In the eighteenth century the Mexican Church experienced spiritual renewal and intellectual reform. The establishment o...
339 downloads
2824 Views
8MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
In the eighteenth century the Mexican Church experienced spiritual renewal and intellectual reform. The establishment of Franciscan missionary colleges, of the Oratory and of convents and sisterhoods greatly enlivened devotion in the diocese of Michoacan. Thriving confraternities demonstrated the vigour of parochial life. But the secular clergy remained divided between a wealthy elite and an impecunious mass of curates and country vicars, with the cathedral chapter dominated by a group of enlightened peninsular canons. Charles III and his successor expelled the Jesuits, secularised mendicant parishes, closely invigilated popular religion, stripped the clergy of their immunity from royal courts and then seized their wealth. In 1810 priests from the Michoacan diocese led the popular Insurgency which challenged Spanish rule. Here is a rounded portrait of the Mexican Church at its meridian, which touches upon virtually all aspects of religious life and highlights the clash between post-Tridentine baroque Catholicism and enlightened despotism.
Church and State in Bourbon Mexico
Church and State in Bourbon Mexico The diocese of Michoacdn I J49-1810 D. A. Brading University Reader in Latin American History, University of Cambridge
CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS
PUBLISHED BY THE PRESS SYNDICATE OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CAMBRIDGE
The Pitt Building, Trumpington Street, Cambridge, United Kingdom CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS
The Edinburgh Building, Cambridge CB2 2RU, UK 40 West 20th Street, New York NY 10011-4211, USA 477 Williamstown Road, Port Melbourne, VIC 3207, Australia Ruiz de Alarcon 13,28014 Madrid, Spain Dock House, The Waterfront, Cape Town 8001, South Africa http://www.cambridge.org © Cambridge University Press 1994 This book is in copyright. Subject to statutory exception and to the provisions of relevant collective licensing agreements, no reproduction of any part may take place without the written permission of Cambridge University Press. First published 1994 First paperback edition 2002 A catalogue recordfor this book is available from the British Library Library of Congress Cataloguing in Publication data
Brading, D. A. Church and State in Bourbon Mexico: the diocese of Michoacan 1749-1810/D. A. Brading. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0 521460921 1. Catholic Church. Diocese of Michoacan de Ocampo (Mexico) Church history -18th century. 2. Michoacan de Ocampo (Mexico) Church history - 18th century. 3. Mexico-Church history-18th century. 4. Mexico-History-Spanish colony, 1540-1810. I. Title. BX1430.M53B73 1994 282'.7237-dc20 93-44303 CIP ISBN 0 521460921 hardback ISBN 0 521 52301 X paperback
In memoriam matri atque patri
. . . the People of God is by faith set free from Babylon, so that in the meantime they are only pilgrims in the midst of her. That is why the Apostle instructs the Church to pray for the kings of that city and those in high places, adding these words: 'that we may lead a quiet and peaceful life with all devotion and love'. St Augustine, City of God
Contents
List of tables Preface
page x xi
Part i: The religious orders 1
Jesuit expulsion
3
2
Mendicant chronicles
20
3
Oratorians
40
4
Secularisation
62
5
Nuns
82
Part 2: Priests and laity 6
Priests
105
7
Confraternities and parochial income
131
8
Devotion and deviance
150
Part 3: Bishops and chapter 9
Cathedral and chapter
173
10
A bishop and his canons
192
11
Tithes and chantries
211
12
Liberal prelate
228
Appendices Notes Bibliography Index
255 267 287 294 ix
Tables
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Population of the Michoacan diocese, c. 1810 page 106 Distribution of clergy in Michoacan diocese, 1793 107 Confraternities in Michoacan diocese, 1791 135 Average annual income of the parish of Zitacuaro, 1800—4 146 Confraternities and mass fees in Leon, 1775 147 Parochial income in Michoacan diocese, 1791 148 Diocesan tithes: distribution, expenses and stipends, 1790 183 Valladolid cathedral expenses, 1790 187 Valladolid cathedral fabric capital and income, 1804 191 Tithe receipts in Michoacan diocese 217 Church income in Michoacan diocese, 1791 221 Appendices
1 Church income in Spanish America, c. 1799 2 Parochial and conventual income in Michoacan diocese, 1791 3 Tithe income in Michoacan diocese, 1787
255 258 264
Preface
In 1979 I went to Morelia - viceregal Valladolid - to study the history of the Mexican Church in the eighteenth century. In Miners and Merchants in Bourbon Mexico (1971), I had described the revolution in government projected by Charles III and traced the fortunes of the entrepreneurial elite who promoted the economic expansion of that epoch, concentrating in particular on the great mining city of Guanajuato. Thereafter, in Haciendas and Ranchos in the Mexican Bajio (1978), I analysed the
patterns of land tenure and the structure of agricultural production in Leon. During my research I had already worked briefly in the archive of the episcopal curia of Michoacan, a diocese, which in the colonial period encompassed the territories of the modern states of Guanajuato, Michoacan, San Luis Potosi, parts of Jalisco and Colima. This archive had been confiscated by the state authorities during the Mexican Revolution and at that time was the only collection of diocesan records open for research. My aim was to complete my exploration of Bourbon Mexico by delving into the world of popular religion and conventual piety and thereby approach more closely the thoughts and sentiments of this epoch than had been possible in my previous books. In the event, the paltry few months of sabbatical leave at my disposal proved far too short a time to master the great mass of uncatalogued documents housed in the Casa Morelos. With over 1,000 legajos for the eighteenth century alone, any attempt even to survey their content was doomed to failure. Moreover, the bias of these records impelled me towards the material and financial side of church life. The result was that I often found myself following the trail blazed by Nancy Farriss in Crown and Clergy in Colonial Mexico (1968) where the attempts of Charles III and his ministers to reform the church were set out with precision. Even on the Enlightenment in Valladolid I saw that German Cardozo Galue in Michoacan en el sigh de las luces (1973) had already covered much of the ground. Subsequent spells of research in Mexico City and in the Archivo de Indias at Seville did not alter this impression. It was at this point that I put my notes to one side and embarked on the nine years of wide
xii
Preface
reading and hard writing that went into The First America (1991). All was not lost, however, since in that book I dealt both with the efflorescence of post-Tridentine Catholicism in New Spain and the assault on its baroque culture launched by the Bourbon Enlightenment. In 1990-1 I returned to Morelia, only to find that in archives where once I had laboured as a solitary student, free to fetch and open such documents as I cared to read, now teams of young graduates were at work cataloguing, reorganising and writing their theses. Within little more than a decade a new generation had appeared on the scene, in part influenced by the new-found interest in local history initiated by Luis Gonzalez and the Colegio de Michoacan at Zamora. One of the first fruits of that new interest was Oscar Mazin's Entre dos majestades (1987) which examined the administration of Bishop Sanchez de Tagle, a prelate about whom I had found abundant traces. Another manifestation of change was the decision of the cathedral chapter to allow a team from the Colegio de Michoacan to catalogue and study their hitherto jealously guarded records. Confronted with this upsurge in archival research, I decided that I could best assist the collective enterprise by employing the materials I had already collected to frame a general account of the church in Michoacan in the second half of the eighteenth century. Although this book can certainly be regarded as the concluding volume in a trilogy on Bourbon Mexico, it possesses a more introductory character than was the case with its two predecessors. To throw into relief the shock caused by the Bourbon assault on the Mexican Church, I have introduced chapters based on the mendicant chroniclers of Michoacan which depict the dynamic character of baroque Catholicism in New Spain during the first decades of the eighteenth century. Notable features here were the Franciscan colleges de propagandafide,the Oratory at San Miguel el Grande and the emergence of beaterias. The second section of the book deals with the secular clergy, the role of confraternities in parochial life and the forms of popular religion. The third section examines the cathedral chapter at Valladolid and provides a systematic account of church finance. The book concludes with a discussion of the life and writings of Manuel Abad y Queipo, the last Spanish bishop of Michoacan. In effect, the book consists of separate essays on different aspects of church life, some taken from published materials, the bulk based on archival sources, but all dealing with the diocese of Michoacan. Two caveats need to be noted, one of principle, the other of method. At some points I describe scenes of conflict and corruption among the clergy; but it should always be remembered that one bad priest was apt to generate more episcopal paperwork than ten good priests going quietly about their business. More
Preface
xiii
practically, since the completion of this book, I have learnt that both the location and the enumeration of documents in the Casa Morelos archive have been radically altered; to trace my references it will now be necessary to discover their possible correlatives in the new catalogue. In both the research and the writing of this book I have incurred debts I am anxious to acknowledge. On first going to Morelia I was greatly assisted by Alfonso de Maria y Campos. So also, the late director of the archive in the Casa Morelos, Manuel Castaneda Ramirez, allowed me uninterrupted use of its materials. On my return to that city I was welcomed by Fausto Zeron Medina; Carlos Herrejon Peredo took me into the archive of the cathedral chapter; and Oscar Mazin and Marta Parada helped clarify my thoughts on diocesan and cathedral administration. The Oratory Fathers at San Miguel presented me with a copy of the life of their Founder and allowed me to consult a key document. The archivist of the province of San Pedro y San Pablo made it possible for me to inspect the Franciscan archive at Celaya. For the rest, I wish to thank Margaret Rankine who has typed this manuscript and often corrected my errors. My research in Morelia was made possible by an award from the British Academy, and subsequent visits to Mexico City and Seville were assisted by grants from the University Travel Fund at Cambridge. Finally, I thank Celia Wu for her unswerving support both during our stay in Morelia and during the summers when this book was written.
Parti
The religious orders
Jesuit expulsion
In 1767 Charles III (1759-88) summarily expelled all Jesuits from his dominions in Europe and America. At this time the Mexican province of the Company of Jesus numbered 678 priests and brothers, many of whom came from leading Creole families. At one stroke, the colleges which had provided education in all the chief cities of the kingdom were closed. In the capital, the San Ildefonso college had been rebuilt on a majestic scale during the 1740s and was renowned for the distinction of its students who became 'bishops, judges, canons and professors in all the faculties'. In Puebla the Jesuits had only just completed rebuilding their splendidly decorated new church. The Mexican province was in the midst of a marked expansion in activity and manifested all the signs of an intellectual regeneration when the detachments of soldiers bearing the expulsion orders arrived at their colleges and mission stations. A priest later recalled how his brethren were abruptly instructed to pack their sparse belongings and within two days were escorted to the port of Veracruz, their journey broken only by a last, merciful visit for prayer to Our Lady of Guadalupe, Mexico's patron saint, in her sanctuary at Tepeyac. Thereafter, the Jesuits faced a long voyage to Cadiz, followed by an equally arduous journey, first to Corsica, and then to Papal States.1 Several elderly or infirm priests died on the way; a few sought release from their vows; and the faithful survivors found lodgings in Italian cities there to eke out a penurious, obscure existence until their death. Of over 500 Mexican-born Jesuits, only two were destined to see their beloved homeland again. The 'urgent, just and compelling causes' which had driven the king to sanction such an apparently arbitrary exercise of power were never divulged to his subjects but remained locked away 'in the royal breast'. The unquestioning loyalty demanded by the Bourbon monarchy was expressed by Archbishop Francisco Antonio de Lorenzana (1766-72) who in a pastoral letter warned his flock against even discussing the
4
The religious orders
matter: 'What has to be done is to obey and be silent.' It was the same prelate who persuaded the Fourth Mexican Church Council, convoked in 1771, to call for the dissolution of the Company of Jesus, a resolution duly cited by the Spanish ambassador to the Holy See when in 1774 he successfully obtained from Pope Clement XIV the extinction of the Jesuits as a recognised institute of the Catholic Church.2 To allay popular consternation caused by these events, the bishop of Oaxaca prepared a pastoral, never actually circulated, in which he exclaimed: How can a pen or mouth write or speak without wonder or dread on a matter about which neither Pope nor King wishes anyone to speak or write and which ought to be already buried in the deepest oblivion . . . it is a matter which simply demands a religious silence and devout veneration towards the inscrutable dispositions of Divine Providence and of the two supreme powers of the ecclesiastical and secular realms.3 The expulsion of the Jesuits coincided with the general visitation of New Spain (1765-71) conducted by Jose de Galvez and had been preceded by the arrival in Mexico of two regiments of regular soldiers. For both the Creole elite and the masses it thus formed part of an entire series of measures introduced by the Spanish crown, all designed to strengthen the power of the monarchy, measures which transformed colonial government but injured the interests of the Mexican people. When the newly arrived inspector general of troops, Juan de Villalba, sought to levy militia forces without distinction of rank or caste, the city council of Mexico indignantly complained to the crown that he had acted 'against the ordinances, against the constitution of this country', entirely disregarding the pre-eminent claims of the Creole nobility to officer the new regiments.4 Although the council did not dare to protest against the Jesuit expulsion, nevertheless, the current viceroy, the marquis of Croix, warned the Minister of the Indies, Julian de Arriaga: 'I shall not hide from Your Excellency that all the clergy and lawyers, since they belong entirely to them [the Jesuits] are also the most resentful.'5 In effect, Creole judges of the high court and canons of the cathedral chapter of Mexico initiated a whispering campaign against Galvez, alleging that he held 'strange' disorderly entertainments in his house. In response the viceroy accused Francisco Javier de Gamboa, an alcalde del crimen in the high court and the crown attorney (fiscal), Juan Antonio de Velarde, of leading an 'anti-government party'. The case became more serious when Gamboa and Canon Antonio Lopez Portillo, a Creole cleric famous for his erudition, were accused of being the joint authors of a pamphlet written in defence of the Jesuits against Archbishop
Jesuit expulsion 6
5
Lorenzana. Although evidence was wanting, in 1768 the crown heeded Croix's insinuations and ordered Velarde, Gamboa, Lopez Portillo and his cousin Archdeacon Ignacio Ceballos to take up positions in the Peninsula. For the diocese of Michoacan, a province which then encompassed the modern states of San Luis Potosi, Guanajuato, Michoacan and Colima, the Jesuit expulsion was greeted by popular riots which were suppressed with brutal vigour by the visitor general. In all, the Company possessed seven colleges in the diocese, situated at Valladolid, Leon, Guanajuato, San Luis Potosi, Celaya, Patzcuaro and San Luis de la Paz, which housed some fifty-two priests and fifteen scholastics and associates. At Guanajuato the Jesuits had arrived only a generation before their expulsion and both the owners of its mines and their workers had contributed generously to raise a magnificent college and church, constructed in the latest Churrigueresque style, which had been consecrated amidst universal rejoicing in 1765.7 Moreover, the populace of this great mining city had already rioted the previous year, protesting against the imposition of excise duties on maize, flour and meat; against the badly made cigars of the newly established royal tobacco monopoly; and against the formation of a local militia. When news of the Jesuit expulsion became public 'a great number of workers from the mines and refining mills together with many vagabonds from the town and its district rioted, throwing stones at the treasury, the tobacco monopoly and gunpowder monopoly and at many other houses'. Backed by a Spanish regiment despatched from Mexico and supported by wealthy Creoles fearful of popular violence, Jose de Galvez suppressed this 'rebellion' with unprecedented severity, imprisoning 600 men for examination, from whose ranks he hanged 9, sent 31 for life imprisonment and sentenced another 148 for varying periods of confinement.8 Much the same sequence of events occurred in San Luis Potosi where miners from the Cerro de San Pedro joined rioters from the Indian suburbs of the city in attacking shops and state buildings, freeing prisoners and threatening 'to finish off all Spaniards at once'. In this case, a leading landowner of the district mobilised his cowboys and joined Galvez in dispersing and capturing the rioters. Other outbreaks occurred in Valle de San Francisco, Guadalcazar and Venado.9 Equally important, in Michoacan the Indian governor of Patzcuaro, Pedro de Soria Villaroel, succeeded in raising the native communities of the highlands against the expulsion and the imposition of new taxes. According to Galvez, 'this mestizo Indian, a blacksmith by profession, in whom cunning and ambition overflow, succeeded in making himself the leader of all the castes of the lowest populace and extended his
6
The religious orders
government over all the 113 villages included in the province'.10 But although various riots occurred, particularly in Uruapan and Patzcuaro, they were easily quelled, their leaders captured and executed and other participants imprisoned or whipped. Although Viceroy Croix and the authorities in Madrid praised Galvez for the decisive fashion in which he defeated the popular challenge to royal authority, many churchmen and officials were appalled at the severity of his punishments. In all, he hanged 85 men, flogged 73, banished 117 and sentenced 674 to various terms of imprisonment. Equally important, he abolished the municipal government of those Indian pueblos in San Luis Potosi and Michoacan which had participated in the riots. Some years after, the parish priest of Santa Clara del Cobre claimed that 'all the economic, political and Christian government of the Indians has fallen to the ground since the hierarchical order which they had among them was abolished5.11 But although appeals were made to restore the self-government of these communities, the appointment of Galvez as Minister of the Indies in 1776 prevented any review of the case. Nor did Galvez express any regrets for his measures, since he insisted that Indians should be prohibited from wearing the clothes of Spaniards and from riding horses, so that they should be kept 'in that humble condition designed for them by the Creator'. It was necessary for government to adopt strong measures in America, because the populace were more dangerous than in Spain since there was 'a greater licence, general nakedness, an exterior religion, and an absence of shame'.12 It was this view that led him to promote the establishment of militia regiments and standing picquets of troops to patrol the leading cities of the province. In San Luis de la Paz, where the Jesuits had administered the parish, Bishop Anselmo Sanchez de Tagle appointed two secular priests to administer it jointly. On informing the viceroy of his decision, he noted that he had visited Patzcuaro to prevent any further trouble and that in the parishes of Dolores and San Miguel el Grande no riots had occurred since the priests there could speak the Indian languages and indeed were 'Indians'. The newly appointed cura of San Luis de la Paz informed the bishop that Galvez had departed for the north leaving 'an example which has left us horrified, since yesterday he hanged three Indians and had another shot and the heads of each one are placed on the corners of the square'. The families of these four leaders had been banished and their houses destroyed, their sites sown with salt. Yet he noted that the 'Indians are very rational', well-behaved and instructed in the Law of God, and indeed that 'most know how to read and some to write'.13 Among the assistant clergy was 'an Indian father from San Miguel called
Jesuit expulsion
7
Ramirez', a sign of the ethnic acculturation in this region during the eighteenth century. The dramatic events of 1767 marked a violent watershed in the history of New Spain: a powerful ecclesiastical corporation had been brutally destroyed by the simple fiat of the crown and the populace savagely repressed for their resistance to change. For Mexico the shock was all the more great since the country had been insulated from the civil wars and foreign invasions which had devastated most European states, including Spain, in the past two centuries. Since the conquest, Mexico had enjoyed an enviable Pax Hispanica, broken only by perennial frontier raids by untamed native tribes such as the Apache, by a cycle of piratical assaults on coastal towns and by two great riots in Mexico City during the seventeenth century. Apart from a minuscule viceregal guard, the interior of the country was entirely bereft of a military establishment, so that any popular commotions had to be subdued by leading citizens and their followers or by the clergy sallying forth with the Holy Sacrament. Since district magistrates were usually more given to the pursuit of commercial profit than the administration of justice, the clergy had come to enjoy the authority and prestige that elsewhere was exercised by the civil power. Indeed, in certain areas of the empire, the church was the state, its ministers acting as judges and as representatives of the monarchy.14 In Madrid the accession of the Bourbon dynasty brought to power ministers who were obsessed with the restoration of Spanish power in Europe. Conversant with mercantilist maxims and impressed by the France of Louis XIV, they sought to reanimate the economy and reform society, since only with a greater flow of trade could the state raise the resources to finance the expansion of its military might, both on land and at sea. The American empire occupied a key place in this project of reform, since with better management its mines and plantations could generate the Atlantic commerce on which the prosperity and strength of the monarchy could be rebuilt. But reports from Mexico and Peru, written by viceroys and official visitors, denounced the church as an obstacle to the revitalisation of the power of the crown in the New World. The religious orders were criticised as corrupt and bishops and their chapters thought to be too wealthy. By reason of their corporate independence, their extensive jurisdiction, their great riches and frequent laxity, the multiple institutions of the American Church thus presented a major obstacle to the plans of the Bourbon ministers to augment the power of the colonial state, to revive the colonial economy and to procure a greater flow of revenue from the New World.15 If the expulsion of the Jesuits constituted the most savage blow dealt
8
The religious orders
to the Mexican Church, it was by no means an isolated incident. In 1749 a special junta of ministers and churchmen recommended that the extensive doctrinas administered by mendicant orders in central New Spain should be transferred to the care of the secular clergy, with the result that during the 1750s friars were summarily expelled from churches and country priories they had occupied since the sixteenth century. Thereafter, in 1771 the Fourth Mexican Church Council debated whether to authorise a general visitation of the religious orders and, when some bishops baulked at this measure, the crown proceeded to despatch visitors to achieve its purpose. The number of novices admitted for profession was reduced and the mendicants found themselves restricted either to an urban ministry or to missionary activity in frontier regions. By the close of the century, provincials complained that many friars now sought liberation from their vows, obtaining individual secularisation from Rome. Although the Mexican bishops and their cathedral chapters collaborated with the crown in its assault on the religious orders, from the 1780s onwards they found their own jurisdiction and income subject to reiterated attack by the ministers and officials of Charles III and his successor, Charles IV. The first major assault on their interests came in 1786 when they received rescripts, supported by the Intendancy Ordinances, which demanded that the administration of the ecclesiastical tithe be transferred to provincial juntas headed by the intendants. In this case, the determined resistance of the hierarchy succeeded in forcing ministers to withdraw the measure. By contrast, when in 1795 the crown abrogated the clergy's absolute immunity from the jurisdiction of royal courts in cases where they were accused of grave crimes, the equally determined protests of the bishops failed to halt the criminal bench of the Mexican high court from proceeding against several clerics. The spectacle of priests imprisoned in a common gaol proved a sore affront both to the faithful and to the clergy.16 In the same decade, ministers introduced a series of small taxes, all designed to tap the income of the clergy, especially of the cathedral chapters. This quest for revenue, which was given added impetus by the crown's virtual bankruptcy, culminated in the Consolidation decree of 1804 which demanded that all church capital should be deposited in the royal treasury that henceforth would be responsible for payment of interest. This amortisation was implemented by a corrupt viceroy despite a flurry of protests from leading institutions, and acted to alienate the clergy still further from their traditional loyalty to the monarchy. In effect, at all levels the Mexican Church suffered an unprecedented assault, initiated by ministers and officials who prided themselves on
Jesuit expulsion
9
their enlightened views, exhibited a growing envy of clerical wealth and feared the clergy's influence over the faithful. Many of these men joined Joseph Bonaparte when in 1808 French forces installed him as king of Spain, hoping thus to complete their 'reform' of the church, closing monasteries and confiscating church property. It was for this reason that bishops and friars figured so prominently in the resistance to the French. Ironically, in New Spain leading clergymen in the diocese of Michoacan called upon their flocks to rebel against the colonial authorities, urging as a pretext the danger of Bonaparte being recognised as king. In reality, their role in the 1810 Insurgency can only be explained as a reaction to the prolonged and reiterated assault on the privileges, jurisdiction, wealth and income of the Mexican Church launched from Madrid by ministers unconversant with the realities of New Spain. II To explain the expulsion of the Jesuits, contemporaries fixed upon the famous Motin de Esquilache, when in 1766 the populace of Madrid rioted and invaded the royal palace, shouting: 'Long live Spain! Death to Squilace!' That an Italian minister should have issued a decree forbidding Spaniards to wear their customary voluminous capes and broad-brimmed hats was too great an insult to Castilian pride. But Charles III and his ministers were convinced that such a dramatic challenge to the crown's authority had been set in motion by a broad coalition of vested interests opposed to their programme of reform of church and state. In a ministerial paper on the riot, Pedro Rodriguez Campomanes (1723-1803), the current attorney (fiscal) of the Council of Castile, identified the Jesuits as its chief, albeit secret, authors. It was not the first time that the Jesuits had plotted against the Spanish monarchy, since in 1640 the Portuguese province had ardently supported the rebellion led by the duke of Braganza. For Campomanes 'the prime vice' of the Company of Jesus was that it was an international institution, enforcing a loyalty which superseded the obligations of its members as citizens, so that every Jesuit 'is the enemy of the Sovereign Power, depending on a despotic government resident in a foreign country'.17 The most striking feature of his report was the prominence given to American issues. The humiliation of Juan de Palafox y Mendoza, bishop of Puebla (1640-54), who was driven from his see owing to his attempt to oblige the Jesuits to pay tithes on the produce of their estates offered an object lesson to all loyal servants of the crown. As for the Jesuit missions in Paraguay, what did they constitute but a kingdom wholly owned by the father-general resident in Rome? The king of Spain
io
The religious orders
enjoyed but nominal authority in a province where the mission priests exercised a despotic power over the natives, forcing them to work on their plantations, selling their produce and employing the profits for unknown purposes. All this led to the conclusion that since the kings of Portugal and France had already banished the Jesuits for 'reasons of state', it was now time for the Spanish crown to exercise its 'economic power' so as to expel the Jesuits, seize their property and ban their doctrines, measures necessary 'to save the country and true religion'.18 If Campomanes condemned the Jesuits so stridently, it was because he sought to enlarge the absolute authority of the Spanish monarchy. Citing the medieval laws of Partida, which declared that kings are 'vicars of God, each one in his own kingdom', he asserted that their sovereign power derived directly from God Almighty. As 'the anointed of God', kings had the right and duty to act as the protectors of the church, crushing heresy and invigilating the discipline of the clergy. Had not Constantine the Great presided over General Councils of the Church? In Spain the Visigothic kings had convoked councils to discuss church affairs and the medieval Cortes had equally intervened in that sphere. Indeed, the privileges, immunities, jurisdiction and property which the church possessed all derived from concessions of the sovereign power of monarchs, who retained the authority as much to abrogate as to confirm these temporal rights. In his Tratado de la regalia de amortization (1765), Campomanes demonstrated that all the monarchies of medieval Europe had passed laws limiting the acquisition of property by the church, legislation especially directed against the religious orders. Despite these measures, however, ecclesiastical institutions in Spain had continued to grow in wealth to the point whereby in the seventeenth century the church had become such a burden on society that it was chiefly responsible for the depopulation of cities and the impoverishment of the kingdom.19 The moral he drew from this bleak history was that the monarchy had ample precedent and clear authority to limit the numbers and wealth of the clergy, measures he considered eminently desirable. Furthermore, in his Juicio impartial (1769), Campomanes argued that the authority of the Papacy was entirely spiritual and that the church did not possess any inherent right to exercise coercive or legal jurisdiction. At the same time, he appealed to history to demonstrate that the Papacy's claim to appoint bishops was a medieval innovation. Consonant with this attack on Rome's pretensions, he counselled that the Papacy should not be permitted to admit appeals on ecclesiastical affairs from Spain or America and still less allowed to despatch rescripts and bulls to the Hispanic Church without consultation with the king's councils. All this led to the conclusion that 'the church exists within the state' and that the
Jesuit expulsion
n
clergy were not exempt from their obligations as 'citizens and subjects'. The king's divine right to govern thus included authority over all aspects of church life other than the strictly doctrinal and spiritual.20 In these uncompromising pronouncements, we encounter the dogmatic foundations of the sustained campaign launched by the enlightened ministers of the last Bourbon monarchs against the privileges, income and property of the Mexican Church. Charles III would never have dared expel the Jesuits had he not been assured of the support of an influential party within the Spanish Church. According to a later source, it was Minister of Justice, Manuel de Roda, a talented lawyer of humble extraction, who engineered an alliance of 'freethinkers and Jansenists' to destroy the Jesuits. The problem here is to define what was meant by Jansenism in this context, especially since the Jesuits both then and later tended to accuse all their opponents of being Jansenists. What is clear is that churchmen in Bourbon Spain took little interest in the grand Augustinian questions of free will and divine grace that had divided Jesuits and Jansenists so bitterly in seventeenthcentury France. There was indeed a great deal of French influence. But it was the Gallican theses of Bossuet and the ecclesiastical history of the abbe Fleury that were most frequently read and cited. Moreover, the Spanish regalist tradition in canon law (on which Campomanes had drawn) found reinforcement from the works of Van Espen and 'Febronius', canonists who sharply criticised the papal monarchy, defining its absolutist pretensions as a medieval abuse which had undermined the rightful authority of national episcopates and church councils.21 But eighteenth-century Spanish Jansenism moved beyond the forms of church government to question the value of the religious orders, choosing to emphasise the pastoral primacy of the bishops and the parochial clergy. The magnification of asceticism and mystical prayer so prevalent in Habsburg Spain was replaced by the teaching of a simple, interior piety and good works. The preaching of the gospel based on scriptural texts was now more esteemed than the pomp and expense of liturgical celebration. As a result, bishops and priests adopted a critical view of popular religion, questioning the belief in miraculous cures and the value ascribed to pilgrimages to sanctuaries housing holy images. It was not long before the enlightened clergy also came to deplore the extravagant gilded churches and altars of the baroque and Churrigueresque styles as offensive to Christian piety and good taste. The simple unadorned lines of the neo-classic satisfied both 'Jansenist' and enlightened opinion. In the sphere of theology and philosophy, scholasticism came under strong attack both for its reliance on the
12
The religious orders
outmoded doctrines of Aristotle and for its disputatious methods. Instead, students were advised to return to the early Fathers of the church and to become acquainted with church history and the proceedings of the great councils. In effect, 'Jansenists' acted as the spearhead of what was a broad movement for reform and renewal within the Spanish Church, a movement which included zealots, moderates and placemen, united only by their repudiation of the spiritual and intellectual culture of baroque post-Tridentine Catholicism.22 If the Jesuits were attacked so strongly, it was because they had employed their formidable talents to defend scholastic doctrines, encourage popular devotions such as the Sacred Heart of Jesus and build richly adorned churches. The issue which united Jansenising churchmen and regalist lawyers was the refusal of the Jesuits in America to pay the full ecclesiastical tithe on the produce of their numerous haciendas. It was his insistence that Jesuits should pay this tax which had led to the downfall of Bishop Palafox, a zealous prelate whom Charles III aspired to see canonised. What especially angered the coterie of ministers who advised the king on this matter was the special arrangement which the Company of Jesus had obtained from the crown in 1750 whereby, instead of the regular tithe, they were allowed to pay only a thirtieth of their produce. The effect of this agreement was to reduce the income of the bishops and cathedral chapters who were maintained by the tithe, and to reduce the crown's income from its share of this tax, the dos novenos or two-ninths. That this agreement had been negotiated by a special junta headed by Jose de Carbajal y Lancaster, supported by Ferdinand VFs leading minister, the marquis of Ensenada, and the king's Jesuit father confessor, Francisco de Ravago, only added fuel to the suspicions of those ministers for whom Ensenada was an enemy whose hand they were later to detect in the Motin de Esquilache.23
The question of tithes was reopened by Charles Ill's father confessor, Fray Joaquin de Osma, a member of the reformed wing of the Franciscan Order and a native of Palafox's last see, Osma. He compiled a file which started in the 1760s when tenants resident on Jesuit haciendas in Chile refused to pay the full tithe, citing the agreement of 1750 that such estates should pay only a thirtieth. Although the cathedral chapter in Santiago de Chile had strongly protested, the high court supported the Jesuits and, indeed, when recourse was had to the Council of the Indies, the crown attorney argued that it could not be resolved by the king (in his royal person) as a matter of executive government, but rather had to be tried by the judicial branch of the Council. Here was an opinion which Osma characterised as entirely favourable to the Jesuits, since 'the case would be eternalised and the
Jesuit expulsion
13
Council would let its clients maintain their usurped rights'. Although the king had always been recognised as 'the sole and absolute lord of the tithes', the 1750 transaction had clearly undermined that claim, since the Jesuits now claimed that their privileges derived from the Papacy. In a memorandum written in January 1765 to the Minister of the Indies, Julian de Arriaga, Osma declared that if the king would but read a resume of this case, he would at once observe how 'some Spaniards, enemies of their country and king' had betrayed royal interests in favour of the Jesuits, an order which had entered the Indies 'as if they had gone there more to conquer haciendas than souls'.24 He called for the ministers of the high court in Chile and of the Council of the Indies to be reprimanded and strongly urged that the 1750 agreement be terminated. The upshot of these recommendations was that count de la Villanueva, a minister of the Council of Castile, was appointed to head a junta charged with the examination of the whole tithe issue. His report, presented in April 1766, made explosive reading.25 By way of introduction, Villanueva noted that it had proved difficult and at times impossible to locate all the relevant documents, especially the papers dealing with the 1750 Settlement. He then emphasised that the crown's interest in the matter stemmed from the papal bull of 16 December 1501 which had granted the kings of Spain 'full, absolute and irrevocable dominion' over all church tithes collected in the Indies, rights which were an expression of its patronato over the American Church. Although the crown had then donated the tithes to the bishops and chapters, nevertheless, it had always retained dos novenos as an expression of its primordial dominion over this tax. However, when the religious orders acquired estates in the New World, they had claimed exemption from payment of tithes. Indeed, the Jesuits obtained successive bulls from the Papacy in 1549 and 1561 which exempted the Company from paying this tax either in Spain or America. If in Europe, this privilege was brought to an end by 1605, in Mexico litigation only started in 1624 and lasted until 1655, in a case affecting all religious orders. In the 1640s Bishop Palafox had complained of the enormous estates which the Jesuits had already acquired and had sought to exact payment. The case was finally resolved by the Council of the Indies in 1655 which commanded that henceforth all religious institutes should pay tithes to the cathedral chapters on the produce of their estates. Faced with such an authoritative ruling, all the parties to the dispute agreed to fulfil their obligations. Only the Jesuits demurred and brought in counter-appeals. Moreover, such tithes as they may have paid thereafter - and the documentation was not clear on this score - were based on their own declarations of production. The result was that in 1735 the cathedral chapter of Mexico complained strongly to
14
The religious orders
the crown about the difficulties of collecting tithes from Jesuits. Their complaints were supported by the high court in Mexico City which averred that by then the Jesuits had an income of 400,000 ps. from a chain of seventy-nine haciendas, an improbably high estimate. On reviewing the documents, Villanueva exclaimed that 'in all the course of this lawsuit the Company has denied His Majesty's dominion, since only in this way could its privileges retain their value'. Since 1742 Father Pedro Ignacio Altamirano had negotiated with royal ministers over the case, assisted at its conclusion by his fellow Jesuit, Francisco de Ravago, Ferdinand VI's father confessor. It was not until 1750 that Altamirano accepted the principle of the crown's 'full dominion' over the tithes and even then he refused to accept the rights of the American bishops and chapters, urging that the privileges granted to the Company of Jesus by the Papacy provided exemption from their jurisdiction. Indeed, Altamirano had flatly rejected the authority of the Council of the Indies and had insisted on negotiating directly with the crown and its ministers. It was this spirited defence that provoked Villanueva to comment indignantly that ca subject litigates with his king, a Jesuit with his lord, Ferdinand VI'. The result was a triumph for the Company, since although the Jesuits finally recognised the crown's absolute dominion over tithes in the Indies, it obtained the extraordinary concession of only paying a thirtieth of its haciendas' produce rather than the regular tenth. Moreover, their estate managers' declaration of production were to be accepted without scrutiny so as to avoid all future quarrels and lawsuits. On recounting this extraordinary sequence of events, Villanueva noted that at least two Jesuit authors had defended the moral legitimacy of rendering false declarations to tax authorities if economic necessity could be urged. In conclusion, he recommended that the 1750 Settlement should be declared null and void and that henceforth the Jesuits should pay the full tithe. It was on 4 December 1766, which is to say, only three months before the expulsion orders were signed, that the crown issued a rescript repealing the 1750 Settlement. It referred to 'the importunate petitions and capricious memorials' presented by the attorney for the Company and noted that the Settlement had been agreed and signed by ministers of the Council of Castile, ignoring both the complaints of the American cathedral chapters and the special knowledge of the Council of the Indies.26 In effect, for two centuries the Company of Jesus had escaped the full rigours of the tithe exacted from all other haciendas and plantations in Spanish America, a contributory cause of their extraordinary success at estate management. Oblivious to the danger which threatened them, in September 1766 the
Jesuit expulsion
15
Jesuits succeeded in obtaining a papal breve which confirmed and renovated all the powers and privileges currently enjoyed by their missionary priests. Among these rights were powers to issue marriage dispensations, licences to read books prohibited by the Inquisition and the definition of Indians as neophytes in the Catholic faith. When the Minister of the Indies, Julian de Arriaga, was apprised by the Spanish minister resident in Rome of the content of this breve, he complained bitterly of both the Papacy and the Jesuits, fixing upon 'the disparity with which that Court treats our bishops of the Indies as compared to the Jesuits, since what to the former it concedes with so much difficulty, to the latter it dispenses with unparalleled freedom; and what costs our Lord King so many applications is effected by an insinuation of the Company's General'. In particular, he took strong exception to the Jesuits' right to define their Indian subjects as neophytes, since this concession of virtually permanent mission status was 'more than sufficient to maintain as many Indians as they please outside the king's jurisdiction for ages and ages, centuries and centuries'. Obviously, what he had in mind was the status of Paraguay as a virtually autonomous Jesuit state only broadly subject to the monarch's authority. In January 1767 Charles III commanded the president of the Council of the Indies to ban the papal breve from circulation, since it had undermined the authority of the crown, the American bishops and the Inquisition.27 On learning of the matter, the attorneys of the Council lamented that the Jesuits had obviously sought to despatch copies of the breve to their colleges and missions in America without first obtaining ministerial permission, and complained that the civil laws did not receive the veneration accorded to ecclesiastical laws, even though they were 'promulgated in the name of the same God, of whom princes and supreme powers are vicars in the temporal sphere'. When the count of Aranda, a minister usually identified as a 'freethinker' provided the president of the Council of the Indies with copies of the decree dated 17 March 1767, which expelled the Jesuits from Spanish dominions in both America and Europe, he emphasised that it was the Jesuits' constant manoeuvres to obtain privileges exempting them from episcopal jurisdiction which had caused their downfall. He insisted on the great dangers that flowed from 'entrusting entire provinces to a religious body with a superior outside the kingdom', especially when 'these provinces or missions were found to be substantially separated from the monarchy'. In regions such as Paraguay, the Jesuits had failed to teach the Indians Spanish, forbade Spaniards to enter their missions for trade and did not recognise the authority of the royal courts.28 In future, the crown would rely on the secular clergy to govern the Indians and would place these territories under the jurisdiction of royal
16
The religious orders
magistrates, granting Spaniards the freedom to enter such lands. Henceforth, Leviathan would brook no rivals in the exercise of state power. Ill If the Bourbon assault on the church proved so shocking to the Mexican clergy, it was because many priests still entertained a providentialist interpretation of the Spanish monarchy. In Politica Indiana (1648), the standard commentary on the Laws of the Indies, written by Juan de Solorzano Pereira, they encountered the resounding affirmation that the Spanish empire derived from the design of God the Almighty who had chosen Spain from amidst the nations of Europe to bring the Christian gospel to the natives of the New World. Its title-deed was the papal donation of 1493, when Alexander VI recognised the Catholic kings of Castile as lords of the New World on condition that they ensured the conversion of its inhabitants to the Catholic faith. Thereafter, Pope Julius II granted the kings the universal patronage of the American Church, with the right to nominate all bishops and canons throughout their vast empire. As regards the relation between the secular and ecclesiastical jurisdictions, Solorzano affirmed that 'of one and the other arm the State of the Commonwealth is composed and in each the care of our kings is manifest'. He thus defined the Catholic religion as the chief foundation of Spain's empire in the New World and declared that as universal patrons of the American Church the Catholic kings acted as 'vicars of the Roman pontificate and as constables of the army of God'.29 In effect, Solorzano envisioned the Habsburg realm as a universal monarchy, composed of several kingdoms, in which the crown was supported by two great orders of government, the secular and the ecclesiastical, each endowed with its own laws, courts, ministers and revenue, respectively led by magistrates and bishops appointed by their common ruler. In New Spain imperial providentialism was matched by a religious cult which affirmed that the Mother of God had chosen the Mexican people for her especial protection. In 1737 when the City of Mexico was beset by a devastating plague which carried off thousands of its inhabitants, Our Lady of Guadalupe was proclaimed as its patron. This proved such a popular measure that in 1747 the bishops and chapters of all the Mexican dioceses united to proclaim the Virgin of Tepeyac as universal patron of New Spain. This solemn act, which was soon ratified by the Papacy, expressed the culmination of a century-long campaign by the Creole clergy to encourage and preach veneration for this image. For it was only in 1648 that Miguel Sanchez published the first circumstantial
Jesuit expulsion
17
account of the miraculous apparition of the Virgin Mary in 1531 to the Indian Juan Diego at Tepeyac, and the equally miraculous imprinting of her image on his cape before Archbishop Zumarraga. Until then, the shrine at Tepeyac, built on a small peak outside Mexico City once dedicated to the Aztec goddess Tonanztin, had only attracted a local veneration, and, indeed, had been sharply criticised by Franciscan missionaries as a mask for the idolatry of Indian pilgrims. But, with the publication of Sanchez's work, Creole canons and university professors vied to exalt and propagate the cult of the Guadalupe image. In the 1660s the pilgrim highway connecting the sanctuary to the capital was lined with small chapels or stations devoted to the mysteries of the rosary, and in 1695 work began on a magnificent new church.30 Endowment bequests mounted and in 1751 a college of canons was established to officiate at the sanctuary, the only body of this type in New Spain outside the cathedral chapters. The significance of the cult was threefold. The narrative of the apparition and the patronage conferred by the preservation of the imprinted image was interpreted by the Creole elite within the clergy as providing the Mexican Church with a heavenly foundation quite distinct from and superior to the spiritual conquest so exultantly celebrated by Franciscan missionaries from the Peninsula. It was owing to the intercession of the Virgin Mary that paganism was so rapidly eradicated from New Spain. Far from constituting a missionary extension of Europe, the Mexican Church took its start from the apparition at Tepeyac. At the same time, veneration for an image, where the Virgin Mary is depicted as an Indian or mestiza, united the Creole clergy and Indian masses in a common devotion. That the appointment of canons at the sanctuary was made conditional upon knowledge of Indian languages emphasises the popular nature of the cult. Indeed, the contemporary historian Mariano Veytia commented that each week Indian pilgrims appeared in the courtyard before the church to dance and sing hymns in their own tongue.31 Finally, the cult served to exalt the primacy of Mexico City and its archbishop, and to unite the entire country under a common patron. In all the cathedral cities and provincial capitals of New Spain, chapels and altars were raised in honour of the Guadalupe, and in many places a sanctuary was built on the outskirts of the town connected by a pilgrim highway, in direct emulation of the relation between Mexico and Tepeyac. Here, then, we encounter both a foundation myth and a popular cult, which aroused a devotion which was both patriotic and religious, the very symbol of a church that was Creole and Indian. In the same decades that veneration for the Guadalupe mounted to its climax, religious architecture entered an exuberant phase of construction
18
The religious orders
dominated by the style generally called Churrigueresque. Once more the cathedral in Mexico City played a central role, calling in two Spanish architects to design the Altar of the Kings and the new sagrario. The result was to introduce into New Spain the latest developments of the Spanish baroque. Thereafter, in the sixty years 1730-90, the altars and facades of Mexican churches, hitherto divided into rectangular panels, their decoration and pillars all dominated by a horizontal emphasis, seemed to dance, as the traditional orders of the Renaissance were dissolved and replaced by estipetes, niched pilasters and elaborate mouldings, the sculptural detail entirely subordinated to the upward movement of the entire frame. The Santa Prisca at Taxco, the Valenciana near Guanajuato, the altars of the Santa Clara at Queretaro: all offer examples of religious architecture for which the only parallels in Europe are to be found in Andalusia and Austria.32 To judge from chronicles published at the time, both the intellectual elite and the masses joined in acclamation of the new marvels which aroused their delight and devotion, a phase which was brought to an abrupt halt by the promulgation of the neo-classic style by the Academy of San Carlos, founded in 1784. The hundred or more years that stretched from the 1640s until the 1750s were a period of spiritual renewal within the Mexican Church, during which the forms and spirit of post-Tridentine, baroque Catholicism sank deep roots in New Spain. The devotion to Our Lady of Guadalupe was but one expression of the cult of miraculous images, a cult so pervasive that virtually every province came to house sanctuaries raised in honour of local images, often acclaimed as patrons of their cities and communities. If the cycle of church building assumed such an exuberant momentum, it was in large measure because the growth of population in the territories lying immediately north of the central valleys proved so explosive, with wealthy silver miners competing to raise ever more splendid edifices. Moreover, the first decades of the eighteenth century witnessed a renewal of missionary activity so extensive and profound that it constituted a second evangelisation of New Spain. The foundation in 1683 of a Franciscan college de propagandafide,which recruited friars from existing provinces in Spain and Mexico, proved so successful that other institutes were established in Zacatecas, Mexico City and Pachuca. The vast territories of the northern frontier offered a theatre of missionary endeavour on an heroic scale as the Franciscans relived the experience of their sixteenth-century predecessors, converting hundreds of Indians to the Christian faith. But the friars of these colleges also conducted extensive and regular missions among the faithful, touring the parishes of the central dioceses. At times, their
Jesuit expulsion
19
penitential sermons proved so powerful that entire congregations sallied on to the streets, carrying crosses and scourging their flesh in repentance for their sins. Moreover, if the impetus to found these colleges came from the Peninsula, Creole friars soon joined them, and, indeed, came to dominate the aptly named college of Our Lady of Guadalupe at Zacatecas. Nor was their influence limited to spectacular acts of penitence, since the founders of the Oratory at San Miguel el Grande and of the sanctuary at Atotonilco both acknowledged their debt to the Franciscans. Is it any coincidence that in this epoch a number of Creole heiresses chose to devote their wealth and lives to the foundation of new convents? Or that groups of devout women gathered together to form beaterias, nuns without vows, who gained their livelihood teaching children and girls? At all levels of its multifarious existence, the Mexican Church, and in particular the diocese of Michoacan, thus experienced a quickening of its Christian life.
Mendicant chronicles
In his chronicle of the Franciscan province of San Pedro y San Pablo, published in 1643, Alonso de la Rea saluted Michoacan as 'this earthly paradise', whose fertile soils were watered by several rivers, lakes and abundant rains. The sugar, fruits and fish of the districts around the lake of Patzcuaro were matched by the cattle, wheat and maize of the lands lying between Celaya and Queretaro and by the rich silver deposits in the mountain ranges of Guanajuato and Tlalpujahua. The very air was so fresh and temperate that 'the climate is among the best in the kingdom'. A native of Queretaro, animated by 'the natural love of patria', de la Rea celebrated the city and its surrounding gardens and fields as reminiscent of Italy, exclaiming that 'there is not a citizen who is not a stockman and lord of very great haciendas'. The fertility of nature combined with the benevolent influence of the stars to produce 'great qualities and talents . . . as much in the pulpits and college chairs as in the political and moral spheres'.1 The city already possessed priories of Franciscans, Augustinians and Carmelites, as well as a Jesuit college and a hill sanctuary housing a miraculous cross. Had written memorials existed, de la Rea would have sought to 'eternalise the valour of the Tarascans with their politic and military government', especially since their kingdom had never been conquered by their Aztec cousins. As it was, he recorded that their last monarch had freely submitted to Hernan Cortes, accepting baptism from Martin de Valencia, leader of the Franciscan mission to New Spain. He reminded his readers of 'the liveliness of the Tarascan character', noting that they were famous in all parts, since 'they are eminent in all the crafts', as much in sculpture as in painting. Their churches numbered among the best maintained in New Spain, since 'by nature the Tarascan is much given to ritual and is careful of his religious cult'. At the same time, however, de la Rea confessed that the conquest had inaugurated a tragic epoch for the native peoples of Michoacan, in which they suffered both from 20
Mendicant chronicles
21
Spanish depredations and the onslaught of epidemic disease. During the great plague of 1543, five-sixths of the population had died, the survivors finding 'the kingdom desolated and without people, the cities in ruins, their haciendas in alien power and they themselves strangers in their own land'. This epidemic was followed by yet another plague in 1577, 'in which the greater part of the Indians died'. The result was that the whole province now had fewer people than had once lived in a single city; the former Tarascan capital of Tzintzuntzan, which had housed 20,000 inhabitants, now supported but 200 households.2 Although de la Rea praised Vasco de Quiroga, the first bishop of Michoacan, for 'his zeal, sanctity and prudence', he presented the Franciscans as the founding fathers of the missionary church. In particular, he hailed Fray Martin de Jesus as another Moses, who conversed with God on the mountain heights; whose sanctity was ratified by frequent 'ecstasies and raptures'; and whose daily warfare against the Devil was sustained by daily self-scourging and the donning of cilices, bristle circlets which afflicted his mortified flesh. The founder of the Franciscan province of San Pedro y San Pablo, which separated from its Mexican parent in 1565, Martin de Jesus was most distressed by 'the excesses of the Spaniards, who acted like lions unleashed upon flocks of sheep, tearing them apart, destroying and killing'. By far the most indefatigable of the first Franciscan missionaries, however, was Fray Juan de San Miguel who preached the gospel in the mountains and valleys of Michoacan and traversed the plains of the Bajio, seeking at all points to concentrate the Indian population in new communities. As de la Rea commented: 'discovering the Tarascans dwelling in their mountain retreats, still so uncivilised, barbarous and ignorant, such a minister was needed to bring them together and reduce them to a political and sociable life'. At Uruapan Juan de San Miguel built the church and hospital and divided the new settlement into nine barrios (wards), each with their own chapel and patron saint. He taught the Indians the entire range of Spanish arts and crafts, ranging from carpentry and metal work to music and painting. It was Juan de San Miguel, so de la Rea averred, who had established the hospitals dedicated to the Immaculate Conception of the Virgin Mary, of which twenty still survived, a precedent copied by Bishop Vasco de Quiroga in Patzcuaro.3 Nor was he alone in the task of founding communities such as Uruapan and San Miguel el Grande, since even at Tzintzuntzan Fray Pedro de Pilar rebuilt the town, and, 'like a Roman consul gave laws to its community in both the political and popular spheres'. It was the Franciscans who took the lead in learning native languages, publishing vocabularies, grammars and catechisms in Tarascan,
22
The religious orders
Nahuatl, Mazahua and Otomi. Indeed, Maturino Gilberti, a French friar, published scriptural translations, leading de la Rea to salute him as 'the Jerome and Cicero of Tarascan', adding that in Tarascan 'which is a very sweet, elegant and copious language, the great Maturino Gilberti was the universal master'. To consolidate conversion, the Franciscans enlisted their native charges into confraternities, dedicated to the Holy Cross and the Blessed Souls in purgatory, whose members met regularly in Lent to scourge themselves and to conduct weekly processions. On the feast of the Finding of the Holy Cross, the Indians staged mock battles, modelled on the Spanish 'battles between Moors and Christians', in which they divided into bands of Spanish and Chichimeca warriors, the latter holding 'mitotes or pagan dances with the most beautiful feathers', versions of which were celebrated in Queretaro, Patzcuaro, Uruapan, Tzintzuntzan and Celaya.4 Although de la Rea's chief purpose was to commemorate the heroic achievements of the founding fathers of his province, he also fixed upon contemporary examples of sanctity, observing of one friar who passed a secluded life in his priory, that his brethren had seen him 'often caught up in the air, insensible and with a face as beautiful and burning as roses wounded by the sun'. So also, he mentioned a lay brother of the priory at Valladolid, who collected alms, traversing New Spain as far south as the silver mines of Taxco, 'walking barefoot, wearing cilices and carrying a heavy wooden cross on his shoulders'. Equally important, he described the foundation in 1607 of the convent of Santa Clara at Queretaro, established by Diego de Tapia, the son of the Otomi founder of that city and 'the owner of the greatest haciendas' in the district. He endowed the nunnery with estates which yielded an annual income of 13,500 ps., a sum sufficient to enable his daughter Luisa to become abbess, presumably the only Indian nun in an institution which required each postulant to present a dowry of 2,000 ps. By 1633 when the construction was completed, Santa Clara had over sixty professed nuns.5 In effect, de la Rea's chronicle registered both the tragic course of the 'spiritual conquest' of the Indian peoples of Michoacan and the emergence of an Hispanic Church based on the cities and haciendas of the region. His nascent Creole patriotism found expression in the celebration of Tarascan attainments, Franciscan sanctity and the positive achievements of Hispanic society in Michoacan. II The first chronicle of the Augustinian friars in Michoacan, published in 1624 by Juan Gonzalez de la Puente, entirely lacked the patriotic
Mendicant chronicles
23
quality of its Franciscan counterpart and had comparatively little to say either about the Indians or the region. After a prologue dealing with the conquest, it concentrated entirely on recounting the lives and works of nine holy friars. Virtually all the emphasis here was on bodily mortification as the means to achieve sanctity. Although de la Puente admitted that pride was 'the root of all vices5 and that ascetic practices were the outward expressions of'the interior sacrifice' of the will, nevertheless, he defined scourges and cilices as the essential arms of the daily battle against the temptation of the Devil, the world and the flesh. On stressing the need to conquer oneself, he added: 'man is married to himself, where the flesh is Eve and the reason Adam'. On recounting his experience of walking for three days with Fray Pedro de Vera, he affirmed that this venerable friar barely spoke during their time together so absorbed was he in prayer, and that he hardly ate and slept on the ground, rising at midnight to scourge himself. So also, in describing the life of Juan de Medina Rincon, who became the third bishop of Michoacan, he made no mention of his acts of government but chose to emphasise his unchanging asceticism and the scale of his almsgiving to the poor of the diocese. It was a triumph that although a bishop, he preserved the virtues of a friar. He narrated a revealing incident of a resentful prebendary of the cathedral, whom Medina Rincon had reprimanded for his expensive garb, spying on the bishop in his country retreat in the hopes of encountering amorous scandal, only to be specked with blood from the prelate's midnight scourging of his back.6 As befitted a peninsular Spaniard, de la Puente celebrated the conquest of Mexico as an act of divine providence, freely comparing Columbus to Moses and Cortes to Gideon, the latter's decision to march inland with only 300 men characterised as 'a deed worthy of eternal memory and of a more than human spirit and heart, where in my opinion grace had more share than nature'. Announced by prodigies and sealed by the apparitions of the Virgin Mary and Santiago in desperate moments of battle, 'this conquest was miraculous and as such was prophesied beforehand in certain places of Scripture'. After all, 'Satan, the great master of dances' had bathed the land in blood, creating in Mexico 'this great chaos of abominations'. It was for this reason that de la Puente fixed upon chapter 18 of the prophet Isaiah, where God sends his ambassadors to a nation once terrible in cruelty and idolatry but now downtrodden and devastated. In line with this spiritual interpretation of events, de la Puente defined the three mendicant orders, the Franciscans, Dominicans and Augustinians as 'the conquerors of these new lands', men who entered their kingdom as lambs.7 It was perhaps inevitable that he should have celebrated his own order as the first of all religious orders
24
The religious orders
recognised by the Catholic Church, founded by St Augustine in the fourth century and established in Spain well before the arrival of the Muslims. By far the most attractive part of de la Puente's chronicle was his life of Fray Juan Bautista de Moya, who arrived in Mexico in 1536 and dedicated himself to the conversion of the Indians of Michoacan. Subsisting on a diet of maize tamales and vegetables, Fray Juan Bautista walked barefoot, exposing himself to both the sun and mosquitoes, and cut short his hours of sleep in order both to pray and to draw blood through self-scourging. But these practices were but the means by which he strengthened himself for his mission to the Indians, journeying across the mountains and tropical valleys in his search for native converts. Drawing on materials assembled by a contemporary friar, de la Puente also recounted a number of extraordinary incidents, as when Fray Juan Bautista slipped from a high mountain path only later to be seen climbing up the other side, his body having been sustained by the air. So too, he was once seen to cross a stream by stepping on the back of a complaisant cayman, the Mexican equivalent of a crocodile. Finally, some Spaniards once witnessed him so wrapt in prayer that his feet were clearly elevated above the ground. Although de la Puente recounted these apparent miracles with caution, their implications were unmistakable. Nor were such virtues unknown in his own days, since the ascetic Pedro de Vera, who once walked from Michoacan to San Luis Potosi in order to preach the Lenten sermons to the Indians working in the silver mines, did not die until 1621. But change was registered in the life of Diego de Chavez, who spent most of his life as a friar in Yuriria, where he was responsible for the construction of its magnificent church and priory, an edifice which de la Puente dubbed 'another Escorial in the Indies'.8 For Chavez was said never to have ventured forth from the priory, living as a monk in a desert. The deficiencies of de la Puente's chronicle were so obvious, especially when compared to its Franciscan counterpart, that in 1671 the current provincial secured licence for the publication of the Historia de la provincia de San Nicolas de Tolentino de Michoacan composed thirty years earlier by Diego Basalenque (1577-1651). A peninsular Spaniard brought to Mexico when he was nine, Basalenque had entered the Augustinians in 1593 and had served as provincial during 1623-6, before retiring to the small priory at Charo, where he wrote a chronicle which provided a remarkable range of information both about his order and Michoacan. As was the case with all monastic histories, his aim was to edify, presenting the lives of his province's holy founders as models for young friars. For information he drew on de la Puente and on the history of the
Mendicant chronicles
25
Augustinian Order in New Spain published in 1624 by Juan de Grijalva. But he himself had conversed with elderly survivors of the first missions and as provincial had reflected on the progress of his Order in Michoacan. Writing his chronicle in retirement, he declared that whereas grammar was necessary for children and metaphysics the appropriate study for men in their maturity, history was an old man's solace.9 As much as the Franciscans, the first Augustinians to enter Michoacan had walked from Mexico, barefoot and carrying crosses. They established their first priory at Tiripitio, where the local encomenderos, the Alvarado brothers, had set aside land for that purpose. The friars taught the Indians carpentry, weaving and masonry and opened a school for musicians and choristers, so that Tiripitio emerged as 'the school of all crafts for the other villages in Michoacan'. As in Uruapan, the town was laid out in squares and streets, with water brought by aqueduct and then distributed in tiled piping to fountains in the hospital, priory and square. From the start, the Augustinians celebrated mass with great pomp and circumstance since 'they knew how much the Indians were taken with external ceremonies'. They organised great dances at Easter, adapted confession to the 'little reason' of the natives and, after a Lenten examination of doctrine, admitted them to annual communion. As he wrote his chronicle, Basalenque observed that at Charo the Indians still attended daily prayers, followed by instruction for the children, and maintained a splendid choir and orchestra. Most households possessed crosses and images of saints and each Friday the villagers participated in a procession headed by the image of Our Lady of the Immaculate Conception which was the hospital patron. It was Vasco de Quiroga, so Basalenque admitted, who had been responsible for the establishment of such hospitals throughout the Indian communities of Michoacan.10 In framing this description of the Augustinian contribution to the 'spiritual conquest', he drew freely on de la Puente's life of Fray Juan Bautista, portraying him as a virtual saint, whose asceticism and miraculous escapes from danger were matched only by his indefatigable preaching of the gospel to the Indians. In contrast to de la Rea's idyllic celebration of his patria and Order, Basalenque displayed no compunction in tracing the conflicts which haunted the Augustinians. Following Juan de Grijalva's chronicle, he described the career of Alonso de la Veracruz, the great theologian of the previous century, who had served as provincial on four separate occasions, and who had strongly resisted the demands of the bishops that Indians should pay tithes on their agricultural production. More important, in 1567 Veracruz had obtained from Pope Pius V exemption from the provisions of the Council of Trent which had stipulated that the
26
The religious orders
religious orders required episcopal licence to administer marriages and to found new priories or colleges. But the Spanish crown then responded in 1574 by commanding that the friars should inform the viceroy of all nominations of priests to administer parishes. In effect, the bishops sought to bring an end to the missionary church, demanding that doctrinas should be converted into regular parishes, each with a canonically appointed priest, subject to episcopal visitation. The friars vigorously resisted these attempts, arguing that the religious were less costly to maintain than the secular clergy, and that bishops had no right to rob them of their churches and priories. In response, the prelates obtained royal rescripts in 1583 and 1603 recognising their right to conduct visitations and to examine the incumbents' knowledge of native languages. These pretensions were strongly resisted by a common front of Franciscans, Dominicans and Augustinians who in 1622 obtained a postponement of the rescripts.11 The question remained a source of conflict and soon after his appointment as bishop of Puebla in 1640, Juan de Palafox y Mendoza ousted the friars from their doctrinas in his diocese, replacing them with secular clergy. But no other prelate followed his example and in Michoacan the friars remained in possession of their extensive parishes well into the eighteenth century. The most striking features of the Augustinians in Michoacan, however, were the splendour of their churches and the wealth of their haciendas. At Yuriria Fray Diego de Chavez, who was the nephew of the Alvarados, succeeded in mobilising the Indian manpower of that doctrina so as to build a majestic church and priory in no more than nine years, an edifice that Basalenque hailed as 'the first marvel of all the buildings of New Spain'. When a viceroy criticised the magnificence of this church which possessed a richly decorated Plateresque facade that soared far above the surrounding village, Chavez justified its grandeur by citing the example of Solomon's Temple, the biblical prototype of all Catholic churches. It is noticeable that if the first Augustinian priories were established in Indian communities such as Tiripitio, Charo, Cuitzeo and Yuriria, to mention but a few, the second wave of foundations were located in Spanish towns such as Zacatecas, San Luis Potosi and Salamanca, where wealthy silver miners and landowners donated monies and lands to provide for their endowment. The result was that most of the leading priories came to derive a handsome income from haciendas they had purchased or received as donations. The jewel in the crown, reserved for the province, was the hacienda of San Nicolas, situated in the jurisdiction of Yuriria and Salvatierra, where successive managers had contrived to open a canal several miles long, connecting the estate to the river Lerma, thereby enabling it to grow wheat on
Mendicant chronicles
27
irrigated land. By the 1640s the San Nicolas hacienda maintained 400 plough oxen, 150 mules for freight and employed 400 Indian peons, its production of wheat rising to 50,000 fanegas a year, a harvest sufficient to yield an annual income of 6,000 ps.12 The information on the operation and value of this estate provided by Basalenque contrasted vividly with his alternate emphasis on the asceticism and apostolic ministry of the first Augustinians in Michoacan. Despite his avowed desire to edify, Basalenque concluded his chronicle by citing the internal divisions of the Macabees and evoked Jeremiah's lamentation over the destruction of the temple at Jerusalem. In 1602 the Augustinians in New Spain had divided into two provinces, with the province of San Nicolas Tolentino de Michoacan administering doctrinas and priories in a vast area which comprised Zacatecas, Guadalajara and Queretaro as well as the diocese from which it took its name. Although numbers soon leapt from 120 to about 250 priests and brothers, discord arose as the great influx of Creoles was matched by the arrival of peninsular Spaniards destined for missions in the Philippines and China who chose to remain in New Spain. So bitter did the conflict between Creoles and gachupines become that the 1614 elections for provincial and priors had to be held in Mexico City in the presence of the viceroy and two judges of the high court. It was in that year that the alternativa was introduced, whereby Creole and peninsular Spaniards occupied the leading positions within the province in alternating threeyear periods. In part, so Basalenque averred, the quarrel was between 'the old observants' and 'careless youngsters'. Whatever the case, although his term as provincial in 1623-6 was marked by installing the chief novitiate at the Valladolid priory and the construction of its new church, it did not see any lessening of partisan divisions. The result was that in 1629 the current viceroy reversed the election of a Creole provincial, imposed a peninsular Spaniard in his place and thereafter forbade all further intake of Creole novices until the balance of numbers between the two parties had been rectified. It was not until 1646 that this ban was lifted.13 In effect, the Creole patriotism to which de la Rea had given such heartfelt expression led to the formation of hostile parties within all the provinces of mendicant friars in New Spain. Tensions in the cloister were lessened but never eradicated by the introduction of the alternativay especially since the decline in the number of missionaries arriving from Spain meant that the small faction of expatriate friars enjoyed an unfair access to high office. If Basalenque concluded his narrative on a despondent note, like Jeremiah lamenting the destruction of Jerusalem, by contrast his successor as chronicler, Matias de Escobar (1690-1748) boldly justified
28
The religious orders
his historical task by evoking the famous vision of the prophet Ezekiel raising Israel from the dead in the valley of bones. So too, he saw himself as another St Jerome writing the lives of the desert fathers and, more audaciously, compared himself to St John the Evangelist, since he was the fourth chronicler to recount the great deeds of the Augustinians in Michoacan. A celebrated preacher much in demand in cathedrals across the land, Escobar prided himself on his friendship with the current bishop of Michoacan, Juan Jose de Escalona y Calatayud (1729-37), during whose episcopate he retired to the small priory at Charo, situated close to Valladolid, there to compose Americana Thebaida (1729-40?). In effect, he spent the best years of his life dwelling in a cell next to that once inhabited by Basalenque, sustained by a library where the stands were full of manuscripts written by friars of his province. 14 But his gifts were more literary than historical and all his considerable talent was devoted to burnishing his prose, multiplying his metaphors, personifications and similitudes to the point where his chronicle became the literary equivalent of an ultra-baroque altarpiece. It was precisely during the decades when he wrote that churches in New Spain witnessed a striking transformation in a style as Churrigueresque exuberance dissolved the architectonic forms of the baroque, subordinating sculptural detail and the traditional orders to the concept of the retablo and facade as a unified composition entirely dominated by soaring vertical movement. So also, Escobar piled classical epithet on classical epithet, at times sacrificing meaning to rhetorical effect, the imperatives of eulogy overwhelming his critical intelligence. Once the conventions of his prose are understood, however, there is a great deal to be learnt from Escobar's narrative, since its very extravagance allows us to approach the religious sensibility of this epoch. A Canary Islander who as a boy had been brought by his parents to Celaya, Escobar enthusiastically adopted de la Rea's description of Michoacan as an earthly paradise, asserting that no other part of Mexico enjoyed such abundant rains or possessed such fertile soil. Not content with such a general statement, he offered a detailed enumeration of the chief rivers and lakes of the province, claiming that he himself like another Columbus had navigated all these waterways. So too, he provided a sympathetic picture of the ancient Tarascans, tracing their peregrination from the northern caves of Aztlan to Michoacan, where under the influence of their principal god, whom he identified as Satan, they established a monarchy, which succeeded in defending its independence from the Mexican emperors. Saluting Calzontli, the last king, as another Constantine for his peaceful submission to Cortes and subsequent baptism, he lamented that the Tarascan history written
Mendicant chronicles
29
by Don Antonio, Calzontli's son, had not been preserved, since otherwise that pious prince would have been as famous as the Peruvian chronicler, the Inca Garcilaso de la Vega.15 Like his predecessors, Escobar also praised the Tarascan skill in all the crafts taught them by the Spaniards. On turning to the achievements of the Augustinians, Escobar fondly recalled that they had entered Michoacan barefoot and carrying crosses, a spectacle which caused him to exclaim: 'We were born in the deserts and we have returned to them', proceeding then to compare their modest straw huts to the stable at Bethlehem, a fitting symbol of their vows of poverty. Once more, the miraculous incidents in the life of Fray Juan Bautista were rehearsed with loving care, the grounds laid for possible canonisation, the province endowed with a saintly patriarch. But when he came to narrate the means by which the Indians were taught Christian doctrine and practice during the spiritual conquest, Escobar followed Basalenque in testifying that at Charo the religious practices introduced during the sixteenth century could still be observed without noticeable change. Each day the children were assembled for instruction in the catechism and daily prayers were offered in the village's nine chapels. So too, every Friday there was a procession from the hospital, a practice which had been strengthened throughout Michoacan by the construction of Calvaries and Stations of the Cross outside the villages. In Charo the musicians and choir were still thriving, and indeed from time to time the choir sang in the cathedral at Valladolid. It remained the custom for many communities to stage mock battles between Spaniards and Chichimecas or Moors and Christians. Although Escobar admitted that drunkenness was as much a vice among Indians as among the Germans or English, he entertained no doubts as to their Christian devotion, noting that many abstained from all alcohol during Lent, a time when they invariably confessed their sins and received holy communion.16 Although Escobar exhibited an attractive sympathy for the natural scenery and native inhabitants of Michoacan, at all points he sought to dignify his narrative by extravagant, often inappropriate comparisons with European places and personages. Not content with describing the sublime virtues and miracles of Fray Juan Bautista, he also expatiated on his natural gifts, declaring that in history he rivalled Thucydides and Livy, in eloquence Demosthenes and Cicero, in poetry Homer and Virgil and in philosophy Plato and Aristotle. When 'the celebrated Antonio Rodriguez' was merely saluted as 'the American Titian', the simplicity of the trope comes as a surprise. The great church at Yuriria, which even de la Puente had seen as another Escorial, was now
30
The religious orders
compared to the temple of Diana at Ephesus, its grandeur prompting the reflection that in America a poor friar had built what in Europe only kings could undertake. Reflecting on the impressive ruins of an encomendero's mansion situated amidst the mountain peaks of Guango, Escobar exclaimed that had the first settlers possessed true curiosity about the country they had conquered then 'Guango might have been the Versailles of this America or the Florence of this New World'. As for the quiet, unassuming valley of Jacona, he acclaimed it as 'the Cyprus of this America, the Elysian Fields of this New World and the splendid paradise of these West Indies'. As in Churrigueresque architecture, which Escobar praised as 'the new style in retablos\ the deliquescence of classical vocabulary sacrificed meaning to rhetorical effect: but whereas in a retablo the sculptural detail was constrained and ordered by the soaring movement of the frame, by contrast in narrative prose the sheer hyperbole of such epithets eventually robbed the descriptions of any quality other than a bizarre, tedious charm. 17 Prior for some years of the Augustinian house in Valladolid, Escobar provided a valuable account of the city and its bishops, inserting a miniature diocesan history in his chronicle. It was perhaps inevitable that he should have dubbed Vasco de Quiroga as another St Ambrose; but he also paid tribute to his virtues and insisted on his close friendship with Fray Alonso de la Veracruz, the great Augustinian defender of the Indians in Mexico. It was the third bishop, Juan de Medina Rincon, another Augustinian, who in 1580 had transferred the cathedral and college from Patzcuaro to Valladolid, which was to say, from a primarily Indian town to a city founded by Spanish encomenderos. By the time this move occurred, Valladolid already had Franciscan and Augustinian priories, each with their parishes, houses which were soon to be joined by a Jesuit college and Carmelite and Mercedarian priories. It was not until 1660, however, that work began on the new cathedral, its construction sufficiently advanced by 1705 for it to be consecrated by the current bishop. 18 In his Voces de triton sonora (1746), Escobar wrote an account of the life, works and last illness of his dear friend, Bishop Juan Jose de Escalona, who had died in 1737. What occasioned his eulogy was the discovery made by workmen repaving the cathedral that Escalona's blood and intestines, which had been buried in the sacristy, were still liquid, despite the passage of seven years. Moreover, his embalmed corpse (bereft of the heart which had been donated to the Santa Caterina nunnery) had remained uncorrupted and emitted a sweet aroma. All this was taken as a portent and sign of sanctity. What rendered the case yet more significant was that the bishop's death had been announced by
Mendicant chronicles
31
the appearance of a comet, a phenomenon notoriously caused by the exhalations of the seas and the corrupt humours of the body, and which astronomers generally interpreted as 'the knives which threaten the heads of princes'. The immediate cause of Escalona's death was dysentery, an illness so common during the rainy season in New Spain that there was a punning proverb on its occurrence: porMayo me desmayo, which was to say, 'in May I faint'. In an extraordinary conclusion, Escobar averred: 'without doubt the venerable prince's intestines were a circus for these two evils, the comet and the dysentery, where they struggled to conquer him'. Of more interest to the church historian was the list of Escalona's good works, which included the construction of the episcopal palace, the building of a sanctuary on the outskirts of the city in honour of Our Lady of Guadalupe connected by a bridge and highway and the donation of 'many thousands of pesos to complete the convent of the nuns of Santa Caterina of this city'.19 That the bishop had spent many days at Charo and had bequeathed his library to the Augustinian priory at Valladolid only strengthened Escobar's veneration for his departed friend. In the closing chapter of Americana Thebaida which dealt with the vale of Jacona, Escobar provided a list of no less than ten crucifixes venerated in churches and chapels of the region, most of which had been found carved within the trunk or roots of local trees, of which the most famous was the celebrated Christ of La Piedad. So also, he told how an Indian fisherman found a large tree root floating in the waters of Lake Chapala. Just as he was about to cast the log into his fire at home, a friend named Juan, an Indian from Jacona, requested the wood from him, having discerned in its tortured lines a likeness of the Virgin Mary and the child Jesus. Taken to his home in 1685 the image soon attracted local veneration and in 1711 a chapel was built in Jacona and a thriving confraternity formed in honour of this miraculous icon. In describing these extraordinary events, Escobar was quick to compare the appearance of this image with the celebrated painting of Our Lady of Guadalupe at Tepeyac, noting that in both cases the images had been discovered by Indians named Juan in years when the respective bishops of Mexico and Michoacan were equally called Juan. The most significant feature of all the crucifixes and images mentioned by Escobar is that their discovery was not accompanied by any miraculous apparitions: instead they were all 'discovered' imbedded within trees or roots, perceived only by the discerning eye of the faithful.20 Here, then, was the final fruit of the spiritual conquest of Michoacan: in a region that was once a wilderness, inhabited by nomad idolaters, Nature itself now gave birth to images of Christ and the Mother of God.
32
The religious orders III
In his Chronica apostolicay serdphica de todos los colegios de propaganda fide de la Nueva Espana de los missioneros franciscanos observantes (1746) Isidro
Felix de Espinosa (1679-1755) recounted the story of the dramatic revival in Franciscan missionary fervour which was destined to exercise such a powerful influence over the religious life of the Mexican people in the eighteenth century. This spiritual renewal did not derive from the existing provinces of observant friars but rather was expressed in the foundation of'apostolic colleges' at Queretaro (1683), Zacatecas (1707) and Mexico City (1731). A native of Queretaro, Espinosa had joined the local college of Santa Cruz while little more than a boy and thereafter in 1716 and 1721 helped to lead missions to Texas before returning to serve first as guardian of Santa Cruz and then as president of the hospice of San Fernando in Mexico City. Stricken by poor health he spent his last years chronicling the stirring events he had witnessed and was later acclaimed as another Julius Caesar, who fought his spiritual battles during the day and who wrote at night. Shortly before his death he was commissioned to write a history of the Franciscan province of Michoacan, a labour he performed with heartfelt groans. But his life of Fray Antonio Margil de Jesus and his chronicle of the colleges are indispensable for the history of the Mexican Church during this period, since although his manifest purpose was to edify and inspire by offering examples of heroic zeal, his plain unvarnished style tells more about the religious attitudes of this period than all the aureate elucubrations of Escobar.21 Despite his parentage, however, no hint of Creole patriotism enters his narrative: his social identity appears to have been entirely subsumed by his Franciscan vocation. According to Espinosa, the spiritual renewal within the observant provinces of his Order began in the seventeenth century when both in Spain and Mexico certain priories were set aside for friars who wished to withdraw from the world, pursuing a more austere, contemplative form of life. It was Fray Antonio Linaz, a native of Mallorca, familiar since his time at university with the doctrines of his compatriot Ramon Lull, who succeeded in persuading his brethren in these conventos recolectos that they should devote at least half their year, or ten years of their life, to preach the gospel, both to the faithful and the unconverted.22 He himself had spent thirteen years attached to the Michoacan province of San Pedro y San Pablo, acting as both prior and lecturer, before suffering a spiritual crisis that drove him to renounce all positions of authority so as to sally forth on preaching tours of New Spain. On his return to Spain in 1679 he found support for his ideas and obtained the requisite licences
Mendicant chronicles
33
both from the Papacy and the crown to establish a missionary college at Queretaro, taking over the existing recolecto priory of Santa Cruz. In 1683 he arrived at Veracruz, accompanied by twenty friars recruited from several provinces of Spain, among whom was the celebrated Fray Antonio Margil de Jesus. Once established, Linaz moved swiftly to conduct missions in Mexico City, Puebla and Valladolid, with the result that a number of Franciscans, both Creoles and peninsulars, abandoned their provinces and enlisted in the college, so that as early as 1707 it was possible to found a new institute at Zacatecas named after Our Lady of Guadalupe.23 In effect, the priests resident in these colleges formed a spiritual elite. They did not intervene in the administration of Indian parishes in central Mexico and sought to avoid the miscellaneous activities of the urban priories, thereby escaping the task of educating novices. For friars from the Peninsula the attraction of such colleges was that they avoided the necessity of administration and the partisan tensions which characterised the observant provinces, enabling them to pursue their missionary vocation without incurring Creole enmity. In Elperegrino septentrional atlante (1737) Fray Antonio Margil de Jesus (1657-1726) was portrayed as a virtual saint who from his novitiate in Valencia until his death in Mexico City practised a rigorous asceticism, walking barefoot and preaching the gospel across the length and breadth of New Spain. Although Espinosa freely admitted that interior mortification, the disciplining of the will and emotions, was superior to any physical penitence, nevertheless, he contrasted this 'passive' mortification to 'the active' which was Very important until the beast yields to reason'. Fearful of temptation, Margil never looked at anyone directly in the face and on leaving Spain shrank from allowing his mother to kiss his hand since 'although she was his mother, she was a woman, recognising it as unworthy of his priestly character, but because of his humility he had to condescend, giving her this small comfort'. like most friars intent on storming heaven, Margil scourged himself each day and wore cilices three days a week, and when in residence sallied forth each evening carrying a heavy cross.24 In effect, Margil conceived of the imitation of Christ as a virtual re-enactment of the Passion, leading Espinosa to comment: 'in his own body he portrayed the image of Jesus Christ with voluntary pains, mortifications, hunger, thirst, fatigue and journeying, always living to kill his passions'. As Margil himself wrote about Jesus: 'since he was born until he died all was cross and more cross, contradiction and more contradiction, so as to teach us that this is the best habit of friends'. This extreme penitence was accompanied by intense absorption in prayer. Indeed, on one occasion a chance visitor to his cell, so Espinosa piously recounts, observed him raised from the ground, 'the
34
The religious orders
body spinning with such violence that it formed a single obscure line from the head to the sandals and nothing could be distinguished owing to the circular movement'. That the chronicler could relate such an incident about a man with whom he had collaborated for several years testified to the craving for physical miracles which characterised the baroque religiosity of this epoch. 25 What distinguished Margil from many self-denying ascetics was his intense commitment to preaching the Christian gospel both to the unconverted Indians inhabiting the confines of empire and to the Catholic faithful of New Spain. In company with Fray Melchor Lopez de Jesus, he toured Guatemala and Yucatan, and subsequently led two successive missions to Texas where, in conjunction with Espinosa, he was responsible for establishing permanent mission stations in that vast province. The founder and guardian of the college of Our Lady of Guadalupe at Zacatecas, he called upon the inhabitants of that city to repent of their sins and succeeded in preventing a company of comedians from performing in the local theatre, which he denounced as a source of temptation. During one sermon, he quit his habit while in the pulpit and lashed his shoulders with a heavy iron chain, drawing blood and eliciting compassionate repentant groans from the congregation. So effective were his sermons in Guadalajara and Valladolid that canons of the cathedral placed themselves at the head of penitential processions, carrying crosses through the streets. So great was his fame that when in 1726 Margil died in Mexico City, his funeral was attended by the viceroy, the city council and cathedral chapter, and by all the religious communities of the capital. 26 If Margil was loved for his sweetness, by contrast Melchor Lopez de Jesus terrified people by the severity of his penances. The two friars had been scandalised when, on reaching the district of Verapaz in Guatemala, they had found the Indians still worshipping idols. Determined to break the power of the Devil, they threatened the village governors and magistrates with imprisonment and the lash if they did not bring in images for burning and assist in the campaign to extirpate idolatry. To demonstrate their repentance the Indians were obliged to walk in public procession carrying heavy crosses and 'armed with cilices'. Wherever Margil and Lopez preached they erected Calvaries and Stations of the Cross outside villages as a permanent incitement to the faithful to deepen their devotion to Christ's Passion. As for Lopez de Jesus himself, Espinosa hailed him as 'a mystical, animated cross . . . a living portrait of Christ crucified . . . Every Friday he sallied out to the fields, barefoot, with a heavy cross on his shoulders, a cord at his neck, and a crown of thorns pressed so tight that at times drops of blood drawn from the thorns could
Mendicant chronicles
35
be seen on his venerable face.' But despite his apostolic labours and his penitence, Lopez was haunted by fears of eternal damnation, since 'all his life he suffered the cross of scruples and found it necessary to confess himself three or four times a day'. Even on his deathbed a companion was stationed at his side to warn him against the possibility of one last temptation from the Devil.27 In his account of the Franciscan missions to Texas, Espinosa painted an attractive portrait of the inhabitants of that province, describing them as handsome in appearance and of good dispositions and understanding, apt for salvation and tractable. 'The Asinasis Indians are naturally lively, perceptive, friendly, proud and high spirited. They have attractive features and are well built, light and robust, ready for warlike expeditions and of good heart.' Since they were unsubdued, it was necessary for the friars to be protected by small garrisons of soldiers, their presence required not to enforce conversion but to safeguard the missionaries' lives. The object of the Franciscans was to concentrate the Indians into villages where they could be taught Spanish crafts as well as Christian doctrine and be assisted in cultivation with plough oxen and other iron implements. Daily prayers were enforced and absentees punished by a whipping. As was to be expected, many Indians sought to escape from these settlements but before succeeding often fell prey to the periodic epidemics which swept through the compounds. To read Espinosa's account of these missions is to return to the first years of the spiritual conquest in New Spain, since we encounter much the same story of zealous friars gathering simple natives into villages, teaching them both the gospel and crafts, only then to witness their destruction by successive plagues. Doubtful whether adult Indians could be truly rescued from the Devil's grasp, Espinosa commented: 'the Fathers remained entirely happy and satisfied with the multitude of young children who died, since after being washed with the sacred water of baptism, their happy souls flew to the sacred mansions of Heaven'.28 At the close of his life, when he was aged seventy, Espinosa was instructed by his superiors to write a history of the Franciscan province of San Pedro y San Pablo of Michoacan, a task he found decidedly wearisome. The problem was simple. Nothing worth recounting had happened in the province since the heroic days of the spiritual conquest and on that subject all he could find was de la Rea's chronicle, supplemented by strands of information in such general histories as Juan de Torquemada's Monarquia Indiana (1615). Nor did he display any interest in celebrating the virtues and glories of Michoacan and its peoples. Indeed, his experience in dealing with the natives of Texas appears to have influenced his view of the Tarascans, since he invariably
36
The religious orders
referred to them as 'barbarians' and praised the first Franciscans for their zeal in congregating the Indians into towns, thereby teaching them how to live as men. On noting how difficult it was to enforce monogamy among the natives, he added that the problem was 'to contain the current of blind appetite within the limits of a single fountain, for those who were accustomed to bathe in so many filthy rivers'. But he praised the Otomi founder of the Santa Clara convent in Queretaro, Diego de Tapia, who had attained 'the nobility most esteemed in all times, that which each one acquired with heroic deeds, from which is shaped his shield of arms'. Whereas de la Rea had expressed fears that the native population was about to disappear from the face of the earth, Espinosa commented on the sufficiency of Indians to support the churches, testimony that the demographic recuperation of the native population was already noticeable. For the rest, he noted that in 1626 the provincial chapter had strictly warned against partisan discord between 'gachupines and Creoles' and had resolved that of the 120 priests in the province 50 should be recruited directly from the Peninsula and that the remaining 70 should consist of equal numbers of peninsulars and Creoles professing in Michoacan. He failed to observe that such an arrangement was designed to enforce a European predominance and that it was doomed to failure.29 Contemporary records reveal that if in 1640 there were 59 Creole priests as against 37 gachupines, by 1693 the proportion had swung still further in favour of Mexican-born priests, with 129 Creoles as against 28 gachupines. 30 If Espinosa carefully avoided mentioning any possible discord between European and American Spaniards, it was in part because the founders of the colleges of de propaganda fide had quietly resolved the question by institutional segregation. Whereas Santa Cruz and San Fernando continued to import friars from the Peninsula throughout the eighteenth century, by contrast Our Lady of Guadalupe soon became the exclusive preserve of Creoles. Just when this segregation occurred and how complete it became it not yet clear. But in 1749 the college at Zacatecas was secretly accused of neglect of its duties precisely because it had not requested the crown to despatch a mission of friars from Spain. In response, the guardian assembled an impressive number of witnesses, from canons of the cathedral in Guadalajara to parish priests and northern governors, who all testified to the heroic zeal of its priests. In fact, the college maintained five mission stations in Texas, centring on San Antonio, and had been far more successful in converting the Indians than their colleagues from the Santa Cruz of Queretaro. Recently, they had accepted from the viceroy an assignment of new missions in the newly colonised region of Nuevo Santander in the modern state of
Mendicant chronicles
37
Tamaulipas. In addition, friars resident in Zacatecas regularly journeyed across the provinces of northern Mexico, from coast to coast, from Guadalajara to Monterrey, preaching to the faithful in streets and churches, hearing innumerable confessions and visiting remote rancherias and haciendas. A striking feature of the guardian's defence was a list of active members of his community, which comprised forty-nine priests and nine lay brothers, of whom eight priests were resident in Texas, fifteen in Nuevo Santander along the Mexican Gulf and twenty-six in Zacatecas. Within this community there were but two peninsulars of whom one, a former guardian, was aged seventy-eight. Moreover, the guardian affirmed that there were an abundance of qualified candidates waiting to join the college which only admitted one or two applicants every year. There was thus absolutely no need to request the crown to send friars from Spain, especially since transport cost the king great sums of money best spent directly on the established missions.31 In effect, the college of Our Lady of Guadalupe at Zacatecas was an institution managed entirely by Mexican-born Spaniards, mainly recruited from the vast region stretching from the Bajio northwards, which had maintained its apostolic zeal and which devoted as much, if not more, of its pastoral energy to missions among the faithful than to the conversion of Indians in Texas and the Gulf. The old gachupin canard that Creole hegemony in the religious orders entailed spiritual decline was here decisively refuted. The publication of Espinosa's chronicle of the apostolic colleges proclaimed to the world that New Spain was in the midst of a grand spiritual revival. Saintly Franciscans preached the gospel to native idolaters on the northern frontiers and created new Christian communities. Equally important, their missions to the faithful elicited mass demonstrations of penitence and were destined to exercise a determining influence upon the forms of popular religion in Mexico. The ultrabaroque rhetoric which found expression in Escobar's Americana Thebaida was surpassed by Espinosa's unvarnished prose since, whereas the Augustinian recounted past glories, the Franciscan narrated the heroic achievements of his contemporaries. Moreover, the Creole exaltation of Our Lady of Guadalupe, which reached an early apogee in 1747 when all the dioceses of New Spain recognised the image of Tepeyac as their common patron, was balanced by the austere Christological bias of the mendicant missioners who presented the Passion as the chief object of Catholic devotion. Obviously, the Franciscans honoured the Mother of God as much as other clerics and indeed Margil passed long hours reading the life of the Virgin Mary written by Sor Maria de Agreda, the famous Spanish visionary of the seventeenth century.32 Their churches housed famous Marian images. But it is surely significant that Espinosa
38
The religious orders
should have opened his chronicle with an account of the stone cross, his college's patron, which had been carved, so he averred, in 1531, the very year in which the Mother of God appeared to Juan Diego at Tepeyac, an image which soon became famous for its miraculous cures and for its prolonged trembling movement during moments of crisis for New Spain. 33 In the last resort, however, the most striking feature of Espinosa's chronicle was its calm assurance of continuity between the heroic epoch of the spiritual conquest and the outpouring of missionary zeal in his own day. What need was there for patriotic enthusiasm when the Christian experience was so dramatic? IV In 1766 there appeared Fragmentos de la viday virtudes del. . . Vasco de
Quiroga, written by Juan Jose Moreno, rector of the college of San Nicolas in Valladolid, who saluted the bishop as 'the apostle of the kingdom' of Michoacan. Lamenting that 'only the barbarism and negligence of that first century of the conquest of this kingdom have passed over such brilliant achievements and virtues in such profound silence', Moreno delved into the records of his own college, which Quiroga had founded, and had been encouraged by the cathedral chapter to consult the documents in their archive. Hitherto, all historical accounts of the Michoacan diocese had been composed by mendicant chroniclers concerned to exalt the sanctity and zeal of the first friars. But now a secular priest chose to magnify the role of Quiroga as founding father of the church in Michoacan and as the legislator who framed the community laws which were to govern the Indian villages of the diocese for centuries to come. That Moreno should have seen fit to compare the bishop both to Lycurgus of Sparta and Peter the Great attested to the new horizons of the Creole clergy of the Bourbon epoch. That he also praised the current bishop, Anselmo Sanchez de Tagle, for his 'defence of ecclesiastical jurisdiction' and signalled the great learning, nobility and virtue of the dignitaries and canons of the cathedral chapter, suggests that his book should be viewed as an historical manifesto designed to advance the prerogatives of the bishop and chapter.34 To start with, Moreno stressed that Quiroga was renowned for his love of the Indians at a time 'when the generality of our nation despised them and wanted to enslave them'. He had founded the two 'hospital' communities of Santa Fe, installing secular priests as their rectors, whose ordinances Moreno printed as an appendix, albeit failing to appreciate that they were modelled on More's Utopia.35 Equally important, he demonstrated that it was Quiroga and not the Franciscans who had
Mendicant chronicles
39
established hospitals in the leading Indian villages, institutions which 'are the centre of the religion, the policy and humanity of the Indians'. There still survived over twenty such hospitals, all governed by the same ordinances and all dedicated to the Virgin Mary's Immaculate Conception. So also, it had been Quiroga who had introduced Spanish crafts in the villages, encouraging communities to concentrate on a particular material, be it lacquer, copper or pottery. Finally, the bishop had also taught the Indians to represent the mysteries of the Christian faith in images, dances and plays, practices which despite criticism of their 'materiality' still continued.36 Although Moreno denied that Quiroga was in any way hostile to the mendicants, nevertheless, he was at pains to note that the bishop had quarrelled with the Augustinians, demanding that they should obtain his licence before erecting any priory in his diocese. So also, the mendicants had to request his permission to celebrate marriages among their native charges. It was his determination to promote the cause of the secular clergy that had prompted Quiroga to establish the college of San Nicolas, to educate students for the priesthood, ordaining many candidates on the strength of their knowledge of native languages.37 To assure his cathedral and chapter of sufficient income, the bishop demanded that Indians should pay the ecclesiastical tithe, a measure which provoked an effective response from Alonso de la Veracruz, the great Augustinian theologian. In all this we can discern the raison d'etre of Moreno's biography. Written at a time when the bishop and chapter were enforcing with considerable enthusiasm the crown's directive to secularise the parishes still administered by the mendicants, the life of Quiroga was designed to provide an historical justification for the assertion of episcopal authority and to demonstrate the role of a secular bishop in the foundation of the Mexican Church. It was thus a text which testified to the profound change in the balance between the religious orders and the secular clergy that was so striking a feature of Bourbon Mexico.
Oratorians
After his ordination by the bishop of Michoacan in 1700, Juan Antonio Perez de Espinosa walked from Valladolid to Queretaro, his native city, there to celebrate his first mass. He was accompanied by his younger brother, then but a subdeacon, Fray Isidro Felix de Espinosa, who in El familiar de la America y domestico de Espana, a life of his brother written
fifty years later, fondly recalled how the secular priest had dismounted from his horse so as to make the journey together on foot. Of reduced but still comfortable means, their parents had raised six children to maturity, of whom the three brothers became priests, and one sister a nun. Educated by the Jesuits in Queretaro, Juan Antonio later studied at the University in Mexico City, residing at the newly founded Oratory, both his education and ordination made possible by Juan Antonio Caballero y Ocio, a wealthy priest and benefactor in Queretaro, who provided him with a chantry endowment sufficient to sustain him. Greatly influenced by Fray Antonio Margil and the college of Santa Cruz, Espinosa joined the Franciscans in preaching on the streets and in the textile workshops of Queretaro, and later accompanied Margil on his mission to Valladolid and Patzcuaro. But if he entered the Third Order of the Franciscans, he was more attracted by the Oratory and with this aim in mind joined the Congregation of Our Lady of Guadalupe, an association of secular priests which possessed its own church, built with funds offered by Caballero. Although he rose to become prefect of this Congregation, his hopes of converting it into the nucleus of an Oratory attracted the hostility of the ecclesiastical authorities and he was forced to resign.1 By then the project had become embroiled with Caballero's scheme to secularise Queretaro's parish, which was still administered by the Franciscans. In 1712 Espinosa preached the Lenten sermons in San Miguel el Grande and so impressed its leading citizens that he was offered the Ecce Homo church, which was owned by the mulatto confraternity of La 40
Oratorians
41
Soledad. Accompanied by two young priests, Espinosa built with his own hands the adobe rooms next to the church where they were to live, and also helped in the garden, eking out their diet of bread and sugar cakes with fresh vegetables and fruits. Licensed by the bishop of Michoacan, these aspirant Oratorians rose early in the morning, spent long hours in the confessional, preached frequently, visited the sick and conducted the rosary and spiritual exercises in the evenings. They encouraged the faithful to take frequent, even daily, communion. Refusing to beg for alms, they subsisted off their chantries and voluntary offerings, and supplemented their income by opening a school for children and giving classes in grammar to adolescents. But they suffered opposition from the parish priest who feared that their public masses might rob his church of fees and attendance.2 A further embarrassment came from the mulatto confraternity which insisted on its right to celebrate its annual feast of Ecce Homo at their church, an occasion accompanied by a great deal of drunkenness, gambling and other disorders. In order to establish a canonically approved Oratory in San Miguel, Espinosa sailed for Europe in 1718, there to solicit the requisite licences from the Spanish crown and the Holy See. This initiative was necessary because each Oratory formed an independent congregation of secular priests, united to fellow institutes only by common observance of the rule of St Philip Neri. In Mexico City the Oratory had suffered a controverted foundation and had obtained final approval in 1701. On arriving in Spain, Espinosa was shocked by 'the calamities, miseries and violence' he encountered in Madrid and sought refuge in the Oratory at Cadiz, only there to confide to his brother that 'in Cadiz there is a general neglect of God and greater superstition, enchantments, greater filth and sins than in all the Indies'. He attributed the languid state of the faith to the presence of foreigners and the effects of trade and warfare. But it was also caused by the popularity of the Comedies, against which he inveighed in the pulpit, only then to learn that Philip V expressly protected the theatre and had ordered priests to be reprimanded for preaching against it.3 Assisted by Cardinal Luis de Belluga y Moncada, the founder of an Oratory in Cordoba, in 1725 Espinosa travelled to Rome where he resided at Vallicelli, the mother house of the Oratorians, and in 1727 duly obtained a papal breve authorising the establishment of an Oratory in San Miguel. He also negotiated the concession of privileges for the Oratories of Spain and America, in recognition of which he was named preposito, or father superior, of the institute at Cordoba. It was not until 1734 that he finally obtained a rescript from the crown authorising both his Oratory and the establishment of a school and college. All these
42
The religious orders
negotiations entailed a considerable outlay of money, since as he observed: 'only avarice reigns and it is necessary to beg and pay in order that they let us serve God!' But he was assisted by the wealthy citizens of San Miguel, such as Manuel de la Canal and Jose de Landeta. When news of the successful conclusion of his mission reached San Miguel, the Fathers of the new Oratory elected Espinosa as their first preposito> albeit delegating his authority to his brother Francisco, also a member, and invited Fray Isidro Felix to preach the sermon on the feast of St Philip Neri.4 In 1737, when he was sixty-one, Espinosa wrote to his brother, exclaiming that 'I am tired of the things of Spain and of the little fruit that the Divine Word yields.' He remembered Fray Antonio Margil, whose bruised and wounded feet he had washed on their journey together to Valladolid. He was perplexed as to how he was to transport his library of over 4,000 volumes. But when Manuel de la Canal sent monies sufficient to pay for his voyage home, Espinosa employed those funds to assist the foundation of an Oratory at Malaga, where he was elected the first preposito. Thereafter, the outbreak of war between Spain and England meant that Cadiz was subjected to a British naval blockade which effectively prevented any convoys sailing for Veracruz. In 1747 Espinosa died and was buried in Cordoba, his death celebrated with solemnity in San Miguel, where all the leading citizens and clergy of the town assembled to attend a requiem mass in the church of Ecce Homo.5 In his biography, a work written in 1753 but not published until 1942, Fray Isidro eulogised his brother according to the conventions of Hispanic sanctity of this epoch. Espinosa rose at 2 o'clock, celebrated mass at 4 a.m. and remained in the confessional until noon. He slept in leather sheets, wore a poor soutane, fasted regularly, wore cilices and scourged himself three times a week, drawing blood. He had a family tree illustrated with skulls and skeletons so as to remind him of his origin and end. At times he slept in a coffin. In a peculiar act of abnegation he wore green-tinted spectacles so that the world always appeared rather dim and off colour. In his frequent sermons, many of which he had printed, he especially warned against sexual temptation, denounced bull fighting as a relic of pagan Rome, inveighed against the Comedies, disapproved of secular music in church and, during the night exercises of the Blessed Souls in Purgatory, beat himself with chains. His sermons emphasised moral examples in place of scholastic doctrine. An advocate of frequent communion, he was devoted to the Eucharist and to Our Lady of Guadalupe, always carrying a likeness of the Virgin with him.6 He did not take money for the masses he celebrated. In effect, Fray Isidro portrayed his brother as an ideal priest, whose personal asceticism was matched
Oratorians
43
only by a dedication to his pastoral ministry in the confessional, the pulpit and the altar. Despite the absence of its founder, the Oratory at San Miguel prospered, opening the college of San Francisco de Sales and sponsoring the beateria of Santa Ana where Espinosa's sister acted as rectora. It also attracted several priests distinguished either for their sanctity or their learning. In the sphere of religion its most notable figure was Luis Felipe Neri de Alfaro (1709-76), a native of Mexico City who in 1730 abandoned the capital to join the Oratory in San Miguel where he subscribed over 5,000 ps. towards the construction of the chapel of La Salud. An austere ascetic, he soon attracted a following among the faithful and founded several brotherhoods called Escuelas de Cristo (schools of Christ) dedicated to helping the poor, visiting the sick, burying the dead and undertaking personal penitence and prayer. These associations were located in Guanajuato, San Luis de la Paz, Leon and San Luis Potosi, as well as at San Miguel. In 1740 Alfaro left the Oratory in order to establish a sanctuary and house of spiritual exercises at Atotonilco, situated in a barren part of the countryside some twelve kilometres from San Miguel. And there he remained, still in good standing with the Oratory, for the rest of his life, slowly extending and embellishing his cherished project. 7 None of this would have been possible had he not devoted his considerable inheritance, first in purchasing for 20,000 ps. the surrounding lands to form a hacienda which comprised forty-four caballerias (1,884 hectares), and then in building a dam 500 yards long at a cost of 12,000 ps. which allowed him to plant wheat. A mill producing flour worth 20,000 ps. completed an estate which yielded an income of 4,000 ps. a year, monies which allowed Alfaro to add further chapels to the sanctuary across the years. 8 Although he actively opened negotiations with the Dominicans, hoping to persuade them to establish a permanent priory at Atotonilco with twelve friars in residence, nothing came of these plans and he remained the sole chaplain until his death. The sanctuary at Atotonilco numbered among the most remarkable and personal creations of the Mexican baroque. Having completed the single sanctuary dedicated to Jesus Nazareno, Alfaro then added no less than six or seven other chapels as well as a camarin behind the high altar and a sacristy. In all these rooms there were a multiplicity of altars and images, of which the most striking was the Calvary with life-size figures depicting Christ on the cross accompanied by the two thieves, the Virgin Mary and apostles. The walls and vaultings were covered by paintings and inscriptions, much of the latter consisting of verses composed by Alfaro. Since the lighting is poor, many of these relatively small chambers
44
The religious orders
are shrouded in shadow and must be imagined lit by the flickering flame of candles. The idea behind this proliferation of chapels was to depict scenes which recalled Bethlehem, the holy house at Nazareth and the Holy Places at Jerusalem where Christ celebrated the Last Supper and suffered his Passion. From the start, Alfaro had perceived a similarity between the barren fields of Atotonilco and the Holy Land.9 Adjoining the sanctuary were the rooms, refectory and patio of the house of spiritual exercises, where penitents spent eight days under Alfaro's direction, their time devoted to collective prayer, meditation, examination of conscience and penitential scourging. The day started at five in the morning and lasted until nightfall, the last sessions conducted in darkness. Since these exercises could attract as many as sixty men, drawn from rich and poor, the large number of chapels allowed penitents to follow the life and Passion of Christ stage by stage. On all these occasions Alfaro served at table in the refectory and on Fridays preached on his knees with a crown of thorns pressed tight on his head. So powerful was his influence that in the years 1765-76 no less than 7,541 men took these exercises and individuals of both sexes attended particular courses. It was estimated that he heard 14,000 general confessions in his career as a priest, in which penitents reviewed the course of their lives before resolving to amend their ways.10 Although Alfaro was inspired by St Ignatius' Spiritual Exercises, he clearly adapted them to local needs and infused them with a Franciscan sensibility since, whereas St Ignatius urged penitents to place themselves at the side of Christ in his life in Nazareth and in his Passion at Jerusalem, Alfaro not merely reproduced the physical setting of these scenes in the images and paintings of his chapels, but also encouraged personal replication of the physical sufferings of Christ. When Alfaro died in 1776, his funeral eulogy was delivered at Atotonilco by Dr Juan Benito Diaz de Gamarra y Davalos, the rector of the Oratorian college of San Francisco de Sales, an address published in the same year under the title of El sacerdotefiel.It was very much a personal tribute, since Gamarra recalled that he had often served mass for Alfaro and had been present at his deathbed. After praising the sanctuary for its beauty, exclaiming that it formed 'a beautiful paradise and refuge of mercy and salvation', the young Oratorian emphasised that although Alfaro was 'a very broad confessor', which was to say, merciful but firm, he marvelled at his castigation of his own flesh. For many years Alfaro ate little more than eggs and vegetables and, not content with loading his limbs with cilices, also donned a spiked hair-shirt which wounded his skin. Often he rose at midnight to adore the sacrament in the chapel where 'he placed himself in a coffin under the altar, his eyes
Oratorians
45
closed and body extended, and passed the night preparing himself for death'. So often did he practise this penitence that over the years three coffins rotted away. Moreover, when he did use his bed, he took a skeleton which was chis inseparable companion for many years in bed and which he had close to him until the eve of his death'. During the day he devoted himself to hearing confessions and leading various devotions, including the Stations of the Cross and the rosary as well as daily mass. On one occasion he prepared for Easter by remaining forty days alone in a small chamber or camarin. His strenuous penitence reached a climax during Holy Week when he led a Good Friday procession from San Miguel to Atotonilco carrying a heavy wooden cross, his crown of thorns pressed so tight as to cause blood to stream down his face, thus offering the world a living representation of Christ in his Passion. Gamarra concluded by exclaiming that the Oratory 'would always glory in having had such a son', especially since Alfaro had loved the Oratory until the end of his life, calling it 'his mother, my beloved and venerable congregation'.11 As Gamarra reminded his fellow mourners, Alfaro had acted as the spiritual director of Maria Josefina de la Canal, the daughter of the wealthy patron of the Oratory, Manuel de la Canal, who had funded the construction of the sanctuary of the Casa de Loreto adjoining their church. From the time she made her first confession with Alfaro the young heiress took daily communion, recited the rosary three times a day and followed the Stations of the Cross. Such a regime reached an early climax when, at the age of sixteen, she undertook eight days of spiritual exercises with Alfaro at Atotonilco, at their close firmly resolving to employ her estate to found a convent of nuns in San Miguel. The former Oratorian accompanied her to Valladolid where she was interviewed by Bishop Elizacoechea, who approved of her project and rapidly obtained the necessary royal rescript. In 1755 four nuns from the Regina Coeli convent in Mexico City arrived in San Miguel and admitted several novices to their company, including Maria Josefina who was soon appointed as novice mistress.12 Although the convent followed the Concepcionist rule, it differed from its counterparts in the capital in refusing to take in servants and in following the common life, eating meals together in the refectory. In his life of Maria Josefina de la Canal, Diaz de Gamarra observed that 'the world is a society whose maxims, sentiments and conduct is directly opposed to the sentiments, maxims and conduct of Jesus Christ'. He based his account on the notes written by Alfaro who had acted as her spiritual director from her first communion until her death in 1770 at the age of thirty-three. Here were 'no ecstasies, visions or miracles', so
46
The religious orders
Gamarra averred, but simply an edifying story of Christian virtue, of a young woman who had abandoned the world 'in the very bloom of her youth, burying herself alive in a cloister built at her own expense'. But Maria Josefina imitated her confessor in practising rigorous penitence, fasting and scourging herself to the point where her biographer exclaimed that 'the mere sight of all the cruel instruments she used to punish her body and subjugate her flesh was enough to horrify. Cilices, iron plates, hair-shirts with sharp points, scourges with hooks - all this she used to tame her flesh and subject it to the spirit.' Under such a regime her health soon broke, her bodily periods ceased, and she died in great pain, tormented by worms which even emerged from her nose.13 The pursuit of sanctity in the Hispanic world was thus an arduous, bloody affair, in which concentration on Christ's Passion prompted friars, priests and nuns to torture their flesh in an attempt not merely to discipline carnal desires but, more important, to re-enact Christ's physical sufferings. II In 1765-6 Dr Jeronimo Lopez Llergo, a prebendary of the Valladolid cathedral, was appointed by Bishop Sanchez de Tagle to conduct an ecclesiastical visitation of San Miguel el Grande. The most striking event of his stay in the town was the triumphant entrance of the nuns of the Purisima Concepcion into their new, still unfinished church and convent. The occasion was marked by a public procession, starting from the parish church, which paraded through streets covered with boughs of wood and adorned with carpets and rich hangings, its progress attended by several choirs and their musicians. The entire ecclesiastical establishment of San Miguel turned out to celebrate. After the standards of twelve confraternities, each accompanied by twelve brothers carrying candles, there came the Third Order of St Francis with their cross, an image of St Joseph carrying the keys of the new church, and a figure of St Anthony of Padua. There followed the Oratorians with their statue of St Philip Neri, the Franciscans and Dominicans with figures of their respective founders and the image of Santa Ana with the 'daughters of her college'. The rear of the procession concluded with a statue of the Purisima Concepcion, the famous image of Christ as Ecce Homo from the parish church borne by four priests and followed by twelve ecclesiastics with candles, and the community of nuns all dressed in white. The Eucharist under its pallium was carried by the visitor general. On arriving at the convent the local cura unlocked the doors of the church and the images were all placed on the altar there to remain for three days during which
Oratorians
47
solemn high mass was celebrated respectively by the parish priest, the preposito of the Oratory and the guardian of the Franciscan priory.14 The magistrates also arranged for the town to be illuminated at night with fireworks and other expressions of public rejoicing. During his visitation Lopez Llergo took note of the twenty-nine priests resident in San Miguel, of whom only sixteen possessed licences to hear confessions.15 He could not enter the Franciscan priory, however, since the internal government of the religious orders was exempt from episcopal jurisdiction. By contrast, the Oratory was a congregation of secular priests who did not take the solemn vows of obedience, poverty and chastity enjoined on all religious communities, and hence were considered subject to the bishop's authority. In his visitation Lopez Llergo reported that the Oratory comprised nine priests, two deacons and seventeen lay brothers supported collectively by an endowment of 22,476 ps., which yielded an annual income of 1,123 Ps- All this marked a considerable improvement from the congregation's beginnings, when they had lived 'in the greatest poverty', since 'not even the doors were covered, the small rooms were made from matting which the Founder made with his own hands, the first young men and lay brothers assisting him as labourers'. They had subsisted on stews cooked in an absurdly small kitchen. Although these heroic first days were long since past, the lay brothers still grew vegetables in the garden to supplement what was clearly a meagre income. The priests of the Oratory had maintained their practice of preaching every night and of reciting the rosary with a congregation composed of both sexes. On Saturdays they preached in the chapel of the town's textile workshop. During Lent they delivered penitential sermons every day, sallying forth on Palm Sunday on to the streets, carrying images of Christ and St Philip Neri, pausing at various points to preach and sing hymns.16 It is clear from this description that the visitor was most impressed by the dedication and discipline he observed at the Oratory. In the college of San Francisco de Sales, established by royal rescripts of 1743 and 1753, Lopez Llergo found twenty-one students taking philosophy, of whom thirteen had scholarships; another ten studied grammar, eight of whom had scholarships; and there were another ten just starting. On applying for entrance, candidates had to present documents certifying their baptism, their good morals and their limpieza de sangre, which was to say, that all four grandparents had been baptised as Spaniards, a rule that excluded all mestizos and mulattos. Indians could be admitted provided they came from cacique or noble families. Illegitimate or abandoned children could be accepted provided they had been raised in Spanish families. The cost of a year's education and
48
The religious orders
maintenance was ioo ps., a rate which was reduced to 80 ps. if the mother was a widow, and to 50 ps. for candidates who were poor or who wished to become priests. Any student who died while at college was buried in its chapel, presumably free of charge. Every day students listened to spiritual reading in the refectory and were instructed in Christian doctrine on Saturday afternoons. They were expected to present themselves for confession on Thursdays and then take communion at the sung mass of that day. The daily time-table was fixed according to a rigorous schedule of classes and study, broken by meals, recreation and devotions, with the afternoons of Sundays and Thursdays turned over to recreation. Once a month the rector and masters took the students on a walking expedition to the countryside, taking fruit, milk and bread, the pupils all expected to wear their gowns and bonnets. Their diet was simple and consisted of mutton, beans, rice, sugar cakes and bread. 17 Although the visitor thus inquired minutely into the living arrangements for the students, in his report he did not raise the question of their curriculum, soon to become a matter of considerable controversy. Another offshoot of the Oratory, albeit more distant, was the beateria of Santa Ana, licensed by the bishop in 1742. Unlike nuns, the beatas did not take solemn vows and were free to leave their Voluntary enclosure' when they wished. By the time Lopez Llergo visited them they numbered forty-eight women, living in cramped conditions, often four to a room, who were responsible for administering a college for girls. It was a priest of the Oratory, Juan Hipolito Aguado, who had sponsored the institute and who in his will of 1748 left his haciendas to provide the beateria and college with an endowment. Sale of his estates brought in 15,830 ps., which was invested to yield an income of 791 ps. a year. The priests of the Oratory continued to act as chaplains of this institute, which was situated next to the college of San Francisco de Sales, but otherwise did not interfere in its administration. 18 One of its first rectoras had been a sister of Perez de Espinosa. Although the Oratory accepted the visitation conducted by Lopez Llergo, especially since it was so favourable, in the following year Nicolas Perez de Arquitiqui was despatched to Spain, there to ascertain whether Perez de Espinosa had left any papers, and to obtain permission to bring the founder's bones back to Mexico. A further aim was for him to proceed to Rome to secure from the Holy See a grant of the privileges and exemptions already enjoyed by the Oratories of Cordoba and Lima. In particular, it was hoped that the preposito would be given first instance jurisdiction over any case, be it criminal or civil, which involved any member of his congregation, with rights of appeal to the bishop. But
Oratorians
49
Arquitiqui had failed to obtain a licence from the viceroy to initiate such ambitious claims which, if granted, were bound to provoke litigation.19 In consequence, he was denied permission to travel to Italy and was obliged to return to New Spain with little accomplished. In this mission Arquitiqui was accompanied by Juan Benito Diaz de Gamarra y Davalos (1745-83), recently ordained as priest, who proceeded to Italy where he spent three years familiarising himself with recent developments in philosophy, his efforts rewarded with the title of doctor of canon law from the University of Pisa. A native of Zamora, the son of a peninsular Spaniard who had served as municipal magistrate, on his mother's side Gamarra descended from the first settlers of that town and had an uncle who had served as rector of the college of Todos Santos. After a year at the Jesuit college of San Ildefonso in Mexico City, Gamarra had enrolled with the Oratory in San Miguel, first as a student and finally as a priest.20 While in Rome he resided at the Oratory of Vallicelli, founded by St Philip Neri, and familiarised himself with the privileges enjoyed by the European Oratories and with the recent controversy in Lima where the Holy See had exempted the Oratory from visitation by the archbishop. On his return to New Spain, however, Gamarra turned his energies to teaching in the college of San Francisco de Sales and in 1774 published his Elementa recentioris philosophiae, in
which he strongly attacked Aristotle's continuing predominance in the schools, and presented the first account of modern philosophy to be printed in Mexico. In his prologue he warmly thanked the bishop of Michoacan, Luis Fernando de Hoyos y Mier, for approving the book as the text for the philosophy course at San Miguel. Episcopal patronage was all important for Gamarra, since his advocacy of curricular reform aroused intense opposition both within the Oratory and beyond, to the point where he was obliged to resign from the rectorship of the college, a position to which he had only recently been appointed. His opponents claimed that his new course had prevented students from graduating from the University of Mexico, since 'in that great theatre which lays down the law in the literary republic of this kingdom' Aristotle still held sway, whereas Gamarra had dismissed the Stagirite with ridicule. At this juncture Bishop Hoyos y Mier intervened to insist that Gamarra should be appointed prefect of studies, a new post designed to allow him to impose his ideas on the college. In a letter to the Oratory, Hoyos praised Gamarra for 'his attractive course of philosophy', saluting him as 'the first American who has toiled over this kind of writing'. Indeed, the Oratorian had planted 'a fertile seed of the most important and true philosophy, eliminating the defects in method and the ineptitude, sterility and disutility of the infantile disputes and
50
The religious orders
questioning of that which is current . . . [which is] a pure ill-conceived abstraction and equivocation of confused terms'. Such was Gamarra's reputation that the rector of the University of Mexico sought the crown's permission to use his new course, thereby 'imitating the most cultured nations of Europe'. In effect, it was now time to accept the recent advances in physics and mathematics, especially since Spain itself had achieved so little progress in the arts and sciences in the last two centuries. By way of reply, the new rector of the college in San Miguel, Carlos Antonio Martinez, confessed that he himself was only acquainted with 'old Aristotle', but promised to install Gamarra's course as the basic text for his students. 21 But Gamarra's attempt to enlist episcopal support for his projects came to grief in 1781-2, when Bishop Juan Ignacio de la Rocha (1777-82) came to San Miguel to conduct a visitation, residing for over six months at the Oratory. At first the relations between the two men were excellent and Rocha was later to recall that the young Oratorian had conversed with him frequently during this time. Indeed, in his Errores del entendimiento humano (1781), published in Puebla under the pseudonym of Juan de Bendiaga, Gamarra warmly commended Rocha as 'the father of the poor, the protector of the sciences'. 22 For his part Rocha set aside 2,000 ps. in his will for the Oratory's primary school, and in May 1781 nominated both Gamarra and the current preposito, Vicente Zerrillo, to assist his visitor general. Archdeacon Jose Perez Calama, in conducting an examination of the resident clergy of San Miguel. 23 Nor was he alone in his opinion since Perez Calama, who accompanied him on the visitation, had also given the Oratory 2,000 ps. and presented a portrait of himself which had been hung in the small chapel. 24 It was precisely these expressions of good will that led Gamarra to presume that the bishop would agree to important concessions about the status of the Oratory, issues which he had discussed with the prelate and archdeacon on several occasions during their stay. The first major grievance he attempted to settle arose from the relation of the Oratory's church to the parish priest of San Miguel. In 1779 the Congregation had appealed to the bishop to revoke the agreement they had signed in 1742 with the landlords of their church, the mulatto confraternity of Ecce Homo y Nuestra Sefiora de la Soledad. According to its terms the confraternity had removed the image of its patron saint and deposited it in the parish church, leaving behind the retablo and pulpit for the sum of 4,185 ps. Although the Oratory thus acquired leasehold (dominio util), they had to recognise that the confraternity still owned the church (derecho directo y de propiedad), and hence agreed as quit-rent to officiate each year at the confraternity's annual feast-day,
Oratorians
51
providing a preacher and four large wax candles. Unhappy that they depended on 'a crowd of blacks and mulattos', the Oratory now complained that although confraternity members were buried in their church, it was the parish priest or his vicars who officiated and pocketed the fees. Hence they petitioned the bishop not merely to recognise their Congregation as the true owners of the church but also to grant them the right of receiving the fees for all masses and services celebrated in their church, citing by way of corroboration the sanctuary of Ocotlan outside Tlaxcala, where the chaplain was paid all such fees. As it was, the Oratorians preached sermons, heard confessions and administered the last sacraments during plagues, all without recompense, so that 'the parish priest has an unpaid vicar in every member of this congregation'.25 That it was Gamarra who was responsible for urging these changes was demonstrated by a letter he wrote to his father superior (preposito) dated 16 February 1780, in which he emphasised that although the Roman Oratory of Vallicelli did not administer a parish it possessed the right to conduct burials, receiving fees without reference to the local cura, adding 'I lived for a year in Rome; I informed myself in some detail about this point.' It was now time to liberate the Oratory of San Miguel from the authority of the parish priest, especially since 'in the person of our illustrious Prelate, clemency, benignity and mercy are now enthroned in Michoacan. Place Your Reverence at his feet and with the confidence that a prince who is so filled with love for our institute ought to inspire, represent to him all that has been said.'26 However, Bishop Rocha had already received strong protests from the mayordomo of the confraternity of La Soledad who affirmed that his brotherhood had owned the church since 1628 and that without the annual sermon and four candles their rights would lapse. More important, the parish priest insisted on his canonical rights to celebrate burial in any church that lay within his jurisdiction and to collect such fees as were appropriate: to abrogate his rights would entail conferring on the Oratory the exemptions and privileges of a religious order. That in March 1780 the bishop rejected the Oratory's petition, refusing to alter the terms of the 1742 agreement, offered a clear warning that his admiration for the Congregation's activities did not include any desire to better its status.27 The rupture between Rocha and the Oratory came in September 1781, when the bishop signed an official decree announcing that he would conduct a visitation of the Congregation and its college. Since he had been staying with them for six months, the matter had been obviously already the object of discussion. The previous May, Perez Calama had been given a copy of all the printed documents of the dispute in Lima, which concluded with a declaration of the Holy See in 1758 exempting
52
The religious orders
the internal regime of the Oratory from episcopal visitation. The Oratorians in San Miguel admitted that they had been 'visited' by either the bishop or his delegate in 1734, 1742, 1766 and 1775, since it was not until 1763 that they had learnt of the Lima dispute and not until the return of Gamarra that they had become cognisant of their rights. Indeed, 'the little oratory . . . the very strength of the institute' had not been established until 1770. None of all this persuaded the bishop and, by now annoyed at their resistance, he left the Oratory, taking up residence in a nearby hacienda, albeit not before donating 1,000 ps. to cover the cost of his protracted stay.28 It was on 7 November that Rocha launched a fierce attack on Gamarra, claiming that whereas he had settled with the father superior to conduct a limited visitation, leaving the question of rights and privileges to be resolved later, the philosopher had intervened to change his superior's mind. In effect, 'the low party, the blind followers of Father Gamarra prevailed over the elders of the Congregation' and, although he had ordered Gamarra to refrain from meddling in such matters, he had won the support of the younger priests and now sought 'the glory of being the hero who would rescue his Congregation from the captivity, tyranny and despotism of the diocesan prelates'. Daunted by this biting criticism, Gamarra now informed his colleagues that he wished to resign from the rectorship of the college, to relinquish his voting rights, and to return to his home in Zamora. 'The notorious resentment of His Lordship' had destroyed his peace of mind. But the Congregation refused to accept his departure and all its members, young and old alike, signed a declaration that they had acted independently. They then wrote to Rocha stating that they were 'filled with bitterness' at his anger, that they were not subject to Gamarra's influence, and that they would not expel him from their midst. Their Congregation was 'composed of secular men, somewhat civilised' who were not prepared to submit to a visitation of 'the economic and internal government' of the Oratory. On 3 December 1781 the bishop decided to suspend the visitation of the Oratory itself and instead ordered Perez Calama to inspect the college of St Francis de Sales. But when the archdeacon, accompanied by the parish priest of San Miguel, entered the college he was met by Gamarra and the staff who informed him that although they freely offered the chapel for his inspection, they refused to provide any accounts of the college since these belonged to its 'economic and interior government' over which the bishop had no jurisdiction. Exasperated by this resistance, Perez Calama instructed the parish priest to apply his authority as ecclesiastical judge to obtain an account of the teaching in the college, of the number of its students and the state of its finances. On
Oratorians
53
2 January 1782 the Oratory informed him that all the resolutions which dealt with the appointment of professors and the methods of teaching in the college were recorded in the minute books of the Oratory, and hence could not be exhibited. At this point, Perez Calama warned the recalcitrant priests that they stood in danger of being excommunicated and, to add substance to the threat, suspended their licences to administer the sacraments. Uncowed by these threats, on 3 January, the Oratory informed Perez Calama that they had already lodged a legal appeal, known technically as recurso defuerza, with the high court in Mexico City, and hence advised him that all proceedings should halt until the case was settled. It was at this point that the bishop ordered the archdeacon to excommunicate all ten priests of the Oratory. At once the town council of San Miguel, composed of wealthy landowners, begged the bishop to lift the sentence, stating that it was their duty to God and king (ambas majestades) to warn him that the local populace might well be stirred by the scandal of this conflict. The parish priest equally intervened to express his alarm. For their part the Oratory declared that publication of the excommunication edict would cause 'universal scandal, sorrow . . . discredit to their poor name', and threatened to appeal to the archbishop. At this point, Gamarra now reminded Perez Calama that he was a commissioner of the Inquisition and as such enjoyed immunity from the bishop's jurisdiction, an effective argument, since on 7 January his sentence was lifted. Once again the Oratory wrote to complain bitterly of their punishment: they were zealous priests, devout and poor; yet they had been treated as delinquents, simply because they had dared to defend their legal rights. Once again they denied that Gamarra had caused the entire incident, adding that he was 'filled with pain and outrage, afflicted, his honour touched to the quick'. On 8 January the bishop bowed to this storm of protest and to avoid further scandal lifted the sentences of excommunication. Barely a week later, on 16 January, Rocha wrote to the viceroy denouncing the Oratory and Gamarra for their refusal to countenance his jurisdiction. As bishop he had the right and duty to visit all churches, confraternities and colleges within his diocese, inspecting their accounts. The Oratory had no documents to substantiate their claim for exemption other than the printed account of the Lima dispute: yet they had refused to allow him to inspect the four minute books of 'the internal government' of their Congregation. Since the college prepared candidates for the priesthood there was good reason for him to ascertain what was being taught there and how well its accounts were kept; yet he had not even seen its constitution. He added:
54
The religious orders
in the said college they do not profess any particular doctrine, allowing the various masters in their time and at their will to teach whatever they themselves were taught in their tender years or have afterwards embraced; and are now accustomed to teach speculative philosophy according to the principles of the Suarezist school, which conforms but little with the doctrines of St Augustine or St Thomas. In practical moral theology there have been times when they have professed laxism in the said college, not offering the youngsters any other books than the moral tracts of Father Juan Maria, the Summa of Busenbaum, and other works of this kind, whose doctrines both time and experience have shown to be noxious. As for Aristotelian philosophy, he averred that the students had been taught 'to despise and ridicule it, dedicating themselves to reading a course of arts that Father Juan Benito Diaz de Gamarra had printed'. The result of all this was that when candidates from the college were examined in Mexico for their bachillerato, 'most of them failed, remaining without the qualification necessary to go forward to higher studies'. Turning to Gamarra, the bishop claimed that the Congregation had sought to cancel the new course of study, but that he had persuaded Bishop Hoyos to intervene, appointing him prefect of studies. Thus to advance 'the prejudicial ambitions of Father Gamarra', the bishop's jurisdiction had first been invoked but was now rejected. The whole reason for this appointment had been to allow Gamarra to impose his Course of Arts, a book he had had printed without licence. In fact, many of the priests of the Oratory were obedient, unpretentious men, quite willing to accept the bishop's authority, but 'the harm that the Congregation now suffers' is that it is 'dominated by the spirit of Father Juan Benito Diaz de Gamarra, a contentious man', who had won an ascendancy over his colleagues 'through his insinuating and seductive style . . . and his learning'. Later in the same month the diocesan legal counsel (promoter fiscal), Lie. Jose Joaquin de Eguia, defined the essence of the dispute from the perspective of a canon lawyer. The Council of Trent, he explained, had maintained the exemption of religious communities from episcopal jurisdiction, an exemption that derived from the exercise of papal authority. But the Oratorians were not a religious order: they comprised a loose confederation of autonomous congregations of secular priests, united only by their common agreement to observe the rules of community life framed by St Philip Neri. They did not take solemn vows. As the Dutch canonist Van Espen had commented, they enjoyed certain privileges but possessed few rights. Since an Oratorian Order, properly speaking, did not exist, it followed that the results of the dispute in Lima
Oratorians
55
had no bearing on the conflict in San Miguel. When in Rome, Gamarra should have obtained a papal breve granting the exemptions he desired. Following Rocha's example, Eguia criticised Gamarra's 'contentious and rebellious character', and concluded by pronouncing that 'Father Gamarra is very far from being able to vie with the venerable founder, Juan Antonio Perez de Espinosa', his brother or his nephews or other fathers, who 'perhaps found nothing useful for their purpose or life in the doctrines of Malebruck [sic], the observations of Noleto [sic], the system of Nuet [sic], and other frivolities of this kind'. Since the high court decided to admit the Oratory's appeal, lawyers for both parties to the dispute prepared printed statements but, whereas the counsel for the bishop did little more than rehearse the arguments put forward by Rocha and Eguia, by contrast, Lie. Manuel Quijano Zavala, the Oratory's advocate, provided a vigorous defence which included additional points of fact. Although he agreed that the Oratorians were not a religious order bound by solemn vows, nevertheless, he insisted they all observed the 1612 Constitution of the Roman Oratory approved by the Holy See, which explicitly prohibited any episcopal visitation of the 'economic and internal government' of the Congregation. Both the papal breve of 1727 and the royal rescript of 1734, which established the Oratory at San Miguel, conferred upon the new Congregation all the privileges and rights already enjoyed by the mother house in Rome. Moreover, the papal breve of 1758 had explicitly declared that the archbishop of Lima had no right to meddle with the internal regime of the Oratory in that city, a ruling which obviously applied to all Oratories in the world. As regards the college of St Francis de Sales, Quijano argued that it had been formally established by a royal rescript of 1753 and was a secular institution since it educated boys recruited from the laity who might opt as much for a secular career as for the priesthood; as such it was not subject to the bishop's jurisdiction. 29 Quijano was also at pains to defend Gamarra from the accusations of Rocha and his diocesan attorney. He revealed that the bishop had stayed at the Oratory for six months prior to opening his visitation, and that the Oratory had prepared their appeal to the high court almost two weeks before their excommunication. He dismissed Rocha's assertion that students from the college at San Miguel could no longer obtain degrees, by printing a certified statement of the secretary of the University of Mexico, which demonstrated that in a recent triennium no less than sixty-two students from the college had graduated with their bachillerato. Gamarra's course on philosophy was greatly valued and he printed the letter from Bishop Hoyos testifying to that effect. As for the diocesan counsel's opinion, his peculiar spelling of Malebranche, Nollet and
56
The religious orders
Newton suggested that he had never read their books. In any case, Gamarra did not simply rely on his own course; he had also printed for the students' use Esteban de Orellana's Instruction de la Lengua Latin and Carlos Rolin's Selectae Veteri Testamento Historiae, a selection of readings
from the Old Testament. Moreover, the students also used Nebrija's Grammar and the Colloquies of Luis Vives, together with Virgil and Horace. As for theology, the college did not teach the doctrines of Suarez but concentrated on St Augustine and St Thomas, interpreted by Melchor Cano and other reputable authors. The works of Busenbaum were certainly not used, since they had been strictly prohibited by a royal rescript in 1769. Finally, Quijano demanded to know why a priest of such high talent and devotion as Gamarra had been slandered, a priest 'who without other interest than the public good has spent his own money and has undertaken immense work'.30 In January 1783 the high court found that the acts of the bishop as visitor hacen fuerza, which is to say, they constituted an unjustified invasion of the Oratory's rights. It was accepted that the papal breve of 1758, issued to resolve the dispute in Lima, applied to all Oratories and hence provided exemption from episcopal visitation. The ruling, however, only affected the Oratory itself and did not directly resolve the controverted question of the status of the college. The following year the Oratory petitioned the crown for recognition of the secular status of their college and sought permission to change the uniform of their students from a gown to 'military dress in black cloth'. The case eventually was heard again by the Council of the Indies which, in 1792, confirmed the high court's judgement but refused to place the college under royal patronage, instead requesting Viceroy Revillagigedo to report as to what was taught there. The matter thus returned to the intendant of Guanajuato who in 1793 provided an outline of the college's curriculum, which demonstrated that Gamarra's course certainly provided the introduction to philosophy but that students also addressed the authors mentioned by Quijano in his defence. The intendant noted that the rules provided for weekly communion and insisted on monthly confession and communion; they also forbade the reading of comedies, romances and tales, 'books so pernicious for good customs'.31 And there the matter rested. The chief protagonists in this dispute did not live to see the matter resolved. Bishop Rocha died in February 1782, still residing on a hacienda close to San Miguel, only a month after issuing his sentence of excommunication. More surprising, Gamarra himself died in November 1783 only aged thirty-eight years. As for Jose Perez Calama, he wrote to the Oratory in June 1784 to express his regrets over the whole affair. He
Oratorians
57
acknowledged his great debt to the learning and spirituality of their Congregation and claimed that it had been Rocha who had caused the confrontation and commanded him to excommunicate its priests. Since Perez Calama prided himself on his enlightened opinions and shared Gamarra's detestation of the arid Aristotelianism of the schools, there is no reason to question his disclaimers. That Rocha was prone to adopt a peremptory defence of episcopal jurisdiction can be demonstrated by his querulous criticism of the Dominican provincial for allowing four of his friars to take up residence in San Miguel without obtaining the bishop's permission, where neither the provincial's apologies nor compliance lessened his indignation.32 Ill In the prologue of his Elementa recentioris philosophiae, Gamarra saluted the youth of Mexico as 'the great hope of the patria', and added that he had laboured day and night, reading over a hundred books, to inform them about the most recent developments in European philosophy. To this end he had sacrificed 'my leisure, the agreeable residence in my patria, a considerable quantity of money that I have spent, and that which mortals usually hold in great account, my fame and good name, since among the ignorant I am treated like a criminal for destroying the philosophy and ancient religion of our ancestors'.33 His consciousness of achievement was revealed in his Errores del entendimiento humano (1781) when, taking advantage of his pseudonym, he praised his own Elementa, immodestly observing 'one cannot deny this scholar the glory of having been the first of our compatriots who dared to combat the old method, giving us a philosophy suited to the taste of the most cultivated nations of Europe'. In his attack on Aristotle and outmoded scholastic categories and his eagerness to inform the Mexican public of 'the very useful doctrines' of modern philosophy and science, Gamarra consciously imitated Benito Jeronimo Feijoo, the Benedictine author of Teatro critico universal (1726-39), describing him as 'the splendour of Spain and of the century that is now growing old'. As much as the Benedictine abbot, he praised the great discoveries of seventeenth-century science, but expressed scepticism or hostility towards the systems of philosophy that had also emerged during the epoch. Conscious of the variegated basis of his thought, he exclaimed: 'How happy are the eclectic philosophers who fly from flower to flower like bees searching for the sweet nectar of knowledge.'34 Above all else, Gamarra attacked Aristotle and the scholastic philosophy that had enshrined him as the supreme authority in all things
58
The religious orders
natural. In his Memorial ajustado (1790), a brief satire published after his death, he depicted a scene 'in the high court of Estagira in this kingdom of Chimeras', where the massed professors of the peripatetic colleges accuse two individuals called 'reason and experience' of assembling the disciples of Descartes, Gassendi and Newton so as to destroy Aristotle's supreme authority and 'prescriptive right'. Horrified by the threat to the doctrine of 'substantial forms', the court accepted the counsel of the attorney Ergotista and decided to suppress the new ideas and destroy all barometers, microscopes and telescopes. 35 In all this Gamarra echoed Los aldeanos criticos (1758) in which the count of Penaflorida, the founder of the Real Sociedad Bascongada de los Amigos del Pais, boldly acclaimed the doctrines of Newton and derided 'the most ancient, bald, wrinkled, tremulous . . . Lord Aristotle of Estagira, Prince of the peripatetics, Duke of substantial forms, Count of antipathies, Marquis of accidents'. 36 T o strengthen his case Gamarra had recourse to ecclesiastical history, noting that all the Church Fathers had praised Plato and rejected Aristotle, who had only entered Christian philosophy in the twelfth and thirteenth centuries owing to the influence of Arab thinkers such as Averroes. The result had been the creation of a barbarous jargon and 'a disputatious, contentious philosophy', whose adherents constantly engaged in 'those sempiternal exercises, disputes and logomachies'. Had not Plato in his Gorgias condemned the sophists of his day? Yet universities in Spain and Mexico were still filled with professors who rejected modern science and insisted on blindly maintaining Aristotelian categories and doctrines that had been resurrected and systematised during the Middle Ages. 37 It was in his account of physics and perceptions that Gamarra most clearly embraced modern science, saluting Galileo as 'the Peter the Great of philosophy', since he had descended from his academic throne to learn matters of practical concern, liberating philosophy from Arabic dominion. As regards the natural world, the categories of Aristotle were not so much false as simply vacuous and irrelevant, since in place of such distinctions as form and matter, substance and accidents, it was necessary to examine the laws of motion. It was thanks to their use of the telescope and microscope that Galileo had scanned the movement of the heavens and Harvey the circulation of the blood. As regards the revolution in astronomy, Gamarra accepted that the heliocentric theories of Copernicus and Galileo explained the movements of the heavens far better than the system of Ptolemy; but described their theories simply as the best hypothesis. Not that he was impressed by Catholic rejection of Copernicus on scriptural grounds, since he argued that the purpose of the Bible was to teach doctrines of salvation, instructing Jews and
Oratorians
59
Christians by metaphors and figures, without any intent of satisfying curiosity about the natural world. As regards 'the sublime Newton, light and ornament of England5, Gamarra accepted that in his study of optics he had clearly demonstrated that colours derive from the operation of light and hence were not accidents of nature. But, although he noted that Newton's physics had been defended by many illustrious philosophers, he admitted that 'this is an impenetrable mystery for those who are not initiated in high mathematics'.38 Unlike contemporary Mexican savants such as Joaquin Velasquez de Leon and Antonio de Leon y Gama, Gamarra obviously did not command sufficient mathematics to expound the achievements of Newtonian physics. In his discussion of metaphysics, which was to say, the doctrines of the soul and of God, Gamarra reversed his modernist stance and openly favoured the 'peripatetics', praising St Thomas Aquinas as a 'genius' and as an 'immortal theologian'. Rejecting both materialism and Cartesian dualism, he asserted that the soul was created by God from nothing and was present from the moment of conception. He followed the Thomist principle that the soul was both the animating form of the body, which gave it both life and intelligence, and also an immortal spirit not exposed to material corruption. He cited an eloquent passage from Cardinal Melchor de Polignac, which depicted the soul as the music and the body as the instrument, both elements necessary to make a human being. As regards the Almighty, Gamarra followed St Thomas in claiming that his existence could be rationally demonstrated, and set out his version of the five famous proofs of the Angelic Doctor, albeit concentrating on the argument from design. As a clock needed a maker, so the complexity and grandeur of the natural world required the power and mind of a Supreme Being to set it in motion and thereafter sustain its existence.39 When he came to deal with morality, Gamarra launched afierceattack on the 'mob' of modern authors, men such as Voltaire, Hobbes and Rousseau, who had cited the customs and morality of all ages and all nations so as to undermine the authority of the Catholic Church. Their libertine ethics and their atheism should provoke 'indignation, scorn and pity', so Gamarra averred, and he advised his students not to read their poisonous books. What better proof for the truth of the Catholic faith could be found than the apostolic virtues of its many saints? As scripture commanded, one had to love God with all one's mind and heart, since God's love was a consuming fire and his punishments greatly to be feared. If God's existence be accepted then it was only right that he should be worshipped in public rites, especially since knowledge of God was 'a necessary bond of natural society and the civil state'. As regards morality, Gamarra affirmed that man was made for society, contrary to
60
The religious orders
Rousseau's fables, and that the golden rule of conduct consisted in not doing to others what one did not want to be done to oneself, or, more positively, to treat one's neighbour as one would wish to be treated by one's neighbour.40 In all this, Gamarra clearly revealed himself as a Catholic priest, encouraging his students to follow the path of Christian morals. In his brief history of philosophy, Gamarra cited a formidable number of modern authors, a list calculated more to dismay than to illumine the student. Yet, when we turn to his discussion of morality, we find that he was more influenced by his reading of the Greek and Latin classics than by any contemporary thinker. A clear instance of this bias was his commendation of Cicero's characterisation of Socrates as abandoning the search for secret causes in Nature in favour of discussion of how to live a good life. In effect he advocated a humanist ethic, drawing upon Cicero, Seneca, Plutarch and Plato for support. How distant all this was from Catholic asceticism can be observed when, on advising readers to take simple, unspiced food, he added 'the best sauce is appetite and this is acquired by exercise of the body', with walks in the country the best form of such exercise.41 The bridge between the classics and contemporary humanism was to be found in his assertion that as a social creature man must be prepared 'to love his patria and also the prince', submitting to laws and accepting public duties. Although he cited the traditional definition of philosophy as 'knowledge of the true, the good and the beautiful', he also declared that true wisdom was 'the knowledge of all necessary and useful things', a utilitarian gloss upon convention. Like most thinkers of his age he was so impressed by the achievements of the past century that he praised 'the geometric spirit which extends over all the sciences and all the arts', creating new marvels. But when he came to discuss 'good taste', he described it as based on 'the doctrine of proportions in the geometry of the spirit'.42 In effect, Gamarra was an eclectic who responded in equal measure to the achievements of modern science and to the neo-classic humanism of his epoch, sources which impelled him to return to the very roots of the Western philosophy in the ancient world. The conjuncture of Luis Felipe Neri de Alfaro and Juan Benito Diaz de Gamarra within the ambit of the Oratory of San Miguel attests to the complex, if not contradictory, character of eighteenth-century Mexican Catholicism. The two men were at opposite poles within the spectrum of Christian life. Whereas the founder of Atotonilco embodied the most austere form of asceticism, depriving his tortured flesh of all earthly comfort, spending his days in the confessional or in the pulpit, by contrast the rector of San Francisco de Sales laboured to effect the
Oratorians
61
intellectual renovation of the Mexican Church through his teaching, reading and writing. But the paradox was that Gamarra deeply admired the older priest and celebrated his ascetic virtues in his funeral eulogy. What united both men was dedication to their priestly ministry, the one through spiritual counsel, the other through books and classes. The presence of such diverse talents within a single institution attests to the extraordinary vitality of the Oratory at San Miguel which, during this epoch, figured among the most original expressions of the Mexican Church.
Secularisation
On 4 October 1749 the Spanish crown issued a rescript which commanded that all parishes or doctrinas currently administered by the religious orders in the dioceses of Lima and Mexico should be henceforth entrusted to the care of the secular clergy. On finding that this measure had elicited little popular protest, in February 1753 the ministers of Ferdinand VI (1746-59) despatched a further rescript extending the process of secularisation to all the dioceses of Spain's American empire. The result was that within less than a decade the Franciscans, Dominicans and Augustinians lost numerous parishes which they had governed since the sixteenth century, among which figured the glorious prizes of the spiritual conquest so celebrated by their early chroniclers. The rude shock dealt both to vested interest and institutional sentiment was magnified by the brutal fashion in which these laws were applied. After all, when Juan de Palafox y Mendoza had secularised mendicant doctrinas in Puebla during the 1640s, he had allowed the friars to retain possession of their churches and priories, providing his clergy with newly built parish churches. By contrast, the colonial authorities now sought to expropriate conventual churches, expelling friars from their small country priories on the grounds that these houses had been constructed without royal licence in Indian villages. According to an anonymous protest, soldiers were at times employed to enforce the measure, so that priories were occupied without warning and friars ordered to leave at once, obliged to set out on foot, carrying little more than their clothes and breviaries.1 To assess the impact of secularisation we should note that in his Theatro americano (1746), Jose Antonio de Villaseftor y Sanchez estimated that 152 of the 527 parishes in the four central dioceses of Mexico, Puebla, Michoacan and Guadalajara were administered by the three mendicant orders. Indeed, in Mexico the secular clergy only held 88 parishes compared to the 101 held by the friars, a figure which failed to take into account the vast area of many of the more 62
Secularisation
63
remote country doctrinas. Following their occupation the archbishop moved swiftly to divide these jurisdictions, so that by 1780 the number of parishes in the diocese of Mexico had risen to 244.2 In effect, secularisation marked a watershed in the history of the church in New Spain. At the same time, the failure of the Mexican populace to launch any effective protest against the measure encouraged the crown and its ministers to proceed with a generation-long assault against the inherited privileges and property of the church in America. The authors of this far-reaching 'reform' were the marquis of Ensenada and Jose de Carbajal y Lancaster, the two leading ministers of Ferdinand VI, who obtained the active support of the king's father confessor, the Jesuit Francisco de Ravago. They were impelled to action by a strong letter from the current viceroy of Peru, the count of Superunda, who complained of the excessive number of nuns resident in Lima and sharply condemned the frequently licentious behaviour of the religious who administered rural parishes. For his part, the viceroy of New Spain, the first count of Revillagigedo, informed the ministers that the religious orders had become so wealthy that they absorbed the greater part of the colony's resources, thereby weakening its trade with the Peninsula. By this time the marquis of Ensenada had presumably read the Noticias Secretas, the extensive report on Spanish possessions in South America, written by Antonio de Ulloa and Jorge Juan, the young naval officers who had accompanied the scientific expedition to Ecuador led by the marquis of La Condamine, a work which offered a vivid description of the immorality and disorders of friars in Quito.3 To deal with the problem, Ensenada persuaded the king to by-pass the Council of the Indies and to nominate Carbajal as president of a special committee (junta) of 'theologians and jurists', composed of the three archbishops-elect of Lima, Mexico and Bogota, the king's father confessor, four members of the Council of Castile and three members of the Council of the Indies. Acting with exemplary despatch, this committee held its first meeting in November 1748 and presented Ensenada with its recommendations by the end of March 1749. In their report the committee provided a brief sketch of the history of the problem, noting that in his Politica Indiana, Juan de Solorzano Pereira, had described the conflict between the mendicant orders and bishops in New Spain over jurisdiction, a conflict which had been resolved in 1624 when the three missionary orders recognised the right of bishops to conduct visitations of their doctrinas and agreed that each doctrina should count as a parish, with a particular friar named as its cura or parish priest, thereby receiving 'canonical appointment' from the bishop. But although this agreement subjected the missionary church to the norms of church
64
The religious orders
government set out in the legislation of the Council of Trent, it did not remove all doubts. If in Puebla Juan de Palafox had moved decisively to quit the friars of all their parishes in his diocese, elsewhere bishops moved cautiously and sporadically to extend the role of secular clergy. Nevertheless, as early as the 1680s the viceroy of Peru, the duke of Palata, had attributed the excessive growth in the number of friars and their evident loss of discipline to their management of rural parishes. Despite this historical precedent and official testimony, the junta recommended Ensenada to limit the application of secularisation to the dioceses of Lima and Mexico so as to ascertain popular reaction. At the same time they urged that all religious houses with fewer than eight resident friars should be closed forthwith. With the support of Ravago, ministers secured royal assent to these measures. Moreover, although they obtained papal bulls approving the projected reforms, they decided to suppress these documents since their phrasing was judged to encroach on the rights of the king as supreme patron of the American Church.4 The brutal celerity with which secularisation was enforced by viceroys and bishops elicited vigorous protest from the friars and the Creole establishment. The General Commissaries of the Franciscans, Dominicans and Augustinians in Madrid bitterly complained to the king's ministers that friars were in 'extreme misery, their honour insulted, handled as if they were lawbreakers, and treated in America with a hostility and rigour that was not displayed nor extended to the Moors and Jews when they were expelled from these kingdoms'. In the same vein, the Franciscan province of Santo Evangelio which had houses and parishes in the dioceses of Puebla, Mexico and Oaxaca, reminded the king of its pioneering role in the conversion of the Mexican Indians and asserted that the spiritual conquest of the sixteenth century had created rights as strong and as enduring as those won by force of arms. With over 800 members, the province lacked room in its urban priories and had no means to support them. Moreover, the effects of the seizure on the parishes had been lamentable. The former priories, often hallowed through their historical associations, now served as stables or as textile workshops, or even as accommodation for the poor. The secular clergy to whom their parishes had been entrusted had no knowledge of the Indian languages in which the friars had become expert and hence were unable to communicate with their flocks, with the result that the natives were threatened by a relapse into superstition or even idolatry. Much the same emphasis on historical rights was advanced by the Augustinian province of the Dulce Nombre de Jesus, which averred that the Christian faith 'was planted through the evangelical preaching of the religious, who erected churches, converted barbarians, tamed wild and
Secularisation
65
domesticated men close to brutes'. They also found it difficult to find the means and space with which to support and house in their urban priories the great number of friars expelled from the rural parishes.5 The city council of Mexico also addressed a long memorial to the crown setting out the harmful effects of secularisation both for the Indians and the friars. In most parishes a team of eight to ten friars had been replaced by two or three secular priests whom custom required 'to dress in silk and to conduct themselves with pomp and authority'. These clerics often had a family to support, their mothers and sisters, and had to set up house. Worse still, few of these priests could speak an Indian tongue, whereas the friars had always made a point of employing native languages in their pastoral ministry, so that the spiritual needs of the Indians were neglected. The council reiterated the mendicants' protests as regards overcrowding: it estimated that the central provinces of the Franciscans, Augustinians and Dominicans had about 2,500 members, of whom only 500 used to reside in Mexico City. But now there was the prospect of doubling that number, filling the urban priories with friars, without adequate accommodation, maintenance or employment. Hitherto, the orders had attracted novices by the prospect of the rural ministry; with that opportunity lost, fewer candidates would be forthcoming.6 None of these considerations deterred the viceroy, the first count of Revillagigedo (1745-55), from seeking to implement secularisation with breakneck speed. He defended the measure by asserting that the mendicants had broken the law by establishing their priories in Indian villages and that in any case few of these houses had the requisite number of eight friars; nor did they observe their rule or even sing the holy office. On inquiry, it had been found that few of the ostensible parish priests among the religious had received due canonical appointment, since superiors moved their friars from district to district according to the needs of their province. As for the Indians, the change was wholly beneficial, since they would now be obliged to learn Spanish, an outcome he hailed as 'the best means to wrest them from the misery and crudity in which they have been left to live for so many years, retaining with their languages their old superstitions and barbarism'. However, his successor, the marquis of Amarillas (1755-60) proved less enthusiastic about the transfer of parishes and sought to slow down the process. By his accession it had become clear that some friars, if not all, had obtained canonical appointment as parish priests from bishops and hence according to canon law could not be legally ejected from their benefices.7 To allay the disquiet in Madrid caused by these protests and doubts,
66
The religious orders
in 1756 Archbishop Manuel Rubio y Salinas (1749-65) despatched a long letter to the king's ministers in which he clearly revealed the principles which underpinned the 'reform'. To start with, he denied the existence of any shortage of priests with knowledge of'Mexican' (Nahuatl), since in a recent round of parish appointments he had found no less than 174 clerics ordained precisely because of their command of Indian languages. Admittedly, most only knew 'Mexican', which they had learnt as children from family servants, and few if any could speak Otomi. In any case, he had established a chair of Mexican language in the diocesan seminary. But the real solution to the problem, so Rubio argued, was to oblige Indians to learn Spanish. The chief cause of native backwardness, still so evident, was the wrong-headed decision of the mendicants in the sixteenth century to employ native languages to preach the gospel, an error maintained by their successors until the present time. Yet it was manifestly impossible to explain the sublime mysteries of the Christian faith in these tongues 'without falling into great imperfections and incongruities'. Already many Indians, especially the leading families of Puebla and Tlaxcala, spoke Spanish and it was precisely such natives who tended to escape the misery and usual vices of their race. Although greatly tempted to abolish 'the use of Indian languages in the spiritual administration of all secularised parishes', he had decided to allow native tongues to be employed in at least half of these districts. But this was only a short-term concession, since he had established no less than 262 schools across the diocese, charged with the task of teaching the Indians Spanish, so that once their instruction took effect more radical steps could be taken, since 'it is necessary to abolish the general use of their languages . . . so that in all that concerns religion only Spanish is spoken'. 8 As regards the friars, Archbishop Rubio adopted an uncompromising stance, insisting that they had never solicited any royal licence to build their priories in Indian villages and that in any case most of these houses only had one or two friars in residence. However, he agreed with Viceroy Amarillas that, where friars had been canonically appointed as parish priests, they should be left in place, their parishes only secularised after the death of the current incumbent. In this way, the process became more gradual and the influx of friars from the country into urban priories slowed down. He admitted there was a problem of overcrowding but recommended that it be resolved by reducing or temporarily halting the intake of novices, thereby effecting an overall reduction in numbers. Looking across New Spain, he failed to see any advantage in the existing division of the Franciscans and Dominicans into several small provinces and urged that their interests could best be served by amalgamation. For
Secularisation
67
the rest, he concluded that the mendicants should be encouraged to direct their pastoral energy to the challenge of the missions on the northern frontier, in the vast zone stretching from Tamaulipas to California. By 1756, when Rubio composed this defence of secularisation, Carbajal had died and both Ensenada and Ravago had fallen from power. Moreover, the king's new father confessor, Manuel Quintano Bonifaz, the inquisitor general of Spain, had already intervened to hold 'repeated discussions' with Julian de Arriaga, the newly appointed Minister of the Indies, to whom he also acted as confessor.9 It was mainly owing to his mediation that a new rescript was issued in June 1757, which confirmed that all religious who had been canonically installed as parish priests by their bishops should remain in their livings until death. More positively, each mendicant province was allowed to retain two parishes of the first class, so as to provide an income. All priories which housed eight or more friars on a regular basis were to be kept open, and if already expropriated were to be returned. But the rescript also commanded the mendicant orders in America to limit their intake of novices so as to effect a reduction in their numbers and called upon them to prepare their friars for the frontier missions. The effect of this measure was to slow down the transfer of parishes and to afford a degree of amelioration; this apart, secularisation remained the objective of royal policy. Nor did the accession of Charles III (1759-88) offer any alteration since, after a summary of the causes and stages of the process was read out to him in November 1760, he gave it his approval. That the summary emphasised the lack of popular resistance and the benefits accruing to the Indians only confirmed the principles and prejudices which had impelled this momentous change in the pastoral ministry of the American Church. 10 The impact of secularisation on the Indians, however, admits no easy assessment. Despite Rubio's assertions that his diocese possessed an abundance of candidates with knowledge of Indian languages, several parishes were in fact given to priests who could only preach in Castilian. Indeed, the archbishop himself protested privately to the crown that Viceroy Amarillas and his wife had both attempted to secure benefices for their chaplains, young men from the Peninsula, without more qualification than their social connections. The Franciscan provincial noted sourly that Rubio was also guilty of a similar offence. Neither the expedient of teaching future ordinands 'Mexican' nor the establishment of schools to teach Indians Spanish appears to have resolved this problem. Instead, bishops were driven to offering scholarships to attract Indians, usually recruited from the cacique class, into the seminaries, men
68
The religious orders
who were then destined to serve as assistants to parish priests or who were given benefices in the more isolated districts of the dioceses. One largely unexpected effect of secularisation was thus to accelerate the recruitment of Indians into the ranks of the Mexican clergy, a social phenomenon which still awaits its historian. 11 II To measure the impact of secularisation on the religious orders, it is necessary to recall that the measure only affected the Augustinians, Dominicans, Observant Franciscans and, in certain marginal areas, the Jesuits. The remaining orders, which is to say, the Carmelites, Mercedarians and descalced Franciscans had never administered doctrinas in the central dioceses of New Spain. At the same time, the missionary orders differed considerably as regards their internal organisation. The Augustinians, for example, had been successful in preserving their unity, so that they consisted of only two provinces; Dulce Nombre de Jesus, which had priories and parishes all the way from Mexico City to Guatemala, and San Nicolas Tolentino de Michoacan, which extended northwards from Queretaro and Valladolid. By contrast, the Dominicans had separated into three provinces, Santiago de Mexico, San Miguel de Puebla and San Hipolito de Oaxaca, which each consisted of a large mother house and a circle of doctrinas and small priories. The Franciscans fell between these two models, since its mother province, Santo Evangelio, had preserved its unity in central New Spain covering the dioceses of Mexico, Puebla and Oaxaca. The Franciscans in Yucatan had always followed their own path since the days of spiritual conquest. It was in the north that fragmentation had occurred, when first the custodia of San Pedro y San Pablo de Michoacan became a province in 1603, followed thereafter by both the Guadalajara and Zacatecas custodias obtaining their independence. But whereas the Michoacan province possessed several large priories in addition to parishes, by contrast Santiago de Jalisco consisted of a large mother house in Guadalajara and a circuit of doctrinas and missions. The size and wealth of these provinces differed enormously. Whereas the Franciscans observed their rule and refrained from acquiring landed estates, their houses supported by parish fees, alms and chantry funds, by contrast both the Augustinians and the Dominicans derived a handsome income from their haciendas. As regards numbers, both Santo Evangelio and Dulce Nombre de Jesus provinces had over 700 members, whereas none of the Dominican provinces supported more than 250 friars. At their height, the Augustinians and Franciscans of Michoacan never recruited
Secularisation
69
more than 350 members and were soon to fall far below that peak. The northern Franciscan provinces were similar in size to their Dominican counterparts in the south. As soon as secularisation gathered momentum, the crown commanded all these provinces to cut their admission of novices and thereby reduce overall numbers. In 1771 visitors were appointed to inspect the orders so as to frame an appropriate schedule of recruitment and membership for each province, a task that was only completed by the end of the decade. Some measure of the scale of change can be obtained from the experience of the Franciscan province of Santo Evangelio which before 1749 had 88 priories and houses and 35 parishes served by 700 professed religious and another 140 lay brothers. By 1774 some 64 priories and 32 parishes had been lost and as early as 1765 numbers had fallen to 630 professed religious and 97 lay brothers. In Mexico City, the Franciscans still retained possession of their great convent which housed well over 100 friars, together with the priory at Santiago Tlatelolco and a house of recollection called San Cosme. But their Indian parish of San Jose, which they had administered since the first years of the conquest, was taken from them. The two parishes they retained, Texcoco and Toluca, each supported a considerable number of religious. In conformity with royal rescripts, the admission of novices was reduced, so that whereas formerly some 80 to 90 candidates had been professed every six years, in the same period after 1757 only 60 novices took their vows, although 134 members of the province had died. By 1792 the province only maintained sixteen priories, two parishes, and four houses of recollection; membership had fallen to about 600. Perhaps the most ominous statistic was that the 1792 census for Mexico City only counted eight novices resident in the province's central priory. On the other hand, Santo Evangelio maintained its traditional commitment to the missions in New Mexico and Tampico.12 The outlying, small Franciscan provinces did not suffer such immediate or drastic change as their central counterpart. In 1766, for example, the bishop of Yucatan obtained the crown's permission for the local Franciscans to retain the twenty parishes they administered, since the diocese lacked sufficient secular priests to replace them. So too, in 1775 the province of Jalisco was allowed to retain twelve parishes since it possessed but one large priory, situated in Guadalajara, which already housed some sixty-five friars. The remainder of the province was dispersed in groups of three to eight friars, serving both the parishes and mission stations in Narayit and Sonora. In 1784 the entire province only numbered 137 priests, 19 students and novices and 8 lay brothers. It was not until 1797 that the crown finally ordered the secularisation of their
70
The religious orders
doctrinas, leaving them with but two parishes, seven priories and their missions.13 The scale of the Jalisco province found an exact counterpart in Zacatecas, which in 1815 counted 125 priests, 15 students and 20 lay brothers, albeit by then almost entirely housed in urban priories situated in the leading towns of the north, ranging from Zacatecas and San Luis Potosi to Durango, Chihuahua and Monterrey.14 The degree to which the smaller provinces of mendicant friars had come to consist of little more than a central priory and a circle of parishes can best be observed in the Dominican Order which had divided into three provinces, Santiago of Mexico, San Miguel of Puebla and San Hipolito of Oaxaca. According to the visitation of these provinces conducted in 1778, some years after the secularisation had stripped them of many parishes, the Santiago province had declined from 230 friars in the 1750s to 184 members, of whom 144 were priests, and the remainder students, and novices and lay brothers. The degree of urban concentration was very high, since no less than eighty-five religious resided in the famous 'convento imperial' in Mexico City, flanked by another twenty-one in the college of Porta Coeli and ten more in a house of recollection. The remainder of the friars were to be found in two Indian parishes and a scatter of small priories situated in such northern cities as Queretaro, Guadalajara and Zacatecas. Much the same situation prevailed in San Miguel de Puebla, where some ninety-five religious resided in the city divided between the main priory, the college of San Luis and a house of recollection. The remaining twenty friars served two Indian parishes and a small priory in Veracruz.15 By far the most interesting Dominican province was San Hipolito of Oaxaca, which in 1778 numbered 144 friars divided between the 68 priests, students and lay brothers in the Santo Domingo priory in Oaxaca and the remainder who served no less than 21 parishes, scattered in groups of 3 to 4 friars, with only the priory at Yanhuitlan housing the minimum 8 members required by the crown. When news of the secularisation rescript reached Oaxaca, the current provincial protested vigorously, referring to 'the misery and poverty in which this unfortunate province finds itself . . . this miserable province is without doubt about to witness its total extinction'. After explaining that the Dominicans in Oaxaca were entirely geared to serving their doctrinas> he asked permission to retain ten parishes in addition to Yanhuitlan and Tlaxiaco, which had already been granted.16 His petition was strongly supported by the current bishop of Oaxaca, Miguel Alvarez de Abreu, a prelate educated by Dominicans in the Canary Islands, who recalled the glorious history of the province in penetrating the isolated mountain valleys of Oaxaca, where they had built churches and converted the
Secularisation
71
Indians. In the city, they also proved their worth, preaching, confessing and visiting gaols and hospitals. In their priory, they educated a great number of Indian boys, teaching them Spanish and how to read, write and count, so that when they returned to their villages they were in a position to act as intermediaries between the friars and the peasantry. In the seminary they taught the doctrine of St Thomas and had taken the place of the expelled Jesuits in providing instruction in Latin. The Dominicans were the only religious order to maintain a novitiate in the city, taking in local men and educating them for service in the several languages spoken in the diocese.17 If the province were to lose its parishes, it would no longer be able to maintain its great priory of Santo Domingo with its magnificent church and ninety-one cells. It was not merely admiration for the Dominicans that impelled the bishop to support their appeal; he simply lacked a sufficient number of secular priests to replace them. As he explained, his diocese had 135 parishes and 335 priests, of whom only 181 were 'fit for the ministry'. In his seminary, 'most of those who study are poor, content with what this diocese offers, since the most they can hope for is a parish, which from the foundation of this church until the present they have obtained by means of an Indian language and stumbling Latin, so that hardly do they finish philosophy than they retire to study a language and abandon letters'. The quality of candidates for the priesthood was poor and included both mestizos and badly educated Indians. The life they had to face was difficult and only a few were able to survive the isolation and the climate of the remote parishes. By contrast the Dominicans trained their priests for this ministry and could always bring them back to the central priory either for retirement or for respite. It was in deference to this argument that in 1781 the crown allowed the Dominicans in Oaxaca to retain twelve parishes.18 Ill Nowhere in New Spain was the impact of secularisation more pronounced than in the diocese of Michoacan. Prior to the rescript of 1753 the Franciscans administered thirty-five doctrinas and the Augustinians the equivalent of twenty-nine parishes. Since a visitation of 1761 only listed 114 parishes in the diocese, it is clear that the two orders which dominated the region's missionary history still continued to exercise a preponderant role until the crown's intervention changed the balance of power in favour of the secular clergy. Moreover, whereas many priories in central Mexico were situated in Indian villages which had declined in importance, by contrast in the Michoacan diocese former
72
The religious orders
frontier missions had become thriving towns surrounded by wealthy agricultural estates. Here too, a clear difference in the reactions to secularisation can be observed. By and large, the Franciscans accepted the changes, albeit not without profound regret in having to abandon time-hallowed churches, and thereafter moved to open new priories situated in the towns, especially in the Bajio. By contrast, the Augustinians fought a determined campaign to retain their leading priories, a determination strengthened by the bishops' attempt to expropriate the rich haciendas that were owned by these houses. So intense was the conflict that eventually the case had to be settled by the Council of the Indies; and as such offered an exemplary instance of the balance of power within the ecclesiastical and civil structures of the Spanish state in Mexico. At the time of secularisation the Augustinian province of San Nicolas Tolentino possessed eleven urban priories and eleven doctrinas, the latter so large as to be the equivalent of twenty-nine parishes. Some 103 religious worked in these doctrinas, men who accounted for 40 per cent of the province's membership, but about half of its ordained priests. 19 Although its centre of operations was the diocese of Michoacan, it possessed priories in Queretaro, Guadalajara and Durango, all of which fell under separate episcopal jurisdictions. The first steps at secularisation occurred in 1753 when Bishop Martin de Elizacoechea commanded that the doctrinas of Vango and Etucuaro be occupied. Since the prelate proved hesitant in applying the law, in 1754 Viceroy Revillagigedo wrote a peremptory letter, ordering the immediate occupation of all churches and priories situated in Indian lands, adding 'it is most necessary to consider that all these priories were founded without the licence of the king and against the laws of the Indies'. It was this demand that prompted Elizacoechea to command the occupation of the magnificent priory of Yuririapundaro, whose great church still ranks among the glories of Mexican sixteenth-century architecture. But when the newly named parish priest, Lie. Francisco Antonio de Eguia, entered his domain in February 1754 he encountered only a few sparse records dealing with the spiritual endowment of the church, so that he was obliged to maintain the established practice of celebrating sung masses on Wednesdays and Saturdays without receiving the customary stipend. Only after repeated complaints did the Augustinian provincial send him 3,000 ps. by way of recompense. But what was at issue here was the fate of the vast hacienda of San Nicolas, situated within the limits of the doctrina of Yuririapundaro, with a chapel which counted as a vicariate of the parish. For this property, which was later to be valued at 500,000 ps., was the favoured residence of the 'absolute ministers' - the Augustinian
Secularisation
73
provincials - and figured as the jewel in the crown of the province of San Nicolas Tolentino.20 It was at this stage that the new bishop, Anselmo Sanchez de Tagle (1758-72), a former inquisitor and bishop of Durango, entered the fray, not merely to hasten the process of secularisation, but also to command the sequestration of the haciendas owned by the occupied priories. Thus, for example, the estates attached to the doctrinas of Charo and Ucareo, which yielded an estimated income of 16,463 ps., were expropriated, and their profits divided equally between the parishes and the religious. Much the same happened at Patzcuaro and other parishes. But the chief prize here was the great hacienda of San Nicolas, situated in the most fertile lands of the Bajio. It was to defend their inheritance that the Augustinians now mobilised their great wealth and their social connections to preserve possession of their priories and their haciendas. The keyfigurehere was Nicolas de Ochoa, a native of Celaya who, after being named administrator of the San Nicolas in 1746, had devoted his life to its development and defence. Indeed, when he served as provincial, in 1758-62 and 1766-70, he remained in residence on the estate. His influence within the province was consolidated by the close alliance he formed with Luis de Ortega, a Spaniard brought to Guadalajara at the age of four, who also served as provincial in alternate quadrennia during this period.21 The case presented by the Augustinians was by no means ill-founded. They argued that the Yuriria priory had been blessed by royal licence and had always functioned as a regular priory with more than the minimum number of eight religious. It had served the local population, offering alms and medicine in addition to spiritual ministrations. Yet now its magnificent cloisters, which were fit for twelve religious, had been rented 'to plebeian people and for artisan crafts, which they inhabit with their women, making do with straw and planks of wood'. Even in their hacienda of San Nicolas a secular chaplain had been installed. These protests carried weight in Mexico City and in 1761 viceroy the marquis of Cruillas (1760-6) accepted the counsel of the royalfiscal,Jose Antonio Velarde, and ordered that the priory and its church should be returned to the Augustinians. After all, one of the chief aims of secularisation was to concentrate the religious in their urban priories, among which Yuriria undoubtedly figured. To superintend the transfer, a Creole judge of the high court, Felix Malo, was despatched to Michoacan, where he not merely returned Yuriria to the friars and re-sited the parish church of San Nicolas beyond the limits of the hacienda, but also ordered the restitution of the haciendas of Charo and Ucareo. It was during this visit that Malo also found himself a wife, a young heiress of the Bajio.22
74
The religious orders
At this point, accusations began to fly and both sides to the dispute sought to mobilise their connections. For Sanchez de Tagle, a scion of a noble family of Santillana del Mar with several wealthy relatives in New Spain, was 'a colegial of Salamanca', which is to say, he had attended the influential colegio mayor in that university, a breeding ground of jurists and prelates. He thus wrote letters to the marquis of Aranda, a minister of the crown, who had attended this college; to 'my colegial Santelices', a member of the Council of the Indies; and also to 'my compatriot Trespalacios', a judge who was soon to join that body. 23 What most provoked his ire was that the Augustinians had organised public celebrations to acclaim the restitution of Yuriria, both in that town and even in their priory at Valladolid, with 'fireworks, rockets, bells and masses of thanksgiving'. At Yuriria itself, the secular priest was given but a day to remove himself and his belongings from the church, obliging him thus to establish his parish centre in the chapel belonging to the local hospital. Then 'for the greater celebration of their triumph, they held four comedies in the ante-chamber and bull-fighting in the interior courtyard of the priory, in the presence of many persons of both sexes'. So also, in the hacienda of San Nicolas the agents who negotiated the case in Mexico were received by the provincial 'with arches, songs, paseos, bull-fights and fireworks'. All these reports led Sanchez de Tagle to complain that 'his person, dignity and sacred immunity' had been wounded by these indecorous proceedings. 24 Although Viceroy Cruillas rejected Sanchez de Tagle's allegations, arguing that he had sought simply to apply the 1757 rescript which had ordered the return of all priories which housed at least eight religious, he failed to stem the prelate's flood of complaints, even when he asserted that the bishop was guilty of seeking to question 'the jurisdiction and powers of the Royal Patron'. Not a whit abashed, in 1766, Sanchez de Tagle wrote a series of letters in which he claimed that Cruillas had fallen under the influence first of Joaquin de Rivadeneira, a Creole judge in the high court, and then of the fiscal Velarde. But the key figure in all this was Francisco Javier de Gamboa, an alcalde del crimen, who had written a lengthy paper on the whole affair favouring the Augustinians. Sanchez de Tagle denounced Gamboa as 'an individual entirely addicted to the province', who had been responsible for framing the petitions which had secured the royal rescripts ordering the return of the haciendas, adding that 'he enjoyed a great correspondence and intimacy with the Reverend Father Absolute Minister, Fray Jose de Ochoa, by reason of having an uncle, his mother's brother, in this Order'. Another high official who favoured the friars was Jose Rodriguez Gallardo, the chief accountant of tributes who, since he married a close relative of Ochoa, had acted as a
Secularisation
75
lawyer for the province. As for Felix Malo, his support for the province had been 'increased by the gifts with which they courted him during his commission'. What is fascinating about Sanchez de Tagle's charges is that he singled out a group of high-placed Creole judges and officials who were soon to be accused of conspiring against the visitor general, Jose de Galvez, especially after the expulsion of the Jesuits. Indeed, Gamboa was despatched to Spain for his enmity towards the future Minister of the Indies.25 In effect, we here encounter two circuits of power and influence: Sanchez de Tagle relying on his colegiales and compatriots and the friars on their Creole lawyers and judges. If the Augustinians succeeded in retaining both their priory at Yuriria and their haciendas, they were obliged to abandon their doctrinas, keeping only Cuitzeo and Tiripitio, each of which possessed two subordinate vicariates and hence covered a large territory. Sanchez de Tagle and his immediate successors continued to protest and in 1773 elicited a rescript from Madrid ordering the Augustinians to submit their land titles. It was at this point that the province despatched Lucas Zenteno, one of their most brilliant members, to Madrid, advancing 28,000 ps. to cover his costs. Finally, in July 1781 the case was heard in a plenary session of all three courts of the Council of the Indies, which after considering the mass of evidence concluded that the bishop of Michoacan had been within his rights to occupy Yuriria and that the rescript of 1761, restoring the priory to the Augustinians, had been issued on the basis of false evidence. The priory and its church were thus once more returned to the secular clergy. So also, the parishes of Cuitzeo and Tiripitio were stripped of their vicariates which emerged as the four parishes of Undameo, Copandaro, Chucandiro and Santa Maria de Gracia. A judge of the Mexican high court was appointed to implement this decision, the actual transfer occurring in 1783.26 While the case was being heard in Madrid, Fr. Lucas Zenteno had negotiated terms with the current bishop of Michoacan, Juan Ignacio de la Rocha, according to which the Augustinians would cede Tiripitio in return for Yuriria; but this exchange was interrupted by the death of the bishop and the decision of the Council of the Indies.27 The story ended in 1802 when, with the viceroy's approbation and the bishop's concurrence, the Augustinians once more entered Yuriria, ceding Tiripitio as Zenteno had suggested. Thus the province succeeded in preserving a wealthy and attractive enclave in the southern Bajio, which included the adjacent parishes of Cuitzeo and Yuriria and the extensive hacienda of San Nicolas. Just what was the outcome as regards the claims over the remaining haciendas once owned by the province is not at all clear.28 While litigation raged, the province was subjected to a visitation in
76
The religious orders
1
773-4 designed to reform its observance of the rule and to reduce the number of friars. The visitation was heralded by a missive from the Augustinian father general, Fr. Pedro Vasquez, a Peruvian by birth, who revealed his Jansenist colours when he wrote: This holy doctrine we should seek in the only true sources of the Holy Scriptures, Divine traditions, the Holy Fathers and the authority of the church in its living teachings and councils, but not in any way in the great folios of Aristotelian theology, in which one learns and is taught (as unfortunately happened to me) to despise venerable authority so as to allow one's understanding full liberty to think, judge, discuss and decide, each according to his whim. The result of this unbridling is that the Catholic world finds itself inundated with a flood of opinions which conspire to obscure the most clear truths of Christian doctrine. Unimpressed by this missive, the provincial and his masters of theology stoutly reaffirmed their loyalty to the teachings of St Augustine and St Thomas Aquinas, the traditional doctors of their school. Indeed, their agent in Madrid had already warned them of the servility of the Spanish hierarchy and its willingness to countenance the pretensions of the crown to intervene in questions of church discipline and doctrine. 29 In 1776 the province of San Nicolas Tolentino reported that it maintained 12 priories in which resided 205 priests, 42 professed students, 14 novices and 13 lay brothers, the bulk of whom resided in Queretaro, Valladolid and Guadalajara. At this time there still were 66 priests working in the 11 parishes that had yet to be secularised. But the decrees of the visitation, issued in 1778, commanded that the province should be restricted to 170 members, thus necessitating a reduction in the number of novices. When 73 friars died during the fevers and infections of 1784-6, the overall membership fell to 158, thereby opening the way to recruit further novices. In 1802 the province counted 129 priests, 48 students, 12 novices and 16 lay brothers, which was to say, a total of 205 compared to 274 thirty years before. 30 For the Franciscan province of San Pedro y San Pablo the threat of secularisation was by no means a novelty, since their doctrina at Queretaro had been a bone of contention since the late seventeenth century. Like other settlements in the Bajio, Queretaro had been founded as an Indian pueblo, only then to receive such an increment of Spanish and casta householders that in 1656 it was recognised by the crown as a city. To further their pretensions, the secular clergy formed the Congregation of Our Lady of Guadalupe, which in 1671 erected a handsome church. Indeed, in 1705 the crown issued a rescript ordering the secularisation of the Franciscan parish, only to encounter such strenuous protests from both the city council and religious that it
Secularisation
77
rescinded the decree. So strong was local sentiment that when news of the 1749 secularisation arrived, the city council despatched a long memorial to the crown, supported by testimonials from other religious communities, in which the Franciscans were hailed as 'a holy religion which initiated the spiritual conquest of this place and of all the kingdom', concluding that 'if temporal conquest creates rights, how much more so does spiritual conquest'. They paid tribute to the weekly sermons and the daily ministrations of the friars who maintained no less than seventeen priests to handle the central parish and its five assistant churches in the suburbs of San Sebastian and Espiritu Santo and three neighbouring Indian pueblos of La Caftada, San Francisco and Huichiapan. During Lent special sermons were provided and up to twelve religious were available to hear confessions. The conventual infirmary also served the sick of the city and during times of plague and famine the friars sallied forth to minister to the sick and dying. As for the priory, it housed over fifty religious, including lecturers and students, and offered special facilities for learning Otomi, the native language spoken in the city and its district. As a house of studies, it figured as 'the womb of the province where the members who distinguish it are born'. Despite this eulogy, when the incumbent died in 1757, a secular priest was entrusted with the parish. But in this case, Viceroy Amarillas had the wisdom to avoid conflict by providing for the construction of a new parish church, thereby allowing the Franciscans to retain their church and priory, together with all the chantry funds on which their maintenance depended.31 Prior to secularisation, the Franciscans had three large priories at Queretaro, Valladolid and Celaya, and another fifty-three houses of which only seventeen counted as guardianias, priories with votes in the election of officers. Numbers reached their peak in 1755 when the province counted 326 religious, of whom about half lived scattered in groups of 2 to 4 priests, administering at least 35 doctrinas. Both Queretaro and Valladolid acted as novitiates and Celaya maintained a college which prepared students for degrees granted by the University of Mexico, one of four such institutions in the diocese of Michoacan. With the onslaught of secularisation, numbers fell and houses were closed so that by 1772 the province only numbered 239 friars including novices and lay brothers.32 However, their exclusion from the rural ministry drove the Franciscans to open new priories in the prosperous, growing urban centres of the Bajio. In 1766 a local landowner provided the means for constructing a priory in Irapuato and in 1791-3 funds were forthcoming for priories to be opened at Silao, Guanajuato and Zamora. At the same time, the province retained the two parishes of Acambaro and San Juan
78
The religious orders
de la Vega, both extensive districts, which were operated by teams of religious.33 Although the Franciscans did not offer any strenuous resistance to secularisation, at times the anguish caused by the enforced necessity of abandoning time-hallowed cloisters was clearly expressed. When the incumbent at Tzintzuntzan died in 1762, the provincial lamented that his Order's 'most venerable fathers' had been buried in its church which also conserved Various other pious and tender monuments'. The priory was cherished 'through having been the glorious cradle of this province and where our first holy founders thrived with such distinguished virtues'. So too, the city council petitioned the viceroy, noting that they had been converted by the friars soon after the conquest of Mexico by Cortes. When the secular priest arrived to take possession of the church and priory there was a public protest by a group of women and some young men. But none of these laments impressed Bishop Sanchez de Tagle, who drily noted that the Indians of Tzintzuntzan were too poor to support two churches in their 'city'. The protest had been organised by misguided friends of the friars and did not represent the common opinion. As for the remains of the holy founders, perhaps their bones could be exhumed and transferred to the priory at Patzcuaro. The prelates of the Bourbon epoch were not responsive to sentiments evoked by historical associations.34 Elsewhere, the Franciscans struggled to retain the priories and churches where they could maintain a sufficient number of religious. Thus at Celaya, where the bishop sought to sequester their church for use by the secular parish, a royal rescript of 1785 allowed the Franciscans to keep the church along with its famous image of La Purisima and its attendant confraternity. The college and priory here were in part supported by income raised in the nearby parish of San Juan de la Vega. Much the same concessions were made in Salvatierra, where secularisation entailed the construction of a new parish church at an estimated cost of 100,000 ps. 35 At Zitacuaro, when the incumbent died in 1759, Sanchez de Tagle gave the Franciscans but one day in which to convey their priory, church and its ornaments to the secular clergy. Since the province usually maintained ten friars in the town, including two priests with knowledge of Otomi, the local guardian appealed to the viceroy, arguing that the crown had provided that priories of this size should not be occupied, adding 'I believe that the intention is to extinguish this province'. Although the viceroy commanded that the priory and church be returned to the Franciscans, the bishop demurred, protesting that the town could not afford the cost of building a new parish church, and only allowed them back into their priory in 1770. It was not until 1785, after
Secularisation
79
another series of appeals, that the Franciscans regained possession of their church together with the image of La Purisima, which had been brought to New Spain in 1543. This image figured as the patron saint of Zitacuaro and was supported by a leading confraternity. The parish priest marvelled that the Franciscans should wish to keep their priory, since it was so old-fashioned in style, consisting of 'old walls, so that even to enter them fills one with melancholy'.36 IV In 1805 a royal rescript was despatched to the bishops of Mexico repeating admonitions already expressed in 1797 about the excessive number of personal secularisations obtained in Rome by religious resident in America. Instead of halting the number of friars seeking to be released from their vows, the previous decree had been ignored and the number of personal secularisations 'has been seen to increase to a scandalous degree5. There was thus a real danger that entire priories would be depopulated. Moreover, many of these petitions came from missionaries whose passage to America had been financed by the crown. The archbishop of Mexico in 1803 had also complained of'the excessive number of secularised religious'. It was to stem this tide that the crown now stipulated that the Spanish minister resident in Rome should henceforth confirm all papal breves granting secularisation and that bishops in America should not accept papal licences unless they carried the minister's stamp of approval.37 In 1804 the prior of the Carmelite priory in San Luis Potosi informed the bishop of Michoacan that one friar resident in the city had already been secularised and that any day papal breves would arrive liberating another five religious from their vows. The grounds for such applications can be ascertained in the case of a Carmelite of this priory, of whom a fellow friar testified in 1798: 'I have noted and known the tedium and horror with which he views the penalties and rigour of religion, as well as the distaste and oppression with which he assists and remains in the choir.' Many of these secularised friars had friends and patrons in the city who created chantry funds for them, thereby providing an annuity for their subsistence. The prior complained of seeing one of his former subjects riding about on horseback, a spectacle which provoked the envy of those remaining in the priory. He concluded gloomily: 'If your Lordship does not deign to devise remedies, within a few years this holy Province of San Alberto will see its end.'38 The problem was by no means peculiar to the Carmelites, since in 1804 Rome released from their vows five Franciscans who belonged to
80
The religious orders
the Michoacan province; and in 1806 another three friars made their exit.39 No complete record of individual secularisations has been found, but all the evidence suggests that the religious orders in New Spain suffered a crisis of vocation at the beginning of the nineteenth century. In 1805 the province of San Pedro y San Pablo only had three students taking theology, a mere handful compared to previous decades. Testimony from the reformed or descalced branch of the Franciscans confirms the impression of decline, since in 1790 their provincial desperately pleaded for friars to be sent from Spain, since whereas at one time the province of San Diego had numbered about 400 religious, now it only had 204 members. But although his plea brought forty-nine friars from the Peninsula, by 1814 numbers remained low and many religious were by then elderly and ill. Moreover, 'for about fourteen years now no novices have presented themselves for the province'.40 Equally important, in the Michoacan diocese, both the Franciscans and the Augustinians were engulfed in bitter internecine disputes in which devoted religious attempted in vain to challenge vested interests and to halt the slide into laxity. In the case of the Augustinians, the possession of the wealthy hacienda of San Nicolas was always bound to be a source of contention and indeed partisan conflict over elections to high office proved so fierce that first the viceroy and high court and then the Council of the Indies and the Holy See were obliged to review the proceedings.41 Although the Franciscans appeared to react more positively to the challenge of secularisation, opening new priories in Zamora, Irapuato and Guanajuato, nevertheless, they also suffered dissension, especially when friars from Spain, who had been sent to work in the missions of Rio Verde, sought to enter the province and thus qualify for election under the rules of the alternativa. By this time many of the Spanish friars were poorly educated and lax in discipline, characteristics which rendered their appointment to high office all the more contentious.42 Despite their central role in the religious history of New Spain, the religious orders still await their historian. Only when the internal records of each province have been scrutinised will it be possible for even a preliminary judgement about the degree to which they continued to observe their rule during the Bourbon period. At present, all we possess are mere strands of evidence which suggest that the secularisation of the doctrinas deprived the religious of that pastoral ministry which had attracted many zealous candidates into their ranks. At the same time, the change in the climate of opinion as regards the utility of a contemplative existence, to which the Bourbon bureaucracy offered so clear a testimony, equally contributed to the decline in vocations. By the beginning
Secularisation
81
of the nineteenth century, the mendicant provinces exhibited clear signs of internal decay and thus were ripe for reform. From this general trend, however, the colleges de propagandafideappear to have been exempt, continuing to attract both missionaries from Spain and Creole friars whose discipline and enthusiasm still attracted the devotion of the laity.
Nuns
In December 1769 Archbishop Lorenzana circulated a printed pastoral in which he sharply criticised the nunneries of Mexico City. It was not the case that the nuns stood accused of any heinous offences or gross immorality, but simply that for every professed nun there were at least two other women living in the convents, consisting of servants, young girls and even ageing widows, many of whom came and went according to their whim, so that conventual seclusion was regularly interrupted. The cause of this disorder was the arrangement whereby each nun had her own kitchen, depending on a servant to cook for her and to purchase or bring in food supplied by relatives. It was to remedy this state of affairs that Lorenzana demanded the introduction of 'the common life', according to which nuns would henceforth eat together in the refectory. He forbade the entrance of novices who did not subscribe to the new regime. But since all the great convents of the capital, apart from the Carmelites and Capuchinas who observed an austere rule, had maintained the system of separate kitchens and cells from time immemorial, they turned to their wealthy relatives and presented a printed protest supported by the city council, the university and merchant guild, in which, led by the Concepcion and Jesus Maria, they complained that 'the method of common life does not agree with the weak and delicate natures of this country'. Nevertheless, both Lorenzana and Bishop Fuero of Puebla persisted in their campaign. When the matter was considered by the Council of the Indies, the result was a royal rescript of May 1774 which affirmed that no one was to be obliged to abandon individual catering. But it supported the prelates in stipulating that henceforth all novices had to enter the common life, and in demanding that all young girls and other supernumerary females were to be expelled from the conventual precincts.1 The goal of the common life was thus clearly set down as the ideal. It was in Puebla that resistance to the reform was strongest and where 82
Nuns
83
the bishops were most adamant in pursuing their objective. The reason why the crown found it necessary to intervene can be found in the vehement protests of nuns in the Santa Ines convent which, by February 1772, had been effectively divided into two separate institutions each with their own patio, albeit sharing the same church. Forty nuns persisted in clinging to their old way and thirty had adopted the common life. The recalcitrant party appealed to the high court in Mexico complaining that the bishop sought to transform their rule, converting them into recoletas similar to the Carmelites and Capuchinas, thereby introducing 'a new religion'. Moreover, the bishop wished them to destroy the individual cells which their fathers had purchased for them, an outrage to 'a community of ladies, of well-born, religious women'. Fearing a public disturbance, since 'the nuns are generally related to leading families', the high court referred the matter to Viceroy Bucareli, who wrote to Bishop Fuero for an explanation, reminding him that 'the anger of women is more to be feared than that of men'. But Fuero responded indignantly, claiming that when he arrived in Puebla he had found that each convent 'cell' was 'a community of women of all conditions', with servants, girls and other women coming and going and even staying on long visits. Since every nun managed her own purse there were great differences in the community, 'some rich nuns and others poor, some with their own cells and others without anything, reduced to begging for a place in which to live'. As was to be expected in these circumstances, it was generally the wealthy nuns who managed the convents and obtained election to its administrative offices. Finally, he noted that when he first called for the introduction of the common life, all five convents in Puebla had agreed to the change, but that Santa Ines had retained individual cells and servants, causing twenty-one of its nuns to appeal to him for help in bringing in reform. If the affair had caused public agitation it was because one of the leaders of the recalcitrant party in Santa Ines was a sister of the high court judge, Antonio Joaquin de Rivadeneira, who 'with great determination and astuteness promotes the resistance'.2 Although Fuero was recalled to Spain, becoming archbishop of Valencia, his successor at Puebla, Victoriano Lopez, continued to harry the nuns who resisted reform. Owing to the intensity of protest, the new archbishop of Mexico, Alonso Nuflez de Haro, was commissioned to inquire and if possible to mediate. He indignantly informed Bucareli that 'among the infidels they would not have done what these spouses of Jesus Christ have suffered. I am perplexed and I do what I can to diminish the outrages perpetrated by Fuero and those which the new bishop has increased by the enforcement of his commands.' He found that nuns had
84
The religious orders
been threatened with damnation and denied absolution in confessions, even when ill, unless they accepted the changes. Yet in the Santa Ines only twelve nuns in a community of fifty-one wanted the common life, and in San Jeronimo the convent was divided into two equal parties. Lopez had displayed little prudence in his handling of the affair and 'it is fully proven that the common life was introduced with violence'. 3 Haro forwarded a letter to the viceroy, written by a nun of the Santa Caterina, who recalled that when Fuero first demanded reform he had claimed that it was a mortal sin for the nuns to oppose him. When the prioress agreed to accept his demands he immediately arrived with eight workers and destroyed two dormitories, sixteen cells and four rooms of the infirmary. He then ordered all the young girls to leave the cells within twenty-four hours and left the convent only seventy-nine servants to cater to all their needs. Moreover, he forbade the nuns to converse with secular persons, even their own relatives, so that 'there would be no one who would visit us, as if we were born from the weeds'. He also reformed their constitution and forbade them to take communion other than on the days expressly signalised in their rule. The result was that some nuns had not been to confession for over six months and that others could not find the money to feed themselves properly. The informant concluded: we once were 'a friendly sisterhood', but now 'are as in hell', with the new bishop coming only to threaten and reprimand them for their resistance. But Lopez remained adamant, insisting that before the reform the nuns had used their income to help their relatives and that 'each one lives as in her own house, eating when she wants, according to the hours her appetite suggests'. They often spent a great deal of time cooking sweets, which they then sold, and several rarely attended the choir. 4 A satire circulated at this time, written by Jorge Mas Theophoro, an obvious pseudonym, which provided an amusing sketch of a conversation between a father confessor and a nun, with the former inquiring: 'How do you feel? Are you in good health? How did you pass the night?', to which the nun replied: 'I felt very poorly, since the fleas woke me, the dogs barked and the cats frightened me.' He praised the bishops for enforcing the canons of the Council of Trent and criticised the confessors who encouraged the nuns to resist the reform. But what renders the piece fascinating is the reference to the rumours and false opinions that were said to be circulating in New Spain about 'the persecution of priests, the new taxes, the expulsion of the Jesuits, and the subjection of the nuns'. In the secular sphere there was much complaint about the establishment of the royal tobacco monopoly and the stationing in Mexico of regiments of soldiers recruited in the Peninsula. More generally, it was rumoured that 'Jansenism has taken possession of
Nuns
85
the mitres, of the crown, and is very close to the papal tiara.' The author prudently deplored all these rumours, attributing them to the Jesuits and their doctrines of 'probabilism'.5 Since even the mention of such matters was viewed with alarm, the Council of the Indies ordered that all copies of this pamphlet should be impounded. Despite the rescript of 1774 which forbade the bishops to force any nun to accept the common life, it is clear that those who resisted were treated harshly. As late as 1778 five nuns from separate convents, who claimed to represent 124 of their sisters, appealed first to the Minister of the Indies, Jose de Galvez, and then to Rome, complaining that their rule had been overturned, that girls had been thrown on to the streets and that all the positions of authority in their communities were now occupied by those who had accepted the bishop's demands, so that they were exposed to persecution. The Concepcion noted that ten cells and seventeen bedrooms had been destroyed in order to build a novitiate. In the same year, Viceroy Bucareli confessed that, of all the problems that had arisen during his term of government, the uproar in the convents of Puebla had been the most difficult and the most painful, since by forming parties within each community Fuero and Lopez had created bitter enemies between nuns, so that the dispute went on and on without any foreseeable resolution. In Mexico City the reform had been handled more prudently and without strife, although it had meant that the Concepcion no longer took any novices, since it preferred to maintain individual catering. In August 1780 the crown forbade any further appeals but reiterated its warning against compulsion.6 When the terms of the rescript of 1774 were communicated to the nuns of Santa Clara at Queretaro they consulted with the Franciscan provincial of Michoacan and on his advice agreed to expel all the young girls who boarded with them. As regards domestic service, it was agreed that each nun should have a personal servant and that the convent should maintain another eighteen women to do the general cleaning and another ten to help with the habitually ill nuns. In 1775 the community discussed the archbishop's request that they introduce the common life and then voted unanimously to retain the existing system of individual kitchens. By way of justification they pointed to the practical difficulties of purchasing and preparing food for a community which by then had ninety-five members. In effect, the Santa Clara numbered among the largest and wealthiest convents in New Spain.7 Somewhat earlier, in 1748-63, a dispute between the Franciscan provincial and the convent's general administrator had revealed that it enjoyed an annual income of about 44,000 ps. which, at the standard 5 per cent interest, derived from a capital of 880,000 ps. Since all nuns were expected to put up a dowry
86
The religious orders
of at least 2,000 ps. to cover their living costs, the endowment of the existing community came close to 200,000 ps. Many nuns came from wealthy families who also purchased 'cells' for their daughters within the convent, one such property going for 2,000 ps. in 1764.8 It was not until 1778 that the Santa Clara was able to admit new novices, who now agreed to observe the common life. II At the beginning of the eighteenth century the diocese of Michoacan possessed but one nunnery, the Santa Caterina de Sena of Valladolid, founded in 1590 from the Dominican convent of the same name in Puebla. As an institution it was overshadowed by the Santa Clara at Queretaro, which drew candidates from across the Bajio. However, its location in a cathedral city meant that it attracted the patronage of both canons and bishops. In particular, Bishop Escalona advanced funds to complete their new convent, an event celebrated with maximum pomp in 1747, when the entire city turned out to celebrate the procession of nuns from their old residence to the splendid new edifice, an event commemorated in a painting still preserved in the city museum. When Bishop Hoyos y Mier informed the prioress of the crown's 1774 rescript about 'the common life', the convent unanimously agreed to adopt the reform. By then the community numbered seventy-one nuns, including five novices and seven lay sisters. In her letter of acceptance the prioress noted that the conventual buildings were very large and that many of the cells on the ground floor were very damp, so that many nuns suffered poor health and, indeed, 'with difficulty does one find anyone who does not suffer from some illness'. Nor did the infirmary help, since its rooms were so damp that it aggravated illness and the sick preferred to avoid it. To compound the problem, the convent's income from its endowment was insufficient to cover costs, and on two separate occasions in recent years it had been necessary to eat into capital in order to pay for clothing. If costs were high, it was because each nun needed a servant to clean her cell, wash clothes and tend her in case of illness. Several nuns were habitually ill and needed two servants. To administer the infirmary, the bakery, the porter's lodge, to sound the bells, to clean the choir and cloister, to light the lanterns, to sew and clean the sacristy vestments and to assist the prioress another 40 mozas were required. The bishop accepted this list of necessary staff, but ordered the expulsion of all young girls and other women who had lodged in the convent. He also took the opportunity to insist on a few trifling 'reforms', such as, that the mother sacristan should not converse with the priests as they took chocolate after
Nuns
87
celebrating mass, and that servants should not join the nuns in choir. More important, he commanded the prioress to obtain a secret report on all candidates for the novitiate to ascertain their character, morals, legitimacy and limpieza, which was to say, their ethnic status as Spaniards.9 Finally, he advised the prioress to see that not too many tallow candles were burnt in the choir, since they were apt to give the nuns headaches. The decision to adopt the common life, which entailed the establishment of a conventual kitchen and refectory, proved to be neither popular nor economical and in January 1788 the community voted to return to la vida particular.10 Although the Santa Caterina possessed a capital endowment of 315,511 ps., by 1782 some 69,000 ps. had been either lost or tied up in litigation over estates embargoed for debt. Accounts for the years 1777-8 registered an annual income of 17,614 ps., which was barely sufficient to cover the costs of food, clothing and church expenses. It is fascinating to observe that the community consumed 2,364 sheep (carneros) a year, which meant that each individual, including nuns and servants, ate about 12 sheep a year. By 1788 the mayordomo, Gabriel Garcia de Obeso, a leading merchant of Valladolid, reported that the convent owed him over 10,000 ps. on supplies received. It was this growing debt that caused the bishop to approve of the community's decision to abandon collective catering.11 Henceforth each nun received 3% ps. a week to feed herself, a system which immediately reduced overall costs. In these last years of the eighteenth century, the Santa Caterina suffered a decline in numbers. In 1801 the prioress requested the bishop to rescind Rocha's edict that dowries should be increased from 2,000 ps. to 4,000 ps. since, whereas in 1783 the community had comprised seventy-seven religious, it now only had fifty-two. But the downward drift continued, with the result that a greater proportion of nuns were elderly or infirm. Whereas in 1797 there were forty-two nuns with a vote and eight excluded, by 1812 only twenty-nine nuns voted, with thirteen excluded because of their incapacity.12 It was in 1747 that eight nuns set out from the Santa Caterina to establish a new convent in Patzcuaro, founded under the double advocation of Santa Caterina de Sena and Nuestra Seflora de la Salud. The funds had come from Pedro Antonio de Ibarra, a local merchant, who had donated 55,000 ps. imposed on three haciendas. Other citizens also offered monies. According to the accounts of 1786-90 the convent received an annual income of 9,802 ps., the equivalent of an endowment worth 196,000 ps.13 By then the numbers had grown since, in the 1775 chapter summoned to elect a prioress, there were thirty-nine nuns with a
88
The religious orders
vote, and another five novices and recent professed. When in the same year the bishop inquired about their decision as to the common life, the community agreed to adopt the reform. In her letter, the prioress noted that the convent was composed 'of a multitude of small houses and apartments which are dispersed over a large space of ground which is enclosed to form a cloister'. There were no dormitories and no common buildings since the community did not have any funds with which to erect such buildings. Since all the religious lived in dispersed cells they each needed a woman to clean, wash and cook and accompany them at night. Moreover, twelve nuns were gravely ill, of whom three were demented, so that another fourteen women were required to care for them. What with the demands of the bakery, the porter's lodge, the lighting and cleaning, the convent needed another thirty-one staff in addition to forty-three personal servants. It should be noted that the community did not possess their own church but used the adjoining sanctuary of Nuestra Seftora de la Salud, employing six poor girls to sound the bells. Attendance at church was a problem for elderly or infirm nuns owing to 'the slopes, lanes and unevenness of the ground of the convent', so that their women had to help them. The bishop reluctantly allowed the community to retain its large staff but demanded that the prioress should strictly regulate the entrance of all secular women into the convent precinct. 14 The most impressive of new foundations in the diocese came in 1756 when the crown accepted Bishop Elizacoechea's recommendation that a convent dedicated to the Purisima Conception should be established in San Miguel el Grande. The initiative had come from Maria Josefina Luisa de la Canal, a young heiress who, at the age of sixteen, had decided to employ her inheritance of 70,000 ps. for the construction of a convent. In supporting this proposal, the cura of San Miguel noted that her father, Manuel de la Canal, whose wealth was matched only by his religious zeal, had hoped to set up a convent of Capuchinas, an Order which observed an austere rule of life. His daughter preferred to follow the Concepcionist rule, bringing nuns from the Regina Coeli convent in Mexico City as founders, albeit insisting that they should not employ servants and should share a common kitchen and refectory. The project envisaged a community of seventy-two nuns, each with a dowry of 3,000 ps. The benefits of such a convent were expounded by the father superior of the Oratory who pointed to the example of Santa Clara in Queretaro, exclaiming: 'examine in the commerce of that city how many parts of its great capital the merchants manage, how great are its deposits, properties, livestock and houses, with all these operations derived from the fountain or bank of silver of that single convent'. It would be a great consolation for the leading families of the town to have their daughters
Nuns
89 15
who wished to become nuns living so close. Nor were these hopes disappointed, since in 1765, when the community walked in triumphant procession to take possession of its church and convent, it numbered twenty-one professed nuns and six novices and lay sisters. However, donations had been less than expected, so that the endowment was still only 95,200 ps. which yielded an income of 4,710 ps. as against expenses of 5*350 ps., the convent depending on its mayordomo and other benefactors to cover its deficit.16 During his visitation, conducted in 1765-6, Dr Jeronimo Lopez Llergo provided an account of the life of these nuns. In good weather they rose at 5 a.m. and at 5.30 were in the choir where half an hour of prayer was followed by Prime, the first office of the day. In the season of heat they rose at 4.30 so as to begin their prayers at 5 a.m. Breakfast followed. They reassembled in church for community mass and at 8 sang the three lesser hours of the Divine Office which, however, on feastdays were included with Prime. On Saturdays mass was followed by benediction and the litany sung in procession around the cloister. They took a refection followed by half an hour in the workroom and a quarter of an hour of spiritual reading. At 11 they devoted fifteen minutes to an examination of conscience and at 11.30 had lunch in the refectory where they listened to spiritual reading. After giving thanks in the choir they rested until 2 p.m. when it was time for Vespers, the Magnificat, the commemoration of San Miguel, the Salve Regina, the rosary with litany and prayers for patrons. They then took chocolate, went to the workroom for thirty minutes and, once finished, rested. At 6 they sang Matins, the Magnificat, had fifteen minutes of private prayer, fifteen minutes of examination of conscience. At 8 they returned to the refectory for supper with spiritual reading, and at 9 received the blessing of their abbess and, after brief prayers, retired to bed. On feast-days this schedule varied somewhat.17 When Bishop Hoyos inquired about their reactions to the royal rescript commanding observance of the common life, the abbess replied that they had always followed this rule, 'eating together in a common refectory and resting in the same way in a dormitory and in some other cells'. They did not employ any servants but relied on a number of lay sisters. They had twelve young girls who lived separately, whom they were educating and who did not join the religious either in the choir or at recreation. It should be noted that all nuns had to present certificates of legitimacy and oflimpieza, a provision that prevented the admission of all mestizas and mulattas.18 In 1782 a new abbess was elected and she soon wrote to the bishop complaining of the torment of the accounts, since the convent did not
90
The religious orders
possess sufficient capital and hence always had expenses greater than its income. The problem here was in the years 1752-61 the cost of constructing the convent and its church had come to 106,178 ps., of which 58,000 ps. was taken from the inheritance of Maria Josefina de la Canal and the remainder supplied by Francisco de Landeta, count of the Casa de Loja, her guardian and first patron of the convent. But the cost of construction meant that the nuns had to subsist on the interest from their dowries, together with a small number of donated endowments. If the convent survived it was because its mayordomo, Jose Maria Loreto de la Canal, the brother of the foundress, handled all the necessary purchase of supplies and set aside on his own hacienda a herd of sheep to supply mutton at a fixed rate. In 1782 the convent owed its mayordomo 19,000 ps. By then the community numbered thirty professed nuns, together with nine lay sisters and another eighteen donadas, lay women who effectively acted as servants.19 By 1790-1 the convent at San Miguel was sinking ever deeper into debt. Its income was 5,845 ps., but expenses came to 7,496 ps., leaving the mayordomo to find 1,651 ps., so that the total debt owed to de la Canal then stood at 39,134 ps. Although the convent's endowment had risen to 148,500 ps., part of this capital was tied up in lawsuits and no less than 1,690 ps. of annual interest had not been paid. So acute was the crisis that Bishop San Miguel commissioned his trusted lieutenant, Manuel Abad y Queipo, to conduct a visitation, charging him to ascertain whether it would be advisable for the Purisima Conception to follow the example of the Santa Caterina in Valladolid and 'many other convents of this kingdom' and abandon the common life, giving each nun a fixed weekly amount for subsistence. This arrangement was to be installed until 'they manage to set about putting their income in a state sufficient to support the greater costs of a rigorous common life'. In April 1792 Abad y Queipo suspended the common life and ordered that each nun should receive 2V2 ps. a week. The pipes which supplied each cell with fresh water were to be cut, leaving four fountains in each corner of the upper patio. Although in 1794 the new mayordomo, Narciso Mariano de la Canal, who had inherited the post from his father, reported that income now matched expenses, three years later he noted that the total debt had risen to 42,181 ps. Moreover, by 1800 it was necessary to raise the weekly allowance to 4 ps., owing to the general increase in prices.20 If the common life proved so costly it was in part because the nuns had abused the kitchen, arranging for meals to be sent out for relatives and feeding the poor who thronged at the porter's lodge. It is perhaps of some interest to note that a community of forty-six women and a few children
Nuns
91
should have consumed 100 pounds of cacao, 250 pounds of sugar and 89 sheep each month. On the other hand, the introduction of individual kitchens meant that the nuns now required servants, some of whom lodged in the convent but many of whom came and went each day, so that the cloisters were now disturbed by 'the multitude of servants that there are in the convent'. Papers and letters from friends and relatives flowed in and out without the abbess being able to invigilate this correspondence. By this time there were only twelve surviving donadas, women who, by reason of their ethnic calidad as mulattas, could not be admitted to 'the lay profession of the white veil'. In 1798 the abbess requested the bishop for permission to allow such women to be professed as lay sisters on their deathbeds as a reward for their faithful service. A licence was granted, with the provision that such women should not be buried with the rest of the community, thus ensuring that even in the grave ethnic distinctions were maintained.21 The insufficiency of the original capital endowment meant that the Purisima Concepcion was never properly completed in the eighteenth century. In 1801 Antonio Velasquez, a trained architect, inspected the building and found 'various cracks, infiltrations of rain water' and the danger that the vaulting over the porteria might fall. The cura of San Miguel, Dr Ignacio Antonio Palacios, agreed that the patio leaked but thought it was only the porter's lodge that stood in any danger. He pointed out that the upper cloister had been finished thanks to donations from the current bishop, Antonio de San Miguel. But the church had never been completed since, although it was designed as a cross, only the choir and altar area had been made ready in 1765 when the nuns took possession, leaving the nave to be closed by an adobe wall only sixteen feet high, the remaining space filled by curtains.22 With the outbreak of the Insurgency of 1810 the Purisima Concepcion was threatened with destruction. Although its capital by then amounted to 159,400 ps., the devastation wrought by civil war meant that the great part of its income was no longer paid since, in the years 1813—17, the convent only received an average of 1,463 ps. a year. Its mayordomo, Narciso Loreto de la Canal, had died after being accused of complicity in the rebellion. If the convent survived, it was because the current cura of San Miguel, Dr Francisco Uraga, subscribed 3,559 ps. every year to maintain the community of thirty-two nuns and fourteen donadas.23 Ill Whereas most nuns in Mexico belonged to orders which had allowed the strict rule of their foundation to be modified by the social expectations of
92
The religious orders
the creole elite, by contrast the relatively small number of religious who opted for the Carmelites and the Capuchinas embraced an austere form of life. But if the disciples of Santa Teresa had arrived in Mexico and Puebla in 1604-16, it was not until 1665 that the Capuchinas, who followed the rule of St Clare without relaxation, arrived in New Spain. 24 In 1721, a group of nuns set out from Mexico City to found the Capuchin convent of San Jose de Gracia in Queretaro, a community which by 1784 numbered thirty-eight nuns, supported by an income of 3,297 ps., the annual deficit of 1,486 ps. covered by the mayordomo. 25 The spiritual reputation of this convent was attested at the funeral in 1792 of the former abbess, Mother Maria Ignacia, who was saluted by Fray Francisco Frias y Olivera, an Augustinian friar, as 'a sacrament of love', adding that 'the same indwelling of persons which one sees in the Sacred Eucharist, one also sees in Ignacia'. Tormented by spiritual dryness for eighteen years, she had suffered attacks from the Devil, ate only four ounces of food a day and was merciless to her mortified flesh, at times planting 'many crosses on the ground with her tongue'. She had written an account of her spiritual life and devotions. The preacher concluded that 'she always maintained an immaculate life, dying with the grace she received in holy baptism'. This sermon, which was printed at the expense of Manuel Rincon Gallardo, a wealthy landowner of Aguascalientes, eventually fell under the scrutiny of the Inquisition, which ordered it be withdrawn from circulation and its author censured, only to find that he had died fourteen years before.26 From the same convent there survives a spiritual autobiography written by Mother Maria Marcela in 1793, in which the author recounts how, after seven years of initial rapture, she suffered both persecution from her companions and an inability to pray, a stage which lasted for many years until she finally attained a sense of peace, assured that the Trinity dwelt within her. The daughter of a wealthy landowner, she recalled that at one point a nun working with her in the sacristy, 'did not treat me as a companion but simply as if I were an Indian'. No doubt she echoed many another religious' plaint when she exclaimed: 'I say in truth that my neighbours are my cross.' Counselled by wise confessors, she found the peace she sought and ended her days in 'a fixed and simple sight before God'. 27 In 1798 seven Capuchin nuns left Queretaro in two carriages, accompanied by the ubiquitous Manuel Abad y Queipo, and after passing the night at a hacienda, arrived the next morning at Salvatierra, where they were welcomed by the town council and all the clergy both secular and religious. After stopping off at the Carmelite beateria, they walked in public procession to take possession of their new convent and
Nuns
93
church, named after the Purisima Conception, where the guardian of the college of Santa Cruz celebrated mass and preached the sermon lauding this new Franciscan foundation. The genesis of this convent had been protracted, since a royal licence had been issued as early as 1767 to Santiago Gines de Parada, who had offered 35,000 ps. for its construction. It was not until the count of Jalpa intervened to take charge of the venture that the cloisters and church were actually built. But he quarrelled with the abbess of the Capuchinas in Queretaro, accusing the community of drinking chocolate and indulging in undue comfort when ill so that only eight or ten nuns actually attended office in choir, the rest parading their infirmities. His object in levelling these accusations was to obtain a contingent of nuns from the Capuchin convent in Lagos and the