Church and State in Historical Perspective: A Critical Assessment and Annotated Bibliography
James E. Wood Jr.
PRAEGER...
59 downloads
2603 Views
6MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Church and State in Historical Perspective: A Critical Assessment and Annotated Bibliography
James E. Wood Jr.
PRAEGER
Church and State in Historical Perspective
Recent Titles in Bibliographies and Indexes in Religious Studies Christianity in South Africa: An Annotated Bibliography David Chidester, Judy Tobler, and Darrel Wratten Islam, Hinduism, and Judaism in South Africa: An Annotated Bibliography David Chidester, Judy Tobler, and Darrel Wratten Consulting Spirits: A Bibliography Joel Bjorling The Religious Dimension of Political Behavior: A Critical Analysis and Annotated Bibliography Laura R. Olson and Ted G. Jelen The Jesus People Movement: An Annotated Bibliography and General Resource David Di Sabatino Jehovah’s Witnesses: A Comprehensive and Selectively Annotated Bibliography Jerry Bergman, compiler Feminism and Christian Tradition: An Annotated Bibliography and Critical Introduction to the Literature Mary-Paula Walsh Anglicans in the Antipodes: An Indexed Calendar of the Papers and Correspondence of the Archbishops of Canterbury, 1788–1961, Relating to Australia, New Zealand, and the Pacific Ruth Frappell, Robert Withycombe, Leighton Frappell, and Raymond Nobbs, compilers and editors Christian Hymnody in Twentieth-Century Britain and America: An Annotated Bibliography David W. Music Abortion from the Religious and Moral Perspective: An Annotated Bibliography George F. Johnston The Holocaust and Its Religious Impact: A Critical Assessment and Annotated Bibliography Jack R. Fischel and Susan M. Ortmann
Church and State in Historical Perspective A Critical Assessment and Annotated Bibliography James E. Wood Jr.
Bibliographies and Indexes in Religious Studies, Number 55 G. E. Gorman, Advisory Editor Westport, Connecticut London
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Wood, James Edward. Church and state in historical perspective : a critical assessment and annotated bibliography / James E. Wood Jr. p. cm. — (Bibliographies and indexes in religious studies, ISSN 0742–6836 ; no. 55) Includes bibliographical references and indexes. ISBN 0–313–25603–9 (alk. paper) 1. Religion and state—History—Bibliography. 2. Church and state—History—Bibliography. I. Title, II. Series. Z7776.72.W66 2005 [BL65.S8] 016.322'1'09—dc22 2004060272 British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data is available. Copyright © 2005 by James E. Wood Jr. All rights reserved. No portion of this book may be reproduced, by any process or technique, without the express written consent of the publisher. Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 2004060272 ISBN: 0–313–25603–9 ISSN: 0742–6836 First published in 2005 Praeger Publishers, 88 Post Road West, Westport, CT 06881 An imprint of Greenwood Publishing Group, Inc. www.praeger.com Printed in the United States of America
The paper used in this book complies with the Permanent Paper Standard issued by the National Information Standards Organization (Z39.48–1984). 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
In Loving Memory of My Life’s Companion for More Than Fifty-Seven Years Alma Leacy MacKenzie Wood
Contents Preface Introduction
xi 1
1
Religion and the State in the Ancient World
3
2
Religion and the State in the Biblical World General Old Testament New Testament
9 9 10 13
3
Christianity and the State The Church in Conflict with the State The Supremacy of the Church over the State The Supremacy of the State over the Church The Christian State The Secular State
23 24 26 28 30 31
4
Religion and the State in Other Religions
35
5
Religious Tolerance and Religious Freedom
49
6
Religion and the Secular State
67
7
Religion in International Affairs and Interfaith Relations
79
Bibliographical Survey General Religion and the State in the Ancient World
91 91 99
viii
Contents Religion and the State in the Biblical World General Old Testament The New Testament Christianity and the State General Roman Empire Byzantine Empire The Middle Ages The Reformation The Counter Reformation and the Inquisition Christian Thought General Roman Catholicism Eastern Orthodoxy Protestantism Religion and the State in Other Religions General Buddhism Confucianism and Taoism Hinduism Islam Jewish-Christian Relations Judaism Shinto Sikhism Zoroastrianism Religious Tolerance and Religious Freedom Religion and the Secular State General Civil Disobedience Civil Religion Liberation Theology Patriotism Religion and Nationalism Religion in International Affairs and Interfaith Relations General The Economic Order Human Rights Interfaith Relations International Affairs War and Peace
Author Index
104 104 106 116 129 129 143 164 167 188 204 210 210 235 269 271 294 294 299 301 303 307 331 389 405 406 408 409 422 422 436 441 443 462 463 469 469 481 508 518 524 532 573
Contents
ix
Title Index
595
Subject Index
641
Preface These volumes have undergone a protracted period of preparation since their genesis, partly as the result of other editing and writing commitments, but, more especially, because of unanticipated personal adversities that resulted in serious interruptions prior to the completion of this work earlier, as originally planned. I am, therefore, particularly grateful for the patience and forbearance of Praeger Publishers in bearing with me during the unanticpated interruptions in the preparation of the final publication of these volumes. The subject of church and state, i.e., religion and the state, has played a major role in the history of the world, past and present. It was arguably viewed by the late Swiss theologian, Emil Brunner, as “the greatest subject in the history of the West.” The subject of church and state has been a dominant theme in the history of Christianity. In the ancient world, as throughout Asia and tribal societies today, there was no differentiation between religion and society, or the nation or empire. Religion played an integral role throughout Africa and the Middle East, as well as in Europe and Latin America, where religion formed the basis of national identity and played a major role in international affairs. In Asia, where all the major world religions had their beginnings, religion has been the great molder and purveyor of civilizations and empires. While the phrase, “church and state,” has had a broad meaning even when applied to the Western world—throughout North America, Latin America, and Europe—it has also had a profound impact in the field of law. Although the phrase “church and state” is used in the titles of both volumes of this work, it should be interpreted or understood as addressing the broad area of religion and the state since both volumes attempt to be inclusive of the major religious traditions throughout the world. The very breadth of these volumes, as envisioned by the publisher, means that they were prepared for the general reader and not the specialist whose focus would necessarily be a much narrower one. Volume 1 focuses on “Church and State in Historical Perspective.” The brief chapters in this volume are intended to serve as introductions to their respective divisions and, thereby,
xii
Preface
to provide the general reader with some background to each of the major sections of the bibliographical survey. Beginning with “Religion and the State in the Ancient World,” subsequent chapters address “Religion and the State in the Biblical World,” “Christianity and the State,” “Religion and the State in Other Religions,” “Religious Tolerance and Religious Freedom,” “Religion and the Secular State,” and “Religion in International Affairs and Interfaith Relations.” Volume 2 focuses on the modern world and, therefore, is organized around the geographical divisions of “Europe,” “Asia, Australia, and Oceania,” “North America,” “Latin America and the Caribbean,” “The Middle East,” and “Africa.” While these volumes have been in progress for some time, the work on them has been ongoing in order to keep them current, particularly the bibliographical surveys. Entries are included through 2003, and a number of volumes published in 2004 are also included in the surveys of each volume. No work of this kind could be undertaken without the assistance of various individuals and libraries without whose services and resources this work could never have been made ready for publication. I gladly acknowledge my debt to the staff of the Baylor University Church-State Research Center, the Moody Library of Baylor University, the Baylor University Law School Library, and the Library of Congress. I am also personally indebted to my former graduate assistants at Baylor University, in particular Perry L. Glanzer, J. David Holcomb, Steven C. Heyduck, Robert Owusu, J. Stephen Phillips, Jinghao Zhou, and Yarong Zhou. A word of appreciation must also be expressed here to Michelle Toon of Baylor University Information Technology Services for programming the data for the bibliographies and to Mary E. Tyler for her computer skills in preparing the final headings, pagination, and author and title indexes for publication. Finally, I am indebted to Elizabeth Potenza and Marcia Goldstein of Praeger Publishers for their assistance and courtesies and for the work of John Beck of Praeger Publishers for the production of both volumes for publication. While serving as a practical and reliable resource, I would dare to hope that these volumes may also encourage and stimulate further inquiry and research in the broad area of religion and the state, a subject of increasing complexity and relevance throughout the world. James E. Wood, Jr.
Introduction The subject of church and state is one intimately associated with the history of Christianity and Western civilization. Indeed, it has been called “the greatest subject in the history of the West”.1 Still other Christian scholars have referred to the subject of church and state as the “gravest problem of Christian ethics,”2 the “most enduring” problem through all the Christian centuries.3 The dawn of Christianity and the emergence of the modem nation-state, often with its abso-lute and totalitarian demands, have given an unprecedented meaning and significance to the subject. However, the subject is one that is by no means limited to anyone religious tradition, civilization, or period of history. Rather, it is a subject that, while in some respects is easily and intimately associated with Christianity, has historical and universal significance to all cultures and religious traditions throughout the world. It is simply undeniable that religion has been, and remains, a powerful force in the making and shaping of cultures, civilizations, nations, and empires. For this reason, these volumes address the broader perspectives of religion and the state in ancient world, as well as in the biblical world of Judaism and Christianity, but in other religious traditions than Christianity. Here, let it be said, that the familiar phrase “church and state” used in these volumes is interpreted throughout this work to mean religion and state in both national and international affairs. The international dimensions of the subject of church and state is amply documented in the contents of Volume 2, which is devoted to the relation of religion and the state throughout the modern world. The first volume of this work begins with religion and state in the ancient world, followed by chapters on religion and state in the biblical world and Christianity and the state. The remainder of this volume, however, treats religion and the state within the major religious traditions of the world and within a broad range of subjects directly bearing on religion and the state with respect to religious tolerance and religious freedom, religion and the secular state, and the role of religion in international affairs and interfaith religions which impact on the world community. In each case, the
2
Church and State
primary focus is on the linkage between church and state in each of the categories. Attention is given to general works on church and state which treat the subject broadly, not limited to any particular nation, religious tradition, or single aspect of church-state relations. As will be noted in the “General” section of the bibliography in this volume, published general works on the subject of this volume abound. In addition to works cited in the general section of Volume 1, valuable references on religion may also be found in Mircea Eliade, Encyclopedia of Religion and James George Frazer, The Golden Bough: A Study in Magic and Religion. It should be noted that the bibliographies in Volume 1 include entries relating not only to Christianity, but to religion and state in other major world religions. Additionally, attention is given to major topics integrally related to church and state, such as civil disobedience, civil religion, liberation theology, patriotism, and religion and nationalism. Finally, sources are included on religion in international affairs and interfaith relations, both necessarily linked to the subject of church and state, as well as religion and the economic order; religion and human rights; interfaith relations, religion and international affairs, and the bearing of religion on war and peace. Volume 2 of this work is limited to church and state or religion and the state in various countries throughout the world, primarily in the modern world, since 1700. Except for general works on religion and the state in the modem period, the bibliographies in Volume 2 are largely restricted to the various geographical areas throughout the world, and then alphabetically arranged by nation-states within in each geographical area.
NOTES 1. Many Christians scholars have expressed this point of view; for this particular quote, see Emil Bnmner, The Divine Imperative (Philadelphia: The Westminster Press, 1947), 552ff. 2. Sidney Cave, The Christian Way: A Study of New Testament Ethics in Relation to Present Problems (New York: The Philosophical Library, 1951), 233. 3. See, for example, H. Richard Niebuhr, Christ and Culture (New York: Harper and Row, 1951), 1-44
Chapter 1 Religion and the State in the Ancient World Religion is universal and, from all available evidence, is as old as humanity itself. Indeed, religion has been an integral part of the life of the human genus from the earliest times to the present. Wherever much has been known of the life of homo sapiens, the phenomenon of religion has been present, whether during the Paleolithic, Mesolithic, and Neolithic times of prehistoric humankind, or during the later Bronze Age, accompanied by the great civilizations of the ancient world.1. While almost nothing is known of the religious behavior of prehistoric homo sapiens prior to the Neanderthalers, there is clear evidence of a sense of the sacred or the religious by the time of the appearance of the Neanderthalers more than one hundred thousand years ago. Initially, Neanderthals were not regarded as capable of religious concepts, but today their religious consciousness has been widely affirmed by scholars of prehistoric religion. The inclusion of tools, flower blossoms, and other burial gifts, and even the placement of corpses, strongly suggest that the dead were thought to live on in some future manner. Certainly, the Neanderthal burial practices show a concern for the phenomenon of death and an existence in another world. Even more revealing of a religious sense of prehistoric homo sapiens is to be found in their works of art, usually found on the walls or roofs of caves. Many scholars of religion ascribe a sense of the sacred to prehistoric man and view him as homo religious. Indeed, a sense of the sacred is today widely regarded as a universal phenomenon that occurred long before recorded history. Throughout human history, religion, far from being an adjunct to culture and civilization, has been the great molder and purveyor of the civilizations of the world. Religion and culture are, in fact, inextricably intertwined throughout human history. Extant tribal religions provide important insights, as well as a
4
Church and State
laboratory, for studying the mind of primitive or prehistoric human kind. They provide modern man with an opportunity to analyze and understand, at least to some degree, the primitive apprehension of existence, which in turn has often been incorporated, in one form or another, into the so-called “higher religion” of today’s world. Such study provides some possible clues or insights into the nature of religion and theories concerning its origin in the life of mankind. To the ancient world, as to traditional tribal people, all of life and all of culture were viewed as sacred or religious. Conventions, customs, traditions, and taboos were all rooted in the sacred, i.e., religious sanctions or prohibitions. To violate any custom, tradition, or taboo was to incur the wrath of the gods or nature. Every important event, from birth to death, was solemnized by religious ceremonies (a pattern by no means unfamiliar in the public and state ceremonies of societies in the modern world). From earliest history religion was a matter for the community as a whole and not the individual. Religion and culture, as already noted, were integrally interrelated, and as religion developed from the tribal to the national stage religious history was inseparable from social and political history. Whereas in some lands, as in India and Persia, there was a priestly class which virtually dominated the entire life of the people, in other lands, as in Greece and Rome, there was little distinction made between the king and the priest. In both social structures, however, there was no real consciousness of the sacred and secular spheres of life; religious and political groupings were indistinguishable, as may be seen today in the patterns of resurgence of religions in parts of Africa, Asia, and the Middle East where religion and nationalism are merged. As one writer has succinctly phrased it: “Man’s church was his state; his state was his church.”2 In the languages of antiquity, there was no word for a religious grouping as distinct from a political entity. This interdependence of all of life was expressed in the intimate and intricate relationship between kingship and priesthood. This phenomenon is treated at some length in a classic work on the subject by Henri Frankfort, Kingship and the Gods: 3 A Study of Ancient Near Eastern Religion as the Integration of Society and Nature Generally speaking, the religious and political head of the community were one; the priest was a magistrate and the magistrate was a priest. Religion was so thoroughly integrated into the nation-state as to constitute a religio-political system by which society was stabilized and governed. To be a king or chieftain meant that his was a sacred office, not merely one of civil or political authority, and that the office of priest was a political as well as a religious office. Consequently, distinctions between religious and civil institutions were non-existent. The religious and the political were fused in such a way as to be virtually inseparable. Within the structure of the nation or state was an integrated system in which ruler, clergy, political decrees, tenets of faith, law, ethics, religious rites, and state rituals were all virtually combined. In the ancient world, religion was an integral part of society or the state and the function of religion was to serve its ruler or chieftains. Throughout much of Africa, Asia, and the Middle East today, the very concept of the sacred and the secular, church and state, would be incomprehensible. In addition, from earliest history, religion was a matter for the community as a whole and not the individual. In the words of one prominent scholar of ancient religion expressed it, ancient
Religion and State in the Ancient World
5 4
religion was “the product of a nation’ and was “a typical people’s religion.” Since ancient and tribal religions recognized no distinction between the religious and the secular, the same authority that promulgated laws regulating relations between persons promulgated laws concerning a person’s obligations to the supernatural. This authority was the king; and although the performance of the sacrifice and other rituals could be delegated to the priests, the source of all law was the head of the state. For example, the Code of Hammurabi, king of Babylon, imposed penalties for homicide, larceny, perjury, and other crimes; at the same time, it regulated the fees of surgeons and the wages of masons and tailors and prescribed rules for the inheritance of property. But the same Code catalogued the gods and assigned them their places in the divine hierarchy. Identification of political rulers with divinity was widespread. In the words of the author of the classic work, The Golden Bough, “In early society the divinity that doth hedge a king is no mere figure of speech.”5 In ancient Babylonia, the king was divine, as in the case of Ur, who called himself the son of a goddess. Similarly, Sargon of Akkad gave himself the title of “god,” and Sargon’s son, Sennacherib, is referred to in the ancient inscriptions of the period as “the god of the city of Akkad.” The Pharaoh of Egypt, as in ancient Babylonia, was no ordinary mortal, but the principal sacred person, who came to be regarded as a god incarnate, as the son of the gods, and the channel through which all blessings came to the people. As high priest, he also presided over all the cultic ceremonies and served as the intermediary between the world of the gods and the world of mortals. As a sacral ruler, he was the central figure in the cultic festivals of Egypt. In Egypt, the queen also held special significance, in large measure given this elevated place as the mother of the sacral monarch. The religion of ancient Egypt was rooted in a homogeneous culture, in which religion was “closely interwoven” with all dimensions of Egyptian society—art, ethics, science, and public life. One other evidence of the fusion of the sacred and secular in ancient Egypt may be found in that no words for religion, piety, or belief appeared in the language of ancient Egypt.6 What is generally referred to as the religion of ancient Greece came into being with the formation of the Greek city-states. Here again, however, power in religious matters resided with those who had what would be termed today “secular” power: first in the family with the father, in the early community with the king, and in city-states with the magistrates or citizen assembly. All formal occasions were inextricably intertwined with religion, and “every formal grouping was also a religious grouping, from the smallest to the largest.”7 Thus, religious history is inseparable from the political or social history of ancient Greece. Since there was no distinction between the religious and the secular, seers were the only religious professionals for they were the interpreters of the omens or divine will by which all public affairs were to be determined. Greek religion possessed no religious organization or church or creed and, therefore, there was no place for either dogma or heresy. Religious piety consisted of proper behavior through acts of respect for the gods. With the growth of democracy came, inexorably, the transformation of the patterns of Greek religion. There is a popular view that holds that Roman religion was but an extension of Greek religion, but such is not the case although, admittedly, Greek
6
Church and State
religion was taken to Rome and appropriated by the Romans. Above all else, the religion of ancient Rome was practical in nature. It did share, however, with the ancient religions of Babylonia, Egypt, and Greece—indeed all of the ancient world—the fusion of religion with the affairs of state and public life. Although Roman religion in its early period was centered in the family, in time the family religion was transformed into the state cultus, and thereby became an affair of the state. In the early Roman state during the time of the monarchy, the king was the chief priest and presided over ceremonial affairs. While the religions of Rome included the oriental religions with their appeal primarily to the masses and the philosophies of Rome that generally served as the religion of the literati, it was the state cultus that came to dominate Roman civilization. It was Octavian (the adopted son of Julius Caesar) who became the founder of the imperial Roman government and who brought about the renascence of Roman state religion. In time, like the Greeks, the Romans came to ascribe divinity to their rulers or emperors. That is to say, the head of the Roman Empire was a sacral ruler and no mere temporal functionary. Meanwhile, ministers of religion were state officials who were appointed to perform their duties like other state officials. Thus, “true to their genius,” as one scholar observed, “the Romans organized this religion as thoroughly as the government, of which in reality it was a part.”8 Roman religion came to consist of state ceremonies in which the rituals were performed with virtually no evidence of religious sentiment. Presiding over the religious affairs of state was the pontifex, members of which varied in number from five to fifteen, who were charged as state officials with responsibilities that today would be looked upon as a largely secular. Members of the pontifex were headed by Pontifex Maximus, an office and title later conferred upon Julius Caesar. The deities of Rome were city or state deities and the ceremonies dedicated to them were city or state ceremonies. Here, again, as in other parts of the ancient world, religion and the state became inseparable. NOTES 1. See E. O. James, “Prehistoric Religion,” in Religions of the Past, ed. C. Jouco Bleeker and George Widengren, Vol. 1 of Historia Religionum: Handbook for the History of Religions (Leiden: E. I. Brill, 1969), 23-39; Mircea Eliade, Patterns in Comparative Religion (New York: Sheed and Ward, 1958); and David L. Carmichael, Sacred Sites, Sacred Places (New York: Routledge, 1994). 2. T.M. Parker, Christianity and the State in the Light of History (New York: Harper and Brothers, 1955), 1. 3. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1978; originally published in 1948, but supplemented by a preface by Noah Kramer. 4. C. J. Bleeker, “The Religion of Ancient Egypt,” in Historia Religionum: Religions of the Past, ed. C. Jouco Bleeker and George Widengren (Leiden: E. I. Brill, 1969), 41. 5. James G. Frazer, Lectures on the Early History of Kingship (London: The Macmillan Co., 1905), 131-32. The contents of this volume consist substantially of extracts from the third edition of The Golden Bough.
Religion and State in the Ancient World
7
6. Bleeker, “The Religion of Ancient Egypt,” 42. 7. Robert Parker, “Greek Religion,” in The Oxford History of the Classical World, ed. John Boardman, Jasper Griffin, and Oswyn Murray (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1986), 265. 8. Edmund Soper, The Religions of Mankind, 3rd ed. rev. (Nashville: Abingdon Press, 1951), 83.
Chapter 2 Religion and the State in the Biblical World General As noted earlier, in the ancient world any separation of the religion from the community, tribe, or empire was inconceivable, since religion was indissolubly linked with one’s identity within the community or empire. In large measure religion formed the basis of one’s cultural identity. Therefore, in terms of the modern world, what might be called the religious community and the political community were one and the same. In years past there was a tendency in many quarters to view the faith of Israel as but one of the religious phenomena of the ancient Near East. Much attention was given, therefore, to the many points of contacts and convergence between the religious features of Israel and her various Near Eastern neighbors. In doing so, very often little attention was given to the uniqueness of the faith of Israel and the nation of Israel. In recent decades, however, there has been a growing understanding that both the faith of Israel and the nation Israel were in many ways original creations without parallel anywhere else in the ancient world. Actually, in some major respects a radical discontinuity separated the faith of Israel from that of her neighbors. At no point is this more manifest than in Israel’s legacy of the Hebrew Scriptures which provide a record of Israel’s uniqueness of faith and nationhood. It also provides a mirror of Israel’s self-understanding.
10
Church and State
Old Testament Israel’s self-understanding was deeply rooted in her election by Yahweh (God). Through both her triumphs and her tragedies as a nation there was always the prophetic reminder of Israel’s election. Even when in captivity, it was God’s purpose that was being fulfilled according to divine ends. All historical events were interpreted by writers of the Old Testament in terms of God’s divine purpose, to which the whole course of human history was being directed. There apparently never was a time when Israel thought of itself as any other than the elect people of God.1 The faith of Israel was not directed, as has been generally the case with national faiths, toward making the genius of the nation or the people the object of its worship, but was a God-centered faith. As a nation, Israel was seen by it prophets and historians as a nation repeatedly in rebellion against God. Far from being an idealized tale, the account of Israel is, in fact, a sorrowful and sordid story of epic proportions. As has often been noted, “Its historians and prophets told the truth about their people as have the patriots of no other nation. The greatest heroes of Israel were at one and the same time both sinners and heroes of faith.”2 The faith of Israel was not in the nation but in God. The very faith of Israel, which included the commandment, “Thou shalt have no other gods before me,” prohibited the deification of the nation Israel. Israel’s election was not based upon divine favoritism. Nor did it rest on the superiority of Israel’s power or righteousness, but rather in the mystery of divine grace.3 While the election of Israel was unmistakable, nowhere was there the claim of greatness or goodness for the nation Israel. Her election was not for Israel’s self-interest or self-centered purposes, but rather Israel was chosen to be a “light” or “witness” to the nations.4 The faith of Israel is the basis upon which the nation Israel is to be understood. Like all nations of the ancient world, Israel’s religious and political life were integrated and not compartmentalized. Israel was not a democracy (although some scholars have termed Israel a “primitive democracy”), but was founded upon a deep and abiding sense of divine election5 which resulted in a covenant relationship with God.6 It was this covenant which bound together the nation Israel, not race, economics, or politics. The election to be God’s servant and witness to the nations, although imperfectly grasped throughout much of its history, gave to Israel a sense of divine mission. The covenant was Israel’s reason for being, its meaning of existence, without which there would have been no faith or nation of Israel and consequently no Old Testament. For the covenant of Israel is at one and the same time the clue to Israel’s history and the clue to understanding the message of the Jewish Scriptures. It was also the basis of the uniqueness of Israel’s faith and status as a nation, and it was this concept of the covenant that is without parallel in the ancient world. Since the religious and political community in the ancient world—the sacred and the secular—generally were fused, or at least made to be inseparable, some have concluded that Israel was simply like her Near Eastern neighbors in identifying the sacred with the secular, the religious with the political. This is, however, to do violence to Israel’s self-understanding as a nation. Although the Israelites shared much in common with others in the ancient world in their view of nation-
Religion and the State in the Biblical World
11
hood, they accomplished the integration of nationhood and the Kingdom of God in a very different way.7 It was this difference which contributed to Israel’s distinct concept of nationhood, which, as noted earlier, was without parallel in the ancient world. The nation of Israel is presented in the Old Testament from two perspectives. Generally speaking, the books of Joshua through II Kings focused on the political affairs of Israel, while I Chronicles through Nehemiah focused on the religious affairs of Israel. In the absence of any parallel political community to which he could liken it, the Jewish historian, Flavius Josephus, coined the word “theocracy” to describe the nation of Israel. Josephus wrote, “Some legislators have permitted their governments to be under monarchies, others put them under oligarchies, and others under a republican form; but our legislator [Moses] had no regard to any of these forms, but he ordained our government to be what, by a strained expression, may be termed a Theocracy, by ascribing the authority and the power to God.”8 The peculiar status of Israel as a nation was to be found in the language of the covenant, in which God declared that Israel was to become “my special possession,” “my kingdom of priests,” “my holy nation.”9 At first glance, the term theocracy may seem quite appropriate when applied to Israel as portrayed in those books written from a priestly-Levitical point of view and to the polity of the Mosaic system. Moses was a deliverer, lawgiver, judge, and prophet—the religious and political leader of the people. Furthermore, in Israel religion applied to all of life, and there was no area of life outside the realm of religion. Civil and ceremonial laws were rooted in religion, and the Decalogue (the Ten Commandments) constituted the basis of the nation of Israel as well as the faith of Israel. Nevertheless, there are those scholars, both Jewish and Christian, who discern an incipient dualism even in the Mosaic period between the sacred and the secular. For though Moses, for example, was the leader of the people, he was not made a priest. The priestly office seems to have begun with his brother, Aaron, and apparently was limited almost exclusively to his descendants, the Levites. It may justifiably be argued that Israel was not a theocracy in the strict sense, since those who held positions of national or tribal authority were not priests or priest-kings, but elders. They constituted the permanent element of government except during those critical periods in the history of Israel when leaders known as judges supplanted the authority of the elders. Like the elders, the judges were independent of the priesthood. During the period of the judges, military and political leaders appeared who did not carry priestly functions with their offices. An exception was Samuel, who in many ways was different from all of the judges. He served preeminently as priest and prophet, and during the establishment and early history of the monarchy, Samuel held the reins of religious leadership while the political leadership was vested in Saul, the first king of Israel. Nowhere was the unique character of the nation Israel more pronounced than in Israel’s concept of kingship. For example, Israel did not hold to the idea of political apotheosis, i.e., the divinity of rulers, and generally even denied the king the right of priestly functions. Although in Hebrew the word king (melek) was applied to God and also to idols, there was no attempt to ascribe deity to Israel’s kings. Israelite kings were not deified as in other parts of the ancient world, nor did they take the
12
Church and State
part of deity in religious rituals. In Mesopotamia, for example, even though the king was not regarded as god incarnate, he was god’s special servant, appointed to help carry out the divine order of the universe and, therefore, the leader of the state cult. There was a distinct difference in Israel’s concept of kingship, which not only denied the idea of the divinity of its kings, but also generally denied the king the right of priestly functions. This is readily seen when Saul, the first king of Israel, dared to usurp the priestly functions reserved for Samuel; he thereby invoked the wrath of Samuel and met divine disapproval, which ultimately cost Saul divine rejection and the loss of his throne. The very founding of the monarchy is treated with ambivalence in the biblical record. On the one hand, the monarchy appears to be permitted as a grudging concession by God in response to the clamor of the elders to make Israel “like all the [other] nations”10; on the other hand, another tradition, often referred to as the Saul source,11 the establishment of the monarchy, while not regarded as the fulfillment of God’s will, is viewed as providential and as a means of bringing deliverance to the people of Israel. Since Yahweh alone was king, Israel could not identify the kingdom of Israel with the Kingdom of God. Evidence of this may be found in the rela-tionship of the kings of Israel to the faith of Israel. Not only was the divinity of rulers denied, but there were no signs of taboo around Israel’s kings as was common among other nations at that time. To be sure, some priestly functions were on occasion assumed by the king, at least in the early period of the monarchy.12 The fact remains, however, the king of Israel was primarily a war-lord, a commander-in-chief of the military. He was clearly the political leader and not the religious leader or arbiter in religious matters. As Henri Frankfort observed in a classic study of kingship in the ancient Near East, “The Hebrew king normally functioned in the profane sphere not in the sacred sphere. He was arbiter in disputes and leader in war. He was emphatically not the leader in the cult.”13 Indeed, an incipient dualism between the religious and secular appeared as early as the Mosaic period in Jewish history. Judges and kings generally functioned in the profane sphere, while priests and prophets served in the sacred sphere. Ultimate authority in Israel was vested in the institution of the Hebrew prophets. These “forthtellers” or spokespersons for God figured prominently in the affairs of state and were consulted even by the kings of Israel.14 The king himself was bound to the law of the covenant, and, consequently, prophetic judgment was repeatedly pronounced upon Israel’s rulers and kings. Israel knew nothing of a “divine right of kings,” for Israel’s commitment to the law and the covenant was prior to kingship. The kings of Israel were to set an example to all in obedience to the law. Therefore, kings no less than the common people were under God judgment for injustice, avarice, exploitation, and immorality.15 Israel’s monotheism, the doctrine of Yahwism, was in large measure responsible for preventing the development of absolute monarchy or the absolutizing of the nation Israel. Prophetic judgment on the evils of the state of Israel steadily gave rise to the Messianic concept and particularly to the doctrine of the Kingdom of God. The failure of Israel to become the people of Yahweh and to fulfill his purpose made apparent that the Kingdom of God could not be equated with the existent Israel. The
Religion and the State in the Biblical World
13
author of Isaiah, for example, acknowledged the doom of Judah and recognized that not all of the people of Israel could be the Kingdom of God, for God’s kingdom is not an earthly kingdom, but an eternal and spiritual kingdom where God reigns and is comprised of the obedient and the faithful.16 As John Bright noted, “The hope of Israel is thus driven ahead beyond the existing nation.”17 Thus, the hope of Israel is made to transcend the nation of Israel. At last the development of the concept of the Kingdom of God made possible the clear separation of the religious community from the political community, although for most Jews, in light of the canonical writings of the prophets, there was little awareness of any distinction between the two. With the collapse of the monarchy and final capture of Jerusalem in 586 B.C.E., the nucleus of Israel was taken into Exile. The Exile witnessed the transference of authority from kingship to priesthood and the organization of the community on an almost entirely religious basis. Here in Exile, under the leadership of Ezekiel, the religion of Judaism was born and religion became distinctly spiritual and personal. The desire for political community and kingship, however, did not die. For many the restoration of Israel was fervent hope and this, it was reasoned could not be realized apart from the re-establishment of the monarchy. Although Ezekiel insisted that the Israel of the future would be a “kingdom of priests”18 he acknowledged the place of a “prince” with restricted civil power.19 Though the monarchy was never actually realized again, the longing for a monarch seems to have been imperishable and regarded as having divine sanction in the hearts of the masses. In the thinking of the Jews, the restoration of Israel as a political state with its capital at Jerusalem, if not to be equated with the Kingdom of God, was at least prerequisite to its realization in history.20 They could not envisage a spiritual kingdom apart from the earthly kingdom of Israel. Lacking political autonomy and being subject to the foreign powers of Babylonia and Persia—and still later to Greece and Rome—the Jews associated civil government with a hostile and pagan foreign power, whereas they felt that they themselves, as the people of Yahweh, represented the true community of faith. During this time the Messianic consciousness of the people was deepened and intensified. It became more than a hope; it was the means of true restoration.
New Testament It was into this environment that Jesus came and ushered in the dawn of Christianity. Recent scholarship has reaffirmed the Jewishness of Jesus, for he can hardly be understood or his teachings properly interpreted apart from his Jewish background. Born “a star out of Jacob,” Jesus remained a faithful Jew throughout his life in Palestine. His message, the Kingdom of God, was a Jewish concept which had already become integral to the prophetic tradition of Israel. Although his life and teachings were to make a unique imprint on Israel and the world, the teachings of Jesus presuppose a Jewish environment and it is impossible to imagine their having come out of any other milieu. This is not to suggest, however, that Jesus’ view of the state was simply an extension of the Jewish sense of nationhood
14
Church and State
and the Kingdom. For Jesus found himself in tension with the theocratic ideal of the Judaism of his day as well as with the Jewish nationalism of the first century. By 63 B.C.E., the Jewish nation had lost its political independence to Roman conquest under Pompey. At first, the Jewish high priest Hyrcanus was retained as ethnarch. Later through the influence of Julius Caesar, the Idumeans—Antipater and his descendants the Herods—ruled over the Jews and controlled the high priest and the Sanhedrin through appointment and dismissal. While religious freedom was granted by the Romans, this did not lessen the hostility and resentment many Jews felt about having not one but two foreign powers ruling over them. For the Jewish revolutionaries, who were zealous theocrats, there could be no rest until political freedom was achieved with the reestablishment of the Jewish nation. This contention was maintained on a religious basis. There were, however, deep cleavages in the Jewish community concerning the relationship of the Jews to Rome, and these cleavages added to the complexity of the times in which Jesus lived. Jewry was divided into four major groups. They generally held different views of Rome, the nationhood of Israel, and the nature of the Kingdom. Often referred to as “collaborationists,” the Sadducees, relatively few in number, were drawn primarily from the aristocratic and priestly families. Having wealth, position, and prestige under the Romans, the Sadducees had nothing to gain through revolt and therefore freely assented to Roman rule. By completely submitting to the Romans, the Sadducees relinquished all hope of the realization of the Kingdom of God in history. Far more numerous and of greater political power, though not primarily a political party as such, the Pharisees represented the popular party. Josephus wrote of them, “These have so great a power over the multitude, that when they say anything against the king, or against the high priest, they are presently believed.”21 They sought through religious means to restore the Jewish community to its rightful place in history. Because of their meticulous observance of both the written and the moral law, Judaism has been called “the monument of the Pharisees.” As both separatists and theocrats, they opposed the Roman state on religious grounds, while at the same time as pacifists they refused to offer any physical resistance against it. The Roman yoke was regarded as chastisement for Israel’s sins that would in time be removed by God, and Israel would once again be restored to her divinely appointed place in history. A third group, known as the Essenes, were an ascetic and esoteric brotherhood, primarily monastic in character. Small in number and centered largely around the Dead Sea, they were separatists who believed in living out the perfect, holy life apart from society and saw themselves as the Sons of Light,” the true people of God. As ascetics they renounced not only the political community but also the world. Hence they lived entirely for the future when the Kingdom of God would be ushered in by the Davidic or royal Messiah. Since they believed that they were living in the last days and the last generation, they were particularly disposed to Messianic and eschatological thought. Unlike the Sadducees and the Pharisees, the Essenes were never condemned by Jesus. “The fourth sect of Jewish philosophy,” as Josephus described them, the
Religion and the State in the Biblical World
15
Zealots shared much in common with the Pharisees in religious matters, but represented the revolutionary wing of the anti-Roman resistance among the Jews. Fanatically nationalistic, they actively, if not openly, opposed Roman rule even to the point of carrying on guerrilla warfare, and many of them advocated a war to the finish. The super patriots of their day, the Zealots saw Israel’s nationhood and God’s kingdom as inseparable. Since God alone was Ruler and Lord, they refused on religious grounds to recognize the validity of any foreign ruler over them. Unlike the Essenes, the Zealots were highly political in their motives. To the Zealots, the only hope for Israel was a holy war by which all foreign domination would be overthrown and the holy nation of Israel reestablished. As insurrectionists, they stood vigorously opposed to the collaborationists, the Sadducees. While there have been those who have sought to identify Jesus as a Zealot, their efforts have not won acceptance among most biblical scholars and historians of early Christianity.22 The importance of Zealotry to the life of the Early Church and its views of the state should not, however, be underestimated. One cannot overlook the fact that the Romans sentenced Jesus to death on the cross as a Zealot and that the inscription on the cross—”King of the Jews”—charged him with a political crime.23 To outsiders Jesus appeared, if not as Zealot, at least as one who shared much in common with the Zealots. Among Jesus’ disciples were Zealots or former Zealots, as in the known case of Simon the Zealot, and possibly even Judas Iscariot, Peter, and James and John, the sons of Zebedee. Certainly, Jesus encountered Zealotism throughout his ministry. There has been a marked awakening of interest in recent years in the relationship of Jesus to the political order. Numerous studies have appeared, written from a wide variety of viewpoints, focusing on the politics of Jesus and his political environment.24 Since there is always the tendency to view Jesus through contemporary rather than through the eyes of the Gospel writers, some of these studies may reveal more about the biases of the authors than they do about the Jesus of the Gospels. More to the point here is that in the New Testament, as Oscar Cullman and many other Christian scholars have maintained, the subject of church and state clearly emerges as inherent and not peripheral, “one which arises because of the very essence and presuppositions of the Christian faith.”25 Or, as another New Testament scholar expressed it, “In point of fact the whole matter of church-andstate lies near the center of our [Christian] theology.26 The oldest and most revered of all Christian creeds, the Apostle’s Creed, takes cognizance of this in the words, “suffered under Pontius Pilate,” the symbol of the authority of the state. It was for insurrection that the Romans sentenced Jesus to death, and the inscription on the cross—“King of the Jews!”—charged him with a political crime.27 The cross, so central to both the history and theology of Christianity, should be seen “not only as the event that mediates forgiveness of God to individuals. . . . It should also be seen as a historical event. . . . and as an event it shows forth the suffering that can often be expected to be consequence of obedience.”28 Although only one explicit teaching by Jesus appears in the biblical record, much significance has been attached to the attitude and the relationship of Jesus to the state. As many writers have observed, Jesus was no anarchist. He showed not only a recognition of the existence of the state, but also a respect
16
Church and State
for the authority of its political institutions and the legitimate functions of the state in maintaining order and collecting taxes. In his own behavior Jesus recognized civil authority and was duly observant of all laws and ordinances. He showed respect for those in positions of civil or political authority and most certainly did not regard civil government as an evil.29 In his trial before Pilate, the Gospel writers reported six times that Pilate found him to be innocent. Just as the attitude of Jesus toward the state was not only one of renunciation, neither was it one of uncritical acceptance. He not only spoke out against the corruption of courts and an unjust judge, he warned Israel of her perils and declared judgment upon her. He criticized the leaders of Israel for not obeying the law, for pride and hypocrisy, for oppression, maladministration, and injustice, and warned against following after them. He specifically expressed harsh criticism of Herod the Idumean. Three days before His crucifixion, Jesus gave classic expression for all time to the nature of one’s relationship to church and state: “Give to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s, and to God the things that are God’s.”30 By this, Jesus openly recognized the dual citizenship of the Christian in the state and the Kingdom of God. This declaration clearly does not mean that the claims of Caesar’s sphere are co-ordinate with the claims of God’s sphere, for the inescapable implication is that not only are these spheres not identical by nature or degree, but that one’s supreme loyalty is to God. Rather, one must not give to Caesar that which belongs only to God! Thus, Jesus made explicit that the state is not to be deified, but that the Kingdom of God is always to have paramount claim. While the legitimate demands of the state are to be recognized, Jesus’ teaching made clear that absolute obedience belongs only to God. Any exaltation of the state to the sphere of the Kingdom of God requires a response in the manner that would later be expressed by Peter and the apostles, “We must obey God rather than men.”31 The brilliant and renowned Catholic scholar of the history of freedom, John Acton, perceptively wrote that the words of Jesus, ‘“Render to Caesar’ give to civil authority under the protection of conscience, a sacredness it had never enjoyed, and bounds it had never acknowledged: and they were the repudiation of absolutism and the inauguration of freedom.”32 Most of the direct teachings in the New Testament concerning the state are to be found in the writings of Paul. His teachings largely provided the foundation for the relationship of the Early Church to the state, and determined for many centuries the attitude of the church toward state. Writing as a Roman citizen and a Hellenist, and before the Roman persecutions had begun against Christianity; Paul viewed Roman law and order in positive terms. He not only did not feel fear or hatred toward Rome, he sought to encourage the early Christians to be good citizens and to see that the Roman Empire could serve to advance the Kingdom of God. The Pauline view of the state may be drawn principally from Romans 13:1-7; I Corinthians 2:8; and I Corinthians 6:1-11. The most developed statement of Paul’s thought on the state and the most systematic statement on the state in the New Testament is to be found in Romans 13:1-7: “Everyone must obey state authorities, because no authority exists without God’s permission, and the exist-ing authorities have been put there by God. [Therefore] he who opposes the existing authority op-
Religion and the State in the Biblical World
17
poses what God has ordered. . . . Because he is God’s servant working for your own good. . . . you must obey the authorities—not just because of God’s punishment, but also as a matter of conscience.”33 Paul goes further than any other biblical writer in recognizing the state as part of a God-given institution within which persons are to live and work in this world. Perhaps no passage in the New Testament has been more grossly misinterpreted than this one. These verses have been used throughout history to justify despotism, oppression, the divine right of kings, and the most absolute demands of the state by sanctioning an unqualified servile obedience to the state. In his detailed exposition of Romans 13 and Revelation 13, the late William Stringfellow argued that in order to “honor the emperor,” as Scripture commands, it becomes necessary to oppose him under certain circumstances.34 Neil Elliott concluded that far from advocating subservience to an “oppressive” or “patriarchal” political order, Paul was a proponent of an early liberation theology.35 In stating that the institution of political authority is ordained of God, is not to say that the state is divine. As Oscar Cullman wrote, “The State in itself is nothing divine. But it maintains a certain dignity in that it stands in an order which is still willed by God.”36 This concept did not originate with Paul but is found also in Jewish writings which likewise held the view that “there is no authority except from God.” The authority of political rulers is from God and therefore political authority is responsible to Him. Thus, in Jewish writings may be found the following: “Learn therefore, king, and understand: learn this, judges of the ends of the earth. . . . For your dominion was given you from the Lord, and your sovereignty from the Most High.”37 Even while Jews were under Roman rule, prayers were offered in the synagogues for the Roman Emperor. It was not that Jews and the early Christians sacralized political rulers, but rather that they viewed government as an institution to be ordained of God and the political ruler, in the words of Paul, in Romans 13:4, to be “God’s servant working for your own good.” While the institution of government de jure is ordained by God, that does not means that any government de facto enjoys divine approval. Paul has often been identified with the principle of non-resistance toward the state. This Pauline view was no doubt conditioned by the tendency of early Christians to identify freedom with license and their widely held belief in Christ’s eminent return to judge the world and usher in his kingdom. In addition Paul sought to emphasize that good citizenship should characterize the Christian community everywhere. While Christians are obligated to be good citizens, the Christian is not to be in uncritical subjection to the state. In Paul’s view, the safeguard of an uncritical exaltation of the state is to be found in the recognition of the sovereignty of God. As for rulers, Paul wrote, Christ is “far above all rule and authority and power and dominion, and above every name that is named, and not only in this age but also in that which is to come; and he has put all things under his feet.”38 Paul took a critical view of the political institutions of his day.39 “The rulers of this age,” both Jewish and Roman, Paul declared, “lack true wisdom and were temporal, doomed to pass away.”40 Paul clearly recognized that while the institution of the state was divinely ordained, the state is not divine in nature, but is temporal. Respect and honor are due the state, but the state is to be worthy of the respect and honor accorded it.
18
Church and State
During the latter half of the first century, the Christian community found itself increasingly in conflict with the Roman state. As Christianity separated itself more and more from Judaism it came to be regarded as a religio illicita, and so remained until the fourth century. With the resistance of early Christians to submit to the worship of the Roman emperors, after 64 C.E. Christians were repeatedly victims of intense persecutions initiated by Roman emperors in an attempt to elicit from the Christian community unqualified allegiance and obedience. The Early Church stood opposed to surrendering to the state that allegiance which they held to belong only to God. In the oft-repeated words of the early Christians, as found in the Book of Acts, “We must obey God rather than men.” The attitude of the early Christians was marked by a dualism toward the state. On the one hand, they recognized the state as an institution ordained of God, and, on the other hand, they found themselves increasingly hostile to the existing state as inherently evil. This dualism had its roots in the teachings of both Jesus and Paul, but was extended and made even more distinct with the emergence of Christianity as a new religion in the Roman Empire. This dualism may be seen as extending throughout the Constantinian era and alternating “between the two extremes of absolute condemnation and rejection on the one hand and hearty approval and even co-operation on the other.”41 In the waning decades of the first century, the early Christians faced an increasingly hostile state, which is reflected in the writings of John, particularly in the Book of Revelation. Although sharing much with the Pauline doctrine of the state, the Johannine literature reflects and typifies the second part of the dualism of the early Christians toward the state, in which the world is viewed as being filled with evil and darkness. To John, Rome had become a Satanic power, which in Revelation 13 John speaks of the state as the “beast,” since Rome had become the kingdom of Satan. For the state is most satanic when it demands what is God’s and thereby arrogates to itself rights and qualities which belong only to God.42 The evil of the Roman state expressed itself primarily in two ways: its claims of deification and worship of the emperor and the persecution of Christians.43 To Christians living under such an evil and satanic state, John exhorted, “Be faithful unto death, and I will give you the crown of life.”44 There is no summons to resistance or call to bear arms against the state. “If anyone is to be taken captive,” John admonished,” to captivity he goes; if anyone slays with the sword, with the sword must he be slain.”45 To be sure, when there is no other alternative but to defy the state, then the Christian community, as noted earlier, “must obey God rather than men.” To the faithful, God promised not only victory, but also divine blessing, as noted in Revelation 2:10. Meanwhile, the church is to anticipate the time when “the kingdoms of this world are become the kingdom of our Lord and of his Messiah; and he shall reign for ever and ever.”46 NOTES 1. The late Old Testament scholar, John Bright, for example, gave emphasis to this; see his work, A History of Israel (Philadelphia: The Westminster Press, 1959), 132.
Religion and the State in the Biblical World
19
2. G. Ernest Wright, “The Faith of Israel,” in The Interpreter’s Bible Commentary, ed. George A. Buttrick, 12 vols. (New York: Abingdon Press, 1952-1957), 1:354. 3. Nowhere in the Hebrew Scriptures can one imagine any of Israel’s historians or prophets exclaiming, “Israel is great, because Israel is good,” as recent American presidents have been fond of saying with regard to America. 4. See Isaiah 42:6; 49:6. 5. Genesis 12:1-3 6. Genesis 17:1-14. 7. During the nineteenth century and the early part of the twentieth century, undue importance was given to the gradual and evolutionary development of Judaism and its similarities with those of the Near East generally. Today, the similarities are generally viewed as more superficial than profound; see Henri Frankfort, Kingship and the Gods: A Study of Ancient Near Eastern Religion as the Integration of Society and Nature (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1948), 337-44 8. Flavius Josephus, Against Apion” bk. 2, sec. 17, in The Works of Flavius Josephus, trans. William Whiston, 4 vols. (Nashville: Broadman Press, 1974), 4:218-19. 9. Exodus 19:5-6. 10. I Samuel 8. 11. II Samuel 9. 12. For instance, Saul offered sacrifice (I Sam. 13:9-11), as did David (II Samuel 6:13, 17), who also, like Solomon, blessed the people (II Samuel 6:18; I Kings 8:14; II Kings 3:4). David, too, on at least one occasion wore the linen ephod, the garment of priesthood (II Samuel 6:14). However, these were the exceptions and not the rule of Israel’s kings, and such practices were later completely repudiated by Jewish orthodoxy. 13. Frankfort, Kingship and the Gods, 342; see also, Joseph Jacobs, “King, ”The Jewish Encyclopedia (New York: KTAV Publishing House, 1904), 7:501; Samuel H. Hooke, Myth, Ritual, and Kingship in the Ancient Near East and Israel (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1958); and Hamish Swanston, The Kings and the Covenant (Baltimore: Helicon Press, 1968), which provides an account of the Hebrew monarchy and its relationship to the covenant with Yahweh. 14. For some examples, see I Samuel 9:6; I Kings 14:1ff; II Kings 19:2; and I Kings 22:6. 15. For example, the prophet Nathan dared to go before King David and say, “David, thou art the man. . . . Wherefore hast thou despised the commandment of the Lord, to do what is evil in His sight?” (II Samuel 12:7, 9). 16. Isaiah 65:8-10. 17. John Bright, The Kingdom of God (New York: Abingdon Press, 1953), 91. 18. Ezekiel 19:6.
20
Church and State
19. Ezekiel 44:3; 45:17; 46. 20. Jeremiah 23:3-5. 21. Josephus, Antiquities of the Jews” bk. 13, chap. 10, sec. 5, in The Works of Flavius Josephus, 3: 252. 22. See, for example, Robert I. Eisler, The Messiah Jesus and John the Baptist According to Flavius Josephus’ Recently Rediscovered ‘Capture of Jerusalem’ (New York: The Dial Press, 1931) and S. G. F. Brandon, Jesus and the Zealots (New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1968); for works that argue that Jesus was not a Zealot, see, for example, Oscar Cullman, Jesus and the Revolutionaries (New York: Harper and Row, 1970) and Martin Hengel, Was Jesus a Revolutionist? (Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1971). 23. John 19:19. 24. Ernst Bammel and C. F. D. Moule, eds., Jesus and the Politics of His Day (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1984); Marcus J. Borg, Conflict, Holiness, and Politics in the Teaching of Jesus (New York: The Edwin Mellen Press, 1984); S. G. F. Brandon, Jesus and Zealots; Richard J. Cassidy, Jesus, Politics, and Society: A Study of Luke’s Gospel (Maryknoll, N. Y.: Orbis Books, 1979); Cullman, Jesus and the Revolutionaries; Hengel, Was Jesus a Revolutionist?; Sean P. Kealy, Jesus and Politics (Collegeville, Minn.: The Liturgical Press, 1990; J. Spencer Kennard, Render to God: A Study of the Tribute Passage (New York: Oxford University Press, 1950); Stephen Liberty, The Political Relations of Christ’s Ministry (London: Oxford University Press, 1916); Jean-Marie Paupert, The Politics of the Gospel (New York: Holt, Rinehart, and Winston, 1969); Alan Richardson, The Political Christ (Waterloo, Ontario: Wilfrid Laurirer University Press, 1991); Herman C. Waetjen, A Reordering of Power: A Socio-Political Reading of Mark’s Gospel (Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1989); Paul W. Walaskay, ‘And So We Came to Rome’: The Political Perspective of St. Luke (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1983); and John Howard Yoder, The Politics of Jesus (2nd ed.; Grand Rapids, Mich.: Wm. B. Eerdmans, 1994). 25. Cullman, The State in the New Testament, viii, passim. 26. Martin H. Scharlemann, “Scriptural Concepts of the Church and State,” Church and State Under God (St. Louis: Concordia Publishing Co., 1964), 16. 27. John 19:19. 28. John C. Bennett, (p. 43). 29. John 19:11. 30. Mark 12:17; cf. the entire passage in Mark 12:13-17 and the parallel passages in Matthew 22:15-22 and Luke 20:20-26. Joseph Klausner sees in the answer the tribute money proved that not from this Galilean Messiah could they hope for national freedom and political redemption”; see Klausner, Jesus of Nazareth (New York: The Macmillan Co., 1952), 318. 31. Acts 5:29. 32. John Acton, The History of Freedom and Other Essays (London: The Macmillan Co., 1909), 29.
Religion and the State in the Biblical World
21
33. Good News Bible translation; for an excellent exegetical study of Romans 13 and its relevance to Christian freedoms and responsibility, see Clinton Morrison, The Powers that Be: Earthly Rules and Demonic Powers in Romans 13:1-7 (Naperville, Ill.: A. A. Allenson, 1960). 34. William Stringfellow, Conscience and Obedience: The Politics of Romans 13 and Revelation 13 in Light of the Second Coming (Waco, Tex.: Word Books, 1977). 35. See Neil Elliott, Liberating Paul: The Justice of God and the Politics of the Apostle (Maryknoll, N.Y.: Orbis Books, 1994). 36. Cullman, The State in the New Testament, 63. 37. Wisdom of Solomon 6:1-5; Goodspeed translation. 38. Ephesians 1:21-22. 39. see Cecil John Cadoux, The Early Church and the World (Edinburgh: T. and T. Clark, 1925), 98ff. 40. I Corinthians 2:6-8. 41. Cadoux, The Early Church and the World, 97. 42. See Ernst Troeltsch, The Social Teaching of the Christian Churches (2 vols.; London: George Allen and Unwin Ltd., 1931), 1:146-48. Oscar Cullman, and others, have rightly pointed out that “in the [John’s] interpretation of the State there is no contradiction--no more than there is within the Pauline letters themselves or among the sayings of Jesus. Regarding the State’s requirement of worship of Caesar’s image Paul would not nave spoken otherwise than the author o the Johannine Apocalypse”; Cullman, The State in the New Testament, 83. 43. See, particularly, Revelation 13. 44. Revelation 2:10. 45. Revelation 13:10. 46. Revelation 11:15.
Chapter 3 Christianity and the State A major part of the history of Christianity has centered around the relationship of church and state. In a profound sense, the relationship of church and state has been historically a problem peculiar to Christianity. With the exception of Judaism, as noted earlier, religions of antiquity were unsystematized in matters of belief and almost exclusively ceremonial in character. In the case of Christianity, however, the subject of church and state has occupied a large place in the course of Christian history. Having briefly reviewed religion and the state in the biblical world and noting the continuity in and the uniqueness of the biblical duality of church and state, it should not be inferred that this view of the state found uniform or representative expression in Christian history. Diverse interpretations of church and state, along with the exigencies of history, resulted in disparate and divergent views of church and state within Christianity. These patterns, in effect, furnish the basis of the Christian political heritage. While certain patterns of church-state relations have characterized certain periods of history and the major Christian traditions of Roman Catholicism, Protestantism, and Eastern Orthodoxy, actually no one pattern has been restricted to any one era or single branch of Christianity. First, in the course of Christian history, the nature of the relationship between church and state has varied greatly. There has been both conflict and concord. Historic examples may be found of open conflict between church and state, of accommodation of the church to the state, and of the accommodation of the state to the church. Second, there have been diverse interpretations within Christianity of the two kingdoms—of Caesar and God—and have included the notions of the Christian state and an established church, and, in contradistinction to this, the concept of a free or secular state and a free church. To be sure, these interpretations have frequently been conditioned and influenced by the forces of history.
24
Church and State
Meanwhile, it is also important to note that recognition of the dualism of church and state has never resolved the complexity or dilemma of church-state relations. Unfortunately, acknowledgment of the dualism of church and state does not in itself define the nature of the relationship between the two powers. Is the church to be over the state, or is the state to be over the church? Is the state to be Christian, or is the state to be secular? Should there be an institutional separation of between the institutions of church and state or should there be a close cooperation between church and state? While not necessarily mutually exclusive, these questions represent historically major patterns regarding the relationship of church and state, and may well serve as major divisions of this chapter. At the risk of oversimplification, the broad periods of the relationship of Christianity to the state may be characterized as falling into four major patterns. The highly variegated patterns of churchstate relations in the modern period may be found in the bibliographical survey, arranged country by country within broad geographical divisions, in Volume 2.
The Church in Conflict with the State Christianity was born out of conflict with the state. Although Jesus was no political revolutionary, as noted earlier, he was charged with and convicted of a political crime, insurrection. During the early apostolic period, however, Roman persecutions were not directed at Christians. As long as Christianity was clearly identified as a Jewish sect within Judaism, the Christian community enjoyed virtually the same rights and protections of Jews. Since Judaism was a legally recognized religion, it was exempt from the rites of the state cult and received certain concessions granted it as a minority religion. While Rome was generally tolerant in religious matters, as Christianity separated itself more and more from Judaism and came to be identified with exclusivism, Christianity faced a growing hostility in its relations with Rome. First faced with persecution during the latter part of Nero’s reign (64-68 C.E.), intermittent persecutions came under Domitian (81-96 C.E.); under Trajan (98-117 C.E.) persecutions against Christians were accelerated and Christianity was made religio illicita.; and under Marcus Aurelius (161-180 C.E.) persecutions of Christians were intensified. In the third century, Decius (249-51 C.E.), in an effort to revive the state religion, carried out the worst of the persecutions against Christianity in an effort to compel Christians by torture and imprisonment to sacrifice to the old Roman gods. While multitudes of Christians endured persecution and suffered martyrdom, thousands of Christians lapsed, only later to seek restoration to the Christian fold. Since Christianity came to be declared by Emperor Trajan an illegal religion, by the beginning of the second century to admit to one’s being a Christian was itself an act of civil or political disobedience, according to law, and therefore to merit punishment by the state. Christianity’s conflict with the state came during the latter part of the first century and inevitably arose when Rome began demanding throughout the empire not only supreme allegiance but the worship of Roman emperors, both those who were deceased as well as living emperors. The Christian com-
Christianity and the State
25
munity, in its affirmation of “Jesus is Lord,” generally felt compelled to resist this practice and, therefore, was repeatedly subjected to intense persecution initiated by Roman rulers not only for political reasons but also as an attempt to elicit from the Christian community unqualified loyalty and unconditional obedience. Thus, the early church stood opposed to surrendering to Rome that allegiance and obedience which, it maintained, belonged only to God. A dualism characterized the early Christians’ relationship to the state, which wavered between an attitude of civil obedience to the state as a divinely ordained institution, and a holy disobedience to Rome’s demands of political allegiance in conflict with the demands of Christian faith. For the early Christians, conflict with the state, in the form of civil disobedience, became inevitable since it demanded that Christians give to Caesar that which, they held, belonged only to God. However, the Christians accepted the legal penalty for their civil disobedience. There is clear evidence to show that the early Christians generally sought to respect the state and to show an attitude of deference toward Rome rather than manifest an attitude of hostility. This viewpoint was given special emphasis by many of the early Apologists who claimed that they were the “best citizens” of the Emperor. Even after the Neronian and Domitian persecutions, prayers continued to be offered for rulers, even the emperor, as divinely appointed officials. For example, Polycarp prayed for the kings and rulers who were persecutors of Christians, as did also Clement of Rome, the first of the Apostolic Fathers.1 With the doctrine of emperor worship as was finally promulgated throughout the Empire, however, Christians were compelled to defy the state and to affirm that to Christ alone they owed supreme allegiance. The mounting corruption of the state and the growing hostility of the state toward Christianity cemented a bond of unity among Christians. With John, they felt, “We know that we are of God, and that the whole world is in the power of the evil one.”2 This view was widely held by the early Christians as expressed by Tertullian more than a century later: “That all the power and dignities of this age are not only alien, but also hostile to God.”3 For almost three centuries the early Christians repeatedly found themselves subject to waves of persecutions carried out in the Roman Empire. Since Christianity was regarded as religio illicita, the very act of professing to be a Christian became an act of civil disobedience to civil authorities because of a prior loyalty to God. Lactantius, writing in 304 C.E., affirmed that “constancy is a virtue, not in order that we may resist those who injure [us] . . .but that, when [the authorities] bid us act contrary to the law of God and contrary to justice, we may be frightened away by no threats of punishments from preferring the bidding of God to the bidding of man.”4 Throughout the early centuries of the church, Christians were admonished to resist the totalitarian demands of the state. While, admittedly, as noted earlier, there were those who lapsed in their faith during waves of intense persecution, history clearly attests that the early church, by and large, did resist the demands of Rome for supreme allegiance and loyalty. Thus, Tertullian, by the end of the second century could write, “The blood of the martyrs is the seed of the church.”5 Although particular attention has been given here to the conflict of the early church with Rome, the church’s conflict with the state has often been experienced in Christian
26
Church and State
history throughout the world. With the rise in the modern world of nationalism, the totalitarian state, and the atheistic communist state there has been a resurgence of conflict between church and state. Many of these conflicts, even in the twentieth century, have been reminiscent of the first three centuries of Christian history.
The Supremacy of the Church over the State The view of the supremacy of the church over the state has a long and intricate history, during which the dualism of church and state was often obscured. For almost a thousand years, roughly from 500-1500 C.E., the period was one of ecclesiastical domination over society and the state. This domination was based upon a particular view of the relationship of church and state. As the claims of God, which are spiritual, are prior to the claims of Caesar, which are temporal, it was reasoned, so the claims of the church are above the claims of the state. This position has been most closely identified with and persistently reaffirmed by Roman Catholicism. For Catholics, it has been rooted in the theological claim that Christ and His visible body, the Roman Catholic Church, are one. Since the Roman Catholic Church represents the perfect society—universal and divine, it can be neither coordinate with nor subordinate to the state. While desiring the cooperation and support of the state, Roman Catholicism has throughout its history sought to maintain the primacy of the Roman Catholic Church over all other authority, civil and temporal. This position has been fundamental in Roman Catholic thought concerning church and state and is essential to understanding Catholicism’s dualism of church and state. In Roman Catholicism, the Catholic Church and the state dare not be completely identified, but are two distinct elements in one divine plan.6 The very primacy of the Church prohibits true union with the state. Catholic historians and theologians, therefore, have consistently, and quite understandably, repudiated the oft-made charge of many non-Catholics that Roman Catholicism is committed simply to the union of church and state, thereby non-Catholics have often failed to comprehend the Catholic principle of the primaryor sovereignty of the Church. To be sure, this primacy of the authority of the Church is in spiritual matters—faith and morals—and not in secular matters such as economic systems or forms of government. Nevertheless, as the renowned Leo XIII declared in his Encyclical Immortale Dei of 1885: “Just as the end at which the Church aims is by far the noblest of ends, so is its authority the most exalted of all authority, nor can it be looked upon as inferior to the civil power, or in any manner dependent upon it.”7 The basic rationale of the supremacy of the Catholic Church over the state is to be found in the concept Libertas Ecclesiae—the independence, freedom, and true sovereignty of the Church. When the issue of discerning which matters are spiritual is clouded, the Church is to counsel with the state in determining the sphere of the Church’s authority. In case of conflict, the state should yield to the authority of the Roman Catholic Church, for the Church can never surrender this decision to the state. The independence of the state from interference by the Church is assured only so long as the state confines its temporal power to temporal matters, and does not infringe
Christianity and the State
27
upon the laws of God, the rights of the Church, and the spiritual interests of persons. Ambrose, Bishop of Milan in the fourth century, is generally credited with providing the foundation of Catholic thought on temporal and spiritual relations. All people, even the emperor, Ambrose wrote, are subject to the Church in spiritual matters, for in that realm laymen have no authority or competence. Ambrose vehemently rejected both the supremacy of the state over the church and the divine right of political rulers. Applications of Ambrose’s principle may be found in his acts of defiance against imperial authority, and in the exclusion of the Emperor Theodosius from the mass because of his part in a massacre in Thessalonica. Always the concern of Ambrose was for the Libertas Ecclesiae, or the independence of the church from the state. It was for the independence of the church from the state, Libertas Ecclesiae, Catholic historians have argued, that the See of Rome steadily increased in authority and prestige in order to maintain the spiritual autonomy of the Catholic Church against temporal rulers.8 Thus, in this way, Catholicism views the struggle of the Church with the state as a struggle of the Church for her liberty and against the Church’s identification with or subordination to the state. Even the struggle for unity became a struggle for liberty. The well-known Gelasian theory of church and state became the basis in the Middle Ages for asserting the primacy of the spiritual authority of the Catholic Church over the state. In 496 C.E., Pope Gelasius I wrote to Emperor Anastasius I, “There are two things, most august emperor, by which this world is chiefly ruled: the sacred authority of the priesthood and the royal power. Of these the priests carry the greater weight, because they will have to render account in the divine judgment even for the kings of men.”9 The ascendancy of the Catholic Church over the state reached its height after Charlemagne, particularly during the twelfth and thirteenth centuries. Nowhere is this supre-macy of the church over the state better epitomized than in the excommunication and removal from office of Emperor Henry IV by Pope Gregory VII. According to one prominent Catholic scholar, this supremacy of the papacy enabled the Catholic church to “fulfill its function of defending the essential independency of the Church.”10 The classic statement of the supremacy of the church over the state was provided by Thomas Aquinas, an eminent Catholic theologian of the thirteenth century. His views on the subject, as on other Catholic theological questions, remain widely influential within Roman Catholicism. Aquinas wrote: The highest aim of mankind is eternal happiness. To this chief aim of aim of mankind all earthly aims must be subordinated. This chief aim cannot be realized through human direction alone, but must obtain divine assistance which is only to be obtained through the Church. Therefore, the State, through which earthly aims are obtained, must be subordinated to the Church. Church and State are as two swords which God has given to Christendom for protection; both of these, however, are given by him to the Pope and the temporal sword by him handed to the rulers of the State.11
Shortly afterwards, Pope Boniface VIII, the last of the great medieval champions of the supremacy of the church over the state, provided still another formulation of the doctrine. Both the spiritual and the material sword, Boniface wrote, are to be “in
28
Church and State
the power of the Church. The latter, indeed, must be exer-cised for the Church, the former by the Church. The former [by the hand] of the priest, the latter by the hand of kings and soldiers, but at the will and sufferance of the priest. For it is necessary that a sword be under a sword, and that temporal authority be subject to spiritual power.”12 With such thinking it was inevitable that papal authority would ultimately seek absolute supremacy, in both temporal and spiritual matters. Papal supremacy in turn became papal infallibility. Thus, Leo XIII forthrightly declared in 1890: “The supreme teacher in the Church is the Roman Pontiff; union of minds, therefore, requires together with the perfect accord in the one faith, complete submission and obedience to the Church and to the Roman Pontiff, as to God himself.”13 Or still later, as expressed by Pius XII in 1954: “Hence, even though to someone certain declarations of the Church may not seem proved by arguments put forward, his obligation to obey still remains.”14 For this reason, no particular pattern of church-state relations or any specific form of civil government is of primary concern to Roman Catholicism. Rather, throughout Roman Catholic thought on church and state only one motif remains: absolute obedience is due only to the church, never to the state. The state which demands supreme loyalty or manifests political absolutism is therefore brought into direct conflict with the basic claim of the Catholic Church. The claim of the divine right of kings as well as rights based on the will of a government or the sovereignty of the people, not on natural laws, are rejected as arbitrary and the potential basis of totalitarianism by the state. For this reason, Heinrich A. Rommen wrote, “The Roman Church has been looked upon as the exemplary enemy of the [totalitarian] states from the early Roman emperors. . .down to modem totalitarianism.”15 The absolutizing of papal authority does not prevent one’s recognizing the positive contributions of the view of the supremacy of the church over the state through the centuries. It is this view that has produced determined efforts of the Catholic Church, even when not successful, to resist political pressures of nations to subjugate the Church to national control and subjugation. During the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, the Catholic Church has repeatedly spoken out against political absolutism and the totalitarian state. Both the claims of absolute sovereignty of rulers and the absolute sovereignty of democratic majorities have been vigorously denounced.
The Supremacy of the State over the Church Far more prevalent in modern history has been the supremacy of the state over the church. Indeed, the whole history of Europe since 1300 has largely been the story of the extension of the authority of temporal rulers. With the rise of modern nation states, the sense of nationality gradually replaced the old concept of Christendom, Mundus Christianus. Through early theorists, such as Marsilius of Padua and William of Ockham, along with the flowering of a new humanism through the Renaissance, a new political concept of the imperial authority of the state arose. The rule of Christian princes was greatly exalted, while ecclesiastical or papal authority diminished and waned, and, in fact, became greatly circumscribed. The result was that political absolutism largely replaced papal absolutism.
Christianity and the State
29
Catholic historians in particular have long viewed these developments as the real basis of the Protestant Reformation, especially of Lutheranism and Anglicanism. In both of these traditions, the church was nationalized and became subject to the state with a national synod or hierarchy responsible to temporal rulers. As one Catholic scholar observed, “What we call the Reformation was . . .the definitive triumph of secular authority in a struggle with the Church already centuries old. The Reformation was part of the process by which Europe was resolved into a series of independent, secular, sovereign States.”16 The subordination of the church to the state, with the church virtually absorbed by the state, and a resultant nationalization of religion in the form of a national church indissolubly linked to the ruling power of the state, is a change persistently made by Roman Catholicism in particular against Eastern Orthodoxy and, to some degree, against the Anglican and Lutheran traditions of European Protestantism. The authority of the state over the church, usually called Erastianism, has clearly and generally dominated the pattern of church-state relations in Europe since 1500. Frequently referred to as “the child of the Renaissance and Reformation,”17 Erastianism brought an end to the independent sovereignty of the church and made the church subordinate to the interests of the state. In some instances, the church was reduced to little more than a department of the state. There were those, such as Niccolo Machiavelli, who argued that the church should be completely absorbed into the sovereignty of the state. Although more peculiar to Protestant countries than to Catholic countries, the Erastian principle has been widespread, appearing in various nation states under different names- Etatism or Gallicanism in France, Febronianism in Germany, and Josephism in Austria. It is true also that Roman Catholicism, more than Protestantism, has vigorously opposed extreme nationalism and political absolutism. The Erastian doctrine held that the church, dependent upon the state, is to be controlled by the state, as to both doctrine and discipline. Advocated particularly by Hugo Grotius and the theologians of the school of Arminius, Erastianism insisted on the religious competence and religious power of the Christian state. “Whoever holds the territory, also holds religion,” meant that territorial sovereignty possessed a “supreme and absolute right over the church.”18 Therefore, Grotius maintained, “it is only his [the monarch’s] duty to suppress the false ones, either by lenient methods or by force.”19 Thus, religious liberty could be denied on political grounds. It was on this basis that the Edict of Nantes, originally issued by Henry IV, providing for the liberty of the Huguenots in France, later was arbitrarily revoked by Louis XIV, and a policy calling for the ruthless persecution of the Huguenots was instituted. Similarly, the Anabaptists were often ruthlessly persecuted. The Erastian character of Martin Luther’s thought may be seen in his address To the Christian Nobility of the German Nation in which he declared: “The secular government may organize the external policy of the Church as seems most convenient to it; it may do as it wills with the property of the Church; and the temporal authorities, if Christian, may even be recognized as ‘bishops’ with authority over the external affairs of the visible Church.”20 In this same work, Luther attacked the distinction made between layman and priest; Luther wrote, “A priest in Christendom is nothing else than an office-holder.”21 For the Magisterial Reformers,
30
Church and State
except for Calvin, Erastianism was based on the premise of the Christian state. During the sixteenth century, England provided a supreme example of the triumph of the ascendancy of the state over the church. As one leading Catholic scholar of the Reformation wrote, “No other Reformation was so completely bare of spiritual motives,”22 at least initially. The political ruler, Henry VIII, was declared to be “the Supreme Head of the Church of England.” Except for Calvin’s theocracy of Geneva, the Erastian pattern prevailed in Protestant Europe, and made serious inroads into Catholic Europe as well. In Russia, Peter the Great replaced the Patriarchate with a Holy Synod, completely subservient to the Czar. In the twentieth century, various forms of the supremacy of the state over the church have appeared under totalitarian regimes, on both the political left and the political right, where the church, when tolerated, is made to serve political ends or national interests. The Nazi state church of the 1930s is a dramatic recent example of the extremes to which the Erastian doctrine may go. Also in the former communist states of Eastern Europe, the basic mission and message of the church were expressly denied in order that the church conform to the state’s concept of religion, and this despite, except for Albania, constitutional provisions for freedom of worship. The continued assaults upon the claim of the catholicity of the church and the exercise of the prophetic role of the church to speak out on social issues, domestic and foreign, when in conflicts with “national interests” or national policy, even in Western democracies are ominous evidences of the assumed superiority of the state over religion.
The Christian State Although not characteristic of early Christianity during its first three and a half centuries, the goal of the Christian state has characterized a large part of Christian history during the past sixteen centuries. Even when not actualized by political decree or alliance, the concept of the Christian state has often been the ultimate goal of institutional Christianity and an important part of its mission. Most of Europe became Christian through the espousal of the faith by kings and rulers who thereby proclaimed their territories as Christian kingdoms. The legal recognition of Christianity by Constantine in 313 C.E. with the Edict of Milan, not only profoundly changed the character of Christianity, but gave birth to a new attitude of the church toward the state, which, in turn, altered the entire outlook of the church toward culture, society, and other faiths. This change is clearly reflected in writings of the early Church Fathers, such as Tertullian and Augustine.23 Unfortunately, Christianity, once the persecuted faith, then tolerated, gradually became by 346 C.E. the persecutor of rival faiths within the Roman Empire. Non-Christian temples were destroyed and the death penalty was imposed upon those who continued to offer sacrifices to pagan gods. The concept of the Christian state found classic expression in the corpus Christianum of Christendom, which under various names and guises has remained the goal of many zealous Christians, both Catholic and Protestant, who would make the church virtually coterminous with culture, community, or nation.
Christianity and the State
31
The view prevailed throughout much of the Middle Ages. With the establishment of the Holy Roman Empire by Charlemagne in 800 C.E., the concept was firmly held and, indeed, attained its ultimate expression. To be a citizen of the Empire was to be a member of the church, and to be a member of the church was the foundation of one’s citizenship in the Empire. Enemies of the church, such as heretics and sectarians, were regarded as enemies of the Empire. Non-Christians, such as Jews, were therefore aliens without any real citizenship. Civil and ecclesiastical authority were virtually indistinguishable. Hence, Jews were treated as a pariah people, without human status and without civil rights. Even though the validity of the concept of the Christian state was from time to time challenged, even by some within the church, such as Marsilius of Padua in the fourteenth century, the supposition prevailed and was generally accepted by the Protestant Reformers—Martin Luther, John Calvin, and Ulrich Zwingli—with only varying interpretations. To the Magisterial Reformers, the nation-state required religious unity. Any notions of a secular state or of religious pluralism were inconceivable. Church establishment was firmly rooted in the notion of the Christian state. The Peace of Augsburg (1555) provided the basic policy for determining which church was to be officially linked with the state: cuius regio, eius religio—whatever the religion the ruler, that would be the religion of the state. For the Magisterial Reformers remained committed to the Christian state, as had the Roman Catholic Church for centuries. Because of its acceptance of the concept of the Christian state, the Protestant Reformation brought neither religious toleration nor church-state separation. In Protestant countries, as during the Middle Ages, those who did not accept the authority of the established church were excluded also from the political community, with which the church was identified. Protestantism was forbidden in Catholic countries,24 Catholicism was forbidden in Protestant countries. The right of dissent was politically prohibited. As during the Middle Ages, Nonconformists were persecuted as heretics of the church and traitors of the state.25
The Secular State Finally, in contrast to the notion of the Christian state, there emerged the concept of the secular state. Whereas the emergence of the secular state is a phenomenon of modern history, the concept of the secular state reaches back through the centuries. Throughout its history, until the modern era, the idea of the secular state has been uniquely related to the history of Christianity and the state. Inherent in the view of the secular state is the clear separation of the spiritual and the temporal powers. The basis of the authority of the state is civil and natural law, not religious decree or divine law. One of the major architects of the concept of the secular state was Marsilius of Padua, a renowned Catholic thinker of the fourteenth century. In his great treatise, Defensor pacis, published in 1324, Marsilius vigorously challenged the claims of the supremacy of the church over the state and likewise rejected the notion of the Christian state or mundus Christianus. In this he
32
Church and State
made a sharp distinction between divine and human law. He insisted that the state must be based only upon law inherent in nature, and the church should not have jurisdiction over the state. Clearly ahead of his time, Marsilius held that laws derive their authority from the nation, and are invalid without its assent.26 Marsilius attacked not only the supremacy of the papacy within the Catholic Church, but he maintained that since Christ and the apostles did not claim temporal power, neither must the Church. Furthermore, divine law cannot be enforced by temporal compulsion, and only Christ is the judge of divine law. Because of the nature of the secular state, there can be no coercion in religious matters. “The rights of the citizens,” he said, “are independent of the faith they profess; and no man may be punished for his religion.”27 Although almost entirely ignored for two centuries, “Marsilius’s ideas were destined to have a profound influence not only on those who later were responsible for the Reformation, but also on the founders of modern constitutional history”28 Out of the Radical Reformation a new conception of the church emerged—the corpus Christi—the church of the redeemed, voluntarily committed to Christ, rather than the corpus Christianum of Catholicism and the Magisterial Reformation. Unlike the Magisterial Reformers, the Radical Reformers championed the principle of voluntarism in religion, which they clearly saw required nothing less than the complete separation of the institutional church from the state, the basic premise of the secular state. Their movement was predicated upon an uncoerced response to the gospel. This, they held, was essential for the esse of the true church. Thus, the use of coercion in religion was opposed. “A Turk or a heretic,” Balthasar Hubmaier, an Anabaptist, wrote, “is not convinced by our act either with the sword or with fire, but only with patience and prayer; and so we should await with patience the judgment of God.”29 The concern of the Radical Reformation was not individual or political rights as such, which came to be espoused later by John Locke, the Enlightenment, and John Stuart Mill, but in the establishment of liberty of conscience. Historians of Christianity, such as Roland H. Bainton, Franklin H. Littell, and George H. Williams, among others, have clearly shown, that the “left wing of the Reformation” was dominated by one common characteristic—the espousal of the separation of church and state.30 The subject of religion and the secular state will be specifically addressed in Chapter 6. NOTES 1. See Polycarp, Epistle to the Philippians, 12:3; Clement, First Epistle to the Corinthians, 41:1 .Numerous other references may be found, including even special prayers for the army; see Justin Apology, 1:17,3; Tertullian, Apology, 30-33,39; and Origen, Against Celsus, 8:73-75. 2. 1 John 5:19; for other similar New Testament evidences of this attitude toward the Roman world, see Luke 11:29; Acts 2:40; 3:26; and John 3:19; 7:7. 3. Tertullian, On Idolatry, XVIII, 1:100. 4. Lactantius, The Divine Institutes. VI, 17:24. 5. Tertullian, Apology, 50.
Christianity and the State
33
6. Pius XII, Ad Summi Pontificatus in Papal Thought on the State, ed. Gerald F. Yates, S.J. (New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts, Inc., 1958), 104-08. 7. Immortale Dei, in Yates, Papal Thought on the State, 15. 8. Cf. Douglas Woodruff, Church and State, Vol. 89 of Twentieth-Century Encyclopedia of Catholicism (New York: Hawthorn Books, 1961), 38f. 9. Quoted in M. Searle Bates, Religious Liberty: An Inquiry (New York: Harper and Brothers, 1945), 136. 10. Woodruff, Church and State, 38. 11. Quoted in Bates, Religious Liberty, 140. 12. Quoted in Henry Denzinger, The Sources of Catholic Dogma (St. Louis: B. Herder Book Co., 1957), 187. 13. Leo XIII, Sapientiae Christiane. 14. Pius XII, The Church’s Right to Speak on Social Questions in Yates, Papal Thought on the State, 137. 15. Heinrich A. Rommen, The State in Catholic Thought (St. Louis: B. Herder Book Co., 1945), 508. 16. Jerome G. Kerwin, Catholic Viewpoint on Church and State (New York: Honover House, 1960), 41-42. 17. See, for example, J.N. Figgis, Churches in the Modern State (New York: Longman, Green, and Co., 1914), 47. 18. John Bekinsau, De supremo et absoluto regis imperio (1546); quoted in Joseph Lecler, S.J., Toleration and the Reformation (2 vols.; New York: Association Press, 1960), 2: 338. 19. Hugo Grotius, De imperio Summarum Potestatum circa sacra (1647); quoted in Lecler, Toleration and the Reformation, 1: 312. 20. Leo Strauss and Joseph Cropsey, eds., History of Political Philosophy (Chicago: Rand McNally and Co., 1963), 287. 21. Quoted in Henry S. Lucas, The Renaissance and the Reformation (New York: Harper and Brothers, 1934), 443. 22. Lecler, Toleration and the Reformation, 2: 334; see also 2: 329-38. 23. Early in the third century, the oppressed Tertullian wrote, “It is not in the nature of religion to coerce religion, which must be adopted freely and not by force.” Years later, when the protagonist of the new orthodoxy, he declared: “Heretics may properly be compelled, not enticed, to duty. Obstinacy must be corrected, not coaxed.” Augustine, while a spokesman for orthodoxy in North Africa, an area then controlled by heretics, fervently pled for liberty of conscience, later with the triumph of orthodoxy, he repudiated the principle of liberty of conscience, by declaring that liberty is the privilege of
34
Church and State
truth alone, “for what is a worse killer of the soul than freedom of error?”; cf. M. Searle Bates, Religious Liberty, 137-39. 24. One exception was the limited toleration accorded the Huguenots in France up to 1685. 25. In England, for example, James I said of the Nonconformists, “I will make them conform, or I will harry them out of the land”. A Puritan leader of the House of Commons in 1629 declared, “Whoever shall bring in innovation in religion, or by favor seek to extend or introduce popery or Arninianism, or other opinions disagreeing from the true and orthodox church, shall be reputed a capital enemy of this kingdom and the commonwealth”; quoted in Wilbur K. Jordan, The Development of Religious Toleration in England (4 vols.; London: Allen and Unwin, 1932-1940). Even though England was many years ahead of the continent of Europe generally in advocating religious toleration, not until the Revolution of 1688 was religious toleration granted in England and even then limited tolerance was granted only to Protestant dissenters, not to Catholics, whose civil disabilities were not finally removed until 1829; see ibid. passim. 26. John Acton, The History of Freedom and Other Essays, (London: The Macmillan Co., 1909), 64-65. 27. Ibid., 65. 28. Leo Pfeffer, Church, State, and Freedom (Boston: Beacon Press, 1953), 17. 29. Henry C. Vedder, A Short History of the Baptists (Philadelphia: The American Baptist Publication Society, 1907), 212. 30. Cf. Roland H. Bainton, The Reformation of the Sixteenth Century (Boston: Beacon Press, 1956); Franklin H. Littell, The Anabaptist View of the State (Boston: Starr King Press, 1952) and The Free Church (Boston: Starr King Press, 1957); and George H. Williams, The Radical Reformation (Philadelphia: The Westminster Press, 1962).
Chapter 4 Religion and the State in Other Religions As noted earlier, religion and the state were indistinguishable or intertwined in the ancient world, and only gradually became distinguishable primarily with the emergence of Christianity and the modern secular state. Even today, in many parts of the world, one’s ethnicity or nationality is closely identified with one’s religion or church. The religions of Hinduism, Sikhism, and Shinto have long served to identify one’s ethnic or national identity and actually fostered a sense of their peoplehood among adherents. Even those religions which claim universality in the modern world—Buddhism, Christianity, and Islam—came to be closely associated with particular civilizations—Asia, the West, and the Middle East. In many countries, even today, religion forms the basis of one’s nationality in which religion and nationality are so intimately linked as to marginalize those citizens who are not adherents of the prevailing religious tradition or sect. Since religion generally served as the basis of one’s identity as a member of the tribe, the community, or the nation, one’s religious identity virtually formed the basis of one’s differentiation from membership in another tribe, community, or nation and from the world at large. What is more, religion often became the root cause of intergroup conflict between tribes, communities, and nations—for example, Israelites and Canaanites, Christians and Romans, Sikhs and Hindus, Muslims and Jews, Eastern Orthodox and Roman Catholics, and Catholics and Protestants. In this way, religion fostered division and not unity, conflict and not concord, and at the heart of this division or conflict was each religion’s perception of the truth, whether based upon its claims of prophetic revelation, some mystical experience(s), or a rational apprehension of existence. The very historical particularity of religion did not make for tolerance, let alone freedom of religion, outside of one’s own
36
Church and State
religious tradition. Each religion generally claimed, or at least assumed, a uniqueness or superiority of its own even when it maintained a posture of inclusivity and embraced some form of syncretism in its philosophical or theological propositions of truth, while retaining its close ties to a particular country or civilization. Virtually all of the major religions of the world have had long and intimateassociation with political power, even when the early history of the religion in question, as in the case of Christianity, was marked by conflict and persecution by the state. At the same time, it should be noted that there are explicit teachings of tolerance and condemnation of religious coercion and disrespect for religious views other than one’s own are to be found in the scriptures of the major world religions.1 Voices against intolerance and religious bigotry may be traced back even to the ancient world. Today, these voices could well provide support for constitutional and legal provisions throughout the world in both national and international law. Furthermore, these teachings from the religions themselves may serve as helpful reminders to their adherents today of the need for greater tolerance and respect for religious adherents of other faiths, made all the more so in their increasing encounter with other faiths in the modern world. Obviously, these teachings from the major world religions need to be lifted from their historical and nationalistic expressions of the religions themselves, and serve as a call to their adherents to be true to the ethical norms and teachings of their respective faiths and thereby move them toward supporting greater religious tolerance and freedom on behalf of those of other faiths.2 Often claimed by Hindus as the mother of all religion, Hinduism has long been regarded as the molder and purveyor of Indian civilization and is widely viewed as embodying the soul of India. In one broad classification given to the religions of the world—tribal, national, and universal—Hinduism is classified as a national religion because of its indissoluble link to Indian civilization and nationhood. Hinduism formed the basis of much of Indian nationalism during India’s colonial and post-colonial periods and continues to form the core of the Hindu Nationalist Party. Since 1998, a politically motivated revival of militant Hindu nationalism has been on the rise in India. At the same time, Hinduism has long laid claim, and continues to do so, to its being the most inclusive and tolerant of all religion and rejects all claims of religious exclusivity, a charge some Hindus frequently make, for example, against both Christianity and Islam. In the teachings of Hinduism intolerance and the denigration of the religious rights of other faiths are expressly condemned. Basic to the Hindu tradition is the declaration, “Truth is One; sages call it by different names.”3 Or again, from Hindu Sacred Writings, “Ignorant is he who says, ‘What I say and know is true; others are wrong.’ It is because of this attitude of the ignorant that there have been doubts and misunderstandings about God. It is this attitude that causes dispute among men. But all doubts vanish when one gains self-control and attains tranquillity by realizing the heart of Truth. Thereupon dispute, too, is at an end.”4 The ancient Sacred Writings of Hinduism affirm not only that tolerance and respect are to be shown those of other religious traditions, but also these writings reason that tolerance and respect are rooted in the belief that there is good to be found in all religions. “Like the bee, gathering honey from different flowers,” Hindu Scriptures declare, “the wise man
Religion and the State in Other Religions
37
accepts the essence of different scriptures and sees only good in all religions.”5 In the words of one of Hinduism’s most renowned twentieth-century thinkers and apologists, Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan, “The faiths of others all desire to be honoured for one reason or another. By honouring them, one exalts one’s own faith and at the same time performs a service to the faith of others. By acting otherwise, one injures one’s own faith and also does disservice to that of others. For if a man extols his own faith and disparages another, because of devotion to his own and because he wants to glorify it, he seriously injures his own faith.”6 Founded in Northeast India by Siddhartha Gautama in the sixth century B.C.E., Buddhism came to embody the “Middle Way,” a path between a life of sensuality and extreme asceticism through a distinteredness and detachment from the normal desires of this world. While Buddhism began as a reform movement within Hinduism, the founder’s rejection of caste, a fundamental concept in Hinduism, along with other differences, inexorably destined Buddhism’s break with Hinduism. Until the coming to power of the Emperor Asoka in the third century B.C.E., Buddhism remained a minor religious sect with most of its adherents confined to North India. After some notable gains in India during the time of Asoka, Buddhism gradually took root primarily in Southeast and East Asia where it flourished and subsequently profoundly influenced the civilizations and countries in those regions. With his world-vision, Asoka, who has often been called the second founder of Buddhism, launched Buddhism’s missionary movement, sending Buddhist emissaries to Egypt, Syria, Crete, Greece, and Ceylon. Later Buddhist missionaries were sent to Burma, Southeast Asia, China, Korea, and, finally, to Japan in 552 B.C.E. With its remarkable geographical expansion, primarily through peaceful means, although clearly benefiting from political patronage and prestige, Buddhism gradually reached down to the common people. Buddhism was the first major religion to become international and to be based on the concept of a voluntary membership. One of the three so-called “missionary” faiths, its adherents today are to be found throughout the world and second in number only to Christianity and Islam. At its core, Buddhism has long been identified with a spirit of tolerance and respect for other religious traditions. Its teachings reflect a charitable attitude toward all religious views and Buddhist Scriptures encourage adherents.to be tolerant of other religions. For example, Gautama urged that his followers not bear ill-will toward anyone who spoke ill of him. Rather, Gautama declared, “If anyone were to speak ill of me or my doctrine or my Order, do not bear ill-will towards him, do not be upset or, perturbed at heart; for if you were to be so, it will only cause you harm.”7 Again, to quote from Buddhist Scriptures, “The Buddha says, ‘To be attached to a certain view and to look down upon other views as inferior—this the wise men call a fetter [i.e., a wrong].’”8 In teaching respect for all believers, Gautama declared, “If a man says, ‘This is my faith,’ so far he maintains truth. But by that he cannot proceed to the absolute conclusion: ‘This alone is Truth, and everything else is false.’”9 In the Sacred Writings of one Buddhist sect in Japan, the Omoto Kyo, is to be found the following: “There is not a single place in all the corners of the world where God is absent.”10 Buddhism has demonstrated throughout much of its history a spirit
38
Church and State
of tolerance and a respect for the religious human rights of those of other faiths. Founded in India by Mahavira, a contemporary of Saddhartha Gautama, Jainism is a radically ascetic religion, dominated by the principle of “ahimsa” (noninjury), reverence for life. Jainism has had a profound influence on the religious, political, social, and economic life of India, far out of proportion to its small numerical membership of between 3 and 4 million, or .05 of India’s population. In the Scriptures of Jainism, founded like Buddhism six centuries before Christianity, appears the following: “Those who praise their own doctrines and disparage the doctrines of others do not solve any problem.”11 Jains are admonished in their sacred scriptures to “comprehend one philosophical view through comprehensive study of another one.”12 Or again, as Jain Scrip-tures declare, “All the doctrines are right in their own respective spheres—but if they encroach upon the province of other doctrines and try to refute their views, they are wrong.”13 Confucianism, called in Chinese, K’ung Chiao, “The Teaching of Confucius,” consists of a body of ethico-political teachings that became highly influential in the development of Chinese civilization. Linked to imperial ceremonies for many centuries, Confucianism was made the official cult of the scholar-class and remained so until the fall of the China monarchy in 1912. For centuries, religion in China remained under the control of the emperor. Confucianism came to be established as the supreme authority of the state and at times intense persecutions erupted, largely stemming from political and economic rather than religious considerations. Both Buddhism and Taoism have experienced repeated periods of repression in China. Religious persecution in China, even today, has historically been based upon those beliefs and teachings that are perceived to be a threat to state orthodoxy. Nonetheless, as noted in other major world religions, regard for differing religious traditions is affirmed in Confucianism. “In the world there are many different roads,” Confucius wrote, “but the destination is the same. There are a hundred deliberations but the result is one.”14 Along with Confucianism, Taoism is one of the two world religions indi-genous to China and in its philosophical teachings enjoys a complementary relationship to Confucianism. Its date of origin is generally conceded to have occurred the same century as the founding of Judaism, Jainism, Buddhism, and Confucianism. For some time, it was common to place both Shinto and Zoroastrianism within approximately the same century, but more recent studies place Zoroaster, the founder of Zoroastrianism, more than 1,000 B.C.E. and the origin of Shinto is admittedly too obscure to warrant any approximate historical date. While popular Taoism is often viewed primarily as a folk religion with widely varying beliefs and practices, the philosophical component of Taoism provided a rich legacy to China’s intellectual heritage. Taoist writings, particularly the Tao Te Ching, which is attributed to Laotze who is credited with being the founder of Taoism, are the source of much profound Chinese philosophical thought. Respect for other religious traditions is reflected in Taoist scripture. One example may suffice: “Let some worship the Truthful One, and revere the Northern Constellation, while others bow before the Buddha and recite sutras. . . . Keep the heart always restrained by reverence and awe. Otherwise what can be the use of the recitation of sutras or the discourses of Confucius.”15
Religion and the State in Other Religions
39
Taoism flourished during those times when it was favored by various emperors; at other times when it was out of favor its secret societies were feared. Taoism flourishes today in Taiwan where it has proved to be very popular. Today, the five religions recognized in China—Buddhism, Taoism, Islam, Catholicism, and Protestantism—are officially designated as “patriotic” associations (e.g., “The Taoist Patriotic Association”). With this official recognition, the present government of China seeks to maintain rigid control over each of these five religions. The very designation, “patriotic,” given them makes clear that their recognition presumes a loyalty to the state, a long honored tradition with respect to religion and the state in China. All other religions that are not so recognized in one of these five associations are without legal standing. In China, religious persecution has generally followed whenever a religion is perceived as not being loyal or patriotic toward China and its rulers. Among the major religions of the world, Shinto (“the way of kami” or the gods) is a supreme example of a national religion. Indigenous to Japan, Shinto makes no claim of universality, since it is linked exclusively to Japan and the Japanese; it is without a founder, creed, or authoritative canon of scripture. Japanese tradition had traditionally dated its origin to the sixth century B.C.E., but, in fact, this native religion of Japan arose gradually out of myths and rituals of prehistoric Japan. With the arrival of Buddhism and Confucianism in Japan, Shinto took on a more formal and institutionalized character, which resulted in prescribed rituals around Shinto shrines. For more than a thousand years, Shinto and Buddhism existed side by side, resulting in what came to be called Ryobu or Dual Shinto (“the two-fold way to the gods). So strong was the influence of Buddhism that one scholar wrote, “Down to the Meiji era, Japan might fairly be described as a Buddhist nation . . . in the same sense in which certain western nations have been described as ‘Christian.’”16 The truth is that Shinto and Buddhism came to have a complementary relationship to one another. With the establishment of the modern Japanese state in 1868, Shinto was made the state religion and all Japanese citizens, whether Christian or of some other religious faith, were enjoined to respect the “way of the gods” by observing state prescribed rituals at Shinto shrines. All citizens were obligated to observe rituals at State Shinto shrines and state Shinto ceremonies. Since State Shinto was directly linked to the state, non-observance of State Shinto could not be tolerated, resulting in persecution for those who refused to participate in State Shinto ceremonies. The close association of Shinto with the state inevitably resulted in periods of intense persecution, including Christianity, and the expulsion of all foreigners. State Shinto reinforced the unity of Shinto and the state and, in effect, formed the basis of an intense Japanese nationalism from 1869 to 1945. State Shinto provided the stated mission of the nation, “the whole world under one Roof” as the basis for building an ever expanding empire. State Shinto advanced the concepts of an unbroken divine sovereignty of the emperor and an elite concept of the Japanese people and nation.17 With the defeat of Japan at the end of World War II in 1945, State Shinto was abolished and the separation of religion and the state was embodied in the new constitution. Sect Shinto continues without legal establishment. As in centuries past, however, most Japanese identify themselves with both Buddhism and Shinto.
40
Church and State
Founded by Zoroaster more than three thousand years ago in Persia, now known as Iran, Zoroastrianism is one of the world’s oldest living religions. It is also, in number of adherents, the smallest with only approximately 150,000 adherents. Monotheistic, and known by its followers as “the Good Religion of the Worshipers of Mazda,” Zoroastriansim holds lofty ethical teachings. It is one of the four world religions which originated in the Near East, along with Judaism, Christianity, and Islam. After the death of its founder, Zoroaster, it became the established religion of Persia and remained the dominant faith there until its virtual extinction after the conquest of Persia by Islam in the seventh century C.E. The influence of Zoroastrianism on Judaism is unmistakable, but Zoroastrian influences may also be found in Christianity and Islam. Increasingly faced were severe persecutions, following the triumph of Islam in Persia, Zoroastrianism gradually became almost extinct in the land of its origin. Today most of its adherents are to be found in India, in and around Bombay and in Gujarat, and a remnant remain in Iran. Judaism has a long history of identification with nationhood—the “promised land” and a people. The tradition of Judaism, however, has long contended for a universal view of God and the world. It was the covenant between God and Israel that became the basis of Jewish identify and ritual. Yet, for more than a thousand years, Jews were made subject to waves of foreign rulers—Assyrian, Babylonian (Persian), Greek, and Roman in spite of repeated efforts toward restoration of the Kingdom of Israel and to gain independence from foreign rule. Christianity arose out of Judaism during Roman rule. Gradually, even before the dawn of Christianity, Jews became know as the people of the Diaspora—the dispersal of Jewish communities in many distant Gentile lands. In Judaism, the very covenant which God established with Israel affirmed that God’s love is for all people, and, according to Jewish Scriptures, God purposed that through that covenant, “All the families of the earth are to be blessed.”18 In the Scriptures of Judaism, which are also viewed as Sacred Scripture by those in the Christian tradition, are these words: “For from the rising of the sun to its setting my name is great among the nations, and in every place incense is offered to my name, and a pure offering; for my name is great among the nations, says the Lord of hosts.”19 This theme appears frequently in the Jewish tradition to this day. In the Tosefta, Rabbi Joshua is recorded as saying, “There are righteous men among the nations who have a share in the world to come.”20 The ultimate ground for respect for all people in Judaism is to be found in its teachings concerning the infinite worth of every person or the sanctity of every individual life. Respect for divergent faiths is clearly and explicitly affirmed in the Talmudic writings of Judaism. “Just as the sin-offering atones for Israel,” Rabbi Yohanan ben Zakkai declared, “so righteousness atones for the peoples of the world.”21 “In the Mishnah are to be found these words, “Therefore, was a single person [first] created to teach thee that if anyone destroys a single soul. . . . Scripture charges him as though he had destroyed a whole world, and whosoever rescues a single soul. . . . Scripture credits him as though he had saved a whole world. . . . The Holy One has stamped all mankind with the die of the first man and yet not
Religion and the State in Other Religions
41
one of them is like to his fellow. Therefore, everyone is bound to say, ‘For my sake was the universe created.’”22 One of Judaism’s most beloved and respected scholars in this century, the late Rabbi Abraham Heschel, was fond of saying, “God’s voice speaks in many languages”—a view widely shared in Judaism.23 As stated earlier, Judaism has a long history of identification with nationhood—a land and a people. This deeply held tradition has found historic expression in this century with the establishment of the modern Jewish State of Israel. While Israel readily claims to be a Jewish state, religious rights are guaranteed to adherents of other religions, as in the case of Christians and Mualims. Islam, along with Buddhism and Christianity, is one of the three great missionary religions in the world and second only to Christianity in the number of its adherents. Within a hundred years after its founding in 632 C.E., Islam had spread throughout North Africa and Asia Minor, and threatened the conquest of central Europe. Most of its great geographical gains were made primarily by military conquest. While often identified with the Middle East, the place of its origin being Saudi Arabia, it should be noted that the largest two Muslim populations in the world today are to be found in Asia—namely, in Indonesia and Pakistan. In classical Islam, there is no distinction to be made between religion and the state, theology and law. All beliefs and doctrines, ethics and morality, social relations, including those between boys and girls and men and women, style of dress, hygiene, and good manners fall within the domain of Islam. In Islam, religion and law, religion and politics, are fused. Therefore, Islamic political theory is an integral part of Islam, which provide a blueprint for the ordering of society. Numerous volumes on Islamic political thought attest to this important feature of Islam. The recent resurgence of Islam, particularly in the Middle East, has resulted in a strong movement not toward what in the West would be conceived of as a state church but a church state, a state ruled by Islamic law or Shari’a. With the collapse of European colonialism, Islam has become the major force in fostering a new found and virulent form of nationalism throughout much of the Muslim world—a nationalism that is primarily aided and abetted by an animus toward the West and the presence of the State of Israel, in what had been for many centuries a traditionally Muslim world. Nevertheless, within Islam may be found lofty teachings of tolerance and respect for other religions. The Qur’an categorically declares that “there shall be no compulsion in religion.”24 The Qur’an further declares that belief is ultimately a matter of personal choice: “Proclaim, O Prophet, This is the truth from your Lord; then let him who will, believe, and let who will, disbelieve.”25 Tolerance toward other religions is explicitly enjoined on those who follow the Qur’an, as follows: “Revile not those deities whom the unbelievers call uponand worship.”26 Indeed according to the teachings of the Qur’an, Muslims should respect the believers and the teachings of all religions—even those not mentioned in the Qur’an, such as Hinduism, Buddhism, Jainism, and Confucianism.” According to Islam, a person’s freedom to choose is prerequisite to faith. Again, in the words of the Qur’an, “If it had been the Lord’s will, all the people on the earth would have come to believe, one and all. Are you then going to compel the people to believe except by God’s dispensation?”28
42
Church and State
The youngest of the major world religions, Sikhism has from its beginning in Northwest India in the fifteenth century been identified with the Punjab, where more than 85 percent of its adherents are to be found today. Influenced by both Islam and Hinduism, Nanak formed a distinct body of teachings which he made his own, declaring, “There is neither Hindu nor Mussulman [Muslim] . . . [for] God is neither Hindu nor Mussulman and the path which I follow is God.” 29 His teachings may be found in Scriptures of Sikhism. Nanak declared, “Search not for the True One afar off; He is in every heart.”30 According to Sikhism, people of God are to be found in all religions. The Scriptures of Sikhism declare, “There are those who read the Vedas and others—Christians, Jews, Muslims—who read the Semitic scriptures. Some wear blue, some white robes. Some call themselves Muslims, others Hindus. Some aspire to bahishat [Muslim heaven], some to swarga [Hindu heaven]. Says Nanak, Whoever realizes the will of the Lord, he will find out the Lord’s secrets!”31 One of the darkest chapters in the history of religion is the record of JewishChristian relations. For more than a thousand years the history of Christianity was marked by intense intolerance and persecution of Jews. The historical and theological juxtaposition of Judaism and Christianity offers in some respects strange paradox in the history of religion. On the one hand, no two faiths are more deeply rooted in a common historical and theological source, and, on the other hand, between no two faiths have there been greater misunderstandings, more intense hostilities, and more frequent conflicts. One of the supreme tragedies of Christian history is that Christian anti-Semitism, sustained by theo-logical arguments, has had such a long and permanent place in so much of Christian history. This tragedy, fed by centuries of virulent Christian anti-Semitism, reached its ultimate climax in the Holocaust carried out by the Third Reich of Nazi Germany. Admittedly, anti-Semitism is deeply and peculiarly rooted in Christianity, both in its theology and in its history. No amount of qualifying or rationalizing can alter the basic contention that anti-Semitism is directly linked to historic Christianity. Furthermore, attitudes and practices from the past still cast their shadows over the present in Jewish-Christian relations. Many studies in recent years have all too painfully served to confirm that the primary and ultimate cause of anti-Semitism, which has infected so much of Western history, is a religious one with roots going back through many centuries even, to early Christianity.32 The matrix of Christianity was Jewish, and, for Jewish thinkers at least, Christianity has been widely regarded, in a profound sense, as the daughter of Judaism. The twelve apostles were Jewish, nearly all of the followers of Jesus were Jewish, those who wept over his crucifixion by Roman soldiers were Jewish, and those who first carried the Christian Gospel to the world beyond Palestine were Jewish. The Christian Gospel was first preached, in Palestine as well as in Asia Minor, in the synagogues. Paul, the greatest interpreter of Christianity and its leading missionary during the first century, never ceased to regard himself as a Jew: “I myself am an Israelite, a descendant of Abraham, a member of the tribe of Benjamin.”33 The Scriptures, as well as most of the rites and symbols, of the early church were Jewish. Every aspect of the original apostolic proclamation was supported by an
Religion and the State in Other Religions
43
appeal to the Jewish Scriptures. The preaching of the apostles was first addressed to the Jews and expressed in Jewish theological terms. Among the earliest Christian writings are those of unmistakable Jewish character, written by Jewish believers, such as Testaments of the Twelve Patriarchs, Psalms of Solomon, Apocalypse of James, Apocalypse of Peter, and Epistle of the Eleven Apostles. Some of these early Christian writings, such as the Testament of the Twelve Patriarchs, were little more than a Christian revision of Jewish writings. The New Testament itself is preeminently a collection of the writings of Jewish Christians, and the Jewish Scriptures remain indispensable to the study and the interpretation of the New Testament; indeed, the Jewish Scriptures are presupposed throughout the New Testament. To the outside world, there was no real distinction between Judaism and Christianity before the end of the first century. For example, Suetonius and Tacitus, Roman historians writing in the second century, still regarded Christianity as a Jewish sect. The simple fact is that Judeo-Christianity, comprised essentially of Jewish or “Torah-true” Christians (those who remained faithful to Jewish observances such as circumcision, the Sabbath, and Temple worship), was the dominant form of Christianity throughout the first century and almost to the middle of the second century. First, under the leadership of James, the brother of Jesus, Judeo-Christianity was centered in Jerusalem until the city’s destruction in 70 C.E. The leadership of the early church up until the siege of the Jews by Hadrian, the church in Jerusalem was governed by fifteen bishops, all of whom were reputedly “Hebrews of ancient stock.” The early church in Jerusalem consisted predominantly of practicing Jews. Until the second century only a small minority of the Christian community was comprised of those from the pagan or Gentile world. The recovery of the Jewishness of Christianity has been called one of achievements of modern scholarship.34 While the Jewishness of early Christianity is undeniable, the conflict between Judaism and early Christianity clearly became evident in the early history of Christianity. After Jesus’ crucifixion, many Jews saw the status of Torah as the supreme authority threatened by the Christian claim that Christ, not Torah, represented “the way, the truth, and the life.” The “unorthodox” view of Jesus and his followers concerning Torah inevitably provoked conflict between Judaism and Christianity. Diaspora Jews, living as they did in a Gentile world, felt more resentful of and more threatened by Christianity’s view of the Law than did the Palestinian Jews. Stephen and Paul, for example, aroused far greater hostility from among the Jews of the Diaspora than from among the Jews in Palestine. In part, this was because Hellenistic Christianity outside of Palestine provoked far more hostility from the Jews of the Diaspora than did Palestinian Christianity among Palestinian Jews. The cleavage between Judaism and Christianity was also deepened by the claims of Christ’s Deity, the acceptance of which was a Jewish impossibility. As indicated earlier, whether or not Jesus was the Messiah did not constitute in itself a basis for Christianity’s separation from Judaism so far as Judaism was concerned, but the teaching of the early church concerning the Deity of Christ and the Incarnation was and remains to this day the great theological divide between Judaism and Christianity. The Christological formulations offered by the early church further
44
Church and State
offended the Jews who resented the fact that Jesus, a fellow-Jew, was declared to be God, a declaration which outside of trinitarian theology could only be interpreted as a direct violation of the First Commandment. Meanwhile, the rejection by the Jewish community of these Christological affirmations of faith concerning Jesus represented to the Christian community a direct repudiation of the central truth of the Christian Gospel. To Rabbinic Judaism, the claim of Christian “liberty” from the primacy of Torah could only be interpretedas blasphemy, and the Jewish acceptance of the Christian claims of Jesus as Christ and Lord could only mean apostasy. The question of Christianity’s remaining a Jewish sect inevitably arose with the coming of converts from the pagan world. Jewish converts to Christianity as a Jewish sect constituted no problem. However, the decision of the Council of Jerusalem in 49 C.E., which established the legitimacy of Gentile Christianity, represented a serious threat to the survival of Rabbinic Judaism since it raised serious questions about the validity of the Law for Gentiles. Basic Jewish rites and ritual requirements were abrogated for Gentile Christian converts, and later, according to Paul, even for Jewish Christians. In freely opening its doors to the Gentile or pagan world, without entry to Christianity through Judaism, Judeo-Christianity was destined to be eclipsed by the missionary expansion of Hellenistic Christianity. The repudiation of any obligation to follow basic rules and ritual requirements of Judaism meant that Christianity’s emergence as a separate movement was assured. The early schism which arose between Judeo-Christians (Judaizers) and pagano-Christians (Gentiles) resulted in an antipathy between Judeo-Christianity and Hellenistic Christianity. Rabbinic Judaism manifested a growing hostility toward Hellenistic Christianity during the first century, primarily over the threat posed by the abrogation of the Law but also probably because by the end of the first century Christianity was a rival of Judaism for the conversion of the pagan world and Judaism did not want to incur any additional political disfavor from its identification with Christianity By the end of the first century, at the Council of Jamnia in 90 C.E., Judaism had pronounced a curse on Christianity as an apostasy. To both Palestinian and Diaspora Jews, Christianity was a disavowal of Israel’s God and Israel’s Law. Similarly, Hellenistic Christianity increasingly manifested an antipathy toward both the Jews and the Judaizers, the Judeo-Christians. Christianity, which clearly began as a Jewish sect, gradually extricated itself from Judaism and became a Gentile movement, quite distinctive and separated from Judaism. While Christianity was an outgrowth of Judaism, usually referred to by Christians as “the fulfillment of Judaism,” Christianity in reality became a new faith. The developing conflict between Judaism and Christianity finally reached its climax of hostility in a Christian theological explanation of the crucifixion which declared that “the Jews killed Jesus.” The charge is one of the great ironies of history. The Jews are charged by Christianity, which began as a Jewish sect, with a crucifixion which was carried out by Romans against Jesus, a Jew, for a political crime. Ironically, and tragically, responsibility for the death of Jesus, according to early Christian tradition, was placed upon the Jews and not upon Pilate and certain Roman soldiers. As recent studies have shown, there is still a definite relationship between prejudice against the Jews and the theological charge that the Jews killed Jesus.35
Religion and the State in Other Religions
45
The gradual alliance of the church with the state, accompanied by the emergence of the Christian state and “Christendom,” posed a serious threat to Jews who for centuries after the fall of Jerusalem and the advance of Islam had settled in great numbers in “Christian” Europe. As religious aliens in a Christian state, Jews were subjected to repeated pogroms and expulsions—from England in 1290, from France in 1306, from Spain in 1492, and from German and Austrian cities during the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries. After the Middle Ages, the violent anti-Semitism of Martin Luther and the Counter Reformation, both aggravated by the refusal of Jews to become Christians in a Christian state, served to stimulate new waves of the Christian anti-Semitism which had by this time so long plagued Christian history. Suffice it to say, for centuries prior to the French Revolution, non-toleration of Jews was a familiar and integral part of the basic religious policy of the leading nations of Europe. Not until the emergence of political democracy, particularly the concept of the secular state, did it become possible to establish the legal equality of different religious faiths, which was further largely reinforced after the latter part of the eighteenth century by the separation of church and state and legal guarantees of religious liberty.36 The seeds of Christian anti-Semitism reached their ultimate and terrifying climax in the Holocaust of Nazi Germany in which more than 6 million Jews were killed in the heart of what was historically termed “Christian Europe. In a profound sense, the history of Jewish-Christian relations may be called a twofold tragedy: a Jewish tragedy marked by Christian theological denigration and falsification of Judaism, accompanied by Jewish martyrology, and a Christian tragedy in its manifest contradiction of the ethical truths of Christian faith and in its repudiation of Christianity’s Jewish historical and theological heritage. While the teachings of the religions hold special significance, at the same time it must also be acknowledged that the spirit of tolerance and respect for freedom of religion have not, by any means, been historically characteristic or descriptive of the religions themselves. Alas, none of the world religions has lived up to its own teachings with regard to religious tolerance and religious rights. The disparity between the teachings of the religions and their historical expression is simply undeniable. Admittedly, the sanctity of the rights of the individual person and the basic human right to religious self-identity have too often been flagrantly and repeatedly violated by the religions themselves. In fact the hallmarks religion’s history have been intolerance not tolerance, conformity not nonconformity, and assent and not dissent.
NOTES 1. Among recent publications that have highlighted this phenomenon, see: Leonard Swidler, Religious Liberty and Human Rights in Nations and in Religions (Philadelphia: Ecumenical Press, 1986; David Little, John Kelsay, and Abdulaziz Sachedina, Human Rights and the Conflicts of Culture: Western and Islamic Perspectives on Religious Liberty (Columbia: University of South Carolina Press, 1988); Arlene Swidler, ed., Human Rights in Religious Traditions (New York: Pilgrim Press, 1982); Leroy S. Rouner, Human Rights and the World's Religions (Notre Dame, Ind.: University of Notre Dame Press, 1988); Robert Traer, Faith in Human Rights: Support In
46
Church and State
Religious Traditions for a Global Struggle (Washington, D.C.: Georgetown University Press, 1991); Hans Kung and Jurgen Moltmann, eds., The Ethics of World Religions and Human Rights (Philadelphia: Trinity Press Inter-national, 1990); and David Cohn-Sherbok, ed., World Religions and Human Liberation (Maryknoll, N.Y.: Orbis Books, 1992). 2. The purpose here in citing the teachings from the Sacred Writings of the major world religions bearing upon respect for religious human rights is not to suggest that there is an essential oneness among the major world religions in their concepts of ultimate reality or that they snare a common world view or way of salvation. Rather, it should be understood that the selections from the sacred writings of the major world religions cited here are made solely because they reflect views of these traditions on religious human rights and the concept of religious liberty. As one Buddhist scholar, Phra Khantipolo, has rightly warned, “To try to steamroller every religion into the concept of basic sameness or ‘all-is-one-ness’ is to ignore facts in favor of a pre-conceived ideal.” For, Kantipolo concludes, “in trying to believe in everything, one does in fact neither believe anything sincerely nor understand anything thoroughly”; Pha Khantipolo, Tolerance: Study from Buddhist Sources (London: Rider, 1964), 35, 37. 3. Rig Veda Book 1, Hymn 164:46. 4. Srimad Bhagavatam 11:15. 5. Srimad Bhagavatam 11:3. 6. Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan, Religion in a Changing World (London: George Allen and Unwin, Ltd., 1967), 174. 7. Digha Nikaya 1:3. 8. Sutta Nipata 798. 9. Majjhima Nikaya 2:176. 10. Michi-no-Shlori. 11. Sutrakritanga 1.1:50. 12. Acarangasutra 5:113. 13. Siddhauna, Sanmatitarka 1:28. 14. I Ching, 2:5. 15. D. T. Suzuki and Paul Carus, trans., The Tract of the Quiet Way [Yi Chih] with Extracts from the Chinese Commentary (Peru, Ill.: Open Court Publishing Co. 1950), 723. 16. Henry Nelson Wieman and Walter Marshall Horton, The Growth of Religion (Chicago: Willett, Clark, and Co., 1938), 88. 17. See D. C. Holtom, Modern Japan and Shinto Nationalism (Chicago: University of Chicasgo Press, 1947}.
Religion and the State in Other Religions
47
18. Genesis 12:3. 19. Malachi 1:11. 20. Tosefta Sanhedrin, 13.2. 21. Talmud Baha Batra, 101. 22. M. Sanhedrin, 4:5. 23. Abraham Joshua Heschel, God in Search of Man: A Philosophy of Judaism (New York: The Jewish Publication Society of America, 1955), 142. 24. Qur’an 2:256. 25. Ibid., 18:29. 26. Ibid., 6:108. 27. See Qur’an 35:24; 40:78; and 22:67. 28. Ibid. 10:99-100; still another translation given ends with these words: “Wilt thou then compel mankind against their will, to believe?” 29. M. A. MacAuliffe, The Sikh Religion: Its Gurus, Sacred Writings, and Anthems, 6 vols. (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1909), 1:328. 30. Adi Granth, Rag Ramkali, 885. 31. There are those who would readily cite passages in the Scriptures of Judaism, Christianity, and Islam, in particular, that would appear to be contradictory to showing respect or even tolerance toward those of other religious traditions. The point being made here, however, is that there are sacred writings of the world’s religions that do affirm a respect for the religious rights of others. 32. Numerous such studies are cited in the “Bibliographical Survey” of Volume 2 of this work, but see, for example, Samuel Amog, ed., Antisemitism Through the Ages (New York: Pergamon Press, 1988; Nicholas A. Berdyaev, Christianity and Anti-Semitism (New York: Philosophical Library, 1954); Randolph L. Braham, ed., The Origins of the Holocaust: Christian Anti-Semitism (Leiden: E. J. Brill Publishing Co.,, 1986; Fred Gladstone Bratton, The Crime of Christendom: Theological Sources of Christian Anti-Semitism (Boston: Beacon Press, 1964); and Malcom V. Hay, The Roots of Christian Anti-Semitism (New York: Freedom Liberty Press, 1981); and Robert S. Wistrich, Antisemitism: The Longest Hastred (New York: Pantheon Books, 1992. 33. Romans 11:1.
48
Church and State
34. See, for example, Jean Danielou, S. J., Dialogue with Israel (Baltimore: Helicon Press, 1968). 35. Among many such studies, see the classic work, Bernhard E. Olson, Faiths and Prejudice: Intergroup Problems in Protestant Curricula (New Haven: Yale Unver-sity, Press, 1963). Although now quite dated, this volume was a report of the findings and insights derived from a massive Protestant self-study to show where religious education materials produced and used by the churches were a breeding ground for prejudice. 36. There are those who apply the separation of church and state not only to the democratic secular state in which freedom of organized religion is legally assured, but also to the totalitarian state, in which far from any institutional separation of religion and the state, there is rigid control, and in the case of the Marxist state, a sworn hostility toward all organized religion. In a totalitarian state, autonomy of religion, is severely limited and there is clearly no institutional separation, but rather an enforced subservience of all organized religion to the state and its national will, usually through some form of government bureaucratic control.
Chapter 5 Religious Tolerance and Religious Freedom In spite of numerous teachings on religious tolerance and religious freedom in the Scriptures of the major world’s religions, as noted in Chapter 4, tolerance, let alone regard for religious freedom, has not been characteristic of the religions themselves, quite to the contrary. The very nature of religious identity readily became the rationale of the separation of each religion from the world at large and the basis of intergroup conflict. Since each religion was rooted in a particular sense of the sacred, in specific ultimate concerns, the almost inevitable consequence, whether intended or not, did not make for tolerance. Rather intolerance and discrimination were often given religious justification. As was noted at the end of the previous chapter, intolerance not tolerance, conformity not nonconformity, and assent not dissent have been dominant motifs in the history of religion. More wars have been fought, more persecutions carried out, and more lives have been lost in the name of religion than probably for any other single cause. As one scholar aptly wrote several decades ago, “Nowhere does the name of God and justice appear more frequently than on the banner and shield of the conqueror.”1 Not only has religion formed the basis of wars between nations, but religious intolerance has also served to foster ethnic and racial prejudice and has often provided a rationale for political and social discrimination against nonadherents and nonconformists of religious majorities. Intrinsic to religion is the absoluteness of each religion’s perception of truth and the world. From his research as an historian of religion, Gustav Mensching concluded that “all world religions raise an extensive claim to absoluteness. Every one of them claims to be the only true and world faith and every one of them demands to be accepted as such.”2 Through the centuries, it was the absoluteness of the truth embraced by each
50
Church and State
religion, even when such intolerance was in conflict with its own scriptural teachings, that provided a religious sanction for intolerance and discrimination. Religion, operating as a matter of ultimate concern, virtually excluded for most adherents the right of freedom or dissent in matters of faith and practice. “All religions,” Ernst Troeltsch, in his historical analysis of religion, perceptively observed, “are born absolute because they . . . express a reality that demands recognition and faith, not only for the sake of its existence, but more yet for the sake of its validity.”3 This has been true not only of the great Near Eastern faiths of prophetic revelation—Judaism, Christianity, and Islam—which are by their very nature exclusive in character, but also of other great Asian religions of mysticism and rationalism—Hindusim, Buddhism, Confucianism, and Taoism—which are inclusive in their perceptions of truth. Even among the latter, however, claims of absouteness are to be found. As the founder of Buddhism, Saddartha Gautama, declared, “Having acquired enlightenment by myself, whom could I call my teacher? I have no teacher, one like unto me is not to be found. In the world with its devas (gods) there is no god equal to me.”4 One Buddhist text states, “There is no other way to gain salvation than through his [Buddha’s] teaching.”5 The absoluteness of each religious tradition has served to provide a religious foundation for the intolerance of other faiths. From his years of study of religious persecution, Roland H. Bainton noted three prerequisites for religious persecution: “that the persecutor must believe that he is right”; “that the point in question is important”; and “that coercion will be effective.”6 While the causes or motives of religious intolerance are many and varied, they may be broadly summarized to include the following: the absolutizing of the faith of the persecutor; the insistence of the persecutor of the necessity of defending one’s faith; fear of the consequences to the religious majority of tolerating moral or religious error; abhorrence of heretical or unorthodox views; resistance to teachings that are perceived to be subversive because they threaten the prevailing pattern of political and religious authority; or the rival religiou’s identification with an alien or foreign power. These characteristics, deeply embedded in interfaith relations throughout the history of religions, have been manifestly present in the waves of persecutions carried out through the centuries in Christianity’s relations with Jews and Judaism, in the confrontations between Islam and Christianity, and in the conflicts between Catholics and Protestants, among many others. In the history of religions, intolerance and persecution have not been restricted to any one era or to any one religion. Among numerous examples are: the persecution of the adherents of Amon of Ikhnaton (Ahmenhotep IV) by the religious establishment of Egypt, of the Canaanites by the Israelites, of Jews and the early Christians by the Romans, of Buddhists by Shintoists, of Sufis by Orthodox Muslims, of Protestants by Catholics, and Catholic by Protestants, of Anabaptists by Lutherans, of sectarians by Eastern Orthodoxy, of “witches” and Quakers by Puritans in early Massachusetts, and of religious dissenters generally by the religious establishment. Among the religions of the world, tolerance has not come easily. The religious identity of the nation with a particular religion has also often contributed to religious intolerance, since to be a dissenter of the established
Religious Tolerance and Religious Freedom
51
religion might cast doubt as to one’s loyalty to the state. The intolerance of ancient Israel toward foreign religious cults stemmed from their threat to the religious identity and unity of Israel, just as in ancient Greece to avow atheism was to manifest disloyalty to the state gods and, therefore, atheism was met with court trials and legal action against such persons as adversaries of the state. As long as religions were tribal or national in character, tolerance of another religion within the tribe or the nation could not be countenanced since it would threaten the unity of the tribe or the nation, which had to be perserved in order to maintain the solidarity or unity of the tribe or nation. While an outward tolerance, i.e., acknowledgment of other gods and religions identified with other peoples, constituted no problem in the ancient world, veneration of foreign gods or criticism or dissent with respect to the religion of one’s own tribe or nation could not be tolerated. Even in ancient Greece, which was a relatively tolerant and syncretistic society, Socrates had to drink the cup of poison for having undermined belief in the Greek gods of the state religion. In undermining Greek religion, Socrates endangered the unity of the Greek state. Even Plato argued that if a person is guilty of “impiety” and not some childish levity, he should be put to death. Historically, as long as religion was identified with the state, religion was an expression of one’s patriotism and national loyalty. Any criticism of the religion of the state became a criticism of the state and hence could not be tolerated, since such criticism threatened the very foundation of the state. While unbelief was a denial of the religious identity of the state, alien religious beliefs endangered the unity of the state or empire. This concern for the unity of the empire, or later the emerging nation states, was recognized from ancient times and, indeed, throughout the world. In the West, it was quite pronounced during the Middle Ages as well as during the Reformation and post-Reformation periods. Because of the need to maintain the unity of the nation or empire, religious differences were met with intolerance and even persecution, since these religious differences were viewed as a threat to the unity and solidarity of the state. The Romans persecuted Christians not because the Christian faith lacked lofty religious truths or good moral teachings, but because Christians refused to worship the emperor of Rome. Christianity was a threat to Roman unity, to the sacred institution of Imperium Romanum. Christianity, deemed religio illicita by the Roman Empire, was subjected to intense and widespread persecutions. Later, with its change of status and new found power as religio licita, Christianity readily became the great persecutor of even those devout Christians whose views were thought to be in conflict with the official teachings of the established Roman Catholic Church and its ecclesiastical authority. Thus, following the legalizing of Christianity by Constantine with the Edict of Milan in 313 C.E.,7 within a few years after becoming the established religion, Christianity became the persecutor of all rival faiths within the Empire. Non-Christian temples were destroyed and the death pernalty was imposed upon those who continued to sacrfice to pagan gods. Heretics were punished more severely and treated with more stringency than the “heathen” within the Empire. This abrupt and radical change in the character of Christianity did not, however, go unnoticed, nor did it receive the approval of
52
Church and State
all the prominent church leaders of that age. St. Hilary of Poitier, for example, writing in 365 C.E., vigorously protested the persecution of heretics and deplored the role of the Catholic Church as persecutor, which he viewed as a revolutionary alteration of the true character of Christianity and its mission. The Church, he wrote, “was propagated by hunted priests, now hunts priests in her turn.”8 From this time on, for almost fifteen hundred years, the history of Christianity is replete with examples of intolerance towards dissenters who dared challenge the authority of the Church or who embraced teachings in conflict with the Church. As with other world religious, when allied with political power. toleration has not come easily for Christianity. Before the modern era, neither Roman Catholicism, nor Eastern Orthodoxy, nor Protestantism espoused toleration, as such, of religious minorities. Tolerance toward other religions was deplored because it was viewed as rooted in religious apathy or indifference. Meanwhile, the concept of compelle intrare, based upon Augustine’s distorted interpretation of the words of Jesus in the parable of the lord and his supper, “Compel them to come in,”9 came to be the solemn mission of the Church to save persons from themselves and to prevent them from leading others astray. St. Augustine, who at first argued for religious freedom when Christianity was decreed to be illegal, eloquently bequeathed to the Church the view that freedom is for truth alone, and that the denial of religious freedom is the denial of error for the sake of maintaining the purity of the Church. Sixty-eight imperial laws, ranging from expulsion and confiscation of property to death, were enacted against non-conformists within a span of fifty-seven years. As early as 385 C.E., Priscillian, a gifted theologian, was accused of Manichaeism. Although he repudiated the Manichaean doctrines, Priscillian was condemned to death along with several of his associates. With the establishment of the Holy Roman Empire by Charlemagne in 800 C.E., the concept of the Chistian state reached its ultimate expression. To be a citizen of the Empire was to be a Christian and a member of the Roman Catholic Church, and to be a member of the Church was the foundation of one’s citizenship in the Empire. Enemies of the Church, such as heretics and sectarians, were regarded as enemies of the Empire. Non-Christians, such as Jews, were, therefore, regarded as aliens without human status or civil rights. Again, religious dissent was viewed as a threat to the very religious identity as well as to the unity of the Empire. Throughout the Middle Ages tribunals were set up for the conviction and punishment of dissenters and heretics. The position of the Church became firm. Even so moderate and devout a churchman as St. Bernard of Clairvaux, who opposed the lynch law for heretics, maintained thst it would be better that heretics be cocerced by the sword than to be free to bring many others into their own error. Heretics must be caught and punished, St. Bernard declared, since they are, quoting from the Song of Solomon, “the little foxes that spoil the vines.”10 In apite of ecclesiastical dominance during this period, heresy and religious dissent steadily increased, and with it the resistance of the Church to religious tolerance or religious freedom. Whereas earlier the Roman Catholic Church had depended on the laws and power of the civil magistrates to carry out its punishment for heresy, in 1209, the death penalty for heresy was decreed, “according to Canon Law and State Law”—secun-
Religious Tolerance and Religious Freedom
53
dum canonicas et legitimas sanctiones. At the Lateran Council in 1215, Innocent III decreed the obligation of every Catholic to seek out and “exterminate” heretics. The faithful were urged to report even their own parents or children suspected of heresy. Still heresy continued. Two years after personally “seeing to it” that a group of heretics were burned at the stake in Rome, Pope Gregory IX formally initiated the Grand Inquisition, which he formally entrusted to the Dominican Order. Inquisitors were sent throughout Europe to establish tribunals which the people termed chambres ardenies or “burning chambers.” Inquisition tribunals continued to be held for more than six hundred years, as late as 1852, at least in Catholic countries. In Holland alone more than fifty thousand persons became victims of the Inquisition. Equally incongruous to the original teachings of Christianity as the Inquisition, were the Crusades during the eleventh, twelfth, and thirteenth centuries. Inaugurated by Pope Urban II, the call to arms in the First Crusade, as in the seven major crusades which followed, was a war against infidels because “God wills it.” Its purpose, by means of military expedition, was to recapture the Holy Land and extend the rule of the Christian faith eastward. While profoundly significant in the subsequent history of Western civilization—in art, literature, learning, commerce, and international relations—the Crusades became a serious blight on organized Christianity. The real motto of the Crusades became “Kill the infidels.” In the final analysis, the Crusades presented the spectacle of the most extreme acts of avarice and economic exploitation, human cruelty and slaughter, and religious bigotry and oppression, carried out and done in the name of Christianity. Meanwhile, some churchmen, such as Peter of Cluny and Peter the Hermit, asked, Why wait for the infidels in the Holy Land? We have infidels right here—the Jews. Innumerable Jews and Jewish settlements in Austria, England, France, Germany, Italy, and Spain were wiped out. It has been estimated that the Frist Crusade alone resulted in the massacre of more than twelve thousand Jews. During the Middle Ages the Jews were reduced to a pariah people, without human or civil rights. As religious aliens in a Christian state, as noted earlier, Jews were for centuries subject to repeated pogroms and expulsions throughout Europe. Almost wherever religion enjoyed political patronage, prestige, and power, it resisted the granting of religious tolerance, let alone religious freedom, to religions or sects in conflict with its own teachings and perceived truths. Historically, even up to the present day, religious toleration and religious freedom have been primarily the concern of disinherited religious minorities, not established religious majorities. The recurring phenomenon of the espousal of religious toleration in principle, on the one hand, and the denial of religious toleration in practice, on the other hand, in Christianity as well as in other religions, is one of the ambiguities in the history of religion. Chrisianity is, in fact, an excellent example of this paradox. Up to this point, the impression may be given that the struggle of Christianity with religious toleration and religous freedom was rooted almost entirely within Roman Catholicism. Such an impression is not intended or warranted in view of the facts of history. Classical Protestantism was no less authoritarian and opposed to toleration and freedom, as such, than was Roman Catholicism. If a seemingly disproportionate amount of attention is given in extended histories and
54
Church and State
treatises, as well as in so brief a general summary as this, to the Roman Catholic struggle with freedom, it should be remembered that up until the sixteenth century, Western Christianity must be viewed overall laargely in terms of the Roman Catholic tradition. Had Protestantism had a longer history, and during such a comparable period as 500-1500 C.E., its record might not have been altogether different from Roman Catholicism in its relationship to toleration and freedom. Contrary to popular belief, religious liberty was not a contribution of the Protestant Reformation per se. As Roland H. Bainton wrote, the Reformation actually “intensified persecution.”11 One Protestant historian of religious liberty wrote more than a half century ago: “The factors of intolerance in positions taken by Luther and Calvin, as well as the state churches within the Early Protestant movement, are notorious.”12 Another prominent Protestant historian of Christianity, William Warren Sweet, wrote as follows: There is a widespread notion among Protestant groups that the separation of Church and State, and thus religious liberty, was one of the immediate products of the Reformation; that the early Protestants were advocates of a large tolerance and that religious liberty was but the logical development of the principles held by all the reformers. Just where this notion arose is difficult to say, and no reputable historian of our own times would endorse it. Historically, of course, the exact opposite is true. The fact is that the rise of Protestantism was accompanied by an unprecedented outburst of intolerance and cruelty in which both Protestants and Catholics participated.13
To be sure, Martin Luther and John Calvin, as rebellious heretics of the Roman Catholic Church, at first pled for toleration of heretics and some measure of religious freedom. Later on, however, as leaders of the Protestant Reformation, as churchmen and not rebellious heretics, they became as authoritarian and resistant to the concept of religious toleration and religious freedom as Rome. Indeed, Protestantism in the sixteenth century continued with the burnings, beheadings, and drownings—i.e. the extermination of all dissenters and heretics—just as the medieval Roman Catholic Church had done. Both Luther and Calvin personally approved and sanctioned the death of heretics and sectarians. Many Protestant scholars have gone to great lengths to explain, if not justify, the historical situation which prompted Luther and Calvin to take such drastic steps against heretics. In all candor one must say that Protestant scholarship, in this regard, has not been unlike that Catholic scholarship which has sought to establish a similar historical interpretation indefense of such popes as Innocent III and Gregory IX, who vigorously sought to preserve the Catholic Church of their time against the potential threat of heresies and heretics. The fact remains, however, for whatever reasons, the Magisterial Reformers—Luther, Calvin, and Huldreich Zwingli—were not allies of religious toleration or religious freedom. Once Luther’s movement was established in Germany, Luther did not fail to demand the extermination of adversaries and heretics whom he called on the rulers to “smite, slay, stab, and kill.” To the Duke of Saxony, Luther wrote, “It will lie heavy upon your conscience if you tolerate the Catholic worship; no secular prince can permit his subjects to be divided by the preaching of opposite doctrines.”14 “Heretics are not to be disputed with,”
Religious Tolerance and Religious Freedom
55
Luther declared, “but to be condemned, unheard, and whilst they perish by fire, the faithful ought to pursue evil to its source and bathe their hands in the blood of the Catholic Bishops, and of the Pope, who is a devil in disguise. . . . all sectarians imperil public peace, and it follows that princes may punish them.”15 Calvin was no less tolerant than Luther. “If Calvin ever wrote anything in favor of religious liberty,” wrote Sebastian Castellio, a Protestant scholar and a contemporary of Calvin, “it was a typographical error.”16 Calvin’s close associate, Theodore Beza, contended that religious freedom was of the devil. Not only heresy, but criticism of religious authority, according to Calvin and Beza, were considered blasphemy and punishable by death. “God hath put the sword,” Calvin wrote, “into the hands of magistrates to suppress crimes against the first, as well as the second, tables of the law of God.” To deny the church the right to suppress dissent or heresy is to incur the guilt on oneself. Calvin declared, “Whoever shall now contend that it is unjust to put heretics and blasphemers to death, will, knowingly and willingly, incur their very guilt. This is not laid down on human authority; it is God that speaks and prescribes a perpetual rule for His Church.”17 The story of the martyrdom of Michael Servetus at the hands of Calvin and the town council of Geneva is well known. Before Servetus’s arrival in Geneva, to which he fled after his condemnation by the Inquisition in France for holding Anabaptist views, Calvin had clearly warned: “. . . if he comes, and my authority avails anything, I shall never suffer him to depart alive.”18 In his classic study of tolerance, Wilbur K. Jordan wrote of Calvin’s intolerance as follows: “No more arrogant or intolerant philosophy has ever been conceived by the human mind.”19 The references cited above are simply intended to show that Protestantism in its early history not only did not espouse toleration or freedom as such, but rather advocated coercion and physical violence, if necessary, to maintain its sway over the territories where it became established. It would be quite misleading, however, to infer from this brief historical summary that voices for religious tolelrance and religious freedom are not be found in the history of religion. Voices against religious intolerance and for religious freedom may be traced back even to the ancient world. In fact, voices for religious tolerance and religious freedom have a long history. Although the practice of religious tolerance emerged slowly, there are examples of religious tolerance in the history of religions that should not be overlooked: the religious tolerance shown Jews in their years of Babylonian exile and their return to Jerusalem under Cyrus the Great. The tolerance of Buddhism was often demonstrated in its encounters with other faiths. In China and Japan, for example, the geographical outreach of Buddhism resulted in its becoming thoroughly indigenous to those cultures, and, by and large, sustained harmonious coexistence with the national faiths of both countries with little conflict and discord on its part. “Buddhism was and is, on the whole, an outspokenly tolerant religion; this is documented by the fact that that wherever it has spread it has never tried to annihilate the original the religion, but rather has existed beside it.”20 Judaism has long contended for religious tolerance and religious freedom. For centuries, the missionary motive in religions has been largely disavowed by Judaism as incompatible with religious tolerance. Teachings of tolerance also
56
Church and State
have a long history in Christianity, although not often demonstrated by Christianity when allied with political power. Jesus preached against intolerance and religious bigotry.21 In Christianity, religious tolerance and religious freedom may be found, as with Judaism, in the affirmation that all of humanity is created in the image of God. Beyond that, Christian Scripture categorically declares that “God has not left himself without witness”22 and speaks of “the true Light which lighteth every man that cometh into the world.”23 Religious tolerance may be found also in Christian Scripture in the manner of God’sdealings with all human beings. Peter, one of the disciples of Jesus who became a leader of early Christianity, is quoted as saying, “God has shown me that I should not call anyone common or unclean.” “Truly, I perceive that God shows no partiality, but in every nation anyone who fears him and does what is right is acceptable to him.”24 The very invitation of Jesus throughout the Gospels is repeatedly conditioned with the words, “whosoever will . . .“ or “if you want to. . . ,” 25 words which by their very nature constitute an invitation born out of respect for the human will in matters of religious belief. God’s very approach to all of humankind is perhaps nowhere in Christian Scripture more clearly portrayed than in the last book of the New Testament, The Revelation, in which respect for the inviolability of the free will of every person is presented dramaticaly and unequivocally: “Behold I stand at the door and knock, if any person hears my voice and opens the door, I will come into his house and eat with him, and he will eat with me.”25 Recognition of the importance of religious tolerance and religious freedom was conceded by the early church fathers. Near the close of the second century, Justin Martyr, who argued for the principle of the logos spermatikos, namely that the seed of the divine word is also present outside of the Christian tradition, perceptively wrote, “Nothing is more contrary to religion than constraint.”27 In the third century, when Emperor Septimus Severus issued a decree in 202 C.E. forbidding conversion to Christianity, Tertullian wrote that freedom of religion is a fundamental right. “It is a matter of both human and natural law,” he declared, “that every man can worship as he pleases. . . . It is not in the nature of religion to impose itself by force,” but “should be adopted freely.”28 Almost a century later, and with considerable insight into the nature of religion, Athanasius declared, “It is not with the sword and spear, nor with soldiers and armed force that truth is to be propagated, but by counsel and sweet persuasion.”29 Similarly, Lactantius, the tutor of Emperor Constantine’s son, argued that “it is only in religion that liberty has chosen to dwell. For nothing is so much a matter of free will as religion, and no one can be required to worship what he does not will to worship. He can perhaps pretend, but he cannot will.”30 During the Middle Ages, when religious liberty existed virtually nowhere in Europe, Marsilius of Padua, a Catholic lawyer, eloquently argued in the fourteenth century that coercion is completely foreign to the nature of religion and that religious convictions by their very nature cannot be forced. No religious authority has the right to exercise coercion for religion and that religious convictions by their very nature cannot be forced. No religious authority, Marsilius argued, has the right to exercise coercion for compliance to religious commandments. “For it would be
Religious Tolerance and Religious Freedom
57
useless,” Marsilius wrote, “for him to coerce anyone to observe them, since the person who observed them under coercion would be helped not at all toward eternal salvation.”31 “For Christ did not ordain that anyone should be coerced to observe in this world the law made by him, and for this reason he did not appoint in this world a judge having coercive power over transgressors of his law.”32 “Even if it were given to the bishop or priest to coerce men in those matters which relate to divine law, it would be useless. For those who were thus coerced would not be helped at all toward eternal salvation by such compulsion.”33 As with earlier voices for religious liberty, Marsilius espoused religious liberty as a matter of principle and viewed religious liberty as an essential feature of authentic religion. Marsilius was perhaps the first to recognize the right of conscience both as a natural and a political right. Two centuries later, Desiderius Erasmus, the great Catholic humanist and irenicist, wrote similarly that the use of coercion is contrary to the nature of religion and, therefore, he argued for “the futility of persecution.”34 In a letter to John Carondolet, Erasmus wrote, “When faith is in the mouth rather than in the heart, when the solid knowledge of Sacred Scripture fails us, nevertheless by terrorization we drive men to believe what they do not believe, to love what they do not love, to know what they do not know. That which is forced cannot be sincere, and that which is not voluntary cannot please Christ.”35 Special tribute must always be given to the Radical Reformers who championed voluntarism in religion and its corollary the separation of church and state, that is the separation of religious affairs from temporal power and the denial of the use of temporal power in religious matters.36 The voices of the Radical Reformation for religious liberty were predicated upon the uncoerced response to the gospel. This, they held, was essential for the esse of the true church. Thus, the use of coercion in religion was opposed. “A Turk or a heretic,” Balthasar Hubmaier wrote, “is not convinced by our act, either by the sword or with fire, but only with patience and prayer; and so we should await with patience the judgment of God.”37 Although religious liberty in the modern world is deeply rooted in religious thought, it stems from the concept of “liberty of conscience,” a phrase of modern origin which came into use after the sixteenth century.38 Even though the Protestant Reformation, by and large, did not espouse the principle of religious freedom, it did represent a revolt against both established religions as well as political authority and, in turn, fostered the emergence of new nation-states and a new national spirit throughout Europe and Great Britain. As is well known, however, the Reformation was, first of all, rooted in a revolt against established religious authority. When his views of Christian Scripture were challenged by the ecclesiastical authorities of his day, Martin Luther proclaimed, “I cannot and will not recant anything, for it is neither safe nor right to go against conscience.” For, “I am more afraid of my own heart than the Pope and all his cardinals.”39Aided by the humanism of the Renaissance, a bold new spirit of freedom in religion appeared, which inevitably gave rise to the cry, “faith is free.” Gradually the principle of religious freedom was forthrightly affirmed, leading finally to an insistence upon “the competency of the individual under God in all matters of religion.” Religious liberty was proclaimed as both a natural and a divine right. Furthermore, it was argued, religious liberty
58
Church and State
demanded civil liberty and civil liberty required liberty of conscience. “Give me the liberty to know, to think, to believe, and to utter freely, according to conscience, above all other liberties,” wrote John Milton in his great work Areopagitica in 1644. In their plea for religious liberty, however, the Free Churches contributed greatly to the emergence of liberty of conscience as the basis for religious lib40 erty. In the words of Franklin H. Littell, “The most direct contribution of the Free Churches to the individual citizen, whether church member or not, was in the establishment of liberty of conscience.” As generally used then, as now, liberty of conscience claimed the inherent right of each person to follow the dictates of his or her own conscience without interference from civil authority or reference to popular opinion. In his monumental and trenchant work, History of Freedom, Lord Acton wrote that liberty of conscience is “the assurance that every man shall be protected in doing what he believes [to be] his duty, and against the influence of authorities and majorities, custom and opinion.”41 Throughout the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries churches, wherever they were established, were consistently conservative, if not reactionary, on virtually all social and political matters. Almost without exception the national church in each country was identified with the royalist and anti-republican traditions. The divine right of kings and the institution of the monarchy were expressly defended, while opposition was repeatedly directed against emerging democratic ideals and revolutions. In France, bishops allied with the nobility against the French Revolution. Popular government was generally denounced by the churches. As late as the nineteenth century, the Roman Catholic Church categorically and officially condemned the democratic credo. In 1832, Pope Gregory XVI in his encyclical Mirai vos castigated the “deadly and execrably liberty” of the press, and with it “the absurd and erroneous maxim, or rather insanity” of liberty of conscience, which he denounced as “madness” (deliramen-tum).42 Pius IX left no doubt about Catholicism’s unalterable opposition to democratic liberalism in his Syllabus of Errors, with its list of eighty heresies. In 1870, at Vatican Council I, Pius IX consummated the longest pontificate in history (1846-1878) with the dogma of papal infallibility, which in part must be understood against the rise of powerful nation states and the spread of democratic liberalism. While the emergence of religious freedom, although nowhere completely realized, is a relatively modern phenomenon, the concept of religious toleration and religious liberty, as has been noted, has a long, albeit tortuous, history. As was noted in Chapter 4, the notion of religious freedom is one to be found in the teachings of the great world religions, even though it has been far from descriptive of the history of the religions themselves. Even tolerance has not been characteristic of the history of religion generally. Rather, as also noted earlier, religion has often been the root cause of conflict between tribes, communities, and nations. In reality, however, the ultimate source of religious tolerance and freedom is to be found in the nature of religion itself. For this reason, it may be rightly argued that religious intolerance is antithetical to religion and is, indeed, religion’s worst enemy. To believe is a voluntary act. To be true to itself,
Religious Tolerance and Religious Freedom
59
authentic religion must wait upon the voluntary responses of persons who are free of coercion in order for religious faith to be genuine and to be true to itself. The voluntariness of religious faith has come to be increasingly recognized in contemporary religious thought.43 Reaffirmation of the voluntary character of religion has been clearly affirmed, for example, in twentieth-century Christian ecumenical thought. The World Council of Churches has on various occasions seen religious freedom as integral to the nature of religion and religious faith. “God’s redemptive dealing with men is not coercive. Accordingly, human attempts by legal enactment or by pressure of social custom to coerce or eliminate faith are violations of the fundamental ways of God with men. The freedom which God has given. . .implies a free response to God’s love. . . .44 In the words of Vatican II, “God calls men to serve him in spirit and in truth; hence they are bound in conscience, but they stand under no compulsion.”45 The heart of the matter is that for religion to be authentic, it must be a vol-untary, personal, and a free act; membership in a faith community is one of voluntary association. Faith is not faith if its voluntary character is abridged by coercion. As Augustin Leonard, a Catholic theologian, wrote, “An imposed faith is a contradiction in terms . . .faith must be free if it is not to destroy itself.”46 Recognition of religious freedom is fundamental to religious human rights and, indeed, to all other human rights. In the words of the late A. F. Carrillo de Albornoz, for some years the Secretary of the Secretariat on Religious Liberty of the World Council of Churches, “No intellectual ingenuity, no organized institution, no kind of compulsion and no power of persuasion can change the fact that God deals with men as free and responsible beings and that he expects from them an uncoerced response.”47 Or, as Albert Hartmann expressed it, “A person’s one and only means of learning God’s will is the voice of one’s conscience.”48 The right to religious identity and to a personal religious faith, including association with others of like faith, requires voluntariness. Authentic religion is undermined and vitiated whenever any form of external coercion is superimposed on the individual in matters of religious faith. The foundation of religious tolerance and religious freedom is to be found in the sanctity of the human person and respect for the inviolability of the human conscience, for together they constitute the basis of a limited state and a free and democratic society. The Preamble of the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948) rightly speaks of “the inherent dignity . . . of all members of the human family” and “the dignity and worth of the human person.” The Preamble, common to both the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (1976) and the International Covenant on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights (1976), declares, “These rights derive from the inherent dignity of the human person.” While the sacredness of personhood is widely acknowledged as the foundation of all human rights, it has particular meaning in the exercise one’s sense of the sacred, i.e., one’s religious faith. Søren Kierkegaard wrote with profound insight that “man is himself primarily and genuinely in his free choice.”49 The intrinsic worth of the human person is simply too sacred to be violated by religious coercion or enforced conformity, which are a denial of the dignity and worth of a person. If religion is to be accorded any real place or to have
60
Church and State
any real meaning in society, there must be legal recognition on the part of the state of the inalienable right of a citizen to decide matters of ultimate beliefs and commitment for oneself. As the World Council of Churches affirmed at the time of its founding more than a half century ago, “The nature and destiny of man. . .establish limits beyond which the government cannot with impunity go.”50 And as Vatican II also proclaimed, ‘The protection and promotion of the inviolable rights of man ranks among the essential duties of government.”51 To the established churches, non-conformity represented not freedom but a threat to the traditional order. The Anglican Church was long in the vanguard of the Tory reaction against democratic ideals. Unfortunately, in spite of certain eloquent and articulate non-clerical spokesmen within, national churches have generally not been identified with causes affecting the advance of civil and religious liberties. By the beginning of the nineteenth century, however, Protestantism, far earlier than Catholicism, was embracing democratic ideals and supporting many liberal and social reforms. The changes in Protestantism were in some respects the inevitable outgrowth of Protestant theology, particularly Calvinism, as in the case of opposition to the absolutizing of all human authority, political or otherwise. The growing alliance of religion and freedom, though still far from complete, was accelerated by the emergence of pluralistic societies resulting from constitutional governments and growing populations of various large ethnic and religious communities. Whereas democracy, as such, is no guarantee to religious liberty, a pluralistic society does provide, in the absence of any overwhelming single community of faith, the best deterrent to religious totalitarianism and the denial of religious freedom. The very disintegration of a united Christendom, or mundus Christianas, actually advanced the cause of religious toleration and religious freedom throughout the Western world. The espousal of religious liberty by various Christian denominations may, therefore, be as expedient in the modern world as the denial of religious liberty seemed to be expedient to the churches during the Middle Ages and the Reformation period. Political patronage to the churches has been in steady decline during the past century and a half. Outside the West, Christianity is represented by scattered, microscopic Christian groups in the midst of the great resurging non-Christian civilizations of Asia and the Middle East.Even the larger established churches in the West have felt the need to express concern for the status of Christian minorities which have emerged, particularly during the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, as a result of their far-flung missionary enterprises. Meanwhile, in the West, widespread defections from Christianity have caused the churches to come to be regarded as representing, at least in some countries, only small minorities in largely alien and hostile societies. There is today, for the first time in more than fifteen hundred years, a consensus among Christian churches themselves in support of the principle of religious freedom. The gradual endorsement of religious liberty by the various Christian communions, and thirty-five years ago by the Roman Catholic Church at Vatican Council II, is in part a glowing tribute to the faithful witness of the free church tradition. It is also be a acknowledgment on the part of the churches themselves of their
Religious Tolerance and Religious Freedom
61
recognition of the importance of religious freedom in a highly pluralistic world. In the Western world, liberty of conscience has been based upon two fundamental principles. First, freedom of conscience is held to be a natural and sacred right of all persons, inalienable, a domain which the true state must protect and into which it must not lightly intrude. Whereas, the final aim of religion is truth, the ultimate goal of the state is freedom, or what Baruch (Benedictus) Spinoza called, “the true aim of government.”52 The second axiom is that because conscience is a natural and sacred right, innate and universal, no person is to be above another in the freedom of its exercise. If religious freedom is to be realized, it must mean non-discrimination as between individuals because of their religious identity or belief and non-discrimnination as between the various communities of faith. As Lord John Acton, a leading Catholic thinker of his day, wrote more than a century ago, “The test of liberty is the position and security of minorities.”53 Religious freedom requires that one neither enjoys advanages nor suffers diadvantages because of one’s religion. In such a society, all persons are equal in rights as in duties, which human authority cannot take away in the case of the former, and to which it cannot add in the case of the latter. Inextricably bound to the sanctity of the human person is the concept of liberty of conscience. Recognition of the religious right of liberty of conscience means the acknowledgment of one’s right to believe or not to believe a religious dogma; to worship one God or many or not to worship; to be a member of a religious association or of none; and the “free exercise” of religion, without civil disabilities, so long as such exercise is not deemed to be detrimental to the basic fabric of society and the security of the state. By its very etymology, conscience refers to moral awareness or moral insight, by which one experiences the impulse to do right and experiences restraint from doing wrong. The very nature of religion requires that it be rooted in conscience, which theologians have termed a “gift” or the “voice” of God. Meanwhile, the problem of tolerance is one of the greatest problems and most urgent challenges now confronting the world. Bitter and violent confrontations over religion continue to characterize the world today. The action taken by the United Nations General Assembly, 15 November 1981, in adopting the “Declaration on the Elimination of All Forms of Intolerance and Discrimination Based on Religion and Belief,” while long overdue, was an important step taken by the family of nations. Admittedly, the adoption, without veto, was supported, however, by nations in which gross violations of religious tolerance continue to occur, sanctioned and supported by laws that are in clear violation of the UN Decalaration itself. At best, however, religious tolerance is by its very nature a negative term, since it implies permissility, i.e., the elimination of overt forms of discrimination based on one’s religion or belief. Tolerance does require, however, respect for religious differences and a person’s right to one’s own religious identity. To be sure, religious tolerance is prerequisite to religious freedom, but falls far short of what is conveyed in the use of the term religious freedom, which connotes that beyond mere permissibility that religion is a basic human right that waits upon the voluntary will of the individual. Of necessity, religious freedom includes not only the right of the individual but also the right of individuals to form faith communities in society.
62
Church and State
Religious freedom may be variously defined but in minimal terms it includes the inherent right of a person to worship in public or in private according to one’s own understanding or preference, to practice and propagate one’s faith, and to change one’s religion—all without hindrance or molestation. Although widely proclaimed today as an inalienable right of all minorities guarantees of full religious freedom are a relatively recent and an uncommon achievement in contemporary society. Religious freedom can never be secure if the state and state institutions, even if supported by the collective will of majorities, are allowed to ignore the rights of conscience. For recognition of liberty of conscience lies at the heart of a free and democratic society and is a check on political absolutism. As Henry David Thoreau wrote more than a century ago, “There will never be a really free and enlightened State until the State comes to recognize the individual as a higher and independent power, from which all its own power and authority are derived, and treats him accordingly. I please myself with imagining a State at least which can afford to be just to all men.”54
NOTES 1. Hubert Muller, Religion and Freedom in the Modern World (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1963), 52. 2. Gustav Mensching, Tolerlance and Truth in Religion (University: University of Alabama Press, 1971), 152. 3. Ernst Troeltsch, The Absoluteness of Christianity and the History of Reli-gions (Richmond, Va.: John Knox Press, 1917), 116. 4. Majjhima Nikaya, 26. 5. Yashomitra, Commentary to Vasubbandu’s Abhidharma-Kosha;; quoted in Mesching, Tolerance and Truth in Religion, 127. 6. Roland H. Bainton, The Travail of Religious Liberety (Philadelphia: West-minster Press, 1951), 11. 7. The Edict did not establish Christianity as the religion of the Empire, but it did grant Christianity legal status, along with other religions. 8. See Hilary of Poitiers, Contra Constantium imperatorem, PL 10,577-603. 9.Luke 14:23; see Augustine, Epistles, 110:10 and 185:24.. 10. Song of Solomon 2:15. 11. See Roland H. Bainton, The Struggle for Religious Liberty,” Church History 10 (1941): 95-124.
Religious Tolerance and Religious Freedom
63
12. M. Searle Bates, Religious Liberty: An Inquiry (Harper and Brothers, 1945). 422. 13. Willam Warren Sweet, Religion in Colonial America (New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1942), 320; see also Johann J. J. Von Doellinger, “Nothing is more untrue than the assertion that the ‘Reformation was a movement for freedom of conscience.’ The exact opposite is the truth,” in The Church and the Churches: or the Papacy and Temporal Power (London: Hurst and Blockett, 1868), 474. 14. Quoted in Bates, Religious Liberty, 156.. 15. Luigi Luzzatti, God in Freedom: Studies in the Relations Between Church and State (New York: The Macmillan Co., 1930), 118. 16. Sebastuab Castellio, Concerning Heretics, Trans. and ed. Roland H. Bainton (New York: Columbia University Press, 1935), 74. 17. Quoted in Bates, Religious Liberty, 157. 18. Ibid. 19. Wilbur K. Jordan, The Development of Religious Toleration in England 4 vols. (London: Allen & Unwin, 1932-1940), 2:203-04. 20. Mensching, Tolerance and Truth in Religion, 22. 21. For some examples of Jesus’ teachings against religious intolerance and religious bigotry, note the following: Matthew 8:5ff., 9:10-13, 21:12-45, 23:1-39; Luke 7:31-50, 9:51-56, 10:25-37, 15:1-32; and John 4:7ff., 21, 24, 48ff. 22. Acts 14:17. 23. John 1:9. 24. Acts 10:28b, 34-35 (New Revised Standard Version). 25. See, for example, Matthew 19:21-22. 26. The Revelation 3:20. 27. Quoted in Bates, Religious Liberty:, 137. 28. Ad Scapulam, 2; Migne, Patrolia Latina, 1:699; quoted in Joseph Lecler, 5.1. “Religious Freedom: An Historical Survey” in Religious Freedom, ed. Neopflytos Edelby and Teodoro Jimenez-Urresti, Concilium (New York: Paulist Press, 1966), 5. 29. Divina Instituta, 54; Migne, Patrolia Latina, 6:1061.
64
Church and State
30. Lactantius, Divina Instltuta, 1,5c 20; Migne, Patrolia Latina, 6:516.54. 31. Marsilius, Defensor Pacis, trans. Alan Gewirth (New York: Columbia University Press, 1956), II, ix, 2. 32. Ibid. 33. Ibid. II. v, 6. 8. 34. Quoted in Roland H. Bainton, Erasmus of Christendom (New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1969), 185. 35. Ep. 1334, 5 January 1523, in Opus epistolarum, 5:11.362-81; quoted in Concerning Heretics: Whether They Are To Be Persecuted and How They Are To Be Treated: A Collection of the Opinions of Learned Men, Both Ancient and Modern, ed. Sebastian Castellio and trans. Roland H. Bainton (New York: Columbia University Press, 1935), 34. Later in 1519, in response to Martin Luther’s dramatic public challenge at Wittenberg of the Roman Catholic Church, Erasmus wrote to the archbishop of Mainz, the following: “If he is innocent, I would not like to see him crushed by evil factions; if he is in error, I would like to see him cured, not lost. Such conduct would agree better with the example of Christ who did not extinguish the smoking flax, nor break the bruised reed”; quoted in Joseph Lecler, S.J., Toleration and Reformation, trans. T. L. Westow, 2 vols. (New York: Association Press, 1960), 1:116. 36. In his monumental study The Radical Reformation, George H. Williams concluded that “almost all of the Radicals [i.e., Radical Reformers] insisted on the utter separation of the church from the state and found in the willingness of the Magisterial Reformers (e.g., Martin Luther, Huldreich Zwingli, and John Calvin) to use coercive power of princes, kings, and town councilors, an aberration from apostolic Christi-anity no less grievous than papal pretensions”; see Williams’s The Radical Reformation (Philadelphia: The Westminster Press, 1962), 860. 37. Henry C. Vedder, Balthasar Hubmaier (New York: G. P. Putnam’s Sons, 1905), 86; see also Article 16 of “On Heretics and Those Who Burn Them,” in Balthasar Hubmaier: Theologian of Anabaptism, trans. and ed. H. Wayne Pipkin and John H. Yoder (Scottdale, Penn.: Herald Press, 1989), 62. 38. Thomas Helwys, A Short Declaration of the Mistery of Iniquity, fac. reprint ed. (London: Kingsgate Press, 1935), 69. Writing a century later in England, in a book which boldly set forth for the first time in the English language the right of universal religious liberty, Thomas Helwys argued that the nature of religion removed it from the jurisdiction of the civil ruler. 39. See The Reformation Writings of Martin Luther, 2 vols., ed. Bertram Lee Wood (London: Lutterworth Press, 1956), 2:155. 40. Franklin H. Littell, The Free Church (Boston: Starr King Press, 1957), 48.
Religious Tolerance and Religious Freedom
65
41. John Emerich Edward Dalberg-Acton, History of Freedom and Other Essays (London: The Macmilla Co., 1907), 3. 42. See the encyclical of Pope Gregory XVI, Mirai vos (Encyclical on Lame-nais), 1832; a full translation may be found in Charles C. Marshall, The Roman Catholic Church in the Modern State (New York: Dodd, Mead, 1928), 187ff. 43. See James E. Wood, Jr., “Religious Liberty in Ecumenical and Inter-national Perspective,” Journal of Church and State 10 (Autumn 1968): 421-36. 44. “Statement on Religious Liberty,” in The New Delhi Report: The Third Assembly of the World Council of Churches, 1961 (New York: Association Press, 1962), 159. 45. De Libertate Religiosa: A Declaration of Religious Freedom; see All Sixteen The Documents of Vatican II: Official Texts Promulgated by the Ecumenical Council, 1963-1965, ed. Walter M. Abbott, S. J. and trans. Joseph Gallagher (New York: Guild Press, 1966), 690. 46. Augustin Leonard, “Freedom of Faith and Civil Toleration,” in Tolerance and the Catholic (New York: Sheed and Ward, 1955), 113. 47. A. F. Carrillo de Albornoz, The Basis of Religious Liberty (New York: Association Press, 1963), 74. 48. Albert Hartmann, Toleranz und Christlicher Glaube (Frankurt-am-Main: Knecht, 1955), 5. 49. Søren Kierkegaard, Training in Christianity (1850); quoted in Niels H. Søe, “The Theological Basis of Religious Liberty.” The Ecumenical Review 11 (January 1958): 41. 50. The First Assembly of the World Council of Churches: Held at Amsterdam, August 22September 4, 1948 (New York: Harper and Brothers, 1949), “Declaration on Religious Liberty.” 93-95. 51. “De Liliertate Religiosa,” in Documents of Vatican II, 684. 52. See Spinoza’s, Tractatus-Theologica-Politicus (1670), Chapter 16, ‘The Basis of the State.” Spinoza vigorously defended the principles of religious toleration and opposed any established form of religion. 53. John Emerich Edward Dalberg-Acton, Essays in Religion, Politics, and Morality, vol. 3 of Selected Writings of Lord Acton, ed. J. Rufus Fears (Indianapolis: Liberty Fund, Inc., 1988), 493. 54. See Henry David Thoreau’s Essay on Civil Disobedience.
Chapter 6 Religion and the Secular State Although the emergence of the secular state is a phenomenon of relatively modern history, the concept of the secular state, like the concept of religious liberty, reaches back through the centuries. Throughout its history, until the modern era, the idea of the secular state has been uniquely related to the history of Christianity and Western civilization. Inherent in the view of the secular state is the clear separation of the spiritual and the temporal powers. The historical connection between religious liberty and the secular state is a direct one. Historically, it has meant the repudiation of the concept of the Christian state and stands, in effect, in contrast to the concept of the Christian state. Inherent in the view of the secular state is that the secular state is a limited state, one in which the authority of the state is limited to the seculum or temporal realm. Just as the state is independent of ecclesiastical or religious control so, in turn, both personal and institutional religion are essentially independent of state or political control. All claims of political authority as rooted in a divine right, whether of monarchs or some other institutional expression, are repudiated. All political authority is perceived as human and not divine, and all civil authority is, therefore, necessarily limited to the realm of the secular or temporal. All claims of a Christian state, a Jewish state, a Muslim state, a Hindu state, a Buddhist state, or a Shinto state are expressly denied as contrary to the very foundation of the secular state. While not hostile to religion, the secular state maintains a view of neutrality toward all religions and the religious beliefs of its citizens so long as they do not contravene the just civil laws of the state. A state committed to secularism—a world view which makes the world of the secular the ultimate reality—by its very nature is a denial of the very essence of the secular state, which is limited to the secular or temporal realm, and is, therefore, uncommitted with respect to what constitutes ultimate reality.
68
Church and State
The concept of religious liberty is integrally related to the concept of the secular state.1 There is both an historical and a philosophical connection between religious liberty and the secular state. Since the secular state is one in which government is limited to the secular (seculum) or temporal realm; the state is independent of institutional religion or ecclesiastical control and, in turn, institutional religion is independent of state or political control. It is a state that is without jurisdiction over religious affairs, not because religious affairs are beneath the concerns of the state, but rather, as in the language of the United States Supreme Court, because “religion is too personal, too sacred, too holy”2 to be subject to popular vote or the currently prevailing will of civil authorities. In application, the secular state stands as a bulwark for religious liberty by denying the right of the state to use political means for the accomplishment of religious ends or to use religious means for the accomplishment of political ends. Because its power is limited to temporal affairs, the relationship of the state to religion is one of neutrality, toward both the various faith communities and to irreligion—a state where citizens are neither advantaged nor disadvantaged because of their religion. It is a state where government is denied the right of domination over the institutions of religion and the institutions of religion are denied the right of domination over the state. Like religious liberty, the concept of the secular state reaches back through the centuries. Historically, it stands in contrast to the concept of national identity based upon a particular religious tradition, be it a Christian, Hindu, Buddhist, Shinto, Muslim, or Sikh state. What is more, the secular state requires that the authority and jurisdiction of the state be limited to the secular or temporal realm. In the case of the secular state, the basis of the state’s authority is civil and natural law, not religious decree or any claim of divine authority or divine law. All claims of a particular political authority as being based on a divine right, whether by a monarch or some other political entity, are expressly eschewed. Similarly, all claims of a particular nation’s being a religious state, divinely ordained, are to be viewed as incompatible with the concept of the secular state. As noted earlier, one of the major architects of the concept of the secular state was Marsilius of Padua, a renowned Roman Catholic thinker of the fourteenth century. In his treatise, Defensor Pacis(1324), Marsilius vigorously challenged the notion of the Christian state or mundus Christianus, and likewise rejected the claims of the supremacy of the church over the state. He did so on the basis of a sharp distinction, which, he argued, must be made between divine and human law. He insisted that the state must be founded upon law inherent in nature, and that the church should not have jurisdiction over the state. Clearly ahead of his time, Marsilius maintained that Laws derive their authority from the nation, and are invalid without its assent. As the whole is greater than any part, it is wrong that any partshouldlegislate for the whole, and as men are equal, it is wrong that one should be bound by laws made by another. But in obeying laws in which all men have agreed, all men, in reality, govern themselves. . . . He [the monarch] is responsible to the nation, and subject to the law; and the nation that appoints him and assigns him his duties has to see that he obeys the Constitution, and has to dismiss him if he breaks it.3
Religion and the Secular State
69
Marsilius not only upheld the notion of the secular state, he denied the right of the church to have or to exercise temporal power. He maintained that since Christ and the apostles did not claim temporal power, neither must the church. “For Christ did not ordain that anyone should be coerced to observe in this world the law made by him, and for this reason he did not appoint in this world a judge having coercive power over transgressors of his law.”4 Furthermore, he argued, divine law cannot be enforced or established by temporal power and that only God is the judge of divine law. Therefore, no form of temporal coercion may be used to enforce conformity in religion. Because of the nature of the secular state, which is limited to the temporal realm, and the very nature of divine law which cannot be coerced, there can be no coercion in religious matters. “The rights of citizens,” Marsilius wrote, “are independent of the faith they profess; and no man may be punished for his religion.” Of the state, he reasoned that “the source of law is to be found, not in any divine right of rulers, not in any superior wisdom of any class or society, but in the whole of its citizens.”5 Although the ideas of Marsilius on the secular state and religious liberty were almost entirely ignored for two centuries, “Marsilius’s ideas,” as one constitutional law scholar wrote, “were destined to have a profound influence not only on those who later were responsible for the Reformation, but also on the founders of modern constitutional history.”6 Two centuries later, out of the Radical Reformation, there arose a reform movement built upon the concept of the voluntary church, the church of the redeemed, corpus Christi, comprised only of persons voluntarily committed to Christ, rather than the corpus Christianum, or Christendom, in which membership in the church and the community or state were virtually made coterminous. This Left Wing of the Protestant Reformation furthered the notion of the secular state. For, unlike the Magisterial Reformers, such as Martin Luther and John Calvin, the Radical Reformers championed the principle of voluntarism in religion, believer’s baptism, and a voluntary or gathered church comprised of those committed to Christ, the corollary of which was nothing less than the institutional separation of the church from the state. The faith they proclaimed and its propagation were predicated upon an uncoerced response to voluntary religious witness. This, the Radical Reformers held, was essential not only for authentic religion, but also for the esse of the true church. In an admonition to Jacob Sturm of Strassburg, Caspar Schwenckfeld—many of whose spiritual descendants would later come to America—wrote in 1549 as follows: “Civil authority has no jurisdiction over the Kingdom of God; that government was divinely ordained for the sole purpose of maintaining an orderly life in human society, but has no right either to influence or to interfere with religious convictions; the individual is accountable to Jesus Christ as the head of the Kingdom of God.”7 Writing during the early part of which boldly set forth for the first right of universal religious liberty, nature of religion removed it from
the seventeenth century, in a book time in the English language the Thomas Helwys argued that the the jurisdiction of the civil ruler:
Our Lord the King is but an earthly King, and he hath no authority as a King, but in earthly causes, and if the King’s people be obedient & true sub-
70
Church and State jects, obeying all humane lawes made by the King, our Lord the King can require no more: for men’s religion to God, is betwixt God and themselves; the King shall not answere for it, neither may the King be jugd betweene God and Man. Let them be heretikes, Turks, Jewes, or whatsoever it apperteynes not to the earthly power to punish them in the least measure.8
Similarly, Leonard Busher, like Helwys an English Separatist, wrote in 1614 the following in opposition to the use of temporal power in religion. “It is not only unmerciful, but unnatural and abominable; yea, monstrous for one Christian to vex and destroy another for difference and questions of religion.”9 The concern of the Radical Reformation was not individual rights as such, which came to be espoused later by John Locke, the Enlightenment, and John Stuart Mill, but in the removal of the power of the state over religion. The Left Wing of the Reformation was dominated by one common characteristic—the espousal of religious liberty and the denial of the state’s jurisdiction over religion.10 The realization of the secular state—although long advocated by certain political and social philosophers, Anabaptists, and certain other religious groups—did not finally occur until the inauguration of the “lively experiment” of Rhode Island. Here, for the first time in history, under the dominant influence of Roger Williams, an essentially secular state was established, with full political rights guaranteed to all regardless of their religious beliefs, as Williams said, “for the good of the whole.”11 It was the principle of religious liberty that gave birth in the New World to the founding of “the first secular state of modern times.”12 The acknowledged architect of the American tradition of the separation of church and state, Williams sought to provide a theological basis for the secular state. The authority of the state, Williams argued, is “not religious, Christian, etc., but natural, human, [and] civil”; and therefore it is “improper” for the state to prescribe or proscribe matters of conscience and religion. “All Civil States with their Officers of justice in their respective constitutions and administrations are proved essentially Civil, and therefore not Judges, Governors or Defenders of the Spiritual or Christian State and Worship.” “Therefore,” Williams argued, “No civil state or country can be truly called Christian, although true Christians be in it.”13 Thus, Williams denied the right of any state to be Buddhist, Hindu, Jewish, or Muslim. To Williams, church and state must be separate not only for the church to be the church, but for the state to be the state, for God to be God, and for Christians to be Christian. “An enforced uniformity of Religion throughout a Nation or civil state,” Williams declared, “confounds the Civil and Religious, [and] denies the principles of Christianity and civility.”14 Consequently, Williams held that compulsory and tax-supported religion is unchristian, that biblical Israel is not a model state for Christians, and that equality of all persons and groups before the law is a fundamental responsibility of all civil government. Through John Locke, the view of the secular state was given still fuller expression, not on the Christian theological basis of liberty, but on the basis of natural rights, not upon mere popular or democratic sovereignty, but upon constitutional government. The starting point for Locke’s political thought was
Religion and the Secular State
71
not the state, but the individual. Every person is born with natural rights to life, liberty, and property. The authority of the state is derived from the consent of the governed, for example through mutual agreement or social contract, and is not subordinate to ecclesiastical power. The truth is that the state was created by individuals for their own conscience—for the protection of private property and the “execution of. . .laws. . .for the public good.” All laws, Locke reasoned, are always accountable to the citizens and political absolutism is “inconsistent with civil society.” Therefore, the power of all government is inevitably limited by the natural rights of a person as an individual.15 The direct influence of Locke on the American Founding Fathers is unmistakable and is nowhere more evident than in the Declaration of Independence, which is practically a verbatim restatement of Locke’s political philosophy. To Locke, the secular state is essentially a limited state, a view still held to be quintessential to the meaning of the secular state. Although the concept of the secular state exerted considerable influence in England and France during the Age of Enlightenment, the United States became the first nation in history to adopt the pattern of the secular state constitutionally, wherein government is prohibited from jurisdiction over religious matters, wherein all religious groups are equal before the law and are free from establishment or preferential treatment, and wherein all religious groups are regarded by the state as private and voluntary associations. To suggest that America constitutionally became a secular state simply because of the multiplicity of religious sects or because only a small percentage of the population were members of any organized religion is to fail to recognize the appeal and force of the secular state concept on the Founding Fathers themselves and in American constitutional law. Early American figures such as Benjamin Frankln, Thomas Paine, John Witherspoon, Isaac Backus, Thomas Jefferson, and James Madison, to name a few, bespoke in large measure of a wide consensus of the American people who were strongly opposed to the sanction and support of religion by the state. Franklin, a strong believer in the secular state, wrote of religion: “When religion is good, I conceive that it will support itself; and when it cannot support itself, and God does not care to support it, so that its professors are obliged to call for the help of the civil power, it is a sign, I apprehend, of its being a bad one.”16 This American commitment to a secular state represented on behalf of the Founding Fathers a bold experiment unparalleled in human history. The secular state is to be neutral both to religion and irreligion and recognizes its utter incompetence in all religious matters, a point of view repeatedly upheld by the United States Supreme Court for more than one hundred and thirty years. It seeks neither to promote nor to hinder religion, and views the individual as a citizen, and not as a member of a particular religious group. The concept of the secular state was not born out of hostility to religion, for hostility to religion is completely incompatible with the nature of the secular state. Rather the secular state is rooted in the inalienable right of conscience and the principle of voluntarism in religion. That there is tension, even conflict. between church and state—the religious and the political community—is not only inevitable, but may well be welcomed, for the person of religious faith should be especially aware that the tensions between the faith to which one is committed necessarily transcends the
72
Church and State
historical realities within any given nation-state. The conflict is one that can never be completely resolved. Meanwhile, the concept of the secular state is in harmony with both the freedom of religion and the freedom of the state. It may well be regarded as best for religion and best for the state, and secures the freedom of both. When properly understood, the emergence of the secular state should be seen as of major historical significance to the growth of religious liberty in the modern world. With respect to religion, the secular state is one which aims at protecting the religious freedom of both individuals and faith communities. As noted earlier in the initial definition given of the secular state, it is a limited state, one that is limited by inalienable human rights which stand over against the claims of the state. The denial of religious human rights, is beyond the rightful jurisdiction of the secular state. Acknowledgment of the secular state’s limited role in religious matters stems from its recognition of the sacred right of individual conscience as to be beyond the jurisdiction of civil authority or civil government. For this reason, for example, the American Constitution expressly forbids government from enacting any law establishing religion, whether in general or in particular, or from prohibiting the free exercise of religion. In the words of the First Amendment, “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.” Thus, the state is expressly prohibited from enacting any law establishing, advancing, or hindering religion—whether religion in general or in particular, whether one religious denomination or all religious denominations. Thomas Paine expressed a view widely shared by the Founding Fathers. Paine wrote, “As to religion, I hold it to be the indispensable duty of all government, to protect all conscientious professors thereof, and I know of no other business which hath to do therewith.”17 Religious liberty necessarily requires legal recognition on the part of the state of the ultimate human and sacred right of each citizen to decide matters of religious belief and religious identity—matters of ultimate concern. In his monumntal and trenchant work, History of Freedom, Lord Acton, a prominent Catholic thinker in nineteenth-century England, wrote that liberty of conscience is “the assurance that every man shall be protected in doing what he believes [to be] his duty against the influence of authority and majorities, custom and opinion.”18 A limited state recognizes that it cannot claim the ultimate loyalty of its citizens—a loyalty that is rooted in conscience and transcends all human relationships. The secular state is one that honors the right of religious dissent and the religious pluralism of its citizens. For, as Lord Acton wrote, “Religious liberty. . .is possible only where the coexistence of different religions is admitted, with an equal right to govern themselves according to their own several principles.”19 Recognition of this principle was acknowledged by U. S. Supreme Court Chief Justice Charles Evans Hughes. “In the forum of conscience,” Justice Hughes declared, “duty to a moral power higher to the state has always been maintained. The reservation of that supreme obligation, as a matter of principle, would unquestionably be made by many of our conscientious and law-abiding citizens.”20 For this reason, as Vatican Council II proclaimed, “The protection and promotion of the inviolable rights of man is a paramount duty of every civil authority.”21 Or, as the World Council of Churches affirmed at the time of its founding fifty-five years ago: “The nature and destiny
Religion and the Secular State
73
of man. . . establish limits beyond which government cannot with impunity go.”22 Freedom of conscience is integral to the secular state, and in the Western world, at least, freedom conscience has been based upon two fundamental principles. First, freedom of conscience is held to be a natural, inalienable, and sacred right of all persons, a domain which the true state must protect and into which it must not lightly intrude. Whereas the final aim of religion is truth. the ultimate goal of the state, as Baruch (Benedictus) Spinoza argued, is freedom.23 The second axiom is that because conscience is a natural and sacred right, innate and universal, no person is to be above another in the freedom of its exercise. All persons are equal in rights as in duties, which human authority cannot take away in the case of the former, and to which it cannot add in the case of the latter. Recognition of the right of freedom of conscience means the acknowledgment of one’s right to believe or not to believe a religious dogma, to worship one God or many or not to worship, to be a member of a religious association or of none; and to enjoy the “free exercise” of religion, without civil disabilities, so long as such exercise is not deemed to be detrimental to the basic fabric of society and the security of the state. More than a half century ago, United States Supreme Court Chief Justice Harlan F. Stone, in his dissent in the 1940 Gobitis case, wrote that if the Constitutional guarantees of liberty “are to have any meaning they must . . . be deemed to withhold from the state any authority to compel belief or the expression of it where that expression violates religious convictions.”24 For the state to intrude on the inviolability of conscience is for the state to assume a transcendency and an ultimate power that belong only to the Divine. Freedom of religion can never be secure if the state and state institutions, even if supported by the collective will of majorities, are allowed to ignore the rights of conscience, for recognition of freedom of conscience lies at the heart of a free and democratic society and is a check on political absolutism. As Henry David Thoreau wrote more than a century ago, There will never be a really free and enlightened State until the State comes to recognize the individual as a higher and independent power, from which all its own power and authority are derived, and treats him accordingly. I please myself with imagining a State at last which can afford to be just to all men.25
Not only the state, but any politically coercive power of religion must be denied if basic human rights and religious liberty are to be held to be inviolate in religious matters, and religious freedom is to prevail. That is to say, the secular state cannot permit its authority or civil power to be used to enforce religious belief or conformity, and cannot allow religion to use the coercive (secular) power of the state for the accomplishment of its work and witness in society. In the secular state, the right to religious liberty is not only guaranteed the individual in matters of religious belief and identity, but also for the corporate or group expression of religion as well. All religious groups have the right to organize, to manage their own affairs, to establish educational and welfare institutions as a part of their religious mission, and to give public witness to their faith. This freedom of association on the basis of religion requires the equality of all religions before the law. It denies the right of any one religion or community of
74
Church and State
faith to fulfill its own particular mission, while other faiths in the same state are denied that right. The secular state assures the right of all organized religions to act independently of the state without political advantage or disadvantage. Equality of all religions and irreligion before the law is an essential feature of the secular state. To grant certain rights or privileges to a particular religious community or tradition, while denying these same rights to other religious communities or traditions, is a denial of a fundamental principle of religious liberty and the secular state, no matter how limited that denial may be. Discrimination based upon one’s religious beliefs or identity is a contradiction of both religious liberty and the secular state. In the secular state a citizen’s religious beliefs or identity is made irrelevant to one’s rights and duties of citizenship. The holding of public office and employment in government service are made independent of a citizen’s religion. In all areas of one’s citizenship, religion is excluded from the citizen’s relationship to the state. Here it may be well to distinguish clearly the secular state from the secularism of the Marxist communist state, which is all too often wrongly identified as a secular state. With its sworn hostility to all religion and its totalitarian character, the communist state is in many ways the very antithesis of the secular state. It is by no means a limited state or one uncommitted with respect to religion or to ultimate allegiance, but rather the communist state is one committed to hostility toward all religion and will not countenance any institutional independence of religion from the state. When tolerated, all religion, far from enjoying institutional independence from the state is closely monitored and beholden to the state in making its decisions with respect to its community and organizational life. Unlike the secular state, the Marxist communist state is one that claims the right to regulate religion to ensure that it serves the political ends of the state. In such a relationship, the principle of religious liberty is clearly denied, to both the individual citizen and to the religious community. The secular state is one in which the institutions of religion and those of the state are institutionally independent—not because of any sworn hostility on the part of the state toward religion, but rather to allow religion and the state to function freely and properly in their respective areas of human activity, each fulfilling its own distinctive purposes and each employing its own methods. All religious communities exist as voluntary associations within the state and under the general civil and criminal laws of the state, but are free to formulate their own creeds and develop their own organizational structures, select their own leaders, found their own educational and welfare institutions, and finance their own activities without interference from the state. In turn, the secular state iswithout jurisdiction over religious affairs, except in areas where religion is institutionally involved and, as with other private voluntary associations, is obligated to operate in compliance with civil and criminal law. Even here, the state’s respect for the free exercise of religion may allow for some accommodations in civil law on matters relating to religious belief and practice. The secular state is restricted from deciding religious questions, such as the truth or falsity of a religious belief or to determine questions of orthodoxy or heresy, since its competence in this area is denied and its power over religion is severely limited. The secular state stands for both religious freedom as well as political freedom—in which
Religion and the Secular State
75
religion is free of control by the state and the state is free of control by religion. The emergence of the secular state, wherever it has occurred, has unquestionably aided the cause of religious liberty in the modern world. Therefore, the secular state should not be viewed as an adversary of religion, but as an ally of religious liberty. The secular state is one which religion should welcome. As one Christian scholar has written, it may well be argued the secular relevance of Christianity, it “has nowhere to stand except with the secular. It refuses to make an idol of religion. It makes common cause with the authentically secular without being permanently wedded to it. It believes in the secular not only as an instrument of divine providence and judgment but also a partner with the church in the work of reconciliation.”26 Persons of religious faith who are wary of the secular state in the modern world would do well to note that political absolutism and deification of the state come either from states that claim identity with a particular religion or from states which embrace an atheistic or anti-religious bias, both of which are incompatible with the secular state. History clearly warns that the concept of the religious state as well as the atheistic state is hazardous for true religion and for both political and religious liberty. Meanwhile, the emergence of religious liberty in national constitutions and international law augurs well for the secular state in which liberty of conscience, religious liberty, and all other human rights are guaranteed to all in both their individual and corporate expressions. Although the concept of the secular state exerted considerable influence in England and France during the Age of Enlightenment, the United States became the first nation in history to adopt constitutionally the pattern of the secular state, wherein government is prohibited from jurisdiction over religious matters or from “prohibiting the free exercise of religion,” there is to be no religious test for public office, all religious groups are equal before the law and are to be free from discrimination or preferential treatment, and all religious groups are regarded by the state as private and voluntary associations. The secular state is to be neutral toward religion and irreligion and is to recognize its utter incompetence in purely religious matters. Again, it seeks neither to promote nor to inhibit religion, and views one’s religious identity as being irrelevant to the rights of citizenship. More than one hundred and twenty years ago, in the first real churchstate case to come before the United States Supreme Court, the Court declared: In this country the full and free right to entertain any religious belief, to practice any religious principle, and to teach any religious doctrine which does not violate the laws of morality and property, and which does not infringe personal rights, is conceded to all. The law knows no heresy, and is committed to the support of no dogma, the establishment of no sect. The right to organize voluntary religious associations to assist in the expression and dissemination of any religious doctrine, and to create tribunals for the decisions of controverted questions of faith within the association, and for the ecclesiastical government of all the individual members, congregations and officers within the general association, is unquestioned.27
In the secular state, a citizen’s religious beliefs or identity is made irrelevant to one’s rights and duties of citizenship. The holding of public office and employ-
76
Church and State
ment in government service are made independent of a citizen’s religion. In all areas of one’s citizenship, religion is excluded from the citizen’s relationship to the state. All religious communities exist as voluntary associations within the state and under the general civil and criminal laws of the state, but are free to formulate their own creeds and develop their own organizational structures, select their own leaders, found their own educational and welfare institutions, and finance their own activities without interference from the state. In turn, the secular state is free of jurisdictional responsibility over religious affairs, except in areas where religion is institutionally involved in temporal affairs.The secular state is free from deciding religious questions since its competence in this area is denied and its power over religion is severely limited. The secular state stands for both religious freedom as well as political freedom—in which religion is free of control by the state and the state is free of control by religion. To be sure, the ideal of the concept of the secular state, like the concept of religious liberty as outlined here, has not been completely realized anywhere in the world, but neither has democracy nor human rights found perfect expression in any nation-state anywhere in the world. This much is clear, however, religious liberty and the secular state are indissolubly linked. The emergence of the secular state has unquestionably aided the cause of religious liberty in the modern world and, therefore, should not be viewed as an adversary of religion but as an ally of religious liberty. The secular state is one which religion should welcome. Persons of religious faith who are wary of the secular state in the modern world would do well to note, as previously stated, that political absolutism and deification of the state come either from states that claim identity with a particular religion or from states which embrace an atheistic or anti-religious bias, both of which are incompatible with the secular state. History clearly warns that the concept of the religious state as well as the atheistic state is hazardous for true religion and for both political and religious liberty. Meanwhile, the emergence of religious liberty in national constitutions and international law augurs well for the secular state in which liberty of conscience, religious liberty, and all other human rights are guaranteed to all in both their individual and corporate expressions.
NOTES 1. For a fairly recent treatment of this theme, see John M. Swomley, Religious Liberty and the Secular State: A Constitutional Context (Buffalo, N.Y.: Pomotheus Books, 1987); written within the American experience. 2. Engel v. Vitale 370 U.S. 431 (1962) at 432. 3. Marsilius, Defensor Pacis, trans. Alan Gewirth (New York: Columbia University Press, 1956) I, xii., 5. 4. Ibid., II, ix, 2.
Religion and the Secular State
77
5. Ibid., I, xii, 5. 6. Leo Pfeffer, Church, State, and Freedom (Boston: Beacon Press, 1953), 17 7. Quoted in Selina Schultz Gerhard, Caspar Schwenckfeld von Ossig: 1489-1561 (Morristown, Penn.: Board of Publication of the Schwenckfeld Church, 1946), 311-12. 8. Thomas Helwys, A Short Declaration of the Mister of Iniquity (fac. reprint ed., 1935), 69. 9. Leonard Busher, Religious Peace: or a Plea for Liberty of Conscience, in Tracts on Liberty of Conscience and Persecution, 1614-1681, ed. Edward Bean Underhill (London: J. Haddon 1846), 24. 10. This has been amply shown in the writings of Reformation historians; see Roland H. Bainton, The Reformation of the Sixteenth Century (Boston: Beacon Press, 1956); Franklin H. Littell, The Anabaptist View of the State (Boston: Starr King Press, 1952) and The Free Church (Boston: Starr King Press, 1957); and George H. Williams, The Radical Reformation (Philadelphia: The Westminster Press, 1962 11. See Roger Williams, The Bloudy Tenent of Persecution, for Cause of Conscience Discussed (1644), in Cornerstone of Religious Freedom in America: Selected Basic Documents, Court Decisions, and Public Statements, ed. Joseph L. Blau (rev. ed. New York: Harper and Row, 1964), 36-51. 12. Carl Bridenbaugh, Fat Mutton and Liberty of Conscience Society in Rhode Island, 1636-1690 (Providence, R.I.: Brown University Press, 1974), 5. 13. Williams, Bloudy Tenent of Persecution, 37; sec also James Ernst, Roger Williams: New England Firebrand (New York:: The Macmillan Co., 1932). 429. 14. Williams, Bloudy Tenent of Persecution, 39; see also Edwin S. Gaustad, Liberty of Conscience: Roger Williams in America (Grand Rapids, Mich.: William B. Eerdmans Publishing Co. 1991). .
15. See John Locke, Two Treatises of Government (New York: Cambridge University Press, 1989). 16. John Bigelow, ed., The Complete Works of Benjamin Franklin, 10 vols. (New York: G. P. Putnam’s Sons, 1887-1888), 7:139-40. 17. Thomas Paine, Common Sense (1776) in Thomas Paine: Collected Writings, comp. and ed. Eric Foner (New York: The Library of America, 1995), 45. 18. John Emerich Edward Dahlberg-Acton, History of Freedom and Other Essays (London: The Macmillan Co., 1907), 3. 19. Ibid., 152. 20. United States v. Mackintosh 283 U.S. 605 (1931) at 633.
78
Church and State
21. .”DeLibertate Religiosa:” A Declaration of Religious Freedom” in The Documents of Vatican II: All Sixteen Official Texts Promulgated by the Ecumenical Council, 19631965, ed., Walter M. Abbott, S. J. and Joseph Gallagher, trans. (New York: Herder and Herder, 1966), 675, 690. 22. “Declaration on Religious Liberty,” The First Assembly of the World Council of Churches: Held at Amsterdam, August 22-September 2, 1948 (New York: Harper and Brothers, 1949), 93. 23. See Baruch Spinoza, Tractatus Theologica-Politicus (1670). Spinoza vigorously defended the principle of religious toleration and opposed any established form of religion. 24. Minersville School District v. Gobitis, 310 U.S. 584 (1940) at 604. 25,Henry David Thoreau, “Essay on Civil Disobedience,” The Writings of Henry David Thoreau, 20 vols. (Boston, 1906), 4: 356, 387. 26. Gayraud S. Wilmore, The Secular Relevance of the Church (Philadelphia: The Westminster Press, 1962), 24-25. 27. Watson v. Jones, 13 Wall 679 (1872) at 728-29.
Chapter 7 Religion in International Affairs and Interfaith Relations Although freedom of religion was long advocated by individuals and religious dissenters, who at least sought religious freedom for themselves, freedom of religion was nowhere legally realized until the modern era and, even today, is far from being a reality in most of today’s world. As late as World War II, as one worldwide study declared, “No writer asserts that there is a generally accepted postulate of international law that every State is under legal obligation to accord religious liberty within its jurisdiction.”1 Today, however, the principle of religious liberty has come to be recognized as a an accepted postulate in international law. It is well to remember that historically pleas for religious toleration and religious liberty have come primarily from religious minorities and dissenters, the religiously disenfranchised and persecuted, and not from religious majorities who enjoyed state patronage and support. At the same time, it should be noted that the major advances toward the recognition of freedom of religion and conscience in the modern world have come not from religious confessions of faith, ecclesiastical councils or synods, but from constitutions, legislative bodies, and courts of law. After the Middle Ages, the emergence of new nation-states and a new national spirit weakened the political power of old religious establishments to a degree from which they generally could not recover. In widely varying degrees, guarantees of religious human rights have become inexorably linked to the modern democratic state. In the twentieth century, among both communities of faith and nation-states throughout the world, a broad consensus gradually evolved toward support of the principle of freedom of religion and conscience, at least in some form. Legal recognition of religious human rights has been particularly aided, both in principle and in practice, by international relations that resulted in the ratifica-
80
Church and State
tion of treaties between states. As one major study on religious liberty written more than fifty years ago declared, “International law and religious liberty grew in intimate association.”2 The study found that a substantial majority of the writers of general treaties on international law following the time of Hugo Grotius, long recognized for his work as a codifier of international law, specifically referred to freedom of religion in their documents.3 In the nineteenth century, with sovereign states identified with different religious traditions, it became common in the drawing up of treaties to include provisions granting the right of religious expression to the nationals of each contracting party in the territory of the other. Since these foreign nationals were identifiable by both their nationality and their religion, it was inevitable that specific safeguards came to be provided for freedom of religion and conscience, worship, and religious work “upon the same terms as nationals of the state of residence,” to use a phrase common to many of the international treaties with provisions of religious liberty. There are many examples of the role of international agreement in the advancement of religious liberty. “The Treaty of Berlin” in 1878 at the close of the Russo-Turkish War, with its provisions for the equal rights of religious minorities, has been called “the most important single expression of international agreement for religious liberty” prior to the post-World War I era.4 Similar guarantees of religious freedom were embodied in “The General Act Relating to African Possessions”5 and “The Minorities Treaties of 1919-23,”6 following World War I. Of special historical significance is “The European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms,” which declared that “everyone has the right to freedom of thought, conscience, and religion.”7 Still later, more than thirty-five nation-states in 1975 signed the Helsinki Final Act (i.e. “The Final Act of the Conference on Security and Cooperation in Europe”) in which religious rights were made an integral part of a major international agreement between thirty-five nations of Europe, Canada, and the United States. For the first time, religious rights were made an integral part of a major international agreement of nation-states. Principle 7 of the document gives special attention to “respect for human rights and fundamental freedoms, including freedom of thought, conscience, religion, or belief.”8 Meanwhile, more and more nationstates have voluntarily entered into constitutional and treaty commitments to secure religious liberty for their own citizens as well as for foreign residents. With the increasingly wide geographical distribution of adherents of the world’s major religions, the religions themselves have challenged those national policies denying religious rights to their own adherents and communities of faith. Soon after the organization of the United Nations in 1945, concerted efforts were inevitably directed toward the formulation of the principle of religious liberty as a fundamental right to which all member nations were to subscribe and in recognition of the vital relationship of religious liberty to relations between states. One of the basic principles included in the Preamble of the Charter of the United Nations is that of “the inherent dignity. . .of all members of the human family” and “the dignity and worth of the human person.” 9 All member nations, therefore, “pledged themselves to take joint and separate action in cooperation with the Organization to promote
Religion in International Affairs and Interfaith Relations
81
and encourage universal respect for the observance of human rights and fundamental freedoms for all without distinction as to race, sex, language, or religion.”10 In “The Universal Declaration of Human Rights,” adopted and proclaimed by the General Assembly within three years after the founding of the international organization, specific attention was given to one’s right to religion, and this right was placed alongside various other rights.11 Article 2 forthrightly affirms that everyone is entitled to all the rights and freedoms in the Declaration without respect to religion.12 Article 18 is expressly concerned with the right to freedom of religion. In minimal terms, it declares that “everyone has the right to freedom of thought, conscience, and religion; this right includes freedom to change his religion or belief, and freedom, either alone or in community with others and in public or in private, to manifest his religion or belief in teaching, practice, worship, and observance.”13 In various forms, this portion of the Declaration has been incorporated into the national constitutions of many nations throughout the world, particularly in the nations that have emerged since 1948. During the latter half of the last century, freedom of religion and conscience was given international recognition in the norms of international law and international agreements and in international ecclesiastical pronouncements. In 1948, the United Nations adopted “The Universal Declaration of Human Rights” (1948), in which it gave specific attention to religion as a basic human right. With this declaration, the United Nations explicitly affirmed freedom of religion and conscience as an international standard among signatory nation-states. The Preamble of the Declaration, as noted above, appropriately speaks of “the inherent dignity . . . of all members of the human family” and “the dignity and worth of the human person.”14 These are reaffirmed in both “The International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights” (1966)15 and “The International Covenant on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights” (1966). The latter declares, “These rights derive from the inherent dignity of the human person.”16 The former affirms that “everyone shall have the right to freedom of thought, conscience, and religion”17 and that “no one shall be subject to coercion which would impair his freedom to have or to adopt a religion or belief of his choice.”18 While the sacredness of personhood is widely acknowledged as the foundation of all human rights, it has particular meaning in the exercise of one’s sense of the sacred, i.e., one’s religious faith or beliefs. As Soren Kierkegaard wrote with profound insight, “Man is himself primarily and genuinely in his free choice.”19 After more than three decades of ongoing consultations. the United Nations Assembly in November 1981 adopted “The Universal Declaration on the Elimination of all Forms of Intolerance and of Discrimination Based on Religion or Belief,”20 in which the religious rights of “The Universal Declaration of Human Rights” were reaffirmed and expanded. The 1981 Declaration categorically declared that “no one shall be subject to discrimination by any State, institution, groups of persons or person on grounds of religion or beliefs.”21 Thus, at long last, freedom of religion and conscience was given explicit and unequivocal recognition in the family of nations as an inviolable and sacred human right. With the adoption by the United Nations of the “Declaration on the Elimination of All Forms of Intolerance and of Discrimination Based on Religion or
82
Church and State
Belief,” the United Nations went out of its way to note that such discrimination must be regarded not only as an “affront” to human dignity, but also a “disavowal” of the very principles of the Charter of the United Nations and a violation of the other freedoms guaranteed in “The Universal Declaration of Human Rights.”22 Religious human rights were acknowledged to be not only individual, but also corporate and social, since they include the rights of religious association and the free exercise of religion within a social context. In sum, religious human rights were perceived as the cornerstone of all human rights—civil, economic, and social—and quintessential for the emergence of a free and democratic state in which respect for both individual and social rights for all are assured. While there is a sense in which all civil liberties, as well with all human rights, both individual and social, may be said to be indivisible, religious liberty constitutes the cornerstone of all other civil and human rights. This is not in any way to diminish the critical role to be played on behalf of economic and social rights, as well as civil and political rights, in the overall worldwide struggle for human rights, for all human rights are inextricably interrelated. Rather, what is being acknowledged here is that freedom of religion and conscience is fundamental and integral to all human rights because of their grounding in the nature and sacredness of the human person. For this reason, this principle is increasingly advanced in modern jurisprudence as well as in much Christian ecumenical thought. As Franklin I. Gamwell has written in this regard, “The principle of religious freedom cannot be merely one constitutional principle among others, all implications taken into account, it is the only constitutional principle. One may even say that religious freedom is the constitution, in the same sense that other constitutional prescriptions are, properly speaking, stipulations necessary to the full and free political discourse that religious freedom constitutes.”23 Ironically, the very century that has witnessed the emergence of religious liberty and religious human rights as norms in international law and virtually universally recognized in principle has been, with the rise of the totalitarian state, the very century in which religious rights and religious liberty have been repeatedly and flagrantly violated on a wholesale scale throughout much of the world. For the first time in human history and for much of this century, governments have come into power with a sworn hostility to religion and expressly dedicated to the eradication of all religion. In minimal terms, totalitarian governments have demanded nothing less than the subjugation of all religion to the state, in which loyalty to the state is made the basis of any legal standing for religion. Although there is overwhelming evidence to indicate that basic guarantees of religious liberty are far from being realized in much of today’s world, with full religious liberty nowhere completely realized, the principle of religious liberty has increasingly become one of those axiomatic commitments that is almost universally recognized. In at least some modified form, the principle of religious liberty has come to be affirmed by virtually all national governments as a part of national law. Even if highly restrictive, some guarantees of religious liberty now appear in almost all national constitutions throughout the world. It is not too much to say that today it is widely conceded that freedom of
Religion in International Affairs and Interfaith Relations
83
religion is a basic civil or human right. For this reason, virtually all types of government throughout the world, even the most totalitarian, claim to be democratic republics, and make at least some claim of giving legal recognition to freedom of religion. It may well be said that freedom of religion has become a normative constitutional principle for virtually all modern nation-states throughout the world. Meanwhile, in more recent years new democracies of both old and new nation-states have come into being in which religious human rights are increasingly being recognized as crucial to a democratic state, as seen most recently in the debates on religious human rights surrounding the emerging democracies of Eastern Europe. Throughout the New Europe, for example, constitutional reform commissions have been involved in addressing questions of freedom of religion and conscience, along with a broad range of other human rights. In some countries, permanent standing committees have been named by parliaments to address ongoing questions relating to new laws on religion. While there are many complex and difficult questions yet to be resolved in the face of counter forces of resistance, the question of religious human rights has become, as never before, one of increasing importance to nations that are attempting to move toward democracy and freedom. Among the questions integrally intertwined with religious human rights are those of ethnic identity, which in many countries throughout the world is readily identified with the rights of religious minorities. The growing recognition of religious human rights in international law has been accompanied by broad ecumenical endorsements of religious liberty by the churches. More than a decade before “The United Nations Declaration on Human Rights” of 1948, an historic ecumenical conference was held in 1938 at Oxford University on “Church, Community, and the State.” Eight conditions of religious freedom were enunciated by the Oxford Conference as “essential . . . to the church’s fulfillment of its primary duty”: (1) “freedom to determine its faith and creed”; (2) “freedom of public and private worship”; (3) “freedom from any imposition by the state on religious ceremonies and forms of worship”; (4) freedom to determine the nature of its government and the qualifications of its minister and members and, conversely, the freedom of the individual to join the church to which he feels called”; (5) “freedom to control the education of its ministers, to give religious instruction to its youth, and to provide for adequate development of their religious life”; (6) freedom of Christian service and missionary activity, both home and abroad”; (7)”freedom to cooperate with other churches”; and (8) “freedom to use such facilities, open to all citizens and associations, as will make possible the accomplishment of these ends: the ownership of property and the collection of funds.”24 Six months later, under the auspices of the International Missionary Council, a conference was held in Madras, India, with 471 delegates from 69 countries or territories. Again, attention was given to the “minimum right of religious freedom upon which the Church should insist.” Of the seven volumes published from the Madras Conference, one entire volume was devoted to the subject of church and state.25 Up to this time, the Madras meeting was the most international and widely represented gathering of Christians ever held. On numerous occasions since World War II, international conferences, in-
84
Church and State
cluding those held even outside the West, have affirmed that “the most fundamental freedom is religious freedom.”26 For many reasons too numerous to be delineated here, freedom of religion and conscience has been recognized as the foundation of all other freedoms, and is fundamentally interrelated to all other civil liberties. In the words of the World Council of Churches, “Religious freedom is the condition and guardian of all true freedom.”27 Without freedom of religion, freedom of speech, freedom of press, freedom of assembly, and freedom of association are all endangered. Without recognition of freedom of religion and conscience, the very right of dissent is seriously threatened, if not denied. In the words of former Chief Justice of the United States Supreme Court, Charles Evans Hughes, “When we lose the right to be different, we lost the right to be free.”28 Respect for religious freedom is profoundly important in the state’s regard for other human rights and its view of the worth of its individual citizens. By respecting religious rights of its citizens, the state is giving substantive expression to its regard for the dignity and worth of its citizens. Such recognition is not only an acknowledgment of the state’s limited political authority, as against the claims of the totalitarian state, but such recognition is far more likely to result in a greater place given to other human rights, both civil and political, economic and social.It is entirely reasonable to argue in the words of the late A. F. Carrillo de Albornoz that respect for the highest values of loyalties of man (which are the religious ones) will be the final “test” and also the best guarantee of the respect for all other human values. If, for instance, a totalitarian state does not recognize even the most sacred sphere of religion, and the most intimate human autonomy, it will most probably not stop before other less important values and less intimate spheres. In this sense it seems perfectly correct to affirm that, if society does not respect religion and its liberty, one does not have any security that the rest will be respected.
With the convening of the First Assembly of the World Council of Churches in Amsterdam in 1947, a clear voice for religious liberty was sounded in a document titled, “Declaration on Religious Liberty.” The Assembly appealed to the churches “to support every endeavor to secure within an international bill of rights adequate safeguards for freedom of religion and conscience, including the right of all men to hold and change their faith, to exercise it in worship and practice, to teach and persuade others, and to decide on the religious education of their children,” and to “press for freedom of speech and expression, of association and assembly, the rights of the family, of freedom from arbitrary arrest, as well as other rights which true freedom. . .requires.” The very establishment of the Council was declared to be “to hasten international reconciliation through its members.”30 The Declaration further asserted that religious liberty is “an essential element in a good international order” and that “Christians, therefore, view the question of religious freedom as an international problem. They are concerned that religious liberty be secured everywhere. In pleading for this freedom, the Declaration declared, “They do not ask for any privilege to be granted Christians that is denied to others.”31 The WCC “Declaration on Religious Liberty” delineated four fundamental rights of religious liberty to “be recognized and observed for all persons without
Religion in International Affairs and Interfaith Relations
85
distinction as to race, colour, sex, language, or religion,” as follows: (1) “every person has the right to determine his own faith and creed”; (2) “every person has the right to express his religious beliefs in worship, teaching and practice, and to proclaim the implications of his beliefs for relationships in a social or political community”; (3) “every person has the right to associate with others and to organize with them for religious purposes”; and (4) “every religious organization, formed or maintained by action in accordance with the right of the individual persons, has the right to determine its policies and practices for the accomplishment of its chosen purposes.”32 Adopted unanimously, the Amsterdam Declaration remains a landmark in the history of religious liberty and must be credited with having considerable influence on the final adoption some months later of “The Universal Declaration of Human Rights” by the United Nations.33 Subsequent assemblies of the World Council of Churches have not only reaffirmed the Amsterdam Declaration but have continued to give voice to the Council’s commitment to religious liberty. In its Third Assembly in New Delhi in 1961, religious liberty was affirmed as a “fundamental right” of all persons everywhere. “Freedom to manifest one’s religion or belief, in public or in private and alone or in community with others,” the Assembly declared, “is essential to the expression of inner freedom.” Religious freedom, the Assembly said, includes freedom of worship in public or in private, freedom to teach and preach, freedom to practice one’s religion or beliefs in word and in deed, freedom of observance of religious customs and rites in public and in private, and freedom to change one’s religion or beliefs “without consequent social, economic, and political disabilities.”34 Religious liberty, the New Delhi Assembly emphasized, is not only a fundamental human right, but is one that is interrelated with all other human rights. Like the Amsterdam Declaration, the New Delhi Declaration was adopted unanimously. The World Council of Churches has continued through its subsequent Assemblies to manifest concern for study and action on behalf of religious liberty throughout the world. The Council’s declarations and statements giving unequivocal voice to the principle of religious liberty represent the most far-reaching and forthright international documents on behalf of religious liberty and constitute one of the major contributions of the Christian ecumenical movement to the world at large. The endorsement of religious liberty by the Roman Catholic Church in Vatican II remains a significant chapter in the long struggle between religion and freedom in the Western World. Released 7 December 1965, “The Declaration on Religious Liberty” was the first papal encyclical expressly in support of the principle of religious liberty and therefore it represented an important step for the Roman Catholic Church. The document affirmed the sacred as well as the natural right of all persons to religious liberty. “This Vatican Synod. . .declares that the right to religious freedom has its foundation in the very dignity of the human person, as this dignity is known through the revealed Word of God and by reason itself.” Carrying the subtitle, “On the Right of the Person and of Communities to Social and Civil Freedom in Matters Religious,” it further declared that a person “should not be coerced to act against his own conscience, nor be impeded to act according to his conscience.” With this document, the Roman Catholic Church
86
Church and State
affirmed both the natural right of corporate religious freedom as well as individual religious freedom. “Religious communities,” Vatican II declared, “have the right not to be hindered from publicly teaching and testifying to their faith both by the written and the spoken word. . .and from showing freely the special value of their own doctrine both for the ordering of society and for the guidance of all human activity.” Almost two decades later, Pope John Paul II declared, “The limitations of the religious freedom of individuals and communities not only is a painful experience for them, but above all strikes at man’s very dignity, regardless of the religion professed.”36 In the ensuing years, Pope John Paul II continued to speak forthrightly on behalf of human rights and religious freedom. These voices for religious liberty from both Catholic and Protestant traditions have contributed substantially to the recognition of religious liberty in national and international law. Indeed, as the late O. Frederick Nolde observed and U.S. government documents subsequently have confirmed, “An international Christian influence played a determining part in achieving the more extensive provision for human rights and fundamental freedoms which ultimately found their way into the [UN] Charter.”37 As is well documented in Robert Traer’s book, Faith in Human Rights, the growing support given to human rights in a wide range of religious traditions around the world, along with the support of secular humanists, offers hope in the ongoing struggle to provide greater legal assurance for religious rights, ethnic identity, and religious liberty.38 For the new democracies of both old and new nation-states, religious liberty is increasingly being recognized as crucial to a free society as seen most recently in the emerging democracies of the New Europe. Throughout the New Europe, constitutional reform commissions have been involved in providing guarantees of religious rights and religious liberty, along with a broad range of other human rights. In some countries, such as Bulgaria, permanent standing committees have been named by parliament to address on an ongoing basis, questions relating to new laws on religion. While there are many complex and difficult questions yet to be resolved, religious liberty has become, as never before, a subject that is being addressed as fundamental in the movement of nations toward democracy and freedom. Intimately intertwined with questions relating to religious rights and religious liberty is ethnic identity, which in many countries throughout the world is virtually conterminous with the rights of religious minorities. Nevertheless, recognition of religious rights as the cornerstone of all human rights—civil, economic, and social—augurs well for the emergence of free and pluralistic nation-states in which respect for both individual and social rights may be realized. As noted earlier, without legal guarantees of religious rights, all other human rights are in peril. 35
The international dimension of the major world religions holds the promise of effecting important gains not only for the advancement of religious human rights, but also for genuine interfaith dialogue and collaboration on behalf of religious freedom and the building of a world community. Religious liberty, like world peace, is not only a moral imperative worthy of universal support of religions around the world, it also needs to be seen as essential for the creation of a world community and may well prove to be crucial in the survival of the human family.
Religion in International Affairs and Interfaith Relations
87
As Wilfred Cantwell Smith has written, “Unless [people] can learn to understand and to be loyal to each other across religious frontiers, unless . . . [they] can build a world in which people of profoundly different faiths can live together and work together, then the prospects for our planet’s future are not bright.”39 While the principle of religious freedom has increasingly become almost universally recognized, government protection of religious human rights remains far from realized in most of today’s world. To express it in a slightly different way, while freedom of religion is almost universally recognized de jure, the principle is by no means recognized de facto in most of today’s world. The issue of religious and civil liberty is one of growing significance in today’s world. The growth of cultural and religious pluralism is worldwide and constitutes one of the major challenges facing virtually all nations and societies throughout the world today. Religious liberty has become particularly crucial with the emergence of religious pluralism throughout most of the world. Religious freedom contributes inevitably to the legitimacy of religious pluralism. The increasing presence of multiple faiths in increasingly secular societies makes religious isolation impossible and interfaith encounters inevitable. The present worldwide distribution of virtually all religious communities has exacerbated the importance of defending the religious human rights not only of the adherents of one’s own religious tradition but also the adherents of all other religious traditions, particularly religious minorities. The international dimension of the major world religions holds the promise of effecting important gains not only for the advancement of freedom of religion, but also for genuine interfaith dialogue and collaboration on behalf of religious human rights for all and the building of a world community. Religious liberty, like world peace, is not only a moral imperative worthy of universal support of nation-states and religions around the world, it also needs to be seen as essential for the emergence of civil liberty and the creation of a world community that may well prove to be crucial to the survival of the human family.
NOTES 1. Norman J. Padelford, International Guarantees of Religious Liberties (New York: International Missionary Council, 1942); quoted in M. Searle Bates, Religious Liberty Inquiry: An Inquiry (New York: Harper and Brothers, 1945), 476. 2. Bates, Religious Liberty, 476. 3. From this study, Bates observed, “[A] review of the forty-seven writers of the more important general treaties in international law, following the time of Grotius, shows that [a] full thirty refer to religious liberty”; ibid. 4. Ibid., 478. 5. General Act of the Berlin Conference Respecting the Congo, 26 February 1885, 165 Consol. T. S. 485.
88
Church and State
6. See Richard B. Lillich and Hurst Hannum, International Human Rights, 3rd. ed. (Buffalo, N.Y.: William S. Hein, 1995), 324. 7. Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, 4 November 1950, art. 9(1), 213 U.N.T.S. 222. 8. Conference on Security and Cooperation in Europe: Final Act (1975), reprinted in 14 I.L.M. (1975), 1923, 9. U.N. Charter, Article 56. 10. Ibid. 11. Universal Declaration of Human Rights, General Assembly Resolution 217A (111), at 71, U.N. Doc. A/810 (1948). 12. Ibid., Article 2. 13. Ibid., Article 18. 14. Universal Declaration of Human Rights, U.N. General Assembly Resolution 219A (111), at 71, U.N. Document A/810 (1948). 15. U. N. General Assembly, 21st Session, Supp. No. 16, at 71, U. N. Document A/6316 (1966). 16. See James Avery Jones, ed., Human Rights: International Documents (1978) 1:12. 17. Universal Declaration, 21, Article 18 (1). 18. Ibid., 2. 19. Soren Kierkegaard, Training in Christianity (1850); quoted in Niels Soe, “TheTheological Basis of Religious Liberty,” Ecumenical Review 11 (1958): 41. 20. “Declaration on the Elimination of all Forms of Intolerance and Discrimination Based on Religion or Belief,” GARes. 36/55, U.N. GAOR, 36th Sess., Supp.
No. 51, at 171, U.N. Doc A/36/51 (1981). 21. Ibid., Article 2. 22. Ibid. 23. Franklin I. Gamwell, The Meaning of Religious Freedom: Modern Politics and the Democratic Revolution (Albany: State University of New York, 1995), 162. 24. J. H. Oldham, ed., The Oxford Conference on Church, Community, and State (Chicago: Willett, Clark and Co., 1937), 72-73; reprinted as J. H. Oldham, ed., Foundations of
Religion in International Affairs and Interfaith Relations
89
Ecumenical Social Thought: The Oxford Conference Report (Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1966), 28-29. 25. See Kenneth G. Grubb, ed., The Church and the State, Vol. 6 of “TheMadras Series,” Presenting Papers Based upon the Meeting of the International Missionary Council, at Tambaram, Madras, India, December 12-29, 1938. 7 vols. (New York and London: International Missionary Council, 1939), 262-63. 26. W. A. Visser ‘t Hooft, ed., The First Assembly of the World Council of Churches: in at Amsterdam, August 22-September 4, 1948 (New York: Harper and Brothers, 1949), 93-95. 27. Ibid., 97-99. 28. Anson Phelps Stokes, Church and State in the United States, 2 vols. (New York: Harper and Brothers, 1950), 2:462. 29. A, F. Carrillo de Albornoz, The Basis of Religious Liberty (New York: Association Press, 1963), 41. 30, Visser ‘t Hooft, ed., The First Assembly of the World Council of Churches, 97. 31. Ibid. 32. Ibid., 93-95. 33, See Otto Frederick Nolde, The Churches and the Nations (Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1970), 149-69, in which the author sets forth the role of the churches in the formation of the United Nations and their influence in the United Nations’ adoption of “The Universal Declaration of Human Rights” in 1948. 34. The New Delhi Report: The Third Assembly of the World Council of Churches, 1961 (New York: Association Press, 1962), 159-61. 35. See “De Libertate Religiosa: A Declaration of Religious Freedom,” in The Documents of Vatican II: All Sixteen Official Texts Promulgated by the Ecumenical Council, 19131965, ed. Walter M. Abbott, S. J. and trans Joseph Gallaghan (New York: Guild Press, 1966), 675, 690. 36. From an address delivered by John Paul II, 10 March 1984, at the Fifth International Colloquium on Juridical Studies, sponsored by the Pontifical Lateran University, Rome Italy. 37. Nolde, The Churches and the Nations, 151.
90
Church and State
38. See Robert Traer, Faith in Human Rights: Support in Religious Traditions for a Global Struggle. Washington D.C.: Georgetown University Press, 1991. 39. Wilfred Cantwell Smith, “The Christian in a Religiously Plural World,” in Christianity and Other Religions, ed. John Hick and Brian Hebblethwaite (Philadel-phia: Fortress Press, 1980), 95.
Bibliographical Survey General 0001.
Acton, John Emerich Edward Dalberg. Essays in Religion, Politics, and Morality. Indianapolis: Liberty Classics of Liberty Fund, Inc., 1988. Collected essays from Lord Acton’s planned History of Liberty, which established him as a thinker of great importance in classical liberalism. He believed that the ultimate duty of the state was to protect the individual’s right to conscience. Acton shared a devotion to both political liberalism and Roman Catholicism
0002.
Acton, John Emerich Edward Dalberg. Essays on Church and State. New York: Thomas Y. Crowell, 1968. Reprinted essays by a distinguished English historian who devoted many years of his life to a monumental research project on the history of freedom. Author of the maxim, “Power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely,” Lord Acton was a participant in Vatican I; the essays in this volume were previously available only in contemporary periodicals.
0003.
Acton, John Emerich Edward Dalberg. The History of Freedom and Other Essays. London: Macmillan Co, 1967. Contains reprints of articles bearing on a subject the author had anticipated writing as a book on a history of liberty which he did not live to complete;
92
Church and State chapters in this volume include: “The History of Freedom in Christianity,” “Political Thoughts on the Church,” “Nationality,” “Conflicts with Rome,” and, “The American Commonwealth.”
0004.
Baird, Robert M. and Stuart E Rosenbaum. Morality and the Law. Buffalo, N.Y.: Prometheus Books, 1988. Based upon the presupposition that law and morality spring from the same source—a fundamental need for order and security, this collection of essays by various thinkers in law and philosophy addresses questions on the conflict between the dictates of conscience and laws and the moral principles that go to the laws themselves to justify civil disobedience.
0005.
Berman, Harold J. Faith and Order: The Reconciliation of Law and Religion. Atlanta, Ga.: Scholars Press, 1993. Argues that despite the tensions that exist in all societies between religious faith and legal order, they inevitably interact, and neither can maintain its vitality independently of the other, a thesis the author develops by: showing how religious beliefs have shaped Western constitutional and criminal law; exposing the fallacies of current theories of law which fail to take into account the religious dimensions; exploring the theological, prophetic, and educational themes that contribute to the emergence of a new world order; and analyzing the interactions between the secular religion of Marxist-Leninism and the legal structures of the Soviet and post-Soviet state.
0006.
Berman, Harold J. The Interaction of Law and Religion. Nashville, Tenn.: Abingdon, 1974. Contends that when persons put law and religion in two different compartments in their mind, the result is disastrous both for law and for religion, and eventually for society, and that without religious underpinning, the law would not be enforceable. Similarly, in every religion there is and must be a legal element—a concern for social order and social justice.
0007.
Berman, Harold J. Law and Revolution: The Formation of the Western Legal Tradition. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1983. A major work of scholarship that traces the roots of the Western legal institutions to the Papal Revolution, an upheaval that established modern law for both the church (i.e., canon law) and the state (i.e., the civil or secular/legal system).
Bibliographical Survey 0008.
93
Church and State/Eglise et Etat: International Bibliography, 1978-1980. Strasbourg, France: Cerdic Publications, 1980. One of a series of bibliographical publications on church and state by Cedric Publications.
0009.
Devlin, Judith and Roman Fanning. Religion and Rebellion. Dublin: University College Dublin Press, 1997. A collection of essays by leading Irish and international historians of religion and politics, ranging from the Middle Ages to the twentieth century, which explores religion not only as a corpus of doctrine and belief, but rather as a mirror of society and as a barometer of social and political realism, showing how religious reform in the Reformation inevitably led to conflict with the state and the place of religion in the Irish uprising of 1641, and the relation between religion and politics in modern India and the United States, for example.
0010.
Dickerson, Fay G. Politics and Religion: A Bibliography. Selected from the ATLA Religion Database. Chicago: American Theological Library Association, 1982. A select bibliography produced by a computer search of the entire American Theological Library Association (ATLA) Religion Database, including Religion Index One: Periodicals, 1975-; Religion Index Two: Multi-Author Works, 1970-; Religion Index Two: Festschriften, 1960-1969; Research in Ministry: An Index, 1981- (Doctor of Ministry Project Reports); and Index to Religious Periodical Literature, Volumes 1-4, 1949-1959 (rev. ed.).
0011.
Fenn, Eric. That They Go Forward: An Impression of the Oxford Conference on Church, Community and State. London: Student Christian Movement Press, 1962. This small volume was written in order to make some of the findings of the 1937 “Oxford Conference on Church, Community, and State” available in short, simple, and readily available form for the average reader.
0012.
George, Leonard. Crimes of Perception: An Encyclopedia of Heresies and Heretics. New York: Paragon House, 1995. This is an encyclopedic collection of the ideas, persons, and practices that, over the centuries, have been judged by the arbiters of religious orthodoxy to be too dangerous to be made known to the general populace;
94
Church and State includes more than six hundred detailed entries and several expansive bibliographies.
0013.
Hart, H. L. A. Law, Liberty, and Morality. Stanford, Cal.: Stanford University Press, 1963. Addresses the question of the use of criminal law to enforce morality, in particular sexual morality, and after examining various arguments that are put forth to justify the use of criminal law to enforce morality, the author argues against such use of criminal law in harmony with John Stuart Mill’s famous declaration, “The only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised over any member of a civilized community is to prevent harm to others.”
0014.
Helmstadter, Richard. Freedom and Religion in the Nineteenth Century. Stanford, Cal.: Stanford University Press, 1997. Covers a wide range of topics, including religious liberty in early America, science and religious freedom, the conflicting ideas of religious freedom in early Victorian England, the arguments over theological innovation in the England of the 1860s, European Jews and the limits of religious freedom, restrictions and controls on the practice of religion in Bismark’s Germany, the Catholic Church in nineteenth-century Europe, religious liberty in France, clericalism and anticlericalism in Chile, and religion and imperialism in nineteenth-century England.
0015.
Helwys, Thomas. Mystery of Iniquity. Ed. Richard Groves. Macon, Ga.: Mercer University Press, 1998. Published in 1612, this classic work boldly set forth, for the first time in the English language, the right of universal religious liberty.
0016.
Journal of Church and State. Published quarterly by the J. M. Dawson Institute of Church-State Studies of Baylor Uniiversity, PO Box 97308, Waco, TX 76798-7308. Interfaith, international, and interdisciplinary, it remains the only scholarly journal expressly devoted to the subject of church and state. Each issue features “Notes” on Church-State Affairs country by country around the world.
0017.
LaNoue, George R., ed. Bibliography of Doctoral Dissertations Undertaken in American and Canadian Universities, 1940-1962, on Religion and Politics. New York: Dept. of Religious Liberty, National Council of Churches of Christ in the U.S.A., 1963.
Bibliographical Survey
95
Contains a listing of 649 dissertations related to the subject of religion and politics, from the disciplines of anthropology, education, history, political science, sociology, and religion; see listing of dissertations on church and state in Canada and the United States in Journal of Church and State since 1964. For later compilations of doctoral dissertations on church and state since 1962 see Journal of Church and State , Vols. 7 (1965)- and the journal’s cumulative indexes for vols. 1-25, 26-30, 31-35, and 36-40. 0018.
Levy, Leonard W. Blasphemy: Verbal Offense Against the Sacred from Moses to Salman Rushdie. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1993. Traces the varied meanings of the offense of blasphemy in Western law— from the ancient Hebrew crimes of cursing God by name to the modern crime of ridiculing God or professing atheistic principles that insult the religious feelings of Christians and explores the blurring of meaning that occurred as at various times blasphemy became nearly indistinguishable from heresy, idolatry, sacrilege, nonconformity, sedition, treason, profanity, obscenity, and breach of peace; a definitive and valuable work.
0019.
Luzzatti, Luigi. God in Freedom: Studies in the Relations Between Church and State. New York: Macmillan Co., 1930. Originally published in 1909 under the title liberte di conscienza e di scienza, the English version is based upon a 1926 edition that enlarged to almost double its original length; the work of a distinguished Italian scholar, whose life and work are reviewed on pp. xvii-xxv of this volume. American supplementary chapters by William H. Taft and others.
0020.
Menendez, Albert J. Church-State Relations: An Annotated Bibliography. New York: Garland Publishing, Inc., 1976. A brief and helpful bibliography, now limited primarily by its date of publication.
0021.
Neusner, Jacob. Religion and the Political Order: Politics in Classical and Contemporary Christianity, Islam, and Judaism. Miami: University of South Florida Press, 1996. A group of well-known scholars reflect on how religious goals have, can, and should be achieved through political activity, when each religion is set forth with an account of the ideal political order, comparing ideals or classical statements with historical and contemporary expressions in order to discern how religion shapes many of today’s headlines.
96 0022.
Church and State Nurser, John. The Reign of Conscience: Individual Church and State in Lord Acton’s History of Liberty. New York: Garland Publishing Co, 1987. Provides a synthesis of the thought of Lord Acton in which he maintained that the heart of Christianity has to do with conscience, the engagement of the soul with God, that the structure of good government is of fundamental importance to the quality of human life, and that no culturally variable absolutes—religious or political systems—should be allowed to interfere with freedom of inquiry; a helpful introduction to Acton’s thought.
0023.
Petersen, Paul D. Politics and Religion: A Bibliography Selected from the ATLA Religion Database. Chicago: American Theological Library Association, 1984. Produced by a computer search of the ATLA (American Theological Library Association) Research Index from magnetic tape files, arranged in alphabetical order based on the author’s name.
0024.
Pfeffer, Leo. Church, State, and Freedom. Boston: Beacon Press, 1953. Long recognized as a major text on the subject; a classic and comprehensive study that still serves as an important reference work for the period prior to 1967.
0025.
Raz, Joseph. Ethics in the Public Domain: Essays in the Morality of Law and Politics. New York: Oxford University Press, 1994. In this collection of essays, the author concentrates in the first part of the book on the consequences of two central aspects of well-being: the importance of membership in groups and the active character of wellbeing and, in the second part, he explores various aspects of the dynamic inter-relations between law and morality, offering some building blocks towards a theory of law.
0026.
Sheldon, Garrett Ward. Religion and Politics: Major Thinkers on the Relation of Church and State. New York: Peter Lang, 1990. A collection of classic theologians’ writings on religion and politics combined with major American documents on church and state; includes the most prominent Catholic and Protestant writers with representatives of liberation theology and the Christian Right and leading U. S. Supreme Court decisions on religious liberty.
Bibliographical Survey 0027.
97
Stroup, Herbert Hewitt. Church and State in Confrontation: A Sociological Study of Church-State Relations from Old Testament Times to the Present. New York: Seabury Press, 1967. Provides a descriptive analysis of the inherent tendencies toward conflict in church-state relations.
0028.
Stumpf, Samuel E. Morality and the Law. Nashville, Tennessee: Vanderbilt University Press, 1966. Explores the moral bases of law and challenges the concept that law has no moral connotations whatsoever. Five ways in which law and morality are inextricably interrelated are the following: that law is what the courts do in fact; that law is the will of the economically dominant class; that law is the command of the sovereign; the role of morality in the development of international law; and the theory of natural law that is concerned chiefly with the question whether a legal order rests upon the moral order.
0029.
Swatos, William H. Encyclopedia of Religion and Society. Thousand Oaks, California: Alta Mira Press, 1998. From succinct brief notes to essay-length entries, this volume covers world religions, religious perspectives on political and social issues, and religious leaders, past and present, throughout the world; topics include abortion, anthropology of religion, definition of religion, ethnicity, fundamentalism, Hinduism, Islam, Judaism, new religious movements, racism, Roman Catholicism, and many others; includes over five hundred entries by more than one hundred contributors.
0030.
Verduin, Leonard. The Anatomy of a Hybrid: A Study in Church-State Relationships. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Wm. B Eerdmans Publishing Co., 1976. A broad historical review of the course of church and state and religious liberty in which the author portrays the evils of the ancient sacral states, the union of church and state from the fourth century, and the great tragedies of all totalitarianism. The author views with alarm the modern rise of monolithic societies, in which all members are expected to share the same ultimate loyalty and there is no room for diversity.
0031.
Voegelin, Eric. Political Religions. Lewiston, NY: The Edwin Mellen Press, 1986.
98
Church and State Explains the processes and root causes of political disorder from the cosmological empire of Akhenaton in ancient Egypt to the more recent heresies of Marxism, Fascism, and Nazism as rooted in the rejection of the transcendental.
0032.
Wink, Walter. When the Powers Fall: Reconciliation in the Healing of Nations. Minneapolis: Augsburg Fortress, 1998. Demonstrates the power, promise, and practicality of Jesus’ ethic of nonviolence for today and applies an analysis of “The Powers,” as they appear in the New Testament, to the global scene.
0033.
Witte, John Jr. and Alexander, Frank S. The Weightier Matters of Law: Essays on Law and Religion. Atlanta: Scholars Press, 1988. Contains a wide variety of essays on such themes as individual rights, the transition of marriage law in the Lutheran Reformation, religion and criminal law, the relation between law and religion, the role of conscience in judicial decision-making, the biblical kingdom and American law, the tension in America between law and religious tradition, et al.
0034.
Wolf, Eric R. Religious Regimes and State Formation: Perspectives from European Ethnology. Albany: State University of New York Press, 1991. Examines power and meaning in their “antagonistic interdependencies” rather than approaching religion purely as a realm of meaning without reference to issues of power, or dealing with politics as the province of power without raising questions of meaning and thus attempts to show that religion and politics should be seen in relation to one another and gives attention to the disputes about how political and religious regimes should be formed.
0035.
Wood, James E., Jr. Nationhood and the Kingdom. Nashville: Broadman Press, 1977. Analyzes the perennial problem for Christians of one’s relationship to nationhood and the kingdom of God as personified in the claims of Caesar and the claims of God for supreme loyalty; conflict between the two has often been avoided either by means of accommocation of one to the other or identification of one with the other. With the emergence of the modern nation-state, the author argues that today the demands of nationhood and the claims of Caesar have been extended in a manner unparalleled in previous history.
Bibliographical Survey 0036.
99
Wood, James E., Jr., ed. Readings on Church and State: Selections from Journal of Church and State. Waco: Baylor University Institute of Church-State Studies, 1989. Contains thirty essays by thirty different authors, representing a wide variety of academic disciplines and religious traditions; while particular attention is given to the American experience of church-state relations, more than half of the essays focus on other parts of the world and on subjects of special importance in today’s world...
0037.
Wood, James E., Jr., E. Bruce Thompson, and Robert T. Miller. Church and State in Scripture, History, and Constitutional Law. Waco: Baylor University Press, 1958. A concise introduction to the subject of church and state; from the perspectives of biblical thought, historicl development, and constitutional law.
0038.
Yinger, John Milton. Religion in the Struggle for Power: A Study in the Sociology of Religion. Durham: Duke University Press, 1946. A sociological analysis of organized religion’s exercise of power to influence society and social institutions in the light of history.
Religion and the State in the Ancient World 0039.
Ahlström, Gvsta W. Royal Administration and National Religion in Ancient Palestine. Leiden, The Netherlands: E. J. Brill, 1982. Attempts to show the intimate relationship between state and religion in ancient Palestine and that private or personal religion had little place in the societies of the ancient Near East; rather, religion was an expression of the life of a community, and therefore constituted a part of the political system, the basic premise being that the god was the ruler of the nation.
0040.
Barker, Ernest. Greek Political Theory: Plato and His Predecessors. London: Metheun and Co., Ltd., 1918. Offers a detailed study of Platonic political theory within its historical context, including a review of the pre-Platonic climate of thought produced by Socrates, the Pythagoreans, and the Sophists, among others.
100
Church and State
0041.
de Polignac, François. Cults, Territory, and the Origin of the Greek CityState. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1995. Provides a series of important insights into the religious functioning of the polis and suggests that Athens was probably the exception, not the rule, in the development of the polis in ancient Greece.
0042.
Drekmeier, Charles. Kingship and Community in Early India. Stanford, Cal.: Stanford University Press, 1962. Analyzes kingship and community in early India, the manner in which these values were symbolized, the various attitudes toward political life and the different ways of thinking about questions of justice and freedom and the methods employed by those in positions of authority in resolving conflict and creating consensus.
0043.
Fowden, Garth. Empire to Commonwealth: Consequences of Monotheism in Late Antiquity. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1993. Shows how powerful beliefs in One God were used to justify and strengthen “world empires” from the peak of the Roman Empire to the onset of the Islamic Empire, but tensions between orthodoxy and heresy that were inherent in monotheism broke the unitary empires of Byzantium and Baghdad into the looser, more pluralistic commonwealths of Eastern Christendom and Islam.
0044.
Frankfort, Henri. Kingship and the Gods: A Study of Ancient Near Eastern Religion as the Integration of Society and Nature. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1948. First published in 1948, now supplemented with a preface by Samuel Noah Kramer, this volume demonstrates how the Egyptian and Mesopotamian attitudes toward nature related to their concept of kingship; in both countries the people regarded the king as their mediator with the gods, but in Mesopotamia the king was only the foremost citizen, while in Egypt the ruler was a divine descendant of the gods and the earthly representative of the God Horus.
0045.
Frankfurter, David. Religion in Roman Egypt: Assimilation and Resistance. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2000. Examines the complex fate of classical Egyptian religion during the centuries from the period when Christianity first made its appearance in Egypt to when it became the region’s dominant religion (roughtly 100 to 600 C.E.). The author argues that the religion of Pharonic Egypt
Bibliographical Survey
101
did not die out as early as has been supposed but was instead relegated from political centers to village and home where it continued a vigorous existence for centuries. 0046.
Fustel de Coulanges, Numa Denis. the Ancient City: A Study on the Religion, Laws, and Institutions of Greece and Rome. Garden City: Doubleday-Anchor, 1956. Originally published in 1864 as La Cite Antigue. This classic study describes the societies of the cities of Greece and Rome in the earliest stages of their history and shows religion was the basis of the civic life and dominated every aspect of the life of these people including the political and legal structures as well as private law. This work has long been regarded as a classic of French historical literature.
0047.
Garland, Robert. Introducing New Gods: The Politics of Athenian Religion. Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University Press, 1992.
Examines the means by which the Athenians established and promoted various religious cults by illuminating the full range of motives—political and economic, as well as spiritual—which prompted them to introduce new gods. 0048.
Hammond, Mason. City-State and World State in Greek and Roman . Political Theory until Augustus. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1951. In analyzing Greek and Roman political thought, the author suggests that one reason for the decay of classical civilization was the inability of the Greeks and the Romans to find a new basis in political theory for the Hellenistic kingdoms and the Roman Empire, which outgrew the concept of the Greek city-state
0049.
Harle, Vilho. Ideas of Social Order in the Ancient World. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Publishing Co., 1998. Focuses on the issue of the social order in the ancient world by providing a comparative analysis of ideas of social order in classical Chinese political philosophy, the Indian epic and political literature, Zoroastrianism, Judaism, classical Greek and Roman political thought, and early Christianity, based on the religious, political, and literary texts that represent their respective civilizations as to both their major achievements and sources of shared values.
102 0050.
Church and State Hooke, Samuel H. Myth, Ritual, and Kingship: Essays on Theory and Practice of Kingship in the Ancient Near East and in Israel. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1958. Includes nine essays by nine prominent scholars on myth and ritual: past and present, the practice of kingship in early semitic kingdoms; the kingship rituals of Egypt; Hittite kingship; myth, ritual, and kingship in the Ras Shamra Tablets; early Hebrew myths and their interpretation; Hebrew conceptions of kingship, ritual, and the Hebrew prophets. Both the myth and ritual are critically considered.
0051.
Jaeger, Werner W. Paideia: The Ideals of Greek Culture. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1939-1944. Includes a comprehensive review of the interrelation of Greek and Roman law and religion.
0052.
Levi, Mario Attilio. Political Power in the Ancient World. New York: New American Library, 1965. Examines the law of the state and the law of the gods in the ancient world, with special emphasis on ancient Egypt, Greece, and Rome; a valuable study.
0053.
Malkin, Irad. Religion and Colonization in Ancient Greece. Leiden, The Netherlands: E.J. Brill, 1987. Provides a comprehensive study of the relation between Greek colonization and religion in ancient Greece and shows how, in addition to innumerable distinctive characteristics, there were certain religious practices and beliefs common to most and commemorated for centuries. In general, however, the creations of new city states introduced changes both in social and religious attitudes and practices which in turn came to influence also the older Greek world.
0054.
Myres, Jon Linton, Sr. Political Ideas of the Greeks. New York: Methodist Book Concern, 1927. Analyzes the political thought of ancient Greece, including the relationship of this thought to Hebrew folkmemory and theocratic societies.
0055.
Otzen, Benedikt. Judaism in Antiquity: Political Developments and Religious Currents from Alexander to Hadrian. Sheffield, Eng.: JSOT Press, 1990.
Bibliographical Survey
103
Traces the political, social, and religious trends in Jewish culture and society from Alexander (336-323 B.C.E.) to Hadrian (138-117); a good resource. 0056.
Petrie, W.M. Flinders. Religion and Conscience in Ancient Egypt. New York: Scribner’s Sons, 1898. Although based on the literature of the Egyptians, the author covers also some general considerations which are equally applicable to religion and conscience of other countries and cultures.
0057.
Redford, Donald B. Akhenaten: The Heretic King. Princeton: Princeton Uni-versity Press, 1984. Drawing on a vast amount of new evidence from his own excavations, the author describes the kingly heretic against the background of imperial Egypt; note particularly, chap. 11, “Of Politics and Foreign Affairs.”
0058.
Rose, H. J. Religion in Greece and Rome. New York: Harper, 1960. A classic study of Greek and Roman religious cults, both of which were creedless, polytheistic, neither attached to any system of ethics, both permitted but did not require the use of cult images and other visible objects of worship, both had their holy places and later their holy buildings, both had priests and priestesses yet neither developed a powerful priesthood that could make its influence felt in politics, and both were closely attached to the organization of the state; yet their religious differences were nonetheless striking.
0059.
Sayce, A. H. The Religions of Ancient Egypt and Babylonia. Edinburgh: T. & T. Clark, 1902. Examines the concept of the divine among the ancient Babylonians and Egyptians, noting that these two civilizations form the background for Judaism and Christianity; at the same, there lies an impassable gulf between the ancient religion and Judaism and Christianity characterized primarily by the difference between revelation and nonrevealed religion.
0060.
Sevenster, Jan Nicholaas. The Roots of Pagan Anti-Semitism in the Ancient World. Leiden, The Netherlands: E. J. Brill, 1975. Examines possible sources of anti-Semitism in the ancient world on the basis of race, social status, and politics and concludes that “the most fundamental reason for pagan anti-Semitism almost always proves to lie
104
Church and State in the strangeness of the Jews amidst ancient society” and the perception of Jews as intolerant based on their exclusive theological claims rooted in the Jewish faith.
0061.
Sinclair, T. A. A History of Greek Political Thought. London,: Routledge and Kegan Paul, Ltd., 1967. Provides a comprehensive survey of political thought in the ancient world from Homer to the beginning of the Christian era, including Herodotus, Euripides, Thucydides, Plato, Aristotle, Polybius, Cicero, and Lucretius, including Jewish influences
0062.
Watson, Alan. International Law in Archaic Rome. Baltimore and London. The Johns Hopkins Press, 1993. Argues that the gods were called upon the gods, not to act as witnesses to defend the Roman cause, but to act impartially, as judges in a trial. The author also explores some of the apparent paradoxes in the Roman approach to international relations, as reflected in their religious conventions and laws of war.
Religion and the State in the Biblical World General 0063.
Bauckham, Richard J. The Bible in Politics: How to Read the Bible Politically. Louisville, Ky.: Westminster/John Knox Press, 1989. Provides a guide on how to read the Bible politically and have it serve as a guide to Christian political action while being cognizant of the distinctive nature of the biblical texts and their distance from today; many of these texts have received very little political attention in the past.
0064.
Carr, Wesley A. Angels and Principalities. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1981. Argues that there is nothing in the Pauline writings that refers to a battle between Christ and hostile forces and that the notion of the mighty forces of evil ranged against humankind was not part of the earliest Christian understanding of the world and the gospel.
0065.
Clavier, Henri. The Duty and the Right of Resistance According to the Bible and to the Church. Oxford: Blackwell’s, 1956.
Bibliographical Survey
105
Delivered as the Dale Lectures at Oxford University in 1946. 0066.
Culver, Robert Duncan. Toward a Biblical View of Civil Government. Chicago: Moody Press, 1974. Seeks to use the methods of historical, biblical, and systematic theology to discover and relate to Christians today biblical concepts regarding the church, civil government, and relations between them; centers on the Bible but does not ignore sociological and political studies.
0067.
Gallardo, José. The Way of Biblical Justice. Scottdale, Penn.: Herald Press, 1983. Shows that biblical justice includes the idea of wholeness in all of life and that God’s plan of justice contains good news for the poor, freedom for the captives, healing for the sick, and release for the oppressed; the author writes out of the context of his experiences in Spain and Latin America.
0068.
Hendricks, Herman. Social Justice in the Bible. Quezon City, Philippines: Claretian Publications, 1988. Examines the biblical view of social justice, including a series of one hundred and fifty texts in the Bible which address the subject in order to determine what the Bible has to say on social justice; the study of biblical texts is preceded by a chapter on the search for social justice in other countries of the ancient Near East.
0069.
McAlpine, Thomas H. Facing the Powers. Monrovia, Calif.: MARC/World Vision, 1991. Reviews the growing literature on “the principalities and power” and four approaches to the issue: Reformed, the Anabaptist, the Third World and the Social Sciences.
0070.
Mouw, Richard J. Politics and the Biblical Drama. Grand Rapids, Mich.: Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Co., 1976. Argues that political theologies which subordinate theology to ideology or conclude that politics is an “untouchable” sphere of activity cannot be defended; examines in some detail the Pauline concept of “principalities and powers” and concludes that political actions should be undertaken with the prayer that God will allow them to act as preparatory signs for the coming of the kingdom.
106 0071.
Church and State Reventlow, Henning Graf, Yair Hoffman, and Benjamin Uffenheimer,. Politics and Theopolitics in the Bible and Postbiblical Literature. Sheffield, Eng.: Sheffield Academic Press, 1994. The essays in this volume share a common thread in that each reflects that human politics has been deeply influenced by the belief in the rule and providence of God and through this the authors seek to bring the Jewish and Christian traditions to a better understanding of one another.
0072.
Schanks, Herschel. Christianity and Rabbinic Judaism: A Parallel History of Their Origins and Early Development. Washington D. C.: Biblical Archaeology Society, 1992. Various Jewish and Christian scholars provide insightful accounts of Judaism and Christianity during the first six centuries of their coexistence, including brief critical assessments of positions taken by the two traditions on disputed questions.
0073.
Snyder, Graydon F. Power and Violence: A Biblical Study. Oak Brook, Illinois: Bethany Theological Seminary, 1971. Part 2 of a colloquium sponsored by Bethany Theological Seminary.
0074.
Stanton, Graham N. and Guy G. Stroumsa. Tolerance and Intolerance in Early Judaism and Christianity. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1997. Examines issues of tolerance and intolerance faced by Jews and Christians between 200 B.C.E. and 200 C.E.; several essays are concerned with aspects of early Jewish-Christian relations, others consider ways Jews and Christians defined themselves, and still others consider issues of tolerance that arose in rival groups within early Judaism and early Christianity
Old Testament 0075.
Bar-Kochva, Bezalel. Judas Maccabaeus: The Jewish Struggle Against the Seleucids. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1988. Recounts the battles fought by Judas Maccabaeus between 166 and 160 B.C.E. against the Seleucids during the Jewish revolt and reexamines the accepted assessments of Maccabaeus’ activities and achievements
0076.
Birch, Bruce C. What Does the Lord Require? The Old Testament Call to Social Witness. Philadelphia: Westminster Press, 1985.
Bibliographical Survey
107
Focuses on the faith of the people of Israel—creation, exodus, covenant, kingship, exile, and restoration—and illustrates how the people of Israel recognized no division between spiritual and secular, personal and social dimensions of faith and applies this outlook to the life and witness of the church today. 0077.
Boecker, Hans Jochen. Law and the Administration of Justice in the Old Testament and Ancient East. Minneapolis, Minn.: Augsburg, 1980. Attempts to show how the law influenced the Old Testament, formed the basis not only for the view of God but for all theological concepts in ancient Israel, and how the law actually worked in everyday life, with special attention given to the Book of the Covenant in Exodus and to Deuteronomy and the Law of Holiness in ancient laws regarding real estate, marriage, adoption and inheritance, the “eye for an eye” formula, and capital punishment
0078.
Bohrmann, Monette. Flavius Josephus, the Zealots, and Yavne: Toward a Rereading of The War of the Jews. Bern: Peter Lang, 1994. Analyzes events from 6 to 73 C.E., which resulted in the opening of hostilities between the Jews and Romans, and suggests that the conflict was also a conflict of mentalities; the Jewish mentality, the author argues, implies a concept of war which contributed to the development of the divisions and schisms between the supporters of full-scale war against Rome (the Zealots) and the non-belligerents (Rabbi Yohanan ben Zaccai and Yavne School, Flavius Josephus).
0079.
Bright, John. The Kingdom of God: The Biblical Concept and its Meaning for the Church. Nashville, Tenn.: Abingdon-Cokesbury Press, 1953. In examining the emergence of the concept of the Kingdom of God in the Old Testament the author contends that “the hope of Israel is thus driven ahead beyond the existing nation.”
0080.
Clark, A. B. Biblical Law. Portland, Oreg.: Binford and Mort, 1944. The author argues that biblical law, to a remarkable degree, covers the entire field of civil, domestic, and even social life.
0081.
Clements, Ronald E. The World of Ancient Israel: Sociological, Anthropological, and Political Perspectives. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1989.
108
Church and State Encapsulates research that has been undertaken on the sociological, anthropological, and political aspects of the history of ancient Israel, including essays of Israel in its historical and cultural setting, Israelite kingship, the origins of the diaspora, the social world of the wisdom and apocalyptic writings, the concept of holy war, covenant ideology, and the land.
0082.
Coote, Robert B. In Defense of Revolution: The Elohist History. Minneapolis, Minn,: Augsburg Fortress, 1991. A provocative study of the protest movement that helped forge the dynamic traditions of Israel, based upon the Elohist (or E) material in the Pentateuch and argues for E’s support of Israel’s revolution against the House of David led by Jeroboam I; a good biblical study of power politics.
0083.
Danube, David. Studies in Biblical Law. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1947. In the early chapters of the book, the author focuses on law as viewed in the early biblical narratives and in the codes while the latter chapters explore a specific aspect of biblical law—lex talionis, communal responsibilities, and Summum Ius-Summa-Tniuria.
0084.
Day, John. King and Messiah in Israel and the Ancient Near East: Proceedings of the Oxford Old Testament Seminar. Sheffield, U.K.: Sheffield Academic Press, 199? Examines kingship and messianism in the Old Testament in particular, but also in the ancient Near East more generally, and in post-biblical Judaism and the New Testament; contains contributions by twenty scholars
0085.
Dearman, Andrew J. Religion and Culture in Ancient Israel. Peabody, Mass.: Hendrickson Publishers, 1992. Examines Israelite religion in light of both the biblical account and extrabiblical sources as background for understanding issues like the origins of Yahwism or the political leadership of the day, either during the premonarchic times or during the post-exilic period.
0086.
Derfler, Steven Lee. The Hasmonean Revolt: Rebellion or Revolution. Lewiston, N. Y.: The Edwin Mellen Press, 1990. Attempts to present a unified synthesis of the many theories that have been attempted in trying to understand the events that transpired at the
Bibliographical Survey
109
time of the rebirth of a Jewish state in Judea after four centuries of foreign domination; centers on the period 168 B.C.E.-135 C.E. 0087.
Doorly, William J. Prophet of Justice: Understanding the Book of Amos. Mahwah, N. J.: Paulist Press, 1990. Argues that Amos’ original prophecy, without the softening given it by later scribes, is an unrelieved prediction of doom for wealthy oppressors of the poor and the righteous; develops from Amos a theology of economic justice that makes the prophet’s words a stirring indictment and illumination of society today.
0088.
Ellul, Jacques. Anarchy and Christianity. Grand Rapids, Mich.: Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Co., 1991. Blends politics, theology, history, and exposition in an analysis of the relationship between political anarchy and biblical faith and concludes that Christians need to look at biblical texts and not reject anarchy as a political option, since it seems to be closest to biblical thinking.
0089.
Elazar, Daniel J. Covenant and Polity in Biblical Israel: Biblical Foundations and Jewish Expressions. New Brunswick, N. J.: Transaction Publishers, 1995. In this first volume of a trilogy, the author addresses political uses of the idea of covenant, the tradition that has adhered to that idea, and the political arrangements that flow from it.
0090.
Elazar, Daniel J. The Book of Joshua as a Political Classic. 1989. Provides a political interpretation of Joshua; very insightful.
0091.
Falk, Ze’ev Wilhelm. Hebrew Law in Biblical Times: An Introduction. Jerusalem: Wahrmann Books, 1964. Examines continuity and change in ancient Hebrew law, as reflected in the biblical sources, and describes the historical background to and the causes of the various legal rules, citing many parallels and contrasts with other ancient laws; emphasis is placed upon the clanship system which prevailed during the age of the Hebrew patriarchs and upon the development of the legal system as a consequence of the settlement of Palestine.
110 0092.
Church and State Fewell, Danna Nolan. Circle of Sovereignty: Plotting Politics in the Book of Daniel. Nashville, Tenn.: Abingdon Press, 1991. Examines the people, the events, and the politics in the book of Daniel and finds that politics and theology converge to create complex, sometimes circular messages concerning sovereignty, hierarchy, and personal fidelity and that one strand of the text seems to suggest that religious fidelity and divine sovereignty are triumphant, while another seems to insist that Jewish heroes are compromised and that sovereignty eludes everyone involved.
0093.
Frick, Frank S. The Formation of the State in Ancient Israel: A Survey of Models and Theories. Decatur, Ga.: The Almond Press, 1985. Argues that the data and theories from the social sciences, especially anthropology, provide the biblical scholar with suggestive and illuminating controlled comparisons between many of the socio-political processes at work in early Israel and similar processes at work elsewhere
0094.
Gerbrandt, Gerald E. Kingship According to the Deuteronomistic History. Decatur, Ga.: Scholars Press, 1986. An examination of the entire Deuteronomistic history in order to determine the biblical author’s(s’) views on kingship. Gerbrandt maintains that the historians were only opposed to those kings who did not adhere to the Deuteronomistic view of kingship.
0095.
Grottanelli, Christiano. Kings and Prophets: Monarchic Power, Inspired Leadership, and Sacred Text in Biblical Narrative. New York: Oxford University Press, 1999. Focuses on the subject of kingship in the ancient world and explores the ways in which centralized state power, as epitomized by the sacred king, encounters other oppositional forms of power, such as those possessed by prophets, tricksters, and women.
0096.
Hamilton, Jeffries M. Social Justice and Deuteronomy: The Case of Deuteronomy 15. Atlanta Ga.: Scholars Press, 1992. Analyzes the structure and language of the text of Deuteronomy 15 and how the release laws of usury and slavery work to evoke assent and compliance in the reader and, finally, the author places this chapter within the context of the larger world of Deuteronomy’s attitude toward those in need of care.
Bibliographical Survey 0097.
111
Harrington, Daniel J. The Maccabean Revolt: Anatomy of a Biblical Revolution. Wilmington, Del.: Michael Glazier, 1988. Analyzes the three major sources of the Maccabean revolt in light of the distinctive theological vantage point of each: God’s kingdom (Daniel), God’s temple (II Maccabees), and God’s dynasty (I Maccabees).
0098.
Mendels, Doron. The Rise and Fall of Jewish Nationalism: Jewish and Christian Ethnicity in Ancient Palestine. Grand Rapids, Mich.: Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Co., 1997. Provides a careful analysis of historical and literary sources, from Josephus to New Testament apocrypha, regarding the development of Jewish nationalism; a valuable introduction to Jewish political history in its international context
0099.
Kang, Sa-Moon. Divine War in the Old Testament and in the Ancient Near East. Berlin and New York: Walter de Gruyter, 1989. Based upon the author’s Ph.D. dissertation, this study deals with the concept of divine war in a comprehensive manner; it is concerned with all its religious and military dimensions and institutions. Part I focuses on “Divine War in the Ancient Near East,” while Part II examines “YHWH War in the Old Testament.
0100.
Mathews, Victor H. Social World of Ancient Israel, 1250-587 B.C.E.. Peabody, Mass.: Hendrickson Publishers, 1993. Takes a special look at the most prominent social institutions of the world of early Israel and the period of the monarchy, and then shows how properly understanding these social institutions are essential for sound biblical interpretation.
0101.
McCarthy, Dennis J. Old Testament Covenant: A Survey of Current Opinions. Richmond, Va.: John Knox Press, 1972. Examines scholarly contributions to the biblical concept of covenant as it relates to law, cult, kingship, and theology; includes extensive bibliography.
0102.
Muffs, Yochanan. Love and Joy: Law, Language, and Religion in Ancient Israel. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1992.
112
Church and State Examines the laws of war in ancient Israel, the figurative nature of legal language, the role of the prophet and prophetic speech, and the expressions of belonging which united Israelite culture.
0103.
Pixley, Jorge V. On Exodus: A Liberation Perspective. Maryknoll, N. Y.: Orbis Books, 1987. A review of the historical significance of the exodus—seen as the liberation of the Jews enslaved in Egypt; provides a thorough treatment of the historical and contemporary liberative meaning of the Exodus.
0104.
Polley, Max. E. Amos and the Davidic Empire: A Socio-Historical Approach. New York: Oxford University Press, 1989. Argues that Amos condemned the Northern Kingdom of Israel for its rebellion against the Davidic dynasty and proceeds from the premise that too little attention is given to the relationship between nationalism and religion in studies of ancient Israelite religion and history.
0105.
Priest, James E. Governmental and Judicial Ethics in the Bible and Rabbinic Literature. New York: KTAV Publishing Houst, 1980. Examines the biblical and rabbinic sources in order to discover their value today in areas of judicial and governmental ethics. Major topics include: the concepts of law in the Bible and Talmud; governmental legal systems; enforcement of judicial ethics; reward and punishment in judicial ethics; the death penalty; judicial ethics of punishment equal to the crime; and the ethics of government in war and peace.
0106.
Rice, Gene. Nations Under God: A Commentary on the Book of 1 Kings. Grand Rapids, Mich.: Wm. B. Eerdmans, Publishing Co., 1990. Out of the concerns of ancient Israel, the author contends that I Kings speaks to the present: it prods us to identify the equivalent of Canaanite religion in our society and to examine ourselves in light of the biblical commandments, directs us to look for God’s presence in the arena of public life, and to recognize that all nations, not just Israel, are “under God.”
0107.
Rosenberg, Joel. King and Kin: Political Allegory in the Hebrew Bible. Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1986. A Jewish scholar’s analysis of political allegory in the Hebrew Bible (Genesis through II Kings) in which he explores the fundamental concepts and contradictions in the history of pre-exilic Israel, emphasizing the
Bibliographical Survey
113
transition from tribal confederation to national kingdom. The author examines the texts that form a single critique of Israel’s national identity from primordial times to the Babylonian exile. He reflects not only on what the Bible is saying, but how and why. 0108.
Safire, William. The First Dissident: The Book of Job in Today’s Politics. New York: Random House, 1992. In applying the Book of Job to the politics of today, the author shows how modern heroes have reshaped authority and history—and how individual citizens can, too—by following the courageous example of Job; a provocative work.
0109.
Schrey, Heinz-Horst. The Biblical Doctrine of Justice and Law. London: SCM Press, 1955.. A helpful and reliable study.
0110.
Schwartz, Seth. Josephus and Judaean Politics. Leiden, The Netherlands: E. J. Brill, 1990. Aims to establish Josephus’ attitudes to the various Judaean groups of the first century—priests, descendants of Herod, and certain sectarians—and shows how these attitudes changed with the actual changes in Judaean politics and society during the thirty years of Josephus’ literary activity, following the destruction of Jerusalem.
0111.
Seitz, Christopher. Theology in Conflict: Reactions to the Exile in the Book of Jeremiah. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter, 1989. A socio-historical analysis of Judah in the pre-exilic and exilic period that is used in combination with a redaction-critical investigation of Jeremiah, Ezekiel, and the Deuteronomistic History; the author maintains that the conflict between communities in Judah and Babylon accounts for the peculiar development and final form of the Book of Jeremiah.
0112.
Smith, Morton. Palestinian Parties and Politics that Shaped the Old Testament. New York: Columbia University Press, 1971. The author attempts to distinguish and describe particular groups and parties behind the writing of the Old Testament—to trace their developments, conflicts. and alliances, and to follow as far as possible the convolutions of each party line, convolutions which explain the
114
Church and State traditions that the party preserved and invented, and indicate those which it suppressed and denied.
0113.
Stadelmann, Luis. Love and Politics: A New Commentary on the Song of Songs. Mahwah, N.J.: Paulist Press, 1992. Attempts to show how the author of Song of Songs, couching his meaning in the disguise of romantic and erotic language, was really putting forth a political treatise calling for the restoration of the Davidic monarchy in Judah during the post-exilic period of the history of Israel; a provocative study.
0114.
Swanston, Hamish. The Kings and the Covenant. Baltimore: Helicon Press, 1968. Provides an historical examination of the Hebrew monarchy, one of the most important periods of Israel history, covering the five hundred-year span from the election of Saul as the first king of the people of Israel to the capture of Jerusalem by the Babylonians. Throughout this period the author focuses on the complex relationship and the covenant between Yahweh and his chosen and free people, Israel..
0115.
Talmon, Shemaryahu. King, Cult, and Calendar in Ancient Israel. Leiden, The Netherlands: E. J. Brill, 1986. The essays in this volume attempt to elucidate the focal religious and social tenets which informed the ancient Israelite res publica and problem in particular the forms of interaction between the king and other societal agents: priests, prophets, and representatives of the people. The development of Israelite kingship is traced from its emergence as a pragmatic response to historical vicissitudes to its culmination in the vision of an “Anointed” who is expected to rise and bring in the future ideal age.
0116.
von Rad, Gerhard. Holy War in Ancient Israel. Grand Rapids, Mich.: Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Co., 1991. Argues that the most important feature of holy war for Israel was the demand for faith in Yahweh’s saving acts; it was, however, not Yahweh alone who acted, rather, the Israelites envisioned Yahweh fighting on their behalf and, thus, they were inspired, and even obliged, to fight harder.
0117.
Walsh, James P. M. The Mighty from Their Thrones: Power in the Biblical Tradition. Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1987.
Bibliographical Survey
115
An examination of the reasons why the people of the covenant chose to be ruled by a human monarch, and the policies that led to exilic experiences of Israel and the end of prophecy 0118.
Walzer, Michael. Exodus and Revolution. New York: Basic Books, 1985. Celebrates the story of the Exodus in terms of the political meanings of the biblical story and shows the part that this story has played in shaping Western political thought and action; views Exodus as a political document.
0119.
Weinfeld, Moshe. Social Justice in Ancient Israel and in the Ancient Near East. Jerusalem: Magness Press, 1995. Analyzes the ideal of justice in relation to social reforms promoted by Israelite monarchy, the implications of the ideal in individual life, and the implications of all aspects of the concept; shows that the biblical expression “to do justice” and “righteousness” generally refers to acting on behalf of the poor and oppressed.
0120.
Weisman, Ze’ev. Political Satire in the Bible. Atlanta: Scholars Press, 1998. Examines political satire as a literary device in the Bible and draws the main lines of its development, exposing the characteristics of political satire in each of the Bible main divisions and in most of its literary types and concludes that satire should be recognized as a widespread literary phenomenon in the Bible.
0121.
Wildavsky, Aaron. Assimilation versus Separation: Joseph the Administrator and the Politics of Religion in Biblical Israel. New Brunswick, N.J.: Transaction Books, 1993. Provides a probing analysis of the problem for Jews of assimilation versus separation and attempts to show that this dilemma has plagued Jewish life from its earliest beginnings and does so by providing an illuminating commentary on the Joseph narrative in Genesis,
0122.
Wildavsky, Aaron. The Nursing Father: Moses as a Political Leader. Tuscaloosa: The University of Alabama Press, 1984.
116
Church and State A fresh examination of Moses, viewed from the standpoint of politics, attempts to enhance the reader’s understanding of political leadership and its role as an integral part of different political regimes.
0123.
Wilson, Andrew. The Nations in Deutero-Isaiah: A Study on Composition and Structure. Lewiston, N.Y.: The Edwin-Mellen Press, 1986. An exegetical study of Deutero-Isaiah’s attitude toward the gentiles and his universal claims for Yahweh’s sovereignty. Intended for specialists in the field.
The New Testament 0124.
Bammel, Ernst and C.F.D. Moule. Jesus and the Politics of His Day. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1984. A collection of twenty-six essays by sixteen authors refuting the thesis that Jesus and the early Christians were sympathetic to political messianism.
0125.
Barth, Karl. Community, State, and Church: Three Essays. Garden City, N.Y.: Doubleday and Co., 1960. The second of the three essays in this volume relates specifically to the church and the state in the New Testament; incisive and forceful, the essays were written by the Christian theologian who emerged in June 1933 as the theologian of the Confessional movement, which attempted to preserve the integrity of the Evangelical Church in Germany against corruption from within Nazi terror without.
0126.
Berrigan, Daniel S.J. Whereon to Stand: The Acts of the Apostles and Ourselves. Baltimore, Maryland Fortkamp Publishing Company, 1991. A biblical commentary on the Book of Acts in which the author advances the thesis that Acts and much of the Pauline Epistles represent a social and literary revolution.
0127.
Borg, Marcus J. Conflict, Holiness, and Politics in the Teaching of Jesus. New York: The Edwin Mellen Press, 1984. Takes note of the recent trend in biblical scholarship which, rather than excluding politics from the life and teachings of Jesus as in earlier periods of scholarship, now highlights the social and political factors which shaped the emergence of the Christian movement and the ministry of the historical Jesus.
Bibliographical Survey 0128.
117
Brandon, S. G. F. Jesus and the Zealots: A Study of the Political Factor in Primitive Christianity. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1968. Proposes that in Roman eyes Jesus was a dangerous political rebel who was executed by Pilate on the charge of sedition and portrays Jesus as a politically aware activist vigorously working against the Palestinian “Establishment”—the Roman occupying forces and Jerusalem’s collaborationist Jewish aristocracy; far from dying ignominiously, the author argues, Jesus in effect died a patriot’s death, a rebel-martyr for his people. While not claiming that Jesus was a Zealot himself, the author cites evidence suggesting Jesus was at least sympathetic to their cause.
0129.
Cassidy, Richard J. Christians and Roman Rule in the New Testament. New York: Crossroad, 2001. Attempts to provide the biblical tools that will enable Christians, while true to their faith, respond to diverse political systems, by illustrating how the New Testament documents portray, in different ways, the connection between Roman imperial rule and the emerging Jesus movement and how the texts themselves reveal appropriate responses for the early Christians to make.
0130.
Cassidy, Richard J. Jesus, Politics, and Society: A Study of Luke’s Gospel. Maryknoll, N.Y.: Orbis Books, 1978. The author demonstrates that Jesus was dangerous to the Roman Empire and a powerful threat to both the political and social structures of his time, based upon a reading of the Gospel of Luke in the light of Romanruled Palestine, an even greater threat to the principles of Roman rule than the Zealot policy could ever be.
0131.
Cassidy, Richard J. John’s Gospel in New Perspective: Christology and the Realities of Roman Power. Maryknoll, N.Y.: Orbis Books, 1992. Argues that the Christology in John’s Gospel is not mere theological theorizing, but a matter of immense political implications and that attempts to downplay the political-theological implications on grounds that there is clear separation between spiritual belief and politics are short-sighted and unbiblical.
0132.
Cassidy, Richard J. Society and Politics in the Acts of the Apostles. Maryknoll, N.Y.: 1987.
118
Church and State Highlights the social and political themes in the Book of Acts, particularly Paul’s relation to the Roman Empire, and suggests that Luke wanted to show Christians how to live in the Roman Empire and specifically to give them examples of how to cope with being tried before political officials.
0133.
Cassidy, Richard J. and Philip J Scharper. Political Issues in Luke-Acts. Maryknoll, N.Y.: Orbis Books, 1983. A collection of essays written in response to Richard J. Cassidy’s Jesus, Politics, and Society, in which he challenged the notion that Luke-Acts was written as a political apologetic; some of the essays in this volume take issue with this thesis on both political and methodological grounds. A stimulating and provocative volume.
0134.
Chester, Andrew. The Social Context of Early Christianity. Oxford: Polity Press, 1990. Stresses the importance of Judaism for an understanding of the New Testament and examines the social, political, and economic characteristics of first-century Palestine and thereby demonstrates the relevance of sociological and historical research to a contemporary understanding of the New Testament.
0135.
Crossan, John Dominic. Who Killed Jesus? Exposing The Roots of AntiSemitism in the Gospel Story of the Death of Jesus. San Francisco: Harper SanFrancisco, 1995. An analysis of the roots of anti-Semitism, which, the author says, are found in the N.T. account of the crucifiction: “The Jews Killed Jesus.”
0136.
Crossan, John Dominic. Jesus: A Revolutionary Biography. New York: HarperCollins Publishers, 1994. In examining the four gospels, the author attempts to provide a portrait of the historical Jesus from which he presents Jesus as a societal rebel who preached and practiced a message of radical egalitarianism and concludes that Jesus was more radical and threatening than any political revolutionary of his time or since.
0137.
Cullman, Oscar. Jesus and the Revolutionaries. New York: Harper and Row, 1970. Lays out arguments and biblical evidence for and against a radicalized concept of Jesus as one condemned and crucified by the Roman authorities
Bibliographical Survey
119
as a Zealot agitator because he was seen as a vocal critic of social injustices and engaged in what Romans saw only as political activity; while Jesus was a revolutionary, he was of an entirely different order from that of the politically motivated Zealots since his focus was on radical individual change and the source of revolution with Jesus lay not with man but in God. 0138.
Cullman, Oscar. The State in the New Testament. New York: Scribner’s Sons, 1956. An excellent and succinct study of the concept of the state in the New Testament; a classic Protestant interpretation.
0139.
Edwards, George R. Jesus and the Politics of Violence. New York: Harper and Row, 1972. Contends that all too often Christianity has been a chaplaincy form of religion wedded to arrogance of power and that to correct this Christians should not join counterrevolution, but should seek social change that is consonant with the nonviolent Jesus and the nature of human good.
0140.
Eller, Vernard. Christian Anarchy: Jesus’ Primacy over the Powers. Grand Rapids, Mich.: Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Co., 1987. Argues that Christian anarchy is a major theme in church history, finds it to have a strong Old Testament background, and identifies Jesus as the true founder of the tradition; Paul carried on the idea, but when the church became institutionalized as the official religion of the Roman Empire, the concept was all but lost until it resurfaced in the Anabaptism of the Reformation’s radical wing.
0141.
Elliott, Neil. Liberating Paul: The Justice of God and the Politics of the Apostle. Maryknoll, N.Y: Orbis Books, 1994. Far from advocating subservience to an “oppressive” and “patriarchal” political order, the author argues that Paul was a proponent of an early liberation theology and that, therefore, there is need for Christians today to practice an “ideological intifada” against contemporary oppressive structures.
0142.
Esler, Philip F. The First Christians in Their Social Worlds: SocialScientific Approaches to New Testament Interpretation. New York: Routledge, 1994.
120
Church and State Examines specific socio-political ideas in various texts of the New Testament, including charismatic phenomena, the admission of Gentiles into early Christian communities, and millenarianism and its relationship to political oppression.
0143.
Filson, Floyd Vivian. The New Testament Against Its Environment: The Gospel of Christ, the Risen Lord. Chicago: Greenery Gateway, 1950. Provides helpful insights concerning the life and work of Jesus in light of the environment and society of his day and analyzes the forces that led to his crucifixion.
0144.
Ford, J. Massyngberde. My Enemy Is My Guest: Jesus and Violence in Luke. Maryknoll, N.Y.: Orbis Books, 1984. An exposition of Luke’s presentation of Jesus as an advocate of nonviolence.
0145.
Foreman, Dale M. Crucify Him: A Lawyer Looks at the Trial of Jesus. Grand Rapids, Mich.: Zondervan, 1990. A legal examination of the trial of Jesus, in which the author as a lawyer presents a detailed analysis of the legality of the trials of Jesus and makes a comparison with modern political show trials and with the practices of modern zealots and pacifists.
0146.
Freudmann, Lillian C. Antisemitism in the New Testament. Lanham, MD: University Press of America, 1994. In the face of the long history of antisemitism, that has been virulent and widespread since the advent of Christianity, the author concludes that this association of Christianity with antisemitism is, at least in part, attributable to her findings that “nearly every book of the New Testament expresses slander and contempt of Jews”; while disclaiming that the purpose of this work is the defamation of Christian Scripture, the author argues that original Christian literature has been a “major factor” in creating and perpetuating hostility toward Jews.
0147.
Georgi, Dieter. Theocracy in Paul’s Praxis and Theology. Minneapolis, Minn.: Augsburg Fortress Press, 1991. Presents Paul’s theology as a critique of Hellenistic Roman political and cultural structures, especially as formulated in Augustan propaganda, and argues that Paul set forth radically democratized models of theocratic
Bibliographical Survey
121
concepts that challenge the fundamental ideological assumptions on which Roman imperial rule was based. 0148.
Griffith, D. R. The New Testament and the Roman State. Swansea, U. K.: John Perry Press, 1970. Following an introductory chapter on the political and historical background of the New Testament, the author surveys the subject of the Roman state in the various New Testament writings; both scholarly and readable, this work is an expansion of the Pantyfedwen Trust Lecture given in 1964.
0149.
Hengel, Martin. Victory over Violence: Jesus and the Revolutionists. Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1973. Argues that the position of Jesus and the early Christians was radically different from that of the Zealots: Jesus was the model of non-violence who demanded of his followers that they renounce violence and love their enemies and that, therefore, the Christian response should be similarly so today.
0150.
Hengel, Martin. Was Jesus a Revolutionist ? Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1971. Based upon the political background at the time of Jesus, especially in view of the Zealot movement, the author argues that Jesus’ ethical system was revolutionary but that his political actions were not.
0151.
Herron, George Davis. Between Caesar and Jesus. New York: Thomas Y. Crowell and Co., 1899. Eight lectures given in Willard Hall, Chicago, 24 October-12 December 1898, for the Christian Citizenship League, on the subject of the relationship of the Christian conscience to the existing social system.
0152.
Herzog, William R., II. Jesus, Justice, and the Reign of God: A Ministry of Liberation. Louisville: Westminster/John Knox Press, 2000. Argues that Jesus is intensely interested in the social, political, and economic well-being of humanity. The author focuses on Jesus’ actions, examining the conflict stories, exorcisms/healings, and the passion narrative.
122
Church and State
0153.
Herzog, William R., II. Parables as Subversive Speech: Jesus as Pedagogue of the Oppressed. Louisville, Ky.: Westminster/ John Knox Press, 1994. Argues that the focus of the parables of Jesus was not on a vision of the glory of the reign of God but on the disturbing details of how oppression served the interest of the ruling class and that the parables were a form of social analysis, as well as theological reflection.
0154.
Hollingshead, James R. The Household of Caesar and the Body of Christ: A Political Interpretation of the Letters from Paul. Lanham, Md.: University Press of America, 1998. Addresses the writings of the Apostle Paul in the political context of the Roman Near East of the first century. The author examine Paul’s worldview, placing special emphasis on the conception of time and human history. Then he explores Paul’s most common images of community beginning with the household, which Paul uses as a metaphor in a way that is at times consistent with and at times critical of Roman social practices.
0155.
Horsley, Richard A. Jesus and Empire: The Kingdom of God and the New World Disrder. Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 2002. Focuses on how Jesus’ proclamation of the Kingdom of God related to Roman and Herodian power politics and how modern ideologies stand before Jesus’ proclamations in the present world.
0156.
Horsley, Richard A. Jesus and the Spiral of Violence: Popular Jewish Resistance in Roman Palestine. San Francisco: Harper and Row, 1987. Opens up a new perspective on the Roman-dominated Jewish Palestine of Jesus’ time, viewing it as an “imperial situation” in which individual acts of violence were responses to institutionalized repression and injustice. The author explores Jewish resistance to Roman rule, emphasizing its popular and nonviolent character, and suggests that Jesus was primarily attempting to catalyze renewal of local communities in a ministry devoted to social, rather than political, revolution.
0157.
Horsley, Richard A., ed. Paul and Politics: Ekklesia, Israel, Imperialism, Interpretation: Essays in Honor of Krister Stendahl. Harrisburg, Penn.: Trinity Press International, 2000. Focuses on Paul not as a theologian but as a social figure within a distinct historical context and how to intrepret him rightly in his imperial context.
Bibliographical Survey 0158.
123
Jenks, Jeremiah W. The Political and Social Significance of the Life and Teachings of Jesus. New York: Young Men’s Christian Association Press, 1906. Particular attention is given in Study 3, “Jesus’ Conception of His Social Mission: Its Relation to the State,” and in Study 10, “Jesus’ Teaching Regarding Non-Resistance to Evil,” to the theme of church and state; still a helpful study.
0159.
Jewett, Robert. Paul, the Apostle to America: Cultural Trends and Pauline Scholarship. Louisville, Ky.: Westminster/John Knox Press, 1994. Using a nontechnical presentation of recent research, the author attempts to show how Paul engages and challenges American society; the author offers explorations of the relevance of Paul’s letters to the American scene and uses the resources of scientific biblical research that allows Paul’s message to be applied to trends in American culture, including popular entertainment and books that are brought into interaction with aspects of Pauline thought.
0160.
Kealy, Sean P. Jesus and Politics. Collegeville, Minn.: The Liturgica Press, a Michael Glazier Book, 1990. Explores the New Testament in an effort to discover Jesus’ views on living a life of peace and justice in a political world based upon the premise that the church cannot minister in the world and remain distant from matters of the state.
0161.
Kennard, J. Spencer. Render to God: A Study of the Tribute Passage. New York: Oxford University Press, 1950. Provides a fresh interpretation of the attitude of Jesus to his Messiahship and to his attitude to the Roman state, with many references to biblical passages.
0162.
Kent, Charles Foster. Social Teachings of the Prophets and Jesus. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1917. Singles out important social teachings of the Bible—social reform, democratic principles, citizenship, and the state—in the light of their historical setting and development.
0163.
Kik, J. Marcellus. Church and State in the New Testament. Philadelphia: Presbyterian and Reformed Publishing Co., 1962.
124
Church and State A brief and somewhat superficial treatment of the subject from a Reformed tradition perspective.
0164.
Liberty, Stephen. The Political Relations of Christ’s Ministry. London: Oxford University Press, 1916. Provides a strong political interpretation of the life and ministry of Jesus in Gospels and sees the political relations of Christ’s ministry against the background of the world’s need at that time and of the particular circumstances of the Gospel history; a controversial and provocative work.
0165.
Loewe, Herbert Martin James. “Render unto Caesar”: Religious and Political Loyalty in Palestine. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1940. Traces the line of Rabbinic teaching before and after the time of Jesus and shows that in the central teaching of “render unto Caesar” there runs a continuous line, a line which is analogous to that of Jesus and concludes that the situation in totalitarian states today affords a close parallel to the conditions under which Jesus lived.
0166.
Mathews, Shailer. A History of New Testament Times in Palestine. New York: Macmillan, 1933. Entire chapters of this study are devoted to church-state themes: “Antiochus Epiphanes and the Loss of Religious Liberty,” “Judas Maccabaeus and the Reestablishment of Religious Liberty,” “Jonathan and the Beginnings of Nationality,” “John Hyrcanus and Political Independence,” “The Roman Conquest of Israel,” along with themes of religious persecution and the rise of the Christian church.
0167.
McLaren, James S. Power and Politics in Palestine: The Jews and the Governing of Their Land 100 B.C-AD 70. 1991. Describes and defines the role and authority of the Jewish leadership, especially the Sanhedrin, in governing Palestine from 100 B.C.E. to 70 C.E.; omits use of Rabbinic materials and focuses exclusively on Josephus, the New Testament, Philo, and Tacitus and concludes that the important Jewish leaders were the chief priests and not the Pharisees.
0168.
Montgomery, John Warwick. Law and Gospel: A Study in Jurisprudence. Oak Park, Ill.: Christian Legal Society, 1978.
Bibliographical Survey
125
A brief study of analogies between secular legal principles and biblical or theological principles and concepts. Secular law is perceived as an illustration of God’s law. 0169.
Morrison, Clinton. The Powers that Be: Earthly Rules and Demonic Powers in Romans 13:1-7. London: SCM Press, Ltd., 1960. An excellent exegetical study of Romans 13 and its relevance to Christian freedoms and civil responsibility; originally written as a doctoral dissertation at the University of Basel.
0170.
Muntz, W. S. Rome, St. Paul, and the Early Church. London: J. Murray, 1913. An analysis of the influence of Roman law on Paul’s teaching and writing and on the development of the church.
0171.
Myers, Ched. Binding the Strong Man: A Political Reading of Mark’s Story of Jesus. Maryknoll, N. Y.: Orbis Books, 1988. The first commentary on the Gospel of Mark to apply systematically a multidisciplinary approach or socio-literary method; a political commentary that integrates literary criticism, socio-historical exegesis, and political hermeneutics in an investigation of Mark as a “manifesto of radical discipleship.”
0172.
Paupert, Jean-Marie. The Politics of the Gospel. New York: Holt, Rinehart, and Winston, 1969. Argues for an evangelical politics or presence in the rebuilding of the secular city and attempts to deepen the commitment of those struggling today against poverty, racism, and war; beginning with an examination of the political context of Jesus’ life, the author insists that the teachings of Jesus cannot be emptied of political content and gives fresh meaning to familiar phrases from the Gospels on the two kingdoms, the things that are Caesar’s, the Sabbath, war, patriotism, and the love of neighbor; highly recommended.
0173.
Penner, Archie. The Christian, the State, and the New Testament. Scottdale, Penn.: Herald Press, 1959. Brings into focus major problems of theology and ethics with respect to the Christian’s relation to society and the state that is in complete loyalty to the Scriptures; though the author does not claim to find a detailed guide
126
Church and State for contemporary Christian conduct, he does set forth main principles for a Christian’s relation to the state. A Mennonite interpretation.
0174.
Pobee, John S. Persecution and Martyrdom in the Theology of Paul. Sheffield, Eng.: JSOT Press, 1985. Presents an analysis of martyrological ideas in Paul’s writings and argues that these ideas are significant for crucial aspects of Pauline theology and that the ideas have been commonly underestimated.
0175.
Price, Jonathan J. Jerusalem under Siege: The Collapse of the Jewish State, 66-70 C.E. Leiden, The Netherlands: E. J. Brill, 1992. An internal history of the four years of the Jewish rebellion, which began with militant optimism in the year 66 and ended with the destruction of the Temple and city of Jerusalem four years later; classical, rabbinic, archaeological, and numismatic evidence are brought to bear in this new interpretation of Josephus’ Bellum Judaicum .
0176.
Richardson, Alan. The Political Christ. Waterloo, Ont.: Wilfrid Laurier University Press, 1991. Provides a look at the political environment during Jesus’ ministry and his relationship with those in authority and with the nationalist movements; delineates the influence of the political Christ on history and implications for churches and politics today.
0177.
Rivkin, Ellis. What Crucified Jesus? The Political Execution of a Charismatic. Nashville, Tenn.: Abingdon Press, 1984. A significant work by a noted Jewish scholar, who sets forth the thesis that “it was not the Jews who crucified Jesus, and it was not the Roman people—it was the imperial system which victimized the Jews, victimized the Romans, and victimized the spirit of God.”
0178.
Sandmel, Samuel. Anti-Semitism in the New Testament. Philadephia: Fortress Press 1978, 1978. A remarkably honest and straightforward examination of “anti-Jewish” or “anti-Judaism” references in the New Testament by an eminent Jewish scholar who devoted his life work to the study of early Christianity, and did so with a measure of sympathetic understanding and critical admiration.
Bibliographical Survey 0179.
127
Shenk, Calvin E. When Kingdoms Clash: The Christian and Ideologies. Scottdale, Perm.: Herald Press, 1988. Argues that the Kingdom of God, as taught by Jesus, judges all political, economic, and social systems and requires that a Christian’s first loyalty is to God.
0180.
Sherwin-White, A. N. Roman Society and Roman Law in the New Testament. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1963. Examines apparent differences among the Gospel accounts and the overall accuracy of the New Testament, and in so doing enriches the reader’s understanding of Roman society and politics.
0181.
Stringfellow, William. Conscience and Obedience: The Politics of Romans 13 and Revelation 13 in Light of the Second Coming. Waco, Tex.: Word Books, 1977. A detailed exposition of Romans 13 and Revelation 13 that brings valuable insights into sharp focus in a bold affirmation of a “biblical hope which comprehends politics” by examining simultaneously the much misused biblical texts of Romans 13 and Revelation 13 and argues that in order to “honor the emperor,” as Scripture commands, it becomes necessary to oppose him under certain circumstances; highly recommended.
0182.
Theissen, Gerd. The Gospels in Context: Social and Political History in the Synoptic Tradition. Minneapolis, Minn.: Fortress Press, 1991. Seeks to provide importance to the discipline of form-text criticism of the synoptic Gospels, taking particular interest in the political and social milieu of the period.
0183.
Trocmé, André. Jesus and the Nonviolent Revolution. Scottdale, Penn: Herald Press, 1973. Presents Jesus as a vigorous revolutionary who refused to use violence; surveys the history of violence and non-violence from Elijah to the time of Herod; and, finally, traces Jesus’ extension of the Jewish religious horizon and notes that in his political and social program he chose nonviolent resistance rather than the way of sacral violence to institute the kingdom; a helpful study.
0184.
Vonck, Pol. “All Authority Comes from God: Romans 13:1-7 —aTricky Text About Obedience to Political Power.” Afer (1984):338-47.
128
Church and State Interprets the biblical text of Romans 13:1-7 about obedience to political power and suggests that Paul’s concern remains valid and challenging: God is to be served in the political realm. Hence “to be enlisted” in the political remains an imperative, a task always to be tested in the light of the full biblical revelation and the signs of the times.
0185.
Waetjen, Herman C. A Reordering of Power: A Socio-Political Reading of Mark’s Gospel. Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1989. Traces the stark conflict between the new ordering of power announced by Jesus and the tenacious domination of the ruling elite in Israel’s agrarian society; written out of the author’s own experiences in the Third World.
0186.
Walaskay, Paul W. `And So We Came to Rome’: The Political Perspective of St. Luke. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1983. Challenges the traditional interpretation of Luke’s two volumes that they were written as an apology for Christianity, to demonstrate to the Roman authorities that the new faith was not a dangerous and subversive innovation and argues that Luke was writing to assure his fellow-Christians that church and empire need not fear or suspect each other; the author’s conclusion is supported by an investigation of the text of Luke-Acts, particularly the trials of Jesus and Paul.
0187.
Welborn, L. L. Politics and Rhetoric in the Corinthian Epistles. Macon, Ga.: Mercer University Press, 1997. Attempts to show that Paul was thoroughly familiar with the conventions of ancient political life, and illustrates how Paul made use of political ideas and strategies to shape the Christian community.
0188.
Wengst, Klaus. Pax Romana: And the Peace of Jesus Christ. Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1987. An examination of Christian responses to Roman rule, ranging from the positive assessment of Luke and Clement of Rome to the vigorous denunciation of the author of the Apocalypse
0189.
Wink, Walter. Jesus and Nonviolence: A Third Way. Minneapolis, Minn.: Augsburg Fortress Press, 2002. Shows how Jesus’ message relates to politics and nonviolence can win the day even when others resort to terror.
Bibliographical Survey 0190.
129
Wink, Walter. Engaging the Powers: Discernment and Resistance in a World of Domination. Minneapolis, Minn.: Augsburg Fortress Press, 1992. Analyzes what happens when social institutions, systems, and structures dominate instead of serve.
0191.
Wink, Walter. Naming the Powers: The Language of Power in the New Testament. Minneapolis, Minn: Fortress Press, 1984. A good exposition on the principalities and powers in the New Testament which underscores their relevance to church and state in the New Testament and for today.
0192.
Yoder, John Howard. The Politics of Jesus: Vicit Agnus Noster. Grand Rapids, Mich.: Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Co., 1972. The author, a Christian pacifist, presents Jesus as “a model for radical political action” in expounding “the doctrine of powers”; the second edition is a thorough revision of the 1972 text, providing updated interaction with publications touching on this subject and, following most of the chapters, new “epilogues” that summarize research that continues to support the insights set forth in the original work; an important work.
0193.
Zeitlin, Irving M. Jesus and the Judaism of His Time. New York: Basil Blackwell, Inc., 1988. A historical reassessment of the life of Jesus in the light of the religious, political, and sociological climate of first-century Israel, including analyses of the social structure of Palestine under Roman occupation, the prevalent sects and movements, and the relationship between the ruling Jewish circles and the Roman authorities.
Christianity and the State General 0194.
Altman, Walter. Luther and Liberation: A Latin American Perspective. Minneapolis, Minn.: Augsburg Fortress Publishers, 1992. Provides readings of Luther’s central theological commitments and his forays into economics, politics, education, violence, and war and thereby
130
Church and State poses challenges to all those who would hail—or decry—Luther and his legacy.
0195.
Arthur, William. The Popes, the Kings and the People: A History of the Movement to Make the Pope Governor of the World. London: Hodder and Stroughton, 1877. Written from a view that is critical of Vatican policies.
0196.
Attwater, Donald. Martyrs: From St. Stephen to John Tung. New York: Sheed and Ward, 1957. Provides sketches of prominent Christian and Roman Catholic martyrs up to the mid-twentieth century, showing how both Catholics and Protestants were among the persecuted and the persecutors.
0197.
Baker, Derek. Church, Society, and Politics. Oxford: Basil Blackwell, 1975. Papers read at the Thirteenth Summer Meeting and Fourteenth Winter Meeting of the Ecclesiastical History Society. The twenty-three essays in this volume cover a wide range of subjects, including: “Early Christian Attitudes to Property and Slavery,” “Church, Society, and Politics in the Early Fifteenth Century as Viewed from an English Pulpit,” “Luther and the Right of Resistance to the Emperor,” “Was the Protestant Reformation a Revolution?,” “Jansenism and Politics in the Eighteenth Century,” “Church and State in Borneo,” “The Barmen Declaration,” and “Church and Politics: Dorothy Buxton and the German Church Struggle.” Taken together, the essays show the complexity of the relationship.
0198.
Barker, William S. and W. Robert Godfrey. . Theonomy: A Reformed Critique. Grand Rapids, Mich.: Zondervan Publishing House, 1990. Contains a collection of sixteen essays which seek to provide a constructive critique of the Christian Reconstruction movement and conclude that theonomy in various ways represents a distorted view of continuities and discontinuities between the Old Testament and today.
0199.
Bernhart, Joseph. The Vatican as a World Power. New York: Longmans, Green, and Co., 1939. An objective and informative analysis.
0200.
Bevan, Wilson Lloyd. Gospel and Government: The Development of the Christian State. New York: Church Missions House, 1914.
Bibliographical Survey
131
Traces the historical development of the concept of the Christian state. 0201.
Brezzi, Paolo. The Papacy: Its Origins and Historical Evolution. Westminster, Md.: Newman Press, 1958. An examination of the nature, purpose, and political role of the papacy in Western culture.
0202.
Brown, Peter. The Rise of Western Christendom: Triumph and Diversity, A.D. 200-1000. Cambridge: Blackwell Publishers, 1996. Traces the history of the distinctly Eastern Christendoms, centered first in Byzantium and later spreading to the Balkans and to Russia, and of Western Christendom focused on Rome but with powerfully independent centers in France, Germany, England, and Ireland; the author moves constantly from the religious and the theological to the social and secular and explains how by the end of the period Christianity had become the dominant factor in political power as well as in the cultural life throughout the region.
0203.
Bruland, Esther Byle. A Passion for Jesus: A Passion for Justice. Valley Forge, Penn.: Judson Press, 1983. Provides biblical and theological reasons why Christians must respond to suffering and injustice; a resource for church groups and individual members to assist them in using their abilities and resources for uplifting the poor and seeking justice for the oppressed.
0204.
Brunner, Emil. Christianity and Civilisation; Gifford Lectures. New York: Scribner’s Sons, 1948. Outlines a Christian philosophy of civilization, first examining the material in each of the separate spheres relevant to his argument for the uncompromising conclusion that Christianity, alone and without qualification, can provide the basis on which a stable civilization can be built, one that is adequate to satisfy the requirements of a worthwhile society; note particularly, 2:101-39.
0205.
Cheetham, Samuel. History of the Christian Church during the First Six Centuries. New York: Macmillan, 1905. An older work which gives particular attention to the early struggles of the church, its divisions and its opponents, its relationship to the state and empire and law and society.
132 0206.
Church and State Chenu, Bruno et al. The Book of Christian Martyrs. New York: Crossroad, 1990. Brings together the history of selected martyrs and acts of martyrdom, beginning with the first centuries, from the Middle Ages to the nineteenth century, and on up to the twentieth century including Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Martin Luther King Jr., and Oscar Arnulfo Romero, showing their diversity and some of the meanings of martyrdom.
0207.
Coote, Robert B. and Mary P. Coote. Power, Politics, and the Making of the Bible: An Introduction. Minneapolis, Minn.: Augsburg Fortress Press, 1990. Examines the powerful and sometimes surprising sociopolitical motivations behind the writing and canonization of the Bible; covers the entire biblical and early church period, including the canonization of both testaments, up to the sixth century.
0208.
Crapsey, Algernon Sidney. Religion and Politics. New York: T. Whittaker, 1905. A collection of lectures on church and state, beginning with the attitude of Jesus to the state and Jesus’ method of government and including essays on “The Democratic Church in the Imperial State,” “The Subjection of the Eastern Church to the State,” “The Supremacy of the Church in the West,” “The Fall of the Medieval Church,” “The Rise of National Churches,” and “The Relation of Church and State in the United States.”
0209.
Curtis, Lionel. Civitas Dei: The Commonwealth of God. New York: Macmillan Co., 1934. Examines how the concept of Christendom developed through the centuries.
0210.
Danielou, Jean and H. Marrou. The Christian Centuries: A New History of the Catholic Church: The First Six Hundred Years. New York: McGrawHill Book Co., 1964. Illustrations selected and annotated by Peter Ludlow. Examines the history of the early centuries of the Christian era, including Christianity beginning as a small group of devout Jews, the opposition of the Roman Empire, the period of martyrdom, and how Christianity was able gradually to effect a radical change throughout the Empire; written from a Roman Catholic perspective.
Bibliographical Survey 0211.
133
Dawson, Christopher H. The Formation of Christendom. New York: Sheed and Ward, 1967. Traces the formation of Christendom from its roots in the Judeo-Christian tradition to the rise and the decline of medieval Christendom; as in all of his works, the author sees religion as the dynamic element of culture and society.
0212.
Dawson, Christopher. Religion and the Rise of Western Culture. New York: Doubleday, 1957. A brilliant synthesis of the role of religion in the formation of Western civilization; widely recognized as a classic work, it remains timely for today.
0213.
Drake, H. A. Constantine and the Bishops: The Politics of Intolerance. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press, 2000. Despite Constantine’s conversion to Christianity, the author argues that Rome remained a world filled with gods and with men seeking to depose rivals for power, and shows how Christian belief motivated and gave shape to imperial rule.
0214.
D’Souza, Jerome, S.J. The Church and Civilization: An Appraisal of the Church’s Relations with Secular Cultures. Garden City, N.Y.: Doubleday, 1967. Examines the church in the Greco-Roman world, the emergence of Europe and of national cultures, revolution and reconstruction in the sixteenth century, and the church and civilizations of Asia and America.
0215.
Ehler, Sidney Z. Twenty Centuries of Church and State: A Survey of Their Relations in Past and Present. Westminster, Md.: Newman Press, 1957. A brief and simple survey of church-state relations through the centuries; written with a strong Roman Catholic bias.
0216.
Ehler, Sidney Z. and John B. Morral, Church and State through the Centuries: A Collection of Historic Documents with Commentaries. Westminster, Md.: Newman Press, 1954.
134
Church and State Contains seventy-nine documents, from Trojan to Communism, with brief introductory commentaries; a reliable and scholarly source book now limited by its date of publication.
0217.
Eidsmoe, John. God and Caesar: Christian Faith and Political Action. Westchester, Ill.: Crossway Books, 1984. Argues that Christians must be involved in their government since they have a firmer basis than anyone else for judging right and wrong; includes a review of what the Bible says about governmental policies.
0218.
Elazar, Daniel J. Covenant and Commonwealth: From Christian Separation Through the Protestant Reformation. Brunswick, N. J.: Transaction Publishers, 1995. The second in a series of volumes exploring the covenantal tradition in Western politics, this volume examines covenant as a political idea and tradition along with the culture and behavior they produced; focuses on the struggle in Europe to produce a Christian covenantal commonwealth, a struggle that climaxed in the Reformed Protestantism of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, and also briefly examines covenant and hierarchy in Islam and other premodern politics that shape our present.
0219.
Elazar, Daniel J. Covenant and Constitutionalism: The Great Frontier and the Matrix of Federal Democracy. New Brunswick, N. J.: Transaction Publishers, 1998. Traces the trends and the developing relationships of constitutionalism and covenant that ultimately led to the transformation of the latter into the former and explores these first steps and the subsequent paths that emerged out of the constitutionalized covenantal tradition in Europe such as federalism, communitarianism, and the cooperative movement; and argues how these covenantal ideas and expressions were both supported and challenged by liberal democracy and individualism as they unfolded in the latter part of the modern epoch and immediately thereafter. A monumental series by a Jewish scholar.
0220.
Ellingsen, Mark. The Cutting Edge: How Churches Speak on Social Issues. Grand Rapids, Mich.: Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Co., 1993. Surveys the many hundreds of often-controversial declarations made since 1964 by a wide variety of churches on nine “cutting-edge” issues: racism, economic development, ecology, war and peace, marriage, abortion, genetic engineering, social justice, and socio-political ideologies;
Bibliographical Survey
135
the most complete summary and analysis ever made of church social statements. 0221.
Ferguson, Everett. Backgrounds of Early Christianity. Grand Rapids, Mich.: Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Co., 1981. Provides an analytical and a systematic introduction to the Roman, Greek, and Jewish political, social, and religious backgrounds of the New Testament and the early church.
0222.
Ferguson, Everett, Michael P. McHugh, Frederick W. Norris, and David M. Scholar, Encyclopedia of Early Christianity. New York: Garland Publishing, Inc., 1990. Provides an important reference source on the origins and early development of the Christian faith; among the topics covered are pagan and Jewish writers important to early Christianity, Roman emperors and other political leaders, persecutions of Christians for heresies and schisms, and church-state relations.
0223.
Ferguson, Everett. Orthodoxy, Heresy, and Schism in Early Christianity. New York: Garland Publishing, 1993. Contains a collection of sixteen essays by various scholars who focus on the arguments used by the church in its struggle with its opponents and the means employed to achieve unity of belief: tradition, the Rule of Faith, and the Apostles’ Creed and examines the various expressions of Christian belief in the early centuries: Marcionism, Montanism, and Donatism and argues that in addition to doctrinal differences, social, national, and personal factors were at work in the religious controversies and division which must be considered and assessed
0224.
Figgis, John Neville. Churches in the Modern State. London: Longmans, Green, and Co., 1913. Argues that the problem of church and state is concerned not with ecclesiastical pretensions so much as with the nature of human life in society; contains four scholarly lectures on “the free church in the free state” concept and the Res Publica Christiana and reflects a passionate concern for freedom in the face of the state’s growing powers.
0225.
Flathman, Richard E. Thomas Hobbes: Skepticism, Individuality, and Chastened Politics. Newbury Park, Calif: Sage Publications, 1993.
136
Church and State Treats Hobbes as a major contributor to and intellectual resource for modern political thinking and practice; aims to do, according to the author, what Hobbes often did to his own philosophical predecessors—“to wrench him out of his context, to thrust him into ours, make his texts speak to questions of present philosophical and especially moral and political concerns.”
0226.
Gavin, Frank Stanton Burnes. Seven Centuries of the Problem of Church and State. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1971. A distinguished historical review that is worthy of careful reading.
0227.
Geffcken, Friedrich Heinrich. Church and State: Their Relations Historically Developed. London: Longmans, Green, and Co., 1877. A scholarly work, but reflects a Victorian viewpoint.
0228.
Greenslade, Stanley Lawrence. Church and State from Constantine to Theodosius. London: SCM Press, 1954. An important study of a crucial period in church-state relations, beginning with the “Christian” emperor, Constantine, then examining the freedom of the church and emergence of the dualistic theory of church and state, and, finally, tracing the beginning of the ascendancy of the church, which would continue throughout the Middle Ages; a helpful summary.
0229.
Greenslade, Stanley Lawrence. The Church and the Social Order: A Historical Sketch. London: SCM Press, 1948. Provides a historical summary that is largely confined to the role of the church and organized Christian movements in the political, economic, and public life of Western civilization, with particular consideration in the final chapter to the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries in England.
0230.
Hall, Douglas John. The End of Christendom and the Future of Christianity. Valley Forge, Penn.: Trinity Press International, 1996. The thesis of this volume is that the Christian movement can have a very significant future, one that will be faithful to the original vision of the movement and of immense service to the beleaguered world of today; but to have that future, the author proposes that the churches make their disestablishment work for good and describes how the Christian movement might serve dominant societies, classes, and institutions in a post-Christian era.
Bibliographical Survey 0231.
137
Hayes, Carlton J. H. Christianity and Western Civilization. Stanford, Calif.: Stanford University Press, 1954. Sets forth the thesis that certain distinctive features of Western civilization, specifically its ideals of freedom, limited government, and compassion have been derived from and inspired by its historic religion.
0232.
Herrin, Judith. The Formation of Christendom. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1989. Treats the crises of the Christian Roman Empire from Constantine to Charlemagne and provides an introduction to the major military and religious upheavals of the late ancient and early medieval world..
0233.
Hyma, Albert. Christianity and Politics: A History of the Principles and Struggles of Church and State. Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott Co., 1938. A good, reliable and thoroughly readable history prior to World War II.
0234.
Innes, A. Taylor. Church and State: A Historical Handbook. Edinburgh: T. & T. Clark, 1890. Provides a general historical survey of the history of church and state in the Christian West from the time of the primitive church to 1870 in Europe and America.
0235.
Johnson, F. Ernest. Foundations of Democracy: A Series of Addresses. New York: Institute for Religious and Social Studies, 1947. Analyzes the historical, philosophical, and religious sources of democracy in light of changing world conditions; essays contributed by eighteen distinguished scholars.
0236.
Kaufman, Peter Iver. Redeeming Politics. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1990. While presenting episodes from the fourth through the sixteenth centuries, the author discusses such figures as Constantine, Augustine, Charlemagne, Pope Gregory VII, Dante, Zwingli, Calvin, and Cromwell to show how chroniclers and apologists attempted to explain both the success and the failure of political campaigns in terms of God’s plan for a triumphant Christian culture.
138 0237.
Church and State Kee, Howard C. et al. Christianity: A Social and Cultural History. New York: Macmillan, 1991. Describes the rise and growth of Christianity in its interactions with the changing social and cultural setting of the past two thousand years rather than a history of the development of doctrines and institutions; attention is given in each of the five parts of this volume to the interactions and conflicts between Christianity and the state and the accommodation of Christianity to its environment.
0238.
Kik, Jacob Marcellus. Church and State: The Story of Two Kingdoms. New York: Nelson, 1963. A survey of church and state relations from the time of Christ to the present; includes bibliography for further study.
0239.
Knight, Derrick. Beyond the Pale: The Christian Political Fringe. London: Kogan Page, 1982. Brings to light significant and disturbing information on the Christian and political groups currently leading a crusade against the World Council of Churches and reveals their connections with extreme Right-wing political movements, including an overview of these Right-wing groupings, their strategies, their activities, and the people who run them; the South African connection is examined in detail, but attention is also given to the similar campaigns in Great Britain and the major industrial countries of Europe, North America, Australia, and New Zealand.
0240.
Latourette, Kenneth Scott. “Colonialism and Missions: Progressive Separation.” Journal of Church and State 7 (Autumn 1965): 330-49.. In reviewing the expansion of Christianity from a historical perspective, the author notes that until the closing years of the eighteenth century Protestant missions were generally independent of government, but with the political and commercial expansion of Europe and the United States, some governments sought to use Christian missions to promote their own political ambitions through supporting Christian missions
0241.
Lea, Henry Charles. A History of the Inquisition in the Middle Ages. New York: Russell and Russell, 1955. Long regarded as a classic work, it is written with considerable objectivity in the treatment of the subject; chronicles the origin and development of the inquisitorial process in Western Europe—its structure, its methods of interrogation and trial, and its treatment of evidence.
Bibliographical Survey 0242.
139
Lehmann, Paul. The Transfiguration of Politics. New York: Harper and Row, 1975. Argues that the relevance of Jesus Christ to an age of revolution is to be found in the “power of his presence to shape the passion for humanization that generates revolution” and thereby preserves revolution from its own pull toward self-destruction; what is required is nothing less than the “transfiguration” of politics and thereby bring human meaning to politics.
0243.
Linder, Robert D. God and Caesar: Case Studies in the Relationship Between Christianity and the State. Longview, Tex.: Conference on Faith and History, 1971. Based on the premise that the relationship of Christianity to the state has been and remains an enduring problem throughout the history of Christianity, this volume of essays includes a wide range of case studies, from the persecution of Christians in the Roman Empire to Baptists as “subversives” in the Soviet Union.
0244.
Marshall, Paul. Thine Is the Kingdom: A Biblical Perspective on the Nature of Government and Politics Today. Grand Rapids, Mich.: Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Co., 1986. Stresses that politics is neither a realm apart from the gospel nor the center of the gospel, but rather is a part of overall Christian service, whose goal is that all aspects of human life should be brought together by God through Christ.
0245.
Martinich, A. P. The Two Gods of Leviathan: Thomas Hobbes on Religion and Politics. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1992. Contrary to the view of Hobbes as a purely secular thinker, the author argues that religious concerns pervade Leviathan and that Hobbes was really intent on providing a rational defense of the Calvinistic Church of England that flourished under the reign of James I and that Christian doctrine, for Hobbes, is not politically destabilizing and is consistent with modern science.
0246.
Mason, Roger. Knox: On Rebellion. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995. Includes the most significant political writings of the Protestant Reformer, John Knox, and presents all of his writings on rebellion, including his
140
Church and State First Blast of the Trumpet against the Monstrous Regiment of Women, and thereby provides the means of tracing the evolution of his political radicalism and evaluating its impact; the first comprehensive edition of Knox’s political writings.
0247.
Moore, R. I. The Formation of a Persecuting Society: Power and Deviance in Western Europe, 950-1250. Cambridge, Mass.: Basil Blackwell, Inc., 1987. Examines the emergence of popular heresy and the establishment of the Inquisition and the expropriation and mass murder of Jews and argues that the treatment of Jews and other minorities was part of a pattern of persecution that created the foundation for racism in Europe today.
0248.
Morris, William Dale. The Christian Origins of Social Revolt. London: Allen and Unwin, 1949. Beginning with an analysis of heretical sects, the author then traces the part that primitive Christian communism played in the great peasant revolts and shows how Christianity took on a revolutionary significance among the Taborites and Anabaptists, examines the social significance of the Reformation and the various non-conformist movements in Britain that attempted to apply the Christian ethic to the reshaping of social order, and finally looks at the part the Christian tradition played in the rise of the modern British Socialist movement
0249.
Neill, Stephen. Colonialism and Christian Missions. New York: McGrawHill Book Co., 1966. In this, the first history of the relationship between the cross and the flag during the colonial era, the author examines the basis of this alliance in which the military and political powers perverted the tenets of Christian faith while ostensibly fostering the spread of Christianity; a balanced and reliable work, highly recommended.
0250.
Oakeshott, Michael. Religion, Politics, and the Moral Life. New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 1993. Written by Britain’s leading twentieth-century political philosopher, this volume contains the author’s early essays on religion and theology, and includes four important unpublished essays and six essays that appeared in remote and inaccessible journals; includes a substantial introduction by the editor.
Bibliographical Survey 0251.
141
Oldham, J. H., ed. The Oxford Conference on Church, Community, and State; Official Report. Chicago: Willet, Clark, and Co., 1937. The official report of the historic conference at Oxford, England, July 1937, on “Church, Community, and State”; presented around major themes of “Church and Community”; “Church and State”; “Church, Community, and State in Relation to the Economic Order”; “Church, Community, and State in Relation to Education”; and “the Universal Church and the World of Nations.”
0252.
Palmer, Frederic. Heretics, Saints, and Martyrs. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1925. Includes cases studies from church history, highlighting the theme of the title of this volume; note especially essays on “The Anabaptists and Their Relation to Civil and Religious Liberty” and “Perpetua and Felicitas, Martyrs and Saints.”
0253.
Parker, Thomas. Christianity and the State in the Light of History. New York: Harper and Brothers, 1955. An excellent historical overview, including the early church, the Middle Ages, and Reformation period (although now dated). Originally delivered as the Bampton Lectures.
0254.
Questier, Michael C. Conversion, Politics, and Religion in England, 1580-1625. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1996. Concentrates on the experience of individual conversion in England during the Reformation when English Protestants urged a change from popery to the Gospel, while Catholics persuaded people from heresy and schism to unity, and investigates the political implications of conversion.
0255.
Rabbie, Edwin. Hugo Grotius: Ordinum Hollandiae ac Westfrisiae Pietas (1613). Leiden, The Netherlands: E. J. Brill, 1995. Contains Hugo Grotius’ first work in the field of church and state; it was written to defend the policy of the States of Holland, which was being attacked by the orthodox Calvinistic party in the Netherlands; this work remains as one of the key texts for knowledge of the religious disputes in the Netherlands during the Twelve Years’ Truce (1609-1621).
0256.
Rahner, Hugo, S. J. Church and State in Early Christianity. San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 1992.
142
Church and State Reviews the relationship of church and state during the first eight centuries, from Christianity’s being persecuted, to tolerated, to being mandated as the Roman Empire’s official religion and argues that the church encountered during those early centuries, in principle, all the forms of church-state relationships it would face in the future.
0257.
Rogers, G. A. J. Locke’s Philosophy: Content and Context. New York: Oxford University Press, 1994. A collection of essays by a distinguished international group of scholars who look both at core areas of Locke’s philosophy and political theory, including the links between Locke’s philosophy and his religious and political thought.
0258.
Runciman, Sir Steven. The Great Church in Captivity: A Study of the Patriarchate of Constantinople from the Eve of the Turkish Conquest to the Greek War of Independence. London: Cambridge University Press, 1968. Written primarily to give particular attention to the Greek Church under the Ottoman Sultans, a period that is comparatively little known, in order to bring greater understanding to what happened to the “Great Church” during the dark centuries of its captivity, and to the Greek Church when its relations ended.
0259.
Stith, Charles R. Political Religion: A Liberal Answer to the Question, ‘Should Religion and Politics Mix?’ Nashville: Abingdon Press, 1995. Offers a framework for putting one’s Christian faith into action in order to engage in the body politics religiously; the author argues that being religious means being political and that it is not an option but an obligation that one’s politics reflects one’s religion.
0260.
Sturzo, Luigi. Church and State. New York: Longmans Green, 1939. Long regarded as a classic study in historiography, written from a liberal Catholic position, reviewing the history of church-state relations from the early history of Christianity to 1938, especially in Europe; divided into three parts: “The Church and Christendom,” “The Church and the Modern State,” and “The Secular Church in the State.” A well-organized scholarly work that remains a valuable resource.
0261.
Sutherland, Arthur E. The Church Shall Be Free: A Glance at Eight Centuries of Church and State. Charlottesville: The University Press of Virginia, 1965.
Bibliographical Survey
143
Published for the Magna Carta Commission of Virginia; a very brief but helpful historical review essay. 0262.
Temple, William. Christianity and the State. London: Macmillan, Ltd., 1928. A future Archbishop of Canterbury analyses the historic theories of the state both in its internal and external relations.
0263.
Villa-Vicencio, Charles. Between Christ and Caesar: Classic and Contemporary Texts on Church and State. Grand Rapids, Mich.: Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Co., 1986. Contains a collection of valuable primary texts from each major period of church history: “The Early Church,” “The Medieval Church,” “The Church of the Reformation,” “The Church of Radical Protestantism,” “The Church of the Third Reich,” “The Church of Vatican II,” “The Latin American Church,” “The Black Church,” “The Church in Africa,” “The Eastern Orthodox Church,” and a series of documents from the South African context.
0264.
Westin, Gunnar. The Free Church Through the Ages. Nashville, Tenn.: Broadman Press, 1958. Based on extensive research, the author brings the free church movement into sharp focus and provides an understandable account of the courage and dedication that enabled the free churches to continue and survive in spite of formidable opposition and persecution; a highly reliable resource.
Roman Empire 0265.
Alföldi, Andrew. The Conversion of Constantine and Pagan Rome. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1948. Attempts to depict the religious development of Constantine as it is reflected in his fight with the only pagan group capable of resisting him and concludes with the triumph of intolerance in Constantine’s religious policy.
0266.
Arnold, Eberhard. The Early Christians After the Death of the Apostles: Selected and Edited from all the Sources of the First Centuries. Rifton, N. Y.: Plough Publishing House, 1970.
144
Church and State Drawing from the oldest sources of church history, the author explores the life, witness, worship, dedication, and martyrdom of the early Christians—in their own words and from accounts of their contemporaries—persecutors, pagan philosophers, political officials, and Roman emperors.
0267.
Bainton, Roland. Early Christianity. New York: Van Nostrand, 1960. Traces the dramatic history of Christianity during its first five centuries, including the struggle with the Roman Empire and with rival religions, the attitude of the church toward ethical and social questions, and the reason for the triumph of Christianity in the Roman Empire; contains brief selections from crucial documents.
0268.
Bardy, Gustave. The Church at the End of the First Century. London: Sands and Co., 1938. Note, particularly, the latter chapters of this volume in which the author addresses questions relating to “Heresy at the End of the First Century” and “Christianity and the Roman Empire.”
0269.
Barnard, Leslie W. “Church-State Relations, A.D. 313-337” Journal of Church and State 24:337-355. 1982. Analyzes Constantine’s religious role and points out that under Theodosius the church became the preferred institution of the Empire and examines the profound differences in the attitudes of Eastern and Western Christendom toward the state in the fourth century and that these differences reflected contrasting social, cultural, and geographical factors.
0270.
Barnes, Arthur Stapylton. Christianity at Rome in the Apostolic Age: An Attempt at Reconstruction of History. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, 1971. Attempts to reconstruct the history of the Apostolic period from the scanty sources available—documentary, archaeological, and traditional—which connects the Apostles with the city of Rome; note especially the chapters on “The Neronian Persecution” and “The Year of the Four Emperors.”
0271.
Barnes, Timothy D. Athanasius and Constantius: Theology and Politics in the Constantinian Empire. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1993. Focuses on Athanasius’ long struggle with Constantius, a struggle amply documented in the works of Athanasius composed to defend himself
Bibliographical Survey
145
against charges of treason and murder. The author argues that Athanasius’ writings are riddled with deliberate misrepresentations, which historians have through the ages all too uncritically accepted, and demonstrates that religious policy and ecclesiastical politics were a constant and central concern to the emperors of the fourth century. 0272.
Baynes, Norman H. Constantine the Great and the Christian Church. London: H. Milford, 1930. An appreciative and highly positive account of the role of Constantine in the history of Christianity and his vision of the New Rome which he had founded; the author concludes that Constantine, “the religiossimus Augustus,” has his place among “the seers and prophets” and may well be called the “thirteenth” Apostle.
0273.
Benko, Stephen. Pagan Rome and the Early Christians. Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1984. Examines specific issues which separated Christians and pagans and provoked a hostility based upon some truth and much rumor about Christians and their use of magic; the author maintains, “Christians used objects, rites, words, and formulas charged with divine potency to force demons to yield, all in accordance with well-known contemporary rules of magic.”
0274.
Benko, Stephen and John J. O’Rourke, eds. The Catacombs and the Colosseum: The Roman Empire and the Setting of Primitive Christianity. Valley Force, Penn.: Judson Press, 1971. This is a scholarly analysis of the social and political forces which affected the development of the early Christian church. Topics discussed include political and imperial history, social classes and social conflict, Roman law, education, the military system, the role of the Jews, religious policies of the Empire, and other associations similar to the church organization.
0275.
Bigg, Charles. The Church’s Task under the Roman Empire. New York: Oxford University Press, 1905. Contends for the “extreme importance” of studying the relation between the Empire and the Church in the period which preceded the recognition of Christianity by Constantine and, further, for ascertaining as clearly as possible the intellectual, moral, and material condition of the people in the Church.
146 0276.
Church and State Bishop, John. Nero: The Man and the Legand. New York: A. S. Barnes and Co., 1964. The author makes no attempt to moralize about the character of Nero, whose unspeakable cruelty is well-known, but to present an honest biography in which truth is unravelled from the skein of myth and falsehood which has surrounded Nero, the fifth Emperor of Rome. The author pays particular attention to the background of the persecution of the Christians in 64 C.E., uses much material from the Epistles of the New Testament, and arrives at a conclusion that may surprise many readers.
0277.
Bowersock, G. W. Martyrdom and Rome. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1995. Examines the historical context of the earliest Christian martyrs, and anchors their self-sacrifice to the everyday life and outlook of the cities (mostly Greek) of the Roman Empire by exploring the remains of contemporary documents of martyrdoms in the centuries before Constantine, and thereby attempts to provide a historical explanation of why martyrdom occurred when and as it did.
0278.
Boyarin, Daniel. Dying for God: Maartyrdom and the Making of Christianity and Judaism. Stanford, Cal.: Stanford University Press, 1999. The author maintains that we can and need to speak of a twin birth of Christianity and Judaism, not a genealogy in which one is parent to the other. In this book, the author develops a revised understanding of the interactions between nascent Christianity and nascent Judaism in late antiquity.
0279.
Boyd, William Kenneth. The Ecclesiastical Edicts of the Theodosian Code. New York: Columbia University Press, 1905. Examines and analyzes the relationship between church and state in the fourth and fifth centuries, as revealed in the laws of the emperors, but with particular attention to the position of the church, and to evaluate the influence of that relationship in shaping conditions in medieval Europe.
0280.
Brakke, David. Athanasius and the Politics of Asceticism. New York: Oxford University Press, 1995. In this study of one of the central figures of the church in the fourth century, the author shows just how deeply political ascetic theology could
Bibliographical Survey
147
also be in the struggle to form a united and dominant church in Egypt under the Roman Empire 0281.
Brown, Peter. Authority and the Sacred: Aspects of the Christianisation of the Roman World. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1995. Examines the factors that proved decisive and the compromises that made the emergence of the Christian “thought world” possible, and shows how Christian holy men were less representative of a triumphant and intransigent faith than negotiators, at ground level, of a working compromise between the new faith and traditional ways of dealing with the religious world.
0282.
Burtchaell, James Tunstead. From Synagogue to Church: Public Services and Offices in the Earliest Christian Communities. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1992. Shows that the first-century Jews knew only one form of community organization, that of the synagogue and argues that the three-level structure of offices in the synagogue—president, elders, and assistant—emerged as the most plausible antecedent for the Christian offices which stand forth clearly in the second century and, therefore, the synagogue offices were present from the moment the early Christians began to form their own congregations.
0283.
Bury, J. B. The Constitution of the Later Roman Empire. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1910. Provides a brief analysis of the constitution of the later Roman Empire in which church and state were not only indivisible, as in the West, but in the Eastern Empire the church is made a department of the state which the emperor directs and the Patriarch of Constantinople is, in effect, the emperor’s minister of the department of religion, in contrast to the West where the pope claimed supreme authority in temporal as well as in religious affairs.
0284.
Cadoux, Cecil John. The Early Church and the World. Edinburgh: T. and T. Clark, 1925. Examines and analyzes the attitude of Jesus and his followers—in the period preceding the Constantinian settlement—towards the nonChristian society around them, particularly in its political aspect; a reliable resource.
148 0285.
Church and State Cameron, Averill. The Later Roman Empire. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1993. Examines the transformation of the Roman Empire into a Christian culture and the shift of power from Rome to Constantinople and, in turn, the Christianization of the Empire and the cultural diversity, represented by figures as different as Ju Apostate and St. Augustine.
0286.
Canfield, Leon Hardy. The Early Persecutions of the Christians. London: Longmans, 1913. Examines the early persecutions of Christians with the documents upon which the opinions expressed in the text are based; each chapter in the first part corresponds to a chapter in the second part in which is given all source material bearing upon that period; a valuable resource.
0287.
Carr, Arthur. The Church and the Roman Empire. New York: A. D. G. Randolph, 1887. Traces in outline the relations between Christianity and the Roman Empire, and the external growth of the church, during the fourth and fifth centuries.
0288.
Charanis, Peter. Church and State in the Later Roman Empire: The Religious Policy of Anastasius the First, 491-518. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 1939. Demonstrates that the religious history of the later Roman Empire was inextricably interwoven with its political and social history; in officially recognizing Christianity, the Roman Empire became an interested party in virtually everything that concerned the church. This study shows further that there was no notion of religious tolerance during this period.
0289.
Coleman-Norton, P. R., comp. Roman State and Christian Church: A Collection of Legal Documents to A.D. 535. London: Society for the Propagation of Christian Knowledge (SPCK), 1966. The 652 documents in English translations in this collection cover the entire period from beginning of the Christian era to C.E. 535, the conventional date for ending of ancient Roman law. Introductions and full annotations are provided, and the value of the collection for the student is enhanced by particularly comprehensive indexing.
0290.
Cunningham, Agnes, SSCM, ed. The Early Church and the State. Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1982.
Bibliographical Survey
149
Provides an English translation of valuable documents from the period of the early church, reflecting the diversity of experiences, attitudes, and responses on the subject of church and state during the first five centuries of the Christian era, plus a helpful introduction by the editor. 0291.
Daniel-Rops, Henri. The Church of Apostles and Martyrs. New York: E. P. Dutton, 1969. This volume begins with the beginning of the church immediately after the ascension of Jesus and includes chapters on the persecutions and the catacombs and closes with an account of the triumph of Christianity when Theodosius the Great established Christianity as the official religion of the Empire on the eve of the barbarian invasion; a valuable resource.
0292.
Digeser, Elizabeth DePalma. The Making of a Christian Empire: Lactantius and Rome. Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell Univesity Press, 1999. The work of the Christian scholar Lactantius provides an ideal lens through which to study how Rome became a Christian empire. Thus, the author shows how Lactantius’ Divine Institutes —seditious in its time—responded to the emperor Diocletian’s persecution and then became an important influence on Constantine the Great, Rome’s first Christian emperor. This work is the first full-length book to interpret the Divine Institutes as a historical source. In exploring Lactantius’ use of theology, philosophy, and rhetorical techniques, the author perceives the Divine Institutes as a sophisticated proposal for a monotheistic state that ultimately connected the religious policies of Diocletian and Constantine, both of whom used religion to fortify and unite the Roman Empire.
0293.
Donfried, Karl P. and Peter Richardson, eds. Judaism and Christianity in First-Century Rome. Grand Rapids, Mich.: Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Co., 1998. The essays in this volume examine the social, historical, and religious character of Judaism and Christianity in first-century Rome, including the Roman policy towards the Jews and their expulsion from the city of Rome. the impact of the Romans on Jewish-Christian relations, and social perspectives on Christianity during the formative years from Nero to Nerva.
0294.
Dörries, Hermann. Constantine and Religious Liberty. New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 1960.
150
Church and State An attempt to evaluate the influence of Constantine’s views concerning religion and tolerance on European church-state relations and the significance of these views for today; a thoroughly stimulating and valuable study on the thought of a man and an epoch that profoundly altered the history of Christianity
0295.
Duchesne, L. M. O. Early History of the Christian Church from Its Foundation to the End of the Fifth Century. New York: Longmans, Green, and Co., 1909. A classic work; note particularly chapters on “Christianity and the State” and “Church and State in the Third Century.”
0296.
Edwards, Douglas R. Religion and Power: Pagans, Jews, and Christians in the Greek East. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1996. Shows how the elite classes appropriated religious images and practices to secure their social, political, and economic power in the Greek provinces of the Roman Empire during the first and second centuries.
0297.
Elliott, T. G. The Christianity of Constantine the Great. Scranton, Penn.: University of Scranton Press, 1997. Contends that the mature character of Constantine’s Christian faith had an important shaping impact on his imperial policy toward Christianity which gave greater nuance and depth not merely to his Edict of Milan, but also to the legal status of Christianity.
0298.
Eusebius. The History of the Church from Christ to Constantine. Minneapolis, Minn.: Augsburg Fortress Press, 1975. A translation of Eusebius’ Historia Ecclesiastica; a classic work written by the most important early Christian church historian (C.E. 260-340).
0299.
Feldman, Louis H. and Gohei Hata. Josephus, Judaism, and Christianity. Detroit: Wayne State University Press, 1987. Provides an important source in the link between Judaism and Christianity since Josephus covers in his history the era just before and during the emergence of Christianity; and he is the chief guide for the archaeologist in the process of recreating the economic, social, cultural, and political life of Judea in the two centuries before the destruction of the Second Temple, and is an important source for much of Greek, Roman, and Parthian political history.
Bibliographical Survey 0300.
151
Ferguson, Everett, David Scholer, and Corby Finney.. Church and State in the Early Church. Hamden, Conn.: Garland Publishing, 1993. Because the legal basis of the persecution of the early Christians by the Roman authorities is far from clear, this collection of essays attempts to examine some of the social factors which were at work since many Christians did not oppose the Roman state and were prepared to take an active role in government, with different Christians offering different perspectives on the relationship of the church to the empire and the profound impact of the conversion of Constantine on church organization and theological development.
0301.
Ferrero, Gugleilmo. The Ruin of the Ancient Civilization and the Triumph of Christianity. New York: G. P. Putnam’s Sons, 1921. Traces the development of imperial authority in the Roman Empire and its dissolution, with particular attention given to the attitude of the emperors to Christianity and the effect of Christianity on the Empire, noting with some detail the Diocletian persecutions and the final triumph of Christianity under Constantine; a classic work.
0302.
Field, Lester L., Jr. Liberty, Dominion, and the Two Swords: On the Origins of Western Political Theology (180-398). Notre Dame: Notre Dame University Press, 1995. Examines the ancient origins of two concepts in the early history of church and state in the West, “the liberty of the church” and “the two swords” and places the historical roots of these concepts prior to Pope Gelasius I (492-96), as far back as the end of the second century and contends that they emerged at a time when Christianity was illegal and thus persecuted and shows how the resulting theologies of martyrdom played a major role in shaping ancient Christian understanding of liberty; Part Two focuses on the concepts of liberty, dominion, and the two swords during the Constantinian revolution of the fourth century and Part Three examines the Age of Ambrose and his articulation of these concepts.
0303.
Fishwick, Duncan. The Imperial Cult in the Latin West: Studies in the Ruler Cult of the Western Provinces of the Roman Empire. Leiden, The Netherlands: E. J. Brill, 1987. An important work for the study of biblical literature and for the history of Christianity, in these volumes the author focuses on the installation and development of the imperial cult in the Western or Latin-speaking
152
Church and State provinces of the Roman Empire in the period from Augustus down to the Severi.
0304.
Frend, W. H. C. “Open Questions Concerning the Christians and the Roman Empire in the Age of the Severi.” Journal of Theological Studies 25 (1974): 331-51. Examines the earlier Christian centuries when Christians faced various issues during the Severan epoch, especially persecution, and argues that Christians were persecuted not only in the largest centers of population but in sparsely populated areas such as in Cappadocia, and that the initiative for the renewed outbreak of persecution in Severus’ reign came from the emperor himself.
0305.
Frend, W. H. C. Martyrdom and Persecution in the Early Church: A Study of a Conflict from the Maccabees to Donatus. Oxford: Basil Blackwell, 1965. While much of this work focuses primarily on the persecutions and struggles of the early Christians in the Roman Empire, the author also attempts to examine the rise of Christianity as a social movement, beginning with the Maccabean revolt against Hellenism to the time of Donatus.
0306.
Glover, T. R. The Conflict of Religions in the Early Roman Empire. London: Methuen and Co. Ltd., 1909. Attempts to portray Jesus and his followers as they appeared among their contemporaries and to represent with equal honesty Christian, Jewish, and pagan perspectives and their conflicts in the early Roman Empire.
0307.
Goodenough, Erwin R. The Church in the Roman Empire. New York: H. Holt & Co., 1931. This classic summary of the beginnings of the Christian church during the time of the Roman Empire and the beginnings of medieval Christianity in Roman civilization is still a reliable work, although somewhat dated; note, particularly chapter 2, “The State Church of the Roman Empire.”
0308.
Goodman, Martin. Mission and Conversion: Proselytizing in the Religious History of the Roman Empire. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1994. Examines the origins of Christian mission against the background of ancient Judaism and the pagan cultures of the Roman Empire and invites a
Bibliographical Survey
153
reconsideration of the grounds for religious conversion in both Christianity and Judaism. 0309.
Grant, Michael. Constantine the Great: The Man and His Times. New York: Scribner’s Sons, 1993. Traces the controversies that surround the last notable Roman emperor, who was responsible for the founding of Constantinople as the Roman capital and the “conversion” of the Roman Empire to Christianity, back to their very beginnings, including his persecution of paganism in the name of Christianity that set precedents for centuries to come and the relationship between church and state that gave way to the totalitarianism of the late Roman Empire; highly recommended.
0310.
Grant, Robert M. Augustus to Constantine: The Rise and Triumph of Christianity in the Roman World. New York: Harper and Row, 1970. Examines in some detail the history of early Christianity as it arose in Roman-controlled Judea soon after the foundation of the Roman empire, spread throughout the Roman world in spite of overt opposition from the state, and finally won the allegiance and the support of the first Christian emperor; attempts to coordinate Christian and Roman history and explain the history of early Christianity with what was going on in the empire.
0311.
Grant, Robert M. Early Christianity and Society: Seven Studies. San Francisco: Harper and Row, 1977. An insightful study of the early church in its relationship to the secular world in seven areas: “The Christian Population of the Roman Empire”; “Christian Devotion to the Monarchy”; “Taxation and Exemption”; “Work and Occupations”; “Private Property”; “The Organization of Alms”; and “Temples, Churches, and Endowments.”
0312.
Grant, Robert M. The Sword and the Cross. New York: Macmillan, 1955. Traces the Roman government’s attitude toward foreign religions from the early days of the republic through the empire and analyzes in particular the legal and judicial precedents for treating Christianity as subversive and the particular teachings of Christianity which set the state against it; a sound and scholarly study.
154
Church and State
0313.
Gregory, Timothy E. Vox Populi: Popular Opinion and Violence in the Religious Controversies of the Fifth Century A.D. Columbus: Ohio State University Press, 1979. Following some discussion of reasons that may serve to explain why Romans were given to accept one theological position over another, the author focuses on the complex question of why the Romans became involved in religious disputes and thereby gained some political force; the author concludes that while the masses could not have understood the nature of populist power or complex theological questions, but could understand the personal importance of the controversy itself, the resolution on which their personal salvation depended.
0314.
Guterman, Simeon Leonard. Religious Toleration and Persecution in Ancient Rome. London: Aiglon Press Ltd., 1971. A historical study that attempts to answer three questions: Why were foreign, pagan cults under the Roman Republic sometimes tolerated and sometimes suppressed? Why was Christianity persecuted, at first sporadically and then systematically? And, finally, why was Judaism generally tolerated? The author analyzes why the Roman government regarded Judaism religio licita while it declared Christianity a religio illicita.
0315.
Hardy, Ernest George. Christianity and the Roman Government: A Study in Imperial Administration. New York: Lenox Hill Publishers, 1894. Written from the point of view of Roman rather than of Christian history, this volumes provides an historical summary of the relations between Christianity and the Roman government during the first two centuries.
0316.
Hazlett, Ian. Early Christianity: Origins and Evolution to A.D. 600. Nashville: Abingdon Press, 1991 The essays in this volume give significant attention to the religious, political, and social backgrounds of early Christian while providing a basically chronological presentation of the early church.
0317.
Healy, Partrick J. The Valerian Persecution: A Study of the Relations Between Church and State in the Third Century A.D. Boston and New York: Houghton, Mifflin, and Co., 1905. Argues that the Valerian persecution, the first systematic attempt to destroy Christianity, was in many ways the most critical period in the history of the church during the first three centuries and that the opposition
Bibliographical Survey
155
to Christianity was rooted in a time-honored state policy of Rome in protecting its cohesiveness and absolutism, and its claims to complete domination over all human affairs. 0318.
Horsley, Richard A. Paul and Empire: Religion and Power in Roman Imperial Society. Harrisburg, Penn.: Trinity Press International, 1997 Argues against the view that Paul was apolitical and that his letters are concerned only with the transcendent dimension; analyzes the religious propaganda and patronage systems of imperial Rome and thereby provides a basis of a new focus in Pauline studies.
0319.
Humphrey, E. F. Politics and Religion in the Days of Augustine. New York: E. F. Humphrey, 1912. Attempts to treat fully and impartially the religious conflicts of the period in the light of all available documentary evidence.
0320.
Huttman, Maude Aline. The Establishment of Christianity and the Proscription of Paganism. New York: Columbia University Press, 1914. Examines the measures taken by Constantine and his successors in the fourth century to limit or destroy the pagan cults and to do so in the context of Constantine’s personal religious belief and his relationship to Christianity, including his conversion and his edicts of toleration.
0321.
Isichei, Elizabeth Allo. Political Thinking and Social Experience: Some Christian Interpretations of the Roman Empire from Tertullian to Salvian. Christchurch, New Zealand: University of Canterbury, 1964. Vividly portrays how the early Christians addressed the question of how they were to regard the Roman Empire through a careful exposition of six Christian apologists: from the separatism of Tertullian, to Eusebius’ acclaim of the realized Kingdom, to Augustine’s rigid distinction between the two cities, and Salvian’s monastic rejection of the standards of his society; while focused on a period now remote in time, the various views addressed remain relevant for today.
0322.
Jeffers, James S. Conflict at Rome: Social Order and Hierarchy in Early Christianity. Minneapolis, Minn.: Fortress Press, 1991.
156
Church and State Shows how hierarchical Roman Christianity evolved out of serious challenges to church leadership and examines the social conflicts among second-century Christians.
0323.
Jones, A. H. M. Constantine and the Conversion of Europe. New York: Collier Books, 1962. Provides a historical review of how Constantine took action to heal the breach caused by the Arian controversy, summoning the first ecumenical council of the church at Nicea, then enforcing its decrees, and establishing the doctrine of caesaropapism and the consequent and lasting tug-of-war between church and state.
0324.
Keresztes, Paul. Imperial Rome and the Christians. Lanham, Md.: University Press of America, 1989. Covers the legal position of Christianity in the Roman Empire from the biblical Jesus to the time of Constantine, when the church finally became legally recognized; contains detailed treatment of the relationship between the church and Imperial Rome, with historical documents. Both volumes cover comprehensively the legal problems of persecutions from 5 B.C.E. up to the time of Constantine’s death in 337 C.E.
0325.
King, N.Q. The Emperor Theodosius and the Establishment of Christianity. Philadelphia: The Westminster Press, 1960. Examines the pattern of church-state relations set by Emperor Theodosius, which shifted from a view that the state is supreme, to a dualistic existence, and even, at one time, to a view that the church is supreme; particular attention is given to the role of Theodosius in establishing the orthodoxy of the earlier Nicean Council and its creed.
0326.
Laistner, M. L. W. Christianity and Pagan Culture in the Later Roman Empire (together with an English Treatise of John Chrysostom’s Address on Vainglory and the Right Way for Parents to Bring up Their Children). Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University Press, 1951. Examines what happened to classical culture and Christian training in the later Roman Empire and shows how the Greek and Roman heritage was transferred to and became an inseparable part of the Christian tradition.
0327.
Lesbaupin, Ivo. Blessed Are the Persecuted: Christian Life in the Roman Empire, A.D. 64- 3l3. Maryknoll, N. Y.: Orbis Books, 1987.
Bibliographical Survey
157
An examination of the history of the early church through the prism of its persecution by the Roman Empire. Based on this history, the author offers a “theology of persecution” developed by its victims; offers valuable lessons applicable to the contemporary scene. The author, a Dominican priest, was detained and tortured in eight different prisons during the years 1969-1973. 0328.
Liebeschuetz, J. H. W. G. Barbarians and Bishops: Army, Church, and State in the Age of Arcadius and Chrysostom. New York: Clarendon Press of Oxford University Press, 1990. Offers a defense of Christianity against the charge that it undermined the response to military threats and contributed to the social and economic disintegration of the Roman Empire and argues that the inability of the Western authorities to secure recruits from “the plundered, though taxpaying citizens resulted in the Empire’s reliance on barbarian federates to defend the imperial frontiers, which, in turn, undermined the authority of the government and allowed the commanders to become virtual rulers of the West”; a scholarly work but advances a thesis many historians will regard as less than satisfactory.
0329.
Liebeschuetz, John Hugo Wolfgang. Continuity and Change in Roman Religion. New York: Oxford University Press, 1979. Surveys religious attitudes reflected in Latin literature from the late Republic to the tine of Constantine, organized around the theme of the development of Roman public religion in that period and shows that the old Roman religion continued to flourish and to contribute in numerous ways to the working of Roman society, including giving the Romans a sense of morality, but was fatally weakened by the political and social crisis of the third century and the tendency of the Roman Empire to depend and encourage new sources of support, which prepared the way for the emergence of Christianity and its adoption by Constantine.
0330.
Lieu, Samuel N. C. and Dominic Montserrat. From Constantine to Julian: Pagan and Byzantine Views: A Source History. New York: Routledge, 1995. Covers the age of transition which saw the establishment of Rome as a Christian Empire and a period of recidivism under Julian, including texts of the anonymous lives of Constantine, relevant sections of Aurelius Victor and “Eumenius, Libanius” Oration 59, the Passion of Artemius and a selection of papyri and inscriptions; most of these texts have not been previously translated into English.
158
Church and State
0331.
MacMullen, Ramsay. Christianizing the Roman Empire, A.D. 100-400. New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 1984. Attempts to look at the conversion of the Roman Empire to Christianity from a Roman rather than a Christian viewpoint and examines the widely differing motives that led to the conversion and the quality of the process in years before and after Constantine became a Christian; in contrast to the early history of Christianity, once Christianity had the sanction of the emperor, it came to benefit from respectability and prestige and the advancement of material rewards.
0332.
MacMullen, Ramsay. Paganism in the Roman Empire. New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 1981. Makes more understandable the rise of Christianity, the major event in the cultural history of the Roman Empire.
0333.
Mason, Arthur James. The Historic Martyrs of the Primitive Church. London: Longmans, Greene, and Co, 1905. In twenty chapters, the author examines the Christian martyrdoms, all of whom suffered for liberty of conscience and their undying loyalty to their Christian faith, during the waves of Roman persecution, from the time of the apostolic age through the third century of the Christian era.
0334.
McLynn, Neil B. Ambrose of Milan: Church and Court in a Christian Capital. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1994. Constructs a new interpretation of Ambrose’s actions and writings and thereby presents an impressive study of the politics and history of the Christian church and the Roman Empire during that period.
0335.
Momigliano, Arnaldo. The Conflict Between Paganism and Christianity in the Fourth Century. Oxford: The Clarendon Press, 1963. Examines, in the aftermath of the conversion of Constantine, the conflicts between pagans and Christians and their effects on the life and thought of fourth-century Rome; topics include the changes in the structure of society, the struggle between pagans and Christians, the revival of ancient cults and beliefs, and the new attitude to the barbarians—all of which are linked with the general decline of the Rome Empire.
0336.
Murphy, Francis X. Politics and the Early Christians. New York: Desclee Company, Inc., 1967.
Bibliographical Survey
159
Foreword by Hubert H. Humphrey. Provides an overview of the political dilemma which confronted and perplexed the early Christian centuries and surveys the political thought and activity from Home to Augustine; describes the essentials of the Greek and Jewish achievement in political thought in a succinct and graphic fashion. 0337.
Palanque, Jean-Rémy et al. The Church in the Christian Roman Empir. Trans.Ernest C, Messenger, 2 vols. New York: Macmillan, 1949-52. Traces the history of Christianity from the beginning of the fourth century to the establishment of the Catholic Church as the state religion in 391-83 C.E.; provides valuable resources on church and state in the West after 313, the religious policy of the Emperor Licinius, the Christian legislation of Constantine, the intellectual reactions against Christianity, the persecutions of Christianity, and finally the union of church and state, which resulted in the proscription of paganism and privileges given the Catholic Church; highly recommended.
0338.
Pelikan, Jaroslav. The Excellent Empire: The Fall of Rome and the Triumph of the Church. New York: Harper and Row, 1990. Details the responses to the fall of Rome by the church fathers, who set the pattern for interpreting this momentous event for all succeeding centuries; also examines historian Edward Gibbon’s interpretation in the light of the original Christian response.
0339.
Perowne, Stewart. Caesars and Saints: The Evolution of the Christian State. London: Hodder and Stroughton, 1962. In tracing the evolution of the Christian state, the author attempts to show three things: why the material world of Rome was in decline; how it was saved from dissolution as much by Semitic as by Italian enterprise; and how natural and inevitable it was that Christianity should become the basis of a new order.
0340.
Pohlsander, Hans A. The Emperor Constantine. New York: Routledge, 1997. Describes the Roman world into which Constantine was born and emphasizes the significance of Constantine as Rome’s first Christian emperor; finally, the author discusses the importance of the establishment of the new capital at Byzantium and provides an assessment of Constantine’s achievements.
160
Church and State
0341.
Ramsay, William Mitchell. The Church in the Roman Empire Before A.D. 170. New York: G. P. Putnam’s Sons, 1893. A classic work, two-thirds of which are devoted to recounting the conflicts and persecutions between Christians and the Roman rulers of the period.
0342.
Ricciotti, Giuseppe. The Age of Martyrs: Christianity from Diocletian to Constantine. Milwaukee, Wisc.: The Bruce Publishing Co., 1959. Examines the history of Christianity from the Great Persecution, under Diocletian’s rule, to liberty and triumph of Christianity under Constantine; a valuable resource.
0343.
Richardson, Peter and Stephen Westerholm. Law in Religious Communities in the Roman Period: The Debate Over Torah and Nomos in Post-Biblical Judaism and Early Christianity. Cleveland, Ohio: The Pilgrim Press, 1991. Examines the role and function of law in religious communities—especially in Judaism and Christianity—during the Roman period; the first fullscale attempt to provide a historical assessment of the debate on this question, with particular attention given to torah in Judaism and early Christianity.
0344.
Rives, J. B. Religion and Authority in Roman Carthage: From Augustus to Constantine. New York: Oxford University Press, 1995. Examines the organization of religion—Christian, pagan, and Jewish—in the Roman Empire at the time of Constantine and Augustine and argues that because official pagan religion was inextricably tied to the structure of individual cities, Christianity was the only religion that could unite the inhabitants of the Empire as a whole.
0345.
Rudich, Vasily. Political Dissidence under Nero: The Price of Dissimulation. New York: Routledge, 1993. Examines in considerable detail the cost, especially the social and psychological dimensions, of dissidence under Nero.
0346.
Sarno, Ronald A. The Cruel Caesars: Their Impact on the Early Church. Staten Island, N. Y.: Alba House, 1976. Attempts to show how men and events of the first-century Roman Empire had a profound influence on Jesus and his followers and how the cruelty
Bibliographical Survey
161
of almost all the emperors was a constant factor in each decade and Christian reaction to this is mirrored in New Testament writings. 0347.
Schowalter, Daniel N. The Emperor and the Gods: Images from the Time of Trajan. Minneapolis, Minn.: Fortress Press, 1991. Focusing on the reign of Trajan in the second century, the author assesses the relationship of the emperor to the gods by examining the works of Pliny, imperial coins, epigrams, and monuments of the period.
0348.
Segal, Alan F. Rebecca’s Children: Judaism and Christianity in the Roman World. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1986. Brings a new perspective to the early histories of Christianity and rabbinic Judaism by showing how they responded to the same social situation; sociologically significant and historically enlightening.
0349.
Setton, Kenneth Meyer. Christian Attitude Towards the Emperor in the Fourth Century, Especially as Shown in Addresses to the Emperor. New York: Columbia University Press, 1941. Attempts to portray the patristic attitude towards the person and office of the Roman Emperor in the fourth century, with particular attention given to letters, speeches, panegyrics, and the like, which were addressed directly to the Emperor.
0350.
Simmons, Michael Bland. Arnobius of Sicca: Religious Conflict and Competition in the Age of Diocletian. New York: Oxford University Press, 1995. Examines and evaluates the influence of the life and writing of Arnobius in the age of Diocletian and demonstrates his significant contribution to the final triumph of Christianity over its Graeco-Roman competitors; the first major study of this subject.
0351.
Smith, John Holland. The Death of Classical Paganism. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1976. Reexamines the triumph of Christianity over Rome and argues that a greater balance is needed in the writing of this history in which greater appreciation is given to the political and cultural value of the Roman state religion and the relevance of this recognition to the destruction by Christian missionaries today of traditional “pagan” religion in Africa, South America, and Polynesia.
162 0352.
Church and State Smith, Rowland B. E. Religion and Philosophy in the Thought and Action of Julian the Apostate. New York: Routledge, 1995. Examines the attempt of Julian to reimpose pagan worship throughout the Roman Empire, focusing on the cultural mentality of Julian, not on the controversy over Christianity.
0353.
Sordi, Marta. The Christians and the Roman Empire. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 1986. In exploring the often tumultuous relationship between Christianity and the Roman state, the author contends that Christianity was not persecuted because it constituted a political threat to the state, but rather because it was an alternative religious movement which undermined Roman religion and that the persecution rarely involved mere political allegiance. The author argues that “Christians were considered dangerous because their ‘impiety’ would, it was thought, undermine the pax decorum and cause the gods to withdraw their protection precisely in the empire’s hour of greatest need.”
0354.
Spence-Jones, H. D. M. The Early Christians in Rome. London: Methuen and Co., 1910. Consists of five books which trace the history of the fortunes of the church in Rome, from its beginning, and from C.E. 64 onward when Christians came to be regarded as enemies of the state; note particularly Book I, “The Beginnings of Christianity in Rome,” and Book IV, “The Roman Catacombs.”
0355.
Stauffer, Ethelbert. Christ and the Caesars: Historical Sketches. Philadelphia: The Westminster Press, 1955. Examines the parallel construction of myth/religion and the imperial state of classical Rome and shows Christianity’s debt to the Roman concept of Roma Aeterna and the imperium aeternum, which were adopted by the Catholic Church upon Rome’s collapse.
0356.
Taylor, Lily Ross. The Divinity of the Roman Emperor. New York: Arno Press, 1975. Traces the introduction of emperor worship at Rome from Julius Caesar’s effort to establish an Oriental form of divine monarchy to the more eclectic cult devised by Augustus and his successors; a classic study.
Bibliographical Survey 0357.
163
Wardman, Alan. Religion and Statecraft Among the Romans. Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press, 1982. Provides an analysis of religious beliefs and practices in different eras and political settings and shows how Roman religion served the interest of the state; particular emphasis is given to the influx of oriental religions, including Christianity and its triumph in the fourth century.
0358.
Watson, Alan. The State, Law, and Religion: Pagan Rome. Athens: University of Georgia Press, 1992. Analyzes the interaction of law and religion in ancient Rome, with particular attention to the apparent paradox that Roman private law was remarkably secular even though until the second century B.C.E. the Romans were regarded (and regarded themselves) as the most religious people in the world; offers a major new perspective on the nature and development of Roman law in the early republic before Christianity was recognized and encouraged by Constantine.
0359.
Westbury-Jones, John. Roman and Christian Imperialism. London: Macmillan, 1939. Examines the interaction between Christianity and the Roman Empire, “the only two powers which claimed absolute dominion over mankind,” and assesses Christianity’s influence on Roman legal, political, and social thought, with attention given to church-state issues.
0360.
Whittaker, Molly. Jews and Christians: Graeco-Roman Views. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1984. Provides access to sources which illustrate Graeco-Roman views of Judaism and Christianity from 200 B.C.E. to 200 C.E. and shows that Jewish circumcision, sabbath-observance, and food laws were taken for granted, with only incidental references of pagan authors to Christianity and only towards the end of the period with accounts of persecution were there sustained anti-Christian polemics employed.
0361.
Wilken, Robert L. The Christians as the Romans Saw Them. New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 1984. Drawing upon well-known sources, both pagan and Christian, the author provides an illuminating account of how Christianity appeared to the Romans before it became the established religion of the empire.
164 0362.
Church and State Williams, Daniel H. Ambrose of Milan and the End of the Nicene-Arian Conflicts. New York: Oxford University Press, 1995. Challenges the traditional view of the triumph of orthodoxy in the early church and provides new insights on the social, political, and theological entanglements of early Christianity.
0363.
Williams, Stephen and Gerald Friell. Theodosius: The Empire at Bay. New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 1995. Examines the life and character of Theodosius I, the last Roman emperor to rule a unified empire of East and West, placing military, religious, and political struggles of his reign in the context of the troubled times of the empire.
Byzantine Empire 0364.
Arnott, Peter. The Byzantines and Their World. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1973. A social history of the period from the formation of the Eastern Empire in the fourth century C.E. to the fall of Constantinople more than one thousand years later.
0365.
Curcic, Slobodan and Doula Mouriki. The Twilight of Byzantium: Aspects of Cultural and Religious History in the Late Byzantine Empire. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1991. Traces the centuries-long economic and military decline of the Byzantine Empire, which culminated in its political disappearance as a state in 1459, and shows how, paradoxically, Byzantine ideological, spiritual and artistic traditions transcended the economic and political realities of the time.
0366.
Dvornik, Francis. Byzantium and the Roman Primacy. New York: Fordham University Press, 1966. Acknowledging that the only remaining obstacle to a closer understanding between the Orthodox Churches and the Church of Rome lies in the Roman Primacy, the author addresses the two principles of both churches: accommodation by which the churches were organized along the lines of the administrative structure of the Empire—based upon the position of the Emperor as God’s vicegerent (the patron and protector of the church) and apostolicity, in the case of Rome stemming from Peter, the Prince of the Apostles, and in the East, stemming from Andrew, the first apostle called by Christ.
Bibliographical Survey 0367.
165
Dvornik, Francis. Early Christian and Byzantine Political Philosophy: Origins and Background. Washington, D. C.: Dumbarton Oaks Center for Byzantine Studies, 1966. Examines Christian history in order to study the trends of political thought in the East at the time when Christianity came into being, including the political ideas of the many cultures in the Near East, and shows how the different civilizations of the pre-Christian era transmitted their ideas on kingship to each other, enriching their new concept which corresponded to their national, religious, or racial character, and to show to what extent the Jewish and Greek genius had absorbed, changed, or adapted them.
0368.
Franzius, Enno. History of the Byzantine Empire: Mother of Nations. New York: Funk and Wagnalls, 1967. This study is an effort to place in historical perspective the Roman Empire during the eleven centuries when its capital was in the East.
0369.
Gerostergios, Asterios. Justinian the Great: Emperor and Saint. Belmont, Mass.: Institute for Byzantine and Modern Greek Studies, 1982. Explores the character of Justinian as administrator, legislator, codifier of law, theologian, builder of churches, and saint of the Orthodox Church.
0370.
Hussey, J. M. The Orthodox Church in the Byzantine Empire. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1986. The author refutes the widely held view that the Eastern Orthodox Church was a department of state of the Byzantine Empire. While the emperor was understood as having responsibility for the life of the Church in Byzantium, the exercise of that responsibility in specific situations was considered null and void, and inoperative when, in the judgment of the Church, the Emperor was unfaithful to its spirit, doctrines, and/or canons.
0371.
Magoulias, Harry J. Byzantine Christianity: Emperor, Church, and the West. Detroit: Wayne State University Press, 1982. Describes the transformation of the Roman Empire from paganism into the Christian state of Byzantium and the development of theological doctrine and the factors leading to the fall and destruction of Constantinople during the Fourth Crusade in 1204.
0372.
Meyendorff, John. Imperial Unity and Christian Divisions: The Church 450-680 A.D. Crestwood, N.Y.: St. Vladimir’s Seminary Press, 1989.
166
Church and State Traces the expansion of Christianity in the East and the West in the fifth, sixth, and seventh centuries and the tensions that inevitably arose between cultural pluralism and the need for church unity, with attention given to the problems raised by the arbitrariness of Eastern Roman emperors and by the gradual development of the primacy of Rome.
0373.
Meyendorff, John. Byzantiusm and the Rise of Russia. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1981. Examines the complicated relations between a waning Byzantium Empire and a rising Moscovite power in the thirteen and fourteenth centuries and notes that the declining Byzantium imperial power was balanced by the correspondingly greater extension of its ecclesiastical influence and authority with the transfer of the Metropolitante of “all Russia” from Kiev to Moscow, which would become the seat of a future Russian state.
0374.
Nicol, Donald M. Church and Society in the Last Centuries of Byzantium. London: Cambridge University Press, 1979. A small but insightful volume that explores the distinct identity of the Byzantine Empire; note particularly the first chapter on “The Theocratic Empire.”
0375.
Obolensky, Dimitri. The Byzantine Commonwealth: Eastern Europe, 500-1453. Crestwood, N.Y.: St. Vladimir’s Press, 1988. In examining the political, economic, ecclesiastical, and cultural relations that existed between the Byzantine Empire and the peoples of Eastern Europe, the author shows how Eastern Europe came to share a common cultural tradition which included the profession of the Orthodox Christian faith, the recognition of the supra-national authority of the Byzantine emperor, and an appreciation of Byzantine art, literature, and culture
0376.
Ostrogorsky, George. History of the Byzantine State. New Brunswick, N.J.: Rutgers University Press, 1957. Revised edition of a work long recognized as the basic history of the Byzantine Empire; traces its thousand year course, with emphasis on political development and social, aesthetic, economic, and ecclesiastical factors and the Empire’s link with classical antiquity.
0377.
Runciman, Steven. The Byzantine Theocracy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1977.
Bibliographical Survey
167
The Weil Lectures for 1973. Provides an historical account of an empire whose “constitution,” to use the author’s term, was based on a religious conviction: that it was the earthly copy of the Kingdom of Heaven and as a universal Empire, seeing itself as the image of God on earth, while confronting the challenge of popular belief, the limits of imperial control, the opposition to the palace and the hierarchy, and finally its decline and fall; a brief but reliable survey. 0378.
Shahid, Irfan. Byzantium and the Arabs in the Fifth Century. Washington, D.C.: Dumbarton Oaks, 1989. The second volume in a series of three which treats the Arab-Byzantine relationship in the proto-Byzantine period, this volume focuses on the political, military, ecclesiastical, and cultural history, beginning with Arcadius (395-408) and ending with Anastasius (491-518).
0379.
Thomas, John Philip. Private Religious Foundations in the Byzantine Empire. Washington D.C.: Dumbarton Oaks Press, 1987. Portrays the Orthodox Church during the time of the Byzantine Empire as one whose institutions became completely controlled by lay power, both petty and great, that resulted in wholesale lay control for profit and of hereditary transmission of proprietary rights in the case of control by a married clergy.
The Middle Ages 0380.
Aquinas, Thomas. Treatise on Law (Summa Theologica, Questions 9097). Washington D. C.: Regnery Publishing, Inc., 1996. Focuses on the nature and structure of law and defines a Christian view of liberty, believing that law achieves its results by imposing moral obligations rather than outright force; the work of one of the greatest theologians of the Roman Catholic Church.
0381.
Backman, Clifford R. The Decline and Fall of Medieval Sicily: Politics, Religion, and Economy in the Reign of Frederick III, 1296-1337. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1995. Argues that there were many more things “wrong” with Sicilian life than just the shape of its overseas trade relations and shows that an entire nexus of factors and influences were at work in unraveling Sicilian life.
168 0382.
Church and State Baldwin, Marshall W. Popes Through History. New York: Newman Press, 1968. Attempts to present in comparatively brief compass the career of Pope Alexander III “in the light of recent research,” a pope who is widely regarded as an eminent jurist during the great schism between Thomas Becket and Henry II of England and the emergence of the papal monarchy.
0383.
Baldwin, Marshall W. The Medieval Church. Ithaca, N. Y.: Cornell University Press, 1953. Explores the development of the medieval church as an institution and its impact on medieval society, reaching its peak during the thirteenth century; note especially the chapters on “The Church and the Reform of Society” and “The Popes and Political Authority.”
0384.
Barlow, Frank. Thoman Beckett. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1986. Presents an account of Becket’s early years, his service as chancellor to Henry II, his election to Canterbury, his quarrel with the king, his exile, his “reconciliation” with Henry, his martyrdom, and the events which followed; aims to be as comprehensive and objective as possible.
0385.
Barraclough, Geoffrey. The Medieval Papacy. New York: Harcourt, Brace and World, Inc., 1968. Provides an historical examination of the medieval papacy from its beginnings in Rome and the relationship of papacy to the Roman Empire, and the rise of the medieval papacy—the growth of papal government and papal monarchy—the Babylonish captivity, and the great schism, to the papacy at the dawn of a new age; written from an historical perspective and not from that of dogmatic theology.
0386.
Barrell, A. D. M. The Papacy, Scotland, and Northern England, 13421378. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995. Examines the Avignon Papacy’s relations with Scotland and northern England during a period in which papal involvement at the local level was unusually wide-ranging, but was still generally accepted, affecting both clerics and lay people; the first analysis of the breadth of papal involvement in late medieval Britain.
Bibliographical Survey 0387.
169
Benson, Robert L. The Bishop-Elect: A Study in Medieval Ecclesiastical Office. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1968. Focuses on the constitutional status of the bishop-elect both within the Church and in his relation to the secular monarch and thereby provides the direct link between church and monarchy.
0388.
Bernhardt, John W. Itinerant Kingship and Royal Monasteries in Early Medieval Germany: c. 936-1075. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1993. Examines the relationship between the royal monarchies in tenth and eleventh-century Germany and the German monarchs, noting that monasteries provided the monarchs payments and services and concludes that German rulers made much greater use of their royal monasteries than has been previously recognized.
0389.
Blumenthal, Uta-Renate. The Investiture Controversy: Church and Monarchy from the Ninth to the Twelfth Century. Leiden, The Netherlands: E. J. Brill, 1988. The author aims to describe “the roots of a set of ideals that effected a radical transformation of eleventh-century European society” and to present them “in their contemporary political, social, and cultural context” under the following headings: “Piety and Monastic Reform During the Tenth and Early Eleventh Centuries;” “The German Emperors and the Legacy of Rome;” “Reform and Rome; Henry IV and Gregory VII;” and “The Controversy Over Investitures in England, France, and Germany Under Gregory’s Successors.”
0390.
Bredero, Adriaan H. Christendom and Christianity in the Middle Ages: The Relations Between Religion, Church, and Society. Grand Rapids, Mich.: Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Co., 1994. Examines why the church of the Middle Ages, buffeted on all sides by social, political, and economic change, was able to adapt and endure as an institution of salvation, rather than becoming a fossil from the past.
0391.
Brooke, Christopher N. et al. Church and Government in the Middle Ages: Essays Presented to C. R. Cheney on His 70th Birthday. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1976.
170
Church and State This collection of essays is centered on the history of church and state in England and on the continent of Europe between the eleventh and the early fourteenth centuries, with occasional extensions.
0392.
Brundage, James A. Law, Sex, and Christian Society in Medieval Europe. Chicago: Chicago University Press, 1987. Demonstrates how the regulation of marriage and divorce today, together with the outlawing of bigamy and polygamy and the imposition of criminal sanctions on certain forms of sexual behavior are all based in large measure upon ideas and beliefs about sexual morality that became law in Europe during the Middle Ages; encyclopedic in its treatment of the subject.
0393.
Burns, J. H. The Cambridge History of Medieval Political Thought, c. 350-1450. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1988. Offers a comprehensive and authoritative account of political thought over a period of a thousand years. While the predominant emphasis is understandably upon ideas that developed within Latin Christendom, much attention is also given to the impact of Byzantine, Jewish, and Islamic thought.
0394.
Burns, J. M. and Thomas M. Izbicki, eds. Conciliarism and Papalism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1997. In this collection the editors bring together the first English translation of four major contributions, almost on the eve of the Reformation, to the long-running debate over the respective authority of popes and councils in the Catholic Church; what is foreshadowed here, beyond the arguments derived from Scripture, theology, and canon law, is the confrontation between “absolutism” and “constitutionalism” which was to be a dominant theme in the politics of early-modern Europe and beyond.
0395.
Canning, Joseph. A History of Medieval Political Thought, 300-1450. New York: Routledge, 1996. Covers four periods, each with a different focus: 1. 300-750—Christian ideas of rulership; 2. 750-1050—the Carolingian period and its aftermath; 3. 1050-1290; 4. 1290-1450. The relationship between temporal and spiritual power, and in ideas of church and state, and in juristic thought. Focuses on crucial primary source material and provides historical and intellectual context for political ideas.
Bibliographical Survey 0396.
171
Cannon, William Ragsdale. History of Christianity in the Middle Ages: From the Fall of Rome to the Fall of Constantinople. Nashville: Abingdon Press, 1960; reprinted Grand Rapids, Mich.: Baker Book House, 1983. Written as a synthetic history of the development of Christianity from C.E. 476 to 1453 in all its aspects, doctrinal as well as institutional, the Greek church as well as the Latin, this well-documented volume provides a good summary of medieval Christianity, with the theme of church and state interwoventhroughout,
0397.
Carlyle, Robert W. and Alexander J. Carlyle. History of Medieval Political Theory in the West. 6 vols. Edinburgh: Blackwood, 1928-1936. A monumental history of political theory in the West during the medieval period with the emergence of the Holy Roman Empire, Christendom, and centuries of ecclesiastical domination; note particularly, Vol. 1, Part III, “The Political Theory of the New Testament and the [Church] Fathers; Vol. 2, “The Political Theory of the Roman Lawyers and the Canonists”; Vol. 3, Part II, chapters on “The Divine Nature of Political Authority”; Vol. 4, “The Theories of the Relation of the Empire and the Papacy from the Tenth Century to the Twelfth”; and Vols. 5 and 6 which focus on the political theory of church and state from the thirteenth through the sixteenth centuries; a classic work.
0398.
Chodorow, Stanley. Christian Political Theory and Church Politics in the Mid-Twelfth Century: The Ecclesiology of Gratian’s Decretum. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1972. Argues that Gratian was not aloof from the politics of the Church of his time, as often assumed in the past, but shows evidence provided by his work and by other sources that he was sympathetic to, if not directly involved with, the reform party of the papal chancellor Haimeric which confronted the curial establishment and that many of Gratian’s ideas reflected such issues as the relations between the pope and emperor and the need for reform in the Church.
0399.
Cohn, Norman. The Pursuit of the Millennium: Revolutionary Messianism in Medieval and Reformation Europe and its Bearing on Modern Totalitarian Movements. Fair Lawn, N. J.: Essential Books, 1957; rev. and expanded ed., New York: Oxford University Press, 1970. Traces and analyzes the tradition of revolutionary millenarianism and mystic anarchism as it developed in Western Europe between the eleventh and the sixteenth centuries; the sects and movements described in this
172
Church and State volume represent in the history of religious dissent what the author contends are the most “absolute” and “anarchic” wings.
0400.
Dahan, Gilbert. The Christian Polemic Against the Jews in the Middle Ages. Notre Dame: Notre Dame University Press, 1998. Provides a compact overview of Jewish conditions in medieval Western Christendom, then moves to a discussion of the changing patterns of Christian-Jewish polemical confrontation, laying particular emphasis on the shift during the twelfth and nineteenth centuries from a fairly open exchange of views to a concerted Christian effort to convert the Jews.
0401.
Daniel-Rops, Henri. The Church in the Dark Ages. Vol. 2 of History of the Church of Christ. Trans. Audrey Butler. London: J. M. Dent and Sons, Ltd., 1959. Begins with an account of St. Augustine of Hippo and the subsequent conversion of the Barbarian, with most of volume devoted to exploring the relationship of the Byzantine Church with the Empire and its eventual separation from Rome.
0402.
D’Entrèves, A. P. Medieval Contribution to Political Thought. New York: Oxford University Press, 1939. A reliable and scholarly study that is still valuable; includes a good summary of Aquinas’s contribution to the modern concept of church and state.
0403.
Duchesne, Louis. The Beginnings of the Temporal Sovereignty of the Popes, A.D. 754-1073. Trans. Arnold Harris Matthew. London: Kega Paul, Trench, Trubner & Co., 1908. Delineates the formation of the papal state in the eighth century and how the conditions under which it was maintained during the first three centuries of its existence are connected with the great religious conflicts in the time of Pope Gregory VII
0404.
Edbury, Peter W. The Kingdom of Cyprus and the Crusades, 1191-1374. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1991. Based on original research, this study traces the fortunes of Cyprus under its royal dynasty and its role in the crusades and in the confrontation of Christian and Muslim in the Near East until the 1370s when it was severely weakened in a war with Genoa; an important contribution to the history of the crusades in the Levant.
Bibliographical Survey 0405.
173
Falco, Giorgio. The Holy Roman Republic: A Historic Profile of the Middle Ages. New York: George Allen and Unwin, 1964. While not a summary history of the Middle Ages, this volume serves well in its analysis of the emergence of the “Christian Empire,” iconoclastic struggles between Rome and Byzantium, the last bid for power of the Medieval Empire, and, finally, the last bid for power of the medieval papacy.
0406.
Finkelstein, Louis. Jewish Self-Government in the Middle Ages. New York: The Jewish Theological Seminary of America, 1924; reprint, Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, 1980. Examines the development of Jewish communal life in the middle ages and Jewish attempts to unite their various communities in nation-wide organizations and, in doing so, portrays the spectacle of a persecuted people in the midst of disunited principalities, governed, as the author says, by their petty barons “for revenue only.”
0407.
Flick, Alexander Clarence. Rise of the Mediaeval Church and Its Influence on the Civilisation of Western Europe. New York: G. P. Putnam’s Sons, 1909. Provides a fair history of the church for the period, but of particular value is its concern with the influence of the church on Western civilization from the first to the thirteenth century, with special chapters devoted to the Roman government’s treatment of the Christians, the transition of the church under Constantine, the rise of papal power and its relationship with the Holy Roman Empire, and other extended discussions of the relation of church and state during this period.
0408.
Giles of Rome, Archbishop of Bourges. On Ecclesiastical Power: De Ecclelsiastica Potestate by Aegidius of Rome. Trans. and introd. Arthur Monahan. Lewiston, N. Y: The Edwin Mellen Press, 1990. Presents a lengthy statement on the classic medieval conflict in church-state relations by a committed and influential papalist writing during the last great confrontation pitting the papacy against the throne, between Pope Boniface VII and Philip the Fair of France at the turn of the fourteenth century and attempts to redress the historical balance of material available in English.
174 0409.
Church and State Godin, Guillaume de Pierre. The Theory of Papal Monarchy in the Fourteenth Century: Tractatus de Causa Immediata Ecclesiastice Potestatis. Toronto: Pontifical Institute of Mediaeval Studies, 1982. Provides a particularly extreme statement of the papal hierocratic point of view, according to which the pope is immune to human judgment because he is the source of all governmental and jurisdictional authority in the church.
0410.
Gow, Andrew Colin. The Red Jews: Antisemtism in an Apocalyptic Age, 1200-1600. Leiden, The Netherlands: E. J. Brill, 1995. Traces and examines with German language texts the repeated and embroidered tale concerning an epochal threat to Christianity by the “Red Jews.”
0411.
Gregorovius, Ferdinand A. Rome and Medieval Culture: Selections from History of the City of Rome in the Middle Ages. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1971. Viewing Rome as the seat of the papacy, as the basis of the Roman Empire, and as the pivot of Italy, the author’s Rome witnesses crucial events of European history from the schism of the East and the West through the duel of pope and emperor to the end of the Italian Renaissance and the beginning of the modern age of liberty; one of the greatest general works of medieval historiography.
0412.
Hallam, Elizabeth. Chronicles of the Crusades. Hyattsville, Md.: Daedalus Books, 1989. Chronicles five hundred years of conflict, from the First Crusade in 1096 to the last confrontation in the sixteenth century, in the words of observers, commentators, and the men and women who took part in this struggle between the opposing faiths of Christianity and Islam.
0413.
Hearnshaw, F. J. C. The Social and Political Ideas of Some Great Mediaeval Thinkers. New York: Holt, 1923. Reprint; Totowa, N.J.: Barnes and Noble, 1967. Provides an exposition of the thought of some major medievalists on church and state, including “St. Augustine and the City of God,” “St. Thomas Aquinas and the Papal Monarchy,” “Dante and World-Empire,” Marsiglio of Padua and Medieval Secularism,” and “John Wycliffe and Divine Dominion;” central to all of the essays in this volume is the relationship of
Bibliographical Survey
175
the ecclesiastical to the secular, the spiritual to the temporal, the clerical to the lay—namely the church to the state. 0414.
Higham, N. J. The Convert Kings: Power and Religious Affiliation in Early Anglo-Saxon England. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1997. Offers a critical re-evaluation of the process of conversion which assesses what the act really meant to new converts, who was responsible for conversion, and why particular influential figures both accepted it for themselves and threw their influence behind the spread of Christianity; gives particular attention to the roles played by Kings Aethelbert, Edwin, Oswald, and Oswin and their religious policies.
0415.
Hill, Bennet D. Church and State in the Middle Ages. New York: Wiley, 1970. A historical study with many documents; a good resource.
0416.
Holt, P. M. The Age of the Crusades: The Near East from the Eleventh Century to 1517. New York: Longman, 1986. Provides an account of the political history of the eastern Mediterranean lands from the eve of the First Crusade to the Ottoman conquest of Syria and Egypt in 1516-17, including the period of the Mamluk sultanate.
0417.
Housley, Norman. Documents on the Later Crusades, 1274-1580. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1996. Brings together sixty-two documents of the later crusades, which illustrate the important role which they played in the religious, political, and social life of Europe in the late Middle Ages and the Renaissance; an invaluable resource for understanding the main stream of the crusading movement and their significance as an expression of Christian Holy War.
0418.
Housley, Norman. The Avignon Papacy and the Crusades, 1305-1378. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1986. Examines the contribution made by the Avignonese Curia to all aspects of the crusades: their initiation, their organization and financing, their control in the field, and their diplomatic repercussions; includes all areas where crusading occurred—the eastern Mediterranean, Spain, eastern Europe, and Italy, most of which have been generally neglected by historians previously.
176
Church and State
0419.
Kay, Richard, trans. Dante’s Monarchia. Toronto: Pontifical Institute of Medieval Studies, 1998. Long regarded as the most famous example of medieval political thought, noted for its search for peace and justice and Dante’s proposal for a world government and by its rigorous separation of religious authority from government. Dante’s solution to the political disunity and social disorder of his time was to revive the authority of the Roman Empire.
0420.
Kedar, Benjamin Z. Crusade and Mission: European Approaches Toward the Muslims. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1984. A wide-ranging study of medieval Europe’s response to the challenge of Islam in which the author examines the relationship between the ideas of crusade and mission, between the European efforts of military conquest and those aimed at conversion; covers the period from the emergence of Islam to the fourteenth century. A masterful work.
0421.
Konstam, Angus. The Crusades: Historical Atlas of the Crusades. New York: Checkmark Books, 2002. Gives a fact-filled account of the wars whose battle cries still haunt both Christian and Muslim alike. The author brings together the evidence from the latest discoveries, historical research, and archaeological excavations to give the reader the most up-to-date account of the Crusades available.
0422.
Lagarde, André. The Latin Church in the Middle Ages. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1915. Examines the survival of the Catholic Church following the collapse of the Roman Empire and its final triumph over invading “barbarians,” “heretics,” and “pagans” and the emergence and domination of the papacy as the “master” of Europe and its monarchs during the Middle Ages.
0423.
Lerner, Ralph and Mushin Mahdi, eds. Medieval Political Philosophy: A Sourcebook. Toronto: Collier-Macmillan, Ltd., 1963. Perhaps the best single volume of Muslim, Jewish, and Christian medieval philosophers and theologians.
0424.
Lewis, Ewart. Medieval Political Ideas. 2 vols. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul Ltd., 1954. Reprint: New York: Cooper Square Publishers, 1974.
Bibliographical Survey
177
Includes valuable primary sources and commentaries on medieval Catholic political thought relative to the idea of law, the origin and purpose of political authority, the individual and the community, the structure of authority in the church, the problem of the empire, and the “regnum and sacerdotium.” 0425.
Logan, F. Donald. Excommunication and the Secular Arm in Medieval England: A Study in Legal Procedure from the Thirteenth to the Sixteenth Century. Toronto: Pontifical Institute of Medieval Studies, 1968. A detailed study of the legal process of excommunication.
0426.
Marsiglio of Padua. Writings on the Empire: Defensor minor and De translatione Imperii. New York: Cambridge University Press: 1993. Presents two minor works of Marsilius which deal with the rights of the emperor over against the pope: the first clears up ambiguities in the Defensor Pacis and gives further insight into Marsilius’ thought, and the second holds that the source of imperial authority is not the papacy but an earthly historical process outside of papal control. See also Marsilius of Padua, under “Roman Catholicism.”
0427.
Mathews, Shailer. Select Mediaeval Documents and other Material Illustrating the History of the Church and Empire, 754 A.D.-1254 A.D. New York: Silver, Burdett, and Co., 1900. Reprint; New York: AMS Press, 1974. Through historic documents portrays the struggles between the popes and emperors during the period of 764-1254 and thereby reflects the dramatic history of church and state during the Middle Ages based on original documents of the period.
0428.
Mayer, Hans Eberhard. The Crusades. Trans., John Gillingham. 2nd ed. New York: Oxford University Press, 1988. Widely regarded as the standard work on the subject, this volume covers all the expeditions which took place between the First Crusade in 1096 and the final retreat from Palestine in 1291, including the entanglement of the Crusades in European politics—for example in the conflicts between pope and emperor and in molding relations between Byzantium and Europe.
178 0429.
Church and State McCready, William D. “Papal plenitudo potestatis and the Source of Temporal Authority in the Late Medieval Papal Hierocratic Theory,” Speculum 48 (1973): 654-74. Examines the significance of the term “plenitudo potestatia” in temporal affairs which the author finds inherent in papal authority; although the pope does not exercise temporal power himself he does have some responsibility in directing the princes of this world in the use of their power
0430.
Moore, R. I. The Origins of European Dissent. Oxford: Blackwell, 1986. Provides a provocative account of the rise of dissent in medieval Europe. Dissent largely focused toward the church and its official proclamations, which were often accompanied with coercion. The author argues that the “habit of dissent was formed and expressed substantially, though not exclusively, in association with the dissemination of popular heresy in the Europe of the eleventh and twelfth centuries;” and highlights three figures in particular who offered alternatives to the reigning religious and political orthodoxies: Henry of Lausanne, Peter of Bruys, and Arnold of Brescia.
0431.
Morrall, John B. Political Thought in Medieval Times. London: Hutchinson, 1958. Reprint: Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1980.. Provides a general sketch of the political thought of the Middle Ages, with particular focus on church and empire, the problem of authority within the Christian commonwealth, the birth of the state, and the coming of age of the state.
0432.
Morris, Colin. The Papal Monarchy: The Western Church from 1050 to 1250. New York: Oxford University Press, 1989. Provides a comprehensive history of this crucial period of Christianity in its relations of church and state; an excellent study.
0433.
Morrison, Karl Frederick. Holiness and Politics in Early Medieval Thought. Leiden, The Netherlands: E. J. Brill, 1985. Addresses three chapters in the formation of Europe: the age of Church Fathers, the Carolingian era, and the investiture conflict, including questions regarding the proper relation between temporal and spiritual order of government.
Bibliographical Survey 0434.
179
Morrison, Karl Frederick. The Two Kingdoms: Ecclesiology in Carolingian Political Thought. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1964. Examines one of the most important episodes in the church-state struggle in the history of Christianity by focusing on the major achievement of the Carolingian “Renaissance,” Frankish ecclesiology, and the influence of ninth-century ecclesiology upon contemporary political thought, and shows how theology affected the evolution of ideas about rightful forms of government in social and political concepts; gives particular attention to the dualistic argument that civil and ecclesiastical government must be completely separate, each supreme in its own area.
0435.
Nederman, Cary J. Community and Consent: The Secular Political Theory of Marsiglio of Padua’s Defensor Pacis. Lanham, Md.: Rowman and Littlefield Publishers, Inc., 1995. Describes Marsiglio’s attempt to resolve the tension in medieval Christian political thought created by competing standards of reason and volition (the realm of every individual) and shows Marsiglio’s continuing relevance in the contemporary and secular world; the first serious examination of Defensor Pacis in almost fifty years.
0436.
Noble, Thomas F. X. The Republic of St. Peter: The Birth of the Papal State, 680-825. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1984. Argues that the Republic of St. Peter was in existence as an independent and political entity by the 730s and was not a creation of the Franks in the 750s and that the Franks did not seek, and were not assigned, specific governmental rights inside the Republic, and that at no time did they absorb the Republic within their kingdom or empire.
0437.
Papadakis, Aristeides and John Meyendorff. The Christian East and the Rise of the Papacy: The Church, 1071-1453 A.D. Crestwood, N. Y.: St. Vladimir’s Seminary Press, 1994. Examines the political and theological developments that brought about the sundering of Christendom in the emergence of the absolute papal claims over the Christian East; places the Great Schism in its historical context and does so from the Eastern Orthodox perspective.
0438.
Pennington, Kenneth and Robert Law Somervill. Church, and Society: Essays in Honor of Stephan Kuttner. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1977.
180
Church and State Provides essays on Pope Innocent III’s views on church and state, infallibility and erring popes, religious orders and offices, church and society, and the development of canon law during the Middle Ages, 6001500.
0439.
Pernoud, Régine. The Crusaders. London: Secker and Warburg, 1963. Examines the crusaders’ mode of life—their outlook, and their customs— how they solved their materials, what was the driving force—what was it that stirred them to action, to battle, and to love? Note especially Part III, “The Spirit of Conquest,” and Part IV, “Mysticism and Politics.”
0440.
Peters, Edward. Heresy and Authority in Medieval Europe. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1980. Noting that to maintain a belief in opposition to orthodox religion was to set o