A SOQAL HISTORY OF
\ translated from the Frehch;.by;;f '
A
%^;;'^
:
\ ROBERT BALDICK-
,-
v^:jj^||;;.
;
This bri...
67 downloads
612 Views
35MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
A SOQAL HISTORY OF
\ translated from the Frehch;.by;;f '
A
%^;;'^
:
\ ROBERT BALDICK-
,-
v^:jj^||;;.
;
This brilliantly imaginative and seminal book offers an fntire! of manners. It tells '-K(^^esjfe new contribution to the hijstory
man's notions abopt chilidhood and family
and developed from the Middle Ages
life
to
have
modern
cjferigeij tintes.
· .~
The The Times Times Literllf'Y Literary SUPPl.em!mt (London), Supplement (London),
reviewing the French French edition of Centuries edition of Centuries of reviewing the of Childhood Childhood in in 1960, called it it "a "a most most valuable valuable 1960, called and and important contribution ... its its insights important contribution... insights open new doors for intellectual excitement new doors for intellectual excitement open and and curiosity." curiosity." The theme book is theme of of this this extraordinary extraordinary book is the of the modem conception the emergence of the modern of emergence conception of family life and and the the modem modern image of the the nanafamily life image of ture of childhood ture of of children. children. The discovery discovery of childhood as of life, M. Aries shows, a distinct as a distinct phase of Aries is life, shows, is phase aa recent recent event. event. Until Until the the end end of of the the Middle Middle Ages, the child child was, almost as as soon soon as he was as he was was, almost Ages, the weaned, as a small adult, who minas a small minweaned, regarded adult, regarded gled, and played with worked, and gled, competed, competed, worked, played with mature mature adults. adults. Only did parents Only gradually gradually did parents begin of adults to encourage the separation begin to encourage the separation of adults and children, and a new family attitude, and a orichildren, family attitude, oriented ented around around the the child child and and his his education, education, appeared. appeared. M. Aries Aries traces traces this this metamorphosis through metamorphosis through the paintings the and diaries of four diaries of four centuries, the centuries, the paintings ~nd history of of games games and and skills, skills, and and the the developdevelophistory of schools schools and their curricula. curricula. Ironiment of and their Ironically, he finds that individualism, far from from he finds that individualism, far cally, triumphing in our time, has been held in in our has been held in time, triumphing check check by by the the family family and and that that the the increasing increasing power of of the the tightly tightly knit knit family family circle circle has has power been been gained gained at at the the expense expense of of the the open, open, richrichtextured communal society society of of earlier earlier times. times. textured But But if if the the emphasis emphasis on on the the child child and and the the home has has meant meant aa loss loss of of social social diversity, diversity, itit has has also also a provided a means for to escape the unmeans for men to the unprovided escape bearable bearable solitude solitude of of modern modem life. life. Though Centuries Centuries of of Childhood Childhood deals deals pripriThough marily with with the the family, family, the the child, child, and and the the marily school school in in pre-nineteenth-century pre-nineteenth-century France France and and England, itit isis undoubtedly undoubtedly destined destined to to have have England, (continued on on back backflap) fl4p) (continued JACKET DESIGN DESIGN BY BY ANITA ANITA KARL KARL JACKET
11/62 11/62
CENTURIES OF OF CHILDHOOD CHILDHOOD CENTURIES
;-AT
311974
o:,r
\
PHILIPPE ARIES
0F CENTURIES OF
CHILDHOOD Social History History of of A Social Family Life Life Family Translated from from the the French French by by ROBERT BALDICK
Translated
New Alfred A. A. Knopf York: Alfred New York: Knopf 62 19 1962
Translated from from the the French French Translated la Ilk familiak sous SfJUJ Vancien I'andm la
L'Et!fant et tt L'Enfant
viefamiliale
,.gime
regime
© 1960 1960 by ~ Librairie Librairie Plon, PIon, Paris Paris English version (S) 1962 1962 by by Jonathan Jonathan Cape Cape Ltd Ltd English version
PRINTIID PRINTED IN BRITAIN IN CRIIAT GREAT BIUTAiN
39':<'.3
A b 9c.
CONTENTS
99
mITRODUCTION INTRODUCTION
CHILDHOOD
PART ONE: THE IDEA OF CHILDHOOD I I o H m ra IV IV V
LIFE THE AGES OF LIFE THE DISCOVERY OF CHILDHOOD
IS 15 33 33
SO CHILDREN'S DRESS 50 mSTORY OF GAMES AND PASTIMES 62 A MODEST CONTRIBUTION TO THE HISTORY 100 IOO FROM IMMODESTY TO INNOCENCE CONCLUSION: THE TWO CONCEPTS OF CHILDHOOD 128 128 PART TWO:
SCHOLASTIC LIFE
MEDIEVAL SCHOLARS YOUNG AND OLD A NEW INSTITUTION: THE COLLEGE
137 137
01 III
THE ORIGINS OF THE SCHOOL CLASS
IV
THE PUPIL'S AGE THE PROGRESS OF DISCIPLINE FROM DAY-SCHOOL TO BOARDING-SCHOOL THE''LITTLE LITTLE SCHOOLS' THE THE ROUGHNESS OF SCHOOLCHILDREN CONCLUSION: SCHOOL AND THE DURATION OF cmLDHOOD CHILDHOOD
176 176 89 1 l8p
II II n
V VI VI VII vii V1ll VIH
ISS 155
241 241
269 269 286 I S 3315
329 329
PART THREE: THE FAMILY II II II
PICTURES OF THE FAMILY CONCLUSION: THE FAMILY AND SOCIABILITY
339 365 365 405 405
CONCLUSION
4II 411
NOTES
19 4419
INDEX
441
FROM THE MEDIEVAL FAMILY TO THE MODERN FAMILY
ILLUSTRATIONS THE CHILDREN OF HENRI-LOUIS HENRI-LOUIS HABERT DE MONTMORT
by Philippe Philippe de Reims Museum. Museum. (Photo de Champaigne, Bulloz.) (Photo Bulloz.) Champaigne, Reims by C£ Part I, Chap. III. Analysed by B. Dorival in the Catalogue Catalogue B. III. Dorival in the Cf. Part I, Chap. Analysed by of Philippe de Champaigne Exhibition Exhibition at at the the Orangerie, de Champaigne of the the Philippe Orangerie, Paris, 1952, No. 33 facing page page 64 No. Paris, 64 1952, 33 facing THE DUG DUC D'ANJOU D'ANJOU:AS AS A CIDLD CHILD by Arnoult. Cf. Part I, Chap. Part Arnoult. Cf. I, Chap. by
III, and 3 n. 3 and n.
65 65
Ill,
THIEVES THE THIEVES
by thieving beggar-boys beggar-boys Callot. Typical Typical thieving by Caliot.
65 65
BURGOMASTER MAYER AND HIS IDS FAMILY
by Holbein, Dresden. (Photo Alinari-Giraudon.) C£ Part I, Cf. Part Holbein, Dresden. by (Photo Alinari-Giraudon.) Chap. III; Part III, Chap. I, and n. 14 and n. Part III, Ill; 14 Chap. Chap. I,
I,
96 96
A GAME OF CHUCKS
by S. Leclerc, from figures contenant tous les les jeux, 1587. contenant tons from Trente-six Trente-six figures S. Leclerc, jeux, 1587. by C£ III, and n. 18; and Chap. IV and and n. Part I, IV Cf. Part I, Chap. HI, 18; Chap. Chap. IDS CHILD THE CRAFTSMAN AND HIS by Lagniei, from Les Proverbes. Proverbes. Note Note the the from Les by Lagniet,
97 97
little playpen playpen supporting supporting
little
97 97
the child the child THE VAN BERGHEM FAMILY, FAMILY, 1561 1561
by F. Floris. (Photo Bulloz.) Cf. Cf. Part I, Chap. Chap. IV; IV; Part Part III, Part I, F. Floris. III, (Photo Bulloz.) by Chap. I, and 23. Typical portrait showing a little and n. n. 23. little family portrait showing a Chap. I, Typical family 160 concert during dessert dessert 160 concert during THE TAVERN
by Lagniet. Lagniet. Little children are to be be seen here too, too, despite the evil Little children are to seen here evil by despite the haunts. C£ Part III, II, and and n. reputation of n. 47 of these these haunts. Cf. Part III, Chap. 47 reputation Chap. II,
161 161
AN EVENING BY THE FIRE FIRE
by treated as as aa scene Stella. An allegory scene of family life. family life. by Stella. (winter) treated allegory (winter) III, Chap. I, and n. 31 Cf. Part Cf. Part III, Chap. I, and n. 31
161
THE WEDDING PROCESSION Stella. C£ Cf. Part by III, Chap. and n. n. Part III, by Stella. Chap. I, and I,
40 40
192 192
GRACE
by Stradan. many such pictures dating dating from the sevenStradan. One of many such pictures the sevenby a teenth century, child III, Chap. teenth century, showing a child saying grace. Cf. Part Cf. Part I III, Chap. I showing saying grace.
192 192
ILLUSTR4'fIONS ILLUSTRATIONS
77
BLIND BUFF and BLIND MAN'S BUFF and THE PAPER PAPER GAME
from Les Les Heures Heures de fa Duchesse Duchesse de de Bourgogne, Bourgogne, Chantilly from de la Chantilly Museum. (Photos Giraudon.) Cf. Part I, Chap. IV, and n. II Museum. Part Cf. and n. n I, (Photos Giraudon.) Chap. IV,
Details Details
facing page page 193 193 facing A CLASS CLASS
by de Pas. Plate from Academia sine vita scho/astica, by Crispin Crispin de Pas. Plate from Academia sine vita scholastic^ Amheim, 1602. C£ Part II, Chap. Chap. III 1602. Cf. Ill Part II, Arnheim,
256 256
SETTING OFF FOR SCHOOL SETTING OFF
by Crispin de Pas. The The Parents Parents are are shown entrusting their boy to to de Pas. shown entrusting their boy by Crispin hand'. The The latter aa preceptor preceptor or to an or rather rather to an 'old is being given a 'old hand'. latter is being given a is taking some money of his his chicken, and the boy's father is and father out of some the chicken, taking money out boy's purse. In the background other schoolboys can be seen already on can In other be seen the schoolboys background already on purse. II, Chap. V and VI 256 their way. Cf. Part and VI their way. Cf. Part II, Chap. 256 A SCHOOL SIGN
(above): An evening for adults, adults. (below): school for (below): A evening school (above): Basle Museum. (Photos Basle little school for children. little school for children. Basle (Photos Basle Museum.) Museum.) C£ VII, and n. 331I 257 and n. Cf. Part Part II, II, Chap. 257 Chap. VII,
by Holbein, Holbein. by
THE MASTER SCRIBE'S SCRIBE*S CLASS CLASS
Note the the age the pupils, pupils, who are wearing swords. of the swords. C£ Cf. Part Part II, Note are wearing II, age of Chap. VII, and 28 and n. n. 28 Chap. VII,
288 288
cmLD PLAYING WITH YOUNG VALET CHILD
by From Les Les Proverbes. Proverbes. Showing which the familiarity by Lagniet. familiarity which Lagniet. Showing the existed between children children and servants. Cf. C£ Part existed between Part I, and servants. I, Chap. V; Chap. V; II 289 Part III, III, Chap. Part II 289 Chap. THE STEPS OF THE AGES OF LIFE LIFE
C£ Cf. Part Part I, I, Chap. Chap. II
289 289
THE FEAST OF ST NICHOLAS
by J. J. Steen, Amsterdam. (Photo Steen, Rijksmuseum. by (Photo HanfstaenglHanfstaenglRijksmuseum, Amsterdam. III, Chap. I, and n. 43 352 Giraudon.) C£ Part n. 43 352 Giraudon.) Cf. Part III, Chap. I, THE CARD-PLAYERS Children playing by Nain. (Photo playing games games of Le Nain. Giraudon.) Children by Le (Photo Giraudon.) chance. Cf. Cf. Part Chap. IV 353 chance. Part I. I, Chap. 353
THE ROYAL FAMILY
by Nocret, Nocret, by
Versailles Museum. Museum. (Photo (Photo Giraudon.) Giraudon.) Cf. C£ Part Part I, I,
Versailles
88
ILLUSTRATIONS ILLUSTRATIONS
CHILD'S TOMB CHILD'S TOMB
Reproduced Chap. II C Part Part I, I, Chap. II Reproduced by by Gaignia-es. Gaigniires. c£
facing page 384 facing page 384
ANTOON ANTOON ANSBLMB ANSELME AND AND IUS HIS FAMILY FAMILY
Brussels. Chap. I, and n. 5; Part III, Brussels. (photo Cf. Part Part I, I, Chap. I, and n. 5; Part III, (Photo Bulloz.) Bulloz.) C£ 384 Chap. Chap. II 384 UTTLB LITTLE GIRL GIRL AT AT THE THE WINE-MERCHANT'S WINE-MERCHANT's Cf. Part Part m, C£ and u. n. 34 HI, Chap. I, and 34 Chap. I,
385 385
INTRODUCTION
T
HIS book book on on the the family family under under the the ancien regime is is not the work work of of ancien regime not the aa specialist specialist in that period, but of a demographic historian who. in that of a but historian who, period, demographic struck by the original characteristics characteristics of of the modern family, felt the struck by the original the modern family, felt the need to go back into into aa more to discover the limits of this need to more distant distant past go back past to discover the limits of this originality. I make it clear from the start that there there is is no no question I must must it make clear from the start that originality. question here examination of society under the ancien regime. II a gratuitous of a of here of examination under the ancien gratuitous society regime. have explained elsewhere!1 difficult it was for me clearly to distinguish have explained elsewhere how difficult it was for clearly to distinguish the characteristics of of our our living present, except by means of the differences the characteristics of the means differences living present, except by which separate separate them the related related but never identical aspects of which them from from the but never identical aspects of the the past. Similarly I can tell the particular nature of a period in the past from I can the nature of a tell in the from past. Similarly particular period past the degree to which it to resemble resemble our present. This to which the degree it fails fails to our present. This dialectic dialectic of of past. and present can be fairly safely neglected by historians of 'short .and of can be 'short historians past present fairly safely neglected by periods',l2 but it must be used in the study of manners and feelings whose periods', but it must be used in the study of manners and feelings whose variations extend period'. This the case the family. a 'long variations extend over over a This is is the case with with the family, 'long period*. with day-long, day-long, lifelong relations between parents and between parents with relations and between between lifelong parents parents and and children. children. But have have we any right to of the the family? Is the the family But talk of a history to talk of a family any right history of family? Is than instinct is? It is possible a phenomenon phenomenon any more subject to history a is to than instinct is? It any more history subject possible to it is is not, not, and maintain that that the the family partakes of to argue and to of the that it to maintain the argue that family partakes immobility of species. It It is no doubt true that that since since the the beginning of the the species. is no doubt true immobility beginning of the the human race have built built homes homes and begot children, children, and it of race men have and begot and it can be be argued that within the great family types, monogamous and and can that within the family monogamous argued great types, comparison polygamous, historical differences are of litde little importance in historical differences are of polygamous, importance in comparison with the the huge huge mass mass of of what what remains unchanged. with remains unchanged. On the the other hand, the great demographic revolution in in the the West, other hand, the great West, demographic revolution from the eighteenth to the has revealed to us us considerconsiderfrom the twentieth century, revealed to the twentieth century, has eighteenth to able possibilities of of change hitherto .believed to be be invariable able possibilities in structures structures hitherto believed to invariable change in because they biological. The adoption measures because were biological. they were contraceptive measures adoption of contraceptive has brought about about both both quantitative and qualitative in the has brought the changes in qualitative changes quantitative and family. However it it is is not not so so_ much the the family as a is our a reality that is our reality ~t family. However family as ~I!hl~ct her~~_t:he an idea. will always as an idea. Tiue, True, men and women will jhe family always family as subject here_as go o;toving one~er: Will always always go having children, children, whether whether another, will go on go on having loving one numbers or give free free rein rein to instinct, and will will always they limit limit their to instinct, or give their numbers they always go go on guiding not the steps of those children. That is is not the question question at children. That at the first first steps of those guiding the these relations issue. The point is that that the the ideas about these relations may may be issue. entertained about ideas pltertained be point is dissimilar dissimilar at by lengthy periods of time. time. It It is is the at moments separated the lengthy periods separated by
THIS
10 10
INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION
of the the family family which which concerns concerns us us here, here, not not the the of description of manners or the nature of law. the nature of kw. description of manners or In what what direction direction isis this this idea idea evolving? evolving? In For aa long long time time itit was was believed believed that that the the family f~..Y _constituted ~ ancient ~.9~t constituted the For bas~ Q( our soc;i~, and that, starting in the eighteenth century. the the basis of our society, and that, starting in the eighteenth century, The progress oflibera1 individualism had ~cn, an.d ~_eak~~ j1. The history individualism had shaken and weakened i$. history progress of liberal of die the family family in in the the nineteenth nineteenth and and twentieth twentieth centuries centuries was was supposed supposed to to of of be that of a decadence: the frequency of divorces and the weakening of be that of a decadence: the frequency of divorces and the weakening marital and and paternal paternal authority authority were were seen seen as as so so many many signs signs of of its its decline. decline. marital The study of modem demographic phenomena led me to a completely a led to The study of modern demographic phenomena completely contrary conclusiotl. It seemed to me (and (and qualified qualified observers observers have have come contrary conclusion. It seemed to 8 that on the to share my conclusions)' the contrary ~ .~y occupied a the to share my conclusions) that on family occupied a contrary had tremendous place in our industrial societ!~, and that it had perhaps and that it tremendous place in our industrial societies, perhaps never before before exercised exercised so so much much influence influence over over the the human condition. condition. The never legal weakening proved only that that the the idea idea (and (and the the reality) reality) did did not not follow follow legal weakening proved only the same curve as the institution. Is not this disparity between living ideas the same curve as the institution. Is not this disparity between living ideas idea and legal structures one of the characteristics of our civilization? The idea and legal structures one of the characteristics of our civilization? I then of the family appeared to be one of the great forces of our time. I then our time. of the family appeared to be one of the great forces of it went on to to wonder, not whether whether it was on on the decline, but but whether whether it the decline, it was went on wonder, not had ever been as strong before, and even whether it had been in existence in existence had ever been as strong before, and even whether it had been out to find out for time. I looked back into past, to find our into our back looked I accordingly time. a long for a past, accordingly long whether not been been born born comparatively had not the family of the idea of die idea whether the recendy, comparatively recendy, family had to at from both both biology itself from freed itself had freed the family time when when the at a a time biology and law to family had become an occasion of emotion. The aim of expression, a theme theme of become aa value, value, a expression, an occasion of emotion. the idea idea of of to this on the of the the modernity this question to is to to reply this' book book is of this' modernity of question reply the the faJnily. family. to But references to of the the past, in the the documents documents of to discover. was II to how was Bui how discover, in past, references far removed things which were too ordinary. too commonplace. too far too too too were which commonplace, ordinary, things from to mention mention writers to for contemporary incident for memorable incident the memorable from the contemporary writers has them? of the. modern demographic rev9lution has revolution the of Our experience them? Our demographic experience revealed of the child's in this We in this silen.t.history~ of the child's role role the importance us the to us revealed to sUemJiistary. importance the of childhood childhood and the know idea of the idea between the is a a connection connection between there is that there know that this connection also that connection idea We were entided to suppose that this also to entided were the family. idea of of the suppose family. of the existed and the help the one with with the and to to estimate estimate one distant past, in a a more more distant existed in help of past, other. going to study them together. them to are is why we are other. That That is together. study why going as a a man man a child child except In unable to to depict artists were were unable tenth century. In the the tenth except as depict a century, artists of childhood to on of childhood to come from from that that ignorance did we we come How did scale. How on aa smaller smaller scale. ignorance in the nineteenth the of the family around the child in the nineteenth century? around the child of the the centring family century? centring of the die How to aa parallel evolution of evolution correspond this evolution does this far does How far parallel evolution correspond to die towards concept people _have of the fat.nily. the feeling they entertain towards it, of the entertain it, feeling they family, concept people jiave history of the idea history of the idea
II INTRODUCTION II INTRODUCTION the value value they they attribute attribute to to it? it? It It will will be be no no surprise surprise to to the the reader reader if if these these the us to the very heart of the great problems of civilization. questions take of of the the to heart us civilization, take great problems very questions of biology biology and and sociology sociology from from for we we are are standing standing on on those those frontiers frontiers of for which mankind mankind derives derives its its hidden hidden strength. strength. whichi
PART ONE
THE IDEA OF CHILDHOOD
I THE AGES OF LIFE LIFE
X A
AN of sixteenth or the seventeenth seventeenth century be astonished of the the sixteenth or the :AN would be astonished century would at the the exigencies with regard to civil status to which submit at to with civil status to we submit which exigencies regard As soon as our children start to talk, teach them quite naturally. children them As soon as our start to teach we talk, quite naturally. proud their name, their age and and their their parents' parents' name. are extremely their age name. We are their name, extremely proud when little asked how old he is, replies correcdy that he is two and old he little Paul, is, replies Paul, asked correctly that he is two and
We
aa half. hal£ We feel fact that that it is aa matter matter of of importance importance that that little Paul feel in in fact it is little Paul should get this this right: what would become of him if he forgot his age? In become him if his what would of he should get right: forgot age? In is still obscure notion, something which is the bush, age African bush, still quite an the African age is quite an obscure notion, something which is not so important that that one one cannot our technical technical civilization, civilization, not so important it. But But in in our cannot forget forget it. ho'Y could anyone anyone forget forget the the exact exact date of his birth, when he he has has to to his birth, date of how could remember it for almost every application he makes, every document he he remember it for almost every application he makes, every document fills in in --and and heaven heaven knows there there are are enough enough of signs, every form he he fills of signs, every form those be more in in the the future. Little Paul Paul will will give give his his age there will will be those and and there future. Little age at will soon Paul - - - of of Form - and and when he he he will at school; soon become become Paul school; he job he he will will be be given, together with his Social Security card, starts his first first job his with Social starts his card, given, together Security aa registration will double his own name. name. At At the double his the same same which will registration number which time as being being Paul indeed rather than being being Paul Paul - - he he rather than Paul - - and indeed time as will be aa number, number, which which will will begin begin with with his sex, the the year of his birth, his sex, of his will be birth, year and month of year. A day day will will come when every will have have citizen will and the of that that year. the month every citizen his number. Our civic civic personality personality is is already more precisely his registration already precisely registration number. expressed by the co-ordinates of birth than than by by our of our time our birth our surname. In time the co-ordinates surname. In expressed by the latter might well not disappear but be be reserved reserved for private life, while well not the latter might for private life, while disappear but birth would be be one aa registration registration number the date in which the of the the date of of birth one of number in elements would take its place for civic purposes. In the Middle Ages the In for civic Middle take its the elements would Ages the place purposes. Christian had been been considered too imprecise imprecise aa description, and it had had and considered too it Christian name had description, a place with aa surname, many been found found necessary necessary to to complete it with in many been surname, a complete it place name in cases. it has become advisable to add further detail, the numerical add aa further the advisable to numerical has become cases. And now no wit detail, character, the the age. age. The Christian belongs to to the world of the the world of fancy, Christian name belongs character, fancy, the surname to to that of tradition. tradition. The age, a quantity legally measurable to a to measurable that of surname age, quantity legally another world, In within aa few few hours, hours, comes comes from another that of precise precise figures. In within world, that figures. our partake at of all worlds. the same time of all worlds. at the our day our registration registration practices practices partake day our There are, however, however, some acts acts which commit us to aa serious us to serious degree. There are, degree, call for for the which we draw up and which which do not not call the inscription which ourselves, and inscription up ourselves, different species, of our our date date of birth. Belonging Belonging to to very are of birth. species, some are very different IS 15
16 16
THE IDEA OF CHILDHOOD
commercial or cheques, cheques, and the others are bills of of exchange others are and the commercial documents, documents, bills exchange or wills. were all devised in ancient times, before the rigour of in But they all devised ancient were the wills. But before times, rigour of they modem identification identification had had been of life. life. The introduced into of been introduced into our modern our way way recording parish registers was imposed on the priests of France in parish of births births in recording of registers was imposed on the priests of France by I, but but to to be be respected, this order, which had already been Franois I, respected, this order, which had already been by Fran~ois prescribed by the authority of the councils, had to to be by people the had of the be accepted councils, authority accepted by people prescribed by who for for aa long time remained hostile to the rigour of abstract accounting. the remained hostile to time of abstract accounting. long rigour It is generally agreed that it was only in the eighteenth century that the It is generally agreed that it was only in the eighteenth century that the parish priests began keeping their registers with the exactness, or the parish priests began keeping their registers with the exactness, or the of its registrars. The attempted which aa modern state requires modern state exactness, which requires of its registrars. The attempted exactness, personal importance of the idea of age must have grown in proportion proportion have of must the idea of age grown in personal importance as religious and reformers imposed imposed it it in in documentary as religious and civic civic reformers form, documentary form, is to say, in the beginning with the more educated social strata, that that the with die more educated social is to in strata, say, beginning sixteenth those had a college education. had a those who education. sixteenth century, century, college In the the fifteenthfifteenth- and memoirs which have conand sixteenth-century conIn which II have sixteenth-century memoirs 1 it is sulted order to collect aa few few examples of the status of scholars,! in order of of it is sulted in to collect the status scholars, examples not uncommon to find at the beginning beginning of story the author's age or of the the story the author's not to find at the age or of birth. Sometimes indeed the age becomes an object his date date and of indeed and place birth. the becomes an his Sometimes age object place of attention. It is inscribed on portraits as an additional sign of of special special attention. It is inscribed on portraits as an additional sign of individualization, authenticity. On many many sixteenth-century and authenticity. exactness and individualization, exactness sixteenth-century - in his ..tEtatis suae 29 his twentytwentyportraits one may fmd inscriptions lIke find like suae one ALtatis 29 - in may inscriptions portraits ninth year year --with with the the date date of the painting painting ANON! (portrait by by ninth of the ANDNI 1551 1551 (portrait 2 2 On the Pourbus Jan Fernaguut, Fernaguut, Bruges). the portraits of famous people, of Jan of Pourbus of famous people, Bruges). portraits court portraits, this reference is be found; but it exists either on this reference is rarely to court portraits, rarely to be found but it exists either on canv.as or the old of family portraits, linked with family family the canvas or on old frame linked with the on the frame of family portraits, symbols. of the oldest examples is admirable portrait of of oldest is the admirable One the the portrait of examples symbols. Margaretha Eyck. the top: co(n)iux m(eu)s Joha(nn)es me me Van At the Eyck. top: co(n}iux m(eu)s Joha(nn)es Margaretha c(om)plevit Junii -- what what meticulous my husband meticulous accuracy: 1439, 17 Junii accuracy: my an(n)o 1439,17 c(om)plevit an(n)o painted on June 17th, 1439; and at the bottom: ..tEtas mea triginta mea me and the bottom: at JEtas triginta June lyth, 1439; painted trium aged thirty-three. Very often these sixteenth-century these often triutn an(n)orum sixteenth-century an(n)orum -aged thirty-three. Very portraits go in pairs: one for the wife, the other for the husband. Each portraits go in pairs: one for the wife, the other for the husband. Each portrait bears the same date, which is is accordingly accordingly given given twice t'Nice over over bears the same date, which portrait of both husband and wife: thus the pictures by together with the age two thus the the of both husband and wife: with pictures by together age Pourbus of Fernaguut and his wife Adrienne de bear the same de Buc the bear and of Jan his wife Pourbus Adrienne Jan Fernaguut the man's case and Anno domini with Altatis .lEtatis suae suae 29 29 in man's case indication: in the indication: Anno domini 1551, 1551, with 3 It sometimes happens too that the 19 in the woman's.s that the portraits too in It the woman's. sometimes 19 portraits of happens like husband painted together on the same canvas, like the the Van same and wife the husband and wife are are painted canvas, together Gindertaelens to Pourbus, Pourbus, depicted with their little their two with little Gindertaelens attributed attributed to depicted has one hand hand on his hip and is the other children. is resting the other on children. The husband husband has his hip resting his shoulder. The two children children are playing at their feet. feet. The date his wife's at their wife's shoulder. are playing date ;
17 17
THE AGES AGE~..OF LIFE
is the husband's is his his coat coat of with the aetas is 1559. husband's side side is arms with of arms the inscription 1559. On the inscription aetas an. 27, and on the wife's side, the coat of arms of her family and the an. 27, and on the wife's side, the coat of arms of her family and the inscription lEtatis mec. 20.' These particulars sometimes take on the inscription JEtatis mec. 20* These particulars sometimes take on the appearance real epigraphic formula, as on the portrait by Martin de of a a real appearance of epigraphic formula, as on the portrait by Martin de Voos which depicts Antoon Anselme, an Antwerp magistrate, dated 1572, Voos dated 1572, which depicts Antoon Anselme, an Antwerp magistrate, his wife wife and their two husband and and wife are sitting on his and their two children. children. 56 The The husband wife are sitting on opposite sides of table, one holding the the boy boy and the other other the of a a table, one holding the girl. and the opposite sides girl. Between their heads, heads, at and in the middle of the canvas, there is Between their at the the top top and in the middle of the canvas, there is aa fme scroll, carefully ornamented, bearing the following inscription: fine scroll, carefully ornamented, bearing the following inscription: cot/cordi ae antonii anton;; anselmi anselmi et johannae Hooftmans Hoofimans feliciq je/iciq: progagini, progagini, Martino Martino concordi ae et johannae de Vos pictore, DD natus natus est est We ann MDXXXVI die febr uxor de Vos pictore, ilk ann die IX febr uxor ann ann decembr liberi /iberi aa lEgidius ann Augusti MDLV D XVI decembr JEgidius ann MDLXXV XXI Augusti Johanna ann septembr. ann MDLXVI XXVI septembr. Johanna These portraits were documents history, as These dated dated family of family as documents of family portraits were family history, photograph were to to be be three three or centuries later. later. The same albums were or four four centuries same photograph albums spiri~ governed the family record books, in which, apart from the spirit governed the family record books, in which, apart from the household domestic events were noted noted down, down, births household accounts, and deaths. deaths. events were births and accounts, domestic the family came together. It Here regard for accuracy and the idea a regard Here a for accuracy and the idea of of the came together. It family was not not so so much aa question of the individual's co-ordinates as of those of of of individual's as of those the co-ordinates question the members of the family: felt aa need need to to give give famIly life aa history history the members of the family: people family life people felt by dating it. curious passion for dating appeared not only in portraits it. Tlus This curious for in not by dating only passion dating appeared portraits but also also in belongings and furniture. In the seventeenth but in personal and furniture. In the seventeenth century personal belongings century it habit to or paint a date beds, coffers, it became became a a common habit to carve carve or date on on beds, chests, coffers, chests, paint a cupboards, spoons and ceremonial glasses. date corresponded to aa and The date ceremonial cupboards, spoons glasses. corresponded to solemn the family's history, generally a marriage. In certain in the solemn moment in a In certain family's history, generally marriage. regions -- Alsace, Alsace, Switzerland, Central Europe Europe -- furniture and Central furniture Austria and Switzerland, Austria regions from to the the nineteenth and particularly painted the seventeenth and from the seventeenth to nineteenth century, century, particularly painted furniture, was dated dated and inscribed with the names of of its its and also also frequently names inscribed with the furniture, was frequently joint owners. In I have noticed this inscription on a chest: a I have this chest: owners. In Thun noticed Museum joint inscription 'Hans - 1709 - Elizabeth Misler'. Misler'. Sometimes Sometimes only the initials of initials of 'Hans Bischof Bischof1709 -Elizabeth only the husband and and wife wife were were inscribed on either either side date of the side of the date of the husband of the the date, inscribed on date, the marriage. very common in France, and and disappeared disappeared in France, This custom became very custom became marriage. This only at the end of the nineteenth century: thus an official of the Musee des an the Musec des thus official of at the end nineteenth of the only century: Arts et Traditions found a piece of furniture in the Upper furniture in the a Arts et found Traditions Populaires Upper piece Populaires Loire bearing the the inscription: 1873 ]V.66 The inscription inscription of ages of Loire bearing ages or of inscription: 1873 LT JV. to the desire the aa date portrait or or an helped to answer the desire to give the to answer date on a a portrait an object give object helped family historical consistency. family greater consistency. greater historical the middle taste for while lasting lasting into into the middle ofthe the The taste for chronological inscription, while chronological inscription, nineteenth century at least among people in average circumstances, rapidly in nineteenth at least among people average circumstances, rapidly century to disappeared and court, it was obviously considered in town and court, where it obviously considered early early on to disappeared in :
18 18
THE IDEA OF CHILDHOOD
be naive and provincial. From the middle ofthe seventeenth century, inscripbe naive and provincial. From the middle ofthe seventeenth century, inscriptions tended to disappear disappear from pictures (there were still a few to be found, from pictures tended to tions (there were still a few to be found, but only on on the the pictures pictures of working in or provinces). Fine Fine of painters in but only or for the provinces). for the painters working period furniture was signed, or, if it was dated, it was dated very discreetly. was if was furniture it it was dated or, dated, signed, very discreetly. period In of the importance which age had acquired in family epigraphy In spite spite of the importance which age had acquired in family epigraphy in the sixteenth in everyday usage remained in and usage sixteenth century, there remained in the custom and century, there everyday custom some curious survivals age when it was an and difficult an age of an it was an uncommon and difficult some curious survivals of thing to remember one's age exactly. I pointed out earlier that our little thing to remember one's age exactly. I pointed out earlier that our little Paul knows age as soon as he begins begins to to talk. talk. Sancho not as soon did not his age as he Paul knows his Panza did Sancho Panza how old his own daughter was, for all that he was extremely old his know exactly all he for that was was, extremely exactly daughter fond her: 'She may be be fifteen, two years years older older or younger, yet she of her: 'She may or two fond of or younger, fifteen, or yet she is as morning ... '77 This This is a case of of is as tall tall as as a a lance lance and and as as fresh fresh as as an an April is a case April morning aa man of the people. people. In In the even in the educated classes even in of the the sixteenth sixteenth century, the educated classes century, where habits habits of modem precision precision were were observed observed at earlier date, date, where of modern an earlier at an children age; but but an an extremely curious custom children doubtless doubtless knew their their age; curious custom extremely forbade them in in the name of good manners manners from it and the name of good from openly forbade them revealing it and openly revealing obliged them to answer questions about it with a certain reserve. them to answer When it with a about certain reserve. obliged questions the humanist and pedagogue Thomas Platter Platter tells the story story of of his his and pedagogue the Valais tells the Valais humanist life,e8 he he states great precision when and where he was born, yet and states with he was with great where life, born, yet precision considers himself obliged obliged to to wrap up the fact in prudent paraphrase: paraphrase: considers himself the fact in a a prudent wrap up 'To begin with, with, there is nothing vouch for for with with less less assurance than there is 'To begin can vouch assurance than nothing II can the exact date birth. it to to ask for the date date date of ask the the exact of my birth. When it occurred to to for occurred me my of my birth, birth, II was was told told that had come into the world in 1499, on of my that II had into the world in 1499, on Quinquagesima Sunday, just as tlle bells were ringing for Mass.' A Mass/ as die bells for were Quinquagesima Sunday, just ringing curious mixture of of uncertainty uncertainty and and precision. precision. This This reserve is an an habitual habitual reserve is curious mixture reserve, a souvenir of aa time time when nobody nobody ever ever knew aa date for certain. certain. souvenir of date for reserve, a What is is surprising surprising is that it have become become aa part part of manners, is that it should of good should have manners, good for this was was how one was supposed give one's one's age response to any to any in response for this one was to give age in supposed to inquiry. In Cordier's dialogues, two boys at school question each other each other In Cordier's at school inquiry. dialogues, boys question during the play-hour: old are are you?' 'Thirteen, so so II have have heard heard my during the play-hour: 'How old you?' 'Thirteen, my 99 mother say. say.'9 the habits of personal personal chronology chronology became became part part Even when the habits of mother of our way way of they did succeed in imposing themselves as aa themselves as of life, of our did not not succeed in imposing life, they positive attainment, and did not immediately dispel the old obscurity of old did the not obscurity of immediately dispel positive attainment, age, and the custom of obscuring one's age lingered on for time for some time the custom of one's age, obscuring age lingered in the observance of good good manners. manners. in the observance of *
. . .
* * * The''ages ages of life* life' occupy a considerable considerable place place in in the the pseudo-scientific pseudo-scientific The occupy a treatises of the the Middle Middle Ages. Ages. Their Their authors use aa terminology authors use terminology which
treatises
THE AGES( OF LIFE LIFE AGES^ ,
19 19
strikes us as verbal: childhood, puerility, adolescence, as purely strikes us childhood, puerility, adolescence, youth, purely verbal: youth, senility, old age -- each each word a different period of life. Since word signifying senility, old age signifying a different period of life. Since then have borrowed these words to denote borrowed some some of then we have of these ideas such words to denote abstract abstract ideas such as puerility or but these meanings were not contained in the first or senility, as puerility senility, but these meanings were not contained in the first The' ages', 'ages of life', or 'ages of man' corresponded in acceptations. acceptations. The 'ages', 'ages of life', or 'ages of man* corresponded in our ancestors' minds minds to to positive concepts, so well known, so often our ancestors' positive concepts, so well known, so often repeated and so commonplace that they passed from the realm of science repeated and so commonplace that they passed from the realm of science to that that of of everyday everyday experience. experience. It hard for for us us today today to the to is hard It is to appreciate appreciate the importance which the the concept of the' ages' had in ancient representations of the had in ancient 'ages' importance which representations concept of world. A man's man's 'age' was a scientific category of the same order the world. of the 'age' was a scientific category of die same order as or speed it formed as weight for our our contemporaries; of a formed part a system of weight or speed for part of system of contemporaries it physical description and explanation which went back to the Ionian which to and went back die Ionian description explanation physical philosophers of B.C., which compilers revived revived of the the sixth sixth century which medieval medieval compilers philosophers century B.C., in the writings of Byzantine Empire and which was still the writings of the and in the Byzantine which was still inspiring the Empire inspiring the first books of scientific vulgarization in the sixteenth century. first printed books of in the scientific sixteenth printed vulgarization century. ~ave no no intention trying to to determine formulation and W e have of trying its exact intention of determine its and We exact formulation its the history of science: all matters here is that should in the all that here its place in of that matters is that science we should history place realize to what what extent this science had become property, how realize to extent this science had become common property, 'far entered into mental habits and what it represented in it had entered and far its its concepts had into mental habits what concepts represented in everyday life. life. everyday We shall shall understand the problem better if if we glance glance through the 1556 understand the 1556 problem better dirough the 10 edition Le Gratld Proprihaire de utes choses. thirteenthof Le edition of Grand Propriltaire de to This was was aa thirteenthtoutes choses. 1o This century Latin compilation which itself itself repeated all the the data data of of the the writers writers century Latin repeated all compilation which of Empire. It was thought fit translate it into French and the Byzantine was to it French and of the It fit to translate into Byzantine Empire. thought to give give it circulation by means of printing. Le Grand Proprihaire to a greater circulation means of it a Le Grand by greater Proprittaire printing. de toutes is an encyclopedia, aa sort sort of Encyclopa:dia Britannica, Britannica, but but de an encyclopedia, of Encyclopaedia toutes choses choses is which is is not not analytical in concept and which attempts to render the in and which which to render the concept attempts analytical Nature and on physics, physics, metaphysics, metaphysics, essential unity of and God. essential unity of Nature God. A treatise treatise on natural history, history, human physiology physiology and and anatomy, hygiene, medicine and and hygiene, natural anatomy, medicine and astronomy, at the same time as theology. Twenty books deal with as deal widi the same time at books astronomy, theology. Twenty God, the angels, the elements, man and his body, diseases, the sky, the and the his the elements, God, the diseases, sky, the angels, body, weather, matter, air, water, fire, birds, etc. The last book is devoted to etc. last is devoted to book birds, fire, weather, matter, air, water, be found numbers and and measures. practical recipes recipes could also be could also in found in numbers measures. Certain Certain practical this book. book. A general idea emerged from it, a scientific idea which had a idea this from scientific which idea it, emerged general fundamental unity become extremely extremely commonplace, the idea of the the fundamental unity of of idea of become commonplace, the Nature, of the solidarity which exists between all the phenomena all exists between the of the which Nature, phenomena of solidarity Nature, phenomena which could not be distinguished from supernatural be not could which Nature, phenomena supernatural distinguished manifestations. The idea idea that that there there was was no opposition opposition between between the the natural natural manifestations. and the derived both from popular beliefs inherited from beliefs inherited the supernatural both from derived popular supernatural well as as paganism and from a science that was physical as well as theological. I that was from a science paganism physical theological. I ;
:
20
THE IDEA OF OP CHILDHOOD
am inclined the unity of Nature think that to think that this this rigorous concept of inclined to rigorous concept of the unity of Nature must be held responsible for the delay in scientific much must be held responsible for the delay in scientific development, development, much more than the authority of tradition, the ancients or the Scriptures. more than the authority of tradition, the ancients or the Scriptures. We cannot on an an element exert any influence on element of cannot exert of Nature unless we are are agreed Nature unless any influence agreed that isolated. Given a certain degree of solidarity be adequately that it it can can be adequately isolated. Given a certain degree of solidarity between postulates, it of Nature, as Le between the the phenomena Le Grand Grand Proprietaire Nature, as phenomena of Proprittaire postulates, it is intervene without setting off a chain reaction, without is impossible to impossible to intervene without setting off a chain reaction, without upsetting the order of the world: none of the categories of the cosmos upsetting the order of the world: none of the categories of the cosmos possesses a sufficient autonomy, and nothing can be done in the face of possesses a sufficient autonomy, and nothing can be done in the face of universal of universal determinism. determinism. Knowledge of Nature Nature is is limited to the limited to the study Knowledge of study of - aa the causality the relations relations governing means of of aa single by means governing phenomena phenomena by single causality knowledge from can foresee foresee but but cannot which can cannot modify. There is is no no escape knowledge which modify. There escape from this except through magic or miracles. A single rigorous law this causality causality except through magic or miracles. single rigorous law governs at one and the same time the movement of the planets, the one and the at the same time of the governs planets, the vegetative of the the seasons, the connections connections between between the the elements, seasons, the elements, cycle of vegetative cycle the the human body and its its humours, and the the destiny of a a man, the with the humours, and man, with body and destiny of result makes it discover the personal effects of that astrology makes result that it possible to to discover the of effects possible astrology personal this universal determinism. this universal determinism. As late late as as the the middle middle of of the the seventeenth seventeenth century, the practice widespread for the of astrology was sufficiently century, the practice of astrology was sufficiently widespread for the sceptical Moliere to choose it a butt for his raillery in Les Amants to choose it as as a Molire butt his for sceptical raillery in Les Amants magnifiques. magnifiques. The correspondence correspondence of of numbers numbers seemed seemed to to be be one the keys keys to to this this one of of the of numbers was a commonplace profound solidarity; the symbolism the of numbers was a profound solidarity; symbolism commonplace theme in religious speculations, in descriptions physics and theme in religious of physics and natural natural speculations, in descriptions of history, and in magic practices. For example, there was a correspondence and in For there a was magic practices. history, example, correspondence between the the number of man's temperaments, temperaments, of the the elements, between the number number of of man's elements, the and the the number of of the the seasons: seasons: the the figure figure 4. 4. We find find it it difficult difficult today today to to and imagine this tremendous concept of a massive world in which nothing this tremendous a of massive in world which imagine concept nothing it could be be distinguished distinguished but but aa few few correspondences. correspondences. Science had made made it could Science had possible to formulate the latter and to define the categories which they to the and formulate latter to the define which possible categories they linked together; together; over over the the centuries centuries these these correspondences correspondences had had slipped slipped from from linked the realm realm of of science science into into that that of of popular popular mythology. mythology. The concepts concepts born born the in in sixth-century sixth-century Ionia Ionia had had gradually gradually been been adopted adopted by by the the ordinary ordinary mentality; the the categories categories of of antiquo-medieval antiquo-medieval science science had had become become mentality; commonplaces: the elements, the temperaments, the planets and their the the the and their elements, commonplaces: planets temperaments, and astrological significance, and the symbolism of numbers. the of numbers. astrological significance, symbolism The concept concept of of the the ages ages of of life life was was also also one one of of the the common ways ways of of in human understanding biology, in accord with the universal system of the accord with universal understanding biology, system of correspondences. This This concept, concept, which which was was destined destined to to become become extremely extremely correspondences. popular, did did not not go go back back to to the the great great period period of of ancient ancient science, science, however. however. popular,
THE AGES OF LIFE LIFE
21
{
{
11 Fulgentius It in the Byzantine Empire in the sixth century.l1 It originated originated in the Byzantine Empire in the sixth century. Fulgentius found it hidden in the Aeneid: he saw in Aeneas's shipwreck the of found it hidden in the Aeneid: he saw in Aeneas's shipwreck the symbol symbol of
man's birth in midst of the storms interpreted Cantos in the the midst of the man's birth of existence. storms of existence. He interpreted Cantos II the image image of of childhood for fabulous tales, and III as as the and III II and childhood hungering and so so fabulous tales, hungering for on. Arabian fresco fresco of of the eighth century already represented the ages on. An Arabian the eighth century already represented the ages oflife. of life. 12 There are countless medieval texts Le Grand Propriitaire There are countless medieval this theme. texts on on this theme. Le Grand Proprittaire de toutes choses deals with the in its sixth book. Here the ages corredeals with de toutes choses the ages ages in its sixth book. Here the ages correspond to the the planets, and there are seven of them: planets, and there are seven of them: spond to The first first age is childhood when the teeth are planted, and and this this age childhood when the teeth are planted, age is age begins born and and lasts lasts until in this this age the child child is is born until seven, and in that seven, and begins when the age that which is born is called an infant, which is as saying which is born is called an is as as good not infant, which good as saying not talking, because because in this age it cannot talk well or form its words in this it cannot talk well or form its words talking, age perfectly, for its teeth are not yet well arranged or firmly implanted, perfectly, for its teeth are not yet well arranged or firmly implanted, as Isidore Isidore says Constantine. After infancy comes the second and Constantine. as After infancy comes the second says and age ... pueritia and is given this name because in this age the ... it it is is called called is and this in because this age pueritia given age the is still like the pupil in the eye, as Isidore says, and this age person is still like the in the as Isidore and this person eye, age pupil says, lasts till till fourteen. lasts fourteen. Afterwards follows the third which is called adolescence, Afterwards follows the third age, age, which is called adolescence, which ends ends according to Constantine in his viaticum in the twentytwentyto which Constantine in his viaticum in the according first year, but but according to Isidore it lasts till it first year, to Isidore it lasts and it till twenty-eight ... and according twenty-eight can on till thirty or thirty-five. This age is adolescence till or can go This is called called adolescence thirty thirty-five. go age because person is is big to beget children, says Isidore. In because the the person big enough enough to beget children, says Isidore. In this the limbs are soft and able to grow and receive strength the limbs are and able this age soft and and to receive age grow strength and vigour from natural heat. because the person grows in this age from heat. natural And the in this because vigour person grows age to the the size to him by Nature. Nature. [Yet growth is before him by to size allotted allotted to is over over before [Yet growth thirty or thirty-five, even even before twenty-eight. And it it was probably or thirty-five, before twenty-eight. was probably thirty even tardy at at aa time time when work at tender age mobilized the even less a tender less tardy at a the mobilized age resources of the constitution constitution earlier earlier on.] resources of the on.] Afterwards which occupies position the central follows youth, central position Afterwards follows youth, which occupies the among the ages, although the person in this age is in his greatest in is in his the this the greatest person age among ages, although strength, and this age lasts until forty-five according to Isidore, or or until to lasts and this Isidore, forty-five according age strength, until fifty according to others. This age is called youth because of the is This called because the until to others. age youth fifty according strength the person person to help himself himself and others, others, according according to to to help in the strength in Aristotle. Afterwards follows according to Isidore, to which Aristotle. Afterwards follows senectitude, Isidore, senectitude, according is half-way half-way between youth and and old old age, calls it it gravity, is Isidore calls and Isidore between youth age, and gravity, because the the person person is his habits and bearing; and in and in his in this this age because habits and is grave in age bearing; grave the person as Isidore the person is old, but but he he has has passed passed his youth, as his youth, Isidore says. is not not old, says. After this After this age follows old which according to some lasts lasts until until old age, age, which according to age follows . . .
22 22
THE IDEA OF CHILDHOOD
seventy and according to others has no end until death .•• old old people people seventy and according to others has no end until death have not such good sense as they had, and talk nonsense in their old have not such good sense as they had, and talk nonsense in their old . . .
age •.• The The last last part part of of old old age age is is called called senies senies in in Latin, Latin, but but in in French French there is no separate word for it ••. The old man is always coughing old is there is no separate word for it ... always coughing and spitting spitting and and dirtying dirtying [we [we are are aa long long way way yet yet from from the the noble noble old old and man of Greuze and Romanticism] until he returns to the ashes and man of Greuze and Romanticism] until he returns to the ashes and dust from from which which he he was was taken. taken. dust Nowadays we may may consider consider this this jargon jargon empty empty and and verbose, verbose, but but it it had had Nowadays of astrology: astrology: it it aa meaning meaning for for those those who read read it, it, aa meaning meaning akin akin to to that that of called to mind the link which joined the destiny of to that of the of the that of man to the which mind link the called to destiny joined planets. The same sort of sidereal correspondence had had inspired inspired another another planets. The same sort of sidereal correspondence division into periods connected with the twelve signs of the zodiac, thus of the twelve with the connected division into periods zodiac, thus signs linking the ages of life with one of the most popular and moving themes and themes of most the moving popular linking the ages of life with one of the Middle Middle Ages: Ages: the the scenes of the the calendar. calendar. A fourteenth-century fourteenth-century scenes of of the poem, reprinted reprinted several times in in the the fifteenth fifteenth and and sixteenth sixteenth centuries, centuries, several times poem, 13 expounds this calendar of the ages :13 expounds this calendar of the ages: age
. . .
The years of life on on earth earth of life six years The first first six We to would compare, would to January compare, January is as For in that month month strength in that as rarc rare For strength is As from birth. birth. in a a child child six six years from As in years 14 u Or witness this thirteenth-century witness this thirteenth-century poem: poem: Of all behold, the first all the first behold, the months months the 15 11i January two-faced and cold. and cold. two-faced January Because its eyes two ways are Because its cast, ways are cast, eyes To face past. and the face the the future future and the past. Thus the child six summers old old Thus the child six Is is told. told. not worth all is Is not worth much when all But one care one must must take take every care every To see he is is fed fed good that he see that fare, good fare, For well life well he who does does not not start start life For he Will one can tell ..• ... one can tell Will finish finish badly, badly, When October winds do blow, October winds blow, Then aa man his his wheat wheat must sow To feed feed the the other other men on earth; earth; Thus a man of worth Thus must must act act a Who has has arrived arrived at at sixty sixty years: years: He must ears folk's ears must sow in in young young folk's Wisdom all all their their hearts hearts to to fill, fill, he will. And give if he will. give them charity charity if
.
Of LIFE LIPE THE AGES OP
,
23
Of the the same same nature nature is is the the correspondence correspondence established established between between the the ages of life and the other 'fours': consensus quatuor elementorum, quatuor ages of life and the other 'fours': consensus quatuor elementorum, quatuor humorum (the (the temperaments), temperaments), quatuor quatuor anni anni temporum temporum et et quatuor quatuor vitae vitae humorum aetatum.18 About About 1265, 1265, Philippe Philippe de de Novare Novare spoke spoke of of the the 'four 'four times times of of aetatum. 17 namely four periods of twenty years each. And these man's age', age',17 man's namely four periods of twenty years each. And these speculations went on recurring in text after text up to the sixteenth speculations went on recurring in text after text up to the sixteenth 18 century.lS century. must try try to to grasp grasp the the fact fact that that this this terminology, terminology, which which seems seems so so We must futile to to us us now, now, expressed expressed ideas ideas which which were were scientific scientific at at the the time time and and futile also corresponded corresponded to to aa popular popular and and commonplace commonplace idea idea of of life. life. Here Here also again, come up against great difficulties of interpretation, because difficulties we come of because up against great interpretation, again, today we no no longer longer have have this this idea idea of of life: life: we see see life life chiefly chiefly as as aa biological biological today phenomenon, as a situation in society. Yet say' Such is life!' to express as a in is life! Yet we Such to situation society. say express phenomenon, at once once our our resignation resignation and our conviction conviction that that there there is, is, outside outside biology biology and our at and sociology, sociology, something something which which has has no no name, name, but but which which stirs us, which which stirs us, and look for for in the news news items items of of the the papers, papers, or or about about which which we say: say: in the we look 'Thit's lifelike.' Life in this this case is aa drama, which rescues rescues us us from from everyLife in case is That's lifelike.' drama, which everyday boredom. For the man of old, on was the on the the contrary, it was the inevitable, For the of old, inevitable, contrary, it day boredom. of the cyclical, sometimes amusing and and sometimes sad continuity the ages sometimes sad continuity of ages cyclical, sometimes amusing of life; aa continuity inscribed. in the general and abstract order of things in and abstract order the of inscribed of life; things continuity general rather than in experience, for periods of heavy mortality mortality in those of heavy in real for in those periods real experience, rather than few to live through all ages. all these to live these were privileged few men were through ages. privileged The popularity of the 'ages of life' made the theme one of the the most the theme one of most of the The popularity 'ages of life' common in iconography. They are to be found for instance on to for on are be found instance in profane profane iconography. They 19 lll some capitals in the baptistery at Parma. in the at Parma. some illuminated illuminated twelfth-century twelfth-century capitals baptistery The has tried to represent at one and the same time the parable The sculptor sculptor has tried to represent at one and the same time the parable of and of the the eleventh eleventh hour, and the the labourers labourers of the vineyard the master of the of the master of hour, and vineyard and the of the ages of life. the first one can see the master of one can the master life. In In the first scene scene see of of the the symbol ages symbol the laying his hand on a child's and underneath an an and underneath a child's head, hand his the vineyard head, vineyard laying inscription points out the allegory of prima aetas primum of the child: prima aetas saeculi saeculi:: primum the child: inscription points out the allegory humane: Further on: hora tertia: aetas the master aetas master secunda -the tertia: puericia secunda hora on: Further humane: infoncia. puericia infancia. of can be seen putting his hand on the shoulder of a young a shoulder the his hand seen can be of the the vineyard young putting vineyard man who is last of the the labourers labourers bill-hook. The last and a a bill-hook. animal and is holding an holding an animal is his mattock: senectus, sexta aetas. sexta aetas. is resting beside resting beside his mattock: senectus, that the the essential essential But in the fourteenth century the fourteenth all in was above But it it was above all century that characteristics of this iconography became fixed. and remained virtually fixed of this iconography characteristics virtually be recognized unchanged can be the eighteenth until the recognized on they can century; they eighteenth century; unchanged until 20 the Eremitani in a a fresco fresco of the than in capitals in the Palace of the Doges" no less less than capitals in the Palace of the Doges 21 First of all the age of at Padua. III toys: children playing with aa hobbychildren of at Padua. First of all the age hobbyplaying toys: the the leashes. horse, a doll, a windmill, or birds on leashes. Then the age of school: the school: horse, a doll, a windmill, or birds age *
*
'
24 24
THE IDEA OF CHILDHOOD
boys learning to to read or carrying book and pen-tray, the the girls learning to to read or and pen-tray, carrying book boys learning girls learning spin. Next the ages of love or of courtly and knightly sports: feasting, spin. Next die ages of love or of courtly and knightly sports: feasting, boys and girls walking together, a court of love, and the Maytime boys and girls walking together, a court of love, and the Maytime wedding festivities hunt of the calendars. calendars. Next Next the the ages ages of of war or hunt of the and war and wedding festivities or chivalry: a man bearing arms. Finally, the sedentary ages: those the of the bearing arms. Finally, the sedentary ages: those of chivalry: a men of law, science or learning the old bearded scholar dressed in oldof law, science or learning the old bearded scholar dressed in oldfashioned clothes, sitting sitting at his desk by the the fire. of life did not at his desk by fashioned clothes, fire. The The ages ages of life did not correspond to biological biological phases phases but also to to social but also social functions; functions; we correspond simply simply to know that that there there were were some some very young lawyers, lawyers, but but in in popular popular imagery very young imagery learning is an old man's trade. learning is an old man's trade. These attributes attributes of of fourteertth-century art are to be found in almost These fourteerlth-century art are to be found in almost identical form in in prints prints of more popular, popular, more more commonplace identical form of a a more type, commonplace type, which lasted with very very few sixteenth century the lasted with from the the sixteenth which few changes to the changes from century to beginning of nineteenth century. They were called the 'steps of the the nineteenth of the beginning century. They were called the steps of the ages', because they depicted a of figures representing the various ages', because they depicted a row of figures representing the various ages death, and going up on the from birth to death, and often on steps birth to often standing ages from standing on steps going up on the left and going on the the right. In the centre of this double staircase, as left and going down on right. In the centre of this double staircase, as under the the arch bridge, stood the skeleton of Death, armed with with his under of a arch of a bridge, stood the skeleton of his Death, armed scythe. ages merged merged with with that it is the theme Here the theme of of the the ages of death, and it is that of death, and scythe. Here probably no ~ccident that these two themes were among the most no that these themes accident two were most the probably among popular: prints prints depicting depicting the the steps of the ages and the dances of death steps of the ages and the dances of death popular: went on recapitulating until the beginning beginning of the nineteenth century an on recapitulating went until the of the an nineteenth century iconography established in the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries. But established in the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries. But iconography unlike the dances of death, death, in which the the costumes costumes never never changed dances of in which unlike the and changed and remained those those of of the and sixteenth centuries even the fifteenth fifteenth and remained sixteenth centuries even when the the was produced in the nineteenth, the steps of the ages dressed their print in was the the of the dressed their nineteenth, produced print steps ages characters fashion of in the the nineteenthnineteenthafter the of the characters after the fashion the day: last of die last of the day: in century prints, First Communion costumes can be seen making First costumes seen can be their century prints, making their appearance. The enduring quality of the symbols is more remarkis all all the of the the remarkappearance. enduring quality symbols able that: the child is is still there riding riding his hobby-horse, the the schoolboy the child for that: still there able for his hobby-horse, schoolboy carrying and pen-tray, the handsome couple, with the young man book the handsome with the carrying pen-tray, couple, young sometimes holding aa may-bush may-bush in one hand as of the the feasts of sometimes holding in one as a a sign feasts of sign of adolescence and the at arms, an officer wearing adolescence and spring, now an the man at officer arms, spring, wearing the sash of command or banner; on the the downward slope, the sash of the or carrying a banner; slope, the carrying a costumes have stopped being in fashion or have remained true to the have remained costumes have in or true fashion to the stopped being fashions of old; the men of their procedureprocedurefashions of of law are are still still equipped with old; the equipped with their bags, the scholars with their books or their astrolabes, and the churchgoers the scholars with their books the or their astrolabes, bags, churchgoers 22 of all all these figures -- with -- the the most most curious curious of these figures with their their rosaries. rosaries. III The repetition repetition of of these these pictures, pictures, pinned pinned to wall next next to to the the calendar to the die wall calendar in the and in the midst everyday objects, fostered the idea of a life cut midst of everyday fostered the idea of a life cut into into objects, *
THE AG,J\$ LIFE AGJB$ OF LIFE
,
25 25
clearly to certain modes of activity, defined sections sections corresponding dearly defined corresponding to certain modes of activity, of dress. The division of life physical types, social functions and styles physical types, social functions and styles of dress. The division of life into periods had the same fixity as the cycle of Nature Nature or the organization organization into periods had the same fixity as the cycle of or the of society. In spite of the constant evocation of old age and the of society. In spite of the constant evocation of old age and death, death, the ages of life remained good-natured, picturesque sketches, life remained character sketches, character good-natured, picturesque ages of silhouettes rather whimsical whimsical kind. kind. of a a rather silhouettes of
* * * Antiquo-medieval speculation speculation had had bequeathed to posterity posterity aa copious Antique-medieval bequeathed to copious terminology relating relating to to the of life. In the sixteenth century, when it it the ages terminology ages of life. In the sixteenth century, was proposed to to translate this terminology French, it it was was found that was proposed translate this into French, found that terminology into the French language, usage, had not as the French and consequently as many had not French usage, language, and consequently French many words at its Latin or or at least learned learned Latin. its disposal as words at had Latin at least Latin. The I556 1556 disposal as had translator Proprietaire de choses makes makes no bones bones about of Le Grand translator of Grand Propri&aire about de toutes toutes choses recognizing the 'It is more difficult in French than in Latin, the difficulty: recognizing difficulty: 'It is more difficult in French than in Latin, for in Latin Latin there there are are seven seven ages referred to by various various names, names, of which for in of which to by ages referred there are only three three in French: to wit, childhood, youth and old age.' are only in French: to wit, there and old childhood, youth age/ It will be noted that since youth signifies signifies the the prime prime of life, there no noted that It will be since youth of life, there is is no room for for adolescence. eighteenth century, adolescence was Until the adolescence. Until the eighteenth was Adolescence century, confused with childhood. In school Latin the puer and confused with childhood. In school Latin the word puer and the the word adolescens were used used indiscriminately. indiscriminately. Preserved Preserved in the Bibliothfeque Bibliotheque in the adolescent were Nationale are the catalogues of the the Jesuit College at Caen, a list of the Nationale are the catalogues of Jesuit College at Caen, a list of the 23 23 pupils' names accompanied by comments. boy of fifteen is is described names A boy of fifteen comments. described pupils' accompanied by in these these catalogues catalogues as bonus puer, puer, while while his young schoolmate thirteen in as bonus his young of thirteen schoolmate of is optimus adolescens. infant prodigies, admitted is called in a a book on infant admitted called optimus adolescens. Baillet, Baillet, in prodigies, that there were were no terms terms in in French French to pueri and and that there to distinguish between pueri distinguish between adolescentes.24 was virtually virtually only one word in use: enfant. in There was one adolescentes^ There use: only enfant. the Middle meaning of this word was was parparend of Middle Ages, the end of the the meaning of this At the Ages, the ticularly extensive. It be applied to both the putto (in the sixteenth the It could could be to both the sixteenth extensive. applied ticularly putto (in century the putti room, room, the the bedchamber bedchamber decorated decorated with with frescoes frescoes depicting depicting century theputti naked children, was referred referred to to as as 'the 'the children's and the the adolesnaked adoleschildren's room') children, was room') and cent, the big big lad lad who was a bad bad lad. sometimes also also a lad. The word enfant was sometimes cent, the enfant (' child')· in the Miracles Miracles de Notre-Dame26 was was used used in the fourteenth fourteenth and in the de Notre-Dame** in the ('child')* as valets, fifteenth as aa synonym valets, valeton, such as other words such fifteenth centuries centuries as valeton, synonym of other garfon,.fils ('valet', 'varlet', 'lad', 'son'): 'he was a valeton' be a valeton 'he was would be 'lad', 'varlet', 'son'): garfon,jils ('valet', the word translated today today as 'he was was aa good-looking lad' t but but the same could could translated as 'he lad', good-looking a child be used of both both aa young was be used handsome valeton') child ('he valeton') and a ('he was young man ('a ('a -Translator's note: In the following following discussion of terminology the wherever the discussion of translator's note: In the 25-32), wherever terminology (pp. (pp. 25-32), word 'child' 'child' or used, the the original original French has 'enfant* 'enfant' or or 'enfants*. 'enfants'. source has or 'children' French source is used, 'children* is
26 26
THE IDEA IDEA OF OF CHILDHOOD CHILDHOOD THE
Ii
valeton, so so they they loved loved him him dearly dearly ... ..• ft valez valez grew grew up'). up'). Only Only one one word word aa valeton, kept this this very very ancient ancient ambiguity ambiguity down to to our our times, times, and and that that is is the the has kept word gars gars ('lad'), (,lad'), which which has has passed passed straight straight from from Old Old French French into into the the word
has
popular modern idiom in which popular modern idiom in which
it is is preserved. preserved. A strange strange child, child, this this bad bad it was 'so 'so perverse perverse and and wicked wicked that that he he would would not not learn learn aa trade trade or or who was behave as as was was fitting fitting in in childhood childhood ... ... he he kept kept company company with with greedy, greedy, idle idle behave folk who often often started started brawls brawls in in taverns taverns and and brothels, brothels, and and he he never never came came folk across aa woman by by herself herself without without raping raping her*. her'. Here Here is is another another child child of of across fifteen: 'Although 'Although he he was was aa fine, fine, handsome handsome son', son', he he refused refused to to go go riding riding fifteen: or to to have have anything anything to to do do with with girls. girls. His His father father thought thought that that it it was was out out or of shyness: shyness: "This 'This is is customary customary in in children.' children.' In In fact, fact, he he was was betrothed betrothed to to of the Virgin. Virgin. His His father father forced forced him into into marriage: marriage: 'The 'The child child became became very very the angry and struck him hard.' tried to his escape and suffered angry and struck him hard.' He tried to make his escape and suffered by falling falling downstairs. downstairs. The Virgin Virgin then then came for for him and and mortal injuries injuries by mortal said to to him: him: 'Dear 'Dear brother, brother, behold behold your your sweetheart.' sweetheart.' And: And: 'At 'At this this the the said to aa sixteenth-century sixteendl-century calendar calendar of of the the child heaved heaved aa sigh.' sigh.' According According to child ages, at twenty-four 'a 'a child is strong strong and brave', and 'this is is what what and 'this and brave', child is ages, at twenty-four 26 becomes of of children they are are eighteen.' eighteen. '28 children when they becomes The same same is is true true in in the the seventeenth seventeenth century. century. The report report of of an an episcopal episcopal The inquiry of 1667 states in one parish 'there is jeune enfans 'there is un un one that in states that of 1667 parish jeune enfans ['a ['a inquiry young child'] aged about fourteen in the year or so he has has been been or so he in the who fourteen about year young child'] aged living in the aforementioned place has has been children of both both been teaching teaching children living in the aforementioned place sexes write, by arrangement with the inhabitants of the of inhabitants the with the and write, read and to read sexes to by arrangement 27 aforementioned place. '27 aforementioned place.' In took place a change seventeenth century of the the seventeenth the course course of In the by which century a change took place by more dependent classes of society, the was maintained in the classes in the was maintained old usage the old society, dependent usage while appeared in the middle class, where the word in the middle the different usage a different while a class, usage appeared •'child' child' was duration of duration its modern meaning. The long to its was restricted restricted to long meaning. childhood the common idiom was due to to the the indifference indifference in idiom the as it it appeared in childhood as appeared with biological phenomena were regarded at the the time: time: which strictly with which regarded at strictly biological phenomena in nobody would have thought of seeing the end of childhood in puberty. childhood the of have would puberty. seeing thought nobody idea of dependence: the The idea the idea with the of childhood childhood was bound up idea of dependence: the up with were also words in vocabulary words sons', •'varlets' varlets' and in the the words also were and 'boys' words •'sons', vocabulary 'boys' of the leave childhood childhood only could leave subordination. One could of feudal feudal subordination. only by by leaving leaving the is or at lower degrees of dependence. That is state lower or at least least the the of dependence, state of dependence. degrees dependence, in a to indicate indicate in why the words associated with childhood would endure to a with childhood associated the words why familiar in the spoken language, men of humble rank whose in the familiar style, spoken language, style, submission for instance, remained absolute: others remained absolute: lackeys, to others submission to instance, journeymen lackeys, for journeymen a child necessarily and not child but 'little boy' (petit garfon) was not but soldiers. A 'little and soldiers. necessarily a boy' (petit garfon) or a foreman aa young servant, just as today an employer or a foreman will say of aa will as an today employer say young servant, just lad lad
TilE AGES AGRS OF LIFE LIFE THE
27 27
,
worker of of twenty twenty to to twenty-five: twenty-five: 'He's 'He's aa good good lad/ lad.' Thus Thus in in 1549, 1549, one one worker of aa college, college, an an educational educational establishment, establishment, wrote wrote to to Badud, the the principal principal of Baduel,
of his his young young pupils pupils about about his his outfit outfit and and attendants: attendants: of 28 is all all that that he he will will need need for for his his personal personal service/ service.'18 , A little little boy boy is 'A At the the beginning beginning of of the the eighteenth eighteenth century, century, Fureti&re's Furetiere's dictionary dictionary gave gave At an explanation explanation of of the the usage: usage: ' "Child* "Child" is is also also aa term term. of of friendship friendship used used an to greet greet or or flatter flatter someone someone or or to to induce induce him to do do something. something. Thus Thus when when him to to one says says to to an an aged aged person: person: "Goodbye, "Goodbye, good good mother" mother" ['so long, grandone ['so long, grandma,' in in the the modern modern idiom] idiom] she she replies: replies: "Goodbye, "Goodbye, my my child" child" ['goodbye, [' goodbye, ma/
the father father of of one one the
*
1
she will will say say to to aa lackey: lackey: "Child, "Child, go go and and get get me this this or or that/' that." lad']. Or she
lad'].
master will will say say to to his his men men when when setting setting them them to to work work: ""Come along, Come along, A master children, get get to to work." work." A captain captain will will say to his his soldiers: soldiers: "Courage, "Courage, children, say to :
fast.'" Front-line Front-line troops, troops, those those most most exposed to danger, children, stand fast/ children, stand exposed to danger, were called called 'the 'the lost lost children'. children'. were At the the same same time, time, but but in in families of gentle gentle birth, birth, where where dependence dependence At families of was.only a consequence of physical infirmity, the vocabulary of childhood of childhood a of the was-only consequence vocabulary physical infirmity, tended rather rather to to the the first age. Its became increasingly refer to first age. Its use use became to refer tended increasingly frequent frequent in the seventeenth seventeenth century: the expression 'little enfant) the 'little child' child' (petit in the (petit enfant) century: expression began to take on the meaning give it. usage had preferred on had we it. The older older take the to usage preferred give meaning began 'young enfant), and this expression had not been completely child' (jeune (jeune enfant), and this expression had not been completely 'young child' abandoned. Fontaine used it, and and again in aa translation of in 1714, translation of La Fontaine used it, abandoned. La 1714, in again in Erasmus, reference to girl' who was not yet five: five: a 'young was not a reference was a to a there was Erasmus, there yet 'young girl' 29 The word petit 'I young girl who has begun to talk.'119 has scarcely *I have have a a young petit scarcely begun to talk/ girl or meaning by the end of the a special one* had also acquired or 'little 'little one' had also acquired a special meaning by the end of the sixteenth even of the all the the pupils the 'little 'little schools', it referred referred to to all sixteenth century: schools', even pupils of century: it In England, the word 'petty' had those children. the In were no no longer children. those who were 'petty' had England, longer the as in French, and a text of 1627 on the subject of school school of a of the in and text as the same same meaning French, 1627 subject meaning 30 spoke of the 'lyttle petties', the smallest pupils. 80 spoke of the 'lytde petties', the smallest pupils. It and pedagogic all the the moral moral and and with with all with Port-Royal all with It was was above above all pedagogic Port-Royal and literature from Port-Royal (or drew its its inspiration literature which which drew gave Port-Royal (or which gave inspiration more expression to a need for moral discipline which was widely more general widely general expression to a need for moral discipline used to the terms terms used to felt that the too bore bore witness), felt and to which which Port-Royal and to witness), that Port-Royal too denote all modem: modern: Jacqueline and above above all became common and denote childhood childhood became Jacqueline middle Pascal's at Port-Royal were divided little ones'. divided into into 'little Pascal's pupils ones', 'middle pupils at Port-Royal were 31 'With regard to ones' ones'.SI the little she wrote, she little children,' the to ones' and 'With and 'big ones'. wrote, children/ regard 'big fed if 'they even more than all others must be taught and fed if possible be others must the all the than even more possible taught 'they at Port-Royal like of the little schools schools at like little little doves.' The regulations doves/ The Port-Royal regulations of the little little ones.'sz ones/ 32 People stated: the little Mass every to Mass stated: 'They do not not go People day, only only the every day, 'They do go to 33 spoke 'little angels'. souls' and 'little a new way 'little souls' in a of 'little angels',88 expressions expressions spoke in way of In her her which which foreshadowed the eighteenth foreshadowed the century and Romanticism. In eighteenth century 1 '
'
*
THE IDEA OF CHILDHOOD
18
~s, Mlle Lheritier claimed to be addressing 'young minds', 'young ss, Mile Lh6ritier claimed to be addressing 'young minds', 'young >ple': 'These pictures pictures probably probably lead lead young people to reflections which "These to reflections which >ple young people 84 It can thus be seen that that seventeenth century feet reasoning.'" It can thus be seen that that seventeenth their reasoning/ feet their century lich have scorned scorned childhood, childhood, in fact brought into use seemed to to have ich seemed in fact brought into use )ressions phrases which which remain remain to to this this day in our Under sessions and and phrases our language. day in language. Under word 'child' 'child' in his dictionary, dictionary, Furetifcre Furetiere quoted proverbs which are in his are which quoted proverbs child, has been allowed to misl familiar to us: us: 'He is a a spoilt 'He is familiar to who has been allowed to mischild, spoilt lave without being punished. The fact is, there there are no longer any lave without fact is, are no being punished. longer any to have reason and cunning at an ldren, are beginning are to have for people reason and at an Idren, for people beginning cunning lyage.' 'Innocent as a new-born child.' as a new-born child.' 'Innocent ly age/ \11 the same, in its its attempts to talk talk about the French French about little Vll the little children, same, in children, the attempts to of the seventeenth century was hampered by the lack of words guage was the seventeenth of the lack of words century hampered by guage The same was true of English, distinguish them from bigger ones. from ones. same was true of bigger distinguish English, was also applied to to big big children. Lily's Latin ere the word 'baby' also applied ere the children. Lily's Latin 'baby' was mmar in English, which which was in use use from the beginning of in English, was in the beginning of the the sixsixr866, was intended intended for babes, all lytell nth century until until 1866, for 'all 'all lyte11 babes, tith century all lytell lytell rldren'.36 rldren'. 85 )n hand there were in in French French some expressions expressions which which seem there were other hand 3n the the other seem these was the word poupart. poupart. In In one refer very little little children. children. One of of these was the refer to to very one the Miracles de Notre-Dame there there was was aa 'little wanted to to feed de Notre-Dame son' who wanted the Miracles 'little son' feed the Infant Jesus. 'Tender-hearted Jesus, seeing the insistence icture Infant Jesus. of the 'Tender-hearted Jesus, icture of insistence Seeing the I good good will will of tlle little to and said: "Poupart, weep of the little child, to him and said: child, spoke spoke "Poupart, weep shall eat Witll me.'" But this poupart was more, for in days you in three shall eat with three days me.'" But this more, for you poupart was t really really what 'o/hat the French today would call a bebe: he was also referred the French a would call he was also bfbf: referred today as clergeon or 'little clerk', wore aa surplice and served at Mass: or 'little as a a clergeon clerk', wore surplice and served at Mass: had few letters and and would ere there were also little were also little children children who had ere there few letters would 36 In her have fed fed at breast than do divine service! '36 at their their mother's mother's breast her have than do In divine service!' of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries the word , language of the seventeenth and the centuries language eighteenth 'part no longer longer denoted denoted aa child, but instead, in the the form poupon, poupon, what what child, but instead, in ipart the same name, but in the feminine: aa , French French today today still call by still call in the same but the feminine: name, by ,pee, or doll. or doll. \pte, ~rench was therefore therefore reduced reduced to to borrowing borrowing from from other other idioms idioms -- either either Drench was - words to or trade to denote eign languages or the slang used in school in or or trade denote the used school slang eign languages an interest henceforth going French that little in whom an to little child child in interest was henceforth French that going to talcen. This was was the the case case with with the which became became the the taken. This the Italian bambino which Italian bambino bambino Mme de de Sevigne used in in the the same sense a form of the :nch sense a inch bambin. of the also used Svigne also in the >venrral pitchoun, which she had doubtless learnt in the course of learnt course word she had doubtless )ven$al pitchoun, 37 Her cousin Coulanges, who did 37 ee of her stays stays with with the the Grignans. cousin did of her Coulanges, Grignans. 88 t like children but but spoke distrusted like children a great distrusted 'three-yeardeal, spoke of them a three-yeargreat deal,88 old word which in the I marmousets', marmousets', an old which in the popular popular idiom would become >
:
I
I
t
1
'
t
l
THB AGES THE
~
LIPB LIFE
chins
marmots.
,
2p
dish'.
'brats with with greasy greasy chins who put put aa finger finger in in every every dish*. People People marmots, 'brats also used slang terms from from school school Latin Latin or or from from sporting sporting and and military academies: aa little little jrater, aa cadet, and, and, when when there there were were several several of of them, them, academies:
military ftater, cadet, a populo populo or or petit petit peuple." peuple.'8 Lastly Lasdy the the use use of of diminutives diminutives became became quite quite a also used slang terms
common: fanfan fanfon isis to to be be found found in in the the letters letters of of Mme de de Svign S6vign6 and and common: of F&ielon. Fenelon. those of those
In time time these these words words In
would come come to to denote denote aa child child who was was still still small small would
but already already beginning beginning to to find find his his feet. feet. There There would would still still remain remain aa gap gap but where aa word word was was needed needed to to denote denote aa child child in in its its first first months months of of life life;; where
this gap gap would would not not be be filled filled until until the the nineteenth nineteenth century, century, when the the French would would borrow borrow from from the the English English the the word word 'baby', 'baby', which which in in the the French sixteenth and seventeenth seventeenth centuries centuries had had denoted children of of school school age. age. denoted children sixteenth and this
This borrowing was was the the last of the story: henceforth, with the This borrowing last stage stage of the story: henceforth, with the litde child child had had aa name. name. little
French word word bAt, bebe, the the very very French
* * * Even when aa vocabulary vocabulary relating relating to to infancy infancy appeared appeared and and expanded, Even when expanded, an remained between childhood and adolescence on the the one and on one an ambiguity between childhood adolescence remained ambiguity hand the category as youth on the other. People had no idea no idea the had as on other. hand and and the known People youth category of adolescence, and the idea time taking taking shape. a long idea was of what and the was a what we call call adolescence, long time shape. One can of it the eighteenth century in two characters in in characters -a glimpse of it in the can catch catch a eighteenth century glimpse as presented by Ch6rubin, and the other social, the one the conscript. one literary, conscript. literary, as presented by Cherubin, and the other social, In of puberty that was uppermost, and was the ambiguity of that In Cherubin it was was the Cherubin it uppermost, and ambiguity puberty the the effeminate boy just just emerging emerging from side of a boy of a the stress laid on effeminate side stress was was laid on the childhood. speaking, this was not a new thing: life social life since social childhood. Stricdy thing: since Strictly speaking, this was not a age, the full, round features of early adolescence, began at a very early of round features the at a adolescence, full, early began very early age, about the This is is the a feminine feminine appearance. of puberty, about the the age boys a gave boys appearance. This age of puberty, gave explanation of the ease with which men disguised themselves as women as themselves which of the ease with disguised explanation and sevenat the the beginning of the the sevennovels at and vice versa in in coundess countless baroque vice versa beginning of baroque novels - two teenth youths becoming friends when one was a girl in a friends one teenth century two girl in youths becoming century disguise, and so on; however credulous readers of adventure stories have stories have readers of adventure credulous and so however on; disguise, that there there always of probability the very been, the probability demands that always been, very minimum of a should and a girl. a beardless beardless boy resemblance between a should have have been some resemblance been some girl. boy at as a However, that resemblance was not presented at the time as a charactercharacterthe time not was that resemblance However, presented istic of age. with beardless men with istic of of adolescence, a characteristic characteristic of adolescence, a age. Those beardless lOft already behaved like fully like behaved ;oft features for they features were not adolescents were not adolescents for fully they already ~rown and giving orders. But in the feminine in Cherubin Ch&rubin the feminine men, fighting jrown men, fighting and giving orders. Lppearance it expressed child to to adult: adult: it transition from child was linked linked with the transition with the ippearance was expressed love. Lcondition a certain period, the period of budding love. the condition during a certain budding period during period, i
30 30
THE IDEA OF CHILDHOOD
Cherubin was was not not destined destined to to have have any any successors. successors. On the the contrary, contrary, itit Chrubin was manly manly strength strength which, which, in in boys, boys, would would express express the the idea idea of ofadolescence, adolescence, was and the the adolescence adolescence was was foreshadowed foreshadowed in in the the eighteenth eighteenth century century by by the the and conscript. Witness the text of this recruiting poster dating from the end conscript. Witness the text of this recruiting poster dating from the end 40 It is addressed to 'shining youth' (brillante of the the eighteenth century. century.~ It is addressed to of shining youth* (brillante *
eighteenth
jeunesse): 'Those 'Those youths youths [jeunesgens] [jeunes gens] who wish wish to to share share in in the the reputation reputation which this this fine fine corps corps has has won for for itself itself can can apply apply to to M. M. d'Ambrun d' Ambrun ... •.. which
jeunesse)
:
bring them them some some upstanding upstanding They [the [the recruiters] recruiters] will will reward reward those those who bring They [beaux homtnes]. hommes].' men [beaux The first first typical typical adolescent adolescent of of modern modem times times was was Wagner's Wagner's Siegfried: Siegfried: The the music music of of Siegfried Siegfried expressed expressed for for the the first first time time that that combination combination of of the (provisional) purity. physical strength, naturism. spontaneity and joie and naturism, joie strength, spontaneity physical (provisional) purity, de vivre vivre which which was was to to make make the the adolescent adolescent the the hero hero of our twentieth twentieth of our de century, the century of adolescence. made its appearance in in What of made its adolescence. the century appearance century, Wagnerian Germany was to enter France at a later date, in the years France at a later in the was to enter date, years Wagnerian Germany around 1900. The 'youth' 'youth' which which at at this this time time was was adolescence adolescence soon soon became became around 1900. The aa literary theme and a subject of concern for moralists and politicians. of concern for moralists and a and theme politicians. subject literary People began wondering wondering seriously what youth was thinking. and inquiries thinking, and inquiries seriously what youth was People began such writers as Massis and Henriot. Youth gave were made made by the and Henriot. as Massis writers such were gave the by impression of secretly possessing values capable of reviving an aged of an values of new reviving aged capable secretly possessing impression and like interest had been evidenced in in the the Romantic Romantic and sclerosed sclerosed society. society. A like interest had been evidenced period, but not with such specific reference to a single age group. and to a such reference not with but single age group, and specific period, moreover been limited that literature. of that literature. readers of and the the readers limited to to literature literature and had been it had moreover it Awareness became aa general phenomenon, however, after the of youth Awareness of youth became general phenomenon, however, after the end orId War, were solidly front were at the the front in which the troops which the of the First W end of the First World War, in solidly troops at opposed to the older generations in the rear. The awareness of youth awareness in rear. the the older to youth generations opposed began by being a feeling common to ex-servicemen, and this was this feeling to a ex-servicemen, feeling began by being feeling to countries, even in the America of Dos of in the America even the belligerent all the be found found in in all to be countries, belligerent Passos. adolescence expanded: it it encroached encroached upon that point, Passos. From that upon point, adolescence expanded: childhood in the other. Henceforth marriage, Henceforth other. in the in one one direction, childhood in direction, maturity marriage, maturity to it: which down', would not not put it: to be be a a 'settling had ceased ceased to which had put an end to 'settling down', the types the most prominent one of the was to to become adolescent was become one the married married adolescent prominent types customs. Thus our of its values, its appetites and its its customs. of our our time, time, dictating dictating its values, its appetites to a a adolescence to society has passed from a period which was ignorant of adolescence society has passed from a period which was ignorant to period in which adolescence is favourite age. We now want to come is the the favourite in adolescence which age. period to linger in it as long as possible. to it it early and early and linger in it as long as possible. This has been been accompanied evolution has This evolution contrary parallel but contrary by aa parallel accompanied by in the the society started evolution We know that old age started early old old age. that evolution of of old early in society age age. MoH&re's old. as Moliere's old men, of We are familiar with of the are familiar with such the past. such examples men, examples as past. the who appear to be still our eyes. Moreover the iconography to be still young to to our iconography of eyes. appear young 9
THE AGES OF LIFE
31 31
old does not always represent it in the guise of a decrepit invalid: old old age age does not always represent it in the guise of a decrepit invalid: old age begins with the losing of one's hair and the wearing of a beard, and age begins with the losing of one's hair and the wearing of a beard, and as a is bald. aa handsome handsome old old man sometimes sometimes appears appears simply simply as a man who is bald. the case with the the old old man man in which is a This is the This is also a case with in Titian's Titian's concert, is also concert, which of the ages of life. But generally speaking, before the representation of the the of before life. But representation ages generally speaking, was regarded regarded as of eighteenth century the old man was as ridiculous. ridiculous. One of eighteenth century the old Rottou's characters to force his daughter daughter to accept aa quinquagenarian quinquagenarian: Rotrou's characters tries tries to to accept force his 'He hasn't aa tooth tooth in In the whole of Nature is only fifty, and He is of Nature in his his head. head. In the whole only fifty, and hasn't not aa man who doesn't was born born in the age of Saturn or there's not he was in the there's of Saturn doesn't think think he or age of the the Flood. which he walks, two two are the time time of on which the feet on are Flood. Of the the three he walks, three feet gouty. at every and are always having to be propped stumble at gouty. They They stumble every step step and are always having to be propped 41 up or picked up.'u in another ten years he will will look look like like this or ten And in another this sexasexapicked up.' years he up his stick, the little old coughs, genarian in Quinault: 'Bent over in his the little old man over 'Bent stick, Quinault: coughs, genarian spits, blows his nose, cracks jokes, and bores Isabelle with tales of the spits, blows his nose, cracks jokes, and bores Isabelle with tales of the 42 days.''' good o.ld days.' good o.ld Old France had little old age: it was the age of retirement, France had little respect for Old respect for old age: it was the age of retirement, whole man in in books, churchgoing and rambling talk. talk. The picture picture of and rambling of the the whole books, churchgoing that of younger man: man: the the sixteenth centuries was was that of a a younger the the and seventeenth sixteenth and seventeenth centuries at the top of steps of the ages. He was not aa young young officer in the the sash of the of the was not sash at the top the steps officer in ages. man, although although he would be be today. that second to that he would second man, today. He corresponded corresponded to ages, between between childhood and old old age, which in category in the childhood and the of the the ages, age, which category of was called youth. Furetiere, Furetiere, who still seventeenth still took called youth. took very seventeenth century very century was seriously the archaic problems of the division of life into periods, thought seriously the archaic problems of the division of life into periods, thought maturity; but but he he recognized recognized that that it up an intermediate of maturity; it was was concept of up an intermediate concept not current and admitted: 'Jurists see only one age in youth and maturity.' not current and admitted: 'Jurists see only one age in youth and maturity.' youth, as The seventeenth century recognized in this itself in this military as the the seventeenth century military youth, recognized itself its adolescents. twentieth century recognizes itself in twentieth century recognizes itself in its adolescents. has disappeared, disappeared, at spoken French, French, where the Today old at least least from spoken where the old age age has Today un vieux, 'an old fellow', has survived with a colloquial, expression has survived with a 'an old fellow', colloquial, expression un vieux, taken place place contemptuous patronizing significance. This evolution has taken evolution has or patronizing significance. This contemptuous or stages. First of all there was the venerable old man, the silverin old was the venerable the silverin two all there two stages. First of man, in precious wise Nestor, Nestor, the the patriarch patriarch rich rich in precious experience: haired the wise haired ancestor, ancestor, the experience: Greuze, Restif Restif de de la and the the whole nineteenth nineteenth the old old man of la Bretonne Bretonne and the of Greuze, was not yet very agile, but he was longer as decrepit as century. He no as but he not was longer decrepit as yet very agile, century. the the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. There still remains still seventeenth centuries. There and remains the old sixteenth old man of of the this respect respect for old man in in the the received received ideas ideas of something the old the of the for the of this something of no has But the fact is this respect longer has any object, for present day. this is that that the fact But respect longer any object, for present day. the second the old has disappeared. in time, and old the has in our second stage, man is the our time, and this this is stage, disappeared. been replaced by •'the the elderly elderly man' and and by by 'well-preserved He has has been ladies 'well-preserved ladies replaced by or gentlemen': is still still middle-class, but is but which is tending or a concept which is which a which middle-class, gentlemen' tending concept :
4
:
32 32
THE IDEA OF CHILDHOOD
to become The technological idea of preservation is replacing to become popular. popular. The technological idea of preservation is replacing of old old age. the biological and moral idea the biological and moral idea of age.
* * * It is as as if, to every of history, history, there a It is to there corresponded if, every period period of corresponded a of human life: 'youth' is the privileged age and a particular division privileged age and a particular division of human life: 'youth* is the the seventeenth childhood of ninetee~ privileged of the seventeenth century, of the the nineteerrthf privileged age age of century, childhood adolescence the twentieth. twentieth. \"'-G';;"-"';-"-of the adolescence of \\G J^^^ variations from one century to another bear witness to the the naive naive The variations from one another bear witness to century to interpretation which public opinion has given, in each and every period, has in which each and interpretation given, public opinion every period, of it could an objective of its its demographic structure, could not not always form an demographic structure, when it always form objective idea of it. it. Thus Thus the the absence absence of and the the contempt idea of of adolescence adolescence and for old old age age contempt for - at on the the one and on the other hand hand the the disappearance of old age one hand, the other of old hand, and disappearance age - at - and the least as aa degradation the introduction introduction of of adolescence, least as adolescence, express degradation - and express of life. the average society's reactions to to the the duration duration of life. Prolongation of society's reactions Prolongation of the average life-span brought into existence tracts of life to which the scholars of the life-span brought into existence tracts of life to which the scholars of the Byzantine the Middle Middle Ages Ages had had given names even even though and the Byzantine Empire Empire and given names though they had not existed for the generality; and the modern language has had not existed the for and the they generality; language has borrowed these terms, which were originally purely theoretical, to borrowed these old old terms, which were originally purely theoretical, to denote realities: the the last phase of familIar and forgotten denote new realities last phase of a a long and familiar now long forgotten the 'ages of lIfe'. theme, that of of the theme, that 'ages of life'. In periods when life life is is short, idea of a privileged privileged age age is even more m~re In periods the idea of a is even short, the important than in our period of longevity. In the following pages, than in our of In the important period following pages, we longevity. shall pay particular particular attention indications of of childhood. In the shall pay to the attention to the indications the course course childhood. In of this this study must never never forget to what what extent extent this representation of of this representation study we must forget to childhood relative, in the preference in comparison childhood remains remains relative, to with the given to comparison with preference given 'youth' in the under examination That the period examination (pre-nineteenth 'youth' in period under century). That (pre-nineteenth century). time was not not one one of of children children or or of or of old men: of old men it it was a time of adolescents a adolescents or of young men. period of men. period young :
:
II THE DISCOVERY OF CHILDHOOD
M
EDIEVAL art art until until about about the the twelfth twelfth century century did did not not know childhood or or did did not not attempt attempt to to portray portray it. it. It It isis hard hard to to believe believe childhood or incapacity; incapacity; it it seems seems that this this neglect neglect was was due due to to incompetence incompetence or that
MEDIEVAL
no place place for for childhood childhood in in the the medieval medieval more probable probable that that there there was was no more of the the twelfth twelfth century century provides provides us us with with aa world. An Ottoman Ottonian miniature miniature of world. of the deformation which an artist at that time would striking example striking example of the deformation which an artist at that time 1 l on children's bodies. The subject is the scene in the Gospels in inflict in the the is scene inflict on children's bodies. The subject Gospels in asks that that little little children children be be allowed allowed to to come to to Him. The which Jesus Jesus asks which
is clear: clear: parvuli. parvuli. Yet Yet the the miniaturist miniaturist has has grouped grouped around around Jesus Jesus is men, without without any any of of the the characteristics characteristics of of what are are obviously obviously eight eight men, what childhood; they they have have simply been depicted on a smaller scale. In a a a scale. In on smaller been childhood; depicted simply
Latin text text Latin
of the the late century the the three three children children brought brought French miniature miniature of late eleventh eleventh century French by St Nicholas are are also reduced to to aa smaller smaller scale than the the adults, adults, to life life by scale than St Nicholas also reduced to
or features. 22 A painter painter would would without any any other difference in in expression other difference without expression or features. not even hesitate to give the naked body of very few cases cases in the the very a child, not even hesitate to give the naked body of a child, in when it was exposed, the musculature of an adult: thus in a Psalter dating a in Psalter when it was exposed, the musculature of an adult: thus dating
from after thirteenth century, or early from the the late late twelfth twelfth or Ishmael, shortly shortly after century, Ishmael, early thirteenth 33 The thirteenth of a man. birth, has the abdominal and pectoral muscles thirteenth man. of a and muscles the abdominal has birth, pectoral century, although it showed more understanding in its its presentation of presentation understanding in century, although it showed 4 In St Louis's moralizing childhood, remained faithful to this method.' Louis's St this method. In to faithful remained childhood, moralizing Bible, are still still indicated indicated only but they are depicted children are often, but Bible, children only they are depicted more often, by in the life of Jacob, Isaac is shown sitting an episode their size. In an size. In sitting episode in die life of Jacob, Isaac is by their between little men who come fifteen little surrounded by his two between his two wives, wives, surrounded by some fifteen up their children. are their children. 65 When these are waists: tllese to the the grown-ups' the level of the level of up to grown-ups' waists: illuminator Job is rewarded for his faith and becomes rich once more, the illuminator Job is rewarded for his faith and becomes rich once more, the his good fortune by placing Job between an equal depicts between equal number of depicts his good fortune by placing Job cattle on the left and children on the right: the traditional picture the traditional the children cattle on the left and picture of right: in the the Book fecundity inseparable from wealth. In another illustration illustration in In another wealth. from fecundity inseparable size. in order of some children are lined up in order of size. lined ofJob, are some children up Job, in an the Sainte-Chapelle, In In the the thirteenth-century Sainte-Chapelle, in Gospel-book of the thirteenth-century Gospel-book the illustration Christ and one of the loaves and fishes, the loaves of the illustration of the miracle miracle of of the fishes, Christ a little man who comes up on either side little Apostles are shown standing side of a either are shown up Apostles standing 8 In the to the fishes. fishes.6 In the world of carried the child who carried to their their waists: the child no doubt doubt the waists no the thirteenili thirteenth century. the end of the to the Romanesque formulas, right century, up to right up Romanesque formulas, :
33 33
B B
34 34
THB IDEA IDBA OF OF CHILDHOOD CHILDHOOD THE
there are are no no children children characterized characterized by by aa special special expression expression but but only only men men there to be on a reduced scale. This refusal to accept child morphology in art is to be on a reduced scale. This refusal to accept child morphology in art is found too in most of the ancient civilizations. A fine Sardinian bronze fine Sardinian bronze found too in most of the ancient civilizations.
A
of the the ninth ninth century century B.C. B.C. shows shows aa sort sort of ofPiet~: mother holding holding in in her her Pieta: aa mother of 7 7 arms the the somewhat somewhat bulky bulky body body of of her her son. son. The The catalogue catalogue tells tells us: us: arms 'The little little masculine masculine figure figure could could also also be be aa child child which, which, in in accordance accordance 'The with the the formula formula adopted adopted in in ancient ancient times times by by other other peoples, peoples, had had been been with that represented as an adult.' Everything in fact would seem to suggest that to in would seem fact adult/ as an suggest Everything represented the realistic realistic representation representation of of children children or or the the idealization idealization of of childhood, childhood, its its the to Greek art. Little Eroses grace and rounded charms, was confined Eroses to Little art. Greek confined was rounded and charms, grace proliferated in in the the Hellenistic Hellenistic period, period, but but childhood childhood disappeared disappeared from proliferated
iconography together with the other Hellenistic themes, and Romanesque
and Romanesque iconography together with the other Hellenistic themes, art returned to that rejection of of the the special special features features of of childhood childhood which had already already characterized characterized the the periods periods of of antiquity antiquity before before Hellenism. Hellenism. had This is is no no mere mere coincidence. coincidence. Our Our starting-point starting-point in in this this study study is is aa world of This art returned to that rejection
pictorial representation in which childhood childhood is is unknown; unknown; literary literary hishisin which the have the same observation about the same observation the have made Mgr and epic, in which child prodigies behave with the courage physical the with behave child which in physical courage prodigies epic, strength of doughty warriors. This This undoubtedly undoubtedly means that that the the men of strength of doughty warriors. the tenth did not not dwell the image childhood, on the dwell on centuries did and eleventh eleventh centuries tenth and the image of childhood, It and that image had neither interest even reality for for them. It even nor interest nor had neither that that and that reality image that of in that suggests too that in realm of real not in and not simply real life, of realm the in the that too life, and simply suggests aesthetic childhood was transition which passed a period was a aesthetic transposition, passed period of transition transposition, childhood quickly. and which was just as quickly forgotten. as was which and quickly forgotten. just quickly little imps to the the little Such How do we get there to is our our starting-point. Such is imps get from there starting-point. in all ages in of of children of all our family of children the photographs to the of Versailles, Versailles, to family ages photographs albums? albums? to be found are to About children are a few of children few types thirteenth century, the thirteenth About the century, a types of which to be a little concept of childhood. the modern to the modem little closer closer to a to be which appear concept appear There depicted in the guise of aa very man, aa young the angel, is the There is young very young young man, angel, depicted in the guise 88 But how old is this this old is ulolescent: as Pere du Colombier remarks. remarks. du Colombier as Pere a clergeon, idolescent: a clergeon, various ages 'little were children of various who were children were The clergeons clerk'? The little clerk'? ages clergeons for holy destined for were destined :rained church and who were in church the responses make the to make rained to holy responses in no seminaries were orders, seminarists of a sort in a period when there were no seminaries there when in a of a sort seminarists orders, period was that existed, and ofschooling kind of the only in Latin, existed, was and when when schooling Latin, the schooling that only kind schooling in de reserved for future clerks. 'Here', says one of the Miracles de Notre-Dame, Miracles the of one clerks. future Notre-Dame, for reserved 'Here', says fed rather have have fed would rather 'there and would letters and had few who had few letters children who little children were little 'there were late that at time: at their mother's breast [but children were weaned very late at that time: weaned children were breast mother's their at very [but do divine divine than do Shakespeare's Juliet was still being breast-fed at at three) three] than Shakespeare's Juliet was still being breast-fed 9 The angel of Reims, to take one is a one service.'8 example. is a big boy rather of take to The service.' Reims, big boy rather example, angel pictorial representation torians such such as Calve as Mgr Calve torians
THE DISCOVERY DISCOVERY Of Of' CHILDHOOD CHILDHOOD THE
.
, J5 3S
than aachild, child, but but the theartists artists have havestressed stressed the theround, round, pretty, pretty, and andsomewhat somewhat than ofyouths youths barely bardy out out of ofchildhood. childhood. We have have already already effeminate features features of effeminate
We
come aa long long way way from from the the small-scale small-scale adults adults of ofthe the Ottoman Ottonian miniature. miniature. come
This type type of ofadolescent adolescent angel angd was was to to become become extremely extremely common common in in the the This was to to last last to to the the very very end end of ofthe the Italian Italian QuattroQuattrofourteenth century century and and was fourteenth cento: the the angels angels of of Fra Fra Angelico, Angelico, Botticelli Botticelli and and Ghirlandajo Ghirlandajo all all belong bdong cento: to it. it. to
The second second type type of of child child was was to to be be the the model modd and and ancestor ancestor of ofall all the the The of art: art: the the Infant Infant Jesus, Jesus, or or the the Infant Infant NotreNotrelittle children children in in the the history history of Dame, for for here here childhood childhood isis linked linked to to the the mystery mystery of of motherhood motherhood and and Dame, the Marian Marian cult cult. To To begin begin with, with, Jesus, Jesus, like like other other children, children, isis an an adult adult on on the reduced scale: scale: aa little little God-priest God-priest in in His His majesty, majesty, depicted depicted by by Theotokos. Theotokos. aa reduced The evolution evolution towards towards aa more more realistic realistic and and more more sentimental sentimental representarepresentaThe tion of of childhood childhood begins begins very very early early on on in in painting: painting: in in aa miniature miniature of of the the tion second half half of of the the twelfth twelfth century, century, Jesus Jesus is is shown wearing wearing aa thin, thin, almost almost second His arms arms round round His His mother's mother's neck, neck, transparent shift and standing with with His transparent shift and standing 10 With the nestling against her, cheek to cheekY) the Virgin's motherhood, cheek. motherhood, to cheek Virgin's nestling against her, of pictorial pictorial representation. representation. In In the the thirteenth thirteenth childhood enters enters the the world world of childhood 11 century it inspires other family scenes. In St Louis's moralizing Bible,1l St Louis's In scenes. other it moralizing Bible, family inspires century are shown surrounded by there are are various various family scenes in which parents are by there family scenes in which parents at the as their children with the same tender respect as on the rood-screen at tender same the with their children respect Chartres: thus in a picture of Moses and his family, husband and wife his of Moses a in Chartres: thus family, picture are are hands while the children men) surrounding them are children (little are holding (little men) surrounding holding hands while the stretching out their hands towards their mother. These cases, however, mother. their however, towards cases, hands their stretching out to the limited to remained of childhood childhood remained limited idea of the touching rare: the remained rare: touching idea Italianas is Jesus until the fourteenth century, when, as is well known, Italian. Infant known, fourteenth when, the Infant Jesus until century, it. art to spread and and devdop was to to hdp art was develop it. help to spread child. A third type of child appeared in the Gothic Gothic period: in the child period: the naked child. A third type of appeared than often More naked. The Infant Jesus was scarcely ever depicted naked. More often than not, not, ever was The Infant Jesus depicted scarcely in like other children of His age, He was chastely wrapped in swaddlingwas He His of swaddlinglike other children chastely wrapped age, the until the undressed until be undressed not be would not clothes He would dress. He or aa dress. shift or in aa shift clad in or clad clothes or Bibles in the of the Middle Ages. Those few miniatures in the moralizing Bibles end miniatures few Those moralizing end of the Middle Ages. in the of the case case of which children showed them fully dressed, except showed them except in which depicted fully dressed, depicted children was Solomon mothers the Innocents or the dead children whose mothers Solomon was judging. whose children dead judging. the Innocents or the into the introduce into the to introduce was to which was soul which of death ItIt was the soul and the death and the allegory was the allegory of in the world of forms the picture of childish nudity. Already in the preof childish prenudity. Already world of forms the picture features of of in which which many Byzantine iconography of the fifth century, the fifth many features century, in Byzantine iconography of bodies the of the their the future Romanesque art made their appearance, the bodies of the made the future Romanesque art appearance, than living bodies. smaller than were smaller dead scale. Corpses in scale. living bodies. dead were reduced in were reduced Corpses were scenes are half batde in the dead the the fliad in the Ambrosian Library the dead in the battle scenes are half In In the Iliad in the Ambrosian Library little
THB IDEA IDBA OF CHILDHOOD THE
36
lll In living.12 In French French medieval medieval art art the the soul soul was was depicted depicted as aa little little child clri1d who was was naked naked and and usually usually sexless. sexless. The The Last Last Judgments Judgments as 13 The lead the the souls souls of of the the righteous righteous to to Abraham's Abraham's bosom bosom in in this this form. form. 18 The lead his mouth in a symbolic dying breathes the child out through the a child out in man breathes his mouth symbolic through dying representation of the soul's departure. This is also the entry of of the the representation of the soul's departure. This is also how the entry is depicted, depicted, whether whether it it isis aa case case of of aa holy, holy, miraculous miraculous soul into into the the world world is soul conception - the Angel of the Annunciation presenting the Virgin with aa conception the Angel of the Annunciation presenting the Virgin with l'naked child, child, Jesus's Jesus's soul soul 14 or aa case case of of aa perfectly perfectly natural natural conception: conception: -or naked a couple couple resting resting in in bed bed apparently apparently quite quite innocently, innocently, but but something something must must a have happened, happened, for for aa naked naked child child can can be be seen seen flying flying through through the the air air and and have entering the woman's moutll 'the creation of the soul by natural natural of the human soul mouth 'the creation woman's the by entering
the size size the
of the the of
living.
15 means '.16 means'.
In the course course of of the the fourteenth fourteenth and and particularly particularly the the fifteenth fifteenth century, century, In the these medieval medieval types types would would develop develop further, further, but but in in the the direction already direction already these llave already already observed observed that tlIat the the indicated in the the thirteenth thirteenth century. century. We have indicated in
We
angel-cum-altar-boy would go on playing its part, without very angel-cum-altar-boy would go on playing its part, without very much the other change, painting of the fifteenth century. On the other in the die religious religious painting of the fifteenth century. change, in hand the theme of the Holy Holy Childhood never cease in would never cease developing of the Childhood would hand the theme developing in - its both and variety from the fourteenth century on and its popularity and the and from fourteenth on both scope century variety popularity scope fecundity bearing witness to the progress, in ilie collective consciousness, fecundity bearing witness to the progress, in the collective consciousness, of that idea idea of observer can can dIstinguish of childhood which only a keen keen observer childhood which of that distinguish only a in and which did not exist at all the in eleventh did not at all in the eleventh and exist thirteenth century which in the the thirteenth century century. In ilie group of Jesus and HIS mother, the artist the stress the and the of His the artist would stress In mother, century. group Jesus graceful, affectionate, naive aspects of early childhood: the child seeking child naive of the childhood affectionate, seeking aspects early graceful, its ready to kiss or caress her, the child playing breast or or getting its motlier's mother's breast getting ready to kiss or caress her, the child playing the child a leash, the child with fruit or a childhood games fruit or a bird bird on a traditional childhood the traditional leash, the games with eating its pap, the child being wrapped ill its Every in its swaddling-doilies. die child its swaddling-clothes. Every being wrapped eating pap, gesture tllat could be observed -- at least by somebody prepared to pay gesture that could be observed at least by somebody prepared to pay attention in pictorial form. to them them -- would henceforth be reproduced henceforth be attention to pictorial form. reproduced in These time to extend to time extend a long of sentinlental take a sentimental realism features of realism would would take These features long beyond iconography, which is scarcely surprising of religious frontiers of the frontiers beyond the religious iconography, which is scarcely surprising when one with landscape and genre that this this was was also the case also ilie case wimlandscape one remembers remembers tlIat genre painting. It none the less that me group Child of Virgin the that the less true true It remains remains none Virgin and child group of painting. changed the picture and became and more profane: in character character and became more and picture of profane: the changed in aa scene life. of everyday scene of life. everyday the painters Timidly then with with increasing at first, first, then painters of frequency, the increasing frequency, Timidly at all they turned religious childhood went beyond that of Jesus. First of all First to childhood of that they turned to religious beyond Jesus. the which inspired at least two new and popular least the childhood childhood of the the Virgin, at Virgin, popular inspired themes: in St the birth St Anne's Anne's the theme of the birth of the Virgin-people themes: the of the Virgin people in over bedroom fussing over the new-born child, bathing her, wrapping the her in in child, bathing her, wrapping her fussing :
THE DISCOVERY OF CHILDHOOD
37 '37
swaddling-clothes and showing her to her mother -- and the theme of the swaddling-clothes and showing her to her mother and the theme of the Virgin's education: a reading reading lesson, lesson, with with the Virgin following the words a the Virgin education: following the words Virgin's of in aa book book held held by by St Anne. Then other holy holy childhoods: St Anne. Then came came other childhoods: those those of in St the Infant Jesus's James, and the children of the holy 's playmate, St Infant St and the the the children of St John, Jesus playmate, holy James, John, women, Mary Mary Zebedee Mary Salome. and Mary Zebedee and Salome. A completely iconowomen, completely new iconography thus came into existence, presenting more and more scenes of graphy thus came into existence, presenting more and more scenes of childhood, care to gather together in similar groups these holy and taking childhood, and taking care to gather together in similar groups these holy children, with or without their their mothers. or without mothers. children, with This which generally speaking started with the fourteenth which This iconography, iconography, generally speaking started with the fourteenth century, coincided with a profusion of priors' tales and legends, such as a with of coincided priors' tales and legends, such as century, profusion those in the the Miracles Miracles de Notre-Dame. It to the seventeenth de Notre-Dame. It continued continued up the seventeenth those in up to century and its can be followed in painting, tapestry and in and its development can followed be development painting, tapestry and century sculpture. shall in any case have occasion to return to it with regard shall in have occasion to return case to it We with any regard sculpture. to the religious practices practices of of childhood. childhood. the religious to From this this religious religious iconography lay iconography iconography of childhood, a lay childhood, a iconography of eventuilly detached itself in the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries. This and in the fifteenth sixteenth This itself detached centuries. eventually was not yet yet the the portrayal portrayal of the child child on own. Genre painting was was of the on its its own. Genre painting was not developing at this time by means of the transformation of a conventhe means of this time transformation of a at convenby developing tional iconography inspired by the antiquo-medieval concept tional allegorical allegorical iconography inspired by the antique-medieval concept of Nature: ages life, seasons, senses, elements. pictures and and elements. Subject of life, of Nature: seasons, senses, Subject pictures ages of anecdotal paintings began began to to take take the the place place of of static static representations representations of of anecdotal paintings symbolic characters. shall cause to deal with this at shall have to have cause deal We with at this evolution evolution characters. symbolic 16 Let us merely note here that the the child became one some length later later on. Let us merely note here that child became on.16 one some length of most frequently frequently found found in these anecdotal anecdotal paintings: paintings: the in these the the characters characters most of the child with his the child with his playmates, were often his child with were the who often his family; child with playmates, family; adults; the child in aa crowd, but very very defmitely his in his child in crowd, but adults; the definitely 'spotlighted' 'spotlighted' in mother's arms, arms, or or holding holding her her hand hand or playing or piddling; the the or playing or even even piddling; mother's child the crowds miracles or or martyrdoms, martyrdoms, listening to crowds watching child among watching miracles listening to among the sermons, or liturgical rites such as presentations or circumrites such as or circumor following sermons, presentations following liturgical cisions; the child an apprentice apprentice to to aa goldsmith goldsmith or a painter painter or as an or a or child serving cisions the serving as an old some or the child at school, an old and popular theme at child or the theme some other other craftsman; school, craftsman; popular which went back back to to the the fourteenth and would go go on inspiring fourteenth century which went century and inspiring subject paintings up to to the the nineteenth nineteenth century. century. subject paintings up as a rule devoted to a general general rule the These subject subject paintings paintings were not not as to the These a great in a cases exclusive portrayal of of childhood, but in many cases there were there were exclusive portrayal childhood, but great many children the characters depicted, both principal principal and secondary. characters depicted, children among secondary. among the the following ideas: first, children mingled with adults And this children ideas: adults the this suggests first, mingled with following suggests the for in life, and any gathering for the purpose of work. relaxation or relaxation or in everyday and work, purpose any gathering everyday life, sport brought together both children and adults; secondly, painters were children both adults; secondly, painters sport brought together for its childhood for particularly fond depicting childhood its graceful graceful or or picturesque picturesque of depicting fond of particularly ;
,
THE IDEA IDEA OP OF CHILDHOOD CHILDHOOD THE
38
qualities (the taste for the picturesque anecdote anecdote developed developed in in the the fifteenth fifteenth
taste for the picturesque qualities (the
and sixteenth sixteenth centuries centuries and and coincided coincided with with the the appreciation appreciation of ofchildhood's childhood's and charms), and they delighted in stressing the presence of a child in aa group group in in the of a child and stressing presence they delighted charms), or aa crowd. crowd. Of these these two two ideas ideas one one now strikes strikes us us as as out out of ofdate, date, for for today, today, or as also also towards towards the the end end of of the the nineteenth nineteenth century, century, we tend tend to to separate separate the the as world of of children children from from that that of of adults; adults; the the other other foreshadows foreshadows the the modern modem world idea idea
of childhood. childhood. of
* * * The origins origins of of the the themes themes of of the the angel, angel, the the holy holy childhoods, childhoods, and and their their The subsequent iconographical developments date as far back as the thirteenth date as far back the as thirteenth subsequent iconographical developments century; two types of child portrayal appeared in in the the fifteenth fifteenth century; two new types of child portrayal appeared century: the portrait and the putta. The child. as have seen, was not not was The as we have and the the child, seen, putto. portrait century: missing from the Middle Ages, at least from the thirteenth century on, at from the least thirteenth Middle the from century on, Ages, missing but there there was was never never aa portrait portrait of of him, him. the the portrait portrait of of aa real real child, child. as as he he was was but at a certain certain moment moment of of his his life. life. at a 17 the child In the funeral funeral effigies effigies listed in the the Gaigni&res Gaignieres Collection, Collection,17 the child listed in In the appeared only at a very late date, in the sixteenth century Curiously in the sixteenth late a at date, century Curiously very appeared only not on his his own tomb tomb or that of enough, his first appearance was or that of his his was not enough, his first appearance parents but on that of his the tombs of the masters of of tombs of the masters his teachers. teachers. On the that of on but parents 18 As early as 18 Bologna, the teacher was shown surrounded by his pupi1s. was his As surrounded teacher the early as by pupils. Bologna, 1378, Cardinal de La Grange, the Bishop of Amiens, had the two princes had the of the two de La Cardinal Amiens, Bishop princes Grange, 1378, he .tutored portrayed at the ages of ten and seven on a 'handsome a 'handsome and often seven on at the hadvtutored he had ages portrayed 19 his cathedral. pillar' in a picture a child child of keeping No one thought cathedral. 19 Noone in his thought of keeping a picture of a pillar* if to manhood or had died in infancy. died or in to lived to to grow had either either lived child had if that that child grow infancy. In an unimportant childhood was simply first case, In the the first case, childhood phase of which simply an unimportant phase there that of the second case, of the in the the second to keep need to no need was no case, that there was record; in any record; keep any dead it was thought that the little thing which had disappeared so that the little it was dead child, child, disappeared so thing thought soon of remembrance: there were far too many far too of remembrance: there not worthy was not life was in life soon in many worthy children was problematical. survival was whose survival was, and children whose feeling was, general feeling problematical. The general in order for order to to keep children in that one one had had several several children time remained, a long for a remained, that keep long time de As late in Le Caquet de l'accouchie, just a few. in as the the seventeenth seventeenth century, late as As a few. Faccouchde, Caquet century, just we have a woman who has has at the bedside of a the bedside have aa neighbour, standing at neighbour, standing just given birth, the mother of five 'little brats', and calming her fears her fears 'little mother five the brats', calming just given birth, with to bother bother you, will 'Before they are old old enough words: 'Before these words: with these you will enough to you, you they are 80 have or perhaps all of them.'10 A strange consolation! or of them/ of them, all consolation! half of lost half have lost them, strange perhaps ,People could not to something attached to allow themselves to become too too attached not allow themselves to something (People could is the the reason for that as loss. This is reason for certain remarks a probable certain as a This remarks loss. was regarded that was probable regarded which shock our present-day sensibility, such as Montaigne's observation: as such our observation: shock which Montaigne's present-day sensibility,
THE DISCOVERY ~. &P CHILDHOOD
.-39 39
'I three children their infancy, not without regret, but two or or three lost two children in in their have lost 'I have infancy, not without regret, but 81 on LOWson in Le I.e MalaJe MalaJe without great great sorrow',ll or Moliere's Moli&re's comment without comment on Louison in sorrow', or
imaginaire: 'The little girl doesn't count.' Most people probably felt, like
imaginaire: 'The litde girl doesn't count.' Most people probably felt, like Montaigne, that recognizable that children children had had 'neither 'neither mental mental activities activities nor nor recognizable Montaigne, 88 ss bodily shape'. shape'. Mme de de Sevigne records without without any sign of surprise of bodily Sevigne records surprise any sign a similar remark made by by Mme de when the latter fainted similar remark de Coetquen a on the latter fainted on Coetquen when receiving the news of her little daughter's death: 'She is greatly distressed receiving the news of her little daughter's death: 'She is greatly distressed
and that she will never again have one so pretty.' and says says that she will never again have one so pretty.' think today, that every child already' Nobody thought, thought, as as we ordinarily Nobody ordinarily think today, that every child already contained a man's personality. Too many many of mine die in man's personality. of them died. 'All 'All mine contained a them died. die in infancy', wrote Montaigne. This indifference was a direct and inevitable infancy', wrote Montaigne. This indifference was a direct and inevitable consequence the demography demography of of the the period. It lasted until the nineof the consequence of period. It lasted until the nineteenth century century in of the country, in so far as it was was compatible compatible in the of in the depths so far as it the teenth depths country, with Christianity, which the immortal soul in every that which respected the soul in immortal child that with Christianity, respected every child had been baptized. baptized. It is recorded that the people of Basque country It is recorded that the people of the the Basque had been country retained for for aa very the custom burying children that had of burying time the custom of had retained children that very long long time died without baptism baptism in in the the house, house, on the the garden. the threshold, or in in the died without threshold, or garden. Here may perhaps rites, of of ancient of sacrificial see a a survival sacrificial offerings, survival of ancient rites, Here we may perhaps see offerings, or rather it it may be that the child that had died too too soon was buried had died soon in in life that the child that life was or rather buried may be as bury a domestic pet, a cat or aa dog. almost as we today a a or much cat domestic almost anywhere, today bury pet, anywhere, dog. inadequately involved in life, was such unimportant little so in an unimportant little thing. so involved such an He was life, thing, inadequately that nobody nobody had fears that he might return after death to pester the return after that he death to had any fears that any might pester the living. It is to note that in the frontispiece to the Tabula in to note that the the It is interesting to Tabula frontispiece interesting living. Cebetis placed the the litde little children children in in aa sort marginal zone, sort of of marginal M6rian has has placed Cebetis Merian zone, between the earth have emerged and the life into which and have the life into which from which which they earth from between the they emerged they have not yet entered, and from which they are separated by a portico they have not yet entered, and from which they are separated by a portico bearing the inscription Introitus ad vitam. 13 This This feeling of indifference indifference feeling of inscription Introitus ad vitam. bearing the towards a too too fragile childhood is not really very far removed from the is far the not childhood towards a really very fragile callousness or Chinese Chinese societies practised the the societies which practised the Roman or of the callousness of exposure of new-born children. can understand the gulf which now understand the can We which children. new-born of gulf exposure separates our concept of childhood from that which existed before the that which existed before the separates our concept of childhood demographic revolution or its preceding stages. There is nothing about is about its or revolution nothing preceding stages. demographic this which should in the the us: it it was only natural should surprise this callousness callousness which only natural in surprise us: there are community conditions of the time. On the hand, there are grounds other hand, the other time. the of conditions grounds community for in the earliness of the idea of childhood, childhood, seeing that conconthe idea for surprise seeing that surprise in the earliness of and ditions were still unfavourable to to it. it. Statistically objectively ditions were still so so unfavourable Statistically objectively later. True, speaking, this idea should have appeared much later. there was the the True, there speaking, this idea should have appeared litde creatures, taste for for the the picturesque, picturesque, pleasing pleasing aspects aspects of the the little the idea idea of taste creatures, the be derived from the the charms charms of to be the the entertainment entertainment to the and the of childhood childhood and as ingenuous antics of infancy: 'puerile nonsense', as Montaigne said, in of Montaigne said, in ingenuous antics infancy: 'puerile nonsense',
40 4O
THE IDEA IDEA OF OF CHILDHOOD CHILDHOOD THE
which we we adults adults take take an an interest interest 'for 'for our our amusement, amusement, like like monkeys'. mo"nkeys'. 2' which But this idea could quite easily go hand in hand with indifference towards But this idea could quite easily go hand in hand with indifference towards 24
the
essential, definitive defmitive personality personality of of the the child: child: the the immortal immortal soul. soul. The The the essential, new taste taste for for the the portrait portrait indicated indicated that that children childrenwere were emerging emerging from from the the new
anonymity in which their slender chance of ofsurvival survivalhad had maintained maintainedthem. them. in fact fact quite quite remarkable remarkable that that at at that that period period of ofdemographic demographic wastage wastage It isis in It aa child of anyone should have felt a desire to record and keep the likeness of child likeness and the record to desire a felt have should keep anyone of ofaa child child that that was was dead. dead. The The portrait portrait of the the that would would go go on on living living or or of that dead child child in in particular particular proves proves that that that that child child was was no no longer longer generally generally dead considered as as an an inevitable inevitable loss. loss. This This solicitous solicitous attitude attitude did did not not exclude exclude considered or eliminate the opposite attitude, that of Montaigne, the neighbour at or eliminate the opposite attitude, that of Montaigne, the neighbour at the mother's mother's bedside, bedside, and and Molire: Moliere: down down to to the the eighteenth eighteenth century century they they the coexisted. It It was was only only in in the the eighteenth eighteenth century, century, with with the the beginning beginning of of coexisted. idea the that Malthusianism and and the the extension extension of of contraceptive contraceptive practices, practices, that the idea Malthusianism of necessary necessary wastage wastage would would disappear. disappear. of The appearance appearance of of the the portrait portrait of of the the dead dead child child in in the the sixteenth sixteenth century century The of feelings. in the feelings. accordingly marked a very important in the history moment a marked history important very accordingly This portrait portrait was was aa funeral funeral effigy effigy to to begin begin with. with. The child child was not not at at first first This the show portrayed alone, alone, but but on on his his parents' parents' tomb. tomb. Gaignifcres's Gaignieres's records records the portrayed 25 feet. child by his his mother's side and very tiny, tiny, or else at his parents' parents' feet. 25 at his or else and very mother's side child by These tombs all back to sixteenth century: the sixteenth to the 1560. date back 1530* 1560. 1503, 1530, all date These tombs century: 1503, that of note that us note let us Among the interesting tombs in Westminster Abbey, let in Westminster tombs the Abbey, interesting Among 26 the in 1586. died in of Winchester, I586. 26 The recumbent Winchester, who died Marchioness of the Marchioness her tomb front of her the front figure qf the Marchioness isis life-size; life-size; represented represented on the figure of the Marchioness the tiny on the Marquess, husband the her husband are her scale are smaller scale tiny on aa smaller kneeling, and the Marquess, kneeling, from 1615 a tomb dating tomb Westminster too, At Westminster 1615 child. At dead child. too, on a of aa dead dating from tomb of in a a pair are represented to of Shrewsbury and Countess Countess of the Earl Earl and pair to 1620, represented in Shrewsbury are 1620, the at their their feet, of with their kneeling at little daughter their little feet, with recumbent figures, of recumbent kneeling daughter figures, who children who the children that the here that her It should be noted noted here in prayer. folded in hands folded her hands prayer. It should be is the whole whole family surround themselves: the dead themselves: not always are not dead are the dead surround the family is always dead time when the time at the when were at it were gathered round the as as if if it that family, of that heads of the heads round family, gathered are still still alive alive the the who are children who they breathed their last. But the children But beside beside the they breathed their last. is always an an there is sculptor has portrayed those who are dead; there are already who those dead; has always already portrayed sculptor hold aa cross cross in in and indication them: they are smaller and they hold are them: smaller to distinguish indication to they they distinguish or else else aa skull skull their on John Coke's tomb at 1639) or at Hoikham, tomb Coke's Holkham, on their hands hands (as 1639) John (as four boys are four there are and (on Cope of Ayley's tomb at Hambledon, tomb at Hambledon, 1633, 1633, there boys and (on Cope of Ayley's are holding one and one three around the dead parents, and one boy and one girl are and dead the around three girls girl boy holding parents, girls aa skull). skull). an extremely is an there is interAt des Augustins Musee des in the the Musee Toulouse in At Toulouse extremely interAugustins there 27 27 The volets Collection. are Du Mege Collection. The volets are esting triptych that comes from the the Du from comes that Mige esting triptych anonymity in which their slender chance
THE DISCOVERY ,OF OF CHILDHOOD
. 41 41
dated either side the Cross' the donors, a side of of a dated 1610. 1610. On either a 'Descent from the Cross* the 'Descent from donors, a husband and wife, are depicted on their knees, together with their ages. husband and wife, are depicted on their knees, together with their ages. Both are Next to the man there is aa child, wearing what what are sixty-three. Both there is child, wearing sixty-three. Next to the was then the fashion for very little children, under five years of age: a was then the fashion for very little children, under five years of age: a girl's dress and pinafore and a big bonnet with feathers. The child is dress and pinafore and a big bonnet with feathers. The child is girl's dressed bright, rich colours, green green brocaded brocaded in in gold, gold, which throw into into in bright, rich colours, dressed in which throw relief the severity of the donors' black clothes. This woman of sixty-three of the the severity relief donors' black of sixty-three clothes. This cannot possibly have a child child of five. It a dead no doubt have a of five. an It is is clearly a doubt an cannot possibly dead child, child, no clearly only whose memory old couple and whom they they wanted son whose the old wanted treasured and only son memory the couple treasured his best to beside them them in in his show beside to show best clothes. clothes. It was pious custom custom in the old days to present churches with aa picture picture a pious was a in the It old days to present churches with or a stained-glass window, and in the sixteenth century the donor had or a stained-glass window, and in the sixteenth century the donor had himself portrayed portrayed with with his his whole whole family. family. On the the walls pillars of of himself and pillars walls and German churches one can still a great many pictures of this kind one can kind still see see a of this German churches many great pictures which family portraits. In St Sebastian's in Niimberg, in a in fact are in fact family which are portraits. In St Sebastian's in Niirnberg, in a portrait from the second half of the sixteenth century, the father is portrait from the second half of the sixteenth century, the father is shown in in the the foreground full-grown sons behind him and with two full-grown and then then sons behind foreground with aa scarcely of six boys crowded crowded together, together, hiding hiding bunch of six boys scarcely distinguishable distinguishable bunch behind each that some them are are barely barely visible. these so that each other other so some of of them behind visible. Surely Surely these must be be dead dead children. children. must A similar dated 1560, and kept in Bregenz Museum, has the similar picture, picture, dated 1560, and kept in Bregenz Museum, has the children's ages recorded banderoles: three three boys, boys, aged two on the the banderoles: recorded on children's ages one, two aged one, and aged one, two, three, four and five. But the eldest eldest four and But the five. and three; five girls, one, two, three, three; five girls, aged of five has the same size dress as the youngest youngest of has been been girl and dress size and as the one. She She has of one. girl of five has the same given her place in the family group just as if she had gone on living, but on as she had the if in her living, but family group just gone given place she been portrayed at the age she died. she died. at the when has been she has age portrayed These groups are naive, clumsy, monotonous works works without without are naive, These family clumsy, monotonous family groups style; their painters, like their models, remain or obscure. It a is a It is unknown or obscure. their remain lie their models, style; painters, different matter when when the the donor has obtained the services a celebrated celebrated of a donor has services of obtained the different matter painter: in such instances art historians have carried out the research painter: in such instances art historians have carried out the research This is is the case with required to identify the figures in a famous painting. This the case identify the figures in a famous painting. required to feet. the Meyer family which Holbein portrayed in 1526 at the Virgin's in at the Holbein the Meyer which 1526 Virgin's feet. portrayed family had died in of the six people in the picture three had died in 1526: three in the We know that the six that of 1526: picture people Jacob Meyer's wife and boys, one of whom were dead at at her two boys, and her first wife Jacob Meyer's first earlier at the of ten and the other, who is naked, at an earlier age. is shown the age and the often naked, other, age. age in the Here in in fact fact we have have aa custom became widespread the custom which became Here widespread in mid-nineteenth sixteenth and remained so until mid-nineteenth century. until the the so and remained sixteenth century century. century Versailles Museum has has aa picture picture by by Nocret Nocret portraying portraying the the families families of Versailles Louis XIV and brother; this painting is is famous because the King King and because the Louis this painting and his his brother; - like gods of Olympus. the at least the princes princes are half-naked -- the the men at least -like are half-naked gods Olympus.
42 42
THE IDEA IDEA OF OF CHILDHOOD CHILDHOOD THE
We would would draw draw attention attention to to one one detail detail here: here: in in the the foreground, foreground, at at Louis Louis
feet, N ocret has placed a framed picture showing two little feet, Nocret has placed a framed picture showing two little children who had had died died in in infancy. infancy. children who Gaignieres's records note as early as as the the end end of of the the sixteenth sixteenth century century Gaigniires's records note as early some tombs bearing effigies of children on their own: one dates from some tombs bearing effigies of children on their own: one dates from 1584, the other from 1608. The child is shown in the costume peculiar to 1584, the other from 1608. The child is shown in the costume peculiar to his age, in a dress and bonnet, like the child in the Toulouse 'Descent from his age, in a dress and bonnet, like the child in the Toulouse 'Descent from the Cross*. Cross'. When within within the the two two years years of of 1606 1606 and and 1607 1607 James James II lost lost two the she was three days old and the other at two years of of daughters, one when old and the other at two years daughters, one when she was three days age, he had them portrayed fully dressed on their tombs at Westminster, dressed on their tombs at Westminster, age, he had them portrayed fully and he he gave gave instructions instructions that that the the younger younger should should be be shown lying lying in in an an and alabaster cradle in which all the accessories the lace of her swaddlingthe lace of her swaddlingalabaster cradle in which all the accessories clothes and and her her bonnet bonnet -- should should be be faithfully faithfully reproduced reproduced to to create create the the clothes illusion of reality. The inscription on the tomb gives a good idea of the illusion of reality. The inscription on the gives a good idea of the pious feeling which endowed this three-day-old child with a definite child with a definite pious feeling which endowed this three-day-old personality: Rosula Regia prae-propero Fato decerpta, parentibus erepta, erepta, ut ut in in Fato Rosula decerpta, parentibus prae-propero Regia personality: Christi Rosario Rosario reflorescat. rejlorescat. Christi Apart from these mortuary effigies, portraits of children Apart from these mortuary effigies, portraits of children shown separately from their parents were were aa rarity rarity until until the the end end of of the the sixteenth sixteenth separately from their parents century: witness the painting of the Dauphin, Charles Orlando, by the the the Charles of the witness Orlando, by Dauphin, painting century: Maitre de Moulins, another instance of pious regard regard felt for children felt for children the pious of the another instance de Moulins, Maltre who had died age. On the hand, they became very other hand, the other an early died at at an who had very they became early age. common at of the seventeenth century; it that it is clear it it is clear that seventeenth the of the beginning at the century; beginning had to preserve by means of the painter's art the the art the means of to become customary had become painter's by preserve customary epheme~al appearance of childhood. In the portraits of this this period the period the ephemeral appearance of childhood. In the portraits at the the child company with the family, just as a century earlier, at as a the with child parted earlier, century family, just parted company beginning of the sixteenth century, the family had parted company the sixteenth the of company family parted century, beginning with section of the presentation portrait. Henceforth Henceforth he the religious with the religious section of the presentation portrait. would by himself and for himself: this great the this was the and for himself: himself be depicted would be novelty great novelty depicted by .of The child would be one of its its favourite of favourite one be child seventeenth century. of the the seventeenth century. the models. the leading are countless countless examples There are models. There leading painters painters of the among the examples among period: Rubens, Van Dyck, Franz HaIs, Le Nain, Philippe de ChamFranz Nain, Hals, Rubens, Philippe Dyck, period: as in in the the picture paigne. Some of little princes, as of these these painters picture of princes, portray little painters portray paigne. II's children children Charles Van Dyck or that of James II's by that or children by I's children Charles I's by James Dyck by as the three children Largilliere; others, the offspring of great lords, such as the three children such of the lords, great offspring Largilli&re; others, 28 painted by VanDyck, the eldest of whom isis wearing sword;;28 and others, others, wearing aa sword painted by Van Dyck, the eldest of or well-to-do such as those depicted by Le Nain or Philippe as such those well-to-do bourgeois Philippe de depicted by bourgeois the child's Champaigne. Sometimes there is inscription giving the child's name there is an an Sometimes inscription giving Champaigne. the is all child all alone and as used to be the custom for adults. child is adults. Now the alone the custom for to be as used and age, age, at Grenoble), the (see Philippe de Champaigne's work at now the painter de Grenoble), painter Champaigne's (see Philippe XIV's XIV's
DISCOVERy'OF CHILDHOOD THE DISCOVERY t>JP
43 43
gathers together several children from the same family. This last is a gathers together several children from the same family. This last is a popular type of portrait. favoured by aa great many anonymous painters, of portrait, favoured by popular type great many anonymous painters, provincial art-galleries or in antique-shops. and often to be found found in to be in provincial and often art-galleries or in antique-shops. Henceforth every wanted portraits of its children, and portraits Henceforth wanted of its and portraits children, every family family portraits painted while they were still children. The custom originated in the while were still children. The custom they originated in the painted seventeenth and is with us. Photography took took over is still still with seventeenth century us. Photography over from from century and painting in the nineteenth century: the idea remained the same. in the nineteenth idea the die remained same. century: painting Before finishing with with the portraits, we must must mention mention the the pictures pictures of of Before finishing the portraits, children the plaques plaques placed placed in to record record the the making making children on ex-votos, in churches churches to ex-votos, the or prayer. There are some some in the museum ofpuy of a a prayer. There are in the of Puy Cathedral, or granting Cathedral, granting of and the Eighteenth Century Exhibition of 1958 Paris revealed revealed an an in Paris and the Exhibition of 1958 in Eighteenth Century astonishing portrait of a sick child which must also be an ex-voto. astonishing portrait of a sick child which must also be an ex-voto. Thus. although did not not greatly greatly change conditions did Thus, although demographic change demographic conditions between the the thirteenth centuries, and child and seventeenth and although seventeenth centuries, thirteenth and between although child mortality remained remained at very high high level, level, aa new sensibility granted thes6 at a a very sensibility granted these mortality fragile, threatened creatures a characteristic characteristic which world had had hitherto hitherto the world threatened creatures a which the fragile, failed to recognize recognize in them: as as if if it were only then that the common in them: it were that the failed to only then conscience discovered that the child's immortal. There too was was immortal. soul too There had discovered that the child's soul conscience had can be no no doubt the importance accorded to the child's personality to the accorded child's that the doubt that can be personality importance was linked the growing life and and manners. of Christianity manners. influence of linked with with the was Christianity on life growing influence This interest shown shown in in the the child child preceded preceded by by more than a century century the the than a This interest change in demographic conditions which can be roughly dated from dated can be from which conditions in roughly demographic change Jenner's great discovery. Correspondences such that of General de as that such as General de Jenner's great discovery. Correspondences 29 lll show Martange that certain families insisted at that time on having their time that their insisted at certain families that show having Martange children vaccinated; this this precaution against the a state of reveals a state of the smallpox children vaccinated; smallpox reveals precaution against mind which which must must have have favoured practices at at the the samej other hygienic favoured other mind same/ hygienic practices time. producing producing aa reduction the death-rate which was was counterbalanced counterbalanced death-rate which in the reduction in time, the of the birth-rate, birth-rate. v to an increasingly widespread control control to some an some extent y^ extent by increasingly widespread by
* * * the Middle Ages Another type of of child portraiture unknown to to the Ages is is the the child portraiture Another type
the end of the putto. the naked child. The putto putto made its the its appearance at appearance at the putto, the naked child.
fourteenth and obviously represented aa revival revival of the the Hellenistic Hellenistic fourteenth century century and obviously represented The theme of the the naked child was immediately immediately welcomed with naked child The theme of extraordinary enthusiasm. even in France, where Italian Italian art art was enenextraordinary enthusiasm, even in France, his Due countering a certain native resistance. The Duc de Berry, according to his resistance. a certain native Berry, according countering a room words inventories. had a 'children's room', in other a hung with other in a had 'children's room', hung inventories, tapestries decorated with putti. Van Marie MarIe wonders 'whether sometimes tapestries decorated with p uttL word "children" did not the scribes for the inventories did not use use the the word" children I t the scribes responsible responsible for the inventories
Eros. Eros.
44 44
THE IDEA OF CHILDHOOD
to denote denote these these semi-pagan semi-pagan angels, angels, these these putti putti who so so often often adorned adorned the the to 80 foliage of tapestries in the second half of the fifteenth century.'80 foliage of tapestries in the second half of the fifteenth century/ In the the sixteenth sixteenth century century the the putto putto invaded invaded the the world world of of painting painting and and In became an ornamental motif which was repeated ad nauseam. Titian in became an ornamental motif which was repeated ad nauseam. Titian in or rather abused it: witness the 'Triumph of Venus , in the particular used witness the 'Triumph of Venus' in the particular used or rather abused it: Prado. Prado. The seventeenth seventeenth century century showed showed no sign sign of of tiring tiring of of it, it, whether whether in in The Rome, in Naples, or at Versailles, where the putti still kept the old name Rome, in Naples, or at Versailles, where the putti still kept the old of marmousets. marmousets. Religious Religious art art succumbed succumbed to to them, them, thanks thanks to to the the transtransof formation of the medieval angel-cum-altar-boy into a putto. Henceforth, formation of the medieval angel-cum-altar-boy into a putto. Henceforth, no longer longer be be with one one exception exception (the (the guardian guardian angel) angel) the the angel angel would would no with the adolescent adolescent still to be be seen seen in in Botticelli's Botticelli's paintings: paintings: he he too too had had become become still to the aa little little naked naked Eros, Eros, even even if, if, in in order order to to satisfy satisfy post-tridentine post-tridentine modesty, modesty, his nudity nudity was was concealed concealed behind behind clouds, clouds, mists mists and and veils. veils. his The putto's putto's nudity nudity spread spread even even to to Jesus Jesus and and the the other other holy holy children. children. The If the the artist artist was was reluctant reluctant to to adopt adopt this this complete nudity, he he simply it If complete nudity, simply made it aa little little more more discreet, taking care care not not to Jesus too clothes: He to give too many discreet, taking give Jesus many clothes: 31 or His mother undoing undoing His was shown with His His swaddling-clothes,31 or His His mother was shown with swaddling-clothes, shoulders were uncovered. Pere du Colombier has already P&re du has uncovered. Colombier and His were His legs shoulders and already legs pointed out with regard to the paintings by Lucca della Robbia in the pointed out with regard to the paintings by Lucca della Robbia in the Hopital des Innocents that it was impossible to portray childhood without Hopital des Innocents that it was impossible to portray childhood without 82 The taste for child nudity was obviously linked with stressing its nudity.BI The taste for child nudity was obviously linked with stressing its nudity. the taste for classical begun to had even even begun which had to affect affect taste for classical nudity the general nudity which general and it the whole of modem portraiture. But and it affected affected But it it lasted lasted much longer the whole of modern portraiture. longer ornamental of the Villa Borghese of the or the Versailles or the ceiling Villa in art: witness witness Versailles ornamental art: ceiling Borghese in putto corresponded to something far deeper than Rome. far to for the the putto than taste for Rome. The taste something deeper corresponded the which can be ascribed ascribed only can be to a a for classical classical nudity, taste for the taste nudity, something something which only to broad of interest in childhood. in childhood. of interest broad surge surge Like the soul, a symbol of the or a a holy or an an medieval child child -- a the medieval Like the soul, or child, or holy child, symbol of - the angelic being putto was never a real, historic the child in in either a historic child never either was the the real, putto angelic being fifteenth remarkable in in that This is is all all the the more remarkable that or the sixteenth century. the sixteenth fifteenth or century. This the putto originated and developed at the same time as the at the time and as the the theme of the the putto theme of developed originated sixteenth century But the children in fifteenth and sixteenth portraits child in fifteenth the children But child portrait. century portraits portrait. are ever, naked children. Either they are are wrapped in or scarcely are never, never, or wrapped in scarcely ever, naked children. Either they 83 or in swaddling-clothes even when they are portrayed kneeling in prayer,A are or even prayer, they portrayed kneeling swaddling-clothes station. Nobody else their age the dress dress of their else they are shown wearing age and station. wearing the Nobody they are could he was very even when he historic child, in the visualize the the historic the could visualize child, even small, in very small, nudity of the mythological and ornamental child, and this distinction the and ornamental this of distinction child, nudity mythological remained a long in force for a remained in force for time. long time. to be the the application The final child iconography final phase of the the iconography was to phase of child application of
THE DISCOVERY 10f! O* CHILDHOOD
• 45 45 .
putto's ornamental nudity to the child portrait. and this too was to take putto's ornamental nudity to the child portrait, and this too was to take pla.ce True. a few portraits of naked children in the the seventeenth seventeenth century. place in century. True, a few portraits of naked children are to be noted in the sixteenth century. are comparatively rare. are to be noted in the sixteenth century, but but they they are comparatively rare. One of the oldest is probably the child in Holbein's of the Meyer of the oldest is probably the child in Holbein's painting painting of the Meyer family who had died in infancy (1521). Them too, in one of had died in infancy (1521). Then too, in one of the in the halls halls in family Innsbruck Palace, there is a fresco in which Maria Theresa wanted Innsbruck Palace, there is a fresco in which Maria Theresa wanted to to gather a dead princess is all her her children: children: next next to to the the living, together all gather together living, a dead princess is portrayed draped state of nudity. in a a very very chastely portrayed in chastely draped state of nudity. 84 Philip II in a dedicatory In a picture In a Titian of of 1571 or 1575," 1571 or I575, picture by by Titian Philip II in a dedicatory gesture is shown holding out to Victory his son, the child child Ferdinand, son, the Ferdinand, who gesture is holding out to Victory his is putto, and is completely naked: he looks looks like like Titian's Titian's usual usual putto, and he he seems seems to to be be completely naked: he finding putti were at the situation situation extremely the putti often depicted were often finding the funny: the extremely funny: depicted at play. play. In In 1560 Veronese in in accordance with custom accordance with custom portrayed the CucinaCucina1560 Veronese portrayed the Fiacco the in front of the Fiacco family front of the Virgin and Child: Child: three three men, men, including family in Virgin and including the fathel', a one woman -- the the mother mother -- and and six six children. children. On the the far far right father, one right a woman is by the the picture: in half is almost almost cut cut in half by the edge of the she is is holding edge of picture: she holding aa naked naked child just as child in in her her arms arms just as the the Virgin is holding the a Child, a Virgin is holding the Holy Holy Child, resemblance the dress stressed by the fact fact that the woman is resemblance stressed that the is not not wearing the dress by the wearing of time. Pushed Pushed to one side side as as she she is, her time. to one she cannot cannot be the mother of her be the mother of of the the is, she 85 A midfamily: perhaps she youngest child. she is is the the wet-nurse wet-nurse of of the the youngest child. sli midfamily: perhaps sixteenth painting by the Dutchman P. P. }Ertsen sixteenth century a family: ^Ertsen shows shows a by the century painting family: the father, aa boy boy about about five, of four, and the mother sitting with a a girl the father, five, a girl of four, and the mother sitting with a 86 naked her lap. lap.86 in her naked child child in There have been other cases which more more extensive research to have been other cases which extensive research are sure sure to There are would bring to light, but but they were not numerous enough to create a not numerous to to light, create a would bring they were enough general taste. taste. general In the seventeenth seventeenth century, century, portrayals portrayals of of this this sort became more more sort became In the numerous and more typical: typical: witness witness the the portrait portrait at Helen at Munich of of Helen numerous and more Fourment carrying carrying her her naked naked son, is distinguished distinguished from from the the ordinary ordinary Fourment son, who is putto not only by the resemblance to his mother but also by a plumed to his mother but a also resemblance the not by plumed only by putto bonnet of of the the sort sort that that children children wore at at the the time. time. The youngest youngest of of bonnet Charles I's I's children children painted painted by by Van Dyck Dyck in in 1637 1637 is is shown next next to to his his Charles half covered covered by by the the linen linen on which which he he brothers and and sisters, sisters, naked, naked, and and half brothers has has been been laid. laid. 'When. in writes L. L. Hautecoeur, Hautecoeur. 'Le 'Le Brun portrays portrays the the banker banker in 1647: 'When, 1647,' writes and collector collector Jabach Jabach in in his his Rue Saint-Merri Saint-Merri house, house. he he shows us us this this and with his on powerful casually dressed, with his stockings pulled anyhow. man dressed, anyhow, stockings pulled powerful casually displaying his latest acquisition to to his his wife wife and son son ... •.. his his other other children children displaying his latest acquisition the last-born, last-born, naked naked as as an an Infant Infant Jesus, Jesus. is is lying lying on aa cushion, cushion, are present: present: the are
46
THE IDEA IDEA OP OF CHILDHOOD CHILDHOOD THE
and one one of ofhis his sisters sisters isis playing playing with withhim/ him.'87 The The litde littleJabach, Jabach. more more than than and the naked naked children children of of Holbein, Holbein. Veronese, Veronese, Titian, Titian, Van VanDyck and even even the Dyck and Rubens, has has exactly exacdy the the same same pose pose as as that that of ofthe the modern modern baby baby in in front front of of Rubens, 87
the studio studio photographer's photographer's camera. camera. Henceforth Henceforth the the nudity nudity of of the the little little the child was was to to be be aa convention convention of ofthe the genre, genre, and and all all the the little little children children who who child
had always always been been so so ceremoniously ceremoniously dressed dressed up up in in the the time time of ofLe Nain and and Le Nain had Philippe de de Champaigne Champaigne would would be be depicted depicted naked. naked. This This convention convention isis to to Philippe be found found both both in in the the work work of ofLargilliere, the painter painter of ofthe the upper upper middlemiddlethe be Largilliere, class, and in that of Mignard, the the court court painter: painter: the the Grand Grand Dauphin's Dauphin's class, and in that of Mignard, in the the painting by by Mignard Mignard in in the the Louvre, Louvre, isis lying lying naked naked youngest child, child, in painting youngest on aa cushion cushion by by his his mother, mother, just just like like the the litde littleJabach. Jabach. on
is completely completely naked, naked, as as in in Mignard's Mignard's portrait portrait of of the the 38 the Comte de de Toulouse, Toulouse,38 where where his his nudity nudity isis scarcely scarcely veiled veiled by by the loop loop of of Comte a ribbon ribbon which which has has come come undone undone for for the the occasion, occasion, or or in in Largillifcre's Largilliere's a 89 or else portrait of a child holding aa billhook; billhook ;39 he is is dressed dressed not not in in aa real real or else he portrait of a child holding at the the time time but but in in aa ntglige neglige costume similar similar to to the the clothes clothes generally generally worn at costume which fails fails to to cover cover his his nudity nudity and and indeed indeed often often reveals reveals it: it: witness witness the the which children's portraits portraits by by Belle Belle in in which which the the legs legs and feet feet are are bare, bare, or or children's shift. a but Mignard's Duc de Bourgogne, dressed in nothing but a flimsy shift. in nothing dressed de Due flimsy Bourgogne, Mignard's no need need to to follow further the the history history of this this theme, theme, which There follow any is no There is any further its conclusion conclusion by now had become conventional. found again at at its It can can be be found conventional. It become had now again by in albums and studio shop windows of yesterstudio photographers' and albums in the the family yestershop photographers' family - for for they the pose just for were day: babies baring their little for the bottoms little bottoms their babies they pose just baring day: - and little and little boys normally covered, swaddled or breeched or breeched swaddled boys covered, normally carefully carefully who were girls in nothing the occasion occasion in for the dressed for were dressed transparent pretty transparent nothing but aa pretty girls who shift. child whose likeness in a likeness was not preserved child not aa single was not There was shift. There preserved single a of the Renaissance: a nude directly inherited from the of the the putti from inherited nude study, putti study, directly taste (bourgeois collective taste remarkable in in the the collective of the the persistence remarkable example (bourgeois persistence example of ornamental. was as of a theme which was originally ornamental. which of a theme as lower-class) much as as much originally lower-class) on went on The rediscovered in fifteenth century, in the the fifteenth of antiquity, Eros of The Eros century, went antiquity, rediscovered and nineteenth and the nineteenth of as a model for the 'artistic of the serving 'artistic portraits' for the a model as portraits' serving twentieth centuries. twentieth centuries. Either the the child child Either
is
* * * to notice notice the failed to the have failed not have The will not the preceding of the reader of The reader pages will preceding pages the themes of themes of evolution in the importance of the seventeenth in the evolution of the of seventeenth century the of century importance of that children on childhood. that portraits of children on seventeenth century in the the seventeenth was in It was childhood. It portraits century in the the seventeenth was in It was seventeenth their and commonplace. numerous and became numerous own became their own commonplace. It older tended to plan much a much older genre, tended to century too that the family portrait, a the too that genre, plan family portrait, century
THE DISCOVERY DISCOVERY *0P 'G'f CHILDHOOD CHILDHOOD THE
47' 47
itself around around the the child. child. This This concentration concentration on on die the child child isis particularly particularly striking in the Rubens family group in which the mother is holding the the is the mother in which in Rubens the holding family group striking 40 and by the the shoulder shoulder while while the the father father has has him him by by the the hand, hand,.a and in in the the child by child works of of Franz Franz Hals, Hals, Van VanDyck and Lebrun, Lebrun, whose whose children children kiss, kiss, cuddle cuddle works Dyck and and generally generally enliven enliven the the group group of ofserious serious adults adults with with their their games games or or their their and affection. The The baroque baroque painter painter depended depended on on them them to to give give his his group group affection. portrait the dynamism that it lacked. In In the the seventeenth seventeenth century century too, too, portrait the dynamism that it lacked. subject painting gave the child a place of honour, with countless countless with a of the child honour, place subject painting gave childhood scenes scenes of of aa conventional conventional character: character: the the reading reading lesson, lesson, in in childhood which the the theme theme of of the the Virgin's Virgin's lesson lesson survived survived in in lay lay form fonn from from the the which religious iconography of the the fourteenth fourteenth and and fifteenth fifteenth centuries, centuries, the the music music religious iconography of of boys boys and and girls girls reading, reading, drawing drawing and and playing. playing. One lesson, and and groups groups of lesson, could go go on on indefinitely indefinitely listing listing these these themes themes which which were were extremely extremely could common in in painting, painting, especially especially in in the the first first half half of of the the century, century, and and in in common the engraving later. Finally, as have seen, it was in the second half of the of half in second the it was as have we later. seen, Finally, engraving seventeenth century century that that nudity nudity became became an an essential essential convention convention in in child child seventeenth portraiture. doubt the discovery of childhood began in the thirteenth the thirteenth in of childhood the doubt No began discovery portraiture. fifteenth art in in the the fifteenth century, and its progress can be traced in the history of art century, and its progress can be traced in the history of its development became more and But the the evidence evidence of of its centuries. But sixteenth centuries. and sixteenth development became the sixteenth century and and plentiful and from the end of the sixteenth century end of from the and significant significant plentiful throughout the seventeenth. the seventeenth. throughout children's This in little little children's time in that time at that interest shown at the interest is confirmed confirmed by This is by the We have already noted, in chapter, habits in the the preceding have and 'jargon'. habits and noted, chapter, preceding already jargon*. how were given new names: bambins, pitchouns and fan/am. People names: were bambins, how they People andfanfans. pitchouns given they also picking up their and children's expressions their children's themselves by amused themselves also amused expressions up by picking nannies using their vocabulary, that their nannies is say, the vocabulary used by their used the is to to that their by vocabulary say, vocabulary, using the most when to them. It for literature, a rare rare thing It is is a literature, even of the when speaking thing for speaking to them. traces popular kind, to preserve traces children's Yet some such traces children's jargon. of traces of to kind, jargon. preserve popular will you further glory are Commedia: 'What further Divina Commedia: the Divina in the found in to be be found are to you glory will before you died before leave an aged flesh if had died had have if you than flesh than an leave if you have if you you aged you 1 in the the existed in stopped sayingpappo and dindi.'61 is The word existed bread. is bread. dindi.'* Pappo and Pappo stopped saying pappo in one one of the is to to be found in of Dante's time: French le papin. It time: Ie French language papln. It is language of Dante's of feeds the picture child who feeds little child Miracles 'the little of 'the that of de Notre-Dame, Miracles ae picture of Notre-Dame, that to Jesus in Our Lady's arms'. But is really confined to is the the word papin But arms'. in Our really papin Lady's Jesus of familiar the to childhood, or does it not rather belong to the familiar speech of everyday rather not it does everyday or speech belong childhood, other sixteenthsixteenthlike other life? de Notre-Dame, Miracles de Notre-Dame, like the Miracles as it it may, Be that that as life? Be may, the from childhood for taste for century texts, bears witness to a certain taste childhood painted from certain a to witness bears painted century texts, the seventeenth seventeenth before the are unusual life. are unusual before children's jargon to children's But references references to life. But jargon in abundance. abundance. found in be found to be are to century. In the seventeenth century they are century. In the seventeenth century they and Stella, Bouzonnet of prints To a collection by Bouzonnet and Stella, collection of a To take one example, take one prints by example, itself
*
THE IDEA IDEA OF 011 CHILDHOOD
48
42 this collection contains dated 1657 I657:0 a series series of of engravings engravings showing showing putti putt; thk collection contains a dated at play. play. There There is is nothing nothing original original about about the the drawings, drawings, but but the the captions, captions, at 1
the
written in in appalling appalling doggerel, doggerel, speak speak the jargon jargon of of infancy infancy and and also also written schoolboy slang, for the of infancy were still anything but clear at at of for the Emits were but clear still infancy anything schoolboy slang, putti playing playing with with hobby-horses hobby-horses is is entitled entitled the time. time. A plate plate showing showing putti the
limits
A
'LeDada'. 'LeDada'.
Some putti putti are are playing playing at at dice. dice. Some One goes goes away, away, and and number number two two Consoles himself himself with with his his toutou. toutou. Consoles
The papin papin of of the the fourteenth fourteenth and and fifteenth fifteenth centuries centuries must must have have been been The of French bourgeois children, possibly dropped, at least from the speech of French the least from at children, bourgeois speech possibly dropped, because it it was was not not confined confined to to infancy. infancy. But But other other childish words had had childish words because appeared which are still in use today: toutou and dada. and toutou in use dada. are still which today: appeared Apart from from this this nursery nursery language, the putti putti also also use use school school slang slang or or the the language, the Apart slang of military academies. In the caption to a drawing of a sledge game a of to a In the academies. of drawing sledge game military caption slang the word word populo, populo, from Latin, is the same childish sense, is used. used. In In the same childish school Latin, from school the sense, Mme de would refer to Mme de Grignan's children as ce petit as refer to de children ce would de Sevigne petit Grignan's Sevigne peuple. One child shows exceptional skill is referred to as ce cadet, a as a skill is referred to ce shows who child cadet, exceptional peuple. term used in the academies academies where where young young gentlemen gentlemen at at the the beginning beginning of of in the term used the taught fencing, riding and war. and the the arts of war. arts of were taught seventeenth century the seventeenth fencing, riding century were we are told that children go and play tennis as Under and tennis as are told that children another picture, Under another play go picture, soon have campos: an academy expression, a military term, which a which an have soon as as they term, academy expression, military campos: they means to have be can be in everyday It was was widely used in leave'. It have leave'. means •'to widely used everyday speech, speech, and can found Again, we are shown some children bathing children are de Sevigne. in Mme de found in bathing Sevigne. Again, and told that health of their camarades. of their camarades. are drinking to the the health the others others are that the are told and are drinking to This further than not date back further than did not date back or at at least least did was also also new or which was This term, term, which the was obviously of military origin (possibly it of was sixteenth century, late sixteenth the late obviously military origin (possibly it century, came mercenaries) and went or German-speaking Germans or the Germans from the came from German-speaking mercenaries) through be more or or less less it would always academies. Incidentally the academies. always be Incidentally it through the confined of the French middle class. It is is still still not class. It not middle of die the familiar familiar speech French to the confined to speech used the older word copain, lower-class speech, which prefers French lower-class in French used in copain, speech, which prefers the older from the medieval medieval compaing. from the compaing. But de Bergerac's In Cyrano the jargon of infancy. to the return to us return let us But let Cyrano de Bergerac's infancy. In jargon of kiss me, Le joue, Granger calls his his toutou: 'Come and kiss his son son his toutou: calls Le Pedant me, come Pidantjout, Granger in my toutou.' The word bonbon, which I suppose originated in nannies' nannies' I which toutou! bonbon, suppose originated my jargon, was admitted to everyday speech. And attempts were even made to admitted was attempts everyday speech. jargon, children to onomatopoeic renderings of the speech of children who had not the of to give speech give onomatopoeic renderings noises the yet learnt to talk. Thus Mme de Sevigne laboriously noted the noises made talk. learnt to de Svign laboriously yet de Grignan by to Mme de them to little daughter and her little Grignan who was daughter and reported reported them by her
THE DISCOVERY
Oli~ .cHILDHOOD CHILDHOOD O^
49 49
48 then in Provence: 'She talks titota, tetita, y totata.'43 then in Provence: 'She talks most most amusingly: amusingly: titota, tetita, y totata/ Already, at the beginning of the century, Heroard, Louis XIII's doctor, the of XIII's at the Louis doctor, Already, beginning century, Heroard, diary his childish pronWlciation of had carefully carefully recorded recorded in in his had his diary his charge's charge's childish pronunciation of certain words: vela for voiti, voila, equivez for ecrivez, and so on. certain words: vela for equivez for dcrivez, and so on. When she she describes her little 'little darling', de describes her little daughter, her daughter, her 'little darling', Mme de Sevigne paints genre .pictures similar to those of Le Nain or Bosse, with with Le Nain or of similar to those Bosse, Sevigne paints genre pictures the pretty pretty affectation affectation oflate engravers and eighteenth and eighteenth the of late seventeenth-century seventeenth-century engravers daughter is dark-haired little little beauty. beauty. She century besides. 'Our is artists besides. She is is a a dark-haired Our daughter century artists very pretty pretty indeed. kisses, but she indeed. Here Here she she comes. comes. She She gives very gives me sticky sticky kisses, but she kisses me, recognizes me, me, she me, she never never screams.' she laughs at me, she screams/ 'She she recognizes 'She kisses me, she laughs at calls just plain Maman [instead of Bonne Maman].' 'I simply adore her. her. 'I adore calls me just simply plain Maman [instead of Bonne Maman].' is aa happy-go-lucky happy-go-lucky style now which which is is just just 1I have have had had her her hair hair cut: cut: it it is style made for for her. her. Her Her complexion, complexion, her her chest her little little body body are are admirable. admirable. and her chest and She and one she caresses, she slaps, she She does does a a hWldred different things: one different hundred and things: she caresses, she slaps, she makes the sign sign of the cross, begs pardon, pardon, she curtsy, she blows a curtsy, she blows she drops makes the of the she begs cross, she drops a aa kiss, kiss, she shrugs her her shoulders, shoulders, she strokes, she holds her her chin: she holds chin: she shrugs she dances, she strokes, dances, she 44 in aa word word she every particular. 1 her for hours on end.''' end/ her in in I watch for hours she is is pretty in watch every particular. pretty COWltless mothers and nannies had had already already felt the same way. But But not a not a felt the same way. Countless mothers and nannies single one had had admitted these feelings were worthy worthy of being expressed expressed of being that these admitted that single one feelings were correspond in an ambitious literary scenes childhood correspond of childhood in such These literary such an ambitious form. form. These scenes of of contemporary painting and engraving: each each reflected reflected to those those of to and engraving: genre painting contemporary genre the discovery of infancy, of the little child's body, habits and chatter. the discovery of infancy, of the little child's body, habits and chatter. *
III •* III
•*
CHILDREN'S CHILDREN'S DRESS DRESS
Tr f
I
HE marked -- except marked indifference indifference shown IHE shown until until the the thirteenth thirteenth century century except
where the the infant infant Virgin where characterwas concerned concerned -- to to the the special Virgin was special characteristics of of childhood in the world of pictures: istics childhood does does not not appear appear simply simply in the world of pictures: dress of of the the the dress the period to what shows to what extent, in the the circumstances real circumstances of of real extent, in period shows was distinguished from manhood. As soon as the life, childhood childhood was from life, manhood. As soon as the child child distinguished his swaddling-band -- the abandoned his band of of doth cloth that that was was wound wound swaddling-band the band his was dressed just like the other tighdy round his body in babyhood he in he was dressed tightly body babyhood just like the other this confusion, men and women ofhis of his class. class. We find find it it difficult difficult to to imagine imagine this confusion, for so so many we who for years wore knickerbockers, the now shameful the now shameful knickerbockers, many years retarded infancy. generation we came out of knickerinsignia In my came out of knickerinsignia of retarded infancy. In my generation at the the end of the the fifth parents, urging bockers at fifth year at school: school: my to year at my parents, urging me to and be patient, the case case of an an uncle uncle of of mine mine who was a general was a and patient, quoted quoted the general to the the military academy in who had gone knickerbockers! Nowadays, gone up up to military academy in knickerbockers! Nowadays, adolescence has has spread adolescence as well well as as downstream. and sports spread upstream downstream, and upstream as sports by both adolescents and children, are tending to take the dothes, adopted both adolescents and clothes, adopted by take the children, are tending to of the clothes place the clothes which were the distinguishing marks of childhood in which were the place distinguishing marks of childhood in the the nineteenth nineteenth century century and the the early early twentieth twentieth century. century. Be Be that that as as it it may, may. if if the the period period 1900 to 1920 1920 still still prolonged prolonged kte late into into adolescence adolescence the the special special 1900 to features of dress dress confined confined to to childhood, childhood, the the Middle Middle Ages Ages features of aa form of dressed dressed every every age age indiscriminately, indiscriminately. taking taking care care only only to to maintain maintain the the ,visible vestiary vestiary signs signs of of the the differences differences in in the the social social hierarchy. hierarchy. Nothing Nothing in in .visible medieval dress dress distinguished distinguished the the child child from from the the adult. adult. In In the the seventeenth seventeenth century, century. however, however, the the child, child, or or at at least least the the child child of of whether noble quality. whether noble or middle-class, ceased to be dressed like the or middle-class, ceased to be dressed like the quality, is the the essential essential point: point: henceforth henceforth he he had had an an outfit outfit reserved reserved grown-up. This This is grown-up. for him apart apart from from the the adults. adults. This This can can be be seen seen for his his age age group, group. which which set set him from from the the first first glance glance at at any any of ofthe the numerous numerous child child portraits portraits painted painted at at the the of the of the seventeenth century. beginning seventeenth beginning century. Let Let us us consider consider the the fine fine painting painting by by Philippe Philippe de de Champaigne, Champaigne, in in Reims Reims Museum, of ofthe the seven seven children children of ofthe the Habert Habert family, family, the the eldest eldest of ofwhom whom Museum, is is ten ten years years of ofage age and and the the youngest youngest eight eight months months old. old. This This painting painting isis of of great interest interest for for our our subject subject because because the the artist artist has has inscribed inscribed die the exact exact age, age. great to to the the nearest nearest month, month, of ofeach each of ofhis his models. models. The The eldest, eldest, at at ten, ten, isis already already dressed dressed like like aa litde litde man, man, wrapped wrapped in in his his cloak; cloak; in in appearance appearance at at least, least, he he
so
50
CHILDREN'S. CHILDREN S DRESS
,51 ,5!
belongs to the world of appearance: he must the world of adults. adults. No doubt doubt it it is is just in belongs to just in appearance: he must be and school life prolongs the age of childhood; he still at and school be still at school, of life the but he school, childhood; but prolongs age will probably probably not not stay at school much longer but leave early in order to at to will school in much but leave order stay early longer he is is already wearing and whose life he mix with the men whose mix with the whose dress dress he and life he whose already wearing will be sharing in camp or court or commerce. But the two twins, will soon soon be sharing in camp or court or commerce. But the two twins, fondly holding each each other other by hand and the shoulder, shoulder, are are only the hand and the four fondly holding by the only four years nine months old: they are no longer dressed like adults but are nine months no dressed like but old: are adults are years they longer wearing a long robe, different from that worn by in that it opens a in different that worn that it from women wearing long robe, by opens is fastened fastened here with buttons, buttons, elsewhere with laces - it it in the front and is in the front and here with elsewhere with laces looks cassock. The same robe is to be found again in the like a a priest's same robe is to be found in looks like cassock. the priest's again of human life' life' by by Cebes. far removed as yet 'picture first age, not Cebes.1 The first 'picture of age, not far removed as yet from non-existence, non-existence, is naked; the the two two following are in swaddlingfrom is naked; following ages ages are in swaddlingclothes. The third, which must be about two years old and cannot yet old and cannot two must about clothes. The which be third, years yet stand by itself, is already wearing a robe, and can tell that it is is aa boy. and we a can tell that it stand by is robe, itself, boy. already wearing The fourth age, sitting astride its hobby-horse, is wearing the same long The fourth age, sitting astride its hobby-horse, is wearing the same long robe, buttoned down the middle in front cassock, as and opening buttoned the middle and like a a cassock, as front like robe, opening in with the the Habert Habert twins twins in the Philippe de Champaigne picture. This robe in the de This robe with Chatnpaigne picture. Philippe was by little boys throughout throughout the the seventeenth find it it seventeenth century. was worn by little boys century. We find again on the child Louis XIII, in countless portraits of French, English in child countless of on the Louis XIII, French, English portraits again and as late late as as the beginning of and as the beginning of the the eighteenth and Dutch Dutch children, children, and eighteenth - for century example, on the young de Bethisy painted by Belle about about on the for de Bethisy painted by Belle example, young century 22 In 1710. In this last picture the boy's robe is longer butroned down the is no last the robe the this buttoned ryio. boy's longer picture front, but it remains different from that of the girls and has no linen that of the it different from and has linen but remains front, girls accessories. accessories. The robe robe can be very very simple, like that child riding riding the the hobbythe child that of the can be The hobbysimple, like of life'. On the other hand it can be extremely horse in in the the 'picture of life'. the hand human other it can be horse extremely 'picture ornamental have aa train attached, like robe worn by by the like the the robe the young and have train attached, ornamental and young 33 Duc d'Aujou in the engraving by Arnoult. Arnoult. in the Due engraving by d'Anjou This robe in form of a cassock cassock was not not the the first of a first type of in the the form This robe type of clothing clothing of his his swaddling-band. swaddling-band. Let Let us us worn by by the the child he had had come out out of after he child after worn return to to Philippe Philippe de portrait of the Habert children. of the Habert children. de Champaigne's return Champaigne's portrait Fran~ois, is twenty-three twenty-three months months old, the youngest youngest child, old, and the child, who Francois, who is like isis eight months old, are both dressed exactly like their sister, that is say, their is to that dressed to say, both are months sister, old, exactly eight is like little women women: in in skirt, robe and apron. This is the dress the youngest This the of and dress robe the like little skirt, apron. youngest sixteenth century boys; it it had had become become customary in the the sixteenth to clothe clothe them them century to customary in boys; like like girls, who for part went on dressing like grown The women. their part for their like girls, grown dressing in the distinction between child still did not not exist exist in the case of women. adult still case of and adult child and distinction between dress which Erasmus gives us aa description description'4 of this this style which his his French French Erasmus style of dress gives us as which publisher in 1714 found easy to translate, as something still existed to still existed found in translate, 1714 something easy publisher a a are burdened in his day: day: 'They [children] are burdened with a vest, a pair of warm in his vest, pair 'They [children] :
52
THE IDEA OF CHILDHOOD
stockings, a thick petticoat, and an outer garment which encumbers the stockings, a thick petticoat, and an outer garment which encumbers the shoulders the hips hips with with aa great great quantity quantity of of stuff pleats, and and the and they shoulders and and pleats, stuff and they are given to to understand this paraphernalia paraphernalia gives gives them them aa wonderful wonderful understand that that all all this are given air.' condemned this this fashion was new new in in his his time time and and fashion which air.' ~asmus \Erasmus condemned which was recom1ireiiCtei greater freedom for young bodies; his opinion carried recomBlSfidea greater freedom for young bodies; his opinion carried little the force of accepted usage, and it was the end of the force of little weight against weight against the accepted usage, and it was the end of the eighteenth century before children's dress became and looser and and before children's dress became lighter century eighteenth lighter and looser drawing by by Rubens Rubens65 shows us allowed greater freedom freedom of of movement. shows us allowed greater movement. A drawing aa little little boy's boy's outfit to that that described described by by Erasmus: the is still outfit which which is still similar similar to Erasmus: the open robe under under which which the can be walk the skirt skirt can seen. The The child child is is starting to be seen. starting to walk open robe and is being being held by braces braces hanging hanging behind behind him, him, which which were were known he is held by and he at the time time as In Heroard's diary, which allows us to as leading-strings. at the leading-strings. In Heroard's diary, which allows us to follow Louis XIII's XIII's childhood day by read in in the the entry for follow Louis childhood day day, we read by day, entry for June 28th, 1602 (Louis XIII was nine months old at the time): 'Leadingnine XIII months old at the was 28th, (Louis time): 'LeadingJune strings have been attached to his robe to teach him to walk.'66 The same strings have been attached to his robe to teach him to walk.' The same his sister wear aa robe resembling his: his: 'Madame Louis XIII did did not not like like his sister to to wear robe resembling Louis XIII his, and and he he sent her away out of jealousy.' arrived wearing aa robe robe just just like like his, of jealousy.' arrived wearing sent her out away As long as as boys wore this feminine costume, they were said to be fa this said to be A la wore feminine As long were costume, boys they bavette, or bib and tucker'. This This was was until the age of four or five. and tucker'. 'in a a bib of or five. or 'in until the four bavette, age Jean Rou, who was born in records in in his his memoirs that he was aa in 1638, was born he was memoirs that 1638, records Jean Rou, tl1at he was sent to Harcourt College accompanied precocious child and and that he was to child sent Harcourt precocious College accompanied by aa servant-girl: 'When II was was still still in bib and tucker, that that is to say, is to in a and tucker, a bib say, servant-girl: by before II had had donned the long long robe robe with a collar came before before the the donned the before collar that that came with a of breeches ... the only one accoutred in the manner I wearing ... I I of breeches I was was the in the manner one accoutred wearing only have just just described described [i.e. dressed like a girl], so that I like a new a I was was like a have dressed like so that [i.e. girl], phenomenon in that place, such had never never been been seen before.'?7 The The as had that place, such as seen before.' phenomenon in collar of the the robe robe was was aa man's man's collar. collar. Henceforth dictated rules of rules of collar of Henceforth custom custom dictated dress for children to their age: the bib and robe as by as worn children according to their and robe dress for the bib according by age: girls, then 'the long robe robe with with aa collar' collar' which which was was also as the the also known as then 'the long girls, jaquette or 'frock'. The regulations regulations of little school, parish school, or parish of of a a little school, or school, of jaquette or 'frock*. 1654 stated that on Sunday the children should be taken to church to to taken church stated on be to that the children should 1654 Sunday hear Mass after instruction, and and that the little little children after receiving that the children hear Mass receiving religious religious instruction, should not be be mixed up up with with the bigger ones, the short robes with the short robes with the the the bigger should not ones, 8 'The little in frocks shall be placed together.'8 long robes: in 'The little ones shall robes: ones frocks be long placed together.' ~- The diary diary of Louis XIII's XIII's childhood childhood which which Heroard Heroard kept kept every of Louis every day day shows how seriously children's dress was treated from that time on: that time it children's dress treated on: it was seriously the stages of the growth which transformed the child into made visible of the transformed the child visible the which into stages growth aa man. man. These These stages as it it were, rites which which had to to be be respected become, as were, rites stages had become, respected and which which Heroard carefully carefully recorded as matters importance. On of importance. matters of recorded as ruly 17th, leading-strings were were attached to the the Dauphin's attached to robe. He 1602, leading-strings iyth, 1602, fuly Dauphin's robe.
a
CHILDREN'S'1)RBSS CHILDREN S i>RESS
13 53
was to to wear wear them them for for over over two two years; years; at at the the age age of of three three years years two two was months, he was given 'the first robe without lea.ding-strings'. The child was he The child 'the first without robe months, given leading-strings'. was delighted, delighted, and and told told the the Captain Captain of of the the Guard: Guard: "Tan "Tan [note [note the the was imitation of of childhood childhood speech], speech], II haven't haven't any any leading-strings, leading-strings, II am going going imitation to walk walk by by myself/ myselC For For his his fourth fourth birthday birthday he he wore wore aa pair pair of of breeches breeches to his robe, robe, and and aa year year later, later, on on August August 7th, 1606, 1606, his his 'child's 'child's bonnet' bonnet' under his under was taken taken away away to to be be replaced replaced by by aa man's man's hat. hat. This This too too was was aa red-letter red-letter was day: 'Now that tha.t your your bonnet bonnet has has been been taken taken away, away, you you have have stopped stopped day: being a child, you have begun to become a man.' But six: days later, the a man.' But six a have to become being child, you days later, the begun him to put his bonnet on again. Queen ordered ordered his on him to bonnet Queen again. put January 8th, 8th, 1607: 'He asked asked when he he would would be be allowed allowed to to wear wear 1607: *He January breeches [instead of the robe]. de Montglat told him that it would him that it would de told breeches of the Mme Montglat [instead robe]. be when when he he was was eight.' eight.' be On June June 6th, when he he was was seven seven years years eight eight months months old, old, Heroard Heroard 6th, 1608, 1608, when recorded with with aa certain certain solemnity: solemnity: 'Today 'Today he he was was dressed in aa doublet doublet dressed in recorded of childhood childhood [i.e. the robe] and and brelx:hes, abandoned abandoned the the clothing clothing of the and brefeches, [i.e. robe] and took cloak were days, however, when he was made he took cloak and sword. There There were and sword.' days, however, to put on the robe robe again, again, just just as he had had been been made to to put put on the the bonnet bonnet as he on the to put this: in doublet and breeches 'he is again, but he hated 'he is very happy and and in breeches he doublet but hated this: very happy and again, joyful, and does not want to put on his robe.' It can be seen that fashion be seen that fashion It can on his robe.' and does not want to put joyful, in clothing is not just a frivolous matter. Here the connection between between connection Here the a matter. in frivolous is not clothing just dress is obvious. for is obvious. it stands stands for of what and the what it dress and the understanding understanding of
7th,
1
In who boarded boarded by robe over a robe over the week wore a In the the schools, the pupils schools, the by the pupils their breeches. Cordier's written at the end of the sixteenth of the end sixteenth at the written their breeches. Cordier's dialogues, dialogues, century, describe the awakening of a boarder: 'After waking up, II got got century, describe the awakening of a boarder: 'After waking up, my doublet out I took a stool, sat on a took my and sagathy, doublet and on my of bed, out of stool, I bed, II put my sagathy, II sat put on breeches fastened my took my both on, and pulled and stockings breeches and shoes, II fastened on, II took my my shoes, pulled both stockings and breeches doublet with laces, I tied my stockings with garters with tied I with doublet to my breeches to laces, garters above my stockings my I took the took my I combed my took my the knee, hair, I belt, I knee, II took my bonnet which II my hair, my belt, '* left the bedroom bedroom... I then arranged carefully, I put on my robe, and then I left the ..• '. I my robe, arranged carefully, put In of the seventeenth century: 'Imagine Francion Francion Paris at at the the beginning In Paris beginning of the seventeenth century: 'Imagine his of breeches out coming into the classroom with his coming out ofhis breeches his underpants with into the classroom underpants coming coming his arm, his on of his shoes, his robe all askew, and his portfolio under his all robe his arm, of his on top askew, shoes, portfolio top 10 to the nose trying to give a rotten apple to one and a on the nose to another.'lO a rap another/ and one to a to rotten rap apple give trying Fliche boardingthe La FlCche at the In century, the regulations at the eighteenth In the boardingeighteenth century, the regulations 'a boarder's robe' robe' include the pupil's outfit should include 'a boarder's school stated that should outfit the that stated school pupil's l11l which had to for two years. to last last for which had years. the girls, This to be be found among not to was not in dress dress was This di1ference difference in girls, who were among the their as they -dressed came out of their swaddlingsoon as as soon like little little women as dressed like swaddlingthey at if we look closely at pictures of seventeenth-century clothes. However, look if clothes. However, pictures closely seventeenth-century
54 54
THE IDEA OF CHILDHOOD
children, that the feminine dress dress of of the the little boys as well as as as well the feminine see that shall see little boys children, we shall of the little little girls included a peculiar ornament which the women did not not a did included ornament the which of the peculiar girls wear: two broad ribbons fastened to the the robe robe behind behind each each shoulder shoulder and and fastened to broad ribbons wear: two hanging the back. These ribbons can be seen, for example, These on ribbons can the back. down be for seen, example, on hanging the Habert children on the the fourth fourth age in the from the children from the left, in the the Habert of the third of the third left, on age Tabula Cebetis (the child in a robe riding a hobby-horse), and on the Tabula Cebetis (the child in a robe riding a hobby-horse), and on the little ten-year-old girl on the early eighteenth-century ladder of the ages, little ten-year-old girl on the early eighteenth-century ladder of the ages, 'human misery or passions of of the the soul in all all its its ages.' The ribbons are or the the passions soul in 'human misery ages.' The ribbons are to be be found many child portraits, to Lancret and Boucher. in a a great child down to and Boucher. to found in Lancret portraits, great many They disappear at the end of the eighteenth century, at the time when end the at of the at the time They disappear eighteenth century, children's radically altered. one of the last portraits altered. Possibly was radically one dress was of the last children's dress Possibly portraits of child wearing wearing these ribbons down the the back back is that painted painted by these ribbons of a is that a child by Mme 12 It shows Gabrielle in 1788 and Victoire. Victoire. 12 for Mmes Adelaide Adelaide and Guiard in Gabrielle Guiard It shows 1788 for their Infante, who had had been dead some some thirty thirty years. years. Mme been dead their sister, sister, Mme Infante, Infante had had lived the age thirty-two, but but Mme Gabrielle Gabrielle Guiard of thirty-two, lived to Infante to the Guiard age of none the less portrayed portrayed her a child child with with her her nanny nanny -- the her as as a to the less desire to none the desire preserve the memory of a of thirty by showing her in her a of woman the of in her her memory thirty by showing preserve childhood reveals aa very very novel novel feeling feeling --and and this child is this child is wearing the childhood reveals wearing the ribbons down the the back back which were still about 1730, but which were still customary about ribbons 1730, but customary of fashion by the time the picture was painted. which had had gone out out of fashion the which the was time gone by picture painted. Thus in the and the eighteenth century these the seventeenth Thus in seventeenth century the early century and early eighteenth century these ribbons down the back had become sartorial indications of of childhood, had become the back sartorial indications ribbons childhood, for boys as as girls. Modem writers have not failed to be intrigued Modern as well well as writers for boys have be not failed to girls. intrigued by them. They have been mistaken for 'leading-strings' (braces for little have been mistaken for them. by They 'leading-strings' (braces for little 18 In the little children wloJ.o were were still their feet).13 in on still unsteady on children who their in the little museum In unsteady feet). Westminster Abbey, there there are a few mortuary effigies in which are a few mortuary in wax which Westminster Abbey, effigies represented the the dead dead person person and which were laid on top of of the the coffm and which were laid coffin on top represented during the funeral ceremony, a medieval practice which was continued the funeral a medieval was continued which during ceremony, practice in England England until until about about 1740. these effigies represents the little in of these 1740. One of effigies represents the little Marquess of Normanby, died at the age of three: he was dressed of who died he was at the dressed in in three: of Normanby, Marquess age aa yellow yellow silk under aa velvet velvet robe robe (the usual costume for little silk skirt skirt under little usual costume for (the children), he is of childhood. is wearing the flat ribbons ribbons of childhood. The catalogue children), and he wearing the flat catalogue describes these as as leading-strings, leading-strings, but but in in fact were cords cords describes these fact leading-strings leading-strings were which bore bore no resemblance to these these ribbons; an engraving by Guerard resemblance to an Guerard ribbons; engraving by illustrating 'manhood' shows us aa child which could a boy boy or or a a girl, shows us child which could be be a illustrating girl, dressed in aa robe, robe, wearing wearing aa Fontange Fontange hair hair style, and seen from behind: dressed in seen and from behind: style, between the two ribbons ribbons hanging hanging from from the the shoulders, one can between the can clearly shoulders, one clearly see the to help cord used used to see the cord help the to walk, walk, the the leading-string. leading-string.114' the child child to This analysis has has enabled enabled us us to pick out of dress This analysis to pick customs of dress confmed out certain certain customs confined that were generally to adopted at the end of the sixteenth the to childhood childhood that at end of the sixteenth generally adopted
CHILDREN' CHILDREN'SS,,'Q.RES ,iptES$S
35
century and preserved until the middle of the eighteenth century. These century and preserved until the middle of the eighteenth century. These customs distinguishing children's clothing and adult clothing' between children's customs distinguishing between clothing and adult clothing' reveal a new desire to put children on one side, to separate desire to reveal a a sort them by sort put children on one side, to separate them by a of what is the origin of this childhood unifonn? is of unifonn. uniform. But But what the origin of this childhood uniform? the Middle Middle Ages, Ages, of the The child's robe is is simply the child's robe of the coat of of the simply the long long coat twelfth and thirteenth centuries, before the revolution which in the case twelfth and thirteenth centuries, before the revolution which in the case of banished it in favour favour of the short and visible visible breeches, breeches. the the of men banished it in of the coat and short coat of our present-day masculine costume. Until the fourteenth ancestors ancestors of our present-day masculine costume. Until the fourteenth century everybody wore wore the or tunic; tunic; the the men's men's robe robe was was not the robe robe or not the the century everybody same as the women's often it was a shorter tunic, or else it same as the women's often it was a shorter tunic, or else it opened opened the peasants peasants in thirteenth-century calendars calendars it down the the front. in the the thirteenth-century front. On the it stops at the knee, while on the great and important it reaches to the feet. stops at the knee, while on the great and important it reaches to the feet. There was in a long long period long fitted in fact which men wore There was fact a wore aa long fitted during which period during costume, as opposed to the traditional draped costume of the or Greeks or costume, as opposed to the traditional draped costume of the Greeks Romans: this this continued continued the Gallic or fashions of the Gallic or Oriental the fashions of the Oriental barbarians barbarians Romans: which had been been added added to to the the Roman fashions during the first centuries fashions during the first which had centuries of unifonnly adopted adopted in the East East as as in West, and in the in the era. It It was was uniformly the West, and was was of our our era. of the Turkish style of dress as well. the origin the origin of the Turkish style of dress as well. In the century men abandoned abandoned the robe for short coat, the robe for the In the short fourteenth century the fourteenth coat, which was sometimes even tight-fitting, to the despair of moralists and sometimes even which was tight-fitting, to the despair of moralists and preachers who denounced the indecency indecency of of these these fashions, denounced the fashions, describing describing preachers them as signs signs of the times. times. In respectable people people of the In fact fact respectable of the the immorality them as immorality of went on wearing wearing the robe, whether whether they they were respectable respectable on account the robe, account of of went on their age age (old men are depicted wearing wearing the the robe the beginning beginning of robe until until the are depicted of their (old the seventeenth account of their station in life of their station in or on account life (magistrates, seventeenth century) the century) or (magistrates, statesmen, have never never given given up up wearing the long coat statesmen, churchmen). churchmen). Some have wearing the long coat and wear it judges, professors least on occasion occasion (barristers, it tod.ay, at and still still wear (barristers, judges, professors today, at least and priests). The priests, priests, incidentally, very near near to abandoning it, to abandoning and priests). it, incidentally, came very for the short coat had and when in had become generally in the the short coat for when when the generally accepted, accepted, and seventeenth its origins had been been completely completely scandal attending the scandal seventeenth century attending its origins century the cassock became too closely connected with his forgotten, the priest's too became his connected cassock with the closely priest's forgotten, ecclesiastical to be be in taste. A priest priest would change change out of in good out of function to ecclesiastical function good taste. to call on his his cassock to go into society, or even to call his bishop, just as an or as an into his cassock to society, bishop, just go 15 to appear at court. court. n officer would change uniform to appear at his uniform of his out of officer would change out least children Children too kept the long children of good family. at least of good Children too coat, at family. A long coat, kept the de Notre-Dame miniature in in the the fifteenth-century fifteenth-century Miracles Miracles de Notre-Dame shows aa family miniature family the father father is a short gathered round the mother's bed; the is wearing a coat, short mother's the round bed; coat, wearing gathered l16 I children are are dressed in long dressed in doublet breeches, but but the three children robes. the three robes. doublet and and breeches, long has a In the same same series the child the Infant Infant Jesus Jesus has a robe robe split down In the series the child feeding feeding the split the the side. side.
5<5
THE THE IDEA IDEA OF OF CHILDHOOD CHILDHOOD
But most of the children painted by the artists of the QuattroBut in in Italy Italy most of the children painted by the artists of the Quattrocento breeches of adults. In France and cento are are wearing the tight-fitting wearing the tight-fitting breeches of adults. In France and Germany it that this fashion failed to it seems that this seems fashion failed to find find favour favour and and that that children children Germany were in the long coat. At the beginning of the sixteenth century the were kept the in coat. the At of the sixteenth kept long beginning century the habit rule: children were always dressed in the robe. habit became became aa general rule: children were dressed in the robe. general always German of the period show four-year-old children wearing the German tapestries tapestries of the period show four-year-old children wearing the 17 Some French engravings by Jean Leclerc on long in front. front.17 Some French engravings by Jean Leclerc on robe, open open in long robe, the of children's games over their of the subject children's show the the children children wearing, subject games show wearing, over their breeches, the robe robe buttoned buttoned down down the the front front which which became breeches, the became the the uniform uniform 18 1S of their their age. of age. The Bat children flat ribbons ribbons down the the back back which which likewise likewise distinguished distinguished children from had the same origins as the robe. in the from adults adults in the seventeenth seventeenth century had the same as the robe. century origins and robes Cloaks otten had sleeves which one Cloaks and robes in in the the sixteenth sixteenth century often had sleeves which one century could into or leave empty at will. In Leclerc's picture of children into or could slip leave at will. In Leclerc's of children slip empty picture playing at chucks, of these these sleeves sleeves can can be be seen seen to to be be fastened chucks, some of fastened only playing at only by women, liked the effect stitches. People of fashion, especially by aa few stitches. People of fashion, especially women, liked the effect these hanging of these their arms into them, with sleeves: they hanging sleeves: they stopped stopped putting putting their arms into them, with the which the result that the result that the sleeves sleeves became became useless useless ornaments. ornaments. Like Like organs organs which to function, have wasted away, lost the hollow inside have ceased ceased to wasted lost the hollow function, they inside into into they away, which the looked like two broad ribbons the arm fitted, flattened out, looked like two fitted, and, broad and, Battened ribbons out, fastened behind the the shoulders: ribbons of seventeenth fastened behind shoulders: the the children's children's ribbons the seventeenth of the and eighteenth centuries centuries were were all all that that remained remained of of the the false sleeves of the and eighteenth false sleeves of the sixteenth century. century. These These atrophied atrophied sleeves sleeves were were also also to to be be found found in in other other sixteenth clothes clothes of of aa popular popuIar or or aa ceremonial ceremonial nature: nature: the the peasant peasant cloak cloak which which the the friars Ignorantin~ friars adopted as their religious costume at the beginning of as their costume the at adopted Ignorantinp religious beginning of the the eighteenth eighteenth century, century, the the first first purely purely military military uniforms uniforms such such as as those those of ofthe the musketeers, musketeers, the the livery livery of ofvalets, valets, and and finally finally the the page's page's uniform uniform -- the the ceremonial uniform uniform of of the the children children and and young young boys boys of of noble noble birth birth who who ceremonial were were placed placed with with families families for for whom they they performed performed certain certain domestic domestic services. The The pages pages of of the the age age of of Louis Louis XUI xm wore wore baggy baggy breeches breeches in in the the services. and false sixteenth-century style and false sleeves. This page's uniform tended to sleeves. This uniform tended to sixteenth-century style page's become the the ceremonial ceremonial costume costume which which was was donned donned as as aa token token of ofhonour honour become and and respect: respect: in in an an engraving engraving by by Lepautre Lepautre some some boys boys in in an an archaic archaic page's page's uniform are shown shown serving serving Mass. Mass.19I1 But But these these ceremonial ceremonial costumes costumes were were uniform are somewhat somewhat rare, rare, whereas whereas the the flat Bat ribbon ribbon was was to to be be found found on on the the shoulders shoulders of ofall all the the children, children, whether whether boys boys or or girls, girls, in in families families of ofquality, quality, whether whether aristocratic aristocratic or or middle-class. middle-class. Thus Thus in in order order to to distinguish distinguish the the child child who who had had hitherto hitherto dressed dressed just just like like an an adult, adult, features features of of old-fashioned old-fashioned costumes costumes which which the the grown-ups grown-ups had had abandoned, abandoned, sometimes sometimes aa long long time time before, before, were were reserved reserved for for his his sole sole
CHILDREN'S CHILDREN'S DRESS DRESS
'57 '57
4
use. coat and the false sleeves, use. This This was was the the case case with with the the robe robe or or long long coat and the false sleeves, also little chilc:lren still also with the bonnet with the bonnet worn worn by little children still in in their their swaddlingby swaddlingclothes: the bonnet was still in the the thirteenth clothes: in thirteenth century the bonnet was still the the noI1l1i1 normal century masculine their hair in position masculine headwear, which the the men men used used to to keep headwear, which keep their hair in position at as can can be at work, be seen seen from from the the calendars calendars of ofNotre-Dame work, as Notre-Dame d'Amiens. etc. d'Amiens, etc.
The used to wear The first children s costume costume was was the the costume costume which which everybody first children's everybody used to wear about before, and which henceforth they were the only ones a century about a and which were the only ones to to wear. wear. century before, henceforth they
It It was obviously out of the the question to invent invent a a costume costume out out of of nothing obviously out of question to nothing it was felt necessary to separate them in a visible manner for yet it for them, was felt to them, yet necessary separate them in a visible manner by means of their dress. They were accordingly given a costume of their dress. were a which by They accordingly given costume ofwhich the the tradition tradition had been been maintained maintained in in certain certain classes, but which which nobody classes, but nobody wore any childhood costume, which more. The adoption of aa special any more. adoption of special childhood costume, which became generalized throughout the upper classes as the classes as from from the the end end of of the the generalized throughout upper sixteenth marked a very important date in the formation of sixteenth century, a date in the formation of the the century, very important idea idea of childhood. childhood. We have to to remember the the importance which dress dress had had in in the the France France importance which of a large capital sum. People spent a great deal of old. old. It It often often represented a sum. a represented large capital People spent great deal on clothes, died they went to to the the trouble trouble of of drawing clothes, and when somebody somebody died they went drawing up an inventory of his or her wardrobe, as we would today only when an his or her as would wardrobe, up inventory today only when fur coats were were involved. was very very expensive, and attempts were fur coats involved. Dress Dress was expensive, and attempts were made by by means means of sumptuary laws to put a curb on luxury clothes, laws to a curb on sumptuary put luxury clothes, as to to their their which ruined ruined some and and allowed allowed others others to to mislead mislead the the gullible gullible as which life. Even more than than in our present-day present-day societybirth and and station station in in life. birth in our society where it it is is still still true true of of the the women, women, whose whose dress dress is is aa visible visible and and necessary necessary where sign of of aa couple's couple's prosperity prosperity or or the the importance importance of of their their social social position positionsign dress pin-pointed pin-pointed the the place place of of the the wearer wearer in in aa complex complex and and undisputed undisputed dress hierarchy: aa man wore the the costume costume of ofhis rank, and and the the etiquette etiquette books books his rank, hierarchy: laid great great emphasis emphasis on on the the impropriety impropriety of of dressing dressing in in any any other other way way laid than that that befitting befitting one's one's age age or or birth. birth. Every Every social social nuance nuance had had its its correcorrethan sponding sign sign in in clothing. clothing. At the the end end of of the the sixteenth sixteenth century, century, custom custom sponding that childhood, childhood, henceforth henceforth recognized recognized as as aa separate separate entity, entity, dictated that dictated should also also have have its its special special costume. costume. should
* * * Wehave haveseen seen that thatchildhood childhooddress dress originated originated in inan an archaism archaism: the the survival survival We of the the long long coat. coat. This This archaizing archaizing tendency tendency continued. continued. Towards Towards the the end end of of of the eighteenth eighteenth century, century, in in the the time time of ofLouis Louis XVI, XVI, little little boys boys were were dressed dressed the :
in
Lancret and and after the fashion of of the the previous previous century. century.
Louis XIII XIII or or Renaissance Renaissance collars. collars. The The children children painted painted by by Lancret in Louis Boucher are are often often dressed dressed Boucher
after the fashion
58 58
THE IDEA IDEA OF OF CHILDHOOD CHILDHOOD THE
But two two other other tendencies tendencies were were to to influence influence the the development development of of But children's dress dress from from the the seventeenth seventeenth century century on. on. The The first first emphasized emphasized children's .fhe effeminate appearance of ofthe the little little boy. We have have seen seen earlier earlier in in this this ie effeminate boy.
appearance
We
work that that the the boy boy 'in 'in bib bib and and tucker', tucker', before before the the age age of of'the 'the robe robe with with work collar', wore wore the the same same robe robe and and skirt skirt as as aa girl. girl. This This effeminization effeminization of of aa collar', the little little boy, boy, which whichbecame became noticeable noticeable about about the the middle middle of ofthe the sixteenth sixteenth the the century, was at first a novelty and barely hinted at. For instance the upper instance For hinted at. and a first at was upper barely novelty century, part of of the the boy's boy's costume costume retained retained the the characteristics characteristics of ofmasculine masculine dress; dress; part but soon soon the the little little boy was was given the the lace lace collar collar of of the the little little girl, girl, which which but boy
given
was exactly exactly the the same same as as that that worn worn by by the the ladies. ladies. It It became became impossible impossible was offour four or or five, five, to distinguish distinguish aa little little boy boy from from aa little little girl girl before before the the age age of to and this this costume costume became became firmly firmly established established for for something something like like two two and centuries. About About 1770 1770 boys boys stopped stopped wearing wearing the the robe robe with with the the collar collar centuries. after four four or or five, five, but but until until they they reached reached that that age age they they were were dressed dressed like like after case until until the the end end of of the the nineteenth nineteenth little girls, and and this this would would be be the the case little girls,
century: this effeminate habit habit century: this effeminate
would be be dropped dropped only only after after the the First First would
World War, War, and and its its abandonment abandonment can can be be compared compared to to that that of the the World woman's corset corset as as symptomatic symptomatic of of the the revolution revolution in in dress dress corresponding corresponding woman's
to the the general general change change in in manners. manners. to It is interesting to note that that the the attempt attempt to to distinguish distinguish children children was to note is interesting It were generally confined to the boys: the little were distinguished only little girls the the to only confined distinguished girls boys: generally as if if childhood century, as by the in the the eighteenth abandoned in false sleeves, the false century, sleeves, abandoned eighteenth by
evidence provided separated girls from did boys. it did than it life less less than adult life from adult provided boys. The evidence separated girls the history by dress bears out the the of furnished by indications furnished other indications the other out bears history dress by by manners: were the first children. They began going to children. the first specialized were began going manners: boys They specialized boys sixteenth century kte sixteenth school numbers as as and the the late as the back far back as far numbers century in large school in large started in a small way of girls early seventeenth century. The education of The education girls started in a small way early seventeenth century. and developed de Maintenon Maintenon and only in the time of Fenelon and de Mme and Mme Fenelon of time the in developed only were the girls slowly and tardily. Without a proper educational system, the educational a Without girls were and system, proper tardily. slowly had as the confused age just as the boys had formerly an early at an women at the women formerly boys with the confused with early age just visible form, ofgiving been form, and nobody the men, with the confused with been confused men, and giving visible thought of nobody thought exist in in to was by means of dress, to a distinction which was beginning to exist reality which a distinction to reality of means beginning dress, by the girls. for but which still remained futile for the futile for the boys girls. for the boys but which still remained he made was he made to to the Why, in order to the boy from the man, was from man, the to distinguish order in boy distinguish Why, did woman? the from look like the girl who was not distinguished from the woman? Why did not was who the Why like look distinguished girl in which which people in a society in that and surprising novel and so novel people that costume, costume, so surprising in a society at least least to the the present started age, last almost to day, at almost last an early at an life at day, adult life started adult present early age, in manners manners the of until of this in spite of the changes in in this century, of the beginning until the changes spite century, beginning Here we we are are touching and of the period of ofchildhood? childhood? Here and the the prolongation touching prolongation of the period of its its consciousness a on' unexplored subject of a society's consciousness of of as yet the as on the society's yet unexplored subject
CHILDREN'S' DRESS 'DRESS CHILDREN'S
behaviour in in relation relation to to age age and and sex: sex: so so far far only only behaviour has been been studied. studied. has
'59
its class-consciousness class-consciousness
its
Another tendency, tendency, which, which, like like archaizing archaizing and and effeminizing, effeminizing, probably probably Another in the taste for fancy dress, led the children of middle-class originated in the taste for led the of children middle-class originated fancy dress, families to to adopt adopt features features of of lower-class lower-class or or working working dress. dress. Here Here the the child child families would forestall forestall masculine masculine fashion fashion and and wear wear trousers trousers as as early early as as the the reign reign would of Louis Louis XVI, XVI, before before the the age age of of the the sans-culottes. sans-culottes. The The costume costume worn worn by by of the well-dressed well-dressed child child in in the the period period of of Louis Louis XVI was was at at once once archaic archaic the (the Renaissance collar), lower-class (the trousers), and military (the (the Renaissance collar), lower-class (the trousers), and military (the military jacket and buttons). military jacket and buttons). In the the seventeenth seventeenth century century there there was was no no distinctive distinctive lower-class lower-class costume costume In and fortiori no no regional regional costumes. The poor poor wore wore the the clothes clothes which which costumes. The and aa fortiori 20 or which they bought from old-clothes dealers. The they were givenllO from or old-clothes dealers. The which were they bought given they lower-class costume costume was was aa second-hand costume, just just as as today today the the lowersecond-hand costume, lowerlower-class class car is is aa second-hand (The comparison comparison between between the the costume costume of of car. (The second-hand car. class car the past* past" and and the the car car of of the the present present day day is is not not as as artificial artificial as as it it may may seem: seem: the has inherited the social which dress used to have.) the car car has inherited the social significance the significance which dress used to have.) of the people was dressed like the the world world aa few Thus the like the of the few dressed man of the was of man the Thus people of Louis XIII's Paris he wore the plumed decades earlier; in the streets he the in of Louis XIlTs Paris wore the streets decades earlier; plumed bonnet which had been fashionable while the in the the sixteenth sixteenth century, the fashionable in had been bonnet which century, while women wore the hood favoured by ladies of the same period. the The ladies of same favoured hood the wore women period. by time-lag varied from one region to another, according to the rapidity time-lag varied from one region to another, according to the rapidity with followed the the the prevailing fashions. At the local gentry the local which the with which prevailing fashions. gentry followed - along beginning of the eighteenth century, the women of certain regions of the certain of the regions along eighteenth century, beginning the In still wearing fifteenth-century coifS. were still instance -- were for instance the Rhine, Rhine, for wearing fifteenth-century coifs. In the course of the eighteenth century this evolution came to a stop, a as this evolution to the of course the stop, as eighteenth century result of a moral estrangement between the rich and the poor and and the the rich between a moral of result poor estrangement also separation. Regional dress in both both a a new dress originated a physical also a originated in physical separation. Regional ,taste (it was the period of the great regional histories histories the the was for regionalism taste for great regional period regionalism (it of Provence, etc., and also of aa revival revival of interest in the interest in the of Brittany, Brittany, Provence, etc., and also of as the the result the proregional languages which had become dialects result of the had dialects as which proregional languages in the in dress to variations variations in the time gress of French) and dress due to differences in and differences gress of French) to reach which reach different different parts and court court took to of town and the fashions fashions of which the parts of the country. the country. the end of the at the the eighteenth In lower-class suburbs, at the great In the century, eighteenth century, great lower-class suburbs, the trousers distinctive trousers the men started wearing a more distinctive costume, namely a started costume, the namely the wearing of the workman's smock in which were the equivalent at that time that time in the at the the the were which equivalent class nineteenth and the dungarees of today: the sign of a class and aa the the and nineteenth century sign dungarees today: century in the the dress the function. that in the eighteenth century the dress of the that is noteworthy It is function. It eighteenth century noteworthy the beggarly it was was lower cities stopped in the the hig class in lower class being the stopped being beggarly costume it big cities
60 60
THE IDEA IDEA OF OF CHILDHOOD CHILDHOOD THE
in the the seventeenth seventeenth-- shapeless, shapeless, anachronistic anachronistic rags, rags, or or cast-offs cast-off's from from an an in old-clothesdealer. dealer.Here Herewe can cansee seethe thespontaneous spontaneousexpression expressionof ofaacollective collective old-clothes
we characteristic, something something like like an an awakening awakening of ofclass-consciousness. class-consciousness. Thus Thus from then then on on there there was was aa kind kind of of artisan's artisan's uniform: uniform: trousers. trousers. Trousers, Trousers, from long breeches reaching down to to the the feet, feet, had had for for aa long long time time been been an an long breeches reaching down article of of seamen's seamen's dress. dress. While While they they might might appear appear in in Italian Italian comedy, comedy, article they were commonly worn by sailors sailors and and also also by by the the inhabitants inhabitants of of they were commonly worn by seaports, Flemings, Flemings, Rhinelanders, Rhinelanders, Danes Danes and and Scandinavians. Scandinavians. The The latter latter seaports, were still still wearing wearing trousers trousers in in the the seventeenth seventeenth century, century, if if we we judge judge by by were collections of of the the clothes clothes of of that that period. period. The The English English had had given given them them up, up, collections although they had worn them them as as far far back back as as the the twelfth twelfth century. century.21 21 They They although they had worn had become become the the uniform uniform of of the the naval naval forces forces when when the the better-organized better-organized had dress of of their their ships' ships' crews. crews. Apparently Apparently at at the the same same states had had regulated regulated the the dress states time they they spread spread to to the the lower lower classes classes in in the the suburbs suburbs of of the the big big cities, cities, who time henceforth refused refused to to wear wear other other people's people's cast-offs, cast-off's, and and to to little little boys boys of of henceforth good family. good family. was rapidly rapidly adopted adopted by by the the children children of The newly newly created created uniform uniform was The the middle middle classes, classes, first first of of all all in in the the private private boarding-schools, boarding-schools, which had the of the the Jesuits Jesuits and which become more more numerous numerous since since the the expulsion expulsion of become careers. The often prepared boys boys for for military academies and military careers. and academies often prepared military military their to dressing silhouette the people's fancy, and adults took to their took adults the dressing silhouette caught people's fancy, caught created thus was created uniform: boys in a costume inspired by military or naval uniform: thus naval or costume in a inspired by military boys the eighteenth the fashion which has the end of the lasted from the has lasted the sailor-boy eighteenth sailor-boy fashion which century to the present day. the to present day. century taste to this this new taste in part The of trousers for children was due in for children The adoption part to adoption of trousers nineteenth century, for to adults in when in the the nineteenth adults to to spread was to which was century, uniform which for uniform spread it had never the or ceremonial ceremonial dress, court or dress, something became court uniform became something it the uniform desire the desire no no doubt, by the been also inspired, It was was also doubt, the Revolution. Revolution. It before the by been before inspired, to give to his traditional traditional dress, of his constraint of dress, to the constraint from the child from the child give him to free free the would lower-class would aa more suburban lower-class the suburban which the costume which casual costume, more casual costume, aa costume both the thus was The boy was thus spared both the henceforth The of pride. kind of with aa kind wear with spared henceforth wear boy pride. unfashionable over-ceremonious breeches, the over-ceremonious and the robe and breeches, over-childish robe or over-childish unfashionable or all the the This happened thanks and navy. class and lower class of lower trousers of the trousers to the happened all thanks to navy. This to give children more in that it always been thought amusing to children been had it had in that give amusing more easily thought always easily such as as the the lower-class dress, of family a few characteristics of of lower-class dress, such of good good family a few characteristics revolutionaries with with the labourer's, peasant's or convict's cap, which the revolutionaries which convict's or labourer's, peasant's cap, one of of Bonnard's Bonnard's bonnet: one their the Phrygian called the tastes called classical tastes their classical Phrygian bonnet: 22 22 In our own this kind. kind. own of us a cap of this In our engravings shows a child wearing us aa child shows cap wearing engravings certain resemblances resemblances offers certain days we have seen a which offers dress which of dress a transfer transfer of seen have we days XVI's time: the Louis XVI's of Louis time: the to of trousers by the boys of the adoption to the adoption of trousers by die boys characteristic,
CHILDRBN'S CHILDREN'S .1)BBSS .MESS
~I 6j
workman's made of coarse blue cloth, have become the 'blue workman's dungarees, dungarees, made of coarse blue cloth, have become the 'blue jeans' which young people proudly wear as the visible sign of their jeans' which young people proudly wear as the visible sign of their adolescence. adolescence.
* * * have come from from the when the child was dressed We have the sixteenth sixteenth century, century, when the child was dressed are like an adult, to childhood costume with which an adult, to the the specialized specialized childhood costume with which we are have already pointed out that this change affected familiar today. We have familiar today. already pointed out that this change affected girls. The idea idea of profited the boys first first of boys more than than girls. of all, childhood profited the boys of childhood all, boys while the girls girls persisted persisted much longer in the traditional way of life which life in the traditional of which while the way longer have cause cause to more than than confused them with with the the adults: to notice confused them shall have notice more adults: we shall once this delay on the part of the in adopting the visible forms of of in the the once this on of the women visible forms delay part adopting the essentially masculine masculine civilization modern times. times. of modern the essentially civilization of If we confine confine our the evidence afforded by by dress, must our attention evidence afforded If attention to to the dress, we must was limited limited for for aa long conclude that the the particularization particularization of of children conclude that children was long time to boys. boys. What is is certain certain is is that that it in middle-class middle-class or or it occurred occurred solely time to solely in aristocratic families. The children of the lower classes, the offspring aristocratic families. The children of the lower classes, the offspring of the peasants and the artisans, those who played played on on the the village village greens, in and the the peasants artisans, those greens, in the city city streets, in the craftsmen's workshops, in the tavern taprooms and and in the tavern in craftsmen's the the streets, taprooms workshops, in kitchens of houses, went on wearing wearing the the same clothes as clothes as of great in the the kitchens great houses, went adults: they were were never never depicted in robes or false sleeves. They kept up sleeves. in or false robes adults: they They kept up depicted way of life which which made no no distinction between children children and the old distinction between the old way of life in work or in play. play. adults, in dress or in or in dress or adults, in like
IV IV A MODEST CONTRIBUTION TO THE HISTORY OF
GAMES AND PASTIMES
T
HANKS to to the the diary diary kept kept by by the the doctor doctor Heroard, Heroard, we can can imagine imagine was like at the beginning of the seventeenth what a child's life what a child's life was like at the beginning of the seventeenth century, what games he played, and to what stages of his physical THANKS century, what games he played, and to what stages of his physical and mental mental development development each each of of his his games games corresponded. corresponded. Although Although the the and was aa Dauphin Dauphin of of France, France, the future Louis Louis XIII, XIII, his his case case child concerned concerned was the future child remains typical typical for for all all that, that, for for at at Henri Henri IV's IV's court court the the royal royal children, remains children, legitimate or illegitimate, were treated in the same way as all aristocratic in the treated same as were aristocratic or illegitimate, way all legitimate was as yet no no real real difference difference between between the the King's King's children, and and there there was as yet children, palaces and the gentry's castles. Apart from the fact that he never went to from the castles. Apart that he to fact never went and the gentry's palaces college, as some of the aristocracy already did, young Louis XIII was was the Louis XIII of as some did, aristocracy already young college, Thus he brought up like like his he was was given and riding his companions. given fencing companions. Thus fencing and riding brought up lessons by by the the same who, in his academy, the in his instructor who, same instructor lessons academy, taught young taught the young de Pluvinel. The illustrations of de aristocracy the arts of war: aristocracy the arts of war: M. de Pluvinel. The illustrations of M. de Pluvinel's manual of horsemanship, the engravings of the fine fine engravings de Pas, of horsemanship, of C. C. de Pluvinel's manual Pas, . show the riding-school. of horseback at at the In the the second half of on horseback second half XIII on Louis XIII show Louis riding-school. In the seventeenth century the monarchical cult separated the little prince the at monarchical cult the little the seventeenth century prince at separated of noble an earlier age in infancy in fact from other mortals, even fact from in other even of noble in earlier an mortals, infancy age birth. birth. Louis XIII was born on on September His doctor, was born Louis XIII Heroard, doctor, Heroard, 2yth, 1601. His September 27th, 1 has us aa detailed his activities. of all all his writes that that at at record of activities. 1 Heroard Heroard writes detailed record has left left us seventeen the violin and sings at the same time'. Before and the time'. Before the violin at same he 'plays months he seventeen months 'plays sings that, to very a the usual little children, with the usual toys he had had played children, a that, he toys given given to very little played with hobby-horse, a windmill and a whippmg-top. But as early as seventeen as as seventeen and a But a windmill early whipping-top. hobby-horse, months violin had had not not yet his hands. into his hands. The violin was put a violin violin was months a yet won put into the fiddle fiddle played recognition as a noble instrument: it for it was still still the for the the a instrument: noble as played recognition dancing weddings and fetes. At the find him playing the same age at village age we find playing dancing at village weddings and fttes. mall: his shot shot and injured muffed his de 'The Dauphin, mall: 'The mall, muffed injured M. de Dauphin, playing playing mall, start playing cricket Longueville.' This is just as if an English boy were to to start playing cricket Longueville.' This is just as if an English boy or months. At twenty-two are of seventeen seventeen months. the age or golf at the twenty-two months we are age of golf at all sorts told sorts of of rhythms' with all to beat his tambourin beat his tambourin with told that he 'continues 'continues to that he rhythms':: every company had its He started drumbeat. its own drum and its its own drumbeat. had started to to every company the talk: are making him pronounce the syllables separately, before are before talk: 'They syllables separately, pronounce making 'They 'the Queen, saying in the words.' words/ The same month, month, August 1603, 'the Queen, going August 1603, going in saying the
62
HISTORY OF GAMES GAMES, AND PASTIMES
63 63
had him him brought brought along along and and placed placed at at the the end end of of her her table. table. and paintings paintings of of the the sixteenth sixteenth and and seventeenth seventeenth centuries centuries often often show show and a child child at at table, table, perched perched in in aa little litde high-chair high-chair out out of of which which he he cannot cannot fall; fall; a it must must have have been been in in one one of of these these chairs chairs that that he he sat sat at at his his mother's mother's table, table. it to dinner, dinner, had to Prints Prints
like other children in other families. This This little litde fellow fellow is is barely barely two two years years find him him being being 'taken 'taken to to the the King's King's apartments apartments and and now we find dancing all sorts of dances to the music of a violin'. Again see to of all sorts of the music a dances violin*. see how we dancing Again early in life music and dancing were introduced into the education of the early in life music and dancing were introduced into the education of the little men of of this this period: period: this this explains explains the the frequency, frequency, in in the the families families of of little professionals, of what should call infant prodigies, such as the the such as of now call infant what we should prodigies, professionals, young Mozart; Mozart; such such cases cases would would become become rarer rarer and and at at the the same same time time seem seem young as familiarity familiarity with with music, music, even even in in its its elementary elementary or or more prodigious prodigious as more bastard forms, forms, grew grew less less common or or disappeared. disappeared. bastard The Dauphin Dauphin began began talking. talking. Heroard Heroard keeps keeps aa phonetic phonetic record record of his of his The chatter: 'Tell 'Tell Papa* Papa' for for 'I tell Papa', Papa'. equivez Iquivez for ecrivez. He was was for tcrivez. *I shall shall tell chatter: often given given aa whipping: whipping: 'Naughty, 'Naughty, whipped whipped (for refusing to to eat): often (for refusing eat): calming down, he asked for his dinner and dined.' 'Went off to his room, to his and dined/ his dinner off he asked for room, down, calming whipped.' Although Although he he screaming the top top of ofhis voice, and and was his voice, was soundly at the soundly whipped/ screaming at now mingled mingled with with adults, adults, playing, dancing and singing with them, he he and with them, singing playing, dancing still children's games. was two years months old seven months old when still played at years seven played at children's games. He was Sully presented him with 'a full of dolls'. full of 'a litde little carriage dolls'. him with carriage Sully presented He to see 'The soldiers are always see soldiers: 'The soldiers are of soldiers: the company liked the He liked glad to always glad company of him.' with a little 'He conducted little conducted cannon/ 'He little military a litde cannon.' with 'He played him/ 'He military played high collar actions a high first collar on him, the first de Marsan Marsan put his soldiers. soldiers. M. de with his actions with him, the put a he 'He played at military engageat he was was delighted.' and he ever worn, he had had ever worn, and military engageplayed delighted/ ments with his he played tennis as as well as that he well as too that lords/ We know too litde lords.' his little ments with played tennis mallhe still a cradle. On July 19th, 1604, when he was two a in cradle. still slept in he mall - yet ipth, 1604, July slept yet years nine months old, 'he his bed bed being with great saw his 'he saw being made with great joy, joy, was years nine months old, put to bed for the first He already knew the rudiments of the his rudiments of his time/ first time.' the for to bed already put 'teligion: at at he was shown the the host host and told told that that it it at the the Elevation, at Mass, Elevation, Mass, "religion: this was note in passing this expression, Ie Dieu. in le bon ban note Dieu. We might le bon bon Dieu. Dieu, was Ie passing expression, might which employed nowadays by priests and churchgoers, but is constantly which is churchgoers, but constantly employed nowadays by priests literature the ancien of literature of the ancien regime. in religious found in be found can be trace can no trace ofwhich which no religious regime. die seventeenth seventeenth century, We can the beginning at the that at here that see here can see century, when beginning of the it belonged to the language not very the was probably not of old, it the expression belonged to the very old, language of expression was probably to children. It contaminated children and nannies when talking to children. It contaminated nannies and of parents or of children or talking parents the eff'eminization the nineteenth century. effeminization the nineteenth in the adults in and, with the ofadults the language century, and, language of le bon bon Dieu Dieu little children. children. of the God of Jacob became Ie of little the of religion. Jacob religion, The out with those those could now talk, talk, and occasionally The Dauphin occasionally came out Dauphin could 'The King showed him the cheeky remarks which amuse grown-ups: him the amuse which remarks King grown-ups: cheeky like other children in other families.
old, yet yet old,
OF CHILDHOOD
THE IDEA
64
birch and asked him: him: "Who is is that that for?" answered angrily: "For and asked birch for?" He answered angrily: "For you." The King could not help laughing'. The could not help laughing'. King you." was three three years years old on Christmas he took took part part in in old when, He was Christmas Eve Eve 1604, when, on 1604, he the traditional festivities. supper he log being lit, Before supper he saw the Yule Yule log the traditional festivities. 'Before saw the lit, being he danced the coming coming of given some and and sang at the of Christmas.' some danced and Christmas/ He was was given and he sang at presents: a ball, and also some 'little baubles from Italy', including a presents: a ball, and also some little baubles from Italy', including a clockwork toys intended for the the Queen as for him. as much for intended as for him. clockwork pigeon, Queen as pigeon, toys During the winter evenings, when he was kept indoors, 'he amused he winter was the 'he amused indoors, During evenings, kept himself by by cutting paper with with scissors.' and dancing still occupied scissors/ Music Music and himself cutting paper occupied dancing still an important place place in in his his life. Heroard writes writes with with aa hint hint of an important life. Heroard of admiration: admiration: 'The Dauphin can can dance dances'. He remembered the ballets ballets which which dance all all the the dances*. 'The Dauphin remembered the he had in which which he he would would soon soon be taking part, part, if if indeed indeed he had and in he had seen seen and be taking he had not already begun doing so: 'Remembering a ballet performed a year a not already so: ballet a begun doing year Remembering performed ago he was was two two years old], he asked: "Why was the little [when he ago [when years old], he asked: "Why was the little Ram bare?'" played Cupid naked.' 'He danced the the galliard, the stark naked.' bare?"' 'He 'He played 'He danced Cupid stark galliard, the bourn~e.' He enjoyed playing Boileau's mandora and saraband, the old the old and bourree/ Boileau's mandora saraband, enjoyed playing singing tlle song Robin. He would would be four years years old old in in aa few be four of Robin. few days' days' song of singing die at least the names the different different strings of the lute. lute. time, he knew at and he least the names of of the of the time, and strings 'He played with with the the tips tips of his fingers his lips, saying: .. Here is the of his on his 'He played fingers on lips, saying: "Here is the acquaintance with with the the lute did not not prevent prevent him from bass.'" But his bass." his early lute did early acquaintance listening to the less aristocratic fiddles played at the wedding of one the to the of the the less fiddles at one of aristocratic listening played wedding of King's chefs or to a bagpipe player, one of the masons were to a one of were chefs or the masons who King's bagpipe player, 'repairing his fireplace': to him him for quite aa long long the 'Dauplun for quite listened to fireplace': the 'repairing his 'Dauphin listened *
*
*
*
.
,
bme. time'.
This was was the the time time when he he was was being being taught to read. read. At the age of three the age of three This taught to years five months 'he amused himself with a of characters from the the a book of characters 'he himself with five months years Bible: his his nanny nanny named the the letters letters and and he he "was was all/ Next he he knew them all.' Bible: taught Pibrac's Pibrac's quatrains, quatrains, aa collection collection of rules of of etiquette and morality of rules taught etiquette and morality which children children had to to recite recite from memory. memory. At the the age four, he was was which age of four, by aa clerk palace chapel called Dumont. given writing writing lessons lessons by clerk of of the the palace chapel called given 'He had his his writing-desk taken into into the write under to write under the dining-room 'He had writing-desk taken dining-room to Dumont's guidance, and said: "I putting my example and down "I said: am Dumont's my example and guidance, putting going to school.'" (The example was the handwriting he model which was the he to school/" handwriting (The example going had to copy.) copy.) 'He wrote wrote his example, following the impression impression made on his example, had to following the the paper, paper, and taking pleasure pleasure in in it/ it.' He started started the and followed it very well, followed it very well, taking learning Latin words. he was six a professional scribe took the scribe took When a words. he was six the Latin learning professional of the chapel clerk: 'He wrote his example. Beaugrand, the King's place the his of clerk: wrote the example. Beaugrand, place King's chapel scribe, to write/ write.' scribe, showed him how to He still played with some little little toys toys and aa dolls: 'He still played with He played played with dolls: German cabinet miniatures by Niimberg craftsmen]. cabinet [wooden miniatures made by Niirnberg craftsmen]. [wooden c
facing:
CInLDREN OF HENRI-LOUIS HABERT DE MONTMORT facing : THE CHILDREN
by Philippe Philippe de de Champaigne Champalgne by
GAMES, AND PASTIMES 65 HISTORY OF GAMES 65 de Lomenie Lomenie gave gave him him aa little little nobleman nobleman splendidly splendidly dressed dressed in in aa scented scented M. de collar ... He combed combed his his hair hair and and said: said: "I "I am going going to to marry marry him him to to collar... Madame's [his [his sister's] sister's] doll/" doll.'" He still still enjoyed enjoyed paper-cutting. paper-cutting. He had had Madame's stories read read to to him him too too: 'His nanny told told him him the the stories stories of of Renard Renard the the Fox, Fox, His nanny stories Dives and and Lazarus.' Lazarus.' 'In 'In bed, bed, he he was was being being told told the the stories stories of of Melusina. Melusina. Dives I told told him him that that they they were were fairy-stories fairy-stories and and not not true true stories/ stories.' (A (A remark remark I which already already foreshadows foreshadows modern modem educational educational practice.) practice.) Children Children were were which not the the only only ones ones to to listen listen to to these these stories: stories: they they were were also also told told to to adults adults at at not evening gatherings. gatherings. evening At the the same same time time as as he he played played with with dolls, dolls, this this child child of of four four or or five five At practised archery, played cards, chess (at six), and adult games such as and adult such as chess (at six), practised archery, played cards, games 'racket-ball', prisoners' prisoners' base base and and countless countless parlour parlour games. games. At At three, three, he he 'racket-ball', was already already playing playing at at crambo, crambo, aa game game common to to both both children children and and was young people. people. With the the pages pages of of the the King's King's Chamber, Chamber, who were were older older young than he he was, was, he he played played at at 'Do you like company?' 'He was the the master master like company?' 'He was 'Do you than of the game] and then, and he did not what [the leader and and he did not know what when of leader the now then, game] [the he had had to to say, say, he he asked; asked; he he played played these these games, games, such such as the game game of lighting of lighting as the he aa candle candle blindfold, blindfold, as as if he were fifteen years he was not not old/ when When he if he were fifteen years old.' playing with pages, he was playing with soldiers: 'He played various various soldiers: he was with with played playing pages, playing games, such as want your place", fiddle-de-dee, and as "I "I want fiddle-de-dee, hand-clapping, your place", hand-clapping, and games, such hide-and-seek, with some soldiers.' At the age of six he played trades trades and and of six he soldiers/ At the with hide-and-seek, played age and stories charades, parlour games games which which consisted stories of guessing trades and consisted of charades, parlour guessing trades that were were represented represented in in pantomime. These were also games played by also These were that games played by pantomime. adolescents and adults. adults. adolescents and To an Dauphin mixed with and took adults and took with adults the Dauphin an ever ever increasing extent, the increasing extent, part in their amusements. At the age of five 'he was taken to the meadow to the the of 'he was taken five age part in their amusements. behind the kennels kennels [at Fontainebleau] to the King's to see Bretons from the see Bretons behind the King's [at Fontainebleau] workshops wrestling.' 'Taken to join tlle King in the ballroom to the ballroom to see see the the to the in 'Taken join King workshops wrestling/ dogs fighting the bears and the bull.' 'He went to the covered tennistennisto the covered and the bull/ the bears dogs fighting court in the the court court ballets. ballets. all he he took took part race/ And above all a badger to see see a court to part in badger race.' At to the the King's a mask, half 'he 'he put and aa half of four four and At the the age mask, went to King's put on a age of apartments to dance a ballet, and then refused to take off his mask, not apartments to dance a ballet, and then refused to take off his mask, not wishing as a a 'Picardy dressed up often dressed be recognized.' to be 'Picardy chamberup as recognized/ He often wishing to 'After maid', or a girl (he was still boy's tunic). a still wearing a or a a shepherdess tunic). 'After maid', a boy's wearing girl (he shepherdess supper he watched some dancing to of a aa a certain certain Laforest', to the the songs some watched he Laforest', dancing songs supper soldier-choreographer farces. At the the the author author of some farces. also the was also soldier-choreographer who was a farce farce in in which age enthusiasm a without great watched without 'he watched of five five 'he great enthusiasm age of the the unfaithful Laforest the comic husband, the Baron de Montglat the unfaithful the comic Laforest played husband, Montglat played wife, her/ At the the age six 'he 'he danced seduced her.' the lover lover who seduced Indret the and Indret wife, and age of six of his in a as a man, in a doublet and breeches on top aa ballet, dressed doublet breeches as a dressed man, ballet, smartly top ofhis smartly *
:
c C
facing above: THE DUC DUG D'ANJOU D'ANJOU AS A CHILD facing above: . below: Callot below: THE THIEVES by by Callot
by Arnoult by Amoult
66 66
THE IDEA OF CHILDHOOD
tunic.' •'He He watched watched the of the magicians devised by the the the devils devised by tunic.' the ballet ballet of devils and and magicians Piedmontese Jean-Baptiste [another soldier-choreographer] danced by danced Picdmontesc Jean-Baptiste by [another soldier-choreographer] de Marsan's Marsan's command.' only ballets soldiers under M. de soldiers under ballets command/ He did did not not dance dance only and court dances, but also took part part in what we should and court call folkfolkalso took in what should now call dances, but dances. was five, he took took part part in in one which reminds reminds me of a of a dances. When he he was one which five, he Tyrolean dance which I once saw some lads in leather breeches perform dance in which I once saw some lads breeches leather Tyrolean perform in cafe: 'The 'The King's King's pages pages danced are in an "There are an Innsbruck Innsbruck cafe: danced the the branIe branle "There cabbages on Midsummer Day" and kicked each other in the bottom; he he on and kicked each in the other Midsummer bottom; cabbages Day" danced it and and did they did!' occasion he he was a did as as they as a danced it was dressed dressed as another occasion did!' On another girl for a play: 'When the farce was over, he took his robe off and for and a took robe off the was he his farce over, girl play: danced on Midsummer Day", kicking his comdanced "There "There are are cabbages cabbages on Midsummer Day", kicking his companions in the bottom. He liked this dance.' in the liked this dance.' bottom. panions Finally he joined the adults in the traditional festivities of of Christmas, he the adults in the traditional festivities Christmas, Finally joined Twelfth Night and it he lit the Midsummer and Midsummer lit the Midsummer Twelfth Night it was he who Midsummer Day; was Day; Day bonfire bonfire in the courtyard of the of Saint-Germain. the in the Saint-Germain. On the the Chateau Chateau of Day courtyard of eve Twelfth Night: Night: 'He the King for the first Everyone eve of of Twelfth was the for the first time. time. 'He was Everyone King shouted: King drinks! drinks!"" God's share is he who eats eats it pay to pay it has has to is left: shouted: "The King left: he God's share aa forfeit.' 'Taken to to the apartments, from which he watched the the forfeit.' 'Taken he watched the Queen's from which Queen's apartments, maypole being set up.' set maypole being up.' Things changed when he he was nearly seven: he abandoned abandoned his his childhood childhood was nearly seven: he changed when Things clothes to men; men; he he left left clothes and and henceforth henceforth his his education entrusted to education was was entrusted of ,'Mamonglas', Mamonglas', Mme de and came under the jurisdiction the de Montglas, and under came jurisdiction of Montglas, de Soubise. was made to persuade him to give up to him M. de to Soubise. An attempt was now give up attempt persuade the and in in particular particular to to stop playing with dolls: 'You of infancy, with dolls: the games games of infancy, and stop playing must stop' playing with these little toys [the German toys] and and playing must playing stop* playing with these little toys [the German toys] the wagoner: wagoner: you you are are aa big boy now, you are no longer a child.' a the child.' He are longer big boy now, you started learning the arts riding, shooting hunting. He played played games started and hunting. arts of of riding, games learning the shooting and of chance: 'He took part part in rafRe and and won aa turquoise.' turquoise.' It indeed of chance: It seems seems indeed a raffle 'He took in a that this age mark.ed aa stage it was was the the age that this of seven seven marked of some some importance: age age of importance: it stage of usually given in the moralistic and pedagogic literature of the seventeenth the seventeenth in and literature the moralistic usually given pedagogic century for starting starting school work. s2 But we should should as the the age school or or starting century as starting work. age for had beware of its importance. For all that he had stopped all that of exaggerating beware its For stopped exaggerating importance. the Dauphin playing, have stopped playing, with his dolls, dolls, the Dauphin or should should have with his playing, or stopped playing, went on leading the same same life as before: before: he he was was still whipping still given a life as given a whipping leading the all. from to time, time, and pastimes scarcely changed at all. went more at He went time to and his from time his pastimes scarcely changed a and more more to to the theatre, and nearly every day: a sign of the theatre, and was was soon soon going going nearly every day: sign of the importance of comedy, farce and ballet in our ancestors' frequent the in our ancestors' of and farce ballet frequent comedy, importance indoor and open-air into the to indoor and the great entertainments. 'He 'He went into great gallery gallery to open-air entertainments. watch the the King King tilting at the ring.' 'He listened to some naughty stories to stories at the listened 'He tilting naughty ring.' by others.' 'Played with some little little Clavette and and others.' in his his apartments by La Clavette apartments with 'Played in
HISTORY OP OF GAMES GAMES, AND ~ND PASTIMES PASTIMES HISTORY
.67 67
noblemen at at heads heads or or tails, tails, like like the the King, King, with with three three dice/ dice.' 'Played 'Played at at noblemen hide-and-seek' with with aa lieutenant lieutenant of of the the Light Light Horse. Horse. 'He 'He went went to to pky play hide-and-seek' tennis and and then then went went to to the the great great gallery gallery to to watch watch them them tilting tilting at at the the tennis
ring.' 'Dressed up and danced the Pantaloon.' ring/ 'Dressed up and danced the Pantaloon/
He was was nine nine years years old old He
now: 'After 'After supper, supper, he he went went to to the the Queen's Queen's apartments, apartments, pkyed played blindblindnow: man's buff, buff, and and made made the the Queen, Queen, the the princesses princesses and and the the ladies ladies pky play it it man's too.' 'He 'He played played "I "I sit sit down'" down'" and and the the usual usual parlour parlour games. games. 'After 'After too/ supper the King's nanny told him some stories, and he enjoyed this.' At supper the King's nanny told him some stories, and he enjoyed this/ At thirteen we find find him him still still playing playing hide-and-seek. hide-and-seek. thirteen Rather more more dolls dolls and and German German toys toys before before seven, seven, and and more hunting, hWlting. Rather riding, fencing fencing and and possibly possibly pkygoing playgoing after after seven; seven; the the change change was was
riding,
almost imperceptible imperceptible in in that that long long succession succession of of pastimes pastimes which which the the child child almost copied from the adults or shared with them. The novelist-cum-historian novelist-cum-historian The them. the or shared with from adults copied
Sorel would would write write aa treatise treatise on on parlour parlour games games intended intended for for adults. adults. But at at Sorel the age age of of three three Louis Louis XIII XIII was was playing playing crambo, crambo, and and at at six, six, trades trades and the charades, all all games which which occupied occupied an an important important place place in in Sorel's Sorel's Maison Maison charades, games
des Jeux. At five he was playing cards. At eight he he won aa prize prize in in aa desjeux. At five he was playing cards. At eight aa game game of of chance in which which fortWles used to to change change hands. hands. fortunes used chance in
rafRe,
raffle,
The same was of musical musical or or theatrical theatrical entertainments: entertainments: when he was true true of The same was Louis XIII was dancing the galliard, the saraband and the old the old the was XIII was three, Louis three, galliard, the saraband dancing bourrt~e, and taking part in the court ballets. At five, he was watching he was At the court ballets. in and five, watching bounce, taking part the and played the violin and the farces, comedies. He sang, at seven, and at seven, comedies. farces, and sang, and played the violin a lute. at a wrestling-match, a at the spectators of the in the front row of the front lute. He was was in wrestling-match, a spectators a or a bearfight, or a display by a tightrope ring-tilting contest, a bullfight a or a or a tightrope display by bearfight, bullfight ring-tilting contest, the that were the walker. he took part in festivals that collective festivals the great in the walker. Finally great collective Finally he took part religious and seasonal feast-days: Christmas, May Day, Midsummer seasonal and Christmas, May Day, feast-days: religious there Day seventeenth century the early in the that in It seems, ... It therefore, that century there seems, therefore, early seventeenth Day ... was games children's is today between children's there is as there division as strict division was not not such such aa strict games today and by adults. YOWlg and the same games. old played and old those played and those games. pkyed the played by adults. Young
*
*
*
no longer this polyvalency At of the seventeenth century this the beginning At the longer poly valency no beginning of the seventeenth century their games. with their familiar with applied to the very small children. We are are familiar We for, children. small to the games, for. very applied their made ever since the fifteenth century when the putti had made their appearance the the ever since fifteenth century appearance putti In at play. children at little children in cOWltless artists had had depicted in iconography, pky. In depicted little iconography, countless artists the bird the their pictures we can recognize the hobby-horse, the windmill, the bird the windmill, can their pictures we hobby-horse, recognize is obvious obvious that that It is dolls. It so often, on not so often, dolls. and sometimes, on aa leash leash ... and sometimes, though though not is entitled to entitled one Yet these dummies were reserved for little children. Yet one is to children. little for reserved these dummies were these had whether and true wonder whether this had always been true and whether these toys had been had this wonder whether toys always . . .
68 68
THE IDEA OF CHILDHOOD
not previously previously belonged to the world of adults. Some toys originated in not belonged to the world of adults. Some toys originated in that of emulation which induces to imitate adult processes, processes, induces children emulation which children to imitate adult that spirit of spirit while reducing them them to to their scale. This the case the hobbyThis is with the is the their own scale. case with while reducing hobbyhorse, time when the horse was the principal means transport and and the principal a time horse was means of of transport at a when the horse, at traction. the litde sails spinning round on the end of a stick stick of a on end the sails round the little traction. Similarly, Similarly, spinning could not be be anything but the imitation by children of a technique which, could not anything but the imitation by children of a technique which, unlike that that of horse, was was not not very very old: the windmill windmill technique of the old: the the horse, unlike technique introduced in the Middle Ages. The The same governs the of children of in the Middle Ages. reflex governs the children same reflex introduced today when they imitate a lorry or a car. But while the windmill has long has a or But the a car. while windmill when imitate long lorry they today ago from our countryside, the child's windmill is still on sale ago disappeared disappeared from our countryside, the child's windmill is still on sale in toyshops and market or stalls. Children form the most and market or fair-ground in toyshops fair-ground stalls. Children form the most conservative of human societies. societies. conservative of Other games seem seem to to have have some other origin than the desire to imitate some other Other games origin than the desire to imitate adults. child is is often depicted playing playing with with aa bird: bird: Louis Louis XIII XIII the child adults. Thus Thus the often depicted had a shrike shrike of fond; the reader himself may he was the himself of which was extremely reader had a which he fond; may extremely perhaps remember trying to tame a wounded crow crow in in his his childhood. childhood. perhaps remember trying to tame a The bird in in these these pictures pictures is is usually attached to a leash which the child is The bird usually attached to a leash which the child is holding in his hand. Sometimes it been just just aa wooden dummy. his hand. it may have in Sometimes dummy. holding may have been In case, judging by the iconographic evidence, the bird on aa leash leash In any the the bird evidence, any case, judging by iconographic would seem seem to to have have been been one of the the most historian The of toys. historian one of most common of would toys. of the religions religions of of Greece, Greece, Nilsson, Nilsson,33 tells that in in ancient as tells us us that ancient Greece, of the Greece, as indeed in modern modem Greece, it was customary during the first days of of first it the indeed in was Greece, days customary during March for boys to to make aa wooden swallow turning on aa pivot pivot and and for boys March swallow turning adorned with flowers. would then take it from house to house and to and house house then take it from adorned with flowers. They would They or its was not an individual toy be given'presents: given·presents: here the bird individual but not an be here the its image was bird or toy but image an collective, seasonal in which youth took part took in in seasonal festivity which of a a collective, an element element of youth festivity part in the which its its age age group group assigned to it. eventually became an an to became the role role which it. What eventually assigned individual toy unconnected with the the community or the the calendar calendar and and individual toy unconnected with community or devoid of any social content, would appear to have been linked at f