. DNA damage (Y-axis) is expressed as the mean damage level in damaged cells within a population of UV-B exposed cells UV-B effec t m o d e l To integrate the experimental results the development of a UV-B effect model has been started. The model structure is shown in Figure 4.3. To realize a global level the Atlantic Ocean has been selected as the model system. It has been chosen because of its pole to pole orientation, covering all climatic and latitudinal zones, both coastal and oceanic. Also, a substantial amount of literature data is available on the various subsystems. By the integration of a mathematical model with the effect study, an improved framework and structure is created for experimental research. The dynamic model is aimed at foodweb processes. P h y t o p l a n k t o n growth is r e g u l a t e d by n u t r i e n t s , t e m p e r a t u r e , PAR and UV-B light, and zooplankton grazing. A distinction will be made between different algal and zooplankton groups, each with their own specific parameters. In this way shifts in the food web are included as combined effects of ADT, ACO2 and AUV-B. Changes in primary and secondary production can be expected. The model will provide both science and politics with a tool to obtain an integrated picture of UV-B effects on aquatic ecosystems. Due to the technical complexity of the research and the r a t h e r unexplored field of UV-B effects on ecosystems, the development of the model (and the generation of experimental input data) will overrun the NRP I period. The expected uncertainties in the model will be quantified and reduced by means of a recently developed model analysis resulting in probability distributions for the parameters and variables.Using this model risk assessments will be made for different marine systems and UV scenarios.
978
temp
PAR
NSML
A i humic id
9
zoo
W........."..1. 4
sP
DET
/ N deep .~I~
Figure 4.3 Schematic structure of the UV-effect model. NSML = N u t r i e n t Surface Mixed Layer; Ndeep = Nutrient deep layer; PAR = Photosynthetic Active Radiation; temp = temperature; NPP = Net Primary Production; SP = Secondary Production; PHYT = Phytoplankton; ZOO = Zooplankton; DET = Detritus
4.5 C o n c l u s i o n s and p e r s p e c t i v e s of results o b t a i n e d d u r i n g N R P I Increased exposure to UV radiation can affect aquatic ecosystems. Phytoplankton produces about 30% of the biomass on Earth, and thereby fixes a large proportion of the greenhouse gas carbon dioxide. Changes in the structure of the algal community may seriously endanger species higher in the food chain. A study of the effects of UV on marine ecosystems is especially relevant because changes in biological activity in the ocean have repercussions on global biogeochemical cycles, not only of carbon but also of sulfur, another element that is directly related to climate change through dimethyl sulfide emission from ocean to atmosphere. During NRP I new insights were gained with respect to UV penetration in aquatic environments and UV stress phenomena after chronic exposure to low levels of LW-B. The results collected during this project will contribute to the knowledge of tolerance and selection. The results obtained during NRP I have revealed that many species show growth inhibition even at ambient UV-B levels. Benthic algae isolated from the Wadden
979 Sea are less sensitive to UV-B compared to pelagic species. This is most likely due to genetic adaptation to the ambient UV-B levels impinging on mud flats during spring and summer. In contrast, marine pelagic species of clear open waters, such as Emiliania huxleyi, are very sensitive to UV-B. This indicates t h a t pelagic algal c o m m u n i t i e s will be affected more strongly by increases in incident UV-B radiation. Clearly, UV-B is a n a t u r a l selective factor in plankton assemblages. Worrest (1983) already calculated t h a t a UV-B free environment would increase global p r i m a r y production with 12%. Since Emiliania huxleyi forms blooms in those a r e a s where ozone depletion has been recorded (northern p a r t s of the Atlantic Ocean), increases in incident UV-B radiation will strongly affect the performance of this organism in the field. As shown in Figure 4.4, which is a combination of experimental growth inhibition data and BED values derived from our radiation and penetration models, significant growth inhibition of Emiliania huxleyi due to UV-B will occur during summer at 52oN at the m e a n ozon level for this latitude: 50% growth inhibition at 5 m depth considering the DNA action s p e c t r u m (ED50(DNA) in Figure 4.4); 50% growth inhibition at 15 m w h e n considering the Plant action spectrum (ED50(PLANT) in Figure 4.4). The results have shown t h a t short term effect studies done so far to estimate UV-B effects on microalgae give a considerable underestimation of UV-B effects: our chronic exposure experiments have revealed t h a t short term photosynthesis m e a s u r e m e n t s are not r e p r e s e n t a t i v e for chronic effects such as growth r a t e reduction. This means t h a t the calculations of production decrease based on short t e r m e x p e r i m e n t s of UV effects on photosynthesis in Antarctic w a t e r s (12% reduction of primary productivity, as estimated by American scientists) have to be reevaluated using p a r a m e t e r s which take into account the chronic UV-B effects such as growth reduction. Our experiments also suggest that growth rate reduction is a more reliable and realistic p a r a m e t e r to be m e a s u r e d t h a n the production m e a s u r e m e n t s done so far: growth rate takes into account UV-B effects over several generations, and, moreover, growth rate is a r e s u l t a n t of all metabolic processes affected by UV-B, including DNA damage - certainly not only the photosynthetic process. UV-B effect modelling is in need of urgent adaptation with respect to this point. This will be realized in the second phase of NRP (NRP II).
980
E(~)~ 1
ED50(DNA)
-
ED50(PLANT)
Depth
lO
lOO
1000
I
,oi
(m)
Figure 4.4 Calculated IJW-B exposure for 15 J u n e at 52~ and ozone thickness of 320 DU. x-axis: biologically effective daily UV-B dose (J.m-2.day-1); Y-axis: water depth (m); DNA: biologically effective dose calculated with Setlow's DNA action spectrum; PLANT: biologically effective dose calculated with Caldwell's P l a n t action spectrum. ED50(DNA): depth at which 50% growth inhibition occurs for Emiliania huxleyi considering the DNA action spectrum; ED50(PLANT): depth at which 50% growth inhibition occurs for E. huxleyi considering the Plant action spectrum The results obtained during NRP I have indicated t h a t DNA damage and its subsequent effect on the cell cycle plays a major role in UV-B mediated growth rate reduction. This approach is new in aquatic UV-B effect studies and further underlines the importance of studying I.W-B effects over several generation times. DNA damage occurs at realistic UV-B levels in most tested species, and the ability to overcome DNA damage is now thought to be a primary determining factor of UV-B sensitivity in phytoplankton species. A substantial body of evidence is presented during the project, indicating t h a t UV-B affects the cell cycle of microalgae, causing an arrest in the G2 phase. This causes shifts in mean cell volume, pigmentation as well as the content of s t r u c t u r a l compounds and storage products. This will most certainly result in changes in the aquatic food web. Herbivore predators in aquatic environments will be affected by these changes because many herbivores rely on a defined food size spectrum, which is altered by cellular volume increases. Also sinking rates will be affected, resulting in a proportional increase in vertical carbon fluxes out of the euphotic zone. Although refinements have to be made with respect to validation, the development of the r a d i a t i o n and penetration models have provided useful tools for the
981 calculation of UV-B exposure to phytoplankton in situ. F u r t h e r m o r e , action spectra will furnish the assessment of biological effective dose rates in n a t u r a l waters. The action spectra for DNA damage and growth can be incorporated in the radiation models after necessary fine tuning operations planned for the future. The experimental results obtained during NRP I provide basic insight into the key p a r a m e t e r s to be included in the model dedicated to risk assessment for specific m a r i n e habitats. Insight into the exposure of algae to chronic n a t u r a l levels of UV-B and effects on the cellular level, to a great extent derived from the insights gained during NRP I, form a firm basis to establish first modelling on large scale. Within the coming years our UV-effect model can become operative (depending on NRP II funding). This simulation model is specifically focussed on the vulnerability of the entire Atlantic Ocean ecosystem for integrated climate change factors, including UV-B, t e m p e r a t u r e and carbon dioxide, and is so far unique within the international scientific community. 4.6 C o o p e r a t i o n w i t h o t h e r r e s e a r c h g r o u p s w i t h i n a n d o u t s i d e N R P
Within NRP framework: -
VU A m s t e r d a m The Netherlands (Dr. J. Rozema): cooperation with respect to DNA damage measurements and modelling. AZU The N e t h e r l a n d s (Prof. J.C. van der Leun, Dr. F.R. de Gruijl): DNA damage method and action spectra.
Outside NRP framework: -
-
Laboratory of Radiation Research (at RIVM), The Netherlands: UV/Ozone data. NIOZ, The Netherlands (Dr. M.J.W. Veldhuis): Flow cytometric DNA damage m e a s u r e m e n t s , Cooperation between NRP participant and NIOZ is being materialised in a joint Ph.D project dedicated to the effect of UV-B on oceanic picoplankters. This project (financed by NIOZ) will s t a r t in the a u t u m n of 1994. LU W a g e n i n g e n , The N e t h e r l a n d s (Dr. E. van Donk) UV-B effects on phytoplankon-zooplankton interactions. TNO, The Netherlands (Dr. L. Roza): DNA damage method development. RUG Plant Physiology Dept., The Netherlands (Dr. F. van Hasselt): General exchange of methods and equipment. University of Oldenburg (Prof. Dr. Th. Hiipner): Mesocosm experiments. University of Lund, Sweden (Dr. Nils Ekelund): DNA damage m e a s u r e m e n t s in mesocosm experiments.
4.7 E f f e c t s o f i n c r e a s e d UV-B r a d i a t i o n o n s t r u c t u r e a n d f u n c t i o n i n g o f a l g a l c o m m u n i t i e s in d i f f e r e n t c l i m a t i c zones: r i s k of a g l o b a l d e c r e a s e in s t r a t o s p h e r i c o z o n e
Assessment Among the innovating elements in this project are the prolonged exposures to enhanced UV-B radiation, extending over several generations of the organisms studied. This realistic experimental condition provides for the inclusion of processes such as repair of DNA damage, and adaptation. For the first time, attention is given to DNA-damage in algae, using techniques developed in Dutch research on skin cancer. Initial determinations were made of action spectra for some of the
982 effects of UV radiation on algae; these show a strong involvement of the UV-B wavelength range. This work is giving real contributions to the international efforts to predict the effects of increased UV-B irradiance on p h y t o p l a n k t o n and the potentially important consequences for the global atmospheric. 5.
INTEGRATION
Integration of the various topics is obviously desirable in a large national research programme. The interim evaluation by S&PA and HCG signalized t h a t in the area of h u m a n h e a l t h there were projects on m a l a r i a vectors and UV-B effects, but direct effects of climate on h u m a n health were not covered in the NRP. The latter should be included anyway in the integration efforts under Theme Integration. The immediate reason for the lack of projects on direct effects of climate on h u m a n h e a l t h was t h a t there were no project proposals in this area. The reason behind this is probably t h a t The Netherlands have a moderate climate, where extreme w e a t h e r conditions are rare; death by heat or cold is practically unknown, and is unlikely to occur with the changes now within the range of expectations. Research into such effects is apparently not considered urgent, or expected to be rewarding. The i n t e g r a t i o n desirable was achieved in a different direction. The groups i n v e s t i g a t i n g effects of UV-B r a d i a t i o n on health, t e r r e s t r i a l and a q u a t i c ecosystems joined forces, and s t a n d a r d i z e d equipment, m e a s u r e m e n t s and methods. Beyond the effects groups the contacts were extended to the groups m a k i n g m e a s u r e m e n t s of ambient UV radiation and those m a k i n g integration models. The specifications of the UV-measurements were carefully adjusted to the needs of the effects studies. And the UV-B effects groups provided input for a longitudinal integration model. This model was developed outside, but in close connection with the NRP, and ranged from production and release of ozone depleting chemicals through atmospheric change to penetration of UV-B radiation and future incidence of skin cancer in The Netherlands; it is the explicit intention to include also other effects of UV-B radiation as soon as sufficient q u a n t i t a t i v e information will be available (Slaper et a1.,1992). 6.
RELEVANCE FOR POLICY MAKING
Even while only the skin cancer effects are sufficiently quantified to be t a k e n into account in the integrated model mentioned, the results already have relevance for Dutch policy. The additional mortality from skin cancer, predicted on the basis of ozone depletions as expected during the coming decades well exceeds the limit of 1 d e a t h per million of the p o p u l a t i o n per y e a r ( H e a l t h Council of The Netherlands,1994). This limit of 1 per million per year is considered the "maximal tolerable risk" in Dutch policy with respect to other e n v i r o n m e n t a l factors influenced by h u m a n activities, such as chemicals and iozining radiation.
983 The ozone depletion t h a t will occur during the next 50 years in spite of successful international efforts to protect the ozone layer will, therefore, have at least one effect of relevance to Dutch policy. As skin cancer is the only effect for which such calculations can be made until now, this finding suggests t h a t quantification of other effects, on health as well as ecosystems, is highly desirable. Some of these effects may will be more important than skin cancer. The H e a l t h Council of The N e t h e r l a n d s is an advisory body to the Dutch Government in matters of health and of the environment. The report on ultraviolet radiation from sunlight was to some extent a byproduct of the research activities in the NRP. The report was prepared by a committee of 14 scientists; 8 of them were also involved in the NRP. The Minister of Housing, Physical Planning and the Environment recently wrote a letter to the Chairman of the Health Council (letter SNV/27694009, dd. July 7, 1994), recognizing the value of the lYV-report for Dutch environmental policy. Likewise, t h e D u t c h i n p u t to the new (UNEP, 1994) A s s e s s m e n t on Environmental Effects of Ozone Depletion results mainly from research sponsored by the NRP.
7.
OUTLOOK: FUTURE WORK
The conditions for research on effects of increasing UV-B radiation are unsteady. Granting agencies tend to refer to each other for the funding. This is made even easier by the fact t h a t the necessity of this research is contested from a variety of viewpoints: a. The problem of ozone depletion does not exist. b. The problem exists, but the biological impacts are negligible. c. The effects on h u m a n health may be easily prevented. d. The problem was already solved. Each of these statements will be briefly discussed.
The problem of ozone depletion does not exist There is a fierce publicity action to deny the problem of ozone depletion. It would be a fake problem, brought into the world by commercial interests. Moreover, the reasoning continues, even if ozone depletion would occur, it would not lead to more UV-radiation, and even if there would come more UV radiation, t h a t would be beneficial rather than harmful (Maduro and Schauerhammer, 1992). The message is pseudoscience, but for the media this message appears to have news value, more t h a n the points of view of regular science which are fairly well-known by now. The counteraction is partly successful, at least in inducing question m a r k s in public opinion. The potential danger is erosion of the public support for the efforts to protect the ozone layer.
The problem exists, but the biological impacts are negligible This viewpoint is around in many forms. I quote one example, written recently by a scientist working in a related field. He suggests t h a t the impacts of the expected increases of UV radiation cannot be very serious, because "an increase in yearly
984 effective UV of 15% at groundlevel is comparable with moving about 400 km nearer to the equator (e.g. Groningen-Maastricht) or moving to an altitude of 500 m compared to sealever'. It a p p e a r s useful to discuss this type of a r g u m e n t a t i o n , as it occurs more generally. The reasoning given can hardly apply to natural ecosystems. Seas and forests do not move appreciably. But even if the reasoning would be valid only for people, it would save a lot of work if it would be so easy to come to a conclusion on the health effects of increased UV-B radiation. The conclusion may appear plausible to a person who did move 400 km South. His individual risk for a particular health effect may have increased from 1.0 x 10-4 to 1.3 x 10-4, but he cannot possibly notice that. He may well be convinced t h a t there was no change at all. Multiplication of this zero-impression by the number of people in a population forms the basis for the suggestion that the risk of such moves is also insignificant for populations. The correct procedure would be, of course, to m u l t i p l y the estimated increase in individual risk by the number of people in the population. Such estimated risks are, however, not yet available for most of the effects under consideration. But this is no excuse for following a loose reasoning which cannot even produce a valid approximation. The risk of moves by entire populations cannot be checked directly, either, because such moves are practically impossible. The Dutch population could move to an altitude of 500 m only by going up into the air, and 400 km south only by invading Belgium and France. How can we know t h a t the risk of such moves would be small? The best indications in this area are produced by migration studies in epidemiology. These investigate how individual risks change by migration from, for instance, Western Europe to Israel or Australia. The results of such studies, together with m a n y other data, form the basis for the risk estimates made for h u m a n health. Only from such quantitative estimations it can be concluded w h e t h e r or not a certain change of UV-B radiation can have important effects. For m a n y effects, further investigations are needed before such a conclusion is possible, but some well-founded quantitive estimations have already been made for skin cancer. These have lead to the conclusion t h a t a 20 percent increase in the incidence of nonmelanoma skin cancer is to be expected after serveral decades as a consequence of ozone depletion (Madronich and de Gruijl, 1993; UNEP, 1994). As these cancers already have the highest incidence of all forms of cancer in several light-skinned populations, this will cause a significant aggravation of an existing public health problem. That can not be talked away with pseudo-quantitative suggestions.
T h e e f f e c t s o n h u m a n h e a l t h m a y be e a s i l y p r e v e n t e d For effects of increased UV-B irradiance on h u m a n health, there is a special consideration. The UV-doses received by people depend not only on the irradiance outdoors, but also on their own behaviour. Any increase in solar UV-B radiation m a y be compensated by staying indoors more of the time and, when outdoors, by keeping in the shade, wearing hats and more clothing and by using sunscreens. It is
985 easier, therefore, to limit undesirable effects by influencing the behaviour of people t h a n by policies r e q u i r i n g knowledge of the m a n y possible effects, such as melanoma and nonmelanoma skin cancer, cataracts, suppressions of the immune system, etc. This solution presupposes that it is feasible to influence the behaviour of people in the desired way. Experience until now gives no strong support to this assumption. Some success is reported only from Australia in recent years. That was achieved in an intensive campaign, launched under exceptionally favourable circumstances: the incidence of skin cancer in Australia is so high that almost everyone knows the problem in his own family. Branches of the Antarctic ozone hole passing over Southern Australia helped mobilize public attention and fear. Even there it is an open question if it will be possible to sustain this changed behaviour for long periods of time, t h a t is, for at least several decades. That would be necessary to influence some of the long-term effects, such as squamous cell carcinoma and cataract. In areas where light-skinned people live under less extreme conditions, it will be even more difficult to convince people t h a t they should change their behaviour. There is certainly reason for trying it, which was recently recommended by the Health Council of The Netherlands, and is now being carried out by the Dutch Cancer Campaign. There may also be reason to do research on how to influence peoples' behaviour more effectively. There is no reason, however, to think that this can be done instead of studying the effects of I.rV-B radiation. Epidemiological observations strongly suggest, for instance, t h a t working indoors, which appears one of the most efficient ways of reducing the UV-exposures, actually increases the risk of melanoma. That may have to do with the irregularity of the remaining exposures. In any case it indicates t h a t protection is not an easy overall-solution. J u s t as other preventive measures it requires knowledge, such as dose-effect relationships and action spectra of the various UV-B effects.
T h e p r o b l e m w a s a l r e a d y solved Prediction of effects of increased UV-B irradiance played an important role in the decision-making process leading to the international efforts to protect the ozone layer. The foundation was laid in the Vienna Convention for the Ozone Layer (1985). Limits to production and use of chemicals that damage stratospheric ozone were specified in the Montreal Protocol on Substances t h a t Deplete the Ozone Layer (1987), and made more stringent in the Amendments of London (1990) and Copenhagen (1992). Practically all producer nations joined this process. According to the latest Amendment, production of almost all ozone depleting chemicals will be stopped by 1996. This process cannot be speeded up any more, even if research would identify i m p o r t a n t new effects of increased UV-B radiation. This is reason for some policy-makers to decide t h a t this type of research does not deserve high priority anymore. This has led to a decrease of funding, especially in the USA. The reasoning given is convincing from the viewpoint of policy decisions on the Montreal Protocol. This is, however, a r a t h e r limited viewpoint. The banning of ozone depleting substances was a necessary first step. Even on the assumption of
986 full and worldwide compliance with the agreements reached, the chlorine loading of the atmosphere will continue to rise for several years, and the ozone layer will be reduced for at least half a century. And anything less than full compliance will make the situation worse. Policy makers, including those in the Dutch Ministry of Housing, Physical Planning and the Environment, are asking what will be the most important consequences, and w h at can be done to prevent or mitigate these. Giving answers to these questions requires much more knowledge than answering the initial question, of whether or not depletion of the ozone layer would have effects important enough to justify action to protect the layer. Organized science has expressed itself clearly on this point. The International Council of Scientific Unions has formed a Scientific Committee on Problems of the Environment (SCOPE). SCOPE paid special attention to the effects of damage to the ozone layer that will persist for a long time in spite of protective action. It produced two reports, "Effects of Increased Ultraviolet Radiation on Biological Systems" (1992) and "Effects of Increased Ultraviolet Radiation on Global Ecosystems" (1993). The potential impacts are considered of such importance that the scientific community is urged to increase its efforts: "This new stage of quantitative questions will require full utilization of existing research capacity, and a major expansion in this direction is essential" (SCOPE 1992, p. 25). The United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) took a leading role in the international efforts to protect the ozone layer. It knows well what was achieved so far. But it does not support the notion that effects research fulfilled its function, and can have lower priority now. In its latest report on "Environmental Effects of Ozone Depletion" (1991), it calls for better funding of research on effects of increasing UV-B radiation: "Urgent problems are still waiting to be addressed" (UNEP, 1991, p.i).
Actual developments The various conflicting views about the urgency of research on effects of increased UV-B radiation play a role in all communities, and cause great variations in funding. Research efforts in the USA, which provided a large proportion of the information in earlier years, have decreased. The European Community, on the other hand, started late but increased its efforts in recent years in the research programme "Environment". Several European countries have national research programmes going. In The Netherlands, NRP-I has given a real boost, roughly doubling the research volume in this area. With the changing philosophy, NRP-II putting emphasis on systems rather than climate factors, the support may well decrease again. This would be a loss for the generation of much needed knowledge, and a pity of the investments in equipment and know-how during NRP-I. Other sources of funding on this scale are not available in The Netherlands.
987 8.
CONCLUSIONS
The projects on effects of increasing UV-B radiation in NRP-I have produced valuable contributions in their areas (section 3 of this assessment). With respect to the importance of increasing UV-B radiation the following conclusions appear justified: a. In the area of h u m a n health, UV-B radiation has many influences. The UV-B increases as expected even under the most favourable scenario of ozone depletion do have health consequences relevant to Dutch policy. Uncertainty about other potentially grave impacts calls for intensive studies. b. In t e r r e s t r i a l ecosystems, the importance of the UV-B irradiance is very different for the various subsystems. The NRP-researchers made progress in identifying those sub-systems where UV-B irradiance is important. c.In aquatic ecosystems the UV-B irradiance is likely to be an important factor. The effects of increased UV-B radiation also have feedback on the atmosphere. The projects on UV-B effects benefited from mutual interactions, with respect to equipment, m e a s u r e m e n t s as well as photobiological aspects. The interactions with the groups making measurements of ambient UV radiation and integration models for effects may be further intensified. The new philosophy for NRP-II, with its emphasis on systems rather than climate factors, may lead to a spreading of UV-B research over different Themes. In t h a t case, some form of interaction in the UV-B sphere should be maintained. It would be a real loss if this new philosophy would lead to cutting out the important study on effects of UV-B radiation on h u m a n health. In The Netherlands UV-B radiation probably has more serious impacts on h u m a n health t h a n any other climatic factor. 9.
REFERENCES
Blumthaler, M. and Ambach, W., 1990. Indication of increasing solar ultra-violet-B radiation flux in Alpine regions. Science 248: 206-208. Buma, A.G.J., Hannen, E.J. van, Veldhuis, M.J.W., Roza, L., and Gieskes W.W.C. Monitoring UV-B induced DNA damage and subsequent repair in a marine diatom u s i n g i m m u n o f l u o r e s c e n t t h y m i n e dimer detection. J. Phycol. submitted. Buma, A.G.J., Zemmelink, H.J., Sjollema, K.A., and Gieskes, W.W.C., 1994. Effect of UV-B on cell characteristics of the marine diatom Cyclotella sp. Proceedings First European Conference on Environmental UV Effects, Nov. 1993, Munich, Germany. (In press). Health Council of The Netherlands, 1994. "UV Straling uit Zonlicht", Report 1994/05. (The report will soon be available in English). Maduro R.A. and R. Schauerhammer, 1992. The Holes in the Ozone Scare, 21st Century Science Associates, Washington, D.C. Madronic, S. and de Gruijl, F.R. 1993. Skin cancer and UV radiation. Nature 366: 23.
988 Rozema, J., Lenssen, G.M. and Staaij, J.W.M. van der, 1990. The combined effect of increased CO2 and UV-B radiation on some agricultural and salt marsh species. In: J. Goudriaan, H. van Keulen and H.H. van Laar (eds). The greenhouse effect and primary productivity in European agro-ecosystems, Pudoc Wageningen, p. 68-71. Rozema, J., Staaij, J. van de, Costa, V., Torres Pereira, J., Broekman, R., Lenssen, G. and Stroetenga, M., 1991. A comparison of the growth, photosynthesis and transpiration of wheat and maize in response to enhanced ultraviolet-B radiation. In: Abrol., V.P. et al. (eds.). Impact of global climatic changes on photosynthesis and plant productivity. Asia publishing house, Sittingbourne, U.K., p. 163-174. Rozema, J., 1993. Plant responses to atmospheric CO2 enrichment: interactions with some soil and atmospheric conditions. Vegetatio 105/105: 173-190. Rozema, J., Lambers, H., van de Geijn, S.C. and Cambridge, M.L., 1993. CO2 and Biosphere. Kluwer, Dordrecht, p. 484. Rozema, J., Tosserams, M., van de Staaij, J., Magendans, E. Nelissen, H. and Brouwer, T., 1994. Impact of enhanced solar UV-B radiation on plants from terrestrial ecosystems. Proceeding EEG Workshop UV-B-Mfinchen, GSF. SCOPE, 1993. Effects of increased ultraviolet radiation on global ecosystems. Proceedings of a workshop arranged by the Scientific Committee on Problems of the Environment (SCOPE), Tramariglio. Sardinia. p. 47. Slaper et al., 1992. Ozone Depletion and Skin Cancer Incidence: An Integrated Modelling Approach. Report nr. 749292991, National Institute of Public Health, Bilthoven. S&PA and HCG Science Policy Associates, Inc. and Holland Consulting Group, 1992. Evaluation of the Technical Emphasis, Policy Relevance and Management Performance, p. 24. Staaij, J.W.M., Huysmans, R., Ernst, W.H.O. and Rozema, J., 1994. The effect of elevated UV-B (280-320 nm) radiation levels on Silene vulgaris: a comparison between a highland and a lowland population. Environmental Pollution (in press). Staaij, J.W.M. van der, Lenssen, G.M., Stroetenga, M. and Rozema, J., 1993. The combined effects of elevated CO2 levels and UV-B radiation on growth characteristcs of Elymus athericus. Vegetatio 104/105: 433-440. Steeneken, S.F., Buma, A.G.J. and Gieskes, W.W.C. Changes in transmission characteristics of polymethylmethacrylate and cellulose(III)acetate during exposure to ultraviolet light. Photochem. & Photobiol., submitted. Sontag, Y., Gurssen,J., de Gruijl, F.R., Van der Leun, J.C., Van Ulster, W.A. and Van Loveren H., 1994. Ultraviolet-radiation-induced impairment of the early initiating and the late effector phases of contact hypersensitivity to picrylchloride: regulation by different mechanisms. J. Invest. Dermatol. 132: 923-927. Tosserams, M. and Rozema, J., 1994. Effects of supplemental UV-B radiation (280-320 nm) on the dune grass land species Calamagrostis epigeios. Environmental Pollution (in press). UNEP, 1994. Assessment on Environmental Effects of Ozone Depletion. Van Hannen E.J., Buma, A.G.J., and Gieskes, W.W.C., 1993. Immunochemische detectie van schade in mariene microalgen geinduceerd door ultraviolet licht (UV-B): evaluatie van een nieuwe methode in ecosysteemonderzoek. NRP Report.
989 Van Liere, L. and Gieskes W.W.C., 1993. Effects of increased UV-B radiation on structure and function of algal communities in different climatic zones: risks of a global decrease in stratospheric ozone. Interim Report NRP Project 851054. Van Hannen E.J., Buma, A.G.J., Roza, L., Veldhuis, M., and Gieskes, W.W.C. Measurement of thymine dimers in phytoplankton on a single cell basis using a monoclonal antibody. Proceedings First European Conference on Environmental UV Effects, Nov. 1993, Munich, Germany (in press). Veen, A., 1992. Experimental analysis of phytoplankton production as affected by enhanced UV-B radiation. In: Annual Scientific Report 1991 of the National Institute of Public Health and Environmental protection, Bilthoven, p. 226-229. Veen, A., 1993. Effects of increased UV-B radiation on phytoplankton. A preliminary study and research programme. RIVM-report 731054001. Veen, A., 1994. Effekten op aquatische ecosystemen. In: Milieurapportage 1993 II. Integrale Rapportage Aantasting Ozonlaag en Blootstelling UV. RIVM, Bilthoven, p. 22-23. Veen, A., 1994. The effect of chronic and acute exposure to ultraviolet-B radiation on the daily oxygen production of Selenastrum capricornutum (Chlorophyceae): A continuous culture study using computer-controlled light regime. Proceedings First European Conference on Environmental UV Effects, Nov. 1993, Munich, Germany, (in press). Veen, A., 1994. Transmissie van UV straling onder water. In: Milieurapportage 1993 II. Integrale Rapportage Aantasting Ozonlaag en Blootstelling UV. RIVM, Bilthoven. p. 19. Yu, W., Teramura, A.H. and Sullivan, J.H. 1991. Model YMT-6 UV-B modulation system, manual of operation, final raport to US EPA, Corvallis, Oregon, USA.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Short papers within NRP subtheme "Effects o f e n h a n c e d UV.B r a d i a t i o n "
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Climate Change Research: Evaluation and Policy Implications S. Zwerver, R.S.A.R. van Rompaey, M.T.J. Kok and M.M. Berk, (Eds.) 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
993
Effects of enhanced UV-B radiation on structure and function of phytoplankton communities A. Veen a and A.G.J. Buma b
aNational Institute of Public Health and Environmental Protection, Laboratory of Water and Drinking Water Research, P.O. Box 1, 3720 BA Bilthoven, The Netherlands
bState University of Groningen, Department of Marine Biology, P.O. Box 14, 9750 AA Haren, The Netherlands
Abstract In a research project aimed at identifying the primary targets and effects of UV-B radiation on microalgae, it was concluded that most research on this subject did not meet the criteria necessary for a quantitative assessment for the effects of ozone related UV-B enhancement. Therefore a new experimental approach was developed. Experiments on long-term effects were carried out under simulated natural light conditions. A reduced growth rate accompanied by an increased cellular biomass and size proved to be the main effect of UV-B exposure. By immunofluoresent labeling and flow-cytometry, specific UV-B induced damage could be detected in the DNA of the studied organisms.
A global decrease in ozone concentration has been detected over the last 15 years. This depletion, which is most distinct during the Antarctic spring (" ozone hole"), raises concern about the negative effects of the resulting increase in UV-B (290-315 nm) radiation on aquatic ecosystems. To assess the impact of enhanced UV-B radiation on the aquatic environment most research is logically focused on the phytoplankton compartment. By virtue of its capacity to store solar energy (photosynthesis) phytoplankton forms the first level of the aquatic trophic structure. Furthermore, because of its photosynthetic activity and formation of calcite (coccolithophores), marine phytoplankton is an essential link in global carbon dioxide cycles. Currently, 40% of fossil fuel carbon dioxide is assumed to be stored in the oceans. Dimethylsulfide (DMS) production from marine phytoplankton blooms is the major source of cloud-condensation nuclei over the oceans. The amount of nuclei determines the albedo of clouds and thus the earth's radiation budget. The role of phytoplankton raises two major questions: firstly, does enhanced UV-B radiation significantly affect climate feedback mechanisms and, secondly, what is the final impact on the
994 wind ~
% Io
D A
0.) r
=
A
~9
K
R
K
o~..4
~,,
,..........
,
,
,
time (h)
time (i)
Figure 1. Schematic presentation of natural light conditions as experienced by algal cells (solid line = PAR-, dotted line = UV-B radiation). Left graph shows surface irradiances. Center graph shows how algae travel through a light gradient (light intensities as % of surface irradiance [Io]). Right graph shows an example of the net effect of vertical transport on the fight regime experienced by algae. aquatic food chain. To answer both these questions, the primary targets and effects of enhanced UV-B radiation have to be defined. Research during the last decades has revealed overwhelming evidence for negative effects of enhanced UV-B radiation on algae. Effects on almost all metabolic processes have been described. However, the scientific merit of most findings is limited. The majority of UV-B effect studies on phytoplankton, both in the field and laboratory, has addressed short-term (hours) effects of acute exposure only. Furthermore, attention is directed mainly towards photosynthetic activity. Within a time frame of several hours neither DNA damage nor processes like induction of adaptation and repair mechanisms are likely to become manifest. As a matter of fact, the only prediction of the effects of enhanced UV-B radiation on Antarctic primary production is based on short-term photosynthesis experiments performed during the Antarctic spring [ 1]. Effects are rarely studied after a prolonged (several days) exposure period. Furthermore, most effects of UV-B radiation are measured in laboratory cultures under relatively high exposure rates. Both experimental time scales and appliedexposure levels hamper any extrapolation to field conditions. Nevertheless, field experiments indicate that even unaffected 86-
2;
g(440)=0.1 g(440)=0.05 g(44o)=o.o2 g(44o)=o
42
i
o
4
10
Chlorophyll-a (mg.m -3 ) Figure 2. Calculated relative attenuation of biologically effective UV-B radiation (Setlow DNA~3oo~) for marine systems. The relative attenuation is given as the ratio to the attenuation of DNA effective UV-B radiation (KDNA) to the attenuation of visible light (KpAR) for four concentrations of humic acids. Concentrations are given as the absorption coefficient at 440 nm (g44o). Most open oceans have a g44oof about 0.02 and a chlorophyll-a concentration of about 1 mg.mL
995 levels of UV-B radiation form a natural stress on phytoplankton communities. It was roughly estimated that if no UV-B radiation was incident at the earth's surface, phytoplankton primary production would increase by about 12% [2]. The assessment of UV-B effects for climate change studies is also complicated by the temporal variation of the damaging radiation and additional effects of UV-A and visible light in determining the final effect level. Under natural conditions algal cells are rarely stratified in the water column. Generally, algae are transported up and down the water column by wind-induced vertical mixing of surface waters (Fig. 1). By travelling through the underwater light gradient, algae will experience a more or less fluctuating light regime. Vertical transport of 10 metres might take from about 0.5 h to more then 10 hours. This dynamics will to a large extent determine the final effect level. As algae need visible light (PAR) for growth and repair of UV-B damage, the ratio of the attenuation of UV-B to PAR determines the effective exposure. Detritus and algae can decrease the ratio in attenuation of about 6 as determined by pure water to a minimum of about 2.5 (Fig. 2). However, the concentration of humic acids is the critical factor in determining UV-B transmission under water. Humic acids selectively absorb UV radiation.
cv wol3o5!
SM
SM
KG3
3530"7,= 25 exO
~D
~. 2 0 15~: 1 0 -
,~.~
-
|
~
.92" ~ . 8 4
UV12'
| |
',
a
~--~
10.64
v
IF
[
Figure 3. Schematic drawing of the culture system consisting of a fiat rectangular culture vessel (CV), two Venetian blinds (VB) controlled via stepper motors (SM), a highintensity PAR light source (HMI), a UV-B light source consisting of five fluorescent tubes (UV-12), a UV cut-off filter set (Schott WG305), a water-cooled blocking f'dter (Schott KG3) and a PC with interface (IF).
0.05
1.26
3.64
DNA eff(300) (KJ.day- 1)
Figure 4. Steady-state cellular dry weight of Selenastrum capricornutum in continuous culture. Open circles refer to dry weights at the start of the light period and closed circles to those at the end of the light period. Bars represent the standard deviations (n = 3). Culture conditions: L:D = 12"12 h, PAR~x = _ 550 larnol.m2.s 1, t = 18~ light regime is sinusoid as in Fig. 1.
We developed a special culture system, to simulate natural light dynamics as shown in Figs. 1 and 2. The system was characterized by a computer-controlled dynamic light system and the flat geometry of the culture vessel, enabling accurate dosimetry (Fig.3). Light intensities were regulated by angular slat displacements of the Venetian blinds. Continuous culture technique was applied to investigate long-term effects. The system and the quantification of the exposure levels have been described in full detail elsewhere [3]. In our experiments we aimed at long-term (several days) effects. Experiments performed so
996 1000
1000= t,.;
lOO
o
6~
100
O
o
10
~
1
.i
GI 0
20 40 D N A c o n t e n t (r.u.)
60
[--.
10
1 0
'
20
'
'~0
'
60
D N A c o n t e n t (r.u.)
Figure 5. Bivariate distribution of DNA content versus the amount of thymine dimers (both in relative units [r.u.]) in a population of Cyclotella sp. as detected by flow-cytometry. A: control, no UV-B exposure; B" exposed to 3 KJ.m 2 UV-B (Setlow DNAaf~3oo)). G 1 and G2 (cells with a double amout of DNA) refer to the different cell phases. far have given a conclusive picture of long-term effects of UV-B radiation. For several species tested we observed a decrease in growth rate coupled to an increase in cell weight and size after prolonged exposure ("steady-state" conditions) (Fig.4). This increase in cell size was caused by an increase in at least three major cell components (proteins, carbohydrates and pigments) [3]. These results do not match with the idea in which the photosystem is seen as the primary target. It does, however, fit a model in which DNA damage is the main target. Using a newly developed antibody labelling method [4], we were able to demonstrate the formation of thymine dimers in the DNA (Fig. 5). These dimers caused an arrest in the cell cycle (S phase) by inhibiting DNA replication. Through our recent research we arrived at a point at which we understand the primary targets and effects of enhanced UV-B radiation. Like damage to the photosystem, DNA damage is also a crucial factor. Obviously, estimations based on short-term effects will have to be reevaluated. Furthermore, changes in energy transfer to higher trophic levels are to be expected. Algal grazing by herbivorous predators (zooplankton) is directly dependent on cell size. Sinking rates might also be affected, resulting in a proportional increase in vertical carbon fluxes from the surface layers of the water. Fairly accurate methods are available to estimate UV-B transmission in different water types (Fig.2). Actually, only now can we direct research to collecting data for an accurate assessment of the effects of enhanced UV-B radiation on phytoplankton communities on a global scale.
References
1 Smith, R.C., B.B. Pr6zelin, K.S. Baker, R.R. Bidigare, N.P. Boucher, T. Coley, D. Karentz, S. Maclntyre, H.A. Matlick, D. Menzies, M. Ondrusek, Z. Wan and K.J. Waters. Science 255 (1992) 952. 2 Worrest, R.C. Physiol. Plant. 58 (1983) 428. 3 Veen, A., M. Reuvers and P. Ron~ak. J. Phycol. in press. 4 Buma, A.G.J., E.J. van Hannen, L. Roza, M.J.W. Veldhuis and W.W.C. Gieskes. J. Phycol. in press.
Climate Change Research: Evaluation and Policy Implications S. Zwerver, R.S.A.R. van Rompaey, M.T.J. Kok and M.M. Berk, (Eds.) 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
997
I m p a c t of e n h a n c e d solar UV-B radiation on plants from terrestrial ecosystems Jelte Rozema, Marcel Tosserams and Erwin Magendans Department of Ecology and Ecotoxicology, Faculty of Biology, Vrije Universiteit, De Boelelaan 1087, 1081 HV Amsterdam, The Netherlands
Abstract The methodology of a UV-B supplementation and UV-B filtration system is described. The response to enhanced UV-B of terrestrial plant species ranges from very sensitive to tolerant or even a positive response; crop plant species tend to be more sensitive to elevated UV-B than wild plant species. Enhanced UV-B is expected to cause changes of both structure (competitive relationships, species composition) and functioning (plant-herbivore relationships, process of decomposition).
1. I N T R O D U C T I O N 1.1. Background Decrease in stratospheric ozone over the last decade has been revealed by satellite measurements. As a result a gradual increase in solar ultraviolet-B radiation occurs. Measurements of UV-B radiation in the Swiss Alps indicate an annual increase of UV-Bradiation of 1% since 1981 (Blumthaler and Ambach, 1990).
1.2. Solar UV-B and terrestrial ecosystems Solar UV-B radiation has important biological and ecological effects. Many crops and natural plant species demonstrate reduced growth, under enhanced UV-B radiation but there is a wide range of sensitivity to UV-B radiation between plant species and cultivars. A major part of research of UV-B effects relates to crop species and only a few UV-B effect studies are known of plant species of natural ecosystems (SCOPE 1992). Most studies of UV-B effects on plants have been conducted in greenhouse or in controlled environment cabinets with UV-B lamps. Relatively low levels of Photosynthetic Active Radiation (PAR), in controlled environment studies may prevent induction of photo-repair of UV-damage. This has led to an overestimation of growth reduction of plants exposed to enhanced levels of UV-B. Outdoor experimental UV-B supplementation systems, with natural levels of PAR provide more realistic responses of plants to enhanced UV-B.
1.3. Scientific aims Our research aimed at development and application of outdoor UV-B supplementation and UV-B filtrations systems and to assess effects of solar UV-B radiation to plant species of terrestrial ecosystems.
2. M E T H O D O L O G Y 2.1. UV-lamp systems In experimental studies with enhanced levels of UV-B irradiance UV-lamps are used that are pre-burnt and filtered with cellulose acetate as a cut off filter of wavelengths smaller than 280 nm. The cellulose acetate filters are renewed twice a week to avoid reduced transmission of 1IV-
998 cover UV-B lamps over control treatment that receive no UV-B irradiance, but where the UV-B levels are the same as in the treatment that receive no with enhanced UV-B (see Figure 1).
Fig. 1. Philips TL12/40 lamps are applied both in indoor and outdoor studies of UV-B effects on plants. The plots shown in the photograph, which are exposed to solar UV-B + UV-B supplied by the lamps, refer to monocultures and mixed cultures of the dune grassland species Calamagrostis epigejos and Holcus lanatus. Thus the effect of enhanced UV-B on competitive relationships between plant species is analysed. We use Philips TL 12/40 lamps both in indoor controlled environment studies and in outdoor studies in an experimental field and in natural ecosystems. Two outdoor unenclosed systems are applied: 1. UV-B Supplementation system and 2. UV-B filtration systems.
2.2. UV-B Supplementation system A lamp system to supplement ambient solar UV-B over experimental plots and over natural vegetation has been developed and applied (Fig. 1). At present this outdoor UV-B supplemenation system is applied in a "square wave" mode of enhanced UV-B radiation. This implies switching UV-B lamps on for a fixed period around midday, when natural solar UV-B is greatest. Currently an outdoor solar tracking UV-B supplementation is developed and installed. This involves continuous measurement of solar UV-B levels using appropriate UV-B sensors (Yu et al. 1991). This allows accurate simulation of enhanced UV-B throughout the day. There is evidence that plant responses to enchanced UV-B supplied in the solar tracking modulated mode differs both qualitatively and quantitatively from responses to UV-B supplied in the square wave mode. The development and testing of this solar tracking UV-B supplementation is in close cooperation with Dr. Andy McLeod, Institute of Terrestrial Ecology, Huntingdon, United Kingdom and Dr. Gaetano Zipoli, IATA-CNR, Florence, Italy.
999 UV-B lamps are mounted above the vegetation and are maintained at a constant height above the canopy. UV-B sensors will measure and track ambient solar UV-B radiation. Dual UV-B sensors are used beneath both treatment and control racks with UV-lamps, spaced such that one is unshaded from direct sunlight by lamps or frame. The unshaded sensor is selected by the control system preventing shading effects from interfering with feedback control of output of UV-lamps. The lamp output is adjusted to give a constant multiple of UV-B radiation above ambient UV-B radiation. Increases of UV-B radiation relative to ambient UV-B irradiance relating to 20% ozone depletion under clear sky are realized.
2.3. UV-filtration system Various types of solid plastic filters are installed above precultured plants in pots or above natural vegetation. These filters absorb either (a) little solar UV-B (and UV-A) (Acrylate filter), (b) all UV-B (Mylar polyester film on top of acrylate filters) and (c) all UV-A + UV-B (Lexan filter). The transmission spectra of these three filter types are given in Fig. 2. 1.0
0.20
0.8
0.15
"~ ~ 0.6
0,0 0.05
295
'
J
j
300
305
310
//,'t 315
320
0.4 .,4
...... A
9
0.2
....
L
M~ ..... no filter
0.0 10
300
320
340
360
380
400
Wavelength (nm) Fig. 2. Solar UV-irradiance (August 1992, 13.00 h), on a clear sky day, beneath the various filter types (A = acrylate, L = Lexan, M = Mylar), compared to full sunlight (no filter). Measurement with a Optronic spectroradiometer (OL 752, Optronics Laboratories, Florida, USA). The development and testing of low-cost solid plastic UV-B filters allow outdoor and ecosystem studies of reduction of ambient levels of solar UV-B radiation. In practice it will allow research of responses of plant from natural terrestrial ecosystems (Fig. 3).
1000
Fig. 3. Application of solid plastic UV-B filters in the study of reduction of ambient solar UV-B radiation on plant species of a dune grassland ecosystem. The height of the plastic UV-B filters can be adjusted according to seasonal development of the vegetation. At the background a rack of UV-lamps over the dune grassland vegetation is shown as a UV-B supplementation system.
3. R E S P O N S E S OF T E R R E S T R I A L PLANTS TO E N H A N C E D S O L A R UV-B IRRADIATION
Solar UV-B effect studies have been performed on a number of crop and native plant species both in controlled environment (greenhouse), unenclosed outdoor (experimental garden) and field studies in a dune grassland ecosystem (Tables 1 and 2). A wide range of sensitivity to enhanced UV-B measured in indoor controlled environment experiments, exists among crop species. Cultivars of crops such as soybean (Glycine max) vary greatly in sensitivity to UV-B. Of the natural plant species from Dutch coastal ecosystems: the salt marsh ecosystem and dune grassland ecosystem, no apparent sensitive plant species were found both in indoor and outdoor studies. It should be noticed that no natural plant species of the Leguminosae (a plant group with many plant species sensitive to UV-B) have been subjected to enhanced UV-B radiation levels in outdoor experiments. The woodland understorey species Alliaria petiolata indicates to be sensitive to enhanced UV-B. It may be that plant species occurring in open habitats (Calamagrostis epigejos, Spartina anglica) and being exposed to relatively high levels of ambient solar UV-B have evolved UV-B adaptation mechanisms. Other species occurring in the woodland understorey with reduced PAR and reduced ambient UV-B, seem to be relatively UV-B sensitive. This hypothesis is studied in current research.
1001 Table 1. Survey of qualitative plant responses to enhanced UV-B in indoor controlled environment studies. Daily biologically effective dose of UV-B relating to 20-50% ozone depletion under clear sky. Response to enhanced UV-B negative response very sensitive sensitive
no significant response
positive
Crop species Pisum sativum Phaseolus vulgaris Vicia faba Lycopersicon esculentum Cucumis sativus Triticum aestivum Zea mays
II II II II
Natural plant species Verbascum thapsus Calamagrostis epigejos Plantago lanceolata Alliaria petiolata Aster tripolium Elymus athericus Spartina anglica Holcus lanatus Silene vulgaris
II II II II II II II II II
The reader is referred to Rozema (1993) for more detailed information.
Table 2. Survey of qualitative plant responses to enhanced UV-B in outdoor studies. Daily biologically effective dose of UV-B relating to 20-50% ozone depletion under clear sky. Response to enhanced UV-B negative response no significant very sensitive sensitive response
positive
Crop species Vicia faba Triticum aestivum Zea mays
II II II
Natural plant species Calama grostis epigejos Plantago lanceolata Urtica dioica Holcus lanatus Verbascum thapsus Silene vulgaris
II II II II II II
The reader is referred to Rozema (1993) for more detailed information.
1002 4. E C O L O G I C A L E F F E C T S O F O Z O N E D E P L E T I O N ; I M P L I C A T I O N S ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY
FOR
1. Responses of terrestrial plant species to enhanced UV-B range from very sensitive to tolerant or even a positive response. This broad range type of response possibly reflects the intrinsic heterogeneity of the various terrestric ecosystems. Grassland ecosystems are much more exposed to full solar UV-B than under storey plants from forest ecosystems. 2. Adaptation to enhanced UV-B may consist of two types of mechanisms. a. UV-B tolerant plant species avoid enhanced UV-B radiation flux at sensitive metabolic sites by absorption of UV-B by epidermal structures and dissolved, UV-B absorbing compounds such as flavonoids. b. UV-B tolerant plant have effective UV-B repair mechanisms, in contrast with UV-B sensitive plant species. The nature and occurrence of these adaptation mechanisms has been analysed only for a few plant species. Understanding of UV-B repsonses of all groups of terrestrial plant species needs research priority. 3. Crop plant species tend to be more sensitive to enhanced UV-B than wild plant species. This may indicate that during the breeding procedure domesticating wild species to crop plants adaptation to (high) UV-B has been lost. Maybe a trade off exists between high productivity and sensitivity to UV-B. This is an intriguing hypothesis. It might indicate that plant species may loose (genetically determined) adaptations to solar UV-B. This implies that certain crops or certain cultivars of crops will be less productive with increasing solar UV-B. It is unknown whether selection for increased tolerance to enhanced UV-B will be successful and over what time period. 4. There are many uncertainties in the knowledge of UV-B effects on plant life in terrestrial ecosystems: effects of UV-B on reproductive biology are largely unknown, some of the reproductive features will be vulnerable to enhanced UV-B. Little is known of UV-B effects on "lower plants" like mosses ferns, fungi and algae. The effect of an enhanced UV-B flux is unknown in a "multiple stress" environment such as UV-B air pollution; UV-B x nutrient and water deficiency There are some indications that enhanced UV-B will cause increased occurrence of plant diseases by fungi, bacteria and viruses. 5. Consequences of enhanced solar UV-B to terrestrial ecosystems are expected to be substantial: there will be a shift to dominance of UV-B resistant plant species the altered biochemistry of plant species exposed to high UV-B fluxes may not only affect plant-herbivore relationships but also change the process of decomposition of leaf litter (Figure 4). -
5. N A T I O N A L AND I N T E R N A T I O N A L C O O P E R A T I O N National and International contacts. Between the different national UV-B research groups exchange of experimental results and methods occurs. Every six months a meeting is organized by one of the participating groups. During these meetings results are presented and discussed. Close collaboration between different groups exists on assessing the impact of UV-B on DNA Damage. Immunological
1003
TERRESTRIAL ECOSYSTE MS UV-B
PAR
y
PLANT LEAFANGLE CANOPY ARCHIITECTURE LAI RGR BIOMASS PROD.
UV-B ABSORBING COMPOUNDS SECUNDARYMETABOLITES
PRIM. PROD.
UV-B
-I COMPETITIVEABILITY
DAMAGE PHOTOREPAIR
/
2
NUTRIENTS
DEFENSEAGAINSTI HERBIVORY GRAZING SEC. PROD. DECOMPOSITION
LEAFLONGEVITY SPROUTING BUDBURST
FIG.4. Conceptual model structure Impact of Enhanced Solar UV-B on Terrestrial Ecosystems: Physiology, Functioning and Dynamics. Ecosystem Functions: 1. Prim. Prod.= Primary productivity: 2. Sec. Prod. = Secundary Productivity: 3. Decomposition. Ecosystem structure: 4. Competitive ability. PAR = Photosynthetic Active Radiation; Pn = Net Photosynthesis; RGR = Relative Growth Rate: LAI = Leaf Area Index.
techniques used in skin cancer research are now also applied to assess DNA damage in marine algae and terrestrial plants. Contacts exist with research groups in Germany (prof. M. Tevini, Karlsruhe) and the United States (prof. A.H. Teramura and Dr. J. Sullivan, Univ. of Maryland, Washington), who are well known for their work on UV-B effects on terrestrial plants. Results were presented and discussed during visits to these research groups in 1992, 1993, 1994.
5.1. National cooperation 1. 2.
Dr. L. van Liere, Dr. A. Veen, RIVM, UV-B and aquatic Ecosystems. Dr. W. Gieskes, Dr. A. Buma, RUG, DNA-UV-B-damage, UV-B dosimetrie.
5.2. International cooperation 3. 4. 5.
Dr. A. McLeod, ITE, Huntingdon, U.K., Prof.Dr. M. Tevini, Dr. J. Ros, TU, Karlsruhe, Prof.Dr. A.H. Teramura, Un. Maryland & Hawai, Dr. J. Sullivan, USA,
5.3. International workshop UV-B and Biosphere The groups involved in this project and in the project on UV-B and algal communities (nr. 851054) will organize an international workshop on the influences of UV-B radiation on terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems. That will be held towards the end of 1995.
1004 Sponsors: the Dutch Ministry of Housing, Physical Planning and the Environment, the Dutch Organisation for Scientific Research, the Royal Dutch Academy of Sciences and the European Community.
6. R E F E R E N C E S
1
M. B lumthaler and W. Ambach, 1990. Indication of increasing solar ultra-violet-B radiation flux in Alpine regions. Science 248,206-208. 2 J. Rozema, Plant responses to atmospheric CO2 enrichment: interactions with some soil and atmospheric conditions. Vegetatio 105/105, 173-190 (1993). 3 J. Rozema, G.M. Lenssen and J.W.M. van der Staaij, The combined effect of increased CO2 and UV-B radiation on some agricultural and salt marsh species. In: J. Goudriaan, H. van Keulen and H.H. van Laar (eds). The greenhouse effect and primary productivity in European agro-ecosystems, Pudoc Wageningen, pp. 68-71. (1990). 4 J. Rozema, J. van de Staaij, V. Costa, J. Torres Pereira, R. Broekman, G. Lenssen, and M. Stroetenga, A comparison of the growth, photosynthesis and transpiration of wheat and maize in response to enhanced ultraviolet-B radiation. In: V.P. Abrol. et al. (eds.). Impact of global climatic changes on photosynthesis and plant productivity. Asia publishing house, Sittingbourne, U.K. pp. 163-174 (1991). 5 J. Rozema, H. Lambers, S.C. van de Geijn and M.L. Cambridge, CO2 and Biosphere. Kluwer, Dordrecht, pp. 484 (1993). 6 J. Rozema, M. Tosserams, J. van de Staaij, E. Magendans, H. Nelissen, and T. Brouwer, Impact of enhanced solar UV-B radiation on plants from terrestrial ecosystems. Proceeding EEG Workshop UV-B-Mtinchen, GSF (1994). 7 SCOPE, Effects of increased ultraviolet radiation on global ecosystems. Proceedings of a workshop arranged by the Scientific Committee on Problems of the Environment (SCOPE), Tramariglio. Sardinia. pp. 47 (1993). 8 J.W.M. van der Staaij, G.M. Lenssen, M. Stroetenga and J. Rozema, The combined effects of elevated CO2 levels and UV-B radiation on growth characteristcs of Elymus athericus. Vegetatio 104/105,433-440 (1993). 9 J.W.M. Staaij, R. Huysmans, W.H.O. Ernst and J. Rozema, The effect of elevated UV-B (280-320 nm) radiation levels on Silene vulgaris: a comparison between a highland and a lowland population. Environmental Pollution (1994.). 10 J.W.M. van de Staaij, Enhanced solar ultraviolet B radiation: consequences for plant growth. Ph.D. Thesis, Vrije Universiteit, Amsterdam, (1994) 130 pp. 11 M. Tosserams and J. Rozema, Effects of supplemental UV-B radiation (280-320 nm) on the dune grass land species Calamagrostis epigeios. Environmental Pollution (1994). 12 W. Yu, A.H. Teramura and J.H. Sullivan, Model YMT-6 UV-B modulation system, manual of operation, final raport to US EPA, Corvallis, Oregon, USA (1991).
Climate Change Research: Evaluation and Policy Implications S. Zwerver, R.S.A.R. van Rompaey, M.T.J. Kok and M.M. Berk, (Eds.) 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
1005
U V B c a n a f f e c t t h e i m m u n e s y s t e m r e s u l t i n g in d e c r e a s e d r e s i s t a n c e to infections and tumors. J. Garssen a, W. Goettsch a, Y. Sonntag b, F. de Gruijl b and H. van Loveren ~. aLaboratory for Pathology, National Institute for Public Health and Environmental Protection (RIVM), P.O.Box 1, 3720 BA Bilthoven, The Netherlands bAcademic Hospital Utrecht, Department of Dermatology, P.O.Box 85500, 3508 GA Utrecht
Abstract As a result of depletion of the ozone layer by industrial waste compounds, all living organisms on the earth's surface may be exposed to increased amounts of UVB radiation. In man UVB radiation can cause deleterious effects on the skin and the eyes. During the last years it has become clear that UVB can affect the immune system also. Hence, UVB may affect the resistance against infectious diseases. It is demonstrated that UVB can inhibit the immune response against skin-associated infectious diseases. However, recently it became clear that UVB can also induce immunosuppression at other loci than the exposed skin. Hence, also the immunological resistance against non-skin associated infectious diseases and tumors can be affected. Recently we demonstrated that low doses of UVB can induce immunosuppression in rodents and man. This suppression was not restricted to the exposed skin. Finally we demonstrated that this immunosuppression leads to a significant suppression of the resistance against non-skin associated infections in the rat. It is noteworthy that the resistance against bacterial (Listeria monocytogenes), viral (cytomegalo virus) as well as parasitic (Trichinella spiralis) infections was inhibited and that this inhibition was correlated to a suppression of the cellular immune system. Because these data demonstrate that low doses of UVB can affect the immune system in man and rodents and because animal studies showed that this immunosuppression inhibits the resistance to infections it is worthwile to analyse the risk for increased UVB levels with respect to infectious diseases in man.
1. I N T R O D U C T I O N
A decrease of the atmospheric (stratospheric) ozone layer, induced by the emission of CFC's, may result in an increased exposure of humans to ultraviolet radiation. Especially the exposure to wavelenghts between 280 and 315 nm (=UVB) will be increased due to
1006 ozone depletion. Aside of a beneficial effect like vitamin D production ultraviolet radiation can cause deleterious effects on human health. Most studies regarding the toxic effects of ultraviolet radiation are restricted to deleterious effects on the skin and eyes. From experimental studies it can be concluded that UVB radiation causes tumors by at least two separate mechanisms: 1) by genotoxic activity of UVB radiation and 2) by affecting the immunologically mediated resistance to tumors. Both in laboratory animals and in humans evidence has been obtained that UVB radiation can affect the immune system. Hence it is reasonable to expect that immunological resistance to infections may also be altered by UVB exposure. It is known that resistance against infectious agents that enter the body via the skin, such as Leishmania, and Herpes simplex, can be affected by UVB irradiation. Whether resistance to infectious agents that enter the body via other routes is affected was as yet not known. Because UVB radiation can induce systemic immunosuppression, suppression of immunity against non-skin associated infections (diseases), may also be suspected. The main purpose of this research project was to determine whether UVB radiation affects the resistance to several systemic non-skin associated infectious diseases and skin tumors in man. For this purpose several infection models and a tumor model in rodents were used. Since such studies cannot be performed in human volunteers, (limited) noninvasive studies in man (blood, biopsies), rat and mouse were needed in order to compare the effects of UVB radiation on various components of the immune system (basal immune parameters). If data on susceptibility differences are obtained using non-invasive tests for basal immune parameters, effects of UVB radiation on resistance against infections in rodents may be extrapolated to man. Finally, epidemiological studies are needed to validate the extrapolated data.
2. R E S U L T S
In non-invasive studies dependency of immunological changes on UVB dose and species (rat, mice, man) was investigated. In all species tested macroscopic and microscopic effects of UVB exposure were studied and compared. These studies demonstrated that the skin of rodents is more sensitive to UVB exposure than that of humans and that the difference in sensitivity in primary skin effects might be due to skin thicknesses. The pathological parameters were dependent on UVB exposure (intensitity and duration dependent). Based on these initial studies the effects of UVB exposure on several basal specific and non-specific immune parameters were investigated. The applied UVB doses were suberythemal (no reddening). Investigations with respect to changes in the number and subtype of immune competent cells in the skin as well as in lymphoid organs were performed and demonstrated that certain subtypes of lymphoid cells migrate to the skin and other subsets leave the skin. Recently, we demonstrated that lymphoid cells with UVBinduced DNA damage were detectable in lymph nodes indicating that systemic effects can occur after exposure to low UVB doses. In addition to these descriptive studies studies on immune function were carried out also. A detailed study on the UVB-induced systemic suppression of a bi-phasic contact hypersensitivity response was carried out to ascertain whether suppression of the early phase would directly lead to the suppression of the late phase (the classical delayed reaction). This appeared not to be the case. Several immune parameters such as T cell responsiveness (e.g. delayed type hypersensitivity) and natural
1007 killer cell function were significantly suppressed by exposure to low UVB doses. This was true for humans and rodents. Differences in susceptibility with respect to these parameters were less clear than with respect to the primary skin effect studies. The effects of UVB exposure on resistance against infectious diseases were studied in rats. Three different models for non-skin associated infectious diseases and one for a skinassociated infectious disease were used. We demonstrated that UVB exposure (suberythemal doses) can inhibit the immunological resistance against Trichinella spiralis infections in rat. Exposure to suberythemal doses of UVB after oral Trichinella infection leads to higher a number of parasites in the carcasses, indicating that the resistance was impaired. Recently, we demonstrated that the specific lymphocyte response to Trichinella was significantly inhibited. This points to an effect of UVB radiation on the cellular (T cell mediated) immune system. Because Trichinella spiralis infections still occur, e.g. in Eastern Europe, effects of UVB on this animal model may be relevant. Additionally, we demonstrated that suberythemal doses of UVB inhibited the resistance against a intraveneously Listeria monocytogenes infection. Especially the specific T cell response to this pathogen was inhibited by UVB exposure. Listeria infections are still a problem for human health especially for humans with a depressed immune system such as transplantation patients, babies and eldery persons. As was found for the parasitic and bacterial infection model also resistance to systemic cytomegalovirus infections was inhibited by UVB exposure of rats. Cytomegalovirus infections are still a health problem in immunosuppressed humans such as transplantation patients. For this reason this infection model in rats is very relevant for the human situation. In sum, resistance against several non-skin-associated infectious diseases that also occur in humans, especially in humans with a suppressed immune system such as in transplantation patients, can be inhibited by UVB exposure. Finally, we demonstrated that UVB radiation also affects the resistance against Herpes simplex skin infections. In man this disease is suggested to be evoked by UVB: e.g. cold sores in skiers and sun bathers. This latter infection model appears particularly suited to compare effects of UVB on resistance in humans and rodents. In addition to these infection studies we demonstrated in an extensive time lapse study in hairless mice that prior to macroscopically observable UVB-induced skin tumors, alterations in composition of lymph node cells and skin immunocompetent cells ocurred. Mice with these immune alterations became incapable of rejecting UVB-induced skin tumors whereas normal (non-exposed) mice rejected these transplants almost immediately. The early immunological changes observed did not coincide with, but amply preceded the time by which the mice started to accept the tumor implants. These findings confirmed and timed the UVB-induced immune alterations in the course of the induction of skin cancer in the hairless mouse model. Using all the obtained data with respect to UVB-induced alterations in several immune parameters (systemic and local) in rodents and man, and UVB-induced alterations in resistance against infectious diseases in rodents, a basis for risk estimation of exposure to elevated UVB levels is formulated. Risk estimation until now was only restricted to skin cancer, and did not explicitely taken into account effects on the immune system. Now, there are several lines of evidence that immune alterations play an important role in the induction of skin cancer and probably also in severity and incidence of infectious diseases.
1008 3. C O N C L U S I O N
From all the experiments that were done we conclude that low UVB doses, i.e. suberythemal doses, can affect the immune system. It is remarkable that this immunosuppression is not restricted to the exposed site (skin). Even in the spleen and lymph nodes immune alterations have been found using several different tests. The effects found were not species specific although the primary skin effects in humans tended to be less severe than in rodents. From animal experiments we conclude that the UVB induced alterations of the immune system play a significant role in the decreased resistance against tumors and infections in rats and mice. With respect to the infection studies it is demonstrated that UVB radiation can affect the resistance against skin-associated infectious diseases, such as the well known cold sores (i.e. Herpes simplex infections) as well as the resistance against non-skin-associated infectious diseases (e.g. oral parasitic, intraveneous bacterial and viral infections). The data obtained, viz. regarding immune effects in man and rodents, and regarding the resistance against infectious diseases and tumors in rodents, form a basis for a better assessment of effects on the incidence and severity of infectious diseases and tumors in UVB-exposed populations. In future these data will be used for calculation of risk from an ozone depletion. Until now, resistance against infectious agents and tumors can only be studied in rodents, and therefor the effects in humans have to be extrapolated from the animal studies. Nevertheless, there are possibilities now to study effects of UVB radiation on the resistance against certain infectious diseases in humans. Some of these infectious diseases are even thought to be related to the induction of skin cancer (human papilloma virus infections). Finally, suitable epidemiological data are needed to improve the human studies and validate the extrapolation of animal studies to man.
4. REFERENCES
~
Y. Sontag, J. Garssen, F.R. de Gruyl, J.C. van der Leun, W.A. van Vloten and H. van Loveren, Photochem. Photobiol., 53 (1991) 24s. W. Goettsch, J. Garssen, F.R. de Gruyl and H. van Loveren, Change, 9 (1992) 3-5. W. Goettsch, J. Garssen, F.R. de Gruyl and H. van Loveren, Thymus, 21 (1993) 93114. J. Garssen, H. van der Vliet, A. de Klerk and H. van Loveren, The Toxicologist 1, (1993) 107. Y. Sontag. F.R. de Gruyl, J. Garssen, H. Van Loveren, M. Kripke and W.A. van Vloten, J. Invest. Dermatology, 160 (1993) 464. J. Garssen, W. Goettsch, A. Deyns, H. van der Vliet, F. Pierik, F.R. de Gruyl and H. van Loveren, J. Invest. Dermatology, 160 (1993) 473. Y. Sontag. F.R. de Gruyl, J. Garssen, H. Van Loveren, M. Kripke and W.A. Van Vloten, Photochem. Photobiol., 57 (1993) 75s. Y. Sontag, F.R. De Gruyl, W.A. Van Vloten, J. Garssen, H. Van Loveren and J.C. van der Leun, Exp. Dermatol., 3 (1994) 145. J. Garssen, W. Goettsch, A. de Klerk, M. Herremans, F.R. de Gruyl and H. van Loveren, Photochem. Photobiol., 59 (1994) 12s.
1009 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17.
W. Goettsch, J. Garssen, A. Deijns, F.R. de Gruyl and H. van Loveren, Photochem. Photobiol., 59 (1994) 12s. W. Goettsch, J. Garssen, F.R. de Gruyl and H. van Loveren, Toxicol. Lett., 72 (1994) 359-363. M. Norval, A. E1-Ghorr, J. Garssen and H. van Loveren, British J. Dermatol., 30 (1994) 693-700. W. Goettsch, J. Garssen, A. Deijns, F.R. de Gruijl and H. van Loveren, Env. Health Persp., 102 (1994), 298-301. M. Hurks, J. Garssen, H. van Loveren and B.J. Vermeer. General aspects of UVirradiation on the immune system. Plenum press, in press, 1994. W. Goettsch, J. Garssen, F.R. de Gruijl and H. van Loveren. In: E.G. Jung, M.F. Holick (eds.), Biological effects of Light, Walter de Gruyter, Berlin, 1994, 637-641. Y. Sontag, J. Garssen, F.R. de Gruijl, J.C. van der Leun, W.A. van Vloten and H. van Loveren, J. Invest. Dermatol., 102 (1994), 923-927. W. Goettsch, J. Garssen, F.R. de Gruijl and H. van Loveren, Photochem. Photobiol., 60 (1994), 373-379.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
THEME "SUSTAINABLE SOL UTIONS"
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Climate Change Research: Evaluation and Policy Implications S. Zwerver, R.S.A.R. van Rompaey, M.T.J. Kok and M.M. Berk, (Eds.) 1995 Elsevier Science B.V.
1013
ASSESSMENT REPORT ON NRP SUBTHEME "ENERGY DEMAND AND SUPPLY OPTIONS TO MITIGATE GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS"
W.C. Turkenburg Department of Science, Technology and Society Utrecht University Padualaan 14 3584 CH Utrecht The Netherlands
With contributions by: E. van den Heuvel H. van Zeijts
BTG, Biomass Technology Group BV, Enschede CLM, Center for Agriculture and Environment, Utrecht
D. Gielen, T. Kram, J.R. Ybema
ECN, Netherlands Energy Research Foundation, Putten
M.J. Lexmond, S. Nonhebel
LLrW, Agricultural University of Wageningen
J. de Beer, K. Blok, J. Farla
RUU, University of Utrecht
M. Gillissen, E. Tellegen
VUA, Free University of Amsterdam
1014 CONTENTS
Abstract 1. 0
0
0
0
0
7.
Introduction E n e r g y efficiency i m p r o v e m e n t 2.1. The database ICARUS 2.2. The long term potential of improving the energy efficiency 2.3. Energy conservation and investment behaviour of firms Material efficiency i m p r o v e m e n t and waste m a n a g e m e n t 3.1. The production, flow and consumption of materials in the Netherlands 3.2. Organized thrift in waste disposal 3.3. Controlled anaerobic treatment of waste and waste water S w i t c h i n g to renewables 4.1. Harvesting the sun using ecosystems 4.2. Conversion routes for energy crops 4.3. Can Dutch agriculture provide clean energy? Decarbonization of fuels and flue gases, and storage of CO2 5.1. Carbon dioxide recovery based on coal gasification 5.2. Chemical absorption and other recovery techniques 5.3. Carbon Dioxide recovery in the manufacturing industry 5.4. Storage of carbon dioxide in aquifers 5.5. Conclusions Integrated assessments: strategies for CO2 emission reduction 6.1. CO2 emission reduction in the Netherlands energy system 6.2. Integrated emission reduction of CO2 and non-CO2 greenhouse gases 6.3. CO2 emission reduction in the Netherlands energy and materials system 6.4. Conclusions References
ABSTRACT The direct and indirect consumption is responsible for more t h a n half the anthropogenic emission of greenhouse gases, especially. It might well be t h a t within 50 - 100 years countries like The Netherlands should reduce their CO2 emission with 80% or more. In principle many options can be developed and applied to reduce the CO2 emission. Focused on The Netherlands, the following ones are investigated within the Dutch National Research P r o g r a m m e on Global Air Pollution and Climate Change, phase I: energy efficiency improvement; material efficiency improvement and waste management; a shift to renewable energy sources, especially biomass; and decarbonization of fuels and flue gases. The
1015 research projects and the results achieved so far are described in this report. Also the set-up and results of an integrated assessment of options to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, especially CO2, are described. From this a s s e s s m e n t one might conclude t h a t technically it seems feasible to reduce the CO2 emissions in The N e t h e r l a n d s with about 70% between 1990 and 2030. The associated marginal costs are calculated at 250-400 NLG or less per ton CO2 avoided. Options t h a t are identified as 'robust' to severe CO2 constraints are: a) the application of energy saving measures, like t h e r m a l insulation in the residential and the commercial sector; b) the use of selected renewable energy options, like geothermal and solar heat, biogas, hydropower, wood power production and energy from wind turbines; c) the removal of CO2 from power plants and other processes, e.g. combined with hydrogen production; d) the application of heat pumps, for space heating and hot water supply in the residential and the commercial sector; e) the use of fuel cells, like for automotive purposes in the transport sector; f) the replacement of fossil fuel use by electricity, like in electric heat pumps; g) the use of hydrogen, as substitute for natural gas in stationary applications, in fuel cells and as alternative automotive fuel in vehicles and aircrafts. The implementation of these options requires a strong R, D&D effort as well as policies and instruments to stimulate the introduction.
1. I N T R O D U C T I O N
The present way in which we produce and use energy carriers is responsible for more t h a n half the anthropogenic emission of greenhouse gases (GHGs) to the atmosphere. The predominant gas is carbon dioxide (CO2). Due to the use of fossil fuels to satisfy our energy needs, the emission of CO2 has increased from the preindustrial level of zero to about 6 Gigaton Carbon per year (GtC/y) at present. Unless major policy changes occur, this amount might increase further to 20 or 30 GtC/y, maybe even higher, at the end of the next century. To reduce the risk of a climate change to a level that can be sustained, it might be necessary to reduce these emissions to less than 3 GtC/yr. For countries like The Netherlands this might well imply a reduction with more than 80%. Following this approach the worldwide emissions of CO2 between the years 1990 and 2100 have to be reduced with an accumulated a m o u n t of about 1200 GtC compared to 'business-as-usual' (IPCC Working Group I, 1990; 1994). To reduce the emission of C O 2 and other greenhouse gases a wide range of options can be applied. Important options in the energy sector are: a. Improvement of the energy efficiency, leading to a reduction of the energy consumption per unit of product or unit of activity. Many technologies to improve the energy efficiency are readily available. New developments can enhance the potential of this option further. b. Improvement of the material efficiency. In modern societies a considerable part of the p r i m a r y energy consumption is connected with the production of materials and consumer goods. Therefore material efficiency improvement,
1016 including a better treatment and management of waste, can reduce the energy demand and the emission of greenhouse gases. Development and application of renewable energy sources. The energy from the sun can be harnessed directly or indirectly and be utilized to replace fossil energy sources. It requires a further development and i m p l e m e n t a t i o n of options like biomass energy production, hydropower, solar energy conversion systems and wind turbines. A shift in the use offuels, from resources with a high carbon content (like coal) to resources with a lower or even no carbon content (like n a t u r a l gas and u r a n i u m ) , although aspects like the availability of resources a n d the acceptability of the conversion technologies involved m i g h t r e s t r i c t its applicability and possible impact. Table 1.1 Potential contribution of options to reduce CO2 emissions compared to 'businessas-usual'. Accumulated figures are shown for the period 1990 to 2100, based on a v a r i e t y of recently published a s s e s s m e n t studies. It should be noted t h a t the figures are mutually dependent - energy and material efficiency improvement application of renewables nuclear fission nuclear fusion fuel shill from coal to natural gas - CO2 recovery and storage - afforestation -
-
-
-
e.
f.
300 - 600 200 - 600 100-300 0- 25 0 - 300 100-300 50- 100
GtC GtC GtC GtC GtC GtC GtC
Decarbonization of fuels and flue gases, e.g. by recovering carbon dioxide from energy conversion processes and storing it outside the atmosphere. This option has begun to receive attention only recently. Several research and development programmes have been set up to get a better u n d e r s t a n d i n g of this option. Afforestation, to remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere. This option is already applied by some utilities to compensate for CO2 emissions due to electricity production.
As a l r e a d y mentioned, it might be necessary to prevent the emission of CO2 b e t w e e n 1990 and 2100 with an a c c u m u l a t e d a m o u n t of about 1200 GtC compared to 'business-as-usual'. As shown in Table 1.1, the above mentioned options are probably able to reach this goal, provided t h a t enough attention is given to their further development and that implementation barriers are removed. For some of these options the potential and prospects for The N e t h e r l a n d s are subject of investigation in the Dutch National Research Programme on Global Air Pollution and Climate Change, phase I (NRP-I). An overview of the r e s e a r c h projects, togethers with the name of the project coordinators, the project n u m b e r and the area in interest, is given in Table 1.2.
1017 In this report the results achieved so far are presented.The research is focused on possibilities to improve the efficiency of our energy consumption, to reduce the inefficient use of materials and the production of waste, to utilize biomass and organic waste as an energy source and to sequester and store CO2 from energy conversion processes. The results are used in a study of integrated strategies for The Netherlands to reduce the emission of CO2 and other greenhouse gases in a cost-effective way. In this study the potential and costs of about 500 energy demand and supply technologies to mitigate the emission of CO2 and other greenhouse gases are assessed and mutually compared using the MARKAL model. Focused on the year 2030 and assuming a continued growth of GDP, the results of this study suggest that in principle it is possible to reduce the net CO2 emission in The Netherlands with at least 70%, with marginal costs below 400 NLG per ton of CO2 avoided, depending on the assumptions made (see Section 6). Table 1.2 List of projects in the NRP subtheme "Energy demand and supply options to mitigate GHG emissions" Title
Project leader
Number
Programming study Theme Sustainable Solutions
C.J.H. Midden/ 850031 C. Daey Ouwens/ E.H. Lysen
Energy and material use scenarios for the limitation of emissions of C02 and other greenhouse gases
W. Kram
850028
The long-term potential for improving energy efficiency K. Blok
853107
Energy conservation and investment behaviour of firms
J.B. Opschoor/ K. Blok
853095
Study on the possibilities of anaerobic fermentation process aimed at the reduction of greenhouse gases
G. Zeeman
852091
Organizing prevention in waste management
E. Tellegen
852090
Harvesting the sun energy using agro ecosystems
J. Goudriaan
853117
Biomass conversion routes for agriculture crops in Europe
H.E.M. Stassen
853108
Sustainability of production and use of biomass for European energy supply (phase I)
E.E. Biewinga
853109
Sustainability of production and use of biomass for European energy supply (phase IIA)
E.E. Biewinga
854143
1018 Management of 4 projects of SOP CO2 removal and storage
P.W. Renaud
Definition and control of the boundary conditions of the system studies in the SOP CO2
L.J.M.J. Blomen 851049
CO 2 recovery from industrial processes
K. Blok
851047
Investigations regarding the storage of CO 2 in aquifers in The Netherlands
F.C. Dufour
851048
Evaluation study of SOP C02 removal and storage
K. Blok
851046
851043
2. E N E R G Y E F F I C I E N C Y I M P R O V E M E N T
An important option to reduce C02 emissions is improving the energy efficiency in conversion and end-use processes. Sometimes it is stated that in countries like The Netherlands the ultimate potential of this option might be limited to several ten percents. In the scientific literature, however, it is claimed this potential is much larger, theoretically more than 80% or even 90%. In the literature it is also indicate t h a t a l r e a d y now m a n y technologies can be applied to improve the energy efficiency in a cost-effective way. If this would be true, it raises the question why these technologies have not yet been implemented. As the a n s w e r to these questions is of major importance for energy policy m a k i n g as well as the formulation of policies to mitigate greenhouse gas emissions, the NRP has decided to sponsor research to the potential of energy efficiency improvement as function of time and to barriers that hinder the implementation of energy conservation technologies. 2.1 T h e d a t a b a s e I C A R U S To achieve a better and concrete u n d e r s t a n d i n g of the potential of energy efficiency improvement between 1990 and 2000 and between 1990 and 2015, the NRP-I is sponsoring the development of a database called ICARUS-3 on the potential and costs of technologies to improve the energy efficiency between 1990 and 2000/2015 in all sectors of the Dutch economic system. Special attention is given to the industry. In this research the present and future consumption of fuels and electricity (assuming a frozen energy efficiency) is divided in sub-sectors and broken down into major energy consuming processes and unit-operations (e.g. drying, pumping, heating and lighting). Next, an identification is made of (nearly) available techniques to improve the energy efficiency. Then, based on the current efficiency of energy use, an estimation is made of the potential of energy efficiency improvement techniques that can be applied. Also an estimation is made of the associated investment and operation and maintenance costs. The results of this study are contained in a Quattro compatible spreadsheet (Blok et al., 1993). To improve the energy efficiency, so far more than 400 options have been identified (De Beer et al., 1993a, 1993b; De Beer et al., 1994). The cost-effectiveness of all these options can be presented in a supply curve. The supply curve derived in this study is presented in Figure 2.1 one for the period 1990-2000 and one for the period
1019 1990-2015. The result indicates a technical potential for efficiency improvement of 36% and an economic potential of 29% for the period 1990-2000. The results vary for different sectors. The technical potential for the period 1990-2000 is found to be as high as 42% in the service sector but 'only' 10% in the basic metal industry. For the period 1990-2015 the results show a technical potential of 56% - which is an increase with more t h a n 50% compared to the period 1990-2000 - and an economic potential of 43%. These figures suggest t h a t there exists a considerable potential to improve the energy efficiency, even when all currently available measures are implemented. It should be noted t h a t for the y e a r 2015 also m e a s u r e s were considered t h a t are not readily available, but could come available if adequate actions are taken.
501
40
| | 30"1
2000 Projected primary energy demand in the year 2000:3510 PJ in the year 2015:4915 PJ
I
2015
I I /
!
/
20
r/~ o ~9
0
.................................
..................
~9 -10r.~ -20-
-30-4050 ' 0%
43% ~
,
10%
20%
,
,
30% 40% C u m u l a t i v e s a v i n g (%)
!
50%
60%
Figure 2.1 Supply curves of energy efficiency improvement measures for the periods 19902000 and 1990-2015. On the horizontal axis the c u m u l a t i v e i m p r o v e m e n t potential is given as percentage of the projected energy demand without efficiency improvements. The European Renaissance scenario is used with physical growth figures.Vertically the specific energy efficiency improvement costs are depicted. The calculations are based on a low energy price scenario, (EZ, 1994). The curves show the results for a discount rate of 5%
2.2 The long term potential of improving the energy efficiency Assessing the potential in an even longer term, technologies should be considered t h a t are now in a very early stage of development. This brings along problems in analyzing options and gathering information. Co-funded byNRP-I, two research projects addressed the long term potential to improve the energy efficiency, both focused on the industrial sector. The first research, also sponsored by SYRENE research programme of NOVEM, is directed at making a preliminary survey of technologies t h a t might reduce the
1020 end-use demand of industrial process on the longer term (Smit et al., 1994). The technology descriptions are based on accessible literature, supplemented with data provided by experts on a specific sector or technology. The descriptions are divided into two sections. The first one gives a description of the reference technology and of the new, energy efficient technology, together with information about state-ofthe-art, ongoing R&D, and applicability of the technology. The second section gives preliminary data about economic and energetic parameters. In Table 2.2 some results of this research are presented. It must be emphasized that the results are based on a limited literature research. A more thorough analysis of the energy efficiency improvement potential is topic of the second research. The second research focuses on the development of a methodology to make a more accurate analysis of the long term energy efficiency improvement potential. The methodology developed so far starts with the determination of the m i n i m u m energy requirement to perform a certain energy function and of the energy losses associated with performing the energy function with the current technology. The question posed is, whether these losses can be reduced without changing the current technology. And if not, can we imagine technologies t h a t can reduce the energy losses. After having compiled a list of potential efficiency improvement technologies, an assessment is made of a possible future development of these technologies. A list of parameters that determine these developments is filled out, based on a review of the literature and a consultation of experts. A study following this line of research has been conducted for the sector 'paper and board' industry (De Beer et al., 1993c). Furthermore, two studies are underway for the sectors 'iron and steel' and 'cement' (De Beer, 1994). Here we present some results of the studies for the paper and board industry and the iron and steel industry. At present the average primary energy demand to make paper out of wood pulp is about 10 GJ/ton paper. Theoretically this figure can be much smaller. The operation with the largest energy losses appeared to be steam generation (in a CHP-unit or boiler). Steam is mainly required for drying of the paper against steam heated driers. Elimination of these losses is only possible if paper is made without the addition of water, but this would have large negative effects on the characteristics of the product. Therefore five other technologies were selected t h a t have the opportunity to reduce the energy losses. An assessment of the potential development of these technologies, resulted in the selection of two t h a t are most promising: condensing belt drying and impulse drying. These technologies have the potential to reduce the specific steam demand by 60%. For the iron and steel industry the study has not been finished yet. The specific energy requirement of an efficient steel plant like Hoogovens in The Netherlands is 19.7 GJ/ton crude steel. Between 1990 and 2000 a reduction to 16.8 GJ/ton is technically feasible. Thermodynamically, the m i n i m u m energy r e q u i r e m e n t to reduce iron oxide is only 6.2 GJ/ton. However, an exergy analysis of an integrated steel mill has revealed that the room to improve this process is limited. Larger i m p r o v e m e n t s seems only feasible when other production routes are chosen. Several options are investigated: an increased share of secondary steel making, advanced iron making processes (e.g. plasma processes), direct steel m a k i n g (inbath melting of iron, ore-to-powder steel making), near shape casting, and the use of hydrogen as reductant. The largest efficiency improvement can be obtained by
1021 an increased share of secondary steel making. Taking into account an improved efficiency of electric arc furnaces and a h i g h e r energy d e m a n d for scrap bonification, a specific primary energy demand for secondary steel making of about 7 GJ/ton steel seems achievable in the longer term. For primary steel making, by a combination of new technologies, the specific primary energy demand might come down to about 12 GJ/ton steel (see also: Van Wijk et al., 1994).
1022
Table 2.3 Selection of long term energy efficiency improvement technologies. All figures are based on the industrial situation in The Netherlands Currents SEC (GJ/ton) 1)
Long-term technology
Long-term SEC (GJ/ton)
Process/ application
Current technologies
Milk powder
Two-stage drier
3.95
Condi-cyclone
2.3
Paper
Steam heated cylinders
9.9
Impulse drying
7.8
Ethylene
Naphtha steam cracking
61 3)
Selective steam cracking
55
Cryogenic distillation
61 3)
Membrane separation
56
Chlorine
Membrane electrolysis
9.9 electricity 1.2 steam
Improved membrane electrolysis
7.5 electricity steam
Bricks
Roller kiln
2.2
Tunnel kiln
1.8
Cement
Standard kiln (dry process)
3.4
Fluidized bed
2.7
Iron making
Blast furnace
17.6 (ton pig iron)
Converted blast furnace
10.6
Steel casting
Casting and rolling
1.64 (ton crude steel)
Strip casting
0.24
Aluminum
Hall-Heroult
51.1 electricity 16.3 fuel
AlCoA
33.1 electricity fuel
2)
Inert cathodes and 42.1 electricity anodes fuel
C r o s s-c u t t i n g technologies
Current technology
Best practice efficiency
Long-term improvements
Long-term efficiency
Electric motors
AC induction motor
95.5% (range 40-100 kW)
E.g. permanent magnets; soft magn. materials; moreefficient fan.
98%
Combined generation of heat and power
Gas turbine with waste heat boiler, or combined cycle
High temp. applications
Furnaces
1) 2) 3)
Tie -- 3 4 - 3 6 %
Energy demand: 200 PJ/year
Increase turbine inlet temperature; improvement of gas turbine cycle. Heat recovery with ceramic recuperators
He "- a b o u t
50%
Energy demand: 170 PJ/year
SEC = specific energy consumption; in this table normally p r i m a r y energy is meant. Savings on s t e a m d e m a n d are 60%, but as electricity d e m a n d increases the savings on p r i m a r y energy are smaller. Including use of fuel as feedstock (43 GJ/ton)
1023 2.3 E n e r g y c o n s e r v a t i o n and i n v e s t m e n t b e h a v i o u r of firms A p a r t from s t u d y i n g the p o t e n t i a l , the NRP-I also i n v e s t i g a t e s the implementation of technologies to improve the energy efficiency, focused on the i n v e s t m e n t behaviour of firms. The question is addressed why firms do not implement measures that, according to the database ICARUS, are economically profitable. The project consists of two parts. In the first part the differences between ICARUS and the observed i m p l e m e n t a t i o n behaviour of firms are analyzed in t e r m s of d e t e r m i n a n t s and barriers to the adoption of Energy Efficiency (EE) technologies. This study should result in an empirically validated implementation model. In the second part of the project the impact of different policy i n s t r u m e n t s on the investment behaviour of firms with respect to EEtechnologies is assessed. The study should provide a simulation model by which the effectiveness of policy instruments to accelerate the adoption of EE-technologies by firms can be assessed. The project was started with an analysis of the literature on investment decision m a k i n g and on the application of investment theories to energy conservation measures. From this study the most i m p o r t a n t theoretical d e t e r m i n a n t s and barriers to the adoption of energy conservation technologies were derived. In a world without uncertainty about future states of events and cash flows, with free and full information, with independence between technologies, and with unlimited access to capital markets, a profit maximizing firm would implement all available technologies t h a t have a positive net present value. However, if these premises are relaxed one can derive barriers that prevent firms from implementing EE-technologies. The potential barriers can be categorized in the following groups (Gillissen, 1994): a. economic barriers: i) low expected energy prices; ii) uncertainty due to expected fluctuations in energy prices; iii) low expected revenues due to low energy bill; iv) budgetary problems; v) too high required return on investment; b. physical~technology barriers: i) reduction in production quality; ii) bounded rationality; iii) "technology-lock"; iv) information gap; c. m a n a g e m e n t barriers: i) no specialized personnel; ii) no interest in energy conservation; iii) no high priority to conservation (high opportunity costs); iv) present technologies are not fully depreciated; v) lack of pressure. Potential determinants for the implementation of EE-technologies are for example the number of information sources, the size of the firm (as a proxy for economies of scale), the presence of an energy coordinator, the presence of an R&D department, external pressure and bilateral agreements. In order to understand why some firms do and others do not adopt EE-technologies that, according to ICARUS, are economically attractive, a conceptual model for the investment behaviour of firms was constructed. The model consists of three "modules". The first module describes the level of information of a firm. Variables are: the n u m b e r of information channels, the presence of an energy coordinator, the presence of an R&D department and the presence of an environmental care system. Other important variables are: firm size, the energy bill, the complexity of an EE-technology and the costs of this technology. The second module describes how firms evaluate the profitability of an investment. Variables influencing the profitability evaluation are the minimally required r e t u r n to investment, and a possible bias in perceived r e t u r n and risk through a low priority for energy
1024 conservation in comparison with "core business activities". It should be noted t h a t the profitability as perceived by the firm may differ from the profitability as calculated in ICARUS because of uncertainties and firm specific expectations. The third module describes the implementation stage. Rational behaviour theories predict t h a t a firm will implement a technology when it is evaluated as being profitable. In practice, however, there can be barriers t h a t prevent a profitable technology from being implemented, whereas non-economic influences can cause an unprofitable technology to be implemented. To validate the hypotheses made in this study and the conceptual implementation model, a survey was made of the investment behaviour of more t h a n 300 Dutch firms. The survey focused on the information and implementation of sector specific EE-technologies, and on variables related to the theoretical d e t e r m i n a n t s and barriers (such as firm size, size energy bill, and required r e t u r n on investment). From this survey, and starting from a set of more t h a n 100 possible influential factors, the most i m p o r t a n t d e t e r m i n a n t s and barriers were identified. Also indicators for the degree of information and implementation were constructed. Finally information was gathered concerning the influence of policy i n s t r u m e n t s and firm specific variables. In another p a r t of the investment behaviour study, the focus is on w h a t actually h a p p e n e d in the Dutch manufacturing industry with regard to energy efficiency improvement. For this study a number a technologies is selected from ICARUS. The actual implementation rate of these technologies in the recent past (19801993) is investigated in relation to economic developments and the previously mentioned potential barriers. The results obtained so far (see Table 2.4) suggest that energy is considered as one of the production factors, and t h a t investments to reduce the use of energy are made largely on the basis of an economic evaluation, taking into account physical and financial constraints. I m p o r t a n t d e t e r m i n a n t s are: firm size, r e t u r n on i n v e s t m e n t , the availability of capital, the possibility of early depreciation. B a r r i e r s t h a t prevail are: u n c e r t a i n t y due to fluctuations in energy prices, b u d g e t a r y problems, poor financial m a r k e t expectations, a lack of knowledge of EE-technologies and the complexity of those technologies. Variables t h a t hardly seem to influence the decision making are amongst others the "core business" argument, the size of the energy bill, and the presence of an R&D department. In other words, decisions on EE-investments do not differ basically from the decisions on "core business" investments.
1025 Table 2.4 D e t e r m i n a n t s a n d b a r r i e r s for the i n v e s t m e n t in EE-technologies, impact (preliminary result)
clustered to
Very important variables
Important variables
Unimportant variables
1. Return on investment 2. Contribution to total profit 3. Securing working conditions 4. Securing production quality 5. Availability of own financial sources 6. Additional required investment costs
1. Size of energy bill 2. Environmental image 3. Depreciation status of old equipment 4. Securing production flexibility 5. Market expectations 6. Availability external fin. sources 7. Uncertainty energy prices 8. Degree of competence
1. Internal opposition 2. Internal rules 3. External rules 4. Low energy prices 5. Distance to core business 6. Costs collection addit. info. 7. Additional time and effort 8. Uncertainty new technologies 9. Qualified personnel
As m e n t i o n e d before, the second p a r t of the project entails an e s t i m a t i o n of the effects of e n e r g y policies on the i m p l e m e n t a t i o n b e h a v i o u r of firms. For t h a t p u r p o s e p l a u s i b l e e n e r g y policy scenarios for the f u t u r e (1994-2015) w e r e constructed and e v a l u a t e d by an expert group. These scenarios consist of a set of economic a n d r e g u l a t o r y i n s t r u m e n t s , combined w i t h expectations r e g a r d i n g economic growth and energy prices. In the next phase of the study, the impact of these elements will be evaluated using the newly developed implementation model and the results of the survey concerning the i n v e s t m e n t behaviour of more t h a n 300 firms. The s t u d y will be focused on the i m p a c t of e n e r g y taxes, e n e r g y subsidies, covenants, a n d i n f o r m a t i o n policies to reduce the i n f o r m a t i o n gap. U l t i m a t e l y , t h e s e a n a l y s e s should r e s u l t s in a s i m u l a t i o n model by which the i m p a c t of different e n e r g y policies on the promotion of e n e r g y savings can be assessed. 3.
M A T E R I A L E F F I C I E N C Y I M P R O V E M E N T AND WASTE MANAGEMENT
While CO 2 is generally considered as an energy related problem, this depends on t h e point of view. For The N e t h e r l a n d s , i n d u s t r i a l m a t e r i a l s p r o d u c t i o n is responsible for a p p r o x i m a t e l y one t h i r d of the n a t i o n a l CO2 emissions (50-60 versus 160 Mt). This p a r t of the CO2 emissions can be influenced by changes in t h e m a t e r i a l s s y s t e m , especially by i m p r o v i n g the efficiency of m a t e r i a l use. Options to improve the m a t e r i a l efficiency are: good housekeeping; a d a p t i o n of p r o d u c t designs; s u b s t i t u t i o n of m a t e r i a l s ; recycling of products; m a t e r i a l recycling; and cascade use of materials. A reduced consumption of m a t e r i a l s and products as well as an improved m a n a g e m e n t of w a s t e s t r e a m s will lead to a reduced depletion r a t e of resources, a reduced consumption of the energy and a
1026 reduced emission of atmosphere.
CO2 and other greenhouse gases (especially CH4) to the
3.1 T h e p r o d u c t i o n , f l o w and c o n s u m p t i o n of m a t e r i a l s in T h e Netherlands To u n d e r s t a n d the potential of material efficiency improvement and its impact on CO2 emissions, within the NRP-I an overview has been made of the production, flow and consumption of materials in the Dutch economic system for the y e a r 1988 and for the year 2000. Also a detailed analysis was made of the associated C02 emissions (Blonk et al, 1991, 1993, 1994; Gielen 1994). In the overview all materials are categorized in 22 groups, all products in 8 groups. This division is not very accurate. However, due to constraints in the availability of statistic data and to limitations of the computer model MARKAL t h a t is used to calculate costeffective routes for GHG-emission reduction based on these data (see Section 6), it does not m a k e sense to strive for a higher accuracy at the moment. Case studies were made to the material composition of complex products, like p a i n t and cars (Mulder, 1993; Moll, 1993). Also possibilities to change the composition of products were investigated (Gielen, 1994). For several products, i.c. fertilizers and plastics, the potential of material efficiency improvement, without influencing the end function, was analyzed in depth (Worrell, 1994). For The Netherlands the technical potential to reduce the application of nitrogen fertilizers - without loss of services - is found to be nearly 45%. Its realization would lead to energy savings of about 40%. For the use of plastics in packaging these figures are 35% and 30% respectively. 3.2 Organized thrift in waste disposal One option to increase the efficiency of material use and to reduce the emission of GHG's is the reduction of the amount of waste that is produced and subsequently burned in incinerators or disposed of on landfills. One factor t h a t influences the a m o u n t of waste produced and the composition of the waste is the institutional setting of the handling and removal of waste. Consequently it might well be t h a t the a m o u n t of waste t h a t is burned or disposed of can be reduced by a change of the institutional structure. Within the NRP-I research is executed to explore the potential of waste reduction in The Netherlands and to design a structure for organized thrift. The project is divided into five phases: 1. Examination of the structure of the Dutch waste sector. 2. Examination of the waste sector in a number of other countries. 3. Comparative study of demand m a n a g e m e n t in other sectors of society. 4. Design of a waste structure aiming at waste reduction and e x a n t e evaluation of the effects on the size of waste streams. 5. Investigation of possible problems in the implementation of the designed structure. In the first phase of the project an inventory was made of the structure of the w a s t e sector in The Netherlands. Also its impact on the m a n a g e m e n t of waste s t r e a m s was investigated. It was found t h a t at some points the present structure does indeed stimulate the growth of waste streams. Also it was found t h a t there are a lot of organizations, both public and private, that try to influence the m a n n e r
1027 in which and the degree to which solid waste is removed and processed. The following categories of actors are distinguished: ( 1 ) w a s t e generators, ( 2 ) w a s t e collectors, (3) w a s t e processors, (4) waste disposers, (5) policy m a k e r s , (6) organizations t h a t provide d a t a and ideas to support policy m a k e r s , and (7) interest groups and umbrella-organizations. The study has shown a n u m b e r of structural impediments for waste reduction. They can be summarized as follows (De Jong and Wolsink, 1993): a. Organizations t h a t collect and provide data about size and composition of w a s t e s t r e a m s s o m e t i m e s have i n t e r e s t s in the outcome of the d a t a collection. This could hinder the provision of objective and reliable data. b. Public a u t h o r i t i e s t h a t are s i m u l t a n e o u s l y waste collectors and w a s t e processors can pass on the corporate risk of an incineration plant to residents by changing the tariffs for the collection of domestic waste. This opportunity m e a n s t h a t the former can accept such risks more readily t h a n private institutions, which stimulates overcapacity of incineration facilities. c. Owners of incineration capacity are able to force waste collectors and waste processors to deliver collected waste to them. Long-term contracts and political influence and extension of waste processing activities are among their means of influence on waste collectors. & I n c i n e r a t i o n p l a n t s t h a t are in accordance w i t h the p r e s e n t s t r i c t environmental standards require large investments. The financial necessity to use these plant at full capacity could hinder investments in waste prevention, recycling of waste or other waste reducing activities. e. The long write-off periods of incineration plants are an obstacle to waste minimization policies of governments. For public authorities t h a t are owners of such plants, waste minimization damages their own financial interests. f. The responsibility of public authorities dealing with waste in general is limited to either the local, regional, provincial, or national level. Private waste organizations often cannot be forced to implement the policy of a public authority because they operate at another scale. g. It is beneficial to private waste collectors not to sign long-term contracts with waste processors. In t h a t way they r e m a i n free to search for the cheapest processing option. This often results in discrepancies between predicted and actual amounts of waste in a certain area. This can lead to a too low supply to the incinerators which implies an increase of the tariffs for contractees. In this situation, private collectors who are not contractually tied can offer "extra" waste to processors who want to see their remaining capacity utilized. The price is agreed by negotiation and is far lower than that to the contractees. h. Private collectors have vested interests in the continuity of the existing waste structure and in the existence of uncertainty among public authorities about quantities of waste t h a t will be offered for incineration. Therefore they try to avoid common decision-making with public authorities. Waste producing enterprises are interested in: Continuity of the existing waste structure and uncertainty about quantities of waste t h a t will be offered for incineration. Overcapacity will lead to lower instead of higher tariffs for the processing of industrial waste. Avoidance of exchange of information t h a t could lead to a better insight is size, weight and composition of waste streams. More information and better planning of facilities will limit bargaining opportunities of enterprises and lead to higher processing tariffs. -
-
1028 Possible solutions to structural impediments are: 1. Changes in contracts between participants in the waste market. 2. Improved exchange of information, cooperation a n d decision-making between participants in the waste sector. 3. Revised division of tasks and competencies of authorities. 4. Creation of an independent institution that can force organizations within the waste sector to give correct information and is able to interpret and to report about these data. 5. Better use of available policy instruments by authorities. In the second phase of the project the waste sector in other countries is examined. Based on criteria derived from the first phase, the following states were selected: Denmark, France, Nordrhein-Westfalen (Germany), California (USA), New Jersey (USA) and Massachusetts (USA). A further selection will be made later on. New J e r s e y became the state of the first case study. The state was visited in May-June 1994. Interviews were held with key persons in the waste structure of this state and written documents were collected. The oral and written information is sorted out and will be published at a later date. Nowadays in m a n y different sectors of the Dutch society, and for quite a n u m b e r of reasons, the need is felt to limit the use of existing (semi) collective facilities. Ideas are formulated and organizational experiments are put in practice to limit the d e m a n d of these facilities. Possibly the ways in which other sectors of society p u t p r e v e n t i v e m e a s u r e s in practice, and in p a r t i c u l a r the o r g a n i z a t i o n a l structures they develop to do so, may be of interest in designing a waste structure t h a t aims at waste minimization. This is investigated in the third phase of the project. Case studies were made of demand m a n a g e m e n t in energy supply, housing, psychiatric hospitalization and social security in The Netherlands. The results will be published in a book (in Dutch) which is in preparation now. Work on phase 4 and 5 of the project has yet to be started. 3.3 C o n t r o l l e d a n a e r o b i c t r e a t m e n t o f w a s t e a n d w a s t e w a t e r
Biological degradation of waste and waste water containing degradable organic substances can generate large quantities of CI-I4 and/or CO2. The actual quantity and composition of the produced gas depends on the amount and the composition of waste produced but also on the way the waste is discharged, stored, and treated. Focused on waste water, aerobic degradation as conventionally applied in most t r e a t m e n t s y s t e m s leads to the production of m a i n l y CO2, w a t e r and a considerable amount of biomass or sludge. Most of the potential energy present in waste water, therefore, ends-up in biomass, the disposal of which is becoming a serious problem. Furthermore, aerobic treatment is rather energy consuming since this process depends on a more or less intensive aeration. An i n t e r e s t i n g alternative is formed by anaerobic t r e a t m e n t (Lettinga & Van Haandel, 1993). Anaerobic degradation occurs when no or insufficient oxygen is available for (complete) aerobic degradation. Under anaerobic conditions organic material can be completely degraded into CO2, CH4, water, a small a m o u n t of biomass, and traces of other components. The produced biogas contains the largest part of the potential energy present in waste water, and can be used as a fuel. By doing so, anaerobic degradation has the following advantages over aerobic degradation: 1)
1029 Production of a valuable fuel, the use of which can lead to a reduction of the a m o u n t of fossil fuel consumed, 2) no energy requirement for aeration, and 3) significantly less sludge production. On the other hand, if anaerobic degradation occurs in an uncontrolled way, CH4 can be emitted to the atmosphere where it enhances the greenhouse effect even more than CO2. Global atmospheric CH4 emission from the treatment, storage, and discharge of all waste water is roughly estimated to be about 26-40 Tg/y, thereby representing about 8-11% of the total anthropogenic CH4 emissions (Thorneloe, 1993). The contribution of the Food & Beverage (F&B) and the Pulp & Paper (P&P) industry, the main contributors to the organic pollution load, is estimated to be 12-18 Tg/y. The contribution of domestic waste water is estimated to be only about 2 Tg/y. In the NRP-I research is done to investigate the potential of applying controlled anaerobic processes for the t r e a t m e n t of both domestic and industrial (F&B and P&P) waste water in order to reduce the global atmospheric emission of both CH4 and CO2. In this project the present day emission of CH4 and CO2 from waste water t r e a t m e n t is estimated. Furthermore, the potential production and use of CH4 from waste water t r e a t m e n t and its impact on the emission of CH4 and CO2 emissions is analyzed (Lexmond and Zeeman, 1993). In the estimations the following cases are considered: 1) Complete anaerobic treatment: Calculated emissions are energy related CO2, and CH4 from anaerobic degradation. Three options are regarded: - All CH4 is flared. - CH4 is partly used for the maintenance of the treatment plant. The excess is flared. - CH4 is completely used for energy production. It is assumed t h a t a certain percentage of the produced CH4 is lost due to leakage and to amounts that are too small to collect. 2) Complete aerobic treatment: Calculated emissions are CO2 from the use of fossil fuels, and CH4 from uncontrolled anaerobic degradation also occurring in aerobic systems (Czepiel et al., 1993). CH4 produced in aerobic systems is assumed to be emitted to the atmosphere. 3) Current situation: Calculated emissions are the energy related CO2 emission and the CH4 emissions from controlled t r e a t m e n t s y s t e m s and from uncontrolled degradation in the environment. Relevant data concerning waste water (amount, composition, degraduability) and t r e a t m e n t systems (efficiency, sludge growth, energy demand, methane emission factors, frequency of operation) were collected from literature and queries. Models were developed to be able to estimate the CH4 and CO2 emissions (Lexmond and Zeeman, 1994). Due to scarcity of information, amongst others an assumption had to be made about the current use of different waste water t r e a t m e n t systems. As this figure has a strong influence on the final results, the a s s u m p t i o n is given in 3.1. Especially the percentage of uncontrolled aerobic and anaerobic degradation of discharged waste water in developing countries is an important parameter. It is assumed that a large part of the waste water is discharged on surface waters.
1030
Table 3.1 Assumptions concerning the t r e a t m e n t of waste water and the division in aerobic and anaerobic degradation a) treated (%) total
u n t r e a t e d (%)
aerobic
anaerobic
total
aerobic
anaerobic
developing countries * domestic
10
70
30
90
75
25
* industrial
50
85
15
50
75
25
d e v e l o p e d countries * domestic * industrial
90 95
90 85
10 15
10 5
80 80
20 20
a) A s s u m p t i o n s are p a r t l y based on a query held among s t u d e n t s from the I n t e r n a t i o n a l I n s t i t u t e for H y d r a u l i c a n d E n v i r o n m e n t a l Engineering, The N e t h e r l a n d s , 1993
The results of the study are shown in Table 3.2. The estimated CH4 and C 0 2 emissions for F&B and P&P industry waste water and domestic sewage t r e a t m e n t are presented as calculated for the five cases described earlier. In the calculations two values for the loss of CH4 were used, 5% and 10%. As shown, the current CH4 emission from the investigated waste water streams is estimated at 5 Tg/y. This is considerably lower than the value of 14-20 Tg/y, estimated by Thorneloe (1993). Also it has been calculated that the present contribution of waste water t r e a t m e n t and disposal to the enhanced greenhouse effect is mainly d e t e r m i n e d by the emission of CH4 from uncontrolled disposal of domestic waste water in developing countries. So, not only from the point of view of h u m a n health, but also from the greenhouse point of view, it is of great importance t h a t in these countries waste w a t e r t r e a t m e n t is stimulated. The results show t h a t anaerobic t r e a t m e n t of waste w a t e r should be stimulated in order to reduce the emissions of greenhouse gases, provided t h a t the loss of CH4 is minimized and the produced CH4 is optimally used.
1031 Table 3.2 E s t i m a t e d emissions from industrial and domestic waste w a t e r t r e a t m e n t and disposal
CH 4 loss
i n d u s t r i a l e m i s s i o n (Tg/y)
d o m e s t i c e m i s s i o n (Tg/y)
5%
5%
10 %
10 %
CH4
C02
CH4
C02
CH4
CO 2
CH 4
C02
0.8
2.8
1.6
2.8
0.9
2.5
1.8
2.5
0.8
0.0
1.6
0.0
0.9
0.0
1.8
0.0
0.8
- 32.8
1.6
- 31.0
0.9
- 36.9
1.8
- 34.8
* aerobic
0.1
17.0
0.1
17.0
0.1
15.3
0.1
15.3
* current situation
1.2
12.1
1.3
12.1
3.6
3.9
3.6
3
Cases * only flaring * partial reuse * complete reuse
It should be noted t h a t the t r e a t m e n t method and the disposal of waste water are the most i m p o r t a n t p a r a m e t e r s for the e s t i m a t e d emissions in the c u r r e n t situation. For most countries very little data is available about these subjects. Within the calculations the most important p a r a m e t e r is the amount of anaerobic degradation in the case of untreated waste water in the developing countries. If we, for instance, would assume t h a t this amount is not 25% but 50%, the total CH4 emission would increase from 5 to about 11 Tg/y. Therefore more data should become available to be able to estimate the present emissions more accurately. In the next phase of the project, a similar study is planned for the t r e a t m e n t of sludge produced during waste w a t e r t r e a t m e n t . During aerobic w a s t e w a t e r t r e a t m e n t about 4 times as much sludge is produced as d u r i n g anaerobic t r e a t m e n t . This sludge has to be disposed of and treated. In The N e t h e r l a n d s sludge of aerobic installations is often digested, resulting in biogas which is normally used or flared. Anaerobic sludge contains less organic material and is therefore less suited for digestion. In order to obtain a complete picture of the emissions from waste w a t e r treatment, a comparison will be made of the most common sludge t r e a t m e n t systems and their related CH4 and CO2 emissions 4.
S W I T C H I N G TO R E N E W A B L E S
An important option to reduce C O 2 emissions is switching to renewable sources of energy. In 1990 the contribution of renewables to the world energy supply was about one-fifth. Several studies have indicated that it might be possible to increase this figure to one-quarter or one-third in the year 2025 and to about one-half in the second half of the next century (UNSEGED, 1992; World Bank, 1992; WEC Study Group on Renewable Energy Resources, 1993; World Energy Council, 1993; T.B. Johansson et al, 1993). In the coming decades, apart from hydro power and wind energy, especially the use of biomass to produce fuels and electricity seems attractive. In the longer term a major contribution is expected also from energy production by solar cells.
1032 In The Netherlands the current consumption of primary energy resources is about 2750 PJ. About 1% of it is obtained from renewables. The potential, however, is much higher. It is estimated that the exploration of renewable energy sources in The Netherlands that can replace about 700 P J of our fossil fuel consumption, with major contributions from solar cells, wind turbines and the production of fuels and electricity from biomass including organic waste (Van Wijk et al., 1994). There are however many uncertainties. Some of these uncertainties are addressed in a r e s e a r c h project i n i t i a t e d by the NRP-I, focused on the p o t e n t i a l and attractiveness of biomass energy production in The Netherlands. 4.1 H a r v e s t i n g the s u n u s i n g e c o s y s t e m s The agricultural production in Western Europe and the US has risen enormously in recent decade. As an example, in The Netherlands the wheat yields per hectare have doubled since 1950. This has led to a reduction in land area needed for food production, meaning that there is land that could be used to grow energy crops. The objective of energy plantations is a high sustainable yield at low cost with minimal adverse impact on the environment. The demands placed on biomass are different from those for regular agricultural crops. Mainly, an energy crop must produce a great deal of material, containing little moisture, and easy to harvest. In this context much attention is given to fast growing wood (e.g. poplar and willow) and some grassy species (e.g. reed and miscanthus). However, there is a great deal of vagueness about what the possible yields of such crops might be, whereas these yields are in fact a key factor in all evaluations of the attractiveness of biomass energy production. Therefore, within the NRP-I, a simple crop growth simulation model is developed to improve the yield estimates of (presently often unknown) energy crops (Nonhebel, 1994). As an example the calculation of the energy yield of a poplar plantation is given. In The Netherlands the poplars begin to sprout at the beginning of May, losing their leaves in October. The amount of solar radiation that is received during this period is 1.5 GJ/m2. Under optimal circumstances (sufficient water, etc.) 1.4 g of plant material is produced for every MJ of radiation. This would result in a biomass production of 21 ton per hectare. As the optimal circumstances seldom occur, in practice the production will be less. Also not all of the biomass can be harvested for energy production (leaves, young twigs, etc.). Therefore, in the year 2000 the annual yield might be 10-12 ton dry matter per hectare. It should be noted t h a t other studies have indicated yields of about 15 ton/ha. These studies were based on field experiments. In practice, yields will generally be lower. Also it should be noted that the growing conditions vary enormously throughout Europe. Thus great differences occur in the potential productivity between different regions. Therefore the simple simulation model will now be used to calculate the maximum yield of a variety of biomass crops in different European regions. This will give an insight into which crops can where best be grown with what productivity. 4.2 C o n v e r s i o n routes for e n e r g y crops There are several conversion routes for the transformation of energy crops into heat, fuels and/or electricity. Within the NRP-I ten conversion routes have been analyzed with respect to technical, financial and environmental characteristics (Van den Heuvel et al., 1994). The options considered include: cogeneration of heat
1033 and power with combustion technology; co-combustion in a pulverized coal fired power plant; electricity production with an integrated gasifier combined cycle plant of 50 MWe; combustion of gasified biomass in a conventional n a t u r a l gas fired power plant; fermentation of wheat to ethanol using wheat straw for combined h e a t and power generation; fermentation of sugar beet to ethanol; and RME production from rape seed followed by esterification. All these technologies are technically m a t u r e , with the exception of the integrated gasification combined cycle plant. The lowest electricity production costs are found for the large-scale gasification option and for co-combustion. The production costs are calculated at 0.15 NLG/kWh. This figure is much higher t h a n current electricity production costs with conventional power stations. In this study also the specific costs to avoid the emission of CO2 have been analyzed. The lowest figure is found for the BIG-CC plant of 50 MWe. The costs are calculated at about 75 NLG per ton CO2 avoided. Much higher costs are calculated for the investigated production of fuels. It is concluded t h a t future research should concentrate on large scale gasification of biomass and on cocombustion of biomass in existing power plants.
4.3 Can Dutch agriculture provide clean energy? By generating energy from vegeTable fibers (biomass) the emission of greenhouse gases can be reduced. As well as an ecological advantage, the cultivation of crops for the supply of energy could also improve the moderate to bad economical results of Dutch arable farms. Energy crops can also create new problems, such as an environmental burden due to their cultivation. So far research into the use of biomass as a source of energy has been focused mainly on its technical and economic feasibility. Therefore, within the NRP-I also research was set up to assess the ecological sustainability of the cultivation and use of energy crops (Zeijts et al., 1994). Can the Dutch agricultural sector provide clean energy? Elements of this question are: how harmful to the environment is the cultivation of energy crops; w h a t are the direct and indirect environmental effects of fitting energy crops into the cropping plan; w h a t indirect effects are to be expected at a regional level; how much energy is produced in the entire cultivation, transport end processing chain and w h a t effect does this have on the emission of greenhouse gases; and w h a t is the overall conclusion for the various crops with regard to sustainability. In this research the following effects of the cultivation and use of energy crops have been assessed: the emission of minerals; the emission of pesticides; the use of energy and the emission of greenhouse gases, the fixation of carbon from CO2; the use of by-products and waste products; desiccation; erosion; the contribution to n a t u r a l values; the contribution to scenic values; and the use of space. Nine crops and their processing chains have been studied: rape (to bio-diesel oil), sugar beet and w i n t e r w h e a t (to ethanol), and maize, hemp, reed, miscanthus, poplar and willow (to electricity and/or heat). First the direct effects of the cultivation of energy crops have been assessed. The results are compared with those of cultivation on fallow land and cultivation of cereal. The direct effects are found different for each energy crop, but in general the conclusions are as follows:
1034 - I f cereal is replaced by energy crops, the emission of minerals deteriorates because the cultivation of cereal leads to low mineral losses. If energy crops are grown on fallow land, the emission remains the same. -For most energy crops, the emission of pesticides reduces if they replace cereal. If they are grown on fallow land, there is no difference on average. - I f a n n u a l energy crops are grown on fallow land or replace cereal, the risk of erosion increases. -Cereals contribute considerably to n a t u r a l values; replacing them by energy crops leads to lower natural values. Compared with cultivation on fallow land, the average effect is neutral. -Fallow land and land on which cereal is grown require little water, so that the risk of desiccation increases if energy crops are grown there instead. Effects that are not directly related to the cultivation of energy crops are known as indirect effects. Indirect effects on environmental pollution and on n a t u r a l and scenic values are found at the level of the individual farm as well as at a regional and national level. A few examples are given here. At the level of the individual farm, perennial crops are likely to have a cleaning effect on the soil as regards persistent weeds and a number of soil pathogens and nematodes. However, the annual crops in the cropping plan will follow each other faster. It is expected t h a t the positive effect (clean soil) is only of interest during the first years after the cultivation of the perennial crop, and t h a t the negative effect (faster rotation of a n n u a l crops) will predominate. On balance, this means greater mineral and pesticide emissions and a greater risk of erosion. An indirect effect at a national level is related to the national mineral surplus. Energy crops will first be grown on fallow land, but will also replace cereal, which is normally used to produce animal feed. If the livestock population remains the same, replacement of cereal leads to an increase in the import of animal feed and/or the use of artificial fertilizers (for more intensive cultivation of animal feed). Negative effects on the national mineral surplus can be compensated by: 1) processing byproducts and waste products (such as b y p r o d u c t s from the fermentation of sugar beet and wheat) in animal feed, so t h a t imports will not increase as much; 2) exporting the waste product ash as a fertilizer as it contains almost all the phosphate from the biomass; 3) using animal m a n u r e r a t h e r t h a n fertilizers for energy crops. In this study the following net avoided emission of greenhouse gases are calculated for the various processing and conversion routes: - 2 to 3 tons of CO2-equivalent per hectare per year in the production of rape diesel oil by means of extraction; - 3 to 7 tons of CO2-equivalent per hectare per year in the production of ethanol by means of fermentation; -8 to 24 tons of CO2-equivalent per hectare per year in the production of electricity by means of burning and gasification. The differences are caused by differences in crops, regions, processing and conversion routes. Rape extraction produces the lowest score on the emission of greenhouse gasses, followed by fermentation of sugar beet and winter cereal. Crops that are burnt or gasified score the highest.
1035 Based on these results, and giving all evaluation criteria equal weight, the following order for the attractiveness of biomass energy production from an environmental point of view is derived: 1. winter wheat; 2. hemp and reed; 3. miscanthus, poplar and willow; 4. rape and maize; 5. sugar beet. Winter wheat scores very high. Its cultivation produces hardly any mineral losses, it has positive n a t u r a l and scenic values and it limits the risk of erosion and desiccation. A great disadvantage, however, is the low score on the emission of greenhouse gasses. Hemp and reed score relatively high. A great advantage is t h a t the net avoided emission of greenhouse gasses is high. A disadvantage of both crops is t h a t they use a great deal of water, which increases the risk of desiccation. Few pesticides are required for the cultivation of both hemp and reed. Reed p r e s u m a b l y uses m i n e r a l s very efficiently, but this effect is countered by the above mentioned negative effects of perennial crops on the emission of minerals and pesticides in the other crops in the cropping plan. Fitting hemp into the cropping plan has a positive indirect effect on the use of pesticides for the other crops. Miscanthus, poplar and willow have moderate scores as regards environmental impact. The net avoided emission of greenhouse gasses is fairly high. The mineral losses in cultivation are not likely to exceed the levels for nitrate in ground water, the use of pesticides is relatively small and erosion is prevented fairly effectively. On the other hand, however, there are negative effects of fitting perennial crops into the cropping plan. Because these crops use a relatively great a m o u n t of water, there is a risk of desiccation. Rape and maize have a slightly negative score. A great disadvantage of rape is the low score on the emission reduction of greenhouse gasses and the use of space. Rape does, however, contribute considerably to natural and scenic values; maize does not. Both crops have a fairly low score on the emission of minerals and pesticides and for the risk of desiccation. The main reason for the low score of rape in the field of pesticides is that rape has the same crop rotation problems as sugar beet. E x t r a rape or sugar beet in the cropping plan will lead to an increase in the need for pesticides. The cultivation of (extra) sugar beet has m a n y ecological disadvantages and no obvious a d v a n t a g e s . It scores low as regards pesticides (also because of the negative effects on soil health), erosion and scenic values. Cultivation of sugar beet also has a low score on minerals, desiccation, natural values and the use of space. An important disadvantage is that it contributes relatively little to decreasing the greenhouse effect. It should be noted t h a t miscanthus, reed, willow and poplar do not only score high from the point of view of environmental impact. They are also economically the most feasible, in view of the results of other studies. There are possibilities for these perennial crops especially at extensive farms with fallow land. Studies of the economic feasibility have shown that in The Netherlands energy from biomass can be profitable in the n e a r future, if the set-aside scheme is continued and an environmental tax on non-renewable energy or a subsidy per ton of CO2 avoided is introduced. Hemp is somewhat less feasible from an economic point of view. For
1036 the mainly intensive Dutch arable farming, however, hemp is interesting because it is easier to fit into the cropping plans. It could be grown on fallow land or it could replace cereal. Also from the point of view of environmental impact, hemp scores high. In other European countries energy from biomass is already being generated on a limited scale. If a European subsidy for avoided CO2 emissions or a E u r o p e a n environmental tax on energy is introduced, the cultivation of energy crops will sooner commence in these other countries t h a n in The Netherlands. In other E u r o p e a n countries ground prices are lower and more land will probably be set aside. Also, in m a n y European regions sustainable cultivation will be easier to realize than in The Netherlands. In the long term, energy from biomass will receive competition from two sides. Firstly, agricultural land will be claimed for other purposes, such as n a t u r e development. Secondly, there may be more cost-effective ways of reducing the emission of greenhouse gasses by then.
0
D E C A R B O N I Z A T I O N O F F U E L S AND F L U E GASES, AND S T O R A G E OF CO2
In the longer term, decarbonization of fuels and flue gas is the only possible GHG mitigation option allowing large-scale use of fossil sources. It can only be done practically in large scale conversion facilities. Till the beginning of the nineties, the potential of this option was hardly investigated. Therefore, in 1991 an explorative r e s e a r c h p r o g r a m was set up with a n u m b e r of research i n s t i t u t e s in The Netherlands. The objective of this program was to get a better u n d e r s t a n d i n g of Carbon Dioxide Removal (CDR) option and to investigate its potential for The Netherlands. The research was carried out in 1991 and 1992. The program was sponsored from various sources, the main ones being the Ministry of Housing, Physical P l a n n i n g and Environment, VROM and the Dutch National Research Programme on Global Air Pollution and Climate Change (NRP-I). The total budget amounted to about 1.5 million Netherlands guilders (NLG). Before the research program started, several publications on carbon dioxide recovery and storage in The Netherlands had already been issued, with special emphasis on carbon dioxide removal from ICGCC power plants and on storage of carbon dioxide in depleted n a t u r a l gas fi